[{"audio_id": "MMy0q6DRltg", "text": {"MMy0q6DRltg-00000-00000112-00000430": "the Apennines or athénée montant Greek", "MMy0q6DRltg-00001-00000431-00000655": "at Vanina or Aladdin a phoniness or a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00002-00000656-00000855": "pnina's Mons", "MMy0q6DRltg-00003-00000856-00001143": "a singular used in the plural Italian a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00004-00001144-00001374": "panini a panini's are a mountain range", "MMy0q6DRltg-00005-00001375-00001590": "consisting of parallel smaller chains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00006-00001591-00002025": "extending C 1,200 kilometers 750 miles", "MMy0q6DRltg-00007-00002026-00002304": "along the length of peninsular Italy in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00008-00002305-00002460": "the northwest they join with the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00009-00002461-00002721": "Ligurian Alps at Altair in the southwest", "MMy0q6DRltg-00010-00002722-00002933": "they end at Reggio d Calabria the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00011-00002934-00003131": "coastal city at the tip of the peninsula", "MMy0q6DRltg-00012-00003132-00003440": "since 2000 the Environment Ministry of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00013-00003442-00003647": "Italy following the recommendations of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00014-00003649-00003876": "the Apennines Park of Europe project has", "MMy0q6DRltg-00015-00003877-00004074": "been defining the Apennines system to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00016-00004075-00004254": "include the mountains of north Sicily", "MMy0q6DRltg-00017-00004255-00004566": "for a total distance of 1500 kilometers", "MMy0q6DRltg-00018-00004567-00004914": "930 miles the system forms an arc", "MMy0q6DRltg-00019-00004915-00005103": "enclosing the east side of the Ligurian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00020-00005104-00005402": "and Tyrrhenian seas", "MMy0q6DRltg-00021-00005403-00005642": "the etymology most frequently repeated", "MMy0q6DRltg-00022-00005643-00005822": "because of its semantic appropriateness", "MMy0q6DRltg-00023-00005823-00006052": "is that it derives from the Celtic pen", "MMy0q6DRltg-00024-00006053-00006406": "mountain summit a pen enos which could", "MMy0q6DRltg-00025-00006408-00006551": "have been assigned during the Celtic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00026-00006552-00006743": "domination of North Italy in the 4th", "MMy0q6DRltg-00027-00006744-00007004": "century BC air before the name", "MMy0q6DRltg-00028-00007005-00007159": "originally applied to the North", "MMy0q6DRltg-00029-00007161-00007420": "Apennines however historical linguists", "MMy0q6DRltg-00030-00007422-00007613": "have never found a derivation with which", "MMy0q6DRltg-00031-00007614-00007711": "they all agree", "MMy0q6DRltg-00032-00007712-00008279": "Wilhelm Deek said dönitz etymology is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00033-00008280-00008489": "doubtful but some derive it from the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00034-00008490-00008750": "Ligurian celtic pen or ben which means", "MMy0q6DRltg-00035-00008751-00009036": "mountain peak", "MMy0q6DRltg-00036-00009037-00009340": "the Apennines also can serve some intact", "MMy0q6DRltg-00037-00009341-00009550": "ecosystems which have survived human", "MMy0q6DRltg-00038-00009551-00009787": "intervention in here there are some of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00039-00009788-00009991": "the best preserved forests and montane", "MMy0q6DRltg-00040-00009992-00010183": "grasslands in the whole continent now", "MMy0q6DRltg-00041-00010184-00010393": "protected by national parks and within", "MMy0q6DRltg-00042-00010394-00010636": "them a high diversity of flora and fauna", "MMy0q6DRltg-00043-00010637-00010885": "these mountains are in fact one of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00044-00010886-00011044": "last refuges for the big European", "MMy0q6DRltg-00045-00011045-00011299": "predators such as the Italian wolf and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00046-00011300-00011521": "the Marcy can Brown bear now extinct in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00047-00011522-00011835": "other countries of Central Europe", "MMy0q6DRltg-00048-00011836-00012031": "the mountains lend their name to the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00049-00012032-00012220": "Athenaeum Peninsula which forms the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00050-00012221-00012469": "major part of Italy they are mostly", "MMy0q6DRltg-00051-00012470-00012666": "verdant although one side of the highest", "MMy0q6DRltg-00052-00012667-00012897": "peak corno grande is partially covered", "MMy0q6DRltg-00053-00012898-00013129": "by Calderone glacier the only glacier in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00054-00013130-00013407": "the Apennines it has been receding since", "MMy0q6DRltg-00055-00013408-00013702": "1794 the eastern slopes down to the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00056-00013703-00013924": "adriatic sea are steep while the western", "MMy0q6DRltg-00057-00013925-00014130": "slopes form foothills on which most of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00058-00014131-00014335": "Peninsular Italy's cities are located", "MMy0q6DRltg-00059-00014336-00014575": "the mountains tend to be named from the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00060-00014576-00014766": "province or provinces in which they are", "MMy0q6DRltg-00061-00014768-00014827": "located", "MMy0q6DRltg-00062-00014828-00015046": "for example the Ligurian Apennines are", "MMy0q6DRltg-00063-00015047-00015319": "in Liguria as the provincial borders", "MMy0q6DRltg-00064-00015319-00015480": "have not always been stable this", "MMy0q6DRltg-00065-00015481-00015697": "practice has resulted in some confusion", "MMy0q6DRltg-00066-00015697-00015858": "about exactly where the Montaigne", "MMy0q6DRltg-00067-00015859-00016119": "borders are often but not always a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00068-00016120-00016318": "geographical feature can be found that", "MMy0q6DRltg-00069-00016319-00016673": "lends itself to being a border", "MMy0q6DRltg-00070-00016674-00017244": "geography the Apennines are divided into", "MMy0q6DRltg-00071-00017245-00017505": "three sectors northern Italian a panino", "MMy0q6DRltg-00072-00017506-00017742": "said internally central a panino central", "MMy0q6DRltg-00073-00017743-00018093": "and southern a panino Meridian Olli", "MMy0q6DRltg-00074-00018094-00018351": "a number of long hiking trails wind", "MMy0q6DRltg-00075-00018352-00018537": "through the Apennines of note is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00076-00018538-00018753": "european walking route II one coming", "MMy0q6DRltg-00077-00018754-00018924": "from Northern Europe and traversing the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00078-00018925-00019071": "lengths of the northern and central", "MMy0q6DRltg-00079-00019072-00019401": "Athens the grand Italian trail begins in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00080-00019402-00019566": "Trieste and after winding through the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00081-00019567-00019815": "Alpine Arc traverses the entire appening", "MMy0q6DRltg-00082-00019816-00020160": "system Sicily and Sardinia", "MMy0q6DRltg-00083-00020161-00020674": "northern Apennines the northern", "MMy0q6DRltg-00084-00020675-00020890": "Apennines consists of three sub chains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00085-00020891-00021130": "the Ligurian a panino Ligure tusks and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00086-00021131-00021376": "emelian a panino Toscano Emiliano and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00087-00021377-00021756": "Umbreon Apennines a panino Umbro", "MMy0q6DRltg-00088-00021757-00022189": "Ligurian Apennines the Ligurian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00089-00022190-00022438": "Apennines border the Ligurian sea in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00090-00022439-00022663": "gulf of genoa from about Savona below", "MMy0q6DRltg-00091-00022664-00022843": "the upper bore meter River Valley to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00092-00022844-00022954": "about La Spezia", "MMy0q6DRltg-00093-00022955-00023206": "the sea is a pass below the upper mangu", "MMy0q6DRltg-00094-00023207-00023473": "River Valley the range follows the Gulf", "MMy0q6DRltg-00095-00023474-00023668": "of Genoa separating it from the upper", "MMy0q6DRltg-00096-00023669-00023731": "Pahlavi", "MMy0q6DRltg-00097-00023732-00024013": "the northwestern border follows the line", "MMy0q6DRltg-00098-00024014-00024204": "of the bore metre river - a creature may", "MMy0q6DRltg-00099-00024205-00024472": "there the river continues north east to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00100-00024473-00024676": "Alessandria in the Po Valley but the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00101-00024677-00025014": "mountains Bend away to the southeast", "MMy0q6DRltg-00102-00025015-00025239": "the upper bore media can be reached by a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00103-00025240-00025436": "number of roads proceeding inland at a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00104-00025437-00025634": "right angle to the coast south west of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00105-00025635-00025802": "salvo nough the chief one being the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00106-00025804-00026100": "autostrada Torino Savona they assent to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00107-00026101-00026301": "the boat jetted the Altair sometimes", "MMy0q6DRltg-00108-00026302-00026777": "called cold DQ de Bona 436 meters 1430", "MMy0q6DRltg-00109-00026779-00026943": "feet the border between the Ligurian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00110-00026944-00027150": "Alps along the coast to the west and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00111-00027151-00027462": "Ligurian Apennines a bronze plaque fixed", "MMy0q6DRltg-00112-00027463-00027671": "to a stone marks the top of the pass in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00113-00027672-00027927": "the vicinity are fragments of the old", "MMy0q6DRltg-00114-00027927-00028095": "road and three ruins of former", "MMy0q6DRltg-00115-00028095-00028337": "fortifications", "MMy0q6DRltg-00116-00028338-00028595": "at car care the main roads connect with", "MMy0q6DRltg-00117-00028595-00028772": "the upper borer media valley for me to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00118-00028773-00028983": "deem a layer before turning west", "MMy0q6DRltg-00119-00028985-00029201": "distribute the Trebbia and the taro", "MMy0q6DRltg-00120-00029202-00029426": "tributaries of the Po River drained the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00121-00029427-00029687": "northeast slopes the range contains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00122-00029688-00029927": "dozens of peaks toward the southern end", "MMy0q6DRltg-00123-00029927-00030110": "the event own natural Regional Park", "MMy0q6DRltg-00124-00030111-00030386": "includes monte Penna nearby is the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00125-00030387-00030577": "highest point of Ligurian Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00126-00030579-00031085": "monte Maggio rasca at 1780 meters 5800", "MMy0q6DRltg-00127-00031086-00031262": "40 feet the main and only feasible", "MMy0q6DRltg-00128-00031263-00031469": "overland route connecting the coastal", "MMy0q6DRltg-00129-00031470-00031664": "plain of Liguria to the north Italian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00130-00031664-00031961": "plane runs through bocha 2d altair it", "MMy0q6DRltg-00131-00031962-00032164": "has always been of strategic importance", "MMy0q6DRltg-00132-00032166-00032387": "defenders of North Italy have had to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00133-00032388-00032594": "control it since ancient times as the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00134-00032595-00032780": "various fortifications placed there", "MMy0q6DRltg-00135-00032781-00033095": "testify Trenitalia the state railway", "MMy0q6DRltg-00136-00033096-00033305": "system highly developed on the coastal", "MMy0q6DRltg-00137-00033306-00033482": "plain natural versus the mountains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00138-00033483-00033656": "routinely through a number of railway", "MMy0q6DRltg-00139-00033657-00034039": "tunnels such as the one at Jovi Pass", "MMy0q6DRltg-00140-00034040-00034270": "the southeastern border of the Ligurian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00141-00034271-00034489": "Apennines is the fiume Madra which", "MMy0q6DRltg-00142-00034490-00034684": "projects into the Tyrrhenian sea south", "MMy0q6DRltg-00143-00034685-00034915": "of La Spezia and a few may taro which", "MMy0q6DRltg-00144-00034916-00035107": "runs in the opposite direction to join", "MMy0q6DRltg-00145-00035108-00035374": "the Po River the divide between the two", "MMy0q6DRltg-00146-00035375-00035614": "upper river valleys is the paso del se", "MMy0q6DRltg-00147-00035615-00035986": "is a sea is a pass under it two tunnels", "MMy0q6DRltg-00148-00035987-00036232": "runs the autostrada del at sea is a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00149-00036233-00036569": "between specia and Parma", "MMy0q6DRltg-00150-00036570-00037064": "Tuscon Emilien Apennines starting at c", "MMy0q6DRltg-00151-00037065-00037286": "is a pass the mountain chains turned", "MMy0q6DRltg-00152-00037287-00037472": "further to the southeast to cross the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00153-00037473-00037649": "peninsula along the border between the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00154-00037650-00037952": "emilia-romagna and tuscany regions they", "MMy0q6DRltg-00155-00037953-00038135": "are also named the Tuscan Emilien", "MMy0q6DRltg-00156-00038136-00038342": "Apennines west of the few de pass and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00157-00038343-00038552": "the Tuscan Rome Agnel Apennines east of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00158-00038553-00038813": "it are just the Tuscan Apennines they", "MMy0q6DRltg-00159-00038814-00039029": "extend to the upper Tiber River the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00160-00039030-00039395": "highest point is Monte sim1 at 2,000 165", "MMy0q6DRltg-00161-00039396-00039805": "metres 7103 feet", "MMy0q6DRltg-00162-00039806-00040084": "a separate branch theophylline out goes", "MMy0q6DRltg-00163-00040085-00040261": "to the southwest bordering the coast", "MMy0q6DRltg-00164-00040262-00040522": "south of La Spezia whether they are to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00165-00040523-00040717": "be considered part of the Apennines is a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00166-00040718-00040909": "matter of opinion certainly they are", "MMy0q6DRltg-00167-00040910-00041109": "part of the Apennine system", "MMy0q6DRltg-00168-00041110-00041305": "topographically only the valley of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00169-00041306-00041515": "river sir Keogh which running parallel", "MMy0q6DRltg-00170-00041516-00041712": "to the coast turns and exits into the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00171-00041713-00041937": "Tyrrhenian sea north of pisa separates", "MMy0q6DRltg-00172-00041938-00042120": "the offal on Alps from the Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00173-00042121-00042331": "geologically the rock is of a slightly", "MMy0q6DRltg-00174-00042332-00042625": "different composition Marvell the Roman", "MMy0q6DRltg-00175-00042626-00042840": "marvel industry was centred at Luna and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00176-00042841-00043145": "is now active in Carrara", "MMy0q6DRltg-00177-00043146-00043364": "as the tuscan Apennines divide the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00178-00043365-00043555": "peninsula between the Po Valley and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00179-00043556-00043774": "plains and hills of Tuscany and lot Co", "MMy0q6DRltg-00180-00043775-00043993": "transportation over them is essential to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00181-00043994-00044199": "political and economic unity", "MMy0q6DRltg-00182-00044200-00044426": "historically the Romans used the Via", "MMy0q6DRltg-00183-00044427-00044654": "Flaminia between Rome and Remini the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00184-00044655-00044855": "Montaigne distance between Florence and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00185-00044856-00045104": "Tuscany and Bologna in Emilia Romagna is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00186-00045105-00045332": "shorter but exploitation of it required", "MMy0q6DRltg-00187-00045333-00045499": "the conquest of more rugged terrain", "MMy0q6DRltg-00188-00045500-00045733": "which was not feasible for the ancient", "MMy0q6DRltg-00189-00045734-00045983": "railway lines were constructed over the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00190-00045984-00046214": "mountains in the early 19th century but", "MMy0q6DRltg-00191-00046215-00046361": "they were of low capacity and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00192-00046362-00046592": "unimprovable", "MMy0q6DRltg-00193-00046593-00046912": "since 1856 a series of tunnels have been", "MMy0q6DRltg-00194-00046913-00047171": "constructed to conduct the Bologna", "MMy0q6DRltg-00195-00047172-00047446": "Florence rail line which is neither a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00196-00047447-00047702": "single line nor a single tunnel the poor", "MMy0q6DRltg-00197-00047703-00047981": "a tunnel line went into service in 1864", "MMy0q6DRltg-00198-00047982-00048236": "the Doretta Seema in 1934 and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00199-00048237-00048617": "high-speed in 1996 a few dozen tunnels", "MMy0q6DRltg-00200-00048618-00048799": "support the three of them the longest on", "MMy0q6DRltg-00201-00048800-00048968": "the high-speed line being the Volia", "MMy0q6DRltg-00202-00048969-00049196": "tunnel at sixteen point seven five seven", "MMy0q6DRltg-00203-00049197-00049446": "kilometers ten point four one two miles", "MMy0q6DRltg-00204-00049447-00049736": "the longest is on the Doretta Seema the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00205-00049737-00049925": "great appening tunnel which at eighteen", "MMy0q6DRltg-00206-00049926-00050132": "point five kilometers", "MMy0q6DRltg-00207-00050133-00050387": "is the longest entirely within Italy", "MMy0q6DRltg-00208-00050388-00050567": "although the simplon tunnel which", "MMy0q6DRltg-00209-00050568-00050836": "connects Italy and Switzerland is longer", "MMy0q6DRltg-00210-00050837-00051068": "automobile traffic is carried by the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00211-00051069-00051358": "autostrada del Sol route a1 which goes", "MMy0q6DRltg-00212-00051359-00051536": "through numerous shorter tunnels by", "MMy0q6DRltg-00213-00051537-00051749": "passing an old Road originally Roman", "MMy0q6DRltg-00214-00051750-00052102": "through few to pass in December 2015 a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00215-00052103-00052351": "new route a one called variant ad Valley", "MMy0q6DRltg-00216-00052352-00052529": "Co was opened after many years of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00217-00052529-00052757": "construction consisting of major tunnels", "MMy0q6DRltg-00218-00052758-00053017": "the longest being the new 8.6 kilometers", "MMy0q6DRltg-00219-00053019-00053467": "5.3 mile tunnel base and new overpasses", "MMy0q6DRltg-00220-00053469-00053654": "notably shortening the traveling time", "MMy0q6DRltg-00221-00053654-00054021": "between Florence and Bologna by Road", "MMy0q6DRltg-00222-00054022-00054279": "inside the tuscan rome Agnel Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00223-00054279-00054488": "are in the southern part also the forest", "MMy0q6DRltg-00224-00054489-00054672": "could sent an SE Mon defaulter ona", "MMy0q6DRltg-00225-00054673-00055024": "campaign a national park", "MMy0q6DRltg-00226-00055025-00055235": "geographically the southernmost sharp", "MMy0q6DRltg-00227-00055236-00055445": "limit of the Tuscan Rome Agnel Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00228-00055446-00055646": "is the boca cereal of past that is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00229-00055647-00055859": "politically in northern Umbria and links", "MMy0q6DRltg-00230-00055860-00056199": "Fano and sitaji Costello", "MMy0q6DRltg-00231-00056200-00056466": "the Tiber River at Rome flows from Monte", "MMy0q6DRltg-00232-00056466-00056661": "few mile Oh in the Tuscan Rome Agnel", "MMy0q6DRltg-00233-00056662-00056822": "appening from northeast to southwest", "MMy0q6DRltg-00234-00056823-00057048": "projecting into the Tyrrhenian sea at", "MMy0q6DRltg-00235-00057049-00057291": "right angles to the shore the upper", "MMy0q6DRltg-00236-00057291-00057348": "Tiber", "MMy0q6DRltg-00237-00057349-00057510": "however flows from Northwest to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00238-00057511-00057719": "southeast gradually turning through one", "MMy0q6DRltg-00239-00057720-00058011": "right angle clockwise the northern Tiber", "MMy0q6DRltg-00240-00058012-00058193": "Valley is deep and separates the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00241-00058194-00058398": "Apennines on the left bank from a lesser", "MMy0q6DRltg-00242-00058399-00058625": "range the Tuscan anterior sub Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00243-00058626-00058859": "on its right", "MMy0q6DRltg-00244-00058860-00059433": "central Apennines the Athenaeum system", "MMy0q6DRltg-00245-00059434-00059619": "forms an irregular arc with centres of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00246-00059620-00059838": "curvature located in the Tyrrhenian see", "MMy0q6DRltg-00247-00059839-00060090": "the northern and southern segments", "MMy0q6DRltg-00248-00060091-00060282": "comprised parallel chains that can be", "MMy0q6DRltg-00249-00060283-00060471": "viewed as single overall mountain ridges", "MMy0q6DRltg-00250-00060472-00060741": "such as the Ligurian mountains the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00251-00060741-00060972": "center being thicker and more complex is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00252-00060973-00061197": "geologically divided into an inner and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00253-00061198-00061383": "an outer arc with regard to the centres", "MMy0q6DRltg-00254-00061384-00061667": "of curvature the geologic definition", "MMy0q6DRltg-00255-00061669-00061833": "however is not the same as the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00256-00061834-00062063": "geographic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00257-00062064-00062285": "based on rock type and orogenic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00258-00062286-00062471": "incidents the northern segment of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00259-00062472-00062669": "arc is divided into the outer northern", "MMy0q6DRltg-00260-00062670-00062863": "Apennines ona and the inner northern", "MMy0q6DRltg-00261-00062864-00063142": "Apennines Heine the central Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00262-00063144-00063359": "are divided into the Umbrian mark Ian a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00263-00063360-00063596": "panino Umbra marchegiano or Roman", "MMy0q6DRltg-00264-00063597-00063781": "Apennines in the north and the Abruzzi", "MMy0q6DRltg-00265-00063782-00064000": "Apennines Anthony no Albert's AZ in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00266-00064001-00064231": "south it extends from focus areola", "MMy0q6DRltg-00267-00064232-00064417": "passing the north to Forli pass in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00268-00064419-00064609": "south", "MMy0q6DRltg-00269-00064610-00065074": "Umbreon Markie and Apennines the West", "MMy0q6DRltg-00270-00065075-00065236": "border of the Umbrian Markie and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00271-00065237-00065584": "Apennines or thumb bro Mark Ian runs", "MMy0q6DRltg-00272-00065585-00065809": "through Kegley they extend south to the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00273-00065810-00065998": "Toronto River the South border of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00274-00065999-00066186": "ona", "MMy0q6DRltg-00275-00066187-00066606": "the highest peak Monty Vittori at 2478", "MMy0q6DRltg-00276-00066607-00066984": "meters 8130 feet is part of the Mondesi", "MMy0q6DRltg-00277-00066985-00067197": "Bellini incorporated into Park onazi", "MMy0q6DRltg-00278-00067198-00067476": "unallied a Mondesi Bellini further", "MMy0q6DRltg-00279-00067477-00067752": "inland is Park o Sasso Simoni Simon", "MMy0q6DRltg-00280-00067753-00067974": "cello and further South Park au naturale", "MMy0q6DRltg-00281-00067975-00068262": "region a legal Adela Rosa D frasassi in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00282-00068263-00068526": "which are the goal of della Rosa Canyon", "MMy0q6DRltg-00283-00068527-00068805": "of the red and frasassi caves the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00284-00068806-00069093": "Italian Park Service calls it the green", "MMy0q6DRltg-00285-00069094-00069384": "heart of Italy the region is heavily", "MMy0q6DRltg-00286-00069385-00069609": "forested such as the reserve and natural", "MMy0q6DRltg-00287-00069610-00069855": "Stan tail go Liddell Furlow wear fur low", "MMy0q6DRltg-00288-00069856-00070146": "pass on the Via Flaminia is located both", "MMy0q6DRltg-00289-00070147-00070368": "the Etruscans and the Romans constructed", "MMy0q6DRltg-00290-00070369-00070608": "tunnels here", "MMy0q6DRltg-00291-00070609-00071046": "of rootsy Apennines the Abruzzi", "MMy0q6DRltg-00292-00071047-00071304": "Apennines located in Abruzzo Molise a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00293-00071305-00071481": "formerly part of Abruzzo and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00294-00071482-00071670": "southeastern lot co contained the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00295-00071671-00071856": "highest peaks and most rugged terrain of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00296-00071857-00072105": "the Apennines they are known in history", "MMy0q6DRltg-00297-00072106-00072336": "as the territory of the italic people's", "MMy0q6DRltg-00298-00072337-00072578": "first defeated by the city of Rome", "MMy0q6DRltg-00299-00072579-00072783": "coincidentally they exist in three", "MMy0q6DRltg-00300-00072784-00072996": "parallel folds or chained surviving from", "MMy0q6DRltg-00301-00072997-00073239": "the origin II these extend in a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00302-00073240-00073443": "Northwest southeast direction from the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00303-00073444-00073653": "river Toronto to the river Sangro which", "MMy0q6DRltg-00304-00073654-00073923": "drained into the Adriatic the coastal", "MMy0q6DRltg-00305-00073924-00074121": "hills of the east extend between san", "MMy0q6DRltg-00306-00074122-00074328": "benedetto del tronto in the north and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00307-00074329-00074657": "Torino de Sangro in the south", "MMy0q6DRltg-00308-00074658-00074904": "the eastern chain consists mainly of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00309-00074905-00075096": "southern part of the Monte Sevilla me", "MMy0q6DRltg-00310-00075097-00075273": "the monte della laga the gran sasso", "MMy0q6DRltg-00311-00075274-00075550": "d'Italia Massif in the Majella Massif", "MMy0q6DRltg-00312-00075551-00075836": "among them are two national parks Gran", "MMy0q6DRltg-00313-00075837-00076098": "Sasso e monte della laga national park", "MMy0q6DRltg-00314-00076099-00076274": "and Magellan national park and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00315-00076275-00076462": "regional park of the mon dicen bruni", "MMy0q6DRltg-00316-00076463-00076797": "Gran Sasso contains corno grande the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00317-00076798-00077066": "highest peak of the Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00318-00077067-00077334": "other features between the Western and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00319-00077335-00077526": "central ranges are the plane of ricci", "MMy0q6DRltg-00320-00077527-00077712": "the valley of the salto and the la", "MMy0q6DRltg-00321-00077713-00077922": "oficina while between the central and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00322-00077923-00078114": "eastern ranges are the valleys of Aquila", "MMy0q6DRltg-00323-00078115-00078393": "and salmona the chief rivers on the west", "MMy0q6DRltg-00324-00078394-00078576": "or the Nira with its tributaries the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00325-00078577-00078834": "valino and salto and the antion both of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00326-00078835-00079083": "which fall into the Tiber on the east", "MMy0q6DRltg-00327-00079084-00079287": "there is at first a succession of small", "MMy0q6DRltg-00328-00079288-00079518": "rivers which flow into the adriatic from", "MMy0q6DRltg-00329-00079519-00079674": "which the highest points of the chain", "MMy0q6DRltg-00330-00079675-00079905": "are some 20 kilometres distant such as", "MMy0q6DRltg-00331-00079906-00080118": "the Toronto toward Eno lamagno and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00332-00080119-00080379": "others the Pescara which receives the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00333-00080380-00080556": "eterno from the northwest and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00334-00080557-00080742": "ghiggia from the southeast is more", "MMy0q6DRltg-00335-00080743-00081079": "important and so is the Sangro", "MMy0q6DRltg-00336-00081080-00081310": "the central Apennines are crossed by the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00337-00081311-00081559": "railway from Rome to Pescara via Amazon", "MMy0q6DRltg-00338-00081560-00081768": "oh and Sulmona the railway from Oort aid", "MMy0q6DRltg-00339-00081769-00081987": "to Terni and then stiffly neo follows", "MMy0q6DRltg-00340-00081988-00082147": "the nearer Valley while from Terra", "MMy0q6DRltg-00341-00082148-00082362": "online ascents to the plane of Ricci and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00342-00082363-00082542": "thence crosses the central chain to a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00343-00082543-00082728": "cola once it follows the valley of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00344-00082729-00083037": "eterno to salmona in ancient times the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00345-00083038-00083313": "via Salaria via caecilia and via valaria", "MMy0q6DRltg-00346-00083314-00083487": "Claudia all ran from Rome to the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00347-00083488-00083811": "adriatic coast the volcanic mountains of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00348-00083812-00084000": "the province of rome are separated from", "MMy0q6DRltg-00349-00084001-00084198": "the Apennines by the Tiber Valley and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00350-00084199-00084387": "the Monti Latini part of the vole she", "MMy0q6DRltg-00351-00084388-00084555": "unchained by the valleys of the Sacko", "MMy0q6DRltg-00352-00084556-00084785": "and Leary", "MMy0q6DRltg-00353-00084786-00085292": "southern Apennines the southern", "MMy0q6DRltg-00354-00085293-00085502": "Apennines can be divided into four major", "MMy0q6DRltg-00355-00085503-00085745": "regions one Samnite Apennines to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00356-00085746-00085964": "campaign ian Apennines three Lucan", "MMy0q6DRltg-00357-00085965-00086192": "Apennines and for Calabrian Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00358-00086193-00086390": "including the sicilian Apennines they", "MMy0q6DRltg-00359-00086391-00086761": "extend from Forli pass towards south", "MMy0q6DRltg-00360-00086762-00087250": "Samnite in campaign Ian Apennines in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00361-00087251-00087440": "southern Apennines to the south of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00362-00087441-00087650": "Sangro Valley the three parallel chains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00363-00087651-00087872": "are broken up into smaller groups among", "MMy0q6DRltg-00364-00087873-00088028": "them may be named the Matisse the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00365-00088029-00088196": "highest point of which is the Monte", "MMy0q6DRltg-00366-00088197-00088493": "maletto 2050 meters six thousand seven", "MMy0q6DRltg-00367-00088494-00088649": "hundred twenty-five feet", "MMy0q6DRltg-00368-00088650-00088894": "the chief rivers on the southwest are", "MMy0q6DRltg-00369-00088895-00089062": "the Leary or Gary Glee Anna with its", "MMy0q6DRltg-00370-00089063-00089318": "tributary the Sacko the voltar no Sabet", "MMy0q6DRltg-00371-00089319-00089579": "o Sarno on the north the Tri no buy fair", "MMy0q6DRltg-00372-00089580-00089810": "no infer Tory the promontory of monte", "MMy0q6DRltg-00373-00089811-00090019": "Gargano on the east is completely", "MMy0q6DRltg-00374-00090020-00090215": "isolated and so are the campaign Ian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00375-00090216-00090515": "volcanic art near Naples the district is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00376-00090516-00090725": "traversed from Northwest to southeast by", "MMy0q6DRltg-00377-00090726-00090935": "the railway from Sulmona to benevento", "MMy0q6DRltg-00378-00090936-00091150": "and on to Abilene oh and from Southwest", "MMy0q6DRltg-00379-00091151-00091375": "to Northeast by the railways from K&L oh", "MMy0q6DRltg-00380-00091376-00091628": "via Sarnia to Campobasso enter moly", "MMy0q6DRltg-00381-00091629-00091862": "from Caserta to Benevento and Foggia and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00382-00091863-00092084": "from nasarah in fairy or a and Avellino", "MMy0q6DRltg-00383-00092085-00092330": "to Racha to s antonio the junction for", "MMy0q6DRltg-00384-00092331-00092579": "Foggia spin Azolla for Barletta VAR e in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00385-00092580-00092924": "Toronto and Potenza Roman roads followed", "MMy0q6DRltg-00386-00092925-00093128": "the same lines as the railways the Via", "MMy0q6DRltg-00387-00093129-00093376": "Appia ran from Capua to Benevento once", "MMy0q6DRltg-00388-00093377-00093548": "the older road went to vanassa and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00389-00093549-00093775": "toronto and so to Brindisi while the via", "MMy0q6DRltg-00390-00093776-00093976": "Triana ran nearly to Foggia and thence", "MMy0q6DRltg-00391-00093977-00094280": "to Bari", "MMy0q6DRltg-00392-00094281-00094748": "Lucan Apennines the valley of the Afon", "MMy0q6DRltg-00393-00094749-00094967": "toe which runs into the Adriatic close", "MMy0q6DRltg-00394-00094968-00095132": "to Barletta marks the northern", "MMy0q6DRltg-00395-00095133-00095309": "termination of the first range of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00396-00095310-00095564": "Lucania Apennines now Basilicata which", "MMy0q6DRltg-00397-00095565-00095768": "runs from east to west while south of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00398-00095769-00095957": "the valleys of the cell on the west and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00399-00095958-00096181": "by sento on the east", "MMy0q6DRltg-00400-00096182-00096388": "which formed the line followed by the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00401-00096389-00096631": "railway from vanta Paglia via Potenza to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00402-00096632-00096807": "metaponto", "MMy0q6DRltg-00403-00096808-00097050": "the second range begins to run due north", "MMy0q6DRltg-00404-00097051-00097250": "and south as far as the plane of Suvari", "MMy0q6DRltg-00405-00097251-00097598": "the highest point is the monte Pollino", "MMy0q6DRltg-00406-00097599-00097896": "2233 meters seven thousand three hundred", "MMy0q6DRltg-00407-00097897-00098025": "twenty-five feet", "MMy0q6DRltg-00408-00098026-00098415": "the chief rivers are the self joined by", "MMy0q6DRltg-00409-00098416-00098535": "the Negro and colori", "MMy0q6DRltg-00410-00098536-00098882": "on the west and the bradda Novecento", "MMy0q6DRltg-00411-00098883-00099131": "angry cine on the east which flow into", "MMy0q6DRltg-00412-00099132-00099356": "the gulf of Toronto to the south of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00413-00099357-00099504": "last-named River there are only", "MMy0q6DRltg-00414-00099505-00099729": "unimportant streams flowing into the sea", "MMy0q6DRltg-00415-00099730-00099924": "east and west in a speck is here the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00416-00099925-00100098": "width of the peninsula diminishes to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00417-00100099-00100505": "some 64 kilometers forty miles", "MMy0q6DRltg-00418-00100506-00100965": "Calabrian and Sicilian Apennines the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00419-00100966-00101190": "railway running south from CICIG nano to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00420-00101191-00101376": "lagun aro ascending the valley of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00421-00101377-00101607": "Negro is planned to extend to Cosenza", "MMy0q6DRltg-00422-00101608-00101802": "along the line followed by the ancient", "MMy0q6DRltg-00423-00101803-00102000": "via poppy Lea which beyond cosenza", "MMy0q6DRltg-00424-00102001-00102177": "reached the west coast of Tarina and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00425-00102178-00102423": "thence followed it to Reggio the via", "MMy0q6DRltg-00426-00102424-00102675": "herculeo a branch of the Via Triana ran", "MMy0q6DRltg-00427-00102676-00102849": "from Hakeem to take him to the ancient", "MMy0q6DRltg-00428-00102850-00103109": "Marilyn at the narrowest point the plane", "MMy0q6DRltg-00429-00103110-00103278": "of Suvari through which the river's", "MMy0q6DRltg-00430-00103279-00103469": "coastal and Kranti flow to the sea", "MMy0q6DRltg-00431-00103470-00103677": "occurs on the east coast extending", "MMy0q6DRltg-00432-00103678-00103932": "halfway across the peninsula here the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00433-00103933-00104159": "limestone Apennines proper cease and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00434-00104160-00104384": "granite mountains of Calabria begin the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00435-00104385-00104571": "first group extends as far as the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00436-00104572-00104748": "Isthmus formed by the Gulf's of south", "MMy0q6DRltg-00437-00104749-00104967": "eufemia and squill as' it is known as", "MMy0q6DRltg-00438-00104968-00105132": "the sila and the highest point reached", "MMy0q6DRltg-00439-00105133-00105501": "is 1930 meters six thousand three", "MMy0q6DRltg-00440-00105502-00105774": "hundred thirty feet the Bob Donato the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00441-00105775-00105930": "forests which covered it in ancient", "MMy0q6DRltg-00442-00105931-00106152": "times supplied the Greeks and Sicilians", "MMy0q6DRltg-00443-00106153-00106404": "with timber for shipbuilding the railway", "MMy0q6DRltg-00444-00106405-00106638": "from South eufemia to Cotton's ro and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00445-00106639-00106854": "Cotton's ro marina crosses the Isthmus", "MMy0q6DRltg-00446-00106855-00107036": "and an ancient road may have run from", "MMy0q6DRltg-00447-00107038-00107196": "squealers to Monte Leone", "MMy0q6DRltg-00448-00107197-00107442": "the second group extends to the south", "MMy0q6DRltg-00449-00107443-00107679": "end of the Italian peninsula culminating", "MMy0q6DRltg-00450-00107680-00108030": "in the Astra Monti 1960 metres six", "MMy0q6DRltg-00451-00108031-00108228": "thousand four hundred twenty feet to the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00452-00108229-00108495": "east of Reggio di Calabria in both", "MMy0q6DRltg-00453-00108496-00108674": "groups the rivers are quite unimportant", "MMy0q6DRltg-00454-00108675-00108921": "finally the Calabrian southern a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00455-00108922-00109128": "pennines extend along the northern coast", "MMy0q6DRltg-00456-00109129-00109422": "of sicily the Sicilian Apennines Italian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00457-00109423-00109634": "Eponine ocq low", "MMy0q6DRltg-00458-00109635-00110268": "Pizza carbonara 6400 93 feet 1979 meters", "MMy0q6DRltg-00459-00110269-00110568": "being the highest peak", "MMy0q6DRltg-00460-00110569-00110970": "ecology", "MMy0q6DRltg-00461-00110971-00111408": "vegetative zones", "MMy0q6DRltg-00462-00111408-00111885": "ecoregions north and central happening", "MMy0q6DRltg-00463-00111886-00112083": "deciduous montane forest temperate", "MMy0q6DRltg-00464-00112084-00112509": "broadleaf and mixed forests biome north", "MMy0q6DRltg-00465-00112510-00112734": "through South Italians Clara Phyllis and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00466-00112735-00112959": "semi deciduous forests Mediterranean", "MMy0q6DRltg-00467-00112960-00113407": "forests woodlands and scrub biome South", "MMy0q6DRltg-00468-00113408-00113628": "South appening mixed montane forests", "MMy0q6DRltg-00469-00113629-00113859": "also a Mediterranean biome the number of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00470-00113860-00114054": "vascular plant species in the Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00471-00114055-00114288": "has been estimated at five thousand five", "MMy0q6DRltg-00472-00114289-00114702": "hundred ninety nine of these 728 23.6%", "MMy0q6DRltg-00473-00114703-00115021": "are in the treeline ecotone hemic RIPTA", "MMy0q6DRltg-00474-00115022-00115176": "fights predominant in the entire a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00475-00115177-00115413": "panini chain", "MMy0q6DRltg-00476-00115414-00115909": "Alpine zone the treeline ecotone is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00477-00115910-00116081": "mainly grasslands of the montane", "MMy0q6DRltg-00478-00116082-00116294": "grasslands and shrublands biome with", "MMy0q6DRltg-00479-00116295-00116488": "temperate broadleaf and mixed forests", "MMy0q6DRltg-00480-00116489-00116704": "and Mediterranean forests woodlands and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00481-00116705-00116959": "scrub below it the treeline in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00482-00116960-00117275": "Apennines can be found in the range 1600", "MMy0q6DRltg-00483-00117276-00117623": "meters 5,200 feet to 2,000 meters six", "MMy0q6DRltg-00484-00117624-00117956": "thousand six hundred feet about 5% of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00485-00117957-00118169": "the map area covered by the Apennines is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00486-00118170-00118489": "at or above the treeline or in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00487-00118490-00118765": "treeline ecotone the snowline is at", "MMy0q6DRltg-00488-00118766-00119156": "about 3,200 meters 10,500 feet leaving", "MMy0q6DRltg-00489-00119157-00119341": "the Apennines below it except for the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00490-00119342-00119633": "one remaining glacier snow may fall from", "MMy0q6DRltg-00491-00119633-00119902": "October to May rainfall increases with", "MMy0q6DRltg-00492-00119903-00120131": "latitude the ranges climates depending", "MMy0q6DRltg-00493-00120132-00120316": "on elevation and latitude are the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00494-00120317-00120473": "oceanic climate and Mediterranean", "MMy0q6DRltg-00495-00120474-00120920": "climate", "MMy0q6DRltg-00496-00120921-00121500": "geology the Apennines were created in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00497-00121501-00121685": "the a pnina orogeny beginning in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00498-00121686-00121961": "early Mia Jean about 20 Mya the middle", "MMy0q6DRltg-00499-00121963-00122201": "Maya scene and continuing today", "MMy0q6DRltg-00500-00122202-00122406": "geographically they are partially are", "MMy0q6DRltg-00501-00122407-00122547": "appeared to be continuous with the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00502-00122548-00122841": "Alpine system prior to the explosion of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00503-00122842-00123021": "data on the topic from about the year", "MMy0q6DRltg-00504-00123022-00123240": "2000 many authors took the approach that", "MMy0q6DRltg-00505-00123241-00123456": "the Apennines had the same origin as the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00506-00123457-00123761": "out even today some authors use the term", "MMy0q6DRltg-00507-00123763-00123975": "Alpine appening system they are not", "MMy0q6DRltg-00508-00123976-00124194": "however the same system and did not have", "MMy0q6DRltg-00509-00124195-00124460": "the same origin the Alps were millions", "MMy0q6DRltg-00510-00124461-00124665": "of years old before the Apennines rose", "MMy0q6DRltg-00511-00124666-00124921": "from the sea", "MMy0q6DRltg-00512-00124922-00125143": "both the Alps and the Apennines contain", "MMy0q6DRltg-00513-00125144-00125358": "primarily sedimentary rock resulting", "MMy0q6DRltg-00514-00125359-00125548": "from sedimentation of the ancient heavy", "MMy0q6DRltg-00515-00125549-00125800": "sea in the Mesozoic the northward", "MMy0q6DRltg-00516-00125801-00125983": "movement of the African plate and its", "MMy0q6DRltg-00517-00125983-00126166": "collision with the European plate then", "MMy0q6DRltg-00518-00126167-00126384": "caused the Alpine orogeny beginning in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00519-00126385-00126658": "the late Mesozoic the band of mountains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00520-00126658-00126880": "created extends from Spain to Turkey in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00521-00126881-00127057": "a roughly east-west direction and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00522-00127058-00127333": "includes the out the Apennines are much", "MMy0q6DRltg-00523-00127333-00127516": "younger extend from Northwest to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00524-00127517-00127720": "southeast and are not a displacement of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00525-00127721-00127961": "the Alpine chain", "MMy0q6DRltg-00526-00127963-00128177": "the key evidence of the difference is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00527-00128178-00128349": "the geologic behavior of the Po Valley", "MMy0q6DRltg-00528-00128350-00128622": "in northern Italy compressional forces", "MMy0q6DRltg-00529-00128623-00128844": "have been acting from north to south in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00530-00128845-00129021": "the Alps and from south to north in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00531-00129022-00129219": "Apennines but instead of being squeezed", "MMy0q6DRltg-00532-00129220-00129372": "into mountains the valley has been", "MMy0q6DRltg-00533-00129373-00129565": "subsiding at one to four millimeters", "MMy0q6DRltg-00534-00129566-00129939": "0.16 in per year since about 25 Mya", "MMy0q6DRltg-00535-00129940-00130235": "before the Apennines existed it is now", "MMy0q6DRltg-00536-00130236-00130454": "known to be not an erosional feature but", "MMy0q6DRltg-00537-00130455-00130640": "is a filled portion of the adriatic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00538-00130641-00130881": "Trench called the Adriatic 40 after its", "MMy0q6DRltg-00539-00130882-00131052": "function as a subduction zone was", "MMy0q6DRltg-00540-00131053-00131310": "discovered the Alps and the Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00541-00131311-00131520": "were always separated by this trench and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00542-00131521-00131858": "were never part of the same system", "MMy0q6DRltg-00543-00131859-00132265": "formation of rocks", "MMy0q6DRltg-00544-00132266-00132863": "Anthony orogeny the a pnina orogeny is a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00545-00132864-00133058": "type of mountain building in which two", "MMy0q6DRltg-00546-00133059-00133220": "simpler types are combined in an", "MMy0q6DRltg-00547-00133221-00133465": "apparently paradoxical configuration", "MMy0q6DRltg-00548-00133466-00133781": "sometimes this is referred to as sin", "MMy0q6DRltg-00549-00133782-00134078": "orogenic extension but the term implies", "MMy0q6DRltg-00550-00134079-00134234": "that the two processes occur", "MMy0q6DRltg-00551-00134235-00134554": "simultaneously during time", "MMy0q6DRltg-00552-00134555-00134788": "some scientists imagine that this is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00553-00134789-00134986": "relatively rare but not unique in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00554-00134987-00135190": "mountain building whereas others imagine", "MMy0q6DRltg-00555-00135191-00135340": "that this is fairly common in all", "MMy0q6DRltg-00556-00135341-00135589": "mountain belts", "MMy0q6DRltg-00557-00135590-00135832": "the retreat project had this specific", "MMy0q6DRltg-00558-00135833-00136219": "feature as one of their focus points in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00559-00136220-00136420": "essence the east side of Italy features", "MMy0q6DRltg-00560-00136421-00136597": "a fold and thrust belt raised by", "MMy0q6DRltg-00561-00136598-00136774": "compressional forces acting under the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00562-00136775-00137074": "adriatic sea this side has been called", "MMy0q6DRltg-00563-00137075-00137362": "the happening adriatic compressional", "MMy0q6DRltg-00564-00137363-00137704": "zone for the Apennines convergent zone", "MMy0q6DRltg-00565-00137705-00137998": "on the west side of italy fault block", "MMy0q6DRltg-00566-00137999-00138241": "mountains prevail created by a spreading", "MMy0q6DRltg-00567-00138242-00138412": "or extension of the crust under the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00568-00138413-00138708": "Tyrrhenian sea this side is called the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00569-00138709-00139000": "tyrrhenian extensional zone the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00570-00139001-00139201": "mountains of Italy are of paradoxical", "MMy0q6DRltg-00571-00139202-00139396": "provenience having to derive from both", "MMy0q6DRltg-00572-00139397-00139685": "compression and extension", "MMy0q6DRltg-00573-00139686-00139951": "the paradox of how contraction and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00574-00139952-00140200": "extension can occur simultaneously in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00575-00140201-00140413": "convergent mountain belts remains a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00576-00140414-00140602": "fundamental and largely unresolved", "MMy0q6DRltg-00577-00140603-00141032": "problem in continental dynamics both the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00578-00141033-00141212": "folded and the fault block systems", "MMy0q6DRltg-00579-00141213-00141490": "include parallel mountain chains in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00580-00141491-00141715": "folded system anticlines erode into the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00581-00141716-00141901": "highest and longest massifs of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00582-00141902-00142139": "Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00583-00142140-00142310": "according to the older theories", "MMy0q6DRltg-00584-00142311-00142640": "originating from the 1930s to 1970s of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00585-00142641-00142853": "Dutch geologists including van bellen", "MMy0q6DRltg-00586-00142854-00143084": "compression and extension can and should", "MMy0q6DRltg-00587-00143085-00143300": "occur simultaneously at different depths", "MMy0q6DRltg-00588-00143301-00143537": "in a mountain belt in these theories", "MMy0q6DRltg-00589-00143538-00143726": "these different levels are called stock", "MMy0q6DRltg-00590-00143727-00144002": "work more recent work in geo tech tonics", "MMy0q6DRltg-00591-00144003-00144214": "and geo dynamics of the same school of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00592-00144215-00144410": "geoscientists Utrecht and Amsterdam", "MMy0q6DRltg-00593-00144411-00144683": "University live lar Wardle and clothing", "MMy0q6DRltg-00594-00144684-00144875": "and their disciples extended these", "MMy0q6DRltg-00595-00144876-00145091": "concepts even further into a temporal", "MMy0q6DRltg-00596-00145092-00145364": "realm they demonstrated that internal", "MMy0q6DRltg-00597-00145365-00145559": "and external forces acting upon the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00598-00145560-00145784": "mountain belt eg slab pull and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00599-00145785-00146012": "intraplate stress field modulations due", "MMy0q6DRltg-00600-00146013-00146219": "to large-scale reorganizations of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00601-00146220-00146432": "tectonic plates result in both longer", "MMy0q6DRltg-00602-00146433-00146657": "episodes and shorter phases of general", "MMy0q6DRltg-00603-00146658-00146849": "extension and compression acting both", "MMy0q6DRltg-00604-00146850-00147056": "upon and inside mountain belts and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00605-00147057-00147311": "tectonic arches see eg for extensive", "MMy0q6DRltg-00606-00147312-00147545": "reviews bibliography and discussions on", "MMy0q6DRltg-00607-00147546-00147854": "the literature van dyke 1992 van Dyken", "MMy0q6DRltg-00608-00147855-00148289": "Okies 1991 van Dyken cheekers 1995 and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00609-00148290-00148628": "van dyke at all 2000 a compressional", "MMy0q6DRltg-00610-00148629-00148847": "zone the gradual subsidence of the Po", "MMy0q6DRltg-00611-00148848-00149036": "Valley including that of Venice and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00612-00149037-00149189": "folding of the mountains of eastern", "MMy0q6DRltg-00613-00149190-00149369": "Italy have been investigated using", "MMy0q6DRltg-00614-00149370-00149600": "seismic wave analysis of the Athenaeum", "MMy0q6DRltg-00615-00149601-00149828": "subduction system along the adriatic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00616-00149829-00150044": "side of italy the floor of the adriatic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00617-00150045-00150230": "sea referred to as the Adriatic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00618-00150231-00150461": "lithosphere or the Adriatic plate terms", "MMy0q6DRltg-00619-00150462-00150659": "whose precise meaning is the subject of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00620-00150660-00150845": "ongoing research is dipping under the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00621-00150846-00151019": "slab on which the Apennines have been", "MMy0q6DRltg-00622-00151020-00151222": "folded by compressional forces", "MMy0q6DRltg-00623-00151223-00151487": "subduction occurs along a fault along", "MMy0q6DRltg-00624-00151488-00151706": "which a hanging wall or overriding slab", "MMy0q6DRltg-00625-00151707-00151946": "is thrust over an overridden slab also", "MMy0q6DRltg-00626-00151947-00152189": "called the subducting slab the fault", "MMy0q6DRltg-00627-00152190-00152405": "that acts as the subduction interface is", "MMy0q6DRltg-00628-00152406-00152555": "at the bottom of the Apennine wedge", "MMy0q6DRltg-00629-00152556-00152753": "characterized by a deep groove in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00630-00152754-00152933": "surface typically filled with sediment", "MMy0q6DRltg-00631-00152934-00153155": "as sedimentation here occurs at a much", "MMy0q6DRltg-00632-00153156-00153419": "faster rate than subduction in North", "MMy0q6DRltg-00633-00153420-00153641": "Italy the dip of this interface is 30", "MMy0q6DRltg-00634-00153642-00153869": "degrees to 40 degrees at a depth of 80", "MMy0q6DRltg-00635-00153870-00154064": "to 90 kilometers the strike of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00636-00154065-00154292": "Apennine subduction zone forms a long", "MMy0q6DRltg-00637-00154293-00154511": "irregular arc with centres of curvature", "MMy0q6DRltg-00638-00154512-00154679": "in the Tyrrhenian sea following the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00639-00154680-00154853": "hanging wall over which the mountains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00640-00154854-00155066": "have been raised ie the eastern wall of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00641-00155067-00155153": "the mountains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00642-00155154-00155369": "it runs from near the base of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00643-00155370-00155522": "Ligurian Apennines in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00644-00155523-00155713": "Valley along the margin of the mountains", "MMy0q6DRltg-00645-00155714-00155936": "to the Adriatic along the coastal dekes", "MMy0q6DRltg-00646-00155937-00156170": "of the Adriatic Shore strikes inland at", "MMy0q6DRltg-00647-00156171-00156403": "Monte Gargano cutting off Apulia out to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00648-00156404-00156550": "sea again through the Gulf of Taranto", "MMy0q6DRltg-00649-00156551-00156773": "widely around the rest of Italy and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00650-00156774-00156988": "Sicily and across inland North Africa", "MMy0q6DRltg-00651-00156989-00157345": "the upper mantle above 250 kilometres", "MMy0q6DRltg-00652-00157346-00157607": "160 miles deep is broken into the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00653-00157608-00157825": "northern Apennines arc and the Calabrian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00654-00157826-00158036": "arc with compressional forces acting in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00655-00158037-00158222": "different directions radially toward the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00656-00158223-00158491": "arcs centers of curvature the overall", "MMy0q6DRltg-00657-00158492-00158699": "plate tectonics of these events has been", "MMy0q6DRltg-00658-00158700-00158885": "modeled in different ways but decisive", "MMy0q6DRltg-00659-00158886-00159170": "data is still missing the tectonics", "MMy0q6DRltg-00660-00159171-00159362": "however are not the same as those which", "MMy0q6DRltg-00661-00159363-00159656": "created the out extensional zone the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00662-00159657-00159869": "west side of Italy is given to a fault", "MMy0q6DRltg-00663-00159870-00160100": "block system where the crust extended by", "MMy0q6DRltg-00664-00160101-00160303": "the lengthening mantle below then broke", "MMy0q6DRltg-00665-00160304-00160513": "along roughly parallel fault lines and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00666-00160514-00160690": "the blocks alternatively sank into", "MMy0q6DRltg-00667-00160691-00160886": "Grauman's or were raised by isostasy", "MMy0q6DRltg-00668-00160887-00161191": "into horst's this system prevails from", "MMy0q6DRltg-00669-00161192-00161369": "Corsica eastward to the valley of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00670-00161370-00161597": "Tiber River the last Rift Valley in that", "MMy0q6DRltg-00671-00161598-00161878": "direction it runs approximately across", "MMy0q6DRltg-00672-00161879-00162095": "the direction of extension in the fault", "MMy0q6DRltg-00673-00162096-00162299": "block system the ridges are lower and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00674-00162300-00162403": "are more steep-sided", "MMy0q6DRltg-00675-00162404-00162651": "since the walls are formed by faults", "MMy0q6DRltg-00676-00162652-00162857": "geographically they are not considered", "MMy0q6DRltg-00677-00162858-00163043": "part of the Apennines proper but er", "MMy0q6DRltg-00678-00163044-00163271": "termed sub Eponine or anti appening", "MMy0q6DRltg-00679-00163272-00163436": "these mountains are found mainly in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00680-00163437-00163789": "Tuscany lot CO and Campania stability of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00681-00163790-00163987": "terrain the terrain of the Apennines as", "MMy0q6DRltg-00682-00163988-00164176": "well as that of the Alps is to a large", "MMy0q6DRltg-00683-00164177-00164411": "degree unstable due to various types of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00684-00164412-00164650": "landslides including Falls and slides of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00685-00164651-00164851": "rocks and debris flows of earth and mud", "MMy0q6DRltg-00686-00164852-00165134": "and sinkholes the Institute for", "MMy0q6DRltg-00687-00165135-00165320": "environmental protection and Research", "MMy0q6DRltg-00688-00165321-00165545": "Institute o superior reaper love", "MMy0q6DRltg-00689-00165546-00165802": "protección de la ricerca ambient ale a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00690-00165803-00166049": "government agency founded in 2008 by", "MMy0q6DRltg-00691-00166050-00166303": "combining three older agencies published", "MMy0q6DRltg-00692-00166304-00166520": "in that year a special report landslides", "MMy0q6DRltg-00693-00166521-00166741": "in Italy summarizing the results of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00694-00166742-00167072": "IFF I project ill progetto iff I the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00695-00167073-00167285": "Italian landslides inventory inventory", "MMy0q6DRltg-00696-00167286-00167554": "O'Day phenomena Fran Tosi and Natalia an", "MMy0q6DRltg-00697-00167555-00167735": "extensive survey of historical", "MMy0q6DRltg-00698-00167736-00167933": "landslides in Italy undertaken by the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00699-00167934-00168287": "government starting in 1997 on December", "MMy0q6DRltg-00700-00168288-00168651": "31st 2007 it had studied and mapped", "MMy0q6DRltg-00701-00168652-00168902": "482,000 272 lat", "MMy0q6DRltg-00702-00168903-00169091": "slides over twenty thousand five hundred", "MMy0q6DRltg-00703-00169092-00169304": "square kilometres seven thousand nine", "MMy0q6DRltg-00704-00169305-00169451": "hundred square miles", "MMy0q6DRltg-00705-00169452-00169721": "it's major statistics are the landslide", "MMy0q6DRltg-00706-00169722-00170003": "index Li here the ratio of the landslide", "MMy0q6DRltg-00707-00170004-00170231": "area to the total area of a region the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00708-00170232-00170429": "landslide index in mountainous hilly", "MMy0q6DRltg-00709-00170430-00170678": "areas here Li M H and the density of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00710-00170679-00170915": "landslides which is the number for 100", "MMy0q6DRltg-00711-00170916-00171312": "square kilometers 39 square miles", "MMy0q6DRltg-00712-00171313-00171714": "Italy as a whole has a Li of 6.8 l IM h", "MMy0q6DRltg-00713-00171715-00172176": "of 9.1 in a density of 160 lombardia Li", "MMy0q6DRltg-00714-00172177-00172722": "of 13.9 Emilia Romagna 11.4 marches 19.4", "MMy0q6DRltg-00715-00172723-00173066": "mole is a 14-point o volley dosa 16", "MMy0q6DRltg-00716-00173067-00173298": "point O and piemonte 9.1 are", "MMy0q6DRltg-00717-00173299-00173579": "significantly higher the most unstable", "MMy0q6DRltg-00718-00173580-00173753": "terrain in the Apennines when the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00719-00173754-00173937": "landslide sites are plotted on the map", "MMy0q6DRltg-00720-00173938-00174135": "are in order for most unstable the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00721-00174136-00174327": "eastern flanks of the Tuscan Emilien", "MMy0q6DRltg-00722-00174328-00174537": "Apennines the central Apennines in the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00723-00174538-00174782": "eastern flank of the southern Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00724-00174783-00174993": "instability there is comparable to the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00725-00174994-00175221": "outs bordering the Po Valley the most", "MMy0q6DRltg-00726-00175222-00175413": "stable terrain is on the western side", "MMy0q6DRltg-00727-00175414-00175782": "Liguria Tuscany Umbria and Lotte Co the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00728-00175783-00175959": "Apennines are slumping away to the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00729-00175960-00176133": "northeast into the Po Valley and the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00730-00176134-00176370": "Adriatic 40 that is the zone where the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00731-00176371-00176583": "Adriatic floor is being subducted under", "MMy0q6DRltg-00732-00176584-00176927": "Italy slides with large translational or", "MMy0q6DRltg-00733-00176928-00177120": "rotational surface movements are most", "MMy0q6DRltg-00734-00177121-00177393": "common eg a whole slope slumps into its", "MMy0q6DRltg-00735-00177394-00177590": "valley placing the population there at", "MMy0q6DRltg-00736-00177591-00177784": "risk", "MMy0q6DRltg-00737-00177785-00178375": "glacial ice glaciers no longer exist in", "MMy0q6DRltg-00738-00178376-00178525": "the Apennines outside the gran sasso", "MMy0q6DRltg-00739-00178526-00178693": "d'Italia Massif", "MMy0q6DRltg-00740-00178694-00178975": "however post plea Aseema rains have been", "MMy0q6DRltg-00741-00178976-00179273": "observed in Basilicata", "MMy0q6DRltg-00742-00179274-00179866": "major peaks the Apennines include about", "MMy0q6DRltg-00743-00179867-00180347": "21 peaks over 1900 meters 6,200 feet the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00744-00180348-00180553": "approximate treeline counting only the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00745-00180554-00180826": "top peak in each Massif most of these", "MMy0q6DRltg-00746-00180827-00180991": "Peaks are located in the central", "MMy0q6DRltg-00747-00180992-00181191": "Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00748-00181192-00181625": "see also", "MMy0q6DRltg-00749-00181626-00181881": "Montee sim brewing the Apennines plants", "MMy0q6DRltg-00750-00181882-00182513": "and animals list geography of italy list", "MMy0q6DRltg-00751-00182514-00182907": "of national parks of italy list of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00752-00182908-00183294": "longest tunnels list of highest paved", "MMy0q6DRltg-00753-00183295-00183835": "roads in europe list of mountain passes", "MMy0q6DRltg-00754-00183836-00184239": "task force miele", "MMy0q6DRltg-00755-00184240-00184671": "notes", "MMy0q6DRltg-00756-00184672-00185111": "references", "MMy0q6DRltg-00757-00185112-00185508": "bibliography", "MMy0q6DRltg-00758-00185509-00185888": "Apennines Miriam Webster's geographical", "MMy0q6DRltg-00759-00185889-00186122": "dictionary third ad Miriam Webster", "MMy0q6DRltg-00760-00186123-00186491": "incorporated 2001", "MMy0q6DRltg-00761-00186492-00186803": "Blackie Kristina Blackie John Stuart", "MMy0q6DRltg-00762-00186804-00187223": "1887 geographical etymology a dictionary", "MMy0q6DRltg-00763-00187224-00187396": "of place names giving their derivations", "MMy0q6DRltg-00764-00187397-00187677": "London Murray", "MMy0q6DRltg-00765-00187678-00188285": "deep w Nesbitt H a translator 1904 Italy", "MMy0q6DRltg-00766-00188286-00188491": "a popular account of the country its", "MMy0q6DRltg-00767-00188492-00188720": "people and its institutions including", "MMy0q6DRltg-00768-00188721-00188981": "Malta and Sardinia London New York", "MMy0q6DRltg-00769-00188982-00189274": "Macmillan Co as Sun and shine and Co", "MMy0q6DRltg-00770-00189275-00189647": "Lunardi Pietro 2008 design and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00771-00189648-00189851": "construction of tunnels analysis of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00772-00189852-00190039": "controlled deformation in rocks and", "MMy0q6DRltg-00773-00190040-00190418": "soils ADEC ors berlin springer", "MMy0q6DRltg-00774-00190419-00190649": "margheriti lucia at all", "MMy0q6DRltg-00775-00190650-00190982": "August October 2006 the subduction", "MMy0q6DRltg-00776-00190983-00191159": "structure of the northern Apennines", "MMy0q6DRltg-00777-00191160-00191338": "results for the retreat seismic", "MMy0q6DRltg-00778-00191339-00191744": "deployment PDF annals of geophysics 49", "MMy0q6DRltg-00779-00191745-00192086": "4/5 archived from the original PDF on", "MMy0q6DRltg-00780-00192087-00192391": "the 19th of June 2010 martini", "MMy0q6DRltg-00781-00192392-00192753": "i Peter by Gian Batista 2001", "MMy0q6DRltg-00782-00192754-00192935": "geomorphological", "MMy0q6DRltg-00783-00192936-00193334": "Artemi I Peter by Gian Bautista anatomy", "MMy0q6DRltg-00784-00193335-00193559": "of an Origin the Apennines and adjacent", "MMy0q6DRltg-00785-00193560-00193801": "Mediterranean basins Dordrecht you a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00786-00193802-00194024": "clue er academic publishers", "MMy0q6DRltg-00787-00194025-00194440": "Kiki 1 2 4 barchi Massimiliano LAN Zhu", "MMy0q6DRltg-00788-00194441-00194800": "Zi Alberto Minelli Giorgio ple Giampaolo", "MMy0q6DRltg-00789-00194801-00195197": "2001 inner northern Apennines in martini", "MMy0q6DRltg-00790-00195198-00195545": "I Peter by Gian Bautista anatomy of an", "MMy0q6DRltg-00791-00195546-00195725": "origin the Apennines and adjacent", "MMy0q6DRltg-00792-00195726-00195991": "Mediterranean basins dordrecht you a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00793-00195992-00196440": "clue er academic publishers pp 215 to", "MMy0q6DRltg-00794-00196441-00196958": "254 Pedro D F a afta D 2003 the high", "MMy0q6DRltg-00795-00196959-00197168": "mountain flora and vegetation of the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00796-00197169-00197464": "Apennines and the Italian out in Maggie", "MMy0q6DRltg-00797-00197465-00197944": "Lazlo grab her G corner CH Thompson DBA", "MMy0q6DRltg-00798-00197945-00198289": "Alpine biodiversity in Europe ecological", "MMy0q6DRltg-00799-00198290-00198659": "studies 167 berlin heidelberg you a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00800-00198660-00199141": "springer verlag PP 73 284 attribution", "MMy0q6DRltg-00801-00199142-00199343": "this article incorporates text from a", "MMy0q6DRltg-00802-00199344-00199508": "publication now in the public domain", "MMy0q6DRltg-00803-00199509-00199931": "lake Phillip 1911 Apennines in Chisholm", "MMy0q6DRltg-00804-00199932-00200263": "q Encyclopedia Britannica - 11th at", "MMy0q6DRltg-00805-00200264-00200452": "Cambridge University Press", "MMy0q6DRltg-00806-00200453-00201063": "pp 161 - 163 external links Italy", "MMy0q6DRltg-00807-00201064-00201329": "catholic online retrieved the 21st of", "MMy0q6DRltg-00808-00201330-00201651": "February 2010 Ligurian Apennine summit", "MMy0q6DRltg-00809-00201652-00202014": "post 2006 retrieved the 16th of February", "MMy0q6DRltg-00810-00202015-00202326": "2010 Italian cultural landscapes wood", "MMy0q6DRltg-00811-00202327-00202509": "pasture and wood meadow in the Ligurian", "MMy0q6DRltg-00812-00202510-00202884": "Tuscan emilian Apennines Italy the ecl", "MMy0q6DRltg-00813-00202885-00203121": "project archived from the original on", "MMy0q6DRltg-00814-00203122-00203499": "the 17th of September 2007 retrieved the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00815-00203500-00203838": "16th of February 2010 Apennine deciduous", "MMy0q6DRltg-00816-00203839-00204111": "montane forests terrestrial ecoregions", "MMy0q6DRltg-00817-00204112-00204402": "World Wildlife Fund retrieved the 16th", "MMy0q6DRltg-00818-00204403-00204791": "of February 2010 Berlin Michael J 2009", "MMy0q6DRltg-00819-00204792-00205053": "the great appening tunnel Mike's railway", "MMy0q6DRltg-00820-00205054-00205313": "history retrieved the 16th of February", "MMy0q6DRltg-00821-00205314-00205559": "2010 10th Mountain Division the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00822-00205560-00205821": "formative World War two years Dartmouth", "MMy0q6DRltg-00823-00205821-00206240": "College class of 1965 2008 retrieved the", "MMy0q6DRltg-00824-00206241-00206631": "16th of February 2010"}}, {"audio_id": "MMzrFvfoZNE", "text": {"MMzrFvfoZNE-00000-00000000-00000141": "you", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00001-00000142-00000827": "you", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00002-00000828-00001143": "okay Oh Inga the place of the strong", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00003-00001144-00001434": "people was settled more than 700 years", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00004-00001435-00001764": "ago in the southwest this Tewa speaking", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00005-00001764-00001992": "pueblos traditional center oh na boo", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00006-00001993-00002244": "Pena has long been the site of a variety", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00007-00002245-00002460": "of spiritual and cultural observances", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00008-00002461-00002751": "and it's connected house blocks used to", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00009-00002752-00003045": "tie families and clans together many of", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00010-00003046-00003240": "the homes in this National Register site", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00011-00003240-00003567": "had fallen into disrepair and those that", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00012-00003568-00003731": "were preserved were limited in their", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00013-00003732-00003951": "ability to serve as permanent residences", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00014-00003952-00004323": "in 2005 the tribe sought to bring life", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00015-00004324-00004532": "back to the historic plazas by", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00016-00004533-00004791": "initiating the oh na boo pina", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00017-00004792-00005034": "preservation project the project is", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00018-00005035-00005169": "rooted in the tribal leaders", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00019-00005170-00005421": "preservation philosophy which seeks to", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00020-00005422-00005577": "preserve not only the built environment", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00021-00005578-00005900": "but the life in the pueblos the tribe", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00022-00005901-00006225": "rehabilitated 34 of the 60 homes in ho", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00023-00006226-00006485": "na boo pena introducing modern amenities", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00024-00006486-00006705": "while respecting and honoring the", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00025-00006706-00006966": "traditions of the site these efforts", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00026-00006967-00007217": "allow contemporary life and cultural", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00027-00007218-00007496": "traditions to co-exist comfortably in", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00028-00007497-00007725": "order to ensure the tribal values of", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00029-00007726-00007959": "okay Oh winging would prevail within", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00030-00007959-00008232": "federal standards the ona open yet", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00031-00008233-00008439": "preservation project brought together", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00032-00008440-00008718": "state and federal agencies to create a", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00033-00008719-00008988": "new model for cultural preservation in a", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00034-00008989-00009192": "culture where preservation means", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00035-00009193-00009543": "sustaining a way of being oh na boo Pena", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00036-00009544-00009834": "shows that preservation can mean far", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00037-00009835-00010059": "more than preserving buildings it", "MMzrFvfoZNE-00038-00010060-00010425": "sustains a way of being"}}, {"audio_id": "MMKgETpwcTM", "text": {"MMKgETpwcTM-00000-00000016-00000247": "it's about pooping off the side of a", "MMKgETpwcTM-00001-00000248-00000478": "building so if you're not into that", "MMKgETpwcTM-00002-00000479-00000877": "this might not be the video for you", "MMKgETpwcTM-00003-00000878-00001335": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00004-00001336-00001527": "hi it's miranda", "MMKgETpwcTM-00005-00001528-00001782": "and um", "MMKgETpwcTM-00006-00001784-00002063": "i wanted to play something", "MMKgETpwcTM-00007-00002064-00002295": "i wanted to play something questionable", "MMKgETpwcTM-00008-00002296-00002542": "something again that's old", "MMKgETpwcTM-00009-00002543-00002623": "that", "MMKgETpwcTM-00010-00002624-00002783": "people were playing like seven eight", "MMKgETpwcTM-00011-00002784-00003055": "years ago i think and um it's about", "MMKgETpwcTM-00012-00003056-00003254": "pooping over the side of a building", "MMKgETpwcTM-00013-00003255-00003383": "i'm not kidding", "MMKgETpwcTM-00014-00003384-00003543": "it's pretty gross", "MMKgETpwcTM-00015-00003544-00003615": "but um", "MMKgETpwcTM-00016-00003615-00003799": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00017-00003800-00003990": "it's not very realistic it's very", "MMKgETpwcTM-00018-00003992-00004191": "cartoonish so", "MMKgETpwcTM-00019-00004192-00004470": "but again it's about pooping off the", "MMKgETpwcTM-00020-00004471-00004654": "side of a building so if you're not into", "MMKgETpwcTM-00021-00004655-00004743": "that", "MMKgETpwcTM-00022-00004744-00004999": "this might not be the video for you", "MMKgETpwcTM-00023-00005000-00005206": "uh if you're wondering", "MMKgETpwcTM-00024-00005207-00005422": "why would she play this", "MMKgETpwcTM-00025-00005423-00005615": "because i think that's kind of funny in", "MMKgETpwcTM-00026-00005616-00005783": "video game setting", "MMKgETpwcTM-00027-00005784-00005927": "only", "MMKgETpwcTM-00028-00005928-00006311": "so i'm going to do that", "MMKgETpwcTM-00029-00006312-00006727": "do it", "MMKgETpwcTM-00030-00006728-00007014": "okay", "MMKgETpwcTM-00031-00007015-00007534": "all right", "MMKgETpwcTM-00032-00007536-00007678": "move poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00033-00007679-00007887": "washed okay", "MMKgETpwcTM-00034-00007888-00008087": "and space bar", "MMKgETpwcTM-00035-00008088-00008478": "to jump", "MMKgETpwcTM-00036-00008479-00008618": "you ready for pooping", "MMKgETpwcTM-00037-00008619-00009319": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00038-00009320-00009678": "what did you eat", "MMKgETpwcTM-00039-00009679-00010167": "i have no money so right now", "MMKgETpwcTM-00040-00010168-00010351": "just gonna", "MMKgETpwcTM-00041-00010352-00010559": "there's our there's our poop meter", "MMKgETpwcTM-00042-00010560-00011559": "there's", "MMKgETpwcTM-00043-00011560-00013358": "wow", "MMKgETpwcTM-00044-00013359-00013727": "wasn't that wasn't that lovely", "MMKgETpwcTM-00045-00013728-00014951": "just gonna poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00046-00014952-00015686": "uh", "MMKgETpwcTM-00047-00015687-00015958": "yeah", "MMKgETpwcTM-00048-00015959-00016119": "okay", "MMKgETpwcTM-00049-00016119-00016399": "chili makes your poop's first impact", "MMKgETpwcTM-00050-00016400-00016663": "larger", "MMKgETpwcTM-00051-00016664-00016863": "okay", "MMKgETpwcTM-00052-00016864-00016958": "burger", "MMKgETpwcTM-00053-00016959-00017327": "makes your poop greasy making it slide", "MMKgETpwcTM-00054-00017328-00017903": "better", "MMKgETpwcTM-00055-00017904-00018183": "let's do it", "MMKgETpwcTM-00056-00018184-00018479": "cotton candy make sure poop lighter", "MMKgETpwcTM-00057-00018480-00018775": "because it bounces better", "MMKgETpwcTM-00058-00018776-00019527": "make sure poop larger", "MMKgETpwcTM-00059-00019528-00019822": "cotton can let's just do it in order i'm", "MMKgETpwcTM-00060-00019823-00020022": "just gonna poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00061-00020023-00020367": "this is fun", "MMKgETpwcTM-00062-00020368-00021719": "pooping together", "MMKgETpwcTM-00063-00021720-00021927": "slide in a little", "MMKgETpwcTM-00064-00021928-00022150": "didn't get as many people except for oh", "MMKgETpwcTM-00065-00022151-00022286": "yeah", "MMKgETpwcTM-00066-00022287-00022750": "but this makes it larger okay", "MMKgETpwcTM-00067-00022751-00023103": "i like burritos", "MMKgETpwcTM-00068-00023104-00023375": "can i aim for this bird", "MMKgETpwcTM-00069-00023376-00023807": "all the way makes it go too far maybe", "MMKgETpwcTM-00070-00023808-00024478": "didn't do a good job amy", "MMKgETpwcTM-00071-00024479-00024903": "slide ugh slide too much but", "MMKgETpwcTM-00072-00024904-00025230": "i made people fall", "MMKgETpwcTM-00073-00025231-00025350": "nope", "MMKgETpwcTM-00074-00025351-00025670": "why did it sound like that", "MMKgETpwcTM-00075-00025672-00026070": "it's in my hair", "MMKgETpwcTM-00076-00026072-00026399": "going after people", "MMKgETpwcTM-00077-00026400-00026646": "anyone running this line that's you how", "MMKgETpwcTM-00078-00026647-00027031": "did you manage it's in my hair", "MMKgETpwcTM-00079-00027032-00027543": "i have in the mouth and merry business", "MMKgETpwcTM-00080-00027544-00027758": "ew", "MMKgETpwcTM-00081-00027760-00028327": "sometimes you just gotta poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00082-00028327-00028535": "can i what do i", "MMKgETpwcTM-00083-00028536-00028662": "what happens if it's in the middle of", "MMKgETpwcTM-00084-00028663-00028951": "the road here", "MMKgETpwcTM-00085-00028952-00029039": "oh", "MMKgETpwcTM-00086-00029039-00029246": "i caused a whole", "MMKgETpwcTM-00087-00029247-00029483": "accident that's not", "MMKgETpwcTM-00088-00029483-00029758": "good all right wow", "MMKgETpwcTM-00089-00029760-00029951": "wow", "MMKgETpwcTM-00090-00029952-00030167": "that's a lot of destruction for one big", "MMKgETpwcTM-00091-00030168-00030302": "poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00092-00030303-00030687": "why am i playing this you ask", "MMKgETpwcTM-00093-00030688-00030895": "why wouldn't you why wouldn't you play", "MMKgETpwcTM-00094-00030895-00031070": "this", "MMKgETpwcTM-00095-00031072-00031262": "it's all about poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00096-00031263-00031462": "i missed it", "MMKgETpwcTM-00097-00031463-00031646": "can i jump am i like missing something", "MMKgETpwcTM-00098-00031647-00031751": "probably", "MMKgETpwcTM-00099-00031752-00031967": "in space", "MMKgETpwcTM-00100-00031968-00032095": "to jump", "MMKgETpwcTM-00101-00032095-00032446": "oh i can jump", "MMKgETpwcTM-00102-00032447-00032614": "i wanted to land in there", "MMKgETpwcTM-00103-00032616-00032951": "no more jumping", "MMKgETpwcTM-00104-00032952-00033111": "probably said", "MMKgETpwcTM-00105-00033112-00033287": "in the beginning or something", "MMKgETpwcTM-00106-00033288-00033518": "space bar", "MMKgETpwcTM-00107-00033519-00033679": "to jump", "MMKgETpwcTM-00108-00033680-00033887": "i tend to", "MMKgETpwcTM-00109-00033888-00034190": "miss more than i think i do", "MMKgETpwcTM-00110-00034191-00034359": "get acknowledged sometimes we're not", "MMKgETpwcTM-00111-00034360-00034615": "that cool", "MMKgETpwcTM-00112-00034616-00035711": "i mean maybe you are i am not that cool", "MMKgETpwcTM-00113-00035712-00036023": "i don't know what i'm going for now", "MMKgETpwcTM-00114-00036024-00036729": "i'm just making some really gross noises", "MMKgETpwcTM-00115-00036730-00037039": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00116-00037040-00037127": "okay", "MMKgETpwcTM-00117-00037128-00037327": "we have chicken makes your poop move", "MMKgETpwcTM-00118-00037328-00037599": "faster", "MMKgETpwcTM-00119-00037600-00037830": "milk gives you the runs your poop leaves", "MMKgETpwcTM-00120-00037831-00038215": "bigger splatters", "MMKgETpwcTM-00121-00038216-00038311": "boop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00122-00038312-00038679": "gum your poop bounces higher", "MMKgETpwcTM-00123-00038680-00038895": "in corn style points makes your poop get", "MMKgETpwcTM-00124-00038896-00039239": "a higher score in money", "MMKgETpwcTM-00125-00039240-00039655": "i don't need more money i mean", "MMKgETpwcTM-00126-00039656-00039887": "i've already purchased everything", "MMKgETpwcTM-00127-00039888-00040143": "the money is so unnecessary now", "MMKgETpwcTM-00128-00040144-00040318": "but", "MMKgETpwcTM-00129-00040319-00040759": "let's just see what happens", "MMKgETpwcTM-00130-00040760-00040846": "oh", "MMKgETpwcTM-00131-00040847-00042199": "that's great so good", "MMKgETpwcTM-00132-00042200-00043167": "it wasn't that impressive but still", "MMKgETpwcTM-00133-00043168-00043358": "trying to move", "MMKgETpwcTM-00134-00043359-00043837": "it almost lets me", "MMKgETpwcTM-00135-00043838-00044062": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00136-00044063-00044230": "i'm not doing a very good job of getting", "MMKgETpwcTM-00137-00044231-00044551": "all this extra stuff though", "MMKgETpwcTM-00138-00044552-00044646": "so", "MMKgETpwcTM-00139-00044647-00045135": "there's that i'm really good", "MMKgETpwcTM-00140-00045136-00045887": "oh and there's one", "MMKgETpwcTM-00141-00045888-00046111": "it caused all the destruction", "MMKgETpwcTM-00142-00046112-00046535": "i got torrential turd", "MMKgETpwcTM-00143-00046536-00046783": "you", "MMKgETpwcTM-00144-00046784-00047574": "no", "MMKgETpwcTM-00145-00047575-00047862": "i don't blame you it's pretty gross", "MMKgETpwcTM-00146-00047863-00048086": "that's where i belong i'm just trashy", "MMKgETpwcTM-00147-00048087-00048390": "poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00148-00048391-00048630": "i'm playing a poop game", "MMKgETpwcTM-00149-00048631-00049599": "why am i doing this", "MMKgETpwcTM-00150-00049600-00049855": "oh god what's the smell", "MMKgETpwcTM-00151-00049856-00050095": "oh jeez that's awful", "MMKgETpwcTM-00152-00050096-00050318": "that's disgusting", "MMKgETpwcTM-00153-00050319-00051030": "oh yeah it's in my hair", "MMKgETpwcTM-00154-00051031-00052854": "some of them are just air biscuits huh", "MMKgETpwcTM-00155-00052855-00053015": "do you hear those", "MMKgETpwcTM-00156-00053016-00053282": "i hope", "MMKgETpwcTM-00157-00053283-00053726": "so that's a lot of poop smear", "MMKgETpwcTM-00158-00053727-00054079": "we are class", "MMKgETpwcTM-00159-00054079-00055099": "there is class", "MMKgETpwcTM-00160-00055100-00055254": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00161-00055255-00056119": "so i've been playing a game about poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00162-00056120-00056511": "i don't know about any of you", "MMKgETpwcTM-00163-00056512-00056926": "somebody did this", "MMKgETpwcTM-00164-00056927-00057094": "oh", "MMKgETpwcTM-00165-00057095-00057326": "oh", "MMKgETpwcTM-00166-00057327-00057535": "i don't i didn't even see the thing that", "MMKgETpwcTM-00167-00057536-00057711": "i got", "MMKgETpwcTM-00168-00057712-00058087": "keep missing the bird", "MMKgETpwcTM-00169-00058088-00058345": "[Applause]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00170-00058346-00058935": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00171-00058936-00059126": "how does that work", "MMKgETpwcTM-00172-00059127-00059263": "that's quite a that's quite an", "MMKgETpwcTM-00173-00059264-00059742": "impressive smear", "MMKgETpwcTM-00174-00059744-00059854": "that's how i feel when i'm thinking", "MMKgETpwcTM-00175-00059855-00060350": "about poop apparently i got soil lamp", "MMKgETpwcTM-00176-00060351-00060479": "all right", "MMKgETpwcTM-00177-00060479-00060687": "poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00178-00060688-00060847": "we're gonna just", "MMKgETpwcTM-00179-00060848-00061238": "poop", "MMKgETpwcTM-00180-00061239-00061447": "this is so silly", "MMKgETpwcTM-00181-00061448-00061911": "i'm just pooping", "MMKgETpwcTM-00182-00061912-00062079": "all right i'm not very good at aiming", "MMKgETpwcTM-00183-00062079-00062271": "for stuff and i just really just wanted", "MMKgETpwcTM-00184-00062272-00062654": "to share", "MMKgETpwcTM-00185-00062655-00062903": "just not have a turd on there", "MMKgETpwcTM-00186-00062904-00063135": "the ridiculousness of this game", "MMKgETpwcTM-00187-00063136-00063550": "i hope you enjoyed", "MMKgETpwcTM-00188-00063551-00063782": "watching this this person poop over the", "MMKgETpwcTM-00189-00063783-00063959": "side of a building and", "MMKgETpwcTM-00190-00063960-00064271": "causing havoc", "MMKgETpwcTM-00191-00064272-00064550": "bye", "MMKgETpwcTM-00192-00064551-00065317": "and i'm sorry", "MMKgETpwcTM-00193-00065319-00066332": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00194-00066333-00066791": "[Music]", "MMKgETpwcTM-00195-00066792-00067092": "hmm"}}, {"audio_id": "MNp5CqXdCr4", "text": {"MNp5CqXdCr4-00000-00000000-00000853": "who's ready for another wearable so", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00001-00000855-00001087": "let's talk wearables some wearables are", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00002-00001088-00001324": "not very stylish but Rebecca Minkoff has", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00003-00001325-00001514": "a bracelet that is pretty to look at and", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00004-00001515-00001766": "can charge your phone having this", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00005-00001767-00001960": "bracelet is a must if you are like me", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00006-00001961-00002134": "and you're constantly needing a charge", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00007-00002135-00002405": "while staying fashionable make sure and", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00008-00002406-00002567": "check out rebecca minkoff today i'll", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00009-00002568-00002692": "leave the link below in the description", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00010-00002693-00002897": "on where you can get this bracelet make", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00011-00002898-00003041": "sure and give this video a thumbs up", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00012-00003042-00003263": "subscribe and I'll see you back here", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00013-00003264-00003503": "next week thank you so much for watching", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00014-00003504-00003688": "this video be sure to follow me on", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00015-00003689-00003922": "twitter at kelly wunderland connect with", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00016-00003923-00004136": "me on Facebook at Kelly wunderland and", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00017-00004137-00004363": "of course don't forget to subscribe to", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00018-00004364-00004574": "my youtube channel so you don't miss any", "MNp5CqXdCr4-00019-00004575-00004880": "other videos"}}, {"audio_id": "MNrI-pxW77c", "text": {"MNrI-pxW77c-00000-00000054-00000297": "the epic games store as a digital video", "MNrI-pxW77c-00001-00000298-00000536": "game storefront operated by Epic Games", "MNrI-pxW77c-00002-00000537-00001289": "it launched in December 2018", "MNrI-pxW77c-00003-00001290-00001818": "topic software", "MNrI-pxW77c-00004-00001819-00002046": "the store is available on the web and", "MNrI-pxW77c-00005-00002047-00002225": "through Epic Games launcher application", "MNrI-pxW77c-00006-00002226-00002457": "it does not have features such as", "MNrI-pxW77c-00007-00002458-00002697": "achievements or virtual reality headset", "MNrI-pxW77c-00008-00002698-00002871": "support epics own games will be", "MNrI-pxW77c-00009-00002872-00003065": "exclusively available through its store", "MNrI-pxW77c-00010-00003066-00003267": "and the company plans to fund developers", "MNrI-pxW77c-00011-00003268-00003429": "to release exclusively through their", "MNrI-pxW77c-00012-00003429-00003654": "store epic plans to offer one free game", "MNrI-pxW77c-00013-00003654-00004349": "every two weeks through 2019", "MNrI-pxW77c-00014-00004350-00004852": "topic history", "MNrI-pxW77c-00015-00004853-00005086": "prior to the epic game store the", "MNrI-pxW77c-00016-00005087-00005302": "principle digital distribution channel", "MNrI-pxW77c-00017-00005303-00005506": "for personal computer games was valve", "MNrI-pxW77c-00018-00005507-00005684": "steam though other competitors like", "MNrI-pxW77c-00019-00005685-00006034": "gog.com origin and Uplay existed valve", "MNrI-pxW77c-00020-00006035-00006245": "took a 30 percent revenue cut of all", "MNrI-pxW77c-00021-00006246-00006436": "games sold via Steam which at the time", "MNrI-pxW77c-00022-00006437-00006634": "steam launched was comparable to other", "MNrI-pxW77c-00023-00006636-00006830": "digital distribution networks like the", "MNrI-pxW77c-00024-00006831-00007193": "App Store in August 2017 epics Tim", "MNrI-pxW77c-00025-00007194-00007463": "Sweeney suggested that 30% was no longer", "MNrI-pxW77c-00026-00007464-00007648": "a reasonable cut and that valve could", "MNrI-pxW77c-00027-00007650-00007820": "still profit if they cut their revenue", "MNrI-pxW77c-00028-00007820-00008149": "share to 8% in early December 2018 Epic", "MNrI-pxW77c-00029-00008150-00008305": "Games announced that it would open a", "MNrI-pxW77c-00030-00008306-00008494": "digital storefront to challenge steam", "MNrI-pxW77c-00031-00008495-00008741": "epic planned to compete with valve on", "MNrI-pxW77c-00032-00008742-00008999": "Game Developers share of profits 88%", "MNrI-pxW77c-00033-00009000-00009352": "with epic against 70% with val epic", "MNrI-pxW77c-00034-00009353-00009580": "would also forego the standard 5%", "MNrI-pxW77c-00035-00009581-00009758": "Revenue fee normally applied to games", "MNrI-pxW77c-00036-00009759-00009932": "using the Unreal Engine if they were", "MNrI-pxW77c-00037-00009933-00010193": "published on the epic game store by", "MNrI-pxW77c-00038-00010194-00010405": "epics calculations the storefronts", "MNrI-pxW77c-00039-00010406-00010574": "reduced portion of profits was", "MNrI-pxW77c-00040-00010575-00010849": "sufficient to be profitable epic also", "MNrI-pxW77c-00041-00010850-00011027": "said that it wouldn't impose digital", "MNrI-pxW77c-00042-00011028-00011260": "rights management DRM restrictions on", "MNrI-pxW77c-00043-00011261-00011504": "games sold through its platform the", "MNrI-pxW77c-00044-00011505-00011741": "store opened days later on December 6", "MNrI-pxW77c-00045-00011742-00012002": "2018 as part of the game Awards with a", "MNrI-pxW77c-00046-00012003-00012194": "handful of games and a short list of", "MNrI-pxW77c-00047-00012195-00012491": "upcoming titles the store is expected to", "MNrI-pxW77c-00048-00012492-00012658": "open for Mac OS and Windows platforms", "MNrI-pxW77c-00049-00012659-00012905": "before expanding to Android and other", "MNrI-pxW77c-00050-00012906-00013244": "platforms prior to the stores launch its", "MNrI-pxW77c-00051-00013244-00013475": "director of publishing strategy Sergey", "MNrI-pxW77c-00052-00013476-00013682": "gali aankhen head runs steam spy a", "MNrI-pxW77c-00053-00013683-00013894": "website that collected steam usage data", "MNrI-pxW77c-00054-00013895-00014119": "from public profiles to create public", "MNrI-pxW77c-00055-00014120-00014222": "sales statistics", "MNrI-pxW77c-00056-00014222-00014507": "he ran the site as a side project but", "MNrI-pxW77c-00057-00014508-00014675": "used it to learn what developers would", "MNrI-pxW77c-00058-00014676-00014869": "want from epics store namely fewer", "MNrI-pxW77c-00059-00014870-00015072": "social elements and less visual clutter", "MNrI-pxW77c-00060-00015073-00015353": "the store will be hand curated until it", "MNrI-pxW77c-00061-00015354-00015550": "opens to developer submissions in mid", "MNrI-pxW77c-00062-00015551-00015838": "201 9 once at this point", "MNrI-pxW77c-00063-00015840-00016016": "epics staff will still need to approve", "MNrI-pxW77c-00064-00016016-00016205": "games for the store a process that", "MNrI-pxW77c-00065-00016206-00016508": "mostly focus s on the technical side of", "MNrI-pxW77c-00066-00016509-00016855": "things and general quality according to", "MNrI-pxW77c-00067-00016856-00017089": "Tim Sweeney epic does not plan to allow", "MNrI-pxW77c-00068-00017090-00017462": "adults only mature content on the store", "MNrI-pxW77c-00069-00017463-00017812": "you", "MNrI-pxW77c-00070-00017813-00018322": "topic reaction", "MNrI-pxW77c-00071-00018323-00018571": "the epic game store was announced a few", "MNrI-pxW77c-00072-00018572-00018769": "days after valve had revealed a change", "MNrI-pxW77c-00073-00018770-00018967": "in the steam revenue sharing model that", "MNrI-pxW77c-00074-00018968-00019147": "reduced valves take reducing their", "MNrI-pxW77c-00075-00019148-00019375": "revenue cut from 30 percent to 25", "MNrI-pxW77c-00076-00019376-00019582": "percent after a game made more than 10", "MNrI-pxW77c-00077-00019583-00019797": "million dollars and to 20 percent after", "MNrI-pxW77c-00078-00019798-00020097": "fifty million dollars several indie game", "MNrI-pxW77c-00079-00020098-00020302": "developers expressed concern that this", "MNrI-pxW77c-00080-00020303-00020467": "change was meant to help keep larger", "MNrI-pxW77c-00081-00020468-00020680": "triple-a developers and publishers and", "MNrI-pxW77c-00082-00020681-00020875": "did little to support smaller developers", "MNrI-pxW77c-00083-00020876-00021157": "as such when the epic games store was", "MNrI-pxW77c-00084-00021158-00021358": "announced several journalists cite is", "MNrI-pxW77c-00085-00021359-00021555": "potentially disruptive to steams current", "MNrI-pxW77c-00086-00021556-00021814": "model some developers have already", "MNrI-pxW77c-00087-00021815-00022005": "announced plans to release games that", "MNrI-pxW77c-00088-00022006-00022131": "they were planning to release through", "MNrI-pxW77c-00089-00022132-00022324": "Steam now exclusively through the epic", "MNrI-pxW77c-00090-00022325-00022530": "game store or to have time exclusivity", "MNrI-pxW77c-00091-00022531-00022753": "on epics storefront before appearing on", "MNrI-pxW77c-00092-00022754-00023004": "other services"}}, {"audio_id": "MNskJazWMWU", "text": {"MNskJazWMWU-00000-00000016-00000371": "okay mom"}}, {"audio_id": "MNwqdsibWmM", "text": {"MNwqdsibWmM-00000-00000908-00001569": "[Music]", "MNwqdsibWmM-00001-00001570-00001759": "sonic boom", "MNwqdsibWmM-00002-00001760-00001921": "what's the boom you hear what's the", "MNwqdsibWmM-00003-00001922-00002182": "sound you hear last two years I've", "MNwqdsibWmM-00004-00002183-00002437": "worked on this book predicting a major", "MNwqdsibWmM-00005-00002438-00002695": "global economic boom my wife thought I", "MNwqdsibWmM-00006-00002696-00002914": "was crazy my editor thought I was crazy", "MNwqdsibWmM-00007-00002915-00003154": "I hope I'm not crazy obviously there are", "MNwqdsibWmM-00008-00003155-00003336": "many problems in the world economically", "MNwqdsibWmM-00009-00003338-00003550": "but I think a global increase of", "MNwqdsibWmM-00010-00003551-00003715": "prosperity is about to happen", "MNwqdsibWmM-00011-00003715-00003847": "I think the developing world especially", "MNwqdsibWmM-00012-00003847-00004075": "which needs it the most is going to", "MNwqdsibWmM-00013-00004076-00004267": "become much better off than your future", "MNwqdsibWmM-00014-00004268-00004468": "I couldn't get over the fact that you", "MNwqdsibWmM-00015-00004469-00004666": "were bringing us these new ideas that", "MNwqdsibWmM-00016-00004667-00004930": "actually made the Sun Shine for one", "MNwqdsibWmM-00017-00004931-00005503": "brief second in my afternoon you said", "MNwqdsibWmM-00018-00005504-00005713": "there is no question that there will be", "MNwqdsibWmM-00019-00005714-00005973": "double the ideas in the world because", "MNwqdsibWmM-00020-00005974-00006238": "women will be participating in full", "MNwqdsibWmM-00021-00006239-00006481": "force as recently as the last generation", "MNwqdsibWmM-00022-00006481-00006676": "most of the world's women have very", "MNwqdsibWmM-00023-00006677-00006909": "little ability to participate in science", "MNwqdsibWmM-00024-00006911-00007185": "engineering business management the", "MNwqdsibWmM-00025-00007186-00007384": "administration of governments hasn't", "MNwqdsibWmM-00026-00007384-00007548": "changed everywhere now but it is in the", "MNwqdsibWmM-00027-00007550-00007789": "process of changing so this means one to", "MNwqdsibWmM-00028-00007790-00008020": "two generations down the road twice as", "MNwqdsibWmM-00029-00008020-00008134": "many people in the world will be", "MNwqdsibWmM-00030-00008134-00008296": "contributing to the global supply of", "MNwqdsibWmM-00031-00008297-00008518": "ideas and I think that will lead to a", "MNwqdsibWmM-00032-00008519-00009061": "flowering of more progress you also had", "MNwqdsibWmM-00033-00009062-00009355": "a sentence which really struck me fewer", "MNwqdsibWmM-00034-00009356-00009661": "people are dying in battle that any time", "MNwqdsibWmM-00035-00009662-00009907": "in the history of the planet your chance", "MNwqdsibWmM-00036-00009908-00010071": "of dying in battle in the last 20 years", "MNwqdsibWmM-00037-00010072-00010203": "has been the lowest in human history", "MNwqdsibWmM-00038-00010204-00010503": "Iraq and Afghanistan and Sudan are", "MNwqdsibWmM-00039-00010504-00010702": "terrible exceptions to an overall rule", "MNwqdsibWmM-00040-00010703-00010989": "of less combat fewer deaths from combat", "MNwqdsibWmM-00041-00010990-00011251": "less global military spending has been", "MNwqdsibWmM-00042-00011252-00011449": "going down for 20 years the end of the", "MNwqdsibWmM-00043-00011450-00011674": "Cold War is one factor but I think", "MNwqdsibWmM-00044-00011675-00011896": "economic interconnectedness is another", "MNwqdsibWmM-00045-00011897-00012112": "factor nations are now competing for", "MNwqdsibWmM-00046-00012113-00012292": "market share more than they're competing", "MNwqdsibWmM-00047-00012293-00012505": "for territory and there's lots of things", "MNwqdsibWmM-00048-00012506-00012694": "wrong with that I mean obviously our", "MNwqdsibWmM-00049-00012695-00012846": "relationship with the Chinese drives us", "MNwqdsibWmM-00050-00012847-00013089": "crazy but it's so much better than", "MNwqdsibWmM-00051-00013090-00013239": "military competition that there's just", "MNwqdsibWmM-00052-00013240-00013503": "no comparison", "MNwqdsibWmM-00053-00013504-00013918": "you say that the manufacturing drought", "MNwqdsibWmM-00054-00013919-00014197": "the manufacturing collapse that is", "MNwqdsibWmM-00055-00014197-00014410": "hitting America is also hitting China", "MNwqdsibWmM-00056-00014411-00014635": "and we don't take that into account that", "MNwqdsibWmM-00057-00014636-00014830": "they've got a banana peel in their", "MNwqdsibWmM-00058-00014831-00015019": "economy - well see it's not", "MNwqdsibWmM-00059-00015019-00015180": "manufacturing manufacturing ZUP", "MNwqdsibWmM-00060-00015181-00015397": "everywhere it's jobs in manufacturing", "MNwqdsibWmM-00061-00015397-00015630": "that are done and I think this would", "MNwqdsibWmM-00062-00015631-00015894": "have happened regardless of the", "MNwqdsibWmM-00063-00015895-00016096": "financial panic of recent years that", "MNwqdsibWmM-00064-00016097-00016213": "states has lost six million", "MNwqdsibWmM-00065-00016213-00016504": "manufacturing jobs in the last decade in", "MNwqdsibWmM-00066-00016505-00016741": "the same period China's lost 28 million", "MNwqdsibWmM-00067-00016742-00016987": "because of more efficient forms of", "MNwqdsibWmM-00068-00016988-00017209": "manufacturing more efficient forms of", "MNwqdsibWmM-00069-00017210-00017407": "manufacturing are good news for most", "MNwqdsibWmM-00070-00017408-00017557": "people will they keep prices down", "MNwqdsibWmM-00071-00017558-00017767": "improve products they're real bad news", "MNwqdsibWmM-00072-00017768-00018025": "appear a factory worker so we see this", "MNwqdsibWmM-00073-00018026-00018225": "transition away from lots of jobs and", "MNwqdsibWmM-00074-00018226-00018361": "factories it would have happened", "MNwqdsibWmM-00075-00018362-00018529": "regardless the same thing happened in", "MNwqdsibWmM-00076-00018530-00018747": "agriculture hundred years ago 100 years", "MNwqdsibWmM-00077-00018748-00018997": "ago 70% of Americans worked in", "MNwqdsibWmM-00078-00018998-00019243": "agriculture today it's 2 percent if you", "MNwqdsibWmM-00079-00019244-00019465": "told somebody 100 years ago that in the", "MNwqdsibWmM-00080-00019466-00019708": "year 2010 two percent of Americans who", "MNwqdsibWmM-00081-00019709-00019855": "were connected I said oh my god it's", "MNwqdsibWmM-00082-00019856-00020266": "gonna be the end of the world if those", "MNwqdsibWmM-00083-00020267-00020659": "manufacturing jobs are shrinking where", "MNwqdsibWmM-00084-00020660-00021013": "did the job surface what's the new 60", "MNwqdsibWmM-00085-00021014-00021127": "percent of Americans know working", "MNwqdsibWmM-00086-00021128-00021343": "white-collar professions white-collar", "MNwqdsibWmM-00087-00021344-00021565": "professions are far from ideal many of", "MNwqdsibWmM-00088-00021566-00021739": "them are very stressful so people don't", "MNwqdsibWmM-00089-00021740-00021886": "like being cubicles like the people", "MNwqdsibWmM-00090-00021887-00022114": "behind you ABC News well maybe they", "MNwqdsibWmM-00091-00022115-00022309": "maybe they like it they love it they", "MNwqdsibWmM-00092-00022310-00022468": "love it okay they're very happy if you", "MNwqdsibWmM-00093-00022469-00022714": "told your great-grandparents look most", "MNwqdsibWmM-00094-00022715-00022843": "of your great-grandchildren are going to", "MNwqdsibWmM-00095-00022844-00023034": "work in air-conditioned offices they", "MNwqdsibWmM-00096-00023035-00023175": "will not do anything back waking a", "MNwqdsibWmM-00097-00023176-00023356": "physically dangerous they will have", "MNwqdsibWmM-00098-00023357-00023494": "stressful relationships with their", "MNwqdsibWmM-00099-00023495-00023709": "bosses but they're not gonna be working", "MNwqdsibWmM-00100-00023710-00023917": "in mines or cutting down trees your", "MNwqdsibWmM-00101-00023918-00024034": "great-grandparents with a son that's", "MNwqdsibWmM-00102-00024035-00024268": "great Greg Leesburg thank you so much", "MNwqdsibWmM-00103-00024269-00024397": "good to talk to you", "MNwqdsibWmM-00104-00024398-00024679": "great thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "MNygmVL7CiA", "text": {"MNygmVL7CiA-00000-00001001-00001291": "welcome to the cube it's a wonderful", "MNygmVL7CiA-00001-00001292-00001603": "Tuesday and we're here talking to Craig", "MNygmVL7CiA-00002-00001604-00001807": "noonas who's the VP of Marketing at des", "MNygmVL7CiA-00003-00001809-00002072": "trium good to be here and Craig who guys", "MNygmVL7CiA-00004-00002073-00002198": "had announcement today in the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00005-00002199-00002420": "announcement particularly refers to the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00006-00002421-00002654": "further convergence or the opportunity", "MNygmVL7CiA-00007-00002655-00002807": "to further converge not only hardware", "MNygmVL7CiA-00008-00002808-00002981": "but now increasingly operating", "MNygmVL7CiA-00009-00002982-00003160": "environment specifically bringing up", "MNygmVL7CiA-00010-00003161-00003511": "some of the Red Hat ecosystem over to", "MNygmVL7CiA-00011-00003513-00003794": "the day trium product set so once tell", "MNygmVL7CiA-00012-00003795-00004165": "us what pattern well we've been making a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00013-00004166-00004499": "great business with customers in the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00014-00004500-00005036": "VMware environment we debuted our kind", "MNygmVL7CiA-00015-00005037-00005267": "of new generation of convergence back", "MNygmVL7CiA-00016-00005268-00005783": "last year and as we were picking up", "MNygmVL7CiA-00017-00005784-00006118": "customers in vSphere we're running into", "MNygmVL7CiA-00018-00006119-00006308": "a number of them who are saying you know", "MNygmVL7CiA-00019-00006309-00006659": "god this is awesome I do have some Linux", "MNygmVL7CiA-00020-00006659-00007021": "stuff going on can you guys help me out", "MNygmVL7CiA-00021-00007022-00007375": "there I can't seem to you know find a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00022-00007376-00007745": "modern converged platform to really take", "MNygmVL7CiA-00023-00007745-00008063": "on both environments and and so that's", "MNygmVL7CiA-00024-00008064-00008234": "precisely what we've done we're", "MNygmVL7CiA-00025-00008235-00008480": "announcing today that we've partnered", "MNygmVL7CiA-00026-00008481-00009044": "with Red Hat to use their stack red Red", "MNygmVL7CiA-00027-00009045-00009364": "Hat Enterprise Linux and and their full", "MNygmVL7CiA-00028-00009365-00009724": "Red Hat virtualization stack run that on", "MNygmVL7CiA-00029-00009725-00010126": "our dvx on our compute nodes alongside", "MNygmVL7CiA-00030-00010127-00010805": "vSphere servers beyond that because we", "MNygmVL7CiA-00031-00010806-00011180": "observe there's a lot of activity going", "MNygmVL7CiA-00032-00011181-00011446": "on in the container space and just a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00033-00011447-00011720": "little CI CD is becoming something that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00034-00011721-00011951": "more and more folks are moving to we've", "MNygmVL7CiA-00035-00011952-00012142": "also partnered up with docker and we're", "MNygmVL7CiA-00036-00012143-00012428": "also going to provide bare metal", "MNygmVL7CiA-00037-00012429-00012659": "container support with a persistent", "MNygmVL7CiA-00038-00012660-00012961": "volume plugin for the platform so this", "MNygmVL7CiA-00039-00012962-00013232": "is all in one go you now have really for", "MNygmVL7CiA-00040-00013233-00013319": "the first time", "MNygmVL7CiA-00041-00013321-00013644": "a modern converged system that can you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00042-00013644-00013860": "know handle what you're doing today with", "MNygmVL7CiA-00043-00013861-00014213": "vSphere probably handle what you you're", "MNygmVL7CiA-00044-00014215-00014397": "already involved in but you're looking", "MNygmVL7CiA-00045-00014397-00014574": "for a way to bring this stuff together", "MNygmVL7CiA-00046-00014575-00014907": "in your your Red Hat environment but", "MNygmVL7CiA-00047-00014908-00015075": "then more importantly you're kind of set", "MNygmVL7CiA-00048-00015076-00015279": "up for you know where you're going with", "MNygmVL7CiA-00049-00015280-00015338": "containers", "MNygmVL7CiA-00050-00015340-00015633": "so when you say handle a date Rheem has", "MNygmVL7CiA-00051-00015634-00015768": "made some interesting decisions", "MNygmVL7CiA-00052-00015769-00016086": "regarding the how to solve some of the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00053-00016087-00016212": "engineering problems associated with", "MNygmVL7CiA-00054-00016213-00016569": "convergence yeah yeah take us through a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00055-00016570-00016752": "little bit about what it means to handle", "MNygmVL7CiA-00056-00016753-00017127": "so here what were you doing on VM of yem", "MNygmVL7CiA-00057-00017128-00017415": "where that you're now especially doing", "MNygmVL7CiA-00058-00017416-00017676": "on the Red Hat ecosystem and we'll be", "MNygmVL7CiA-00059-00017677-00017919": "doing F as you move more closely towards", "MNygmVL7CiA-00060-00017920-00018165": "containers so in the world of converge", "MNygmVL7CiA-00061-00018166-00018501": "infrastructure you know of course we", "MNygmVL7CiA-00062-00018502-00018678": "started with kind of packaging", "MNygmVL7CiA-00063-00018679-00018942": "convergence with arrays and servers and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00064-00018943-00019161": "hyperconvergence came along to really", "MNygmVL7CiA-00065-00019162-00019433": "bring storage into the x86 architecture", "MNygmVL7CiA-00066-00019434-00020061": "a super cool idea in principle the the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00067-00020062-00020313": "challenge with that is because storage", "MNygmVL7CiA-00068-00020314-00020556": "is now part of your server everything is", "MNygmVL7CiA-00069-00020557-00020724": "stateful everything is a storage node", "MNygmVL7CiA-00070-00020725-00021003": "and you know it's tougher to scale it's", "MNygmVL7CiA-00071-00021004-00021281": "tougher to service and and you know", "MNygmVL7CiA-00072-00021282-00021531": "taking nothing away from the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00073-00021532-00021705": "hyper-converged guys it's great for", "MNygmVL7CiA-00074-00021706-00022017": "single use case great for edge but we're", "MNygmVL7CiA-00075-00022018-00022233": "really aiming for you know what people", "MNygmVL7CiA-00076-00022234-00022371": "are trying to get done in the private", "MNygmVL7CiA-00077-00022372-00022602": "cloud datacenter and so for that we", "MNygmVL7CiA-00078-00022603-00022959": "found that by separating the persistence", "MNygmVL7CiA-00079-00022960-00023160": "the durable capacity from the i/o", "MNygmVL7CiA-00080-00023161-00023424": "processing on the server we could", "MNygmVL7CiA-00081-00023425-00023622": "provide this wonderful converged", "MNygmVL7CiA-00082-00023623-00023967": "platform that scales that you can use", "MNygmVL7CiA-00083-00023968-00024138": "any server you like you can bring your", "MNygmVL7CiA-00084-00024139-00024360": "blades you could use our own compute", "MNygmVL7CiA-00085-00024361-00024690": "nodes whatever and it gives folks just a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00086-00024691-00024990": "lot more freedom to get get the job done", "MNygmVL7CiA-00087-00024991-00025149": "servers are stateless like they were", "MNygmVL7CiA-00088-00025150-00025362": "with your arrays but have all the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00089-00025363-00025634": "benefits that you're desiring with a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00090-00025635-00025893": "converged infrastructure so we brought", "MNygmVL7CiA-00091-00025894-00026136": "that to vSphere and what folks have", "MNygmVL7CiA-00092-00026137-00026412": "taken away is Wow since everything runs", "MNygmVL7CiA-00093-00026413-00026670": "local on the server and flash", "MNygmVL7CiA-00094-00026670-00026856": "it's faster than an all-flash erasure", "MNygmVL7CiA-00095-00026857-00027243": "because there's no sin but it's all you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00096-00027244-00027620": "know vm based and brings all the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00097-00027622-00027899": "simplicity you would expect from a hyper", "MNygmVL7CiA-00098-00027900-00028239": "converge platform only at scale and so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00099-00028239-00028605": "and so what we're doing is taking that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00100-00028606-00029071": "model to Linux and containers now one", "MNygmVL7CiA-00101-00029072-00029283": "relatively new thing we did just", "MNygmVL7CiA-00102-00029283-00029520": "recently in addition to you know taking", "MNygmVL7CiA-00103-00029520-00029664": "on kind of be in consolidation", "MNygmVL7CiA-00104-00029664-00030093": "acceleration we built right in all the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00105-00030094-00030312": "data management capabilities you would", "MNygmVL7CiA-00106-00030313-00030582": "need for you know backup an instant", "MNygmVL7CiA-00107-00030583-00030861": "recovery disaster recovery archive", "MNygmVL7CiA-00108-00030862-00031236": "compliance search analytics copy data", "MNygmVL7CiA-00109-00031237-00031458": "management right into the platform so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00110-00031458-00031715": "really the virtualization guy the DevOps", "MNygmVL7CiA-00111-00031716-00032129": "guy or gal whoever is running the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00112-00032130-00032436": "applications can not only run them but", "MNygmVL7CiA-00113-00032437-00032835": "protect them share them etc from one", "MNygmVL7CiA-00114-00032836-00033054": "cockpit one UI so we're really bringing", "MNygmVL7CiA-00115-00033055-00033308": "you know taking a whole load of stuff", "MNygmVL7CiA-00116-00033309-00033614": "that folks have had to deal with and and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00117-00033615-00033815": "tossing that for you know one very", "MNygmVL7CiA-00118-00033816-00034032": "simple platform that scales as you grow", "MNygmVL7CiA-00119-00034033-00034283": "so you're bringing new services to the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00120-00034284-00034539": "basic management console of date reom", "MNygmVL7CiA-00121-00034540-00034836": "and expanding that set of services exact", "MNygmVL7CiA-00122-00034837-00035004": "loud for that's right so talk to us a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00123-00035005-00035196": "little bit about how you see this", "MNygmVL7CiA-00124-00035197-00035481": "evolving as the whole world of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00125-00035482-00035664": "containers comes on because as you know", "MNygmVL7CiA-00126-00035665-00035918": "containers means more of them new", "MNygmVL7CiA-00127-00035919-00036207": "security models today most communication", "MNygmVL7CiA-00128-00036208-00036486": "takes place through the VM yeah when you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00129-00036487-00036642": "start talking about adding the kind of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00130-00036643-00036831": "storage flexibility of data flexible", "MNygmVL7CiA-00131-00036832-00037043": "event guys providing it suggests that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00132-00037044-00037248": "you've got some new ways of looking at", "MNygmVL7CiA-00133-00037249-00037401": "containers your applicants an absolutely", "MNygmVL7CiA-00134-00037402-00037581": "talked a little bit about yeah here is", "MNygmVL7CiA-00135-00037582-00038039": "where you know a modern platform really", "MNygmVL7CiA-00136-00038040-00038343": "is important and and again not to knock", "MNygmVL7CiA-00137-00038344-00038556": "hyper-converged but you know five or six", "MNygmVL7CiA-00138-00038557-00038829": "years ago when that was born it was", "MNygmVL7CiA-00139-00038830-00039065": "pretty cool to manage things that a VM", "MNygmVL7CiA-00140-00039066-00039290": "level right an era virtualization was", "MNygmVL7CiA-00141-00039291-00039602": "hot and heavy as we move into containers", "MNygmVL7CiA-00142-00039603-00040047": "you know VMs are just not granular in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00143-00040048-00040347": "enough and in fact folks want to be able", "MNygmVL7CiA-00144-00040348-00040601": "to manage at this per container level", "MNygmVL7CiA-00145-00040602-00040875": "arrays you know we're talking about Lunz", "MNygmVL7CiA-00146-00040876-00041154": "they're hyper-converged is going to stop", "MNygmVL7CiA-00147-00041155-00041451": "it short at VMs and so what we're", "MNygmVL7CiA-00148-00041452-00041724": "bringing folks is a way to manage you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00149-00041725-00042099": "know in the VM side VMS v disks files", "MNygmVL7CiA-00150-00042100-00042468": "that make up VMs individual container", "MNygmVL7CiA-00151-00042469-00042924": "persistent volumes so you can protect", "MNygmVL7CiA-00152-00042925-00043098": "and share the way you need to and what", "MNygmVL7CiA-00153-00043099-00043449": "we do because it's kind of a you know", "MNygmVL7CiA-00154-00043450-00043638": "double edged sword you can manage", "MNygmVL7CiA-00155-00043639-00043872": "everything at that level but now you've", "MNygmVL7CiA-00156-00043873-00044067": "got thousands and thousands of them so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00157-00044068-00044253": "we actually give you an opportunity to", "MNygmVL7CiA-00158-00044254-00044514": "group those what we call protection", "MNygmVL7CiA-00159-00044515-00044828": "groups think of it as a policy group and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00160-00044829-00045132": "we've set it up around your applications", "MNygmVL7CiA-00161-00045133-00045509": "and you set your policies per group and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00162-00045510-00046005": "through naming conventions if you spin", "MNygmVL7CiA-00163-00046006-00046284": "up a new VM or container it's going to", "MNygmVL7CiA-00164-00046285-00046551": "get included as a part of that group", "MNygmVL7CiA-00165-00046552-00046791": "without you having to you know manually", "MNygmVL7CiA-00166-00046792-00047028": "go in and assign it so we're we're", "MNygmVL7CiA-00167-00047029-00047298": "effectively putting the capabilities in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00168-00047299-00047592": "so you can manage tens of thousands of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00169-00047593-00048045": "objects very simply and that is the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00170-00048046-00048225": "world of containers right if you thought", "MNygmVL7CiA-00171-00048226-00048402": "there were a lot of VM there's a whole", "MNygmVL7CiA-00172-00048403-00048567": "lot more in the way of containers", "MNygmVL7CiA-00173-00048568-00048684": "that'll be there well one of the things", "MNygmVL7CiA-00174-00048685-00048855": "that a tree has done correctly if I have", "MNygmVL7CiA-00175-00048856-00049053": "this wrong leave I got it right is one", "MNygmVL7CiA-00176-00049054-00049188": "of the things daydrian is done is it", "MNygmVL7CiA-00177-00049189-00049365": "facilitated the kind of any-to-any", "MNygmVL7CiA-00178-00049366-00049470": "addressability", "MNygmVL7CiA-00179-00049471-00049746": "between storage or compute resources and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00180-00049747-00050061": "and data resources sprang the various", "MNygmVL7CiA-00181-00050062-00050214": "types of nodes that are in there so you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00182-00050215-00050397": "used to have all the data inside a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00183-00050398-00050583": "particular server and that kind of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00184-00050584-00050828": "creates an segmentation wrangles lines", "MNygmVL7CiA-00185-00050829-00051108": "and so you men respect you created", "MNygmVL7CiA-00186-00051109-00051327": "networks of resources the day tree only", "MNygmVL7CiA-00187-00051328-00051540": "managed in that way are you doing", "MNygmVL7CiA-00188-00051541-00051657": "something similar as we think about", "MNygmVL7CiA-00189-00051658-00051790": "containers where you're literally", "MNygmVL7CiA-00190-00051791-00052026": "describing a network of containers as", "MNygmVL7CiA-00191-00052027-00052260": "part of that resource mix and being able", "MNygmVL7CiA-00192-00052261-00052404": "to add things to that is that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00193-00052404-00052602": "effectively what the group becomes yeah", "MNygmVL7CiA-00194-00052603-00052887": "the the group of containers is", "MNygmVL7CiA-00195-00052888-00053235": "completely independent of the servers", "MNygmVL7CiA-00196-00053236-00053324": "that our hosts", "MNygmVL7CiA-00197-00053325-00053798": "them so you can literally you know group", "MNygmVL7CiA-00198-00053799-00054110": "a collection of containers across all of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00199-00054111-00054470": "your Linux servers and and you know", "MNygmVL7CiA-00200-00054471-00054701": "treat that in a special way and so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00201-00054702-00055034": "you've got great flexibility and it's", "MNygmVL7CiA-00202-00055035-00055289": "like I say it's something that is really", "MNygmVL7CiA-00203-00055290-00055550": "intended to scale we've got some very", "MNygmVL7CiA-00204-00055551-00055871": "powerful search tools as a part of that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00205-00055872-00056060": "so if you do need to find things quickly", "MNygmVL7CiA-00206-00056061-00056312": "and get it rolling when it comes to", "MNygmVL7CiA-00207-00056313-00056546": "containers you know it's all about you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00208-00056547-00057101": "know speed keeping keeping up the pace", "MNygmVL7CiA-00209-00057102-00057705": "and partly what we bring to the party is", "MNygmVL7CiA-00210-00057707-00058115": "great data reduction capabilities so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00211-00058116-00058325": "when you're doing development in like a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00212-00058326-00058637": "let's pick on a Jenkins development", "MNygmVL7CiA-00213-00058638-00058802": "environment you've got you know master", "MNygmVL7CiA-00214-00058803-00059204": "slave and you are collecting data as", "MNygmVL7CiA-00215-00059204-00059576": "part of every every object all of that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00216-00059577-00059777": "stuff has to move through the master and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00217-00059778-00060041": "the better you are at handling data", "MNygmVL7CiA-00218-00060041-00060422": "efficiency the the faster your runtime", "MNygmVL7CiA-00219-00060423-00060682": "is going to be we're observing about a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00220-00060683-00060995": "30% faster runtime for developers in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00221-00060996-00061279": "that Jenkins environment and capacity", "MNygmVL7CiA-00222-00061280-00061652": "wise we're probably consuming 95% less", "MNygmVL7CiA-00223-00061653-00061940": "capacity then you otherwise would have", "MNygmVL7CiA-00224-00061941-00062125": "to do in kind of your more traditional", "MNygmVL7CiA-00225-00062126-00062482": "storage environment so maybe 5% it it is", "MNygmVL7CiA-00226-00062483-00062779": "a 20 to one reduction because there are", "MNygmVL7CiA-00227-00062780-00063128": "so many copies in development and you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00228-00063129-00063347": "know we can D do Paul of that away so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00229-00063348-00063620": "it's fundamentally a breakthrough for", "MNygmVL7CiA-00230-00063621-00063875": "guys thinking about development test", "MNygmVL7CiA-00231-00063876-00064189": "DevOps etc so you talk about capacity", "MNygmVL7CiA-00232-00064190-00064414": "improvements that you get a stupid", "MNygmVL7CiA-00233-00064415-00064682": "improvements but as you said when we", "MNygmVL7CiA-00234-00064683-00064874": "start going to containers we", "MNygmVL7CiA-00235-00064875-00065090": "increasingly start thinking about how", "MNygmVL7CiA-00236-00065091-00065303": "fast we can add new function how fast we", "MNygmVL7CiA-00237-00065304-00065489": "can bring new capabilities together and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00238-00065490-00065660": "and one of the things that we're", "MNygmVL7CiA-00239-00065661-00065828": "fascinating about this will be tell me", "MNygmVL7CiA-00240-00065829-00066061": "if this is a benefit that you see is", "MNygmVL7CiA-00241-00066062-00066464": "that it dramatically accelerates the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00242-00066465-00066583": "entire cross", "MNygmVL7CiA-00243-00066584-00066781": "of doing Development Bank you have a", "MNygmVL7CiA-00244-00066782-00067051": "four five seven twelve times does it", "MNygmVL7CiA-00245-00067052-00067276": "lead yeah in the development process and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00246-00067277-00067474": "not only get better run time and do you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00247-00067475-00067729": "get dramatically better utilization of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00248-00067730-00068005": "resources but you were also accelerating", "MNygmVL7CiA-00249-00068006-00068212": "the productivity of people yeah but are", "MNygmVL7CiA-00250-00068213-00068341": "actually on the work are you getting", "MNygmVL7CiA-00251-00068342-00068539": "that as well absolutely there's in fact", "MNygmVL7CiA-00252-00068540-00068716": "there are two two things going on here", "MNygmVL7CiA-00253-00068717-00069051": "one is as part of the platform when you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00254-00069052-00069400": "clone a container you know you do that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00255-00069401-00069673": "on your your dev server or whatever that", "MNygmVL7CiA-00256-00069674-00070045": "clone is immediately available to all", "MNygmVL7CiA-00257-00070046-00070332": "other servers in the cluster there is no", "MNygmVL7CiA-00258-00070333-00070729": "copying and and moving around it is", "MNygmVL7CiA-00259-00070730-00070981": "immediately available for the developers", "MNygmVL7CiA-00260-00070982-00071257": "who just can go the the other", "MNygmVL7CiA-00261-00071258-00071709": "interesting thing is there are in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00262-00071710-00071931": "development environments depending on", "MNygmVL7CiA-00263-00071932-00072346": "the number of developers and executives", "MNygmVL7CiA-00264-00072347-00072739": "involved in development you can have", "MNygmVL7CiA-00265-00072740-00073066": "problems maintaining the state that you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00266-00073067-00073474": "desire and so part of what we are doing", "MNygmVL7CiA-00267-00073475-00073657": "here with these very efficient cloning", "MNygmVL7CiA-00268-00073658-00073982": "capabilities we can spin up a new", "MNygmVL7CiA-00269-00073983-00074218": "environment for folks that is you know", "MNygmVL7CiA-00270-00074219-00074443": "got pristine state which means down the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00271-00074444-00074698": "line quality is better and you're not", "MNygmVL7CiA-00272-00074699-00074899": "going to thrash on those iterations in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00273-00074900-00075232": "your QA cycle so from you know from end", "MNygmVL7CiA-00274-00075233-00075577": "to end it's all faster runtime QA the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00275-00075578-00075868": "whole nine yards so daydreams relatively", "MNygmVL7CiA-00276-00075869-00076315": "new company we began shipping in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00277-00076316-00076963": "February 16 we we've had a great 2017 in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00278-00076964-00077374": "fact well of course it was great we had", "MNygmVL7CiA-00279-00077375-00077744": "a wonderful fundraising in December 16", "MNygmVL7CiA-00280-00077745-00078076": "one of the largest of last year and so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00281-00078077-00078355": "that's really propelled us in the market", "MNygmVL7CiA-00282-00078356-00078760": "and we had a wonderful set of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00283-00078761-00079021": "announcements just about a quarter ago", "MNygmVL7CiA-00284-00079022-00079251": "with the data management capabilities", "MNygmVL7CiA-00285-00079252-00079567": "and we added these day trium compute", "MNygmVL7CiA-00286-00079568-00079932": "nodes and just last quarter alone", "MNygmVL7CiA-00287-00079933-00080290": "our installed base which had been you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00288-00080291-00080496": "know already showing record adoption", "MNygmVL7CiA-00289-00080497-00080872": "grew a whopping 50 percent in a single", "MNygmVL7CiA-00290-00080873-00081206": "quarter and one of the most interesting", "MNygmVL7CiA-00291-00081207-00081617": "statistic sequentially or your ear", "MNygmVL7CiA-00292-00081618-00081946": "sequentially questions sequentially you", "MNygmVL7CiA-00293-00081947-00082242": "the end of q1 to the end of q2 boom and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00294-00082243-00082707": "not only that one out of every three of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00295-00082708-00083134": "our customers already has multiple DV", "MNygmVL7CiA-00296-00083135-00083428": "X's deployed so that's a huge testimony", "MNygmVL7CiA-00297-00083429-00083590": "to you know they're they're kind of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00298-00083591-00083791": "liking what they what they've got so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00299-00083792-00084180": "yeah so it's been a sprint and like I", "MNygmVL7CiA-00300-00084181-00084460": "say we've been very kind of vSphere", "MNygmVL7CiA-00301-00084461-00084906": "focused our founders are a couple of", "MNygmVL7CiA-00302-00084907-00085078": "Diane Greene's early principled", "MNygmVL7CiA-00303-00085079-00085593": "engineers it VMware but customer demand", "MNygmVL7CiA-00304-00085594-00085873": "customers King and they're looking for", "MNygmVL7CiA-00305-00085874-00086094": "the same same kind of capability in", "MNygmVL7CiA-00306-00086095-00086298": "their Linux and container environment so", "MNygmVL7CiA-00307-00086299-00086361": "here we are", "MNygmVL7CiA-00308-00086362-00086641": "hey speed is important to infrastructure", "MNygmVL7CiA-00309-00086642-00087040": "people to write on yeah so Craig thanks", "MNygmVL7CiA-00310-00087041-00087136": "very much for joining us here in the", "MNygmVL7CiA-00311-00087137-00087405": "cube once again great to have gage can", "MNygmVL7CiA-00312-00087406-00087571": "talk a little bit about unannounced but", "MNygmVL7CiA-00313-00087572-00087825": "that they did today about adding the Red", "MNygmVL7CiA-00314-00087826-00087993": "Hat environment to what you the great", "MNygmVL7CiA-00315-00087994-00088107": "work that they're doing in VMware and", "MNygmVL7CiA-00316-00088108-00088431": "vSphere and the future of how containers", "MNygmVL7CiA-00317-00088432-00088567": "related technology will start getting", "MNygmVL7CiA-00318-00088568-00088854": "folded into that whole thing yeah great", "MNygmVL7CiA-00319-00088855-00089167": "results good early start keep it up", "MNygmVL7CiA-00320-00089168-00089359": "thank you all right hey Peter", "MNygmVL7CiA-00321-00089360-00089637": "I'm Peter Burris good to have you once", "MNygmVL7CiA-00322-00089638-00089773": "again with the cube we've been talking", "MNygmVL7CiA-00323-00089774-00089919": "to date room about their new", "MNygmVL7CiA-00324-00089920-00090222": "announcement craig munis a craig newness", "MNygmVL7CiA-00325-00090223-00090492": "craig newness of date room", "MNygmVL7CiA-00326-00090493-00090640": "vice president marketing thanks for", "MNygmVL7CiA-00327-00090641-00090967": "being a good my pleasure"}}, {"audio_id": "MNQZ7bZ7cry", "text": {"MNQZ7bZ7cry-00000-00000008-00000311": "you can rent a girlfriend in japan so my", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00001-00000312-00000495": "incredible friend jake has once again", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00002-00000496-00000663": "hooked me up with some free content he", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00003-00000664-00000823": "sent me the link to this video", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00004-00000824-00001111": "we rented a girlfriend in japan by asian", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00005-00001112-00001150": "boss", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00006-00001151-00001319": "now asian boss has some great videos", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00007-00001320-00001503": "their interviews are incredible", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00008-00001504-00001775": "this video is bound to surpass them all", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00009-00001776-00001918": "i've seen the first few minutes and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00010-00001919-00002055": "after that i thought", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00011-00002056-00002342": "this is too crazy to not do a reaction", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00012-00002343-00002383": "to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00013-00002384-00002671": "so here we are hey guys my name is max", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00014-00002672-00002815": "recently in japan", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00015-00002816-00002999": "renting people out has become a trending", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00016-00003000-00003206": "business and you can even pay somebody", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00017-00003207-00003359": "to act as your spouse", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00018-00003360-00003575": "relative co-worker or any kind of", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00019-00003576-00003686": "acquaintance even", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00020-00003688-00003854": "that sentence you can pay someone to act", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00021-00003855-00004143": "as your spouse who", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00022-00004144-00004335": "what sorry for interrupting we'll keep", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00023-00004336-00004447": "going but", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00024-00004448-00004735": "it's going to get crazier we've even", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00025-00004736-00004935": "showcased ourselves here in previous", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00026-00004936-00005118": "videos renting out a family and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00027-00005119-00005383": "even a middle-aged man but did you also", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00028-00005384-00005799": "know you can rent out a girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00029-00005800-00006022": "japan what you're playing i know you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00030-00006023-00006191": "like to be different i know your culture", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00031-00006192-00006334": "is you know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00032-00006335-00006527": "like some parts of it are completely", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00033-00006528-00006695": "different to the western world", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00034-00006695-00007087": "but jesus christ this is a new", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00035-00007088-00007383": "renting girlfriends again sorry for", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00036-00007384-00007567": "interrupting it's just it's crazy i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00037-00007568-00007767": "can't stress how crazy this is", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00038-00007768-00008031": "it's unbelievable i genuinely thought", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00039-00008031-00008239": "that it was a joke video when i got sent", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00040-00008240-00008495": "it well today i'm out here in tokyo to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00041-00008496-00008703": "rent one out and see if i can find my", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00042-00008704-00008814": "dream girl", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00043-00008815-00009551": "will i succeed or will i fail", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00044-00009552-00009767": "how can you feel at renting a girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00045-00009768-00009959": "let's find out", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00046-00009960-00010199": "so i'm on this website and i never", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00047-00010200-00010359": "thought i would be on a website where i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00048-00010360-00010471": "would try to pay", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00049-00010472-00010783": "for my own girlfriend imagine imagine", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00050-00010784-00010910": "seeing that you've paid", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00051-00010911-00011167": "for a girlfriend it's just it's just too", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00052-00011168-00011255": "weird man", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00053-00011256-00011455": "but i'll browse through them to see if i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00054-00011456-00011623": "think anyone's cute", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00055-00011624-00011999": "and it's so creepy", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00056-00012000-00012270": "it's so weird scrolling through as if", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00057-00012271-00012455": "you're trying to order your delivery", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00058-00012456-00012703": "just picking out a girlfriend also don't", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00059-00012704-00012879": "juice the blinds at 2pm it's for the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00060-00012880-00012935": "light and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00061-00012936-00013294": "look this is horrible this lighten it's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00062-00013295-00013599": "it won't it doesn't work okay", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00063-00013600-00013863": "i like this girl she's pretty cute and i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00064-00013863-00013991": "can rent her out", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00065-00013991-00014183": "because that's just how the service", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00066-00014184-00014311": "works so okay", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00067-00014312-00014607": "she'll be here any minute now kind of", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00068-00014608-00014783": "getting nervous", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00069-00014784-00015247": "waiting waiting", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00070-00015247-00015703": "yes i am uh", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00071-00015704-00016086": "nice to meet you uh so i guess we are", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00072-00016087-00016183": "already", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00073-00016184-00016471": "girlfriend boyfriend right okay that's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00074-00016472-00016607": "good", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00075-00016608-00016822": "thank you thank you so much uh i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00076-00016823-00016943": "actually uh", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00077-00016944-00017135": "already brought you something it's a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00078-00017136-00017247": "it's a little gift", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00079-00017248-00017535": "it's organic fair trade salted almond", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00080-00017536-00017679": "dark chocolate", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00081-00017680-00018022": "i like organic chocolate you do", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00082-00018023-00018158": "you know the first time i watched this