diff --git "a/data/en108/text/00000016.json" "b/data/en108/text/00000016.json"
new file mode 100644--- /dev/null
+++ "b/data/en108/text/00000016.json"
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[{"audio_id": "ONh58jhNX0U", "text": {"ONh58jhNX0U-00000-00000012-00003943": "[Music]", "ONh58jhNX0U-00001-00003944-00005652": "[Music]", "ONh58jhNX0U-00002-00005653-00011819": "[Music]", "ONh58jhNX0U-00003-00011820-00013694": "[Music]", "ONh58jhNX0U-00004-00013696-00016910": "[Music]", "ONh58jhNX0U-00005-00016911-00019904": "[Music]", "ONh58jhNX0U-00006-00019905-00020231": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "ONpdzlrB74A", "text": {"ONpdzlrB74A-00000-00000200-00000311": "in this lecture", "ONpdzlrB74A-00001-00000312-00000574": "we seek a further understanding of", "ONpdzlrB74A-00002-00000575-00000839": "two-sample hypothesis testing", "ONpdzlrB74A-00003-00000840-00001158": "welcome to our lecture in previous", "ONpdzlrB74A-00004-00001159-00001439": "lectures about hypothesis testing", "ONpdzlrB74A-00005-00001440-00001710": "we were content to follow a very simple", "ONpdzlrB74A-00006-00001711-00001918": "step-by-step process", "ONpdzlrB74A-00007-00001919-00002271": "that resulted in reject the null", "ONpdzlrB74A-00008-00002272-00002463": "hypothesis or don't reject the null", "ONpdzlrB74A-00009-00002464-00002550": "hypothesis", "ONpdzlrB74A-00010-00002551-00002823": "everything was very clearly laid out and", "ONpdzlrB74A-00011-00002824-00002958": "regimented", "ONpdzlrB74A-00012-00002959-00003222": "in this lecture what we're trying to do", "ONpdzlrB74A-00013-00003223-00003390": "is help you to understand", "ONpdzlrB74A-00014-00003392-00003670": "exactly what you're doing when you test", "ONpdzlrB74A-00015-00003671-00003831": "the hypothesis", "ONpdzlrB74A-00016-00003832-00004111": "and what it means if you reject if you", "ONpdzlrB74A-00017-00004112-00004238": "manage to reject it", "ONpdzlrB74A-00018-00004239-00004567": "and what it means if you don't", "ONpdzlrB74A-00019-00004568-00004775": "in this example we're going to look at a", "ONpdzlrB74A-00020-00004776-00004935": "comparison", "ONpdzlrB74A-00021-00004936-00005159": "of men and women and how well they do in", "ONpdzlrB74A-00022-00005160-00005270": "terms of leadership", "ONpdzlrB74A-00023-00005271-00005647": "aptitude as you can see from the example", "ONpdzlrB74A-00024-00005648-00005983": "the mean for women was 83.7", "ONpdzlrB74A-00025-00005984-00006183": "this is on a scale that goes from zero", "ONpdzlrB74A-00026-00006184-00006311": "to a hundred", "ONpdzlrB74A-00027-00006312-00006759": "the mean for the men was 74.3", "ONpdzlrB74A-00028-00006759-00006903": "of course we didn't look at all the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00029-00006904-00007078": "women and the men in the world", "ONpdzlrB74A-00030-00007079-00007478": "we took a sample of 64 women and 54 men", "ONpdzlrB74A-00031-00007479-00007678": "and as you'll see in a moment the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00032-00007679-00007927": "difference is 9.4 points", "ONpdzlrB74A-00033-00007928-00008271": "we want to know is this 9.4 difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00034-00008272-00008483": "significant was it just chance", "ONpdzlrB74A-00035-00008484-00008742": "difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00036-00008743-00009151": "as you can see we end up with a z value", "ONpdzlrB74A-00037-00009152-00009583": "of 2.97 okay now the z is a distribution", "ONpdzlrB74A-00038-00009584-00009855": "we need that to get a probability", "ONpdzlrB74A-00039-00009856-00010191": "so our computed z value of 2.97", "ONpdzlrB74A-00040-00010192-00010383": "if we're testing at the o5 level it's a", "ONpdzlrB74A-00041-00010384-00010591": "two-tailed test", "ONpdzlrB74A-00042-00010592-00010935": "you need to be greater than 1.96", "ONpdzlrB74A-00043-00010936-00011119": "on the positive side or less than what", "ONpdzlrB74A-00044-00011120-00011310": "minus 1.96", "ONpdzlrB74A-00045-00011311-00011646": "on the left tail to reject", "ONpdzlrB74A-00046-00011647-00011910": "anything between plus 1.96 and minus", "ONpdzlrB74A-00047-00011911-00012095": "1.96", "ONpdzlrB74A-00048-00012096-00012438": "we don't reject in quotes we accept", "ONpdzlrB74A-00049-00012439-00012710": "okay here we got 2.97 which is clearly", "ONpdzlrB74A-00050-00012711-00012886": "more than 1.96", "ONpdzlrB74A-00051-00012887-00013247": "so we say we reject h0 at a probability", "ONpdzlrB74A-00052-00013247-00013455": "of o5 in other words", "ONpdzlrB74A-00053-00013456-00013630": "we have found that men and women are", "ONpdzlrB74A-00054-00013631-00013879": "different with regard to leadership", "ONpdzlrB74A-00055-00013880-00014158": "aptitude", "ONpdzlrB74A-00056-00014159-00014327": "let me talk about a straw man because", "ONpdzlrB74A-00057-00014328-00014471": "the null hypothesis", "ONpdzlrB74A-00058-00014472-00014686": "is generally a straw man what is a straw", "ONpdzlrB74A-00059-00014687-00014927": "man we set it up", "ONpdzlrB74A-00060-00014928-00015135": "because we're trying to knock it down", "ONpdzlrB74A-00061-00015136-00015391": "we're actually saying let's pretend", "ONpdzlrB74A-00062-00015391-00015655": "that there's no difference between the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00063-00015656-00015758": "two groups in this case", "ONpdzlrB74A-00064-00015759-00016038": "men and women they're exactly the same", "ONpdzlrB74A-00065-00016040-00016215": "okay now we say", "ONpdzlrB74A-00066-00016216-00016447": "let's look at the sample evidence is", "ONpdzlrB74A-00067-00016448-00016679": "this the kind of sample evidence", "ONpdzlrB74A-00068-00016680-00016975": "we should see if there indeed is no", "ONpdzlrB74A-00069-00016976-00017047": "difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00070-00017048-00017215": "so if men and women are exactly the same", "ONpdzlrB74A-00071-00017216-00017391": "leadership ability", "ONpdzlrB74A-00072-00017392-00017735": "should we find a 9.4 difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00073-00017736-00018022": "in the two samples that's what we found", "ONpdzlrB74A-00074-00018023-00018222": "we found a 9.4 difference is that what", "ONpdzlrB74A-00075-00018223-00018350": "we expect if there's really no", "ONpdzlrB74A-00076-00018351-00018471": "difference not clearly", "ONpdzlrB74A-00077-00018472-00018630": "if we said no difference we found a", "ONpdzlrB74A-00078-00018631-00018791": "difference of let's say", "ONpdzlrB74A-00079-00018792-00018967": "a quarter of a point we'd all know right", "ONpdzlrB74A-00080-00018968-00019175": "away that we can't reject", "ONpdzlrB74A-00081-00019176-00019383": "h o but here we found the difference of", "ONpdzlrB74A-00082-00019384-00019591": "9.4 points and that's we're trying to", "ONpdzlrB74A-00083-00019592-00019679": "see", "ONpdzlrB74A-00084-00019680-00019830": "so we start off with a straw man the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00085-00019831-00020022": "null hypothesis pretending right now", "ONpdzlrB74A-00086-00020023-00020214": "there's no difference in men and women", "ONpdzlrB74A-00087-00020215-00020407": "now is this the sample evidence we", "ONpdzlrB74A-00088-00020408-00020783": "should be seeing", "ONpdzlrB74A-00089-00020784-00021022": "anyway we see that there's a difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00090-00021023-00021247": "between the two sample means", "ONpdzlrB74A-00091-00021248-00021855": "men women and men 83.7 versus 74.3", "ONpdzlrB74A-00092-00021856-00022175": "or a 9.4 point difference in leadership", "ONpdzlrB74A-00093-00022176-00022335": "aptitude scores", "ONpdzlrB74A-00094-00022336-00022543": "now the two possibilities why what does", "ONpdzlrB74A-00095-00022544-00022750": "that mean we see a difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00096-00022751-00022991": "okay one possibility is that men and", "ONpdzlrB74A-00097-00022992-00023055": "women", "ONpdzlrB74A-00098-00023056-00023214": "are exactly the same when it comes to", "ONpdzlrB74A-00099-00023215-00023511": "leadership and that difference of 9.4", "ONpdzlrB74A-00100-00023512-00023671": "is just sampling error it's just chance", "ONpdzlrB74A-00101-00023672-00023799": "it just so happened there's going to be", "ONpdzlrB74A-00102-00023800-00024063": "a difference and it's not meaningful", "ONpdzlrB74A-00103-00024064-00024278": "that's one possibility there's a second", "ONpdzlrB74A-00104-00024279-00024478": "possibility however", "ONpdzlrB74A-00105-00024479-00024742": "that it's too much that 9.4 difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00106-00024743-00024886": "is just too much to", "ONpdzlrB74A-00107-00024887-00025191": "be attributable to chance", "ONpdzlrB74A-00108-00025192-00025527": "and rather we're going to have to", "ONpdzlrB74A-00109-00025528-00025678": "conclude that women and men", "ONpdzlrB74A-00110-00025679-00025790": "are different when it comes to", "ONpdzlrB74A-00111-00025791-00026014": "leadership aptitude that 9.4 difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00112-00026016-00026167": "is significant", "ONpdzlrB74A-00113-00026168-00026683": "and that women are better leaders than", "ONpdzlrB74A-00114-00026683-00026807": "men", "ONpdzlrB74A-00115-00026808-00027111": "now if you look at the cumulative z uh", "ONpdzlrB74A-00116-00027112-00027358": "distribution table you can see that it", "ONpdzlrB74A-00117-00027360-00027643": "gives you all the values from", "ONpdzlrB74A-00118-00027644-00027935": "2.97 that's our z value", "ONpdzlrB74A-00119-00027936-00028079": "we go to infinity because we're not only", "ONpdzlrB74A-00120-00028080-00028231": "looking at the difference of nine point", "ONpdzlrB74A-00121-00028232-00028390": "four in our sample what about more than", "ONpdzlrB74A-00122-00028391-00028511": "nine point four", "ONpdzlrB74A-00123-00028512-00028687": "so we're actually looking at differences", "ONpdzlrB74A-00124-00028688-00028855": "that are more than nine point four", "ONpdzlrB74A-00125-00028856-00029070": "like ten point four fifteen point four", "ONpdzlrB74A-00126-00029072-00029183": "twenty point four", "ONpdzlrB74A-00127-00029183-00029479": "thirty fifty those clearly would you", "ONpdzlrB74A-00128-00029480-00029543": "know", "ONpdzlrB74A-00129-00029544-00029702": "be more than what we found so we want to", "ONpdzlrB74A-00130-00029704-00029870": "know what is the likelihood of finding", "ONpdzlrB74A-00131-00029872-00030055": "this difference", "ONpdzlrB74A-00132-00030056-00030231": "if nothing is going on again the straw", "ONpdzlrB74A-00133-00030232-00030431": "man is no different so", "ONpdzlrB74A-00134-00030432-00030607": "we're looking at our sample evidence or", "ONpdzlrB74A-00135-00030608-00030751": "something even more extreme now we got", "ONpdzlrB74A-00136-00030752-00030799": "to do it", "ONpdzlrB74A-00137-00030800-00030958": "we got to double it because we're also", "ONpdzlrB74A-00138-00030960-00031151": "looking at the two-tailed test", "ONpdzlrB74A-00139-00031152-00031239": "so we're going to look at that", "ONpdzlrB74A-00140-00031239-00031574": "probability", "ONpdzlrB74A-00141-00031575-00031814": "essentially what we find is that there's", "ONpdzlrB74A-00142-00031816-00031887": "only three", "ONpdzlrB74A-00143-00031888-00032039": "chances in a thousand if there's", "ONpdzlrB74A-00144-00032039-00032190": "actually no difference between men and", "ONpdzlrB74A-00145-00032191-00032255": "women", "ONpdzlrB74A-00146-00032256-00032543": "getting a difference of 9.4 or greater", "ONpdzlrB74A-00147-00032544-00032670": "again we're doing it as a two-tailed", "ONpdzlrB74A-00148-00032672-00032790": "test we're looking at", "ONpdzlrB74A-00149-00032791-00033118": "minus nine by four and less too", "ONpdzlrB74A-00150-00033119-00033327": "but a difference of an absolute value of", "ONpdzlrB74A-00151-00033328-00033462": "9.4 or greater", "ONpdzlrB74A-00152-00033463-00033735": "has only three chances in a thousand of", "ONpdzlrB74A-00153-00033736-00033846": "happening", "ONpdzlrB74A-00154-00033847-00034127": "if men and women are indeed the same", "ONpdzlrB74A-00155-00034128-00034190": "okay", "ONpdzlrB74A-00156-00034191-00034335": "so essentially what we're finding is", "ONpdzlrB74A-00157-00034336-00034502": "this is not what should be happening the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00158-00034503-00034646": "sample evidence", "ONpdzlrB74A-00159-00034647-00034951": "should not be happening if", "ONpdzlrB74A-00160-00034952-00035111": "if the straw man is true that men and", "ONpdzlrB74A-00161-00035112-00035295": "women are the same that the two groups", "ONpdzlrB74A-00162-00035296-00035407": "are the same", "ONpdzlrB74A-00163-00035408-00035646": "this is too big a difference to be", "ONpdzlrB74A-00164-00035647-00035711": "chance", "ONpdzlrB74A-00165-00035712-00035879": "so that's what that three chances in a", "ONpdzlrB74A-00166-00035880-00036079": "thousand it would have been less than", "ONpdzlrB74A-00167-00036080-00036383": "it would have been the seven chances out", "ONpdzlrB74A-00168-00036384-00036543": "of a hundred remember we're using five", "ONpdzlrB74A-00169-00036544-00036783": "out of a hundred as our criterion", "ONpdzlrB74A-00170-00036784-00037030": "oh five that's our alpha it would have", "ONpdzlrB74A-00171-00037031-00037199": "been like seven percent ten percent", "ONpdzlrB74A-00172-00037200-00037351": "twenty percent we would not reject but", "ONpdzlrB74A-00173-00037352-00037502": "this is only three chances", "ONpdzlrB74A-00174-00037503-00037671": "in a thousand so we have to just", "ONpdzlrB74A-00175-00037672-00037927": "basically shoot down the straw man", "ONpdzlrB74A-00176-00037928-00038287": "and reject h0 if you use a computer the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00177-00038288-00038559": "computer simply gives you the p-value", "ONpdzlrB74A-00178-00038560-00038823": "the probability of getting that sample", "ONpdzlrB74A-00179-00038824-00039039": "evidence of something more extreme", "ONpdzlrB74A-00180-00039040-00039159": "and then all you have to do is compare", "ONpdzlrB74A-00181-00039160-00039295": "it with the alpha if you look at the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00182-00039296-00039407": "p-value", "ONpdzlrB74A-00183-00039408-00039559": "it comes in a print out you'll see it in", "ONpdzlrB74A-00184-00039560-00039943": "excel in any other computer programs", "ONpdzlrB74A-00185-00039944-00040111": "you can see right away whether you", "ONpdzlrB74A-00186-00040112-00040271": "should be rejecting", "ONpdzlrB74A-00187-00040272-00040446": "h0 or not so for example if you're", "ONpdzlrB74A-00188-00040447-00040655": "working on an alpha o5", "ONpdzlrB74A-00189-00040656-00040951": "and the computer prints out a p p value", "ONpdzlrB74A-00190-00040952-00040990": "of", "ONpdzlrB74A-00191-00040991-00041335": "let's say 0.0003 you know right away", "ONpdzlrB74A-00192-00041336-00041639": "to reject alpha it's telling you", "ONpdzlrB74A-00193-00041640-00041790": "the likelihood of getting the sample", "ONpdzlrB74A-00194-00041791-00042095": "evidence or something more extreme", "ONpdzlrB74A-00195-00042096-00042383": "if the two groups are the same is very", "ONpdzlrB74A-00196-00042384-00042543": "unlikely this is not what is this is not", "ONpdzlrB74A-00197-00042544-00042702": "what should be happening", "ONpdzlrB74A-00198-00042703-00043007": "that's why we reject h o so again if the", "ONpdzlrB74A-00199-00043008-00043030": "p", "ONpdzlrB74A-00200-00043031-00043430": "value is less than alpha", "ONpdzlrB74A-00201-00043431-00043607": "so again if valve is o5 and you get", "ONpdzlrB74A-00202-00043608-00043955": "something less than 05 let's say", "ONpdzlrB74A-00203-00043956-00044127": "0.0002", "ONpdzlrB74A-00204-00044128-00044551": "you're going to reject alpha", "ONpdzlrB74A-00205-00044552-00044855": "as always i encourage you to do as many", "ONpdzlrB74A-00206-00044856-00045095": "problems as you can find", "ONpdzlrB74A-00207-00045096-00045343": "it will help to strengthen your", "ONpdzlrB74A-00208-00045344-00045455": "knowledge", "ONpdzlrB74A-00209-00045456-00045743": "in statistics and it will also help you", "ONpdzlrB74A-00210-00045744-00045799": "do well", "ONpdzlrB74A-00211-00045800-00046368": "on exams practice practice practice"}}, {"audio_id": "ONIPEddREB0", "text": {"ONIPEddREB0-00000-00000305-00000309": "[Music]", "ONIPEddREB0-00001-00000310-00002138": "[Applause]", "ONIPEddREB0-00002-00002139-00003661": "[Music]", "ONIPEddREB0-00003-00003663-00004375": "[Music]", "ONIPEddREB0-00004-00004376-00004430": "foreign", "ONIPEddREB0-00005-00004431-00007383": "[Music]", "ONIPEddREB0-00006-00007384-00007919": "[Music]", "ONIPEddREB0-00007-00007920-00008131": "oh", "ONIPEddREB0-00008-00008133-00010127": "[Music]", "ONIPEddREB0-00009-00010128-00010336": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "ONVd6h7cL8y", "text": {"ONVd6h7cL8y-00000-00000003-00000644": "member Stevens member Stevens", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00001-00000645-00000989": "I apologize member for London fan shop", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00002-00000990-00001289": "Thank You speaker I am I want to talk", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00003-00001290-00001462": "about today about the education system", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00004-00001463-00001589": "and specifically I want to bring the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00005-00001590-00001777": "voice of a student in my riding Kristen", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00006-00001778-00001916": "and she wrote me a letter and she said", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00007-00001917-00002134": "I'm a grade seven student at Evelyn", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00008-00002135-00002324": "Harris public school in London Ontario I", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00009-00002325-00002617": "have a few concerns concerns addressing", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00010-00002618-00002809": "all the new cuts possibly be made to the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00011-00002810-00003050": "education system my first concern is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00012-00003051-00003281": "what may be happening with the special", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00013-00003282-00003509": "needs classes this concerns me because I", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00014-00003510-00003674": "have a friend that is in grade six and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00015-00003675-00003931": "he has very severe autism he needs all", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00016-00003932-00004154": "the help he can get every day because", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00017-00004155-00004361": "his mood can change very fast for", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00018-00004362-00004552": "example he could get be happy one minute", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00019-00004553-00004766": "and sad the other my heart breaks", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00020-00004767-00004967": "knowing that next year he may not get", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00021-00004968-00005186": "the help he needs my second concern is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00022-00005187-00005443": "addressing a cutting teachers jobs", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00023-00005444-00005672": "this concerns me because my aunt and my", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00024-00005673-00005854": "uncle are both teachers and I would hate", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00025-00005855-00006056": "to see them lose their jobs if the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00026-00006057-00006293": "government does decide to cut more jobs", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00027-00006294-00006475": "for teachers their families will go", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00028-00006476-00006742": "hungry or even worse go homeless my", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00029-00006743-00006962": "teachers husband and her husband are", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00030-00006963-00007127": "booked my teacher and her husband are", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00031-00007128-00007355": "both teachers as well they have two kids", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00032-00007356-00007523": "and if they get cut and if they have", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00033-00007523-00007694": "these cuts they might not have enough", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00034-00007695-00007948": "money to keep their house finally if", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00035-00007950-00008195": "these classes are bigger there will be", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00036-00008196-00008432": "less focused towards teachers and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00037-00008433-00008645": "students I hope you take 2 in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00038-00008646-00008846": "consideration the lives that you may be", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00039-00008847-00009077": "affecting so speaker here we are", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00040-00009078-00009305": "students like Kristen in grade 8", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00041-00009306-00009584": "emailing us sending us letters and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00042-00009585-00009824": "asking this government to stop the cuts", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00043-00009825-00010001": "to education for the better a target", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00044-00010002-00010531": "schools member samie member", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00045-00010532-00010808": "chris-barbara news partner Thank You mr.", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00046-00010809-00010885": "speaker", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00047-00010886-00011149": "I have immense privilege to represent", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00048-00011150-00011389": "the great writing of Scarborough roots", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00049-00011390-00011560": "Park there is the home to great", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00050-00011561-00011767": "institutions such as University of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00051-00011768-00012020": "Toronto Scarborough campers the Toronto", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00052-00012021-00012263": "Zoo and of course the Rouge national", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00053-00012264-00012560": "urban park as beautiful and vibrant as", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00054-00012561-00012818": "Carrboro is it has lagged behind the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00055-00012819-00013085": "rest of Toronto in job creation and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00056-00013086-00013268": "economic growth", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00057-00013269-00013481": "youth and employment in Scarborough", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00058-00013482-00013669": "Rouge Park among the highest in the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00059-00013671-00013907": "province and people have found it hard", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00060-00013908-00014272": "to fight find employment that is why I'm", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00061-00014274-00014549": "hosting my first Scarborough job fair on", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00062-00014550-00014840": "March the 14th at the Malvern Family", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00063-00014841-00015088": "Resource Center where my constituents", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00064-00015090-00015316": "will have the opportunity to directly", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00065-00015318-00015611": "connect with local businesses and larger", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00066-00015612-00016112": "companies such as Amazon RBC Toronto Zoo", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00067-00016113-00016379": "Scarborough Health Network and so much", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00068-00016380-00016655": "more I want to thank the Minister of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00069-00016656-00016832": "Labour training and skills development", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00070-00016833-00017114": "for his support on this initiative", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00071-00017115-00017306": "I'm also proud of the work our", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00072-00017307-00017543": "government continues to do to address", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00073-00017544-00017935": "unemployment since we got elected over", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00074-00017936-00018266": "300,000 new jobs have been created here", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00075-00018267-00018554": "in Ontario and mr. speaker I'll continue", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00076-00018555-00018722": "to fight for the residents of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00077-00018723-00019240": "Scarborough roots pause Thank You", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00078-00019241-00019502": "members Davies member for Comiskey mean", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00079-00019503-00019679": "Cochrane thank you speaker this", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00080-00019680-00019963": "statement is for the Ministry of Finance", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00081-00019964-00020183": "businesses small businesses I think", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00082-00020184-00020318": "throughout the province but certainly in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00083-00020319-00020543": "my riding are being choked and are", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00084-00020544-00020783": "almost closing are closing because of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00085-00020784-00020975": "the cost of insurance and I'll give you", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00086-00020976-00021206": "some examples JPL storage and Haileybury", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00087-00021207-00021439": "the son wants to take the business over", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00088-00021440-00022007": "fully trained to drive a a z truck can't", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00089-00022008-00022219": "get insurance only facility we've got", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00090-00022220-00022481": "Alex Forest great all business same", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00091-00022482-00022819": "thing Eve rents on contracting DJ and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00092-00022820-00023194": "sons contracting both are closing there", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00093-00023195-00023384": "or threatening to close or snow removal", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00094-00023385-00023702": "businesses because why speaker the cost", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00095-00023703-00023936": "of insurance the cost of liability and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00096-00023937-00024137": "caught insurance the cost of insurance", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00097-00024138-00024331": "to drive a commercial vehicle is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00098-00024332-00024791": "shutting rural Ontario down insurance is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00099-00024792-00025219": "it provincially regulated its if it is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00100-00025220-00025457": "provincially regulated and and the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00101-00025458-00025708": "government has the power to help these", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00102-00025710-00025886": "small businesses there is a budget", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00103-00025887-00026189": "coming up we're this government with the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00104-00026189-00026405": "majority and they are saying that they", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00105-00026406-00026633": "are open for business it's time that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00106-00026633-00026945": "they help small businesses like Jeep JPL", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00107-00026945-00027230": "so they can actually afford the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00108-00027231-00027473": "insurance so Earl can take over that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00109-00027474-00027658": "business because if Earl can't take that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00110-00027660-00027883": "business over that business is going to", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00111-00027885-00028105": "close and that's going to happen across", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00112-00028106-00028358": "rural Ontario this government has the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00113-00028358-00028540": "power to stop but it's time to step up", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00114-00028541-00029204": "for small business thank you so much mr.", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00115-00029205-00029357": "speaker and I'm very pleased to share", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00116-00029358-00029444": "with the house that there was a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00117-00029445-00029669": "celebration on March the second in my", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00118-00029670-00029864": "writing of Thornhill at the promenade", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00119-00029864-00030026": "shopping center and it was a big", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00120-00030027-00030251": "celebration to celebrate a commitment", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00121-00030252-00030488": "that was made to healthcare in York", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00122-00030489-00030689": "Region the promenade group the Saraya", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00123-00030689-00030895": "family the Darvish family and liberty", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00124-00030897-00031160": "development generally sleep gifted five", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00125-00031161-00031339": "million dollars to support the new", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00126-00031341-00031589": "Mackenzie Vaughan Hospital a new", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00127-00031589-00031751": "hospital will be the first hospital in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00128-00031752-00031985": "Canada to feature fully integrated smart", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00129-00031986-00032201": "technology systems and medical devices", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00130-00032202-00032483": "that speak to one another to maximize", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00131-00032483-00032723": "information exchange scheduled to open", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00132-00032724-00032915": "later this year this hospital will be", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00133-00032916-00033119": "groundbreaking for both for both", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00134-00033120-00033335": "healthcare in Ontario and for the York", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00135-00033336-00033575": "Region community the new McKenzie Vaughn", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00136-00033576-00033715": "hospital will feature the newest", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00137-00033716-00033914": "technology and diagnostic imaging", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00138-00033915-00034223": "surgical service services ambulatory", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00139-00034224-00034442": "clinics and many other subfields of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00140-00034443-00034694": "medicine innovation and efficiency have", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00141-00034695-00034874": "been a center focus of this government", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00142-00034875-00035051": "since taking office and I am proud that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00143-00035052-00035276": "York Region is able to exemplify these", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00144-00035277-00035486": "values through projects like this", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00145-00035487-00035735": "hospital I truly commend that prominent", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00146-00035736-00035960": "group the Sirois family the Darvish", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00147-00035961-00036164": "family and liberty development on their", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00148-00036165-00036335": "generous donation and their commitment", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00149-00036336-00036545": "to helping Ontario continue to flourish", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00150-00036546-00036848": "and to set examples for the entire world", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00151-00036849-00037070": "so thank you thank you to all the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00152-00037071-00037235": "families involved thank you for", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00153-00037236-00037406": "everybody at we call it the promenade", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00154-00037407-00037580": "mall not the promenade shopping center", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00155-00037581-00037777": "but thank you for everybody to the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00156-00037778-00037927": "customers and the people who work there", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00157-00037928-00038191": "take her", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00158-00038192-00038420": "mind all the members that are coming to", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00159-00038421-00038597": "the chamber we are in member statements", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00160-00038598-00038741": "and asked them to keep the banter to a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00161-00038742-00038792": "minimum", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00162-00038793-00039029": "remember statements remember for", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00163-00039030-00039233": "Davenport morning mr. speaker in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00164-00039234-00039416": "recognition of International Women's Day", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00165-00039417-00039674": "I rise today to salute the work of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00166-00039675-00039872": "women's advocacy organizations in my", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00167-00039873-00040112": "community of Davenport organizations", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00168-00040113-00040298": "like the South Asian Women's Center", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00169-00040299-00040577": "Working Women's community center Abrigo", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00170-00040578-00040847": "Center and sister e provide essential", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00171-00040848-00041015": "services to women when they need it the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00172-00041016-00041261": "most often operating on very limited", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00173-00041262-00041501": "budgets and forced to continually apply", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00174-00041502-00041741": "for grants to sustain their operations", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00175-00041742-00041939": "Mr Speaker despite the weather the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00176-00041940-00042170": "wealth generated in Ontario poverty", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00177-00042171-00042362": "persists especially in our urban", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00178-00042363-00042635": "communities that poverty is gendered and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00179-00042636-00042938": "it is racialized the YWCA has estimated", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00180-00042939-00043235": "that 450,000 Ontario women live on low", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00181-00043236-00043400": "incomes but instead of acting", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00182-00043401-00043610": "meaningfully to address this gendered", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00183-00043611-00043790": "poverty this government has made things", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00184-00043791-00044006": "much worse with cuts to childcare to", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00185-00044007-00044216": "social services to rape crisis centers", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00186-00044217-00044426": "they've targeted the earnings of women", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00187-00044427-00044666": "in the public sector taking us backward", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00188-00044667-00044870": "not forward in the fight for pay equity", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00189-00044871-00045098": "while offering tax giveaways to the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00190-00045099-00045233": "wealthiest speaker our community", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00191-00045234-00045482": "agencies are working overtime to keep", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00192-00045483-00045800": "women safe housed and employed they", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00193-00045801-00045983": "deserve a government that works with", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00194-00045984-00046187": "them to lift women up instead of one", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00195-00046188-00046329": "that works to hold them down", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00196-00046330-00046550": "indeed don't all women deserve that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00197-00046551-00046652": "Thank You mr. speaker", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00198-00046653-00047500": "[Applause]", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00199-00047501-00047837": "one more time I'll ask the members to be", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00200-00047838-00048236": "quiet we are in member statements I need", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00201-00048237-00048359": "to be able to hear the member who has", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00202-00048360-00048683": "the floor the next member statement the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00203-00048684-00048848": "member for Dawn Valley West it's very", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00204-00048849-00049028": "much mr. speaker mr. speaker yesterday I", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00205-00049029-00049268": "hosted my annual Danville International", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00206-00049269-00049424": "Women's Day celebration I want to thank", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00207-00049425-00049664": "all of the hundred men and women who", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00208-00049665-00049859": "came to mark this important day the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00209-00049860-00050129": "theme of this year's IWD was each for", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00210-00050130-00050393": "equal the movement to equality for women", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00211-00050394-00050546": "around the world comprises", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00212-00050547-00050792": "organizational change coordinated action", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00213-00050793-00051017": "but as importantly the actions of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00214-00051018-00051176": "millions of individuals in their lives", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00215-00051177-00051367": "every day we talked about the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00216-00051369-00051545": "expectations and social norms that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00217-00051546-00051707": "create barriers for women in business", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00218-00051708-00051940": "and their communities and in politics we", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00219-00051941-00052102": "talked about the times in all of our", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00220-00052103-00052298": "lives as women when we've challenged", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00221-00052299-00052478": "those expectations and pushed through", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00222-00052479-00052796": "over or around those barriers one young", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00223-00052797-00053012": "woman told us about her experience as", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00224-00053013-00053171": "the youngest woman member of the Afghan", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00225-00053172-00053390": "parliament it was her mother who", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00226-00053391-00053594": "encouraged her and helped her find the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00227-00053595-00053795": "strength to defy the expectation that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00228-00053796-00054011": "she what she should have been doing was", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00229-00054012-00054169": "getting married and having a family", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00230-00054170-00054404": "another young woman who aspired to make", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00231-00054404-00054575": "a contribution by joining a corporate", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00232-00054576-00054848": "board was discouraged by her friends but", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00233-00054849-00055004": "she didn't have the experience and that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00234-00055004-00055214": "she should give up on the idea she heard", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00235-00055215-00055466": "the advice but moved ahead and has been", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00236-00055466-00055729": "successful what we know for sure mr.", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00237-00055730-00055910": "speaker is that we're nowhere close to", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00238-00055911-00056090": "equal representation of women in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00239-00056091-00056305": "positions of authority and power thank", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00240-00056307-00056477": "you to each individual who is working", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00241-00056478-00056729": "for true equality for women here and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00242-00056729-00057292": "around the world member statements the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00243-00057294-00057880": "member for Oakville North March this", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00244-00057882-00058057": "year is the inaugural Hellenic Heritage", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00245-00058058-00058361": "Month in Ontario I'm very honored that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00246-00058362-00058591": "the Legislature passed my bill last year", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00247-00058592-00058886": "to establish this month and I thank all", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00248-00058887-00059075": "my colleagues in this house who gave", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00249-00059076-00059348": "unanimous support to this bill March", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00250-00059349-00059432": "25th", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00251-00059433-00059585": "is the day that Greece declared his", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00252-00059586-00059798": "independence from the Ottoman Empire", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00253-00059799-00060004": "which is why the month of March was", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00254-00060005-00060200": "chosen for this commemoration", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00255-00060201-00060453": "Hellenic Heritage Month celebrates the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00256-00060454-00060690": "contributions of Halim's and Hellenic", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00257-00060691-00060933": "culture to our great province of Ontario", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00258-00060934-00061119": "to Canada and the world", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00259-00061120-00061374": "Greeks gave us the first amok recei in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00260-00061375-00061710": "ancient Athens Greek philosophy medicine", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00261-00061711-00061944": "science history and much more are a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00262-00061945-00062181": "vital part of the cultural foundation of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00263-00062182-00062484": "Western countries the Islamic world and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00264-00062485-00062793": "many other nations the month also honors", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00265-00062794-00062991": "the many Canadians of hellenic descent", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00266-00062992-00063192": "whose families came to Canada", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00267-00063193-00063432": "seeking a better life mothers and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00268-00063433-00063591": "fathers and grandfathers and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00269-00063592-00063852": "grandparents who worked hard building a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00270-00063853-00064011": "new life for themselves and their", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00271-00064012-00064096": "children", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00272-00064097-00064335": "Hellenic Canadian Canadian Canadian", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00273-00064336-00064707": "Canadians today their children excel in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00274-00064708-00064986": "every field business sport culture", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00275-00064987-00065298": "politics and education and many more I", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00276-00065299-00065640": "invite all mpps today to join with the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00277-00065641-00065874": "dignitaries who are with us for a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00278-00065875-00066135": "picture on the grand staircase after", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00279-00066136-00066876": "question period Thank You speaker member", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00280-00066877-00067021": "statements remember for Scarborough", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00281-00067022-00067374": "Southwest Thank You speaker on March 6th", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00282-00067375-00067563": "a very special constituent of", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00283-00067564-00067731": "Scarborough Southwest celebrated his", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00284-00067732-00068004": "hundredth birthday Fred arsenal's a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00285-00068005-00068221": "decorated Second World War veteran who", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00286-00068222-00068514": "served our country valiantly in Italy", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00287-00068515-00068712": "and the Netherlands as a private in the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00288-00068713-00068943": "infantry celebrated this milestone last", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00289-00068944-00069129": "Friday Mr Arsenault", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00290-00069130-00069411": "enjoys receiving the mail it is what has", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00291-00069412-00069675": "gotten him through that past years he", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00292-00069676-00069816": "remembers reading the letters he", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00293-00069817-00069933": "received from his mom", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00294-00069934-00070185": "at night in the trenches of Italy since", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00295-00070186-00070383": "then he has always enjoyed going through", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00296-00070384-00070557": "the mail last month", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00297-00070558-00070812": "mr. Arsenal's son Ron Arsenault made an", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00298-00070813-00071040": "appeal on social media for a hundred", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00299-00071041-00071178": "cards to celebrate the extraordinary", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00300-00071179-00071544": "milestone and by Friday Mr Arsenault had", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00301-00071545-00072092": "received over 90,000 cars and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00302-00072093-00072342": "wishing him happy birthday and thanking", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00303-00072343-00072555": "him for his service he received letters", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00304-00072556-00072729": "from children countless veterans and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00305-00072730-00073017": "people from all walks of life I've had", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00306-00073018-00073272": "the chance to meet Fred at Remembrance", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00307-00073273-00073440": "Day events in Scarborough and last", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00308-00073441-00073617": "couple that last couple of years and it", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00309-00073618-00073860": "has been always a tremendous honor to", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00310-00073861-00074046": "meet him and listen to his stories", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00311-00074047-00074501": "Fred's honor includes from 1939 to 1945", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00312-00074502-00074813": "star in Italy star of France and Germany", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00313-00074814-00075030": "star a defense medal a Canadian", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00314-00075031-00075257": "volunteer service medal with overseas", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00315-00075258-00075599": "bar and a war medal we thank you for", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00316-00075600-00075818": "your service Fred to this country Fred", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00317-00075819-00075974": "OTT from all of us in the Ontario", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00318-00075975-00076207": "legislature we wish you a very happy", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00319-00076208-00077716": "birthday thank you", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00320-00077717-00077967": "member statements the member for Whitney", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00321-00077968-00078292": "your last Tuesday the Honourable 15", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00322-00078293-00078541": "Elliot the Minister of Health and the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00323-00078542-00078700": "Honorable Michael T below associate", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00324-00078701-00078890": "minister of mental health and addictions", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00325-00078891-00079057": "were in Ontario short Center for Mental", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00326-00079058-00079338": "Health Sciences in my writing to launch", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00327-00079339-00079594": "roadmap to wellness a plan to build an", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00328-00079595-00079798": "Ontario mental health and addiction", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00329-00079799-00080044": "system speaker which provides a clear", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00330-00080045-00080287": "path towards offering antarians easier", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00331-00080288-00080536": "access to higher quality care and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00332-00080537-00080761": "supports in their communities speaker by", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00333-00080762-00080998": "improving the availability and quality", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00334-00080999-00081197": "of mental health and addiction supports", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00335-00081198-00081406": "and by better connecting antarians with", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00336-00081407-00081661": "these services this new plan speaker", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00337-00081662-00081826": "will help us build healthier communities", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00338-00081827-00082087": "by alleviating growing pressures on our", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00339-00082088-00082348": "hospitals and in doing so significantly", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00340-00082349-00082579": "support our goal of ending hallway", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00341-00082580-00082768": "health care speaker the government", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00342-00082769-00082997": "continues to fill our promise of making", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00343-00082998-00083159": "mental health and addictions our", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00344-00083160-00083425": "priority the roadmap to wellness moves", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00345-00083426-00083617": "us in the right directions towards", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00346-00083618-00083842": "building a comprehensive and connected", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00347-00083843-00084073": "mental health and addiction system that", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00348-00084074-00084241": "works for all Ontarians across the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00349-00084242-00084497": "lifespan this is a plan speaker that is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00350-00084498-00084742": "client centered data-driven and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00351-00084743-00085054": "evidence-based most of all speaker is a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00352-00085055-00085282": "plan that will ensure that all Ontarians", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00353-00085283-00085535": "are able to access high-quality services", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00354-00085536-00085807": "and supports where and when they need", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00355-00085808-00085997": "them Thank You speaker", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00356-00085998-00086441": "[Applause]", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00357-00086442-00086894": "member statements the member for Barry", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00358-00086895-00087263": "Innisfil mr. speaker our government has", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00359-00087264-00087491": "an ambitious agenda over the next ten", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00360-00087492-00087662": "years we will be investing over a", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00361-00087663-00087899": "hundred billion dollars in new schools", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00362-00087900-00088178": "hospitals transportation projects and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00363-00088179-00088505": "more yet if the workforce is not", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00364-00088506-00088769": "available these projects cannot happen", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00365-00088770-00089086": "in industrial electrician and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00366-00089087-00089324": "Construction Trades the job vacancy", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00367-00089325-00089690": "rates in the third quarter 2009 were 51", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00368-00089691-00089927": "percent higher than they were four years", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00369-00089928-00090176": "ago according to the job site indeed", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00370-00090177-00090449": "the skilled trades are meaningful and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00371-00090450-00090722": "often lucrative careers especially for", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00372-00090723-00091220": "young women yet they make up only 17% in", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00373-00091221-00091553": "registered apprentices yesterday was", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00374-00091554-00091868": "International Women's Day I am proud to", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00375-00091869-00092075": "work with our government and the work", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00376-00092076-00092276": "that our government is doing to end the", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00377-00092277-00092525": "stigma to make skills trades the first", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00378-00092526-00092843": "choice for our young women this includes", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00379-00092844-00093119": "running ads that feature two female", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00380-00093120-00093332": "journey persons an arborist and a crane", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00381-00093333-00093575": "operator working in careers that Derrick", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00382-00093576-00093800": "day I dare I say mr. speaker they", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00383-00093801-00094046": "wouldn't trade another challenge is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00384-00094047-00094280": "encouraging female students to take STEM", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00385-00094281-00094496": "related courses and our government is", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00386-00094497-00094700": "working with organizations like skills", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00387-00094701-00094943": "Ontario to break down the barriers and", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00388-00094944-00095174": "there is plenty of more mr. speaker our", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00389-00095175-00095333": "government is working with businesses", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00390-00095334-00095576": "working with labor and Ontario's open", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00391-00095577-00096203": "for opportunities for everyone thank you", "ONVd6h7cL8y-00392-00096204-00096437": "very much"}}, {"audio_id": "Op5N7eJf2mc", "text": {"Op5N7eJf2mc-00000-00000048-00000093": "[Music]", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00001-00000094-00000421": "the Bermuda Triangle mystery has been", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00002-00000422-00000708": "solved", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00003-00000709-00000998": "how many creepy stories about the", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00004-00000999-00001211": "disappearing of airplanes and ships in", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00005-00001212-00001462": "the Bermuda Triangle have you heard we", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00006-00001463-00001748": "guess a whole bunch it is a large area", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00007-00001748-00002051": "in the Atlantic Ocean between Florida", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00008-00002052-00002363": "cuarto Rico and Bermuda this region is", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00009-00002364-00002641": "notorious for its mysterious phenomena", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00010-00002642-00002882": "huge amounts of ships and planes have", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00011-00002883-00003184": "disappeared here its second name is the", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00012-00003185-00003476": "devil's triangle all those mythical", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00013-00003477-00003725": "vanishings happened under unknown and", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00014-00003726-00003983": "unexplained circumstances some of the", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00015-00003984-00004217": "planes and ships have never been found", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00016-00004218-00004469": "there have been many theories about why", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00017-00004470-00004727": "it all occurs in that area starting from", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00018-00004728-00004967": "water spouts to aliens and even sea", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00019-00004968-00005267": "monsters but those were only theories", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00020-00005268-00005445": "[Music]", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00021-00005446-00005795": "reports go back to 1945 when five", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00022-00005796-00006052": "American torpedo bombers and a plane", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00023-00006053-00006206": "that was sent out to find them all", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00024-00006207-00006368": "vanished without a trace", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00025-00006369-00006758": "since that day another 75 aircraft and", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00026-00006759-00007145": "several hundred ships have been lost the", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00027-00007145-00007423": "latest tragedy happened in 2015 when the", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00028-00007425-00007681": "cargo ship El Faro disappeared in this", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00029-00007683-00007931": "region El Faro was a u.s. vessel", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00030-00007931-00008228": "traveling from Florida to Puerto Rico it", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00031-00008229-00008402": "disappeared from the radars on the 1st", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00032-00008403-00008789": "of October 2015 and was found wreck on", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00033-00008790-00009026": "the bottom of the ocean on the 31st of", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00034-00009027-00009121": "October", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00035-00009122-00009473": "[Music]", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00036-00009474-00009711": "another big incident happened on the", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00037-00009712-00010064": "20th of June 2005 when the first Piper", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00038-00010065-00010305": "PA airplane disappeared in the Bermuda", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00039-00010306-00010569": "Triangle there were three people on", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00040-00010570-00010824": "board the second similar incident", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00041-00010825-00011148": "happened on the 10th of April 2007 when", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00042-00011149-00011427": "one more Piper pa airplane disappeared", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00043-00011428-00011562": "near Bury Island", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00044-00011563-00011742": "there was only one pilot on board", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00045-00011743-00011931": "without any passengers", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00046-00011932-00012363": "neither plane has ever been found there", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00047-00012364-00012521": "were small incidents as well", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00048-00012522-00012810": "a luxury cabin cruiser witchcraft that", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00049-00012811-00013019": "belonged to Buraq who owns a popular", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00050-00013020-00013263": "hotel as well went along the shore of", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00051-00013263-00013518": "Miami together with his father to enjoy", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00052-00013519-00013806": "the beauty of Christmas lights in 1967", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00053-00013807-00014118": "after some time the shore guard got a", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00054-00014119-00014366": "call from Buraq who said that his vessel", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00055-00014368-00014622": "hit something and asked for towing when", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00056-00014622-00014825": "the guard arrived at the place after 20", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00057-00014826-00015090": "minutes they couldn't find anyone the", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00058-00015091-00015325": "boat together with Barak and his father", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00059-00015326-00015947": "disappeared and have never been found", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00060-00015947-00016200": "many stories are whirling around this", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00061-00016201-00016530": "area but now finally the mystery behind", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00062-00016531-00016743": "the Bermuda Triangle may have been", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00063-00016744-00016974": "solved at least that's what a science", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00064-00016975-00017253": "Channel show claims a team of American", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00065-00017254-00017400": "scientists from the University of", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00066-00017401-00017643": "Colorado analyze satellite weather", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00067-00017644-00017877": "images of this notorious area and", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00068-00017878-00018192": "noticed a series of unusual hexagonal", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00069-00018193-00018438": "clouds on them the meteorologists", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00070-00018439-00018663": "theorized that these clouds might act", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00071-00018664-00018975": "like real air bombs it's believed they", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00072-00018976-00019185": "are the main cause of the deadly blasts", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00073-00019186-00019527": "of air which can easily exceed 170 miles", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00074-00019528-00019590": "per hour", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00075-00019591-00019842": "these hurricane-force winds literally", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00076-00019843-00020088": "blow up the air and can generate waves", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00077-00020089-00020513": "of more than 45 feet in length", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00078-00020514-00020850": "no ship can survive such a storm and no", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00079-00020851-00021041": "aircraft can withstand such a wind", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00080-00021042-00021285": "clouds don't typically form straight", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00081-00021286-00021540": "edges however judging by the satellite", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00082-00021541-00021798": "images the Bermuda Triangle is an", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00083-00021799-00022068": "exception to this rule the announcement", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00084-00022069-00022272": "of this theory has motivated a lot of", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00085-00022273-00022512": "further research scientists from all", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00086-00022513-00022695": "over the globe are trying to figure out", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00087-00022696-00023028": "what the reasons for such anomalies are", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00088-00023029-00023165": "[Music]", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00089-00023166-00023457": "do you know any other Bermuda Triangle", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00090-00023458-00023748": "stories do you have another theory for", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00091-00023749-00024111": "all those abnormalities share them in", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00092-00024112-00024333": "the comment section below as for me I", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00093-00024334-00024525": "was once lost in the Bermuda Triangle", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00094-00024526-00024840": "but I was rescued by an alien who left", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00095-00024841-00025005": "me off at area 51", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00096-00025006-00025236": "true story don't forget to hit the like", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00097-00025237-00025446": "button below the video and will tell you", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00098-00025447-00025631": "other mysterious theories about our", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00099-00025632-00025850": "planet see you back here soon", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00100-00025851-00026295": "on the bright side of life", "Op5N7eJf2mc-00101-00026295-00026613": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OpvPj6OcEiA", "text": {"OpvPj6OcEiA-00000-00000170-00000473": "[Music]", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00001-00000474-00000755": "welcome to the self governing teams", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00002-00000756-00001097": "through sofa sociocracy for all uh which", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00003-00001098-00001366": "will be delivered by my device is based", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00004-00001367-00001582": "out of North Carolina he's the business", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00005-00001583-00001841": "agility coach with project brilliant he", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00006-00001842-00001979": "is currently engaged in agile", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00007-00001980-00002218": "transformation for healthcare it he's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00008-00002219-00002597": "got into agile in 2008.", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00009-00002598-00002800": "without any further delay over to you I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00010-00002801-00003160": "am otherwise thank you so much pankaj so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00011-00003161-00003419": "I am going to share my screen", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00012-00003420-00003743": "awesome so today's topic is talking", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00013-00003744-00003865": "about", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00014-00003865-00004120": "self-governance for self-organizing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00015-00004121-00004367": "teams and uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00016-00004368-00004583": "we will probably go through depending on", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00017-00004584-00004751": "how many people should be made do some", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00018-00004752-00005159": "more interactive uh exercises here but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00019-00005160-00005356": "just to just to add on to what Punker", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00020-00005357-00005579": "said I'm also a sociocracy for all", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00021-00005580-00005909": "facilitator a practitioner and on my way", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00022-00005910-00006191": "to becoming a trainer as well and I am a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00023-00006192-00006454": "working member of sofa I am part of the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00024-00006455-00006646": "organization where I help with open", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00025-00006647-00006910": "source content Circle so there's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00026-00006911-00007084": "multiple connection points I'm available", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00027-00007086-00007433": "on the interwebs and happy to always uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00028-00007434-00007606": "chat up if this topic is of more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00029-00007608-00007870": "interest for you so with that let's get", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00030-00007872-00008003": "into the topic", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00031-00008004-00008387": "so why governance now governance", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00032-00008388-00008645": "typically means how do you run the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00033-00008646-00008992": "organization how does funding happen how", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00034-00008993-00009346": "do you make the whole organization a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00035-00009347-00009569": "more futuristic organization especially", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00036-00009570-00009760": "in this topic of governance that we have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00037-00009761-00010001": "where people who are governing also have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00038-00010002-00010246": "a voice in how they're governed", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00039-00010247-00010541": "the world is rapidly changing we have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00040-00010542-00010828": "for up to five different Generations in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00041-00010829-00011141": "the workforce and covet has permanently", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00042-00011142-00011441": "changed our landscape and more and more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00043-00011442-00011592": "people have different expectations", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00044-00011593-00011988": "whether we are in you know in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00045-00011989-00012377": "manufacturing in medical devices in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00046-00012378-00012569": "software development everybody is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00047-00012570-00012815": "touched by software so we're essentially", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00048-00012816-00013085": "in an era where knowledge work was the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00049-00013086-00013372": "term that we started with but all these", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00050-00013373-00013643": "systems have you've been using", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00051-00013644-00013858": "governance models from many many many", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00052-00013859-00014158": "decades ago right what are the typical", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00053-00014159-00014344": "one like you know top down hierarchy", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00054-00014345-00014807": "boss decides or we all decide or you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00055-00014808-00015088": "know in the family mom decides or we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00056-00015090-00015401": "vote right majority vote wins then you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00057-00015402-00015593": "know there'll be winners and losers if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00058-00015594-00015851": "you have simple majority then other", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00059-00015852-00016085": "folks that who had less majority or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00060-00016086-00016361": "minority will lose but all these aspects", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00061-00016362-00016594": "are important to understand well who who", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00062-00016595-00016708": "decides", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00063-00016709-00016961": "who decides like how do decision making", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00064-00016962-00017297": "happen and do I even have a voice the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00065-00017298-00017567": "way Society Works in a democracy is not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00066-00017568-00017813": "quite the way organizations or companies", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00067-00017814-00018065": "work so it is important to see that how", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00068-00018066-00018353": "do we tie in this connection", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00069-00018354-00018550": "now a lot of times people will say well", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00070-00018551-00018899": "you know we have this weird balance that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00071-00018900-00019169": "we need to achieve we need to get worked", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00072-00019170-00019397": "up we need to just get it done like in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00073-00019398-00019655": "just work work work we don't have we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00074-00019656-00019871": "don't have time to do anything else or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00075-00019872-00020219": "we can be connecting thinking in a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00076-00020220-00020471": "building empathy listening is either or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00077-00020472-00020843": "so I find that this either or thinking", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00078-00020844-00021179": "is also not helpful we have to find the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00079-00021180-00021467": "right balance and there is a possibility", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00080-00021468-00021841": "of increasing increasing the balance", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00081-00021842-00022272": "towards a more Humane more connected", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00082-00022273-00022541": "organization so if you are in an agile", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00083-00022542-00022703": "team you're practicing scrum you're", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00084-00022704-00022955": "practicing XP you're practicing kanban", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00085-00022956-00023147": "we still have a lot of opportunities", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00086-00023148-00023386": "that hey when decisions are being made", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00087-00023387-00023644": "do we go back into the old patterns from", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00088-00023645-00023908": "1980s the management style of the all", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00089-00023909-00024113": "versus that you know making sure that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00090-00024114-00024347": "people feel included and we're still", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00091-00024348-00024593": "getting work done power isn't", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00092-00024594-00024858": "necessarily bad but how we share power", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00093-00024859-00025199": "in a team in an organization does matter", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00094-00025200-00025457": "so we have to think about how are we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00095-00025458-00025594": "governing each other how are we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00096-00025595-00025846": "governing our team", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00097-00025847-00026014": "so in that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00098-00026016-00026243": "this is the most common model that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00099-00026244-00026387": "you've probably seen many many versions", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00100-00026388-00026614": "The Pyramid model like you know the top", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00101-00026616-00026896": "makes the decisions and people on the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00102-00026897-00027107": "bottom carry out those decisions right", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00103-00027108-00027340": "so whoever's on the top they'll give the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00104-00027341-00027533": "next order person next line person next", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00105-00027533-00027724": "line person and decisions are being", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00106-00027725-00027977": "carried out and this is a little bit of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00107-00027977-00028120": "an outdated model", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00108-00028122-00028618": "so in sociocracy we say well we have to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00109-00028619-00028979": "think about three things we have to talk", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00110-00028980-00029314": "about how our organization can have an", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00111-00029316-00029717": "unseeded flow of information so we use", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00112-00029718-00030064": "the term circles circles and we will go", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00113-00030066-00030281": "a little bit more into it circles are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00114-00030282-00030646": "containers of of people who are getting", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00115-00030647-00031055": "work done and there is decision making", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00116-00031056-00031181": "happening", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00117-00031182-00031481": "which is happening by consent not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00118-00031482-00031679": "consensus there's a little bit of a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00119-00031680-00031990": "Nuance there and it's coming up to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00120-00031991-00032146": "understand well what does that mean", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00121-00032147-00032327": "because a lot of time you know you talk", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00122-00032327-00032573": "to especially if some of you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00123-00032574-00032740": "um you know I don't know if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00124-00032741-00032909": "um let me ask this question how many of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00125-00032910-00033262": "you are software developers or put it in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00126-00033263-00033545": "chat your your you know what you do so I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00127-00033546-00033809": "I can give you a better example uh if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00128-00033810-00033971": "you are a software developer please", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00129-00033972-00034157": "write in chat that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00130-00034158-00034439": "um you are a software developer or share", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00131-00034440-00034985": "what your roles are I'm curious to know", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00132-00034986-00035645": "you're an agile coached", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00133-00035646-00035849": "software engineer", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00134-00035850-00035993": "hi Bart", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00135-00035994-00036515": "so Bart's a friend of mine", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00136-00036516-00036935": "all right uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00137-00036936-00037127": "and I'm still waiting for maybe one or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00138-00037128-00037283": "two responses it's possible that you're", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00139-00037284-00037499": "probably distracted so software is a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00140-00037500-00037745": "good example right so let's let's go", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00141-00037746-00037973": "back to software so a lot of times when", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00142-00037974-00038146": "I find when I'm talking to software", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00143-00038147-00038339": "developers they get really really bound", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00144-00038340-00038567": "up in the type of Frameworks it's like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00145-00038568-00038812": "you know the flavor of ice cream right I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00146-00038813-00039040": "like vanilla or this person likes", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00147-00039041-00039274": "chocolate and they get really hung up on", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00148-00039275-00039502": "hey vanilla for me all day long with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00149-00039503-00039689": "chocolate for me all day long and those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00150-00039690-00039833": "type of things are called personal", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00151-00039834-00040090": "preferences but if it's a really really", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00152-00040091-00040337": "hot day you won't care what the flavor", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00153-00040338-00040630": "is you'll have ice cream so we want to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00154-00040631-00040846": "make sure we move away from preferences", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00155-00040847-00041093": "and into area where you're tolerate or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00156-00041094-00041305": "accepted for the benefit of the group", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00157-00041306-00041651": "whereas whereas where problems what we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00158-00041652-00041921": "want to do is remove any harm if there's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00159-00041922-00042167": "any harm that's there we want to remove", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00160-00042168-00042359": "that and so that's why consent is still", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00161-00042360-00042533": "important because the point is not to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00162-00042534-00042695": "make sure that you get your chocolate", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00163-00042696-00042971": "and the other person doesn't get like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00164-00042972-00043199": "chocolate doesn't get it but is to make", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00165-00043200-00043409": "sure that when there are things", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00166-00043410-00043630": "parameters around if that is agreeable", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00167-00043631-00043817": "for everybody and no harm is being done", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00168-00043818-00044080": "and then the last point is to be", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00169-00044081-00044302": "continuously evolving so you don't need", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00170-00044303-00044537": "to bring things wholesale like for", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00171-00044538-00044783": "example I was leading a team of coaches", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00172-00044784-00045083": "uh in a financial technology space that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00173-00045084-00045323": "had adopted Spotify model and we were", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00174-00045324-00045527": "bringing in already bringing elements of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00175-00045528-00045857": "of sociocracy it was not wholesale where", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00176-00045858-00046037": "the whole organization is adopted", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00177-00046038-00046240": "although if you're smaller you'll find", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00178-00046241-00046480": "that there's less resistance and you can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00179-00046481-00046780": "easily get to there so it is effective", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00180-00046781-00046996": "with egalitarian and the point is to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00181-00046997-00047327": "always focus on what is the aim and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00182-00047328-00047590": "domain of this organization", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00183-00047591-00047830": "so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00184-00047831-00048065": "with that being said maybe maybe I'll go", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00185-00048066-00048268": "a little bit deeper in this uh so the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00186-00048269-00048574": "word sociocracy as opposed to democracy", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00187-00048575-00048839": "comes from those who work together or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00188-00048840-00048989": "associate together", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00189-00048990-00049283": "makes decisions together and it's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00190-00049284-00049601": "egalitarian medis means that people who", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00191-00049602-00049967": "are are the subject of your decision", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00192-00049968-00050243": "are also have hold a voice in your", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00193-00050244-00050368": "decision making", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00194-00050369-00050567": "and there are three key pillars that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00195-00050568-00050752": "those three killer pillars that we just", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00196-00050753-00050999": "showed that decision by content and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00197-00051000-00051179": "decision by consent Circle structure and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00198-00051180-00051311": "continuous Evolution if they exist", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00199-00051312-00051538": "you're already on the way", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00200-00051539-00051611": "um", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00201-00051612-00051820": "so what's important in this this this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00202-00051821-00052126": "may go a little bit more detail for now", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00203-00052127-00052349": "we can hold off on the academic part of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00204-00052350-00052685": "it but it's important to understand that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00205-00052686-00052913": "you know", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00206-00052914-00053207": "there is a type of organization called", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00207-00053208-00053447": "to I don't know if anybody's familiar", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00208-00053448-00053573": "with it if you are familiar with the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00209-00053574-00053891": "word key you put yes in chat otherwise I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00210-00053891-00054094": "can give a quick description", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00211-00054095-00054280": "so I'm looking at you can you give me a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00212-00054282-00054604": "quick indication or give me a Emoji", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00213-00054605-00054911": "thumbs up that you know teal do you when", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00214-00054912-00055163": "I say a teal organization do people", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00215-00055164-00055576": "understand what I'm saying", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00216-00055577-00055847": "just say yes in chat or give me a thumbs", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00217-00055848-00056044": "up if you already know so we don't need", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00218-00056045-00056261": "to go in detail on that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00219-00056262-00056549": "so there's one person or 12", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00220-00056550-00056842": "oh so there's a couple of people that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00221-00056844-00057179": "know it to you so by practicing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00222-00057179-00057454": "sociocracy you're actually implementing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00223-00057455-00057713": "tea so it's one of the most practical", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00224-00057714-00058079": "ways to move in that direction", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00225-00058079-00058313": "and so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00226-00058314-00058487": "because there's a couple people I won't", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00227-00058488-00058738": "go into the total detail of lalu's model", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00228-00058739-00058966": "and teen and all that but let's go back", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00229-00058967-00059182": "to sociocracy well where did it start", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00230-00059183-00059429": "and who uses it it started in the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00231-00059429-00059585": "Netherlands but this gentleman named", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00232-00059586-00059854": "Gerard endenberg who had a company", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00233-00059855-00060073": "called social", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00234-00060074-00060280": "sociocratic electric something like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00235-00060282-00060719": "sociocratic Center and they had all this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00236-00060720-00061013": "implementations in the 80s and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00237-00061014-00061204": "essentially the model got created then", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00238-00061205-00061553": "so it's not a new model it's been in in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00239-00061554-00061876": "service for a long while but Gerard's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00240-00061877-00062213": "work has got it into other places so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00241-00062214-00062663": "this uh this model is now in schools in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00242-00062664-00062873": "Netherlands in many other places in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00243-00062874-00063125": "India there's a famous documentary I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00244-00063126-00063287": "invite you encourage you to watch it's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00245-00063288-00063544": "called children's Parliament that is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00246-00063545-00063785": "implementing sociocracy with children", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00247-00063786-00064019": "and this fascinating stuff going on to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00248-00064020-00064337": "say child-led uh participatory structure", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00249-00064338-00064654": "with 10 000 neighborhood communities in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00250-00064655-00064966": "23 states it is so exciting and I I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00251-00064967-00065194": "watched the documentary but there's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00252-00065195-00065441": "there's again element sociocracy that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00253-00065441-00065656": "are brought in now the question for our", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00254-00065657-00065855": "business side for those of you are agile", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00255-00065856-00066126": "coaches or software developers is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00256-00066127-00066394": "although you know we use the word", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00257-00066395-00066575": "Spotify model and there's a problem with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00258-00066576-00066821": "using that term it's not necessarily", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00259-00066822-00067025": "what's ever considered Spotify model but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00260-00067026-00067259": "if you look in the origins of it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00261-00067260-00067493": "what Spotify did was take elements of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00262-00067494-00067650": "sociocracy and start to create", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00263-00067651-00067943": "structures that are more Matrix style", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00264-00067944-00068249": "more inclusive so and they talk a lot", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00265-00068250-00068465": "about autonomy with alignment so Spotify", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00266-00068466-00068656": "was an implementation of sociocracy", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00267-00068657-00068867": "again you know I invite you to go into", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00268-00068868-00069143": "the details how sociocracy connects with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00269-00069144-00069431": "what Spotify did not necessarily I will", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00270-00069432-00069605": "I wouldn't go as far as calling it The", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00271-00069606-00069791": "Spotify model but there were some", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00272-00069792-00069935": "experiments that started and they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00273-00069936-00070097": "continue to evolve it so what's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00274-00070098-00070276": "happening in Spotify now is much", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00275-00070277-00070463": "different from what you might find in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00276-00070464-00070631": "popular blogs", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00277-00070632-00070944": "and this is the circle I support", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00278-00070945-00071232": "is if you go to sociocracy for all", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00279-00071233-00071441": "sociocracy and free and open source", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00280-00071442-00071729": "projects so I hold a working position in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00281-00071730-00071855": "this circle", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00282-00071856-00072106": "um as I'm practicing and learning more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00283-00072107-00072425": "and more across sociocracy in in real", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00284-00072426-00072641": "life uh by being part of the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00285-00072642-00072881": "organization for a few years", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00286-00072882-00073109": "so now I want to invite you I'm going to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00287-00073110-00073450": "drop this link for you in chat and just", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00288-00073451-00073726": "to to make a point on how things work if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00289-00073727-00073871": "you can kindly", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00290-00073872-00074231": "jump into this Google doc", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00291-00074232-00074537": "my invitation to you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00292-00074538-00074867": "is to jump in this folder and actually", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00293-00074868-00075041": "you know what let me do this and let me", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00294-00075042-00075209": "give you an example of how what I expect", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00295-00075210-00075700": "you to do is to color these dots by if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00296-00075701-00075887": "you're still seeing my screen", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00297-00075888-00076211": "fill it by any color you want", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00298-00076212-00076409": "and what we're doing is we're going to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00299-00076410-00076685": "write the word agile", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00300-00076686-00076973": "let's see if we can accomplish that goal", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00301-00076974-00077197": "without", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00302-00077198-00077471": "uh with minimum effort I mean if if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00303-00077472-00077693": "these two or three of you can jump into", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00304-00077694-00077891": "the Google Doc", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00305-00077892-00078209": "on slide 17 if you are in there", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00306-00078210-00078455": "you can click on my icon or I can bring", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00307-00078456-00078623": "it to you so you don't have to work", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00308-00078624-00078869": "write the word agile but you can select", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00309-00078870-00079169": "a select a cell and clicked on the fill", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00310-00079170-00079481": "icon and select any color you want we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00311-00079482-00079667": "are going to use this pixels let's see", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00312-00079668-00079937": "how long it takes us to write the word", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00313-00079938-00080297": "agile", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00314-00080298-00080500": "you know if you've never done this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00315-00080501-00080819": "before essentially and a might like and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00316-00080820-00081011": "I can start off some part of it like so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00317-00081012-00081371": "for example this is an a that I'm", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00318-00081372-00081485": "forming but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00319-00081486-00081761": "decide how you want to participate if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00320-00081762-00082109": "you make a mistake you can change the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00321-00082110-00082337": "colors but let's let's see if you can we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00322-00082338-00082553": "can work together", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00323-00082554-00082726": "we'll need at least a couple of people", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00324-00082727-00083531": "to do this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00325-00083532-00083729": "so I see a couple of people if you guys", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00326-00083730-00084053": "could also jump in the it normally we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00327-00084054-00084226": "have five or six people this goes much", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00328-00084227-00084515": "faster", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00329-00084516-00084797": "colors don't matter well it's but you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00330-00084798-00086062": "know the word a g i l e does matter", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00331-00086063-00086309": "is there anybody having difficulty", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00332-00086310-00086644": "getting the so I see a couple one two", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00333-00086645-00086861": "and three people actually", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00334-00086862-00087059": "quite let's see", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00335-00087060-00087497": "how quickly we can get this done", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00336-00087498-00087731": "and you do you can unmute your mic and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00337-00087732-00089065": "give me some feedback", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00338-00089066-00090323": "ah we got a screenshot", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00339-00090324-00090556": "let's see let's get the whole word done", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00340-00090557-00090767": "it's interesting because I started off", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00341-00090768-00090953": "as an example and we're just basically", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00342-00090954-00092050": "following the same color which is okay", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00343-00092051-00092362": "and I know we have a about how many", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00344-00092363-00092621": "people do we have on the call", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00345-00092622-00093088": "looks like we have eight", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00346-00093089-00093232": "let's give it a couple more minutes", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00347-00093233-00095387": "let's finish this exercise", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00348-00095388-00096593": "ah", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00349-00096594-00096868": "it's interesting we have a view pop-up", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00350-00096869-00100061": "so maybe we can change it to an E", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00351-00100062-00100318": "and you can help each other because it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00352-00100319-00100517": "the point of this exercise is to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00353-00100518-00100829": "collaborate", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00354-00100830-00101194": "I love that all right so this is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00355-00101195-00101524": "complete from my point of view so now", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00356-00101525-00101717": "why did I do that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00357-00101718-00102029": "so the point here is that even with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00358-00102030-00102232": "limited instructions", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00359-00102233-00102592": "we are able to accomplish", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00360-00102593-00102815": "you know the goal the goal was to write", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00361-00102816-00103090": "agile and even though it may come up", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00362-00103091-00103228": "with different colors or shapes or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00363-00103229-00103456": "exactly if only one person did but how", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00364-00103457-00103601": "was this accomplished is pretty", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00365-00103602-00103889": "illegible anybody for those who", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00366-00103890-00104051": "participate in success can you unmute", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00367-00104052-00104266": "yourself how did it feel", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00368-00104267-00104489": "doing this with another person on the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00369-00104490-00104699": "same slide who you've never met and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00370-00104700-00104842": "talked to before", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00371-00104843-00105040": "possibly", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00372-00105041-00105251": "please unmute your mic and share with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00373-00105252-00105851": "you how that experience was", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00374-00105852-00106433": "if you can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00375-00106433-00106565": "I know there's a couple of people who", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00376-00106566-00106745": "are working on it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00377-00106746-00106908": "here", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00378-00106908-00107419": "[Music]", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00379-00107420-00107740": "one thing I observed is what we could", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00380-00107741-00108113": "see uh what each of us was doing so it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00381-00108114-00108377": "was very visible and transparent so that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00382-00108378-00108636": "helped us self-adjust", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00383-00108638-00108952": "exactly and and that's a format form of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00384-00108953-00109145": "feedback that's a form of feedback you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00385-00109146-00109247": "know if you're working in the open", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00386-00109248-00109463": "that's an awesome form of feedback then", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00387-00109464-00109697": "we can adjust as well versus working", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00388-00109698-00109847": "separately and then worrying about", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00389-00109848-00110021": "integration thank you for sharing that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00390-00110022-00110327": "Risha so good", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00391-00110328-00111269": "what else anybody else", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00392-00111270-00111460": "I know it's in the afternoon right for", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00393-00111461-00111640": "most of most of the folks who are there", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00394-00111641-00112090": "it is it is 5 19 a.m where I am in North", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00395-00112091-00112366": "Carolina", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00396-00112367-00112823": "so maybe I I should also think about but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00397-00112824-00113039": "like let's see let's call on folks that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00398-00113040-00113183": "were participating maybe you can write", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00399-00113183-00113608": "in chat uh did oh so Sarat I know you've", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00400-00113609-00113825": "been interacting in chat would you were", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00401-00113826-00113951": "you participating in the exercise what", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00402-00113952-00114136": "was your experience like what was your", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00403-00114138-00114652": "observation", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00404-00114653-00114978": "uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00405-00114979-00115252": "the Google form or whatever link that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00406-00115253-00115519": "you have given and I was just observing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00407-00115520-00115804": "what did You observe", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00408-00115805-00116051": "the collaboration initially I mean", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00409-00116052-00116213": "probably people didn't join everybody", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00410-00116214-00116573": "didn't join the board but then slowly I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00411-00116574-00116807": "think people were helping each other and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00412-00116808-00117034": "could see that uh towards the end we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00413-00117035-00117304": "could complete it quickly", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00414-00117305-00117563": "absolutely and by the way normally this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00415-00117564-00117743": "exercise if you do such a short", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00416-00117744-00118013": "lettering you'll find that the E the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00417-00118014-00118271": "line of the E becomes a problem but I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00418-00118272-00118457": "was so this was a more Innovative", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00419-00118458-00118708": "solution and people are able to do that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00420-00118709-00119134": "and I I'm always surprised if you allow", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00421-00119135-00119327": "people to communicate with each other", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00422-00119328-00119507": "interact with each other they come up", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00423-00119508-00119695": "with Creative Solutions and you know", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00424-00119696-00120052": "there's a lot of times we have to think", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00425-00120053-00120227": "a little bit more about the structure", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00426-00120228-00120515": "how we are working together versus just", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00427-00120516-00120719": "the task at hand and getting done with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00428-00120720-00120886": "it thank you for sharing so we are going", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00429-00120888-00121145": "to move on to the exercise so now this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00430-00121146-00121390": "is the the idea I was explaining before", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00431-00121391-00121752": "that we are trying to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00432-00121753-00122069": "integrate objections like so for example", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00433-00122070-00122254": "if somebody had", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00434-00122255-00122566": "um put in the a completely different", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00435-00122567-00122884": "color or just erased everything we saw", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00436-00122885-00123107": "somebody put in a screenshot there so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00437-00123108-00123257": "that would be an objection well now I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00438-00123258-00123575": "can't even see the the canvas so those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00439-00123576-00123802": "are objections that's harm from the work", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00440-00123803-00123995": "or the aim of what we're trying to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00441-00123996-00124193": "accomplish but a lot of times you have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00442-00124194-00124354": "variability somebody has selected pink", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00443-00124355-00124631": "color somebody had selected a different", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00444-00124632-00124931": "um letter size a larger e a shorter e", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00445-00124932-00125140": "doesn't matter as long as it's legible", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00446-00125141-00125447": "it means that it is usable at least in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00447-00125448-00125602": "an early stage before we go into", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00448-00125603-00125927": "refining is acceptable so the idea here", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00449-00125928-00126234": "is we are constantly thinking about", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00450-00126235-00126533": "preference which is where the realm of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00451-00126533-00126743": "consensus a lot of times and then the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00452-00126744-00127049": "Rage of Tolerance that this is maybe not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00453-00127050-00127427": "my personal style but hey it's not bad I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00454-00127428-00127631": "can accept it and that gives you more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00455-00127632-00127877": "room to work with whether you're in a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00456-00127878-00128213": "natural working team in a startup in a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00457-00128214-00128410": "large organization you want to keep", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00458-00128411-00128621": "working with more otherwise you're going", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00459-00128622-00128771": "to lock in with very very small", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00460-00128772-00129010": "parameters so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00461-00129011-00129286": "don't try to please people is the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00462-00129288-00129497": "message here that we cannot match", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00463-00129498-00129707": "everybody's preference but we can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00464-00129708-00129863": "definitely bring into a range of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00465-00129864-00130181": "tolerance and any harm that is done we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00466-00130182-00130354": "want to remove that harm", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00467-00130355-00130793": "if you any of you have done sailing and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00468-00130794-00131069": "on a sailboat you'll find that there's a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00469-00131070-00131357": "term they use tacking sailboat does not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00470-00131358-00131585": "go in a straight line what happens it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00471-00131586-00131873": "works with the opposing winds and the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00472-00131874-00132125": "attacking process works with those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00473-00132126-00132295": "opposing Wheels to keep moving forward", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00474-00132296-00132616": "and that's an excellent metaphor for", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00475-00132617-00132778": "applying sociocracy to any of these", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00476-00132779-00133037": "decision making is that how do you work", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00477-00133038-00133211": "with objections", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00478-00133212-00133547": "to keep moving forward towards the AIM", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00479-00133548-00133666": "and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00480-00133667-00133925": "we want to make sure that we are not in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00481-00133926-00134093": "the business of convincing and saying", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00482-00134094-00134297": "like we are right or we want to say well", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00483-00134298-00134471": "what else is out there and I could have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00484-00134472-00134711": "said hey that letter needs to be that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00485-00134712-00134909": "cell size like you know it has to be the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00486-00134910-00135121": "square it cannot be a different element", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00487-00135122-00135419": "but why it's still legible it's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00488-00135420-00135664": "reasonable and even though that's not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00489-00135665-00135881": "the solution I would have yeah I may", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00490-00135882-00136102": "have preferred but it does the same job", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00491-00136103-00136402": "in a way it's actually exciting so what", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00492-00136403-00136709": "we want to think about is this dark", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00493-00136710-00136931": "green circle is what your personal", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00494-00136932-00137207": "preference might be and this light green", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00495-00137208-00137449": "circle is the area you would tolerate", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00496-00137450-00137825": "and then the red part is that you would", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00497-00137826-00138011": "not there is an actual harm there's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00498-00138012-00138263": "there's an objection that this is not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00499-00138264-00138383": "going to work", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00500-00138384-00138587": "so what we want to do is constantly", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00501-00138588-00138797": "through conversations through meeting", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00502-00138798-00139031": "protocols through sociocracy protocols", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00503-00139032-00139216": "or any other ways I mean that's not the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00504-00139217-00139363": "only way to do it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00505-00139364-00139721": "move from objections to the area of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00506-00139722-00139859": "consent", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00507-00139860-00140207": "now this is good enough we'll say good", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00508-00140208-00140351": "enough for now", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00509-00140352-00140609": "safe enough to try", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00510-00140610-00140963": "because anything beyond that like trying", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00511-00140964-00141340": "to move over here but everybody is like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00512-00141341-00141587": "each other everybody is 100 agreed upon", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00513-00141588-00141995": "that last 20 percent is not worth your", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00514-00141996-00142199": "time so we want to keep things practical", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00515-00142200-00142409": "as soon as you get into the space of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00516-00142410-00142661": "consent we'll say consent and let's move", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00517-00142662-00142954": "on because otherwise this type of effort", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00518-00142955-00143302": "to get to this stage is not good for is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00519-00143303-00143507": "not it's not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00520-00143508-00143843": "um the the amount of time and work", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00521-00143844-00144028": "that's needed and the result is not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00522-00144029-00144190": "proportional", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00523-00144191-00144389": "so consent gives you more to work with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00524-00144390-00144695": "everybody has if you were to like take a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00525-00144696-00145109": "uh diagram a vanish diagram here you'll", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00526-00145110-00145361": "see that people have their preferences", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00527-00145362-00145595": "and you can see the overlap of their", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00528-00145596-00145775": "preferences so each one of these if you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00529-00145776-00145949": "look at three individuals here so this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00530-00145950-00146159": "is one individual second and third they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00531-00146160-00146387": "have an overlap of preferences but with", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00532-00146388-00146578": "an overlap of Tolerance", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00533-00146579-00146849": "you you have more to work with and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00534-00146850-00147035": "anything outside of this range will be", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00535-00147036-00147328": "things that you are not a green talk", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00536-00147329-00147545": "that's a that's an objection", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00537-00147546-00147790": "so with that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00538-00147791-00148175": "let's let's try an example out so I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00539-00148176-00148523": "would need a few volunteers and those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00540-00148524-00148781": "will so if I can get three volunteers", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00541-00148782-00148877": "please", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00542-00148878-00149201": "um raise your hand", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00543-00149202-00149387": "I'm looking for three volunteers to do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00544-00149388-00149621": "this exercise with me", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00545-00149622-00149957": "give me a thumbs up", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00546-00149958-00150131": "if not I can also describe if I can't", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00547-00150132-00150335": "get three it's probably not it won't", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00548-00150336-00150787": "illustrate a point", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00549-00150788-00151354": "uh Tom did I see your hand raised", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00550-00151355-00151607": "right well videos ready I really", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00551-00151608-00151835": "appreciate people on video because that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00552-00151836-00152051": "way I can get another sense of feedback", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00553-00152052-00152381": "so looks like I'm not getting uh three", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00554-00152382-00152597": "volunteers at the moment and that could", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00555-00152598-00152926": "be as you'll be you may be multitasking", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00556-00152927-00153137": "or you may be busy or audio is too bad", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00557-00153138-00153599": "that's okay so I would have uh given and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00558-00153600-00153899": "we would have gone through rounds and we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00559-00153900-00154078": "would have I would have put myself in a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00560-00154079-00154313": "round and would have gone around like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00561-00154314-00154540": "one by one talking about what our", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00562-00154541-00154835": "Reflections are and what what if whether", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00563-00154836-00155057": "something is agreeable to us or not and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00564-00155058-00155207": "then we would have gone to a Concentra", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00565-00155208-00155471": "so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00566-00155472-00155837": "if our aim for today's session to the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00567-00155838-00156064": "workshop is to understand the experience", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00568-00156065-00156287": "and there is an experience the basic", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00569-00156288-00156461": "principles of sociocracy and how might", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00570-00156462-00156676": "that work in our software development", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00571-00156677-00156887": "teams our organizations then I would", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00572-00156888-00157109": "have made a proposal no cell phone use", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00573-00157110-00157361": "during this class except for emergencies", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00574-00157362-00157643": "or urgent calls then I would have gone", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00575-00157644-00157871": "so for example", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00576-00157872-00157925": "um", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00577-00157926-00158261": "a few folks that have given me feedback", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00578-00158262-00158459": "so if I would say hey", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00579-00158460-00158795": "um let's go with Tom then Usha and then", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00580-00158796-00158993": "once Tom and ushero what are what are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00581-00158994-00159173": "your reactions to this proposal so well", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00582-00159174-00159335": "I don't like this proposal I like this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00583-00159336-00159587": "proposal because and then Usha then", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00584-00159588-00159869": "Sarat so and then Sarah can be and then", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00585-00159870-00160054": "we'll go once we do that round we hear", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00586-00160055-00160295": "all those objections and then we'll try", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00587-00160296-00160535": "to in include those objections and we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00588-00160536-00160804": "will make modifications to the proposals", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00589-00160805-00160985": "until we have integrated those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00590-00160986-00161231": "objections and then we'll go and do a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00591-00161232-00161590": "round of consent all right is this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00592-00161591-00161921": "proposal Good Enough Tom danusha and Tom", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00593-00161922-00162125": "wouldn't I say like yes agreeable Usha", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00594-00162126-00162359": "may say yes agreeable and then Surat may", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00595-00162360-00162521": "say well I still have objection to them", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00596-00162522-00162719": "we can do another reflection we want to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00597-00162720-00162940": "keep on going well it has to be some", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00598-00162941-00163193": "harm when an objection has to be real it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00599-00163194-00163414": "cannot be in the realm of preference and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00600-00163415-00163583": "if you get consent from all of us we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00601-00163584-00163883": "agree and we move on so it's really to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00602-00163884-00164249": "illustrate what that steps look like and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00603-00164250-00164501": "you can take this and implement it in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00604-00164502-00164783": "any I would say I've I've done this in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00605-00164784-00165035": "agile teams I've talked with in actually", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00606-00165036-00165245": "family gatherings as well here's the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00607-00165246-00165431": "proposal let's understand the purpose", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00608-00165432-00165587": "and people may have clarifying questions", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00609-00165588-00165947": "the reactions then we'll go do a round", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00610-00165948-00166211": "of Explorations and then we'll consent", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00611-00166212-00166414": "to it make those decisions and move on", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00612-00166415-00166673": "so essentially that's one of the core", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00613-00166674-00167063": "pillars of sociocracy and in that it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00614-00167064-00167309": "allows it includes voices and the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00615-00167310-00167501": "benefit of going grounds and making sure", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00616-00167502-00167866": "that we are doing that Circle or like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00617-00167867-00168107": "you know that conversation is that you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00618-00168108-00168340": "may have a question that somebody else", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00619-00168341-00168593": "already has asked by the time it comes", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00620-00168594-00168719": "to your attorney you've already got to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00621-00168720-00168928": "hear that answer and then you may have a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00622-00168929-00169216": "different question so it's very very", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00623-00169217-00169516": "efficient in that process", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00624-00169517-00169823": "uh we talked about consent process now", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00625-00169824-00170051": "let's let's talk about Circle structure", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00626-00170052-00170369": "so sociocracy really believes in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00627-00170370-00170707": "decisions that are made in small groups", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00628-00170708-00170951": "small groups is important because if", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00629-00170952-00171245": "you're doing rounds with 40 people", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00630-00171246-00171551": "that will take a very long time one by", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00631-00171552-00171983": "one by one by one so we create a smaller", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00632-00171984-00172235": "container of people that we call a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00633-00172236-00172528": "circle and we build expertise and trust", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00634-00172529-00172781": "and we create psychological safety is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00635-00172782-00173128": "the somewhat similar to how scrum also", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00636-00173129-00173416": "promotes seven to nine people so that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00637-00173417-00173837": "you know we can we can limit the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00638-00173838-00174101": "communication channels and make sure", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00639-00174102-00174364": "that we are working together closely so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00640-00174365-00174676": "this is an example of a circle of uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00641-00174677-00174869": "individuals who are working together", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00642-00174870-00175157": "towards an aim whether that's an agile", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00643-00175158-00175463": "team a governance board leadership team", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00644-00175464-00175702": "marketing doesn't matter they have a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00645-00175703-00175883": "need to work together", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00646-00175884-00176135": "and we know you know you guys are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00647-00176136-00176369": "agilists that the whole point is proof", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00648-00176370-00176716": "from Individual tours teamwork so say", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00649-00176717-00176885": "they have expertise they have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00650-00176886-00177178": "documentation and documentation is also", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00651-00177179-00177425": "core benefit that you get out of it like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00652-00177426-00177725": "you know agenda making documentation and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00653-00177726-00178138": "so far has a ton of uh templates that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00654-00178139-00178361": "you can use I've used those templates to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00655-00178362-00178571": "run my Sprint planning sessions I've", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00656-00178572-00178738": "used those templates to run my meetings", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00657-00178739-00178913": "and there's definitely elements and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00658-00178914-00179273": "benefits of that so so the each circle", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00659-00179274-00179495": "needs to have an aim", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00660-00179496-00179747": "and domain like area of responsibility", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00661-00179748-00179993": "what can they do what they can't do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00662-00179994-00180304": "right and aim would be translating to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00663-00180305-00180514": "purpose or Charter however you want to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00664-00180515-00180749": "call it but they all need to have an aim", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00665-00180750-00180940": "and a domain of focus", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00666-00180941-00181204": "so imagine we create", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00667-00181205-00181426": "a few Circle so this isn't this is one", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00668-00181427-00181687": "Circle and they have their own expertise", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00669-00181688-00182135": "they could be uh a circle so if if this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00670-00182136-00182423": "is uh the intentional community of that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00671-00182424-00182669": "term is not familiar with you guys say a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00672-00182670-00182878": "community that has", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00673-00182879-00183004": "um", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00674-00183005-00183323": "as gardening has electrical work has", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00675-00183324-00183587": "construction has infrastructure so maybe", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00676-00183588-00183785": "this is the gardening group and then", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00677-00183786-00184025": "there's two other circles so let's let's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00678-00184026-00184337": "take an example of this group is is a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00679-00184338-00184493": "gardening Circle and this is a fencing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00680-00184494-00184799": "Circle so imagine that they are putting", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00681-00184800-00185081": "senses in the org in that physical", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00682-00185082-00185411": "location and that creates shade on", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00683-00185412-00185638": "plants that need full sunlight now", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00684-00185639-00185866": "that's creates a problematic situation", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00685-00185867-00186131": "where hey why did you put these fences", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00686-00186132-00186275": "where they are because now you're", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00687-00186276-00186466": "impacting the plants all the work that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00688-00186467-00186671": "we've done for plants that need full sun", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00689-00186672-00186947": "so obviously there is there is a missing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00690-00186948-00187175": "communication link here so what we do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00691-00187176-00187451": "here is instead of creating silos which", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00692-00187452-00187666": "is really how you know even an agile", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00693-00187667-00187954": "Transformations we tend to create small", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00694-00187955-00188147": "teams but then we forget the connecting", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00695-00188148-00188363": "layer we forget the coordinating layer", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00696-00188364-00188602": "so there's this is to First Look at", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00697-00188603-00188776": "intentionally you know how do we make", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00698-00188777-00189154": "that connection so if we had two", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00699-00189155-00189293": "Representatives", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00700-00189294-00189587": "from each of these circles let's call", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00701-00189588-00189911": "them a leader and a delegate", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00702-00189912-00190151": "which is a selected position in that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00703-00190152-00190559": "group then we form a new Circle so this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00704-00190560-00190990": "gentleman and this young lady there are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00705-00190991-00191285": "in that they are part of this circle but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00706-00191286-00191423": "they're also part of this middle circle", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00707-00191424-00191704": "the connecting layer and then these two", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00708-00191705-00191878": "are part of this circle and these two", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00709-00191879-00192095": "are part of the circle so when when they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00710-00192096-00192287": "have their own Circle meetings and they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00711-00192288-00192497": "turn around and join this circle they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00712-00192498-00192683": "can report out and they can share and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00713-00192684-00193001": "tell hey we are putting new fences and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00714-00193002-00193181": "this is the region they can immediately", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00715-00193182-00193457": "say well hold on or we have plants that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00716-00193458-00193714": "require full sun and with your fans", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00717-00193715-00193937": "they're going to have shade on it how", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00718-00193938-00194237": "might we work together to make sure that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00719-00194238-00194578": "you're not creating harm for our work so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00720-00194579-00194819": "because the opportunity exists and by", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00721-00194820-00195028": "the way if you go deeper into the idea", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00722-00195029-00195257": "of scrum of scrums or something like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00723-00195258-00195509": "that or if you're doing flight levels", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00724-00195510-00195863": "it's the same idea but sociocracy what", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00725-00195864-00196216": "what sociocracy or brings in is the idea", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00726-00196217-00196487": "of double linkage and that we have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00727-00196488-00196673": "continuous flow of information", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00728-00196674-00196990": "throughout all these circles and they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00729-00196991-00197152": "meet and they make sure that those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00730-00197153-00197369": "voices are brought up and how they work", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00731-00197370-00197651": "together each circle has their aim and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00732-00197652-00197843": "domain the circle in the middle the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00733-00197844-00198083": "General Circle their responsibility is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00734-00198084-00198388": "making sure that we're connecting the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00735-00198389-00198619": "child circles back to the main Circle", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00736-00198620-00198893": "and they have the responsibility to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00737-00198894-00199097": "bring it back to say well here's what we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00738-00199098-00199276": "heard here's new things that are coming", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00739-00199277-00199426": "up", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00740-00199427-00199666": "so the General Circle is a circle that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00741-00199667-00199961": "has participants from all other circles", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00742-00199962-00200285": "and we will create sometimes sub-circles", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00743-00200286-00200507": "like helping circles to solve a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00744-00200508-00200723": "temporary problem or a long-standing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00745-00200724-00201016": "problem it really is more fluid than", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00746-00201017-00201311": "saying hey let's create a permanent team", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00747-00201312-00201700": "everywhere but by having a mission", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00748-00201701-00202061": "Circle we can actually drive focus on uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00749-00202062-00202381": "policies procedures like you know", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00750-00202382-00202733": "funding there's the some people call it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00751-00202734-00202943": "the governing board but there is it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00752-00202944-00203164": "benefits in creating those circles so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00753-00203165-00203350": "now these guys are doing work but they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00754-00203351-00203614": "also have these linkages", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00755-00203615-00203783": "so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00756-00203784-00204052": "and you can continue to evolve and this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00757-00204053-00204311": "continues to grow so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00758-00204312-00204664": "within a circle there are sociocracy", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00759-00204665-00204929": "calls out specific roles that have to be", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00760-00204930-00205271": "filled so I already mentioned a leader a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00761-00205271-00205536": "leader of a circle has a responsibility", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00762-00205537-00205805": "and it's an it's a selected position so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00763-00205806-00206069": "they all nominate they all agree to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00764-00206069-00206266": "objection integrate objection and one", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00765-00206267-00206507": "person takes that role on so the leader", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00766-00206508-00206842": "is the person who is responsible to to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00767-00206844-00207064": "run that Circle who was who has the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00768-00207065-00207227": "mission in their mind the aim in their", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00769-00207228-00207640": "mind and thus not necessarily A person", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00770-00207641-00207958": "who holds Authority because any one of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00771-00207959-00208144": "them can be leaders and then the circle", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00772-00208146-00208427": "designs who should be the leader but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00773-00208428-00208546": "once they do it they do have a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00774-00208548-00208798": "responsibility the delegate is a person", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00775-00208800-00209062": "who will work with this General Circle", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00776-00209063-00209369": "to to represent the voice and the double", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00777-00209369-00209614": "linkage is very important we don't so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00778-00209615-00209794": "one of the things that missing in sales", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00779-00209796-00210108": "scrum of scrums is we sometimes those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00780-00210109-00210334": "especially feel like a safe-like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00781-00210335-00210581": "environment or other places and S2 and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00782-00210582-00210881": "S3 they delve into becoming a scrum", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00783-00210882-00211060": "Master Forum where all these scum", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00784-00211061-00211265": "Masters attend but none of the product", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00785-00211266-00211463": "owners do or none of the other people do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00786-00211464-00211798": "but by having that that double linkage a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00787-00211800-00212021": "you benefit from people can take on", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00788-00212021-00212327": "vacations so we uh I mean I'm in the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00789-00212328-00212548": "free and open source Circle myself and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00790-00212550-00212741": "we had a couple of times where the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00791-00212742-00213071": "leader was had to go on a call and the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00792-00213071-00213203": "delegate was the only person available", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00793-00213204-00213377": "and other times the delegate had to go", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00794-00213378-00213527": "on vacation but the leader was available", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00795-00213528-00213815": "so we are always thinking about that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00796-00213816-00214073": "there has to be a connectivity going up", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00797-00214073-00214319": "to the parent Circle the other rules", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00798-00214319-00214703": "that democracy 35 minutes more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00799-00214704-00214889": "thank you pankaj", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00800-00214890-00215087": "so the other roles are facilitator", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00801-00215088-00215327": "similar to a scrum Master you can think", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00802-00215328-00215669": "of it uh and a secretary a person who's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00803-00215669-00215987": "taking notes this the secretary works", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00804-00215988-00216160": "with the facilitator to run the meeting", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00805-00216161-00216353": "and the facilitator works with the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00806-00216354-00216665": "leader to make sure that anything we are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00807-00216666-00216946": "hearing from the parent circle is also", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00808-00216948-00217144": "being brought in and brought in as our", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00809-00217146-00217439": "agenda items or our backlog to move", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00810-00217440-00217853": "forward so similar similar sounding and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00811-00217854-00218098": "very much you if you'd go deeper into it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00812-00218100-00218308": "there is a lot of correlation with how", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00813-00218309-00218506": "we set up agile teams and this is does", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00814-00218507-00218644": "not matter whether you're doing scrum", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00815-00218646-00218951": "kanban none of that because it it still", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00816-00218952-00219232": "applies to search the need of well we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00817-00219233-00219389": "have onboarded a new person where do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00818-00219390-00219629": "they even start where is the lightweight", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00819-00219630-00219815": "documentation how do we keep it alive", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00820-00219816-00220042": "and then the operational roles for", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00821-00220044-00220313": "example a web developer or admin or just", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00822-00220314-00220541": "an example I gave of a community like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00823-00220542-00220756": "gardening and fencing those are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00824-00220757-00221075": "operational roles and is based on the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00825-00221076-00221381": "type of work you do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00826-00221382-00221551": "so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00827-00221552-00221944": "delegates are selected bottom up and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00828-00221946-00222179": "confirmed consented by the whole group", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00829-00222180-00222563": "and they're sent up and each group have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00830-00222564-00222791": "those Representatives going in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00831-00222792-00223175": "with that this is the same picture", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00832-00223176-00223469": "but with an illustration of why we do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00833-00223469-00223571": "this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00834-00223571-00223973": "so this in the middle and out of if it's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00835-00223973-00224267": "possible for you to see we see if I can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00836-00224267-00224369": "use", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00837-00224369-00224855": "a spotlight so right here if you see uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00838-00224856-00225160": "my Red Dot this is the General Circle", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00839-00225161-00225544": "and then this is one those circles like", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00840-00225546-00225719": "the gardening Circle or the fencing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00841-00225719-00226001": "Circle and the point of linkage here", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00842-00226002-00226271": "because when you do a report out that's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00843-00226271-00226534": "the delegate and when you're doing a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00844-00226535-00226721": "report in from the parent Circle that's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00845-00226721-00226942": "the leader and you can always continue", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00846-00226944-00227171": "to morph and increase since you can have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00847-00227171-00227477": "sub circles but the point here imagine", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00848-00227478-00227758": "all these people are standing in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00849-00227759-00228058": "physical space and holding hands so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00850-00228059-00228251": "essentially it's like holding has this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00851-00228252-00228534": "information is flowing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00852-00228535-00228892": "bi-directionally and unseated so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00853-00228894-00229144": "unhindered and that's the whole point", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00854-00229146-00229469": "why we create structures like these so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00855-00229469-00229756": "that we are not holding and blocking", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00856-00229757-00229991": "information where it's needed and when", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00857-00229992-00230279": "it's needed otherwise harm can be done", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00858-00230280-00230542": "so with that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00859-00230544-00230825": "we I will share this I think at this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00860-00230826-00230956": "slide that will be shared with you guys", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00861-00230957-00231305": "but essentially there's other models of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00862-00231306-00231508": "governance that exist", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00863-00231509-00231934": "you see if I can go back to that so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00864-00231935-00232271": "autocracy democracy no governance system", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00865-00232271-00232558": "like you know no alignment no everybody", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00866-00232559-00232781": "running around everywhere all group", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00867-00232782-00233069": "consensus is good but what a whole group", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00868-00233069-00233273": "consensus takes a very long time and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00869-00233273-00233531": "then finally sociocracy where circles", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00870-00233532-00233801": "and roles coming in it's one of the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00871-00233802-00233969": "better ways it's also not a silver", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00872-00233969-00234281": "bullet but I've seen real benefit in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00873-00234282-00234587": "improving the Team Dynamics by just", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00874-00234588-00234856": "applying the idea of rounds and the idea", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00875-00234857-00235025": "of consent", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00876-00235026-00235444": "so a lot of our eye chart and in because", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00877-00235446-00235739": "we're now going into", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00878-00235740-00235967": "um well let's go into it so this is this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00879-00235967-00236296": "is good so how do you select a leader", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00880-00236298-00236579": "how do you select a facilitator", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00881-00236580-00236896": "right do do you volunt tell people which", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00882-00236898-00237082": "is the way world has worked in the past", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00883-00237083-00237503": "well the way sociocracy says and is so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00884-00237504-00237742": "this is this is where it becomes real", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00885-00237744-00238079": "that you define the role and the length", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00886-00238080-00238439": "of that role so say hey we are going to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00887-00238440-00238619": "select a facilitator but we want other", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00888-00238619-00238817": "people to take that opportunity so we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00889-00238817-00239069": "will uh hold that term for six months or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00890-00239069-00239248": "three months I mean whatever rotation", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00891-00239250-00239506": "makes sense to you or a whole year in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00892-00239507-00239656": "some cases these are long-standing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00893-00239657-00239831": "position but then gather the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00894-00239832-00240034": "qualification what type of skills are we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00895-00240035-00240323": "looking for as a team in that person and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00896-00240323-00240587": "then consent to the qualifications then", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00897-00240588-00240875": "we all sit down and write note on our", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00898-00240876-00241079": "nominations we go through a nomination", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00899-00241080-00241367": "round we go through a change route we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00900-00241367-00241631": "propose the kind candidate and we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00901-00241632-00241979": "consent to who that is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00902-00241980-00242213": "um with that this is what a template we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00903-00242214-00242482": "use will will say for example hey", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00904-00242483-00242644": "facilitator", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00905-00242646-00242860": "this person is a facilitator who's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00906-00242861-00243082": "facilitating a small group meeting their", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00907-00243083-00243269": "term is just for today well what type of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00908-00243269-00243539": "skills do we need and then people who", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00909-00243540-00243737": "are in the circle so for example if I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00910-00243738-00244031": "were to say like you know Usha sarath", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00911-00244032-00244379": "Tom Bart they will put their name there", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00912-00244380-00244684": "and then they'll they will will all give", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00913-00244685-00244925": "an opportunity to nominate and we'll go", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00914-00244926-00245165": "in in a round to look at the nomination", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00915-00245166-00245453": "people may give a different person's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00916-00245454-00245741": "name as a hey we really think Usha", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00917-00245742-00246125": "should be the facilitator or or Usha may", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00918-00246126-00246431": "say well saratmi should be the nominee", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00919-00246432-00246623": "so now we have some differences then we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00920-00246623-00246892": "go look at NY and why it should be the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00921-00246894-00247175": "num should they be the nominee and in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00922-00247176-00247284": "that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00923-00247285-00247546": "we will we will ask questions okay well", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00924-00247548-00247805": "what was the reason why which has really", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00925-00247806-00248056": "you know she could really read a room", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00926-00248057-00248248": "she can bring the fee bring the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00927-00248250-00248392": "background information in the foreground", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00928-00248394-00248656": "so all that and this only gets to be", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00929-00248657-00248782": "revealed when you have gotten a chance", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00930-00248783-00248992": "to work together so you don't really", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00931-00248994-00249208": "select it right away but you can start", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00932-00249209-00249473": "and if if you say well I'm not quite", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00933-00249473-00249755": "sure you can reduce the term", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00934-00249756-00250031": "so that we can experiment then as we get", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00935-00250032-00250282": "a chance to work more than we we find", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00936-00250283-00250517": "out okay over time this is the direction", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00937-00250517-00250841": "we go and then we go around hey is or do", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00938-00250842-00251032": "you have an objection to it or would you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00939-00251033-00251242": "tolerate it and with that change around", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00940-00251244-00251513": "then we are able to come up with a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00941-00251514-00251765": "second set and finally we do the consent", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00942-00251766-00252023": "route so what that might look like and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00943-00252023-00252215": "I'll I'll I will share an example I was", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00944-00252216-00252503": "going to do this exercise but um", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00945-00252504-00252887": "since it may be difficult based on the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00946-00252888-00253139": "last call so I will give an example of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00947-00253140-00253325": "what that might look like so in the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00948-00253326-00253715": "first round we go and go in in a in a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00949-00253716-00253858": "ground and ask people what are the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00950-00253859-00254044": "skills needed for this person well this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00951-00254046-00254237": "person needs to hold space and the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00952-00254238-00254398": "secretary is taking notes they need to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00953-00254400-00254560": "be themselves good sense of humor", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00954-00254561-00254813": "ability to multitask be able to seek", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00955-00254814-00254998": "really whatever the group thinks", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00956-00255000-00255251": "whatever the team thinks are the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00957-00255252-00255479": "necessary skills for this person and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00958-00255480-00255701": "then those folks in the group and you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00959-00255702-00255898": "can add more rows if there's a larger", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00960-00255900-00256067": "Circle you can reduce rows if there's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00961-00256067-00256306": "less it really depends on what you guys", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00962-00256307-00256456": "are but then you go in the rounds of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00963-00256457-00256715": "well why do you think so Tamsin would", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00964-00256716-00256960": "say Mary or why why Mary well because", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00965-00256961-00257146": "many hold all of these qualifications", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00966-00257148-00257410": "really really good at it so then we go", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00967-00257411-00257603": "to nominations now obviously most people", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00968-00257604-00257879": "said Mary and one person said Thompson", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00969-00257880-00258221": "and Amir and we asked like well would", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00970-00258221-00258532": "you would you consent to Mary being a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00971-00258533-00258748": "facilitator or is there a real objection", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00972-00258750-00258971": "there and this is where the team comes", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00973-00258971-00259271": "about here's yeah I mean I can see Mary", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00974-00259271-00259523": "can do it too damson can do it too so I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00975-00259523-00259775": "can I can change my position to the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00976-00259776-00260027": "second round to marry but in some cases", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00977-00260028-00260242": "they're gonna hold on so we'll ask the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00978-00260244-00260465": "last time hey is this a real objection", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00979-00260466-00260794": "or would