[{"audio_id": "S1sJYjO1h3Y", "text": {"S1sJYjO1h3Y-00000-00000000-00000421": "foreign", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00001-00000422-00001238": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00002-00001239-00001985": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00003-00001986-00005335": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00004-00005336-00005493": "thank you", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00005-00005494-00006898": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00006-00006900-00007073": "foreign", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00007-00007073-00009871": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00008-00009872-00010155": "thank you", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00009-00010156-00013013": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00010-00013013-00013535": "foreign", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00011-00013536-00014566": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00012-00014568-00014750": "foreign", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00013-00014751-00018763": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00014-00018764-00019476": "thank you", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00015-00019477-00020779": "[Music]", "S1sJYjO1h3Y-00016-00020780-00022102": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "S1w8tlN7Ckg", "text": {"S1w8tlN7Ckg-00000-00000017-00000340": "the Florida Space Institute FSI is a", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00001-00000341-00000512": "Research Institute of the State", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00002-00000513-00000709": "University System of Florida and the", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00003-00000710-00000958": "University of Central Florida located in", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00004-00000959-00001270": "Orlando Florida United States the", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00005-00001271-00001499": "director of the Institute is Ramon Lugo", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00006-00001500-00001751": "3 who previously served as the director", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00007-00001752-00001955": "of NASA's Glenn Research Center the", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00008-00001955-00002143": "Institute provides a wide range of", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00009-00002144-00002359": "research information and education", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00010-00002360-00002551": "services for the space research and", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00011-00002552-00002752": "development defense and commercial", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00012-00002753-00003005": "community of Central Florida the", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00013-00003006-00003226": "Institute also provides education", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00014-00003227-00003410": "activities within the University of", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00015-00003411-00003518": "Central Florida", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00016-00003519-00003797": "UCF and other member institutions of the", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00017-00003797-00004574": "State University System of Florida topic", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00018-00004575-00005204": "history the Florida Space Institute was", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00019-00005205-00005477": "established in 1996 as a Research", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00020-00005478-00005635": "Institute within the State University", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00021-00005636-00006050": "System of Florida in 2012 the Institute", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00022-00006051-00006242": "moved from the Kennedy Space Center to", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00023-00006243-00006505": "the Central Florida research park at UCF", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00024-00006506-00006788": "the move coincided with the end of the", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00025-00006789-00007592": "Space Shuttle program in 2011 topic", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00026-00007593-00008237": "partner institutions the Florida Space", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00027-00008238-00008441": "Institute is part of a broad statewide", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00028-00008442-00008678": "partnership within the State University", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00029-00008679-00008906": "system to support and expand Florida's", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00030-00008907-00009071": "involvement in the field of space", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00031-00009072-00009371": "exploration since completing its move to", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00032-00009372-00009631": "Orlando the Institute now falls under", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00033-00009632-00009833": "the organizational and fiscal governance", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00034-00009834-00010070": "of UCF though it continues to support", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00035-00010071-00010264": "research and development projects and", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00036-00010265-00010499": "services at partner institutions in the", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00037-00010500-00010774": "State University System partner", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00038-00010775-00011139": "institutions Brevard Community College", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00039-00011140-00011456": "Broward College Embry Riddle", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00040-00011457-00011726": "Aeronautical University Florida", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00041-00011727-00012028": "Agricultural and Mechanical University", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00042-00012029-00012380": "Florida Atlantic University Florida", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00043-00012381-00012749": "Institute of Technology University of", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00044-00012750-00013197": "Florida University of Miami Yoona", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00045-00013197-00014272": "City of South Florida topic see also", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00046-00014272-00014528": "University of Central Florida research", "S1w8tlN7Ckg-00047-00014529-00014788": "centers"}}, {"audio_id": "S1z_pmBlqBo", "text": {"S1z_pmBlqBo-00000-00000064-00000359": "this is the day that the lord", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00001-00000360-00000831": "has made we shall rejoice and be glad in", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00002-00000832-00000923": "it", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00003-00000924-00001207": "hallelujah just", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00004-00001208-00001517": "god see the glory of all the blessings", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00005-00001518-00001747": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00006-00001748-00002295": "hallelujah praise the lord love you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00007-00002296-00002607": "amen and uh last few days the housing", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00008-00002608-00002734": "body cannot", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00009-00002735-00003047": "stand amen country as a nation", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00010-00003048-00003422": "cannot stand if we're going to have", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00011-00003423-00003751": "a political party to ideology", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00012-00003752-00004111": "our differences as as as a means to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00013-00004112-00005047": "divide the house", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00014-00005048-00005311": "we i think we need really pray for unity", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00015-00005312-00005470": "to buy that christ", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00016-00005471-00005679": "we gotta pray for unity by christ across", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00017-00005680-00005775": "the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00018-00005776-00005934": "if this nation is to be revived it's", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00019-00005935-00006086": "going to be revived", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00020-00006087-00006263": "in that manner there has to be a revival", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00021-00006264-00006446": "in the body yes sir", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00022-00006447-00006663": "so that's why i got those two those two", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00023-00006664-00006863": "things that's kind of brought two things", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00024-00006864-00007087": "like you said the mother of all problems", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00025-00007088-00007446": "tonight", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00026-00007447-00007878": "and then this one it really tells us", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00027-00007879-00008151": "look watch out for what you consider", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00028-00008152-00008278": "your neighbor", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00029-00008279-00008527": "your neighbor does not mean", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00030-00008528-00008663": "justification", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00031-00008664-00008959": "to hurt somebody that's not yours your", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00032-00008960-00009046": "neighbor", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00033-00009047-00009246": "is who you show mercy to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00034-00009247-00009391": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00035-00009392-00009567": "yeah and your neighbor doesn't need to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00036-00009568-00009855": "be no need to be justified", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00037-00009856-00010167": "no for for uh", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00038-00010168-00010487": "compassion no you don't have to justify", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00039-00010488-00010703": "the compassion that you've given", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00040-00010704-00010967": "to your neighbor you just give it come", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00041-00010968-00011071": "on", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00042-00011072-00011342": "that's the key in it your kids is who's", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00043-00011343-00011431": "my neighbor", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00044-00011432-00011710": "the one i show mercy to and if i if i", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00045-00011711-00011870": "don't show mercy", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00046-00011871-00012119": "it does not justify me doing bad", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00047-00012120-00012327": "behavior toward that person", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00048-00012328-00012591": "that's the key now elliot cause we wrap", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00049-00012592-00012631": "up what", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00050-00012632-00012879": "show yours if you could put it up there", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00051-00012880-00012966": "but as we go", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00052-00012967-00013151": "we're wrapping up with this one but see", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00053-00013152-00013286": "there's like", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00054-00013287-00013615": "can we approach this the way he", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00055-00013616-00013807": "descriptor do you need to bring you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00056-00013808-00013975": "don't have to script up with an elder or", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00057-00013976-00014083": "do you need it i do", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00058-00014084-00015388": "it", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00059-00015390-00015494": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00060-00015495-00015671": "went to uh luke on this but we went to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00061-00015672-00015815": "luke", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00062-00015816-00015991": "and i just i just pulled it up and i", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00063-00015991-00016207": "just i hit the hot points on it says", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00064-00016208-00016455": "discipleship as a central idea in the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00065-00016456-00016567": "parable of the sword", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00066-00016568-00016807": "that was that was a focus okay and", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00067-00016808-00016903": "initially i didn't", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00068-00016904-00017167": "it and and and i still i did put a", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00069-00017168-00017263": "little spin on", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00070-00017264-00017463": "what we talked about the other day jesus", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00071-00017464-00017591": "in his examination", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00072-00017592-00017855": "to his disciples did not specifically", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00073-00017856-00018111": "address the discipleship aspect", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00074-00018112-00018383": "they did but his proclamation but his", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00075-00018384-00018463": "proclamation", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00076-00018464-00018743": "he that has ears to his let them hear", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00077-00018744-00018967": "implies that the conditions of the soil", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00078-00018968-00019375": "and this is where the cicit comes in", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00079-00019376-00019543": "the condition of the soil the heart the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00080-00019544-00019863": "ear is immutable", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00081-00019864-00020047": "and these are changing conditions are", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00082-00020048-00020199": "essential to hopefulness", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00083-00020200-00020599": "or discipleship so basically", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00084-00020600-00020750": "it's addressing the person where they're", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00085-00020751-00021022": "at their heart", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00086-00021023-00021230": "that's to me you can't disciple a person", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00087-00021231-00021414": "who hasn't hurt you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00088-00021415-00021622": "you know if the carers are real", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00089-00021623-00021894": "overwhelmed if it's on stony ground", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00090-00021895-00021999": "that's not gonna be much of a", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00091-00022000-00022143": "discipleship they're just throwing seed", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00092-00022144-00022286": "out there somebody else that comes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00093-00022287-00022614": "with that so this discipleship", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00094-00022615-00022991": "this this cit is not on uh matthew 16", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00095-00022992-00023319": "24. well actually it was on matthew 16", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00096-00023320-00023358": "20.", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00097-00023359-00023703": "i used the new version okay because he", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00098-00023704-00023855": "gave me a little bit more explanation to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00099-00023856-00023991": "where i was at on that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00100-00023992-00024199": "yes i found it this is difficult to deal", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00101-00024200-00024335": "with initially because i thought", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00102-00024336-00024639": "jesus explained it out pretty good but", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00103-00024640-00024791": "then when bishop added the other", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00104-00024792-00025030": "element of discipleship then i had to go", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00105-00025031-00025158": "back and look at it again", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00106-00025159-00025375": "specifically because he said that it was", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00107-00025376-00025535": "pretty over it", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00108-00025536-00025711": "uh where he when he was talking about", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00109-00025712-00025894": "discipleship yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00110-00025895-00026174": "when i went to luke it looked more over", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00111-00026175-00026311": "when i looked at the word that he said", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00112-00026312-00026511": "but those who have years here", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00113-00026512-00026743": "yeah jesus dean didn't force people to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00114-00026744-00026902": "become a disciple", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00115-00026904-00027087": "he allowed him to become disciples he", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00116-00027088-00027223": "inspired him but he didn't just gotta", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00117-00027224-00027423": "say y'all need to follow me", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00118-00027424-00027711": "he let them know i mean he said if you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00119-00027712-00027855": "don't you can't hear what i'm saying", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00120-00027856-00028087": "hey maybe any time you live yet move", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00121-00028088-00028199": "just move", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00122-00028200-00028567": "you know i think for me for me it's a", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00123-00028568-00028799": "very useful uh tactic because", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00124-00028800-00029070": "uh we we we're just a thousand man so we", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00125-00029072-00029135": "can't really", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00126-00029136-00029343": "sit there and go like you know you you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00127-00029344-00029527": "let a lot you can find lord you know you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00128-00029527-00029711": "can't do that you throw it out there", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00129-00029712-00029870": "if they grab hold of it then they'll", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00130-00029872-00030046": "come back for the rest yeah the lord", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00131-00030047-00030174": "sends somebody else to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00132-00030175-00030439": "water it and what what we want to be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00133-00030439-00030502": "able to do is", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00134-00030503-00030823": "eventually really have those other units", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00135-00030824-00030918": "like this one", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00136-00030919-00031062": "uh-huh a lot of students like these that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00137-00031063-00031255": "you have access to yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00138-00031256-00031470": "uh churches that are teaching the word", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00139-00031472-00031623": "you have them come out and disciple the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00140-00031624-00031679": "people because", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00141-00031680-00031918": "for us discipline people out there in", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00142-00031919-00032118": "the field is very different", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00143-00032119-00032399": "i mean i guess we could do it but uh", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00144-00032400-00032662": "it's a lot easier if you've got a", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00145-00032663-00032943": "location where you got a teacher who's", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00146-00032944-00033055": "really teaching somebody", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00147-00033056-00033359": "who's full-time invested in that yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00148-00033360-00033567": "yeah and that's what their focus is", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00149-00033568-00033727": "we're gonna be outside in another few", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00150-00033728-00033918": "minutes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00151-00033919-00034159": "so uh we're gonna go back to work yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00152-00034160-00034255": "but we", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00153-00034256-00034390": "we're looking for you that are willing", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00154-00034391-00034607": "to hear amen", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00155-00034608-00034815": "and anything change people's lives", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00156-00034816-00035023": "change isn't in circumstances changing", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00157-00035024-00035102": "their life", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00158-00035103-00035279": "softens them up a bit that's basically", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00159-00035280-00035423": "what it comes down to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00160-00035424-00035639": "yeah you got to wait for people to get a", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00161-00035640-00035815": "physician receiving thing at night", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00162-00035816-00036071": "and you can convince them everybody you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00163-00036072-00036159": "sign", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00164-00036160-00036407": "for street ministry everybody approaches", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00165-00036408-00036631": "who you're showing compassion", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00166-00036632-00037495": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00167-00037496-00037607": "you're gonna preach the gospel what's", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00168-00037608-00037759": "the gospel to me the gospel is", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00169-00037760-00038535": "reconciliation to mankind", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00170-00038536-00038718": "we on the other side of the garden right", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00171-00038719-00038967": "with god you know what i'm saying", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00172-00038968-00039167": "come on take advantage of this when you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00173-00039168-00039311": "get in this class and then they'll teach", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00174-00039312-00039487": "you a little a lot more about what that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00175-00039488-00039646": "looks like", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00176-00039647-00039823": "but first thing you need to know is that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00177-00039824-00040055": "it doesn't happen yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00178-00040056-00040230": "you can receive it that's a done deal", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00179-00040231-00040399": "when you said that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00180-00040400-00040623": "uh elder something just i mean it just", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00181-00040624-00040735": "popped in my script", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00182-00040736-00041039": "by my spirit we've been brought back to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00183-00041040-00041127": "the garden", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00184-00041128-00041518": "yes but this garden this garden has been", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00185-00041519-00041583": "changed", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00186-00041584-00041895": "it has thorns and thistles in it", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00187-00041896-00042223": "it does you know it it it because", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00188-00042224-00042607": "what god said it has to be yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00189-00042608-00042927": "so now now now this garden of eden", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00190-00042928-00043246": "it is what it is but", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00191-00043247-00044583": "we brought thorns and thistles in yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00192-00044584-00044758": "that's the thing that i had to grasp is", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00193-00044759-00044943": "that once you were born again", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00194-00044944-00045158": "all that reversed back to where it was a", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00195-00045159-00045302": "matter of fact it goes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00196-00045303-00045543": "i think for my system to go beyond where", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00197-00045544-00045623": "it was because", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00198-00045624-00045783": "prior you didn't have a knowledge of", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00199-00045784-00045983": "good in you but now we have a knowledge", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00200-00045984-00046095": "of good you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00201-00046096-00046399": "but now we chosen good and we were being", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00202-00046400-00046518": "raised in righteousness we would be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00203-00046519-00046679": "excluding righteousness disciples and", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00204-00046680-00046774": "righteousness", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00205-00046775-00046951": "so we've been reunited with the father", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00206-00046952-00047143": "with everything that those guys had", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00207-00047144-00047446": "plus some more yeah in addition to the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00208-00047447-00047574": "thrones of christmas they're not in the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00209-00047575-00047686": "garden anyway", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00210-00047687-00047958": "but yeah but now you know we said you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00211-00047959-00048207": "just can't undo the work for the bill", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00212-00048208-00048390": "yeah yeah so because you're involved in", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00213-00048391-00048543": "the system because that's an inviting", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00214-00048544-00048679": "decision though i'm involved in this", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00215-00048680-00048767": "system", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00216-00048768-00048911": "some of the things this has been done", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00217-00048912-00049329": "with yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00218-00049330-00050502": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00219-00050503-00050958": "uh city for discipleship yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00220-00050959-00051183": "yeah we gotta back off yeah back it up", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00221-00051184-00051607": "okay", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00222-00051608-00052007": "did i get it you still up there we're", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00223-00052008-00052166": "not just the size out there", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00224-00052167-00053791": "okay there you go there you go", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00225-00053791-00054047": "jesus christ being living sacrifice of", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00226-00054048-00054126": "god", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00227-00054127-00054311": "hoping for this world would be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00228-00054312-00054575": "transformed by you in your mind", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00229-00054576-00054954": "and that's a scripture", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00230-00054954-00055079": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00231-00055079-00055423": "and believe in jesus christ professor", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00232-00055424-00055471": "said", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00233-00055472-00055791": "live faith from faith to faith and put", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00234-00055791-00056038": "on the whole life of god", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00235-00056039-00056350": "to me that's discipleship uh-huh follow", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00236-00056351-00056511": "people", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00237-00056512-00057030": "right if you're gonna follow him come on", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00238-00057032-00057335": "if he's going to disciple you yeah then", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00239-00057336-00057391": "this is", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00240-00057391-00057759": "this is the process yep", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00241-00057760-00058063": "i agree with that 100 that we do", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00242-00058064-00058415": "i mean if if if if if you're going to be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00243-00058416-00058679": "a disciple of a carpenter", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00244-00058679-00059071": "yes you'd have to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00245-00059072-00059391": "give up what you desire to learn", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00246-00059391-00059703": "something from that master carpet", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00247-00059704-00060023": "exactly exactly you can't be conformed", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00248-00060024-00060350": "to how everybody else is living", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00249-00060351-00060599": "you have to conform to how that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00250-00060600-00060742": "carpenter is living", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00251-00060744-00060942": "right and then you have to renew your", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00252-00060944-00061087": "mind from what", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00253-00061088-00061471": "you think is being a carpenter is", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00254-00061472-00061791": "to the mind of that carpenter well", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00255-00061791-00062230": "so likewise being a disciple of christ", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00256-00062232-00062471": "it's the same thing and the scripture to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00257-00062472-00062599": "me the scriptures just", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00258-00062600-00062919": "just bear it out you know", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00259-00062920-00063199": "and so that's why i just use pretty much", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00260-00063200-00063382": "just the scriptures to the same because", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00261-00063383-00063433": "i mean", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00262-00063434-00063615": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00263-00063616-00063950": "these to me explain discipleship", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00264-00063951-00064254": "each one yeah you know that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00265-00064255-00064575": "that's very good interesting", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00266-00064576-00064750": "of jesus christ the following jesus", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00267-00064751-00064926": "christ that's the one thing the church", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00268-00064927-00065038": "hasn't taught", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00269-00065039-00065438": "yeah that that has nothing", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00270-00065439-00065638": "we have been so distracted from jesus", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00271-00065639-00065815": "that he's barely a part of the scenario", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00272-00065816-00065845": "you know", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00273-00065846-00066995": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00274-00066996-00067303": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00275-00067304-00067438": "from that grave everything that we", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00276-00067439-00067647": "believe is the crocker species", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00277-00067648-00068047": "and without him we'd all be investing", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00278-00068048-00068367": "in a farm we", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00279-00068368-00068671": "we're gonna need some some some sheep", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00280-00068672-00068949": "some some turtle doves", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00281-00068950-00069135": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00282-00069136-00069353": "we don't need a we gonna need a priest", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00283-00069354-00069791": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00284-00069792-00070082": "and this yeah no hope without god in the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00285-00070083-00070229": "world", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00286-00070230-00071047": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00287-00071048-00071511": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00288-00071512-00071735": "for you but you just struggling or", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00289-00071736-00071926": "whatever", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00290-00071927-00072294": "this walk is uh the moral", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00291-00072295-00072415": "i understand what i'm supposed to be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00292-00072416-00072655": "doing there's a lot more spending than i", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00293-00072656-00072750": "wanted to be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00294-00072751-00072894": "okay i'm not accustomed to the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00295-00072895-00073238": "discipline right", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00296-00073239-00073550": "hey hey i think i think if you keep this", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00297-00073551-00073743": "i think if you recognize you got some", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00298-00073744-00073950": "ground you need to be cultivated", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00299-00073951-00074287": "right and i'm mine and then knowing who", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00300-00074288-00074559": "your neighbor is", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00301-00074560-00074743": "i think it helped i think i think too", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00302-00074744-00074862": "there are others that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00303-00074863-00075191": "is when you say we", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00304-00075192-00075406": "when we deal with the uh the gangsters", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00305-00075407-00075503": "and the bugs", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00306-00075504-00076738": "i think that we're taking we out", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00307-00076739-00077082": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00308-00077083-00077303": "hey all i know is you're not out there", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00309-00077304-00077375": "doing the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00310-00077376-00077519": "shooting up shooting people in", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00311-00077520-00077719": "neighborhood or making you're not the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00312-00077720-00077847": "one falling", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00313-00077848-00078094": "uh great writing songs your songs don't", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00314-00078095-00078182": "say", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00315-00078183-00078494": "pose it", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00316-00078495-00078815": "not your song you don't sing no song", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00317-00078816-00079031": "i know that they didn't make it to the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00318-00079032-00079167": "paper yet and it definitely made the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00319-00079168-00079494": "print though", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00320-00079495-00079662": "if you do do that that's a different", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00321-00079663-00080055": "story didn't you become the weak", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00322-00080056-00080367": "but the body of christ we are in this", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00323-00080368-00080447": "world", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00324-00080448-00080719": "but we're not ever of this world i don't", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00325-00080720-00080871": "know yet", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00326-00080872-00081111": "the level of discipline and thought life", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00327-00081112-00081238": "is a thing that really", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00328-00081239-00081535": "it man it's 24 7. and i'm beginning to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00329-00081536-00081638": "really", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00330-00081639-00081806": "embrace that because you don't have to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00331-00081807-00081943": "sleep for the moment", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00332-00081944-00082175": "you know mentally go to the wrong place", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00333-00082176-00082367": "in the moment you can lose a lot", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00334-00082368-00082638": "amen and i have done that you know god", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00335-00082639-00082799": "has been gracious enough to allow", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00336-00082800-00083038": "me to experience it in my flesh whenever", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00337-00083039-00083262": "i go partner i experience it almost", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00338-00083263-00083375": "immediately", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00339-00083376-00083638": "i will get sick and be physically ill", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00340-00083639-00083815": "and i have to make the correction", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00341-00083816-00084038": "so but what i'm finding out is oh i", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00342-00084039-00084188": "didn't need to share this phrase report", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00343-00084189-00084311": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00344-00084312-00084438": "by the top number when the blood", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00345-00084439-00084631": "pressure was up around 180", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00346-00084632-00084975": "180 is 200 right he's now down", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00347-00084976-00085287": "to the 150s all right", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00348-00085288-00085655": "progress weight lost about 30 pounds", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00349-00085656-00086015": "30 pounds yeah zero", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00350-00086016-00086318": "medication at this point oh wow for the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00351-00086319-00086382": "last two", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00352-00086383-00086679": "two months the last two months i've", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00353-00086680-00086831": "gotten off all the medication the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00354-00086832-00086999": "swelling has gone down about", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00355-00087000-00087343": "60 percent so it's been a chance it's", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00356-00087344-00087479": "been a turnaround but", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00357-00087480-00087662": "you know i'm still having to keep my", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00358-00087663-00087871": "mind in the right place and all that too", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00359-00087872-00088087": "exactly we're experiencing some", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00360-00088088-00088294": "tremendous changes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00361-00088295-00088462": "and some tremendous stresses that go", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00362-00088463-00088711": "along with", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00363-00088712-00088918": "well yeah keep on the power for losing", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00364-00088919-00089023": "the weight", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00365-00089024-00089262": "i think that's the key to it yeah", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00366-00089263-00089415": "brothers are gonna give us a crap for", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00367-00089416-00089543": "that after we do the community real", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00368-00089544-00089591": "quick", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00369-00089592-00089782": "so he's gonna do the communion brother", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00370-00089783-00089975": "addison and then you close out with", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00371-00089976-00090055": "prayer", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00372-00090056-00090255": "give him a prayer special prayer for", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00373-00090256-00090391": "elvis johnson", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00374-00090392-00090655": "oh well you can definitely do that amen", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00375-00090656-00090735": "so let", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00376-00090736-00091006": "the brothers go to the chameleon elder", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00377-00091007-00091094": "all right", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00378-00091095-00091238": "on the night that he was betrayed he", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00379-00091239-00091424": "took bread", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00380-00091425-00091559": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00381-00091560-00091775": "he blessed it break it and he gave it to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00382-00091776-00092038": "the disciples that take eat all of you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00383-00092039-00092215": "but this is my body which shall be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00384-00092216-00092438": "broken for you whenever you do it", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00385-00092439-00092671": "you're gonna remember to me so they took", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00386-00092672-00093543": "the bread and break it", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00387-00093544-00093882": "when the supper was ended he took the", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00388-00093883-00094015": "cup", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00389-00094016-00094359": "again he gave thanks and praise", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00390-00094360-00094567": "he blessed it he gave it to his", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00391-00094568-00094759": "disciples and said", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00392-00094760-00095182": "take frank all of you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00393-00095183-00095431": "this is a cup of my blood the blood of", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00394-00095432-00095647": "the new and everlasting covenant", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00395-00095648-00095815": "it shall be shared for you and for all", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00396-00095816-00096103": "men so that sins may be forgiven", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00397-00096104-00096303": "whenever you do this do it in", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00398-00096304-00096455": "remembrance of me", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00399-00096456-00096845": "and so they took the cup in the drinking", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00400-00096846-00097143": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00401-00097144-00097326": "and so on accords with my brothers and", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00402-00097327-00097487": "catholicism", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00403-00097488-00097718": "and so we proclaim the mystery of faith", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00404-00097719-00097887": "christ has died", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00405-00097888-00098367": "christ is risen christ will come again", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00406-00098368-00098655": "amen brother absent give us that prayer", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00407-00098656-00098703": "sir", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00408-00098704-00099031": "close it up", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00409-00099032-00099223": "we truly thank you for this day we thank", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00410-00099224-00099399": "you for your", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00411-00099400-00099671": "fellowship with us lord god we thank you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00412-00099672-00099711": "that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00413-00099712-00100047": "your spirit has been here uh opening our", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00414-00100048-00100191": "minds to your truth", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00415-00100192-00100503": "not ours but your truth amen amen", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00416-00100504-00100679": "we thank you for the revelations that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00417-00100680-00101055": "have been has been revealed we we pray", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00418-00101056-00101255": "that these things", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00419-00101256-00101582": "fall on good ground that they grow", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00420-00101583-00101918": "and produce fruit yes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00421-00101919-00102223": "that they produce fruit father", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00422-00102224-00102471": "we we truly thank you for that we thank", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00423-00102472-00102599": "you that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00424-00102600-00102942": "that uh your word is life life to us", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00425-00102943-00103342": "to to our our our souls to our", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00426-00103343-00103647": "our our our our well-being lord god", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00427-00103648-00103975": "we uh ask that you continue to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00428-00103976-00104286": "to to open our minds to", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00429-00104288-00104663": "your vision not ours but yours that we", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00430-00104664-00104983": "are disciples after you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00431-00104983-00105239": "yes and your son jesus christ that your", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00432-00105240-00105351": "love", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00433-00105352-00105583": "is the principal thing in our life", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00434-00105583-00105727": "father god that we", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00435-00105728-00106054": "we always subject ourselves to that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00436-00106055-00106483": "that we are the samaritan that you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00437-00106483-00106799": "desire amen", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00438-00106800-00107095": "so that the hope of this world is not", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00439-00107096-00107215": "lost", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00440-00107216-00107615": "that the harvest shall be reap yes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00441-00107616-00107895": "that we do our part father and we truly", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00442-00107896-00107966": "thank you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00443-00107967-00108143": "we we pray for all those who could not", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00444-00108144-00108390": "attend this particular", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00445-00108391-00108695": "gathering we pray for those uh", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00446-00108696-00109039": "who who have their mind to to fellowship", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00447-00109040-00109239": "with you on this day the day that set", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00448-00109240-00109399": "aside so that many", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00449-00109400-00109590": "will go in to learn of you and be", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00450-00109591-00109815": "perfected and we thank you for", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00451-00109816-00110047": "in advance for those who are being", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00452-00110048-00110239": "perfected on this day", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00453-00110240-00110502": "uh lord god i i look at my", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00454-00110503-00110683": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00455-00110683-00110999": "uh my brother here", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00456-00111000-00111431": "yes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00457-00111432-00111790": "and i pray father god that you continue", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00458-00111791-00112334": "to lift him up in spirit lord god", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00459-00112335-00112695": "to to give him a joy that surpasses", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00460-00112696-00112927": "all understanding father god that you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00461-00112928-00113239": "that you open his mind to know the depth", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00462-00113240-00113543": "and the width and the height of all that", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00463-00113544-00113599": "you have", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00464-00113600-00113910": "for him through his son", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00465-00113911-00114286": "that that though", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00466-00114288-00114566": "physical exercises may profit a little", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00467-00114567-00114686": "lord god but your", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00468-00114688-00114975": "word is the key to life and life", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00469-00114976-00115158": "everlasting father god", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00470-00115159-00115495": "that our faith in you shall surpass", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00471-00115496-00115831": "any and every attack against", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00472-00115832-00116134": "our physical body father but your", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00473-00116135-00116247": "healing", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00474-00116248-00116575": "will follow your word father god", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00475-00116576-00116983": "yes that by your son stripes", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00476-00116983-00117140": "that we are here", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00477-00117141-00117383": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00478-00117383-00117583": "and we truly thank you for that thank", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00479-00117583-00117751": "you for your word we thank you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00480-00117752-00118031": "for the manifestation of of healing and", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00481-00118032-00118215": "well-being in our brothers", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00482-00118216-00118678": "yes and we will be always careful", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00483-00118679-00118863": "hallelujah thank you all the honor and", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00484-00118864-00119086": "all the praise thank you jesus thank you", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00485-00119088-00121008": "in jesus name amen amen", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00486-00121009-00123078": "[Music]", "S1z_pmBlqBo-00487-00123079-00123288": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S1-8wA0jhpU", "text": {"S1-8wA0jhpU-00000-00000025-00003800": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00001-00003801-00003900": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00002-00003901-00005857": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00003-00005858-00006618": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00004-00006619-00010405": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00005-00010406-00010483": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00006-00010484-00011634": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00007-00011635-00012391": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00008-00012392-00017097": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00009-00017098-00017212": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00010-00017213-00019393": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00011-00019394-00020421": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00012-00020422-00022030": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00013-00022031-00025003": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00014-00025004-00025103": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00015-00025104-00027822": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00016-00027823-00030906": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00017-00030907-00030986": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00018-00030987-00032367": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00019-00032368-00032960": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00020-00032961-00037600": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00021-00037601-00037716": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00022-00037717-00039896": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00023-00039897-00042537": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00024-00042538-00045510": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00025-00045511-00045610": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00026-00045611-00048328": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00027-00048329-00052114": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00028-00052115-00053052": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00029-00053053-00053574": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00030-00053575-00054165": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00031-00054166-00057129": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00032-00057129-00057930": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00033-00057932-00058807": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00034-00058808-00058922": "[Applause]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00035-00058923-00062923": "[Music]", "S1-8wA0jhpU-00036-00062924-00064339": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "S1_1F1hDbzI", "text": {"S1_1F1hDbzI-00000-00000101-00000416": "my dumbass brain just realized that my", "S1_1F1hDbzI-00001-00000417-00000947": "country is not part of the EU so this", "S1_1F1hDbzI-00002-00000948-00001385": "channel survives another day but I feel", "S1_1F1hDbzI-00003-00001386-00001829": "bad for everyone else which article 13 I", "S1_1F1hDbzI-00004-00001830-00002626": "was mostly 15 article 13 hits and yeah"}}, {"audio_id": "S2-DS4-c-OE", "text": {"S2-DS4-c-OE-00000-00000003-00000233": "alright guys this is the full-body multi", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00001-00000234-00000350": "limb warmup", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00002-00000351-00000484": "we're we're gonna work our way from head", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00003-00000485-00000659": "to toes just warming up and loosening up", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00004-00000660-00000821": "all the major muscles and joints at the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00005-00000822-00000989": "body this is something that you should", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00006-00000990-00001332": "be memorizing and not having users", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00007-00001333-00001641": "so unless you want to look", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00008-00001642-00001814": "we're just our body synchronized", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00009-00001816-00002004": "breathing that's with a squat and an arm", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00010-00002005-00002214": "raise and basically we're gonna do eight", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00011-00002215-00002394": "of all of these movements or four and", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00012-00002395-00002583": "then reverse therefore so you're gonna", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00013-00002584-00002661": "squat down", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00014-00002662-00002901": "big inhale and then exhale arms raise up", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00015-00002902-00003108": "eight times here we go", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00016-00003109-00003425": "Biggin Hill and one", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00017-00003426-00003763": "inhale and to", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00018-00003764-00004172": "and three inhale and four", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00019-00004173-00004572": "inhale", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00020-00004573-00004740": "and since", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00021-00004741-00004974": "inhale", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00022-00004975-00005163": "in hell", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00023-00005164-00005409": "eight all right hands come down to your", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00024-00005410-00005529": "sides we're going to stretch out the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00025-00005530-00005778": "neck with neck pains so we're gonna hang", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00026-00005779-00005883": "your head into your chest", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00027-00005884-00006326": "ready and go", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00028-00006327-00006547": "come up to neutral hanging over to your", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00029-00006548-00006740": "right side I like to do four counts for", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00030-00006741-00006944": "three two one", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00031-00006945-00007377": "back to Center other side", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00032-00007378-00007575": "one back to Center we're gonna do", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00033-00007576-00007745": "shoulder foods to stretch out the chest", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00034-00007747-00007959": "and upper back and a little movement in", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00035-00007959-00008180": "the traps so we're going to go", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00036-00008181-00008551": "if you go forward", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00037-00008552-00009046": "and down again forward back", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00038-00009047-00009327": "again forward", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00039-00009328-00010133": "back and down one more time forward back", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00040-00010134-00010803": "forward down up forward", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00041-00010804-00011278": "and back up forward down and back one", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00042-00011279-00011402": "more time", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00043-00011403-00011696": "forward down", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00044-00011697-00011888": "we're in a new shoulder bolt this gets", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00045-00011889-00012084": "more into the clavicle and trapezius", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00046-00012085-00012270": "muscle so basically we're in a world of", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00047-00012271-00012620": "shoulders that same movement", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00048-00012621-00012844": "three", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00049-00012845-00013197": "one we're gonna reverse here we go", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00050-00013197-00013418": "three two", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00051-00013419-00013601": "one perfect we're going to open up with", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00052-00013602-00013772": "larger circles getting more into the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00053-00013772-00014000": "actual rotator cuff agility point ready", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00054-00014001-00014351": "here we go back home record breathe nice", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00055-00014352-00014664": "and high in straight arms", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00056-00014665-00015091": "first perform", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00057-00015093-00015375": "one full of arms are gonna come straight", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00058-00015376-00015669": "out in front we do chest openers", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00059-00015671-00015925": "the chest stretch down exhale one arm", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00060-00015926-00016090": "back fall it with your head and", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00061-00016091-00016219": "alternate here we go", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00062-00016219-00016449": "great", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00063-00016450-00017378": "seven", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00064-00017379-00018055": "three", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00065-00018056-00018178": "we're going to interlace our fingers", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00066-00018179-00018410": "better Ella slightly twist left and", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00067-00018411-00018614": "right this is probably lower diamond", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00068-00018615-00018913": "hips", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00069-00018914-00019974": "eight", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00070-00019975-00020142": "at the center we were to do read routes", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00071-00020143-00020295": "that I loosen up the glutes and get", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00072-00020296-00021444": "movin", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00073-00021445-00021635": "for", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00074-00021636-00021823": "three", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00075-00021824-00022153": "to", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00076-00022154-00022314": "right we're gonna do these circles", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00077-00022315-00022541": "getting into the acetabular the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00078-00022542-00022766": "English we're getting into the ball and", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00079-00022767-00022955": "socket joint in defense basically gonna", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00080-00022956-00023069": "take your knee bring it in towards the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00081-00023070-00023225": "midline your body Circle it out to the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00082-00023226-00023683": "side alternating sides ready here we go", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00083-00023684-00023995": "seven", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00084-00023996-00024320": "five nice and wide", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00085-00024321-00024863": "three two", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00086-00024864-00025046": "next one we're going to do straight leg", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00087-00025047-00025232": "swings forward this is solution of the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00088-00025233-00025421": "hamstrings basically you're gonna flex", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00089-00025422-00025535": "the foot and bring it up nice and", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00090-00025536-00025672": "straight as high as you can without", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00091-00025673-00026017": "bending the knee reading and vegan eight", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00092-00026018-00026851": "seven", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00093-00026852-00027080": "to", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00094-00027081-00027311": "backwards knees here going to drive the", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00095-00027312-00027527": "heel above the hip keeping the knee bent", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00096-00027527-00027692": "to stretch out the hip flexors and", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00097-00027693-00028395": "quadriceps ready and begin", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00098-00028395-00028748": "six-five", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00099-00028749-00028906": "three", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00100-00028907-00029246": "to", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00101-00029247-00029480": "last part full-body marching and", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00102-00029481-00030082": "breathing opposite on lake 30 seconds", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00103-00030083-00030320": "Reeth", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00104-00030320-00030567": "my big round six", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00105-00030568-00030818": "so", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00106-00030819-00031295": "9", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00107-00031295-00031773": "12:13", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00108-00031774-00032045": "16:17", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00109-00032045-00032293": "nineteen", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00110-00032294-00033070": "one two three knees high Oh", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00111-00033071-00033754": "seven eight nine you're done have a", "S2-DS4-c-OE-00112-00033755-00034078": "great workout see ya"}}, {"audio_id": "S2B_RdnpGAE", "text": {"S2B_RdnpGAE-00000-00000012-00000348": "the Office of Strategic Services Oz was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00001-00000349-00000555": "a wartime intelligence agency of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00002-00000556-00000795": "United States during World War two and a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00003-00000796-00000969": "predecessor of the modern Central", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00004-00000969-00001311": "Intelligence Agency CIA the Oz was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00005-00001312-00001482": "formed as an agency of the Joint Chiefs", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00006-00001483-00001776": "of Staff JCS to coordinate espionage", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00007-00001777-00001992": "activities behind enemy lines for all", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00008-00001993-00002160": "branches of the United States Armed", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00009-00002161-00002454": "Forces other ausf unction z' included", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00010-00002455-00002667": "the use of propaganda subversion and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00011-00002668-00003054": "post-war planning on December 14th 2016", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00012-00003055-00003230": "the organization was collectively", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00013-00003231-00003920": "honored with a Congressional Gold Medal", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00014-00003921-00004418": "topic origin", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00015-00004419-00004658": "prior to the formation of the Osthe the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00016-00004659-00004847": "various departments of the executive", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00017-00004848-00005090": "branch including the State Treasury Navy", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00018-00005091-00005324": "and war departments conducted American", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00019-00005325-00005504": "intelligence activities on an ad-hoc", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00020-00005505-00005722": "basis with no overall Direction", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00021-00005723-00006068": "coordination or control the US Army and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00022-00006069-00006266": "US Navy had separate code-breaking", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00023-00006267-00006515": "departments signal intelligence service", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00024-00006516-00006788": "and op2 OG a previous code-breaking", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00025-00006789-00007006": "operation of the State Department the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00026-00007008-00007256": "me8 run by Herbert Yardley had been shut", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00027-00007256-00007556": "down in 1929 by Secretary of State Henry", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00028-00007556-00007706": "Stimson deeming at an inappropriate", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00029-00007706-00007948": "function for the diplomatic arm because", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00030-00007950-00008180": "gentlemen don't read each other's mail", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00031-00008181-00008501": "the FBI was responsible for domestic", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00032-00008502-00008802": "security and anti espionage operations", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00033-00008803-00009052": "President Franklin D Roosevelt was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00034-00009053-00009210": "concerned about American intelligence", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00035-00009211-00009463": "deficiencies on the suggestion of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00036-00009464-00009656": "William Stephenson the senior British", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00037-00009657-00009857": "intelligence officer in the Western", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00038-00009858-00009929": "Hemisphere", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00039-00009930-00010121": "Roosevelt requested that William J", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00040-00010122-00010340": "Donovan draft a plan for an intelligence", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00041-00010341-00010517": "service based on the British Secret", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00042-00010518-00010781": "Intelligence Service mi6 and Special", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00043-00010782-00011099": "Operations Executive SOE after", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00044-00011100-00011318": "submitting his work memorandum of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00045-00011319-00011549": "establishment of service of strategic", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00046-00011550-00011785": "information Colonel Donovan was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00047-00011786-00012049": "appointed coordinator of information on", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00048-00012050-00012362": "July 11 1941 heading the new", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00049-00012363-00012560": "organization known as the office of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00050-00012561-00012832": "coordinator of information COI", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00051-00012833-00013058": "thereafter the organization was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00052-00013059-00013216": "developed with British assistance", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00053-00013218-00013463": "Donovan had responsibilities but no", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00054-00013463-00013666": "actual powers in the existing US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00055-00013668-00013894": "agencies were skeptical if not hostile", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00056-00013894-00014171": "until some months after Pearl Harbor the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00057-00014172-00014410": "bulk of US intelligence came from the UK", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00058-00014411-00014716": "British security coordination BSC", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00059-00014718-00014936": "trained the first US agents in Canada", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00060-00014937-00015140": "until training stations were set up in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00061-00015141-00015322": "the US with guidance from BSC", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00062-00015323-00015491": "instructors who also provided", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00063-00015491-00015719": "information on how the SOE was arranged", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00064-00015719-00015983": "and managed the British immediately made", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00065-00015984-00016183": "available their shortwave broadcasting", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00066-00016184-00016405": "capabilities to Europe Africa and the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00067-00016406-00016601": "Far East and provided equipment for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00068-00016602-00016796": "agents until American production was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00069-00016797-00016958": "established the Office of Strategic", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00070-00016959-00017158": "Services was established by a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00071-00017159-00017372": "presidential military order issued by", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00072-00017373-00017768": "President Roosevelt on June 13th 1942", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00073-00017769-00017969": "and analyze strategic information", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00074-00017970-00018125": "required by the Joint Chiefs of Staff", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00075-00018126-00018356": "and to conduct special operations not", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00076-00018357-00018614": "assigned to other agencies during the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00077-00018615-00018842": "war the AH supplied policymakers with", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00078-00018843-00019037": "facts and estimates but the AHS never", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00079-00019038-00019217": "had jurisdiction over all foreign", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00080-00019218-00019538": "intelligence activities the FBI was left", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00081-00019539-00019742": "responsible for intelligence work in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00082-00019743-00019913": "Latin America and the Army and Navy", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00083-00019914-00020126": "continued to develop and rely on their", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00084-00020127-00020778": "own sources of intelligence", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00085-00020779-00021303": "topic activities", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00086-00021304-00021533": "ah sprue de specially useful in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00087-00021534-00021722": "providing a worldwide overview of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00088-00021723-00021908": "German war effort its strengths and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00089-00021909-00022208": "weaknesses in direct operations it was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00090-00022209-00022425": "successful in supporting Operation Torch", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00091-00022426-00022742": "in French North Africa in 1942 where it", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00092-00022743-00022934": "identified pro allied potential", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00093-00022935-00023219": "supporters and located landing sites US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00094-00023220-00023414": "operations in neutral countries", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00095-00023415-00023669": "especially Stockholm Sweden provided", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00096-00023670-00023883": "in-depth information on German advanced", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00097-00023884-00024167": "technology the Madrid station set up", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00098-00024168-00024380": "agent networks in France that supported", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00099-00024381-00024528": "the Allied invasion of southern France", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00100-00024529-00024936": "in 1944 most famous were the operations", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00101-00024937-00025152": "in Switzerland run by Allen Dulles that", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00102-00025153-00025380": "provided extensive information on German", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00103-00025381-00025575": "strength air defenses submarine", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00104-00025576-00025908": "production and the v1 and v2 weapons it", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00105-00025908-00026072": "revealed some of the secret German", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00106-00026073-00026268": "efforts in chemical and biological", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00107-00026269-00026345": "warfare", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00108-00026345-00026604": "Switzerland's station also supported", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00109-00026605-00026805": "resistance fighters in France and Italy", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00110-00026806-00027002": "and helped with the surrender of German", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00111-00027003-00027312": "forces in Italy in 1945 for the duration", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00112-00027313-00027510": "of world war ii the Office of Strategic", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00113-00027511-00027693": "Services was conducting multiple", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00114-00027694-00027906": "activities and missions including", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00115-00027907-00028068": "collecting intelligence by spying", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00116-00028069-00028305": "performing acts of sabotage waging", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00117-00028306-00028502": "propaganda war organizing and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00118-00028503-00028731": "coordinating anti-nazi resistance groups", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00119-00028732-00028877": "in Europe and providing military", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00120-00028878-00029082": "training for anti-japanese guerrilla", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00121-00029083-00029376": "movements in Asia among other things at", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00122-00029377-00029550": "the height of its influence during world", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00123-00029551-00029870": "war ii the us employed almost 24,000", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00124-00029872-00030245": "people from 1943 to 1945 the US played a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00125-00030247-00030464": "major role in training Kuomintang troops", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00126-00030465-00030699": "in China and Burma and recruited Kachin", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00127-00030700-00030887": "and other indigenous irregular forces", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00128-00030888-00031080": "for sabotage as well as guides for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00129-00031081-00031265": "Allied forces in Burma fighting the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00130-00031266-00031577": "Japanese army among other activities the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00131-00031578-00031773": "AHS helped armed train and supply", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00132-00031774-00031974": "resistance movements in areas occupied", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00133-00031975-00032220": "by the Axis powers during World War two", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00134-00032220-00032483": "including Mao Zedong's Red Army in China", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00135-00032484-00032679": "known as the Dixie mission and the Viet", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00136-00032680-00032964": "Minh in French Indochina US officer", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00137-00032965-00033149": "Archimedes Patty played a central role", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00138-00033150-00033411": "in US operations in French Indochina and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00139-00033412-00033705": "met frequently with Ho Chi Minh in 1945", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00140-00033706-00033896": "one of the greatest accomplishments of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00141-00033897-00034086": "the AA stirring world war 2 was its", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00142-00034087-00034289": "penetration of Nazi Germany by US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00143-00034290-00034601": "operatives the US was responsible for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00144-00034602-00034701": "training german and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00145-00034702-00034883": "Austrian individuals for missions inside", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00146-00034884-00035180": "Germany some of these agents included", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00147-00035181-00035411": "exiled communists and socialists party", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00148-00035412-00035643": "members labor activists and D Nazi", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00149-00035644-00035835": "prisoners of war and German and Jewish", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00150-00035836-00036158": "refugees the US also recruited and ran", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00151-00036159-00036383": "one of the wars most important spies the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00152-00036384-00036804": "German diplomat Fritz Colby in 1943 the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00153-00036805-00037014": "Office of Strategic Services set up", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00154-00037015-00037296": "operations in Istanbul Turkey as a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00155-00037297-00037476": "neutral country during the Second World", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00156-00037477-00037712": "War was a place where both the axis and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00157-00037713-00037983": "Allied powers had spy networks the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00158-00037984-00038180": "railroads connecting Central Asia with", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00159-00038181-00038355": "Europe as well as Turkey's close", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00160-00038356-00038589": "proximity to the Balkan states placed it", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00161-00038590-00038742": "at a crossroads of intelligence", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00162-00038743-00039008": "gathering the goal of the assistant bull", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00163-00039009-00039252": "operation called Project net1 was to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00164-00039253-00039458": "infiltrate and extenuate subversive", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00165-00039459-00039605": "action in the old ottoman and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00166-00039606-00039821": "austro-hungarian empires the head of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00167-00039822-00040002": "operations at assistant bull was a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00168-00040003-00040289": "banker from Chicago named Lani", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00169-00040290-00040505": "mcFarland who maintained a cover story", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00170-00040506-00040712": "as a banker for the American lend-lease", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00171-00040713-00041039": "program mcfarland hired alfred schwartz", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00172-00041040-00041240": "a chechi Slovakian engineer and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00173-00041241-00041405": "businessman who came to be known as", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00174-00041406-00041705": "dogwood and ended up establishing the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00175-00041706-00041976": "dogwood information chain dogwood intern", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00176-00041977-00042201": "hired a personal assistant named walter", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00177-00042202-00042383": "aren't and established himself as an", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00178-00042384-00042555": "employee of the Istanbul Western", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00179-00042556-00042815": "Electric Company through Schwartz and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00180-00042816-00042992": "aren't the Oz was able to infiltrate", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00181-00042993-00043220": "anti-fascist groups in Austria Hungary", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00182-00043221-00043505": "and Germany Schwartz was able to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00183-00043506-00043764": "convince Romanian Bulgarian Hungarian", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00184-00043765-00043992": "and Swiss diplomatic couriers to smuggle", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00185-00043993-00044193": "American intelligence information into", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00186-00044194-00044405": "these territories and establish contact", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00187-00044406-00044618": "with elements antagonistic to the Nazis", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00188-00044619-00044846": "and their collaborators couriers and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00189-00044847-00045057": "agents memorized information and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00190-00045058-00045258": "produced analytical reports when they", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00191-00045259-00045435": "were not able to memorize effectively", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00192-00045436-00045639": "they recorded information on microfilm", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00193-00045640-00045798": "and hid it in their shoes or hollowed", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00194-00045799-00046037": "pencils through this process information", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00195-00046038-00046265": "about the Nazi regime made its way to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00196-00046266-00046487": "McFarland and the Austin Istanbul and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00197-00046488-00046770": "eventually to Washington while the Oz", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00198-00046771-00047064": "dog would chain produced a lot of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00199-00047065-00047258": "information its reliability was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00200-00047259-00047424": "increasingly questioned by British", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00201-00047425-00047748": "intelligence by May 1944 through", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00202-00047749-00047939": "collaboration between the US British", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00203-00047940-00048074": "intelligence Kyra", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00204-00048075-00048302": "in Washington the entire dogwood chain", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00205-00048303-00048539": "was found to be unreliable and dangerous", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00206-00048540-00048789": "planting phony information into the oz", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00207-00048790-00049004": "was intended to misdirect the resources", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00208-00049005-00049286": "of the allies Schwartz's dogwood chain", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00209-00049287-00049433": "which was the largest American", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00210-00049434-00049673": "intelligence gathering tool in occupied", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00211-00049674-00049889": "territory was shortly thereafter shut", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00212-00049890-00050108": "down the Oz purchased Soviet code and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00213-00050109-00050333": "cypher material or Finnish information", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00214-00050334-00050507": "on them from emigres Finnish army", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00215-00050508-00050901": "officers in late 1944 Secretary of State", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00216-00050902-00051120": "Edward Stettinius jr. protested that", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00217-00051121-00051324": "this violated an agreement President", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00218-00051325-00051527": "Roosevelt made with the Soviet Union not", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00219-00051528-00051737": "to interfere with Soviet cypher traffic", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00220-00051738-00051995": "from the United States general Donovan", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00221-00051996-00052187": "might have copied the papers before", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00222-00052188-00052391": "returning them the following January but", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00223-00052392-00052556": "there is no record of Arlington Hall", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00224-00052557-00052826": "receiving them and CIA and NSA archives", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00225-00052827-00053126": "have no surviving copies this codebook", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00226-00053127-00053312": "was in fact used as part of the Venona", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00227-00053313-00053480": "decryption effort which helped uncover", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00228-00053482-00053736": "large-scale Soviet espionage in North", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00229-00053737-00053945": "America", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00230-00053946-00054170": "topic weapons and gadgets the AUSA", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00231-00054171-00054404": "espionage and sabotage operations", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00232-00054404-00054584": "produced a steady demand for highly", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00233-00054585-00054860": "specialized equipment general Donovan", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00234-00054861-00055136": "invited experts organized workshops and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00235-00055137-00055342": "funded labs that later formed the core", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00236-00055344-00055540": "of the research and development branch", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00237-00055541-00055826": "Boston chemist Stanley P level became", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00238-00055827-00056024": "its first head and Donovan humorously", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00239-00056025-00056212": "called him his Professor Moriarty", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00240-00056213-00056462": "throughout the war years the ostry", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00241-00056463-00056638": "search and development successfully", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00242-00056639-00056846": "adapted allied weapons and espionage", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00243-00056847-00057029": "equipment and produced its own line of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00244-00057029-00057236": "novel spy tools and gadgets including", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00245-00057237-00057503": "silenced pistols lightweight submachine", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00246-00057504-00057730": "guns Vino grenades that exploded upon", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00247-00057732-00057803": "impact", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00248-00057804-00058016": "explosives disguised as lumps of coal", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00249-00058016-00058294": "black joe or bags of chinese flour and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00250-00058295-00058544": "jemima acetone time-delay fuses for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00251-00058545-00058772": "limpet mines compasses hidden in uniform", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00252-00058773-00058954": "buttons playing cards that concealed", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00253-00058955-00059242": "maps a 16 millimeters Kodak camera in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00254-00059244-00059476": "the shape of a matchbox tasteless poison", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00255-00059477-00059744": "tablets K and L pills and cigarettes", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00256-00059745-00059966": "laced with tetrahydrocannabinol acetate", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00257-00059966-00060161": "an extract of Indian hemp to induce", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00258-00060162-00060376": "uncontrollable chattiness the US also", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00259-00060377-00060572": "developed innovative communication", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00260-00060573-00060776": "equipment such as wiretap gadgets", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00261-00060777-00061007": "electronic beacons for locating agents", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00262-00061008-00061196": "and the Joan Eleanor portable radio", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00263-00061197-00061351": "system that made it possible for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00264-00061352-00061553": "operatives on the ground to establish", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00265-00061554-00061726": "secure contact with a plane that was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00266-00061727-00062003": "preparing to land or drop cargo the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00267-00062004-00062198": "ostry Search and Development also", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00268-00062199-00062429": "printed fake German and Japanese issued", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00269-00062429-00062680": "identification cards and various passes", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00270-00062682-00062897": "ration cards and counterfeit money on", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00271-00062898-00063269": "August 28 1943 stanley level was asked", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00272-00063270-00063457": "to make a presentation in front of a not", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00273-00063458-00063638": "very friendly audience of the Joint", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00274-00063639-00063857": "Chiefs of Staff since the u.s. top brass", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00275-00063858-00064076": "were largely skeptical of all US plans", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00276-00064077-00064253": "beyond collecting military intelligence", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00277-00064254-00064456": "and were ready to split the Oz between", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00278-00064457-00064700": "the Army and the Navy while explaining", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00279-00064701-00064847": "the purpose and mission of his", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00280-00064848-00065015": "department and introducing various", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00281-00065016-00065297": "gadgets and tools he reportedly casually", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00282-00065298-00065506": "dropped into a wastebasket a heady a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00283-00065507-00065741": "panic inducing explosive device in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00284-00065742-00065924": "shape of a firecracker which shortly", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00285-00065925-00066116": "produced a loud shrieking sound followed", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00286-00066117-00066404": "by a deafening boom the presentation was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00287-00066405-00066590": "interrupted and did not resume since", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00288-00066591-00066896": "everyone in the room fled in reality the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00289-00066897-00067103": "Hedy jokingly named after Hollywood", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00290-00067104-00067312": "movie star Hedy Lamarr for her a bill", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00291-00067313-00067541": "to distract men later saved the lives of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00292-00067542-00067807": "some trapped operatives not all projects", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00293-00067808-00068084": "worked some ideas were on such as a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00294-00068085-00068291": "failed attempt to use insects to spread", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00295-00068292-00068597": "anthrax in Spain stanley level was later", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00296-00068598-00068803": "quoted saying it was my policy to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00297-00068804-00068996": "consider any method whatever that might", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00298-00068997-00069211": "aid the war however unorthodox or", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00299-00069212-00069521": "untried in 1939 a young physician named", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00300-00069522-00069722": "christian j Lambertson developed an", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00301-00069723-00069928": "oxygen rebreather set the Lambertson", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00302-00069929-00070111": "amphibious respiratory unit and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00303-00070112-00070312": "demonstrated it to the US after already", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00304-00070313-00070579": "being rejected by the US Navy in a pool", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00305-00070580-00071009": "at a hotel in Washington DC in 1942 the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00306-00071010-00071147": "hasta not only bought into the concept", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00307-00071148-00071356": "they hired Lambertson to lead the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00308-00071357-00071542": "program and build up the dive element", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00309-00071543-00071730": "for the organization his", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00310-00071731-00071953": "responsibilities included training and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00311-00071954-00072109": "developing methods of combining", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00312-00072110-00072274": "self-contained diving and swimmer", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00313-00072275-00072451": "delivery including the Lambertson", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00314-00072452-00072647": "amphibious respiratory unit for the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00315-00072648-00072919": "operational swimmer group growing", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00316-00072920-00073090": "involvement of the US with coastal", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00317-00073091-00073303": "infiltration and water based sabotage", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00318-00073304-00073510": "eventually led to creation of the AHS", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00319-00073511-00074107": "maritime unit", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00320-00074108-00074640": "topic facilities", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00321-00074641-00074981": "at camp 10 near Whitby Ontario and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00322-00074982-00075267": "assassination and elimination training", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00323-00075268-00075456": "program was operated by the British", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00324-00075457-00075693": "Special Operations Executive assigning", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00325-00075694-00075885": "exceptional masters in the art of knife", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00326-00075886-00076098": "wielding combat such as William II", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00327-00076099-00076320": "Fairburn and Eric a Sykes to instruct", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00328-00076321-00076587": "trainees many members of the Office of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00329-00076588-00076785": "Strategic Services also were trained", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00330-00076786-00077103": "there it was dubbed the school of mayhem", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00331-00077104-00077361": "and murder by George hunter white who", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00332-00077362-00077595": "trained at the facility in the 1950s", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00333-00077596-00077790": "from these incipient beginnings the Oz", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00334-00077791-00078003": "began to take charge of its own destiny", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00335-00078004-00078192": "and opened camps in the United States", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00336-00078193-00078462": "and finally abroad Prince William Forest", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00337-00078463-00078684": "Park then known as Chapo Amish it's", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00338-00078685-00078909": "recreational demonstration area was the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00339-00078910-00079128": "site of an Australian camp that operated", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00340-00079129-00079704": "from 1942 to 1945 Area C consisting of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00341-00079705-00079998": "approximately 6,000 acres 24 square", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00342-00079999-00080193": "kilometers was used extensively for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00343-00080194-00080444": "communications training whereas area a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00344-00080445-00080715": "was used for training some of the OGIS", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00345-00080716-00081024": "operational groups Catoctin Mountain", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00346-00081025-00081261": "Park now the location of Camp David was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00347-00081262-00081558": "the site of aah straining area B where", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00348-00081559-00081795": "the first special operations or so were", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00349-00081796-00082053": "trained special operations was modeled", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00350-00082054-00082269": "after Great Britain's Special Operations", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00351-00082270-00082473": "Executive which included parachute", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00352-00082474-00082728": "sabotage self-defense weapons and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00353-00082729-00082920": "leadership training to support guerrilla", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00354-00082921-00083211": "or partisan resistance considered most", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00355-00083212-00083352": "mysterious of all was the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00356-00083353-00083676": "cloak-and-dagger secret intelligence or", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00357-00083677-00083967": "si branch secret intelligence employed", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00358-00083968-00084195": "country estates as schools for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00359-00084196-00084405": "introducing recruits into the murky", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00360-00084406-00084747": "world of espionage thus it established", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00361-00084748-00085194": "training areas a and RT u 11 the farm in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00362-00085195-00085449": "spacious manor houses with surrounding", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00363-00085450-00085737": "horse farms morale operations training", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00364-00085738-00085962": "included psychological warfare and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00365-00085963-00086172": "propaganda the Congressional Country", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00366-00086173-00086451": "Club area F in Bethesda Maryland was the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00367-00086452-00086706": "primary ah straining facility the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00368-00086707-00086931": "facilities of the Catalina Island Marine", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00369-00086932-00087186": "Institute at Toyon Bay on Santa Catalina", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00370-00087187-00087441": "Island Calif are composed in part of a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00371-00087442-00087630": "former off survival training camp", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00372-00087631-00087888": "the National Park Service commissioned a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00373-00087889-00088026": "study of Austin", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00374-00088027-00088233": "parque training facilities by Professor", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00375-00088234-00088467": "John Chambers of Rutgers University the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00376-00088468-00088650": "main a straining camps abroad were", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00377-00088651-00088815": "located initially in Great Britain", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00378-00088816-00089073": "French Algeria and Egypt later as the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00379-00089074-00089298": "Allies advanced a school was established", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00380-00089299-00089559": "in southern Italy in the Far East ah", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00381-00089560-00089778": "straining facilities were established in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00382-00089779-00090087": "India Salon and then China the London", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00383-00090088-00090282": "branch shall be us its first overseas", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00384-00090283-00090585": "facility was at 70 Grosvenor Street w1", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00385-00090586-00090822": "in addition to training local agents the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00386-00090823-00091029": "overseas ah schools also provided", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00387-00091030-00091245": "advanced training and field exercises", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00388-00091246-00091428": "for graduates of the training camps in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00389-00091429-00091620": "the United States and for Americans who", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00390-00091621-00091896": "enlisted in the US in the war zones the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00391-00091897-00092091": "most famous of the latter was Virginia", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00392-00092092-00092343": "Hall in France the OSS is Mediterranean", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00393-00092344-00092631": "training center in Cairo Egypt known to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00394-00092632-00092820": "many as the spy school was a lavish", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00395-00092821-00092994": "Palace belonging to King Farooq's", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00396-00092995-00093300": "brother-in-law called Ra's al genius it", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00397-00093301-00093492": "was modeled after the SOE s training", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00398-00093493-00093878": "facility STS 102 in Haifa Palestine", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00399-00093879-00094092": "Americans whose heritage stemmed from", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00400-00094093-00094341": "Italy Yugoslavia and Greece were trained", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00401-00094342-00094641": "at the spy school and also sent for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00402-00094642-00094836": "parachute weapons and commando training", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00403-00094837-00095058": "and Morse code and encryption lessons at", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00404-00095059-00095421": "STS 102 after completion of their spy", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00405-00095422-00095619": "training these agents were sent back on", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00406-00095620-00095802": "missions to the Balkans in Italy where", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00407-00095803-00095952": "their accents would not pose a problem", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00408-00095953-00096577": "for their assimilation", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00409-00096578-00097088": "topic personnel", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00410-00097089-00097376": "the names of all 13,000 das personnel", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00411-00097377-00097544": "and documents of their ah service", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00412-00097545-00097784": "previously a closely guarded secret were", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00413-00097785-00098012": "released by the US National Archives on", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00414-00098013-00098423": "August 14 2008 among the 24,000 names", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00415-00098424-00098645": "were those of Julia Child Ralph Bunche", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00416-00098646-00098897": "Arthur Goldberg Saul k-pot over Arthur", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00417-00098898-00099182": "Schlessinger Jr Bruce Sundlun Rene joyas", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00418-00099183-00099614": "MD and John Ford the 750,000 pages in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00419-00099615-00099872": "the 35,000 personnel files include", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00420-00099873-00100046": "applications of people who were not", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00421-00100047-00100238": "recruited or hired as well as the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00422-00100239-00100424": "service records of those who served US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00423-00100425-00100631": "soldiers were primarily inducted from", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00424-00100632-00100798": "the United States Armed Forces", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00425-00100799-00101111": "nonetheless director William J Donovan", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00426-00101112-00101315": "enlisted from the great Kadri of men and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00427-00101316-00101510": "women that embodied the United States of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00428-00101511-00101789": "America other members included foreign", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00429-00101790-00101945": "nationals including displaced", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00430-00101946-00102134": "individuals from the former Czarist", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00431-00102135-00102338": "Russia an example being Prince Serge", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00432-00102339-00102671": "obolensky Donovan sought independent", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00433-00102672-00102835": "thinkers and in order to bring together", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00434-00102836-00103043": "those many intelligent quick-witted", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00435-00103044-00103196": "individuals who could think out of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00436-00103197-00103384": "box he cleverly chose them from all", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00437-00103385-00103553": "walks of life backgrounds without", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00438-00103554-00103758": "distinction to culture or religion", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00439-00103759-00103994": "Donovan was quoted as saying I'd rather", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00440-00103995-00104198": "have a young lieutenant with enough guts", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00441-00104199-00104423": "to disobey a direct order than a colonel", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00442-00104424-00104696": "too regimented to think for himself in a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00443-00104697-00104903": "matter of a few short months he formed", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00444-00104904-00105080": "an organization which equalled and then", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00445-00105081-00105218": "rivaled Great Britain's Secret", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00446-00105219-00105416": "Intelligence Service and its Special", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00447-00105417-00105722": "Operations Executive one such agent was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00448-00105723-00105961": "Ivy League polyglot and Jewish American", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00449-00105963-00106220": "baseball catcher Moe Berg who played 15", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00450-00106221-00106510": "seasons in the major leagues as a secret", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00451-00106511-00106715": "intelligence agent he was dispatched to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00452-00106716-00106909": "seek information on German physicist", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00453-00106910-00107093": "Werner Heisenberg and his knowledge on", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00454-00107094-00107335": "the atomic bomb one of the most highly", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00455-00107336-00107579": "decorated and flamboyant US soldiers was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00456-00107580-00107818": "u.s. Marine Colonel Peter Ortiz", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00457-00107819-00108071": "enlisting early in the war as a French", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00458-00108072-00108257": "Foreign Legion heir he went on to join", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00459-00108258-00108428": "the US and earn the title of the most", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00460-00108429-00108647": "highly decorated US Marine in the US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00461-00108648-00108899": "during World War two Julia Child who", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00462-00108900-00109091": "later authored cookbooks work directly", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00463-00109092-00109382": "under Donovan jumpin Joe sovaldi", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00464-00109383-00109628": "codename Sampson was recruited by the US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00465-00109629-00109901": "in 1942 because of his hand-to-hand", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00466-00109902-00110096": "combat and language skills as well as", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00467-00110097-00110252": "his deep knowledge of the Italian", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00468-00110253-00110514": "geography and Benito Mussolini's Kampf", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00469-00110515-00110700": "he was assigned to the Special", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00470-00110701-00110889": "Operations branch and took part in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00471-00110890-00111090": "missions in North Africa Italy and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00472-00111091-00111546": "France during 1943 to 1945 one of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00473-00111547-00111735": "forefathers of today's commandos was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00474-00111736-00112002": "Navy lieutenant Jack Taylor he was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00475-00112003-00112197": "sequestered by the Oesterle in the war", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00476-00112198-00112383": "and had a long career behind enemy lines", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00477-00112384-00112665": "taro and mitsushima both japanese", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00478-00112666-00112839": "political dissidents who were imprisoned", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00479-00112840-00113025": "in japan for protesting its regime", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00480-00113026-00113250": "worked for the austin psychological", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00481-00113251-00113478": "warfare against the japanese empire this", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00482-00113479-00113829": "a linguists in late 1943 a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00483-00113830-00114153": "representative from us visited the 442nd", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00484-00114154-00114319": "Infantry Regiment looking to recruit", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00485-00114320-00114500": "volunteers willing to undertake", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00486-00114501-00114781": "extremely hazardous assignment all", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00487-00114782-00115008": "selected were NISS a the recruits were", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00488-00115009-00115270": "assigned to Austin touch mints 101 and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00489-00115271-00115524": "202 in the china burma india theater", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00490-00115525-00115795": "once deployed they were to interrogate", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00491-00115796-00116034": "prisoners translate documents monitor", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00492-00116035-00116250": "radio communications and conduct covert", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00493-00116251-00116733": "operations detachment 101 and 102 s", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00494-00116734-00116932": "clandestine operations were extremely", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00495-00116933-00117515": "successful", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00496-00117516-00118171": "topic dissolution into other agencies", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00497-00118172-00118549": "on September 20th 1945 President Truman", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00498-00118550-00118945": "signed executive order 9621 terminating", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00499-00118946-00119008": "the offs", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00500-00119008-00119239": "the State Department took over the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00501-00119240-00119452": "research and analysis branch it became", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00502-00119453-00119638": "the Bureau of intelligence and research", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00503-00119639-00119857": "the War Department took over the Secret", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00504-00119858-00120127": "Intelligence si and counterespionage X", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00505-00120128-00120336": "two branches which were then housed in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00506-00120338-00120615": "the new Strategic Services Unit SSU", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00507-00120616-00120895": "Brigadier General John Magruder formerly", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00508-00120896-00121057": "Donovan's deputy director for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00509-00121058-00121306": "intelligence in us became the new SSU", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00510-00121307-00121584": "director he oversaw the liquidation of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00511-00121585-00121785": "the US and managed the institutional", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00512-00121786-00121951": "preservation of its clandestine", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00513-00121952-00122275": "intelligence capability in January 1946", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00514-00122276-00122494": "President Truman created the Central", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00515-00122495-00122698": "Intelligence Group sig which was the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00516-00122699-00123073": "direct precursor to the CIA SSU assets", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00517-00123074-00123268": "which now constituted a streamline", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00518-00123269-00123595": "nucleus of clandestine intelligence were", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00519-00123596-00123880": "transferred to the sig in mid-1946 and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00520-00123881-00124054": "reconstituted as the Office of Special", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00521-00124055-00124426": "Operations osa the National Security Act", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00522-00124427-00124693": "of 1947 established the first permanent", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00523-00124694-00124935": "peacetime intelligence agency in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00524-00124936-00125098": "United States the Central Intelligence", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00525-00125099-00125361": "Agency which then took up AHS functions", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00526-00125363-00125575": "the direct descendant of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00527-00125576-00125811": "paramilitary component of the US as the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00528-00125813-00126076": "CIA special Activities Division today", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00529-00126077-00126307": "the joint branch United States Special", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00530-00126308-00126628": "Operations Command founded in 1987 uses", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00531-00126629-00126796": "the same spearhead design on its", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00532-00126797-00127000": "insignia as homage to its indirect", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00533-00127001-00127554": "lineage", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00534-00127555-00128423": "topic branches", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00535-00128424-00128944": "topic detachments", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00536-00128945-00129389": "US army units attached to the Oz topic", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00537-00129390-00129656": "in popular culture films the 1946", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00538-00129657-00129928": "paramount film OSS starring Alan Ladd", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00539-00129929-00130153": "and Geraldine Fitzgerald showed agents", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00540-00130154-00130333": "training and on a dangerous mission", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00541-00130333-00130561": "commander John Shaheen acted as", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00542-00130563-00130946": "technical adviser the 1946 film 13 rue", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00543-00130947-00131165": "Madeleine stars James Cagney as an", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00544-00131166-00131339": "Aussie Junt who must find a mole in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00545-00131340-00131645": "French partisan operations peter ortiz", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00546-00131646-00132004": "acted as technical adviser the 1946 film", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00547-00132005-00132251": "cloak-and-dagger stars gary cooper as a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00548-00132252-00132464": "scientist recruited to us to exfiltrate", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00549-00132465-00132665": "a German scientist defecting to the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00550-00132666-00132857": "Allies with the help of a woman gorilla", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00551-00132858-00133178": "and her partisans II Michael Burke acted", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00552-00133179-00133451": "as technical adviser in the 2001 film", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00553-00133452-00133760": "franchise Spy Kids franchise the Cortez", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00554-00133761-00133903": "family is working for an organization", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00555-00133904-00134162": "called the oz organization of super", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00556-00134163-00134471": "spies in the 2006 film The Good Shepherd", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00557-00134472-00134759": "Matt Damon plays Edward Wilson a skull", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00558-00134760-00134953": "and bones recruit who joins the US to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00559-00134954-00135194": "help with a mission in London he quickly", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00560-00135195-00135350": "gains rank as the head of the newly", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00561-00135351-00135596": "formed CIA's counterintelligence service", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00562-00135597-00135947": "the 2008 biographical film flash of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00563-00135948-00136175": "genius as about famed American inventor", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00564-00136176-00136453": "and ahs veteran Robert Kearns in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00565-00136454-00136709": "2008 film Indiana Jones and the Kingdom", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00566-00136710-00136937": "of the Crystal Skull it is indicated", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00567-00136938-00137099": "that Indiana Jones worked for the US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00568-00137100-00137351": "attaining the rank of colonel in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00569-00137352-00137618": "2009 film Inglourious Basterds by", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00570-00137619-00137825": "Quentin Tarantino the bastards are", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00571-00137826-00138023": "members of us although no such Aussie", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00572-00138024-00138395": "unit ever actually existed the 2009 film", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00573-00138396-00138628": "Julie and Julia includes flashback", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00574-00138629-00138865": "scenes depicting Julia Child's wartime", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00575-00138866-00139175": "service with the Oz television in 1957", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00576-00139176-00139448": "1958 Ron Randle starred in the series", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00577-00139449-00139820": "OSS in Knight Rider Devon miles mentions", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00578-00139821-00139985": "that he served in Oz during World War", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00579-00139986-00140348": "two one of the characters in the 1975", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00580-00140349-00140603": "episode of the NBC show Ellery Queen", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00581-00140604-00140777": "titled the adventure of Colonel Nivens", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00582-00140778-00141014": "memoirs identifies himself as major", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00583-00141015-00141299": "George Pierson OSS he offers some Soviet", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00584-00141300-00141602": "diplomats political asylum in the season", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00585-00141603-00141875": "six x-files episode triangle the woman", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00586-00141876-00142100": "from the 1939 scenes portrayed by", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00587-00142101-00142304": "gillian anderson as Scully as a member", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00588-00142305-00142385": "of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00589-00142386-00142801": "in season 3 episode Liang H of NCIS Los", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00590-00142802-00143033": "Angeles the OSS is mentioned as the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00591-00143034-00143338": "predecessor of the CIA in the American", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00592-00143339-00143549": "animated comedy series Archer the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00593-00143550-00143750": "character Malory Archer mother of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00594-00143751-00143929": "main characters sterling Archer is a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00595-00143930-00144320": "former OSS agent the 2014 Yap films", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00596-00144321-00144545": "documentary for History Channel Canada", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00597-00144546-00144754": "called camp 10 secret agent school", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00598-00144755-00144968": "portrays the first spy school in North", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00599-00144969-00145268": "America US agents their training at Camp", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00600-00145269-00145450": "10 and their missions behind enemy lines", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00601-00145451-00145784": "are depicted it was aired in Canada the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00602-00145785-00146045": "2014 Yap films documentary for the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00603-00146046-00146270": "Smithsonian channel called World War 2", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00604-00146271-00146432": "spy school was aired in the United", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00605-00146433-00146650": "States and around the world portraying", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00606-00146651-00146839": "Camp 10 and the other training sites", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00607-00146840-00147068": "overseas as well as hace gence and their", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00608-00147069-00147376": "missions literature the 1976 book a man", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00609-00147377-00147581": "called intrepid the secret war by", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00610-00147582-00147766": "William Stephenson Canadian writer", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00611-00147767-00147971": "describes the operations of the US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00612-00147972-00148169": "particularly the role of Sir William", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00613-00148170-00148354": "Samuel Stevenson head of British", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00614-00148355-00148598": "security coordination in New York in its", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00615-00148599-00148943": "formation he also authored a 1986 book", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00616-00148944-00149329": "entitled Intrepid's last case the 1957", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00617-00149330-00149510": "book you're stepping on my cloak and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00618-00149511-00149720": "dagger by Roger Wolcott Hall as a witty", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00619-00149721-00149920": "look at Hall's experiences with the Oz", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00620-00149921-00150337": "the 1986 book camp 10 by David Stafford", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00621-00150338-00150490": "is the most accurate account of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00622-00150491-00150739": "activities and personnel of camp 10 the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00623-00150740-00150962": "secret agent training camp for sabotage", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00624-00150963-00151184": "and guerrilla warfare at Ajax near", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00625-00151185-00151397": "Oshawa Ontario Canada that was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00626-00151398-00151568": "administered by the British Special", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00627-00151569-00151858": "Operations Executive author w eb", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00628-00151859-00152104": "Griffin's honorbound and men at war", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00629-00152105-00152300": "series revolves around fictional US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00630-00152301-00152597": "operations some of his characters in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00631-00152598-00152815": "core series also are recruited by the US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00632-00152816-00153059": "notably Ken McCoy Edward banning and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00633-00153060-00153449": "Fleming Pickering a French pulp fiction", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00634-00153450-00153766": "series US 117 by author Jean Bruce", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00635-00153767-00153971": "follows the adventure of Hubert boney", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00636-00153972-00154315": "sir de la bath alias oz 117 a French", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00637-00154316-00154562": "operative working for the oz the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00638-00154563-00154787": "original series four or five books a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00639-00154788-00155186": "year lasted from 1949 to 1963 until the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00640-00155187-00155387": "death of Jean Bruce and was continued by", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00641-00155388-00155684": "his wife and children until 1992", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00642-00155685-00155894": "numerous films were made from it in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00643-00155895-00156266": "1960s and in 2006 a nostalgic comedy was", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00644-00156267-00156544": "made celebrating the spy movie genre US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00645-00156545-00156869": "117 Cairo best of spies with Jean", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00646-00156870-00157244": "Dujardin playing us 117 a sequel", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00647-00157245-00157646": "followed in 2009 called oz 117 lost in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00648-00157647-00157997": "Rio original title in French us 117", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00649-00157998-00158558": "reown a rape on+ in 1963 former austech", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00650-00158559-00158759": "turf or special project Stanley P", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00651-00158760-00158912": "Louisville published a book about the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00652-00158913-00159116": "activities of his department titled of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00653-00159117-00159404": "spies and stratagems in it he recalls", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00654-00159405-00159611": "how he was recruited by Donovan who is", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00655-00159612-00159806": "looking for his own Professor Moriarty", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00656-00159807-00160022": "some of the devices special projects", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00657-00160023-00160223": "developed from the high standard silent", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00658-00160224-00160406": "flash less pistol to the anti-vehicle", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00659-00160407-00160592": "bomb codenamed firefly to a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00660-00160593-00160826": "psychological warfare compound codename", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00661-00160827-00161177": "who me the OSS is involvement in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00662-00161178-00161378": "document forgery and counterfeiting and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00663-00161379-00161579": "hinted at the valour of its agents which", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00664-00161580-00161762": "was only then starting to be revealed by", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00665-00161763-00162116": "the government the 2004 book operatives", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00666-00162117-00162398": "spies and saboteurs the unknown story of", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00667-00162399-00162602": "the men and women of world war ii zaas", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00668-00162603-00162803": "by author Patrick K O'Donnell a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00669-00162804-00163022": "revealing look into the intrigue and", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00670-00163023-00163181": "extraordinary courage of our", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00671-00163182-00163456": "intelligence gatherers of world war ii a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00672-00163457-00163754": "rare combination of suspense thriller", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00673-00163755-00164003": "and true heroism by a great American", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00674-00164004-00164269": "writer Clive Cussler", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00675-00164270-00164675": "the 1946 book cloak and dagger the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00676-00164676-00164873": "secret story of the Office of Strategic", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00677-00164874-00165230": "Services by Corey Ford and Alistair", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00678-00165231-00165488": "McBain covers a broad overview of OSS", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00679-00165489-00165689": "information and includes a chapter about", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00680-00165690-00165980": "Joseph Wald II titled the saga of jumpin", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00681-00165981-00166268": "Joe featuring a basic recounting of a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00682-00166269-00166489": "portion of the McGregor mission comics", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00683-00166490-00166820": "the Oz was a featured organization in DC", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00684-00166821-00167182": "Comics introduced in GI combat number", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00685-00167183-00167585": "192 July 1976 led by the mysterious", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00686-00167586-00167846": "control they operated as an espionage", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00687-00167847-00168097": "unit initially in nazi-occupied France", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00688-00168098-00168344": "the organization would later become", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00689-00168345-00168710": "argent DC Comics superheroine Wonder", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00690-00168711-00168950": "Woman's alter-ego Diana Prince works for", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00691-00168951-00169138": "Maj Steve Trevor at the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00692-00169139-00169402": "in this position she found herself privy", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00693-00169403-00169633": "to intelligence on axis operations in", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00694-00169634-00169852": "the United States and many times foiled", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00695-00169853-00170103": "agents of Nazi Germany Imperial Japan", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00696-00170104-00170302": "and fascist Italy in their attempts to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00697-00170303-00170478": "defeat the Allies and achieve world", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00698-00170479-00170736": "domination tabletop role-playing games", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00699-00170737-00171028": "the AUSA peers in the backstory of Delta", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00700-00171029-00171325": "Green the eponymous organization started", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00701-00171326-00171520": "as the fictional p4 division of the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00702-00171521-00171811": "Office of Naval Intelligence and in 1942", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00703-00171812-00172039": "the oniy transfers the p4 division to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00704-00172040-00172203": "the US so they can act in the entire", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00705-00172204-00172378": "Allied theater under the cover of a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00706-00172379-00172597": "psychological warfare research division", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00707-00172598-00172882": "it is under the hasta the p4 division", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00708-00172883-00173200": "acquires the codename Delta Green the US", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00709-00173201-00173403": "also is mentioned in Pell grain pressed", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00710-00173404-00173635": "the fall of Delta Green player", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00711-00173636-00173857": "characters can be exes agents in other", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00712-00173858-00174103": "agencies such as the CIA which can be", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00713-00174104-00174277": "beneficial to the claim and carry", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00714-00174278-00174514": "authenticity experience and authority to", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00715-00174515-00174769": "their past career in the US video games", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00716-00174770-00175069": "in the Wolfenstein series of video games", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00717-00175070-00175261": "the main character as a member of a", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00718-00175262-00175486": "fictional organization called the OSA", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00719-00175487-00175678": "office of secret actions which is", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00720-00175679-00175987": "inspired by the us most games in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00721-00175988-00176185": "Medal of Honor video game franchise", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00722-00176186-00176383": "feature a fictional loss agent as the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00723-00176384-00176728": "main character in the 2012 game Sniper", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00724-00176729-00176974": "Elite v2 and it's sequels Sniper Elite 3", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00725-00176975-00177223": "the protagonist is an Aussie Jin sniper", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00726-00177224-00177484": "in Indiana Jones and the infernal", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00727-00177485-00177823": "machine 1999 the main female character", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00728-00177824-00178078": "Sophia Hapgood is an oscillator CIA", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00729-00178079-00178615": "agent in call of duty world at war 2008", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00730-00178616-00179298": "dr. Peter McCain is an AW spy", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00731-00179299-00179819": "topic C also", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00732-00179820-00180173": "Charles Douglas Jackson operation", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00733-00180174-00180585": "halyard operation Jedburgh Operation", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00734-00180586-00180683": "Paperclip", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00735-00180684-00180996": "hasta attachment 101 operated in the", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00736-00180997-00181202": "china burma india theater of world war", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00737-00181203-00181528": "ii paramarines", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00738-00181529-00181828": "Special Forces United States Army", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00739-00181829-00182232": "Special Operations Executive x2", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00740-00182233-00182523": "counterespionage branch Central", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00741-00182524-00183276": "Intelligence Agency history of espionage", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00742-00183277-00183772": "topic notes", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00743-00183773-00184179": "Paulsen Allen 1995 required reading us", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00744-00184180-00184562": "weapons fighting firearms three two", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00745-00184563-00185221": "22:21 8281 runner John 1991 oz crossbows", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00746-00185222-00185698": "Phillips publications ISBN own 9 3 2 5 7", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00747-00185699-00186276": "2 1 5 4 runner John 2005 US weapons -", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00748-00186277-00186772": "Phillips publications ISBN 978 oh 9 3 2", "S2B_RdnpGAE-00749-00186773-00187164": "5 7 2 4 3 1"}}, {"audio_id": "S2FV-Yj1Szo", "text": {"S2FV-Yj1Szo-00000-00000000-00000488": "Oh 12 day of Christmas the crystal gave", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00001-00000488-00001070": "to me 12 bath response team 11 gamers", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00002-00001071-00001579": "frightening 10 lovers laughing 9 Freya's", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00003-00001580-00002057": "Lansing it was a soaking 7 buffman", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00004-00002058-00002680": "breathing 6 winds up beeping blow the", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00005-00002681-00002967": "change", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00006-00002968-00003589": "though our Treves 3d remake two special", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00007-00003590-00004270": "guys have the garland to knock you down", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00008-00004271-00005186": "[Music]", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00009-00005187-00006616": "[Music]", "S2FV-Yj1Szo-00010-00006617-00006929": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "S2QMMaCJL4E", "text": {"S2QMMaCJL4E-00000-00000315-00000537": "[Applause]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00001-00000538-00001247": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00002-00001248-00001399": "i should have picked this swiffer even", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00003-00001400-00001614": "though it's spot zones like oh god no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00004-00001616-00001975": "no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00005-00001976-00002110": "all right ladies and gentlemen welcome", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00006-00002111-00002334": "to my lovely let's play of guitar hero", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00007-00002335-00002518": "where today we suffer with our fingers", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00008-00002519-00002742": "if i miss a note i have to go back not", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00009-00002743-00002999": "even a single person on youtube made a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00010-00003000-00003319": "single video about squidwards too i am", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00011-00003320-00003599": "totally serious that's not sarcasm no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00012-00003600-00003767": "i'm trying so hard", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00013-00003768-00003943": "i'm trying so hard to not die it's not", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00014-00003944-00004247": "as difficult because i'm not okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00015-00004248-00004751": "this is extremely slow", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00016-00004752-00004967": "i'm having fun ooh girlfriend copless", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00017-00004968-00005167": "let's go no way i can feel with this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00018-00005168-00005375": "okay how am i not messing this up how am", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00019-00005376-00005551": "i not messing this up this is actually", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00020-00005552-00005822": "really easy man look at me i'm so good", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00021-00005823-00005999": "at freaking squidby sucks no wonder why", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00022-00006000-00006167": "it's underrated not many people play", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00023-00006168-00006367": "because of how much it", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00024-00006368-00006583": "sucks", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00025-00006584-00006863": "oh on to the more catchy theme let's go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00026-00006864-00007014": "i'm gonna be completely honest i don't", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00027-00007015-00007159": "even know how to commentate over this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00028-00007159-00007398": "because one the music is good too i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00029-00007400-00007731": "suffering from concentration", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00030-00007733-00008174": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00031-00008175-00008367": "okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00032-00008368-00008574": "let's get back that zone we barely got", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00033-00008575-00008759": "that zone oh my goodness", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00034-00008760-00008927": "rest in peace that guy rest in peace", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00035-00008928-00009159": "that guy too", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00036-00009160-00009414": "can i at least get a snipe let me live", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00037-00009415-00009614": "let me live i don't want to play squid", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00038-00009615-00009951": "beats again this video sucks", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00039-00009952-00010119": "i'm gonna feel miserably at this watch", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00040-00010120-00010391": "me guys watch this watch me feel", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00041-00010392-00010671": "horribly and i'm not even trying to fail", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00042-00010672-00010974": "i'm actually trying to pass this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00043-00010975-00011255": "are you kidding me right now this clash", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00044-00011256-00011703": "blaster main really okay thank you yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00045-00011704-00011838": "slap you too", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00046-00011839-00012063": "content content content there we go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00047-00012064-00012303": "no no no content no content no content", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00048-00012304-00012599": "no no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00049-00012600-00012855": "i didn't even sneeze shane oh listen we", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00050-00012856-00012965": "don't", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00051-00012966-00013175": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00052-00013176-00013494": "oh didn't you say plus two here you go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00053-00013495-00013743": "i guess", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00054-00013744-00013931": "why do you do this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00055-00013932-00014862": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00056-00014863-00015005": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00057-00015006-00015051": "[Applause]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00058-00015052-00015286": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00059-00015287-00017719": "no no no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00060-00017720-00017791": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00061-00017792-00017983": "[__] my hands slipped sorry", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00062-00017984-00018127": "can i get like a counter for every time", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00063-00018128-00018935": "i guess", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00064-00018936-00019679": "[Laughter]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00065-00019680-00020103": "goodness", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00066-00020104-00020463": "you should pick your favorite color", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00067-00020464-00020647": "champion", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00068-00020648-00020999": "oh i thought it was peter pan", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00069-00021000-00021239": "yes yeah shane peter pan it's a panda", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00070-00021240-00021367": "okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00071-00021368-00021830": "oh no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00072-00021831-00021935": "come on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00073-00021936-00022111": "come on come on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00074-00022112-00022337": "wait shane what color", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00075-00022338-00022455": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00076-00022456-00023967": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00077-00023968-00024158": "i win", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00078-00024159-00024399": "oh heartbreaker harp yeah that's what", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00079-00024400-00024630": "you did", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00080-00024631-00025063": "you broke my heart", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00081-00025064-00025255": "i know you are", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00082-00025256-00025407": "shane", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00083-00025408-00026068": "i'm sorry", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00084-00026069-00027288": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00085-00027289-00028374": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00086-00028375-00028687": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00087-00028688-00029087": "oh no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00088-00029088-00031438": "oh well you know if nikki", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00089-00031439-00032095": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00090-00032095-00032214": "of hades", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00091-00032216-00032431": "whose very name inspires fear and", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00092-00032432-00032551": "penitence", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00093-00032552-00032758": "reminding us of the inevitable fate", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00094-00032760-00032935": "which we all share", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00095-00032936-00033183": "what no thank you i would just rather", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00096-00033184-00033431": "give up oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00097-00033432-00033662": "thank you so much for listening to uh uh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00098-00033663-00033951": "sun hades over here or uh little boy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00099-00033952-00034118": "hades um", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00100-00034119-00034295": "[__] hades there we go that's a better", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00101-00034296-00034431": "name man", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00102-00034432-00034607": "there's no challenge here", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00103-00034608-00034831": "let's go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00104-00034832-00035023": "what did i just spit out okay hold on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00105-00035024-00035231": "before we meet she i don't know who she", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00106-00035232-00035351": "is but", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00107-00035352-00035623": "hello she for a moment", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00108-00035624-00035812": "i thought that said something else", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00109-00035813-00036071": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00110-00036072-00036318": "the freak is like oh my god those", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00111-00036319-00036607": "these big boys are big i'll tell you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00112-00036608-00036846": "that these are super big", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00113-00036847-00036983": "very", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00114-00036984-00037071": "big", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00115-00037072-00037255": "i don't appreciate this why am i stuck", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00116-00037256-00037479": "in the face being good boy walk on the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00117-00037480-00037743": "trap please thank you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00118-00037744-00037895": "i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00119-00037896-00038102": "pretty much everybody dies sometime this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00120-00038103-00038367": "person's faces me at 3am hey room i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00121-00038368-00038662": "back yes room room has a personality me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00122-00038663-00038999": "name is room uh you live in me i be the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00123-00039000-00039271": "room that you shall step your feet in", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00124-00039272-00040446": "because", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00125-00040447-00040623": "i just punched you in the groin and you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00126-00040624-00040871": "say that oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00127-00040872-00041287": "neptune oh man", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00128-00041288-00041543": "it has its own reward ah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00129-00041544-00041702": "i see yeah you say", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00130-00041703-00041862": "i just smack my controller against my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00131-00041863-00042262": "desk come on die", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00132-00042263-00042943": "oh god no no this is worse", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00133-00042944-00043190": "let's give everything another shot i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00134-00043191-00043318": "kind of hoping the bone error is not", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00135-00043319-00043502": "going to be as bad as the sword this bow", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00136-00043503-00043718": "sucks okay aiming with this thing with", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00137-00043719-00043823": "the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00138-00043824-00044158": "oh god the aim", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00139-00044159-00044383": "this is the most boring bow and arrow", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00140-00044384-00044935": "ever", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00141-00044936-00045262": "oh god there's so many of them yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00142-00045263-00045583": "okay okay my headphones are falling off", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00143-00045584-00045887": "oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00144-00045888-00048758": "okay there we go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00145-00048759-00048958": "i just want to ask you things i want to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00146-00048959-00049167": "just to relieve stress this isn't me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00147-00049168-00049327": "pointing fingers this is just me wanting", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00148-00049328-00049558": "to understand the thing um epi there was", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00149-00049559-00049686": "a moment where you were standing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00150-00049687-00049911": "completely and utterly still and i was", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00151-00049912-00050071": "just wondering if you could clarify to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00152-00050072-00050327": "me what that was", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00153-00050328-00050511": "so i can briefly explain yeah please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00154-00050512-00050662": "please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00155-00050663-00050815": "i failed the one card swipe and i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00156-00050816-00051023": "succeeded on my second one and then you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00157-00051024-00051214": "kind of like walked away for a second", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00158-00051215-00051502": "and you just stood pogging off i guess", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00159-00051503-00051782": "it's because my hand was shaking", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00160-00051783-00052158": "yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00161-00052159-00052311": "okay what is the chance that it's me and", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00162-00052312-00052647": "weaver again like i feel like just like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00163-00052648-00052838": "funny it's a chance", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00164-00052839-00053063": "there is let's be real there is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00165-00053064-00054550": "we have had someone get like five times", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00166-00054551-00054682": "here right", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00167-00054683-00054950": "now out of here right now", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00168-00054951-00055047": "wow", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00169-00055048-00055271": "turn of the table so", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00170-00055272-00055463": "i come into electrical after breaking", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00171-00055464-00055679": "away from my dearest friends starlet", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00172-00055679-00055879": "siren and grinder i come into electrical", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00173-00055879-00056926": "where i have four times", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00174-00056927-00057359": "trust me guys he's trolling okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00175-00057360-00057566": "he's just trying to frame me he's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00176-00057567-00057815": "spreading the gas all into my eyelids", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00177-00057816-00058159": "just so he can set me ablaze and kill me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00178-00058160-00058294": "it was alpha", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00179-00058295-00058694": "i'm telling you dawg no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00180-00058695-00058935": "i am going to take your stupid fedora", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00181-00058936-00059119": "and i'm going to [__] it open with my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00182-00059120-00059687": "knees", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00183-00059688-00059830": "i can't breathe", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00184-00059832-00060142": "that was good", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00185-00060144-00060479": "goddess grinders your eyes oh he's going", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00186-00060479-00061023": "to freak out", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00187-00061024-00061247": "i knew he was the imposter and he just", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00188-00061248-00061454": "got annoyed", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00189-00061455-00061799": "i knew that was going to happen", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00190-00061800-00062103": "he was literally just slowly sliding", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00191-00062104-00062430": "ever so quietly", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00192-00062432-00062775": "now he's dead slowly so happy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00193-00062776-00062894": "ebby had been chasing me around the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00194-00062895-00063063": "whole time watching me do tasks which", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00195-00063064-00063182": "would have been great if he was still", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00196-00063183-00063342": "alive because he could say that i was", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00197-00063344-00063599": "doing tasks we got separated in storage", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00198-00063600-00063799": "when doors closed", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00199-00063800-00064191": "what shootout after the wave", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00200-00064191-00064735": "okay i'm just gonna stay over here", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00201-00064736-00064919": "oh my god that's please i swear to god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00202-00064920-00065191": "if you don't see my body it's literally", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00203-00065191-00065631": "right there", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00204-00065632-00065806": "did i miss something", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00205-00065807-00067238": "how did you do", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00206-00067239-00067438": "it was a stupid argument i started", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00207-00067439-00068094": "before anyone what are you laughing at", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00208-00068095-00068263": "no but nobody moved at first because", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00209-00068264-00068431": "alpha's like i'm going to be afk so i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00210-00068432-00068719": "just like oh speaking of which", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00211-00068720-00068831": "right is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00212-00068832-00069015": "the thing that made me laugh was the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00213-00069016-00069199": "just the whole idea of just being like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00214-00069200-00069431": "oh my god this is dead body let me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00215-00069432-00069575": "contemplate in a second before i click", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00216-00069576-00069655": "on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00217-00069656-00069847": "you just one", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00218-00069848-00070047": "yeah that was funny", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00219-00070048-00071094": "ah shields", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00220-00071095-00071447": "are you crying are you kidding me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00221-00071448-00071671": "oh my god greatest", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00222-00071672-00071903": "do you think i'm blind oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00223-00071904-00072111": "are you pulling this again okay first of", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00224-00072112-00072335": "all", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00225-00072336-00072615": "don't even don't even give me that you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00226-00072616-00072791": "just play the ground music i'm just", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00227-00072792-00073471": "saying gun was right last", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00228-00073472-00073687": "why would i go all the way from", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00229-00073688-00074023": "navigation onto just a measly little a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00230-00074024-00074262": "cool shiny red button that brings all my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00231-00074263-00075391": "pals", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00232-00075392-00075526": "imposter and then they would think", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00233-00075527-00077111": "there's one imposter left when there's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00234-00077112-00077479": "one but i just nearly fought them", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00235-00077480-00077599": "die", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00236-00077600-00077806": "oh just vote me out please just pulled", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00237-00077807-00078006": "me out just move me out right now please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00238-00078007-00078199": "i was about to say epi's been alive for", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00239-00078200-00078447": "two rounds", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00240-00078448-00079155": "that's a new", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00241-00079156-00079943": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00242-00079944-00080126": "do you remember who walked up there", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00243-00080127-00080375": "there was someone else in cafeteria with", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00244-00080376-00080543": "me and siren that walked up and then i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00245-00080544-00080911": "walk up and then boom beppy dead", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00246-00080912-00081231": "wait wait what did you just say becky", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00247-00081232-00081471": "i sadly do not have a can of beepest i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00248-00081472-00081679": "sorry you don't have a can of happy damn", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00249-00081680-00082215": "i also have a bar of arrow chocolate too", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00250-00082216-00082471": "kind of happy a can of me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00251-00082472-00082703": "what's a kid of me me i want a kin of", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00252-00082704-00083423": "you break you right up", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00253-00083424-00083631": "that was so weird", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00254-00083632-00083831": "doing my upload task would takes 10", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00255-00083832-00084543": "billion years so i'll play this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00256-00084544-00084694": "okay it's done", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00257-00084695-00084862": "oh this could be a very advanced", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00258-00084863-00085247": "impossible it's happy it's up here", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00259-00085248-00086655": "who's you banana man oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00260-00086656-00087782": "hmm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00261-00087783-00087862": "yo", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00262-00087863-00088494": "ink", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00263-00088495-00088975": "goodbye", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00264-00088976-00089167": "dang he's already gone crazy oh my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00265-00089168-00089375": "goodness oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00266-00089376-00089526": "ah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00267-00089527-00089582": "yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00268-00089583-00089718": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00269-00089719-00089982": "yay cat shine", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00270-00089983-00090447": "i don't know what that does", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00271-00090448-00091694": "oh he has a health bar i just realized", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00272-00091695-00091831": "that's the alternate ending to the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00273-00091832-00092111": "titanic movie instead of you know jack", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00274-00092112-00092279": "whatever name", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00275-00092280-00092487": "sinks into the ocean bowser instead does", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00276-00092488-00092647": "is that him in the background just like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00277-00092648-00092831": "sitting there what's up baby bastard", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00278-00092832-00093087": "yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00279-00093088-00093606": "yeah okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00280-00093607-00093815": "what marty's just not buying it he's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00281-00093816-00094031": "used to this bs i can't change that back", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00282-00094032-00094335": "by myself", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00283-00094336-00094559": "i've never seen him so", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00284-00094560-00094831": "interrogational it's not even a word", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00285-00094832-00094967": "that's probably not even the right word", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00286-00094968-00095431": "to use", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00287-00095432-00095606": "it's super convinced", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00288-00095607-00095862": "yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00289-00095863-00096047": "and you look through them off the edge", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00290-00096048-00096262": "die", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00291-00096263-00096318": "you do", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00292-00096319-00096535": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00293-00096536-00096694": "i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00294-00096695-00096926": "i i'm gonna get demonetized when the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00295-00096927-00097359": "beast awakens so shall i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00296-00097360-00097559": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00297-00097560-00098215": "oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00298-00098216-00098494": "that can't be it that cannot be it yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00299-00098495-00098606": "that's why i thought there just had to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00300-00098607-00098791": "be more popping up it'll take more than", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00301-00098792-00099015": "that to beat my papa i was about to say", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00302-00099016-00099255": "if that was really that easy then jesus", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00303-00099256-00099374": "christ", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00304-00099375-00099631": "mario's in for a role", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00305-00099632-00099726": "thank you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00306-00099727-00100271": "okay i should probably", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00307-00100272-00100503": "ah so what you're telling me that i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00308-00100504-00100726": "can't collect the shine if bowser is out", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00309-00100727-00100903": "otherwise he'll just go back into his", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00310-00100904-00101150": "hiding hole aka the ocean in which he's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00311-00101151-00101303": "currently bubbling out of all right", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00312-00101304-00101511": "plessy we're coming on a journey oh my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00313-00101512-00101591": "god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00314-00101592-00102062": "let's go on a journey plessy we're going", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00315-00102063-00102206": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00316-00102207-00102439": "come on please please please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00317-00102440-00102663": "okay just", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00318-00102664-00102854": "dang that doesn't work wait a minute", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00319-00102855-00103023": "nothing's fight okay no that's something", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00320-00103024-00103127": "i want", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00321-00103128-00103247": "yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00322-00103248-00103471": "he gets the treatment of his lifetime", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00323-00103472-00103639": "let's go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00324-00103640-00103815": "please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00325-00103816-00103910": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00326-00103911-00104023": "please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00327-00104024-00104175": "god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00328-00104176-00104294": "come on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00329-00104295-00104575": "oh my god please please just get this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00330-00104576-00104815": "over with just get this over with get", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00331-00104816-00104958": "out of my way bowser", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00332-00104959-00105102": "i don't think he's ever gonna fade away", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00333-00105103-00105327": "this time please please please let me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00334-00105328-00105790": "make it no no no no no no no no no no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00335-00105791-00106710": "sorry pipe", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00336-00106711-00106902": "he puked up all that gatorade i know", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00337-00106903-00107039": "junior", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00338-00107040-00107310": "your dad had an addiction you these", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00339-00107311-00107463": "abominations", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00340-00107464-00107710": "no don't smile mario don't smile why are", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00341-00107711-00108215": "they in frame now get them out of here", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00342-00108216-00108495": "okay i'm scared for life", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00343-00108496-00108631": "i okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00344-00108632-00108815": "platforming is a bit of a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00345-00108816-00108948": "joke right now", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00346-00108949-00109254": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00347-00109255-00109663": "forget i said anything it's not a joke", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00348-00109664-00109847": "that's a joke your great strength marks", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00349-00109848-00110039": "you amongst us", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00350-00110040-00110231": "you freaking mosquito looking thing that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00351-00110232-00110415": "just expo are you kidding me this this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00352-00110416-00110599": "thing thinks i'm a champ right", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00353-00110600-00110807": "you think i'm a champ right [__] yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00354-00110808-00110999": "thank you so much lovely i gotta get", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00355-00111000-00111127": "everything", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00356-00111128-00111390": "you freaking suck you little thingy i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00357-00111391-00111495": "don't even know what you are but you're", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00358-00111496-00111647": "a little thingy and i don't like little", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00359-00111648-00111815": "thingies because little thingies are the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00360-00111816-00111951": "most annoying thing are you kidding me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00361-00111952-00112190": "there we go oh my god my headphones just", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00362-00112191-00112390": "keep falling off you're a good thing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00363-00112391-00112534": "right", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00364-00112535-00112702": "you're not a good thing you're not a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00365-00112703-00112807": "good thing you're not a good thing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00366-00112808-00112943": "you're not a good thing i thought you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00367-00112944-00113175": "were a good thing i am happy to be", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00368-00113176-00113415": "proved wrong in the worst way possible", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00369-00113416-00113654": "uh do i hit you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00370-00113655-00113975": "ew did i just spurt gunk all over the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00371-00113976-00114263": "place what what", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00372-00114264-00114534": "why am i getting gunk why is the gunk", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00373-00114535-00114686": "helping me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00374-00114688-00115478": "yeah okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00375-00115479-00115831": "okay i give up", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00376-00115832-00115910": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00377-00115911-00116054": "i did not know there was a hole there", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00378-00116055-00116263": "what the freak is this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00379-00116264-00116671": "what is this game this is a curse", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00380-00116672-00116943": "that's french for monstrosity misuma oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00381-00116944-00117127": "i was down there", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00382-00117128-00117390": "oh that makes a lot of sense", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00383-00117391-00117663": "that doesn't help", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00384-00117664-00117758": "yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00385-00117759-00117849": "there we go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00386-00117850-00117983": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00387-00117983-00118223": "what did you spit out of me you freaking", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00388-00118224-00118423": "disgusting freak", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00389-00118424-00118678": "thank you you disgusting freak oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00390-00118679-00118823": "there's another disgusting there's two", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00391-00118824-00118934": "there's two there's two there's two", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00392-00118935-00119215": "there's you ah no no are you [__]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00393-00119216-00119583": "kidding me no no no no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00394-00119583-00119799": "anything over here i wonder", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00395-00119800-00120310": "i swear to god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00396-00120311-00120495": "what", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00397-00120496-00120758": "oh okay i did not know i was supposed to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00398-00120759-00121143": "hit you charge charge charge charge", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00399-00121144-00121343": "you could do that that's cheating why'd", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00400-00121344-00121543": "i run into him why am i in him i didn't", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00401-00121544-00121727": "even know there was a boss like i saw", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00402-00121728-00121902": "the icon i was like okay so there's got", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00403-00121903-00122071": "to be a boss there it's a big fat thick", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00404-00122072-00122614": "dummy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00405-00122615-00122878": "why are there multiple difficulties to a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00406-00122879-00123119": "tutorial okay let's check out tutorial", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00407-00123120-00123663": "hard this cannot be bad right", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00408-00123664-00123919": "this is hard difficulty", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00409-00123920-00124454": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00410-00124455-00124743": "this is hard difficulty ah okay now", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00411-00124744-00124966": "you're showing your difficulty", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00412-00124967-00125231": "oh my god okay i regret everything i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00413-00125232-00125710": "said", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00414-00125711-00126086": "oh it sounds like shrek's constipation", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00415-00126088-00126286": "what the [__] why is he have a gun okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00416-00126288-00126454": "i'm pretty sure this is a rap battle not", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00417-00126455-00126671": "a gun battle i think picking hard was a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00418-00126672-00126919": "bad idea oh this was a this was a bad", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00419-00126920-00127095": "idea", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00420-00127096-00127263": "okay ladies and gentlemen i got beat up", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00421-00127264-00127495": "by a kid with a gun i mean of course he", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00422-00127496-00127880": "had a gun", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00423-00127881-00128063": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00424-00128064-00128214": "sucks that i can't play through all of", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00425-00128215-00128799": "it today okay well", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00426-00128800-00129047": "hi again i have practiced i have learned", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00427-00129048-00129295": "that's totally part of my plan i thought", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00428-00129296-00129463": "easy with difficulty", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00429-00129464-00129623": "would like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00430-00129624-00129790": "lower the amount of arrows i have to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00431-00129791-00129982": "press not slow them down", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00432-00129983-00130271": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00433-00130272-00130383": "i don't care about the arrows on the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00434-00130383-00130671": "left those aren't important", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00435-00130672-00130863": "wait what this is easy mode this is easy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00436-00130864-00131054": "mode this is easy mode this is freaking", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00437-00131055-00131751": "easy mode", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00438-00131752-00131927": "ladies and gentlemen welcome to salmon", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00439-00131928-00132063": "run fury", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00440-00132064-00132311": "hey i did it now get those eggs to the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00441-00132312-00132590": "flag", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00442-00132591-00132823": "okay okay i see you i see you now get", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00443-00132824-00133111": "those eggs to the fly i did exactly that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00444-00133112-00133366": "a game hello", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00445-00133367-00133623": "i got two out of three", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00446-00133624-00133807": "i i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00447-00133808-00134231": "if you hitted your target its hailed bar", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00448-00134232-00134375": "will go down", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00449-00134376-00134631": "i will do my best it's in the thing it's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00450-00134632-00134966": "in the thing it's in the thing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00451-00134967-00135119": "i think we have enough power eggs to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00452-00135120-00135295": "build a cannon", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00453-00135296-00135478": "i could go for a cannon camera it's time", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00454-00135479-00135759": "to go on to the next mission uh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00455-00135760-00136127": "where oh there", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00456-00136128-00136302": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00457-00136303-00136639": "oh i'm a genius i'm a genius", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00458-00136640-00136783": "i'm a genius", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00459-00136784-00136966": "can i swim in this haha i'm out of egg", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00460-00136967-00137111": "i'm out of bake i'm out of it i'm out of", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00461-00137112-00137335": "vic wait was the water rising for first", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00462-00137336-00137687": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00463-00137688-00137990": "okay give me this like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00464-00137991-00138431": "okay there we go no no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00465-00138432-00138702": "thank you god almighty", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00466-00138703-00138951": "that was ridiculous that was super", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00467-00138952-00139247": "ridiculous my headphones are falling out", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00468-00139248-00139463": "how the freak can you climb you cannot", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00469-00139464-00139759": "climb you're on a freaking device you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00470-00139760-00139999": "cannot climb i'm gonna have to call a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00471-00140000-00140214": "few scientist friends to see if they can", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00472-00140215-00140727": "actually do that that's a scrapper", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00473-00140728-00140951": "i broke your thing you're in the wall", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00474-00140952-00141127": "how are you in the wall this makes no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00475-00141128-00141271": "sense you're in the wall how are you in", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00476-00141272-00141399": "the wall can the salmon just jump out of", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00477-00141400-00141654": "the water please i would very much love", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00478-00141655-00141911": "that thank you oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00479-00141912-00142038": "hey", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00480-00142039-00142351": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00481-00142352-00142639": "you have no place to be here thank you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00482-00142640-00143043": "you'll do perfectly hey", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00483-00143044-00143814": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00484-00143815-00144023": "i just need one more golden egg and i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00485-00144024-00144214": "think i beat this game i mean i know", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00486-00144215-00144335": "there's multiple versions of these", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00487-00144336-00144871": "levels but i ain't gonna bother", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00488-00144872-00145102": "uh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00489-00145103-00145351": "epi spy is a nearby town", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00490-00145352-00145535": "that's what the subtitle says at the top", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00491-00145536-00145807": "that's not what i saw but you know what", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00492-00145808-00145966": "i mean", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00493-00145967-00146183": "i can't wait for everyone to see this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00494-00146184-00146797": "this is gonna be amazing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00495-00146798-00147311": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00496-00147312-00147454": "i'm sorry", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00497-00147455-00147599": "i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00498-00147600-00147951": "been boring today you are alarmingly", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00499-00147952-00148302": "skinny my friend okay mom that's that's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00500-00148303-00148799": "your name stop it", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00501-00148800-00148983": "my child is so happy right that's your", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00502-00148984-00149263": "son you're so pretty purple guy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00503-00149264-00149566": "you're so smart", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00504-00149567-00149895": "hey it's isaac i i played your game so", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00505-00149896-00150143": "many times for the past two weeks it's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00506-00150144-00150326": "not a lie oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00507-00150327-00150471": "my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00508-00150472-00150695": "it's choosing me to play the dark lord", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00509-00150696-00150871": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00510-00150872-00151111": "i am the dark lord shane mario i'm not", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00511-00151112-00151319": "doing his voice i've come to wreck havoc", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00512-00151320-00151502": "and terror on this miserable little", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00513-00151503-00151687": "world shane i thought we were friends", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00514-00151688-00152014": "what the heck is this oh my goodness", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00515-00152015-00152359": "no daddy the sun", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00516-00152360-00152519": "purple guy's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00517-00152520-00153119": "face is now fully purple", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00518-00153120-00153311": "i'm suing the person who sent me these", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00519-00153312-00153743": "codes please tell my daddy i will gladly", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00520-00153744-00153935": "do that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00521-00153936-00154375": "give daddy's first back", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00522-00154376-00154623": "can you hear me no i can't what good", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00523-00154624-00154847": "fortune this i said no i can't hear you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00524-00154848-00155031": "what is this now you may not believe", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00525-00155032-00155223": "what i'm about to tell you but i am a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00526-00155224-00155298": "god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00527-00155299-00155483": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00528-00155484-00155735": "why that's the correct reaction rather", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00529-00155736-00155943": "than just having like a would you like a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00530-00155944-00156214": "little help now i'm fine no no no no i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00531-00156215-00156375": "can't just leave you it would hurt my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00532-00156376-00156654": "divine credentials well", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00533-00156655-00156902": "i can handle myself", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00534-00156903-00157231": "let's go i have successfully helped the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00535-00157232-00157439": "day my poor", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00536-00157440-00157599": "i'm not even gonna say anything anymore", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00537-00157600-00157847": "vanquish the vile shane mario and save", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00538-00157848-00158007": "this world", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00539-00158008-00158231": "you see i kind of have a video to stop", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00540-00158232-00158414": "recording and i think now's the perfect", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00541-00158415-00158566": "time so i'm just gonna say no so there", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00542-00158567-00158628": "you go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00543-00158629-00158783": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00544-00158784-00158926": "unfortunately you have no say in the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00545-00158927-00159151": "matter well thank you god you're amazing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00546-00159152-00159311": "you do owe me for saving you from that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00547-00159312-00159495": "monster", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00548-00159496-00159671": "well i kind of don't care i'm at a loss", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00549-00159672-00159902": "for what to do here well hopefully you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00550-00159903-00160454": "don't go genocide on me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00551-00160455-00160639": "it's so perfect", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00552-00160640-00160807": "i'm sorry", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00553-00160808-00161143": "this game is amazing i love it man oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00554-00161144-00161254": "my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00555-00161255-00161519": "oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00556-00161520-00161790": "let me help you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00557-00161791-00161911": "yeah", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00558-00161912-00162087": "okay spongebob", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00559-00162088-00162375": "spongebob's a freaking meat selfie now", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00560-00162376-00162607": "look at his face", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00561-00162608-00162807": "i can't get enough of that spongebob", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00562-00162808-00163078": "join my team let's go i got spongebob on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00563-00163079-00163223": "my team", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00564-00163224-00163447": "this space", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00565-00163448-00163814": "why is that so funny smash smash", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00566-00163815-00165126": "yup that makes me snatch", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00567-00165127-00165359": "i don't know who that guy is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00568-00165360-00165751": "i don't know either", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00569-00165752-00166078": "oh my god you're freaking kidding me my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00570-00166079-00166207": "buddy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00571-00166208-00166311": "let's go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00572-00166312-00167935": "wait is this new", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00573-00167936-00168214": "there's goku the supposed smash bros", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00574-00168215-00168454": "character oh my god here we go here we", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00575-00168455-00168759": "go here we go let's find the guff all", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00576-00168760-00169038": "right i'm sleeping good night", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00577-00169039-00169238": "next up", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00578-00169239-00170399": "okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00579-00170400-00170726": "shane your microphone is uh is really", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00580-00170727-00170919": "robotic", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00581-00170920-00171102": "i think i think this this milk in my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00582-00171103-00171271": "cereal has expired i feel like that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00583-00171272-00171454": "relates to what shane is going through", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00584-00171455-00171757": "right now", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00585-00171758-00171863": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00586-00171864-00172159": "gregory's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00587-00172160-00173687": "special daddy my special", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00588-00173688-00174111": "live on stream i will not stand for this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00589-00174112-00174319": "i have been disrespected by you angus", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00590-00174320-00174487": "and bald before you will not let that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00591-00174488-00174671": "stand", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00592-00174672-00175119": "what have i done", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00593-00175120-00175559": "stick bug no i got stick parked", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00594-00175560-00175663": "what makes you think stepping out of", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00595-00175664-00175807": "spawn would be the best idea when", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00596-00175808-00176023": "there's people literally pointing at the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00597-00176024-00176287": "spawn oh jeep i'm sorry i thought i was", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00598-00176288-00176431": "trying to i thought i was supposed to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00599-00176432-00176663": "get more turf you know like the game is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00600-00176664-00176943": "called before i was going to say you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00601-00176944-00177351": "need patience", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00602-00177352-00177607": "just a sprott roller", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00603-00177608-00177735": "grout if you're the biggest [__] ever", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00604-00177736-00177902": "i'm just like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00605-00177903-00178102": "did you just say uh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00606-00178103-00178390": "a bad no-no word female dog no that's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00607-00178391-00178775": "not that's not a swear come on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00608-00178776-00179126": "dude", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00609-00179127-00179250": "no don't you no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00610-00179251-00180893": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00611-00180894-00182338": "[Laughter]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00612-00182339-00182638": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00613-00182639-00183741": "all right so far so happy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00614-00183742-00184887": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00615-00184888-00185247": "thank", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00616-00185248-00187190": "he's gonna go with the splash isn't he", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00617-00187191-00187369": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00618-00187370-00187959": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00619-00187960-00188326": "[__] a breakfast pizza you can eat pizza", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00620-00188327-00188478": "for breakfast", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00621-00188479-00188885": "a world has opened to me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00622-00188886-00190217": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00623-00190218-00190502": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00624-00190503-00190702": "this very stream and trust me you'll be", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00625-00190703-00191054": "able to rewind and find it said", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00626-00191055-00191335": "what a bunch", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00627-00191336-00191559": "that is your announcement for today i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00628-00191560-00191775": "mean i must confess i don't really like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00629-00191776-00192695": "it", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00630-00192696-00194590": "what", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00631-00194591-00194902": "what was that [__] noise what the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00632-00194903-00195102": "[__]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00633-00195103-00195254": "i'm just here making all the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00634-00195255-00195478": "questionable sounds at this point dude", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00635-00195479-00195687": "this editing video is going to be 99", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00636-00195688-00195863": "like you making fun of yourself do you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00637-00195864-00195966": "want to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00638-00195967-00196143": "buy your dance shane i'm playing a game", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00639-00196144-00196375": "i can't voice crack and a half that's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00640-00196376-00196647": "disturbing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00641-00196648-00196878": "what's disturbing uh that i was that i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00642-00196879-00197023": "was saying that's a voice crack and a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00643-00197024-00197302": "half and you finished my sentence oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00644-00197303-00197487": "wait whoa oh wait what were you saying", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00645-00197488-00197711": "beforehand were you not even aware that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00646-00197712-00197950": "you were doing it i closed my room did", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00647-00197951-00198207": "you close your room i guess uh my room", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00648-00198208-00198431": "is not open wait", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00649-00198432-00198614": "are you making the room", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00650-00198615-00198871": "no i was i said you had to make the room", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00651-00198872-00199579": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00652-00199580-00202950": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00653-00202951-00203311": "i'm sorry what did you just say so okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00654-00203312-00203463": "there's there's this disease right which", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00655-00203464-00203663": "turns your your people", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00656-00203664-00204263": "oh oh very interesting", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00657-00204264-00204407": "i great if you know what you do better", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00658-00204408-00204575": "hearing aids oh wait you don't even have", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00659-00204576-00204775": "hearing aids everyone your attention", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00660-00204776-00205094": "please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00661-00205096-00205390": "make we come together to give mpd award", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00662-00205391-00205694": "of most sick burden existence", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00663-00205696-00205919": "for you need a better hearing aid i mean", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00664-00205919-00206086": "wait you don't really have a hearing aid", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00665-00206087-00206310": "but you need a better one everyone", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00666-00206311-00206406": "please", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00667-00206407-00206614": "something ever", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00668-00206615-00206966": "in celebration as epi has lost its final", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00669-00206967-00207214": "brain cell we have two grisco blasters", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00670-00207215-00207462": "we have a roller and we have it's called", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00671-00207463-00207742": "a splat roller actually yeah but if", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00672-00207744-00207942": "you're going to give the bingo blasters", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00673-00207944-00208142": "uh the actual brand the weapon is you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00674-00208144-00208310": "should give the sprawl or a full name", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00675-00208311-00208446": "too it's uh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00676-00208448-00208598": "good talk everyone", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00677-00208600-00208966": "shut the [__] up", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00678-00208967-00209086": "everyone", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00679-00209087-00209271": "right ears so happy what did you always", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00680-00209271-00209447": "say nothing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00681-00209448-00209638": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00682-00209639-00209831": "what you got against these hands we bird", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00683-00209832-00210087": "come on what you got against these hands", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00684-00210088-00210287": "huh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00685-00210288-00210479": "okay oh there's so much there's so much", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00686-00210480-00210646": "going on there's so much going on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00687-00210648-00210775": "there's so much going on there's so much", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00688-00210776-00210894": "going on there's so much going on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00689-00210896-00211126": "there's so much going on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00690-00211127-00211806": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00691-00211807-00212055": "i'm just gonna get used to the patterns", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00692-00212056-00212191": "i gotta get used to the patterns that's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00693-00212192-00212319": "what i gotta do i gotta get used to the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00694-00212319-00212446": "pattern so i don't miss any of the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00695-00212448-00212582": "arrows but the problem is my reaction", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00696-00212583-00212860": "time sucks and i ever said", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00697-00212861-00213455": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00698-00213456-00213703": "turning this [__] on easy mode", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00699-00213704-00213838": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00700-00213839-00214063": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00701-00214064-00214551": "oh my god that was intense i never felt", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00702-00214552-00214742": "right", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00703-00214744-00214934": "i don't care about lefts and rights i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00704-00214935-00215071": "thought this was a challenge come on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00705-00215071-00215382": "woody what you got", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00706-00215383-00215631": "okay he's still going he's still going", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00707-00215632-00215767": "ignore what i said there that was a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00708-00215767-00215967": "taunt that was a weak taunt this is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00709-00215967-00216110": "normal difficulty it feels like easy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00710-00216111-00216334": "mode all over again i might be speaking", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00711-00216335-00216471": "to you soon though maybe i'm gonna eat", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00712-00216471-00216975": "my words eventually", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00713-00216976-00217153": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00714-00217154-00217303": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00715-00217304-00217391": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00716-00217392-00217710": "okay i'm eating my word", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00717-00217711-00217823": "all right ladies and gentlemen we're", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00718-00217823-00218119": "back with freaking easy mode feel free", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00719-00218119-00218246": "to call me a failure all you want", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00720-00218248-00218375": "because there's no way in hell i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00721-00218376-00218615": "beating that slogan", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00722-00218616-00218855": "this is easy mode how bad can this be", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00723-00218856-00219255": "it's still pretty bad regardless", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00724-00219256-00219567": "what the [__] you're in the void my own", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00725-00219567-00219887": "special prison", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00726-00219888-00220031": "yeah we're perfectly fine with this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00727-00220032-00220303": "let's rename ourselves to um", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00728-00220304-00220479": "actually what do i want to rename myself", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00729-00220480-00220623": "to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00730-00220623-00221015": "there we go eppy the legendary name the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00731-00221016-00221382": "legendary eppy about to climb down the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00732-00221383-00221679": "climb down climb up the mountain to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00733-00221680-00221791": "victory", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00734-00221792-00222006": "we're climbing mount everest today oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00735-00222007-00222239": "man surely nothing will go wrong okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00736-00222240-00222558": "the trail is falling down by me no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00737-00222559-00222823": "becky thought my tail was big becca used", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00738-00222823-00223191": "to let me smash your walls", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00739-00223192-00223342": "did i peek my mic", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00740-00223344-00223494": "i keep forgetting how", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00741-00223496-00223671": "i keep forgetting how amazing the music", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00742-00223671-00223767": "is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00743-00223767-00224039": "like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00744-00224040-00224134": "let me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00745-00224135-00224411": "grab this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00746-00224412-00224615": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00747-00224616-00225039": "hey sorry i'm well epp why i'd say you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00748-00225040-00225279": "come to the right place why is that so", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00749-00225280-00225446": "funny i don't know how i'm doing this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00750-00225448-00225598": "but i'm doing it it's probably because i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00751-00225600-00225687": "played the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00752-00225688-00225879": "i'm here to get you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00753-00225880-00226094": "i go back to that clip you saw my hair", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00754-00226096-00226887": "touching that that was just bs", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00755-00226888-00227191": "okay yeah this is going to be a pain", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00756-00227192-00227375": "oh come on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00757-00227376-00227967": "boom", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00758-00227967-00228223": "i will take that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00759-00228223-00228431": "no i keep forgetting you can't go to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00760-00228432-00228615": "wherever she goes because that's where", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00761-00228616-00229294": "you going", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00762-00229296-00229551": "that was close that was close that was", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00763-00229552-00229742": "close oh there's three of you that's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00764-00229744-00229934": "good to see that's really good there's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00765-00229935-00230215": "three parts of me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00766-00230216-00230471": "i can't go that way no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00767-00230471-00230758": "sucker there's something up here aha", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00768-00230759-00230951": "there is something up here i knew what", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00769-00230952-00231167": "my headphones were falling off", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00770-00231167-00231398": "what is up with maria's face", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00771-00231400-00231758": "that's the smuggest face i've ever seen", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00772-00231759-00232087": "whoa", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00773-00232088-00232382": "yes my favorite song in splatoon history", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00774-00232383-00232694": "bomb rush blush you gotta love it", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00775-00232694-00233575": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00776-00233576-00233734": "oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00777-00233735-00233927": "yes", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00778-00233928-00234423": "oh wait no um", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00779-00234423-00235806": "i muted", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00780-00235807-00235927": "you know i would love to say the name of", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00781-00235928-00236223": "the song but it's very unfamily friendly", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00782-00236223-00236398": "and i would rather not risk getting", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00783-00236400-00236734": "demonetized oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00784-00236735-00236839": "okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00785-00236840-00237055": "let's do it okay what's better than", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00786-00237056-00237231": "having one marina", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00787-00237232-00237487": "oh yeah two marinas you're sitting on", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00788-00237488-00237623": "the speaker but i don't know which one's", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00789-00237623-00237887": "talking to me is it you or you oh my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00790-00237888-00238839": "ah agent 8 is ready to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00791-00238840-00239439": "where am i you're in the pits of hell", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00792-00239440-00240582": "here we", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00793-00240583-00240830": "literally the first race and you're so", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00794-00240831-00241046": "far behind my not so great but i'm in", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00795-00241048-00241310": "12th place", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00796-00241311-00241982": "you're all the way there", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00797-00241983-00242187": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00798-00242188-00242687": "wow controller", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00799-00242688-00242798": "he's like this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00800-00242800-00242934": "these [__]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00801-00242935-00243198": "exactly that's me right now", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00802-00243200-00245046": "rocks no i got shots get on the way", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00803-00245048-00245198": "i need to accept these lovely friend", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00804-00245200-00245551": "requests hey contendo", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00805-00245552-00245894": "contendo", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00806-00245896-00245982": "yo", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00807-00245983-00246151": "okay there you are would like to tell", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00808-00246152-00246271": "the stream about how the time you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00809-00246271-00246482": "mistaken an ostrich as a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00810-00246483-00246615": "flamingo no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00811-00246616-00246830": "no no no no no were you about to sing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00812-00246831-00247103": "the among us theme we'll just say no oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00813-00247104-00247487": "my god no no no no no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00814-00247488-00247582": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00815-00247583-00247871": "no no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00816-00247871-00248687": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00817-00248688-00250734": "yes", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00818-00250735-00250894": "how do you feel if you were to play with", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00819-00250896-00251063": "one joycon do you think that would help", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00820-00251064-00251230": "you but that's not gonna work that's not", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00821-00251231-00251439": "gonna work which one has the drift", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00822-00251440-00251663": "exactly both", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00823-00251664-00251927": "how are you not depressed yet", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00824-00251928-00252239": "are you in nintendo yeah yeah i'm matt", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00825-00252240-00252406": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00826-00252407-00252519": "freaking colleagues me is just like", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00827-00252519-00252630": "looking around like why is everyone", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00828-00252631-00252830": "changing to defaults who the [__] is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00829-00252831-00253103": "player on red", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00830-00253104-00253439": "okay so who's matt and matt is this epi", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00831-00253440-00253687": "and nintendo", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00832-00253688-00253887": "looks the most accurate i guess they", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00833-00253888-00254151": "both look accurate i'm trying to set the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00834-00254152-00254382": "scenes i can't even okay who do i play", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00835-00254383-00254606": "is it the top of the bottom one", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00836-00254607-00254903": "not to talk it to each other", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00837-00254904-00255039": "now i'm happy i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00838-00255040-00255398": "[__] [__] who did that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00839-00255400-00255919": "say i'm happy", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00840-00255919-00256175": "bless you oh you got for oh i want to", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00841-00256176-00256591": "see a reissue wait [__]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00842-00256592-00256767": "never do that again today i'm making the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00843-00256767-00256951": "most life-changing splatoon video that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00844-00256952-00257175": "you'll ever see on this channel and that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00845-00257176-00257303": "is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00846-00257304-00257582": "changing my hairstyle", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00847-00257583-00257687": "oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00848-00257688-00257903": "you know what name one splatoon content", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00849-00257904-00258087": "creator that wears this hairstyle we're", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00850-00258088-00258727": "gonna do great we are going to win this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00851-00258728-00258975": "okay fine i'll just go to surfboards", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00852-00258976-00259271": "jesus okay clash blaster was a bad idea", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00853-00259271-00259519": "you can't do that you cannot do that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00854-00259519-00259775": "you can't do that i can do this i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00855-00259776-00260015": "popping your soda bottles i am too", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00856-00260016-00260391": "incapable of using the clash as proof by", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00857-00260392-00260751": "face my clash okay i'm dirty sounded", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00858-00260752-00260951": "relevant this is the worst decision i've", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00859-00260952-00261087": "ever made in my life i'm gonna pull a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00860-00261088-00261375": "sneaky real quick", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00861-00261376-00261567": "when you try to pull sneaky but you feel", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00862-00261567-00261742": "absolutely miserably let me try this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00863-00261744-00263227": "again", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00864-00263228-00263503": "oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00865-00263504-00263599": "wait", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00866-00263600-00263871": "dude what what the cafe the cafe the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00867-00263872-00264006": "rails", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00868-00264007-00264206": "okay hey i think i have a reason to play", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00869-00264207-00264503": "animal crossing again yay brewster oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00870-00264504-00267423": "this is low polish", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00871-00267424-00267839": "no not yet it's splatoon", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00872-00267840-00268149": "i'm just going to be quiet now", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00873-00268150-00268358": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00874-00268359-00269727": "look at the invite my eyes", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00875-00269728-00269958": "we've been waiting forever we are eating", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00876-00269959-00270279": "good tonight so", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00877-00270280-00270439": "here we are you can't really find the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00878-00270440-00270775": "comment there but you can take my word", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00879-00270776-00270910": "can you get the [__] out of the frame", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00880-00270911-00271103": "come on both water you're disgusting", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00881-00271104-00271239": "because you're pulled people probably", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00882-00271240-00271399": "beat in you but you know that's besides", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00883-00271400-00271630": "the ball i'm not going to spam cl i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00884-00271631-00271775": "not going to squint back anybody oh my", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00885-00271776-00271934": "gosh i'm not gonna squint back anyone", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00886-00271935-00272110": "like the toxic", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00887-00272111-00272343": "noob that i was but instead i will treat", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00888-00272344-00272510": "everyone with dignity", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00889-00272511-00272647": "and respect", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00890-00272648-00272767": "and care", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00891-00272768-00272951": "because everyone deserves to feel that", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00892-00272952-00273279": "way get the [__] out of here i see it", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00893-00273280-00273510": "i could sir you have no right to booya", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00894-00273511-00273727": "and we lost late you just lost all your", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00895-00273728-00273991": "effort villages i i just i [__] i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00896-00273992-00274134": "will kill you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00897-00274135-00274367": "i will follow you down before me", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00898-00274368-00274503": "literally you're the one that was", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00899-00274504-00274767": "standing like this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00900-00274768-00274919": "of course have to look down at you if", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00901-00274920-00275009": "you're gonna", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00902-00275010-00275255": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00903-00275256-00275606": "dude you have scoliosis", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00904-00275607-00276030": "where are you there you are", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00905-00276031-00276263": "do i have a tiny head yes or no no you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00906-00276264-00276519": "look like uh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00907-00276520-00276719": "yeah we might need to leave the game oh", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00908-00276720-00276903": "and we're just booging up in the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00909-00276904-00277151": "background", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00910-00277152-00277510": "hello camera how are you doing oh no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00911-00277511-00277615": "they're gone", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00912-00277616-00278061": "you look like chris grass", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00913-00278062-00278191": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00914-00278192-00278406": "it literally says optional objectives i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00915-00278407-00278591": "guess can you read", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00916-00278592-00279383": "but if you do the optional objective", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00917-00279384-00279806": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00918-00279807-00279982": "what are they doing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00919-00279983-00280239": "i look at the [__] right here", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00920-00280240-00280501": "look at the [__]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00921-00280502-00281055": "[Laughter]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00922-00281056-00282429": "it's the ghost spanish", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00923-00282430-00284319": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00924-00284320-00284951": "see ceiling see", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00925-00284952-00285271": "it's through your hands", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00926-00285272-00285543": "you can press g to drop it you know", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00927-00285544-00286218": "thank you", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00928-00286219-00286647": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00929-00286648-00286727": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00930-00286728-00286823": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00931-00286824-00286910": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00932-00286911-00287006": "no", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00933-00287007-00287175": "no give me your flashlight i guess i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00934-00287176-00287351": "guess i guess do you want me to i want i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00935-00287352-00288333": "want i want this flashlight", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00936-00288334-00289191": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00937-00289192-00289583": "to come to the garage", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00938-00289584-00290394": "[Applause]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00939-00290395-00290442": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00940-00290443-00290927": "[Applause]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00941-00290928-00291355": "i found a ouija board", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00942-00291356-00292687": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00943-00292688-00292910": "standing next to me i we both heard the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00944-00292911-00293127": "ghosts my cameras are glitching i'm", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00945-00293128-00294143": "leaving i'm driving this truck away", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00946-00294144-00294319": "oh god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00947-00294320-00294503": "a flashlight a flashlight is a", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00948-00294504-00294710": "flashlight guys listen a flashlight is", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00949-00294711-00294919": "50 bucks", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00950-00294920-00295134": "i i don't think any of us have 50 bucks", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00951-00295135-00295287": "let's just let's just start a new game", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00952-00295288-00295447": "i'm sure a lot of people remember the", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00953-00295448-00295630": "story mode from splatoon 1 where they go", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00954-00295631-00295815": "through levels one by one and encounter", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00955-00295816-00295999": "dangerous foes like the elite octoling", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00956-00296000-00296206": "who's totally not gonna have an f mod", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00957-00296207-00296391": "based around them", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00958-00296392-00296671": "oh you're joking what if i'm slow at", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00959-00296672-00296871": "like you know tapping buttons i mean i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00960-00296872-00297175": "suppose i'm not designed i'm okay i", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00961-00297176-00297310": "should shut up", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00962-00297311-00297510": "i can't see what she's doing", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00963-00297511-00298271": "wait what the [__] wait what happens", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00964-00298272-00298732": "okay right right up left right okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00965-00298733-00298951": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00966-00298952-00299071": "okay", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00967-00299072-00299303": "no what the [__] is this", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00968-00299304-00299727": "this is this is stupid", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00969-00299728-00300430": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00970-00300431-00300606": "oh my god", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00971-00300607-00300917": "fine away", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00972-00300918-00301710": "[Music]", "S2QMMaCJL4E-00973-00301711-00302011": "bye"}}, {"audio_id": "S344dnnhBvQ", "text": {"S344dnnhBvQ-00000-00001492-00002410": "so", "S344dnnhBvQ-00001-00002411-00003404": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00002-00003404-00003999": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00003-00004000-00004171": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00004-00004172-00004326": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00005-00004327-00004754": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00006-00004755-00005683": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00007-00005684-00005863": "so", "S344dnnhBvQ-00008-00005864-00005900": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00009-00005901-00006246": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00010-00006247-00006289": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00011-00006290-00006833": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00012-00006834-00006863": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00013-00006864-00007016": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00014-00007017-00007048": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00015-00007050-00007390": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00016-00007391-00007436": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00017-00007437-00007773": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00018-00007773-00007823": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00019-00007825-00008022": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00020-00008023-00008208": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00021-00008209-00008483": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00022-00008484-00008588": "so", "S344dnnhBvQ-00023-00008589-00008800": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00024-00008801-00008976": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00025-00008977-00009504": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00026-00009505-00012940": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00027-00012941-00013043": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00028-00013044-00013769": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00029-00013771-00013812": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00030-00013813-00014446": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00031-00014447-00014580": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00032-00014581-00015441": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00033-00015443-00015800": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00034-00015801-00015999": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00035-00016000-00016182": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00036-00016183-00016981": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00037-00016982-00017226": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00038-00017227-00017425": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00039-00017426-00018131": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00040-00018132-00018804": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00041-00018805-00019085": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00042-00019086-00019188": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00043-00019189-00019683": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00044-00019684-00019956": "so", "S344dnnhBvQ-00045-00019957-00020621": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00046-00020622-00020724": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00047-00020725-00021083": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00048-00021084-00021298": "so", "S344dnnhBvQ-00049-00021299-00022157": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00050-00022158-00022483": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00051-00022484-00022644": "so", "S344dnnhBvQ-00052-00022645-00023693": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00053-00023694-00023883": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00054-00023884-00024181": "so", "S344dnnhBvQ-00055-00024182-00025437": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00056-00025438-00026073": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00057-00026074-00026720": "[Music]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00058-00026720-00027039": "[Applause]", "S344dnnhBvQ-00059-00027039-00027247": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S3BXB9-snWU", "text": {"S3BXB9-snWU-00000-00000768-00001215": "since this is a hot topic all over the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00001-00001216-00001412": "world I'm sure that that will also be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00002-00001413-00001737": "the case here so at the end of my", "S3BXB9-snWU-00003-00001738-00001948": "presentation you can send in your", "S3BXB9-snWU-00004-00001950-00002493": "questions on paper but if you also we", "S3BXB9-snWU-00005-00002494-00002775": "can also give you a microphone for you", "S3BXB9-snWU-00006-00002776-00003129": "to ask your questions here in the floor", "S3BXB9-snWU-00007-00003130-00003377": "and try to be brief so that we can take", "S3BXB9-snWU-00008-00003378-00003688": "as many questions as possible I", "S3BXB9-snWU-00009-00003689-00004172": "coordinated centers seer body that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00010-00004173-00004529": "provides free information to journalists", "S3BXB9-snWU-00011-00004530-00005182": "but there is also free access to the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00012-00005183-00005411": "information on the website for the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00013-00005412-00005848": "general public this is the link", "S3BXB9-snWU-00014-00005849-00006445": "www.professormesser.com and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00015-00006447-00007662": "www.redcross.org spot.com right in the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00016-00007663-00008139": "text for this talk I realized that I", "S3BXB9-snWU-00017-00008140-00008412": "wouldn't have enough time to read it all", "S3BXB9-snWU-00018-00008413-00009332": "so tomorrow on this side I will the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00019-00009333-00009969": "original talk in its full version and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00020-00009970-00010215": "here I'm going to try to share with you", "S3BXB9-snWU-00021-00010216-00010530": "a summary a synthesized version so that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00022-00010531-00010785": "I can stick to the time allotted to me", "S3BXB9-snWU-00023-00010786-00011322": "usually I don't read my talks but in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00024-00011323-00011598": "this case I made any solution and I'm", "S3BXB9-snWU-00025-00011599-00012135": "going to read because I have to say it's", "S3BXB9-snWU-00026-00012136-00012662": "extremely important so I would rather", "S3BXB9-snWU-00027-00012663-00013083": "you chose some words without making a", "S3BXB9-snWU-00028-00013084-00013565": "mistake", "S3BXB9-snWU-00029-00013566-00013897": "I have four very good pieces of news to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00030-00013899-00014563": "give to you that have the potential to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00031-00014565-00015097": "make a change for the better in the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00032-00015099-00015437": "world as we know it and this sets a new", "S3BXB9-snWU-00033-00015438-00015830": "paradigms a new way of looking and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00034-00015831-00016261": "thinking about politics economics and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00035-00016262-00016723": "the organization of society by way of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00036-00016724-00017162": "introductions we are going to watch two", "S3BXB9-snWU-00037-00017163-00018800": "short two-minute videos into a cognitive", "S3BXB9-snWU-00038-00018801-00019237": "system and you won't even realize hello", "S3BXB9-snWU-00039-00019238-00019934": "hello Amelia 17 State Street yes that's", "S3BXB9-snWU-00040-00019935-00020177": "right robots are coming out of the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00041-00020178-00020381": "factories their fourth revolution has", "S3BXB9-snWU-00042-00020382-00020714": "already started and infusing all types", "S3BXB9-snWU-00043-00020715-00020957": "of increasingly efficient or an", "S3BXB9-snWU-00044-00020958-00021326": "autonomous machine a mainly a total wave", "S3BXB9-snWU-00045-00021327-00021611": "available it can keep several", "S3BXB9-snWU-00046-00021612-00021782": "conversations at the same time at a", "S3BXB9-snWU-00047-00021783-00022034": "professional level every day of the year", "S3BXB9-snWU-00048-00022035-00022346": "at any time during the day or not the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00049-00022347-00022652": "master technological way that is most", "S3BXB9-snWU-00050-00022653-00022922": "reliable and cheaper than human beings", "S3BXB9-snWU-00051-00022923-00023162": "has created a revolution in full", "S3BXB9-snWU-00052-00023163-00023438": "employment this can lead to the loss of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00053-00023439-00023747": "millions of jobs in any sector an", "S3BXB9-snWU-00054-00023748-00023960": "unprecedented situation is going to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00055-00023961-00024701": "happen in the labor market what happened", "S3BXB9-snWU-00056-00024702-00025157": "with the video so what about the world", "S3BXB9-snWU-00057-00025158-00025385": "of technology their statistics are quite", "S3BXB9-snWU-00058-00025386-00025649": "worrisome because it seems that robot", "S3BXB9-snWU-00059-00025650-00025958": "please listen to this robots could", "S3BXB9-snWU-00060-00025958-00026294": "eliminate jobs by 2025 only six years", "S3BXB9-snWU-00061-00026295-00026480": "from now robots in the world could", "S3BXB9-snWU-00062-00026481-00026654": "eliminate", "S3BXB9-snWU-00063-00026655-00027069": "75 million Charles that is why yesterday", "S3BXB9-snWU-00064-00027070-00027324": "we tell that we need to consider all the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00065-00027325-00027515": "new programs and new professions and we", "S3BXB9-snWU-00066-00027516-00027639": "also need to consider this information", "S3BXB9-snWU-00067-00027639-00027987": "yes that's right and five years later in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00068-00027988-00028526": "by 2030 800 million jobs will be lost", "S3BXB9-snWU-00069-00028527-00028787": "here you can see it on the screen that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00070-00028788-00029244": "is at least the word is claimed but IT", "S3BXB9-snWU-00071-00029245-00029493": "experts from the Oxford University or", "S3BXB9-snWU-00072-00029494-00029879": "World Bank economists who are making", "S3BXB9-snWU-00073-00029880-00030189": "alarming statements with these data some", "S3BXB9-snWU-00074-00030189-00030402": "of the jobs are higher levels of risk", "S3BXB9-snWU-00075-00030402-00030627": "are those that involve physical activity", "S3BXB9-snWU-00076-00030627-00030923": "in factories industrial sector perhaps", "S3BXB9-snWU-00077-00030924-00031514": "bricklayers machines are taking care of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00078-00031516-00031719": "many of these activities experts say", "S3BXB9-snWU-00079-00031720-00032096": "that the programs of Education that will", "S3BXB9-snWU-00080-00032097-00032325": "be more popular would be data analyst", "S3BXB9-snWU-00081-00032326-00032652": "design managers experts on social", "S3BXB9-snWU-00082-00032652-00032886": "intelligence programmers and software", "S3BXB9-snWU-00083-00032887-00033201": "developers companies are going to look", "S3BXB9-snWU-00084-00033202-00033573": "for those professions in the US there", "S3BXB9-snWU-00085-00033574-00033879": "are already forecasts for change in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00086-00033880-00034296": "their university syllabus and curricula", "S3BXB9-snWU-00087-00034297-00034560": "to move more to the technological side", "S3BXB9-snWU-00088-00034561-00034860": "experts say that robots take very little", "S3BXB9-snWU-00089-00034861-00035169": "space they don't get sick they don't", "S3BXB9-snWU-00090-00035170-00035556": "need to negotiate wages every year they", "S3BXB9-snWU-00091-00035557-00035817": "don't submit claims there is no MBO", "S3BXB9-snWU-00092-00035818-00036021": "competition against their fellow robots", "S3BXB9-snWU-00093-00036022-00036255": "that is what companies say those that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00094-00036256-00036446": "are looking into the situation and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00095-00036447-00036720": "forecast their job losses for the next", "S3BXB9-snWU-00096-00036721-00036821": "10 to 20 years", "S3BXB9-snWU-00097-00036822-00037142": "yes exactly no less than 20 years tenure", "S3BXB9-snWU-00098-00037143-00037794": "in our TV station we see this in our", "S3BXB9-snWU-00099-00037795-00038040": "country is ranked 17th of the best", "S3BXB9-snWU-00100-00038041-00038325": "country as one of the better prepare to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00101-00038326-00038550": "receive this kind of technology compared", "S3BXB9-snWU-00102-00038551-00038826": "to Mexico Colombia Brazil so Argentina", "S3BXB9-snWU-00103-00038827-00039048": "is already using this kind of machine so", "S3BXB9-snWU-00104-00039049-00039306": "we'll start soon with the sole pluses", "S3BXB9-snWU-00105-00039307-00040114": "for instance", "S3BXB9-snWU-00106-00040115-00040511": "in the first video from the Spanish", "S3BXB9-snWU-00107-00040512-00040999": "televisions only so one minute I don't", "S3BXB9-snWU-00108-00041000-00041195": "know why I stopped after one minute was", "S3BXB9-snWU-00109-00041196-00041387": "because Australia was so 2 minute video", "S3BXB9-snWU-00110-00041388-00041671": "the remaining portion that we didn't see", "S3BXB9-snWU-00111-00041672-00041924": "spoke about something very important", "S3BXB9-snWU-00112-00041925-00042146": "that is that many people think that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00113-00042147-00042779": "basic income is utopia but it is lesser", "S3BXB9-snWU-00114-00042780-00043252": "utopia than promising jobs that is what", "S3BXB9-snWU-00115-00043253-00043481": "the video says that promising that there", "S3BXB9-snWU-00116-00043482-00043820": "will be jobs will be more utopian than", "S3BXB9-snWU-00117-00043821-00044096": "thinking about a basic income on the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00118-00044097-00044408": "second video we saw the news from a TV", "S3BXB9-snWU-00119-00044409-00044845": "show in Argentina and they said that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00120-00044846-00045386": "according to forecasts there will be 75", "S3BXB9-snWU-00121-00045387-00045620": "million people displaced from their jobs", "S3BXB9-snWU-00122-00045621-00045980": "and 5 years later by 2030 800 million", "S3BXB9-snWU-00123-00045981-00046393": "jobs would be lost so look at the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00124-00046394-00046700": "exponential growth of labour", "S3BXB9-snWU-00125-00046701-00047071": "displacement so what would happen in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00126-00047072-00047624": "five years after 2030 perhaps we would", "S3BXB9-snWU-00127-00047625-00047914": "have 80 or 90 percent of the world", "S3BXB9-snWU-00128-00047915-00048320": "population jobless that could be a valid", "S3BXB9-snWU-00129-00048321-00049039": "question as I told you before this party", "S3BXB9-snWU-00130-00049040-00049421": "many could think that this is a negative", "S3BXB9-snWU-00131-00049422-00049780": "aspect or a negative situation but this", "S3BXB9-snWU-00132-00049781-00050433": "gives us grounds to share with you four", "S3BXB9-snWU-00133-00050434-00050987": "significant pieces of news as regards", "S3BXB9-snWU-00134-00050988-00051220": "the future evolution of the world in the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00135-00051221-00051463": "next coming years the first piece of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00136-00051464-00051733": "news is that new technologies apply to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00137-00051734-00052258": "labour especially robots AI and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00138-00052259-00052533": "automation", "S3BXB9-snWU-00139-00052534-00052855": "allow for an increase of production and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00140-00052857-00053163": "research a considerable reduction in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00141-00053164-00053529": "costs every year these technologies are", "S3BXB9-snWU-00142-00053529-00054054": "enhanced that rating the product", "S3BXB9-snWU-00143-00054054-00054348": "production capability all over the world", "S3BXB9-snWU-00144-00054349-00054582": "that is good more production at a lower", "S3BXB9-snWU-00145-00054583-00054882": "cost the second good piece of news is", "S3BXB9-snWU-00146-00054883-00055671": "that the new technology is over super", "S3BXB9-snWU-00147-00055672-00055929": "production capability to produce more", "S3BXB9-snWU-00148-00055929-00056274": "food stuffs more drugs more homes more", "S3BXB9-snWU-00149-00056275-00056666": "clothes for the first time in history of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00150-00056667-00057375": "humankind will make it possible for each", "S3BXB9-snWU-00151-00057376-00057732": "state to provide to each of its", "S3BXB9-snWU-00152-00057733-00058128": "inhabitants from the moment they are", "S3BXB9-snWU-00153-00058129-00058416": "born throughout their life until they", "S3BXB9-snWU-00154-00058416-00058863": "die every month an income in the form of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00155-00058864-00059129": "money and services to allow that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00156-00059130-00059520": "individual to live decent life without", "S3BXB9-snWU-00157-00059521-00060191": "lacking any of the basic elements to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00158-00060191-00060975": "live a dignified life this will bring", "S3BXB9-snWU-00159-00060976-00061263": "about an end to poverty poverty that has", "S3BXB9-snWU-00160-00061264-00061536": "existed for so many years would come to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00161-00061537-00061959": "an end this income would be given to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00162-00061960-00062196": "those who work on those who don't work", "S3BXB9-snWU-00163-00062197-00062636": "those who want to work and make salary", "S3BXB9-snWU-00164-00062637-00063227": "would get this additional basic income", "S3BXB9-snWU-00165-00063228-00063570": "in addition to the salary this income is", "S3BXB9-snWU-00166-00063571-00064187": "known as the unconditioned basic income", "S3BXB9-snWU-00167-00064188-00064449": "universal basic income that can be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00168-00064450-00064761": "applied to any country regardless of its", "S3BXB9-snWU-00169-00064762-00065330": "model capitalistic socialist model the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00170-00065332-00065801": "third piece of news is", "S3BXB9-snWU-00171-00065802-00066548": "that implementation of basic income is", "S3BXB9-snWU-00172-00066549-00067061": "politically feasible indispensable and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00173-00067062-00067644": "unavoidable many proposals to improve", "S3BXB9-snWU-00174-00067645-00068070": "the world failed over time they never", "S3BXB9-snWU-00175-00068071-00068351": "got to fruition because they were", "S3BXB9-snWU-00176-00068352-00068745": "politically unfeasible they encountered", "S3BXB9-snWU-00177-00068746-00069033": "a strong opposition from many sectors in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00178-00069034-00069267": "this case the universal basic income", "S3BXB9-snWU-00179-00069268-00069546": "will be accepted by all economic sectors", "S3BXB9-snWU-00180-00069547-00069834": "the most powerful ones and the least", "S3BXB9-snWU-00181-00069835-00070323": "powerful because if these are income not", "S3BXB9-snWU-00182-00070324-00070659": "accepted all individuals will be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00183-00070660-00070944": "affected and companies would close down", "S3BXB9-snWU-00184-00070945-00071526": "or they would size down because they", "S3BXB9-snWU-00185-00071527-00072135": "would have no consumers the system for", "S3BXB9-snWU-00186-00072136-00072348": "that would make it possible for", "S3BXB9-snWU-00187-00072349-00072675": "businesses to exist and to have a profit", "S3BXB9-snWU-00188-00072676-00072978": "we'll need to have consumers so this", "S3BXB9-snWU-00189-00072979-00073233": "will lead to a crisis of consumption", "S3BXB9-snWU-00190-00073234-00073425": "that will have negative effects for all", "S3BXB9-snWU-00191-00073426-00074144": "but in addition to that there will be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00192-00074145-00074517": "lack of governance as a result of the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00193-00074518-00074853": "political and social crisis derive from", "S3BXB9-snWU-00194-00074854-00075299": "unemployment and poverty and exclusion", "S3BXB9-snWU-00195-00075300-00075771": "countries would not be gather levels the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00196-00075772-00076169": "Oxford University and the World Bank", "S3BXB9-snWU-00197-00076170-00076659": "shared the results of some of their", "S3BXB9-snWU-00198-00076660-00077019": "research studies and these illustrate", "S3BXB9-snWU-00199-00077020-00077412": "and also supplement the focus by other", "S3BXB9-snWU-00200-00077413-00077745": "experts and they say that between 50 to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00201-00077746-00078093": "80 percent of jobs will be replaced by", "S3BXB9-snWU-00202-00078094-00078469": "new technology by 2050", "S3BXB9-snWU-00203-00078470-00078784": "and in their reports they break down", "S3BXB9-snWU-00204-00078785-00079098": "this information on a country-by-country", "S3BXB9-snWU-00205-00079099-00079351": "basis to give you some examples they say", "S3BXB9-snWU-00206-00079352-00079765": "that in the US 47 percent of people will", "S3BXB9-snWU-00207-00079766-00080098": "lose their jobs in Argentina 65 percent", "S3BXB9-snWU-00208-00080099-00080575": "in India 69 in China 77 percent of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00209-00080576-00080839": "people will lose their jobs if states do", "S3BXB9-snWU-00210-00080840-00081163": "not provide so-called universal basic", "S3BXB9-snWU-00211-00081164-00081819": "income the lack of governance will be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00212-00081820-00082237": "effect so the universal basic income as", "S3BXB9-snWU-00213-00082238-00082687": "a proposal is having for the first time", "S3BXB9-snWU-00214-00082688-00082939": "in the history of humankind across the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00215-00082940-00083190": "world support from people from all", "S3BXB9-snWU-00216-00083191-00083575": "sectors the business sector and the way", "S3BXB9-snWU-00217-00083576-00083782": "Turner said so the rich and the poor", "S3BXB9-snWU-00218-00083783-00084049": "people from the left and people from the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00219-00084050-00084544": "right universal basic income benefits", "S3BXB9-snWU-00220-00084545-00085048": "all because there is no other proposal", "S3BXB9-snWU-00221-00085049-00085368": "put forward by any other sector that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00222-00085369-00085779": "identifies how this expected", "S3BXB9-snWU-00223-00085780-00085990": "unemployment situation could be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00224-00085991-00086608": "addressed the new types of jobs that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00225-00086609-00086893": "could be created and that do not exist", "S3BXB9-snWU-00226-00086894-00087145": "nowadays and that we ignore what they", "S3BXB9-snWU-00227-00087146-00087574": "could be so far in most of the cases we", "S3BXB9-snWU-00228-00087575-00087835": "should expect these jobs not to be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00229-00087836-00088140": "handled by human beings but rather by", "S3BXB9-snWU-00230-00088141-00088882": "automated systems and robots the first", "S3BXB9-snWU-00231-00088883-00089371": "good piece of news is that these these", "S3BXB9-snWU-00232-00089372-00089700": "technologies have a super production", "S3BXB9-snWU-00233-00089701-00090058": "capability of goods and services the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00234-00090059-00090337": "second good piece of news is that thanks", "S3BXB9-snWU-00235-00090338-00090691": "to that large volume of production they", "S3BXB9-snWU-00236-00090692-00090952": "can provide to all individuals what they", "S3BXB9-snWU-00237-00090953-00091231": "need to meet their needs in terms of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00238-00091232-00091660": "money and goods the third good piece of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00239-00091661-00091816": "news is that this is Anna", "S3BXB9-snWU-00240-00091817-00092053": "because politically this is the only", "S3BXB9-snWU-00241-00092054-00092350": "option available no matter who likes it", "S3BXB9-snWU-00242-00092351-00092671": "or doesn't like it there is no potential", "S3BXB9-snWU-00243-00092672-00092944": "opposition because right now in the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00244-00092945-00093413": "world there is no other viable proposal", "S3BXB9-snWU-00245-00093414-00093874": "to provide a solution to this situation", "S3BXB9-snWU-00246-00093875-00094030": "that doesn't take into account their", "S3BXB9-snWU-00247-00094031-00094287": "basic income but I told you that there", "S3BXB9-snWU-00248-00094288-00094522": "is a fourth good piece of news and that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00249-00094523-00095080": "is one that is specially targeted to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00250-00095081-00095236": "Argentinian those who live in this", "S3BXB9-snWU-00251-00095237-00095542": "country Argentina has optimal conditions", "S3BXB9-snWU-00252-00095543-00095797": "to be the first country in the world to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00253-00095798-00096346": "implement basic income and that put an", "S3BXB9-snWU-00254-00096347-00096574": "end to poverty in the country it would", "S3BXB9-snWU-00255-00096575-00096805": "have the economic and political support", "S3BXB9-snWU-00256-00096806-00097111": "of all sectors because the world is", "S3BXB9-snWU-00257-00097112-00097354": "interested in running a test in a", "S3BXB9-snWU-00258-00097355-00097786": "specific country to see the benefits of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00259-00097787-00098106": "this basic income us the only possible", "S3BXB9-snWU-00260-00098107-00098532": "way of avoiding the crisis that we", "S3BXB9-snWU-00261-00098533-00098751": "described earlier then other countries", "S3BXB9-snWU-00262-00098752-00099050": "other countries would follow this", "S3BXB9-snWU-00263-00099051-00099313": "Argentina is potentially one of the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00264-00099314-00099442": "richest countries in the world", "S3BXB9-snWU-00265-00099443-00099709": "considering its natural resources its", "S3BXB9-snWU-00266-00099710-00100194": "vast territory it has solar energy wind", "S3BXB9-snWU-00267-00100195-00100510": "energy capabilities it has gas and oil", "S3BXB9-snWU-00268-00100511-00100804": "reserves and an abundance of minerals it", "S3BXB9-snWU-00269-00100805-00101059": "has the largest reserves of lithium in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00270-00101060-00101479": "the world it has fresh water and it has", "S3BXB9-snWU-00271-00101480-00101892": "an invaluable wealth in it", "S3BXB9-snWU-00272-00101893-00102463": "submarine platform shelf and they are", "S3BXB9-snWU-00273-00102464-00102699": "her only 16 inhabitants per square", "S3BXB9-snWU-00274-00102700-00103099": "kilometer the United States at 36 Spain", "S3BXB9-snWU-00275-00103100-00103734": "93 France 122 China 146 Italy 207", "S3BXB9-snWU-00276-00103735-00104553": "Germany 234 UK 270 Japan 336 India 441", "S3BXB9-snWU-00277-00104554-00104877": "so once again Argentina only has 16", "S3BXB9-snWU-00278-00104878-00105175": "inhabitants per square kilometer", "S3BXB9-snWU-00279-00105176-00105615": "the our children people wants and me to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00280-00105616-00106104": "look for new ways to address its huge", "S3BXB9-snWU-00281-00106105-00106327": "economic problems so it is convenient", "S3BXB9-snWU-00282-00106328-00106560": "for the artisan people to look into this", "S3BXB9-snWU-00283-00106561-00106831": "proposal to be the first country in the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00284-00106832-00107200": "world to implement the universal basic", "S3BXB9-snWU-00285-00107201-00107509": "income system for all its inhabitants", "S3BXB9-snWU-00286-00107510-00107713": "[Music]", "S3BXB9-snWU-00287-00107714-00108084": "rulers may choose this path or not one", "S3BXB9-snWU-00288-00108085-00108378": "of the people is aware of its existence", "S3BXB9-snWU-00289-00108379-00108703": "every artist has to decide what is best", "S3BXB9-snWU-00290-00108704-00109095": "to continue complaining about the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00291-00109096-00109393": "situation in the country or demand that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00292-00109394-00109714": "this alternative be looked into and this", "S3BXB9-snWU-00293-00109715-00110061": "baited the sooner the debate start the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00294-00110063-00110407": "better for the country now thinking", "S3BXB9-snWU-00295-00110408-00110644": "about the needs that sooner or later", "S3BXB9-snWU-00296-00110645-00110848": "this basic income will have to be", "S3BXB9-snWU-00297-00110849-00111178": "implemented experiment has to be to take", "S3BXB9-snWU-00298-00111179-00111352": "place in different countries Finland", "S3BXB9-snWU-00299-00111353-00111700": "Germany Japan Canada Mexico the u.s.", "S3BXB9-snWU-00300-00111701-00112132": "Namibia Kenya Mexico thousands of people", "S3BXB9-snWU-00301-00112133-00112416": "we are given this income as a test to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00302-00112417-00112702": "see the change in behaviors and the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00303-00112703-00112981": "results were quite good most of the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00304-00112982-00113511": "people use their time to do things that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00305-00113513-00113661": "were useful for them and for the society", "S3BXB9-snWU-00306-00113663-00113926": "they improve their health status and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00307-00113927-00114178": "their ability to study there was a", "S3BXB9-snWU-00308-00114179-00114496": "significant reduction in crime rates and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00309-00114497-00114745": "stress levels and they continued", "S3BXB9-snWU-00310-00114746-00115190": "performing paid jobs at a lower level", "S3BXB9-snWU-00311-00115191-00115588": "than the general population countries", "S3BXB9-snWU-00312-00115589-00115758": "need to be encouraged to start", "S3BXB9-snWU-00313-00115759-00116026": "implementing this basic income system", "S3BXB9-snWU-00314-00116027-00116572": "gradually to avoid the crisis of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00315-00116573-00117078": "unemployment to affect them seriously", "S3BXB9-snWU-00316-00117079-00117424": "leaving hundreds of millions of people", "S3BXB9-snWU-00317-00117425-00117960": "in debt and poverty the only that's all", "S3BXB9-snWU-00318-00117961-00118254": "factors that the population will have", "S3BXB9-snWU-00319-00118255-00118449": "information about", "S3BXB9-snWU-00320-00118450-00118683": "some cons of this system is beneficial", "S3BXB9-snWU-00321-00118683-00118929": "for society because they can open their", "S3BXB9-snWU-00322-00118930-00119210": "minds to a new proposal a proposal that", "S3BXB9-snWU-00323-00119211-00119534": "is different from those the incumbent", "S3BXB9-snWU-00324-00119535-00119817": "ones to see how life can be organized", "S3BXB9-snWU-00325-00119818-00120126": "differently how the economy in a society", "S3BXB9-snWU-00326-00120127-00120357": "can be organized differently last year", "S3BXB9-snWU-00327-00120358-00120591": "there were two important developments I", "S3BXB9-snWU-00328-00120592-00120825": "would call them historical developments", "S3BXB9-snWU-00329-00120826-00121032": "in the evolution of the concept of the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00330-00121033-00121422": "universal basic income that showed the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00331-00121423-00121596": "world that from an economic standpoint", "S3BXB9-snWU-00332-00121597-00121848": "it is feasible and necessary to", "S3BXB9-snWU-00333-00121849-00122256": "implement this basic income one of the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00334-00122257-00122514": "developments happened on January the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00335-00122515-00123276": "23rd of last year with even advice from", "S3BXB9-snWU-00336-00123277-00123606": "economic experts the Parliamentary", "S3BXB9-snWU-00337-00123607-00123830": "Assembly of the Council of Europe", "S3BXB9-snWU-00338-00123831-00124317": "adopted a historical resolution with a", "S3BXB9-snWU-00339-00124318-00124865": "majority of the vote of the legislators", "S3BXB9-snWU-00340-00124866-00125208": "approved this resolution recommending", "S3BXB9-snWU-00341-00125208-00125640": "all European states to look into the way", "S3BXB9-snWU-00342-00125641-00125940": "to adequately implement the universal", "S3BXB9-snWU-00343-00125941-00126161": "basic income in their own country the", "S3BXB9-snWU-00344-00126163-00126474": "other historical event happened in", "S3BXB9-snWU-00345-00126475-00126741": "September last year at the opening of", "S3BXB9-snWU-00346-00126742-00127175": "the 73rd session of the United Nations", "S3BXB9-snWU-00347-00127176-00127571": "the secretary-general Antonio Guterres", "S3BXB9-snWU-00348-00127572-00127869": "in his remarks made the same", "S3BXB9-snWU-00349-00127870-00128079": "recommendation to all countries around", "S3BXB9-snWU-00350-00128080-00128928": "the world so out of time so as I said", "S3BXB9-snWU-00351-00128929-00129386": "initially on the website that I showed", "S3BXB9-snWU-00352-00129388-00129699": "you you will find all the rationale and", "S3BXB9-snWU-00353-00129700-00130251": "further details about the topic because", "S3BXB9-snWU-00354-00130252-00130452": "I didn't have enough time to go through", "S3BXB9-snWU-00355-00130453-00130859": "them here thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "S3IZ1XTxyHU", "text": {"S3IZ1XTxyHU-00000-00000062-00000233": "thank you Peter for all these", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00001-00000234-00000688": "suggestions so far this morning in this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00002-00000689-00000923": "topic of the first 20 years of economic", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00003-00000924-00001232": "and monetary union we've had to I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00004-00001233-00001487": "very rich presentations about DC B's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00005-00001488-00001904": "monetary policy and we've also had the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00006-00001905-00002171": "rave scene presentations by Jean and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00007-00002172-00002480": "discussion by Shabnam on convergence so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00008-00002481-00002681": "no doubt in this panel will return to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00009-00002682-00002933": "these topics but my guess is we'll also", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00010-00002934-00003224": "visit at many other topics in this very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00011-00003225-00003458": "broad agenda about economic and monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00012-00003459-00003736": "union I think when we have a calendar", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00013-00003738-00004036": "like 20 years I think there's always", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00014-00004037-00004254": "going to be three parts to do discussion", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00015-00004255-00004490": "one is at understanding what actually", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00016-00004491-00004852": "happened two is at think about the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00017-00004853-00005066": "counterfactual of what would have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00018-00005067-00005293": "happened with the euro but with a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00019-00005294-00005527": "different institutional framework and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00020-00005528-00005924": "then the third of course always is what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00021-00005925-00006101": "would have happened without the euro and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00022-00006102-00006295": "in the President's speech earlier on you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00023-00006296-00006569": "know the kind of factual of life without", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00024-00006570-00006737": "the euro it is always interesting to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00025-00006738-00007001": "think about of course