i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00083-00018159-00018327": "was cringing so hard at this dialogue", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00084-00018328-00018471": "for some reason the second time watching", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00085-00018472-00018663": "this beer it's not bad", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00086-00018664-00018822": "it's like it's not that bad maybe", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00087-00018823-00018935": "because i've already watched it but my", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00088-00018936-00019135": "first reaction to this was", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00089-00019136-00019447": "this is this is so cringy this is so bad", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00090-00019448-00019607": "there's something so well i know what", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00091-00019608-00019799": "the something off is the fact that he", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00092-00019800-00020039": "paid for i'd be standing there yeah it's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00093-00020040-00020175": "just there's just someone really off", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00094-00020176-00020350": "about it i don't like it i don't like it", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00095-00020351-00020503": "it's just awkward", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00096-00020504-00020758": "i was actually thinking we could share", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00097-00020759-00020822": "it later", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00098-00020823-00021135": "so yeah okay uh and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00099-00021136-00021471": "also before we go on our date i was", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00100-00021472-00021583": "wondering maybe", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00101-00021584-00022239": "we can give each other nicknames", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00102-00022240-00022807": "okay that this is this is great", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00103-00022808-00023158": "let's go together and eat something", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00104-00023159-00023550": "okay this is like a handshake", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00105-00023551-00023999": "i think it should be like this", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00106-00024000-00024142": "i don't think max has ever had an", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00107-00024143-00024335": "interaction with a woman in his life", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00108-00024336-00024494": "now listen right i don't have a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00109-00024495-00024647": "girlfriend i'm single", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00110-00024648-00024958": "but uh i am never i hope", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00111-00024959-00025199": "i pray to allah that i never get as", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00112-00025200-00025303": "desperate", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00113-00025304-00025606": "as renting a girlfriend i wonder if like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00114-00025607-00025774": "the agency or company they're with like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00115-00025775-00025950": "trains them on how to deal with people", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00116-00025951-00026158": "because i'm guessing that he is like one", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00117-00026160-00026206": "of the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00118-00026207-00026351": "nicer people and i'm guessing there's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00119-00026352-00026479": "going to be some policy that's like oh", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00120-00026480-00026646": "yeah she can back out or whatever but", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00121-00026647-00026839": "imagine the people who were just like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00122-00026839-00026983": "absolute [__] to the to the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00123-00026983-00027151": "girlfriends that they ran out", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00124-00027152-00028083": "[Laughter]", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00125-00028083-00028514": "okay", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00126-00028514-00029214": "[Music]", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00127-00029216-00029374": "marvel's sprinting my brother's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00128-00029375-00029543": "sprinting to get out of the rain", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00129-00029544-00029711": "oh she better be sharing that on brother", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00130-00029712-00029999": "does some poor service right there", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00131-00030000-00030158": "i think she's sharing the umbrella i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00132-00030160-00030423": "think she is", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00133-00030424-00030687": "she's not hey give my man a bit of", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00134-00030688-00030895": "coverage come on what's going on he's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00135-00030895-00031039": "paid for you and you're not even gonna", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00136-00031039-00031143": "you know you're gonna shield them from", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00137-00031144-00031199": "the ring", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00138-00031200-00033679": "that's poor from you me that's poor", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00139-00033680-00034055": "looks good", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00140-00034056-00034927": "shall we cheers cheers", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00141-00034928-00035279": "i really don't like videos that are like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00142-00035280-00035518": "trying to film something that's meant to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00143-00035519-00035671": "be like a real", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00144-00035672-00035855": "natural event i don't know if it's just", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00145-00035856-00036030": "me but does it just feel really invasive", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00146-00036031-00036095": "like you're not", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00147-00036096-00037030": "like it's just awkward and uncomfortable", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00148-00037031-00037215": "they both hate that they both absolutely", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00149-00037216-00037895": "hate that look at their faces", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00150-00037896-00038230": "mmm so good", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00151-00038231-00038511": "um so good and then cheating the exact", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00152-00038512-00038630": "same thing but they both don't want to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00153-00038631-00038959": "admit that they're both here", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00154-00038960-00040023": "so delicious", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00155-00040024-00040199": "but it's really good it's hot but it's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00156-00040200-00040455": "really good", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00157-00040456-00041015": "um but what is this actually um", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00158-00041016-00041415": "what what is shiraku", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00159-00041416-00041662": "i've never heard of shirakol fish", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00160-00041663-00042083": "seminole", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00161-00042084-00042855": "fluid", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00162-00042856-00043246": "so in japan fish semen is a delicacy", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00163-00043247-00043471": "yo you just you just eaten the fish", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00164-00043472-00043623": "babies you're just eating the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00165-00043624-00043967": "the unborn fish babies i cool", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00166-00043968-00044167": "all right this is weird enough and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00167-00044168-00044367": "nothing can make it weirder sure yeah", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00168-00044368-00044423": "yeah", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00169-00044424-00044590": "yeah what yeah sure rhett and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00170-00044591-00044807": "girlfriends eating fish semen", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00171-00044808-00045318": "what what next i see yeah", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00172-00045319-00045655": "you did surprise me yeah yeah i didn't", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00173-00045656-00045702": "know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00174-00045703-00046071": "japanese people ate neither the top", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00175-00046072-00046287": "thank you very much for this you can", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00176-00046288-00046479": "have the rest though yeah", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00177-00046480-00046758": "please have the rest i will eat this one", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00178-00046759-00046999": "yeah you can have the right", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00179-00047000-00047302": "please have the rest please do not give", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00180-00047303-00047683": "me any more fish semen", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00181-00047684-00047886": "please", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00182-00047887-00048167": "so how long have you bro she can be", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00183-00048168-00048295": "pregnant with a fish", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00184-00048296-00048415": "she'll be pregnant with the fish after", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00185-00048416-00048623": "eating that fish semen yeah a level", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00186-00048624-00048758": "biology that's right let's go", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00187-00048759-00048974": "we've been doing this rental girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00188-00048975-00049367": "thing", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00189-00049368-00050702": "and how did you get started", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00190-00050703-00050951": "at what point do you get so desperate", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00191-00050952-00051086": "and lonely that you think i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00192-00051087-00051254": "time to splash the cash i'm wondering at", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00193-00051255-00051390": "what point cuz she's just said right", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00194-00051391-00051582": "it's men who've never had girlfriends", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00195-00051583-00051679": "right or never", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00196-00051679-00051879": "you know been in relationships or never", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00197-00051879-00051999": "uh you know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00198-00052000-00052207": "being intimate with a girl well actually", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00199-00052208-00052326": "no because i would make", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00200-00052327-00052511": "the rent the girlfriends prostitutes and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00201-00052512-00052694": "that and them", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00202-00052695-00052999": "that probably isn't in the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00203-00053000-00053207": "terms and conditions of the job", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00204-00053208-00053615": "otherwise it would just be prostitutes", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00205-00053616-00053815": "anyways so so after what amount of time", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00206-00053816-00053959": "of being lonely does one", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00207-00053960-00054487": "resort to renting a girlfriend i wonder", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00208-00054488-00056063": "did somebody introduce you to this job", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00209-00056064-00056375": "is this pretty common in japan this", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00210-00056376-00056911": "service of running a girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00211-00056912-00057482": "okay so still running", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00212-00057483-00058054": "around", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00213-00058055-00058399": "two hour minimum rental two hours you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00214-00058400-00058615": "rent a girlfriend for two hours", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00215-00058616-00058750": "i thought the minimum would be like a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00216-00058751-00058982": "day or something two hours what are you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00217-00058983-00059391": "gonna do in two hours", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00218-00059391-00059703": "fifty five dollars an hour fifty", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00219-00059704-00059935": "so the minimum the minimum price is a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00220-00059936-00060103": "hundred percent what's that quid", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00221-00060104-00060535": "it's gonna be like what like 95 quits", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00222-00060536-00060791": "for two hours just to spend time with", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00223-00060791-00060919": "some random loss", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00224-00060920-00062399": "and call them your girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00225-00062400-00062606": "okay so wait you've gotta pay extra to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00226-00062607-00062726": "choose who it is", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00227-00062727-00062926": "you've gotta pay an extra 18 dollars", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00228-00062927-00063111": "what was that like like 14 quid you've", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00229-00063112-00063511": "got to pay", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00230-00063512-00063719": "me these these girls in these companies", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00231-00063720-00063935": "would be minted they must be so", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00232-00063936-00064175": "rich so so is this creating just an", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00233-00064176-00064326": "opportunity for", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00234-00064327-00064591": "just lonely like like introverted law", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00235-00064591-00064726": "like socially awkward", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00236-00064727-00064999": "people to just feel what it's like to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00237-00065000-00065079": "have a girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00238-00065079-00065254": "well imagine you catch feelings after", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00239-00065255-00065399": "those two hours you know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00240-00065400-00065575": "even even though i've had to pay to have", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00241-00065576-00065735": "you here i really feel the connection", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00242-00065736-00065911": "you know i feel about chemistry here i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00243-00065912-00066087": "don't know if you feel the same", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00244-00066088-00066359": "i won't i i do i really do how about we", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00245-00066360-00066463": "how about we forget", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00246-00066464-00066735": "that you know you paid for me and then", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00247-00066736-00066791": "you know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00248-00066792-00066959": "we can we can be together you know i'd", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00249-00066960-00067094": "like that oh i'm good", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00250-00067095-00067326": "oh see you later time's up thank you for", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00251-00067327-00067791": "your hundred and ten dollars", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00252-00067792-00068038": "how much do you make you think in one", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00253-00068039-00068350": "yeah how much do you mean", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00254-00068351-00068806": "she gets a 50 commission 50 percent", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00255-00068807-00069055": "gee so she's literally getting 55 quid", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00256-00069056-00069271": "for two hours of just being like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00257-00069272-00069479": "yeah i'm your girlfriend hello that's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00258-00069480-00069623": "quality", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00259-00069624-00069831": "bro i bet you when they go to eat like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00260-00069832-00070006": "the guy pays as well what kind of rules", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00261-00070007-00070150": "does the company set", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00262-00070151-00070431": "when they offer this service like what", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00263-00070432-00070503": "do they", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00264-00070504-00070687": "say is okay and what do they say is not", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00265-00070688-00071482": "only yeah so this is someone else", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00266-00071483-00072023": "okay", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00267-00072024-00072287": "yeah i would have guessed uh that it was", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00268-00072288-00072447": "very different to prostitution", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00269-00072448-00072791": "but wait is prostitution legal in japan", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00270-00072792-00073038": "oh it's illegal okay so yeah it wouldn't", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00271-00073039-00073143": "be able to happen anyways because it's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00272-00073144-00073638": "illegal", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00273-00073639-00073894": "do you feel like you have to be acting", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00274-00073895-00073999": "on these dates", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00275-00074000-00074175": "or do you feel like it's very natural", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00276-00074176-00074975": "for you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00277-00074976-00075279": "uh have you ever actually fallen in love", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00278-00075280-00075606": "with kissing it's going to be long no", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00279-00075607-00076943": "i just get the cash", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00280-00076944-00077087": "these guys out here renting girlfriends", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00281-00077088-00077238": "they could actually they could get a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00282-00077239-00077375": "real girlfriend if they actually you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00283-00077376-00077543": "know if they decided to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00284-00077544-00077767": "socialize with natural girls and not not", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00285-00077768-00077862": "pay for them that's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00286-00077863-00078062": "that's sad you know it's like yeah you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00287-00078063-00078223": "know someone who's actual boyfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00288-00078224-00078303": "material", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00289-00078304-00078503": "just thinking oh yeah i'm so money i've", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00290-00078504-00078606": "got splash the cash", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00291-00078607-00078926": "bro hey all you kings out there", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00292-00078927-00079079": "if you're ever that damn bad that you're", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00293-00079080-00079262": "considering paying if you're in japan", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00294-00079263-00079503": "right and you're thinking all right", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00295-00079504-00079662": "i've been on you for a good while gotta", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00296-00079663-00079887": "rent a girlfriend no confidence", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00297-00079888-00080159": "is everything just get out there get", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00298-00080160-00080223": "yourself", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00299-00080224-00080350": "i'm saying like it's easy i'm saying", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00300-00080351-00080462": "that like i've got a girlfriend all", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00301-00080463-00080550": "right ignore me", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00302-00080551-00081287": "so what is your type", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00303-00081288-00081455": "well that is very sweet that's very cute", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00304-00081456-00081623": "you know her morals are in the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00305-00081624-00081847": "in all the right places fair enough fair", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00306-00081848-00081959": "enough she's doing what she's doing", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00307-00081960-00082071": "she's making the killing", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00308-00082072-00082326": "anyway enough questions for now i'm", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00309-00082327-00084038": "hungry so i'm going to eat", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00310-00084039-00084335": "thank thank you so much you're you're a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00311-00084336-00084447": "great", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00312-00084448-00084750": "uh even though that wasn't that weird", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00313-00084751-00084806": "did that", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00314-00084807-00085175": "did i just feel like uh for anyone else", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00315-00085176-00085318": "i don't wanna use always like awkward or", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00316-00085319-00085479": "cringy or weird because you know it's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00317-00085480-00085671": "not really that bad boost", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00318-00085672-00085967": "hmm ah that means feel a bit uneasy i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00319-00085968-00086038": "don't know why", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00320-00086039-00086175": "i don't know what it is about it", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00321-00086176-00086687": "girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00322-00086688-00086967": "oh what all right why why was that the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00323-00086968-00087103": "most awkward part about i think you the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00324-00087104-00087206": "silence afterwards", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00325-00087207-00087767": "girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00326-00087768-00088038": "why why is that funny what why why did", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00327-00088039-00088150": "the others not just", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00328-00088151-00089726": "bro these are just trying", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00329-00089727-00089905": "and now it's my turn", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00330-00089906-00090471": "[Music]", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00331-00090472-00090638": "i know you're eating ice cream but i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00332-00090639-00090815": "feel like do you want to get something", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00333-00090816-00091055": "else after this like maybe we can go and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00334-00091056-00091135": "get", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00335-00091136-00091503": "coffee or cafe company", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00336-00091504-00091823": "okay let's go to the cafe", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00337-00091824-00092006": "does max know japanese like can you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00338-00092007-00092135": "speak japanese", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00339-00092136-00092335": "or is this being translated and then", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00340-00092336-00092462": "we're just they're just editing out the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00341-00092463-00092526": "translated", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00342-00092527-00092775": "like is he understanding here if so why", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00343-00092776-00092943": "isn't he speaking it back or", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00344-00092944-00093103": "your my head's in the wrong place right", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00345-00093104-00093335": "now i'm thinking about the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00346-00093336-00093701": "production and everything oh that's cute", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00347-00093702-00093823": "[Music]", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00348-00093824-00094150": "it'd be more cute if it wasn't paid for", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00349-00094151-00094367": "i'm i'm sorry i'm just laundering this", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00350-00094368-00094503": "blossoming relationship going on i'm", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00351-00094504-00094679": "very sorry guys", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00352-00094680-00095191": "i'm ruining it i should stop", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00353-00095192-00095511": "okay so i'm actually curious though", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00354-00095512-00095743": "you know why do you think somebody wants", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00355-00095744-00095887": "to use your service", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00356-00095888-00097103": "um", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00357-00097104-00097415": "okay that makes a bit more sense yeah", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00358-00097416-00097559": "i did i didn't think about it that way", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00359-00097560-00097759": "but then again so if you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00360-00097760-00097894": "don't have time for a girlfriend but you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00361-00097895-00098015": "want the girlfriend experience for a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00362-00098016-00098167": "brief amount of time", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00363-00098168-00098350": "surely that would be so much more", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00364-00098351-00098471": "amplified", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00365-00098472-00098647": "if you had an actual girlfriend but you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00366-00098648-00098791": "both", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00367-00098792-00099038": "had good enough communication to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00368-00099039-00099191": "acknowledge that you won't", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00369-00099192-00099350": "spend a lot of time together because", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00370-00099351-00099487": "then that would make the small amount of", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00371-00099488-00099631": "time you have together really good", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00372-00099632-00099782": "or am i thinking too deeply about this", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00373-00099783-00099903": "should i just accept that there's a lot", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00374-00099904-00099974": "of", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00375-00099975-00100199": "rich horny people in japan why am i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00376-00100200-00100303": "saying horny it's not", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00377-00100304-00100431": "i keep having to tell myself it's not", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00378-00100432-00100599": "prostitution it's not like it's not like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00379-00100600-00100935": "that", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00380-00100936-00101182": "generally speaking what kind of people", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00381-00101183-00101335": "use the rental", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00382-00101336-00102071": "girlfriend service", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00383-00102072-00102231": "these are really good questions props to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00384-00102232-00102415": "marx and the producers and everyone", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00385-00102416-00102551": "like this is answering like all the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00386-00102552-00103447": "questions that i've got in my mind", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00387-00103448-00103775": "by the way do men give you monetary tips", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00388-00103776-00103799": "or", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00389-00103800-00104006": "anything at the end imagine paying a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00390-00104007-00104254": "hundred and ten dollars 2018 if you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00391-00104255-00104382": "choose new girlfriend and i'm thinking", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00392-00104383-00104542": "oh yeah that was so good i'm gonna give", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00393-00104543-00104639": "you a tip", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00394-00104640-00104878": "so she's dreamed your bank account and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00395-00104879-00105047": "you've decided yeah i'll just give you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00396-00105048-00105902": "more money another day", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00397-00105903-00106039": "oh i've never even thought about", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00398-00106040-00106286": "expensive gifts imagine you rent a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00399-00106288-00106447": "girlfriend just to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00400-00106448-00106902": "give her like a two grand bracelet", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00401-00106903-00107023": "you can you can tell i don't have a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00402-00107024-00107831": "girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00403-00107832-00107999": "okay yeah i'm guessing that he", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00404-00108000-00108158": "definitely knows japanese or at least", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00405-00108159-00108271": "you can understand it", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00406-00108272-00108551": "that i deny this in a different video we", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00407-00108552-00108654": "did in china", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00408-00108655-00109534": "the girlfriend got a gift of 15 000.", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00409-00109535-00109799": "that's cop that's that's what we're", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00410-00109800-00109975": "reacting to next video we're going to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00411-00109976-00110151": "compare rent to girlfriends in the next", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00412-00110152-00110207": "video", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00413-00110208-00110383": "this is the baseline to find out what it", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00414-00110383-00110543": "actually is next video skip the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00415-00110544-00110654": "introduction we're getting straight to", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00416-00110655-00111295": "the comparison", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00417-00111296-00111463": "guys guys guys please do not spend 10", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00418-00111464-00111647": "grand with me i mean 9 grand", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00419-00111648-00111895": "sure i'll i'll take it you know but yeah", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00420-00111896-00112015": "10 grams off the table", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00421-00112016-00112239": "so do you actually have a boyfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00422-00112240-00112671": "right now a real boyfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00423-00112672-00112943": "imagine having a real having a boyfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00424-00112944-00113102": "and being like i i'm going to go off and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00425-00113103-00113183": "pretend to have", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00426-00113183-00113383": "you know a billion boyfriends for the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00427-00113383-00113527": "day say that i", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00428-00113528-00113702": "well actually i'm saying that there's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00429-00113703-00113839": "there's girls with only fans who've got", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00430-00113840-00113975": "boyfriends well there's this whole thing", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00431-00113976-00114071": "about like you know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00432-00114072-00114223": "if your girlfriend had only fans would", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00433-00114224-00114343": "you be okay with it all that sort of", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00434-00114344-00114399": "stuff", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00435-00114400-00114575": "so you know what this isn't actually it", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00436-00114576-00114751": "wouldn't be that bad if you did have a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00437-00114752-00114886": "boyfriend it wouldn't be bad at all do", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00438-00114888-00114934": "you think", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00439-00114935-00115190": "you can actually have a relationship", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00440-00115191-00115319": "with the real boyfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00441-00115320-00115695": "while doing this job", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00442-00115696-00115854": "yeah exactly if you both got a good", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00443-00115855-00116095": "enough communication", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00444-00116096-00116390": "exactly exactly some guys probably would", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00445-00116391-00116478": "understand", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00446-00116479-00116654": "but a lot of guys wouldn't really", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00447-00116655-00116854": "understand or be accepting of this type", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00448-00116855-00116910": "of", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00449-00116911-00117175": "job if you started dating someone for", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00450-00117176-00117231": "real", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00451-00117232-00117527": "and he started doing a rental boyfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00452-00117528-00117678": "would you be okay with that", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00453-00117679-00117919": "that's sick imagine just the absolute", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00454-00117920-00118134": "power couple just get in that bag", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00455-00118135-00118254": "get in the cash both of them just", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00456-00118255-00118358": "pretend to be the girl from the", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00457-00118359-00118478": "boyfriend of other people for the whole", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00458-00118479-00118631": "day coming back be like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00459-00118632-00118927": "hey let's splash this gosh last question", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00460-00118928-00119031": "what do you want to say", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00461-00119032-00119278": "to any people who might want to rent a", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00462-00119279-00119407": "girlfriend", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00463-00119408-00119743": "get a life get outside get", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00464-00119744-00120007": "hobbies talk to girls that's what that's", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00465-00120008-00120483": "what i would say", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00466-00120483-00121134": "um", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00467-00121135-00121399": "hey she she's promoting herself i'll", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00468-00121400-00121463": "give her that", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00469-00121464-00123007": "she's she's got that going for her", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00470-00123008-00123214": "many people will surely rent you out", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00471-00123215-00123519": "you'll hear business after this video", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00472-00123520-00123743": "almost five million views actually i was", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00473-00123744-00123886": "thinking maybe", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00474-00123888-00124190": "you know we can go out later so you know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00475-00124191-00124423": "let me have your number and you know", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00476-00124424-00124534": "i'll i'll call you", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00477-00124535-00124766": "and we can keep going somewhere max mark", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00478-00124767-00124975": "sparks max marks", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00479-00124976-00125207": "are you are you are you making a wheel", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00480-00125208-00125358": "vlog do you shoot in your shot", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00481-00125359-00125910": "you're all the confidence go on", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00482-00125911-00126551": "oh he shot his shirt", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00483-00126552-00127047": "so i can't have your number", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00484-00127048-00127380": "marks apologies", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00485-00127381-00128158": "[Music]", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00486-00128159-00128319": "this was produced very well like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00487-00128320-00128471": "obviously that whole bit of scripted", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00488-00128472-00128695": "just now", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00489-00128696-00128839": "i like this video is a very well", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00490-00128840-00129454": "produced video", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00491-00129455-00129623": "we didn't get to eat my chocolate with", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00492-00129624-00129919": "her", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00493-00129920-00130119": "i'm sorry bro maybe one day you'll find", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00494-00130120-00130239": "the right kill or share your chocolate", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00495-00130240-00130278": "with", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00496-00130279-00130463": "damn that was a good video you know very", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00497-00130464-00130639": "good video it's very insightful it", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00498-00130640-00130799": "doesn't seem that wild actually after", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00499-00130800-00130910": "watching that video it doesn't seem like", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00500-00130911-00130975": "that well", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00501-00130976-00131175": "it's still insane but just a bit less", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00502-00131176-00131343": "insane well i hope you enjoyed learning", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00503-00131344-00131527": "something new with me today about japan", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00504-00131528-00131839": "the wonderful culture that is japan and", "MNQZ7bZ7cry-00505-00131840-00132215": "i'll see you in the next video"}}, {"audio_id": "MNSY_pOJAwc", "text": {"MNSY_pOJAwc-00000-00000035-00000313": "Star Trek generations as a first-person", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00001-00000314-00000566": "shooter with adventure game and strategy", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00002-00000567-00000778": "game elements by microprose based on", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00003-00000779-00001003": "Star Trek generations the seventh film", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00004-00001005-00001742": "in the Star Trek film franchise", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00005-00001743-00002197": "topic story", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00006-00002198-00002434": "the plot basically is the same as the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00007-00002435-00002653": "film Captain jean-luc Picard and the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00008-00002654-00002866": "crew of the enterprise-d responds to a", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00009-00002867-00003015": "distress call from the Amargosa", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00010-00003016-00003222": "Observatory and commander William Riker", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00011-00003224-00003538": "is sent over to investigate once there", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00012-00003539-00003739": "he finds dr. Tulley and Sauron a", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00013-00003740-00003940": "scientist and madman hell-bent on", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00014-00003940-00004129": "returning to the Nexus a paradise", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00015-00004130-00004408": "dimension Sauron escapes and the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00016-00004409-00004612": "enterprise goes on various missions to", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00017-00004613-00004870": "try to find him to return to the Nexus", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00018-00004871-00005104": "Sauron intends on destroying stars in", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00019-00005105-00005308": "order to cause the Nexus due to loss of", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00020-00005309-00005509": "the stars gravity to pass near Veridian", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00021-00005510-00005755": "3 the player needs to guess which", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00022-00005756-00005956": "planets Sauron intends to destroy in", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00023-00005957-00006241": "order to pursue him apart from being", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00024-00006242-00006439": "based on the film the game is also a", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00025-00006440-00006664": "semi sequel to Star Trek the next", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00026-00006665-00006883": "generation of final unity since the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00027-00006884-00007081": "aliens from that game the choatic make", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00028-00007081-00007652": "an appearance", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00029-00007653-00008170": "topic gameplay", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00030-00008172-00008405": "the game combines many computer game", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00031-00008406-00008621": "genres and follows the main nonlinear", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00032-00008622-00008804": "philosophy of alternate paths to", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00033-00008805-00008987": "complete the game followed in other Star", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00034-00008988-00009302": "Trek games the major portion of the game", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00035-00009303-00009521": "occurs in stellar cartography also", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00036-00009522-00009704": "appearing in the film although only for", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00037-00009705-00009854": "some minutes where the player plans", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00038-00009855-00010037": "their next moves the main opponents", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00039-00010038-00010292": "being time and Sauron this part of the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00040-00010293-00010490": "game includes the strategic part where", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00041-00010491-00010676": "the player has to calculate and guess", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00042-00010677-00010880": "where Sauron could be in order to travel", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00043-00010881-00011036": "there and stop him before he destroys", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00044-00011037-00011354": "the system when a crew member beams to a", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00045-00011355-00011543": "planet or space station the game", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00046-00011544-00011708": "switches to first-person action", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00047-00011709-00011996": "adventure the main objective of every", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00048-00011997-00012176": "away mission is finding and fighting", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00049-00012177-00012353": "with Sauron who beams away seconds", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00050-00012354-00012593": "before being killed by the player the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00051-00012594-00012815": "mission is then successful however not", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00052-00012816-00012974": "all away missions need to be successful", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00053-00012975-00013259": "to win the game enemy ships are", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00054-00013260-00013493": "encountered while in space the game then", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00055-00013494-00013700": "switches to pure tactical simulator", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00056-00013701-00013888": "where the player controls the enterprise", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00057-00013890-00014144": "against the enemy ships the fighting", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00058-00014144-00014344": "system is simplified over the extremely", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00059-00014346-00015094": "difficult tactical part of a final unity", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00060-00015095-00015608": "topic development", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00061-00015609-00015851": "producer Simon Finch explained the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00062-00015852-00016055": "game's storytelling philosophy we were", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00063-00016056-00016193": "trying to put the player into the", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00064-00016194-00016385": "situation that the characters were in", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00065-00016386-00016565": "the movie generations but we wanted to", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00066-00016566-00016733": "let them do what they wanted to do and", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00067-00016734-00016937": "have the situations deviate fairly far", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00068-00016938-00017255": "from the film concerning the gameplay", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00069-00017256-00017567": "style he commented we definitely wanted", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00070-00017568-00017747": "to teach players that violence isn't", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00071-00017748-00017927": "always the right solution but we never", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00072-00017928-00018130": "wanted to water down gameplay by taking", "MNSY_pOJAwc-00073-00018131-00018443": "that option away from them"}}, {"audio_id": "Mp92Cl5uem8", "text": {"Mp92Cl5uem8-00000-00000000-00000106": "[Music]", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00001-00000107-00000787": "foreign", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00002-00000788-00001145": "the story of the F-111 Aardvark began in", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00003-00001146-00001361": "the early 1960s when the U.S Department", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00004-00001362-00001541": "of Defense initiated the Tactical", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00005-00001542-00001913": "fighter experimental tfx program", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00006-00001914-00002129": "the goal was to create a single aircraft", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00007-00002130-00002326": "that could fulfill multiple roles for", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00008-00002327-00002573": "both the U.S Air Force and Navy", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00009-00002574-00002765": "General Dynamics and Grumman were", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00010-00002766-00002939": "selected as partners to develop this", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00011-00002940-00003100": "ambitious aircraft", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00012-00003101-00003431": "in 1962 their proposal won the Tactical", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00013-00003432-00003803": "fighter experimental or tfx contract and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00014-00003804-00004001": "the F-111 was born", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00015-00004002-00004235": "the F-111 was a groundbreaking design", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00016-00004236-00004427": "that incorporated numerous Innovative", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00017-00004428-00004679": "features", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00018-00004680-00004883": "it was the first production aircraft to", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00019-00004884-00005122": "feature variable geometry Wings also", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00020-00005123-00005291": "known as swing wings", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00021-00005292-00005488": "These Wings could be adjusted in flight", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00022-00005489-00005711": "to optimize performance allowing the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00023-00005712-00005945": "F-111 to excel in both high-speed and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00024-00005946-00006275": "low-speed missions", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00025-00006276-00006550": "the F-111 was powered by two Pratt and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00026-00006551-00006809": "Whitney tf-30 turbofan engines which", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00027-00006809-00007037": "gave it impressive speed and range", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00028-00007038-00007277": "it could reach a top speed of Mach 2.5", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00029-00007278-00007534": "and had an unrefueled range of over 3000", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00030-00007536-00007769": "miles", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00031-00007770-00008020": "the F-111 was designed to be versatile", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00032-00008022-00008231": "and adaptable with several variants", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00033-00008232-00008374": "being developed for different Mission", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00034-00008375-00008614": "profiles", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00035-00008615-00008855": "the f-111a was the initial production", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00036-00008856-00009101": "variant primarily used for tactical", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00037-00009102-00009245": "strike missions", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00038-00009246-00009503": "it featured Advanced avionics terrain", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00039-00009504-00009695": "following radar and an Innovative", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00040-00009696-00009941": "side-by-side cockpit layout for improved", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00041-00009942-00010096": "crew coordination", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00042-00010097-00010481": "over 150 f-111as were produced with the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00043-00010482-00010906": "first aircraft entering service in 1967.", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00044-00010907-00011171": "the f-111b was a short-lived variant", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00045-00011172-00011369": "intended for the U.S Navy as a fleet", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00046-00011370-00011656": "defense interceptor however it was", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00047-00011657-00011813": "ultimately canceled due to weight and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00048-00011814-00011969": "performance issues", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00049-00011970-00012341": "The f-111b's Experience though was not", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00050-00012342-00012514": "in vain as it led to the development of", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00051-00012515-00012760": "the F-14 Tomcat which would become a", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00052-00012761-00013096": "legendary aircraft in its own right", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00053-00013097-00013391": "the f-111c was an export version for the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00054-00013391-00013588": "Royal Australian Air Force which", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00055-00013590-00013877": "combined the avionics of the f-111a with", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00056-00013878-00014069": "a stronger airframe and longer wingspan", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00057-00014069-00014236": "of the f-111b", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00058-00014237-00014543": "Australia received a total of 24 F-111", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00059-00014544-00014758": "Seas which served as the backbone of", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00060-00014759-00015113": "their Strike Force for decades", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00061-00015113-00015388": "the f-111d was an upgraded version with", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00062-00015390-00015629": "even more advanced avionics improved", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00063-00015630-00015851": "engines and an enhanced navigation and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00064-00015852-00015994": "attack system", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00065-00015995-00016199": "it was primarily used for precision", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00066-00016200-00016361": "strike missions", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00067-00016362-00016739": "despite its improvements only 96 f-111ds", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00068-00016740-00016936": "were produced due to cost overruns and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00069-00016937-00017236": "technical issues", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00070-00017237-00017561": "the f-111e was a simplified lower cost", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00071-00017562-00017771": "variant which still maintained the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00072-00017772-00017915": "impressive performance of the original", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00073-00017916-00018041": "design", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00074-00018042-00018371": "over 90 f-111es were built and served", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00075-00018372-00018779": "with distinction in various operations", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00076-00018780-00019013": "the f-111f was the final production", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00077-00019014-00019243": "variant featuring upgraded engines", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00078-00019244-00019517": "avionics and the capability to carry", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00079-00019518-00019703": "more advanced Munitions such as", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00080-00019704-00019879": "laser-guided bombs", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00081-00019880-00020249": "106 f-111fs were produced with many of", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00082-00020250-00020417": "them participating in key combat", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00083-00020418-00020885": "missions in the 1980s and 1990s", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00084-00020886-00021203": "finally The ef-111a Raven was an", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00085-00021204-00021419": "electronic warfare variant designed for", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00086-00021420-00021611": "radar jamming and suppression of enemy", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00087-00021612-00021736": "air defenses", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00088-00021737-00022007": "a total of 42 Ravens were converted from", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00089-00022008-00022253": "existing f-111as and served until the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00090-00022254-00022583": "late 1990s", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00091-00022584-00022847": "the F-111 Aardvark was a Pioneer in", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00092-00022848-00023075": "several technological advancements that", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00093-00023076-00023225": "would later become standard in military", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00094-00023226-00023530": "Aviation", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00095-00023531-00023819": "the f-111's advanced avionics Suite was", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00096-00023820-00023986": "a significant Leap Forward in aircraft", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00097-00023987-00024119": "technology", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00098-00024120-00024371": "its terrain following radar allowed", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00099-00024372-00024569": "Pilots to maintain a constant altitude", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00100-00024570-00024803": "during low-level flight enabling them to", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00101-00024804-00025013": "avoid enemy radar and deliver their", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00102-00025014-00025367": "payloads with pinpoint accuracy", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00103-00025368-00025606": "another Innovation was the f-111's", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00104-00025607-00025739": "escape capsule", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00105-00025739-00025990": "in the event of an emergency the entire", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00106-00025991-00026189": "cockpit could be jettisoned as a single", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00107-00026189-00026399": "unit protecting the crew during ejection", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00108-00026400-00026801": "at high speeds or low altitudes", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00109-00026802-00027011": "the F-111 Aardvark served with", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00110-00027012-00027233": "distinction in various conflicts and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00111-00027233-00027389": "operations throughout its operational", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00112-00027389-00027701": "history", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00113-00027702-00027958": "the F-111 first saw combat during the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00114-00027960-00028162": "Vietnam war where it was initially", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00115-00028163-00028511": "deployed in 1968. it quickly gained a", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00116-00028512-00028685": "reputation for its ability to deliver", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00117-00028686-00028840": "Precision strikes in all weather", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00118-00028841-00029062": "conditions thanks to its Advanced", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00119-00029063-00029255": "terrain following radar and low-level", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00120-00029256-00029417": "flight capabilities", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00121-00029418-00029717": "over the course of the war f-111s flew", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00122-00029718-00029933": "more than 4 000 missions and achieved an", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00123-00029933-00030101": "impressive Mission success rate of over", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00124-00030102-00030467": "80 percent", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00125-00030468-00030827": "in 1986 the F-111 played a key role in", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00126-00030827-00031073": "operation El Dorado Canyon the U.S", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00127-00031074-00031277": "bombing raid against Libya", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00128-00031277-00031595": "the f-111fs of the 48th tactical Fighter", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00129-00031595-00031751": "Wing demonstrated the aircraft's", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00130-00031752-00031996": "long-range strike capabilities flying", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00131-00031997-00032267": "over 6400 miles round trip from England", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00132-00032268-00032435": "to Libya and back", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00133-00032436-00032693": "the F-111 successfully attacked key", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00134-00032694-00032933": "Libyan military targets proving their", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00135-00032934-00033101": "effectiveness in real-world combat", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00136-00033102-00033449": "scenarios", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00137-00033450-00033652": "the f-111's most significant", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00138-00033653-00033839": "contribution came during Operation", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00139-00033840-00034096": "Desert Storm in 1991.", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00140-00034097-00034289": "the aircraft excelled in the conflict", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00141-00034290-00034565": "delivering 80 of the laser-guided bombs", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00142-00034566-00034787": "dropped by the U.S Air Force", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00143-00034788-00034990": "it was also during this operation that", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00144-00034991-00035231": "the ef-111a Ravens showcased their", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00145-00035232-00035405": "capabilities in suppressing enemy air", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00146-00035406-00035645": "defenses protecting Coalition aircraft", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00147-00035646-00036065": "from radar-guided threats", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00148-00036066-00036293": "in addition to its service with the U.S", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00149-00036294-00036574": "Air Force the F-111 also served with the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00150-00036575-00036809": "Royal Australian Air Force from 1973", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00151-00036810-00037162": "until 2010. the Australian f-111s", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00152-00037163-00037331": "participated in various Regional", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00153-00037332-00037559": "exercises and deployments demonstrating", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00154-00037560-00037690": "their long-range strike in", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00155-00037691-00038039": "reconnaissance capabilities", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00156-00038040-00038302": "the F-111 was retired from the U.S Air", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00157-00038303-00038680": "Force in 1996 with the ef-111a Raven", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00158-00038681-00039011": "following in 1998. as more advanced", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00159-00039012-00039299": "aircraft like the f-15e Strike Eagle and", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00160-00039300-00039527": "F-16 Fighting Falcon took over their", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00161-00039528-00040061": "roles the f-111's time came to an end", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00162-00040062-00040318": "the F-111 Aardvark may have been retired", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00163-00040319-00040517": "but its Legacy lives on in the", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00164-00040518-00040679": "Innovations it brought to the field of", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00165-00040680-00040859": "military Aviation", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00166-00040860-00041046": "its pioneering swing Wing design", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00167-00041047-00041321": "Advanced avionics and versatile Mission", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00168-00041322-00041507": "profiles set the stage for future", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00169-00041508-00041671": "generations of combat aircraft", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00170-00041672-00041885": "influencing the development of planes", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00171-00041886-00042167": "like the F-22 Raptor and F-35 lightning", "Mp92Cl5uem8-00172-00042168-00042410": "II"}}, {"audio_id": "Mp-SJ9gxzyU", "text": {"Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00000-00000046-00000407": "migdal insurance and financial holdings", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00001-00000408-00000923": "limited hebrew mg/dl tazed mg/dl is one", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00002-00000924-00001187": "of the largest and oldest israeli", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00003-00001188-00001912": "insurance companies", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00004-00001913-00002477": "topic history", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00005-00002478-00002933": "migdal was founded in jerusalem in 1934", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00006-00002934-00003281": "the original group of investors included", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00007-00003282-00003626": "local Palestinian Jews families from", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00008-00003627-00003869": "Egypt and Italy and the Italian", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00009-00003870-00004147": "insurance company Asakura Sione", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00010-00004148-00004484": "generally which held a 50% stake and", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00011-00004485-00004768": "provided the original financial and", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00012-00004769-00005122": "professional backing generally", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00013-00005123-00005528": "eventually held 70% of Migdal shares and", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00014-00005529-00005642": "Bank Leumi", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00015-00005643-00006329": "owns almost 10% in September 1996 Migdal", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00016-00006330-00006590": "made its initial public offering on the", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00017-00006591-00006926": "Tel Aviv Stock Exchange selling twenty", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00018-00006927-00007459": "percent shares stake in March 2012", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00019-00007461-00007805": "Asakura gionee generally sold Migdal to", "Mp-SJ9gxzyU-00020-00007806-00008122": "Eliyahu"}}, {"audio_id": "MpEAb2WGmgg", "text": {"MpEAb2WGmgg-00000-00000521-00001491": "[Music]", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00001-00001492-00001910": "me", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00002-00001911-00003246": "for me", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00003-00003247-00003999": "[Music]", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00004-00004000-00005302": "slow it down", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00005-00005303-00007083": "[Music]", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00006-00007084-00008483": "right", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00007-00008484-00009078": "is", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00008-00009079-00009319": "keep up with the schedule cause life is", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00009-00009320-00009559": "all about adding those decimals but now", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00010-00009560-00009814": "the master hit me with persuasion who", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00011-00009815-00010388": "told me change", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00012-00010389-00010974": "[Music]", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00013-00010975-00013391": "like i don't belong", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00014-00013391-00013694": "losing traction feel the impaction all", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00015-00013695-00013847": "my passions turn to an", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00016-00013847-00014111": "action and i threw everything into the", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00017-00014112-00014199": "catcher", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00018-00014200-00014479": "imma tell you how all of this happened i", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00019-00014480-00014735": "set my dreams aside to learn adaption", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00020-00014736-00014943": "since life's a flurry picture with no", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00021-00014944-00015175": "caption and all my wants and needs are", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00022-00015176-00015294": "overlapping", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00023-00015295-00015527": "i haven't had much time to really type", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00024-00015528-00015775": "in some of my peers seem to have it", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00025-00015776-00015871": "together", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00026-00015872-00016079": "they don't even seem like kids they seem", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00027-00016080-00016279": "better maybe it's just for the grammar", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00028-00016280-00016447": "they raise the tone of my psyche maybe", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00029-00016448-00016615": "they're trying to pull themselves up", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00030-00016616-00016886": "just like me i still feel alone i want", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00031-00016887-00017615": "to", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00032-00017616-00018767": "faster than ever before", "MpEAb2WGmgg-00033-00018768-00019984": "won't let the time come"}}, {"audio_id": "MpTj3-vCFNc", "text": {"MpTj3-vCFNc-00000-00000014-00000340": "the UN Security Council passed a number", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00001-00000341-00000593": "of resolutions concerning Iran mainly", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00002-00000594-00001319": "related to its nuclear program", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00003-00001320-00001920": "topic list of resolutions", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00004-00001921-00002141": "United Nations Security Council", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00005-00002142-00002409": "resolution 2 passed on the 30th of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00006-00002410-00002799": "January 1946 encouraged Iran and the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00007-00002800-00003021": "Soviet Union to resolve their conflict", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00008-00003022-00003236": "concerning Soviet troops occupying", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00009-00003238-00003567": "Iranian territory the Security Council", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00010-00003568-00003825": "requested to be updated on negotiations", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00011-00003826-00004193": "between the two sides at any time United", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00012-00004194-00004452": "Nations Security Council resolution 3", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00013-00004453-00004845": "passed on April 4th 1946 acknowledged", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00014-00004846-00005070": "that the Soviet troops in Iran could not", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00015-00005071-00005280": "be removed in time to meet the deadline", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00016-00005281-00005484": "under the tripartite treaty but", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00017-00005485-00005703": "requested the Soviet Union remove them", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00018-00005704-00005904": "as fast as possible and that no member", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00019-00005905-00006231": "state in any way this process if", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00020-00006232-00006438": "any developments threaten the withdrawal", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00021-00006439-00006669": "of troops the Security Council requested", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00022-00006670-00007023": "to be informed United Nations Security", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00023-00007023-00007348": "Council resolution 5 passed on May 8", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00024-00007350-00007752": "1946 deferred decisions on Soviet troops", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00025-00007753-00007995": "in Iran until the Iranian government had", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00026-00007995-00008232": "time to confer with the Soviet Union and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00027-00008233-00008475": "submit a report to the UN regarding all", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00028-00008476-00008700": "information about Soviet troops in the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00029-00008701-00009028": "country United Nations Security Council", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00030-00009029-00009399": "resolution 6096 passed on the 31st of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00031-00009400-00009837": "July 2006 demanded that Iran suspend all", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00032-00009838-00010028": "enrichment related and reprocessing", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00033-00010029-00010209": "activities and threatened sanctions", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00034-00010210-00010473": "invoking Chapter 7 of the United Nations", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00035-00010474-00010719": "Charter to make that demand legally", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00036-00010720-00011046": "binding on Iran United Nations Security", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00037-00011047-00011399": "Council resolution 17 37 passed on the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00038-00011400-00011753": "23rd of December 2006 in response to the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00039-00011754-00011946": "proliferation risks presented by the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00040-00011947-00012162": "Iranian nuclear program and in this", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00041-00012163-00012428": "context by Iran's continuing failure to", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00042-00012429-00012560": "meet the requirements of the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00043-00012561-00012795": "International Atomic Energy Agency Board", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00044-00012796-00012978": "of Governors and to comply with the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00045-00012979-00013166": "provisions of Security Council", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00046-00013168-00013683": "resolution 16 96 2006 made mandatory for", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00047-00013684-00013913": "Iran to suspend enrichment related and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00048-00013915-00014138": "reprocessing activities and cooperate", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00049-00014140-00014403": "with the IAEA imposed sanctions banning", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00050-00014404-00014643": "the supply of nuclear related materials", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00051-00014644-00014880": "and technology and froze the assets of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00052-00014881-00015119": "key individuals and companies related to", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00053-00015120-00015269": "Iran's nuclear and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00054-00015271-00015569": "programs it established a committee to", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00055-00015571-00015936": "monitor sanctions implementation United", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00056-00015937-00016221": "Nations Security Council resolution 17", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00057-00016222-00016625": "47 passed on the 24th of March 2007", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00058-00016626-00016944": "imposed an arms embargo and expanded the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00059-00016945-00017172": "freeze on Iranian assets welcomed the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00060-00017173-00017340": "proposal by the permanent five members", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00061-00017341-00017634": "of the Security Council plus Germany for", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00062-00017635-00017832": "resolving issues regarding Iran's", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00063-00017833-00018174": "nuclear program United Nations Security", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00064-00018175-00018492": "Council resolution 1803 passed on the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00065-00018493-00018873": "3rd of March 2008 extended the asset", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00066-00018874-00019077": "freezes and called upon states to", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00067-00019078-00019290": "monitor the activities of Iranian banks", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00068-00019291-00019557": "inspect Iranian ships and aircraft and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00069-00019558-00019755": "to monitor the movement of individuals", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00070-00019756-00019944": "involved with the program through their", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00071-00019945-00020184": "territory imposed travel restrictions on", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00072-00020185-00020424": "sanctioned persons and bar exports of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00073-00020425-00020616": "nuclear and missile related dual-use", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00074-00020617-00020970": "goods to Iran United Nations Security", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00075-00020971-00021366": "Council resolution 1835 passed the 27th", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00076-00021367-00021630": "of September 2008 reaffirmed the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00077-00021631-00021870": "preceding four resolutions the only one", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00078-00021871-00022139": "of the seven not to invoke chapter 7", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00079-00022140-00022367": "United Nations Security Council", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00080-00022368-00022689": "resolution 1929 passed on the 9th of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00081-00022690-00023073": "June 2010 and Iran from participating in", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00082-00023074-00023250": "any activities related to ballistic", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00083-00023251-00023456": "missiles tightened the arms embargo", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00084-00023457-00023754": "travel bans on individuals involved with", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00085-00023755-00023985": "the program froze the funds and assets", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00086-00023986-00024192": "of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00087-00024193-00024414": "Islamic Republic of Iran shipping lines", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00088-00024415-00024639": "and recommended that States inspect", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00089-00024640-00024879": "Iranian cargo prohibit the servicing of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00090-00024880-00025104": "Iranian vessels involved in prohibited", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00091-00025105-00025305": "activities prevent the provision of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00092-00025306-00025542": "financial services used for sensitive", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00093-00025543-00025808": "nuclear activities closely watch Iranian", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00094-00025810-00026025": "individuals and entities when dealing", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00095-00026026-00026181": "with them prohibit the opening of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00096-00026182-00026373": "Iranian banks on the territory and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00097-00026374-00026577": "prevent Iranian banks from entering into", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00098-00026577-00026783": "relationship with the banks if it might", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00099-00026785-00026985": "contribute to the nuclear program and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00100-00026986-00027249": "prevent financial institutions operating", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00101-00027250-00027411": "in the territory from opening offices", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00102-00027412-00027726": "and accounts in Iran the resolution", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00103-00027727-00027987": "passed by a vote of 12 to 2 with Turkey", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00104-00027988-00028197": "and Brazil voting against and Lebanon", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00105-00028198-00028494": "abstaining a number of countries imposed", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00106-00028495-00028652": "measures to implement and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00107-00028654-00028854": "extend these sanctions including the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00108-00028855-00029073": "United States the European Union", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00109-00029074-00029388": "Australia Canada Japan Norway South", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00110-00029389-00029730": "Korea and Russia United Nations Security", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00111-00029731-00030069": "Council resolution 1984 passed on the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00112-00030070-00030354": "9th of June 2011 this resolution", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00113-00030355-00030591": "extended the Mandate of the panel of", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00114-00030592-00030885": "experts established by resolution 1929", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00115-00030886-00031064": "that supports the Iran sanctions", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00116-00031066-00031427": "committee for one year United Nations", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00117-00031429-00031745": "Security Council resolution 2049 passed", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00118-00031747-00032085": "on the 7th of June 2012 renewed the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00119-00032086-00032304": "Mandate of the Iran sanctions committees", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00120-00032305-00032649": "panel of experts for one year United", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00121-00032650-00033057": "Nations Security Council resolution 2105", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00122-00033058-00033420": "passed the 5th of June 2013 renewed the", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00123-00033421-00033639": "Mandate of the Iran sanctions committees", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00124-00033640-00033987": "panel of experts for one year United", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00125-00033988-00034404": "Nations Security Council resolution 2159", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00126-00034405-00034764": "passed the ninth of June 2014 renewed", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00127-00034765-00034920": "the Mandate of the Iran sanctions", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00128-00034921-00035249": "committees panel of experts for one year", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00129-00035250-00035483": "United Nations Security Council", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00130-00035484-00035955": "resolution 2231 passed the 20th of July", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00131-00035956-00036339": "2015 endorsed the Iran nuclear deal and", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00132-00036340-00036555": "lifted all previous sanctions on Iran", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00133-00036556-00036804": "provided that Iran remains in compliance", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00134-00036805-00037047": "with its responsibilities in the nuclear", "MpTj3-vCFNc-00135-00037048-00037278": "deal"}}, {"audio_id": "MpUwn__YYuM", "text": {"MpUwn__YYuM-00000-00000422-00000784": "I you know I've learned something in all", "MpUwn__YYuM-00001-00000785-00000928": "of my time on the internet and that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00002-00000930-00001162": "that if you don't hate yourself", "MpUwn__YYuM-00003-00001163-00001324": "you're not really on the internet", "MpUwn__YYuM-00004-00001325-00001504": "Because the Internet teaches you to hate", "MpUwn__YYuM-00005-00001505-00001660": "yourself", "MpUwn__YYuM-00006-00001661-00001882": "that's some solid philosophy right there", "MpUwn__YYuM-00007-00001884-00002171": "I gotta say so these three lovely people", "MpUwn__YYuM-00008-00002172-00002339": "have their own channels have their own", "MpUwn__YYuM-00009-00002340-00002500": "links have their own stuff that they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00010-00002501-00002663": "work on they do it a lot better than I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00011-00002664-00002813": "do the links are down below except for", "MpUwn__YYuM-00012-00002814-00003023": "vashati", "MpUwn__YYuM-00013-00003024-00003427": "I mean if there's a video on my channel", "MpUwn__YYuM-00014-00003428-00003706": "a lot of work to launch a channel so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00015-00003707-00003904": "this is true I don't know what you mean", "MpUwn__YYuM-00016-00003905-00004127": "by a channel unless you mean some kind", "MpUwn__YYuM-00017-00004128-00004354": "of ah Channel", "MpUwn__YYuM-00018-00004355-00004656": "a channel", "MpUwn__YYuM-00019-00004657-00004859": "channels if anybody remembers that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00020-00004860-00005038": "terrible Frank I think it was it was", "MpUwn__YYuM-00021-00005039-00005201": "either William Lane Craig or Frank Turk", "MpUwn__YYuM-00022-00005202-00005327": "that did the whole like I don't know", "MpUwn__YYuM-00023-00005328-00005483": "what you mean by atheism unless you mean", "MpUwn__YYuM-00024-00005484-00005772": "some kind of atheism", "MpUwn__YYuM-00025-00005773-00006245": "I forgot about that oh no at least it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00026-00006246-00006467": "not as bad as Amanda calvo saying there", "MpUwn__YYuM-00027-00006468-00006664": "aren't any atheists because atheist just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00028-00006665-00006819": "means a theist", "MpUwn__YYuM-00029-00006820-00006881": "[Music]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00030-00006883-00007069": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00031-00007070-00007409": "yeah uh all right please direct me to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00032-00007409-00007559": "the [__] Razorback these are the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00033-00007559-00007728": "jokes", "MpUwn__YYuM-00034-00007729-00008074": "all right so I'm here I'm excited these", "MpUwn__YYuM-00035-00008075-00008285": "guys hate themselves and I mean we can", "MpUwn__YYuM-00036-00008286-00008441": "pretty much just jump right into it if", "MpUwn__YYuM-00037-00008442-00008603": "we want except I do think it's a good", "MpUwn__YYuM-00038-00008604-00008824": "idea if you want to chill to do it now", "MpUwn__YYuM-00039-00008825-00009077": "rather than and then again at the end so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00040-00009078-00009281": "that way you get out where people can", "MpUwn__YYuM-00041-00009282-00009509": "find you so that way they can", "MpUwn__YYuM-00042-00009510-00009773": "have to listen subscribe to those too", "MpUwn__YYuM-00043-00009774-00010031": "yes subscribe to those two it's a it's a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00044-00010032-00010246": "good idea to go subscribe to Dr Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00045-00010247-00010421": "it's a really bad idea to come anywhere", "MpUwn__YYuM-00046-00010422-00010655": "near my channel", "MpUwn__YYuM-00047-00010656-00010949": "laughs", "MpUwn__YYuM-00048-00010950-00011171": "if you want to learn stuff go go", "MpUwn__YYuM-00049-00011172-00011369": "subscribe to Dr Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00050-00011370-00011764": "if you want the generously go to service", "MpUwn__YYuM-00051-00011765-00011946": "basically", "MpUwn__YYuM-00052-00011947-00012281": "basically a degeneracy I have no idea", "MpUwn__YYuM-00053-00012282-00012706": "what you're talking about", "MpUwn__YYuM-00054-00012707-00012922": "there you go", "MpUwn__YYuM-00055-00012923-00013193": "all right should we go", "MpUwn__YYuM-00056-00013194-00013403": "yeah we should all right yeah let's get", "MpUwn__YYuM-00057-00013404-00013679": "started with all right all right so I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00058-00013680-00013930": "did skip the first couple of minutes", "MpUwn__YYuM-00059-00013931-00014177": "just because it's just some it's a very", "MpUwn__YYuM-00060-00014178-00014429": "bizarre introduction if I ever did see", "MpUwn__YYuM-00061-00014430-00014680": "one uh but it's not that entertaining", "MpUwn__YYuM-00062-00014681-00014879": "it's just kind of strange and he talks", "MpUwn__YYuM-00063-00014880-00015143": "about dreams and he how he did a thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00064-00015144-00015371": "on Genesis before and now he wants to go", "MpUwn__YYuM-00065-00015372-00015575": "through and do the entire Bible so this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00066-00015576-00015743": "is The Exodus one", "MpUwn__YYuM-00067-00015744-00016019": "so this is only available as far as I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00068-00016019-00016277": "know if you pay for the daily wire", "MpUwn__YYuM-00069-00016278-00016630": "subscription which I definitely did and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00070-00016631-00016894": "I am definitely not telling people or", "MpUwn__YYuM-00071-00016895-00017207": "encouraging piracy at all why would you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00072-00017208-00017680": "ever do that I I would never legal I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00073-00017681-00017944": "would never do anything like that so I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00074-00017945-00018136": "do have it mirrored so if you do see any", "MpUwn__YYuM-00075-00018137-00018341": "text on the screen it is going to be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00076-00018342-00018527": "backwards so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00077-00018528-00018730": "let's just jump into it shall we check", "MpUwn__YYuM-00078-00018731-00019079": "mate Hebrews written right to left I win", "MpUwn__YYuM-00079-00019080-00019372": "oh perfect three backwards", "MpUwn__YYuM-00080-00019373-00019667": "turns out my my big brain actually got", "MpUwn__YYuM-00081-00019668-00019829": "it right", "MpUwn__YYuM-00082-00019830-00020272": "there story and what it means and why", "MpUwn__YYuM-00083-00020273-00020477": "it's significant today and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00084-00020478-00020663": "hang on and why it's been significant", "MpUwn__YYuM-00085-00020664-00020939": "for several thoughts", "MpUwn__YYuM-00086-00020940-00021203": "I have gone until that very moment", "MpUwn__YYuM-00087-00021204-00021443": "without hearing this guy's voice wait", "MpUwn__YYuM-00088-00021444-00021586": "really I thought it would be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00089-00021587-00021905": "you've never never heard you've never", "MpUwn__YYuM-00090-00021906-00022097": "heard the Glorious voice of Jordan B", "MpUwn__YYuM-00091-00022098-00022325": "Peterson", "MpUwn__YYuM-00092-00022326-00022511": "calm down Kermit", "MpUwn__YYuM-00093-00022512-00022727": "I will never calm down it's not easy", "MpUwn__YYuM-00094-00022728-00023117": "listening to someone I understand", "MpUwn__YYuM-00095-00023118-00023297": "if I want to listen to someone off their", "MpUwn__YYuM-00096-00023298-00023453": "own farts it's not going to be him", "MpUwn__YYuM-00097-00023454-00023711": "so I assumed that his voice would be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00098-00023712-00023867": "like faux intellectual and like really", "MpUwn__YYuM-00099-00023868-00024011": "deep okay", "MpUwn__YYuM-00100-00024012-00024221": "I'm just imagining just imagine that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00101-00024222-00024383": "voice but he's saying the chemical", "MpUwn__YYuM-00102-00024384-00024622": "composition of his own farts like Edward", "MpUwn__YYuM-00103-00024623-00024772": "Elric when he's talking about how a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00104-00024773-00024989": "human body is made", "MpUwn__YYuM-00105-00024990-00025213": "he's just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00106-00025214-00025564": "reciting it the whole time", "MpUwn__YYuM-00107-00025565-00025828": "oh we have uh two uh memberships for 35", "MpUwn__YYuM-00108-00025829-00026081": "months that said uh hello everyone and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00109-00026082-00026279": "celebrate 35 months can we get an oo", "MpUwn__YYuM-00110-00026280-00026417": "from Cyrus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00111-00026418-00027293": "no you can't go away", "MpUwn__YYuM-00112-00027294-00027514": "Mania said this is going to be my", "MpUwn__YYuM-00113-00027516-00027857": "numbing and one question for Dr Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00114-00027858-00028085": "um have you ever auditioned for Chip and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00115-00028086-00028333": "Dales I can hook you up", "MpUwn__YYuM-00116-00028333-00028631": "yeah there's this uh this video did it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00117-00028632-00028870": "on Saturday Night Live uh I think it was", "MpUwn__YYuM-00118-00028872-00029183": "opposite Patrick Swayze that was me", "MpUwn__YYuM-00119-00029183-00029399": "Chris Farley", "MpUwn__YYuM-00120-00029400-00029908": "everybody's working for the weekend", "MpUwn__YYuM-00121-00029910-00030137": "all right are we ready to go now that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00122-00030138-00030377": "we've popped uh vishantes Jordan", "MpUwn__YYuM-00123-00030377-00030593": "Peterson Cherry which is a sentence that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00124-00030594-00030851": "makes please never say Jordan Peterson", "MpUwn__YYuM-00125-00030852-00030983": "cherry", "MpUwn__YYuM-00126-00030983-00031267": "please don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-00127-00031268-00031583": "I'm gonna take a bath in acid after this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00128-00031583-00031781": "is over so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00129-00031782-00031999": "I told you I'm here you're here for pain", "MpUwn__YYuM-00130-00032000-00032314": "let's go yeah it's yours and so I'll get", "MpUwn__YYuM-00131-00032316-00032458": "everybody first of all to introduce", "MpUwn__YYuM-00132-00032460-00032627": "themselves and I'm going to start with", "MpUwn__YYuM-00133-00032627-00032861": "Dr Douglas Headley on my left it will go", "MpUwn__YYuM-00134-00032862-00033155": "around this way and Dr Headley well my", "MpUwn__YYuM-00135-00033156-00033655": "name is Douglas Headley and I'm a fellow", "MpUwn__YYuM-00136-00033656-00034121": "Lamar University Cambridge College and I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00137-00034122-00034333": "teach the philosophy of religion", "MpUwn__YYuM-00138-00034334-00034751": "and I think there's the crisis not a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00139-00034752-00034961": "person with a history degree got it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00140-00034962-00035381": "no I love this guy's voice", "MpUwn__YYuM-00141-00035382-00035621": "they're they're all gonna be experts in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00142-00035622-00035824": "a field that's not this one they'll be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00143-00035825-00036046": "experts in everything", "MpUwn__YYuM-00144-00036047-00036299": "I just like the that this guy that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00145-00036300-00036568": "sounds like this and looks like that is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00146-00036569-00036851": "the philosopher", "MpUwn__YYuM-00147-00036852-00037049": "I think I'm sorry I'm gonna be making", "MpUwn__YYuM-00148-00037050-00037235": "Blazing Saddles jokes this whole time", "MpUwn__YYuM-00149-00037236-00037427": "princess guy's name's actually Headley", "MpUwn__YYuM-00150-00037428-00037655": "and so every single time I'm gonna think", "MpUwn__YYuM-00151-00037656-00037949": "of Hedley Lamar why do you think I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00152-00037950-00038333": "invited you here", "MpUwn__YYuM-00153-00038334-00038537": "so I could [__] post", "MpUwn__YYuM-00154-00038538-00038735": "there we go that's contributing nothing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00155-00038736-00038902": "[__] post everything the only person", "MpUwn__YYuM-00156-00038903-00039023": "who's gonna have anything to contribute", "MpUwn__YYuM-00157-00039024-00039167": "here is gonna be Dr Josh let's be honest", "MpUwn__YYuM-00158-00039168-00039401": "let's be honest with ourselves", "MpUwn__YYuM-00159-00039402-00039737": "all right show's on your back", "MpUwn__YYuM-00160-00039738-00039880": "no pressure", "MpUwn__YYuM-00161-00039881-00040079": "he's just like thanks guys why can't I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00162-00040080-00040246": "be a [__] poster you can be a [__]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00163-00040247-00040517": "poster you're allowed here probably yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00164-00040518-00040817": "yeah probably wouldn't be any good at it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00165-00040818-00040996": "I can make up", "MpUwn__YYuM-00166-00040997-00041255": "all you have to do is do your Kent Hoven", "MpUwn__YYuM-00167-00041256-00041830": "impersonation and we will all get on it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00168-00041831-00042305": "in our culture and the crisis is linked", "MpUwn__YYuM-00169-00042306-00042623": "to a certain ignorance of the very", "MpUwn__YYuM-00170-00042624-00042971": "backbone of our own culture and the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00171-00042972-00043337": "Bible is very much at the core of our", "MpUwn__YYuM-00172-00043338-00043577": "cultural inheritage", "MpUwn__YYuM-00173-00043578-00043768": "at the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00174-00043769-00044152": "Temple of Apollo in Delphi there was an", "MpUwn__YYuM-00175-00044153-00044477": "inscription know thyself and we're in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00176-00044478-00044662": "danger of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00177-00044663-00044993": "not being able to know ourselves because", "MpUwn__YYuM-00178-00044994-00045365": "of the ignorance of the very foundations", "MpUwn__YYuM-00179-00045366-00045701": "of our inscription was actually in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00180-00045702-00045911": "kitchen for the oracle", "MpUwn__YYuM-00181-00045912-00046240": "that's that's completely where I saw it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00182-00046241-00046471": "oh in The Matrix", "MpUwn__YYuM-00183-00046472-00046780": "oh it was on okay she's making him", "MpUwn__YYuM-00184-00046781-00047111": "cookies yeah yeah she was like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00185-00047112-00047473": "isn't Heritage a word", "MpUwn__YYuM-00186-00047474-00047818": "to say inheritage am I missing something", "MpUwn__YYuM-00187-00047819-00048046": "I'm actually not 100 certain but I am", "MpUwn__YYuM-00188-00048047-00048346": "willing to be the consummate googler", "MpUwn__YYuM-00189-00048347-00048665": "real quick oh well thank you let's see", "MpUwn__YYuM-00190-00048666-00048817": "here", "MpUwn__YYuM-00191-00048818-00049121": "uh is this one in the chat is asking is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00192-00049122-00049271": "this guy using an upgraded Stephen", "MpUwn__YYuM-00193-00049272-00049633": "Hawking Speak and Spell", "MpUwn__YYuM-00194-00049634-00049895": "uh in Heritage", "MpUwn__YYuM-00195-00049896-00050285": "is actually a word it's an archaic form", "MpUwn__YYuM-00196-00050286-00050507": "of it is actually an archaic form of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00197-00050508-00050717": "inheritance which means", "MpUwn__YYuM-00198-00050718-00050999": "that this man is up his own ass", "MpUwn__YYuM-00199-00051000-00051232": "because the only people who use archaic", "MpUwn__YYuM-00200-00051233-00051575": "versions of actual like the words that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00201-00051576-00051875": "we have standard usage for now are", "MpUwn__YYuM-00202-00051876-00052073": "people who are up their own ass", "MpUwn__YYuM-00203-00052074-00052235": "saying", "MpUwn__YYuM-00204-00052236-00052420": "oh yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00205-00052421-00052680": "absolutely there's no reason", "MpUwn__YYuM-00206-00052682-00052954": "of people who use like that upper class", "MpUwn__YYuM-00207-00052955-00053242": "Posh received pronunciation and people", "MpUwn__YYuM-00208-00053244-00053488": "up their own ass it's very close to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00209-00053489-00053644": "being a circle but it's not quite it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00210-00053645-00053776": "like there are some people who are very", "MpUwn__YYuM-00211-00053777-00053915": "humble that also have received", "MpUwn__YYuM-00212-00053916-00054226": "pronunciation so it's like have you have", "MpUwn__YYuM-00213-00054227-00054521": "any of you read The Dresden Files", "MpUwn__YYuM-00214-00054522-00054850": "uh a little bit of them so the the white", "MpUwn__YYuM-00215-00054851-00055025": "Council and the Dresden Files they only", "MpUwn__YYuM-00216-00055026-00055216": "ever speak to each other in Latin not", "MpUwn__YYuM-00217-00055217-00055397": "because they need to not because they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00218-00055398-00055541": "need to but because they're all arrogant", "MpUwn__YYuM-00219-00055541-00055669": "classical", "MpUwn__YYuM-00220-00055670-00055937": "uh classical Latin because many of them", "MpUwn__YYuM-00221-00055938-00056200": "are actually pronunciation it's hard to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00222-00056201-00056363": "say because it's it's literally it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00223-00056364-00056621": "written as they spoke these things in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00224-00056622-00056873": "Latin and then you uh it's written in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00225-00056874-00057029": "English", "MpUwn__YYuM-00226-00057029-00057275": "so I would assume I would assume", "MpUwn__YYuM-00227-00057276-00057491": "classical because most of them are old", "MpUwn__YYuM-00228-00057491-00057785": "like very very oldest sin I was gonna", "MpUwn__YYuM-00229-00057786-00057988": "say because people there's this whole", "MpUwn__YYuM-00230-00057989-00058138": "debate in the Latin speaking community", "MpUwn__YYuM-00231-00058139-00058319": "of whether you use ecclesiastical or", "MpUwn__YYuM-00232-00058320-00058475": "classical pronunciation it's like a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00233-00058476-00058787": "whole thing yeah as far as 12 books into", "MpUwn__YYuM-00234-00058788-00058930": "the series and as far as I know Jim", "MpUwn__YYuM-00235-00058932-00059159": "Butcher never makes a distinction", "MpUwn__YYuM-00236-00059160-00059332": "but he does at least say that it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00237-00059333-00059650": "because they are all pops [__]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00238-00059651-00059759": "Eric", "MpUwn__YYuM-00239-00059760-00059975": "if he comes back to DragonCon this year", "MpUwn__YYuM-00240-00059976-00060209": "then I'll ask him okay there we go write", "MpUwn__YYuM-00241-00060210-00060425": "that one down he shows up and hangs out", "MpUwn__YYuM-00242-00060426-00060676": "in the art of Sally so awesome just grab", "MpUwn__YYuM-00243-00060677-00060887": "just be like hey which kind which kind", "MpUwn__YYuM-00244-00060888-00061085": "of which kind of Latin does the white", "MpUwn__YYuM-00245-00061086-00061530": "Council speak just yet", "MpUwn__YYuM-00246-00061532-00061792": "shove a microphone on his face and just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00247-00061794-00061966": "be like um excuse me I didn't know about", "MpUwn__YYuM-00248-00061967-00062075": "your thoughts about this very", "MpUwn__YYuM-00249-00062076-00062369": "controversial topic", "MpUwn__YYuM-00250-00062370-00062725": "fandom is split gym", "MpUwn__YYuM-00251-00062726-00063130": "white Council fans need to know", "MpUwn__YYuM-00252-00063132-00063354": "I'm particularly", "MpUwn__YYuM-00253-00063355-00063809": "fascinated by Dr Peterson's Endeavors in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00254-00063810-00064338": "the last few years", "MpUwn__YYuM-00255-00064339-00064582": "developments they're all dick suckers in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00256-00064583-00064747": "the next few days", "MpUwn__YYuM-00257-00064748-00065063": "I warmed your invitation because I was", "MpUwn__YYuM-00258-00065064-00065213": "born in China", "MpUwn__YYuM-00259-00065214-00065506": "and I was a seven-year-old in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00260-00065507-00065729": "Chinese Revolution", "MpUwn__YYuM-00261-00065730-00066005": "and when I was later an Oxford student I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00262-00066006-00066329": "had dinner with sir Isaiah Berlin", "MpUwn__YYuM-00263-00066330-00066538": "in the Chinese Revolution I know that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00264-00066539-00066821": "bad grammar he probably meant during the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00265-00066822-00066994": "revolution but then when he said I was a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00266-00066995-00067193": "seven-year-old in the Chinese Revolution", "MpUwn__YYuM-00267-00067194-00067523": "that implies that he fought in it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00268-00067524-00067775": "this is true", "MpUwn__YYuM-00269-00067776-00067937": "I don't think that's what he meant I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00270-00067938-00068099": "don't think it's what he meant either I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00271-00068100-00068255": "don't think he meant like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00272-00068256-00068671": "father sold me into the wall you see", "MpUwn__YYuM-00273-00068672-00069071": "I was a Child Soldier this is an edited", "MpUwn__YYuM-00274-00069072-00069406": "like movie style documentary style thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00275-00069407-00069713": "like they could have just not", "MpUwn__YYuM-00276-00069714-00070006": "could have done a retake", "MpUwn__YYuM-00277-00070007-00070259": "the great Jewish philosopher and as it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00278-00070260-00070505": "turned out he'd been a seven-year-old in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00279-00070506-00070685": "the Russian Revolution", "MpUwn__YYuM-00280-00070686-00070906": "and comparing notes on it and we were", "MpUwn__YYuM-00281-00070907-00071141": "saying what the revolutions meant", "MpUwn__YYuM-00282-00071142-00071329": "but the lack of people today", "MpUwn__YYuM-00283-00071330-00071665": "understanding them and for me Exodus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00284-00071666-00071909": "obviously a classic in its own right", "MpUwn__YYuM-00285-00071910-00072053": "politically", "MpUwn__YYuM-00286-00072054-00072575": "the birth of a great nation and people", "MpUwn__YYuM-00287-00072576-00072809": "but many people don't realize this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00288-00072810-00073163": "behind the English Revolution and also", "MpUwn__YYuM-00289-00073164-00073409": "behind the American Revolution", "MpUwn__YYuM-00290-00073410-00073625": "and to understand that throws an", "MpUwn__YYuM-00291-00073626-00073871": "incredible light on the present crisis", "MpUwn__YYuM-00292-00073872-00074129": "because as I say you've got a basic", "MpUwn__YYuM-00293-00074130-00074453": "clash between ideas coming down from the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00294-00074454-00074593": "American Revolution", "MpUwn__YYuM-00295-00074594-00075029": "1776 which came from you mentioned you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00296-00075030-00075209": "mentioned that they that this is very", "MpUwn__YYuM-00297-00075210-00075371": "edited and they had the ability to use", "MpUwn__YYuM-00298-00075372-00075665": "another take am I the only one and maybe", "MpUwn__YYuM-00299-00075666-00075838": "it's some kind of neurodivergency for me", "MpUwn__YYuM-00300-00075839-00076049": "I don't know but am I the only one that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00301-00076050-00076253": "is hearing very very wet sounds coming", "MpUwn__YYuM-00302-00076254-00076571": "from his mouth", "MpUwn__YYuM-00303-00076572-00077215": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00304-00077216-00077411": "I don't think I've ever looked at a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00305-00077412-00077615": "person in my life and went God you make", "MpUwn__YYuM-00306-00077616-00077932": "a lot of wet sounds that's Charming", "MpUwn__YYuM-00307-00077933-00078761": "hi I'm glad we finished", "MpUwn__YYuM-00308-00078762-00078905": "because I was like well it's not really", "MpUwn__YYuM-00309-00078906-00079132": "gonna add to like The Exodus part but", "MpUwn__YYuM-00310-00079133-00079421": "they're spitting garbage like this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00311-00079422-00079721": "glad I left it in I'm well because", "MpUwn__YYuM-00312-00079722-00079853": "inevitably I'm gonna be like who the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00313-00079854-00080188": "[__] is this [__] right right we get", "MpUwn__YYuM-00314-00080189-00080291": "this out of the way", "MpUwn__YYuM-00315-00080292-00080644": "on the Torah and ideas which come down", "MpUwn__YYuM-00316-00080645-00080891": "from the French Revolution and it says", "MpUwn__YYuM-00317-00080892-00081269": "and so we've got a profound crisis and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00318-00081270-00081467": "many people don't understand the roots", "MpUwn__YYuM-00319-00081468-00081682": "of it on either side", "MpUwn__YYuM-00320-00081683-00081894": "so what you're doing I think is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00321-00081895-00082109": "immensely I promise no one keeps", "MpUwn__YYuM-00322-00082110-00082349": "stopping us every 30 seconds but that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00323-00082350-00082588": "what we're here for", "MpUwn__YYuM-00324-00082589-00082769": "when he's safe he's saying that the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00325-00082770-00083087": "American Revolution happened because of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00326-00083088-00083375": "Exodus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00327-00083376-00083675": "um I don't think that he's got that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00328-00083676-00083903": "quite right oh yeah I mean I'm I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00329-00083904-00084143": "fairly certain I think that I'm fairly", "MpUwn__YYuM-00330-00084144-00084262": "certain there might have been at least a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00331-00084263-00084515": "handful of people in in the early like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00332-00084516-00084809": "Puritan movements that saw themselves", "MpUwn__YYuM-00333-00084810-00085162": "like the Israelites leaving like I could", "MpUwn__YYuM-00334-00085163-00085343": "imagine that was at least some", "MpUwn__YYuM-00335-00085344-00085576": "conversation sure yeah people right", "MpUwn__YYuM-00336-00085577-00085859": "taking that that identity on over the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00337-00085860-00086147": "years but uh whether whether earned or", "MpUwn__YYuM-00338-00086148-00086285": "not are you sure that it had a little", "MpUwn__YYuM-00339-00086286-00086503": "bit more to do with like representative", "MpUwn__YYuM-00340-00086504-00086999": "governments and tax rates and stuff like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00341-00087000-00087547": "that and not hey guys Exodus stuff", "MpUwn__YYuM-00342-00087548-00087887": "the English the English Monarchy is the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00343-00087888-00088282": "pharaoh to our Moses of of then again", "MpUwn__YYuM-00344-00088283-00088487": "Erica leave it to the English guy to get", "MpUwn__YYuM-00345-00088488-00088618": "the reasons for the American Revolution", "MpUwn__YYuM-00346-00088619-00088817": "wrong so oh you got a license for those", "MpUwn__YYuM-00347-00088818-00089237": "slaves", "MpUwn__YYuM-00348-00089238-00089417": "well I mean apparently there's like a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00349-00089418-00089650": "good portion of America that would say", "MpUwn__YYuM-00350-00089651-00089867": "like all the you know the Confederate", "MpUwn__YYuM-00351-00089868-00090143": "types that that would say that slavery", "MpUwn__YYuM-00352-00090144-00090317": "was fine so they shouldn't have an issue", "MpUwn__YYuM-00353-00090318-00090550": "or they would have an issue with Exodus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00354-00090551-00090832": "from Moses's side", "MpUwn__YYuM-00355-00090833-00091085": "oh Dr Josh there's a cue for you in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00356-00091086-00091265": "chat I'm gonna read it because I want to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00357-00091266-00091523": "answer it first uh there's a cue for Dr", "MpUwn__YYuM-00358-00091524-00091667": "Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00359-00091668-00091888": "Dr Robert M price does not think very", "MpUwn__YYuM-00360-00091889-00092032": "highly of you what's your response my", "MpUwn__YYuM-00361-00092033-00092376": "response is eat a dick Bob", "MpUwn__YYuM-00362-00092377-00092632": "ah so bashadi's just gonna answer for Dr", "MpUwn__YYuM-00363-00092633-00092788": "Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00364-00092789-00092975": "that's my answer that's not Dr Josh's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00365-00092976-00093268": "answer just so you know that's me that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00366-00093269-00093443": "was me", "MpUwn__YYuM-00367-00093444-00093688": "oh that was a real question it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00368-00093689-00093868": "actually in there yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00369-00093869-00094259": "you don't feel", "MpUwn__YYuM-00370-00094260-00094529": "I mean I you know I'm the kind of person", "MpUwn__YYuM-00371-00094530-00094655": "that's never", "MpUwn__YYuM-00372-00094656-00095009": "thrilled when people don't like me but", "MpUwn__YYuM-00373-00095010-00095255": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-00374-00095256-00095644": "I feel like uh yeah I mean it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00375-00095645-00095909": "that's not great I guess", "MpUwn__YYuM-00376-00095910-00096197": "um but that's gonna feel good I feel", "MpUwn__YYuM-00377-00096198-00096473": "good uh about", "MpUwn__YYuM-00378-00096474-00096743": "my track record", "MpUwn__YYuM-00379-00096744-00097156": "so you're also not a misogynist so you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00380-00097157-00097349": "got that going for you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00381-00097350-00097523": "unlike Robert", "MpUwn__YYuM-00382-00097524-00097847": "shoddy's got all the shade let's go", "MpUwn__YYuM-00383-00097848-00098087": "listen I know the T on this whole thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00384-00098088-00098297": "so oh I don't know the T all right you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00385-00098298-00098555": "guys gonna have to spill it later then", "MpUwn__YYuM-00386-00098556-00098729": "yeah you guys got to fill me in in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00387-00098730-00099041": "background apparently I missed something", "MpUwn__YYuM-00388-00099042-00099412": "later Dr Orr James Orr my name is Chang", "MpUwn__YYuM-00389-00099413-00099617": "zor I'm uh assistant professor in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00390-00099618-00099737": "philosophy of religion at the University", "MpUwn__YYuM-00391-00099738-00099994": "of Cambridge where I teach philosophy of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00392-00099995-00100109": "religion and moral philosophy", "MpUwn__YYuM-00393-00100110-00100379": "theological ethics and much of that work", "MpUwn__YYuM-00394-00100380-00100606": "focuses on what you might call the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00395-00100607-00100894": "Hellenic that is to say the the Fountain", "MpUwn__YYuM-00396-00100895-00101279": "of Western wisdom in Greek philosophy", "MpUwn__YYuM-00397-00101280-00101524": "too often I think we neglect the hebraic", "MpUwn__YYuM-00398-00101525-00101717": "that is to say the contribution to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00399-00101718-00102023": "western thought of the great abreic", "MpUwn__YYuM-00400-00102024-00102287": "sources and most of all of course the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00401-00102288-00102592": "Torah the pentateuch it's thrilling to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00402-00102593-00102816": "be able to sit around and talk with", "MpUwn__YYuM-00403-00102817-00103049": "these distinguished friends and with you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00404-00103050-00103223": "Dr Peterson about about the book of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00405-00103224-00103336": "Exodus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00406-00103338-00103577": "um as Oz was saying it has enormous", "MpUwn__YYuM-00407-00103578-00103768": "significance historically the English", "MpUwn__YYuM-00408-00103769-00103930": "Revolution the American Revolution and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00409-00103931-00104116": "more recently many of the sort of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00410-00104117-00104327": "Liberation narratives that we're", "MpUwn__YYuM-00411-00104328-00104530": "familiar with in the Contemporary from", "MpUwn__YYuM-00412-00104531-00104692": "the Contemporary political landscape and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00413-00104693-00104866": "contemporary debates", "MpUwn__YYuM-00414-00104867-00105269": "it's almost like it's a popular trope", "MpUwn__YYuM-00415-00105270-00105689": "yeah I'm also again once more", "MpUwn__YYuM-00416-00105690-00105983": "we have not found somebody with a with a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00417-00105983-00106086": "degree", "MpUwn__YYuM-00418-00106088-00106373": "in in any form of History we've we have", "MpUwn__YYuM-00419-00106374-00106589": "found people whose professions are on", "MpUwn__YYuM-00420-00106590-00106907": "talking about philosophy people and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00421-00106908-00107158": "they're just as as a person who had a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00422-00107159-00107386": "very very deep hyper fixation uh on", "MpUwn__YYuM-00423-00107388-00107681": "Philosophy for a long enough to make a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00424-00107682-00107921": "whole Channel about it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00425-00107922-00108125": "I don't give a [__] what any philosopher", "MpUwn__YYuM-00426-00108126-00108245": "thinks", "MpUwn__YYuM-00427-00108246-00108569": "just that's just that's just where I got", "MpUwn__YYuM-00428-00108570-00108815": "from like rereading Bunches of things in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00429-00108816-00109054": "the SCP I finally just went wow", "MpUwn__YYuM-00430-00109055-00109181": "these are a lot of interesting", "MpUwn__YYuM-00431-00109182-00109447": "perspectives I've stopped giving a [__]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00432-00109448-00110104": "this round table is just an SCP", "MpUwn__YYuM-00433-00110105-00110452": "the active one oh my God amazing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00434-00110453-00110669": "welcome to debate Hub Euclid this stream", "MpUwn__YYuM-00435-00110670-00110825": "is anomalous", "MpUwn__YYuM-00436-00110826-00111004": "well it's the thing is like why are they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00437-00111005-00111310": "all English first off second off like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00438-00111311-00111671": "why why across the table okay I mean so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00439-00111672-00111928": "far this this we're on the third one out", "MpUwn__YYuM-00440-00111929-00112116": "of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00441-00112117-00112457": "I just want one person whose field of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00442-00112458-00112751": "study is the thing we're talking about", "MpUwn__YYuM-00443-00112752-00113002": "that's what I want and I ask should I do", "MpUwn__YYuM-00444-00113003-00113236": "a poll do you remember that time where I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00445-00113238-00113428": "predicted that no one would have a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00446-00113429-00113651": "degree in this field in the relevant", "MpUwn__YYuM-00447-00113652-00113777": "field", "MpUwn__YYuM-00448-00113778-00113915": "because I don't even want I don't even", "MpUwn__YYuM-00449-00113916-00114071": "necessarily need a degree they can be I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00450-00114072-00114245": "think this is a troll it has to be they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00451-00114246-00114497": "can be they can be autodides purify", "MpUwn__YYuM-00452-00114498-00114628": "yourself why don't you purify yourself", "MpUwn__YYuM-00453-00114629-00114893": "in the late Waters of Lake Minnetonka", "MpUwn__YYuM-00454-00114894-00115139": "like I'm I'm okay if even one of them is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00455-00115140-00115415": "like fully auto Didact when it comes to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00456-00115416-00115649": "to history I just went there I just want", "MpUwn__YYuM-00457-00115650-00115823": "their profession to have something to do", "MpUwn__YYuM-00458-00115824-00116015": "with it then too like either either your", "MpUwn__YYuM-00459-00116016-00116165": "field of study or your profession", "MpUwn__YYuM-00460-00116166-00116308": "something", "MpUwn__YYuM-00461-00116309-00116566": "something that is not just I talk about", "MpUwn__YYuM-00462-00116567-00116675": "thinking", "MpUwn__YYuM-00463-00116676-00116902": "okay cool we get it you talk about", "MpUwn__YYuM-00464-00116903-00117257": "thinking", "MpUwn__YYuM-00465-00117258-00117515": "no they're not one I predict not one", "MpUwn__YYuM-00466-00117516-00117736": "person I predict not one field Josh how", "MpUwn__YYuM-00467-00117738-00118049": "many how many do you think not one", "MpUwn__YYuM-00468-00118050-00118228": "will have a degree in a relevant field", "MpUwn__YYuM-00469-00118229-00118433": "yeah either have a degree in a relative", "MpUwn__YYuM-00470-00118433-00118589": "field or have a profession in a relevant", "MpUwn__YYuM-00471-00118590-00118727": "field one of the two", "MpUwn__YYuM-00472-00118728-00118925": "that's fair yeah see this is the thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00473-00118926-00119165": "like I I'm not sure so I haven't watched", "MpUwn__YYuM-00474-00119166-00119260": "this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00475-00119261-00119327": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-00476-00119328-00119477": "you mean you don't pay for the daily", "MpUwn__YYuM-00477-00119478-00119510": "wire", "MpUwn__YYuM-00478-00119511-00119884": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00479-00119885-00120251": "I just I don't know what the point is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00480-00120252-00120725": "thus far uh so if it sounds to this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00481-00120726-00121054": "point that it's it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00482-00121055-00121163": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-00483-00121164-00121439": "it's like we're trying to take aspects", "MpUwn__YYuM-00484-00121440-00121769": "of let's say like the Epic of Gilgamesh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00485-00121770-00122158": "and to abstract them and then bring them", "MpUwn__YYuM-00486-00122159-00122345": "back down in something", "MpUwn__YYuM-00487-00122346-00122608": "from the modern period and see how it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00488-00122609-00122777": "can inform us", "MpUwn__YYuM-00489-00122778-00123034": "uh which is fine like I yeah like like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00490-00123035-00123245": "my dad used to do that with the Exodus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00491-00123246-00123647": "story right he'd yes he he'd be uh he", "MpUwn__YYuM-00492-00123648-00123802": "used to do construction he'd be out", "MpUwn__YYuM-00493-00123803-00123899": "there", "MpUwn__YYuM-00494-00123900-00124066": "and something would go wrong with the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00495-00124067-00124265": "job and it'd be off off schedule and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00496-00124266-00124523": "you'd hear him sing oh my Lord knows the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00497-00124524-00124684": "way through the Wilderness all I got to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00498-00124685-00124984": "do is follow and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00499-00124985-00125183": "um to him", "MpUwn__YYuM-00500-00125183-00125345": "you know the historicity of the account", "MpUwn__YYuM-00501-00125346-00125549": "or the archeology behind it right like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00502-00125550-00125627": "it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00503-00125628-00125825": "mismo at that [__] you know is what his", "MpUwn__YYuM-00504-00125826-00126173": "his uh tone would have said", "MpUwn__YYuM-00505-00126174-00126239": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-00506-00126240-00126658": "what he was utilizing that narrative for", "MpUwn__YYuM-00507-00126659-00126958": "was to say like God's with me he's gonna", "MpUwn__YYuM-00508-00126959-00127163": "get me through it right I just have to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00509-00127164-00127427": "trust him and so if that's all we're", "MpUwn__YYuM-00510-00127428-00127607": "doing here", "MpUwn__YYuM-00511-00127608-00127877": "no okay but I mean like I just I don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-00512-00127878-00128015": "know what the point is of this round", "MpUwn__YYuM-00513-00128016-00128128": "table", "MpUwn__YYuM-00514-00128129-00128434": "right", "MpUwn__YYuM-00515-00128435-00128657": "through the intro because all right so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00516-00128658-00128747": "I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00517-00128748-00129034": "sorry don't be sorry for having a like a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00518-00129035-00129364": "take that's actually relevant we're here", "MpUwn__YYuM-00519-00129365-00129599": "for the opinions of everyone here at", "MpUwn__YYuM-00520-00129600-00129797": "least I'm here for that because I I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00521-00129798-00129952": "not gonna have we're all here actually", "MpUwn__YYuM-00522-00129953-00130234": "for the opinions of Dr Josh alone yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00523-00130235-00130336": "pretty much", "MpUwn__YYuM-00524-00130338-00130589": "he's the only one qualified I mean I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00525-00130590-00131213": "mean none of us are qualified", "MpUwn__YYuM-00526-00131214-00131399": "so just use particularly what we get", "MpUwn__YYuM-00527-00131400-00131621": "talking about uh the decalog The Ten", "MpUwn__YYuM-00528-00131622-00131861": "Commandments the significance of this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00529-00131862-00132083": "extraordinary claim almost without", "MpUwn__YYuM-00530-00132084-00132359": "precedent that morality is wait wait", "MpUwn__YYuM-00531-00132360-00132751": "wait wait without precedent what almost", "MpUwn__YYuM-00532-00132752-00133127": "almost that almost I don't care if a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00533-00133128-00133433": "[__] about weasel language uh no almost", "MpUwn__YYuM-00534-00133434-00133613": "without president", "MpUwn__YYuM-00535-00133614-00133925": "I'm sorry the idea that morals are given", "MpUwn__YYuM-00536-00133926-00134140": "correct the the idea that morals are", "MpUwn__YYuM-00537-00134141-00134375": "given from a higher power is not almost", "MpUwn__YYuM-00538-00134376-00134614": "without precedent in Christianity nor", "MpUwn__YYuM-00539-00134615-00134801": "Judaism there are religions older than", "MpUwn__YYuM-00540-00134802-00135089": "both of them with that idea firmly in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00541-00135090-00135387": "mind but okay sure", "MpUwn__YYuM-00542-00135388-00135559": "[Music]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00543-00135560-00135814": "almost without precedent except for you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00544-00135815-00136061": "know a whole lot of other cultures who", "MpUwn__YYuM-00545-00136062-00136264": "believe that their laws were handed down", "MpUwn__YYuM-00546-00136265-00136613": "from a higher power I just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00547-00136614-00137002": "not simply invented and constructed and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00548-00137003-00137201": "that's one of I think many many vital", "MpUwn__YYuM-00549-00137202-00137399": "themes to our age that we'll be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00550-00137400-00137590": "exploring productively in the days ahead", "MpUwn__YYuM-00551-00137591-00137857": "I hope", "MpUwn__YYuM-00552-00137858-00138677": "all laws", "MpUwn__YYuM-00553-00138678-00138983": "I didn't tell Cyrus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00554-00138984-00139247": "he's got his own universities so I don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-00555-00139248-00139325": "know", "MpUwn__YYuM-00556-00139326-00139469": "I don't give a [__] about weasel", "MpUwn__YYuM-00557-00139470-00140123": "language", "MpUwn__YYuM-00558-00140124-00140309": "you have", "MpUwn__YYuM-00559-00140310-00140578": "you have made me listen to a man's voice", "MpUwn__YYuM-00560-00140579-00140981": "that I only ever want to hear in that I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00561-00140982-00141227": "forget the the the Channel's name but", "MpUwn__YYuM-00562-00141228-00141364": "that one channel that makes Eldritch", "MpUwn__YYuM-00563-00141365-00141569": "Abominations of every conservative think", "MpUwn__YYuM-00564-00141570-00141647": "tank", "MpUwn__YYuM-00565-00141648-00141916": "that that's the that's the only way I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00566-00141917-00142133": "want to hear this man's voice", "MpUwn__YYuM-00567-00142134-00142385": "I told you guys were here to suffer they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00568-00142386-00142564": "should be pop vishantes Jordan Peterson", "MpUwn__YYuM-00569-00142565-00142721": "Cherry now we're making service listen", "MpUwn__YYuM-00570-00142722-00142895": "to Prager again", "MpUwn__YYuM-00571-00142896-00143309": "okay well I rolled a 17 on my", "MpUwn__YYuM-00572-00143310-00143519": "Constitution so I think I'll I'll", "MpUwn__YYuM-00573-00143520-00143801": "survive Prager for now for now", "MpUwn__YYuM-00574-00143802-00143969": "oh we doing we're doing skill checks", "MpUwn__YYuM-00575-00143970-00144149": "hold on let me see if I live", "MpUwn__YYuM-00576-00144150-00144389": "yeah go ahead make a roll let me see if", "MpUwn__YYuM-00577-00144390-00144533": "I survive hold on I think I'm gonna be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00578-00144534-00144761": "taking a lot of psychic damage Dr Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00579-00144762-00144990": "you have a D20 handy", "MpUwn__YYuM-00580-00144991-00145193": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00581-00145194-00145566": "what are they saying now", "MpUwn__YYuM-00582-00145567-00145828": "okay so obviously his perception check", "MpUwn__YYuM-00583-00145829-00146128": "failed got it okay uh let's see here I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00584-00146129-00146471": "got a I got a 15 but I'm