you consent to it and if they", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00980-00260796-00260975": "say yeah no it's just a personal preface", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00981-00260976-00261160": "I think a beer should be it and I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00982-00261161-00261346": "shouldn't be the facilitator but if I'm", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00983-00261348-00261610": "asked to do it I will do it and you can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00984-00261611-00261869": "totally nominate yourself so with Mary", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00985-00261869-00262151": "saying Amir and uh everybody else is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00986-00262152-00262360": "marrying we had option of either Amir or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00987-00262361-00262637": "Mary and then we all go through consent", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00988-00262638-00262889": "Round And if everybody consent to it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00989-00262890-00263201": "and finally we make that selection", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00990-00263202-00263495": "so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00991-00263496-00263873": "just I'm gonna pause for now and see", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00992-00263874-00264077": "because I've thrown a few things we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00993-00264078-00264280": "talked about rounds we talked about", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00994-00264281-00264556": "consent and now we talked about circles", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00995-00264557-00264773": "you know more tactically speaking the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00996-00264774-00264947": "selection process", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00997-00264948-00265247": "what questions might you have so far", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00998-00265248-00265547": "before I go to the next step", "OpvPj6OcEiA-00999-00265548-00265787": "put your question in chat if something's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01000-00265788-00266051": "puzzling you if I use the term that was", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01001-00266052-00266291": "not very clear", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01002-00266292-00266530": "unmute yourself or write your question", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01003-00266531-00268043": "in chat I do have chat window open", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01004-00268044-00268289": "what questions might you have unmute", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01005-00268290-00268534": "yourself if you like to ask it live", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01006-00268535-00269573": "or if you want to put it in chat", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01007-00269574-00269723": "right", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01008-00269724-00269939": "thank you sarad", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01009-00269940-00270191": "so it sounds like I'm I may be preaching", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01010-00270192-00270365": "to the faithful like you know folks are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01011-00270366-00270587": "already familiar with a lot of inclusive", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01012-00270588-00270845": "protocols it's just another system and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01013-00270846-00271097": "it's a very effective system", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01014-00271098-00271379": "uh all right so with that since I don't", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01015-00271380-00271643": "see any questions coming up I'm gonna go", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01016-00271644-00271960": "back to the slide deck", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01017-00271961-00272110": "so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01018-00272111-00272356": "who uses sociocracy I probably don't", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01019-00272357-00272573": "need to give a lot of examples here but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01020-00272574-00272860": "it's slowly slowly it's it's going on to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01021-00272861-00273058": "many serves Because by the way so far", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01022-00273059-00273479": "itself uses sociocracy and I am part of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01023-00273480-00273839": "the ecosystems sub Circle so I'm", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01024-00273840-00273995": "actually in the organizational chart too", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01025-00273996-00274193": "so um", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01026-00274194-00274499": "if you have interest in learning more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01027-00274500-00274732": "about sociocracy in using their", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01028-00274733-00274960": "templates some very bite-sized", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01029-00274961-00275123": "information there's a lot of venues you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01030-00275124-00275341": "can you can go to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01031-00275342-00275639": "sociocracyforall.org training and you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01032-00275640-00275849": "can find content that you can consume or", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01033-00275850-00276041": "join a public class there's a lot of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01034-00276042-00276275": "opportunities there you can also join a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01035-00276276-00276521": "sociocracy leadership training I've been", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01036-00276522-00276739": "gone through an academy myself", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01037-00276740-00277037": "so it was a year-long journey but it's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01038-00277038-00277313": "it's it is very powerful to see how this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01039-00277314-00277679": "can other just and just understand the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01040-00277680-00277877": "mental models how do we practice and how", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01041-00277878-00278123": "do we get better at that there are these", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01042-00278124-00278441": "three books uh many voices one song", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01043-00278442-00278782": "which is the manual of sociocracy who", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01044-00278783-00279058": "decides who decides and then sociocracy", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01045-00279059-00279329": "in schools similar to the children's", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01046-00279330-00279575": "parliament in India which is also", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01047-00279576-00279797": "implementing that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01048-00279798-00280301": "so I will now leave it open to any other", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01049-00280302-00280601": "question pankaj we seem to be closing", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01050-00280602-00280919": "earlier but uh how might we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01051-00280920-00281075": "see if there's any questions people", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01052-00281076-00282095": "might have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01053-00282096-00282377": "because I could we could do all right", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01054-00282378-00282623": "there's some questions coming now", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01055-00282624-00282887": "Alia is saying can we use the shocks for", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01056-00282888-00283091": "team formation based on the nature of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01057-00283092-00283289": "Engagement", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01058-00283290-00283469": "um tell me more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01059-00283470-00283943": "what do you mean by team formation", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01060-00283944-00284399": "could you unmute yourself", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01061-00284400-00284606": "Dixit", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01062-00284607-00285353": "[Music]", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01063-00285354-00285532": "can you help me understand team", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01064-00285533-00285701": "formation", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01065-00285702-00285875": "do you mean like launching a brand new", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01066-00285876-00286193": "standing up a brand new uh agile team is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01067-00286194-00286355": "is was that your", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01068-00286356-00287195": "question", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01069-00287196-00287560": "um um so I if if your question is about", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01070-00287561-00288005": "forming a team I would say yes there is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01071-00288006-00288215": "ways you can improve depending on the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01072-00288216-00288473": "level of organization like who's who", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01073-00288474-00288721": "gets to decide", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01074-00288722-00289097": "what um who's part of a team so when we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01075-00289098-00289445": "are when we have a leader who's newly", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01076-00289446-00289703": "formed say in a is a product owner or a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01077-00289704-00290087": "team lead typically they have already an", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01078-00290088-00290393": "idea of what the team's purpose might be", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01079-00290394-00290608": "so that's a starting point and you can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01080-00290609-00290860": "use elements of sociocracy to say okay", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01081-00290861-00291095": "well what are the skills needed what is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01082-00291096-00291347": "that conversation the the way you will", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01083-00291348-00291545": "Implement sociocracy not in that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01084-00291546-00291701": "particular setting is a wholesale but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01085-00291702-00291880": "think about or what are the skills", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01086-00291881-00292097": "needed and have that conversation as a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01087-00292098-00292493": "team and invite feedback into what is", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01088-00292494-00292625": "your purpose", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01089-00292626-00293069": "um in in team liftoffs is a book that I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01090-00293070-00293332": "think aligns very well with sociocracy", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01091-00293333-00293549": "and there's a lot of practical", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01092-00293550-00293771": "facilitation techniques in that book uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01093-00293772-00294017": "if somebody can drop the link for Team", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01094-00294018-00294275": "liftoffs by Diana Larson and you will", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01095-00294276-00294437": "you will find that they talk about", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01096-00294438-00294677": "purpose alignment and context and when", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01097-00294678-00294827": "they're talking purpose alignment and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01098-00294828-00294971": "context you can bring in elements of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01099-00294972-00295169": "theocracy and integrate those templates", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01100-00295170-00295487": "in that team launch process to make sure", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01101-00295488-00295745": "that we are when when we are launching", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01102-00295746-00295960": "teams people feel like they they have a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01103-00295961-00296147": "voice and they're working together to", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01104-00296148-00296380": "form it so in that you could but without", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01105-00296381-00296693": "knowing specifically what might be under", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01106-00296694-00296873": "team formation", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01107-00296874-00297232": "um I'm not sure how I could just uh so I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01108-00297233-00297341": "will need a little bit more information", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01109-00297342-00297695": "but what I would recommend is uh use", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01110-00297696-00297934": "things like team liftoffs and bring in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01111-00297935-00298151": "elements of sociocracy you will still", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01112-00298152-00298337": "have meetings you still have workshops", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01113-00298338-00298558": "you will still have to work through some", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01114-00298559-00298984": "of those differences and go move remove", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01115-00298985-00299147": "those objections integrate those", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01116-00299148-00299339": "objections in a place where it's good", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01117-00299340-00299447": "enough for now", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01118-00299448-00299729": "thank you Alia and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01119-00299730-00299843": "right", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01120-00299844-00300119": "and yes if I ramble on you need to let", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01121-00300120-00300365": "me know that I may be going to to maybe", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01122-00300366-00300629": "repeating myself at some point Bart has", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01123-00300630-00300784": "a question any tips on how to transition", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01124-00300785-00301073": "of traditional orgs to sociocracy this", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01125-00301074-00301313": "is a very tough tough question the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01126-00301314-00301469": "larger the organization the more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01127-00301470-00301637": "difficult it will be", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01128-00301638-00301951": "um I am I'm Consulting with a uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01129-00301952-00302308": "co-hosting community in Eco Village and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01130-00302309-00302591": "they have very little resistance moving", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01131-00302592-00302806": "into sociocracy but they're also very", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01132-00302807-00303034": "small they're growing very quickly but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01133-00303035-00303289": "they're small uh the 40 people in total", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01134-00303290-00303551": "but if if you could talk with a large", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01135-00303552-00303743": "organization it's going to be an uphill", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01136-00303744-00303958": "battle but what I can do and I was in an", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01137-00303959-00304163": "organization that had", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01138-00304164-00304319": "um you know the particular group I was", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01139-00304320-00304630": "supporting it at 1800 Associates you can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01140-00304631-00304943": "start to Bringing elements of it in the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01141-00304944-00305230": "teams that you influence or have a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01142-00305231-00305477": "saying but transitioning from a complete", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01143-00305478-00305741": "organization is probably going to be you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01144-00305742-00305956": "know and you but you're probably", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01145-00305957-00306197": "familiar with the agile fluency so", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01146-00306198-00306515": "that's the last Zone zone four", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01147-00306516-00306743": "um the one that we understand where we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01148-00306744-00307013": "have a whole organization operating in", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01149-00307014-00307301": "synchronously but if you're a startup I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01150-00307302-00307601": "would say start from day one but for", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01151-00307602-00307787": "traditional organizations there's many", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01152-00307788-00308051": "many steps to take first with validated", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01153-00308052-00308249": "experiments within the organization why", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01154-00308250-00308554": "socioccas is working so having pilot and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01155-00308555-00308789": "test groups within a few teams who are", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01156-00308790-00309065": "willing to make decision making by", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01157-00309066-00309334": "consent and support that and evidence of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01158-00309335-00309521": "that working those are the things I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01159-00309522-00309713": "would start with like you know where", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01160-00309714-00309941": "where we have certain teams that could", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01161-00309942-00310156": "be further along and ready for it versus", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01162-00310157-00310499": "some support teams and other say legal", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01163-00310500-00310745": "or marketing or compliance that may be", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01164-00310746-00310973": "harder so where's the safe experiment", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01165-00310974-00311284": "and start there but just like we say not", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01166-00311285-00311549": "all of the even Azure fluency has four", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01167-00311550-00311806": "different zones it doesn't mean that the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01168-00311807-00311987": "fourth Zone is the best zone for all of", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01169-00311988-00312239": "them but sociocracy does belong in the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01170-00312240-00312413": "fourth zone so you may have one or two", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01171-00312414-00312701": "teams that are in that zone and start", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01172-00312702-00312904": "there and when the organization starts", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01173-00312905-00313097": "to notice that hey look at how much", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01174-00313098-00313271": "value we got out of that that's where", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01175-00313272-00313469": "there's energy to build upon and bring", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01176-00313470-00313654": "it to the rest of the organization but", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01177-00313655-00314056": "the smaller the organization the better", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01178-00314057-00314213": "right", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01179-00314214-00314380": "thank you Bart", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01180-00314381-00314801": "any other questions", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01181-00314802-00315323": "so with that I will leave you", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01182-00315324-00315580": "well I I will stay back for any more", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01183-00315581-00315856": "questions but I think that that was the", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01184-00315857-00316073": "content uh we we were planning to do a", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01185-00316074-00316253": "few breakouts", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01186-00316254-00316475": "um I mean that's where I said well we", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01187-00316476-00316660": "can I get three or four volunteers but I", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01188-00316661-00316882": "don't I I don't think that is as", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01189-00316883-00317087": "valuable for this group but I do invite", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01190-00317088-00317308": "you to come in and learn more about", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01191-00317309-00317489": "sociocracy for all and I can actually", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01192-00317490-00317765": "drop that link for you guys here in case", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01193-00317766-00317982": "uh", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01194-00317983-00318473": "it's it's not something that is uh that", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01195-00318474-00318749": "may be of interest for you to expect as", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01196-00318750-00318893": "an agile coach like you know if somebody", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01197-00318894-00319030": "saves you well how do I make an", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01198-00319031-00319254": "organization deal well", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01199-00319255-00319541": "sofa is one of those ways that you can", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01200-00319542-00319834": "actually make a deal and it works it it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01201-00319835-00319973": "if we have evidence we have", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01202-00319974-00320219": "organizations that are now signing up", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01203-00320220-00320603": "and making this change but if it will it", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01204-00320604-00320825": "takes a while it's not in it's not an", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01205-00320826-00321203": "easy solution but it is a practical and", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01206-00321204-00321353": "purposeful solution", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01207-00321354-00321563": "thank you so much pankaj for hosting me", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01208-00321564-00321743": "and thank you for everyone for listening", "OpvPj6OcEiA-01209-00321744-00322009": "attentively"}}, {"audio_id": "OpL72w7gJlg", "text": {"OpL72w7gJlg-00000-00000350-00001439": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00001-00001440-00001606": "it's", "OpL72w7gJlg-00002-00001607-00002471": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00003-00002472-00003295": "the walls are down", "OpL72w7gJlg-00004-00003296-00003567": "my consciousness", "OpL72w7gJlg-00005-00003568-00004856": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00006-00004857-00005686": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00007-00005687-00006006": "nothing else", "OpL72w7gJlg-00008-00006007-00007264": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00009-00007265-00007919": "[Applause]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00010-00007920-00009078": "me", "OpL72w7gJlg-00011-00009079-00009167": "i", "OpL72w7gJlg-00012-00009168-00009342": "can't stop", "OpL72w7gJlg-00013-00009343-00010287": "this", "OpL72w7gJlg-00014-00010288-00010471": "but now you're feeling something that", "OpL72w7gJlg-00015-00010472-00010788": "you can't", "OpL72w7gJlg-00016-00010789-00011351": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00017-00011352-00011495": "a ignore", "OpL72w7gJlg-00018-00011496-00012517": "who trembles and moans", "OpL72w7gJlg-00019-00012518-00012838": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00020-00012839-00013091": "for the first time", "OpL72w7gJlg-00021-00013093-00014500": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00022-00014501-00015038": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00023-00015038-00016140": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00024-00016141-00016247": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00025-00016247-00017855": "me", "OpL72w7gJlg-00026-00017856-00018558": "is", "OpL72w7gJlg-00027-00018559-00018697": "we touch", "OpL72w7gJlg-00028-00018698-00018911": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00029-00018912-00019236": "sensations", "OpL72w7gJlg-00030-00019237-00020263": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00031-00020264-00020874": "is", "OpL72w7gJlg-00032-00020875-00021294": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00033-00021295-00024750": "so", "OpL72w7gJlg-00034-00024751-00026358": "me", "OpL72w7gJlg-00035-00026360-00028350": "is", "OpL72w7gJlg-00036-00028351-00028990": "[Music]", "OpL72w7gJlg-00037-00028991-00029200": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OpTuHbwQF_8", "text": {"OpTuHbwQF_8-00000-00000473-00000836": "there being eight eyes and 57 nose the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00001-00000836-00001019": "matter is resolved in the negative it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00002-00001019-00001199": "being after two o'clock the committee", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00003-00001200-00001718": "will now report progress the committee", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00004-00001719-00001973": "reports progress will move to questions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00005-00001973-00002141": "without notice I'll give senators at the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00006-00002142-00004908": "moment to return to their seats", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00007-00004909-00005197": "ask senators to resume their seats", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00008-00005198-00005614": "I'll call senator Wong Thank You mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00009-00005615-00005764": "president my question is the Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00010-00005765-00005920": "representing the Prime Minister senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00011-00005921-00006163": "Corman over the past week New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00012-00006164-00006304": "Wales and Queensland have been", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00013-00006305-00006541": "devastated by bush fires leading to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00014-00006542-00006703": "three people tragically losing their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00015-00006704-00006901": "lives and countless more losing their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00016-00006902-00007159": "homes weather forecasts are predicting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00017-00007159-00007378": "that the situation will only worsen both", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00018-00007379-00007720": "today and over coming days as we all", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00019-00007720-00007896": "indicated yesterday I thought so with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00020-00007897-00008050": "all of those facing this immediate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00021-00008051-00008395": "crisis thinks of with the crews and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00022-00008396-00008563": "firefighters battling these fires across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00023-00008564-00008779": "the country and in in that context I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00024-00008780-00008920": "asked the minister to provide us the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00025-00008921-00009046": "Senate with an update on the current", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00026-00009047-00009249": "situation being faced by communities in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00027-00009250-00009418": "New South Wales and Queensland Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00028-00009419-00009562": "representing the prime minister senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00029-00009563-00009943": "call them thank you very much mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00030-00009944-00010087": "president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00031-00010088-00010399": "and I thank Senator Wong for that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00032-00010400-00010651": "question as we indicated yesterday our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00033-00010652-00010929": "first concern is for the safety and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00034-00010930-00011110": "needs of those directly affected", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00035-00011111-00011319": "Australians are the best in difficult", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00036-00011320-00011530": "times like this they're shown incredible", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00037-00011531-00011773": "spirit heart and generosity and our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00038-00011774-00011929": "emergency services are once again", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00039-00011930-00012069": "showing their professionalism and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00040-00012070-00012277": "dedication in the face of very difficult", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00041-00012278-00012574": "conditions and we thank all the Korean", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00042-00012575-00012715": "voluntary emergency service personnel", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00043-00012716-00013102": "fighting these fires and I acknowledge", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00044-00013103-00013435": "the comradeship on display by their by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00045-00013436-00013602": "the contribution to the New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00046-00013603-00013822": "firefighting efforts of Interstate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00047-00013822-00014062": "personnel from the ICT South Australia", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00048-00014063-00014299": "Tasmania Victoria the Australian gävle", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00049-00014300-00014482": "of course continues to stand ready to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00050-00014483-00014655": "immediately assist communities impacted", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00051-00014656-00014887": "by bush fires and the clear advice that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00052-00014888-00015130": "we give to our communities I used to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00053-00015131-00015349": "plan ahead and be prepared now in terms", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00054-00015350-00015604": "of updates devastating fires continue to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00055-00015605-00015799": "burn across large parts of northeast New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00056-00015800-00016132": "South Wales it is important that people", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00057-00016133-00016405": "remind vigilant of more than 70 fires", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00058-00016406-00016726": "which are still burning across across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00059-00016727-00017022": "the state the New South Wales fires have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00060-00017023-00017169": "had a devastating impact on the many", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00061-00017170-00017325": "affected communities the New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00062-00017326-00017575": "Rural Fire Service estimates that at", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00063-00017576-00017719": "least hundred and 50 structures have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00064-00017720-00017905": "been lost including a large number of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00065-00017906-00018101": "homes other property damage", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00066-00018102-00018293": "loss includes telecommunications and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00067-00018294-00018509": "power infrastructure bridges and to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00068-00018510-00018713": "schools more than 30 hundred", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00069-00018714-00018869": "firefighters and support personnel along", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00070-00018870-00019127": "with 93 aircraft have been battling to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00071-00019128-00019319": "his fires the forecast for today is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00072-00019320-00019511": "deeply roaring at all Commonwealth", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00073-00019512-00019679": "agencies stand ready to assist state", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00074-00019680-00019795": "authorities in the community", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00075-00019796-00020153": "catastrophic fire danger is forecast for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00076-00020154-00020330": "the greater Sydney Ryder hunter in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00077-00020331-00020597": "Illawarra scroll heaven Haven areas to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00078-00020598-00020816": "die due to the worsening weather", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00079-00020817-00021014": "conditions the first time such", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00080-00021015-00021200": "conditions have been forecast for Sydney", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00081-00021201-00021497": "since the new fire danger ratings were", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00082-00021498-00021803": "introduced in 2009 catastrophic is the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00083-00021804-00021950": "highest level of bushfire danger it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00084-00021951-00022115": "means that homes are not designed to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00085-00022116-00022283": "withstand the fire under these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00086-00022284-00022535": "conditions and if a fire takes hold", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00087-00022536-00022697": "during catastrophic fire conditions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00088-00022698-00022940": "lives and homes will be lost in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00089-00022941-00023102": "Queensland fires of concern are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00090-00023103-00023258": "continuing to burn in southeast", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00091-00023259-00023504": "Queensland 12 homes have been confirmed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00092-00023505-00023879": "as destroyed lives and property senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00093-00023880-00024206": "Corman supplementary question Thank You", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00094-00024207-00024401": "mr. president I think the Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00095-00024402-00024665": "his answer he in his answer referenced", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00096-00024666-00024887": "assistance being provided or offered by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00097-00024888-00025115": "other states and I asked him of to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00098-00025116-00025384": "detail if he's able to that assistance", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00099-00025385-00025613": "the offers of assistance from other", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00100-00025614-00025880": "states and also other countries and how", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00101-00025881-00026042": "those offers are being facilitated", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00102-00026043-00026429": "senator Corman thank you very much mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00103-00026430-00026660": "president I think centered on one for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00104-00026661-00026791": "that supplementary as I've indicated", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00105-00026792-00027035": "there have been offers of support which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00106-00027036-00027242": "have been greatly appreciated from a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00107-00027243-00027677": "number of jurisdictions into into New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00108-00027677-00027872": "South Wales in particular in Queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00109-00027873-00028268": "out of the ICT South Australia Tasmania", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00110-00028269-00028627": "in Victoria in my next question both", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00111-00028629-00028849": "senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00112-00028850-00029198": "Reynolds and Senator McKenzie will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00113-00029199-00029438": "provide further updates in relation to a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00114-00029439-00029648": "support provided through our Defense", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00115-00029649-00029879": "Forces and indeed I provide a more", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00116-00029880-00030023": "thorough updates they're going through", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00117-00030024-00030323": "all of the detail in relation to support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00118-00030324-00030715": "provided in relevant local communities", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00119-00030716-00030952": "but I should also say in terms of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00120-00030954-00031049": "providing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00121-00031050-00031379": "further further update that in Western", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00122-00031380-00031712": "Australia we remain concerned we are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00123-00031713-00031883": "severe to extreme fire danger is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00124-00031884-00032087": "forecast to die over southern and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00125-00032088-00032552": "central fire a warm final supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00126-00032553-00032835": "question thank you in addition to bush", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00127-00032836-00032990": "fires in New South Wales and Queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00128-00032991-00033242": "warnings have been issued or are present", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00129-00033243-00033437": "in other parts of the country Western", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00130-00033438-00033642": "Australia also parts of South Australia", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00131-00033643-00033776": "can the Minister update the Senate on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00132-00033777-00033971": "the status of bushfire warnings in other", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00133-00033972-00034136": "states and territories senator Corman", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00134-00034137-00034361": "thank you very much well as I was just", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00135-00034362-00034652": "indicating we remain we continued to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00136-00034653-00034817": "watch the Western Australia in other", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00137-00034818-00034998": "parts of Australia with concern in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00138-00034999-00035310": "relation to Western Australia there is a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00139-00035311-00035630": "severe to extreme fire danger forecast", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00140-00035631-00035826": "today over southern and central fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00141-00035827-00036014": "weather areas in relation to South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00142-00036015-00036449": "Australia McKenzie has further updates I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00143-00036450-00036743": "don't have any specific updates in front", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00144-00036744-00037024": "of in front of me today but may I also", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00145-00037025-00037410": "advise the chamber my also advise the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00146-00037411-00037730": "chamber that in terms of defence support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00147-00037731-00037923": "in terms of emergency management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00148-00037924-00038132": "Australia firebombing aircraft continues", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00149-00038133-00038315": "to be an action against these fires our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00150-00038316-00038501": "national area of firefighting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00151-00038502-00038651": "arrangements are ensuring the best", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00152-00038652-00038858": "possible aerial firefighting equipment", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00153-00038859-00039123": "is available to protect Australians and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00154-00039124-00039405": "and of course defense also is provided", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00155-00039406-00039648": "is available to provide support and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00156-00039649-00039807": "Senator Reynolds will provide further", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00157-00039808-00040019": "information relation to this the Royal", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00158-00040020-00040157": "Australian Air Force aircrafts have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00159-00040158-00040385": "transported fire fighters from Canada", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00160-00040386-00040661": "before I come to you senator McGraw I'd", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00161-00040662-00040862": "like to draw to honourable attention of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00162-00040863-00040994": "honourable senators the presence in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00163-00040995-00041226": "chamber and gallery of a delegation from", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00164-00041227-00041414": "the Cook Islands led by the Honorable", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00165-00041415-00041601": "Henry Cunha prime minister of the Cook", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00166-00041602-00041826": "Islands on behalf of all senators I wish", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00167-00041827-00041976": "to a warm welcome to Australia and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00168-00041977-00042235": "particularly to the Senate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00169-00042236-00042593": "senator McGraw I Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00170-00042594-00042746": "my question is to the Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00171-00042747-00042959": "defense senator Reynolds can the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00172-00042960-00043136": "Minister update the Senate on what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00173-00043137-00043289": "assistance the Australian Defence Force", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00174-00043290-00043496": "is providing to the current firefighting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00175-00043497-00043742": "effort the Minister for defence senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00176-00043743-00043985": "Reynolds thank you very much mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00177-00043986-00044177": "president and I think Senator McGrath", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00178-00044178-00044516": "whose most important question today all", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00179-00044517-00044672": "of our thoughts and prayers are with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00180-00044673-00044860": "those in Queensland and New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00181-00044861-00045134": "who are dealing with the threat and also", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00182-00045135-00045290": "now the consequences of these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00183-00045291-00045587": "catastrophic bush fires already they've", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00184-00045588-00045878": "endured days and long nights of anxiety", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00185-00045879-00046109": "and disruption not knowing where the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00186-00046110-00046418": "fires will strike next and firstly I do", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00187-00046419-00046682": "pay tribute to our amazing emergency", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00188-00046683-00046982": "services workers who are battling these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00189-00046983-00047282": "fires in extraordinarily in almost", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00190-00047283-00047558": "unimaginable circumstances but I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00191-00047559-00047753": "particularly think our ADF personnel who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00192-00047754-00047920": "are supporting the firefighting efforts", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00193-00047921-00048275": "Royal Australian Air Force 737 and c-130", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00194-00048276-00048460": "aircraft have already transported", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00195-00048461-00048653": "firefighters and their equipment from", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00196-00048654-00048896": "Canberra Adelaide and Hobart to Port", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00197-00048897-00049165": "Macquarie an area of high and immediate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00198-00049166-00049427": "needs at singleton and Lismore defence", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00199-00049428-00049625": "bases in New South Wales are already", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00200-00049626-00049796": "also providing accommodation and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00201-00049797-00050009": "catering to firefighters from the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00202-00050010-00050363": "Victorian County Fire Authority today", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00203-00050364-00050636": "and tomorrow army and naval helicopters", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00204-00050637-00050840": "will also support fire fighter movements", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00205-00050841-00051165": "air observers and civilian rescuers as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00206-00051166-00051551": "requested yesterday I asked the Chief of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00207-00051552-00051733": "Defence Force to give an order to all", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00208-00051734-00052001": "military base commander's making clear", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00209-00052002-00052214": "that they have the authority to use", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00210-00052215-00052523": "local defence assets and resources to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00211-00052524-00052786": "respond to any local contingencies", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00212-00052787-00053066": "defense is also posited to provide", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00213-00053066-00053264": "further airlift and is prepared to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00214-00053265-00053435": "provide assistance in areas such as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00215-00053436-00053680": "aerial fire reconnaissance logistical", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00216-00053682-00053975": "support and also engineering on request", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00217-00053976-00054316": "it is important to remember that our ADF", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00218-00054317-00054569": "members are not firefighters and they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00219-00054570-00054764": "are not trained fire fighters but they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00220-00054765-00055016": "are doing everything that they can to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00221-00055016-00055238": "help the community in this current", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00222-00055239-00055475": "catastrophic circumstances senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00223-00055476-00055571": "McGuire supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00224-00055572-00055741": "question thank you can the minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00225-00055742-00055922": "update the Senate on what further", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00226-00055923-00056143": "Australian defense support can be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00227-00056144-00056411": "provided if requested by the states and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00228-00056412-00056735": "territories senator Reynolds thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00229-00056736-00057122": "very much mr. president as Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00230-00057123-00057323": "defense at this time of unprecedented", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00231-00057324-00057592": "fire threats I am focused on ensuring", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00232-00057593-00057787": "that the ATF are ready to provide", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00233-00057788-00058004": "additional support for the nation's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00234-00058004-00058351": "frontline our first responders our first", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00235-00058352-00058598": "call is always to our regular forces and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00236-00058599-00058823": "the capabilities that they bring with us", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00237-00058824-00059137": "but work is also now underway to scope", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00238-00059138-00059360": "the availability and also the readiness", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00239-00059361-00059593": "of our highly capable reserve forces", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00240-00059594-00059986": "across all three services ATF reservists", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00241-00059987-00060187": "are already regularly employed for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00242-00060188-00060355": "emergency disaster assistance and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00243-00060356-00060665": "disaster recovery under voluntary what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00244-00060666-00060994": "is called call for arrangements which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00245-00060995-00061263": "means the voluntary call for our reserve", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00246-00061264-00061555": "emergency support forces already have a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00247-00061556-00061786": "hundred and twenty person capacity in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00248-00061787-00062161": "Brisbane and also 130 person capacity in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00249-00062162-00062392": "Sydney to provide transport logistics", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00250-00062393-00062755": "and other requires and requested support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00251-00062756-00063007": "order senator Reynolds senator McGuire a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00252-00063008-00063215": "final supplementary question can the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00253-00063216-00063422": "minister outline what longer-term", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00254-00063423-00063643": "preparations are underway to prepare for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00255-00063644-00063941": "this high-risk weather season including", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00256-00063941-00064174": "mobilization of reserves senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00257-00064175-00064312": "Reynolds thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00258-00064313-00064574": "in addition to the call for activities", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00259-00064575-00064801": "that we now have underway I'm also", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00260-00064802-00065056": "working with defense to work through how", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00261-00065057-00065326": "we can provide further response to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00262-00065327-00065554": "larger more severe and also more", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00263-00065555-00065849": "protracted and natural disasters beyond", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00264-00065850-00066079": "as I've said the call for arrangements a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00265-00066080-00066436": "broader response is also can includes a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00266-00066437-00066763": "compulsory call out of reserves if the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00267-00066764-00067150": "situation requires reserve forces can be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00268-00067151-00067346": "called out by the governor-general in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00269-00067347-00067553": "accordance with section 28 of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00270-00067554-00067847": "defence acts this mechanism has never", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00271-00067848-00068129": "been used defense is working through", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00272-00068130-00068342": "every aspect at the moment of such a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00273-00068343-00068709": "call out to ensure that we are prepared", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00274-00068710-00068985": "requires defense will continue tasking", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00275-00068986-00069186": "discrete elements of the Army Reserves a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00276-00069187-00069447": "naval and also Air Force Reserves using", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00277-00069448-00069663": "existing existing voluntary call for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00278-00069664-00069912": "arrangements again as the circumstances", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00279-00069913-00070209": "require and can I decipher half of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00280-00070210-00070434": "saw thank you very much I'm very proud", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00281-00070435-00070629": "of a many women in uniform and for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00282-00070630-00070968": "support senator is mr. president my", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00283-00070969-00071082": "question is to the Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00284-00071083-00071181": "agriculture", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00285-00071182-00071436": "senator Mackenzie in a deal with one", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00286-00071437-00071727": "nation the Minister has finally released", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00287-00071728-00071967": "the draft dairy Code of Conduct for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00288-00071968-00072273": "consultation key elements of the draft", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00289-00072274-00072509": "code have changed since January", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00290-00072510-00072741": "including watering down the express", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00291-00072742-00073044": "prohibition of retrospective price drops", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00292-00073045-00073338": "for dairy farmers why has the minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00293-00073339-00073572": "watered down the draft code released by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00294-00073573-00073887": "former minister David little prayer the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00295-00073888-00074025": "Minister of Agriculture Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00296-00074026-00074235": "Mackenzie well thank you very much mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00297-00074236-00074427": "president I thank the senator for his", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00298-00074428-00074805": "question the Nationals have stood up for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00299-00074806-00075036": "our farming families and communities for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00300-00075037-00075375": "100 years and we unashamedly want to see", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00301-00075376-00075591": "a prosperous and sustainable dairy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00302-00075592-00075750": "industry going forward that means", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00303-00075751-00075918": "opening up markets fighting on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00304-00075919-00076233": "competition policies and decreasing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00305-00076234-00076485": "regulation for our farmers at the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00306-00076486-00076671": "election there were two plans for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00307-00076672-00076929": "dairy industry put forward one was the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00308-00076930-00077235": "Labour Party's position to re-regulate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00309-00077236-00077508": "the dairy industry the other was a suite", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00310-00077509-00077670": "of initiatives that actually went to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00311-00077671-00078024": "heart of the issues which one was going", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00312-00078025-00078225": "to be putting in a mandatory code of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00313-00078226-00078462": "conduct to regulate the relationships", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00314-00078463-00078729": "between processors and farmers to make", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00315-00078730-00079041": "sure farmers get a feel fair deal after", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00316-00079042-00079200": "they'd been suffering from egregious", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00317-00079201-00079482": "behavior from processors for many many", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00318-00079483-00079740": "years making sure we put downward", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00319-00079741-00079917": "pressure on energy prices for our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00320-00079918-00080067": "farmers because it is one of the high", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00321-00080068-00080418": "input costs so we have order senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00322-00080419-00080577": "Mackenzie senator is on a point of order", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00323-00080578-00080730": "on on relevance", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00324-00080731-00080973": "mr. president the question was very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00325-00080974-00081126": "specific", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00326-00081127-00081327": "why has the Minister watered down the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00327-00081328-00081540": "draft code released by former", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00328-00081541-00081750": "agriculture minister David little proud", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00329-00081751-00081960": "the men asked me to draw her to that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00330-00081961-00082131": "question the Minister is allowed to be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00331-00082132-00082301": "directly relevant to the preamble as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00332-00082302-00082503": "well at this point I do consider the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00333-00082504-00082682": "Minister to be directly relevant they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00334-00082683-00082826": "don't minister doesn't have to accept", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00335-00082827-00082965": "the premise of a question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00336-00082966-00083331": "I'm listening carefully call senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00337-00083332-00083525": "Mackenzie to continue thank you very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00338-00083526-00083742": "much mr. president and I absolutely", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00339-00083743-00084054": "categorically reject the suggestion that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00340-00084055-00084354": "there is a watering down of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00341-00084355-00084488": "treatment of processes and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00342-00084489-00084642": "relationship between farmers and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00343-00084643-00084936": "processes with the code I'm happy to go", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00344-00084937-00085179": "through for the senator the process our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00345-00085180-00085392": "government is undertaken since the a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00346-00085393-00085644": "Triple C report recommended or that we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00347-00085645-00085838": "have a mandatory dairy code", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00348-00085839-00086136": "so on April 2018 on the back of Murray", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00349-00086137-00086328": "Goulburn and Fonterra clawbacks and step", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00350-00086329-00086732": "downs a triple a triple C released a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00351-00086733-00086906": "recommendation that we implement a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00352-00086907-00087131": "mandatory dairy code which we agreed to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00353-00087132-00087441": "do in October 2018 we announced the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00354-00087442-00087612": "first round of consultation with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00355-00087613-00087762": "industry and this was the very first", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00356-00087763-00087969": "opportunity for a dairy industry that is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00357-00087970-00088244": "quite fractured to come together around", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00358-00088245-00088394": "what were the measures that they could", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00359-00088395-00088578": "agree on that could be part of a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00360-00088579-00088923": "mandatory code in January 2019 a set of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00361-00088924-00089073": "draft clauses for the code was released", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00362-00089074-00089484": "and a second round is a supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00363-00089485-00089640": "question we'll try again mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00364-00089641-00090003": "on ABC a.m. this morning the minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00365-00090004-00090324": "refused four times to make clear who had", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00366-00090325-00090603": "requested this change will the Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00367-00090604-00090791": "now make clear which stakeholders", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00368-00090792-00091193": "requested this change of wording set it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00369-00091194-00091449": "up Mackenzie Thank You mr. president and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00370-00091450-00091706": "I'm going through the process so we get", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00371-00091707-00091956": "the consultation in January around the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00372-00091957-00092225": "draft clauses develops nine principles", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00373-00092226-00092511": "that go to a raft of issues around the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00374-00092512-00092715": "how the parties treat each other", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00375-00092716-00092997": "requiring annual set date the process is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00376-00092998-00093176": "publicly released standard form", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00377-00093177-00093450": "agreements and prohibit prescriptive", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00378-00093451-00094154": "step downs unless in specific", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00379-00094155-00094380": "circumstance the minister refused to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00380-00094381-00094532": "answer this four times this morning on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00381-00094533-00094680": "radio will she", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00382-00094681-00094907": "now answer it the fifth time okay", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00383-00094908-00095081": "senator what I'm going to ask you to at", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00384-00095082-00095184": "least", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00385-00095185-00095382": "attempt to make a point of direct", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00386-00095383-00095637": "relevance rather than rather than pursue", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00387-00095638-00095837": "a follow-up question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00388-00095838-00096069": "it has repeatedly not answered this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00389-00096070-00096261": "question in the media so like an answer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00390-00096262-00096540": "here look the question went to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00391-00096541-00097161": "changes I'm listing order the question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00392-00097162-00097407": "from Senator Ayers went specifically to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00393-00097408-00097737": "the changes in the code and which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00394-00097738-00097884": "stakeholders requested them", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00395-00097885-00098298": "senator Wong you want is to clarify mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00396-00098299-00098613": "president it was not that all changes in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00397-00098614-00098721": "the code there was a very specific", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00398-00098722-00098907": "wording change which was referenced in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00399-00098908-00099090": "the primary primary that is the issue", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00400-00099091-00099222": "that the minister was pressed on this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00401-00099223-00099492": "was I was coming to that which is that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00402-00099493-00099683": "question specifically went to that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00403-00099684-00100059": "specified change in the code and well", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00404-00100060-00100275": "and which they called ask administer to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00405-00100276-00100482": "change it I'm going to decreed if the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00406-00100483-00100647": "minister is speaking about the change", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00407-00100648-00100881": "that specific change in the code I do", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00408-00100882-00101031": "consider that to be directly relevant", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00409-00101032-00101220": "and I'm listening very carefully the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00410-00101221-00101436": "minister has 36 seconds remaining to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00411-00101437-00101658": "answer that specific point Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00412-00101659-00101859": "Medicaid senator Mackenzie right well", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00413-00101860-00102012": "thank you mr. president for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00414-00102013-00102219": "opportunity so as I was saying the cloth", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00415-00102220-00102402": "the principle that was consulted on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00416-00102403-00102555": "which goes directly to your question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00417-00102556-00102771": "senator was to prohibit prosthetic", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00418-00102772-00103014": "perspective step downs and lesson", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00419-00103015-00103227": "specific service circumstances such as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00420-00103228-00103452": "force majeure or exceptional market", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00421-00103453-00103661": "circumstances or major changes in global", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00422-00103663-00103830": "market circumstances", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00423-00103831-00104079": "now those principles were sent off to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00424-00104080-00104417": "the office two of the drafters and what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00425-00104418-00104756": "came back was that we must not bury the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00426-00104757-00105123": "agreement you know senator wall on a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00427-00105124-00105359": "point of order this again goes to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00428-00105360-00105608": "process she was asked which stakeholders", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00429-00105608-00106158": "requested the change like that I'll take", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00430-00106158-00106281": "the interdiction is the minister the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00431-00106282-00106440": "stakeholder requested the change", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00432-00106441-00106784": "senator wall as I said I think in my", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00433-00106785-00107046": "view as long as the minister is talking", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00434-00107047-00107433": "about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00435-00107434-00107899": "I will rule when there's silence as long", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00436-00107900-00108073": "as the minister is addressing the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00437-00108074-00108276": "specific change in the question about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00438-00108277-00108426": "that part of the code", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00439-00108427-00108649": "I think the minister is being directly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00440-00108650-00108868": "relevant I cannot director how to answer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00441-00108869-00109074": "a question but she must be specific to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00442-00109075-00109249": "that specific change and the very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00443-00109250-00109431": "specific nature of that question I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00444-00109432-00109683": "believe at the point that point of order", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00445-00109684-00109836": "was raised the Minister was talking", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00446-00109838-00110102": "about that specific change", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00447-00110103-00110628": "senator Mackenzie there were no", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00448-00110629-00110904": "stakeholders that requested a change the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00449-00110905-00111232": "principles as I see time as it's time", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00450-00111233-00111319": "has expired", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00451-00111320-00111745": "the answer senator senator is a software", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00452-00111746-00112024": "supplementary question following the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00453-00112025-00112294": "release of the draft code Nationals", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00454-00112295-00112582": "Nationals member for line dr. Gillespie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00455-00112583-00112882": "warned that a dotted farmers and refused", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00456-00112883-00113083": "to rule out a leadership tilt over the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00457-00113083-00113391": "issue why is the minister siding with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00458-00113392-00113574": "big producers instead of protecting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00459-00113575-00114157": "dairy farmers senator Mackenzie Oh mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00460-00114158-00114370": "president thank you very very much well", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00461-00114371-00114607": "senator you don't actually understand", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00462-00114608-00114868": "what the National Party's advocacy in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00463-00114869-00115147": "this area has been for years it is in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00464-00115148-00115434": "competition policy is getting actually", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00465-00115435-00115599": "addressing the issues of the dairy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00466-00115600-00115791": "industry which are high energy prices", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00467-00115792-00116034": "high fodder costs they've increased by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00468-00116035-00116376": "50% thanks to the drought and if you are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00469-00116377-00116620": "a dairy farmer in areas of that require", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00470-00116621-00116952": "irrigation water has increased over 300%", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00471-00116953-00117268": "in the pricing so the input costs for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00472-00117269-00117493": "our dairy farmers and make it incredibly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00473-00117494-00117757": "difficult for them to get the margins", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00474-00117758-00117874": "that they need which is why our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00475-00117875-00118099": "government took a suite of initiatives", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00476-00118100-00118362": "to the election one is the mandatory DAF", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00477-00118363-00118606": "code of conduct to regulate that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00478-00118607-00118800": "unconscionable behavior by some of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00479-00118801-00119049": "processes and recognizes that we've got", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00480-00119050-00119347": "eight very unique regions across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00481-00119348-00119557": "Australia when it comes to daring what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00482-00119558-00119751": "works in northern Queensland is not been", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00483-00119752-00120169": "a work in W a is not gonna work no time", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00484-00120170-00120322": "for the answer has expired", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00485-00120323-00120407": "order on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00486-00120408-00121063": "I left order senator waters order thanks", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00487-00121064-00121216": "president my questions to the minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00488-00121217-00121408": "representing the prime minister senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00489-00121409-00121627": "Corman today a member of the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00490-00121628-00121885": "mr. Barnaby Joyce said I acknowledged", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00491-00121886-00122077": "that the two people who died were most", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00492-00122078-00122273": "likely people who voted for the Green", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00493-00122274-00122428": "Party so I'm not going to start", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00494-00122429-00122744": "attacking them and do you support these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00495-00122745-00123001": "vile comments and is it now the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00496-00123002-00123178": "government's position that it's not okay", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00497-00123179-00123398": "to talk about the climate crisis but it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00498-00123399-00123674": "is I talk about people who burned alive", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00499-00123675-00123850": "in bush fires and how they might have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00500-00123851-00124157": "voted will you offer an unconditional", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00501-00124158-00124358": "apology to the families of the victims", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00502-00124358-00124519": "and will you take disciplinary action", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00503-00124520-00124876": "against mr. Barnaby Joyce order on my", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00504-00124877-00125083": "left during the questions please the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00505-00125084-00125219": "minister representing the prime minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00506-00125220-00125521": "senator Corman thank you very much I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00507-00125522-00125752": "mean the short answer to the initial", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00508-00125753-00125935": "question is no I don't think that these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00509-00125936-00126197": "were appropriate comments in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00510-00126198-00126458": "circumstances and that is because I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00511-00126458-00126751": "believe and we believe that it is not an", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00512-00126752-00127026": "appropriate time to bring politics into", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00513-00127027-00127325": "this debate when people have lost their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00514-00127326-00127718": "lives and while this same fires continue", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00515-00127719-00128099": "to burn equally the time to have policy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00516-00128100-00128326": "discussions is not in the middle of an", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00517-00128327-00128554": "operational response it is not in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00518-00128555-00128890": "middle of people literally fighting for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00519-00128891-00129013": "their homes and fighting for their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00520-00129014-00129304": "survival as the Prime Minister has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00521-00129305-00129484": "stated all of our attention as the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00522-00129485-00129644": "government remains focused on supporting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00523-00129645-00129872": "our firefighters and volunteers and on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00524-00129873-00130135": "ensuring that people in fire affected", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00525-00130136-00130358": "communities are kept safe and continue", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00526-00130358-00130609": "to receive the support they need senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00527-00130610-00130793": "Ward is a supplementary question Thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00528-00130794-00131002": "You president in April this year former", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00529-00131003-00131266": "fire chiefs and fire experts asked to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00530-00131267-00131372": "talk with the government about the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00531-00131373-00131512": "climate crisis and the lack of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00532-00131513-00131737": "preparedness for catastrophic fire but", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00533-00131738-00131924": "the prime minister didn't want to meet", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00534-00131925-00132209": "them they then asked again in September", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00535-00132210-00132386": "but the prime minister didn't want to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00536-00132387-00132656": "meet them they have still not had a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00537-00132657-00132860": "meeting if the government didn't want to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00538-00132861-00133066": "talk about the climate crisis and fires", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00539-00133067-00133288": "in April you didn't want to talk about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00540-00133289-00133453": "it in September you still don't want to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00541-00133454-00133694": "talk about it now when is the right time", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00542-00133695-00133904": "talk about how coal is making these five", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00543-00133905-00134264": "senator waters senator Corman thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00544-00134265-00134768": "very much mr. president I don't accept", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00545-00134769-00135044": "the premise of the question I meeting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00546-00135045-00135320": "was offered and that offer wasn't taken", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00547-00135321-00135653": "up that is my advice my advice is that a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00548-00135654-00135905": "meeting was offered and the meeting of I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00549-00135906-00136025": "was not taken happily", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00550-00136026-00136205": "senator waters a final supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00551-00136206-00136580": "question thanks president John Howard", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00552-00136581-00136811": "responded to the Port Arthur tragedy by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00553-00136812-00136970": "quickly putting in place a National", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00554-00136971-00137147": "Firearms agreement which was supported", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00555-00137148-00137276": "across the Parliament and across the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00556-00137277-00137522": "country given the climate crisis that is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00557-00137523-00137747": "fueling catastrophic bush fires across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00558-00137748-00137915": "the country will your government now", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00559-00137916-00138227": "convene urgent cross-party talks to put", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00560-00138228-00138416": "in place a national agreement to phase", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00561-00138417-00138731": "out coal senator Corman think thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00562-00138732-00138818": "very much", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00563-00138819-00139028": "mr. president I would very respectfully", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00564-00139029-00139310": "refer senator waters to my primary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00565-00139311-00139595": "answer to her first question senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00566-00139596-00139823": "Griffin I thank you mr. president my", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00567-00139824-00139970": "question is of a minister representing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00568-00139971-00140108": "the Minister for energy and emissions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00569-00140109-00140354": "reductions senator Birmingham in recent", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00570-00140355-00140516": "months the Australian energy market", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00571-00140517-00140738": "operator warned that the outage of to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00572-00140739-00140929": "Victorian power units poses a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00573-00140930-00141176": "significant risk of insufficient supply", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00574-00141177-00141395": "this summer the Australian Energy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00575-00141396-00141566": "Regulator release data showing sharp", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00576-00141567-00141737": "reductions in surplus generation in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00577-00141738-00141950": "Victoria and New South Wales and we know", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00578-00141951-00142091": "the coming summer will be very much", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00579-00142092-00142322": "hotter dry this all points to a greater", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00580-00142323-00142496": "likelihood of high power prices and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00581-00142497-00142709": "power cuts this summer given the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00582-00142710-00142889": "Victoria a South Australia's only link", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00583-00142890-00143042": "to the National Grid I'm particularly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00584-00143043-00143201": "concerned about the potential for a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00585-00143202-00143372": "blackout in Victoria affecting my home", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00586-00143373-00143591": "state of South Australia Minister has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00587-00143592-00143744": "the government received any recent", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00588-00143745-00143930": "advice about the potential for blackouts", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00589-00143931-00144092": "this summer in South Australia or", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00590-00144093-00144308": "Victoria the minister representing the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00591-00144309-00144434": "Minister for energy and emissions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00592-00144435-00144683": "reduction senator Birmingham thanks so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00593-00144684-00144779": "Thank You mr. president I thank Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00594-00144780-00145067": "Griff for his question particularly as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00595-00145068-00145325": "it relates to energy reliability in our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00596-00145326-00145517": "home state of South Australia and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00597-00145518-00145643": "certain senator Griff", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00598-00145644-00145961": "I can reassure you that the Morison", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00599-00145962-00146102": "government together with the Marshall", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00600-00146103-00146234": "Liberal government in South Australia", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00601-00146235-00146519": "has been working to ensure enhanced", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00602-00146520-00146702": "reliability of the grid in South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00603-00146703-00146981": "Australia recently the Australian energy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00604-00146982-00147136": "market opera", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00605-00147137-00147367": "released this year's electricity", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00606-00147368-00147577": "statement of opportunities", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00607-00147578-00147853": "this shows that grid reliability in Si", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00608-00147854-00148242": "is in fact improving in 2018 amo", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00609-00148243-00148459": "predicted that and reported that the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00610-00148460-00148654": "reliability standard as set by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00611-00148655-00148927": "government would in fact be exceeded in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00612-00148928-00149050": "South Australia that there would be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00613-00149051-00149386": "heightened risk of blackouts going in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00614-00149387-00149680": "now that the forecasts for 2019 shows", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00615-00149681-00149860": "that that is no longer the case", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00616-00149861-00150088": "and to that reliability standard is in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00617-00150089-00150349": "the context of South Australia expected", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00618-00150350-00150631": "to be met and it's met by a range of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00619-00150632-00150955": "factors increasing of course energy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00620-00150956-00151207": "generation in the state some through", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00621-00151208-00151423": "renewable capability but also those that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00622-00151424-00151699": "can provide the type of peaking support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00623-00151700-00151978": "to provide for reliability last week", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00624-00151979-00152239": "Minister Taylor opened additional gas", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00625-00152240-00152548": "power capability on Torrens Island the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00626-00152549-00152773": "new 210 megawatt Barker inlet power", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00627-00152774-00153019": "station will complement the very high", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00628-00153020-00153208": "shares of intermittent wind and solar", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00629-00153209-00153505": "generated in South Australia reducing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00630-00153506-00153688": "prices and helping to improve", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00631-00153689-00153943": "reliability we're also pursuing a range", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00632-00153944-00154057": "of other measures to help with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00633-00154058-00154252": "reliability the main risk in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00634-00154253-00154399": "national electricity market is you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00635-00154400-00154660": "identified a Senator Griff indeed now", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00636-00154661-00155011": "comes from Victoria in that state and we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00637-00155012-00155287": "have seen that the threat of blackouts", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00638-00155288-00155550": "is real and that's a result of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00639-00155551-00155875": "shutdown driven by state government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00640-00155876-00156136": "policies there of large generators who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00641-00156137-00156250": "in a state government that also", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00642-00156251-00156496": "continues to insist on a gas ban which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00643-00156497-00156718": "puts real pressures in terms of all the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00644-00156719-00156955": "air energy generation Senator Griffo", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00645-00156956-00157159": "supplementary question I think it mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00646-00157160-00157198": "president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00647-00157199-00157432": "back in January this year Minister the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00648-00157433-00157588": "temperatures reach 48 degrees as you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00649-00157589-00157714": "know in Adelaide in the electricity", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00650-00157715-00157924": "system was very much pushed to its limit", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00651-00157925-00158170": "now generation was insufficient leading", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00652-00158171-00158317": "to power cuts of Victoria an average", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00653-00158318-00158521": "weekly prices of more than $1,000 per", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00654-00158522-00158794": "megawatt hour in SA and Victoria the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00655-00158795-00158983": "highest on record what is the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00656-00158984-00159202": "government's plan to avoid price surges", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00657-00159203-00159453": "in South Australia this coming summer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00658-00159454-00159796": "senator Birmingham makes it resident", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00659-00159797-00160051": "well indeed that that additional energy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00660-00160052-00160261": "generation in the South Australian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00661-00160262-00160567": "market importantly will not only", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00662-00160568-00160852": "contribute to reliability but contribute", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00663-00160853-00161142": "to a greater stabilization of power", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00664-00161143-00161506": "prices in South Australia in fact one of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00665-00161507-00161761": "the proof points in terms of the threats", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00666-00161762-00161947": "that exist now in Victoria", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00667-00161948-00162217": "relative to South Australia is that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00668-00162218-00162472": "Victorian power prices have now", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00669-00162473-00162715": "overtaken in South Australia's as the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00670-00162716-00163084": "most expensive energy in the nation so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00671-00163085-00163375": "our policies are yielding dividends in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00672-00163376-00163618": "relation to stability in SA and that's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00673-00163619-00163804": "partly a result of our work partly a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00674-00163805-00163948": "result of the work of the South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00675-00163949-00164065": "Australian government and the close", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00676-00164066-00164299": "collaboration between the two of us and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00677-00164300-00164545": "we continue to work to pursue other", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00678-00164546-00164764": "opportunities such as through the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00679-00164765-00165004": "underwriting new generation investments", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00680-00165005-00165223": "programme which is looking at new", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00681-00165224-00165421": "reliable generation opportunities in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00682-00165422-00165646": "South Australia to provide again for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00683-00165647-00165994": "peaking capacity or smooth the system is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00684-00165995-00166327": "required supplementary question Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00685-00166328-00166507": "the Ocoee Energy Council is the forum", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00686-00166508-00166633": "for the Commonwealth and the states to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00687-00166634-00166804": "work together on energy policy and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00688-00166805-00167152": "admits six times in 2018 but has not met", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00689-00167153-00167599": "yet in 2019 which is quite a big concern", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00690-00167600-00167935": "now can you explain why the Energy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00691-00167936-00168085": "Council has not met this year and why", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00692-00168086-00168229": "the government is not making greater use", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00693-00168230-00168439": "of this forum to manage the risks facing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00694-00168440-00168655": "South Australia senator Birmingham", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00695-00168656-00168817": "thanks mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00696-00168818-00169000": "the Quahog Energy Council will I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00697-00169001-00169291": "understand meet on November 22 and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00698-00169292-00169420": "although it hasn't physically met", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00699-00169421-00169588": "recently and has continued to pursue", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00700-00169589-00169750": "work including out of session work", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00701-00169751-00169996": "during during the course of this year", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00702-00169997-00170212": "and the government's new retailer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00703-00170213-00170494": "reliability obligation and was agreed by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00704-00170495-00170653": "ministers of the colleg Energy Council", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00705-00170654-00170923": "out of session in May of this year and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00706-00170924-00171085": "so the government could implement this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00707-00171086-00171346": "key election policy effective from the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00708-00171347-00171625": "1st of July a retail of reliability", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00709-00171626-00171841": "obligation that is now triggered in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00710-00171842-00172141": "relation to aspects of the Victorian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00711-00172142-00172396": "energy market and hoping to ensure that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00712-00172397-00172758": "supply can meet demand in Victoria I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00713-00172759-00172971": "of the coming summer the council", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00714-00172972-00173160": "continues to work on key other issues", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00715-00173161-00173439": "out of session the department convening", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00716-00173440-00173576": "a general business meeting of senior", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00717-00173577-00173789": "committee officials on the 2nd of august", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00718-00173790-00174144": "20 19 to inform the discussions that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00719-00174145-00174459": "will occur on November 22 focus they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00720-00174460-00174618": "will be on affordability and reliability", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00721-00174619-00174887": "as our government is in every state", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00722-00174888-00175103": "senator Kay Neeley Thank You mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00723-00175104-00175236": "president my question is to the Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00724-00175237-00175461": "for aged care and senior Australian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00725-00175462-00175826": "Senator Kovac the devastating interim", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00726-00175827-00176066": "report of the Royal Commission into aged", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00727-00176067-00176259": "care quality and safety has confirmed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00728-00176260-00176504": "the shameful neglect of older", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00729-00176505-00176838": "Australians today we see analysis that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00730-00176839-00177156": "about 50,000 older Australians across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00731-00177157-00177426": "the country are at risk as a result of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00732-00177427-00177756": "an unacceptably high risk of insolvency", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00733-00177757-00178038": "of at least 200 residential aged care", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00734-00178039-00178376": "providers will the minister take", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00735-00178377-00178584": "responsibility for fixing Australia's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00736-00178585-00178901": "broken aged care system Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00737-00178902-00179088": "aged care and senior Australians senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00738-00179089-00179486": "Kovac seconds to present the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00739-00179487-00179796": "has taken significant if it's over", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00740-00179797-00180077": "recent times to repair the aged care", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00741-00180078-00180377": "system and mr. president one of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00742-00180378-00180629": "actions that we took in relation to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00743-00180630-00180846": "dealing with the circumstances that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00744-00180847-00181068": "occur in the aged care sector is to call", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00745-00181069-00181364": "the Royal Commission and that Royal", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00746-00181365-00181691": "Commission mr. president made set a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00747-00181692-00182031": "number of things it laid open the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00748-00182032-00182208": "circumstance of aged care in this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00749-00182209-00182603": "country it put Australia on notice it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00750-00182604-00182757": "put us the Australian government on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00751-00182758-00183014": "notice support the Australian aged care", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00752-00183015-00183201": "sector on notice and it put the aged", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00753-00183202-00183510": "care industry on notice order about the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00754-00183511-00183783": "circumstance in aged care and made some", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00755-00183784-00184023": "recommendations mr. president in respect", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00756-00184024-00184226": "of what needed to be done to repair that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00757-00184227-00184518": "the government said in response to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00758-00184519-00184715": "report when it was released last week", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00759-00184716-00184938": "that we would take some action", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00760-00184939-00185133": "particularly in the areas that were", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00761-00185134-00185365": "recommended by the Royal Commission", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00762-00185366-00185722": "it made three key elements that it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00763-00185723-00185881": "wanted to see done is one of the see", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00764-00185882-00186127": "some active action with respect to home", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00765-00186128-00186307": "care packages and the Prime Minister has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00766-00186308-00186547": "said that we will make some statements", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00767-00186548-00186724": "about that prior to Christmas and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00768-00186725-00187031": "government will do that it also said mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00769-00187032-00187294": "president that he wanted to see some", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00770-00187295-00187495": "work done with respect to young people", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00771-00187496-00187777": "in aged care and that work has already", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00772-00187778-00187919": "commenced and we will take further", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00773-00187920-00188176": "action in that place as I have said and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00774-00188177-00188437": "as the government said it also said mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00775-00188438-00188746": "president that we wanted to do some work", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00776-00188747-00189025": "with respect to the use of restraints", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00777-00189026-00189259": "and the government has said we will take", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00778-00189260-00189547": "some action to deal with it so mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00779-00189548-00189838": "president the HK royal commission report", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00780-00189839-00190111": "said that the issues in aged care were", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00781-00190112-00190336": "historical over a number of governments", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00782-00190337-00190519": "not just this government but a number of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00783-00190520-00190963": "governments and mr. president the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00784-00190964-00191468": "government will take action connealy a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00785-00191469-00191722": "supplementary question I note the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00786-00191723-00191935": "minister mentioned taking action by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00787-00191936-00192169": "Christmas so let me ask the royal", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00788-00192170-00192370": "commissions interim report recommended", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00789-00192371-00192574": "as one of 3 urgent actions an immediate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00790-00192575-00192814": "injection of more government funds into", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00791-00192815-00193033": "homecare services in addition", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00792-00193034-00193261": "leading-edge service now argues that an", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00793-00193262-00193444": "urgent pre-christmas injection into", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00794-00193445-00193687": "residential aged-care is also required", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00795-00193688-00194029": "what urgent support will the Morison", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00796-00194030-00194219": "government give the aged care sector", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00797-00194220-00194650": "prior to Christmas Senator Colbeck Thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00798-00194651-00194866": "You mr. president mr. president the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00799-00194867-00195016": "government will do what it said it would", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00800-00195017-00195269": "do when the Royal Commission report was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00801-00195270-00195688": "released week before last it will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00802-00195689-00195934": "consider the report carefully and it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00803-00195935-00196186": "will take action particularly with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00804-00196187-00196450": "respect to home care places and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00805-00196451-00196615": "Prime Minister has said quite clearly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00806-00196616-00196868": "that we will make additional investment", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00807-00196869-00197369": "into the home care sector and I've also", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00808-00197370-00197681": "said that we will look at reforming the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00809-00197682-00197836": "home care sector because that's what the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00810-00197837-00198013": "Royal Commission report said we should", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00811-00198014-00198534": "do so we will be doing that cause they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00812-00198535-00198793": "Senator Cannella direct relevance the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00813-00198794-00199000": "ministers been speaking for 30 seconds", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00814-00199001-00199195": "he has less than that time left the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00815-00199196-00199372": "question was very specific what urgent", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00816-00199373-00199483": "support will be delivered before", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00817-00199484-00199693": "Christmas either he can answer it or he", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00818-00199694-00200074": "can't he hasn't done that yet I think", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00819-00200075-00200281": "I'm listening very carefully to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00820-00200282-00200610": "minister's answer I you have restated", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00821-00200611-00200875": "the end of the question I believe the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00822-00200876-00201178": "minister is talking about the issues", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00823-00201179-00201310": "that are directly relevant to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00824-00201311-00201484": "question I can't instruct him how to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00825-00201485-00201655": "answer a question but he is specifically", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00826-00201656-00201844": "talking about the issue one of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00827-00201845-00202039": "issues is supported that you you raised", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00828-00202040-00202273": "there is an opportunity after question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00829-00202274-00202396": "time to debate the merits of a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00830-00202397-00202669": "minister's answer senator clapping Thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00831-00202670-00202762": "You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00832-00202763-00203068": "Thank You mr. president as I as I was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00833-00203069-00203281": "saying we have said quite clearly that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00834-00203282-00203458": "we'll make additional investment into", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00835-00203459-00203650": "the aged care sector prior to Christmas", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00836-00203651-00203820": "and we will make some specific", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00837-00203821-00204229": "announcements in alignment with my fo", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00838-00204230-00204445": "order after we've been through our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00839-00204446-00204709": "proper process of government that's what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00840-00204710-00204981": "we will do and Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00841-00204982-00205192": "senator Kay Neeley a final supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00842-00205192-00205333": "question thank you I know the minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00843-00205334-00205483": "said there will be announcements before", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00844-00205484-00205759": "Christmas we will watch chief executive", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00845-00205760-00205951": "of leading-edge services Australia Sean", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00846-00205952-00206230": "Rooney says that and I quote if there is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00847-00206231-00206440": "no action from the government on this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00848-00206441-00206694": "there is a risk of missed care and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00849-00206696-00206911": "threat of service failure and closure", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00850-00206912-00207267": "after six years in government when will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00851-00207269-00207550": "the coalition finally take action to fix", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00852-00207551-00207805": "a broken age care system that's leaving", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00853-00207806-00208032": "older Australians at risk", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00854-00208033-00208387": "senator Kovac mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00855-00208388-00208639": "we are clearly taking action and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00856-00208640-00208848": "recalling of the Royal Commission was a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00857-00208850-00209089": "part of that process because what we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00858-00209090-00209202": "wanted was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00859-00209203-00209679": "an industry-wide author left of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00860-00209680-00209940": "aged-care sector so that they could then", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00861-00209941-00210102": "come back to us and make recommendations", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00862-00210103-00210446": "to us on how the aged-care sector should", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00863-00210448-00210717": "look in the future if Senator connealy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00864-00210717-00210984": "had read the report she would see in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00865-00210985-00211413": "report that it calls for action in three", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00866-00211414-00211619": "areas which we've said we will in the we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00867-00211621-00211869": "will take but it also says it doesn't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00868-00211869-00212136": "want to be working and working on a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00869-00212137-00212379": "moving target so it cautions about what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00870-00212380-00212640": "actions were taking what areas as part", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00871-00212641-00212931": "of our process is moving forward but mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00872-00212932-00213300": "president orders have already taken what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00873-00213301-00213633": "we would hope we've taken already is new", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00874-00213634-00214042": "age care regulations new regulations or", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00875-00214044-00214503": "new resident faith order Senator Kohl", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00876-00214504-00214760": "Bev time the answer has expired", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00877-00214761-00215096": "senator McDonald my question is to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00878-00215098-00215259": "Minister representing the Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00879-00215260-00215442": "natural disasters and emergency", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00880-00215442-00215502": "management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00881-00215503-00215709": "senator Mackenzie can the minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00882-00215710-00215873": "please provide an update on the bush", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00883-00215875-00216078": "fires in New South Wales in Queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00884-00216079-00216323": "the Minister for natural disaster and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00885-00216325-00216453": "emergency management so administer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00886-00216454-00216594": "representing the Minister for natural", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00887-00216594-00216744": "disaster emergency management senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00888-00216744-00216912": "Mackenzie Thank You mr. president and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00889-00216913-00217080": "thank you senator MacDonald for your", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00890-00217081-00217244": "question I know we're all very concerned", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00891-00217246-00217448": "here today about the devastating bush", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00892-00217450-00217659": "fires burning across New South Wales and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00893-00217660-00217919": "Queensland our first concern is for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00894-00217921-00218106": "safety and well-being of those directly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00895-00218107-00218364": "affected and like Senator Reynolds I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00896-00218365-00218610": "would also like to pay tribute to our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00897-00218611-00218838": "emergency service workers the RFS the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00898-00218839-00219060": "SES who risk their lives to protect", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00899-00219061-00219264": "others and of course to those who've", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00900-00219265-00219600": "lost loved ones and home as of 1 a 1", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00901-00219601-00219927": "p.m. today all fires nationwide are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00902-00219928-00220098": "burning at the watch and act level or", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00903-00220098-00220287": "below catastrophic fire danger", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00904-00220288-00220494": "conditions are forecast for parts of New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00905-00220494-00220710": "South Wales including the greater hunter", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00906-00220711-00220896": "greater Sydney and Illawarra Shoalhaven", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00907-00220896-00221166": "for today this is the first time since", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00908-00221167-00221367": "the new fire danger ratings were", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00909-00221367-00221604": "introduced in 2009 that catastrophic", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00910-00221605-00221814": "fire danger has been forecast for Sydney", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00911-00221815-00222051": "very high to severe fire dangers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00912-00222052-00222323": "continue on Wednesday the 13th over", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00913-00222325-00222514": "northeast New South Wales and south", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00914-00222515-00222723": "Queensland with a risk of dry lightning", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00915-00222724-00222957": "exacerbating the danger the South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00916-00222958-00223117": "Westerley changed moves through", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00917-00223117-00223321": "southeast Queensland and severe fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00918-00223321-00223530": "dangers of forecast for southeast", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00919-00223531-00223701": "Queensland and the Northern Tablelands", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00920-00223702-00223956": "of New South Wales very high fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00921-00223957-00224154": "dangers are forecast elsewhere over", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00922-00224155-00224423": "central and northeast New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00923-00224424-00224634": "unfortunately no rainfall is expected", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00924-00224635-00224853": "for the northeast of New South Wales in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00925-00224854-00225048": "southeast Queensland over the next seven", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00926-00225049-00225316": "days as we know tragically three people", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00927-00225317-00225477": "have lost their lives and our thoughts", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00928-00225478-00225606": "are with their families and loved ones", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00929-00225607-00225744": "at this difficult time", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00930-00225746-00225924": "more than 30 people have been injured", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00931-00225925-00226182": "including around 20 firefighters the New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00932-00226183-00226377": "South Wales fire fight fires have had a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00933-00226378-00226569": "devastating impact on many affected", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00934-00226571-00226765": "communities with a hundred and fifty", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00935-00226766-00227076": "structures destroyed 96 confirmed other", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00936-00227077-00227198": "property damage includes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00937-00227199-00227424": "telecommunications power infrastructure", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00938-00227425-00227655": "bridges and to schools evacuation", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00939-00227656-00227805": "centers have been established to support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00940-00227806-00227976": "fire effective communities and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00941-00227977-00228234": "commencing yesterday the New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00942-00228235-00228394": "premier declared a state of emergency", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00943-00228394-00228657": "for the whole state for seven days more", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00944-00228658-00228846": "than 1300 five fighters and support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00945-00228848-00229305": "personnel the supplementary question can", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00946-00229306-00229471": "the minister outlined to the Senate the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00947-00229471-00229680": "types of assistance that's available to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00948-00229681-00230025": "those impacted senator Mackenzie Thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00949-00230026-00230124": "You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00950-00230125-00230277": "well fires continue to threaten lives", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00951-00230278-00230517": "and properties overnight particularly on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00952-00230519-00230703": "the Sunshine Coast and it comperable", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00953-00230704-00230994": "we're west of your poun quite close to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00954-00230996-00231190": "where senator Canavan lives and Lou", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00955-00231191-00231534": "O'Brien's election near Luke the New Sun", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00956-00231535-00231759": "disaster recovery assistance is now", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00957-00231760-00231988": "being provided under the disaster", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00958-00231989-00232144": "recovery funding arrangements that we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00959-00232144-00232335": "have with the states in response to New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00960-00232336-00232588": "South Wales that assistance is available", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00961-00232589-00232779": "for the Mid North Coast bushfires for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00962-00232780-00232902": "local governments in Coffs Harbour", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00963-00232903-00233146": "Kempsey Mid Coast nan Bukka Port", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00964-00233146-00233346": "Macquarie in Hastings the northern New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00965-00233348-00233496": "South Wales bush fires", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00966-00233498-00233689": "Armidale Clarence Valley Glen Innes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00967-00233690-00233967": "welker a range of assistance including", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00968-00233969-00234135": "support for people's suffering personal", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00969-00234136-00234297": "hardship concessional interest rate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00970-00234298-00234514": "loans freight subsidies for primary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00971-00234515-00234694": "producers grants to eligible", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00972-00234694-00234948": "non-for-profit organization support for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00973-00234949-00235171": "affected local councils and funding to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00974-00235171-00235374": "cover counter disaster operation costs", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00975-00235375-00235623": "including firefighting activities this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00976-00235624-00235708": "assistance is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00977-00235709-00235825": "administered by the New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00978-00235826-00236041": "government and anyone in need can", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00979-00236042-00236271": "contact after senator McKenzie senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00980-00236273-00236404": "McDonald the final supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00981-00236405-00236611": "question can the Minister advise how", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00982-00236612-00236767": "Australians can best prepare themselves", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00983-00236767-00236994": "for the current bushfire situation and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00984-00236996-00237100": "into the future", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00985-00237101-00237369": "senator Mackenzie well thank you senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00986-00237371-00237760": "MacDonald Queensland also is a recipient", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00987-00237761-00238069": "of the DRF a response and they'll be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00988-00238069-00238189": "able to contact the queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00989-00238190-00238336": "government who'll be administering that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00990-00238337-00238540": "in terms of being prepared for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00991-00238541-00238735": "situation such as these devastating fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00992-00238736-00238960": "requires a collaboration between all", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00993-00238961-00239212": "levels of government australians know", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00994-00239213-00239344": "the importance of preparing for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00995-00239344-00239551": "bushfire season especially those who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00996-00239552-00239800": "live in or near bushland and our farmers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00997-00239801-00240076": "in particular are very aware of having", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00998-00240077-00240321": "bushfire plans in place but I think", "OpTuHbwQF_8-00999-00240323-00240508": "these fires have shown that it's just", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01000-00240509-00240664": "not those that live in and around", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01001-00240665-00240867": "bushland that need to ensure they've got", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01002-00240869-00241182": "an active fire plan in in place", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01003-00241183-00241408": "practically speaking anyone who lives in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01004-00241409-00241666": "a high-risk area needs to have that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01005-00241667-00241888": "bushfire plan in place that means", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01006-00241889-00242098": "clearing vegetation around buildings and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01007-00242098-00242350": "fences clearing your driveways your", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01008-00242351-00242598": "gatherings etc some advice is to turn", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01009-00242600-00242905": "off electric fences and always pay", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01010-00242906-00243079": "attention to the emergency service", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01011-00243080-00243358": "providers and act and leave when they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01012-00243359-00243564": "give you that advice Senator Lambie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01013-00243565-00243760": "Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01014-00243761-00243904": "my question is for the senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01015-00243905-00244066": "representing the Attorney General", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01016-00244067-00244315": "apparently nearly 2,400 people have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01017-00244316-00244561": "direct direct access to Parliament House", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01018-00244562-00244882": "with a sponsored security pass getting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01019-00244883-00245086": "one of these so called orange passes is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01020-00245087-00245359": "a huge windfall obvious it lets them", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01021-00245360-00245500": "wander wander around the halls of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01022-00245501-00245692": "Parliament house without an escort it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01023-00245692-00245848": "gives them a chance to bump into", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01024-00245848-00246178": "ministers at Ozzy's cafe or drop in to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01025-00246179-00246508": "see MPs or senators in their offices but", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01026-00246509-00246706": "Australians much to their disgrace are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01027-00246707-00246883": "in the dark about who these orange pass", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01028-00246884-00247081": "holders are whose interests I represent", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01029-00247082-00247405": "and what they're actually doing here why", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01030-00247406-00247633": "can't why can't they know the people of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01031-00247634-00247879": "Australia know the details of who they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01032-00247880-00247927": "are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01033-00247928-00248148": "why is there no transparency over who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01034-00248150-00248321": "has direct sex", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01035-00248321-00248564": "to federal politicians inside Parliament", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01036-00248565-00248810": "House Minister representing the Attorney", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01037-00248811-00249338": "General senator Paine senator Lambie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01038-00249339-00249556": "thank you very much for your question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01039-00249557-00249867": "my understanding is such matters as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01040-00249869-00250082": "access to Parliament House and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01041-00250083-00250246": "issuing of passes it's a matter for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01042-00250248-00250352": "Department of parliamentary services", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01043-00250353-00250550": "which is of course administered by the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01044-00250551-00250798": "president and the speaker if the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01045-00250800-00251075": "president wishes to provide a response", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01046-00251076-00251408": "in meet by me taking this on notice or", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01047-00251409-00251644": "which is just provide a response now mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01048-00251646-00251896": "president of course then I would defer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01049-00251898-00252152": "entirely to the president senator Lambie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01050-00252153-00252410": "I won't take up question time by adding", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01051-00252411-00252614": "now it has been covered in estimates", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01052-00252615-00252779": "there is an estimate spillover where I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01053-00252780-00252923": "could be quizzed later this week senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01054-00252923-00253103": "Lambie or you're also of course at", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01055-00253104-00253286": "liberty to quiz me in the chamber at any", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01056-00253287-00253478": "point as well but I won't take up any", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01057-00253479-00253628": "more question time by adding to what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01058-00253629-00253934": "I've said on the record yet there are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01059-00253935-00254159": "the opportunities for you to ask myself", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01060-00254160-00254276": "on behalf of the parliamentary services", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01061-00254277-00254498": "department in the future that I'll call", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01062-00254498-00254678": "you to ask a supplementary question if", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01063-00254679-00255131": "you wish so I have to be honest mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01064-00255132-00255236": "president it shouldn't be that difficult", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01065-00255237-00255496": "I mean we have just on 600 people on the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01066-00255498-00255721": "lobbyist register and I'm sure you've", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01067-00255723-00255867": "noticed that that means there's 800", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01068-00255869-00256123": "lobbyists that are slipping under the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01069-00256125-00256171": "radar", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01070-00256171-00256565": "so does mops or yourself intend to do", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01071-00256566-00256754": "something about this in the future and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01072-00256755-00256979": "actually changed the regulations so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01073-00256980-00257135": "they're up to scratch I mean even New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01074-00257136-00257375": "Zealand has nothing to fear and they're", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01075-00257376-00257606": "doing it so if the Kiwis can do it I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01076-00257607-00257825": "just would like to know why we can't be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01077-00257826-00257963": "honest to the Australian people and show", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01078-00257964-00258298": "them who's on the list um if the Senate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01079-00258300-00258446": "is happy I can take this as a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01080-00258446-00258878": "supplementary question to myself I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01081-00258879-00259111": "if he's leave granted senator Lambie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01082-00259112-00259369": "there's I'm happy to forward to your", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01083-00259371-00259604": "office lengthy discussions and handsets", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01084-00259605-00259766": "to provide the context but in the end", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01085-00259767-00259931": "the lobbyists register is not the same", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01086-00259932-00260150": "as the register the sponsor passes there", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01087-00260151-00260369": "is some crossover the lobbyists register", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01088-00260369-00260516": "which is administered by the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01089-00260517-00260654": "not by the Department of parliamentary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01090-00260655-00260882": "services as has been a subject of debate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01091-00260883-00261125": "refers to lobbyists to lobby on behalf", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01092-00261126-00261401": "of paid clients the sponsored passes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01093-00261402-00261704": "include people who are representing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01094-00261705-00262040": "community groups and other NGOs people", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01095-00262041-00262202": "who are not paid lobbyists nor are they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01096-00262203-00262376": "necessarily lobbyists in the employ of a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01097-00262377-00262577": "single firm as you know government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01098-00262578-00262778": "affairs managers and the like I'm happy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01099-00262779-00262973": "to provide you with the hand side of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01100-00262974-00263192": "previous discussion before Thursday so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01101-00263193-00263339": "you have an opportunity to quiz me at", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01102-00263340-00263522": "the estimates spillover if you wish or", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01103-00263523-00263747": "to raise it again in the chamber senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01104-00263748-00263804": "Paine", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01105-00263805-00263969": "I made one leave very briefly in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01106-00263970-00264113": "response to Senator lambie's question I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01107-00264114-00264452": "recognize this is unorthodox but if", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01108-00264453-00264644": "there is further information that the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01109-00264645-00264872": "Attorney General is able to provide in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01110-00264873-00265037": "relation to your question as it relates", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01111-00265038-00265268": "to the register then I will take that on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01112-00265269-00265508": "notice and seek to obtain response from", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01113-00265509-00265736": "the Attorney General the final", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01114-00265737-00265970": "supplementary Senator Lambie Thank You", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01115-00265971-00266201": "mr. president I think I think everyone", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01116-00266202-00266369": "needs to realize here that Australians", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01117-00266370-00266492": "know there's pretty strange stuff going", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01118-00266493-00266660": "on up here when it comes to lobbyists in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01119-00266661-00266951": "these passes and it's about time in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01120-00266952-00267119": "name of democracy in this country well", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01121-00267120-00267359": "what open it honest of who was getting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01122-00267360-00267515": "these passes exactly what they were", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01123-00267516-00267614": "doing up here", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01124-00267615-00267956": "and honestly the only the the only", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01125-00267957-00268256": "people and what bothers Australians more", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01126-00268257-00268361": "than anything is how many of these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01127-00268362-00268517": "lobbyists are coming in and actually", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01128-00268518-00268688": "giving out political donations at the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01129-00268689-00268847": "same time and that's where the problem", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01130-00268848-00269243": "is on I don't have anything to add to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01131-00269244-00269393": "what I said earlier senator Lambie I'm", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01132-00269394-00269522": "happy to provide the information on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01133-00269523-00269657": "notice and you can pursue it with me", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01134-00269658-00269903": "publicly here or in committee or", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01135-00269904-00270128": "privately to senator Paine you don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01136-00270129-00270236": "have anything further to add", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01137-00270237-00270443": "I will then move to senator Farrell", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01138-00270444-00270581": "Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01139-00270582-00270794": "my question is to the Minister for sport", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01140-00270795-00271097": "senator Colbert prior to the election", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01141-00271098-00271469": "Sports Australia CEO Kate Palmer twice", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01142-00271470-00271688": "stated that senator Mackenzie as Sports", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01143-00271689-00271931": "Minister had only awarded community", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01144-00271932-00272192": "sports infrastructure grants to projects", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01145-00272193-00272486": "recommended by sports Australia then", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01146-00272487-00272744": "only three days before the election mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01147-00272745-00272935": "parmitt changed her position stating", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01148-00272936-00273236": "some projects from the eligible pool of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01149-00273237-00273440": "applicants that were preferred by the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01150-00273441-00273866": "Minister were approved by her how many", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01151-00273867-00274163": "how many times did senator Mackenzie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01152-00274164-00274451": "approved taxpayer money for her", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01153-00274452-00274754": "personally preferred projects against", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01154-00274755-00275068": "the recommendation of sports Australia", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01155-00275069-00275618": "Minister the Minister order on my left I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01156-00275619-00275810": "will call the minister when I can hear", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01157-00275811-00276032": "him the Minister for youth in sport", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01158-00276033-00276184": "senator Kovac Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01159-00276185-00276794": "mr. president or Die senator what mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01160-00276795-00277040": "president the government invested 100", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01161-00277041-00277352": "and 2.5 million dollars in the community", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01162-00277353-00277532": "sport infrastructure and program and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01163-00277533-00278123": "delivered 648 projects building better", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01164-00278124-00278372": "sporting facilities for healthier and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01165-00278373-00278513": "stronger communities by promoting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01166-00278514-00278740": "physical activity and social connection", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01167-00278741-00279026": "these grants are enabling people from", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01168-00279027-00279284": "right across the country to get more", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01169-00279285-00279641": "active order more often projects include", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01170-00279642-00279809": "upgrades to female change room", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01171-00279810-00280022": "facilities lighting upgrades for local", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01172-00280023-00280268": "sporting clubs and surface upgrades to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01173-00280269-00280585": "ensure a safer and sporting environment", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01174-00280586-00281069": "mr. president over 2050 applications", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01175-00281070-00281309": "totaling nearly 400 million dollars were", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01176-00281310-00281654": "made to the program which has seen 204", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01177-00281655-00281906": "24 projects funded as round part of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01178-00281907-00282392": "round one 232 projects founded as Lord", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01179-00282393-00282662": "out of two molbeck senator Farrell on a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01180-00282663-00283013": "point of order yes mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01181-00283014-00283475": "it's in relation to relevance and we've", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01182-00283476-00283664": "heard about all of these projects the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01183-00283665-00284129": "government is funding but my question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01184-00284130-00284375": "was quite specifically quite specific", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01185-00284376-00284633": "how many times did Senator McKenzie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01186-00284634-00284966": "approved taxpayer money for projects", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01187-00284967-00285227": "against the recommendations of sports", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01188-00285228-00285413": "Australia I don't want to know which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01189-00285414-00285535": "projects the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01190-00285536-00285706": "portant I want to know the ones they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01191-00285707-00286033": "rejected against the evidence and advice", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01192-00286034-00286315": "of sports Australia I accept the sub", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01193-00286316-00286840": "order I'll make a ruling when they're", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01194-00286841-00287374": "silence I will we're using up time in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01195-00287375-00288196": "question time with noise on my left is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01196-00288197-00288391": "there going to be silence to allow me to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01197-00288392-00288796": "make a ruling on on the point of order I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01198-00288797-00289009": "accept the substance of the question was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01199-00289010-00289492": "about ministerial action and ministerial", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01200-00289493-00289690": "decision not the program generally I'm", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01201-00289691-00289849": "listening carefully to the minister who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01202-00289850-00290047": "has 57 seconds remaining to answer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01203-00290048-00290470": "senator Colbeck Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01204-00290471-00290746": "as I said there were 232 projects funded", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01205-00290747-00291181": "as part of round 2 and 228 projects", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01206-00291182-00291529": "funded as part of round 3 mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01207-00291530-00291859": "each application was individually", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01208-00291860-00292098": "assessed using criteria including", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01209-00292099-00292366": "community participation community need", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01210-00292367-00292704": "and project design and delivery", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01211-00292705-00292903": "recommendations were then provided to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01212-00292904-00293170": "the Minister for sport who was the grant", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01213-00293171-00293607": "delegate for final decision and approval", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01214-00293608-00293946": "senator Farrell a supplementary question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01215-00293947-00294157": "Thank You mr. president I do have the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01216-00294158-00294433": "further row supplementary question over", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01217-00294434-00294715": "three rounds of this program 684", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01218-00294716-00294895": "successful applications have been", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01219-00294896-00295126": "awarded funding according to the sports", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01220-00295127-00295510": "Australia website how many of these 684", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01221-00295511-00295756": "successful applicants were personally", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01222-00295757-00296038": "selected by Senator Mackenzie against", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01223-00296039-00296254": "the advice of sports Australia and on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01224-00296255-00296559": "what basis were those decisions made", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01225-00296560-00296806": "senator Kohl Becker mr. president as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01226-00296807-00297175": "I've just said senator Mackenzie as the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01227-00297176-00297334": "then Minister was the delegate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01228-00297335-00297559": "responsible for approving every project", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01229-00297560-00297751": "that was so wrong that was so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01230-00297752-00297900": "responsibility", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01231-00297901-00298158": "or what so mr. president Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01232-00298159-00298347": "Mackenzie was responsible for approving", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01233-00298348-00298677": "every single project each one of which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01234-00298678-00298923": "mr. president met the guidelines of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01235-00298924-00298995": "program", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01236-00298996-00299277": "so it's it's really quite simple mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01237-00299278-00299532": "president there were over 2,000", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01238-00299533-00299772": "applications totaling nearly 400 million", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01239-00299773-00300009": "dollars the project program was very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01240-00300010-00300351": "very popular very popular the extent", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01241-00300352-00300551": "that we ran three rounds of the program", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01242-00300552-00300819": "before the election and Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01243-00300820-00301068": "Mackenzie as the responsible delegate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01244-00301069-00301356": "made the decisions on which projects", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01245-00301357-00301610": "were approved senator Farrell final", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01246-00301611-00301803": "supplementary question Thank You mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01247-00301804-00302013": "president I do have one in evidence", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01248-00302014-00302199": "before Senate estimates it was revealed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01249-00302200-00302592": "that 618 recommended applications were", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01250-00302593-00302922": "rejected by Senator Mackenzie how many", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01251-00302923-00303207": "of these 618 eligible grassroots", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01252-00303208-00303423": "projects would have received local", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01253-00303424-00303669": "funding if Senator Mackenzie had not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01254-00303670-00304009": "intervened and hand-picked her favorites", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01255-00304010-00304353": "senator Kovac mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01256-00304354-00304602": "as I've said in answers to previous", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01257-00304603-00304941": "questions Minister Mackenzie as the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01258-00304942-00305226": "delegate was responsible for your final", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01259-00305227-00305447": "approval of every project in the program", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01260-00305448-00305817": "the 224 projects that were funded as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01261-00305818-00306108": "part of round one the 232 projects that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01262-00306109-00306366": "were funded as part of round 2 and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01263-00306367-00306633": "228 or without senator farrell on a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01264-00306634-00306888": "powered rota I'm thinking about mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01265-00306889-00307137": "president and again relevant so we're", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01266-00307138-00307404": "not asking about which programs Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01267-00307405-00307644": "McKenzie approved we're asking about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01268-00307645-00307998": "which projects she rejected the advice", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01269-00307999-00308190": "of sports Australia her Department", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01270-00308191-00308391": "Senator Farrell I think with respect", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01271-00308392-00308682": "you're going to how the minister is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01272-00308683-00308883": "answering the question there's an", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01273-00308884-00309015": "opportunity for debating that after", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01274-00309016-00309198": "question time but by talking about the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01275-00309199-00309375": "approval process which may or may not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01276-00309376-00309792": "meet with your approval or wish I think", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01277-00309793-00309924": "he is however being directly relevant", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01278-00309925-00310188": "senator Colbeck Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01279-00310189-00310503": "as I said every project that was funded", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01280-00310504-00310797": "under this program was eligible for fan", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01281-00310798-00311043": "under the guidelines Minister McKenzie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01282-00311044-00311322": "as the responsible minister had the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01283-00311323-00311526": "final say and responsibilities with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01284-00311527-00311700": "respect to the approval of the projects", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01285-00311701-00311991": "under each round of the program senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01286-00311992-00312345": "Stoker my question is to the Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01287-00312346-00312606": "for Foreign Affairs senator Paine can", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01288-00312607-00312792": "the Minister please update the Senate on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01289-00312793-00312999": "recent international consultations about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01290-00313000-00313215": "countering terrorism the Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01291-00313216-00313382": "Foreign Affairs senator Paine", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01292-00313383-00313545": "thank you very much mr. president and I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01293-00313546-00313731": "thank senator Stoker for her a question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01294-00313732-00313926": "but mr. president last week Australia", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01295-00313927-00314192": "hosted the second no money for Terror", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01296-00314193-00314388": "International Conference and I want to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01297-00314389-00314592": "acknowledge and thank France for their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01298-00314593-00314805": "leadership in convening the first of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01299-00314806-00315027": "no money for terror conferences in 2018", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01300-00315028-00315291": "and indeed knowledge India for offering", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01301-00315292-00315564": "to host next year's conference I also", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01302-00315565-00315707": "want to acknowledge mr. Dutton and Home", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01303-00315708-00315939": "Affairs for their work in convening the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01304-00315940-00316109": "Melbourne meeting the goal of these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01305-00316110-00316331": "conferences mr. president is to work", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01306-00316332-00316569": "across international boundaries to close", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01307-00316570-00316907": "loopholes for terrorist financing we had", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01308-00316908-00317115": "some 81 delegations attending the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01309-00317116-00317328": "Melbourne meeting representing 67", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01310-00317329-00317523": "countries and jurisdictions as well as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01311-00317524-00317745": "14 international organizations and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01312-00317746-00317970": "almost 20 of those delegations were led", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01313-00317971-00318141": "by ministers or minister equivalents", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01314-00318142-00318369": "both the Minister for Home Affairs the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01315-00318370-00318530": "Attorney General and Iran sessions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01316-00318531-00318683": "during the conference which are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01317-00318684-00318879": "important opportunities for Australia to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01318-00318880-00319155": "engage and lead on these issues we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01319-00319156-00319326": "discussed the international and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01320-00319327-00319590": "regional threat environment global", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01321-00319591-00319803": "responses to kidnap for terrorism of a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01322-00319804-00320001": "ransom I'm sorry and the effect of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01323-00320002-00320210": "emerging technologies on terrorism", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01324-00320211-00320514": "financing risks we also considered how", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01325-00320515-00320679": "we can enhance public/private", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01326-00320680-00320955": "partnerships in the context of the no", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01327-00320956-00321158": "money for terror theme mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01328-00321159-00321359": "because the engagement of the private", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01329-00321360-00321621": "sector is obviously pivotal in terms of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01330-00321622-00321806": "the movement of money and how we can", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01331-00321807-00322029": "take a collective security approach to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01332-00322030-00322179": "preventing the exploitation of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01333-00322180-00322353": "not-for-profit organizations for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01334-00322354-00322614": "terrorism purposes indeed the private", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01335-00322615-00322757": "sector was well represented on the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01336-00322758-00322974": "second day of the of the event in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01337-00322975-00323112": "recognition of the fact that in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01338-00323113-00323355": "countering terrorism and making sure our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01339-00323356-00323544": "civil society organizations are not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01340-00323545-00323763": "exploited by terrorists it has to be a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01341-00323764-00324039": "whole of community undertaking we know", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01342-00324040-00324252": "that governments can't defeat terrorism", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01343-00324253-00324489": "nor their support networks by acting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01344-00324490-00324557": "alone", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01345-00324558-00324828": "we need a whole of society approach if", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01346-00324829-00325002": "we're to achieve collective security and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01347-00325003-00325251": "that was the approach taken during the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01348-00325252-00325593": "no money for terror conference senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01349-00325594-00325797": "Stoker a supplementary question Thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01350-00325798-00325883": "You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01351-00325884-00326148": "can the Minister please advise of what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01352-00326149-00326376": "particular concerns Australia has about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01353-00326377-00326517": "the way the terrorists fund their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01354-00326518-00326820": "operations senator Paine mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01355-00326821-00326994": "as part of our commitment to combatting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01356-00326995-00327174": "terrorism the Australian Government has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01357-00327175-00327366": "a long-standing policy across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01358-00327367-00327669": "governments that it does not pay ransoms", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01359-00327670-00327966": "daesh accrued up to forty five million", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01360-00327967-00328208": "dollars u.s. from kidnappings between", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01361-00328209-00328606": "September 2013 and September 2014 alone", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01362-00328607-00328896": "kidnapping contributed about us 89", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01363-00328897-00329135": "million dollars into the al-qaida war", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01364-00329136-00329432": "chest between 2013 and 2017", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01365-00329433-00329697": "it's important to note that as ransom", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01366-00329698-00329868": "has have been paid more frequently so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01367-00329869-00330213": "the ransom price has gone up in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01368-00330214-00330431": "early 2000s we saw payment demanded for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01369-00330432-00330600": "hostages in the tens of thousands of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01370-00330601-00330822": "dollars now it's as much as five million", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01371-00330823-00331064": "dollars per case kidnap for