there's also that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00026-00007002-00007381": "the temptation given the euro was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00027-00007383-00007580": "founded 20 years ago to say everything", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00028-00007581-00007831": "that happened last 20 years was due to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00029-00007833-00008120": "the euro so part of the challenge for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00030-00008120-00008456": "the panel will be to differentiate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00031-00008457-00008685": "between all of the events that happened", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00032-00008686-00008963": "whether that's the rise of emerging", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00033-00008964-00009251": "markets like China whether is the global", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00034-00009252-00009478": "financial cycle including the crisis", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00035-00009479-00009760": "whether is the role of demography and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00036-00009761-00010217": "technology driving the low movement in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00037-00010218-00010621": "in the R star whether the change in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00038-00010622-00010778": "European Union through the entry of new", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00039-00010779-00011027": "member states or whether even it's just", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00040-00011028-00011321": "simply the spectacular rise and fall and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00041-00011322-00011594": "rise and fall in a price of oil which is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00042-00011595-00011767": "really working behind a lot of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00043-00011768-00012139": "monetary policy discussion so happy by 1", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00044-00012140-00012302": "p.m. all of this would be sort of that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00045-00012303-00012571": "by this exceptional panel so the format", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00046-00012572-00012866": "is each of the other panelists will make", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00047-00012866-00013166": "an initial short presentation and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00048-00013166-00013307": "they've all been very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00049-00013308-00013615": "they've given me exact timing of their", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00050-00013616-00013916": "interventions we then will have a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00051-00013916-00014126": "discussion including I hope many", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00052-00014127-00014300": "interesting questions from the floor", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00053-00014301-00015154": "so Lawrence over to you thanks thanks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00054-00015155-00015472": "it's obviously super difficult to talk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00055-00015474-00015809": "about after Peter both because of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00056-00015810-00016034": "depth of the analysis and because he's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00057-00016035-00016283": "got so many anecdote on an incredible", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00058-00016284-00016664": "talent for for speaking so I will be a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00059-00016665-00016877": "lot shorter and that will be one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00060-00016878-00017132": "difference and what I will try to you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00061-00017133-00017351": "leveraging on what you've presented is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00062-00017352-00017807": "make a distinction between what we can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00063-00017808-00018011": "ascribe to policy in terms of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00064-00018012-00018206": "performance and how this is to be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00065-00018207-00018578": "distinguished from from the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00066-00018579-00018887": "institutional framework so I will pass", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00067-00018888-00019151": "over this very quickly but it is to say", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00068-00019152-00019490": "I think it's very important that we make", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00069-00019491-00019706": "this difference because we won't correct", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00070-00019707-00020060": "police mistakes with reform to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00071-00020061-00020344": "institution and conversely will not be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00072-00020345-00020552": "able to make better policies when the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00073-00020553-00020987": "real issue is about institution so I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00074-00020988-00021293": "will go through the real fiscal monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00075-00021294-00021560": "and financial aspect and let me start", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00076-00021561-00021997": "with the real one so it's just word to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00077-00021998-00022400": "say that in terms of trying to close the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00078-00022401-00022715": "gap with the u.s. it has been a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00079-00022716-00022934": "challenge and a lot has been said about", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00080-00022935-00023219": "the first ten years of the Euro so I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00081-00023220-00023483": "won't get into there but what I would", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00082-00023484-00023729": "like to highlight is how much it has the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00083-00023730-00023918": "gap with the nine or is the best", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00084-00023919-00024206": "performing countries which are not in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00085-00024207-00024511": "the euro has stabilized and I'd probably", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00086-00024512-00024839": "highlighting a lack of structural", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00087-00024840-00025028": "reforms even so they were quite a lot of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00088-00025029-00025409": "efforts during the crisis and one of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00089-00025410-00025649": "main two lines freedom was designed at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00090-00025650-00025972": "the beginning of EMU for adjustment with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00091-00025973-00026158": "real adjustment and that's the first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00092-00026160-00026476": "point I would like to make", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00093-00026477-00026727": "is when you look at this slide you can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00094-00026728-00027148": "see that the countries which had wider", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00095-00027149-00027430": "deficit a widening deficit in the first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00096-00027431-00027768": "ten years of the Euro actually undertook", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00097-00027769-00028110": "a very strong wage price adjustment and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00098-00028111-00028479": "corrected this current account imbalance", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00099-00028480-00028893": "but conversely we could say that it was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00100-00028894-00029070": "very much one-sided because the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00101-00029072-00029302": "countries that had expanded current", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00102-00029302-00029587": "account surplus have not gone through", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00103-00029588-00029883": "the same type of adjustment and actually", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00104-00029884-00030154": "the wage price evolution has been much", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00105-00030155-00030439": "more muted so the first thing is we were", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00106-00030439-00030601": "relying a lot on this wage price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00107-00030602-00030907": "adjustment in a in a currency union and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00108-00030908-00031111": "I think it's fair to say that it's been", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00109-00031112-00031570": "at best one-sided second thing is is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00110-00031570-00031980": "going to fiscal policy and a lot has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00111-00031981-00032274": "been said here so I will focus on a few", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00112-00032275-00032574": "points but one very positive one is in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00113-00032575-00033031": "2009 do you like the u.s. actually and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00114-00033032-00033217": "indeed especially there was a concerted", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00115-00033218-00033460": "effort for a very large synchronized", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00116-00033461-00033805": "stimulus and that shows that the you can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00117-00033806-00034065": "really act with force when it decides to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00118-00034066-00034435": "do so then we enter the period of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00119-00034436-00034698": "fiscal tightening that Peter mentioned", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00120-00034699-00034999": "and I think we should analyze that in it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00121-00035000-00035199": "was in part largely explained by the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00122-00035200-00035505": "sequence of sovereign downgrades that we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00123-00035506-00035842": "were going through so obviously with the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00124-00035843-00036133": "benefit of insight it was a synchronized", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00125-00036134-00036451": "mistake on both sides of the Atlantic", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00126-00036452-00036720": "given where the output gap where but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00127-00036721-00036945": "perhaps would was more specific to the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00128-00036946-00037257": "euro was that the adjustment took place", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00129-00037258-00037510": "while the ad output gap was still", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00130-00037511-00037755": "widening whereas if you look at the US", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00131-00037756-00037957": "on the right-hand side the output gap", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00132-00037958-00038227": "was already shrinking or started to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00133-00038228-00038530": "shrink and I think part of the reason is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00134-00038531-00038871": "that in the euro area the adjustment was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00135-00038872-00039112": "wound at the individual country level", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00136-00039113-00039414": "and did not take into account spillovers", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00137-00039415-00039714": "that would be that would form a euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00138-00039715-00039802": "area why", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00139-00039803-00040306": "it stands a lot has been said of about", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00140-00040307-00040522": "the wounds and how they constraint the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00141-00040523-00040744": "individual country adjustment and a lot", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00142-00040745-00040921": "more will be said by the panel so I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00143-00040922-00041164": "won't get into this because what I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00144-00041165-00041326": "really want to focus on ian is the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00145-00041327-00041620": "coordination and reforming the rules", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00146-00041621-00041823": "will actually not address this issue of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00147-00041824-00042244": "coordination which in turn and Peter", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00148-00042245-00042511": "mention it as well as Olivia yesterday", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00149-00042512-00043015": "has hindered stabilization when some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00150-00043016-00043312": "countries like fiscal space and when the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00151-00043313-00043648": "economy is weak euro area fiscal stance", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00152-00043649-00043888": "which is exclusively driven by rules", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00153-00043889-00044095": "focusing on individual countries", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00154-00044096-00044365": "situation it's very likely to deliver", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00155-00044366-00044713": "insufficient support first do you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00156-00044714-00045058": "overall your stance may not be enough to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00157-00045059-00045352": "stabilize the euro area as well and even", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00158-00045353-00045583": "for individual countries it may not be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00159-00045584-00045807": "enough because there will be leakages", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00160-00045808-00046249": "across countries in addition to this the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00161-00046250-00046444": "absence or the lack of coordination", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00162-00046445-00046678": "increases the likelihood of adverse", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00163-00046679-00046957": "market reaction and we've seen that in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00164-00046958-00047236": "the first part of the crisis and the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00165-00047237-00047422": "Jackson Hole speech by Maya Draghi", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00166-00047423-00047758": "actually mentioned it and conversely", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00167-00047759-00048043": "obviously if coordination can create", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00168-00048044-00048268": "fiscal space because it's strengthening", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00169-00048269-00048604": "confidence in the capacity of the region", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00170-00048605-00049063": "to address shock and what I like to add", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00171-00049064-00049288": "is not only a euro fiscal capacity can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00172-00049289-00049597": "make coordination simpler but it we also", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00173-00049598-00049917": "ensure a stabilization we put response", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00174-00049918-00050176": "commensurate to the shock or the demand", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00175-00050177-00050596": "gap so that's for fiscal policy and let", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00176-00050597-00050950": "me now move to the monetary part if I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00177-00050951-00051175": "they're given everything that has been", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00178-00051176-00051439": "said this morning so I will just focus", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00179-00051440-00051733": "on a very few points first one liquidity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00180-00051734-00051961": "provision I think it's fair to say that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00181-00051962-00052275": "the ECB has provided ample liquidity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00182-00052276-00052579": "fulfill this one of last of lender of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00183-00052579-00052833": "last resort to banks for various means", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00184-00052834-00053058": "even so we had the 20", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00185-00053059-00053565": "episode that Peter mentioned now from", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00186-00053566-00053784": "the outside and as a former market", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00187-00053785-00054276": "participant the SMP did not appear as a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00188-00054277-00054582": "nuclear weapon to markets because of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00189-00054583-00054911": "self-imposed size limits ex ante and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00190-00054912-00055224": "also become collateral policy was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00191-00055225-00055419": "dependent on rating which turn out to be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00192-00055420-00055746": "political and that has contributed to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00193-00055747-00055977": "destabilize the surrendered market at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00194-00055978-00056304": "the time and it took until December 2012", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00195-00056304-00056511": "that we mentioned several times for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00196-00056512-00056910": "ECB to appear as the pillar of the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00197-00056911-00057354": "area stability turning towards more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00198-00057354-00057654": "monetary side early in the crisis then", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00199-00057654-00057909": "Peter mentioned we can say that interest", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00200-00057910-00057978": "with Heights", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00201-00057979-00058254": "again with the benefit of inside we're a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00202-00058254-00058728": "mistake and it took until 2015 for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00203-00058729-00059010": "ECB to move into QE on top of the larger", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00204-00059011-00059228": "liquidity support and get Eve rights", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00205-00059229-00059496": "what the Fed had started QE on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00206-00059497-00059748": "largest AG scale more than four years", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00207-00059749-00060186": "before this has several implication but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00208-00060187-00060339": "first it means that monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00209-00060340-00060629": "accommodation was not only early in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00210-00060630-00060885": "US but it was also larger throughout the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00211-00060886-00061229": "episode of fiscal tightening and it I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00212-00061230-00061488": "mention how the macro framework was a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00213-00061489-00061854": "lot tighter in the eurozone so what what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00214-00061854-00062298": "can be the institutional reasons behind", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00215-00062299-00062675": "this I think one source of delay is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00216-00062676-00062867": "consensus-building and sometimes even", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00217-00062869-00063174": "unanimity building on that probably is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00218-00063175-00063392": "under that understandable when when a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00219-00063394-00063612": "central bank is as young as what the ECB", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00220-00063613-00063873": "was but there were signs of this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00221-00063874-00064089": "tensions which were reflected in legal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00222-00064090-00064425": "cases bought about against the ECB and I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00223-00064426-00064824": "was probably not helpful and this may", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00224-00064825-00065073": "have delayed a large enough consensus", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00225-00065074-00065329": "for delivering QE", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00226-00065330-00065625": "another source of delay I think was the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00227-00065626-00065883": "very complex political relationship with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00228-00065884-00065969": "90", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00229-00065970-00066251": "fiscal authorities as opposed to one in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00230-00066252-00066557": "the US and you will remember that it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00231-00066558-00066902": "took DTSC G for the ECB to move in LTL", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00232-00066903-00067193": "and it took the package of fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00233-00067194-00067481": "compact post banking Union plus GSM for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00234-00067482-00067888": "the ECB to move into QE so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00235-00067889-00068123": "consensus-building as as we were saying", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00236-00068124-00068456": "when necessary especially when the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00237-00068457-00068726": "fiscal response was so hesitant and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00238-00068727-00068903": "Peter again mentioned the necessity of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00239-00068904-00069293": "of political support it's an additional", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00240-00069294-00069539": "argument why having a fiscal entity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00241-00069540-00069788": "responsible for a euro fiscal stance", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00242-00069789-00070067": "would give a lot more clarity to the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00243-00070068-00070289": "central bank in times of crisis and make", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00244-00070290-00070667": "it a normal interlocutor in most of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00245-00070668-00070991": "times this one additional point that we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00246-00070992-00071213": "could mention which is that the Fed has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00247-00071214-00071510": "actually employment as a second leg or", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00248-00071511-00071747": "as permanent and objective as inflation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00249-00071748-00072124": "and to be fair if the ECB had this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00250-00072125-00072464": "objective as permanent as inflation then", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00251-00072465-00072776": "we will probably critics would have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00252-00072777-00072992": "probably more time because this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00253-00072993-00073255": "objective has been more than", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00254-00073256-00073709": "satisfactorily achieved so that's for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00255-00073710-00074026": "monetary policy and now I will move to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00256-00074027-00074368": "financial policy which is the third", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00257-00074369-00074822": "angle of adjustment well it has been", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00258-00074823-00075149": "said before do you zoom banks didn't", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00259-00075150-00075305": "clean up their balance sheet and we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00260-00075306-00075602": "capitalized as fast as necessary and we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00261-00075603-00075752": "just have to remember that some stress", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00262-00075753-00075956": "tests were passed and a few weeks later", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00263-00075957-00076313": "they were bank failures I think one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00264-00076314-00076490": "important point as well is that when the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00265-00076491-00076760": "new financial regime was voted there was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00266-00076761-00077009": "no transition to speed up and help", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00267-00077010-00077201": "balance sheet cleaning and with the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00268-00077202-00077506": "benefit of insider with an issue and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00269-00077507-00077786": "persistently encumber balance sheet of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00270-00077787-00078032": "banks today and the low profitability is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00271-00078033-00078286": "also a hindrance to monetary policy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00272-00078287-00078641": "transmission and again we have sealed so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00273-00078642-00078886": "when bang Nexus which which prevails", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00274-00078887-00079080": "so looking", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00275-00079081-00079308": "the institutional side for financial", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00276-00079309-00079596": "Boise we have to remember that there was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00277-00079597-00079863": "no framework for banking Union our", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00278-00079864-00080139": "capital market Union until 2012 so that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00279-00080140-00080478": "was a big progress but conversely since", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00280-00080479-00080958": "then progress have stoled there is no", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00281-00080959-00081182": "common Deposit Guarantee or insurance", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00282-00081183-00081423": "arrangement there is an incomplete", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00283-00081424-00081633": "backstop and it's not large enough to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00284-00081634-00082026": "avoid national wing fencing supervision", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00285-00082027-00082251": "remains too much linked to the national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00286-00082252-00082461": "level for a large part of the banking", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00287-00082462-00082887": "sector macro prudential measures also", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00288-00082888-00083130": "are too decentralized to enhance a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00289-00083131-00083484": "credible unified framework the SRB has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00290-00083485-00083706": "few policy instruments on the pallet", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00291-00083707-00084060": "with recommendation or warnings the ECB", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00292-00084061-00084288": "can only used to that influence lenders", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00293-00084289-00084690": "behavior not Boras behavior the later", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00294-00084691-00084870": "remaining in the heads of national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00295-00084871-00085200": "authority and capital market unions", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00296-00085201-00085506": "making little progress and and to be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00297-00085507-00085734": "fair in addition to the absence of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00298-00085735-00085998": "fiscal restraint outside of for one then", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00299-00085999-00086262": "we have very limited private risk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00300-00086263-00086775": "sharing so I was appointed slippage of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00301-00086776-00087054": "two minutes so in 15 seconds I'm gonna", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00302-00087055-00087636": "sign up what I wanted to say I think we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00303-00087637-00087912": "have to manage that structural national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00304-00087913-00088092": "reforms and the European one are", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00305-00088093-00088251": "necessary but they probably not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00306-00088252-00088488": "sufficient when we are in a period like", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00307-00088489-00088773": "now and the completion of the single", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00308-00088774-00088920": "market will not solve all our problems", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00309-00088921-00089259": "we have to turn to it the other", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00310-00089260-00089610": "adjustment we see on the macro side I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00311-00089611-00089877": "think the main point is that monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00312-00089878-00090348": "policy alone cannot actually do the job", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00313-00090349-00090582": "by itself it needs the support of a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00314-00090583-00090903": "fiscal capacity and a fiscal single", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00315-00090904-00091364": "interlocutor that's super important also", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00316-00091365-00091743": "we were what Peter clawed diplomatically", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00317-00091744-00091977": "the clarification of monetary policy in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00318-00091978-00092268": "2003 I think we can safely ask for a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00319-00092269-00092414": "review of monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00320-00092415-00092756": "we framework now with all the new tools", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00321-00092757-00093095": "and the evolution of the eurozone for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00322-00093096-00093329": "fiscal I think it's super important that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00323-00093330-00093602": "we have coordination at the very minimum", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00324-00093603-00093884": "and to complement the individual rule", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00325-00093885-00094148": "and obviously a euro area budget for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00326-00094149-00094442": "stabilization would make everybody's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00327-00094443-00094786": "life easier and stabilization more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00328-00094787-00095291": "efficient and finally financial policy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00329-00095292-00095591": "as you've seen women so fragmented and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00330-00095592-00095843": "here I think there is an enormous task", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00331-00095844-00096122": "ahead of us the details of which I will", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00332-00096123-00096294": "spare you thank you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00333-00096295-00096887": "[Applause]", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00334-00096888-00097062": "[Applause]", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00335-00097063-00097792": "thank you next up is a Marcus thanks a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00336-00097793-00097897": "lot for having me back", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00337-00097898-00098181": "it's good to be back at Sentra talking", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00338-00098182-00098605": "about the last 20 years of the Euro so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00339-00098606-00098746": "there were a lot of successes in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00340-00098747-00098925": "last 20 years there was initial", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00341-00098926-00099166": "convergence the inclusion also I would", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00342-00099167-00099298": "like to mention more generally for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00343-00099299-00099444": "European Union of the Eastern and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00344-00099445-00099679": "Central European countries and there was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00345-00099680-00099916": "Christ ability like the deutsche mark", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00346-00099917-00100153": "had low inflation but of course there", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00347-00100154-00100326": "was some regional divergence in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00348-00100327-00100557": "inflation rates as well going on in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00349-00100558-00100863": "first decade of the euro there was huge", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00350-00100864-00101031": "progress on the banking Union but there", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00351-00101032-00101232": "also many challenges left and let me", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00352-00101233-00101440": "focus a little bit on the challenges and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00353-00101441-00101641": "as Peter pointed out I think one big", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00354-00101642-00101818": "challenge we have to overcome is that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00355-00101819-00102162": "which came really where we became aware", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00356-00102163-00102385": "in the euro crisis that there are very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00357-00102386-00102649": "different ways of thinking how to manage", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00358-00102650-00102997": "a eurozone or euro area and this reign", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00359-00102998-00103179": "divided which is often refer to as the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00360-00103180-00103438": "dividing line how to think about how to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00361-00103439-00103678": "manage a macro economy became there very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00362-00103679-00103959": "apparent so there the four dimensions at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00363-00103960-00104204": "least discussion was those rules", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00364-00104205-00104457": "solidarity was a liability principle", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00365-00104458-00104691": "very much moral hazard focused whenever", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00366-00104692-00104844": "there are financial problems is it a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00367-00104845-00105054": "liquidity problem or is it a solvency", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00368-00105055-00105256": "problem you know do you have to deal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00369-00105257-00105390": "with spill overs and bailouts is the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00370-00105391-00105628": "right thing to do or do you fail in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00371-00105629-00105836": "Keynesian stimulus and the austerity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00372-00105838-00106116": "reform agenda on the other side and I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00373-00106117-00106264": "think this is more broad it's not only", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00374-00106265-00106426": "Germany and France it's more broadly but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00375-00106427-00106621": "its most pronounced in the way of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00376-00106622-00106789": "thinking in Germany in France and most", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00377-00106790-00107008": "recently in also just came up and the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00378-00107008-00107340": "last debate the UE area budget do we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00379-00107341-00107488": "need this or do we have to focus much", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00380-00107489-00107668": "more on risk reduction and there's some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00381-00107669-00107944": "big disagreement on this dimensions as", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00382-00107945-00108186": "well as you know echo Finn just debated", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00383-00108188-00108376": "in recent weeks about that and you have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00384-00108377-00108568": "to find this little red thing should be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00385-00108569-00108913": "fine perches over these dividing ways of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00386-00108914-00109290": "how to run a macro economy and I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00387-00109291-00109450": "there's some progress being made and as", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00388-00109451-00109594": "also the recognition that there's this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00389-00109595-00109744": "difference in the way of thinking and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00390-00109745-00109903": "that's the first step in order to find", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00391-00109904-00109960": "some common", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00392-00109961-00110335": "ground the other challenge is that we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00393-00110336-00110611": "have limited monetary policies space we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00394-00110613-00110819": "have this effective lower bound or", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00395-00110820-00110999": "reversely interest rate if you cut into", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00396-00111000-00111164": "set below the river as Linda said it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00397-00111165-00111358": "becomes actually it reverses its power", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00398-00111359-00111515": "it's not a commodity of anymore it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00399-00111516-00111733": "becomes then contractionary and the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00400-00111734-00111998": "question is how low can you go and what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00401-00111999-00112307": "determines the effective lower bound and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00402-00112308-00112499": "there are different effects and the one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00403-00112500-00112664": "in mini cut the interest rate of the new", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00404-00112665-00112895": "Keynesian demand effect so you stimulate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00405-00112896-00113114": "them on that's a good thing for cutting", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00406-00113115-00113321": "interest rates and you also cause", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00407-00113322-00113564": "capital gains or long dated asset so if", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00408-00113565-00113765": "the banks have a lot of long dated", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00409-00113766-00113929": "assets on the balance sheets there's a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00410-00113930-00114104": "lot of maturity mismatch on the bank's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00411-00114105-00114310": "balance sheets then you cause a lot of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00412-00114311-00114524": "capital gains for the banks so maturity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00413-00114525-00114658": "mismatch on the bank's balance sheet is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00414-00114659-00114914": "good because you cut into sit and really", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00415-00114915-00115106": "create capital gains for the banks but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00416-00115107-00115384": "for all ongoing forward-looking business", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00417-00115385-00115607": "you have a negative effect from the net", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00418-00115608-00115804": "interest income so the net interest", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00419-00115805-00116033": "income for banks is going down so in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00420-00116033-00116318": "long run you actually hurt the banks so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00421-00116319-00116525": "this is Keynes and demand effects the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00422-00116526-00116771": "cab regains effects but then from the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00423-00116772-00116990": "ongoing business from new business going", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00424-00116991-00117029": "on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00425-00117030-00117326": "you have my way with lower interest", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00426-00117327-00117638": "margins and that hurts you and the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00427-00117639-00117869": "second question is then you know how low", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00428-00117870-00118049": "can you go we calculated this and this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00429-00118050-00118190": "reverse the interest rate paper with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00430-00118191-00118448": "young Kobe to a minus one percent so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00431-00118449-00118619": "roughly you can go up to minus one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00432-00118620-00118861": "percent but you cannot stay low for too", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00433-00118863-00119057": "long because there's a creeping up", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00434-00119058-00119216": "effect and why is that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00435-00119217-00119404": "the creeping up if that comes the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00436-00119405-00119606": "carrier gains effects come at one time", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00437-00119607-00119798": "you get these capital gains but then", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00438-00119799-00120089": "over time as time passes you only have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00439-00120090-00120239": "this negative effect coming in and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00440-00120240-00120599": "because the old assets mature and will", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00441-00120600-00120806": "be replaced with the new asset that's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00442-00120807-00121028": "whichever lower return because of this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00443-00121029-00121256": "low interest rate environment so this is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00444-00121257-00121472": "not specific to you earlier that's you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00445-00121473-00121625": "know at the global scale it's in Japan", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00446-00121626-00121883": "that's in the US and more generally and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00447-00121883-00122156": "that's something which requires you know", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00448-00122157-00122329": "some creative thinking how to get around", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00449-00122330-00122618": "these challenges that the multi policy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00450-00122619-00123008": "space is very limited so what's one way", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00451-00123008-00123251": "out one way out is to say an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00452-00123252-00123497": "these be moved this direction let's move", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00453-00123498-00123658": "away from focusing only on their", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00454-00123659-00123839": "interest rates let's focus on the risk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00455-00123840-00124040": "premium because what really matters at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00456-00124041-00124268": "the end of the day is the risk-free rate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00457-00124269-00124466": "the short-term rate then the long-term", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00458-00124467-00124654": "ability to UM spread and then the credit", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00459-00124655-00124976": "spread on top of it and what determines", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00460-00124977-00125195": "these spreads is some expected loss", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00461-00125196-00125408": "component which is really you know we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00462-00125408-00125651": "can't avoid that but there is premium", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00463-00125652-00125798": "you can affect and what's the risk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00464-00125799-00126053": "premium a risk premium consists of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00465-00126054-00126488": "price of a risk times the risk and the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00466-00126489-00126679": "risk itself is and divided in exogenous", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00467-00126680-00126908": "this exogenous shocks which cannot", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00468-00126908-00127106": "control and there's also an endogenous", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00469-00127107-00127331": "component to it so there's an XOR to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00470-00127332-00127558": "shock and then it's amplified through", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00471-00127559-00127757": "the endogenous channels amplification", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00472-00127758-00128083": "channels spirals runs and all these", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00473-00128084-00128333": "endogenous risk is emerging if you don't", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00474-00128333-00128540": "have set up your economy the right way", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00475-00128541-00128708": "and that's the question how can we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00476-00128708-00128860": "actually set up the economy in such a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00477-00128861-00129095": "way to can actually reduce Indulgence", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00478-00129096-00129293": "risk and when you reduce in dorchester", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00479-00129294-00129511": "risk you also reduce the price of risk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00480-00129513-00129815": "and that you know produces this demand", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00481-00129816-00129971": "that you can effect much more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00482-00129972-00130283": "effectively by doing the right things", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00483-00130283-00130408": "setting up the economy right when", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00484-00130409-00130625": "intervening also in terms of asset", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00485-00130626-00130907": "purchases at the right way and one way", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00486-00130908-00131266": "just one of out of many is to zoom in or", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00487-00131267-00131491": "to how do we need a safe asset design a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00488-00131492-00131756": "safe asset for the euro area to reduce", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00489-00131757-00131984": "this endogenous risk which is inherent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00490-00131985-00132166": "in the current architecture of the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00491-00132167-00132541": "zone so i would like to focus on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00492-00132542-00132782": "safe asset in particular because you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00493-00132783-00132941": "have this risk-on risk-off", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00494-00132942-00133202": "switches so the market is very volatile", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00495-00133203-00133379": "so you cannot really rely on the markets", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00496-00133380-00133529": "so much and also the price signals of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00497-00133530-00133676": "the market because the markets are miss", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00498-00133677-00133928": "switches from a risk under his or face", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00499-00133929-00134195": "and what the problem is once you switch", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00500-00134196-00134444": "to a risk off face suddenly all the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00501-00134445-00134660": "capital is rushing in to save assets and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00502-00134661-00134909": "if the safe acid is azimuth is applied", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00503-00134910-00135134": "by the core of the euro area then you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00504-00135135-00135326": "have this cross-border flows suddenly", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00505-00135327-00135578": "there's huge shift out of the peripheral", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00506-00135579-00135794": "countries to the core countries and that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00507-00135795-00135995": "destabilizes the whole system and that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00508-00135996-00136109": "destabilizes", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00509-00136110-00136349": "and creates endogenous risk which then", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00510-00136350-00136542": "exante's priced with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00511-00136543-00136779": "price of risk and that causes for a much", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00512-00136780-00136977": "higher risk premium there has to be some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00513-00136978-00137165": "structural reform in this dimension", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00514-00137166-00137490": "which you know in a coherent less", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00515-00137491-00137766": "intrusive way but reduces overall in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00516-00137767-00137982": "tortures risk in the system which then", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00517-00137983-00138153": "reduces the price of risk and things", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00518-00138154-00138393": "premier down because we can't do much on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00519-00138394-00138594": "a short-term interstate anymore so we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00520-00138595-00138780": "have to work on the risk dimension and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00521-00138781-00138984": "that's a thing to worry to go of course", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00522-00138985-00139161": "to save acid there's also a second", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00523-00139162-00139500": "dimension which you know many young", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00524-00139501-00139674": "economists will talk about this there's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00525-00139675-00139845": "some papers dedicated to that on the two", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00526-00139846-00140025": "more diabolic loop there's actually two", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00527-00140026-00140406": "loops making things worse once you go", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00528-00140407-00140709": "negative shock it's amplified and this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00529-00140710-00141033": "way now what's the other challenge the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00530-00141034-00141183": "third challenge is that you have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00531-00141184-00141333": "essentially if you focus on interstate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00532-00141334-00141519": "policy of a single monetary policy tool", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00533-00141520-00141815": "and but you have a very heterogeneous", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00534-00141816-00142185": "currency union and as I said the earlier", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00535-00142186-00142470": "the euro area fiscal budget there are", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00536-00142471-00142680": "very different philosophies there's you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00537-00142681-00142869": "know one philosophy were focusing very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00538-00142870-00143076": "much on that and let me just say on one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00539-00143077-00143291": "thing there is quite some fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00540-00143292-00143490": "amplification I learned yesterday the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00541-00143491-00143679": "European Investment Bank invested three", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00542-00143680-00144041": "and a billion euros in new projects and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00543-00144042-00144357": "it was part of cool finding of Chilean", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00544-00144358-00144597": "opinions oh but it's also in a sense of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00545-00144598-00144771": "Fisk intervention it's in none of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00546-00144772-00144936": "statistics but the opinion it's about", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00547-00144937-00145362": "what I think 2% of your area GDP which", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00548-00145363-00145662": "is a sizable you know countermeasure", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00549-00145663-00145860": "against financial crisis so it should be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00550-00145861-00146112": "included in the debate as well and as I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00551-00146113-00146265": "mentioned so monetary policy has limited", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00552-00146266-00146601": "space or we have no agreement what to do", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00553-00146602-00146826": "in the fiscal budget side and there's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00554-00146827-00146979": "some tensions again I think the big", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00555-00146980-00147219": "tensions are that on the one hand we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00556-00147220-00147480": "really put the accelerator on on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00557-00147481-00147696": "monetary policy we ezp that everything", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00558-00147697-00147900": "to stimulate the economy cut industries", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00559-00147901-00148122": "and many other measures but then on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00560-00148123-00148323": "prudential policy we put the brakes on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00561-00148324-00148524": "ok we said the bank's you know you have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00562-00148525-00148689": "to be way more careful the banks were", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00563-00148690-00148932": "cutting back on this so this way there's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00564-00148933-00149079": "inconsistencies there so on the one hand", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00565-00149080-00149289": "you really try to push the banks to go", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00566-00149290-00149526": "animal this thing because you get a very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00567-00149527-00149743": "low interest rate from holding", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00568-00149744-00150043": "on risky things and you should push them", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00569-00150044-00150247": "into more risky lending but then you put", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00570-00150248-00150390": "the potential measures on and said no no", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00571-00150391-00150583": "not into risky lending and that somehow", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00572-00150584-00150910": "not find a person consistent and on top", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00573-00150911-00151215": "of it there is also the heterogeneity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00574-00151216-00151515": "which requires entry for some not only", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00575-00151516-00151810": "nationally focused Mac potential", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00576-00151811-00151977": "approach but also some euro wide", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00577-00151978-00152308": "coordination on that so what's the way", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00578-00152309-00152466": "out on that and I think we should", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00579-00152467-00152659": "probably go away from saying Mac the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00580-00152660-00152886": "potential is purely think of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00581-00152887-00153223": "catechol buffer is purely an instrument", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00582-00153224-00153474": "to manage financial stability Mac and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00583-00153475-00153825": "potential policies basel can't", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00584-00153826-00154069": "physically bar find other things impact", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00585-00154070-00154270": "tremendously the macro economy can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00586-00154271-00154476": "stimulate the macro economy also take", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00587-00154477-00154732": "stimulus out of it and we should really", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00588-00154733-00155028": "see it as a tool as financial stability", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00589-00155029-00155335": "of course but also on top of it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00590-00155336-00155562": "stimulate the macro economy and of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00591-00155563-00155754": "course I am aware that the Tinbergen", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00592-00155755-00155961": "principle you know might be make this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00593-00155962-00156150": "challenging but there are many many", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00594-00156151-00156351": "market potential tools to manage that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00595-00156352-00156588": "and it should be considered as a tool", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00596-00156589-00156813": "also to manage the macro economy in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00597-00156814-00156985": "particular if you have very limited room", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00598-00156986-00157239": "on the monetary policy side and on top", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00599-00157240-00157456": "of it you can also manage Kitteridge in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00600-00157457-00157902": "18 as less so Lucas when this symposium", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00601-00157903-00158119": "was in 2010 I proposed that you really", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00602-00158120-00158379": "you can optimize a suboptimal currency", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00603-00158380-00158601": "area because you can fine-tune at the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00604-00158602-00158794": "regional level your market potential", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00605-00158795-00159007": "tools but of course it also requires", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00606-00159008-00159462": "some coordination at the euro area so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00607-00159463-00159762": "let me conclude so I think we had some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00608-00159763-00159978": "great early successes overall I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00609-00159979-00160287": "and a broad fill it for pointing this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00610-00160288-00160515": "out if we didn't have the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00611-00160516-00160779": "we also would probably have a crisis and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00612-00160780-00160977": "it might have been a much worse crisis", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00613-00160978-00161187": "and that's always forgotten I think -", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00614-00161188-00161352": "just blaming everything to Euro I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00615-00161353-00161700": "is not the right way to go the lot of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00616-00161701-00161961": "early successes there was a resilience", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00617-00161962-00162165": "through creativity we need additional", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00618-00162166-00162515": "creativity to find some resilience and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00619-00162516-00162807": "Mario Draghi speeches stands out on that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00620-00162808-00163053": "we have a lot of progress on the banking", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00621-00163054-00163191": "unions there's still some steps to be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00622-00163192-00163371": "done but we shouldn't ignore what has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00623-00163372-00163670": "been done big achievements and that the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00624-00163671-00163878": "tensions because we have different ways", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00625-00163879-00164049": "of thinking about the macro economies", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00626-00164050-00164268": "through this green divide you get the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00627-00164269-00164442": "challenges we have limited policy space", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00628-00164443-00164712": "on the monetary policy side we should", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00629-00164713-00164955": "focus much under this premier much more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00630-00164956-00165263": "reducing into or China's risk and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00631-00165264-00165480": "there's a challenge because we have this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00632-00165481-00165624": "monetary policy we put the accelerator", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00633-00165625-00165912": "on macro body to put the brakes on we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00634-00165913-00166185": "should see macro potential also as a way", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00635-00166186-00166350": "to stimulate the macro economy and that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00636-00166351-00166581": "also to do at the regional level can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00637-00166582-00166854": "also optimize the the currency here here", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00638-00166855-00167190": "as a whole and one big element to to do", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00639-00167191-00167472": "this reduce the overall endogenous is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00640-00167473-00167823": "the save asset component to bring the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00641-00167824-00167976": "indoor chance to this town and with it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00642-00167977-00168606": "or the time they display", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00643-00168607-00169152": "[Applause]", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00644-00169153-00169456": "next up Ricardo great well thank you for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00645-00169457-00169657": "having me when I was first given the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00646-00169658-00169885": "mission of trying to give a ten minute", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00647-00169886-00170098": "introduction on twenty years of the Euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00648-00170099-00170311": "I realized the first task had to be to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00649-00170312-00170596": "narrow down and so to narrow it what I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00650-00170597-00170896": "did was went in read what some of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00651-00170897-00171067": "reflections on the first tendency of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00652-00171068-00171310": "ten years of the euro had been precisely", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00653-00171311-00171520": "ten years ago and I think they're well", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00654-00171521-00171853": "captured by this quote from ass Peter", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00655-00171854-00172027": "John Claude Trichet at the time gave", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00656-00172028-00172249": "which was that the year is historic", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00657-00172250-00172408": "achievement in its first ten years have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00658-00172409-00172612": "been a success but more important than", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00659-00172613-00172750": "the verdict were the criteria that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00660-00172751-00173044": "jean-claude used ten years ago for its", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00661-00173045-00173242": "first criteria was the stability of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00662-00173243-00173398": "euro which he measured in terms of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00663-00173399-00173527": "anchoring of inflation in its", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00664-00173528-00173827": "expectations second the role of the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00665-00173828-00174082": "in terms of its use as a currency within", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00666-00174083-00174223": "the single European market both in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00667-00174224-00174469": "financial as well as trade transactions", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00668-00174470-00174718": "and third in terms of the institutions", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00669-00174719-00175090": "of the Euro meaning the ability of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00670-00175091-00175279": "ECB and the Euro system to focus on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00671-00175280-00175531": "price stability independently from", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00672-00175532-00175705": "fiscal authorities in other parts of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00673-00175706-00175897": "government I would compliment those", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00674-00175898-00176158": "though with an extra sentence from", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00675-00176159-00176407": "another one of the evaluators of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00676-00176408-00176557": "first ten years of the years in terms of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00677-00176558-00176737": "the policymakers in charge then this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00678-00176738-00176962": "case lukas papademos who said that the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00679-00176963-00177171": "year has been a resounding success and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00680-00177172-00177442": "pointed instead to its establish itself", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00681-00177443-00177658": "as a stable incredible currency the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00682-00177659-00177796": "second most important one in the world", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00683-00177797-00177994": "after the US dollar so you would modify", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00684-00177995-00178246": "the role if you want to be its", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00685-00178247-00178423": "importance not just within the eurozone", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00686-00178424-00178725": "but especially in the world so my", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00687-00178726-00179050": "strategy for the next nine minutes is to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00688-00179051-00179392": "copy their three criteria and evaluate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00689-00179393-00179554": "not the 20 years of the Euro but the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00690-00179555-00179752": "last ten years of the era that is to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00691-00179753-00179968": "what extent how is the euro performed in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00692-00179969-00180283": "terms of its stability role in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00693-00180284-00180709": "institutions looking at more of the last", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00694-00180710-00180865": "ten years so the first criteria", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00695-00180866-00181141": "stability that is the value of the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00696-00181142-00181396": "its real value how has it been affected", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00697-00181397-00181792": "by inflation and it's it was already", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00698-00181793-00182044": "mentioned in the speech before Mary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00699-00182045-00182182": "dragons wealth communities right peter", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00700-00182183-00182243": "prat", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00701-00182244-00182573": "that the mandate those are not demanded", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00702-00182574-00182720": "but the interpretation of the manner has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00703-00182721-00182888": "changed somewhat over the years in terms", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00704-00182889-00183128": "that it was before and in Fletcher", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00705-00183129-00183359": "between 0 and 2 percent over the medium", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00706-00183360-00183650": "and to then 2 percent or lower over the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00707-00183651-00183824": "medium run to more recently perhaps", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00708-00183825-00184139": "symmetric 2% over the medium run and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00709-00184140-00184394": "note how the common parts here are 2%", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00710-00184395-00184796": "and medium run that as the ECB has been", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00711-00184797-00185008": "throughout its history committed to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00712-00185009-00185381": "price stability over a medium or medium", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00713-00185382-00185615": "run horizon that is unlike other", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00714-00185616-00185903": "inflation targeting central bank's DCB", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00715-00185904-00186116": "has always been what is nowadays perhaps", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00716-00186117-00186356": "called an average inflation target err", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00717-00186357-00186581": "or what in the monetary posture gets", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00718-00186582-00186800": "closer to a price level target err when", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00719-00186801-00186977": "matters inflation over a medium and over", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00720-00186978-00187175": "average of five seven years or whatnot", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00721-00187176-00187508": "therefore the criteria is that gray line", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00722-00187509-00187718": "that Peter represented that is would", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00723-00187719-00187940": "would it be a price level target or an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00724-00187941-00188144": "average inflation target or an inflation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00725-00188145-00188372": "target over a medium run of two percent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00726-00188373-00188615": "since its creation and over the ten", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00727-00188616-00188792": "years like jean-claude had had known in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00728-00188793-00188984": "his speech the euro has been extremely", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00729-00188985-00189254": "successful insofar as it almost exactly", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00730-00189255-00189571": "hit the 2% gray line in January of 2009", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00731-00189572-00189815": "but over the last 10 years in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00732-00189816-00190001": "particularly the last five the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00733-00190002-00190193": "deviations from the gray line have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00734-00190194-00190535": "accumulated now at first I say myself", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00735-00190536-00190682": "because I was on the record saying that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00736-00190683-00190904": "back to two years ago I did not think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00737-00190905-00191033": "this was a source for great concern", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00738-00191034-00191333": "after all when we worried about price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00739-00191334-00191531": "stability and the real value of the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00740-00191532-00191765": "we were at about 5 10 20 percent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00741-00191766-00192062": "inflation a few decimal points below 2", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00742-00192063-00192245": "percent especially given the measurement", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00743-00192246-00192374": "errors involved in building a price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00744-00192375-00192527": "index that anyone who's worked in price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00745-00192528-00192746": "index is aware of does not seem like", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00746-00192747-00192859": "something to make a big deal about", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00747-00192860-00193148": "however and this is why the medium run", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00748-00193149-00193400": "emphasis I think puts the onus on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00749-00193401-00193649": "right forces us to look at the gray line", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00750-00193650-00193883": "the persistence of these deviations", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00751-00193884-00194195": "below 2% even if every year there only a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00752-00194196-00194402": "few decimals below does lead to some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00753-00194403-00194606": "sources of concern today where because", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00754-00194607-00194792": "we are starting to be significantly", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00755-00194793-00195197": "below that gray line now as Mario Draghi", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00756-00195198-00195446": "mentioned in the speech this morning it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00757-00195447-00195596": "is important to think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00758-00195597-00195863": "that when we think about hitting 2", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00759-00195864-00196061": "percent on average over this medium run", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00760-00196062-00196220": "that sometimes you're below and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00761-00196221-00196505": "sometimes you're you're above and like", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00762-00196506-00196658": "with an Olivia Blunt shard yesterday at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00763-00196659-00196961": "dinner mentioned the key challenge in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00764-00196962-00197153": "your current union is and always will be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00765-00197154-00197345": "the fundamental challenge is how to deal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00766-00197346-00197555": "with relative price adjustments across", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00767-00197556-00197867": "sectors or across regions as well as the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00768-00197868-00198095": "overtime averaging so let me try to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00769-00198096-00198317": "bring it a third different perspective", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00770-00198318-00198563": "somewhat complementary with the two of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00771-00198564-00198821": "them think of the euro zone is having", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00772-00198822-00199079": "two regions so set its inflation rate pi", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00773-00199080-00199394": "ez is a weighted average of Pi in a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00774-00199395-00199783": "region C and inflation in a region P and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00775-00199784-00200084": "think of the magnitude ECB as being as", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00776-00200085-00200477": "stated and repeated to try to reach 2%", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00777-00200478-00200708": "inflation or below as it has been during", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00778-00200709-00200942": "most of this decade but let me also", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00779-00200943-00201248": "consider a second criteria that is that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00780-00201249-00201575": "region C being more inflation hawkish or", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00781-00201576-00201767": "more averse to inflation would like", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00782-00201768-00201992": "inflation it's in its region not to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00783-00201993-00202352": "exceed 2% now in a scenario in which the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00784-00202353-00202571": "real exchange rate the price adjustments", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00785-00202572-00202724": "which Olivia talked about yesterday at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00786-00202725-00203024": "dinner are such that they require that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00787-00203025-00203243": "the relative price of the sea region", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00788-00203244-00203513": "Falls relative the relative price of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00789-00203514-00203882": "pre region then these two these two", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00790-00203883-00204095": "goals are not in conflict of any way and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00791-00204096-00204311": "one can reach 2 percent inflation on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00792-00204312-00204521": "average while having less than 2 percent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00793-00204522-00204973": "inflation in the sea region however if", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00794-00204975-00205246": "we are instead in a scenario where the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00795-00205248-00205471": "real exchange rate the price adjustments", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00796-00205473-00205631": "have to occur in the opposite direction", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00797-00205632-00205871": "that is it must be that prices in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00798-00205871-00206114": "sea region go up well to the P region", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00799-00206115-00206534": "then in order to satisfy criteria 2 it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00800-00206535-00206923": "must be that the inflation in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00801-00206925-00207359": "overall region is well below 2% or at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00802-00207360-00207538": "least somewhat significantly 2%", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00803-00207539-00207794": "apologies for them for the symbols but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00804-00207794-00207998": "this is somewhat an elementary an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00805-00207998-00208300": "elementary I think algebraic conclusion", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00806-00208301-00208607": "why did I 1 I light it though let's look", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00807-00208608-00208865": "at the eurozone inflation subtracted", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00808-00208866-00208979": "from its 2% target", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00809-00208980-00209248": "blue here and let's in orange put indeed", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00810-00209250-00209419": "the change in the real exchange rate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00811-00209421-00209623": "between a sea region and a P region", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00812-00209625-00210155": "before 2013 we had indeed the scenario a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00813-00210156-00210527": "and inflation was indeed very close to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00814-00210528-00210776": "the two percent is in criteria one but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00815-00210777-00211190": "after 2013 what changed was that instead", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00816-00211191-00211490": "we had higher inflation the sea region", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00817-00211491-00211808": "relative to the P region the change in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00818-00211809-00211952": "the real exchange rate was therefore had", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00819-00211953-00212216": "to be positive and indeed we had that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00820-00212217-00212411": "inflation fell below two percent on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00821-00212412-00212705": "average for the euro zone now all of you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00822-00212706-00212852": "are well-informed and already and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00823-00212853-00213011": "understood what do I mean by the sea", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00824-00213012-00213230": "region in the P region the sea region is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00825-00213231-00213401": "the core of Europe Germany and France", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00826-00213402-00213611": "which account for roughly 40 percent of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00827-00213612-00213967": "the GDP and the P reason I picked Greece", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00828-00213969-00214094": "Ireland Italy Portugal and Spain", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00829-00214094-00214334": "accounting for roughly 30 percent of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00830-00214335-00214471": "GP reason with apologies for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00831-00214473-00214642": "remaining 30 percent and I didn't put in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00832-00214644-00214826": "either C or pee in my simplification", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00833-00214827-00215075": "there is what happens 2013 was that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00834-00215076-00215398": "whereas before in the 2000s the the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00835-00215400-00215576": "first decade of the euro the challenge", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00836-00215577-00215792": "was that bilasa Samuelson effects as", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00837-00215792-00215927": "well as capital flows from the core of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00838-00215928-00216094": "the periphery meant the price that to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00839-00216096-00216344": "rise faster in the periphery than in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00840-00216344-00216554": "core that was what was needed for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00841-00216555-00216791": "welter price adjustments in the last", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00842-00216792-00216986": "fight in the last ten years and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00843-00216987-00217198": "especially in the last five years prices", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00844-00217200-00217517": "had to rise faster in the core than they", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00845-00217517-00217763": "did in the periphery it was therefore", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00846-00217764-00217952": "inevitable for the ECB to stay within", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00847-00217953-00218108": "its two percent on average than", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00848-00218109-00218267": "inflation in the core France and Germany", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00849-00218267-00218494": "had to be well above two percent that is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00850-00218496-00218669": "the only way that was possible to have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00851-00218669-00218990": "two percent but instead for inflation to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00852-00218991-00219179": "stay below two percent in the core in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00853-00219180-00219523": "the periphery as it did it stayed didn't", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00854-00219525-00219707": "that being inevitable that inflation in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00855-00219708-00219880": "the eurozone had to be well below 2%", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00856-00219881-00220229": "looking just at the last 15 months or 16", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00857-00220230-00220454": "months we see that inflation in the core", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00858-00220455-00220754": "actually exceeded 2% now for a few", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00859-00220755-00221071": "months and consistent with the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00860-00221073-00221342": "adjustment story that I told you we see", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00861-00221342-00221534": "that actually expected inflation fell", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00862-00221535-00221819": "for the closer is the higher is expect", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00863-00221819-00222140": "inflation in the core then the more the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00864-00222141-00222311": "average has to be below in order to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00865-00222312-00222344": "bring it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00866-00222344-00222653": "down to the 2% second criteria the role", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00867-00222654-00222973": "of the year or that's global use in one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00868-00222975-00223148": "way the eurozone the second egg was a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00869-00223148-00223436": "success the eurozone no country left the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00870-00223437-00223763": "euro the eurozone kept growing from its", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00871-00223764-00223955": "original decade to the ones that joined", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00872-00223956-00224117": "in that first decade into the second", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00873-00224117-00224342": "decade for another perspective the use", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00874-00224342-00224542": "of the year in invoicing or in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00875-00224544-00224759": "holdings of global reserves as", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00876-00224760-00224966": "significally fallen over the last ten", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00877-00224967-00225317": "years the Euro still well like like in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00878-00225317-00225563": "like in the Lucas Papademos quote it's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00879-00225564-00225812": "clearly the second world currency but it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00880-00225813-00226091": "has fallen somewhat looking back and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00881-00226092-00226294": "trying to assess that euro second role I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00882-00226296-00226498": "would separate three parts from going", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00883-00226500-00226742": "from outcomes instead to policies the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00884-00226742-00226907": "provision of liquidity in euros", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00885-00226908-00227078": "especially the countries that were in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00886-00227079-00227366": "the way to to joining the euro as well", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00887-00227367-00227473": "as in other used to do appear in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00888-00227475-00227617": "countries where the euros widely used", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00889-00227619-00227765": "and which account for a lot of this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00890-00227766-00228086": "usage of the euro was this was preserved", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00891-00228087-00228341": "through the quick deployment of euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00892-00228342-00228533": "swap lines that allow these countries", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00893-00228534-00228809": "both to defend their pegs as well as to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00894-00228810-00229048": "finance their financial sectors when", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00895-00229050-00229259": "those were fight faced with sun stops of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00896-00229260-00229508": "their your funding at the same time", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00897-00229509-00229694": "though asset so that was in liquidity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00898-00229694-00229892": "provision at the same time though in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00899-00229892-00230075": "terms of reducing transaction costs", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00900-00230076-00230258": "reaping the economies of scale there are", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00901-00230259-00230483": "neither for financial transactions euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00902-00230484-00230639": "markets have entered in the last few", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00903-00230640-00230825": "years when the uncertainty with the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00904-00230826-00230984": "uncertainty related to breaks it into", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00905-00230985-00231215": "the existence or not of financial", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00906-00231216-00231401": "markets in euros that will continue to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00907-00231402-00231626": "be vibrant more roaring though is the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00908-00231627-00231821": "last point that Marcus Bruno Meijer", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00909-00231821-00232004": "already emphasized which is with an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00910-00232005-00232262": "absence of a euro I'd safe asset it is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00911-00232263-00232556": "very difficult for there to be a larger", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00912-00232557-00232723": "usage of the euro as a reserve currency", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00913-00232725-00233027": "and for invoicing euros for the lack of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00914-00233028-00233198": "that safe asset makes it essentially", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00915-00233198-00233398": "impossible to hedge the risk associated", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00916-00233400-00233726": "with that euro third and final criteria", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00917-00233727-00233936": "independence and in particularly depends", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00918-00233937-00234164": "from fiscal policy the fundamental", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00919-00234165-00234367": "challenge of EMU which continues for its", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00920-00234369-00234590": "foundation until its present is how to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00921-00234591-00234857": "combine a single monetary policy with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00922-00234858-00235117": "fragmented fiscal policies the founding", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00923-00235119-00235265": "treaty said clearly that the central", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00924-00235266-00235457": "bank should be independent should not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00925-00235458-00235663": "take any instructions from", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00926-00235664-00235848": "government asserting its Independence of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00927-00235850-00236023": "the fiscal authorities and the first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00928-00236023-00236280": "decade indeed avoided that dominance", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00929-00236281-00236500": "official authorities very successfully", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00930-00236501-00236802": "by preventing any attempt at fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00931-00236803-00237094": "interference on the ECB's creation of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00932-00237094-00237396": "seniors or desire or better even lack", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00933-00237398-00237700": "thereof of inflation away and expectedly", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00934-00237701-00238039": "any public debt at the same time though", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00935-00238040-00238626": "a second mark sorry let me see", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00936-00238627-00238901": "at the same time though a second and new", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00937-00238902-00239159": "challenges emerge in the separation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00938-00239160-00239413": "think of lender of last resort theory", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00939-00239414-00239607": "which is ultimately how or lender last", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00940-00239608-00239802": "resort a liquidity policy which is where", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00941-00239803-00240067": "central bank gets dragged in during a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00942-00240067-00240255": "fiscal during a financial crisis", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00943-00240256-00240442": "happened in the last ten years what do I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00944-00240442-00240627": "think is the theory and best practice of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00945-00240628-00240841": "lenders last resort across the world or", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00946-00240842-00241023": "academically as well as in practice a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00947-00241025-00241225": "central bank should start either to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00948-00241226-00241383": "individual banks or to finance system as", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00949-00241384-00241573": "a whole to start by learning to a liquid", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00950-00241573-00241725": "but solve institutions the Badger", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00951-00241726-00241983": "principle now it is inevitable that in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00952-00241984-00242157": "some states of the world deal liquid", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00953-00242158-00242365": "become insolvent that's just life that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00954-00242366-00242577": "states of the world realize at that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00955-00242578-00242775": "point best practice in theory says the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00956-00242776-00242898": "central bank should call the Treasury", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00957-00242900-00243169": "for now this is a fiscal operation the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00958-00243169-00243342": "taxpayers money is at stake and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00959-00243344-00243627": "therefore it is no it's part it's time", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00960-00243628-00243838": "for the central bank to pass over to the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00961-00243839-00243994": "treasurer its operations okay", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00962-00243994-00244155": "note that this amelie implies that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00963-00244156-00244312": "lender of last resort laquida policies", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00964-00244313-00244546": "have a fiscal dimension once we hit a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00965-00244546-00244782": "serious crisis you have at some point to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00966-00244783-00245004": "call and turbos liquidity into fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00967-00245005-00245253": "and you cannot avoid this there's no", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00968-00245254-00245442": "separation strict between this the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00969-00245444-00245641": "separation only exists when you are in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00970-00245642-00245805": "the good states of the world nor crises", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00971-00245806-00246021": "happen have price stability requires", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00972-00246023-00246171": "ruling out this fiscal dominance", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00973-00246173-00246474": "now who can the ECB call what it engaged", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00974-00246475-00246609": "in delay of last resort liquidity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00975-00246610-00246798": "operations and it turns out that the bad", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00976-00246800-00246969": "side of the world realizes in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00977-00246971-00247094": "situation should not have be insolvent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00978-00247096-00247321": "now looking back I think one can say", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00979-00247321-00247506": "that when he reached individual banks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00980-00247507-00247680": "either in Cyprus or in some small banks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00981-00247681-00247771": "in Portugal or Spain", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00982-00247771-00248092": "the ECB indeed force resolution said I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00983-00248092-00248266": "will withdraw ability of some of these", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00984-00248267-00248460": "banks to have access to liquid if", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00985-00248461-00248631": "shielded ECB and force the national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00986-00248632-00248826": "treasures take the fiscal loss during", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00987-00248827-00248973": "the systemic crisis that effect of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00988-00248975-00249013": "financial", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00989-00249014-00249228": "systems of many periphery countries this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00990-00249229-00249381": "would be who did it call a called the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00991-00249382-00249576": "IMF and the Commission and nowadays in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00992-00249577-00249804": "the future the ESM is by forming the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00993-00249805-00249957": "troika can saying this is now a fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00994-00249958-00250227": "solvency is at risk you must be part of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00995-00250228-00250414": "it and finally when it came to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00996-00250415-00250666": "redistribution across regions the ECB", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00997-00250667-00250912": "following its mandate change the rules", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00998-00250913-00251157": "so that sovereign bonds would be held by", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-00999-00251158-00251338": "the national central banks and so that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01000-00251339-00251542": "all national risk would be held at the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01001-00251542-00251689": "national central bank level therefore", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01002-00251690-00251914": "separating any risk sharing in any", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01003-00251915-00252126": "distribution at all now in light of its", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01004-00252127-00252346": "price stability mandate this was indeed", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01005-00252346-00252534": "fiscal dominant success was prevented in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01006-00252535-00252828": "all three ways ECB succeeded in keeping", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01007-00252829-00253005": "its independence and keeping its focus", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01008-00253006-00253260": "price stability note I need to know", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01009-00253261-00253380": "parenthetically though that in terms of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01010-00253381-00253540": "social welfare as a price too high", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01011-00253541-00253701": "stability all three of these bullet", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01012-00253702-00253857": "points can be argued as having gone", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01013-00253858-00254044": "against the social welfare but as a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01014-00254044-00254148": "discussion for another day", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01015-00254148-00254469": "looking forward though when we look at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01016-00254471-00254644": "the second decade this question still", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01017-00254644-00254931": "looms large will the fact that these TV", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01018-00254932-00255187": "faces segmented fiscal policies that it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01019-00255188-00255354": "doesn't have an obvious person to call", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01020-00255355-00255603": "in the midst of financial crisis imply", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01021-00255604-00255759": "there will cut out lender of last resort", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01022-00255760-00256002": "too early not internalizing the fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01023-00256003-00256173": "cost that this causes on national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01024-00256175-00256489": "Treasuries oral instead stain lenders", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01025-00256490-00256723": "are stay in lender of last resort until", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01026-00256723-00256908": "too late as fiscal authorities", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01027-00256909-00257046": "especially of different countries in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01028-00257048-00257235": "Eurozone play chicken games on who wants", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01029-00257236-00257409": "to cut on who wants to pay the fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01030-00257410-00257709": "cost of resolving and as banks solution", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01031-00257710-00257907": "across Europe more generally with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01032-00257908-00258094": "macro-prudential policy that's national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01033-00258094-00258391": "DCB will find sooner or later if it has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01034-00258392-00258585": "not found itself already and for that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01035-00258586-00258723": "the experience of the UK is an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01036-00258725-00258885": "instructive one that you can create an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01037-00258886-00259090": "independent financial stability Mac", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01038-00259091-00259284": "oppression Authority but when a crisis", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01039-00259285-00259476": "hits you the central bank are the first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01040-00259477-00259683": "respondent and you are the one who has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01041-00259684-00259864": "to know what to do how to do that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01042-00259865-00260113": "passing to conclude in my three", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01043-00260114-00260323": "assessments in many ways the second", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01044-00260323-00260467": "decade you could say was more successful", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01045-00260467-00260641": "in the first the challenge were bigger", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01046-00260642-00260844": "and yet inflation control leader", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01047-00260846-00260989": "continues to be the second large global", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01048-00260990-00261234": "currency and liquidity was provided", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01049-00261235-00261421": "averting a financial collapse while", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01050-00261421-00261579": "preserving the price stability managed", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01051-00261580-00261882": "independence but these success if you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01052-00261883-00262048": "want leaves very big questions for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01053-00262048-00262106": "future", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01054-00262107-00262333": "defining the target", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01055-00262334-00262522": "enlightened not just of overtime and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01056-00262523-00262702": "symmetry but in light of regional price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01057-00262703-00262963": "adjustments seems crucial for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01058-00262964-00263142": "currency union challenge to be met", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01059-00263143-00263326": "investing in the architecture for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01060-00263327-00263584": "year to grow such as safe assets seems", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01061-00263585-00263845": "crucial for the year to go anywhere", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01062-00263846-00264028": "beyond where it is it's a global", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01063-00264029-00264253": "currency and rethinking and more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01064-00264254-00264388": "importantly restating what independence", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01065-00264389-00264610": "of fiscal policy means in the context of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01066-00264611-00264829": "macro parental policies and last resort", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01067-00264830-00265129": "policies will become for sure cut the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01068-00265130-00265494": "front row in the next crisis thank you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01069-00265495-00266151": "[Applause]", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01070-00266152-00266563": "so I will not try to exactly summarize", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01071-00266564-00266869": "all that we've heard in the panel so far", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01072-00266870-00267193": "but maybe one way to frame the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01073-00267194-00267457": "discussion is that part of what we heard", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01074-00267458-00267724": "is essentially looking at the euro area", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01075-00267725-00268048": "as an aggregate so just like we might", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01076-00268049-00268249": "look at the US and your other large", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01077-00268250-00268489": "economy essentially what is the best", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01078-00268490-00268723": "multi strategy that what is the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01079-00268724-00268891": "appropriate role for fiscal policy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01080-00268892-00269221": "versus monetary policy in stabilization", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01081-00269222-00269455": "in a low inflation world so that's one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01082-00269456-00269734": "part of the discussion a second part of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01083-00269735-00269989": "the discussion is a monetary union works", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01084-00269990-00270235": "better when there's less divergence", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01085-00270236-00270565": "across the member states so that's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01086-00270566-00270795": "partly about well how can we avoid", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01087-00270796-00271150": "shocks that create divergence as a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01088-00271151-00271504": "better policymaking at the national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01089-00271505-00271804": "level more similarity convergence if is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01090-00271805-00271966": "convergence to trade through single", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01091-00271967-00272077": "market and so on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01092-00272078-00272254": "maybe the Sharks would be less", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01093-00272255-00272536": "asymmetric but it's also the question of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01094-00272537-00272905": "what kind of institutions amplify shocks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01095-00272906-00273132": "what kind of institutions damping shocks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01096-00273133-00273433": "so these are issues about in a world", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01097-00273434-00273643": "where banking Union with capital markets", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01098-00273644-00273915": "Union with a central fiscal capacity", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01099-00273916-00274273": "with a safe asset with macro proof maybe", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01100-00274274-00274504": "shocks will happen but they won't be so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01101-00274505-00274723": "dramatic and therefore the single", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01102-00274724-00274897": "monetary policy would be more effective", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01103-00274898-00275155": "so before I I gather questions from the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01104-00275156-00275302": "floor maybe I'll just ask", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01105-00275303-00275521": "starting with Peter if there's any", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01106-00275522-00275704": "instant responses to what you've heard", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01107-00275705-00275737": "from there", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01108-00275738-00276190": "panelists - Peter yeah I told you very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01109-00276191-00276577": "briefly my reactions a bit I like what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01110-00276578-00276835": "what you just had no feel about the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01111-00276836-00277099": "thinking about what are the amplifying", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01112-00277100-00277354": "mechanism or institutions weak", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01113-00277355-00277675": "institutions amplifying shocks because", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01114-00277676-00278122": "when you look at the past what you see", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01115-00278123-00278518": "is that the crisis we had and certainly", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01116-00278519-00278881": "the last ten years period you could have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01117-00278882-00279139": "much better results and you had you know", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01118-00279140-00279295": "some of the institution's we created", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01119-00279296-00279352": "later", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01120-00279353-00279760": "so I not so pessimistic as I was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01121-00279761-00279967": "expressed also by you these fundamental", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01122-00279968-00280150": "divergences that we had that you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01123-00280151-00280321": "explained the cultural divergences I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01124-00280322-00280525": "think if you have proper institutions", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01125-00280526-00280705": "and we we are building and are not find", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01126-00280706-00280885": "out as this is the concern but the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01127-00280886-00281053": "institutions all the amplifying", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01128-00281054-00281233": "mechanisms that we have the panic you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01129-00281234-00281467": "know the the the fact that when there is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01130-00281468-00281626": "a shock there isn't there is nothing", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01131-00281627-00281896": "there you know when you have to react in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01132-00281897-00282133": "I think that we we made a lot of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01133-00282134-00282361": "progress there now it is true and that's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01134-00282362-00282589": "really what Ricardo came many things", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01135-00282590-00282796": "that disagree with you Ricardo but there", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01136-00282797-00282994": "is one story no because I don't think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01137-00282995-00283195": "you're very well aware of the recent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01138-00283196-00283459": "developments that you have in terms of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01139-00283460-00283693": "less and linear as resort you know even", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01140-00283694-00283996": "for systemic crisis it is true that the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01141-00283997-00284227": "the architecture is not finalized today", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01142-00284228-00284446": "so there you have a point so what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01143-00284447-00284593": "happens when you have a systemic shock", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01144-00284594-00284875": "or systemic institution is it in spite", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01145-00284876-00285085": "of the BRD in spite of all what we have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01146-00285086-00285295": "now you know how would the system react", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01147-00285296-00285418": "in the central bank you know for example", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01148-00285419-00285721": "providing liquidity in resolution is not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01149-00285722-00285982": "yet an issue which has been solved who", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01150-00285983-00286159": "foots the bill you know if a big", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01151-00286160-00286342": "institution gets down or if you have a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01152-00286343-00286528": "systemic shock so we are not yet there", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01153-00286529-00286762": "and this is a source of concern but you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01154-00286763-00287005": "should not also say that not much has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01155-00287006-00287152": "been done so far I think as huge", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01156-00287153-00287407": "progress has been done so far compared", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01157-00287408-00287572": "to what it was before but I think you're", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01158-00287573-00287746": "right Phillip to say that we have to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01159-00287747-00287920": "focus on the amplifying mechanism I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01160-00287921-00288109": "always reminds me in the Lehman brother", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01161-00288110-00288430": "if if you look at how to solve the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01162-00288431-00288583": "Lehman Brothers on a spreadsheet it's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01163-00288584-00288799": "not that expensive actually the thing is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01164-00288800-00288964": "that your institution framework has not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01165-00288965-00289071": "been appropriate then you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01166-00289072-00289320": "into sort of panic you know situation we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01167-00289321-00289500": "are not yet there that's what worries me", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01168-00289501-00289692": "but the lot has been done yet I mean so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01169-00289693-00289869": "so you have to be much more granular", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01170-00289870-00290070": "when in the discussion so I cannot be I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01171-00290071-00290298": "I think the cultural you know when you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01172-00290299-00290628": "came with jean-pierre you know and and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01173-00290629-00290925": "and and the other colleague how old with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01174-00290926-00291138": "your book in Mannheim some years ago I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01175-00291139-00291410": "think it's it's interesting but having", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01176-00291411-00291621": "is a very Calicut oral presentation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01177-00291622-00291822": "about you know the dividing line between", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01178-00291823-00292089": "friends and and journey or that I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01179-00292090-00292245": "we should be careful about can occur to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01180-00292246-00292476": "us about cultures and I told you that at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01181-00292477-00292749": "that time I think it's useful for those", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01182-00292750-00292998": "knowledgeable people but it looks like a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01183-00292999-00293133": "bit populist you know sort of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01184-00293134-00293322": "communication I'm sorry markers but it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01185-00293323-00293508": "looks like tableau it's sort of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01186-00293509-00293715": "communication when say solvency", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01187-00293716-00293919": "liquidity and you see this I told you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01188-00293920-00294075": "already before but you have to be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01189-00294076-00294252": "careful I think indeed circle it's fine", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01190-00294253-00294405": "but I think we should be a bit careful", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01191-00294406-00294663": "it's not it's not exactly that and it's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01192-00294664-00294906": "much more complicated than that the the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01193-00294907-00295113": "question I think which is fascinating", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01194-00295114-00295464": "but is as your reversal rate now you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01195-00295465-00295929": "come with one percent of course minus", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01196-00295930-00296118": "one percent of your reversal rate I mean", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01197-00296119-00296454": "so far we have seen some of the banks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01198-00296455-00296657": "including in countries like Switzerland", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01199-00296658-00296829": "for example but we have seen or in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01200-00296830-00297066": "Scandinavian countries you see countries", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01201-00297067-00297276": "where the negative rates is is quite low", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01202-00297277-00297516": "and where the profitability has been", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01203-00297517-00297816": "quite good actually so I think yeah well", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01204-00297817-00297981": "I think that they've managed they cost", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01205-00297982-00298200": "much better than others Lewis you came", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01206-00298201-00298326": "recently in the financial stability", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01207-00298327-00298563": "review with that point so I don't know", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01208-00298564-00298760": "what's the reversal rate what I know is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01209-00298761-00298985": "there are many ways for banks to tackle", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01210-00298986-00299277": "with that situation and I think you know", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01211-00299278-00299459": "I think you pushed your reversal rate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01212-00299460-00299676": "you know 2-1 I think it was not was it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01213-00299677-00299858": "always minus one I think it was weaker", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01214-00299859-00300129": "was always minus one okay quit okay I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01215-00300130-00300426": "don't remember whether so that the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01216-00300427-00300707": "macro-prudential tools for a cyclical", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01217-00300708-00301053": "policy I well I think there is a box in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01218-00301054-00301254": "the financial stability review I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01219-00301255-00301449": "which would be extremely careful I don't", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01220-00301450-00301656": "think we put on the accelerator on one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01221-00301657-00301893": "side by liquidity provision and on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01222-00301894-00302049": "other side on the brake you know by", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01223-00302050-00302280": "Prudential first the Prudential rules", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01224-00302281-00302380": "are for banks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01225-00302381-00302593": "and the financial system is not only", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01226-00302594-00302797": "being so it is true that one deals very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01227-00302798-00302974": "much with the high leverage high", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01228-00302975-00303217": "liquidity risk institutions and then we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01229-00303218-00303448": "provide liquidity to them to allow them", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01230-00303449-00303664": "to adjust to the new environment but I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01231-00303665-00303829": "don't think it's it's it's a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01232-00303830-00304024": "contradictory policy it's it's a very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01233-00304025-00304225": "well thought you know what you do when", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01234-00304226-00304426": "you have a financial crisis you provide", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01235-00304427-00304633": "liquidity of course there is a moral", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01236-00304634-00304798": "hazard problem when you do that but then", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01237-00304799-00304945": "you tighten on the other side by", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01238-00304946-00305133": "regulation and that takes more time and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01239-00305134-00305296": "that's a little bit you know the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01240-00305297-00305491": "Pittsburgh you know strategy net was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01241-00305492-00305764": "there and well that's what what we have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01242-00305765-00306067": "been doing and so just a couple of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01243-00306068-00306244": "remarks but then thank you Peter Adler", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01244-00306245-00306625": "Ross did you give any reactions through", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01245-00306626-00307308": "the other panels so far surprise here", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01246-00307309-00307734": "well a couple of them first I think when", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01247-00307735-00308071": "I look at Marcus I agree you made me", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01248-00308072-00308290": "feel very French and I can assure you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01249-00308291-00308494": "that the child had been and the thinking", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01250-00308495-00308689": "was done at the OECD with a crowd of you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01251-00308690-00308980": "and non-euro people so I think I would", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01252-00308981-00309265": "agree on this that it was a bit him he's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01253-00309266-00309541": "a bit of a turn-on them it was true at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01254-00309542-00309823": "the beginning probably but I think it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01255-00309824-00310216": "has evolved quite a lot and deep down I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01256-00310217-00310405": "think anyway we need to overcome that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01257-00310406-00310608": "because if we continue with this clear", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01258-00310609-00310828": "distinction between monetary and fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01259-00310829-00311116": "policy we won't get out of the situation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01260-00311117-00311449": "we're in and in the next crisis I might", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01261-00311450-00311803": "be a bit less less optimistic than Peter", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01262-00311804-00312022": "because I think the divide may have gone", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01263-00312023-00312250": "it's going to be more difficult to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01264-00312251-00312766": "overcome okay Marcus let me just read to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01265-00312767-00313231": "some of course what I meant by this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01266-00313232-00313504": "French German I meant more broadly and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01267-00313505-00313602": "it's it's a black-and-white", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01268-00313603-00313860": "representation it's just to make it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01269-00313861-00314248": "clear of the communication the universal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01270-00314249-00314449": "interest rate of course is very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01271-00314450-00314590": "different this very dependent how the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01272-00314591-00314788": "banks of funding so if you're in Sweden", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01273-00314789-00314974": "for example it'll you a lot of out of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01274-00314975-00315176": "holes and fundings or changes in hor", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01275-00315177-00315479": "it wasn't to settle out I didn't have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01276-00315480-00316004": "time to go into that so I just want to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01277-00316005-00316187": "reiterate the physical side I think the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01278-00316188-00316328": "European Investment Bank I think can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01279-00316329-00316538": "play a big role in this dimension it has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01280-00316539-00316710": "played a big role I think that's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01281-00316711-00316973": "something which we should also take into", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01282-00316974-00317492": "account and and I very much like", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01283-00317493-00317741": "Ricardo's point that you know if you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01284-00317742-00318128": "look at the average inflation having 2%", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01285-00318129-00318338": "target then the probably has to be some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01286-00318339-00318473": "countries which are more buffered some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01287-00318474-00318737": "other countries which are below but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01288-00318738-00318902": "perhaps we should also be me do some", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01289-00318903-00319130": "forecasting also have more about the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01290-00319131-00319376": "divergence across different regions and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01291-00319377-00319532": "if there's an inflation target I don't", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01292-00319533-00319604": "know whether you want to have an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01293-00319605-00319822": "inflation target for various countries", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01294-00319823-00320083": "if you in particular want to change the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01295-00320084-00320372": "middle in exchange rate within the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01296-00320373-00320525": "area then it might make sense to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01297-00320526-00320705": "communicate this to some extent as well", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01298-00320706-00321245": "okay okay the rounds again just actually", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01299-00321246-00321608": "a reaction on the surface set because I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01300-00321609-00321899": "find talking about safe SAT in in a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01301-00321900-00322274": "totally abstract way is if you forgive", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01302-00322275-00322529": "me nearly a little hypocritical because", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01303-00322530-00322763": "where's this saved I said coming from", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01304-00322764-00322958": "either it's coming from a common area", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01305-00322959-00323249": "fiscal capacity and when we are talking", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01306-00323250-00323425": "again about having a common", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01307-00323426-00323714": "stabilization tool and then it issues", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01308-00323715-00323884": "debt and it's safe I said because", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01309-00323885-00324113": "everybody's guaranteeing it when and I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01310-00324114-00324263": "hope Philippe will forgive me this time", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01311-00324264-00324734": "but if it's a totally private sector say", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01312-00324735-00324893": "if I say then the private sector can do", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01313-00324894-00325238": "it by itself without any implication of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01314-00325239-00325466": "the public sector without some sort of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01315-00325467-00325697": "guarantee or tax incentive which shows", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01316-00325698-00325880": "that the public sector believes in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01317-00325881-00326201": "Detroit then it will not be a totally", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01318-00326202-00326579": "safe effect thank you Ricardo", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01319-00326580-00326753": "let me be very brief scene said my first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01320-00326754-00326873": "intervention I think I took a little", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01321-00326874-00327002": "longer than others I want to just", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01322-00327003-00327173": "emphasize this monetary fiscal which i", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01323-00327174-00327365": "think is permeated many of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01324-00327366-00327554": "discussions and many have said to what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01325-00327555-00327842": "extent one needs some fiscal if you want", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01326-00327843-00328031": "aggregate demand management to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01327-00328032-00328190": "complement that one offered by the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01328-00328191-00328277": "monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01329-00328278-00328553": "and certainly in the case of when it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01330-00328554-00328732": "comes to stabilizing business cycles I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01331-00328733-00329177": "think that is an ambiguously true I want", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01332-00329178-00329435": "I was emphasizing more and in my", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01333-00329436-00329567": "presentation I will do