pretty sure I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00585-00146472-00146728": "have a skill modifier of neg2 uh because", "MpUwn__YYuM-00586-00146729-00147340": "I'm really bad at sad applications", "MpUwn__YYuM-00587-00147341-00147569": "I was kind of expecting you to try a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00588-00147570-00147857": "rollover", "MpUwn__YYuM-00589-00147858-00148085": "look I've played warlocks with negative", "MpUwn__YYuM-00590-00148086-00148277": "Charisma it's very fun", "MpUwn__YYuM-00591-00148278-00148891": "oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00592-00148892-00149057": "[Music]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00593-00149058-00149333": "I always max out like the the charm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00594-00149334-00149663": "skills so stop trying to stall out", "MpUwn__YYuM-00595-00149664-00149933": "pregger it's not gonna work", "MpUwn__YYuM-00596-00149934-00150131": "you're not gonna smack me with Dungeons", "MpUwn__YYuM-00597-00150132-00150304": "and Dragons and vampire masquerade", "MpUwn__YYuM-00598-00150305-00150478": "you're not gonna do it what trimester", "MpUwn__YYuM-00599-00150479-00150766": "are we trying to stall pregger into", "MpUwn__YYuM-00600-00150767-00151116": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00601-00151117-00151451": "I am living my dream in my life being", "MpUwn__YYuM-00602-00151452-00151571": "here", "MpUwn__YYuM-00603-00151572-00151864": "it was his dream to be here Victoria to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00604-00151865-00152014": "the world", "MpUwn__YYuM-00605-00152015-00152314": "I am a religious Jew", "MpUwn__YYuM-00606-00152315-00152501": "just to spread the Torah to the world so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00607-00152502-00153023": "he's being a part of this thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00608-00153024-00153119": "and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00609-00153120-00153245": "yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00610-00153246-00153509": "I'm blessed to know Biblical Hebrew I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00611-00153510-00153731": "started it as the age of five", "MpUwn__YYuM-00612-00153732-00153928": "I still have to translate to English", "MpUwn__YYuM-00613-00153929-00154240": "whenever I think of a verse no", "MpUwn__YYuM-00614-00154241-00154523": "the Torah uh is this is not known to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00615-00154524-00154835": "almost any non-jew the Torah is Primus", "MpUwn__YYuM-00616-00154836-00155063": "interparas in the Bible first among", "MpUwn__YYuM-00617-00155064-00155237": "equals", "MpUwn__YYuM-00618-00155238-00155452": "I was raised and I still believe that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00619-00155453-00155687": "the Tories", "MpUwn__YYuM-00620-00155688-00155807": "okay", "MpUwn__YYuM-00621-00155808-00155945": "I'm not going to go off on Long rabbit", "MpUwn__YYuM-00622-00155946-00156137": "Trails about how he's talking about", "MpUwn__YYuM-00623-00156138-00156304": "Judaism but I just want to say that he's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00624-00156305-00156443": "like oh yeah we're near Spirit tour of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00625-00156444-00156697": "the world Jews famously known for", "MpUwn__YYuM-00626-00156698-00156935": "evangelizing yeah well because you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00627-00156936-00157114": "remember literally one of the religions", "MpUwn__YYuM-00628-00157115-00157349": "that doesn't proselytize you have to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00629-00157350-00157625": "remember the Dennis Dennis Christians", "MpUwn__YYuM-00630-00157626-00157895": "for too long he doesn't just view his", "MpUwn__YYuM-00631-00157896-00158189": "his ideology as Judaism he views it as", "MpUwn__YYuM-00632-00158190-00158513": "Christian Judaism so he's naturally", "MpUwn__YYuM-00633-00158514-00158813": "going to adopt a lot of that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00634-00158814-00159347": "and I'm sorry anytime he hangs out", "MpUwn__YYuM-00635-00159348-00159569": "I was just gonna say anytime you have to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00636-00159570-00159839": "say something like I still have to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00637-00159840-00160001": "translate it into English when I read", "MpUwn__YYuM-00638-00160002-00160289": "the Hebrew it's like saying you know to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00639-00160290-00160469": "to somebody that works for you I'm your", "MpUwn__YYuM-00640-00160470-00160702": "supervisor right like if you have to say", "MpUwn__YYuM-00641-00160703-00160925": "it like you're not doing it very well so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00642-00160926-00161326": "I I he does not have to translate when", "MpUwn__YYuM-00643-00161327-00161699": "like that's a really good enough GPS", "MpUwn__YYuM-00644-00161700-00162414": "[Music]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00645-00162415-00162713": "oh yeah oh yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00646-00162714-00162976": "um we're not using Orthodox Jews who", "MpUwn__YYuM-00647-00162977-00163109": "grew up like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00648-00163110-00163439": "studying Torah to not talmud whatever", "MpUwn__YYuM-00649-00163440-00163619": "their secondary language might be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00650-00163620-00163864": "English but those schools primarily tend", "MpUwn__YYuM-00651-00163865-00164225": "to be like Yiddish speaking so all right", "MpUwn__YYuM-00652-00164226-00164519": "did he grow up speaking Yiddish first", "MpUwn__YYuM-00653-00164520-00164789": "because he doesn't sound like he has a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00654-00164790-00164909": "very strong", "MpUwn__YYuM-00655-00164910-00165287": "like accent that way I'm very confused", "MpUwn__YYuM-00656-00165288-00165575": "but yeah he's lying he does not have to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00657-00165576-00165790": "translate Hebrew when he reads it he's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00658-00165791-00165923": "just trying to flex on people because he", "MpUwn__YYuM-00659-00165924-00166066": "knows most Christians don't know a look", "MpUwn__YYuM-00660-00166067-00166283": "of Hebrew so hey", "MpUwn__YYuM-00661-00166284-00166504": "look at the special magic shoes he is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00662-00166505-00166997": "their supervisor respect his authority", "MpUwn__YYuM-00663-00166998-00167302": "how God delivers his business I have no", "MpUwn__YYuM-00664-00167303-00167521": "particular interest in the methodology", "MpUwn__YYuM-00665-00167522-00167909": "only in the ultimate authorship", "MpUwn__YYuM-00666-00167910-00168221": "and I've written three of the five", "MpUwn__YYuM-00667-00168222-00168413": "volumes of the Torah commentary called", "MpUwn__YYuM-00668-00168414-00168607": "the rational Bible", "MpUwn__YYuM-00669-00168608-00168863": "Exodus which interestingly was the first", "MpUwn__YYuM-00670-00168864-00169157": "one that I did given", "MpUwn__YYuM-00671-00169158-00169373": "that it has thy favorite document in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00672-00169374-00169559": "history The Ten Commandments and as I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00673-00169560-00169913": "say on my American talk show", "MpUwn__YYuM-00674-00169914-00170159": "if you want to defund the police there", "MpUwn__YYuM-00675-00170160-00170399": "is actually a way have everyone live by", "MpUwn__YYuM-00676-00170400-00170831": "the Ten Commandments What", "MpUwn__YYuM-00677-00170832-00171539": "what is that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00678-00171540-00171826": "oh no can we just keep going can we just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00679-00171827-00171947": "keep I don't want to go off on a rant", "MpUwn__YYuM-00680-00171948-00172223": "can we just skip a bit about the police", "MpUwn__YYuM-00681-00172224-00172589": "skip a bit about the police so that is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00682-00172590-00172889": "uh that is where I come from", "MpUwn__YYuM-00683-00172890-00173123": "in this discussion he looks awesome I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00684-00173124-00173302": "trust you will all defer appropriately", "MpUwn__YYuM-00685-00173303-00173669": "to a member of the chosen people see", "MpUwn__YYuM-00686-00173670-00173933": "this is exactly did I not just say", "MpUwn__YYuM-00687-00173934-00174166": "special Stephen Blackwood yep thanks", "MpUwn__YYuM-00688-00174167-00174364": "Jordan it's real pleasure to be here I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00689-00174365-00174575": "Stephen Blackwood I'm the president of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00690-00174576-00174761": "Ralston College in Savannah Georgia an", "MpUwn__YYuM-00691-00174762-00175090": "effort to revive and reinvent the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00692-00175091-00175333": "traditional University", "MpUwn__YYuM-00693-00175334-00175585": "I grew up", "MpUwn__YYuM-00694-00175586-00175823": "quite a lot yeah I was going to say that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00695-00175824-00176190": "sounds like a red flag to me", "MpUwn__YYuM-00696-00176191-00176452": "wait I'm gonna look this up what what", "MpUwn__YYuM-00697-00176453-00176633": "university did he say was was in Georgia", "MpUwn__YYuM-00698-00176634-00176740": "somewhere", "MpUwn__YYuM-00699-00176741-00177016": "Savannah something I think", "MpUwn__YYuM-00700-00177017-00177197": "Savannah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00701-00177198-00177449": "uh chesh could you replay the uh when", "MpUwn__YYuM-00702-00177450-00177935": "you said the name", "MpUwn__YYuM-00703-00177936-00178121": "say online hopefully I didn't put an", "MpUwn__YYuM-00704-00178122-00178319": "American talk show", "MpUwn__YYuM-00705-00178320-00178559": "if you want to defund the police there", "MpUwn__YYuM-00706-00178560-00179261": "was actually another way", "MpUwn__YYuM-00707-00179262-00179854": "so that is uh that is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00708-00179855-00180323": "I would be very interested to hear which", "MpUwn__YYuM-00709-00180324-00180635": "of the Ten Commandments he thinks", "MpUwn__YYuM-00710-00180636-00180881": "um they're unique to the ancient near", "MpUwn__YYuM-00711-00180882-00181049": "East that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00712-00181050-00181307": "you know would would be something that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00713-00181308-00181469": "he would call it out for that would that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00714-00181470-00181709": "would you know uh meet this goal that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00715-00181710-00181847": "he's set forth we wouldn't we wouldn't", "MpUwn__YYuM-00716-00181848-00182002": "need to pay for law enforcement anymore", "MpUwn__YYuM-00717-00182003-00182207": "because we didn't boil goats in their", "MpUwn__YYuM-00718-00182208-00182333": "mother's milk", "MpUwn__YYuM-00719-00182334-00182561": "I have to watch his podcast it's not in", "MpUwn__YYuM-00720-00182562-00182933": "the decalogue that's yeah I mean yeah is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00721-00182934-00183197": "it not worshiping another God is it you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00722-00183198-00183364": "know the Sabbath but is what is it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00723-00183365-00183569": "because we are yeah I was gonna say oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00724-00183570-00183826": "yeah it was against theft and murder so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00725-00183827-00184109": "what exactly are we missing here I don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-00726-00184110-00184223": "know he probably believes a whole lot", "MpUwn__YYuM-00727-00184224-00184402": "about the adultery thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00728-00184403-00184595": "like divorce and stuff and stuff yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00729-00184596-00184951": "but I mean like if that's divorce is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00730-00184952-00185309": "but I I feel like any of the law is safe", "MpUwn__YYuM-00731-00185310-00185704": "for you know the ones that are strictly", "MpUwn__YYuM-00732-00185705-00185933": "yeah wistic I I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00733-00185934-00186299": "be very if those aren't the ones", "MpUwn__YYuM-00734-00186300-00186551": "um why wouldn't he turn to the laws of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00735-00186552-00186778": "ornament or why wouldn't he Hammurabi or", "MpUwn__YYuM-00736-00186779-00186904": "so I don't understand", "MpUwn__YYuM-00737-00186905-00187169": "anyway see those aren't a part of his", "MpUwn__YYuM-00738-00187170-00187397": "Christian tradition he's got to pretend", "MpUwn__YYuM-00739-00187398-00187709": "that his are unique Etc Dr Josh has", "MpUwn__YYuM-00740-00187710-00187913": "already thought more about this than", "MpUwn__YYuM-00741-00187914-00188413": "Prager has", "MpUwn__YYuM-00742-00188414-00188633": "appropriately to a member of the chosen", "MpUwn__YYuM-00743-00188634-00188662": "people", "MpUwn__YYuM-00744-00188663-00189323": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00745-00189324-00189575": "next time it's a pleasure to be here I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00746-00189576-00189778": "Stephen Blackwood I'm the president of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00747-00189779-00189959": "Ralston College in Savannah Georgia an", "MpUwn__YYuM-00748-00189960-00190493": "effort to Ralston College", "MpUwn__YYuM-00749-00190494-00190793": "yes I'm also an older gentleman so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00750-00190794-00190943": "that's why I'm around this panel thank", "MpUwn__YYuM-00751-00190944-00191249": "you yeah I also like to talk to uh hey", "MpUwn__YYuM-00752-00191250-00191645": "Dick hey hey", "MpUwn__YYuM-00753-00191646-00191776": "hey that time I said it's probably", "MpUwn__YYuM-00754-00191777-00192019": "accredited unaccredited yeah yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00755-00192020-00192281": "Ralston College in Savannah Georgia the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00756-00192282-00192497": "very first sentence it's an unaccredited", "MpUwn__YYuM-00757-00192498-00192845": "institution oh my God", "MpUwn__YYuM-00758-00192846-00193169": "shocking I'm two for two baby so we've", "MpUwn__YYuM-00759-00193170-00193433": "got two unaccredited universities here", "MpUwn__YYuM-00760-00193434-00193702": "we've also only got one guy left and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00761-00193703-00193829": "still no relevant", "MpUwn__YYuM-00762-00193830-00194038": "[Music]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00763-00194039-00194638": "forehand 85 said no and 14 said yes", "MpUwn__YYuM-00764-00194639-00194909": "we got one more left oh this is gonna be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00765-00194910-00195233": "a problem oh check this out so Ralston", "MpUwn__YYuM-00766-00195234-00195359": "College", "MpUwn__YYuM-00767-00195360-00195502": "um it says it declared a commitment to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00768-00195503-00195661": "freedom of speech", "MpUwn__YYuM-00769-00195662-00195935": "here's another red flag guess who the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00770-00195936-00196169": "chancellor guess who the chancellor is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00771-00196170-00196463": "of Ralston College yeah Jordan Peterson", "MpUwn__YYuM-00772-00196464-00196728": "oh my f wait wait wait", "MpUwn__YYuM-00773-00196729-00196957": "in Savannah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00774-00196958-00197309": "I could drive there", "MpUwn__YYuM-00775-00197310-00197590": "I could drive you're in Georgia you know", "MpUwn__YYuM-00776-00197591-00197813": "yes I live in Marjory Taylor Green's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00777-00197814-00197981": "District", "MpUwn__YYuM-00778-00197982-00198251": "did I go there with like uh I'm sorry a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00779-00198252-00198419": "microphone and shove it in somebody's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00780-00198420-00198557": "face and be like what made you think", "MpUwn__YYuM-00781-00198558-00198763": "hiring", "MpUwn__YYuM-00782-00198764-00199169": "I'm just say Josh like money you say you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00783-00199170-00199390": "went you know go there you should go", "MpUwn__YYuM-00784-00199391-00199535": "there", "MpUwn__YYuM-00785-00199536-00199697": "would you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00786-00199698-00199907": "with Dr Peter", "MpUwn__YYuM-00787-00199908-00200075": "Peterson", "MpUwn__YYuM-00788-00200076-00200297": "people dislike it when I do that because", "MpUwn__YYuM-00789-00200298-00200507": "I have small hands", "MpUwn__YYuM-00790-00200508-00200776": "all right anyway", "MpUwn__YYuM-00791-00200777-00201040": "revive and reinvent the traditional", "MpUwn__YYuM-00792-00201041-00201257": "University", "MpUwn__YYuM-00793-00201258-00201604": "I grew up reading the Bible quite a lot", "MpUwn__YYuM-00794-00201605-00201893": "the wow I'd say the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00795-00201894-00202204": "Bible gave me the primary images through", "MpUwn__YYuM-00796-00202205-00202390": "which I came to understand", "MpUwn__YYuM-00797-00202391-00202702": "myself and the world then when I went to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00798-00202703-00202895": "University in the West", "MpUwn__YYuM-00799-00202896-00203081": "sort of stumbled into the discovery of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00800-00203082-00203266": "philosophy and literature especially of", "MpUwn__YYuM-00801-00203267-00203447": "the the Greek and Roman you might say", "MpUwn__YYuM-00802-00203448-00203621": "the backdrop to", "MpUwn__YYuM-00803-00203622-00203890": "to Western culture in the in the ancient", "MpUwn__YYuM-00804-00203891-00204100": "sense and since then there's been quite", "MpUwn__YYuM-00805-00204101-00204316": "a lot of time thinking about the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00806-00204317-00204497": "relation between that tradition and the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00807-00204498-00204635": "biblical tradition and the way in which", "MpUwn__YYuM-00808-00204636-00205007": "those uh are synthesized and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00809-00205008-00205325": "I saw a couple of looks so I thought I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00810-00205326-00205505": "would pause", "MpUwn__YYuM-00811-00205506-00205738": "I think Dr Josh and I are on the same", "MpUwn__YYuM-00812-00205739-00206177": "wavelength go ahead Dr Josh no no please", "MpUwn__YYuM-00813-00206178-00206310": "no no no no no", "MpUwn__YYuM-00814-00206311-00206831": "sorry did he I I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00815-00206832-00206938": "yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00816-00206939-00207131": "it sounded like what he said in my", "MpUwn__YYuM-00817-00207132-00207503": "memory is not is not great so if I get", "MpUwn__YYuM-00818-00207504-00207671": "it wrong please correct me but it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00819-00207671-00207821": "sounded like he said", "MpUwn__YYuM-00820-00207821-00207971": "that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00821-00207971-00208169": "the Greek world was", "MpUwn__YYuM-00822-00208169-00208342": "the backdrop", "MpUwn__YYuM-00823-00208344-00208564": "the the yep", "MpUwn__YYuM-00824-00208565-00208942": "ancient backdrop of yeah Greek and Roman", "MpUwn__YYuM-00825-00208944-00209242": "are the ancient backdrop of current and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00826-00209244-00209490": "recent like basically American history", "MpUwn__YYuM-00827-00209491-00209813": "in society yeah okay all right sorry", "MpUwn__YYuM-00828-00209814-00210041": "that's not what I heard him say", "MpUwn__YYuM-00829-00210042-00210221": "um it sounded like what he was saying is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00830-00210221-00210619": "that the Exodus was", "MpUwn__YYuM-00831-00210619-00210827": "was like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00832-00210828-00210958": "yeah there's a little bit of a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00833-00210959-00211115": "contextual question mark around what", "MpUwn__YYuM-00834-00211116-00211348": "this guy's saying for sure gotcha", "MpUwn__YYuM-00835-00211350-00211523": "probably in his mind as well", "MpUwn__YYuM-00836-00211525-00211884": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00837-00211885-00212251": "that synthesis", "MpUwn__YYuM-00838-00212252-00212567": "Roman was the Pinnacle of society oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00839-00212567-00212719": "yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-00840-00212719-00213029": "in the Western World", "MpUwn__YYuM-00841-00213030-00213089": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-00842-00213090-00213256": "I suppose I'm particularly excited to be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00843-00213257-00213581": "here because I as others have said do", "MpUwn__YYuM-00844-00213582-00213796": "profoundly think that we're living in a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00845-00213798-00213946": "time in which we've lost the images", "MpUwn__YYuM-00846-00213948-00214108": "through which we can make sure that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00847-00214109-00214355": "looks so boring of ourselves and of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00848-00214356-00214560": "world in a way that's adequate too", "MpUwn__YYuM-00849-00214561-00214765": "please", "MpUwn__YYuM-00850-00214766-00215141": "as a job literally", "MpUwn__YYuM-00851-00215142-00215417": "this is an interview but also", "MpUwn__YYuM-00852-00215417-00215644": "the only people people say that like oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00853-00215646-00215806": "Gregor Robin was the Pinnacle of society", "MpUwn__YYuM-00854-00215807-00216010": "and we've Fallen away from it those", "MpUwn__YYuM-00855-00216011-00216382": "people are usually tread cats and they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00856-00216383-00216646": "are always far right bigots they're the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00857-00216648-00216892": "scariest [__] like I'm waiting for one", "MpUwn__YYuM-00858-00216894-00217091": "of them to drop the word degenerate", "MpUwn__YYuM-00859-00217092-00217360": "that's how like I already had these guys", "MpUwn__YYuM-00860-00217361-00217456": "number", "MpUwn__YYuM-00861-00217457-00217637": "I'm just gonna I'm just waiting for one", "MpUwn__YYuM-00862-00217638-00217805": "of them to say the word degenerate and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00863-00217806-00217996": "then it's like in the bag", "MpUwn__YYuM-00864-00217998-00218219": "hmm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00865-00218219-00218579": "so uh hopefully we'll", "MpUwn__YYuM-00866-00218580-00218777": "hopefully these images will come to be", "MpUwn__YYuM-00867-00218778-00219091": "alive for us and for those who", "MpUwn__YYuM-00868-00219092-00219455": "decide to listen to this word lives", "MpUwn__YYuM-00869-00219456-00219719": "Jonathan Peugeot another Canadian that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00870-00219719-00219901": "right", "MpUwn__YYuM-00871-00219902-00220379": "I am an artist and I'm someone who for a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00872-00220380-00220577": "very long time has been reading the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00873-00220578-00220846": "Bible and I've been thinking about he's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00874-00220848-00221237": "not one he's not", "MpUwn__YYuM-00875-00221238-00221410": "foreign", "MpUwn__YYuM-00876-00221411-00221675": "when I'm right I'm right so he's just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00877-00221676-00221932": "he's just sitting there his contribution", "MpUwn__YYuM-00878-00221933-00222106": "is I'm just a little guy", "MpUwn__YYuM-00879-00222107-00222346": "I'm just a little guy I'm just a dude", "MpUwn__YYuM-00880-00222348-00222617": "I'm just I just do art pie I do an art", "MpUwn__YYuM-00881-00222617-00222760": "I'm a little I'm a little dude on the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00882-00222761-00222971": "internet I do art I appreciate art the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00883-00222971-00223163": "art I appreciate specifically is art", "MpUwn__YYuM-00884-00223164-00223325": "that is from the Greco-Roman area and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00885-00223326-00223571": "Modern Art is bad because reasons that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00886-00223571-00223781": "I'm imagining that because because", "MpUwn__YYuM-00887-00223782-00224021": "Prager used done a [__] video like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00888-00224021-00224392": "that no way this guy this Canadian I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00889-00224394-00224621": "built here totally has a Tumblr account", "MpUwn__YYuM-00890-00224621-00224848": "with all the art on because it's just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00891-00224850-00225010": "animals", "MpUwn__YYuM-00892-00225011-00225323": "um his alt account is classic art", "MpUwn__YYuM-00893-00225323-00225625": "enjoyer", "MpUwn__YYuM-00894-00225626-00226037": "it's got the Chad meme but with like a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00895-00226038-00226169": "filter that makes it look like he's a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00896-00226169-00226415": "statue", "MpUwn__YYuM-00897-00226416-00226781": "yeah Trad art and joyer", "MpUwn__YYuM-00898-00226782-00226991": "all right let's hear what the artist is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00899-00226992-00227179": "going to say", "MpUwn__YYuM-00900-00227180-00227398": "don't put yourself down like he cares", "MpUwn__YYuM-00901-00227400-00227692": "about what the artist has to say what", "MpUwn__YYuM-00902-00227694-00227975": "one single qualified person on that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00903-00227976-00228263": "panel nope I'm not even close baby", "MpUwn__YYuM-00904-00228264-00228508": "but it's more like an artist I would say", "MpUwn__YYuM-00905-00228509-00228839": "in terms of structure in terms of rhyme", "MpUwn__YYuM-00906-00228840-00229115": "and Rhythm and so I'm interested in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00907-00229116-00229344": "book of Exodus more as a mystical text", "MpUwn__YYuM-00908-00229346-00229637": "and uh based in the Christian it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00909-00229638-00229798": "actually there's a small little book", "MpUwn__YYuM-00910-00229800-00229942": "called The Life of Moses by Saint", "MpUwn__YYuM-00911-00229944-00230141": "Gregory of Nissa which is one of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00912-00230142-00230405": "foundations of Christian mysticism and", "MpUwn__YYuM-00913-00230406-00230615": "so I will be approaching the book mostly", "MpUwn__YYuM-00914-00230616-00230963": "can I just through how can I ask if we", "MpUwn__YYuM-00915-00230964-00231160": "if we're to take bets", "MpUwn__YYuM-00916-00231161-00231431": "um you notice that they all either have", "MpUwn__YYuM-00917-00231432-00231665": "their Bible open to Exodus or there's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00918-00231666-00231887": "something marking it how much would you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00919-00231888-00232001": "want to bet that it's because they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00920-00232002-00232265": "couldn't find it again I think their", "MpUwn__YYuM-00921-00232266-00232567": "Bible closed", "MpUwn__YYuM-00922-00232567-00232987": "uh yeah uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-00923-00232988-00233327": "you see when I when I was a kid when I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00924-00233328-00233723": "was a kid and I was in Pennsylvania", "MpUwn__YYuM-00925-00233723-00233956": "when I was in PCA we actually had to do", "MpUwn__YYuM-00926-00233957-00234269": "a [__] song to remember the uh the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00927-00234269-00234508": "books of the Bible in order so if I had", "MpUwn__YYuM-00928-00234509-00234755": "to learn it they could learn it too", "MpUwn__YYuM-00929-00234756-00235042": "I mean I just remember it and this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00930-00235044-00235241": "always will stand out is when people", "MpUwn__YYuM-00931-00235242-00235505": "really know their Bible and you say like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00932-00235506-00235756": "you'll hear them say like oh where where", "MpUwn__YYuM-00933-00235757-00235906": "are you reading from they'll say it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00934-00235907-00236292": "page 612.", "MpUwn__YYuM-00935-00236294-00236734": "damn I I feel like anybody who is doing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00936-00236735-00237142": "videos like like Prager you and like the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00937-00237144-00237358": "daily wire and like anybody who does", "MpUwn__YYuM-00938-00237359-00237484": "like biblical readings like the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00939-00237485-00237682": "transformed wife and like your Paula", "MpUwn__YYuM-00940-00237683-00237910": "Morgans and like any Pastor should", "MpUwn__YYuM-00941-00237911-00238132": "aspire to know the Bible well enough", "MpUwn__YYuM-00942-00238133-00238373": "when asked for a reference they give a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00943-00238373-00238723": "[__] page number damn", "MpUwn__YYuM-00944-00238723-00238931": "respect at that point they know it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00945-00238932-00239146": "like their Bible because there's only", "MpUwn__YYuM-00946-00239148-00239375": "one version and one printing of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00947-00239376-00239681": "Bible ever well I mean it's there that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00948-00239682-00239891": "whatever one they're reading that's it", "MpUwn__YYuM-00949-00239892-00240071": "doesn't matter the point is is like they", "MpUwn__YYuM-00950-00240071-00240292": "just know it that well that it's just", "MpUwn__YYuM-00951-00240294-00240437": "like excuse me Pastor where are you", "MpUwn__YYuM-00952-00240438-00240808": "reading from page 625 three paragraphs", "MpUwn__YYuM-00953-00240809-00241060": "down it's just this this this survives", "MpUwn__YYuM-00954-00241061-00241253": "me a minute but this reminds me of that", "MpUwn__YYuM-00955-00241254-00241469": "psych quote where he says that you have", "MpUwn__YYuM-00956-00241469-00241715": "never read the Bible have you Genesis", "MpUwn__YYuM-00957-00241716-00242027": "Exorcist Leviathan you do the right", "MpUwn__YYuM-00958-00242028-00242377": "thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00959-00242378-00242758": "yes oh this this stream is Ari we are", "MpUwn__YYuM-00960-00242759-00242963": "just getting through the intros and I", "MpUwn__YYuM-00961-00242964-00243106": "live this is already better than I could", "MpUwn__YYuM-00962-00243107-00243310": "have imagined I heard", "MpUwn__YYuM-00963-00243311-00243551": "my my brain filled in the blanks on the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00964-00243552-00243706": "right books and I feel like that's a", "MpUwn__YYuM-00965-00243707-00243882": "trauma response judge", "MpUwn__YYuM-00966-00243883-00244708": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-00967-00244709-00244991": "how long we've been live an hour 40", "MpUwn__YYuM-00968-00244992-00245201": "minutes for sure is to get treated 40", "MpUwn__YYuM-00969-00245202-00245398": "minutes look look", "MpUwn__YYuM-00970-00245400-00245675": "he he started he started saying do what", "MpUwn__YYuM-00971-00245676-00245825": "my brain was like you know that you know", "MpUwn__YYuM-00972-00245826-00246046": "that like it's the square hole yes the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00973-00246048-00246341": "square hole my brain was just like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00974-00246342-00246821": "Leviticus no no okay okay Deuteronomy no", "MpUwn__YYuM-00975-00246821-00247198": "no no no no please", "MpUwn__YYuM-00976-00247200-00247517": "oh it describes a structure narrative", "MpUwn__YYuM-00977-00247517-00247684": "structure which is also a geographic", "MpUwn__YYuM-00978-00247685-00247894": "structure the mountain the temple uh the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00979-00247896-00248267": "Tabernacle and how this uh fits with", "MpUwn__YYuM-00980-00248267-00248441": "even the our own perception of reality", "MpUwn__YYuM-00981-00248442-00248706": "and how reality comes together how how", "MpUwn__YYuM-00982-00248707-00249082": "chaos humans so that is really the way", "MpUwn__YYuM-00983-00249083-00249287": "that I'll be you're looking at it so I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-00984-00249288-00249460": "really looking forward to this very", "MpUwn__YYuM-00985-00249461-00249839": "diverse discussion excellent so what is", "MpUwn__YYuM-00986-00249840-00250055": "diverse about this there's nothing", "MpUwn__YYuM-00987-00250056-00250271": "diverse about a group of a bunch of old", "MpUwn__YYuM-00988-00250271-00250619": "white men from the exact same uh like", "MpUwn__YYuM-00989-00250619-00250925": "type of religious background who all", "MpUwn__YYuM-00990-00250926-00251189": "equally have no experience in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-00991-00251190-00251369": "relevant field", "MpUwn__YYuM-00992-00251369-00251698": "there's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00993-00251700-00252034": "there's no diversity there it's so", "MpUwn__YYuM-00994-00252035-00252298": "diverse guys I know Dennis breaker's", "MpUwn__YYuM-00995-00252300-00252575": "gonna be like well you see um I identify", "MpUwn__YYuM-00996-00252576-00252773": "as a woman for the purposes of this", "MpUwn__YYuM-00997-00252773-00252989": "conversation this is a very diverse", "MpUwn__YYuM-00998-00252990-00253146": "piece", "MpUwn__YYuM-00999-00253148-00253487": "though he would he would", "MpUwn__YYuM-01000-00253488-00253715": "he would one of the things that's really", "MpUwn__YYuM-01001-00253716-00253913": "fascinated me about Exodus apart from", "MpUwn__YYuM-01002-00253914-00254158": "the the fundamental structure of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01003-00254159-00254405": "narrative which is escape from tyranny", "MpUwn__YYuM-01004-00254406-00254639": "sojourn through the desert and then", "MpUwn__YYuM-01005-00254640-00254825": "re-emergence hypothetically into the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01006-00254826-00254951": "promised land it's a very classic", "MpUwn__YYuM-01007-00254952-00255631": "hypothetically", "MpUwn__YYuM-01008-00255632-00255892": "they literally say that oh you need to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01009-00255894-00256060": "go to the place flowing with milk and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01010-00256061-00256348": "honey there is no hypothetical in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01011-00256350-00256546": "story they are told you're physically", "MpUwn__YYuM-01012-00256548-00256810": "walking to the promised land and when", "MpUwn__YYuM-01013-00256811-00257027": "they screw up", "MpUwn__YYuM-01014-00257028-00257410": "they are told okay we're adding years to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01015-00257411-00257608": "your walking through literally there's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01016-00257609-00257794": "no hypothetical", "MpUwn__YYuM-01017-00257796-00257982": "also", "MpUwn__YYuM-01018-00257983-00258221": "literally no one makes it to the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01019-00258221-00258473": "promised land in the entire Torah that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01020-00258473-00258623": "doesn't start happening until the Book", "MpUwn__YYuM-01021-00258623-00258796": "of Joshua", "MpUwn__YYuM-01022-00258798-00259073": "The Exodus in Exodus only takes up like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01023-00259073-00259198": "the first", "MpUwn__YYuM-01024-00259200-00259510": "18-ish to 19ish Chapters", "MpUwn__YYuM-01025-00259511-00259984": "don't spoil that that next happens", "MpUwn__YYuM-01026-00259985-00260242": "sorry spoiler alert on a 3 000 year old", "MpUwn__YYuM-01027-00260244-00260423": "book it writes it like it's a Harry", "MpUwn__YYuM-01028-00260423-00260651": "Potter novel you have to find the next", "MpUwn__YYuM-01029-00260652-00260879": "book I mean I just doubt that anybody at", "MpUwn__YYuM-01030-00260880-00261005": "the table is actually read the story", "MpUwn__YYuM-01031-00261006-00261160": "through so", "MpUwn__YYuM-01032-00261161-00261353": "look well maybe maybe that's what this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01033-00261354-00261515": "tip maybe that's what the table is about", "MpUwn__YYuM-01034-00261516-00261887": "they're gonna retrigger it and spoiler", "MpUwn__YYuM-01035-00261888-00261979": "alert", "MpUwn__YYuM-01036-00261980-00262187": "through it a bunch of time but I don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01037-00262188-00262393": "think the rest of them happened", "MpUwn__YYuM-01038-00262394-00262739": "Judas betrays Jesus spoiler alert", "MpUwn__YYuM-01039-00262740-00262889": "oh [__]", "MpUwn__YYuM-01040-00262890-00263375": "it says double door dies", "MpUwn__YYuM-01041-00263376-00263501": "that's what I thought I was watching the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01042-00263502-00263819": "Disney version of Davy Crockett and uh I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01043-00263820-00264034": "got like got down near the end and he's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01044-00264035-00264251": "like he's run out of ammo in the Alamo", "MpUwn__YYuM-01045-00264252-00264425": "and he's he's got the barrel of his", "MpUwn__YYuM-01046-00264426-00264569": "rifle and he's swinging it at people", "MpUwn__YYuM-01047-00264570-00264755": "coming up the steps and I look down at", "MpUwn__YYuM-01048-00264756-00264906": "the the VCR", "MpUwn__YYuM-01049-00264907-00265163": "uh and there's only three minutes left", "MpUwn__YYuM-01050-00265164-00265415": "and I call my my ex-wife my now ex-wife", "MpUwn__YYuM-01051-00265416-00265595": "and said hey what's the deal is there", "MpUwn__YYuM-01052-00265596-00265769": "like a part two to this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01053-00265770-00265967": "she said why as well I mean it doesn't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01054-00265968-00266269": "look how's he gonna get out of this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01055-00266270-00266599": "he doesn't he doesn't Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01056-00266600-00267082": "oh sounds like someone forgot the Alamo", "MpUwn__YYuM-01057-00267083-00267256": "but that's what I said but wait a minute", "MpUwn__YYuM-01058-00267257-00267419": "I thought they always say like Remember", "MpUwn__YYuM-01059-00267420-00267641": "the Alamo like yeah because they lost", "MpUwn__YYuM-01060-00267642-00267808": "dumbass you know of course that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01061-00267809-00268169": "because they lost yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01062-00268170-00268393": "it's like my dearest husband", "MpUwn__YYuM-01063-00268394-00268756": "oh they did they did lose badly actually", "MpUwn__YYuM-01064-00268757-00268925": "I thought you were gonna say she called", "MpUwn__YYuM-01065-00268926-00269117": "you a dumbass and then that's why you're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01066-00269118-00269284": "not everything and then the divorce", "MpUwn__YYuM-01067-00269285-00269453": "followed after that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01068-00269454-00269815": "you dumbass I'm filing the papers", "MpUwn__YYuM-01069-00269816-00270082": "and then she's gonna be like Stephen", "MpUwn__YYuM-01070-00270083-00270310": "Crowder's wife it turns out Dr Josh had", "MpUwn__YYuM-01071-00270311-00270689": "a divorce lawyer already hired oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01072-00270690-00270949": "topical", "MpUwn__YYuM-01073-00270950-00271313": "if I speak on that why isn't Stephen", "MpUwn__YYuM-01074-00271314-00271582": "Crowder on this panel where's the funny", "MpUwn__YYuM-01075-00271583-00271727": "man", "MpUwn__YYuM-01076-00271728-00271973": "okay never mind if have you guys ever", "MpUwn__YYuM-01077-00271974-00272213": "watched like Stephen Crowder and Ben", "MpUwn__YYuM-01078-00272214-00272495": "Shapiro side by side because those guys", "MpUwn__YYuM-01079-00272496-00272815": "can we just move on", "MpUwn__YYuM-01080-00272816-00273077": "is the manner in which God is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01081-00273078-00273419": "represented as the primary spirit in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01082-00273420-00273629": "text and so I've been toying with this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01083-00273630-00273808": "idea that part of what the Bible is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01084-00273809-00274132": "doing is describing a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01085-00274133-00274571": "a priority a manner in which perceptions", "MpUwn__YYuM-01086-00274572-00274967": "and actions might be prioritized and a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01087-00274968-00275230": "structural priority is a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01088-00275231-00275723": "um talk about a belt Jordan Peterson but", "MpUwn__YYuM-01089-00275724-00275999": "listening to him talk he loves to hear", "MpUwn__YYuM-01090-00276000-00276245": "himself talk but he's not saying", "MpUwn__YYuM-01091-00276246-00276641": "anything yeah huh yeah he's not saying", "MpUwn__YYuM-01092-00276642-00276863": "anything", "MpUwn__YYuM-01093-00276864-00277175": "correct P.S what the f what was he", "MpUwn__YYuM-01094-00277176-00277367": "talking about God presents as the only", "MpUwn__YYuM-01095-00277368-00277463": "spirit", "MpUwn__YYuM-01096-00277464-00277793": "you mean God who sent a a separate", "MpUwn__YYuM-01097-00277794-00277979": "entity that we call the angel of death", "MpUwn__YYuM-01098-00277980-00278182": "and God's presented as the only Spirit", "MpUwn__YYuM-01099-00278183-00278447": "okay at least the primaries whiskey", "MpUwn__YYuM-01100-00278448-00278729": "reading exactly I mean quite frankly I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01101-00278730-00278908": "don't but I I like to think that Jordan", "MpUwn__YYuM-01102-00278909-00279101": "Peterson gets paid by the word", "MpUwn__YYuM-01103-00279102-00279317": "so that's why he talks like that he acts", "MpUwn__YYuM-01104-00279318-00279563": "like it yeah right yeah he's not saying", "MpUwn__YYuM-01105-00279564-00279713": "anything he's just saying a bunch of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01106-00279714-00279899": "words", "MpUwn__YYuM-01107-00279900-00280108": "oh my God it's true people were not", "MpUwn__YYuM-01108-00280109-00280432": "exaggerating I'm so glad that I've done", "MpUwn__YYuM-01109-00280433-00280613": "I got to Spring this on you this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01110-00280614-00280793": "amazing it's been a while since I've", "MpUwn__YYuM-01111-00280794-00281032": "seen somebody see him for the first time", "MpUwn__YYuM-01112-00281033-00281329": "I lit I thought people were exaggerating", "MpUwn__YYuM-01113-00281330-00281663": "nope oh yeah no no he talks all the time", "MpUwn__YYuM-01114-00281664-00281806": "he doesn't really say a lot and he just", "MpUwn__YYuM-01115-00281807-00281993": "uses a lot of words because that makes", "MpUwn__YYuM-01116-00281994-00282106": "people think he's smart and I'll say", "MpUwn__YYuM-01117-00282107-00282245": "okay yeah you guys probably just you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01118-00282246-00282467": "know exaggerating hyperbole for the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01119-00282468-00282719": "funny and no", "MpUwn__YYuM-01120-00282720-00282893": "oh my goodness", "MpUwn__YYuM-01121-00282894-00283043": "it's very metal structure and something", "MpUwn__YYuM-01122-00283044-00283301": "has to be at the top and I learned from", "MpUwn__YYuM-01123-00283302-00283582": "Carl Jung that whatever is at the top of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01124-00283583-00283810": "your hierarchy of assumptions functions", "MpUwn__YYuM-01125-00283811-00284165": "as God for you whether or not you're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01126-00284166-00284356": "religious and maybe you have multiple", "MpUwn__YYuM-01127-00284357-00284549": "things at the top which just means that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01128-00284550-00285179": "you're conventionally and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01129-00285180-00285365": "it's a hierarchy guys everything's a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01130-00285366-00285605": "hierarchy because Jordan Peterson likes", "MpUwn__YYuM-01131-00285606-00285832": "pyramids", "MpUwn__YYuM-01132-00285833-00286030": "he said there's a pyramidal structure", "MpUwn__YYuM-01133-00286031-00286223": "worth one thing at the topic yes that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01134-00286224-00286480": "how pyramids work yeah and then people", "MpUwn__YYuM-01135-00286481-00286697": "who have two things at the top they're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01136-00286698-00286930": "just confused he woke up one morning", "MpUwn__YYuM-01137-00286931-00287243": "when he was like 12 and he had", "MpUwn__YYuM-01138-00287244-00287441": "experienced his first wet dream and had", "MpUwn__YYuM-01139-00287442-00287627": "morning wood saw a pyramid there and was", "MpUwn__YYuM-01140-00287628-00287801": "like this is life", "MpUwn__YYuM-01141-00287802-00287975": "so you just explained the plot of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01142-00287976-00288306": "Silence", "MpUwn__YYuM-01143-00288307-00288671": "no he then goes on to say that because", "MpUwn__YYuM-01144-00288672-00288827": "people have different priorities in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01145-00288828-00289013": "their life your highest one or ones if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01146-00289014-00289234": "you're confused are God for you even if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01147-00289235-00289505": "you're not a theist what yeah it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01148-00289506-00289751": "whatever you prioritize except he's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01149-00289752-00289991": "specifying like whatever you prioritize", "MpUwn__YYuM-01150-00289992-00290243": "enough and like you can't like Falafel", "MpUwn__YYuM-01151-00290244-00290405": "can't be at the top", "MpUwn__YYuM-01152-00290406-00290699": "look all I'm saying is there can be two", "MpUwn__YYuM-01153-00290700-00290860": "things at the top it's just called being", "MpUwn__YYuM-01154-00290861-00291005": "polyamorous", "MpUwn__YYuM-01155-00291006-00291155": "you just have two things that are", "MpUwn__YYuM-01156-00291156-00291287": "equally important to the top of your", "MpUwn__YYuM-01157-00291288-00291532": "prior list and they're people", "MpUwn__YYuM-01158-00291533-00291730": "no it's almost like Jordan Peterson's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01159-00291731-00291941": "like hierarchy philosophy makes no sense", "MpUwn__YYuM-01160-00291942-00292108": "at all", "MpUwn__YYuM-01161-00292109-00292234": "I mean", "MpUwn__YYuM-01162-00292235-00292691": "polycule rates one anarchism later", "MpUwn__YYuM-01163-00292692-00292925": "than if young is correct and I believe", "MpUwn__YYuM-01164-00292926-00293129": "he is then the question of what should", "MpUwn__YYuM-01165-00293130-00293410": "be at the top really exists as the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01166-00293411-00293567": "Paramount question and part of the way", "MpUwn__YYuM-01167-00293568-00293753": "the biblical narrative represents that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01168-00293754-00294065": "or addresses that is by describing God", "MpUwn__YYuM-01169-00294066-00294293": "in some sense as a literary character as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01170-00294294-00294532": "Northrop fry a Canadian critic pointed", "MpUwn__YYuM-01171-00294533-00294725": "out and one of the things that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01172-00294726-00295001": "remarkable about the Exodus text is that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01173-00295002-00295223": "the highest", "MpUwn__YYuM-01174-00295224-00295397": "ethical", "MpUwn__YYuM-01175-00295398-00295667": "Spirit to which we're beholden is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01176-00295668-00295979": "presented precisely as that spirit that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01177-00295980-00296230": "allies itself with the cause of Freedom", "MpUwn__YYuM-01178-00296231-00296621": "against tyranny and that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01179-00296622-00296899": "so he's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01180-00296900-00297184": "I will parse this and make this tldr as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01181-00297185-00297460": "possible Jordan Peterson is I know what", "MpUwn__YYuM-01182-00297461-00297658": "he said I miss a lot of words it's okay", "MpUwn__YYuM-01183-00297659-00297817": "it's not just for you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01184-00297818-00298156": "it's Jordan Peterson just said that the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01185-00298157-00298325": "hierarchy of the way the Bible is set up", "MpUwn__YYuM-01186-00298326-00298606": "showing God as the primary spirit is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01187-00298607-00298805": "representative in the text of Exodus", "MpUwn__YYuM-01188-00298806-00299129": "specifically as a force against tyranny", "MpUwn__YYuM-01189-00299130-00299671": "and he said that unironically", "MpUwn__YYuM-01190-00299672-00299884": "considering some of the laws that he's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01191-00299885-00300125": "literally about to give them saying that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01192-00300126-00300347": "he's like super into Liberation and not", "MpUwn__YYuM-01193-00300348-00300671": "tyranny's a little sauce or that angel", "MpUwn__YYuM-01194-00300672-00300784": "of death we were all talking about", "MpUwn__YYuM-01195-00300785-00300905": "earlier", "MpUwn__YYuM-01196-00300906-00301027": "everybody", "MpUwn__YYuM-01197-00301028-00301355": "my name is God I don't like tuberty", "MpUwn__YYuM-01198-00301356-00301699": "follow all of my rules or bird", "MpUwn__YYuM-01199-00301700-00302021": "okay no it's not that and if you start", "MpUwn__YYuM-01200-00302022-00302356": "agreeing with me I'm going to force you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01201-00302357-00302525": "to follow the rules", "MpUwn__YYuM-01202-00302526-00302734": "I will point this out just because I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-01203-00302735-00302921": "pedantic and being the only Jew I have", "MpUwn__YYuM-01204-00302922-00303299": "to be pedantic you're welcome is this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01205-00303300-00303443": "whole obey me or I'll burn you for", "MpUwn__YYuM-01206-00303444-00303580": "everything that's a Christian concept", "MpUwn__YYuM-01207-00303581-00303827": "like oh I know that's not something that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01208-00303828-00304132": "we care yeah but I know you're like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01209-00304133-00304277": "foreign Christian but it's just like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01210-00304278-00304469": "this God's more like hey I'm really", "MpUwn__YYuM-01211-00304470-00304763": "super not into tyranny so when you're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01212-00304764-00304967": "produced procuring yourself slaves from", "MpUwn__YYuM-01213-00304968-00305099": "other nations", "MpUwn__YYuM-01214-00305100-00305249": "what", "MpUwn__YYuM-01215-00305250-00305789": "it's like freedom for me but not for me", "MpUwn__YYuM-01216-00305790-00306089": "got any thoughts on that Dr Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01217-00306090-00306334": "yeah I mean", "MpUwn__YYuM-01218-00306335-00306665": "Leviticus 26 and Deuteronomy 28 like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01219-00306666-00306845": "spring to my mind", "MpUwn__YYuM-01220-00306846-00307115": "you know once once Israel enters into", "MpUwn__YYuM-01221-00307116-00307258": "this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01222-00307259-00307606": "in a vassal treaty with Yahweh then", "MpUwn__YYuM-01223-00307607-00308003": "the blessings and and curses stand uh on", "MpUwn__YYuM-01224-00308004-00308158": "them so I mean it's like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01225-00308159-00308632": "uh do what I tell you uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01226-00308633-00308897": "and then I will send you I'll send you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01227-00308898-00309125": "rain and I'll give you lots of produce", "MpUwn__YYuM-01228-00309126-00309323": "but you know [__] with me", "MpUwn__YYuM-01229-00309324-00309658": "and uh you know you're one man will", "MpUwn__YYuM-01230-00309659-00309929": "reply uh put a thousand of you to flight", "MpUwn__YYuM-01231-00309930-00310193": "and heaven will be as iron and Earth", "MpUwn__YYuM-01232-00310194-00310379": "will be his brass and sucks to be you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01233-00310380-00310625": "know I wasn't aware that it'll be it'll", "MpUwn__YYuM-01234-00310626-00310799": "be good though I wasn't aware that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01235-00310800-00311915": "Yahweh was Walter White", "MpUwn__YYuM-01236-00311916-00312280": "the word limit on their research paper", "MpUwn__YYuM-01237-00312281-00312503": "accurate", "MpUwn__YYuM-01238-00312504-00312760": "forward as a prime ethical dictum so if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01239-00312761-00313006": "it's the voice of God speaking to you so", "MpUwn__YYuM-01240-00313007-00313325": "to speak then it's going to call you out", "MpUwn__YYuM-01241-00313326-00313553": "of slavery maybe the slavery of your own", "MpUwn__YYuM-01242-00313554-00313745": "mind the slavery of external conditions", "MpUwn__YYuM-01243-00313746-00313949": "the slavery of the Tyranny hang on it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01244-00313950-00314519": "going to call you blunt", "MpUwn__YYuM-01245-00314520-00314963": "man what if like it's tyranny of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01246-00314964-00315113": "Mind", "MpUwn__YYuM-01247-00315114-00315469": "[Laughter]", "MpUwn__YYuM-01248-00315470-00315689": "I'm clipping this and making it a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01249-00315690-00315929": "YouTube short", "MpUwn__YYuM-01250-00315930-00316397": "my legacy yep yep you are now slavery", "MpUwn__YYuM-01251-00316398-00316727": "into Freedom even what I just said you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01252-00316728-00316937": "are now content", "MpUwn__YYuM-01253-00316938-00317273": "yay sad pulls you into the desert and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01254-00317274-00317434": "that's really something that's really", "MpUwn__YYuM-01255-00317435-00317597": "something to know and I think something", "MpUwn__YYuM-01256-00317598-00317813": "that's deeply true all right so having", "MpUwn__YYuM-01257-00317814-00317999": "said that and introduced everybody we're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01258-00318000-00318167": "going to start with the text and all as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01259-00318168-00318395": "I said I'll read it and I'll make", "MpUwn__YYuM-01260-00318396-00318556": "comments when they strike me and we'll", "MpUwn__YYuM-01261-00318557-00318784": "have everyone jump in and Away will go", "MpUwn__YYuM-01262-00318785-00319169": "so Exodus one now these are the names of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01263-00319170-00319427": "the children of Israel which came into", "MpUwn__YYuM-01264-00319428-00319751": "Egypt every man and his household", "MpUwn__YYuM-01265-00319752-00319979": "came with Jacob", "MpUwn__YYuM-01266-00319980-00320356": "Reuben Simeon Levi and Judah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01267-00320357-00320717": "issachar zebulun and Benjamin I'm gonna", "MpUwn__YYuM-01268-00320718-00320969": "say this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01269-00320970-00321154": "uh way more interesting listening to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01270-00321155-00321275": "people read the Bible when you're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01271-00321276-00321545": "listening to them chant or sing it then", "MpUwn__YYuM-01272-00321546-00321808": "just reading it flat and boring like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01273-00321809-00322019": "they could have literally also picked", "MpUwn__YYuM-01274-00322020-00322241": "anybody besides Jordan Peterson at the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01275-00322242-00322393": "table to have read that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01276-00322394-00322691": "he's just trying to imbue every word", "MpUwn__YYuM-01277-00322692-00322943": "with some sort of emphasis yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01278-00322944-00323189": "everything I say is like everything and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01279-00323190-00323608": "you highlight nothing yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01280-00323609-00323782": "I had that problem with heiress and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01281-00323783-00324130": "Kingdom Hearts the first one", "MpUwn__YYuM-01282-00324131-00324406": "really just for like I can't not tell", "MpUwn__YYuM-01283-00324407-00324580": "people trivia", "MpUwn__YYuM-01284-00324581-00324808": "um in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01285-00324809-00325091": "like Judaism the books are not named", "MpUwn__YYuM-01286-00325092-00325384": "like subject wise they're named after", "MpUwn__YYuM-01287-00325385-00325553": "like the first important word of like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01288-00325554-00325721": "that particular book so this book is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01289-00325722-00326051": "called names or shmote in Hebrew and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01290-00326052-00326213": "because the first significant word of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01291-00326214-00326351": "that particular", "MpUwn__YYuM-01292-00326352-00326639": "scroll is these are the names and that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01293-00326640-00326910": "why it lists a whole bunch of names so", "MpUwn__YYuM-01294-00326911-00327149": "Genesis they it's more or less the same", "MpUwn__YYuM-01295-00327150-00327323": "it's in the beginning that's what that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01296-00327324-00327479": "one word is when we learned like this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01297-00327480-00327593": "one's names because it starts out with a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01298-00327594-00327791": "bunch of names listening the cast of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01299-00327792-00327934": "characters like old movies used to do", "MpUwn__YYuM-01300-00327935-00328277": "before it starts and uh yeah the next", "MpUwn__YYuM-01301-00328278-00328451": "one's called in the wilderness because", "MpUwn__YYuM-01302-00328452-00328660": "guess what that book's about", "MpUwn__YYuM-01303-00328661-00328954": "and then the next one is uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01304-00328955-00329243": "words literally", "MpUwn__YYuM-01305-00329244-00329417": "words", "MpUwn__YYuM-01306-00329418-00329597": "yeah and then you got vikra which is and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01307-00329598-00329758": "he called because he called me he's like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01308-00329759-00329993": "hey get over here but not as cool as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01309-00329994-00330203": "scorpion that would be cool though we're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01310-00330204-00330401": "educational over here at the show I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01311-00330402-00330575": "think the next time that I read", "MpUwn__YYuM-01312-00330576-00330719": "Leviticus which is what we're talking", "MpUwn__YYuM-01313-00330720-00330989": "about uh vikra I'm gonna have God say", "MpUwn__YYuM-01314-00330990-00331579": "get over here oh there you go", "MpUwn__YYuM-01315-00331580-00331967": "it's like when Nathan says every time I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01316-00331968-00332110": "read that in English it's like you the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01317-00332111-00332515": "man", "MpUwn__YYuM-01318-00332516-00332884": "yes it's like quite a what is it what is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01319-00332885-00333221": "that the uh is it the um ah [__] the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01320-00333222-00333451": "stones the the the the the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01321-00333452-00333880": "girls at Camp uh they have a necklace", "MpUwn__YYuM-01322-00333881-00334103": "it's broken in half and I can't is it as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01323-00334104-00334289": "a Mitzvah Stones", "MpUwn__YYuM-01324-00334290-00334479": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-01325-00334480-00334632": "[Music]", "MpUwn__YYuM-01326-00334633-00334906": "may God watch over you and me while we", "MpUwn__YYuM-01327-00334907-00335075": "are apart and you know when they're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01328-00335076-00335225": "they're leaving camp some Christian", "MpUwn__YYuM-01329-00335226-00335387": "summer camp haven't been like there for", "MpUwn__YYuM-01330-00335388-00335549": "three weeks and made the best friends of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01331-00335550-00335765": "your life they're you know crying and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01332-00335766-00336034": "saying you you have this half of the of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01333-00336035-00336208": "the the stone and all of this and may", "MpUwn__YYuM-01334-00336209-00336401": "God watch over you and me while we're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01335-00336402-00336569": "apart when really this story is like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01336-00336570-00336839": "[__] see this Stone I won't come", "MpUwn__YYuM-01337-00336840-00336989": "across you to kill you and you won't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01338-00336990-00337169": "come across it to kill me you know may", "MpUwn__YYuM-01339-00337170-00337482": "God watch over you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01340-00337483-00337775": "it's literally him going he's got his", "MpUwn__YYuM-01341-00337776-00337991": "eye and now I know where the brothers", "MpUwn__YYuM-01342-00337992-00338171": "War Story in Magic the Gathering came", "MpUwn__YYuM-01343-00338172-00338434": "from", "MpUwn__YYuM-01344-00338435-00338827": "nice", "MpUwn__YYuM-01345-00338828-00339130": "intense some of these texts are and how", "MpUwn__YYuM-01346-00339131-00339323": "hysterically funny", "MpUwn__YYuM-01347-00339324-00339503": "they just don't because you read it and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01348-00339504-00339804": "you just like these are boring words", "MpUwn__YYuM-01349-00339805-00340091": "how to tell a story I should have set it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01350-00340092-00340253": "up so that way I could show like two", "MpUwn__YYuM-01351-00340254-00340421": "people on the screen bigger at the time", "MpUwn__YYuM-01352-00340422-00340613": "at a time and so that way when life is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01353-00340614-00340780": "Shanti and Dr Josh want to go it would", "MpUwn__YYuM-01354-00340781-00340895": "just go to just the two of them and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01355-00340896-00341069": "it'll be great and then when me and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01356-00341070-00341430": "Cyrus like spin off in a nerd them", "MpUwn__YYuM-01357-00341431-00341656": "because we would rather do anything than", "MpUwn__YYuM-01358-00341657-00342091": "listen to Kim Jordan Peterson yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01359-00342092-00342353": "and Asher", "MpUwn__YYuM-01360-00342354-00342617": "and all the souls that came out of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01361-00342618-00342989": "loins of Jacob were 70 Souls for Jesus", "MpUwn__YYuM-01362-00342990-00343319": "was in Egypt already and Joseph Donald", "MpUwn__YYuM-01363-00343320-00343613": "at the same time and all his brethren", "MpUwn__YYuM-01364-00343614-00343865": "and all that generation", "MpUwn__YYuM-01365-00343866-00344075": "and the children of Israel were fruitful", "MpUwn__YYuM-01366-00344076-00344303": "and increased abundantly and multiplied", "MpUwn__YYuM-01367-00344304-00344615": "and waxed exceeding mighty", "MpUwn__YYuM-01368-00344616-00344956": "and the land was filled with them", "MpUwn__YYuM-01369-00344957-00345239": "is waxing exceeding exceedingly mightily", "MpUwn__YYuM-01370-00345240-00345406": "is that like just jacking is that just", "MpUwn__YYuM-01371-00345407-00345610": "that just", "MpUwn__YYuM-01372-00345611-00345887": "no you don't your way of saying they got", "MpUwn__YYuM-01373-00345888-00346132": "big and strong you don't I could still", "MpUwn__YYuM-01374-00346133-00346393": "be that thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-01375-00346394-00346804": "not not every religion needs a dick joke", "MpUwn__YYuM-01376-00346805-00347117": "every religion is a dick joke oh every", "MpUwn__YYuM-01377-00347118-00347854": "religion has Dick jokes they better", "MpUwn__YYuM-01378-00347855-00348071": "we did get a question from Dr tapioca", "MpUwn__YYuM-01379-00348072-00348269": "weasel it says hey Chad I just wanted to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01380-00348270-00348413": "drop in and ask if everyone here", "MpUwn__YYuM-01381-00348414-00348599": "acknowledges an ultimate metaphysical", "MpUwn__YYuM-01382-00348600-00348791": "primary grounding in the laws of logic", "MpUwn__YYuM-01383-00348792-00349043": "and reason anyone", "MpUwn__YYuM-01384-00349044-00349337": "listen I I just don't think that the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01385-00349338-00349499": "good doctor can instantiate the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01386-00349500-00349708": "necessary preconditions for the ultimacy", "MpUwn__YYuM-01387-00349709-00349841": "of the grounding of impossible", "MpUwn__YYuM-01388-00349842-00349969": "possibilities", "MpUwn__YYuM-01389-00349970-00350441": "uh you know if you can't instantiate", "MpUwn__YYuM-01390-00350442-00350627": "that necessary precondition then you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01391-00350628-00350710": "know you're just barring from the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01392-00350711-00351137": "Christian worldview", "MpUwn__YYuM-01393-00351138-00351365": "understood some of those words that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01394-00351366-00351604": "why he's got the PHD yeah that's why", "MpUwn__YYuM-01395-00351605-00351767": "he's got the bow tie got the big brain", "MpUwn__YYuM-01396-00351768-00351971": "oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01397-00351972-00352199": "which I know are valuable", "MpUwn__YYuM-01398-00352200-00352373": "I think it just means that I've suffered", "MpUwn__YYuM-01399-00352374-00352828": "through Darth Dawkins too much too much", "MpUwn__YYuM-01400-00352829-00352991": "it's a trauma response we understand", "MpUwn__YYuM-01401-00352992-00353237": "yeah sometimes I'm happy", "MpUwn__YYuM-01402-00353238-00353441": "sometimes I'm happy that I swapped doing", "MpUwn__YYuM-01403-00353442-00353675": "mostly politics and less theology I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01404-00353676-00353813": "forgot how much of a headache the side", "MpUwn__YYuM-01405-00353814-00354178": "of the internet is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01406-00354179-00354430": "so Jacob and the Israelites are", "MpUwn__YYuM-01407-00354431-00354689": "presented as sojourners into into Egypt", "MpUwn__YYuM-01408-00354690-00354880": "so they're foreigners they're Strangers", "MpUwn__YYuM-01409-00354881-00355139": "In a Strange Land you might say and they", "MpUwn__YYuM-01410-00355140-00355667": "came in under the uh uh the guidance and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01411-00355668-00355960": "patrimony of Jacob who had a good", "MpUwn__YYuM-01412-00355961-00356147": "relationship with the power structure in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01413-00356148-00356458": "Egypt but he dies and his the generation", "MpUwn__YYuM-01414-00356459-00356765": "after him dies and relationships between", "MpUwn__YYuM-01415-00356766-00356963": "Israelites and the Egyptians become", "MpUwn__YYuM-01416-00356964-00357275": "strained is commenting while you read it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01417-00357276-00357575": "okay Jordan Peterson struggled to add", "MpUwn__YYuM-01418-00357576-00357760": "more words to the Senate says he's like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01419-00357761-00358121": "going yep the brain I mean this like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01420-00358122-00358427": "this overview is roughly", "MpUwn__YYuM-01421-00358428-00358613": "it's if it's like roughly what you would", "MpUwn__YYuM-01422-00358614-00358787": "read with like a like a seven-year-old", "MpUwn__YYuM-01423-00358788-00359063": "synopsis of the story but he's really", "MpUwn__YYuM-01424-00359064-00359297": "trying to make it sound deep it's like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01425-00359298-00359441": "he's actually he's not actually reading", "MpUwn__YYuM-01426-00359442-00359777": "the synopsis of of Exodus he's actually", "MpUwn__YYuM-01427-00359778-00360034": "reading the synopsis of like the movie", "MpUwn__YYuM-01428-00360035-00360358": "The Ten Commandments", "MpUwn__YYuM-01429-00360359-00360563": "it's gonna break into the princesses or", "MpUwn__YYuM-01430-00360564-00360851": "something you mean yeah they comment at", "MpUwn__YYuM-01431-00360852-00361330": "any point so adjust for all of your uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01432-00361331-00361558": "edification in Jewish life", "MpUwn__YYuM-01433-00361559-00361960": "if there are 10 best known verses in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01434-00361961-00362297": "entire Torah a new king arose over Egypt", "MpUwn__YYuM-01435-00362298-00362489": "who did not know Joseph", "MpUwn__YYuM-01436-00362490-00362693": "is one of the ten it's not the first one", "MpUwn__YYuM-01437-00362694-00362854": "I would have picked it summarizes the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01438-00362855-00363463": "human condition of ingratitude perfectly", "MpUwn__YYuM-01439-00363464-00363797": "okay okay okay", "MpUwn__YYuM-01440-00363798-00364030": "I know that when Dapper catches up to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01441-00364031-00364241": "this he also is going to laugh at that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01442-00364242-00364493": "for the same reason I did literally the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01443-00364494-00364804": "most famous like quote from the entire", "MpUwn__YYuM-01444-00364805-00365128": "Torah if you were to ask a Jew right now", "MpUwn__YYuM-01445-00365129-00365387": "would most likely be the Shema we say it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01446-00365388-00365543": "twice a day", "MpUwn__YYuM-01447-00365544-00365993": "literally", "MpUwn__YYuM-01448-00365994-00366304": "you're right and he's like oh no no it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01449-00366305-00366443": "this one you know random verse about", "MpUwn__YYuM-01450-00366444-00366575": "Pharaoh that we really only read during", "MpUwn__YYuM-01451-00366576-00366730": "Passover but no no no it's one of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01452-00366731-00367013": "top ten see I've got like Craig are you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01453-00367014-00367217": "stuck in my brain and I just recently", "MpUwn__YYuM-01454-00367218-00367571": "did a video about CRT and in the video", "MpUwn__YYuM-01455-00367572-00367804": "about CRT I went looking at like all", "MpUwn__YYuM-01456-00367805-00368117": "these think tanks that are like prageru", "MpUwn__YYuM-01457-00368118-00368482": "side of fence things and like how often", "MpUwn__YYuM-01458-00368483-00368734": "I saw quotes from those groups of people", "MpUwn__YYuM-01459-00368735-00369053": "being like Oh yeah this minority group", "MpUwn__YYuM-01460-00369054-00369299": "just doesn't appreciate what America", "MpUwn__YYuM-01461-00369300-00369623": "does for them as much like how dare the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01462-00369624-00369958": "like Nori D group criticize or have", "MpUwn__YYuM-01463-00369959-00370277": "criticisms of the Great American system", "MpUwn__YYuM-01464-00370278-00370517": "and that's all my brain heard as soon as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01465-00370518-00370793": "he said it was a story of ingratitude I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01466-00370794-00371056": "was just like ah black gross", "MpUwn__YYuM-01467-00371057-00371410": "birth", "MpUwn__YYuM-01468-00371411-00371675": "Joseph had saved the Egyptians from", "MpUwn__YYuM-01469-00371676-00371782": "starvation", "MpUwn__YYuM-01470-00371783-00372082": "and the next Pharaoh doesn't even know", "MpUwn__YYuM-01471-00372083-00372232": "his name", "MpUwn__YYuM-01472-00372233-00372539": "uh so he's forgotten the debts", "MpUwn__YYuM-01473-00372540-00372760": "he has forgotten the debts he has", "MpUwn__YYuM-01474-00372761-00372928": "entirely", "MpUwn__YYuM-01475-00372929-00373217": "but this is as I say I The Human", "MpUwn__YYuM-01476-00373218-00373475": "Condition uh we have forgotten our debts", "MpUwn__YYuM-01477-00373476-00373956": "in America", "MpUwn__YYuM-01478-00373957-00374137": "hold up", "MpUwn__YYuM-01479-00374138-00374567": "so a leader doing leader stuff it means", "MpUwn__YYuM-01480-00374568-00374795": "that the people owe him a debt isn't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01481-00374796-00374939": "that just what you're supposed to do as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01482-00374940-00375191": "a ruler like protect people and provide", "MpUwn__YYuM-01483-00375192-00375454": "like at least somewhat feeling like you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01484-00375455-00375706": "owe a debt to the leader who who did", "MpUwn__YYuM-01485-00375707-00375899": "great things for your country but", "MpUwn__YYuM-01486-00375900-00376054": "feeling like you owe a debt to that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01487-00376055-00376234": "leader", "MpUwn__YYuM-01488-00376235-00376475": "is one of the things that I would", "MpUwn__YYuM-01489-00376476-00376654": "attribute to say you know more like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01490-00376655-00376954": "monarchal systems like ah yes you owe a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01491-00376955-00377110": "debt to the great leader for doing the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01492-00377111-00377465": "thing pay your tithes citizen", "MpUwn__YYuM-01493-00377466-00377710": "there seems to be like maybe this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01494-00377711-00377975": "very authoritarian it is maybe this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01495-00377976-00378178": "just my interpretation of it though but", "MpUwn__YYuM-01496-00378179-00378478": "wasn't like Joseph and this is Joseph of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01497-00378479-00378713": "the Technicolor code right if that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01498-00378714-00379127": "Joseph was Hebrew and then he was ruling", "MpUwn__YYuM-01499-00379128-00379408": "over Egypt he's saying that the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01500-00379409-00379606": "Egyptians forgot and then therefore", "MpUwn__YYuM-01501-00379607-00379889": "Enslaved the Jews despite what the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01502-00379890-00380128": "Jewish people did for yeah because this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01503-00380129-00380423": "very one specific Jew who was literally", "MpUwn__YYuM-01504-00380424-00380680": "governing as in the text he was", "MpUwn__YYuM-01505-00380681-00380956": "governing part of Egypt they're like oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01506-00380957-00381178": "no no those those ungrateful Egyptians", "MpUwn__YYuM-01507-00381179-00381425": "they owed the Hebrews like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01508-00381426-00381808": "no right but he's also saying that as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01509-00381809-00382175": "like as if all like as if the nation of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01510-00382176-00382517": "Egypt now owes yeah just Jewish people", "MpUwn__YYuM-01511-00382518-00382727": "oh no he's gonna spin this into like oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01512-00382728-00382913": "no people have left their theological", "MpUwn__YYuM-01513-00382914-00383056": "rude so we should get back to the Bible", "MpUwn__YYuM-01514-00383057-00383237": "blah blah blah blah blah it's like oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01515-00383238-00383458": "these leaders and right now he's talking", "MpUwn__YYuM-01516-00383459-00383710": "about like early American leaders yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01517-00383711-00384023": "P.S we all know them [__]", "MpUwn__YYuM-01518-00384024-00384689": "dead", "MpUwn__YYuM-01519-00384690-00384875": "this is true and they are they're dead", "MpUwn__YYuM-01520-00384876-00385073": "like what am I gonna do go over to their", "MpUwn__YYuM-01521-00385074-00385378": "grave and just be like hey buddy", "MpUwn__YYuM-01522-00385379-00385595": "dance they don't set up a country like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01523-00385596-00385810": "that's not easy", "MpUwn__YYuM-01524-00385811-00385967": "um they tried you know to win their", "MpUwn__YYuM-01525-00385968-00386117": "independence and they succeeded barely", "MpUwn__YYuM-01526-00386118-00386339": "that's also not easy I'm not like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01527-00386340-00386632": "knocking them for that thanks France", "MpUwn__YYuM-01528-00386633-00386999": "but also he's just gonna say we owe them", "MpUwn__YYuM-01529-00387000-00387227": "like not all of them were fundamentalist", "MpUwn__YYuM-01530-00387228-00387484": "Evangelical Christians spoiler alert", "MpUwn__YYuM-01531-00387485-00387701": "lots of them were deists I don't think", "MpUwn__YYuM-01532-00387702-00387851": "he's gonna like that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01533-00387852-00387982": "I don't think he's gonna acknowledge", "MpUwn__YYuM-01534-00387983-00388319": "that that would be very very bad for my", "MpUwn__YYuM-01535-00388320-00388510": "narrative if I were to acknowledge those", "MpUwn__YYuM-01536-00388511-00388804": "things you said I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01537-00388805-00389141": "this and there arose a new generation in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01538-00389142-00389530": "America who who knew not Madison you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01539-00389531-00389765": "that could be a perfect verse right okay", "MpUwn__YYuM-01540-00389766-00390067": "literally every kid learns about Madison", "MpUwn__YYuM-01541-00390068-00390478": "and I am Alexander Hamilton which knew", "MpUwn__YYuM-01542-00390479-00390701": "not Joseph", "MpUwn__YYuM-01543-00390702-00391037": "and he said unto his people behold the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01544-00391038-00391282": "people of the children of Israel are", "MpUwn__YYuM-01545-00391283-00391727": "more and mightier than we", "MpUwn__YYuM-01546-00391728-00391973": "come on let us deal wisely with them", "MpUwn__YYuM-01547-00391974-00392249": "lest they multiply and it come to pass", "MpUwn__YYuM-01548-00392250-00392573": "that when there fall without any War", "MpUwn__YYuM-01549-00392574-00392873": "they join also unto our enemies and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01550-00392874-00393215": "fight against us", "MpUwn__YYuM-01551-00393216-00393454": "okay I'm just gonna say it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01552-00393455-00393725": "you know how like super xenophobic and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01553-00393726-00393960": "anti-immigrant these far crap turds are", "MpUwn__YYuM-01554-00393961-00394277": "ah yeah what I think is funny is that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01555-00394278-00394504": "narratively like the bad guys in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01556-00394505-00394804": "story are the ones who are like ew all", "MpUwn__YYuM-01557-00394805-00395039": "these foreigners we don't want them", "MpUwn__YYuM-01558-00395040-00395225": "burners coming in our country and out", "MpUwn__YYuM-01559-00395226-00395380": "breeding us", "MpUwn__YYuM-01560-00395381-00395639": "we should uh enslave them", "MpUwn__YYuM-01561-00395640-00395915": "or press them that's what you get these", "MpUwn__YYuM-01562-00395916-00396101": "are the bad guys in the story do you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01563-00396102-00396310": "think that irony hits any of them at any", "MpUwn__YYuM-01564-00396311-00396604": "point no not really", "MpUwn__YYuM-01565-00396605-00396821": "that requires self-awareness you have to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01566-00396822-00396995": "remember there are people what was that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01567-00396996-00397121": "one post that got deleted off Twitter", "MpUwn__YYuM-01568-00397122-00397360": "today for the one like girl who claimed", "MpUwn__YYuM-01569-00397361-00397745": "she was a teacher said that hey I don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01570-00397746-00398110": "agree with Hitler but maybe he has that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01571-00398111-00398351": "I've got no no no no no no no no no yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01572-00398352-00398567": "I saw that one no no no no no no no no", "MpUwn__YYuM-01573-00398568-00398782": "she was like yeah genocide was really", "MpUwn__YYuM-01574-00398783-00398939": "bad unless it's against this one group", "MpUwn__YYuM-01575-00398940-00399232": "that I hate yeah but maybe as soon as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01576-00399233-00399425": "you say hey I don't agree with Hitler", "MpUwn__YYuM-01577-00399426-00399695": "but you shouldn't there should never be", "MpUwn__YYuM-01578-00399696-00399991": "a butt there should never be a bite", "MpUwn__YYuM-01579-00399992-00400193": "unless it's like I don't agree with", "MpUwn__YYuM-01580-00400194-00400415": "Hitler you have to hand it to him but if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01581-00400416-00400577": "he had stayed in art school like that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01582-00400578-00400804": "probably the only uh I don't agree with", "MpUwn__YYuM-01583-00400805-00401032": "Hitler but that I'm okay with", "MpUwn__YYuM-01584-00401033-00401419": "right right", "MpUwn__YYuM-01585-00401420-00401675": "out of the land", "MpUwn__YYuM-01586-00401676-00401860": "there's an accusation of a crime before", "MpUwn__YYuM-01587-00401861-00402010": "it's committed right these people are", "MpUwn__YYuM-01588-00402011-00402197": "just a threat and a plague and we can't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01589-00402198-00402358": "trust them and that's part of this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01590-00402359-00402610": "ingratitude as well and a breakdown of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01591-00402611-00402754": "trust and that's definitely that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01592-00402755-00402917": "definitely sets the stage for conflict", "MpUwn__YYuM-01593-00402918-00403193": "the breakdown of trust therefore", "MpUwn__YYuM-01594-00403194-00403534": "they did set over them task Masters to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01595-00403535-00403745": "afflict them with their burdens nobody", "MpUwn__YYuM-01596-00403746-00403877": "else got to say anything about that they", "MpUwn__YYuM-01597-00403878-00404051": "built for Pharaoh treasure cities", "MpUwn__YYuM-01598-00404052-00404308": "pithome and Ramses", "MpUwn__YYuM-01599-00404309-00404525": "so the response to the hypothetical", "MpUwn__YYuM-01600-00404526-00404795": "Crimes of the Israelites was to enslave", "MpUwn__YYuM-01601-00404796-00404945": "them and one of the things we should", "MpUwn__YYuM-01602-00404946-00405239": "notice very early on in this is that the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01603-00405240-00405491": "the book of Exodus regards that move of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01604-00405492-00405706": "enslavement as fundamentally wrong it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01605-00405707-00405958": "like an axiomatic precondition of the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01606-00405959-00406121": "narrative itself", "MpUwn__YYuM-01607-00406122-00406373": "yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01608-00406374-00406589": "that's like going man I can't believe", "MpUwn__YYuM-01609-00406590-00406780": "the protagonist wife died in the first", "MpUwn__YYuM-01610-00406781-00406984": "three minutes of the movie it's almost", "MpUwn__YYuM-01611-00406985-00407158": "like that's narratively set up so we", "MpUwn__YYuM-01612-00407159-00407506": "have a plot", "MpUwn__YYuM-01613-00407507-00407791": "I can't believe the great Deku Tree died", "MpUwn__YYuM-01614-00407792-00408089": "damn it I can't believe this I can't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01615-00408090-00408330": "believe this story has conflict", "MpUwn__YYuM-01616-00408331-00408673": "yeah I can't believe", "MpUwn__YYuM-01617-00408674-00408947": "it's not like we're trying to tell a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01618-00408948-00409217": "story or anything having a premise for", "MpUwn__YYuM-01619-00409218-00409439": "Adam Lee of course it makes sense that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01620-00409440-00409655": "[__] Jordan Peterson is just like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01621-00409656-00409780": "what do you mean you have a point to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01622-00409781-00409907": "what you're saying you're not just", "MpUwn__YYuM-01623-00409908-00410359": "saying words at me", "MpUwn__YYuM-01624-00410360-00410693": "I was gonna say about uh the TV show", "MpUwn__YYuM-01625-00410693-00410932": "Justified is that there's one episode in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01626-00410933-00411059": "the first season where they meet a guy", "MpUwn__YYuM-01627-00411060-00411443": "who's just obsessed with collecting the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01628-00411443-00411610": "paintings of Hitler and they're like wow", "MpUwn__YYuM-01629-00411612-00411916": "this guy is like really weird this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01630-00411917-00412109": "not okay and it comes to find out at the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01631-00412110-00412295": "end of the episode that because he hates", "MpUwn__YYuM-01632-00412296-00412510": "his dad so much he's decided to vent", "MpUwn__YYuM-01633-00412512-00412637": "this anger by collecting all the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01634-00412638-00412889": "Hitler's paintings burning them to Ash", "MpUwn__YYuM-01635-00412889-00413213": "and storing them in jars on shelves in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01636-00413214-00413339": "his house and he's like and I won't stop", "MpUwn__YYuM-01637-00413339-00413470": "until I burned every last one of those", "MpUwn__YYuM-01638-00413471-00413609": "shitty paintings", "MpUwn__YYuM-01639-00413610-00413887": "and you're just like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01640-00413888-00414203": "okay that's uh that's a pretty strong", "MpUwn__YYuM-01641-00414204-00414389": "daddy issue like we're talking like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01642-00414389-00414587": "Andrew Tate level of daddy issue here", "MpUwn__YYuM-01643-00414588-00414995": "but uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01644-00414996-00415222": "I mean I guess that's a good thing by uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01645-00415223-00415564": "Robert picardo which makes hey I love", "MpUwn__YYuM-01646-00415566-00415889": "Robert picardo yes so yeah you should", "MpUwn__YYuM-01647-00415889-00415978": "watch that episode is pretty", "MpUwn__YYuM-01648-00415979-00416239": "entertaining", "MpUwn__YYuM-01649-00416239-00416609": "Justified noted mm-hmm", "MpUwn__YYuM-01650-00416610-00416849": "and modern people I suppose don't find", "MpUwn__YYuM-01651-00416850-00417005": "that surprising because we all believe", "MpUwn__YYuM-01652-00417006-00417305": "that slavery is wrong but it is that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01653-00417306-00417672": "most of the countries", "MpUwn__YYuM-01654-00417673-00417989": "well you know humans now think slavery's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01655-00417989-00418145": "wrong", "MpUwn__YYuM-01656-00418146-00418330": "because the asshat that said something", "MpUwn__YYuM-01657-00418331-00418645": "like you know I sure I mean you know", "MpUwn__YYuM-01658-00418646-00418966": "right being no longer a you know", "MpUwn__YYuM-01659-00418967-00419314": "property uh offensive you know property", "MpUwn__YYuM-01660-00419316-00419639": "like yeah okay so that's that's good I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01661-00419639-00419879": "guess that uh that women have that right", "MpUwn__YYuM-01662-00419880-00420077": "now but you know is it really the best", "MpUwn__YYuM-01663-00420078-00420364": "way like it's it's messing with the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01664-00420366-00420689": "hierarchy pyramid it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01665-00420689-00421085": "error", "MpUwn__YYuM-01666-00421085-00421289": "women at the top of the pyramid that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01667-00421289-00421643": "illegal you can't do that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01668-00421643-00421829": "you actually have the past the top", "MpUwn__YYuM-01669-00421830-00422033": "that's chaos", "MpUwn__YYuM-01670-00422034-00422549": "right that's like an inverted pyramid", "MpUwn__YYuM-01671-00422550-00422747": "no that and again I'll say it again on", "MpUwn__YYuM-01672-00422747-00422975": "Chad silver Harlow no there is a literal", "MpUwn__YYuM-01673-00422976-00423197": "episode of Justified in season one where", "MpUwn__YYuM-01674-00423197-00423413": "Robert picardo plays the character who", "MpUwn__YYuM-01675-00423414-00423514": "collects all of Hitler's shitty", "MpUwn__YYuM-01676-00423515-00423629": "paintings burns them to Ash and keeps", "MpUwn__YYuM-01677-00423630-00423755": "the jar in itself", "MpUwn__YYuM-01678-00423756-00423959": "I own these DVDs I've seen like a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01679-00423960-00424060": "million times", "MpUwn__YYuM-01680-00424062-00424264": "if White Collar also did an episode that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01681-00424265-00424397": "was similar cool but I've never watched", "MpUwn__YYuM-01682-00424397-00424613": "white one thing that we're gonna all end", "MpUwn__YYuM-01683-00424614-00424799": "up disagreeing on is gonna be like the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01684-00424800-00425027": "time code of this show that shot he", "MpUwn__YYuM-01685-00425028-00425201": "watches", "MpUwn__YYuM-01686-00425202-00425405": "back to slavery", "MpUwn__YYuM-01687-00425406-00425716": "regarded it as wrong and so this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01688-00425717-00425914": "invisible ethic that already permeates", "MpUwn__YYuM-01689-00425915-00426118": "The Narrative has a revolutionary aspect", "MpUwn__YYuM-01690-00426119-00426329": "in that sense but the more they", "MpUwn__YYuM-01691-00426330-00426964": "Afflicted them see see sorry", "MpUwn__YYuM-01692-00426965-00427283": "that's a little vexing", "MpUwn__YYuM-01693-00427284-00427403": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-01694-00427404-00427709": "because it's not slavery", "MpUwn__YYuM-01695-00427710-00427949": "that the Hebrew Bible considers to be", "MpUwn__YYuM-01696-00427950-00428243": "bad as a social institution it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01697-00428243-00428531": "enslaving the Israelites specifically", "MpUwn__YYuM-01698-00428532-00428813": "like yeah that's the point and this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01699-00428814-00429035": "where I I do not like this bait and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01700-00429035-00429113": "switch", "MpUwn__YYuM-01701-00429114-00429287": "apologists do this all the time", "MpUwn__YYuM-01702-00429288-00429466": "obviously", "MpUwn__YYuM-01703-00429467-00429701": "but you know you read through a passage", "MpUwn__YYuM-01704-00429702-00429983": "like Leviticus 25 and it it says okay", "MpUwn__YYuM-01705-00429984-00430114": "look you used to be able to keep", "MpUwn__YYuM-01706-00430115-00430264": "Israelites as dead slaves you're not", "MpUwn__YYuM-01707-00430265-00430372": "allowed to do that anymore you can't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01708-00430373-00430618": "trade him as that slice it's like aha", "MpUwn__YYuM-01709-00430619-00430870": "say there's there's progress here God is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01710-00430871-00431093": "working them out of that but then then", "MpUwn__YYuM-01711-00431093-00431309": "it says so if you want slaves they get", "MpUwn__YYuM-01712-00431310-00431479": "them from the foreigners", "MpUwn__YYuM-01713-00431480-00431807": "right it's it's it's like loans right", "MpUwn__YYuM-01714-00431808-00431945": "when you read through Deuteronomy and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01715-00431946-00432149": "it's like don't take loans you know I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01716-00432150-00432389": "mean don't take interest on the loans", "MpUwn__YYuM-01717-00432389-00432581": "that you give to your fellow Israelites", "MpUwn__YYuM-01718-00432582-00432814": "it's it's not that taking interest is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01719-00432815-00433127": "bad it's just charging interest to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01720-00433128-00433420": "fellow Israelites is bad like like so", "MpUwn__YYuM-01721-00433421-00433613": "there's there's not this moral component", "MpUwn__YYuM-01722-00433614-00433816": "to it which I think it's just racism", "MpUwn__YYuM-01723-00433817-00433985": "trying to suggest", "MpUwn__YYuM-01724-00433985-00434243": "right they just they just replaced the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01725-00434243-00434416": "things they arbitrarily said were bad", "MpUwn__YYuM-01726-00434417-00434722": "with racism that one good you see", "MpUwn__YYuM-01727-00434723-00434987": "slavery bad when of your own race", "MpUwn__YYuM-01728-00434988-00435395": "slavery good when of other people", "MpUwn__YYuM-01729-00435396-00435622": "bigotry bigotry bad towards us but not", "MpUwn__YYuM-01730-00435623-00435864": "towards other people yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01731-00435865-00436199": "like just just to be uh you know very", "MpUwn__YYuM-01732-00436200-00436409": "very clear here that that was nothing", "MpUwn__YYuM-01733-00436410-00436672": "there's nothing distinctive really about", "MpUwn__YYuM-01734-00436673-00436810": "that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01735-00436812-00436883": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-01736-00436884-00437164": "you know in the Hebrew Bible said that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01737-00437165-00437351": "this sort of thing where you know", "MpUwn__YYuM-01738-00437352-00437579": "something being done to the citizens of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01739-00437580-00437770": "your populace uh you know of your", "MpUwn__YYuM-01740-00437771-00437981": "country or whatever or of your city or", "MpUwn__YYuM-01741-00437982-00438113": "whatever", "MpUwn__YYuM-01742-00438114-00438449": "um is different from foreigners that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01743-00438450-00438647": "that wasn't different in the ancient", "MpUwn__YYuM-01744-00438647-00438820": "areas the Hebrew Bible is very much on", "MpUwn__YYuM-01745-00438821-00438913": "par", "MpUwn__YYuM-01746-00438914-00439181": "with that so like nobody", "MpUwn__YYuM-01747-00439182-00439301": "yeah I don't think anybody should hear", "MpUwn__YYuM-01748-00439302-00439433": "me saying that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01749-00439434-00439618": "um oh look how awful", "MpUwn__YYuM-01750-00439619-00439775": "you know the Hebrew Bible is there so", "MpUwn__YYuM-01751-00439776-00439907": "that's that's not what I'm saying it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01752-00439908-00440207": "just but it's holding holding this out", "MpUwn__YYuM-01753-00440208-00440435": "which is an apologetic move to try to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01754-00440435-00440675": "say see we should be basing our morals", "MpUwn__YYuM-01755-00440676-00440933": "on this ancient text because look here", "MpUwn__YYuM-01756-00440934-00441107": "right at the outset it says that slavery", "MpUwn__YYuM-01757-00441108-00441316": "is immoral yeah it doesn't really work", "MpUwn__YYuM-01758-00441317-00441616": "that way you shouldn't have to be trying", "MpUwn__YYuM-01759-00441617-00441881": "to [__] and and circumvent what it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01760-00441882-00442043": "trying to what it's actually trying to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01761-00442043-00442349": "present uh well I mean again people like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01762-00442350-00442577": "this guy they use it more as a tool for", "MpUwn__YYuM-01763-00442578-00442714": "the rhetor because they've already oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01764-00442715-00442913": "right right that's the way most people", "MpUwn__YYuM-01765-00442914-00443249": "use it so that they're just that to me", "MpUwn__YYuM-01766-00443250-00443477": "is just respect like disrespectful of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01767-00443478-00443681": "the book itself and whatever it is that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01768-00443682-00443897": "you're actually trying to Pony I mean", "MpUwn__YYuM-01769-00443897-00444070": "yeah again Jordan Peterson's trying to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01770-00444071-00444227": "say is it's okay to be white literally", "MpUwn__YYuM-01771-00444228-00444553": "later on in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01772-00444554-00444809": "but yeah it's this idea oh yeah we know", "MpUwn__YYuM-01773-00444810-00445037": "slavery's bad now but like we're just", "MpUwn__YYuM-01774-00445038-00445181": "gonna not talk about the parts where", "MpUwn__YYuM-01775-00445182-00445441": "it's explicitly commanded later on", "MpUwn__YYuM-01776-00445442-00445763": "technically technically if they if they", "MpUwn__YYuM-01777-00445764-00445979": "do the whole like look at look at what", "MpUwn__YYuM-01778-00445980-00446141": "this book says about slavery slavery bad", "MpUwn__YYuM-01779-00446142-00446375": "in this book uh you go Okay cool so what", "MpUwn__YYuM-01780-00446376-00446549": "kind of slavery did America have well it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01781-00446550-00446705": "was one where we bought slaves from", "MpUwn__YYuM-01782-00446706-00446945": "other nations outside of our own and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01783-00446946-00447064": "then we brought them in okay so what", "MpUwn__YYuM-01784-00447065-00447359": "about that slavery because our own", "MpUwn__YYuM-01785-00447360-00447616": "constituents in the United States made a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01786-00447617-00447827": "point to quote those verses in defense", "MpUwn__YYuM-01787-00447828-00448207": "of slavery", "MpUwn__YYuM-01788-00448208-00448433": "this is what happens when you don't have", "MpUwn__YYuM-01789-00448434-00448595": "a single historian on the panel oh my", "MpUwn__YYuM-01790-00448596-00448714": "God", "MpUwn__YYuM-01791-00448715-00449063": "right oh my God or like a Biblical", "MpUwn__YYuM-01792-00449064-00449405": "expert even I was able to do better none", "MpUwn__YYuM-01793-00449406-00449663": "of them are yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01794-00449664-00449945": "um miles better Dr kapioca weasel for 20", "MpUwn__YYuM-01795-00449946-00450185": "said the Bible doesn't endorse slavery I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01796-00450185-00450359": "mean yeah I read the whole book about", "MpUwn__YYuM-01797-00450360-00450622": "how it does but it's negated by a typo", "MpUwn__YYuM-01798-00450623-00450922": "in the second last line of page 91 as", "MpUwn__YYuM-01799-00450923-00451081": "this verse", "MpUwn__YYuM-01800-00451082-00451505": "sick often cited so who cares", "MpUwn__YYuM-01801-00451506-00451714": "yeah you know this is what happens when", "MpUwn__YYuM-01802-00451715-00451907": "you edit your own books this is uh you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01803-00451908-00452153": "copied it yeah every every time I cover", "MpUwn__YYuM-01804-00452154-00452357": "biblical gender roles I remember he has", "MpUwn__YYuM-01805-00452358-00452801": "an editor and here we are it's yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01806-00452802-00453010": "uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01807-00453012-00453310": "you know what though uh I just finished", "MpUwn__YYuM-01808-00453312-00453568": "and I'm working on the copy editing now", "MpUwn__YYuM-01809-00453569-00453839": "of the second edition of that book and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01810-00453839-00453995": "I'm sure that there will be more typos", "MpUwn__YYuM-01811-00453996-00454270": "because it's gone from like 200 pages to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01812-00454271-00454510": "700 so", "MpUwn__YYuM-01813-00454512-00454805": "it's exciting congratulations well if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01814-00454806-00454972": "I'm sure you're paying someone", "MpUwn__YYuM-01815-00454973-00455218": "professionally to do it but I also am", "MpUwn__YYuM-01816-00455219-00455393": "available if you need a second pair of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01817-00455393-00456037": "Bibles", "MpUwn__YYuM-01818-00456038-00456263": "creating something backwards is always", "MpUwn__YYuM-01819-00456264-00456449": "the way that I double check anything if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01820-00456450-00456647": "you read it backwards it stops your mind", "MpUwn__YYuM-01821-00456647-00456941": "from just filling in automatically so if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01822-00456942-00457157": "you read your sentences backwards it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01823-00457158-00457343": "catches typos and spelling mistakes and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01824-00457343-00457655": "grammatical errors oh wow yeah nice that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01825-00457656-00457829": "is a skill I don't that's the same kind", "MpUwn__YYuM-01826-00457830-00457997": "of thing as shooting my own horn now", "MpUwn__YYuM-01827-00457997-00458201": "because I really am available you don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-01828-00458202-00458303": "have to pay me", "MpUwn__YYuM-01829-00458304-00458716": "I'm just saying oh yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01830-00458717-00459059": "I made extremely good grades in college", "MpUwn__YYuM-01831-00459060-00459209": "so", "MpUwn__YYuM-01832-00459210-00459497": "like you gotta send them your your CV", "MpUwn__YYuM-01833-00459497-00459725": "now", "MpUwn__YYuM-01834-00459726-00459929": "I'm just saying like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01835-00459930-00460151": "it's a nice skill to fall back on", "MpUwn__YYuM-01836-00460152-00460295": "because", "MpUwn__YYuM-01837-00460296-00460493": "you know people always need a second", "MpUwn__YYuM-01838-00460493-00460709": "pair of eyeballs because you read your", "MpUwn__YYuM-01839-00460710-00460859": "own stuff so many times you don't see it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01840-00460860-00461116": "so that's why you gotta have editors", "MpUwn__YYuM-01841-00461117-00461275": "thank you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01842-00461276-00461464": "set you guys up to chat in the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01843-00461465-00462077": "background", "MpUwn__YYuM-01844-00462078-00462299": "and they were grieved because this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01845-00462300-00462485": "what I'm here for Israel and the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01846-00462485-00462725": "Egyptians made the children of Israel", "MpUwn__YYuM-01847-00462726-00462983": "to serve with rigor", "MpUwn__YYuM-01848-00462984-00463205": "and they made their lives better with", "MpUwn__YYuM-01849-00463206-00463505": "hard bondage in mortar and in Brick and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01850-00463506-00463751": "in all manner of service in the field", "MpUwn__YYuM-01851-00463752-00463937": "all their service", "MpUwn__YYuM-01852-00463938-00464170": "wherein they made them serve", "MpUwn__YYuM-01853-00464171-00464459": "was with rigor that that reminds me that", "MpUwn__YYuM-01854-00464460-00464716": "part of of what happened in the 20", "MpUwn__YYuM-01855-00464717-00465018": "minutes almost two years", "MpUwn__YYuM-01856-00465019-00465370": "as well there we go idea that you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01857-00465371-00465520": "identify your enemies and then you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01858-00465521-00465720": "sentence them", "MpUwn__YYuM-01859-00465721-00466055": "against their will and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01860-00466056-00466283": "you mean that police like that Police", "MpUwn__YYuM-01861-00466284-00466529": "Issue and jail issue that Prager brought", "MpUwn__YYuM-01862-00466530-00466697": "up earlier", "MpUwn__YYuM-01863-00466697-00466966": "no not prison now just have them follow", "MpUwn__YYuM-01864-00466967-00467363": "the ten commandments hey I know uh I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01865-00467364-00467543": "know it's naive of me and I was like you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01866-00467543-00467651": "know maybe we'll get through this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01867-00467652-00467899": "without a reference to the Nationals", "MpUwn__YYuM-01868-00467900-00468251": "party but no no no no no why would you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01869-00468252-00468545": "think that give up hope all ye who enter", "MpUwn__YYuM-01870-00468546-00468643": "here", "MpUwn__YYuM-01871-00468643-00468868": "I did not see that reference coming but", "MpUwn__YYuM-01872-00468869-00469031": "you know here we are now", "MpUwn__YYuM-01873-00469032-00469385": "yeah so you see this idea echoed very", "MpUwn__YYuM-01874-00469385-00469570": "early in this story and something that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01875-00469571-00469709": "definitely echoed through the 20th", "MpUwn__YYuM-01876-00469710-00469937": "century yeah it's home but there's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01877-00469938-00470122": "really this idea at least somebody else", "MpUwn__YYuM-01878-00470123-00470297": "got to talk about this passage is doing", "MpUwn__YYuM-01879-00470297-00470518": "is reducing wants to reduce Israel to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01880-00470519-00470783": "potential for Egypt basically and you'll", "MpUwn__YYuM-01881-00470784-00470945": "see it later when he he wants to get rid", "MpUwn__YYuM-01882-00470946-00471179": "of the men he just wants women and so in", "MpUwn__YYuM-01883-00471180-00471425": "this image and it's it repeats even the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01884-00471426-00471587": "story of Abraham you know how the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01885-00471588-00471766": "Pharaoh wants to take his wife it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01886-00471767-00471995": "about taking the potential of another", "MpUwn__YYuM-01887-00471996-00472253": "people and try to subjugate it to you to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01888-00472254-00472475": "yourself so it's a reflection of mental", "MpUwn__YYuM-01889-00472476-00472660": "usage that's right yeah and so you know", "MpUwn__YYuM-01890-00472662-00472883": "you you can see that in people's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01891-00472884-00473014": "proclivity to use one another", "MpUwn__YYuM-01892-00473015-00473218": "interpersonally because when you're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01893-00473219-00473518": "talking to someone you can decide a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01894-00473519-00473831": "priori what you want from them and then", "MpUwn__YYuM-01895-00473832-00473975": "you can bend your words and your", "MpUwn__YYuM-01896-00473976-00474203": "interactions so that you exploit what", "MpUwn__YYuM-01897-00474204-00474431": "they have to offer for your purposes or", "MpUwn__YYuM-01898-00474432-00474595": "your engagement that's called", "MpUwn__YYuM-01899-00474596-00474910": "manipulation Jordan there's one single", "MpUwn__YYuM-01900-00474912-00475037": "word for that you don't have to like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01901-00475038-00475343": "over explain it I would just love I", "MpUwn__YYuM-01902-00475343-00475595": "would just love somehow to get them to", "MpUwn__YYuM-01903-00475596-00475895": "pause and read Deuteronomy 20 10 to 14.", "MpUwn__YYuM-01904-00475896-00476189": "like just right now after him having", "MpUwn__YYuM-01905-00476189-00476477": "said that like uh because that's the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01906-00476478-00476735": "passage about what to do when Israelites", "MpUwn__YYuM-01907-00476735-00476957": "go to war against people that are", "MpUwn__YYuM-01908-00476958-00477113": "outside of Israel proper because you're", "MpUwn__YYuM-01909-00477114-00477305": "supposed to kill all of them take all", "MpUwn__YYuM-01910-00477306-00477581": "the women for yourself", "MpUwn__YYuM-01911-00477582-00478055": "foreign", "MpUwn__YYuM-01912-00478056-00478333": "I like how he is trying to utilize", "MpUwn__YYuM-01913-00478334-00478751": "philosophical language to justify what", "MpUwn__YYuM-01914-00478752-00478872": "is like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01915-00478873-00479213": "what the Shadi said manipulation from", "MpUwn__YYuM-01916-00479214-00479405": "like us because he's the psychologist on", "MpUwn__YYuM-01917-00479406-00479716": "the panel and I just want to see if the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01918-00479717-00480029": "philosopher calls him out the super", "MpUwn__YYuM-01919-00480030-00480251": "hoity-toity guy and if he calls him out", "MpUwn__YYuM-01920-00480252-00480431": "he better call him out in Latin oh", "MpUwn__YYuM-01921-00480432-00480695": "Savage Cobra for five said and when the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01922-00480696-00480901": "Israel", "MpUwn__YYuM-01923-00480902-00481127": "question the only option is Elon", "MpUwn__YYuM-01924-00481128-00481301": "Starship but there is no ethically", "MpUwn__YYuM-01925-00481302-00481468": "sourced Brides of events this is common", "MpUwn__YYuM-01926-00481469-00481601": "practice", "MpUwn__YYuM-01927-00481602-00481793": "you kill the men and take the women like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01928-00481793-00482093": "that absolutely It's Not Unusual yep", "MpUwn__YYuM-01929-00482093-00482255": "acting like it's oh I can't believe they", "MpUwn__YYuM-01930-00482256-00482375": "did this horrific thing like literally", "MpUwn__YYuM-01931-00482376-00482663": "everyone was doing that this dialogue", "MpUwn__YYuM-01932-00482664-00482933": "where the purpose is mutual enrichment", "MpUwn__YYuM-01933-00482934-00483197": "and that that what would you call it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01934-00483197-00483497": "instrumental end doesn't dominate so and", "MpUwn__YYuM-01935-00483497-00483814": "you can experience it like at least they", "MpUwn__YYuM-01936-00483815-00484020": "talk about Egypt also as representing", "MpUwn__YYuM-01937-00484021-00484759": "your own passions", "MpUwn__YYuM-01938-00484760-00484966": "so it's like you I don't know anything", "MpUwn__YYuM-01939-00484967-00485135": "that you have I think you'd like to eat", "MpUwn__YYuM-01940-00485135-00485363": "and then then you you're there and at", "MpUwn__YYuM-01941-00485364-00485609": "first when everything knows you like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01942-00485610-00485825": "when your passion knows you then then", "MpUwn__YYuM-01943-00485826-00485951": "you're fine it's in the right order", "MpUwn__YYuM-01944-00485952-00486113": "things are in the right order but when", "MpUwn__YYuM-01945-00486114-00486316": "your passion or desires or whatever", "MpUwn__YYuM-01946-00486317-00486599": "Behavior you have forgets you then you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01947-00486600-00486791": "become an instrument of it like think of", "MpUwn__YYuM-01948-00486792-00487001": "a drug a drug addict where everything", "MpUwn__YYuM-01949-00487002-00487307": "they do deserves this Tyrant and so all", "MpUwn__YYuM-01950-00487308-00487516": "their potential he's talking about the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01951-00487517-00487709": "hierarchy triangle that Peterson brought", "MpUwn__YYuM-01952-00487710-00487889": "up at the beginning where falafels are", "MpUwn__YYuM-01953-00487889-00488057": "at the top and if falafels are at the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01954-00488058-00488339": "top you're gonna have a bad time", "MpUwn__YYuM-01955-00488339-00488507": "because now you're being driven by", "MpUwn__YYuM-01956-00488508-00488753": "falafels instead of by God", "MpUwn__YYuM-01957-00488754-00489263": "I would rather be driven by falafels", "MpUwn__YYuM-01958-00489264-00489605": "what if Egypt just like represents the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01959-00489606-00489949": "addictions in your mind man like", "MpUwn__YYuM-01960-00489950-00490325": "passions you know I need to know you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01961-00490326-00490559": "and you need to know them like but if", "MpUwn__YYuM-01962-00490560-00490925": "you forget that you're a slave man", "MpUwn__YYuM-01963-00490926-00491497": "it's angel dust Holmes", "MpUwn__YYuM-01964-00491497-00491663": "PCP", "MpUwn__YYuM-01965-00491664-00491843": "he's like take it out ripping out a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01966-00491843-00492010": "piece of the Bible and like cutting it", "MpUwn__YYuM-01967-00492012-00492383": "up and shoving it in a pipe", "MpUwn__YYuM-01968-00492384-00492599": "imagining that that episode of South", "MpUwn__YYuM-01969-00492600-00492947": "Park where uh where Cartman's cutting up", "MpUwn__YYuM-01970-00492947-00493175": "the like skin of the KFC chicken trying", "MpUwn__YYuM-01971-00493176-00493445": "to snort it as as Colonel Sanders is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01972-00493446-00493649": "coming but it's Jordan Peterson coming", "MpUwn__YYuM-01973-00493650-00493864": "and there's a [__]", "MpUwn__YYuM-01974-00493865-00494129": "bits of the Bible you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01975-00494130-00494309": "like ah God I just gotta get this", "MpUwn__YYuM-01976-00494310-00494489": "scripture", "MpUwn__YYuM-01977-00494489-00494579": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-01978-00494580-00494868": "yeah yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-01979-00494869-00495214": "you get reduced a potential for a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01980-00495215-00495451": "behavior", "MpUwn__YYuM-01981-00495452-00495695": "in some sense that might be your stomach", "MpUwn__YYuM-01982-00495696-00495905": "or your lust and so that's very", "MpUwn__YYuM-01983-00495906-00496079": "interesting too because the word Israel", "MpUwn__YYuM-01984-00496080-00496439": "means we my lust is a deity who struggle", "MpUwn__YYuM-01985-00496439-00496739": "with God and so yeah psychologically is", "MpUwn__YYuM-01986-00496739-00497099": "that the that which should be at the", "MpUwn__YYuM-01987-00497100-00497351": "highest place which is the part of you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01988-00497352-00497549": "that's struggling with the highest then", "MpUwn__YYuM-01989-00497550-00497741": "subordinated instrumentally to something", "MpUwn__YYuM-01990-00497742-00497866": "that should be lower in the ethical", "MpUwn__YYuM-01991-00497867-00498035": "hierarchy and that could be your own", "MpUwn__YYuM-01992-00498035-00498166": "inner tyranny and it could be someone", "MpUwn__YYuM-01993-00498167-00498370": "else's instrumental will or some state", "MpUwn__YYuM-01994-00498371-00498610": "I'm sorry mental will I'm sorry did he", "MpUwn__YYuM-01995-00498612-00498881": "just use the struggling with God in a", "MpUwn__YYuM-01996-00498882-00499151": "negative way yes yeah yeah that's", "MpUwn__YYuM-01997-00499152-00499325": "interesting yeah that's interesting you", "MpUwn__YYuM-01998-00499326-00499589": "gotta remember he's the quote atheists", "MpUwn__YYuM-01999-00499589-00499918": "here so like he's the one that can say", "MpUwn__YYuM-02000-00499919-00500122": "that", "MpUwn__YYuM-02001-00500123-00500489": "he's also like the he's just pushing his", "MpUwn__YYuM-02002-00500489-00500795": "like hierarchy I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02003-00500796-00500945": "think hierarchy and there's there's a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02004-00500946-00501113": "hierarchy of the fight inside of you and", "MpUwn__YYuM-02005-00501114-00501251": "you've got to put God at the top because", "MpUwn__YYuM-02006-00501252-00501413": "if if you don't then something else is", "MpUwn__YYuM-02007-00501414-00501557": "and then you're making God subservient", "MpUwn__YYuM-02008-00501558-00501737": "and that's just not the natural order of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02009-00501738-00501857": "things and then you've got to make", "MpUwn__YYuM-02010-00501858-00502018": "something else coming to a sermon", "MpUwn__YYuM-02011-00502019-00502205": "because I've heard preachers talk about", "MpUwn__YYuM-02012-00502206-00502439": "how like no no see God gave you all", "MpUwn__YYuM-02013-00502439-00502595": "these desires he just wants you to have", "MpUwn__YYuM-02014-00502596-00502739": "like boundaries on him because you know", "MpUwn__YYuM-02015-00502739-00502864": "it's good it's great to have sex but", "MpUwn__YYuM-02016-00502865-00503009": "only in the boundary of marriage and", "MpUwn__YYuM-02017-00503010-00503243": "it's okay to you know talk but you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02018-00503243-00503387": "should only guard like your speech and", "MpUwn__YYuM-02019-00503388-00503657": "say good things it's like I I literally", "MpUwn__YYuM-02020-00503658-00503801": "feel like I'm he's about to hit like you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02021-00503802-00504118": "Pastor boys I remember when I was in PCA", "MpUwn__YYuM-02022-00504119-00504287": "and I was hearing this exact", "MpUwn__YYuM-02023-00504288-00504514": "conversation but it was about Pokemon", "MpUwn__YYuM-02024-00504515-00504799": "and the Nintendo 64.", "MpUwn__YYuM-02025-00504800-00505145": "it was literally them going those are", "MpUwn__YYuM-02026-00505146-00505451": "literally in in non-denominational so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02027-00505452-00505775": "basically Baptist light circles the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02028-00505776-00505991": "narrative goes whatever you are", "MpUwn__YYuM-02029-00505992-00506183": "prioritizing the most in your life that", "MpUwn__YYuM-02030-00506184-00506327": "is your god and you're not supposed to", "MpUwn__YYuM-02031-00506328-00506620": "put any Gods before God so yeah by that", "MpUwn__YYuM-02032-00506621-00506837": "logic they would say yeah your Nintendo", "MpUwn__YYuM-02033-00506838-00507022": "can be God", "MpUwn__YYuM-02034-00507023-00507275": "yep and then they treat it as a whole", "MpUwn__YYuM-02035-00507276-00507520": "team yeah whatever is taking priority in", "MpUwn__YYuM-02036-00507521-00507683": "your life at that time you now are", "MpUwn__YYuM-02037-00507684-00507875": "somehow worshiping it or you're somehow", "MpUwn__YYuM-02038-00507876-00508181": "that's an idol being driven by that and", "MpUwn__YYuM-02039-00508182-00508409": "only that thing it's it's absurd what's", "MpUwn__YYuM-02040-00508410-00508637": "funny is that like that's a that's a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02041-00508638-00509009": "uniquely uh Protestant thing because", "MpUwn__YYuM-02042-00509010-00509249": "when when I've talked with uh when I've", "MpUwn__YYuM-02043-00509250-00509368": "talked with friends of mine and even", "MpUwn__YYuM-02044-00509369-00509537": "like people have had debates with who", "MpUwn__YYuM-02045-00509538-00509716": "were catholic they've got like a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02046-00509717-00509866": "three-tier system when it comes to", "MpUwn__YYuM-02047-00509867-00510041": "worship where there's a type of worship", "MpUwn__YYuM-02048-00510042-00510185": "that's there for the Saints a type of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02049-00510185-00510389": "worship that's there for the for God and", "MpUwn__YYuM-02050-00510389-00510545": "a type of worship that's there for like", "MpUwn__YYuM-02051-00510546-00510814": "the uh people and things you love and so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02052-00510815-00511060": "it's not like it's not the same thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-02053-00511062-00511349": "that you get with evangelicals where", "MpUwn__YYuM-02054-00511350-00511709": "they go no it's all worship and if you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02055-00511710-00512141": "do it the wrong way God mad yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-02056-00512142-00512453": "yeah big bed all right we're gonna", "MpUwn__YYuM-02057-00512454-00512657": "totally toxic though we are getting", "MpUwn__YYuM-02058-00512658-00512818": "close to about an hour and a half I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02059-00512819-00512945": "don't know how you guys are feeling if", "MpUwn__YYuM-02060-00512946-00513101": "you want to go for two hours or if you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02061-00513102-00513233": "want to wrap up at the hour and a half", "MpUwn__YYuM-02062-00513234-00513443": "we haven't even really gotten into this", "MpUwn__YYuM-02063-00513443-00513641": "we're 20 minutes in man they're just", "MpUwn__YYuM-02064-00513642-00513953": "saying nothing this is it Oh I thought", "MpUwn__YYuM-02065-00513954-00514264": "this was gonna break into like an actual", "MpUwn__YYuM-02066-00514265-00514813": "okay wow God no this is just what it is", "MpUwn__YYuM-02067-00514814-00515213": "this is 10 episodes long and they're two", "MpUwn__YYuM-02068-00515214-00515531": "hours and 20 minutes each wait it's not", "MpUwn__YYuM-02069-00515532-00516162": "10 episodes long it's 16 now", "MpUwn__YYuM-02070-00516163-00516712": "it is now 16 . it's still going", "MpUwn__YYuM-02071-00516713-00517272": "and like they're all two hours yes", "MpUwn__YYuM-02072-00517273-00517505": "what are they going through the whole", "MpUwn__YYuM-02073-00517506-00517625": "book or are they just going through the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02074-00517626-00517907": "story of The Exodus let's just pick it", "MpUwn__YYuM-02075-00517908-00518339": "out [__] [__] in regular order", "MpUwn__YYuM-02076-00518339-00518566": "it's just all this it's the whole thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-02077-00518567-00518722": "is this", "MpUwn__YYuM-02078-00518723-00518999": "and see for for me and I probably will", "MpUwn__YYuM-02079-00519000-00519233": "have to to go after the hour and a half", "MpUwn__YYuM-02080-00519234-00519472": "but um because Oliver will get me up at", "MpUwn__YYuM-02081-00519473-00519695": "four I'm pretty sure yeah I figured it", "MpUwn__YYuM-02082-00519696-00519827": "was starting to get late", "MpUwn__YYuM-02083-00519828-00520216": "but I like I I don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-02084-00520217-00520420": "I don't have a problem with this sort of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02085-00520421-00520607": "reader response", "MpUwn__YYuM-02086-00520608-00520966": "uh interpretive model because this is", "MpUwn__YYuM-02087-00520967-00521303": "this is very much like watching", "MpUwn__YYuM-02088-00521304-00521495": "um a facilitator lead a Sunday school", "MpUwn__YYuM-02089-00521496-00521675": "class an adult Sunday school class like", "MpUwn__YYuM-02090-00521676-00521903": "this is what you see right they read a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02091-00521904-00522070": "text and then they just sort of all say", "MpUwn__YYuM-02092-00522071-00522214": "how it makes them feel and what it", "MpUwn__YYuM-02093-00522215-00522335": "reminds them of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02094-00522335-00522539": "and the thing is I think that's great I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02095-00522539-00522743": "wish Christianity were just like that", "MpUwn__YYuM-02096-00522743-00523049": "that the problem is", "MpUwn__YYuM-02097-00523050-00523289": "um because when you do that you filter", "MpUwn__YYuM-02098-00523289-00523564": "it through which you already know", "MpUwn__YYuM-02099-00523565-00523889": "you have a like a moral set", "MpUwn__YYuM-02100-00523889-00524087": "you know you have an ethical system in", "MpUwn__YYuM-02101-00524088-00524260": "place and so when you read something", "MpUwn__YYuM-02102-00524262-00524459": "like Slaughter the amalekites you're", "MpUwn__YYuM-02103-00524460-00524735": "like what does that really mean right", "MpUwn__YYuM-02104-00524736-00525037": "because it can't mean that right right", "MpUwn__YYuM-02105-00525038-00525335": "so you pick up something else I wish", "MpUwn__YYuM-02106-00525336-00525514": "that everybody would do it that way the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02107-00525515-00525689": "problem is that they do it with their", "MpUwn__YYuM-02108-00525690-00525845": "own little reader response thing and", "MpUwn__YYuM-02109-00525846-00526120": "then say this is how you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02110-00526121-00526349": "should interpret it right that's where", "MpUwn__YYuM-02111-00526350-00526577": "it becomes a problem yeah no I agree", "MpUwn__YYuM-02112-00526578-00526805": "with that I think that that that kind of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02113-00526806-00527081": "there's kicks off our last words so uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-02114-00527082-00527237": "vashadi do you wanna well what I was", "MpUwn__YYuM-02115-00527238-00527477": "gonna say is there's such a really", "MpUwn__YYuM-02116-00527478-00527753": "interesting and bizarre conflict there", "MpUwn__YYuM-02117-00527754-00527968": "because the same people they're like hey", "MpUwn__YYuM-02118-00527969-00528316": "this is what this verse means to me they", "MpUwn__YYuM-02119-00528317-00528431": "also", "MpUwn__YYuM-02120-00528432-00528647": "literally will quote the verses that say", "MpUwn__YYuM-02121-00528648-00528827": "like oh but no scriptures of any private", "MpUwn__YYuM-02122-00528828-00528964": "interpretation when you start", "MpUwn__YYuM-02123-00528965-00529270": "disagreeing with them right", "MpUwn__YYuM-02124-00529271-00529462": "you don't have the Holy Spirit so you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02125-00529463-00529595": "can't really understand it yeah yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-02126-00529596-00529837": "yeah yeah of course of course not", "MpUwn__YYuM-02127-00529838-00530159": "but no true Scotsman beside me otherwise", "MpUwn__YYuM-02128-00530160-00530314": "I just will never be able to learn how", "MpUwn__YYuM-02129-00530315-00530562": "to read", "MpUwn__YYuM-02130-00530563-00530861": "or interpret literally that's what they", "MpUwn__YYuM-02131-00530862-00531077": "said right I'm not I'm not paraphrasing", "MpUwn__YYuM-02132-00531078-00531443": "right yeah right but it also like kind", "MpUwn__YYuM-02133-00531444-00531616": "of adds this extra layer of like how do", "MpUwn__YYuM-02134-00531617-00531929": "you even then start attempting to", "MpUwn__YYuM-02135-00531930-00532289": "evangelize at all or bring more religion", "MpUwn__YYuM-02136-00532290-00532822": "to anybody else ever", "MpUwn__YYuM-02137-00532823-00533039": "that's why there's you know thousands of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02138-00533040-00533207": "Christian denominations because they'll", "MpUwn__YYuM-02139-00533208-00533375": "disagree with each other and then jump", "MpUwn__YYuM-02140-00533376-00533657": "off and start a whole new church so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02141-00533658-00533933": "I want to divorce my wife I'm gonna go", "MpUwn__YYuM-02142-00533934-00534209": "build a building to go worship Him", "MpUwn__YYuM-02143-00534210-00534353": "I thought you were gonna say I'm gonna", "MpUwn__YYuM-02144-00534354-00534509": "go to yeah", "MpUwn__YYuM-02145-00534510-00534725": "gonna start my own shirt I'm gonna go to", "MpUwn__YYuM-02146-00534726-00535061": "build a religion", "MpUwn__YYuM-02147-00535062-00535187": "I'm gonna take this so we're gonna take", "MpUwn__YYuM-02148-00535188-00535301": "this we're gonna take this and we're", "MpUwn__YYuM-02149-00535302-00535414": "gonna Stitch it all together can you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02150-00535415-00535564": "please put the little heartbeat chip", "MpUwn__YYuM-02151-00535565-00535716": "Inside My Religion", "MpUwn__YYuM-02152-00535717-00535918": "this is the one that invented", "MpUwn__YYuM-02153-00535919-00536135": "Build-A-Bear it's just an invented", "MpUwn__YYuM-02154-00536136-00536322": "religion", "MpUwn__YYuM-02155-00536323-00536549": "all right I think we're gonna start like", "MpUwn__YYuM-02156-00536550-00536837": "okay well here's my final not final word", "MpUwn__YYuM-02157-00536838-00537053": "about the whole thing but yeah the last", "MpUwn__YYuM-02158-00537054-00537311": "important thing I'll say is it's always", "MpUwn__YYuM-02159-00537312-00537487": "interesting to me to listen how", "MpUwn__YYuM-02160-00537488-00537766": "absolutely for clamped and they get the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02161-00537767-00537922": "vapors that Christians are when people", "MpUwn__YYuM-02162-00537923-00538157": "disagree with them and they can't handle", "MpUwn__YYuM-02163-00538158-00538391": "this and I'm like literally Judaism has", "MpUwn__YYuM-02164-00538392-00538564": "entire study houses where we do nothing", "MpUwn__YYuM-02165-00538565-00538720": "but discuss the text and disagree with", "MpUwn__YYuM-02166-00538721-00538907": "each other right in fact we love", "MpUwn__YYuM-02167-00538908-00539218": "recording our disagreements so much we", "MpUwn__YYuM-02168-00539219-00539411": "have 40-something volumes in two", "MpUwn__YYuM-02169-00539412-00539639": "different talmuds where we do that I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02170-00539640-00539789": "mean that's cool and that's what people", "MpUwn__YYuM-02171-00539790-00539987": "should be doing laws and stuff we don't", "MpUwn__YYuM-02172-00539988-00540281": "just read a text we read everybody's", "MpUwn__YYuM-02173-00540282-00540539": "thoughts and comments on it and it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-02174-00540540-00540725": "like you never get just one point of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02175-00540726-00540845": "view so it's like people getting all", "MpUwn__YYuM-02176-00540846-00540989": "butt hurt and I can't believe there's a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02177-00540990-00541235": "disagreement listen that sounds healthy", "MpUwn__YYuM-02178-00541236-00541487": "and I'm gonna have to ask you to stop", "MpUwn__YYuM-02179-00541488-00541801": "respectfully", "MpUwn__YYuM-02180-00541802-00542039": "all right let's uh let's start with", "MpUwn__YYuM-02181-00542040-00542212": "service end with vashanti go the other", "MpUwn__YYuM-02182-00542213-00542429": "way we'll uh tell us who you are and", "MpUwn__YYuM-02183-00542430-00542687": "where you're at and don't [__] me this", "MpUwn__YYuM-02184-00542688-00542885": "time like you did at the beginning you a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02185-00542886-00543112": "bunch of losers we there's nobody nobody", "MpUwn__YYuM-02186-00543113-00543389": "did that nobody we were all honest with", "MpUwn__YYuM-02187-00543390-00543677": "ourselves and the audience", "MpUwn__YYuM-02188-00543678-00543953": "and if and if if you if you can't handle", "MpUwn__YYuM-02189-00543954-00544127": "that chesh that sounds like a you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02190-00544128-00544283": "problem", "MpUwn__YYuM-02191-00544284-00544697": "listen here you little [__]", "MpUwn__YYuM-02192-00544698-00545087": "I will let you die in bot Lane", "MpUwn__YYuM-02193-00545088-00545357": "oh you would too I would you would too I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02194-00545358-00545711": "would laugh about it oh my God but I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02195-00545712-00546029": "guess that's fair but okay so my name is", "MpUwn__YYuM-02196-00546030-00546401": "Sirius uh I do a little commentary for", "MpUwn__YYuM-02197-00546402-00546605": "the most part I also still do atheist", "MpUwn__YYuM-02198-00546606-00546803": "content uh not as much as I used to", "MpUwn__YYuM-02199-00546804-00546964": "because it's not it's just not as much", "MpUwn__YYuM-02200-00546965-00547162": "of my focus anymore but it is still a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02201-00547163-00547355": "thing that's done on my channel", "MpUwn__YYuM-02202-00547356-00547607": "um past that I also stream a lot it's", "MpUwn__YYuM-02203-00547608-00547775": "where all of my content comes from if", "MpUwn__YYuM-02204-00547776-00547961": "you want to see a more chill atmosphere", "MpUwn__YYuM-02205-00547962-00548087": "where I'm mixing things like doing", "MpUwn__YYuM-02206-00548088-00548464": "gaming as well as uh talking about the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02207-00548465-00548693": "most recent bill that comes through with", "MpUwn__YYuM-02208-00548694-00548849": "the goal of stripping people's human", "MpUwn__YYuM-02209-00548850-00548968": "rights away so that the justice", "MpUwn__YYuM-02210-00548969-00549233": "department can then uh put a hammer on", "MpUwn__YYuM-02211-00549234-00549377": "Tennessee for stripping people's human", "MpUwn__YYuM-02212-00549378-00549683": "rights away you know fun happy stuff", "MpUwn__YYuM-02213-00549684-00549881": "with no conflict whatsoever", "MpUwn__YYuM-02214-00549882-00550162": "yay", "MpUwn__YYuM-02215-00550163-00550355": "and uh Dr Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-02216-00550356-00550535": "um I also got a super chat for you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02217-00550536-00550751": "specifically that says Hell's Bells", "MpUwn__YYuM-02218-00550752-00551141": "empty night right oh my God that is that", "MpUwn__YYuM-02219-00551142-00551518": "is a Dresden", "MpUwn__YYuM-02220-00551519-00551687": "that's not the Super Chat I think they", "MpUwn__YYuM-02221-00551688-00551818": "were talking about", "MpUwn__YYuM-02222-00551819-00552095": "I think another one Israelites got rid", "MpUwn__YYuM-02223-00552096-00552275": "of all the men later", "MpUwn__YYuM-02224-00552276-00552533": "no that was that was somebody else maybe", "MpUwn__YYuM-02225-00552534-00552697": "he meant Cyrus", "MpUwn__YYuM-02226-00552698-00552991": "you might have meant Cyrus and said Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-02227-00552992-00553253": "[Music]", "MpUwn__YYuM-02228-00553254-00553511": "just look on my face may suggest further", "MpUwn__YYuM-02229-00553512-00553727": "Evidence all right who are you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02230-00553728-00553864": "apparently people are getting you too", "MpUwn__YYuM-02231-00553865-00554099": "confused sorry", "MpUwn__YYuM-02232-00554100-00554201": "um", "MpUwn__YYuM-02233-00554202-00554603": "so yeah I'm Dr Josh uh Megan", "MpUwn__YYuM-02234-00554604-00554962": "um runs digital Hammurabi and is the the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02235-00554963-00555193": "new host or is the host of the new", "MpUwn__YYuM-02236-00555194-00555425": "misquoting Jesus podcast was Bart", "MpUwn__YYuM-02237-00555426-00555653": "ehrmann so she's actually the famous one", "MpUwn__YYuM-02238-00555654-00555839": "now", "MpUwn__YYuM-02239-00555840-00556072": "um so I I don't do a lot on the channel", "MpUwn__YYuM-02240-00556073-00556333": "anymore", "MpUwn__YYuM-02241-00556334-00556555": "my uh", "MpUwn__YYuM-02242-00556556-00556931": "my work is uh my work is primarily done", "MpUwn__YYuM-02243-00556932-00557099": "doing interviews on other people's", "MpUwn__YYuM-02244-00557100-00557266": "channels it seems like the only thing", "MpUwn__YYuM-02245-00557267-00557575": "I'm good to talk about now is slavery", "MpUwn__YYuM-02246-00557576-00557872": "uh so oh no you've been Typecast just", "MpUwn__YYuM-02247-00557873-00557975": "finishing", "MpUwn__YYuM-02248-00557976-00558366": "oh no", "MpUwn__YYuM-02249-00558367-00558743": "uh yeah so but I've got but but I am the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02250-00558744-00558970": "author of um The Atheist handbook to the", "MpUwn__YYuM-02251-00558971-00559211": "Old Testament volumes one and two so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02252-00559212-00559372": "um but if you go to Amazon and type in", "MpUwn__YYuM-02253-00559373-00559541": "Joshua Bowen", "MpUwn__YYuM-02254-00559542-00559679": "everything that I've written will come", "MpUwn__YYuM-02255-00559680-00559979": "up but yeah go find Dr Josh and if you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02256-00559980-00560141": "want to have Dr Josh on to talk about", "MpUwn__YYuM-02257-00560142-00560314": "something other than slavery maybe send", "MpUwn__YYuM-02258-00560315-00560501": "him an email", "MpUwn__YYuM-02259-00560502-00560639": "laughs", "MpUwn__YYuM-02260-00560640-00560818": "yeah I'm sure you're kind of getting", "MpUwn__YYuM-02261-00560819-00561047": "over that you're welcome here to talk", "MpUwn__YYuM-02262-00561048-00561262": "about anything you want anytime Dr Josh", "MpUwn__YYuM-02263-00561263-00561427": "thank you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02264-00561428-00561851": "man they'll stop bringing it up", "MpUwn__YYuM-02265-00561852-00562091": "I just really like it so yeah I'm", "MpUwn__YYuM-02266-00562092-00562325": "bashanti and I just killed a spider so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02267-00562326-00562547": "that's oh that's what that was", "MpUwn__YYuM-02268-00562548-00562775": "spider Panic just", "MpUwn__YYuM-02269-00562776-00563057": "just saying listen I respect their point", "MpUwn__YYuM-02270-00563058-00563272": "in the food chain I am fine with them", "MpUwn__YYuM-02271-00563273-00563501": "doing what they do they are required not", "MpUwn__YYuM-02272-00563502-00563620": "to do it within my field of vision", "MpUwn__YYuM-02273-00563621-00563825": "that's it that's the only restriction", "MpUwn__YYuM-02274-00563826-00564053": "just do what you do outside my field of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02275-00564054-00564316": "vision then you can live as long as you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02276-00564317-00564551": "need to and that's fine but no once I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02277-00564552-00564862": "see you it's over it's on site so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02278-00564863-00565193": "you can find me on YouTube as vashanti", "MpUwn__YYuM-02279-00565194-00565355": "if you want to right now my channel has", "MpUwn__YYuM-02280-00565356-00565625": "not been officially launched uh mostly", "MpUwn__YYuM-02281-00565626-00565864": "hang out on Twitter where I try to talk", "MpUwn__YYuM-02282-00565865-00566093": "about stuff that's important but", "MpUwn__YYuM-02283-00566094-00566327": "sometimes I just [__] post so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02284-00566328-00566668": "go at your own risk uh eventually when I", "MpUwn__YYuM-02285-00566669-00566807": "do get my channel up I'll talk