ransom", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01372-00331065-00331385": "unfortunately is a an important and a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01373-00331386-00331685": "reliable literal revenue stream for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01374-00331686-00331890": "terrorist groups which we are determined", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01375-00331891-00332163": "to disrupt in the kidnap for ransom", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01376-00332164-00332367": "section both the french foreign minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01377-00332368-00332613": "jean-yves le drian new zealand justice", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01378-00332614-00332888": "minister Andrew little and the UN cted", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01379-00332889-00333150": "director stork onyx Kinshasa to answers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01380-00333151-00333300": "expired senator Stoker a final", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01381-00333301-00333455": "supplementary question Thank You mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01382-00333456-00333504": "president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01383-00333505-00333768": "can the minister advise on the future", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01384-00333769-00333972": "steps to take towards countering", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01385-00333973-00334235": "terrorism senator Paine just briefly mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01386-00334236-00334563": "president I can advise that in in 2019", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01387-00334564-00334907": "the UN the g20 the ASEAN Regional Forum", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01388-00334908-00335100": "have all sought to focus attention on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01389-00335101-00335367": "the link between ransoms and terrorism", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01390-00335368-00335619": "in fact UN Security Council resolution", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01391-00335620-00335940": "21 33 specifically calls on and I quote", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01392-00335941-00336162": "member states to prevent terrorists from", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01393-00336163-00336380": "benefitting directly or indirectly from", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01394-00336381-00336632": "ransom payments or political concessions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01395-00336633-00336792": "to secure the safe relief", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01396-00336793-00337086": "of hostages release of hostages mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01397-00337087-00337290": "president they UN Security Council", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01398-00337291-00337616": "resolution gives a foundation upon which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01399-00337617-00337821": "actions from the no money for terror", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01400-00337822-00338019": "conference can be pursued and will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01401-00338020-00338166": "continue to work with other countries", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01402-00338167-00338406": "towards a common approach to kidnap for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01403-00338407-00338934": "ransom yeah senator calico in this to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01404-00338935-00339087": "the minister representing the prime", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01405-00339088-00339372": "minister senator Corman in an article in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01406-00339373-00339536": "yesterday's Australian Financial Review", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01407-00339537-00339906": "entitled first home buyer risk Royals", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01408-00339907-00340218": "banks it is revealed that big banks want", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01409-00340219-00340440": "to charge higher interest rates under", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01410-00340441-00340656": "the Morison government's first home", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01411-00340657-00340983": "first home loan and deposit scheme can", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01412-00340984-00341142": "the government guarantee that borrowers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01413-00341143-00341394": "who used the first home loan deposit", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01414-00341395-00341652": "scheme will not be charged a higher rate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01415-00341653-00341880": "of interest minister representing the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01416-00341881-00342141": "prime minister senator Corman thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01417-00342142-00342570": "very much mr. president I can reassure", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01418-00342571-00342774": "senator Gallagher that loan pricing is a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01419-00342775-00342972": "key evaluation criteria the National", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01420-00342973-00343200": "Housing Finance & Investment Corporation", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01421-00343201-00343446": "will consider in selecting the scheme's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01422-00343447-00343617": "panel of lenders a number of lenders", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01423-00343618-00343872": "including small lenders have already", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01424-00343873-00344055": "indicated through the market sounding", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01425-00344056-00344187": "process they are prepared to offer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01426-00344188-00344397": "products under the scheme that do not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01427-00344398-00344631": "charge first home buyers more and that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01428-00344632-00344973": "is what we want to say in approving", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01429-00344974-00345138": "lenders for participation in this scheme", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01430-00345139-00345357": "the National Housing Finance &", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01431-00345358-00345498": "Investment Corporation will assess", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01432-00345499-00345720": "impacts on competition as well as the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01433-00345721-00345897": "attractiveness of each lenders loan", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01434-00345898-00346089": "products in terms of interest rates and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01435-00346090-00346329": "fees lenders participating in the scheme", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01436-00346330-00346655": "will continue to be subject to existing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01437-00346656-00346881": "responsible ending obligations including", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01438-00346882-00347094": "ensuring that loans are only extended to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01439-00347095-00347295": "borrowers that can comfortably service", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01440-00347296-00347523": "that longer Senator Gallagher", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01441-00347524-00347721": "supplementary question Thank You mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01442-00347722-00347778": "president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01443-00347779-00348105": "how will these measures that the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01444-00348106-00348398": "government undertake actually ensure", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01445-00348399-00348774": "that no user is charged a higher rate of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01446-00348775-00349098": "interest senator Corman well I thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01447-00349099-00349254": "very much sir mr. president I've just", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01448-00349255-00349677": "provided that information to Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01449-00349678-00349730": "Gallagher", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01450-00349731-00349973": "the first home loan deposit scheme is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01451-00349974-00350087": "administered through the National", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01452-00350088-00350338": "Housing Finance Investment Corporation", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01453-00350339-00350606": "which of course has gone through a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01454-00350607-00350840": "market sounding process and it's very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01455-00350841-00351179": "clear from their process that's not that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01456-00351180-00351464": "there are offers available product", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01457-00351465-00351599": "offers available under the scheme that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01458-00351600-00351839": "do not charge first homebuyers mortgages", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01459-00351840-00352097": "what we want to say I would also of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01460-00352098-00352460": "course make the point that the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01461-00352461-00352646": "government made a commitment in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01462-00352647-00352814": "lead-up to the election to this scheme", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01463-00352815-00353045": "which we now delivering the scheme is to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01464-00353046-00353156": "be administered as I've indicated", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01465-00353157-00353312": "through the National Housing Finance", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01466-00353313-00353510": "Investment Corporation which will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01467-00353511-00353687": "partner with lenders to deliver the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01468-00353688-00354074": "scheme NH if ICS commenced the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01469-00354075-00354233": "procurement process to establish an", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01470-00354234-00354428": "initial panel of lenders the panel will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01471-00354429-00354617": "have no more than two of the four major", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01472-00354618-00354836": "banks and is designed to meet the gums", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01473-00354837-00355001": "expectations that smaller lenders will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01474-00355002-00355276": "play a significant role in scheme", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01475-00355277-00355466": "delicate the final supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01476-00355467-00355721": "question thanks mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01477-00355722-00355988": "the article also reveals that big banks", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01478-00355989-00356129": "have queried whether the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01479-00356130-00356381": "scheme will be up and running by the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01480-00356382-00356693": "promise start date of January 1 can the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01481-00356694-00356846": "government guarantee that the scheme", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01482-00356847-00357116": "will be fully operational by the 1st of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01483-00357117-00357458": "January 2020 senator Corman thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01484-00357459-00357605": "very much mr. president the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01485-00357606-00357776": "remains indeed on track to make the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01486-00357777-00358015": "scheme available from 1 January 2020", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01487-00358016-00358781": "Sarah antek oh sorry sorry Sarah woman", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01488-00358782-00358964": "what a chair I think I think the time", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01489-00358965-00359108": "has expired", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01490-00359109-00359408": "it was odd 208 you started senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01491-00359409-00359633": "Coleman I'm sorry senator long it was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01492-00359634-00359834": "208 was my note I'm looking at the clock", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01493-00359835-00360218": "who I think agrees senator antic Thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01494-00360219-00360365": "You mr. president this is a ripping", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01495-00360366-00360512": "question so I thank you for that my", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01496-00360513-00360632": "question is to the Minister for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01497-00360633-00360830": "resources in northern Australia senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01498-00360831-00361052": "can of an can the Minister please update", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01499-00361053-00361253": "the Senate on any recent developments on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01500-00361254-00361409": "the site selection process for a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01501-00361410-00361586": "national radioactive waste management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01502-00361587-00361862": "facility Minister for resources in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01503-00361863-00362009": "northern Australia senator can event", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01504-00362010-00362279": "thank you thank you very much mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01505-00362280-00362456": "president I thank Senator Paul his", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01506-00362457-00362672": "question he would know coming from South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01507-00362673-00362763": "Australia that the guy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01508-00362764-00363027": "is considering a number of sites in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01509-00363028-00363240": "South Australia for the location of a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01510-00363241-00363540": "national radioactive waste facility to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01511-00363541-00363756": "store our waste we've been trying to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01512-00363757-00364008": "find a long-term place to store this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01513-00364009-00364320": "waste for about 40 years it's extremely", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01514-00364321-00364587": "important because the waste that it will", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01515-00364588-00364845": "store comes from production or primarily", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01516-00364846-00364992": "from the production of nuclear medicines", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01517-00364993-00365184": "that we make at Lucas Heights near", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01518-00365185-00365244": "Sydney", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01519-00365245-00365427": "now nuclear medicines has allowed us to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01520-00365428-00365697": "control in some cases killer conditions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01521-00365698-00365871": "like cancer related to our road", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01522-00365872-00366093": "conditions bone pain caused by cancer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01523-00366094-00366321": "and many other medical conditions in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01524-00366322-00366570": "fact on average around 1 in 2", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01525-00366571-00366744": "Australians will require the use of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01526-00366745-00366930": "nuclear medicines during their lifetime", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01527-00366931-00367089": "so it's been very important that we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01528-00367090-00367212": "manage and store this waste", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01529-00367213-00367419": "appropriately currently our radioactive", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01530-00367420-00367578": "waste has spread across about a hundred", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01531-00367579-00367803": "storage facilities is envisaged at a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01532-00367804-00368001": "national radioactive waste management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01533-00368002-00368184": "facility will consolidate this waste", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01534-00368185-00368499": "into a single safe location so as I said", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01535-00368500-00368631": "we are looking at three different", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01536-00368632-00368982": "proposed sites in South Australia - in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01537-00368983-00369246": "near the town of Kimber and one near the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01538-00369247-00369621": "town of hawker just last week a ballot", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01539-00369622-00369801": "was finalised in the community of Kimber", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01540-00369802-00369963": "on whether they would like their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01541-00369964-00370254": "community - to host such a facility and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01542-00370255-00370509": "I it's welcome news to report that over", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01543-00370510-00370668": "90 percent of people in that community", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01544-00370669-00370977": "voted was it was a voluntary vote and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01545-00370978-00371157": "around sixty one and a half percent of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01546-00371158-00371367": "residents supported a facility located", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01547-00371368-00371577": "in there in their community now this is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01548-00371578-00371769": "just one piece of information the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01549-00371770-00371913": "government will consider before making a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01550-00371914-00372120": "decision on any facility there is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01551-00372121-00372282": "another ballot due to occur in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01552-00372283-00372477": "Hawker region that's open this week and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01553-00372478-00372600": "will be concluded before the end of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01554-00372601-00372804": "Christmas but I welcome that level of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01555-00372805-00372969": "community support I particularly thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01556-00372970-00373179": "the entire community of Kimber and also", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01557-00373180-00373335": "those in the Hawker region as well for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01558-00373336-00373497": "their patience and resilience through", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01559-00373498-00373770": "this process as we try to find a place", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01560-00373771-00374010": "to store the life so the waste from the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01561-00374011-00374403": "production antek a supplementary", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01562-00374404-00374631": "question thank you how is the federal", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01563-00374632-00374781": "government supporting communities where", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01564-00374782-00374928": "the site of this facility is being", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01565-00374929-00374976": "considered", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01566-00374977-00375225": "senator Coburn thank you very much mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01567-00375226-00375507": "president and mr. person can I say up", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01568-00375508-00375738": "front that it's been a privilege for me", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01569-00375739-00375858": "to visit these communities multiple", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01570-00375859-00376076": "times through this process they are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01571-00376077-00376346": "kimber at hawker fantastic towns it's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01572-00376347-00376478": "been great to get to know that the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01573-00376479-00376589": "leaders of those communities and many", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01574-00376590-00376838": "others in that in their community and we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01575-00376839-00376982": "have tried to support these towns for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01576-00376983-00377126": "this process I said it has gone on a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01577-00377127-00377330": "while and through that period we have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01578-00377331-00377612": "invested already 5.7 six million dollars", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01579-00377613-00377858": "across 57 projects across Kimber and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01580-00377859-00378035": "Flinders Ranges region to help their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01581-00378036-00378185": "community grow and develop and make", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01582-00378186-00378425": "their broader goals additionally I've", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01583-00378426-00378578": "announced a further for the governor's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01584-00378579-00378724": "announced a further four million dollars", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01585-00378725-00378998": "to provide additional community support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01586-00378999-00379190": "because the Evoque took a little bit", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01587-00379191-00379349": "longer to get to because of a court case", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01588-00379350-00379592": "and mr. president if we ought to proceed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01589-00379593-00379754": "with a facility will will invest", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01590-00379755-00379922": "thirty-one million dollars in in that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01591-00379923-00380102": "community they helped them up skilled to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01592-00380103-00380285": "take the best advantage of this facility", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01593-00380286-00380495": "which will provide 45 local jobs and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01594-00380496-00380759": "lots of benefits to small businesses we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01595-00380760-00380885": "very much hope to partner with the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01596-00380886-00381095": "community help them grow and develop as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01597-00381096-00381293": "well as help solve a national issue for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01598-00381294-00381539": "our entire country senator antic a final", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01599-00381540-00381677": "supplementary question Thank You mr.", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01600-00381678-00381818": "president you know so what are the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01601-00381819-00382022": "benefits of the National radioactive", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01602-00382023-00382166": "waste management facility for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01603-00382167-00382339": "community which decides the hosted", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01604-00382340-00382628": "senator Canavan well thank you mister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01605-00382629-00382889": "person again as I said before in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01606-00382890-00383012": "question you know there are some direct", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01607-00383013-00383246": "benefits for the community it will be a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01608-00383247-00383588": "facility that requires 45 jobs about 20", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01609-00383589-00383779": "to 25 of those jobs will not require any", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01610-00383780-00384035": "skills they'll be on-the-job training so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01611-00384036-00384227": "that will be open obviously to most", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01612-00384228-00384428": "people in any town or community we are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01613-00384429-00384617": "also putting on a table eight million", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01614-00384618-00384803": "dollars to help skilled people in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01615-00384804-00385082": "community to train ahead of the any", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01616-00385083-00385259": "construction or operation of a facility", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01617-00385260-00385448": "to fill the the more skilled jobs as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01618-00385449-00385616": "well to bring skilled jobs to a local", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01619-00385617-00385781": "rural town and one thing I'm very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01620-00385782-00385973": "excited about mr. president if we are to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01621-00385974-00386153": "proceed with a facility at one of these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01622-00386154-00386432": "communities it will link a small country", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01623-00386433-00386633": "town in South Australia with our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01624-00386634-00386789": "world-class nuclear medicine supply", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01625-00386790-00387062": "chain we have already hosted students", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01626-00387063-00387284": "community members at Lucas Heights from", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01627-00387285-00387440": "both of these communities and if we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01628-00387441-00387614": "maintain that relationship over a long", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01629-00387615-00387809": "period of time that will help young", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01630-00387810-00388034": "people in these towns they have been", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01631-00388035-00388229": "exposed to a world-class industry and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01632-00388230-00388448": "maybe pique their interest in going on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01633-00388449-00388616": "to contribute to what is an amazing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01634-00388617-00388748": "industry that we're luckier to have in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01635-00388749-00388895": "this country senator Corman", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01636-00388896-00389054": "I think it was the president asked at", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01637-00389055-00389261": "Pella Christian speed placed on a notice", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01638-00389262-00389334": "paper", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01639-00389335-00389679": "and I also a seek leave to move emotion", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01640-00389680-00389895": "relating to the routine of business for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01641-00389896-00390165": "the remainder of today he's Lee granted", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01642-00390166-00390531": "leave in accord the motion circulated in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01643-00390532-00390774": "my name question is that motion be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01644-00390775-00391065": "agreed to oh sorry", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01645-00391066-00391344": "leave was granted I put on putting I'm", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01646-00391345-00391527": "going to put the motion question is the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01647-00391528-00391704": "motion moved by senator Corman be agreed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01648-00391705-00391869": "to those of that opinion say aye", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01649-00391870-00393900": "contrary no the eyes have it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01650-00393901-00394118": "are there any motions to take note of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01651-00394119-00394343": "answer senator connealy thank you madam", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01652-00394344-00394534": "deputy president I rise BJ Cardin", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01653-00394535-00394726": "senator clearly sorry sorry senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01654-00394727-00395083": "Mackenzie thank you madam deputy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01655-00395084-00395237": "president I took a couple of things on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01656-00395238-00395407": "notice yesterday so I'd just like to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01657-00395408-00395827": "inform the Senate so in response to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01658-00395828-00395966": "Senator Greene regarding the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01659-00395967-00396148": "reallocation of our jet funds in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01660-00396149-00396385": "tropical North Queensland my advice is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01661-00396386-00396550": "the Department of Industry innovation", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01662-00396551-00396709": "and Sciences business grants have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01663-00396710-00396866": "provided the Department of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01664-00396867-00397021": "infrastructure transport cities and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01665-00397022-00397150": "regional development with the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01666-00397151-00397327": "eligibility and merit assessment for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01667-00397328-00397514": "each application the Department of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01668-00397515-00397688": "infrastructure transport cities and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01669-00397689-00397825": "regional development provide its", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01670-00397826-00398023": "recommendation to the ministerial panel", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01671-00398024-00398243": "based on the merit assessments the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01672-00398244-00398395": "ministerial panel considered the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01673-00398396-00398645": "recommendations and made its funding", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01674-00398646-00398888": "decisions the Labor Party claimed there", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01675-00398889-00399103": "is no electoral bias and asked the AMAO", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01676-00399104-00399328": "to look into that specific issue the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01677-00399329-00399547": "AMAO did specifically look at that issue", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01678-00399548-00399784": "and concluded there was no electoral", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01679-00399785-00399955": "bias evident in the assessment and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01680-00399956-00400150": "decision-making process concerning", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01681-00400151-00400388": "funding of projects in our deep regions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01682-00400389-00400544": "far north queensland was not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01683-00400545-00400795": "shortchanged the government recommitted", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01684-00400796-00401039": "funding to other key priority projects", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01685-00401040-00401278": "in the region including the habitat dome", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01686-00401279-00401714": "and the sky rail tourism projects which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01687-00401715-00401949": "the former leader of the Opposition", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01688-00401950-00402242": "visited during the X election campaign", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01689-00402243-00402496": "in response to a question asked by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01690-00402497-00402740": "Senator erkut regarding the cafe project", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01691-00402741-00402982": "on Flinders Island Tasmania I'm advised", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01692-00402983-00403132": "that the reason for the co-funding", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01693-00403133-00403300": "exemption application was the limited", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01694-00403301-00403417": "capacity of this not-for-profit", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01695-00403418-00403678": "organisation to contribute cash funding", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01696-00403679-00403913": "to the project the ministerial panel", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01697-00403914-00404093": "approved the original application for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01698-00404094-00404237": "the cafe and other amenities I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01699-00404238-00404417": "understand the proponent the Flinders", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01700-00404418-00404635": "Island tourism and business incorporated", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01701-00404636-00404891": "sought a change of scope to the project", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01702-00404892-00405097": "as the original concept of a permanent", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01703-00405098-00405320": "facility was now not able to proceed as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01704-00405321-00405520": "the site was sold prior to funding", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01705-00405521-00405682": "approval and they'd not been out of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01706-00405683-00405934": "secured replacement site the request was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01707-00405935-00406187": "made to each of the components cafe and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01708-00406188-00406251": "commercial", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01709-00406252-00406509": "accomodation Community Center individual", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01710-00406510-00406719": "semi-permanent removable units which", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01711-00406720-00406890": "could then be loaded onto a truck to be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01712-00406891-00407106": "transported to island events when and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01713-00407107-00407310": "where required the grant recipient was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01714-00407311-00407475": "also requested to add an amenities", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01715-00407476-00407688": "component to the project the units would", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01716-00407689-00407862": "allow from maximum flexibility to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01717-00407863-00408006": "service the needs of individual events", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01718-00408007-00408183": "and assist in addressing a major", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01719-00408184-00408396": "inhibited for growth at these events on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01720-00408397-00408597": "the island the units would supplement", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01721-00408598-00408756": "the facilities at the Flinders Island", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01722-00408757-00409065": "food and crayfish Festival and the Ferno", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01723-00409066-00409302": "Island festival music in the vines etc", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01724-00409303-00409458": "etc letters of support from the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01725-00409459-00409692": "communities were provided to support the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01726-00409693-00409910": "reefs coped project the Department of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01727-00409912-00410093": "Industry innovation and Sciences oz", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01728-00410095-00410325": "industry grants hub assess the reefs", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01729-00410326-00410592": "coped project in terms of job outcomes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01730-00410593-00410763": "costs and impacts on other business in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01731-00410764-00410982": "the region's and approved the change in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01732-00410983-00411318": "scope and finally I took on behalf of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01733-00411318-00411468": "Minister little proud a question for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01734-00411468-00411705": "Senator Walsh yesterday around moira", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01735-00411706-00412050": "Shire and my advice is that last week", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01736-00412051-00412224": "the government announced that a further", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01737-00412225-00412389": "1 million dollars would be provided to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01738-00412389-00412662": "122 councils which a previously receive", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01739-00412663-00412905": "funding under the DCP extension as well", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01740-00412906-00413088": "as a million dollars for six new", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01741-00413089-00413334": "councils the six new councils all met", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01742-00413335-00413550": "the rainfall deficiency and agricultural", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01743-00413551-00413826": "employment reliance criteria at the end", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01744-00413827-00414005": "of September as part of the normal", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01745-00414006-00414207": "quarterly update the government has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01746-00414208-00414401": "announced a review of the DCP and is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01747-00414402-00414549": "expecting the outcomes of that review", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01748-00414550-00414720": "before January a range of information", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01749-00414721-00414968": "will be considered and that will inform", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01750-00414970-00415289": "the government's the 50 million dollars", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01751-00415291-00415407": "that was announced by the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01752-00415408-00415634": "last week on how that can support", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01753-00415635-00415853": "projects in drought affected LGAs across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01754-00415854-00416088": "the country and any additional councils", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01755-00416089-00416259": "will be announced after the review is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01756-00416260-00416480": "completed the member for Nichols asked", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01757-00416481-00416764": "the Minister for drought to consider", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01758-00416766-00416997": "exercising his discretionary powers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01759-00416997-00417101": "under the guidelines", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01760-00417102-00417251": "the member for Nichols office was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01761-00417252-00417476": "advised the Minister for drought was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01762-00417477-00417726": "considering his request thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01763-00417727-00418047": "Thank You Minister and I had called", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01764-00418047-00418253": "senator connealy to take note about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01765-00418254-00418364": "Senator Cannella", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01766-00418366-00418542": "thank you madam deputy president I rise", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01767-00418543-00418680": "to take note of the answer given by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01768-00418681-00418791": "senator Corman", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01769-00418792-00419099": "to the question asked by Senator Wong", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01770-00419100-00419303": "yesterday the Commissioner of the New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01771-00419304-00419460": "South Wales Rural", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01772-00419460-00419679": "services Shane Fitzsimmons said that we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01773-00419680-00419934": "are currently facing quote the most", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01774-00419935-00420264": "dangerous bushfire week this nation has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01775-00420264-00420600": "ever seen as of this afternoon there are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01776-00420601-00420882": "over 70 fires raging across the state of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01777-00420883-00421143": "New South Wales 40 of those fires are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01778-00421143-00421476": "uncontained ten are at emergency levels", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01779-00421477-00421791": "ten fires are at the watch and act level", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01780-00421792-00422082": "over 600 schools are closed and nine", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01781-00422083-00422364": "have had to be evacuated we know the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01782-00422364-00422516": "conditions this evening have the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01783-00422517-00422670": "potential to turn worse than they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01784-00422671-00422930": "currently are and can develop rapidly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01785-00422931-00423183": "for the first time in our history a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01786-00423184-00423402": "catastrophic fire warning has been", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01787-00423403-00423612": "issued for the greater Sydney area as", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01788-00423613-00423845": "well as the greater hunter Illawarra and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01789-00423846-00424145": "Shoalhaven regions this represents an", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01790-00424146-00424364": "extraordinary threat to life and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01791-00424365-00424677": "property many more fires are threatening", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01792-00424678-00424953": "communities in Queensland and South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01793-00424954-00425295": "Australia madam deputy president bush", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01794-00425296-00425532": "fires are cruel they are a force of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01795-00425533-00425754": "nature that indiscriminately takes life", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01796-00425755-00426099": "and property with them they take part of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01797-00426100-00426539": "our nation's soul the tragic 1993 and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01798-00426540-00426759": "1994 bush fires that impacted", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01799-00426760-00426985": "communities across the eastern seaboard", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01800-00426986-00427287": "happened before I moved permanently to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01801-00427288-00427560": "Australia my now husband Ben was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01802-00427560-00427755": "visiting me in the United States as we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01803-00427756-00427943": "followed the news particularly of his", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01804-00427944-00428147": "family being involved in taking in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01805-00428148-00428334": "people who had to evacuate their homes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01806-00428335-00428751": "in January 1994 Sydney was threatened", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01807-00428752-00428928": "with the total isolation due to these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01808-00428929-00429285": "fires those 1994 bush fires destroyed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01809-00429285-00429545": "80,000 hectares of bush land along with", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01810-00429546-00430005": "225 homes they took four lives they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01811-00430006-00430191": "changed Sydney and they changed New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01812-00430192-00430562": "South Wales the events of 1994 were one", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01813-00430563-00430737": "of the catalysts in forming today's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01814-00430738-00431100": "modern Rural Fire Service the same RFS", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01815-00431101-00431274": "that is bravely battling on the ground", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01816-00431275-00431597": "today protecting people and property and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01817-00431597-00431847": "yet since the start of this year's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01818-00431847-00432212": "bushfire season a million hectares have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01819-00432213-00432445": "been raised across New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01820-00432446-00432701": "surpassing that of the horrifying events", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01821-00432702-00433097": "1994 the devastation inflicted by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01822-00433098-00433370": "bushfires is senseless along with the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01823-00433371-00433605": "way that they impact the lives of our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01824-00433606-00433964": "fellow Australians since Friday we know", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01825-00433966-00434160": "that three people have lost their lives", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01826-00434160-00434430": "in New South Wales this is an", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01827-00434431-00434783": "irreconcilable and incomprehensible loss", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01828-00434784-00435039": "given some of the commentary earlier", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01829-00435039-00435267": "today by the member for New England I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01830-00435268-00435568": "would like to respectfully pay my", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01831-00435569-00435900": "tributes to these three Australian New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01832-00435901-00436185": "South Wales citizens and pay my respects", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01833-00436185-00436439": "and send my sorrow to their families of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01834-00436441-00436677": "these three people I speak specifically", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01835-00436678-00436950": "of Georgian all Julie Fletcher and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01836-00436951-00437142": "Vivien Chaplin who have lost their lives", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01837-00437143-00437595": "in these fires more than 150 homes have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01838-00437596-00437757": "been destroyed but we will not be able", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01839-00437758-00437922": "to comprehend the full scope of this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01840-00437922-00438293": "disaster for some time labour extends", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01841-00438294-00438483": "our sincere sympathies to those who have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01842-00438484-00438717": "lost loved ones livestock pets and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01843-00438718-00438942": "property our thoughts are with you at", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01844-00438943-00439113": "this time and we stand ready to work", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01845-00439114-00439389": "alongside the government and affected", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01846-00439389-00439672": "communities to help in any way we can I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01847-00439673-00439902": "would also like to pay tribute to our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01848-00439903-00440064": "incredible emergency personnel and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01849-00440064-00440289": "volunteers who are currently battling", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01850-00440289-00440582": "these fires across the eastern seaboard", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01851-00440583-00440864": "more than 3,000 firefighters have either", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01852-00440866-00441047": "been deployed across New South Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01853-00441048-00441245": "today to fight they have been deployed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01854-00441246-00441489": "across New South Wales today to fight", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01855-00441489-00441720": "these fires and prevent further loss of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01856-00441721-00441972": "life as the former Premier of New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01857-00441972-00442254": "Wales and as a member of that parliament", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01858-00442255-00442514": "for nearly 10 years I've been honored to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01859-00442516-00442772": "see our emergency services and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01860-00442773-00443088": "volunteers up close whether it be during", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01861-00443089-00443397": "times of flood or bushfire they are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01862-00443397-00443720": "highly skilled dedicated and courageous", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01863-00443721-00444072": "they typify the Australian spirit of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01864-00444072-00444368": "helping out one another in a time of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01865-00444369-00444582": "need that Australian spirit is on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01866-00444583-00444726": "display right now in the most harrowing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01867-00444727-00444924": "of conditions professional firefighters", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01868-00444925-00445209": "and volunteers working alongside local", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01869-00445210-00445368": "community members and Defence Force", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01870-00445368-00445643": "personnel we know bush fires don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01871-00445644-00445797": "respect borders and we thank those", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01872-00445797-00445957": "people who traveled from interest", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01873-00445958-00446158": "date to fight the fires in New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01874-00446159-00446401": "Wales the footage we've seen is truly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01875-00446402-00446605": "terrifying and only serves to underline", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01876-00446606-00446779": "the extraordinary bravery being", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01877-00446780-00447076": "demonstrated every moment by those who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01878-00447077-00447187": "are risking their lives to protect", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01879-00447188-00447502": "people homes and communities so I urge", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01880-00447503-00447688": "everyone whose effect in areas affected", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01881-00447689-00447889": "by fires including in my hometown of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01882-00447889-00448126": "Sydney please remain village vigilant", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01883-00448127-00448372": "listen to warnings down on the Rural", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01884-00448372-00448689": "Fire Service Service fires near me today", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01885-00448691-00448897": "immediately their time has expired", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01886-00448897-00449389": "rapid fire is a friend and FA of light", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01887-00449389-00449752": "fire is being an absolute foe destroying", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01888-00449753-00450018": "property livestock habitat and most", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01889-00450020-00450334": "tragically human lives decent", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01890-00450335-00450571": "Australians thoughts and prayers are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01891-00450572-00450775": "with the victims and their families", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01892-00450776-00451030": "those in the thick of it and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01893-00451031-00451327": "selfless frontline workers valiantly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01894-00451328-00451606": "fighting the fires seeking to protect", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01895-00451607-00452026": "lives property and habitat we do face a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01896-00452027-00452460": "bushfire emergency regrettably it's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01897-00452462-00453057": "nothing new in Australia and in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01898-00453058-00453349": "recognizing the commentary from Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01899-00453350-00453721": "connealy yes it is true that it is the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01900-00453722-00454060": "first time ever that it's been labeled", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01901-00454060-00454393": "as catastrophic the reason being that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01902-00454393-00454942": "we've got a new fire level management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01903-00454943-00455196": "system that has introduced the term", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01904-00455197-00455529": "catastrophic and that was introduced in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01905-00455530-00456091": "2009 so let's get a sense of proportion", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01906-00456092-00456358": "and not seek to play politics with this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01907-00456359-00456745": "let's actually understand that a new", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01908-00456746-00457068": "regime has been introduced which uses", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01909-00457070-00457279": "the term catastrophic which was", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01910-00457280-00457710": "introduced in 2009 because whilst 1", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01911-00457712-00457996": "million acres I think or hectares I'm", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01912-00457997-00458257": "not sure which the good senator referred", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01913-00458258-00458431": "to as having been burnt out and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01914-00458432-00458782": "undoubtedly much much more a million", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01915-00458783-00459070": "acres and I did a rough calculation I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01916-00459071-00459327": "hope I'm right is about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01917-00459328-00459763": "4000 square kilometres the Black", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01918-00459764-00460353": "Saturday fires in Victoria in 2009 burnt", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01919-00460354-00460635": "4,500 square kilometers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01920-00460635-00460957": "26 years earlier the Ash Wednesday fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01921-00460958-00461479": "in Victoria South Australia burned 5200", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01922-00461480-00461776": "square kilometers 16 years before that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01923-00461777-00462243": "in my home state of Tasmania 2600 square", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01924-00462244-00462634": "kilometers were burnt out before that by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01925-00462635-00463255": "28 GS in 1939 20,000 square kilometers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01926-00463256-00463555": "were burned out and so you can go back", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01927-00463556-00463941": "in history especially back to the 1850s", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01928-00463942-00464510": "where huge fires devastated our country", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01929-00464512-00464997": "the Royal Commission into the Victorian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01930-00464998-00465457": "bushfires in 1939 said that for more", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01931-00465458-00465751": "than 20 years the state of Victoria had", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01932-00465752-00466033": "not seen its countryside and forests in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01933-00466034-00466414": "such travail creeks and springs ceased", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01934-00466414-00466924": "to run so this was in 1939 20 years", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01935-00466925-00467380": "prior that means starting from 1919 we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01936-00467381-00467938": "also know that from 1895 to about 1983", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01937-00467939-00468259": "there about there was an Akey Federation", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01938-00468260-00468543": "grout that saw the mighty Mary stop", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01939-00468544-00468778": "running we've got to understand that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01940-00468779-00469039": "this is a country of droughts and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01941-00469039-00469297": "flooding rains as Dorothea Mackellar tol", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01942-00469297-00469783": "to say poignantly in her poem I love a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01943-00469784-00470152": "sunburnt country and say is our fellow", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01944-00470153-00470545": "Australians fight Faiz seeking to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01945-00470546-00470966": "protect life limb property livestock", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01946-00470967-00471370": "native wildlife let's just be mindful of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01947-00471371-00471706": "the tasks that they are facing remember", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01948-00471707-00471970": "them in our thoughts and prayers give", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01949-00471971-00472210": "them all the support that we possibly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01950-00472210-00472572": "can in these most difficult time", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01951-00472573-00472933": "and let's not seek in any way shape or", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01952-00472934-00473353": "form to play a game that might be seen", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01953-00473354-00473791": "as taking an opportunistic approach to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01954-00473792-00474324": "this very very serious issue fires are a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01955-00474325-00474735": "absolute foe and menace to us in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01956-00474737-00474991": "Australian landscape especially when", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01957-00474992-00475282": "fuel loads are allowed to build up and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01958-00475283-00475588": "build up we know that that is a lesson", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01959-00475589-00475855": "that we learned from the Australian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01960-00475856-00476206": "habitat our indigenous people ensured", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01961-00476207-00476476": "that fuel loads were in fact relatively", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01962-00476477-00476779": "low around the countryside but", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01963-00476780-00477058": "nevertheless massive landscape bush", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01964-00477059-00477360": "fires devastated my home state of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01965-00477362-00477610": "Tasmania about the time of white", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01966-00477610-00478168": "settlement 1967 major fire 1934 a major", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01967-00478168-00478464": "fire and so the list goes on let's not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01968-00478466-00478651": "play politics with fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01969-00478652-00478924": "let's give every support to the men and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01970-00478925-00479149": "women who are fighting them and are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01971-00479150-00479341": "fearing for their life in the centre", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01972-00479342-00479557": "it's your time has expired senator it is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01973-00479558-00480001": "thank you madam deputy president I rise", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01974-00480002-00480222": "also to take note of the the answer", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01975-00480223-00480424": "given by senator Corman to Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01976-00480425-00480464": "Wong's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01977-00480466-00480843": "question in relation to the fires across", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01978-00480845-00481102": "the country in particular in New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01979-00481103-00481347": "Wales and Queensland the Rural Fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01980-00481348-00481555": "Service Deputy Commissioner in New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01981-00481556-00481920": "Wales Rob Rogers said that the situation", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01982-00481921-00482310": "was unprecedented and worse than he", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01983-00482312-00482401": "could have imagined", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01984-00482402-00482728": "earlier today more than 3,000", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01985-00482729-00482983": "firefighters are currently deployed in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01986-00482984-00483260": "New South Wales supported by 60 aircraft", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01987-00483262-00483604": "the response of the state government in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01988-00483605-00483889": "New South Wales is at a scale that has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01989-00483889-00484264": "not been seen before more than 600", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01990-00484264-00484432": "schools will be closed across New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01991-00484433-00484939": "Wales today and additional schools I'm", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01992-00484939-00485242": "advised are being closed throughout the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01993-00485243-00485397": "course the day as fires", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01994-00485398-00485792": "threaten them there are 55 fires burning", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01995-00485793-00486092": "through New South Wales 30 of those are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01996-00486093-00486193": "uncontained", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01997-00486193-00486563": "seven are at emergency level eight at", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01998-00486564-00486992": "what's an act there are there are very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-01999-00486993-00487295": "significant fires in particular while", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02000-00487296-00487442": "there are fires from the Queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02001-00487443-00487802": "border through to the bigger Valley the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02002-00487803-00487991": "most significant fires in New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02003-00487992-00488312": "Wales at this stage are in the New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02004-00488313-00488507": "England and on the Mid North Coast and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02005-00488508-00488909": "far north coast of New South Wales in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02006-00488910-00489224": "that country particularly in northern", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02007-00489225-00489514": "New South Wales there are many townships", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02008-00489514-00489932": "and many farms on the coastal hinterland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02009-00489933-00490229": "there are retirees and families living", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02010-00490230-00490571": "on small Bush blocks all that enormous", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02011-00490572-00491066": "risk today and and over the course of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02012-00491067-00491462": "last week and I know that the thoughts", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02013-00491463-00491846": "of everybody in this place with those", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02014-00491847-00492431": "people I spoke to Paul sick V who whose", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02015-00492432-00492779": "property was destroyed over the course", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02016-00492780-00492977": "of Friday", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02017-00492978-00493243": "he said thoughtless I should say all of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02018-00493245-00493505": "the adjoining properties in his area", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02019-00493506-00493895": "were destroyed his shed was destroyed he", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02020-00493896-00494195": "returned home to a house that will be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02021-00494196-00494591": "uninhabitable to a note from the Rural", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02022-00494592-00494813": "Fire Service that said we're really glad", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02023-00494814-00495128": "we could save your house I'm sorry about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02024-00495129-00495503": "your shed I spoke to the mayor of Glen", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02025-00495504-00495914": "Innes Carol sparks yesterday I rang her", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02026-00495914-00496042": "for two reasons", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02027-00496043-00496391": "one was because I think right now it's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02028-00496392-00496562": "the job of people in this place to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02029-00496563-00496859": "listen and learn and certainly the mayor", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02030-00496860-00497075": "of Glen Innes was forthright in her", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02031-00497076-00497318": "views about what Canberra and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02032-00497318-00497597": "politicians should be doing but secondly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02033-00497597-00497777": "it's the country that I grew up in I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02034-00497778-00498380": "know it very well the countryside", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02035-00498381-00498572": "particularly the state forests and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02036-00498572-00498842": "National Park are densely wooded they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02037-00498843-00499114": "are dry they have never been drier", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02038-00499115-00499453": "it is very difficult to defend", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02039-00499454-00499687": "properties and to defend those small", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02040-00499688-00500255": "townships in that circumstance and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02041-00500256-00500560": "three people who were killed last week", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02042-00500560-00500887": "George called Vivian Fletcher at the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02043-00500888-00501302": "fire and white alibi and and Julie", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02044-00501303-00501820": "Fletcher in in Johns River we do mourn", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02045-00501821-00502072": "their deaths I think it's also to put on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02046-00502073-00502210": "record what the mayor of Glennon has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02047-00502212-00502462": "said to me about the people in white Al", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02048-00502463-00502741": "Abbar who fought so hard to save not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02049-00502742-00502912": "just property but the lives of their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02050-00502913-00503110": "fellow residents who were ultimately", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02051-00503112-00503639": "killed now I was astonished to hear what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02052-00503639-00503801": "the member for New England had to say", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02053-00503802-00504278": "earlier today on sky it's vulgar it's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02054-00504279-00504487": "crass and it seems that there is no low", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02055-00504488-00504724": "that the former Deputy Prime Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02056-00504725-00505124": "hasn't sunk to or1 Singh - what", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02057-00505125-00505391": "difference does it make who Australian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02058-00505392-00505757": "is affected by fire vote for I don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02059-00505758-00505970": "think anyone should have any regard to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02060-00505971-00506228": "that I don't actually think that anybody", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02061-00506229-00506593": "in this place should it is beneath", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02062-00506594-00506675": "contempt", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02063-00506676-00506789": "it is a source of enormous", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02064-00506789-00507064": "disappointment to his constituents in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02065-00507065-00507332": "New England Australian should be working", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02066-00507333-00507755": "together in these crises on the latest", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02067-00507756-00508058": "part we're thinking of the people here", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02068-00508059-00508220": "we want to support the emergency", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02069-00508221-00508475": "services volunteer and professional I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02070-00508476-00508730": "know that people in that region in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02071-00508731-00508949": "relation to one fire have been fighting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02072-00508950-00509287": "that fire for 70 days in a row they are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02073-00509288-00509497": "exhausted we want to see the full", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02074-00509498-00509722": "resources of government committed to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02075-00509723-00509884": "making sure that they are safe and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02076-00509885-00510487": "restraining so I rise to take note of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02077-00510488-00510785": "answers to questions related to drought", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02078-00510785-00510983": "and all speak to the coalition", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02079-00510984-00511157": "government support for drought hit", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02080-00511158-00511529": "communities and farmers Madame acting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02081-00511530-00511714": "deputy president the coalition", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02082-00511715-00512072": "government and we taking note of answers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02083-00512072-00512264": "to questions that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02084-00512265-00512465": "senator Wong asked of senator Corman and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02085-00512466-00512735": "they were referred to drought now they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02086-00512736-00514010": "went to fires okay thank you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02087-00514010-00514406": "apologies gonna make we all make", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02088-00514407-00514868": "mistakes our first concern is for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02089-00514869-00515072": "safety and the needs of those directly", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02090-00515073-00515381": "affected I think we'll all agree", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02091-00515382-00515645": "especially in this chamber it's in times", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02092-00515646-00515795": "like this that we have to work together", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02093-00515796-00516179": "and to look out for each other as the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02094-00516180-00516362": "Prime Minister's said on his visit to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02095-00516363-00516533": "the fire affected communities in New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02096-00516534-00516810": "South Wales the Australians are at their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02097-00516810-00517148": "best in difficult moments like this they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02098-00517149-00517379": "show incredible spirit heart and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02099-00517380-00517925": "generosity our emergency services are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02100-00517926-00518117": "once again showing their professionalism", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02101-00518118-00518385": "and dedication in the face of very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02102-00518385-00518702": "difficult conditions and I repeat advice", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02103-00518703-00518948": "already given today in this chamber that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02104-00518949-00519256": "if people in fire affected areas are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02105-00519257-00519662": "Salif by the fire services or emergency", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02106-00519663-00519962": "services that they should do so to look", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02107-00519963-00520118": "out for their family and look out for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02108-00520119-00520383": "themselves to protect their lives and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02109-00520384-00520614": "those of their families before looking", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02110-00520614-00520962": "after their properties I would also like", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02111-00520963-00521246": "to add my thanks to all the career and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02112-00521247-00521489": "volunteer emergency services personnel", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02113-00521489-00521985": "fighting these fires I'd also like to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02114-00521985-00522177": "acknowledge the comradeship on display", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02115-00522178-00522402": "by the contribution to the New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02116-00522403-00522770": "Wales firefighting efforts shown by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02117-00522771-00523056": "Interstate personnel from the Australian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02118-00523057-00523283": "Capital Territory South Australia", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02119-00523284-00523796": "Tasmania and Victoria the clear advice", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02120-00523797-00524085": "given by Fire Services and I'd like to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02121-00524085-00524423": "repeat this to our communities is to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02122-00524424-00524781": "plan ahead and to be prepared days like", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02123-00524782-00525006": "today aren't the times where you want to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02124-00525007-00525179": "start that planning will start your", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02125-00525180-00525452": "preparations this is these are the days", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02126-00525453-00525627": "were those efforts", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02127-00525628-00526251": "to be bearing fruit now I'd also like to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02128-00526252-00526401": "add the Australian government stands", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02129-00526402-00526665": "ready to immediately assist those", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02130-00526666-00526911": "affected by fires in New South Wales and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02131-00526912-00527688": "Queensland the I'd like to note also the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02132-00527689-00528159": "the defense ministers answering question", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02133-00528160-00528426": "time that the Australian Defense Forces", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02134-00528427-00528762": "are coming to the aid of those fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02135-00528763-00529572": "areas talking about the Australian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02136-00529573-00529893": "government assistance as well as the ADF", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02137-00529894-00530118": "forces that are being added to this fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02138-00530119-00530361": "bombing aircraft have been in action", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02139-00530362-00530622": "across these fires and our national", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02140-00530623-00530778": "aerial firefighting arrangements are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02141-00530779-00530937": "ensuring the best possible aerial", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02142-00530938-00531195": "firefighting equipment is available to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02143-00531196-00531573": "protect Australians every year the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02144-00531574-00531884": "Australian government invests about", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02145-00531885-00532275": "sorry not about around fourteen point", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02146-00532276-00532446": "eight million dollars in aerial", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02147-00532447-00532794": "firefighting the Director General of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02148-00532795-00532974": "Emergency Management Australia EEMA", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02149-00532975-00533400": "activated the Commodus plant in on 31", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02150-00533401-00533640": "October in response to a formal request", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02151-00533641-00533931": "for Australian government non-financial", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02152-00533932-00534174": "assistance following significant fire", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02153-00534175-00534417": "activity in New South Wales and this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02154-00534418-00534954": "remains activated today the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02155-00534955-00535152": "director-general of emergency management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02156-00535153-00535395": "straight sorry Emergency Management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02157-00535396-00535557": "Australian liaison officers have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02158-00535558-00535743": "deployed to the New South Wales RFS", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02159-00535744-00536013": "state operation centre and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02160-00536014-00536229": "queensland state disaster cord", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02161-00536230-00536478": "Coordination Center the Australian", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02162-00536479-00536730": "Government is in close contact with New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02163-00536731-00536985": "South Wales and Queensland authorities", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02164-00536986-00537678": "and stands ready to assist disaster", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02165-00537679-00537867": "recovery assistance is being provided", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02166-00537868-00538155": "under the DFR a the disaster recovery", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02167-00538156-00538434": "funding arrangements in response to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02168-00538435-00538605": "bush fires that have affected the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02169-00538606-00538812": "mid-north coast and northern New South", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02170-00538813-00538932": "Wales", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02171-00538933-00539383": "d RFA assistance is available for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02172-00539384-00539638": "Mid North Coast bushfires in their local", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02173-00539639-00539784": "government areas of coffs harbour", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02174-00539785-00540139": "Kempsey Mid Coast nimbarka", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02175-00540140-00540645": "in Port Macquarie Hastings the northern", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02176-00540646-00540967": "New South Wales Bush was affected are in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02177-00540968-00541149": "the local government areas of our model", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02178-00541150-00541486": "balligan Clarence Valley Glen Innes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02179-00541487-00541905": "7 in Burrell Richmond Valley Tenterfield", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02180-00541906-00542295": "Yala and Walter a range of assistance is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02181-00542296-00543067": "available Green thank you I rise to take", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02182-00543068-00543277": "note of the answers given by Minister", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02183-00543278-00543484": "comin to the question asked by Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02184-00543485-00543918": "Wong today is a tough day for Queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02185-00543919-00544210": "and tomorrow will be even tougher", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02186-00544211-00544438": "I want to thank Minister corpsman Anson", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02187-00544439-00544743": "and McKenzie for their comments today", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02188-00544744-00544995": "and add that the Queensland fire and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02189-00544996-00545314": "emergency services are responding to 55", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02190-00545315-00545595": "active fires across the state there's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02191-00545596-00545875": "currently 170 crews on the ground", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02192-00545876-00546172": "working to keep Queenslanders safe some", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02193-00546173-00546409": "of these fires located in the southeast", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02194-00546410-00546622": "corner of Queensland have been burning", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02195-00546623-00546958": "since September as they are in locations", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02196-00546959-00547306": "difficult to access twelve homes have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02197-00547307-00547690": "been destroyed the mundane to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02198-00547691-00547959": "memories family photographs clothes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02199-00547960-00548506": "heirlooms items from pantries Queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02200-00548507-00548740": "foreign emergency services have prepared", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02201-00548741-00549004": "to leave notices today to the following", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02202-00549005-00549262": "areas Roseville Mount", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02203-00549263-00549601": "Alphin double-top Clumber Jerome", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02204-00549602-00549979": "Adelaide Park Carew ball Maryvale and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02205-00549980-00550315": "Lake Mary residents have been told to be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02206-00550316-00550501": "vigilant when it comes to air quality in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02207-00550502-00550756": "Brisbane it's switch and the Gold Coast", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02208-00550757-00551083": "air pollution is 10 times higher than", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02209-00551084-00551358": "usual and likely to be the same tomorrow", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02210-00551359-00551647": "there are strong winds tonight and they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02211-00551648-00551941": "will be more tomorrow complicated and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02212-00551942-00552118": "challenging wind conditions", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02213-00552119-00552316": "make it challenging for firefighters on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02214-00552317-00552565": "the ground so can I take this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02215-00552566-00552763": "opportunity to thank the state and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02216-00552764-00552976": "federal government for the response to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02217-00552977-00553243": "this most recent weather event I know in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02218-00553244-00553405": "my home state we have the very best", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02219-00553406-00553593": "experts in emergency and disaster", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02220-00553594-00553804": "management and response and we thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02221-00553805-00554034": "every emergency service personnel", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02222-00554035-00554299": "firefighters police ambulance officers", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02223-00554300-00554599": "and all of their support staff we thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02224-00554600-00554776": "those members of the emergency service", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02225-00554777-00554932": "personnel from other states and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02226-00554933-00555133": "countries traveling to Queensland to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02227-00555134-00555391": "provide support to our own brave and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02228-00555392-00555712": "most likely exhausted fireese please", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02229-00555713-00555985": "stay safe please know your service is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02230-00555986-00556312": "appreciated I'd like to thank also the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02231-00556313-00556510": "regional Queenslanders and others", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02232-00556511-00556684": "working in the media today to bring", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02233-00556685-00556912": "information and updates to Queenslanders", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02234-00556913-00557220": "who face unthinkable threats we are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02235-00557221-00557401": "incredibly lucky in regional Queensland", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02236-00557402-00557632": "to have local newsrooms and journalists", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02237-00557633-00557895": "dedicated to delivering stories they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02238-00557896-00558297": "bring the stories they bring the rest of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02239-00558298-00558529": "the pictures that convey the true horror", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02240-00558530-00558763": "of these fires that bring us the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02241-00558764-00559032": "catastrophic human face of these events", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02242-00559033-00559366": "often in the line of fires themselves we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02243-00559367-00559543": "don't often thank the media in this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02244-00559544-00559804": "place but in regional Queensland they", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02245-00559805-00560056": "are also part of our community and we do", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02246-00560057-00560350": "thank them for their service over the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02247-00560351-00560512": "past few days I've heard a number of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02248-00560513-00560818": "comments on what is correct to say and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02249-00560819-00561202": "debate during times like these on the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02250-00561203-00561427": "one hand we have climate change denying", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02251-00561428-00561645": "denies blaming vegetation management", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02252-00561646-00561928": "legislation for these conditions and on", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02253-00561929-00562099": "the other hand reactions that seek to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02254-00562100-00562384": "blame Senators in this chamber for the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02255-00562385-00562642": "direct lighting of fires themselves I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02256-00562643-00562984": "would warn both sides on this no one", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02257-00562985-00563167": "comes to this debate with clean hands", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02258-00563168-00563454": "and politicizing what is a tragic event", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02259-00563455-00563670": "what people living in regional", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02260-00563671-00563935": "Queensland want right now the people who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02261-00563936-00564109": "are continually impacted by these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02262-00564110-00564545": "disasters is less talk in more action", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02263-00564546-00564912": "Queenslanders are tough and resilient", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02264-00564913-00565376": "flood win fire we've had it all thrown", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02265-00565377-00565748": "way but when the sky turns black and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02266-00565749-00565970": "wind picks up and the smoke starts to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02267-00565971-00566267": "fill the air around you it's hard not to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02268-00566268-00566642": "feel lost and hopeless Queenslanders our", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02269-00566643-00567013": "stoic but right now they are suffering", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02270-00567014-00567356": "so to those people back in Queensland I", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02271-00567357-00567734": "say this the smoke will pass and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02272-00567735-00568094": "fires will burn out the remains of your", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02273-00568095-00568454": "houses will be rebuilt but no", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02274-00568455-00568745": "Queenslander will do this alone because", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02275-00568746-00569003": "above all else Queenslanders stand", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02276-00569004-00569399": "together today tomorrow and always Thank", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02277-00569400-00569741": "You senator Lambie on Nestle would you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02278-00569742-00569888": "like to move your own motion about your", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02279-00569889-00570257": "question on this okay so I took the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02280-00570258-00570476": "motion about that question and the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02281-00570477-00570692": "question is the motion moved by Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02282-00570693-00570836": "Kay Neeley be agreed to those of that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02283-00570837-00570932": "opinion say aye", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02284-00570933-00571100": "contrary no the eyes have it Senator", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02285-00571101-00571364": "Lambie thank you Thank You mr. president", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02286-00571365-00571565": "I move that the Senate take note of the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02287-00571566-00571877": "answers given moment there by the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02288-00571878-00572078": "minister and yourself relating to the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02289-00572079-00572258": "number of parliamentary sponsored passes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02290-00572259-00572510": "in circulation every year the number of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02291-00572511-00572681": "lobbyists balloons further and further", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02292-00572682-00572867": "out and every year the number of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02293-00572868-00573050": "lobbyists who are registered on the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02294-00573051-00573247": "books shrinks further and further away", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02295-00573248-00573464": "don't forget either that only the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02296-00573465-00573623": "registered ones are required to stick to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02297-00573624-00573872": "the code of conduct the ones who are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02298-00573873-00574091": "Burrage said well apparently they don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02299-00574092-00574352": "care we don't care what they do if you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02300-00574353-00574604": "want to lie that's fine if you don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02301-00574605-00574730": "want to tell anybody who you're actually", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02302-00574731-00574913": "working for that's fine too there's not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02303-00574914-00575111": "a problem there if you want to walk in", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02304-00575112-00575303": "out of a minister's office you go for it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02305-00575304-00575489": "the lobbying register needs more than a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02306-00575490-00575680": "lick of paint it needs a total makeover", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02307-00575681-00575918": "it needs to be water and it needs to be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02308-00575919-00576098": "a hell of a lot tougher and it needs to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02309-00576099-00576242": "be reward enough to cover everybody who", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02310-00576243-00576461": "is lobbying government it needs to be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02311-00576462-00576569": "tough enough to keep them on the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02312-00576570-00576761": "straight and narrow and right now it's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02313-00576762-00576920": "narrow enough to basic to cover", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02314-00576921-00577115": "basically nothing and it's weak enough", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02315-00577116-00577355": "to achieve basically nothing which is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02316-00577356-00577547": "exactly what it's doing the government", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02317-00577548-00577676": "says we can't say the list of people", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02318-00577677-00577910": "responsive passes think about this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02319-00577911-00578114": "there's two and a half thousand people", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02320-00578115-00578339": "with complete access to offices in the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02321-00578340-00578554": "parliament they have the active", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02322-00578555-00578758": "because the parliamentarian sponsored", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02323-00578759-00579001": "them they signed a form saying they have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02324-00579002-00579184": "known them for at least 12 months and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02325-00579185-00579493": "they vouch for them and we have what do", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02326-00579494-00579655": "you guess no idea who they are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02327-00579656-00579862": "we don't know who sponsored them we", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02328-00579863-00580018": "don't know who they work for we don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02329-00580019-00580177": "know how often they come into Parliament", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02330-00580178-00580297": "we don't know how many times they're", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02331-00580298-00580513": "coming in out of certain offices in fact", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02332-00580514-00580675": "we have to drag out the government to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02333-00580676-00580870": "even find out how many there are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02334-00580871-00581116": "what's going on what more the secrecy", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02335-00581117-00581404": "who's benefiting out of this New Zealand", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02336-00581405-00581593": "publishes details of approved visitors", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02337-00581594-00581800": "who have swap access to Parliament house", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02338-00581801-00582067": "like Australian orange pass holders New", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02339-00582068-00582286": "Zealand approved visitors have to show", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02340-00582287-00582421": "that they require regular business", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02341-00582422-00582667": "access to Parliament to obtain a pass", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02342-00582668-00583018": "New Zealand can do it why can't we we're", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02343-00583019-00583189": "not able to cover that apparently all", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02344-00583190-00583384": "lobbyists in Canada and the US have to", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02345-00583385-00583525": "disclose information about their", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02346-00583526-00583744": "lobbying activities whether they work", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02347-00583745-00583906": "for an employer or they work as a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02348-00583907-00584197": "clients both jurisdictions also have", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02349-00584198-00584386": "strong penalties for breaching the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02350-00584387-00584584": "regulations including fines and jail", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02351-00584585-00584950": "time for deterrence what do we have here", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02352-00584951-00585163": "under our system the Menil minute", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02353-00585164-00585355": "apparently the minerals Council aren't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02354-00585356-00585556": "lobbyists the Business Council aren't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02355-00585557-00585721": "lobbyists the Australian Council of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02356-00585722-00585895": "trade unions apparently are not", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02357-00585896-00586156": "lobbyists they aren't in the building", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02358-00586157-00586363": "lobbying the Senate loving the Senate", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02359-00586364-00586552": "today as we speak whatever they're doing", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02360-00586553-00586870": "apparently it's not lobbying must be", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02361-00586871-00586990": "plenty of cups to tell you they're", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02362-00586991-00587251": "having and get this lobbyists who break", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02363-00587252-00587416": "the code can be kicked off the lobbyists", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02364-00587417-00587677": "register but guess what they never are", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02365-00587678-00587944": "and even if they were they can keep", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02366-00587945-00588166": "their sponsored pass and keep getting", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02367-00588167-00588352": "access to Parliament and escorted", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02368-00588353-00588660": "unaccounted for and basically invisible", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02369-00588661-00588880": "been saying this for years that the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02370-00588881-00589042": "solution to this problem is right under", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02371-00589043-00589294": "your noses rewrite the rules so that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02372-00589295-00589507": "everyone with a sponsored Orange pass is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02373-00589508-00589768": "considered a lobbyist and everyone's", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02374-00589769-00589969": "who's a lobbyist is required to sign up", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02375-00589970-00590263": "to the register and everybody on it is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02376-00590264-00590467": "required to abide by the lobbying code", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02377-00590468-00590752": "of conduct and if you don't abide by it", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02378-00590753-00590965": "you go off the register and you lose", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02379-00590966-00591136": "your past it's pretty simple and you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02380-00591137-00591334": "lose your privileged access to these", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02381-00591335-00591649": "Parliament governments can only govern", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02382-00591650-00591841": "with the consent of the governed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02383-00591842-00591995": "if you lose the trust of the people", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02384-00591996-00592175": "you're trying to govern you lose", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02385-00592176-00592286": "everything", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02386-00592287-00592487": "this building is more than just the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02387-00592488-00592678": "place of politicians hang around", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02388-00592679-00592870": "complaining about each other this", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02389-00592871-00593099": "building is where governments are formed", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02390-00593100-00593324": "and governments change the country and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02391-00593325-00593507": "they only do that because we trust them", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02392-00593508-00593722": "supposedly trust them to do so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02393-00593723-00594077": "we're losing the grip on that trust my", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02394-00594078-00594266": "proposal says if you're lobbyists and", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02395-00594267-00594397": "you break the rules you lose your", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02396-00594398-00594635": "special access into Parliament if you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02397-00594636-00594820": "still need to get in to see someone so", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02398-00594821-00595007": "on the visitors like everybody else has", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02399-00595008-00595226": "to you had the chance to do the right", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02400-00595227-00595339": "thing you will trust it with that", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02401-00595340-00595547": "privilege and you've used it to benefit", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02402-00595548-00595682": "your own special interest which is", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02403-00595683-00595901": "exactly what's going on and then you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02404-00595902-00596066": "under Dan undermine the trust that fuels", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02405-00596067-00596279": "this place you don't get to keep coming", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02406-00596280-00596558": "back to it you've got to send a very", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02407-00596559-00596756": "clear message that the rules are rules", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02408-00596757-00596947": "and it doesn't matter if you're working", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02409-00596948-00597107": "for unions for big companies for", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02410-00597108-00597293": "charities or for your own business down", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02411-00597294-00597524": "the road you go into a meeting with a", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02412-00597525-00597670": "minister who required to play by the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02413-00597671-00597857": "rules don't lie don't bribe don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02414-00597858-00598061": "threaten don't arrest don't corrupt the", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02415-00598062-00598238": "political process can you mate see you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02416-00598239-00598489": "can make a dollar or two out of it don't", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02417-00598490-00598754": "do these things because if you do we'll", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02418-00598755-00598958": "come down you down on you like a ton of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02419-00598959-00599207": "bricks you'll lose more than an orange", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02420-00599208-00599375": "pass around your neck I can tell you", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02421-00599376-00599537": "you'll lose access of your loose", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02422-00599538-00599837": "influence and you know what they deserve", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02423-00599838-00600206": "it question is the motion moved by", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02424-00600207-00600377": "senator Lambie be agreed to those of", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02425-00600378-00600670": "that opinion say I country know the eyes", "OpTuHbwQF_8-02426-00600671-00601157": "habit petition"}}, {"audio_id": "OO8i8fPCUCQ", "text": {"OO8i8fPCUCQ-00000-00000007-00000191": "[Music]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00001-00000192-00000532": "foreign", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00002-00000533-00002298": "[Music]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00003-00002299-00004582": "[Applause]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00004-00004583-00004852": "[Music]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00005-00004853-00005129": "foreign", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00006-00005130-00008098": "[Music]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00007-00008100-00008402": "foreign", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00008-00008403-00013632": "[Music]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00009-00013633-00013822": "[Music]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00010-00013823-00014081": "foreign", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00011-00014082-00016829": "[Music]", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00012-00016830-00017129": "foreign", "OO8i8fPCUCQ-00013-00017130-00017630": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OO8YdcSHsXI", "text": {"OO8YdcSHsXI-00000-00000029-00000335": "hello guys welcome back to the hello", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00001-00000336-00000769": "guys welcome", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00002-00000770-00001133": "why not and today we are gonna try and", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00003-00001134-00002009": "get some dupes", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00004-00002010-00002189": "and we're gonna try and complete the", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00005-00002190-00002542": "path the Most Wanted parks", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00006-00002543-00003281": "to get the free skin before a few days", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00007-00003282-00003799": "yeah", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00008-00003800-00004186": "because I got my software", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00009-00004187-00004409": "guys I've actually started the new", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00010-00004410-00004709": "editing software", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00011-00004710-00005027": "since like um for a while now I've been", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00012-00005028-00005195": "using it", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00013-00005196-00005491": "because I've been using captions", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00014-00005492-00005825": "and that's but that keeps on getting", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00015-00005826-00006113": "buggy", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00016-00006114-00006299": "so you know it's you've seen it before", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00017-00006300-00006581": "guys in my when I accidentally exposed", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00018-00006581-00007145": "it", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00019-00007145-00007569": "foreign", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00020-00007570-00009146": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00021-00009147-00009319": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00022-00009320-00009689": "guys if I don't have air Island it is", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00023-00009690-00011095": "because", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00024-00011096-00011477": "because I had to use steam instead", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00025-00011478-00011764": "and oh my God wipes out from my single", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00026-00011765-00012046": "Waters so I had to start again so sorry", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00027-00012047-00012922": "if all my monsters are still attacked", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00028-00012923-00013216": "throw them out", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00029-00013218-00014135": "monsters", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00030-00014136-00014843": "and Monsters videos", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00031-00014844-00015113": "guys comment down below what should I do", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00032-00015113-00015544": "next time", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00033-00015545-00015991": "back", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00034-00015991-00016229": "oh yeah if you haven't seen my community", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00035-00016230-00016475": "post on the 10th of February on the 10th", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00036-00016476-00016661": "of March until the 12th", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00037-00016662-00017035": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00038-00017036-00017399": "I'm gonna call", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00039-00017400-00017567": "so basically I'm gonna be able to record", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00040-00017568-00017897": "for that week", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00041-00017898-00018161": "maybe maybe", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00042-00018162-00018425": "there's a risk like new season video", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00043-00018426-00019336": "would be a week late", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00044-00019337-00022283": "no way you're welcome", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00045-00022284-00022630": "guys I like handle Square", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00046-00022631-00023611": "the coffee alive", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00047-00023612-00023927": "oh yes guys if you remember I posted a", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00048-00023928-00024222": "video a few minutes", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00049-00024223-00024827": "but now it's deleted", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00050-00024828-00025249": "because I can't I don't I didn't really", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00051-00025250-00026218": "I bet it's just Rage Quit", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00052-00026219-00027077": "eat boy", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00053-00027077-00027718": "haha", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00054-00027719-00028073": "guys are good at the toxic", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00055-00028074-00028696": "hahaha", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00056-00028697-00029002": "was full", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00057-00029004-00029381": "I have one thousand dollars", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00058-00029382-00029573": "I'm gonna have to spend it in Bargain", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00059-00029574-00031679": "Bin week in two weeks", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00060-00031680-00035239": "foreign", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00061-00035240-00035627": "show me way of it just show me wherever", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00062-00035628-00036029": "you want edges", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00063-00036030-00036905": "show me where everyone is on the map", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00064-00036906-00037612": "oh so kill them with pleasure", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00065-00037613-00038315": "oh circles", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00066-00038316-00038627": "I think season two oh yeah sees it guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00067-00038628-00038861": "just haven't heard yet season two will", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00068-00038862-00039137": "bring a new feature called neuter moles", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00069-00039138-00039407": "we should probably replace Wildlife with", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00070-00039408-00039574": "like", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00071-00039575-00039940": "like some for example chickens like go", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00072-00039941-00040177": "back to being wet", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00073-00040178-00040511": "African Legends are like like Adrian", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00074-00040512-00040924": "ambushy from season one and season four", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00075-00040925-00041062": "I don't", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00076-00041063-00041158": "oh", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00077-00041159-00041761": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00078-00041762-00042580": "there's no volts here", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00079-00042581-00046867": "foreign", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00080-00046868-00047137": "thank you", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00081-00047138-00049324": "I did pretty cool", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00082-00049325-00053141": "foreign", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00083-00053141-00053326": "because she used to think I've never", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00084-00053327-00053554": "been", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00085-00053555-00054137": "try and knock down the hill", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00086-00054138-00054941": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00087-00054941-00056404": "never mind", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00088-00056405-00057341": "foreign", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00089-00057342-00059273": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00090-00059274-00060138": "it's kind of cool", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00091-00060139-00061124": "I don't know how long", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00092-00061125-00062629": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00093-00062629-00063850": "wait no he has a favorite shotgun", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00094-00063851-00064613": "service like", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00095-00064614-00064865": "just see how long I've been recording", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00096-00064866-00066167": "for", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00097-00066168-00066347": "oh I've been recorded for 11 minutes", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00098-00066348-00066623": "guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00099-00066624-00066826": "I will record it for 11 minutes guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00100-00066827-00067187": "sorry guys if you saw in many of my", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00101-00067188-00067325": "photos", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00102-00067326-00067594": "it's not to do with you guys it's just", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00103-00067595-00067961": "my role play my all-time videos go on", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00104-00067962-00068255": "the photos I forgot to delete them so", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00105-00068256-00069106": "there's some screenshots from yesterday", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00106-00069107-00069329": "I delete my videos afterwards because", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00107-00069330-00069569": "they're starving space and I don't have", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00108-00069570-00069955": "much of that yet", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00109-00069956-00070300": "oh my", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00110-00070301-00070726": "God oh my fingers will get started", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00111-00070727-00070919": "fingers crossed I'll be able to do more", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00112-00070920-00071243": "video games", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00113-00071244-00072005": "maybe even move on to the", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00114-00072006-00072263": "right our night is one of the most", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00115-00072264-00072606": "popular things", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00116-00072607-00073615": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00117-00073616-00073937": "it would be nice for you to like hit the", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00118-00073938-00074419": "like button and support them", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00119-00074420-00074675": "I'm gonna delete that", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00120-00074676-00075779": "the game", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00121-00075780-00077026": "oh my soul", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00122-00077027-00077597": "guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00123-00077598-00077812": "is a hot Drop", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00124-00077813-00079663": "guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00125-00079664-00080603": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00126-00080604-00081012": "foreign", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00127-00081013-00083124": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00128-00083125-00084262": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00129-00084263-00084665": "thank you", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00130-00084666-00087475": "hello buddy boy", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00131-00087476-00088360": "one minute", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00132-00088361-00089624": "[Applause]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00133-00089625-00090432": "[Music]", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00134-00090433-00091337": "over here", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00135-00091338-00093943": "foreign", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00136-00093944-00094241": "no weapon guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00137-00094242-00094517": "this game's too sweaty", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00138-00094518-00094841": "um", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00139-00094842-00095182": "you know what that's it that's it you", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00140-00095183-00095417": "know what guys that's it I know it's", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00141-00095418-00096575": "only been two rounds", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00142-00096576-00096803": "I like perfectness", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00143-00096804-00097168": "this space for an update having guys I'm", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00144-00097169-00097571": "just checking if I still recording yes", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00145-00097572-00097756": "we are", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00146-00097757-00098279": "that way guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00147-00098280-00098609": "that's it I had enough", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00148-00098610-00098897": "I had enough guys I had enough can't be", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00149-00098898-00099137": "bothered with this game anymore", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00150-00099138-00099347": "you know what yeah it's been a good time", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00151-00099348-00100138": "but", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00152-00100139-00101471": "what is my life", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00153-00101472-00102551": "call it the 16 minutes guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00154-00102552-00102839": "I don't want steam open I'll play my", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00155-00102840-00103066": "single monsters later", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00156-00103067-00103271": "me now man", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00157-00103272-00103480": "that's it guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00158-00103481-00103732": "why is it still running it should be", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00159-00103733-00104177": "closed", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00160-00104178-00105239": "um I don't want to go Unreal Engine", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00161-00105240-00105649": "I've played for", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00162-00105650-00106133": "1237 hours and 18 minutes", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00163-00106133-00106421": "I am I've been wasting so much of my", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00164-00106422-00106702": "time on fortnite I'm Not Really Gonna", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00165-00106703-00107027": "uninstall it guys because my", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00166-00107028-00107357": "just in case it gets better but that's", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00167-00107358-00107693": "it no more fortnite videos no more I'm", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00168-00107694-00108328": "taking a break from it that's it look", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00169-00108329-00108839": "delete", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00170-00108840-00109127": "now it's deleted", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00171-00109128-00109366": "boom guys that's it no more fortnite", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00172-00109367-00109552": "videos no more", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00173-00109553-00109781": "look", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00174-00109782-00109966": "look guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00175-00109967-00110333": "it's not on first star anymore", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00176-00110333-00110602": "it actually is guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00177-00110603-00111113": "I just deleted it from the home page", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00178-00111114-00111316": "I don't care if you even mine at the", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00179-00111317-00111383": "minute", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00180-00111383-00111569": "but then guys", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00181-00111570-00111754": "I can't be bothered with this game", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00182-00111755-00111857": "anymore", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00183-00111858-00112366": "I deleted from the taskbar as you guys I", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00184-00112367-00112534": "didn't even for taskbar but I didn't", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00185-00112535-00112828": "actually uninstall it guys I just", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00186-00112829-00113039": "taking a break from it", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00187-00113040-00113225": "so that means you'll probably only see", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00188-00113226-00113410": "my stinking Monsters videos for the next", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00189-00113411-00113590": "few weeks", "OO8YdcSHsXI-00190-00113591-00114067": "or maybe even be acting so Batman Maya"}}, {"audio_id": "OOlrAVl-bj0", "text": {"OOlrAVl-bj0-00000-00000000-00000730": "I asked for sign I didn't like what it", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00001-00000731-00001907": "said I kept on keeping all instead they", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00002-00001907-00002632": "say nothing beats a fair board a try", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00003-00002633-00003415": "guess that's one thing i'm doing right", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00004-00003415-00004320": "then kicking around the same old tunes", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00005-00004321-00005258": "tangled up in a protectable here all the", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00006-00005259-00005968": "ink i spilled on rambling songs in", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00007-00005969-00006941": "floating me 90 get in me go stubborn is", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00008-00006942-00007892": "as stupid does my head knows better put", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00009-00007893-00008696": "my feet won't budge my donkey sense has", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00010-00008697-00009455": "got me frozen in this track some kind of", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00011-00009456-00010220": "death down every other path I wrote", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00012-00010221-00010546": "myself into a", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00013-00010547-00011097": "fit part now I am sketching out the", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00014-00011098-00011922": "framework of a fresh start they say", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00015-00011923-00012660": "nothing beats a fair border try I'm", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00016-00012661-00013578": "gonna mess it up good tonight", "OOlrAVl-bj0-00017-00013579-00013784": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OOpdbzoFTaQ", "text": {"OOpdbzoFTaQ-00000-00000038-00000320": "ohayo sixth congressional district is", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00001-00000321-00000515": "represented by representative bill", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00002-00000516-00000848": "Johnson ro this district runs along the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00003-00000849-00001028": "southeast side of the state bordering", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00004-00001029-00001258": "Kentucky West Virginia and Pennsylvania", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00005-00001259-00001520": "it stretches from rural lucasville", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00006-00001521-00001718": "through Athens and several older Ohio", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00007-00001719-00001916": "River industrial towns all the way to", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00008-00001917-00002576": "the Youngstown city limits", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00009-00002577-00002904": "topic history", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00010-00002905-00003087": "you", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00011-00003088-00003342": "when Robert McEwen was first elected in", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00012-00003343-00003554": "1980 the sixth District of Ohio", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00013-00003556-00003864": "consisted of Adams Brown Clinton Fayette", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00014-00003865-00003993": "Highland Pickaway", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00015-00003994-00004247": "Pike Scioto and Ross counties plus", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00016-00004248-00004434": "Clermont County outside the city of", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00017-00004435-00004644": "Loveland Harrison Township in Vinton", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00018-00004645-00004842": "County and the Warren County townships", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00019-00004843-00005100": "of Clear Creek Deerfield Hamilton Harlan", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00020-00005101-00005442": "Massey Salem and Wayne at that time the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00021-00005443-00005670": "Washington Post described the sixth s a", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00022-00005671-00006024": "fail-safe republican district the Ohio", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00023-00006025-00006218": "General Assembly redrew the sixth", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00024-00006219-00006386": "District following the results of the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00025-00006387-00006780": "1980 census the boundaries from 1983 to", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00026-00006781-00007083": "1987 included all of Adams Clinton", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00027-00007084-00007356": "Fayette Highland Hocking Jackson Pike", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00028-00007356-00007644": "Ross Scioto Vinton and Warren counties", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00029-00007645-00007854": "plus Waterloo and York townships in", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00030-00007855-00008088": "Athens County Wayne Township in Clermont", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00031-00008089-00008436": "County Concord Jasper Marion Perry Union", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00032-00008437-00008592": "and Wayne townships in Fayette County", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00033-00008593-00008826": "and Washington Township and the cities", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00034-00008827-00009033": "of Miamisburg and West Carrollton in", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00035-00009034-00009135": "Montgomery County", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00036-00009136-00009333": "beginning with the 100th Congress in", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00037-00009334-00009570": "1987 adjustments were made by the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00038-00009571-00009719": "legislature to the boundaries", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00039-00009720-00009933": "reapportionment between censuses is", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00040-00009934-00010238": "unusual in American politics a small", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00041-00010239-00010413": "part of the Montgomery County territory", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00042-00010414-00010631": "was detached as were parts of Fayette", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00043-00010632-00010863": "County in Washington courthouse in Union", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00044-00010864-00011067": "Township and the townships of Jasper and", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00045-00011068-00011345": "Marion part of Brown County was added", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00046-00011346-00011577": "Jackson and Eagle townships these were", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00047-00011578-00011745": "the boundaries for the rest of McEwen", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00048-00011746-00011955": "service in Congress the district was", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00049-00011956-00012162": "largely rural and agricultural with no", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00050-00012163-00012408": "large cities one of the major industries", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00051-00012409-00012641": "was the United States Department of", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00052-00012642-00012804": "Energy's Portsmouth gaseous diffusion", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00053-00012805-00013059": "plant at Piketon which manufactured", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00054-00013060-00013356": "uranium for nuclear weapons the district", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00055-00013357-00013629": "was 97% white with a median household", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00056-00013630-00014109": "income of twenty 1761 dollars in 1992", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00057-00014110-00014259": "the district was altered significantly", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00058-00014260-00014519": "to accommodate Ohio's loss of two House", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00059-00014521-00014757": "seats in redistricting the state", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00060-00014758-00014982": "legislature anticipated that Clarence", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00061-00014983-00015168": "Miller of the neighboring 10th district", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00062-00015169-00015341": "would retire and thus combined the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00063-00015343-00015497": "southern end of his district which", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00064-00015499-00015735": "included Athens Gallipolis in Ironton", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00065-00015736-00015890": "with most of the area previously", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00066-00015891-00016166": "represented by McEwen although the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00067-00016168-00016316": "district did not include Miller's", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00068-00016318-00016484": "hometown of Lancaster Mill", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00069-00016485-00016670": "decided not to retire an instead", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00070-00016671-00016877": "challenged McEwan in the 6th district", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00071-00016878-00017228": "primary in 1992 the campaign was bitter", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00072-00017229-00017408": "and McEwen eked out only a narrow", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00073-00017409-00017738": "victory in November McEwen was upset by", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00074-00017739-00017936": "Democrat Ted Strickland a prison", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00075-00017937-00018212": "psychologist Strickland himself was", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00076-00018213-00018500": "defeated in 1994 by Republican frank", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00077-00018501-00018805": "kremens but won the seat back in 1996", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00078-00018806-00019112": "for 2002 the district was shifted", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00079-00019113-00019292": "dramatically eastward to make the seat", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00080-00019293-00019469": "friendlier for Strickland at the same", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00081-00019470-00019664": "time it effectively ended the career of", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00082-00019665-00019892": "james Traficant in the neighboring 17th", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00083-00019893-00020063": "district by placing his hometown of", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00084-00020064-00020363": "Poland into the sixth traffic and opted", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00085-00020364-00020603": "to run in his old district and lost the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00086-00020604-00020774": "district currently includes all of", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00087-00020775-00021014": "Belmont Carroll Columbiana Galia", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00088-00021015-00021284": "Guernsey Jackson Jefferson Lawrence", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00089-00021285-00021545": "makes Monroe Noble and Washington", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00090-00021546-00021785": "counties and portions of Athens mahoning", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00091-00021786-00022055": "Muskingum Scioto and Tuscarawas counties", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00092-00022056-00022439": "in 2010 Republican bill Johnson defeated", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00093-00022440-00022646": "incumbent Democrat Charles Wilson", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00094-00022647-00022835": "returning the seat Republican for the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00095-00022836-00023213": "first time since 1997 following the 2010", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00096-00023214-00023429": "United States Census the bounds of the", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00097-00023430-00023615": "sixth District were changed again as", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00098-00023616-00023837": "Ohio lost two seats in Congress in", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00099-00023838-00024014": "recent years and like much of coal", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00100-00024015-00024236": "country the district has swung decidedly", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00101-00024237-00024440": "toward the Republican Party at local", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00102-00024441-00024719": "state and national levels going from", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00103-00024720-00024851": "what was once a dead heat in", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00104-00024852-00025118": "presidential elections such as in 2000", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00105-00025119-00025391": "or 2004 to a 42 point win for Donald", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00106-00025392-00026150": "Trump over Hillary Clinton in 2016", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00107-00026151-00026739": "topic list of Representatives", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00108-00026739-00027104": "you", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00109-00027105-00027725": "topic recent election results", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00110-00027726-00027947": "the following chart shows historic", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00111-00027948-00028205": "election results bold type indicates", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00112-00028206-00028923": "Victor italic type indicates incumbent", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00113-00028924-00029470": "topic competitiveness", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00114-00029471-00030162": "election results from presidential races", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00115-00030163-00030793": "topic historical district boundaries", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00116-00030794-00031160": "you", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00117-00031161-00031695": "topic see also", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00118-00031695-00032062": "Ohio's congressional districts list of", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00119-00032063-00032670": "United States congressional districts", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00120-00032671-00033243": "topic notes and references", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00121-00033244-00033658": "Mardis Kenneth C 1989 the historical", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00122-00033659-00033837": "atlas of political parties in the United", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00123-00033838-00034123": "States Congress new york macmillan", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00124-00034124-00034567": "publishing company Mardis Kenneth C 1982", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00125-00034568-00034804": "the historical atlas of United States", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00126-00034805-00035049": "congressional districts New York", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00127-00035050-00035328": "Macmillan publishing company", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00128-00035329-00035577": "Congressional biographical directory of", "OOpdbzoFTaQ-00129-00035578-00036048": "the United States 1774 present"}}, {"audio_id": "OOtYXyCM6kM", "text": {"OOtYXyCM6kM-00000-00000059-00000311": "we see a man named Victor Frankenstein", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00001-00000312-00000497": "when the movie starts", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00002-00000498-00000695": "he is actually a medical student and", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00003-00000696-00000869": "wants to achieve something big in his", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00004-00000869-00000989": "life", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00005-00000990-00001229": "one night he visits a circus there he", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00006-00001230-00001516": "sees a beautiful girl named Lorelei", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00007-00001517-00001841": "while performing she falls from the peak", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00008-00001842-00002189": "as a result she receives a fatal injury", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00009-00002190-00002465": "we also see Igor at that place he is", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00010-00002466-00002657": "actually hunched back", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00011-00002658-00002855": "he cannot walk properly because of a", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00012-00002856-00003010": "lump on his back", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00013-00003011-00003304": "he has an attraction towards Lorelei", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00014-00003305-00003509": "she was Finding difficulty in breathing", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00015-00003510-00003701": "due to the injury", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00016-00003702-00003922": "but Igor understands her problem and the", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00017-00003923-00004120": "way to recover her easily", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00018-00004121-00004343": "as Igor has enough knowledge about human", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00019-00004344-00004517": "physiology", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00020-00004518-00004703": "as he was hunched back he studied many", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00021-00004704-00004877": "books to gain knowledge so that he can", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00022-00004878-00005045": "cure his disease", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00023-00005046-00005231": "he has no degree but he was not less", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00024-00005232-00005399": "than a doctor", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00025-00005400-00005686": "he rescues Lorelei within no time", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00026-00005687-00005927": "and she restores her breath", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00027-00005928-00006113": "Victor Frankenstein gets shocked", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00028-00006114-00006263": "witnessing it", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00029-00006264-00006532": "he goes to Igor and asks", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00030-00006533-00006820": "how did you do it he tells I have read a", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00031-00006822-00006970": "number of books", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00032-00006972-00007210": "Victor says to him you are wasting your", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00033-00007211-00007367": "time in the circus", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00034-00007368-00007510": "come with me", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00035-00007511-00007714": "I will change your life", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00036-00007715-00007925": "the ringmaster who is also the owner of", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00037-00007926-00008092": "that place hears it", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00038-00008093-00008327": "he becomes Furious as Igor wanted to", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00039-00008328-00008483": "leave that place", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00040-00008484-00008681": "he locks him in a cage and threatens him", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00041-00008682-00008873": "I will give you to the custody of police", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00042-00008874-00009142": "if you try to escape as you are my slave", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00043-00009143-00009341": "all the human knowledge you gained is by", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00044-00009342-00009485": "the stolen books and police will", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00045-00009486-00009749": "immediately arrest you in no time", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00046-00009750-00009964": "after some time Victor Frankenstein", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00047-00009965-00010114": "arrives there and starts running after", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00048-00010115-00010367": "releasing Igor from that cage", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00049-00010368-00010546": "other people in the circus also", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00050-00010547-00010756": "witnessed them and pursue them", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00051-00010757-00010955": "but Victor brings Igor to his house", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00052-00010956-00011135": "safely but with much effort hiding from", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00053-00011136-00011309": "the eyes of others", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00054-00011310-00011585": "reaching the house first of all Victor", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00055-00011586-00011801": "ejects the pus from his hatchback using", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00056-00011802-00011981": "injection and medicine so that his body", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00057-00011982-00012155": "posture gets recovered", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00058-00012156-00012437": "and we see Igor is recovered", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00059-00012438-00012641": "he was also able to stand for the first", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00060-00012642-00012760": "time", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00061-00012761-00013043": "it means Igor is not a hunchback person", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00062-00013044-00013288": "he could walk properly now", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00063-00013290-00013505": "on the other side we see a police", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00064-00013506-00013691": "officer who is investigating missing", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00065-00013691-00013955": "Igor and a local murder case", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00066-00013956-00014177": "Victor tells Igor I am doing an", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00067-00014178-00014441": "experiment named reversal of death", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00068-00014441-00014716": "it means I can revive the dead man or an", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00069-00014718-00014836": "animal", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00070-00014837-00015022": "but I have to work a lot on it and you", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00071-00015023-00015197": "have to assist me", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00072-00015197-00015436": "he also shows the human eyes placed in a", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00073-00015437-00015563": "container", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00074-00015563-00015761": "when he passes the electricity through", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00075-00015762-00016019": "them those eyes start to move", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00076-00016019-00016258": "as Igor was very smart he points a", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00077-00016259-00016427": "mistake done by Victor", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00078-00016428-00016607": "he tells him", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00079-00016608-00016817": "you have not attached the eyes of nerves", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00080-00016818-00016955": "perfectly", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00081-00016956-00017153": "Victor gets very pleased as he has", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00082-00017154-00017308": "corrected his mistake", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00083-00017309-00017572": "he gets more impressed by him", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00084-00017573-00017849": "now he hires Igor as his assistant", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00085-00017850-00018130": "after some days both revive the organs", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00086-00018131-00018365": "of dead animals both want to create a", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00087-00018366-00018557": "giant chimpanzee with different organs", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00088-00018558-00018772": "that would resemble like a monster", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00089-00018773-00018994": "they were Desiring to take science to an", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00090-00018995-00019139": "advanced level", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00091-00019140-00019403": "after working for some days Victor and", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00092-00019404-00019571": "Igor attend a party", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00093-00019572-00019847": "their Igor sees Lorelei whom we see in", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00094-00019848-00019991": "the circus", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00095-00019992-00020183": "that girl could not recognize him but", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00096-00020184-00020411": "Igor was still in love with her", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00097-00020412-00020597": "here Victor suggests him to keep away", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00098-00020598-00020771": "from that girl", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00099-00020772-00021035": "he tells that girl is a distraction for", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00100-00021036-00021119": "you", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00101-00021120-00021364": "if you focus on her you will not be able", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00102-00021365-00021593": "to concentrate on your work", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00103-00021594-00021869": "later they come back to their house", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00104-00021870-00022097": "here we see the chimpanzee for the first", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00105-00022098-00022186": "time", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00106-00022187-00022361": "it was chained with different electric", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00107-00022362-00022517": "wires", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00108-00022518-00022697": "now it was the time to pass the", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00109-00022698-00022811": "electricity", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00110-00022812-00023003": "electricity is passed through the dead", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00111-00023004-00023267": "chimpanzee so that it comes to life", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00112-00023268-00023585": "Igor is seen very confused here", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00113-00023586-00023813": "but he relaxes when the dead chimpanzee", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00114-00023814-00023993": "starts moving", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00115-00023994-00024172": "it means that their experiment was", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00116-00024173-00024322": "successful", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00117-00024323-00024586": "the next day Victor Frankenstein brings", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00118-00024587-00024797": "that chimpanzee into his university to", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00119-00024798-00024964": "prove his science", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00120-00024965-00025199": "there he faces some hurdles to revive it", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00121-00025200-00025414": "later it starts to attack people around", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00122-00025415-00025511": "it", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00123-00025512-00025733": "it starts hurting the people", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00124-00025733-00026033": "so Victor kills that chimpanzee", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00125-00026033-00026273": "later Victor is thrown out by his", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00126-00026274-00026417": "university", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00127-00026418-00026711": "as he has used unconventional methods", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00128-00026712-00026914": "there we see as classmates who were very", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00129-00026916-00027029": "rich", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00130-00027030-00027239": "one of his classmate named Finnegan is", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00131-00027239-00027496": "very much interested in Victor's work", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00132-00027497-00027785": "he says to Victor I will fund you", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00133-00027786-00028031": "continue these experiments", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00134-00028032-00028277": "and he also asks him make an artificial", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00135-00028277-00028457": "humanoid for me", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00136-00028458-00028667": "it means such a creature which has to be", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00137-00028668-00028924": "created according to our requirements", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00138-00028925-00029129": "so that it may assist us in our various", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00139-00029130-00029249": "works", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00140-00029250-00029446": "in addition to it he offers him a large", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00141-00029447-00029602": "amount of money", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00142-00029604-00029795": "here it is notice that Igor does not", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00143-00029795-00029968": "want to work for them", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00144-00029969-00030227": "overlooking Igor Victor accepts the", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00145-00030227-00030395": "offer of Finnegan", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00146-00030395-00030658": "Igor also agrees with him as Victor has", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00147-00030660-00030839": "given him a new life after curing his", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00148-00030839-00030964": "disease", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00149-00030966-00031187": "he had saved his life owing him he", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00150-00031188-00031439": "consents to cooperate with Victor", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00151-00031439-00031685": "the next day the same police officers", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00152-00031686-00031901": "visit Victor's house", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00153-00031902-00032164": "so that they may investigate that case", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00154-00032166-00032405": "they also know that an effort was made", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00155-00032406-00032705": "to revive chimpanzee in the University", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00156-00032706-00032915": "police officers had no warrant to check", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00157-00032916-00033137": "the house so Victor does not allow them", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00158-00033138-00033311": "to check the house", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00159-00033312-00033557": "they returned back with disappointment", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00160-00033558-00033785": "we see Igor meeting Lorelai whom he", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00161-00033786-00033935": "loves very much", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00162-00033936-00034181": "she explains to him tell Victor to keep", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00163-00034182-00034343": "away from that experiment as he will", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00164-00034344-00034552": "again create a monster", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00165-00034553-00034846": "they spend a lot of time with each other", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00166-00034847-00035099": "when ior returns back from there he", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00167-00035100-00035290": "observes those police officers and their", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00168-00035291-00035531": "workers breaking Victor's house door", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00169-00035532-00035717": "entering the house from the other door", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00170-00035718-00035974": "he alerts Victor to escape", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00171-00035975-00036137": "he tells him that your classmate", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00172-00036138-00036424": "Finnegan has arranged a way to escape", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00173-00036425-00036629": "but Victor does not leave from there and", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00174-00036630-00036887": "starts damaging the Machinery there", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00175-00036888-00037061": "he does not want to leave the Machinery", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00176-00037062-00037252": "in the hands of others", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00177-00037253-00037511": "meanwhile the police officer enters the", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00178-00037512-00037702": "house he points the gun at them and", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00179-00037703-00037877": "tries to stop them", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00180-00037878-00038093": "but they could not stop Victor", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00181-00038094-00038267": "we see a fight between the police", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00182-00038268-00038452": "officer and Victor", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00183-00038453-00038705": "after a great quarrel Victor pushes him", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00184-00038706-00038890": "and the police officer's hand strucks in", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00185-00038891-00039059": "the Big Tooth wheel", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00186-00039060-00039293": "and his hand gets amputated", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00187-00039294-00039527": "now the police officer loses one of his", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00188-00039528-00039646": "hands", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00189-00039647-00039905": "on the other side both go to Finnegan", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00190-00039906-00040085": "sitting in a carriage", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00191-00040086-00040277": "there is friend Finnegan hands over some", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00192-00040278-00040433": "money to them", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00193-00040434-00040762": "and says work on my project create an", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00194-00040763-00040918": "artificial human", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00195-00040919-00041183": "working here is not safe for you so go", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00196-00041184-00041333": "to Scotland there I have an ancestral", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00197-00041334-00041518": "bangalow and you can work there silently", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00198-00041519-00041639": "and easily", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00199-00041640-00041861": "Victor leaves for Scotland", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00200-00041862-00042112": "so that he may work on his project", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00201-00042113-00042412": "Finnegan visits Igor as Victor leaves", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00202-00042413-00042646": "he tells him I will finish Victor when", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00203-00042647-00042893": "the experiment gets completed and I will", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00204-00042894-00043157": "utilize his artificial human as a weapon", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00205-00043158-00043355": "as it is artificial it will be", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00206-00043356-00043529": "bulletproof and no one will be able to", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00207-00043530-00043637": "end it", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00208-00043638-00043877": "and it will work on my commands", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00209-00043878-00044074": "later Igor is thrown into the water", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00210-00044075-00044296": "while fastening his hands and feet", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00211-00044297-00044495": "with great effort Igor comes upward", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00212-00044496-00044699": "saving his life", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00213-00044700-00044927": "later he goes to Lorelei and tells her", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00214-00044928-00045130": "that Victor's life is at risk", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00215-00045131-00045352": "and we have to save his life", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00216-00045353-00045574": "both leave for Scotland together so that", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00217-00045575-00045755": "Victor may be informed that his life is", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00218-00045756-00045868": "at risk", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00219-00045869-00046108": "reaching there he reveals everything to", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00220-00046109-00046211": "Victor", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00221-00046212-00046433": "that his life is in danger", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00222-00046434-00046607": "but Victor wants to continue the", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00223-00046608-00046780": "experiment in spite of knowing that his", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00224-00046781-00046943": "life was at risk", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00225-00046944-00047195": "because he tells a secret to him", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00226-00047196-00047393": "when a storm broke out many years ago", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00227-00047394-00047657": "his elder brother fell victim to it", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00228-00047658-00047843": "and Victor blames himself for his", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00229-00047844-00048035": "brother's death in some way", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00230-00048036-00048233": "and he wants to revive his elder brother", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00231-00048234-00048389": "through this experiment", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00232-00048390-00048640": "after some time Finnegan and police", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00233-00048641-00048857": "officers also come to that place where", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00234-00048858-00049079": "Victor was conducting his experiment", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00235-00049080-00049283": "High electricity was generated during", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00236-00049284-00049457": "the experiment which begins to cause", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00237-00049458-00049649": "great destruction everywhere", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00238-00049650-00049852": "everything starts destructing and their", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00239-00049853-00050033": "machine gets exploded", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00240-00050034-00050212": "due to that explosion Finnegan