it again", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01334-00329568-00329837": "the need for monitor physical separation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01335-00329838-00330101": "though which is that it is crucial for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01336-00330102-00330350": "price stability that there is no fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01337-00330351-00330563": "dominance and that the fiscal risks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01338-00330564-00330863": "taken by a central bank are both highly", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01339-00330864-00331103": "managed understood and not subject to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01340-00331104-00331283": "interference and as I said I think in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01341-00331284-00331442": "the first I think we understand that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01342-00331443-00331667": "relatively well when it comes to let's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01343-00331668-00331904": "say normal times generation of senior", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01344-00331905-00332072": "age inflating the debt we in the stent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01345-00332073-00332210": "well extent we need central bank", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01346-00332211-00332384": "independence and I think the ECB", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01347-00332385-00332504": "understood that well in the first 10", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01348-00332505-00332711": "years over the last ten years we've", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01349-00332712-00332876": "understood how it conventional monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01350-00332877-00333143": "policies lead to a series of solvency if", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01351-00333144-00333314": "you want or capital loss type risks to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01352-00333315-00333482": "the central bank and we've understood", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01353-00333483-00333749": "how we can manage those again in a in a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01354-00333750-00333899": "way that I feel somewhat confident that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01355-00333900-00334081": "we know how to address that challenge", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01356-00334082-00334325": "moving forward though and even if much", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01357-00334326-00334489": "progress has been done like Peter said", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01358-00334490-00334769": "understanding the monetary fiscal not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01359-00334770-00334916": "cooperation per se but even just", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01360-00334917-00335201": "separation independence in this in a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01361-00335202-00335333": "scenario in which there's a lender of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01362-00335334-00335504": "last resort in the scenarios financial", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01363-00335505-00335675": "crisis and we're a single monitor", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01364-00335676-00335899": "authority has to face several", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01365-00335900-00336137": "independent fiscal authorities knowing", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01366-00336138-00336281": "that bailouts will happen", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01367-00336282-00336476": "maybe with mail and maybe not and that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01368-00336477-00336638": "the central bank is always at the start", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01369-00336639-00336830": "of that I think is still an unsolved", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01370-00336831-00337013": "question not in Europe but theoretically", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01371-00337014-00337328": "in general and I think it's one that has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01372-00337329-00337580": "to play a bigger role and intellectually", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01373-00337581-00337772": "as well as in practice one has to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01374-00337773-00337931": "seriously consider precisely because I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01375-00337932-00338138": "think that separation is important for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01376-00338139-00338219": "the preservation of price stability", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01377-00338220-00338435": "which being a little bit of a hawk I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01378-00338436-00338651": "myself am very much committed to beyond", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01379-00338652-00338789": "the aggregate demand management that is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01380-00338790-00338948": "emphasized and then very briefly on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01381-00338949-00339197": "runs I mean for at least the usage of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01382-00339198-00339590": "the euro as a global safe asset and for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01383-00339591-00339740": "it to be more used as a currency of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01384-00339741-00339986": "invoicing as a currency that's important", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01385-00339987-00340223": "in financial assets in Holdings I do not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01386-00340224-00340391": "think that you need risk sharing you do", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01387-00340392-00340580": "not need a euro bond type instrument you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01388-00340581-00340808": "do not need tax backing those would be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01389-00340809-00340946": "important if you want to achieve risk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01390-00340947-00341291": "sharing perhaps but I I certainly do not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01391-00341292-00341459": "say that some may think so and that's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01392-00341460-00341659": "fine but if all you want is to create", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01393-00341660-00341875": "a liquid instrument that allows you to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01394-00341876-00342037": "have a well-defined yield curve that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01395-00342038-00342280": "allows people to hedge their risk that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01396-00342281-00342523": "allows people to have like Marcus said", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01397-00342524-00342706": "break the diabolic loops at generating", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01398-00342707-00343006": "dodges risk as well as drop cross-border", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01399-00343007-00343228": "flows that emphasize and that enhance", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01400-00343229-00343354": "these real exchange rate and price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01401-00343355-00343540": "adjustments for those I don't think you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01402-00343541-00343696": "need the fiscal backing I think you can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01403-00343697-00343909": "produce them privately publicly I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01404-00343910-00344047": "publicly is probably better as the work", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01405-00344048-00344266": "for the ESRB on sovereign bond back", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01406-00344267-00344425": "securities I think is shown but those", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01407-00344426-00344560": "would be important from an architecture", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01408-00344561-00344800": "sense even if not providing any risk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01409-00344801-00345043": "sharing and that's not involving any", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01410-00345044-00345262": "personal commitment Thank You Ricardo so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01411-00345263-00345526": "the what I'm going to do is is gather", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01412-00345527-00345790": "some questions collectively before", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01413-00345791-00345988": "coming back to the panel and actually", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01414-00345989-00346861": "the first person I see is Francoise many", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01415-00346862-00347047": "thanks to all of you one quick comment", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01416-00347048-00347467": "and one question my comment Marcus will", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01417-00347468-00347656": "be an additional one very short on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01418-00347657-00347869": "Rhine divide Romi a personal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01419-00347870-00348067": "consideration I happen to be born in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01420-00348068-00348445": "Strasbourg on the Rhine if you were", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01421-00348446-00348664": "right it would be a very uncomfortable", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01422-00348665-00348940": "position but you might be right that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01423-00348941-00349144": "there is some kind of cultural divide", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01424-00349145-00349354": "but if there is one it's probably more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01425-00349355-00349654": "an Atlantic divided with a financial cut", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01426-00349655-00349930": "in Germany insisting more true on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01427-00349931-00350209": "stability and rules and a financial", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01428-00350210-00350413": "culture in the u.s. insisting more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01429-00350414-00350629": "flexibility in markets but I will stop", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01430-00350630-00351207": "here my question is for Peter and Peter", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01431-00351208-00351463": "congratulations for your 17 slides I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01432-00351464-00351865": "were excellent you touched upon the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01433-00351866-00352117": "issue of the monetary pillar and you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01434-00352118-00352453": "suggested that we should perhaps revisit", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01435-00352454-00352732": "it and Link it to financial stability", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01436-00352733-00352990": "considerations could you elaborate a bit", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01437-00352991-00353307": "more about that thank you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01438-00353308-00353761": "okay I have a lot of hands up so with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01439-00353762-00354001": "apologies for not trying to follow any", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01440-00354002-00354587": "particular order it's on clothes", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01441-00354588-00354840": "thank you very much you will forgive me", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01442-00354841-00355023": "to concentrate a little bit on the for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01443-00355024-00355329": "your first years of the crisis which", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01444-00355330-00355626": "were really very dramatic and I fully", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01445-00355627-00355911": "agree with has been said namely that it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01446-00355912-00356169": "was the worst crisis since 29 30s and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01447-00356170-00356460": "not not only since world war two one to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01448-00356461-00356610": "echo what has been said on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01449-00356611-00356967": "divergences between states we could", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01450-00356968-00357192": "observe that in a single currency area", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01451-00357193-00357534": "it was pretty possible for the wages and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01452-00357535-00357792": "salaries in the public sector in two", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01453-00357793-00358071": "countries member of that single currency", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01454-00358072-00358455": "area to diverge over ten years in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01455-00358456-00358728": "following fashion augmentation in one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01456-00358729-00358926": "country second three eight twenty plus", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01457-00358927-00359235": "twenty percent in Euros and country Bey", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01458-00359236-00359454": "plus a hundred and seventeen percent in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01459-00359455-00359748": "Euros this was not foreseen by anybody", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01460-00359749-00359925": "we could not imagine that it could", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01461-00359926-00360297": "happen it can still happen in my opinion", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01462-00360298-00360561": "if we are not very very attentive and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01463-00360562-00360920": "from that standpoint the invention of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01464-00360921-00361973": "the I would say multi the MIP the the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01465-00361974-00362217": "imbalance procedure yeah because I have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01466-00362218-00362435": "the venture according mean mine", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01467-00362436-00362769": "namely that control of the divergences", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01468-00362770-00363075": "both on the side of the competitiveness", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01469-00363076-00363339": "cost competitiveness and on the side of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01470-00363340-00363624": "the overall external imbalances is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01471-00363625-00363948": "absolutely free and I mentioned that on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01472-00363949-00364164": "personal because it seems to me that we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01473-00364165-00364371": "pay not sufficient attentions to that's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01474-00364372-00364740": "not the ECB job but DCB should be on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01475-00364741-00364935": "record for having told all ministers of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01476-00364936-00365262": "finance since 2005 you are diverging and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01477-00365263-00365643": "that divergences will create in immense", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01478-00365644-00365880": "problem another element that I would", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01479-00365881-00366038": "like to mention Ricardo made the point", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01480-00366039-00366321": "history is at stake there not only", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01481-00366322-00366633": "because it's the boulders endeavor in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01482-00366634-00366942": "the monetary area ever in my own", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01483-00366943-00367182": "understanding but also because when we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01484-00367183-00367578": "are in charge when when the vemma past", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01485-00367579-00367980": "the bathroom we were already 12 when I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01486-00367981-00368516": "passed the baton to Nalu we were already", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01487-00368517-00368910": "17 and Maha had to accept more countries", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01488-00368911-00369243": "himself so we were 11 at the very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01489-00369244-00369647": "beginning then very rapidly 12 19 today", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01490-00369648-00370019": "who can say that this does not create", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01491-00370020-00370359": "enormous new challenges threats for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01492-00370360-00370500": "central bank concern I'm done speaking", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01493-00370501-00370710": "of the of the government themselves but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01494-00370711-00370965": "this is something which is not necessary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01495-00370966-00371331": "captures in from outside even even", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01496-00371332-00371541": "across the channel or across the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01497-00371542-00371814": "Atlantic across the Pacific that history", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01498-00371815-00372078": "is in the making in a way which is very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01499-00372079-00372321": "unique of you see and let me also", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01500-00372322-00372848": "mention to conclude that practically all", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01501-00372849-00373236": "new I would say very bold unconventional", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01502-00373237-00373641": "tools we're experienced in the first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01503-00373642-00373851": "four years man we had the full allotment", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01504-00373852-00374204": "at fixed rate what would have been the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01505-00374205-00374499": "monetary policy transmission in the euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01506-00374500-00374856": "area in the crisis if we didn't have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01507-00374857-00375141": "this concept which is still there and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01508-00375142-00375363": "permits of course at least at the very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01509-00375364-00375708": "very low interest rate of the yield", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01510-00375709-00375933": "curve to have the same exactly the same", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01511-00375934-00376173": "in all countries because the banks have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01512-00376174-00376401": "access to that full allotment at fixed", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01513-00376402-00376697": "rate we had the SMP with the SMP was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01514-00376698-00376989": "terribly criticized when decided by the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01515-00376990-00377118": "Governing Council", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01516-00377119-00377379": "we even had colleagues that were very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01517-00377380-00377730": "very infuriated it represented the old", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01518-00377731-00378020": "taken into account if I'm not mistake", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01519-00378021-00378396": "218 billion euros targeted on one third", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01520-00378397-00378630": "of the GDP of the euro area so it was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01521-00378631-00378876": "the equivalent of something like 600", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01522-00378877-00379191": "billion in the u.s. yeah in a short span", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01523-00379192-00379539": "of time and of course it prevented us", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01524-00379540-00379829": "from having absolutely dramatic", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01525-00379830-00380166": "unfolding of speculation so it was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01526-00380167-00380472": "something which was very in my opinion", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01527-00380473-00380809": "very important for Mario when he", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01528-00380810-00381259": "said we can do anything and that was you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01529-00381260-00381679": "know we can go and multiply what has", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01530-00381680-00382039": "been already experienced and was no not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01531-00382040-00382303": "continued because the government at a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01532-00382304-00382627": "certain moment had accepted themselves", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01533-00382628-00382921": "to take the baton and I was reading", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01534-00382922-00383260": "again the conclusion the communique of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01535-00383261-00383563": "the Brussels European Council is the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01536-00383564-00383892": "21st of July 2011 where they had", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01537-00383893-00384298": "reaffirmed themselves that the ESF s yes", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01538-00384299-00384556": "M could intervene on the secondary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01539-00384557-00384997": "market which permitted us maybe a little", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01540-00384998-00385309": "bit too naively to think that they could", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01541-00385310-00385564": "step in and that there was the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01542-00385565-00385750": "possibility of the government to really", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01543-00385751-00386047": "step in experience as demonstrated but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01544-00386048-00386122": "not the case", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01545-00386123-00386572": "thank you so right behind you Volker", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01546-00386573-00386869": "thank you for excellent presentations so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01547-00386870-00387079": "we've heard a lot of praise about multi", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01548-00387080-00387235": "policy we've heard that fiscal policy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01549-00387236-00387528": "needs to be put at the European level to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01550-00387529-00387865": "optimally manage fiscal policy for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01551-00387866-00388072": "euro area kind of shifting the IES curve", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01552-00388073-00388354": "for the euro area but I'm worried that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01553-00388355-00388609": "there is a bit of a disconnect to the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01554-00388610-00388801": "developments we've actually observed in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01555-00388802-00388990": "Europe in the European elections I mean", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01556-00388991-00389236": "we have you know in my mind my call was", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01557-00389237-00389512": "campaigning on the proposals for example", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01558-00389513-00389707": "Lauren's mentioned right but he lost", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01559-00389708-00389965": "against lepen right the majority is euro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01560-00389966-00390127": "critic and yet the majority but the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01561-00390128-00390352": "largest party is euro critical if we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01562-00390353-00390646": "look at Italy we clearly also have a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01563-00390647-00390922": "trend there - even from the government -", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01564-00390923-00391189": "more sovereignty back to the national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01565-00391190-00391380": "level I mean they're not calling for a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01566-00391381-00391657": "fiscal government in Brussels they want", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01567-00391658-00391882": "to have more fiscal leeway there while", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01568-00391883-00392095": "they're calling and this is why they're", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01569-00392096-00392299": "calling for ECP to guarantee the debt so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01570-00392300-00392535": "we have this trend to more national", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01571-00392536-00392776": "sovereignty and away from Brussels how", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01572-00392777-00393148": "are we going to turn that around I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01573-00393149-00393370": "didn't hear any proposals about that and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01574-00393371-00393631": "I'd like to put that question and maybe", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01575-00393632-00393886": "one if you allow me one plug for the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01576-00393887-00394177": "Buddhist Bank in Germany actually", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01577-00394178-00394381": "also have a euro critical party but it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01578-00394382-00394591": "stayed at 11 12 percent which is more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01579-00394592-00394819": "than enough but I think the steadfast", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01580-00394820-00395110": "and you know effective defense the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01581-00395111-00395281": "Bundesbank put up for negative interest", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01582-00395282-00395584": "rate policies for target balances for QE", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01583-00395585-00395794": "in Germany you know in the police bang", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01584-00395795-00395986": "is a trusted organization and I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01585-00395987-00396190": "that really kept the trust in these", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01586-00396191-00396421": "policies among their population as a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01587-00396422-00396739": "site plug thank you thank you Stan", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01588-00396740-00397074": "Fischer", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01589-00397075-00397762": "so I Richard versus Stan Stan thanks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01590-00397763-00398200": "Rick Ricardo I think you are ignoring", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01591-00398201-00398809": "history the IMF as a neutral lender of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01592-00398810-00399147": "last resort which is not fiscal ask", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01593-00399148-00399676": "slash habla what happened in Greece it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01594-00399677-00400009": "was done by the fiscal authorities so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01595-00400010-00400294": "there is no lender of last resort that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01596-00400295-00400642": "does not end up inflicting something on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01597-00400643-00400990": "the fiscal authorities and don't prevent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01598-00400991-00401257": "it because one day if you really prevent", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01599-00401258-00401671": "it you will get into a huge crisis okay", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01600-00401672-00402007": "right behind you Richards and then our", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01601-00402008-00402193": "Iran and then I'm going to cut it at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01602-00402194-00402517": "that point I won't go into the rather", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01603-00402518-00402781": "difficult issue of macro Peru and the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01604-00402782-00402925": "relationship between macro crew and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01605-00402926-00403219": "monetary policy but focus on macro Pro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01606-00403220-00403543": "number of people did and we have I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01607-00403544-00404160": "a rather curious situation in Europe the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01608-00404161-00404514": "macro Peru authority first of all the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01609-00404515-00404917": "review of the institution's did not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01610-00404918-00405184": "significantly enhance the role of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01611-00405185-00405343": "European systemic risk board although it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01612-00405344-00405757": "did for asthma and second we have this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01613-00405758-00406120": "as I say curious position in which we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01614-00406121-00406354": "have the ESRB on the one hand and a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01615-00406355-00406774": "substantial macro crew capacity in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01616-00406775-00406918": "European Central Bank on the other hand", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01617-00406919-00407159": "yes the ESRB is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01618-00407160-00407630": "the entire EU and the ECB is just the 19", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01619-00407631-00407957": "but my observation suggests that there's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01620-00407958-00408218": "not much coordination relationship", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01621-00408219-00408374": "between the two and that you could", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01622-00408375-00408692": "strengthen significantly macro policy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01623-00408693-00408911": "even without the power to tell", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01624-00408912-00409160": "individual countries what to do you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01625-00409161-00409397": "could strengthen macro prove policy by a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01626-00409398-00409598": "better integration between those two", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01627-00409599-00410787": "Thank You Olli Rehn", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01628-00410788-00411081": "thank you many thanks and my question", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01629-00411082-00411524": "leaks to the lessons learned concerning", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01630-00411525-00411897": "unconventional measures and it could", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01631-00411897-00412262": "also link to what Peter was referring to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01632-00412263-00412524": "further clarification of monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01633-00412525-00412859": "strategy and Laurence was referring to a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01634-00412860-00413239": "review of monetary policy frameworks", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01635-00413241-00413609": "namely the paper of Philip Hartman and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01636-00413610-00413988": "Frank Smith's have an int he grows an", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01637-00413989-00414372": "interesting comparison concerning the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01638-00414372-00414767": "asset purchases and their effect and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01639-00414768-00415074": "based on this cooperation it appears", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01640-00415075-00415455": "that the asset purchase is during the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01641-00415456-00415760": "crisis probably had a more modest effect", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01642-00415762-00416184": "on output in the euro area than in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01643-00416185-00416810": "US and in the UK so in your view what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01644-00416812-00417114": "could explain these differences between", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01645-00417114-00417534": "the euro area and the US UK is it the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01646-00417535-00417797": "timing because the u.s. started it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01647-00417799-00418259": "earlier than the euro area second is it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01648-00418260-00418722": "the structure of asset purchases in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01649-00418722-00419109": "US the QE one especially was more", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01650-00419110-00419393": "effective buying a private sector", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01651-00419395-00419939": "securities and third or third was it the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01652-00419941-00420143": "structure of the financial system", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01653-00420145-00420363": "because as we know the euro area has a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01654-00420364-00420684": "more Bank based financing system than", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01655-00420685-00420918": "than the United States so which of these", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01656-00420918-00421179": "would explain the effect because this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01657-00421180-00421445": "also may have a short term implications", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01658-00421446-00421747": "as appropriate if needed", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01659-00421749-00422201": "Thank You Allie so we've got a range of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01660-00422202-00422376": "contributions there some mix of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01661-00422377-00422652": "questions and comments so I'm going to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01662-00422653-00422955": "ask in turn the panelists to respond but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01663-00422956-00423164": "maybe also bear in mind that since we're", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01664-00423166-00423443": "over running unfortunately won't go to a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01665-00423445-00423582": "second round of questions so those of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01666-00423583-00423872": "you have more questions you can just", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01667-00423872-00424166": "in a Overland approach deep the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01668-00424167-00424343": "panelists so Peter", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01669-00424343-00424945": "so for fossa I would be careful not to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01670-00424946-00425168": "transform the second pillar into a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01671-00425168-00425387": "financial stability pillar I would be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01672-00425388-00425560": "cautious we have to reflect on this I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01673-00425561-00425914": "think the the money and credit now is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01674-00425915-00426128": "extremely useful to have a focus on the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01675-00426129-00426479": "transmission I think more important I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01676-00426480-00426689": "mean that's one point so I would stick", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01677-00426689-00427031": "to that but the question is to one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01678-00427032-00427345": "extent should you in the conversation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01679-00427346-00427635": "introduce more in a more systematic way", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01680-00427636-00427864": "financial stability consideration", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01681-00427865-00428116": "question mark and I say we have to be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01682-00428117-00428410": "careful about this because you you yet", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01683-00428411-00428714": "very often different time horizons and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01684-00428714-00428941": "you want at the end of the day to take", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01685-00428942-00429224": "decisions sorry to say that but so it's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01686-00429225-00429310": "something you have to think very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01687-00429311-00429701": "carefully what leads us to say that is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01688-00429702-00429905": "that when you look at what happened", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01689-00429906-00430109": "before the crisis you see this huge", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01690-00430110-00430289": "expansion of credit which we don't see", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01691-00430289-00430495": "today but do use the expansion of credit", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01692-00430496-00430727": "and we said well there are some website", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01693-00430728-00430937": "ways for price stability linked to the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01694-00430938-00431207": "second pillar I think God bit shot on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01695-00431208-00431447": "the ball you see it it's a very strong", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01696-00431447-00431726": "signal of trouble much later on and that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01697-00431727-00431930": "didn't really come sufficient it came I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01698-00431931-00432137": "know because I read also the speeches at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01699-00432138-00432362": "that time it came in the communication", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01700-00432363-00432610": "but we didn't have at that time a macro", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01701-00432611-00432782": "Prudential framework and the instruments", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01702-00432783-00432908": "because you would have increased the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01703-00432909-00433214": "rates at that time to master a little", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01704-00433214-00433352": "bit that there would not have worked", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01705-00433353-00433541": "because we would have you know increase", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01706-00433542-00433693": "the rates too much you know it would", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01707-00433694-00433870": "have killed the economy immediately so I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01708-00433871-00434110": "say before jumping to that conclusion I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01709-00434111-00434293": "would be very careful for the time being", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01710-00434294-00434564": "I think it's transmission but I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01711-00434564-00434756": "how do you bring in the conversation or", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01712-00434757-00434927": "the financial stability a consideration", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01713-00434928-00435182": "that we have given also the fact that we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01714-00435183-00435266": "say you have fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01715-00435267-00435395": "you have monetary policy any of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01716-00435396-00435620": "macro-prudential the sort of tools and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01717-00435621-00435800": "at some points you need to put these", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01718-00435801-00435935": "things together in the inner", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01719-00435935-00436114": "conversation that's only the thing I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01720-00436115-00436550": "said the the the question also which I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01721-00436551-00437012": "think only about the QE in the US you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01722-00437013-00437252": "should ask Frank I am NOT", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01723-00437253-00437543": "right in what they I have a sort of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01724-00437543-00437753": "degree of skepticism about this about", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01725-00437754-00437930": "you know the reason is basically what", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01726-00437931-00438110": "you said is very different sort of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01727-00438110-00438514": "environment and QE per se you cannot see", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01728-00438516-00438797": "a per se QE because it was part of a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01729-00438797-00439037": "complex set of instrument interacting", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01730-00439038-00439196": "with Israel and so it's very difficult", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01731-00439197-00439457": "to disentangle this different thing the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01732-00439458-00439691": "only thing I can say is that there was a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01733-00439692-00439970": "dramatic easing of financial conditions", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01734-00439971-00440180": "at the end of the day and I don't know", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01735-00440181-00440432": "what the transmission I think what you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01736-00440433-00440668": "said on the on the risk channel I have a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01737-00440670-00440885": "bit difficulty when you say we have to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01738-00440885-00441139": "target directly the risk premium we do", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01739-00441141-00441464": "when we buy bonds we do that actually so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01740-00441464-00441685": "that we do it already we do it", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01741-00441687-00441910": "indirectly via the portfolio rebalancing", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01742-00441910-00442262": "are you suggesting suggesting that we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01743-00442263-00442529": "have to go directly into other classes", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01744-00442530-00442763": "of assets to compress you know risk", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01745-00442764-00443110": "renea like credit high credit risk sort", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01746-00443112-00443453": "of assets or even equity premium I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01747-00443454-00443576": "that's something that you have to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01748-00443577-00443816": "reflect carefully before you say that in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01749-00443817-00443993": "public there are many many different", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01750-00443993-00444149": "implications and also political", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01751-00444150-00444416": "implication if you join so we prefer to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01752-00444417-00444647": "do it indirectly basically except for", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01753-00444647-00444839": "some classes well defined class of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01754-00444839-00445093": "assets but saying you know that has to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01755-00445095-00445295": "be the new policy I think you have to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01756-00445296-00445475": "think carefully about that okay thank", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01757-00445476-00445871": "you Peter Adler all so I'm gonna be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01758-00445872-00446089": "quite quick and I think I'd focus on", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01759-00446089-00446399": "fiscal for finance and monetary policy I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01760-00446400-00446689": "I think I agree with Stan that it's you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01761-00446691-00446872": "need a fiscal backstop for a lender of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01762-00446874-00447139": "last resort you need a fiscal backstop", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01763-00447141-00447416": "for banks resolution at some stage I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01764-00447417-00447587": "don't think the safe asset you've", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01765-00447588-00447821": "described is actually a euro safe I said", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01766-00447822-00448039": "the one you described is the blunt and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01767-00448041-00448283": "we have it or we can do risk weighted", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01768-00448284-00448495": "assets of what exists in the euro area", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01769-00448496-00448781": "and I think that for micro Stabilization", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01770-00448782-00449021": "we also need to have a fiscal complement", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01771-00449022-00449339": "today especially when monetary poise is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01772-00449339-00449507": "where it is and especially when there is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01773-00449508-00449762": "such a mounting backlash against the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01774-00449763-00449966": "independence of central bank the burdens", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01775-00449967-00450268": "needs to be shared and I don't think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01776-00450268-00450437": "again", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01777-00450438-00450668": "that actually there's so much difference", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01778-00450669-00451043": "between France and Germany I think 2009", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01779-00451044-00451266": "tepees that showed that it actually can", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01780-00451267-00451551": "be the case that we think the same where", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01781-00451552-00451812": "the difference is is probably how much", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01782-00451813-00452091": "transfer or how do we do how funds in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01783-00452092-00452339": "Germany do organize the transfer but but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01784-00452340-00452556": "essentially when faced with a crisis", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01785-00452557-00452820": "both country react in the same way and I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01786-00452821-00452934": "would just like to finish with a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01787-00452935-00453147": "sentence which I can't remember who said", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01788-00453147-00453309": "that but I think it's so true that I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01789-00453310-00453568": "repeat it it's anglo-saxons have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01790-00453569-00454077": "Europeans we have always underestimated", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01791-00454078-00454320": "the economic cost of the European", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01792-00454321-00454535": "monetary union but Anglo Saxon have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01793-00454536-00454722": "always underestimated the political", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01794-00454722-00454959": "commitment for the European Union okay", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01795-00454960-00455352": "thank you Marcus yes so let me just not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01796-00455353-00455529": "yet I'm all about building bridges", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01797-00455530-00455789": "across any ravaging particularly the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01798-00455790-00456030": "River Rhine and that the reason is to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01799-00456031-00456177": "highlight the differences in order to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01800-00456178-00456525": "overcome them very much appreciate your", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01801-00456526-00456722": "clothes intervention about increases in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01802-00456723-00456927": "public wages and perhaps you should have", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01803-00456928-00457095": "not on inflation target but also", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01804-00457096-00457305": "inflation is divergence targets so if", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01805-00457306-00457434": "there's some diversions that we really", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01806-00457435-00457905": "point out to that I very much applaud", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01807-00457906-00458109": "you know the macro potential instruments", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01808-00458110-00458247": "are integrated in a broader framework", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01809-00458247-00458505": "rather than just treating it as totally", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01810-00458506-00458855": "separate with regard to only greens", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01811-00458856-00459081": "questions on unconventional monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01812-00459082-00459453": "policy in my view what you saw in the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01813-00459454-00459722": "United States is that what really worked", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01814-00459723-00459893": "were the purchase of mortgage-backed", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01815-00459894-00460145": "securities so buying US Treasuries as a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01816-00460146-00460431": "QE measure did not have much impact but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01817-00460432-00460584": "buying mortgage-backed securities had", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01818-00460585-00460800": "huge impact why first there was a rule", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01819-00460801-00460941": "only to buy new mortgage-backed", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01820-00460942-00461202": "securities so it really brought mortgage", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01821-00461203-00461418": "rates down and supported house prices", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01822-00461418-00461628": "and that made a huge difference to the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01823-00461629-00461735": "macro economy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01824-00461736-00461925": "similarly I think in more generally I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01825-00461926-00462129": "think whenever you depress credit", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01826-00462130-00462312": "spreads then it has some impact if you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01827-00462313-00462552": "just swap a long dated safe asset for a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01828-00462553-00462801": "short dated safe acid the impact is much", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01829-00462802-00463074": "much smaller and and the same thing in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01830-00463075-00463302": "in Europe if you buy German bonds", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01831-00463303-00463456": "probably as Vivian", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01832-00463457-00463654": "little impact on the German economy if", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01833-00463655-00463924": "you buy mobility country's sovereign", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01834-00463925-00464128": "debt and bring down their interest rate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01835-00464129-00464341": "and it has a much bigger impact so I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01836-00464342-00464532": "think that's where the focus should be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01837-00464533-00464830": "with regard to buying more risky assets", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01838-00464831-00465016": "I don't think you should target at this", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01839-00465017-00465225": "premium it just you should be aware", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01840-00465226-00465421": "through that it is premium how the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01841-00465422-00465634": "monetary channel how it really works at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01842-00465635-00465904": "the end of the day thank you Ricardo I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01843-00465905-00466108": "just reply very briefly to stand because", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01844-00466109-00466297": "I was a little troubled because I think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01845-00466297-00466441": "I failed at transmitting when I was a I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01846-00466442-00466582": "try to make three points and the first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01847-00466583-00466726": "one which now I understand at first", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01848-00466727-00466939": "probably preaching to the choir was to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01849-00466939-00467071": "say that all lender of last resort", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01850-00467072-00467266": "liquid operations are ultimately fiscal", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01851-00467267-00467455": "and I made that plain theory and you", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01852-00467456-00467629": "said that's what history shows and so I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01853-00467630-00467824": "completely agree all heartily that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01854-00467825-00467953": "history shows that lender of last resort", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01855-00467954-00468168": "is ultimately fiscal operation and that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01856-00468170-00468427": "was the first point I made for three or", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01857-00468428-00468564": "four minutes then I complement that with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01858-00468566-00468838": "two points which was one that because of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01859-00468839-00468979": "that and because the first lender of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01860-00468980-00469255": "last resort in Europe especially when we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01861-00469256-00469422": "have a single monetary and fragmented", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01862-00469424-00469593": "fiscal is very often the European", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01863-00469595-00469870": "Central Bank we therefore have to think", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01864-00469871-00470083": "hard about what is the independence and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01865-00470084-00470235": "separation in monetary and fiscal in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01866-00470237-00470410": "that setting which i think is a harder", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01867-00470410-00470605": "problem that history can teach us much", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01868-00470606-00470782": "about because we usually have one", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01869-00470783-00470938": "monitor in fiscal that can coordinate", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01870-00470939-00471157": "much better as happened in the United", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01871-00471158-00471339": "States as we see an interaction of Long", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01872-00471341-00471496": "Bear Stearns or Lehman between the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01873-00471497-00471664": "Treasury and the Fed which was very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01874-00471664-00471874": "active in terms of passing exactly being", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01875-00471875-00472018": "sent around to the other and which in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01876-00472018-00472243": "Europe I argued is harder and therefore", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01877-00472243-00472381": "a challenge for it and then my third", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01878-00472382-00472639": "point was that ECB had made some choices", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01879-00472639-00472839": "over this over the last ten years that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01880-00472841-00473028": "those probably preserve price stability", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01881-00473029-00473275": "may or may not have led to higher lower", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01882-00473276-00473488": "alpha welfare I left that open but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01883-00473489-00473616": "they're looking forward and here perhaps", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01884-00473617-00473847": "being more on the other side of her", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01885-00473849-00474034": "Rhine in terms of markets description I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01886-00474035-00474235": "asked for better rules better than Stan", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01887-00474235-00474433": "about institutions of exactly what will", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01888-00474434-00474649": "be the monetary fiscal separation when", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01889-00474650-00474843": "we discussed lender of last resort but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01890-00474845-00475066": "this all starting from point 1 which is", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01891-00475067-00475216": "lender of last resort in liquidity as", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01892-00475217-00475462": "history shows is inherently ultimately", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01893-00475463-00475687": "always a fiscal operation but one where", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01894-00475688-00475825": "the monetary authorities involved and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01895-00475826-00475978": "that's what I think triggered my", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01896-00475979-00476110": "discussion of that point so I could not", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01897-00476110-00476322": "agree more that history shows us that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01898-00476324-00476482": "that was the starting point of what I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01899-00476483-00476680": "was trying to bring to the light", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01900-00476681-00477016": "Thank You Ricardo let me just close at", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01901-00477017-00477250": "maybe with one minute of reflection", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01902-00477251-00477477": "before allowing Aaron to go to lunch", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01903-00477478-00477709": "first of all and I think this is a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01904-00477710-00478066": "really fantastic panel which follows I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01905-00478067-00478228": "think a very important morning in terms", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01906-00478229-00478618": "of our understanding of ECB multi-policy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01907-00478618-00479050": "of convergence and so on let me just", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01908-00479051-00479254": "respond to two points that came up with", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01909-00479255-00479647": "Ali on a QE I we heard this morning that", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01910-00479647-00479902": "OMT was a version of QE in terms of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01911-00479903-00480160": "bringing down the spreads so in terms of", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01912-00480160-00480520": "working at the overall impact of East be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01913-00480521-00480757": "unconventional policies we have to", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01914-00480758-00481003": "laughter that and second it came up", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01915-00481004-00481177": "repeatedly especially from Marcus and", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01916-00481178-00481453": "Ricardo and Ricardo's issue bad", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01917-00481454-00481759": "preferences are about inflation at a", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01918-00481760-00482022": "national level I mean I think it's very", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01919-00482024-00482191": "important issue about regional price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01920-00482192-00482416": "divergences but these are always going", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01921-00482417-00482626": "to be a finite and temporary because", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01922-00482627-00482875": "it's not the case you can apparently", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01923-00482876-00483079": "have an inflation differential there", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01924-00483080-00483310": "they're self-correcting and so what's", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01925-00483310-00483607": "interesting about the divergence is in", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01926-00483608-00483841": "some years there might be Germany below", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01927-00483842-00484003": "or above in another year it might be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01928-00484004-00484195": "Spain and so on so in terms of the", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01929-00484196-00484420": "coherence of the monetary union that we", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01930-00484421-00484743": "all have a common mistake in a monetary", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01931-00484745-00484989": "stability price stability but", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01932-00484991-00485170": "recognizing that these are real price", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01933-00485171-00485437": "movements may be persistent but they're", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01934-00485438-00485685": "not permanent they're persistent so I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01935-00485687-00485863": "personally wouldn't call this inflation", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01936-00485864-00486139": "you know it's rather price adjustment so", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01937-00486139-00486409": "with that I'm sure you'll all be", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01938-00486410-00486660": "discussing these topics over lunch I", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01939-00486662-00486868": "think we made some progress this morning", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01940-00486868-00487143": "so thank you to everyone and enjoy enjoy", "S3IZ1XTxyHU-01941-00487145-00487368": "lunch"}}, {"audio_id": "S3VtyLl4Ou8", "text": {"S3VtyLl4Ou8-00000-00000137-00000465": "tobelo Indonesian bahasa tobelo is a", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00001-00000466-00000675": "North halmahera language spoken on the", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00002-00000676-00000861": "eastern Indonesian island of halmahera", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00003-00000861-00001052": "and on parts of several neighboring", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00004-00001053-00001347": "islands the tobelo speaking Heartland is", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00005-00001348-00001565": "in the district Indonesian kak ammidon", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00006-00001566-00001766": "of tobelo located on the western shore", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00007-00001767-00002091": "of Cal Bay the district capital also", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00008-00002092-00002295": "known as tobelo serves as a regional", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00009-00002296-00002499": "commercial and administrative center and", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00010-00002500-00002872": "is the largest settlement on halmahera", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00011-00002873-00003458": "dialects six principle dialects are", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00012-00003459-00003950": "generally recognized boarhog 1988 hell", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00013-00003951-00004979": "owaru bang da ting go lake pocket Kakuma", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00014-00004980-00005485": "to pop on to get ill or forest to bellow", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00015-00005486-00005786": "may constitute an additional dialectal", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00016-00005787-00005903": "variant but this has not been", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00017-00005904-00006132": "satisfactorily documented", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00018-00006133-00006498": "intelligibility is not great", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00019-00006500-00006706": "in addition based on cognition", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00020-00006706-00006967": "percentages in a basic vocabulary list", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00021-00006968-00007255": "for Hope 1988 identifies five other", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00022-00007256-00007450": "North halmahera and language varieties", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00023-00007451-00007645": "as dialects of the putative northeast", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00024-00007645-00007876": "halmahera in language together with", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00025-00007877-00007942": "tobelo", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00026-00007943-00008155": "these varieties are gelila laloux de", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00027-00008156-00008470": "model pas GU and Tavarua most speakers", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00028-00008471-00008683": "consider these to be distinct languages", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00029-00008684-00008869": "from tobelo although they do acknowledge", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00030-00008870-00009007": "a certain degree of mutual", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00031-00009008-00009269": "intelligibility", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00032-00009270-00009698": "phonology", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00033-00009699-00010185": "consonant consonant sounds in", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00034-00010186-00010424": "parentheses only occur in loanwords or", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00035-00010425-00010780": "in other tobelo dialects", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00036-00010781-00011320": "bowels mid front vowels can range from", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00037-00011321-00011706": "e2", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00038-00011707-00012093": "directionals", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00039-00012094-00012375": "most all of the 50 languages of Maluku", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00040-00012376-00012630": "have some sort of directional system at", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00041-00012631-00012825": "the least the up-down distinction seems", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00042-00012826-00013085": "to be an aerial feature but this brings", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00043-00013086-00013393": "up the chicken and the egg phenomenon", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00044-00013394-00013666": "is this directional system of in turn an", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00045-00013666-00013988": "origin or is it a mixture", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00046-00013988-00014255": "perhaps it is not a coincidence that the", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00047-00014256-00014457": "tobelo are the most widespread ethnic", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00048-00014458-00014565": "group in Maluku", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00049-00014566-00014750": "with sizeable immigrant population", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00050-00014751-00014961": "throughout the province we can at least", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00051-00014962-00015155": "be sure that the Malay directionals are", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00052-00015156-00015618": "that egg because Malay is spoken in", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00053-00015619-00015807": "western Indonesia does not use these", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00054-00015808-00016035": "directionals whereas Moluccan Malay uses", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00055-00016036-00016455": "direct counts of the tobelo terms vowel", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00056-00016456-00016800": "a TAS de Raadt lout", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00057-00016801-00017046": "tobelo directionals are described in", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00058-00017047-00017358": "taylor 1984", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00059-00017359-00017766": "tobelo directional adverbs occur on", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00060-00017767-00018048": "motion verbs to specify direction of", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00061-00018049-00018480": "motion announced to specify motion away", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00062-00018481-00018628": "from or toward an object this", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00063-00018629-00018858": "interpretation of directional adverbs is", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00064-00018859-00019039": "entirely context dependent", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00065-00019040-00019474": "for example if I meet you'll and words", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00066-00019475-00019662": "of the house this means that I'm headed", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00067-00019663-00019929": "inland from my house", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00068-00019930-00020127": "if I meet you see words of the house", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00069-00020128-00020316": "then it means I'm headed inland to the", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00070-00020317-00020550": "house", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00071-00020551-00020956": "references", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00072-00020957-00021791": "external links tobelo bible app", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00073-00021792-00022514": "further reading Holton Gary 2003 tobelo", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00074-00022515-00022869": "languages of the world materials 328", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00075-00022870-00023318": "Munich Li NCO am Europa ISBN three eight", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00076-00023319-00023748": "nine five eight six seven oh six three", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00077-00023749-00024205": "cutie Anton 1908 total or each hall inch", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00078-00024206-00024424": "worden book met Holland Tobel origin", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00079-00024425-00024837": "hats off gave s graven hich Nyhof", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00080-00024838-00025266": "cutie Anton 1908 Oh - Bella Hoka manga", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00081-00025267-00025470": "todo de ver holland and ver telling an", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00082-00025471-00025797": "indictable orici tall by Dragan Todd -", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00083-00025798-00026088": "tall land and Vulcan kunde 61 point one", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00084-00026089-00026365": "two 318", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00085-00026366-00026827": "cuting Anton 1936 ie T's / despot", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00086-00026828-00027107": "Constanta Toba lorry she tall by Dragan", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00087-00027108-00027352": "Todd - tall land and Vulcan kunde ninety", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00088-00027353-00027533": "four point two nine five two four", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00089-00027533-00027758": "hundred seven", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00090-00027759-00028142": "Taylor Paul Michael 1984 Tovah Laurie's", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00091-00028143-00028340": "dykes Asst anthropological linguistics", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00092-00028341-00028607": "twenty six point one zero two two twenty", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00093-00028608-00028814": "two", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00094-00028814-00029212": "for ho CL 1988 the languages of the", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00095-00029213-00029443": "northern halmahera in stock papers in", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00096-00029444-00029671": "New Guinea linguistics number twenty six", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00097-00029672-00029852": "one hundred eighty one to two hundred", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00098-00029852-00030251": "nine Pacific linguistics a 76 Canberra", "S3VtyLl4Ou8-00099-00030252-00030587": "Australian National University"}}, {"audio_id": "S46czoMhctQ", "text": {"S46czoMhctQ-00000-00001452-00001746": "so can we start by having you say and", "S46czoMhctQ-00001-00001747-00001968": "spell your name yes my name is Rebecca", "S46czoMhctQ-00002-00001969-00002583": "Stan's our EBE c CA SP ence awesome so", "S46czoMhctQ-00003-00002584-00002922": "today is Wednesday June 26th ah we are", "S46czoMhctQ-00004-00002923-00003251": "at Harbor farmhouse ales and we are", "S46czoMhctQ-00005-00003252-00003525": "talking with Rebecca suspense about four", "S46czoMhctQ-00006-00003526-00003876": "well crafted in C sir thank you", "S46czoMhctQ-00007-00003877-00003996": "can you tell us a little bit about", "S46czoMhctQ-00008-00003997-00004247": "yourself and about your background yes", "S46czoMhctQ-00009-00004248-00004659": "sue I live in Greensboro with my husband", "S46czoMhctQ-00010-00004660-00005436": "and we moved out here 2015 grew up down", "S46czoMhctQ-00011-00005437-00005556": "on the coast moved out here to", "S46czoMhctQ-00012-00005557-00005900": "Greensboro in 2015 and I was trying to", "S46czoMhctQ-00013-00005901-00006122": "get back into the brewing industry I had", "S46czoMhctQ-00014-00006123-00006488": "managed to find my way there early on in", "S46czoMhctQ-00015-00006489-00006912": "2013 and it took a little while but it", "S46czoMhctQ-00016-00006913-00007158": "may eventually found saxophone", "S46czoMhctQ-00017-00007159-00007442": "oh and the rest is kind of history", "S46czoMhctQ-00018-00007443-00007814": "awesome um so let's talk a little bit", "S46czoMhctQ-00019-00007815-00007983": "about how you how you got here", "S46czoMhctQ-00020-00007984-00008135": "so what was kind of your first foray", "S46czoMhctQ-00021-00008136-00008835": "into brewing okay yeah so 2013 well", "S46czoMhctQ-00022-00008836-00009048": "probably should start 2012 so twenty", "S46czoMhctQ-00023-00009049-00009206": "twelve moved out to Greensboro to go to", "S46czoMhctQ-00024-00009207-00009546": "UNCG did a year there and then over", "S46czoMhctQ-00025-00009547-00009723": "summer break my best friend and I were", "S46czoMhctQ-00026-00009724-00009876": "living together we moved back home to", "S46czoMhctQ-00027-00009877-00010080": "the coast on the Outer Banks", "S46czoMhctQ-00028-00010081-00010445": "so Jarvis Berg curry talk area and", "S46czoMhctQ-00029-00010446-00010698": "that's where the weeping radish is right", "S46czoMhctQ-00030-00010699-00010884": "now so they had moved from manio down", "S46czoMhctQ-00031-00010885-00011166": "curry tuck several years earlier through", "S46czoMhctQ-00032-00011167-00011489": "her I ended up working over there and", "S46czoMhctQ-00033-00011490-00011691": "that was my first experience started off", "S46czoMhctQ-00034-00011692-00011846": "front of house so doing a lot of their", "S46czoMhctQ-00035-00011847-00012167": "retail beer sales I'm sorry yeah retail", "S46czoMhctQ-00036-00012168-00012366": "for yourselves and then butchery stuff", "S46czoMhctQ-00037-00012367-00012674": "and through that kind of got into craft", "S46czoMhctQ-00038-00012675-00012974": "beer a little bit more so I got into a", "S46czoMhctQ-00039-00012975-00013155": "little bit right after I turned 21 but", "S46czoMhctQ-00040-00013156-00013374": "it wasn't wasn't taking advantage of", "S46czoMhctQ-00041-00013375-00013616": "like the Greensboro beer culture yet so", "S46czoMhctQ-00042-00013618-00013815": "when we moved home started to get into a", "S46czoMhctQ-00043-00013816-00014091": "little bit more of that and then they", "S46czoMhctQ-00044-00014091-00014229": "needed help back in the brewery because", "S46czoMhctQ-00045-00014230-00014403": "summers are obviously crazy down there", "S46czoMhctQ-00046-00014404-00014613": "so they needed an extra pair of hands", "S46czoMhctQ-00047-00014613-00014658": "and I said", "S46czoMhctQ-00048-00014659-00014910": "it off beer monkey washing kegs filling", "S46czoMhctQ-00049-00014911-00015161": "liter bottles washing liter bottles kind", "S46czoMhctQ-00050-00015162-00015285": "of connecting the back and the front", "S46czoMhctQ-00051-00015286-00015500": "together and that's how I got interested", "S46czoMhctQ-00052-00015501-00015713": "in craft beer and got into the beer", "S46czoMhctQ-00053-00015715-00015954": "industry at the same time I'll beat it", "S46czoMhctQ-00054-00015955-00016211": "in like a really small way but it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00055-00016212-00016502": "great and it makes me happy obviously", "S46czoMhctQ-00056-00016503-00016811": "that that's how the industry still works", "S46czoMhctQ-00057-00016812-00017030": "you can start small and then kind of", "S46czoMhctQ-00058-00017031-00017228": "work your way up and that's that's", "S46czoMhctQ-00059-00017229-00017408": "exactly what happened I was there in", "S46czoMhctQ-00060-00017409-00017693": "both capacities for a little while until", "S46czoMhctQ-00061-00017694-00018015": "we moved back out to Greensboro a few", "S46czoMhctQ-00062-00018016-00018222": "years later and then from there I", "S46czoMhctQ-00063-00018223-00018417": "started home brewing doing a lot of", "S46czoMhctQ-00064-00018418-00018636": "spontaneous fermentation experiments", "S46czoMhctQ-00065-00018637-00018725": "things like that", "S46czoMhctQ-00066-00018726-00019022": "food fermentation so kind of just", "S46czoMhctQ-00067-00019023-00019263": "wanting to grow my body of knowledge and", "S46czoMhctQ-00068-00019264-00019413": "experiment and play with the actual", "S46czoMhctQ-00069-00019414-00019668": "fermentation side of things so a few", "S46czoMhctQ-00070-00019669-00019955": "years later yeah probably two years", "S46czoMhctQ-00071-00019956-00020277": "later ended up following a buddy out", "S46czoMhctQ-00072-00020278-00020450": "here when they needed the help in the", "S46czoMhctQ-00073-00020451-00020669": "same capacity so I bear monkeyed around", "S46czoMhctQ-00074-00020670-00021030": "until they needed help as an assistant", "S46czoMhctQ-00075-00021031-00021669": "brewer and you mentioned UNCG what were", "S46czoMhctQ-00076-00021670-00022025": "you studying at UNCG so I was doing I", "S46czoMhctQ-00077-00022026-00022272": "was studying history actually I study", "S46czoMhctQ-00078-00022273-00022524": "history and I took a couple of their", "S46czoMhctQ-00079-00022525-00022658": "theatre classes as well because that's", "S46czoMhctQ-00080-00022659-00022900": "always been like a corollary interest so", "S46czoMhctQ-00081-00022901-00023193": "not anything sciency which is a little", "S46czoMhctQ-00082-00023194-00023450": "weird that was always more of a side", "S46czoMhctQ-00083-00023451-00024275": "project for me pretty handy so you know", "S46czoMhctQ-00084-00024276-00024533": "you talked about kind of starting I", "S46czoMhctQ-00085-00024534-00024656": "guess you started on an industrial", "S46czoMhctQ-00086-00024657-00024867": "system then went home brewing and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00087-00024868-00025089": "went back yeah I haven't really it's a", "S46czoMhctQ-00088-00025090-00025253": "weird background when you look at it cuz", "S46czoMhctQ-00089-00025254-00025452": "a lot of people either start from doing", "S46czoMhctQ-00090-00025453-00025662": "like they start the school background", "S46czoMhctQ-00091-00025663-00025827": "they go and they do brewing Kyle or a", "S46czoMhctQ-00092-00025827-00026033": "brewing school trade school and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00093-00026034-00026237": "they jump right into the commercial side", "S46czoMhctQ-00094-00026238-00026376": "of it or you've got home brewers who", "S46czoMhctQ-00095-00026377-00026625": "work your way up and you still jump in", "S46czoMhctQ-00096-00026626-00027018": "as Brewer but yeah mine was way back and", "S46czoMhctQ-00097-00027019-00027210": "forth started off doing", "S46czoMhctQ-00098-00027211-00027389": "I didn't brew while I was there I start", "S46czoMhctQ-00099-00027391-00027543": "I was able to help with a couple of", "S46czoMhctQ-00100-00027544-00027764": "small things regarding the brewing but", "S46czoMhctQ-00101-00027765-00027914": "it was more cellaring and package", "S46czoMhctQ-00102-00027915-00028097": "and just kind of learning through a", "S46czoMhctQ-00103-00028098-00028436": "through absorption and then yeah just", "S46czoMhctQ-00104-00028437-00028598": "kind of flip-flopped it around a little", "S46czoMhctQ-00105-00028599-00029018": "bit yeah so can you talk about some of", "S46czoMhctQ-00106-00029019-00029246": "the resources that you've drawn on just", "S46czoMhctQ-00107-00029247-00029582": "to learn and teach yourself or learn", "S46czoMhctQ-00108-00029583-00030101": "from others yeah so I think the first I", "S46czoMhctQ-00109-00030102-00030332": "do a lot of talking to people", "S46czoMhctQ-00110-00030333-00030557": "the assistant Brewers wherever I go", "S46czoMhctQ-00111-00030558-00030800": "or the wherever I go the two breweries", "S46czoMhctQ-00112-00030801-00031107": "I've worked at I've always been put", "S46czoMhctQ-00113-00031108-00031316": "right there with the assistant Brewers", "S46czoMhctQ-00114-00031317-00031574": "which is great because I there", "S46czoMhctQ-00115-00031575-00031860": "mounds of reasons of just information", "S46czoMhctQ-00116-00031861-00032069": "you know ed Brewers are more often than", "S46czoMhctQ-00117-00032070-00032198": "not busy if you're lucky enough to have", "S46czoMhctQ-00118-00032199-00032448": "okay head brewer assistant brewer and", "S46czoMhctQ-00119-00032449-00032610": "then your packaging crew your cellar", "S46czoMhctQ-00120-00032611-00032885": "crew more more organization than most", "S46czoMhctQ-00121-00032886-00033035": "breweries have got because", "S46czoMhctQ-00122-00033036-00033467": "tight tight crews around around here but", "S46czoMhctQ-00123-00033468-00033704": "if you can go on to somebody who knows", "S46czoMhctQ-00124-00033705-00033977": "and then just pick their brains so I did", "S46czoMhctQ-00125-00033978-00034154": "a lot of that with Chase when he was", "S46czoMhctQ-00126-00034155-00034475": "assistant brewer and then Corey was our", "S46czoMhctQ-00127-00034476-00034649": "system brewer over at the weeping radish", "S46czoMhctQ-00128-00034650-00034943": "so got to talk to them a lot and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00129-00034944-00035207": "outside of being around people who I", "S46czoMhctQ-00130-00035208-00035486": "could kind of question like that a lot", "S46czoMhctQ-00131-00035487-00035741": "of reading some of the Brewers", "S46czoMhctQ-00132-00035742-00035969": "Association publications a lot of those", "S46czoMhctQ-00133-00035970-00036125": "books that really enjoy still working my", "S46czoMhctQ-00134-00036126-00036354": "way through some of them chase it was", "S46czoMhctQ-00135-00036355-00036529": "nice enough to lend me some of his", "S46czoMhctQ-00136-00036530-00036911": "textbooks from from the Wake Tech", "S46czoMhctQ-00137-00036912-00037082": "program so those have been really", "S46czoMhctQ-00138-00037083-00037361": "informative and then like just I mean", "S46czoMhctQ-00139-00037362-00037511": "you get a while here and one know about", "S46czoMhctQ-00140-00037512-00037673": "loggers like there are so many good", "S46czoMhctQ-00141-00037674-00038150": "resources online a lot of a lot of the", "S46czoMhctQ-00142-00038151-00038604": "more official web sites have like more", "S46czoMhctQ-00143-00038605-00038829": "in-depth and science side of it which I", "S46czoMhctQ-00144-00038830-00039123": "really enjoy so that kind of stuff and", "S46czoMhctQ-00145-00039124-00039800": "then one other oh yeah Sandor Katz is", "S46czoMhctQ-00146-00039801-00039962": "art of fermentation has been really", "S46czoMhctQ-00147-00039963-00040124": "informative for me yeah that's that's", "S46czoMhctQ-00148-00040125-00040323": "what got me into a lot of different", "S46czoMhctQ-00149-00040324-00040625": "things kind of the missing piece from", "S46czoMhctQ-00150-00040626-00040817": "the history major and then that's got a", "S46czoMhctQ-00151-00040818-00041067": "lot of cultural stuff so that got me", "S46czoMhctQ-00152-00041068-00041229": "interested in more of", "S46czoMhctQ-00153-00041230-00041364": "it bridged the gap and got me interested", "S46czoMhctQ-00154-00041365-00041535": "in the science side of it so from there", "S46czoMhctQ-00155-00041536-00041688": "on could go on and use it as a", "S46czoMhctQ-00156-00041689-00041979": "jumping-off point lots of books lots of", "S46czoMhctQ-00157-00041980-00042186": "podcast lots of talking to people yeah", "S46czoMhctQ-00158-00042187-00042522": "so here at however you know the beers", "S46czoMhctQ-00159-00042523-00042839": "are mainly Belgians hmm", "S46czoMhctQ-00160-00042840-00043167": "weeping radish is mostly lager yeah you", "S46czoMhctQ-00161-00043168-00043320": "talk a little bit about the differences", "S46czoMhctQ-00162-00043321-00043560": "there and maybe some of the differences", "S46czoMhctQ-00163-00043561-00043812": "not necessarily in terms of style but we", "S46czoMhctQ-00164-00043813-00044115": "can go into that too but process yeah", "S46czoMhctQ-00165-00044116-00044385": "and your your role in that oh turnaround", "S46czoMhctQ-00166-00044386-00044523": "time is the biggest one that people", "S46czoMhctQ-00167-00044524-00044589": "think about", "S46czoMhctQ-00168-00044590-00045033": "so lagers take their cold fermented and", "S46czoMhctQ-00169-00045034-00045291": "it takes you know different different", "S46czoMhctQ-00170-00045292-00045669": "process from fermentation side brewing", "S46czoMhctQ-00171-00045670-00045885": "is mostly the same for both lagers", "S46czoMhctQ-00172-00045886-00046020": "anything else dependent until you get", "S46czoMhctQ-00173-00046021-00046194": "into specific kinds of ales specific", "S46czoMhctQ-00174-00046195-00046530": "kinds of lagers but yeah you're looking", "S46czoMhctQ-00175-00046531-00046769": "at like a six to eight week turnaround", "S46czoMhctQ-00176-00046770-00047082": "cellar time for lagers and then for ales", "S46czoMhctQ-00177-00047083-00047453": "you know two to four depending so it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00178-00047454-00047772": "it's a different kind of product to you", "S46czoMhctQ-00179-00047773-00047991": "know lagers are associate with being a", "S46czoMhctQ-00180-00047992-00048390": "lot more crisp a lot more light but", "S46czoMhctQ-00181-00048391-00048561": "that's probably the biggest the biggest", "S46czoMhctQ-00182-00048562-00048711": "difference that I've noted between the", "S46czoMhctQ-00183-00048712-00049113": "two of them yeah so as a history nerd", "S46czoMhctQ-00184-00049114-00049329": "when you were working at weeping ratted", "S46czoMhctQ-00185-00049330-00049554": "you were you aware like the history of", "S46czoMhctQ-00186-00049555-00049677": "the place where you were working is that", "S46czoMhctQ-00187-00049678-00049845": "where the culture there oh definitely", "S46czoMhctQ-00188-00049846-00050115": "yeah it's um it's not necessarily", "S46czoMhctQ-00189-00050116-00050232": "something that gets talked about on a", "S46czoMhctQ-00190-00050233-00050529": "daily basis but they've got tours that", "S46czoMhctQ-00191-00050530-00050676": "come through so you get to hear that a", "S46czoMhctQ-00192-00050677-00051095": "lot they've got a wall that details", "S46czoMhctQ-00193-00051096-00051345": "North Carolina breweries by gear so you", "S46czoMhctQ-00194-00051346-00051716": "can kind of see the growth over time but", "S46czoMhctQ-00195-00051717-00052008": "yeah with with Ely being kind of the", "S46czoMhctQ-00196-00052009-00052203": "grandfather of it all yet it's very", "S46czoMhctQ-00197-00052204-00052482": "present and for me it's a really", "S46czoMhctQ-00198-00052483-00052707": "historical area anyway so I was looking", "S46czoMhctQ-00199-00052708-00052902": "into that stuff to begin with and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00200-00052903-00053117": "especially with them initially being", "S46czoMhctQ-00201-00053119-00053354": "rooted in Manteo you know you start", "S46czoMhctQ-00202-00053355-00053595": "looking at any history over there bring", "S46czoMhctQ-00203-00053596-00053754": "it up to the present you're gonna run", "S46czoMhctQ-00204-00053754-00053979": "across like mile markers like that it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00205-00053979-00054264": "kind of kind of cool plus their new", "S46czoMhctQ-00206-00054265-00054344": "location", "S46czoMhctQ-00207-00054345-00054599": "wealth new location but where they are", "S46czoMhctQ-00208-00054600-00054827": "on the mainland now is about five", "S46czoMhctQ-00209-00054828-00055112": "minutes from my house so it was it was", "S46czoMhctQ-00210-00055113-00055366": "very present and I did a lot of looking", "S46czoMhctQ-00211-00055367-00055767": "into it prior to yeah it's really cool", "S46czoMhctQ-00212-00055769-00056353": "yeah so let's talk a little bit about", "S46czoMhctQ-00213-00056354-00056702": "your process here mid-fall River what", "S46czoMhctQ-00214-00056703-00056917": "does what does the brewing cycle look", "S46czoMhctQ-00215-00056919-00057239": "like here okay let's see particularly", "S46czoMhctQ-00216-00057240-00057440": "from your respect for me okay", "S46czoMhctQ-00217-00057441-00057695": "so I started off more doing seller stuff", "S46czoMhctQ-00218-00057696-00057998": "to begin with kind of learn and work", "S46czoMhctQ-00219-00057999-00058208": "into the production side a little bit", "S46czoMhctQ-00220-00058209-00058964": "more it comes in more on the well", "S46czoMhctQ-00221-00058965-00059162": "starting from the backend honestly like", "S46czoMhctQ-00222-00059163-00059354": "it's a weird way to think about it but", "S46czoMhctQ-00223-00059354-00060125": "if we like I started off doing more work", "S46czoMhctQ-00224-00060126-00060395": "with finished beer so bright tank on", "S46czoMhctQ-00225-00060396-00060653": "kegging things like that making sure our", "S46czoMhctQ-00226-00060654-00060860": "carbonation levels are right and some", "S46czoMhctQ-00227-00060861-00061082": "flavor adjustments that happen on the", "S46czoMhctQ-00228-00061083-00061319": "end of the process there and that was", "S46czoMhctQ-00229-00061320-00061622": "where I kind of got started with however", "S46czoMhctQ-00230-00061623-00061970": "doing more of that finished product type", "S46czoMhctQ-00231-00061971-00062205": "stuff under under direction and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00232-00062207-00062573": "working forward towards the actual like", "S46czoMhctQ-00233-00062574-00062750": "okay you start with the brewing and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00234-00062751-00062941": "working it through the different you got", "S46czoMhctQ-00235-00062942-00063067": "brewing then the fermentation process", "S46czoMhctQ-00236-00063069-00063407": "and then the finishing you know", "S46czoMhctQ-00237-00063408-00063578": "secondary fermentation and packaging", "S46czoMhctQ-00238-00063579-00063884": "kind of deal so I kind of learned it", "S46czoMhctQ-00239-00063885-00064157": "backwards but yeah looking at it now", "S46czoMhctQ-00240-00064158-00064436": "it's very nice to be able to be with the", "S46czoMhctQ-00241-00064437-00064646": "beer from start to finish and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00242-00064647-00064775": "learning a little bit more about the", "S46czoMhctQ-00243-00064776-00064973": "science that goes on in the middle of it", "S46czoMhctQ-00244-00064974-00065294": "right which I like I was using I was", "S46czoMhctQ-00245-00065295-00065426": "sneaking suspicion I knew the answer to", "S46czoMhctQ-00246-00065427-00065567": "this already but what's your favorite", "S46czoMhctQ-00247-00065568-00065930": "part yeah that's probably it the", "S46czoMhctQ-00248-00065931-00066203": "fermentation and just because it's it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00249-00066204-00066383": "fascinating to see how it's different", "S46czoMhctQ-00250-00066384-00066752": "from beer to beer and it makes me", "S46czoMhctQ-00251-00066753-00066911": "realize there's so much that I don't", "S46czoMhctQ-00252-00066912-00067127": "know about it if you're thinking about", "S46czoMhctQ-00253-00067128-00067355": "it from like a molecular level up you", "S46czoMhctQ-00254-00067356-00067530": "know it's really", "S46czoMhctQ-00255-00067531-00067833": "you don't see a lot of that but I love", "S46czoMhctQ-00256-00067834-00067989": "knowing that it's going on and knowing", "S46czoMhctQ-00257-00067990-00068142": "that all of these different factors that", "S46czoMhctQ-00258-00068143-00068547": "we have a hand in from start all the way", "S46czoMhctQ-00259-00068548-00068876": "through to fermentation affect how the", "S46czoMhctQ-00260-00068877-00069039": "beer is gonna finish how it's going to", "S46czoMhctQ-00261-00069040-00069231": "develop in the tank and then how it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00262-00069232-00069309": "going to finish", "S46czoMhctQ-00263-00069310-00069663": "yeah fermentation is definitely the most", "S46czoMhctQ-00264-00069664-00069819": "fascinating part of the process for me", "S46czoMhctQ-00265-00069820-00070122": "brewing is a ton of fun and the seller", "S46czoMhctQ-00266-00070123-00070299": "and the packaging that's the hard work", "S46czoMhctQ-00267-00070300-00070701": "part but but I very much enjoy the care", "S46czoMhctQ-00268-00070702-00070944": "of with the yeast and the work as", "S46czoMhctQ-00269-00070945-00071960": "fermentation goes on what is one of your", "S46czoMhctQ-00270-00071961-00072426": "I think most people in the brewing", "S46czoMhctQ-00271-00072427-00072582": "industry probably relate to this one", "S46czoMhctQ-00272-00072583-00073073": "it's the seller logistics so to speak um", "S46czoMhctQ-00273-00073074-00073371": "you you package the beer and then you", "S46czoMhctQ-00274-00073372-00073560": "have to have somewhere to put it like", "S46czoMhctQ-00275-00073561-00073755": "somewhere that's gonna be organized", "S46czoMhctQ-00276-00073756-00073959": "somewhere that's going to be the right", "S46czoMhctQ-00277-00073960-00074124": "temperature so that it is the same", "S46czoMhctQ-00278-00074125-00074289": "product that went into kegs when", "S46czoMhctQ-00279-00074290-00074523": "somebody here or down the road takes it", "S46czoMhctQ-00280-00074524-00074655": "out of the kegs", "S46czoMhctQ-00281-00074656-00074931": "so after care of the beer is something", "S46czoMhctQ-00282-00074932-00075240": "that I have had to make an effort to", "S46czoMhctQ-00283-00075241-00075605": "make a lot be way more mindful of", "S46czoMhctQ-00284-00075606-00075918": "because you know it's very easy okay", "S46czoMhctQ-00285-00075919-00076260": "it's done I was like no stop to take", "S46czoMhctQ-00286-00076261-00076386": "care of that and you put so much work", "S46czoMhctQ-00287-00076387-00076728": "into it so yeah the logistics after the", "S46czoMhctQ-00288-00076729-00077271": "fact or definitely not as wonderful I", "S46czoMhctQ-00289-00077272-00077432": "still can't say I don't like it because", "S46czoMhctQ-00290-00077433-00077628": "I like waited a long time to be in the", "S46czoMhctQ-00291-00077629-00078321": "industry so right specific styles and", "S46czoMhctQ-00292-00078322-00078519": "specific features so do you have a", "S46czoMhctQ-00293-00078520-00078714": "specific style of beer that's really", "S46czoMhctQ-00294-00078715-00079101": "like your favorite to breathe um here", "S46czoMhctQ-00295-00079102-00079392": "here versus at home are kind of two", "S46czoMhctQ-00296-00079393-00079611": "different answers like I love brewing", "S46czoMhctQ-00297-00079612-00079793": "and making mix culture beers at home", "S46czoMhctQ-00298-00079794-00079986": "because you get to play with it and it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00299-00079987-00080322": "way more way more unencumbered you know", "S46czoMhctQ-00300-00080323-00080505": "you know to a degree what you're gonna", "S46czoMhctQ-00301-00080506-00080694": "get but there's a lot of stuff that is", "S46czoMhctQ-00302-00080695-00080763": "just", "S46czoMhctQ-00303-00080764-00081036": "wild and wonderful so you can play with", "S46czoMhctQ-00304-00081037-00081156": "it plus you're not worrying about", "S46czoMhctQ-00305-00081157-00081338": "contaminating anything which is", "S46czoMhctQ-00306-00081339-00081529": "something that's just completely", "S46czoMhctQ-00307-00081530-00081768": "different on a production side so that's", "S46czoMhctQ-00308-00081769-00081847": "the fun part", "S46czoMhctQ-00309-00081848-00082104": "mix cultures sours at home definitely my", "S46czoMhctQ-00310-00082105-00082299": "favorite here I've really enjoyed", "S46czoMhctQ-00311-00082300-00082494": "getting to work with some of our darker", "S46czoMhctQ-00312-00082495-00082866": "beers that was something I did more at", "S46czoMhctQ-00313-00082867-00083148": "at home a lot of stuff that's what my", "S46czoMhctQ-00314-00083149-00083418": "family likes to drink so the like the", "S46czoMhctQ-00315-00083419-00083671": "Java berry cream stout the st. Benedict", "S46czoMhctQ-00316-00083672-00083898": "sprek this double and then some of our", "S46czoMhctQ-00317-00083899-00084162": "two barrels stuff love growing on our", "S46czoMhctQ-00318-00084163-00084316": "two barrel system I could probably say", "S46czoMhctQ-00319-00084317-00084543": "anything we brew over there but we've", "S46czoMhctQ-00320-00084544-00084847": "done a couple of hybrid beers I think of", "S46czoMhctQ-00321-00084848-00084966": "them as hybrid beers like beer two", "S46czoMhctQ-00322-00084967-00085161": "guards so we're using our saison yeast", "S46czoMhctQ-00323-00085162-00085360": "and then cold fermenting it like you", "S46czoMhctQ-00324-00085361-00085632": "would a lager so it really pulls from", "S46czoMhctQ-00325-00085633-00085826": "both traditions that I'm familiar with", "S46czoMhctQ-00326-00085827-00086116": "or Belgian becoming more familiar with", "S46czoMhctQ-00327-00086117-00086428": "but you get to do the German side of it", "S46czoMhctQ-00328-00086429-00086647": "with the lagering process I'll just you", "S46czoMhctQ-00329-00086648-00086923": "know pulls my heartstrings and then", "S46czoMhctQ-00330-00086924-00087225": "stuff that is very harder and that's", "S46czoMhctQ-00331-00087226-00087492": "those are probably my favorite favorite", "S46czoMhctQ-00332-00087493-00088240": "styles to do professionally a harbor", "S46czoMhctQ-00333-00088241-00088297": "beer", "S46czoMhctQ-00334-00088298-00088528": "oh well initially like right out the", "S46czoMhctQ-00335-00088529-00088743": "gate you know anything Belgian styles", "S46czoMhctQ-00336-00088744-00088984": "especially if you're looking at seasons", "S46czoMhctQ-00337-00088985-00089175": "in particular because I wasn't overly", "S46czoMhctQ-00338-00089176-00089353": "familiar with saison is coming into this", "S46czoMhctQ-00339-00089354-00089541": "brewery and it was like okay I have some", "S46czoMhctQ-00340-00089542-00089841": "research to do and then just paying a", "S46czoMhctQ-00341-00089842-00089965": "lot of attention to the hands-on", "S46czoMhctQ-00342-00089966-00090097": "learning part because it's it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00343-00090098-00090322": "different yes they're ales but they are", "S46czoMhctQ-00344-00090323-00090646": "like to me they're more mindfully", "S46czoMhctQ-00345-00090647-00090829": "crafted because you're looking at that", "S46czoMhctQ-00346-00090830-00091124": "Belgian farmhouse tradition so", "S46czoMhctQ-00347-00091125-00091329": "especially when you come into like some", "S46czoMhctQ-00348-00091330-00091494": "of the mixed culture stuff that we do it", "S46czoMhctQ-00349-00091495-00091915": "harkens back to that quite a bit but yes", "S46czoMhctQ-00350-00091916-00092128": "and you mentioned you know you mentioned", "S46czoMhctQ-00351-00092129-00092307": "a member owain laying around there what", "S46czoMhctQ-00352-00092308-00092416": "are some of your favorite things that", "S46czoMhctQ-00353-00092417-00092598": "you've played around with", "S46czoMhctQ-00354-00092599-00093010": "whether they worked or not yeah that's", "S46czoMhctQ-00355-00093011-00093160": "part of the fun of players yeah that I", "S46czoMhctQ-00356-00093161-00093763": "guess I'm trying to diversify or I am", "S46czoMhctQ-00357-00093764-00094042": "trying did try as well you don't get as", "S46czoMhctQ-00358-00094043-00094561": "much time to do it home but played", "S46czoMhctQ-00359-00094562-00094741": "around with trying to diversify the", "S46czoMhctQ-00360-00094742-00094924": "different styles I was brewing so", "S46czoMhctQ-00361-00094925-00095059": "getting to know some different strains", "S46czoMhctQ-00362-00095060-00095506": "of yeast and molds especially I need to", "S46czoMhctQ-00363-00095507-00095791": "need to keep expanding my hop repertoire", "S46czoMhctQ-00364-00095792-00096061": "I usually reference our resident IPA", "S46czoMhctQ-00365-00096062-00096580": "expert for that but let's see I would", "S46czoMhctQ-00366-00096581-00097009": "say probably so recently I had a gift", "S46czoMhctQ-00367-00097010-00097312": "beer that I brewed for somebody and it", "S46czoMhctQ-00368-00097313-00097696": "was a stout it was an Imperial Stout", "S46czoMhctQ-00369-00097697-00098088": "that we aged on red white red wine", "S46czoMhctQ-00370-00098089-00098463": "soaked wood chips and added cocoa nibs", "S46czoMhctQ-00371-00098464-00098674": "and secondary fermentation and that was", "S46czoMhctQ-00372-00098675-00098842": "probably one of my favorite ones that", "S46czoMhctQ-00373-00098843-00099112": "we've done just being us a week my", "S46czoMhctQ-00374-00099113-00099318": "husband helped collaborate on that beer", "S46czoMhctQ-00375-00099319-00099544": "but that was probably one of my favorite", "S46czoMhctQ-00376-00099545-00099850": "ones so far just because execution was a", "S46czoMhctQ-00377-00099851-00100054": "lot better and it was weird it was a", "S46czoMhctQ-00378-00100055-00100210": "bunch of stuff we hadn't tried before on", "S46czoMhctQ-00379-00100211-00100489": "the homebrew scale but outside of that I", "S46czoMhctQ-00380-00100490-00100894": "did a sour bar not a sour a mixed", "S46czoMhctQ-00381-00100895-00101098": "fermentation barley wine that aged out", "S46czoMhctQ-00382-00101099-00101623": "to be pretty fun you know kind of to go", "S46czoMhctQ-00383-00101624-00102144": "back to the history piece of things when", "S46czoMhctQ-00384-00102145-00102331": "you're working on the beers particularly", "S46czoMhctQ-00385-00102332-00102566": "at home are you thinking about like", "S46czoMhctQ-00386-00102567-00102829": "historical beers and how things have", "S46czoMhctQ-00387-00102830-00102957": "come along have you tried any of those", "S46czoMhctQ-00388-00102958-00103194": "so those are definitely on my list yeah", "S46czoMhctQ-00389-00103195-00103525": "right now I have done more oh gosh and", "S46czoMhctQ-00390-00103526-00103774": "it's been a while it wasn't necessarily", "S46czoMhctQ-00391-00103775-00104254": "a beer it was more of like a well there", "S46czoMhctQ-00392-00104255-00104491": "have been several more historical more", "S46czoMhctQ-00393-00104492-00104805": "culturally rooted fermentations that", "S46czoMhctQ-00394-00104806-00105009": "I've done but they weren't Lisa they", "S46czoMhctQ-00395-00105010-00105289": "weren't necessarily malt beverages but", "S46czoMhctQ-00396-00105290-00105463": "it definitely is something that when I'm", "S46czoMhctQ-00397-00105464-00105759": "looking into building out a recipe I go", "S46czoMhctQ-00398-00105760-00105928": "back and I look at how things have been", "S46czoMhctQ-00399-00105929-00106144": "done throughout the years and whether", "S46czoMhctQ-00400-00106145-00106327": "you're trying to do you know an accurate", "S46czoMhctQ-00401-00106328-00106515": "representation of the style or if you're", "S46czoMhctQ-00402-00106516-00106738": "trying to go sideways a little bit I", "S46czoMhctQ-00403-00106739-00106870": "think that information is really useful", "S46czoMhctQ-00404-00106871-00107131": "I have because it's gonna tell you it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00405-00107132-00107283": "gonna connect you to that beer for one", "S46czoMhctQ-00406-00107284-00107508": "which is something that's important to", "S46czoMhctQ-00407-00107509-00107934": "me as as a crafter you know having a", "S46czoMhctQ-00408-00107935-00108124": "connection to your product or whatever", "S46czoMhctQ-00409-00108125-00108510": "it is that you're doing and yeah the", "S46czoMhctQ-00410-00108511-00108781": "some of the historical beers I love", "S46czoMhctQ-00411-00108782-00108949": "looking through those recipes and", "S46czoMhctQ-00412-00108950-00109195": "reading them and it's informed a couple", "S46czoMhctQ-00413-00109196-00109354": "of the things that you know we do here", "S46czoMhctQ-00414-00109355-00109522": "everybody here is pretty good about that", "S46czoMhctQ-00415-00109523-00109825": "research aspect but yes I have got some", "S46czoMhctQ-00416-00109826-00110036": "of those on my list of what to do", "S46czoMhctQ-00417-00110038-00110281": "especially some of the like the molasses", "S46czoMhctQ-00418-00110282-00110508": "beers and the more herbal some of the", "S46czoMhctQ-00419-00110509-00110766": "weird recipes yeah yeah they're there in", "S46czoMhctQ-00420-00110767-00111493": "the books for sure kind of maybe how", "S46czoMhctQ-00421-00111494-00111625": "something like that was incorporated", "S46czoMhctQ-00422-00111626-00111874": "into a beer here at Fall River let's see", "S46czoMhctQ-00423-00111875-00112191": "a lot of times it's gonna be in like our", "S46czoMhctQ-00424-00112192-00112341": "pins and the Tyrians that would do a", "S46czoMhctQ-00425-00112342-00112519": "little one offs that we break off from", "S46czoMhctQ-00426-00112520-00112848": "the big batches the", "S46czoMhctQ-00427-00112849-00113283": "so I say that and the one I think of", "S46czoMhctQ-00428-00113284-00113435": "doesn't have anything to do with those", "S46czoMhctQ-00429-00113436-00113731": "well like when you're looking at the we", "S46czoMhctQ-00430-00113732-00114054": "did a sage and or we have coming up it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00431-00114055-00114271": "a sage and strawberry Newlands pen that", "S46czoMhctQ-00432-00114272-00114684": "we did and part of the sage came from", "S46czoMhctQ-00433-00114685-00114889": "well we've got it down there but when", "S46czoMhctQ-00434-00114890-00115065": "we're looking into how to use it I'll go", "S46czoMhctQ-00435-00115066-00115321": "through there's a book called sacred and", "S46czoMhctQ-00436-00115322-00115546": "herbal healing beers and it's got a lot", "S46czoMhctQ-00437-00115547-00115809": "of really weird like one-off recipes", "S46czoMhctQ-00438-00115810-00115990": "going back you know they're written in", "S46czoMhctQ-00439-00115991-00116152": "the Old English and it's not telling you", "S46czoMhctQ-00440-00116153-00116344": "pounds or ounces or whatever it's saying", "S46czoMhctQ-00441-00116345-00116679": "you know 1tu in any okay now I have to", "S46czoMhctQ-00442-00116680-00116863": "look up what that is and see what the", "S46czoMhctQ-00443-00116864-00116997": "reference is for okay", "S46czoMhctQ-00444-00116998-00117268": "but they have a section on stage they've", "S46czoMhctQ-00445-00117269-00117406": "got it all this different weird stuff", "S46czoMhctQ-00446-00117407-00117609": "you know so I'll go and I'll look into", "S46czoMhctQ-00447-00117610-00117858": "that and if we've got an idea from", "S46czoMhctQ-00448-00117859-00118057": "either chase says oh I've got this at", "S46czoMhctQ-00449-00118058-00118351": "home or we've got it here looking at", "S46czoMhctQ-00450-00118352-00118504": "that and seeing how other people have", "S46czoMhctQ-00451-00118505-00118608": "used it", "S46czoMhctQ-00452-00118609-00118868": "and kind of letting that maybe inform", "S46czoMhctQ-00453-00118869-00119084": "[Music]", "S46czoMhctQ-00454-00119085-00119413": "measurements to some degree so it takes", "S46czoMhctQ-00455-00119414-00119563": "a little extra research when it's that", "S46czoMhctQ-00456-00119564-00119776": "old but it's part of the fun for me yeah", "S46czoMhctQ-00457-00119777-00120016": "and when we did the the bearded guard on", "S46czoMhctQ-00458-00120017-00120258": "the two barrel system that one I", "S46czoMhctQ-00459-00120259-00120415": "definitely went back and I looked and", "S46czoMhctQ-00460-00120416-00120643": "said okay well this says ons we know", "S46czoMhctQ-00461-00120644-00120973": "about you know but what specifically", "S46czoMhctQ-00462-00120974-00121207": "about the bearded guard has been what's", "S46czoMhctQ-00463-00121208-00121402": "what's been representative of that beer", "S46czoMhctQ-00464-00121403-00121516": "throughout the years what makes it", "S46czoMhctQ-00465-00121517-00121666": "different from say Zhaan's or like a", "S46czoMhctQ-00466-00121667-00121891": "Grizz ed or it goes or something", "S46czoMhctQ-00467-00121892-00122158": "and then use that to build out my recipe", "S46czoMhctQ-00468-00122158-00122326": "to try and make it really representative", "S46czoMhctQ-00469-00122327-00122773": "of the style yeah so putting on your", "S46czoMhctQ-00470-00122774-00123139": "forward-thinking hey where where do you", "S46czoMhctQ-00471-00123140-00123346": "see you know brewery today is a lot", "S46czoMhctQ-00472-00123347-00123510": "different from when you first started", "S46czoMhctQ-00473-00123511-00123831": "and we can ravage oh yeah", "S46czoMhctQ-00474-00123832-00124069": "can you talk a little bit about the", "S46czoMhctQ-00475-00124070-00124240": "changes that have happened but also kind", "S46czoMhctQ-00476-00124241-00124444": "of how you see the trends moving forward", "S46czoMhctQ-00477-00124445-00124954": "yeah so it was very much IPAs when I was", "S46czoMhctQ-00478-00124955-00125346": "first in the brewing brewery setting and", "S46czoMhctQ-00479-00125347-00125821": "with that being said they were weeping", "S46czoMhctQ-00480-00125822-00126046": "radish wasn't necessarily like jumping", "S46czoMhctQ-00481-00126047-00126364": "on and do it it's the same here", "S46czoMhctQ-00482-00126365-00126658": "we don't necessarily jump on every trend", "S46czoMhctQ-00483-00126658-00126931": "that comes along but we've got stuff", "S46czoMhctQ-00484-00126932-00127153": "that is representative of the overall", "S46czoMhctQ-00485-00127154-00127425": "beer culture worked into our own", "S46czoMhctQ-00486-00127426-00127791": "personal credos so like you will have", "S46czoMhctQ-00487-00127792-00128065": "the Sun hands that we've got on right", "S46czoMhctQ-00488-00128066-00128230": "now is a good example you know happy", "S46czoMhctQ-00489-00128231-00128404": "stuff being really popular but it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00490-00128405-00128689": "still a belt and Gollum strong so with", "S46czoMhctQ-00491-00128690-00129019": "the stuff that that's popular that was", "S46czoMhctQ-00492-00129020-00129379": "popular than I mean yeah", "S46czoMhctQ-00493-00129380-00129844": "IPAs always and not being not having", "S46czoMhctQ-00494-00129845-00130254": "been on the production side of it", "S46czoMhctQ-00495-00130255-00130464": "then I couldn't really inform a whole", "S46czoMhctQ-00496-00130465-00130716": "lot as to the individual ingredients and", "S46czoMhctQ-00497-00130717-00130957": "stuff but one thing that was that was", "S46czoMhctQ-00498-00130958-00131199": "cool to see from the production", "S46czoMhctQ-00499-00131200-00131499": "standpoint was that's when they started", "S46czoMhctQ-00500-00131500-00131794": "using more North Carolina malts they got", "S46czoMhctQ-00501-00131795-00132010": "one of river bins first shipments when", "S46czoMhctQ-00502-00132011-00132177": "they first opened up which was super", "S46czoMhctQ-00503-00132178-00132423": "cool and then to see that perpetuate", "S46czoMhctQ-00504-00132424-00132675": "through to today you know now you've got", "S46czoMhctQ-00505-00132676-00132924": "a lot more local maltsters and a lot of", "S46czoMhctQ-00506-00132925-00133258": "people using them but style wise in the", "S46czoMhctQ-00507-00133259-00133548": "future I'm excited that people are", "S46czoMhctQ-00508-00133549-00133875": "getting excited about lagers a lot of", "S46czoMhctQ-00509-00133876-00134115": "the at the festivals you're seeing", "S46czoMhctQ-00510-00134116-00134289": "people pouring a lot more lagers you're", "S46czoMhctQ-00511-00134290-00134598": "seeing better representations of that", "S46czoMhctQ-00512-00134599-00134754": "style come through people are getting", "S46czoMhctQ-00513-00134755-00134985": "creative I'm a little I'm a little", "S46czoMhctQ-00514-00134986-00135378": "apprehensive to see like bubblegum or", "S46czoMhctQ-00515-00135379-00135619": "ice you know something crazy we see this", "S46czoMhctQ-00516-00135620-00135765": "all these crazy things that are", "S46czoMhctQ-00517-00135766-00136176": "sometimes really good but like when", "S46czoMhctQ-00518-00136177-00136311": "people start to get creative with the", "S46czoMhctQ-00519-00136312-00136463": "loggers I think they're gonna find out", "S46czoMhctQ-00520-00136464-00136984": "how much different the yeast they've the", "S46czoMhctQ-00521-00136985-00137182": "Brewers know they know how it is the", "S46czoMhctQ-00522-00137183-00137407": "like it's gonna be interesting to see", "S46czoMhctQ-00523-00137408-00137664": "how let's forgive it yeah thank you", "S46czoMhctQ-00524-00137665-00137804": "that's a better way to put it yeah", "S46czoMhctQ-00525-00137805-00138036": "little I don't know if it's lessons like", "S46czoMhctQ-00526-00138037-00138169": "wiggle room but it's gonna be", "S46czoMhctQ-00527-00138170-00138312": "interesting to see when people start to", "S46czoMhctQ-00528-00138313-00138481": "get super creative with it and adding a", "S46czoMhctQ-00529-00138482-00138745": "bunch of adjuncts kind of excited to see", "S46czoMhctQ-00530-00138746-00139009": "how that rolls yeah but you know new", "S46czoMhctQ-00531-00139010-00139285": "that is new and exciting styles of IPAs", "S46czoMhctQ-00532-00139286-00139653": "I mean they've got the more wine", "S46czoMhctQ-00533-00139654-00139902": "informed styles I'm seeing a lot now is", "S46czoMhctQ-00534-00139903-00140127": "starting out west again wine and", "S46czoMhctQ-00535-00140128-00140340": "champagne and form styles so now I'd be", "S46czoMhctQ-00536-00140341-00140727": "very interesting yeah so you know I", "S46czoMhctQ-00537-00140728-00140913": "don't have to tell you that craft", "S46czoMhctQ-00538-00140914-00141207": "brewing is traditionally a", "S46czoMhctQ-00539-00141208-00141528": "male-dominated field even though if", "S46czoMhctQ-00540-00141529-00141741": "you're a good history to it you know it", "S46czoMhctQ-00541-00141742-00142072": "reads back to when alewives yeah you", "S46czoMhctQ-00542-00142073-00142198": "know can you talk a little bit about", "S46czoMhctQ-00543-00142199-00142660": "being a woman in a industry that's more", "S46czoMhctQ-00544-00142661-00142870": "male-dominated yeah some of the", "S46czoMhctQ-00545-00142871-00143025": "challenges or even benefits", "S46czoMhctQ-00546-00143026-00143355": "that come from that oh for sure the it", "S46czoMhctQ-00547-00143356-00143613": "it actually it was part of the draw for", "S46czoMhctQ-00548-00143614-00143844": "me initially because I've always been", "S46czoMhctQ-00549-00143845-00144132": "very comfortable I grew up as a tomboy I", "S46czoMhctQ-00550-00144133-00144321": "had my sister and then like one other", "S46czoMhctQ-00551-00144322-00144567": "female friend so I was really used to", "S46czoMhctQ-00552-00144568-00144717": "hanging out with all the guy cousins and", "S46czoMhctQ-00553-00144718-00144939": "everything so it was a place I was", "S46czoMhctQ-00554-00144940-00145296": "comfortable with and throughout the", "S46czoMhctQ-00555-00145297-00145491": "growth and in the industry I've got to", "S46czoMhctQ-00556-00145492-00146118": "say it's been a particularly I haven't", "S46czoMhctQ-00557-00146119-00146262": "had some of the experiences that other", "S46czoMhctQ-00558-00146263-00146397": "women have had in the industry", "S46czoMhctQ-00559-00146398-00146574": "especially when you look at some of the", "S46czoMhctQ-00560-00146575-00146874": "stories coming out in other states North", "S46czoMhctQ-00561-00146875-00147216": "Carolina has a good culture for women in", "S46czoMhctQ-00562-00147217-00147570": "so far as my experience has been and for", "S46czoMhctQ-00563-00147571-00147755": "a lot of the other female Brewers and", "S46czoMhctQ-00564-00147756-00148089": "bartenders and just sales people", "S46czoMhctQ-00565-00148090-00148233": "everyone within the industry I've spoken", "S46czoMhctQ-00566-00148234-00148590": "with by and large has not had anything", "S46czoMhctQ-00567-00148591-00148911": "overly negative to say being in the", "S46czoMhctQ-00568-00148912-00149559": "brewery particularly the here I will say", "S46czoMhctQ-00569-00149560-00149925": "I will say here has been really nice", "S46czoMhctQ-00570-00149926-00150219": "because the guys back there do they", "S46czoMhctQ-00571-00150220-00150321": "don't treat you differently because", "S46czoMhctQ-00572-00150322-00150615": "you're a woman as long as you know like", "S46czoMhctQ-00573-00150616-00150798": "with any other job and with anybody else", "S46czoMhctQ-00574-00150799-00151005": "as long as you can demonstrate that you", "S46czoMhctQ-00575-00151006-00151110": "know what you're doing and you're", "S46czoMhctQ-00576-00151111-00151547": "competent I haven't had any instances of", "S46czoMhctQ-00577-00151548-00152025": "sexism anybody being patronizing nothing", "S46czoMhctQ-00578-00152026-00152109": "so far", "S46czoMhctQ-00579-00152110-00152316": "there are definitely definitely places", "S46czoMhctQ-00580-00152317-00152580": "out there outside of the brewing", "S46czoMhctQ-00581-00152581-00152895": "industry where I've had that happen so", "S46czoMhctQ-00582-00152896-00153093": "it's been really refreshing and kind of", "S46czoMhctQ-00583-00153094-00153267": "surprising given that it is really a", "S46czoMhctQ-00584-00153268-00153825": "male-dominated place no but it's been", "S46czoMhctQ-00585-00153826-00154149": "really informative for me not having", "S46czoMhctQ-00586-00154150-00154362": "those experiences getting involved with", "S46czoMhctQ-00587-00154363-00154578": "organizations like pink boots where you", "S46czoMhctQ-00588-00154579-00154800": "have a lot of women from various sectors", "S46czoMhctQ-00589-00154801-00155018": "in the beer industry coming together and", "S46czoMhctQ-00590-00155019-00155355": "talking about their experiences and you", "S46czoMhctQ-00591-00155356-00155487": "know even though my experience hasn't", "S46czoMhctQ-00592-00155488-00155828": "has been overly positive it's been", "S46czoMhctQ-00593-00155829-00156087": "really good to hear the stories of other", "S46czoMhctQ-00594-00156088-00156312": "people and be able to say okay well if", "S46czoMhctQ-00595-00156313-00156396": "that's happening", "S46czoMhctQ-00596-00156397-00156684": "somebody else you know not only is it", "S46czoMhctQ-00597-00156685-00156852": "something to keep an eye on as you go", "S46czoMhctQ-00598-00156853-00157323": "and you are at other places and support", "S46czoMhctQ-00599-00157324-00157521": "your your fellow females in the industry", "S46czoMhctQ-00600-00157522-00157800": "but to kind of look at it and say okay", "S46czoMhctQ-00601-00157801-00157935": "well if that's happening what can we do", "S46czoMhctQ-00602-00157936-00158067": "to fix it", "S46czoMhctQ-00603-00158068-00158364": "then that that's been great yeah and", "S46czoMhctQ-00604-00158365-00158676": "pink boots in North Carolina has been", "S46czoMhctQ-00605-00158677-00158955": "like booming yeah lots of regional", "S46czoMhctQ-00606-00158956-00159177": "groups and it's exciting a presentation", "S46czoMhctQ-00607-00159178-00159501": "for the triack group recently yes oh man", "S46czoMhctQ-00608-00159502-00159738": "it was a lot of fun I'm so excited to", "S46czoMhctQ-00609-00159739-00159882": "finally have a chapter in Greensboro", "S46czoMhctQ-00610-00159883-00160152": "because it's well triad because we've", "S46czoMhctQ-00611-00160153-00160346": "got Winston and everybody in there too", "S46czoMhctQ-00612-00160347-00160728": "but yeah it's it's such a different beer", "S46czoMhctQ-00613-00160729-00160938": "community out there than it is out here", "S46czoMhctQ-00614-00160939-00161121": "more towards Raleigh we're kind of", "S46czoMhctQ-00615-00161122-00161337": "smacked out in the middle but it's it's", "S46czoMhctQ-00616-00161338-00161490": "a lot smaller and probably because I'm", "S46czoMhctQ-00617-00161491-00161694": "more familiar with the area too but", "S46czoMhctQ-00618-00161695-00162021": "everybody is more condensed and there", "S46czoMhctQ-00619-00162022-00162210": "are fewer breweries that more now that", "S46czoMhctQ-00620-00162211-00162438": "they're popping up but everybody kind of", "S46czoMhctQ-00621-00162439-00162609": "knows each other it's a very communal", "S46czoMhctQ-00622-00162610-00162963": "feeling so it was really nicely I have a", "S46czoMhctQ-00623-00162964-00163194": "new Christina from joy mongers I'd met", "S46czoMhctQ-00624-00163195-00163374": "her through pink boots but I didn't", "S46czoMhctQ-00625-00163375-00163515": "realize that they also have a female", "S46czoMhctQ-00626-00163516-00163707": "Brewer over at prior as well", "S46czoMhctQ-00627-00163708-00164049": "so that's really nice getting to know", "S46czoMhctQ-00628-00164050-00164226": "the other people not only in the beer", "S46czoMhctQ-00629-00164227-00164463": "community but specifically the women", "S46czoMhctQ-00630-00164464-00164793": "it's yeah every meeting for the pink", "S46czoMhctQ-00631-00164794-00164949": "boots that I have been to whether it be", "S46czoMhctQ-00632-00164950-00165243": "Raleigh chapter or now Greensboro and", "S46czoMhctQ-00633-00165244-00165576": "winston-salem has been super edifying", "S46czoMhctQ-00634-00165577-00165978": "and just really encouraging really a lot", "S46czoMhctQ-00635-00165979-00166134": "of fun to be honest you just you get to", "S46czoMhctQ-00636-00166135-00166341": "go and you get to exchange ideas and and", "S46czoMhctQ-00637-00166342-00166632": "problem-solve a little bit so it's very", "S46czoMhctQ-00638-00166633-00166836": "cool to meet other people other women in", "S46czoMhctQ-00639-00166837-00167178": "the industry yeah and I think I would", "S46czoMhctQ-00640-00167179-00167289": "assume that having kind of that", "S46czoMhctQ-00641-00167290-00167514": "localized mm-hm moreso than just a", "S46czoMhctQ-00642-00167515-00167715": "statewide group oh yeah it's not a lot -", "S46czoMhctQ-00643-00167716-00168000": "yeah it is and on a professional level", "S46czoMhctQ-00644-00168001-00168168": "as well because these are the people", "S46czoMhctQ-00645-00168169-00168423": "where you know oh well we don't we're", "S46czoMhctQ-00646-00168424-00168612": "missing a bag of dextrose okay well I've", "S46czoMhctQ-00647-00168613-00168849": "got you know so-and-so around the corner", "S46czoMhctQ-00648-00168850-00169185": "maybe they can lend us one yeah so if we", "S46czoMhctQ-00649-00169186-00169259": "had", "S46czoMhctQ-00650-00169260-00169595": "some a woman walk for right now and say", "S46czoMhctQ-00651-00169596-00169886": "I want to become a Brewer what would be", "S46czoMhctQ-00652-00169887-00170273": "your advice for her oh man um I would", "S46czoMhctQ-00653-00170274-00170549": "probably say read as much as you can", "S46czoMhctQ-00654-00170550-00170732": "ahead of time make sure that you", "S46czoMhctQ-00655-00170733-00170890": "understand what you're getting into", "S46czoMhctQ-00656-00170891-00171226": "because it's I I've experienced it with", "S46czoMhctQ-00657-00171227-00171593": "like guys in and with women they come", "S46czoMhctQ-00658-00171594-00171785": "into the brewing industry thinking hey", "S46czoMhctQ-00659-00171786-00172019": "I'm gonna be brewing that's actually", "S46czoMhctQ-00660-00172020-00172322": "like the smallest part of the job", "S46czoMhctQ-00661-00172323-00172672": "yeah talked as they talk to people read", "S46czoMhctQ-00662-00172673-00172973": "and like find somebody who home brews", "S46czoMhctQ-00663-00172974-00173072": "and jump in on that", "S46czoMhctQ-00664-00173073-00173374": "like Go Go with them through the recipe", "S46czoMhctQ-00665-00173375-00173534": "building process through all the", "S46czoMhctQ-00666-00173535-00173723": "nitty-gritty through the equipment setup", "S46czoMhctQ-00667-00173724-00173906": "like that's a more accurate", "S46czoMhctQ-00668-00173907-00174311": "representation of the level of effort", "S46czoMhctQ-00669-00174312-00174560": "you're going to be expending because", "S46czoMhctQ-00670-00174561-00174829": "throwing on a big system is it's still", "S46czoMhctQ-00671-00174830-00174964": "work and it's still attention to detail", "S46czoMhctQ-00672-00174965-00175153": "but it's a lot easier that it is a", "S46czoMhctQ-00673-00175154-00175331": "homebrew system because you have to set", "S46czoMhctQ-00674-00175332-00175528": "up and you have to you're responsible", "S46czoMhctQ-00675-00175529-00175685": "for everything and you have to jerry-rig", "S46czoMhctQ-00676-00175686-00175909": "it and that's a huge part of this job", "S46czoMhctQ-00677-00175910-00176147": "rolling with it and making it work are", "S46czoMhctQ-00678-00176148-00176669": "like the key phrases yeah do the", "S46czoMhctQ-00679-00176670-00176938": "research walk Murray come and experience", "S46czoMhctQ-00680-00176939-00177295": "a day of collaging if they take", "S46czoMhctQ-00681-00177296-00177695": "deliveries at home yes I promise the", "S46czoMhctQ-00682-00177696-00178054": "ceiling will fall through yeah go and", "S46czoMhctQ-00683-00178055-00178303": "volunteer for a day and and wash kegs or", "S46czoMhctQ-00684-00178304-00178453": "do whatever grunt work it is that they", "S46czoMhctQ-00685-00178454-00178721": "need doing because that's going to be an", "S46czoMhctQ-00686-00178722-00178888": "accurate representation of life in a", "S46czoMhctQ-00687-00178889-00179074": "brewery it's a lot of fun and it's a lot", "S46czoMhctQ-00688-00179075-00179306": "of creativity but it's a lot of actual", "S46czoMhctQ-00689-00179307-00179602": "physical work too so know what you're", "S46czoMhctQ-00690-00179603-00179824": "getting into", "S46czoMhctQ-00691-00179825-00180586": "so we've got a few kind of fun questions", "S46czoMhctQ-00692-00180587-00180886": "what's your favorite beer here to drink", "S46czoMhctQ-00693-00180887-00181390": "oh yeah yeah I really enjoy Darius the", "S46czoMhctQ-00694-00181391-00181777": "Giant it is our red it's a red sour bass", "S46czoMhctQ-00695-00181778-00182021": "we use a Flemish ale blend in it and", "S46czoMhctQ-00696-00182022-00182476": "then it's it's it's for like a year plus", "S46czoMhctQ-00697-00182477-00182866": "on mounds of cherries in a bourbon", "S46czoMhctQ-00698-00182867-00183166": "barrel so it's it's just a beautiful", "S46czoMhctQ-00699-00183167-00183376": "sour I mean it's tart it's acidic but", "S46czoMhctQ-00700-00183377-00183640": "it's balanced on the multi side it", "S46czoMhctQ-00701-00183641-00183877": "appeals to that like funky heart that", "S46czoMhctQ-00702-00183878-00184186": "I've got love the clean beers but man I", "S46czoMhctQ-00703-00184187-00184462": "really love some funk and it's just", "S46czoMhctQ-00704-00184463-00184745": "really well done yeah so what about", "S46czoMhctQ-00705-00184746-00185062": "outside of here do you have a favorite", "S46czoMhctQ-00706-00185063-00185219": "yeah viewers from North Carolina", "S46czoMhctQ-00707-00185220-00185369": "breweries other than here", "S46czoMhctQ-00708-00185370-00185825": "absolutely I really enjoy a lot of old", "S46czoMhctQ-00709-00185826-00186260": "hickory stuff and right now well right", "S46czoMhctQ-00710-00186261-00186674": "now because it's summer a lot of it a", "S46czoMhctQ-00711-00186675-00186852": "lot of the places that have outdoor", "S46czoMhctQ-00712-00186853-00187129": "seating or knives I'm saying right now", "S46czoMhctQ-00713-00187130-00187404": "because I've been staying in Greensboro", "S46czoMhctQ-00714-00187405-00187625": "but one way or another", "S46czoMhctQ-00715-00187626-00187879": "I love joy monger stuff I'll go over", "S46czoMhctQ-00716-00187880-00188041": "there and hang out there crew is great", "S46czoMhctQ-00717-00188042-00188263": "their beer is wonderful haven't been", "S46czoMhctQ-00718-00188264-00188423": "over to the barrel hall yet I'm excited", "S46czoMhctQ-00719-00188424-00188650": "to go travel Winston and do a little bit", "S46czoMhctQ-00720-00188651-00188945": "of that but yeah they're always they", "S46czoMhctQ-00721-00188946-00189110": "have one of my favorite food er cultures", "S46czoMhctQ-00722-00189111-00189359": "going right now from anywhere I've had", "S46czoMhctQ-00723-00189360-00189695": "its stellar and plus they are already", "S46czoMhctQ-00724-00189696-00190027": "brewing lagers which is a big plus and", "S46czoMhctQ-00725-00190028-00190445": "they do it well so yeah I'm I'm a little", "S46czoMhctQ-00726-00190446-00190598": "bit like I told chase I'm a little bit", "S46czoMhctQ-00727-00190599-00190786": "of a lazy beer drinker to some degree if", "S46czoMhctQ-00728-00190787-00191011": "it's close by I'm more likely to try it", "S46czoMhctQ-00729-00191012-00191335": "but that means that means Winston and", "S46czoMhctQ-00730-00191336-00191476": "that means Greensboro and that means", "S46czoMhctQ-00731-00191477-00191662": "that means I need to get out to the", "S46czoMhctQ-00732-00191663-00192335": "Raleigh area more Oh tons of killer", "S46czoMhctQ-00733-00192336-00192813": "stuff steel strings Zebulon yeah yeah so", "S46czoMhctQ-00734-00192814-00193429": "what do you do when you're not when", "S46czoMhctQ-00735-00193430-00193658": "you're not here I would love to homebrew", "S46czoMhctQ-00736-00193659-00193847": "more yes", "S46czoMhctQ-00737-00193848-00194066": "my husband's a small business center so", "S46czoMhctQ-00738-00194067-00194219": "I help him out a lot with whatever he", "S46czoMhctQ-00739-00194220-00194552": "needs doing and then it's we're kind of", "S46czoMhctQ-00740-00194553-00194831": "boring we just pretty much we got a", "S46czoMhctQ-00741-00194832-00195080": "house and a yard and dogs that take care", "S46czoMhctQ-00742-00195081-00195425": "of and then we're we're big ol nerds", "S46czoMhctQ-00743-00195426-00195707": "so we're possibly at a brewery playing", "S46czoMhctQ-00744-00195708-00195947": "magic or at our house playing Dungeons", "S46czoMhctQ-00745-00195948-00196232": "and Dragons or yeah we're we're giant", "S46czoMhctQ-00746-00196233-00196568": "children we like to drink beer and play", "S46czoMhctQ-00747-00196569-00197180": "games yeah I'm with it well those are", "S46czoMhctQ-00748-00197181-00197288": "all the questions that I came prepared", "S46czoMhctQ-00749-00197289-00197420": "is there anything that we haven't talked", "S46czoMhctQ-00750-00197421-00197567": "about that you would want to talk about", "S46czoMhctQ-00751-00197568-00197705": "just in terms of telling your whole", "S46czoMhctQ-00752-00197706-00198166": "story nothing I can necessarily think of", "S46czoMhctQ-00753-00198167-00198499": "yeah yeah a love beer love making beer", "S46czoMhctQ-00754-00198500-00199849": "sounds good thank you thank you join it", "S46czoMhctQ-00755-00199850-00200057": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S48L3Vkm7RQ", "text": {"S48L3Vkm7RQ-00000-00000028-00000055": "[Music]", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00001-00000056-00000231": "my name is jamie hansen and from the", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00002-00000231-00000447": "edtech design department and today i am", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00003-00000448-00000591": "going to tell you", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00004-00000592-00000839": "and show you from the smart board how to", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00005-00000840-00001064": "download pdf and images", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00006-00001065-00001582": "[Music]", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00007-00001583-00001934": "i'm going to start out in class link", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00008-00001935-00002271": "and i'm going to go get a pdf from stem", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00009-00002272-00002583": "scopes", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00010-00002584-00002975": "pick your grade", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00011-00002976-00003166": "and the lesson i'm going to teach is", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00012-00003167-00003375": "going to be on life cycles so i'm going", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00013-00003376-00003799": "to scroll down", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00014-00003800-00004022": "go into life cycles and i'm specifically", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00015-00004023-00004222": "want the vocabulary", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00016-00004223-00004375": "so the vocabulary is going to be under", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00017-00004376-00004638": "explain", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00018-00004639-00004967": "and in here you can see pictures and you", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00019-00004968-00005079": "can see", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00020-00005080-00005335": "the word and the definition i like this", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00021-00005336-00005543": "but i want the pdf version so i'm going", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00022-00005544-00005711": "to click", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00023-00005712-00006095": "download here", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00024-00006096-00006383": "and it opens up", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00025-00006384-00006463": "in", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00026-00006464-00006734": "basically whiteboard so here i go i have", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00027-00006736-00006942": "all the vocabulary here", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00028-00006943-00007278": "with the picture definition in word", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00029-00007279-00007391": "and", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00030-00007392-00007583": "i just by clicking and holding down i", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00031-00007584-00007878": "uploaded it into", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00032-00007879-00008119": "whiteboard it is also over here in my", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00033-00008120-00008559": "files", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00034-00008560-00008735": "i'm going to go", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00035-00008736-00008887": "to downloads", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00036-00008888-00009127": "and it's right here also in your files", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00037-00009128-00009263": "under downloads", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00038-00009264-00009487": "all right i'm also going to", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00039-00009488-00009895": "download some math in thinkcentral", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00040-00009896-00010255": "so i'm going to go back to my class link", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00041-00010256-00010463": "think central's right here here we go", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00042-00010464-00010806": "third grade and into the student edition", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00043-00010807-00011006": "ebook", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00044-00011007-00011303": "go to pdfs", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00045-00011304-00011503": "this time is a little different i'm", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00046-00011504-00011791": "going to do say problem solving", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00047-00011792-00011999": "i'm going to hold it down on that one", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00048-00012000-00012119": "and you can see all the different", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00049-00012120-00012246": "options to", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00050-00012247-00012455": "choose from i'm going to choose open in", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00051-00012456-00012567": "new tab", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00052-00012568-00012735": "okay", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00053-00012736-00012966": "and it went", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00054-00012967-00013343": "back into your files", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00055-00013344-00013463": "right here", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00056-00013463-00013822": "and again you can click on it", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00057-00013823-00014071": "and it will open it up into", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00058-00014072-00014549": "your whiteboard", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00059-00014550-00015294": "[Music]", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00060-00015295-00015591": "so i uploaded a pdf from stem scopes", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00061-00015591-00015703": "into", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00062-00015704-00015911": "the whiteboard area just by clicking", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00063-00015912-00016238": "download pdf but i noticed that", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00064-00016240-00016615": "in here i need the frog life cycle so", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00065-00016616-00016783": "i'm going to go find that image of a", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00066-00016784-00017055": "frog life cycle and download that", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00067-00017056-00017263": "so i'm gonna go back to", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00068-00017264-00017447": "my browser", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00069-00017448-00017639": "and i'm going to open up a new tab and", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00070-00017640-00017911": "i'm going to search for", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00071-00017912-00018135": "lifecycle of a frog", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00072-00018136-00018655": "in images so switch it to images", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00073-00018656-00018871": "and as i look through", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00074-00018872-00019063": "i really like", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00075-00019064-00019167": "say", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00076-00019168-00019367": "this image right here", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00077-00019368-00019671": "so once you tap on it it's now over here", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00078-00019672-00019871": "hold it down", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00079-00019872-00020143": "and all these different options start", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00080-00020144-00020319": "i would pick", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00081-00020320-00020607": "download image", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00082-00020608-00020719": "and", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00083-00020720-00020967": "all done go back to your board", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00084-00020968-00021150": "go to your files", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00085-00021151-00021327": "and you have the image there but i want", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00086-00021328-00021550": "it into the presentation", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00087-00021551-00021671": "of", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00088-00021672-00022063": "the pdf that i had of your life cycles", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00089-00022064-00022214": "so here it is here", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00090-00022215-00022543": "i'm going to add a new page", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00091-00022544-00022886": "and i'm going to go to images the", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00092-00022887-00023030": "from the board", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00093-00023031-00023319": "gallery", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00094-00023320-00023463": "there's my", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00095-00023464-00023655": "frog image", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00096-00023656-00023735": "and", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00097-00023736-00023911": "i just uploaded it into the same", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00098-00023912-00024119": "presentation here you can again make it", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00099-00024120-00024375": "larger and change the size", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00100-00024376-00024686": "another way to put this image onto an", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00101-00024687-00024991": "existing slide would be the same way", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00102-00024992-00025263": "say you want to put a side by side add", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00103-00025264-00025455": "in an image you took from online on this", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00104-00025456-00025567": "slide", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00105-00025568-00025814": "you could go i'm on this slide go back", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00106-00025816-00025934": "to your picture", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00107-00025935-00026174": "go to gallery and i saved my frog", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00108-00026175-00026702": "picture there it's right here", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00109-00026704-00027055": "and now it put it on top but", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00110-00027056-00027343": "you may want to shrink it down and put", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00111-00027344-00027583": "it right next to it so now you have a", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00112-00027583-00027790": "side by side to show your kids two", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00113-00027791-00028267": "different life cycles", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00114-00028268-00028535": "[Music]", "S48L3Vkm7RQ-00115-00028536-00028744": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S4mHD3kZff4", "text": {"S4mHD3kZff4-00000-00000168-00000782": "[Music]", "S4mHD3kZff4-00001-00000783-00001054": "dear distinguished mpe members", "S4mHD3kZff4-00002-00001055-00001335": "i feel privileged and proud to be here", "S4mHD3kZff4-00003-00001336-00001543": "with you to celebrate the 10th year of", "S4mHD3kZff4-00004-00001544-00001663": "mpe", "S4mHD3kZff4-00005-00001664-00001855": "i am grateful for your presence to", "S4mHD3kZff4-00006-00001855-00002134": "witness the journey of mpe from birth", "S4mHD3kZff4-00007-00002135-00002447": "our time in mpe has been quite a journey", "S4mHD3kZff4-00008-00002448-00002631": "i acted as a vice president first in", "S4mHD3kZff4-00009-00002632-00002823": "myeloma unit and then in the merger", "S4mHD3kZff4-00010-00002824-00003087": "times where i acted as interim director", "S4mHD3kZff4-00011-00003088-00003367": "of the two existing myeloma societies", "S4mHD3kZff4-00012-00003368-00003670": "like myeloma uranet and my european", "S4mHD3kZff4-00013-00003671-00003847": "myeloma platform", "S4mHD3kZff4-00014-00003847-00004111": "it was really painful and took some two", "S4mHD3kZff4-00015-00004112-00004238": "years to merge", "S4mHD3kZff4-00016-00004239-00004559": "because it was not only the merging uh", "S4mHD3kZff4-00017-00004560-00004847": "the constitutions or organizations but", "S4mHD3kZff4-00018-00004848-00005031": "also the spirits had to merge", "S4mHD3kZff4-00019-00005032-00005318": "on the way of having one strong voice of", "S4mHD3kZff4-00020-00005319-00005575": "myeloma patients in europe", "S4mHD3kZff4-00021-00005576-00005863": "and then i was given the privilege to", "S4mHD3kZff4-00022-00005864-00006031": "run the newborn mpe", "S4mHD3kZff4-00023-00006032-00006399": "as president for two terms with uh", "S4mHD3kZff4-00024-00006400-00006719": "precious board members it was tough and", "S4mHD3kZff4-00025-00006720-00006910": "challenging and i remember there were", "S4mHD3kZff4-00026-00006911-00007119": "times where we witnessed the", "S4mHD3kZff4-00027-00007120-00007406": "life of mpe was hanging in the balance", "S4mHD3kZff4-00028-00007408-00007687": "and we had to take some", "S4mHD3kZff4-00029-00007688-00008039": "painful decisions sometimes", "S4mHD3kZff4-00030-00008040-00008263": "the first two period is considered as", "S4mHD3kZff4-00031-00008264-00008519": "birth the survival period like a baby", "S4mHD3kZff4-00032-00008520-00008607": "being born", "S4mHD3kZff4-00033-00008608-00008903": "and then the childhood i'm not", "S4mHD3kZff4-00034-00008904-00008983": "witnessing", "S4mHD3kZff4-00035-00008984-00009255": "that mp is a young woman or man very", "S4mHD3kZff4-00036-00009256-00009351": "attractive", "S4mHD3kZff4-00037-00009352-00009663": "very energetic but still needs to get", "S4mHD3kZff4-00038-00009664-00009742": "major", "S4mHD3kZff4-00039-00009743-00010046": "with much more success to come with time", "S4mHD3kZff4-00040-00010047-00010263": "to be able to touch the lives of every", "S4mHD3kZff4-00041-00010264-00010463": "myeloma patient across europe", "S4mHD3kZff4-00042-00010464-00010687": "and with the new board members so keep", "S4mHD3kZff4-00043-00010688-00010887": "up the good work and", "S4mHD3kZff4-00044-00010888-00011231": "hold this momentum while saying hi to", "S4mHD3kZff4-00045-00011232-00011303": "all of you", "S4mHD3kZff4-00046-00011304-00011638": "and let me tell you what i've been up to", "S4mHD3kZff4-00047-00011639-00011855": "it's just that we know that 70 or 80", "S4mHD3kZff4-00048-00011856-00012006": "percent of the patients are using", "S4mHD3kZff4-00049-00012007-00012223": "supplements and alternative therapies", "S4mHD3kZff4-00050-00012224-00012431": "without the knowledge of their doctors", "S4mHD3kZff4-00051-00012432-00012614": "you know as i'm able to say a researcher", "S4mHD3kZff4-00052-00012615-00012751": "and a medical doctor", "S4mHD3kZff4-00053-00012752-00012974": "and i'm writing some novel cancer and", "S4mHD3kZff4-00054-00012975-00013191": "myeloma clinical trials in the united", "S4mHD3kZff4-00055-00013191-00013286": "states to find", "S4mHD3kZff4-00056-00013287-00013519": "evidence in order to pull back these", "S4mHD3kZff4-00057-00013519-00013711": "therapies towards the mainstream", "S4mHD3kZff4-00058-00013712-00013783": "medicine", "S4mHD3kZff4-00059-00013784-00013983": "for the benefit of cancer and myeloma", "S4mHD3kZff4-00060-00013984-00014158": "patients maybe i'll explain", "S4mHD3kZff4-00061-00014159-00014335": "you some of these results in the coming", "S4mHD3kZff4-00062-00014336-00014519": "years and personally", "S4mHD3kZff4-00063-00014519-00014758": "i started writing a book to highlight", "S4mHD3kZff4-00064-00014759-00014999": "the real issues that will matter", "S4mHD3kZff4-00065-00015000-00015279": "and need to be scientifically advocated", "S4mHD3kZff4-00066-00015280-00015407": "in the next 10 years", "S4mHD3kZff4-00067-00015408-00015703": "as well as highlight cancer champions", "S4mHD3kZff4-00068-00015704-00015775": "champions", "S4mHD3kZff4-00069-00015776-00016086": "like all of you as role models to", "S4mHD3kZff4-00070-00016087-00016350": "cancer survivors for this they're really", "S4mHD3kZff4-00071-00016351-00016479": "good examples", "S4mHD3kZff4-00072-00016480-00016871": "in myeloma community our dear colleagues", "S4mHD3kZff4-00073-00016872-00017199": "who really doing great now but also", "S4mHD3kZff4-00074-00017200-00017527": "never forget that in the past who", "S4mHD3kZff4-00075-00017528-00017879": "those who did amazing job never forget", "S4mHD3kZff4-00076-00017880-00017967": "our friends", "S4mHD3kZff4-00077-00017968-00018222": "the stars the rebellious forces of", "S4mHD3kZff4-00078-00018223-00018486": "myeloma patients to be reckoned with", "S4mHD3kZff4-00079-00018487-00018839": "those who then passed away like krista", "S4mHD3kZff4-00080-00018840-00019167": "like my mika sorry yucky", "S4mHD3kZff4-00081-00019168-00019503": "peter lisa and much more", "S4mHD3kZff4-00082-00019504-00019783": "of course not for getting the young", "S4mHD3kZff4-00083-00019784-00019847": "angel", "S4mHD3kZff4-00084-00019848-00020294": "anna may their soul", "S4mHD3kZff4-00085-00020295-00020607": "rest in peace forever a wise man once", "S4mHD3kZff4-00086-00020608-00020647": "said", "S4mHD3kZff4-00087-00020648-00020878": "that a journey is best measures in", "S4mHD3kZff4-00088-00020879-00020967": "smiles", "S4mHD3kZff4-00089-00020968-00021191": "rather than in miles so i'm very happy", "S4mHD3kZff4-00090-00021192-00021486": "to see so many smiling faces despite the", "S4mHD3kZff4-00091-00021487-00021647": "fact that you're all virtual", "S4mHD3kZff4-00092-00021648-00021991": "during this pandemic always good for a", "S4mHD3kZff4-00093-00021992-00022214": "few moments to look back on our", "S4mHD3kZff4-00094-00022215-00022327": "incredible mp", "S4mHD3kZff4-00095-00022328-00022622": "journey before we look to the future we", "S4mHD3kZff4-00096-00022623-00022694": "proved", "S4mHD3kZff4-00097-00022695-00022950": "and it's all of us that our grassroots", "S4mHD3kZff4-00098-00022951-00023158": "efforts to save mpe", "S4mHD3kZff4-00099-00023159-00023383": "and harness thousands and thousands of", "S4mHD3kZff4-00100-00023384-00023494": "patients", "S4mHD3kZff4-00101-00023495-00023703": "was not just about myeloma disease", "S4mHD3kZff4-00102-00023704-00024071": "itself but quality of life", "S4mHD3kZff4-00103-00024072-00024319": "equity equal access to medicine", "S4mHD3kZff4-00104-00024320-00024391": "treatment", "S4mHD3kZff4-00105-00024392-00024663": "justice and much more and a solid moral", "S4mHD3kZff4-00106-00024664-00024742": "compass", "S4mHD3kZff4-00107-00024743-00025086": "that unites the human soul i have always", "S4mHD3kZff4-00108-00025087-00025255": "believed that we are born", "S4mHD3kZff4-00109-00025256-00025535": "into this world and at a certain place", "S4mHD3kZff4-00110-00025536-00025694": "to be with certain people", "S4mHD3kZff4-00111-00025695-00025967": "for a reason and a purpose everyone has", "S4mHD3kZff4-00112-00025968-00026078": "a destiny", "S4mHD3kZff4-00113-00026079-00026390": "and because of all the myeloma patients", "S4mHD3kZff4-00114-00026391-00026470": "i", "S4mHD3kZff4-00115-00026472-00026743": "and we all stood here with a renewed", "S4mHD3kZff4-00116-00026744-00026799": "vigor", "S4mHD3kZff4-00117-00026800-00027118": "and sense of purpose may the ongoing", "S4mHD3kZff4-00118-00027119-00027183": "boards", "S4mHD3kZff4-00119-00027183-00027511": "of mpe always remember the past", "S4mHD3kZff4-00120-00027512-00027855": "where our collective values of loyalty", "S4mHD3kZff4-00121-00027856-00028167": "and courage and kindness for", "S4mHD3kZff4-00122-00028168-00028462": "one of another uh really prevail by", "S4mHD3kZff4-00123-00028463-00028574": "working together", "S4mHD3kZff4-00124-00028575-00028887": "and only together with succeed the new", "S4mHD3kZff4-00125-00028888-00028958": "board with", "S4mHD3kZff4-00126-00028960-00029246": "your contribution have demonstrated", "S4mHD3kZff4-00127-00029247-00029431": "success to the world and will", "S4mHD3kZff4-00128-00029432-00029718": "continue to do so that it is a", "S4mHD3kZff4-00129-00029719-00029823": "collective", "S4mHD3kZff4-00130-00029824-00030031": "moral obligation and social", "S4mHD3kZff4-00131-00030032-00030158": "responsibility", "S4mHD3kZff4-00132-00030160-00030455": "to protect the mp culture which provides", "S4mHD3kZff4-00133-00030456-00030487": "an", "S4mHD3kZff4-00134-00030488-00030831": "honorable dignified work to strive", "S4mHD3kZff4-00135-00030832-00031135": "to provide all unmet needs of myeloma", "S4mHD3kZff4-00136-00031136-00031214": "patients", "S4mHD3kZff4-00137-00031216-00031535": "across europe my work mr regards to all", "S4mHD3kZff4-00138-00031536-00032607": "of you", "S4mHD3kZff4-00139-00032608-00032816": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S4uI-eDwDn4", "text": {"S4uI-eDwDn4-00000-00000096-00000359": "we are live welcome to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00001-00000360-00000839": "obi-wan kenobi episode 3 thoughts", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00002-00000840-00000991": "so", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00003-00000992-00001166": "diving right in", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00004-00001167-00001383": "right a couple of things on", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00005-00001384-00001491": "previous", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00006-00001492-00001743": "episodes i really appreciated seeing", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00007-00001744-00001910": "more of alderaan", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00008-00001911-00002095": "pretty much all we really saw in episode", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00009-00002096-00002223": "4 was", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00010-00002224-00002883": "alderaan chunks where alderaan space was", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00011-00002884-00003495": "now let's see", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00012-00003496-00003622": "i've seen some people dislike the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00013-00003623-00003759": "tension and conflict between the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00014-00003760-00003943": "inquisitors especially that the grand", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00015-00003944-00004199": "inquisitor kept antagonizing riva even", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00016-00004200-00004399": "right before she stabs him in the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00017-00004400-00004543": "original trilogy the downfall of the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00018-00004544-00004743": "empire is consistently", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00019-00004744-00004919": "that they are too convinced that they", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00020-00004920-00005063": "can't lose so", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00021-00005064-00005191": "this is just", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00022-00005192-00005367": "more of that i really appreciate it's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00023-00005368-00005799": "staying true to that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00024-00005800-00005959": "see", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00025-00005960-00006215": "right so diving into the episode obi-wan", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00026-00006216-00006399": "is still attempting but failing to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00027-00006400-00006559": "communicate with qui-gon", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00028-00006559-00006751": "this is the first coastline your call is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00029-00006752-00006927": "very important to us", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00030-00006928-00007119": "i really love seeing darth vader be", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00031-00007120-00007470": "assembled creepy epic and at the end of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00032-00007472-00007814": "it the iconic breathing", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00033-00007815-00008006": "awesome establishing shot of the planet", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00034-00008008-00008431": "mustafar", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00035-00008432-00008599": "prove yourself and the position of grand", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00036-00008600-00008791": "inquisitor is yours fail me and you will", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00037-00008792-00009014": "not live to regret it yes there appears", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00038-00009015-00009223": "to have been a job opening and this time", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00039-00009224-00009519": "it wasn't even vader who killed the guy", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00040-00009520-00009839": "progress", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00041-00009840-00010055": "okay for how intelligent they've written", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00042-00010056-00010223": "leia to be in this episode one of the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00043-00010224-00010431": "first things she says is basically are", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00044-00010432-00010751": "we there yet", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00045-00010752-00010967": "it's a trade route liam can't you use", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00046-00010968-00011103": "the force", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00047-00011104-00011367": "that's not how the force works i doubt", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00048-00011368-00011774": "you could oh really", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00049-00011775-00011951": "i appreciate that as much as leia is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00050-00011952-00012110": "annoyed with some aspects of this whole", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00051-00012111-00012319": "rescue thing she does thank ben for", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00052-00012320-00012455": "fixing lola", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00053-00012456-00012631": "and we find out that the reason she", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00054-00012632-00012935": "calls it lola the reason she calls her", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00055-00012936-00013327": "lola is that her designation is like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00056-00013328-00013511": "l 0", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00057-00013512-00013591": "l", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00058-00013591-00013719": "a or s", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00059-00013719-00014127": "4 or something like that so yeah", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00060-00014128-00014319": "and ben believes he sees anakin in", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00061-00014319-00014486": "episode three guard but then he suddenly", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00062-00014487-00014743": "disappears when ben looks away", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00063-00014744-00015047": "i don't know exactly who this", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00064-00015047-00015183": "hallucination", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00065-00015184-00015375": "ghost is but", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00066-00015376-00015630": "i do believe we're looking at a graduate", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00067-00015631-00015815": "of the michael myers school of messing", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00068-00015816-00016038": "with your future victim possibly even", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00069-00016040-00016350": "someone who graduated with honors", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00070-00016351-00016607": "send out the probes those searchy", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00071-00016608-00016935": "thorough probes", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00072-00016936-00017158": "i love the whole exchange about how you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00073-00017159-00017343": "know ben doesn't want her to talk and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00074-00017344-00017583": "then she immediately starts talking you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00075-00017584-00017758": "know she flags down the transport talks", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00076-00017759-00017999": "to freck with full faith that he's nice", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00077-00018000-00018222": "because she's used to people that she's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00078-00018223-00018422": "around being nice like the least nice", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00079-00018423-00018599": "she's experienced was her cousin the guy", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00080-00018600-00018855": "is naho but he's not exactly imperial", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00081-00018856-00018950": "bad", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00082-00018951-00019207": "and ben notices there's an empire symbol", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00083-00019208-00019439": "on the back of the thing", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00084-00019440-00019671": "and i i really that's such a great", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00085-00019672-00019919": "because like there was already like this", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00086-00019920-00020239": "uncertainty like can you trust like the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00087-00020240-00020599": "official kind of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00088-00020600-00020878": "people aren't good gonna be like super", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00089-00020879-00021199": "open about being against the empire and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00090-00021200-00021503": "thus on the side of ben and leia", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00091-00021504-00021607": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00092-00021608-00021814": "you know so i forget might have been new", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00093-00021815-00022071": "rock stars or or screen rant but someone", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00094-00022072-00022222": "pointed out", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00095-00022223-00022503": "that's like the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00096-00022504-00022775": "uh what was it he he made that himself", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00097-00022776-00023007": "you know so he is so in favor of the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00098-00023008-00023214": "empire that he took the time to make", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00099-00023215-00023422": "that he didn't just like slap a bumper", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00100-00023423-00023711": "sticker on or something it yeah", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00101-00023712-00024063": "and it's a great bit of tension because", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00102-00024064-00024286": "once ben sees that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00103-00024287-00024614": "what is he gonna like he can't say oh um", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00104-00024615-00024830": "we i think we'll take the next one", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00105-00024831-00024958": "because it's like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00106-00024959-00025207": "oh they must have seen the the empire", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00107-00025208-00025422": "symbol back there why else would he", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00108-00025423-00025711": "suddenly change his mind", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00109-00025712-00025902": "and he starts talking positively of the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00110-00025904-00026062": "empire and then stops to give a ride to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00111-00026063-00026262": "some stormtroopers who are on a first", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00112-00026263-00026535": "name basis with him", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00113-00026536-00026718": "and they get into the transport you can", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00114-00026719-00026895": "tell ben is very concerned because if", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00115-00026895-00027095": "they open fire at this range even they", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00116-00027095-00027207": "can't miss", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00117-00027208-00027446": "i'm kidding i still maintain it's not", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00118-00027447-00027670": "that they have bad aim it's that most of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00119-00027672-00027879": "the characters we see them shoot at have", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00120-00027880-00028351": "plot armor", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00121-00028352-00028631": "i wouldn't know a jedi if i saw one", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00122-00028632-00028999": "us two", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00123-00029000-00029167": "that's a long story", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00124-00029168-00029351": "it's a long way", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00125-00029352-00029518": "you called her leia i thought her name", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00126-00029519-00029718": "was luma", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00127-00029719-00029935": "that was her mother's name it's very", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00128-00029936-00030311": "it's it's a great like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00129-00030312-00030599": "it's a it's a good", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00130-00030600-00030935": "cover you know and he", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00131-00030936-00031127": "you know tell me you're thinking of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00132-00031127-00031279": "padme without telling me you're thinking", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00133-00031280-00031527": "of padme", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00134-00031527-00031767": "and some of the audio dropped out when", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00135-00031768-00031983": "the stormtroopers said you called her", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00136-00031983-00032190": "leia excellent choice it really was like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00137-00032191-00032414": "a gut punch when he accidentally called", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00138-00032416-00032679": "her leia but he's been calling her leia", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00139-00032680-00032862": "all this time so of course he did he you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00140-00032863-00032967": "know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00141-00032968-00033415": "he's not really at least not these days", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00142-00033416-00033583": "are you my real father i mean i feel", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00143-00033584-00033759": "like they had to address that fan theory", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00144-00033760-00033918": "a lot of people would prefer", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00145-00033919-00034311": "over anakin as the real father", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00146-00034312-00034495": "a couple of strays i found thought you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00147-00034496-00034671": "might want to check them out so he was", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00148-00034672-00034846": "just pretending to be trusting it was", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00149-00034847-00035199": "always his plan to take them here", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00150-00035200-00035487": "incredibly tense during the the checking", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00151-00035488-00035718": "of you know ben slowly raises his head", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00152-00035719-00035902": "is recognized by the probe", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00153-00035903-00036135": "cool action scene holy crap ben took", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00154-00036136-00036311": "freck as a human shield he's not messing", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00155-00036312-00036527": "around and one of the stormtroopers gets", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00156-00036528-00036702": "cut in half from lasers letting us know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00157-00036703-00036902": "how deadly they are", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00158-00036903-00037151": "run ben there are too many of them", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00159-00037152-00037327": "but then the imperial officer shoots the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00160-00037328-00037702": "stormtroopers", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00161-00037703-00037911": "i didn't mean to run away i appreciate", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00162-00037912-00038118": "for how intelligent they make her she", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00163-00038119-00038302": "still does still express this kind of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00164-00038303-00038735": "vulnerability", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00165-00038736-00038943": "and the moment leia knows the robot is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00166-00038944-00039127": "on their side she greets him and so does", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00167-00039128-00039399": "lola", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00168-00039400-00039559": "he's just a loader they don't allow him", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00169-00039560-00039743": "to communicate but what if he has", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00170-00039744-00040087": "something to say very sweet", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00171-00040088-00040318": "and two stormtroopers enter and look", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00172-00040319-00040495": "around we see that the loader had a", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00173-00040496-00040918": "hammer ready in case needed to fight", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00174-00040919-00041087": "can you teach me how to shoot i mean in", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00175-00041088-00041230": "her defense if she had a gun when the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00176-00041231-00041390": "kidnappers came and she shoots half as", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00177-00041391-00041590": "good as she runs away from adults twice", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00178-00041591-00041735": "her size she would never have gotten", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00179-00041736-00041902": "kidnapped in the show i mean in real", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00180-00041903-00042143": "life i'm pro control", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00181-00042144-00042327": "i love the way they film vader's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00182-00042328-00042543": "entrance into the camp versus just the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00183-00042544-00042799": "shadow and his feet his hands and the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00184-00042800-00042983": "lightsaber the cape", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00185-00042984-00043271": "and then finally the camera pans up the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00186-00043272-00043583": "front of him this is how you introduce", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00187-00043584-00043823": "and uses telekinesis to kill some of the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00188-00043824-00044030": "people of the camp very sinister i'm", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00189-00044031-00044199": "thinking he agrees with the grand", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00190-00044200-00044383": "inquisitor and he's pushing for obi-wan", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00191-00044384-00044839": "to reveal himself to save these people", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00192-00044840-00044918": "now", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00193-00044919-00045190": "when vader ignites his lightsaber and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00194-00045191-00045343": "ben draws his but doesn't ignite and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00195-00045344-00045487": "then run off", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00196-00045488-00045655": "like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00197-00045656-00046062": "i like that he's in such bad shape for", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00198-00046063-00046230": "for lightsaber like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00199-00046231-00046543": "think about it for these last 10 years", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00200-00046544-00046767": "ben has been doing what he could to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00201-00046768-00047007": "avoid using a lightsaber he buried it in", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00202-00047008-00047327": "the desert you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00203-00047328-00047702": "vader i'm thinking he's savoring anybody", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00204-00047703-00047935": "he can get away with sabering", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00205-00047936-00048135": "all the time like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00206-00048136-00048367": "when we saw his", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00207-00048368-00048511": "you know this episode makes it clear", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00208-00048512-00048743": "vader is in extreme", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00209-00048744-00049062": "agony he is in such intense physical", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00210-00049063-00049143": "pain", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00211-00049144-00049455": "so yeah i'm i'm thinking he takes every", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00212-00049456-00049711": "opportunity he can to to cut someone", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00213-00049712-00050071": "down", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00214-00050072-00050374": "now but but yeah with that said i i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00215-00050375-00050567": "forget exactly who it was who said it", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00216-00050568-00050662": "but", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00217-00050663-00050855": "someone pointed out", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00218-00050856-00051151": "on youtube that in a youtube video", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00219-00051152-00051270": "it's very", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00220-00051271-00051599": "weirdly awkwardly filmed and edited i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00221-00051600-00051782": "don't know exactly what was happening", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00222-00051783-00051863": "like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00223-00051864-00052175": "is it possible that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00224-00052176-00052319": "originally the sequence played", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00225-00052320-00052559": "completely differently and so they had", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00226-00052560-00052742": "to edit it", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00227-00052744-00052919": "like edit out the stuff that they were", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00228-00052920-00053103": "no longer using because it's it's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00229-00053104-00053415": "baffling like this is not a badly filmed", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00230-00053416-00053519": "show", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00231-00053520-00053775": "as like in general so far these three", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00232-00053776-00054047": "episodes have been filmed very well but", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00233-00054048-00054191": "then you have this", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00234-00054191-00054438": "yeah i i can't help but wonder if like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00235-00054439-00054582": "originally", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00236-00054583-00054799": "maybe someone else got involved in the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00237-00054800-00055023": "fight and so they had to edit that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00238-00055024-00055182": "character out when they decided they", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00239-00055183-00055519": "weren't going to be in the fight and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00240-00055520-00055703": "that you know so they ended up with", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00241-00055704-00056038": "these awkward awkward shots i i get that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00242-00056039-00056238": "you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00243-00056239-00056447": "in part they're going for it being", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00244-00056448-00056679": "very disorienting", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00245-00056679-00056847": "because we're seeing it from obi-wan's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00246-00056848-00057126": "perspective and he is very disempowered", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00247-00057127-00057407": "but you can do that without it being", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00248-00057408-00057582": "like it's it's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00249-00057583-00057750": "yeah it was", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00250-00057751-00057926": "it was not", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00251-00057927-00058199": "filmmaking for the purpose of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00252-00058200-00058382": "you know making it", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00253-00058383-00058599": "like like um", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00254-00058600-00058750": "showing how disempowered the character", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00255-00058751-00059511": "is it was bad filmmaking", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00256-00059512-00059654": "what have you become", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00257-00059655-00059919": "you're the one who made me", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00258-00059920-00060094": "and yeah we get some lightsaber dueling", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00259-00060095-00060342": "between vader and obi-wan looks much", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00260-00060344-00060494": "more like something out of episode four", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00261-00060495-00060654": "than the prequel trilogy so we are", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00262-00060655-00060903": "closing the gap between the two", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00263-00060904-00061087": "i really appreciate that obviously a lot", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00264-00061088-00061271": "of audience members are going to prefer", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00265-00061272-00061454": "a more high speed fight", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00266-00061455-00061623": "it takes a lot to give the audience not", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00267-00061624-00061847": "what they want but what they need", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00268-00061848-00062038": "i'm not saying you know you're entitled", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00269-00062039-00062287": "to european for sure you are", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00270-00062288-00062566": "i'm not saying i'm right", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00271-00062567-00062950": "i'm just expressing my point of view", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00272-00062951-00063111": "so some people are saying that we'll", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00273-00063112-00063342": "probably get at least one more fight", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00274-00063344-00063591": "before the show is over", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00275-00063591-00063982": "i could see that if so i hope that it", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00276-00063983-00064182": "feels like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00277-00064183-00064494": "um i hope that they maintained that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00278-00064495-00064742": "obi-wan himself is not", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00279-00064744-00064975": "in fighting shape", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00280-00064976-00065142": "maybe dancing shape but not fighting", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00281-00065144-00065415": "shape and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00282-00065416-00065591": "the the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00283-00065592-00065767": "yeah i i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00284-00065768-00065903": "like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00285-00065904-00066055": "i mean it's kind of difficult because", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00286-00066056-00066311": "ultimately like they're not gonna mess", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00287-00066312-00066535": "up ben because we already know alec", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00288-00066536-00066791": "guinness has all of his limbs in in", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00289-00066792-00067126": "episode four", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00290-00067127-00067391": "and if like if he cuts off some of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00291-00067392-00067623": "vader's limbs they're just gonna be", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00292-00067624-00067806": "reattached he already did that so i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00293-00067807-00067911": "don't know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00294-00067912-00068271": "exactly what but like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00295-00068272-00068431": "yeah i don't know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00296-00068432-00068726": "i hope that they make it feel", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00297-00068727-00068863": "final", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00298-00068864-00069079": "you know in episode 4 i don't know if i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00299-00069080-00069375": "would say that it's as much a fight as", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00300-00069376-00069591": "just like he's making sure to buy a", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00301-00069592-00069726": "little time", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00302-00069727-00069991": "because the moment the very moment that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00303-00069992-00070255": "ben like looks over and sees", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00304-00070256-00070623": "they're there they're close to the ship", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00305-00070624-00070903": "leia is safe he immediately", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00306-00070904-00070982": "like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00307-00070983-00071199": "he doesn't throw in the towel", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00308-00071200-00071462": "but he drops the cloak", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00309-00071463-00071575": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00310-00071576-00071791": "i really didn't feel like that was him", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00311-00071792-00071967": "trying to win", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00312-00071968-00072111": "so", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00313-00072112-00072311": "yeah i mean i don't", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00314-00072312-00072582": "yeah yeah if it's like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00315-00072583-00072823": "maybe if they do another one another", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00316-00072824-00072982": "fight in the show before the show is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00317-00072983-00073103": "over", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00318-00073104-00073238": "if he like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00319-00073239-00073591": "fights intently and you know for a while", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00320-00073592-00073815": "and then he sees that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00321-00073816-00073982": "leia is safe or whoever you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00322-00073983-00074159": "whatever the exact", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00323-00074160-00074343": "and then he", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00324-00074344-00074503": "you know i don't know i mean obviously", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00325-00074504-00074615": "he's not gonna", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00326-00074616-00074806": "die there but", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00327-00074807-00074967": "if if", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00328-00074968-00075206": "just he he does something that shows", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00329-00075207-00075582": "that he was just buying time so you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00330-00075583-00075750": "i don't want", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00331-00075751-00075950": "you know i feel like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00332-00075951-00076103": "you know i'm not the biggest fan of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00333-00076104-00076231": "episode 3", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00334-00076232-00076567": "of the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00335-00076568-00076719": "revenge of the sith", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00336-00076720-00077055": "but i feel like that was the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00337-00077056-00077311": "climactic fight between anakin and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00338-00077312-00077855": "obi-wan you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00339-00077856-00077982": "you should have killed me when you had", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00340-00077983-00078287": "the chance charles i mean ben", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00341-00078288-00078447": "i really appreciate the consistent", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00342-00078448-00078679": "characterization of riva even when vader", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00343-00078680-00078879": "himself told her not to engage she still", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00344-00078880-00079150": "does", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00345-00079151-00079359": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00346-00079360-00079575": "vader force chokes ben throws him into", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00347-00079576-00079782": "the fire holy crap that's dark he", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00348-00079783-00079935": "doesn't want him dead he wants him to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00349-00079936-00080487": "suffer like he did and probably still is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00350-00080488-00080567": "i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00351-00080568-00080782": "don't know why fire prevents the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00352-00080783-00081079": "imperials from presuming ben", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00353-00081080-00081247": "and the spy dressed as an imperial", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00354-00081248-00081438": "officer fires off a couple shots there's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00355-00081439-00081575": "a fire between", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00356-00081576-00082262": "vader and ben", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00357-00082263-00082462": "and riva killed the person who was", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00358-00082463-00082655": "supposed to take leia hoping to trickle", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00359-00082656-00082894": "she does run off but you know it looks", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00360-00082895-00082967": "like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00361-00082968-00083159": "i mean i guess it depends on if riva is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00362-00083160-00083471": "any better at chasing down", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00363-00083472-00083767": "you know ten-year-old leia than all of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00364-00083768-00084006": "those mercenaries were so", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00365-00084007-00084271": "yeah that would actually yeah i kind of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00366-00084272-00084359": "want to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00367-00084360-00084550": "i'm wondering if next way if there's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00368-00084551-00084711": "going to be like this", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00369-00084712-00084967": "odd clash between how", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00370-00084968-00085191": "much the writers want leia to run away", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00371-00085192-00085359": "from adults", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00372-00085360-00085950": "to how badass they're making riva", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00373-00085951-00086150": "which you know i i don't have any", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00374-00086151-00086335": "problem with you know i i think it's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00375-00086336-00086518": "great that a black woman is getting to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00376-00086519-00086743": "be a badass like this in", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00377-00086744-00087006": "a star wars story in a live-action star", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00378-00087007-00087247": "wars story", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00379-00087248-00087343": "but the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00380-00087344-00087599": "you know some of the things", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00381-00087600-00087775": "you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00382-00087776-00087999": "yeah uh", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00383-00088000-00088191": "you know a guy here on youtube that i've", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00384-00088192-00088406": "had a couple of discussions with you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00385-00088407-00088726": "know pointed out how ridiculous", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00386-00088727-00088855": "it is that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00387-00088856-00089399": "riva wasn't caught for killing the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00388-00089400-00089647": "ah", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00389-00089648-00089831": "inquisitor", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00390-00089832-00090071": "grand inquisitor that's it", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00391-00090072-00090159": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00392-00090160-00090526": "you know how she's ridiculously good at", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00393-00090527-00090767": "force mind reading which", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00394-00090768-00091015": "you know way more than we've seen others", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00395-00091016-00091303": "including vader b", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00396-00091304-00091415": "other people have pointed out the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00397-00091416-00091623": "reluctant hero ben taking care of the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00398-00091624-00091838": "child leia is the same formula as the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00399-00091839-00092126": "mandalorian i think they're legitimately", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00400-00092127-00092335": "worried that people will end up hating", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00401-00092336-00092526": "another one of their star wars disney", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00402-00092527-00092782": "plus shows they probably figured that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00403-00092783-00092982": "you know they probably figured that they", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00404-00092983-00093182": "couldn't go wrong with boba fett he's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00405-00093183-00093438": "you know everybody loves boba fett and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00406-00093439-00093599": "we do", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00407-00093600-00093759": "and it's like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00408-00093760-00093967": "yeah you know that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00409-00093968-00094215": "that show is not great", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00410-00094216-00094343": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00411-00094344-00094479": "yeah i mean i i think there's some", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00412-00094480-00094711": "chance they they maybe figured we you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00413-00094712-00094838": "know they didn't have to put in that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00414-00094839-00095079": "much effort for boba fett that people", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00415-00095080-00095311": "were gonna love it regardless", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00416-00095312-00095526": "and people did not", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00417-00095527-00095703": "and so they're now", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00418-00095704-00095903": "yeah although this one has also gotten", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00419-00095904-00096055": "some really bad reviews", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00420-00096056-00096287": "negative reviews", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00421-00096288-00096382": "now", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00422-00096383-00096687": "i i agree with a lot of nerds criticisms", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00423-00096688-00096943": "of this episode but one thing they said", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00424-00096944-00097079": "that it was bad writing that the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00425-00097080-00097215": "stormtrooper said", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00426-00097216-00097367": "you know it's a long drive then two", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00427-00097368-00097550": "minutes later they were there i mean i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00428-00097551-00097735": "think the dude was lying i think it", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00429-00097736-00097918": "would have been pretty ridiculous if he", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00430-00097919-00098015": "was like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00431-00098016-00098191": "oh it's a long story well in that case", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00432-00098192-00098318": "let me just completely ignore my", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00433-00098319-00098711": "responsibility you know like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00434-00098712-00098982": "it's instead of basically like arresting", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00435-00098983-00099279": "him on the spot for obstructing or", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00436-00099280-00099494": "something you know he's basically", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00437-00099495-00099655": "like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00438-00099656-00099879": "pretending that oh it's it's not that", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00439-00099880-00100126": "serious i just i'm interested you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00440-00100127-00100487": "like the moment that you say no to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00441-00100488-00100655": "a fascist", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00442-00100656-00100831": "you know they they don't tend to like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00443-00100832-00101311": "that very much so yeah", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00444-00101312-00101471": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00445-00101472-00101815": "that is everything that i had so yeah", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00446-00101816-00102031": "i know not everybody agrees with me", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00447-00102032-00102367": "i continue to really love this show and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00448-00102368-00102566": "as long as they're as long as this is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00449-00102567-00102878": "what they do with ben and vader", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00450-00102879-00103223": "you know i i really don't want them to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00451-00103224-00103342": "like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00452-00103343-00103615": "them you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00453-00103616-00103758": "i am a little worried that they'll end", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00454-00103759-00103982": "up ruining some of these characters", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00455-00103983-00104239": "you know there are three episodes left", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00456-00104240-00104486": "you know and they did", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00457-00104488-00104647": "really do some", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00458-00104648-00104847": "they made some strange decisions when", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00459-00104848-00105223": "handling boba fett but", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00460-00105224-00105447": "ben he's in a different place that we've", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00461-00105448-00105551": "seen", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00462-00105552-00105719": "in live action i haven't watched the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00463-00105720-00106007": "anime i will i will i promise but i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00464-00106008-00106223": "haven't gotten to him yet", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00465-00106224-00106358": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00466-00106359-00106671": "you know yeah with vader like it's this", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00467-00106672-00106839": "sort of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00468-00106840-00107063": "middle ground", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00469-00107064-00107207": "between", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00470-00107208-00107375": "the prequel trilogy", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00471-00107376-00107447": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00472-00107448-00107743": "the original trilogy he's not quite", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00473-00107744-00107883": "at the point", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00474-00107883-00108151": "like the the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00475-00108152-00108375": "you know the vader of the the original", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00476-00108376-00108551": "trilogy", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00477-00108552-00108766": "you know didn't", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00478-00108767-00108983": "yeah like when you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00479-00108983-00109263": "we've we've seen what it looks like when", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00480-00109264-00109439": "ben and darth vader", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00481-00109440-00109599": "in the original trilogy when they come", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00482-00109600-00109895": "face to face you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00483-00109896-00110110": "darth vader doesn't say this is all your", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00484-00110111-00110271": "fault", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00485-00110272-00110478": "he says", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00486-00110479-00110710": "i am more powerful than you you know so", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00487-00110711-00110886": "there there's a there's a distinct", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00488-00110888-00111047": "difference between the i i know that's", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00489-00111048-00111334": "not a direct quote", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00490-00111335-00111647": "you know yeah you know the quote um", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00491-00111648-00111799": "if you're watching this video presumably", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00492-00111800-00111999": "you love star wars so i don't have to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00493-00112000-00112095": "quote", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00494-00112096-00112375": "the exact verbatim line", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00495-00112376-00112566": "you know what i'm talking about you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00496-00112567-00112663": "he", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00497-00112664-00113078": "he is more like trying to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00498-00113079-00113286": "you know in in this one he's trying to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00499-00113288-00113463": "shame him", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00500-00113464-00113710": "where in the the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00501-00113711-00114031": "in a new hope he's basically trying to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00502-00114032-00114286": "like overwhelm him scare him overpower", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00503-00114288-00114399": "him", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00504-00114400-00114607": "you know so so these are very different", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00505-00114608-00114878": "vaders and very different bends", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00506-00114879-00115151": "you know that's another thing ben also", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00507-00115152-00115334": "was you know he's like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00508-00115335-00115566": "only a master of evil", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00509-00115567-00115766": "you know he's he's not trying to reach", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00510-00115767-00116015": "him he's saying", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00511-00116016-00116351": "you were once good and now you're evil", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00512-00116352-00116599": "you know the the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00513-00116600-00116766": "again you know here", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00514-00116767-00117023": "like when when ben says", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00515-00117024-00117190": "what have you become", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00516-00117191-00117447": "there's like this this shock to it like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00517-00117448-00117631": "he hasn't", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00518-00117632-00117863": "which again aleghinis did not seem", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00519-00117864-00118110": "shocked he was like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00520-00118111-00118334": "here he comes here's here's vader and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00521-00118335-00118566": "i'm gonna i'm gonna buy them some time", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00522-00118567-00118871": "and that's it you know so", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00523-00118872-00119119": "yeah the the these are these are very", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00524-00119120-00119263": "different they're not just trying to", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00525-00119264-00119439": "redo they're not like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00526-00119440-00119647": "wink wink nudge nudge remember this", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00527-00119648-00119799": "situation it's it's a different", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00528-00119800-00119951": "situation", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00529-00119952-00120199": "you know the the people", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00530-00120200-00120366": "are technically", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00531-00120367-00120543": "you know it's this is technically the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00532-00120544-00120775": "ben who becomes alec guinness this is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00533-00120776-00121071": "technically the vader who becomes", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00534-00121072-00121214": "i'm sorry dude i don't remember your", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00535-00121215-00121423": "name david something you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00536-00121424-00121575": "carried", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00537-00121576-00121854": "the old guy in a clockwork orange up and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00538-00121855-00122063": "down stairs a million times because", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00539-00122064-00122295": "kubrick made you", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00540-00122296-00122607": "you are a big part of why original vader", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00541-00122608-00122758": "was awesome", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00542-00122759-00122934": "and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00543-00122935-00123134": "yeah i'm um", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00544-00123135-00123231": "you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00545-00123232-00123534": "it was a huge loss when you die r.i.p", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00546-00123535-00123734": "but the the yeah the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00547-00123735-00123895": "these characters will eventually become", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00548-00123896-00124214": "those but they aren't at this time and", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00549-00124215-00124414": "yeah i really appreciated that i really", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00550-00124415-00124614": "really liked the the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00551-00124615-00124895": "difference there and the the same thing", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00552-00124896-00125143": "with th that's actually i can kind of", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00553-00125144-00125390": "see what people mean that leia is almost", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00554-00125391-00125527": "written to be", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00555-00125528-00125647": "already", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00556-00125648-00125831": "leia of a new hope like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00557-00125832-00126054": "okay she doesn't know how to shoot yet", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00558-00126055-00126295": "and she's a little trusting and stuff", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00559-00126296-00126366": "but", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00560-00126367-00126551": "she talks like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00561-00126552-00126902": "teenage leia and that's weird because", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00562-00126903-00127134": "she's not you know i i want to say it", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00563-00127135-00127278": "was", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00564-00127279-00127454": "sean chandler talks about who", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00565-00127455-00127654": "specifically pointed out like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00566-00127655-00127814": "if i recall he said something like i", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00567-00127815-00127975": "have an eight-year-old i have a 10 year", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00568-00127976-00128095": "old", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00569-00128096-00128207": "this is a", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00570-00128208-00128414": "10 year old who sometimes acts like an", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00571-00128415-00128527": "eight-year-old you know something like", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00572-00128528-00128766": "go watch his video he's great", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00573-00128767-00129047": "yeah you know the the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00574-00129048-00129175": "yeah the", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00575-00129176-00129383": "it is a little awkward i think they're", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00576-00129383-00129495": "worried", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00577-00129496-00129654": "that people are gonna say they're", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00578-00129655-00129975": "they're making a female character weak", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00579-00129976-00130207": "and as much as i hate when", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00580-00130208-00130319": "you know", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00581-00130320-00130543": "yeah i i think", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00582-00130544-00130743": "if you can you should try to make female", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00583-00130744-00130927": "characters strong", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00584-00130928-00131047": "but", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00585-00131048-00131327": "there's a it gets a little silly at", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00586-00131328-00131583": "times when when she really she is", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00587-00131584-00131683": "talking", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00588-00131684-00131983": "like she's she's uh", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00589-00131984-00132183": "you know older than", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00590-00132184-00132383": "yeah it's it's yeah", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00591-00132384-00132478": "anyway", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00592-00132479-00132631": "that was all", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00593-00132632-00132911": "for this one i hope you enjoyed watching", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00594-00132912-00133087": "as i enjoyed watching recording and i'll", "S4uI-eDwDn4-00595-00133088-00133384": "catch you next time"}}, {"audio_id": "S4BmPbDJEbU", "text": {"S4BmPbDJEbU-00000-00000119-00000443": "so we're now we're now recording good", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00001-00000444-00000614": "morning good afternoon and good evening", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00002-00000615-00000908": "to everyone and welcome to this", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00003-00000909-00001100": "consultation meeting as we prepare for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00004-00001101-00001482": "the vou international partners meeting I", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00005-00001483-00001793": "see we've got a quite a good number of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00006-00001794-00002099": "folk that have joined us just one or two", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00007-00002100-00002357": "housekeeping rules if you could just", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00008-00002358-00002626": "please mute your audio if you're not", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00009-00002627-00002941": "speaking so that we can avoid any", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00010-00002942-00003226": "feedback loops towards the bottom of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00011-00003227-00003497": "your panels there should be a little", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00012-00003497-00003688": "microphone icon that you can toggle on", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00013-00003689-00003886": "and off so I'd appreciate that if you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00014-00003887-00004019": "could just mute if you're not speaking", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00015-00004020-00004213": "and then of course remember to turn it", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00016-00004214-00004625": "back on if you want to say something if", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00017-00004626-00004786": "this is your first sort of open", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00018-00004787-00004961": "consultation meeting that you are", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00019-00004962-00005443": "joining sort of standard practice is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00020-00005444-00005702": "when we are discussing decisions that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00021-00005703-00006074": "silence means a sense so Yamini when", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00022-00006075-00006179": "it's free to contribute to the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00023-00006180-00006322": "conversation but you know if you're", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00024-00006323-00006484": "taking a decision if we don't hear", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00025-00006486-00006770": "anything we assume that everybody is in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00026-00006770-00007114": "agreement with us and that is pretty", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00027-00007115-00007451": "much how we run these sessions now I've", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00028-00007452-00007603": "scheduled an hour for the meeting and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00029-00007604-00007792": "our team that we get finished with in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00030-00007793-00008192": "that hour and with your permission I", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00031-00008193-00008384": "think it would be a good idea if you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00032-00008385-00008542": "just skip the introductions if that's", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00033-00008543-00008807": "okay with you because if everybody has a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00034-00008808-00008939": "minute or two introducing themselves", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00035-00008940-00009098": "through between e minutes into the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00036-00009099-00009533": "meeting so with your permission we'll", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00037-00009534-00009791": "skip the introductions of everyone but", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00038-00009792-00009980": "when when you do speak or contribute to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00039-00009981-00010117": "the meeting you can introduce yourself", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00040-00010118-00010427": "then does that meet everybody's", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00041-00010428-00010567": "agreement or would you like to go", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00042-00010568-00010909": "through a quick round of introductions", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00043-00010910-00011206": "I'll take silence unison that we went", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00044-00011207-00011605": "we'll skip over the introductions okay", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00045-00011606-00011914": "great thank you very much so let's see", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00046-00011915-00012149": "technology willing you see if I can get", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00047-00012150-00012701": "a screen share going yeah", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00048-00012702-00012930": "that should be coming through for you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00049-00012931-00014022": "now okay is the screen shaker coming", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00050-00014022-00014213": "through Dave can just give me a thumbs", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00051-00014215-00014496": "up if the screen she's text yeah that's", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00052-00014497-00014934": "all good so there we go so this is the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00053-00014935-00015138": "agenda I posted it's been available in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00054-00015138-00015480": "the wiki and the aims that became for us", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00055-00015481-00015729": "just to cover today just review our", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00056-00015730-00015924": "progress with the OEO University of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00057-00015925-00016319": "study and the - MVP Minimum Viable", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00058-00016320-00016683": "Product technology platform then to move", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00059-00016684-00016869": "move on to the consultation of the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00060-00016870-00017058": "agenda for the six international", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00061-00017059-00017255": "partners meeting we have the tradition", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00062-00017256-00017475": "that the AVR you that we consult with", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00063-00017476-00017688": "our partners in shaping at the agenda", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00064-00017689-00017871": "once we've had this discussion today", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00065-00017872-00018147": "I'll also be meeting with the Africa and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00066-00018148-00018414": "the European partners who in the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00067-00018415-00018660": "different time zone next week to have", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00068-00018661-00018924": "this conversation with them as well", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00069-00018925-00019097": "and then we will start crafting the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00070-00019098-00019314": "agenda in the wiki based on the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00071-00019315-00019563": "conversations we've had now and then you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00072-00019564-00019668": "know it's all done openly and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00073-00019669-00019815": "transparently so you'd be able to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00074-00019816-00020184": "contribute it at any time and then also", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00075-00020185-00020456": "just to update on a couple of related", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00076-00020457-00020709": "projects in the marketing and analytics", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00077-00020710-00021147": "space I also posted a rough outline", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00078-00021148-00021647": "agenda on the wiki page there I assumed", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00079-00021648-00021762": "that we were all comfortable with the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00080-00021763-00021981": "agenda I didn't have anybody posting the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00081-00021982-00022253": "additional items on the agenda so before", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00082-00022254-00022569": "we move on is the agenda okay with you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00083-00022570-00022922": "again silence means assent anything you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00084-00022923-00023633": "would like to add just on", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00085-00023634-00023816": "of housekeeping if you do if you would", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00086-00023817-00024179": "like to get the microphone at the bottom", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00087-00024180-00024422": "on the panel that you're looking at this", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00088-00024423-00024665": "there's a participant link I believe and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00089-00024666-00024905": "you can actually raise your hand and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00090-00024906-00025091": "then I should be able to see on my in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00091-00025092-00025424": "the photo raise their hands to want to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00092-00025425-00026105": "speak okay right so what I did is I put", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00093-00026106-00026285": "together a couple of slides just to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00094-00026286-00026437": "summarize the progress of where we were", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00095-00026438-00026624": "at with the diversity of study and I", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00096-00026625-00026786": "thought that would be a good a good", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00097-00026787-00027074": "place to start and provide context for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00098-00027075-00027465": "the meeting so it's just quickly do that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00099-00027466-00027701": "with that on full-screen mode so that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00100-00027702-00028130": "should be coming through obviously our", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00101-00028131-00028390": "major focus this year has been the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00102-00028391-00028655": "implementation of the OVR you first year", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00103-00028656-00029020": "of study and we are targeting to exit", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00104-00029022-00029339": "qualifications the first one is the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00105-00029339-00029501": "certificate of higher education in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00106-00029502-00029770": "business which will be conferred by the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00107-00029772-00029957": "University of the Highlands and Islands", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00108-00029958-00030258": "in Scotland and we're at the point that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00109-00030260-00030686": "the appropriate academic board at the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00110-00030687-00030860": "University of Highlands and Islands has", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00111-00030861-00031162": "been abated the qualification subject to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00112-00031163-00031471": "implementing a couple of requirements", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00113-00031472-00031739": "and Andy Brown is in the process of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00114-00031739-00031964": "implementing those as final requirements", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00115-00031964-00032290": "and so what validation means in the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00116-00032291-00032458": "University of Highlands and Islands", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00117-00032459-00032723": "context once the qualification is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00118-00032724-00033008": "validated they are able to list it on", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00119-00033009-00033275": "the University calendar and even though", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00120-00033276-00033526": "all the courses might not be completed", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00121-00033527-00033787": "we can actually start teaching the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00122-00033788-00034082": "program so in terms of how the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00123-00034083-00034298": "qualification is structured it's a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00124-00034299-00034669": "hundred and twenty UK based credits", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00125-00034670-00034982": "there are three core courses that total", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00126-00034983-00035215": "60 credits which the University of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00127-00035216-00035375": "Highlands and Islands will be assembling", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00128-00035376-00035471": "as OVR", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00129-00035472-00035864": "and then the remaining 60 credits will", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00130-00035865-00036098": "be made up from the list of optional", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00131-00036099-00036389": "courses we've got them we have a total", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00132-00036390-00036704": "of 94 prehensile or optional credits", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00133-00036705-00036857": "that will be available so we have more", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00134-00036858-00036955": "than", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00135-00036956-00037219": "sufficient courseware for this attribute", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00136-00037220-00037480": "of higher education in business the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00137-00037481-00037756": "green ticks you see there are courses", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00138-00037757-00038047": "that are completed and published on the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00139-00038048-00038443": "oer u platform the progress bar courses", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00140-00038444-00038785": "there are more than 75 percent complete", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00141-00038786-00039016": "and should be completed by the time we", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00142-00039017-00039235": "get to the international partners", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00143-00039236-00039685": "meeting in october also of interest is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00144-00039686-00039910": "we've signed an agreement with the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00145-00039911-00040147": "Saylor foundation we have given us a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00146-00040148-00040516": "license to use the item test banks for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00147-00040517-00040696": "summative assessment for the principles", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00148-00040697-00040864": "of microeconomics and principles of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00149-00040865-00041116": "microeconomics courses so that could", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00150-00041117-00041308": "mean any of our partner institutions", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00151-00041309-00041554": "would be able to use automated", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00152-00041555-00041953": "assessment for these courses should they", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00153-00041954-00042109": "want to we have a license to use those", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00154-00042110-00042489": "test banks and we are keen to you know", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00155-00042490-00042781": "implement an arrangement with prop to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00156-00042782-00043066": "you for the identity validation for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00157-00043067-00043288": "those two courses so that's kind of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00158-00043289-00043438": "where we're at on the certificate of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00159-00043439-00043854": "higher education in business the second", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00160-00043855-00044110": "exit qualification is the certificate of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00161-00044111-00044335": "general studies that will become third", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00162-00044336-00044689": "by Thomson Rivers University the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00163-00044690-00044905": "certificate of general studies at TR u", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00164-00044906-00045136": "has a residency requirement of six North", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00165-00045137-00045505": "American credits and basically TR you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00166-00045506-00045799": "have in fact completed the two courses", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00167-00045800-00045988": "that would be required for the residency", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00168-00045989-00046219": "requirement art appreciation and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00169-00046220-00046380": "techniques has been completed", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00170-00046381-00046579": "introduction to research methods in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00171-00046580-00046804": "psychology has in fact been completed on", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00172-00046805-00047053": "the wiki the only work that is being", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00173-00047054-00047404": "done there now is just to reconfigure it", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00174-00047405-00047833": "or reconfigure that course into micro", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00175-00047834-00048109": "courses and so here you are progressing", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00176-00048110-00048603": "that work we will have in the arts field", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00177-00048604-00048955": "26 credits available you can see the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00178-00048956-00049165": "courses that have been really competed", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00179-00049166-00049374": "there and available for offer", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00180-00049375-00049675": "introductory to psychology regime I know", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00181-00049676-00050046": "you are pretty much close to done there", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00182-00050047-00050255": "also", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00183-00050256-00050490": "doing a certificate in general studies", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00184-00050491-00050838": "it's also possible to have the business", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00185-00050839-00051114": "courses recognized towards the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00186-00051115-00051308": "certificate in all studies at EIU", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00187-00051309-00051594": "there's an internal approval process for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00188-00051595-00051880": "all these courses and Brenda Thompson", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00189-00051882-00052200": "the Associate Dean of Arts there is the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00190-00052201-00052437": "needing you know the internal approval", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00191-00052438-00052734": "processes and tiu so that's all looking", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00192-00052735-00052884": "good we've got sufficient calls for you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00193-00052885-00053364": "to get moving there as you well know", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00194-00053365-00053532": "those if you've been traveling with the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00195-00053533-00053847": "earlier you for a long time I mean the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00196-00053848-00054177": "key features of our credit transfer", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00197-00054178-00054396": "model is that our partner institutions", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00198-00054397-00054678": "retain decision-making autonomy over all", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00199-00054679-00054980": "aspects of the credit transfer and as", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00200-00054982-00055179": "you know we've designed the credit", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00201-00055179-00055434": "transfer system in a way that is able to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00202-00055435-00055766": "operate within existing policies of our", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00203-00055767-00056229": "partner institutions with the partners", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00204-00056229-00056424": "who are actively engaged with the first", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00205-00056425-00056579": "day of study in other words those that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00206-00056580-00056832": "will be have confirmed that they will be", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00207-00056833-00057005": "offering assessment services for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00208-00057007-00057242": "transcript credits as well as the to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00209-00057244-00057545": "confirming institutions have", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00210-00057546-00057807": "collaborated and developed between a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00211-00057808-00058016": "transferred contract which is the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00212-00058017-00058203": "agreement that will be signed between", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00213-00058204-00058616": "the participating partners that a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00214-00058617-00058854": "document has been reviewed by the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00215-00058854-00059141": "respective registrar's at these partner", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00216-00059142-00059223": "institutions", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00217-00059224-00059492": "I've also circulated the consultation", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00218-00059494-00059871": "documents that if any of the part any of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00219-00059872-00060138": "the other partners want to get on board", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00220-00060139-00060333": "with the first year of study in either", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00221-00060334-00060579": "offering assessment services for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00222-00060579-00060900": "transcript credit or recognizing any of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00223-00060901-00061119": "the area ru causes in the first year of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00224-00061120-00061379": "study towards local qualifications I've", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00225-00061380-00061572": "circulated that document so that you'll", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00226-00061573-00061833": "be able to see what it looks like and of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00227-00061834-00062088": "course any feedback would be welcome I", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00228-00062089-00062244": "just want to note that that credit", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00229-00062245-00062617": "transfer agreement was based on the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00230-00062619-00062883": "guidelines for credit transfer and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00231-00062884-00063107": "credit accumulation that we approved at", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00232-00063108-00063573": "the 2015 meeting so I mean this has been", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00233-00063574-00063835": "arguably the hardest not to crack within", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00234-00063836-00064072": "the network but we've actually made very", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00235-00064073-00064305": "very good progress with the fact that we", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00236-00064306-00064454": "have you know the registrar's", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00237-00064455-00064755": "comfortable with the articulation", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00238-00064756-00065142": "agreements I also just want to update", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00239-00065143-00065630": "you the OVR you has partnered with a new", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00240-00065631-00065838": "micro-credentialing initiative called", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00241-00065839-00066040": "oedipus which has been led by a target", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00242-00066041-00066346": "polytechnic and all the optional", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00243-00066347-00066736": "business courses all the optional micro", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00244-00066737-00066924": "courses that we've assembled for the OVR", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00245-00066925-00067212": "university of study will be available", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00246-00067213-00067510": "for transcript credit i also just want", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00247-00067511-00067804": "to mention a recent announcement by the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00248-00067805-00067978": "new zealand minister of tertiary", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00249-00067979-00068272": "education skills and employment that is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00250-00068273-00068467": "wrong and all that better that is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00251-00068468-00068763": "launched three micro-credentialing pilot", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00252-00068764-00069097": "studies for new zealand to investigate", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00253-00069098-00069547": "and the edibles pilot with OVR u is one", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00254-00069548-00069697": "of the official pilots that have been", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00255-00069698-00069957": "investigated in new zealand so i mean", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00256-00069958-00070222": "clearly there is growing interest in how", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00257-00070223-00070510": "the micro-credentialing model might pan", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00258-00070511-00070846": "out in the future so for example in the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00259-00070847-00071086": "earlier you context this is an example", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00260-00071087-00071307": "of the introduction to project", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00261-00071308-00071526": "management course which is part of the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00262-00071527-00071697": "certificate of higher education business", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00263-00071698-00072129": "there are four micro courses that are", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00264-00072130-00072466": "available once we learners complete each", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00265-00072467-00072779": "one of these micro courses they will", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00266-00072780-00073050": "receive a digital or they will receive", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00267-00073051-00073212": "digital certification for assess", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00268-00073213-00073440": "learning and once the learners have", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00269-00073441-00073767": "completed the Associated set of micro", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00270-00073768-00074088": "credentials at Agra Polytechnic will be", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00271-00074089-00074526": "able to issue transcript credit which", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00272-00074527-00074706": "will be recognized towards the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00273-00074707-00074860": "certificate of higher education", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00274-00074861-00075190": "businesses at UAH ISO will also be able", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00275-00075191-00075513": "to pilot the whole micro-credentialing", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00276-00075514-00075926": "space with the area university of study", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00277-00075927-00076362": "we are we have announced a soft launch", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00278-00076363-00076644": "schedule commensurate with the decision", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00279-00076645-00076870": "that was taken at the 2016 partners", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00280-00076871-00077224": "meeting you know to focus on realistic", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00281-00077225-00077515": "but you know and conservative targets as", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00282-00077516-00077746": "we slowly build brand awareness and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00283-00077747-00078274": "collect data with the launch of the Ohio", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00284-00078275-00078553": "first year of study so the first phase", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00285-00078554-00078757": "is will to start with the with one", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00286-00078758-00078901": "course which we'll be learning in a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00287-00078902-00079171": "digital age which focuses on building", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00288-00079172-00079333": "the digital and learning literacies that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00289-00079334-00079627": "are required for the 21st century which", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00290-00079628-00079804": "is one of the courses that will be", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00291-00079805-00079936": "recognized towards a certificate of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00292-00079937-00080212": "higher education in business and then we", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00293-00080213-00080446": "decided to focus on courses which are", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00294-00080447-00080944": "likely to have a large appeal in these", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00295-00080945-00081150": "early phases so we can gather data", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00296-00081151-00081391": "during phase two we're looking at", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00297-00081392-00081591": "launching principles of management", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00298-00081592-00081849": "introduction to entrepreneurship and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00299-00081850-00082143": "introduction to project management and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00300-00082144-00082408": "then what we will do is we will plot out", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00301-00082409-00082729": "the de phase launch four phases three", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00302-00082730-00083128": "and beyond and our thinking is that that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00303-00083129-00083380": "will be one of the major agenda items at", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00304-00083381-00083785": "the international partners meeting so", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00305-00083786-00083970": "that in terms of where we're at with", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00306-00083971-00084259": "courseware the other side of the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00307-00084260-00084538": "equation is this concept of open", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00308-00084539-00084820": "pedagogy which I accept is not well", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00309-00084821-00085090": "defined yet and you know it's still very", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00310-00085091-00085351": "much a contested concept but I do think", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00311-00085352-00085654": "it's worthwhile to think about what are", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00312-00085655-00085993": "the oer you open model enables that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00313-00085994-00086329": "closed is not easy all their clothes", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00314-00086330-00086587": "would not be able to do and we have a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00315-00086588-00086842": "couple of interesting examples one is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00316-00086843-00087340": "this notion of the discovery the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00317-00087341-00087673": "pedagogy of discovery which Jim Taylor", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00318-00087674-00087922": "has been working with now I accept that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00319-00087923-00088132": "the image that I've got these only semi", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00320-00088133-00088366": "free-range learning you will see that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00321-00088367-00088519": "there is a little fence in the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00322-00088520-00088723": "background but I thought but I suppose", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00323-00088724-00089107": "that's you know in indicative of the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00324-00089108-00089254": "kinds of constraints that we have to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00325-00089255-00089497": "work with so we've got we've got a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00326-00089498-00089800": "number of courses that have implemented", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00327-00089801-00090109": "this thinking of the pedagogy of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00328-00090110-00090244": "discovery we learn as go", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00329-00090245-00090577": "and access and find resources in pursuit", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00330-00090578-00090778": "of the own learning interests in order", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00331-00090779-00090946": "to achieve the learning outcomes of the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00332-00090947-00091396": "courses and one of the good examples of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00333-00091397-00091717": "this is the course that USQ assembled", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00334-00091718-00091918": "regional relations in Asia and the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00335-00091919-00092191": "Pacific I mean the Asia Pacific region", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00336-00092192-00092451": "is more than 40 different countries and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00337-00092452-00092665": "arguably I don't think it would be easy", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00338-00092666-00092959": "to assemble a closed textbook that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00339-00092960-00093244": "covers 40 different countries it's a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00340-00093245-00093718": "good example of how this open pedagogy", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00341-00093719-00094000": "of discovery is able to support learning", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00342-00094001-00094255": "in ways that close models are not able", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00343-00094256-00094489": "to do we've also implemented the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00344-00094490-00094702": "pedagogy of discovery in the learning in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00345-00094703-00094993": "the digital age course the other", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00346-00094994-00095326": "dimension is you know thinking about", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00347-00095327-00095626": "what learning on the open web might look", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00348-00095627-00095839": "like in the future and this is one of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00349-00095840-00096010": "the strengths I think of the area you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00350-00096011-00096316": "network is that we've taken enough an", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00351-00096317-00096766": "approach rather than presenting and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00352-00096767-00097042": "offering our learning environments", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00353-00097043-00097309": "through a single application we are", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00354-00097310-00097513": "thinking about how would you design the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00355-00097514-00097711": "system where learners are actually", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00356-00097712-00097960": "learning on the Internet as opposed to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00357-00097961-00098128": "for example using a single learning", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00358-00098129-00098476": "management system and we can you know", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00359-00098477-00098752": "have a look at some of our technology", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00360-00098753-00098989": "that we're using to achieve this those", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00361-00098990-00099265": "of you that have been engaged with the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00362-00099266-00099523": "Assembly of oh we are you courses will", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00363-00099524-00099784": "be familiar with the model we use we", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00364-00099785-00100087": "also all our courses using a wiki", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00365-00100088-00100255": "technology in fact the media wiki", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00366-00100256-00100501": "software angel and this gives us the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00367-00100502-00100774": "ability to collaborate internationally", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00368-00100775-00101086": "across our different countries but also", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00369-00101087-00101353": "to maintain a detailed version history", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00370-00101354-00101707": "of all the edits that are made with our", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00371-00101708-00101950": "our course developments so basically", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00372-00101951-00102166": "what an all the does is they assemble a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00373-00102167-00102478": "simple outline on the wiki for our", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00374-00102479-00102742": "earlier partners we provide the ability", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00375-00102743-00102988": "to request a snapshot which triggers a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00376-00102989-00103353": "script that automatically publishes a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00377-00103354-00103624": "responsive website that is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00378-00103625-00104016": "hosted on WordPress technology on the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00379-00104017-00104181": "other side of the equation this is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00380-00104182-00104476": "pretty much what the delivery platform", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00381-00104477-00104786": "looks like from the learners perspective", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00382-00104788-00105060": "learners access the course materials", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00383-00105061-00105208": "that are published on the website these", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00384-00105208-00105585": "WordPress websites as are we are no", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00385-00105586-00105772": "passwords are required in order to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00386-00105773-00106134": "access the materials for us any course", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00387-00106135-00106375": "materials that require a password or a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00388-00106376-00106594": "definite would be per definition a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00389-00106595-00106914": "closed write so learners are able to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00390-00106915-00107115": "access all the course materials for all", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00391-00107116-00107431": "our courses on the web press publish", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00392-00107432-00107764": "sites and then we use a number of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00393-00107765-00107979": "distribution technology as Best of Breed", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00394-00107980-00108258": "open-source technologies that enable the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00395-00108259-00108457": "learners to interact with each other and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00396-00108458-00108751": "we have some smart technologies that are", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00397-00108752-00108997": "able to syndicate and aggregate all", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00398-00108998-00109264": "these interactions on the web in the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00399-00109265-00109527": "life course feed and in a moment Dave", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00400-00109528-00109752": "will explain a little bit of what's", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00401-00109753-00109983": "happening underneath the hood in terms", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00402-00109984-00110173": "of how all those technologies fit", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00403-00110174-00110707": "together so technology willing I've", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00404-00110708-00110928": "embedded an iframe here which is an", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00405-00110929-00111390": "example of the live learning the first", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00406-00111391-00111568": "micro course of the learning in the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00407-00111569-00111802": "digital age digital literacies for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00408-00111803-00111990": "online learning this is pretty much what", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00409-00111991-00112302": "I published course site would look like", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00410-00112303-00112558": "we assemble all our courses as", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00411-00112558-00112929": "individual learning pathways so I could", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00412-00112930-00113127": "go for example into one of these", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00413-00113128-00113320": "learning pathways this is the learning", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00414-00113321-00113565": "pathway on finding and selecting open", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00415-00113566-00113816": "resources you will see that it is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00416-00113817-00114090": "assembled as the number of individual", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00417-00114091-00114322": "course pages learners can navigate", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00418-00114323-00114579": "either through the main menu or just", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00419-00114580-00114814": "clicking on the next button so you get", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00420-00114815-00115002": "the idea in terms of how learners can", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00421-00115003-00115189": "navigate through the course materials", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00422-00115190-00115461": "the other interesting thing is which I", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00423-00115463-00115813": "won't click on now but at every course", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00424-00115814-00116139": "page that is published has a link back", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00425-00116140-00116746": "to the source content in the wiki so you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00426-00116747-00116952": "know that's how we are able to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00427-00116953-00117070": "you know keep the course materials", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00428-00117071-00117324": "up-to-date and have a you know have one", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00429-00117325-00117585": "source of course materials that has", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00430-00117586-00118104": "version control D just the other thing I", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00431-00118105-00118258": "just wanted to highlight just to give", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00432-00118258-00118398": "you a bit of a sense of how this", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00433-00118399-00118629": "pedagogy of discovery works with the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00434-00118630-00119028": "different technologies here is a list of", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00435-00119029-00119289": "a number of learning challenges that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00436-00119290-00119436": "have been assembled for this course", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00437-00119437-00119668": "where the learners go out and do a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00438-00119669-00119949": "number of things and produce artifacts", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00439-00119950-00120387": "of learning with a pedagogy of discovery", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00440-00120388-00120825": "one of the technologies we use is this", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00441-00120826-00121171": "the resource bank so I'm just going to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00442-00121172-00121507": "get our full screen mode here and let me", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00443-00121508-00121824": "just click on a resource Bank activity", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00444-00121825-00122010": "within the course materials so you can", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00445-00122011-00122458": "get an idea so basically what happens", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00446-00122458-00122746": "you know bit of instructions this is", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00447-00122747-00122940": "around learners you know developing a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00448-00122941-00123222": "definition on digital literacies you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00449-00123223-00123416": "know there were social resources and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00450-00123417-00123621": "they're given a couple of instructions", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00451-00123622-00123885": "and then they invited to share resources", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00452-00123886-00124329": "that they find on the resource Bank said", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00453-00124330-00124811": "let me open that up so this is a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00454-00124812-00125068": "technology called semantic scuttle it's", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00455-00125069-00125269": "a piece of open source software which", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00456-00125270-00125474": "enables the sharing of resource links", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00457-00125475-00125883": "not dissimilar to the proprietary diva", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00458-00125884-00126201": "web service where learners can share", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00459-00126202-00126465": "resources they found useful to their own", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00460-00126466-00126702": "learning interests it has features where", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00461-00126703-00127231": "I'm not logged in at the moment but if I", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00462-00127232-00127485": "were logged in they would be able to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00463-00127486-00127662": "vote for resources they found useful", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00464-00127663-00127933": "they can look at just the resources", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00465-00127933-00128133": "they've shared they can look at", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00466-00128134-00128271": "resources that have been shared", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00467-00128272-00128538": "according to different links and tags so", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00468-00128539-00128688": "you can get an idea of how this", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00469-00128689-00128997": "disability learners could able would be", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00470-00128998-00129256": "able to share resources that they found", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00471-00129257-00129609": "useful in terms of their own learning so", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00472-00129610-00129899": "just going back to the course site again", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00473-00129900-00130558": "back", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00474-00130558-00131369": "list of challenges another example that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00475-00131370-00131648": "we have integrated some of you will be", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00476-00131649-00131912": "familiar with this technology called", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00477-00131913-00132089": "hypothesis", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00478-00132090-00132485": "it's a open source technology that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00479-00132486-00132869": "enables learners to annotate any web", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00480-00132870-00133187": "page on the Internet", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00481-00133188-00133358": "so here's an example of an activity", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00482-00133359-00133729": "where the learners are invited to go and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00483-00133730-00134105": "read this article that mark maja Bailey", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00484-00134106-00134354": "had written on digital skills and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00485-00134355-00134831": "digital literacies and so they would", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00486-00134832-00135166": "then go to hypothesis it's just good", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00487-00135167-00135536": "hypothesis website so I'm now logged", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00488-00135537-00136109": "into hypothesis here's the article that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00489-00136110-00136250": "we've invited the learners to go and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00490-00136251-00136598": "annotate and let's just wait for that to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00491-00136599-00137018": "load so there's the the article and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00492-00137019-00137570": "basically how this works is you will see", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00493-00137571-00137852": "here that you know learners would be", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00494-00137853-00138377": "able to annotate any page right they", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00495-00138378-00138626": "could add their comments related to that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00496-00138627-00138863": "annotation and in learners would then", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00497-00138864-00139166": "also be able to reply to posts that", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00498-00139167-00139388": "other learners have made and in by", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00499-00139389-00139619": "adding the course tag our technologies", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00500-00139620-00139982": "will be able to harvest any links to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00501-00139983-00140315": "annotations or replies that learners", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00502-00140316-00140549": "have posted on the course there's just", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00503-00140550-00141002": "two examples of the different", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00504-00141003-00141488": "technologies we're using to enable this", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00505-00141489-00141758": "you know distributed pedagogy so at this", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00506-00141759-00142022": "point what I'm going to do is hand back", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00507-00142023-00142397": "to Dave or hand over to Dave to talk us", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00508-00142398-00142685": "through what's happening underneath the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00509-00142686-00143093": "hood Thank You Wayne yeah I'm Dave Lane", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00510-00143094-00143408": "I'm a open source", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00511-00143409-00143630": "Technologist that's my role with the oer", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00512-00143631-00143840": "Foundation and I'm based in Christchurch", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00513-00143841-00144242": "in New Zealand so I have inherited a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00514-00144243-00144461": "very amazing piece of software written", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00515-00144462-00144629": "by some of you may may be familiar with", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00516-00144630-00144932": "Jim ditzler who was the technologist the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00517-00144933-00145118": "main technologist in the OER foundation", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00518-00145119-00145598": "prior to my taking on that role and I'm", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00519-00145599-00145967": "just sort of updating this technology", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00520-00145968-00146159": "which we refer to as wiki educator notes", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00521-00146160-00146795": "or we notes as you can see the the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00522-00146796-00147053": "concept is that learners will have any", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00523-00147054-00147238": "number of places that they can", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00524-00147239-00147449": "collaborate with one another or", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00525-00147450-00147668": "materials that they can identify as", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00526-00147669-00147845": "being of interest to them in a context", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00527-00147846-00148154": "of a given course so Wayne has just", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00528-00148155-00148469": "showed you the semantic scuttle which", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00529-00148470-00148679": "you can see here is the oer you bookmark", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00530-00148680-00148886": "so we've rebranded it for our own use as", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00531-00148887-00149111": "aru bookmarks because semantic scuttle", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00532-00149112-00149399": "is a bit of a mouthful and but we've got", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00533-00149400-00149558": "a whole number of other technologies", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00534-00149559-00150029": "that our feed harvesters are able to", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00535-00150030-00150491": "automatically check with every well in", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00536-00150492-00150650": "some cases they do it in real time and", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00537-00150651-00150764": "in some cases depending on the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00538-00150765-00151052": "technology they'll do it every 10 or 15", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00539-00151053-00151289": "minutes so anytime someone publishes", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00540-00151290-00151696": "something for example if they do a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00541-00151697-00152012": "hypothesis annotation or if they make a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00542-00152013-00152456": "post in our discourse forums or they use", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00543-00152457-00152909": "our Mastodon micro blogging engine which", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00544-00152910-00153110": "is very similar to Twitter although it's", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00545-00153111-00153338": "open source and it's not run by a single", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00546-00153339-00153725": "corporation or they post a message on", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00547-00153726-00154262": "the online group's mailing list or they", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00548-00154263-00154798": "submit a we note through the actual post", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00549-00154799-00155159": "the posting capability of the course", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00550-00155160-00155345": "feeds that each course has so for", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00551-00155346-00155474": "example you see on the right-hand side", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00552-00155475-00155873": "of this page a screen capture of a", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00553-00155874-00156134": "course feed you'll see that each of the", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00554-00156135-00156485": "course feeds has a post we note right", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00555-00156486-00157358": "there", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00556-00157359-00187771": "you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00557-00187772-00290932": "you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00558-00290933-00304260": "you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00559-00304261-00365827": "you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00560-00365828-00379733": "you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00561-00379734-00380195": "good Archie's well well hope to talk", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00562-00380196-00380501": "soon yeah and have a good look and you", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00563-00380502-00381527": "choose the hall is cooler right if I can", "S4BmPbDJEbU-00564-00381528-00382067": "stop the screenshare stop the recording"}}, {"audio_id": "S4JGzZyYdyy", "text": {"S4JGzZyYdyy-00000-00000041-00000142": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00001-00000143-00000830": "foreign", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00002-00000831-00001370": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00003-00001371-00003433": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00004-00003434-00004751": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00005-00004752-00005740": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00006-00005741-00009653": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00007-00009654-00012379": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00008-00012380-00012685": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00009-00012686-00012891": "it's a destination", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00010-00012893-00013899": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00011-00013900-00014093": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00012-00014094-00014679": "foreign", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00013-00014680-00017729": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00014-00017730-00018509": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00015-00018510-00019759": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00016-00019760-00020804": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00017-00020805-00021150": "[Music]", "S4JGzZyYdyy-00018-00021151-00021476": "thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "S5qaM03Mfhc", "text": {"S5qaM03Mfhc-00000-00000872-00000975": "hello everyone", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00001-00000976-00001199": "in this presentation we will talk about", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00002-00001200-00001431": "scientific workflows and reproducibility", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00003-00001432-00001663": "in ecological niche modelling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00004-00001664-00001910": "my name is liz nadia i work at the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00005-00001911-00002087": "national laboratory for scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00006-00002088-00002279": "computing in brazil", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00007-00002280-00002534": "i'm currently on leave to work at the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00008-00002535-00002679": "balance of the microburst", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00009-00002680-00002950": "cluster of excellence and the university", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00010-00002951-00003231": "of vienna in germany", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00011-00003232-00003470": "this presentation will also be given by", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00012-00003471-00003670": "marie luisa mondeli", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00013-00003671-00003886": "she's a doctoral student at the national", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00014-00003887-00003975": "laboratory for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00015-00003976-00004295": "scientific computing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00016-00004296-00004679": "this is the agenda for our presentation", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00017-00004680-00004999": "uh first we will introduce uh", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00018-00005000-00005199": "some concepts from data intensive", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00019-00005200-00005335": "science", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00020-00005336-00005759": "and computational scientific experiments", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00021-00005760-00006254": "next we talk about scientific workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00022-00006255-00006463": "defining them and showing how they have", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00023-00006464-00006655": "been used so far", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00024-00006656-00006975": "in ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00025-00006976-00007278": "next we", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00026-00007279-00007574": "describe reproducibility in ecological", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00027-00007575-00007783": "niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00028-00007784-00008095": "showing the challenge and also", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00029-00008095-00008374": "ongoing research in this area and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00030-00008375-00008695": "finally we close the the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00031-00008696-00008878": "presentation with some concluding", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00032-00008879-00009359": "remarks", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00033-00009360-00009695": "data intensive science is defined", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00034-00009696-00009942": "by the exploration of large-scale data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00035-00009943-00010095": "sets to produce", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00036-00010096-00010438": "scientific results", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00037-00010439-00010751": "it is enabled by the large scale", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00038-00010752-00011063": "computational infrastructures now", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00039-00011064-00011183": "available", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00040-00011184-00011438": "and also by the increasing volumes of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00041-00011439-00011623": "data produced by high capacity", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00042-00011624-00011855": "scientific instruments", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00043-00011856-00012144": "and also by initiatives to", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00044-00012145-00012295": "[Music]", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00045-00012296-00012687": "produce and gather data such as the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00046-00012688-00013143": "digitization of biological collections", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00047-00013144-00013366": "data intensive science involves various", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00048-00013368-00013566": "research objects", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00049-00013568-00013847": "such as data sets including reference", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00050-00013847-00013919": "data sets", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00051-00013919-00014238": "created databases scientific software", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00052-00014240-00014527": "scientific workflows experimental", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00053-00014528-00014655": "protocols", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00054-00014656-00015111": "and also the resulting publications", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00055-00015112-00015483": "from this computational research", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00056-00015484-00015791": "ideally all the research objects", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00057-00015791-00016086": "should follow the fair principles this", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00058-00016087-00016303": "means that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00059-00016304-00016615": "it should be easy to discover them", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00060-00016616-00017167": "independently by humans and machines", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00061-00017168-00017439": "uh it should be easy to recover them", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00062-00017440-00017727": "under well-defined conditions", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00063-00017728-00018055": "uh it should be easy to integrate them", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00064-00018056-00018447": "with other research objects especially", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00065-00018448-00018711": "when metadata standards are used for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00066-00018712-00018886": "instance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00067-00018887-00019111": "and finally it should be", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00068-00019112-00019271": "[Music]", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00069-00019272-00019639": "easy to use these research", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00070-00019640-00019983": "objects and experimentary executions", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00071-00019984-00020655": "along with other research objects", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00072-00020656-00020911": "data intensive science also relies on", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00073-00020912-00021175": "computational scientific experiments", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00074-00021176-00021558": "these can be defined as the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00075-00021559-00021927": "can be defined by the composition of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00076-00021928-00022230": "various computational activities such as", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00077-00022231-00022367": "programs", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00078-00022368-00022750": "and