a little", "MpUwn__YYuM-02286-00566808-00567203": "bit about uh Judaism and how we do our", "MpUwn__YYuM-02287-00567204-00567557": "stuff I'll do kind of comedic readings", "MpUwn__YYuM-02288-00567558-00567827": "of the biblical text putting my own", "MpUwn__YYuM-02289-00567828-00567983": "little flavor in there as in starting", "MpUwn__YYuM-02290-00567984-00568216": "the Book of Leviticus with God said get", "MpUwn__YYuM-02291-00568217-00568420": "over here that stuff", "MpUwn__YYuM-02292-00568421-00568679": "because I'm a very serious person", "MpUwn__YYuM-02293-00568680-00568901": "yeah you can also sometimes find her on", "MpUwn__YYuM-02294-00568902-00569068": "Dapper Channel if you're interested you", "MpUwn__YYuM-02295-00569069-00569203": "can go find her there as well yes", "MpUwn__YYuM-02296-00569204-00569549": "sometimes I I get to guess and we react", "MpUwn__YYuM-02297-00569550-00569795": "to really just mind-numbingly bad", "MpUwn__YYuM-02298-00569796-00569933": "Christian youngers creationist", "MpUwn__YYuM-02299-00569934-00570053": "polygenics", "MpUwn__YYuM-02300-00570054-00570293": "so thank you so much for joining us this", "MpUwn__YYuM-02301-00570294-00570491": "has been debatehub I am chesh your", "MpUwn__YYuM-02302-00570492-00570664": "master debater and you can find all of", "MpUwn__YYuM-02303-00570665-00570887": "these people in the lovely links Down", "MpUwn__YYuM-02304-00570888-00571043": "Below in the description thank you so", "MpUwn__YYuM-02305-00571044-00571175": "much for coming thank you so much for", "MpUwn__YYuM-02306-00571176-00571295": "supporting and super chatting please", "MpUwn__YYuM-02307-00571296-00571414": "feel free to leave us comments down", "MpUwn__YYuM-02308-00571415-00571547": "below and maybe we'll be able to do a", "MpUwn__YYuM-02309-00571548-00571679": "follow-up", "MpUwn__YYuM-02310-00571680-00571870": "I'm gonna get out of here thanks for", "MpUwn__YYuM-02311-00571871-00572003": "joining us and have a good night", "MpUwn__YYuM-02312-00572004-00572452": "everybody bye foreign", "MpUwn__YYuM-02313-00572453-00572796": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "MOfOaON-H3M", "text": {"MOfOaON-H3M-00000-00000443-00000785": "so this is topic ten and let's talk", "MOfOaON-H3M-00001-00000786-00001000": "about going from from polar to", "MOfOaON-H3M-00002-00001001-00001357": "rectangular coordinates and then the", "MOfOaON-H3M-00003-00001358-00001522": "other way is well back and forth so", "MOfOaON-H3M-00004-00001523-00001666": "rectangular coordinates are just what", "MOfOaON-H3M-00005-00001667-00002321": "we're used to points in the form XY", "MOfOaON-H3M-00006-00002322-00002524": "called rectangular because it's you kind", "MOfOaON-H3M-00007-00002525-00002743": "of move in it along the side of a", "MOfOaON-H3M-00008-00002744-00002860": "rectangle to get there you know you go", "MOfOaON-H3M-00009-00002861-00003290": "over X and you go up Y so thinking about", "MOfOaON-H3M-00010-00003290-00003620": "that polar coordinates are another way", "MOfOaON-H3M-00011-00003621-00003824": "of talking about getting to a point and", "MOfOaON-H3M-00012-00003825-00004057": "polar coordinates involve some sort of", "MOfOaON-H3M-00013-00004058-00004229": "angle some rotation we'll call it theta", "MOfOaON-H3M-00014-00004230-00004475": "and then some distance R so you turn", "MOfOaON-H3M-00015-00004476-00004709": "that that distance or I'm sorry you turn", "MOfOaON-H3M-00016-00004710-00004864": "that rotation data and then you go that", "MOfOaON-H3M-00017-00004865-00005129": "distance R and so these are written in", "MOfOaON-H3M-00018-00005130-00005456": "the form R theta", "MOfOaON-H3M-00019-00005457-00005688": "so the question is how do we go back and", "MOfOaON-H3M-00020-00005689-00005988": "forth between them so one thing that I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00021-00005989-00006186": "noticed just right off the bat with", "MOfOaON-H3M-00022-00006187-00006522": "these is that if I make this distance", "MOfOaON-H3M-00023-00006523-00006744": "here if our theta and X Y are in the", "MOfOaON-H3M-00024-00006745-00006821": "same spot", "MOfOaON-H3M-00025-00006822-00006981": "there's my R so I can tell right away", "MOfOaON-H3M-00026-00006981-00007188": "that x squared plus y squared equals R", "MOfOaON-H3M-00027-00007189-00007386": "bird", "MOfOaON-H3M-00028-00007387-00007551": "you", "MOfOaON-H3M-00029-00007552-00007908": "I also know that if I go over X if this", "MOfOaON-H3M-00030-00007909-00008277": "is my theta right here this is my fate", "MOfOaON-H3M-00031-00008278-00008670": "if I go over X that would be if our was", "MOfOaON-H3M-00032-00008671-00009035": "1 that would be cosine of theta but it", "MOfOaON-H3M-00033-00009036-00009296": "if ours not one it's kind of scaled that", "MOfOaON-H3M-00034-00009297-00009528": "so it'd be R times cosine theta and I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00035-00009529-00009671": "also know height this sine so I know", "MOfOaON-H3M-00036-00009672-00010053": "that this side is our sine theta so I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00037-00010054-00010404": "also know that that x equals R cosine", "MOfOaON-H3M-00038-00010405-00011083": "theta and y equals R sine theta", "MOfOaON-H3M-00039-00011084-00011501": "and one other thing I know here if I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00040-00011502-00011852": "have this this data right here tangent", "MOfOaON-H3M-00041-00011853-00012311": "of that angle is opposite over adjacent", "MOfOaON-H3M-00042-00012312-00012659": "or Y over X so that means that theta I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00043-00012660-00012884": "could get at theta by using the inverse", "MOfOaON-H3M-00044-00012885-00013199": "tangent of Y over X so there's kind of", "MOfOaON-H3M-00045-00013200-00013484": "all my my pieces so let me go one way", "MOfOaON-H3M-00046-00013485-00013871": "first if I had a rectangular point let's", "MOfOaON-H3M-00047-00013872-00014149": "just say it was three negative four", "MOfOaON-H3M-00048-00014150-00014322": "boo-boo-boo", "MOfOaON-H3M-00049-00014324-00014759": "sorry negative four that would be the", "MOfOaON-H3M-00050-00014760-00015134": "point here three negative four and I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00051-00015135-00015443": "want to change it into a polar which", "MOfOaON-H3M-00052-00015444-00015953": "would be R theta so one thing I know is", "MOfOaON-H3M-00053-00015954-00016526": "that R is going to be R squared is x", "MOfOaON-H3M-00054-00016527-00017114": "squared plus y squared so this is nine", "MOfOaON-H3M-00055-00017115-00017212": "plus sixteen", "MOfOaON-H3M-00056-00017213-00017713": "[Music]", "MOfOaON-H3M-00057-00017714-00017877": "so R", "MOfOaON-H3M-00058-00017878-00018672": "25 sorry about that so our must be 5 and", "MOfOaON-H3M-00059-00018673-00018951": "the other thing I know is this theta and", "MOfOaON-H3M-00060-00018952-00019173": "get that through my inverse tangent so I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00061-00019174-00019683": "go inverse tangent of negative 4 over 3", "MOfOaON-H3M-00062-00019684-00020055": "y over X let me grab my calculator and", "MOfOaON-H3M-00063-00020056-00020849": "do that", "MOfOaON-H3M-00064-00020850-00021065": "this actually gives me a value of", "MOfOaON-H3M-00065-00021066-00021365": "negative fifty three point one three", "MOfOaON-H3M-00066-00021366-00021542": "degrees and now I'm gonna have to", "MOfOaON-H3M-00067-00021543-00021833": "interpret this because like if this if", "MOfOaON-H3M-00068-00021834-00022070": "this had actually terminated here for", "MOfOaON-H3M-00069-00022071-00022244": "example if it had been the point 3", "MOfOaON-H3M-00070-00022245-00022460": "negative 4 that would have that would", "MOfOaON-H3M-00071-00022461-00022601": "have been right there's that's negative", "MOfOaON-H3M-00072-00022602-00022979": "53 degrees right there I'm 13", "MOfOaON-H3M-00073-00022980-00023258": "but it doesn't terminate here with here", "MOfOaON-H3M-00074-00023259-00023447": "so if I think about this whole line this", "MOfOaON-H3M-00075-00023448-00023710": "is 180 degrees so if I take 180 degrees", "MOfOaON-H3M-00076-00023711-00024158": "or for this case and I add it to that", "MOfOaON-H3M-00077-00024159-00024479": "inverse tangent that I got negative 50", "MOfOaON-H3M-00078-00024480-00024743": "3.13 that'll give me the actual angle", "MOfOaON-H3M-00079-00024744-00024992": "that this terminates to so add 180 to", "MOfOaON-H3M-00080-00024993-00025406": "that and it looks like that is 126 about", "MOfOaON-H3M-00081-00025407-00025802": "about that point 8 7 so my R theta would", "MOfOaON-H3M-00082-00025802-00026350": "be five 126 point eight seven degrees", "MOfOaON-H3M-00083-00026351-00026567": "okay how about going the other way how", "MOfOaON-H3M-00084-00026568-00026717": "about if I have an R theta and I want to", "MOfOaON-H3M-00085-00026718-00027100": "turn it into XY so let's say I had I", "MOfOaON-H3M-00086-00027101-00027664": "don't know the point seven two hundred", "MOfOaON-H3M-00087-00027666-00028183": "degrees", "MOfOaON-H3M-00088-00028185-00028439": "so at 200° is somewhere around here", "MOfOaON-H3M-00089-00028441-00028731": "seven is that distance right there so", "MOfOaON-H3M-00090-00028732-00028889": "here's my relationship right here I know", "MOfOaON-H3M-00091-00028891-00029333": "that X is seven times cosine two degrees", "MOfOaON-H3M-00092-00029335-00029520": "and notice this is going to take care of", "MOfOaON-H3M-00093-00029520-00029655": "my negatives and positives there's", "MOfOaON-H3M-00094-00029656-00029922": "there's no no extra piece I have to do", "MOfOaON-H3M-00095-00029923-00030111": "like I had to do with the tangent this", "MOfOaON-H3M-00096-00030112-00030207": "will give me the answers right away", "MOfOaON-H3M-00097-00030208-00030561": "seven sine of two hundred degrees so if", "MOfOaON-H3M-00098-00030562-00030948": "I do those on my calculator seven cosine", "MOfOaON-H3M-00099-00030949-00031377": "of two hundred degrees", "MOfOaON-H3M-00100-00031377-00031802": "it's about negative six point five eight", "MOfOaON-H3M-00101-00031803-00032124": "there's my x value and my Y value would", "MOfOaON-H3M-00102-00032125-00032562": "be seven fine it's 100 degrees which is", "MOfOaON-H3M-00103-00032563-00032915": "about negative two point three nine", "MOfOaON-H3M-00104-00032916-00033120": "which looks right you know that's in", "MOfOaON-H3M-00105-00033121-00033217": "that third quadrant they're both", "MOfOaON-H3M-00106-00033218-00033465": "negative so there's a there's how to go", "MOfOaON-H3M-00107-00033466-00033624": "back with back and forth with the points", "MOfOaON-H3M-00108-00033625-00033840": "between"}}, {"audio_id": "MOip5pnONhy", "text": {"MOip5pnONhy-00000-00000000-00000191": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00001-00000192-00000438": "okay so uh the first thing you gotta do", "MOip5pnONhy-00002-00000440-00000695": "inside i think uh", "MOip5pnONhy-00003-00000696-00000823": "you're gonna get this round you're", "MOip5pnONhy-00004-00000824-00001015": "specifically going to have to book a new", "MOip5pnONhy-00005-00001016-00001383": "game", "MOip5pnONhy-00006-00001384-00001582": "it only lasts until about act two and", "MOip5pnONhy-00007-00001583-00001782": "then you have to pick another person but", "MOip5pnONhy-00008-00001784-00001879": "uh", "MOip5pnONhy-00009-00001880-00002055": "you just", "MOip5pnONhy-00010-00002056-00002297": "do skip on scene text and actually", "MOip5pnONhy-00011-00002298-00002518": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00012-00002519-00002750": "so the main game goes as normal you know", "MOip5pnONhy-00013-00002751-00002950": "you skip through everything that just", "MOip5pnONhy-00014-00002951-00003199": "you know if you watch the old videos you", "MOip5pnONhy-00015-00003200-00003383": "will understand the game it is a horror", "MOip5pnONhy-00016-00003384-00003743": "game so uh just a warning", "MOip5pnONhy-00017-00003744-00003911": "if you want to see the new content", "MOip5pnONhy-00018-00003911-00004104": "you're probably going to have to", "MOip5pnONhy-00019-00004105-00004295": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00020-00004296-00004447": "now the thing is you're going to have to", "MOip5pnONhy-00021-00004448-00004879": "write a good poem for sayori", "MOip5pnONhy-00022-00004880-00005238": "now boop it's hard [__] okay", "MOip5pnONhy-00023-00005239-00005495": "there has to be something that", "MOip5pnONhy-00024-00005496-00005838": "okay", "MOip5pnONhy-00025-00005839-00006151": "giggle might", "MOip5pnONhy-00026-00006152-00006406": "play might get her okay", "MOip5pnONhy-00027-00006408-00006591": "i think she likes all the", "MOip5pnONhy-00028-00006592-00006695": "nice", "MOip5pnONhy-00029-00006695-00006991": "bubbles [__]", "MOip5pnONhy-00030-00006992-00007452": "does she like excitement okay", "MOip5pnONhy-00031-00007453-00007814": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00032-00007815-00008014": "[__]", "MOip5pnONhy-00033-00008015-00008142": "funny", "MOip5pnONhy-00034-00008143-00008759": "are you serious why do you like these", "MOip5pnONhy-00035-00008760-00008935": "[__]", "MOip5pnONhy-00036-00008936-00009646": "sugar", "MOip5pnONhy-00037-00009647-00009774": "amazing", "MOip5pnONhy-00038-00009775-00009877": "childhood", "MOip5pnONhy-00039-00009878-00010838": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00040-00010839-00011438": "lucky probably", "MOip5pnONhy-00041-00011439-00011535": "cry", "MOip5pnONhy-00042-00011536-00011838": "there we go we got our words", "MOip5pnONhy-00043-00011839-00012231": "hi again boy", "MOip5pnONhy-00044-00012232-00013430": "okay so i think this is", "MOip5pnONhy-00045-00013431-00013935": "do", "MOip5pnONhy-00046-00013936-00014751": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00047-00014752-00014927": "oh yeah here it is", "MOip5pnONhy-00048-00014928-00015143": "you'll need to get used to it don't say", "MOip5pnONhy-00049-00015144-00015407": "that out loud i glanced over my", "MOip5pnONhy-00050-00015408-00015607": "shoulders", "MOip5pnONhy-00051-00015608-00015758": "it's true though", "MOip5pnONhy-00052-00015759-00016030": "yeah i know i know there's nothing to", "MOip5pnONhy-00053-00016031-00016350": "say", "MOip5pnONhy-00054-00016351-00016494": "that's a problem", "MOip5pnONhy-00055-00016495-00016711": "what about you oops", "MOip5pnONhy-00056-00016712-00016855": "how could you be better than you always", "MOip5pnONhy-00057-00016856-00017150": "have for yourself go over to everyday", "MOip5pnONhy-00058-00017151-00019671": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00059-00019672-00019898": "okay", "MOip5pnONhy-00060-00019899-00020512": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00061-00020513-00021445": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00062-00021446-00021743": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00063-00021744-00021992": "do", "MOip5pnONhy-00064-00021993-00022967": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00065-00022968-00023259": "do", "MOip5pnONhy-00066-00023260-00023959": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00067-00023960-00024543": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00068-00024544-00026790": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00069-00026791-00027148": "uh", "MOip5pnONhy-00070-00027149-00028558": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00071-00028560-00029067": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00072-00029068-00029937": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00073-00029938-00032167": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00074-00032168-00032358": "different times", "MOip5pnONhy-00075-00032360-00032527": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00076-00032527-00032727": "man i'm depressed that yuri doesn't like", "MOip5pnONhy-00077-00032727-00032918": "my phone", "MOip5pnONhy-00078-00032919-00033135": "that saddens me", "MOip5pnONhy-00079-00033136-00033527": "saddens me way too much", "MOip5pnONhy-00080-00033528-00033735": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00081-00033736-00033895": "to get through the sale or you're out", "MOip5pnONhy-00082-00033896-00034071": "you're gonna see their fight their fight", "MOip5pnONhy-00083-00034072-00034213": "happens", "MOip5pnONhy-00084-00034214-00035159": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00085-00035160-00035390": "say ari", "MOip5pnONhy-00086-00035391-00035495": "yeah", "MOip5pnONhy-00087-00035496-00035718": "everyone's fighting i mean", "MOip5pnONhy-00088-00035719-00035895": "everyone's fighting is making sayori", "MOip5pnONhy-00089-00035896-00036223": "uncomfortable", "MOip5pnONhy-00090-00036224-00037207": "they're still fighting", "MOip5pnONhy-00091-00037208-00039473": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00092-00039474-00039686": "[Applause]", "MOip5pnONhy-00093-00039687-00042343": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00094-00042344-00042658": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00095-00042659-00044846": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00096-00044847-00045095": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00097-00045096-00047711": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00098-00047712-00050015": "let's uh", "MOip5pnONhy-00099-00050016-00050302": "[Applause]", "MOip5pnONhy-00100-00050303-00050470": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00101-00050471-00050990": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00102-00050991-00051230": "okay so this is just a normal scene", "MOip5pnONhy-00103-00051232-00051335": "where", "MOip5pnONhy-00104-00051336-00051526": "she gets a cookie smacked against her", "MOip5pnONhy-00105-00051527-00052375": "face", "MOip5pnONhy-00106-00052376-00052626": "okay so this is the new scene", "MOip5pnONhy-00107-00052627-00052838": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00108-00052839-00053030": "basically they go to get like shot from", "MOip5pnONhy-00109-00053032-00053359": "another classroom", "MOip5pnONhy-00110-00053360-00054350": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00111-00054351-00054671": "then she already fell and", "MOip5pnONhy-00112-00054672-00055126": "hurt her head and hurt her forehead", "MOip5pnONhy-00113-00055127-00055271": "and it hurts", "MOip5pnONhy-00114-00055272-00055463": "and", "MOip5pnONhy-00115-00055464-00055774": "she decided to put a", "MOip5pnONhy-00116-00055775-00057615": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00117-00057616-00057871": "then you got her apple", "MOip5pnONhy-00118-00057872-00058204": "you know that she likes apple juice", "MOip5pnONhy-00119-00058204-00060339": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00120-00060340-00061606": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00121-00061607-00061921": "time", "MOip5pnONhy-00122-00061922-00063404": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00123-00063405-00063782": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00124-00063783-00064197": "she end up liking your poems", "MOip5pnONhy-00125-00064198-00064254": "[Applause]", "MOip5pnONhy-00126-00064254-00065111": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00127-00065112-00065571": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00128-00065572-00066671": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00129-00066672-00067256": "do", "MOip5pnONhy-00130-00067257-00067814": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00131-00067815-00068015": "[Applause]", "MOip5pnONhy-00132-00068016-00068142": "um", "MOip5pnONhy-00133-00068143-00069231": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00134-00069232-00069431": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00135-00069432-00070926": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00136-00070927-00071279": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00137-00071280-00071827": "okay", "MOip5pnONhy-00138-00071828-00072584": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00139-00072585-00073335": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00140-00073336-00073438": "so", "MOip5pnONhy-00141-00073439-00075015": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00142-00075016-00075238": "and if you try to pick sayori that goes", "MOip5pnONhy-00143-00075239-00075487": "to their house", "MOip5pnONhy-00144-00075488-00075631": "you have to pick one of the girls i'm", "MOip5pnONhy-00145-00075632-00075838": "just gonna make that suitcase already", "MOip5pnONhy-00146-00075839-00076071": "been to her house before", "MOip5pnONhy-00147-00076072-00076292": "it was kind of creepy to be honest", "MOip5pnONhy-00148-00076293-00076735": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00149-00076736-00076894": "then", "MOip5pnONhy-00150-00076895-00077094": "sayori tells you about the depression", "MOip5pnONhy-00151-00077095-00077432": "thing", "MOip5pnONhy-00152-00077433-00077967": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00153-00077968-00078191": "then you get busy in the bacon cupcakes", "MOip5pnONhy-00154-00078192-00078343": "and rough housing but it looks a little", "MOip5pnONhy-00155-00078344-00078479": "bit sus", "MOip5pnONhy-00156-00078480-00078590": "in", "MOip5pnONhy-00157-00078591-00079903": "[Music]", "MOip5pnONhy-00158-00079904-00080135": "hugged you then you go to school next", "MOip5pnONhy-00159-00080136-00080238": "day i'm pretty sure you know what's", "MOip5pnONhy-00160-00080239-00080488": "coming"}}, {"audio_id": "MOy_ygwAA1u", "text": {"MOy_ygwAA1u-00000-00000042-00003340": "foreign", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00001-00003342-00004104": "okay", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00002-00004105-00004493": "should I start or do you think we should", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00003-00004494-00004588": "wait", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00004-00004589-00005261": "a bit feel a bit more", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00005-00005262-00005404": "start", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00006-00005405-00005575": "equally arrive", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00007-00005576-00006077": "okay so hello everybody Welcome to our", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00008-00006078-00006204": "presentation", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00009-00006205-00006617": "that will be focusing on uh not much", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00010-00006618-00006917": "results but just the problems of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00011-00006918-00007175": "simulating propagation of cryptocurrency", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00012-00007176-00007369": "transactions", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00013-00007370-00007823": "I am the second author in that uh in the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00014-00007823-00008219": "role martial Marek and also my colleague", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00015-00008220-00008531": "Vladimir yazabeck is here as well", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00016-00008532-00008896": "he just Waits at you and you might have", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00017-00008897-00009209": "heard Vladimir Vasily yesterday doing", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00018-00009210-00009491": "the the same presentation in the in the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00019-00009492-00009724": "small group", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00020-00009725-00010049": "so all right", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00021-00010050-00010391": "now uh just small introduction who we", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00022-00010392-00010889": "are we are sort of uh sitting on two", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00023-00010890-00011281": "chairs uh at once one is the net search", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00024-00011282-00011741": "limited uh uh unlimited company uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00025-00011742-00011987": "established in 2015 as a university", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00026-00011988-00012137": "spin-off", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00027-00012138-00012383": "and that's the second chair that we are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00028-00012384-00012742": "sitting in is the uh berno University of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00029-00012743-00013001": "Technology where we provide everyone", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00030-00013002-00013229": "that is part of the company studied or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00031-00013230-00013721": "still studying either Masters or PhD and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00032-00013722-00014021": "doing uh a little bit of research and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00033-00014022-00014297": "development a little bit of production", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00034-00014297-00014669": "uh product development mainly for law", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00035-00014669-00014951": "enforcement agencies you can find out", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00036-00014952-00015372": "more at the URL", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00037-00015373-00015707": "uh what are the areas of interest is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00038-00015708-00015911": "that we do cryptocurrency forensics", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00039-00015912-00016241": "that's going to be uh tightly connected", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00040-00016241-00016522": "uh topic that I will be presenting today", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00041-00016523-00016847": "we also do some password cracking and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00042-00016848-00017158": "traffic interception although we are not", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00043-00017159-00017453": "going to need a traffic interception in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00044-00017454-00017749": "the same sense uh in this presentation", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00045-00017750-00018149": "but it's also connected because we will", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00046-00018150-00018430": "be talking about monitoring Network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00047-00018431-00018857": "traffic to get some off-chain metadata", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00048-00018858-00019217": "for the crypto crypto forensics", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00049-00019218-00019589": "uh so yeah again what's the agenda and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00050-00019590-00019894": "goal of this presentation is to to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00051-00019895-00020044": "present the state-of-the-art of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00052-00020045-00020285": "blockchain forensics present the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00053-00020286-00020536": "challenging challenges and existing", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00054-00020537-00020755": "simulators that are capable of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00055-00020756-00021100": "simulating Bitcoin or or uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00056-00021101-00021336": "cryptocurrency in general", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00057-00021337-00021743": "and then we will focus on a way how to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00058-00021744-00022121": "exploit Bitcoin peer-to-peer Network to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00059-00022122-00022511": "God gather some additional data and then", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00060-00022512-00022949": "we will talk about the cry Sim the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00061-00022950-00023303": "hopefully uh outcoming simulator that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00062-00023304-00023603": "will be the the goal the the result of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00063-00023604-00023849": "uh of our project", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00064-00023850-00024136": "but yeah I can mention this presentation", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00065-00024137-00024413": "is going to be focused on the state of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00066-00024414-00024683": "the art what are the problems and what", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00067-00024684-00025085": "are the uh outline goals uh how to uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00068-00025086-00025363": "how to achieve it but not so much on the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00069-00025364-00025817": "resulting uh simulator not just yet", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00070-00025818-00026105": "and what is possible yes uh we will go", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00071-00026106-00026327": "ahead and talk about what is possible uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00072-00026327-00026518": "actually to to get from the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00073-00026519-00026755": "cryptocurrency peer and transaction", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00074-00026756-00027155": "geolocation and talk about what uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00075-00027156-00027611": "simulation simulators actually exist", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00076-00027612-00027929": "uh what is the state of the art so just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00077-00027930-00028258": "to give you brief interaction into the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00078-00028260-00028649": "world of cryptocurrency here we have a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00079-00028650-00029045": "Bitcoin Network it's uh very similar for", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00080-00029045-00029423": "all the existing cryptocurrencies but", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00081-00029424-00029767": "there might be slight uh slide uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00082-00029768-00030118": "details that are different but in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00083-00030119-00030370": "general they work very much very much", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00084-00030372-00030605": "the same so you have a peer-to-peer", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00085-00030606-00031043": "network of nodes that constitutes the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00086-00031044-00031361": "Bitcoin uh Bitcoin Network you might", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00087-00031362-00031679": "have some uh Norm by the way can you see", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00088-00031680-00032135": "my cursor can you see the mouse", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00089-00032136-00032507": "yes we can see okay because I cannot", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00090-00032508-00032693": "paint because I don't have a touch", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00091-00032694-00032933": "screen as Vladimir did yesterday so just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00092-00032934-00033112": "to highlight it with uh with the mouse", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00093-00033113-00033352": "so in this slide you can see the peer", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00094-00033353-00033496": "triple Network there are two different", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00095-00033497-00033935": "types of nodes when you are either just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00096-00033936-00034217": "a normal user that basically wants to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00097-00034218-00034517": "just use the network to send the uh send", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00098-00034518-00034817": "a transaction or received some some", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00099-00034818-00035093": "funds then you have specialized nodes", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00100-00035094-00035495": "that serve the purpose of mining that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00101-00035496-00035759": "actually generate the the blocks and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00102-00035760-00036071": "validate the transaction Etc and all of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00103-00036072-00036317": "them are connected together into a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00104-00036318-00036677": "peer-to-peer network if you want to send", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00105-00036678-00037018": "money to to somebody you're gonna use", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00106-00037019-00037339": "some uh some application", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00107-00037340-00037667": "that is able to say how much you want to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00108-00037668-00037937": "send you might add some Edition label", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00109-00037938-00038195": "and then you specify the the receiver", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00110-00038196-00038567": "address and just issue the money if you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00111-00038568-00038818": "want to be the The Miner then you need", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00112-00038819-00039143": "additional dedicated uh software that's", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00113-00039144-00039443": "actually validating the transaction and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00114-00039444-00039773": "basically putting them into a single", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00115-00039774-00040115": "block and then propagating them to to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00116-00040116-00040273": "the network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00117-00040274-00040721": "and then what you get out of it is a for", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00118-00040722-00040895": "example transaction like this when you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00119-00040896-00041237": "have some input address you have the the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00120-00041238-00041489": "value of the input and then you have", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00121-00041490-00041855": "multiple addresses on the output and the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00122-00041856-00042155": "specific value of of that output you can", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00123-00042156-00042377": "also have multiple addresses on the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00124-00042378-00042707": "input side as well that's sort of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00125-00042708-00042977": "one of the differences between a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00126-00042978-00043357": "transaction that you are used to from", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00127-00043358-00043811": "your normal transaction AKA Fiat money", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00128-00043812-00044129": "transfer you would usually when I would", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00129-00044130-00044471": "be sending uh some money to Vladimir I", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00130-00044472-00044735": "would be on the sender side and Vladimir", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00131-00044736-00044945": "would be on the receiver side so there", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00132-00044946-00045155": "will be just two of us but in Bitcoin", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00133-00045156-00045389": "you can have multiple input side on the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00134-00045390-00045689": "input and multiple entities on the on", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00135-00045690-00045961": "the output", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00136-00045962-00046205": "what's uh yeah what constitutes the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00137-00046206-00046421": "cryptocurrency intelligence you can", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00138-00046422-00046702": "separate it into a three parts the first", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00139-00046703-00047021": "one is blockchain forensics there you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00140-00047022-00047327": "have the cryptocurrency address there oh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00141-00047328-00047627": "sorry I wanted to highlight it uh that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00142-00047628-00048058": "identifies the uh the address the the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00143-00048059-00048311": "wallet that holds the or that is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00144-00048312-00048552": "associated with with the funds", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00145-00048553-00048821": "then you have the cryptocurrency", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00146-00048822-00049193": "transactions which is identified by uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00147-00049194-00049457": "by a hash that identifies the the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00148-00049458-00049852": "transactions which uh consists of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00149-00049853-00050207": "inputs and outputs uh the unspent", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00150-00050208-00050489": "transaction uh uh onstand transaction", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00151-00050490-00050818": "outputs on the input side and on the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00152-00050819-00050968": "output side", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00153-00050969-00051557": "then in the off chain data you have some", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00154-00051558-00051779": "open and closed Source intelligence", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00155-00051779-00052144": "either by scraping web pages uh either", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00156-00052145-00052385": "public internet and dark net or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00157-00052386-00052691": "monitoring social networks or some", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00158-00052691-00052876": "locally available information I would", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00159-00052877-00053057": "say from the cloud Source intelligence", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00160-00053058-00053321": "meaning that the law enforcement agency", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00161-00053322-00053704": "have some additional data that can as", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00162-00053705-00053980": "they can associate with either a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00163-00053982-00054203": "transaction hash or either with", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00164-00054204-00054400": "cryptocurrency address maybe because", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00165-00054401-00054779": "some victim reported to them that they", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00166-00054779-00055019": "have been scammed Etc so they can mark", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00167-00055020-00055307": "the addresses and transaction in the in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00168-00055308-00055571": "the blockchain with additional data", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00169-00055572-00055997": "and the third part is by monitoring the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00170-00055998-00056326": "peer-to-peer Network you can uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00171-00056327-00056699": "basically associate the uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00172-00056700-00056909": "uh inventory the data that is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00173-00056910-00057203": "transferred between the the nodes with", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00174-00057204-00057587": "IP address and record it all recorded", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00175-00057588-00057838": "all into a pickup file even maybe for", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00176-00057839-00058307": "later analysis and Etc here you can see", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00177-00058308-00058750": "just a example of the metadata that you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00178-00058751-00059080": "are able to to store because if you're", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00179-00059082-00059315": "monitoring the network Active network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00180-00059316-00059669": "communication you can see the start of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00181-00059670-00059879": "the activity you can see the end of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00182-00059879-00060154": "activity there's also user agent that is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00183-00060155-00060485": "sending uh that the node is sending", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00184-00060486-00060821": "protocol version and services that the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00185-00060822-00061037": "node is offering", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00186-00061038-00061369": "and you can monitor that for maybe later", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00187-00061370-00061709": "for a additional source of identifying", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00188-00061710-00062153": "the the notes and the originator of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00189-00062154-00062375": "transaction but we will get uh to that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00190-00062376-00062663": "in more detail later", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00191-00062664-00062915": "so what can be or what are the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00192-00062916-00063179": "investigative goals usually if you are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00193-00063179-00063371": "law enforcement agency you are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00194-00063372-00063611": "investigating some crimes so who has", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00195-00063612-00063773": "committed the crime who is the real", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00196-00063774-00063971": "person behind the cryptocurrency address", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00197-00063972-00064271": "or a transaction and what device", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00198-00064272-00064499": "originated cryptocurrency transaction", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00199-00064500-00064775": "because if you can do uh I mean if you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00200-00064776-00064919": "can do the real person that's probably", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00201-00064920-00065230": "your end goal then you're fine but even", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00202-00065232-00065615": "to be able to identify the device of uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00203-00065616-00065849": "of the originator that can help you a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00204-00065850-00066100": "lot because then you might use another", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00205-00066101-00066491": "tool not necessarily uh crypto tracking", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00206-00066492-00066694": "tools but some other ways how to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00207-00066695-00067073": "identify who this device belong to and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00208-00067074-00067349": "also there is money associated with the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00209-00067350-00067625": "crime now uh basically to monitor how", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00210-00067626-00067888": "the funds transfer through the through", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00211-00067889-00068111": "the network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00212-00068112-00068447": "so doing just blockchain uh blockchain", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00213-00068448-00068719": "forensics if you know the entry point", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00214-00068720-00069119": "and you have uh information about the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00215-00069120-00069347": "exit point then you are able to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00216-00069348-00069700": "backtrack uh the uh information in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00217-00069701-00069994": "between because the blockchain is uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00218-00069995-00070243": "blockchain is public so you can actually", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00219-00070244-00070631": "go through the inner transaction and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00220-00070632-00070871": "figure out through what exchange or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00221-00070872-00071153": "through what service it went and who pay", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00222-00071154-00071237": "what", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00223-00071238-00071500": "that's not a problem the issue is how to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00224-00071501-00071806": "actually put a real name to to this long", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00225-00071807-00072137": "uh to this long string which is sort of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00226-00072138-00072419": "cellular anonymous", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00227-00072420-00072815": "uh this is just a sort of view what uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00228-00072816-00073019": "kind of information you can associate", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00229-00073020-00073225": "with an address", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00230-00073226-00073517": "uh but yeah I'll just skip through this", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00231-00073518-00073732": "basically by using the open source", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00232-00073733-00073991": "intelligence you can scrape the this", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00233-00073992-00074488": "Bitcoin address to a Bitcoin forum and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00234-00074489-00074723": "if you are so lucky then you would get a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00235-00074724-00075065": "photo of the owner and you can you might", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00236-00075066-00075323": "use the the photo uh to to basically", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00237-00075324-00075629": "scan through your amazing maybe", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00238-00075630-00076006": "government uh documents and see who that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00239-00076007-00076205": "might be but this is rarely the case", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00240-00076206-00076415": "that you would get a photo with the uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00241-00076416-00076600": "Bitcoin address", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00242-00076601-00076985": "you can also use some uh other analytics", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00243-00076986-00077291": "to see what kind of behavior the the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00244-00077292-00077597": "address uh is doing but I would say it's", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00245-00077598-00077838": "not really really irrelevant to our case", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00246-00077839-00078203": "usually the address is part of a cluster", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00247-00078204-00078532": "or you can call it a wallet that might", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00248-00078533-00078761": "be the the usual term that you will see", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00249-00078762-00079175": "and then basically by identifying all", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00250-00079176-00079505": "the other addresses within a wallet you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00251-00079506-00079750": "can investigate further", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00252-00079751-00080159": "but yeah in this case you see what this", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00253-00080160-00080393": "wallet actually communicated with where", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00254-00080394-00080765": "it sent money and who sent money to that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00255-00080766-00080944": "address as well", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00256-00080945-00081197": "and then yeah visualize it basically to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00257-00081198-00081629": "to track it but uh okay", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00258-00081630-00082097": "this is not the real status you cannot", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00259-00082098-00082385": "just go to the address and get", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00260-00082386-00082711": "immediately which is sort of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00261-00082712-00083249": "uh the originator and it would just work", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00262-00083250-00083644": "that okay we got an IP address of uh of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00263-00083645-00083944": "the source it's not that easy", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00264-00083945-00084305": "because as the uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00265-00084306-00084587": "peer-to-peer network is working the way", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00266-00084588-00084847": "how uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00267-00084848-00085309": "the uh for example uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00268-00085310-00085588": "transactions are mined or the blocks are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00269-00085589-00085847": "mine that you you as a single user uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00270-00085848-00086153": "nowadays are not able to compete uh with", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00271-00086154-00086387": "the mining pool so you are not able to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00272-00086388-00086729": "actually mine the the the the next block", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00273-00086730-00086921": "so you group together with another", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00274-00086922-00087299": "miners to form a mining pool and then", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00275-00087300-00087629": "when you mind the block the address that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00276-00087630-00087935": "is associated with the rewards for the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00277-00087936-00088223": "mining does not represent a single user", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00278-00088224-00088517": "but it represents the the mining proof", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00279-00088518-00088955": "plus different uh uh mining pools uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00280-00088956-00089303": "uses the different uh mining protocol so", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00281-00089304-00089537": "it's difficult to to monitor all of them", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00282-00089538-00089800": "because uh yeah they constantly change", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00283-00089801-00090268": "it also not every note if you see the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00284-00090269-00090605": "the notes marked as a user uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00285-00090606-00090988": "or not every device not every user can", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00286-00090989-00091259": "actually be the the full node because", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00287-00091260-00091553": "for Bitcoin you need almost 500", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00288-00091554-00091787": "gigabytes of data to be able to verify", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00289-00091788-00092015": "the transaction to be able to send a new", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00290-00092016-00092255": "transaction out so in terms of mobile", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00291-00092256-00092561": "devices this is an unrealistic that you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00292-00092562-00092776": "would download how to turn up data just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00293-00092777-00093053": "to be able to pay for an ice cream so", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00294-00093054-00093359": "you get some other uh devices that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00295-00093360-00093821": "basically Outsource this uh to to a full", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00296-00093822-00094073": "node and you use just a some light", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00297-00094074-00094438": "client that enables you to generate the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00298-00094439-00094625": "transaction and send it to somebody who", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00299-00094626-00094853": "have the full blockchain and that will", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00300-00094854-00095068": "actually do the transaction", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00301-00095069-00095425": "and again there are different uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00302-00095426-00095776": "protocols that do the communication with", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00303-00095777-00096149": "the backbone with the full full node", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00304-00096150-00096467": "yeah for the back kitchen backbone and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00305-00096468-00096893": "doing even one level more because the uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00306-00096894-00097247": "Bitcoin network is able to do only five", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00307-00097248-00097571": "transactions per second so nowadays you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00308-00097572-00097865": "have some layer 2 protocols in this case", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00309-00097866-00098044": "lightning protocol", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00310-00098045-00098488": "that basically is able to do the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00311-00098489-00098831": "transactions out of the the blockchain", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00312-00098832-00099149": "out of the public Ledger and you just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00313-00099150-00099415": "doing uh some", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00314-00099416-00099923": "transactions between the between oh yeah", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00315-00099924-00100138": "let's use the example previous I want to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00316-00100139-00100468": "send money to Vladimir but maybe I'm", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00317-00100469-00100729": "buying an ice cream from him every day", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00318-00100730-00101123": "and because I trust him I will open the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00319-00101124-00101459": "transaction and keep it open maybe for a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00320-00101460-00101681": "whole month because every day I will", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00321-00101682-00102041": "come there and spend just a few cents", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00322-00102042-00102299": "for the for the ice cream so it's not", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00323-00102300-00102599": "necessary for us to pay a huge fee just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00324-00102600-00103073": "a small amount and once either we decide", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00325-00103074-00103330": "that we want to close the the account or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00326-00103331-00103553": "how we want to call it the transaction I", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00327-00103554-00103744": "no longer want to buy ice cream from", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00328-00103745-00103973": "Vladimir so it's not necessary to keep", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00329-00103974-00104260": "the tab open or Vladimir maybe doesn't", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00330-00104261-00104573": "believe me that I will pay it or maybe", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00331-00104574-00104836": "he's just closing shop so at any point", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00332-00104838-00105178": "of time using the Litecoin uh Litecoin", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00333-00105179-00105497": "sorry lightning Network he can terminate", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00334-00105498-00105754": "the transaction and send it back to the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00335-00105755-00106115": "layer one so it will actually reflect in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00336-00106116-00106486": "the blockchain and it will be a legit uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00337-00106488-00106828": "Bitcoin transaction but until that point", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00338-00106829-00107201": "we can handle all our transactions just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00339-00107202-00107428": "between us and since this is sort of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00340-00107429-00107621": "local transactions because it's standing", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00341-00107622-00107951": "only between uh node one and two which", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00342-00107952-00108251": "would be me and Vladimir we don't need", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00343-00108252-00108454": "to propagate the information throughout", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00344-00108455-00108736": "the blockchain etc etc and sync it then", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00345-00108738-00109049": "it's much much faster and it's also much", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00346-00109050-00109313": "more scalable you can have much much", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00347-00109314-00109678": "more transaction pair per second and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00348-00109679-00109919": "then only once you want to finalize the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00349-00109920-00110723": "the transaction or finalize some uh some", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00350-00110724-00111028": "exchange then you send the information", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00351-00111029-00111323": "back to the layer one to the Bitcoin and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00352-00111324-00111671": "propagate it to the normal Bitcoin uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00353-00111672-00111940": "Bitcoin flow but the benefit is that you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00354-00111941-00112204": "can actually avoid the the big fee and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00355-00112205-00112439": "also avoid the I would say small", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00356-00112440-00112775": "throughput of transactions per second", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00357-00112776-00113033": "and like I said this is just one example", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00358-00113033-00113266": "of the layer two protocols there can be", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00359-00113267-00113560": "multiple multiple of them so again you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00360-00113561-00113819": "add another difficulty basically what", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00361-00113820-00114052": "kind of protocols you need to be able to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00362-00114053-00114275": "understand to be able to monitor the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00363-00114276-00114449": "network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00364-00114450-00114784": "and yeah this is a one side there is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00365-00114785-00114971": "actually doing that to monitor the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00366-00114972-00115265": "network it's 1ml.com you can visit", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00367-00115266-00115536": "yourself and see see the details how the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00368-00115538-00115834": "lightning network works", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00369-00115835-00116189": "leveling up even more here you can see", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00370-00116190-00116615": "how many cryptocurrencies are currently", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00371-00116616-00116927": "uh currently exist and just to say", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00372-00116928-00117178": "there's a lot of them to be able to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00373-00117179-00117436": "understand and actually write a packet", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00374-00117438-00117701": "decoder for all of them that is a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00375-00117702-00118007": "basically each of them could be a task", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00376-00118008-00118301": "for a dedicated team so it's unrealistic", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00377-00118302-00118463": "to be able to do it as sort of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00378-00118464-00118708": "researcher or even a company to be able", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00379-00118709-00118925": "to understand all of them", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00380-00118926-00119358": "here you have a list of a simulators", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00381-00119359-00119813": "that support a Bitcoin uh Bitcoin", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00382-00119814-00120095": "protocol and I would say at various uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00383-00120096-00120257": "various levels", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00384-00120258-00120701": "and but they are usually uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00385-00120702-00121108": "uh focused only on a a single task or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00386-00121109-00121536": "and they don't really offer some general", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00387-00121538-00121852": "generalized uh generalized use cases to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00388-00121853-00122254": "be able uh for example to answer our", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00389-00122255-00122704": "research question of identifying or the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00390-00122705-00123065": "originator of a transaction of a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00391-00123066-00123358": "transaction and match it with the geolo", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00392-00123359-00123702": "geolocation metadata", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00393-00123703-00124193": "okay now going to say more detail more", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00394-00124194-00124595": "the the meat of of this presentation uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00395-00124596-00124834": "what we actually want to do how to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00396-00124835-00125008": "exploit the Bitcoin peer-to-peer", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00397-00125009-00125386": "protocol to get the data that we are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00398-00125388-00125633": "interested in Bitcoin protocol is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00399-00125633-00125843": "codified by Bitcoin Foundation it's", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00400-00125844-00125957": "binary", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00401-00125958-00126197": "but it's not encrypted uh you cannot", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00402-00126198-00126533": "read it just by uh sort of sniffing it", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00403-00126533-00126839": "and passing it through uh like a saving", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00404-00126840-00127097": "to a text file but just opening it by", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00405-00127098-00127343": "Bioshock you can easily see all the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00406-00127344-00127697": "messages uh that the notes are sending", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00407-00127698-00128081": "to to each other or at least to to you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00408-00128082-00128351": "uh yeah and there you can see what are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00409-00128352-00128536": "the default ports and I would say that's", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00410-00128538-00128771": "not necessary interesting", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00411-00128772-00129052": "here we have all the messages that uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00412-00129053-00129323": "exist there well the ones that are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00413-00129324-00129581": "interested for us is the inventory", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00414-00129582-00129952": "message and the get data message and the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00415-00129953-00130381": "transaction uh message", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00416-00130382-00130840": "so uh yeah Discovery I will skip this", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00417-00130841-00131152": "part you can maybe go through it uh once", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00418-00131153-00131314": "offline but it's just detailed how you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00419-00131315-00131543": "sort of spin up the notes and how you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00420-00131544-00131764": "connect to the network it's not that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00421-00131765-00132151": "interested in our topic", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00422-00132152-00132478": "uh okay connecting to node again that's", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00423-00132479-00132743": "not really what we are about here now we", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00424-00132744-00132959": "are getting to the interesting part", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00425-00132960-00133378": "imagine you have four notes node a node", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00426-00133379-00133901": "B note C note D note a have uh some uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00427-00133902-00134243": "transaction or block or some other", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00428-00134244-00134525": "information it sends the inventory to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00429-00134526-00134716": "its neighbor", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00430-00134717-00134969": "since the node B the the neighboring", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00431-00134970-00135275": "node does not have the transaction of or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00432-00135276-00135581": "block in question or in this case a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00433-00135582-00135995": "transaction it tells the node uh it", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00434-00135996-00136319": "tells the Note 8 please send me the the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00435-00136320-00136625": "transaction and node a response with the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00436-00136626-00136816": "actual transaction data", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00437-00136817-00137231": "and because node B is connected to node", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00438-00137232-00137537": "C and node D it does the same thing as", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00439-00137538-00137807": "the node a did in the first step it", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00440-00137808-00138154": "sends its neighbors information about uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00441-00138155-00138490": "the new inventory that it received", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00442-00138491-00138899": "the node C and Nod either uh sort of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00443-00138900-00139163": "discard the message or in case they", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00444-00139164-00139373": "don't have the data yet they will again", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00445-00139374-00141895": "send a data response and node B will", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00446-00141896-00142187": "yeah Marshall is stacked internet", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00447-00142188-00142421": "connection and he will be back in a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00448-00142422-00142577": "minute", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00449-00142578-00142925": "yeah this is not work yeah sorry sorry", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00450-00142926-00143195": "for that you know we are just uh company", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00451-00143196-00143411": "focused on networking so obviously we", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00452-00143412-00143628": "have network issues", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00453-00143629-00144064": "uh okay so now you can see I hope that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00454-00144065-00144352": "you caught uh this slide that how you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00455-00144353-00144593": "propagate the the transaction to to all", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00456-00144594-00144881": "the nodes and basically what we or what", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00457-00144882-00145163": "I talk about here in theory here you can", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00458-00145164-00145607": "here here you can see it in real where", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00459-00145608-00145823": "this is a communication that some nodes", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00460-00145824-00146099": "sends uh it has inventory data the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00461-00146100-00146321": "neighbors replied okay I'm interested in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00462-00146322-00146525": "this data and then the node actually", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00463-00146526-00146819": "sent the the transaction data in the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00464-00146820-00146951": "response message", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00465-00146952-00147059": "foreign", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00466-00147060-00147449": "this is sort of uh or the the way how", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00467-00147450-00147787": "you can uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00468-00147788-00148121": "utilize the the peer-to-peer Network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00469-00148122-00148331": "is that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00470-00148332-00148561": "you're gonna try to appear with everyone", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00471-00148562-00149014": "so in that case whoever sends the uh the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00472-00149015-00149278": "transaction it will send it to you as", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00473-00149279-00149531": "well because you are peering with the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00474-00149532-00149878": "note and then you can say okay this one", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00475-00149879-00150178": "is the originator of of that transaction", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00476-00150179-00150389": "within the network and since you know", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00477-00150390-00150599": "the IP address of the neighbor you can", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00478-00150600-00150851": "say okay this one is the originator of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00479-00150852-00151259": "the of the transaction but it's not that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00480-00151260-00151540": "easy first of all to be able to appear", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00481-00151541-00151828": "with everyone it takes some resources", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00482-00151829-00152128": "but it's uh yeah it's doable", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00483-00152129-00152476": "and there are already a with a service", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00484-00152477-00152890": "that is doing that they peering with all", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00485-00152891-00153095": "the notes just to be able to basically", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00486-00153096-00153311": "provide you with these statistics how", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00487-00153312-00153707": "many uh notes are in uh in what country", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00488-00153708-00153971": "and some additional additional", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00489-00153972-00154349": "statistics in details here", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00490-00154350-00154745": "there's another uh another uh research", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00491-00154746-00154973": "group that is focusing on that here you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00492-00154974-00155339": "can see basically uh the client version", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00493-00155340-00155549": "different kind version throughout time", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00494-00155550-00155771": "so you can see what's the sort of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00495-00155772-00156064": "major version or how the new version", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00496-00156065-00156383": "actually propagates through uh through", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00497-00156384-00156790": "the notes uh how fast the does the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00498-00156791-00157054": "network actually deploys the the new", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00499-00157055-00157147": "version", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00500-00157148-00157564": "here you can see the sliders so how we", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00501-00157565-00157889": "attribute the IP addresses of the notes", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00502-00157890-00158063": "that we are appearing with so you have", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00503-00158064-00158513": "some IP address you uh add the country", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00504-00158514-00158807": "code and city using the using a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00505-00158808-00159166": "geolocation database and then because", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00506-00159167-00159364": "you have IP address you can get the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00507-00159365-00159563": "autonomous system and organization", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00508-00159564-00160163": "number for the uh bgp bgp peering", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00509-00160164-00160414": "well yeah here you have example of notes", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00510-00160415-00160751": "from uh Czech Republic and together with", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00511-00160752-00161099": "a map and the activities", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00512-00161100-00161219": "Etc", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00513-00161220-00161525": "here you can see what the uh the what is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00514-00161526-00161873": "the agent and what are the services uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00515-00161874-00162202": "it's not uh your direct source of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00516-00162203-00162676": "information but you can use it to get", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00517-00162677-00163085": "additional additional data because uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00518-00163086-00163307": "yeah you can identify based on protocol", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00519-00163308-00163583": "version or use agent if there is sort of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00520-00163584-00163726": "unique enough", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00521-00163727-00164099": "and the services Etc but uh finally", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00522-00164100-00164351": "getting to to the real meat why is peer", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00523-00164352-00164495": "monitoring tricky", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00524-00164496-00164837": "because if you consider the network like", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00525-00164838-00164914": "this", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00526-00164915-00165119": "there are some nodes that might be", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00527-00165120-00165485": "behind a net there might be inside uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00528-00165486-00166054": "inside a tour or they might use VPN so", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00529-00166055-00166343": "you are not able to even connect to them", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00530-00166344-00166589": "or if you are connected to them you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00531-00166590-00166757": "don't really see their IP address in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00532-00166758-00167057": "case of the Thor Exeter so you have to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00533-00167058-00167290": "consider only the notes that you are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00534-00167291-00167687": "able to uh to actually reach that you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00535-00167688-00168016": "can connect to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00536-00168017-00168299": "um yeah currently the Bitcoin Network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00537-00168300-00168551": "now consists of about 14", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00538-00168552-00168911": "000 reachable nodes but there you have", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00539-00168912-00169102": "the unreachable notes and the estimate", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00540-00169103-00169361": "is between forty thousand and hundred", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00541-00169362-00169625": "thousand nodes that are unreachable so", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00542-00169626-00170014": "you can see how that uh the volume is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00543-00170015-00170243": "much much larger for the nodes that you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00544-00170244-00170423": "are not able to connect to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00545-00170424-00170693": "so the other way might be to basically", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00546-00170694-00170981": "generate enough notes that you force or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00547-00170982-00171299": "allow them to connect to you so you're", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00548-00171300-00171437": "not trying to connect to them but", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00549-00171438-00171707": "basically by spawning enough notes they", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00550-00171708-00172097": "will uh buy sort of a lock connect uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00551-00172098-00172421": "connect to you in this uh yeah in this", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00552-00172422-00172745": "scheme", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00553-00172746-00172966": "so what can you do if you are really", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00554-00172967-00173266": "peering with everyone you can conduct", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00555-00173267-00173489": "correlation based on time of detected", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00556-00173490-00173740": "event I didn't sort of emphasize on that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00557-00173741-00173902": "but even if you are peering with", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00558-00173903-00174016": "everyone", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00559-00174017-00174263": "there's no you're not guaranteed to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00560-00174264-00174569": "receive the trend section from the first", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00561-00174570-00174809": "from the actual originator of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00562-00174810-00175204": "transaction because it uses uh it uses", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00563-00175205-00175631": "some uh random timer to actually just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00564-00175632-00175859": "send the transaction out and we will get", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00565-00175860-00176063": "back to we will get to to that in the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00566-00176064-00176273": "next slide but yeah so you need to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00567-00176274-00176501": "conduct a correlation based off time of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00568-00176502-00176813": "the detected events if you have the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00569-00176814-00177143": "monitoring node you might see a for a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00570-00177144-00177352": "single transaction you see all the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00571-00177353-00177616": "neighboring nodes uh that sent or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00572-00177617-00177833": "propagated this transaction together", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00573-00177834-00178138": "with a with a time and if you have", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00574-00178139-00178463": "multiple uh monitoring notes you combine", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00575-00178464-00178709": "it into a single table and then you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00576-00178710-00179033": "obviously try to select the the notes", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00577-00179034-00179357": "that or the hosts that have the soonest", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00578-00179358-00179711": "time and then you try to do basically", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00579-00179712-00180059": "correlation on on top of that because", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00580-00180060-00180376": "you see the same note on many of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00581-00180377-00180664": "monitoring nodes", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00582-00180665-00180904": "and yeah then you can propagate it in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00583-00180905-00181223": "some sort of order of the IP addresses", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00584-00181224-00181504": "that you saw for that particular at the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00585-00181505-00181876": "transaction including a a time yeah here", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00586-00181877-00182069": "we have a geolocation example for", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00587-00182070-00182278": "Bitcoin address that belonging to a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00588-00182279-00182566": "Ukraine government so yeah you have uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00589-00182567-00182795": "address transaction and then you can", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00590-00182796-00183154": "sort of plot it on a map based on the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00591-00183155-00183401": "count of uh of the not based on the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00592-00183402-00183659": "number of transactions that are feeding", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00593-00183660-00184051": "into your monitoring wallet address", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00594-00184052-00184349": "again there are different algorithms how", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00595-00184350-00184823": "the transaction propagate uh whether if", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00596-00184824-00185116": "you are inbound or outbound peers so", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00597-00185117-00185314": "whether you connect it to the nodes or", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00598-00185315-00185602": "if the node connected to you the Bitcoin", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00599-00185603-00185843": "protocol uses two different approaches", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00600-00185844-00186185": "it uses poisson distribution with a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00601-00186186-00186628": "Lambda of 30 meaning that for uh each uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00602-00186629-00187081": "peer there will be a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00603-00187082-00187475": "uh event in on average in two seconds", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00604-00187476-00187714": "for the inbound peers there is a Delta", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00605-00187715-00187966": "of 12 meaning that there will be a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00606-00187967-00188375": "message in uh on average in five seconds", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00607-00188376-00188626": "how does it look like if you just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00608-00188627-00188890": "visualize the deposit distribution how", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00609-00188891-00189197": "it might look and how it actually looks", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00610-00189198-00189557": "like in terms of uh number of sent", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00611-00189558-00189671": "messages", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00612-00189672-00189904": "here you can see that for the outbound", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00613-00189905-00190264": "peers there is a sort of dedicated timer", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00614-00190265-00190588": "for each of them so you see uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00615-00190589-00190871": "throughout time when each peer received", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00616-00190872-00191159": "the message but for the inbound peers", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00617-00191160-00191537": "once the timer expires you tell it uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00618-00191538-00191740": "you send the message to to all of them", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00619-00191741-00191976": "at once", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00620-00191977-00192557": "and yeah like even if you are yeah", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00621-00192558-00192814": "in real time in real world although", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00622-00192815-00193043": "because in our testing transaction", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00623-00193044-00193276": "although you know that this one is the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00624-00193277-00193547": "real originator it just happens so that", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00625-00193548-00193769": "none of those none of the monitoring", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00626-00193770-00194140": "nodes saw the IP address as the first as", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00627-00194141-00194416": "the originator of the of the transaction", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00628-00194417-00194723": "so it's not enough just to record the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00629-00194724-00195016": "time when you saw the when you saw the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00630-00195017-00195221": "transaction propagator Network you need", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00631-00195222-00195749": "to uh apply it some uh some additional", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00632-00195750-00195893": "criteria", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00633-00195894-00196264": "uh different okay yeah why is it uh why", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00634-00196265-00196373": "is it different because each", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00635-00196374-00196661": "cryptocurrency uses a little bit uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00636-00196662-00196888": "different a little bit different code to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00637-00196889-00197188": "to actually trigger the uh the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00638-00197189-00197471": "distribution of the transactions", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00639-00197472-00197687": "uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00640-00197688-00197788": "yeah", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00641-00197789-00197987": "the distribution so you need to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00642-00197988-00198185": "basically you cannot have a generic", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00643-00198186-00198419": "solution that would cover all of the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00644-00198420-00198575": "cryptocurrencies you need to always", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00645-00198576-00198895": "tailor it for the the specific one", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00646-00198896-00199228": "and yeah so it basically described you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00647-00199229-00199625": "the research questions and now you are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00648-00199626-00199793": "wondering what is actually the the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00649-00199794-00200213": "answer the answer will be here hopefully", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00650-00200214-00200440": "in the next two months next 12 months", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00651-00200441-00200693": "sorry uh we will be presenting the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00652-00200694-00201078": "results at the next uh next omnet Summit", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00653-00201079-00201443": "that basically we will be able to answer", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00654-00201444-00201647": "the question", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00655-00201648-00202049": "are we able to actually geolocate the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00656-00202050-00202247": "transaction just from the propagation", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00657-00202248-00202787": "data or once we simulate the uh the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00658-00202788-00203050": "Bitcoin propagation Network or Bitcoin", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00659-00203051-00203357": "transaction propagation uh Network we", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00660-00203358-00203663": "might determine that just based on the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00661-00203664-00203975": "uh Randomness based on the statistics", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00662-00203976-00204233": "you are not able to correlate the data", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00663-00204234-00204611": "with a IP address that would uh sort of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00664-00204612-00204871": "identify the the source", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00665-00204871-00205438": "and that is all from me and now", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00666-00205439-00205601": "hopefully there's time for your", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00667-00205602-00205882": "questions what's the I might be a little", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00668-00205883-00206116": "bit over time but yeah hopefully if you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00669-00206117-00207094": "have a question", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00670-00207096-00207388": "yeah my question is is it also possible", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00671-00207389-00207682": "or are you planning to work also on", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00672-00207683-00207934": "layer 2 monitoring because that's a", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00673-00207935-00208171": "quite a different thing but I believe", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00674-00208171-00208525": "that's a different uh type of", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00675-00208526-00208834": "communication where", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00676-00208835-00209266": "it's it's on our roadmap but", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00677-00209267-00209579": "uh as I hopefully I was able to to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00678-00209580-00209855": "convey the information it's not uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00679-00209856-00210142": "exactly easy to do it for Bitcoin and we", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00680-00210144-00210503": "are extending to to Litecoin and in sort", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00681-00210504-00210731": "of long-term goal is also to monitor", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00682-00210732-00211001": "light lightning network but it's not in", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00683-00211002-00211205": "terms of weeks or months but it's maybe", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00684-00211206-00211594": "like a uh after after like six months we", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00685-00211596-00211792": "we might get into it but first we need", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00686-00211794-00212051": "to sort of figure out all the all the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00687-00212052-00212279": "details for Bitcoin Litecoin and then", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00688-00212280-00212501": "yeah", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00689-00212502-00212710": "but because yeah definitely the the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00690-00212711-00212908": "layer two is really interesting uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00691-00212909-00213131": "interesting thing to to focus on so yeah", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00692-00213132-00213425": "we we are planning on that as well and", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00693-00213426-00213641": "for the simulator it's uh if you are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00694-00213642-00213989": "planning to run it on a real Network so", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00695-00213990-00214225": "I mean you are planning to run it on", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00696-00214226-00214601": "inet or it's more more generic", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00697-00214602-00214823": "obstructive application like you just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00698-00214823-00215110": "want to actually program the delays", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00699-00215111-00215556": "between the peers and then", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00700-00215557-00215992": "the first phase sort of is to do it uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00701-00215994-00216221": "outside of image like you said just the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00702-00216221-00216496": "generic uh note or the generic module", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00703-00216498-00216958": "with uh uh changing the the delay but uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00704-00216959-00217217": "I will push for the ultimate goal to", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00705-00217217-00217505": "actually implement it in inet it will", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00706-00217506-00217775": "obviously not be full a Bitcoin protocol", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00707-00217776-00218003": "but at least the part that we are", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00708-00218004-00218242": "interested would mimic the the real work", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00709-00218244-00218465": "scenario much better because it would", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00710-00218466-00218705": "take into account all the all the", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00711-00218706-00218975": "underlying uh network uh Network", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00712-00218976-00219215": "protocols but yeah the first step is", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00713-00219216-00219431": "definitely is going to be just a generic", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00714-00219432-00219682": "note and generic messages basically just", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00715-00219683-00219869": "to simulate the transaction uh", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00716-00219869-00220181": "propagation okay thank you", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00717-00220182-00220877": "foreign", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00718-00220878-00221032": "okay", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00719-00221033-00221410": "anything else any question", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00720-00221411-00221663": "if no then I would like to thank you for", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00721-00221664-00221891": "the presentation you're most welcome", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00722-00221892-00222203": "yeah and then", "MOy_ygwAA1u-00723-00222204-00222530": "I'm stopped to record"}}, {"audio_id": "MODSURLGGqE", "text": {"MODSURLGGqE-00000-00000175-00000217": "you", "MODSURLGGqE-00001-00000218-00000480": "[Music]", "MODSURLGGqE-00002-00000481-00000886": "[Laughter]", "MODSURLGGqE-00003-00000886-00001131": "[Music]", "MODSURLGGqE-00004-00001132-00001414": "now master friends welcome to art and", "MODSURLGGqE-00005-00001415-00001714": "tarot in this video I'm going to talk", "MODSURLGGqE-00006-00001714-00002053": "about a series which came on HBO in the", "MODSURLGGqE-00007-00002054-00002344": "year 2003 and the name of the series is", "MODSURLGGqE-00008-00002345-00002865": "the carnival this has two seasons set in", "MODSURLGGqE-00009-00002866-00003256": "the year 1934 the story is about a", "MODSURLGGqE-00010-00003257-00003645": "battle between the good and the evil the", "MODSURLGGqE-00011-00003646-00003943": "heaven and the hell in desperate times", "MODSURLGGqE-00012-00003944-00004329": "good Lord looks over the fun and chooses", "MODSURLGGqE-00013-00004330-00004750": "one man to inspire the motors to one man", "MODSURLGGqE-00014-00004751-00005031": "to accomplish the impossible and who are", "MODSURLGGqE-00015-00005032-00005236": "we to judge the wisdom of your almighty", "MODSURLGGqE-00016-00005237-00005829": "a fight between a poor Dirt Farmer and a", "MODSURLGGqE-00017-00005830-00006138": "charismatic priest both possessing", "MODSURLGGqE-00018-00006139-00006498": "extraordinary powers which they are not", "MODSURLGGqE-00019-00006500-00006831": "even aware of and at the same time they", "MODSURLGGqE-00020-00006833-00007164": "have no control of also one is the", "MODSURLGGqE-00021-00007165-00007450": "creation of light and the other is the", "MODSURLGGqE-00022-00007451-00007761": "creation of darkness or a jacquard a", "MODSURLGGqE-00023-00007762-00008002": "magician reversed you have a great", "MODSURLGGqE-00024-00008003-00008305": "talent ability it's been wasted and", "MODSURLGGqE-00025-00008306-00008674": "fulfill against you can wonders and what", "MODSURLGGqE-00026-00008675-00009136": "are you hiding", "MODSURLGGqE-00027-00009137-00009410": "the show has many interesting characters", "MODSURLGGqE-00028-00009411-00009761": "and many good actors to like a blind", "MODSURLGGqE-00029-00009762-00010127": "Claire event a tarot card reader with a", "MODSURLGGqE-00030-00010128-00010505": "telepathic mother the twins a bearded", "MODSURLGGqE-00031-00010506-00010712": "lady at atwood monkey man", "MODSURLGGqE-00032-00010713-00011152": "with a tail they're all in this carnival", "MODSURLGGqE-00033-00011153-00011732": "[Music]", "MODSURLGGqE-00034-00011733-00011809": "[Applause]", "MODSURLGGqE-00035-00011810-00012397": "[Music]", "MODSURLGGqE-00036-00012398-00013190": "[Music]", "MODSURLGGqE-00037-00013191-00013637": "this is kind of a real TV series which", "MODSURLGGqE-00038-00013638-00013993": "you get to see it's dark it's gritty and", "MODSURLGGqE-00039-00013994-00014276": "disturbingly invented the shoe follows", "MODSURLGGqE-00040-00014277-00014630": "these two main characters one a poor man", "MODSURLGGqE-00041-00014631-00014888": "Hawkins who travels at this carnival and", "MODSURLGGqE-00042-00014888-00015377": "the other man a priest a feature known", "MODSURLGGqE-00043-00015378-00015779": "as brother Justin both men had materias", "MODSURLGGqE-00044-00015780-00016058": "powers and they are somehow linked with", "MODSURLGGqE-00045-00016059-00016106": "each other", "MODSURLGGqE-00046-00016107-00016355": "knowingly or unknowingly and at the same", "MODSURLGGqE-00047-00016356-00016655": "time these two are also linked that this", "MODSURLGGqE-00048-00016656-00016982": "man known as Scudder young Hawkins is", "MODSURLGGqE-00049-00016983-00017294": "picked up by the carnival as an extra", "MODSURLGGqE-00050-00017295-00017626": "hand and while he was traveling with the", "MODSURLGGqE-00051-00017627-00017954": "carnival he starts realizing his dreams", "MODSURLGGqE-00052-00017955-00018281": "and powers what he possess and how he", "MODSURLGGqE-00053-00018282-00018476": "can use it for the good and for the", "MODSURLGGqE-00054-00018477-00018763": "benefit for the people and meanwhile", "MODSURLGGqE-00055-00018764-00019325": "this preacher the brother Justin he also", "MODSURLGGqE-00056-00019326-00019496": "in the meantime starts realizing the", "MODSURLGGqE-00057-00019497-00019993": "powers he has which are dark and", "MODSURLGGqE-00058-00019994-00020578": "destructive how long you been like that", "MODSURLGGqE-00059-00020579-00021858": "pray with you Frank the show strength is", "MODSURLGGqE-00060-00021859-00022158": "in the presentation and the scenes which", "MODSURLGGqE-00061-00022159-00022497": "are created in a very powerful way which", "MODSURLGGqE-00062-00022498-00022614": "will hope the audience through their", "MODSURLGGqE-00063-00022615-00022878": "screens overall this is a fantastic TV", "MODSURLGGqE-00064-00022879-00023146": "series hope they would have made the", "MODSURLGGqE-00065-00023147-00023424": "thirties and also which they didn't as", "MODSURLGGqE-00066-00023425-00023725": "far as we see the show will interview", "MODSURLGGqE-00067-00023726-00024036": "and open your mind for mysteries the", "MODSURLGGqE-00068-00024037-00024217": "good and the evil are both inside of us", "MODSURLGGqE-00069-00024218-00024433": "it depends on you who do you want to", "MODSURLGGqE-00070-00024434-00024669": "bring out so I would like to end my", "MODSURLGGqE-00071-00024670-00024936": "review with this beautiful story which I", "MODSURLGGqE-00072-00024937-00025286": "came across the story is about a painter", "MODSURLGGqE-00073-00025287-00025671": "who wanted to paint the most beautiful", "MODSURLGGqE-00074-00025672-00025981": "man the most godly man among human", "MODSURLGGqE-00075-00025982-00026236": "beings so he was searching for this man", "MODSURLGGqE-00076-00026237-00026614": "and one day he found a shepherd in the", "MODSURLGGqE-00077-00026614-00027055": "mountains and his face when he saw was", "MODSURLGGqE-00078-00027056-00027295": "the most beautiful and godly he has ever", "MODSURLGGqE-00079-00027295-00027910": "seen so he painted that man and the time", "MODSURLGGqE-00080-00027911-00028267": "past 20 years passed and after 20 years", "MODSURLGGqE-00081-00028268-00028527": "this man decided to paint the most evil", "MODSURLGGqE-00082-00028528-00028864": "and the most devilish man among human", "MODSURLGGqE-00083-00028864-00029208": "beings so he started looking for him", "MODSURLGGqE-00084-00029208-00029433": "looking for him at all the places that", "MODSURLGGqE-00085-00029434-00029865": "he could find him and finally he found a", "MODSURLGGqE-00086-00029866-00030120": "prisoner in the jail who has committed", "MODSURLGGqE-00087-00030122-00030355": "several crimes and who was about to be", "MODSURLGGqE-00088-00030356-00030724": "hanged in few days when he saw this man", "MODSURLGGqE-00089-00030725-00031002": "he saw is the most devilish man he has", "MODSURLGGqE-00090-00031003-00031296": "ever seen the most ugliest face so he", "MODSURLGGqE-00091-00031297-00031549": "decided to paint him and as he was about", "MODSURLGGqE-00092-00031550-00031815": "to finish his painting the prisoner", "MODSURLGGqE-00093-00031816-00031912": "started crying", "MODSURLGGqE-00094-00031913-00032289": "a painter asked what happened did I hurt", "MODSURLGGqE-00095-00032290-00032470": "you in any way", "MODSURLGGqE-00096-00032472-00032750": "the prisoner said all this while I was", "MODSURLGGqE-00097-00032751-00033113": "trying to hide from you you don't", "MODSURLGGqE-00098-00033114-00033311": "remember me you have painted me twenty", "MODSURLGGqE-00099-00033312-00033653": "years ago as the most beautiful man now", "MODSURLGGqE-00100-00033654-00033827": "you're painting me as the most devilish", "MODSURLGGqE-00101-00033828-00034355": "man so both of them the good and the", "MODSURLGGqE-00102-00034356-00034663": "evil they are all inside of you", "MODSURLGGqE-00103-00034664-00034951": "depends on you who you want to bring out", "MODSURLGGqE-00104-00034952-00035255": "Carnaval is a very interesting series if", "MODSURLGGqE-00105-00035256-00035504": "you happen to get a chance to watch it", "MODSURLGGqE-00106-00035505-00035831": "do watch it so that's a special rating", "MODSURLGGqE-00107-00035832-00036266": "for this show Carnival is 8.0 do give us", "MODSURLGGqE-00108-00036267-00036572": "your comments and suggestions hope you", "MODSURLGGqE-00109-00036573-00036800": "liked this video see you in my next one", "MODSURLGGqE-00110-00036801-00036927": "namaste", "MODSURLGGqE-00111-00036928-00037573": "[Music]", "MODSURLGGqE-00112-00037574-00037783": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "MOM5R8a6AV8", "text": {"MOM5R8a6AV8-00000-00000000-00000214": "the trash now the trash problem is much", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00001-00000215-00000437": "easier less expensive to solve it just", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00002-00000438-00000659": "needs action on the part of the city", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00003-00000660-00000904": "because it was 140 million dollars to", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00004-00000905-00001103": "solve the other one right this would be", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00005-00001104-00001349": "like fixing one sewer line just enforce", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00006-00001350-00001667": "those ordinances hey one last thank you", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00007-00001668-00001823": "um I believe Michael Smith and his board", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00008-00001823-00001979": "are voting on two thousand dollars", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00009-00001980-00002621": "toward the next goat yeah that's good", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00010-00002622-00002825": "thank you you're welcome thank you so", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00011-00002826-00003319": "much", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00012-00003320-00003520": "now we gotta have you back because we", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00013-00003521-00003670": "got cut off we couldn't talk forever", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00014-00003671-00003922": "well that's okay that's okay you know", "MOM5R8a6AV8-00015-00003923-00004184": "where to find me"}}, {"audio_id": "MOMLHIjsMV4", "text": {"MOMLHIjsMV4-00000-00000008-00000182": "cool well welcome everyone we're going", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00001-00000183-00000399": "to get started this is obviously the iep", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00002-00000400-00000599": "class on the replication crisis i'm", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00003-00000600-00000799": "david ramsey i'm going to be helping", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00004-00000800-00001062": "co-teach along with matt grow and noah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00005-00001063-00001303": "jones over here so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00006-00001304-00001447": "you'll be hearing from all of us over", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00007-00001448-00001751": "the next few weeks um i'm really psyched", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00008-00001752-00001910": "that all of you are here", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00009-00001911-00002215": "i think in my opinion the stakes when it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00010-00002216-00002326": "comes to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00011-00002327-00002623": "social psychology couldn't be higher", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00012-00002624-00002702": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00013-00002703-00002783": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00014-00002784-00003039": "whether we want to figure out how to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00015-00003040-00003191": "create meaning in our lives or think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00016-00003192-00003415": "about meaning in people's lives whether", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00017-00003415-00003567": "we're thinking about solving mental", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00018-00003568-00003735": "health problems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00019-00003736-00003919": "building good habits or breaking bad", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00020-00003920-00004222": "habits you know misinformation", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00021-00004223-00004535": "our public discourse you know our the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00022-00004536-00004783": "stability of our society right there", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00023-00004784-00004983": "couldn't be more at stake when it comes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00024-00004984-00005270": "to understanding individual psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00025-00005271-00005527": "and the way the environment shapes that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00026-00005528-00005622": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00027-00005623-00005767": "i think we've really been getting it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00028-00005768-00006015": "wrong empirically for the last 20 or 30", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00029-00006016-00006183": "years so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00030-00006184-00006270": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00031-00006271-00006478": "this is the place places like the media", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00032-00006479-00006623": "lab where we do cross-disciplinary", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00033-00006623-00006863": "research where i think we can revise", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00034-00006864-00007023": "the strategies we're taking on this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00035-00007023-00007246": "stuff right we can bring rigorous", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00036-00007247-00007414": "statistics into play we can measure", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00037-00007415-00007495": "things about people in their", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00038-00007495-00007727": "environments we can design interventions", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00039-00007728-00007910": "and we can really push", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00040-00007911-00008063": "computational social science and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00041-00008064-00008263": "empirical techniques in psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00042-00008264-00008503": "forward in a way that just hasn't been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00043-00008504-00008663": "done", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00044-00008664-00008935": "up until now so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00045-00008936-00009103": "this is the place", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00046-00009104-00009335": "um so before i talk at all about sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00047-00009336-00009455": "like the logistics of the class and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00048-00009456-00009687": "stuff i just want to start um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00049-00009688-00009903": "by telling you a story", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00050-00009904-00010055": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00051-00010056-00010367": "so imagine that it's 2011", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00052-00010368-00010606": "and you're the editor of a really well", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00053-00010607-00010871": "respected social psychology journal the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00054-00010872-00011071": "journal of personality and social", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00055-00011072-00011206": "psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00056-00011207-00011471": "and you have a big problem", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00057-00011472-00011574": "okay", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00058-00011575-00011655": "you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00059-00011656-00011887": "have received a paper from this man he's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00060-00011888-00012070": "a really well-respected professor named", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00061-00012071-00012263": "daryl bem from cornell", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00062-00012264-00012423": "he's he's published lots of really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00063-00012424-00012719": "well-respected theories about psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00064-00012720-00012983": "uh before and this is his magnum opus", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00065-00012984-00013191": "this is two years of his work", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00066-00013191-00013294": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00067-00013295-00013479": "it's rigorous it follows all the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00068-00013480-00013638": "statistical techniques that you're used", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00069-00013640-00013822": "to seeing in all of your papers it looks", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00070-00013823-00013943": "just like any other paper you would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00071-00013944-00014151": "publish but you really do not want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00072-00014152-00014383": "publish the paper that this man has sent", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00073-00014384-00014543": "you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00074-00014544-00014694": "and the reason", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00075-00014695-00014935": "is because this paper proves that we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00076-00014936-00015175": "capable of seeing the future", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00077-00015176-00015550": "right he calls it retro causality or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00078-00015551-00015743": "uh and it includes several different", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00079-00015744-00015966": "experiments that prove that we all have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00080-00015968-00016238": "premonitions the most famous one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00081-00016240-00016383": "is one where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00082-00016384-00016583": "undergraduates are looking get to look", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00083-00016584-00016815": "at two separate curtains they click a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00084-00016816-00016911": "curtain", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00085-00016912-00017111": "and randomly after they click a curtain", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00086-00017112-00017279": "one of the curtains will have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00087-00017280-00017494": "pornography behind it and one of them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00088-00017495-00017735": "will have a knot and because we all want", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00089-00017736-00017927": "to see the pornography", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00090-00017928-00018094": "it turns out that people actually click", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00091-00018095-00018311": "the one they have a premonition and they", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00092-00018312-00018455": "click the one with the pornography", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00093-00018456-00018822": "behind it 53 percent of the time", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00094-00018823-00019030": "and if they're steam stimulus seeking", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00095-00019031-00019127": "people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00096-00019128-00019263": "they actually click the one with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00097-00019264-00019591": "pornography behind it 57 of the time", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00098-00019592-00019735": "so these are the kinds of experiments", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00099-00019736-00019911": "that were in this paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00100-00019912-00020071": "many of these experiments", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00101-00020072-00020247": "so what do you do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00102-00020248-00020414": "if you're the editor what do you do with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00103-00020415-00020694": "this paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00104-00020695-00020894": "well the journal editors that have this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00105-00020895-00021119": "decision to make they published it and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00106-00021120-00021319": "alongside it they wrote this little", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00107-00021320-00021599": "editorial and they said we openly admit", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00108-00021600-00021814": "that the reported findings conflict with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00109-00021815-00022094": "our own beliefs about causality and that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00110-00022095-00022478": "we find them to be extremely puzzling", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00111-00022479-00022703": "and the next day the new york times on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00112-00022704-00023039": "the front page published this story", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00113-00023040-00023294": "and they said one of psychology's most", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00114-00023295-00023511": "respected journals agreed to publish a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00115-00023512-00023630": "paper presenting what the author", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00116-00023631-00023830": "describes as strong evidence for extra", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00117-00023831-00024119": "sensory perception the ability to sense", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00118-00024120-00024255": "future events", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00119-00024256-00024478": "the decision is already mortifying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00120-00024479-00024727": "scientists generating a mixture of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00121-00024728-00025007": "amusement and scorn", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00122-00025008-00025319": "this story is viewed as the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00123-00025320-00025591": "sort of initiation of the replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00124-00025592-00025806": "crisis and social psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00125-00025807-00025911": "it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00126-00025912-00026022": "caused", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00127-00026023-00026167": "the field to be seen as kind of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00128-00026168-00026343": "laughingstock when this was published", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00129-00026344-00026551": "but what these editors did was made a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00130-00026552-00026758": "really great decision for the field", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00131-00026760-00027046": "because it exposed the fact that the the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00132-00027047-00027270": "empirical statistical techniques that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00133-00027272-00027639": "had become common practice were not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00134-00027639-00027846": "working properly they were not working", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00135-00027847-00028031": "properly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00136-00028032-00028287": "the next year daniel kahneman who's an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00137-00028288-00028527": "incredibly famous uh nobel winning", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00138-00028527-00028751": "psychologist um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00139-00028752-00029007": "had seen a failed replication attempt of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00140-00029008-00029231": "social priming research which is this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00141-00029232-00029462": "idea that you know subtle subtle", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00142-00029463-00029599": "influences in the environment really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00143-00029600-00029790": "manifest in their behavior one of the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00144-00029791-00029983": "canonical examples was", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00145-00029983-00030174": "um doing crossword puzzles where you see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00146-00030175-00030455": "words like elderly makes you walk slower", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00147-00030456-00030614": "right which has been sort of debunked", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00148-00030616-00030783": "since um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00149-00030783-00031031": "and kahneman wrote an open letter to the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00150-00031032-00031255": "field where he basically said i see a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00151-00031256-00031431": "train wreck looming", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00152-00031432-00031590": "in the field of social priming and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00153-00031591-00031927": "social psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00154-00031927-00032214": "and kahneman was absolutely right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00155-00032216-00032335": "about that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00156-00032336-00032551": "so this table represents", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00157-00032552-00032902": "a major effort to to replicate lots of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00158-00032903-00033199": "findings in social psychology so this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00159-00033200-00033431": "this was done by 270 different", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00160-00033432-00033662": "psychologists all collaborating together", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00161-00033663-00033871": "on over a hundred different social", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00162-00033872-00034167": "psychology findings", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00163-00034168-00034271": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00164-00034272-00034374": "this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00165-00034375-00034631": "they replicated many times with the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00166-00034632-00034855": "instruction of the original authors", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00167-00034856-00035039": "all of these different findings in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00168-00035040-00035239": "several major psychology journals", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00169-00035240-00035518": "and what they found was that on average", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00170-00035519-00035655": "36", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00171-00035656-00036102": "of the original findings replicated", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00172-00036103-00036262": "and i just want to like pause and let", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00173-00036263-00036423": "that sink in with an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00174-00036424-00036735": "appropriately apocryphal gif", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00175-00036736-00036871": "36", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00176-00036872-00037255": "replicated right that's less than 50 50.", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00177-00037256-00037407": "if you see if you see one of these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00178-00037408-00037590": "papers and it's 36 you should actually", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00179-00037591-00037895": "revise your prior down right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00180-00037896-00038311": "um that's that's horrifying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00181-00038312-00038551": "and this is another example of a paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00182-00038552-00038815": "that appeared in nature", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00183-00038816-00038887": "that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00184-00038888-00039190": "did a very similar thing 21 high power", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00185-00039191-00039423": "replications of only the articles that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00186-00039424-00039615": "appeared in science in nature the two", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00187-00039616-00039767": "highest impact journals that we can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00188-00039768-00039862": "imagine", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00189-00039863-00039943": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00190-00039944-00040151": "and they did these these replications", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00191-00040152-00040415": "with five times on average the the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00192-00040416-00040655": "sample sizes of the original studies and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00193-00040656-00040839": "they found a little bit better result", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00194-00040840-00041190": "that 62 of the the studies replicated", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00195-00041191-00041287": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00196-00041288-00041527": "the fascinating thing about this plot is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00197-00041528-00041743": "that at the same time they also did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00198-00041744-00041911": "prediction markets on each of these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00199-00041912-00041999": "studies", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00200-00042000-00042207": "right so they asked people to predict", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00201-00042208-00042327": "whether they thought the studies would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00202-00042328-00042574": "replicate and so what you see here is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00203-00042575-00042815": "the yellow ones did not replicate the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00204-00042816-00043079": "blue ones did replicate and this x-axis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00205-00043080-00043318": "is how people guessed whether they would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00206-00043319-00043583": "replicate or not and it turns out people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00207-00043584-00043783": "guessed really really well", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00208-00043784-00043911": "which ones would replicate and which", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00209-00043912-00044055": "ones wouldn't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00210-00044056-00044271": "so even though the replication rate is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00211-00044272-00044471": "really poor there there is one of two", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00212-00044472-00044599": "things that you can take away from this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00213-00044600-00044943": "plot either people are really good at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00214-00044944-00045183": "intuiting what things drive human", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00215-00045184-00045311": "behavior and you should trust your", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00216-00045312-00045511": "intuition or people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00217-00045512-00045646": "you know these people had access to the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00218-00045647-00045879": "papers they were able to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00219-00045880-00046055": "check the papers and decide for", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00220-00046056-00046190": "themselves whether the methodologies are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00221-00046191-00046318": "good so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00222-00046319-00046527": "even though things don't replicate right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00223-00046528-00046679": "a lot of things don't replicate and you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00224-00046680-00046871": "should be very very skeptical when", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00225-00046872-00047127": "you're going through this literature um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00226-00047128-00047383": "there's hope right if you understand the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00227-00047384-00047567": "types of mistakes people make and you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00228-00047568-00047711": "have good intuition and you bring it to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00229-00047712-00047958": "bear you know it's possible to sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00230-00047959-00048383": "dissect these things pretty reliably", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00231-00048384-00048551": "i just want to mention that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00232-00048552-00048774": "this is not just something that occurs", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00233-00048775-00048974": "in the field of social psychology so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00234-00048975-00049199": "this is a very famous paper from 2005", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00235-00049200-00049358": "about the medical literature from", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00236-00049359-00049695": "ionitis from stanford and it's sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00237-00049696-00049935": "well known and well", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00238-00049936-00050102": "established at this point when it comes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00239-00050103-00050174": "to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00240-00050175-00050415": "drug research and pre-clinical cancer", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00241-00050416-00050590": "research that when they move to the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00242-00050591-00050830": "clinical trials about half of them fail", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00243-00050831-00050974": "so this causes tens of billions of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00244-00050975-00051174": "dollars it's the same sort of systemic", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00245-00051175-00051287": "problem", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00246-00051288-00051414": "as we're talking about in social", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00247-00051415-00051638": "psychology there's similar problems in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00248-00051639-00051807": "machine learning this is a paper written", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00249-00051808-00052007": "by a guy that i in a group i worked with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00250-00052008-00052175": "at google a few years ago that i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00251-00052176-00052350": "is really fascinating where he looked at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00252-00052351-00052535": "a particular type of neural network", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00253-00052536-00052671": "began", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00254-00052672-00052766": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00255-00052767-00052991": "he took all of the improvements that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00256-00052991-00053126": "people had made on again in the next", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00257-00053127-00053375": "four years and he tested all of them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00258-00053376-00053591": "over all hyper parameters over all data", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00259-00053591-00053847": "sets and showed that none of them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00260-00053848-00054094": "had actually improved the original game", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00261-00054095-00054294": "and you can see uh in the paper he says", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00262-00054295-00054494": "we need a more systematic and objective", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00263-00054495-00054750": "evaluation procedure so similar similar", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00264-00054751-00054894": "sorts of problems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00265-00054895-00055111": "affect machine learning", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00266-00055112-00055294": "um and then the other one that's very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00267-00055295-00055494": "common right now is neuroscience and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00268-00055495-00055726": "fmri research a lot of these studies are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00269-00055727-00055982": "underpowered and some of the analyses", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00270-00055983-00056182": "have shown", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00271-00056183-00056319": "there's a lot of variability in how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00272-00056320-00056494": "people do their data analysis so they", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00273-00056495-00056726": "get in this study they gave people the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00274-00056727-00056999": "same data 70 different teams from great", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00275-00057000-00057142": "universities around the world the same", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00276-00057144-00057303": "data and all of them came up with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00277-00057304-00057438": "different results on the different", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00278-00057439-00057719": "hypotheses so this kind of problem is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00279-00057720-00057871": "actually endemic to lots of different", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00280-00057872-00058007": "disciplines", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00281-00058008-00058150": "and it's not just social science even", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00282-00058151-00058271": "though we're going to be focusing on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00283-00058272-00058663": "social science in the class", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00284-00058664-00058807": "so welcome", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00285-00058808-00059023": "welcome to the class um i hope i have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00286-00059024-00059191": "convinced