gets", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00241-00050213-00050333": "killed", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00242-00050334-00050555": "the police officer blames Victor for the", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00243-00050556-00050686": "root of all the destruction and", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00244-00050687-00050945": "everything is happening because of him", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00245-00050946-00051143": "here we also see a monster that was", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00246-00051144-00051352": "created by the experiment", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00247-00051353-00051580": "during the conversation that monster", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00248-00051582-00051754": "starts to move", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00249-00051755-00051970": "here we see Victor getting excited as", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00250-00051971-00052211": "his experiment was successful", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00251-00052212-00052402": "Victor tries to communicate with that", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00252-00052403-00052654": "monster but it does not utter a word", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00253-00052655-00052859": "and that monster keeps standing at that", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00254-00052860-00053057": "place without moving", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00255-00053058-00053266": "the police officer was afraid as that", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00256-00053267-00053519": "monster was looking very dangerous so he", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00257-00053520-00053759": "shoots it taking out his gun", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00258-00053760-00053944": "that injury was very painful to the", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00259-00053945-00054173": "monster so it kills the police officer", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00260-00054174-00054341": "by attacking him", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00261-00054341-00054592": "afterwards that monster starts fighting", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00262-00054594-00054791": "with Victor and Igor and starts harming", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00263-00054791-00054899": "them", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00264-00054900-00055066": "later they both end that monster", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00265-00055067-00055229": "cooperatively", "OOtYXyCM6kM-00266-00055229-00055614": "in the end Victorious"}}, {"audio_id": "OOvpOSJ7fGA", "text": {"OOvpOSJ7fGA-00000-00000026-00000332": "not to be confused with public knowledge", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00001-00000333-00000698": "a nonprofit in Washington DC the public", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00002-00000699-00000890": "knowledge project is a non-profit", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00003-00000891-00001160": "research initiative that is focused on", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00004-00001161-00001406": "the importance of making the results of", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00005-00001407-00001634": "publicly funded research freely", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00006-00001635-00001895": "available through open access policies", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00007-00001896-00002167": "and on developing strategies for making", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00008-00002168-00002390": "this possible including software", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00009-00002391-00002741": "solutions it is a partnership between", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00010-00002742-00002987": "the Faculty of Education at the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00011-00002988-00003263": "University of British Columbia the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00012-00003264-00003461": "Canadian Centre for studies in", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00013-00003461-00003715": "publishing at Simon Fraser University", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00014-00003715-00004088": "the University of Pittsburgh Ontario", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00015-00004089-00004379": "Council of University Libraries the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00016-00004380-00004649": "California digital library in the School", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00017-00004650-00004954": "of Education at Stanford University it", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00018-00004955-00005161": "seeks to improve the scholarly and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00019-00005162-00005411": "public quality of academic research", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00020-00005412-00005642": "through the development of innovative", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00021-00005643-00006352": "online environments", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00022-00006353-00006920": "topic history", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00023-00006922-00007359": "they're pkp was founded in 1998 by John", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00024-00007359-00007587": "Waylan ski in the Department of language", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00025-00007588-00007887": "and literacy education at the Faculty of", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00026-00007888-00008156": "Education at the University of British", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00027-00008158-00008427": "Columbia in Vancouver British Columbia", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00028-00008428-00008748": "Canada based on his research in", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00029-00008749-00009138": "education and publishing will in ski is", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00030-00009139-00009336": "a leading advocate of open access", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00031-00009337-00009552": "publishing and has written extensively", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00032-00009553-00009882": "on the value of public research the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00033-00009883-00010113": "pique peas initial focus was on", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00034-00010114-00010377": "increasing access to scholarly research", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00035-00010378-00010599": "and output beyond the traditional", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00036-00010600-00011010": "academic environments this soon led to a", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00037-00011011-00011222": "related interest in scholarly", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00038-00011223-00011433": "communication and publishing and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00039-00011434-00011676": "especially on ways to make it more", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00040-00011677-00011921": "cost-effective and less reliant on", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00041-00011922-00012126": "commercial enterprises and their", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00042-00012127-00012576": "generally restricted access models pkp", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00043-00012577-00012879": "has developed free open source software", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00044-00012880-00013101": "for the management publishing and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00045-00013102-00013394": "indexing of journals conferences and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00046-00013395-00013911": "monographs the pkp has collaborated with", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00047-00013912-00014187": "a wide range of partners interested in", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00048-00014188-00014416": "making research publicly available", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00049-00014418-00014688": "including the scholarly publishing and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00050-00014688-00015012": "academic resources coalition spark the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00051-00015013-00015215": "Brazilian Institute for information", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00052-00015216-00015608": "Science and Technology IB ICT and the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00053-00015609-00015804": "international network for the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00054-00015805-00016025": "availability of scientific publications", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00055-00016026-00016755": "i na SP together with i na SP the pkp is", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00056-00016756-00017049": "working with publishers librarians and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00057-00017050-00017280": "academics in the development of", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00058-00017281-00017496": "scholarly research portals in the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00059-00017497-00017739": "developing world including african", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00060-00017740-00018015": "journals online age AOL and asia", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00061-00018016-00018474": "journals online as of 2008 the pkp has", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00062-00018475-00018722": "joined the synergies canada initiative", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00063-00018723-00018981": "contributing their technical expertise", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00064-00018982-00019239": "to integrating work being done within a", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00065-00019240-00019493": "five party consortium to create a", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00066-00019494-00019761": "decentralized national platform for", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00067-00019762-00020057": "social sciences and humanities research", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00068-00020058-00020169": "communication", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00069-00020170-00020781": "in Canada", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00070-00020782-00021687": "topic growth 2005 to 2009", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00071-00021688-00021948": "the public knowledge project grew", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00072-00021949-00022656": "between 2005 and 2009 in 2006 there were", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00073-00022657-00022989": "approximately 400 journals using open", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00074-00022990-00023421": "journal systems ojs 50 conferences using", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00075-00023422-00023756": "open conference systems OCS for", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00076-00023757-00024071": "organizations using the harvester and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00077-00024072-00024372": "350 members registered on the online", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00078-00024373-00024906": "support forum in 2009 over 5,000", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00079-00024907-00025269": "journals were using ojs more than 500", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00080-00025270-00025616": "conferences were using OCS at least 10", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00081-00025617-00025872": "organizations are using the harvester", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00082-00025873-00026229": "and there were over 2,400 members on the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00083-00026230-00026727": "support forum since 2005 there were", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00084-00026727-00027018": "major releases version 2 of three", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00085-00027019-00027458": "software modules ojs OCS harvester as", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00086-00027460-00027741": "well as the addition of lemon-aid XML", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00087-00027742-00027995": "with a growing number of downloads being", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00088-00027997-00028220": "recorded every month for all of the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00089-00028222-00028714": "software from June 12 2009 to December", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00090-00028716-00029301": "21st 2009 there were 28,000 451", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00091-00029302-00029988": "downloads of ojs 6000 329 of OCS 12:55", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00092-00029989-00030327": "of the harvester and 1096 of lemonade", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00093-00030327-00030833": "XML a new module open monograph press a", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00094-00030835-00031074": "publication management system for", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00095-00031075-00031500": "monographs has also been released the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00096-00031501-00031830": "pkp also witnessed increased community", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00097-00031831-00032120": "programming contributions including new", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00098-00032122-00032355": "plugins and features such as the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00099-00032356-00032652": "subscription module allowing ojs to", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00100-00032652-00032949": "support full open access delayed open", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00101-00032950-00033267": "access or full subscription only access", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00102-00033268-00033636": "a growing number of translations have", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00103-00033637-00033852": "been contributed by community members", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00104-00033853-00034181": "with Croatian English French German", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00105-00034182-00034548": "Italian Japanese Portuguese Russian", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00106-00034549-00034929": "Spanish Turkish and Vietnamese versions", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00107-00034930-00035062": "of ojs can", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00108-00035063-00035876": "pleated and several others in production", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00109-00035877-00036555": "topic growth from 2010", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00110-00036556-00036965": "a German platform based on ojs is being", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00111-00036966-00037164": "developed by the center for digital", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00112-00037165-00037562": "systems cedis Free University of Berlin", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00113-00037563-00037840": "and two other institutions", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00114-00037841-00038076": "funding by the German Research", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00115-00038077-00038502": "Foundation DFG initially runs from 2014", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00116-00038503-00039232": "to 2016", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00117-00039233-00039958": "topic pkp conferences", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00118-00039959-00040329": "they're pkp holds a biannual conference", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00119-00040330-00040678": "the first pkp scholarly publishing", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00120-00040679-00040962": "conference was held in Vancouver British", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00121-00040963-00041494": "Columbia Canada on July 11 to 13 2007", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00122-00041495-00041731": "and the second peak AP scholarly", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00123-00041732-00041992": "publishing conference was also held in", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00124-00041993-00042526": "Vancouver on July 8 to 10 2009 the third", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00125-00042527-00042832": "peak AP scholarly publishing conference", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00126-00042833-00043215": "was held in Berlin Germany between 26 to", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00127-00043216-00043729": "28 September 2011 the fourth pkp", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00128-00043730-00043965": "scholarly publishing conference was held", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00129-00043966-00044445": "in Mexico City Mexico in August 19 to 21", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00130-00044446-00044796": "2013 notes on the presentations were", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00131-00044797-00045043": "recorded on a scholarly publishing blog", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00132-00045044-00045502": "for both the 2007 and 2009 conferences", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00133-00045503-00045826": "and selected papers from the 2007", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00134-00045827-00046084": "conference were published in a special", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00135-00046085-00046345": "issue of the online journal first Monday", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00136-00046346-00046681": "papers from the 2009 conference are", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00137-00046682-00046915": "available in the inaugural issue of the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00138-00046916-00047115": "journal scholarly and research", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00139-00047116-00047768": "communication", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00140-00047769-00048345": "topic software", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00141-00048346-00048690": "they're pkp suite of software includes", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00142-00048691-00048917": "four separate but interrelated", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00143-00048918-00049146": "applications to demonstrate the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00144-00049147-00049440": "feasibility of open access the open", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00145-00049441-00049698": "journal systems the open conference", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00146-00049699-00050085": "systems the pkp open archives harvester", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00147-00050086-00050558": "and open monograph press pkp briefly", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00148-00050559-00050820": "experimented with a fifth application", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00149-00050821-00051147": "Lemonade XML but has since opted to", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00150-00051148-00051462": "incorporate the XML functionality into", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00151-00051463-00051830": "the existing applications all of the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00152-00051832-00052077": "products are open source and freely", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00153-00052078-00052344": "available to anyone interested in using", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00154-00052345-00052683": "them they share similar technical", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00155-00052684-00053075": "requirements PHP mysql apache or", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00156-00053076-00053544": "microsoft iis 6 and a Linux BSD Solaris", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00157-00053545-00053985": "mac OS X or Windows operating system and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00158-00053986-00054249": "need only a minimal level of technical", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00159-00054250-00054585": "expertise to get up and running in", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00160-00054586-00054852": "addition the software is well supported", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00161-00054853-00055158": "with a free online support forum and a", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00162-00055159-00055386": "growing body of publications and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00163-00055387-00055616": "documentation is available on the", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00164-00055617-00056017": "project website increasingly", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00165-00056019-00056310": "institutions are combining the pkp", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00166-00056311-00056619": "software using ojs to publish their", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00167-00056620-00056942": "research results OCS to organize their", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00168-00056944-00057198": "conferences and publish the proceedings", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00169-00057199-00057513": "and the oai harvester to organize and", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00170-00057514-00057678": "make the metadata from these", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00171-00057679-00058041": "publications searchable together with", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00172-00058041-00058314": "other open-source software applications", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00173-00058315-00058555": "such as dspace for creating", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00174-00058557-00058823": "institutional research repositories", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00175-00058824-00059058": "institutions are creating their own", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00176-00059059-00059259": "infrastructure for sharing their", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00177-00059260-00059930": "research output", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00178-00059932-00060588": "topic involved parties", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00179-00060589-00060857": "it is a partnership among the following", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00180-00060858-00061429": "entities Simon Fraser University library", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00181-00061430-00061721": "the University of British Columbia", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00182-00061722-00062190": "library Canadian Centre for studies in", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00183-00062191-00062569": "publishing at Simon Fraser University", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00184-00062570-00063096": "University of Pittsburgh Ontario Council", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00185-00063097-00063516": "of University Libraries graduate school", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00186-00063516-00064267": "of education at Stanford University", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00187-00064269-00064866": "topic seal so", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00188-00064866-00065330": "list of open access journals list of", "OOvpOSJ7fGA-00189-00065332-00065913": "open access projects open access"}}, {"audio_id": "OOQaU5hCdgY", "text": {"OOQaU5hCdgY-00000-00000053-00000352": "a joint family or undivided family as an", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00001-00000353-00000558": "extended family arrangement prevalent", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00002-00000559-00000692": "throughout the Indian subcontinent", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00003-00000693-00000943": "particularly in India consisting of many", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00004-00000944-00001153": "generations living in the same household", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00005-00001154-00001852": "all bound by the common relationship", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00006-00001853-00002421": "topic family structure", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00007-00002422-00002686": "historically for generations India had a", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00008-00002687-00002884": "prevailing tradition of the joint Hindu", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00009-00002885-00003199": "family or undivided family the system is", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00010-00003200-00003415": "an extended family arrangement prevalent", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00011-00003415-00003546": "throughout the Indian subcontinent", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00012-00003547-00003799": "particularly in India consisting of many", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00013-00003800-00004009": "generations living in the same home all", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00014-00004010-00004300": "bound by the common relationship a joint", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00015-00004301-00004486": "family consists of a husband and wife", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00016-00004487-00004722": "their sons their daughters and so on up", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00017-00004723-00004963": "to generations any number of these", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00018-00004964-00005158": "people may without impacting the legal", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00019-00005159-00005470": "existence of the family be decreased the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00020-00005471-00005650": "family is headed by a senior person", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00021-00005651-00005884": "called a Carta usually the oldest male", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00022-00005885-00006075": "or female who makes decisions on", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00023-00006076-00006303": "economic and social matters on behalf of", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00024-00006304-00006580": "the entire family the patriarchs wife", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00025-00006581-00006766": "generally exerts control over the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00026-00006767-00006988": "household and minor religious practices", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00027-00006989-00007170": "and often wields considerable influence", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00028-00007172-00007492": "in domestic matters family income flows", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00029-00007493-00007720": "into a common pool from which resources", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00030-00007720-00007864": "are drawn to meet the needs of all", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00031-00007865-00008053": "members which are regulated by the heads", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00032-00008054-00008317": "of the family however with urbanization", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00033-00008318-00008548": "and economic development India has", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00034-00008549-00008721": "witnessed a break up of traditional", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00035-00008722-00008908": "joint family into more nuclear like", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00036-00008909-00009088": "families and the traditional joint", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00037-00009089-00009285": "family in India accounted for a small", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00038-00009286-00009585": "number of Indian households a Hindu", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00039-00009586-00009862": "Undivided family or HUF as a legal term", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00040-00009863-00010120": "related to the Hindu Marriage Act the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00041-00010121-00010314": "female members are also given the right", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00042-00010315-00010617": "of share to the property in the HUF the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00043-00010618-00010806": "term finds reference in the provisions", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00044-00010807-00011002": "of the Income Tax Act but the expression", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00045-00011003-00011256": "is not defined in the act there are", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00046-00011257-00011488": "various aspects of Hindu law relevant", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00047-00011489-00011664": "for the purpose assessment of income of", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00048-00011665-00012019": "HUF with Hindu succession Act 1956 an", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00049-00012020-00012321": "Income Tax Act 1961 and wealth in the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00050-00012322-00012570": "status of HUF as well as the impact of", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00051-00012571-00012766": "the provisions of Hindu succession Act", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00052-00012767-00013066": "1956 as amended by Hindu succession", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00053-00013066-00013324": "Amendment Act 2005 relevant for the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00054-00013325-00013501": "purpose of assessment of income and", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00055-00013502-00013705": "wealth in the status of HUF under the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00056-00013706-00014101": "Income Tax Act 1961 in the case of", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00057-00014102-00014653": "Surjeet Lal Chopra 101 ITR 776 SC joint", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00058-00014654-00014830": "family and undivided family are", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00059-00014831-00014893": "synonymous", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00060-00014894-00015175": "a joint Hindu family consists of persons", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00061-00015176-00015369": "lineally descended from a common", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00062-00015369-00015613": "ancestor and includes their wives and", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00063-00015613-00015774": "unmarried daughters", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00064-00015775-00016035": "the daughter on marriage ceases to be a", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00065-00016036-00016230": "member of her father's family and", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00066-00016231-00016587": "becomes a member of her husband's family", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00067-00016588-00016869": "in 2016 a judgement of the Delhi High", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00068-00016870-00017031": "Court ruled that the eldest female", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00069-00017032-00017280": "member of a Hindu Undivided family can", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00070-00017281-00017972": "be its car top manager", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00071-00017973-00018498": "topic relationships", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00072-00018499-00018708": "different relationships are addressed", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00073-00018709-00018906": "via different names the nature of", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00074-00018907-00019200": "relationship also varies relations can", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00075-00019201-00019410": "be of equivalence mutual respect or", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00076-00019411-00019716": "teasing in nature in joint families in", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00077-00019717-00019896": "northern and central India between a", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00078-00019897-00020106": "bride or sister-in-law and her younger", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00079-00020107-00020310": "brother-in-law a joking or teasing", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00080-00020311-00020466": "relationship as common and the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00081-00020467-00020664": "relationship towards an older brother in", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00082-00020665-00020952": "law is that of respectfulness in a", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00083-00020953-00021165": "traditional joint hindu family there is", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00084-00021166-00021354": "a subservient relationship between the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00085-00021355-00021537": "wives of the brothers the patriarchs", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00086-00021538-00021792": "wife is addressed as baddie bhabhi in", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00087-00021793-00022173": "hindi meaning eldest brother's wife she", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00088-00022174-00022320": "has traditionally considered the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00089-00022321-00022494": "mistress of the house and is in charge", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00090-00022495-00022671": "of running the household Affairs and", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00091-00022672-00022911": "overseeing the servants if any the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00092-00022912-00023076": "subsequent younger brothers wives", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00093-00023077-00023304": "typically seek her advice and permission", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00094-00023305-00023505": "for any matters decisions regarding the", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00095-00023506-00024171": "household and rearing of the children", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00096-00024172-00024712": "topic see also", "OOQaU5hCdgY-00097-00024713-00025246": "nuclear family extended family"}}, {"audio_id": "OPn84Eu5Uwg", "text": {"OPn84Eu5Uwg-00000-00002472-00002971": "[Laughter]", "OPn84Eu5Uwg-00001-00002972-00004464": "[Music]", "OPn84Eu5Uwg-00002-00004465-00005618": "[Music]", "OPn84Eu5Uwg-00003-00005619-00005975": "[Music]", "OPn84Eu5Uwg-00004-00005976-00006300": "blah blah"}}, {"audio_id": "OPtbCySiWdg", "text": {"OPtbCySiWdg-00000-00000005-00000296": "the Sherbourne complex is a joint land", "OPtbCySiWdg-00001-00000297-00000503": "management venture of the US Fish and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00002-00000504-00000686": "Wildlife Service the Louisiana", "OPtbCySiWdg-00003-00000687-00000979": "Department of Wildlife and Fisheries ldw", "OPtbCySiWdg-00004-00000980-00001160": "F and the US Army Corps of Engineers", "OPtbCySiWdg-00005-00001161-00001591": "that began in 1983 the area consists of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00006-00001592-00001937": "44,000 acres 180 square kilometers and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00007-00001938-00002120": "is managed by the Louisiana Department", "OPtbCySiWdg-00008-00002121-00002467": "of Wildlife and Fisheries the complex is", "OPtbCySiWdg-00009-00002468-00002692": "located in the Morganza floodway system", "OPtbCySiWdg-00010-00002693-00002921": "of the Atchafalaya Basin about 30 miles", "OPtbCySiWdg-00011-00002922-00003151": "48 kilometres west of Baton Rouge", "OPtbCySiWdg-00012-00003152-00003353": "Louisiana and actually extends a little", "OPtbCySiWdg-00013-00003354-00003547": "south of the i-10 Atchafalaya Basin", "OPtbCySiWdg-00014-00003548-00003869": "bridgett whiskey Bay Louisiana the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00015-00003870-00004058": "bridge crosses the whiskey Bay pilot", "OPtbCySiWdg-00016-00004059-00004445": "channel located on the gravel del a 975", "OPtbCySiWdg-00017-00004446-00004645": "the West boundary is on the east side of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00018-00004646-00004822": "the Atchafalaya River with the east", "OPtbCySiWdg-00019-00004823-00005027": "boundary being the East protection levee", "OPtbCySiWdg-00020-00005028-00005315": "the complex stretches just north of Old", "OPtbCySiWdg-00021-00005316-00005615": "Highway 190 and a short distance to the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00022-00005616-00005911": "south of i-10 the nearest town is Krotz", "OPtbCySiWdg-00023-00005912-00006379": "Springs to the north of us 190 topic", "OPtbCySiWdg-00024-00006380-00006605": "history the Atchafalaya Basin is in the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00025-00006606-00006791": "lower Mississippi River area of the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00026-00006792-00007064": "Mississippi River Delta the culmination", "OPtbCySiWdg-00027-00007065-00007253": "of events that eventually led to the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00028-00007254-00007481": "existence of wildlife management areas", "OPtbCySiWdg-00029-00007481-00007655": "in the basin in general and the sherry", "OPtbCySiWdg-00030-00007656-00007877": "burn complex in particular began after", "OPtbCySiWdg-00031-00007878-00008221": "the great flood of 1844 and 1851 the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00032-00008222-00008546": "great flood of 1927 prompted the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00033-00008547-00008749": "Louisiana Legislature to pass several", "OPtbCySiWdg-00034-00008750-00008963": "flood control bills including the Flood", "OPtbCySiWdg-00035-00008964-00009217": "Control Act of 1928 as well as", "OPtbCySiWdg-00036-00009218-00009473": "Mississippi River and tributaries mrn T", "OPtbCySiWdg-00037-00009474-00009556": "project", "OPtbCySiWdg-00038-00009557-00009773": "the result was the Atchafalaya Basin", "OPtbCySiWdg-00039-00009774-00010064": "flood way system channelization whiskey", "OPtbCySiWdg-00040-00010065-00010237": "Bay cutoff and bank stabilization", "OPtbCySiWdg-00041-00010238-00010648": "projects during the 1930s and 1940s", "OPtbCySiWdg-00042-00010649-00010883": "extensive dredging was performed on the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00043-00010884-00011239": "Atchafalaya in 1954 after the great", "OPtbCySiWdg-00044-00011240-00011552": "flood of 1951 major dredging was resumed", "OPtbCySiWdg-00045-00011553-00011912": "by the Corps in 1963 the old river", "OPtbCySiWdg-00046-00011913-00012116": "control structure was built to prevent", "OPtbCySiWdg-00047-00012117-00012281": "the capture of the Mississippi by the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00048-00012282-00012628": "Atchafalaya in 1968 because of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00049-00012629-00012833": "environmental concerns as well as a lack", "OPtbCySiWdg-00050-00012834-00013155": "of funds dredging was discontinued in", "OPtbCySiWdg-00051-00013156-00013393": "1972 the Louisiana Congress", "OPtbCySiWdg-00052-00013394-00013719": "enacted act 365 that established the H", "OPtbCySiWdg-00053-00013721-00013894": "flayer Basin division within the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00054-00013894-00014188": "Department of Public Works the Corps was", "OPtbCySiWdg-00055-00014188-00014359": "directed to develop a plan for the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00056-00014360-00014590": "Atchafalaya Basin which was completed in", "OPtbCySiWdg-00057-00014591-00014836": "1982 and became the Atchafalaya Basin", "OPtbCySiWdg-00058-00014837-00015405": "floodway system project a BFS in 1983", "OPtbCySiWdg-00059-00015406-00015760": "10230 two acres 41.4 one square", "OPtbCySiWdg-00060-00015761-00015946": "kilometres were purchased by the state", "OPtbCySiWdg-00061-00015947-00016105": "for the creation of the Sherbourne", "OPtbCySiWdg-00062-00016106-00016468": "Wildlife Management Area in 1985", "OPtbCySiWdg-00063-00016469-00016795": "Louisiana public law 99 to 88 was", "OPtbCySiWdg-00064-00016796-00016984": "enacted to authorize a multi-purpose", "OPtbCySiWdg-00065-00016985-00018232": "plan topic state authorization in 1986", "OPtbCySiWdg-00066-00018233-00018498": "the United States Congress approved", "OPtbCySiWdg-00067-00018499-00018751": "250,000 dollars towards the creation of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00068-00018752-00018946": "the Atchafalaya Basin program in", "OPtbCySiWdg-00069-00018947-00019375": "Louisiana public law 99 to 662 section", "OPtbCySiWdg-00070-00019376-00019669": "906 stated the plan to be of national", "OPtbCySiWdg-00071-00019670-00019960": "interests governor foster appointed the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00072-00019961-00020116": "Louisiana Department of Natural", "OPtbCySiWdg-00073-00020117-00020308": "Resources to work with the Corps of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00074-00020309-00020518": "Engineers to produce the Atchafalaya", "OPtbCySiWdg-00075-00020519-00020869": "Basin master plan for the development of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00076-00020870-00021214": "the basin in 1988 a plan was implemented", "OPtbCySiWdg-00077-00021215-00021343": "and the current alliance was formed", "OPtbCySiWdg-00078-00021344-00021643": "section 4.4 one B of the master plan", "OPtbCySiWdg-00079-00021644-00022432": "creating the Sherbourne complex topic", "OPtbCySiWdg-00080-00022433-00023068": "sherburn complex the Sherbourne complex", "OPtbCySiWdg-00081-00023069-00023242": "combines the Sherbourne Wildlife", "OPtbCySiWdg-00082-00023243-00023569": "Management Area WMA at shafilea National", "OPtbCySiWdg-00083-00023570-00023803": "Wildlife Refuge and the US Army Corps of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00084-00023804-00024061": "Engineers bio DES our sirs bio of the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00085-00024062-00024259": "Bears with the intent of conservation", "OPtbCySiWdg-00086-00024260-00024444": "and management of all fish and wildlife", "OPtbCySiWdg-00087-00024445-00024724": "within the boundaries of the complex the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00088-00024725-00025027": "entire area is classified as bottomland", "OPtbCySiWdg-00089-00025028-00025336": "hardwoods the area contains swamps", "OPtbCySiWdg-00090-00025337-00025600": "overflow lakes and many bayous this", "OPtbCySiWdg-00091-00025601-00025813": "provides opportunities for scientific", "OPtbCySiWdg-00092-00025814-00026038": "research environmental education and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00093-00026039-00026283": "fish and wildlife oriented recreation", "OPtbCySiWdg-00094-00026285-00026587": "the three combined areas of her ATV", "OPtbCySiWdg-00095-00026588-00026773": "trails - campgrounds a", "OPtbCySiWdg-00096-00026774-00027073": "range and boat launchers there is also a", "OPtbCySiWdg-00097-00027074-00027385": "17-mile 27 kilometers marked paddling", "OPtbCySiWdg-00098-00027386-00027574": "trail that let's visitors tour the Bayou", "OPtbCySiWdg-00099-00027575-00027855": "without a guide recreations also", "OPtbCySiWdg-00100-00027856-00028042": "includes birding and nature watching", "OPtbCySiWdg-00101-00028043-00028287": "hunting fishing trapping camping and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00102-00028288-00028504": "nature photography all complemented by", "OPtbCySiWdg-00103-00028505-00029777": "all-weather roads topic sherburn WMA", "OPtbCySiWdg-00104-00029778-00030187": "11780 acres 47.7 square kilometers are", "OPtbCySiWdg-00105-00030188-00030387": "owned by the Louisiana Department of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00106-00030388-00030673": "Wildlife and Fisheries the headquarters", "OPtbCySiWdg-00107-00030674-00030996": "is located 3 miles 4.8 kilometers south", "OPtbCySiWdg-00108-00030997-00031330": "of khat springs on la 975 in Pointe", "OPtbCySiWdg-00109-00031331-00031633": "Coupee Parish 15 miles 24 kilometers", "OPtbCySiWdg-00110-00031633-00031918": "north of i-10 the office is the site of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00111-00031919-00032104": "the Sherbourne ghost town which was a", "OPtbCySiWdg-00112-00032105-00032364": "logging town from the 1880s to the 1930s", "OPtbCySiWdg-00113-00032365-00032620": "and ceased to exist after the timber was", "OPtbCySiWdg-00114-00032620-00033406": "exhausted topic at shafilea National", "OPtbCySiWdg-00115-00033407-00033990": "Wildlife Refuge an area of fifteen", "OPtbCySiWdg-00116-00033991-00034158": "thousand two hundred and twenty acres", "OPtbCySiWdg-00117-00034159-00034408": "sixty one point six square kilometers", "OPtbCySiWdg-00118-00034409-00034635": "set aside as a National Wildlife Refuge", "OPtbCySiWdg-00119-00034636-00034945": "established in 1986 is part of the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00120-00034946-00035236": "complex Atchafalaya is a chopped or", "OPtbCySiWdg-00121-00035237-00035445": "Native American word Hatcher for river", "OPtbCySiWdg-00122-00035446-00035764": "and falaya for long or long river all", "OPtbCySiWdg-00123-00035765-00035995": "persons older than 16 or younger than", "OPtbCySiWdg-00124-00035996-00036262": "sixty using wildlife management areas in", "OPtbCySiWdg-00125-00036263-00036457": "the state of Louisiana including the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00126-00036458-00036652": "refuge for any reason other than just", "OPtbCySiWdg-00127-00036653-00037008": "traveling la 975 must purchase a wild", "OPtbCySiWdg-00128-00037009-00037210": "Louisiana stamp hunting or fishing", "OPtbCySiWdg-00129-00037211-00037943": "license or pay a daily charge of $2", "OPtbCySiWdg-00130-00037944-00038529": "topic bio des hours", "OPtbCySiWdg-00131-00038530-00038874": "an area of 17,000 acres 69 square", "OPtbCySiWdg-00132-00038875-00039114": "kilometres is owned by the US Army Corps", "OPtbCySiWdg-00133-00039115-00039408": "of Engineers the name means bio of the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00134-00039409-00039533": "bears and is across the Atchafalaya", "OPtbCySiWdg-00135-00039534-00039768": "River from twenty eight thousand five", "OPtbCySiWdg-00136-00039769-00039968": "hundred acres one hundred and fifteen", "OPtbCySiWdg-00137-00039969-00040182": "square kilometers of core land called", "OPtbCySiWdg-00138-00040183-00040508": "Indian Bayou the area also includes the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00139-00040509-00041590": "South farm unit topic Atchafalaya Basin", "OPtbCySiWdg-00140-00041591-00041843": "the combined area of the Sherbourne", "OPtbCySiWdg-00141-00041844-00042051": "complex is part of the Atchafalaya Basin", "OPtbCySiWdg-00142-00042052-00042270": "the nation's largest river swamp", "OPtbCySiWdg-00143-00042271-00042515": "containing almost 1 million acres four", "OPtbCySiWdg-00144-00042516-00042798": "thousand square kilometres the basin", "OPtbCySiWdg-00145-00042799-00042993": "begins near tzimmes port and stretches", "OPtbCySiWdg-00146-00042994-00043389": "some 140 miles 230 kilometres southward", "OPtbCySiWdg-00147-00043390-00043532": "to the Gulf of Mexico", "OPtbCySiWdg-00148-00043533-00043827": "currently the Atchafalaya Basin is bound", "OPtbCySiWdg-00149-00043828-00044012": "by natural ridges formed by levee", "OPtbCySiWdg-00150-00044013-00044189": "building along active and abandoned", "OPtbCySiWdg-00151-00044190-00044454": "courses of the Mississippi River around", "OPtbCySiWdg-00152-00044455-00044702": "60 species of reptiles and amphibians", "OPtbCySiWdg-00153-00044703-00044987": "along with over 250 species of birds", "OPtbCySiWdg-00154-00044988-00045198": "including the American bald eagle and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00155-00045199-00045399": "the peregrine falcon can be found in", "OPtbCySiWdg-00156-00045400-00045668": "this productive region many types of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00157-00045669-00045867": "animal life and nearly 100 different", "OPtbCySiWdg-00158-00045868-00046076": "species of fish and aquatic life can", "OPtbCySiWdg-00159-00046077-00046895": "also be found in the basin topic oil and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00160-00046896-00047477": "gas there are extensive gas pipelines", "OPtbCySiWdg-00161-00047478-00047705": "with names such as Gulf central pipeline", "OPtbCySiWdg-00162-00047706-00047933": "dixie pipeline dow pipeline gas", "OPtbCySiWdg-00163-00047934-00048146": "gathering pipeline as well as oil wells", "OPtbCySiWdg-00164-00048147-00049211": "located in the area topic controversy", "OPtbCySiWdg-00165-00049212-00049462": "since 2001 and the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00166-00049463-00049672": "controversy overrode tree right-of-way", "OPtbCySiWdg-00167-00049673-00049852": "clear-cutting for oil wells many", "OPtbCySiWdg-00168-00049853-00050065": "agencies and organizations give input", "OPtbCySiWdg-00169-00050066-00050305": "oversight and management assistance to", "OPtbCySiWdg-00170-00050306-00050527": "the Louisiana Department of Wildlife and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00171-00050528-00050713": "Fisheries concerning the protection and", "OPtbCySiWdg-00172-00050714-00050980": "future of the complex right-of-way", "OPtbCySiWdg-00173-00050981-00051204": "clearings for a new road to allow access", "OPtbCySiWdg-00174-00051205-00051394": "to oil wells allowed cutting of kite", "OPtbCySiWdg-00175-00051395-00051523": "nesting trees at the height of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00176-00051524-00051829": "neotropical migrant breeding season the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00177-00051829-00052000": "results including a meeting at the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00178-00052001-00052282": "Sherbourne WMA headquarters August 14", "OPtbCySiWdg-00179-00052283-00052585": "2001 resulted in many changes in the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00180-00052586-00052783": "policies of the complex including that", "OPtbCySiWdg-00181-00052784-00052972": "there will be no further implementation", "OPtbCySiWdg-00182-00052973-00053158": "of forestry prescriptions during the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00183-00053159-00053442": "breeding season the Louisiana natural", "OPtbCySiWdg-00184-00053444-00053716": "heritage program within the ldw F is", "OPtbCySiWdg-00185-00053716-00053929": "part of the Nature Conservancy along", "OPtbCySiWdg-00186-00053929-00054103": "with other organizations with the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00187-00054104-00054289": "responsibility of ensuring that the", "OPtbCySiWdg-00188-00054290-00054480": "protection of the natural integrity of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00189-00054482-00054661": "the complex is maintained within all", "OPtbCySiWdg-00190-00054662-00054787": "aspects of planning and implementation", "OPtbCySiWdg-00191-00054788-00056053": "of future decisions topic see also list", "OPtbCySiWdg-00192-00056054-00056366": "of national wildlife refuges louisiana", "OPtbCySiWdg-00193-00056367-00056719": "interstate 10 in louisiana list of", "OPtbCySiWdg-00194-00056720-00057327": "louisiana wildlife management areas", "OPtbCySiWdg-00195-00057328-00058086": "topic great floods great flood of 1844", "OPtbCySiWdg-00196-00058087-00058699": "flood of 1851 great flood of 1951 great", "OPtbCySiWdg-00197-00058700-00058996": "flood of 1993"}}, {"audio_id": "OPLH18E8DNI", "text": {"OPLH18E8DNI-00000-00000020-00000028": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00001-00000029-00001286": "foreign", "OPLH18E8DNI-00002-00001287-00002019": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00003-00002020-00003269": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00004-00003270-00003881": "through", "OPLH18E8DNI-00005-00003882-00004156": "the wastelands through the highways to", "OPLH18E8DNI-00006-00004157-00005004": "my Shadows", "OPLH18E8DNI-00007-00005005-00005871": "through the highways", "OPLH18E8DNI-00008-00005872-00006605": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00009-00006606-00006976": "thank you", "OPLH18E8DNI-00010-00006977-00008309": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00011-00008310-00008587": "finding Life along the way", "OPLH18E8DNI-00012-00008588-00008921": "Melodies we haven't played", "OPLH18E8DNI-00013-00008922-00009360": "no I don't want no rest", "OPLH18E8DNI-00014-00009361-00009760": "like going around these walls fighting", "OPLH18E8DNI-00015-00009761-00010007": "to create a song", "OPLH18E8DNI-00016-00010008-00011014": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00017-00011015-00011195": "through the wastelands through the", "OPLH18E8DNI-00018-00011196-00012021": "highways to my shadow turns to sunrays", "OPLH18E8DNI-00019-00012022-00015090": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00020-00015091-00015811": "[Applause]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00021-00015812-00017004": "thousands and we'll grow in numbers", "OPLH18E8DNI-00022-00017005-00017242": "[Applause]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00023-00017243-00019649": "[Music]", "OPLH18E8DNI-00024-00019650-00019816": "thank you", "OPLH18E8DNI-00025-00019817-00020699": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OPVYIkVrAao", "text": {"OPVYIkVrAao-00000-00000035-00000391": "Tigers doing his is and today I'm being", "OPVYIkVrAao-00001-00000392-00000580": "like a boss fight map they you let's go", "OPVYIkVrAao-00002-00000581-00000761": "customize", "OPVYIkVrAao-00003-00000762-00002201": "[Music]", "OPVYIkVrAao-00004-00002202-00002964": "[Music]", "OPVYIkVrAao-00005-00002965-00003247": "so once you guys load into the map if", "OPVYIkVrAao-00006-00003247-00003486": "Griggs can please support me by using my", "OPVYIkVrAao-00007-00003487-00003718": "code ace whitey which does help me out a", "OPVYIkVrAao-00008-00003719-00003985": "lot if you guys are new make sure to", "OPVYIkVrAao-00009-00003986-00004531": "drop a like so when I first started to", "OPVYIkVrAao-00010-00004532-00004747": "make this map I wanted to make a map", "OPVYIkVrAao-00011-00004748-00004968": "that you guys could customize the way", "OPVYIkVrAao-00012-00004969-00005175": "you wanted to play us to customize the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00013-00005176-00005350": "map you play in the woods wicker", "OPVYIkVrAao-00014-00005351-00005532": "customize the mode did you use or", "OPVYIkVrAao-00015-00005533-00005631": "free-for-all", "OPVYIkVrAao-00016-00005632-00005832": "one who wants to be two is you know four", "OPVYIkVrAao-00017-00005833-00005961": "before three threes", "OPVYIkVrAao-00018-00005962-00006220": "you guys could change the load up that", "OPVYIkVrAao-00019-00006221-00006486": "you guys have you guys could choose the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00020-00006487-00006631": "weapons that you guys you would you", "OPVYIkVrAao-00021-00006631-00006802": "basically literally do anything you want", "OPVYIkVrAao-00022-00006803-00006981": "in this map so I'm gonna be showcasing", "OPVYIkVrAao-00023-00006983-00007165": "the maps first then I'm gonna be", "OPVYIkVrAao-00024-00007166-00007408": "showcasing the weapons changes and the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00025-00007409-00007612": "free-for-all let's just start off with I", "OPVYIkVrAao-00026-00007613-00007821": "have a wagers one of your map this is", "OPVYIkVrAao-00027-00007822-00008065": "basically a map where it's not a lot", "OPVYIkVrAao-00028-00008066-00008313": "going on it's just a regular map where", "OPVYIkVrAao-00029-00008314-00008563": "people could you know wager they want a", "OPVYIkVrAao-00030-00008564-00008782": "simple thing so the map cook food and", "OPVYIkVrAao-00031-00008783-00009010": "nothing basically Bobby run so this is a", "OPVYIkVrAao-00032-00009011-00009096": "map for them", "OPVYIkVrAao-00033-00009097-00009637": "he went for 2v2 3v3 and for you as you", "OPVYIkVrAao-00034-00009638-00009828": "see it's just a basic map that you could", "OPVYIkVrAao-00035-00009829-00010149": "use and the guns are a are shotgun a", "OPVYIkVrAao-00036-00010150-00010456": "slip fridge and too many's with mats and", "OPVYIkVrAao-00037-00010457-00010846": "ammo so if you just want to change the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00038-00010847-00010987": "map all you just have to do is change", "OPVYIkVrAao-00039-00010988-00011199": "the team it's literally five different", "OPVYIkVrAao-00040-00011200-00011449": "maps that you could choose from and I'll", "OPVYIkVrAao-00041-00011450-00011710": "talk about this map later but the next", "OPVYIkVrAao-00042-00011711-00011892": "model I'm gonna show is the Neo map it", "OPVYIkVrAao-00043-00011893-00012106": "was inspired by obviously please who", "OPVYIkVrAao-00044-00012107-00012424": "make the map I just recreated it and put", "OPVYIkVrAao-00045-00012425-00012655": "my own twist on it as you see once you", "OPVYIkVrAao-00046-00012656-00012894": "load in its the new map that we", "OPVYIkVrAao-00047-00012895-00013281": "basically used I just recreated it with", "OPVYIkVrAao-00048-00013282-00013612": "my own twist so you can choose from any", "OPVYIkVrAao-00049-00013613-00013803": "box type map that you want just by", "OPVYIkVrAao-00050-00013804-00014026": "Canada team if I made a really", "OPVYIkVrAao-00051-00014027-00014251": "they're both so I just have to do is", "OPVYIkVrAao-00052-00014252-00014416": "just change the dreams and you just be", "OPVYIkVrAao-00053-00014416-00014626": "able to you know come to this unique box", "OPVYIkVrAao-00054-00014627-00014821": "like map we could go for clips though", "OPVYIkVrAao-00055-00014822-00015004": "the next map I'm gonna be showing you", "OPVYIkVrAao-00056-00015005-00015211": "this the aesthetic map that I made", "OPVYIkVrAao-00057-00015212-00015463": "before it was a video that I made couple", "OPVYIkVrAao-00058-00015463-00015685": "of weeks ago or just have to do is once", "OPVYIkVrAao-00059-00015686-00015871": "again go to team six and the other one", "OPVYIkVrAao-00060-00015872-00016126": "go to team five and just start the game", "OPVYIkVrAao-00061-00016127-00016285": "it's a map that I made before it's", "OPVYIkVrAao-00062-00016286-00016503": "pretty aesthetic it looks pretty clean", "OPVYIkVrAao-00063-00016504-00016774": "so I made this map pretty simple it's", "OPVYIkVrAao-00064-00016775-00017011": "just really clean there's not a lot", "OPVYIkVrAao-00065-00017012-00017248": "going on and it just looks really cool", "OPVYIkVrAao-00066-00017249-00017749": "once you're one-to-one so the second to", "OPVYIkVrAao-00067-00017750-00017911": "last month I'll be showing you guys the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00068-00017912-00018169": "water map this is really cool it's just", "OPVYIkVrAao-00069-00018170-00018340": "simple I didn't see a lot of people make", "OPVYIkVrAao-00070-00018341-00018580": "like the water box like map so I decided", "OPVYIkVrAao-00071-00018581-00018862": "to make one myself so once you load in", "OPVYIkVrAao-00072-00018863-00019063": "you can see the maps looks pretty clean", "OPVYIkVrAao-00073-00019064-00019330": "and pretty I didn't see anyone make a", "OPVYIkVrAao-00074-00019331-00019531": "water box pipe map I might do a tutorial", "OPVYIkVrAao-00075-00019532-00019744": "on this and you know add on to the map", "OPVYIkVrAao-00076-00019745-00019951": "for future videos we're just want to see", "OPVYIkVrAao-00077-00019952-00020218": "it but the map looks really cool and", "OPVYIkVrAao-00078-00020219-00020611": "it's just simple there so the last", "OPVYIkVrAao-00079-00020612-00020827": "unique map I'm gonna show you guys is a", "OPVYIkVrAao-00080-00020828-00021157": "6x6 free-for-all map up to six people go", "OPVYIkVrAao-00081-00021158-00021373": "play on it so all you guys have to do is", "OPVYIkVrAao-00082-00021374-00021649": "get six people and or you can even get", "OPVYIkVrAao-00083-00021650-00021823": "three people it doesn't matter just", "OPVYIkVrAao-00084-00021824-00022108": "change from team's 11 to 16 so one", "OPVYIkVrAao-00085-00022109-00022300": "person will go to team eleven other word", "OPVYIkVrAao-00086-00022301-00022729": "12 13 14 15 and up to 16 and you're just", "OPVYIkVrAao-00087-00022730-00022924": "gonna change teams I'm just gonna show", "OPVYIkVrAao-00088-00022925-00023248": "you guys this right now so it's a cool 6", "OPVYIkVrAao-00089-00023249-00023544": "by 6 map it's just simple and everyone", "OPVYIkVrAao-00090-00023545-00023902": "will have their own box it's being too", "OPVYIkVrAao-00091-00023903-00024079": "crowded since there's a lot of space for", "OPVYIkVrAao-00092-00024080-00024349": "you guys to box like up to 6 people to", "OPVYIkVrAao-00093-00024350-00024799": "box about over here so the last thing", "OPVYIkVrAao-00094-00024800-00024922": "that I'm gonna be showing you guys is", "OPVYIkVrAao-00095-00024923-00025138": "this map right here I called their wager", "OPVYIkVrAao-00096-00025139-00025498": "map v2 so this is basically for the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00097-00025499-00025732": "people who want to use an SMG in their", "OPVYIkVrAao-00098-00025733-00025900": "map I don't know a lot of people that", "OPVYIkVrAao-00099-00025901-00026077": "does but there are just some people out", "OPVYIkVrAao-00100-00026077-00026236": "there that likes to use the SMGs in", "OPVYIkVrAao-00101-00026237-00026497": "their map and I just wanted to make like", "OPVYIkVrAao-00102-00026498-00026679": "a map for them where they could do", "OPVYIkVrAao-00103-00026680-00027049": "wagers and use SMG if they wanted to so", "OPVYIkVrAao-00104-00027050-00027166": "all you have to do is change", "OPVYIkVrAao-00105-00027167-00027505": "from Team 9 or to team 10 strange to any", "OPVYIkVrAao-00106-00027506-00027676": "of them and then as you see right here", "OPVYIkVrAao-00107-00027677-00027913": "we have an SMG is basically the same", "OPVYIkVrAao-00108-00027914-00028141": "thing as the first vision map the only", "OPVYIkVrAao-00109-00028142-00028363": "thing that's different is the SMG and", "OPVYIkVrAao-00110-00028364-00028519": "everything else is basically the same", "OPVYIkVrAao-00111-00028520-00028729": "the match the ammo and everything else", "OPVYIkVrAao-00112-00028730-00028983": "will change so that'll be it for the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00113-00028985-00029145": "video I hope you guys did enjoy this", "OPVYIkVrAao-00114-00029147-00029283": "custom map where you guys could", "OPVYIkVrAao-00115-00029285-00029548": "basically customize the map you use the", "OPVYIkVrAao-00116-00029549-00029820": "loadout you use the mode that you play", "OPVYIkVrAao-00117-00029822-00029983": "in free-for-all what you want to be", "OPVYIkVrAao-00118-00029983-00030274": "choose etc and literally you guys could", "OPVYIkVrAao-00119-00030275-00030472": "do anything you want in this map I'm", "OPVYIkVrAao-00120-00030473-00030601": "pretty sure I'm one of the first person", "OPVYIkVrAao-00121-00030602-00030757": "to make a map like this that is box", "OPVYIkVrAao-00122-00030758-00030898": "fighting and literally you could choose", "OPVYIkVrAao-00123-00030899-00031111": "whatever you want so I hope you guys do", "OPVYIkVrAao-00124-00031112-00031294": "enjoy this video make sure to drop a", "OPVYIkVrAao-00125-00031295-00031531": "like subscribe your question you turn on", "OPVYIkVrAao-00126-00031532-00031702": "post notifications and I'll see you guys", "OPVYIkVrAao-00127-00031702-00031983": "next time", "OPVYIkVrAao-00128-00031985-00033392": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OQ0EJG6Wx_U", "text": {"OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00000-00000000-00000167": "hey guys it's me matthew and today we", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00001-00000168-00000375": "are playing halo last episode i crashed", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00002-00000376-00000503": "my car and went through a bunch of", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00003-00000504-00000711": "aliens now we're trying to", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00004-00000712-00001007": "kill this break this gun thing uh either", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00005-00001008-00001174": "way i hope you enjoyed the video and now", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00006-00001175-00001407": "let's get to it", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00007-00001408-00001558": "i'm gonna guess those guns up there oh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00008-00001559-00001663": "wait", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00009-00001664-00001902": "yeah bruh i'm guessing those sensors are", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00010-00001903-00002079": "doing something", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00011-00002080-00002183": "wrong", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00012-00002184-00002342": "attack", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00013-00002343-00002526": "i always forgot to do it okay we gotta", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00014-00002527-00002767": "go back", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00015-00002768-00003209": "you gotta go somewhere", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00016-00003210-00004063": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00017-00004064-00005318": "how does that not work okay please", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00018-00005319-00005559": "and at that moment i realized that uh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00019-00005560-00005767": "you really just need to punch the legs", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00020-00005768-00005959": "uh those thousands of hours of each", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00021-00005960-00006159": "punching the center was wait is all", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00022-00006160-00006351": "wasted because i just needed to punch", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00023-00006352-00006663": "the legs in the top part", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00024-00006664-00006775": "all right sure", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00025-00006776-00007206": "hey ghost can you well get off camp", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00026-00007208-00007391": "that works too you kind of wanted to", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00027-00007392-00007527": "drive that", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00028-00007528-00007646": "everything", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00029-00007647-00008014": "can't do that", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00030-00008015-00008255": "i don't know let's go let's go", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00031-00008256-00008383": "there's no", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00032-00008384-00011063": "oh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00033-00011064-00011910": "yeah that's a good idea", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00034-00011911-00012127": "there we go there that sounds that's", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00035-00012128-00012799": "what i call some ghosting", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00036-00012800-00012974": "all right let's just", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00037-00012975-00013135": "murder these people", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00038-00013136-00013335": "oh another thing but this is actually", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00039-00013336-00013575": "kind of dangerous", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00040-00013576-00013766": "you have to do some different darn stuff", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00041-00013768-00013879": "about it", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00042-00013880-00014086": "i don't know", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00043-00014087-00014607": "i", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00044-00014608-00015558": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00045-00015559-00015766": "i love it oh wow looking really look at", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00046-00015768-00015991": "that that's just that's just a sight to", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00047-00015991-00016311": "see", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00048-00016312-00016486": "i forgot people are trying to stop me", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00049-00016487-00016686": "from comparing these posts see what", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00050-00016687-00016935": "those people get those people getting", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00051-00016936-00017047": "neo", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00052-00017048-00017535": "wow", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00053-00017536-00017999": "those people still get a case of neo", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00054-00018000-00018230": "all right a few people have no life or", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00055-00018231-00018430": "at least until here you are merely just", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00056-00018431-00018686": "pawns literally like you're the party", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00057-00018687-00018847": "but you can't even turn into a queen", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00058-00018848-00018991": "they're like the worser version of the", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00059-00018992-00019103": "pawn", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00060-00019104-00019399": "oh my god another one", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00061-00019400-00019543": "do you have a funny animation if you", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00062-00019544-00020239": "shoot them in the right problem oh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00063-00020240-00020375": "wow", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00064-00020376-00020463": "wow", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00065-00020464-00020567": "wow", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00066-00020568-00020663": "wow", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00067-00020664-00020927": "wow", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00068-00020928-00021239": "i think i know how to do this", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00069-00021240-00021614": "that's english alive we are good to go", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00070-00021615-00022661": "oh it just makes you lose you know yes", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00071-00022662-00022935": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00072-00022936-00023078": "oh i did", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00073-00023079-00023439": "oh shoot okay", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00074-00023440-00023607": "permission to commence", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00075-00023608-00025078": "heading two to four point six", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00076-00025079-00026039": "it's been neutralized where is", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00077-00026039-00026327": "okay so we cannot drop our gun because", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00078-00026327-00026470": "you know we don't want to do that but we", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00079-00026472-00028958": "have to get into the car all right", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00080-00028960-00029158": "i'm dead now sorry can you say that", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00081-00029160-00030823": "again thanks", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00082-00030824-00031014": "okay i didn't actually get what she said", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00083-00031016-00031151": "so this is actually a good time to", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00084-00031152-00031399": "listen to four bombing run hitting two", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00085-00031400-00031895": "two four point six permission", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00086-00031895-00032023": "southwest", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00087-00032024-00032279": "southwest southwest where's six in the", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00088-00032280-00035095": "southern", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00089-00035096-00035351": "but yeah i don't even appreciate it so", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00090-00035352-00035886": "can you please chill out man no thanks", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00091-00035887-00036007": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00092-00036008-00037371": "taste the power of fountain neal", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00093-00037372-00037679": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00094-00037680-00038199": "oh hi guys did i miss anything probably", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00095-00038200-00038439": "attack ah", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00096-00038440-00038743": "this is a horrible idea why did i choose", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00097-00038744-00039283": "this", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00098-00039284-00039527": "yes yes", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00099-00039528-00039727": "screw this come on protect me i'm about", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00100-00039728-00039902": "to die", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00101-00039903-00040671": "attack himself", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00102-00040672-00041936": "where's", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00103-00041937-00043135": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00104-00043136-00043327": "i definitely that's not where we go", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00105-00043328-00043511": "where are you going here not follow me", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00106-00043512-00043758": "just like no that's us where do we go", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00107-00043759-00044095": "guys", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00108-00044096-00044399": "okay uh okay found him let's tell him", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00109-00044400-00044839": "you know the girl", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00110-00044840-00045023": "wait you're not done yeah yeah okay uh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00111-00045024-00045255": "you look weird uh school", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00112-00045256-00045735": "what the heck oh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00113-00045736-00045990": "you guys are some [__] heart", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00114-00045991-00046199": "this looks like a zip line i don't know", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00115-00046200-00049807": "i mean", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00116-00049808-00050367": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00117-00050368-00050686": "oh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00118-00050687-00050902": "did he just say i can't resume is he", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00119-00050903-00051750": "like stuck in palms", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00120-00051751-00052054": "oh no", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00121-00052055-00052311": "all right well there's only one possible", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00122-00052312-00052711": "solution to this", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00123-00052712-00053199": "there's actually a better solution", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00124-00053200-00053566": "all right goodbye try it off", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00125-00053567-00054471": "there we go that's nice", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00126-00054472-00056087": "okay yes", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00127-00056088-00057519": "all right wow", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00128-00057520-00057663": "all right guys can um up with me", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00129-00057664-00058247": "something of course", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00130-00058248-00058438": "yes", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00131-00058439-00058550": "okay", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00132-00058551-00058750": "there we go", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00133-00058751-00059694": "there we go", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00134-00059695-00061342": "um", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00135-00061344-00061930": "i can do it yeah i can do this uh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00136-00061932-00062454": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00137-00062455-00062615": "never mind that's not that's not that", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00138-00062616-00062806": "bad that's not that good okay i don't", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00139-00062807-00065882": "need it's fine i can lock my data", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00140-00065883-00066224": "just you exist hello there", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00141-00066225-00066399": "[Music]", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00142-00066400-00066638": "thanks for the big gun all right um you", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00143-00066639-00066871": "got a second gun", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00144-00066872-00067191": "this neck just snapped", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00145-00067192-00067350": "can you shut up i'm trying to do like a", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00146-00067351-00067519": "youtube video like you're supposed to", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00147-00067520-00067806": "kind of like play in the bottom man", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00148-00067807-00067950": "fine", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00149-00067951-00068087": "by killing you", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00150-00068088-00068238": "oh no", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00151-00068239-00069703": "oh hello there", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00152-00069704-00070271": "what do you mean", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00153-00070272-00070599": "there comes a concussion ah all right uh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00154-00070600-00070815": "what are these things i don't know but i", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00155-00070816-00071399": "really like breaking these so", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00156-00071400-00071703": "and last but not least needed better", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00157-00071704-00071943": "spelling but", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00158-00071944-00072231": "no okay", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00159-00072232-00072431": "but he's dead so i can't probably go", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00160-00072432-00072767": "with this one", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00161-00072768-00075631": "i don't want that kind", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00162-00075632-00078206": "you have a bad", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00163-00078207-00078615": "yes", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00164-00078616-00078887": "oh my god that man like just ran in the", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00165-00078888-00079006": "way i guess", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00166-00079007-00079526": "he just finished", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00167-00079527-00080975": "he's just shooting", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00168-00080976-00082375": "oh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00169-00082376-00083791": "oh", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00170-00083792-00085482": "is", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00171-00085483-00085767": "is actually it's not compromising like", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00172-00085768-00085982": "jekyll's game apparently was but it", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00173-00085983-00086271": "wasn't like that bad it was actually", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00174-00086272-00086359": "like", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00175-00086360-00086591": "oh look it's a thing", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00176-00086592-00086799": "you can visualize that", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00177-00086800-00086918": "i'm kind of", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00178-00086919-00087167": "good at that and with this handy dandy", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00179-00087168-00087375": "[__] little gun which", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00180-00087376-00087591": "sucks everything off because it just", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00181-00087592-00087871": "sticks and then blows up", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00182-00087872-00088575": "you don't see me", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00183-00088576-00088871": "okay i think he caught me guys um", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00184-00088872-00089887": "i don't really know what to say", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00185-00089888-00090126": "okay so um if you can't see right now", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00186-00090127-00090431": "there's a second command post or aaa gun", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00187-00090432-00090662": "or double a battery i have no idea what", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00188-00090663-00090894": "it's called but there's a thing that i", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00189-00090895-00091079": "have to blow up i blowed it up a couple", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00190-00091080-00091206": "of times i'm just going to call it a", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00191-00091207-00091406": "double a gun or something in the title", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00192-00091407-00091623": "you'll you'll know that but that's not", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00193-00091624-00091871": "the point the point is that i'm going to", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00194-00091872-00092071": "do the next episode and yeah this is", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00195-00092072-00092326": "this is a part of a two-part series of", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00196-00092327-00092543": "two-part series of an episode of a", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00197-00092544-00092847": "series for a part of a game so i could", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00198-00092848-00093191": "understand the lore to another game that", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00199-00093192-00093374": "okay this is i'm making this a lot more", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00200-00093375-00093559": "confusing than it needs to be either way", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00201-00093560-00093815": "um the the the next video may be out or", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00202-00093816-00094031": "may not be out of that but that's all", "OQ0EJG6Wx_U-00203-00094032-00094416": "now guys so good bye"}}, {"audio_id": "OQtu5kpgT08", "text": {"OQtu5kpgT08-00000-00000052-00000615": "[Music]", "OQtu5kpgT08-00001-00000616-00000878": "amdocs is a leader in providing software", "OQtu5kpgT08-00002-00000880-00001103": "and services to some key industries like", "OQtu5kpgT08-00003-00001104-00001319": "telecommunications media and financial", "OQtu5kpgT08-00004-00001320-00001687": "services in our next session we welcome", "OQtu5kpgT08-00005-00001688-00001798": "cedric", "OQtu5kpgT08-00006-00001800-00002079": "jaegoo who's the head of technical", "OQtu5kpgT08-00007-00002080-00002255": "product at amdocs and we'll learn about", "OQtu5kpgT08-00008-00002256-00002526": "amdoc's modernization journey and how it", "OQtu5kpgT08-00009-00002527-00002655": "added value", "OQtu5kpgT08-00010-00002656-00003031": "for their end customers cedric welcome", "OQtu5kpgT08-00011-00003032-00003295": "welcome how are you good thank you so", "OQtu5kpgT08-00012-00003296-00003654": "describe your modern application your", "OQtu5kpgT08-00013-00003655-00003831": "portfolio and you know what you're", "OQtu5kpgT08-00014-00003832-00004206": "delivering for for customers", "OQtu5kpgT08-00015-00004207-00004527": "so um docs is a bss oss player so we are", "OQtu5kpgT08-00016-00004528-00004791": "providing a full digital suite for", "OQtu5kpgT08-00017-00004792-00005047": "customers", "OQtu5kpgT08-00018-00005048-00005254": "our customers are communication service", "OQtu5kpgT08-00019-00005255-00005399": "providers which", "OQtu5kpgT08-00020-00005400-00005575": "have to deploy", "OQtu5kpgT08-00021-00005576-00005886": "full digital suites customer experience", "OQtu5kpgT08-00022-00005887-00006038": "um", "OQtu5kpgT08-00023-00006039-00006367": "we're uh for the full os bss oss stacks", "OQtu5kpgT08-00024-00006368-00006639": "so actually mdox is one of the leader in", "OQtu5kpgT08-00025-00006640-00006967": "this kind of digital transformations", "OQtu5kpgT08-00026-00006968-00007231": "yeah so of course you talk about oss and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00027-00007231-00007406": "bs i mean you're talking about some", "OQtu5kpgT08-00028-00007408-00007567": "really hardened", "OQtu5kpgT08-00029-00007568-00007831": "uh stacks right uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00030-00007831-00008031": "the telco industry", "OQtu5kpgT08-00031-00008031-00008119": "uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00032-00008120-00008310": "say what you want about it but boy the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00033-00008311-00008599": "phone works when you dial it so so you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00034-00008600-00008831": "got sort of a decades-old", "OQtu5kpgT08-00035-00008832-00008974": "you know platform that you guys have", "OQtu5kpgT08-00036-00008975-00009174": "been evolving over the over the years", "OQtu5kpgT08-00037-00009175-00009295": "describe", "OQtu5kpgT08-00038-00009296-00009551": "this modernization journey and and the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00039-00009552-00009774": "role that that couch base played you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00040-00009775-00009967": "know what value", "OQtu5kpgT08-00041-00009968-00010206": "does this offer this modernization offer", "OQtu5kpgT08-00042-00010207-00010351": "to your organization and where does", "OQtu5kpgT08-00043-00010352-00010591": "couchbase fit", "OQtu5kpgT08-00044-00010592-00010799": "yeah exactly there's the example that so", "OQtu5kpgT08-00045-00010800-00011031": "basically what is uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00046-00011032-00011183": "all solution is you know it's a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00047-00011184-00011446": "portfolio of a large number of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00048-00011447-00011687": "components which are to deal with from", "OQtu5kpgT08-00049-00011688-00011783": "the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00050-00011784-00012135": "the the experience of the user and from", "OQtu5kpgT08-00051-00012136-00012383": "and then dealing all the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00052-00012384-00012567": "the activation of the services in the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00053-00012568-00012871": "network in order to deliver a solution", "OQtu5kpgT08-00054-00012872-00013094": "service like mobile services or", "OQtu5kpgT08-00055-00013095-00013319": "communication services to uh to the end", "OQtu5kpgT08-00056-00013319-00013527": "users so um", "OQtu5kpgT08-00057-00013528-00013903": "we have a full suite which", "OQtu5kpgT08-00058-00013904-00014111": "was previously based", "OQtu5kpgT08-00059-00014112-00014303": "on you know on tech technologies based", "OQtu5kpgT08-00060-00014304-00014591": "on oracle with web logic and something", "OQtu5kpgT08-00061-00014591-00014686": "like that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00062-00014687-00014863": "and what we did is that we do a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00063-00014863-00015127": "modernization of of this something like", "OQtu5kpgT08-00064-00015128-00015303": "six years ago a bit more than six years", "OQtu5kpgT08-00065-00015304-00015630": "ago we start the modernization and the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00066-00015631-00015855": "transformation of our product into a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00067-00015856-00016038": "cloud native solution collaborative", "OQtu5kpgT08-00068-00016040-00016191": "solution so", "OQtu5kpgT08-00069-00016191-00016366": "and when we did that we start with", "OQtu5kpgT08-00070-00016368-00016535": "coachbase", "OQtu5kpgT08-00071-00016536-00016671": "as a partner", "OQtu5kpgT08-00072-00016672-00016839": "to provide the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00073-00016840-00017055": "the cloud native database", "OQtu5kpgT08-00074-00017056-00017335": "so uh we are actually delivering we have", "OQtu5kpgT08-00075-00017336-00017615": "an r d of more than 8 000 people", "OQtu5kpgT08-00076-00017616-00017783": "developing this product it's a product", "OQtu5kpgT08-00077-00017784-00017950": "which is used", "OQtu5kpgT08-00078-00017951-00018263": "by more than 300 customers", "OQtu5kpgT08-00079-00018264-00018447": "so so it's it's really a product that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00080-00018448-00018630": "needs to be very flexible they need to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00081-00018631-00018894": "address many kind of use cases from our", "OQtu5kpgT08-00082-00018895-00019143": "telco our customers which are csps", "OQtu5kpgT08-00083-00019144-00019407": "usually tier zero tier one telcos so we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00084-00019408-00019686": "what we wanted to build is a full cloud", "OQtu5kpgT08-00085-00019687-00019879": "native solution that can work on any", "OQtu5kpgT08-00086-00019880-00019967": "cloud", "OQtu5kpgT08-00087-00019968-00020135": "and can uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00088-00020136-00020367": "can scale very uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00089-00020368-00020671": "very easily and can address multiple use", "OQtu5kpgT08-00090-00020672-00020871": "cases okay and that's why coach base", "OQtu5kpgT08-00091-00020872-00021135": "when we selected coach basic it match a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00092-00021136-00021430": "lot of requirements and criterias we had", "OQtu5kpgT08-00093-00021431-00021655": "and when we decided to to modernize our", "OQtu5kpgT08-00094-00021656-00021863": "product we decided to work with cadre", "OQtu5kpgT08-00095-00021864-00022047": "yeah so you had a lot of experience in", "OQtu5kpgT08-00096-00022048-00022286": "in legacy with oracle and web logic i'm", "OQtu5kpgT08-00097-00022287-00022430": "curious to have a follow-up why didn't", "OQtu5kpgT08-00098-00022431-00022614": "you stay with oracle you mentioned got", "OQtu5kpgT08-00099-00022615-00022743": "to run on any cloud you've got to be", "OQtu5kpgT08-00100-00022744-00022894": "flexible but could you could you double", "OQtu5kpgT08-00101-00022895-00023158": "click on what couchbase delivered from a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00102-00023159-00023327": "requirement standpoint that was such a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00103-00023328-00023583": "good fit", "OQtu5kpgT08-00104-00023584-00023878": "well there's a good fit with technology", "OQtu5kpgT08-00105-00023879-00024030": "such as a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00106-00024031-00024207": "coach base it's first it's a nosql", "OQtu5kpgT08-00107-00024208-00024358": "database right so it's in terms of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00108-00024359-00024599": "performance for some of the use cases", "OQtu5kpgT08-00109-00024600-00024863": "that we have it's very important to have", "OQtu5kpgT08-00110-00024864-00025063": "you know technologies which are hardened", "OQtu5kpgT08-00111-00025064-00025286": "and optimized for the nosql use cases", "OQtu5kpgT08-00112-00025287-00025471": "that's the first thing the second thing", "OQtu5kpgT08-00113-00025472-00025687": "as i mentioned the scalability the fact", "OQtu5kpgT08-00114-00025688-00025999": "that you can uh almost indefin", "OQtu5kpgT08-00115-00026000-00026246": "infinitely you can increase the size of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00116-00026247-00026367": "your cluster", "OQtu5kpgT08-00117-00026368-00026639": "you can add more", "OQtu5kpgT08-00118-00026639-00026895": "servers and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00119-00026895-00027223": "and and and this will scale you know", "OQtu5kpgT08-00120-00027224-00027527": "very rapidly and also what were very", "OQtu5kpgT08-00121-00027527-00027727": "interesting to have from coachbase is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00122-00027727-00027935": "the ability to have something which can", "OQtu5kpgT08-00123-00027936-00028031": "be", "OQtu5kpgT08-00124-00028032-00028302": "replicated across multiple sites so with", "OQtu5kpgT08-00125-00028304-00028567": "xdcr technology from coachbase which", "OQtu5kpgT08-00126-00028568-00028839": "enable to build you know very modern", "OQtu5kpgT08-00127-00028839-00029127": "architecture with deployment on multiple", "OQtu5kpgT08-00128-00029127-00029446": "regions to have disaster recovery", "OQtu5kpgT08-00129-00029447-00029623": "active active sites you know things like", "OQtu5kpgT08-00130-00029624-00029879": "that which are very becoming like the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00131-00029880-00030127": "main requirement for more customers now", "OQtu5kpgT08-00132-00030127-00030318": "okay so i'm presuming there were there", "OQtu5kpgT08-00133-00030319-00030518": "were parts of your application portfolio", "OQtu5kpgT08-00134-00030519-00030758": "that you you you weren't going to touch", "OQtu5kpgT08-00135-00030760-00030967": "and throw away you had to collect or", "OQtu5kpgT08-00136-00030968-00031062": "connect", "OQtu5kpgT08-00137-00031063-00031167": "the new", "OQtu5kpgT08-00138-00031168-00031399": "with the old that's always you know", "OQtu5kpgT08-00139-00031400-00031543": "you know a challenge i'm wondering what", "OQtu5kpgT08-00140-00031544-00031767": "advice you'd give to an organization", "OQtu5kpgT08-00141-00031768-00031990": "that's kind of investing in a similar", "OQtu5kpgT08-00142-00031991-00032214": "path trying to deliver the best digital", "OQtu5kpgT08-00143-00032216-00032487": "experiences to to customers you know", "OQtu5kpgT08-00144-00032488-00032599": "what what would you say are the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00145-00032600-00032902": "modernization you got to have must-haves", "OQtu5kpgT08-00146-00032903-00033111": "whether it's architecture you know", "OQtu5kpgT08-00147-00033112-00033271": "internal culture", "OQtu5kpgT08-00148-00033272-00033471": "what are some of those items", "OQtu5kpgT08-00149-00033472-00033671": "so so yes you're right i think the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00150-00033672-00033871": "integration with the legacy systems is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00151-00033872-00033967": "actually", "OQtu5kpgT08-00152-00033968-00034207": "you know a very very important", "OQtu5kpgT08-00153-00034208-00034302": "topic", "OQtu5kpgT08-00154-00034303-00034559": "in in our domain in the telco domain", "OQtu5kpgT08-00155-00034560-00034823": "but we we made a very uh i would say", "OQtu5kpgT08-00156-00034824-00035071": "drastic choice or brave choice choice", "OQtu5kpgT08-00157-00035072-00035407": "when uh in six years from now when we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00158-00035408-00035679": "decided to reformat to re-platform sorry", "OQtu5kpgT08-00159-00035680-00035911": "completely our part for you okay so we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00160-00035912-00036118": "changed more than 95 percent of our", "OQtu5kpgT08-00161-00036119-00036239": "portfolio", "OQtu5kpgT08-00162-00036240-00036455": "and 95 percent of our portfolio today", "OQtu5kpgT08-00163-00036456-00036623": "are cloud native which means that they", "OQtu5kpgT08-00164-00036624-00036823": "can be deployed on any cloud", "OQtu5kpgT08-00165-00036824-00037143": "that actually they are fully scalable", "OQtu5kpgT08-00166-00037144-00037279": "and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00167-00037280-00037462": "and and still because we did this", "OQtu5kpgT08-00168-00037463-00037630": "transformation now when we do the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00169-00037631-00037830": "digital transformation of the of our", "OQtu5kpgT08-00170-00037831-00037967": "telco", "OQtu5kpgT08-00171-00037968-00038246": "of the see our customer system then we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00172-00038247-00038518": "need to integrate with legacy systems", "OQtu5kpgT08-00173-00038519-00038671": "and we need to help our customers to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00174-00038672-00038871": "migrate from their legacy systems to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00175-00038872-00039071": "cloud native solutions", "OQtu5kpgT08-00176-00039072-00039455": "and doing so it's it's important to have", "OQtu5kpgT08-00177-00039456-00039662": "in the database domain it's very", "OQtu5kpgT08-00178-00039663-00039871": "important to have a solution which is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00179-00039872-00040062": "very flexible in terms of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00180-00040063-00040279": "what kind of data i can manage", "OQtu5kpgT08-00181-00040280-00040388": "and i can", "OQtu5kpgT08-00182-00040389-00040543": "[Music]", "OQtu5kpgT08-00183-00040544-00040774": "as i said scale easily for sure but also", "OQtu5kpgT08-00184-00040775-00040951": "it's secure okay because when you are", "OQtu5kpgT08-00185-00040952-00041271": "moving the data from a legacy system", "OQtu5kpgT08-00186-00041272-00041518": "oracle based or whatever to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00187-00041519-00041815": "another type of uh of database you want", "OQtu5kpgT08-00188-00041816-00041974": "to be sure that you are you can do it", "OQtu5kpgT08-00189-00041975-00042302": "securely and you are not compromising in", "OQtu5kpgT08-00190-00042303-00042487": "any sense uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00191-00042488-00042911": "in term of security scalability", "OQtu5kpgT08-00192-00042912-00043111": "etc right so so", "OQtu5kpgT08-00193-00043112-00043230": "um", "OQtu5kpgT08-00194-00043231-00043502": "in in this case i mean i will say in", "OQtu5kpgT08-00195-00043503-00043687": "in this approach in this", "OQtu5kpgT08-00196-00043688-00043839": "journey", "OQtu5kpgT08-00197-00043840-00044118": "coach base was very very uh a very very", "OQtu5kpgT08-00198-00044119-00044390": "important component in our or you know", "OQtu5kpgT08-00199-00044391-00044590": "in our strategy", "OQtu5kpgT08-00200-00044591-00044783": "for all the reasons i mentioned right", "OQtu5kpgT08-00201-00044784-00044974": "it's very cloud native it's scalable", "OQtu5kpgT08-00202-00044975-00045127": "it's secure", "OQtu5kpgT08-00203-00045128-00045335": "it's an add-on product a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00204-00045336-00045590": "telco grade so so that's that's why", "OQtu5kpgT08-00205-00045591-00045718": "there is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00206-00045719-00045983": "the the key aspect here you know this", "OQtu5kpgT08-00207-00045984-00046215": "notion that 90 per you really we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00208-00046216-00046551": "re-platformed 90 of your portfolio and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00209-00046552-00046807": "made a cloud native that's that's is a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00210-00046808-00047071": "brave move because a lot of companies do", "OQtu5kpgT08-00211-00047072-00047271": "that that i've talked to they'll build", "OQtu5kpgT08-00212-00047272-00047486": "an abstraction layer and microservices", "OQtu5kpgT08-00213-00047487-00047679": "make that piece cloud native and then", "OQtu5kpgT08-00214-00047680-00047886": "have that kind of overlay", "OQtu5kpgT08-00215-00047887-00048167": "uh you decided not to do that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00216-00048168-00048374": "why is that was that for", "OQtu5kpgT08-00217-00048375-00048558": "performance reasons you were worried", "OQtu5kpgT08-00218-00048559-00048767": "about you just bringing along technical", "OQtu5kpgT08-00219-00048768-00048927": "debt i mean that really", "OQtu5kpgT08-00220-00048928-00049095": "must have been an interesting discussion", "OQtu5kpgT08-00221-00049096-00049399": "internally in your company", "OQtu5kpgT08-00222-00049400-00049599": "yeah dave it's true i mean the main", "OQtu5kpgT08-00223-00049600-00049815": "motivation the main driver was business", "OQtu5kpgT08-00224-00049816-00050071": "flexibility because now we live in a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00225-00050072-00050279": "world where our customers what they need", "OQtu5kpgT08-00226-00050280-00050511": "is to be able to test the new feature", "OQtu5kpgT08-00227-00050512-00050774": "quickly and they need to be able to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00228-00050775-00051039": "to to to scale their system in a matter", "OQtu5kpgT08-00229-00051040-00051118": "of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00230-00051119-00051270": "hours okay", "OQtu5kpgT08-00231-00051271-00051494": "so we are not in in a domain anymore", "OQtu5kpgT08-00232-00051495-00051702": "where you you when you have to upgrade", "OQtu5kpgT08-00233-00051703-00051870": "something you need to take a few days it", "OQtu5kpgT08-00234-00051871-00052102": "needs to be done in a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00235-00052103-00052335": "very very quickly and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00236-00052336-00052582": "the only way to achieve those", "OQtu5kpgT08-00237-00052583-00052766": "requirements these business requirements", "OQtu5kpgT08-00238-00052767-00052982": "is to be cloud native it's to build", "OQtu5kpgT08-00239-00052983-00053454": "micro services and to really rely 100 of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00240-00053455-00053663": "micro services architectures because", "OQtu5kpgT08-00241-00053664-00053830": "this is the only way you will have the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00242-00053832-00054023": "business less flexibility you will be", "OQtu5kpgT08-00243-00054024-00054375": "able to have a resilient architecture", "OQtu5kpgT08-00244-00054376-00054671": "you know you can", "OQtu5kpgT08-00245-00054672-00054903": "you can deploy this with a full high", "OQtu5kpgT08-00246-00054904-00055111": "availability across multiple zones", "OQtu5kpgT08-00247-00055112-00055430": "multiple regions and things like that so", "OQtu5kpgT08-00248-00055432-00055719": "any modern architecture today that that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00249-00055720-00055982": "is competing with us are actually a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00250-00055983-00056199": "micro services based architecture there", "OQtu5kpgT08-00251-00056200-00056511": "is no other way to achieve the to to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00252-00056512-00056694": "meet the requirement of the market today", "OQtu5kpgT08-00253-00056695-00056950": "and especially when 5g is coming", "OQtu5kpgT08-00254-00056951-00057119": "things will become much more complex", "OQtu5kpgT08-00255-00057120-00057375": "will become much more", "OQtu5kpgT08-00256-00057376-00057591": "distributed", "OQtu5kpgT08-00257-00057591-00057766": "you cannot work anymore with a modulated", "OQtu5kpgT08-00258-00057767-00057950": "architecture and again", "OQtu5kpgT08-00259-00057951-00058271": "having the database is no way different", "OQtu5kpgT08-00260-00058272-00058447": "needs to follow the same kind of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00261-00058448-00058679": "architecture needs to follow the same", "OQtu5kpgT08-00262-00058679-00058847": "principles", "OQtu5kpgT08-00263-00058848-00059215": "so that's that that's why i mean another", "OQtu5kpgT08-00264-00059216-00059471": "and another another point about uh about", "OQtu5kpgT08-00265-00059472-00059654": "rodriguez yeah so if i if i had to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00266-00059655-00059838": "summarize it sounds like your top three", "OQtu5kpgT08-00267-00059839-00060007": "requirements would be flexibility which", "OQtu5kpgT08-00268-00060008-00060142": "you're getting from the cloud native and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00269-00060144-00060463": "microservices piece the scale and the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00270-00060464-00060630": "security is that right did i get that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00271-00060632-00060799": "right the three top that's correct", "OQtu5kpgT08-00272-00060800-00060966": "that's right and the resiliency as well", "OQtu5kpgT08-00273-00060967-00061126": "i mean the fact that now you know with", "OQtu5kpgT08-00274-00061127-00061359": "microservices architecture if one of the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00275-00061360-00061615": "system is done he knows how to self", "OQtu5kpgT08-00276-00061616-00061942": "to restart it himself right itself sorry", "OQtu5kpgT08-00277-00061944-00062175": "so so that's this kind of architecture", "OQtu5kpgT08-00278-00062176-00062406": "that we built it's an architecture which", "OQtu5kpgT08-00279-00062407-00062566": "can be resilient in the sense that it", "OQtu5kpgT08-00280-00062567-00062863": "can sense itself and it can ensure a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00281-00062864-00063047": "full availability and if something is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00282-00063048-00063263": "going down or is it is not working", "OQtu5kpgT08-00283-00063264-00063375": "properly", "OQtu5kpgT08-00284-00063376-00063623": "then all other kind of mechanisms will", "OQtu5kpgT08-00285-00063624-00063903": "happen in order to to go back to a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00286-00063904-00064135": "stable state yeah so you've got that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00287-00064136-00064294": "automation in there so you don't doesn't", "OQtu5kpgT08-00288-00064295-00064471": "require the labor that it might have you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00289-00064472-00064638": "know 10 years ago so you're you're", "OQtu5kpgT08-00290-00064639-00064838": "obviously embracing cloud native", "OQtu5kpgT08-00291-00064839-00064999": "micro services", "OQtu5kpgT08-00292-00065000-00065126": "so you're on that journey i'm curious", "OQtu5kpgT08-00293-00065127-00065294": "what are you doing with that you you're", "OQtu5kpgT08-00294-00065295-00065543": "free you're freeing up your guys used to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00295-00065544-00065743": "bring in lab coats and dig in and figure", "OQtu5kpgT08-00296-00065744-00066006": "out what's wrong or restart the system", "OQtu5kpgT08-00297-00066007-00066119": "where are you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00298-00066120-00066287": "in your journey and how are you sort of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00299-00066288-00066519": "reallocating those resources and and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00300-00066520-00066815": "where do you see that going", "OQtu5kpgT08-00301-00066816-00067006": "yeah okay so that's that's a very good", "OQtu5kpgT08-00302-00067007-00067238": "point because actually we when we build", "OQtu5kpgT08-00303-00067239-00067575": "this new system which is unable to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00304-00067576-00067847": "you know to self-heal heal himself right", "OQtu5kpgT08-00305-00067848-00068111": "uh actually the question was more about", "OQtu5kpgT08-00306-00068112-00068294": "how we can improve the system even more", "OQtu5kpgT08-00307-00068295-00068638": "how we can be sure that uh uh you know", "OQtu5kpgT08-00308-00068639-00068863": "issues that we any issues which are we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00309-00068864-00069143": "are facing will not happen again will", "OQtu5kpgT08-00310-00069144-00069382": "not occur again okay and this is a sre", "OQtu5kpgT08-00311-00069383-00069687": "uh principle okay practice that we have", "OQtu5kpgT08-00312-00069688-00069950": "now people are working on automation", "OQtu5kpgT08-00313-00069951-00070111": "they are building", "OQtu5kpgT08-00314-00070112-00070375": "automation around all these recovery", "OQtu5kpgT08-00315-00070376-00070663": "procedures or about", "OQtu5kpgT08-00316-00070664-00070919": "fixing so they are not actually digging", "OQtu5kpgT08-00317-00070920-00071038": "into the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00318-00071039-00071303": "application now anymore into the system", "OQtu5kpgT08-00319-00071304-00071575": "they learn how the system is is working", "OQtu5kpgT08-00320-00071576-00071862": "and building all the right automation", "OQtu5kpgT08-00321-00071863-00072087": "tasks to ensure that the system is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00322-00072088-00072359": "considered constitutively resilient", "OQtu5kpgT08-00323-00072360-00072606": "right so that's the screen practices our", "OQtu5kpgT08-00324-00072607-00072855": "organization is now built around you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00325-00072856-00072999": "know this kind of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00326-00073000-00073287": "this approach devops pure develops", "OQtu5kpgT08-00327-00073288-00073487": "being fully agile obviously having an", "OQtu5kpgT08-00328-00073488-00073735": "sre organization or sre oriented", "OQtu5kpgT08-00329-00073736-00073862": "organization", "OQtu5kpgT08-00330-00073863-00074103": "and and that's the only way you know you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00331-00074104-00074279": "can reach very high", "OQtu5kpgT08-00332-00074280-00074487": "higher sla in terms of level", "OQtu5kpgT08-00333-00074488-00074623": "availability", "OQtu5kpgT08-00334-00074624-00074887": "so the big problem that your traditional", "OQtu5kpgT08-00335-00074888-00075126": "telco customers have is the the amount", "OQtu5kpgT08-00336-00075127-00075359": "of data that they're servicing going", "OQtu5kpgT08-00337-00075360-00075567": "through the roof and the cost per bit", "OQtu5kpgT08-00338-00075568-00075750": "is sinking like that and you have all", "OQtu5kpgT08-00339-00075751-00076023": "the over-the-top providers coming in", "OQtu5kpgT08-00340-00076024-00076255": "creating these customer experiences with", "OQtu5kpgT08-00341-00076256-00076438": "modern applications and they've owned", "OQtu5kpgT08-00342-00076439-00076719": "the customer data you mentioned 5g so", "OQtu5kpgT08-00343-00076720-00076894": "i'm interested what the future of modern", "OQtu5kpgT08-00344-00076895-00077135": "apps looks like for amdocs and your", "OQtu5kpgT08-00345-00077136-00077326": "customers because 5g", "OQtu5kpgT08-00346-00077327-00077575": "gives your traditional telco customers", "OQtu5kpgT08-00347-00077576-00077831": "the ability if you if they can have", "OQtu5kpgT08-00348-00077832-00077991": "these flexible systems that you're", "OQtu5kpgT08-00349-00077992-00078182": "providing to now have better", "OQtu5kpgT08-00350-00078183-00078382": "relationships with customers and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00351-00078383-00078615": "actually kind of reclaim you know some", "OQtu5kpgT08-00352-00078616-00078871": "of that uh that value that they've lost", "OQtu5kpgT08-00353-00078872-00079031": "to a lot of competitors your thoughts on", "OQtu5kpgT08-00354-00079032-00079279": "the future", "OQtu5kpgT08-00355-00079280-00079471": "so first you know technically speaking", "OQtu5kpgT08-00356-00079472-00079550": "we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00357-00079551-00079775": "we will have two challenges one is about", "OQtu5kpgT08-00358-00079776-00079975": "data another one is about distribution", "OQtu5kpgT08-00359-00079976-00080150": "of the workload okay because when we are", "OQtu5kpgT08-00360-00080151-00080335": "speaking about 5g we are speaking about", "OQtu5kpgT08-00361-00080336-00080550": "the age we are speaking about the fact", "OQtu5kpgT08-00362-00080551-00080638": "that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00363-00080639-00080806": "an application", "OQtu5kpgT08-00364-00080807-00080999": "may be allocated very closely to the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00365-00081000-00081255": "network because it needs to be to to to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00366-00081256-00081543": "achieve you know to deliver very", "OQtu5kpgT08-00367-00081544-00081887": "short latency and uh oh and and this", "OQtu5kpgT08-00368-00081888-00082159": "application can move okay so you you you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00369-00082160-00082311": "you will have to be able to distribute", "OQtu5kpgT08-00370-00082312-00082511": "completely your solutions okay and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00371-00082512-00082750": "that's why we are working closely with", "OQtu5kpgT08-00372-00082751-00083191": "the the cloud providers aws azure google", "OQtu5kpgT08-00373-00083192-00083303": "and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00374-00083304-00083423": "because we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00375-00083424-00083591": "we need to be sure that the applications", "OQtu5kpgT08-00376-00083592-00083815": "of the systems that we are building will", "OQtu5kpgT08-00377-00083816-00084071": "be able to distribute the applications", "OQtu5kpgT08-00378-00084072-00084318": "as close as as possible to the end users", "OQtu5kpgT08-00379-00084319-00084518": "okay so that's that's one of the key", "OQtu5kpgT08-00380-00084519-00084655": "challenges which means that the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00381-00084656-00084831": "application needs to be very portable it", "OQtu5kpgT08-00382-00084832-00085079": "needs to be very scalable", "OQtu5kpgT08-00383-00085080-00085279": "and then it needs to be able to move", "OQtu5kpgT08-00384-00085280-00085494": "very quickly from one place to another", "OQtu5kpgT08-00385-00085495-00085694": "that's really what is what will what is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00386-00085695-00085903": "happening now and what will become the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00387-00085904-00086023": "norm", "OQtu5kpgT08-00388-00086024-00086182": "with 5g", "OQtu5kpgT08-00389-00086183-00086471": "the other challenge is uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00390-00086472-00086631": "behind the communication of all these", "OQtu5kpgT08-00391-00086632-00086815": "components is really the data because", "OQtu5kpgT08-00392-00086816-00087038": "now we will capture", "OQtu5kpgT08-00393-00087039-00087215": "more and more data coming from the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00394-00087216-00087367": "different systems and i'm not speaking", "OQtu5kpgT08-00395-00087368-00087582": "only about the the cons", "OQtu5kpgT08-00396-00087583-00087750": "the customer data", "OQtu5kpgT08-00397-00087751-00088047": "who they are what they are what they", "OQtu5kpgT08-00398-00088048-00088262": "they like and what they want to do etc", "OQtu5kpgT08-00399-00088263-00088471": "i'm speaking also about", "OQtu5kpgT08-00400-00088472-00088718": "the the monitoring data of the systems", "OQtu5kpgT08-00401-00088719-00088879": "okay so we will generate a lot of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00402-00088880-00089062": "information and this those this", "OQtu5kpgT08-00403-00089063-00089343": "information needs to be", "OQtu5kpgT08-00404-00089344-00089567": "treated very quickly needs to be stored", "OQtu5kpgT08-00405-00089568-00089879": "in very large data lake and we will need", "OQtu5kpgT08-00406-00089880-00090087": "to have extraction and manipulation of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00407-00090088-00090438": "the data very very quickly to to to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00408-00090439-00090606": "to give the right information to the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00409-00090607-00090775": "applications", "OQtu5kpgT08-00410-00090776-00090967": "in this case okay it's very important to", "OQtu5kpgT08-00411-00090968-00091167": "have applications to have databases that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00412-00091168-00091479": "can as i said scale uh very quickly", "OQtu5kpgT08-00413-00091480-00091743": "but also will be able to have very uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00414-00091744-00091918": "high density nodes you know some that", "OQtu5kpgT08-00415-00091919-00092103": "they with", "OQtu5kpgT08-00416-00092104-00092375": "a certain amount of memory or sentiment", "OQtu5kpgT08-00417-00092376-00092606": "of storage you can store a lot of data", "OQtu5kpgT08-00418-00092607-00092887": "and this is where we are always you know", "OQtu5kpgT08-00419-00092888-00093071": "checking what is the best technologies", "OQtu5kpgT08-00420-00093072-00093238": "and so far you know coachbase is a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00421-00093239-00093447": "technology that we are using for for", "OQtu5kpgT08-00422-00093448-00093871": "stocking storing all those data", "OQtu5kpgT08-00423-00093872-00093974": "because", "OQtu5kpgT08-00424-00093975-00094247": "because it's it's the the ratio in term", "OQtu5kpgT08-00425-00094248-00094359": "of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00426-00094360-00094543": "performance on the number of data you", "OQtu5kpgT08-00427-00094544-00094647": "can store", "OQtu5kpgT08-00428-00094648-00094999": "uh is very high okay so that's that's uh", "OQtu5kpgT08-00429-00095000-00095231": "another challenge that we're addressing", "OQtu5kpgT08-00430-00095232-00095447": "of course coach base is is not the only", "OQtu5kpgT08-00431-00095448-00095799": "solution but it's another another one", "OQtu5kpgT08-00432-00095800-00095943": "excellent okay we're going to leave it", "OQtu5kpgT08-00433-00095944-00096103": "there cedric thanks so much a great", "OQtu5kpgT08-00434-00096104-00096247": "story and really appreciate your", "OQtu5kpgT08-00435-00096248-00096447": "insights", "OQtu5kpgT08-00436-00096448-00096662": "you're welcome thank you very much okay", "OQtu5kpgT08-00437-00096663-00096767": "that's it for today i hope you've", "OQtu5kpgT08-00438-00096768-00096991": "enjoyed the application modernization", "OQtu5kpgT08-00439-00096992-00097231": "summit made possible by couchbase we", "OQtu5kpgT08-00440-00097232-00097438": "shared some fresh survey data and got", "OQtu5kpgT08-00441-00097439-00097606": "the perspectives of three expert", "OQtu5kpgT08-00442-00097607-00097918": "analysts we got an outstanding road map", "OQtu5kpgT08-00443-00097919-00098103": "from ravi", "OQtu5kpgT08-00444-00098104-00098406": "mayram who's the cto of couchbase", "OQtu5kpgT08-00445-00098407-00098662": "and of course we got the customer angle", "OQtu5kpgT08-00446-00098663-00098855": "from cedric so look maybe you're an", "OQtu5kpgT08-00447-00098856-00098967": "organization going through a", "OQtu5kpgT08-00448-00098968-00099191": "modernization initiative and if you're", "OQtu5kpgT08-00449-00099192-00099343": "thinking about what the future of", "OQtu5kpgT08-00450-00099344-00099606": "applications looks like check out couch", "OQtu5kpgT08-00451-00099607-00099791": "base on the road this summer the", "OQtu5kpgT08-00452-00099792-00099967": "application modernization summit it's", "OQtu5kpgT08-00453-00099968-00100111": "hitting the road", "OQtu5kpgT08-00454-00100112-00100335": "traversing north america and europe find", "OQtu5kpgT08-00455-00100336-00100591": "out where they'll be where they'll be", "OQtu5kpgT08-00456-00100592-00100935": "near you by visiting couchbase.com", "OQtu5kpgT08-00457-00100936-00101174": "roadshow ravi is going to be there along", "OQtu5kpgT08-00458-00101175-00101382": "with other thought leaders and peers who", "OQtu5kpgT08-00459-00101383-00101518": "will be sharing learnings and best", "OQtu5kpgT08-00460-00101519-00101838": "practices on how to modernize now and", "OQtu5kpgT08-00461-00101839-00101982": "for the future and you'll get a chance", "OQtu5kpgT08-00462-00101983-00102174": "to interact with some of those peers", "OQtu5kpgT08-00463-00102175-00102382": "something that everyone i know is", "OQtu5kpgT08-00464-00102383-00102599": "looking forward to this is dave vellante", "OQtu5kpgT08-00465-00102600-00102775": "thanks for joining us today and thanks", "OQtu5kpgT08-00466-00102776-00103557": "for watching thecube", "OQtu5kpgT08-00467-00103558-00104063": "[Music]", "OQtu5kpgT08-00468-00104064-00104272": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OQCmMHqiiDM", "text": {"OQCmMHqiiDM-00000-00000008-00000199": "hello there my beautiful lovely internet", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00001-00000200-00000471": "friends when i lost my leg because of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00002-00000472-00000711": "well you know that vampire bite to my", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00003-00000712-00000927": "ankle the fish tank accident the assault", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00004-00000927-00001158": "by that gosh darn kitten the very slow", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00005-00001159-00001350": "zombie people see or hear that i'm an", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00006-00001351-00001535": "amputee the common response is oh my god", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00007-00001536-00001702": "i'm so sorry i'm sorry for your loss", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00008-00001703-00001910": "right and while i will absolutely take", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00009-00001911-00002095": "and soak up your pity the reality of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00010-00002096-00002255": "this situation is that it gave me more", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00011-00002256-00002423": "than i ever could have asked for and no", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00012-00002424-00002550": "this is not one of those videos where", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00013-00002551-00002726": "i'm about to lecture you about how it", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00014-00002727-00002926": "made me so much stronger i'm talking", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00015-00002927-00003118": "about the very practical real ways in", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00016-00003119-00003319": "which this actually made my life", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00017-00003320-00003503": "exponentially better so often we think", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00018-00003504-00003751": "of amputation as only a bad thing as", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00019-00003752-00003870": "someone who had to choose this i'm here", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00020-00003871-00004015": "to tell you it's not so let's get some", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00021-00004015-00004167": "stuff done around the house and tell you", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00022-00004168-00004343": "my top 10 things that i gained from", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00023-00004344-00004567": "losing my leg you know i just said 10 i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00024-00004568-00004695": "don't actually have a list that long so", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00025-00004696-00004886": "maybe maybe 10 we'll figure it out okay", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00026-00004887-00005070": "so thing number one as i get the rest of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00027-00005071-00005222": "the nail polish off my nails because i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00028-00005223-00005375": "did not finish that this morning and if", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00029-00005376-00005502": "you don't know the story of how i lost", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00030-00005503-00005638": "my leg i will link it up above so you", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00031-00005639-00005822": "can check it out feeling like my body", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00032-00005823-00006006": "was actually my own again like this", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00033-00006007-00006231": "sense of autonomy like i owned the skin", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00034-00006232-00006470": "i was in i went through about 14 years", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00035-00006472-00006663": "of surgeries on my ankle and i felt like", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00036-00006664-00006823": "i was always just kind of along for the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00037-00006823-00007063": "ride i'd go to a doctor do what they", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00038-00007064-00007239": "said as i should have and there was", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00039-00007240-00007519": "never any say like i felt like my body", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00040-00007520-00007695": "wasn't my own it was hurting me all the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00041-00007695-00007967": "time and i was just there i really felt", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00042-00007968-00008142": "like my life was just being dragged from", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00043-00008143-00008295": "surgery to surgery and completely", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00044-00008296-00008455": "controlled by this part of my body that", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00045-00008456-00008646": "was failing and when i realized that i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00046-00008647-00008846": "had a choice in front of me about what i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00047-00008847-00009055": "wanted to do i could have kept my ankle", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00048-00009056-00009239": "it would have kept causing me severe", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00049-00009240-00009423": "issues when i realized that i could make", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00050-00009424-00009623": "that choice for myself about what i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00051-00009624-00009799": "wanted to do with my own body and my", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00052-00009800-00009999": "surgeons were on board for whatever i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00053-00010000-00010223": "chose making that decision obviously was", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00054-00010224-00010463": "agonizing and very difficult but having", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00055-00010464-00010671": "a say in what happened to my body and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00056-00010672-00010919": "getting to decide the time and the place", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00057-00010920-00011110": "being able to prepare for it and knowing", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00058-00011111-00011438": "that i made this call for myself as", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00059-00011439-00011646": "opposed to being just along for the ride", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00060-00011647-00011823": "was really powerful and made me start", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00061-00011824-00012070": "feeling like i had my body instead of my", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00062-00012071-00012319": "body just having me second thing is i am", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00063-00012320-00012519": "demonstrating at the moment the ability", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00064-00012520-00012687": "to walk again in the last couple of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00065-00012688-00012846": "months leading up to my amputation i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00066-00012847-00013071": "could technically walk like i wasn't", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00067-00013072-00013222": "using a wheelchair which comes as a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00068-00013223-00013430": "shock to some people but walking on that", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00069-00013431-00013671": "ankle was so painful that i kind of did", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00070-00013672-00013838": "everything i could to avoid it and the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00071-00013840-00014022": "life with a prosthetic leg in my nubbin", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00072-00014023-00014286": "here is not pain free by any means it is", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00073-00014287-00014503": "so much better than it was before thing", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00074-00014504-00014703": "number three but first a word from our", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00075-00014704-00014886": "sponsor sunferd is a fragrance", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00076-00014887-00015030": "subscription website but i want to give", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00077-00015031-00015191": "you a quick story before i talk about", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00078-00015191-00015430": "them i have a very weird pre-filming", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00079-00015431-00015615": "ritual that i've never told anyone about", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00080-00015616-00015838": "and it actually makes no sense uh so for", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00081-00015840-00016079": "the past three years of making videos", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00082-00016080-00016238": "when i get ready to like get in front of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00083-00016240-00016479": "the camera i always put on perfume or", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00084-00016480-00016694": "body spray as if you smell me through", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00085-00016695-00016879": "the screen which you do not which is", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00086-00016880-00017055": "unfortunate because right now i smell", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00087-00017056-00017263": "amazing which brings us to scentbird", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00088-00017264-00017422": "sunfert is a fragrant subscription", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00089-00017423-00017599": "service where every month you get to try", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00090-00017600-00017839": "a new designer fragrance for just 16 no", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00091-00017840-00017999": "surprises you can skip a month at any", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00092-00018000-00018175": "time and with each fragrance comes a 30", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00093-00018176-00018383": "day supply which for reference cute", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00094-00018384-00018575": "packaging by the way looks like this so", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00095-00018576-00018703": "you can wear and figure out what", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00096-00018704-00018871": "fragrance you love before you actually", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00097-00018872-00019014": "commit to a full bottle you have over", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00098-00019015-00019183": "600 designer brands to choose from i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00099-00019184-00019303": "promise you they'll have something for", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00100-00019304-00019486": "you and if you aren't sure what kind of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00101-00019487-00019630": "scent you want to try out they actually", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00102-00019631-00019750": "have a quiz on their website where they", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00103-00019751-00019911": "can help you get started today i am", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00104-00019912-00020175": "wearing confessions of a rebels let's be", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00105-00020176-00020319": "real which is a blend of some of my", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00106-00020320-00020486": "favorite scents like jasmine and vanilla", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00107-00020487-00020630": "make sure to click the link below and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00108-00020631-00020911": "use code joe 55 at checkout for 55 off", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00109-00020912-00021030": "your first month that makes it about", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00110-00021031-00021214": "seven dollars to try out an absolute", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00111-00021215-00021407": "steal if you ask me thank you so much to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00112-00021408-00021550": "scentbird for sponsoring today's video", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00113-00021551-00021735": "now let's get back to number three so", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00114-00021736-00021903": "this third thing is one that has been", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00115-00021904-00022150": "incredibly powerful in how i view myself", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00116-00022151-00022383": "when i lost my leg i expected my body", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00117-00022384-00022583": "image to really take a hit you know", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00118-00022584-00022750": "which is expected you go through some", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00119-00022751-00022943": "major body modification and how you see", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00120-00022944-00023135": "yourself might be altered but i was a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00121-00023136-00023271": "little worried about this honestly", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00122-00023272-00023422": "because i spent", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00123-00023423-00023671": "many years of my life uh dealing with an", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00124-00023672-00023847": "eating disorder and then even when sort", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00125-00023848-00024094": "of the active presence of that was gone", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00126-00024095-00024294": "i dealt with those disordered eating", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00127-00024295-00024503": "thoughts like all throughout my 20s i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00128-00024504-00024678": "wasn't actively participating in sort of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00129-00024679-00024886": "the harmful behaviors i had before but i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00130-00024887-00025063": "sure was thinking about them like i was", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00131-00025064-00025214": "always thinking about my body through", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00132-00025215-00025463": "the lens of what it should be how the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00133-00025464-00025639": "world wants it to look you know wanting", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00134-00025639-00025822": "to be skinnier wanting to control how", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00135-00025823-00026046": "this looks for aesthetic reasons and in", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00136-00026047-00026262": "a strange twist of fate going through", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00137-00026263-00026543": "something so substantial with my body", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00138-00026544-00026743": "losing a major piece of myself made me", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00139-00026744-00026927": "begin to really appreciate the body i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00140-00026927-00027231": "had left and to want to treat it well", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00141-00027232-00027455": "for no other reason than like it's the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00142-00027456-00027662": "vehicle that allows me to live life and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00143-00027663-00027839": "do things i no longer cared as much", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00144-00027839-00027990": "about what my body looked like and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00145-00027991-00028127": "started really caring about what it", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00146-00028127-00028343": "could do for me i sort of switched to a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00147-00028344-00028574": "very neutral view of the skin that i am", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00148-00028575-00028743": "in and i wanted to nourish and take care", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00149-00028744-00028918": "of it and you know be strong for no", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00150-00028919-00029158": "other reason then it allows me to do", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00151-00029160-00029335": "things living in a body that is very", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00152-00029336-00029470": "different from the majority of the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00153-00029472-00029711": "people who are around me does bring a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00154-00029712-00029902": "set of issues with how i view myself", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00155-00029904-00030070": "does bring some insecurities but", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00156-00030072-00030270": "honestly not nearly as many as i had", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00157-00030272-00030414": "before you know i think it's about time", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00158-00030416-00030574": "we throw some tennis balls for sophie", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00159-00030575-00030807": "for number four where's your ball go get", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00160-00030808-00031039": "it go get it", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00161-00031039-00031183": "number four this one might sound a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00162-00031183-00031358": "little bit funny but i think i kind of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00163-00031360-00031527": "gained a cool factor that i never had", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00164-00031527-00031743": "before to a lot of people like yes", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00165-00031744-00031895": "people are definitely uncomfortable and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00166-00031895-00032102": "weird about my legs sometimes but a lot", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00167-00032103-00032279": "of the times they're just fascinated and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00168-00032280-00032431": "curious and i get to talk to people and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00169-00032432-00032599": "educate people like i pretty much always", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00170-00032600-00032711": "have an ice breaker and there's", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00171-00032712-00032831": "something that people want to talk to me", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00172-00032832-00033031": "about and to be honest having a having a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00173-00033032-00033262": "carbon fiber rocket cyborg leg is kind", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00174-00033263-00033399": "of neat looking", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00175-00033400-00033535": "i think we're going to spend the rest of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00176-00033536-00033702": "this video painting my nails because it", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00177-00033703-00033887": "will give me a reason to sit still long", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00178-00033888-00034062": "enough to actually let them dry for once", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00179-00034063-00034318": "number five a career this is something", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00180-00034319-00034551": "that honestly was entirely unexpected", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00181-00034552-00034702": "i've always really enjoyed things like", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00182-00034703-00034887": "public speaking i wanted to pursue that", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00183-00034888-00035079": "i was looking into it but when i started", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00184-00035080-00035239": "this channel and started filming kind of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00185-00035240-00035374": "going through the process of losing my", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00186-00035375-00035574": "leg and adjusting to that i gained an", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00187-00035575-00035799": "audience that i generally never expected", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00188-00035800-00035927": "and then it has grown into what it is", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00189-00035928-00036111": "today which is mind-blowing to me and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00190-00036112-00036295": "now i get to speak both on the internet", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00191-00036296-00036518": "here and professionally about things i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00192-00036519-00036671": "really care about like getting through", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00193-00036672-00036839": "hard things mental health you know", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00194-00036840-00037095": "losing limb amputation disability and it", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00195-00037096-00037223": "certainly wasn't something that i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00196-00037224-00037415": "expected to gain when i lost my leg a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00197-00037416-00037551": "very happy surprise and one that i'm", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00198-00037552-00037862": "very grateful for number six a community", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00199-00037863-00038039": "hear me out on this one i want to make", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00200-00038040-00038223": "it really clear that no not every", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00201-00038224-00038455": "amputee knows every other amputee i feel", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00202-00038456-00038574": "like there's this misconception that", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00203-00038575-00038743": "there's probably like 10 amputees in the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00204-00038744-00038887": "world and we definitely all know each", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00205-00038888-00039030": "other the reality is that there's", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00206-00039031-00039271": "hundreds of thousands and not every", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00207-00039272-00039535": "amputee gets along but i have discovered", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00208-00039536-00039774": "that the people in the limb difference", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00209-00039775-00039951": "community our apps are freaking lutely", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00210-00039952-00040159": "amazing i have made so many friends and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00211-00040160-00040318": "so many amazing connections with people", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00212-00040319-00040527": "who i share interests with and share", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00213-00040528-00040679": "passions with and the amount of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00214-00040680-00040855": "willingness to help willingness to be", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00215-00040856-00040999": "there for each other willingness to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00216-00041000-00041183": "share information or tips and tricks in", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00217-00041184-00041327": "the lim difference community is", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00218-00041328-00041535": "absolutely incredible camera angle", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00219-00041536-00041718": "changed because i was bored of that one", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00220-00041719-00042046": "numero siete the capacity and ability to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00221-00042047-00042239": "run again uh this is something that i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00222-00042240-00042518": "dreamed of since i was like 14 years old", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00223-00042519-00042718": "i could never run my ankle would not", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00224-00042719-00042895": "allow it and i thought it was something", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00225-00042896-00043102": "that was entirely off the table for me", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00226-00043103-00043335": "but i was very wrong uh running was sort", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00227-00043336-00043527": "of the icing on the cake when it came to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00228-00043528-00043702": "losing my leg about a year and a half", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00229-00043703-00043895": "after my amputation i got a levitate", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00230-00043896-00044087": "blade fantastic company i absolutely", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00231-00044088-00044271": "love working with them and i learned to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00232-00044272-00044551": "run i ran a 5k i jogged with my dad", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00233-00044552-00044727": "which is something i dreamed of doing", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00234-00044728-00045062": "it's so funny how becoming more disabled", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00235-00045063-00045271": "actually enabled me to do so much more", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00236-00045272-00045407": "in my life which brings us to the last", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00237-00045408-00045543": "couple of numbers which i'm going to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00238-00045544-00045758": "lump together like i live in colorado", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00239-00045759-00045895": "right um and if you know anything about", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00240-00045896-00046111": "the state you know it's big on hiking", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00241-00046112-00046351": "and big on winter sports the amount of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00242-00046352-00046543": "skiing and snowboarding we have here is", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00243-00046544-00046679": "nuts it's one of the best places in the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00244-00046680-00046886": "world for it and i never was able to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00245-00046887-00047079": "take part in that at all definitely", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00246-00047080-00047246": "never thought i'd be able to uh but this", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00247-00047247-00047423": "past year i learned how to snowboard and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00248-00047424-00047711": "it was so cool huge challenge and still", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00249-00047712-00047886": "is to learn how to do that with my", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00250-00047887-00048095": "prosthetic leg but i could actually do", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00251-00048096-00048415": "it quick side note my hands shake so bad", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00252-00048416-00048639": "the doing nail polish is well it's", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00253-00048640-00048799": "always an art project along the same", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00254-00048800-00049062": "lines of outdoor activities hiking i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00255-00049063-00049190": "absolutely love hiking and it's", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00256-00049191-00049407": "something that is like a part of who i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00257-00049408-00049567": "am it's kind of how i reconnect and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00258-00049568-00049774": "breathe couldn't do that with two legs", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00259-00049775-00049983": "and i can totally do it now with one and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00260-00049984-00050167": "a half also being able to rock climb", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00261-00050168-00050343": "again go to the ninja gym be able to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00262-00050344-00050479": "participate in jiu jitsu it's been", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00263-00050480-00050646": "awesome uh this is one i actually i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00264-00050647-00050807": "didn't write down but it just came to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00265-00050808-00051015": "mind acting opportunities i've been able", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00266-00051016-00051230": "to audition for some really cool stuff", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00267-00051232-00051414": "that is nothing i ever thought i would", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00268-00051415-00051630": "ever be able to do but because hollywood", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00269-00051632-00051814": "is kind of trying to make a push towards", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00270-00051815-00051935": "actually including people with", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00271-00051936-00052214": "disabilities in disabled roles which we", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00272-00052215-00052350": "love to see it i've been able to work", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00273-00052351-00052511": "with my friend dominic who's an acting", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00274-00052512-00052735": "coach and realized that acting is so", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00275-00052736-00052959": "much fun i really enjoy it i'm looking", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00276-00052960-00053150": "to pursue it more just because it's cool", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00277-00053151-00053303": "and therapeutic and you get to kind of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00278-00053304-00053438": "explore a different part of yourself all", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00279-00053439-00053607": "right coat one done now i just have to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00280-00053608-00053815": "stay put long enough not to ruin it oh", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00281-00053816-00053935": "no", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00282-00053936-00054126": "i got nail polish on my table this i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00283-00054127-00054254": "should have seen this coming we got a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00284-00054255-00054494": "shepherd hi sophie you just want to use", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00285-00054495-00054847": "me so i can throw your tennis ball", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00286-00054848-00055007": "last but not least thing number 10", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00287-00055008-00055159": "though i'm pretty sure we're like at 11", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00288-00055160-00055375": "or 12 reduced pain i'm not going to say", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00289-00055376-00055582": "pain-free because i do still experience", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00290-00055583-00055854": "a lot of phantom pain i have a lot of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00291-00055855-00056030": "sore spots and i have a neuroma right", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00292-00056032-00056191": "now that i may have to have surgery for", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00293-00056191-00056391": "there is definitely still pain in my leg", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00294-00056391-00056582": "and throughout the rest of my body but", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00295-00056583-00056847": "the combined value of that is", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00296-00056848-00057071": "substantially less than when i had an", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00297-00057072-00057215": "ankle and if you've ever lived in", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00298-00057216-00057447": "chronic pain you know the toll that", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00299-00057448-00057535": "takes", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00300-00057536-00057854": "so any pain reduction is a win for me in", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00301-00057855-00058199": "so many tangible and life-changing ways", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00302-00058200-00058447": "losing my leg has given me so much i'm", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00303-00058448-00058591": "so grateful that i got to make the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00304-00058591-00058807": "choice that i feel like i had some say", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00305-00058808-00059015": "in the direction of my life that things", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00306-00059016-00059215": "generally worked out this is a challenge", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00307-00059216-00059391": "it will continue to be for the rest of", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00308-00059391-00059575": "my life but of the options that i had it", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00309-00059576-00059742": "was the best one and it has given me so", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00310-00059744-00059911": "much in my life i really like talking", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00311-00059912-00060135": "about this kind of stuff because we", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00312-00060136-00060342": "often think of disability or amputation", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00313-00060344-00060471": "like i said at the beginning of the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00314-00060472-00060719": "video as just a loss across the board", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00315-00060720-00060879": "like i'm so sorry", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00316-00060879-00061087": "and while there is pain there is loss", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00317-00061088-00061350": "there is grief there's a lot of joy a", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00318-00061351-00061511": "lot of really beneficial things that", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00319-00061512-00061687": "have come from this change in my life", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00320-00061688-00061854": "that is it for today's list thank you so", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00321-00061855-00062030": "much to this lovely commenter for", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00322-00062032-00062230": "suggesting today's video i put a poll on", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00323-00062232-00062391": "my community page asking what you guys", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00324-00062391-00062519": "wanted to hear about because i felt like", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00325-00062520-00062726": "filming um if you saw my last video you", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00326-00062727-00062879": "know that life is a little interesting", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00327-00062879-00063054": "right now a little challenging but i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00328-00063055-00063230": "wanted to have a reason to sort of get", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00329-00063232-00063350": "put together and get in front of the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00330-00063351-00063526": "camera and talk about distracting things", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00331-00063527-00063679": "so i really appreciate you hanging out", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00332-00063679-00063863": "with me here today big thank you again", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00333-00063864-00063999": "to scentbird for sponsoring today's", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00334-00064000-00064135": "video check out that link and code in my", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00335-00064136-00064247": "description it helps to support the", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00336-00064248-00064382": "channel and also said bird is really", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00337-00064383-00064582": "gosh darn cool a huge thank you to all", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00338-00064583-00064759": "of my lovely members on patreon to so", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00339-00064760-00064903": "many new faces there it means the world", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00340-00064904-00065030": "to me that you guys are there thank you", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00341-00065032-00065215": "for your generosity and your support and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00342-00065216-00065423": "to you watching this video right now you", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00343-00065424-00065526": "could be anywhere else in the world", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00344-00065527-00065663": "doing anything else but you chose to", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00345-00065664-00065775": "hang out with me for a few minutes here", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00346-00065776-00065911": "today and i really appreciate that i", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00347-00065912-00066047": "love you guys i'm thinking about you and", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00348-00066048-00066255": "i will see you in the next video bye", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00349-00066256-00067494": "guys", "OQCmMHqiiDM-00350-00067495-00067704": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OQeMhW8xWFQ", "text": {"OQeMhW8xWFQ-00000-00000102-00000401": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "ORyqMx5Ys9U", "text": {"ORyqMx5Ys9U-00000-00000312-00000665": "[Music]", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00001-00000666-00001171": "by the 1950s led a dangerous neurotoxin", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00002-00001172-00001375": "that was once buried deep in the ground", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00003-00001376-00001741": "far far away had polluted the entire", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00004-00001742-00001816": "planet", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00005-00001817-00002221": "thanks to leaded gasoline I mean it's", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00006-00002222-00002389": "hard to imagine a better way for", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00007-00002390-00002623": "maximizing population exposure to a", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00008-00002624-00002890": "poison than to have it emitted by a", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00009-00002891-00003184": "ubiquitous mobile source to line the", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00010-00003185-00003477": "surfaces of our neighborhoods with it", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00011-00003478-00003870": "overall about five million metric tons", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00012-00003871-00004263": "of lead was deposited a single busy", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00013-00004264-00004557": "street could receive more than a ton a", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00014-00004558-00004902": "year and the ledges built up decade", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00015-00004903-00005200": "after decade but at least thanks to", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00016-00005201-00005436": "regulation starting in the 70s we", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00017-00005437-00005709": "stopped spewing so much into the air and", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00018-00005710-00006156": "as lead use dropped so did the levels of", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00019-00006157-00006546": "lead in our blood resulting in a 98%", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00020-00006547-00006756": "reduction in the percentage of young", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00021-00006757-00006963": "children with elevated blood lead levels", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00022-00006964-00007452": "of course the term elevated is relative", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00023-00007453-00007891": "prior to 1970 lead toxicity was defined", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00024-00007892-00008187": "as 60 micrograms per deciliter or higher", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00025-00008188-00008416": "but then they dropped the definition to", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00026-00008417-00008848": "40 then 30 then 25 then 10 as lead", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00027-00008849-00009058": "levels previously thought to be safe or", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00028-00009059-00009285": "inconsequential for children was", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00029-00009286-00009549": "consistently shown to be risk factors", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00030-00009550-00009880": "for cognitive and behavioral problems", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00031-00009881-00010195": "currently elevated is considered more", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00032-00010196-00010467": "than five but under five your LED level", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00033-00010468-00010752": "is considered non elevated normal but", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00034-00010753-00011046": "what does having a normal lead level", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00035-00011047-00011346": "mean virtually all residents of", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00036-00011347-00011589": "industrialized countries have bone lead", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00037-00011590-00011845": "stores that are several orders of", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00038-00011846-00012027": "magnitude greater than those of our", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00039-00012028-00012306": "pre-industrial ancestors if you go to a", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00040-00012307-00012580": "museum and test the lead levels of", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00041-00012581-00012838": "ancient skeletons buried on millennia", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00042-00012838-00013288": "ago they have a thousand times lower", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00043-00013288-00013552": "lead level compared to people today", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00044-00013553-00013822": "which indicates the probable existence", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00045-00013822-00014086": "within most Americans of dysfunctions", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00046-00014087-00014358": "caused by poisoning from chronic", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00047-00014359-00014638": "excessive over exposure to industrial", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00048-00014638-00015049": "lead this is a graphical representation", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00049-00015050-00015307": "where each dot represents 40 micrograms", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00050-00015308-00015553": "of lead the amount of lead in the right", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00051-00015554-00015838": "figure represents overtly symptomatic", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00052-00015838-00016003": "lead poisoning or where you might be", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00053-00016004-00016272": "doubled over in pain where's the middle", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00054-00016273-00016549": "figure is the lead and a typical", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00055-00016550-00016780": "American citizen and the left figure is", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00056-00016781-00016950": "how much they found in pre-industrial", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00057-00016951-00017266": "bodies see what that medical and", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00058-00017267-00017419": "research community has failed to", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00059-00017420-00017655": "understand is that they just been", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00060-00017656-00017997": "looking at these two figures alright", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00061-00017998-00018187": "people with lead poisoning and those of", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00062-00018188-00018424": "us down at normal level so-called very", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00063-00018425-00018796": "low levels but what this new data on", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00064-00018797-00019108": "what's natural for our species shows is", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00065-00019109-00019414": "that typical levels of lead and humans", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00066-00019415-00019675": "are quite definitely not very low at all", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00067-00019676-00019947": "but instead constitute grossly excessive", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00068-00019948-00020412": "thousand fold over exposure levels the", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00069-00020413-00020706": "bottom line is that no level of lead", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00070-00020707-00020974": "exposure appears to be safe and even the", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00071-00020975-00021180": "current quote unquote low levels of", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00072-00021181-00021394": "exposure and children are associated", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00073-00021395-00021615": "with neurodevelopmental deficits", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00074-00021616-00022050": "including reduced IQ but hey it could", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00075-00022051-00022209": "have been a lot worse if we hadn't", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00076-00022210-00022505": "started restricting leaded gas", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00077-00022506-00022775": "thanks to falling a blood lead level", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00078-00022776-00023003": "starting in the 70s preschoolers born in", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00079-00023004-00023303": "the 90s were like 2 to 5 IQ points", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00080-00023304-00023646": "smarter than kids like me born before", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00081-00023647-00024011": "1976 so when we see our kids and", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00082-00024012-00024189": "grandkids being such whizzes at", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00083-00024190-00024411": "technology that it's hard to keep up", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00084-00024412-00024658": "with them a small part of that may be", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00085-00024659-00024972": "them not suffering as much lead induced", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00086-00024973-00025355": "brain damage as we did and what that", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00087-00025356-00025578": "means for the country is potentially", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00088-00025579-00025796": "hundreds of billions of dollars of", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00089-00025797-00026021": "improved productivity because her kids", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00090-00026022-00026327": "are less brain damaged if that seems", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00091-00026328-00026696": "like a lot for just a few IQ points well", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00092-00026697-00026893": "you have to realize is that even a small", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00093-00026894-00027273": "shift in average IQ could result in a", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00094-00027274-00027573": "50% increase in the number of so-called", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00095-00027574-00027902": "mentally [__] millions more in need", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00096-00027903-00028323": "of special education and services so the", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00097-00028324-00028545": "removal of lead from gasoline in the", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00098-00028545-00028718": "United States may be one of the great", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00099-00028719-00029001": "public health achievements of the 20th", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00100-00029002-00029537": "century but it almost did not happen", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00101-00029538-00029781": "tremendous pressure by the lead industry", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00102-00029782-00029949": "was brought to bear to quite even", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00103-00029950-00030129": "intimidate researchers and clinicians", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00104-00030130-00030446": "who dared report on or identify lead as", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00105-00030447-00030795": "a hazard decent scientists and health", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00106-00030795-00031152": "officials faced enormous opposition but", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00107-00031152-00031346": "never lost sight of the mandate to", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00108-00031347-00031712": "protect public health in this personal", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00109-00031713-00031995": "perspective two of the idealistic young", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00110-00031995-00032264": "employees at the newly formed EPA", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00111-00032266-00032480": "who played key roles in the fight", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00112-00032481-00032768": "recount how naive they were to the ways", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00113-00032769-00033158": "of Washington our youth was used against", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00114-00033159-00033420": "us they recall their inexperience cited", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00115-00033421-00033618": "as a reason for rejecting their", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00116-00033619-00033942": "proposals in retrospect however their", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00117-00033943-00034152": "youth and inexperience may have helped", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00118-00034153-00034367": "them to succeed in taking on a", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00119-00034368-00034715": "billion-dollar industry we were too", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00120-00034716-00035039": "young to know that regulating lead and", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00121-00035040-00036001": "gasoline was impossible", "ORyqMx5Ys9U-00122-00036002-00036370": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OREnbixMGEE", "text": {"OREnbixMGEE-00000-00000296-00003572": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00001-00003572-00004283": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00002-00004284-00006268": "is", "OREnbixMGEE-00003-00006269-00006798": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00004-00006800-00007326": "let's go round number one", "OREnbixMGEE-00005-00007327-00008483": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00006-00008484-00009823": "hey", "OREnbixMGEE-00007-00009824-00010363": "subscribe", "OREnbixMGEE-00008-00010364-00012583": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00009-00012584-00013865": "oh my god", "OREnbixMGEE-00010-00013866-00014083": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00011-00014084-00014500": "m", "OREnbixMGEE-00012-00014501-00015483": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00013-00015484-00016883": "um", "OREnbixMGEE-00014-00016884-00017824": "um", "OREnbixMGEE-00015-00017825-00018283": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00016-00018284-00019550": "yes", "OREnbixMGEE-00017-00019551-00020305": "means a tiger", "OREnbixMGEE-00018-00020306-00020983": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00019-00020984-00022655": "oh my god", "OREnbixMGEE-00020-00022656-00025283": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00021-00025284-00026277": "foreign", "OREnbixMGEE-00022-00026279-00026683": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00023-00026683-00028083": "um", "OREnbixMGEE-00024-00028083-00029943": "um", "OREnbixMGEE-00025-00029944-00030848": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00026-00030849-00031808": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00027-00031808-00032283": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00028-00032283-00035083": "subscribers", "OREnbixMGEE-00029-00035084-00035338": "okay", "OREnbixMGEE-00030-00035339-00036483": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00031-00036484-00037883": "expensive", "OREnbixMGEE-00032-00037884-00038920": "um", "OREnbixMGEE-00033-00038921-00039283": "[Music]", "OREnbixMGEE-00034-00039284-00039584": "video"}}, {"audio_id": "ORZjx5e-o4Q", "text": {"ORZjx5e-o4Q-00000-00000065-00000364": "you know what hey I'm just gonna", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00001-00000365-00000641": "cheat", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00002-00000642-00001162": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00003-00001163-00001535": "one bro", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00004-00001536-00001757": "why", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00005-00001757-00002184": "is it okay is it working nope", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00006-00002185-00002339": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00007-00002340-00003017": "all right oh what the hell are those", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00008-00003018-00003569": "oh what the hell is this gotta go", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00009-00003570-00003865": "no no no no no no no no", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00010-00003865-00004049": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00011-00004050-00004490": "just one", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00012-00004491-00004836": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00013-00004837-00005704": "all right oh", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00014-00005705-00005950": "get exiled let's go", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00015-00005951-00006409": "[Applause]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00016-00006411-00006841": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00017-00006842-00007337": "all right all right", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00018-00007338-00007528": "get in", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00019-00007529-00007723": "we're just getting", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00020-00007723-00007925": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00021-00007926-00008483": "what the", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00022-00008484-00009241": "that's why here's why yes what do this", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00023-00009242-00009719": "knock it out get out of here to end the", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00024-00009720-00009889": "end", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00025-00009890-00010182": "yes yes", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00026-00010183-00010499": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00027-00010500-00010794": "see you no no no no no no no", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00028-00010795-00010963": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00029-00010964-00011333": "why what is this game what is this game", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00030-00011334-00011560": "what is this game please please please", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00031-00011561-00011692": "please please please please please", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00032-00011693-00012163": "please please just get me get it", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00033-00012164-00012509": "no no no no no no no let's go no no no", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00034-00012510-00012993": "no no no no no", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00035-00012994-00014465": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00036-00014466-00014753": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00037-00014754-00014938": "what", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00038-00014938-00015125": "[Music]", "ORZjx5e-o4Q-00039-00015126-00015344": "no"}}, {"audio_id": "ORa81asfga8", "text": {"ORa81asfga8-00000-00000199-00000975": "[Music]", "ORa81asfga8-00001-00000976-00001174": "over the edge", "ORa81asfga8-00002-00001175-00001462": "i feel like i'm flowing through", "ORa81asfga8-00003-00001463-00002910": "the air", "ORa81asfga8-00004-00002911-00003254": "the web i need to kick the habit that my", "ORa81asfga8-00005-00003255-00005102": "mind is", "ORa81asfga8-00006-00005103-00005659": "fearless", "ORa81asfga8-00007-00005660-00005863": "[Music]", "ORa81asfga8-00008-00005864-00006627": "with", "ORa81asfga8-00009-00006628-00007606": "[Music]", "ORa81asfga8-00010-00007608-00009635": "with", "ORa81asfga8-00011-00009636-00010005": "exaggerated that's what give us", "ORa81asfga8-00012-00010006-00011255": "[Music]", "ORa81asfga8-00013-00011256-00012623": "i want", "ORa81asfga8-00014-00012624-00013830": "spent all", "ORa81asfga8-00015-00013831-00014482": "fearless", "ORa81asfga8-00016-00014483-00015355": "[Music]", "ORa81asfga8-00017-00015356-00017810": "[Music]", "ORa81asfga8-00018-00017811-00018639": "[Music]", "ORa81asfga8-00019-00018640-00018848": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "ORbCz4b3Qb0", "text": {"ORbCz4b3Qb0-00000-00000444-00000740": "yesterday I am so the main topic of this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00001-00000741-00000917": "presentation will be the topic of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00002-00000918-00001058": "password reuse but also general", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00003-00001059-00001511": "statistics on passwords first my agenda", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00004-00001512-00001742": "so first I motivated topic so what's the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00005-00001743-00002067": "main problem why do we do this analysis", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00006-00002068-00002312": "what kind of data that we use for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00007-00002313-00002657": "analysis some general statistics on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00008-00002658-00002977": "data afterwards like more concrete", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00009-00002978-00003182": "statistics on the topic of password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00010-00003183-00003415": "reuse and the last part we show how we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00011-00003417-00003689": "can use this knowledge to show that", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00012-00003690-00003832": "casper cracking can be even more", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00013-00003833-00004193": "improved because of password reuse and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00014-00004194-00004672": "again we come to a conclusion so first", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00015-00004673-00004895": "of all like the general problems of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00016-00004896-00005239": "leaks database leaks identity leaks", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00017-00005240-00005552": "however you call them so this graph", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00018-00005553-00005785": "shows you like how many identities are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00019-00005786-00006157": "usually leaked every month on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00020-00006158-00006341": "internet and so publicly leaked", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00021-00006342-00006545": "everybody can access them everybody can", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00022-00006545-00006962": "download them and so I think in median", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00023-00006963-00007229": "they are like 5 million identity sleep", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00024-00007230-00007820": "per month so what's the problem of these", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00025-00007820-00008027": "leaks so usually the people that are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00026-00008028-00008231": "affected by them so the the users that", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00027-00008232-00008453": "are in these database dumps they don't", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00028-00008454-00008585": "know that the data has been leaked", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00029-00008586-00009014": "and so because not all the leaks are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00030-00009015-00009176": "reported in the media only the very big", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00031-00009177-00009485": "ones and even the big ones not everybody", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00032-00009486-00009671": "cares about the news they will only", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00033-00009672-00009821": "realize if their accounts are actually", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00034-00009822-00010343": "compromised and yeah and their money is", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00035-00010344-00010607": "stolen or their identity is stolen", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00036-00010608-00010907": "something like this and so the cyber", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00037-00010908-00011224": "criminals that can use this easily so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00038-00011225-00011477": "they use the fact that people don't know", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00039-00011478-00011780": "and they have a lot of time or a big", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00040-00011781-00011996": "time frame where they can misuse to data", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00041-00011997-00012289": "until the victims actually realize what", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00042-00012290-00013055": "has happened okay so for this or for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00043-00013056-00013343": "this general problem we have created a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00044-00013344-00013647": "service for people to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00045-00013647-00013991": "to warn the people about identity leaks", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00046-00013991-00014253": "because we came so we start this project", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00047-00014254-00014639": "with the Adobe League in 2013 and we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00048-00014640-00014835": "were interested how many people from our", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00049-00014836-00015122": "faculty my actually affected by this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00050-00015123-00015461": "Adobe leak and so we wanted to know", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00051-00015462-00015680": "which people we have to warn in our", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00052-00015681-00016002": "faculty about these leaks and so this is", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00053-00016003-00016169": "the start of our service so when we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00054-00016169-00016469": "sorted okay now it didn't stop with", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00055-00016470-00016635": "Adobe so they where more leaks coming", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00056-00016636-00016899": "and we incorporated this into the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00057-00016900-00017025": "service and made it accessible to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00058-00017026-00017571": "everyone so this is the service so you", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00059-00017572-00017790": "can go to this web page sector to HP IDE", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00060-00017791-00018069": "type in your email and then you will see", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00061-00018070-00018372": "whether you are affected by an identity", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00062-00018373-00018933": "leak yeah for now so we start the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00063-00018934-00019081": "service in May 2014", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00064-00019082-00019430": "until then 2.7 million people have", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00065-00019431-00019794": "requested our servers and from these 2.7", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00066-00019795-00019977": "million two hundred seventy thousand", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00067-00019978-00020217": "people were actually affected by one or", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00068-00020218-00020480": "Diabolique so this is like 10% of the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00069-00020481-00020853": "people are affected or together now we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00070-00020854-00021189": "have 2.5 billion credentialed in this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00071-00021190-00021603": "service which currently are from 70", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00072-00021604-00022169": "different database leaks and yeah so at", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00073-00022170-00022325": "the moment we are also collecting other", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00074-00022326-00022458": "leaks automatically for example from", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00075-00022459-00022715": "pastebin or from other forums or web", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00076-00022716-00023003": "pages and altogether now we have more", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00077-00023004-00023208": "than 20,000 leaks but it's really hard", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00078-00023209-00023369": "to incorporate it into the service", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00079-00023370-00023644": "because it requires a menu verification", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00080-00023645-00024250": "about a said oh okay so based on this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00081-00024251-00024647": "service we had the ability to actually", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00082-00024648-00025044": "have access to this data and to do some", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00083-00025045-00025394": "tests on this okay now to the problem of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00084-00025395-00025694": "password reuse so there was an", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00085-00025695-00026055": "interesting report from Verizon and 2016", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00086-00026056-00026310": "where they said that 63% of all", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00087-00026311-00026558": "confirmed data breaches are because of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00088-00026559-00026787": "the wrong use of passwords so this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00089-00026788-00027006": "includes password reuse", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00090-00027007-00027183": "that passwords have been stolen so also", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00091-00027183-00027438": "some kind of reuse or the usage of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00092-00027439-00027870": "default passwords if we look at some of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00093-00027870-00028104": "the biggest data leak that I have that", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00094-00028105-00028455": "have happened this year Dropbox and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00095-00028456-00028710": "LinkedIn so there it's known or not", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00096-00028711-00028970": "known but like the assume that these", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00097-00028972-00029139": "data leaks only happened because of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00098-00029139-00029397": "hazard reuse so in the case of Dropbox", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00099-00029398-00029738": "they assume that one employee actually", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00100-00029739-00030063": "was hacker there their credentials were", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00101-00030064-00030219": "leaked so this employees credentials", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00102-00030220-00030431": "predict somewhere in another league and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00103-00030432-00030642": "this credentials were then used to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00104-00030643-00030801": "access the Dropbox of this employee and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00105-00030802-00031002": "in this Dropbox there were more", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00106-00031002-00031200": "information where the attackers were", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00107-00031201-00031533": "able to access the database of Dropbox", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00108-00031533-00031952": "and this again led to another data leak", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00109-00031954-00032364": "which can then again be used to yeah to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00110-00032364-00032655": "compromise more databases same for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00111-00032656-00033426": "LinkedIn yeah another example for this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00112-00033427-00033645": "how password reuse actually effects us", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00113-00033646-00033975": "so after this LinkedIn leak and MySpace", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00114-00033976-00034188": "leak which happened this year we started", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00115-00034189-00034595": "on Twitter or many social networks like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00116-00034596-00034932": "accounts from prominent people we're", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00117-00034933-00035181": "taking over because they used or reuse", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00118-00035182-00035559": "their passwords from the myspace leak so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00119-00035560-00035772": "some examples for example Mark", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00120-00035773-00035922": "Zuckerberg Katy Perry", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00121-00035923-00036197": "David Guetta so all the accounts we're", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00122-00036198-00036681": "taking over and get a general problem of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00123-00036682-00036888": "this we use is everybody talks about it", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00124-00036889-00037050": "everybody knows that this is a general", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00125-00037051-00037241": "problem but there's no real", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00126-00037242-00037488": "comprehensive study on this or like on a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00127-00037489-00037728": "big data set so it's just in the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00128-00037729-00037893": "assumption that this is a big problem", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00129-00037894-00038379": "and we wanted to confirm this in in our", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00130-00038380-00038747": "study", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00131-00038748-00039114": "yes our goal is to based on the huge", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00132-00039115-00039534": "data set we have for service anyhow to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00133-00039535-00039810": "create a study based on real password or", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00134-00039811-00040308": "real-world password data", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00135-00040309-00040657": "so the advantage we have is that for our", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00136-00040658-00040789": "service we have to normalize the leaks", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00137-00040790-00040978": "in a way so we have to know at which", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00138-00040979-00041251": "position in the database leaks the the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00139-00041252-00041446": "emails are stored that we can then hash", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00140-00041447-00041686": "and like make accessible of our webpage", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00141-00041687-00042039": "for querying and we know where the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00142-00042040-00042289": "passwords are positioned in the leaks so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00143-00042290-00042436": "that we know where the user is actually", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00144-00042437-00042792": "affected by a leak passwords or not and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00145-00042793-00043218": "so this normalization we can already use", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00146-00043219-00043918": "for further analysis okay here you see a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00147-00043919-00044115": "list of leaks we actually incorporated", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00148-00044116-00044323": "into our study so at a point we did the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00149-00044324-00044586": "study like not all the currently known", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00150-00044587-00044929": "database leaks were actually publicly", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00151-00044930-00045235": "accessible so for example Dropbox which", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00152-00045236-00045535": "is not part of this so altogether we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00153-00045536-00046077": "analyzed 31 different leaks from there", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00154-00046078-00046420": "21 databases it's sure that they're kind", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00155-00046421-00046707": "that they came from database dumps and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00156-00046708-00047008": "ten other leaks it's not know where they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00157-00047009-00047187": "come from these are just collections of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00158-00047188-00047632": "credentials and so it's not or it's", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00159-00047633-00047935": "quite sure that these passwords do not", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00160-00047936-00048043": "come from the service but we are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00161-00048044-00048364": "collected otherwise so what's quite", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00162-00048365-00048955": "typical is that people try to or take a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00163-00048956-00049207": "big database already then try these", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00164-00049208-00049399": "credentials on a different side for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00165-00049400-00049555": "example this was the case or probably", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00166-00049556-00049737": "case for Twitter so they tried", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00167-00049738-00049942": "credentials on Twitter and when they saw", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00168-00049943-00050214": "that there was a successful login they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00169-00050215-00050383": "collected this into a big database and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00170-00050384-00050677": "then publish this database of like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00171-00050678-00050995": "successful login as Twitter database but", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00172-00050996-00051187": "this is not the database of Twitter but", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00173-00051188-00051330": "these are just valid credentials for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00174-00051332-00051736": "Twitter and so for the password we use", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00175-00051737-00052032": "you can only use these 21 leaks because", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00176-00052033-00052204": "they there you really know that they are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00177-00052204-00052614": "not a product of password reuse", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00178-00052615-00052978": "altogether these 31 different leaks they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00179-00052979-00053122": "have nine hundred ninety five million", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00180-00053123-00053387": "credentials altogether and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00181-00053388-00053541": "[Music]", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00182-00053542-00053761": "among these credentials there are they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00183-00053762-00054103": "are 884 million distinct email addresses", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00184-00054104-00054565": "in it from these 884 million there are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00185-00054566-00054796": "68 million addresses that have an", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00186-00054797-00054999": "account at least in two of these leaks", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00187-00055000-00055324": "so these 68 million addresses actually", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00188-00055325-00055594": "qualify for analysis on the password we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00189-00055595-00056146": "use okay some general statistics on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00190-00056147-00056473": "data we collected so we had to look at", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00191-00056474-00056782": "the at the password routines that they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00192-00056783-00057139": "used and then and so on the very right", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00193-00057140-00057373": "side you see the dumps so the 21 I just", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00194-00057374-00057579": "mentioned so this is the one that we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00195-00057580-00057754": "have to take into account not the number", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00196-00057754-00058324": "of leaks so there you see that sixty", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00197-00058325-00058579": "percent sixty two percent of the data", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00198-00058579-00058786": "leaks actually store their passwords in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00199-00058787-00059016": "securely this means either clear text", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00200-00059017-00059316": "md5 or sha-1 so because md5 and sha-1 is", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00201-00059317-00059554": "pretty easy to look it up in the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00202-00059554-00059824": "internet and find the right password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00203-00059825-00060526": "behind it so only 30 percent of the of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00204-00060527-00060886": "the databases use more secure mechanisms", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00205-00060887-00061198": "like combining md5 and sha-1 with a salt", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00206-00061199-00061522": "but still it's possible to recover a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00207-00061523-00061926": "large amount of passwords yeah", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00208-00061927-00062338": "for these routines and only one service", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00209-00062339-00062563": "actually used a secure password store", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00210-00062564-00063532": "mechanism which is really scary ok so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00211-00063533-00063799": "when we look at the passwords and they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00212-00063800-00063979": "write included so this didn't only", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00213-00063979-00064246": "contain key text passwords but also hash", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00214-00064247-00064648": "passwords as we just saw and so around", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00215-00064649-00064795": "50 percent of the passwords were", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00216-00064796-00065248": "actually password hashes and because we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00217-00065249-00065407": "cannot compare or we cannot use this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00218-00065408-00065677": "data for the password reuse or general", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00219-00065678-00065971": "password analysis we looked into common", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00220-00065972-00066358": "ways on how to like get from the hashes", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00221-00066359-00066736": "to the password and so here like four", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00222-00066737-00066935": "main methods we have used", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00223-00066936-00067178": "so first of all you can use rainbow", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00224-00067179-00067378": "tables larger rainbow tables for looking", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00225-00067379-00067622": "up passwords but this is only like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00226-00067623-00067849": "possible for aspects that happen really", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00227-00067850-00068080": "often because it's a really", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00228-00068081-00068350": "time-consuming test to look up hashes in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00229-00068351-00068810": "a rainbow table also for passwords that", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00230-00068811-00068941": "you find quite often you could use", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00231-00068942-00069181": "Google to look them up so because many", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00232-00069182-00069481": "people already try to recover passwords", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00233-00069482-00069769": "from from hashes and if you just type in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00234-00069770-00069982": "a hash on Google you will find the clear", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00235-00069983-00070381": "text passwords in many cases for the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00236-00070382-00070760": "majority of the passwords you can come", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00237-00070761-00071017": "to a head cracking web pages so there", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00238-00071018-00071328": "are web pages that where this community", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00239-00071329-00071647": "is cracking passwords basically the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00240-00071648-00071972": "whole day and they are distributing the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00241-00071973-00072229": "correct passwords in the forums and this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00242-00072230-00072454": "you can download and then like compare", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00243-00072455-00072736": "it to the hashes you have so in in this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00244-00072737-00073117": "case for many larger leaks you find like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00245-00073118-00073334": "huge listings of all the crack passwords", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00246-00073335-00073699": "in it so for example for myspace I think", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00247-00073700-00074155": "up to now 99 or even more of the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00248-00074156-00074869": "passwords have been correct 99% okay", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00249-00074870-00075457": "yeah and what we also did is four so for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00250-00075458-00075865": "four passwords for a hashed email", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00251-00075866-00076178": "address where there was one key text", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00252-00076179-00076346": "password at least we tried this clear", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00253-00076347-00076567": "text password also for the hashed", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00254-00076568-00077029": "variants of the same hashed email so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00255-00077030-00077285": "this allows us to like better conclude", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00256-00077286-00077611": "the password we use okay so this is the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00257-00077612-00077811": "number of are the percentages", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00258-00077812-00078049": "shown and also the number of clear text", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00259-00078050-00078229": "passwords for each of the leaks we could", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00260-00078230-00078544": "recover by these methods so altogether", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00261-00078545-00078862": "we were able to like recover eighty-five", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00262-00078863-00079015": "percent of all the passwords in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00263-00079016-00079438": "clear-text altogether this is eight", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00264-00079439-00079642": "hundred forty eight million credentials", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00265-00079643-00080023": "and clear text and altogether discovers", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00266-00080024-00080482": "320 million different passwords", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00267-00080483-00080690": "okay so now we have to clear text", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00268-00080691-00080987": "passwords and yeah now we did different", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00269-00080988-00081251": "analysis on it so first of all the links", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00270-00081252-00081509": "analysis we did this for the distinct", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00271-00081510-00081926": "passwords empty individual passwords so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00272-00081927-00082214": "individual means a password like if one", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00273-00082215-00082571": "password was used by ten users then the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00274-00082572-00082934": "dis ting would be one-time and the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00275-00082935-00083278": "individual one would be ten times so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00276-00083279-00083525": "there you see like the majority of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00277-00083526-00083684": "passwords it's actually in the range of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00278-00083685-00084317": "of eight character links eight and the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00279-00084318-00084491": "reason for this is that at the moment", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00280-00084492-00084803": "still the recommendation for the optimal", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00281-00084804-00085031": "password is eight characters which we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00282-00085032-00085283": "know is not the best recommendation that", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00283-00085284-00085442": "is probably what many users think is", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00284-00085443-00085475": "right", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00285-00085476-00085802": "so they exactly take eight characters as", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00286-00085803-00086336": "their length for the character", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00287-00086337-00086789": "distribution of these passwords we see", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00288-00086790-00087077": "that 56 percent of the passwords are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00289-00087078-00087455": "actually off on a miracle and so this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00290-00087456-00087617": "you can see on the left side you see", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00291-00087618-00087863": "which character classes are included a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00292-00087864-00088145": "new password and on the right side you", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00293-00088146-00088340": "see which sequence of character classes", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00294-00088341-00088640": "appear in the password and so that's", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00295-00088641-00088958": "quite interesting that 39 percent of all", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00296-00088959-00089186": "the passwords are actually alpha is", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00297-00089187-00089492": "followed by digits so the typical", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00298-00089493-00090164": "password 1 or password 1 2 3 okay like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00299-00090165-00090347": "to talk passwords not so interesting so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00300-00090348-00090911": "or nothing nothing so new you see that", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00301-00090912-00091166": "many of the passwords are actually going", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00302-00091167-00091457": "back to keyboard walks or some sort of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00303-00091458-00091787": "keyboard walk and so all this is like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00304-00091788-00092057": "quite easy to or like draw a line on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00305-00092058-00092131": "keyboard", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00306-00092132-00092564": "except phrases like password and I love", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00307-00092565-00093122": "you", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00308-00093123-00093410": "okay for the password we use coming out", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00309-00093411-00093842": "to this topic we use two approaches to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00310-00093843-00094214": "look at this one is to find identical", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00311-00094215-00094628": "passwords that I used among one email", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00312-00094629-00095096": "and similar passwords because we know", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00313-00095097-00095372": "that some users are advanced and don't", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00314-00095373-00095600": "only use the identical password but like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00315-00095601-00095915": "used for example the current year at the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00316-00095916-00096239": "end so that we also want to come on in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00317-00096240-00096545": "some way and that we also consider the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00318-00096546-00097013": "similar passwords for the password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00319-00097014-00097328": "similarity we use the levenshtein", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00320-00097329-00097676": "distance which is like easiest to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00321-00097677-00098024": "calculate and still like gives a proper", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00322-00098025-00098306": "value where you can work with so this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00323-00098307-00098534": "latest Anderson basically shows you how", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00324-00098535-00098693": "many modifications have been done on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00325-00098694-00099059": "passwords how many insertions delete", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00326-00099060-00099368": "deletions and substitutions I have been", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00327-00099369-00099563": "applied on my password so here on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00328-00099564-00099734": "right you see an example for this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00329-00099735-00100051": "password and password password one where", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00330-00100052-00100295": "the S has been replaced by dollar sign", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00331-00100296-00100727": "and the OL replaced by 0 and here the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00332-00100728-00101252": "distance will be 4 and if you yeah and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00333-00101253-00101438": "if you take this number and divide it by", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00334-00101439-00101669": "the the maximum length of the password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00335-00101670-00102161": "you receive a relative scoring for this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00336-00102162-00102472": "distance so this means a password that's", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00337-00102473-00102839": "100% identical has a score of 1 hour per", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00338-00102840-00103543": "cent or 1 and yeah 10 a password of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00339-00103544-00103772": "length 10 we have three characters have", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00340-00103773-00104192": "been modified as a as a score of 70% or", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00341-00104193-00104915": "0.7 okay and so because many are there", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00342-00104916-00105227": "there are some users which are available", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00343-00105228-00105623": "in like multiple sites five six seven", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00344-00105624-00106060": "sites we had to find a way to find", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00345-00106061-00106304": "passwords or clusters of passwords which", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00346-00106305-00106464": "are similar", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00347-00106465-00106695": "because it might be that some users use", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00348-00106696-00106869": "multiple passwords for different sites", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00349-00106870-00107364": "and yet these classes of passwords we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00350-00107365-00107643": "want to detect so that's why we use", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00351-00107644-00107933": "graphs for this our weighted graph in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00352-00107934-00108381": "this case in this case the nodes of the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00353-00108382-00108672": "graph of the graph are a password with", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00354-00108673-00109095": "its source and the edges of the of two", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00355-00109096-00109307": "passwords or of two password nodes", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00356-00109308-00109608": "indicate the similarity or the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00357-00109608-00109791": "Levenstein or the relative Levenstein", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00358-00109792-00110283": "distance and to find similar and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00359-00110283-00110421": "identical passwords we basically put a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00360-00110422-00110808": "mask on this graph where we say okay now", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00361-00110808-00111161": "give us all the sub graphs where each of", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00362-00111163-00111468": "the nodes are all of the nodes are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00363-00111469-00111714": "connected with an edge that is at least", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00364-00111715-00112052": "over a certain threshold so four", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00365-00112053-00112275": "identical passwords the threshold would", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00366-00112276-00112941": "be 1.0 or 100% and for the similarity we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00367-00112942-00113346": "chose a value of 70 percent so that we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00368-00113347-00113672": "set the value must be larger or equal to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00369-00113673-00114483": "70% so finding this these clusters can", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00370-00114483-00114651": "be done like with typical graph", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00371-00114652-00115210": "algorithms finding cliques in the graph", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00372-00115211-00115533": "okay so based on these sixty-eight", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00373-00115533-00116048": "million email addresses we have analyzed", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00374-00116049-00116397": "that have at least two credentialed we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00375-00116398-00116580": "found out that four identical password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00376-00116581-00116867": "so for a similarity score of 100 percent", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00377-00116868-00117132": "twenty percent of the users on average", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00378-00117133-00117381": "use identical credentials for multiple", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00379-00117382-00117839": "pages so in 60 thousand users from this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00380-00117840-00118083": "68 million actually use the same", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00381-00118083-00118623": "password over more than four sources for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00382-00118624-00118830": "similar passwords so with the similarity", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00383-00118831-00119307": "score of 70 percent it's 77 27% of the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00384-00119308-00119751": "users", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00385-00119752-00120082": "okay now a more detailed overview of the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00386-00120083-00120520": "similarities so what we did is because", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00387-00120521-00120742": "it's like a general score like a average", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00388-00120743-00121273": "scored is 20% and so we know that some", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00389-00121274-00121648": "pages have much higher we use cars", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00390-00121649-00121858": "actually so that's why we compared each", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00391-00121858-00122176": "source with each source and so what's", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00392-00122177-00122418": "quite interesting so I marked a few here", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00393-00122419-00122755": "which can be combined to a certain", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00394-00122756-00123013": "cluster of websites and the blue one", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00395-00123014-00123360": "which is shiny sites and the red one for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00396-00123361-00123609": "dating sites and if you see the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00397-00123610-00123874": "similarity scores there for Chinese for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00398-00123875-00124203": "example you see that there is 61 2 or", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00399-00124204-00124611": "even 70% of password reuse for shiny", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00400-00124613-00124959": "sites and also for dating sites they're", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00401-00124960-00125275": "much higher reuse rates and typical 20%", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00402-00125276-00125476": "they are like forty five percent and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00403-00125477-00125745": "forty forty two percent forty percent so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00404-00125746-00126342": "that's quite scary actually", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00405-00126343-00126711": "all right yeah another stuff or another", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00406-00126713-00127276": "analysis we did is based on the on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00407-00127277-00127594": "regional passwords so when we analyze", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00408-00127595-00127908": "the the passwords we also extracted the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00409-00127909-00128155": "top-level domain from the emails and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00410-00128156-00128589": "like did a listing for unique passwords", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00411-00128590-00128932": "for top-level domains so basically we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00412-00128933-00129169": "calculated the top 1,000 the general top", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00413-00129170-00129598": "1,000 passwords and extract it from the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00414-00129599-00129877": "original ones extract the top 1000 from", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00415-00129878-00130048": "these and in the end there were only the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00416-00130049-00130180": "ones that are really specific to the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00417-00130181-00130434": "country and yeah what's quite", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00418-00130435-00130882": "interesting so for UK that there are the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00419-00130883-00131170": "football clubs certain names that are", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00420-00131171-00131626": "typical for the country for the German", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00421-00131627-00132061": "one that there's a like the keyboard", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00422-00132062-00132625": "layout you can see you know so maybe one", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00423-00132626-00133001": "or like a few specifics on", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00424-00133002-00133199": "nice and Russian passwords what you can", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00425-00133200-00133409": "see is so Russian and Chinese passwords", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00426-00133410-00133738": "are I have a lot of numbers in it and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00427-00133739-00134113": "for Russians what we can observe is that", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00428-00134114-00134329": "basically the Russians have their", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00429-00134330-00134543": "Corolla keyboard in front of them", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00430-00134544-00134870": "typing there like Krulak passwords on it", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00431-00134871-00135149": "but in the computer they have the u.s.", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00432-00135150-00135407": "keyboard layout selected so when they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00433-00135408-00135689": "type their password in the end the few", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00434-00135690-00135926": "like random characters appear because", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00435-00135927-00136094": "like the mapping is completely different", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00436-00136095-00136364": "and if you see the password or the top", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00437-00136365-00136691": "passwords of Russian users you will", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00438-00136692-00136865": "think that these are random character", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00439-00136866-00137084": "strings they don't make any sense but if", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00440-00137085-00137264": "you know this fact and you know what", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00441-00137265-00137630": "password is behind it for Chinese ones", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00442-00137631-00137762": "what they have", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00443-00137763-00138314": "so you see here like 5 2 0 1 3 1 4 this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00444-00138315-00138614": "is actually an if you pronounce password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00445-00138615-00138977": "or if you pronounce numbers in or these", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00446-00138978-00139166": "numbers in Chinese it sounds like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00447-00139167-00139604": "something I love you or like you are my", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00448-00139605-00139871": "only one and no so these are like lab", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00449-00139872-00140819": "related passwords same as this wine ok", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00450-00140820-00141152": "based on this knowledge and I told you", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00451-00141153-00141374": "that there's one leak which actually", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00452-00141375-00141800": "used strong password hashes this was the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00453-00141801-00142094": "Ashley Madison leak which has decreed", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00454-00142095-00142463": "with a cost factor of 12 and what this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00455-00142464-00142777": "means is if you try to brute-force", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00456-00142778-00143276": "bcrypt you have like rates of around 10", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00457-00143277-00143600": "to 100 calculated hashes per second", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00458-00143601-00143915": "which is extremely slow and so this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00459-00143916-00144170": "means if you want to only like to check", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00460-00144171-00144434": "the top 100 against Ashley Madison this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00461-00144435-00145208": "can take maybe multiple years and yeah", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00462-00145209-00145481": "so this is not really reasonable to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00463-00145482-00145655": "crack passwords in the traditional", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00464-00145656-00146114": "manner for Ashley Madison and there was", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00465-00146115-00146360": "one article by", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00466-00146361-00146726": "the cynosure team who tried to attack", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00467-00146727-00146984": "these Hesh shells and what hey did they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00468-00146985-00147170": "use the weakness in this league", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00469-00147171-00147425": "so actually medicine in the like and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00470-00147426-00147611": "some older times they stored some", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00471-00147612-00147911": "passwords in md5 or in the modified md5", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00472-00147912-00148376": "version so they they lowercased all the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00473-00148377-00148562": "passwords and calculated the md5", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00474-00148563-00148934": "password from it and sort of fun to find", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00475-00148935-00149048": "out the real password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00476-00149049-00149213": "you basically have to try all the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00477-00149214-00149405": "variations because it was lowercase you", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00478-00149406-00149519": "have to try all the variations with", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00479-00149520-00149692": "upper cases to find a real password", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00480-00149693-00149924": "because in the new version they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00481-00149925-00150224": "accounted for the the Kaazing so they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00482-00150225-00150581": "did in lower case and so first they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00483-00150582-00150797": "cracked the md5 hashes with the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00484-00150798-00151127": "lowercase version and then tried all the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00485-00151128-00151595": "uppercase variations with bcrypt so like", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00486-00151596-00152168": "for some Passover like if you say so", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00487-00152169-00152396": "this means for each password you have to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00488-00152397-00152663": "only check a few passwords and bcrypt in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00489-00152664-00152903": "the end so I'm using this approach they", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00490-00152904-00153104": "were able to recover 2.1 million", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00491-00153105-00153584": "passwords from this leak okay what we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00492-00153585-00153902": "tried now is so based on the on the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00493-00153903-00154163": "leaks we have already and the clear text", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00494-00154164-00154396": "passwords we had already we tried to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00495-00154397-00154703": "like for the users that were stored in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00496-00154704-00154997": "Ashley Madison to find passwords and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00497-00154998-00155243": "other leaks and checked whether this", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00498-00155244-00155468": "password is actually the same as the one", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00499-00155469-00155558": "that was sort of bcrypt", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00500-00155559-00155861": "and using this approach we were able to", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00501-00155862-00156164": "recover 2.9 million passwords only in a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00502-00156165-00156344": "few hours because we only had to check", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00503-00156345-00156695": "more or less to free passwords for each", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00504-00156696-00156920": "of these users and yeah if there was a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00505-00156921-00157658": "match then we merely see the result and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00506-00157659-00158123": "this also shows that password reuse does", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00507-00158124-00158309": "not even protect against like strong", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00508-00158310-00158647": "cryptography or strong password hashes", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00509-00158648-00158935": "you still have to use different", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00510-00158936-00159230": "credentials for different sides even if", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00511-00159231-00159638": "they securely store their passwords", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00512-00159639-00159836": "okay like our conclusion so we have", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00513-00159837-00160052": "provided a password study that's", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00514-00160053-00160445": "basically working on a few hundred", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00515-00160446-00160916": "millions of passwords yeah the main", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00516-00160917-00161183": "topic or the main focus here was the", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00517-00161184-00161372": "topic of passwords because it's like in", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00518-00161373-00161561": "this everybody talks about it but nobody", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00519-00161562-00161939": "knows the real numbers from it and we", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00520-00161940-00162158": "found out that on average twenty percent", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00521-00162159-00162412": "of the users reuse their passwords", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00522-00162413-00162751": "twenty seven use similar passwords and", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00523-00162752-00162974": "similar sites even have much higher", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00524-00162975-00163373": "rates than this yeah password reuse a", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00525-00163374-00163682": "serious problem and even if you use", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00526-00163683-00164081": "strong hashing it doesn't help you for", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00527-00164082-00164462": "the security of your password and people", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00528-00164463-00164609": "should really care about using different", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00529-00164610-00165010": "passwords on different web pages okay", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00530-00165011-00165346": "that's it for the presentation", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00531-00165347-00165976": "[Applause]", "ORbCz4b3Qb0-00532-00165977-00166183": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OS1rO2ENJB8", "text": {"OS1rO2ENJB8-00000-00000020-00000286": "[Music]", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00001-00000287-00000443": "foreign", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00002-00000444-00000985": "[Music]", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00003-00000986-00001216": "angle Cube news here from Mobile World", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00004-00001217-00001397": "Congress this is a Mobile World Congress", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00005-00001398-00001648": "news update Dell in the news here", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00006-00001650-00001817": "partners with leading infrastructure", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00007-00001818-00002039": "companies Dell Technologies really", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00008-00002039-00002291": "setting up an ecosystem here Dell with", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00009-00002292-00002423": "leading Telecom and infrastructure", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00010-00002424-00002591": "players accelerating the network", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00011-00002592-00002860": "adoption announcing that is launching", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00012-00002861-00003095": "the Dell's open Telecom ecosystem", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00013-00003096-00003269": "Community a community of multiple", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00014-00003270-00003509": "Telecom partners and Communications", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00015-00003510-00003736": "service providers aimed at becoming a", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00016-00003738-00003953": "unifying force in the Telecom industry", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00017-00003954-00004217": "this announcement comes just days after", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00018-00004218-00004429": "Dell introduced a host of new hardware", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00019-00004430-00004606": "platforms designed to help the", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00020-00004607-00004799": "teleconference build Cloud native open", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00021-00004800-00005002": "radio network access also called ran", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00022-00005003-00005231": "architectures using proprietary and sub", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00023-00005232-00005483": "components for various suppliers Dell's", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00024-00005484-00005686": "open Telecom ecosystem Community has", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00025-00005687-00005872": "already partnered with Nokia Qualcomm", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00026-00005873-00006059": "amdocs and Juniper Networks to create", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00027-00006060-00006322": "new offerings aimed at accelerating open", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00028-00006323-00006520": "ran price performance for Communication", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00029-00006522-00006742": "service providers this includes creating", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00030-00006743-00006964": "a new virtual ran offering using Telecom", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00031-00006965-00007187": "ecosystem labs and as a center for", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00032-00007188-00007427": "testing and validation building Next", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00033-00007428-00007745": "Generation 5G virtualized distributed", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00034-00007745-00008003": "units and deploy an automated validated", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00035-00008004-00008296": "5G sa network with various Partners", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00036-00008297-00008560": "across the ecosystem Dell's promising", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00037-00008561-00008728": "that this is just the beginning of the", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00038-00008729-00008885": "collaboration with the Telecom industry", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00039-00008886-00009178": "as it seeks to accelerate the adoption", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00040-00009179-00009449": "of 5G networking Technologies and solve", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00041-00009450-00009713": "key industry challenges more actions on", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00042-00009714-00009887": "the ground go to thecube.net the cube is", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00043-00009888-00010060": "broadcasting live for four days Dave", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00044-00010061-00010295": "vellante Lisa Martin I'm in the studios", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00045-00010296-00010481": "in Palo Alto bringing you the news a lot", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00046-00010482-00010619": "of action happening of course go to", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00047-00010620-00010828": "siliconangle.com to catch all the", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00048-00010829-00010973": "breaking news we have a special report", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00049-00010974-00011188": "we already got 10 plus stories already", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00050-00011189-00011351": "flowing probably have another 10 today", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00051-00011352-00011723": "day two tomorrow as mwc continues to", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00052-00011724-00011951": "power more news coverage for the edge", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00053-00011952-00012307": "and Cloud native Technologies", "OS1rO2ENJB8-00054-00012308-00013159": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OS4PeNh6o30", "text": {"OS4PeNh6o30-00000-00000664-00004167": "[Music]", "OS4PeNh6o30-00001-00004168-00004359": "it is really motivating to work at a", "OS4PeNh6o30-00002-00004360-00004495": "place where you feel that you're making", "OS4PeNh6o30-00003-00004496-00004615": "a difference", "OS4PeNh6o30-00004-00004616-00004822": "as part of electrification we strive for", "OS4PeNh6o30-00005-00004823-00005291": "a safe smart and sustainable world", "OS4PeNh6o30-00006-00005292-00005406": "[Music]", "OS4PeNh6o30-00007-00005407-00005615": "i would say that people are our greatest", "OS4PeNh6o30-00008-00005616-00005751": "asset", "OS4PeNh6o30-00009-00005752-00005975": "it's with the great work engagement and", "OS4PeNh6o30-00010-00005976-00006199": "collaboration from our people that plays", "OS4PeNh6o30-00011-00006200-00006414": "a key role for our success now and in", "OS4PeNh6o30-00012-00006415-00006567": "the future we are part of", "OS4PeNh6o30-00013-00006568-00006767": "electrification smart power and we are", "OS4PeNh6o30-00014-00006768-00007006": "producing contactors soft starters and", "OS4PeNh6o30-00015-00007008-00007255": "pilot devices and are responsible for", "OS4PeNh6o30-00016-00007256-00007455": "the value chain for safety products and", "OS4PeNh6o30-00017-00007456-00008095": "arcguard system", "OS4PeNh6o30-00018-00008095-00008374": "i really like working with abb i like", "OS4PeNh6o30-00019-00008375-00008535": "meeting new people and that's one of the", "OS4PeNh6o30-00020-00008536-00008742": "reasons why i moved here in sweden the", "OS4PeNh6o30-00021-00008743-00008991": "safety criteria over here is", "OS4PeNh6o30-00022-00008992-00009223": "is very high so", "OS4PeNh6o30-00023-00009224-00009471": "it is also important for people who work", "OS4PeNh6o30-00024-00009472-00009663": "over here to feel safe and this is what", "OS4PeNh6o30-00025-00009664-00009848": "abb gives you", "OS4PeNh6o30-00026-00009849-00010142": "[Music]", "OS4PeNh6o30-00027-00010143-00010423": "we are certified according to iso 5001", "OS4PeNh6o30-00028-00010424-00010710": "since 2018 and we are working to become", "OS4PeNh6o30-00029-00010711-00011006": "carbon dioxide neutral by 2030.", "OS4PeNh6o30-00030-00011007-00011191": "we work on sustainability aspects", "OS4PeNh6o30-00031-00011192-00011399": "throughout the unit from life cycle", "OS4PeNh6o30-00032-00011400-00011591": "analysis and product development to", "OS4PeNh6o30-00033-00011592-00011814": "sorting waste in the workshop or office", "OS4PeNh6o30-00034-00011815-00011974": "and installing ev chargers in the", "OS4PeNh6o30-00035-00011975-00012243": "parking lot for our employees", "OS4PeNh6o30-00036-00012244-00012542": "[Music]", "OS4PeNh6o30-00037-00012543-00012815": "our success is built on teamwork", "OS4PeNh6o30-00038-00012816-00013030": "respectful environment and empowerment", "OS4PeNh6o30-00039-00013031-00013191": "of people", "OS4PeNh6o30-00040-00013191-00013366": "if we want our product to be relevant", "OS4PeNh6o30-00041-00013368-00013494": "for the future", "OS4PeNh6o30-00042-00013495-00013719": "we believe we need a culture where", "OS4PeNh6o30-00043-00013719-00013943": "people are the center of the why and the", "OS4PeNh6o30-00044-00013944-00014151": "how we do things", "OS4PeNh6o30-00045-00014152-00014311": "that's one of the things that gives us", "OS4PeNh6o30-00046-00014312-00014538": "an edge", "OS4PeNh6o30-00047-00014540-00015271": "[Music]", "OS4PeNh6o30-00048-00015272-00015479": "we do set up targets we follow up and", "OS4PeNh6o30-00049-00015480-00015679": "create a drive in the pursuit of an", "OS4PeNh6o30-00050-00015680-00016007": "equal and diverse workplace", "OS4PeNh6o30-00051-00016008-00016271": "we are convinced that a more even gender", "OS4PeNh6o30-00052-00016272-00016399": "distribution", "OS4PeNh6o30-00053-00016400-00016591": "leads to a better working environment", "OS4PeNh6o30-00054-00016592-00016891": "greater well-being and productivity", "OS4PeNh6o30-00055-00016892-00019664": "[Music]", "OS4PeNh6o30-00056-00019665-00021999": "[Music]", "OS4PeNh6o30-00057-00022000-00022208": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OSm8203OBBc", "text": {"OSm8203OBBc-00000-00000005-00001156": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00001-00001157-00002807": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00002-00002808-00003063": "my second menace of longest large error", "OSm8203OBBc-00003-00003064-00003286": "the super duper extremely longest and", "OSm8203OBBc-00004-00003288-00003535": "very super massively scariest barb error", "OSm8203OBBc-00005-00003536-00003815": "in the solar system part of one fixed", "OSm8203OBBc-00006-00003815-00007945": "version", "OSm8203OBBc-00007-00007945-00008806": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00008-00008807-00008999": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00009-00009000-00009246": "we interrupt your windows xp session to", "OSm8203OBBc-00010-00009247-00009453": "bring you up hey", "OSm8203OBBc-00011-00009454-00009951": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00012-00009952-00010263": "barney was killed by amy ira storm amy", "OSm8203OBBc-00013-00010264-00010527": "iris storm put a bomb in barney's lair", "OSm8203OBBc-00014-00010528-00010767": "it will explode in one millennium you", "OSm8203OBBc-00015-00010768-00011110": "get 1 500 chances and that's all you get", "OSm8203OBBc-00016-00011111-00011359": "i want to remind you please do not turn", "OSm8203OBBc-00017-00011360-00011703": "off your windows xp computer i repeat", "OSm8203OBBc-00018-00011704-00011927": "please do not turn off your windows xp", "OSm8203OBBc-00019-00011928-00012255": "computer warning because if you do then", "OSm8203OBBc-00020-00012256-00012423": "barney will get mad at you and you will", "OSm8203OBBc-00021-00012424-00012559": "lose a chance", "OSm8203OBBc-00022-00012560-00012863": "second repeat if you do then barney will", "OSm8203OBBc-00023-00012863-00013015": "get mad at you and you will lose a", "OSm8203OBBc-00024-00013016-00013351": "chance be careful and most importantly", "OSm8203OBBc-00025-00013352-00013671": "if you waste all of your 1500 chances", "OSm8203OBBc-00026-00013672-00013847": "then you will not like it", "OSm8203OBBc-00027-00013847-00014158": "last repeat if you waste all of your", "OSm8203OBBc-00028-00014159-00014455": "500 chances then you will not like it", "OSm8203OBBc-00029-00014456-00014703": "good luck and please listen to barney", "OSm8203OBBc-00030-00014704-00014935": "about not to turn off your computer", "OSm8203OBBc-00031-00014936-00015263": "so this is tom over and out", "OSm8203OBBc-00032-00015263-00015519": "remember i'm watching you and don't you", "OSm8203OBBc-00033-00015519-00015679": "even think about turning off your", "OSm8203OBBc-00034-00015680-00015886": "windows xp computer", "OSm8203OBBc-00035-00015887-00016175": "you know what barney screw you hard i", "OSm8203OBBc-00036-00016176-00016455": "can do whatever i want because of this", "OSm8203OBBc-00037-00016456-00016711": "i'm turning off my windows xp computer", "OSm8203OBBc-00038-00016712-00017464": "whenever you like it or not", "OSm8203OBBc-00039-00017465-00017927": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00040-00017928-00018239": "hey i see you turned off your windows xp", "OSm8203OBBc-00041-00018240-00018511": "computer please do not do it again", "OSm8203OBBc-00042-00018512-00018735": "because if you do it two more times then", "OSm8203OBBc-00043-00018736-00019025": "the timer will reduce to 90 centuries", "OSm8203OBBc-00044-00019026-00020007": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00045-00020008-00020263": "okay zachter you turned it off for the", "OSm8203OBBc-00046-00020264-00020550": "second time now as you can remember that", "OSm8203OBBc-00047-00020551-00020750": "if you turn off your computer one more", "OSm8203OBBc-00048-00020751-00020991": "time then the timer will reduce to 90", "OSm8203OBBc-00049-00020992-00021121": "centuries", "OSm8203OBBc-00050-00021122-00022103": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00051-00022104-00022414": "really third time already now the timer", "OSm8203OBBc-00052-00022415-00022686": "has been reduced to nine centuries so", "OSm8203OBBc-00053-00022687-00022919": "here's the deal every three times you", "OSm8203OBBc-00054-00022920-00023135": "turn off your computer then the timer", "OSm8203OBBc-00055-00023136-00023599": "will reduce also you only have 170 497", "OSm8203OBBc-00056-00023600-00023757": "chances left", "OSm8203OBBc-00057-00023758-00024735": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00058-00024736-00024919": "did the narrator said you can turn off", "OSm8203OBBc-00059-00024920-00025311": "your windows xp computer am i right no", "OSm8203OBBc-00060-00025312-00025542": "and you want to know what your chances", "OSm8203OBBc-00061-00025543-00025819": "are now reduced to 14.96", "OSm8203OBBc-00062-00025820-00026807": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00063-00026808-00027055": "okay seriously you have turned your", "OSm8203OBBc-00064-00027056-00027295": "computer off for the fifth time already", "OSm8203OBBc-00065-00027295-00027487": "please be careful when turning off your", "OSm8203OBBc-00066-00027488-00027718": "computer you will get me mad after you", "OSm8203OBBc-00067-00027719-00028046": "waste all of your chances so please stop", "OSm8203OBBc-00068-00028047-00028238": "turning off your computer", "OSm8203OBBc-00069-00028239-00029231": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00070-00029232-00029462": "now the timer has been reduced to yet", "OSm8203OBBc-00071-00029463-00029711": "you guessed it eight centuries now", "OSm8203OBBc-00072-00029712-00029927": "please stop turning off your computer", "OSm8203OBBc-00073-00029927-00030143": "continuously and that way you can have", "OSm8203OBBc-00074-00030144-00030350": "your computer back forever", "OSm8203OBBc-00075-00030351-00031343": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00076-00031344-00031527": "well it appears that you turned your", "OSm8203OBBc-00077-00031527-00031783": "computer off seven times now now i", "OSm8203OBBc-00078-00031783-00031967": "highly recommend you to start turning", "OSm8203OBBc-00079-00031968-00032167": "off your computer so that way you get", "OSm8203OBBc-00080-00032168-00032407": "your computer back this is trend times", "OSm8203OBBc-00081-00032408-00032631": "important than watching tv listening to", "OSm8203OBBc-00082-00032632-00032902": "music or playing video games", "OSm8203OBBc-00083-00032903-00033151": "you know what barney i never had a", "OSm8203OBBc-00084-00033152-00033359": "chance to introduce myself", "OSm8203OBBc-00085-00033360-00033607": "let me tell you everything about myself", "OSm8203OBBc-00086-00033608-00033879": "my name is zachter it's been a long time", "OSm8203OBBc-00087-00033880-00034151": "since i never introduced myself to you", "OSm8203OBBc-00088-00034152-00034383": "so you are telling me not to turn off my", "OSm8203OBBc-00089-00034384-00034607": "computer right barney", "OSm8203OBBc-00090-00034608-00034887": "yeah zachter you are right that's the", "OSm8203OBBc-00091-00034888-00035079": "number one important rule you need to", "OSm8203OBBc-00092-00035080-00035262": "follow and listen to me", "OSm8203OBBc-00093-00035263-00035502": "well you know what barney i will still", "OSm8203OBBc-00094-00035503-00035702": "turn off my computer no matter what you", "OSm8203OBBc-00095-00035703-00035974": "say to me well i guess you are not", "OSm8203OBBc-00096-00035975-00036337": "listening to me and following my rules", "OSm8203OBBc-00097-00036338-00036807": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00098-00036808-00037039": "you know what if you turn it off two", "OSm8203OBBc-00099-00037040-00037246": "more times then i will change the", "OSm8203OBBc-00100-00037247-00037471": "background to lightest pink but if you", "OSm8203OBBc-00101-00037472-00037702": "do it again then the timer will reduce", "OSm8203OBBc-00102-00037703-00037884": "to seven centuries", "OSm8203OBBc-00103-00037885-00038871": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00104-00038872-00039062": "now if you turn off your computer one", "OSm8203OBBc-00105-00039063-00039246": "more time then i will change the", "OSm8203OBBc-00106-00039247-00039495": "background to lightest pink thus the", "OSm8203OBBc-00107-00039496-00039671": "timer has been reduced to seven", "OSm8203OBBc-00108-00039672-00039783": "centuries", "OSm8203OBBc-00109-00039784-00040007": "you know what barney i'm still not", "OSm8203OBBc-00110-00040008-00040199": "listening to you i'll turn off my", "OSm8203OBBc-00111-00040200-00041450": "computer no matter what", "OSm8203OBBc-00112-00041451-00043383": "[Music]", "OSm8203OBBc-00113-00043384-00043591": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OSyo-DbR-Z4", "text": {"OSyo-DbR-Z4-00000-00000013-00006163": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00001-00006164-00007123": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00002-00007125-00010790": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00003-00010791-00011441": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00004-00011442-00012158": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00005-00012159-00017693": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00006-00017694-00018225": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00007-00018226-00019225": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00008-00019226-00020430": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00009-00020431-00020574": "so", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00010-00020575-00028318": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00011-00028319-00030155": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00012-00030156-00031142": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00013-00031143-00031686": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00014-00031687-00034297": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00015-00034298-00035862": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00016-00035863-00038711": "[Music]", "OSyo-DbR-Z4-00017-00038712-00038919": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OTieW3lgHj8", "text": {"OTieW3lgHj8-00000-00000112-00000623": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00001-00000624-00000882": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00002-00000883-00001810": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00003-00001811-00003464": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00004-00003465-00004475": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00005-00004476-00004879": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00006-00004880-00005344": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00007-00005345-00006483": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00008-00006484-00007487": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00009-00007488-00007704": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00010-00007705-00008478": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00011-00008479-00009106": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00012-00009107-00010438": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00013-00010439-00010653": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00014-00010654-00012671": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00015-00012672-00013111": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00016-00013112-00013352": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00017-00013353-00014615": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00018-00014616-00018207": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00019-00018208-00018503": "foreign", "OTieW3lgHj8-00020-00018504-00024924": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00021-00024925-00025606": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00022-00025607-00027046": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00023-00027047-00027157": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00024-00027158-00029413": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00025-00029414-00030962": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00026-00030963-00031374": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00027-00031375-00031514": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00028-00031514-00033671": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00029-00033672-00033809": "so", "OTieW3lgHj8-00030-00033810-00034866": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00031-00034867-00035567": "[Music]", "OTieW3lgHj8-00032-00035568-00035775": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OTo6Nb7uoyk", "text": {"OTo6Nb7uoyk-00000-00000002-00001083": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00001-00001084-00002748": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00002-00002749-00004806": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00003-00004807-00008483": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00004-00008484-00008604": "hey", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00005-00008605-00011283": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00006-00011284-00011446": "so", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00007-00011447-00011566": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00008-00011567-00014724": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00009-00014725-00016313": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00010-00016313-00018280": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00011-00018281-00018799": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00012-00018800-00020917": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00013-00020918-00021083": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00014-00021084-00021448": "oh", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00015-00021449-00024070": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00016-00024071-00025635": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00017-00025636-00026683": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00018-00026683-00027535": "oh", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00019-00027536-00029255": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00020-00029256-00030351": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00021-00030352-00043483": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00022-00043484-00043649": "oh", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00023-00043650-00051383": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00024-00051384-00056021": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00025-00056022-00057965": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00026-00057966-00058516": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00027-00058516-00058882": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00028-00058883-00059054": "so", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00029-00059055-00061566": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00030-00061567-00062185": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00031-00062186-00063527": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00032-00063528-00064482": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00033-00064483-00064790": "so", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00034-00064791-00065638": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00035-00065639-00066593": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00036-00066594-00068682": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00037-00068683-00069004": "so", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00038-00069005-00069858": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00039-00069859-00070625": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00040-00070626-00071101": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00041-00071102-00071285": "[Laughter]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00042-00071286-00072304": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00043-00072305-00072419": "[Laughter]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00044-00072420-00072882": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00045-00072883-00073936": "so", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00046-00073937-00075247": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00047-00075248-00075876": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00048-00075877-00077916": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00049-00077917-00079287": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00050-00079288-00079490": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00051-00079491-00081245": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00052-00081246-00081745": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00053-00081746-00082854": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00054-00082855-00083204": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00055-00083205-00083308": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00056-00083309-00084184": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00057-00084185-00084390": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00058-00084391-00086143": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00059-00086144-00086282": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00060-00086283-00088102": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00061-00088103-00088272": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00062-00088273-00088981": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00063-00088982-00090061": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00064-00090062-00090507": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00065-00090508-00091101": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00066-00091102-00092021": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00067-00092022-00092518": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00068-00092519-00093979": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00069-00093980-00094069": "[Applause]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00070-00094070-00094406": "[Music]", "OTo6Nb7uoyk-00071-00094407-00094616": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OTKO6jUqzSc", "text": {"OTKO6jUqzSc-00000-00000216-00000425": "welcome to our panel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00001-00000426-00000529": "[Music]", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00002-00000530-00000833": "that we will have today to accompany the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00003-00000834-00001075": "Purdue engineering", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00004-00001076-00001385": "distinguished lecture series", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00005-00001386-00001695": "I'll simply introduce our moderator for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00006-00001696-00001798": "our panel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00007-00001800-00002121": "dr. bill Clark who is alumnus of our", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00008-00002122-00002463": "school of chemical engineering also MD", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00009-00002464-00002682": "from Indiana University Medical School", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00010-00002683-00003078": "and has spent his career in medicine and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00011-00003079-00003314": "and nephrology and medical devices", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00012-00003315-00003567": "including a distinguished career at -", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00013-00003568-00003846": "medical device companies so without", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00014-00003847-00004164": "further ado let me hand the floor to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00015-00004165-00004447": "Bill to introduce the panel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00016-00004448-00004785": "thank you very much dr. Kim and welcome", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00017-00004786-00004986": "everyone to the panel discussion after", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00018-00004987-00005310": "such a stellar lecture by dr. Ann Seth", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00019-00005311-00005645": "will focus the the topic now to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00020-00005646-00005997": "precision medicine and how biomaterial", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00021-00005998-00006276": "development kind of fix fits into that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00022-00006277-00006642": "context the agenda is shown here very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00023-00006643-00007059": "briefly I will give a very short", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00024-00007059-00007298": "overview of precision medicine what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00025-00007300-00007662": "exactly it is and and how biomaterials", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00026-00007663-00008019": "play into that will have an initial", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00027-00008020-00008292": "introduction of the panel members and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00028-00008293-00008481": "then more formal introductions before", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00029-00008482-00008805": "each of their short presentations and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00030-00008806-00009177": "then finally we'll have a period of at", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00031-00009178-00009513": "least 30 minutes hopefully of questions", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00032-00009514-00009842": "and answers in general discussion and by", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00033-00009843-00010107": "the way we we do have an absolutely hard", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00034-00010108-00010478": "stop at 5:15 because dr. ANSYS needs to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00035-00010479-00010710": "head back to Indianapolis to the airport", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00036-00010711-00011006": "so we will have to advise", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00037-00011007-00011238": "so this again is just the brief", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00038-00011239-00011658": "introduction dr. Anza after the the very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00039-00011659-00011967": "nice introduction by the Dean I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00040-00011968-00012237": "you you know Pro qualifications and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00041-00012238-00012444": "again after such a stellar lecture I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00042-00012445-00012735": "think we all have a keen appreciation of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00043-00012736-00012986": "how accomplished her academic career has", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00044-00012987-00013257": "been and our other panelists first of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00045-00013258-00013611": "all dr. Liu and dr. Solorio will provide", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00046-00013612-00014091": "faculty research lab perspectives on the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00047-00014093-00014371": "role precision medicine in terms of what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00048-00014372-00014647": "they do dr. Brightman will provide a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00049-00014647-00014919": "bioethics perspective and finally dr.", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00050-00014921-00015181": "Hiles will will provide an industry", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00051-00015182-00015261": "perspective", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00052-00015262-00015459": "so first of all", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00053-00015460-00015688": "personalized or precision medicine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00054-00015688-00016111": "defined it's there's no no absolutely", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00055-00016112-00016447": "agreed-upon definition but one take is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00056-00016448-00016590": "the the combination", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00057-00016591-00016900": "of clinical practice at least how it's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00058-00016901-00017161": "established by existing clinical data", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00059-00017162-00017404": "that have been generated from clinical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00060-00017405-00017581": "trials involving large number of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00061-00017582-00017842": "patients and taking that information in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00062-00017843-00018154": "combination with newer molecular bait", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00063-00018155-00018472": "based data combining that all together", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00064-00018473-00018618": "and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00065-00018619-00018901": "providing more specified in specific", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00066-00018902-00019303": "therapies to patients this approach has", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00067-00019304-00019474": "been already widely used in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00068-00019475-00019792": "pharmaceutical industry and as you can", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00069-00019793-00020113": "see there there's a sense that the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00070-00020114-00020392": "pharmaceutical industry will even adopt", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00071-00020393-00020694": "this approach more broadly in the future", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00072-00020695-00020947": "the components of precision medicine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00073-00020948-00021364": "essentially touch most aspects of the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00074-00021365-00021634": "clinical care of patients everything for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00075-00021635-00021792": "example", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00076-00021793-00022171": "as a just one example risk assessment in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00077-00022172-00022534": "a patient who for instance has a family", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00078-00022535-00022824": "history of some type of genetic disorder", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00079-00022825-00023080": "broadening the scale a little bit it can", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00080-00023081-00023382": "be applied to on a larger population", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00081-00023383-00023713": "detection of a certain disease in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00082-00023714-00024000": "high-risk population and then finally", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00083-00024001-00024307": "firming up the diagnosis in a specific", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00084-00024308-00024553": "patient providing a treatment plan and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00085-00024554-00024666": "then importantly", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00086-00024667-00024979": "ensuring and follow-up that a certain", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00087-00024980-00025171": "outcome has been achieved and that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00088-00025172-00025647": "outcome is a durable and and robust one", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00089-00025648-00025928": "so there was an absolutely fascinating", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00090-00025929-00026283": "position paper that was written by dr.", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00091-00026285-00026508": "ancef and colleagues so it's very timely", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00092-00026510-00026721": "that we're discussing this issue and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00093-00026722-00026933": "that she's involved in our panel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00094-00026934-00027180": "discussion so the general idea here is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00095-00027181-00027452": "again is how do we take whether it's a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00096-00027453-00027767": "drug or medical device or a biomaterial", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00097-00027768-00028130": "that has been clinically qualified in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00098-00028131-00028404": "sometimes a clinical trial that involves", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00099-00028405-00028730": "hundreds or even thousands of patients", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00100-00028731-00028949": "that that obviously have significant", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00101-00028950-00029223": "biologic variability and heterogeneity", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00102-00029224-00029486": "how do you take that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00103-00029487-00029821": "particular biomaterial your device and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00104-00029822-00030167": "customize it so that it's actually very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00105-00030168-00030417": "appropriate and specific in a given", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00106-00030418-00030717": "patient so that's the challenge that dr.", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00107-00030718-00030960": "ancef and colleagues tried to address in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00108-00030961-00031185": "this paper and essentially it was kind", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00109-00031186-00031304": "of a call to action", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00110-00031305-00031602": "to to engineers to start thinking about", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00111-00031602-00031889": "how precision medical medicine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00112-00031890-00032133": "principles should be applied in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00113-00032133-00032393": "further development of biomaterials so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00114-00032394-00032627": "the previous figure and the next two", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00115-00032628-00032982": "figures are drawn directly from from the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00116-00032983-00033318": "paper these are just four examples of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00117-00033319-00033729": "how this principle of applying precision", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00118-00033730-00034001": "medicine ideas to development of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00119-00034002-00034295": "biomaterials may play out first of all", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00120-00034296-00034532": "material chemistry and by the way going", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00121-00034533-00034761": "from left to right is going from more", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00122-00034762-00035096": "general to more customized so the on the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00123-00035097-00035387": "the approach on the left for material", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00124-00035388-00035645": "chemistry is just a a relatively", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00125-00035646-00035961": "nonspecific diffusion of a drug out of a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00126-00035962-00036215": "some type of polymer matrix all the way", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00127-00036216-00036498": "to the to the right the most customized", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00128-00036499-00036893": "approach would be a system that reacts", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00129-00036894-00037161": "to a space of patient specific enzyme", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00130-00037162-00037445": "another example in terms of fabrication", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00131-00037446-00037764": "would be a more customized approach", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00132-00037765-00038024": "would be a 3d printed for instance organ", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00133-00038025-00038289": "and then even further customized would", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00134-00038290-00038570": "be allowing for that organ to kind of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00135-00038571-00039020": "grow as the patient evolves in in his or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00136-00039021-00039317": "her clinical disorder thirdly", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00137-00039318-00039638": "bioactive components in the transplant", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00138-00039639-00039924": "world and allogeneic transplant even", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00139-00039925-00040112": "though it may be so to speak well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00140-00040113-00040289": "matched there are still some", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00141-00040290-00040611": "difficulties that may result once the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00142-00040612-00040860": "once the transplant is done autologous", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00143-00040861-00041137": "transplant the patient's own cells", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00144-00041138-00041393": "would would be an improvement and then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00145-00041394-00041679": "even further and more customized would", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00146-00041680-00041945": "be an approach in which the cells that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00147-00041946-00042180": "are being transplanted actually would be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00148-00042181-00042461": "adapted so that they would behave in a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00149-00042462-00042665": "certain way in the milieu in which", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00150-00042666-00043029": "they're going to live in in the in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00151-00043030-00043245": "newly transplanted environment and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00152-00043246-00043667": "finally we all have heard much about big", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00153-00043668-00044024": "data and the application of that to to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00154-00044025-00044232": "medicine and certainly precision", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00155-00044233-00044483": "medicine plays a role there it's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00156-00044484-00044726": "anticipated to do so in the future and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00157-00044727-00044967": "again these are examples of going from", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00158-00044968-00045257": "fairly general on the left to much more", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00159-00045258-00045449": "specific and customized on the right", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00160-00045450-00045801": "where an in situ approach of some type", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00161-00045802-00046058": "of data tracking system could provide", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00162-00046059-00046180": "real-time", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00163-00046181-00046493": "evidence and data in the progression of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00164-00046494-00046762": "a disease or maybe the monitoring of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00165-00046763-00047021": "some type of intervention in terms of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00166-00047022-00047249": "the patient's response so with that very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00167-00047250-00047586": "brief overview as I mentioned we'll", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00168-00047587-00047870": "we'll have two faculty members who are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00169-00047871-00048107": "laboratory researchers who will provide", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00170-00048108-00048429": "their perspectives on on how precision", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00171-00048430-00048780": "medicine may apply to what they do the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00172-00048781-00048977": "first laboratory researcher is a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00173-00048978-00049176": "colleague of mine from chemical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00174-00049177-00049376": "engineering dr. Julie Liu is an", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00175-00049377-00049568": "associate professor of chemical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00176-00049569-00049751": "engineering and also biomedical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00177-00049752-00049986": "engineering by courtesy her laboratory", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00178-00049987-00050274": "is focused on biomaterials particularly", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00179-00050275-00050526": "as they apply to musculoskeletal", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00180-00050527-00050912": "disorders and surgical applications so I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00181-00050913-00051670": "will hand it over to dr. Lu", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00182-00051671-00051944": "I really just wanted to show you two", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00183-00051945-00052179": "eight two examples from my laboratory on", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00184-00052179-00052358": "some problems that we're working on and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00185-00052359-00052556": "how the personalized aspect could be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00186-00052557-00052899": "applied to this to these two projects so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00187-00052900-00053166": "the first is Ashley work my Charlie Lynn", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00188-00053166-00053334": "who's in the audience and was defending", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00189-00053335-00053457": "next week", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00190-00053458-00053607": "he's been working on designing these", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00191-00053608-00053879": "redox responsive hydrogels and the ideas", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00192-00053880-00054075": "this is actually a very similar polymer", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00193-00054076-00054275": "to what Christy talked about so it's a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00194-00054276-00054521": "PEG polymer these have the file groups", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00195-00054522-00054791": "and what he had done is he wanted to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00196-00054792-00054972": "make a one-pot reaction where you can", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00197-00054973-00055154": "have both", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00198-00055154-00055416": "reducible bonds shown in gold and then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00199-00055416-00055725": "the non-reducible bonds shown in red the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00200-00055726-00056054": "idea was often if you're using the style", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00201-00056055-00056276": "chemistry if you get increased", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00202-00056277-00056547": "mechanical properties you can't really", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00203-00056548-00056796": "decouple that from how they degrade and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00204-00056797-00057016": "so he wanted to combine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00205-00057017-00057429": "both the non so basically the permanent", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00206-00057429-00057684": "and the temporary bonds and he was able", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00207-00057685-00058016": "to get gels that had the same stiffness", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00208-00058017-00058226": "but you could tune the degradation rate", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00209-00058227-00058404": "based on how many of the reducible bonds", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00210-00058404-00058655": "you have and the gels are degrading in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00211-00058657-00058938": "response to reducing conditions so kind", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00212-00058939-00059175": "of thinking about how this could be then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00213-00059176-00059407": "applied there's some tissue engineering", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00214-00059408-00059600": "examples but the one I have here is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00215-00059601-00059841": "maybe a little bit more related to drug", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00216-00059841-00060023": "delivery on the Left", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00217-00060024-00060246": "stiffness might be important in drug", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00218-00060247-00060462": "delivery for thinking about having force", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00219-00060463-00060716": "actually induce the release of your", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00220-00060717-00060963": "drugs so if you have something very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00221-00060964-00061156": "stiff it might", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00222-00061157-00061551": "not compress as much for the deformation", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00223-00061552-00061763": "which would then release the drug or in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00224-00061764-00061949": "the converse when you're stretching it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00225-00061950-00062294": "depending on how stiff it is you might", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00226-00062295-00062460": "have a different release in terms of the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00227-00062461-00062616": "molecules are embedded inside of your", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00228-00062616-00062726": "hydrogel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00229-00062727-00062991": "on the flipside so if you're decoupling", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00230-00062991-00063157": "the stiffness and the degradation", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00231-00063158-00063419": "since these are redox responsive I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00232-00063420-00063678": "it's been well known that tumor cells", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00233-00063679-00063984": "themselves have a higher intracellular", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00234-00063985-00064166": "lever of glutathione so a reducing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00235-00064167-00064428": "condition but some recent work also has", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00236-00064429-00064607": "shown that the extracellular matrix", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00237-00064608-00064941": "around some of those cells seem to be in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00238-00064941-00065138": "a more reducing condition if they're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00239-00065139-00065361": "going to be metastatic and so I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00240-00065362-00065634": "this could be an example of having some", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00241-00065635-00066015": "sort of Depot that could basically based", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00242-00066016-00066318": "on how reducing the environment your", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00243-00066319-00066581": "tumor is right that's correlated with", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00244-00066582-00066779": "metastasis", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00245-00066780-00066959": "would then deliver some sort of molecule", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00246-00066960-00067315": "or a drug so that's my first example", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00247-00067316-00067651": "um the second one kind of ties into this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00248-00067652-00067922": "cartilage engineering so my student", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00249-00067923-00068084": "Clair Kilmer who's sitting in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00250-00068085-00068215": "audience as well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00251-00068216-00068494": "she's been working a lot on developing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00252-00068495-00068993": "protein based scaffolds to improve the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00253-00068994-00069242": "repair of cartilage that has degenerated", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00254-00069243-00069593": "due to osteoarthritis we've worked on", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00255-00069594-00069905": "these gels in cell culture so in an", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00256-00069906-00070097": "incubator but and looked at how cells", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00257-00070098-00070267": "respond but she's also", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00258-00070268-00070586": "done an animal study where she basically", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00259-00070587-00070805": "harvested the bone marrow for individual", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00260-00070806-00071044": "rabbits so the model here would be the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00261-00071045-00071204": "rabbits the patient's so if you were the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00262-00071205-00071324": "patient you would harvest the bone", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00263-00071325-00071467": "marrow their", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00264-00071468-00071744": "culture the cells and then expanded them", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00265-00071745-00072007": "and then embedded them inside of this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00266-00072008-00072184": "gel that was then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00267-00072185-00072497": "placed into the defect of the knees that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00268-00072498-00072728": "we made into these rabbits and I'm just", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00269-00072729-00072923": "showing some histological sections I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00270-00072924-00073126": "wasn't expecting most people to be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00271-00073127-00073379": "familiar with histology but the idea", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00272-00073380-00073559": "here is that the first column it says", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00273-00073560-00073957": "collagen call 1/2 that's our kind of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00274-00073958-00074257": "improved hydrogel and when you put it in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00275-00074258-00074435": "the defect the defect is marked by the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00276-00074436-00074753": "arrowheads the proteoglycans which is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00277-00074754-00074984": "indicative of cartilage matrix shown in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00278-00074985-00075288": "pink you see a lot more of that forming", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00279-00075289-00075593": "compared to a control just collagen one", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00280-00075594-00075887": "which is often used or the empty defect", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00281-00075888-00076022": "where you don't fill it just to see what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00282-00076023-00076385": "would happen what does the animal do and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00283-00076386-00076507": "so kind of thinking about the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00284-00076508-00076756": "personalized aspects of this certainly", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00285-00076757-00077006": "we're thinking right now of using a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00286-00077007-00077192": "target cell so cells that you would", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00287-00077193-00077492": "gather from yourself the patient and in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00288-00077493-00077696": "this case we actually preformed the gel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00289-00077697-00077825": "but I think one of the things we're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00290-00077826-00078026": "interested in going towards is maybe", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00291-00078027-00078326": "thinking about if you have this defect", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00292-00078327-00078518": "do you want to do bio printing for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00293-00078519-00078875": "cartilage or maybe it's simple enough to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00294-00078876-00079079": "just inject it but it'll kind of conform", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00295-00079080-00079231": "to that patient defect so there's a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00296-00079232-00079393": "little bit of personalization rather", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00297-00079394-00079654": "than just buying some material that's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00298-00079655-00079922": "prefabricated maybe the surgeon chops it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00299-00079923-00080129": "a little bit but here it's just trying", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00300-00080130-00080254": "to actually", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00301-00080255-00080551": "conform to the defect size those are my", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00302-00080552-00080881": "two examples", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00303-00080882-00081146": "Thank You dr. Liu and I should mention", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00304-00081147-00081329": "at this point also that although we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00305-00081330-00081668": "didn't want to overly burden dr. Anthony", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00306-00081669-00081899": "her to prepare another presentation for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00307-00081900-00082130": "the panel of course we'll welcome any", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00308-00082131-00082519": "comments or input that she has along the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00309-00082520-00082800": "way for sure so the the next", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00310-00082801-00083113": "panelist to speak is dr. luis laurio", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00311-00083114-00083419": "from the Weldon school by biomedical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00312-00083420-00083660": "engineering assistant professor he his", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00313-00083661-00083921": "laboratory is very focused on cancer", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00314-00083922-00084206": "modalities not only understand under", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00315-00084207-00084319": "standing of the underlying", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00316-00084320-00084631": "pathophysiology but also developing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00317-00084632-00084951": "platforms for instance that screen for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00318-00084952-00085324": "effective therapies so doctors Laurie oh", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00319-00085325-00085586": "thank you for having me so what I'll", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00320-00085587-00085819": "talk to you about today is this idea of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00321-00085820-00086099": "cancer metastasis and so when we think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00322-00086100-00086234": "of cancer I think we're all pretty", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00323-00086235-00086423": "well-versed with this idea that it's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00324-00086424-00086587": "it's pretty terrible disease and it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00325-00086588-00086826": "affects lots of people very tragically", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00326-00086827-00087053": "what a lot of people aren't aware of is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00327-00087054-00087278": "it's not actually the the primary tumor", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00328-00087279-00087509": "that tends to be the cause of patient", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00329-00087510-00087653": "mortality but it's actually the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00330-00087654-00087929": "metastasis that causes that and so what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00331-00087930-00088091": "my lab really focused on is kind of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00332-00088092-00088300": "trying to understand these steps in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00333-00088301-00088598": "metastatic cascade and where we can use", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00334-00088599-00088853": "engineering technologies to kind of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00335-00088854-00089062": "identify and really find effective", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00336-00089063-00089324": "treatments to prevent this effect now", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00337-00089325-00089455": "when we think about metastases", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00338-00089456-00089687": "classically we think about this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00339-00089688-00089863": "population of cells that are growing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00340-00089864-00090005": "Robley right it's completely out of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00341-00090006-00090244": "control and then they they they undergo", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00342-00090245-00090371": "some sort of stressor this could be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00343-00090372-00090521": "drugs it could be the environment", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00344-00090522-00090682": "something is driving them to transition", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00345-00090683-00090992": "into a new state and then they leave the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00346-00090993-00091162": "environment go someplace else and then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00347-00091163-00091328": "seed and then ideally those they'll", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00348-00091329-00091484": "switch and they'll grow and it's this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00349-00091485-00091667": "process that we think of this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00350-00091668-00091930": "accumulation of mutations that starts to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00351-00091931-00092255": "change how they respond to drugs well it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00352-00092256-00092468": "turns out that this classical pathway is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00353-00092469-00092747": "is not really correct it's it's kind of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00354-00092748-00092975": "old this is the old thought this is and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00355-00092976-00093212": "and research by David Lighting's group", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00356-00093213-00093596": "Julio eggie eggie so has really shown", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00357-00093597-00093824": "that it's actually much more complicated", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00358-00093825-00094081": "so it's not just a single collection of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00359-00094082-00094358": "primary tumor cells but it's it's really", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00360-00094359-00094574": "a whole physiological system that's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00361-00094575-00094793": "working in concert and it's these", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00362-00094794-00095036": "interactions that change things and not", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00363-00095037-00095282": "only do we have to think about this time", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00364-00095283-00095450": "course of events and that meta", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00365-00095451-00095762": "metastasis is this in stage event no it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00366-00095763-00095939": "actually happens before there's a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00367-00095940-00096107": "palpable tumor so they're actually early", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00368-00096108-00096323": "disseminated cells that will escape well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00369-00096324-00096503": "before there's anything detectable so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00370-00096504-00096626": "you have metastasis that occurs", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00371-00096627-00096794": "throughout a person potentially", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00372-00096795-00096911": "throughout a person's lifetime they may", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00373-00096912-00097139": "not ever outgrow but they could happen", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00374-00097140-00097457": "and what we've seen is that this idea of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00375-00097458-00097801": "organo tropism or tissue specificity", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00376-00097802-00098126": "develops in response to this so think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00377-00098127-00098297": "the cancer cells actually release things", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00378-00098298-00098435": "that create what we call a pre", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00379-00098436-00098654": "metastatic niche so this is a small", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00380-00098655-00098867": "little tissue space that's very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00381-00098868-00099053": "hospitable to the cancer cells and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00382-00099054-00099386": "allows for metastatic outgrowth and so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00383-00099387-00099602": "we we kind of started a focus on this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00384-00099603-00099779": "concept of what is this pre-med", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00385-00099780-00100118": "aesthetic niche and so what we find is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00386-00100119-00100361": "that if we look at a normal healthy lung", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00387-00100362-00100622": "we sees lower levels of fibronectin", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00388-00100623-00100862": "expression but then during early", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00389-00100863-00101000": "metastasis we start to see this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00390-00101001-00101210": "fibrillar network of fibronectin form", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00391-00101211-00101414": "and it's this fibrillar network that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00392-00101415-00101612": "actually it's this fiber aspect that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00393-00101613-00101831": "actually changes these cells and it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00394-00101832-00102020": "provides an environment for cells to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00395-00102021-00102269": "actually grow and so what we wanted to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00396-00102270-00102440": "do was develop a way to kind of mimic", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00397-00102441-00102619": "and recapitulate that aspect of the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00398-00102620-00102808": "tumor space and so we developed a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00399-00102809-00102956": "platform that allows us to take", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00400-00102957-00103205": "fibronectin which is just part of your", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00401-00103206-00103534": "blood plasma and then transition it from", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00402-00103535-00103754": "this globular completely inactive state", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00403-00103755-00104011": "into fib roles that actually drive that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00404-00104013-00104282": "and facilitate that metastatic outgrowth", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00405-00104283-00104504": "and then using the system to create that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00406-00104505-00104705": "sort of environment what we were able to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00407-00104706-00104972": "show was that if we take cancer cells", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00408-00104973-00105194": "from a pleural effusion so these are a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00409-00105195-00105385": "buildup of lymphatic fluid in a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00410-00105386-00105590": "patient's lung it just happens it's a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00411-00105591-00105791": "course of metastasis and it's very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00412-00105792-00105956": "uncomfortable uncomfortable for the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00413-00105957-00106196": "patient it's this giant Lewis cells no", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00414-00106197-00106352": "one really knows completely what's in it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00415-00106353-00106580": "it changes constantly so we can take", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00416-00106581-00106805": "this solution and if we try and grow it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00417-00106806-00106997": "on plaster this cells dying they don't", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00418-00106998-00107291": "see now if we take this synthetic", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00419-00107292-00107567": "pre-med aesthetic niche and then see it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00420-00107568-00107720": "ourselves on top of it we have now", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00421-00107721-00107954": "selected for that inherent population of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00422-00107955-00108188": "cells and then what we find even more", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00423-00108189-00108353": "exciting is that we're actually able to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00424-00108354-00108548": "enrich for the cancer cell population", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00425-00108549-00108766": "and this gives us a snapshot into a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00426-00108767-00109046": "patient specific cancer so during the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00427-00109047-00109181": "time course of all their treatments", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00428-00109182-00109307": "they're going to have this fluid drain", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00429-00109308-00109532": "and what we can do is we can sample this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00430-00109533-00109759": "fluid put it on our small little chip", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00431-00109760-00109958": "platform and screen unbias leaf or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00432-00109958-00110144": "thousands of compounds and so that's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00433-00110145-00110359": "kind of where we're going with respect", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00434-00110360-00110519": "to the precision medicine aspect is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00435-00110520-00110833": "using this approach to really tailor", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00436-00110833-00111065": "specifically to these cells that that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00437-00111066-00111266": "are constantly mutating and different", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00438-00111267-00111413": "from patient to patient and so it gives", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00439-00111414-00111650": "us a real strategy really the idea is to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00440-00111651-00111908": "give clinicians the tools to narrow down", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00441-00111908-00112118": "which drugs they potentially would want", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00442-00112119-00112292": "to give the patient when they have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00443-00112293-00112442": "thousands and thousands of compounds to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00444-00112443-00112574": "choose from and it just kind of helps", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00445-00112575-00112742": "them narrow down that selectivity so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00446-00112743-00112885": "that hopefully we can actually improve", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00447-00112886-00113257": "the patient outcome", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00448-00113258-00113630": "thank you very much the next speaker is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00449-00113631-00113963": "dr. Andrew Brightman from the Weldon", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00450-00113964-00114443": "School of biomedical engineering and he", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00451-00114444-00114647": "has andrew has a very strong background", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00452-00114648-00115055": "in among other things in engineering", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00453-00115056-00115379": "ethics and has led the effort in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00454-00115380-00115585": "school of biomedical engineering to make", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00455-00115586-00115796": "sure that this perspective is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00456-00115797-00116132": "incorporated into the curriculum so he", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00457-00116133-00116345": "will even though precision medicine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00458-00116346-00116639": "presents many fantastic opportunities", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00459-00116640-00116963": "there also are some a lot of issues that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00460-00116964-00117116": "have to be raised from an ethical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00461-00117117-00117326": "perspective and dr. Brightman will", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00462-00117327-00117547": "address some of those", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00463-00117548-00117815": "thank you very much", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00464-00117816-00118060": "yes I think there's a number of aspects", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00465-00118061-00118309": "that we could look at I chose to think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00466-00118310-00118598": "about personalized bio printing as one", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00467-00118599-00118867": "area to consider the ethics", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00468-00118868-00119066": "dr. Anne says", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00469-00119067-00119249": "making those materials that could", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00470-00119250-00119456": "potentially become bio inks and then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00471-00119457-00119681": "printing used bio printing into tissues", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00472-00119682-00120029": "or organs is a field that is an emerging", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00473-00120030-00120348": "technology and has a lot of potential in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00474-00120349-00120646": "medicine I like that quote that bio", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00475-00120647-00120884": "printing 3d organs could have the same", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00476-00120885-00121122": "revolutionary and democratizing effect", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00477-00121123-00121389": "as book printing in their applicability", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00478-00121390-00121611": "to regenerative medicine in industry and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00479-00121612-00121809": "I think particularly to personalized", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00480-00121810-00121916": "medicine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00481-00121917-00122245": "there's two aspects that I think are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00482-00122246-00122514": "important to consider when you're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00483-00122515-00122683": "looking at a bio ethical perspective one", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00484-00122683-00122922": "is the identification of what the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00485-00122923-00123198": "ethical issues could be and the second", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00486-00123199-00123414": "is then what do you do about them or how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00487-00123415-00123609": "do you respond to them and that in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00488-00123610-00123982": "first aspect I take an approach and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00489-00123983-00124197": "encourage this among our biomedical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00490-00124198-00124488": "engineers that's built from biomedical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00491-00124489-00124783": "ethics using the four principles of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00492-00124783-00125064": "biomedical ethics promoted by Beecham", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00493-00125065-00125276": "and Childress and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00494-00125277-00125691": "in their classic work on principles of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00495-00125692-00125874": "biomedical ethics we use that as a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00496-00125875-00126147": "framework to identify issues the second", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00497-00126148-00126366": "I want to consider briefly is just a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00498-00126367-00126583": "framework of responsible research", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00499-00126583-00126970": "innovation this idea that two aspects of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00500-00126971-00127243": "it one that we if we think about the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00501-00127244-00127575": "biomedical ethical issues early in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00502-00127576-00127807": "design and innovation process we can end", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00503-00127808-00128013": "up actually with better innovation at", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00504-00128014-00128289": "the end and part of that thinking about", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00505-00128290-00128460": "those ethical issues is who gets", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00506-00128461-00128712": "involved and how to incorporate them and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00507-00128713-00128975": "I'll say a little bit right at the end", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00508-00128976-00129297": "so if we use the four principles of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00509-00129298-00129571": "biomedical ethics as a framework they", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00510-00129572-00129879": "are beneficence or to do as much good as", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00511-00129880-00130171": "possible and non-maleficence which is to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00512-00130172-00130425": "do as little harm or no harm as possible", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00513-00130426-00130594": "the other two on the next slide are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00514-00130595-00130933": "justice and respect for autonomy so I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00515-00130933-00131387": "just tried to identify a few issues", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00516-00131388-00131581": "most of these are from the published", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00517-00131582-00131739": "literature you can probably think of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00518-00131740-00132031": "others but that are around the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00519-00132032-00132273": "beneficence of or the good that can be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00520-00132274-00132493": "done with bio printing in a precision", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00521-00132494-00132694": "medicine framework certainly they are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00522-00132695-00132999": "allowed to address very specific patient", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00523-00133000-00133215": "needs you can bio print an organ that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00524-00133216-00133452": "could be very tailored to that unique", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00525-00133453-00133698": "Vigil there'd certainly be a reduced", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00526-00133699-00133875": "need for organ donation if you can", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00527-00133876-00134130": "create these organs without having to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00528-00134131-00134436": "sacrifice anyone else's organs you would", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00529-00134437-00134757": "avoid xenotransplantation and all the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00530-00134758-00134973": "issues that come from that both cultural", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00531-00134974-00135077": "and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00532-00135078-00135447": "and biological there's a reduced need", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00533-00135448-00135609": "for immune suppression if you're using", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00534-00135610-00135824": "the patient's own cells and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00535-00135825-00136200": "nonreactive biomaterials certainly", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00536-00136201-00136407": "providing organs and tissues that could", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00537-00136408-00136599": "have an adaptability or a growth", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00538-00136600-00136791": "potential would be great for pediatric", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00539-00136792-00137061": "applications creating better disease", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00540-00137062-00137253": "models for testing whether it's new", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00541-00137254-00137513": "drugs or tissue engineered products and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00542-00137514-00137739": "certainly providing alternatives to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00543-00137740-00137913": "animal testing would be considered a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00544-00137914-00138177": "beneficence issue on the other side", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00545-00138178-00138444": "there's possible harms or risks of harms", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00546-00138445-00138681": "there is risk of rejections if you're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00547-00138682-00138990": "creating organs bioprinting with using", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00548-00138991-00139265": "some mixture of animal cells in there", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00549-00139266-00139572": "there's a possibility that you're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00550-00139573-00139782": "running a higher risk of failure these", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00551-00139783-00139949": "high complexity", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00552-00139950-00140235": "bioprinted organs if they're going to be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00553-00140236-00140493": "functional they're high complexity so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00554-00140494-00140736": "they're a lot harder to both develop and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00555-00140737-00140976": "and to test certainly there's risk to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00556-00140977-00141147": "the unknown side effects so longer", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00557-00141148-00141387": "animal testing and clinical trials might", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00558-00141388-00141600": "be necessary before they could get into", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00559-00141601-00141909": "a patient limited irreversibility once", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00560-00141910-00142293": "bioprinted organs are implanted they get", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00561-00142294-00142566": "incorporated and then if you've done", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00562-00142567-00142797": "something wrong there in the body now", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00563-00142798-00143064": "and how do you reverse that might be a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00564-00143065-00143292": "possible high cost of development and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00565-00143293-00143445": "translation with any new emerging", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00566-00143446-00143613": "technologies you have to consider the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00567-00143614-00143762": "cost and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00568-00143763-00143988": "opportunity costs and that could be a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00569-00143989-00144186": "potential harm and certainly managing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00570-00144187-00144450": "public expectations and hype around a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00571-00144451-00144660": "potential emerging technology that might", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00572-00144661-00144900": "take ten years before it's ever or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00573-00144901-00145085": "longer before it's realized", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00574-00145086-00145407": "on the on the Justice side which is the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00575-00145408-00145557": "just distribution of healthcare and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00576-00145558-00146040": "benefits and and risk of harm a few more", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00577-00146041-00146250": "issues access to advanced technologies", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00578-00146251-00146385": "may be limited only to those who can", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00579-00146386-00146568": "afford them or to countries where the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00580-00146569-00146745": "inference structure to develop them and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00581-00146746-00147024": "deliver those bioprinted organs legal", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00582-00147025-00147225": "ownership of the tissues who owns what's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00583-00147226-00147498": "been printed do you own your own cells", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00584-00147499-00147702": "did the company that used them to the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00585-00147703-00147897": "hospital that made the tissues for you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00586-00147898-00148128": "the rights to market them what if we're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00587-00148129-00148247": "designing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00588-00148248-00148519": "personalized tissues and then marketing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00589-00148520-00148695": "them more broadly if they had broad", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00590-00148696-00148950": "applicability who gets the the right to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00591-00148951-00149121": "market in the reef and the funds from", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00592-00149122-00149295": "that and certainly there's issues around", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00593-00149296-00149495": "personalized testing and how long and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00594-00149496-00149835": "complicated that might be and the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00595-00149836-00150009": "respect for autonomy also comes in this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00596-00150010-00150198": "right to make decisions so it is the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00597-00150199-00150461": "patient get to make decisions about how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00598-00150462-00150660": "bioprinted organs made from their", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00599-00150661-00150957": "tissues are used do you ever have the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00600-00150958-00151131": "right to grow your own tissues and then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00601-00151132-00151325": "do what you want with them", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00602-00151326-00151584": "create and that possibility of you know", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00603-00151585-00151850": "home printing is probably", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00604-00151851-00152115": "quite a lot longer away than doing it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00605-00152116-00152241": "commercially but it's still a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00606-00152242-00152496": "possibility creating enhanced organs is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00607-00152497-00152628": "another issue that we have to think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00608-00152629-00152916": "about what if we want not just disease", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00609-00152917-00153222": "repair but we want our muscles to have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00610-00153223-00153465": "faster twitch or our organs to do", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00611-00153466-00153879": "specialized metabolism or do we have any", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00612-00153880-00154083": "rights or regulations to print anything", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00613-00154084-00154419": "that we want and implant it or use it so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00614-00154420-00154647": "the last piece is just a framework so if", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00615-00154648-00154806": "we have these issues how do we respond", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00616-00154807-00155021": "to them how do we begin to specify how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00617-00155022-00155340": "risky they are or how detrimental they", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00618-00155341-00155634": "might be and who gets involved in that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00619-00155635-00155784": "decision and then how do we regulate", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00620-00155785-00155964": "that and so the responsible research", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00621-00155965-00156195": "innovation framework suggests that more", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00622-00156196-00156394": "than just the technologist the engineers", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00623-00156395-00156546": "and the clinicians who are involved in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00624-00156547-00156759": "this technology you need a public", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00625-00156760-00157095": "opinion you need social scientists you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00626-00157096-00157290": "need ethicists to be involved in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00627-00157291-00157494": "early stages of this kind of innovation", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00628-00157495-00157851": "to collectively assess the risks and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00629-00157852-00158049": "mitigate and manage them and be in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00630-00158050-00158662": "charge of the overall regulation", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00631-00158663-00158893": "thank you very much and the last", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00632-00158894-00159250": "presentation is by dr. Michael Hiles", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00633-00159251-00159547": "from Cook biotech senior vice president", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00634-00159548-00159748": "and chief scientific officer there also", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00635-00159749-00160111": "an adjunct professor in both Welding", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00636-00160112-00160276": "school biomedical engineering and the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00637-00160277-00160480": "College of Veterinary Medicine has a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00638-00160481-00160819": "very strong history and relationship", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00639-00160820-00161086": "with Purdue having gotten both electoral", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00640-00161087-00161218": "engineering and veterinary medicine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00641-00161219-00161500": "degrees and he's been instrumental in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00642-00161501-00161731": "that program for for a number of years", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00643-00161732-00162058": "and finally from an industry side and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00644-00162059-00162205": "that's the perspective he's going to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00645-00162206-00162433": "provide today is has over 30 years", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00646-00162434-00162712": "experience in the field that we're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00647-00162713-00163060": "discussing so dr. Hiles thank you for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00648-00163061-00163249": "that kind introduction and for having me", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00649-00163250-00163534": "this is fun I should say perhaps now for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00650-00163535-00163677": "something completely different", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00651-00163678-00163879": "because I didn't have a lot of pretty", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00652-00163880-00164044": "pictures are really focused on research", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00653-00164045-00164302": "instead I was asked to talk about what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00654-00164303-00164536": "is it that might be the obstacles or the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00655-00164537-00164728": "opportunities to commercializing this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00656-00164729-00164875": "stuff so I put together a couple of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00657-00164876-00165250": "slides just to about those and so here's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00658-00165251-00165403": "a couple of points these processes", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00659-00165404-00165730": "always lag I'm all kinds of new research", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00660-00165731-00165979": "processes always lag behind the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00661-00165980-00166111": "technology that actually gets", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00662-00166112-00166270": "commercialized so there's always a lag", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00663-00166271-00166516": "time and often a preponderance of safety", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00664-00166517-00166786": "has to be first established no current", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00665-00166787-00167068": "paradigms paradigms allow for all", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00666-00167069-00167278": "outputs of a given process and what I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00667-00167279-00167458": "meant by that is is that over the years", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00668-00167459-00167683": "we've gotten more and more in vitro", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00669-00167684-00167845": "diagnostics to the point that the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00670-00167846-00168148": "division of devices within the FDA has a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00671-00168149-00168367": "whole special sub branch on in vitro", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00672-00168368-00168592": "diagnostics and I think what we're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00673-00168593-00168784": "finding is is that we're starting to get", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00674-00168785-00169012": "more and more I'll call it ex vivo", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00675-00169013-00169294": "personal process develop more personal", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00676-00169295-00169492": "production that we might need a whole", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00677-00169493-00169780": "new regulatory framework to regulate", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00678-00169781-00169975": "these things in other words if you could", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00679-00169976-00170251": "get a product by process that's a that's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00680-00170252-00170476": "a terminology that a lot of patent", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00681-00170477-00170728": "lawyers use but a product by process and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00682-00170729-00170926": "you get an approval for every product", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00683-00170927-00171073": "that comes out of that process if you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00684-00171074-00171190": "can keep it within certain parameters", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00685-00171191-00171385": "then that might be a regulatory", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00686-00171386-00171547": "framework that would work for these but", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00687-00171548-00171724": "we're currently the regulatory climate", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00688-00171725-00171913": "is not mature enough to determine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00689-00171914-00172104": "whether these things are devices drugs", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00690-00172105-00172282": "or something else and that's why I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00691-00172283-00172486": "maybe there's opportunity for a whole", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00692-00172487-00172744": "new framework because many of the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00693-00172745-00172882": "examples that you've seen today both", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00694-00172883-00173065": "here at this part and and at the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00695-00173066-00173320": "original lecture as soon as you start", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00696-00173321-00173557": "adding something that has a biological", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00697-00173558-00173719": "function that starts to alter cell", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00698-00173720-00173974": "behavior it's a drug and to give you an", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00699-00173975-00174148": "idea at least in the FDA and in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00700-00174149-00174307": "world that we live in the drug takes", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00701-00174308-00174499": "somewhere north of 10 years and a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00702-00174500-00174631": "billion dollars from start to finish", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00703-00174632-00174874": "whereas an average device you know", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00704-00174875-00175057": "typically maybe five years and five", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00705-00175058-00175246": "million dollars a big difference and so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00706-00175247-00175465": "if you're just a scaffold without any", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00707-00175466-00175633": "bioactivity you're a device at least", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00708-00175634-00175774": "right now but as soon as you start", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00709-00175775-00175996": "tailoring all these things what is it so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00710-00175997-00176131": "we need to think about maybe that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00711-00176132-00176322": "product by process type of regulatory", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00712-00176323-00176779": "that might be new but effective and then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00713-00176780-00176932": "I just threw in some commercialization", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00714-00176933-00177235": "questions is the manufacture of end", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00715-00177236-00177466": "products now subsumed by supplies tools", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00716-00177467-00177643": "and software so if you think about it if", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00717-00177644-00177802": "you could bio print right next to the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00718-00177803-00177997": "operating room anything that the patient", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00719-00177998-00178147": "needs then there's no reason for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00720-00178148-00178402": "manufacturing the thing that patient", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00721-00178403-00178566": "needs or you're not manufacturing the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00722-00178567-00178756": "endpoint you're simply manufacturing the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00723-00178757-00178975": "device to build it and the supplies the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00724-00178976-00179170": "inks that it uses and the software that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00725-00179171-00179350": "it runs on so you've changed the whole", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00726-00179351-00179604": "paradigm of what manufacturing is how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00727-00179605-00179761": "strict limits will be placed on each", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00728-00179762-00179923": "component in each process so nothing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00729-00179924-00180121": "harmful can be created so that gets this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00730-00180122-00180358": "gets back to the product by process and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00731-00180359-00180618": "if there's any way to tune it so that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00732-00180619-00180997": "you can't make or you can make something", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00733-00180998-00181183": "toxic or something dangerous then you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00734-00181184-00181453": "want to inhibit that I have to tell you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00735-00181454-00181684": "a quick antidote and that is that we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00736-00181685-00181861": "were at a Medical Advisory Board meeting", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00737-00181862-00182026": "one time we had a group of doctors there", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00738-00182027-00182122": "we were talking about a particular", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00739-00182123-00182329": "device that we were working on and the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00740-00182330-00182596": "doctor got up there and said and no", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00741-00182597-00182770": "offense to you but he said you've got to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00742-00182771-00182932": "make this device idiot-proof because at", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00743-00182933-00183070": "the medical schools we'll just build a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00744-00183071-00183341": "better idiot", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00745-00183342-00183583": "finally what tolerances and patient data", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00746-00183584-00183753": "will cause inappropriate outputs or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00747-00183754-00183919": "contraindications for treatment so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00748-00183920-00184111": "that's the other thing which is if we're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00749-00184112-00184219": "gonna do this whole personalized", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00750-00184220-00184432": "medicine and use patient's own data to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00751-00184433-00184629": "then tailor the device you know what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00752-00184630-00184855": "what parts of that data can be used and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00753-00184856-00185029": "what parts can't be used and what parts", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00754-00185030-00185257": "might make the device non functional or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00755-00185258-00185545": "functional so just some ideas because at", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00756-00185546-00185716": "cook biotech we spend a lot of time", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00757-00185717-00185899": "looking at technologies and what we call", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00758-00185900-00186163": "a technology readiness level which is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00759-00186164-00186328": "goes across a lot of industries but how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00760-00186329-00186547": "close is it to commercialization is it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00761-00186548-00186784": "is it years away is it months away it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00762-00186785-00187179": "was a decades away so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00763-00187180-00187537": "thanks very much to all the panelists", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00764-00187538-00187861": "and before we open it up for questions", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00765-00187862-00188083": "and discussion I'll just check in with", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00766-00188084-00188368": "dr. answers and see if fish if you have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00767-00188369-00188680": "any quick comments or views again before", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00768-00188681-00188994": "we open it up more broadly I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00769-00188995-00189271": "think the points were very well raised", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00770-00189272-00189517": "and I think it's a challenge for us also", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00771-00189518-00189802": "to figure out is what is most impactful", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00772-00189803-00190219": "for us to be doing in this space as well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00773-00190220-00190456": "as we go towards more precision and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00774-00190457-00190756": "personalization we see all the advances", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00775-00190757-00191047": "and cancer immunotherapy so work with", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00776-00191048-00191281": "your t-cells and there's car t-cell", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00777-00191282-00191835": "therapy one patient one treatment is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00778-00191836-00191991": "$500,000", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00779-00191992-00192301": "versus should we be thinking globally", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00780-00192302-00192556": "and what impact can we do to better", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00781-00192557-00192745": "understand how different subsets of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00782-00192746-00192931": "patients with lower technology can be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00783-00192932-00193144": "treated and yeah there's no right answer", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00784-00193145-00193345": "there but I think it's a challenge to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00785-00193346-00193665": "think about as well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00786-00193666-00194041": "okay well thank you again and we'll open", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00787-00194042-00194416": "it up for a broad discussion any pointed", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00788-00194417-00194656": "questions to any of the panelists", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00789-00194657-00195127": "presentations or your comments a good", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00790-00195128-00195331": "moderator always has some questions in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00791-00195332-00195559": "his back pocket in case the there", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00792-00195560-00195748": "they're slow to come so I've got a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00793-00195749-00195852": "couple", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00794-00195853-00196267": "so we we kind of touched upon the that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00795-00196268-00196579": "how do you clinically validate these", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00796-00196580-00196930": "these types of new products because as", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00797-00196931-00197239": "we talked to talked about for drugs you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00798-00197240-00197494": "mentioned dr. Hiles that it's at least a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00799-00197495-00197776": "10-year process and the phase 3 clinical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00800-00197777-00198067": "trial could be four hundred five hundred", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00801-00198068-00198427": "million dollars to look at two or three", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00802-00198428-00198692": "thousand patients so again that's a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00803-00198693-00198992": "heterogeneous group of patients that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00804-00198993-00199202": "that but then the drug or the technology", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00805-00199203-00199397": "is only used in a given patient so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00806-00199398-00199805": "looking forward I don't think that that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00807-00199806-00199970": "paradigm is going to change but what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00808-00199971-00200162": "additional clinical validation is going", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00809-00200163-00200489": "to be required for these for some of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00810-00200490-00200864": "these newer approaches to satisfy