calls for function libraries", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00079-00022751-00022949": "for instance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00080-00022950-00023294": "[Music]", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00081-00023295-00023494": "these these computational scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00082-00023495-00023878": "experiments have some frequent features", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00083-00023879-00024103": "such as the multitude of computational", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00084-00024104-00024399": "activities", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00085-00024400-00024678": "the management of large-scale amounts of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00086-00024679-00024822": "data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00087-00024823-00025283": "and the use of parallel and distributed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00088-00025284-00025567": "computing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00089-00025568-00025870": "scientific workflows can be seen as a", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00090-00025872-00025999": "concrete example", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00091-00026000-00026423": "of computational scientific experiments", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00092-00026424-00026631": "they consist of the specification of the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00093-00026632-00026743": "chain of scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00094-00026744-00027135": "applications that need to be executed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00095-00027136-00027374": "and also of the mutual dependencies that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00096-00027375-00027527": "exist between these", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00097-00027527-00027862": "scientific applications", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00098-00027863-00028214": "scientific workflows follow a life cycle", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00099-00028216-00028551": "that is similar to that to that of the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00100-00028552-00028895": "computational scientific experiments", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00101-00028895-00029351": "so we have a step of composition", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00102-00029352-00029679": "where the the scientific applications", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00103-00029680-00029774": "that compose", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00104-00029775-00030087": "the scientific workflow will be", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00105-00030088-00030431": "defined along with", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00106-00030432-00030846": "the dependencies that exist between", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00107-00030847-00031183": "the scientific applications uh", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00108-00031183-00031527": "in a subsequent step", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00109-00031527-00031751": "uh the scientific workflow needs to be", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00110-00031752-00031824": "executed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00111-00031825-00031951": "[Music]", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00112-00031952-00032199": "so every scientific application needs to", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00113-00032200-00032439": "be mapped to some computational", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00114-00032439-00032783": "resource where it will be executed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00115-00032784-00033062": "and also the data sets that will be", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00116-00033063-00033374": "consumed by each scientific application", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00117-00033375-00033551": "need to be transferred to this", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00118-00033552-00033887": "computational resource", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00119-00033888-00034262": "and finally there is a step of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00120-00034263-00034527": "documentation where metadata and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00121-00034528-00034655": "provenance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00122-00034656-00035083": "are collected and these consist", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00123-00035084-00035399": "of events that happen during the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00124-00035400-00035479": "execution", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00125-00035480-00035927": "of the workflow for instance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00126-00035928-00036127": "and a scientific workflow management", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00127-00036128-00036271": "system is", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00128-00036272-00036599": "a system that allows for managing the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00129-00036600-00036951": "life cycle of scientific workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00130-00036952-00037295": "so it supports the composition", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00131-00037296-00037615": "execution and documentation of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00132-00037616-00038095": "scientific workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00133-00038096-00038287": "so one of the main objectives of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00134-00038288-00038583": "scientific workflow management systems", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00135-00038584-00038759": "is the automation of computational", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00136-00038760-00039062": "scientific experiments", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00137-00039063-00039446": "so some features that are", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00138-00039447-00039655": "commonly commonly found in scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00139-00039656-00039799": "workflow management systems", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00140-00039800-00040183": "include scheduling tasks based on data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00141-00040184-00040367": "dependencies", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00142-00040368-00040790": "uh data flow between these tasks", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00143-00040791-00041158": "identifying parallel and identifying", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00144-00041159-00041383": "independent tasks and executing them in", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00145-00041384-00041679": "parallel", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00146-00041680-00041958": "scheduling tasks in high performance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00147-00041959-00042311": "computing environments or cloud", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00148-00042312-00042687": "computing environments managing and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00149-00042688-00042807": "querying", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00150-00042808-00043135": "data provenance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00151-00043136-00043535": "that describe the execution of the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00152-00043536-00043599": "scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00153-00043600-00044030": "workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00154-00044031-00044271": "some examples of scientific workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00155-00044272-00044527": "management systems include", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00156-00044528-00044895": "kepler a kepler has a graphical", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00157-00044896-00045174": "user interface for defining and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00158-00045175-00045430": "composing the workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00159-00045431-00045718": "it is often used for executing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00160-00045719-00046030": "bioinformatics bioinformatics workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00161-00046031-00046295": "and it has a good integration with the r", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00162-00046296-00046527": "scripting language", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00163-00046528-00046727": "swift is a scientific workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00164-00046728-00046895": "management system", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00165-00046896-00047199": "focused on high performance computing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00166-00047200-00047399": "it has a functional programming language", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00167-00047400-00047543": "for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00168-00047544-00047967": "specifying the workflow and it has", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00169-00047968-00048286": "features for automated and implicit", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00170-00048287-00048535": "parallelism", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00171-00048536-00048855": "this trails is another scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00172-00048856-00049111": "workflow management system", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00173-00049112-00049511": "that also has a graphical user interface", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00174-00049512-00049839": "it's uh often used for scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00175-00049840-00050095": "visualization applications", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00176-00050096-00050483": "and it has good support for recording", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00177-00050484-00051055": "provenance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00178-00051056-00051399": "more recently there is a trend", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00179-00051400-00051882": "of incorporating workflow management", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00180-00051883-00052007": "techniques", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00181-00052008-00052447": "to python and r since these are", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00182-00052448-00052815": "scripting languages often used by", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00183-00052816-00053119": "computational scientists and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00184-00053120-00053519": "and it's common that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00185-00053520-00053942": "many of these scientists don't want to", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00186-00053944-00054247": "dedicate their time to learn a new", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00187-00054248-00054335": "language", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00188-00054336-00054663": "or a new system", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00189-00054664-00054942": "specialized only in specifying the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00190-00054944-00055126": "workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00191-00055127-00055438": "so some some libraries", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00192-00055439-00055759": "were implemented for python nr to bring", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00193-00055760-00056023": "the functionality of workflow management", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00194-00056024-00056263": "uh to these languages", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00195-00056264-00056479": "so we have some examples here no", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00196-00056479-00056615": "workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00197-00056616-00056982": "is a library for python that allows for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00198-00056983-00057519": "capturing uh and analyzing provenance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00199-00057520-00057759": "our data tracker is also a provenance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00200-00057760-00057926": "management implementation", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00201-00057927-00058150": "but in this case for the r scripting", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00202-00058151-00058326": "language", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00203-00058327-00058726": "parso is a library for python", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00204-00058727-00059126": "that allows for the specification", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00205-00059127-00059503": "and composition of scientific workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00206-00059504-00059838": "and it has support for automated", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00207-00059839-00060103": "parallelism", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00208-00060104-00060703": "during the execution of these workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00209-00060704-00061063": "next we will explore how", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00210-00061064-00061303": "these scientific workflows have been", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00211-00061304-00061559": "used for ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00212-00061560-00061887": "one first example is a", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00213-00061888-00062179": "work from pennington and colleagues from", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00214-00062179-00062430": "2007", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00215-00062432-00062679": "they used the kepler workflow management", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00216-00062679-00062791": "system", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00217-00062791-00063063": "to implement an ecological niche", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00218-00063064-00063366": "modeling workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00219-00063367-00063711": "this allowed for uh", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00220-00063712-00063942": "easy management of the structural", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00221-00063944-00064126": "aspects of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00222-00064127-00064391": "the clutch finish modeling workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00223-00064391-00064623": "allowing for instance for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00224-00064624-00064935": "application components to be easily", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00225-00064936-00065166": "replaced", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00226-00065167-00065366": "they implemented also a library of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00227-00065367-00065606": "application components", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00228-00065607-00065919": "for ecological niche modeling including", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00229-00065920-00066231": "data transformation and pre-processing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00230-00066232-00066526": "geospatial processing and semantic", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00231-00066527-00066911": "annotation of processes", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00232-00066912-00067350": "they did a case study", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00233-00067351-00067582": "with occurrence data from the memo", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00234-00067583-00067815": "network information system", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00235-00067816-00068079": "and future climatological scenarios from", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00236-00068080-00068247": "ipcc", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00237-00068248-00068559": "to predict the impact of climate change", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00238-00068560-00069143": "on more than two thousand species", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00239-00069144-00069487": "the software for assisted habitat", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00240-00069488-00069615": "modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00241-00069616-00069959": "is another example of a scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00242-00069960-00070023": "workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00243-00070024-00070463": "for ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00244-00070464-00070799": "it also has implemented a", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00245-00070800-00071262": "library of computational activities", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00246-00071263-00071526": "regarding ecological niche modeling for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00247-00071527-00071926": "instance for pre and post processing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00248-00071927-00072359": "the implementation was performed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00249-00072360-00072591": "in the vistrio's workflow management", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00250-00072592-00072823": "system", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00251-00072824-00073175": "which has benefited", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00252-00073176-00073311": "the ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00253-00073312-00073494": "application uh", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00254-00073495-00073775": "since it supports provenance management", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00255-00073776-00073831": "and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00256-00073832-00074006": "keeping track of the events that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00257-00074007-00074150": "happened during", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00258-00074151-00074375": "the execution of ecology furnish", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00259-00074376-00075062": "modeling workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00260-00075063-00075494": "more recently in 2016", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00261-00075495-00075806": "a work was published", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00262-00075807-00076103": "describing biovale biovale is the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00263-00076104-00076238": "biodiversity virtual", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00264-00076239-00076687": "e-laboratory and it's a", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00265-00076688-00076999": "web application that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00266-00077000-00077319": "implemented a number of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00267-00077320-00077615": "workflows and computational activities", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00268-00077616-00077847": "for biodiversity in general", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00269-00077848-00078191": "and many of them for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00270-00078192-00078616": "ecological niche modeling specifically", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00271-00078617-00078767": "[Music]", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00272-00078768-00079038": "so some examples of of predefined", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00273-00079039-00079150": "activities", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00274-00079151-00079438": "that are available in in this web", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00275-00079439-00079575": "interface", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00276-00079576-00079806": "include the geographic and temporal", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00277-00079807-00080071": "selection of occurrences", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00278-00080072-00080367": "they're cleaning taxonomic name", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00279-00080368-00080452": "resolution", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00280-00080453-00080606": "[Music]", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00281-00080607-00080806": "there are a number of ecological niche", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00282-00080807-00081103": "modeling algorithms available", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00283-00081104-00081335": "and also computational activities from", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00284-00081336-00081431": "other", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00285-00081432-00081815": "aspects of biodiversity", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00286-00081816-00081982": "for instance metagenomics and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00287-00081983-00082191": "phylogenetics", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00288-00082192-00082471": "applications and all of these", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00289-00082472-00082599": "applications", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00290-00082600-00082991": "components can be composed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00291-00082992-00083343": "freely into various", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00292-00083344-00083550": "scientific workflows for analyzing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00293-00083551-00084111": "biodiversity", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00294-00084112-00084535": "um also we have many examples", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00295-00084536-00084855": "of ecological niche modeling tools", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00296-00084856-00085047": "that were implemented in script", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00297-00085048-00085215": "scripting language", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00298-00085216-00085503": "such as r and python and at the same", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00299-00085504-00085623": "time", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00300-00085624-00085959": "uh supporting uh workflow management", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00301-00085960-00086079": "techniques", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00302-00086080-00086462": "so for instance uh all of these examples", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00303-00086463-00086599": "here", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00304-00086600-00086950": "target reproducibility", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00305-00086951-00087262": "such as sdn model r wallace", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00306-00087263-00087623": "zone r and k-u-e-n-n", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00307-00087624-00088038": "uh and also for instance model r", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00308-00088039-00088462": "uh has also support for the parallel", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00309-00088463-00088615": "execution", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00310-00088616-00089255": "of ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00311-00089256-00089599": "so this was a brief overview of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00312-00089600-00089903": "scientific workflows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00313-00089904-00090167": "and how they have been used in", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00314-00090168-00090431": "ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00315-00090432-00090815": "next maria luisa will explore", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00316-00090816-00091223": "the topic of reproducibility hello", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00317-00091224-00091318": "everyone", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00318-00091319-00091638": "professor louise uh mentioned aspects of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00319-00091639-00091782": "computational experiments", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00320-00091783-00092006": "and how defining them using scientific", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00321-00092007-00092150": "workflow concepts", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00322-00092151-00092391": "and technologies can be useful these", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00323-00092392-00092479": "technologies", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00324-00092480-00092718": "are important not only in terms of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00325-00092719-00092815": "organizing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00326-00092816-00093174": "or automating the analysis or experiment", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00327-00093175-00093255": "but also", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00328-00093256-00093462": "for enabling and improving group of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00329-00093463-00093582": "disabilities so", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00330-00093583-00093847": "i would like to take the opportunity to", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00331-00093848-00093911": "comment", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00332-00093912-00094174": "on some aspects of group disability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00333-00094175-00094350": "complementing a little bit", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00334-00094351-00094687": "what was presented in week number 31", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00335-00094688-00094991": "so in week number 31 we had", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00336-00094992-00095215": "uh some presentations on the challenges", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00337-00095216-00095367": "of with a disability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00338-00095368-00095599": "in ecological niche modeling and i", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00339-00095600-00095679": "brought", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00340-00095680-00095894": "here some points to remember what those", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00341-00095895-00096047": "challenges are", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00342-00096048-00096311": "so considering the scenario in which we", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00343-00096312-00096582": "have a paper written by someone", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00344-00096583-00096855": "when reading this paper we usually look", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00345-00096856-00097031": "for details to understand the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00346-00097032-00097159": "methodology", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00347-00097160-00097447": "under which conditions and data and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00348-00097448-00097711": "analysis for example was performed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00349-00097712-00097967": "and if we intend to reproduce what has", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00350-00097968-00098023": "been done", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00351-00098024-00098238": "we need the success to be sufficient for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00352-00098239-00098526": "us to be able to recover the data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00353-00098527-00098671": "parameters settings", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00354-00098672-00098982": "and so on however this information is", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00355-00098983-00099055": "not always", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00356-00099056-00099367": "easily accessible or reported in some", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00357-00099368-00099406": "way", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00358-00099407-00099718": "in papers this uh this happens", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00359-00099719-00099974": "in in the most diverse areas it's not a", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00360-00099975-00100087": "specific problem", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00361-00100088-00100406": "of ecological niche modelling in fact uh", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00362-00100407-00100615": "research studies have indicated the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00363-00100616-00100862": "existence of irritability crisis in", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00364-00100863-00101038": "scientific research", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00365-00101039-00101287": "and because of that we need to adopt", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00366-00101288-00101399": "good practices", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00367-00101400-00101743": "for reproducibility and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00368-00101744-00102303": "formalize how to report results", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00369-00102304-00102647": "that said uh what representability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00370-00102648-00102878": "really means well repressibility is", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00371-00102879-00102975": "related", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00372-00102976-00103247": "to the idea that a method should produce", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00373-00103248-00103502": "consistent results when performed", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00374-00103503-00103806": "more than once and because of that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00375-00103807-00104215": "results can be validated and verified", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00376-00104216-00104463": "representability also allows others to", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00377-00104464-00104582": "reuse and extend", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00378-00104583-00104790": "experiments and this can increase", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00379-00104791-00104919": "research impact", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00380-00104920-00105199": "quality and visibility in addition there", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00381-00105200-00105351": "is no consensus", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00382-00105352-00105563": "on the exact definition of the term", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00383-00105564-00105719": "representability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00384-00105720-00105975": "but we understand that there is a small", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00385-00105976-00106063": "difference", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00386-00106064-00106302": "between the terms reproducibility and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00387-00106303-00106454": "reflectability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00388-00106455-00106719": "so we choose to use the following", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00389-00106720-00106943": "definitions replicability is doing the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00390-00106944-00107063": "exact same", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00391-00107064-00107343": "experiment again and reproducibility", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00392-00107344-00107471": "allows variations", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00393-00107472-00107727": "on the original experiment or data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00394-00107728-00107958": "analysis", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00395-00107959-00108271": "and because representability allows for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00396-00108272-00108431": "variations we can have", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00397-00108432-00108695": "different representability levels", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00398-00108696-00108775": "especially", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00399-00108776-00109023": "since most of the time not all the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00400-00109024-00109302": "artifacts can be", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00401-00109303-00109639": "made available uh the artifacts that uh", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00402-00109640-00109999": "were used in the experiment but even so", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00403-00110000-00110223": "we can allow a certain level of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00404-00110224-00110327": "reproduction", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00405-00110328-00110615": "and by artifact i mean the components", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00406-00110616-00110702": "that up", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00407-00110703-00111015": "are part of the data analysis process", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00408-00111016-00111231": "or the experiments such as data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00409-00111232-00111390": "algorithms", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00410-00111391-00111710": "code for example in this paper by", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00411-00111711-00112031": "juliana freidy we have the definition of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00412-00112032-00112310": "some levels for example the repeatable", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00413-00112311-00112390": "level", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00414-00112391-00112623": "is more related to the idea of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00415-00112624-00112727": "replicability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00416-00112728-00113047": "that i mentioned before and is that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00417-00113048-00113351": "all artifacts have no changes and are", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00418-00113352-00113583": "available for reproduction to be done", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00419-00113583-00113966": "at that specific level the re-runnable", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00420-00113967-00114031": "level", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00421-00114032-00114302": "tells us the results of an experiment", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00422-00114303-00114431": "remain consistent", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00423-00114432-00114727": "even with variations in the input data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00424-00114728-00114934": "or the primary settings used", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00425-00114935-00115127": "this is useful for example when we", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00426-00115128-00115271": "cannot make the data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00427-00115272-00115607": "available for some reason but yet we can", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00428-00115608-00115654": "make", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00429-00115655-00115966": "other artifacts available so others can", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00430-00115967-00116102": "still explore", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00431-00116103-00116366": "what we have done and we have another", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00432-00116367-00116495": "other level", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00433-00116496-00116734": "for example portable extendable and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00434-00116735-00117031": "modified", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00435-00117032-00117327": "some studies indicate good practices for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00436-00117328-00117519": "reproducibility i bought here", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00437-00117520-00117831": "two references and outline some of these", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00438-00117832-00117902": "practices", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00439-00117903-00118127": "you may consider this as the main", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00440-00118128-00118263": "practices", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00441-00118264-00118566": "and considering that each area has its", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00442-00118567-00118823": "specificities and there is still no", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00443-00118824-00119015": "exact consensus", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00444-00119016-00119310": "on how to report or conduct with", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00445-00119311-00119463": "predictable research", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00446-00119464-00119807": "there is no recipe or rule that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00447-00119808-00120263": "generalizes on which tools or guidelines", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00448-00120264-00120590": "to follow this may also depend on the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00449-00120591-00120654": "journal", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00450-00120655-00121063": "you will submit your paper for example", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00451-00121064-00121295": "some journals have specific guidelines", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00452-00121296-00121478": "for responsibility and data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00453-00121479-00121831": "availability in any case following these", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00454-00121832-00122063": "good practices can be useful not only", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00455-00122064-00122151": "for people", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00456-00122152-00122383": "who will try to reproduce your work but", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00457-00122383-00122478": "also for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00458-00122479-00122766": "your own productivity and why is that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00459-00122767-00122831": "well", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00460-00122832-00123095": "for works that are based on previous", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00461-00123096-00123175": "analysis", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00462-00123176-00123590": "or evolve from those analysis we often", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00463-00123591-00123878": "need to go back to steps already", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00464-00123879-00124023": "implemented", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00465-00124024-00124351": "and these practices help us to stay more", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00466-00124352-00124702": "organized and remember details that are", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00467-00124703-00124983": "not always so trivial to remember so", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00468-00124983-00125023": "here", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00469-00125024-00125334": "uh are some practices for example code", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00470-00125335-00125527": "and data versioning", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00471-00125528-00125902": "hit is a good tool for this use the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00472-00125903-00126223": "use of standardized data formats use of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00473-00126224-00126271": "free", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00474-00126272-00126654": "and open tools testing data sharing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00475-00126655-00126951": "through platforms like feed share guide", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00476-00126952-00127119": "automation", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00477-00127120-00127319": "through the use of scientific workflow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00478-00127320-00127439": "technologies", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00479-00127440-00127751": "or scripting languages such as python", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00480-00127752-00128078": "and r and also detailed process", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00481-00128079-00128286": "documentation such as recording", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00482-00128288-00128431": "providence data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00483-00128432-00128883": "metadata and checklist the use of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00484-00128883-00128999": "checklists", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00485-00129000-00129254": "speaking a little bit more about the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00486-00129255-00129319": "tools", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00487-00129320-00129623": "specific to ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00488-00129624-00129934": "i brought here two examples um that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00489-00129935-00130223": "professor luiz already mentioned", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00490-00130224-00130458": "they were built to support", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00491-00130459-00130614": "reproducibility", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00492-00130615-00130919": "um for example we have", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00493-00130920-00131263": "bioval it offers a web-based environment", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00494-00131264-00131527": "for managing scientific workforce for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00495-00131528-00131807": "biodiversity and it has various", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00496-00131808-00131975": "predefined activities", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00497-00131976-00132335": "um available in", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00498-00132336-00132599": "like geographic and temporal selection", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00499-00132600-00132647": "of", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00500-00132648-00132878": "occurrences data cleaning ecological", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00501-00132879-00133175": "niche modeling algorithms and others", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00502-00133176-00133559": "zoom r is a modular framework for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00503-00133560-00133719": "constructing representable", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00504-00133720-00134135": "fdm workflows for r the results can be", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00505-00134136-00134375": "published through a data repository so", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00506-00134376-00134407": "that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00507-00134408-00134943": "others can assess it access it and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00508-00134944-00135175": "it can be loaded back into the r", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00509-00135176-00135247": "environment", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00510-00135248-00135431": "together with the package along with", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00511-00135432-00135671": "reproducibility of the analysis", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00512-00135672-00136007": "and here uh we have also three", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00513-00136008-00136399": "other examples of general purpose tools", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00514-00136400-00136759": "hotel um is a platform for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00515-00136760-00136975": "creating publishing and executing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00516-00136976-00137151": "research objects", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00517-00137152-00137423": "it has components for data collection", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00518-00137424-00137527": "identity", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00519-00137528-00137814": "management data publication and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00520-00137815-00137927": "interfaces with", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00521-00137928-00138359": "anal analytical tools to manipulate data", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00522-00138360-00138727": "it also uses docker to preserve the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00523-00138728-00138799": "computational", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00524-00138800-00139190": "environment used another tool is", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00525-00139191-00139535": "reposit is an open source tool to pack", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00526-00139536-00139790": "your research along with all necessary", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00527-00139791-00139919": "data files", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00528-00139920-00140311": "libraries environment variables", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00529-00140312-00140575": "and other options so anyone who wants to", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00530-00140576-00140702": "reproduce does not", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00531-00140703-00140895": "need to install the tools and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00532-00140896-00141135": "dependencies", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00533-00141136-00141575": "manually and we also have drake", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00534-00141576-00141927": "it's a our package that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00535-00141928-00142254": "analyzes the workflow and skip skip", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00536-00142255-00142326": "steps", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00537-00142327-00142614": "uh with up-to-date results avoiding", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00538-00142615-00142887": "unnecessary re-executions", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00539-00142888-00143211": "it also has functionalities uh for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00540-00143212-00143359": "reproducibility", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00541-00143360-00143775": "and here uh in this link", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00542-00143776-00144111": "it has a list of several other useful", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00543-00144112-00144271": "tools for group disability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00544-00144272-00144543": "and it may be helpful for you if you are", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00545-00144544-00144854": "looking for any specific functionality", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00546-00144855-00145159": "so you can", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00547-00145160-00145511": "you can find more other tools", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00548-00145512-00145831": "in this link now", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00549-00145832-00146207": "thinking about how to allow a complete", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00550-00146208-00146551": "reproduction of a workflow we thought", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00551-00146552-00146814": "of a framework in this paper we", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00552-00146815-00146895": "published", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00553-00146896-00147199": "last year where the idea is somehow", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00554-00147200-00147431": "packaging the workflow and its", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00555-00147432-00147566": "dependencies", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00556-00147567-00147911": "allowing it to be encapsulated", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00557-00147912-00148223": "we do not propose a need", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00558-00148224-00148590": "a new tool but instead we propose the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00559-00148591-00148839": "steps that can benefit from existing", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00560-00148840-00148975": "tools to support", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00561-00148976-00149287": "disability so considering this scenario", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00562-00149288-00149654": "in which we have an analysis implemented", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00563-00149655-00150031": "using scripting language which consumes", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00564-00150032-00150383": "and produces data the idea is to first", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00565-00150384-00150711": "encapsulate this here i use", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00566-00150712-00151031": "model r which is a r package for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00567-00151032-00151239": "ecological niche modeling", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00568-00151240-00151526": "by detecting its dependencies and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00569-00151527-00151623": "placing it", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00570-00151624-00151959": "on a virtual machine", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00571-00151960-00152295": "then a validation step", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00572-00152296-00152511": "uh we have a realization step for", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00573-00152512-00152711": "executing and collecting the problems", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00574-00152712-00152902": "data of this analysis", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00575-00152903-00153175": "within this virtual machine and finally", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00576-00153176-00153383": "a step for publication", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00577-00153384-00153719": "um of the experiment and its prevalence", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00578-00153720-00154007": "data on a platform that allows", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00579-00154008-00154190": "these experiments to be easily", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00580-00154191-00154414": "referenced and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00581-00154415-00154783": "accessible following uh the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00582-00154784-00155095": "the fair principles that we we", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00583-00155096-00155319": "already mentioned in this presentation", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00584-00155320-00155439": "so by following these", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00585-00155440-00155711": "steps the user should be able to share", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00586-00155712-00155902": "and reuse the experiment", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00587-00155903-00156087": "and publication contains information", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00588-00156088-00156287": "that meets even minimally", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00589-00156288-00156719": "the fair principle", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00590-00156720-00157071": "in weeks number 31 fang presented the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00591-00157072-00157199": "checklist suggesting", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00592-00157200-00157478": "essential items to be reported on", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00593-00157479-00157663": "ecological niche models", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00594-00157664-00157911": "a checklist like this is of great", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00595-00157912-00157999": "importance", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00596-00158000-00158231": "and provides guidelines on important", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00597-00158232-00158495": "information to allow with a disability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00598-00158496-00158799": "so just to make a comparison checklist", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00599-00158800-00158943": "like this one", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00600-00158944-00159207": "provide more focused recommendations at", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00601-00159208-00159463": "the domain level of the analysis", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00602-00159464-00159743": "while our research and the framework", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00603-00159744-00159878": "i've presented is more", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00604-00159879-00160175": "related to the other computational", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00605-00160176-00160263": "layers", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00606-00160264-00160566": "that are involved in this process", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00607-00160567-00160895": "of course there are intersections", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00608-00160896-00161047": "between them", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00609-00161048-00161359": "between these two approaches", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00610-00161360-00161671": "and the combination of them increases", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00611-00161672-00161759": "the chances", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00612-00161760-00162271": "of an experiment to be repressible", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00613-00162272-00162487": "including this presentation uh we", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00614-00162488-00162631": "basically saw that", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00615-00162632-00162839": "scientific workflow with cell", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00616-00162840-00163014": "technologies can automate", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00617-00163015-00163302": "experiment and data analysis it can also", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00618-00163303-00163463": "help in scalability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00619-00163464-00163783": "in execution especially on", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00620-00163784-00164095": "high computing platforms", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00621-00164096-00164375": "high computational platforms and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00622-00164376-00164526": "insurance representability", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00623-00164527-00164902": "is not a trivial task of course but", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00624-00164903-00165143": "reproducibility can support validation", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00625-00165144-00165238": "of results", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00626-00165239-00165543": "trends and indicators produced by", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00627-00165544-00165838": "experiments in biodiversity for example", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00628-00165839-00166078": "and these aspects can be understood and", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00629-00166079-00166335": "perceived as ways to provide", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00630-00166336-00166683": "more effective contributions for the", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00631-00166684-00166919": "community so that's it", "S5qaM03Mfhc-00632-00166920-00168048": "thank you very much"}}, {"audio_id": "S5r10yIThH0", "text": {"S5r10yIThH0-00000-00000008-00001243": "[Music]", "S5r10yIThH0-00001-00001244-00002160": "thank you", "S5r10yIThH0-00002-00002161-00002897": "[Music]", "S5r10yIThH0-00003-00002898-00003065": "thank you", "S5r10yIThH0-00004-00003066-00004227": "foreign", "S5r10yIThH0-00005-00004228-00005316": "[Music]", "S5r10yIThH0-00006-00005317-00005627": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "S5Thp5LrcCo", "text": {"S5Thp5LrcCo-00000-00001475-00002290": "three two one ah once you own again what", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00001-00002291-00005342": "a stash legs let's go oh well oh wait no", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00002-00005343-00006050": "weapons let's go oh oh wow oh my oh", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00003-00006051-00006532": "great Oh Hassan your no way you're no I", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00004-00006533-00007210": "get it whoa jumping leg thick hey hey", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00005-00007211-00007475": "whoa whoa whoa whoa make mess up in the", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00006-00007476-00008059": "hole oh oh oh stop so I said make a boy", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00007-00008060-00008581": "Oh Oh Suze I month omc sermon because I", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00008-00008582-00008770": "can get kind of hot and you can I gets", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00009-00008771-00009212": "gonna rock a lot of Uncle Ben ah oh oh", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00010-00009213-00009626": "nice um more", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00011-00009627-00010433": "enemies wah wah whoa with non dominant", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00012-00010434-00011545": "enough or see the movie oh nice cool", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00013-00011546-00011821": "she's my man oh no he's a man and I", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00014-00011822-00012504": "meant born a man oh wait", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00015-00012505-00013050": "ah I hope it's dead yeah he did it OOP", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00016-00013051-00014130": "Oh super dude oh ok ok helmet I oh wow", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00017-00014131-00015391": "most animals a train em all rights go", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00018-00015393-00015783": "Sammy Jo schedule cool beans you sound", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00019-00015784-00017026": "haha ha ha Oh", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00020-00017027-00017480": "wha-wha-wha wha-wha-wha I boss sees our", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00021-00017481-00018350": "money since a man sees a man you're dead", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00022-00018351-00018833": "away away let your message must three", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00023-00018834-00019136": "key nah there's a one hit me here", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00024-00019137-00019391": "playing little grabby I no matter i am", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00025-00019392-00019892": "praying that I or imagining attorneys to", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00026-00019893-00020519": "charge this good say oh no Harbor some", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00027-00020520-00020756": "having a sign up Anna your medallion", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00028-00020757-00021227": "Naruto that all I was our own place my", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00029-00021228-00021948": "tapas place", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00030-00021949-00022137": "you're not happy yeah i'm gonna shower", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00031-00022138-00022494": "all right hi boys she tried to mine we", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00032-00022495-00022776": "all all right to get them when you move", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00033-00022777-00023810": "now", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00034-00023811-00024133": "what happening", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00035-00024134-00024992": "when Donna leche whoa I'm will pick up", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00036-00024993-00025571": "Oh nodded shoes but you're not happy at", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00037-00025572-00026006": "all I do not have to know maybe not a", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00038-00026007-00028163": "sit-up someone a caddy hmm good good", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00039-00028164-00028793": "good I see source trust my gosh yo yo yo", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00040-00028794-00028964": "no la can I get skinny poppin", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00041-00028964-00029300": "accommodate a larger a day after he knew", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00042-00029301-00029747": "this is a my fine settimana at all right", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00043-00029748-00029995": "for food can I gravity for Adam c'mon", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00044-00029997-00030254": "Goomer okay whoa I don't wanna do I", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00045-00030255-00030563": "suppose under my mom agrees microfiber", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00046-00030564-00031052": "so who's always cool Tomas worth white", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00047-00031052-00031750": "guy 14 terumo tips Ala Moana every game", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00048-00031751-00032164": "winning adding something else makeup I", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00049-00032166-00032455": "gotta half", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00050-00032456-00033007": "alright so the my last name boy ain't", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00051-00033008-00033190": "nothing then before I put 11 so it's man", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00052-00033191-00034435": "got a new putting get away wait", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00053-00034436-00035479": "all right oh you did it whoa yay yay", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00054-00035480-00036183": "violence poop and three suddenly trees", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00055-00036184-00036921": "whoa whoa bottomley look again soon when", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00056-00036922-00037436": "guys cabron roushana the lava salam o", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00057-00037437-00037920": "fun battle buddy but sobrang cugina old", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00058-00037921-00038236": "school game spy ninja on an O'Malley", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00059-00038237-00038455": "buddy buddy buddy Panama didn't owe a", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00060-00038456-00038982": "sovereign cool oh no oh no it's bad Oh", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00061-00038983-00039434": "shoes emo river", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00062-00039435-00040541": "know what I mean would he think Leon you", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00063-00040542-00041297": "go dude black let's go idaho demons you", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00064-00041298-00041660": "now running up", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00065-00041661-00042204": "sequence and raava I likes it mwah all", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00066-00042205-00042793": "right all right", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00067-00042794-00043149": "now i am missing you sent your no way", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00068-00043150-00043855": "okay don't if another passage", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00069-00043856-00044591": "on a la la la I was", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00070-00044592-00045004": "oh wait you are now multiple enemies now", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00071-00045005-00045317": "hey darling whatever about Kentucky nah", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00072-00045318-00045689": "I don't need it scratch it", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00073-00045690-00045980": "alright animal and I owe my name back on", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00074-00045981-00046318": "deck Your Honor I biotech money by a", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00075-00046319-00046462": "pitch one and only kuma get to the", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00076-00046463-00046808": "particle winema him do you know just /", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00077-00046809-00047252": "me the thing that way oh wait it's over", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00078-00047253-00047381": "and I'm a little boy nothing and it's", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00079-00047382-00047612": "good it's good i guess i'm happy for now", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00080-00047613-00047912": "but you know Cee Cee without you own a", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00081-00047913-00048682": "gala", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00082-00048683-00050068": "lord I animal obey the trees major what", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00083-00050069-00050437": "I'm sensing transition from awesome on", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00084-00050438-00050833": "top of railway but in the trees all", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00085-00050834-00051964": "right all right okay nice cool", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00086-00051965-00052603": "all right this is nothing that I'd wait", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00087-00052604-00053704": "Wow ha silica boy or dying Oh a diet oh", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00088-00053704-00054274": "ok imagine how i edit ass in a whoo all", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00089-00054275-00054538": "right let's go we I keep and then hang", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00090-00054539-00054923": "on I'm when I keep the granades Osama", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00091-00054924-00055818": "Madiba all right your own right no hmm", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00092-00055819-00056592": "Hassan all over to mrs. one and easy oh", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00093-00056593-00057216": "hey all right", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00094-00057217-00058541": "00", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00095-00058541-00058948": "alright", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00096-00058949-00059248": "sign uplog nomics male magamit going on", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00097-00059249-00059982": "Joey you somewhere fun ah", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00098-00059983-00060763": "ah", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00099-00060764-00061848": "no hurry to go no wait wait wait no ohh", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00100-00061849-00062254": "way that was bad it's going to go slow", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00101-00062255-00063004": "then I boy nothing hope ya your swag", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00102-00063004-00063809": "laughing Oh what lovely my readiness", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00103-00063810-00064804": "escape it in oh hey ollie oh they got", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00104-00064805-00065281": "this boom all right we got his voice got", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00105-00065282-00065868": "this way", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00106-00065869-00066872": "I can fit eight", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00107-00066873-00067389": "mmm stop", "S5Thp5LrcCo-00108-00067390-00068622": "no oh man wait wait Lana wait love foof"}}, {"audio_id": "S5U5wOfjaxI", "text": {"S5U5wOfjaxI-00000-00001672-00001910": "this is an example on", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00001-00001911-00002047": "oblique", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00002-00002048-00002255": "projections", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00003-00002256-00002439": "so we're going to be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00004-00002440-00002767": "making", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00005-00002768-00002958": "an oblique", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00006-00002959-00003215": "projection of this solid", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00007-00003215-00003399": "the front view and the top view which is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00008-00003400-00003879": "given over here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00009-00003879-00004095": "so in oblique projections we try to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00010-00004096-00004286": "ensure that we", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00011-00004287-00004543": "show the true features", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00012-00004544-00005038": "on the plane of the sheet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00013-00005039-00005302": "and along the depth direction which", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00014-00005303-00005543": "could be either 30 degrees or 45 degrees", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00015-00005544-00005943": "or 60 degrees from the horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00016-00005944-00006254": "we try to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00017-00006255-00006399": "show this solid as if it's a", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00018-00006400-00006583": "three-dimensional solid", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00019-00006584-00006742": "so in a sense", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00020-00006743-00006934": "oblique projection", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00021-00006936-00007239": "is a nice marriage between orthographic", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00022-00007240-00007559": "and isometric projections", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00023-00007559-00007806": "so i'll draw two kinds", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00024-00007808-00008095": "the cavalier projection and cabinet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00025-00008095-00008383": "projection", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00026-00008384-00008483": "in one of", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00027-00008484-00008655": "these", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00028-00008656-00008863": "this depth", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00029-00008864-00009095": "is the same", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00030-00009096-00009319": "and in the second one", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00031-00009320-00009727": "this depth is reduced to half", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00032-00009728-00009831": "giving", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00033-00009832-00010199": "an impression of foreshortening", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00034-00010200-00010487": "so if you look at this object carefully", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00035-00010488-00010678": "there are not many features of course", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00036-00010679-00010823": "there's a circular feature here circular", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00037-00010824-00011023": "feature here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00038-00011024-00011214": "semi-circle semicircle joined by two", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00039-00011215-00011335": "straight lines and then there's a", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00040-00011336-00011527": "semicircular feature here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00041-00011528-00011799": "and these features are", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00042-00011800-00012014": "to be represented or depicted on three", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00043-00012015-00012255": "planes", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00044-00012256-00012535": "so i'll try to draw the cavalier", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00045-00012536-00012742": "projection of this solid first", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00046-00012743-00012894": "once again i'll start with the bounding", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00047-00012895-00013038": "box", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00048-00013039-00013279": "the center to center distance", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00049-00013280-00013583": "is 120", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00050-00013584-00013855": "and this distance is about 35", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00051-00013856-00014175": "and this distance is also about 35", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00052-00014176-00014599": "so 70 plus 120", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00053-00014600-00015047": "would be close to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00054-00015047-00015158": "200", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00055-00015159-00015638": "precisely 190.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00056-00015640-00015783": "i want to make sure if i draw both of", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00057-00015784-00015983": "these on one to one scale", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00058-00015984-00016207": "then i have enough", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00059-00016208-00016919": "space on my sheet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00060-00016920-00017271": "let me double check this is 120", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00061-00017272-00017591": "and 70 190.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00062-00017592-00018303": "before i start let me align my drafter", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00063-00018304-00018471": "with the horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00064-00018472-00018847": "margin of the sheet make sure that it is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00065-00018848-00019071": "aligned properly once i align this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00066-00019072-00019311": "properly i tighten the screw", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00067-00019312-00019599": "and i'm ready to draw once again", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00068-00019600-00019822": "i'll start with the bounding boxes so", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00069-00019823-00020167": "what i'll do is i will sketch these", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00070-00020168-00020375": "three planes", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00071-00020376-00020671": "at different depths", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00072-00020672-00021319": "so at depth zero", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00073-00021320-00022007": "this is about 190 i'm using a 2h", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00074-00022008-00022422": "and this is about 70.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00075-00022423-00022775": "so i'll mark this here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00076-00022776-00022967": "it's close to the margin should be as", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00077-00022968-00023191": "close but i am not really sure if i'll", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00078-00023192-00023486": "have enough space looks like i will", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00079-00023487-00023622": "through the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00080-00023623-00024239": "to draw the second", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00081-00024240-00024447": "oblique protection", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00082-00024448-00024639": "nevertheless", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00083-00024640-00024886": "coming back to the first one", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00084-00024887-00025702": "this is 90 this should be 70.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00085-00025704-00025902": "and this should be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00086-00025904-00026167": "90 again so i'll draw", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00087-00026168-00027358": "this plane here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00088-00027360-00027767": "measure this again it's the 70", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00089-00027768-00028062": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00090-00028063-00028935": "this is 70.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00091-00028936-00029623": "just about close to this point", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00092-00029624-00029895": "and then i'll use my friend the 36", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00093-00029895-00030046": "square", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00094-00030047-00030311": "and to show the depth", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00095-00030312-00030431": "i'll use", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00096-00030432-00031358": "the 30 degree angle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00097-00031360-00031527": "so for this one i'm going to be using", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00098-00031527-00031783": "the true depth of a t", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00099-00031783-00032062": "so i'll use", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00100-00032063-00032543": "a longer line segment", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00101-00032544-00033343": "so these are just construction lines", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00102-00033344-00033502": "and let me", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00103-00033503-00033679": "rotate this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00104-00033680-00034031": "measure 80", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00105-00034032-00034495": "just about there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00106-00034496-00035559": "and then draw vertical", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00107-00035560-00035927": "let me also", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00108-00035928-00036230": "draw these depth directions", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00109-00036231-00037743": "from these two vertices", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00110-00037744-00038151": "since i've already measured 80 from here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00111-00038152-00038862": "maybe i just come back", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00112-00038863-00039151": "and then draw this horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00113-00039152-00039623": "and perhaps", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00114-00039624-00039943": "draw this horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00115-00039944-00040287": "at this time they are dim lines", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00116-00040288-00040471": "you probably may not be able to see most", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00117-00040472-00040839": "of them", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00118-00040840-00041127": "but when we construct the final solid", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00119-00041128-00041246": "hopefully most of the lines will be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00120-00041247-00041951": "clear to you", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00121-00041952-00042343": "and then let me have this vertical", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00122-00042344-00042927": "let me see if i have this thing right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00123-00042928-00043167": "just about 80", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00124-00043168-00043799": "and maybe this is a little less than 80.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00125-00043800-00043983": "i want to be as accurate as possible so", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00126-00043984-00044343": "that i don't", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00127-00044344-00045174": "make mistakes", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00128-00045175-00045367": "it's okay for me to use the eraser at", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00129-00045368-00045662": "this time and hopefully", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00130-00045663-00045790": "even though i hope that i'll not be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00131-00045791-00046046": "needing it later", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00132-00046047-00046735": "once no", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00133-00046736-00046958": "always a good idea to have", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00134-00046959-00047174": "a piece of cloth with you", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00135-00047175-00048399": "just to make sure your sheet is clean", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00136-00048400-00049286": "to get a better view maybe i'll", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00137-00049287-00049439": "use the bottom part of the horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00138-00049440-00049935": "scale", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00139-00049936-00050695": "now this looks about all right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00140-00050696-00050895": "and then maybe i'll join these two", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00141-00050896-00051199": "vertices", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00142-00051200-00051382": "quite a while ago i said that my mini", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00143-00051383-00051614": "draft was not accurate", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00144-00051615-00052007": "and i'm just managing", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00145-00052008-00052214": "i'm doing a little better than managing", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00146-00052215-00052423": "anyhow so i've got this plane here and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00147-00052424-00052550": "i've got this plane here about this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00148-00052551-00052638": "plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00149-00052639-00052919": "maybe i'll sketch that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00150-00052920-00053135": "uh", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00151-00053136-00053282": "i would imagine this is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00152-00053283-00053591": "about 20 from here because this 60 and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00153-00053591-00053854": "this is 80 so it's about 20 from here so", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00154-00053855-00054047": "maybe i'll mark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00155-00054048-00054982": "that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00156-00054983-00055271": "and once i have made this mark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00157-00055272-00055447": "i'm going to be using the verticals and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00158-00055448-00055703": "the horizontals to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00159-00055704-00058254": "identify that plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00160-00058255-00058519": "looks a little better", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00161-00058520-00058926": "just want to double check this 20", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00162-00058927-00059071": "yeah", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00163-00059072-00060815": "a little deviation but that's okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00164-00060816-00061135": "and then i've got this plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00165-00061136-00061511": "all right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00166-00061512-00061959": "hopefully", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00167-00061960-00062079": "pretty much", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00168-00062079-00062654": "so i got three planes", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00169-00062655-00062879": "would it be a good idea for me to start", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00170-00062879-00063150": "drawing this from the back side", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00171-00063151-00063423": "or from the front side", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00172-00063424-00063599": "so remember just in case of isometric", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00173-00063600-00063830": "views i need to show the lines in dark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00174-00063832-00064015": "which are visible and i need to show the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00175-00064016-00064279": "lines in light", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00176-00064279-00064582": "graphite", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00177-00064583-00064742": "impressions", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00178-00064744-00065206": "which are not visible", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00179-00065207-00065447": "so this feature", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00180-00065448-00065663": "rather these two circles will be on this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00181-00065664-00065831": "plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00182-00065832-00066038": "this feature here will be on the second", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00183-00066039-00066271": "plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00184-00066272-00066447": "and this feature", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00185-00066448-00066806": "will be again on the second plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00186-00066807-00067015": "so perhaps what i can do is i can draw", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00187-00067016-00067255": "this feature on this plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00188-00067256-00067479": "because i know that that will be visible", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00189-00067480-00067759": "and i'll draw these two semicircles on", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00190-00067760-00067967": "the plane behind because i know that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00191-00067968-00068247": "they're visible as well", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00192-00068248-00068647": "all right so having said that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00193-00068648-00069199": "so let me mark the center lines", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00194-00069200-00069471": "so remember this entire length is this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00195-00069472-00069663": "length", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00196-00069664-00069919": "so this is a mental note to myself", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00197-00069920-00070631": "so let me go 35 left from here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00198-00070632-00070767": "mark this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00199-00070768-00071175": "let me go 35 right from here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00200-00071176-00071375": "mark this here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00201-00071376-00071599": "but rather there's no point going 35", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00202-00071600-00071759": "right from here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00203-00071760-00072015": "because these features are on the plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00204-00072016-00072159": "behind this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00205-00072160-00072494": "so let me mark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00206-00072495-00072879": "the center lines over here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00207-00072880-00073135": "and this is about", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00208-00073136-00073279": "70.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00209-00073280-00074215": "so i'll go 35 up", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00210-00074216-00074759": "okay so", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00211-00074760-00075111": "before i start drawing these two circles", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00212-00075112-00075494": "always a nice idea to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00213-00075495-00075735": "locate the center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00214-00075736-00075871": "well you have to look at the center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00215-00075872-00077375": "image", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00216-00077376-00077575": "here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00217-00077576-00077782": "and the center would be on the back", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00218-00077783-00078335": "plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00219-00078336-00079335": "so let me mark the center line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00220-00079336-00079623": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00221-00079624-00080087": "let me mark 35 on the back plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00222-00080088-00080238": "and mark the horizontal of the center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00223-00080239-00080438": "line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00224-00080439-00081526": "rather the horizontal center line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00225-00081527-00081631": "all right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00226-00081632-00081871": "having done that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00227-00081872-00082359": "i'll use my compass", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00228-00082360-00082759": "and i'll first draw the outer semicircle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00229-00082760-00082935": "making sure that i", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00230-00082936-00083087": "touch", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00231-00083088-00084406": "both the horizontal edges", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00232-00084407-00084623": "looks like i do", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00233-00084624-00084871": "and perhaps this edge also", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00234-00084872-00085199": "so maybe i need to adjust my", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00235-00085200-00085726": "center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00236-00085727-00086191": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00237-00086192-00086718": "there goes my semicircle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00238-00086719-00087967": "uniform pressure", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00239-00087968-00088247": "rather this would be a full circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00240-00088248-00088406": "so let me rather go ahead and complete", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00241-00088407-00089487": "this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00242-00089488-00089694": "so a mental note to myself and the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00243-00089695-00089943": "others watching this video that this is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00244-00089944-00090094": "a", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00245-00090095-00090255": "cavalier", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00246-00090256-00090503": "projection", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00247-00090504-00090767": "okay now the inner circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00248-00090768-00090943": "is of", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00249-00090944-00091206": "diameter 40.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00250-00091207-00091479": "i don't have that on my stencil so maybe", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00251-00091480-00091726": "i will have to draw that using my", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00252-00091727-00092087": "compass", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00253-00092088-00092382": "so i just mark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00254-00092383-00093126": "20.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00255-00093127-00093447": "it's pretty much here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00256-00093448-00093694": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00257-00093695-00094599": "draw this circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00258-00094600-00095031": "a few times so that i get the graphite", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00259-00095032-00095550": "uniformly", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00260-00095551-00095799": "impressed on the sheet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00261-00095800-00096079": "these two circles done", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00262-00096080-00096238": "let me take care of", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00263-00096239-00096423": "the outer semicircle and the inner", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00264-00096424-00096967": "semicircle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00265-00096968-00097191": "first the inner because the radius is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00266-00097192-00097343": "something that i", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00267-00097344-00097471": "know", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00268-00097472-00099238": "20.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00269-00099239-00103934": "and the outer one which is 35.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00270-00103935-00104278": "i need to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00271-00104279-00104486": "adjust my compass a little", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00272-00104488-00104815": "i think i've got it", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00273-00104816-00104990": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00274-00104991-00105254": "there would be minor errors but i will", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00275-00105255-00105943": "tend to ignore them", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00276-00105944-00106478": "so i got this part right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00277-00106479-00106854": "now this distance is 60.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00278-00106855-00107519": "measure 60 from here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00279-00107520-00107831": "and draw a center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00280-00107832-00109078": "rather vertical centerline", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00281-00109079-00109286": "maybe i'll have a horizontal centerline", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00282-00109288-00109847": "as well a part of it", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00283-00109848-00110175": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00284-00110176-00110527": "so i've got the center for this arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00285-00110528-00110871": "now this arc is on this plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00286-00110872-00111575": "and a part of the sock will be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00287-00111576-00111734": "hidden behind", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00288-00111735-00111927": "this circular feature", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00289-00111928-00112110": "so i'll have to be a little careful and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00290-00112111-00112247": "i have to draw", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00291-00112248-00112543": "only a part of it", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00292-00112544-00112758": "so i take my compass", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00293-00112759-00113439": "readjust the radius to 20", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00294-00113440-00113654": "get the center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00295-00113655-00113839": "and i'll draw only that part of the arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00296-00113840-00114158": "which is going to be visible", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00297-00114159-00114495": "and i'll let go of the other arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00298-00114496-00114951": "so i'll start from here i'll be careful", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00299-00114952-00115278": "i got this part right possibly", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00300-00115279-00115519": "a little distance", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00301-00115520-00115766": "and perhaps from here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00302-00115767-00115966": "up to this part", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00303-00115967-00116439": "again keeping a little distance", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00304-00116440-00116607": "so i do some", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00305-00116608-00116919": "touching", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00306-00116920-00117095": "and once i", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00307-00117096-00117278": "do that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00308-00117279-00117654": "i'm ready to draw the horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00309-00117655-00118086": "lines", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00310-00118088-00118407": "just want to make sure that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00311-00118408-00118631": "i hit the two points", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00312-00118632-00118878": "it looks like i do", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00313-00118879-00119102": "and here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00314-00119103-00119334": "i hit the two points here as well looks", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00315-00119335-00119990": "like probably i do", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00316-00119991-00120247": "a little bit of touching", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00317-00120248-00120478": "so i have this feature", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00318-00120479-00120863": "all set", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00319-00120864-00120975": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00320-00120976-00121127": "now i have to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00321-00121128-00121399": "work this part out", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00322-00121400-00121575": "for that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00323-00121576-00121823": "i need to project the center back or", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00324-00121824-00122047": "maybe measure", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00325-00122048-00122190": "the corresponding center from the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00326-00122191-00122399": "vertical and the horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00327-00122400-00122695": "so there's a 35 35", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00328-00122696-00123007": "maybe better i would do that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00329-00123008-00123283": "use my 2h", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00330-00123283-00123527": "35 and this time", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00331-00123528-00124119": "i'll just be using a dim line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00332-00124120-00124207": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00333-00124208-00124695": "perhaps", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00334-00124696-00124990": "so this is where my horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00335-00124991-00125599": "line would be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00336-00125600-00126047": "and if i use a 30", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00337-00126048-00126254": "60 set square", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00338-00126255-00126423": "and if i try to project the cent line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00339-00126424-00126607": "over there i should be able to confirm", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00340-00126608-00126710": "that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00341-00126711-00127134": "it lies on the line which it does", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00342-00127135-00127543": "now", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00343-00127544-00128023": "what i'll do is i'll use", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00344-00128024-00128454": "r35 this radius", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00345-00128455-00129175": "and using this center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00346-00129176-00129439": "do i have the center right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00347-00129440-00129854": "not sure", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00348-00129855-00130486": "perhaps it's going to be the center here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00349-00130488-00130695": "of course there would be a little gap", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00350-00130696-00130823": "on the left", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00351-00130824-00130934": "anyhow", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00352-00130935-00131295": "so i'll draw a very damn", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00353-00131296-00131727": "arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00354-00131728-00132014": "you know just to get this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00355-00132015-00132327": "tangent 30 degree line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00356-00132328-00132631": "once i have that i'll use my set square", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00357-00132632-00132854": "and my drafter assembly", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00358-00132855-00133351": "go very close to this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00359-00133352-00133663": "and think about", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00360-00133664-00134302": "drawing this tangent line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00361-00134303-00134543": "i'm having a hard time", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00362-00134544-00134831": "seeing the features from here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00363-00134832-00135014": "but", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00364-00135015-00135239": "if i hope that i've gotten this right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00365-00135240-00136327": "maybe a little lot", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00366-00136328-00136454": "probably", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00367-00136455-00136863": "would have it this way", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00368-00136864-00137143": "touch", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00369-00137144-00137431": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00370-00137432-00137647": "then i would know that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00371-00137648-00138039": "this part of the arc is visible", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00372-00138040-00138247": "i'll get back to the center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00373-00138248-00139031": "and darken this part of the arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00374-00139032-00139375": "all right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00375-00139376-00139631": "now what i would do is i would extend", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00376-00139632-00140014": "this line up to possibly this position", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00377-00140015-00140263": "now for that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00378-00140264-00140495": "i need to get this part projected over", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00379-00140496-00140671": "there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00380-00140672-00140951": "i'll use my 360s square", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00381-00140952-00141135": "change pencils", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00382-00141136-00141327": "go up there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00383-00141328-00141799": "you know just gently project this point", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00384-00141800-00141975": "so i can extend this line up till this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00385-00141976-00142078": "point", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00386-00142079-00142166": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00387-00142167-00142359": "of course this feature is tangent to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00388-00142360-00142535": "this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00389-00142536-00142863": "so i know what to do", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00390-00142864-00143199": "i go on top", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00391-00143200-00143311": "make sure i", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00392-00143312-00143519": "don't draw a double line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00393-00143520-00144078": "and that's a little difficult at times", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00394-00144079-00144295": "draw a solid line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00395-00144296-00144599": "and right at this position", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00396-00144600-00144926": "i make a little", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00397-00144927-00145111": "freehand arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00398-00145112-00145247": "just to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00399-00145248-00145495": "give the viewers the impression that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00400-00145496-00145683": "this is tangent", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00401-00145684-00147463": "and i finally make this line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00402-00147464-00147599": "all right so looks like i've gotten this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00403-00147600-00147823": "part right now what i need to do is i", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00404-00147824-00148078": "need to get this part right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00405-00148079-00148326": "and i know that this would be a circular", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00406-00148327-00148543": "feature here so", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00407-00148544-00148966": "i take my drafter here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00408-00148967-00149190": "get the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00409-00149191-00149711": "vertical line at 35", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00410-00149712-00150078": "mark that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00411-00150079-00150502": "maybe with a little thicker line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00412-00150503-00150695": "so that that's visible", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00413-00150696-00151231": "get 35 from the horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00414-00151232-00151535": "mark this get the intersection between", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00415-00151536-00151831": "these two", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00416-00151832-00152190": "well they don't need to be that dark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00417-00152191-00152726": "just this point is good enough", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00418-00152727-00153207": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00419-00153208-00153375": "the radius", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00420-00153376-00153999": "on my compass is set", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00421-00154000-00154951": "maybe it's not", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00422-00154952-00155135": "looks like i need to shrink that a", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00423-00155136-00155511": "little bit", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00424-00155512-00155766": "seems okay seems okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00425-00155767-00156014": "seems all right", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00426-00156015-00156214": "and then", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00427-00156215-00156366": "although", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00428-00156367-00156607": "i'll draw this part", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00429-00156608-00156966": "using a light pencil", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00430-00156967-00157175": "and then search for", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00431-00157176-00157319": "i don't need to search for tangent over", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00432-00157320-00157495": "here but i need to search for one over", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00433-00157496-00157671": "here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00434-00157672-00157814": "so this part is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00435-00157815-00158014": "a little thicker than i imagined it", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00436-00158015-00158214": "would be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00437-00158215-00158399": "rather this part is a little darker than", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00438-00158400-00158551": "i imagined this to be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00439-00158552-00159271": "so i'll erase this part", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00440-00159272-00159663": "wipe this off", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00441-00159664-00159919": "first work on this horizontal line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00442-00159920-00160111": "which i know will be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00443-00160112-00160335": "solid", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00444-00160336-00160590": "rather dark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00445-00160591-00160766": "i just want to make sure i don't double", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00446-00160767-00161735": "line this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00447-00161736-00161975": "looks like i'm all right there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00448-00161976-00162366": "and using my 30 60", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00449-00162367-00162759": "square", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00450-00162760-00163023": "draw a little", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00451-00163024-00163199": "oops i should be using a different", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00452-00163200-00163799": "pencil", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00453-00163800-00163943": "little line here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00454-00163944-00164135": "so i know that my curve is going to get", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00455-00164136-00164302": "truncated", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00456-00164303-00164911": "at this juncture", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00457-00164912-00165271": "so from here to here maybe i can", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00458-00165272-00165590": "darken the circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00459-00165591-00165799": "i have that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00460-00165800-00165999": "and then", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00461-00166000-00166183": "perhaps", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00462-00166184-00166366": "i can go ahead", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00463-00166367-00166999": "and darken this line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00464-00167000-00167183": "and a little", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00465-00167184-00167278": "touch", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00466-00167279-00167463": "so this is my", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00467-00167464-00167719": "caviar", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00468-00167720-00168278": "projection of the solid", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00469-00168279-00168535": "now let me on the side make", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00470-00168536-00168711": "cabinet projection maybe i can use this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00471-00168712-00168871": "part", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00472-00168872-00169126": "and let you figure the difference", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00473-00169127-00169335": "between these two", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00474-00169336-00169511": "so what i'll do is i'll make some", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00475-00169512-00169735": "preparations", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00476-00169736-00170087": "and i'll ask my friend astochia to stop", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00477-00170088-00170471": "the camera to stop the camera", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00478-00170472-00170647": "the preparations pretty much are the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00479-00170648-00171014": "same as this just that this depth and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00480-00171015-00171238": "this depth", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00481-00171239-00171487": "rather this depth they'll be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00482-00171488-00171959": "halved", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00483-00171960-00172183": "rather scaled to half", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00484-00172184-00172343": "so this would be 40 and this would be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00485-00172344-00172519": "30.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00486-00172520-00172759": "well perhaps on second thought let me", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00487-00172760-00172935": "go ahead and make all these", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00488-00172936-00173095": "constructions all over again in front of", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00489-00173096-00173311": "you", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00490-00173312-00173551": "what i would do is i would mute myself", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00491-00173552-00173671": "so that you can just focus on the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00492-00173672-00173966": "construction and not listen to the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00493-00173967-00174207": "blabbering that i have been doing", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00494-00174208-00174335": "over", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00495-00174336-00175023": "you know many minutes", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00496-00175024-00184999": "so i'll use this part of the sheet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00497-00185000-00185383": "perhaps one statement from my side", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00498-00185384-00185551": "these", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00499-00185552-00186071": "depth dimensions they will be halved", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00500-00186072-00186335": "so instead of 80 i would need to take", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00501-00186336-00193687": "this as 40 and this is 30.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00502-00193688-00194014": "one more thing this plane would be at 10", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00503-00194015-00194223": "behind this plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00504-00194224-00194447": "so like in this case i'll have to draw", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00505-00194448-00199735": "this third plane as well", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00506-00199736-00200295": "okay first these two circles", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00507-00200296-00206286": "on this plane the front plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00508-00206287-00207598": "full circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00509-00207600-00208286": "a few rounds", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00510-00208287-00208582": "and a smaller circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00511-00208583-00208831": "of diameter", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00512-00208832-00211519": "20.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00513-00211519-00213134": "again a few rounds of this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00514-00213135-00213334": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00515-00213335-00213663": "now this feature is on the second plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00516-00213664-00213839": "i need to identify", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00517-00213840-00217542": "the center for that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00518-00217544-00217775": "for the outer circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00519-00217776-00217975": "rather for the inner circle", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00520-00217976-00219951": "in a semicircle rather", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00521-00219952-00220223": "i might as well extend", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00522-00220223-00220431": "the center line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00523-00220432-00220998": "to somewhere here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00524-00221000-00222510": "this distance is 60.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00525-00222511-00222782": "and then with the same radius i draw", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00526-00222783-00223582": "this arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00527-00223583-00223798": "now notice that only a part of this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00528-00223800-00223975": "feature will be visible", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00529-00223976-00224110": "the rest is going to be hidden behind", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00530-00224111-00225023": "this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00531-00225023-00225167": "i just want to make sure that i don't", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00532-00225167-00225687": "overshoot", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00533-00225688-00225927": "if i do", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00534-00225928-00226239": "i'll probably have to take help of my", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00535-00226240-00226358": "friend", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00536-00226359-00226510": "stunning just", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00537-00226511-00226727": "rather sitting just there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00538-00226728-00227367": "looks like i do", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00539-00227367-00227575": "well not to worry because the next thing", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00540-00227576-00227839": "that i'm going to do is make a larger", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00541-00227840-00229206": "arc of the same radius as this one", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00542-00229207-00229679": "looks like i'm all right there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00543-00229680-00229903": "a little touch up", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00544-00229904-00230103": "so next is this semicircle with that", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00545-00230104-00230846": "center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00546-00230848-00231119": "i need to reduce", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00547-00231119-00231846": "or shrink my compass a little bit", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00548-00231848-00233351": "and there i go", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00549-00233352-00233503": "and of course these lines are going to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00550-00233504-00233734": "get extended", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00551-00233735-00233871": "up to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00552-00233871-00234287": "this here let me", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00553-00234288-00234494": "project this tangent line along the 30", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00554-00234496-00234663": "degree direction so that i get this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00555-00234664-00235406": "corresponding point in the cabinet view", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00556-00235407-00236734": "possibly here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00557-00236735-00237567": "so this is my first horizontal line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00558-00237567-00237758": "switch and pencil just want to make sure", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00559-00237759-00238198": "that i don't draw a double", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00560-00238200-00238671": "me erase this part just a little bit", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00561-00238671-00239263": "i can always touch it up later", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00562-00239264-00239415": "no no no no", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00563-00239416-00240671": "i'm working here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00564-00240671-00240839": "okay well", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00565-00240840-00241846": "this horizontal line will also be there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00566-00241848-00243239": "so would this be", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00567-00243240-00243542": "and of course so what", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00568-00243544-00247191": "this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00569-00247192-00247406": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00570-00247407-00247639": "all i need to do is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00571-00247640-00247767": "identify", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00572-00247767-00247894": "these features", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00573-00247896-00248063": "on the back plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00574-00248064-00248327": "and use the horizontal lines and then i", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00575-00248328-00248655": "think i should be done with it", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00576-00248656-00248767": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00577-00248767-00249079": "going back to the back plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00578-00249080-00249455": "identifying the centers", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00579-00249456-00249998": "identifying the vertical", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00580-00250000-00250294": "using radian lines", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00581-00250296-00251167": "identifying the horizontal", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00582-00251167-00251510": "so this is the first center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00583-00251511-00251710": "right there", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00584-00251711-00252687": "and this would be my second one", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00585-00252688-00252839": "on this vertical line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00586-00252840-00253063": "all right and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00587-00253064-00253263": "perhaps", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00588-00253264-00253846": "let me use my set square", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00589-00253848-00254294": "oh i have to be on the back plane", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00590-00254296-00255567": "pretty much over here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00591-00255567-00255871": "maybe a little up", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00592-00255871-00256142": "that'll get adjusted", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00593-00256144-00256615": "okay so", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00594-00256616-00256815": "this is about 35 yeah so it looks like", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00595-00256816-00257071": "this is the center", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00596-00257071-00257327": "taking my compass my radius is all", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00597-00257328-00257591": "set i think", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00598-00257592-00257934": "before center here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00599-00257935-00258191": "well a little to the left", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00600-00258192-00258398": "perhaps", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00601-00258400-00258775": "maybe a little more to the left", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00602-00258776-00259039": "yeah all i need is just this part of the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00603-00259040-00259223": "arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00604-00259223-00259534": "again something dim", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00605-00259535-00259758": "and from here maybe this is where my", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00606-00259759-00260271": "center was", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00607-00260271-00260679": "maybe a little up", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00608-00260680-00261127": "perhaps over here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00609-00261128-00261398": "yeah it looks like i'm okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00610-00261400-00261951": "and this part of the arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00611-00261952-00262223": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00612-00262224-00262382": "so the first", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00613-00262383-00263282": "tangent", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00614-00263283-00264015": "here using my solid line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00615-00264016-00265567": "and the second tangent here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00616-00265568-00265806": "blending", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00617-00265807-00266087": "okay", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00618-00266088-00266343": "let me", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00619-00266344-00266543": "redraw the rest of the arc", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00620-00266544-00266751": "maybe", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00621-00266752-00267015": "until this point", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00622-00267016-00267567": "i can do the touch up later", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00623-00267568-00268158": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00624-00268159-00268743": "the suck a little darker", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00625-00268744-00268895": "i realize that there is a bit of", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00626-00268896-00269871": "inaccuracy here but", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00627-00269872-00270463": "so the final touches in this drawing", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00628-00270464-00270639": "this line was", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00629-00270640-00270951": "dark already so maybe a little touch up", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00630-00270952-00271167": "here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00631-00271168-00271430": "and this line was a little dark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00632-00271431-00271567": "already", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00633-00271568-00271847": "we'll make it a little more darker", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00634-00271848-00272391": "rather a little more dark", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00635-00272392-00272734": "and a little touch up here", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00636-00272735-00272967": "and finally", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00637-00272968-00273551": "the horizontal line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00638-00273552-00274703": "i hope i don't make it a double line", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00639-00274704-00275391": "there i am", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00640-00275392-00275951": "little touch-up", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00641-00275952-00276423": "so this sheet now is ready let me", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00642-00276424-00276663": "stripe this", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00643-00276664-00276879": "object off", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00644-00276880-00277143": "get the drafter out of the way", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00645-00277144-00277399": "and so this is the cavalier projection", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00646-00277400-00277543": "caviar oblique projection this is a", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00647-00277544-00277710": "cabinet oblique projection", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00648-00277711-00277887": "the height remains the same i'll have to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00649-00277888-00278119": "get back the height remains 80 the", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00650-00278120-00278343": "height is foreshortened", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00651-00278344-00278823": "conventionally to half of 80 spotty", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00652-00278824-00279223": "just observe the subtle differences", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00653-00279224-00279391": "in the two views", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00654-00279392-00279606": "you know one nice thing is that this is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00655-00279607-00279871": "as i said before a nice marriage between", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00656-00279872-00280082": "orthographic projections and isometric", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00657-00280083-00280358": "projections so if you want to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00658-00280359-00280543": "show", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00659-00280544-00280782": "the circular features", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00660-00280783-00280991": "pretty much in true scale", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00661-00280992-00281143": "you would want to choose a plane which", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00662-00281144-00281423": "is parallel to your sheet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00663-00281424-00281751": "yeah here parallel to your sheet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00664-00281752-00281895": "and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00665-00281896-00282103": "for the depth dimension you might want", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00666-00282104-00282310": "to choose this angle as 30 or 45", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00667-00282311-00282671": "depending on your convenience", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00668-00282672-00283127": "and get the three dimensional", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00669-00283128-00283510": "impression to this solid", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00670-00283511-00283775": "so well if i ask you which one is", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00671-00283776-00284151": "looking more three-dimensional", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00672-00284152-00284519": "i mean it's up to you to observe and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00673-00284520-00284727": "then tell yourself", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00674-00284728-00285023": "for me possibly this because this has", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00675-00285024-00285367": "a little foreshortened feature", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00676-00285368-00285510": "but this is also all right i mean just", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00677-00285511-00285847": "imagine that if you have this depth to", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00678-00285848-00286030": "be 160", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00679-00286031-00286510": "then this would rather be a", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00680-00286511-00286630": "cabinet", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00681-00286631-00286982": "projection for this depth to be 160 and", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00682-00286983-00287247": "this depth to be 120.", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00683-00287248-00287567": "i believe yeah all right so observe", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00684-00287568-00287799": "the differences", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00685-00287800-00288079": "while i leave you for", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00686-00288080-00288430": "today and come back with perspective", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00687-00288431-00288687": "projections later", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00688-00288688-00291951": "in the next lab", "S5U5wOfjaxI-00689-00291952-00292159": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S64ybwjnkYg", "text": {"S64ybwjnkYg-00000-00000200-00000351": "okay we'll get started now it's ten", "S64ybwjnkYg-00001-00000352-00000638": "o'clock um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00002-00000639-00000774": "for those of you who don't know me i'm", "S64ybwjnkYg-00003-00000775-00000958": "peter will work executive director of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00004-00000959-00001207": "knapsack foundation um thank you very", "S64ybwjnkYg-00005-00001208-00001527": "much for participating in this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00006-00001528-00001759": "quarterly prep tech talk i'm really", "S64ybwjnkYg-00007-00001760-00002079": "excited about the presentation today", "S64ybwjnkYg-00008-00002080-00002279": "and looking forward to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00009-00002280-00002487": "any questions you might have we're going", "S64ybwjnkYg-00010-00002488-00002615": "to try something a little different than", "S64ybwjnkYg-00011-00002616-00002783": "we have in the past", "S64ybwjnkYg-00012-00002784-00002983": "where we are actually going to try to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00013-00002984-00003222": "open up participant questions for live", "S64ybwjnkYg-00014-00003223-00003559": "questions we will monitor the q a but", "S64ybwjnkYg-00015-00003560-00003751": "during the presentation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00016-00003752-00004086": "vanessa and bull might ask you for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00017-00004087-00004286": "any feedback or questions or commentary", "S64ybwjnkYg-00018-00004287-00004535": "you might have and raise your hand in", "S64ybwjnkYg-00019-00004536-00004702": "the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00020-00004703-00005015": "in the um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00021-00005016-00005206": "hand raising function you'll see at the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00022-00005207-00005422": "bottom of the screen and we'll unmute", "S64ybwjnkYg-00023-00005423-00005638": "you so we can have a bit of a dialogue", "S64ybwjnkYg-00024-00005639-00005767": "might be a little clunky because we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00025-00005768-00005927": "haven't done that as much in the past", "S64ybwjnkYg-00026-00005928-00006047": "but we're really looking forward to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00027-00006048-00006318": "trying that for this particular session", "S64ybwjnkYg-00028-00006319-00006510": "so without further ado i'll introduce", "S64ybwjnkYg-00029-00006511-00006606": "our", "S64ybwjnkYg-00030-00006608-00006775": "trainers for today", "S64ybwjnkYg-00031-00006776-00007055": "um first person we will", "S64ybwjnkYg-00032-00007056-00007334": "introduce is dr bull holland he is the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00033-00007336-00007534": "director at hacking for homeland", "S64ybwjnkYg-00034-00007536-00007751": "security h4x", "S64ybwjnkYg-00035-00007752-00007974": "training and he's an adjunct professor", "S64ybwjnkYg-00036-00007975-00008327": "at north carolina state university", "S64ybwjnkYg-00037-00008328-00008655": "and also joining bull is vanessa zabala", "S64ybwjnkYg-00038-00008656-00008863": "who is program manager for hacking for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00039-00008864-00009031": "homeland security and hacking for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00040-00009032-00009151": "diplomacy", "S64ybwjnkYg-00041-00009152-00009383": "at bmnt which is an innovative", "S64ybwjnkYg-00042-00009384-00009542": "consulting firm", "S64ybwjnkYg-00043-00009543-00009703": "the title of this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00044-00009704-00009935": "training session is hacking for homeland", "S64ybwjnkYg-00045-00009936-00010231": "security lean innovation training and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00046-00010232-00010438": "without further ado i'll mute myself and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00047-00010439-00010863": "turn it over to vanessa to start us off", "S64ybwjnkYg-00048-00010864-00011078": "wonderful thank you peter uh well good", "S64ybwjnkYg-00049-00011079-00011271": "morning everybody uh like peter said my", "S64ybwjnkYg-00050-00011272-00011503": "name is vanessa zabala and so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00051-00011504-00011727": "uh just to give you uh an idea of what", "S64ybwjnkYg-00052-00011728-00011895": "we're gonna go through today", "S64ybwjnkYg-00053-00011896-00012135": "so first i'll be exposing you to this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00054-00012136-00012383": "program that is already funded by the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00055-00012384-00012583": "department of homeland security and then", "S64ybwjnkYg-00056-00012584-00012863": "we'll go into the details of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00057-00012863-00013094": "how this program uses innovation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00058-00013095-00013294": "frameworks and then actually", "S64ybwjnkYg-00059-00013295-00013511": "uh get you uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00060-00013512-00013735": "more more insight into how that truly", "S64ybwjnkYg-00061-00013736-00013903": "works and how you could possibly apply", "S64ybwjnkYg-00062-00013904-00014119": "it and that's where bull will come in so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00063-00014119-00014358": "just to to give you the cadence of uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00064-00014359-00014591": "what i'll be exposing you first uh a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00065-00014591-00014807": "program that you have the option to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00066-00014808-00015063": "engage with uh that uses the methodology", "S64ybwjnkYg-00067-00015063-00015303": "that bull will be going over", "S64ybwjnkYg-00068-00015304-00015638": "um okay so hacking for homeland security", "S64ybwjnkYg-00069-00015640-00015927": "is an accredited accredited university", "S64ybwjnkYg-00070-00015928-00016222": "course funded by dhs snt", "S64ybwjnkYg-00071-00016223-00016366": "uh it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00072-00016368-00016647": "pretty much gets uh challenges or", "S64ybwjnkYg-00073-00016648-00016911": "problems from uh the department of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00074-00016912-00017063": "homeland security", "S64ybwjnkYg-00075-00017064-00017407": "uh mainly from the employees and uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00076-00017408-00017639": "gives them to universities and for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00077-00017640-00017863": "graduate students to work on that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00078-00017864-00018143": "problem for an entire semester they use", "S64ybwjnkYg-00079-00018144-00018399": "uh what we call lean or innovation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00080-00018400-00018591": "frameworks which is what bull is going", "S64ybwjnkYg-00081-00018592-00018743": "to go over which is pretty much", "S64ybwjnkYg-00082-00018744-00019039": "hypothesis testing every assumption and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00083-00019040-00019247": "idea that you have around what is the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00084-00019248-00019463": "actual problem what's the fail and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00085-00019464-00019719": "success criteria for any solution and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00086-00019720-00020007": "then which solutions would uh be a best", "S64ybwjnkYg-00087-00020008-00020279": "fit for that and how do we test it uh so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00088-00020280-00020422": "that's pretty much what the students do", "S64ybwjnkYg-00089-00020423-00020678": "and obviously they work with the uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00090-00020679-00020903": "employee the dhs employee that submitted", "S64ybwjnkYg-00091-00020904-00021127": "that challenge in that problem in order", "S64ybwjnkYg-00092-00021128-00021343": "to guide the students through", "S64ybwjnkYg-00093-00021344-00021630": "how the organization works uh and then", "S64ybwjnkYg-00094-00021631-00021791": "be able to integrate the solution that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00095-00021792-00022135": "they come up with after the semester", "S64ybwjnkYg-00096-00022136-00022439": "so uh what this has really done on these", "S64ybwjnkYg-00097-00022440-00022599": "are some quotes you'll see from previous", "S64ybwjnkYg-00098-00022600-00022783": "problem sponsors from", "S64ybwjnkYg-00099-00022784-00023063": "from fema specifically um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00100-00023064-00023294": "it gives you uh new ideas and solutions", "S64ybwjnkYg-00101-00023295-00023503": "the students not only give you the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00102-00023504-00023742": "business case of why this problem is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00103-00023743-00023958": "important because they do usually around", "S64ybwjnkYg-00104-00023959-00024199": "50 to 100 interviews so they give you