you that this is a real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00287-00059191-00059623": "problem it's an important problem um and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00288-00059624-00059766": "uh i just want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00289-00059767-00059975": "talk a little bit now about why we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00290-00059976-00060166": "doing this class and what you can expect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00291-00060167-00060415": "from the class so for me a lot of the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00292-00060416-00060606": "motivation here is you know i'm in the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00293-00060607-00060806": "responsive environments group here at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00294-00060807-00060982": "the media lab", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00295-00060983-00061279": "when i came in i was really bought in to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00296-00061279-00061559": "pop psychology hard you know i really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00297-00061560-00061759": "believed that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00298-00061760-00061966": "subtle changes in your environment sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00299-00061967-00062182": "of puppeteer your behavior in ways that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00300-00062183-00062391": "you do not understand and that we could", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00301-00062391-00062654": "nudge you and sort of control you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00302-00062655-00062830": "and really powerfully manipulate you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00303-00062832-00063079": "based off of modifying the environment", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00304-00063079-00063326": "and it's only over a few years of sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00305-00063327-00063519": "of digging into the research", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00306-00063520-00063630": "looking critically as some of these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00307-00063632-00063806": "things that i came to realize that a lot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00308-00063807-00063982": "of the things i believed in were just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00309-00063983-00064166": "wrong and and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00310-00064167-00064471": "incredibly overstated um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00311-00064472-00064750": "and i've also noticed when i meet people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00312-00064751-00064879": "that have sort of come to this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00313-00064879-00065215": "conclusion themselves we typically don't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00314-00065216-00065438": "cite the same primary sources it's a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00315-00065439-00065671": "blog here or a researcher there that we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00316-00065672-00065782": "really like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00317-00065783-00065959": "and there hasn't there isn't really a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00318-00065960-00066175": "centralized source of information", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00319-00066176-00066391": "how to deal with this problem in social", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00320-00066392-00066582": "psychology how to pour the social", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00321-00066583-00066791": "psychology into our work and use it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00322-00066792-00067055": "practically right so um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00323-00067056-00067326": "that's a big part of the goal in my mind", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00324-00067327-00067519": "for this course is just centralizing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00325-00067520-00067687": "some of these ideas", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00326-00067688-00067775": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00327-00067776-00068006": "focusing on solutions so if you want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00328-00068007-00068150": "be a practitioner how can we sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00329-00068151-00068326": "build back up instead of just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00330-00068327-00068567": "show what's wrong", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00331-00068568-00068711": "and the other thing i would say is i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00332-00068712-00068935": "think very few people folk covered the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00333-00068936-00069150": "full extent of the crisis and i'll talk", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00334-00069151-00069319": "about this a little bit in a minute but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00335-00069320-00069463": "a lot of people focus just on the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00336-00069464-00069687": "statistical problems that led to this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00337-00069688-00069855": "crisis and i think there's there are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00338-00069856-00070047": "levels that are much deeper that matt", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00339-00070048-00070159": "and i are going to be talking about in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00340-00070160-00070535": "future future lectures", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00341-00070536-00070799": "so uh the the structure of the class is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00342-00070800-00070950": "just going to be five", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00343-00070951-00071159": "five lectures basically we have two hour", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00344-00071160-00071423": "blocks the goal is going to be to um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00345-00071424-00071606": "have the lecture be an hour and a half", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00346-00071607-00071806": "or so an hour to an hour and a half and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00347-00071807-00072094": "leave time for us to talk um i'd like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00348-00072095-00072326": "for it to be a very sort of flat", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00349-00072327-00072494": "class structure i mean we're all we all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00350-00072495-00072655": "bring something different to the table", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00351-00072656-00072855": "we're all sort of figuring this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00352-00072856-00073094": "replication crisis stuff out together", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00353-00073095-00073375": "and i'm constantly learning myself of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00354-00073376-00073623": "new papers new techniques and so i'm", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00355-00073624-00073759": "hoping that this can serve as a place", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00356-00073760-00073926": "just for people that are interested in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00357-00073927-00074150": "this kind of work to chat get to know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00358-00074151-00074438": "each other share resources and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00359-00074439-00074631": "we'll we'll try to keep some time just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00360-00074632-00074894": "to keep that aspect of the class", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00361-00074895-00075006": "at the end", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00362-00075007-00075206": "in terms of what we're going to cover", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00363-00075207-00075359": "today i'm going to try to cover just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00364-00075360-00075550": "like a big picture", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00365-00075551-00075726": "what's going on with the crisis why did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00366-00075727-00075975": "it happen you know like a self-contained", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00367-00075976-00076223": "introduction to the crisis and how to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00368-00076224-00076455": "think about it and we'll get into more", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00369-00076456-00076743": "details as we go along um the next class", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00370-00076744-00076919": "noah is going to be talking to us about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00371-00076920-00077055": "practical skills for navigating the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00372-00077056-00077367": "crisis um some meta statistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00373-00077368-00077623": "techniques for analyzing groups of uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00374-00077624-00077782": "literature and then we're going to get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00375-00077783-00077999": "more into the sort of philosophical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00376-00078000-00078191": "underpinnings that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00377-00078192-00078382": "cause the crisis i think there's some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00378-00078383-00078559": "really interesting meaty stuff to talk", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00379-00078560-00078703": "about there and then we're going to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00380-00078704-00078926": "finish up with um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00381-00078927-00079150": "practical stories of what has failed to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00382-00079151-00079359": "replicate things you should avoid you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00383-00079360-00079503": "know how to think about some of these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00384-00079504-00079582": "things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00385-00079583-00079903": "if you're taking the class for credit um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00386-00079904-00080126": "we will there will be one assignment and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00387-00080127-00080415": "that will will sort of explain it next", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00388-00080416-00080655": "class um which will basically be to take", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00389-00080656-00080871": "a topic that you're interested in read", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00390-00080872-00081038": "several papers and pull out the main", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00391-00081039-00081287": "statistic from them and do a very basic", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00392-00081288-00081550": "meta meta-statistical analysis on that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00393-00081551-00081743": "topic and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00394-00081744-00081903": "time permitting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00395-00081904-00082055": "we will have people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00396-00082056-00082231": "talk about their meta-statistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00397-00082232-00082615": "analysis on the last day of class", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00398-00082616-00082799": "so i think we have about 13 people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00399-00082800-00082943": "registered for credit right now i don't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00400-00082944-00083159": "know how many people will continue to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00401-00083160-00083438": "the end um but so to be determined", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00402-00083439-00083791": "exactly on how we structure that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00403-00083792-00083991": "um the other two things i want to note", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00404-00083992-00084215": "one just to say up front right like a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00405-00084216-00084343": "lot of the people that you might think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00406-00084344-00084511": "of as perpetrators", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00407-00084512-00084806": "of the replication crisis are really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00408-00084807-00085062": "victims of it right like they have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00409-00085063-00085215": "learned they've been taught bad", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00410-00085216-00085487": "statistical techniques they applied them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00411-00085488-00085759": "they built careers over 20 or 30 years", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00412-00085760-00085959": "and now everything that they've done", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00413-00085960-00086094": "is being called into question their", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00414-00086095-00086335": "careers are likely falling apart right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00415-00086336-00086415": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00416-00086416-00086582": "uh there's a little bit of shooting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00417-00086583-00086782": "freud kind of like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00418-00086783-00086935": "delight in hypocrisy that i think is a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00419-00086936-00087118": "natural instinct and just want to sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00420-00087119-00087303": "of say up front that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00421-00087304-00087582": "try not to give in to that if you see me", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00422-00087583-00087735": "sit you know sort of be like oh my god", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00423-00087736-00087926": "can you believe this and not be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00424-00087927-00088079": "charitable to the people that we're sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00425-00088080-00088238": "of like talking about i think it's just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00426-00088239-00088367": "very important to be cognizant of the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00427-00088368-00088575": "tone when when you're dealing with you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00428-00088576-00088759": "know people's livelihoods and careers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00429-00088760-00088926": "and many times it's not their fault that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00430-00088927-00089071": "they've been promoting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00431-00089072-00089391": "what is empirically poor research right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00432-00089392-00089575": "um the other thing i'll say too is for", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00433-00089576-00089662": "me", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00434-00089663-00089950": "uh you know there there are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00435-00089951-00090191": "very advanced great statistical minds", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00436-00090192-00090415": "right now who are arguing about what we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00437-00090416-00090662": "would normally think of as very simple", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00438-00090663-00090943": "statistical concepts and so i would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00439-00090944-00091118": "encourage you to go back to basics with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00440-00091119-00091287": "your statistics and really dig in with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00441-00091288-00091447": "some of these things but just to sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00442-00091448-00091623": "remain humble because it's amazing how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00443-00091624-00091894": "even very simple statistics can be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00444-00091895-00092103": "you know very complex if you start to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00445-00092104-00092279": "wrestle with them at a high level and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00446-00092280-00092455": "part of what we're going to do today is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00447-00092456-00092679": "try to talk about conceptually how we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00448-00092680-00092847": "should be thinking about some pretty", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00449-00092848-00092991": "what would be normally considered very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00450-00092992-00093494": "simple statistical techniques", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00451-00093495-00093832": "any questions", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00452-00093833-00094071": "[Music]", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00453-00094072-00094279": "well so i sort of alluded to the fact", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00454-00094280-00094415": "that i feel like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00455-00094416-00094687": "people don't always cover all aspects of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00456-00094688-00094855": "the replication crisis when they talk", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00457-00094856-00095079": "about the replication crisis and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00458-00095080-00095287": "um they're expert this is how i think of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00459-00095288-00095526": "it so there are experts at each level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00460-00095527-00095606": "here", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00461-00095607-00095862": "um but the sort of fundamental level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00462-00095863-00096023": "which doesn't usually get talked about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00463-00096024-00096159": "with the replication crisis which we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00464-00096160-00096335": "going to cover is something i would call", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00465-00096336-00096559": "ontologies so what are the things that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00466-00096560-00096671": "we're talking about what are the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00467-00096672-00096831": "quantities we're talking about and how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00468-00096832-00097038": "do they relate to each other right what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00469-00097039-00097279": "does it mean to measure the meaning in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00470-00097280-00097487": "someone's life what does it mean to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00471-00097488-00097647": "measure attention", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00472-00097648-00097926": "how does behavior and personality how do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00473-00097927-00098079": "those things interact what can you even", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00474-00098080-00098247": "say about an individual right like do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00475-00098248-00098582": "they have traits moods dispositions how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00476-00098583-00098831": "does that interact with environments how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00477-00098832-00099062": "do you describe environments and really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00478-00099063-00099174": "capture all the variability of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00479-00099175-00099326": "environments you know what are the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00480-00099327-00099574": "fundamental units that we're using", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00481-00099575-00099767": "when we're talking about social science", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00482-00099768-00099999": "and how do those things interact and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00483-00100000-00100182": "mediate and moderate how we how do we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00484-00100183-00100431": "reason about these relationships so i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00485-00100432-00100655": "actually think we've made some very big", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00486-00100656-00100855": "problematic assumptions at this level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00487-00100856-00101055": "that we'll be describing later in the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00488-00101056-00101215": "class and a lot of the really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00489-00101216-00101335": "interesting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00490-00101336-00101559": "problems and a lot of interesting work", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00491-00101560-00101750": "moving forward actually exists at this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00492-00101751-00101959": "sort of ontological level which", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00493-00101960-00102182": "is below what is typically discussed", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00494-00102183-00102335": "when we talk about the replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00495-00102336-00102463": "crisis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00496-00102464-00102606": "the next level up", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00497-00102607-00102790": "is this sort of systemic level which", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00498-00102791-00103006": "does get talked about a bit but is less", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00499-00103007-00103199": "talked about i would say and this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00500-00103200-00103430": "just the sort of if you have if you've", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00501-00103431-00103630": "heard of kuhn the sort of like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00502-00103631-00103990": "philosophy of science uh level of how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00503-00103991-00104190": "we're doing research right how much of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00504-00104191-00104399": "it is about real empiricism versus", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00505-00104400-00104654": "individuals who are incentivized to tell", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00506-00104655-00104966": "a story right and what are we rewarding", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00507-00104967-00105215": "in the academic sort of scholarship", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00508-00105216-00105447": "level and so there are things like hype", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00509-00105448-00105623": "fraud you know the types of things that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00510-00105624-00105751": "you would expect when there are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00511-00105752-00105999": "systematic incentive problems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00512-00106000-00106223": "right um so that's sort of a level above", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00513-00106224-00106407": "once we've agreed on the fundamental", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00514-00106408-00106566": "things we're measuring", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00515-00106567-00106663": "and then", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00516-00106664-00106815": "obviously part of the system is the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00517-00106816-00106958": "methods we're using the statistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00518-00106959-00107166": "methods we're using and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00519-00107167-00107366": "a lot of people do misapply the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00520-00107367-00107599": "statistical methods and so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00521-00107600-00107719": "this is what we're going to really talk", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00522-00107720-00107943": "about today probably one and two a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00523-00107944-00108143": "little bit but mostly one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00524-00108144-00108343": "and this is really what most people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00525-00108344-00108486": "focus on when they talk about the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00526-00108488-00108639": "replication crisis but like i said we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00527-00108640-00109063": "going to try to cover all three", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00528-00109064-00109310": "all right so to to kick things off and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00529-00109311-00109463": "to kind of have this conversation at all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00530-00109464-00109654": "like how did we end up in this state", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00531-00109655-00109966": "where so few findings replicate right we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00532-00109967-00110110": "really need to go back to basics with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00533-00110111-00110286": "conceptual stats", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00534-00110288-00110399": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00535-00110400-00110583": "and i'm gonna try to review this in a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00536-00110583-00110790": "way that is accessible to people even if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00537-00110791-00111039": "they haven't really had statistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00538-00111040-00111286": "training but i'm gonna move quickly and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00539-00111288-00111390": "just kind of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00540-00111391-00111607": "review the basic sort of hypothesis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00541-00111608-00111886": "testing and what goes wrong so i hope i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00542-00111888-00112102": "hope it's a review for you if it's new", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00543-00112103-00112295": "and it feels like it's going too fast", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00544-00112296-00112431": "you know i'm happy to sit down with you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00545-00112432-00112615": "and talk through it in more detail but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00546-00112616-00112743": "we're just going to kind of quickly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00547-00112744-00113031": "review some concepts about how to think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00548-00113032-00113254": "about hypothesis testing and i really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00549-00113255-00113727": "like this quote by garrett gigarenzer um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00550-00113728-00113902": "where he was looking at he was he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00551-00113903-00114110": "surveyed a bunch of professors", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00552-00114111-00114423": "researchers you know uh teachers of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00553-00114424-00114727": "stats statist statistics teachers and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00554-00114728-00114951": "sort of showed that basically all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00555-00114952-00115215": "researchers have some very fundamental", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00556-00115216-00115575": "misunderstanding of of course statistics", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00557-00115576-00115686": "and that we should be teaching", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00558-00115688-00115927": "statistical thinking not statistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00559-00115928-00116143": "rituals and i really like that way of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00560-00116144-00116278": "thinking about it it's about the way", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00561-00116279-00116439": "you're thinking when you approach these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00562-00116440-00116686": "problems and if you're applying a ritual", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00563-00116688-00116951": "blindly you are definitely not doing it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00564-00116952-00117199": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00565-00117200-00117551": "um so to start out with um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00566-00117552-00117702": "i'm going to talk about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00567-00117703-00117975": "uh comparing two groups as you would in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00568-00117976-00118110": "sort of like a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00569-00118111-00118343": "two-sample t-test right so let's just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00570-00118344-00118615": "say that we are we have a miracle drug", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00571-00118616-00118719": "that's going to help you with your", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00572-00118720-00118831": "depression", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00573-00118832-00119102": "and we have a control group in yellow we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00574-00119103-00119239": "have an intervention group that's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00575-00119240-00119527": "getting the drug in in green", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00576-00119528-00119734": "and we're monitoring their self-reported", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00577-00119735-00119847": "happiness", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00578-00119848-00120175": "so in this case we can assume that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00579-00120176-00120327": "there are thousands of people in this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00580-00120328-00120519": "study thousands and thousands so these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00581-00120520-00120758": "distributions are very accurate", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00582-00120759-00120966": "and so what we would expect here", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00583-00120967-00121223": "is that our p-value is low it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00584-00121224-00121383": "statistically significant because we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00585-00121383-00121599": "because we have a lot of confidence in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00586-00121600-00121751": "the study we have a large number of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00587-00121752-00121886": "participants", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00588-00121888-00122119": "and then we can look and see that our", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00589-00122120-00122366": "our effect size the difference between", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00590-00122367-00122639": "the means of this group is about one on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00591-00122640-00122951": "a scale of zero to ten right so one out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00592-00122952-00123271": "of eleven so we can be very confident", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00593-00123272-00123502": "we have a very low p value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00594-00123503-00123743": "but the effect is very small and maybe", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00595-00123744-00123958": "not very important in the grand picture", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00596-00123959-00124102": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00597-00124103-00124247": "we can contrast that with something like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00598-00124248-00124519": "this let's say we have a much smaller n", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00599-00124520-00124727": "right so we can't be quite as certain", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00600-00124728-00125014": "that these distributions actually are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00601-00125015-00125223": "the distributions right that that we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00602-00125224-00125399": "would expect if we kept sampling and we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00603-00125400-00125639": "had a much larger n right so our p value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00604-00125640-00125919": "maybe isn't significant in this case", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00605-00125920-00126166": "but it's very suggest this this very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00606-00126167-00126383": "very large effect size is suggestive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00607-00126383-00126663": "that maybe this is a miracle drug right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00608-00126664-00126927": "so the point that i want to make", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00609-00126928-00127134": "is that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00610-00127135-00127471": "effect sizes are are very very important", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00611-00127472-00127583": "and the thing that you really should be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00612-00127583-00127799": "focusing on p-values are important too", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00613-00127800-00128031": "but so much when it comes to how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00614-00128032-00128223": "statistics are taught people say focus", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00615-00128224-00128399": "on the p-value and p-value tends to be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00616-00128400-00128558": "the thing that people take away", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00617-00128559-00128702": "effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00618-00128703-00128958": "is more important i would say effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00619-00128959-00129247": "size is extremely important so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00620-00129248-00129478": "when you're trying to understand", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00621-00129479-00129607": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00622-00129608-00129807": "you know how an intervention", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00623-00129808-00130007": "whether an intervention actually matters", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00624-00130008-00130127": "the number one thing that you should", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00625-00130128-00130271": "really be concerned about is the effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00626-00130272-00130439": "size you know how much does it actually", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00627-00130440-00130533": "increasing happiness", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00628-00130534-00130758": "[Music]", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00629-00130759-00130910": "and let's take a look at this example", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00630-00130911-00131143": "too right so same thing let's just say", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00631-00131144-00131359": "both of these are really high n so we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00632-00131360-00131511": "can have really high confidence in both", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00633-00131512-00131631": "of these they're both statistically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00634-00131632-00131919": "significant right and moreover both of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00635-00131920-00132127": "them have the same", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00636-00132128-00132343": "absolute effect size right so they're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00637-00132344-00132590": "both moving these populations", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00638-00132591-00132695": "one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00639-00132696-00132854": "one on a scale of one to ten of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00640-00132855-00133063": "self-reported happiness", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00641-00133064-00133263": "in this case right we're moving two", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00642-00133264-00133407": "standard deviations basically we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00643-00133408-00133654": "moving everybody from a three to a four", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00644-00133655-00133919": "and in this case we're moving people you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00645-00133920-00134143": "know point two standard deviation moving", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00646-00134144-00134383": "people from a zero to a nine up a little", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00647-00134384-00134687": "bit to a one 1 to a 10.", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00648-00134688-00134871": "those are different we should probably", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00649-00134872-00135135": "conceive of those as as different right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00650-00135136-00135214": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00651-00135215-00135351": "the point that i want you to take away", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00652-00135352-00135623": "from this plot is that we care both", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00653-00135624-00135902": "about the absolute effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00654-00135903-00136127": "you know that this is one on a scale of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00655-00136128-00136254": "one to ten", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00656-00136255-00136502": "and the normalized effect size that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00657-00136503-00136663": "we've moved people to standard", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00658-00136664-00136863": "deviations versus point two standard", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00659-00136864-00137014": "deviations both of those are useful", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00660-00137015-00137223": "pieces of information for us to reason", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00661-00137224-00137535": "about you know what's happening here", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00662-00137536-00137823": "so to summarize i have quoted a couple", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00663-00137824-00138151": "of the best statisticians of the last", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00664-00138152-00138351": "you know 100 years", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00665-00138352-00138535": "statistical significance is the least", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00666-00138536-00138735": "interesting thing about results", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00667-00138736-00138895": "you should describe the results in terms", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00668-00138896-00139071": "of measures of magnitude", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00669-00139072-00139223": "the primary product of a research", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00670-00139224-00139383": "inquiry is one or more measures of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00671-00139384-00139654": "effect size not p-values when you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00672-00139655-00139807": "reading papers and you're reasoning", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00673-00139808-00140007": "about these things you should be focused", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00674-00140008-00140359": "on effect sizes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00675-00140360-00140575": "so this is the summary aside to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00676-00140576-00140839": "summarize a basic um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00677-00140840-00141095": "t-test from from your statistics courses", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00678-00141096-00141247": "hopefully you remember it but i want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00679-00141248-00141447": "walk through it really fast", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00680-00141448-00141566": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00681-00141567-00141735": "once again we're talking about the same", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00682-00141736-00141943": "kind of example we have a control and we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00683-00141944-00142111": "have an intervention group", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00684-00142112-00142335": "and we sample these groups and the first", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00685-00142336-00142566": "thing we're going to do is calculate an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00686-00142567-00142847": "effect size a normalized effect size so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00687-00142848-00143063": "we're looking at the difference in means", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00688-00143064-00143214": "between these groups", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00689-00143215-00143502": "divided by the pooled standard deviation", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00690-00143503-00143639": "right and when you're looking in the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00691-00143640-00143766": "literature you'll see this called", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00692-00143767-00143911": "cohen's d", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00693-00143912-00144190": "or you'll see it called hodges g and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00694-00144191-00144359": "hodges g just has a different way of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00695-00144360-00144575": "computing this pooled standard deviation", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00696-00144576-00144799": "that's better for smaller sample sizes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00697-00144800-00145023": "so the first thing that we always do is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00698-00145024-00145263": "calculate a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00699-00145264-00145495": "normalized effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00700-00145496-00145726": "the next thing we do is we calculate our", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00701-00145727-00146078": "test statistic so that's t here right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00702-00146079-00146302": "and t is simply", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00703-00146303-00146511": "our normalized effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00704-00146512-00146647": "divided by", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00705-00146648-00146878": "some measure of sampling error right so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00706-00146879-00147047": "this these ends are how many samples", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00707-00147048-00147247": "we're drawing in our in our two groups", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00708-00147248-00147478": "right so all test statistics are this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00709-00147479-00147766": "ratio between a normalized effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00710-00147767-00147990": "and some measure of sampling error", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00711-00147991-00148263": "so this t value is one number that gives", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00712-00148264-00148343": "us", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00713-00148344-00148559": "basically an idea of how confident we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00714-00148560-00148766": "should be in our result right it gets", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00715-00148767-00149031": "bigger when we have a bigger spread", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00716-00149032-00149119": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00717-00149120-00149326": "a larger number of standard deviations", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00718-00149327-00149535": "of difference and it also gets bigger as", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00719-00149536-00149671": "we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00720-00149672-00149926": "increase our n and we sample more right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00721-00149927-00150207": "so one useful number", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00722-00150208-00150335": "and if you look at your statistics", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00723-00150336-00150502": "textbook what you'll typically see is a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00724-00150503-00150783": "distribution of this t value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00725-00150784-00150926": "that represents", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00726-00150927-00151175": "what you would expect if there was no", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00727-00151176-00151414": "difference between the control group and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00728-00151415-00151559": "the intervention group", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00729-00151560-00151831": "right so if if in reality we're just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00730-00151832-00152039": "drawing from this one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00731-00152040-00152135": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00732-00152136-00152287": "control group distribution and there's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00733-00152288-00152463": "no difference between our two right if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00734-00152464-00152687": "we we can pull a few samples and then a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00735-00152688-00152847": "few samples and we're going to expect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00736-00152848-00153047": "some difference of mean between those", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00737-00153048-00153247": "those samples just because of randomness", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00738-00153248-00153383": "right so we're going to get some effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00739-00153384-00153663": "size and some t value but on average we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00740-00153664-00153878": "expect that value to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00741-00153879-00154054": "be centered around zero", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00742-00154055-00154278": "so we can plot the t values we would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00743-00154279-00154559": "accept expect just from randomness", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00744-00154560-00154678": "basically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00745-00154679-00154759": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00746-00154760-00154966": "if we were drawing from one underlying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00747-00154967-00155143": "distribution", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00748-00155144-00155319": "and this is how this is where we get our", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00749-00155320-00155575": "p value right this is where we say", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00750-00155576-00155831": "whether our test is significant or not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00751-00155832-00156095": "right so our p-value represents where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00752-00156096-00156423": "how where on this curve we're falling", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00753-00156424-00156614": "um how likely it is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00754-00156615-00156854": "that the data that we're seeing was", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00755-00156855-00156975": "drawn", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00756-00156976-00157311": "is the result of random drawing from", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00757-00157312-00157454": "an underlying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00758-00157455-00157614": "the sort of null distribution right like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00759-00157615-00157902": "the the un one underlying distribution", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00760-00157903-00158135": "for both our control group and our", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00761-00158136-00158311": "intervention group", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00762-00158312-00158495": "right and typically what has happened", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00763-00158496-00158663": "you know what you're used to seeing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00764-00158664-00159014": "right is if that p-value is is uh less", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00765-00159015-00159207": "than 0.05", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00766-00159208-00159390": "then we would accept it as statistically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00767-00159391-00159639": "significant right and that p that o5", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00768-00159640-00159926": "number is known as the alpha", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00769-00159927-00160031": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00770-00160032-00160311": "so the p-value once again is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00771-00160312-00160526": "where we fall on this curve how likely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00772-00160527-00160702": "it is how much area there is under this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00773-00160703-00160959": "distribution how likely it is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00774-00160960-00161039": "that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00775-00161040-00161263": "the data that we're seeing is due to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00776-00161264-00161566": "random sampling from one underlying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00777-00161567-00161895": "distribution basically it's noise from", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00778-00161896-00162319": "one underlying distribution", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00779-00162320-00162495": "and i this i've taken from this guy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00780-00162496-00162711": "chris tufts website", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00781-00162712-00162951": "this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00782-00162952-00163166": "basically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00783-00163167-00163383": "how we would think about power analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00784-00163384-00163559": "so another thing that you can do and you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00785-00163560-00163823": "should do right we can plot the t values", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00786-00163824-00164126": "we would expect to get if there's no", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00787-00164127-00164375": "effect and we can plot against we can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00788-00164376-00164543": "plot over top of that the t values we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00789-00164544-00164759": "would expect to get with an effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00790-00164760-00164975": "that we choose right so let's assume", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00791-00164976-00165095": "that we're going to get a certain effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00792-00165096-00165359": "size say like 1.1 standard deviation we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00793-00165360-00165478": "can plot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00794-00165479-00165687": "the distribution of t values that we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00795-00165688-00165919": "would expect for that effect size if we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00796-00165920-00166111": "assume that effect size would be true", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00797-00166112-00166319": "and using that we can make estimates", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00798-00166320-00166623": "about how likely we are to see a real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00799-00166624-00166919": "result or to accept a real result", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00800-00166920-00167271": "if we set our alpha value at some level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00801-00167272-00167438": "and that's considered the power so the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00802-00167439-00167663": "power gives you some indication right of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00803-00167664-00167863": "how likely you are to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00804-00167864-00168135": "correctly reject the null hypothesis and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00805-00168136-00168366": "accept an alternative hypothesis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00806-00168367-00168654": "um if there is a real effect of the size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00807-00168655-00168847": "that you have assumed", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00808-00168848-00169031": "right i know that's i know this is a lot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00809-00169032-00169214": "but the basic thing that i want you to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00810-00169215-00169495": "take away right is as we increase our", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00811-00169496-00169807": "sampling rate we increase our power", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00812-00169808-00169895": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00813-00169896-00170102": "the more power there is the more likely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00814-00170103-00170359": "we are to to accurately", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00815-00170360-00170575": "to capture that there's a real effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00816-00170576-00170766": "when in fact there is a real effect and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00817-00170767-00170999": "if there's too little power we're very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00818-00171000-00171190": "likely to not see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00819-00171191-00171454": "statistical significance when there is a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00820-00171455-00171799": "real underlying effect right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00821-00171800-00171943": "so to summarize everything that we just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00822-00171944-00172223": "go over we just went over right we care", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00823-00172224-00172414": "about the effect size you should care", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00824-00172415-00172551": "very much about the effect size always", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00825-00172552-00172711": "look at the effect size we care about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00826-00172712-00172847": "the normalized effect size which is the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00827-00172848-00173014": "main thing that you see reported", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00828-00173015-00173183": "frequently um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00829-00173184-00173431": "in the psychology literature our test", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00830-00173432-00173638": "statistic is the normalized effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00831-00173639-00173878": "over some sampling error", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00832-00173879-00174151": "and then we have a few different ways of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00833-00174152-00174287": "thinking about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00834-00174288-00174623": "alpha our 0.05 value beta which is the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00835-00174624-00174887": "inverse of of power so alpha", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00836-00174888-00175135": "is the likelihood of a false positive if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00837-00175136-00175399": "we never test a true claim", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00838-00175400-00175614": "right if we never test a true claim how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00839-00175615-00175926": "likely are we to see a p-value of of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00840-00175927-00176143": "greater than or e equal to alpha", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00841-00176144-00176343": "and power is how likely are we to detect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00842-00176344-00176671": "an effect if there is an effect right of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00843-00176672-00177175": "the size that we have expected", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00844-00177176-00177414": "so what's wrong with this picture", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00845-00177415-00177654": "what is wrong with how we're approaching", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00846-00177655-00177838": "this like how is it when we do this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00847-00177839-00178078": "hypothesis testing we ended up with all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00848-00178079-00178295": "of these failures of replications and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00849-00178296-00178383": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00850-00178384-00178607": "such a dire", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00851-00178608-00178759": "state of affairs in the research", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00852-00178760-00178919": "literature", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00853-00178920-00179095": "well", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00854-00179096-00179359": "i would say that the problem here is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00855-00179360-00179566": "alpha right and it's really the a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00856-00179567-00179838": "misinterpretation of alpha", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00857-00179839-00179990": "it's a it's a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00858-00179991-00180254": "thinking of alpha categorically that if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00859-00180255-00180438": "something is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00860-00180439-00180759": "less than alpha it's true and if it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00861-00180760-00180966": "more than alpha it's false right if we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00862-00180967-00181166": "have a p-value less than .05 it must be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00863-00181167-00181383": "true and if it's if it's uh more than", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00864-00181384-00181551": "that it's false", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00865-00181552-00181783": "and i want to just really dig into that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00866-00181784-00182007": "because it's such an important point and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00867-00182008-00182295": "it's something that a lot of people get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00868-00182296-00182502": "wrong and in fact the surveys have sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00869-00182503-00182631": "of shown that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00870-00182632-00182902": "86 of statistic teachers and 40 of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00871-00182903-00183119": "psychology professors fundamentally", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00872-00183120-00183423": "misunderstand how to interpret a p-value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00873-00183424-00183647": "right so this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00874-00183648-00183863": "a simple concept but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00875-00183864-00183951": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00876-00183952-00184119": "it's very very important and a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00877-00184120-00184326": "people get it very very wrong and so to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00878-00184327-00184566": "illustrate it i want you to think about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00879-00184567-00184895": "two professors professor alice and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00880-00184896-00185038": "professor bob", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00881-00185039-00185119": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00882-00185120-00185311": "and professor alice", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00883-00185312-00185599": "is testing very unlikely hypotheses", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00884-00185600-00185719": "she's searching for a needle in the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00885-00185720-00185911": "haystack she's looking for that big", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00886-00185912-00186087": "life-changing paradigm shifting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00887-00186088-00186295": "invention right or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00888-00186296-00186671": "result and so because of that one out of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00889-00186672-00186823": "the thousands of the things that she's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00890-00186824-00187038": "testing are going to be real right she's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00891-00187039-00187247": "really searching for something very very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00892-00187248-00187423": "far out there and then we have professor", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00893-00187424-00187702": "bob and professor bob is simply", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00894-00187703-00188031": "quantifying effect sizes of common sense", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00895-00188032-00188207": "things that we all know to be true right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00896-00188208-00188495": "professor bob is saying you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00897-00188496-00188766": "sugar causes cavities right we know that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00898-00188767-00188919": "so i'm just going to see how much it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00899-00188920-00189102": "causes cavities and i want to quantify", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00900-00189103-00189326": "that so professor bob and professor", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00901-00189327-00189478": "bob's case four out of five of the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00902-00189479-00189687": "things that he's testing are real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00903-00189688-00189863": "they're real effects they have different", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00904-00189864-00190183": "strategies as professors and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00905-00190184-00190311": "for this example we're going to say", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00906-00190312-00190502": "let's look at one experiment you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00907-00190503-00190654": "they're both going to do one experiment", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00908-00190655-00191031": "at 90 power", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00909-00191032-00191126": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00910-00191127-00191335": "in this one experiment what are the odds", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00911-00191336-00191654": "of a p-value less than 0.05", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00912-00191655-00191883": "just from noise from chance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00913-00191884-00192214": "right it's not a trick question", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00914-00192215-00192399": "the answer is five there's a five", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00915-00192400-00192638": "percent likelihood 0.05 right that is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00916-00192639-00192935": "sort of the definition of the of um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00917-00192936-00193159": "what a p-value means right there's a 5", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00918-00193160-00193326": "chance just from randomness that we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00919-00193327-00193631": "would get a p-value less than 0.05", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00920-00193632-00193799": "the odd and then what are the odds of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00921-00193800-00193950": "real effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00922-00193951-00194254": "um leading to a p-value of 0.05 for each", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00923-00194255-00194519": "of these professors well the odds of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00924-00194520-00194678": "that are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00925-00194679-00194838": "going to be related to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00926-00194839-00195111": "the likelihood that they have a real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00927-00195112-00195214": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00928-00195215-00195359": "effect that they're seeing which is the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00929-00195360-00195583": "prior right so if professor alice is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00930-00195584-00195759": "running these tests only one out of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00931-00195760-00195950": "thousands have a real effect and then we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00932-00195951-00196111": "and then we multiply that by the power", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00933-00196112-00196407": "how likely is professor alice to detect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00934-00196408-00196583": "a real effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00935-00196584-00196775": "um given that there is a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00936-00196776-00197071": "a real effect to detect right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00937-00197072-00197319": "so professor alice because she's very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00938-00197320-00197566": "rarely testing hypotheses that are real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00939-00197567-00197766": "right when she sees she's going to get a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00940-00197767-00197902": "lot of chance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00941-00197903-00198150": "p value is less than 0.05 and only very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00942-00198151-00198287": "seldomly is she going to get one due to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00943-00198288-00198495": "a real effect professor bob on the other", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00944-00198496-00198623": "hand because almost everything he's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00945-00198624-00198878": "testing is real he's going to get a lot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00946-00198879-00199038": "of p-values", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00947-00199039-00199247": "that are because of real effects", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00948-00199248-00199431": "and also a similar number from chance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00949-00199432-00199687": "just like a small number from chance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00950-00199688-00199854": "so if we look at them what is the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00951-00199855-00199975": "likelihood", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00952-00199976-00200295": "of a p-value less than .05 being a real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00953-00200296-00200550": "effect for each of them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00954-00200551-00200766": "it's pretty simple to calculate and the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00955-00200767-00200990": "numbers are pretty dramatic right so for", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00956-00200991-00201166": "professor alice", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00957-00201167-00201463": "1.8 of the p-value we would expect 1.8", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00958-00201464-00201623": "of the p-values that she sees that are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00959-00201624-00201871": "less than 0.05 to be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00960-00201872-00202078": "evidence of a real effect that she found", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00961-00202079-00202271": "something real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00962-00202272-00202487": "right whereas for professor bob the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00963-00202488-00202807": "answer is 98 98 of the time right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00964-00202808-00203126": "professor bob is going to uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00965-00203127-00203326": "a p value of less than 0.05 means that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00966-00203327-00203678": "there's a real effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00967-00203679-00203847": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00968-00203848-00204054": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00969-00204055-00204295": "if you are feeling", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00970-00204296-00204502": "like an instinct that i just made a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00971-00204503-00204678": "value judgment or that i've said that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00972-00204679-00204823": "professor bob", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00973-00204823-00205151": "is a better researcher or we should you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00974-00205152-00205351": "know that there's something", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00975-00205352-00205542": "here where i have preferentially said", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00976-00205544-00205679": "something of professor bob that means", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00977-00205680-00205879": "that you've internalized the incorrect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00978-00205880-00206079": "interpretation of p-values i have this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00979-00206080-00206271": "feeling right it's like oh if i look at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00980-00206271-00206398": "these two researchers that with a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00981-00206400-00206655": "p-value of less than .05 bob is the good", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00982-00206656-00206871": "one right but that's not at all what i'm", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00983-00206871-00206951": "saying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00984-00206952-00207158": "right both of these folks are running", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00985-00207159-00207431": "their experiments at 90 power right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00986-00207432-00207590": "they're both good researchers and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00987-00207591-00207766": "honestly i'd rather be professor alice i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00988-00207767-00207942": "don't want to be quantifying things that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00989-00207944-00208142": "everyone knows right like i much prefer", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00990-00208144-00208351": "to be trying to find things that are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00991-00208352-00208534": "sort of unique and interesting and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00992-00208535-00208734": "undiscovered the thing that i'm saying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00993-00208735-00209031": "is that you can't use the same p-value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00994-00209032-00209262": "for both of these people right the way", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00995-00209263-00209486": "you think about the p-value has to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00996-00209487-00209598": "change", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00997-00209600-00209798": "and if you care about understanding", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00998-00209800-00210039": "whether an effect is real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-00999-00210040-00210287": "based off of the p-value you have to do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01000-00210288-00210503": "this mental calculation every time you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01001-00210504-00210687": "come in contact with a p-value it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01002-00210688-00210894": "depends on the prior", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01003-00210896-00211151": "it depends on how likely the thing that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01004-00211152-00211446": "is being tested is to exist", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01005-00211448-00211687": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01006-00211688-00211919": "and that quantity has a name it's called", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01007-00211919-00212142": "the positive predictive value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01008-00212144-00212334": "right so this is the thing that people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01009-00212335-00212679": "very frequently confuse p values for", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01010-00212680-00212919": "and you can see it's the calculation", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01011-00212919-00213191": "that we just did right how how likely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01012-00213192-00213423": "something is to be true given a certain", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01013-00213423-00213551": "p value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01014-00213552-00213710": "has to do with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01015-00213711-00213991": "the alpha that you've selected", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01016-00213992-00214158": "uh the power of the study that you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01017-00214159-00214391": "using and then your prior odds your", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01018-00214392-00214519": "prior odds", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01019-00214519-00214615": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01020-00214616-00214846": "and you can see here a nice plot that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01021-00214848-00215039": "appears in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01022-00215040-00215358": "a paper on power analysis where for", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01023-00215359-00215582": "studies of different power and different", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01024-00215583-00215910": "prior odds you can see how likely an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01025-00215911-00216103": "effect is to be real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01026-00216104-00216319": "right so you should not trust", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01027-00216319-00216551": "underpowered studies", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01028-00216552-00216671": "you should not trust underpowered", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01029-00216671-00216958": "studies and you should you have to scale", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01030-00216959-00217039": "your", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01031-00217040-00217223": "uh interpretation of how likely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01032-00217223-00217382": "something is to be real with a given", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01033-00217383-00217958": "p-value based off of your prior", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01034-00217959-00218198": "so to quote fischer the father of modern", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01035-00218200-00218342": "statistics", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01036-00218344-00218558": "no scientific worker has a fixed level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01037-00218559-00218727": "of significance at which from year to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01038-00218728-00218934": "year in all circumstances he rejects", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01039-00218935-00219182": "hypotheses he rather gives his mind to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01040-00219183-00219439": "each particular case in the light of his", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01041-00219440-00219734": "evidence and his ideas", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01042-00219735-00219903": "so you should never", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01043-00219904-00220127": "use a fixed level of when you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01044-00220128-00220319": "thinking about p-values right and you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01045-00220319-00220503": "should not confuse these these two", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01046-00220504-00220655": "quantities", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01047-00220656-00221046": "so just to drive this home one more time", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01048-00221048-00221287": "does a p-value of less than .05 mean an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01049-00221288-00221646": "effect is 95 likely to be real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01050-00221648-00221919": "what is what is the likelihood of an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01051-00221919-00222142": "effect being real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01052-00222144-00222415": "that's the positive predictive value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01053-00222416-00222534": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01054-00222535-00222703": "that's a this is a common error that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01055-00222704-00222887": "people make does a p-value less than", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01056-00222888-00223079": "0.05 mean the same experiment will find", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01057-00223080-00223527": "a significant result 95 of the time", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01058-00223528-00223767": "no right what is that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01059-00223767-00224167": "this is steady power", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01060-00224167-00224358": "does a hypothesis tell you anything", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01061-00224359-00224463": "certain", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01062-00224464-00224791": "about the hypothesis being true or false", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01063-00224792-00224871": "no", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01064-00224871-00225055": "right it depends on your priors and you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01065-00225056-00225206": "need to be thinking probabilistically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01066-00225207-00225406": "about these things right categorical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01067-00225407-00225567": "thinking is not the right way to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01068-00225567-00225855": "approach hypothesis testing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01069-00225856-00226119": "so i'm not the only one that is up on a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01070-00226119-00226439": "you know soapbox about this topic and if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01071-00226440-00226582": "you look in the literature over the last", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01072-00226583-00226823": "like three or four years you'll see that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01073-00226823-00227046": "the american statistical association has", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01074-00227048-00227358": "been issuing many commentaries", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01075-00227359-00227534": "exactly on this topic against the idea", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01076-00227535-00227758": "of statistical significance that p less", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01077-00227759-00228031": "than .05 matters or doesn't and that the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01078-00228032-00228319": "way we talk about statistics is wrong", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01079-00228319-00228567": "and this summarizes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01080-00228567-00228767": "this appeared in nature this summarizes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01081-00228767-00228934": "some of it right so it shows the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01082-00228935-00229063": "american", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01083-00229064-00229367": "statistician came out saying don't use", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01084-00229367-00229542": "statistically significant another", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01085-00229544-00229742": "article a dozen of signatories also", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01086-00229744-00229982": "calls on authors and general editors to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01087-00229983-00230303": "disavow these terms we agree and call", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01088-00230304-00230534": "for the entire concept of statistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01089-00230535-00230791": "significance to be abandoned", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01090-00230792-00231142": "and if they did an analysis of you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01091-00231144-00231310": "800 articles across five different", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01092-00231311-00231631": "journals and showed that over 50", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01093-00231632-00231798": "are fundamentally misunderstanding this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01094-00231800-00232167": "extremely basic concept", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01095-00232167-00232319": "so the takeaway", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01096-00232319-00232439": "from this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01097-00232440-00232694": "what i've just described is don't say", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01098-00232696-00232934": "statistically significant in your papers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01099-00232935-00233103": "don't say statistically statistically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01100-00233104-00233223": "significant", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01101-00233223-00233551": "report full p values don't ever report p", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01102-00233552-00233806": "less than 0.05 and if you see a paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01103-00233807-00233975": "where someone does report p less than", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01104-00233976-00234191": "0.05 you probably shouldn't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01105-00234192-00234342": "your ears should perk up because they", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01106-00234344-00234479": "misunderstand the statistics", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01107-00234480-00234606": "fundamentally", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01108-00234607-00234798": "um and then the other thing is obviously", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01109-00234800-00235063": "interpret pre-values cautiously based", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01110-00235064-00235215": "off of your priors", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01111-00235216-00235655": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01112-00235656-00235871": "so if you're playing along", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01113-00235871-00236023": "the next question you might have is what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01114-00236023-00236151": "does that mean for the idea of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01115-00236152-00236415": "replication right doesn't this destroy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01116-00236416-00236575": "the idea of replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01117-00236576-00236703": "because what how do we think of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01118-00236704-00236855": "replication right is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01119-00236856-00237031": "someone did a test it was statistically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01120-00237032-00237303": "significant we repeat the same test is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01121-00237304-00237567": "it still statistically significant right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01122-00237567-00237751": "so the idea of replication is really a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01123-00237752-00237967": "categorical idea", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01124-00237967-00238182": "and you're absolutely right right the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01125-00238183-00238391": "idea of replication is a really terrible", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01126-00238392-00238575": "idea that perpetuates the same problems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01127-00238576-00238775": "that got us here in the first place", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01128-00238776-00239055": "right and the way to think about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01129-00239056-00239246": "the word replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01130-00239248-00239479": "uh is really as like a heuristic to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01131-00239480-00239782": "communicate efficiently not as", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01132-00239783-00239982": "the concept that you might want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01133-00239983-00240167": "ascribe to it right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01134-00240167-00240310": "so when you see the term replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01135-00240311-00240446": "there's really two ways that i've seen", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01136-00240448-00240727": "it used one is the estimated replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01137-00240728-00240815": "rate", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01138-00240816-00241023": "right which is if you run the exact same", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01139-00241023-00241198": "study with the exact same number of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01140-00241200-00241342": "participants again", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01141-00241344-00241598": "would how many times would you expect it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01142-00241600-00241758": "to replicate versus it gave you a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01143-00241759-00241998": "statistically significant result or not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01144-00242000-00242142": "and then there's sort of the colloquial", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01145-00242144-00242358": "use of the term which is we're going to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01146-00242359-00242558": "run the same study but at a much higher", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01147-00242559-00242742": "power and we're going to say something", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01148-00242744-00242934": "about whether the first study was right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01149-00242935-00243271": "in terms of the effect size and you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01150-00243271-00243463": "sort of loosely interpreted did it did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01151-00243464-00243719": "that paper was that paper honest you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01152-00243719-00243982": "know um but you should be very careful", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01153-00243983-00244358": "about the term replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01154-00244359-00244534": "because categorical thinking is a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01155-00244535-00244663": "cardinal sin", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01156-00244664-00244830": "in statistics", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01157-00244831-00244982": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01158-00244983-00245142": "okay so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01159-00245144-00245358": "we've talked a little bit about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01160-00245359-00245567": "this sort of real big problem of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01161-00245567-00245767": "thinking categorically now i want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01162-00245767-00245975": "talk about how that translates to what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01163-00245976-00246175": "we see in the literature right so how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01164-00246176-00246303": "does it happen", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01165-00246304-00246439": "when we apply", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01166-00246440-00246623": "statistical what happens when we apply", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01167-00246623-00246815": "this concept this sort of categorical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01168-00246816-00247127": "concept of things that hit our p-value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01169-00247128-00247375": "of 0.05 are true you know what happens", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01170-00247376-00247567": "when we apply that to the literature", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01171-00247567-00247879": "right and i love this xkcd you should", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01172-00247880-00248046": "keep this front of mind when you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01173-00248048-00248423": "thinking about the replication crisis so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01174-00248423-00248606": "as you can see right the scientists are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01175-00248607-00248910": "testing every color of jelly bean to see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01176-00248911-00249142": "whether jelly beans cause acne and they", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01177-00249144-00249375": "test every 20 different types of colors", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01178-00249376-00249503": "and guess what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01179-00249504-00249742": "because of random chance one of them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01180-00249744-00249958": "achieves a p-value of 0.05 because we've", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01181-00249959-00250127": "done 20 tests", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01182-00250128-00250415": "and the headline is now green jelly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01183-00250416-00250679": "beans linked to acne", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01184-00250680-00250927": "this perfectly captures the state of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01185-00250928-00251039": "affairs", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01186-00251040-00251246": "in academia right now when it comes to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01187-00251248-00251463": "social psychology right we have access", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01188-00251464-00251775": "to a newspaper or or paper that makes a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01189-00251776-00251991": "claim like this and we need to reason", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01190-00251992-00252279": "back about the process that led to that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01191-00252280-00252367": "claim", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01192-00252367-00252630": "right there's not a problem if we knew", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01193-00252631-00252791": "right that these people were testing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01194-00252792-00253006": "every single color of jelly bean it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01195-00253007-00253175": "wouldn't be a problem right we would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01196-00253176-00253455": "expect that ap value would be would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01197-00253456-00253671": "arrive that was less than 0.05 and we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01198-00253671-00253846": "would revise the way we think about that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01199-00253848-00254071": "p value right because we know they did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01200-00254071-00254294": "20 tests and we would expect one just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01201-00254296-00254591": "from random chance to be less than .05", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01202-00254592-00254855": "but when we throw all this away and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01203-00254856-00255071": "we're just left with the results that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01204-00255071-00255271": "we're looking at we have no idea how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01205-00255271-00255439": "many tests they you know they were", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01206-00255440-00255623": "running it's a lot harder to reason", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01207-00255623-00255846": "about what's going on right so this is a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01208-00255848-00256110": "really great analogy um that really sums", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01209-00256111-00256239": "up a lot of things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01210-00256240-00256598": "so how do we get there well systemically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01211-00256600-00256719": "one of the first things we can talk", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01212-00256719-00256958": "about is publication bias so this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01213-00256959-00257151": "right this is where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01214-00257152-00257430": "all 20 papers got submitted to the to a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01215-00257431-00257630": "journal right they submitted blue jelly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01216-00257631-00257839": "beans cause acne red jelly beans cause", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01217-00257840-00258023": "but the only one that the journal wants", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01218-00258023-00258223": "to publish is the one that sounds catchy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01219-00258223-00258391": "and interesting right so they only", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01220-00258392-00258687": "publish green jelly beans cause acne and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01221-00258688-00258919": "not blue jelly beans don't yellow jelly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01222-00258919-00259127": "beans don't you know teal jelly beans", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01223-00259128-00259375": "don't right so that's publication bias", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01224-00259376-00259503": "that's one way we can get into this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01225-00259504-00259719": "situation", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01226-00259719-00259991": "a similar problem is the fire drawer", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01227-00259992-00260175": "effect right which is when researchers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01228-00260176-00260455": "internalize the fact that publications", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01229-00260456-00260655": "are not going to print their", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01230-00260656-00260879": "non-significant results so instead of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01231-00260880-00261063": "even submitting them they do test and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01232-00261064-00261223": "they put them in their file drawer and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01233-00261223-00261367": "they don't submit them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01234-00261367-00261551": "right so this is a big problem we don't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01235-00261552-00261758": "know who's testing what and instead of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01236-00261759-00261934": "having you know access to all that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01237-00261935-00262151": "information we only get the result that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01238-00262152-00262423": "achieves statistical significance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01239-00262424-00262695": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01240-00262696-00262910": "luckily there are tools that we can use", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01241-00262911-00263199": "to detect this kind of problem", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01242-00263200-00263295": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01243-00263296-00263471": "uh noah's gonna be covering a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01244-00263472-00263734": "this in his talk uh next time but just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01245-00263735-00263903": "briefly this is one that i really like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01246-00263904-00264134": "this is called a funnel plot and the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01247-00264135-00264391": "idea here right is that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01248-00264392-00264591": "the larger", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01249-00264592-00264782": "n you have the more confidence you can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01250-00264783-00264934": "have in your measurement the less", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01251-00264935-00265151": "variability you would expect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01252-00265152-00265310": "in your effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01253-00265311-00265382": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01254-00265383-00265519": "the better your test the less", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01255-00265520-00265703": "variability close to the true effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01256-00265704-00266071": "size you would expect and as you get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01257-00266072-00266334": "less smaller sample sizes you expect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01258-00266335-00266534": "more variability that spreads out and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01259-00266535-00266695": "you would expect this to create a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01260-00266696-00266910": "triangle right you're getting closer to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01261-00266911-00267039": "the true average", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01262-00267040-00267119": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01263-00267120-00267206": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01264-00267207-00267367": "when you see this sort of skew it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01265-00267368-00267534": "indicates that we have problems of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01266-00267535-00267734": "publication bias and there are a bunch", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01267-00267735-00268030": "of techniques that we can use to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01268-00268031-00268327": "to analyze and tell whether this type of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01269-00268328-00268487": "thing is going on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01270-00268488-00268679": "i'll also point out that one of my", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01271-00268680-00268903": "favorite guys in this topic area ulric", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01272-00268904-00269095": "shimak has a blog where he analyzes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01273-00269096-00269247": "journals and runs metastatistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01274-00269248-00269415": "techniques on them and publishes the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01275-00269416-00269599": "results so you can go there and you can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01276-00269600-00269751": "actually look and see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01277-00269752-00270087": "you know get a little bit of a sense for", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01278-00270088-00270319": "what whether a journal is behaving in a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01279-00270320-00270534": "way that is appropriate or not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01280-00270535-00270679": "this should always be taken with a grain", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01281-00270680-00270839": "of salt all of these sort of metastatic", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01282-00270840-00271015": "analysis have a lot of potential flaws", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01283-00271016-00271391": "with them and can be very noisy but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01284-00271392-00271543": "it is something that is useful to think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01285-00271544-00271758": "about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01286-00271759-00271951": "file drawer effects are particularly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01287-00271952-00272103": "dangerous when it comes to really in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01288-00272104-00272295": "vogue research right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01289-00272296-00272479": "so if every single researcher in the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01290-00272480-00272758": "world is testing some topic of interest", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01291-00272759-00272895": "most of them are not going to get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01292-00272896-00273047": "significant results and put it in a file", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01293-00273048-00273199": "drawer some of them are going to hit", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01294-00273200-00273391": "crazy effect sizes just because of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01295-00273392-00273630": "randomness right so this is a particular", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01296-00273631-00273879": "you should be particularly aware of this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01297-00273880-00274127": "if there's a really in vogue hot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01298-00274128-00274358": "research topic you know it's more likely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01299-00274359-00274567": "that people by random chance will get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01300-00274568-00274767": "really big effect sizes just because so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01301-00274768-00274967": "many people are trying those topics so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01302-00274968-00275199": "beware of in-vogue research topics and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01303-00275200-00275423": "then for you as a researcher you should", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01304-00275424-00275575": "publish all of your findings all the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01305-00275576-00275847": "time if you can right and that includes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01306-00275848-00276095": "open access if you can't you know get a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01307-00276096-00276599": "peer review journal to publish them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01308-00276600-00276879": "so a corollary of this problem", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01309-00276880-00277119": "is what's called the winner's curse", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01310-00277120-00277271": "and once again right we have a bunch of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01311-00277272-00277439": "people sort of rolling the die trying to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01312-00277440-00277687": "get that p-value that's less than .05", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01313-00277688-00277855": "and what happens is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01314-00277856-00278134": "if you have really underpowered studies", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01315-00278135-00278382": "right the only way to get that t that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01316-00278383-00278551": "test statistic up", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01317-00278552-00278871": "is to get a really big effect size so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01318-00278872-00279071": "when you're rolling the die like this if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01319-00279072-00279247": "you have a lot of underpowered studies", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01320-00279248-00279455": "you would expect the effect sizes to be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01321-00279456-00279710": "reported to be grossly inflated because", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01322-00279711-00279863": "that's the only way that you can hit the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01323-00279864-00280087": "p-value that gets you into a journal", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01324-00280088-00280287": "right and there's a lot of good analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01325-00280288-00280519": "of this but basically you know what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01326-00280520-00280767": "happens is generally across the board", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01327-00280768-00280958": "right you can expect the real effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01328-00280959-00281287": "sizes to be a half to 1 100th of what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01329-00281288-00281367": "gets", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01330-00281368-00281543": "reported and that's like a really rough", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01331-00281544-00281719": "heuristic but it's just something to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01332-00281720-00281919": "keep in mind that there is a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01333-00281920-00282191": "inflation uh in the literature in terms", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01334-00282192-00282439": "of the real effect sizes um and it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01335-00282440-00282599": "good to just kind of you know if you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01336-00282600-00282719": "going to try to build an intervention", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01337-00282720-00282887": "based off of some social psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01338-00282888-00283039": "study beware", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01339-00283040-00283647": "and revise your estimates down", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01340-00283648-00283815": "so i just touched on ways that we sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01341-00283816-00283991": "of systematically get to this problem", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01342-00283992-00284191": "where we're left with this newspaper and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01343-00284192-00284399": "we have no access to this stuff next i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01344-00284400-00284623": "want to talk about um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01345-00284624-00284751": "how this happens as an individual", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01346-00284752-00284943": "researcher right so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01347-00284944-00285079": "as an individual researcher you can do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01348-00285080-00285206": "the same thing you can test 20", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01349-00285207-00285503": "hypotheses and report one right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01350-00285504-00285710": "you're creating the the same type of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01351-00285711-00285895": "problem as the systemic issues of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01352-00285896-00286167": "publication bias and file drawer effects", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01353-00286168-00286430": "so i lovingly entitled this how not to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01354-00286431-00286775": "be a bad researcher", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01355-00286776-00286919": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01356-00286920-00287079": "all of these are just variations on this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01357-00287080-00287279": "theme basically of running a bunch of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01358-00287280-00287591": "hypothesis tests and um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01359-00287592-00287767": "only reporting the ones that hit but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01360-00287768-00288039": "that comes in a lot of different styles", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01361-00288040-00288263": "right and we typically call these things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01362-00288264-00288415": "questionable research practices or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01363-00288416-00288679": "research degrees of freedom", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01364-00288680-00288887": "and a bunch of other different names but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01365-00288888-00289079": "i just want to point out a few examples", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01366-00289080-00289279": "of how you might", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01367-00289280-00289543": "accidentally do this right so one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01368-00289544-00289775": "example is optimal stopping right so you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01369-00289776-00289999": "run a test on 10 people you check to see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01370-00290000-00290191": "if it was significant you add another", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01371-00290192-00290358": "five people you check to see if it was", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01372-00290359-00290534": "significant you run another five people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01373-00290535-00290703": "you checked and if you keep checking", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01374-00290704-00290854": "that all of a sudden we've tested our", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01375-00290855-00291087": "hypothesis 20 times right we've done", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01376-00291088-00291263": "multiple hypothesis testing so if you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01377-00291264-00291575": "see a paper that has some weird n", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01378-00291576-00291743": "that doesn't seem like they picked it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01379-00291744-00291910": "ahead of time", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01380-00291911-00292087": "perhaps you know this could be a reason", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01381-00292088-00292223": "why and your ear should perk up a little", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01382-00292224-00292406": "bit when you see that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01383-00292407-00292558": "another thing that i've seen in many", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01384-00292559-00292734": "papers that i think are interesting in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01385-00292735-00292839": "psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01386-00292840-00292910": "is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01387-00292911-00293199": "all people combine weird sub groups of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01388-00293200-00293351": "tests and experiments together and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01389-00293352-00293671": "running the analysis on those groups on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01390-00293672-00293879": "the individual subsets you know they run", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01391-00293880-00293967": "all these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01392-00293968-00294151": "interesting combinations", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01393-00294152-00294423": "of analysis right and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01394-00294424-00294551": "once again", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01395-00294552-00294767": "you know it's very easy to test lots and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01396-00294768-00295110": "lots of hypotheses um very quickly and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01397-00295111-00295367": "only report the one that that hits right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01398-00295368-00295679": "so beware if if a paper reports some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01399-00295680-00295951": "very unusual combination of experimental", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01400-00295952-00296175": "results that they that they tested and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01401-00296176-00296327": "they don't report that they tested", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01402-00296328-00296519": "individual things or things that make", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01403-00296520-00296606": "sense", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01404-00296607-00296782": "you know your ears should perk up that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01405-00296783-00296910": "perhaps they tried a bunch of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01406-00296911-00297039": "combinations of things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01407-00297040-00297287": "and they only published the one that hit", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01408-00297288-00297703": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01409-00297704-00297887": "and again testing many hypotheses and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01410-00297888-00298087": "only reporting the successes very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01411-00298088-00298303": "similar similar problem this one i'll", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01412-00298304-00298671": "say like our green jelly bean example", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01413-00298672-00298839": "right if you read a paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01414-00298840-00298999": "and there's some weird mediating", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01415-00299000-00299247": "variable like why are green jelly beans", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01416-00299248-00299447": "causing acne why isn't it just jelly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01417-00299448-00299695": "beans causing acne right that doesn't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01418-00299696-00299975": "make any sense perhaps they tested all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01419-00299976-00300182": "the colors of jelly beans and they just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01420-00300183-00300382": "reported the one that was that happened", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01421-00300383-00300615": "to hit right so if you see weird", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01422-00300616-00300839": "mediating variables or weird very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01423-00300840-00301127": "specific you know conditions that's a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01424-00301128-00301391": "sign for you to be a little bit worried", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01425-00301392-00301591": "about the report the the results that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01426-00301592-00301743": "are being reported", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01427-00301744-00302047": "and then another one is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01428-00302048-00302134": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01429-00302135-00302310": "people that have a narrative agenda", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01430-00302311-00302567": "motivated research right so if you see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01431-00302568-00302710": "someone that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01432-00302711-00302895": "every study they ever publish all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01433-00302896-00303110": "supports one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01434-00303111-00303415": "idea and it all you know every single", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01435-00303416-00303654": "test is spotless and there's never any", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01436-00303655-00303871": "question you know there's never any", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01437-00303872-00304071": "results that don't hit significance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01438-00304072-00304223": "maybe they're testing something obvious", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01439-00304224-00304375": "i mean maybe they've hit on something", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01440-00304376-00304527": "really good you have to use your prior", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01441-00304528-00304799": "and your intuition here but this is also", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01442-00304800-00305071": "you know something to be very uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01443-00305072-00305287": "cognizant of and just as an example", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01444-00305288-00305558": "daryl bem our our guy from the very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01445-00305559-00305847": "first story you know he has sort of an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01446-00305848-00306015": "interview said exactly this type of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01447-00306016-00306215": "thing right i gather data to show how my", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01448-00306216-00306406": "point would be made i use it as a point", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01449-00306407-00306543": "of persuasion", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01450-00306544-00306639": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01451-00306640-00306782": "probably the type of studies that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01452-00306783-00306943": "someone that has this approach to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01453-00306944-00307151": "research is putting out are not ones", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01454-00307152-00307775": "that you should be trusting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01455-00307776-00307934": "okay so we've talked about testing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01456-00307935-00308223": "multiple hypotheses and reporting one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01457-00308224-00308327": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01458-00308328-00308463": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01459-00308464-00308647": "i want to be clear that it's okay to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01460-00308648-00308863": "test multiple hypotheses", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01461-00308864-00309087": "if you report everything that you do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01462-00309088-00309279": "right the the big thing is that we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01463-00309280-00309534": "understand the landscape of what you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01464-00309535-00309703": "doing so we can revise how we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01465-00309704-00309934": "interpreting your results appropriately", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01466-00309935-00310087": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01467-00310088-00310382": "but so far we've talked about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01468-00310383-00310606": "reporting hypotheses that you have come", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01469-00310607-00310823": "up with without seeing the data and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01470-00310824-00311151": "something that you really should not do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01471-00311152-00311310": "is called harking right and that's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01472-00311311-00311534": "coming up with a hypothesis hypothesis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01473-00311535-00311703": "after looking at the data that you've", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01474-00311704-00311934": "collected right hypothesizing after the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01475-00311935-00312158": "results are known", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01476-00312159-00312471": "right so if if someone is running a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01477-00312472-00312734": "study and they think before that study", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01478-00312735-00312919": "right i think there could be like a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01479-00312920-00313087": "linear relationship between these two", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01480-00313088-00313271": "quantities and then they collect a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01481-00313272-00313479": "little bit of data and it shows a linear", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01482-00313480-00313582": "relationship between those two", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01483-00313583-00313815": "quantities that's incredibly powerful", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01484-00313816-00313910": "evidence", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01485-00313911-00314039": "that there is probably a linear", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01486-00314040-00314143": "relationship between those two", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01487-00314144-00314319": "quantities right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01488-00314320-00314543": "if on the flip side you collect a bunch", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01489-00314544-00314647": "of data", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01490-00314648-00314782": "and you look at it all in all the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01491-00314783-00314927": "different you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01492-00314928-00315199": "combinations of things and you see that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01493-00315200-00315358": "a couple of variables have a linear", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01494-00315359-00315534": "relationship well there's all sorts of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01495-00315535-00315687": "patterns that you might expect in the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01496-00315688-00315999": "data right and if you then act like you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01497-00316000-00316199": "predicted that there was a linear", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01498-00316200-00316358": "relationship when you see the linear", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01499-00316359-00316519": "relationship or you fit a line to that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01500-00316520-00316639": "and you show that it's a really good", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01501-00316640-00316910": "line right that's incredibly misleading", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01502-00316911-00317182": "right the assumption is that you've made", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01503-00317183-00317510": "a a priori hypothesis and then you test", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01504-00317511-00317679": "it afterwards right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01505-00317680-00317847": "so this is this can be very difficult to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01506-00317848-00318030": "detect and it's very important that you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01507-00318031-00318215": "don't do this one version of this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01508-00318216-00318454": "trying a ton of different variations in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01509-00318455-00318630": "your modeling technique right and i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01510-00318631-00318767": "think so many people you know i've been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01511-00318768-00318934": "guilty of this so many people don't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01512-00318935-00319087": "realize what they're doing when they're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01513-00319088-00319303": "doing this but right you you throw out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01514-00319304-00319543": "an outlier and that didn't work maybe", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01515-00319544-00319671": "you know you normalize your data", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01516-00319672-00319815": "slightly differently that doesn't work", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01517-00319816-00320158": "you whatever you like impute your data", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01518-00320159-00320295": "the missing parts of your data a little", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01519-00320296-00320423": "bit that doesn't work you know you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01520-00320424-00320558": "slightly change", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01521-00320559-00320710": "you know you you end up running 50", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01522-00320711-00320927": "different variations of some tests", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01523-00320928-00321167": "one of them happens to hit right like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01524-00321168-00321263": "this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01525-00321264-00321503": "a sort of textbook something that you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01526-00321504-00321663": "should not do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01527-00321664-00322054": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01528-00322055-00322343": "which is not to say so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01529-00322344-00322487": "it's textbook something you should not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01530-00322488-00322751": "do if you report that data as", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01531-00322752-00322934": "you have come up with the hypothesis a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01532-00322935-00323215": "priori right but it is okay", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01533-00323216-00323430": "to collect some data", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01534-00323431-00323743": "and mine it you know like look for", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01535-00323744-00323927": "relationships as long as you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01536-00323928-00324182": "extremely explicit about the fact that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01537-00324183-00324399": "what you did was is an exploratory", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01538-00324400-00324510": "analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01539-00324511-00324654": "right so there are two ways we think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01540-00324655-00324854": "about these these kinds of studies we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01541-00324855-00325047": "can have exploratory studies and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01542-00325048-00325295": "confirmatory studies right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01543-00325296-00325551": "and the textbook example for this one is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01544-00325552-00325991": "john gottman who's really famous as a um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01545-00325992-00326158": "researcher on divorce", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01546-00326159-00326327": "right and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01547-00326328-00326463": "he has good", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01548-00326464-00326654": "you know good ideas", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01549-00326655-00326847": "a lot of you know he's very successful", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01550-00326848-00326967": "but if you look at his website the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01551-00326968-00327110": "number one most frequently asked", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01552-00327111-00327230": "question is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01553-00327231-00327575": "can dr gottman really predict whether a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01554-00327576-00327830": "couple will get divorced with 94", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01555-00327831-00327958": "accuracy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01556-00327959-00328182": "and the answer is no obviously no one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01557-00328183-00328358": "can ever predict human behavior with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01558-00328359-00328519": "that kind of accuracy that's insane", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01559-00328520-00328687": "right i mean maybe you can predict kids", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01560-00328688-00328887": "like sweets with that kind of i don't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01561-00328888-00329087": "know probably not even that right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01562-00329088-00329334": "no you can't right and where that came", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01563-00329335-00329615": "from is the fact that john gottman did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01564-00329616-00329806": "an exploratory study", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01565-00329807-00330030": "and people interpreted it as a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01566-00330031-00330230": "confirmatory study right so what he did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01567-00330231-00330343": "was he had a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01568-00330344-00330727": "group of you know 20 couples he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01569-00330728-00330854": "measured a bunch of things about those", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01570-00330855-00331047": "couples and he looked to see which one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01571-00331048-00331206": "got divorced", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01572-00331207-00331367": "and then he went back and he separated", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01573-00331368-00331503": "the divorce", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01574-00331504-00331703": "couples from the couples that didn't get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01575-00331704-00331830": "divorced and he said what are the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01576-00331831-00332087": "relationships in this group of couples", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01577-00332088-00332319": "this group of ten couples say that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01578-00332320-00332503": "didn't get rid of divorced", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01579-00332504-00332727": "that is different from the ones that did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01580-00332728-00332967": "right and it turns out if you have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01581-00332968-00333175": "10 couples there's going to be lots of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01582-00333176-00333375": "things that separate 10 any 10 couples", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01583-00333376-00333567": "from any other 10 couples right you can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01584-00333568-00333734": "exp you can get 94", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01585-00333735-00334103": "on any two groups of 10 couples right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01586-00334104-00334382": "and this is what got confused right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01587-00334383-00334567": "everyone started reporting he can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01588-00334568-00334854": "predict divorce with 94 accuracy what he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01589-00334855-00335103": "can do is look at those things and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01590-00335104-00335254": "reason about them right like oh there", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01591-00335255-00335399": "are relationships in this couple that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01592-00335400-00335519": "aren't in this couple does that make", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01593-00335520-00335710": "sense would that predict divorce and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01594-00335711-00336006": "then he can run a confirmatory study", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01595-00336007-00336151": "to um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01596-00336152-00336375": "test whether those relationships", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01597-00336376-00336478": "actually", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01598-00336479-00336823": "um are predictive of divorce right and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01599-00336824-00337006": "he has done some of that work and it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01600-00337007-00337151": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01601-00337152-00337358": "obviously nowhere near 94", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01602-00337359-00337534": "but this is sort of a textbook example", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01603-00337535-00337758": "of exploratory versus confirmatory", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01604-00337759-00337878": "studies these are two