the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00811-00200865-00201289": "FDA and other regulatory bodies", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00812-00201290-00201503": "well I'll give a stab it at that but", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00813-00201504-00201677": "it's a great question because", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00814-00201678-00201839": "regulations seem to be getting tighter", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00815-00201840-00202240": "not looser and the concept of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00816-00202241-00202478": "personalizing something I think maybe", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00817-00202479-00202742": "has to start with all of the components", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00818-00202743-00202931": "being already approved so that you're at", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00819-00202932-00203177": "least have a basis on which of safety to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00820-00203178-00203351": "build and then say ok we're going to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00821-00203352-00203588": "take these already approved products and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00822-00203589-00203840": "mix them in various ways and then you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00823-00203841-00204002": "know as I suggested maybe through a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00824-00204003-00204301": "possible new regulatory pathway or some", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00825-00204302-00204548": "particular pilot program that they might", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00826-00204549-00204755": "put together specifically for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00827-00204756-00205051": "personalized medicine and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00828-00205052-00205376": "well I think we saw one of the examples", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00829-00205377-00205477": "as well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00830-00205478-00206017": "you know I think we need to find ways to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00831-00206019-00206241": "fail earlier I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00832-00206242-00206504": "personalized approaches that allow more", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00833-00206505-00206831": "sophisticated in vitro assays are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00834-00206832-00207007": "important", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00835-00207008-00207404": "but I also think on the flip side too", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00836-00207405-00207616": "there was a New York Times article about", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00837-00207617-00207796": "how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00838-00207796-00208019": "personalized and precision medicine was", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00839-00208019-00208283": "failing the average patient our person", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00840-00208284-00208478": "because it wasn't really benefiting them", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00841-00208479-00208898": "so you know the average response and the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00842-00208898-00209021": "average treatment can actually be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00843-00209021-00209333": "harmful to many many people so how do we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00844-00209334-00209858": "navigate that that space I have one", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00845-00209859-00210035": "colleague just as one example you know a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00846-00210036-00210269": "woman is not a small man as the talk she", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00847-00210269-00210546": "gives yet we dose drugs based upon", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00848-00210548-00210827": "weights you know and and so I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00849-00210828-00211112": "there's at some level the economies of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00850-00211113-00211478": "what what subsets can we look at and the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00851-00211479-00211736": "markets can bear financial development", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00852-00211737-00212001": "for four different sub populations is is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00853-00212002-00212219": "a really important thing and I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00854-00212221-00212406": "engineers have to play a role in that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00855-00212407-00212604": "well I think one thing we're starting to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00856-00212605-00212778": "do now though is that we because we're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00857-00212779-00213012": "collecting so much data on patients that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00858-00213013-00213252": "if there's a particular ailment like", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00859-00213253-00213390": "they have a hernia and they need a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00860-00213391-00213548": "hernia repair and there's a dozen", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00861-00213550-00213846": "different types of devices that they", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00862-00213846-00214035": "might use they can go back and look at", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00863-00214036-00214146": "the patient and there might be some", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00864-00214146-00214305": "reason why they might be contraindicated", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00865-00214306-00214662": "for a particular therapy so now it's not", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00866-00214663-00214923": "just the physician deciding that oh I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00867-00214923-00215106": "like this product better so I'll use it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00868-00215107-00215262": "in everybody they are starting to look", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00869-00215263-00215403": "at the demographic of the patient and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00870-00215404-00215642": "tailor the solution if it's already on", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00871-00215644-00215838": "the market to the patient but it's not", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00872-00215839-00216158": "being made next door I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00873-00216159-00216494": "would also say that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00874-00216494-00216714": "clinical trials were designed for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00875-00216715-00217096": "testing both safety and efficacy", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00876-00217098-00217335": "protecting the patient safety is a high", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00877-00217336-00217737": "value we we do as the emergent", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00878-00217738-00217902": "technology need to think about new", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00879-00217903-00218219": "paradigms for clinical testing and part", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00880-00218221-00218451": "of that it there are engineers coming", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00881-00218452-00218673": "and clinicians as well working together", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00882-00218673-00218856": "to come up with these new forms of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00883-00218857-00219167": "testing we really need a testing science", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00884-00219167-00219419": "revised testing science for clinical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00885-00219421-00219600": "testing when it's a personalized", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00886-00219601-00219783": "medicine or otherwise we're gonna have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00887-00219784-00219981": "safety issues all the way down the road", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00888-00219982-00220233": "because you you can't generalize those", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00889-00220234-00220601": "kinds of technologies", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00890-00220602-00221117": "doctor I'm Christa", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00891-00221119-00221369": "evolved", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00892-00221371-00221764": "curious about to what extent does FDA", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00893-00221765-00222142": "get involved in using personalized", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00894-00222142-00222484": "strategies for example let's say you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00895-00222485-00222700": "base it on mathematical modeling and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00896-00222701-00222944": "point out to the clinician that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00897-00222946-00223315": "each individual patient there is a way", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00898-00223316-00223590": "to learn about the patient's special", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00899-00223591-00223909": "response to a given drug and if you were", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00900-00223910-00224127": "to come up with strategies for dosage", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00901-00224128-00224413": "will you could take the attitude maybe", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00902-00224414-00224671": "that could be used as a suggestion to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00903-00224671-00224946": "the clinician and it would be up to the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00904-00224946-00225232": "clinicians discretion as to whether use", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00905-00225233-00225594": "it or not or would the FDA get involved", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00906-00225596-00225883": "that even the clinician can't use it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00907-00225884-00226401": "until we approve it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00908-00226402-00226557": "so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00909-00226558-00226742": "good", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00910-00226744-00227121": "it's a good question and I think it's a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00911-00227123-00227254": "hard question but first of all", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00912-00227255-00227521": "physicians can't prescribe anything that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00913-00227521-00227728": "hasn't been approved already with very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00914-00227729-00227986": "few exceptions there are some emergency", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00915-00227987-00228198": "uses and things like that but very few", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00916-00228200-00228526": "exceptions but the FDA also very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00917-00228527-00228703": "carefully says we do not regulate the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00918-00228704-00228886": "practice of medicine and what they say", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00919-00228887-00229054": "by that is is that we will not stand", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00920-00229055-00229237": "between the doctor and the patient and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00921-00229238-00229516": "so if the doctor prescribes a drug that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00922-00229517-00229663": "is supposed to have this regiment and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00923-00229664-00229848": "instead he prescribes that regimen", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00924-00229850-00230041": "that's between him and the patient it's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00925-00230042-00230251": "the FDA doesn't step in but the drug", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00926-00230252-00230407": "couldn't have been there at least it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00927-00230408-00230587": "would less it was approved for a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00928-00230588-00230785": "particular thing which gets to a whole", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00929-00230786-00231096": "other discussion about off-label use of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00930-00231098-00231307": "medical products whether it's drugs or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00931-00231308-00231523": "devices and a lot of people when outlay", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00932-00231523-00231763": "law off-label use but if that's true", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00933-00231764-00232183": "then for diabetics and for and for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00934-00232184-00232357": "Pediatrics or children or whatever a lot", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00935-00232358-00232534": "of things would go away because none of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00936-00232535-00232651": "them were made for that in the first", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00937-00232652-00232785": "place I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00938-00232786-00233026": "could follow up with that on some level", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00939-00233027-00233473": "because when a clinician so say a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00940-00233473-00233742": "patient is prescribed with a her2", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00941-00233744-00233908": "positive cancer and they want to get", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00942-00233909-00234136": "they want to give them the Herceptin", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00943-00234137-00234348": "that the drugs are treated based off of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00944-00234350-00234610": "after status and it fails well once that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00945-00234611-00234808": "standard of care therapy fails the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00946-00234809-00234988": "clinician is you know they're kind of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00947-00234989-00235183": "going blind at that point and so a lot", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00948-00235184-00235387": "of the times already they have to rely", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00949-00235388-00235639": "on just their past experiences to guide", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00950-00235640-00235858": "and dictate what that patient has and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00951-00235859-00236077": "there's no evidence that it's not", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00952-00236078-00236332": "evidence-based and so I think with", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00953-00236333-00236563": "respect to the FDA approval it's I mean", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00954-00236564-00236673": "that's the standard would already be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00955-00236675-00236944": "there and will let the doctors you use", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00956-00236944-00237115": "the information as they see fit and I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00957-00237116-00237235": "think that would probably be a wise", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00958-00237236-00237446": "strategy", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00959-00237448-00237775": "and maybe just to add a slightly", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00960-00237776-00238186": "different point to is um that as we have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00961-00238187-00238480": "more data and in certain areas of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00962-00238481-00238656": "Medicine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00963-00238657-00238969": "modeling artificial intelligence machine", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00964-00238969-00239244": "learning can sometimes detect things", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00965-00239246-00239536": "better than the doctor for the treatment", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00966-00239537-00239763": "you know for example certain", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00967-00239764-00240040": "macular degeneration and it has been", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00968-00240041-00240376": "shown but as a regulatory aspect we have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00969-00240377-00240688": "tort law in our country as well and even", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00970-00240689-00240871": "though some of this technology exists", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00971-00240871-00241189": "most medical practices are not yet", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00972-00241190-00241563": "willing to trust the outcome of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00973-00241564-00241998": "image diagnosis over they'll face the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00974-00242000-00242161": "face of what a doctor recommends to a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00975-00242162-00242341": "patient so kind of echoing these", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00976-00242342-00242551": "doctor/patient kind of relations so we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00977-00242552-00243552": "aren't there yet so it's interesting", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00978-00243553-00243740": "I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00979-00243741-00243971": "have a question about privacy", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00980-00243971-00244404": "so currently when we collect data about", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00981-00244405-00244677": "patients bioinformatics we have ways to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00982-00244678-00244967": "anonymize the data it's just bits and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00983-00244969-00245229": "bytes right if we start harvesting", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00984-00245230-00245484": "tissue from patients in order to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00985-00245485-00245721": "regenerate organs for them and they", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00986-00245721-00246051": "consent to donate the residual tissue to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00987-00246052-00246276": "the company for further research are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00988-00246277-00246480": "there any ways for us to anonymize", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00989-00246481-00246794": "tissue so that the company can keep", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00990-00246796-00247071": "working with it without any sort of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00991-00247071-00247439": "privacy concerns from the patient", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00992-00247440-00247863": "there are and and bio banking ethics", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00993-00247864-00248073": "deals with this quite often we already", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00994-00248073-00248296": "collect a lot of tissues and samples", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00995-00248298-00248589": "what I think you're getting at the which", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00996-00248590-00248856": "is even highlighted in personalized", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00997-00248857-00249204": "medicine is we're when that tissue is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00998-00249205-00249396": "donated a lot of screenings gonna be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-00999-00249396-00249654": "done that will point to that as a unique", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01000-00249655-00249990": "piece of tissue that data will be stored", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01001-00249991-00250106": "and protected", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01002-00250107-00250323": "lots of other information may be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01003-00250323-00250530": "collected about that particular patient", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01004-00250531-00250779": "their background and other aspects", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01005-00250780-00251109": "genetics and as that tissue and that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01006-00251110-00251367": "data is being used particularly if", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01007-00251367-00251609": "there's modeling going on or other kinds", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01008-00251610-00251802": "of databases are involved or that debt", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01009-00251803-00252021": "data needs to be shared with other kinds", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01010-00252021-00252296": "of researchers or even clinicians we run", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01011-00252298-00252398": "into the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01012-00252398-00252729": "potential for D identifying a particular", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01013-00252730-00253215": "patient because those algorithms even if", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01014-00253216-00253431": "they're encrypted or as you're sharing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01015-00253432-00253566": "them there's more opportunities for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01016-00253567-00253717": "those to be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01017-00253719-00254007": "matched or mapped back to the original", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01018-00254008-00254273": "patient so we have to have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01019-00254273-00254565": "processes to put that are heightened in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01020-00254566-00254946": "terms of policies of protection for the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01021-00254946-00255353": "patients I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01022-00255354-00255612": "think that's also another interesting", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01023-00255613-00256182": "point so also what what is patient data", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01024-00256183-00256285": "and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01025-00256286-00256581": "you know I think in a medical context we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01026-00256582-00256816": "have all kinds of protect and rules and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01027-00256817-00256935": "regulation", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01028-00256936-00257191": "but now a lot of this technology even", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01029-00257192-00257479": "just gets out into the general public", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01030-00257480-00257811": "going directly towards getting their", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01031-00257812-00258064": "genome sequenced themselves and loading", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01032-00258065-00258286": "it up to ancestry.com it's public data", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01033-00258287-00258667": "and it's available and how is that used", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01034-00258667-00258996": "I think Apple and our phones and the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01035-00258998-00259204": "watches we wear can collect data on our", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01036-00259205-00259521": "health and that can be a very good thing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01037-00259523-00259744": "it can lead to interventions or monetary", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01038-00259744-00260041": "but that data is not subjected to this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01039-00260042-00260269": "same type of privacy issues and I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01040-00260269-00260439": "a lot of people don't know that and so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01041-00260440-00260809": "it's it's an interesting time with not", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01042-00260810-00261031": "just how can we lead to improvements in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01043-00261032-00261477": "medical care but what are implications", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01044-00261478-00261719": "health insurance", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01045-00261721-00261954": "life insurance", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01046-00261955-00262243": "so there's there's both sides to it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01047-00262244-00262564": "which I think you raised as well I just", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01048-00262565-00262864": "wanted to add I'm sure many of you who", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01049-00262865-00262996": "work with spells I've heard of HeLa", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01050-00262997-00263248": "cells and there's a very famous well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01051-00263249-00263458": "there's a book that's been published in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01052-00263459-00263635": "the last five years talking about", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01053-00263636-00263860": "Henrietta Lacks right so she was the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01054-00263861-00264166": "donor and I think we also had be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01055-00264167-00264382": "cognizant about she didn't really", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01056-00264383-00264697": "realize what kinds of purposes her cells", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01057-00264698-00265002": "will be put to and I think a lot of her", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01058-00265003-00265285": "children were actually quite upset to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01059-00265286-00265468": "know that there were pieces of her", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01060-00265469-00265756": "living out there and I think part of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01061-00265757-00265975": "your question yes we have to D anonymize", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01062-00265976-00266140": "or how do we do that when we have so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01063-00266141-00266383": "much specific information but how do we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01064-00266384-00266695": "also educate the person so they really", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01065-00266696-00266893": "understand what's gonna be done with", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01066-00266894-00267154": "that tissue and what kind of information", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01067-00267155-00267540": "will people know about them I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01068-00267541-00267772": "would also say bioethicists are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01069-00267773-00268006": "struggling with this idea of what does", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01070-00268007-00268291": "privacy mean in both in the medical and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01071-00268292-00268582": "recent human research because we've come", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01072-00268583-00268902": "into a in era it seems where it's not a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01073-00268903-00269242": "binary it's not either private or public", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01074-00269243-00269494": "there are grades of what privacy is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01075-00269495-00269845": "which means our policies need to reflect", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01076-00269846-00270169": "that shift in our current status of how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01077-00270170-00270354": "much we're willing to give up and for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01078-00270355-00270654": "what value or in return but", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01079-00270655-00270905": "understanding the the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01080-00270906-00271246": "uses of what that data is going to be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01081-00271247-00271465": "critical to that gradation of what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01082-00271466-00272019": "privacy means", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01083-00272020-00272307": "since we have representatives was there", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01084-00272308-00272490": "a question", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01085-00272491-00272766": "since we have representatives from", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01086-00272767-00273054": "academics and industry here maybe I'll", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01087-00273055-00273255": "float a question to everybody does", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01088-00273256-00273555": "generally speaking the the field of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01089-00273556-00273960": "precision medicine does it offer a lot", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01090-00273961-00274216": "of opportunity in terms of industry", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01091-00274217-00274528": "academic collaboration or what what's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01092-00274529-00274683": "your feeling about about the future", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01093-00274684-00274908": "especially given the pharmaceutical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01094-00274909-00275142": "industry's apparent", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01095-00275143-00275769": "kind of latching on to it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01096-00275770-00276081": "so my personal feel interacting with", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01097-00276082-00276387": "other companies is a sense of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01098-00276388-00276660": "cautious optimism and they you know", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01099-00276661-00276796": "we've gone down these roads before", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01100-00276797-00276997": "thinking you know this is gonna be the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01101-00276998-00277225": "next big thing the and then a lot of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01102-00277226-00277390": "money's been invested in it and it's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01103-00277391-00277578": "kind of fizzled out and I think you know", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01104-00277579-00277774": "there's a definitely excitement and but", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01105-00277775-00277939": "there's also let's see what you can do", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01106-00277940-00278106": "from a research side and let's see how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01107-00278107-00278331": "realistic a little bit more I think from", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01108-00278332-00278491": "industry perspectives it seems that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01109-00278492-00278590": "they're a little bit more cautious than", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01110-00278591-00278757": "they might have been you know 20 years", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01111-00278758-00278907": "ago if we would have been at the same", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01112-00278908-00279073": "state just because there have been", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01113-00279074-00279223": "failures in the past they're really", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01114-00279224-00279405": "advanced things at the rate that you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01115-00279406-00279894": "know we're promised from academia I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01116-00279895-00280090": "think there's a great amount of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01117-00280091-00280278": "opportunity I mean I don't know whether", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01118-00280279-00280519": "you have to basically narrow it a narrow", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01119-00280520-00280672": "and narrow it and say as a company we're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01120-00280673-00280792": "gonna come talk to these researchers", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01121-00280793-00280983": "about a very particular disease and a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01122-00280984-00281133": "very particular disease state in a very", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01123-00281134-00281403": "particular population maybe that's where", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01124-00281404-00281551": "it'll start but I think there's a lot of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01125-00281552-00281862": "opportunity", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01126-00281863-00282185": "any other questions or is there another", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01127-00282186-00282393": "question from the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01128-00282394-00282775": "back to the topic on FDA approvals for", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01129-00282776-00283144": "particular devices so as we know on the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01130-00283145-00283347": "topic of off-label use", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01131-00283348-00283556": "it can be a physician's discretion to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01132-00283557-00283704": "try to treat these patients when there", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01133-00283705-00284043": "are no other solutions and if enough", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01134-00284044-00284295": "data presents itself that can be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01135-00284296-00284483": "published in case studies and what was", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01136-00284484-00284775": "once off-label can't become on label", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01137-00284776-00285109": "through FDA approvals so my question is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01138-00285110-00285471": "can personalized medicine keep pace with", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01139-00285472-00285699": "some of these innovative discoveries", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01140-00285700-00285956": "that are found somewhat", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01141-00285957-00286331": "organically or are we risking", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01142-00286332-00286680": "an opportunity where innovation maybe is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01143-00286681-00286980": "stifled in ways that are yet unknown how", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01144-00286981-00287118": "do we encourage those types of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01145-00287119-00287384": "innovation innovations through academics", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01146-00287385-00287694": "to be sure that we're not missing out on", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01147-00287695-00287892": "opportunities to treat a variety of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01148-00287893-00288147": "disease states that the original intent", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01149-00288148-00288866": "may not been there", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01150-00288867-00289122": "well my first thought is better and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01151-00289123-00289283": "better modeling if we can prove that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01152-00289284-00289497": "models are validated also that we can", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01153-00289498-00289719": "actually guess in silico or whatever", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01154-00289720-00289896": "that this is really gonna work and those", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01155-00289897-00290127": "models get better and better then we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01156-00290128-00290376": "might be able to improve that and then", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01157-00290377-00290680": "that way", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01158-00290681-00290976": "I mean to your point it seems like a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01159-00290977-00291138": "little bit different situation though", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01160-00291139-00291342": "for instance off-label use of a device", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01161-00291343-00291632": "or a drug is typically just as you know", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01162-00291633-00291972": "is just taking that technology and using", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01163-00291973-00292160": "it in a patient population that it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01164-00292161-00292452": "wasn't that not indicated for based on", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01165-00292453-00292677": "the regulatory process but here I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01166-00292678-00292931": "we're talking about maybe even if they", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01167-00292932-00293155": "involve kind of off-the-shelf", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01168-00293156-00293517": "cleared or approved products it still is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01169-00293518-00293904": "almost by definition kind of mixing", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01170-00293905-00294117": "things together to form a package", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01171-00294118-00294348": "whether it's a diagnostic with a drug or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01172-00294349-00294584": "a sensor with a medical device or", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01173-00294585-00294840": "whatever so it's maybe a little bit", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01174-00294841-00295017": "different pathway and maybe that's what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01175-00295018-00295448": "makes it a little more complicated", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01176-00295449-00295791": "yeah I mean I think the pessimist so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01177-00295792-00296033": "I've been in and in some discussions", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01178-00296034-00296151": "where people think the pace of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01179-00296152-00296454": "innovation is slowing because of our are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01180-00296455-00296793": "some of our regulations and and what we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01181-00296794-00296902": "focus on", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01182-00296903-00297138": "but I think there's many reasons to be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01183-00297139-00297395": "optimistic as well", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01184-00297396-00297671": "you know unfortunately you might know", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01185-00297672-00297860": "the statistics better but medical", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01186-00297861-00298184": "devices and some of their approval you", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01187-00298185-00298368": "know I think 80 to 90 percent get", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01188-00298369-00298574": "approved through what's called a 510 K", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01189-00298575-00299030": "or it's based upon something that exists", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01190-00299031-00299357": "so and you want to make what you're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01191-00299358-00299555": "doing sound as close to something that's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01192-00299556-00299771": "already a product and in some ways that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01193-00299772-00300087": "suppresses our hides so some of the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01194-00300088-00300312": "innovation and what's going forward and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01195-00300313-00300623": "I think there's movement afield right", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01196-00300624-00300854": "now of what's going to happen maybe in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01197-00300855-00301159": "the future with some of medical devices", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01198-00301160-00301392": "but you know I think also when you think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01199-00301393-00301545": "globally I think there's also a huge", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01200-00301546-00301835": "opportunity for innovation and and what", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01201-00301836-00302156": "we know now is based really even a lot", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01202-00302157-00302528": "on smaller subpopulations European and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01203-00302529-00302746": "US and I think there are different", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01204-00302747-00303015": "populations and groups and in Africa", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01205-00303016-00303202": "where there can be lots of tremendous", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01206-00303203-00303425": "innovation applied in different ways", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01207-00303426-00303772": "depending on how you define it I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01208-00303773-00304124": "think a risk-averse society as well as", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01209-00304125-00304379": "cost containment in health care both", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01210-00304380-00304628": "work against the innovation I'm not", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01211-00304629-00304767": "saying it's killing it it's not an", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01212-00304768-00304962": "indictment of anything other than it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01213-00304963-00305112": "just makes more challenges because", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01214-00305113-00305324": "something new that you've got to bring", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01215-00305325-00305570": "you've got to bring to the table and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01216-00305571-00305763": "realize that it may it's not gonna be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01217-00305764-00305897": "perfect so if this gets me at least", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01218-00305898-00306125": "sometimes back into this better modeling", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01219-00306126-00306253": "approach", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01220-00306254-00306620": "and I think you raise an issue of where", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01221-00306621-00306977": "in just very recently the FDA paying", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01222-00306978-00307354": "more attention to real-world data from", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01223-00307355-00307716": "use whether it's off-label or other in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01224-00307717-00308027": "the ability to approve I think it opens", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01225-00308028-00308268": "a possibility if people want to do", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01226-00308269-00308447": "modeling and they want to look at that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01227-00308448-00308651": "real world data and go back and say oh", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01228-00308652-00308919": "maybe this is only working for this sub", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01229-00308920-00309203": "population or maybe this works best in", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01230-00309204-00309470": "this population we might be able to get", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01231-00309471-00309690": "some innovations out of that real world", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01232-00309691-00309875": "data that will inform how the research", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01233-00309876-00310254": "progresses", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01234-00310255-00310662": "i'm krista", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01235-00310663-00310832": "another", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01236-00310833-00311173": "question here whether it's actually", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01237-00311174-00311518": "germane to this discussion or not it's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01238-00311519-00311869": "an expression of frustration that comes", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01239-00311870-00312163": "about from the difference between the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01240-00312164-00312554": "culture of physicians and engineers", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01241-00312555-00312925": "one of the issues with modeling that has", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01242-00312926-00313123": "been hard to get across the physicians", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01243-00313124-00313341": "is the fact that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01244-00313342-00313813": "equations can a base of the model", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01245-00313814-00314106": "equations are based on some view of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01246-00314107-00314360": "what's actually happening and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01247-00314361-00314607": "individuals are represented by the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01248-00314608-00314904": "parameters that are in there and it's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01249-00314905-00315076": "been very hard to get that point across", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01250-00315077-00315379": "the physicians that you can write the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01251-00315380-00315721": "same equation and be able to describe", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01252-00315722-00316035": "the response to a drug of two entirely", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01253-00316036-00316447": "different people two patients in the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01254-00316448-00316690": "sense that perhaps some of the processes", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01255-00316691-00316939": "that are occurring in one patient are a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01256-00316940-00317139": "little bit different qualitatively", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01257-00317140-00317473": "quantitatively speaking this is an issue", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01258-00317474-00317713": "that has not been easy to get across the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01259-00317714-00318016": "physicians I don't know what others feel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01260-00318017-00318295": "about this but I've tried to get across", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01261-00318296-00318592": "for example the idea that water and air", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01262-00318593-00319045": "are two very different fluids they are", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01263-00319046-00319257": "both Newtonian as long as you don't", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01264-00319258-00319529": "worry about compressibility", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01265-00319530-00319872": "viscosity and density are the two things", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01266-00319873-00320160": "that you use the equations are the same", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01267-00320161-00320457": "but there's nothing similar about water", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01268-00320458-00320896": "there this is an issue that I dearly", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01269-00320897-00321348": "want to get across the physicians", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01270-00321349-00321676": "and my cue it goes back to your point of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01271-00321677-00321949": "better modeling and yeah well at the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01272-00321950-00322165": "risk of sounding Rumsfeld asked there's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01273-00322166-00322399": "the known knowns the unknown unknowns", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01274-00322400-00322653": "and and everything in between and and I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01275-00322654-00322857": "think it's hard to convince the doctors", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01276-00322858-00323058": "that your model is good when they have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01277-00323059-00323203": "patients that are sitting in front of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01278-00323204-00323347": "them that they could easily", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01279-00323348-00323607": "you know 150 different variables and did", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01280-00323608-00323776": "you take all those into account or not", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01281-00323777-00324022": "or did you decide that most of them were", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01282-00324023-00324216": "irrelevant and so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01283-00324217-00324550": "it becomes at least in I think in a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01284-00324551-00324730": "physician's mind it comes a very complex", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01285-00324731-00324928": "process that that can be simplified if", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01286-00324929-00325054": "you're an engineer and take through it", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01287-00325055-00325401": "can be simplified but communicating", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01288-00325402-00325776": "you're the physician", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01289-00325777-00326050": "my specialty is very quantitative", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01290-00326051-00326250": "nephrology is", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01291-00326251-00326556": "but I would say in fairness most", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01292-00326557-00326731": "physicians are relatively", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01293-00326732-00327114": "non-quantitative III would I would agree", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01294-00327115-00327431": "the idea of being able to reduce a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01295-00327432-00327656": "complex", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01296-00327657-00328032": "human down into elements that can be", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01297-00328033-00328228": "modeled that I would I would say that's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01298-00328229-00328447": "a very general statement but", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01299-00328448-00328779": "nevertheless probably pretty accurate I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01300-00328780-00329044": "would maybe say two things right so we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01301-00329045-00329382": "are seeing examples of medical schools", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01302-00329383-00329682": "now starting that I have an engineering", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01303-00329683-00330004": "centric curriculum so I I think that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01304-00330005-00330220": "will be interesting to see what that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01305-00330221-00330541": "generation of physicians and how they", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01306-00330542-00330955": "think and I do think you call to a point", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01307-00330956-00331512": "that right now we're in an era of", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01308-00331513-00331729": "quantitating and measuring lots and lots", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01309-00331730-00332020": "of things all right so the whole genome", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01310-00332021-00332323": "the whole proteomics and the approach", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01311-00332324-00332585": "has largely been to try to understand", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01312-00332586-00333055": "every single aspect of the changes that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01313-00333056-00333258": "are occurring but what I where I think", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01314-00333259-00333472": "what you mentioned and what modeling and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01315-00333473-00333735": "engineering brings to the table is we", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01316-00333736-00333970": "understand a system we reduce complexity", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01317-00333971-00334192": "we understand governing principles and", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01318-00334193-00334380": "somehow I think we've got to play a role", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01319-00334381-00334731": "in that that how simple becomes complex", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01320-00334732-00335047": "enough to model or provide guidance to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01321-00335048-00335480": "treat a patient or a person", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01322-00335481-00335818": "one other thing I'm not sure how if I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01323-00335819-00336100": "can elaborate the or you know state this", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01324-00336101-00336372": "properly but basically if you're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01325-00336373-00336625": "treating a patient and you can find the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01326-00336626-00336850": "parameters of particular variable -", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01327-00336851-00337096": "trying to tweak that don't cause harm so", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01328-00337097-00337231": "you've got this range in which you're", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01329-00337232-00337342": "pretty sure you're not going to cause", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01330-00337343-00337602": "any harm but yet you have", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01331-00337603-00337873": "no effect there are a lot of people out", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01332-00337874-00338014": "there that say that if you administer a", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01333-00338015-00338236": "therapy and it has no effect that that's", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01334-00338237-00338521": "harm because you've set up an", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01335-00338522-00338746": "expectation that you didn't meet so that", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01336-00338747-00338977": "makes the definition of harm even fuzzy", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01337-00338978-00339282": "at times so I", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01338-00339283-00339484": "think we're kind of winding down", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01339-00339485-00339757": "timewise so if there aren't any more", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01340-00339758-00339904": "questions or comments from the audience", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01341-00339905-00340150": "I'd like to say thank you very much the", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01342-00340151-00340336": "panelists and and thanks once again to", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01343-00340337-00340582": "dr. Anne set for her stellar", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01344-00340583-00340822": "presentation participating in the panel", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01345-00340823-00341074": "and thanks for joining us", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01346-00341075-00342172": "[Applause]", "OTKO6jUqzSc-01347-00342173-00342379": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OUkY68gODbA", "text": {"OUkY68gODbA-00000-00000029-00000582": "foreign", "OUkY68gODbA-00001-00000583-00001015": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00002-00001016-00001312": "good old Melbourne weather yeah", "OUkY68gODbA-00003-00001313-00001469": "it's um", "OUkY68gODbA-00004-00001470-00001847": "what are you gonna do so", "OUkY68gODbA-00005-00001848-00002092": "um g'day everybody thanks for joining me", "OUkY68gODbA-00006-00002093-00002363": "if you're here today if not you can um", "OUkY68gODbA-00007-00002364-00002645": "probably catch this later on so yeah", "OUkY68gODbA-00008-00002646-00002713": "it's it's", "OUkY68gODbA-00009-00002714-00002957": "really cool just about to play a few", "OUkY68gODbA-00010-00002958-00003772": "songs for you today and", "OUkY68gODbA-00011-00003773-00005177": "of a drink or something first", "OUkY68gODbA-00012-00005178-00005447": "so to start off with", "OUkY68gODbA-00013-00005448-00005633": "his first songs", "OUkY68gODbA-00014-00005634-00005801": "um", "OUkY68gODbA-00015-00005802-00006131": "a little bit of um send up with a class", "OUkY68gODbA-00016-00006132-00006304": "system", "OUkY68gODbA-00017-00006305-00006901": "and um this one's called sophisticated", "OUkY68gODbA-00018-00006902-00008167": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00019-00008168-00008359": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00020-00008360-00009155": "maybe I should be annihilated", "OUkY68gODbA-00021-00009156-00009551": "with my mobile phone", "OUkY68gODbA-00022-00009552-00009913": "a classic", "OUkY68gODbA-00023-00009914-00010277": "it's kind of vital sense", "OUkY68gODbA-00024-00010278-00011106": "won't get me anywhere", "OUkY68gODbA-00025-00011107-00011546": "above all of you", "OUkY68gODbA-00026-00011547-00011728": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00027-00011729-00011971": "could be", "OUkY68gODbA-00028-00011972-00012514": "missing something too", "OUkY68gODbA-00029-00012515-00012887": "with my Ralph Lauren", "OUkY68gODbA-00030-00012888-00013355": "cafe latte", "OUkY68gODbA-00031-00013356-00013751": "pretend lifted the lights got not much", "OUkY68gODbA-00032-00013752-00014371": "to say", "OUkY68gODbA-00033-00014372-00014633": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00034-00014634-00015172": "it seems it's black or white", "OUkY68gODbA-00035-00015173-00015538": "variation", "OUkY68gODbA-00036-00015540-00016103": "you can quite just right", "OUkY68gODbA-00037-00016104-00016369": "foreign", "OUkY68gODbA-00038-00016371-00017208": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00039-00017209-00019318": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00040-00019319-00019819": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00041-00019820-00020147": "my hands feel to exist", "OUkY68gODbA-00042-00020148-00021019": "leaving nothing into", "OUkY68gODbA-00043-00021020-00021486": "I'm sophisticated", "OUkY68gODbA-00044-00021487-00022959": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00045-00022960-00023597": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00046-00023598-00023867": "yeah", "OUkY68gODbA-00047-00023868-00024289": "so there we go", "OUkY68gODbA-00048-00024290-00024821": "the ears flying by", "OUkY68gODbA-00049-00024822-00025042": "managed nearly on school holidays", "OUkY68gODbA-00050-00025043-00025283": "sometimes just", "OUkY68gODbA-00051-00025284-00025505": "disappearing into the rear view mirror", "OUkY68gODbA-00052-00025506-00025834": "of life so um", "OUkY68gODbA-00053-00025835-00026273": "and this is a timely song", "OUkY68gODbA-00054-00026274-00026567": "one of my early influences", "OUkY68gODbA-00055-00026568-00026845": "Eric Clapton is having his", "OUkY68gODbA-00056-00026845-00027124": "78th birthday can you believe today and", "OUkY68gODbA-00057-00027125-00027208": "he's", "OUkY68gODbA-00058-00027210-00027485": "still out there touring though", "OUkY68gODbA-00059-00027486-00027635": "um", "OUkY68gODbA-00060-00027636-00027995": "got a new album on the way soon", "OUkY68gODbA-00061-00027995-00028289": "this is one of my songs it's quite", "OUkY68gODbA-00062-00028289-00028487": "inspired him it's called further on off", "OUkY68gODbA-00063-00028488-00029274": "the road", "OUkY68gODbA-00064-00029275-00029633": "further run up the road", "OUkY68gODbA-00065-00029633-00030073": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00066-00030074-00030449": "stop and every drink", "OUkY68gODbA-00067-00030450-00030840": "relax a little while", "OUkY68gODbA-00068-00030841-00031264": "further on a throw", "OUkY68gODbA-00069-00031266-00031643": "a girl I Used to Know", "OUkY68gODbA-00070-00031644-00031951": "came to a love", "OUkY68gODbA-00071-00031952-00032611": "sure was no show", "OUkY68gODbA-00072-00032612-00032962": "in the end", "OUkY68gODbA-00073-00032963-00033343": "too much stuff too bad", "OUkY68gODbA-00074-00033344-00033755": "as well just lose your mind", "OUkY68gODbA-00075-00033756-00034250": "running out of time", "OUkY68gODbA-00076-00034251-00035218": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00077-00035219-00035962": "I didn't match nothing here", "OUkY68gODbA-00078-00035963-00036361": "well it lives there still", "OUkY68gODbA-00079-00036362-00036757": "for the run of the road", "OUkY68gODbA-00080-00036758-00037140": "collecting all the attacks", "OUkY68gODbA-00081-00037141-00037433": "man for what you give", "OUkY68gODbA-00082-00037434-00037787": "don't get much fit back", "OUkY68gODbA-00083-00037788-00038058": "foreign", "OUkY68gODbA-00084-00038059-00040979": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00085-00040980-00041171": "yeah", "OUkY68gODbA-00086-00041172-00041779": "yeah", "OUkY68gODbA-00087-00041780-00042305": "I really need to take a deep", "OUkY68gODbA-00088-00042306-00042461": "breath", "OUkY68gODbA-00089-00042462-00042749": "and so um", "OUkY68gODbA-00090-00042750-00043229": "about six months ago I released a", "OUkY68gODbA-00091-00043230-00043493": "song that's um I think quite important", "OUkY68gODbA-00092-00043494-00043685": "about just", "OUkY68gODbA-00093-00043686-00044008": "trying to get the right balance in life", "OUkY68gODbA-00094-00044009-00044405": "things can go so fast sometimes", "OUkY68gODbA-00095-00044406-00044645": "we can forget that we need to just take", "OUkY68gODbA-00096-00044646-00044807": "a step back", "OUkY68gODbA-00097-00044808-00045240": "foreign", "OUkY68gODbA-00098-00045241-00046093": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00099-00046094-00046685": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00100-00046686-00047251": "I saw you on the morning TV", "OUkY68gODbA-00101-00047252-00047879": "world's best practice gym equipment", "OUkY68gODbA-00102-00047880-00048383": "apart from the dodgy gel in your hair", "OUkY68gODbA-00103-00048384-00048990": "guess you were almost with it", "OUkY68gODbA-00104-00048991-00049511": "it's amazing time and time again", "OUkY68gODbA-00105-00049512-00050074": "how much you can fit in one space", "OUkY68gODbA-00106-00050075-00050317": "I've tried it myself", "OUkY68gODbA-00107-00050318-00050586": "flying first class", "OUkY68gODbA-00108-00050587-00051294": "always falling fat on my face", "OUkY68gODbA-00109-00051295-00051744": "breathe sick of yourself", "OUkY68gODbA-00110-00051745-00052235": "seek out your premiums man", "OUkY68gODbA-00111-00052236-00052482": "foreign", "OUkY68gODbA-00112-00052483-00052871": "try not to think of you well", "OUkY68gODbA-00113-00052872-00053753": "doing the best that you can", "OUkY68gODbA-00114-00053754-00054359": "I caught you out in the midday song", "OUkY68gODbA-00115-00054360-00054875": "one in the four minute mile", "OUkY68gODbA-00116-00054876-00055271": "you said in times of stress you went", "OUkY68gODbA-00117-00055272-00055438": "through", "OUkY68gODbA-00118-00055439-00056053": "and stay there for a while", "OUkY68gODbA-00119-00056054-00056579": "something said let's get ahead", "OUkY68gODbA-00120-00056579-00057173": "you have to be like in and drive", "OUkY68gODbA-00121-00057174-00057742": "either that or instantly dead to give", "OUkY68gODbA-00122-00057744-00058644": "some times to be alive", "OUkY68gODbA-00123-00058645-00059076": "breathe for the sake of the South", "OUkY68gODbA-00124-00059077-00059797": "seek out your premiums man", "OUkY68gODbA-00125-00059798-00060215": "breathe try not to think of you well", "OUkY68gODbA-00126-00060216-00060841": "you're doing the best that you can", "OUkY68gODbA-00127-00060841-00061366": "I could make a man maybe", "OUkY68gODbA-00128-00061367-00061979": "with crazy hair brain schemes", "OUkY68gODbA-00129-00061979-00062494": "said I pause with oxygen on tap it's", "OUkY68gODbA-00130-00062495-00063166": "amazing what appears in dreams", "OUkY68gODbA-00131-00063167-00063382": "okay", "OUkY68gODbA-00132-00063383-00063953": "so you want shop for selling", "OUkY68gODbA-00133-00063954-00064519": "another miracle innovation", "OUkY68gODbA-00134-00064520-00065111": "it's amazing what works here", "OUkY68gODbA-00135-00065112-00065351": "like deeper concentration", "OUkY68gODbA-00136-00065352-00065644": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00137-00065645-00066173": "this room already a few keep on track", "OUkY68gODbA-00138-00066174-00066623": "five bonus could be around the corner", "OUkY68gODbA-00139-00066624-00067300": "foreign", "OUkY68gODbA-00140-00067301-00068005": "ER", "OUkY68gODbA-00141-00068006-00068382": "breathe for the sake of yourself", "OUkY68gODbA-00142-00068383-00069079": "sake of your premiums man", "OUkY68gODbA-00143-00069080-00069521": "breathe try not to think if you will", "OUkY68gODbA-00144-00069522-00070398": "do in the best that you can", "OUkY68gODbA-00145-00070399-00070894": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00146-00070895-00071291": "Just Breathe", "OUkY68gODbA-00147-00071292-00072917": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00148-00072918-00073825": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00149-00073826-00074554": "ah there we go so um", "OUkY68gODbA-00150-00074555-00075634": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00151-00075635-00076223": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00152-00076224-00076619": "sometimes we get stuck in life and um", "OUkY68gODbA-00153-00076620-00076979": "you're in a situation or", "OUkY68gODbA-00154-00076980-00077309": "a place that things not really working", "OUkY68gODbA-00155-00077310-00077494": "for us so", "OUkY68gODbA-00156-00077495-00077819": "this next song's all about that", "OUkY68gODbA-00157-00077820-00078059": "plants we just need to", "OUkY68gODbA-00158-00078060-00080219": "get on down to somewhere better", "OUkY68gODbA-00159-00080220-00081329": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00160-00081330-00081605": "I'm gonna get on down", "OUkY68gODbA-00161-00081606-00081815": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00162-00081816-00082116": "I'm gonna have to lose", "OUkY68gODbA-00163-00082117-00083803": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00164-00083804-00084376": "I think I'm gonna get on now", "OUkY68gODbA-00165-00084377-00084668": "maybe somewhere for the South", "OUkY68gODbA-00166-00084669-00085212": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00167-00085213-00086331": "the correct to escaping coaching down", "OUkY68gODbA-00168-00086332-00086862": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00169-00086863-00087221": "I think I'm gonna get on by", "OUkY68gODbA-00170-00087222-00087385": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00171-00087386-00087988": "there's no time to raise a side", "OUkY68gODbA-00172-00087989-00088178": "before", "OUkY68gODbA-00173-00088179-00088432": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00174-00088433-00088700": "foreign", "OUkY68gODbA-00175-00088701-00091099": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00176-00091100-00091379": "get on down", "OUkY68gODbA-00177-00091380-00091643": "thank you", "OUkY68gODbA-00178-00091644-00092009": "get on down", "OUkY68gODbA-00179-00092010-00092141": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00180-00092142-00092374": "get on down", "OUkY68gODbA-00181-00092375-00093185": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00182-00093186-00093631": "get on down", "OUkY68gODbA-00183-00093632-00094925": "get on down", "OUkY68gODbA-00184-00094926-00095188": "ah there we go", "OUkY68gODbA-00185-00095189-00095453": "did things get a little better and", "OUkY68gODbA-00186-00095454-00095687": "move on to something else", "OUkY68gODbA-00187-00095688-00095915": "like this one which is a", "OUkY68gODbA-00188-00095916-00096161": "song about a", "OUkY68gODbA-00189-00096162-00096473": "bad fashion disaster it's called wrong", "OUkY68gODbA-00190-00096474-00096685": "shoes dear", "OUkY68gODbA-00191-00096686-00097363": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00192-00097364-00098797": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00193-00098798-00099205": "and I know it", "OUkY68gODbA-00194-00099206-00100177": "time is so near so watch be throwing", "OUkY68gODbA-00195-00100178-00101556": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00196-00101557-00101903": "long sock still swear they're not quite", "OUkY68gODbA-00197-00101904-00102179": "the fear", "OUkY68gODbA-00198-00102180-00102497": "and this carries them forever", "OUkY68gODbA-00199-00102498-00102904": "come see", "OUkY68gODbA-00200-00102905-00103336": "nothing fashion with such a passengers I", "OUkY68gODbA-00201-00103338-00103757": "will choose", "OUkY68gODbA-00202-00103758-00104551": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00203-00104552-00104908": "high heels shoes", "OUkY68gODbA-00204-00104908-00106110": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00205-00106111-00106645": "by the times", "OUkY68gODbA-00206-00106646-00106933": "it's running", "OUkY68gODbA-00207-00106934-00108517": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00208-00108518-00108834": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00209-00108835-00109181": "long twist here squirts too stylish for", "OUkY68gODbA-00210-00109182-00109499": "the rest", "OUkY68gODbA-00211-00109500-00109781": "way it is have to always", "OUkY68gODbA-00212-00109782-00110140": "my best", "OUkY68gODbA-00213-00110141-00110447": "nothing fashioned with such a passion", "OUkY68gODbA-00214-00110448-00111303": "those high heels shoes without you", "OUkY68gODbA-00215-00111304-00111421": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00216-00111422-00111778": "loving fashion with such a passion goes", "OUkY68gODbA-00217-00111779-00112309": "high heels shoes without you", "OUkY68gODbA-00218-00112310-00113021": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00219-00113022-00113689": "thank you", "OUkY68gODbA-00220-00113690-00114729": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00221-00114730-00115386": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00222-00115388-00115849": "ah beautiful wonderful Sunny Melbourne", "OUkY68gODbA-00223-00115850-00116099": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00224-00116100-00116327": "see long for winter again but that's", "OUkY68gODbA-00225-00116328-00116477": "okay", "OUkY68gODbA-00226-00116478-00116754": "it's the season that's life", "OUkY68gODbA-00227-00116755-00116982": "go through all these patterns", "OUkY68gODbA-00228-00116983-00117184": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00229-00117185-00117678": "um", "OUkY68gODbA-00230-00117679-00117884": "snake songs", "OUkY68gODbA-00231-00117885-00118201": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00232-00118202-00118769": "about the Perils of materialism and", "OUkY68gODbA-00233-00118770-00118997": "it's getting a little bit too much and", "OUkY68gODbA-00234-00118998-00119110": "um", "OUkY68gODbA-00235-00119111-00119308": "I was actually inspired to write it", "OUkY68gODbA-00236-00119309-00119669": "while listening to her", "OUkY68gODbA-00237-00119670-00119951": "Don Henley album inside job I think it", "OUkY68gODbA-00238-00119952-00120281": "was many years ago this one's called", "OUkY68gODbA-00239-00120282-00120878": "put it down to lust", "OUkY68gODbA-00240-00120879-00121704": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00241-00121705-00122207": "never noticed how the world likes", "OUkY68gODbA-00242-00122208-00122921": "to drop its arms around its loved ones", "OUkY68gODbA-00243-00122922-00123323": "keeping its interest close to its chest", "OUkY68gODbA-00244-00123324-00123523": "like a salad", "OUkY68gODbA-00245-00123524-00124115": "circling around the Sun", "OUkY68gODbA-00246-00124116-00124430": "can see lines so clear", "OUkY68gODbA-00247-00124431-00124615": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00248-00124616-00125031": "been throughout all history", "OUkY68gODbA-00249-00125032-00125213": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00250-00125214-00125728": "rich and Polished English veneer", "OUkY68gODbA-00251-00125729-00126130": "and without its own Mystery", "OUkY68gODbA-00252-00126131-00127033": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00253-00127033-00127513": "put it down to lust haven't you ruined", "OUkY68gODbA-00254-00127514-00128149": "everyone's asking for more and more", "OUkY68gODbA-00255-00128150-00128590": "put it down to lust it's a new cat's", "OUkY68gODbA-00256-00128591-00129050": "world and even reflection is the store", "OUkY68gODbA-00257-00129051-00129352": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00258-00129353-00129564": "please", "OUkY68gODbA-00259-00129565-00130764": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00260-00130765-00131404": "haven't noticed how the world lights", "OUkY68gODbA-00261-00131405-00131839": "ever noticed Italian dog", "OUkY68gODbA-00262-00131840-00132066": "gets pushed under", "OUkY68gODbA-00263-00132067-00132593": "multinational speed", "OUkY68gODbA-00264-00132594-00132964": "so many variables in the program", "OUkY68gODbA-00265-00132965-00133349": "the surprise were you rush out chicken", "OUkY68gODbA-00266-00133350-00133584": "feet", "OUkY68gODbA-00267-00133585-00133925": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00268-00133926-00134098": "lines so clear", "OUkY68gODbA-00269-00134099-00134302": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00270-00134303-00134643": "written in all prayers", "OUkY68gODbA-00271-00134644-00134890": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00272-00134891-00135275": "woman praise and maker we're all drawn", "OUkY68gODbA-00273-00135276-00135377": "too", "OUkY68gODbA-00274-00135378-00135865": "now without its own mixed success", "OUkY68gODbA-00275-00135866-00136397": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00276-00136398-00136675": "put it down to lust", "OUkY68gODbA-00277-00136676-00136861": "habitual", "OUkY68gODbA-00278-00136862-00137229": "everyone's asking for more and more", "OUkY68gODbA-00279-00137230-00138037": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00280-00138038-00138374": "for luxuries to store", "OUkY68gODbA-00281-00138375-00138863": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00282-00138864-00139163": "what's the devil's so proudly kind of", "OUkY68gODbA-00283-00139164-00139421": "not all these new recruiters", "OUkY68gODbA-00284-00139422-00139819": "see them all around you", "OUkY68gODbA-00285-00139820-00140044": "my chance you", "OUkY68gODbA-00286-00140045-00141521": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00287-00141522-00142649": "ever noticed how the sideshow happens", "OUkY68gODbA-00288-00142650-00142943": "she believe beats it down the signs out", "OUkY68gODbA-00289-00142944-00143136": "of you", "OUkY68gODbA-00290-00143137-00143269": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00291-00143270-00143995": "think of opportunity ways", "OUkY68gODbA-00292-00143996-00144419": "see lines so clear", "OUkY68gODbA-00293-00144420-00144760": "we're natural", "OUkY68gODbA-00294-00144761-00145078": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00295-00145079-00145468": "woman pressing make it withdrawn too", "OUkY68gODbA-00296-00145469-00145609": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00297-00145610-00145933": "unfold that highlight", "OUkY68gODbA-00298-00145934-00146827": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00299-00146828-00147343": "put it down to Lost haven't you heard", "OUkY68gODbA-00300-00147344-00147722": "everyone's asking for more and more", "OUkY68gODbA-00301-00147723-00148277": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00302-00148278-00148554": "catch wood", "OUkY68gODbA-00303-00148555-00148995": "luxuries to store", "OUkY68gODbA-00304-00148996-00149352": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00305-00149353-00149593": "haven't you", "OUkY68gODbA-00306-00149594-00150086": "everyone's asking for more and more", "OUkY68gODbA-00307-00150087-00150731": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00308-00150732-00151027": "luxury", "OUkY68gODbA-00309-00151028-00151987": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00310-00151988-00152357": "can't take it with you", "OUkY68gODbA-00311-00152358-00152633": "this next songs", "OUkY68gODbA-00312-00152634-00153040": "about moving in the right direction", "OUkY68gODbA-00313-00153041-00153314": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00314-00153315-00154751": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00315-00154752-00155286": "to needs a bit more something", "OUkY68gODbA-00316-00155287-00157723": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00317-00157724-00158071": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00318-00158072-00158297": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00319-00158298-00158725": "to spend much to shoot", "OUkY68gODbA-00320-00158726-00159062": "I've been broken down not soon", "OUkY68gODbA-00321-00159063-00159289": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00322-00159290-00159603": "sing a different tune", "OUkY68gODbA-00323-00159604-00160140": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00324-00160141-00160633": "so much for the big picture", "OUkY68gODbA-00325-00160634-00161042": "cause the intent wasn't so focused", "OUkY68gODbA-00326-00161043-00161190": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00327-00161191-00161454": "so much for the big picture", "OUkY68gODbA-00328-00161455-00161740": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00329-00161741-00162216": "kiss the colors they don't match", "OUkY68gODbA-00330-00162217-00162604": "I have to go back to the drawing board", "OUkY68gODbA-00331-00162605-00162793": "again", "OUkY68gODbA-00332-00162794-00163068": "try another track", "OUkY68gODbA-00333-00163069-00163771": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00334-00163772-00164098": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00335-00164099-00165331": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00336-00165332-00165643": "missing with my mind", "OUkY68gODbA-00337-00165644-00166223": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00338-00166224-00166654": "much for the grandest gesture", "OUkY68gODbA-00339-00166655-00167190": "cause the intent wasn't so focused", "OUkY68gODbA-00340-00167191-00167541": "have to go back to the egg again", "OUkY68gODbA-00341-00167542-00167731": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00342-00167732-00168247": "hope that no one noticed", "OUkY68gODbA-00343-00168248-00168721": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00344-00168722-00169024": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00345-00169025-00169207": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00346-00169208-00169747": "you just left too early", "OUkY68gODbA-00347-00169748-00169969": "broken down", "OUkY68gODbA-00348-00169970-00170275": "Twisted", "OUkY68gODbA-00349-00170276-00170596": "expected going surely", "OUkY68gODbA-00350-00170597-00171097": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00351-00171098-00171436": "so much for the big picture", "OUkY68gODbA-00352-00171437-00171625": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00353-00171626-00171889": "so much for", "OUkY68gODbA-00354-00171890-00172645": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00355-00172646-00173570": "so much for the big picture", "OUkY68gODbA-00356-00173571-00175207": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00357-00175208-00175509": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00358-00175510-00176254": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00359-00176255-00176546": "broken down a lot soon", "OUkY68gODbA-00360-00176547-00176743": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00361-00176744-00177047": "sing a different tune", "OUkY68gODbA-00362-00177048-00177637": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00363-00177638-00177902": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00364-00177903-00178204": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00365-00178205-00178389": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00366-00178390-00178666": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00367-00178667-00178967": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00368-00178968-00179190": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00369-00179191-00179389": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00370-00179390-00179740": "[Music]", "OUkY68gODbA-00371-00179741-00180340": "where you think you're going", "OUkY68gODbA-00372-00180341-00180710": "on the hands but"}}, {"audio_id": "OUCq2NL2n8I", "text": {"OUCq2NL2n8I-00000-00000043-00000280": "following as a table of United States", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00001-00000281-00000463": "presidential elections in New Jersey", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00002-00000465-00000782": "ordered by year since its admission to", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00003-00000783-00001045": "statehood in 1787 New Jersey has", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00004-00001046-00001286": "participated in every US presidential", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00005-00001287-00001544": "election winners of the state are in", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00006-00001545-00002062": "bold", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00007-00002063-00002787": "topic elections from 1864 to present", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00008-00002788-00003158": "you", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00009-00003159-00003792": "topic election of 1860", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00010-00003793-00004077": "the election of 1860 was a complex", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00011-00004078-00004245": "realigning election in which the", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00012-00004246-00004422": "breakdown of the previous two-party", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00013-00004423-00004614": "alignment culminated in four parties", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00014-00004615-00004779": "each competing for influence in", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00015-00004780-00005001": "different parts of the country the", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00016-00005002-00005178": "result of the election with the victory", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00017-00005179-00005394": "of an ardent opponent of slavery spurred", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00018-00005395-00005592": "the secession of 11 states and brought", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00019-00005593-00005859": "about the American Civil War New", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00020-00005860-00006057": "Jersey's electoral vote was split with", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00021-00006058-00006255": "four of the electors pledged to Lincoln", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00022-00006256-00006434": "being elected because the alternative", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00023-00006436-00006636": "effusion ticket of electors supporting", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00024-00006637-00006822": "other candidates saw the Breckinridge", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00025-00006823-00006995": "and Bell electors finished behind all", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00026-00006997-00007170": "other candidates and three Douglas", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00027-00007170-00007798": "electors being elected", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00028-00007798-00008609": "topic elections from 1828 to 1856", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00029-00008610-00008983": "you", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00030-00008984-00009638": "topic election of 1824", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00031-00009639-00009941": "the election of 1824 was a complex", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00032-00009942-00010118": "realigning election following the", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00033-00010119-00010301": "collapse of the prevailing Democratic", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00034-00010302-00010505": "Republican Party resulting in four", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00035-00010506-00010691": "different candidates each claiming to", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00036-00010692-00010838": "carry the banner of the party and", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00037-00010839-00011021": "competing for influence in different", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00038-00011022-00011264": "parts of the country the election was", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00039-00011265-00011477": "the only one in history to be decided by", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00040-00011478-00011654": "the House of Representatives under the", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00041-00011655-00011837": "provisions of the 12th amendment to the", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00042-00011838-00012053": "United States Constitution after no", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00043-00012054-00012236": "candidate secured a majority of the", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00044-00012237-00012496": "electoral vote it was also the only", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00045-00012497-00012671": "presidential election in which the", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00046-00012672-00012866": "candidate who received a plurality of", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00047-00012866-00013099": "electoral votes Andrew Jackson did not", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00048-00013100-00013283": "become president a source of great", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00049-00013284-00013430": "bitterness for Jackson and his", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00050-00013431-00013604": "supporters who proclaimed the election", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00051-00013605-00014250": "of Adams a corrupt bargain", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00052-00014251-00015113": "topic elections from 1788 to 89 to 1820", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00053-00015113-00015388": "in the election of 1820 incumbent", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00054-00015390-00015608": "President James Monroe ran effectively", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00055-00015609-00015785": "unopposed winning all eight of New", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00056-00015786-00015971": "Jersey's electoral votes and all", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00057-00015972-00016184": "electoral votes nationwide except one", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00058-00016185-00016457": "vote in New Hampshire to the extent that", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00059-00016458-00016685": "a popular vote was held it was primarily", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00060-00016686-00016868": "directed to filling the office of Vice", "OUCq2NL2n8I-00061-00016869-00017129": "President"}}, {"audio_id": "OUMGNQ4CZv4", "text": {"OUMGNQ4CZv4-00000-00000000-00000621": "you", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00001-00000622-00002274": "you", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00002-00002275-00002766": "hello let's let's have a look at Unicode", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00003-00002767-00003714": "and utf-8 so if it works okay so in the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00004-00003715-00003981": "beginning it was chaos there was there", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00005-00003982-00004197": "were several different way to encode", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00006-00004198-00004396": "characters about the CR but they were", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00007-00004397-00004872": "actually used for example very funny one", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00008-00004873-00005242": "was the baudot code which was five bits", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00009-00005243-00005607": "that means that it was stateful so there", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00010-00005608-00005878": "was a special code to switch to for", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00011-00005879-00006174": "example numbers instead of letters", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00012-00006175-00006821": "the famous ebcdic from from from IBM and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00013-00006822-00007306": "then ASCII 7-bit which was actually", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00014-00007306-00007796": "considered pretty modern by the time", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00015-00007797-00008010": "obviously with seven bits you cannot do", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00016-00008011-00008419": "that match the idea of putting both", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00017-00008420-00008760": "uppercase and lowercase letters in the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00018-00008761-00009273": "same code where I was already considered", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00019-00009274-00009867": "innovative so yeah it was not that nice", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00020-00009868-00010035": "so they decided to make it worse so", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00021-00010036-00010248": "basically okay ASCII we have the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00022-00010249-00010477": "standard English alphabets what about", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00023-00010478-00010764": "other alphabets which require more", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00024-00010765-00011073": "letters so the invented this thing", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00025-00011074-00011313": "called code pages so basically you would", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00026-00011314-00011556": "use 8 bits instead of 7 and you would", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00027-00011557-00012108": "used a higher part of the code space for", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00028-00012109-00012585": "the special characters this means that", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00029-00012586-00013027": "the same code would represent you", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00030-00013028-00013228": "different special characters depending", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00031-00013229-00013546": "on the character set used by the person", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00032-00013547-00013944": "receiving the text and of course you", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00033-00013945-00014221": "anybody could only use one set of", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00034-00014222-00014440": "special characters at a time you could", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00035-00014441-00014701": "never mix up for example of a character", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00036-00014702-00014950": "only found in one special character set", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00037-00014951-00015199": "like for example the German a set with I", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00038-00015200-00015322": "don't know Russian", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00039-00015322-00015919": "later so minimize in Japan they had", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00040-00015919-00016225": "Jesus and shift jeez so basically they", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00041-00016226-00016513": "could represent multiple alphabets at", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00042-00016514-00016830": "the same time they could represent all", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00043-00016831-00017221": "the official Japanese kanjis characters", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00044-00017222-00017725": "could be one or two bytes long they had", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00045-00017726-00018078": "a first first code page basically a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00046-00018079-00018330": "first code to represent just the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00047-00018331-00018708": "syllabic character and then they", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00048-00018709-00018897": "extended it to represent and that was", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00049-00018898-00019144": "and there one byte was enough and then", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00050-00019145-00019399": "they extended it to represent everything", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00051-00019400-00019764": "else and then they needed more of course", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00052-00019765-00020128": "the funny thing is that there was no way", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00053-00020129-00020331": "to know if a given byte was a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00054-00020332-00020655": "continuation of a longer character or", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00055-00020656-00020811": "the start of a new character so in case", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00056-00020812-00021025": "of errors or if you needed to search", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00057-00021026-00021547": "backwards you were screwed basically and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00058-00021548-00021930": "so it did only represent a subset of all", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00059-00021931-00022237": "of all the alphabets used in the world", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00060-00022238-00022755": "anyway so yeah let's make a new standard", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00061-00022756-00023158": "right let's let's make a new standard", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00062-00023159-00023655": "that covers everyone's use cases certain", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00063-00023656-00024130": "invented Unicode so the idea is okay", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00064-00024131-00024594": "let's represent abstract a characters", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00065-00024595-00024930": "with abstract numbers let's cover all", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00066-00024931-00025303": "the languages yeah sixteen bits are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00067-00025304-00025671": "enough right and it seems to be", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00068-00025672-00026014": "something cool so everybody implements", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00069-00026014-00026433": "it or well everybody most the most", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00070-00026434-00026694": "influent at the time companies and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00071-00026695-00027114": "suddenly a so now but implemented so", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00072-00027116-00027364": "that's why you find that for example in", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00073-00027364-00027625": "Java characters are sixteen bits in", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00074-00027626-00028213": "Windows characters are 16 bits the white", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00075-00028214-00028427": "character anyway", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00076-00028429-00028926": "yeah oh wait 16 bits are not enough", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00077-00028927-00029292": "let's expand it afterwards so let's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00078-00029293-00029463": "expand it to 2 this comic number it's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00079-00029464-00030214": "not even a power of 2 it's 17 times 64 K", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00080-00030216-00030600": "so basically 2 bytes are not enough", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00081-00030601-00031208": "anyway so as of now version 6.1 defines", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00082-00031210-00032139": "a 110,000 181 character yeah so that's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00083-00032139-00032469": "why it never works", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00084-00032470-00032751": "no there is more I will not talk too", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00085-00032752-00033042": "much about all that stuff I will just", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00086-00033043-00033450": "say that there is a specific there are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00087-00033451-00033645": "specific rules in the Unicode standard", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00088-00033646-00033867": "so it the unica standard is not just a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00089-00033868-00034140": "set of characters there are so specific", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00090-00034141-00034386": "rules for example for collation so how", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00091-00034387-00034704": "to sort characters depending also on the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00092-00034705-00035454": "locale for example the lowercase I has", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00093-00035455-00035721": "different uppercase versions depending", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00094-00035722-00035940": "for example if the locale is Turkish", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00095-00035941-00036273": "then the uppercase I is the uppercase I", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00096-00036274-00036588": "with the dot above and the lowercase of", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00097-00036589-00036924": "the standard I is the lowercase I", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00098-00036925-00037107": "without the dot because that's the way", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00099-00037108-00037296": "it's work in turn in Turkish so you need", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00100-00037297-00037656": "to properly take care of that then", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00101-00037657-00037953": "complex capitalization rules case", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00102-00037954-00038480": "mapping and case folding so things like", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00103-00038481-00038700": "the same letter has two different", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00104-00038701-00038949": "uppercase variations depending if the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00105-00038950-00039189": "thing is full uppercase like in the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00106-00039190-00039357": "middle of a text or if it's the first", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00107-00039358-00039624": "letter which is uppercase and the rest", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00108-00039625-00039981": "is not uppercase and case folding like", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00109-00039982-00040356": "you search for something and you want to", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00110-00040357-00040598": "write for example the German s set and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00111-00040599-00041328": "you want it to match also SS then you", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00112-00041329-00041565": "can compose characters there are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00113-00041566-00041811": "specific characters that are just", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00114-00041812-00042192": "modifier so accents for example that are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00115-00042193-00042458": "supposed to be put over other characters", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00116-00042459-00042746": "there are specific rules on how to", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00117-00042747-00043023": "compose which letters which characters", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00118-00043024-00043449": "together and which is the resulting", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00119-00043450-00043674": "character sometimes there is a resulting", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00120-00043675-00043865": "characteristic that is pretty composed", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00121-00043866-00044240": "and how to compose back so if you have a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00122-00044241-00044400": "specific character", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00123-00044401-00044880": "with accent how to get the accent and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00124-00044881-00045237": "the base character to compose it back so", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00125-00045238-00045648": "ligatures like f i the the the thing", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00126-00045649-00046074": "that always works in for example in", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00127-00046075-00046317": "logic its also defined in unicode and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00128-00046318-00046527": "the fact that that's actually an F and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00129-00046528-00046805": "an I so again like case mapping", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00130-00046806-00047243": "right-to-left and stuff like that", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00131-00047244-00047529": "one thing which is quite important is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00132-00047530-00047873": "that the Unicode standard does not", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00133-00047874-00048336": "define glyphs so not does not define how", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00134-00048337-00048705": "the character appears but only the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00135-00048706-00048908": "abstract character being represented and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00136-00048909-00049137": "if you want a different representation", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00137-00049138-00049577": "you use a different font so for example", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00138-00049578-00050150": "here you see the same character twice", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00139-00050151-00050715": "well four characters twice one is the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00140-00050716-00050943": "Japanese version and that is the Chinese", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00141-00050944-00051195": "version but it's the same number because", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00142-00051196-00051466": "it represents the same idea the same", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00143-00051467-00051864": "it's the same character it's the same", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00144-00051865-00052647": "yep which is kind of forms because it", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00145-00052648-00052899": "was all kind of drama resulting from", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00146-00052900-00053330": "that like Japanese and Chinese people", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00147-00053332-00053637": "insulting the Westerners because they", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00148-00053638-00053862": "don't understand how it works really", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00149-00053863-00054119": "well let's not talk about this because", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00150-00054120-00054279": "it is really funny especially", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00151-00054279-00054491": "considering that it was a bunch of", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00152-00054492-00054738": "Japanese Korean and Chinese people who", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00153-00054739-00054967": "did that in the first place", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00154-00054969-00055146": "yep", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00155-00055147-00055655": "so we have abstract characters and we", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00156-00055657-00055995": "have numbers the code point is the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00157-00055996-00056316": "abstract number that identifies the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00158-00056316-00056733": "abstract character the representation is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00159-00056734-00057122": "how do we represent this abstract number", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00160-00057123-00057905": "so it's it's not straightforward that's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00161-00057907-00058304": "why we have all these funny things so", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00162-00058304-00058616": "the base case is okay we have this", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00163-00058617-00059040": "number we put I don't know 32 bits and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00164-00059041-00059310": "we put the number inside that's it okay", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00165-00059311-00059610": "that's utf-32 you need 4 bytes per", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00166-00059611-00059823": "character which is quite a waste", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00167-00059824-00060123": "especially considering that you will", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00168-00060124-00060363": "never need more than 21 bits anyway", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00169-00060364-00060944": "because that's the the maximum amount", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00170-00060945-00061416": "that's the defined so far better side", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00171-00061416-00061770": "forward you have fixed length every", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00172-00061771-00061973": "character is has the same length", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00173-00061974-00062469": "everybody's happy then you have utf-16", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00174-00062470-00063054": "which is basically a legacy we we have", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00175-00063054-00063554": "from the from version 1.0 when", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00176-00063554-00064287": "everything was only 16 bit long and so", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00177-00064288-00064587": "well they discovered they decided", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00178-00064588-00064827": "afterwards that they needed more so they", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00179-00064828-00065216": "needed to somehow handle the fact that", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00180-00065217-00065586": "so much software was around using 2", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00181-00065587-00066237": "bytes characters instead of 4 so they'd", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00182-00066238-00066416": "invented this standard which I will not", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00183-00066417-00066657": "cover now I will just say that basically", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00184-00066658-00066959": "every character in the base in the basic", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00185-00066960-00067689": "plane so the first 64,000 characters are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00186-00067690-00068054": "represented with a single 16-bit", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00187-00068055-00068325": "sequence and all the others are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00188-00068326-00068500": "represented with", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00189-00068501-00068884": "two of those 16 with sequences so 32", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00190-00068885-00069433": "bits again and then we have utf-8 which", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00191-00069434-00069865": "is the thing everybody should have been", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00192-00069866-00070213": "using since the beginning anyway how", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00193-00070214-00070279": "does it work", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00194-00070280-00070636": "basically the representation is exactly", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00195-00070637-00071305": "like that if the first bit of a byte is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00196-00071306-00071694": "zero then the remaining seven bits are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00197-00071695-00072310": "the code point which means that a ski so", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00198-00072311-00072801": "7-bit ascii is also valid utf-8 and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00199-00072802-00073531": "misha versa so you can take legacy", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00200-00073532-00073827": "programs that don't understand utf-8 and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00201-00073828-00074062": "give them I mean it don't understand", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00202-00074063-00074404": "Unicode and give them utf-8 input if", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00203-00074405-00074653": "it's in still in the ASCII version it's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00204-00074654-00074854": "exactly the same representation which is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00205-00074855-00074961": "nice", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00206-00074962-00075490": "then there are disorder representations", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00207-00075491-00075664": "for all the rest of the characters", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00208-00075665-00075952": "basically works like that before to be", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00209-00075953-00076303": "they are set to the first the first bits", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00210-00076304-00076786": "are set to one there is exactly as many", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00211-00076787-00077176": "bits set to one as long is that the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00212-00077177-00077419": "sequence so in this case cube it's 31", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00213-00077420-00077638": "and that's 0 to 2 mark the end of the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00214-00077639-00077872": "sequence of the marker sequence and then", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00215-00077873-00078232": "the rest of the bits is used for the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00216-00078233-00078445": "value of the code point and then all the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00217-00078446-00078696": "continuation bytes are marked with a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00218-00078697-00079081": "sequence 1 0 which means hey I am the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00219-00079082-00079398": "continuation of a multiplied sequence", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00220-00079399-00079879": "this means that in any case no character", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00221-00079880-00080158": "is represented with more than four bytes", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00222-00080159-00080551": "anyway and actually most characters in", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00223-00080552-00081040": "the base plan plane are represented with", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00224-00081041-00081511": "two or three bytes in any case neighbor", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00225-00081512-00081972": "for", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00226-00081973-00082735": "this this is very nice now let's see of", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00227-00082736-00082987": "course you could argue that you could", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00228-00082988-00083335": "use four bytes to represent a low", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00229-00083336-00083712": "character no it's forbidden", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00230-00083713-00083976": "the only legal sequences are the one", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00231-00083977-00084381": "with the least number of bits all the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00232-00084382-00084588": "sequences are other sequences are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00233-00084589-00084781": "illegal or should be there are some", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00234-00084782-00085096": "exploits because somebody didn't put", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00235-00085097-00085509": "checks and so basically some web servers", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00236-00085510-00085954": "let you put dot dot slash and so on", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00237-00085955-00086734": "because yeah okay so why is it so nice", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00238-00086735-00087046": "okay first it represents all of Unicode", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00239-00087047-00087541": "yeah okay it's backwards compatible with", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00240-00087542-00087813": "ASCII because okay in case of ASCII it's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00241-00087814-00088213": "just askew but in case of high", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00242-00088214-00088688": "characters so anything above 100 127 a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00243-00088689-00088888": "Legacy Program might not know that", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00244-00088889-00089230": "that's a single character but it will", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00245-00089231-00089686": "any any any way handle it the byte 0 is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00246-00089687-00089866": "guaranteed not to appear in any sequence", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00247-00089867-00090328": "so new Terminator strings still work so", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00248-00090329-00090675": "you legacy programs don't don't really", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00249-00090676-00091063": "don't have to worry about it it's very", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00250-00091064-00091288": "easy to scan bat forwards and backwards", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00251-00091289-00091743": "because you know you easily know when a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00252-00091744-00091968": "byte is the beginning of the sequence", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00253-00091969-00092382": "you easily know when a byte is the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00254-00092383-00092671": "continuation of a sequence so you can", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00255-00092672-00092863": "discover if there is some corruption", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00256-00092864-00093148": "going on if the pipe if the character", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00257-00093149-00093600": "should be longer because it's a little 5", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00258-00093601-00094180": "4 4 bytes and you get another beginning", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00259-00094181-00094390": "of character in the middle then you know", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00260-00094391-00094650": "that something's gone wrong you can", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00261-00094651-00094784": "recover", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00262-00094785-00095206": "if if you get random continuation around", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00263-00095207-00095336": "you know that something's come from", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00264-00095337-00095518": "somewhere because this should not happen", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00265-00095519-00096035": "and if you scan backwards you know where", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00266-00096036-00096481": "to stop because yeah if as long as you", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00267-00096482-00096706": "just go backwards as long as you get", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00268-00096707-00096880": "continuation when you find the beginning", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00269-00096881-00097180": "also since the length of the character", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00270-00097181-00097460": "is determined in the first byte you also", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00271-00097461-00097946": "know how to skip forwards when looking", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00272-00097947-00098192": "for a given character for example if you", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00273-00098193-00098378": "know if you see that character is four", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00274-00098379-00098555": "bytes long than you for the next", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00275-00098556-00098780": "character you just keep forward four", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00276-00098781-00099359": "bytes for example okay sometimes UTF", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00277-00099360-00099544": "representation of characters are bigger", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00278-00099545-00099665": "one byte", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00279-00099666-00100046": "then utf-16 that's necessary because of", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00280-00100047-00100456": "how its represented so some some", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00281-00100457-00100975": "characters are represented with three", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00282-00100976-00101237": "bytes instead of the two need for utf-16", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00283-00101238-00101550": "but I think that the disadvantages are", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00284-00101551-00101788": "not so big compared to the advantages", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00285-00101789-00103901": "you have questions why did they water", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00286-00103902-00104174": "yes that's my - just making this very", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00287-00104175-00104368": "advanced education why did they actually", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00288-00104369-00104702": "waste some waste supply at the second", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00289-00104703-00104908": "world why didn't they just say okay if", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00290-00104909-00105176": "there's one at the first at the first", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00291-00105177-00105374": "time then is obviously a sequence why", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00292-00105375-00105683": "the one zero why didn't they went they", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00293-00105683-00106013": "waste like two bites on", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00294-00106014-00106471": "each line with two bits sorry", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00295-00106472-00106754": "why don't why don't they say okay we", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00296-00106755-00106960": "always have if there's a multi byte", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00297-00106961-00107267": "sequence we always put first one to one", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00298-00107268-00107633": "and then we have line zero zero if it's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00299-00107633-00107911": "a two point one zero one zero one it is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00300-00107913-00108383": "a three five one four one one zero four", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00301-00108383-00108767": "four five one and so on and so forth we", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00302-00108768-00109088": "don't why they wasted it yeah because", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00303-00109089-00109445": "because because how do you actually do", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00304-00109446-00109721": "that then I mean if the first bit is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00305-00109722-00110069": "zero then it's the remaining seven bits", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00306-00110070-00110291": "are ASCII then okay in that's in this", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00307-00110292-00110632": "okay then you must start with one right", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00308-00110633-00110942": "angles then how do then if you have one", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00309-00110943-00111107": "then what do you what do you want to put", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00310-00111108-00111428": "a zero no that's a continuation yes", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00311-00111429-00111515": "that's the point", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00312-00111516-00111677": "why don't they why don't they put it", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00313-00111678-00111872": "that way we could all we will just say", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00314-00111873-00112094": "okay the first defines if it's a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00315-00112095-00112289": "multi sequence or not avoiding okay okay", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00316-00112290-00112598": "so zero means lower body sequence and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00317-00112599-00112778": "one means we have more the sequence okay", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00318-00112779-00113027": "if we then define okay the first the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00319-00113028-00113207": "first byte that we received with one", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00320-00113208-00113533": "seven the next two bits so pitch number", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00321-00113534-00113930": "two and three are four how many are in", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00322-00113931-00114211": "the normal bit representation how many", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00323-00114213-00114586": "sequences are following so instead of", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00324-00114588-00114926": "having of wasting one byte with a one", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00325-00114927-00115199": "bit with the true by definition and then", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00326-00115200-00115325": "and then how do you know with", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00327-00115326-00115547": "thirty-fifth if the bite is a the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00328-00115548-00115733": "beginnings of the points they have their", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00329-00115733-00115928": "differencing they were differentiating", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00330-00115929-00116174": "between at the sacrifice they have two", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00331-00116175-00116264": "one zero", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00332-00116265-00116453": "yes that's a continuation right yes it's", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00333-00116454-00116594": "a continuation that's right but the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00334-00116595-00116855": "point is that if we have an error in it", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00335-00116856-00117275": "and we for example from emojis from a", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00336-00117276-00117685": "multi sequence definition we lose the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00337-00117686-00117998": "first byte do some yeah connection", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00338-00117999-00118274": "problem yeah then the argument was okay", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00339-00118275-00118405": "now that we have the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00340-00118406-00118584": "I invite we know that there's one zero", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00341-00118585-00118840": "always a continuation so obviously we", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00342-00118841-00119077": "lost something so this current character", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00343-00119078-00119440": "is lost into some reason I think that if", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00344-00119441-00119725": "this character is lost then it should be", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00345-00119726-00120022": "okay to just have a moody sequence by it", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00346-00120023-00120183": "and just kill this complete body", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00347-00120184-00120399": "sequence by so the continuation", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00348-00120400-00120688": "definition is actually not necessary in", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00349-00120689-00120963": "my opinion", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00350-00120964-00121153": "where should we differentiate between", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00351-00121154-00121383": "the start of the movie sequence by which", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00352-00121384-00121606": "we could lose or the continuation which", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00353-00121607-00121825": "we could use as well the old logic by", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00354-00121826-00122040": "character is lost if all elements", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00355-00122041-00122224": "configuration you can have a pattern", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00356-00122225-00122491": "which indicates the start or the new", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00357-00122492-00122848": "sequence so in your approach you said", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00358-00122849-00123033": "that if you lose the beginning of the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00359-00123034-00123163": "sequence you would just delete the whole", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00360-00123164-00123325": "sequence when Walia see whole text", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00361-00123326-00123502": "consists of sequences in Japanese for", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00362-00123503-00123984": "example there is still text okay also", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00363-00123985-00124123": "that that's the second point", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00364-00124124-00124359": "let's the key point of utf-8 if you if", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00365-00124360-00124509": "you lose something you can always", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00366-00124510-00124761": "continue successfully to make all the", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00367-00124763-00125005": "text the I didn't think that there", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00368-00125006-00125179": "should that there could be actually more", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00369-00125180-00125452": "than what level sequence 5 yeah and", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00370-00125453-00125626": "there are tax in which most of it is", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00371-00125627-00125821": "multi sequence and yeah for example", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00372-00125822-00126025": "think something within reduction for", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00373-00126026-00126307": "example with or we don't be a to buy", "OUMGNQ4CZv4-00374-00126308-00126895": "sequence because it's not okay"}}, {"audio_id": "OUW76IgjieA", "text": {"OUW76IgjieA-00000-00000093-00001088": "[Music]", "OUW76IgjieA-00001-00001089-00001646": "[Applause]", "OUW76IgjieA-00002-00001647-00001962": "so in the previous classes we have", "OUW76IgjieA-00003-00001963-00002291": "discussed in detail that that product", "OUW76IgjieA-00004-00002292-00002487": "operator formalism for describing", "OUW76IgjieA-00005-00002488-00002790": "density operator evolution through an", "OUW76IgjieA-00006-00002791-00003363": "NMR experiment and we have seen how it", "OUW76IgjieA-00007-00003364-00003815": "becomes easier to use this formalism for", "OUW76IgjieA-00008-00003817-00004238": "analyzing the NMR experiments explicitly", "OUW76IgjieA-00009-00004239-00004556": "we considered the spin echo in the", "OUW76IgjieA-00010-00004557-00004918": "previous classes and I am going to", "OUW76IgjieA-00011-00004919-00005152": "exchange this further", "OUW76IgjieA-00012-00005153-00005631": "describe to you one more experiment as", "OUW76IgjieA-00013-00005632-00006152": "an example and that is the inept inept", "OUW76IgjieA-00014-00006153-00006470": "stands for insensitive nuclear", "OUW76IgjieA-00015-00006472-00006890": "enhancement by polarization transfer", "OUW76IgjieA-00016-00006891-00007131": "this experiment has actually been", "OUW76IgjieA-00017-00007131-00007419": "described to you in the previous classes", "OUW76IgjieA-00018-00007420-00007823": "by Professor Ashutosh Kumar and this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00019-00007825-00008004": "the polarization transfer experiment", "OUW76IgjieA-00020-00008005-00008280": "where the magnetization is transferred", "OUW76IgjieA-00021-00008281-00008724": "from proton to an insensitive nucleus", "OUW76IgjieA-00022-00008725-00009180": "like carbon 13 or nitrogen 15 so here I", "OUW76IgjieA-00023-00009181-00009632": "will consider proton and carbon 13 here", "OUW76IgjieA-00024-00009633-00009924": "to see how the polarization or", "OUW76IgjieA-00025-00009925-00010140": "magnetization gets transferred from the", "OUW76IgjieA-00026-00010141-00010455": "proton to the carbon and we detect the", "OUW76IgjieA-00027-00010456-00010896": "carbon so the full sequence for this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00028-00010897-00011265": "shown here so on the proton channel you", "OUW76IgjieA-00029-00011266-00011595": "apply these pulses you have a 90 X", "OUW76IgjieA-00030-00011596-00011955": "followed by tau and then you have a", "OUW76IgjieA-00031-00011956-00012270": "180-degree pulse which is applied", "OUW76IgjieA-00032-00012271-00012579": "simultaneously on both proton and the", "OUW76IgjieA-00033-00012580-00012816": "carbon channels then you have another", "OUW76IgjieA-00034-00012816-00013203": "time period tau and which is followed by", "OUW76IgjieA-00035-00013204-00013430": "a 90 degree pulse", "OUW76IgjieA-00036-00013431-00013713": "on proton channel and a 90-degree pulse", "OUW76IgjieA-00037-00013713-00014072": "on the carbon channel and this is the F", "OUW76IgjieA-00038-00014073-00014642": "ID notice here you'll have to be careful", "OUW76IgjieA-00039-00014643-00014948": "with regard to the phases of the pulses", "OUW76IgjieA-00040-00014949-00015362": "here it is a 90 X pulse this is the 180", "OUW76IgjieA-00041-00015363-00015633": "this can be X or Y doesn't matter but", "OUW76IgjieA-00042-00015634-00015924": "this has to be Y if this is X this has", "OUW76IgjieA-00043-00015925-00016319": "to be Y parts this can be X or Y doesn't", "OUW76IgjieA-00044-00016320-00016542": "matter this carbon pulse 90 experts can", "OUW76IgjieA-00045-00016543-00016739": "be nice when the X of 90 Y doesn't", "OUW76IgjieA-00046-00016740-00016964": "matter but it is very crucial here that", "OUW76IgjieA-00047-00016965-00017261": "if this is 90 X this has to be 90 why", "OUW76IgjieA-00048-00017262-00017447": "there has to be 90 degrees phase shift", "OUW76IgjieA-00049-00017448-00017734": "between these two 90 degree pulses and", "OUW76IgjieA-00050-00017735-00018003": "the various time points here are", "OUW76IgjieA-00051-00018004-00018455": "represented like this 0 1 2 3 4 5 and", "OUW76IgjieA-00052-00018456-00018797": "this is the time point 6 which is in", "OUW76IgjieA-00053-00018798-00019147": "your detection period you also recall", "OUW76IgjieA-00054-00019148-00019394": "that this is very similar to the spin", "OUW76IgjieA-00055-00019395-00019617": "echo sequence the spin echo also had", "OUW76IgjieA-00056-00019618-00020000": "this 91 80 90 and separated by the time", "OUW76IgjieA-00057-00020001-00020421": "tau and except that we are now using it", "OUW76IgjieA-00058-00020422-00020639": "as a hetero experiment for transferring", "OUW76IgjieA-00059-00020640-00021005": "polarization from proton to carbon how", "OUW76IgjieA-00060-00021006-00021239": "does it happen let us see this we will", "OUW76IgjieA-00061-00021240-00021458": "analyze that using the product operator", "OUW76IgjieA-00062-00021459-00021743": "formalism okay", "OUW76IgjieA-00063-00021744-00022086": "so at time point 0 we consider the", "OUW76IgjieA-00064-00022087-00022361": "density operator which consists of the", "OUW76IgjieA-00065-00022362-00022596": "proton magnetization along the z axis", "OUW76IgjieA-00066-00022597-00022842": "and so this we call I right here now as", "OUW76IgjieA-00067-00022843-00023108": "Hz so don't confuse this with the", "OUW76IgjieA-00068-00023109-00023456": "Hamiltonian this is the operator for the", "OUW76IgjieA-00069-00023457-00023681": "proton Z mechanization and therefore I", "OUW76IgjieA-00070-00023682-00024099": "write it as Hz when I apply 9tx pulse on", "OUW76IgjieA-00071-00024100-00024414": "the proton channel notice there is no", "OUW76IgjieA-00072-00024415-00024668": "proton nor pulse applied on the carbon", "OUW76IgjieA-00073-00024669-00024725": "channel", "OUW76IgjieA-00074-00024726-00024903": "so therefore the carbon mechanization", "OUW76IgjieA-00075-00024904-00025077": "which is along the z axis is unaffected", "OUW76IgjieA-00076-00025078-00025280": "so therefore therefore we don't even", "OUW76IgjieA-00077-00025281-00025499": "write the carbon mechanization here we", "OUW76IgjieA-00078-00025500-00025692": "will only write the proton mechanization", "OUW76IgjieA-00079-00025693-00026058": "here H that and the the pulse is applied", "OUW76IgjieA-00080-00026058-00026315": "only on the proton channel and therefore", "OUW76IgjieA-00081-00026316-00026479": "we get a Rho 1", "OUW76IgjieA-00082-00026480-00026970": "- hy and during the period 1 to 4 what", "OUW76IgjieA-00083-00026972-00027195": "happens this is a spin echo we have seen", "OUW76IgjieA-00084-00027197-00027379": "that this is the spinnaker the spinnaker", "OUW76IgjieA-00085-00027380-00027693": "sequence is exactly in that manner so", "OUW76IgjieA-00086-00027694-00028074": "two things happen here first the proton", "OUW76IgjieA-00087-00028075-00028467": "chemical shift is refocused completely", "OUW76IgjieA-00088-00028468-00028948": "through the 90 X tau 180 X tau at the", "OUW76IgjieA-00089-00028949-00029161": "end of that there is a spin echo so at", "OUW76IgjieA-00090-00029162-00029412": "the point four nine point four this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00091-00029413-00029623": "the spin echo and the proton chemical", "OUW76IgjieA-00092-00029624-00029776": "shift is therefore refocused", "OUW76IgjieA-00093-00029777-00030139": "however the proton mechanization evolves", "OUW76IgjieA-00094-00030139-00030615": "under the proton carbon coupling okay so", "OUW76IgjieA-00095-00030616-00030837": "this Hamiltonian is operating this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00096-00030838-00031002": "not refocused so the coupling is not", "OUW76IgjieA-00097-00031003-00031305": "refocused in in the spin echo experiment", "OUW76IgjieA-00098-00031306-00031561": "when the 180 pulse is applied on both of", "OUW76IgjieA-00099-00031562-00031807": "the channels what the nuclear therefore", "OUW76IgjieA-00100-00031808-00032074": "we will directly write row four because", "OUW76IgjieA-00101-00032075-00032233": "we don't consider the chemical shift", "OUW76IgjieA-00102-00032233-00032386": "revolution at all because it is", "OUW76IgjieA-00103-00032387-00032745": "refocused therefore we from Row 1 to Row", "OUW76IgjieA-00104-00032746-00033010": "4 we will only consider only the", "OUW76IgjieA-00105-00033011-00033299": "evolution under the coupling Hamiltonian", "OUW76IgjieA-00106-00033300-00033589": "between proton and carbon so how does", "OUW76IgjieA-00107-00033590-00033832": "this hy evolve this is through the", "OUW76IgjieA-00108-00033833-00034083": "product operator formalism the row food", "OUW76IgjieA-00109-00034084-00034239": "turns out to be like this", "OUW76IgjieA-00110-00034240-00034762": "hy evolves as H wine cosine PI J HC 2", "OUW76IgjieA-00111-00034763-00034926": "tau for the time period of the whole", "OUW76IgjieA-00112-00034927-00035533": "thing is 2 tau minus 2 HX cz sine PI J", "OUW76IgjieA-00113-00035534-00035793": "HC 2 tau notice now these are the", "OUW76IgjieA-00114-00035794-00036130": "operators ok this represents the anti", "OUW76IgjieA-00115-00036131-00036448": "phase magnetization of proton with", "OUW76IgjieA-00116-00036449-00036736": "respect to the carbon and this is the in", "OUW76IgjieA-00117-00036737-00037048": "phase mechanization of proton of along", "OUW76IgjieA-00118-00037049-00037326": "the y axis so these are the operators hy", "OUW76IgjieA-00119-00037327-00037674": "+ 2 H 6 C that are the operators and tau", "OUW76IgjieA-00120-00037675-00037933": "is the time course and j HC is the", "OUW76IgjieA-00121-00037934-00038155": "coupling constant between proton and", "OUW76IgjieA-00122-00038156-00038687": "carbon now what we do is we set tau", "OUW76IgjieA-00123-00038688-00039035": "equal to 1 by 4 times J", "OUW76IgjieA-00124-00039036-00039370": "see so here if I put a tog is equal to 1", "OUW76IgjieA-00125-00039371-00039476": "by 4", "OUW76IgjieA-00126-00039477-00039787": "JH see what happens so this HC HC will", "OUW76IgjieA-00127-00039788-00040045": "cancel so this will become cosine PI by", "OUW76IgjieA-00128-00040046-00040304": "2 and similarly here this will become", "OUW76IgjieA-00129-00040305-00040667": "sine PI by 2 therefore this goes to 0", "OUW76IgjieA-00130-00040668-00041062": "and only this term remains okay", "OUW76IgjieA-00131-00041063-00041815": "therefore Rho 4 becomes 2 HX cz okay and", "OUW76IgjieA-00132-00041816-00042017": "notice this minus sign and this minus", "OUW76IgjieA-00133-00042018-00042421": "sign becomes plus and therefore here I", "OUW76IgjieA-00134-00042422-00042839": "have 2 HX cz and this is now the proton", "OUW76IgjieA-00135-00042840-00043220": "magnetization anti phase to carbon okay", "OUW76IgjieA-00136-00043221-00043408": "this is this is we learnt it from the", "OUW76IgjieA-00137-00043409-00043757": "product operator descriptions now when I", "OUW76IgjieA-00138-00043758-00044333": "apply a 90 pulse on proton and carbon we", "OUW76IgjieA-00139-00044334-00044639": "get rho phi and a rho phi so apply p--", "OUW76IgjieA-00140-00044640-00044951": "when i'm applying a 90 y pulse on proton", "OUW76IgjieA-00141-00044952-00045320": "right so therefore this HX goes to H Z", "OUW76IgjieA-00142-00045321-00045773": "and cz goes to see why because I am", "OUW76IgjieA-00143-00045774-00046018": "applying this counter carbon chain and", "OUW76IgjieA-00144-00046019-00046243": "I'm applying along the on the x axis", "OUW76IgjieA-00145-00046244-00046615": "therefore this goes to C Y now this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00146-00046616-00046874": "carbon mechanization anti phase to", "OUW76IgjieA-00147-00046875-00047117": "proton and that is the interesting thing", "OUW76IgjieA-00148-00047118-00047489": "therefore Rho for 2 rho phi represents", "OUW76IgjieA-00149-00047490-00047680": "the coherence transfer from pro tanto", "OUW76IgjieA-00150-00047681-00047999": "carbon which all the polarization which", "OUW76IgjieA-00151-00048000-00048251": "is present on the proton has now become", "OUW76IgjieA-00152-00048252-00048614": "carbon mechanization what is the meaning", "OUW76IgjieA-00153-00048615-00048854": "of this this means there is a", "OUW76IgjieA-00154-00048855-00049087": "significant sensitivity enhancement of", "OUW76IgjieA-00155-00049088-00049379": "the carbon per mechanization right", "OUW76IgjieA-00156-00049380-00049558": "sensitivity enhancement by factor gamma", "OUW76IgjieA-00157-00049559-00049886": "H by gamma C because proton", "OUW76IgjieA-00158-00049887-00050105": "magnetization is determined by the gara", "OUW76IgjieA-00159-00050106-00050417": "magnetic ratio of proton and the carbon", "OUW76IgjieA-00160-00050418-00050614": "mechanization is normally determined by", "OUW76IgjieA-00161-00050615-00050882": "the gyromagnetic ratio of of the carbon", "OUW76IgjieA-00162-00050883-00051107": "but here the proton magnetization is", "OUW76IgjieA-00163-00051108-00051295": "appearing as carbon mechanization", "OUW76IgjieA-00164-00051296-00051463": "therefore there is a sensitivity", "OUW76IgjieA-00165-00051464-00051745": "enhancement of the carbon signal by a", "OUW76IgjieA-00166-00051746-00052088": "factor gamma H by gamma C and this is a", "OUW76IgjieA-00167-00052089-00052254": "factor of 4 right", "OUW76IgjieA-00168-00052255-00052491": "this is a factor of four if this were a", "OUW76IgjieA-00169-00052492-00052690": "nitrogen for example then this will be a", "OUW76IgjieA-00170-00052691-00052923": "factor of ten and that implies the", "OUW76IgjieA-00171-00052924-00053142": "substantial saving in time and the great", "OUW76IgjieA-00172-00053143-00053331": "improvement in the signal-to-noise ratio", "OUW76IgjieA-00173-00053332-00053544": "in your experimental time because", "OUW76IgjieA-00174-00053545-00053850": "experimental time goes as a square of", "OUW76IgjieA-00175-00053851-00054571": "this factor okay now after this roof Rho", "OUW76IgjieA-00176-00054572-00054816": "Phi evolves during the detection period", "OUW76IgjieA-00177-00054817-00055090": "under the influence of chemical shift", "OUW76IgjieA-00178-00055091-00055429": "and coupling Hamiltonians of carbon okay", "OUW76IgjieA-00179-00055429-00055725": "so these two H's led to CY", "OUW76IgjieA-00180-00055726-00056011": "during the detection period evolves", "OUW76IgjieA-00181-00056012-00056199": "under the chemical shift as well as the", "OUW76IgjieA-00182-00056200-00056446": "coupling let us first consider the", "OUW76IgjieA-00183-00056447-00056661": "coupling evolution because you remember", "OUW76IgjieA-00184-00056662-00056841": "I had told you that it doesn't matter", "OUW76IgjieA-00185-00056842-00057040": "which evolution you will consider first", "OUW76IgjieA-00186-00057041-00057249": "and which evolution you will consider", "OUW76IgjieA-00187-00057250-00057685": "later okay so we'll consider the", "OUW76IgjieA-00188-00057686-00057853": "coupling evolution first there is a", "OUW76IgjieA-00189-00057854-00058068": "purpose in it so I will illustrate this", "OUW76IgjieA-00190-00058069-00058380": "to you very quickly so to H that CY now", "OUW76IgjieA-00191-00058381-00058668": "this is the product operator and you are", "OUW76IgjieA-00192-00058669-00058824": "considering its evolution under the", "OUW76IgjieA-00193-00058825-00058980": "influence of the coupling Hamiltonian", "OUW76IgjieA-00194-00058981-00059323": "between proton and carbon so this gives", "OUW76IgjieA-00195-00059324-00059821": "you 2 Hz to C Y cosine Phi J HCT now it", "OUW76IgjieA-00196-00059822-00060086": "is a function of time during the F ID", "OUW76IgjieA-00197-00060087-00060294": "during the fi t this is what we are", "OUW76IgjieA-00198-00060295-00060634": "getting to H let's see Y cosine PI J HC", "OUW76IgjieA-00199-00060635-00061210": "t minus C X sine pi z HC T so the same", "OUW76IgjieA-00200-00061211-00061467": "thing is written once more here and now", "OUW76IgjieA-00201-00061468-00061851": "you notice that this particular term is", "OUW76IgjieA-00202-00061852-00062049": "not observable this is nt phase", "OUW76IgjieA-00203-00062050-00062328": "mechanization is not an observable term", "OUW76IgjieA-00204-00062329-00062613": "right so therefore if we did not have", "OUW76IgjieA-00205-00062614-00062836": "this coupling evolution we would not", "OUW76IgjieA-00206-00062837-00063000": "have any mechanization which is", "OUW76IgjieA-00207-00063001-00063196": "observable this is not observable term", "OUW76IgjieA-00208-00063197-00063561": "because you recall our discussion that", "OUW76IgjieA-00209-00063562-00063861": "to be observable it's a trace with the C", "OUW76IgjieA-00210-00063862-00064240": "X or C Y has to be nonzero now if you", "OUW76IgjieA-00211-00064241-00064534": "take the trace of this with either C X", "OUW76IgjieA-00212-00064535-00064806": "or C Y this is 0 and we are actually", "OUW76IgjieA-00213-00064807-00065037": "described this earlier also that the NT", "OUW76IgjieA-00214-00065038-00065260": "phase magnetization is not an observable", "OUW76IgjieA-00215-00065261-00065532": "operator whereas this one is an", "OUW76IgjieA-00216-00065533-00065618": "observable", "OUW76IgjieA-00217-00065619-00065929": "therefore the coupling evolution leads", "OUW76IgjieA-00218-00065930-00066196": "to an observable mechanization here of", "OUW76IgjieA-00219-00066197-00066342": "the river will turn so this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00220-00066343-00066559": "observable term and this is not", "OUW76IgjieA-00221-00066560-00066853": "observable now therefore for after this", "OUW76IgjieA-00222-00066854-00067032": "we need not consider the evolution of", "OUW76IgjieA-00223-00067033-00067204": "this at all for the chemical shift", "OUW76IgjieA-00224-00067205-00067437": "because this is anyway not observable so", "OUW76IgjieA-00225-00067438-00067626": "this will go away now we will only", "OUW76IgjieA-00226-00067627-00067873": "consider this term therefore we will now", "OUW76IgjieA-00227-00067874-00068167": "consider minus CX sine PI jsct", "OUW76IgjieA-00228-00068168-00068404": "will evolve this under the chemical", "OUW76IgjieA-00229-00068405-00068805": "shift so take keep the minus sign pi FCT", "OUW76IgjieA-00230-00068806-00069172": "outside and evolve this CX operator the", "OUW76IgjieA-00231-00069173-00069438": "under the chemical shift of karma so", "OUW76IgjieA-00232-00069439-00069788": "this gives you C X cosine Omega CT plus", "OUW76IgjieA-00233-00069789-00070171": "C Y sine Omega CT this is the normal", "OUW76IgjieA-00234-00070172-00070425": "chemical shift evolution under the", "OUW76IgjieA-00235-00070426-00070791": "influence of the carbon chemical shift", "OUW76IgjieA-00236-00070792-00071151": "Zeeman Hamiltonian okay now so I have a", "OUW76IgjieA-00237-00071152-00071538": "C X term and a Cy term right so if I", "OUW76IgjieA-00238-00071539-00071797": "observe the X magnetization I get this", "OUW76IgjieA-00239-00071798-00072012": "term if I have to observe the Y", "OUW76IgjieA-00240-00072013-00072334": "magnetization then I get this term so", "OUW76IgjieA-00241-00072335-00072561": "therefore row six the density operator", "OUW76IgjieA-00242-00072562-00072879": "if I were to do X detection then I get", "OUW76IgjieA-00243-00072880-00073281": "this minus CX sine pi j HC T cosine", "OUW76IgjieA-00244-00073282-00073581": "Omega CT and if I went to do a y", "OUW76IgjieA-00245-00073582-00074035": "direction I will get minus C Y sine pi j", "OUW76IgjieA-00246-00074036-00074592": "HC T sine Omega C T okay what is our", "OUW76IgjieA-00247-00074593-00074866": "signal to see what is the signal I have", "OUW76IgjieA-00248-00074867-00075186": "to take the trace of this with C X or C", "OUW76IgjieA-00249-00075187-00075456": "Y okay so when I take the place of this", "OUW76IgjieA-00250-00075457-00075663": "is C X we have operators this C X terms", "OUW76IgjieA-00251-00075664-00075886": "will vanish I will only be left with", "OUW76IgjieA-00252-00075887-00076111": "this coefficients which actually are", "OUW76IgjieA-00253-00076112-00076338": "functions of time and that is my", "OUW76IgjieA-00254-00076339-00076662": "observed signal so therefore the signal", "OUW76IgjieA-00255-00076663-00076899": "what we get after taking the trace with", "OUW76IgjieA-00256-00076900-00077185": "the C X or C Y so this will be 4x", "OUW76IgjieA-00257-00077186-00077659": "detection sine pi j HC T cosine Omega C", "OUW76IgjieA-00258-00077660-00078085": "T right okay now let us try to expand", "OUW76IgjieA-00259-00078086-00078675": "this and the sign a sign YJ HC P cosine", "OUW76IgjieA-00260-00078676-00078801": "Omega C", "OUW76IgjieA-00261-00078802-00079078": "we'll be expanded as the sum of two sine", "OUW76IgjieA-00262-00079079-00079506": "terms okay so when we expand this as sum", "OUW76IgjieA-00263-00079507-00079822": "of two we get this here I have to put", "OUW76IgjieA-00264-00079823-00080147": "this as there is a factor of 1 by 2 here", "OUW76IgjieA-00265-00080148-00080511": "I have to put it in so I will get two", "OUW76IgjieA-00266-00080512-00080697": "frequencies here right there are two", "OUW76IgjieA-00267-00080698-00080880": "sine terms here so there are two", "OUW76IgjieA-00268-00080881-00081165": "frequencies the frequencies are Omega C", "OUW76IgjieA-00269-00081166-00081498": "plus pi j HC and the other one is omega", "OUW76IgjieA-00270-00081499-00081784": "c minus pi j HC of course these are in", "OUW76IgjieA-00271-00081785-00082059": "radians so if I take out if I want to", "OUW76IgjieA-00272-00082060-00082307": "express them in Hertz in terms of", "OUW76IgjieA-00273-00082308-00082653": "numbers then I take out this 2 pi here I", "OUW76IgjieA-00274-00082654-00083019": "write this as sine 2 pi nu C nu C is", "OUW76IgjieA-00275-00083020-00083247": "actually in terms of the chemical shift", "OUW76IgjieA-00276-00083248-00083835": "plus j HC by 2t and this is minus sine 2", "OUW76IgjieA-00277-00083836-00084279": "pi nu c minus t HC by 2 T so I have 2", "OUW76IgjieA-00278-00084280-00084628": "sine terms here with the frequencies nu", "OUW76IgjieA-00279-00084629-00085026": "c plus d HC by 2 and nu C minus 2 HC by", "OUW76IgjieA-00280-00085027-00085240": "2 so if I would do Fourier", "OUW76IgjieA-00281-00085241-00085482": "transformation of this signal then I", "OUW76IgjieA-00282-00085483-00085737": "will get two frequencies right the", "OUW76IgjieA-00283-00085738-00085956": "frequency spectrum but this frequency", "OUW76IgjieA-00284-00085957-00086160": "spectrum will have dispersed you line", "OUW76IgjieA-00285-00086161-00086403": "shape because these ones are sine terms", "OUW76IgjieA-00286-00086404-00086607": "this is what we have seen in the very", "OUW76IgjieA-00287-00086608-00087109": "early discussions in the course so this", "OUW76IgjieA-00288-00087110-00087402": "sine term is giving me two dispersive", "OUW76IgjieA-00289-00087403-00087675": "signals and now because of this minus", "OUW76IgjieA-00290-00087676-00088023": "sign these two also have opposite faces", "OUW76IgjieA-00291-00088024-00088206": "so this goes like this", "OUW76IgjieA-00292-00088207-00088465": "positive and negative width and then", "OUW76IgjieA-00293-00088466-00088650": "that this will be opposite in sign", "OUW76IgjieA-00294-00088651-00088881": "compared to this and therefore this goes", "OUW76IgjieA-00295-00088882-00089148": "in this manner and we have two", "OUW76IgjieA-00296-00089149-00089440": "dispersive signals which are anti phase", "OUW76IgjieA-00297-00089441-00089751": "in nature we call the NT phase doublet", "OUW76IgjieA-00298-00089752-00090336": "with dispersive line shapes ok now", "OUW76IgjieA-00299-00090337-00090534": "during the detection during the", "OUW76IgjieA-00300-00090535-00090852": "detection period these two signals will", "OUW76IgjieA-00301-00090853-00090987": "be present as they are", "OUW76IgjieA-00302-00090988-00091185": "if you don't decouple you cannot", "OUW76IgjieA-00303-00091186-00091356": "decouple this if you want to decouple", "OUW76IgjieA-00304-00091357-00091542": "this then of course these two will", "OUW76IgjieA-00305-00091543-00091759": "collapse fall on top of each other and", "OUW76IgjieA-00306-00091760-00091938": "then this will be", "OUW76IgjieA-00307-00091939-00092193": "so therefore in this situation we cannot", "OUW76IgjieA-00308-00092194-00092528": "decouple the during the detection period", "OUW76IgjieA-00309-00092529-00092844": "okay and this the center of this is the", "OUW76IgjieA-00310-00092845-00093036": "chemical shift and the separation", "OUW76IgjieA-00311-00093037-00093333": "between these two is the coupling", "OUW76IgjieA-00312-00093334-00093615": "constant jch that is from here notice", "OUW76IgjieA-00313-00093616-00093834": "the center is here okay the center is", "OUW76IgjieA-00314-00093835-00094026": "not here or here this this center is", "OUW76IgjieA-00315-00094027-00094290": "here this center is here so from here to", "OUW76IgjieA-00316-00094291-00094725": "here it is j CH now if I were to do is", "OUW76IgjieA-00317-00094726-00095019": "why detection then my turn what I have", "OUW76IgjieA-00318-00095020-00095442": "is sine PI J HC t sine Omega C T once", "OUW76IgjieA-00319-00095443-00095613": "again the operator part has gone off", "OUW76IgjieA-00320-00095614-00095805": "because after they take the press with", "OUW76IgjieA-00321-00095806-00096072": "the cy that the trace of C Y square is 1", "OUW76IgjieA-00322-00096073-00096309": "so therefore that will not appear and I", "OUW76IgjieA-00323-00096310-00096486": "will I only have the time dependent", "OUW76IgjieA-00324-00096487-00096699": "function here which actually is part of", "OUW76IgjieA-00325-00096700-00096948": "their Friday so once again here I will", "OUW76IgjieA-00326-00096949-00097998": "have a factor of 1/2 so I have now once", "OUW76IgjieA-00327-00097999-00098241": "again the same two frequencies Omega c", "OUW76IgjieA-00328-00098242-00098663": "plus PI J HC and Omega C minus PI J HC", "OUW76IgjieA-00329-00098664-00098886": "okay these are the two frequencies with", "OUW76IgjieA-00330-00098887-00099078": "the present but now the difference is", "OUW76IgjieA-00331-00099079-00099357": "these ones are cosine functions so", "OUW76IgjieA-00332-00099358-00099540": "representing them in this in terms of", "OUW76IgjieA-00333-00099541-00099720": "the hertz so again i write it here as", "OUW76IgjieA-00334-00099721-00100218": "cosine 2 pi nu c plus d HC by 2 and this", "OUW76IgjieA-00335-00100219-00100653": "is nu c minus j HC by 2 reason cosa both", "OUW76IgjieA-00336-00100654-00100893": "are cosine terms and once again these", "OUW76IgjieA-00337-00100894-00101259": "two have opposite signs so this one is", "OUW76IgjieA-00338-00101260-00101478": "if i were to take it as positive and", "OUW76IgjieA-00339-00101479-00101688": "this will because of the minus sign this", "OUW76IgjieA-00340-00101689-00101939": "will be negative now it will represent", "OUW76IgjieA-00341-00101940-00102168": "absorptive signals because these are", "OUW76IgjieA-00342-00102169-00102393": "cosine terms so the cosine terms will", "OUW76IgjieA-00343-00102394-00102639": "produce me and absorb your signal here", "OUW76IgjieA-00344-00102640-00102927": "at this particular frequency and this", "OUW76IgjieA-00345-00102928-00103176": "will produce a negative signal at this", "OUW76IgjieA-00346-00103177-00103422": "particular frequency which is this so", "OUW76IgjieA-00347-00103423-00103634": "once again because of these anti phase", "OUW76IgjieA-00348-00103635-00103947": "signals CH cannot be decoupled during", "OUW76IgjieA-00349-00103948-00104100": "detection what happens if you decouple", "OUW76IgjieA-00350-00104101-00104343": "because this they will overlap they come", "OUW76IgjieA-00351-00104344-00104439": "on top of each other", "OUW76IgjieA-00352-00104440-00104601": "this will come here and this will come", "OUW76IgjieA-00353-00104602-00104814": "here therefore they will cancel so", "OUW76IgjieA-00354-00104815-00104959": "therefore you cannot decouple", "OUW76IgjieA-00355-00104960-00105251": "if the signals are anti-phase in nature", "OUW76IgjieA-00356-00105252-00105535": "the NT phase doublet will appear like", "OUW76IgjieA-00357-00105536-00106004": "this so here is an experimental example", "OUW76IgjieA-00358-00106005-00106181": "this was a very first data which was", "OUW76IgjieA-00359-00106182-00106430": "recorded this came from Morrison Freeman", "OUW76IgjieA-00360-00106431-00106889": "and this is published in 1979 in Journal", "OUW76IgjieA-00361-00106890-00107141": "of American Chemical Society and you can", "OUW76IgjieA-00362-00107142-00107357": "see here there are three anti-phase", "OUW76IgjieA-00363-00107358-00107720": "doublets so one here this is positive", "OUW76IgjieA-00364-00107721-00107942": "negative positive negative positive and", "OUW76IgjieA-00365-00107943-00108133": "of course you are seeing some fine", "OUW76IgjieA-00366-00108134-00108356": "structure here and of some molecule", "OUW76IgjieA-00367-00108357-00108508": "which is there and because this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00368-00108509-00108658": "because of the carbon-carbon coupling", "OUW76IgjieA-00369-00108659-00108950": "which also evolved during the detection", "OUW76IgjieA-00370-00108951-00109148": "period so we are not done nothing about", "OUW76IgjieA-00371-00109149-00109289": "the carbon-carbon couplings", "OUW76IgjieA-00372-00109290-00109459": "so wherever there is a carbon-carbon", "OUW76IgjieA-00373-00109460-00109631": "coupling it will lead to a splitting and", "OUW76IgjieA-00374-00109632-00109901": "therefore the whole set here will", "OUW76IgjieA-00375-00109902-00110096": "contain this carbon-carbon couplings", "OUW76IgjieA-00376-00110097-00110378": "here so there are three carbons C 2 C 4", "OUW76IgjieA-00377-00110379-00110567": "C 3 and they are coupled to each other", "OUW76IgjieA-00378-00110568-00110879": "and that results in this kind of a fine", "OUW76IgjieA-00379-00110880-00111107": "structure here and we have NT faced", "OUW76IgjieA-00380-00111108-00111620": "doublets for each of the carbons now but", "OUW76IgjieA-00381-00111621-00111859": "this NTV's nature is often a disturbance", "OUW76IgjieA-00382-00111860-00112082": "and they can if there are two NT phase", "OUW76IgjieA-00383-00112083-00112247": "which are close by then they may lead to", "OUW76IgjieA-00384-00112248-00112481": "cancellations and therefore we don't", "OUW76IgjieA-00385-00112482-00112658": "want to have that thing to happen so", "OUW76IgjieA-00386-00112658-00112790": "therefore we need to do something", "OUW76IgjieA-00387-00112791-00113078": "further to improve upon this so", "OUW76IgjieA-00388-00113079-00113282": "therefore what we do we do what we", "OUW76IgjieA-00389-00113283-00113471": "called as the refocused inept", "OUW76IgjieA-00390-00113472-00113768": "so here the pulse sequence is extended", "OUW76IgjieA-00391-00113769-00114085": "see the inept was ending here and you", "OUW76IgjieA-00392-00114086-00114308": "are having the F ID collected from here", "OUW76IgjieA-00393-00114308-00114632": "now for the refocused inept what you do", "OUW76IgjieA-00394-00114633-00114875": "is you extend this pulse sequence by", "OUW76IgjieA-00395-00114876-00115159": "introducing and their spin a consequence", "OUW76IgjieA-00396-00115160-00115561": "here tau 180 tau and the 180 pulse is", "OUW76IgjieA-00397-00115563-00115793": "applied on both the sequences and both", "OUW76IgjieA-00398-00115794-00116015": "of the channels both proton and carbon", "OUW76IgjieA-00399-00116016-00116450": "so we have tau na T tau applied and the", "OUW76IgjieA-00400-00116451-00116710": "data is collected as a function of time", "OUW76IgjieA-00401-00116711-00116918": "on the carbon channel and you can also", "OUW76IgjieA-00402-00116919-00117215": "do couple here on the proton channel how", "OUW76IgjieA-00403-00117216-00117685": "it happens we will I will show you okay", "OUW76IgjieA-00404-00117686-00117985": "so until Rho Phi the product operator", "OUW76IgjieA-00405-00117986-00118223": "description is the same so we do not", "OUW76IgjieA-00406-00118224-00118295": "want to do that", "OUW76IgjieA-00407-00118296-00118759": "once more here now Rho Phi is 2 Hz CY", "OUW76IgjieA-00408-00118760-00118984": "this is the carbon mechanization and T", "OUW76IgjieA-00409-00118985-00119215": "phase 2 proton right so this is what we", "OUW76IgjieA-00410-00119216-00119563": "had now evolution under coupling so now", "OUW76IgjieA-00411-00119564-00119831": "where is Rho 6 here see the row 6 is at", "OUW76IgjieA-00412-00119832-00120047": "this point this is the extended point we", "OUW76IgjieA-00413-00120048-00120176": "want to calculate was the density", "OUW76IgjieA-00414-00120177-00120553": "operator at this point so Row 5 to row 6", "OUW76IgjieA-00415-00120554-00120848": "what happens there is no chemical shift", "OUW76IgjieA-00416-00120849-00121033": "evolution because of the 180 pulse the", "OUW76IgjieA-00417-00121034-00121276": "magnetization is on carbon mechanization", "OUW76IgjieA-00418-00121277-00121690": "is here and this gets refocused chemical", "OUW76IgjieA-00419-00121691-00121826": "shift is the refocus across so through", "OUW76IgjieA-00420-00121827-00122069": "the 180 pulse but and then because of", "OUW76IgjieA-00421-00122070-00122381": "the 180 pulses on both carbon and proton", "OUW76IgjieA-00422-00122382-00122611": "channels this evolution under the", "OUW76IgjieA-00423-00122613-00122809": "coupling continues and that is not", "OUW76IgjieA-00424-00122810-00123125": "refocused therefore at this point row 6", "OUW76IgjieA-00425-00123126-00123308": "we have to considered evolution under", "OUW76IgjieA-00426-00123308-00123691": "the coupling only ok so therefore if I", "OUW76IgjieA-00427-00123692-00123886": "do evolution and the coupling that gives", "OUW76IgjieA-00428-00123888-00124196": "me the row 6 and what is that two H's at", "OUW76IgjieA-00429-00124197-00124397": "CY evolution under a coupling", "OUW76IgjieA-00430-00124398-00124834": "Hamiltonian leads me to 2 HZ z y cosine", "OUW76IgjieA-00431-00124835-00125183": "y h is AC to tau because once again", "OUW76IgjieA-00432-00125183-00125333": "because of the Tudor period of the", "OUW76IgjieA-00433-00125333-00125750": "spinnaker sequence minus CX sine pi j HC", "OUW76IgjieA-00434-00125751-00126125": "2 tau now once again I adjust my tau", "OUW76IgjieA-00435-00126126-00126407": "because this is under my control I just", "OUW76IgjieA-00436-00126408-00126788": "my tau to be equal to 1 by 4 times j HC", "OUW76IgjieA-00437-00126789-00127208": "for assuming j HC is of 150 Hertz and", "OUW76IgjieA-00438-00127208-00127376": "this will be only tau will be", "OUW76IgjieA-00439-00127377-00127556": "approximately one point six six", "OUW76IgjieA-00440-00127557-00127706": "milliseconds or one point seven", "OUW76IgjieA-00441-00127707-00128041": "millisecond so this is the approximate", "OUW76IgjieA-00442-00128042-00128300": "therefore if it is 140 or so 150 years", "OUW76IgjieA-00443-00128301-00128423": "and things like that so approximately", "OUW76IgjieA-00444-00128424-00128641": "one can adjust this to one point six", "OUW76IgjieA-00445-00128642-00129074": "seven milliseconds now when you put that", "OUW76IgjieA-00446-00129075-00129338": "this term goes to zero as before because", "OUW76IgjieA-00447-00129339-00129583": "this is cosine PI by 2 and this will", "OUW76IgjieA-00448-00129584-00130007": "become one okay therefore 2 Hz to C Phi", "OUW76IgjieA-00449-00130008-00130298": "will now become just minus CX", "OUW76IgjieA-00450-00130299-00130544": "all the time dependent these terms are", "OUW76IgjieA-00451-00130545-00130820": "gone I only see the row six is therefore", "OUW76IgjieA-00452-00130821-00131319": "simply equal to minus C X now", "OUW76IgjieA-00453-00131320-00131631": "the proton was not decoupled okay", "OUW76IgjieA-00454-00131632-00131931": "suppose the proton was not decoupled now", "OUW76IgjieA-00455-00131932-00132128": "CX will evolve under a chemical shift as", "OUW76IgjieA-00456-00132129-00132345": "well as coupling during the detection", "OUW76IgjieA-00457-00132346-00132531": "period right so now we're considering", "OUW76IgjieA-00458-00132532-00132696": "what happens during the detection period", "OUW76IgjieA-00459-00132697-00133158": "row six was at the end of the spin echo", "OUW76IgjieA-00460-00133159-00133524": "right now the this will love you fall", "OUW76IgjieA-00461-00133525-00134010": "under the coupling right this is the row", "OUW76IgjieA-00462-00134011-00134220": "six the row six was here there is no", "OUW76IgjieA-00463-00134221-00134429": "pulse applied here so this will evolve", "OUW76IgjieA-00464-00134430-00134718": "during the Phi D it will evolve under", "OUW76IgjieA-00465-00134719-00134862": "the influence of the chemical shift in", "OUW76IgjieA-00466-00134863-00135099": "the coupling and depending upon what you", "OUW76IgjieA-00467-00135100-00135486": "do so if we wait considering without", "OUW76IgjieA-00468-00135487-00135798": "proton decoupling then I will consider", "OUW76IgjieA-00469-00135799-00135975": "the evolution under chemical shift as", "OUW76IgjieA-00470-00135976-00136209": "well as the coupling okay let us", "OUW76IgjieA-00471-00136210-00136356": "consider first the evolution under", "OUW76IgjieA-00472-00136357-00136640": "chemical shift so this will give me C X", "OUW76IgjieA-00473-00136641-00137019": "cosine Omega C T plus C Y sine Omega C T", "OUW76IgjieA-00474-00137020-00137225": "just I ignored the sign here so it", "OUW76IgjieA-00475-00137226-00137547": "doesn't matter so C X cosine Omega CT", "OUW76IgjieA-00476-00137548-00137876": "plus C Y sine Omega CT assuming X", "OUW76IgjieA-00477-00137877-00138207": "detection okay we will ignore this term", "OUW76IgjieA-00478-00138208-00138447": "this because we are only demonstrating", "OUW76IgjieA-00479-00138448-00138587": "in principle of course when you're", "OUW76IgjieA-00480-00138588-00138843": "collecting the data and evolving so", "OUW76IgjieA-00481-00138844-00138975": "you'll have to consider all the terms", "OUW76IgjieA-00482-00138976-00139134": "which are present but this is to", "OUW76IgjieA-00483-00139135-00139449": "demonstrate how things develop depending", "OUW76IgjieA-00484-00139450-00139761": "upon what term you select so if I were", "OUW76IgjieA-00485-00139762-00140012": "to collect X data and that is X", "OUW76IgjieA-00486-00140013-00140228": "detection and evolve under the J", "OUW76IgjieA-00487-00140229-00140489": "coupling now so Kim shift evolution has", "OUW76IgjieA-00488-00140490-00140793": "produced CX and CY now consider the", "OUW76IgjieA-00489-00140794-00141048": "evolution of the X part under J coupling", "OUW76IgjieA-00490-00141049-00141384": "and this gives me row 7 so the row 7", "OUW76IgjieA-00491-00141385-00141812": "gives me cosine Omega C T C X cosine PI", "OUW76IgjieA-00492-00141813-00142161": "J HCT now it is a function of time right", "OUW76IgjieA-00493-00142162-00142683": "plus to see why it's Z sine PI J HCT", "OUW76IgjieA-00494-00142684-00143012": "once again this term is not observable", "OUW76IgjieA-00495-00143013-00143268": "this is anti phase carbon mechanization", "OUW76IgjieA-00496-00143269-00143535": "with respect to the proton and this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00497-00143536-00143721": "not observable because this trace will", "OUW76IgjieA-00498-00143722-00144125": "be 0 with respect to C X or C Y", "OUW76IgjieA-00499-00144126-00144512": "therefore my signal will be cosine Omega", "OUW76IgjieA-00500-00144513-00144714": "C T cosine pi", "OUW76IgjieA-00501-00144715-00145152": "HC d so once more I write the signal as", "OUW76IgjieA-00502-00145153-00145650": "this and I will decompose this into two", "OUW76IgjieA-00503-00145651-00145959": "terms into the two frequency terms put", "OUW76IgjieA-00504-00145960-00146429": "here once more a factor of half so what", "OUW76IgjieA-00505-00146430-00146654": "do you get here now so this is the same", "OUW76IgjieA-00506-00146655-00147096": "as before we get two frequencies Omega c", "OUW76IgjieA-00507-00147097-00147498": "plus phi j HC and omega c minus pi j HC", "OUW76IgjieA-00508-00147499-00147759": "because if i take it in terms of the 2", "OUW76IgjieA-00509-00147760-00147993": "pi out in terms of the radians we take", "OUW76IgjieA-00510-00147994-00148344": "it out your new c plus JSC by 2 and nu c", "OUW76IgjieA-00511-00148345-00148626": "minus HC by 2 but now notice i have a", "OUW76IgjieA-00512-00148627-00148881": "plus sign here earlier this was a minus", "OUW76IgjieA-00513-00148882-00149061": "sign now i have a plus sign which means", "OUW76IgjieA-00514-00149062-00149416": "both these signals have the same phase", "OUW76IgjieA-00515-00149417-00149541": "right", "OUW76IgjieA-00516-00149542-00149868": "they both are positive therefore this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00517-00149869-00150282": "an interface doublet of carbon so we", "OUW76IgjieA-00518-00150283-00150450": "starting from the proton magnetization", "OUW76IgjieA-00519-00150451-00150696": "with the refocused inept during the", "OUW76IgjieA-00520-00150697-00150984": "detection period so I have here in phase", "OUW76IgjieA-00521-00150985-00151326": "doublet as a measurement now this", "OUW76IgjieA-00522-00151327-00151662": "separation is j HC j CH now i can", "OUW76IgjieA-00523-00151663-00151911": "decouple this if i D couple these two", "OUW76IgjieA-00524-00151912-00152295": "will collapse into a singlet D coupling", "OUW76IgjieA-00525-00152296-00152454": "collapsed with this doublet into a", "OUW76IgjieA-00526-00152455-00152679": "singlet and this will be at the center", "OUW76IgjieA-00527-00152680-00152895": "here and with the twice the intensity", "OUW76IgjieA-00528-00152896-00153102": "because both this will contribute to the", "OUW76IgjieA-00529-00153103-00153318": "intensity and intensity of this will be", "OUW76IgjieA-00530-00153319-00153600": "twice so this will be a big advantage", "OUW76IgjieA-00531-00153601-00154134": "for the carbene signal so now here it is", "OUW76IgjieA-00532-00154135-00154359": "a comparison of a next experimental", "OUW76IgjieA-00533-00154360-00154557": "spectra under the various conditions", "OUW76IgjieA-00534-00154558-00154773": "this is the carbon-13 spectra of", "OUW76IgjieA-00535-00154774-00154950": "methanoic acid there is only one carbon", "OUW76IgjieA-00536-00154951-00155286": "and one proton and so you have here a", "OUW76IgjieA-00537-00155287-00155573": "couple dispatcher which is a doublet", "OUW76IgjieA-00538-00155574-00155891": "normal coupled spectrum carbon detection", "OUW76IgjieA-00539-00155892-00156165": "direct carbon detection okay and if you", "OUW76IgjieA-00540-00156166-00156474": "decouple this you have this appearing in", "OUW76IgjieA-00541-00156475-00156693": "the center here the carbon this is a", "OUW76IgjieA-00542-00156694-00156941": "decouple spectrum now if we did an inept", "OUW76IgjieA-00543-00156942-00157209": "experiment now it is the magnetization", "OUW76IgjieA-00544-00157210-00157452": "is now coming from the proton remember", "OUW76IgjieA-00545-00157453-00157641": "it is not the you not", "OUW76IgjieA-00546-00157642-00157824": "the carbon mechanization as it is done", "OUW76IgjieA-00547-00157825-00158013": "here the mechanization is coming from", "OUW76IgjieA-00548-00158014-00158235": "the proton and therefore this has a", "OUW76IgjieA-00549-00158236-00158568": "gamma H by gamma C signal enhancement", "OUW76IgjieA-00550-00158569-00158865": "therefore in the normal inept you have", "OUW76IgjieA-00551-00158866-00159259": "this NT phase signals which are one", "OUW76IgjieA-00552-00159260-00159472": "positive here and one negative here now", "OUW76IgjieA-00553-00159473-00159786": "if I did a refocused in apt this will", "OUW76IgjieA-00554-00159787-00159948": "turn out to be positive it will go up", "OUW76IgjieA-00555-00159949-00160002": "like this", "OUW76IgjieA-00556-00160003-00160239": "so this is positive here and this is", "OUW76IgjieA-00557-00160240-00160558": "positive here and now refocused and be", "OUW76IgjieA-00558-00160559-00160791": "coupled now you decouple this so this", "OUW76IgjieA-00559-00160792-00160962": "will to collapse again once more here", "OUW76IgjieA-00560-00160963-00161226": "and you have a huge signal here coming", "OUW76IgjieA-00561-00161227-00161448": "here so this is the significant", "OUW76IgjieA-00562-00161449-00161786": "advantage in the signal-to-noise ratio", "OUW76IgjieA-00563-00161787-00162094": "through this refocused decoupled inept", "OUW76IgjieA-00564-00162095-00162331": "experiment and that is how this has", "OUW76IgjieA-00565-00162332-00162532": "become an extremely important tool", "OUW76IgjieA-00566-00162533-00162816": "extremely important technique for", "OUW76IgjieA-00567-00162817-00163018": "heteronuclear experiments for all", "OUW76IgjieA-00568-00163019-00163243": "organic chemistry people this has become", "OUW76IgjieA-00569-00163244-00163419": "an extremely useful technique for", "OUW76IgjieA-00570-00163420-00163708": "determining how many carbons there are", "OUW76IgjieA-00571-00163709-00163911": "in their molecules how to get single", "OUW76IgjieA-00572-00163912-00164059": "tuner and you can do with the natural", "OUW76IgjieA-00573-00164060-00164298": "abundance you can do carbon-13 spectra", "OUW76IgjieA-00574-00164299-00164550": "at natural abundance you use proton", "OUW76IgjieA-00575-00164551-00164688": "mechanization to enhance the", "OUW76IgjieA-00576-00164689-00164884": "signal-to-noise ratio and you can", "OUW76IgjieA-00577-00164885-00165118": "identify the number of carbons in your", "OUW76IgjieA-00578-00165119-00165375": "molecule and if you couple the record", "OUW76IgjieA-00579-00165376-00165588": "proton couple spectra also then of", "OUW76IgjieA-00580-00165589-00165711": "course you can see the multiplet", "OUW76IgjieA-00581-00165712-00166033": "structures in all of those things so I", "OUW76IgjieA-00582-00166034-00166291": "think we'll stop here", "OUW76IgjieA-00583-00166292-00167657": "[Music]", "OUW76IgjieA-00584-00167658-00167990": "[Applause]", "OUW76IgjieA-00585-00167991-00168144": "[Music]", "OUW76IgjieA-00586-00168145-00169102": "[Applause]", "OUW76IgjieA-00587-00169103-00169671": "[Applause]", "OUW76IgjieA-00588-00169672-00170134": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OV04krv2RQM", "text": {"OV04krv2RQM-00000-00000049-00000645": "Quintus Konya speediness c9 BC C ad 76", "OV04krv2RQM-00001-00000646-00000950": "was a Roman historian in his later years", "OV04krv2RQM-00002-00000951-00001173": "he resided in Rome and there he died", "OV04krv2RQM-00003-00001174-00001391": "after having been blind for 12 years at", "OV04krv2RQM-00004-00001392-00001667": "the age of 85 during the reigns of", "OV04krv2RQM-00005-00001668-00001880": "Claudius and Nero he compiled for his", "OV04krv2RQM-00006-00001881-00002187": "sons from various sources eg the Gazette", "OV04krv2RQM-00007-00002188-00002435": "a table shorthand reports her skeletons", "OV04krv2RQM-00008-00002436-00002642": "comentary of Cicero's unpublished", "OV04krv2RQM-00009-00002643-00002909": "speeches heroes life of Cicero speeches", "OV04krv2RQM-00010-00002910-00003098": "and letters of Cicero's contemporaries", "OV04krv2RQM-00011-00003099-00003465": "various historical writers eg Varro", "OV04krv2RQM-00012-00003465-00003731": "Atticus angeas 10 tetanus and fenestella", "OV04krv2RQM-00013-00003732-00003941": "a contemporary of Livy whom he often", "OV04krv2RQM-00014-00003942-00004197": "criticizes historical commentaries on", "OV04krv2RQM-00015-00004198-00004461": "Cicero's speeches of which only 5 is in", "OV04krv2RQM-00016-00004462-00004722": "P sonam Pro Skaro Pro Malone pro", "OV04krv2RQM-00017-00004723-00004961": "cornelio and in toga Candida in a very", "OV04krv2RQM-00018-00004962-00005168": "mutilated edition are preserved under", "OV04krv2RQM-00019-00005169-00005375": "the modern title q Ascona pedi on e", "OV04krv2RQM-00020-00005376-00005627": "oration vm Cicero knees Quinn clay and a", "OV04krv2RQM-00021-00005628-00005961": "ratio in an ode upon the speech proscar", "OV04krv2RQM-00022-00005962-00006209": "oh he speaks of longest see Cena died ad", "OV04krv2RQM-00023-00006210-00006441": "57 as still living while his words", "OV04krv2RQM-00024-00006442-00006720": "implied that Claudius died ad 54 was not", "OV04krv2RQM-00025-00006720-00007002": "alive this statement therefore must have", "OV04krv2RQM-00026-00007003-00007359": "been written between ad 54 and 57 these", "OV04krv2RQM-00027-00007359-00007559": "valuable notes written