a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00105-00024200-00024503": "lot of data to say why this is important", "S64ybwjnkYg-00106-00024504-00024678": "and then what it's needed what is needed", "S64ybwjnkYg-00107-00024679-00024991": "in order for a solution to be integrated", "S64ybwjnkYg-00108-00024992-00025214": "obviously it's a fresh perspective", "S64ybwjnkYg-00109-00025215-00025399": "since they are not from the organization", "S64ybwjnkYg-00110-00025400-00025767": "itself uh and what we found is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00111-00025768-00026055": "that this also creates an understanding", "S64ybwjnkYg-00112-00026056-00026358": "of potential careers within fema so we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00113-00026360-00026527": "actually had a semester at the colorado", "S64ybwjnkYg-00114-00026527-00026727": "school of mines and we now have two", "S64ybwjnkYg-00115-00026727-00026958": "students are working full-time in region", "S64ybwjnkYg-00116-00026960-00027174": "eight and they told us that they would", "S64ybwjnkYg-00117-00027175-00027374": "have never even considered it if it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00118-00027375-00027535": "wasn't for this course and because they", "S64ybwjnkYg-00119-00027536-00027727": "got to do about 100 informational", "S64ybwjnkYg-00120-00027727-00027862": "interviews they got to see the different", "S64ybwjnkYg-00121-00027863-00028087": "career pathways that people can take", "S64ybwjnkYg-00122-00028088-00028318": "within an organization like fema", "S64ybwjnkYg-00123-00028319-00028414": "um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00124-00028416-00028567": "so i think that's pretty", "S64ybwjnkYg-00125-00028568-00028790": "pretty cool uh some testimonials here", "S64ybwjnkYg-00126-00028791-00028967": "since you'll be getting these slides i'm", "S64ybwjnkYg-00127-00028968-00029087": "not gonna read through it but pretty", "S64ybwjnkYg-00128-00029088-00029287": "much this is saying from a previous", "S64ybwjnkYg-00129-00029288-00029518": "problem sponsor it's a great program i'm", "S64ybwjnkYg-00130-00029519-00029727": "a little biased so you know this uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00131-00029727-00029902": "slide always is useful", "S64ybwjnkYg-00132-00029904-00029990": "um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00133-00029991-00030207": "and that you know it's worth it so how", "S64ybwjnkYg-00134-00030208-00030423": "it works just to recap really quick we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00135-00030424-00030662": "get uh challenges or problem statements", "S64ybwjnkYg-00136-00030663-00030918": "from people like you so it's not just", "S64ybwjnkYg-00137-00030919-00031279": "only uh fema employees but also partner", "S64ybwjnkYg-00138-00031280-00031511": "organizations we'd only ask that you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00139-00031512-00031783": "partner with a dhs employee so with a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00140-00031783-00031990": "fema employee but that could be kind of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00141-00031991-00032239": "like what we call a co-sponsoring uh and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00142-00032239-00032439": "then that can go to the university again", "S64ybwjnkYg-00143-00032439-00032655": "this is already funded the main thing", "S64ybwjnkYg-00144-00032656-00032887": "that would we ask is that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00145-00032888-00032967": "um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00146-00032968-00033167": "if you are if you do want to engage this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00147-00033168-00033446": "program um that you engage with the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00148-00033447-00033735": "students uh one to three hours a week so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00149-00033736-00033943": "that's to for them to gather that data", "S64ybwjnkYg-00150-00033944-00034111": "that we talked about for hypothesis", "S64ybwjnkYg-00151-00034112-00034207": "testing", "S64ybwjnkYg-00152-00034208-00034431": "uh and that that's you referring them to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00153-00034432-00034583": "people that they can speak to and then", "S64ybwjnkYg-00154-00034584-00034687": "coaching them through how the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00155-00034688-00034943": "organization actually works so that's uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00156-00034944-00035111": "the students using the entrepreneurial", "S64ybwjnkYg-00157-00035112-00035311": "framework and then integrating those", "S64ybwjnkYg-00158-00035312-00035535": "solutions and obviously that also leads", "S64ybwjnkYg-00159-00035536-00035735": "to potential career opportunities so if", "S64ybwjnkYg-00160-00035736-00035974": "you also have like any internship or", "S64ybwjnkYg-00161-00035975-00036271": "uh potential uh opportunities uh that's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00162-00036272-00036543": "also an easy way to get them exposed", "S64ybwjnkYg-00163-00036544-00036767": "uh right now we're", "S64ybwjnkYg-00164-00036768-00036967": "uh we actually just moved the deadline", "S64ybwjnkYg-00165-00036968-00037295": "for the fall 2022 to this friday uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00166-00037296-00037439": "either way we're having a spring", "S64ybwjnkYg-00167-00037440-00037671": "semester so that deadline is uh in", "S64ybwjnkYg-00168-00037672-00038030": "november uh to submit the problem but if", "S64ybwjnkYg-00169-00038031-00038183": "you think of something that you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00170-00038184-00038383": "that the students can work on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00171-00038384-00038671": "uh then you know feel free to reach out", "S64ybwjnkYg-00172-00038672-00038839": "to me and then we can decide if it's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00173-00038840-00038999": "appropriate for this upcoming semester", "S64ybwjnkYg-00174-00039000-00039318": "or the next one", "S64ybwjnkYg-00175-00039319-00039862": "oh so um there uh this program uh is a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00176-00039863-00040062": "spin out from uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00177-00040063-00040374": "hacking for defense uh which was created", "S64ybwjnkYg-00178-00040375-00040679": "in 2015. it's had so much success that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00179-00040680-00040999": "now we started this one in 2020 uh we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00180-00041000-00041302": "are growing last semester we had two", "S64ybwjnkYg-00181-00041303-00041558": "problems go through uh to universe to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00182-00041559-00041751": "universities and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00183-00041752-00041902": "now this upcoming semester we're having", "S64ybwjnkYg-00184-00041903-00042167": "eight so as you can see we are growing", "S64ybwjnkYg-00185-00042168-00042455": "uh but it does help if you have any", "S64ybwjnkYg-00186-00042456-00042630": "challenges to submit to show that there", "S64ybwjnkYg-00187-00042631-00042887": "is demand for uh the continuation of a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00188-00042888-00043118": "program like this uh and i think the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00189-00043119-00043358": "neatest part about this is that 90 of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00190-00043359-00043615": "all we call problem sponsor which is the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00191-00043616-00043902": "dhs employees that have submitted a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00192-00043903-00044127": "problem to uh the hacking for homeland", "S64ybwjnkYg-00193-00044128-00044383": "security pro uh program", "S64ybwjnkYg-00194-00044384-00044702": "uh 90 that have engaged this program say", "S64ybwjnkYg-00195-00044703-00044855": "that they're actually doing something", "S64ybwjnkYg-00196-00044856-00045102": "either with the findings and then uh and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00197-00045103-00045318": "changing policy or they're actually", "S64ybwjnkYg-00198-00045319-00045495": "getting the solution and implementing it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00199-00045496-00045767": "right now", "S64ybwjnkYg-00200-00045768-00046015": "uh here are some challenges uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00201-00046016-00046151": "challenges that were submitted for the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00202-00046152-00046383": "upcoming semester uh and these are", "S64ybwjnkYg-00203-00046384-00046567": "highlighted in the different", "S64ybwjnkYg-00204-00046568-00046807": "colors to showcase who the main", "S64ybwjnkYg-00205-00046808-00047102": "beneficiary is the pain point and the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00206-00047103-00047446": "outcome so uh for example uh region", "S64ybwjnkYg-00207-00047447-00047702": "eight is needing a way to assess", "S64ybwjnkYg-00208-00047703-00047895": "long-term economic impact of small", "S64ybwjnkYg-00209-00047896-00048230": "cities of disasters in small cities to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00210-00048231-00048462": "allocate government disaster procurement", "S64ybwjnkYg-00211-00048463-00048655": "resources effectively so this is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00212-00048656-00048958": "actually something that uh the uh female", "S64ybwjnkYg-00213-00048959-00049158": "employee was saying that they've hit", "S64ybwjnkYg-00214-00049159-00049302": "their head against the wall so many", "S64ybwjnkYg-00215-00049303-00049590": "times it's not a super high priority but", "S64ybwjnkYg-00216-00049591-00049823": "it would have such a high impact if", "S64ybwjnkYg-00217-00049824-00050079": "something like this was solved so that's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00218-00050080-00050239": "the kind of problem that we're really", "S64ybwjnkYg-00219-00050240-00050390": "looking for something that you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00220-00050391-00050630": "you're not already hiring a consultant", "S64ybwjnkYg-00221-00050631-00050783": "but it would make quite a bit of a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00222-00050784-00050895": "difference something that's been", "S64ybwjnkYg-00223-00050896-00051079": "annoying you for a while and this is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00224-00051080-00051270": "something that the students can take for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00225-00051271-00051511": "a full semester give you the business", "S64ybwjnkYg-00226-00051512-00051823": "case of why it's that important to solve", "S64ybwjnkYg-00227-00051824-00052063": "and some solution options to integrate", "S64ybwjnkYg-00228-00052064-00052166": "as well", "S64ybwjnkYg-00229-00052167-00052342": "um so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00230-00052344-00052511": "this is what we do in the process of if", "S64ybwjnkYg-00231-00052512-00052719": "you want to submit uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00232-00052720-00052975": "a uh a challenge statement well", "S64ybwjnkYg-00233-00052976-00053142": "uh we just refine it to make it more", "S64ybwjnkYg-00234-00053144-00053350": "actionable don't want to boil the ocean", "S64ybwjnkYg-00235-00053351-00053582": "we can boil a cup in a semester not the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00236-00053583-00053807": "entire ocean so that's what this process", "S64ybwjnkYg-00237-00053808-00053887": "is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00238-00053888-00054191": "um the universities for fall is texas a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00239-00054191-00054438": "m and rochester institute of technology", "S64ybwjnkYg-00240-00054439-00054599": "and then like i said in spring the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00241-00054600-00054830": "deadline is more in october uh we're", "S64ybwjnkYg-00242-00054832-00055079": "defining the universities right now but", "S64ybwjnkYg-00243-00055079-00055247": "uh you get the point", "S64ybwjnkYg-00244-00055248-00055438": "uh i just want to go through one example", "S64ybwjnkYg-00245-00055439-00055663": "there's a bunch in here that you'll get", "S64ybwjnkYg-00246-00055664-00055854": "uh but this one i thought it was really", "S64ybwjnkYg-00247-00055855-00056150": "neat because this was getting power", "S64ybwjnkYg-00248-00056151-00056391": "after disasters happen to people in more", "S64ybwjnkYg-00249-00056391-00056638": "remote areas how do you actually do that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00250-00056639-00056854": "so this team actually did over a hundred", "S64ybwjnkYg-00251-00056855-00057038": "informational interviews", "S64ybwjnkYg-00252-00057039-00057254": "and uh they as you can see they", "S64ybwjnkYg-00253-00057255-00057519": "partnered with not just fema but sister", "S64ybwjnkYg-00254-00057520-00057687": "there were all other components that had", "S64ybwjnkYg-00255-00057688-00057926": "this issue as well and they came up with", "S64ybwjnkYg-00256-00057927-00058087": "an understanding that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00257-00058088-00058407": "of what was needed in order to get power", "S64ybwjnkYg-00258-00058408-00058630": "to certain communities so they came up", "S64ybwjnkYg-00259-00058632-00058791": "with um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00260-00058791-00059079": "essentially a drone but a very specific", "S64ybwjnkYg-00261-00059079-00059359": "one so this was an example of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00262-00059360-00059599": "the uh the student team didn't create", "S64ybwjnkYg-00263-00059600-00059766": "the solution themselves but it was", "S64ybwjnkYg-00264-00059767-00059999": "actually in the marketplace so once the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00265-00060000-00060166": "students have that all that data and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00266-00060167-00060359": "that business case built they do market", "S64ybwjnkYg-00267-00060360-00060591": "research to see if it already exists a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00268-00060591-00060799": "solution already exists if not they", "S64ybwjnkYg-00269-00060800-00061015": "create it themselves uh and just to let", "S64ybwjnkYg-00270-00061016-00061223": "you know this upcoming semester because", "S64ybwjnkYg-00271-00061224-00061415": "we're working with texas a m and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00272-00061416-00061591": "rochester institute of technology these", "S64ybwjnkYg-00273-00061591-00061879": "are mainly engineering computer science", "S64ybwjnkYg-00274-00061879-00061991": "students", "S64ybwjnkYg-00275-00061991-00062150": "there's plenty of semesters where", "S64ybwjnkYg-00276-00062151-00062342": "sometimes we have more policy oriented", "S64ybwjnkYg-00277-00062344-00062503": "next semester for example we're looking", "S64ybwjnkYg-00278-00062504-00062654": "to work with the university of puerto", "S64ybwjnkYg-00279-00062655-00062887": "rico in their department of architecture", "S64ybwjnkYg-00280-00062888-00063087": "and design so if you have those kinds of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00281-00063088-00063415": "problems for example tsa had an issue", "S64ybwjnkYg-00282-00063416-00063654": "with um the wheelchairs are getting", "S64ybwjnkYg-00283-00063655-00063887": "bigger but the space for the lines and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00284-00063888-00064126": "the cues in security checkpoints aren't", "S64ybwjnkYg-00285-00064127-00064375": "getting bigger so how do you design a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00286-00064376-00064566": "way so that it doesn't backstop and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00287-00064567-00064879": "backlog the the the line of the security", "S64ybwjnkYg-00288-00064879-00065094": "line at the airports so that's just one", "S64ybwjnkYg-00289-00065095-00065342": "example uh but that you can also you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00290-00065344-00065550": "know put an architecture design project", "S64ybwjnkYg-00291-00065551-00065767": "on uh how do you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00292-00065768-00065991": "potentially build up temporary housing", "S64ybwjnkYg-00293-00065992-00066199": "very quickly with renewable materials or", "S64ybwjnkYg-00294-00066200-00066438": "whatever it may be uh so that each", "S64ybwjnkYg-00295-00066439-00066647": "semester as we announce the universities", "S64ybwjnkYg-00296-00066648-00066935": "if you just want to sign up for just", "S64ybwjnkYg-00297-00066936-00067038": "alerts", "S64ybwjnkYg-00298-00067039-00067350": "when we have new information to send", "S64ybwjnkYg-00299-00067351-00067526": "feel free to email me and i'll make sure", "S64ybwjnkYg-00300-00067527-00067838": "to put my uh email in the chat", "S64ybwjnkYg-00301-00067839-00068079": "so the sponsors will say okay i have an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00302-00068080-00068326": "idea of a problem or a challenge that i", "S64ybwjnkYg-00303-00068327-00068511": "want to submit for graduate students to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00304-00068512-00068726": "work on what you're committing to is one", "S64ybwjnkYg-00305-00068727-00068999": "to three hours of work with the students", "S64ybwjnkYg-00306-00069000-00069247": "it ebbs and flows uh and mainly your", "S64ybwjnkYg-00307-00069248-00069415": "responsibility is to introduce them to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00308-00069416-00069591": "people because that's the only way that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00309-00069592-00069750": "they actually advance through the course", "S64ybwjnkYg-00310-00069751-00069926": "through that data gathering and then", "S64ybwjnkYg-00311-00069927-00070223": "coaching uh and giving them feedback so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00312-00070224-00070350": "that they understand how the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00313-00070351-00070559": "organization works you know that it is a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00314-00070560-00070663": "uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-00315-00070664-00070926": "um a student team that uh most likely", "S64ybwjnkYg-00316-00070927-00071287": "has never worked with uh dhs so uh that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00317-00071288-00071519": "kind of guidance is useful", "S64ybwjnkYg-00318-00071520-00071703": "uh so this is the road map kind of we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00319-00071704-00071847": "already went over it we gather the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00320-00071848-00072023": "challenges there's the deadline then we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00321-00072024-00072182": "send them to the universities and the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00322-00072183-00072343": "student teams are the ones that actually", "S64ybwjnkYg-00323-00072344-00072687": "choose uh which problems they're gonna", "S64ybwjnkYg-00324-00072688-00072903": "work through uh since they need to have", "S64ybwjnkYg-00325-00072904-00073175": "a vested interest and care", "S64ybwjnkYg-00326-00073176-00073382": "uh to actually go through it if your", "S64ybwjnkYg-00327-00073383-00073582": "problem is not selected it is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00328-00073583-00073791": "automatically put for next semester we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00329-00073792-00073967": "check with you to see if that's okay", "S64ybwjnkYg-00330-00073968-00074159": "either way like i said this builds up", "S64ybwjnkYg-00331-00074160-00074406": "our case to keep growing the program and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00332-00074407-00074726": "have instead of eight problems 12 or 50", "S64ybwjnkYg-00333-00074727-00074887": "problems a semester that we can put", "S64ybwjnkYg-00334-00074888-00074982": "through", "S64ybwjnkYg-00335-00074983-00075135": "um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00336-00075136-00075399": "and that's pretty much it uh i'll put", "S64ybwjnkYg-00337-00075400-00075567": "i'll stop sharing now if you guys have", "S64ybwjnkYg-00338-00075568-00075735": "any questions let me know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00339-00075736-00075991": "i'll put my email in the chat", "S64ybwjnkYg-00340-00075992-00076294": "um and as i said you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00341-00076295-00076511": "bull is going to go over how this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00342-00076512-00076735": "actually works within the course it's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00343-00076736-00076919": "not just for students we do this at the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00344-00076920-00077111": "innovation consulting company there's a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00345-00077112-00077262": "lot of private companies that use it as", "S64ybwjnkYg-00346-00077263-00077455": "well as public agencies", "S64ybwjnkYg-00347-00077456-00077567": "um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00348-00077568-00077743": "so yeah i'll stop there uh see if", "S64ybwjnkYg-00349-00077744-00077950": "anybody has any questions and then if", "S64ybwjnkYg-00350-00077951-00078367": "not i'll lead it off to pull", "S64ybwjnkYg-00351-00078368-00078526": "great bo we'll have you share your", "S64ybwjnkYg-00352-00078527-00078703": "screen and kick start and we'll keep an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00353-00078704-00081311": "eye on any questions", "S64ybwjnkYg-00354-00081312-00082399": "okay bo you ready", "S64ybwjnkYg-00355-00082400-00082599": "the unmute button moved so i had to go", "S64ybwjnkYg-00356-00082600-00082682": "find it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00357-00082683-00082982": "right hey i'm i'm bull holland i'm the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00358-00082983-00083255": "director of h4x training at bmnt and so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00359-00083256-00083462": "today in about 15 minutes i'm going to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00360-00083463-00083623": "teach you all the things you all ever", "S64ybwjnkYg-00361-00083624-00083855": "need to know about innovation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00362-00083856-00084159": "so short course nothing", "S64ybwjnkYg-00363-00084160-00084311": "not not too intense actually actually", "S64ybwjnkYg-00364-00084312-00084415": "we're just going to talk about the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00365-00084416-00084606": "difference really in what we mean by", "S64ybwjnkYg-00366-00084607-00084799": "innovation and what we typically see", "S64ybwjnkYg-00367-00084800-00085015": "which is innovation theater so i really", "S64ybwjnkYg-00368-00085016-00085143": "want this to be an interactive", "S64ybwjnkYg-00369-00085144-00085391": "discussion i only have four slides and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00370-00085392-00085638": "this is one of them so we've got", "S64ybwjnkYg-00371-00085639-00085879": "opportunity to have a rich conversation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00372-00085880-00086159": "or not let's see what happens", "S64ybwjnkYg-00373-00086160-00086287": "that's really my goal for this first", "S64ybwjnkYg-00374-00086288-00086462": "part of the presentation is to talk", "S64ybwjnkYg-00375-00086463-00086703": "about what it is we mean", "S64ybwjnkYg-00376-00086704-00087038": "when we say innovation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00377-00087039-00087150": "so of course when we talk about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00378-00087151-00087326": "innovation we mean something new we mean", "S64ybwjnkYg-00379-00087327-00087550": "something modern so we should start in", "S64ybwjnkYg-00380-00087551-00087911": "the 1560s with sir francis bacon because", "S64ybwjnkYg-00381-00087912-00088175": "what bacon did is he really developed", "S64ybwjnkYg-00382-00088176-00088367": "the scientific method that we've used", "S64ybwjnkYg-00383-00088368-00088494": "ever since", "S64ybwjnkYg-00384-00088495-00088831": "and the key to what he did that as", "S64ybwjnkYg-00385-00088832-00088999": "opposed to as opposed to what the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00386-00089000-00089238": "galileo galilei was doing and many", "S64ybwjnkYg-00387-00089239-00089511": "others is that while the other", "S64ybwjnkYg-00388-00089512-00089711": "natural philosophers of their time we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00389-00089712-00089918": "didn't call them scientists back then", "S64ybwjnkYg-00390-00089919-00090167": "were observing the world and then", "S64ybwjnkYg-00391-00090168-00090359": "collecting information", "S64ybwjnkYg-00392-00090360-00090575": "what they weren't doing is hypothesizing", "S64ybwjnkYg-00393-00090576-00090718": "and that's what", "S64ybwjnkYg-00394-00090719-00090991": "bacon's real addition to science was is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00395-00090992-00091191": "the idea of inductive reasoning it's the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00396-00091192-00091415": "idea that i saw this happen and then i", "S64ybwjnkYg-00397-00091416-00091591": "saw it happen again and i saw it happen", "S64ybwjnkYg-00398-00091592-00091750": "again so i think", "S64ybwjnkYg-00399-00091751-00091950": "when this happens that happens and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00400-00091951-00092167": "that's the essence of science", "S64ybwjnkYg-00401-00092168-00092247": "i've", "S64ybwjnkYg-00402-00092248-00092382": "talked quite a bit about the difference", "S64ybwjnkYg-00403-00092383-00092559": "between science and technology and we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00404-00092560-00092815": "can just focus on the science piece here", "S64ybwjnkYg-00405-00092816-00092982": "the essence of science is the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00406-00092983-00093255": "relationship between two phenomena", "S64ybwjnkYg-00407-00093256-00093567": "force equals mass times acceleration", "S64ybwjnkYg-00408-00093568-00093774": "increase the mass increase the force", "S64ybwjnkYg-00409-00093775-00093982": "decrease the acceleration decrease the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00410-00093983-00094087": "force", "S64ybwjnkYg-00411-00094088-00094287": "it's all about those relationships and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00412-00094288-00094503": "that's what a hypothesis really is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00413-00094504-00094726": "that's what bacon gave us what drove him", "S64ybwjnkYg-00414-00094727-00094967": "to this is about this time is when we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00415-00094968-00095191": "were discovering biology we finally had", "S64ybwjnkYg-00416-00095192-00095403": "the optics to take a look at", "S64ybwjnkYg-00417-00095404-00095679": "microorganisms and a lot of observations", "S64ybwjnkYg-00418-00095680-00095911": "were happening but what no one none of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00419-00095912-00096079": "these natural philosophers could do is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00420-00096080-00096191": "they could say", "S64ybwjnkYg-00421-00096192-00096359": "what is truth", "S64ybwjnkYg-00422-00096360-00096591": "i saw this you saw that how do we know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00423-00096592-00096735": "one from the other so he developed an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00424-00096736-00096903": "entire model for this but the piece that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00425-00096904-00097087": "i want to focus on here", "S64ybwjnkYg-00426-00097088-00097294": "to help understand when we say", "S64ybwjnkYg-00427-00097295-00097494": "innovation what's different", "S64ybwjnkYg-00428-00097495-00097767": "is this idea of inductive reasoning", "S64ybwjnkYg-00429-00097768-00098006": "if you aren't hypothesizing it's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00430-00098007-00098150": "actually really hard to make a good", "S64ybwjnkYg-00431-00098151-00098487": "hypothesis testable falsifiable", "S64ybwjnkYg-00432-00098488-00098711": "then you aren't doing scientific", "S64ybwjnkYg-00433-00098712-00098903": "research or scientific analysis now look", "S64ybwjnkYg-00434-00098904-00099087": "when we talk to people about scientific", "S64ybwjnkYg-00435-00099088-00099191": "research", "S64ybwjnkYg-00436-00099192-00099423": "we ain't publishing in nature here okay", "S64ybwjnkYg-00437-00099424-00099574": "we're not worried about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00438-00099575-00099806": "an alpha of 0.05 we're not looking for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00439-00099807-00100031": "sufficient statistical power we're", "S64ybwjnkYg-00440-00100032-00100287": "looking for evidence that gives us", "S64ybwjnkYg-00441-00100288-00100479": "enough confidence to start making", "S64ybwjnkYg-00442-00100480-00100655": "investments and decisions about where to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00443-00100656-00100806": "apply resources", "S64ybwjnkYg-00444-00100807-00100967": "and i believe that that transfers well", "S64ybwjnkYg-00445-00100968-00101191": "to the work that fema does because at", "S64ybwjnkYg-00446-00101192-00101423": "the end of the day at the top level what", "S64ybwjnkYg-00447-00101424-00101582": "you have to do is figure out how to get", "S64ybwjnkYg-00448-00101583-00101823": "the right resources and capabilities", "S64ybwjnkYg-00449-00101824-00102015": "which really means human beings with the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00450-00102016-00102206": "right training and skills to the right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00451-00102207-00102454": "place at the right time we're going to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00452-00102455-00102678": "talk about an example at the end that i", "S64ybwjnkYg-00453-00102679-00102854": "hope relates some of the things we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00454-00102855-00103127": "discuss here about how and why we think", "S64ybwjnkYg-00455-00103128-00103310": "those same principles of innovation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00456-00103311-00103510": "could apply so we're going to skip all", "S64ybwjnkYg-00457-00103511-00103742": "the way from the 1560s up to not too", "S64ybwjnkYg-00458-00103743-00104006": "many years ago and an author named", "S64ybwjnkYg-00459-00104007-00104247": "nassim talib he wrote a book you may", "S64ybwjnkYg-00460-00104248-00104510": "have heard of called the black swan", "S64ybwjnkYg-00461-00104511-00104590": "and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00462-00104591-00104823": "he reintroduced kind into the public", "S64ybwjnkYg-00463-00104824-00105127": "lexicon this idea of inductive reasoning", "S64ybwjnkYg-00464-00105128-00105278": "technically he got into abductive", "S64ybwjnkYg-00465-00105279-00105407": "reasoning but we really don't want to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00466-00105408-00105543": "have a discussion on logic and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00467-00105544-00105727": "philosophy this morning right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00468-00105728-00105958": "so he brings back the side in idea of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00469-00105959-00106102": "inductive reasoning but he brings it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00470-00106103-00106334": "into risk management that's going to tie", "S64ybwjnkYg-00471-00106335-00106519": "into another topic we talk about in just", "S64ybwjnkYg-00472-00106520-00106878": "a minute and what uh what talib's real", "S64ybwjnkYg-00473-00106879-00107031": "complaint was", "S64ybwjnkYg-00474-00107032-00107271": "was that um all the people who worked in", "S64ybwjnkYg-00475-00107272-00107454": "the financial markets where he worked", "S64ybwjnkYg-00476-00107455-00107710": "would say look our models work perfectly", "S64ybwjnkYg-00477-00107711-00107839": "well", "S64ybwjnkYg-00478-00107840-00108134": "if you just ignore 1929 in 2008", "S64ybwjnkYg-00479-00108135-00108415": "everything fits the model exactly right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00480-00108416-00108583": "and his whole point was", "S64ybwjnkYg-00481-00108583-00108815": "that's the problem your models ignore", "S64ybwjnkYg-00482-00108816-00108927": "reality", "S64ybwjnkYg-00483-00108928-00109278": "and you base the idea that all your risk", "S64ybwjnkYg-00484-00109279-00109671": "calculations work on the idea that all", "S64ybwjnkYg-00485-00109672-00109927": "the events are normally distributed", "S64ybwjnkYg-00486-00109928-00110095": "and that just doesn't match reality", "S64ybwjnkYg-00487-00110096-00110366": "either so when i was working as in a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00488-00110367-00110551": "scientific position at the army research", "S64ybwjnkYg-00489-00110552-00110734": "lab we got this task down from our", "S64ybwjnkYg-00490-00110735-00110910": "higher headquarters and it said someone", "S64ybwjnkYg-00491-00110911-00111063": "had you know the book had been out not", "S64ybwjnkYg-00492-00111064-00111223": "that long someone gave us a task that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00493-00111224-00111495": "says the army research lab's job is to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00494-00111496-00111734": "predict black swans", "S64ybwjnkYg-00495-00111735-00111934": "right so they made the mistake of giving", "S64ybwjnkYg-00496-00111935-00112143": "me this this problem and so my answer", "S64ybwjnkYg-00497-00112144-00112271": "was step one", "S64ybwjnkYg-00498-00112272-00112551": "read the book right because to leave's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00499-00112552-00112766": "entire point was you don't predict the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00500-00112767-00112958": "black swan what you can do as an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00501-00112959-00113286": "organization is be anti-fragile and when", "S64ybwjnkYg-00502-00113288-00113519": "i see the things that and the processes", "S64ybwjnkYg-00503-00113520-00113727": "that nema excuse me that fema is working", "S64ybwjnkYg-00504-00113728-00113910": "to put in place then i see an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00505-00113911-00114063": "organization that is attempting to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00506-00114064-00114327": "achieve that goal and i think that if we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00507-00114328-00114566": "apply some principles of innovation we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00508-00114567-00114839": "can help accelerate and maintain and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00509-00114840-00115143": "continue to stay ahead of in contact", "S64ybwjnkYg-00510-00115144-00115215": "with", "S64ybwjnkYg-00511-00115216-00115407": "the disasters that can't be predicted", "S64ybwjnkYg-00512-00115408-00115719": "but we can become anti-fragile", "S64ybwjnkYg-00513-00115720-00115943": "so i talked about risk management and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00514-00115944-00116166": "there's a term that's used in innovation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00515-00116167-00116343": "often and it's called the minimum viable", "S64ybwjnkYg-00516-00116344-00116527": "product it's probably the least well", "S64ybwjnkYg-00517-00116528-00116783": "understood most misused", "S64ybwjnkYg-00518-00116783-00116951": "concept we have", "S64ybwjnkYg-00519-00116952-00117263": "and it's not that's not a problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-00520-00117264-00117495": "because those of us who use the term in", "S64ybwjnkYg-00521-00117496-00117702": "teaching get frustrated that our syntax", "S64ybwjnkYg-00522-00117703-00117854": "gets used by someone who doesn't know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00523-00117855-00118023": "what they're doing it's a problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-00524-00118024-00118119": "because", "S64ybwjnkYg-00525-00118120-00118302": "this is what we do in the government i", "S64ybwjnkYg-00526-00118303-00118551": "was in the army for 23 years most of it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00527-00118552-00118751": "is a soldier someone is a civilian stop", "S64ybwjnkYg-00528-00118752-00118910": "me if you've heard this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00529-00118911-00119254": "um oh that new idea that new thing yeah", "S64ybwjnkYg-00530-00119255-00119383": "turns out we've been doing that all", "S64ybwjnkYg-00531-00119383-00119527": "along we just called it something", "S64ybwjnkYg-00532-00119528-00119695": "different so sure innovation we've", "S64ybwjnkYg-00533-00119696-00119863": "always done innovation we don't have", "S64ybwjnkYg-00534-00119864-00120134": "minimum viable product absolutely we've", "S64ybwjnkYg-00535-00120135-00120334": "been doing minimal viable products for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00536-00120335-00120614": "decades we know exactly how to do this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00537-00120615-00120790": "there's a point to what i want to tell", "S64ybwjnkYg-00538-00120791-00121023": "you about why what we do in industry is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00539-00121024-00121143": "different than the way the government", "S64ybwjnkYg-00540-00121144-00121319": "typically does it and there are three", "S64ybwjnkYg-00541-00121320-00121502": "people here that i want to talk about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00542-00121503-00121775": "around this one concept of the minimum", "S64ybwjnkYg-00543-00121776-00122023": "viable product the first and the first", "S64ybwjnkYg-00544-00122024-00122158": "is the person who really brought the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00545-00122159-00122302": "idea to life and that's mr frank", "S64ybwjnkYg-00546-00122303-00122663": "robinson about 2000 2001", "S64ybwjnkYg-00547-00122664-00122943": "software developer right so if you've", "S64ybwjnkYg-00548-00122944-00123223": "ever written any code then the logical", "S64ybwjnkYg-00549-00123224-00123375": "way to do this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00550-00123376-00123534": "is you build the hole in an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00551-00123535-00123695": "object-oriented or server or", "S64ybwjnkYg-00552-00123696-00123886": "service-oriented architecture you build", "S64ybwjnkYg-00553-00123888-00124014": "the whole", "S64ybwjnkYg-00554-00124015-00124239": "floor the foundation the architecture", "S64ybwjnkYg-00555-00124240-00124454": "right you got to build the data layer", "S64ybwjnkYg-00556-00124455-00124695": "you got to build the security layer and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00557-00124696-00124919": "then you'll build the individual", "S64ybwjnkYg-00558-00124920-00125183": "services that will call back in your", "S64ybwjnkYg-00559-00125183-00125551": "seven layer osi model and then you build", "S64ybwjnkYg-00560-00125552-00125775": "the user interface right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00561-00125776-00126054": "now that means that you build a lot of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00562-00126055-00126231": "code", "S64ybwjnkYg-00563-00126232-00126423": "that everything else has to rely on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00564-00126424-00126647": "before you get anything out the door", "S64ybwjnkYg-00565-00126648-00126823": "but it's still a logical way for a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00566-00126824-00126990": "programmer to start doing this robinson", "S64ybwjnkYg-00567-00126991-00127143": "says that doesn't make any sense at all", "S64ybwjnkYg-00568-00127144-00127375": "look you're spending a bunch of money", "S64ybwjnkYg-00569-00127376-00127583": "before you even know whether or not", "S64ybwjnkYg-00570-00127583-00127743": "you've gotten the product features out", "S64ybwjnkYg-00571-00127744-00127886": "that your customers want so if you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00572-00127888-00128134": "imagine an x-axis that could be software", "S64ybwjnkYg-00573-00128135-00128447": "lines of code or time and a y-axis that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00574-00128448-00128790": "could be revenue or roi", "S64ybwjnkYg-00575-00128791-00129078": "then what robinson said is no pick the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00576-00129079-00129319": "product features that most of your", "S64ybwjnkYg-00577-00129320-00129502": "customers want", "S64ybwjnkYg-00578-00129503-00129727": "build that out first and get it out the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00579-00129728-00129863": "door", "S64ybwjnkYg-00580-00129864-00130223": "then build out the rest of what you need", "S64ybwjnkYg-00581-00130224-00130486": "and it was really logical premise", "S64ybwjnkYg-00582-00130488-00130758": "he alluded to the idea of getting", "S64ybwjnkYg-00583-00130759-00130927": "feedback from people about those product", "S64ybwjnkYg-00584-00130928-00131078": "features but it wasn't the sole purpose", "S64ybwjnkYg-00585-00131079-00131223": "the purpose was", "S64ybwjnkYg-00586-00131224-00131471": "get the return on investment first", "S64ybwjnkYg-00587-00131472-00131614": "instead of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00588-00131615-00131935": "spending years at possibly building out", "S64ybwjnkYg-00589-00131936-00132151": "this entire infrastructure before you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00590-00132152-00132359": "get the things you already know people", "S64ybwjnkYg-00591-00132360-00132543": "want out there", "S64ybwjnkYg-00592-00132544-00132735": "well then um the next person we really", "S64ybwjnkYg-00593-00132736-00132943": "see pushing some of these ideas forward", "S64ybwjnkYg-00594-00132944-00133223": "is mr steve blank now vanessa and i know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00595-00133224-00133414": "steve probably the friendliest most", "S64ybwjnkYg-00596-00133415-00133566": "user-friendly billionaire you'll ever", "S64ybwjnkYg-00597-00133567-00133687": "meet right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00598-00133688-00133895": "he is known as the godfather of silicon", "S64ybwjnkYg-00599-00133896-00134175": "valley his his website's amazing he's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00600-00134176-00134319": "got an incredible history and he's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00601-00134320-00134519": "really the the person who pushed the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00602-00134520-00134735": "ideas that led to hacking for defense", "S64ybwjnkYg-00603-00134736-00134935": "and what he was doing launch pad", "S64ybwjnkYg-00604-00134936-00135102": "stanford and colombia and berkeley years", "S64ybwjnkYg-00605-00135103-00135383": "ago so what steve does is that based on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00606-00135384-00135583": "his experience as an entrepreneur he", "S64ybwjnkYg-00607-00135584-00135823": "takes robinson's idea of the mvp and he", "S64ybwjnkYg-00608-00135824-00135902": "says", "S64ybwjnkYg-00609-00135903-00136127": "yep get something out there to the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00610-00136128-00136407": "customer but the purpose of getting a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00611-00136408-00136751": "customer is not to hit this high roi", "S64ybwjnkYg-00612-00136752-00136919": "is to get feedback", "S64ybwjnkYg-00613-00136920-00137111": "is to begin that iterative loop that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00614-00137112-00137231": "we're going to talk about in just a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00615-00137232-00137447": "minute that is really the essence of any", "S64ybwjnkYg-00616-00137448-00137654": "methodology we talk about in the space", "S64ybwjnkYg-00617-00137655-00137927": "of innovation so that's a key change in", "S64ybwjnkYg-00618-00137928-00138207": "key innovation steve moves from looking", "S64ybwjnkYg-00619-00138208-00138511": "at this as a business proposition to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00620-00138512-00138863": "moving into the idea of using a minimum", "S64ybwjnkYg-00621-00138864-00139175": "bible product as a way to learn how", "S64ybwjnkYg-00622-00139176-00139327": "you're going to go back and change the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00623-00139328-00139502": "code not just the code but change the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00624-00139503-00139719": "product features figure out what your", "S64ybwjnkYg-00625-00139720-00139831": "customers", "S64ybwjnkYg-00626-00139832-00140023": "actually need now before i go on and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00627-00140024-00140223": "talk about how eric reese fits in that i", "S64ybwjnkYg-00628-00140224-00140359": "want to make this distinction between", "S64ybwjnkYg-00629-00140360-00140647": "customers and beneficiaries right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00630-00140648-00140887": "a customer has a choice beneficiary", "S64ybwjnkYg-00631-00140888-00141095": "doesn't and and that's the space we live", "S64ybwjnkYg-00632-00141096-00141254": "in in the gov whether you're in the army", "S64ybwjnkYg-00633-00141255-00141454": "whether you're in fema or if you're in a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00634-00141455-00141671": "lot of not-for-profit spaces you're", "S64ybwjnkYg-00635-00141672-00141823": "trying to do the best you can for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00636-00141824-00142039": "someone but it's not like they have a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00637-00142040-00142319": "marketplace to choose from so all the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00638-00142320-00142478": "things we've talked about to this point", "S64ybwjnkYg-00639-00142479-00142702": "have been about customers people whether", "S64ybwjnkYg-00640-00142703-00142878": "it's a business to business relationship", "S64ybwjnkYg-00641-00142879-00143095": "or a business to customer relationship", "S64ybwjnkYg-00642-00143096-00143287": "people who actually have free choice of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00643-00143288-00143511": "what to do with their resources", "S64ybwjnkYg-00644-00143512-00143702": "and so that's who can give you good", "S64ybwjnkYg-00645-00143703-00143831": "feedback", "S64ybwjnkYg-00646-00143832-00144039": "the next person who comes along and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00647-00144040-00144254": "moves minimum bioproduct to the space", "S64ybwjnkYg-00648-00144255-00144511": "where vanessa and i use it and what we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00649-00144512-00144711": "engage with is eric reese who's a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00650-00144712-00145102": "student of steve bike what reese said is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00651-00145103-00145295": "feedback yes but you don't have to wait", "S64ybwjnkYg-00652-00145296-00145502": "to get a product out the door", "S64ybwjnkYg-00653-00145503-00145711": "i can hypothesize that if i give you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00654-00145712-00145919": "this it will do that and i can draw a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00655-00145920-00146143": "sketch on a napkin and say hey", "S64ybwjnkYg-00656-00146144-00146302": "would this work for you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00657-00146303-00146447": "and after i get past the sketch on a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00658-00146448-00146614": "napkin and i can say well if i'm", "S64ybwjnkYg-00659-00146615-00146751": "building software what if i just build a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00660-00146752-00146902": "front end user interface and say if i", "S64ybwjnkYg-00661-00146903-00147047": "gave you this and you could push this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00662-00147048-00147247": "button and get this data", "S64ybwjnkYg-00663-00147248-00147471": "would that solve this problem for you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00664-00147472-00147639": "and you get a lot of feedback that says", "S64ybwjnkYg-00665-00147640-00147814": "yeah yeah but mostly what you want is no", "S64ybwjnkYg-00666-00147815-00148023": "no that doesn't work at all all right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00667-00148024-00148175": "people will tell you yes just because", "S64ybwjnkYg-00668-00148176-00148278": "they don't want to talk to you anymore", "S64ybwjnkYg-00669-00148279-00148399": "the people you want to listen to the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00670-00148400-00148607": "people who tell you no give you a great", "S64ybwjnkYg-00671-00148608-00148783": "example that steve gibbs from one of his", "S64ybwjnkYg-00672-00148784-00148887": "classes", "S64ybwjnkYg-00673-00148888-00149119": "he had a group of students going through", "S64ybwjnkYg-00674-00149120-00149319": "his lean launch pad course and they had", "S64ybwjnkYg-00675-00149320-00149614": "this great idea for a small business", "S64ybwjnkYg-00676-00149615-00149790": "because steve was teaching entrepreneurs", "S64ybwjnkYg-00677-00149791-00149999": "or one of the entrepreneurs at stanford", "S64ybwjnkYg-00678-00150000-00150207": "who go on to become pretty successful", "S64ybwjnkYg-00679-00150208-00150423": "and they said you know what we could do", "S64ybwjnkYg-00680-00150424-00150702": "we could put a hyperspectral camera on a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00681-00150703-00150911": "drone we could fly it over farmers", "S64ybwjnkYg-00682-00150912-00151126": "fields in california and we could help", "S64ybwjnkYg-00683-00151127-00151287": "them understand their irrigation", "S64ybwjnkYg-00684-00151288-00151502": "patterns where their water is going and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00685-00151503-00151766": "where it's needed right so what did they", "S64ybwjnkYg-00686-00151767-00151990": "do they went out and they got a drone", "S64ybwjnkYg-00687-00151991-00152183": "and they got a camera and they started", "S64ybwjnkYg-00688-00152184-00152478": "to fly it and then through the class", "S64ybwjnkYg-00689-00152479-00152711": "steve said wait a minute", "S64ybwjnkYg-00690-00152712-00152831": "what does you want to learn with this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00691-00152832-00153071": "drone we want to show them how it works", "S64ybwjnkYg-00692-00153072-00153175": "yeah but they're not going to pay you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00693-00153176-00153351": "for the drone right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00694-00153352-00153502": "no no no we're going to give them", "S64ybwjnkYg-00695-00153503-00153678": "information well", "S64ybwjnkYg-00696-00153679-00153839": "why don't you show them an example of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00697-00153840-00153966": "the information and see if that's what", "S64ybwjnkYg-00698-00153967-00154159": "they really want so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00699-00154160-00154375": "stop buying the drones stop connecting", "S64ybwjnkYg-00700-00154376-00154678": "it to the camera built a spreadsheet", "S64ybwjnkYg-00701-00154679-00154990": "said hey farmer jones here's your farm", "S64ybwjnkYg-00702-00154991-00155207": "and all your different sections and if", "S64ybwjnkYg-00703-00155208-00155423": "we gave you this data on water with", "S64ybwjnkYg-00704-00155424-00155647": "these mocked up heat maps from satellite", "S64ybwjnkYg-00705-00155648-00155766": "imagery", "S64ybwjnkYg-00706-00155767-00156007": "would this give you what you want", "S64ybwjnkYg-00707-00156008-00156359": "and most of the farmer jones has said no", "S64ybwjnkYg-00708-00156360-00156535": "i i don't need that at all i've already", "S64ybwjnkYg-00709-00156536-00156735": "got another way to get that but you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00710-00156736-00156959": "what if you could give me", "S64ybwjnkYg-00711-00156960-00157159": "this data", "S64ybwjnkYg-00712-00157160-00157254": "that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00713-00157255-00157454": "would be a big problem solver", "S64ybwjnkYg-00714-00157455-00157687": "so now they can go back and actually got", "S64ybwjnkYg-00715-00157688-00157831": "to put their hyperspectral camera on a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00716-00157832-00157975": "drone but they changed their whole idea", "S64ybwjnkYg-00717-00157976-00158271": "of a business model they moved from", "S64ybwjnkYg-00718-00158272-00158463": "a service company that was going to pay", "S64ybwjnkYg-00719-00158464-00158671": "for hours flying jones drones to a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00720-00158672-00158863": "service company that was going to sell", "S64ybwjnkYg-00721-00158864-00159047": "subscription services for information", "S64ybwjnkYg-00722-00159048-00159247": "for farmers so they can understand how", "S64ybwjnkYg-00723-00159248-00159414": "to make the most efficient use of the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00724-00159415-00159566": "water they have", "S64ybwjnkYg-00725-00159567-00159783": "that's the idea that we use now in a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00726-00159784-00159951": "minimum viable product and that's the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00727-00159952-00160135": "idea that i want to convey to you about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00728-00160136-00160407": "why when we say innovation we mean", "S64ybwjnkYg-00729-00160408-00160583": "something genuinely different when i say", "S64ybwjnkYg-00730-00160584-00160790": "innovation i mean modern industry", "S64ybwjnkYg-00731-00160791-00160983": "business practices", "S64ybwjnkYg-00732-00160984-00161190": "modern industry business practices is a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00733-00161191-00161487": "mouthful so we say innovation right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00734-00161488-00161599": "the last thing i want to talk to you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00735-00161600-00161702": "about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00736-00161703-00161919": "is this key principle of search and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00737-00161920-00162111": "pivot and so if you think about the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00738-00162112-00162335": "example i just gave with steve and his", "S64ybwjnkYg-00739-00162336-00162726": "students who had a drone and an idea", "S64ybwjnkYg-00740-00162727-00163063": "what they learned to do is instead of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00741-00163064-00163239": "figure out the best way to attach a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00742-00163240-00163478": "camera to a drone and fly it get data", "S64ybwjnkYg-00743-00163479-00163783": "they learn to search for what's the real", "S64ybwjnkYg-00744-00163784-00163887": "need", "S64ybwjnkYg-00745-00163888-00164063": "this thing we initially call product", "S64ybwjnkYg-00746-00164064-00164351": "market fit on the business side", "S64ybwjnkYg-00747-00164352-00164495": "and this is where we come back to the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00748-00164496-00164623": "difference between customers and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00749-00164624-00164766": "beneficiaries", "S64ybwjnkYg-00750-00164767-00165038": "the farmer jones's got to say", "S64ybwjnkYg-00751-00165039-00165278": "that doesn't solve my problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-00752-00165279-00165511": "the people who are receiving services on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00753-00165512-00165726": "the other end of the disaster", "S64ybwjnkYg-00754-00165727-00165999": "often don't have that choice there's no", "S64ybwjnkYg-00755-00166000-00166143": "time it's not because", "S64ybwjnkYg-00756-00166144-00166287": "the people who are trying to solve those", "S64ybwjnkYg-00757-00166288-00166487": "problems don't want to give them choice", "S64ybwjnkYg-00758-00166488-00166647": "it's because the resources are what the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00759-00166648-00166807": "resources are and the resources they", "S64ybwjnkYg-00760-00166808-00166959": "could get there or the resources that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00761-00166960-00167102": "could get there", "S64ybwjnkYg-00762-00167103-00167302": "but we can do some things ahead of time", "S64ybwjnkYg-00763-00167303-00167431": "to make sure we're getting the right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00764-00167432-00167583": "resources to the right people at the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00765-00167584-00167831": "right time and so these two concepts", "S64ybwjnkYg-00766-00167832-00168071": "that i wanted to show you here all the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00767-00168072-00168214": "way on the left hand side when you're", "S64ybwjnkYg-00768-00168215-00168423": "first starting to think about your ideas", "S64ybwjnkYg-00769-00168424-00168702": "ido company out of san francisco really", "S64ybwjnkYg-00770-00168703-00168878": "kind of put forward these ideas of human", "S64ybwjnkYg-00771-00168879-00169087": "centered design which grew out of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00772-00169088-00169359": "actually the design school at stanford", "S64ybwjnkYg-00773-00169360-00169599": "around started in the late 50s early 60s", "S64ybwjnkYg-00774-00169600-00169759": "really took that long to mature through", "S64ybwjnkYg-00775-00169760-00170159": "academia into ideo becoming a company", "S64ybwjnkYg-00776-00170160-00170423": "late 90s before they were really formed", "S64ybwjnkYg-00777-00170424-00170607": "to commercialize these ideas that are", "S64ybwjnkYg-00778-00170608-00170751": "now prevalent", "S64ybwjnkYg-00779-00170752-00170919": "across the industry", "S64ybwjnkYg-00780-00170920-00171166": "and then something many of us have heard", "S64ybwjnkYg-00781-00171167-00171366": "of but not everyone understands well the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00782-00171367-00171654": "idea of agile product methodology it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00783-00171655-00171943": "uses these same ideas", "S64ybwjnkYg-00784-00171944-00172199": "of hypothesize experiment", "S64ybwjnkYg-00785-00172200-00172463": "gather data and analyze", "S64ybwjnkYg-00786-00172464-00172783": "either reinforce and accelerate or pivot", "S64ybwjnkYg-00787-00172784-00173014": "often you pivot and that's one of the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00788-00173015-00173143": "things that's very different about how", "S64ybwjnkYg-00789-00173144-00173319": "we do things in government", "S64ybwjnkYg-00790-00173320-00173551": "and so here's my last slide that i", "S64ybwjnkYg-00791-00173552-00173838": "wanted to give we'll have after this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00792-00173839-00173966": "hopefully we have a good discussion", "S64ybwjnkYg-00793-00173967-00174119": "about this and then i'll have one other", "S64ybwjnkYg-00794-00174120-00174263": "slide for us to talk about this more of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00795-00174264-00174519": "a fema specific example", "S64ybwjnkYg-00796-00174520-00174702": "uh my experience in government is that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00797-00174703-00174854": "this is how we do it maybe it's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00798-00174855-00175135": "different in dhs right um but", "S64ybwjnkYg-00799-00175136-00175319": "someone gets tasked to solve a problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-00800-00175320-00175438": "they come up with an idea for the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00801-00175439-00175735": "problem and then you socialize it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00802-00175736-00175935": "you've got the answer and then you go", "S64ybwjnkYg-00803-00175936-00176159": "around and you figure out who do i need", "S64ybwjnkYg-00804-00176160-00176366": "to say yes and who do i need to make", "S64ybwjnkYg-00805-00176367-00176543": "sure doesn't say no", "S64ybwjnkYg-00806-00176544-00176702": "and those are the people you talk to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00807-00176703-00176999": "those people who sit around that big old", "S64ybwjnkYg-00808-00177000-00177231": "table where all those decisions are made", "S64ybwjnkYg-00809-00177232-00177366": "and you say well what do you think about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00810-00177367-00177535": "this and you shape it a little bit you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00811-00177536-00177711": "add in some of their ideas and hear what", "S64ybwjnkYg-00812-00177712-00177863": "you want to hear and you move forward", "S64ybwjnkYg-00813-00177864-00178038": "right and so then eventually as you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00814-00178039-00178214": "start going through the process and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00815-00178215-00178351": "you're trying to get these inputs from", "S64ybwjnkYg-00816-00178352-00178614": "all these people you're the one who's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00817-00178615-00178847": "been moving this idea forward so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00818-00178848-00179159": "criticisms of the idea are in effect", "S64ybwjnkYg-00819-00179160-00179351": "criticisms of you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00820-00179352-00179535": "and there's no evidence it's just a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00821-00179536-00179695": "series of people's different opinions", "S64ybwjnkYg-00822-00179696-00179838": "from the hats they happened to wear at", "S64ybwjnkYg-00823-00179839-00180166": "that time and you got them to say yes or", "S64ybwjnkYg-00824-00180167-00180351": "you recognize they were going to say no", "S64ybwjnkYg-00825-00180352-00180566": "and you need enough people to say yes to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00826-00180567-00180759": "overcome them that's how we make", "S64ybwjnkYg-00827-00180760-00180919": "decisions in the government in my", "S64ybwjnkYg-00828-00180920-00181135": "experience and i've always heard it and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00829-00181136-00181295": "i'd like to refer to the term as the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00830-00181296-00181495": "bogat method it's a bunch of guys around", "S64ybwjnkYg-00831-00181496-00181711": "the table right it's a series of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00832-00181712-00181951": "opinions from people who", "S64ybwjnkYg-00833-00181952-00182231": "have expert power or positional power", "S64ybwjnkYg-00834-00182232-00182407": "and they're the ones who are making the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00835-00182408-00182599": "in who are making the final decisions on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00836-00182600-00182814": "whether or not your idea works that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00837-00182815-00183143": "doesn't work in industry", "S64ybwjnkYg-00838-00183144-00183311": "it simply doesn't work", "S64ybwjnkYg-00839-00183312-00183454": "that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00840-00183455-00183751": "private concerns have the advantage of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00841-00183752-00184038": "knowing whether or not their ideas were", "S64ybwjnkYg-00842-00184039-00184335": "right because people do or don't choose", "S64ybwjnkYg-00843-00184336-00184559": "to apply the finite resources they have", "S64ybwjnkYg-00844-00184560-00184783": "to consume that idea", "S64ybwjnkYg-00845-00184784-00184919": "in short", "S64ybwjnkYg-00846-00184920-00185071": "if people don't pay for it you don't", "S64ybwjnkYg-00847-00185072-00185238": "have a company anymore", "S64ybwjnkYg-00848-00185239-00185414": "so your job is not to go out and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00849-00185415-00185575": "socialize and get people to tell you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00850-00185576-00185878": "they like your idea in fact your job is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00851-00185879-00186054": "to go out and hypothesize and find those", "S64ybwjnkYg-00852-00186055-00186231": "people who say that doesn't make any", "S64ybwjnkYg-00853-00186232-00186359": "sense at all", "S64ybwjnkYg-00854-00186360-00186495": "because those exact same people are", "S64ybwjnkYg-00855-00186496-00186654": "often the ones who will turn around say", "S64ybwjnkYg-00856-00186655-00186838": "what if you did this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00857-00186839-00186999": "that's the idea of search and pivot", "S64ybwjnkYg-00858-00187000-00187247": "because the if you did this gives you a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00859-00187248-00187502": "new thing to hypothesize about go out", "S64ybwjnkYg-00860-00187503-00187831": "and test last point on this topic", "S64ybwjnkYg-00861-00187832-00187990": "academically", "S64ybwjnkYg-00862-00187991-00188223": "we're limited when we can have students", "S64ybwjnkYg-00863-00188224-00188390": "go out and engage people to do", "S64ybwjnkYg-00864-00188391-00188511": "interviews", "S64ybwjnkYg-00865-00188512-00188695": "um so they interview the best people", "S64ybwjnkYg-00866-00188696-00188926": "that can before class starts again but", "S64ybwjnkYg-00867-00188927-00189063": "there's some concepts in here that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00868-00189064-00189247": "relate all the way back to francis", "S64ybwjnkYg-00869-00189248-00189471": "bacon's work that are about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00870-00189472-00189638": "understanding the population to which", "S64ybwjnkYg-00871-00189639-00189838": "you are trying to generalize and taking", "S64ybwjnkYg-00872-00189839-00190095": "the appropriate sample right so the way", "S64ybwjnkYg-00873-00190096-00190254": "that i'll end this conversation is on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00874-00190255-00190471": "that idea that the whole notion of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00875-00190472-00190719": "science applying the scientific method", "S64ybwjnkYg-00876-00190720-00190919": "in the business context that we're doing", "S64ybwjnkYg-00877-00190920-00191231": "it is based on what bacon did a long", "S64ybwjnkYg-00878-00191232-00191431": "time ago and we've really", "S64ybwjnkYg-00879-00191432-00191631": "stuck with over the years", "S64ybwjnkYg-00880-00191632-00191871": "and understanding who the real", "S64ybwjnkYg-00881-00191872-00192095": "population you're trying to serve is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00882-00192096-00192326": "matters because if you've seen one", "S64ybwjnkYg-00883-00192327-00192471": "electron", "S64ybwjnkYg-00884-00192472-00192599": "see them all", "S64ybwjnkYg-00885-00192600-00192831": "you talk to one afghan elder you talk to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00886-00192832-00192999": "one afghan elder", "S64ybwjnkYg-00887-00193000-00193214": "so you have to understand anytime you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00888-00193215-00193535": "start engaging with people which is what", "S64ybwjnkYg-00889-00193536-00193847": "i would say fema's business is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00890-00193848-00194063": "then you really have to dig deep to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00891-00194064-00194166": "understand", "S64ybwjnkYg-00892-00194167-00194414": "how do you really know what that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00893-00194415-00194654": "different group of beneficiaries needs", "S64ybwjnkYg-00894-00194655-00194895": "so you can begin to test and find", "S64ybwjnkYg-00895-00194896-00195111": "whether or not you can provide it", "S64ybwjnkYg-00896-00195112-00195335": "okay that's about as long as i wanted to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00897-00195336-00195550": "talk and so let me stop let's talk about", "S64ybwjnkYg-00898-00195551-00195766": "these ideas of innovation i'll have one", "S64ybwjnkYg-00899-00195767-00195975": "more slide for an example and then we'll", "S64ybwjnkYg-00900-00195976-00197559": "declare a victory", "S64ybwjnkYg-00901-00197560-00197711": "thanks well it looks like we have some", "S64ybwjnkYg-00902-00197712-00197926": "questions as well um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00903-00197927-00198135": "if you'd like to um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00904-00198136-00198311": "answer those", "S64ybwjnkYg-00905-00198312-00198478": "i'd be glad to i can't see them right", "S64ybwjnkYg-00906-00198479-00198654": "now someone yes i can i can read them to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00907-00198655-00198935": "you so i know we did have one vanessa", "S64ybwjnkYg-00908-00198936-00199095": "answered one but i wanted to give you an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00909-00199096-00199247": "opportunity to answer as well and i just", "S64ybwjnkYg-00910-00199248-00199463": "before we get to that just wanted to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00911-00199464-00199799": "comment i mean i really do um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00912-00199800-00200038": "fully buy into this concept and in part", "S64ybwjnkYg-00913-00200039-00200238": "because i think we try at knapsack", "S64ybwjnkYg-00914-00200239-00200511": "foundation we try to practice this", "S64ybwjnkYg-00915-00200512-00200726": "not as artfully as you've just described", "S64ybwjnkYg-00916-00200727-00200902": "it and we have a very simplistic way of", "S64ybwjnkYg-00917-00200903-00201102": "describing it is build it and they will", "S64ybwjnkYg-00918-00201103-00201407": "come we avoid that because that is", "S64ybwjnkYg-00919-00201408-00201590": "presuming you know your market you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-00920-00201591-00201823": "your pro you know the problems um you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00921-00201824-00202175": "know everything um and and we never do", "S64ybwjnkYg-00922-00202176-00202399": "right so our practice is to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00923-00202400-00202631": "really iterate and try to understand the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00924-00202632-00202902": "problems of our partners um understand", "S64ybwjnkYg-00925-00202903-00203102": "that we don't know how to solve those", "S64ybwjnkYg-00926-00203103-00203238": "problems fully", "S64ybwjnkYg-00927-00203239-00203463": "um so we work with not only work with", "S64ybwjnkYg-00928-00203464-00203631": "our community not only to understand the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00929-00203632-00203783": "problem but to understand that we ain't", "S64ybwjnkYg-00930-00203784-00203999": "even on the right track for the solution", "S64ybwjnkYg-00931-00204000-00204263": "um so i love that a lot i think it's a", "S64ybwjnkYg-00932-00204264-00204423": "great um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00933-00204424-00204583": "i love how you've laid this out i think", "S64ybwjnkYg-00934-00204584-00204766": "it really resonates with me", "S64ybwjnkYg-00935-00204767-00205006": "um so quick question i know vanessa has", "S64ybwjnkYg-00936-00205007-00205103": "answered this but give you an", "S64ybwjnkYg-00937-00205104-00205303": "opportunity as well is um hacking for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00938-00205304-00205446": "homeland security more focused on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00939-00205448-00205631": "technical products", "S64ybwjnkYg-00940-00205632-00205798": "for example um", "S64ybwjnkYg-00941-00205800-00205990": "the example given here is power outage", "S64ybwjnkYg-00942-00205991-00206214": "scenarios or is it more focused on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00943-00206215-00206503": "planning and workflow for projects", "S64ybwjnkYg-00944-00206504-00206727": "so let me um i'll say something to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00945-00206728-00206846": "answer this then let me come back and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00946-00206848-00207103": "have vanessa reinforce please so let me", "S64ybwjnkYg-00947-00207104-00207279": "distinguish between the program that", "S64ybwjnkYg-00948-00207280-00207423": "vanessa is leading and hacking for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00949-00207423-00207582": "homeland security homeland security and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00950-00207583-00207886": "what i'm doing in h4x training as", "S64ybwjnkYg-00951-00207887-00208079": "vanessa described that the hacking for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00952-00208080-00208303": "homeland security program is a program", "S64ybwjnkYg-00953-00208304-00208486": "of graduate students where we're looking", "S64ybwjnkYg-00954-00208487-00208727": "for sponsors to bring in problems so", "S64ybwjnkYg-00955-00208728-00208919": "those graduate students can learn the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00956-00208919-00209119": "methodology but also the people who", "S64ybwjnkYg-00957-00209119-00209246": "bring in the problems will learn", "S64ybwjnkYg-00958-00209248-00209431": "something about the methodology and", "S64ybwjnkYg-00959-00209432-00209719": "really focus on real solutions we can", "S64ybwjnkYg-00960-00209719-00209894": "make up things academically but that's", "S64ybwjnkYg-00961-00209896-00210046": "how you learn learn when you work on", "S64ybwjnkYg-00962-00210048-00210439": "real problems i am focused on training", "S64ybwjnkYg-00963-00210440-00210519": "you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00964-00210519-00210767": "right the the people that i i look for", "S64ybwjnkYg-00965-00210767-00210975": "are the workforce who want to actually", "S64ybwjnkYg-00966-00210976-00211151": "apply these methodologies where they", "S64ybwjnkYg-00967-00211152-00211319": "live in work right now so that's the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00968-00211319-00211527": "distinction in the two different groups", "S64ybwjnkYg-00969-00211528-00211767": "that we work on the you just heard the", "S64ybwjnkYg-00970-00211767-00211975": "examples that i gave are", "S64ybwjnkYg-00971-00211976-00212134": "our focus the examples i did were", "S64ybwjnkYg-00972-00212135-00212310": "focused on process for a reason you're", "S64ybwjnkYg-00973-00212311-00212471": "going to see the same thing that we", "S64ybwjnkYg-00974-00212471-00212679": "talked about in just a minute um with", "S64ybwjnkYg-00975-00212680-00213006": "hurricane maria but the the methodology", "S64ybwjnkYg-00976-00213007-00213271": "is really the same um whether you're", "S64ybwjnkYg-00977-00213271-00213455": "trying to solve a doctrine problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-00978-00213456-00213639": "organization problem training problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-00979-00213640-00213958": "leadership problem materiel problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-00980-00213959-00214263": "the idea of having a hypothesis", "S64ybwjnkYg-00981-00214264-00214479": "gathering evidence analyzing what you", "S64ybwjnkYg-00982-00214480-00214719": "gather deciding whether or not to pivot", "S64ybwjnkYg-00983-00214719-00214887": "and then doing it over and over again", "S64ybwjnkYg-00984-00214888-00215087": "until you know enough to make a decision", "S64ybwjnkYg-00985-00215088-00215246": "is the same methodology that applies", "S64ybwjnkYg-00986-00215248-00215503": "across all the spectrums so long answer", "S64ybwjnkYg-00987-00215504-00215694": "to a short question let me turn it over", "S64ybwjnkYg-00988-00215696-00215863": "to vanessa", "S64ybwjnkYg-00989-00215864-00216015": "um yeah no", "S64ybwjnkYg-00990-00216016-00216167": "that's actually part of what i was gonna", "S64ybwjnkYg-00991-00216167-00216471": "hit on so thanks bo um so to be direct", "S64ybwjnkYg-00992-00216471-00216719": "with the question uh it is a wide range", "S64ybwjnkYg-00993-00216719-00216871": "if you go to that link you'll see", "S64ybwjnkYg-00994-00216871-00216982": "there's like", "S64ybwjnkYg-00995-00216983-00217182": "we've had topics from communications to", "S64ybwjnkYg-00996-00217183-00217287": "energy", "S64ybwjnkYg-00997-00217288-00217623": "technology logistics policy process", "S64ybwjnkYg-00998-00217623-00217894": "uh even work flowing uh definitely had", "S64ybwjnkYg-00999-00217896-00217998": "that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01000-00218000-00218287": "go under from like data to process", "S64ybwjnkYg-01001-00218288-00218455": "personnel management we've had some", "S64ybwjnkYg-01002-00218456-00218758": "solutions be more of like um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01003-00218759-00218975": "personality testing to identify who's", "S64ybwjnkYg-01004-00218976-00219255": "the right person for the right job so", "S64ybwjnkYg-01005-00219256-00219382": "uh you know when we talk about", "S64ybwjnkYg-01006-00219383-00219606": "innovation to bull's point it really is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01007-00219607-00219798": "how do you just make whatever it is that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01008-00219800-00220055": "you're dealing with more efficient", "S64ybwjnkYg-01009-00220056-00220246": "and what the students do would be the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01010-00220248-00220487": "process that bull would trade could", "S64ybwjnkYg-01011-00220488-00220606": "train you on", "S64ybwjnkYg-01012-00220607-00220871": "uh so how hacking for homeland security", "S64ybwjnkYg-01013-00220871-00221134": "is a way to leverage a student team to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01014-00221135-00221439": "sort of do the grunt work for you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01015-00221440-00221734": "uh but uh going through this program", "S64ybwjnkYg-01016-00221735-00221991": "doesn't actually teach you how to do it", "S64ybwjnkYg-01017-00221992-00222231": "you're interacting with the students to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01018-00222232-00222479": "kind of guide them uh they're going", "S64ybwjnkYg-01019-00222480-00222631": "through that they're going to courses to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01020-00222632-00222871": "learn through that um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01021-00222871-00223087": "and so bull would be the kind of person", "S64ybwjnkYg-01022-00223088-00223182": "that would", "S64ybwjnkYg-01023-00223183-00223431": "uh be that section that where you learn", "S64ybwjnkYg-01024-00223432-00223575": "through it uh and i know that you have", "S64ybwjnkYg-01025-00223576-00223831": "an awesome example that kind of ties all", "S64ybwjnkYg-01026-00223832-00223975": "of this together especially to make it", "S64ybwjnkYg-01027-00223976-00224167": "fema focused uh but just wanted to make", "S64ybwjnkYg-01028-00224167-00224439": "sure we answered that question great and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01029-00224440-00224655": "before we jump into the example just one", "S64ybwjnkYg-01030-00224656-00224846": "quick other question", "S64ybwjnkYg-01031-00224848-00225134": "waterfall seems the preferred method in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01032-00225135-00225319": "government just because of the budget", "S64ybwjnkYg-01033-00225319-00225598": "process rfp process what are some", "S64ybwjnkYg-01034-00225600-00225806": "recommendations to overcome this", "S64ybwjnkYg-01035-00225807-00226039": "challenge we have seen that to be an", "S64ybwjnkYg-01036-00226040-00226271": "early adopter innovator when it comes to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01037-00226271-00226487": "technology requires either a lot of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01038-00226488-00226798": "money or a lot of staff time both of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01039-00226800-00227079": "which are lacking in government right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01040-00227080-00227342": "hey great question and so we do things", "S64ybwjnkYg-01041-00227344-00227575": "nose to tail in government because we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01042-00227576-00227775": "started a lot of our management", "S64ybwjnkYg-01043-00227776-00227991": "philosophies off an idea that was", "S64ybwjnkYg-01044-00227992-00228231": "popular really kind of peaked in the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01045-00228232-00228446": "early 80s called total quality", "S64ybwjnkYg-01046-00228448-00228798": "management and it's imminently logical", "S64ybwjnkYg-01047-00228800-00228879": "right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01048-00228880-00229087": "before i give you a solution i really", "S64ybwjnkYg-01049-00229088-00229303": "got to write down what the problem is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01050-00229304-00229503": "and before i can take the next step i've", "S64ybwjnkYg-01051-00229504-00229615": "got to figure out how much it's going to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01052-00229616-00229710": "cost", "S64ybwjnkYg-01053-00229711-00229846": "well i'm the government i don't make", "S64ybwjnkYg-01054-00229848-00230046": "things i pay people to make things so i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01055-00230048-00230167": "got to go out", "S64ybwjnkYg-01056-00230167-00230294": "get everybody to come in and tell me", "S64ybwjnkYg-01057-00230296-00230479": "what they want now keep in mind if i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01058-00230480-00230623": "tell everybody to come and give me a bid", "S64ybwjnkYg-01059-00230623-00230775": "i can't go back and change but instead", "S64ybwjnkYg-01060-00230776-00230951": "of one of them bid on right so i got to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01061-00230952-00231127": "get that right the first time then i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01062-00231128-00231287": "come and i get all these proposals i got", "S64ybwjnkYg-01063-00231288-00231479": "to go through a very very rigorous", "S64ybwjnkYg-01064-00231480-00231734": "process to ensure that we're being fair", "S64ybwjnkYg-01065-00231735-00231934": "to everyone and i eventually got a lot", "S64ybwjnkYg-01066-00231935-00232175": "of contract and contracts have six", "S64ybwjnkYg-01067-00232176-00232351": "elements but they all boil down to this", "S64ybwjnkYg-01068-00232352-00232558": "idea there's an agreement between you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01069-00232559-00232679": "and i you're going to do something i'm", "S64ybwjnkYg-01070-00232680-00232798": "going to pay for it and we're not", "S64ybwjnkYg-01071-00232800-00232967": "changing that something in the middle of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01072-00232967-00233063": "it", "S64ybwjnkYg-01073-00233064-00233287": "imminently logical", "S64ybwjnkYg-01074-00233288-00233527": "the problem we have is that we try and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01075-00233528-00233823": "do it all in one step um agile is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01076-00233823-00234094": "improperly defined as a series of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01077-00234096-00234327": "waterfalls that's a mistakenly that's a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01078-00234328-00234558": "mistake to understand waterfall", "S64ybwjnkYg-01079-00234559-00234734": "excuse me agile because the underlying", "S64ybwjnkYg-01080-00234735-00234919": "philosophy is really about understanding", "S64ybwjnkYg-01081-00234919-00235087": "what people need", "S64ybwjnkYg-01082-00235088-00235287": "but the the problem that we have in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01083-00235288-00235527": "government is that instead of breaking", "S64ybwjnkYg-01084-00235528-00235815": "the problem into smaller increments and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01085-00235816-00235991": "understanding that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01086-00235992-00236182": "there's a zero percent chance we have", "S64ybwjnkYg-01087-00236183-00236351": "100 percent right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01088-00236352-00236567": "and we need to learn from that first", "S64ybwjnkYg-01089-00236567-00236710": "increment that goes out this is why", "S64ybwjnkYg-01090-00236711-00236910": "steve blank's modification of the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01091-00236911-00237182": "minimum viable product is so critical", "S64ybwjnkYg-01092-00237183-00237398": "because that learning allows us to come", "S64ybwjnkYg-01093-00237400-00237479": "back", "S64ybwjnkYg-01094-00237480-00237703": "and sometimes fundamentally change the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01095-00237704-00237894": "solution we were headed for now if you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01096-00237896-00238103": "think about the ppve the planning", "S64ybwjnkYg-01097-00238104-00238255": "programming budgeting and execution", "S64ybwjnkYg-01098-00238256-00238463": "process that all federal agencies are", "S64ybwjnkYg-01099-00238464-00238710": "under omb circular 11 alpha whether", "S64ybwjnkYg-01100-00238711-00238951": "you're in dod or dhs you all got to meet", "S64ybwjnkYg-01101-00238952-00239175": "those same requirements and you do have", "S64ybwjnkYg-01102-00239176-00239382": "to push that out two years", "S64ybwjnkYg-01103-00239383-00239606": "but that doesn't mean when you fill out", "S64ybwjnkYg-01104-00239607-00239806": "your documents for the congressional", "S64ybwjnkYg-01105-00239807-00240039": "budget justification book that you can't", "S64ybwjnkYg-01106-00240040-00240239": "give yourself enough flexibility even in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01107-00240240-00240471": "the year of execution to learn from and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01108-00240471-00240710": "make some of these adjustments so the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01109-00240711-00240846": "answer to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01110-00240848-00241087": "the challenges we find in government is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01111-00241088-00241415": "to apply agile by breaking our problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-01112-00241416-00241534": "solutions", "S64ybwjnkYg-01113-00241535-00241719": "into increments", "S64ybwjnkYg-01114-00241719-00241894": "the reason so if it's so obvious why", "S64ybwjnkYg-01115-00241896-00242079": "don't we do that i'll give you a quick", "S64ybwjnkYg-01116-00242080-00242303": "example right so", "S64ybwjnkYg-01117-00242304-00242519": "you're someone who has believed in this", "S64ybwjnkYg-01118-00242519-00242751": "idea of agile you're solving what you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01119-00242752-00242919": "believe is a critical problem for the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01120-00242919-00243071": "people that you have to solve problems", "S64ybwjnkYg-01121-00243071-00243327": "for and so you lay out here's the end", "S64ybwjnkYg-01122-00243328-00243463": "solution and here are the various", "S64ybwjnkYg-01123-00243464-00243663": "increments i have to do it in you put", "S64ybwjnkYg-01124-00243664-00243919": "that in over a series of time maybe five", "S64ybwjnkYg-01125-00243919-00244063": "years for our program objective", "S64ybwjnkYg-01126-00244064-00244223": "memorandum that we do in the department", "S64ybwjnkYg-01127-00244223-00244423": "of defense and then here's what", "S64ybwjnkYg-01128-00244423-00244606": "somebody's going to tell you some great", "S64ybwjnkYg-01129-00244607-00244798": "beards who's been there for a day or two", "S64ybwjnkYg-01130-00244800-00245030": "to put their arm around you and say", "S64ybwjnkYg-01131-00245031-00245142": "here's what's going to happen in your", "S64ybwjnkYg-01132-00245144-00245358": "program right so you got these five", "S64ybwjnkYg-01133-00245359-00245615": "increments you know you know that guy up", "S64ybwjnkYg-01134-00245616-00245806": "there in the budget office", "S64ybwjnkYg-01135-00245807-00246023": "about two years he's going to draw a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01136-00246023-00246175": "line right through the middle of your", "S64ybwjnkYg-01137-00246176-00246327": "increments and say", "S64ybwjnkYg-01138-00246328-00246471": "good enough", "S64ybwjnkYg-01139-00246471-00246671": "and that last half of stuff you say you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01140-00246671-00246855": "think you need you'll never get and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01141-00246856-00247023": "before you can even begin to argue but", "S64ybwjnkYg-01142-00247023-00247158": "that doesn't solve the whole problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-01143-00247159-00247455": "they'll say but you already said you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01144-00247456-00247623": "were giving something to the people who", "S64ybwjnkYg-01145-00247623-00247806": "needed something you fielded these first", "S64ybwjnkYg-01146-00247807-00247942": "two increments", "S64ybwjnkYg-01147-00247944-00248191": "you already added value", "S64ybwjnkYg-01148-00248192-00248446": "maybe you can't gold plated anymore but", "S64ybwjnkYg-01149-00248448-00248767": "you've done enough will declare victory", "S64ybwjnkYg-01150-00248767-00248991": "none of that is a statutory problem none", "S64ybwjnkYg-01151-00248992-00249223": "of that is a regulatory problem that is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01152-00249223-00249446": "purely a cultural and business", "S64ybwjnkYg-01153-00249448-00249679": "management problem so even within the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01154-00249680-00249951": "confines we have of our systems when we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01155-00249952-00250134": "take a hard look we'll really find most", "S64ybwjnkYg-01156-00250135-00250358": "of our wounds are self-inflicted", "S64ybwjnkYg-01157-00250359-00250558": "agile can and has still worked we have", "S64ybwjnkYg-01158-00250559-00250703": "some examples of that across the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01159-00250704-00250991": "services but by far waterfall is still", "S64ybwjnkYg-01160-00250992-00251223": "the method we use because it'll you're", "S64ybwjnkYg-01161-00251223-00251479": "100 correct person asks a question it", "S64ybwjnkYg-01162-00251480-00251719": "aligns so much more clearly", "S64ybwjnkYg-01163-00251719-00251927": "with these processes because last", "S64ybwjnkYg-01164-00251928-00252175": "comment the the person who designed this", "S64ybwjnkYg-01165-00252176-00252406": "original processes was mcnamara right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01166-00252407-00252567": "that's where you got this idea of palm", "S64ybwjnkYg-01167-00252567-00252903": "of ppbe from what he learned at ford", "S64ybwjnkYg-01168-00252904-00253046": "ford grew out of the second industrial", "S64ybwjnkYg-01169-00253048-00253215": "revolution henry ford was famous for", "S64ybwjnkYg-01170-00253216-00253446": "saying our customers can have any kind", "S64ybwjnkYg-01171-00253448-00253694": "of car they want as long as it's a black", "S64ybwjnkYg-01172-00253696-00253806": "model t", "S64ybwjnkYg-01173-00253807-00254063": "right so that that's the methodology you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01174-00254064-00254279": "had when you weren't in the knowledge", "S64ybwjnkYg-01175-00254280-00254391": "economy", "S64ybwjnkYg-01176-00254392-00254606": "when there wasn't customer choice the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01177-00254607-00254751": "way there is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01178-00254752-00254991": "that's obviously changed and our systems", "S64ybwjnkYg-01179-00254992-00255158": "and government have not changed with it", "S64ybwjnkYg-01180-00255159-00255319": "and so that's a part of what vanessa and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01181-00255319-00255671": "i are working on is that groundswell", "S64ybwjnkYg-01182-00255671-00255823": "look i'd love to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01183-00255823-00255975": "teach your political appointees and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01184-00255976-00256198": "senior leaders that would be great but", "S64ybwjnkYg-01185-00256200-00256398": "it's going to be an overview what i want", "S64ybwjnkYg-01186-00256400-00256551": "to do is i'm going to teach the next", "S64ybwjnkYg-01187-00256552-00256727": "generation of leaders", "S64ybwjnkYg-01188-00256728-00257023": "some of them are on this call right now", "S64ybwjnkYg-01189-00257023-00257239": "thanks cool um do you want to transition", "S64ybwjnkYg-01190-00257240-00257358": "now to the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01191-00257359-00257582": "uh maria example", "S64ybwjnkYg-01192-00257583-00258006": "sure let's give it a try", "S64ybwjnkYg-01193-00258007-00258158": "okay um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01194-00258159-00258415": "so this could be dynamic right so the um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01195-00258416-00258551": "the one thing you always do in a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01196-00258552-00258734": "presentation is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01197-00258735-00258910": "never never try and do public math but", "S64ybwjnkYg-01198-00258911-00259071": "we're going to do it anyway right i'm", "S64ybwjnkYg-01199-00259071-00259334": "not in fema i wasn't a part of hurricane", "S64ybwjnkYg-01200-00259335-00259542": "maria but here in talking to the people", "S64ybwjnkYg-01201-00259544-00259806": "i know of fema is an example where i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01202-00259807-00260015": "think the methodologies that we teach", "S64ybwjnkYg-01203-00260016-00260151": "could have mattered i want to be real", "S64ybwjnkYg-01204-00260152-00260406": "clear about something upfront it is in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01205-00260407-00260687": "our nature to say the problem is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01206-00260688-00260815": "those guys", "S64ybwjnkYg-01207-00260816-00261158": "right those knuckleheads what", "S64ybwjnkYg-01208-00261159-00261463": "buffoon made this decision", "S64ybwjnkYg-01209-00261464-00261630": "i'm more of the opinion that people made", "S64ybwjnkYg-01210-00261631-00261782": "the best decisions they could with the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01211-00261783-00261958": "information they had at the time", "S64ybwjnkYg-01212-00261959-00262142": "right so we just went through an example", "S64ybwjnkYg-01213-00262144-00262279": "with a really good question talking", "S64ybwjnkYg-01214-00262280-00262463": "about how waterfall aligns to what we do", "S64ybwjnkYg-01215-00262464-00262623": "in government because that's what we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01216-00262624-00262703": "teach", "S64ybwjnkYg-01217-00262704-00262958": "we never trained anyone to do this so", "S64ybwjnkYg-01218-00262959-00263247": "we'll start talking about this this idea", "S64ybwjnkYg-01219-00263248-00263495": "with one of my fundamental axioms is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01220-00263496-00263719": "that the solution to most government", "S64ybwjnkYg-01221-00263720-00263967": "problems is usually a chainsaw", "S64ybwjnkYg-01222-00263968-00264215": "and so in maria what we see is we see", "S64ybwjnkYg-01223-00264216-00264503": "devastation in puerto rico", "S64ybwjnkYg-01224-00264504-00264782": "and immediately fema goes into action", "S64ybwjnkYg-01225-00264783-00265055": "and one of the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01226-00265056-00265223": "is the essential security punctuation", "S64ybwjnkYg-01227-00265224-00265575": "the esf's that fema uses is has to do", "S64ybwjnkYg-01228-00265576-00265758": "with providing medical support so you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01229-00265759-00265887": "know immediately people are going to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01230-00265888-00266143": "need medical support you start judging", "S64ybwjnkYg-01231-00266144-00266310": "how much medical support", "S64ybwjnkYg-01232-00266311-00266495": "they need and i believe it's the uss", "S64ybwjnkYg-01233-00266496-00266671": "comfort that's on the east coast and the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01234-00266672-00266855": "mercy is on the west so we deploy the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01235-00266856-00267047": "uss comfort now some of the people i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01236-00267048-00267223": "talked to in vmware are like great here", "S64ybwjnkYg-01237-00267224-00267415": "we go again right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01238-00267416-00267551": "we've seen over and over again you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01239-00267552-00267751": "deploy the ship it's the wrong wrong", "S64ybwjnkYg-01240-00267752-00267975": "tool for the job but you know what it is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01241-00267976-00268223": "um that i personally think is important", "S64ybwjnkYg-01242-00268224-00268471": "is it's about giving people confidence", "S64ybwjnkYg-01243-00268472-00268663": "that someone's coming to do something", "S64ybwjnkYg-01244-00268664-00268958": "it's more it's the cynically it's that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01245-00268959-00269167": "way you know our leaders can you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-01246-00269168-00269287": "look like they're doing something good", "S64ybwjnkYg-01247-00269288-00269406": "on the news", "S64ybwjnkYg-01248-00269407-00269591": "that's not the way i view it and the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01249-00269592-00269758": "whole point of talking about the uss", "S64ybwjnkYg-01250-00269759-00269975": "comfort here is that problems are far", "S64ybwjnkYg-01251-00269976-00270158": "more complex when you get into the human", "S64ybwjnkYg-01252-00270159-00270447": "domain than just literally giving", "S64ybwjnkYg-01253-00270448-00270575": "someone a fish", "S64ybwjnkYg-01254-00270576-00270895": "right and so the whole idea of being", "S64ybwjnkYg-01255-00270896-00271039": "able to first let people know", "S64ybwjnkYg-01256-00271040-00271206": "psychologically that we care and we're", "S64ybwjnkYg-01257-00271207-00271487": "providing you this globally unique", "S64ybwjnkYg-01258-00271488-00271710": "capability to try and meet your needs", "S64ybwjnkYg-01259-00271711-00271943": "is the right idea", "S64ybwjnkYg-01260-00271944-00272103": "but then we send doctors down with it", "S64ybwjnkYg-01261-00272104-00272230": "because we say there's a shortage of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01262-00272231-00272406": "medical personnel", "S64ybwjnkYg-01263-00272407-00272575": "and when you start digging into the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01264-00272576-00272782": "problem a little bit more you definitely", "S64ybwjnkYg-01265-00272783-00272999": "have people who need medical care", "S64ybwjnkYg-01266-00273000-00273263": "there is a shortage of people being able", "S64ybwjnkYg-01267-00273264-00273503": "to receive medical care but the problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-01268-00273504-00273599": "isn't because there aren't enough", "S64ybwjnkYg-01269-00273600-00273710": "providers", "S64ybwjnkYg-01270-00273711-00273791": "right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01271-00273792-00273967": "well okay but they can't go to the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01272-00273968-00274103": "hospital because the hospital is out of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01273-00274104-00274263": "power so we need to get power to the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01274-00274264-00274482": "hospital they need more", "S64ybwjnkYg-01275-00274483-00274719": "generators now it turns out that they", "S64ybwjnkYg-01276-00274720-00274863": "didn't need more generators they had", "S64ybwjnkYg-01277-00274864-00275119": "plenty of generators but yes but those", "S64ybwjnkYg-01278-00275120-00275279": "generators need fuel and we've got to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01279-00275280-00275647": "get fuel for those generators", "S64ybwjnkYg-01280-00275648-00275863": "now it needs you to ship more fuel from", "S64ybwjnkYg-01281-00275864-00276039": "new york or another harbor in the united", "S64ybwjnkYg-01282-00276040-00276175": "states there was plenty out there on the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01283-00276176-00276279": "barge", "S64ybwjnkYg-01284-00276280-00276455": "the problem was you couldn't get the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01285-00276456-00276558": "doctors", "S64ybwjnkYg-01286-00276559-00276758": "the people or the fuel", "S64ybwjnkYg-01287-00276759-00276871": "the hospital", "S64ybwjnkYg-01288-00276872-00277047": "because roads were blocked what you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01289-00277048-00277143": "needed", "S64ybwjnkYg-01290-00277144-00277439": "was a chainsaw a bunch of them so", "S64ybwjnkYg-01291-00277440-00277615": "more chainsaws and chainsaw crews and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01292-00277616-00277782": "the equipment to clear the road so that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01293-00277783-00277927": "the fuel the power of patients and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01294-00277928-00278134": "doctors could get to the hospital to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01295-00278135-00278367": "provide medical care is what was needed", "S64ybwjnkYg-01296-00278368-00278551": "so let's take a quick walk through how", "S64ybwjnkYg-01297-00278552-00278751": "we could have gotten there from here", "S64ybwjnkYg-01298-00278752-00278975": "is if we hypothesize that what our need", "S64ybwjnkYg-01299-00278976-00279134": "is needed is more doctors how would we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01300-00279135-00279263": "have tested that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01301-00279264-00279423": "did we have people on the ground in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01302-00279424-00279615": "puerto rico who could answer that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01303-00279616-00279775": "question are there still people we were", "S64ybwjnkYg-01304-00279776-00280006": "in telecommunication with puerto rico", "S64ybwjnkYg-01305-00280007-00280239": "that could answer that question and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01306-00280240-00280399": "it's it's nowhere near as simple as i'm", "S64ybwjnkYg-01307-00280400-00280551": "making a sound it's not a video game", "S64ybwjnkYg-01308-00280552-00280751": "where you moved your doctor icon onto", "S64ybwjnkYg-01309-00280752-00280927": "the puerto rico icon and suddenly the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01310-00280928-00281079": "problem was solved now you have to go to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01311-00281080-00281279": "the detailed planning of where are we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01312-00281280-00281527": "going to put what specialists in what", "S64ybwjnkYg-01313-00281528-00281782": "cable in what capacity and what parts of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01314-00281783-00282095": "the country to do the most good so you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01315-00282096-00282271": "have to solve all those problems as", "S64ybwjnkYg-01316-00282272-00282455": "you're going through this but if we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01317-00282456-00282727": "solve the initial one of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01318-00282728-00283063": "before we start figuring out how to make", "S64ybwjnkYg-01319-00283064-00283287": "the thing right and assign the right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01320-00283288-00283487": "skill set to the right place", "S64ybwjnkYg-01321-00283488-00283647": "got to answer the question", "S64ybwjnkYg-01322-00283648-00283871": "are we making the right thing", "S64ybwjnkYg-01323-00283872-00284047": "and if we'd have those skills to say", "S64ybwjnkYg-01324-00284048-00284254": "let's hypothesize and test and turn", "S64ybwjnkYg-01325-00284255-00284487": "quickly again we ain't publishing in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01326-00284488-00284663": "nature here we're not going to design a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01327-00284664-00284839": "survey instrument over the course of six", "S64ybwjnkYg-01328-00284840-00285079": "months and then get a thousand inputs", "S64ybwjnkYg-01329-00285080-00285182": "we're going to pick up the phone and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01330-00285183-00285391": "gather evidence as best we could", "S64ybwjnkYg-01331-00285392-00285591": "could we have pivoted to have a better", "S64ybwjnkYg-01332-00285592-00285854": "understanding of what was needed at the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01333-00285855-00286095": "time where it was so last comment for me", "S64ybwjnkYg-01334-00286096-00286295": "before i hope we get some some inputs", "S64ybwjnkYg-01335-00286296-00286527": "here but by the way feel free to correct", "S64ybwjnkYg-01336-00286528-00286703": "my understanding of what happened to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01337-00286704-00287030": "hurricane maria i wasn't there relaying", "S64ybwjnkYg-01338-00287031-00287182": "what i understand from the professionals", "S64ybwjnkYg-01339-00287183-00287327": "i talked to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01340-00287328-00287551": "this is this is back to that idea that i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01341-00287552-00287791": "think is uniquely important to fema", "S64ybwjnkYg-01342-00287792-00288206": "and that notion of um being anti-fragile", "S64ybwjnkYg-01343-00288207-00288406": "we're often criticized in the idea of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01344-00288407-00288639": "preparing for the last war", "S64ybwjnkYg-01345-00288640-00288887": "fair right um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01346-00288888-00289127": "i i don't think that applies to the fema", "S64ybwjnkYg-01347-00289128-00289254": "i don't think anyone's applying for the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01348-00289255-00289358": "last", "S64ybwjnkYg-01349-00289359-00289519": "preparing for the last hurricane maybe", "S64ybwjnkYg-01350-00289520-00289703": "i'm wrong i i think that what you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01351-00289704-00289951": "learned from maria when you went beyond", "S64ybwjnkYg-01352-00289952-00290167": "the esf's into the lifelines to try and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01353-00290168-00290423": "take a bigger perspective view of the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01354-00290424-00290654": "problem is the exact", "S64ybwjnkYg-01355-00290655-00290887": "right lesson to learn", "S64ybwjnkYg-01356-00290888-00291087": "but you're still not going to be able to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01357-00291088-00291199": "apply", "S64ybwjnkYg-01358-00291200-00291382": "the right capability the right place at", "S64ybwjnkYg-01359-00291383-00291519": "the right time", "S64ybwjnkYg-01360-00291520-00291663": "if you don't have the evidence that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01361-00291664-00291823": "shows you what it is and that requires", "S64ybwjnkYg-01362-00291824-00292006": "hypothesis testing", "S64ybwjnkYg-01363-00292007-00292206": "so that's the example i wanted to use to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01364-00292207-00292391": "relate what we talked about with", "S64ybwjnkYg-01365-00292392-00292710": "innovation back to an example of what", "S64ybwjnkYg-01366-00292711-00293047": "the the work that fema does to see", "S64ybwjnkYg-01367-00293048-00293167": "whether or not it generates some", "S64ybwjnkYg-01368-00293168-00293839": "conversation", "S64ybwjnkYg-01369-00293840-00294095": "terrific any of the participants want to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01370-00294096-00294463": "jump in and ask any questions of bull on", "S64ybwjnkYg-01371-00294464-00294654": "hurricane maria his assumptions their", "S64ybwjnkYg-01372-00294655-00294806": "experiences", "S64ybwjnkYg-01373-00294807-00295063": "again we we know this isn't um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01374-00295064-00295223": "kind of a new experiment for us we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01375-00295224-00295406": "haven't done this for a few years but", "S64ybwjnkYg-01376-00295407-00295567": "looking for some brave volunteers to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01377-00295568-00295839": "help participate", "S64ybwjnkYg-01378-00295840-00296191": "and all you do is raise your hand in the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01379-00296192-00296439": "bottom of the screen and we can", "S64ybwjnkYg-01380-00296440-00297958": "unmute", "S64ybwjnkYg-01381-00297959-00298054": "all right we're", "S64ybwjnkYg-01382-00298055-00298206": "we're looking like we've got a shy", "S64ybwjnkYg-01383-00298207-00298527": "audience they bowl and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01384-00298528-00298679": "we'll do our best to see if we get", "S64ybwjnkYg-01385-00298680-00298903": "anyone to participate but anything else", "S64ybwjnkYg-01386-00298904-00299103": "that you and or vanessa want to cover", "S64ybwjnkYg-01387-00299104-00299334": "while we're waiting for anyone to jump", "S64ybwjnkYg-01388-00299335-00300710": "in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01389-00300711-00300982": "i put in the chat uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-01390-00300983-00301199": "to answer one of the questions uh the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01391-00301200-00301415": "website that we have with all the case", "S64ybwjnkYg-01392-00301416-00301647": "studies and things like that so", "S64ybwjnkYg-01393-00301648-00301854": "uh you know if you want to engage in a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01394-00301855-00302071": "lighter way uh with every other", "S64ybwjnkYg-01395-00302072-00302327": "methodology that bull just went through", "S64ybwjnkYg-01396-00302328-00302503": "uh definitely leverage hacking for", "S64ybwjnkYg-01397-00302504-00302639": "homeland security", "S64ybwjnkYg-01398-00302640-00302991": "if that later on piques your interest in", "S64ybwjnkYg-01399-00302992-00303230": "um actually wanting to do it yourself uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-01400-00303231-00303399": "definitely you can feel free to reach", "S64ybwjnkYg-01401-00303400-00303527": "out to me and i can", "S64ybwjnkYg-01402-00303528-00303710": "uh forward you to bull or you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-01403-00303711-00303991": "obviously you go straight to him um i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01404-00303992-00304167": "mean i personally am", "S64ybwjnkYg-01405-00304168-00304375": "biased obviously i have drank the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01406-00304376-00304606": "kool-aid on all this but uh having used", "S64ybwjnkYg-01407-00304607-00304823": "it countless times it really is a way to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01408-00304824-00305006": "help de-risk", "S64ybwjnkYg-01409-00305007-00305239": "uh the possibility of integrating a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01410-00305240-00305471": "solution that works uh and throughout", "S64ybwjnkYg-01411-00305472-00305647": "the way what i've found is and what i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01412-00305648-00305847": "love about it the most is that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01413-00305848-00306079": "builds the the data for you so when you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01414-00306080-00306295": "make an argument it's not about no one's", "S64ybwjnkYg-01415-00306296-00306415": "fighting against you they're fighting", "S64ybwjnkYg-01416-00306416-00306679": "against the data which helps build a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01417-00306680-00306782": "case", "S64ybwjnkYg-01418-00306783-00307087": "naturally and uh also kind of like a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01419-00307088-00307215": "posse around", "S64ybwjnkYg-01420-00307216-00307327": "why this", "S64ybwjnkYg-01421-00307328-00307591": "needs to happen uh so as you're doing", "S64ybwjnkYg-01422-00307592-00307767": "these interviews and like really getting", "S64ybwjnkYg-01423-00307768-00307975": "to know the the ground level of the the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01424-00307976-00308167": "reality uh", "S64ybwjnkYg-01425-00308168-00308351": "people are like oh you're actually doing", "S64ybwjnkYg-01426-00308352-00308543": "the work you actually understand what's", "S64ybwjnkYg-01427-00308544-00308823": "happening let me know how i can help and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01428-00308824-00309079": "so that really builds a coalition i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01429-00309080-00309310": "would say or like or some people call", "S64ybwjnkYg-01430-00309311-00309471": "them like a working group or however you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01431-00309472-00309799": "want to really uh so i i can't speak", "S64ybwjnkYg-01432-00309800-00309943": "enough to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01433-00309944-00310199": "um the approach as a whole uh you know", "S64ybwjnkYg-01434-00310200-00310367": "logically it makes sense", "S64ybwjnkYg-01435-00310368-00310543": "there's so much more", "S64ybwjnkYg-01436-00310544-00310919": "to it uh like as you've seen", "S64ybwjnkYg-01437-00310920-00311158": "so we do have one question um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01438-00311159-00311487": "uh a comment from relative to maria um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01439-00311488-00311719": "one of the problems i'm reading the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01440-00311720-00311863": "question one of the problems i saw with", "S64ybwjnkYg-01441-00311864-00312071": "fema and puerto rico was fema was not", "S64ybwjnkYg-01442-00312072-00312247": "understanding that everything was", "S64ybwjnkYg-01443-00312248-00312582": "connected across all sectors as far as", "S64ybwjnkYg-01444-00312583-00313030": "data were concerned", "S64ybwjnkYg-01445-00313031-00313230": "you know i got the same comment from one", "S64ybwjnkYg-01446-00313231-00313382": "of the people that i talked to at the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01447-00313383-00313567": "national level with fema is that and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01448-00313568-00313734": "they really worked they really worked on", "S64ybwjnkYg-01449-00313735-00313871": "that idea", "S64ybwjnkYg-01450-00313872-00314127": "and is it cci is the system you told me", "S64ybwjnkYg-01451-00314128-00314287": "that they have in place now that they", "S64ybwjnkYg-01452-00314288-00314567": "try and bring to every problem to at", "S64ybwjnkYg-01453-00314568-00314830": "least achieve communications", "S64ybwjnkYg-01454-00314831-00315127": "they're in the knowledge economy in the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01455-00315128-00315367": "fourth industrial revolution there there", "S64ybwjnkYg-01456-00315368-00315527": "isn't a harder problem than a data", "S64ybwjnkYg-01457-00315528-00315791": "problem right it's easy to talk about", "S64ybwjnkYg-01458-00315792-00316054": "these poor two courts of ai on it solves", "S64ybwjnkYg-01459-00316055-00316182": "everything right", "S64ybwjnkYg-01460-00316183-00316423": "the i i would tell you that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01461-00316424-00316679": "if uh i'm not shocked that fema would", "S64ybwjnkYg-01462-00316680-00316887": "have a data problem because frankly", "S64ybwjnkYg-01463-00316888-00317134": "everyone has a data problem and when you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01464-00317135-00317391": "work in a business you get the idea", "S64ybwjnkYg-01465-00317392-00317582": "that you can structure the things you do", "S64ybwjnkYg-01466-00317583-00317734": "and don't want to do your walmart you're", "S64ybwjnkYg-01467-00317735-00317951": "not selling john deere tractors", "S64ybwjnkYg-01468-00317952-00318287": "don't think um do you do get to decide", "S64ybwjnkYg-01469-00318288-00318567": "what products you want to provide and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01470-00318568-00318799": "doing that necessarily means you get to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01471-00318800-00319071": "control the data quick walmart example", "S64ybwjnkYg-01472-00319072-00319215": "they almost put rubbermaid out of", "S64ybwjnkYg-01473-00319216-00319310": "business", "S64ybwjnkYg-01474-00319311-00319623": "because they demanded 45's no 45 days no", "S64ybwjnkYg-01475-00319624-00319863": "interest terms now walmart will turn its", "S64ybwjnkYg-01476-00319864-00320071": "inventory four times before they have to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01477-00320072-00320279": "pay for the first set and part of the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01478-00320280-00320439": "way they do that is that if you want to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01479-00320440-00320591": "do business with walmart or at least", "S64ybwjnkYg-01480-00320592-00320791": "this used to be true that in order to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01481-00320792-00320943": "ship something to them you had to use", "S64ybwjnkYg-01482-00320944-00321199": "their codes their labels their system", "S64ybwjnkYg-01483-00321200-00321382": "because they grabbed that data and they", "S64ybwjnkYg-01484-00321383-00321582": "were able to put it into their system", "S64ybwjnkYg-01485-00321583-00321687": "and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01486-00321688-00321910": "and very practically know what was on", "S64ybwjnkYg-01487-00321911-00322110": "each shelf and when to order the next", "S64ybwjnkYg-01488-00322111-00322319": "series of supplies", "S64ybwjnkYg-01489-00322320-00322543": "i don't think fema will ever be able to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01490-00322544-00322775": "do that because you'll never be able to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01491-00322776-00323054": "control the situation to that degree", "S64ybwjnkYg-01492-00323055-00323263": "so i'm not shocked that there's a data", "S64ybwjnkYg-01493-00323264-00323391": "problem there", "S64ybwjnkYg-01494-00323392-00323543": "but i think that that is i think that's", "S64ybwjnkYg-01495-00323544-00323647": "one of the challenges you're going to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01496-00323648-00323887": "face that you can't use some industry", "S64ybwjnkYg-01497-00323888-00323999": "solutions for", "S64ybwjnkYg-01498-00324000-00324223": "yeah and and and both it's actually kind", "S64ybwjnkYg-01499-00324224-00324415": "of a great segue to the follow-up", "S64ybwjnkYg-01500-00324416-00324551": "question and it's something that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01501-00324552-00324734": "knapsack foundation really tries to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01502-00324735-00325030": "struggle it tries to prioritize and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01503-00325031-00325143": "i know", "S64ybwjnkYg-01504-00325144-00325382": "we broadly as a public safety community", "S64ybwjnkYg-01505-00325383-00325647": "struggle with at times um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01506-00325648-00325830": "coming", "S64ybwjnkYg-01507-00325831-00325975": "one of the feedback that folks have", "S64ybwjnkYg-01508-00325976-00326167": "gotten from maria and i think you could", "S64ybwjnkYg-01509-00326168-00326430": "substitute any other disaster honestly", "S64ybwjnkYg-01510-00326431-00326687": "is that a lot of really great learnings", "S64ybwjnkYg-01511-00326688-00326919": "and ideas that come from folks who are", "S64ybwjnkYg-01512-00326920-00327087": "actually the boots on the ground really", "S64ybwjnkYg-01513-00327088-00327319": "experiencing the disasters", "S64ybwjnkYg-01514-00327320-00327495": "have they have a really hard time", "S64ybwjnkYg-01515-00327496-00327630": "providing", "S64ybwjnkYg-01516-00327631-00327839": "that feedback is you know actually", "S64ybwjnkYg-01517-00327840-00328071": "direct feedback as well as ideas for", "S64ybwjnkYg-01518-00328072-00328334": "solving problems to the decision makers", "S64ybwjnkYg-01519-00328335-00328606": "um i know this process isn't necessarily", "S64ybwjnkYg-01520-00328607-00328806": "designed for that but i think it's a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01521-00328807-00328958": "really interesting way to to help", "S64ybwjnkYg-01522-00328959-00329215": "facilitate that that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01523-00329216-00329391": "getting some of that direct feedback and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01524-00329392-00329599": "as well as solution ideas to decision", "S64ybwjnkYg-01525-00329600-00329871": "makers curious your reaction", "S64ybwjnkYg-01526-00329872-00330143": "so it's it's an interesting problem and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01527-00330144-00330319": "let me give you an example of why i", "S64ybwjnkYg-01528-00330320-00330582": "think this process is designed for that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01529-00330583-00330791": "um it's a company you're going to hear", "S64ybwjnkYg-01530-00330792-00331087": "about in about five days", "S64ybwjnkYg-01531-00331088-00331310": "called reveal ai", "S64ybwjnkYg-01532-00331311-00331591": "reveal ai started out as aurora", "S64ybwjnkYg-01533-00331592-00331863": "and aurora was formed at bmnt because we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01534-00331864-00331943": "thought", "S64ybwjnkYg-01535-00331944-00332143": "we we have a better way to figure out", "S64ybwjnkYg-01536-00332144-00332375": "what customers actually need so we went", "S64ybwjnkYg-01537-00332376-00332606": "in and literally poured two courts of ai", "S64ybwjnkYg-01538-00332607-00332751": "on it we built a natural language", "S64ybwjnkYg-01539-00332752-00332958": "processing system to collect that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01540-00332959-00333071": "information", "S64ybwjnkYg-01541-00333072-00333327": "because surveys don't work well in the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01542-00333328-00333519": "situation so you've been the person with", "S64ybwjnkYg-01543-00333520-00333703": "the boots on the ground how do we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01544-00333704-00333975": "collect that volume of information", "S64ybwjnkYg-01545-00333976-00334087": "well", "S64ybwjnkYg-01546-00334088-00334287": "you probably need a psychometricist to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01547-00334288-00334454": "help you design the right survey", "S64ybwjnkYg-01548-00334455-00334647": "instrument then you have to take a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01549-00334648-00334839": "population which is usually already", "S64ybwjnkYg-01550-00334840-00334991": "surveyed to death and get them to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01551-00334992-00335167": "respond then you've got to have the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01552-00335168-00335487": "correct ontology so that broken doesn't", "S64ybwjnkYg-01553-00335488-00335743": "mean damage doesn't mean destroyed", "S64ybwjnkYg-01554-00335744-00335887": "but if you use natural language", "S64ybwjnkYg-01555-00335888-00336110": "processing you can actually pull in very", "S64ybwjnkYg-01556-00336111-00336278": "large samples of that data and let", "S64ybwjnkYg-01557-00336279-00336495": "people describe things in their own way", "S64ybwjnkYg-01558-00336496-00336751": "to start drilling down deeper into", "S64ybwjnkYg-01559-00336752-00337087": "what's the real problem so in that we we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01560-00337088-00337215": "know that", "S64ybwjnkYg-01561-00337216-00337510": "because we had to pivot about four times", "S64ybwjnkYg-01562-00337511-00337663": "with aurora", "S64ybwjnkYg-01563-00337664-00337854": "to get to the company that's about to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01564-00337855-00338054": "spin out of bmnt i'm not trying to sell", "S64ybwjnkYg-01565-00338055-00338271": "reveal ai to you right and i don't even", "S64ybwjnkYg-01566-00338272-00338423": "know that that would work though if", "S64ybwjnkYg-01567-00338424-00338558": "you're interested i'll give robert a", "S64ybwjnkYg-01568-00338559-00338847": "call but the that is an idea where the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01569-00338848-00339206": "same notion of let's try this learn and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01570-00339207-00339303": "pivot", "S64ybwjnkYg-01571-00339304-00339551": "actually led us to solving the very", "S64ybwjnkYg-01572-00339552-00339775": "problem that you've identified of how do", "S64ybwjnkYg-01573-00339776-00339991": "we get that information so it doesn't", "S64ybwjnkYg-01574-00339992-00340143": "literally solve the information problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-01575-00340144-00340351": "we hire some really smart people to do", "S64ybwjnkYg-01576-00340352-00340678": "that but knowing what the right problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-01577-00340679-00340806": "was", "S64ybwjnkYg-01578-00340807-00341015": "led us to being able to get the people", "S64ybwjnkYg-01579-00341016-00341199": "who could solve the problem", "S64ybwjnkYg-01580-00341200-00341423": "yeah that's terrific and again i think", "S64ybwjnkYg-01581-00341424-00341639": "it's um you could substitute maria with", "S64ybwjnkYg-01582-00341640-00341878": "almost anything even in an auto accident", "S64ybwjnkYg-01583-00341879-00342030": "on a daily basis", "S64ybwjnkYg-01584-00342031-00342367": "um so it it's it's probably", "S64ybwjnkYg-01585-00342368-00342503": "the biggest challenge we have in the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01586-00342504-00342671": "public safety community is getting", "S64ybwjnkYg-01587-00342672-00342847": "actionable information up the chain but", "S64ybwjnkYg-01588-00342848-00343015": "also then having", "S64ybwjnkYg-01589-00343016-00343271": "solution ideas up the chain as well and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01590-00343272-00343471": "then having it flow back down in a way", "S64ybwjnkYg-01591-00343472-00343606": "that is", "S64ybwjnkYg-01592-00343607-00343791": "additionally actionable", "S64ybwjnkYg-01593-00343792-00343871": "um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01594-00343872-00343975": "so", "S64ybwjnkYg-01595-00343976-00344239": "really thank you both bull and vanessa", "S64ybwjnkYg-01596-00344240-00344534": "for your time this is terrific", "S64ybwjnkYg-01597-00344535-00344703": "it's something that that knapsack", "S64ybwjnkYg-01598-00344704-00344910": "foundation really embraces as a concept", "S64ybwjnkYg-01599-00344911-00345182": "and we're we really appreciate your time", "S64ybwjnkYg-01600-00345183-00345454": "um and thank you to our participants for", "S64ybwjnkYg-01601-00345455-00345734": "joining and for asking questions um", "S64ybwjnkYg-01602-00345735-00345967": "sorry for springing on you a new model", "S64ybwjnkYg-01603-00345968-00346127": "where we're going to ask you to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01604-00346128-00346303": "speak up but", "S64ybwjnkYg-01605-00346304-00346495": "you know we'll we'll continue to try to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01606-00346496-00346654": "weave that into some of our prep tech", "S64ybwjnkYg-01607-00346655-00346895": "talks in the future um but again thank", "S64ybwjnkYg-01608-00346896-00347175": "you everybody for your time um and we", "S64ybwjnkYg-01609-00347176-00347399": "really appreciate it and as always the", "S64ybwjnkYg-01610-00347400-00347567": "recording for this will be available on", "S64ybwjnkYg-01611-00347568-00347743": "the website um probably next week", "S64ybwjnkYg-01612-00347744-00347934": "sometime as well as a presentation and", "S64ybwjnkYg-01613-00347935-00348191": "analysis of the q a so look forward to", "S64ybwjnkYg-01614-00348192-00348478": "that sometime in the next seven or ten", "S64ybwjnkYg-01615-00348479-00348575": "days", "S64ybwjnkYg-01616-00348576-00348751": "again we'll sign off now and thank you", "S64ybwjnkYg-01617-00348752-00348967": "very much to everybody", "S64ybwjnkYg-01618-00348968-00349134": "thank you thanks a lot for having us", "S64ybwjnkYg-01619-00349135-00349516": "yeah thank you so much"}}, {"audio_id": "S6hYzPSci6Q", "text": {"S6hYzPSci6Q-00000-00000112-00001504": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00001-00001505-00002187": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00002-00002188-00002506": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00003-00002507-00003217": "[Laughter]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00004-00003218-00004123": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00005-00004124-00004647": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00006-00004648-00005058": "so", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00007-00005059-00006418": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00008-00006419-00010808": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00009-00010809-00012342": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00010-00012343-00012902": "this", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00011-00012903-00014010": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00012-00014011-00015466": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00013-00015468-00015927": "[Music]", "S6hYzPSci6Q-00014-00015928-00016136": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S6MoXPVAFIU", "text": {"S6MoXPVAFIU-00000-00000239-00000430": "hello everyone", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00001-00000431-00000767": "so this is yet another episode of", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00002-00000768-00000911": "insights", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00003-00000911-00001231": "where i bring to you the co-authors of", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00004-00001232-00001374": "the book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00005-00001375-00001647": "caterpillar to butterfly and in this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00006-00001648-00001759": "series", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00007-00001760-00001879": "we now", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00008-00001880-00001991": "get", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00009-00001992-00002231": "into a conversation with dr anushi", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00010-00002232-00002510": "samaya a holistic coach", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00011-00002511-00002687": "she's from dubai", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00012-00002688-00002799": "and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00013-00002800-00003039": "i would love to hear", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00014-00003040-00003191": "what dr", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00015-00003192-00003431": "samaya dr anushi samaya has actually", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00016-00003432-00003711": "written in the book in her chapter but", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00017-00003711-00003967": "before that let's just ask her", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00018-00003968-00004286": "whether she intended to be", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00019-00004287-00004519": "an author sometime in her life or it was", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00020-00004520-00004927": "just just like that dr anishi", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00021-00004928-00005175": "first of all thank you so much sabnaji", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00022-00005176-00005518": "for having me here and i'm so happy and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00023-00005519-00005670": "excited", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00024-00005671-00005751": "so", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00025-00005752-00006111": "in my journey in the whole life i never", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00026-00006112-00006463": "thought that i can be an author it was", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00027-00006464-00006710": "never on my wish list", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00028-00006711-00007095": "i cannot imagine that i can write a book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00029-00007095-00007414": "so i can say that yeah in the journey of", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00030-00007415-00007631": "this 12 years", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00031-00007631-00007767": "of this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00032-00007768-00007998": "wellness and holistic coaching which i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00033-00008000-00008134": "am in", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00034-00008136-00008391": "so i realized that yes i am good at", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00035-00008392-00008727": "offering meditations feeling the energy", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00036-00008728-00008942": "accessing the divine energy", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00037-00008943-00009199": "because my clients they would tell me", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00038-00009200-00009446": "during the workshops or maybe during the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00039-00009447-00009631": "coaching session that yeah they felt", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00040-00009632-00009855": "completely relaxed", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00041-00009856-00010135": "listening to my voice or they would say", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00042-00010136-00010406": "that their physical pain has gone or", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00043-00010407-00010606": "sometimes they feel that energetic", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00044-00010607-00010823": "shifts and then when i give them some", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00045-00010824-00010999": "practices they achieve some personal", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00046-00011000-00011183": "goals or professional goals so i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00047-00011184-00011478": "realized yes i am good at this but i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00048-00011479-00011942": "never knew that that i can write a book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00049-00011943-00012223": "that itself is an example that we all", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00050-00012224-00012599": "have so many talents within us which we", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00051-00012600-00012910": "would never realize isn't it that was", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00052-00012911-00013215": "for everyone yes someone not here to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00053-00013216-00013527": "shrink into the darkness of cocoon you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00054-00013528-00013630": "are here", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00055-00013631-00014055": "to break it grow and transform into a", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00056-00014056-00014375": "butterfly which you are meant to be", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00057-00014376-00014479": "isn't it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00058-00014480-00014719": "absolutely meant to be", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00059-00014719-00014999": "there there's always you know um", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00060-00015000-00015191": "scope to grow", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00061-00015191-00015399": "and we should just allow ourselves to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00062-00015400-00015486": "grow", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00063-00015487-00015950": "allow us to take you know leaps of faith", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00064-00015951-00016166": "and just see where it goes it's okay", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00065-00016168-00016327": "just to fail also", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00066-00016328-00016503": "but if you're in the right company with", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00067-00016504-00016727": "the right people there is less chances", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00068-00016728-00016927": "of you failing you will just get you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00069-00016928-00017055": "know going", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00070-00017056-00017327": "uh with the momentum of uh", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00071-00017328-00017703": "i won't say crowd but of the environment", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00072-00017704-00017822": "you are in", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00073-00017823-00018086": "environment is very important at the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00074-00018087-00018399": "same time right tools also they should", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00075-00018400-00018614": "these people don't know that that there", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00076-00018615-00018919": "are two techniques which can make them", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00077-00018920-00019167": "feel that yeah these are the practices", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00078-00019168-00019486": "which we use them and then that that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00079-00019487-00019919": "allows them to access to their own power", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00080-00019920-00020158": "then they can really grow", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00081-00020159-00020263": "yeah", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00082-00020264-00020407": "so uh", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00083-00020408-00020550": "wonderfully put", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00084-00020551-00020814": "so dr anushi tell us um", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00085-00020815-00020894": "how", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00086-00020895-00021167": "uh you know you felt when you first", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00087-00021168-00021527": "thought of writing", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00088-00021528-00021847": "yeah as i first said that yeah i thought", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00089-00021848-00022030": "i can't write", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00090-00022031-00022263": "but then then i then i realized that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00091-00022264-00022599": "yeah how i can whatever i am offering in", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00092-00022600-00022950": "my workshops whatever i help them so we", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00093-00022951-00023278": "each one of us have that something", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00094-00023279-00023542": "experience some something that we can", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00095-00023543-00023671": "share", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00096-00023672-00023919": "with the world and just i put it on the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00097-00023920-00024430": "paper and then i realized oh wow", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00098-00024431-00024639": "it's a magnificent piece", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00099-00024640-00024742": "of course", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00100-00024743-00025071": "yeah so what's what is the name of this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00101-00025072-00025375": "magnificent piece that you have created", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00102-00025376-00025575": "what's the name of your chapter", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00103-00025576-00025862": "i would love to share that the chapter's", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00104-00025863-00026327": "name is i'm not just me", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00105-00026327-00026479": "i'm not just", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00106-00026480-00026790": "i'm more than that in other words right", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00107-00026791-00027007": "absolutely wow", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00108-00027008-00027255": "and how did you think of this title", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00109-00027256-00027439": "for your chapter", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00110-00027439-00027687": "because that's what we all have the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00111-00027688-00028046": "question that okay who am i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00112-00028047-00028295": "we all have this question right", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00113-00028295-00028614": "that's what i have explained in this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00114-00028616-00028918": "chapter that you are much more than your", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00115-00028919-00029095": "physical body", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00116-00029095-00029311": "on the spiritual aspect as well as", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00117-00029312-00029655": "scientific aspect i have explained it so", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00118-00029656-00029935": "for that i had to read the book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00119-00029936-00030079": "yes of course", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00120-00030080-00030302": "people will have to read the book and i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00121-00030303-00030527": "am sure all the co-authors are also", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00122-00030527-00030790": "raring to read each other's chapters", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00123-00030791-00031062": "also because i'm sure uh all the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00124-00031063-00031311": "chapters put together not one not two", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00125-00031312-00031623": "not three not four they're 14 different", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00126-00031624-00031783": "chapters", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00127-00031783-00032046": "yeah and from all over the world people", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00128-00032047-00032318": "have got together with their expertise", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00129-00032319-00032590": "and put it in their chapters", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00130-00032591-00032743": "and the beauty is you can just pick up", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00131-00032744-00032887": "any chapter and start reading in the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00132-00032888-00033055": "book you don't really have to start from", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00133-00033056-00033318": "the beginning and finish it at the end", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00134-00033319-00033518": "although it is placed in a way that it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00135-00033519-00033799": "will take you a long a journey but you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00136-00033800-00034039": "are free to one is free to pick up any", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00137-00034040-00034223": "chapter and read", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00138-00034224-00034646": "so uh yeah and uh dr samaya dr anushi", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00139-00034647-00035015": "samaya i would love to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00140-00035016-00035239": "know from you do you have a favorite", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00141-00035240-00035543": "part in the chapter yeah but before that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00142-00035544-00035902": "can i just tell them what is in it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00143-00035903-00036030": "yeah", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00144-00036031-00036535": "i have many favorite", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00145-00036536-00036783": "the parts for us but before that i want", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00146-00036784-00036895": "to tell", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00147-00036896-00037135": "our viewers that what exactly they'll", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00148-00037136-00037351": "get when they read the chapter so of", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00149-00037352-00037543": "course they'll come to know that who", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00150-00037544-00037735": "they really are", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00151-00037736-00037879": "definitely", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00152-00037880-00038159": "they definitely want to know that we all", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00153-00038160-00038423": "have the question of who am i so that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00154-00038424-00038687": "question will be answered when they read", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00155-00038688-00038839": "this chapter", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00156-00038840-00039159": "and when you understand that you realize", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00157-00039160-00039502": "that you are the magnificent expression", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00158-00039503-00039846": "of that divine that god your creator", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00159-00039847-00040127": "wow you have that divine spark that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00160-00040128-00040415": "unlimited power within you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00161-00040416-00040630": "all you need to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00162-00040631-00041079": "claim that power feel that worthiness", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00163-00041080-00041190": "and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00164-00041191-00041351": "even", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00165-00041352-00041743": "feel that believe that i am valued", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00166-00041744-00042007": "not in an