separate", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01605-00337879-00338119": "techniques that you should use um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01606-00338120-00338271": "when you're thinking about these things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01607-00338272-00338503": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01608-00338504-00338710": "this is another example", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01609-00338711-00338919": "of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01610-00338920-00339151": "sort of a p hacking a very textbook p", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01611-00339152-00339439": "hacking example this is brian wansink", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01612-00339440-00339591": "from cornell", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01613-00339592-00339751": "basically every research study that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01614-00339752-00339975": "you've heard of on food you know this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01615-00339976-00340287": "guy wrote and he ended up having to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01616-00340288-00340654": "resign because of academic misconduct um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01617-00340655-00340863": "and he has blog posts where he talks you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01618-00340864-00341054": "know he talks about p hacking shouldn't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01619-00341055-00341310": "be confused with deep data dives and he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01620-00341311-00341606": "basically goes through and describes p", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01621-00341607-00341767": "hacking his data and doing exactly what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01622-00341768-00341871": "we're talking about coming up with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01623-00341872-00342127": "hypotheses after the fact applying them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01624-00342128-00342287": "and um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01625-00342288-00342463": "and then reporting them as if they were", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01626-00342464-00342830": "a priority hypothesis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01627-00342831-00343127": "so there are a few tools that we can use", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01628-00343128-00343334": "to do researcher specific", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01629-00343335-00343454": "analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01630-00343455-00343534": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01631-00343535-00343775": "once again ulrich shimak has a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01632-00343776-00344087": "personalized p-value web page where he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01633-00344088-00344382": "ranks the top 400 psychologists again", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01634-00344383-00344534": "interpret this with an incredible amount", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01635-00344535-00344847": "of caution it's very noisy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01636-00344848-00345078": "but you can go through and see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01637-00345079-00345271": "some meta statistics about all of these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01638-00345272-00345463": "different researchers based off of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01639-00345464-00345630": "really rough analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01640-00345631-00345758": "and one of the things you'll notice if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01641-00345759-00345951": "you look at it is that he will", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01642-00345952-00346254": "automatically reduce the alpha level of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01643-00346255-00346478": "significance for many of the researchers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01644-00346479-00346671": "and that's a good heuristic to have i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01645-00346672-00346958": "think in general right so you know if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01646-00346959-00347215": "everyone's p hacking at a level of 0.05", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01647-00347216-00347478": "and we reduce the level of results we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01648-00347479-00347743": "accept as being meaningful to 0.01 we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01649-00347744-00347927": "going to throw out a lot of the bad", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01650-00347928-00348175": "results right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01651-00348176-00348327": "so that's just like a heuristic that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01652-00348328-00348519": "that might be useful and there's also a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01653-00348520-00348775": "ton of metastatistical tools to look at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01654-00348776-00348943": "bias and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01655-00348944-00349110": "to detect all of the types of things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01656-00349111-00349278": "that we've been talking about in groups", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01657-00349279-00349415": "of literature which once again i'm not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01658-00349416-00349615": "really going to go over them but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01659-00349616-00349782": "noah will cover some of these things at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01660-00349783-00349930": "the next", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01661-00349931-00350295": "level um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01662-00350296-00350382": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01663-00350383-00350534": "a couple of other things that i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01664-00350535-00350727": "are really important just to go over", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01665-00350728-00350871": "when it comes to how not to be a bad", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01666-00350872-00351087": "researcher we've talked a little bit", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01667-00351088-00351319": "about power analysis and the problems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01668-00351320-00351503": "that are associated with low power", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01669-00351504-00351758": "studies right and so it's always", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01670-00351759-00351958": "important when you're doing research to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01671-00351959-00352239": "perform an a priori power analysis right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01672-00352240-00352454": "so you you should guess how big of an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01673-00352455-00352663": "effect size you might", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01674-00352664-00352782": "expect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01675-00352783-00352910": "and then", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01676-00352911-00353103": "see how large of a sample size you would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01677-00353104-00353391": "need in order to detect that that um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01678-00353392-00353615": "effect and this is just to preserve your", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01679-00353616-00353815": "time right if you're running studies", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01680-00353816-00353982": "where your study is severely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01681-00353983-00354134": "underpowered you're not going to be able", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01682-00354135-00354375": "to detect real effects when the real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01683-00354376-00354591": "effects are there right and other people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01684-00354592-00354743": "are not going to trust your work if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01685-00354744-00354871": "you're running underpowered studies all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01686-00354872-00355078": "the time so you should always", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01687-00355079-00355334": "do an a priori power analysis and these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01688-00355335-00355551": "are a few links i'll be sending this out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01689-00355552-00355678": "but these are a few links that sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01690-00355679-00355951": "talk about how to do that and a couple", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01691-00355952-00356127": "of tools that you can use in order to do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01692-00356128-00356471": "that when you go to do your own research", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01693-00356472-00356687": "and a corollary of the fact that you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01694-00356688-00356951": "should do an a priori power analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01695-00356952-00357103": "is you should be where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01696-00357104-00357247": "researchers who", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01697-00357248-00357471": "start with an n e n equals 20 right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01698-00357472-00357567": "because this is kind of like the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01699-00357568-00357767": "standard practice in social psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01700-00357768-00357927": "over the last several years and this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01701-00357928-00358103": "indicates that this researcher probably", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01702-00358104-00358430": "did not do an a priority power analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01703-00358431-00358663": "and i would suggest that you should so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01704-00358664-00358903": "if if you run into a paper where there's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01705-00358904-00359095": "an n equals 20 you should say what is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01706-00359096-00359367": "the effect that this person is testing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01707-00359368-00359543": "how big do i think that effect is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01708-00359544-00359710": "probably going to be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01709-00359711-00359815": "and then", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01710-00359816-00359975": "how big of a sample size would that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01711-00359976-00360175": "person need to detect that effect and if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01712-00360176-00360310": "the sample size they have in the paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01713-00360311-00360558": "is 20 and they need a sample size of 200", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01714-00360559-00360782": "or 500 because you you know based off of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01715-00360783-00360967": "your intuition you know perhaps you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01716-00360968-00361103": "should not trust", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01717-00361104-00361471": "the results of that paper right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01718-00361472-00361591": "the other thing that's really important", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01719-00361592-00361719": "to know is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01720-00361720-00361958": "pre-registration right so this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01721-00361959-00362206": "gaining momentum here a few places where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01722-00362207-00362391": "you can pre-register your studies this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01723-00362392-00362623": "mitigates so many of the problems right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01724-00362624-00362871": "like you you a priori you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01725-00362872-00363095": "write down what hypotheses you have the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01726-00363096-00363327": "data analysis techniques you use", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01727-00363328-00363503": "and more and more of the major", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01728-00363504-00363687": "universities are signing up to this sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01729-00363688-00363895": "of pre-registration challenge", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01730-00363896-00364063": "and papers that are doing this and many", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01731-00364064-00364230": "journals get a badge that they were", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01732-00364231-00364463": "pre-registered so this is a great", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01733-00364464-00364575": "indicator that you should trust the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01734-00364576-00364823": "paper and this is something that you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01735-00364824-00366503": "know you should do for yourself", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01736-00366504-00366687": "yeah it's a fair point", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01737-00366688-00366967": "i mean i these systems aren't foolproof", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01738-00366968-00367119": "right and i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01739-00367120-00367295": "there's sort of there's a certain level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01740-00367296-00367623": "of um trust and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01741-00367624-00367799": "inability to detect real fraud and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01742-00367800-00367958": "manipulation that sort of goes along", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01743-00367959-00368119": "with all these things right i think like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01744-00368120-00368247": "sort of at the end of the day trusting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01745-00368248-00368599": "your gut uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01746-00368600-00368839": "is important right and and i think a lot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01747-00368840-00368967": "of these things come out over time i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01748-00368968-00369119": "mean we'll talk in a second about some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01749-00369120-00369319": "examples of fraud um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01750-00369320-00373710": "but yeah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01751-00373711-00373782": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01752-00373783-00374247": "yeah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01753-00374248-00374399": "yeah i mean i think in general all of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01754-00374400-00374567": "these sorts of techniques if you're an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01755-00374568-00374799": "intelligent person you can find a way", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01756-00374800-00375087": "around a lot many of them right like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01757-00375088-00375287": "there are a bunch of data analysis tools", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01758-00375288-00375519": "to detect fraud or to to sort of figure", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01759-00375520-00375815": "out whether your data is realistic and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01760-00375816-00375934": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01761-00375935-00376127": "it's it's like security right and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01762-00376128-00376278": "privacy right like there's sort of an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01763-00376279-00376575": "escalating war where at some level it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01764-00376576-00376743": "certainly i think it's certainly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01765-00376744-00377015": "possible to dupe almost any of these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01766-00377016-00377167": "things the question is just how much", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01767-00377168-00377334": "effort are you putting in how difficult", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01768-00377335-00377510": "is it to make it and how much are we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01769-00377511-00377743": "going to rely on the good intent of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01770-00377744-00377895": "people who want to contribute good", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01771-00377896-00378054": "research you know there is evidence of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01772-00378055-00378327": "fraud right people do game the system", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01773-00378328-00378447": "but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01774-00378448-00378702": "not much it doesn't seem like right like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01775-00378703-00378854": "people people do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01776-00378855-00379078": "you know there is a huge cost if you get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01777-00379079-00379302": "caught it is harder it's getting harder", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01778-00379303-00379502": "and harder to do that kind of thing and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01779-00379503-00379719": "i think you know so there's sort of this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01780-00379720-00379895": "question of the social system and how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01781-00379896-00380134": "well we we are capable of rooting that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01782-00380135-00380430": "out and um so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01783-00380431-00380639": "yeah and i mean honestly if it's an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01784-00380640-00380767": "interesting enough effect that you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01785-00380768-00380999": "pre-register um that and an effect size", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01786-00381000-00381158": "that's so surprising right other people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01787-00381159-00381358": "are going to replicate it and you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01788-00381359-00381527": "ideally they're sort of system level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01789-00381528-00381751": "checks no one researcher is really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01790-00381752-00381943": "writing a narrative for the entire field", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01791-00381944-00382158": "but it's a great it's a great point you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01792-00382159-00382295": "know and if you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01793-00382296-00382447": "i think that there's plenty of open", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01794-00382448-00382599": "space to actually work to address this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01795-00382600-00382758": "kind of thing you know like if you can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01796-00382759-00383078": "think of new systems to help um prevent", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01797-00383079-00383230": "this kind of thing new ways to collect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01798-00383231-00383510": "data that are verified or you know this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01799-00383511-00383678": "kind of thing where you really can't do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01800-00383679-00383878": "your study a priority then register it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01801-00383879-00384039": "and then sort of like input it after the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01802-00384040-00384230": "fact and act like you you're acting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01803-00384231-00384447": "honestly you know um but hopefully we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01804-00384448-00385082": "not there yet in terms of trust you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01805-00385083-00385295": "um yeah so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01806-00385296-00385415": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01807-00385416-00385623": "so that sort of concludes this section", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01808-00385624-00385830": "of the talk where i think we basically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01809-00385831-00386247": "covered methods you know and uh i wanna", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01810-00386248-00386454": "i hope you know you feel reasonably", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01811-00386455-00386615": "confident about all of these sorts of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01812-00386616-00386799": "things that we've listed here the next", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01813-00386800-00386943": "thing i want to talk about just very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01814-00386944-00387223": "briefly is some of these system problems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01815-00387224-00387495": "like fraud right so the two other issues", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01816-00387496-00387671": "that i that i just want to briefly talk", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01817-00387672-00387902": "about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01818-00387903-00388175": "are fraud and hype", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01819-00388176-00388343": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01820-00388344-00388463": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01821-00388464-00388630": "this is probably the most canonical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01822-00388631-00388871": "example in social psychology of fraud", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01823-00388872-00389102": "this man is dedrick staple he's actually", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01824-00389103-00389367": "written a book now on it and he's gained", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01825-00389368-00389495": "a lot actually", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01826-00389496-00389695": "seems like a very successful career over", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01827-00389696-00390158": "telling the story of his fraud um but he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01828-00390159-00390382": "had 58 retractions and it came out that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01829-00390383-00390599": "he was making up everything that he was", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01830-00390600-00390895": "doing and this man has published a paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01831-00390896-00391143": "on basically everything of interest in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01832-00391144-00391327": "social psychology that you can imagine", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01833-00391328-00391478": "so like a couple of the papers i wrote", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01834-00391479-00391719": "down here in science he had a paper that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01835-00391720-00391895": "showed physical environments that are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01836-00391896-00392095": "more disordered promotes stereotyping", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01837-00392096-00392247": "and discrimination", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01838-00392248-00392430": "right or carnivores you might have heard", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01839-00392431-00392606": "of this one carnivores are more selfish", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01840-00392607-00392863": "than uh vegetarians", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01841-00392864-00393102": "or ads affect how consumers think about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01842-00393103-00393254": "themselves you know these sorts of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01843-00393255-00393463": "findings you if you look through", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01844-00393464-00393663": "everything that this that he's written", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01845-00393664-00393847": "you will find something on a topic of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01846-00393848-00394151": "interest to you um in social psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01847-00394152-00394239": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01848-00394240-00394478": "um fascinating example and actually if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01849-00394479-00394727": "you look at retraction watch at the top", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01850-00394728-00394943": "uh retraction people actually the worst", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01851-00394944-00395215": "uh frauds are anesthesiologists there", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01852-00395216-00395399": "are two anesthesiologists", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01853-00395400-00395623": "that have like had to retract hundreds", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01854-00395624-00395910": "of papers so but in social science this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01855-00395911-00396175": "man is the is the winner", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01856-00396176-00396358": "another famous example which i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01857-00396359-00396502": "matt is going to cover more in his", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01858-00396503-00396839": "lecture that's recent is dan ariely um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01859-00396840-00397087": "and a textbook textbook fraud right like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01860-00397088-00397158": "this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01861-00397159-00397447": "the the data in his study um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01862-00397448-00397639": "should follow a normal distribution it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01863-00397640-00397767": "widely known that it should follow a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01864-00397768-00397927": "normal distribution and the data was", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01865-00397928-00398206": "like a flat box right so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01866-00398207-00398510": "super obvious there was no denying it um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01867-00398511-00398710": "and it's been a very popular scandal in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01868-00398711-00398999": "the news so fraud does happen", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01869-00399000-00399087": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01870-00399088-00399358": "a good place to go to just double check", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01871-00399359-00399487": "what's going on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01872-00399488-00399727": "um is retractiondatabase.org", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01873-00399728-00399895": "it has this nice interface where you can", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01874-00399896-00400039": "put in the doi of the paper you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01875-00400040-00400215": "interested in or search for an author or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01876-00400216-00400391": "whatever and it they catalog all the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01877-00400392-00400639": "retractions that are that exist so it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01878-00400640-00400927": "a really useful um tool", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01879-00400928-00401134": "and i would highly encourage you to use", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01880-00401135-00401295": "it because", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01881-00401296-00401495": "there's other research that's out there", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01882-00401496-00401719": "right now that has been suggesting that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01883-00401720-00401910": "replicated paper and this seems to be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01884-00401911-00402063": "you know there are many people that have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01885-00402064-00402263": "looked into this that findings that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01886-00402264-00402454": "aren't replicated or findings that are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01887-00402455-00402630": "retracted tend to be cited and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01888-00402631-00402839": "outrageously", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01889-00402840-00403182": "outrageously more than the replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01890-00403183-00403447": "attempts or the findings that the other", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01891-00403448-00403639": "research right because these types of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01892-00403640-00403815": "findings tend to be really blockbuster", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01893-00403816-00404127": "findings right so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01894-00404128-00404351": "don't cite papers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01895-00404352-00404591": "that have been replicated that fail", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01896-00404592-00404751": "replication or that are retracted it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01897-00404752-00405015": "really important to uh to double check", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01898-00405016-00405134": "what you're citing and what you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01899-00405135-00405310": "reading", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01900-00405311-00405454": "um and i think a lot of people are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01901-00405455-00405671": "guilty of just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01902-00405672-00405871": "reading the title and the abstract and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01903-00405872-00406151": "citing the paper please you know please", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01904-00406152-00406302": "don't do that when you're writing papers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01905-00406303-00406454": "it's important to really understand the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01906-00406455-00406791": "background material", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01907-00406792-00407023": "another one that i think we're all aware", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01908-00407024-00407254": "of you're all aware of is hype", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01909-00407255-00407430": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01910-00407431-00407647": "we definitely live in an ecosystem that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01911-00407648-00407975": "rewards eye-catching claims you know big", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01912-00407976-00408239": "narratives you and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01913-00408240-00408471": "doesn't necessarily reward extremely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01914-00408472-00408663": "rigorous nuanced", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01915-00408664-00408951": "uh methodology right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01916-00408952-00409110": "you need to find something interesting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01917-00409111-00409310": "in order to get a job a lot in a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01918-00409311-00409670": "cases right um and so i you know when it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01919-00409671-00409870": "comes to the news we kind of expect this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01920-00409871-00410055": "we expect people to oversell and to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01921-00410056-00410247": "oversimplify and to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01922-00410247-00410351": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01923-00410352-00410455": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01924-00410456-00410695": "conflate this is a really bad one and i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01925-00410696-00410887": "it bothers me a lot conflates", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01926-00410888-00411095": "statistically significant with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01927-00411096-00411295": "significant right like as we talked", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01928-00411296-00411470": "about before", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01929-00411471-00411647": "p values and statistical significance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01930-00411647-00411807": "means we can have some amount of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01931-00411808-00412070": "confidence or not that this the effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01932-00412071-00412230": "is real not that the effect is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01933-00412231-00412374": "meaningful not that there's a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01934-00412375-00412534": "significant you know that it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01935-00412535-00412782": "significant to people right that's the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01936-00412783-00413007": "effect size whether the effect matters", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01937-00413008-00413143": "is how big of an effect it is not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01938-00413143-00413359": "whether it exists or not and people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01939-00413360-00413622": "really you know conflate statistically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01940-00413623-00413878": "significant to mean meaningful when it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01941-00413879-00414087": "when it does not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01942-00414088-00414199": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01943-00414200-00414455": "but i think for us as researchers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01944-00414456-00414607": "you'd be surprised how much this kind of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01945-00414608-00414807": "stuff actually appears in papers too", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01946-00414808-00414959": "right like people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01947-00414960-00415134": "will um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01948-00415135-00415263": "it's important to be vigilant when", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01949-00415264-00415391": "you're reading papers and so i pulled", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01950-00415392-00415703": "out a couple of pretty famous plots that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01951-00415704-00415870": "um get thrown around the research to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01952-00415871-00416055": "justify a couple things one of them is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01953-00416056-00416303": "from the stereotype threat um the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01954-00416304-00416503": "canonical stereotype threat people where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01955-00416504-00416726": "we're conditioning adjusting by prior", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01956-00416727-00416982": "sat store there have been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01957-00416983-00417126": "we'll talk about this in a lot more", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01958-00417127-00417263": "detail there's a lot of nuance with all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01959-00417264-00417495": "of these things but there have been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01960-00417496-00417726": "you know dozens of papers back and forth", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01961-00417727-00418039": "about how misinterpreted this plot has", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01962-00418039-00418191": "been and how misinterpreted the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01963-00418192-00418463": "stereotype threat literature has been um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01964-00418464-00418591": "and so this is kind of a canonical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01965-00418592-00418766": "example that gets argued about whether", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01966-00418767-00418878": "you should be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01967-00418879-00419199": "you know basically taking out the sat", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01968-00419200-00419318": "score", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01969-00419319-00419591": "prior to focus on the differences right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01970-00419592-00419879": "this is another one that uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01971-00419880-00420222": "is a very popular paper uh that that get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01972-00420223-00420455": "in a very popular graph that gets thrown", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01973-00420456-00420583": "around quite a bit", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01974-00420584-00420775": "uh dan ariely called this i think his", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01975-00420776-00421022": "favorite plot and all of social science", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01976-00421023-00421239": "and this is one for the default effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01977-00421239-00421383": "right so you may have heard of this idea", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01978-00421384-00421631": "that you know for organ donors if you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01979-00421632-00421766": "make the form", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01980-00421767-00421847": "say", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01981-00421847-00422110": "you know do you want to opt out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01982-00422112-00422310": "people will", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01983-00422312-00422655": "stay opted in at insane levels right and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01984-00422656-00422870": "if you want to opt in you know no one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01985-00422871-00423047": "will opt in because it's such a cut and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01986-00423047-00423214": "the story is it's such a complex", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01987-00423215-00423318": "decision", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01988-00423319-00423487": "that people will just go with the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01989-00423488-00423695": "default you know that it's it's too", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01990-00423696-00423879": "complex and abstract so they just trust", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01991-00423880-00424039": "the default and this is the plot that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01992-00424039-00424310": "gets shown to justify that well it turns", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01993-00424312-00424583": "out that all of these countries it's not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01994-00424584-00424863": "um opt out in these countries", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01995-00424864-00425127": "in these countries it's presumed consent", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01996-00425128-00425270": "right so these countries you don't make", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01997-00425271-00425518": "a choice in order to opt out you have to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01998-00425519-00425718": "mail something in you know you have to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-01999-00425719-00425887": "think about it and decide and mail", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02000-00425888-00426070": "something in and when they actually do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02001-00426071-00426239": "look at the statistics of opt-in versus", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02002-00426239-00426366": "opt-out there's a little bit of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02003-00426367-00426559": "difference you know there it makes a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02004-00426560-00426735": "little bit of a difference but it's it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02005-00426735-00426951": "is not this difference right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02006-00426952-00427063": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02007-00427064-00427166": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02008-00427167-00427351": "no country no policy has been adopted", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02009-00427352-00427622": "that is opt-in opt-out when it comes to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02010-00427623-00427887": "organ donation right but this this plot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02011-00427888-00428039": "is a super famous one that gets thrown", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02012-00428039-00428175": "around quite a bit and has a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02013-00428176-00428375": "controversy surrounding it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02014-00428376-00428751": "and that's right out of a paper right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02015-00428752-00429055": "here's another example this is uh from", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02016-00429056-00429422": "michael walker's book why we sleep", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02017-00429423-00429622": "this is the real data this is the data", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02018-00429623-00429822": "that he's citing in the book", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02019-00429823-00430055": "this is the plot that he put in the book", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02020-00430056-00430214": "you might notice", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02021-00430215-00430295": "that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02022-00430296-00430535": "the five-hour bar is missing because it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02023-00430535-00430727": "doesn't fit with the narrative", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02024-00430728-00430887": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02025-00430888-00431031": "you know there's some examples of just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02026-00431032-00431199": "really egregious stuff when it comes to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02027-00431200-00431575": "plots so my heuristics on looking at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02028-00431576-00431791": "plots and reading papers tend to be one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02029-00431792-00432007": "mind the axes you'd be surprised you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02030-00432008-00432103": "know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02031-00432104-00432279": "it can be hard to look through the paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02032-00432280-00432422": "and figure out what the axes are that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02033-00432423-00432622": "are getting plot two is check the error", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02034-00432623-00432863": "bars people oscillate between doing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02035-00432864-00433110": "standard error and a 95 confidence", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02036-00433112-00433318": "interval and those are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02037-00433319-00433631": "a two a scaling factor of two right so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02038-00433632-00433791": "just you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02039-00433792-00433887": "i don't know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02040-00433888-00434039": "just make sure that you know what the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02041-00434039-00434310": "error bars are in the paper and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02042-00434312-00434518": "obviously always beware of relative", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02043-00434519-00434703": "claims this is a really common one where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02044-00434704-00434943": "people will say things like there's a 50", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02045-00434943-00435151": "increase in order to make it sound you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02046-00435152-00435439": "know really powerful but in absolute", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02047-00435439-00435614": "terms it's very very small and not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02048-00435615-00436095": "particularly meaningful", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02049-00436096-00436327": "cool so the last thing that i want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02050-00436328-00436551": "talk about before we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02051-00436552-00436710": "are done and break", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02052-00436712-00436966": "is just a quick overview of a couple of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02053-00436967-00437135": "failures of replication", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02054-00437135-00437422": "um so like i said before i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02055-00437423-00437566": "i can talk about this for hours there", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02056-00437567-00437718": "are so many interesting failures of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02057-00437719-00437951": "replication and nuances here and i'm", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02058-00437952-00438135": "just gonna do a very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02059-00438135-00438247": "tough", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02060-00438247-00438447": "you know there should be nuance when we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02061-00438447-00438631": "talk about these things right like we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02062-00438632-00438783": "already talked about with the hypothesis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02063-00438784-00438966": "testing you know you can't think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02064-00438967-00439214": "categorically everything has a caveat", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02065-00439215-00439359": "you should be thinking sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02066-00439360-00439527": "probabilistically about all these things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02067-00439528-00439670": "but i just want to sort of point out a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02068-00439671-00439831": "few of the things that i at least have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02069-00439832-00440079": "come to sort of not believe in anymore", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02070-00440080-00440247": "and we'll talk in more depth about the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02071-00440247-00440799": "nuance uh a little bit later", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02072-00440800-00440870": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02073-00440871-00441087": "one of the first ones that i want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02074-00441088-00441335": "mention is sublime subliminal", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02075-00441335-00441495": "advertising and subliminal effects in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02076-00441496-00441591": "general", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02077-00441592-00441903": "so this was the sort of original", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02078-00441904-00442327": "subliminal advertising", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02079-00442328-00442543": "experiment that set off the whole idea", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02080-00442543-00442710": "right and this was done by a guy named", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02081-00442712-00442959": "james vickery and it was an absolute", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02082-00442960-00443191": "fraud the guy made millions and millions", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02083-00443192-00443407": "of dollars as a marketing consultant by", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02084-00443408-00443695": "saying that by flashing this sign hungry", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02085-00443696-00444110": "eat popcorn you know 20 of people uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02086-00444112-00444375": "more went and got popcorn and if you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02087-00444376-00444655": "look at the literature even now", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02088-00444656-00444766": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02089-00444767-00444983": "scientific american reports i think in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02090-00444984-00445159": "the last their last piece on subliminal", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02091-00445160-00445359": "advertising that it's real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02092-00445360-00445647": "and uh there was a there's a study about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02093-00445647-00445903": "lipton iced tea you know that has some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02094-00445904-00446087": "of the problems we talked about before", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02095-00446088-00446439": "lipton iced tea people um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02096-00446439-00446695": "subliminal advertising works to make you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02097-00446696-00446951": "drink lipton iced tea but only", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02098-00446952-00447127": "if it's a brand that's not a very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02099-00447128-00447383": "popular brand and only if you prime", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02100-00447384-00447583": "people to be thirsty before you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02101-00447584-00447791": "introduce the subliminal advertising", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02102-00447792-00447918": "that should set off", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02103-00447919-00448270": "a million alarm bells in your mind right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02104-00448271-00448447": "and that has been reported like i said", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02105-00448447-00448670": "in scientific american as a real result", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02106-00448671-00448927": "bbc did a tv series where they tried to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02107-00448928-00449079": "replicate it with the help of the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02108-00449080-00449287": "researcher that that found it a few", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02109-00449288-00449495": "years ago with three times the number of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02110-00449496-00449670": "people and obviously there was no effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02111-00449671-00449839": "right so be very cautious about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02112-00449839-00450039": "subliminal anything subliminal you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02113-00450039-00450159": "should be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02114-00450160-00450270": "you're you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02115-00450271-00450495": "cautious about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02116-00450496-00450766": "uh one of the huge ones right is this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02117-00450767-00450975": "idea of social", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02118-00450976-00451318": "priming and priming research in general", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02119-00451319-00451583": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02120-00451584-00451783": "one example of this is that warm", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02121-00451784-00452103": "beverages make you warm towards people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02122-00452104-00452270": "this one has failed to replicate this is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02123-00452271-00452463": "a really popular one to see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02124-00452464-00452631": "another one is like i mentioned before", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02125-00452632-00452863": "the elderly one where if you see elderly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02126-00452864-00453110": "words that suggest being old or elderly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02127-00453112-00453383": "you walk slower and there are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02128-00453384-00453639": "thousands of papers that all fall into", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02129-00453639-00453991": "this category of suggesting some sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02130-00453992-00454207": "concept", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02131-00454208-00454351": "you know that doesn't that you're not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02132-00454352-00454470": "consciously", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02133-00454471-00454655": "processing but it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02134-00454656-00454895": "sort of creates some sort of association", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02135-00454896-00455183": "in your mind that then leads to behavior", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02136-00455184-00455463": "change that is measurable", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02137-00455464-00455670": "most of that you should be extremely", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02138-00455671-00455887": "skeptical of right you should be very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02139-00455888-00456391": "very skeptical of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02140-00456392-00456670": "another one that is pretty famous and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02141-00456671-00456935": "that i've become very skeptical of are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02142-00456935-00457207": "uh physiological drivers of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02143-00457208-00457455": "uh emotional state and and feeling in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02144-00457456-00457614": "general so one of the famous examples", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02145-00457615-00457807": "here is the power posing research amy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02146-00457808-00458031": "cuddy the first officer on this paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02147-00458032-00458199": "has come out and said that she does not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02148-00458200-00458391": "believe this is a real effect but amy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02149-00458392-00458510": "cuddy still", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02150-00458512-00458670": "sort of argues that there's something", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02151-00458671-00458910": "real here um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02152-00458912-00459166": "so this is a really famous example in in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02153-00459167-00459399": "the replication world", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02154-00459400-00459559": "and another one is the facial feedback", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02155-00459560-00459814": "hypothesis the idea that smiling makes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02156-00459815-00459927": "you happy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02157-00459928-00460183": "and the way that we test whether smiling", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02158-00460184-00460422": "makes you happy right we can't tell you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02159-00460423-00460566": "to smile", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02160-00460567-00460766": "because if we tell you to smile", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02161-00460767-00460966": "you will believe you know you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02162-00460967-00461118": "thinking oh i'm going to smile i want to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02163-00461119-00461310": "be happy right we have this this sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02164-00461312-00461559": "second order effect right so we have to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02165-00461560-00461743": "somehow isolate the idea that the facial", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02166-00461743-00461895": "muscles what we care about is whether", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02167-00461896-00462127": "your facial muscles when you smile make", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02168-00462128-00462287": "you feel happy that there's some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02169-00462288-00462487": "physiological driver of your happiness", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02170-00462488-00462743": "and it's not some other aspect of you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02171-00462743-00462966": "deciding to smile you thinking about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02172-00462967-00463159": "smiling et cetera et cetera so the way", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02173-00463160-00463327": "that this research gets done is they", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02174-00463328-00463479": "tell people to pull the pen in their", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02175-00463480-00463718": "mouth and activate the muscles that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02176-00463719-00463887": "would be the smile muscles or they look", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02177-00463888-00464063": "at people with botox you know and they", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02178-00464064-00464318": "say like do do your emotional states", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02179-00464319-00464591": "change when your muscles change right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02180-00464592-00464727": "similar to the sort of power posing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02181-00464728-00464847": "stuff right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02182-00464847-00465063": "and this has been one of the famous", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02183-00465064-00465527": "failures of replication as well um so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02184-00465528-00465743": "this is this is an interesting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02185-00465743-00465966": "sphere the sort of physiological drivers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02186-00465967-00466127": "of emotional state and mental state this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02187-00466128-00466351": "is i think more plausible and there's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02188-00466352-00466639": "more nuance here and i feel less", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02189-00466639-00466887": "confident saying throw all of this away", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02190-00466888-00467047": "but you should be very skeptical when", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02191-00467047-00467143": "you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02192-00467143-00467399": "encounter research that suggests that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02193-00467400-00467599": "driving someone's physiology without", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02194-00467600-00467863": "them consciously aware of it or without", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02195-00467864-00468031": "them consciously making decisions to do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02196-00468032-00468279": "it themselves right will actually result", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02197-00468280-00468766": "in a change in mental state", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02198-00468767-00469055": "another one that i think is fascinating", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02199-00469056-00469255": "is behavioral economics and nudging", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02200-00469256-00469431": "research so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02201-00469432-00469727": "this is a paper recently um that looks", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02202-00469728-00469818": "at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02203-00469819-00470063": "126 random controlled randomized", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02204-00470064-00470231": "controlled trials over 23 million", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02205-00470232-00470447": "individuals this is looking at all of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02206-00470447-00470727": "the major government behavioral nudge", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02207-00470728-00470983": "units interventions that have come out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02208-00470984-00471287": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02209-00471288-00471479": "the estimated", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02210-00471480-00471766": "take-up effect was 8.7 percent by all of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02211-00471767-00472039": "the researchers the actual effect sizes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02212-00472039-00472343": "that they measured on average is 1.4", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02213-00472343-00472535": "for all of the nudge interventions from", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02214-00472535-00472727": "behavioral economics and if you look at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02215-00472728-00472903": "that with a relative number like we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02216-00472904-00473191": "cautioned ourselves earlier right the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02217-00473192-00473575": "academic estimate was a 33.5 percent", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02218-00473576-00473887": "change increase in a certain behavior", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02219-00473888-00474118": "right so you can see we can go from a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02220-00474119-00474318": "very big sounding number to a very small", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02221-00474319-00474518": "sounding number very quickly", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02222-00474519-00474647": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02223-00474647-00474727": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02224-00474728-00474839": "nudging works", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02225-00474839-00475063": "right i mean this is a huge huge study", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02226-00475064-00475255": "it works 1.4", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02227-00475256-00475422": "right but if you're going to try to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02228-00475423-00475695": "apply these ideas these nudge nudge", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02229-00475696-00475918": "ideas at a personal level", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02230-00475919-00476055": "right that's going to you know you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02231-00476056-00476191": "going to have to have a huge number of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02232-00476192-00476391": "participants to detect this kind of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02233-00476392-00476695": "effect size on an individual level right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02234-00476696-00477022": "so this is something to be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02235-00477023-00477199": "worried of right like this is real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02236-00477200-00477447": "there's real impact one percent you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02237-00477447-00477710": "sort of at the scale of the u.s right is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02238-00477712-00477910": "meaningful but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02239-00477912-00478118": "you know if we're designing individual", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02240-00478119-00478327": "interventions something to really take", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02241-00478328-00478495": "into consideration", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02242-00478496-00478703": "and in general a lot of these things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02243-00478704-00478935": "sort of fall under the umbrella of what", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02244-00478935-00479143": "jesse sengal calls prime worlds and i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02245-00479143-00479375": "like this idea you know that really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02246-00479376-00479527": "subtle little", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02247-00479528-00479703": "interventions and changes in your", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02248-00479704-00479966": "environment have these crazy big effects", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02249-00479967-00480191": "on your behavior and there's a ton of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02250-00480192-00480343": "research that falls in under this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02251-00480343-00480463": "umbrella", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02252-00480464-00480655": "much of which we just talked about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02253-00480656-00480862": "and a lot of this goes back to a guy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02254-00480863-00481079": "named mitchell", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02255-00481080-00481295": "who wrote he's famous because he did the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02256-00481296-00481487": "marshmallow test in psychology where you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02257-00481488-00481575": "put the marshmallow in front of the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02258-00481576-00481766": "little kids right and see if they eat", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02259-00481767-00481943": "the marshmallow or will wait to get a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02260-00481943-00482118": "second marshmallow", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02261-00482119-00482303": "one of these canonical studies in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02262-00482304-00482510": "psychology and he actually wrote a book", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02263-00482512-00482670": "in 1968", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02264-00482671-00482959": "called personality and assessment", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02265-00482960-00483255": "and he claimed that behavior is too", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02266-00483256-00483470": "situationally dependent too", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02267-00483471-00483687": "cross-situationally dependent to say", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02268-00483688-00483935": "anything about personality people don't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02269-00483935-00484151": "behave consistently enough across", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02270-00484152-00484359": "context for personality to be useful at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02271-00484360-00484455": "all", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02272-00484456-00484639": "and he basically sent", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02273-00484639-00484983": "personality psychology away for the next", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02274-00484984-00485199": "until now personality psychologists are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02275-00485200-00485447": "a rare breed and social psychology took", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02276-00485447-00485670": "over this idea that the situation is the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02277-00485671-00485822": "primary thing that we need to be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02278-00485823-00486079": "concerned about and the situationism as", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02279-00486080-00486318": "a movement really sort of took over um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02280-00486319-00486575": "from trait psychology and after all of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02281-00486576-00486831": "this time right it actually turns out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02282-00486832-00487047": "that traits are more predictive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02283-00487047-00487239": "typically than situations", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02284-00487239-00487510": "when it comes to human behavior but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02285-00487512-00487718": "still personality psychology is still", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02286-00487719-00487862": "kind of like a second class citizen and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02287-00487863-00488007": "it's only just now coming back so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02288-00488008-00488279": "there's some really interesting um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02289-00488280-00488470": "uh sort of history to the fact that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02290-00488471-00488639": "we've arrived at this world view that's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02291-00488639-00489055": "so popular in the psychology right now", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02292-00489056-00489135": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02293-00489135-00489351": "another big one that i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02294-00489352-00489510": "i love to think about and talk about is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02295-00489512-00489703": "positive psychology right so positive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02296-00489704-00490062": "psychology i think is full of um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02297-00490063-00490303": "interesting results um one of the most", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02298-00490304-00490631": "famous ones is from barbara frederickson", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02299-00490632-00490879": "called the critical positivity ratio", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02300-00490880-00491183": "which was hailed as this um incredible", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02301-00491184-00491422": "empirical finding and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02302-00491423-00491766": "it was derived from the lorenz equations", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02303-00491767-00492047": "suggesting that for non the nonlinear", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02304-00492047-00492270": "dynamic system of emotion if you have a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02305-00492271-00492514": "precise ratio of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02306-00492515-00492766": "2.9013 positive feelings to negative", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02307-00492767-00493070": "feelings you will flourish and if you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02308-00493071-00493310": "are less than that you will languish", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02309-00493312-00493535": "and this was taught for eight years as", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02310-00493535-00493703": "one of the great findings of positive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02311-00493704-00493822": "psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02312-00493823-00494095": "it's total bs and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02313-00494096-00494175": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02314-00494176-00494383": "the story around how it was retracted", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02315-00494384-00494551": "and sort of back and forth here is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02316-00494552-00494814": "really pretty interesting um an older", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02317-00494815-00495039": "masters student was being taught it and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02318-00495039-00495191": "sort of decided to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02319-00495192-00495431": "do some fact checking in it you know the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02320-00495432-00495591": "author who did the math just stopped", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02321-00495592-00495814": "responding and it became a big deal", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02322-00495815-00496047": "right but but barbara frederickson is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02323-00496047-00496159": "still a big deal in the positive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02324-00496160-00496351": "psychology community and she still", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02325-00496352-00496551": "promotes this idea of a critical ratio", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02326-00496552-00496718": "where you know if you have these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02327-00496719-00496918": "positive feelings you you flourish and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02328-00496919-00497175": "negative feelings you languish and i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02329-00497176-00497351": "have a lot to say", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02330-00497352-00497470": "about how we think about positive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02331-00497471-00497631": "psychology i love this sort of idea of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02332-00497632-00497831": "make mindfulness that the sort of in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02333-00497832-00497999": "vogue ways we think about meaning in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02334-00498000-00498199": "people's lives are and the empirical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02335-00498200-00498455": "data that supports those is uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02336-00498456-00498695": "really lacking", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02337-00498696-00498910": "and the last thing i'll mention is a lot", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02338-00498912-00499222": "of the really canonical studies", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02339-00499223-00499407": "in psychology things like the milgram", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02340-00499408-00499535": "experiments", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02341-00499535-00499935": "uh the bystander effects", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02342-00499935-00500166": "the the stanford prison experiments", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02343-00500167-00500295": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02344-00500296-00500431": "that they're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02345-00500432-00500670": "the marshmallow test uh a lot of these", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02346-00500671-00500822": "things have been called into question in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02347-00500823-00501047": "various ways so like this one this was", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02348-00501047-00501270": "an outright fraud the story of kitty", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02349-00501271-00501431": "genovese so the bystander effect the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02350-00501432-00501662": "reason that you know we coined that term", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02351-00501663-00501879": "right is that this woman was murdered", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02352-00501880-00502183": "and something 37 people were around and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02353-00502184-00502310": "no one did anything and she was murdered", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02354-00502312-00502487": "in this horrific way that's not actually", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02355-00502488-00502614": "true and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02356-00502615-00502791": "the editor of the new york times at the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02357-00502792-00502879": "time", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02358-00502880-00502983": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02359-00502984-00503247": "fabricated the story basically i mean", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02360-00503247-00503487": "she was murdered but it was not in the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02361-00503488-00503631": "way that it was reported that there were", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02362-00503632-00503799": "all these people around and nobody did", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02363-00503800-00504070": "anything right um so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02364-00504071-00504262": "and then same thing milgram the milgram", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02365-00504263-00504439": "experiments there's nothing wrong with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02366-00504439-00504631": "the methodology these things happen same", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02367-00504632-00504735": "thing with the stanford prison", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02368-00504735-00504903": "experiments these things happened but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02369-00504904-00505087": "the way we interpret them has been the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02370-00505088-00505287": "subject of a lot of debate and scrutiny", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02371-00505288-00505583": "now and um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02372-00505584-00505855": "a lot of this is being revised right so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02373-00505856-00506103": "the popular conceptions around almost", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02374-00506104-00506335": "every major philosophical or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02375-00506335-00506583": "psychological finding has been really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02376-00506584-00506791": "contested in the last five or six years", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02377-00506792-00507007": "is pretty shocking and surprising and so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02378-00507008-00507183": "we'll talk a little bit about some of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02379-00507184-00507318": "these things as well", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02380-00507319-00507566": "later on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02381-00507567-00507831": "so i just want to end with um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02382-00507832-00507975": "where we started", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02383-00507976-00508231": "which is the story of daryl bem so daryl", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02384-00508232-00508351": "bem is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02385-00508352-00508575": "a great guy actually he's been very open", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02386-00508576-00508862": "with his data he's shared it he believes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02387-00508863-00509031": "in psy he believes that we have", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02388-00509032-00509351": "premonitions and i mean but he has been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02389-00509352-00509583": "great for the field great for the field", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02390-00509584-00509695": "and he's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02391-00509696-00509855": "you know like i said very open about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02392-00509856-00509983": "sharing his data", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02393-00509984-00510151": "his paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02394-00510152-00510343": "that kicked all this off still has not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02395-00510343-00510470": "been retracted", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02396-00510471-00510703": "right and and the paper there have been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02397-00510704-00510966": "multiple people that have done analysis", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02398-00510967-00511199": "after the fact of his data this is a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02399-00511200-00511479": "letter from 2020 trying to get the paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02400-00511480-00511655": "retracted you know it's still not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02401-00511656-00511799": "retracted", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02402-00511800-00511966": "and if you look at", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02403-00511967-00512151": "a paper that he wrote in 2015 he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02404-00512152-00512422": "actually did a meta-analysis using the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02405-00512423-00512710": "latest bayesian techniques to show", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02406-00512712-00512951": "that over 90 experiments", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02407-00512952-00513231": "anticipation of random future events is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02408-00513232-00513366": "real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02409-00513367-00513710": "so the story keeps going right and daryl", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02410-00513712-00513918": "ben you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02411-00513919-00514214": "continues to poke and prod at the latest", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02412-00514215-00514414": "empirical methods and who knows i mean", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02413-00514415-00514599": "maybe our ability to have premonitions", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02414-00514600-00514791": "really is real you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02415-00514792-00514975": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02416-00514976-00515214": "so i'm gonna end there this is sort of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02417-00515215-00515543": "summary of take away points that i tried", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02418-00515543-00515751": "to make throughout the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02419-00515752-00516095": "lecture i will be posting the lecture um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02420-00516096-00516295": "so that you all can go through it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02421-00516296-00516422": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02422-00516423-00516510": "yeah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02423-00516512-00516695": "i think that's pretty much pretty much", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02424-00516696-00516966": "it um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02425-00516967-00517262": "so next class we'll be hearing from noah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02426-00517263-00517639": "um about meta statistical techniques um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02427-00517639-00517822": "we have free time now for the next half", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02428-00517823-00518039": "hour i'm gonna stick around i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02429-00518039-00518239": "these guys will stick around and if you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02430-00518239-00518431": "want to chat if you have questions i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02431-00518432-00518599": "mean we just kind of wanted to leave a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02432-00518600-00521239": "fair amount of time open yeah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02433-00521239-00521351": "so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02434-00521352-00521655": "yeah this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02435-00521656-00521799": "this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02436-00521800-00522118": "yeah so this is just the chance that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02437-00522119-00522366": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02438-00522367-00522559": "yeah that's actually a fair critique uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02439-00522560-00522655": "i was just", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02440-00522656-00523095": "well so if you if the idea was that uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02441-00523096-00523199": "you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02442-00523200-00523518": "have the odds of a p-value from chance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02443-00523519-00523759": "and the odds of a p-value", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02444-00523760-00523935": "real effect leading to a p-value that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02445-00523935-00524087": "there's some overlap in the odds that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02446-00524088-00524351": "they would co-occur right that you would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02447-00524352-00524751": "sort of like draw", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02448-00524752-00525031": "and that you should separate that out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02449-00525032-00525247": "when you're looking at the likelihood", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02450-00525248-00525566": "of a p-value from chance um being", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02451-00525567-00525839": "overlapped by a real p-value right so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02452-00525840-00526047": "like if if i think it's maybe easier to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02453-00526048-00526279": "consider in this example 1 out of 20", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02454-00526280-00526431": "times we would expect one from random", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02455-00526432-00526695": "chance but four out of five times we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02456-00526696-00527039": "would expect the real one so like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02457-00527040-00527222": "at some time when we would expect one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02458-00527223-00527343": "from random chance we're going to get a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02459-00527344-00527439": "real one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02460-00527440-00527614": "and so when those two things would", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02461-00527615-00527783": "co-occur", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02462-00527784-00527983": "when those two things would co-occur we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02463-00527984-00528207": "have to subtract out the the odds of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02464-00528208-00528495": "getting a real one to get the the number", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02465-00528496-00528703": "of times that we would get a fake one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02466-00528704-00528911": "but we're not getting a fake one when", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02467-00528912-00529062": "we're getting a real one i don't know if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02468-00529063-00529159": "that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02469-00529160-00529255": "sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02470-00529256-00529470": "makes sense right so like one out of 20", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02471-00529471-00529775": "times we're getting the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02472-00529776-00529887": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02473-00529888-00530087": "one from random noise", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02474-00530088-00530166": "but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02475-00530167-00530447": "four out of five times we're getting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02476-00530448-00530679": "uh an actual effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02477-00530680-00530918": "so if we look just at the subset of the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02478-00530919-00531143": "one out of 20 times that we draw a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02479-00531144-00531303": "random one", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02480-00531304-00531439": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02481-00531440-00531735": "sometimes we many times we will actually", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02482-00531736-00531935": "also be getting sort of like a real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02483-00531936-00532103": "effect like four out of five times that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02484-00532104-00532366": "we have the one out of 20 times", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02485-00532367-00532543": "we'll get the real effect right because", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02486-00532544-00532670": "that's just sort of how it works out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02487-00532671-00532791": "right so you have to sort of take that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02488-00532792-00532943": "into account when you're doing the math", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02489-00532944-00533166": "that that um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02490-00533167-00533503": "some amount of times you'll uh that .05", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02491-00533504-00533703": "will sort of like be overtaken by the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02492-00533704-00534151": "real effect", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02493-00534152-00534318": "yes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02494-00534319-00534543": "for that for that quantity", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02495-00534544-00534687": "yeah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02496-00534688-00535351": "yep", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02497-00535352-00535759": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02498-00535760-00536058": "yep", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02499-00536059-00536655": "[Music]", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02500-00536656-00538135": "five", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02501-00538136-00538511": "that's a great question uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02502-00538512-00538695": "i feel like i want to make some very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02503-00538696-00538887": "philosophical point about i'd love to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02504-00538888-00539039": "hear you guys weigh in on this as well i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02505-00539040-00539199": "like my instincts to make some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02506-00539200-00539391": "philosophical point about intuition and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02507-00539392-00539543": "reason and you know how do we know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02508-00539544-00539743": "anything is true ever and you should", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02509-00539744-00539975": "just you know like everything is relied", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02510-00539976-00540207": "on the basis of intuition i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02511-00540208-00540343": "strongly there there's some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02512-00540344-00540470": "philosophical point that i'd like to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02513-00540471-00540775": "make a more specific point might be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02514-00540776-00541014": "weekly informed priors also typically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02515-00541015-00541183": "work really well with all of this stuff", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02516-00541184-00541391": "right so you can run this this type of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02517-00541392-00541622": "analysis typically with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02518-00541623-00541831": "you know on two values a value that you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02519-00541832-00542039": "think is a really low likelihood sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02520-00542040-00542222": "lower or a high likelihood lower bound", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02521-00542223-00542559": "and an upper bound and you know see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02522-00542560-00542735": "see for yourself you know sort of take", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02523-00542736-00542983": "your own uncertainty into account when", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02524-00542984-00543207": "it comes to these sorts of things", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02525-00543208-00543375": "that would be i think that's the right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02526-00543376-00543583": "answer right is like sort of like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02527-00543584-00543807": "use a weakly informed prior and really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02528-00543808-00544014": "sort of like bound it in order to get a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02529-00544015-00544191": "sense and then you know maybe it is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02530-00544192-00544431": "really sensitive in that range", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02531-00544432-00544607": "you know typically these things i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02532-00544608-00544783": "aren't but maybe it's really sensitive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02533-00544784-00544999": "and then you have to sort of weigh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02534-00545000-00545111": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02535-00545112-00545279": "your intuition against how much work", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02536-00545280-00545422": "you're going to be doing and maybe do an", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02537-00545423-00545703": "exploratory analysis or read more or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02538-00545704-00545879": "you know i mean it is a bit of a chicken", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02539-00545880-00546055": "and the egg problem right like you got", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02540-00546056-00546231": "to look at maybe you look at previous", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02541-00546232-00546399": "research maybe you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02542-00546400-00546591": "you know go out and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02543-00546592-00546791": "drink a bunch of you know try to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02544-00546792-00546983": "convince your friends to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02545-00546984-00548718": "you know i don't know right like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02546-00548719-00549343": "totally totally", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02547-00549344-00551711": "oh yeah sure sorry sorry uh online folks", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02548-00551712-00553591": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02549-00553592-00556687": "full", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02550-00556688-00556911": "right so the question is is it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02551-00556912-00557191": "reasonable to rely on previous research", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02552-00557192-00557447": "findings to inform your own prior when", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02553-00557448-00557583": "they probably had a really flawed", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02554-00557584-00557807": "understanding in the first place yeah i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02555-00557808-00557879": "think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02556-00557880-00558055": "yeah i think well and so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02557-00558056-00558159": "back to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02558-00558160-00558335": "a lot of the heuristics that we've been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02559-00558336-00558487": "trying to use", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02560-00558488-00558670": "or trying to sort of like promote here", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02561-00558671-00558959": "is like how much yes if that paper is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02562-00558960-00559199": "bad your you would be", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02563-00559200-00559366": "continuing bad research and that's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02564-00559367-00559503": "exactly the cycle we want to try to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02565-00559504-00559703": "break right so the question is can you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02566-00559704-00559895": "evaluate that paper in any meaningful", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02567-00559896-00560143": "way to say whether that data is useful", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02568-00560144-00560270": "or not and hopefully there are some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02569-00560271-00560462": "heuristics here that you can bring to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02570-00560463-00560743": "bear and you should trust or not that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02571-00560744-00560927": "paper based off of you know some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02572-00560928-00561095": "combination of your intuition your own", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02573-00561096-00561303": "lived experience which is you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02574-00561304-00561447": "your own lived experience and maybe", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02575-00561448-00561575": "you're evolved", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02576-00561576-00561822": "intuitive social physics or something", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02577-00561823-00561983": "and like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02578-00561984-00562255": "uh what data you have but i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02579-00562256-00562470": "yeah it's absolutely possible if you if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02580-00562471-00562647": "you sort of take", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02581-00562648-00562870": "data in the literature at wholesale that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02582-00562871-00563062": "you will make a mistake and all of this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02583-00563063-00563222": "stuff i mean it it's also a fair", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02584-00563223-00563455": "critique of sort of it's sort of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02585-00563456-00563622": "fundamental", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02586-00563623-00563766": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02587-00563767-00563966": "point about frequentist versus bayesian", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02588-00563967-00564127": "statistics right i mean i think that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02589-00564128-00564231": "like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02590-00564232-00564479": "you know you sort of live in a world", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02591-00564480-00564670": "sort of asian world view right is like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02592-00564671-00564839": "we don't live in a world of certainty", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02593-00564840-00565095": "everything is probabilistic and like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02594-00565096-00565295": "there's sort of an inherent risk you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02595-00565296-00565527": "sort of inherently have to rely on some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02596-00565528-00565735": "amount of intuition and like the more", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02597-00565736-00565903": "weakly informed you know it turns out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02598-00565904-00566055": "that if you use really weak priors for a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02599-00566056-00566222": "lot of things they will it will converge", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02600-00566223-00566391": "and it'll converge pretty fast and so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02601-00566392-00566559": "you don't really have to make ideally", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02602-00566560-00566799": "very strong assumptions but i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02603-00566800-00567083": "you know absolutely you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02604-00567084-00567375": "know absolutely it's possible to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02605-00567376-00567583": "propagate bad science if you rely too", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02606-00567584-00567855": "heavily on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02607-00567856-00567959": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02608-00567960-00568087": "papers that are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02609-00568088-00568199": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02610-00568200-00568414": "not not empirically strong", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02611-00568415-00568543": "and you should do everything you can not", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02612-00568544-00568807": "to do that and i i actually you know i i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02613-00568808-00569103": "also personally think right that like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02614-00569104-00569327": "a lot of this stuff is start from", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02615-00569328-00569583": "scratch and rebuilt in a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02616-00569584-00569727": "different areas", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02617-00569728-00569975": "of social psychology and psychology", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02618-00569976-00570087": "there are a lot of assumptions that go", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02619-00570088-00570231": "into a lot of the psych research that i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02620-00570232-00570359": "think are really bad assumptions and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02621-00570360-00570543": "there's there's a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02622-00570544-00570847": "uh opportunity to really revisit", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02623-00570848-00570999": "fundamental assumptions about what types", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02624-00571000-00571103": "of things we're studying and how we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02625-00571104-00571231": "reasoning about them", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02626-00571232-00571407": "and like really build back from the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02627-00571408-00571662": "ground up and i think you sort of see", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02628-00571663-00571862": "the research community in this period of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02629-00571863-00571975": "transition", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02630-00571976-00572295": "from frequentist debasion assumptions", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02631-00572296-00572462": "causal and counterfactual modeling", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02632-00572463-00572647": "techniques that you know just haven't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02633-00572648-00573014": "really been used and um with a real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02634-00573015-00573214": "reckoning on like all the bad", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02635-00573215-00573359": "statistical techniques that we've had", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02636-00573360-00573575": "right so um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02637-00573576-00573766": "it's a it's a very interesting time to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02638-00573767-00573943": "be involved in this field not only", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02639-00573944-00574143": "because it's such an important field but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02640-00574144-00574366": "because", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02641-00574367-00574543": "it's really like start from the ground", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02642-00574544-00574695": "up you know you could be the person", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02643-00574696-00574839": "right that that's sort of like charting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02644-00574840-00576422": "the new territory i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02645-00576423-00579710": "uh i don't off the top of my head", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02646-00579711-00582622": "thank yeah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02647-00582623-00582727": "right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02648-00582728-00582910": "right yeah so the question is about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02649-00582911-00583039": "daryl bem and why it hasn't been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02650-00583040-00583222": "retracted and what is going on there", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02651-00583223-00583375": "yeah so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02652-00583376-00583583": "you're right i think that so the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02653-00583584-00583807": "conversation generally is the author has", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02654-00583808-00584014": "the power to retract their paper", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02655-00584015-00584222": "otherwise you have to show some evidence", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02656-00584223-00584455": "right and daryl bem has been very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02657-00584456-00584655": "willing to share his data and other", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02658-00584656-00584983": "people have gone through the data and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02659-00584984-00585143": "the evidence", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02660-00585144-00585470": "is suggestive but it's not conclusive", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02661-00585471-00585647": "that you know it like with so many of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02662-00585648-00585799": "these things right it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02663-00585800-00585983": "you can't necessarily", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02664-00585984-00586151": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02665-00586152-00586287": "it's hard to know what was going on in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02666-00586288-00586462": "his head how much of it was a priori", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02667-00586463-00586759": "versus sort of like after the fact uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02668-00586760-00587070": "data analysis techniques right and so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02669-00587071-00587359": "um like the the response letter that i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02670-00587360-00587575": "showed was actually to another", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02671-00587576-00587814": "researcher who had access to daryl bem's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02672-00587815-00588118": "data had gone through it cited five or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02673-00588119-00588510": "six concerning things that are pretty", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02674-00588511-00588599": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02675-00588600-00588879": "pretty damning if you're prior is that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02676-00588880-00589087": "this results isn't real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02677-00589088-00589422": "um but the the editors sort of said", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02678-00589423-00589551": "there's not you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02679-00589552-00589775": "a lot of the response tends to be this", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02680-00589776-00590062": "was standard practice at the time and we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02681-00590063-00590279": "can't retroactively sort of use the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02682-00590280-00590527": "statistical rigor that we are now", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02683-00590528-00590703": "accepting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02684-00590704-00590983": "to sort of retract articles because we", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02685-00590984-00591135": "would end up retracting you know like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02686-00591136-00591359": "every article that we ever had basically", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02687-00591360-00591631": "um but which i think is really bad", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02688-00591632-00591855": "sort of logic but uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02689-00591856-00592062": "that's true and it's been a really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02690-00592063-00592207": "slow shift i mean just getting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02691-00592208-00592407": "replications into these journals that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02692-00592408-00592607": "was like a no-go until a few years ago", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02693-00592608-00592743": "right so like the the culture is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02694-00592744-00592966": "changing but it's it's a very slow", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02695-00592967-00593175": "slow change so but yeah i mean to your", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02696-00593176-00596399": "point um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02697-00596400-00596631": "so he states sort of like in interviews", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02698-00596632-00596862": "that his in his interpretation is that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02699-00596863-00597127": "humans are pre-cognizant right and it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02700-00597128-00597310": "it's the type of question you're asking", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02701-00597311-00597495": "i think is um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02702-00597496-00597687": "indicative of this sort of categorical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02703-00597688-00597879": "versus probabilistic way of viewing the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02704-00597880-00598031": "world right like there's nothing wrong", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02705-00598032-00598255": "with the probabilistic", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02706-00598256-00598591": "uh assumption that 53 of people click on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02707-00598592-00598751": "the one that magically has a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02708-00598752-00598966": "pornographic image behind it right that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02709-00598967-00599127": "doesn't prove", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02710-00599128-00599270": "to most people that doesn't prove", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02711-00599271-00599543": "anything right um and so with other", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02712-00599544-00599718": "people repeating these experiments which", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02713-00599719-00599935": "they have and published you know similar", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02714-00599936-00600166": "attempts that don't show the same result", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02715-00600167-00600335": "we get a more complete statistical", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02716-00600336-00600527": "picture so in some sense you're right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02717-00600528-00600727": "there's no reason to retract", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02718-00600728-00600847": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02719-00600848-00601143": "that particular paper except that he had", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02720-00601144-00601375": "nine experiments all of them hit with", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02721-00601376-00601551": "statistical significance", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02722-00601552-00601791": "so there's pretty you know there seems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02723-00601792-00601966": "to be pretty strong evidence", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02724-00601967-00602110": "particularly in the context of other", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02725-00602111-00602239": "people that have tried to replicate the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02726-00602240-00602407": "results that he", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02727-00602408-00602710": "did some sort of selective filtering or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02728-00602711-00602910": "combining of his studies and there and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02729-00602911-00603039": "there is evidence of that kind of thing", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02730-00603040-00603279": "right like weird ends in the paper and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02731-00603280-00603470": "weird combinations of sub", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02732-00603471-00603718": "sub experiments but but that was common", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02733-00603719-00603887": "practice at the time", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02734-00603888-00604014": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02735-00604015-00604103": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02736-00604104-00604262": "it's not necessarily evidence of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02737-00604263-00604518": "malfeasance etc etc so these things get", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02738-00604519-00604687": "very touchy and political and kind of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02739-00604688-00604870": "weird which is why it's really important", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02740-00604871-00605127": "to understand the sort of social context", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02741-00605128-00605295": "when you're reading these papers right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02742-00605296-00605414": "and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02743-00605415-00605607": "you're sort of on your own in a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02744-00605608-00605727": "ways to make sure that what you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02745-00605728-00608599": "reading is empirically valid research", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02746-00608600-00611351": "who knows exactly what happened", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02747-00611352-00611647": "a great question i mean", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02748-00611648-00611847": "well so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02749-00611848-00611983": "i think that there are a lot of places", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02750-00611984-00612647": "where you see this uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02751-00612648-00612927": "to me the biggest areas that where i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02752-00612928-00613166": "think there is real there's like a real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02753-00613167-00613366": "problem and this is really infiltrated", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02754-00613367-00613551": "the sort of that i think this has really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02755-00613552-00613775": "infiltrated the public's debate right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02756-00613776-00613999": "these ways of viewing the world", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02757-00614000-00614127": "particularly this notion of sort of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02758-00614128-00614422": "prime world right so you'll get a lot of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02759-00614423-00614647": "social critics that are talking about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02760-00614648-00614727": "how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02761-00614728-00614927": "you know let's talk about like facebook", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02762-00614928-00615127": "and how facebook is destroying democracy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02763-00615128-00615287": "right and like the design decisions that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02764-00615288-00615431": "facebook are making and how that's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02765-00615432-00615575": "affecting individual choice or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02766-00615576-00615870": "advertising like our economic models you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02767-00615871-00616031": "know how are the decisions we're making", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02768-00616032-00616303": "around advertising manipulating people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02769-00616304-00616487": "are they coercive is there something", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02770-00616488-00616727": "fundamentally wrong you know what about", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02771-00616728-00616887": "you know you sort of look at the history", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02772-00616888-00616975": "of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02773-00616976-00617247": "uh right we had", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02774-00617248-00617439": "like the history of the 20th century", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02775-00617440-00617783": "right we started we we had uh democracy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02776-00617784-00618070": "and then and marxism sort of battling", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02777-00618071-00618343": "this out right and um then all of a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02778-00618344-00618631": "sudden in germany you know democracy", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02779-00618632-00618879": "fell into fascism and everyone freaks", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02780-00618880-00619103": "out and we invent public relations to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02781-00619104-00619310": "basically propagandize to our own", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02782-00619311-00619479": "population because we're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02783-00619480-00619814": "we have lost the belief that society is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02784-00619815-00620039": "stable because people can be manipulated", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02785-00620040-00620191": "in very specific ways and you have a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02786-00620192-00620439": "whole history in psychology of people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02787-00620440-00620631": "looking at how we're manipulating you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02788-00620632-00620807": "know how easy it is to manipulate people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02789-00620808-00621166": "the milgram experiments you know um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02790-00621167-00621303": "the stanford prison experiments that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02791-00621304-00621487": "whole era is real", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02792-00621488-00621759": "rife with this idea that people are so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02793-00621760-00622031": "easily manipulated by their context that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02794-00622032-00622255": "they have no agency and we really need", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02795-00622256-00622503": "to control them as a government", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02796-00622504-00622751": "right so like there are huge there's a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02797-00622752-00622910": "whole history of really huge", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02798-00622911-00623118": "ramifications there i think there's a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02799-00623119-00623343": "huge history in psychoanalysis and how", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02800-00623344-00623559": "we treat and even think about like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02801-00623560-00623822": "mental illness and well-being there's a", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02802-00623823-00624079": "whole like multi-billion dollar industry", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02803-00624080-00624375": "around positive psychology that in my", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02804-00624376-00624662": "opinion is preaching", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02805-00624663-00624751": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02806-00624752-00624951": "to people ways of finding meaning in", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02807-00624952-00625103": "their lives that are absolutely devoid", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02808-00625104-00625343": "of meaning and and are like really", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02809-00625344-00625607": "misleading people you know so there's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02810-00625608-00625831": "you know not to mention the number of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02811-00625832-00626110": "people in hci and design who are trying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02812-00626111-00626439": "to build you know technology or trying", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02813-00626440-00626591": "to do research where they're they're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02814-00626592-00626766": "really putting effort to like make", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02815-00626767-00626870": "things that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02816-00626871-00627118": "help people you know change their lives", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02817-00627119-00627262": "or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02818-00627263-00627462": "break habits or build habits or you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02819-00627463-00627703": "like people that are really trying you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02820-00627704-00627943": "know but their instincts are deeply", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02821-00627944-00628159": "misinformed by", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02822-00628160-00628414": "years of of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02823-00628415-00628518": "a very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02824-00628519-00628614": "you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02825-00628615-00628814": "out of touch world view that's been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02826-00628815-00629014": "promoted by", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02827-00629015-00629199": "this kind of you know so social", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02828-00629200-00629422": "psychology basically um so i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02829-00629423-00629607": "there's there's really big ramifications", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02830-00629608-00629847": "actually in the world over and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02831-00629848-00629999": "uh a lot of this has not made it out", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02832-00630000-00630231": "into the mainstream yet you know and if", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02833-00630232-00630479": "you read any pop psychology book", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02834-00630480-00630622": "you know once you've sort of been", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02835-00630623-00630822": "exposed to a lot of this stuff", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02836-00630823-00630991": "it's in every single one of them every", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02837-00630992-00631183": "single one of them is making", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02838-00631184-00631359": "some crazy claims you know even the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02839-00631360-00631543": "really good ones that i really love you", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02840-00631544-00631775": "know there will always be a chapter or", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02841-00631776-00631935": "or something where you're just like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02842-00631936-00632159": "that's crazy you know how could is that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02843-00632160-00632279": "really true and then you sort of like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02844-00632280-00632455": "dig into the literature that it's based", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02845-00632456-00632775": "on and it's pretty dubious right so i", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02846-00632776-00634775": "think there's a lot at stake", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02847-00634776-00636910": "oh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02848-00636911-00639087": "a lot of faces", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02849-00639088-00641359": "okay", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02850-00641360-00641487": "i think it's a great point i mean it", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02851-00641488-00641687": "really is they're like intelligent", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02852-00641688-00641895": "people there's a lot of politics that's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02853-00641896-00642039": "associated with you know like if you're", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02854-00642040-00642191": "tearing down the findings of all the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02855-00642192-00642422": "great people in the field right like", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02856-00642423-00642559": "are you gonna go into that field and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02857-00642560-00642679": "like what is the state of that field", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02858-00642680-00642918": "gonna be if you don't and you let people", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02859-00642919-00643070": "that are willing to play the game kind", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02860-00643071-00643327": "of like rise to the top so it's a very", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02861-00643328-00643527": "very high stakes yeah yeah it's a great", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02862-00643528-00644470": "point", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02863-00644471-00645999": "you said", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02864-00646000-00647175": "step step", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02865-00647176-00648495": "uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02866-00648496-00648775": "i'm not aware of any publishing house", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02867-00648776-00648999": "doing that kind of thing i mean", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02868-00649000-00649191": "i'm not sure if the incentives are there", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02869-00649192-00649359": "for publishing houses too the question", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02870-00649360-00649583": "is about publishing houses uh", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02871-00649584-00649783": "sort of self-policing when it comes to", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02872-00649784-00650007": "retractions and this stuff i mean yeah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02873-00650008-00650183": "i'm not aware of any publishing houses", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02874-00650184-00650375": "doing that but there has been this slow", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02875-00650376-00650631": "move towards accepting replications", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02876-00650632-00650807": "which you know are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02877-00650808-00651055": "tend to be boring papers that they don't", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02878-00651056-00651207": "want to publish so accepting", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02879-00651208-00651343": "replications there's been a move towards", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02880-00651344-00651439": "that there's been a move towards the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02881-00651440-00651639": "pre-register thing so so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02882-00651640-00651807": "there there is evidence that they are", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02883-00651808-00651966": "changing their culture but i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02884-00651967-00652231": "there's a my personal view is it seems", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02885-00652232-00652431": "like there's a lot of reticence to go", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02886-00652432-00652527": "back", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02887-00652528-00652935": "and really deeply you know", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02888-00652936-00653087": "go through", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02889-00653088-00653295": "the careers of the people that are the", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02890-00653296-00653566": "editors and you know whatever like and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02891-00653567-00653703": "and to sort of like undermine all that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02892-00653704-00653895": "stuff but there are a lot of tools that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02893-00653896-00654047": "are available that kind of automate some", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02894-00654048-00654239": "of this stuff and there are blogs where", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02895-00654240-00654414": "people are doing these sorts of analyses", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02896-00654415-00654591": "on the topics that are really popular", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02897-00654592-00654703": "and so", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02898-00654704-00654847": "yeah i mean i think", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02899-00654848-00655007": "there are people outside of that that", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02900-00655008-00655231": "are starting to combine", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02901-00655232-00655591": "meta statistics and automated processes", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02902-00655592-00655910": "to give people easy tools to use to do", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02903-00655911-00656135": "this kind of thing but i my instinct is", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02904-00656136-00656295": "that all of that work is going to happen", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02905-00656296-00656607": "sort of like outside of the actual", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02906-00656608-00656718": "publishers", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02907-00656719-00656879": "um there's also a big move in open", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02908-00656880-00657047": "publishing too i mean it's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02909-00657048-00657199": "you know that's", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02910-00657200-00657462": "not to be ignored right like an and open", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02911-00657463-00657662": "open review and all these other sorts of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02912-00657663-00657855": "things where you're seeing you know sort", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02913-00657856-00658079": "of counter movements in publishing but", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02914-00658080-00660799": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02915-00660800-00664183": "okay", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02916-00664184-00665310": "um", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02917-00665311-00668662": "all right", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02918-00668663-00668839": "cool well i think we're basically out of", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02919-00668840-00669062": "time so unless there you have any other", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02920-00669063-00669255": "questions please come chat", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02921-00669256-00669487": "otherwise we'll see you on thursday and", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02922-00669488-00669614": "we'll be doing the assignment on", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02923-00669615-00669766": "thursday and we'll be hearing from noah", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02924-00669767-00670007": "so it should be should be fun", "MOMLHIjsMV4-02925-00670008-00670332": "thank you guys"}}, {"audio_id": "MOYNu60OnXU", "text": {"MOYNu60OnXU-00000-00000495-00001097": "[Music]", "MOYNu60OnXU-00001-00001098-00001543": "[Music]", "MOYNu60OnXU-00002-00001544-00001939": "the seven four nine three I see binary", "MOYNu60OnXU-00003-00001941-00002333": "counter the seven four nine three I see", "MOYNu60OnXU-00004-00002334-00002606": "is an up counter that is capable of", "MOYNu60OnXU-00005-00002607-00002894": "operating as a multi modulus counter it", "MOYNu60OnXU-00006-00002895-00003092": "is constructed of two negative edge", "MOYNu60OnXU-00007-00003093-00003308": "triggered counters