in good Latin", "OV04krv2RQM-00028-00007561-00007752": "relate chiefly to historical and", "OV04krv2RQM-00029-00007753-00008024": "antiquarian matters a commentary of", "OV04krv2RQM-00030-00008025-00008235": "superior latinidad mainly of a", "OV04krv2RQM-00031-00008236-00008456": "grammatical character on Cicero's Vereen", "OV04krv2RQM-00032-00008457-00008523": "orations", "OV04krv2RQM-00033-00008524-00008667": "was transmitted alongside the", "OV04krv2RQM-00034-00008668-00008849": "commentaries of Estonia's but is", "OV04krv2RQM-00035-00008850-00009002": "regarded as a fourth or fifth century", "OV04krv2RQM-00036-00009003-00009258": "work both works were found by poggio in", "OV04krv2RQM-00037-00009259-00009612": "a manuscript at st. Gallen in 1416 this", "OV04krv2RQM-00038-00009613-00009863": "manuscript is lost but three transcripts", "OV04krv2RQM-00039-00009864-00010095": "were made by poggio so Meany sozo", "OV04krv2RQM-00040-00010096-00010313": "meanness a pistoia and Bartolomeo da", "OV04krv2RQM-00041-00010314-00010628": "Montepulciano that of poggio is now at", "OV04krv2RQM-00042-00010629-00010899": "Madrid mattre tensest X 81 and that of", "OV04krv2RQM-00043-00010900-00011096": "zou Meany is in the Forte Garry library", "OV04krv2RQM-00044-00011097-00011477": "at pistoia number 37 a copy of Bartolome", "OV04krv2RQM-00045-00011478-00011706": "o--'s transcript exists in florence lore", "OV04krv2RQM-00046-00011707-00011984": "5 the later manuscripts are derived from", "OV04krv2RQM-00047-00011985-00012234": "Poe Geo's copy other works attributed to", "OV04krv2RQM-00048-00012235-00012599": "ESCO Gnaeus were a life of Sallust", "OV04krv2RQM-00049-00012600-00012758": "a defense of Virgil against his", "OV04krv2RQM-00050-00012759-00013037": "detractors a treatise perhaps a", "OV04krv2RQM-00051-00013038-00013250": "symposium in imitation of Plato on", "OV04krv2RQM-00052-00013251-00013730": "health and long life", "OV04krv2RQM-00053-00013731-00014177": "soppec editions", "OV04krv2RQM-00054-00014178-00014633": "Keasling and shoal 1875 Albert Curtis", "OV04krv2RQM-00055-00014634-00014963": "Clark Oxford 1907 contains a previously", "OV04krv2RQM-00056-00014963-00015134": "unpublished collation of Poe Geo's", "OV04krv2RQM-00057-00015135-00015466": "manuscript Ascona is online on Attalus", "OV04krv2RQM-00058-00015468-00015816": "org", "OV04krv2RQM-00059-00015816-00016350": "topic references", "OV04krv2RQM-00060-00016351-00016653": "Johan nickel I'm advocacy ownio Padilla", "OV04krv2RQM-00061-00016654-00017082": "no 18:28 be a marshal a historical", "OV04krv2RQM-00062-00017083-00017344": "commentary on ESCO Gnaeus colombia", "OV04krv2RQM-00063-00017345-00017502": "universe", "OV04krv2RQM-00064-00017503-00017943": "1985 ASCO Gnaeus commentaries on 5", "OV04krv2RQM-00065-00017944-00018459": "speeches of Cicero Simon Squires 1990"}}, {"audio_id": "OVfuJHZTJNg", "text": {"OVfuJHZTJNg-00000-00000035-00000164": "hello", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00001-00000165-00002026": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00002-00002027-00002098": "okay", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00003-00002099-00002502": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00004-00002503-00003413": "yes I'm saying forever", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00005-00003414-00005675": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00006-00005676-00007136": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00007-00007137-00008346": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00008-00008347-00008555": "thank you", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00009-00008556-00009336": "as a circle exam 11 minutes", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00010-00009337-00010141": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00011-00010142-00010921": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00012-00010922-00012556": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00013-00012557-00013024": "Brothers", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00014-00013025-00014038": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00015-00014038-00014435": "[Music]", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00016-00014436-00014851": "foreign", "OVfuJHZTJNg-00017-00014852-00015180": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "OVhKclanLW8", "text": {"OVhKclanLW8-00000-00000000-00000238": "and welcome to our broadcast this", "OVhKclanLW8-00001-00000239-00000511": "morning facebook comrades and", "OVhKclanLW8-00002-00000512-00000767": "youtube comrades and everybody who sees", "OVhKclanLW8-00003-00000768-00000886": "this in", "OVhKclanLW8-00004-00000888-00001039": "any venue", "OVhKclanLW8-00005-00001040-00001327": "we're happy to have you rosanna michael", "OVhKclanLW8-00006-00001328-00001767": "anita and scott hello good morning good", "OVhKclanLW8-00007-00001768-00002126": "morning revolution good morning", "OVhKclanLW8-00008-00002127-00002407": "well um it is a bright beautiful morning", "OVhKclanLW8-00009-00002408-00002607": "here in new york city", "OVhKclanLW8-00010-00002608-00002702": "uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00011-00002703-00002855": "and uh but that doesn't stop the", "OVhKclanLW8-00012-00002856-00003095": "homeless crisis", "OVhKclanLW8-00013-00003096-00003443": "and it doesn't stop a bad jobs report", "OVhKclanLW8-00014-00003444-00003554": "[Music]", "OVhKclanLW8-00015-00003555-00003759": "194 thousand", "OVhKclanLW8-00016-00003760-00003870": "only", "OVhKclanLW8-00017-00003871-00004079": "one nine four thousand they said it was", "OVhKclanLW8-00018-00004079-00004303": "gonna be 500.", "OVhKclanLW8-00019-00004304-00004559": "this morning i that was the", "OVhKclanLW8-00020-00004560-00004831": "pre-projection", "OVhKclanLW8-00021-00004832-00005191": "but it was you know not even close", "OVhKclanLW8-00022-00005192-00005511": "not even half of that um", "OVhKclanLW8-00023-00005512-00005670": "and uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00024-00005671-00005959": "rosanna the economy is continuing to", "OVhKclanLW8-00025-00005960-00006111": "sputter", "OVhKclanLW8-00026-00006112-00006311": "wouldn't you say", "OVhKclanLW8-00027-00006312-00006527": "yeah i'm angry they're supposed to have", "OVhKclanLW8-00028-00006528-00006639": "expected", "OVhKclanLW8-00029-00006640-00006959": "the growth because the end of the uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00030-00006959-00007087": "the federal", "OVhKclanLW8-00031-00007088-00007270": "stimulus and", "OVhKclanLW8-00032-00007272-00007495": "all these other things", "OVhKclanLW8-00033-00007495-00007687": "so i don't know", "OVhKclanLW8-00034-00007688-00007895": "i'm not sure why", "OVhKclanLW8-00035-00007895-00008023": "people don't want to go back to work", "OVhKclanLW8-00036-00008023-00008142": "scott", "OVhKclanLW8-00037-00008143-00008303": "well i think a lot of people", "OVhKclanLW8-00038-00008304-00008463": "a lot of people can't go back to work", "OVhKclanLW8-00039-00008464-00008783": "right because schools are still not", "OVhKclanLW8-00040-00008784-00008983": "you know fully and reliably open there", "OVhKclanLW8-00041-00008984-00009263": "are a lot of outbreaks uh closures", "OVhKclanLW8-00042-00009264-00009414": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00043-00009415-00009495": "and", "OVhKclanLW8-00044-00009496-00009623": "uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00045-00009624-00009814": "you know it's so it's not just", "OVhKclanLW8-00046-00009815-00009974": "wanting to go back to work it's the the", "OVhKclanLW8-00047-00009975-00010206": "concrete possibility and the other thing", "OVhKclanLW8-00048-00010207-00010367": "is that you know when the when these", "OVhKclanLW8-00049-00010368-00010527": "wage", "OVhKclanLW8-00050-00010528-00010806": "increases started happening because um", "OVhKclanLW8-00051-00010807-00010974": "employers were there was a so-called", "OVhKclanLW8-00052-00010975-00011127": "labor shortage or", "OVhKclanLW8-00053-00011128-00011263": "or whatever", "OVhKclanLW8-00054-00011264-00011414": "uh companies started bumping up their", "OVhKclanLW8-00055-00011415-00011703": "wages um i think a lot of people", "OVhKclanLW8-00056-00011704-00011942": "interpreted that as wow you know this is", "OVhKclanLW8-00057-00011943-00012159": "like finally workers are in a position", "OVhKclanLW8-00058-00012160-00012383": "of power and our you know wages are", "OVhKclanLW8-00059-00012384-00012670": "going up and whatever and", "OVhKclanLW8-00060-00012671-00012807": "you know worker's power doesn't come", "OVhKclanLW8-00061-00012808-00012935": "from the market it comes from", "OVhKclanLW8-00062-00012936-00013151": "organization um", "OVhKclanLW8-00063-00013152-00013230": "and", "OVhKclanLW8-00064-00013231-00013438": "so those those gains", "OVhKclanLW8-00065-00013440-00013615": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00066-00013616-00013838": "in in wages are are i think now being", "OVhKclanLW8-00067-00013840-00013975": "offset by", "OVhKclanLW8-00068-00013976-00014086": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00069-00014087-00014263": "you know reluctance to hire on the part", "OVhKclanLW8-00070-00014263-00014422": "of employers and and", "OVhKclanLW8-00071-00014423-00014711": "um increasing overwork of", "OVhKclanLW8-00072-00014712-00014935": "uh employees that are uh that are", "OVhKclanLW8-00073-00014936-00015047": "employed", "OVhKclanLW8-00074-00015047-00015199": "i mean", "OVhKclanLW8-00075-00015200-00015486": "i just read this idea scott", "OVhKclanLW8-00076-00015487-00015871": "that wages are rising according to some", "OVhKclanLW8-00077-00015872-00016175": "of the bourgeois economists", "OVhKclanLW8-00078-00016176-00016303": "and plus", "OVhKclanLW8-00079-00016304-00016543": "you got", "OVhKclanLW8-00080-00016544-00016886": "the child tax credit in your pocket", "OVhKclanLW8-00081-00016887-00017150": "and they said that people are", "OVhKclanLW8-00082-00017151-00017263": "that that", "OVhKclanLW8-00083-00017264-00017647": "feeling comfortable i actually read that", "OVhKclanLW8-00084-00017648-00017830": "they feel uncomfortable", "OVhKclanLW8-00085-00017831-00017935": "and", "OVhKclanLW8-00086-00017936-00018255": "it strengthens the position of labor", "OVhKclanLW8-00087-00018256-00018463": "you don't agree with that uh i think", "OVhKclanLW8-00088-00018464-00018679": "what strengthens the position of labor", "OVhKclanLW8-00089-00018680-00018767": "is", "OVhKclanLW8-00090-00018768-00018975": "organizing and", "OVhKclanLW8-00091-00018976-00019183": "um we're seeing a lot of that you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00092-00019184-00019391": "the the strike wave that you've talked", "OVhKclanLW8-00093-00019392-00019935": "about before is um is ongoing um but", "OVhKclanLW8-00094-00019936-00020127": "yes i mean we should we should be clear", "OVhKclanLW8-00095-00020128-00020263": "especially the", "OVhKclanLW8-00096-00020264-00020407": "the the", "OVhKclanLW8-00097-00020408-00020599": "extension of the supplemental", "OVhKclanLW8-00098-00020600-00020839": "unemployment uh benefits in the first", "OVhKclanLW8-00099-00020840-00021078": "round of covet relief under biden that", "OVhKclanLW8-00100-00021079-00021150": "was", "OVhKclanLW8-00101-00021151-00021335": "that was huge and it did", "OVhKclanLW8-00102-00021336-00021583": "put pressure on employers to raise wages", "OVhKclanLW8-00103-00021584-00021663": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00104-00021664-00021791": "but", "OVhKclanLW8-00105-00021792-00021886": "without", "OVhKclanLW8-00106-00021887-00022167": "i mean again the the power of workers", "OVhKclanLW8-00107-00022168-00022422": "doesn't come from", "OVhKclanLW8-00108-00022423-00022686": "from market forces it comes from", "OVhKclanLW8-00109-00022687-00022807": "how", "OVhKclanLW8-00110-00022808-00023094": "you know how organized we are", "OVhKclanLW8-00111-00023095-00023303": "but there are objective factors in media", "OVhKclanLW8-00112-00023304-00023671": "that that are influencing in the economy", "OVhKclanLW8-00113-00023672-00023839": "whether or not people want to go back to", "OVhKclanLW8-00114-00023840-00024055": "work i mean", "OVhKclanLW8-00115-00024056-00024230": "i had a guy tell me the other day in", "OVhKclanLW8-00116-00024231-00024407": "northeast ohio they got a big sign", "OVhKclanLW8-00117-00024408-00024647": "outside of a friendship", "OVhKclanLW8-00118-00024648-00024975": "uh factory so i will give you a 1500", "OVhKclanLW8-00119-00024976-00025303": "bonus if you come back to work", "OVhKclanLW8-00120-00025304-00025542": "i mean what do you think and then", "OVhKclanLW8-00121-00025543-00025855": "starvation wages after that um you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00122-00025856-00026214": "15 an hour okay okay well you know i'm", "OVhKclanLW8-00123-00026216-00026390": "glad they're i'm glad the the the", "OVhKclanLW8-00124-00026391-00026470": "florida", "OVhKclanLW8-00125-00026472-00026735": "starvation wages but not in", "OVhKclanLW8-00126-00026736-00026855": "and a warren", "OVhKclanLW8-00127-00026856-00027055": "but the but the counter side to that is", "OVhKclanLW8-00128-00027056-00027199": "they're also at least here in new york", "OVhKclanLW8-00129-00027200-00027358": "they're paying they're paying a hundred", "OVhKclanLW8-00130-00027360-00027743": "dollars to anyone who gets the vaccine", "OVhKclanLW8-00131-00027744-00028007": "anita so you're you're the b-o-o-r what", "OVhKclanLW8-00132-00028008-00028255": "are you saying to the working class", "OVhKclanLW8-00133-00028256-00028518": "well i i mean i think there i think we", "OVhKclanLW8-00134-00028519-00028862": "desperately need the biden's uh uh jobs", "OVhKclanLW8-00135-00028863-00029055": "bill he doesn't call it the job or they", "OVhKclanLW8-00136-00029056-00029302": "don't call it the jobs bill anymore but", "OVhKclanLW8-00137-00029304-00029535": "um but that bill that that has the child", "OVhKclanLW8-00138-00029536-00029831": "care subsidies and the um the uh the", "OVhKclanLW8-00139-00029832-00030127": "wages for uh the caring economy elder", "OVhKclanLW8-00140-00030127-00030455": "care and child care family leave act all", "OVhKclanLW8-00141-00030456-00030679": "of these things and child care subsidies", "OVhKclanLW8-00142-00030680-00031031": "i mean the the con the uh pandemic um", "OVhKclanLW8-00143-00031032-00031246": "recession really hit women hard and they", "OVhKclanLW8-00144-00031247-00031487": "still have not come back to the economy", "OVhKclanLW8-00145-00031488-00031758": "and they can't get child care to um that", "OVhKclanLW8-00146-00031760-00032014": "are that's reliable and sometimes as", "OVhKclanLW8-00147-00032016-00032214": "scott said there's their kids get sent", "OVhKclanLW8-00148-00032216-00032462": "home for you know two weeks because of", "OVhKclanLW8-00149-00032463-00032815": "uh covet outbreaks um so i think the the", "OVhKclanLW8-00150-00032816-00033127": "the anti-vaxxers and the anti-massacres", "OVhKclanLW8-00151-00033128-00033431": "are are delaying uh that that process", "OVhKclanLW8-00152-00033432-00033631": "but i think think also we need an", "OVhKclanLW8-00153-00033632-00033759": "infusion", "OVhKclanLW8-00154-00033760-00034023": "of federal support for those kind of", "OVhKclanLW8-00155-00034024-00034207": "jobs programs and i think that would be", "OVhKclanLW8-00156-00034208-00034415": "really the the way our economy could", "OVhKclanLW8-00157-00034416-00034583": "turn around a little bit", "OVhKclanLW8-00158-00034584-00034823": "and yeah we don't have a planned economy", "OVhKclanLW8-00159-00034824-00035031": "of course that would be even better", "OVhKclanLW8-00160-00035032-00035279": "mansion is calling it an entitlement you", "OVhKclanLW8-00161-00035280-00035518": "trying to create an entitlement society", "OVhKclanLW8-00162-00035519-00035671": "michael", "OVhKclanLW8-00163-00035672-00035974": "and we don't need an entitlement society", "OVhKclanLW8-00164-00035975-00036239": "we need a caring society you agree with", "OVhKclanLW8-00165-00036240-00036390": "that", "OVhKclanLW8-00166-00036391-00036471": "well", "OVhKclanLW8-00167-00036472-00036671": "i didn't hear that quote from mansion i", "OVhKclanLW8-00168-00036672-00036927": "was more disturbed by lindsey graham who", "OVhKclanLW8-00169-00036928-00037143": "did get the vaccine you know republican", "OVhKclanLW8-00170-00037144-00037399": "senator from um south carolina he was", "OVhKclanLW8-00171-00037400-00037671": "addressing some of his constituents", "OVhKclanLW8-00172-00037672-00037823": "a few days ago", "OVhKclanLW8-00173-00037824-00037959": "and", "OVhKclanLW8-00174-00037960-00038199": "when he suggested that they think about", "OVhKclanLW8-00175-00038200-00038415": "the vex just think about it that he was", "OVhKclanLW8-00176-00038416-00038615": "booed off the stage", "OVhKclanLW8-00177-00038616-00038759": "and so", "OVhKclanLW8-00178-00038760-00038959": "what kind of society is that you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00179-00038960-00039095": "that's a that's an", "OVhKclanLW8-00180-00039096-00039351": "i i think we need a society that um", "OVhKclanLW8-00181-00039352-00039495": "cares for one another we have to care", "OVhKclanLW8-00182-00039496-00039735": "for one another and you know part of us", "OVhKclanLW8-00183-00039736-00039959": "being communist is that we're", "OVhKclanLW8-00184-00039960-00040127": "we're we're selfless in that sense you", "OVhKclanLW8-00185-00040128-00040279": "know we maybe we don't like getting a", "OVhKclanLW8-00186-00040280-00040502": "needle in the arm but we have to you", "OVhKclanLW8-00187-00040503-00040695": "know all get vaccinated to stop this", "OVhKclanLW8-00188-00040696-00040871": "virus and you know in order for us to", "OVhKclanLW8-00189-00040872-00041102": "get back to work and for us to you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00190-00041103-00041358": "uh go back to normal", "OVhKclanLW8-00191-00041359-00041551": "like we were before the pandemic we're", "OVhKclanLW8-00192-00041552-00041702": "gonna have to suck it up and get this", "OVhKclanLW8-00193-00041703-00041902": "vaccine and so you know in in terms of", "OVhKclanLW8-00194-00041903-00042102": "mansion who doesn't get the job done", "OVhKclanLW8-00195-00042103-00042239": "holding all this up", "OVhKclanLW8-00196-00042240-00042462": "um in terms of these people like anita", "OVhKclanLW8-00197-00042463-00042702": "was saying anti-vaxxers the you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00198-00042703-00042871": "people who refuse to believe in science", "OVhKclanLW8-00199-00042872-00043135": "and uh debate all these uh conspiracy", "OVhKclanLW8-00200-00043136-00043318": "theories it's not helping anyone it", "OVhKclanLW8-00201-00043319-00043599": "affects them negatively as well", "OVhKclanLW8-00202-00043600-00043830": "well i think you and rosanna are right", "OVhKclanLW8-00203-00043831-00043999": "that the uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00204-00044000-00044302": "issue of the vaccine and covert is a big", "OVhKclanLW8-00205-00044303-00044407": "thing", "OVhKclanLW8-00206-00044408-00044583": "everybody spoke to this by the way", "OVhKclanLW8-00207-00044584-00044790": "keeping people away from", "OVhKclanLW8-00208-00044791-00044895": "some", "OVhKclanLW8-00209-00044896-00045151": "you know participating and going back to", "OVhKclanLW8-00210-00045152-00045383": "work and all of that and the quickest", "OVhKclanLW8-00211-00045384-00045646": "way to end that is to", "OVhKclanLW8-00212-00045647-00045855": "pull your arm up", "OVhKclanLW8-00213-00045856-00046102": "pull yours roll your sleeve up", "OVhKclanLW8-00214-00046103-00046351": "get the goddamn vaccine stop messing", "OVhKclanLW8-00215-00046352-00046486": "around", "OVhKclanLW8-00216-00046487-00046711": "you're gonna cause but the rate higher", "OVhKclanLW8-00217-00046712-00046927": "than california the rates going down", "OVhKclanLW8-00218-00046928-00047174": "proportion i mean that's the over deaths", "OVhKclanLW8-00219-00047175-00047415": "i hope so", "OVhKclanLW8-00220-00047416-00047662": "yeah it's going down considerably", "OVhKclanLW8-00221-00047663-00047767": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00222-00047768-00048055": "you know it's it's uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00223-00048056-00048399": "i think we had uh 10 deaths", "OVhKclanLW8-00224-00048400-00048590": "that were reported which is the really", "OVhKclanLW8-00225-00048591-00048807": "low not low low low number but you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00226-00048808-00048958": "in california and", "OVhKclanLW8-00227-00048959-00049223": "in los angeles where i live we have", "OVhKclanLW8-00228-00049224-00049415": "they've just implemented in fact it goes", "OVhKclanLW8-00229-00049416-00049574": "into effect today", "OVhKclanLW8-00230-00049575-00049902": "very strict laws that even if you go to", "OVhKclanLW8-00231-00049903-00050030": "a bar", "OVhKclanLW8-00232-00050031-00050255": "if you're going anywhere", "OVhKclanLW8-00233-00050256-00050527": "you need to have proof of vaccine so if", "OVhKclanLW8-00234-00050528-00050767": "you're going into the amusement parks", "OVhKclanLW8-00235-00050768-00051046": "uh all of those kinds of things you have", "OVhKclanLW8-00236-00051047-00051238": "to have either a", "OVhKclanLW8-00237-00051239-00051430": "negative covet test", "OVhKclanLW8-00238-00051432-00051702": "72 hours before it or you have to have", "OVhKclanLW8-00239-00051703-00051942": "proof of your vaccination in order to", "OVhKclanLW8-00240-00051944-00052119": "get into some of the in many of these", "OVhKclanLW8-00241-00052120-00052311": "venues and pretty much everything it's", "OVhKclanLW8-00242-00052312-00052479": "very very strict", "OVhKclanLW8-00243-00052479-00052719": "uh they're very serious about you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00244-00052720-00052959": "curving this too many people have died", "OVhKclanLW8-00245-00052960-00053071": "really", "OVhKclanLW8-00246-00053072-00053263": "you know too many people have died to", "OVhKclanLW8-00247-00053264-00053599": "just think of yourself", "OVhKclanLW8-00248-00053600-00053830": "has anybody been following what's going", "OVhKclanLW8-00249-00053832-00054087": "on in the uh with respect to the new", "OVhKclanLW8-00250-00054088-00054407": "report by the senate judiciary committee", "OVhKclanLW8-00251-00054408-00054519": "they", "OVhKclanLW8-00252-00054520-00054742": "say they detail how", "OVhKclanLW8-00253-00054744-00055079": "trump and them were trying to strong-arm", "OVhKclanLW8-00254-00055079-00055294": "the justice department to overturn the", "OVhKclanLW8-00255-00055295-00055615": "election i mean", "OVhKclanLW8-00256-00055616-00055879": "surprise anybody", "OVhKclanLW8-00257-00055879-00056126": "no i i just i just saw that his attorney", "OVhKclanLW8-00258-00056127-00056415": "one of his attorneys who resigned uh in", "OVhKclanLW8-00259-00056416-00056550": "georgia i think", "OVhKclanLW8-00260-00056551-00056687": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00261-00056688-00056863": "he said that you know he didn't know he", "OVhKclanLW8-00262-00056864-00057111": "didn't understand why but trump during", "OVhKclanLW8-00263-00057112-00057350": "during those those those final days of", "OVhKclanLW8-00264-00057351-00057519": "the uh of his", "OVhKclanLW8-00265-00057520-00057807": "administration was obsessed with georgia", "OVhKclanLW8-00266-00057808-00057982": "he really really thought", "OVhKclanLW8-00267-00057983-00058054": "that", "OVhKclanLW8-00268-00058055-00058263": "he could have never lost in georgia so", "OVhKclanLW8-00269-00058264-00058423": "he was he was convinced it wasn't just", "OVhKclanLW8-00270-00058424-00058575": "him you know carrying on and on he was", "OVhKclanLW8-00271-00058576-00058742": "really convinced by his own conspiracy", "OVhKclanLW8-00272-00058744-00058838": "theory", "OVhKclanLW8-00273-00058839-00058911": "and", "OVhKclanLW8-00274-00058912-00059030": "you know the people that were", "OVhKclanLW8-00275-00059032-00059199": "perpetuating them and i think that's", "OVhKclanLW8-00276-00059200-00059359": "dangerous because there was kind of", "OVhKclanLW8-00277-00059360-00059503": "remember i don't know if you all", "OVhKclanLW8-00278-00059504-00059671": "remember but the the", "OVhKclanLW8-00279-00059672-00059847": "mainstream media was really trying to", "OVhKclanLW8-00280-00059848-00060079": "disconnect um", "OVhKclanLW8-00281-00060079-00060294": "what trump did i guess the conservative", "OVhKclanLW8-00282-00060295-00060454": "media what what trump said in that", "OVhKclanLW8-00283-00060455-00060599": "speech when he said let's march on the", "OVhKclanLW8-00284-00060600-00060863": "capital from like the the kind of q anon", "OVhKclanLW8-00285-00060864-00061135": "and an all-right planning that took that", "OVhKclanLW8-00286-00061136-00061326": "took uh place before", "OVhKclanLW8-00287-00061327-00061526": "um they stormed the capital it was oh no", "OVhKclanLW8-00288-00061527-00061719": "it was it wasn't related but", "OVhKclanLW8-00289-00061720-00061935": "you know if he truly believed", "OVhKclanLW8-00290-00061936-00062111": "that and he wasn't just being a sore", "OVhKclanLW8-00291-00062112-00062342": "loser that he could have never possibly", "OVhKclanLW8-00292-00062344-00062542": "lost in a southern state like georgia", "OVhKclanLW8-00293-00062544-00062679": "you know that's pretty dangerous because", "OVhKclanLW8-00294-00062679-00062815": "that means that you know there was in", "OVhKclanLW8-00295-00062816-00063015": "fact a coup that he was planning", "OVhKclanLW8-00296-00063016-00063279": "and um you know fortunate for us you", "OVhKclanLW8-00297-00063279-00063511": "know the institutions kind of uh in", "OVhKclanLW8-00298-00063512-00063742": "place uh prevented that from happening", "OVhKclanLW8-00299-00063744-00063991": "um but it just goes to show that we're", "OVhKclanLW8-00300-00063991-00064166": "we're not out of this yet we're finding", "OVhKclanLW8-00301-00064167-00064303": "out more and more", "OVhKclanLW8-00302-00064304-00064503": "um as time goes on and as people you", "OVhKclanLW8-00303-00064504-00064638": "know begin to step forward and we're", "OVhKclanLW8-00304-00064639-00064830": "finding documents and conversations that", "OVhKclanLW8-00305-00064832-00065079": "are surfacing now and um", "OVhKclanLW8-00306-00065079-00065223": "as i understand it you know biden's", "OVhKclanLW8-00307-00065224-00065471": "approval ratings are dropping and trumps", "OVhKclanLW8-00308-00065472-00065638": "are are going up you know more p i don't", "OVhKclanLW8-00309-00065639-00065838": "think it's quite 50 yet i think the", "OVhKclanLW8-00310-00065839-00066038": "latest number i saw was 44", "OVhKclanLW8-00311-00066039-00066303": "but there's already trump 2024 flags", "OVhKclanLW8-00312-00066304-00066447": "that you can see flying around and so", "OVhKclanLW8-00313-00066448-00066719": "that's a dangerous um it's a dangerous", "OVhKclanLW8-00314-00066720-00066967": "mentality that we're dealing with", "OVhKclanLW8-00315-00066968-00067255": "well you know the uh big issue though is", "OVhKclanLW8-00316-00067256-00067511": "that are still making plans i saw steve", "OVhKclanLW8-00317-00067512-00067655": "bannon", "OVhKclanLW8-00318-00067656-00067975": "calling for 20 000 shock troops", "OVhKclanLW8-00319-00067976-00068326": "to dismantle the administrative state", "OVhKclanLW8-00320-00068327-00068559": "once trump is re-elected he said we own", "OVhKclanLW8-00321-00068560-00068711": "this country", "OVhKclanLW8-00322-00068712-00068999": "anita and we need to start acting like", "OVhKclanLW8-00323-00069000-00069071": "it", "OVhKclanLW8-00324-00069072-00069255": "does he own ohio", "OVhKclanLW8-00325-00069256-00069535": "uh we have to be so vigilant of this uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00326-00069536-00069791": "of this trend and i think i'm sure there", "OVhKclanLW8-00327-00069792-00069959": "are folks in ohio who would really", "OVhKclanLW8-00328-00069960-00070294": "support that too but um you know yeah i", "OVhKclanLW8-00329-00070295-00070599": "i i don't know i'd like to think that he", "OVhKclanLW8-00330-00070600-00070791": "was defeated one time and he could get", "OVhKclanLW8-00331-00070792-00071006": "defeated again but i know there are", "OVhKclanLW8-00332-00071007-00071215": "rules in place there are voter", "OVhKclanLW8-00333-00071216-00071487": "suppression laws in place that will just", "OVhKclanLW8-00334-00071488-00071735": "make stealing the next election easier", "OVhKclanLW8-00335-00071736-00071999": "uh than it was for him to have stolen", "OVhKclanLW8-00336-00072000-00072238": "this one so uh yeah i think we're in a", "OVhKclanLW8-00337-00072239-00072406": "really dangerous place and we have to", "OVhKclanLW8-00338-00072407-00072606": "keep fighting against uh the fascist", "OVhKclanLW8-00339-00072607-00072959": "danger just like we said in 2020", "OVhKclanLW8-00340-00072960-00073062": "i think", "OVhKclanLW8-00341-00073063-00073247": "i think we have the numbers", "OVhKclanLW8-00342-00073248-00073487": "you know i think uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00343-00073488-00073662": "if we if", "OVhKclanLW8-00344-00073663-00073823": "even if with all of these things in", "OVhKclanLW8-00345-00073824-00073967": "place", "OVhKclanLW8-00346-00073968-00074159": "those of us that can go out and vote", "OVhKclanLW8-00347-00074160-00074415": "that can drive that you know withstand", "OVhKclanLW8-00348-00074416-00074582": "standing in line for six hours or", "OVhKclanLW8-00349-00074583-00074823": "whatever we're the ones who need to step", "OVhKclanLW8-00350-00074824-00075094": "up at this point in time a massive", "OVhKclanLW8-00351-00075095-00075375": "massive massive voter turnout", "OVhKclanLW8-00352-00075376-00075479": "can", "OVhKclanLW8-00353-00075480-00075782": "can really help in in preventing this", "OVhKclanLW8-00354-00075783-00075926": "take over", "OVhKclanLW8-00355-00075927-00076167": "so i think that you know and education", "OVhKclanLW8-00356-00076168-00076311": "of the workers", "OVhKclanLW8-00357-00076312-00076575": "into the process and all that is also", "OVhKclanLW8-00358-00076576-00076831": "necessary and we should be preparing for", "OVhKclanLW8-00359-00076832-00076959": "that", "OVhKclanLW8-00360-00076960-00077135": "so there's some elections coming up in", "OVhKclanLW8-00361-00077136-00077279": "virginia", "OVhKclanLW8-00362-00077280-00077399": "right", "OVhKclanLW8-00363-00077400-00077775": "and uh in new york city and in buffalo", "OVhKclanLW8-00364-00077776-00077911": "with a mayor", "OVhKclanLW8-00365-00077912-00078182": "when is the election uh in pennsylvania", "OVhKclanLW8-00366-00078183-00078455": "scott i think for a friend", "OVhKclanLW8-00367-00078456-00078671": "it's coming up soon i'm in new york but", "OVhKclanLW8-00368-00078672-00078799": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00369-00078800-00079094": "it's you right on the border right yeah", "OVhKclanLW8-00370-00079095-00079294": "you're a border straggler you should", "OVhKclanLW8-00371-00079295-00079535": "vote i'm looking forward to", "OVhKclanLW8-00372-00079536-00079767": "god i hope uh john fetterman wins the", "OVhKclanLW8-00373-00079768-00080047": "senate race in in pennsylvania um and", "OVhKclanLW8-00374-00080048-00080326": "when is the election in ohio anita well", "OVhKclanLW8-00375-00080327-00080638": "uh november 2nd but we have uh in my own", "OVhKclanLW8-00376-00080639-00080838": "district where i live we have allison", "OVhKclanLW8-00377-00080839-00080943": "russo", "OVhKclanLW8-00378-00080944-00081279": "uh a democrat running against mike casey", "OVhKclanLW8-00379-00081280-00081511": "i think his name is mike casey is a", "OVhKclanLW8-00380-00081512-00081775": "trump republican who um", "OVhKclanLW8-00381-00081776-00081967": "you know it's an em it's an open seat", "OVhKclanLW8-00382-00081968-00082279": "the uh the incumbent resigned um and", "OVhKclanLW8-00383-00082280-00082550": "mike casey is a formal former coal", "OVhKclanLW8-00384-00082551-00082911": "lobbyist and all really tied up in some", "OVhKclanLW8-00385-00082912-00083215": "really shady stuff in in west virginia", "OVhKclanLW8-00386-00083216-00083375": "and he's running it's a it's a", "OVhKclanLW8-00387-00083376-00083647": "gerrymandered republican district uh but", "OVhKclanLW8-00388-00083648-00083855": "we're trying our best we're getting", "OVhKclanLW8-00389-00083856-00084047": "getting people out on the street to try", "OVhKclanLW8-00390-00084048-00084318": "to try to defeat mike casey because we", "OVhKclanLW8-00391-00084319-00084615": "don't want him in in congress definitely", "OVhKclanLW8-00392-00084616-00084855": "well the right wing wins again we're", "OVhKclanLW8-00393-00084856-00085031": "going to have to take our billions of", "OVhKclanLW8-00394-00085032-00085415": "dollars that we have located offshore", "OVhKclanLW8-00395-00085416-00085615": "what's the name of that new scandal that", "OVhKclanLW8-00396-00085616-00085847": "they have pandora papers", "OVhKclanLW8-00397-00085848-00086118": "pandora papers and uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00398-00086119-00086367": "now we can go to switzerland live up in", "OVhKclanLW8-00399-00086368-00086687": "the alps or the chateau", "OVhKclanLW8-00400-00086688-00087071": "uh scott and drink brandy and ski and", "OVhKclanLW8-00401-00087072-00087279": "smoke cocaine and", "OVhKclanLW8-00402-00087280-00087479": "you know that that scandal", "OVhKclanLW8-00403-00087480-00087703": "that scandal is not isolated from the", "OVhKclanLW8-00404-00087704-00087879": "fascist danger either they found you", "OVhKclanLW8-00405-00087880-00088191": "know three right-wing uh candidates or i", "OVhKclanLW8-00406-00088192-00088382": "guess uh politicians in latin america", "OVhKclanLW8-00407-00088383-00088567": "the president of recently elected", "OVhKclanLW8-00408-00088568-00088799": "president of ecuador the right-wing", "OVhKclanLW8-00409-00088800-00088982": "almost like pinochet like dictator", "OVhKclanLW8-00410-00088983-00089215": "pinera right now in chile and the", "OVhKclanLW8-00411-00089216-00089455": "dominican president uh abhinav they're", "OVhKclanLW8-00412-00089456-00089703": "all related to that scandal as well and", "OVhKclanLW8-00413-00089704-00089967": "so i don't know i think and then going", "OVhKclanLW8-00414-00089968-00090175": "back to talking about the elections", "OVhKclanLW8-00415-00090176-00090438": "again i i don't think people should they", "OVhKclanLW8-00416-00090439-00090575": "were warning people on uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00417-00090576-00090815": "spanish-language news television uh the", "OVhKclanLW8-00418-00090816-00091015": "other day telemundo univision they were", "OVhKclanLW8-00419-00091016-00091167": "saying you know don't think that the", "OVhKclanLW8-00420-00091168-00091391": "republicans can't win in new york you", "OVhKclanLW8-00421-00091392-00091575": "know we have adams you know former", "OVhKclanLW8-00422-00091576-00091775": "republican african-american former", "OVhKclanLW8-00423-00091776-00091926": "police officer running as a democratic", "OVhKclanLW8-00424-00091927-00092118": "candidate and the right-wing candidate", "OVhKclanLW8-00425-00092119-00092318": "forget his name slipping me right now", "OVhKclanLW8-00426-00092319-00092535": "looks so ridiculous wearing his like red", "OVhKclanLW8-00427-00092536-00092782": "beret you know like a fascist but we've", "OVhKclanLW8-00428-00092783-00092982": "had two republicans in recent history be", "OVhKclanLW8-00429-00092983-00093231": "the mayor of new york you know um we had", "OVhKclanLW8-00430-00093232-00093462": "bloomberg we had giuliani and then you", "OVhKclanLW8-00431-00093463-00093631": "know cuomo stepped down", "OVhKclanLW8-00432-00093632-00093759": "um and so you know there's going to be", "OVhKclanLW8-00433-00093760-00093943": "the the governor race as well and so", "OVhKclanLW8-00434-00093944-00094111": "there's just you can't just take things", "OVhKclanLW8-00435-00094112-00094238": "for granted and say oh that'll never", "OVhKclanLW8-00436-00094239-00094423": "happen that'll never happen um the", "OVhKclanLW8-00437-00094424-00094638": "struggle continues well i want to get", "OVhKclanLW8-00438-00094639-00094823": "back to this question of the the report", "OVhKclanLW8-00439-00094824-00095031": "from the senate judiciary committee", "OVhKclanLW8-00440-00095032-00095182": "uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00441-00095183-00095335": "for a sec because", "OVhKclanLW8-00442-00095336-00095438": "it", "OVhKclanLW8-00443-00095439-00095599": "it seems like you know since the", "OVhKclanLW8-00444-00095600-00095774": "beginning of trump's presidency there's", "OVhKclanLW8-00445-00095775-00095879": "been this", "OVhKclanLW8-00446-00095880-00096015": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00447-00096016-00096159": "continual", "OVhKclanLW8-00448-00096160-00096574": "uh stream of reports of all kinds of the", "OVhKclanLW8-00449-00096575-00096950": "shadiest and most criminal behavior um", "OVhKclanLW8-00450-00096951-00097182": "with the mueller report being the you", "OVhKclanLW8-00451-00097183-00097303": "know the most", "OVhKclanLW8-00452-00097304-00097550": "prominent example and what happened with", "OVhKclanLW8-00453-00097551-00097694": "the mueller report seems to be like a", "OVhKclanLW8-00454-00097695-00097855": "kind of paradigm for the rest of it", "OVhKclanLW8-00455-00097856-00098087": "where you have this report with oh yeah", "OVhKclanLW8-00456-00098088-00098279": "we have all this", "OVhKclanLW8-00457-00098280-00098503": "but we're not gonna charge anybody", "OVhKclanLW8-00458-00098504-00098694": "right we're not gonna actually", "OVhKclanLW8-00459-00098695-00098799": "um", "OVhKclanLW8-00460-00098800-00098887": "you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00461-00098888-00099167": "prosecute um and", "OVhKclanLW8-00462-00099168-00099391": "there seems to be this", "OVhKclanLW8-00463-00099392-00099494": "sort of", "OVhKclanLW8-00464-00099495-00099735": "it seems like they're the investigations", "OVhKclanLW8-00465-00099736-00099855": "they're hoping they work as like a", "OVhKclanLW8-00466-00099856-00100103": "propaganda campaign if we just like make", "OVhKclanLW8-00467-00100104-00100382": "people aware of how shady all of this", "OVhKclanLW8-00468-00100383-00100638": "was they'll but that's not", "OVhKclanLW8-00469-00100639-00100806": "that's not what the government needs to", "OVhKclanLW8-00470-00100807-00101062": "do at this point if these institutions", "OVhKclanLW8-00471-00101063-00101343": "as michael said are are going to", "OVhKclanLW8-00472-00101344-00101599": "play some role in in preventing the", "OVhKclanLW8-00473-00101600-00101918": "fascist danger it needs to be more than", "OVhKclanLW8-00474-00101919-00102023": "than just", "OVhKclanLW8-00475-00102024-00102311": "you know threats of resignations or you", "OVhKclanLW8-00476-00102312-00102615": "know revelations of shady behavior it", "OVhKclanLW8-00477-00102616-00102830": "needs to be actual", "OVhKclanLW8-00478-00102831-00102982": "you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00479-00102983-00103199": "i'm you know not it feels weird as a", "OVhKclanLW8-00480-00103200-00103375": "communist to be saying you know bring", "OVhKclanLW8-00481-00103376-00103502": "the hammer down", "OVhKclanLW8-00482-00103503-00103886": "state power uh whatever you know in a", "OVhKclanLW8-00483-00103888-00104182": "capitalist state but um", "OVhKclanLW8-00484-00104183-00104423": "i i think we should be demanding a much", "OVhKclanLW8-00485-00104424-00104630": "more aggressive uh investigation and", "OVhKclanLW8-00486-00104631-00104790": "prosecution of", "OVhKclanLW8-00487-00104791-00105047": "uh trump and his cronies and the entire", "OVhKclanLW8-00488-00105048-00105502": "january 6th affair", "OVhKclanLW8-00489-00105503-00105702": "yeah i heard one of the talking heads", "OVhKclanLW8-00490-00105703-00105958": "this morning say exactly what you're", "OVhKclanLW8-00491-00105959-00106086": "saying scott", "OVhKclanLW8-00492-00106088-00106310": "that they need to open up an", "OVhKclanLW8-00493-00106311-00106519": "investigation in the", "OVhKclanLW8-00494-00106520-00106815": "uh justice department with respect to", "OVhKclanLW8-00495-00106816-00107086": "their uh obstruction of justice and", "OVhKclanLW8-00496-00107088-00107439": "attempts to overturn the election stop", "OVhKclanLW8-00497-00107440-00107639": "playing around with it that's one part", "OVhKclanLW8-00498-00107640-00107878": "of it then the other part of it is that", "OVhKclanLW8-00499-00107879-00108119": "they're uh trying to they issue", "OVhKclanLW8-00500-00108120-00108302": "subpoenas this", "OVhKclanLW8-00501-00108303-00108566": "uh committee was to call the select", "OVhKclanLW8-00502-00108567-00108919": "committee on january the sixth to", "OVhKclanLW8-00503-00108920-00109078": "a bannon and", "OVhKclanLW8-00504-00109079-00109239": "three or four others", "OVhKclanLW8-00505-00109240-00109566": "and trump told them ignore it", "OVhKclanLW8-00506-00109567-00109790": "don't comply", "OVhKclanLW8-00507-00109791-00110215": "and the issue is how serious is the", "OVhKclanLW8-00508-00110216-00110383": "select committee and the justice", "OVhKclanLW8-00509-00110383-00110683": "department and congress to enforce those", "OVhKclanLW8-00510-00110683-00110839": "subpoenas", "OVhKclanLW8-00511-00110840-00111086": "are they gonna put them in jail if they", "OVhKclanLW8-00512-00111088-00111327": "don't show up or are they just using it", "OVhKclanLW8-00513-00111328-00111458": "for", "OVhKclanLW8-00514-00111459-00111799": "propagandistic uh purposes", "OVhKclanLW8-00515-00111800-00112063": "but here's the thing in my opinion", "OVhKclanLW8-00516-00112064-00112375": "all of that taken into consideration", "OVhKclanLW8-00517-00112376-00112775": "if you don't have movement on the ground", "OVhKclanLW8-00518-00112776-00112966": "if people are not", "OVhKclanLW8-00519-00112967-00113158": "protesting", "OVhKclanLW8-00520-00113159-00113351": "in big numbers", "OVhKclanLW8-00521-00113352-00113719": "pushing pushing pushing pushing", "OVhKclanLW8-00522-00113720-00113983": "all that stuff taking place on the top", "OVhKclanLW8-00523-00113983-00114231": "is just going to take place on the top", "OVhKclanLW8-00524-00114232-00114366": "they're going to make deals they're", "OVhKclanLW8-00525-00114367-00114486": "going to make", "OVhKclanLW8-00526-00114488-00114743": "compromises not their compromises", "OVhKclanLW8-00527-00114744-00114910": "okay you know you have to make", "OVhKclanLW8-00528-00114911-00115134": "compromises in life you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00529-00115135-00115495": "but the protests matter", "OVhKclanLW8-00530-00115496-00115719": "that's my slogan of the week rosanna", "OVhKclanLW8-00531-00115720-00115910": "protests matter", "OVhKclanLW8-00532-00115911-00116054": "and uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00533-00116055-00116263": "we were out there on the weekend by the", "OVhKclanLW8-00534-00116264-00116351": "way", "OVhKclanLW8-00535-00116352-00116583": "for the women's marches", "OVhKclanLW8-00536-00116583-00116710": "in d.c", "OVhKclanLW8-00537-00116711-00116934": "scott we had uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00538-00116935-00117223": "in new york city in columbus", "OVhKclanLW8-00539-00117224-00117463": "in houston", "OVhKclanLW8-00540-00117464-00117790": "you know party was out there public and", "OVhKclanLW8-00541-00117791-00117934": "uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00542-00117935-00118271": "and we're going to stay out there", "OVhKclanLW8-00543-00118272-00118415": "until", "OVhKclanLW8-00544-00118416-00118647": "justice is done which is", "OVhKclanLW8-00545-00118648-00119078": "that's going to be a long time 500 years", "OVhKclanLW8-00546-00119079-00119319": "i'll be dead and gone at that point but", "OVhKclanLW8-00547-00119320-00119463": "anyway", "OVhKclanLW8-00548-00119464-00119671": "i'm going to raise up the younger people", "OVhKclanLW8-00549-00119672-00119934": "to take to take our place", "OVhKclanLW8-00550-00119935-00120078": "uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00551-00120079-00120343": "michael do we have any", "OVhKclanLW8-00552-00120344-00120483": "programs coming", "OVhKclanLW8-00553-00120483-00120902": "up um we have one on the 17th a deep", "OVhKclanLW8-00554-00120903-00121102": "organizing um", "OVhKclanLW8-00555-00121103-00121351": "workshop you can go to cpusa.org and", "OVhKclanLW8-00556-00121352-00121519": "sign up for that", "OVhKclanLW8-00557-00121520-00121639": "and then towards the end of the month i", "OVhKclanLW8-00558-00121640-00121847": "believe it's the 24th we're going to", "OVhKclanLW8-00559-00121848-00122071": "have a class on rural communities how to", "OVhKclanLW8-00560-00122072-00122295": "organize rural workers um who live in", "OVhKclanLW8-00561-00122296-00122463": "you know republican controlled districts", "OVhKclanLW8-00562-00122464-00122599": "and some of them may be influenced by", "OVhKclanLW8-00563-00122600-00122831": "some of trump's backwards ideas you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00564-00122832-00122990": "we can't give up on that section of the", "OVhKclanLW8-00565-00122991-00123183": "working class and so comrade tim wheeler", "OVhKclanLW8-00566-00123183-00123407": "is going to lead the discussion on that", "OVhKclanLW8-00567-00123408-00123543": "topic", "OVhKclanLW8-00568-00123544-00123710": "all right then the labor commission is", "OVhKclanLW8-00569-00123711-00123895": "having a conference on", "OVhKclanLW8-00570-00123896-00124054": "the working class", "OVhKclanLW8-00571-00124055-00124183": "and different trends if you're", "OVhKclanLW8-00572-00124183-00124534": "interested write to us at cpusa", "OVhKclanLW8-00573-00124535-00124814": "cpusa.org", "OVhKclanLW8-00574-00124815-00125183": "uh we can uh we can hook you up", "OVhKclanLW8-00575-00125183-00125399": "but our movement is growing", "OVhKclanLW8-00576-00125400-00125710": "did y'all see that picture of grimes", "OVhKclanLW8-00577-00125711-00125975": "reading the manifesto", "OVhKclanLW8-00578-00125976-00126158": "she's not a party member we have to be", "OVhKclanLW8-00579-00126159-00126414": "clear people oh she's a party member", "OVhKclanLW8-00580-00126415-00126702": "we had to make that clear just like yeah", "OVhKclanLW8-00581-00126703-00126958": "yeah when cnn there were some criticisms", "OVhKclanLW8-00582-00126959-00127175": "for it", "OVhKclanLW8-00583-00127176-00127295": "they said oh", "OVhKclanLW8-00584-00127296-00127510": "this is bourgeois", "OVhKclanLW8-00585-00127511-00127702": "but if she were to join the communist", "OVhKclanLW8-00586-00127703-00128047": "party wouldn't we welcome her", "OVhKclanLW8-00587-00128048-00128286": "i mean yeah anyone willing to pick up", "OVhKclanLW8-00588-00128288-00128486": "the workers struggle should be welcome", "OVhKclanLW8-00589-00128488-00128719": "you know it's you know we've had we've", "OVhKclanLW8-00590-00128720-00128878": "had singers be in the part she's a", "OVhKclanLW8-00591-00128879-00129047": "singer we've had singers be in the party", "OVhKclanLW8-00592-00129048-00129247": "before paul robeson you know we have", "OVhKclanLW8-00593-00129248-00129463": "turned him away because he's a singer", "OVhKclanLW8-00594-00129464-00129607": "who has a little bit more money than the", "OVhKclanLW8-00595-00129608-00129854": "average oh we had singers actors", "OVhKclanLW8-00596-00129855-00130151": "musicians composers", "OVhKclanLW8-00597-00130152-00130399": "artists of all different and we still do", "OVhKclanLW8-00598-00130400-00130607": "you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00599-00130608-00130775": "i think that the issue is that she's", "OVhKclanLW8-00600-00130776-00130863": "rich", "OVhKclanLW8-00601-00130864-00131071": "and that she was dating", "OVhKclanLW8-00602-00131072-00131278": "elon musk", "OVhKclanLW8-00603-00131279-00131847": "and everybody hates him correctly so uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00604-00131848-00132087": "everybody makes mistakes", "OVhKclanLW8-00605-00132088-00132359": "everybody makes mistakes it's true", "OVhKclanLW8-00606-00132360-00132566": "the thing is is that she reading that", "OVhKclanLW8-00607-00132567-00132766": "well she wasn't reading she post she", "OVhKclanLW8-00608-00132767-00132919": "posed with a picture of it she said i'm", "OVhKclanLW8-00609-00132920-00133190": "not a communist um but i agree with you", "OVhKclanLW8-00610-00133191-00133390": "know universal basic income or you know", "OVhKclanLW8-00611-00133391-00133654": "whatever but the point is is that during", "OVhKclanLW8-00612-00133655-00133823": "the 1950s", "OVhKclanLW8-00613-00133824-00134039": "we had comrades or people even just", "OVhKclanLW8-00614-00134040-00134231": "closely associated progressive people in", "OVhKclanLW8-00615-00134232-00134543": "hollywood were arrested for even um you", "OVhKclanLW8-00616-00134544-00134759": "know holding progressive ideas so", "OVhKclanLW8-00617-00134760-00134911": "imagine what would have happened had", "OVhKclanLW8-00618-00134912-00135047": "they you know posted a picture of", "OVhKclanLW8-00619-00135048-00135199": "reading the manifesto that's what this", "OVhKclanLW8-00620-00135200-00135439": "is about you know i don't think", "OVhKclanLW8-00621-00135440-00135671": "i don't think anyone expects grimes to", "OVhKclanLW8-00622-00135672-00135814": "build the communist party or whatever", "OVhKclanLW8-00623-00135815-00136039": "but she's encouraging people to read", "OVhKclanLW8-00624-00136040-00136175": "marks and you know people who hadn't", "OVhKclanLW8-00625-00136176-00136351": "heard about marx before and they're in", "OVhKclanLW8-00626-00136352-00136478": "the grocery store and they picked up the", "OVhKclanLW8-00627-00136479-00136687": "tabloid they said oh maybe i should you", "OVhKclanLW8-00628-00136688-00136919": "know check that out more power to him", "OVhKclanLW8-00629-00136920-00137031": "it's double", "OVhKclanLW8-00630-00137032-00137278": "like everything under capitalism right", "OVhKclanLW8-00631-00137279-00137471": "because there's this sense where the", "OVhKclanLW8-00632-00137472-00137599": "ruling class", "OVhKclanLW8-00633-00137600-00137943": "wants to co-opt right they want to um", "OVhKclanLW8-00634-00137944-00138199": "make a spectacle of", "OVhKclanLW8-00635-00138200-00138399": "revolutionary and even progressive", "OVhKclanLW8-00636-00138400-00138727": "politics and sort of defang it right so", "OVhKclanLW8-00637-00138728-00139007": "but on the one hand you know it's it's", "OVhKclanLW8-00638-00139008-00139166": "part of that and it's not not i'm not", "OVhKclanLW8-00639-00139167-00139414": "saying that grimes personally has that", "OVhKclanLW8-00640-00139415-00139583": "tactic in mind but the ruling class as a", "OVhKclanLW8-00641-00139584-00139678": "whole", "OVhKclanLW8-00642-00139679-00139887": "does that with revolutionary ideas but", "OVhKclanLW8-00643-00139888-00140102": "that's also like i said double edged", "OVhKclanLW8-00644-00140103-00140311": "because it as michael was saying it", "OVhKclanLW8-00645-00140312-00140423": "exposes", "OVhKclanLW8-00646-00140424-00140527": "our", "OVhKclanLW8-00647-00140528-00140799": "ideas more so what", "OVhKclanLW8-00648-00140800-00140943": "determines", "OVhKclanLW8-00649-00140944-00141231": "which side it falls on who who benefits", "OVhKclanLW8-00650-00141232-00141478": "and it's like joe and rosanna everybody", "OVhKclanLW8-00651-00141479-00141647": "on the show always says it's the", "OVhKclanLW8-00652-00141648-00141775": "strength of the movement it's the", "OVhKclanLW8-00653-00141776-00142014": "organization the political development", "OVhKclanLW8-00654-00142015-00142383": "of the mass working-class movement the", "OVhKclanLW8-00655-00142384-00142607": "our success and the ideological struggle", "OVhKclanLW8-00656-00142608-00142759": "that's going to determine whether", "OVhKclanLW8-00657-00142760-00142911": "grime's posing with the communist", "OVhKclanLW8-00658-00142912-00143151": "manifesto is going to", "OVhKclanLW8-00659-00143152-00143287": "increase", "OVhKclanLW8-00660-00143288-00143566": "class consciousness and revolutionary uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00661-00143567-00143766": "thinking or whether it's going to you", "OVhKclanLW8-00662-00143767-00143847": "know", "OVhKclanLW8-00663-00143848-00144095": "co-opt and defang um it's not", "OVhKclanLW8-00664-00144096-00144263": "automatically that as soon as a rich", "OVhKclanLW8-00665-00144264-00144454": "person holds the manifesto", "OVhKclanLW8-00666-00144455-00144831": "uh you know it's automatically uh", "OVhKclanLW8-00667-00144832-00145087": "then co-opted or whatever", "OVhKclanLW8-00668-00145088-00145343": "and you have the last word until next", "OVhKclanLW8-00669-00145344-00145423": "week", "OVhKclanLW8-00670-00145424-00145607": "comrades and friends brothers and", "OVhKclanLW8-00671-00145608-00145919": "sisters stay strong stay safe", "OVhKclanLW8-00672-00145920-00146199": "and stay in the fight", "OVhKclanLW8-00673-00146200-00146660": "have a great day good morning revolution"}}, {"audio_id": "OVHwBtOuytY", "text": {"OVHwBtOuytY-00000-00000511-00003695": "[Music]", "OVHwBtOuytY-00001-00003696-00004151": "do", "OVHwBtOuytY-00002-00004152-00007956": "[Music]", "OVHwBtOuytY-00003-00007958-00008362": "[Applause]", "OVHwBtOuytY-00004-00008363-00011758": "[Music]", "OVHwBtOuytY-00005-00011759-00014422": "[Music]", "OVHwBtOuytY-00006-00014423-00014631": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "OVPOZBJ_eiQ", "text": {"OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00000-00000000-00000167": "we are going to see today two projects", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00001-00000168-00000318": "that were born during the first year of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00002-00000319-00000463": "the terraforming", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00003-00000463-00000647": "the transforming is this design research", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00004-00000648-00000878": "program hosts the stralka institute for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00005-00000880-00001095": "media architecture and design located in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00006-00001096-00001215": "moscow", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00007-00001216-00001383": "and the projects we are going to see", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00008-00001384-00001679": "today are cassandra and cosmos law both", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00009-00001680-00001823": "projects", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00010-00001823-00002039": "could say rely on modeling and sensing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00011-00002039-00002287": "as tools to address the transformations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00012-00002288-00002526": "required to face climate crisis", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00013-00002527-00002687": "cosmos law proposes a governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00014-00002688-00002895": "articulated but an independent their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00015-00002896-00003102": "dependency between different layers of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00016-00003103-00003303": "the celestial bodies that unchain a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00017-00003304-00003438": "feedback between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00018-00003439-00003622": "sensing ecosystems and resource", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00019-00003623-00003895": "extraction cassandra however speculates", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00020-00003896-00004079": "around a possible recursivity between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00021-00004079-00004319": "sensing and sovereignty for example to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00022-00004320-00004511": "define the control of our territory in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00023-00004512-00004735": "the case it is identified as a carrier", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00024-00004736-00005047": "of um resources or viable resources", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00025-00005048-00005295": "the program directed by benjamin bratton", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00026-00005296-00005447": "comes with the participation of an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00027-00005448-00005727": "amazing faculty the gathers and thinkers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00028-00005728-00005999": "as josie parika helen hester nandita", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00029-00006000-00006238": "sharma or rethane garistani", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00030-00006239-00006406": "to speculate about the transformations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00031-00006408-00006614": "that have to be planned on the earth to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00032-00006615-00006814": "enable it to remain a viable host for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00033-00006815-00006959": "life forms", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00034-00006959-00007134": "we will see the video", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00035-00007136-00007383": "that they developed that was presented", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00036-00007384-00007710": "at the end of the program in a way yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00037-00007711-00007910": "in a way that that end of the program i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00038-00007911-00008110": "would say that we like to understand the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00039-00008111-00008287": "the program or the end of the program as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00040-00008288-00008455": "the beginning actually", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00041-00008456-00008695": "um because it's when those researchers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00042-00008696-00008927": "start to overcome the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00043-00008928-00009078": "the framework or the proposal that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00044-00009079-00009278": "evangeline um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00045-00009279-00009614": "kind of present in this book no", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00046-00009615-00009791": "so after the videos they will share how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00047-00009792-00009959": "their searches are evolving and where", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00048-00009960-00010103": "are they now", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00049-00010104-00010295": "the term terraforming usually refers to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00050-00010296-00010495": "the transformation that ecosystems of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00051-00010496-00010671": "other planets or moons to make them", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00052-00010672-00010959": "capable of supporting us like life", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00053-00010960-00011119": "but the ecological consequences that we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00054-00011120-00011303": "start to experience nowadays due to the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00055-00011304-00011503": "human action on the planet suggests that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00056-00011504-00011687": "in the decades to come", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00057-00011688-00012023": "we will need to transform earth as well", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00058-00012024-00012223": "if it is to remain a viable horse for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00059-00012224-00012446": "earth like life terraform and then the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00060-00012447-00012631": "reforming then refers both to the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00061-00012632-00012822": "terraforming that has taken place on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00062-00012823-00012991": "earth in the past over the course of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00063-00012991-00013135": "urbanization", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00064-00013136-00013383": "and also to a reforming that must now be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00065-00013384-00013591": "planned and conducted as a planetary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00066-00013591-00013815": "design initiative to prevent future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00067-00013816-00013991": "catastrophes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00068-00013991-00014199": "some months ago kahanera translated the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00069-00014200-00014422": "text written by benjamin bratton that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00070-00014423-00014558": "works as the basis for the design", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00071-00014559-00014703": "research program", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00072-00014704-00014983": "this text constitutes the agenda of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00073-00014984-00015135": "issues that were to be addressed during", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00074-00015136-00015358": "the three editions of these six months", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00075-00015359-00015535": "think tank", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00076-00015536-00015799": "however it also sets a specific", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00077-00015800-00015950": "understanding of how this process of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00078-00015951-00016103": "transformation of the air have to be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00079-00016104-00016215": "addressed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00080-00016216-00016383": "from the assumptions from where to start", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00081-00016384-00016550": "to the selection of a certain set of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00082-00016551-00016830": "concepts or techniques to build a schema", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00083-00016831-00017039": "to the main language used the book", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00084-00017040-00017271": "constitutes a political statement", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00085-00017272-00017422": "the framework that benjamin bratton", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00086-00017423-00017591": "proposes has to be understood as a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00087-00017592-00017735": "starting point to be questioned and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00088-00017736-00017894": "problematized", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00089-00017895-00018047": "it was absolutely necessary and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00090-00018048-00018207": "radically important that he started this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00091-00018208-00018439": "conversation as much as it is necessary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00092-00018440-00018614": "now to evolve", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00093-00018615-00018703": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00094-00018704-00018879": "complete and shape", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00095-00018880-00019039": "the set of concepts", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00096-00019040-00019214": "i would say this is the reason why we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00097-00019215-00019455": "are here today to discuss different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00098-00019456-00019686": "ideas of how terraforming can be to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00099-00019687-00020039": "share speculate complexify open think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00100-00020040-00020311": "deconstruct construct reframe expand and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00101-00020312-00020550": "generate together alternative", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00102-00020551-00020799": "alternate yeah alternative the serial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00103-00020800-00021047": "terraform is to come", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00104-00021048-00021286": "braton's idea after reforming is one and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00105-00021287-00021447": "we can say is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00106-00021448-00021727": "his idea built up around like surrounded", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00107-00021728-00021975": "by a lot of people but it is a specific", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00108-00021976-00022191": "one that as he states is based in an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00109-00022192-00022343": "urbanism that is proclaiming for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00110-00022344-00022558": "artificial anti-collapse through", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00111-00022559-00022775": "universalist anti-totality", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00112-00022776-00022958": "pro-materialists", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00113-00022959-00023094": "etc", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00114-00023095-00023439": "etc and pro egalitarian distribution", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00115-00023440-00023630": "it is one that depends", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00116-00023631-00023863": "not defense that automation is a general", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00117-00023864-00023975": "principle", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00118-00023976-00024150": "by which ecosystems works and that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00119-00024151-00024311": "necessary fundamental shifts in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00120-00024312-00024478": "geotechnology are likely to precede", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00121-00024479-00024663": "necessary fundamental shifts in your", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00122-00024664-00024791": "politics", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00123-00024792-00024991": "but it is also one that still lives out", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00124-00024992-00025175": "many other significances forms of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00125-00025176-00025414": "organization reasons feelings ethics", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00126-00025415-00025519": "meanings", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00127-00025520-00025694": "systems values", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00128-00025695-00025918": "that are already operating in the planet", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00129-00025919-00026102": "today", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00130-00026104-00026190": "these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00131-00026191-00026431": "sets of or these other orders sometimes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00132-00026432-00026599": "are far from the dominant spheres of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00133-00026600-00026751": "knowledge", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00134-00026752-00026951": "but there is a lot that we can learn", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00135-00026952-00027174": "from them and it's important to include", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00136-00027175-00027358": "them in the conversation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00137-00027360-00027551": "to think about complete transform at", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00138-00027552-00027718": "complexity or test the scenario that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00139-00027719-00027943": "breton is proposing respond responds to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00140-00027944-00028158": "the conviction that this reforming is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00141-00028160-00028374": "still in the process to be designed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00142-00028375-00028558": "but maybe more the subscription that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00143-00028560-00028758": "this is not about a unique way there are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00144-00028760-00028895": "forming perhaps", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00145-00028895-00029031": "we shouldn't take the book as the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00146-00029032-00029223": "solution but as the opening of a process", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00147-00029224-00029462": "of design and conversation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00148-00029463-00029631": "to design a technological entanglement", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00149-00029632-00029823": "of plurality of mechanisms to be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00150-00029824-00029967": "activated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00151-00029968-00030207": "so it is wonderful to meet here two", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00152-00030208-00030495": "years after that you finish the program", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00153-00030495-00030655": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00154-00030656-00030927": "this initial kind of training to see how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00155-00030927-00031174": "the project has evolved how your ideas", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00156-00031175-00031327": "of how to ambition and design the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00157-00031327-00031502": "terraforming are evolving", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00158-00031503-00031743": "and articulating the touching or perhaps", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00159-00031744-00031918": "getting closer to benjamin's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00160-00031919-00032031": "framework", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00161-00032032-00032214": "a clear statement that we all fellows", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00162-00032216-00032407": "here is that the approach in the program", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00163-00032408-00032639": "is about raising questions instead of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00164-00032639-00032911": "giving answers or providing solutions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00165-00032912-00033151": "the design consists in the design of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00166-00033152-00033279": "question and the reformulation of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00167-00033280-00033518": "concepts that are used to deal with an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00168-00033519-00033759": "understanding of what is going on the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00169-00033760-00033927": "refraining of the narration that we have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00170-00033928-00034039": "been told", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00171-00034040-00034239": "so the program is about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00172-00034240-00034374": "looking at the reality from different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00173-00034375-00034551": "perspectives to be able to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00174-00034552-00034735": "reconceptualize our ideas given for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00175-00034736-00034943": "granted of what the planet is as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00176-00034944-00035183": "cassandra proposes the filter has always", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00177-00035184-00035399": "been here it is a matter to recognize", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00178-00035400-00035590": "the signals on time to be able to act", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00179-00035591-00035759": "over it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00180-00035760-00035830": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00181-00035831-00036062": "i would say this is all and we can start", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00182-00036063-00036363": "with the videos", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00183-00036364-00038311": "[Applause]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00184-00038312-00038487": "planetarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00185-00038488-00038639": "a condition rendered through the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00186-00038640-00038911": "extensive planetary scale computational", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00187-00038912-00039087": "infrastructures generating", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00188-00039088-00039343": "interdependent effects between different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00189-00039344-00039630": "scales locations and times", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00190-00039631-00039807": "it provides the epistemological", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00191-00039808-00040030": "framework that exposes the continuous", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00192-00040031-00040311": "and consequential flows of the planet", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00193-00040312-00040455": "as you look into the planetary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00194-00040456-00040639": "conditions of earth and its ongoing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00195-00040640-00040855": "climate crisis we see that current", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00196-00040856-00041055": "actions for dealing with climate change", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00197-00041056-00041255": "by the paris agreement proposed and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00198-00041256-00041527": "enforced mainly on a voluntary basis are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00199-00041528-00041727": "not enough", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00200-00041728-00041895": "unbalanced carbon cycles and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00201-00041896-00042135": "uncontrolled resource extraction review", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00202-00042136-00042327": "the absence of a plan to govern both", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00203-00042328-00042767": "planetarity and planetary conditions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00204-00042768-00042927": "what would a governance system for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00205-00042928-00043135": "climate change look like if it took", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00206-00043136-00043343": "earth as a part of space instead of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00207-00043344-00043639": "space as an expansion of earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00208-00043640-00043839": "what if our experience and comprehension", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00209-00043840-00044039": "of earth as a world expanded into a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00210-00044040-00044223": "different status closer to that of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00211-00044224-00044511": "moon mars and beyond", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00212-00044512-00044671": "a place where we necessarily have to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00213-00044672-00044871": "artificially plan its resources and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00214-00044872-00045071": "operate them via new and deliberate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00215-00045072-00045558": "legal and epistemological apparatus", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00216-00045559-00045935": "in russian the word for space is cosmos", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00217-00045936-00046127": "in its greek origin the concept of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00218-00046128-00046343": "cosmos describes the physical nature of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00219-00046344-00046532": "space and earth together", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00220-00046533-00046639": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00221-00046640-00046846": "contrary to astronauts which are those", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00222-00046847-00047015": "who traveled from airspace to outer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00223-00047016-00047271": "space cosmonauts are the ones who sailed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00224-00047272-00047462": "for the world planets and the stars as a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00225-00047463-00047639": "whole", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00226-00047640-00047902": "cosmos law proposes earth as a subset of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00227-00047903-00048046": "space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00228-00048047-00048239": "it is a holistic legal framework and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00229-00048240-00048462": "governance model that can replace an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00230-00048463-00048679": "outdated space law and update", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00231-00048680-00048879": "terrestrial governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00232-00048880-00049446": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00233-00049447-00049711": "humans have always been in movement it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00234-00049712-00049902": "is a natural logic that coincides with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00235-00049903-00050095": "nature's flows and tides", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00236-00050096-00050279": "but our history is also full of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00237-00050280-00050518": "limitation of national boundaries", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00238-00050519-00050735": "today's westphalian model of sovereignty", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00239-00050736-00050974": "implies that each state has exclusive", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00240-00050975-00051183": "power over its territory including", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00241-00051184-00051319": "resources", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00242-00051320-00051542": "however planetary flows obey different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00243-00051544-00051719": "spatial logic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00244-00051720-00051879": "geochemistry operates through a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00245-00051879-00052142": "decentralized flow that organizes and is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00246-00052144-00052390": "organized by interdependent multiscaler", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00247-00052391-00052663": "and polytemporal effect", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00248-00052664-00052854": "as western history centered human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00249-00052855-00053047": "boundaries as the mechanism for which to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00250-00053048-00053342": "govern planetary resources a fragmented", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00251-00053344-00053526": "and mismatched model of sovereignty took", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00252-00053527-00053647": "place", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00253-00053648-00053815": "one that configured imperialist", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00254-00053816-00054038": "expansions disputed markets and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00255-00054039-00054271": "short-term thinking and in the process", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00256-00054272-00054438": "shaped the initial legal blueprint that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00257-00054439-00054687": "would justify itself", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00258-00054688-00054903": "te tejanulis was one of the first legal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00259-00054904-00055087": "principles that set the tone for the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00260-00055088-00055350": "following generation of laws", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00261-00055351-00055599": "a latin expression for nobody's lent the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00262-00055600-00055815": "hanoi poses that if a land seems", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00263-00055816-00055966": "unoccupied then it's free for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00264-00055967-00056166": "acquisition through occupation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00265-00056167-00056375": "it is at the core of the roman empire", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00266-00056376-00056566": "expansion and that which gave the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00267-00056567-00056775": "contingent history of colonialism its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00268-00056776-00056926": "foundation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00269-00056927-00057126": "lands external of imperial sovereign", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00270-00057127-00057599": "territories were seen as empty outsides", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00271-00057600-00057750": "the following timeline with four", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00272-00057751-00057959": "examples will show how the te handuli's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00273-00057960-00058166": "mindset informed other practices", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00274-00058167-00058463": "conventions and treaties", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00275-00058464-00058694": "between the 16th and 18th centuries", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00276-00058695-00058911": "naval privateers such as the west india", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00277-00058912-00059094": "companies were private corporations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00278-00059095-00059311": "granted jurisdictional powers by the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00279-00059312-00059559": "north sea empires", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00280-00059560-00059735": "they acted as an extension of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00281-00059736-00059950": "sovereign state in colonies as a way to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00282-00059951-00060111": "resolve issues of control and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00283-00060112-00060406": "enforcement such as execute convicts and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00284-00060407-00060623": "negotiate treaties", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00285-00060624-00060838": "they extended foreign jurisdiction into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00286-00060839-00061006": "occupied land", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00287-00061007-00061342": "the guano island act from 1856 allowed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00288-00061344-00061535": "any american citizen to possess", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00289-00061536-00061766": "resources and proclaim united states", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00290-00061767-00062015": "jurisdiction in any unclaimed island", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00291-00062016-00062223": "with the bird guanophysis", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00292-00062224-00062430": "a valuable fertilizer and gunpowder", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00293-00062432-00062623": "production material", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00294-00062624-00062830": "under the guano island act more than a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00295-00062832-00062991": "thousand islands were occupied by the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00296-00062991-00063215": "united states and the act paved the way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00297-00063216-00063399": "for resources being claimed without", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00298-00063400-00063703": "territorial ownership", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00299-00063704-00064038": "it is currently is to enforce", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00300-00064039-00064230": "both practices are the precedent for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00301-00064232-00064471": "public and private cooperation as well", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00302-00064472-00064679": "as private forms of jurisdiction", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00303-00064679-00065006": "execution beyond national borders", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00304-00065007-00065319": "in 1961 the antarctic treaty system", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00305-00065320-00065526": "legislated that the continent should be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00306-00065527-00065791": "divided among several nations but the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00307-00065792-00066006": "mary bird land portion would remain", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00308-00066007-00066271": "unclaimed making it the single largest", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00309-00066272-00066591": "unclaimed territory on earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00310-00066592-00066935": "this agreement will expire in 2048 and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00311-00066936-00067167": "new claims over disputed areas might", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00312-00067168-00067503": "lead to a new global conflict", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00313-00067504-00067726": "common territories have had their status", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00314-00067727-00067975": "changed before when powerful actors are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00315-00067976-00068271": "interested in their resources", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00316-00068272-00068511": "such as the case of continental shelves", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00317-00068512-00068711": "underwater parts of the continents that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00318-00068712-00069023": "surround coastal lines of nation states", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00319-00069024-00069223": "these areas are full of assets such as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00320-00069224-00069455": "fossil fuels and were previously stated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00321-00069456-00069679": "as commons", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00322-00069680-00069950": "their status changed in 1964 with the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00323-00069951-00070159": "continental shelf convention which", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00324-00070160-00070350": "granted rights to countries to claim", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00325-00070351-00070543": "ownership and explore the areas for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00326-00070544-00070823": "their own benefit", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00327-00070824-00071015": "as different presidents shaped laws of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00328-00071016-00071199": "land occupation from international", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00329-00071200-00071350": "treaties to disputed political", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00330-00071351-00071575": "imaginaries and as technical and social", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00331-00071576-00071838": "apparatus allows humankind to go further", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00332-00071839-00072135": "into and exploit unknown territories", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00333-00072136-00072350": "one key factor becomes apparent", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00334-00072351-00072479": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00335-00072480-00072767": "legal frameworks are created by need", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00336-00072768-00072950": "by those who have the power to either", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00337-00072951-00073199": "shape them by convention and norm or by", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00338-00073200-00073511": "proposition and negotiation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00339-00073512-00073743": "not only space is seen as empty but the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00340-00073744-00074038": "space of law is also a tehanuli's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00341-00074039-00074247": "an empty space that gets occupied and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00342-00074248-00074532": "wielded on the go", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00343-00074533-00074655": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00344-00074656-00074935": "land resources and infrastructure", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00345-00074936-00075126": "are tied together in an intricate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00346-00075127-00075279": "relationship when it comes to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00347-00075280-00075679": "territorial exploration and occupation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00348-00075680-00075919": "it fragments planetarity and presumes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00349-00075920-00076119": "mismatched divisions for planetary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00350-00076120-00076294": "conditions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00351-00076295-00076511": "this relationship gets more complicated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00352-00076512-00076703": "as we expand throughout a space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00353-00076704-00077406": "repeating similar logic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00354-00077407-00077703": "when on october 4th 1957 the soviet", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00355-00077704-00077999": "union sent sputnik 1 into orbit a new", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00356-00078000-00078231": "horizon came into focus", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00357-00078232-00078503": "it was the beginning of the space race", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00358-00078504-00078679": "it's launched triggered a new set of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00359-00078680-00078862": "conventions and treaties regarding", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00360-00078863-00079038": "sovereign airspace and outer space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00361-00079039-00079175": "territory", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00362-00079176-00079343": "a new horizon of exploration and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00363-00079344-00079694": "occupation called for new legislation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00364-00079695-00079903": "the next timeline looks into space law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00365-00079904-00080311": "and three space treaties in more detail", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00366-00080312-00080615": "the outer space treaty from 1967 and its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00367-00080616-00080838": "three follow-ups laid a foundation for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00368-00080839-00081038": "international space law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00369-00081039-00081247": "because of its cold war baggage the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00370-00081248-00081455": "outer space treaty focused mainly on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00371-00081456-00081606": "safety and territory sovereignty", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00372-00081607-00081838": "concerns contemplating international", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00373-00081839-00081967": "peace", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00374-00081968-00082191": "its main point state outer space as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00375-00082192-00082406": "commons establishing that space is free", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00376-00082407-00082638": "for exploration and utilization by all", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00377-00082639-00082743": "nations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00378-00082744-00082967": "it forbids territorial claims in outer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00379-00082968-00083159": "space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00380-00083160-00083367": "yet it was full of gray areas", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00381-00083368-00083559": "one of them is the karman line the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00382-00083560-00083711": "border that divides where national", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00383-00083712-00084006": "airspace ends and outer space begins", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00384-00084007-00084247": "its actual position is still undefined", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00385-00084248-00084406": "making it possible for nations to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00386-00084407-00084606": "manipulate the airspace area for their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00387-00084607-00084782": "own purposes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00388-00084783-00084975": "the outer space treaty also failed to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00389-00084976-00085206": "provide a feasible framework for future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00390-00085207-00085455": "space issues such as lunar and asteroid", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00391-00085456-00085550": "mining", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00392-00085551-00085791": "debris management and commercialization", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00393-00085792-00085975": "of space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00394-00085976-00086262": "one follow-up is of special interest", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00395-00086263-00086575": "the moon treaty from 1979 envisioned an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00396-00086576-00086823": "updated framework more egalitarian and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00397-00086824-00087062": "accountable focusing on the use of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00398-00087063-00087375": "moon and other celestial bodies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00399-00087376-00087599": "it emphasized the concept of the common", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00400-00087600-00087815": "heritage of humankind to outer space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00401-00087816-00088047": "activities and proposed the creation of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00402-00088048-00088247": "a regime that would regulate mining and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00403-00088248-00088479": "prevent the moon and space resources", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00404-00088480-00088679": "from becoming a source of international", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00405-00088680-00088838": "conflict", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00406-00088839-00089031": "however it is still currently only", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00407-00089032-00089294": "ratified by 11 countries since powerful", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00408-00089295-00089518": "actors like the united states and russia", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00409-00089519-00089823": "didn't support its terms", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00410-00089824-00090006": "in an attempt to get leverage to an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00411-00090007-00090255": "unbalanced space race and orbital space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00412-00090256-00090494": "occupation equatorial countries put", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00413-00090495-00090862": "forward in 1976 the bogota declaration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00414-00090863-00091094": "which proposed that the geostationary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00415-00091095-00091311": "orbit of earth would be tied to its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00416-00091312-00091526": "corresponding locations country is a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00417-00091527-00091879": "gravitational sovereign expansion", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00418-00091880-00092118": "the geostationary orbit hosts most of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00419-00092119-00092311": "the communication satellites since its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00420-00092312-00092526": "fixed position allows for antennas to be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00421-00092527-00092743": "permanently pointed at their specified", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00422-00092744-00092911": "location", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00423-00092912-00093143": "again powerful nation states disregarded", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00424-00093144-00093350": "the proposition as it is in their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00425-00093351-00093574": "interest to maintain orbit occupation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00426-00093575-00094062": "unregulated or ambiguous", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00427-00094063-00094247": "since these treaties were first written", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00428-00094248-00094462": "space technologies have developed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00429-00094463-00094662": "the perspective on space exploration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00430-00094663-00094847": "also changed from being a display of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00431-00094848-00095031": "national power to an extremely", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00432-00095032-00095262": "profitable activity in the near future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00433-00095263-00095471": "the space industry is foreseen to reach", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00434-00095472-00095879": "1 trillion us dollars by 2040.", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00435-00095880-00096071": "another two contemporary legal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00436-00096072-00096311": "blueprints are worth mentioning", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00437-00096312-00096615": "with the 2015 space act the united", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00438-00096616-00096774": "states allowed its citizens and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00439-00096775-00096950": "industries to engage in the commercial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00440-00096951-00097167": "exploration and exploitation of space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00441-00097168-00097406": "resources paving the way for space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00442-00097407-00097582": "privatization", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00443-00097583-00097774": "an act that is very close to the guano", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00444-00097775-00097943": "island act and naval privateers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00445-00097944-00098279": "practices and in may 2020 nasa published", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00446-00098280-00098503": "the artemis accord a united states", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00447-00098504-00098711": "alternative to the moon treaty that sets", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00448-00098712-00098903": "the guidelines for the exploration and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00449-00098904-00099135": "occupation of the moon where prosperity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00450-00099136-00099447": "is as important as safety and peace", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00451-00099448-00099711": "by legalizing private space enterprises", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00452-00099712-00099894": "nation states will be able to hire", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00453-00099895-00100094": "private firms to provide a wider range", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00454-00100095-00100455": "of space services including space mining", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00455-00100456-00100735": "the june 2020 launch of nasa astronauts", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00456-00100736-00100991": "to orbit by spacex marked one of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00457-00100992-00101182": "most important shifts in the direction", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00458-00101183-00101382": "of states withdrawing from space and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00459-00101383-00101638": "giving room to markets", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00460-00101639-00101838": "today's space law says it protects the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00461-00101839-00101999": "common interest of the international", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00462-00102000-00102182": "community with due regard to the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00463-00102183-00102382": "corresponding interest of individual", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00464-00102383-00102630": "states so far it was successful", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00465-00102631-00102894": "primarily because it has corresponded to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00466-00102895-00103118": "the interest of major powers making", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00467-00103119-00103327": "space affairs indispensable from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00468-00103328-00103590": "terrestrial geopolitics", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00469-00103591-00103782": "as the economic interest of individual", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00470-00103783-00104015": "states in space arising a new robust", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00471-00104016-00104254": "international legal framework is needed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00472-00104255-00104486": "to ensure a balanced space exploration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00473-00104488-00104799": "that will actually benefit all humankind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00474-00104800-00104966": "furthermore the way we govern new", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00475-00104967-00105158": "resources and commons in space could", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00476-00105159-00105334": "define how we should govern the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00477-00105335-00105519": "terrestrial ones", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00478-00105520-00105710": "space law could become a model to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00479-00105711-00105943": "revisit the legal blueprints of resource", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00480-00105944-00106366": "exploration on earth itself", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00481-00106367-00106566": "after exploring the history of land and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00482-00106567-00106758": "outer space legislation a few", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00483-00106759-00106999": "problematics come into focus", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00484-00107000-00107166": "first is the question of west valley and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00485-00107167-00107319": "sovereignty when state power and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00486-00107320-00107463": "autonomy is contained within its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00487-00107464-00107615": "territory", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00488-00107616-00107799": "in space sovereignty is defined by the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00489-00107800-00108031": "vehicle and infrastructure meaning that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00490-00108032-00108254": "nation-states retain jurisdiction over", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00491-00108255-00108495": "cosmonauts or any spacecraft launched", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00492-00108496-00108719": "under their registry expanding their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00493-00108720-00109023": "territory to space via spacecraft", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00494-00109024-00109231": "countries like luxembourg already hold", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00495-00109232-00109647": "more space in space than on earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00496-00109648-00109799": "on the other side of sovereignty and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00497-00109800-00110031": "liability is orbit occupation and space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00498-00110032-00110166": "debris", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00499-00110167-00110334": "because nation states remain their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00500-00110335-00110583": "liability for any object they launch no", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00501-00110583-00110775": "one else can sees it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00502-00110776-00110990": "with no legal obligation to remove the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00503-00110991-00111223": "objects nations continue to occupy", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00504-00111224-00111431": "orbits without any consequence", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00505-00111432-00111663": "generating orbit gems and immense amount", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00506-00111664-00111831": "of debris", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00507-00111832-00112015": "infrastructure sovereignty is already", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00508-00112016-00112223": "redefining the westphalian model into a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00509-00112224-00112495": "radically vertical one and future orbit", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00510-00112496-00112734": "occupation depends on better regulation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00511-00112735-00112990": "of this verticality", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00512-00112991-00113215": "besides horizontal world order space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00513-00113216-00113358": "occupation is challenging other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00514-00113359-00113495": "boundaries too", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00515-00113496-00113702": "current planetary infrastructure is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00516-00113703-00113886": "already dependent on an increasing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00517-00113888-00114127": "number of space-based services and vice", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00518-00114128-00114415": "versa space infrastructure depends on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00519-00114416-00114663": "ground infrastructure", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00520-00114664-00114847": "the terrestrial network of ground", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00521-00114848-00115102": "stations and internet network enables", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00522-00115103-00115358": "space exploration reinforcing the fact", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00523-00115359-00115583": "that in order to go to space we need the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00524-00115583-00115815": "whole planet to cooperate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00525-00115816-00116015": "however there are specific places on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00526-00116016-00116190": "earth that are particularly well", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00527-00116191-00116454": "suitable for outer space activities", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00528-00116455-00116686": "their locations enable receiving signals", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00529-00116688-00116886": "that could not be caught everywhere", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00530-00116888-00117086": "such territories gain a different kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00531-00117088-00117263": "of leverage over space programs and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00532-00117264-00117463": "industries", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00533-00117464-00117683": "finally there is the issue of competing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00534-00117683-00117927": "planetarities earth's own planetarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00535-00117928-00118119": "came to view in different ways varying", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00536-00118120-00118319": "from astronomy to cold war military", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00537-00118320-00118454": "surveillance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00538-00118455-00118647": "yet the weather satellite monitoring and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00539-00118648-00118839": "modeling developed through the climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00540-00118840-00119086": "sciences have also generated the image", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00541-00119088-00119271": "of the earth as a planet", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00542-00119272-00119519": "this epistemological framework should be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00543-00119520-00119719": "radically used not only for climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00544-00119720-00119919": "monitoring but also for planetary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00545-00119920-00120295": "governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00546-00120296-00120527": "resource extraction infrastructure", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00547-00120528-00120854": "sovereignty debris removal and liability", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00548-00120855-00121039": "and the absence of leverage against", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00549-00121040-00121286": "powerful actors exposes how the present", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00550-00121288-00121534": "configuration of outer space exploration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00551-00121535-00121902": "still follows an empty outside logic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00552-00121903-00122119": "current international space law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00553-00122120-00122423": "continues to reproduce law as tejanulis", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00554-00122424-00122639": "instead of envisioning a legal status", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00555-00122640-00122804": "for planetarity as such", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00556-00122805-00123166": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00557-00123167-00123286": "cosmos", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00558-00123288-00123502": "the physical nature of earth and space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00559-00123503-00123702": "together", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00560-00123703-00123983": "cosmos law expands space law to include", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00561-00123983-00124207": "governance of planetary conditions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00562-00124208-00124383": "seeing the earth and outer space in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00563-00124383-00124614": "their indispensable connectivity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00564-00124615-00124854": "it opposes the tehanuli's mindset and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00565-00124855-00125183": "instead of seeing space as empty sees it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00566-00125183-00125379": "as full", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00567-00125380-00125823": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00568-00125824-00126039": "the main principles of cosmos law are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00569-00126040-00126247": "based on protecting a viable planetarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00570-00126248-00126439": "of celestial bodies for establishing and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00571-00126440-00126607": "protecting commons that ensure the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00572-00126608-00126814": "planetarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00573-00126815-00126999": "cosmos law operates through a model", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00574-00127000-00127175": "which embraces spatial and physical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00575-00127176-00127358": "properties that shouldn't be separated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00576-00127359-00127575": "from the legal apparatus", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00577-00127576-00127823": "it is composed of five layers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00578-00127824-00127975": "the boundaries of those layers are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00579-00127976-00128166": "defined by the physical conditions such", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00580-00128167-00128390": "as gravity size and mass of a celestial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00581-00128391-00128527": "body", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00582-00128528-00128727": "for cosmos law legislation should not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00583-00128728-00129023": "just be written but modeled", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00584-00129024-00129239": "the layers have different speciality but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00585-00129240-00129510": "also are largely interdependent", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00586-00129511-00129710": "next each of the layers is explored in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00587-00129711-00129919": "more detail", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00588-00129920-00130171": "in outer space cosmos law governs", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00589-00130172-00130390": "interplanetarity spatiality through a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00590-00130391-00130566": "mediation layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00591-00130567-00130814": "specifically it organizes logistical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00592-00130815-00131007": "issues such as travel in between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00593-00131008-00131254": "celestial bodies and asteroid capture", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00594-00131255-00131463": "and relocation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00595-00131464-00131663": "on the celestial bodies cosmos law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00596-00131664-00131775": "governs", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00597-00131776-00131983": "the orbits of the planets the orbital", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00598-00131984-00132111": "layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00599-00132112-00132351": "their planetary conditions the ecosystem", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00600-00132352-00132447": "layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00601-00132448-00132623": "the apparatus that informs those", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00602-00132624-00132902": "conditions the information layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00603-00132903-00133054": "and the surfaces and depths the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00604-00133055-00133231": "territorial layer of the celestial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00605-00133232-00133359": "bodies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00606-00133360-00133575": "the layers are consequent overlapping", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00607-00133576-00133831": "and interdependent", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00608-00133832-00134087": "the orbital layer governs material flows", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00609-00134088-00134311": "and activities located in the orbits of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00610-00134312-00134487": "a celestial body", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00611-00134488-00134678": "the layer sets a framework for more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00612-00134679-00134951": "egalitarian use of orbit space based on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00613-00134952-00135119": "the provisions defined by the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00614-00135120-00135295": "information layer and geopolitical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00615-00135296-00135647": "realities of the territorial layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00616-00135648-00135863": "the ecosystem layer defines a legal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00617-00135864-00136063": "framework for managing environmental", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00618-00136064-00136319": "flows and activities tied to the scale", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00619-00136320-00136487": "of effect on the ecosystem of a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00620-00136488-00136671": "celestial body", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00621-00136672-00136911": "its operations are largely informed by", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00622-00136912-00137095": "the orbital and information layers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00623-00137096-00137431": "providing satellite sensing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00624-00137432-00137654": "the information layer sets the rules for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00625-00137655-00137871": "information flows of planetary sensing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00626-00137872-00138039": "data collection storage and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00627-00138040-00138199": "communications", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00628-00138200-00138390": "the layer operates within radio", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00629-00138391-00138590": "frequency spectrum and includes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00630-00138591-00138814": "infrastructural facilities with adjacent", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00631-00138815-00139023": "areas that are needed to support", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00632-00139024-00139335": "planetary scale information networks", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00633-00139336-00139471": "due to ground to satellite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00634-00139472-00139727": "interdependence the layer is interlinked", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00635-00139728-00139911": "with the realities of the territorial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00636-00139912-00140014": "layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00637-00140015-00140207": "which finally governs territorial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00638-00140208-00140399": "divisions flows and extraction of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00639-00140400-00140647": "resources on and below the surface of a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00640-00140648-00140975": "celestial body whether solid or liquid", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00641-00140976-00141199": "it depends on the ecosystem layer's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00642-00141200-00141743": "carrying capacity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00643-00141744-00142102": "instead of a world earth as planet", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00644-00142103-00142335": "as cosmos law proposes a model for the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00645-00142336-00142551": "governance of many different celestial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00646-00142552-00142814": "bodies leveling their status it also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00647-00142815-00143126": "reframes the governance of earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00648-00143127-00143383": "under the cosmos law proposition we now", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00649-00143384-00143614": "explore in more detail how each layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00650-00143615-00143790": "could affect the management and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00651-00143791-00144063": "governance of earth's viable planetarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00652-00144064-00144263": "corresponding to the urgent terraforming", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00653-00144264-00144511": "we need in order to reverse current", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00654-00144512-00144735": "climate change conditions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00655-00144736-00144966": "the orbital layer would be primarily", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00656-00144967-00145175": "concerned with governing orbits as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00657-00145176-00145423": "commons which implies an egalitarian", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00658-00145424-00145719": "distribution of orbit space and ensuring", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00659-00145720-00145935": "that everyone benefits from space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00660-00145936-00146063": "exploration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00661-00146064-00146311": "to prevent uneven occupation of orbits", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00662-00146312-00146551": "that further reinforces the dominance of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00663-00146552-00146823": "the most powerful space actors cosmos", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00664-00146824-00147095": "law would introduce orbit rights an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00665-00147096-00147431": "analog to air rights on the surface", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00666-00147432-00147654": "it would ensure that every state has an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00667-00147655-00147799": "equal area", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00668-00147800-00148031": "nations would even be able to rent an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00669-00148032-00148287": "orbit as an alternative way to benefit", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00670-00148288-00148447": "from the commons", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00671-00148448-00148663": "the space industry is already on the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00672-00148664-00148759": "rise", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00673-00148760-00149039": "space tourism cloud services satellite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00674-00149040-00149254": "internet and transportation above the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00675-00149255-00149511": "karman line urgently require an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00676-00149512-00149871": "agreement on commons generated revenue", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00677-00149872-00150111": "under cosmos law this could possibly be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00678-00150112-00150366": "explored through a taxation system", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00679-00150367-00150590": "used towards maintaining the whole orbit", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00680-00150591-00150911": "infrastructure similar to tow roads fee", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00681-00150912-00151223": "or even operations on other layers such", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00682-00151224-00151575": "as climate maintenance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00683-00151576-00151790": "the ecosystem layer would be primarily", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00684-00151791-00151983": "concerned with the vitality of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00685-00151984-00152231": "ecosystems and on earth it would", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00686-00152232-00152478": "establish a legal regime for climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00687-00152479-00152702": "change mitigation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00688-00152703-00152951": "it would identify the hot spots of our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00689-00152952-00153175": "ecosystem that are vital to its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00690-00153176-00153590": "existence and reframe them as commons", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00691-00153591-00153847": "in this regard carbon sinks are an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00692-00153848-00154054": "optimal example since they are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00693-00154055-00154247": "indispensable for earth's viable", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00694-00154248-00154599": "planetarity and climate equilibrium", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00695-00154600-00154831": "currently endangered by unilateral", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00696-00154832-00155143": "governance or predatory practices algae", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00697-00155144-00155414": "reach oceans and forests of the amazon", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00698-00155415-00155687": "and siberia would instead be protected", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00699-00155688-00155999": "territories outside of any nation-state", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00700-00156000-00156263": "sovereignty", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00701-00156264-00156566": "besides future carbon emissions past and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00702-00156567-00156831": "current carbon flows are an obstacle for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00703-00156832-00157159": "balancing earth's climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00704-00157160-00157335": "constantly informed by climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00705-00157336-00157575": "monitoring from the information layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00706-00157576-00157807": "these emissions would be managed through", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00707-00157808-00158007": "transnational practices of carbon", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00708-00158008-00158302": "capture and storage", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00709-00158303-00158511": "by establishing a planetary sensing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00710-00158512-00158783": "apparatus on earth the information layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00711-00158784-00159023": "will facilitate the resolution of two", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00712-00159024-00159231": "main pressing issues", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00713-00159232-00159454": "one being better monitoring and modeling", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00714-00159455-00159735": "of climate change the other egalitarian", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00715-00159736-00159951": "exploration of space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00716-00159952-00160135": "because the ground segment is as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00717-00160136-00160351": "important as space infrastructures in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00718-00160352-00160447": "orbit", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00719-00160448-00160639": "scattered areas on the surface of our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00720-00160640-00160878": "planet that are particularly well suited", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00721-00160879-00161078": "for infrastructure that enables", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00722-00161079-00161359": "exploration of outer space would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00723-00161360-00161647": "identified and protected", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00724-00161648-00161863": "similarly to the astronomy geographic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00725-00161864-00162087": "advantage act that protects", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00726-00162088-00162287": "strategically important areas for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00727-00162288-00162511": "astronomy and related scientific", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00728-00162512-00162759": "endeavors", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00729-00162760-00163007": "moreover under the cosmos law this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00730-00163008-00163223": "ground to satellite interdependency", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00731-00163224-00163447": "would be used to reinforce the planetary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00732-00163448-00163730": "scope needed for outer space exploration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00733-00163731-00163863": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00734-00163864-00164095": "the need for cooperation could become a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00735-00164096-00164326": "leverage for equal use of orbit and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00736-00164327-00164726": "against space monopolies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00737-00164727-00164959": "the focus of the territorial layer would", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00738-00164960-00165143": "be primarily concerned with the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00739-00165144-00165383": "configuration of borders and resource", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00740-00165384-00165654": "extraction and ownership", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00741-00165655-00165871": "application of cosmos law to the earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00742-00165872-00166047": "would explore the implications of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00743-00166048-00166235": "sovereignty being expanded to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00744-00166236-00166614": "extraterritorial infrastructures", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00745-00166615-00166775": "the idea that sovereignty can be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00746-00166776-00167047": "fragmented and distributed questions the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00747-00167048-00167295": "world order based on the westphalian", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00748-00167296-00167607": "model of the nation-state", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00749-00167608-00167831": "it opens up a case for more radical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00750-00167832-00168071": "forms of sovereignty one of them being", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00751-00168072-00168359": "the earth model which suggests that 50", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00752-00168360-00168614": "percent of all of earth's territory be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00753-00168615-00168871": "left to natural reserves while the other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00754-00168872-00169238": "half for occupation of humans", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00755-00169239-00169414": "in this case sovereignty would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00756-00169415-00169599": "reassembled into new forms of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00757-00169600-00169790": "territorial hegemony", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00758-00169791-00169999": "territorial resource ownership and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00759-00170000-00170223": "extraction regulation will also be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00760-00170224-00170375": "revisited", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00761-00170376-00170607": "building upon the idea that resources of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00762-00170608-00170807": "the celestial bodies can be only", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00763-00170808-00171014": "extracted if the ecosystem carrying", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00764-00171015-00171214": "capacity allows for it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00765-00171215-00171471": "a better carbon cycle management system", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00766-00171472-00171638": "will be established", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00767-00171639-00171895": "likewise possession of the resources", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00768-00171896-00172087": "under the national soil would not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00769-00172088-00172278": "necessarily mean that they can be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00770-00172279-00172566": "extracted especially if extraction", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00771-00172567-00172759": "negativity affects the viable", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00772-00172760-00173231": "planetarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00773-00173232-00173375": "planetarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00774-00173376-00173535": "a condition rendered through the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00775-00173536-00173726": "disentering of the human from the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00776-00173727-00173911": "continuous and consequential flows of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00777-00173912-00174063": "the planet", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00778-00174064-00174231": "constructing it through the climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00779-00174232-00174454": "monitoring apparatus can reinforce the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00780-00174455-00174702": "planet's interdependencies of ecosystems", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00781-00174703-00174887": "infrastructures information and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00782-00174888-00175151": "resources and challenge our conceptions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00783-00175152-00175695": "of governance at and for planetary scale", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00784-00175696-00175951": "legal frameworks are created by need and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00785-00175952-00176166": "the law distributes power and gives", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00786-00176167-00176511": "shape to what is possible or otherwise", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00787-00176512-00176743": "our current and most pressing need is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00788-00176744-00176926": "the challenge to reverse the climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00789-00176927-00177135": "crisis which is also the challenge of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00790-00177136-00177326": "matching planetary conditions with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00791-00177327-00177583": "planetary governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00792-00177584-00177943": "space legislation is then an opportunity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00793-00177944-00178231": "cosmos law seizes it to counteract the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00794-00178232-00178487": "status quo of horizontal sovereignty and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00795-00178488-00178702": "arbitrary divisions that produce a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00796-00178703-00178911": "fragmented planetarity and our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00797-00178912-00179343": "separation from outer space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00798-00179344-00179604": "we have always been cosmonauts", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00799-00179605-00181634": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00800-00181635-00189447": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00801-00189448-00189607": "the stories that we tell about the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00802-00189608-00189847": "future habitability of earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00803-00189848-00190047": "are continuously informing humanity's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00804-00190048-00190271": "chances of survival", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00805-00190272-00190447": "and we are not talking about the stories", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00806-00190448-00190663": "that are told to the larger public", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00807-00190664-00190911": "although they are indeed important", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00808-00190912-00191199": "but the story states banks and ngos tell", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00809-00191200-00191526": "themselves and each other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00810-00191527-00191847": "these fictions guide policies laws co2", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00811-00191848-00191966": "emissions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00812-00191967-00192183": "influence the breathability of the air", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00813-00192184-00192438": "the quality of our food", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00814-00192439-00192663": "these stories are crafted here", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00815-00192664-00192983": "in the boardroom", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00816-00192984-00193190": "the performance of public commitments", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00817-00193191-00193454": "binding signatures and handshakes leads", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00818-00193455-00193687": "to delusions about actions which always", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00819-00193688-00194031": "happen elsewhere in the future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00820-00194032-00194238": "in the climate science fields", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00821-00194239-00194454": "the intergovernmental panel on climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00822-00194455-00194711": "change has crafted five narratives to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00823-00194712-00194983": "predict how socioeconomic parameters", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00824-00194984-00195126": "will guide the concentration of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00825-00195127-00195329": "greenhouse gases in the atmosphere", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00826-00195330-00195495": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00827-00195496-00195702": "they are called shared socioeconomic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00828-00195703-00195990": "pathways and map five different roads", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00829-00195991-00196231": "forking into different scenarios with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00830-00196232-00196463": "divergent consequences unfolding through", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00831-00196464-00196735": "the upcoming 80 years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00832-00196736-00197007": "there is the green roads the rocky roads", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00833-00197008-00197383": "the highway and so on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00834-00197384-00197687": "the ipcc pathways refer to historically", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00835-00197688-00197935": "and culturally specific indicators that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00836-00197936-00198126": "do not necessarily prioritize the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00837-00198127-00198438": "thriving of ours and other species", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00838-00198439-00198575": "for instance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00839-00198576-00198863": "levels of equality education or health", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00840-00198864-00199183": "are measured by their link to the gdp", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00841-00199184-00199383": "a mere representation of wealth that is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00842-00199384-00199590": "inadequate in addressing the existential", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00843-00199591-00199880": "threats climate collapse faces us with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00844-00199881-00200159": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00845-00200160-00200390": "ssp scenario modeling relies on the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00846-00200391-00200543": "access and availability of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00847-00200544-00200814": "socio-economic data which is unevenly", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00848-00200815-00201038": "distributed across nation-states and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00849-00201039-00201231": "regions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00850-00201232-00201454": "the practice of futurology and climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00851-00201455-00201695": "change discourse often takes the shape", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00852-00201696-00202095": "of institutionalized wishful thinking", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00853-00202096-00202278": "the role of scenario planning is to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00854-00202279-00202519": "entertain fantasies of success", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00855-00202520-00202743": "constantly deferred into the future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00856-00202744-00203054": "to help explain away present failures", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00857-00203055-00203263": "visualizing the future as a branching", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00858-00203264-00203471": "tree full of possibilities", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00859-00203472-00203711": "locates climate change into an outside", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00860-00203712-00204038": "realm preventing us from dealing with it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00861-00204039-00204247": "the roads and branches are pictured as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00862-00204248-00204526": "metaphorical paths that it has suggested", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00863-00204527-00204640": "we can choose to follow", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00864-00204641-00204894": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00865-00204896-00205071": "but the reality is more complex than", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00866-00205071-00205198": "that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00867-00205200-00205351": "we have already crossed some of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00868-00205352-00205542": "thresholds that will trigger non-linear", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00869-00205544-00205758": "and abrupt environmental change", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00870-00205759-00206286": "also known as planetary boundaries", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00871-00206287-00206414": "what is more interesting than", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00872-00206415-00206606": "apocalyptic prophecies is perhaps", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00873-00206607-00206782": "looking at the models that are already", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00874-00206783-00206982": "terraforming earth today", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00875-00206983-00207127": "and think of how they can be made", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00876-00207128-00207494": "operational", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00877-00207496-00207734": "the leakages between present past and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00878-00207735-00207998": "future manifest themselves in what we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00879-00208000-00208494": "call governing simulations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00880-00208496-00208671": "they are the models and projections", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00881-00208671-00208879": "which emerge when separate processes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00882-00208880-00209094": "within the material reality are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00883-00209096-00209262": "translated into approximate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00884-00209263-00209542": "representations of themselves", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00885-00209544-00209751": "these models reorganize the material", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00886-00209752-00209975": "reality in their image", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00887-00209976-00210198": "enacting the recursive process in which", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00888-00210200-00210415": "the simulation governs what it is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00889-00210416-00210582": "modeling", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00890-00210583-00210782": "we want to look at those models that are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00891-00210783-00211039": "already terraforming earth and take them", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00892-00211040-00211206": "as the starting point to conceive the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00893-00211207-00211406": "future as a recursive and eternal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00894-00211407-00211646": "presence", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00895-00211648-00211863": "we focus on filling the gap between du", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00896-00211864-00212079": "jour institutional discourse on climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00897-00212080-00212167": "change", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00898-00212167-00212423": "and the factor recursivity of governing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00899-00212423-00213556": "simulations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00900-00213557-00213687": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00901-00213688-00213975": "on the 20th of april of 2020", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00902-00213976-00214191": "the price of oil went negative for the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00903-00214192-00214494": "first time in history the oil market", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00904-00214496-00214742": "runs on futures contracts which are the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00905-00214744-00214982": "forward price of oil or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00906-00214983-00215175": "the expectation that oil will be at a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00907-00215176-00215351": "certain price on a given date in the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00908-00215352-00215487": "future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00909-00215488-00215791": "in april 2020 the expectation of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00910-00215792-00216046": "value of the commodity going forward", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00911-00216048-00216246": "was said to be below zero", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00912-00216248-00216415": "the practical implication of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00913-00216416-00216663": "negative price meant that oil producers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00914-00216664-00216855": "would offer to pay warehouse buyers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00915-00216856-00217110": "money to get rid of the excess supply of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00916-00217111-00217382": "barrels at the center of it was cushion", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00917-00217383-00217519": "oklahoma", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00918-00217519-00217798": "the designated storage site for futures", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00919-00217800-00217958": "where the barrels of oil tied to the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00920-00217959-00218127": "futures contracts are physically", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00921-00218128-00218391": "delivered", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00922-00218392-00218582": "the site is comprised of cylinder", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00923-00218583-00218839": "reservoirs with floating roofs arranged", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00924-00218840-00219110": "in orderly grids", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00925-00219111-00219334": "this circular typology for the storing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00926-00219335-00219542": "of oil was invented by a russian", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00927-00219544-00219655": "engineer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00928-00219656-00220151": "vladimir shukov in azerbaijan in 1878", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00929-00220152-00220342": "30 years after the world's first", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00930-00220344-00220734": "commercial oil well was drilled there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00931-00220735-00221006": "in the early 21st century hedge funds", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00932-00221007-00221231": "and other speculators would use drone", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00933-00221232-00221487": "and satellite imagery to estimate how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00934-00221488-00221734": "full or empty the oil cylinders were at", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00935-00221735-00222046": "a certain point in time", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00936-00222048-00222223": "they would use the images taken from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00937-00222223-00222439": "above to capture the shadows on top of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00938-00222440-00222639": "their floating roofs", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00939-00222640-00222815": "which would then inform the future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00940-00222816-00223079": "speculation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00941-00223080-00223263": "and so when the storage was full the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00942-00223264-00223401": "prices would drop", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00943-00223402-00223663": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00944-00223664-00223910": "this particular incident reveals how the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00945-00223911-00224134": "recursive nature of the process", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00946-00224135-00224327": "is in fact premised on the different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00947-00224328-00224582": "qualities of lights", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00948-00224583-00224806": "how the drone and satellite sensors that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00949-00224807-00224982": "gather data through an exchange of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00950-00224983-00225206": "electromagnetic frequencies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00951-00225207-00225431": "are here used to register the optical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00952-00225432-00225663": "phenomena of light and shadow on top of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00953-00225664-00225910": "the oil tanks", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00954-00225911-00226142": "they infer the capacity of cylinders", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00955-00226144-00226334": "which store the products of decay from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00956-00226335-00226631": "the organisms that themselves came to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00957-00226632-00226863": "life because of photosynthesis millions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00958-00226864-00227158": "of years ago the synchronicity of these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00959-00227159-00227382": "processes is however", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00960-00227383-00227655": "in contrast with the disparity of scale", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00961-00227656-00227839": "between the deep time process of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00962-00227840-00228039": "fossilization that made possible the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00963-00228040-00228215": "extraction of oil", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00964-00228216-00228391": "and the speed of light trading happening", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00965-00228392-00228823": "at stock exchanges all over the world", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00966-00228823-00229079": "in april this disparity manifested", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00967-00229080-00229294": "itself clearly", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00968-00229296-00229542": "crude oil went from resource to waste in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00969-00229544-00229703": "a matter of hours", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00970-00229704-00229879": "and the cushioning storage facility", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00971-00229880-00231406": "became a dumping ground", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00972-00231407-00231703": "a study from 2013 describes how the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00973-00231704-00231903": "scanning of the surface of the black sea", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00974-00231904-00232134": "with remote sensing technologies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00975-00232135-00232342": "revealed the disproportionate amount of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00976-00232344-00232551": "oil spills of shipping origins within", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00977-00232552-00232782": "the russian sector of the sea and on its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00978-00232783-00232910": "borders", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00979-00232911-00233182": "oil tankers when traveling empty carry", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00980-00233183-00233455": "tanks filled with ballast sea water to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00981-00233456-00233687": "achieve the best velocity and stability", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00982-00233688-00233951": "configuration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00983-00233952-00234167": "the water that becomes mixed with oil", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00984-00234167-00234479": "particles is then dumped into the sea", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00985-00234480-00234758": "either in authorized discharge zones or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00986-00234759-00234998": "illegal dumping grounds to prepare the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00987-00235000-00235282": "space later filled with valuable", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00988-00235283-00235606": "cargo sensed through synthetic aperture", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00989-00235607-00235719": "radar", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00990-00235719-00236039": "these oil spills perform as contrast dye", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00991-00236040-00236271": "used in x-ray exams", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00992-00236271-00236439": "they visually highlight where the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00993-00236440-00236751": "russian territory ends in the allegedly", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00994-00236752-00236975": "borderless terrain of the sea like the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00995-00236976-00237246": "coloring book outlines on its surface", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00996-00237248-00237534": "all due to questions of jurisdiction", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00997-00237535-00237967": "governance accountability and value", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00998-00237967-00238334": "what happens in 10 or 100 or 500 years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-00999-00238335-00238527": "when the arctic keeps melting and the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01000-00238528-00238782": "sea level rises and these oil borders in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01001-00238783-00239158": "the black sea spill into other countries", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01002-00239159-00239367": "will russia accept the accountability", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01003-00239367-00239551": "and jurisdiction over the task of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01004-00239552-00239742": "cleaning up those dumps because they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01005-00239744-00239894": "will lead to an expansion of its", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01006-00239896-00240046": "territory", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01007-00240048-00240303": "or is it that by then there won't be any", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01008-00240304-00240494": "nation-states at all to care about the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01009-00240496-00240662": "territorial disputes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01010-00240663-00240887": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01011-00240888-00241110": "access to technologies of extended", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01012-00241111-00241327": "vision and remote sensing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01013-00241328-00241510": "inform the way in which fragments of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01014-00241511-00241782": "reality are read and simulated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01015-00241783-00242006": "it posits the possibility of control", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01016-00242007-00242167": "over a territory", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01017-00242167-00242406": "in case it is identified as a carrier of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01018-00242407-00242655": "a valuable resource", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01019-00242656-00242887": "this recursive relationship between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01020-00242888-00243175": "sensing and sovereignty is however not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01021-00243176-00243463": "limited by territorial disputes it can", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01022-00243464-00243679": "determine claims of jurisdiction over", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01023-00243680-00243958": "commodity an ecological phenomenon or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01024-00243959-00244182": "even a metabolic process", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01025-00244183-00244423": "the resolution of the infrastructure for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01026-00244423-00244679": "sensing and simulation appears within", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01027-00244680-00244975": "the process of climate modeling itself", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01028-00244976-00245175": "the standard average resolution of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01029-00245176-00245463": "global climate models used by the ipcc", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01030-00245464-00245639": "for its fifth report", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01031-00245640-00245927": "consists of 100 times 100 square", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01032-00245928-00246175": "kilometer cells within the grid that the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01033-00246176-00246375": "biosphere is divided into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01034-00246376-00246567": "along the longitude and latitude of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01035-00246567-00246751": "globe", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01036-00246752-00246975": "the horizontal model grids also extend", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01037-00246976-00247175": "vertically up through the atmosphere", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01038-00247176-00247334": "where it is broken up into layers that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01039-00247335-00247598": "can be as thin as 11 kilometers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01040-00247600-00248110": "and down through the ocean", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01041-00248111-00248327": "the simulation is then calculated in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01042-00248328-00248655": "30-minute steps to inform past or future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01043-00248656-00248839": "climate projections", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01044-00248840-00249151": "in the ipcc context the spatial cell is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01045-00249152-00249463": "a representation of balance what is the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01046-00249464-00249655": "biggest quantity of data you can feed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01047-00249656-00249839": "into the model before it overwhelms the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01048-00249840-00250079": "computational capacity that would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01049-00250080-00250287": "needed to calculate all possible", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01050-00250288-00250575": "interactions with that data set", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01051-00250576-00250767": "the question then is whether the same", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01052-00250767-00251006": "precision can be extended into the space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01053-00251007-00251271": "between simulation and governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01054-00251271-00251382": "that is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01055-00251383-00251542": "how do you render the simulation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01056-00251544-00251782": "operational so that it can turn into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01057-00251783-00252071": "recursive governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01058-00252071-00252279": "instead of thinking of high resolution", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01059-00252280-00252479": "as an abundance of data", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01060-00252480-00252719": "we focus on the question of fine tuning", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01061-00252719-00252927": "and justification", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01062-00252928-00253134": "we think of resolution as the level of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01063-00253135-00253367": "precision with which the capture of data", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01064-00253367-00253630": "is fine-tuned to produce the simulations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01065-00253631-00253791": "that are able to govern what is being", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01066-00253792-00254030": "captured in a way that will bring the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01067-00254031-00255942": "desirable ends in predictable ways", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01068-00255944-00256198": "cassandra saw a business opportunity in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01069-00256200-00256455": "the growing field of now casting data", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01070-00256456-00256671": "analytics and the increasingly complex", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01071-00256671-00256942": "sensing technologies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01072-00256944-00257158": "from nader's usage of hot air balloons", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01073-00257159-00257446": "to create aerial photos of paris", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01074-00257448-00257727": "to arthur batut's experiments with kites", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01075-00257728-00257998": "to the modifications made by sputnik one", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01076-00258000-00258294": "enabling it to track cloud patterns", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01077-00258296-00258494": "cassandra carried the legacy of remote", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01078-00258496-00258775": "sensing onwards with acute awareness of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01079-00258776-00259030": "the scope of its applications", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01080-00259031-00259198": "their first breakthrough happened with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01081-00259200-00259439": "the carbon high-res projects", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01082-00259440-00259679": "having invested billions of dollars", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01083-00259680-00259879": "cassandra created the physical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01084-00259880-00260142": "infrastructure connecting technologies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01085-00260144-00260382": "of carbon sensing with the private and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01086-00260383-00260630": "public companies who were smart enough", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01087-00260631-00260863": "to see a new market opportunity in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01088-00260864-00261006": "carbon storage", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01089-00261007-00261239": "the carbon high-res project was launched", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01090-00261240-00261519": "in the spring of 2013 and became a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01091-00261519-00261742": "milestone in the ongoing efforts to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01092-00261744-00262006": "terraform earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01093-00262007-00262223": "the surface of the planet was mapped and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01094-00262224-00262439": "captured at high resolution", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01095-00262440-00262703": "from space now anyone could tell a red", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01096-00262704-00262934": "pine from a scarlet oak", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01097-00262935-00263143": "the two species most efficient in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01098-00263144-00263375": "sequestering co2 attain the highest", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01099-00263376-00263471": "value", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01100-00263472-00263647": "and were hunted for by competing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01101-00263648-00264015": "companies and governments", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01102-00264016-00264310": "now in full operation the carbon hi-res", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01103-00264311-00264567": "is comprised of a fleet of satellites", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01104-00264568-00264799": "which can count the leaves on a fern", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01105-00264800-00265079": "perceiving its stems and margins veins", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01106-00265080-00265247": "and venules", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01107-00265248-00265503": "and estimate the co2 that each little", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01108-00265504-00265767": "element can store with a high degree of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01109-00265768-00266015": "accuracy", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01110-00266016-00266310": "they run calculations in situ and report", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01111-00266311-00266534": "back to decentralized control rooms on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01112-00266535-00266799": "earth which regulate the price of co2 in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01113-00266800-00266943": "return", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01114-00266944-00267215": "transitioning away from carbon tax and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01115-00267216-00267487": "towards embracing recursive models that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01116-00267488-00267767": "rely on high resolution imagery", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01117-00267768-00268619": "cassandra was behind it all", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01118-00268620-00273534": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01119-00273535-00273806": "hello everyone my name is kiara um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01120-00273807-00273999": "together with laura", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01121-00274000-00274295": "cuguci i'm cara de lone we're part of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01122-00274296-00274510": "the cassandra team", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01123-00274511-00274710": "and we're very very happy and grateful", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01124-00274711-00274943": "to be here and to share the project", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01125-00274944-00275191": "again after two years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01126-00275192-00275487": "um in two years i guess a lot of a lot", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01127-00275488-00275710": "has changed and very little has changed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01128-00275711-00275847": "at the same time", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01129-00275848-00276103": "i think things that we didn't think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01130-00276104-00276319": "would change so much did and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01131-00276320-00276527": "vice versa so it's very interesting to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01132-00276528-00276806": "kind of revise it um at this at this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01133-00276807-00276943": "point so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01134-00276944-00277158": "maybe it would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01135-00277159-00277510": "uh good to kind of go a little bit into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01136-00277511-00277719": "our motivation for starting this project", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01137-00277720-00277967": "back then and then kind of see what", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01138-00277968-00278119": "happened between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01139-00278120-00278447": "so um when we were in stroke we were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01140-00278448-00278782": "presented with this climate scenarios", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01141-00278783-00279055": "that the ipcc publishes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01142-00279056-00279182": "and we found them to be very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01143-00279183-00279447": "conservative and very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01144-00279448-00279775": "reproductive of the present that we have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01145-00279776-00279871": "already", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01146-00279872-00280063": "in many ways some of which we have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01147-00280064-00280239": "explained in the video", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01148-00280240-00280503": "and so we we try to find ways to to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01149-00280504-00280758": "challenge this this idea of the future", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01150-00280759-00281095": "not just in terms of having more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01151-00281096-00281303": "imaginative and radical features but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01152-00281304-00281543": "also in terms of what", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01153-00281544-00281703": "changing and challenging the idea of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01154-00281704-00281887": "what the future is and what the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01155-00281888-00282047": "relationship between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01156-00282048-00282382": "future projections and action and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01157-00282383-00282659": "recursivity and governance is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01158-00282660-00282782": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01159-00282783-00282967": "a couple of things i find interesting is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01160-00282968-00283175": "that we speculate about the carbon", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01161-00283176-00283319": "market", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01162-00283320-00283615": "and we speculate about having this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01163-00283616-00283879": "satellite images that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01164-00283880-00284095": "estimate the carbon that's in a forest", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01165-00284096-00284287": "and that some kind somehow is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01166-00284288-00284495": "financialized and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01167-00284496-00284703": "the voluntary carbon market has gotten", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01168-00284704-00284903": "really really big in the past two years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01169-00284904-00285182": "it has grown to several billions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01170-00285183-00285447": "and the price of carbon has", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01171-00285448-00285719": "gone up significantly", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01172-00285720-00285982": "and this kind of market-based solutions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01173-00285983-00286175": "to climate change are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01174-00286176-00286423": "more and more dominant", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01175-00286424-00286630": "although i sort of believe in them less", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01176-00286631-00286767": "and less", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01177-00286768-00286999": "so i find it interesting that we had", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01178-00287000-00287399": "this kind of prophetic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01179-00287400-00287551": "sort of if i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01180-00287552-00287815": "if i say so myself", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01181-00287816-00288030": "about what might happen and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01182-00288031-00288334": "i think that the way it it is happening", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01183-00288335-00288543": "it's sort of underwhelming in many ways", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01184-00288544-00288743": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01185-00288744-00288975": "yes um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01186-00288976-00289110": "yeah laura would you like to add", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01187-00289111-00289239": "anything on that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01188-00289240-00289375": "sure um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01189-00289376-00289471": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01190-00289472-00289703": "i was thinking that yeah the the project", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01191-00289704-00289967": "started with also this critical reading", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01192-00289968-00290206": "of