egoistic manner", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00167-00042008-00042311": "but you a very humble manner", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00168-00042312-00042639": "to have that deep gratitude for that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00169-00042640-00042879": "divinity which is within", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00170-00042880-00043023": "you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00171-00043024-00043399": "each one has those unique gifts to share", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00172-00043400-00043621": "with the world", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00173-00043622-00043943": "[Music]", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00174-00043944-00044183": "and they make the world", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00175-00044184-00044302": "bright", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00176-00044303-00044590": "so i have shared that how by shifting", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00177-00044591-00044951": "your mindset and aligning our energy", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00178-00044952-00045199": "with the energy of this divine", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00179-00045200-00045687": "you can become your best version", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00180-00045688-00045855": "if you do this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00181-00045856-00046183": "the whole world is yours you are bright", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00182-00046184-00046518": "the old world is bright", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00183-00046519-00046862": "so dr anusha are you ever sad or unhappy", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00184-00046863-00047046": "or frustrated i mean talking to you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00185-00047047-00047271": "doesn't look like it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00186-00047272-00047623": "no darling that's the that's the story", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00187-00047624-00047951": "of that that we all have sadness we all", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00188-00047952-00048246": "have down times and we don't have to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00189-00048247-00048607": "suppress them we actually have to learn", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00190-00048608-00048895": "to express them in a positive manner", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00191-00048896-00049230": "it's very important then once we do that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00192-00049231-00049446": "it's only the happiness on the other", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00193-00049447-00049735": "side the joy the love peace and calmness", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00194-00049736-00049974": "is that's the true nature", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00195-00049975-00050223": "but when you feel that if you don't know", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00196-00050224-00050423": "how to express it it's very very", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00197-00050424-00050711": "difficult for you to feel that so", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00198-00050712-00051030": "it's and many time it happens but i know", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00199-00051031-00051230": "the truth that okay", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00200-00051232-00051511": "it is telling you something you need to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00201-00051512-00051766": "be there and that divine is there that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00202-00051767-00052046": "guides you constantly", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00203-00052047-00052270": "thank you so much for the compliment but", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00204-00052271-00052494": "it's very important for us too i was", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00205-00052495-00052694": "just wondering with all this knowledge", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00206-00052695-00052959": "and with the kind of calmness that you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00207-00052960-00053054": "speak", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00208-00053055-00053287": "do you ever get angry", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00209-00053288-00053687": "do you lose your temper like all of us", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00210-00053688-00053879": "it's struck in my head this question", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00211-00053879-00054087": "just came into my head", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00212-00054088-00054382": "absolutely but there are tools with that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00213-00054383-00054623": "we can understand to express those", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00214-00054624-00054950": "emotions negative emotions let them go", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00215-00054951-00055215": "and then we access that calmness there", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00216-00055216-00055471": "are techniques which makes you calm and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00217-00055472-00055742": "relaxed and go into those directions and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00218-00055744-00055999": "then of course then divine is there", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00219-00056000-00056391": "which can constantly yeah so um this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00220-00056391-00056638": "book is 14 ways", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00221-00056639-00056863": "to give wings to your mindset", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00222-00056864-00057094": "which mindset are you catering to in", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00223-00057095-00057215": "this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00224-00057216-00057359": "chapter", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00225-00057360-00057679": "so it's about as i said for me i believe", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00226-00057679-00057982": "that why is when you shift the mindset", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00227-00057983-00058279": "then you are you are opening all the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00228-00058279-00058382": "doors", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00229-00058383-00058703": "it's opening the door to not only", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00230-00058704-00058975": "spiritually physically mentally", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00231-00058976-00059238": "intellectually materialistically all of", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00232-00059239-00059494": "that when you are accessing it doesn't", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00233-00059495-00059975": "work on a one level all areas", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00234-00059976-00060223": "it's okay all right yeah you had asked", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00235-00060224-00060447": "me the favorite part do you want me to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00236-00060448-00060742": "yeah i i was just going to ask you again", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00237-00060744-00060887": "do you have a favorite part would you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00238-00060888-00061126": "want to read it for us", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00239-00061127-00061399": "there are many parts in fact i feel that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00240-00061400-00061911": "the whole chapter is", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00241-00061912-00062215": "because i can give them one", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00242-00062216-00062519": "trailer so then they'll be interested in", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00243-00062520-00062615": "that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00244-00062616-00062957": "so here it is", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00245-00062958-00063263": "[Music]", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00246-00063264-00063494": "it would be very interesting to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00247-00063495-00063782": "know the favorite part of the author", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00248-00063783-00064030": "see there are as i told you there are", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00249-00064032-00064335": "many paths which i really love but this", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00250-00064336-00064606": "is really interesting then when we see a", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00251-00064607-00064911": "movie that time we see we love the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00252-00064912-00065191": "trailer also right so one of their part", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00253-00065191-00065342": "is also really", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00254-00065344-00065559": "something which we really love", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00255-00065560-00065926": "so i'm going to share that with them", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00256-00065927-00066303": "our deepest fear is not that we are", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00257-00066304-00066455": "inadequate", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00258-00066456-00066919": "our deepest fear is that we are powerful", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00259-00066920-00067103": "beyond measure", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00260-00067104-00067350": "what is our light", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00261-00067351-00067535": "not over darkness", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00262-00067536-00067831": "that most frighten us", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00263-00067832-00068143": "please ask ourselves", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00264-00068144-00068287": "who am i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00265-00068288-00068694": "to be brilliant gorgeous talented", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00266-00068695-00068926": "fabulous", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00267-00068927-00069071": "actually", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00268-00069072-00069255": "who are you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00269-00069256-00069438": "not to be", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00270-00069439-00069726": "you are a child of god", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00271-00069727-00069926": "you're playing small", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00272-00069927-00070255": "does not serve the world", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00273-00070256-00070575": "there is nothing enlightened about", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00274-00070576-00070719": "shrinking", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00275-00070720-00071062": "so that other people won't feel insecure", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00276-00071063-00071231": "around you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00277-00071232-00071615": "you are all meant to shine as children", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00278-00071616-00071782": "do", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00279-00071783-00072031": "we were born to manifest", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00280-00072032-00072455": "the glory of god that is within us", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00281-00072456-00072799": "it is not just in some of us", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00282-00072800-00073071": "it's in everyone", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00283-00073072-00073150": "and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00284-00073151-00073487": "as we let our own light shine", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00285-00073488-00073838": "we unconsciously give other people", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00286-00073839-00074206": "permission to do the same", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00287-00074207-00074671": "as we are liberated from our own theory", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00288-00074672-00074782": "our", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00289-00074783-00074959": "presence", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00290-00074960-00075335": "automatically liberates others", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00291-00075336-00075535": "wow nice", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00292-00075536-00075847": "thank you lovely lovely", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00293-00075848-00076087": "of course i've read this before and i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00294-00076088-00076294": "know how um", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00295-00076295-00076511": "how impactful", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00296-00076512-00076743": "williamson yes", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00297-00076744-00076855": "so i had", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00298-00076856-00077087": "this is one of the piece i have voted in", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00299-00077088-00077559": "it so i'm sure people would love it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00300-00077560-00077847": "yeah so dr anishi you wrote this chapter", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00301-00077848-00078031": "all by yourself or you had to take help", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00302-00078032-00078247": "from others", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00303-00078248-00078455": "what was it like it was was it your own", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00304-00078456-00078726": "baby or others were also part of it was", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00305-00078727-00079038": "only my baby but of course many of them", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00306-00079039-00079231": "helped me with the grammar and all one", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00307-00079232-00079535": "of them", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00308-00079536-00079647": "so", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00309-00079648-00080062": "we all have um our qualities so i'm", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00310-00080063-00080375": "thankful to you too and the all coaches", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00311-00080376-00080591": "all the teachers divine", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00312-00080592-00080855": "whoever are there to help", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00313-00080856-00081094": "each and every woman there are so many", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00314-00081095-00081423": "people whom we cannot forget right yeah", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00315-00081424-00081575": "in our journey", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00316-00081576-00082215": "my dear ones", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00317-00082216-00082415": "you're so full of gratitude i'm so happy", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00318-00082416-00082735": "that you trusted me with your chapter um", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00319-00082736-00082887": "totally honored", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00320-00082888-00083167": "uh okay and uh coming to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00321-00083168-00083391": "the launch the book is about to launch", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00322-00083392-00083615": "do you have any plans for it for the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00323-00083616-00083703": "lunch", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00324-00083704-00083918": "yes i'm so excited", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00325-00083919-00084238": "it's on 30th of april and we have give", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00326-00084239-00084462": "we are going to keep a very low price", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00327-00084463-00084687": "through a price", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00328-00084688-00084903": "inviting all the reader all the viewers", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00329-00084904-00085150": "to grab that opportunity", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00330-00085151-00085511": "and buy it at very minimal price we will", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00331-00085512-00085759": "share the link with them yeah of course", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00332-00085760-00085950": "at the launch time international", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00333-00085951-00086182": "conference i am not going to be there", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00334-00086183-00086462": "we'll miss you definitely see them", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00335-00086463-00086703": "online", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00336-00086704-00087055": "lots of love and blessings and all the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00337-00087056-00087238": "people oh yes", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00338-00087239-00087782": "divine wellness for the book and us", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00339-00087783-00088031": "yeah we'll certainly miss you i'm it is", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00340-00088032-00088262": "not very easy to fly international for", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00341-00088263-00088503": "an event uh although we would have loved", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00342-00088504-00088711": "to have you and see you and meet you if", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00343-00088712-00088959": "this was a good opportunity", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00344-00088960-00089182": "so dr alicia do you have", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00345-00089183-00089335": "a what thoughts do you have what do you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00346-00089336-00089471": "think have you read all the chapters in", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00347-00089472-00089671": "the book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00348-00089672-00090238": "most", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00349-00090239-00090511": "is so magnificent i can say that each", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00350-00090512-00090599": "one", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00351-00090600-00090782": "even the youngest", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00352-00090783-00091103": "author has written so well so i feel", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00353-00091104-00091431": "that it has the essence of", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00354-00091432-00091823": "it has the taste of everything in it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00355-00091824-00092031": "a lot of flavors in it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00356-00092032-00092399": "favors all flavors yes i can say that so", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00357-00092400-00092623": "as you had asked me that which area", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00358-00092624-00092911": "impacted this for the all the areas from", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00359-00092912-00093103": "that journey from", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00360-00093104-00093279": "to how the butterfly goes through", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00361-00093280-00093511": "different places so that's how the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00362-00093512-00093687": "leader will feel", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00363-00093688-00093918": "yeah i think the leader will enter the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00364-00093919-00094231": "book as a caterpillar and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00365-00094232-00094438": "by the end of the book will fly out like", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00366-00094439-00094750": "a butterfly colorful one", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00367-00094751-00095031": "own unique butterfly", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00368-00095032-00095135": "yes", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00369-00095136-00095271": "oh beautiful", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00370-00095272-00095471": "the entire thought itself is you know", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00371-00095472-00095694": "visually so appealing", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00372-00095695-00095791": "yes", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00373-00095792-00096135": "yeah i can you visualize that yes", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00374-00096136-00096382": "not so colorful but each one is so", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00375-00096383-00096662": "beautiful it makes the world", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00376-00096663-00096862": "absolutely absolutely", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00377-00096863-00097191": "so you're i'm sure this journey of yours", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00378-00097192-00097359": "is a memorable one", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00379-00097360-00097550": "uh writing and being part of an", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00380-00097551-00097735": "anthropology are you writing a book of", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00381-00097736-00098047": "your own uh your own uh", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00382-00098048-00098326": "you know authoring or", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00383-00098327-00098599": "are you planning something", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00384-00098600-00098926": "right no there is no plan but as i said", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00385-00098927-00099143": "you never know what", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00386-00099144-00100255": "you can you have with it you never know", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00387-00100256-00100487": "so we look forward to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00388-00100488-00100862": "your own uh book your solely yours you", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00389-00100863-00101206": "know dr anuji samaya written on the book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00390-00101207-00101462": "as such as an author and we look forward", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00391-00101463-00101703": "to it and in the meantime", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00392-00101704-00101855": "we are going to enjoy caterpillar to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00393-00101856-00102079": "that butterfly together all of us", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00394-00102080-00102206": "together", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00395-00102207-00102542": "thank you for being with us uh dr anushi", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00396-00102543-00102815": "was lovely listening to you and it's", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00397-00102816-00103006": "amazing to hear about your chapter i'm", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00398-00103007-00103254": "sure people are very very interested and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00399-00103255-00103494": "intrigued about what more does the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00400-00103495-00103702": "chapter have what more does the book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00401-00103703-00103975": "have i'm really happy to be interviewing", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00402-00103976-00104294": "each author here and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00403-00104295-00104454": "it because i have not read all the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00404-00104455-00104599": "chapters i am getting more and more", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00405-00104600-00104815": "interested i have read a couple of them", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00406-00104816-00104966": "here and there", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00407-00104967-00105199": "for whatever purpose editing purposes", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00408-00105200-00105471": "and likewise but i've not read all of it", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00409-00105472-00105678": "and i'm really really excited to hold", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00410-00105679-00105975": "the book in my hand and go through it i", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00411-00105976-00106271": "the caterpillar in me is", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00412-00106272-00106790": "you know ready to become a butterfly", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00413-00106791-00106927": "[Music]", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00414-00106928-00107215": "thank you so much for having me it was", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00415-00107216-00107454": "truly truly", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00416-00107455-00107758": "glad and i'm so excited and happy to be", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00417-00107759-00107910": "here", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00418-00107911-00108158": "as i had started the interview and i'm", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00419-00108159-00108471": "staying filled with that happiness i'm", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00420-00108472-00108583": "so happy", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00421-00108583-00108871": "thank you so much and um guys", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00422-00108872-00109095": "you know by now that you have to grab", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00423-00109096-00109215": "your copy", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00424-00109216-00109439": "by 29th 30th", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00425-00109440-00109695": "30th year it's a three-day event so uh", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00426-00109696-00109943": "it'll probably latest by 38 you should", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00427-00109944-00110134": "be getting the book in hand", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00428-00110135-00110407": "stay tuned to us you will know when and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00429-00110408-00110551": "how and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00430-00110552-00110766": "how you you know you can manage to have", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00431-00110767-00110943": "a copy in your hand but", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00432-00110944-00111127": "make sure that you pick it up on the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00433-00111128-00111278": "first day itself because that's going to", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00434-00111279-00111534": "be the cheapest price ever for it the", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00435-00111535-00111702": "launch price", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00436-00111703-00112086": "all right thank you so much and", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00437-00112088-00112351": "well i hope i'll interview you again", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00438-00112352-00112583": "when you write your own book", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00439-00112583-00112807": "definitely i would love to hear that", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00440-00112808-00112990": "have a good information", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00441-00112991-00113143": "have a great day", "S6MoXPVAFIU-00442-00113144-00113444": "bye"}}, {"audio_id": "S6XV7gXCwLk", "text": {"S6XV7gXCwLk-00000-00000020-00000031": "[Music]", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00001-00000032-00000206": "thecube presents kubecon and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00002-00000208-00000463": "cloudnativecon europe 2022 brought to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00003-00000463-00000630": "you by red hat the cloud native", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00004-00000631-00000839": "computing foundation and its ecosystem", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00005-00000840-00001023": "partners", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00006-00001024-00001399": "welcome to valencia spain", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00007-00001400-00001566": "kubecon", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00008-00001567-00001734": "cloud native con", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00009-00001735-00001910": "europe 2022", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00010-00001911-00002191": "i'm keith townsend your host and we're", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00011-00002192-00002431": "continuing the conversations around", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00012-00002432-00002791": "ecosystem cloud native 7 500 people", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00013-00002792-00002883": "here", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00014-00002884-00003158": "170 plus", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00015-00003159-00003438": "show floor sponsors it is for open", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00016-00003439-00003606": "source conference i think the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00017-00003607-00003990": "destination i might even premise that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00018-00003992-00004135": "this may be", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00019-00004136-00004335": "this may eventually road to the biggest", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00020-00004336-00004551": "tech conference in the industry maybe", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00021-00004552-00004863": "outside of aws re invent", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00022-00004864-00005151": "my next guest is nick van riggen rigoren", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00023-00005152-00005327": "wigarin", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00024-00005328-00005679": "vp engineering of planet scale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00025-00005680-00005822": "nick i'm going to start off the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00026-00005823-00006031": "conversation right off the bat planet", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00027-00006032-00006334": "scale uh cloud native database", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00028-00006335-00006534": "why do we need another database", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00029-00006536-00006678": "well why don't you another database i", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00030-00006679-00006846": "mean are you happy with yours is anyone", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00031-00006847-00006998": "happy with theirs that's a good question", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00032-00007000-00007183": "i don't think anyone's quite happy with", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00033-00007184-00007367": "i don't know i've never seen an excited", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00034-00007368-00007574": "database user except for", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00035-00007575-00007759": "guys with really or gout", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00036-00007759-00007910": "guys with great beers or whatever with", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00037-00007911-00008119": "gray hair or maybe yeah outside of the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00038-00008120-00008287": "dungeon i think no one really is happy", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00039-00008288-00008391": "with their database and that's what", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00040-00008392-00008542": "we're here to change we're not just", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00041-00008543-00008727": "building the database we're actually", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00042-00008728-00008871": "building the whole kind of start to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00043-00008872-00009095": "finish experience so that people can get", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00044-00009096-00009214": "more done", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00045-00009215-00009478": "so what do you mean by getting more done", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00046-00009479-00009623": "because", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00047-00009624-00009846": "my sequel has been the underpinnings of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00048-00009847-00009935": "like", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00049-00009936-00010206": "massive cloud database deployments it", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00050-00010207-00010631": "has been the de facto standard for cloud", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00051-00010632-00010783": "databases", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00052-00010784-00011046": "what is planet scale doing", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00053-00011047-00011303": "and enabling us to do that i can't do", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00054-00011304-00011583": "with something like a mysql or a sql", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00055-00011584-00011814": "server great question so we are mysql", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00056-00011815-00012103": "compatible so under the hood it's a lot", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00057-00012104-00012310": "of them my sql you know and love but on", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00058-00012311-00012527": "top of that we've layered workflows", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00059-00012528-00012783": "we've layered scalability we've layered", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00060-00012784-00012991": "serverless so that you can get all of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00061-00012991-00013151": "the the parts of the mysql that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00062-00013152-00013351": "dependability the thing that people have", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00063-00013352-00013599": "used for 20 30 years right people don't", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00064-00013600-00013799": "even know a world before my sequel but", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00065-00013800-00013991": "then you also get this ability to make", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00066-00013991-00014215": "schema changes faster so you can kind of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00067-00014216-00014383": "do your work quicker get to the business", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00068-00014384-00014630": "objectives faster you can scale farther", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00069-00014631-00014775": "so when you get to your mysql and you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00070-00014776-00014943": "say well you know can we handle adding", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00071-00014944-00015094": "this one feature on top can we handle", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00072-00015095-00015286": "the user growth we've got you don't have", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00073-00015287-00015447": "to worry about that either so it's kind", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00074-00015447-00015599": "of the best of both worlds we've got one", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00075-00015600-00015791": "foot in history and we've got one foot", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00076-00015791-00015966": "in the new kind of cloud native database", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00077-00015968-00016135": "world we want to give everyone the best", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00078-00016136-00016439": "of both so when i think of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00079-00016440-00016622": "serverless because that's the buzz buzzy", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00080-00016623-00016703": "world", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00081-00016704-00016830": "but when i think of serverless i think", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00082-00016831-00016999": "about developers being able to write", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00083-00017000-00017086": "code", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00084-00017087-00017543": "deploy the code not worry about vm sizes", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00085-00017544-00017743": "amount of disk space", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00086-00017744-00018039": "cpu etc but we're talking about", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00087-00018040-00018294": "databases yep i gotta i gotta", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00088-00018295-00018471": "i gotta describe what type of disk i", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00089-00018472-00018686": "wanna use i gotta describe describe the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00090-00018687-00019030": "performance uh levels yep i got all the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00091-00019031-00019183": "descriptive stuff that i have to do", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00092-00019184-00019455": "about infrastructures databases are not", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00093-00019456-00019622": "serverless yep they're the furthest", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00094-00019623-00019855": "thing from it so despite what the name", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00095-00019856-00020063": "may say i can guarantee you planet scale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00096-00020064-00020230": "your planet scale database does run on", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00097-00020231-00020414": "at least one server usually more than", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00098-00020415-00020503": "one", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00099-00020504-00020727": "but the idea is exactly what you said so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00100-00020728-00020943": "especially when you're starting off when", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00101-00020944-00021094": "you're first beginning your let's say", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00102-00021095-00021278": "database journey that's a word i use a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00103-00021279-00021367": "lot", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00104-00021368-00021591": "the furthest thing from your mind is how", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00105-00021592-00021839": "many cpus do i need how many disk ios do", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00106-00021840-00022063": "i need how much memory do i need what we", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00107-00022064-00022214": "want you to be able to do is get started", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00108-00022215-00022383": "on focusing on shipping your code right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00109-00022384-00022558": "the same way that lambda the same way", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00110-00022559-00022711": "that kubernetes and all of these other", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00111-00022712-00022903": "cloud native technologies just help", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00112-00022904-00023047": "people get done what they want to get", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00113-00023048-00023255": "done planet scale is the same way you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00114-00023256-00023422": "want a database you sign up you click", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00115-00023423-00023655": "two buttons you've got a database we'll", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00116-00023656-00023822": "handle scaling the disk as you grow", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00117-00023823-00024063": "we'll handle giving you more resources", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00118-00024064-00024222": "and when you get to a spot where you're", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00119-00024223-00024399": "really starting to think about you know", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00120-00024400-00024535": "my database has got hundreds of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00121-00024536-00024767": "gigabytes or petabytes terabytes that's", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00122-00024768-00024894": "when we'll start to talk to you a little", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00123-00024895-00025022": "bit more about hey you know it really", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00124-00025023-00025207": "does run on a server we can go to help", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00125-00025208-00025375": "you with the capacity planning but", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00126-00025376-00025511": "there's no reason people should have to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00127-00025512-00025767": "do that up front i mean that stinks when", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00128-00025768-00025878": "you want to use a database you want to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00129-00025879-00026070": "use a database you don't want to use a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00130-00026072-00026439": "you know a 747 with 27 different knobs", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00131-00026439-00026646": "you just want to get going so also when", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00132-00026647-00027014": "i think of serverless and cloud native i", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00133-00027016-00027318": "think of stateless yep now", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00134-00027319-00027599": "they're stateless with databases help me", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00135-00027600-00027774": "reconcile like", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00136-00027775-00027967": "when you say it's cloud native yep how", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00137-00027968-00028127": "is it cloud native when i think of cloud", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00138-00028127-00028383": "native space yeah so it's cloud native", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00139-00028383-00028535": "because it exists where you want it in", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00140-00028536-00028711": "the cloud right no matter where you've", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00141-00028712-00028879": "deployed your application", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00142-00028880-00029079": "on your own cloud on a public cloud or", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00143-00029080-00029287": "something like that our job is to meet", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00144-00029288-00029574": "you and match the same level of velocity", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00145-00029575-00029718": "and the same level of change that you've", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00146-00029719-00029902": "got on your kind of cloud native setup", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00147-00029904-00030095": "so there's a lot of state right we are", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00148-00030095-00030207": "your state", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00149-00030208-00030423": "and that's a big responsibility and so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00150-00030424-00030599": "what we want to do is we want to let you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00151-00030600-00030727": "experiment with the rest of the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00152-00030727-00030943": "stateless workloads and be right there", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00153-00030944-00031095": "next to you so that you can kind of get", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00154-00031095-00031279": "done what you need to get done all right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00155-00031280-00031535": "so this con concept of clicking two", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00156-00031536-00031751": "buttons yeah deploying", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00157-00031752-00031935": "it's a database yep", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00158-00031936-00032167": "it has to run somewhere so let's say", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00159-00032168-00032583": "that i'm in aws i have aws vpc", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00160-00032583-00032767": "what does it look like from a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00161-00032768-00033079": "developer's perspective to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00162-00033080-00033295": "consume the server yes so we've got a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00163-00033296-00033487": "couple different offerings", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00164-00033488-00033711": "aws is a great example so at the very", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00165-00033712-00033967": "kind of um the most basic database unit", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00166-00033968-00034174": "you click you get an endpoint a host", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00167-00034175-00034374": "name a password in the username you feed", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00168-00034375-00034518": "that right into your application and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00169-00034519-00034799": "it's tls secure and stuff like that goes", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00170-00034800-00034990": "right into the database no problem as", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00171-00034991-00035159": "you grow larger and larger we can use", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00172-00035160-00035367": "things like aws private link and stuff", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00173-00035368-00035543": "like that to actually start to integrate", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00174-00035544-00035799": "more with your aws environment all the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00175-00035800-00035999": "way over to what we call planet scale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00176-00036000-00036199": "managed which is where we actually", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00177-00036200-00036415": "deploy your data plane in your aws", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00178-00036416-00036639": "account so you give us some permissions", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00179-00036640-00036823": "and we kind of you know create a sub", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00180-00036824-00036974": "account and stuff like that and we can", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00181-00036975-00037174": "actually start sending pods and whole", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00182-00037175-00037383": "clusters and stuff like that into your", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00183-00037384-00037630": "aws account give you a private link so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00184-00037631-00037743": "that everything looks like it's kind of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00185-00037744-00037918": "wrapped up in your ownership but you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00186-00037919-00038071": "still get the same kind of planet scale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00187-00038072-00038287": "cloud experience cloud native experience", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00188-00038288-00038543": "so how do i make calls to the database", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00189-00038544-00038639": "so i mean", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00190-00038640-00038767": "do i", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00191-00038768-00038959": "do i have to install a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00192-00038960-00039046": "new", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00193-00039047-00039174": "great question", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00194-00039175-00039527": "like agent or or uh do some weird sql", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00195-00039528-00039679": "configuration yeah am i in i like it", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00196-00039680-00039823": "what's the experience nope we just speak", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00197-00039824-00040030": "my sequel same way you'd go uh you know", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00198-00040031-00040199": "brew install my sql if you're on a mac", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00199-00040200-00040415": "or app to get install my sql on a on a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00200-00040416-00040679": "linux pc you just username password", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00201-00040680-00040855": "database name and stuff like that you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00202-00040856-00040967": "feed that into your app and it just", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00203-00040968-00041207": "works all right so databases are", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00204-00041208-00041399": "typically", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00205-00041400-00041558": "security", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00206-00041559-00041879": "when when my security person sees a new", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00207-00041880-00042046": "database oh they get excited they're", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00208-00042047-00042262": "like oh my god they do my job just got", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00209-00042263-00042518": "real easy i can find like eight or nine", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00210-00042519-00042743": "findings how do you help me with", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00211-00042744-00042967": "compliance yeah and uh answering these", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00212-00042968-00043143": "tough security questions from security", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00213-00043144-00043318": "great question so security's at the core", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00214-00043319-00043479": "of what we do right we've got security", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00215-00043480-00043687": "people ourselves we do the same thing", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00216-00043688-00043871": "for all the new vendors that we on board", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00217-00043872-00044143": "so we invest a lot for example the only", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00218-00044144-00044287": "way you can connect to a planet scale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00219-00044288-00044455": "database even if you're using private", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00220-00044456-00044583": "link even if you're not touching the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00221-00044584-00044839": "public internet at all is over uh tls", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00222-00044840-00045046": "secured endpoint right from the very", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00223-00045047-00045230": "first day the very first beta that we", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00224-00045231-00045455": "had we knew not a single byte goes over", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00225-00045456-00045655": "the internet that's not encrypted it's", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00226-00045656-00045943": "encrypted at rest we have audit logging", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00227-00045944-00046143": "we do a ton internally as well to make", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00228-00046144-00046302": "sure that you know what's happening to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00229-00046303-00046439": "your database is something you can find", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00230-00046440-00046639": "out the favorite thing that i think", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00231-00046640-00046823": "though is all your schema changes are", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00232-00046824-00047030": "tracked on planet scale because we", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00233-00047031-00047207": "provide an entire workflow for your", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00234-00047208-00047390": "schema changes we actually have you know", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00235-00047391-00047607": "like a github pull request style thing", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00236-00047608-00047743": "your security folks can actually look", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00237-00047744-00047886": "and say what changes were made to the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00238-00047887-00048102": "database day in day out they can go back", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00239-00048103-00048311": "and there's a full history of that log", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00240-00048312-00048479": "so you actually have i think better", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00241-00048480-00048630": "security than a lot of other databases", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00242-00048631-00048735": "where you know you've got to build all", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00243-00048736-00048935": "these tools and stuff like that it's all", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00244-00048936-00049151": "built into planet scale so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00245-00049152-00049367": "you we we started out the conversation", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00246-00049368-00049527": "with two clicks", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00247-00049528-00049823": "but i'm a developer and i'm developing a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00248-00049824-00050071": "service at scale yep i want to have a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00249-00050072-00050286": "sas offering how do i automate the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00250-00050287-00050479": "deployment of the database in the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00251-00050480-00050655": "management of the database across", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00252-00050656-00050830": "multiple customers yeah so everything's", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00253-00050831-00051086": "api driven uh we've got a you know an", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00254-00051087-00051207": "api that you can use supervision", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00255-00051208-00051430": "databases to make schema changes to make", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00256-00051432-00051550": "you know whatever changes you want to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00257-00051551-00051750": "that database we have an api that powers", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00258-00051751-00051975": "our website the same api that customers", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00259-00051976-00052119": "can use to kind of automate any part of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00260-00052120-00052270": "the workflow that they want there's", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00261-00052271-00052430": "actually someone who did a talk earlier", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00262-00052432-00052687": "using i think crossplane.io where they", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00263-00052688-00052847": "can use kubernetes custom resource", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00264-00052848-00053063": "definitions to provision planet scale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00265-00053064-00053271": "databases completely automatically so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00266-00053272-00053391": "you can even do it as part of your", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00267-00053391-00053599": "standard deployment workflow just create", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00268-00053600-00053735": "a planet scale database create a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00269-00053736-00053935": "password inject it in your app", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00270-00053936-00054166": "all automatically so nick as i'm", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00271-00054167-00054415": "thinking about", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00272-00054416-00054654": "scale yep i'm thinking about multiple", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00273-00054655-00054950": "customers i have a successful product", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00274-00054951-00055126": "yep and now these customers are coming", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00275-00055127-00055311": "to me with different requirements one", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00276-00055312-00055519": "customer wants to upgrade", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00277-00055520-00055750": "once every quarter another one it's like", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00278-00055751-00055894": "you know what just bring it on", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00279-00055895-00056087": "bring the schema changes on yeah i want", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00280-00056088-00056359": "the latest features etc how do i manage", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00281-00056360-00056559": "that with planet scale when i'm thinking", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00282-00056560-00056838": "about my sequels a little that can be a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00283-00056839-00056999": "little difficult yeah but how does", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00284-00057000-00057182": "planet scale help me solve that problem", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00285-00057183-00057342": "yeah so again i think it's that same", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00286-00057344-00057511": "workflow engine that we've built so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00287-00057512-00057726": "every database has its own kind of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00288-00057727-00058030": "deploy queue its own migration system so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00289-00058032-00058199": "you can automate all these processes and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00290-00058200-00058407": "say on this database you know i want to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00291-00058408-00058559": "change this schema this way on this", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00292-00058560-00058742": "database i'm going to hold off you can", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00293-00058744-00058950": "use our api to drive a view into like", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00294-00058951-00059119": "well what's the schema in this database", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00295-00059120-00059311": "what's the schema on this database what", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00296-00059312-00059471": "version am i running on this database", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00297-00059472-00059623": "and you can actually bring all that in", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00298-00059624-00059766": "and if you were you know really", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00299-00059767-00059903": "successful you'd have this single pane", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00300-00059904-00060063": "of glass where you can see what's the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00301-00060064-00060230": "status of all my databases and how are", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00302-00060232-00060391": "they doing all powered by kind of the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00303-00060391-00060679": "planet scale api so we can't talk about", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00304-00060679-00060911": "databases without talking about backup", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00305-00060912-00060999": "and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00306-00061000-00061254": "and recovery yep how do i back this", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00307-00061255-00061463": "thing up and make sure that i can fall", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00308-00061464-00061782": "back i've i someone deleted a table it", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00309-00061783-00061999": "happens all the time 100 percent how do", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00310-00062000-00062191": "i recover from so there's two pieces of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00311-00062191-00062303": "this and i'm going to talk about two", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00312-00062304-00062415": "different ways that we can help you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00313-00062416-00062623": "solve this problem one of them is every", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00314-00062624-00062791": "planet scale database comes with backups", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00315-00062791-00062999": "built in and we test them fairly often", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00316-00063000-00063199": "right we use these backups we actually", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00317-00063200-00063399": "give you a free daily backup on every", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00318-00063400-00063599": "database because it's important to us as", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00319-00063600-00063791": "well we want to be able to restore from", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00320-00063791-00063919": "backup we want to be able to do", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00321-00063920-00064142": "failovers and stuff like that all that's", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00322-00064144-00064326": "handled automatically the other thing", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00323-00064327-00064463": "though is this feature that we launched", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00324-00064464-00064711": "in march called planet scale rewind and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00325-00064712-00064894": "what rewind is is actually a schema", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00326-00064895-00065150": "migration undo button so let's say you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00327-00065151-00065319": "know you're you're a developer you're", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00328-00065320-00065535": "dropping a table or a column you you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00329-00065536-00065743": "mean to drop this but you drop the other", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00330-00065744-00065943": "one on accident or you thought this", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00331-00065944-00066167": "column was unused but it wasn't", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00332-00066168-00066335": "you know when you you do something wrong", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00333-00066336-00066471": "you know you cause an incident you get", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00334-00066472-00066647": "that sick feeling in your stomach okay", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00335-00066648-00066735": "you know", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00336-00066736-00066935": "i've pulled a drive that was written not", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00337-00066936-00067206": "rate five exactly and you kind of start", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00338-00067207-00067391": "to go oh man what am i going to do next", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00339-00067392-00067550": "you know everyone watching this right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00340-00067551-00067679": "now is probably squirming in their seat", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00341-00067680-00067855": "a bit you know the feeling yeah i know", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00342-00067856-00068015": "the feeling um well planet scale gives", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00343-00068016-00068271": "you an undo button so you can click uh", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00344-00068272-00068463": "undo migration for 30 minutes after you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00345-00068464-00068655": "do the migration and we'll revert your", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00346-00068656-00068871": "schema with all the data in it back to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00347-00068872-00069055": "what your database looked like before", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00348-00069056-00069271": "you did that migration drop a column on", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00349-00069272-00069479": "accident drop a table on accident click", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00350-00069480-00069647": "the rewind button there's all the data", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00351-00069648-00069759": "there and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00352-00069760-00069903": "the new rights that you've taken while", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00353-00069904-00070055": "that's happened are there as well so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00354-00070056-00070175": "it's not just a restore to a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00355-00070176-00070382": "point-in-time backup it's actually that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00356-00070383-00070623": "we've replicated your rights sent them", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00357-00070624-00070806": "to both the old and the new schema and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00358-00070807-00070943": "we can get you right back to where you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00359-00070944-00071215": "started downtime solved so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00360-00071216-00071479": "go ahead dbas are dbas whether they've", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00361-00071480-00071791": "become now reformed dbas that are cloud", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00362-00071792-00072055": "architects but they're dbas so there's a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00363-00072056-00072191": "couple of things that they're going to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00364-00072192-00072326": "want to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00365-00072327-00072623": "know one how do i get my zero backup in", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00366-00072624-00072950": "my hands i want my i want my my is a my", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00367-00072951-00073182": "sequel data i want my my sequel back up", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00368-00073183-00073335": "yeah so you could just take backups off", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00369-00073336-00073503": "the database yourself the same way that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00370-00073504-00073735": "uh you're doing today right my sql dump", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00371-00073736-00073911": "my sql backup and all of those kinds of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00372-00073912-00074094": "things if you don't trust planet scale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00373-00074095-00074311": "and look i'm all about backups right you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00374-00074312-00074511": "want them in two different data centers", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00375-00074512-00074662": "on different mediums", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00376-00074663-00074815": "you can just add on your own backup", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00377-00074816-00074967": "tools that you have right now and also", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00378-00074968-00075062": "use that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00379-00075063-00075215": "i'd like you to trust that planetscale", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00380-00075216-00075367": "has the backups as well but you know if", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00381-00075368-00075494": "you want to keep doing that and run your", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00382-00075495-00075687": "own system we're totally cool with that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00383-00075688-00075855": "as well in fact i'd go as far as to say", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00384-00075856-00076023": "i recommend it uh you never have too", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00385-00076024-00076223": "many backups so in a moment we're going", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00386-00076224-00076423": "to run cubeclock so get get you know get", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00387-00076424-00076615": "your uh all right get you know all right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00388-00076616-00076735": "stand tall", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00389-00076736-00076919": "i'll get ready you know i'm tall i'm", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00390-00076920-00077167": "tall we're both tall", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00391-00077168-00077382": "the last question before", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00392-00077383-00077655": "keep clock is", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00393-00077656-00077871": "let's talk a little nerve knobs okay the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00394-00077872-00078103": "reform dba yeah", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00395-00078104-00078359": "they want they're they're like oh this", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00396-00078360-00078679": "this this uh curie ran a little bit slow", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00397-00078680-00078903": "i know i can squeeze a little bit more", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00398-00078904-00079150": "out of that who do they talk to yeah so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00399-00079151-00079311": "that's a great question so we provide", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00400-00079312-00079487": "you some insights on the product itself", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00401-00079488-00079638": "right so you can take a look and see how", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00402-00079639-00079847": "are my queries performing and stuff like", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00403-00079848-00079926": "that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00404-00079927-00080150": "our goal our job is to surface to you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00405-00080151-00080287": "all the metrics that you need to make", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00406-00080288-00080415": "that decision because at the end of the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00407-00080416-00080487": "day", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00408-00080488-00080750": "uh reform dba or not it is still a skill", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00409-00080751-00080926": "to analyze the performance of a mysql", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00410-00080927-00081159": "query run and explain you know kind of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00411-00081160-00081350": "figure all that out we can't do all of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00412-00081351-00081535": "that for you so we want to give you the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00413-00081536-00081823": "information you need either knowledge or", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00414-00081824-00081982": "or you know", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00415-00081983-00082159": "stuff to learn whatever it is because", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00416-00082160-00082367": "some of it does have to come back to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00417-00082368-00082550": "what's my schema what's my query and how", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00418-00082551-00082711": "can i optimize and i'm missing an index", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00419-00082712-00082847": "and stuff like that", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00420-00082848-00083071": "all right so", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00421-00083072-00083359": "you're early adopter of", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00422-00083360-00083679": "the cube clock okay", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00423-00083680-00083815": "i have to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00424-00083816-00084103": "people say they're ready oh okay all the", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00425-00084104-00084326": "time people say they're ready but i'm", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00426-00084327-00084582": "not quite sure that they're ready so are", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00427-00084583-00084718": "you ready", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00428-00084719-00084935": "do i have any other choice", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00429-00084936-00085006": "no", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00430-00085007-00085191": "you don't then i am", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00431-00085192-00085415": "but are you ready sure let's go", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00432-00085416-00085559": "all right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00433-00085560-00085815": "start the cube clock", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00434-00085816-00085991": "all right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00435-00085992-00086247": "what do you want me to do", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00436-00086248-00086375": "go all right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00437-00086376-00086494": "you're saying you were ready i'm ready", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00438-00086495-00086623": "all right i'm ready all right okay i'll", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00439-00086624-00086782": "reach i'll get you i'll get see people", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00440-00086783-00086926": "are saying they're ready you're right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00441-00086927-00087159": "you're right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00442-00087160-00087271": "but", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00443-00087272-00087503": "start the cute plaque okay are you happy", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00444-00087504-00087679": "with how your database works are you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00445-00087680-00087855": "happy with the velocity are you happy", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00446-00087856-00088038": "with what your engineers and what your", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00447-00088039-00088231": "teams can do with their database follow", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00448-00088232-00088471": "the dream not the twelve you gotta agree", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00449-00088472-00088662": "not to dream you gotta be able to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00450-00088663-00088847": "deliver at the end of the day you gotta", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00451-00088848-00089031": "deliver what the business wants it's not", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00452-00089032-00089703": "about getting it all be", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00453-00089704-00089838": "it's not just about foreign my query", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00454-00089839-00089975": "right it's about are my customers", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00455-00089976-00090111": "getting what they want you're here you", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00456-00090112-00090294": "deserve receipt and that's and that's", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00457-00090295-00090479": "that's what credit scale provides right", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00458-00090480-00090647": "plan", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00459-00090648-00090806": "planet scale is a tool for getting done", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00460-00090807-00090943": "what you need to get done as a business", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00461-00090944-00091118": "that's what we're here for ultimately we", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00462-00091119-00091279": "want to be the best database for", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00463-00091280-00091479": "developing software too", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00464-00091480-00091662": "that's it end of day nick you took a", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00465-00091663-00091806": "shot", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00466-00091807-00091982": "i'm buying it", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00467-00091983-00092126": "great job", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00468-00092127-00092343": "you know this is fun", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00469-00092344-00092667": "our jobs are complex yep", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00470-00092668-00093023": "databases are hard yep it is", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00471-00093024-00093326": "the where your organization keeps", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00472-00093327-00093606": "the most valuable assets that you have", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00473-00093607-00093918": "100 and we are having these tough", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00474-00093919-00094231": "conversations here in valencia", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00475-00094232-00094399": "you're talking to", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00476-00094400-00094623": "the leader in tech coverage from", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00477-00094624-00094862": "valencia spain i'm keith townsend and", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00478-00094863-00095094": "you're watching thecube", "S6XV7gXCwLk-00479-00095095-00095580": "the leader in high-tech coverage"}}, {"audio_id": "S6ZjYeyv2TQ", "text": {"S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00000-00000048-00000262": "so far we've been talking about trees", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00001-00000263-00000424": "that are involved in classification", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00002-00000425-00000647": "either crisp classification or", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00003-00000648-00000899": "probabilistic classification but there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00004-00000900-00001108": "is a whole other class of trees called", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00005-00001109-00001487": "regression trees that allow us to Output", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00006-00001488-00001751": "not a class but some sort of Contin", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00007-00001752-00001967": "continuous value", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00008-00001968-00002242": "so the most common form of a regression", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00009-00002243-00002633": "tree is one that outputs a constant", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00010-00002634-00002879": "value for any sample that falls down", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00011-00002880-00003071": "into a particular leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00012-00003072-00003293": "so what this ends up giving us is a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00013-00003294-00003629": "piecewise constant function defined over", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00014-00003629-00003881": "the feature space the more General case", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00015-00003882-00004181": "we can actually put a function over the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00016-00004182-00004445": "full feature Vector in each of the leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00017-00004446-00004697": "nodes so so each Leaf node gets its own", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00018-00004698-00005009": "function that gets learned this allows", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00019-00005010-00005302": "us to have a much more expressive type", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00020-00005303-00005615": "of function as compared to say the same", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00021-00005616-00005827": "form of function defined over the entire", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00022-00005828-00006125": "feature space but it does give us a lot", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00023-00006126-00006484": "more complexity so let's look at a bit", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00024-00006486-00006910": "of the math around regression trees at", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00025-00006911-00007120": "least the simple form and then we'll do", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00026-00007122-00007534": "a simple example in drawing form", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00027-00007536-00007775": "just as with our other regression", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00028-00007776-00008033": "approaches we still have a training set", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00029-00008034-00008285": "that's composed of pairs of samples so", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00030-00008286-00008824": "we have a set XJ and that is associated", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00031-00008825-00009053": "with some sort of an output value here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00032-00009054-00009196": "we're just going to focus on the scalar", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00033-00009197-00009467": "form of this of course y could be a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00034-00009468-00009635": "vector in and of itself", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00035-00009636-00009778": "so we're going to measure the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00036-00009779-00009881": "performance", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00037-00009882-00010199": "of our regression tree just as we have", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00038-00010200-00010624": "with our other approaches", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00039-00010625-00010937": "using mean squared error", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00040-00010938-00011135": "so that's just our", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00041-00011136-00011453": "sum of our Js", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00042-00011454-00011819": "and there are M of those", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00043-00011820-00012160": "and it's a difference between our true", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00044-00012161-00012670": "label and the the uh the value that is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00045-00012671-00012808": "output by", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00046-00012809-00013007": "our regression tree so that's what this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00047-00013008-00013271": "y hat is here okay before we take this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00048-00013272-00013522": "further let's look at what a decision", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00049-00013523-00013925": "tree actually does here so so as we've", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00050-00013926-00014147": "already discussed we we started some", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00051-00014147-00014429": "sort of a root node below that is a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00052-00014430-00014825": "question node that brings us to a set of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00053-00014826-00014951": "branches", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00054-00014952-00015191": "which each have their own potentially", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00055-00015191-00015479": "their own question nodes and and on down", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00056-00015480-00015736": "the line and ultimately there's down at", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00057-00015737-00015953": "the bottom here there's a set of leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00058-00015954-00016108": "nodes", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00059-00016109-00016300": "I'm going to refer to this one as Leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00060-00016301-00016477": "zero", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00061-00016478-00016799": "and uh this is leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00062-00016800-00016967": "Leaf one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00063-00016968-00017194": "so those two are right next to each", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00064-00017195-00017375": "other", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00065-00017376-00017663": "somewhere along the line there's a a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00066-00017664-00018017": "leaf I'm going to use little K for to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00067-00018018-00018191": "uh indicate", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00068-00018192-00018467": "this leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00069-00018468-00018958": "and then in the far right hand side", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00070-00018959-00019144": "there's another Leaf node here they", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00071-00019145-00019343": "don't all have to be at the same depth I", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00072-00019344-00019483": "just happen to be drawing them that way", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00073-00019484-00019877": "I'm going to call this one leaf Big K", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00074-00019878-00020069": "and hopefully that's clear the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00075-00020070-00020213": "difference between the little K and the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00076-00020214-00020441": "Big K actually that's a big K minus one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00077-00020442-00020867": "so we have a total of Big K leaves now", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00078-00020868-00021064": "if we take our training set", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00079-00021065-00021299": "a particular training sample it's it's", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00080-00021300-00021599": "going to wind its way down this tree and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00081-00021600-00021833": "ultimately end up at some leaf and then", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00082-00021834-00022055": "another training sample might end up", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00083-00022056-00022307": "coming down to leaf k and some other one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00084-00022308-00022528": "might find its way down to the the one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00085-00022529-00022805": "on the very far uh right hand side", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00086-00022806-00023194": "so so in some sense our our tree is uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00087-00023195-00023447": "sorting all of the the samples in our", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00088-00023448-00023675": "training set into this these distinct", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00089-00023676-00023783": "leaves", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00090-00023784-00024007": "so so I'm going to introduce another", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00091-00024008-00024407": "symbol here I'm going to refer to I'm", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00092-00024408-00024857": "going to refer to the set of all samples", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00093-00024858-00025169": "that fall into Leaf zero as Big L zero", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00094-00025170-00025463": "and uh here L1", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00095-00025464-00026056": "L little K and this is L Big K minus one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00096-00026057-00026512": "so this is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00097-00026513-00026795": "uh all", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00098-00026795-00027964": "XJ that", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00099-00027966-00028540": "okay so so big L1 is uh the set of all", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00100-00028541-00028835": "XJ that fall into Leaf number one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00101-00028836-00029140": "it's a set so we can we can also measure", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00102-00029141-00029345": "the size of this set", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00103-00029345-00029987": "so this is equal to the number of xjs", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00104-00029988-00030214": "that fall into", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00105-00030216-00030790": "this leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00106-00030791-00030964": "all right so with this sorting what", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00107-00030966-00031090": "we're going to do is separate the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00108-00031091-00031402": "elements of this sum into individual", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00109-00031404-00031667": "sums one for each of our Leaf nodes", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00110-00031668-00031937": "actually I'm going to come down", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00111-00031938-00032105": "come down here where I have a little bit", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00112-00032106-00032212": "more space", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00113-00032213-00032729": "so so this is equal to a sum over all of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00114-00032730-00033089": "our Leaf nodes so it's little K", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00115-00033090-00033461": "going from zero to Big K minus one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00116-00033462-00033851": "and then within that leaf node there is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00117-00033852-00034145": "a set of samples within that leaf node", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00118-00034146-00034324": "we're going to sum over those", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00119-00034325-00034583": "and the way I'm going to designate that", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00120-00034584-00035140": "is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00121-00035141-00035452": "is J is a member of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00122-00035453-00035861": "of L little K so we're going to sum over", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00123-00035862-00036173": "all of the the JS that are in the cake", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00124-00036174-00036311": "leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00125-00036312-00036593": "and then we still have our y j minus our", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00126-00036594-00036809": "y j hat", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00127-00036810-00036965": "squared", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00128-00036966-00037259": "we haven't changed our mean squared", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00129-00037260-00037517": "error we've just reorganized this set of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00130-00037518-00037757": "sums we've split them up into the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00131-00037758-00037955": "individual Leaf nodes and then taken a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00132-00037956-00038261": "sum over over all the elements within", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00133-00038262-00038524": "that leaf node okay so let's clean this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00134-00038525-00038801": "decision tree up just a little bit", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00135-00038802-00039017": "let me now introduce uh the function", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00136-00039018-00039190": "that we're going to represent in each of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00137-00039191-00039496": "our Leaf nodes as I said before we're", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00138-00039497-00039845": "going to capture the simplest form so so", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00139-00039846-00040139": "we're going to just introduce a simple", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00140-00040140-00040480": "constant", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00141-00040481-00040793": "so this is going to be c0 this one will", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00142-00040794-00041429": "be C1 this is C", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00143-00041430-00041899": "C little K and this is C Big K minus one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00144-00041900-00042317": "and what I mean by this is that if a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00145-00042318-00042629": "sample does indeed fall down into this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00146-00042630-00042857": "Leaf node then what our regression tree", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00147-00042858-00043096": "is going to do is output this continuous", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00148-00043097-00043555": "value of C1 or if uh some other", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00149-00043556-00044002": "element x j falls down into Leaf little", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00150-00044003-00044380": "K then the regression tree is going to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00151-00044381-00044645": "Output this constant C little K so when", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00152-00044646-00044927": "we when we consider things in this way", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00153-00044928-00045340": "we can we can replace this element here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00154-00045341-00045515": "with", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00155-00045516-00045718": "the value that we're actually predicting", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00156-00045719-00046468": "so let me rewrite this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00157-00046469-00046690": "so this is again is the sum over all the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00158-00046691-00046918": "leaf nodes and then we're going to take", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00159-00046919-00047152": "a sum over all the elements in the the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00160-00047153-00047452": "leaf node", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00161-00047453-00048073": "and that's y j minus C little K", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00162-00048074-00048485": "all right so with this form of our cost", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00163-00048486-00048799": "function we can actually then talk about", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00164-00048800-00049108": "what is the right choice for all of our", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00165-00049109-00049415": "C K's so so we're assuming here that we", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00166-00049416-00049571": "have a particular", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00167-00049572-00049865": "tree structure already in place we've", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00168-00049866-00050027": "sorted all of our training set elements", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00169-00050028-00050374": "into our Leaf nodes and and now we can", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00170-00050375-00050783": "ask how best to choose the cks and the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00171-00050784-00051035": "answer to that is is we're going to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00172-00051036-00051364": "choose our CK", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00173-00051365-00052344": "in this way", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00174-00052345-00052697": "okay so so we're taking a sum it should", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00175-00052698-00052859": "be a little bit more precise about that", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00176-00052860-00053419": "sum there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00177-00053420-00053903": "shaking a sum over all of the JS in LK", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00178-00053904-00054082": "of the Y's", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00179-00054083-00054287": "and then we're dividing it by the number", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00180-00054288-00054616": "of elements that we have in this set and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00181-00054617-00054769": "and this is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00182-00054770-00054976": "hopefully you recognize that this is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00183-00054977-00055241": "just the average", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00184-00055241-00055711": "uh YJ", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00185-00055712-00056626": "uh in leaf k", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00186-00056627-00056885": "so so that's that's the answer", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00187-00056886-00057244": "for those of you who want to do the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00188-00057245-00057521": "derivation let me show you what the uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00189-00057522-00057911": "the path is if you imagine uh taking our", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00190-00057912-00058276": "MSE and Computing the derivative of MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00191-00058277-00058549": "partial derivative with respect to some", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00192-00058550-00058763": "c k", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00193-00058764-00059165": "and if you set that to zero", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00194-00059166-00059519": "and and then solve for CK then you you", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00195-00059520-00059866": "end up with this solution over here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00196-00059867-00060149": "so I I encourage you to to give that a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00197-00060150-00060366": "shot all right given that background", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00198-00060367-00060761": "let's consider a uh what happens when we", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00199-00060762-00061109": "try to introduce a new split to a tree", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00200-00061110-00061979": "so the uh scenario is I have already", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00201-00061979-00062392": "some some particular Leaf node", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00202-00062394-00062866": "and I'm going to define the mean squared", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00203-00062867-00063179": "error for this Leaf node as being equal", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00204-00063179-00063400": "to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00205-00063401-00063761": "the average error of those things that", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00206-00063762-00064085": "have fallen down into the leaf node", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00207-00064086-00065873": "that's a little K there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00208-00065874-00066155": "and now we're imagining", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00209-00066156-00066467": "transitioning to taking this Leaf node", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00210-00066468-00066731": "and expanding it out so we still have", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00211-00066732-00066899": "some number of things that are coming", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00212-00066900-00067144": "down some number of items in their", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00213-00067145-00067319": "training set coming down this particular", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00214-00067320-00067511": "link but now we're introducing a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00215-00067512-00067931": "question of of some form that produces", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00216-00067932-00068249": "in the binary tree case two branches and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00217-00068250-00068429": "two other Leaf nodes", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00218-00068430-00068644": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00219-00068645-00068909": "so over here on the left hand side we", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00220-00068910-00069029": "had l", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00221-00069030-00069263": "K things that have fallen down into this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00222-00069264-00069503": "Leaf node we're going to designate the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00223-00069504-00069635": "things that have fallen into the left", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00224-00069636-00070055": "Leaf node as l k Prime and the things", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00225-00070056-00070355": "that have fallen down into the right", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00226-00070356-00070649": "hand side as LK double Prime", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00227-00070650-00071026": "and the the uh the intersection of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00228-00071027-00071309": "course of of these two sets here is is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00229-00071310-00071549": "the null set because every sample has to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00230-00071550-00071794": "fall to the left or to the right and the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00231-00071795-00072287": "union is equal to our LK over here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00232-00072288-00072629": "so let's start with our mean squared", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00233-00072630-00072832": "error", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00234-00072833-00073038": "definition for", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00235-00073039-00073379": "element K here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00236-00073380-00073673": "and I'm this is going to evolve a little", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00237-00073674-00073871": "bit so I'm going to add a little hat", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00238-00073872-00074188": "here but that again is equal to what we", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00239-00074189-00074279": "have", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00240-00074280-00074488": "over here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00241-00074489-00074693": "okay so so these these two cost", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00242-00074694-00074915": "functions are identical what we're going", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00243-00074916-00075400": "to do is split this particular sum into", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00244-00075401-00075779": "the constituent Parts the K Prime and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00245-00075780-00076132": "the K double Prime parts so I'm going to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00246-00076133-00076379": "leave myself some room here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00247-00076380-00076721": "so that is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00248-00076722-00076961": "equal to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00249-00076962-00077188": "we still have our one over", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00250-00077189-00077623": "size of LK", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00251-00077624-00078106": "and it's going to be now a sum over all", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00252-00078107-00078659": "of the elements in l k Prime", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00253-00078660-00078844": "YJ", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00254-00078845-00079265": "and this is now c k Prime so we have a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00255-00079266-00079476": "CK Prime now here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00256-00079477-00079882": "nsck double Prime and we had a CK over", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00257-00079883-00080675": "in our original model", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00258-00080676-00080962": "and then we also have to take the sum", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00259-00080963-00081215": "over the elements on the on the right", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00260-00081216-00081943": "hand side", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00261-00081944-00082679": "and there's a squared element there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00262-00082680-00082879": "okay so if", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00263-00082880-00083303": "CK if CK Prime and CK double Prime if", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00264-00083304-00083575": "those are exactly the same value then", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00265-00083576-00083932": "this total sum here collapses back down", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00266-00083933-00084394": "to this sum here we're now talking about", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00267-00084395-00084661": "what our error is now that we've added", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00268-00084662-00085393": "this uh this new pair of leaf nodes", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00269-00085394-00085606": "all right I'm I'm just going to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00270-00085607-00085991": "reorganize this just a little bit", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00271-00085992-00086771": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00272-00086772-00087079": "and I'm going to multiply this sum here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00273-00087080-00087473": "by 1.", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00274-00087474-00087605": "and I'm going to write it in a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00275-00087606-00087875": "particular way here but hopefully it's", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00276-00087876-00088447": "obvious where I'm going with this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00277-00088448-00089555": "and then we have our sum", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00278-00089556-00089800": "and then there's the other piece for", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00279-00089801-00089975": "which I'm running out of room", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00280-00089976-00090299": "so this is LK double Prime", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00281-00090300-00090509": "times 1 over", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00282-00090510-00091768": "l k double Prime size", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00283-00091769-00091955": "there's a squared there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00284-00091956-00092231": "Okay so", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00285-00092232-00092555": "so the motivation for doing this is now", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00286-00092556-00092944": "uh is that sorry this piece right here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00287-00092945-00093203": "if we stare at that that is just the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00288-00093204-00093455": "mean squared error prediction error for", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00289-00093456-00093850": "all the elements in l k Prime and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00290-00093851-00094055": "likewise this piece right here is our", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00291-00094056-00094271": "mean squared error for all of the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00292-00094272-00094906": "elements in in L Double K double Prime", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00293-00094907-00095159": "so let me let me go ahead and rewrite", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00294-00095160-00095309": "things", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00295-00095310-00095525": "so this is 1 over", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00296-00095526-00095962": "okay", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00297-00095963-00096268": "and inside we have", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00298-00096269-00096515": "size of LK Prime", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00299-00096516-00096941": "times the MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00300-00096942-00097132": "of K Prime", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00301-00097133-00097793": "and size of LK double Prime Times MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00302-00097794-00097973": "of K double Prime", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00303-00097974-00098123": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00304-00098124-00098399": "and then the last step uh is to just", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00305-00098400-00098729": "push this uh inside", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00306-00098730-00098993": "and I'm just going to modify the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00307-00098994-00099238": "equation to to reflect that rather than", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00308-00099239-00100391": "rewriting", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00309-00100392-00100685": "okay so so our new MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00310-00100686-00100979": "that we started with up here it can be", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00311-00100980-00101344": "expressed as a weighted sum of the mses", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00312-00101345-00101555": "of the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00313-00101556-00101909": "uh the the two new Leaf nodes so there's", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00314-00101910-00102167": "there's this MSE and there's the the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00315-00102168-00102713": "other one there uh the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00316-00102714-00103144": "the sum of these two here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00317-00103145-00103408": "uh if you work that out the sum of those", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00318-00103409-00103673": "two is one so it is literally a weighted", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00319-00103674-00104273": "average of the two mean squared errors", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00320-00104274-00104525": "okay so so now let's", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00321-00104526-00104806": "Let's uh talk about what is our", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00322-00104807-00105058": "Improvement", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00323-00105059-00105640": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00324-00105641-00105952": "so we started with this MSC here that", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00325-00105953-00106163": "we've measured and then we went and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00326-00106164-00106513": "computed uh this MSE hat", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00327-00106514-00106871": "based on the idea of introducing one new", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00328-00106872-00107489": "question and this new pair of leaf notes", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00329-00107490-00107921": "so we'll just call that Delta MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00330-00107922-00108190": "and that is MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00331-00108191-00108328": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00332-00108329-00108557": "K minus", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00333-00108558-00109073": "uh MSE oops", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00334-00109074-00109210": "MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00335-00109211-00109493": "uh hat k", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00336-00109494-00109834": "and this MSE hat K of course is this uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00337-00109835-00110183": "expression right here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00338-00110183-00110621": "so this can become our our measure of uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00339-00110622-00111071": "how good a particular split is uh is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00340-00111072-00111340": "going to be so so this is measuring how", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00341-00111341-00111581": "much how much better our predictions are", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00342-00111582-00111773": "uh when we add the splits and the two", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00343-00111774-00112054": "new Leaf nodes", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00344-00112055-00112402": "if if Delta MSE", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00345-00112403-00113057": "is small", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00346-00113058-00113399": "then this this means that the split is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00347-00113400-00113549": "not", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00348-00113550-00113993": "uh is uh not helpful", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00349-00113994-00114334": "nice formal", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00350-00114335-00114863": "definition there uh if it's large", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00351-00114864-00115175": "then then we have a good Improvement", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00352-00115176-00115636": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00353-00115638-00115877": "so then our what our greedy algorithm is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00354-00115878-00116177": "going to do is it's going to work", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00355-00116178-00116554": "through our tree", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00356-00116555-00116908": "and attempt expanding", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00357-00116909-00117202": "perhaps each one of our existing Leaf", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00358-00117203-00117431": "nodes figuring out what the new question", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00359-00117432-00117671": "should be and then Computing what the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00360-00117672-00118036": "new c k should be and then asking how", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00361-00118038-00118366": "much does this split actually help and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00362-00118367-00118613": "the the greedy algorithm says let's look", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00363-00118614-00119033": "at Delta MSE as a means of evaluating uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00364-00119033-00119158": "which of those splits we're actually", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00365-00119159-00119386": "going to choose we'll pick the one with", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00366-00119388-00119657": "the the highest Delta M MSE and and then", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00367-00119658-00119927": "continue from there of course if the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00368-00119928-00120316": "largest Delta MSE is very small then", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00369-00120317-00120652": "we're going to want to stop our uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00370-00120653-00120839": "expansion and and this is one of those", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00371-00120840-00121145": "places where uh where regularization can", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00372-00121146-00121252": "come in", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00373-00121253-00121643": "that is the the idea behind regression", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00374-00121644-00121883": "trees at least a simple form let's do a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00375-00121883-00122184": "simple example", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00376-00122185-00122597": "and what we'll do is draw out a data set", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00377-00122598-00122995": "here and then pick a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00378-00122996-00123316": "grow a tree that tries to capture this", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00379-00123317-00123904": "data set", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00380-00123905-00124199": "so let's put some samples I guess I", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00381-00124200-00124486": "should say that this is our feature and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00382-00124488-00124715": "this is our output here why", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00383-00124716-00124913": "so those are our true", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00384-00124914-00125123": "labels", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00385-00125124-00125428": "okay so there's there's some samples", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00386-00125429-00125602": "there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00387-00125603-00125771": "all right so let's let's go ahead and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00388-00125772-00125993": "start with our our first tree", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00389-00125994-00126378": "and that's going to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00390-00126379-00126665": "just have the root node and the in one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00391-00126666-00127031": "leaf node and and so our C here is going", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00392-00127032-00127457": "to be equal to the average y over all of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00393-00127458-00127763": "our points and I'm just going to eyeball", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00394-00127764-00128110": "this here but uh that average y looks to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00395-00128111-00128489": "be say about right there so that's if", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00396-00128490-00128843": "this is the origin here then 2 4 6", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00397-00128844-00129533": "that's C is equal to 8 here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00398-00129533-00129640": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00399-00129641-00129901": "so that's not a particularly nice", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00400-00129902-00130223": "approximation of the this data set and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00401-00130224-00130433": "so the question is where should we start", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00402-00130433-00130666": "to Institute our splits now if we were", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00403-00130667-00130775": "to pick", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00404-00130776-00131140": "say a split down the middle here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00405-00131141-00131393": "if we kind of stare at the the average", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00406-00131394-00131566": "values on the left and the right hand", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00407-00131567-00131795": "side those don't change a whole lot we", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00408-00131796-00131993": "might we might end up coming down just a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00409-00131994-00132347": "little bit here but we probably wouldn't", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00410-00132348-00132557": "change this all that much so the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00411-00132558-00132940": "improvement in our ability to produce", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00412-00132941-00133301": "the right y's is is not really all that", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00413-00133302-00133487": "great our Delta MSE is not all that", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00414-00133488-00133643": "great", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00415-00133644-00134009": "um but if we were to say choose", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00416-00134010-00134501": "uh a different dividing line", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00417-00134502-00134747": "so for example we might pick this one", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00418-00134748-00135083": "right here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00419-00135084-00135299": "that corresponds to adding a question", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00420-00135300-00135569": "over here where", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00421-00135570-00135911": "we now ask whether x0 is greater than or", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00422-00135912-00136145": "equal to three", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00423-00136146-00136487": "and uh the nose so those are the things", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00424-00136488-00136811": "on the left hand side uh is this set of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00425-00136812-00136973": "points over here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00426-00136974-00137375": "and the average of those probably sits", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00427-00137376-00137669": "say about right here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00428-00137670-00137914": "oops that's supposed to be a horizontal", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00429-00137915-00138271": "line", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00430-00138272-00138593": "so the new Leaf node here says that we", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00431-00138594-00139139": "want our C uh to be equal to say 3.5", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00432-00139140-00139504": "and down the left hand Branch or C", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00433-00139505-00139852": "probably hasn't changed very much but it", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00434-00139853-00140207": "does necessarily have to migrate a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00435-00140208-00140375": "little bit so we might have might end up", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00436-00140376-00140735": "about here so now C is not 8 but C is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00437-00140736-00140939": "8.5", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00438-00140940-00141197": "okay so so now we have we actually have", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00439-00141198-00141359": "a reasonable approximation for what's", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00440-00141360-00141604": "going on over here but we still have a", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00441-00141605-00141911": "large amount of uh error on on this side", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00442-00141912-00142331": "here so the next step in our uh Tree", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00443-00142332-00142540": "Learning algorithm we're and going to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00444-00142541-00143002": "end up uh considering a change on the uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00445-00143003-00143207": "left hand side down this yes Branch here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00446-00143208-00143483": "which did not intend to remove the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00447-00143484-00143735": "branch", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00448-00143736-00143914": "but now we're going to introduce a new", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00449-00143915-00144204": "uh question", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00450-00144205-00144539": "and uh it's a good question as to what", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00451-00144540-00144952": "we should actually choose I'm going to", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00452-00144953-00145193": "um let's pick a different color here I'm", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00453-00145194-00145481": "going to make a choice uh say about", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00454-00145482-00145828": "right here so this is uh x0 is greater", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00455-00145829-00146213": "than or equal to 8.5 and that has a no", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00456-00146214-00146464": "branch and a yes branch", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00457-00146465-00146693": "for the for the no Branch now the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00458-00146694-00146957": "average is probably sitting about right", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00459-00146958-00147293": "in here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00460-00147294-00147695": "and the the yes Branch necessarily has", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00461-00147696-00147887": "moved down a bit so let's go ahead and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00462-00147888-00148102": "draw it in about right there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00463-00148103-00148228": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00464-00148229-00148966": "so no now sits at", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00465-00148967-00149261": "no now sits at uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00466-00149262-00149723": "I don't know 10.4 and yes now sits at", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00467-00149724-00150737": "seven", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00468-00150738-00151007": "we're doing an okay job now of sort of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00469-00151008-00151163": "capturing here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00470-00151164-00151397": "um but we're still have a fair amount of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00471-00151398-00151787": "of error uh over on this side so let's", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00472-00151788-00152335": "go ahead and induce a new uh a new split", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00473-00152336-00152866": "and that again is down the yes branch", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00474-00152867-00153064": "so let's figure out where that threshold", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00475-00153065-00153202": "ought to be", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00476-00153203-00153652": "so if I were to say add a split right", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00477-00153653-00153893": "uh right here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00478-00153894-00154313": "at 10.", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00479-00154314-00154547": "then our average", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00480-00154548-00154871": "is probably sitting right about in here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00481-00154872-00155039": "and", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00482-00155040-00155411": "our average for for the yes branch is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00483-00155412-00155681": "price probably hasn't changed a whole", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00484-00155682-00155801": "lot", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00485-00155802-00156190": "so down the the no Branch the C is", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00486-00156191-00156623": "is 9.2 or so and down the yes Branch", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00487-00156624-00156989": "it's not changed a whole lot", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00488-00156990-00157378": "so we're at about 6.8", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00489-00157379-00157643": "if we were to split again", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00490-00157644-00157828": "and I'm not we're not going to walk", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00491-00157829-00158099": "through this but the next split probably", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00492-00158100-00158597": "is best about right in here and what", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00493-00158598-00158795": "that would allow us to do is to kind of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00494-00158796-00159016": "capture this this really this constant", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00495-00159017-00159245": "region here and then capture this region", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00496-00159246-00159514": "out in here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00497-00159515-00159793": "foreign", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00498-00159794-00160151": "and then once we've uh made improvements", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00499-00160152-00160349": "there then one can start to imagine", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00500-00160350-00160595": "really addressing what's going on here", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00501-00160596-00160835": "and and then maybe address some of the", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00502-00160836-00161063": "finer details out on the left hand side", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00503-00161064-00161231": "there", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00504-00161232-00161459": "but that at least gives you a sense of", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00505-00161460-00161735": "what tree growth uh might actually uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00506-00161736-00162107": "look like in a regression tree", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00507-00162108-00162359": "all right so next up uh it's time to do", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00508-00162360-00162690": "a little bit of uh code around this uh", "S6ZjYeyv2TQ-00509-00162691-00163082": "this type of algorithm"}}, {"audio_id": "S6a-O36CAq4", "text": {"S6a-O36CAq4-00000-00000035-00002223": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00001-00002224-00002627": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00002-00002628-00003359": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00003-00003360-00003694": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00004-00003695-00007814": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00005-00007815-00007916": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00006-00007917-00010089": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00007-00010090-00010244": "[Applause]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00008-00010245-00010542": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00009-00010543-00011073": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00010-00011074-00011193": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00011-00011194-00011854": "[Applause]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00012-00011855-00013375": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00013-00013376-00013699": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00014-00013700-00014599": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00015-00014600-00014862": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00016-00014863-00016694": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00017-00016695-00016845": "do", "S6a-O36CAq4-00018-00016846-00017447": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00019-00017448-00017710": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00020-00017711-00019572": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00021-00019573-00020403": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00022-00020404-00021783": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00023-00021784-00022004": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00024-00022005-00024671": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00025-00024672-00025124": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00026-00025125-00025495": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00027-00025496-00025650": "[Applause]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00028-00025651-00025934": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00029-00025935-00026479": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00030-00026480-00026599": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00031-00026600-00027414": "[Applause]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00032-00027416-00027698": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00033-00027699-00028033": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00034-00028033-00028743": "[Applause]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00035-00028744-00029104": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00036-00029105-00029916": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00037-00029917-00030007": "[Applause]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00038-00030008-00030858": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00039-00030858-00034302": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00040-00034303-00034696": "do", "S6a-O36CAq4-00041-00034697-00045156": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00042-00045157-00045502": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00043-00045503-00045708": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00044-00045709-00047532": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00045-00047533-00050135": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00046-00050136-00051004": "do", "S6a-O36CAq4-00047-00051005-00052503": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00048-00052504-00052654": "do", "S6a-O36CAq4-00049-00052654-00053775": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00050-00053776-00054309": "so", "S6a-O36CAq4-00051-00054310-00057487": "[Music]", "S6a-O36CAq4-00052-00057488-00057783": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "S7tL6Z2yRj0", "text": {"S7tL6Z2yRj0-00000-00000003-00000584": "so sighs some words what is life anyway", "S7tL6Z2yRj0-00001-00000585-00000761": "but compared to the immortality of a", "S7tL6Z2yRj0-00002-00000762-00000844": "high-score", "S7tL6Z2yRj0-00003-00000846-00000892": "[Music]", "S7tL6Z2yRj0-00004-00000893-00001230": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "S7csI64ggKg", "text": {"S7csI64ggKg-00000-00000652-00000991": "Mining right now is strong generally the", "S7csI64ggKg-00001-00000992-00001216": "recession stopped a lot of the", "S7csI64ggKg-00002-00001217-00001556": "construction which changes though takes", "S7csI64ggKg-00003-00001557-00001745": "away a lot of jobs and when the mining", "S7csI64ggKg-00004-00001746-00002048": "industry I here lays off or anything", "S7csI64ggKg-00005-00002049-00002348": "happens with that it affects absolutely", "S7csI64ggKg-00006-00002349-00002558": "everything we're also finding that some", "S7csI64ggKg-00007-00002559-00002692": "of those people working at the mine are", "S7csI64ggKg-00008-00002693-00002875": "still downsizing you know there's still", "S7csI64ggKg-00009-00002876-00003058": "you know renting apartments that they", "S7csI64ggKg-00010-00003059-00003193": "would normally would have owned a home", "S7csI64ggKg-00011-00003194-00003628": "before being up north we have very high", "S7csI64ggKg-00012-00003629-00003977": "utility bills the people have a choice", "S7csI64ggKg-00013-00003978-00004250": "they have children or just them in the", "S7csI64ggKg-00014-00004251-00004442": "home and you're getting a high heating", "S7csI64ggKg-00015-00004443-00004636": "go a high electric bill and your", "S7csI64ggKg-00016-00004637-00004901": "decision is do we eat and stay warm and", "S7csI64ggKg-00017-00004902-00005201": "make the house payment or do we skip the", "S7csI64ggKg-00018-00005202-00005368": "payment this month a lot of the clients", "S7csI64ggKg-00019-00005369-00005561": "that we're seeing or working you know", "S7csI64ggKg-00020-00005562-00005801": "two part-time jobs or a part-time in a", "S7csI64ggKg-00021-00005802-00006074": "you know and a full time job or going to", "S7csI64ggKg-00022-00006075-00006347": "school and having to work part-time just", "S7csI64ggKg-00023-00006348-00006496": "till they can get that skill set built", "S7csI64ggKg-00024-00006497-00006745": "up to get in a more affordable wage the", "S7csI64ggKg-00025-00006747-00006985": "wages are tough like I said if you work", "S7csI64ggKg-00026-00006986-00007162": "in the mines or you have certain jobs", "S7csI64ggKg-00027-00007163-00007466": "they're doing fine and the trickle-down", "S7csI64ggKg-00028-00007467-00008073": "of them spending money is what we rely", "S7csI64ggKg-00029-00008073-00008279": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "S7cHBUn9zBE", "text": {"S7cHBUn9zBE-00000-00000063-00000353": "space opera as a sub-genre of science", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00001-00000354-00000524": "fiction", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00002-00000525-00001216": "space opera may also refer to", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00003-00001217-00001754": "topic literature", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00004-00001755-00002207": "space opera novel a 1965 parody by Jack", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00005-00002208-00002423": "Vance about an interstellar operatic", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00006-00002424-00002675": "company which brings culture to deprived", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00007-00002676-00003308": "worlds space opera 1974 anthology a 1974", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00008-00003309-00003524": "science fiction collection of short", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00009-00003525-00003772": "stories and novellas edited by Brian", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00010-00003773-00004354": "Aldous space opera 1996 anthology a 1996", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00011-00004355-00004568": "science fiction collection of short", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00012-00004569-00004784": "stories and novellas edited by anne", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00013-00004785-00005059": "mccaffrey and elizabeth scarborough", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00014-00005060-00005483": "space opera a 1961 short story written", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00015-00005484-00005947": "by Ray Russell space opera 2018 novel a", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00016-00005948-00006304": "science fiction humor novel by Kathryn M", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00017-00006305-00006834": "Valente", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00018-00006836-00007328": "topic other", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00019-00007329-00007652": "space opera in Scientology the Xenu", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00020-00007653-00007973": "story and other doctrines of scientology", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00021-00007973-00008285": "space opera role-playing game a game", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00022-00008286-00008655": "created by edward ii symbolist a mark", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00023-00008656-00008891": "Ratner and Phil McGregor for fantasy", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00024-00008892-00009276": "games unlimited space opera a space", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00025-00009277-00009669": "disco opera by didier Marwan II space", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00026-00009670-00010362": "opera a Jack's big music show episode", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00027-00010363-00010910": "topic see also", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00028-00010911-00011264": "Newton's wake a space opera a 2004", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00029-00011265-00011560": "science fiction novel by Ken MacLeod the", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00030-00011561-00011993": "new space opera a 2007 science fiction", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00031-00011994-00012302": "collection of short stories the new", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00032-00012303-00012662": "space opera - a 2009 science fiction", "S7cHBUn9zBE-00033-00012663-00012974": "collection of short stories"}}, {"audio_id": "S8dbqukjwVc", "text": {"S8dbqukjwVc-00000-00000825-00001195": "[Music]", "S8dbqukjwVc-00001-00001196-00001841": "we don't know", "S8dbqukjwVc-00002-00001842-00004877": "[Music]", "S8dbqukjwVc-00003-00004878-00005351": "thank you", "S8dbqukjwVc-00004-00005352-00006745": "[Music]", "S8dbqukjwVc-00005-00006747-00007198": "[Music]", "S8dbqukjwVc-00006-00007200-00007976": "foreign", "S8dbqukjwVc-00007-00007977-00012295": "[Music]", "S8dbqukjwVc-00008-00012296-00013630": "[Music]", "S8dbqukjwVc-00009-00013631-00013751": "please", "S8dbqukjwVc-00010-00013752-00014399": "yourself", "S8dbqukjwVc-00011-00014400-00015119": "yourself", "S8dbqukjwVc-00012-00015119-00015252": "it's not my children", "S8dbqukjwVc-00013-00015253-00015605": "[Music]"}}]