that in their natural", "MOYNu60OnXU-00008-00003309-00003718": "state are a mod two up counter and a mod", "MOYNu60OnXU-00009-00003719-00004175": "eight up counter the mod to counter used", "MOYNu60OnXU-00010-00004176-00004472": "by itself flip-flop a operates as a mod", "MOYNu60OnXU-00011-00004473-00004709": "to counter the count begins with a zero", "MOYNu60OnXU-00012-00004710-00004981": "at the Q output and the maximum count", "MOYNu60OnXU-00013-00004982-00005399": "occurs when the Q output is at a one the", "MOYNu60OnXU-00014-00005400-00005612": "counter recycles back to zero when the", "MOYNu60OnXU-00015-00005613-00005927": "next clock pulse is applied the mod to", "MOYNu60OnXU-00016-00005928-00006203": "counter changes its count every time a", "MOYNu60OnXU-00017-00006204-00006418": "negative edge of a clock pulse is", "MOYNu60OnXU-00018-00006419-00006653": "applied to its clock input which is", "MOYNu60OnXU-00019-00006654-00007165": "labeled CLK a the mod eight counter", "MOYNu60OnXU-00020-00007166-00007553": "flip-flops B C and D make up the mod", "MOYNu60OnXU-00021-00007554-00007826": "eight counter the count begins at zero", "MOYNu60OnXU-00022-00007827-00008126": "zero zero with the maximum count at 1 1", "MOYNu60OnXU-00023-00008127-00008384": "1 or the decimal equivalent to 7", "MOYNu60OnXU-00024-00008385-00008753": "creating eight different counts the mod", "MOYNu60OnXU-00025-00008754-00009002": "8 counter changes its count every time a", "MOYNu60OnXU-00026-00009003-00009203": "negative edge of a clock pulse is", "MOYNu60OnXU-00027-00009204-00009446": "applied to its clock input which is", "MOYNu60OnXU-00028-00009447-00009784": "labeled CLK B", "MOYNu60OnXU-00029-00009785-00010363": "the mod 16 counter the 749 3 IC can be", "MOYNu60OnXU-00030-00010364-00010684": "made to operate as a mod 16 binary up", "MOYNu60OnXU-00031-00010685-00010936": "counter by connecting an external wire", "MOYNu60OnXU-00032-00010937-00011332": "from the mod to output QA to clock input", "MOYNu60OnXU-00033-00011333-00011656": "B of the mod 8 counter or by applying", "MOYNu60OnXU-00034-00011657-00012076": "clock pulses to clock input a the seven", "MOYNu60OnXU-00035-00012077-00012319": "four nine three IC can operate at", "MOYNu60OnXU-00036-00012320-00012580": "various modulus counts other than two", "MOYNu60OnXU-00037-00012581-00012919": "eight or sixteen by using to reset leads", "MOYNu60OnXU-00038-00012919-00013275": "labeled r01 in our zero two", "MOYNu60OnXU-00039-00013276-00013531": "when logic highs are applied to both", "MOYNu60OnXU-00040-00013532-00013794": "reset leads simultaneously the count", "MOYNu60OnXU-00041-00013795-00014224": "resets to zero zero zero zero under", "MOYNu60OnXU-00042-00014225-00014428": "normal counts both leads should be", "MOYNu60OnXU-00043-00014429-00014887": "connected to a logic low the mod twelve", "MOYNu60OnXU-00044-00014888-00015175": "counter modification the seven four nine", "MOYNu60OnXU-00045-00015176-00015438": "three can be modified to operate as a", "MOYNu60OnXU-00046-00015440-00015675": "mod twelve up counter which means it", "MOYNu60OnXU-00047-00015676-00015910": "will have 12 different counts from 0 to", "MOYNu60OnXU-00048-00015911-00016378": "11 to operate as a mod 12 counter QC and", "MOYNu60OnXU-00049-00016379-00016728": "QD output leads are connected to R 0 1", "MOYNu60OnXU-00050-00016729-00017275": "and R 0 2 as soon as the binary count of", "MOYNu60OnXU-00051-00017276-00017641": "1 1 0 0 the decimal equivalent of 12 is", "MOYNu60OnXU-00052-00017642-00018067": "reached R 0 1 and R 0 2 are both high", "MOYNu60OnXU-00053-00018068-00018456": "which causes the counter to reset the", "MOYNu60OnXU-00054-00018457-00018694": "count of 12 is preset for only 40", "MOYNu60OnXU-00055-00018695-00018949": "nanoseconds which is faster than what", "MOYNu60OnXU-00056-00018950-00019146": "can be detected by the human eye", "MOYNu60OnXU-00057-00019147-00019417": "therefore 12 is not considered a valid", "MOYNu60OnXU-00058-00019418-00019774": "count we will apply 12 clock pulses and", "MOYNu60OnXU-00059-00019775-00021219": "observe the count", "MOYNu60OnXU-00060-00021220-00021526": "you have completed this activity the", "MOYNu60OnXU-00061-00021527-00021781": "seven four nine three I see binary", "MOYNu60OnXU-00062-00021782-00022030": "counter"}}, {"audio_id": "MPnZkYDgHcg", "text": {"MPnZkYDgHcg-00000-00000114-00001726": "[Music]", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00001-00001727-00002063": "now ah in this part we will consider the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00002-00002064-00002455": "hydrogen compression and expansion", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00003-00002456-00002679": "now the hydrogen compression or", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00004-00002680-00002958": "expansion that will depend upon which", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00005-00002959-00003238": "thermodynamic process has been used", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00006-00003239-00003479": "and thus the final state of the gas will", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00007-00003479-00003735": "also be determined by the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00008-00003736-00003959": "the process used", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00009-00003960-00004263": "in actual practice it is very difficult", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00010-00004264-00004527": "to identify the process actual process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00011-00004528-00004783": "that occurs in the compression and it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00012-00004784-00004983": "requires a lot of efforts", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00013-00004984-00005102": "so what", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00014-00005103-00005454": "is done is actual process is in fact", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00015-00005455-00005695": "mapped to a reference thermodynamic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00016-00005696-00005854": "process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00017-00005855-00006102": "which closely approximate the actual", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00018-00006103-00006247": "process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00019-00006248-00006454": "so we can consider the process to be", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00020-00006455-00006678": "either an isoentropic compression or we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00021-00006679-00006919": "can consider it to be a isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00022-00006920-00007039": "compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00023-00007040-00007263": "now if the process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00024-00007264-00007478": "of compression is considered to be an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00025-00007479-00007767": "isothermal compression in that case the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00026-00007768-00008103": "work of compression required is minimum", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00027-00008104-00008791": "if it is isothermal compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00028-00008792-00009078": "then the compression work required is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00029-00009079-00009519": "minimum", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00030-00009520-00009710": "and that we know from the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00031-00009711-00009967": "knowledge of thermodynamics", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00032-00009968-00010206": "if the process of compression is modeled", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00033-00010207-00010846": "to isoentropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00034-00010847-00011335": "in that case the compression work", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00035-00011336-00011759": "is maximum", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00036-00011760-00011903": "now", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00037-00011904-00012127": "single stage or whether it is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00038-00012128-00012695": "multi-stage compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00039-00012696-00013094": "compressors when they", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00040-00013095-00013415": "are compressing hydrogen gas and", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00041-00013416-00013663": "cooling is involved or cooling is being", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00042-00013663-00013886": "considered during the compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00043-00013887-00014255": "process then they can be modeled as", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00044-00014256-00014471": "isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00045-00014472-00014655": "or the process can be modeled as", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00046-00014656-00015007": "isothermal process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00047-00015008-00015127": "however", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00048-00015128-00015350": "there is no cooling involved", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00049-00015351-00015558": "during the compression process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00050-00015559-00016286": "or for moderate pressure ratios", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00051-00016287-00016543": "the process can be modeled as an iso", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00052-00016544-00016839": "entropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00053-00016840-00017103": "and if there is no efforts being put in", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00054-00017104-00017279": "so as to remove the heat which is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00055-00017280-00017575": "generated during the compression process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00056-00017576-00017791": "then in that case this is an adiabatic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00057-00017792-00017983": "process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00058-00017984-00018191": "so the process can be modeled according", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00059-00018192-00018343": "to the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00060-00018344-00018599": "whether the process is involves cooling", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00061-00018600-00018791": "whether it is it does not involve", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00062-00018792-00019022": "cooling so accordingly the process can", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00063-00019023-00019183": "be modeled to the appropriate", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00064-00019184-00019358": "thermodynamic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00065-00019359-00019550": "process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00066-00019551-00019911": "now let us first consider the hydrogen", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00067-00019912-00020150": "compression process to be an isoentropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00068-00020151-00020407": "process so as mentioned it is very", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00069-00020408-00020630": "difficult to find out what the actual", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00070-00020631-00020911": "process would approximate to however it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00071-00020912-00021222": "can be modeled to be isoentropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00072-00021223-00021327": "where", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00073-00021328-00021614": "the when the compression is done to a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00074-00021615-00021750": "elevated", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00075-00021751-00021863": "pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00076-00021864-00021958": "the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00077-00021959-00022303": "work of compression we can calculate", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00078-00022304-00022567": "if we consider the gas to be an ideal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00079-00022568-00022678": "gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00080-00022679-00022807": "then the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00081-00022808-00023078": "isoentropic work involved is given by", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00082-00023079-00023199": "the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00083-00023200-00023471": "specific heat ratio gamma divided by", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00084-00023472-00023767": "gamma minus 1 r is the gas constant", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00085-00023768-00023975": "t is the initial temperature", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00086-00023976-00024191": "p2 is the discharge or the final", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00087-00024192-00024375": "pressure p1 is the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00088-00024376-00024607": "initial pressure or the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00089-00024608-00024750": "inlet pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00090-00024751-00024950": "and again to the power gamma minus 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00091-00024951-00025135": "upon gamma minus 1. so this is the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00092-00025136-00025430": "isoentropic work considering the gas to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00093-00025431-00025639": "be an ideal gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00094-00025639-00025846": "here since the process is of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00095-00025847-00025958": "so the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00096-00025960-00026127": "initial pressure is lower than the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00097-00026127-00026399": "delivery or the final discharge pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00098-00026400-00026631": "now considering the gas to be", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00099-00026632-00026862": "diatomic because hydrogen is diatomic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00100-00026863-00027167": "gas the specific heat ratio", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00101-00027168-00027487": "is 1.4", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00102-00027488-00027743": "now this is the process considering an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00103-00027744-00028055": "isoentropic process which is reversible", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00104-00028056-00028343": "but in actual process the process is not", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00105-00028344-00028527": "a reversible process there are several", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00106-00028527-00028790": "irreversibilities involved to account", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00107-00028791-00028983": "for those in reversibilities we can", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00108-00028983-00029255": "consider an isoentropic compressor", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00109-00029256-00029383": "efficiency", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00110-00029383-00029623": "so this is considering the ideal process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00111-00029624-00029918": "which is reversible but if in order to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00112-00029919-00030102": "account for the irreversibilities", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00113-00030103-00030311": "involved in the process we can", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00114-00030312-00030535": "include the isoentropic compressor", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00115-00030536-00030783": "efficiency in the denominator so the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00116-00030783-00031014": "actual work done", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00117-00031016-00031318": "is the ratio of the two the isentropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00118-00031319-00031399": "work", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00119-00031400-00031631": "and the isoentropic compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00120-00031632-00031790": "efficiency", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00121-00031791-00032087": "this isoentropic compressor efficiency", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00122-00032088-00032335": "this lies in the range of 75 to 80", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00123-00032336-00032574": "percent besides that we have to also", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00124-00032575-00032751": "include the efficiency of the motor", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00125-00032752-00033279": "which lies in the range of 90 percent", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00126-00033280-00033479": "now", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00127-00033480-00033807": "ideal gas we know this is a is a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00128-00033808-00034007": "theoretical concept", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00129-00034008-00034111": "where we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00130-00034112-00034351": "know that we consider that the gases", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00131-00034352-00034511": "these are", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00132-00034512-00034639": "made up of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00133-00034640-00034879": "hard molecules which have negligible", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00134-00034880-00035087": "volume solid spheres", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00135-00035088-00035255": "and they have no interaction between the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00136-00035256-00035399": "gas molecules", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00137-00035400-00035646": "however in actual case", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00138-00035647-00036023": "the real gases they have an interaction", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00139-00036024-00036271": "a attractive or a repulsive interaction", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00140-00036272-00036615": "that exists so the behavior of the gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00141-00036616-00036902": "as we have seen in the earlier class", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00142-00036903-00037095": "for a real gas it is different from the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00143-00037096-00037271": "ideal gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00144-00037272-00037479": "now in order to calculate the work which", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00145-00037480-00037687": "is required for compression using an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00146-00037688-00038023": "isoentropic process for a real gas we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00147-00038024-00038190": "can find the work", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00148-00038191-00038367": "that is given by the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00149-00038368-00038639": "gas constant r t 1 the initial", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00150-00038640-00038743": "temperature", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00151-00038744-00038999": "the compressibility factor z 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00152-00039000-00039262": "and the initial pressure p 1.", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00153-00039263-00039679": "so r t 1 z 1 p 1 raised to the power", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00154-00039680-00039935": "1 minus k 1 upon k k 1 is the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00155-00039936-00040271": "isoentropic coefficient", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00156-00040272-00040607": "which relates the pressure volume", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00157-00040608-00040855": "equation of state and then there is an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00158-00040856-00041062": "integration from initial pressure to the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00159-00041063-00041367": "final pressure p 2", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00160-00041368-00041551": "p raised to the power", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00161-00041552-00041679": "k 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00162-00041680-00041783": "minus", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00163-00041784-00042015": "1 over k 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00164-00042016-00042399": "integrated over the pressure dp", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00165-00042400-00042727": "now we know that the exponent k1 also", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00166-00042728-00042879": "changes", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00167-00042880-00043087": "when pressure changes so we know that it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00168-00043088-00043262": "is a function of both temperature and", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00169-00043263-00043502": "pressure at a particular temperature let", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00170-00043503-00043774": "us say t when the pressure changes from", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00171-00043775-00044071": "p1 to p2 the exponent also changes", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00172-00044072-00044358": "now since the variation is linear we can", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00173-00044359-00044583": "take average of the exponent in these", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00174-00044584-00044911": "two states so the k1 average we can use", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00175-00044912-00045127": "so if at pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00176-00045128-00045423": "p1 temperature t1 the value is k1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00177-00045424-00045679": "at temperature t2 pressure p2", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00178-00045680-00045895": "the value and the two values and we can", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00179-00045896-00046095": "take its average", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00180-00046096-00046367": "now this average exponent", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00181-00046368-00046655": "1 average divided by 1 minus k 1 average", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00182-00046656-00047007": "r t 1 z 1 p 2 by p 1 to the power k 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00183-00047008-00047286": "average minus 1 upon k 1 average my", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00184-00047287-00047511": "average minus 1 this gives the iso", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00185-00047512-00047679": "entropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00186-00047680-00047774": "work", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00187-00047775-00047839": "for", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00188-00047840-00048030": "compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00189-00048031-00048935": "for a real gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00190-00048936-00049174": "the another possibility is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00191-00049175-00049423": "if the actual process is modeled to be", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00192-00049424-00049607": "isothermal process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00193-00049608-00049790": "that means", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00194-00049791-00049990": "we are removing the heat during the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00195-00049991-00050158": "compression so whatever is the heat", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00196-00050159-00050351": "generated during the compression that is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00197-00050352-00050543": "removed such that the temperature of the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00198-00050544-00050758": "process remains constant", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00199-00050759-00050999": "now here again we can consider either", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00200-00051000-00051214": "the gas to be ideal gas if we consider", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00201-00051215-00051311": "the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00202-00051312-00051479": "gas to be ideal gas the work of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00203-00051479-00051830": "isothermal compression is rt ln of v2", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00204-00051832-00052182": "upon v1 we can have different models for", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00205-00052183-00052423": "real gas and considering the van der", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00206-00052424-00052671": "waals gas model we can also get the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00207-00052672-00052894": "isothermal work for the van der waals", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00208-00052895-00053215": "gas as rtln of v2 minus b upon v1 minus", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00209-00053216-00053326": "b plus", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00210-00053327-00053638": "alpha upon v two minus alpha upon v one", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00211-00053639-00053830": "so this is the required work of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00212-00053832-00054054": "compression considering the process to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00213-00054055-00054247": "be isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00214-00054248-00054366": "however if we include the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00215-00054367-00054575": "compressibility factor as a deviation", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00216-00054576-00054823": "between the real and ideal gas behavior", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00217-00054824-00055047": "we can write the isothermal compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00218-00055048-00055335": "work as rt integration", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00219-00055336-00055535": "over the initial pressure to final", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00220-00055536-00055823": "pressure compressibility factor z upon p", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00221-00055824-00056015": "integrated over dp", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00222-00056016-00056287": "so rt integration p1 to p2 applied upon", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00223-00056288-00056623": "pdp on integration we can get a value of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00224-00056624-00056735": "rt", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00225-00056736-00057063": "z average ln of p2 upon p1 so the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00226-00057064-00057223": "pressure ratio", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00227-00057224-00057575": "now again this z average is the average", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00228-00057576-00057766": "compressibility factor we have already", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00229-00057767-00057950": "seen the variation of compressibility", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00230-00057951-00058111": "factor for different temperature and", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00231-00058112-00058342": "pressure now in this case since it is an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00232-00058344-00058511": "isothermal process the temperature", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00233-00058512-00058935": "remains constant", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00234-00058936-00059223": "so the average compressibility factor is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00235-00059224-00059326": "found", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00236-00059327-00059511": "as an average of the compressibility", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00237-00059512-00059726": "factor in the two different states where", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00238-00059727-00059919": "the pressure was different in one state", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00239-00059920-00060103": "where the pressure was p one in the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00240-00060104-00060279": "another state when the pressure was p", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00241-00060279-00060375": "two", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00242-00060376-00060615": "and then we can find out the isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00243-00060616-00060742": "work", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00244-00060744-00060991": "for the compressible gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00245-00060991-00061071": "now", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00246-00061072-00061279": "this figure shows", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00247-00061279-00061559": "that depending upon which gas model we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00248-00061560-00061815": "have used the work of compression may", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00249-00061816-00061991": "differ", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00250-00061991-00062319": "so whether we have used an ideal gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00251-00062320-00062430": "model", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00252-00062432-00062582": "whether we have considered it to be a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00253-00062583-00062815": "real gas whether it is an isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00254-00062816-00063006": "process whether it is an isoentropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00255-00063007-00063111": "process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00256-00063112-00063263": "whether we have considered a vendor", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00257-00063264-00063391": "walls gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00258-00063391-00063550": "or we have considered it to be a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00259-00063551-00063694": "compressible", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00260-00063695-00063871": "gas considering the compressibility", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00261-00063872-00064215": "factor the different curves are obtained", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00262-00064216-00064575": "so for an ideal gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00263-00064576-00064775": "considering it to be an isoentropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00264-00064776-00064942": "process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00265-00064944-00065271": "we are getting the highest amount of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00266-00065272-00065487": "work of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00267-00065488-00065775": "similarly for considering it to be a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00268-00065776-00065959": "compressible gas with the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00269-00065960-00066199": "compressibility factor the model which", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00270-00066200-00066350": "uses the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00271-00066351-00066559": "compressibility factor", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00272-00066560-00066631": "and", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00273-00066632-00067094": "considering it to be isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00274-00067095-00067311": "the third one is considering it to be a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00275-00067312-00067694": "vendor walls gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00276-00067695-00068079": "and under isothermal conditions", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00277-00068080-00068279": "and finally considering it to be an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00278-00068280-00068471": "ideal gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00279-00068472-00068887": "under isothermal conditions", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00280-00068888-00069119": "this shows that depending upon the gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00281-00069120-00069279": "model used", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00282-00069280-00069471": "the work of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00283-00069472-00069750": "varies with the pressure now important", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00284-00069751-00070047": "thing to be noted here is that", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00285-00070048-00070247": "other than the gas model the effect of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00286-00070248-00070431": "the gas model used", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00287-00070432-00070726": "the curve is not linear that is to be", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00288-00070727-00070831": "noted", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00289-00070832-00071087": "it shows a parabolic nature so the curve", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00290-00071088-00071375": "shows a parabolic nature", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00291-00071376-00071679": "and that is very important consideration", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00292-00071680-00071911": "because the work of compression its", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00293-00071912-00072135": "variation with the pressure the delivery", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00294-00072136-00072375": "pressure or the discharge pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00295-00072376-00072638": "is showing a parabolic nature", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00296-00072639-00072879": "that means it depends upon the suction", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00297-00072880-00073038": "pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00298-00073039-00073119": "how", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00299-00073120-00073367": "let us say if we have compressed it to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00300-00073368-00073647": "350 bar", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00301-00073648-00073967": "so if we compare the work of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00302-00073968-00074175": "which is required to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00303-00074176-00074462": "compress from ambient pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00304-00074463-00074647": "to 350 bar", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00305-00074648-00074862": "is much higher", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00306-00074863-00075055": "if we see the variation this is much", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00307-00075056-00075294": "higher as compared to the amount of work", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00308-00075295-00075438": "which is required", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00309-00075439-00075623": "to compress it to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00310-00075624-00076006": "from 350 to 700 baht", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00311-00076007-00076223": "so this work is much higher", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00312-00076224-00076479": "compared to the amount of energy which", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00313-00076480-00076711": "will be required to compress it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00314-00076712-00077638": "from 350 to 700 bar", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00315-00077639-00078071": "and thus this makes it very important", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00316-00078072-00078343": "that the method of hydrogen production", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00317-00078344-00078550": "which is used whether it is reformer", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00318-00078551-00078735": "based hydrogen production or whether it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00319-00078736-00078959": "is the hydrogen which is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00320-00078960-00079287": "being produced is from electrolyzer", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00321-00079288-00079567": "whatever production route is giving", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00322-00079568-00079815": "hydrogen at a higher pressure we can", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00323-00079816-00080094": "save in terms of the work of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00324-00080095-00080311": "or the process can get more and more", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00325-00080312-00080631": "energy efficient if the suction pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00326-00080632-00080862": "for the compressor is available at a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00327-00080863-00081094": "higher pressure and that is the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00328-00081095-00081287": "importance", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00329-00081288-00081511": "when the delivery from the production", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00330-00081512-00082150": "plant is at a higher pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00331-00082151-00082231": "now", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00332-00082232-00082479": "as mentioned", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00333-00082480-00082599": "the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00334-00082600-00082823": "theoretically the work required to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00335-00082824-00083031": "compress hydrogen in an isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00336-00083032-00083238": "process is minimum", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00337-00083239-00083423": "and to compress it through an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00338-00083424-00083687": "isoentropic process it is maximum", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00339-00083688-00083935": "but the actual work of compression it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00340-00083936-00084167": "lies between the two theoretical limits", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00341-00084168-00084359": "of isothermal and isoentropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00342-00084360-00084599": "compression so the actual process of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00343-00084600-00084926": "compression it is neither isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00344-00084927-00085135": "the reason being as we compress the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00345-00085136-00085343": "temperature of the gas increases", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00346-00085344-00085511": "on compression so we cannot keep it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00347-00085512-00085638": "isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00348-00085639-00085871": "neither it is adiabatic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00349-00085872-00085991": "because", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00350-00085992-00086143": "there will be heat exchange with the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00351-00086144-00086303": "surroundings", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00352-00086304-00086638": "neither it is isoentropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00353-00086639-00086847": "because in isentropic process the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00354-00086848-00087015": "process is considered to be reversible", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00355-00087016-00087182": "but the actual process is a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00356-00087183-00087375": "non-reversible process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00357-00087376-00087591": "there will be losses associated because", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00358-00087592-00087838": "of the friction there will be viscous", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00359-00087839-00088103": "losses so all these make", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00360-00088104-00088343": "the actual process neither isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00361-00088344-00088735": "nor adiabatic nor an isoentropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00362-00088736-00088815": "so", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00363-00088816-00088975": "some of the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00364-00088976-00089159": "reports some of the researchers they", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00365-00089160-00089391": "have even modeled the process to be a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00366-00089392-00089575": "polytropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00367-00089576-00089782": "here in this curve the work of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00368-00089783-00090031": "compression has been plotted so the same", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00369-00090032-00090294": "curve has been plotted as a percentage", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00370-00090295-00090479": "lower heating value that the how much", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00371-00090480-00090775": "amount of energy of hydrogen would be", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00372-00090776-00091006": "required energy content of hydrogen", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00373-00091007-00091206": "would be required in compressing the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00374-00091207-00091575": "hydrogen to a higher pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00375-00091576-00091743": "now as mentioned", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00376-00091744-00092047": "some researchers consider the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00377-00092048-00092255": "compression process to be a polytropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00378-00092256-00092494": "process so if we consider the process to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00379-00092495-00092711": "be a polytropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00380-00092712-00093038": "then it is pv to the power n is equal to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00381-00093039-00093167": "constant", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00382-00093168-00093591": "and that n is the polytropic index", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00383-00093592-00093879": "so the polytropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00384-00093880-00094174": "work is n upon n minus 1 n is the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00385-00094175-00094423": "polytropic index r t 1 the initial", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00386-00094424-00094671": "temperature gas constant", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00387-00094672-00094950": "times the p 2 by p 1 pressure ratio", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00388-00094951-00095311": "to the power n minus 1 upon n minus 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00389-00095312-00095503": "so this is the work of compression which", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00390-00095504-00095662": "will be required", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00391-00095663-00095838": "if the process is considered to be a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00392-00095839-00096038": "polytropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00393-00096039-00096271": "this is considering an ideal process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00394-00096272-00096535": "however the actual work of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00395-00096536-00096774": "will be higher and that can be accounted", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00396-00096775-00096903": "for", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00397-00096904-00097287": "by considering a polytropic efficiency", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00398-00097288-00097431": "neeta p", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00399-00097432-00097655": "and this polytropic efficiency is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00400-00097656-00097926": "related to both the polytropic index and", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00401-00097927-00098182": "the specific heat ratio as", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00402-00098183-00098462": "n is the polytropic index n upon n minus", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00403-00098463-00098759": "1 is equal to gamma upon gamma minus 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00404-00098760-00099023": "neeta p where gamma is the specific heat", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00405-00099024-00099206": "ratio neeta p is the polytropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00406-00099207-00099343": "efficiency", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00407-00099344-00099526": "now considering the process of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00408-00099527-00099743": "compression the temperature the final", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00409-00099744-00099982": "temperature of the gas on compressing it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00410-00099983-00100271": "from pressure p1 to p2 can be obtained", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00411-00100272-00100526": "as t2 will be the final temperature so", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00412-00100527-00100791": "t2 upon the initial temperature t1 is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00413-00100792-00101006": "the pressure ratio p2 upon p1 to the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00414-00101007-00101303": "power n minus 1 upon n", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00415-00101304-00101479": "usually in the compression process the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00416-00101480-00101679": "temperature increases so on compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00417-00101680-00101926": "we know that now since the temperature", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00418-00101927-00102231": "increases if we cool down the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00419-00102232-00102335": "gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00420-00102336-00102518": "on compression the increase in the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00421-00102519-00102694": "temperature and we reduce", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00422-00102695-00102934": "the temperature of the gas the required", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00423-00102935-00103263": "work of compression will also reduce", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00424-00103264-00103671": "so if we cool the gas on compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00425-00103672-00104047": "the work of compression reduces", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00426-00104048-00104278": "now ideally what is required is as we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00427-00104279-00104518": "know that the isothermal process if we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00428-00104519-00104727": "make the process to be completely", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00429-00104728-00105015": "isothermal an ideal isothermal process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00430-00105016-00105239": "is very difficult to attain", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00431-00105240-00105447": "the reason being", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00432-00105448-00105663": "by means of isothermal process and ideal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00433-00105664-00105847": "isothermal process is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00434-00105848-00105934": "we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00435-00105935-00106239": "we remove the heat from the gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00436-00106240-00106486": "or during the compression process at the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00437-00106488-00106751": "same rate as it is being produced in the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00438-00106752-00106854": "process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00439-00106855-00107047": "or we consider that the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00440-00107048-00107310": "the temperature is uniform throughout", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00441-00107311-00107615": "the ah the compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00442-00107616-00107686": "so", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00443-00107688-00107886": "it is ideally it is very difficult to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00444-00107888-00108158": "achieve it is a very complicated cooling", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00445-00108159-00108415": "system will be required so actually we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00446-00108416-00108671": "can approximate it by considering a", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00447-00108672-00108951": "multi stage compression or including an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00448-00108952-00109239": "intercooling stage so that the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00449-00109240-00109566": "temperature at each stage of the gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00450-00109567-00109831": "attains its initial temperature", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00451-00109832-00110047": "so if this intercooling which is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00452-00110048-00110254": "introduced between the different stages", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00453-00110255-00110415": "if it is perfect", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00454-00110416-00110663": "in that case the temperature of the gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00455-00110664-00110902": "will become same it will be identical", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00456-00110903-00111158": "after each stage of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00457-00111159-00111278": "considering", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00458-00111279-00111510": "a two stage compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00459-00111511-00111783": "considering an ideal gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00460-00111783-00112083": "undergoing an isoentropic", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00461-00112083-00112343": "compression including two stage of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00462-00112344-00112486": "compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00463-00112488-00112751": "if the initial pressure or the suction", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00464-00112752-00113271": "pressure is p one", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00465-00113272-00113483": "the delivery pressure is let us say p", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00466-00113483-00113878": "three or the discharge pressure is p3", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00467-00113879-00114015": "and there is an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00468-00114016-00114383": "intermediate or an optimal pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00469-00114383-00114599": "this is an intermediate", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00470-00114600-00114743": "pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00471-00114744-00115063": "an optimal pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00472-00115064-00115278": "considering that the isoentropic work of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00473-00115279-00115647": "compression is given by gamma r t 1 upon", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00474-00115648-00115847": "gamma minus 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00475-00115848-00116078": "times the pressure ratio p 2 upon p 1 to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00476-00116079-00116343": "the power gamma minus 1 upon gamma", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00477-00116344-00116534": "minus 1 this is corresponding to the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00478-00116535-00116719": "first stage", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00479-00116720-00116878": "plus", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00480-00116879-00117095": "gamma rt1 the temperature remains", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00481-00117096-00117254": "constant", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00482-00117255-00117502": "after the first stage compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00483-00117503-00117758": "upon gamma minus 1 times the pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00484-00117759-00118023": "ratio p3 upon p2 to the power gamma", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00485-00118024-00118215": "minus 1 upon gamma", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00486-00118216-00118399": "minus 1", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00487-00118400-00118558": "where", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00488-00118559-00118823": "the pressure p2", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00489-00118824-00119023": "which is the intermediate optimal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00490-00119024-00119399": "pressure is given by under root of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00491-00119400-00119702": "p3 and p1 so", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00492-00119703-00119871": "ideally it is considered that the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00493-00119872-00120134": "pressure ratio should be same between", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00494-00120135-00120334": "the different stages", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00495-00120335-00120566": "now if we consider a multi-stage", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00496-00120567-00120686": "compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00497-00120688-00120934": "with inter cooling in between so what we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00498-00120935-00121214": "are doing is after each stage we are", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00499-00121215-00121351": "cooling down", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00500-00121352-00121599": "the gas to its initial temperature by", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00501-00121600-00121823": "introducing an intercooler", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00502-00121824-00122199": "and using that it is it is not becoming", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00503-00122200-00122399": "ideal isothermal process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00504-00122400-00122631": "but we are trying to", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00505-00122632-00122854": "keep the temperature same after every", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00506-00122855-00123143": "stage and using that we can reduce the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00507-00123144-00123399": "work of compression now if we consider", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00508-00123400-00123623": "the electrical", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00509-00123624-00123871": "work which is required for compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00510-00123872-00124247": "as against the variation in the pressure", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00511-00124248-00124551": "for two different suction pressure this", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00512-00124552-00124647": "is being", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00513-00124648-00124839": "plotted in this curve", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00514-00124840-00125190": "so for two different pressures", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00515-00125191-00125399": "35 bar", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00516-00125400-00125678": "and two bar considering different", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00517-00125679-00126014": "stages of compression for two bar there", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00518-00126015-00126199": "have been five stages which has been", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00519-00126200-00126495": "considered", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00520-00126496-00126839": "considering one stage", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00521-00126840-00126975": "considering", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00522-00126976-00127231": "two stage three stage and five stage", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00523-00127232-00127439": "compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00524-00127440-00127743": "for 35 bar three stages has been", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00525-00127744-00128047": "considered stay one stage two stage and", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00526-00128048-00128166": "three stage", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00527-00128167-00128390": "now from this curve we can see that", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00528-00128391-00128654": "introducing an additional stage with", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00529-00128655-00128958": "intercooling in between it reduces the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00530-00128959-00129207": "amount of work of compression as we go", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00531-00129208-00129486": "from stage 1 to stage 5 the work of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00532-00129488-00129790": "compression required reduces", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00533-00129791-00130054": "at the same time this curve also", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00534-00130055-00130319": "emphasizes that the importance of the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00535-00130320-00130527": "suction pressure so if the initial", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00536-00130528-00130775": "pressure for compression is higher the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00537-00130776-00130990": "required amount of work for hydrogen", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00538-00130991-00131271": "compression will be lower", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00539-00131272-00131383": "usually", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00540-00131384-00131599": "like the there is a trade-off between", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00541-00131600-00131902": "the number of stages that we can add", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00542-00131903-00132063": "to the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00543-00132064-00132335": "the amount of energy being saved", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00544-00132336-00132590": "like if we add more number of stages", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00545-00132591-00132775": "then there will be a requirement of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00546-00132776-00133007": "infrastructure and additional cost", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00547-00133008-00133351": "associated with it and that needs to be", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00548-00133352-00133575": "considered against the energy which is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00549-00133576-00133783": "being shaved or energy work of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00550-00133784-00133999": "compression which is being saved by", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00551-00134000-00134207": "adding an additional stage of", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00552-00134208-00134375": "compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00553-00134376-00134727": "to summarize uh this part we have seen", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00554-00134728-00134999": "that it is difficult to approximate the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00555-00135000-00135166": "actual process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00556-00135167-00135390": "it requires a lot of efforts as such the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00557-00135391-00135607": "actual process could be approximated by", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00558-00135608-00135863": "a reference thermodynamic process it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00559-00135864-00136054": "could be an isothermal process or an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00560-00136055-00136319": "isoentropic process depending upon", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00561-00136320-00136559": "whether the compression is done with", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00562-00136560-00136751": "cooling or whether the heat is not", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00563-00136752-00137039": "removed during the compression process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00564-00137040-00137231": "we know from the basic thermodynamics", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00565-00137232-00137463": "that the work of compression required is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00566-00137464-00137647": "minimum if the process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00567-00137648-00137871": "is an isothermal process however it is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00568-00137872-00138039": "maximum when the process is an", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00569-00138040-00138223": "isoentropic process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00570-00138224-00138502": "so we have in this class also seen that", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00571-00138503-00138743": "work of compression considering whether", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00572-00138744-00138871": "the gas is", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00573-00138872-00139166": "ideal gas or whether it is a real gas", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00574-00139167-00139390": "which type of thermodynamic process we", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00575-00139391-00139687": "have modeled and also we have looked at", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00576-00139688-00139799": "the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00577-00139800-00139999": "compression work which is required when", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00578-00140000-00140207": "it is multi stage compression with inter", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00579-00140208-00140478": "cooling multi stage compression with", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00580-00140479-00140735": "intercooling has an advantage that it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00581-00140736-00141095": "can save the work of compression and it", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00582-00141096-00141375": "can approximate it to be a isothermal", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00583-00141376-00141663": "nearly isothermal process such that the", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00584-00141664-00141919": "temperature of the process", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00585-00141920-00142287": "is same after every stage of compression", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00586-00142288-00142891": "thank you", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00587-00142892-00146078": "[Music]", "MPnZkYDgHcg-00588-00146079-00146288": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "MPDQA3ATRSg", "text": {"MPDQA3ATRSg-00000-00000003-00000299": "from Gillette Stadium in Foxborough", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00001-00000300-00000407": "Massachusetts", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00002-00000408-00000839": "it's the cube covering Vita winter", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00003-00000840-00001584": "warmer 2018 presented by Silicon Engel", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00004-00001585-00001862": "hi I'm Stu minimun and this is the cubes", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00005-00001863-00002185": "coverage of V tug winter warmer 2018", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00006-00002186-00002282": "happy to welcome to the program", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00007-00002283-00002516": "first-time guests kevin Kotecki who's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00008-00002517-00002692": "the vice president of sales at igneous", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00009-00002693-00002870": "systems Kevin thanks for joining us yeah", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00010-00002871-00002954": "thanks for having me", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00011-00002955-00003184": "all right so we've we've been talking to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00012-00003185-00003379": "igneous since we've really the early", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00013-00003380-00003554": "days we've known some of the founders of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00014-00003554-00003811": "the team before we get into it tell us a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00015-00003812-00003956": "little bit about your background how", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00016-00003957-00004129": "long you bid with igneous and kind of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00017-00004130-00004325": "your day-to-day activities there yeah so", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00018-00004326-00004472": "I've been with igneous for three years", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00019-00004473-00004724": "now so very early stage came in", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00020-00004725-00004870": "pre-product pre-revenue I've been", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00021-00004871-00005063": "working with our earliest stage", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00022-00005064-00005234": "perspective customers and our earliest", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00023-00005235-00005570": "customers from day one so I've had the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00024-00005571-00005726": "pleasure over the last few months of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00025-00005727-00005924": "building out the sales organization more", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00026-00005925-00006029": "broadly the marketing organization", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00027-00006030-00006286": "growing as well as we have achieved that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00028-00006287-00006442": "product market fit that every startups", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00029-00006443-00006641": "looking for and going out and solving", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00030-00006642-00006794": "those problems at scale across the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00031-00006795-00006944": "country and having the feet on the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00032-00006945-00007139": "street to help with that yeah you know", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00033-00007140-00007283": "it's interesting we talk a lot on this", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00034-00007284-00007487": "program about you know these user groups", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00035-00007488-00007634": "they're great for the users to get", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00036-00007634-00007789": "education it's also a great place for", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00037-00007790-00007999": "hiring I've had helped lots of friends", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00038-00008000-00008252": "at this specific event you know talk to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00039-00008253-00008384": "a number of companies that are like oh", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00040-00008385-00008528": "yeah we're higher Nessie's everybody's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00041-00008529-00008746": "hiring SES yes I'm gay you're probably", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00042-00008747-00008956": "doing some interviews we are yeah while", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00043-00008957-00009281": "you're here but you know it's also loved", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00044-00009282-00009492": "I love to watch the the maturing of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00045-00009493-00009752": "startups a number of companies I met", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00046-00009753-00009946": "here at the first time igneous has been", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00047-00009947-00010135": "part of this event for a number of years", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00048-00010136-00010399": "yeah what brings igneous you know what I", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00049-00010400-00010546": "kind of come into the key objectives", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00050-00010547-00010709": "coming to an event like this yeah so", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00051-00010710-00010976": "with with v-tex winter warmer it's an", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00052-00010977-00011296": "opportunity to see customers first and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00053-00011297-00011546": "foremost and interact with local Boston", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00054-00011547-00011741": "companies that are here that fit the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00055-00011742-00011917": "profile and have the problems that we", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00056-00011918-00012046": "solve but it's also an opportunity to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00057-00012047-00012251": "see our partners and to have visibility", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00058-00012252-00012439": "in the community and show that support", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00059-00012440-00012613": "of the of the local business community", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00060-00012614-00012835": "as well all right so let's talk about", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00061-00012836-00013108": "igneous so you know at this show it's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00062-00013109-00013241": "the change in dynamics of what's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00063-00013241-00013330": "happening in the world of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00064-00013331-00013628": "josè ssin what's happening cloud igneous", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00065-00013629-00013991": "sits in those spaces and you know how", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00066-00013991-00014186": "does it differentiate itself from this", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00067-00014187-00014453": "massive market of you know cloud and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00068-00014454-00014600": "storage and everything that's going out", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00069-00014601-00014878": "there yeah so a good question the at a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00070-00014879-00015091": "high level what we do is we help", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00071-00015093-00015322": "organizations manage their unstructured", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00072-00015323-00015589": "data wherever it may be when that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00073-00015590-00015787": "unstructured data is at scale and and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00074-00015788-00015961": "begins to break traditional paradigms", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00075-00015962-00016363": "for doing so and the specific problems", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00076-00016365-00016561": "that we solve start with data protection", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00077-00016562-00016840": "day one it's a great way to help", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00078-00016841-00017042": "customers get insight into their full", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00079-00017043-00017330": "suite of unstructured file data and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00080-00017331-00017533": "build an index around that that's there", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00081-00017534-00017708": "with this extensible empowers or other", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00082-00017709-00018040": "services like archive like end user", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00083-00018041-00018295": "search and restore and and also feeds", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00084-00018296-00018439": "into our policy engine that helps", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00085-00018440-00018683": "customers tear data to the public cloud", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00086-00018684-00019000": "and specifically to cost appropriate", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00087-00019001-00019211": "cloud products like Amazon glacier like", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00088-00019212-00019514": "Azure Archive and so that intersection", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00089-00019515-00019700": "that we sit in between cloud and storage", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00090-00019701-00019908": "and all of that is really around", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00091-00019909-00020105": "delivering the entire experience as a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00092-00020106-00020386": "service and solving day one very", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00093-00020387-00020593": "difficult data protection problems yeah", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00094-00020594-00020815": "we talk about things like scale can you", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00095-00020816-00020996": "quantify for us you know what's what's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00096-00020997-00021158": "kind of the low bar for your customers", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00097-00021159-00021311": "have you know where does it start and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00098-00021312-00021602": "how big is big yeah so for us you know a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00099-00021603-00021775": "minimum starting point would be a couple", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00100-00021776-00022008": "a few hundred terabytes of file data", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00101-00022009-00022267": "it's not that big right yeah and in", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00102-00022268-00022502": "today's world not so much but it", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00103-00022503-00022658": "certainly does bring clarity to the type", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00104-00022659-00023017": "of customers that we can help and in and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00105-00023018-00023167": "its really we're not focused on", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00106-00023168-00023330": "structured data right we believe that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00107-00023331-00023521": "there are a lot of great solutions out", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00108-00023522-00023719": "there for protecting databases and and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00109-00023720-00023903": "virtualized infrastructure and that's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00110-00023904-00024089": "not what we do we partner with those", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00111-00024090-00024464": "folks and and as far as what how big is", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00112-00024465-00024658": "big you know our largest customers are", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00113-00024659-00024928": "have approximately 100 petabytes of file", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00114-00024929-00025130": "data and so approaching kind of the top", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00115-00025131-00025436": "end of what customers have still", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00116-00025437-00025759": "on-premise today okay so great sounds", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00117-00025760-00025987": "like you can start with I mean most", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00118-00025988-00026168": "customers are gonna have that kind of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00119-00026169-00026314": "data I mean do you find maybe it's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00120-00026315-00026458": "because it's unstructured there's plenty", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00121-00026459-00026608": "of companies that you know might not", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00122-00026609-00026687": "kind of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00123-00026688-00026858": "in your bucket and then you've got", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00124-00026858-00027023": "plenty of headroom for scale is what I'm", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00125-00027024-00027188": "hearing correct yeah an architectural a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00126-00027189-00027410": "that a Headroom is built in day one I", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00127-00027411-00027599": "think the the focus from a customer", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00128-00027600-00027818": "standpoint or an unstructured data is if", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00129-00027819-00028106": "we if we quantify and qualify what that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00130-00028107-00028325": "data is and where it comes from it's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00131-00028326-00028511": "really machine generated data at scale", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00132-00028512-00028751": "its application generated data at scale", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00133-00028752-00028945": "and so the types of industries where", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00134-00028947-00029189": "we're really doing well are call it", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00135-00029189-00029354": "electronic design and automation whether", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00136-00029355-00029519": "that's in a semiconductor space or an", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00137-00029520-00029714": "engineering use cases", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00138-00029714-00029924": "it's in media entertainment you know a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00139-00029925-00030133": "traditional place that has large-scale", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00140-00030135-00030392": "file data it's in legal services it's in", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00141-00030393-00030572": "proprietary trading it's in all the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00142-00030573-00030833": "places where that data exists but then", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00143-00030833-00031061": "it's also in bioinformatics where genome", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00144-00031062-00031244": "sequences and next-generation 3d", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00145-00031245-00031420": "microscopes are producing those kinds of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00146-00031422-00031664": "datasets and so not every organization", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00147-00031664-00031988": "is in that boat today right and so we're", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00148-00031989-00032174": "really working at machine scale as", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00149-00032175-00032357": "opposed to human scale data creation", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00150-00032358-00032608": "yeah it really goes back I think of you", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00151-00032610-00032741": "know when object storage was first", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00152-00032742-00032981": "discussed it was you described it really", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00153-00032982-00033179": "well kind of the people data versus you", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00154-00033180-00033389": "know machine data all the industries", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00155-00033390-00033644": "that you went through you know it's the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00156-00033645-00033953": "there's just the growth portfolio that I", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00157-00033954-00034253": "have to do things and we look it's you", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00158-00034254-00034409": "know how do I take that from being oh my", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00159-00034410-00034637": "gosh this is a challenge to how do I", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00160-00034638-00034772": "make an opportunity how do i leverage", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00161-00034773-00034987": "that data how do I use it", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00162-00034988-00035222": "it's about monetizing the data right and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00163-00035223-00035459": "if it's just simply data that you're", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00164-00035460-00035783": "storing then there's less incentive to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00165-00035784-00035939": "invest in platforms that allow the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00166-00035940-00036302": "extensibility of that data to to come", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00167-00036303-00036458": "through and be integrated into other", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00168-00036459-00036626": "applications other use cases that then", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00169-00036627-00036899": "can be monetized right and if we come", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00170-00036900-00037091": "back to some of the core problems that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00171-00037092-00037538": "we really solve and get us demonstrate", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00172-00037539-00037703": "the value of the product of the approach", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00173-00037704-00037949": "to customers it does indeed start with", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00174-00037950-00038135": "data protection day one right and so", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00175-00038136-00038345": "many of our customers today are", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00176-00038346-00038587": "protecting their data in a in a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00177-00038588-00038819": "traditional paradigm of whether that be", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00178-00038820-00039077": "ndmp to tape or just working within", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00179-00039078-00039326": "backup windows where the goal as an IT", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00180-00039327-00039548": "organization is to not impact your", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00181-00039549-00039715": "end-users and their ability to create", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00182-00039716-00039871": "the type of data that they can then", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00183-00039872-00040010": "monetize right so whether that's an", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00184-00040011-00040055": "engineer", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00185-00040056-00040307": "organization that's writing code or", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00186-00040308-00040604": "creating designs whatever it may be the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00187-00040605-00040778": "goal is to be behind the scenes right", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00188-00040779-00040987": "and so when the scale of data creation", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00189-00040988-00041240": "when the density of the file data that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00190-00041241-00041477": "is being created creates challenges", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00191-00041478-00041693": "those traditional architectures whether", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00192-00041694-00041846": "that be around metadata management or", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00193-00041847-00042131": "some other you know challenge of scale", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00194-00042132-00042356": "that's where we come in and we shine and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00195-00042357-00042518": "so we start day one focusing on", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00196-00042519-00042770": "customers hardest problems as it relates", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00197-00042771-00043052": "to file data scale and protecting it and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00198-00043053-00043253": "then once that data is on our system the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00199-00043254-00043442": "power of that platform the power of the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00200-00043443-00043634": "micro services driven architecture that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00201-00043635-00043739": "we've spoken about here on past", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00202-00043740-00044020": "interviews the power of the extensible", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00203-00044021-00044378": "you know compute context if you will", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00204-00044379-00044558": "that can then integrate into other", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00205-00044559-00044774": "applications and be leveraged for also", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00206-00044775-00044948": "very tangible things like archive and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00207-00044949-00045169": "reducing your spend on primary storage", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00208-00045170-00045412": "and also integrating with the cloud", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00209-00045413-00045602": "right yeah Kevin one of the things we've", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00210-00045603-00045785": "looked at is inside an organization a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00211-00045786-00046031": "lot of times this paradigm shift also", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00212-00046032-00046244": "goes with you know organizationally who", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00213-00046245-00046421": "owns this when I think about a lot of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00214-00046422-00046571": "the applications it would be that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00215-00046572-00046775": "application owner that has the problem D", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00216-00046776-00047042": "but isn't connected necessarily with the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00217-00047043-00047249": "storage admin or virtualization admin or", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00218-00047250-00047525": "cloud architect how does igneous how do", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00219-00047526-00047677": "you get involved there and how do you", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00220-00047678-00047849": "work help companies work through some of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00221-00047850-00048083": "those organizational dynamics yeah so", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00222-00048084-00048193": "that's been one of the most satisfying", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00223-00048194-00048415": "elements over the last years of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00224-00048416-00048635": "successfully solving customer problems", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00225-00048636-00048884": "has been actually seen seeing the closer", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00226-00048885-00049106": "marriage of those three entities within", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00227-00049107-00049271": "organization so again the application", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00228-00049272-00049546": "owner the backup or disaster recovery", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00229-00049547-00049946": "owner and the storage owner and so the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00230-00049947-00050255": "most tangible example I can give is in a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00231-00050256-00050560": "world where backups were impacting", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00232-00050561-00050815": "end-users in this case an engineering", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00233-00050816-00050996": "organization that would experience", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00234-00050997-00051190": "latency in their application and then", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00235-00051191-00051335": "the work they're trying to do there", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00236-00051336-00051554": "they're traditionally their first order", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00237-00051554-00051911": "I guess their first solution is was to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00238-00051912-00052165": "contact the backup team and say hey are", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00239-00052166-00052364": "you running a backup if so kill it", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00240-00052365-00052579": "because you're impacting my ability to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00241-00052580-00052862": "do my job and then the storage folks of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00242-00052863-00052994": "course we're experiencing pain around", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00243-00052995-00053194": "trying to manage the scale of the arc", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00244-00053195-00053416": "the infrastructure to support", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00245-00053417-00053600": "to support that engineering organization", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00246-00053601-00053849": "and so in our approach we don't impact", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00247-00053850-00054137": "the end-users in any way and so and we", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00248-00054138-00054342": "provide continuous and automated", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00249-00054344-00054647": "protection which allows those data", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00250-00054648-00054872": "protection team members to focus on", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00251-00054873-00054965": "other things that are higher-order", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00252-00054966-00055157": "priorities than sitting there managing", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00253-00055158-00055361": "actively managing a backup window or", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00254-00055362-00055516": "backup itself that's that's something", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00255-00055517-00055709": "software does for them now and the end", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00256-00055710-00055859": "users no longer complain and and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00257-00055860-00056066": "therefore their daily interaction with", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00258-00056066-00056237": "ideas as it relates to data protection", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00259-00056238-00056660": "is less colored by the IT impacting", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00260-00056661-00056822": "their ability to do their job through", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00261-00056823-00057035": "through the data protection approaches", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00262-00057036-00057229": "that they're using today yeah when it", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00263-00057230-00057430": "comes to kind of some high-level data", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00264-00057432-00057659": "protection secondary storage there's a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00265-00057660-00057899": "lot of players out there and you know", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00266-00057900-00058085": "many of them it's like it's not it's", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00267-00058086-00058136": "like Oh", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00268-00058137-00058319": "data domain you know very different from", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00269-00058320-00058637": "you know a rubric or cohesive where does", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00270-00058638-00058855": "the igneous fit in kind of the spectrum", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00271-00058857-00059032": "of what's going on you know what are", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00272-00059033-00059182": "kind of some of the kind of you know", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00273-00059183-00059363": "companies that you're running up against", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00274-00059364-00059522": "that makes sense for you as opposed to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00275-00059523-00059707": "which ones they were just in the wrong", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00276-00059708-00059978": "conversation here right so the clear", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00277-00059979-00060215": "line of delineation between us and most", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00278-00060216-00060362": "of the other new entrants and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00279-00060363-00060505": "traditional entrants in the field is", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00280-00060507-00060728": "that we're only focused on file data we", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00281-00060729-00060919": "believe that the growth of unstructured", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00282-00060920-00061180": "data is is unbounded and will continue", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00283-00061182-00061391": "to be unbounded and will break", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00284-00061391-00061598": "traditional architectural paradigms and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00285-00061599-00061729": "so that's the problem that we're", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00286-00061730-00061889": "specifically focused on is how to help", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00287-00061890-00062032": "customers manage and protect that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00288-00062033-00062230": "therefore we're not focused on", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00289-00062232-00062486": "protecting structured data databases and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00290-00062487-00062771": "vm's that's not our point of entry what", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00291-00062772-00062975": "that does do within that space is create", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00292-00062976-00063116": "a lot of opportunities for partnership", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00293-00063116-00063338": "where our architectural approach is", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00294-00063339-00063560": "unique and is something that is very", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00295-00063561-00063794": "difficult to pull off if you're day one", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00296-00063795-00063989": "focus is on protecting virtual machines", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00297-00063990-00064238": "it's not easy for you to step up to the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00298-00064239-00064454": "plate and protect to three petabytes of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00299-00064454-00064651": "file data right and so that's an", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00300-00064652-00064867": "opportunity for Best of Breed solutions", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00301-00064869-00065096": "where the customer can have the best", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00302-00065097-00065309": "data protection and to vendors in place", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00303-00065310-00065513": "for those types of use cases ok Kevin", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00304-00065514-00065642": "want to give you the final word maybe do", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00305-00065643-00065786": "you have you know customer story you", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00306-00065787-00065849": "talked a little bit up the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00307-00065850-00066080": "organizational piece but you know what", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00308-00066081-00066287": "what's a customer story that you could", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00309-00066288-00066533": "relate that people might", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00310-00066534-00066689": "to find interesting so being in Boston", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00311-00066690-00066884": "having Boston to be such a hotbed of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00312-00066885-00067226": "bioinformatics the one of our recent", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00313-00067227-00067631": "customers is leveraging new 3d", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00314-00067632-00067814": "microscope technology to do very", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00315-00067815-00068123": "important research on you know the human", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00316-00068124-00068309": "body and disease and and things of that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00317-00068310-00068510": "nature and that's produces you know", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00318-00068511-00068804": "petabyte scale data even once it's been", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00319-00068805-00068978": "processed and so what we're helping them", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00320-00068979-00069230": "do is both protect that and minimize", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00321-00069231-00069494": "their costs of implementing primary", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00322-00069495-00069680": "storage minimize their cost around a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00323-00069681-00069887": "data protection and not have to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00324-00069888-00070211": "implement or put IT folks in play to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00325-00070212-00070364": "manage that whole process it's all very", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00326-00070365-00070550": "automated in this deployment but then", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00327-00070551-00070751": "also more even more importantly as from", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00328-00070752-00070964": "a collaborative standpoint they leverage", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00329-00070965-00071222": "us to tear to the cloud to then move", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00330-00071223-00071363": "that data and share that data with their", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00331-00071364-00071624": "other collaborating investigators and", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00332-00071625-00071888": "then also meet grant requirements of", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00333-00071889-00072104": "publishing their findings in a in a", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00334-00072105-00072287": "publicly available downloadable format", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00335-00072288-00072536": "and so that end-to-end ability to", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00336-00072537-00072743": "provide a solution for customers that", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00337-00072744-00072962": "have unique challenges in creating", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00338-00072963-00073238": "large-scale file data is just has been", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00339-00073239-00073319": "really satisfying", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00340-00073320-00073487": "alright well Kevin Kotecki appreciate", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00341-00073488-00073733": "all the updates as we've been saying for", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00342-00073734-00073865": "the last couple of years data is at the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00343-00073866-00074066": "center of it and need to change from", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00344-00074067-00074261": "that kind of you know challenges around", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00345-00074262-00074447": "data to huge opportunities out there", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00346-00074448-00074627": "Congrats on all the success well thank", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00347-00074628-00074807": "you very much appreciate it", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00348-00074808-00075047": "well lots more coverage here at the Vita", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00349-00075048-00075302": "2018 I'm Stu minimun you're watching the", "MPDQA3ATRSg-00350-00075303-00075530": "cube"}}, {"audio_id": "MQ1gfAyIuII", "text": {"MQ1gfAyIuII-00000-00000727-00000927": "we've got two trials i want to talk to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00001-00000927-00001150": "you about today the first one was done", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00002-00001151-00001374": "in three year old first calf cows the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00003-00001375-00001558": "second one in heifers", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00004-00001559-00001726": "and all of them are going to be related", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00005-00001727-00002039": "to progesterone production by the corpus", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00006-00002039-00002279": "luteum and how that affects the uter", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00007-00002280-00002463": "environment and establishment of", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00008-00002464-00002631": "pregnancy", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00009-00002632-00002895": "so if we start over at the estrous cycle", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00010-00002896-00003118": "itself you've probably all seen this we", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00011-00003119-00003335": "have increasing progesterone", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00012-00003336-00003543": "luteal regression cow comes in here a", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00013-00003544-00003759": "few days later", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00014-00003760-00003975": "first study i'm looking at", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00015-00003976-00004254": "is right about day seven of the estrous", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00016-00004255-00004375": "cycle", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00017-00004376-00004606": "and the reason day seven is important is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00018-00004607-00004822": "it's just after when the embryo was", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00019-00004823-00005038": "migrated into the uterus", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00020-00005039-00005286": "progesterone from that corpus luteum is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00021-00005287-00005495": "stimulating the uterine secretions", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00022-00005496-00005831": "required for embryonic development", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00023-00005832-00006215": "and for about 30 years we've known that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00024-00006216-00006542": "just in those few days around day 7 5 6", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00025-00006543-00006678": "7", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00026-00006679-00007006": "elevated levels of progesterone", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00027-00007008-00007255": "advance these uterine secretions", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00028-00007256-00007487": "you end up with bigger embryos", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00029-00007488-00007727": "now that was always done", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00030-00007728-00008039": "artificially by giving animals exogenous", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00031-00008040-00008223": "progesterone which is obviously not", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00032-00008224-00008391": "something you can do", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00033-00008392-00008735": "at a herd level and this whole story", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00034-00008736-00008846": "started", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00035-00008847-00009046": "when we were comparing the different", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00036-00009047-00009223": "forms of selenium", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00037-00009224-00009487": "and i observed that the mixed form was", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00038-00009488-00009727": "actually stimulating early ludial", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00039-00009728-00009991": "progesterone secretion i weren't looking", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00040-00009992-00010119": "for it", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00041-00010120-00010342": "but i guess i'd been", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00042-00010343-00010551": "lucky enough to find it because it was", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00043-00010552-00010783": "one of the key points of time where", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00044-00010784-00011006": "you're setting up that uterus for a", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00045-00011007-00011167": "pregnancy", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00046-00011168-00011359": "so we got a bunch of", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00047-00011360-00011574": "heifers no this was a two three-year-old", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00048-00011575-00011863": "cows ran them out to about day seven of", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00049-00011864-00012078": "the cycle and popped out their corporal", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00050-00012079-00012191": "ludia", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00051-00012192-00012374": "took him into the lab to try and work", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00052-00012375-00012599": "out the mechanism", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00053-00012600-00012783": "and i thought that it would be a", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00054-00012784-00012999": "selenium form-induced increase in", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00055-00013000-00013238": "steroidogenic enzymes", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00056-00013240-00013375": "which it wasn't", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00057-00013376-00013558": "which didn't make too much sense to me", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00058-00013559-00013775": "but sometimes that happens", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00059-00013776-00013975": "so we kept looking and found out it was", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00060-00013976-00014255": "all concerned with cholesterol influx", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00061-00014256-00014463": "into these luteal cells giving them the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00062-00014463-00014807": "ability to make progesterone", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00063-00014808-00015022": "you think about the corpus luteum itself", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00064-00015023-00015375": "it's a very metabolically active tissue", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00065-00015376-00015686": "and selena proteins are affecting redox", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00066-00015687-00015838": "so they're getting rid of hydrogen", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00067-00015840-00016135": "peroxide free radicals maintaining the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00068-00016136-00016366": "integrity of the cell giving it a better", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00069-00016368-00016630": "ability to do what it needs to do", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00070-00016631-00016911": "which has produced progesterone for a", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00071-00016912-00017135": "potential pregnancy", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00072-00017136-00017367": "so that took a little while to go and we", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00073-00017368-00017655": "found out yes it was cholesterol influx", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00074-00017656-00017863": "not steroidogenesis and we've still got", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00075-00017864-00018086": "a few more things to do with that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00076-00018087-00018286": "but it gave us enough information to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00077-00018287-00018479": "look forward and really look at", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00078-00018480-00018719": "pregnancy itself which is what you're", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00079-00018720-00018911": "all interested from a reproductive point", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00080-00018912-00019063": "of view", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00081-00019064-00019294": "so this last spring", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00082-00019295-00019583": "we'd run bunch of heifers", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00083-00019584-00019775": "on our different forms", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00084-00019776-00019967": "got them bred", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00085-00019968-00020175": "and killed them at maternal recognition", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00086-00020176-00020399": "of pregnancy which is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00087-00020400-00020927": "right here just before your regression", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00088-00020928-00021271": "it was uh we killed on day 17.", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00089-00021272-00021567": "so basically as close to the regression", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00090-00021568-00021839": "as you can get and maternal recognition", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00091-00021840-00022078": "of pregnancy is basically the conceptus", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00092-00022079-00022335": "in the uterus telling mum that it's", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00093-00022336-00022583": "there maintain that corpus luteum", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00094-00022584-00022830": "because we need that progesterone to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00095-00022831-00023127": "continue a pregnancy", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00096-00023128-00023335": "so we", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00097-00023336-00023542": "bred our animals we presume they were", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00098-00023543-00023847": "pregnant took them in killed them took", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00099-00023848-00024158": "out their uterus took out their embryos", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00100-00024159-00024407": "measured their embryo length which is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00101-00024408-00024607": "probably the most definitive sign of", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00102-00024608-00024839": "fertility that we have at the moment", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00103-00024840-00025039": "size of the embryo is going to affect", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00104-00025040-00025327": "the secretions it's producing which is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00105-00025328-00025606": "going to affect the response to the mum", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00106-00025607-00025783": "promote pregnancy", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00107-00025783-00026014": "and basically we say oh", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00108-00026016-00026183": "bigger embryos", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00109-00026183-00026407": "in the red here are individual animals", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00110-00026408-00026670": "that run our inorganic supplement", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00111-00026672-00026990": "the green here is that 50 50 blend", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00112-00026991-00027214": "the black line is the median", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00113-00027216-00027351": "so we saw", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00114-00027352-00027623": "an increase from about 17 and a half to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00115-00027624-00027862": "close to 25 centimeters as the whole", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00116-00027863-00028118": "conceptus length now that's not the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00117-00028119-00028239": "length of the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00118-00028239-00028495": "embryo itself it's just a little", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00119-00028495-00028751": "spot in the middle but these membranes", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00120-00028752-00028951": "are what's going to form the placental", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00121-00028952-00029302": "tissue but they're also what's secreting", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00122-00029304-00029590": "the signals to tell mum it's pregnant so", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00123-00029591-00029855": "that she continues on keeps that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00124-00029856-00030102": "progesterone level high we can then form", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00125-00030103-00030302": "a placental attachment and establish a", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00126-00030303-00030446": "pregnancy", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00127-00030447-00030702": "so just with a very very limited number", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00128-00030703-00030935": "we're actually able to increase", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00129-00030936-00031174": "embryonic length which is really", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00130-00031175-00031431": "our hallmark for fertility as far as", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00131-00031432-00031839": "science research goes at the moment", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00132-00031839-00032070": "over here we actually looked at the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00133-00032072-00032302": "level of these selena proteins in the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00134-00032303-00032527": "corpus luteum itself", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00135-00032527-00032702": "remembering that cells are very", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00136-00032703-00032918": "metabolically active tissue and you need", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00137-00032919-00033118": "to get rid of these free radicals to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00138-00033119-00033255": "keep function", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00139-00033256-00033439": "and pretty well we increase the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00140-00033440-00033671": "expression of all the selena proteins in", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00141-00033672-00033967": "that corpus luteum again with this", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00142-00033968-00034271": "mixed form of selenium", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00143-00034272-00034607": "at the moment we're looking at", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00144-00034608-00034846": "uterine gene expression to work out how", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00145-00034847-00035062": "that placentation which is the next step", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00146-00035063-00035239": "is going to occur", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00147-00035240-00035583": "are the signals from that conceptus then", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00148-00035584-00035823": "affecting the potential placentation", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00149-00035824-00036046": "sites on the uterus so hopefully next", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00150-00036047-00036207": "year i'll have", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00151-00036208-00036423": "more stories to tell you there", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00152-00036424-00036623": "and then hopefully running that out to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00153-00036624-00036790": "about", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00154-00036791-00037015": "two months into pregnancy where we've", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00155-00037016-00037351": "formed that placental attachment", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00156-00037352-00037527": "we always get our", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00157-00037528-00037879": "cows pregnant regardless of the form", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00158-00037880-00038135": "but if we can get our cows pregnant", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00159-00038136-00038374": "early and maintaining those pregnancies", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00160-00038375-00038671": "through those first you know 40 50 days", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00161-00038672-00038823": "which is where you're going to get your", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00162-00038824-00039046": "embryonic loss you're going to get your", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00163-00039047-00039287": "cows deliver calves earlier they're", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00164-00039288-00039462": "going to grow quicker", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00165-00039463-00039639": "make more money that way", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00166-00039640-00039855": "so that was my real quick quick go", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00167-00039856-00039983": "seeing", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00168-00039984-00040159": "we've only got a few more minutes what", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00169-00040160-00040374": "questions do you have", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00170-00040375-00040623": "what time of year was this done did you", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00171-00040624-00040871": "read the spring or fall these animals", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00172-00040872-00040990": "for the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00173-00040991-00041239": "embryo collection we killed all those", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00174-00041240-00041430": "this spring so they were bred in the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00175-00041431-00041727": "spring and killed 17 days later", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00176-00041728-00041967": "for the corpus luteum study which is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00177-00041968-00042199": "this part here and showing the pathway", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00178-00042200-00042415": "up there they were", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00179-00042416-00042679": "done in the fall okay", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00180-00042680-00042783": "these", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00181-00042784-00042999": "studies we looked at ludial function", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00182-00043000-00043390": "early they weren't bred at all", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00183-00043391-00043639": "these ones here obviously were bred", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00184-00043640-00043830": "i don't think", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00185-00043831-00044095": "season's going to have a big effect on", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00186-00044096-00044271": "these results", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00187-00044272-00044535": "but one thing that's really not showing", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00188-00044536-00044662": "here is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00189-00044663-00044918": "the tie-in with fescue", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00190-00044919-00045190": "so i've performed studies looking at", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00191-00045191-00045415": "these parameters on cows that are on", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00192-00045416-00045735": "both high and low fescue or low", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00193-00045736-00045918": "endophyte fescue", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00194-00045919-00046199": "we see a bigger divergence in", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00195-00046200-00046502": "progesterone secretion when we're on", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00196-00046503-00046774": "toxic fescue because the cows are", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00197-00046775-00046990": "probably under more stress", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00198-00046991-00047246": "and the selena protein increase the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00199-00047247-00047511": "greater redox ability that this mix is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00200-00047512-00047758": "giving is alleviating that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00201-00047759-00048030": "so we still see an effect on a low", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00202-00048031-00048246": "endophyte pasture but we see an even", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00203-00048247-00048479": "more pronounced", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00204-00048480-00048599": "good effect", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00205-00048600-00048886": "when we have cows on those hot pastures", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00206-00048887-00049302": "as well", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00207-00049303-00049439": "so", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00208-00049440-00049607": "in my understanding the bottom line the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00209-00049608-00049935": "mix of inorganic and organic selenium", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00210-00049936-00050102": "is kind of what you're leaning toward to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00211-00050103-00050311": "be the best at this time yeah until i", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00212-00050312-00050415": "got", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00213-00050416-00050655": "this result here everything was very", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00214-00050656-00050935": "mechanistic you know progesterone here", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00215-00050936-00051158": "this and that and that but this is the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00216-00051159-00051463": "real first practical result that would", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00217-00051464-00051630": "give me", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00218-00051632-00051814": "what i needed to say", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00219-00051815-00052046": "i would recommend mix which is something", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00220-00052047-00052230": "that research people don't do that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00221-00052232-00052487": "extension people do but i think that the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00222-00052488-00052742": "results here are probably", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00223-00052744-00052991": "arguably the best results i've achieved", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00224-00052991-00053238": "in my career as far as practical", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00225-00053239-00053494": "application we're showing a real effect", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00226-00053495-00053711": "and that increase in embryo length that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00227-00053712-00054038": "maternal recognition of pregnancy is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00228-00054039-00054247": "really the ultimate for this type of", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00229-00054248-00054359": "study", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00230-00054360-00054638": "that should translate to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00231-00054639-00054879": "better pregnancy outcome better", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00232-00054879-00055182": "placentation less embryonic loss", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00233-00055183-00055391": "especially around maternal recognition", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00234-00055391-00055559": "of pregnancy where you're losing the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00235-00055560-00055894": "majority of your potential pregnancies", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00236-00055895-00056023": "we did some", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00237-00056024-00056303": "economics maths or maths", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00238-00056304-00056582": "and basically one cycle so psych so", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00239-00056583-00056879": "breeding from ai to conceiving the next", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00240-00056879-00057015": "cycle", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00241-00057016-00057391": "is between 70 and 100 dollars ahead", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00242-00057391-00057559": "money out of your pocket when it comes", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00243-00057560-00057735": "to selling that animal just from the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00244-00057736-00058038": "daily gain you'll get in that one month", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00245-00058039-00058254": "two years later", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00246-00058255-00058430": "is there a mineral out there now that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00247-00058432-00058559": "doesn't mix", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00248-00058560-00058711": "it's the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00249-00058712-00058911": "organic the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00250-00058912-00059279": "the uk beef irm can be purchased but", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00251-00059279-00059454": "it's usually purchased more at the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00252-00059455-00059671": "extension agent level and then", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00253-00059672-00059854": "distributed to the people in the county", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00254-00059855-00059959": "that way", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00255-00059960-00060247": "it can be made specifically for anyone", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00256-00060248-00060350": "if they", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00257-00060351-00060559": "have the need for a certain amount if", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00258-00060560-00060711": "you're a big producer you go to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00259-00060712-00060966": "berkman's or something so you make this", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00260-00060967-00061199": "but for the smaller producers sometimes", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00261-00061200-00061454": "the co-ops will organize to get a batch", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00262-00061455-00061623": "made for it", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00263-00061624-00061838": "but it is um", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00264-00061839-00062119": "it's remarkable the difference mixing", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00265-00062120-00062430": "these two forms gives compared to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00266-00062432-00062687": "the organic or the inorganic alone it's", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00267-00062688-00062975": "never in the middle we have an inorganic", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00268-00062976-00063206": "organic and then the mix comes out over", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00269-00063207-00063399": "here is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00270-00063400-00063606": "somehow by stimulating the cellular", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00271-00063607-00063903": "uptake through these different pathways", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00272-00063904-00064166": "you get a more pronounced effect at the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00273-00064167-00064366": "level of the tissue and we've looked at", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00274-00064367-00064606": "a as jamie said a variety of different", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00275-00064607-00064863": "tissues and everything is affected and", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00276-00064864-00065150": "all goes really back down to that", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00277-00065151-00065399": "cellular stress you keep those cells", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00278-00065400-00065631": "happy get rid of the hydrogen peroxide", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00279-00065632-00065831": "the free radicals they can function", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00280-00065832-00066063": "better do their job better", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00281-00066064-00066319": "get a better outcome", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00282-00066320-00066511": "my advantage is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00283-00066512-00066775": "i can see more tangible results rather", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00284-00066776-00066887": "than", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00285-00066888-00067071": "you know muscle mass and things like", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00286-00067072-00067423": "that which for a repro person like me is", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00287-00067424-00067750": "where i'm aiming for yeah", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00288-00067751-00067999": "he was just telling me that the uk", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00289-00068000-00068263": "danny i'd replace the uk mineral", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00290-00068264-00068567": "should have it already yeah yeah yeah", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00291-00068568-00069182": "the uk irm is bland to do the 50 50 max", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00292-00069183-00069375": "i have a question for both of you is how", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00293-00069376-00069615": "do you control for genetics and your", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00294-00069616-00069815": "studies because we know that bulls", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00295-00069816-00070199": "coming from out west fall apart", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00296-00070200-00070382": "so there's got to be some genetic", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00297-00070383-00070631": "component that we've brought in and", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00298-00070632-00070863": "and for you i'd say how do you know the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00299-00070864-00071150": "embryo size isn't because of different", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00300-00071151-00071415": "genetics all these animals", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00301-00071416-00071606": "in this study here were bred to the same", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00302-00071607-00071694": "ball", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00303-00071695-00071799": "using", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00304-00071800-00072079": "heifers that were from our herds here so", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00305-00072080-00072535": "the genetics are very similar yeah", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00306-00072536-00072806": "but it seems like within my herd", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00307-00072807-00073062": "fiscal toxicity genetically affects", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00308-00073063-00073255": "different animals that's true yeah", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00309-00073256-00073535": "definitely see a difference yes", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00310-00073536-00073847": "yeah we we kept it as close as we could", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00311-00073848-00074087": "uh but that brings a good point actually", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00312-00074088-00074319": "a few years ago before i started looking", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00313-00074320-00074559": "on the female side we did some work with", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00314-00074560-00074719": "bulls", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00315-00074720-00074903": "and we", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00316-00074904-00075111": "we ran them on the different planes and", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00317-00075112-00075319": "collected semen at various times and", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00318-00075320-00075615": "looked at the semen analysis and uh had", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00319-00075616-00075806": "very limited numbers so it was never", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00320-00075807-00076094": "anything we could publish but", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00321-00076095-00076303": "we had two bulls that had totally", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00322-00076304-00076575": "immobile sperm", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00323-00076576-00076799": "put them on mix", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00324-00076800-00077055": "two months later", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00325-00077056-00077423": "they had normal motility and morphology", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00326-00077424-00077799": "it went from zero to like 70 percent and", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00327-00077800-00078031": "two months is the spermatogenic cycle in", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00328-00078032-00078159": "the ball so that's how long it's going", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00329-00078160-00078367": "to take to see an effect", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00330-00078368-00078447": "but", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00331-00078448-00079047": "we had one bull that had high fertility", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00332-00079048-00079294": "she gradually tapered off", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00333-00079295-00079519": "so there is a lot of especially with", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00334-00079520-00079775": "bulls a lot of variation and", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00335-00079776-00079935": "how they respond to the different", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00336-00079936-00080143": "stresses in the environment but also", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00337-00080144-00080326": "what's going on in their own physiology", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00338-00080327-00080471": "they're a lot more variable than the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00339-00080472-00080687": "female side of things", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00340-00080688-00080871": "but it wasn't a", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00341-00080872-00081087": "something