scenario planning as one of the main", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01193-00290207-00290382": "techniques for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01194-00290383-00290519": "narrating", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01195-00290520-00290663": "the future and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01196-00290664-00290823": "institutional", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01197-00290824-00291263": "strategies to use these different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01198-00291264-00291534": "narrative forms to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01199-00291535-00291839": "justify policies and to justify", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01200-00291840-00292215": "uh their this these practices and so uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01201-00292216-00292495": "i think for um for the past two years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01202-00292496-00292703": "something that we've learned is that the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01203-00292704-00292934": "more you you research this field the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01204-00292935-00293310": "less you realize you know and also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01205-00293311-00293606": "we realize how important it is to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01206-00293607-00293815": "map the possible", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01207-00293816-00294043": "literacies and like the possible", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01208-00294044-00294247": "interdisciplinary collaborations that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01209-00294248-00294534": "can be that can happen in this field for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01210-00294535-00294791": "a more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01211-00294792-00294958": "more realistic somehow but also more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01212-00294959-00295199": "imaginative", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01213-00295200-00295406": "perspective about about the future and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01214-00295407-00295663": "the governance of complex systems", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01215-00295664-00295927": "and uh something that uh because the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01216-00295928-00296110": "first time that we see the film uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01217-00296111-00296319": "projected in front of an audience apart", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01218-00296320-00296439": "from the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01219-00296440-00296734": "because it was because of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01220-00296735-00296910": "the course was interrupted by by the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01221-00296911-00297143": "pandemic and i was not seeing again that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01222-00297144-00297358": "like the for example the reason why we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01223-00297359-00297647": "may we decided to make it visible uh in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01224-00297648-00297919": "the video like the drones and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01225-00297920-00298151": "some of the like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01226-00298152-00298415": "interfaces for machine vision was a way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01227-00298416-00298591": "also to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01228-00298592-00298823": "reflect on the fact that it's important", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01229-00298824-00299071": "to also map the meta narratives and like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01230-00299072-00299167": "the way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01231-00299168-00299343": "knowledge around", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01232-00299344-00299591": "climate science is produced and how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01233-00299592-00299791": "knowledge and science become science and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01234-00299792-00300023": "how science become policy and how policy", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01235-00300024-00300334": "become law so i think this is also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01236-00300335-00300519": "something that has been progressing in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01237-00300520-00300703": "the past couple of years and and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01238-00300704-00300943": "recently and we're very interested in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01239-00300944-00301167": "trying to find", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01240-00301168-00301415": "channels for different audiences also to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01241-00301416-00301543": "access", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01242-00301544-00301806": "the science in in different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01243-00301807-00301919": "formats", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01244-00301920-00302119": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01245-00302120-00302527": "and the richness that can come from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01246-00302528-00302871": "translating and applying models for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01247-00302872-00303079": "uh for knowledge from one field to the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01248-00303080-00303239": "other and uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01249-00303240-00303367": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01250-00303368-00303623": "yeah so i think more or less something", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01251-00303624-00304030": "else", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01252-00304031-00304223": "no i think um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01253-00304224-00304343": "yeah it is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01254-00304344-00304543": "since that i'm mostly a writer i don't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01255-00304544-00304758": "normally do films and now just looking", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01256-00304759-00304871": "back at", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01257-00304872-00305127": "articulating these ideas also visually i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01258-00305128-00305263": "think that in that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01259-00305264-00305551": "being at stroka and kind of using that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01260-00305552-00305775": "extra dimension of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01261-00305776-00306023": "visualizing our ideas i think that's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01262-00306024-00306199": "something that makes i want to do it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01263-00306200-00306319": "again", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01264-00306320-00306519": "now that i saw it again yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01265-00306520-00306791": "i also yeah just was thinking about this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01266-00306792-00306982": "and also in the context of this program", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01267-00306983-00307263": "and mediocentes the fact that it's very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01268-00307264-00307623": "important to also yeah visualize all of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01269-00307624-00307710": "these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01270-00307711-00307943": "different forms of knowledge and there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01271-00307944-00308230": "cannot be only one one point of access", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01272-00308231-00308454": "to it so i think this is also very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01273-00308455-00308630": "very um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01274-00308631-00308887": "enriching and productive to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01275-00308888-00309151": "think of research uh also through the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01276-00309152-00309327": "the presentation of the research and the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01277-00309328-00309599": "visuals and how uh yeah using all of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01278-00309600-00309823": "these different techniques for for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01279-00309824-00310087": "machine vision and for image processing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01280-00310088-00310295": "and uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01281-00310296-00310463": "how it's possible to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01282-00310464-00310710": "track all of these different processes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01283-00310711-00310863": "so yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01284-00310864-00311110": "last thing to that um yeah i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01285-00311111-00311327": "that's really important to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01286-00311328-00311510": "to have like a wealth of different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01287-00311511-00311703": "lenses and you know some of them might", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01288-00311704-00311854": "be art or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01289-00311855-00312143": "cinema or you know design", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01290-00312144-00312279": "because if you look at the way that the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01291-00312280-00312454": "future is rendered in a big", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01292-00312455-00312582": "institutional", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01293-00312583-00312887": "context it's always through a paragraph", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01294-00312888-00313199": "or a quadrant that tells you oh xyz is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01295-00313200-00313399": "going to happen in 10 years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01296-00313400-00313623": "there is a graph and it sort of ends", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01297-00313624-00313782": "there or there is some kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01298-00313783-00314047": "simulation that's like sort of emotional", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01299-00314048-00314279": "like intended to provoke some feelings", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01300-00314280-00314479": "into the participants of this scenario", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01301-00314480-00314615": "planning workshop", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01302-00314616-00314791": "but it's always the same language and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01303-00314792-00315054": "it's always the same articulation of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01304-00315055-00315247": "future and like i mean the suspicion is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01305-00315248-00315343": "that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01306-00315344-00315599": "maybe we could try something else", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01307-00315600-00315679": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01308-00315680-00315919": "yeah but thanks everyone for watching", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01309-00315920-00316134": "our project again um sorry about the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01310-00316135-00316415": "mismatch of the spanish subtitles but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01311-00316416-00316806": "we'll upload a correct version online so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01312-00316807-00317358": "yeah thanks everyone", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01313-00317359-00317495": "hello", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01314-00317496-00317799": "my name is vladavanassif i'm", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01315-00317800-00318030": "a designer and researcher from ukraine", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01316-00318031-00318334": "and i responsible for the cosmos law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01317-00318335-00318639": "uh together i've done in collaboration", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01318-00318640-00318951": "with brazilian artist louisa crossman", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01319-00318952-00319127": "and georgian", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01320-00319128-00319487": "urban planner elena", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01321-00319488-00319533": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01322-00319534-00319654": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01323-00319655-00319943": "we were kind of interested", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01324-00319944-00320054": "into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01325-00320055-00320263": "into space law because we were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01326-00320264-00320447": "we were looking into absence of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01327-00320448-00320630": "planetary governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01328-00320631-00320887": "in the absence of the governance of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01329-00320888-00321158": "natural flows and what we kind of need", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01330-00321159-00321254": "to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01331-00321255-00321527": "do in the climate change because of our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01332-00321528-00321791": "current model of governance of different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01333-00321792-00322030": "state westphalian model of governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01334-00322031-00322271": "and we're looking into the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01335-00322272-00322582": "uh space law kind of looking back how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01336-00322583-00322703": "how we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01337-00322704-00322967": "came here to this point and we were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01338-00322968-00323191": "looking at the past of colonial legacy", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01339-00323192-00323391": "the kind of this concept of terenolius", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01340-00323392-00323647": "when when people were coming to the to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01341-00323648-00323879": "the foreign land like it was australia", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01342-00323880-00323999": "they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01343-00324000-00324287": "haven't seen their civilization and they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01344-00324288-00324567": "treated land as empty and that's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01345-00324568-00324767": "basically how how it is with the space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01346-00324768-00325039": "law now and so we kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01347-00325040-00325167": "treated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01348-00325168-00325582": "what film does conceptually and visually", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01349-00325583-00325687": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01350-00325688-00325871": "to kind of create this epistemological", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01351-00325872-00326191": "model where we as humans kind of were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01352-00326192-00326479": "migrating from the point and expanding", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01353-00326480-00326663": "to the point where we expand to space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01354-00326664-00326919": "now and we're expanding the logic of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01355-00326920-00327206": "laws that we had from the colonial past", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01356-00327207-00327406": "and we tried to reverse this logic and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01357-00327407-00327647": "great speculation what if we are looking", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01358-00327648-00327847": "from the space on earth back", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01359-00327848-00328095": "and how then we would govern", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01360-00328096-00328382": "the earth not as a kind of our human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01361-00328383-00328606": "perspective but the perspective of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01362-00328607-00328830": "planetary because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01363-00328831-00329023": "basically now we confront it with this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01364-00329024-00329143": "reality", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01365-00329144-00329415": "of planetary crises such as climate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01366-00329416-00329671": "change pandemic with the time much", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01367-00329672-00329775": "longer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01368-00329776-00330199": "than the kind of our human history", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01369-00330200-00330406": "what else to say", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01370-00330407-00330806": "i'm not a writer i'm a designer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01371-00330807-00331175": "so it's harder for me to talk", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01372-00331176-00331399": "how yeah the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01373-00331400-00331623": "we we ended up in the very strange", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01374-00331624-00331815": "situation because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01375-00331816-00332015": "it's quite a niche topic it was niche", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01376-00332016-00332191": "topic two years ago because there was", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01377-00332192-00332382": "only like if you know something about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01378-00332383-00332567": "space you probably know that's elon musk", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01379-00332568-00332727": "send the tesla", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01380-00332728-00332919": "out of space and this is kind of like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01381-00332920-00333078": "the state of think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01382-00333079-00333230": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01383-00333231-00333495": "yeah there is not even institutional", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01384-00333496-00333582": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01385-00333583-00333751": "research", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01386-00333752-00334006": "uh body about space law because it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01387-00334007-00334223": "very niche like space lawyer they're", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01388-00334224-00334406": "they're not the general or the lawyer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01389-00334407-00334558": "only for space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01390-00334559-00334758": "and like there are some artists that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01391-00334759-00334919": "work with space but they don't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01392-00334920-00335143": "don't work with legislation so we kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01393-00335144-00335327": "of struggled to find an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01394-00335328-00335551": "institutional base to develop our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01395-00335552-00335806": "project but on the other hand", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01396-00335807-00335991": "the last two years were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01397-00335992-00336119": "just", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01398-00336120-00336303": "insanely", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01399-00336304-00336519": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01400-00336520-00336751": "how do you say like the evolution of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01401-00336752-00336951": "space activities was incredible like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01402-00336952-00337287": "just the last months the china released", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01403-00337288-00337527": "white paper the first white paper in the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01404-00337528-00337775": "five years exploring the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01405-00337776-00338006": "the kind of perspective on the space and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01406-00338007-00338175": "planning together with the space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01407-00338176-00338415": "legislation and the same deeds the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01408-00338416-00338639": "united states and russia and basically", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01409-00338640-00338895": "space right now it's uh for the last two", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01410-00338896-00339103": "years i think became everyday life of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01411-00339104-00339351": "everybody everybody knows this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01412-00339352-00339647": "this kind of the part of our life", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01413-00339648-00339767": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01414-00339768-00340023": "yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01415-00340024-00340247": "also a space um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01416-00340248-00340534": "was elon musk's company name", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01417-00340535-00340943": "spacex satellite crashed into the moon", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01418-00340944-00341158": "i think two weeks ago or something", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01419-00341159-00341363": "random fact but yeah i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01420-00341364-00341682": "[Laughter]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01421-00341683-00342030": "um i wanted to make a connection between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01422-00342031-00342278": "cassandra and cosmos law because i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01423-00342279-00342463": "that both", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01424-00342464-00342687": "um like a central team to both projects", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01425-00342688-00342823": "is trying to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01426-00342824-00343175": "break with a reproductive past like with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01427-00343176-00343399": "reproducing the past so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01428-00343400-00343727": "for example space law says well if", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01429-00343728-00343982": "territorial law on earth is not good", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01430-00343983-00344230": "then we shouldn't expand it into space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01431-00344231-00344471": "and in the same way we try to say well", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01432-00344472-00344663": "if the models of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01433-00344664-00344967": "thinking and acting upon the future are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01434-00344968-00345223": "based on cold war dynamics and they're", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01435-00345224-00345399": "not sufficient we should try and find", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01436-00345400-00345751": "new models to do that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01437-00345752-00345991": "and yeah i think also in terms of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01438-00345992-00346247": "awareness that the general audience has", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01439-00346248-00346391": "in terms of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01440-00346392-00346582": "how important scenario planning is there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01441-00346583-00346734": "has been a lot of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01442-00346735-00346951": "a lot of progress in the past two years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01443-00346952-00347191": "the ipcc came out with the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01444-00347192-00347471": "with their sixth assessment report and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01445-00347472-00347719": "they narrowed down their scenarios quite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01446-00347720-00347823": "a lot", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01447-00347824-00348015": "um and that's a really good thing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01448-00348016-00348206": "because um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01449-00348207-00348415": "basically before there was the very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01450-00348416-00348606": "utopian scenario where you know you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01451-00348607-00348799": "could you know the carbon emission just", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01452-00348800-00348910": "do this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01453-00348911-00349047": "and you would have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01454-00349048-00349319": "you know still economic growth and still", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01455-00349320-00349527": "everybody was very very rich and very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01456-00349528-00349734": "happy but you know we would have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01457-00349735-00350023": "photovoltaic panels and everywhere um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01458-00350024-00350223": "and like some kind of crazy assumptions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01459-00350224-00350447": "and they got rid of these ones um and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01460-00350448-00350615": "they also got rid of the very very very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01461-00350616-00350782": "bad ones um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01462-00350783-00350895": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01463-00350896-00351167": "and i've seen a lot of discussions and a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01464-00351168-00351358": "lot of like critical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01465-00351359-00351654": "discussions around this so i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01466-00351655-00351951": "i think in that sense that um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01467-00351952-00352030": "we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01468-00352031-00352199": "were on the right track maybe i don't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01469-00352200-00352351": "know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01470-00352352-00352615": "i also noticed watching again cosmos law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01471-00352616-00352710": "how many", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01472-00352711-00352863": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01473-00352864-00353095": "similar like similar interest we had", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01474-00353096-00353358": "when we started the project and uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01475-00353359-00353463": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01476-00353464-00353647": "for example like the different layers of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01477-00353648-00353815": "like sovereignty and the different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01478-00353816-00353967": "layers of like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01479-00353968-00354182": "the spectrum between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01480-00354183-00354454": "resource and waste that can change", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01481-00354455-00354654": "across time and this is something that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01482-00354655-00354903": "really has uh has animated our work from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01483-00354904-00355158": "the beginning and i was thinking in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01484-00355159-00355406": "relation to this also to the fact that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01485-00355407-00355623": "this can also be applied to information", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01486-00355624-00355782": "for example that information through", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01487-00355783-00356151": "time across time can become something uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01488-00356152-00356478": "really common and uh and available uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01489-00356479-00356647": "even there is an abundance of it and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01490-00356648-00356975": "then when", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01491-00356976-00357191": "certain entities", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01492-00357192-00357343": "detect some", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01493-00357344-00357543": "possibility for value extraction from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01494-00357544-00357767": "this information then it becomes a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01495-00357768-00357934": "resource and then it's not free and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01496-00357935-00358151": "available anymore so also in terms of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01497-00358152-00358382": "this ecology of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01498-00358383-00358599": "of how knowledge and how resources are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01499-00358600-00358767": "distributed i thought there was also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01500-00358768-00359023": "this meta layer somehow of like yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01501-00359024-00359271": "related to yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01502-00359272-00359478": "yeah also another connection is just the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01503-00359479-00359606": "interest in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01504-00359607-00359823": "kind of operationalizing a framework and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01505-00359824-00359999": "not just saying this is how things", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01506-00360000-00360271": "should work but so trying to build a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01507-00360272-00360503": "model that goes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01508-00360504-00360630": "yeah that's that's not just a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01509-00360631-00360839": "description like you said that the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01510-00360840-00361030": "cosmos law will not be written but it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01511-00361031-00361375": "will be it will be modeled", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01512-00361376-00361487": "i think that's really interesting", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01513-00361488-00361727": "concept i think that kind of percolated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01514-00361728-00361991": "the entire terraforming group in general", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01515-00361992-00362199": "this idea that is not enough to kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01516-00362200-00362478": "describe how you want things to work but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01517-00362479-00362615": "you should", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01518-00362616-00362727": "design", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01519-00362728-00362943": "some mechanisms through which this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01520-00362944-00363119": "ambitions can", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01521-00363120-00363358": "can be operationalized and can can you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01522-00363359-00363487": "know be true", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01523-00363488-00363623": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01524-00363624-00363791": "so i guess that was", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01525-00363792-00364158": "both for our ambition what do you think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01526-00364159-00364358": "yeah i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01527-00364359-00364591": "i think that's what we kind of do", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01528-00364592-00364758": "i think it's important to get to the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01529-00364759-00364999": "audience the idea like that we're not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01530-00365000-00365087": "nerds", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01531-00365088-00365287": "we're just trying to kind of apply our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01532-00365288-00365543": "skills to the topics that are not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01533-00365544-00365871": "usually a part of our discipline and so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01534-00365872-00366039": "that disciplines are also benefit from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01535-00366040-00366206": "our skills and so it was like for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01536-00366207-00366487": "instance modeling doesn't really apply", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01537-00366488-00366663": "for for a law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01538-00366664-00366751": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01539-00366752-00366951": "although it's starting and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01540-00366952-00367191": "like with the with the cassandra it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01541-00367192-00367287": "not like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01542-00367288-00367558": "the remotes and it's all", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01543-00367559-00367871": "often a flight for scenario planning", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01544-00367872-00367967": "so yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01545-00367968-00368071": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01546-00368072-00368287": "it's very much related to the media lab", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01547-00368288-00368447": "program right now", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01548-00368448-00368695": "so maybe maybe should we open up", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01549-00368696-00369023": "two questions and stuff", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01550-00369024-00369254": "yes i don't know if anyone", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01551-00369255-00369551": "someone wants or i can like follow up", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01552-00369552-00369823": "precisely with this last comment you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01553-00369824-00370015": "like or this kind of connection you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01554-00370016-00370271": "brought in between both projects that i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01555-00370272-00370358": "was", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01556-00370359-00370551": "also thinking about to what extent there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01557-00370552-00370639": "is a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01558-00370640-00370743": "or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01559-00370744-00370919": "have you have a common conversation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01560-00370920-00371054": "because um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01561-00371055-00371303": "in relation to the model and how you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01562-00371304-00371430": "propose to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01563-00371431-00371702": "model the situation instead of right not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01564-00371703-00371991": "the possibility or the other regulation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01565-00371992-00372175": "have you like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01566-00372176-00372454": "at any point try to imagine how this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01567-00372455-00372830": "model or how this um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01568-00372831-00373071": "can be generated or can be generalized i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01569-00373072-00373302": "mean one of the most interesting parts", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01570-00373303-00373391": "of the program is the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01571-00373392-00373623": "interdisciplinarity and of course", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01572-00373624-00373967": "we like uh i i face the same problem or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01573-00373968-00374151": "the same situation where we were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01574-00374152-00374399": "thinking about possibilities but then", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01575-00374400-00374623": "how to imagine or envision this could", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01576-00374624-00374799": "really really happen", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01577-00374800-00374895": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01578-00374896-00375247": "we try to ask to the expert in computing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01579-00375248-00375439": "like the computer engineering we had in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01580-00375440-00375654": "the program to imagine or envision how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01581-00375655-00375878": "this model could be so i wanted to or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01582-00375879-00376087": "i'm curious about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01583-00376088-00376215": "if you have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01584-00376216-00376478": "been thinking these previous states not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01585-00376479-00376815": "how the model could take part in the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01586-00376816-00377006": "regulation of the sovereignty of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01587-00377007-00377278": "territories but the main government", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01588-00377279-00377510": "kind of governmental force in the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01589-00377511-00377743": "construction of the models who would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01590-00377744-00377934": "in charge of the design of the model or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01591-00377935-00378087": "what would be the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01592-00378088-00378295": "the reasons that good address the design", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01593-00378296-00378478": "of the models could could be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01594-00378479-00378567": "the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01595-00378568-00378702": "interest", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01596-00378703-00379039": "underneath the motivations of well we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01597-00379040-00379295": "all know that all these kind of layers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01598-00379296-00379447": "had a lot of implications in how the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01599-00379448-00379710": "model performed so i'm curious about if", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01600-00379711-00379791": "you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01601-00379792-00380039": "have get to start thinking on in those", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01602-00380040-00380319": "terms of yeah the main engineering of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01603-00380320-00380502": "the of the models and how they can", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01604-00380503-00381087": "perform in a way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01605-00381088-00381367": "yeah um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01606-00381368-00381671": "i think to bring couple example uh our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01607-00381672-00381927": "team were reached by our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01608-00381928-00382078": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01609-00382079-00382334": "australian office of outer space that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01610-00382335-00382575": "work with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01611-00382576-00382815": "with artemis accord so they work with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01612-00382816-00382943": "australian", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01613-00382944-00383119": "space agency and they work on artemis", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01614-00383120-00383287": "accord it's a next mission to bring", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01615-00383288-00383487": "people to the moon and it's like a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01616-00383488-00383663": "collaboration between different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01617-00383664-00383991": "nation states and they basically trying", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01618-00383992-00384127": "to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01619-00384128-00384334": "because there is a lot of spatial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01620-00384335-00384591": "problems like you cannot by the treaty", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01621-00384592-00384767": "you cannot say who is territory because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01622-00384768-00384958": "territory is for everybody so they're", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01623-00384959-00385199": "trying to kind of avoid it and they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01624-00385200-00385447": "invited landscape architects", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01625-00385448-00385654": "different designer to kind of develop", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01626-00385655-00386063": "it and also microsoft azure", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01627-00386064-00386487": "does similar thing it's their ai based", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01628-00386488-00386758": "ai cloud that does many many things with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01629-00386759-00386943": "satellite and remote regions and they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01630-00386944-00387206": "basically bring in like the earth into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01631-00387207-00387463": "the materials which mainly right now", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01632-00387464-00387727": "corporation does and just couple days", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01633-00387728-00387943": "ago the space force", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01634-00387944-00388151": "the united states", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01635-00388152-00388343": "force that regulates space activities", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01636-00388344-00388567": "and kind of space terrorism and all that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01637-00388568-00388695": "they decided to build their own", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01638-00388696-00388919": "metaverse where the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01639-00388920-00389078": "the army of united states would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01640-00389079-00389367": "operate so the army of the united states", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01641-00389368-00389582": "will govern outer space activity through", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01642-00389583-00389775": "the metaverse through the model", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01643-00389776-00390054": "that they built and thus is like this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01644-00390055-00390206": "really question how do you design this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01645-00390207-00390367": "model and it's like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01646-00390368-00390551": "it's a model for military but nobody's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01647-00390552-00390775": "going to space right there's 10 people", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01648-00390776-00390991": "that's how we do it we're doing through", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01649-00390992-00391167": "the model", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01650-00391168-00391263": "is that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01651-00391264-00392087": "something you wanted to hear", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01652-00392088-00392278": "yeah i was thinking like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01653-00392279-00392439": "since the very beginning actually we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01654-00392440-00392654": "thought that uh something we want to do", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01655-00392655-00392902": "would be to work with institutions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01656-00392903-00393175": "and in the sense of like participating", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01657-00393176-00393271": "in their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01658-00393272-00393543": "scenario projections and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01659-00393544-00393863": "perhaps like also intervening in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01660-00393864-00394167": "the design for example of the of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01661-00394168-00394439": "production of these scenarios and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01662-00394440-00394687": "like yeah putting together like a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01663-00394688-00394943": "interdisciplinary team and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01664-00394944-00395134": "in this way like to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01665-00395135-00395495": "try to have this kind of interactive", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01666-00395496-00395678": "collaboration with institutions but i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01667-00395679-00395791": "also think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01668-00395792-00395991": "that um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01669-00395992-00396263": "the act of like visualizing and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01670-00396264-00396623": "presenting in different formats these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01671-00396624-00396815": "models and this alternative models in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01672-00396816-00396919": "itself", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01673-00396920-00397175": "is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01674-00397176-00397510": "has a huge impact i think in the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01675-00397511-00397791": "expansion of the imagination around the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01676-00397792-00398063": "in the in in the around", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01677-00398064-00398358": "yeah the the limits of this field so i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01678-00398359-00398534": "also think that yes it's important to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01679-00398535-00398758": "try and collaborate and reach out to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01680-00398759-00399054": "institutions but also to present", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01681-00399055-00399271": "a vision perhaps that if it's out there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01682-00399272-00399527": "maybe it will actually attract interest", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01683-00399528-00399847": "of the institutions and uh yeah so i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01684-00399848-00400302": "think both ways it's important", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01685-00400303-00400695": "um yeah so in terms of governance models", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01686-00400696-00400791": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01687-00400792-00400902": "and how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01688-00400903-00401127": "yeah where is the agency that where does", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01689-00401128-00401302": "the agency reside basically that's where", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01690-00401303-00401495": "you're asking like how can these models", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01691-00401496-00401599": "become", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01692-00401600-00401927": "real like who gets to decide right and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01693-00401928-00402143": "um i think that you know everybody", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01694-00402144-00402302": "thinks that you know wouldn't it be nice", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01695-00402303-00402478": "if governments weren't so important that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01696-00402479-00402671": "we would live in like a post nation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01697-00402672-00402758": "state", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01698-00402759-00402927": "world and we've been speculating about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01699-00402928-00403134": "that since a long time but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01700-00403135-00403287": "um and you would think that that would", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01701-00403288-00403463": "be the case especially with a pandemic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01702-00403464-00403663": "because you know kobe doesn't care if", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01703-00403664-00403887": "you're spanish or from ukraine but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01704-00403888-00404215": "actually we've seen a further like sort", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01705-00404216-00404478": "of balkanization or like further", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01706-00404479-00404687": "enforcing of borders", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01707-00404688-00404927": "and i think that yeah governments and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01708-00404928-00405182": "national states are still", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01709-00405183-00405334": "hugely important", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01710-00405335-00405510": "and um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01711-00405511-00405647": "and that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01712-00405648-00405806": "unfortunately or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01713-00405807-00406127": "i don't know they are the key to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01714-00406128-00406327": "coordinating", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01715-00406328-00406678": "and kind of reach planetary scale", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01716-00406679-00406927": "governance i think governments are still", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01717-00406928-00407087": "keys you know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01718-00407088-00407334": "if you think about the ipcc", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01719-00407335-00407502": "scenarios they are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01720-00407503-00407678": "the blueprints from which governments", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01721-00407679-00407951": "make policies and they are the ones that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01722-00407952-00408158": "translate this like planetary scale", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01723-00408159-00408471": "goals of reaching a certain um level of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01724-00408472-00408654": "emissions or a certain", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01725-00408655-00408823": "temperature", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01726-00408824-00409015": "they translate these big goals into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01727-00409016-00409367": "smaller ones and then they kind of um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01728-00409368-00409607": "yeah communicate them downstream so this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01729-00409608-00409887": "is the way the things work now and of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01730-00409888-00410063": "course i mean", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01731-00410064-00410222": "a lot of people really believe in the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01732-00410223-00410422": "market and in other ways to do things", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01733-00410423-00410582": "that are outside of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01734-00410583-00410759": "of the government or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01735-00410760-00410966": "at least in you know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01736-00410967-00411134": "in their imagination they're outside of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01737-00411135-00411399": "the government so um there are different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01738-00411400-00411630": "things but you know also in our video we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01739-00411631-00411951": "speculate about this oil spills and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01740-00411952-00412143": "we speculate oh in 100 years what will", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01741-00412143-00412374": "russia do when the oil", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01742-00412375-00412510": "you know will they clean up they will", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01743-00412512-00412718": "will they want to have territorial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01744-00412719-00412943": "claims but probably because i mean", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01745-00412943-00413199": "i don't know i think this is this kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01746-00413200-00413343": "of fiction of national states is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01747-00413343-00413503": "something that's sticking", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01748-00413504-00413774": "uh way more than that we would have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01749-00413775-00413895": "hoped", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01750-00413896-00414022": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01751-00414023-00414287": "yeah yeah no and anything you were going", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01752-00414288-00414543": "to get", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01753-00414543-00414759": "yeah i just wanted to add that like yes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01754-00414760-00414934": "there is the layer of the national", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01755-00414935-00415191": "states but but there's also other layers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01756-00415192-00415407": "that are much harder to track and they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01757-00415408-00415503": "are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01758-00415504-00415718": "those that include the entanglements", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01759-00415719-00415926": "with like corporate entities and like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01760-00415927-00416143": "other forms of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01761-00416143-00416303": "commercial entities and for example", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01762-00416304-00416414": "those that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01763-00416415-00416622": "lead the exploration of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01764-00416623-00416895": "not only like the moon and celestial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01765-00416896-00417159": "bodies but also of the seabed for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01766-00417160-00417414": "example and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01767-00417415-00417630": "because of the interest in turning the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01768-00417631-00417934": "seabed into a resource then also there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01769-00417935-00418263": "is a possibility to map the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01770-00418264-00418510": "other areas of the planet or the outer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01771-00418512-00418718": "of outer space and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01772-00418719-00418974": "this information then can lead to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01773-00418975-00419214": "other kinds of representation not only", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01774-00419215-00419663": "the extractive one so yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01775-00419664-00419879": "yeah that is super interesting and also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01776-00419880-00420151": "i have to say that um while watching", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01777-00420152-00420327": "again the videos and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01778-00420328-00420399": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01779-00420400-00420551": "paying attention to these connections", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01780-00420552-00420887": "and um i noticed how that i could say", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01781-00420888-00421103": "both but maybe because more cosmos law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01782-00421104-00421366": "is um proposing um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01783-00421367-00421670": "this alternative or this transformation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01784-00421671-00421903": "of the governance focusing on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01785-00421904-00422191": "um the very physical conditions of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01786-00422192-00422470": "celestial bodies no you talk about mass", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01787-00422471-00422710": "size or weight even", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01788-00422712-00423014": "and i was thinking that maybe this could", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01789-00423015-00423343": "be also a way of imagine or envision a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01790-00423343-00423639": "kind of distributed governance in a way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01791-00423639-00423918": "that maybe this um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01792-00423919-00424183": "yeah burning through models that and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01793-00424184-00424566": "sensing by models um could regulate the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01794-00424567-00424759": "resource destruction of resources and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01795-00424760-00424870": "they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01796-00424871-00425079": "these kind of situations more related to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01797-00425080-00425214": "this physical", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01798-00425215-00425366": "condition and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01799-00425367-00425479": "material", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01800-00425480-00425791": "and then in terms of populations because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01801-00425792-00425991": "yeah populations of movement of people", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01802-00425992-00426214": "maybe the governance has to come in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01803-00426215-00426422": "another way so i was wondering if have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01804-00426423-00426695": "you ever speculated about a distributed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01805-00426696-00426918": "mode of governance that could", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01806-00426919-00427143": "act through different kind of mechanisms", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01807-00427143-00427255": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01808-00427256-00427559": "tools in depending on what is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01809-00427560-00427766": "the thing or the body to be regulated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01810-00427767-00427943": "because you were saying no that right", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01811-00427943-00428199": "now with the pandemics this kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01812-00428200-00428407": "speculations came to be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01813-00428408-00428703": "super like um provocative or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01814-00428704-00428903": "radical importance because of the times", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01815-00428904-00429191": "and we have experience that we have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01816-00429192-00429383": "certain kind of movement of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01817-00429384-00429599": "goods but then other kind of regulations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01818-00429600-00429743": "for the movement of people but at the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01819-00429743-00430039": "end there is a moment where the bodies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01820-00430039-00430303": "are or the pers the people are the ones", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01821-00430304-00430510": "that are suffering them", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01822-00430512-00430855": "stronger control over the movement so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01823-00430856-00430983": "have you or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01824-00430984-00431159": "did you get to come have a conversation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01825-00431160-00431327": "about what if", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01826-00431328-00431599": "there are different kind of government", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01827-00431600-00431863": "models or systems operating at the same", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01828-00431864-00432143": "time depending on whether", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01829-00432143-00433007": "what is the thing to be governed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01830-00433008-00433295": "yeah uh i think what cosmos law trying", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01831-00433296-00433559": "to do it's a there is no", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01832-00433560-00433727": "absolutely no governments there is like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01833-00433728-00433991": "the space of law is empty on the level", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01834-00433992-00434303": "after nation state and we don't have any", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01835-00434304-00434575": "body of governance that regulate", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01836-00434576-00434775": "the macroscope what is bigger than the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01837-00434776-00434975": "nation state it doesn't say it's like we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01838-00434976-00435151": "don't need to get rid of the nation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01839-00435152-00435399": "states the nation's tales are effective", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01840-00435400-00435687": "on the certain scale and uncertain they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01841-00435688-00435783": "are not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01842-00435784-00435951": "uncertain we need supernational", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01843-00435952-00436183": "institutions something bigger", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01844-00436184-00436391": "on some issues we need smaller like for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01845-00436392-00436591": "instance city governance is much better", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01846-00436592-00436783": "in some issues than", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01847-00436784-00437047": "than the state governments and like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01848-00437047-00437207": "coalition of these cities for instance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01849-00437208-00437455": "cfc-40 i think it's called", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01850-00437456-00437695": "uh like correlation over 40 cities they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01851-00437696-00437863": "much better", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01852-00437864-00438014": "they they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01853-00438015-00438183": "much better improved our climate change", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01854-00438184-00438422": "condition than their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01855-00438423-00438583": "then the states are because that's where", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01856-00438584-00438870": "our mission happens in the cities and so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01857-00438871-00439110": "like there was sociologists who said the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01858-00439112-00439239": "states", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01859-00439239-00439439": "are very bad for the big thing and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01860-00439439-00439583": "they're very bad for the small things", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01861-00439584-00439839": "but they're very good for the like for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01862-00439839-00439959": "for what", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01863-00439960-00440183": "for their appropriate scale", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01864-00440184-00440287": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01865-00440288-00440591": "about the decentralization", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01866-00440592-00440814": "i don't know like the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01867-00440815-00441007": "the supernational institution quite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01868-00441008-00441287": "decentralized like pcc", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01869-00441288-00441366": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01870-00441367-00441503": "it's a super national institution the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01871-00441504-00441679": "one like the international panel of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01872-00441680-00441863": "climate change there are many peoples", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01873-00441864-00442095": "they are thereby married they're they're", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01874-00442096-00442255": "on their initiative they're working for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01875-00442256-00442483": "free like for instance coyote protocol", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01876-00442484-00442647": "that's uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01877-00442647-00442863": "protecting a zone hole", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01878-00442864-00443022": "it's just a protocol it's a treaty it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01879-00443023-00443214": "international treaty", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01880-00443215-00443414": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01881-00443415-00443687": "we don't need to really governance by", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01882-00443688-00444031": "buy some some one person or one", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01883-00444032-00444135": "committee", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01884-00444135-00444359": "we need international law that's protect", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01885-00444360-00444614": "some things from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01886-00444615-00444918": "from doing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01887-00444919-00445151": "you could rebrand space law a cosmos", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01888-00445152-00445270": "lawyers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01889-00445271-00445479": "space tree or something", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01890-00445480-00445655": "like decentralized", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01891-00445656-00445943": "space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01892-00445943-00446047": "yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01893-00446047-00446879": "are there other any other questions", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01894-00446880-00446991": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01895-00446992-00447135": "thank you for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01896-00447135-00447343": "videos and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01897-00447343-00447591": "for expanding my mind a little bit", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01898-00447592-00447895": "because i really like this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01899-00447896-00448095": "this loop how to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01900-00448096-00448247": "like reinvent", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01901-00448247-00448503": "our like current law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01902-00448504-00448710": "uh through the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01903-00448712-00448975": "this outer point of view and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01904-00448976-00449310": "i noticed interesting fact that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01905-00449312-00449614": "we have a borders but borders are flat", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01906-00449615-00449918": "yeah it's like 2d image mapped on a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01907-00449919-00450063": "sphere", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01908-00450064-00450199": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01909-00450200-00450422": "and the law like written accordingly", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01910-00450423-00450679": "accordingly to that it's like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01911-00450680-00451095": "flat law or 2g laws yeah and when and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01912-00451096-00451359": "this is happening because of gravitation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01913-00451360-00451710": "so we can use these flat laws because we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01914-00451712-00452039": "have this force that applied and like we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01915-00452039-00452389": "have a barrier it's a problem we can't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01916-00452391-00452583": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01917-00452584-00452831": "like go or jump through the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01918-00452832-00452983": "through this and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01919-00452984-00453287": "um it's interesting question how how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01920-00453288-00453559": "this volumetric", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01921-00453560-00453735": "like borders", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01922-00453735-00454031": "and how volumetric law will like look", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01923-00454032-00454247": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01924-00454247-00454575": "and i also like this connection", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01925-00454576-00454847": "to the gravity force here so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01926-00454847-00455191": "space is not linear in that case and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01927-00455192-00455487": "this is interesting place where like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01928-00455488-00455775": "bureaucracy meeting einstein", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01929-00455776-00455983": "physics model", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01930-00455984-00456183": "and this is really interesting to think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01931-00456184-00456470": "about law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01932-00456471-00456831": "in terms of black hole like what is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01933-00456832-00457247": "how it's like going that because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01934-00457247-00457535": "even the time is going different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01935-00457535-00457614": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01936-00457615-00457807": "in that place so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01937-00457808-00457903": "yeah it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01938-00457904-00458047": "that was cool to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01939-00458047-00458159": "think about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01940-00458160-00458470": "uh this thank you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01941-00458471-00458718": "thank you i really like this framing uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01942-00458719-00458837": "low mid einstein", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01943-00458838-00458959": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01944-00458960-00459183": "but it is about like that the concept", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01945-00459184-00459422": "planetary that's important for for both", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01946-00459423-00459583": "of our project and the kind of for the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01947-00459584-00459839": "terraforming program in general is the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01948-00459839-00460014": "kind of uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01949-00460015-00460214": "like for instance deepest chakra party", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01950-00460215-00460422": "historian he distinguished global", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01951-00460423-00460710": "history like the history how we imagine", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01952-00460712-00460863": "like the globe", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01953-00460864-00461047": "through the like capitalist expansion", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01954-00461047-00461151": "through the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01955-00461152-00461318": "facebook", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01956-00461319-00461495": "information infrastructure that's kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01957-00461496-00461727": "of like the human layer and our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01958-00461728-00461975": "technologies from the planetary history", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01959-00461976-00462231": "which much longer than we are and the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01960-00462232-00462479": "kind of i think the current challenge", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01961-00462480-00462655": "that we have how we transition from the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01962-00462656-00462975": "old globe mods to this new", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01963-00462976-00463199": "planetary mod and pandemic is a good", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01964-00463200-00463439": "example for it it's like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01965-00463439-00463663": "now we kind of understand that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01966-00463664-00463903": "the planetary force is much stronger", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01967-00463904-00464070": "than our human forces and there is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01968-00464071-00465103": "nothing you can do with it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01969-00465104-00465279": "yeah i also thought it's uh it's very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01970-00465280-00465479": "interesting to to think this way and to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01971-00465480-00465743": "think of how sometimes is the perception", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01972-00465743-00466022": "that changes also the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01973-00466023-00466255": "the concept somehow in your head and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01974-00466256-00466607": "also how it's uh it's shared and i was", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01975-00466608-00466807": "thinking for example that yes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01976-00466808-00467063": "um so many of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01977-00467064-00467318": "structures and infrastructures and legal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01978-00467319-00467551": "infrastructures about the like around", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01979-00467552-00467683": "the earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01980-00467684-00467991": "uh don't work are not efficient for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01981-00467992-00468191": "example because exactly they perhaps", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01982-00468192-00468518": "they apply bi-dimensional", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01983-00468519-00468710": "parameters to something that is not and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01984-00468712-00468903": "i was also thinking in terms of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01985-00468904-00469118": "volumetric cinema and like how when", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01986-00469119-00469366": "you're using a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01987-00469367-00469559": "virtual environment for example that of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01988-00469560-00469791": "like you use in game design and like if", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01989-00469792-00470110": "you can apply a property to an object or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01990-00470112-00470318": "a texture and then make it behave in a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01991-00470319-00470575": "certain way and thinking of like how yes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01992-00470576-00470703": "you cannot", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01993-00470704-00470879": "apply a certain law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01994-00470880-00471175": "or a certain restriction to that object", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01995-00471176-00471407": "because it just doesn't respond and so i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01996-00471408-00471607": "was thinking how it's it's it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01997-00471608-00471807": "generative in this way to think through", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01998-00471808-00472022": "the representation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-01999-00472023-00472199": "as opposed to the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02000-00472200-00472551": "the theory or like just", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02001-00472552-00472831": "acknowledging the history uh and not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02002-00472832-00473070": "thinking about like a more speculative", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02003-00473071-00474127": "more imaginative form of representation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02004-00474128-00474327": "and yeah i think what cassandra trying", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02005-00474328-00474622": "to do that to say that scenarios that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02006-00474623-00474847": "seems like just a graph or just a story", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02007-00474847-00475063": "that we came up with it's actually built", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02008-00475064-00475351": "by the model with the very complicated", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02009-00475352-00475487": "model", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02010-00475488-00475751": "calculated by supercomputer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02011-00475752-00475983": "that's built on the real model of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02012-00475984-00476214": "earth that we kind of don't see that's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02013-00476215-00476487": "we in it's in the back end but it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02014-00476488-00477022": "actually a real model of the real horse", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02015-00477023-00477191": "hi um thank you very much for the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02016-00477192-00477343": "presentation um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02017-00477343-00477503": "it's really interesting to see the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02018-00477504-00477695": "projects and i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02019-00477696-00477951": "i'm interested in this part of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02020-00477952-00478239": "of the special debris that you refer in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02021-00478239-00478431": "the cosmos law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02022-00478432-00478583": "specifically in this part of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02023-00478584-00478710": "satellite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02024-00478712-00478918": "they say pollution there's this amount", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02025-00478919-00479127": "of like a calculation of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02026-00479128-00479447": "uh luxembourg is as more space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02027-00479447-00479655": "amount rather than space in than in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02028-00479656-00479895": "earth i was wondering first like how is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02029-00479896-00480079": "this calculated how how do you come up", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02030-00480080-00480231": "with with this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02031-00480232-00480366": "sort of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02032-00480367-00480647": "yeah comparisons or relations", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02033-00480647-00480814": "it's a joke", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02034-00480815-00481031": "we decided not to say but that's a quote", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02035-00481032-00481262": "from the president of luxembourg that's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02036-00481263-00481470": "great yeah that's because they signed uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02037-00481471-00481639": "like a couple years ago they signed an", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02038-00481639-00481855": "agreement and that kind of was a joke", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02039-00481856-00482031": "but like the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02040-00482032-00482143": "if you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02041-00482143-00482310": "think about the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02042-00482312-00482759": "uh comparably how much luxembourg uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02043-00482760-00482975": "have space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02044-00482976-00483159": "in relationship to other countries to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02045-00483160-00483366": "like huge countries like brazil or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02046-00483367-00483518": "something", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02047-00483519-00483775": "and how much they have satellites in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02048-00483776-00483927": "comparison to other countries they are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02049-00483928-00484166": "actually much bigger than 80 percent of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02050-00484167-00484303": "the countries and that's what our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02051-00484304-00484566": "project trying to show that's the we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02052-00484567-00484814": "might think that space for everybody but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02053-00484815-00484999": "in fact what defines sovereignty of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02054-00485000-00485175": "space is not like the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02055-00485176-00485407": "the rocks and we don't need to give the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02056-00485408-00485575": "passport to the rocks or the sovereignty", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02057-00485576-00485822": "to the rocks it's infrastructure that we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02058-00485823-00486039": "send there because that's what important", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02059-00486039-00486375": "on earth because for instance if uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02060-00486376-00486591": "i don't know spain decided that they", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02061-00486592-00486814": "want their own internet they own", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02062-00486815-00487031": "firewall like russia decide they cannot", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02063-00487032-00487231": "do it without the satellite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02064-00487232-00487422": "and thus who can", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02065-00487423-00487639": "who has more satellites this really", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02066-00487639-00487870": "controls the earthquake planetary scale", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02067-00487871-00488062": "infrastructure and this is only three", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02068-00488063-00488247": "countries who does this it's russia", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02069-00488247-00488343": "china", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02070-00488343-00488551": "and united states", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02071-00488552-00488766": "okay uh just to follow up on on this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02072-00488767-00489055": "topic then um i mean the the satellite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02073-00489056-00489222": "let's say um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02074-00489223-00489527": "kind of like formation or how this uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02075-00489528-00489727": "like i don't know like a pollution of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02076-00489728-00489831": "this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02077-00489832-00490255": "uh over loaded space presence and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02078-00490256-00490503": "um i don't know how this how can you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02079-00490504-00490703": "arrange this or how can you go deeper", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02080-00490704-00490831": "into that topic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02081-00490832-00490966": "i don't know in this kind of research", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02082-00490967-00491191": "let's say of how should be this arranged", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02083-00491192-00491310": "now if there's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02084-00491312-00491566": "already clearly uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02085-00491567-00491862": "private interest dominating this this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02086-00491863-00492022": "place know you there's these few", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02087-00492023-00492239": "companies which are overtaking the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02088-00492239-00492351": "special", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02089-00492352-00492647": "area this fear so is there some proposal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02090-00492647-00492807": "already or some ideas of how to go", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02091-00492808-00493039": "further into that to regulate the space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02092-00493039-00493239": "debris yes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02093-00493239-00493575": "yeah there are and everybody", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02094-00493576-00493814": "very very scared about that right now", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02095-00493815-00493927": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02096-00493928-00494070": "firstly it's come from scientists", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02097-00494071-00494255": "because scientist is very uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02098-00494256-00494447": "very cautious of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02099-00494447-00494543": "the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02100-00494543-00494822": "light pollution provided by the star", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02101-00494823-00494999": "link new", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02102-00495000-00495199": "uh new satellites for the internet by", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02103-00495200-00495318": "elon musk", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02104-00495319-00495447": "because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02105-00495447-00495670": "he basically the last year put more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02106-00495671-00495918": "satellites than they were for the last", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02107-00495919-00496039": "50 years", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02108-00496039-00496135": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02109-00496135-00496359": "if it's going to continue this way for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02110-00496360-00496543": "three years we're not gonna be able to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02111-00496543-00496703": "use any", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02112-00496704-00496999": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02113-00497000-00497391": "terrestrial based telescope which like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02114-00497392-00497535": "very important for scientific", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02115-00497535-00497759": "discoveries and like what yeah we have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02116-00497760-00497935": "we have now the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02117-00497935-00498127": "space web telescope we have now now", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02118-00498128-00498359": "hubble two telescope other is not gonna", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02119-00498360-00498527": "work if there would be enough debris and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02120-00498528-00498735": "there would be enough satellites so the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02121-00498735-00498943": "first who want to regulate this thing is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02122-00498943-00499207": "a scientific committee that's trying now", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02123-00499208-00499495": "to push to stop the elon musk the stop", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02124-00499496-00499679": "the amazon creeper which is the same", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02125-00499680-00499910": "project stop other commentary companies", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02126-00499912-00500095": "for to send in it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02127-00500096-00500359": "and another problem that's like the past", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02128-00500360-00500462": "year", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02129-00500463-00500583": "esa", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02130-00500584-00500751": "was going to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02131-00500752-00501103": "crash into this basic satellite and like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02132-00501104-00501247": "if satellites crashed to the moon it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02133-00501247-00501583": "not really a problem", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02134-00501584-00501807": "yeah it's not it's not nice but if", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02135-00501808-00502007": "satellites crashed on another satellite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02136-00502008-00502247": "it's it's very much a problem because it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02137-00502247-00502455": "generates huge amount of debris that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02138-00502456-00502614": "will crush other satellites and it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02139-00502615-00502895": "like a chain and effect and basically", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02140-00502896-00503183": "spacex just pieced couple of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02141-00503184-00503462": "uh emails from isa", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02142-00503463-00503759": "and replied them and two days oh sorry", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02143-00503760-00503991": "and these i needed to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02144-00503992-00504255": "make the space up like special operation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02145-00504256-00504391": "to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02146-00504392-00504607": "create an alternative trajectory to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02147-00504608-00504766": "avoid this basic satellite so it's a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02148-00504767-00505070": "private company by tesla which is re", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02149-00505071-00505255": "recently like 30 percent of all tesla", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02150-00505256-00505422": "went back to factory because they will", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02151-00505423-00505583": "shitly", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02152-00505584-00505655": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02153-00505656-00505831": "it's need to be regulated and it needs", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02154-00505832-00506070": "to be regulated very fast", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02155-00506071-00506647": "and it's very important yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02156-00506647-00506839": "yeah i also think that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02157-00506839-00507055": "if elon musk actually manages to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02158-00507056-00507287": "implement this its plan of sending all", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02159-00507288-00507470": "the satellites into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02160-00507471-00507718": "um into orbit i think there will be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02161-00507719-00508047": "virtually no rare earth materials left", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02162-00508047-00508366": "on earth so it's a really like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02163-00508367-00508631": "very material very serious thing and um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02164-00508632-00508799": "i feel like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02165-00508800-00508879": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02166-00508880-00509079": "maybe that's something that i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02167-00509080-00509279": "i've always been critical about also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02168-00509280-00509414": "astralica that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02169-00509415-00509575": "there is the idea that you always need", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02170-00509576-00509751": "to have some kind of incentive not to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02171-00509752-00510014": "let people do bad things you can just", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02172-00510015-00510175": "forbid them to do", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02173-00510176-00510383": "things and punish them when they do and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02174-00510384-00510655": "regulate and make them pay taxes and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02175-00510656-00510966": "prevent them from from doing that um and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02176-00510967-00511262": "i mean the us would totally have the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02177-00511263-00511487": "kind of power to stop", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02178-00511488-00511735": "you know uh spacex from doing these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02179-00511735-00511943": "things the u.s alone you know even", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02180-00511943-00512159": "without thinking of a planetary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02181-00512160-00512455": "coalition of china russia and in the us", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02182-00512456-00512718": "it's literally the u.s could do it um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02183-00512719-00512791": "but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02184-00512792-00512983": "somehow we we're here thinking like oh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02185-00512984-00513143": "how can we find a way so that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02186-00513143-00513327": "everybody's happy and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02187-00513328-00513599": "like no i mean you can just", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02188-00513600-00514007": "don't don't let the guy do this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02189-00514008-00514175": "yeah i was", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02190-00514176-00514343": "i was also i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02191-00514343-00514518": "i came across a piece of knew that i'm", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02192-00514519-00514847": "not 100 sure it's verified but like it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02193-00514847-00515087": "was actually about a chinese", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02194-00515088-00515303": "uh private company", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02195-00515304-00515647": "launching a satellite to collect the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02196-00515647-00515910": "space debris and they already collected", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02197-00515912-00516079": "some and this is also something that has", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02198-00516080-00516343": "been just done and not decided at any", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02199-00516343-00516566": "level and of course like there were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02200-00516567-00516862": "comments of like um american journalist", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02201-00516863-00517070": "commenting that you know this is a some", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02202-00517071-00517318": "sort of like breach of sovereignty of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02203-00517319-00517551": "space to do something actually good for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02204-00517552-00517822": "space so it's it's very complicated i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02205-00517823-00518047": "don't even know like exactly how it went", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02206-00518047-00518247": "but like these are also issues that will", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02207-00518247-00518503": "emerge for sure like these initiatives", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02208-00518504-00518751": "also for virtuous um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02209-00518752-00519095": "purposes and uh that create all of these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02210-00519096-00519247": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02211-00519247-00520159": "problems and the resistances so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02212-00520160-00520599": "yeah i think in this case when chinese", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02213-00520600-00520903": "satellite collected these debris", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02214-00520904-00521039": "a lot of people", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02215-00521039-00521270": "from the space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02216-00521271-00521527": "fields they saw", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02217-00521528-00521766": "kind of security issues because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02218-00521767-00521975": "if this satellite can", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02219-00521976-00522183": "collect debris", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02220-00522184-00522375": "it also can collect", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02221-00522376-00522679": "other satellites and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02222-00522680-00522918": "yeah i think it's a huge problem and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02223-00522919-00523199": "should be regulated as well yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02224-00523200-00523295": "it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02225-00523296-00523535": "wasn't really the case because there is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02226-00523535-00523727": "a liability convention in our normal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02227-00523728-00524007": "convention it's a treaties from the cold", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02228-00524008-00524199": "war which basically forbid you touch", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02229-00524200-00524366": "other country's satellite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02230-00524367-00524535": "because it would be considered the act", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02231-00524536-00524631": "of war", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02232-00524632-00524791": "and that's why it's because we have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02233-00524792-00524983": "outdated treaties you cannot do", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02234-00524984-00525191": "something new and the treat is going to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02235-00525192-00525383": "change because there are 40 years old", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02236-00525384-00525551": "and there was no elon musk the only", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02237-00525552-00525870": "states could could launch a rocket and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02238-00525871-00526014": "what people were afraid about that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02239-00526015-00526191": "somebody would launch in the space in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02240-00526192-00526759": "nuclear bomb", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02241-00526760-00527047": "yeah i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02242-00527048-00527214": "want to ask when you say like don't let", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02243-00527215-00527399": "the guy do it that it's amazing actually", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02244-00527400-00527614": "it's like yeah this is how things should", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02245-00527615-00527783": "be but then there is a thing that these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02246-00527784-00528135": "guys are incredibly rich and if the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02247-00528136-00528343": "way to punish them is about taxation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02248-00528344-00528462": "maybe it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02249-00528463-00528639": "not enough because they could pay", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02250-00528640-00528887": "whatever we can imagine so wondering", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02251-00528888-00529062": "well this is a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02252-00529063-00529262": "continuous thinking about what could be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02253-00529263-00529462": "other ways of punishment that is not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02254-00529463-00529591": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02255-00529592-00529862": "uh killing them or or ask for a lot of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02256-00529863-00530111": "money like what what do they yeah what", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02257-00530112-00530422": "are the reasons or how to imagine like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02258-00530423-00530518": "other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02259-00530519-00530639": "ways of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02260-00530640-00530847": "yeah kind of cooperation or solidarity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02261-00530848-00531055": "that is not in relation to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02262-00531056-00531151": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02263-00531152-00531327": "yeah to them to the money because at the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02264-00531328-00531527": "end this seems to be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02265-00531528-00532118": "not enough", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02266-00532119-00532422": "i don't understand", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02267-00532423-00532687": "like what can like what are the ways or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02268-00532688-00533022": "what other ways can we imagine to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02269-00533023-00533287": "make the guys do good things instead of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02270-00533288-00533518": "bad like maybe it's about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02271-00533519-00533879": "education or sharing or communication or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02272-00533880-00534111": "like how to make the guys the bad guys", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02273-00534112-00534391": "cooperate and work in a good way instead", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02274-00534392-00534670": "of a bad way not only by making them pay", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02275-00534671-00535031": "putting them in jail you mean", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02276-00535032-00535311": "no i mean like maybe if we think like if", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02277-00535312-00535511": "it is so clear that this is not a good", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02278-00535512-00535759": "thing to do and we all can", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02279-00535760-00536007": "kind of agree if it is so evident maybe", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02280-00536008-00536175": "it's because it is not that evident or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02281-00536176-00536366": "maybe because this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02282-00536367-00536655": "nations or the governors are also like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02283-00536656-00536927": "inside of this kind of bad behavior so i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02284-00536928-00537166": "mean what are like where is the good and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02285-00537167-00537303": "where is the bad because maybe for us", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02286-00537304-00537495": "it's super evident but not for them", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02287-00537496-00537703": "because they are pushing all that kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02288-00537704-00537879": "of interest or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02289-00537880-00538079": "yeah of course you know elon musk or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02290-00538080-00538366": "whatever it's just a kind of caricature", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02291-00538367-00538718": "of an infrastructure and the system that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02292-00538719-00538935": "made that kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02293-00538936-00539166": "bizarre characters possible", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02294-00539167-00539239": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02295-00539240-00539335": "that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02296-00539336-00539518": "portrayed them as being success", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02297-00539519-00539759": "successful they built the kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02298-00539760-00539991": "social and economic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02299-00539992-00540199": "underpinning structures that allowed", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02300-00540200-00540462": "them to do that so i i don't know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02301-00540463-00540647": "um yeah obviously", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02302-00540648-00540822": "change everything but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02303-00540823-00540927": "yes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02304-00540928-00541047": "sure i don't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02305-00541048-00541207": "i don't know but for now i mean they're", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02306-00541208-00541431": "very obvious things that to me i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02307-00541432-00541639": "nation states could do", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02308-00541640-00541855": "to stop them and then yeah like totally", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02309-00541856-00542103": "reforming a capitalistic system i don't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02310-00542104-00542407": "know maybe but i mean it's really", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02311-00542408-00542622": "you know like a very big big question i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02312-00542623-00542759": "have no idea", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02313-00542760-00542918": "i didn't pretend you to write the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02314-00542919-00543111": "question like this sorry it's like about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02315-00543112-00543311": "like a reflection like maybe it's not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02316-00543312-00543575": "about the management of resources of uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02317-00543576-00543822": "and money but a matter of education and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02318-00543823-00544070": "this is i think in relation to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02319-00544071-00544455": "how the terraforming is uh conceived in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02320-00544456-00544607": "the main program on the main like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02321-00544608-00544766": "statement my stroke", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02322-00544767-00544962": "be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02323-00544963-00545166": "geotechnical uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02324-00545167-00545327": "activation should come before", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02325-00545328-00545518": "geopolitical modifications i'm i'm not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02326-00545519-00545695": "that sure if this is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02327-00545696-00545775": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02328-00545776-00546039": "well i i don't have also neither the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02329-00546040-00546295": "answer but i'm not that sure if this is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02330-00546296-00546607": "the way that we are going to achieve the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02331-00546608-00546855": "required a transformation of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02332-00546856-00546991": "planetary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02333-00546992-00547295": "regulations or models or systems because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02334-00547296-00547647": "at the end we can kind of cover", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02335-00547648-00547935": "holes but if the society is still", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02336-00547936-00548039": "being", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02337-00548040-00548262": "informed with this kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02338-00548263-00548511": "characters and people behaving this way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02339-00548512-00548695": "and these are the kind of people that we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02340-00548696-00548966": "have as a model are okay i mean", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02341-00548967-00549166": "that i'm not that sure if the geo take", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02342-00549167-00549343": "like yeah your technical should come", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02343-00549344-00549511": "before the geopolitical modifications", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02344-00549512-00549670": "yeah i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02345-00549671-00549903": "i think i i sort of under understand", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02346-00549904-00550151": "where we're trying to get um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02347-00550152-00550422": "uh yeah i think one point that we try to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02348-00550423-00550711": "make with cassandra is that um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02349-00550712-00550935": "you know technology or like prime entire", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02350-00550936-00551159": "scale technology or even geoengineering", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02351-00551160-00551407": "is not simply like the brick and mortar", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02352-00551408-00551631": "kind of canon then", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02353-00551632-00551855": "co2 or the atmosphere", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02354-00551856-00552014": "thing but it's also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02355-00552015-00552318": "more acceptable technologies like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02356-00552319-00552518": "language or scenario planning if you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02357-00552519-00552727": "give government a menu of things that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02358-00552728-00552887": "they can do they're going to pick", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02359-00552888-00553039": "something from that menu and it's also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02360-00553040-00553175": "technology", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02361-00553176-00553239": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02362-00553240-00553518": "we tried to address that specific", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02363-00553519-00553743": "kind of corner um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02364-00553744-00553879": "that you know there were many other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02365-00553880-00554014": "projects that kind of deal with other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02366-00554015-00554239": "things like carbon capture or more kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02367-00554240-00554359": "of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02368-00554360-00554655": "um yeah hardcore sort of in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02369-00554656-00554943": "interventions into the world and but i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02370-00554944-00555191": "think that things like you know policy", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02371-00555192-00555447": "and law and scenario planning are not in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02372-00555448-00555727": "any way less real than these other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02373-00555728-00555903": "things that are not in any way less", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02374-00555904-00556047": "important", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02375-00556048-00556191": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02376-00556192-00556407": "yeah for sure", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02377-00556408-00556695": "yeah i also think like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02378-00556696-00557087": "there is a tendency to reduce the like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02379-00557088-00557166": "one", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02380-00557167-00557391": "final lesson from the terraforming", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02381-00557392-00557614": "program and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02382-00557615-00557703": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02383-00557704-00557799": "i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02384-00557800-00558022": "actually what we realized throughout the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02385-00558023-00558247": "program and afterwards continuing our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02386-00558248-00558414": "project was that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02387-00558415-00558718": "it you cannot really place the blame or", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02388-00558719-00559014": "the accountability in one place only and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02389-00559015-00559247": "there are of course more glaring uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02390-00559248-00559407": "nodes of these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02391-00559408-00559759": "accountabilities and tracking of how um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02392-00559760-00560039": "yeah how all of all of all of this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02393-00560040-00560447": "infrastructure is then enacted but then", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02394-00560448-00560703": "it's very important to keep", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02395-00560704-00560887": "the big picture and every different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02396-00560888-00560975": "layer", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02397-00560976-00561175": "layer and every different node in this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02398-00561176-00561391": "in the in the layers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02399-00561392-00561670": "under scrutiny and it's important to to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02400-00561671-00561943": "keep mapping and to keep", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02401-00561944-00562262": "trying to connect the dots and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02402-00562263-00562431": "actually yeah like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02403-00562432-00562670": "trace the genealogy of how all of these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02404-00562671-00562959": "processes happen so the fact that yes of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02405-00562960-00563239": "course um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02406-00563240-00563583": "technology um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02407-00563584-00563831": "uh somehow like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02408-00563832-00564111": "facilitates the work of the of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02409-00564112-00564311": "governments but also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02410-00564312-00564527": "what technologies are developed also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02411-00564528-00564822": "depend on forms of government support", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02412-00564823-00565127": "and for certain purposes so perhaps", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02413-00565128-00565295": "there are a lot of technologies that are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02414-00565296-00565495": "not being developed because of this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02415-00565496-00565662": "narrow", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02416-00565663-00565966": "vision for example and uh so yes i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02417-00565967-00566111": "it's uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02418-00566112-00566375": "so many different layers and uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02419-00566376-00566518": "also the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02420-00566519-00566799": "the less uh i don't know even the the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02421-00566800-00567143": "boring aspects of the bureaucracy of the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02422-00567144-00567414": "the processes of how things", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02423-00567415-00567655": "are enacted and enforced this is also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02424-00567656-00567870": "something that needs to be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02425-00567871-00569791": "we need to keep always an eye on so yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02426-00569792-00569966": "thank you thank you for the videos and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02427-00569967-00570310": "the conversation and the yeah all these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02428-00570311-00570551": "inspiring ideas so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02429-00570552-00570703": "um there's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02430-00570704-00570966": "the question comes from from the second", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02431-00570967-00571231": "project so cosmos law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02432-00571232-00571455": "and i think it goes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02433-00571456-00571718": "then to cassandra and it is a question", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02434-00571719-00571991": "about the idea of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02435-00571992-00572287": "alien agency", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02436-00572288-00572431": "and how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02437-00572432-00572710": "alien agency", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02438-00572711-00573007": "reshapes the idea of modeling", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02439-00573008-00573222": "and turns it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02440-00573223-00573318": "from", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02441-00573319-00573591": "something related to management", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02442-00573592-00573814": "to something", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02443-00573815-00574047": "related to conversation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02444-00574048-00574310": "and perhaps conflict", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02445-00574311-00574607": "so for instance in in cosmos law the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02446-00574608-00574727": "question would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02447-00574728-00574935": "how would", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02448-00574936-00575255": "alien intelligence alien", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02449-00575256-00575483": "law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02450-00575484-00575647": "alien", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02451-00575648-00575807": "yeah alien laws", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02452-00575808-00576062": "would be mapped into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02453-00576063-00576303": "into this idea", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02454-00576304-00576414": "and then", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02455-00576415-00576614": "i think this also goes to the question", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02456-00576615-00576887": "of of modeling as us", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02457-00576888-00577110": "as as a as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02458-00577111-00577199": "as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02459-00577200-00577439": "yeah as related to governance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02460-00577440-00577662": "so in which ways", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02461-00577663-00578070": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02462-00578071-00578359": "i i was thinking in which ways", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02463-00578360-00578735": "does the project of cassandra assume", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02464-00578736-00578862": "that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02465-00578863-00579118": "the earth or the processes of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02466-00579119-00579191": "on", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02467-00579192-00579431": "on on the earth the idea that these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02468-00579432-00579679": "processes can be modeled", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02469-00579680-00579991": "somehow invisibilizes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02470-00579992-00580391": "the very possibility of the earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02471-00580392-00580670": "responding to the modeling activities i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02472-00580671-00580895": "know there's a recursive loop", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02473-00580896-00581014": "and there's a possibility of this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02474-00581015-00581262": "recursive loop but i wonder in which", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02475-00581263-00581351": "ways", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02476-00581352-00581527": "this recursive loop", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02477-00581528-00581839": "necessarily leads to an equilibrium", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02478-00581840-00581927": "point", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02479-00581928-00582191": "or rather as it occurs within financial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02480-00582192-00582303": "markets", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02481-00582304-00582470": "to the continuous", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02482-00582471-00582775": "production and reproduction of noise so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02483-00582776-00582879": "within", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02484-00582880-00583070": "finance markets", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02485-00583071-00583414": "there's plenty of modeling activity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02486-00583415-00583831": "but there's it is about modeling human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02487-00583832-00583999": "human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02488-00584000-00584143": "actors", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02489-00584144-00584343": "and therefore", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02490-00584344-00584631": "they know they are being modeled human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02491-00584632-00584975": "and non-human so it is about algorithms", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02492-00584976-00585247": "competing with other algorithms so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02493-00585248-00585479": "there's there's this loop of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02494-00585480-00585807": "modeling together with the awareness of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02495-00585808-00585895": "being", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02496-00585896-00586055": "modeled", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02497-00586056-00586310": "so then then there's the the space of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02498-00586311-00586455": "response", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02499-00586456-00586727": "so you behave in a different way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02500-00586728-00586959": "i don't know if the earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02501-00586960-00587222": "would be able to synthesize", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02502-00587223-00587335": "in different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02503-00587336-00587639": "you know carbon dioxide some bacteria", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02504-00587640-00587799": "but perhaps", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02505-00587800-00588095": "and i don't know if this in production", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02506-00588096-00588366": "of invisibility", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02507-00588367-00588470": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02508-00588471-00589143": "might be problematic or not so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02509-00589144-00589566": "can you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02510-00589567-00589662": "can you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02511-00589663-00589910": "tell a bit more about production of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02512-00589911-00590062": "invisibility what do you mean by", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02513-00590063-00590214": "visibility", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02514-00590215-00590575": "yeah invisibilizing the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02515-00590576-00590670": "the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02516-00590671-00591087": "possibility of agency of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02517-00591088-00591391": "that which is being modeled of that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02518-00591392-00591543": "entity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02519-00591544-00591631": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02520-00591632-00591831": "the the agency of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02521-00591832-00592310": "responding to the model", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02522-00592311-00592735": "so personally um i'm always kind of wary", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02523-00592736-00592999": "of kind of locating", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02524-00593000-00593207": "agency that's outside of humans", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02525-00593208-00593487": "somewhere else of course we do not have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02526-00593488-00593735": "all of the agency that we map we can", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02527-00593736-00593903": "only map you know as far as we are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02528-00593904-00594062": "concerned and there is always something", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02529-00594063-00594247": "that's external", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02530-00594248-00594495": "but i'm always wary of characterizing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02531-00594496-00594687": "that external thing it's something that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02532-00594688-00595031": "has its own wants or agency", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02533-00595032-00595222": "i never particularly like the guy", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02534-00595223-00595503": "hypothesis for example um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02535-00595504-00595743": "and because they think it just tends to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02536-00595744-00595910": "anthropomorphize", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02537-00595911-00595999": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02538-00596000-00596231": "the earth or the planet and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02539-00596232-00596359": "i mean i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02540-00596360-00596527": "i could talk about why i don't like it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02541-00596528-00596807": "but it's basically bottom line i don't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02542-00596808-00596951": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02543-00596952-00597110": "in terms of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02544-00597111-00597262": "cassandra i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02545-00597263-00597407": "you know scenario planning is a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02546-00597408-00597559": "technique that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02547-00597560-00597775": "does account for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02548-00597776-00598159": "kind of external and non-non-human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02549-00598160-00598343": "agency in a quite", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02550-00598344-00598503": "productive way", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02551-00598504-00598799": "it was developed by hermann khan around", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02552-00598800-00599087": "in the 50s to kind of face the threat of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02553-00599088-00599414": "nuclear war and the nuclear bomb itself", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02554-00599415-00599679": "was something that was conceptualized as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02555-00599680-00599743": "a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02556-00599744-00599862": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02557-00599863-00600055": "possible doomsday machine so as a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02558-00600056-00600239": "mechanism that once triggered would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02559-00600240-00600414": "automatic and would be outside of human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02560-00600415-00600655": "control and could have been stopped", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02561-00600656-00600847": "right so there is always this desire to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02562-00600848-00601007": "kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02563-00601008-00601279": "you know understand that we we do not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02564-00601280-00601399": "really have the agency there is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02565-00601400-00601535": "something else", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02566-00601536-00601727": "and in case of scenario planning it was", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02567-00601728-00602127": "always this unthinkable that herman khan", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02568-00602128-00602383": "thought of and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02569-00602384-00602551": "yeah i feel like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02570-00602552-00602631": "in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02571-00602632-00602918": "contemporary climate scenario planning", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02572-00602919-00603062": "because it's what we've been looking at", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02573-00603063-00603247": "there are you know climate models kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02574-00603248-00603543": "of tend to accommodate for this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02575-00603544-00603735": "and again like i wouldn't know what to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02576-00603736-00603895": "enter in terms of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02577-00603896-00605614": "agency of of the earth", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02578-00605615-00605799": "what do you mean by aliens like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02579-00605800-00606143": "extraterrestrial intelligence", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02580-00606144-00606399": "it is of course playing the speculative", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02581-00606400-00606503": "game", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02582-00606504-00606670": "so we are here already in the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02583-00606671-00606910": "speculative game so why not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02584-00606911-00607287": "but it is about yeah this possibility so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02585-00607288-00607422": "the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02586-00607423-00607727": "so it is this possibility of space so it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02587-00607728-00608127": "so just imagine so 15th century people", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02588-00608128-00608287": "going west", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02589-00608288-00608575": "and arriving to what they thought were", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02590-00608576-00608679": "the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02591-00608680-00608935": "yeah the east india", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02592-00608936-00609127": "and then they found something different", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02593-00609128-00609383": "so this encounter not really unthinkable", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02594-00609384-00609462": "no", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02595-00609463-00609599": "so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02596-00609600-00609870": "speaking of cosmos law there is of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02597-00609871-00610135": "course this possibility of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02598-00610136-00610414": "yeah this this and how so of of this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02599-00610415-00610759": "encounter aliens so yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02600-00610760-00610910": "so that would be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02601-00610911-00611079": "how how is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02602-00611080-00611479": "how this unthinkable can be introduced", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02603-00611480-00611607": "into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02604-00611608-00611743": "into this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02605-00611744-00612079": "law space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02606-00612080-00612335": "i first i'm first gonna prefer that i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02607-00612336-00612551": "think i'm quite on the same page with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02608-00612552-00612743": "kyra i didn't think we should", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02609-00612744-00613014": "romanticize like non-human", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02610-00613015-00613247": "like animal entities non-annulators like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02611-00613248-00613527": "rock on the mars like this colonial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02612-00613528-00613783": "discourse this is max mars is not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02613-00613784-00613975": "empty we shouldn't go there and do", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02614-00613976-00614175": "anything any scientific because there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02615-00614176-00614295": "are microbes", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02616-00614296-00614566": "i don't think that's the case i think we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02617-00614567-00614862": "need to accept that we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02618-00614863-00615070": "did some bad thing for the natural", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02619-00615071-00615310": "cycles but many other things also do and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02620-00615311-00615535": "it's a place of responsibility of humans", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02621-00615536-00615814": "to fix it but not to kind of romanticize", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02622-00615815-00615959": "some kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02623-00615960-00616222": "agency outside of us i think it's more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02624-00616223-00616543": "of a like we we need more agency inside", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02625-00616544-00616735": "ourselves in our effort more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02626-00616736-00616943": "responsibility for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02627-00616944-00617118": "for the kind of the system than rather", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02628-00617119-00617351": "just say okay yeah animals need rights", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02629-00617352-00617575": "or animals needs money or like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02630-00617576-00617935": "the earth's regulators itself", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02631-00617936-00618670": "for the extraterrestrial intelligence", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02632-00618671-00619007": "the cosmos law kind of speaks about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02633-00619008-00619295": "where law happened not how it happened", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02634-00619296-00619447": "and we like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02635-00619448-00619559": "the least", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02636-00619560-00619759": "interesting part for me the most", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02637-00619760-00619999": "speculative part in the project is that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02638-00620000-00620287": "we imagine this low meets einstein that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02639-00620288-00620503": "we define where law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02640-00620504-00620743": "operates by the gravitational force of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02641-00620744-00621055": "the celestial body so thus you kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02642-00621056-00621207": "not expanding", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02643-00621208-00621479": "the law from earth everywhere but you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02644-00621480-00621751": "expanding it from the every celestial", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02645-00621752-00622047": "body so moon has its own stock of layers", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02646-00622048-00622166": "of law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02647-00622167-00622518": "and thus it's kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02648-00622519-00622695": "it can say", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02649-00622696-00622879": "there was this mediation layer between", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02650-00622880-00623143": "celestial bodies that's that's kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02651-00623144-00623375": "regulate asteroids", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02652-00623376-00623655": "but how we would regulate uh contact", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02653-00623656-00624143": "with aliens", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02654-00624144-00624214": "well", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02655-00624215-00624366": "it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02656-00624367-00624591": "it's a question for a scenario planning", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02657-00624592-00624847": "i think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02658-00624848-00625031": "you know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02659-00625032-00625207": "okay last thing i want to say about this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02660-00625208-00625414": "because i i take the question very", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02661-00625415-00625551": "seriously i think it's a really good", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02662-00625552-00625695": "question and i think that taking it a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02663-00625696-00625879": "bit less literally might be actually", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02664-00625880-00626055": "very interesting because if you think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02665-00626056-00626422": "about the alien as not just like an 80", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02666-00626423-00626622": "kind of guy but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02667-00626623-00626903": "it's some kind of outside point of view", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02668-00626904-00627247": "that can look at what's already here and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02669-00627248-00627503": "make you see the absurdity of what many", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02670-00627504-00627670": "things that we're doing that you know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02671-00627671-00627862": "i'm just thinking of oh what if there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02672-00627863-00628110": "were aliens and we are we are kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02673-00628111-00628255": "mining the moon and doing all this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02674-00628256-00628479": "stupid stuff like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02675-00628480-00628639": "and and you know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02676-00628640-00628847": "in the same way for example i don't know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02677-00628848-00628943": "all these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02678-00628944-00629214": "casino feminists maybe in some ways kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02679-00629215-00629366": "of tries to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02680-00629367-00629551": "to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02681-00629552-00629751": "you know this this idea of alienation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02682-00629752-00629903": "and um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02683-00629904-00630183": "being alienated from your own experience", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02684-00630184-00630366": "and trying to abstract things and i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02685-00630367-00630599": "think in that sense maybe", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02686-00630600-00630814": "it could be an interesting framework to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02687-00630815-00630983": "think about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02688-00630984-00631510": "yeah space or the future or yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02689-00631511-00631743": "um yeah i was also thinking about the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02690-00631744-00631959": "fact that uh when we think of aliens", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02691-00631960-00632218": "like we tend we tend to project like uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02692-00632219-00632495": "entrepreneurial eyes also when we think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02693-00632496-00632759": "of non-human or post-human subjectivity", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02694-00632760-00633087": "and agency and and that's the the danger", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02695-00633088-00633399": "as uh as we mentioned before but um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02696-00633400-00633687": "uh perhaps like you know the the alien", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02697-00633688-00634022": "form could be some bacteria that is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02698-00634023-00634327": "falling from because of the moon", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02699-00634328-00634447": "extraction", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02700-00634448-00634639": "on in the moon and then it arrives and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02701-00634640-00634839": "then it kind of like feeds back into", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02702-00634840-00635118": "this uh into this process but also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02703-00635119-00635359": "to respond to the other question i was", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02704-00635360-00635622": "also thinking that yes of course like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02705-00635623-00635910": "uh every form of representation is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02706-00635911-00636222": "violence some to an extent also language", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02707-00636223-00636583": "somehow is violence um and uh it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02708-00636584-00636879": "impossible to to have a map as big as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02709-00636880-00637087": "the territory because the the level of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02710-00637088-00637431": "detail then would be um anyway", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02711-00637432-00637599": "impossible to read because of the the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02712-00637600-00637759": "amount uh the sheer amount of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02713-00637760-00637983": "information", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02714-00637984-00638103": "and uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02715-00638104-00638287": "of course um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02716-00638288-00638366": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02717-00638367-00638495": "this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02718-00638496-00638814": "aspect of mapping and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02719-00638815-00638895": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02720-00638896-00639175": "machine vision and satellite imagery", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02721-00639176-00639422": "this is something that is very um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02722-00639423-00639883": "driven by extractive logics uh but also", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02723-00639884-00640055": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02724-00640056-00640287": "giving up like the attempt completely", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02725-00640288-00640510": "because of not wanting to feed this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02726-00640511-00640822": "logic it's also quite dangerous because", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02727-00640823-00641135": "it allows only these predatory", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02728-00641136-00641383": "intentions to proliferate at a very high", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02729-00641384-00641662": "speed so i think this is a very it's a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02730-00641663-00641887": "big dilemma because yes you don't want", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02731-00641888-00642135": "to contribute to um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02732-00642136-00642414": "a process that then is destined to fail", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02733-00642415-00642695": "uh but also it's important to try and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02734-00642696-00642807": "find", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02735-00642808-00643095": "a way to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02736-00643096-00643327": "interject somehow or like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02737-00643328-00643479": "yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02738-00643480-00643766": "find a space in in the cracks to extract", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02739-00643767-00643862": "to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02740-00643863-00644303": "not to reproduce this extractive logic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02741-00644304-00644631": "yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02742-00644632-00644766": "just one thing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02743-00644767-00645070": "uh i think it's very useful for the kind", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02744-00645071-00645287": "of even for our laws and for our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02745-00645288-00645483": "epistemological model to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02746-00645484-00645918": "think of aliens as a role model not real", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02747-00645919-00646231": "interaction with animals but the animals", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02748-00646232-00646303": "the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02749-00646304-00646559": "aliens like for instance there was a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02750-00646560-00646647": "this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02751-00646648-00646814": "russian physicist kardashev who", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02752-00646815-00647110": "developed three uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02753-00647111-00647347": "type of civilization first type of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02754-00647348-00647591": "civilization who would be able", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02755-00647592-00647870": "to gather all the energy from the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02756-00647871-00648033": "their planet the second time", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02757-00648034-00648222": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02758-00648223-00648414": "of civilization who would be got their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02759-00648415-00648575": "energy from their", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02760-00648576-00648751": "solar system and that they would need to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02761-00648752-00648918": "build like a sphere around the sun and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02762-00648919-00649231": "the third who would be able to gather", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02763-00649232-00649431": "all the energy from the galaxy and he", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02764-00649432-00649679": "developed it to look for aliens but i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02765-00649680-00649910": "think this model is very useful for us", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02766-00649911-00650103": "to imagine how we would develop as a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02767-00650104-00650359": "planetary force right now because we are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02768-00650360-00650527": "a planetary force", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02769-00650528-00650831": "and so we kind of need to think", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02770-00650832-00651055": "like an annuls like how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02771-00651056-00651231": "how would civilization in the other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02772-00651232-00651439": "planet in the other solar system would", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02773-00651440-00651679": "develop because for instance", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02774-00651680-00651791": "we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02775-00651792-00651983": "kind of knew about climate change", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02776-00651984-00652239": "through the exploration of venus", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02777-00652240-00652422": "we knew about the green gas effect", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02778-00652423-00652614": "because first it happened on venus and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02779-00652615-00652879": "that's how like carl sagan develops this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02780-00652880-00653118": "framework", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02781-00653119-00653447": "so in this case the space is a role", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02782-00653448-00653751": "model for to understand ourselves better", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02783-00653752-00653910": "and they kind of think if there is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02784-00653911-00654151": "islands because they probably they are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02785-00654152-00654303": "there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02786-00654304-00654503": "we need to study more and we need to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02787-00654504-00654766": "kind of apply these models back to our", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02788-00654767-00655222": "our own home", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02789-00655223-00655343": "i", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02790-00655344-00655591": "just wanted to add about uh aliens in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02791-00655592-00655703": "the law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02792-00655704-00656014": "i think the main problems here", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02793-00656015-00656214": "i don't know if it's still actual but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02794-00656215-00656327": "anyway", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02795-00656328-00656470": "i got the mic", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02796-00656471-00656887": "uh so uh i think the main", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02797-00656888-00657183": "problem uh of how we can imagine this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02798-00657184-00657366": "kind of law is that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02799-00657367-00657647": "law usually is written and it's written", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02800-00657648-00657831": "in some kind of language and we don't", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02801-00657832-00658110": "know any alien language until we met", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02802-00658111-00658383": "them and i think this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02803-00658384-00658527": "case should be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02804-00658528-00658687": "like", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02805-00658688-00658783": "solved", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02806-00658784-00658903": "when we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02807-00658904-00659118": "met the situation", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02808-00659119-00659295": "yeah so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02809-00659296-00659622": "i think it's a simple answer yeah that's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02810-00659623-00659862": "good critique of current state of law", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02811-00659863-00660318": "the aliens wouldn't understand", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02812-00660319-00660935": "too much bureaucracy", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02813-00660936-00661207": "i was right thinking in the same terms", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02814-00661208-00661295": "as", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02815-00661296-00661495": "what you were saying before", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02816-00661496-00661705": "for his intervention that the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02817-00661706-00661822": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02818-00661823-00661975": "this is the way i was understanding the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02819-00661976-00662239": "project like the radical interest that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02820-00662240-00662566": "i find in cosmos law it's not about the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02821-00662567-00662831": "possibility of imagining how to deal", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02822-00662832-00663039": "with aliens but", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02823-00663040-00663151": "um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02824-00663152-00663543": "the useful tool it is to try to think in", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02825-00663544-00663751": "wider terms i mean yeah for other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02826-00663752-00663927": "planets or for other", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02827-00663928-00664103": "outer space", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02828-00664104-00664399": "to be able to to open the idea of how to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02829-00664400-00664599": "regulate our own house and also it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02830-00664600-00664799": "sometimes like looking to the neighbor", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02831-00664800-00664918": "to the neighbor", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02832-00664919-00665110": "enable you to see what is not working", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02833-00665111-00665366": "inside so maybe the speculation is there", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02834-00665367-00665631": "now and you see yeah you have this third", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02835-00665632-00665918": "chapter speculating i'm", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02836-00665919-00666231": "telling a wonderful story about how to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02837-00666232-00666414": "go to the planet that could also be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02838-00666415-00666703": "criticized as a way of why we are going", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02839-00666704-00666943": "to decide how these all the planets have", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02840-00666944-00667110": "you know whatever but i understand that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02841-00667111-00667287": "you this is not your purpose your", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02842-00667288-00667607": "purpose was to well", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02843-00667608-00667887": "but i like to understand it as a way to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02844-00667888-00668087": "yeah to look outside to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02845-00668088-00668447": "envision other ways of possibilities of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02846-00668448-00668695": "rethink or redesign what we have already", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02847-00668696-00668799": "here that", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02848-00668800-00668951": "it's", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02849-00668952-00669110": "we all see that it's not a well", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02850-00669111-00669510": "operating nor it's not working well so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02851-00669511-00669718": "yeah i think this is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02852-00669719-00669943": "something that is exploitable to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02853-00669944-00670214": "many other ideas or projects this is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02854-00670215-00670447": "speculation about what we don't know", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02855-00670448-00670703": "but like why you are not in the center", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02856-00670704-00670822": "or what you are not thinking about", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02857-00670823-00671047": "yourself you can kind of see with a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02858-00671048-00671247": "perspective that is then", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02859-00671248-00671399": "very useful and more great if you are", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02860-00671400-00671591": "able to go back and and apply to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02861-00671592-00671879": "yourself and well this is my last", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02862-00671880-00672007": "comment and i think we are going to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02863-00672008-00672310": "finish and just say super like big big", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02864-00672311-00672462": "big thanks for", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02865-00672463-00672775": "all what you have shared with us and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02866-00672776-00673022": "thank you to all that came and and be", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02867-00673023-00673535": "here and listen carefully and yeah", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02868-00673536-00673743": "now thank you for everything it was so", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02869-00673744-00673983": "interesting i think is", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02870-00673984-00674287": "is is is interesting to having more", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02871-00674288-00674518": "discussions and not just reading a book", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02872-00674519-00674751": "on oh no this thing what what is the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02873-00674752-00674991": "manifesto or the program what happened", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02874-00674992-00675070": "uh", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02875-00675071-00675366": "science this no or what is going to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02876-00675367-00675558": "what kind of discussion and perspective", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02877-00675559-00675791": "we can have in this kind of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02878-00675792-00675991": "scale sometimes you know and thank you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02879-00675992-00676222": "so much everything to come and to", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02880-00676223-00676470": "moderate to host and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02881-00676471-00676822": "co-create the event", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02882-00676823-00677014": "well thank you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02883-00677015-00677214": "well i think that's it and so i will do", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02884-00677215-00677422": "the institutional", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02885-00677423-00677607": "grouping up the boring institutional", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02886-00677608-00677743": "wrapping up", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02887-00677744-00677975": "so first of all thank you so much", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02888-00677976-00678151": "to three of you for coming here and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02889-00678152-00678303": "share with us", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02890-00678304-00678510": "those two amazing projects", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02891-00678511-00678735": "i think they i mean we since the", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02892-00678736-00678903": "beginning when we talked with with marta", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02893-00678904-00679062": "and kahanegra we thought it was super", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02894-00679063-00679239": "pertinent to bring those projects here", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02895-00679240-00679455": "because they are dealing with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02896-00679456-00679614": "topics that are super relevant with", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02897-00679615-00679831": "mediocentes the lab we are doing right", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02898-00679832-00679991": "now this idea of", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02899-00679992-00680175": "at the bottom of all the ecological", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02900-00680176-00680343": "issues we are going through there is not", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02901-00680344-00680518": "a problem of ecology there is not a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02902-00680519-00680670": "problem of technology there is a", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02903-00680671-00680839": "governance problem right", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02904-00680840-00681143": "which is what we are trying to address", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02905-00681144-00681358": "and that issue of the reclusivity right", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02906-00681359-00681591": "that we saw which is a key point and how", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02907-00681592-00681679": "we", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02908-00681680-00681943": "trigger it in the way we want", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02909-00681944-00682258": "i'm i like to think that some somehow um", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02910-00682259-00682383": "[Music]", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02911-00682384-00682695": "culture is is that trigger right it says", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02912-00682696-00682870": "it's the recursive process right right", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02913-00682871-00683079": "now here is that is that recursive", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02914-00683080-00683207": "process right we're thinking about these", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02915-00683208-00683447": "kind of things only that happens in time", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02916-00683448-00683607": "scale then maybe we can we don't feel it", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02917-00683608-00683839": "like a recursive process right", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02918-00683840-00684110": "so well thank you so much thank you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02919-00684111-00684207": "maria", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02920-00684208-00684358": "for the moderation and again thank you", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02921-00684359-00684607": "so much kahanegra for bringing this", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02922-00684608-00684935": "amazing idea to the table of media lab", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02923-00684936-00685007": "and", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02924-00685008-00685247": "co-curate the the process and finally", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02925-00685248-00685591": "thank you to all of you for sharing", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02926-00685592-00685935": "this space and this conversation with us", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02927-00685936-00686296": "thank you so much thank you so much", "OVPOZBJ_eiQ-02928-00686297-00686629": "[Applause]"}}]