that we had the animals to", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00342-00081088-00081319": "continue doing to looking at and the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00343-00081320-00081550": "female side of thing was more my focus", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00344-00081551-00082023": "anyway but very very good point", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00345-00082024-00082438": "we also looked before that at", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00346-00082439-00082671": "testes collected", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00347-00082672-00082935": "two days after birth so", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00348-00082936-00083150": "cows were maintained on these different", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00349-00083151-00083415": "forms castrate we typically castrate", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00350-00083416-00083718": "about two three days after birth and i", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00351-00083719-00083879": "looked at gene expression in these", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00352-00083880-00084150": "neonatal testes that are functional", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00353-00084151-00084367": "but they're still got to develop", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00354-00084368-00084623": "and we saw", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00355-00084624-00084911": "a thousand genes differed just at two", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00356-00084912-00085182": "days of birth and there is about a dozen", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00357-00085183-00085350": "that was specifically involved in", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00358-00085351-00085526": "steroidogenesis", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00359-00085527-00085782": "which fits with here and about a dozen", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00360-00085783-00085943": "that was specifically involved in", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00361-00085944-00086103": "spermatogenesis", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00362-00086104-00086294": "and this is just after", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00363-00086295-00086575": "you know gestational development of the", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00364-00086576-00086759": "the testes itself", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00365-00086760-00087038": "so it has a really pronounced effect", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00366-00087039-00087287": "and we still haven't got to carry over", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00367-00087288-00087423": "effects", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00368-00087424-00087567": "you know what's", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00369-00087568-00087847": "if the mum's developed on mix is her", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00370-00087848-00088079": "calf going to respond", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00371-00088080-00088262": "differently is he going to have some", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00372-00088263-00088550": "genetic traits that carry over judo", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00373-00088551-00088750": "development itself", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00374-00088751-00088887": "that all takes", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00375-00088888-00089191": "more time and more money and we", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00376-00089192-00089574": "generally don't have enough of it either", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00377-00089575-00090271": "[Music]", "MQ1gfAyIuII-00378-00090272-00090480": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "MQ1x_IXTEEY", "text": {"MQ1x_IXTEEY-00000-00000119-00000827": "foreign", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00001-00000827-00001462": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00002-00001463-00002050": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00003-00002051-00002913": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00004-00002914-00003365": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00005-00003365-00003572": "foreign", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00006-00003574-00004195": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00007-00004196-00005017": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00008-00005018-00006121": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00009-00006122-00007217": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00010-00007218-00007391": "foreign", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00011-00007392-00008611": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00012-00008612-00009712": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00013-00009713-00010533": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00014-00010534-00012091": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00015-00012092-00012682": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00016-00012683-00012893": "[Music]", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00017-00012894-00013541": "foreign", "MQ1x_IXTEEY-00018-00013543-00014036": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "MQrpccxH74o", "text": {"MQrpccxH74o-00000-00000094-00000371": "meditation has helped me tremendously in", "MQrpccxH74o-00001-00000372-00000614": "my life journey what would you say is", "MQrpccxH74o-00002-00000615-00000802": "the best way to work through personal", "MQrpccxH74o-00003-00000803-00001087": "family issues so that they do not lead", "MQrpccxH74o-00004-00001088-00001404": "to excessive thoughts of stress or worry", "MQrpccxH74o-00005-00001405-00001679": "based on a sense of instability and", "MQrpccxH74o-00006-00001680-00002549": "change how do I solve my life closely", "MQrpccxH74o-00007-00002550-00002900": "how do I fix everything", "MQrpccxH74o-00008-00002901-00003164": "that's all you're asking though talk", "MQrpccxH74o-00009-00003165-00004421": "about making my head hurt", "MQrpccxH74o-00010-00004422-00004683": "why are we born to the people were born", "MQrpccxH74o-00011-00004684-00004944": "to why do we have the parents we have", "MQrpccxH74o-00012-00004945-00005154": "the siblings we have children we have", "MQrpccxH74o-00013-00005155-00005403": "friends we have there's a lot involved", "MQrpccxH74o-00014-00005404-00006117": "here there's a backstory so the idea", "MQrpccxH74o-00015-00006118-00006324": "that there would be some answer that I", "MQrpccxH74o-00016-00006325-00006639": "could give over YouTube that would fix", "MQrpccxH74o-00017-00006640-00007040": "all of that this incredibly complex", "MQrpccxH74o-00018-00007041-00007494": "model spanning countless lifetimes the", "MQrpccxH74o-00019-00007495-00007779": "backstory behind yours your family", "MQrpccxH74o-00020-00007780-00007983": "problems what seemed like just family", "MQrpccxH74o-00021-00007984-00008187": "problems the back story behind the make", "MQrpccxH74o-00022-00008188-00008478": "that question a little bit difficult and", "MQrpccxH74o-00023-00008479-00008967": "to answer to say believe so but I think", "MQrpccxH74o-00024-00008968-00009225": "that is an answer is that you have to", "MQrpccxH74o-00025-00009226-00009516": "realize that this isn't something that", "MQrpccxH74o-00026-00009517-00009840": "can be easily answered easily fixed this", "MQrpccxH74o-00027-00009841-00010179": "is this is a very important part of your", "MQrpccxH74o-00028-00010180-00010401": "practice your family your friends the", "MQrpccxH74o-00029-00010402-00010574": "people around you the relationships you", "MQrpccxH74o-00030-00010575-00010953": "have that's a very important factor in", "MQrpccxH74o-00031-00010954-00011544": "your practice usually well often in many", "MQrpccxH74o-00032-00011545-00012029": "cases a debt and a negative factor a", "MQrpccxH74o-00033-00012030-00012243": "inhibiting factor something that gets in", "MQrpccxH74o-00034-00012244-00012417": "the way of your meditation because most", "MQrpccxH74o-00035-00012418-00012639": "the reason we're born to our families is", "MQrpccxH74o-00036-00012640-00012837": "not usually because we're all meditators", "MQrpccxH74o-00037-00012838-00013368": "could be but for most of us it's because", "MQrpccxH74o-00038-00013369-00013641": "of attachments because we're attached to", "MQrpccxH74o-00039-00013641-00013791": "these people either in positive or", "MQrpccxH74o-00040-00013791-00014063": "negative ways and it's so there's", "MQrpccxH74o-00041-00014065-00014232": "there's positive in the sense of", "MQrpccxH74o-00042-00014233-00014415": "attachment it's not positive in a good", "MQrpccxH74o-00043-00014416-00014660": "way it's positive and sense of wanting", "MQrpccxH74o-00044-00014661-00014958": "desiring it could be negative and in the", "MQrpccxH74o-00045-00014959-00015416": "sense of aversion disliking and and we", "MQrpccxH74o-00046-00015418-00015888": "have our vengeance and revenge and so on", "MQrpccxH74o-00047-00015888-00016328": "and all this so you're dealing you know", "MQrpccxH74o-00048-00016329-00016587": "in trying to fix that it's not really", "MQrpccxH74o-00049-00016588-00016830": "the place to start the place to start as", "MQrpccxH74o-00050-00016831-00017216": "your reactions to these things and", "MQrpccxH74o-00051-00017217-00017853": "so take the personal family issues that", "MQrpccxH74o-00052-00017854-00018036": "the stress that comes from them as your", "MQrpccxH74o-00053-00018037-00018234": "practice instead of what many people do", "MQrpccxH74o-00054-00018235-00018528": "is try to escape so people will run off", "MQrpccxH74o-00055-00018529-00018780": "into the jungle thinking that their", "MQrpccxH74o-00056-00018781-00018975": "family is getting in their way and and", "MQrpccxH74o-00057-00018976-00019254": "and the simplest answer is just to", "MQrpccxH74o-00058-00019255-00019548": "escape them doesn't always work it", "MQrpccxH74o-00059-00019549-00019746": "doesn't often work if you have if you", "MQrpccxH74o-00060-00019747-00020481": "have strong bad karma or bad feelings", "MQrpccxH74o-00061-00020482-00020841": "with your parents especially going often", "MQrpccxH74o-00062-00020842-00021486": "the forest rarely solves that so I would", "MQrpccxH74o-00063-00021487-00021780": "say be careful about how you try to", "MQrpccxH74o-00064-00021781-00022236": "approach these things about how you try", "MQrpccxH74o-00065-00022237-00022488": "to fix or try to find a quick fix for", "MQrpccxH74o-00066-00022489-00022755": "your family problems they should be", "MQrpccxH74o-00067-00022756-00022943": "approached with incredible delicacy and", "MQrpccxH74o-00068-00022944-00023325": "shouldn't be seen as having a fix and", "MQrpccxH74o-00069-00023326-00023625": "immediate figs one of the best things is", "MQrpccxH74o-00070-00023626-00024179": "is to I suppose have a little faith you", "MQrpccxH74o-00071-00024180-00024414": "know and you see the benefit of the", "MQrpccxH74o-00072-00024415-00024627": "meditation right you say it should help", "MQrpccxH74o-00073-00024628-00025221": "you tremendously so make that leap it's", "MQrpccxH74o-00074-00025222-00025368": "not really a face but it's kind of like", "MQrpccxH74o-00075-00025369-00025638": "a leap of faith but so your mind is is", "MQrpccxH74o-00076-00025639-00025820": "is missing something here's you have to", "MQrpccxH74o-00077-00025822-00026082": "make the connection where you say this", "MQrpccxH74o-00078-00026083-00026385": "is also helping my family this is also", "MQrpccxH74o-00079-00026386-00026712": "improving my family situation even", "MQrpccxH74o-00080-00026713-00026835": "though it often doesn't look like it", "MQrpccxH74o-00081-00026836-00027120": "have some sort of faith not exactly", "MQrpccxH74o-00082-00027120-00027533": "faith but but really logic I would say", "MQrpccxH74o-00083-00027535-00027780": "that tells you that well if it's", "MQrpccxH74o-00084-00027781-00028014": "affecting me it must be affecting all", "MQrpccxH74o-00085-00028014-00028113": "the people around me", "MQrpccxH74o-00086-00028114-00028479": "we're not Islands so they must be if I'm", "MQrpccxH74o-00087-00028480-00028686": "being positively influenced they must be", "MQrpccxH74o-00088-00028687-00028889": "positively influenced by this as well", "MQrpccxH74o-00089-00028891-00029304": "and be patient with that be dedicated to", "MQrpccxH74o-00090-00029305-00029502": "that to the practice again right", "MQrpccxH74o-00091-00029502-00029670": "difference between practice and", "MQrpccxH74o-00092-00029670-00029835": "realizations be dedicated to the", "MQrpccxH74o-00093-00029836-00030087": "practice the cultivation of goodness not", "MQrpccxH74o-00094-00030088-00030474": "so worried about are we there yet to", "MQrpccxH74o-00095-00030475-00030518": "know", "MQrpccxH74o-00096-00030519-00031043": "is everything figs so not expecting for", "MQrpccxH74o-00097-00031044-00031277": "yourself to have a stress-free family", "MQrpccxH74o-00098-00031278-00031718": "life but as your stress decreases be", "MQrpccxH74o-00099-00031719-00031937": "happy with that be confident that you're", "MQrpccxH74o-00100-00031938-00032154": "on the right for my right path that's", "MQrpccxH74o-00101-00032155-00032426": "about all I have to say and just that", "MQrpccxH74o-00102-00032427-00032687": "such a general question can't be really", "MQrpccxH74o-00103-00032688-00032835": "answered you have to give me more", "MQrpccxH74o-00104-00032836-00032999": "specifics you have a specific problems", "MQrpccxH74o-00105-00033000-00033270": "often we can try to muddle through them", "MQrpccxH74o-00106-00033271-00033599": "and and offer strategies but how do I", "MQrpccxH74o-00107-00033600-00034043": "fix my life I don't have meditate you", "MQrpccxH74o-00108-00034044-00034179": "can general answer general quite a", "MQrpccxH74o-00109-00034180-00034544": "neural question generally and say that"}}, {"audio_id": "MQsJjvKD6EM", "text": {"MQsJjvKD6EM-00000-00000109-00000366": "you", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00001-00000367-00000705": "hi my feet I have a question", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00002-00000706-00000889": "you're just learning about the solar", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00003-00000890-00001116": "system I have a question about our gas", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00004-00001117-00001461": "rights how come our gas giant seeing", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00005-00001462-00001687": "this fear instead of the gas just", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00006-00001688-00001932": "blowing around everywhere in space hope", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00007-00001934-00002422": "you'll answer my question bye hello my", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00008-00002423-00002524": "name is anna frebel", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00009-00002525-00002719": "and i'm a professor here at MIT i'm", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00010-00002720-00002958": "actually an astronomer and i'm going to", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00011-00002959-00003156": "answer your question about space", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00012-00003157-00003504": "you asked about gas giants so large", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00013-00003505-00003727": "planets that have a gaseous atmosphere", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00014-00003728-00004029": "and why they're in a sphere it's mostly", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00015-00004030-00004306": "due to gravity gravity acts on matter in", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00016-00004307-00004620": "in space under and acts on all objects", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00017-00004621-00004857": "in space and it acts particularly over", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00018-00004858-00005229": "large distances so in a gas giant like", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00019-00005230-00005532": "Jupiter what's happening is that gravity", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00020-00005533-00005859": "pulls on all matter in the same way that", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00021-00005860-00006091": "a person on earth is being pulled to", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00022-00006092-00006252": "Earth and that's why we're not floating", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00023-00006253-00006525": "in space but we can stand on the ground", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00024-00006526-00006790": "the same is happening in Jupiter all the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00025-00006791-00007039": "gas is just mass it's little particles", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00026-00007040-00007240": "spread apart in the gas rather than", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00027-00007241-00007537": "clump together in solid matter like a", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00028-00007538-00007879": "rock for example so what's happening", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00029-00007880-00008143": "then is gravity is pulling the material", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00030-00008144-00008518": "towards the center of Jupiter and there", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00031-00008519-00008788": "is some some gas pressure from the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00032-00008789-00009013": "atmosphere for example or and some heat", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00033-00009014-00009322": "also that acts outwards that wants to", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00034-00009323-00009523": "push things away when things get hot", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00035-00009524-00009904": "they want to expand and the reason why", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00036-00009905-00010150": "everything stays in a sphere is because", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00037-00010151-00010453": "gravity is pulling things in and as", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00038-00010454-00010723": "pressure from the planet is pushing", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00039-00010724-00010945": "things out and it keeps everything in a", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00040-00010946-00011206": "nice equilibrium and the result of this", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00041-00011207-00011452": "of that is that it is actually a sphere", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00042-00011453-00012040": "because the force of gravity acts in the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00043-00012041-00012277": "same way in the same amount in all", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00044-00012278-00012529": "directions so if you sit in the middle", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00045-00012530-00012757": "of the planet and you have a whole bunch", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00046-00012758-00012940": "of strings in your hand that are", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00047-00012941-00013266": "attached to all points around you behind", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00048-00013268-00013563": "you and in front of you on the plane", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00049-00013565-00013839": "those strings all have to be equal if", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00050-00013840-00014113": "you imagine you were sitting in a cube", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00051-00014113-00014355": "and you know gravity is pulling things", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00052-00014356-00014763": "in and the pressures pushing things out", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00053-00014765-00015258": "then that would actually disrupt the the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00054-00015259-00015633": "cube because the force is not equal in", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00055-00015634-00016014": "all directions if you if you you have a", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00056-00016015-00016287": "shorter string right to the to the flat", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00057-00016288-00016483": "part of the cube in front of you and you", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00058-00016484-00016627": "would have a longer string you would", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00059-00016628-00016852": "need a longer string to the through the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00060-00016853-00017092": "corner of the cube so in order to keep", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00061-00017093-00017317": "things stable and nice and not floating", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00062-00017318-00017608": "around in space you need to pull in the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00063-00017609-00017899": "the string going to the corner until it", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00064-00017900-00018127": "has the same length to the string that", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00065-00018128-00018456": "that was going to to the front of the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00066-00018457-00018730": "cube and so if you do this for all the", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00067-00018731-00018939": "points around you you would end up", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00068-00018940-00019194": "sitting in in a ball in a sphere again", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00069-00019195-00019552": "and so that that is uh that's why why", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00070-00019553-00019722": "everything even when it's made from gas", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00071-00019723-00020086": "as long as there's enough mass where", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00072-00020087-00020433": "gravity can act on is is nice and", "MQsJjvKD6EM-00073-00020434-00020829": "contained in a big ball"}}, {"audio_id": "MQK4ZHyRqHQ", "text": {"MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00000-00000008-00000254": "10 proven steps to ask any sigma female", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00001-00000256-00000519": "out and get a yes but before we begin", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00002-00000520-00000774": "let's take a quick look at sigma females", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00003-00000775-00000943": "they are a rare and unique breed of", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00004-00000944-00001247": "women that make up only 0.9 of the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00005-00001248-00001478": "female population on earth they are", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00006-00001479-00001655": "officially the rarest and most", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00007-00001655-00001895": "intelligent set of women alive they are", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00008-00001896-00002095": "smart intelligent loners who have been", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00009-00002096-00002279": "referred to on many occasions as the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00010-00002280-00002487": "human lie detector they consent", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00011-00002488-00002710": "deceitful men who like to play games", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00012-00002711-00002902": "with women just from their appearance", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00013-00002903-00003039": "and the way they talk and carry", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00014-00003040-00003150": "themselves", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00015-00003151-00003335": "now that you are fully aware of the kind", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00016-00003336-00003543": "of woman you are up against here are 10", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00017-00003544-00003775": "proven steps to get any sigma female to", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00018-00003776-00004063": "chill and watch netflix with you one", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00019-00004064-00004343": "do the basics to ask any sigma female", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00020-00004344-00004551": "out you must start with the basics take", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00021-00004552-00004838": "a bath brush and shave you need to look", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00022-00004839-00005063": "good and sharp because sigma females", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00023-00005064-00005302": "have a keen eye for details put on male", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00024-00005303-00005567": "dominant colors like blue or teal over", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00025-00005568-00005791": "shades of orange or white over black and", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00026-00005792-00006086": "vice visa to stand out put on a cheap", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00027-00006087-00006295": "watch if that is what you can afford", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00028-00006296-00006534": "after all she won't notice wear a nice", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00029-00006536-00006734": "body spray and don't forget to do your", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00030-00006736-00006991": "hair sigma women and women in general", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00031-00006992-00007246": "consider men with nice smell attractive", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00032-00007247-00007414": "looking good is just the first step", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00033-00007415-00007598": "towards earning yourself some netflix", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00034-00007600-00007831": "time with any sigma female if you know", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00035-00007831-00007942": "what i mean", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00036-00007943-00008239": "2. the entanglement the entanglement is", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00037-00008240-00008439": "spotting the sigma female and walking up", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00038-00008440-00008687": "to her how you approach a sigma female", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00039-00008688-00008895": "matters a lot and the best way to", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00040-00008896-00009055": "approach a sigma woman is with a", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00041-00009056-00009295": "question asking questions is the best", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00042-00009296-00009455": "way to get her to drop her guard", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00043-00009456-00009687": "unknowingly ask questions that begin", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00044-00009688-00009951": "with how what or where and follow up", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00045-00009952-00010271": "with why questions for example excuse me", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00046-00010272-00010478": "where can i buy a sandwich i am really", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00047-00010479-00010871": "hungry are you no thanks i am fine but", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00048-00010872-00011199": "why or don't you like sandwiches i mean", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00049-00011200-00011471": "not like that i kind of like sandwiches", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00050-00011472-00011727": "but and there she goes blabbing the goal", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00051-00011728-00011935": "here is the keep her talking and make", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00052-00011936-00012174": "her curious and the best way to do that", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00053-00012175-00012391": "is to withhold information and share it", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00054-00012392-00012670": "in bits the more curious a sigma female", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00055-00012671-00012879": "is the more likely she will develop an", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00056-00012880-00013135": "appetite for more and a liking for you", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00057-00013136-00013319": "make sure to note the topics you guys", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00058-00013319-00013503": "agree on because you will need this", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00059-00013504-00013815": "information later in step six three keep", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00060-00013816-00014063": "her juices flowing to keep her juices", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00061-00014063-00014222": "flowing you need to speak to her in the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00062-00014223-00014463": "language she understands and sarcasm is", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00063-00014463-00014686": "the language of sigma females being", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00064-00014687-00014894": "sarcastic does two things to the sigma", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00065-00014895-00015135": "female it shows her how intelligent and", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00066-00015136-00015366": "bold you are qualities every sigma woman", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00067-00015368-00015599": "wants in her man and how funny you are", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00068-00015600-00015838": "because sigma females love funny men", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00069-00015840-00016103": "strangers also bond easily in funny and", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00070-00016104-00016391": "cozy environments so keep her laughing", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00071-00016392-00016575": "the pitch and frequency of her laughter", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00072-00016576-00016767": "can tell you how much she likes you", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00073-00016768-00016991": "already don't be in a haste to ask her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00074-00016992-00017199": "number you don't want to interrupt her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00075-00017200-00017399": "juices from flowing and to spook her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00076-00017400-00017607": "into thinking you are only trying to get", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00077-00017608-00017822": "under her skin for her number now will", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00078-00017823-00018047": "be a bad time to start losing points at", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00079-00018048-00018207": "this stage of the game", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00080-00018208-00018550": "4. leave her wanting by step 4 the sigma", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00081-00018551-00018727": "female should be feeling comfortable", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00082-00018728-00018950": "around you chatting freely and laughing", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00083-00018951-00019183": "at your jokes the goal here is to stay", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00084-00019184-00019430": "mysterious be genuine and prevent her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00085-00019431-00019647": "from psychoanalyzing you because if she", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00086-00019648-00019863": "does that and finds something fishy the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00087-00019864-00020086": "tides will turn and you will stand no", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00088-00020087-00020263": "chance of getting her to chill and watch", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00089-00020264-00020511": "netflix with you the essence of step one", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00090-00020512-00020719": "to four is for you to catch the sigma", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00091-00020720-00020935": "female off guard throw her off her own", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00092-00020936-00021183": "game and let it stay that way for as", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00093-00021184-00021447": "long as you can this step is crucial", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00094-00021448-00021599": "because you need to lead the sigma", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00095-00021600-00021855": "female wanting to do this you need to", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00096-00021856-00022063": "plan your exit carefully because a poor", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00097-00022064-00022311": "exit can ruin everything a good exit", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00098-00022312-00022478": "strategy is to leave her with three", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00099-00022479-00022727": "things a smile on her face a burning", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00100-00022728-00022894": "thought on her mind and a heightened", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00101-00022895-00023143": "curiosity any excuse that is time", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00102-00023144-00023335": "related always works well with sigma", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00103-00023336-00023542": "females because they cherish their time", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00104-00023543-00023886": "more than they do with money 5. the ask", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00105-00023887-00024086": "the ask comes just before your", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00106-00024087-00024335": "time-related excuse to exit the scene", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00107-00024336-00024542": "the ask is simply asking for her number", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00108-00024543-00024678": "to stay in touch", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00109-00024679-00024863": "if you succeeded in putting a smile on", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00110-00024864-00025063": "her face and planting a thought on her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00111-00025064-00025271": "mind then her heightened curiosity will", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00112-00025272-00025447": "force her to give her number to you a", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00113-00025448-00025678": "complete stranger when she gives you her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00114-00025679-00025927": "number promise to shoot her a text later", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00115-00025927-00026279": "and leave it at that six the mind game", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00116-00026280-00026470": "step one to five is simply getting the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00117-00026472-00026670": "sigma females attention to know that a", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00118-00026672-00026935": "handsome guy like you wants her step six", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00119-00026936-00027183": "is where the actual mind game begins the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00120-00027183-00027343": "goal here is to learn more about the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00121-00027344-00027535": "sigma female through text without her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00122-00027536-00027807": "knowing while staying mysterious use the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00123-00027808-00027990": "information she blabbed about in step", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00124-00027991-00028214": "two to start a conversation pivot the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00125-00028216-00028390": "discussion around the topics you guys", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00126-00028391-00028631": "agreed on in step two the shorter the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00127-00028632-00028823": "time she takes to respond to your text", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00128-00028824-00029070": "messages the better for you try not to", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00129-00029072-00029262": "over share about yourself in this step", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00130-00029263-00029470": "because it is very tempting to do so", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00131-00029472-00029655": "once you are certain the sigma female", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00132-00029656-00029870": "likes you remember the goal here is to", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00133-00029872-00030070": "learn about the sigma female while", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00134-00030072-00030295": "keeping her in the dark about yourself", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00135-00030295-00030487": "the more she shares about herself the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00136-00030488-00030655": "more invested she becomes when she", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00137-00030656-00030927": "realizes she knows very little about you", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00138-00030927-00031135": "your goal is to keep her curiosity about", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00139-00031136-00031351": "you alive while secretly collecting her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00140-00031352-00031607": "personal info to be used in step seven", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00141-00031608-00031807": "remember to always keep things snappy", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00142-00031808-00032135": "and short seven take a reading on her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00143-00032136-00032318": "taking a reading on her before she does", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00144-00032319-00032487": "on you is the point of secretly", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00145-00032488-00032679": "collecting the sigma female's personal", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00146-00032680-00032911": "info in step six the essence of this", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00147-00032912-00033118": "step is to impress the sigma female that", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00148-00033119-00033287": "you care and that you have been paying", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00149-00033288-00033502": "attention to her to do that use the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00150-00033503-00033727": "information you have gathered so far and", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00151-00033728-00033959": "take a wild guest of her personality", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00152-00033960-00034215": "don't be too specific use words like for", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00153-00034216-00034446": "example it seems to me that you prefer", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00154-00034447-00034662": "to spend time alone and that you prefer", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00155-00034663-00034895": "to have meaningful conversations instead", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00156-00034896-00035159": "of just gossiping using phrases like it", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00157-00035160-00035415": "seems to me allows room for flaws and a", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00158-00035416-00035630": "chance for the sigma female to comment", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00159-00035631-00035799": "and further share information about", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00160-00035800-00036023": "herself doing this correctly will not", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00161-00036024-00036223": "only tell the sigma female that you", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00162-00036224-00036423": "understand her it will also remind her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00163-00036424-00036607": "of how intelligent you are the number", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00164-00036608-00036807": "one quality every sigma is looking for", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00165-00036808-00036911": "in a man", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00166-00036912-00037095": "if your reading of her goes well she", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00167-00037096-00037302": "will ask you how manage were you able to", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00168-00037303-00037518": "correctly predict stuff about her which", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00169-00037519-00037743": "is your cue to launch step 8. remember", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00170-00037744-00037935": "the success of this step depends on the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00171-00037936-00038239": "data you collected in step six eight buy", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00172-00038240-00038471": "more empathy the goal here is to get a", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00173-00038472-00038671": "rooting for you and to do that ask her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00174-00038672-00038887": "to take a reading on you ask her what", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00175-00038888-00039087": "she thinks about you so far by", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00176-00039088-00039271": "compelling her to take a reading on you", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00177-00039272-00039430": "you trigger her to look only at your", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00178-00039431-00039646": "positive attributes and because she", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00179-00039647-00039790": "wants to make a good impression of", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00180-00039791-00039990": "herself and not appear like the typical", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00181-00039991-00040262": "sigma female she will go soft on you", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00182-00040263-00040439": "getting her to empathize with you on a", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00183-00040440-00040639": "deeper level makes her more concerned", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00184-00040640-00040846": "about you getting her to think of you in", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00185-00040847-00041039": "that dimension is laying the groundwork", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00186-00041040-00041190": "for the final ask", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00187-00041191-00041407": "9. the final ask", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00188-00041408-00041590": "up to this point you know more about her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00189-00041591-00041799": "than she knows about you her curiosity", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00190-00041800-00041999": "to know more about you is up and she has", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00191-00042000-00042230": "started rooting for you now it is left", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00192-00042231-00042390": "for you to make her an offer she can't", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00193-00042391-00042487": "refuse", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00194-00042488-00042695": "the final ask is simply asking her out", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00195-00042696-00042911": "on a date the goal here is to keep", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00196-00042912-00043143": "everything simple and casual nothing", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00197-00043144-00043471": "fancy and no exaggerations sigma females", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00198-00043472-00043671": "are very sensitive to such things and", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00199-00043672-00043879": "they tend to see them as fake to make", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00200-00043880-00044111": "the final ask for example ask about her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00201-00044112-00044351": "favorite fast food meal ask her if she", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00202-00044352-00044535": "can eat it three times a day her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00203-00044536-00044758": "response will be a yes because everybody", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00204-00044759-00044974": "always says yes to this question then", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00205-00044975-00045199": "offer to take her out for a try of her", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00206-00045200-00045471": "favorite fast food meal and there you go", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00207-00045472-00045743": "but we are not done yet the key here is", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00208-00045744-00045967": "to always take sigma females out to less", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00209-00045968-00046262": "crowded places be at a restaurant bar or", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00210-00046263-00046486": "park because the quieter the place the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00211-00046487-00046735": "more likely you guys will bond faster", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00212-00046736-00047046": "10. the d-day all the secret service", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00213-00047047-00047239": "tactics we have employed from step one", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00214-00047240-00047415": "to step nine were to get you to this", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00215-00047416-00047630": "step the moment of truth for you in the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00216-00047631-00047879": "sigma female your goal in this step is", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00217-00047880-00048079": "to prove to the sigma female that you", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00218-00048080-00048279": "are exactly the same person she met on", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00219-00048280-00048479": "day one the same person she has been", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00220-00048480-00048679": "chatting with on the phone and the same", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00221-00048680-00048918": "person she is chatting with now remember", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00222-00048919-00049127": "the sigma female never forgets anything", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00223-00049128-00049399": "you say the d-day for sigma females is", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00224-00049400-00049639": "meant for facts finding remember that", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00225-00049640-00049823": "all this while you have been keeping the", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00226-00049824-00050039": "sigma in the loop just for this moment", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00227-00050040-00050207": "it is show time for you to make your", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00228-00050208-00050430": "final impression on the sigma female by", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00229-00050431-00050695": "being genuine and sincere with this last", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00230-00050696-00050911": "display of honesty from you she is left", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00231-00050912-00051111": "with no choice but to fall head over", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00232-00051112-00051375": "heels for you if you know what i mean", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00233-00051376-00051582": "remember the goal of this video was to", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00234-00051583-00051814": "teach you how to ask her out and not how", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00235-00051815-00052070": "to take her home taking a sigma female", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00236-00052071-00052238": "from a date night to your house is a", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00237-00052239-00052438": "different ball game a tale for another", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00238-00052439-00052679": "video please subscribe to the channel if", "MQK4ZHyRqHQ-00239-00052679-00053008": "you loved what you heard"}}, {"audio_id": "MR9UxPXoU8c", "text": {"MR9UxPXoU8c-00000-00000134-00000391": "hello and welcome to this reading guide", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00001-00000392-00000749": "video on chapter 25 of the open Stax", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00002-00000750-00001097": "textbook in this chapter you're going to", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00003-00001098-00001310": "read a few sections in preparation for", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00004-00001311-00001514": "our second unit of this course on", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00005-00001515-00001934": "geometric optics which covers how light", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00006-00001935-00002183": "and as we will see in class electrons", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00007-00002184-00002729": "move through materials so we begin with", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00008-00002730-00003146": "an introduction to the topic and then on", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00009-00003147-00003302": "the second page we have a nice", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00010-00003303-00003554": "discussion of how manifests this", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00011-00003554-00003761": "particular topic is in your everyday", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00012-00003761-00004301": "life section 25.1 introduces the idea of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00013-00004302-00004645": "the ray now we'll talk a little bit more", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00014-00004646-00004916": "about rays and whatnot in class but a", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00015-00004917-00005113": "good way to think of it in terms of the", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00016-00005114-00005360": "ideas before you discussed is the path", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00017-00005361-00005627": "of the photons so you can imagine little", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00018-00005628-00005854": "photons traveling in Nice straight lines", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00019-00005855-00006817": "those are your light rays and geometric", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00020-00006818-00007202": "optics mostly deals with rays so we're", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00021-00007203-00007498": "going to be mostly with a few exceptions", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00022-00007500-00007771": "working in the so called particle", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00023-00007772-00007921": "picture where we'll be thinking about", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00024-00007922-00008196": "photons as particles of light and", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00025-00008197-00008513": "electrons as particles we won't be", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00026-00008514-00008753": "dealing with the wave nature of these", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00027-00008754-00009031": "objects very much in unit 2 that will", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00028-00009032-00009299": "come in unit 3 which begins after your", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00029-00009300-00009923": "first exam section 25 point 2 is the law", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00030-00009924-00010399": "of reflection and the big thing to get", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00031-00010400-00010796": "out of this particular section is really", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00032-00010797-00011120": "summarized in this picture the law", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00033-00011121-00011501": "reflection states that the object with", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00034-00011502-00011881": "which a light or electron leaves after", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00035-00011882-00012128": "reflecting a surface is the same angle", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00036-00012129-00012460": "as which it came in this should make", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00037-00012461-00012635": "some intuitive sense using the particle", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00038-00012636-00012932": "picture of light and electrons imagine", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00039-00012933-00013185": "just a ball bouncing off of the ground", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00040-00013186-00013413": "the angle with which the ball leaves is", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00041-00013413-00013677": "the same as the angle with which the", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00042-00013678-00013826": "ball comes in", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00043-00013827-00014132": "you're also introduced to a key", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00044-00014133-00014463": "convention of geometric optics the", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00045-00014463-00014751": "convention for measuring angles in this", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00046-00014752-00014979": "entire unit we shall be measuring our", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00047-00014980-00015315": "angles like this with respect to what's", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00048-00015316-00015690": "called the normal or perpendicular to", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00049-00015691-00016005": "the surface so if you remember from 131", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00050-00016006-00016185": "the word normal just means perpendicular", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00051-00016186-00016542": "and throughout this unit we will be", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00052-00016543-00016770": "measuring our angles with respect to the", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00053-00016771-00017037": "normal do not ever measure your angles", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00054-00017038-00017235": "with respect to the surface things will", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00055-00017236-00017694": "not work out you then have a nice", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00056-00017695-00017916": "description of why some objects are", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00057-00017917-00018165": "shiny and some things are not why can", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00058-00018166-00018333": "you see a reflection in some objects and", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00059-00018334-00018569": "not in others this is good information", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00060-00018570-00019155": "to know but not quite as critical this", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00061-00019156-00019533": "discussion of how much of a person you", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00062-00019534-00019782": "can see in a mirror and what not you can", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00063-00019783-00020025": "kind of skip through will give this a", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00064-00020026-00020217": "more thorough treatment with some proper", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00065-00020218-00020739": "geometry in class then we get to section", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00066-00020740-00021069": "25 point 3 which is the law of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00067-00021070-00021486": "refraction beginning with the definition", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00068-00021487-00021690": "of refraction this of course is very", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00069-00021691-00022244": "critical moving into a nice discussion", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00070-00022245-00022425": "on the speed of light now we've talked a", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00071-00022426-00022803": "little bit about this in class but I", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00072-00022804-00023181": "know a few of you asked how has the", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00073-00023182-00023403": "speed of light been measured and the top", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00074-00023404-00023763": "of page 9 87 gives a nice example of one", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00075-00023764-00023934": "way in which the speed of light has been", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00076-00023935-00024393": "measured one of the key things to get", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00077-00024394-00024575": "out of this unit is essentially this", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00078-00024576-00024840": "expression right here the definition of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00079-00024841-00025244": "the so-called index of refraction so", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00080-00025245-00025389": "make sure that you really understand", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00081-00025390-00025875": "this concept then on the next page", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00082-00025876-00026064": "you've got a list of indices of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00083-00026064-00026274": "refraction for various materials you", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00084-00026275-00026427": "don't need to know this I would always", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00085-00026427-00026562": "provide you", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00086-00026563-00026910": "any numbers you need 1t to point out is", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00087-00026911-00027227": "that air has an index of refraction of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00088-00027229-00027639": "very close to one so you can see that", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00089-00027639-00027924": "for air light moves it roughly the same", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00090-00027925-00028427": "speed as it does in vacuum you have an", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00091-00028429-00028632": "example problem using the index of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00092-00028633-00028820": "refraction this is a good thing to pay", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00093-00028822-00028983": "attention to is you will have a few of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00094-00028983-00029091": "these types of problems in your", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00095-00029092-00029552": "preparatory homework and then we move", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00096-00029554-00030198": "into the law of refraction this book has", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00097-00030199-00030585": "sort of an example of why the law of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00098-00030586-00030773": "refraction kind of makes some sense I", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00099-00030774-00031038": "don't particularly like this example", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00100-00031039-00031295": "we'll do a more thorough reasoning of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00101-00031297-00031545": "why the law of refraction makes sense in", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00102-00031545-00031814": "class using the wave picture of light", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00103-00031816-00032163": "but what I do want you to know is I want", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00104-00032164-00032402": "you to know what the law of reflect", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00105-00032404-00032733": "refraction or Snell's law is so you need", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00106-00032733-00032961": "to know this and you need to know what", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00107-00032962-00033180": "all of the symbols in this expression", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00108-00033181-00033732": "mean and then you have a couple of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00109-00033733-00034236": "examples of this idea here good examples", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00110-00034237-00034368": "to study because again you'll have", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00111-00034369-00034581": "problems of this type in your homework", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00112-00034582-00034887": "so give that a look and this is where", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00113-00034888-00035022": "you will need to stop so you're just", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00114-00035023-00035355": "going to read sections through 25.3", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00115-00035356-00035574": "everything after that we'll deal with in", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00116-00035575-00035766": "class I just want you to have some of", "MR9UxPXoU8c-00117-00035767-00036198": "the basics this concludes this video"}}, {"audio_id": "MR9Wh--XBYk", "text": {"MR9Wh--XBYk-00000-00000096-00000390": "plastic on an amg this should be illegal", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00001-00000391-00000615": "especially in addition with the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00002-00000616-00001095": "gle 63 animation here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00003-00001096-00001454": "yes", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00004-00001455-00001630": "guys which of these three would you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00005-00001632-00001863": "choose the diamond white the black or", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00006-00001864-00002047": "the brilliant blue speck this makes me", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00007-00002048-00002350": "go crazy i swear to god so this is my", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00008-00002351-00002647": "way to go it's looking so", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00009-00002648-00003959": "sporty now", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00010-00003960-00004343": "hello guys i am back welcoming you all", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00011-00004344-00004522": "with the new", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00012-00004523-00005143": "2021 model mercedes amg gle63s", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00013-00005144-00005231": "coupe", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00014-00005232-00005511": "mercedes has sent me this beautiful car", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00015-00005512-00005791": "and today we will be fully experiencing", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00016-00005792-00006063": "it by doing a full walk around showing", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00017-00006064-00006334": "you all the exterior features afterwards", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00018-00006335-00006550": "jumping inside show you the amazing", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00019-00006551-00006791": "sound of this one and finish it all off", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00020-00006792-00007087": "with a resume but before we start guys", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00021-00007088-00007359": "this is another brilliant blue car that", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00022-00007359-00007670": "mercedes has sent me i have had the gle", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00023-00007672-00007951": "53 coupe in brilliant blue i've had the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00024-00007952-00008399": "gle 63s suv in brilliant blue i've had", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00025-00008400-00008687": "the e350 coupe in brilliant blue i've", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00026-00008688-00009046": "had the g350 in brilliant blue the e53", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00027-00009047-00009263": "cabriolet in brilliant blue magno and", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00028-00009264-00009542": "the gtc also in brilliant blue magno", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00029-00009543-00009855": "oh mercedes that's enough stop sending", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00030-00009856-00010159": "me blue cars i need new specs to present", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00031-00010160-00010414": "to you guys i'm just joking honestly the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00032-00010415-00010646": "blue the brilliant blue looks very very", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00033-00010647-00010871": "nice but yeah let's just get right into", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00034-00010872-00011095": "it let's start talking about this car", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00035-00011096-00011567": "here we have the gle 63s coupe the 2021", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00036-00011568-00011870": "model finished in brilliant blue we have", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00037-00011871-00012078": "no night package we have the silver", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00038-00012079-00012383": "multi-spoke amg wheels talking about the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00039-00012384-00012767": "performance of this beast 612", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00040-00012768-00013102": "horsepower but that's not enough we also", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00041-00013103-00013343": "have the starter generator supporting", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00042-00013344-00013655": "the engine with another 22 horsepower v8", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00043-00013656-00013935": "by turbo amg engine but yeah let's just", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00044-00013936-00014127": "get right into it and start with the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00045-00014128-00014471": "walk around i've already did a gle 63s", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00046-00014472-00014686": "coupe in diamond white", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00047-00014687-00014871": "it was at the amg headquarters in the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00048-00014872-00015135": "fighter bar and i also did a full black", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00049-00015136-00015486": "one at holman last year and now this", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00050-00015487-00015750": "brilliant blue speck guys which of these", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00051-00015751-00015999": "three would you choose the diamond white", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00052-00016000-00016215": "the black or the brilliant blue speck", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00053-00016216-00016422": "leave it in the comment section below so", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00054-00016423-00016639": "let's get right into it and start with", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00055-00016640-00016847": "the walk around starting with the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00056-00016848-00017286": "beautiful front of this car the gle63s", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00057-00017287-00017567": "front the front in total is exactly the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00058-00017568-00017807": "same as we have with the coupe air i'll", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00059-00017808-00017999": "be talking about the differences later", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00060-00018000-00018263": "on multibeam gle specific headlights we", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00061-00018264-00018486": "have the so-called panamericana front", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00062-00018487-00018727": "grille including that we have the from", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00063-00018728-00018983": "mercedes-benz star emblem but we also", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00064-00018984-00019167": "have in the surroundings this chrome", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00065-00019168-00019343": "ring which makes the grille look even", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00066-00019344-00019550": "bigger the mercedes-benz star on the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00067-00019551-00019839": "bonnet these nice and sporty looking", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00068-00019840-00020111": "lines the front bumper guys i'm honest", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00069-00020112-00020367": "with you for example with the 53 this is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00070-00020368-00020591": "full finished in plastic they are just", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00071-00020592-00020839": "covers but with the 63 you can also see", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00072-00020840-00021199": "the radiators so this is a real intake", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00073-00021200-00021703": "but something i don't like is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00074-00021704-00021983": "plastic plastic on an amg it's this", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00075-00021984-00022158": "should be illegal but yeah let's just", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00076-00022159-00022367": "skip that since we have no mic package", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00077-00022368-00022527": "for chrome finish also the front", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00078-00022528-00022711": "splitter chrome finish on the right side", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00079-00022712-00022863": "again as you can see", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00080-00022864-00023078": "the radiator but yeah plastic finish", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00081-00023079-00023303": "again let's just skip that before i go", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00082-00023304-00023511": "crazy but yeah all in all guys how do", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00083-00023512-00023735": "you like the front of this let me talk", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00084-00023736-00023991": "about the side because this is what", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00085-00023992-00024263": "makes the gle coupe so special when you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00086-00024264-00024519": "compare the suv with the coupe the only", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00087-00024520-00024719": "difference is the wheelbase back in the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00088-00024720-00024967": "days when we had the old gle coupe and", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00089-00024968-00025230": "the 63 amg version the wheelbase was", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00090-00025231-00025447": "exactly the same it was on base of the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00091-00025448-00025718": "normal suv model but now mercedes has", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00092-00025719-00025999": "worked it out we have a shorter", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00093-00026000-00026262": "wheelbase compared to the suv 60", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00094-00026263-00026495": "millimeters which makes this car way", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00095-00026495-00026767": "more agile and way more sporty in its", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00096-00026768-00027079": "driving characteristics compared to the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00097-00027080-00027358": "suv should i compare both the coupe and", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00098-00027360-00027535": "suv just leave it in the comment section", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00099-00027536-00027727": "below let's talk about the wheels here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00100-00027727-00028023": "we have the 22-inch multi-spoke wheels", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00101-00028024-00028231": "the y-shaped ones which i love", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00102-00028232-00028487": "especially in this chrome finish as you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00103-00028488-00028711": "see amg brake calipers you can also go", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00104-00028712-00028911": "for the optional ceramic brakes which", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00105-00028912-00029087": "are finished in golden but this has a", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00106-00029088-00029318": "normal amg brake system which is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00107-00029319-00029543": "finished in red and engraved over here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00108-00029544-00029790": "as well since we have no mic package", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00109-00029791-00030007": "everything here is finished in chrome we", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00110-00030008-00030223": "have the v8 by turbo batch on the side", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00111-00030224-00030502": "4matic the plus here finished in red", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00112-00030503-00030670": "matches extremely good with the brake", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00113-00030672-00030887": "calipers on the side here everything", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00114-00030888-00031174": "finished in chrome even the door handles", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00115-00031175-00031374": "as i mentioned we have no night package", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00116-00031375-00031702": "in the rear again 22 inches here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00117-00031703-00031935": "i just love the look of these wheels", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00118-00031936-00032046": "honestly", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00119-00032047-00032255": "having no night package plus these", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00120-00032256-00032470": "wheels look amazing and very elegant in", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00121-00032472-00032735": "my eyes let's just start to talk about", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00122-00032736-00032935": "the rear guys because this one is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00123-00032936-00033239": "beautiful i just love the rear of this", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00124-00033240-00033487": "the gle 63s", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00125-00033488-00033631": "coupe", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00126-00033632-00033831": "guys i just lowered the car as you can", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00127-00033832-00033983": "see here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00128-00033984-00034199": "it's looking so", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00129-00034200-00034439": "sporty now but yeah guys let's just", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00130-00034440-00034599": "start with the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00131-00034600-00034887": "rear view especially with the taillights", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00132-00034888-00035118": "very sharp looking tail lights here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00133-00035119-00035318": "updated by mercedes", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00134-00035319-00035567": "all in all as you can see the look is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00135-00035568-00035790": "not even close to what we had back in", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00136-00035791-00036015": "the days with the old gle koopa", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00137-00036016-00036230": "guys would you like to see a comparison", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00138-00036231-00036407": "between the old versus new especially", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00139-00036408-00036567": "with the taillights leave it in the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00140-00036568-00036702": "comment section below", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00141-00036703-00036871": "in addition to that we have this rear", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00142-00036872-00037143": "spoiler here which is finished in the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00143-00037144-00037367": "exterior paint the brilliant blue", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00144-00037368-00037687": "gle 63s badge chrome mercedes-benz star", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00145-00037688-00037902": "chrome and the amg badge as well", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00146-00037903-00038118": "finished in chrome something i hate", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00147-00038119-00038415": "about this i just hate i literally hate", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00148-00038416-00038855": "it", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00149-00038856-00039079": "do you hear that guys this makes me go", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00150-00039080-00039399": "crazy i swear to god this i hate this i", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00151-00039400-00039727": "hate this why would you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00152-00039728-00040023": "the starting price for gle 63 s coupe is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00153-00040024-00040230": "at 145", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00154-00040231-00040687": "000 euros which is a lot of money guys", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00155-00040688-00040990": "then you go spend this money on this car", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00156-00040991-00041174": "which is beautiful i love it", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00157-00041175-00041711": "but then you have these plastic parts", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00158-00041712-00041983": "mercedes give us the option to go for a", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00159-00041984-00042295": "carbon fiber for a full black finish for", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00160-00042296-00042502": "a exterior paint finish i mean i", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00161-00042503-00042718": "understand it suv characteristics but", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00162-00042719-00042815": "still", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00163-00042816-00042951": "why would you do that let's just skip", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00164-00042952-00043127": "that here again three exhaust tips", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00165-00043128-00043327": "finished in chrome and silver since we", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00166-00043328-00043535": "have no night package where the fuso as", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00167-00043536-00043758": "well finished in", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00168-00043759-00044023": "plastic", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00169-00044024-00044223": "but yeah let's just get started and", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00170-00044224-00044511": "start talking about the interior here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00171-00044512-00044774": "opening the doors for you guys", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00172-00044775-00044883": "and look at", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00173-00044884-00045190": "this nice but as you can instantly see", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00174-00045191-00045495": "this is boring the entire interior spec", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00175-00045496-00045767": "is just very base back but yeah let me", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00176-00045768-00046007": "just show you just a quick one full", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00177-00046008-00046239": "black leather finish here gray stitching", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00178-00046240-00046430": "aluminium the high-end ball mister", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00179-00046431-00046655": "system which then comes with the bow", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00180-00046656-00046943": "master covers also over here you see", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00181-00046944-00047127": "this finished in plastic as well i just", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00182-00047128-00047311": "don't like the the look of this in", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00183-00047312-00047486": "addition with the bulmister covers over", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00184-00047487-00047655": "here but as you know you need to upgrade", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00185-00047656-00047783": "it then you also have them over here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00186-00047784-00048015": "with the nice ambient lighting and the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00187-00048016-00048223": "inside you can instantly see full black", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00188-00048224-00048327": "finish", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00189-00048328-00048567": "black leather on the seats amg badge as", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00190-00048568-00048846": "well nice stitching here beautiful but", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00191-00048847-00049143": "yeah let's just get inside amg step", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00192-00049144-00049430": "boards amg floor mats", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00193-00049431-00049615": "and here we are", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00194-00049616-00049855": "yeah nice especially in addition with", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00195-00049856-00050007": "the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00196-00050008-00050343": "gle 63 animation here so we are now", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00197-00050344-00050486": "inside this will be a very quick", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00198-00050487-00050671": "interior of you always just showing you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00199-00050672-00050830": "the things i like and don't like about", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00200-00050831-00051079": "this interior first of all the aluminium", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00201-00051080-00051246": "brushed is not", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00202-00051247-00051438": "i would rather upgrade it to the carbon", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00203-00051439-00051663": "fiber look on this also the piano finish", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00204-00051664-00051854": "here i'm not the biggest fan of it but", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00205-00051855-00052102": "something i love is that we have the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00206-00052103-00052270": "leather package here which means that", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00207-00052271-00052550": "all like the dashboard the side panels", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00208-00052551-00052711": "everything is finished in leather with a", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00209-00052712-00052959": "very nice touch plus on the steering", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00210-00052960-00053182": "wheel the amg flat bottom steering wheel", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00211-00053183-00053375": "right in front of me and i love this", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00212-00053376-00053638": "look the airbag cover is finished in", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00213-00053639-00053742": "leather", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00214-00053744-00054007": "this makes a huge difference guys if you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00215-00054008-00054238": "go get yourself an amg try to get the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00216-00054239-00054535": "amg leather airbag cover here it will", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00217-00054536-00054735": "just look 10 times better in my eyes we", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00218-00054736-00054999": "have the head up display also and", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00219-00055000-00055247": "something i hate guys just look it's", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00220-00055248-00055438": "very dark inside even though we have a", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00221-00055439-00055654": "nice lightning outside since we don't", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00222-00055655-00055854": "have a panorama roof guys if you go and", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00223-00055855-00056030": "get yourself a mercedes this should be", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00224-00056032-00056230": "standard just go and get it invest that", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00225-00056232-00056438": "money it's definitely worth it you have", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00226-00056439-00056630": "so much more light in the interior but", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00227-00056632-00056799": "yeah that's it basically for the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00228-00056800-00057054": "interior view now let's get right into", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00229-00057055-00057223": "it and start", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00230-00057224-00057482": "with a sound check guys okay i'll be", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00231-00057483-00057807": "just yeah preparing everything for you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00232-00057808-00057911": "here", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00233-00057912-00058111": "lowering the windows as well so we have", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00234-00058112-00058238": "a nice", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00235-00058239-00058526": "sound okay are you ready guys okay three", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00236-00058527-00058911": "two one let's go", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00237-00058912-00059130": "easy startup around", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00238-00059132-00059487": "1500 rpm", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00239-00059488-00059726": "are you ready guys listen the exhaust is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00240-00059727-00061766": "on", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00241-00061767-00061966": "nice but guys we need to experience it", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00242-00061967-00062215": "from the outside so let's go", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00243-00062216-00062447": "guys now it's time for a proper sound", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00244-00062448-00062623": "check from the outside it sounds ten", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00245-00062624-00062823": "times better okay we will be starting", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00246-00062824-00063447": "with an emotion start so let's go", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00247-00063448-00065247": "yes that's what i'm talking", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00248-00065248-00065471": "nice guys how do you like the sound of", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00249-00065472-00065735": "this even though we have an opf and the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00250-00065736-00066047": "rev limiter on this vehicle the sound is", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00251-00066048-00066287": "still very good in my eyes how do you", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00252-00066288-00066463": "like it leave it in the comment section", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00253-00066464-00066967": "below so now it's time for a resume", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00254-00066968-00067135": "so that's it basically for today's video", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00255-00067136-00067494": "guys how do you like the new gle 63s", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00256-00067495-00067719": "coupe how do you like the front the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00257-00067720-00067982": "wheels the side the rear the interior", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00258-00067983-00068182": "and the sound looking forward to read", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00259-00068183-00068391": "all your comments guys in my opinion", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00260-00068392-00068671": "this is a great vehicle back in the days", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00261-00068672-00068926": "with the old one we had the exact same", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00262-00068927-00069126": "wheelbase which the coupe shared with", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00263-00069127-00069415": "the suv but now the coupe is so much", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00264-00069416-00069703": "more sportier so much more dynamic and", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00265-00069704-00070087": "agile comparing to the suv model finally", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00266-00070088-00070399": "all in all i love this as i'm a big kupe", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00267-00070400-00070550": "fanboy i'm not the biggest fan of the", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00268-00070551-00070903": "suv so this is my way to go guys what", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00269-00070904-00071111": "car would you like to see next looking", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00270-00071112-00071303": "forward to see you all again and wish", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00271-00071304-00071494": "you all a great day", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00272-00071495-00073167": "i will be back", "MR9Wh--XBYk-00273-00073168-00073376": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "MRNxpWlJQRM", "text": {"MRNxpWlJQRM-00000-00000039-00002281": "[Music]", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00001-00002282-00002471": "thank you", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00002-00002472-00003000": "questions", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00003-00003001-00005627": "[Music]", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00004-00005628-00005923": "foreign", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00005-00005924-00009846": "[Music]", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00006-00009847-00010073": "thank you", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00007-00010074-00012403": "[Music]", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00008-00012404-00013307": "thank you", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00009-00013308-00014855": "[Music]", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00010-00014856-00015141": "foreign", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00011-00015141-00017279": "[Music]", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00012-00017280-00017647": "foreign", "MRNxpWlJQRM-00013-00017648-00019215": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "MROkXqE4eLk", "text": {"MROkXqE4eLk-00000-00000024-00000419": "oh", "MROkXqE4eLk-00001-00000420-00003911": "[Music]", "MROkXqE4eLk-00002-00003911-00004737": "a few moments later", "MROkXqE4eLk-00003-00004738-00005054": "[Music]", "MROkXqE4eLk-00004-00005055-00006079": "okay", "MROkXqE4eLk-00005-00006080-00006271": "oh", "MROkXqE4eLk-00006-00006272-00007237": "[Music]", "MROkXqE4eLk-00007-00007238-00008168": "[Music]", "MROkXqE4eLk-00008-00008169-00008374": "[Music]", "MROkXqE4eLk-00009-00008375-00008826": "is", "MROkXqE4eLk-00010-00008827-00009606": "[Music]", "MROkXqE4eLk-00011-00009607-00010483": "hey", "MROkXqE4eLk-00012-00010484-00011310": "[Music]", "MROkXqE4eLk-00013-00011311-00011482": "hey", "MROkXqE4eLk-00014-00011483-00013299": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "MS5WTlN4-Y8", "text": {"MS5WTlN4-Y8-00000-00000440-00000630": "hello working preachers this is ralph", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00001-00000631-00000839": "jacobson kicking off the official first", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00002-00000840-00001143": "day of our fall fundraising campaign", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00003-00001144-00001319": "i wanted to take a moment to let you", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00004-00001320-00001511": "know that all gifts made during the fall", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00005-00001512-00001695": "campaign will be doubled with a dollar", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00006-00001696-00001910": "for dollar match up to ten thousand", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00007-00001911-00002014": "dollars", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00008-00002016-00002159": "when you make a gift during the fall", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00009-00002160-00002518": "campaign november 1st through the 30th", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00010-00002519-00002815": "we will send you a free ebook titled", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00011-00002816-00002983": "youthful sermons", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00012-00002984-00003183": "youthful sermons is a workbook to help", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00013-00003184-00003399": "young people preach their first sermon", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00014-00003400-00003654": "with mentoring from their pastor working", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00015-00003655-00003863": "preacher would not be possible without", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00016-00003864-00004119": "generous donors like you and we are so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00017-00004120-00004359": "grateful for each and every one of you", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00018-00004360-00004622": "you can make your gift online today at", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00019-00004623-00004815": "workingpreacher.org", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00020-00004816-00004975": "welcome to sermon brainwave with me", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00021-00004976-00005295": "caroline lewis and me ralph jacobson", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00022-00005296-00005759": "and me joy j moore and me matt skinner", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00023-00005760-00005967": "this is the podcast for all saints", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00024-00005968-00006383": "sunday which falls on november 7 2021.", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00025-00006384-00006639": "if you are looking for the podcast for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00026-00006640-00006942": "the 24th sunday after pentecost you can", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00027-00006943-00007183": "pop over there and it's available", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00028-00007184-00007487": "but this is the podcast for all saints", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00029-00007488-00007655": "sunday if that is what you are", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00030-00007656-00007895": "remembering this particular festival", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00031-00007895-00008199": "sunday and the texts for all saints this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00032-00008200-00008335": "year", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00033-00008336-00008439": "are", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00034-00008440-00008823": "isaiah chapter 25 verses 6 through 9", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00035-00008824-00009078": "the psalm is psalm 24", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00036-00009079-00009414": "revelation 21 1 through 6 a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00037-00009415-00009742": "and the gospel reading is john 11", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00038-00009743-00010055": "verses 32 through 44", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00039-00010056-00010599": "a section of the raising of lazarus", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00040-00010600-00010806": "should we start there", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00041-00010807-00010951": "yeah are we going to disagree about what", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00042-00010952-00011319": "happens to lazarus", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00043-00011320-00011606": "no because we don't act well uh well i", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00044-00011607-00011742": "don't know maybe we'll see we'll see", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00045-00011743-00011967": "what happens see where it goes okay uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00046-00011968-00012110": "what happened", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00047-00012111-00012295": "i think he's resuscitated", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00048-00012296-00012487": "yeah and i don't oh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00049-00012488-00012855": "we're gonna disagree yeah yeah anyway", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00050-00012856-00013135": "that's not where i was going i uh i want", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00051-00013136-00013566": "to focus on uh particularly uh this year", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00052-00013568-00013751": "one of the things that i've been really", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00053-00013752-00014022": "struck by uh in this past year and it", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00054-00014023-00014247": "has to do with some work that i'm doing", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00055-00014247-00014471": "with a with a book", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00056-00014472-00014847": "uh but uh bringing trauma theory to uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00057-00014847-00015135": "the interpretation of scripture and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00058-00015136-00015399": "that uh and and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00059-00015400-00015663": "inviting preachers this year to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00060-00015663-00015838": "to note", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00061-00015840-00015935": "that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00062-00015936-00016079": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00063-00016080-00016279": "kind of an obvious thing but it's it's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00064-00016280-00016407": "worth noting", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00065-00016408-00016575": "that you know this whole this whole", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00066-00016576-00016750": "chapter at least up into the raising of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00067-00016751-00016950": "lazarus is called the raising of lazarus", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00068-00016951-00017143": "when actually the raising of lazarus is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00069-00017144-00017471": "only two verses uh it's 43 to 44. that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00070-00017472-00017655": "the narrative space", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00071-00017656-00017807": "is given to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00072-00017808-00018079": "uh the grief and the trauma", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00073-00018080-00018311": "of death and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00074-00018312-00018494": "uh and that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00075-00018495-00018591": "that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00076-00018592-00018943": "we that we acknowledge the ways in which", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00077-00018944-00019111": "scripture does", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00078-00019112-00019303": "give space for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00079-00019304-00019511": "uh grief and trauma", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00080-00019512-00019783": "and and the way the the resurrection", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00081-00019784-00019975": "narratives you know before that before", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00082-00019976-00020143": "they were", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00083-00020144-00020407": "lilies and trumpets and peeps and all of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00084-00020408-00020494": "that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00085-00020495-00020735": "are really trauma narratives uh why", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00086-00020736-00020903": "isn't that mary why is it that mary", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00087-00020904-00021014": "magdalene", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00088-00021015-00021214": "doesn't recognize jesus because it's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00089-00021215-00021439": "impossible in that moment", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00090-00021440-00021622": "uh for her to do so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00091-00021623-00021839": "and and so that maybe", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00092-00021840-00022055": "and so we look at that narrative space", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00093-00022056-00022375": "of these characters", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00094-00022376-00022663": "uh sitting in the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00095-00022664-00022958": "the absolute trauma of death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00096-00022959-00023199": "and and the way in which that's where we", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00097-00023200-00023558": "are uh uh death uh death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00098-00023559-00023822": "in our in our immediate circles whether", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00099-00023823-00023958": "that's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00100-00023959-00024255": "a loved one due to due to covet or", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00101-00024256-00024527": "communal uh a communal", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00102-00024528-00024767": "somebody in our community due to covid", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00103-00024768-00025094": "or another death but just the the wide", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00104-00025095-00025255": "scale", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00105-00025256-00025519": "uh number of death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00106-00025520-00025758": "in the since we've been since", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00107-00025760-00025950": "all since we've been at all saints from", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00108-00025951-00026111": "last year and i", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00109-00026112-00026287": "and then that makes me", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00110-00026288-00026551": "really focus then on", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00111-00026552-00026807": "the weeping of jesus", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00112-00026808-00027070": "that we hear the weeping of jesus as", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00113-00027072-00027399": "this is not uh this is not", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00114-00027400-00027639": "this is not a sentimental", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00115-00027639-00028111": "uh moment here but that jesus is weeping", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00116-00028112-00028423": "for uh lazarus", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00117-00028424-00028599": "he weeps for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00118-00028600-00028839": "uh himself", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00119-00028839-00029111": "because he knows what's going to come", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00120-00029112-00029383": "and he weeps for the reality of death in", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00121-00029383-00029495": "general", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00122-00029495-00029751": "because he knows what death does", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00123-00029752-00030014": "uh he knows that death causes", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00124-00030016-00030295": "separation that is that is beyond", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00125-00030295-00030439": "fathomable", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00126-00030439-00030711": "uh and grief that is beyond", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00127-00030712-00030790": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00128-00030791-00031062": "beyond anything we can we can imagine", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00129-00031063-00031287": "being able to feel and getting through", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00130-00031288-00031455": "and experience", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00131-00031456-00031614": "uh and that maybe that's the first", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00132-00031616-00031799": "homolytical move", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00133-00031800-00031902": "this year", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00134-00031903-00032302": "uh is that that that that jesus weeps", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00135-00032303-00032535": "for uh for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00136-00032536-00032774": "what death uh does", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00137-00032775-00033079": "for in our lives and what death brings", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00138-00033080-00033383": "and uh and maybe this year jesus is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00139-00033384-00033495": "weeping", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00140-00033496-00033846": "uh even more uh when we look at the last", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00141-00033847-00034135": "um the last year and the kind of death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00142-00034136-00034295": "that we've had to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00143-00034296-00034423": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00144-00034424-00034639": "deal with and that we've had to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00145-00034640-00034823": "um experience", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00146-00034824-00034959": "that's way more interesting than talking", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00147-00034960-00035127": "about resurrection and resuscitation", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00148-00035128-00035246": "that's brilliant and it's really", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00149-00035247-00035462": "important stuff that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00150-00035463-00035623": "um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00151-00035624-00035846": "i i think too of the way grief is so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00152-00035847-00036135": "extended right now", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00153-00036136-00036327": "in so many communities", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00154-00036328-00036527": "what psychologists call complicated", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00155-00036528-00036655": "grief", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00156-00036656-00036935": "when you're unable to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00157-00036936-00037023": "pre", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00158-00037024-00037223": "to practice grieving in the kind of the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00159-00037224-00037407": "culturally", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00160-00037408-00037607": "sanctioned or normative ways that we're", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00161-00037608-00037839": "all used to because you know", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00162-00037840-00037967": "you get practice and learning how to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00163-00037968-00038167": "grieve deaths but there's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00164-00038168-00038415": "there's such a backlog of grieving over", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00165-00038416-00038646": "the last two years", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00166-00038647-00038783": "um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00167-00038784-00038974": "that that trauma gets just more and more", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00168-00038975-00039055": "um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00169-00039056-00039359": "it's the word i want it's intensified", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00170-00039360-00039454": "yeah so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00171-00039455-00039630": "[Music]", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00172-00039631-00039871": "crucial to provide i think space for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00173-00039872-00039999": "some of that just to come out this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00174-00040000-00040302": "sunday in addition to the preaching", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00175-00040303-00040479": "you know i think that's why", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00176-00040480-00040862": "i think i think that's exactly right", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00177-00040863-00041111": "matt and caroline and i think that's why", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00178-00041112-00041311": "people don't remember", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00179-00041312-00041471": "all saints sermons", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00180-00041472-00041639": "but what they remember they do remember", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00181-00041640-00041774": "the ritual", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00182-00041775-00041879": "of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00183-00041880-00042118": "maybe going up and lighting a candle", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00184-00042119-00042239": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00185-00042240-00042415": "especially though i think people", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00186-00042416-00042574": "remember that ritual if your", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00187-00042575-00042735": "congregation does something like that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00188-00042736-00043111": "which i strongly urge um especially", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00189-00043112-00043255": "people will remember for the rest of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00190-00043256-00043471": "their lives going up and lighting it for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00191-00043472-00043711": "the first time after the death of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00192-00043712-00043918": "somebody so this will be the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00193-00043919-00044151": "first all saints since my mom died since", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00194-00044152-00044430": "my uncle died", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00195-00044431-00044567": "and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00196-00044568-00044815": "most intensely believe it or not since", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00197-00044816-00045111": "uh very recently my cousins my first", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00198-00045112-00045262": "cousin's 30 year old son died", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00199-00045263-00045567": "unexpectedly so my extended family has", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00200-00045568-00045862": "just been through three weeks actually", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00201-00045863-00046374": "15 days of really intense", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00202-00046375-00046662": "morning together um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00203-00046663-00046871": "and then", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00204-00046872-00047071": "leaning into then", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00205-00047072-00047358": "the all saints experience and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00206-00047359-00047527": "we're obviously recording this before", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00207-00047528-00047743": "all saints and i'm very much looking", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00208-00047744-00047846": "forward", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00209-00047847-00048007": "to that to that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00210-00048008-00048383": "grief ritual as part of all saints um so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00211-00048384-00048679": "to come alongside that with the sermon", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00212-00048680-00048886": "uh talking about whether it's talking", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00213-00048887-00049199": "about christ wiping away every tear or", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00214-00049200-00049358": "talking about", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00215-00049359-00049871": "that god feels i mean the one of the big", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00216-00049872-00050135": "one of the big um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00217-00050136-00050502": "i don't know assertions of the biblical", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00218-00050503-00050830": "about the biblical god is that god feels", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00219-00050831-00050974": "this is one of the things that made", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00220-00050975-00051270": "marcion reject the old testament because", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00221-00051271-00051550": "martian wanted an unmoved mover a god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00222-00051551-00051823": "who was unmoved emotionally", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00223-00051824-00052079": "somehow he and others in the hellenistic", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00224-00052079-00052166": "world", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00225-00052167-00052430": "thought that idea was um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00226-00052432-00052735": "uh ridicul ridiculable", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00227-00052736-00052911": "i don't know what the word um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00228-00052912-00053199": "i'm looking for is but that is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00229-00053200-00053559": "jesus weeps god actually feels our pain", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00230-00053560-00053791": "and feels pain", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00231-00053791-00053982": "because of us and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00232-00053983-00054166": "on our behalf", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00233-00054167-00054294": "i think that's a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00234-00054295-00054487": "very important uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00235-00054488-00054599": "piece of our", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00236-00054600-00054911": "biblical faith", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00237-00054912-00055191": "i appreciate ben reminding us of the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00238-00055191-00055350": "numbers uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00239-00055351-00055694": "currently the covet numbers worldwide", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00240-00055695-00055991": "it's approaching 5 million", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00241-00055991-00056407": "and in the u.s approaching 750 000", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00242-00056408-00056535": "deaths", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00243-00056536-00056630": "and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00244-00056632-00056791": "for that reason", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00245-00056791-00056903": "this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00246-00056904-00057207": "recognition of the reality of death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00247-00057208-00057542": "and in this particular text as caroline", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00248-00057544-00057799": "opened us to remember that just in the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00249-00057800-00058166": "midst of that moment how dare us think", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00250-00058167-00058399": "it natural to expect", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00251-00058400-00058591": "some um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00252-00058591-00059038": "easy resurrection some easy fix we we", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00253-00059039-00059359": "need to linger in the lament to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00254-00059360-00059559": "to um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00255-00059560-00060007": "to tr travail to traverse this territory", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00256-00060008-00060135": "of grief", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00257-00060136-00060494": "uh i am reminded uh shortly after my mom", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00258-00060495-00060791": "died that a friend of mine shared with", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00259-00060791-00061126": "me a text and i don't know if if", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00260-00061127-00061366": "it's a quote someone gave her", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00261-00061367-00061703": "uh or if this was her own writing but", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00262-00061704-00061991": "the words are grief", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00263-00061991-00062279": "is a foreign territory", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00264-00062279-00062671": "with rules all its own that one only", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00265-00062672-00062838": "discovers", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00266-00062839-00063215": "by traversing the unwelcome travain", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00267-00063216-00063447": "terrain", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00268-00063448-00063711": "one unwelcome reality", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00269-00063712-00063959": "is being bone tired", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00270-00063960-00064079": "and not but", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00271-00064079-00064382": "unable to calm the mind and heart", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00272-00064383-00064766": "to receive deep rest", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00273-00064767-00064982": "and that is exactly the promise that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00274-00064983-00065215": "jesus makes to us i mean not in this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00275-00065216-00065319": "text", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00276-00065320-00065719": "but that that's one of the promises that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00277-00065720-00065882": "we will be given", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00278-00065883-00066279": "rest and this is the one place where it", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00279-00066280-00066679": "feels at least at the when when when", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00280-00066680-00066943": "death enters into our home", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00281-00066944-00067319": "into directly into our lives", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00282-00067320-00067582": "how do you rest from that how do you how", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00283-00067583-00067887": "do you feel peace in the midst of that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00284-00067888-00068143": "and for me it's knowing", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00285-00068144-00068455": "that god grieves too", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00286-00068456-00068831": "it's knowing that god is vulnerable here", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00287-00068832-00068926": "too", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00288-00068927-00069279": "it's knowing that god also", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00289-00069280-00069494": "in the midst of that grief in the midst", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00290-00069495-00069743": "of that vulnerability", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00291-00069744-00070143": "has power over even death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00292-00070144-00070535": "and walking that terrain with god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00293-00070536-00070767": "is hope filled", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00294-00070768-00071119": "because of what god can do and does do", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00295-00071120-00071311": "in the midst of that grief should we go", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00296-00071312-00071862": "to isaiah", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00297-00071863-00072031": "it's such a great text", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00298-00072032-00072238": "you know both here and when it gets uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00299-00072239-00072638": "recalled in in revelation 21", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00300-00072639-00072775": "just a great", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00301-00072776-00073159": "promise um especially in the midst of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00302-00073160-00073343": "whether it's personal grief or just the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00303-00073344-00073687": "numbing loss of so many people and and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00304-00073688-00073806": "and that's something else too i think", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00305-00073807-00073975": "that for preachers to think about ways", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00306-00073976-00074159": "to help your congregation grieve for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00307-00074160-00074326": "strangers", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00308-00074327-00074487": "as well to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00309-00074488-00074687": "open people up to the you know then", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00310-00074688-00074903": "those numbers are are immense in terms", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00311-00074904-00075150": "of loss but just the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00312-00075151-00075526": "the numbness of all of this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00313-00075527-00075782": "uh but here's the promise right as corey", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00314-00075783-00075975": "carvalho says in the commentary god will", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00315-00075976-00076215": "swallow up the swallower uh you know", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00316-00076216-00076519": "that you know moat this this this deity", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00317-00076520-00076767": "of death that just", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00318-00076768-00076967": "travels the earth with its jaws wide", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00319-00076968-00077150": "open swallowing up", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00320-00077151-00077591": "uh people you know this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00321-00077592-00077991": "this image of just destruction", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00322-00077992-00078175": "uh will become you know the victim of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00323-00078176-00078415": "god's own design as well", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00324-00078416-00078567": "which still you know this is not one of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00325-00078568-00078759": "the texts but first corinthians 15 right", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00326-00078760-00078943": "the last enemy to be defeated is death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00327-00078944-00079150": "itself", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00328-00079151-00079319": "um so there's promise right there are", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00329-00079320-00079575": "these promises in here that are", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00330-00079576-00079806": "huge aspirational but how that can pull", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00331-00079807-00079982": "us into doxology the way the book of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00332-00079983-00080159": "revelation does i know we're doing", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00333-00080160-00080367": "isaiah but i find it helpful to think of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00334-00080368-00080535": "those two together", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00335-00080536-00080782": "now i do too um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00336-00080783-00080935": "the thing that always strikes me about", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00337-00080936-00081071": "this text", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00338-00081072-00081415": "is um the first image in it though is of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00339-00081416-00081687": "a feast", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00340-00081688-00081926": "and and maybe this is a time to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00341-00081927-00082087": "so let me just talk about that for a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00342-00082088-00082206": "minute that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00343-00082207-00082350": "um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00344-00082351-00082550": "most of the old testament including this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00345-00082551-00082671": "passage", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00346-00082672-00082991": "uh was written before money existed", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00347-00082992-00083199": "um they had silver that they used for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00348-00083200-00083494": "exchange but not money uh that the first", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00349-00083495-00083631": "money was", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00350-00083632-00083750": "um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00351-00083751-00084006": "silver that that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00352-00084007-00084167": "somebody that the government had said", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00353-00084168-00084391": "yes this weighs a shekel that it you", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00354-00084392-00084671": "know it's an agreed weight and from that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00355-00084672-00084887": "then eventually money uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00356-00084888-00085143": "as an abstract concept but so before", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00357-00085144-00085431": "money what's the image of abundance", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00358-00085432-00085591": "and the in the primary image of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00359-00085592-00085767": "abundance in the old testament is the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00360-00085768-00085871": "feast", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00361-00085872-00085975": "and so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00362-00085976-00086262": "so god you know", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00363-00086263-00086447": "here's the picture the poet paints for", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00364-00086448-00086526": "us", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00365-00086527-00086862": "uh a feast of the best food and the best", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00366-00086863-00086959": "wine", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00367-00086960-00087079": "um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00368-00087080-00087318": "and that it's going to be for all people", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00369-00087319-00087591": "this incredible feast and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00370-00087592-00087887": "that's one of the ways we we also grieve", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00371-00087888-00088111": "and we mark things like that is we do", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00372-00088112-00088206": "have", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00373-00088207-00088494": "uh we do have feasts at uh both that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00374-00088495-00088606": "that mark", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00375-00088607-00088894": "our best days and and we bless each", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00376-00088895-00089087": "other with food in the midst of grief", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00377-00089088-00089271": "you know the one thing people know how", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00378-00089272-00089391": "to do when someone's going through", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00379-00089392-00089743": "trauma is to bring food um so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00380-00089744-00090015": "i just that image of the feast", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00381-00090016-00090279": "and uh when we say", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00382-00090280-00090535": "when we sing in in when some of us that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00383-00090536-00090759": "come from liturgical traditions saying", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00384-00090760-00090982": "that this is the feast it's not talking", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00385-00090983-00091206": "about community now which is a foretaste", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00386-00091207-00091399": "it's talking about the feast of victory", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00387-00091400-00091631": "that revelation the book of revelation", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00388-00091632-00091991": "is saying will come for for all people", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00389-00091992-00092375": "i really appreciate that uh setting um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00390-00092376-00092550": "uh that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00391-00092551-00092831": "we're not talking about just this uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00392-00092832-00093071": "little uh moment today we are", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00393-00093072-00093223": "anticipating", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00394-00093224-00093582": "and uh that this text as uh matt has uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00395-00093583-00093847": "repeatedly said and and you're saying as", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00396-00093848-00094143": "well ralph is about this is repeated and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00397-00094144-00094406": "we think we know it from revelation from", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00398-00094407-00094582": "the new testament because that's where", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00399-00094583-00094943": "we read it but it is the assurance of a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00400-00094944-00095262": "covenant of a promise that was made", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00401-00095263-00095479": "to the people of god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00402-00095480-00095767": "uh from from the very beginning from the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00403-00095768-00095982": "from from the beginning if you if you", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00404-00095983-00096287": "hear the echoes of the creation story", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00405-00096288-00096711": "where they're um uh in um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00406-00096712-00096967": "uh in the the creation story the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00407-00096968-00097087": "the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00408-00097088-00097374": "food that is available for all of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00409-00097375-00097759": "humanity and the animals is sufficient", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00410-00097760-00098215": "in the seeds of of the plants um so this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00411-00098216-00098559": "abundance for all is from the very", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00412-00098560-00098871": "beginning and uh i love the fact that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00413-00098872-00099167": "you called us to linger here", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00414-00099168-00099406": "to know that in the midst of grief in", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00415-00099407-00099694": "the midst of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00416-00099695-00099894": "lament in the midst of loss that's the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00417-00099895-00100055": "words i'm looking for in the midst of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00418-00100056-00100343": "grief in the midst of loss", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00419-00100344-00100655": "we have this eternal promise", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00420-00100656-00101006": "that god has provided for us and that we", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00421-00101007-00101191": "can celebrate", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00422-00101192-00101455": "and come together and as a single person", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00423-00101456-00101703": "who's eaten a lot of meals alone", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00424-00101704-00101974": "i really love the fact when i'm invited", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00425-00101975-00102238": "to gather with others", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00426-00102239-00102454": "even if it's only one other to break", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00427-00102455-00102639": "bread and to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00428-00102640-00102910": "share drinks um even if it's just a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00429-00102911-00103271": "ginger ale with lime my favorite drink", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00430-00103272-00103502": "but to be able to do that with someone", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00431-00103503-00103694": "else who understands", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00432-00103695-00103942": "the reality of my moment whether it's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00433-00103943-00104254": "celebration or grief and we can journey", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00434-00104255-00104415": "together in this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00435-00104416-00104623": "the song do we want to say anything", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00436-00104624-00104799": "about the song you know one thing that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00437-00104800-00105047": "is as we were talking and and looking at", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00438-00105048-00105383": "uh particularly the isaiah text and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00439-00105383-00105790": "and the psalm 24 and psalm 24", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00440-00105791-00106110": "uh and you know the ways in which this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00441-00106111-00106271": "you know the imagery and metaphors", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00442-00106272-00106519": "around around feast and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00443-00106520-00106671": "and uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00444-00106672-00106823": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00445-00106824-00106951": "and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00446-00106952-00107166": "the presence and activity of god in the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00447-00107167-00107310": "midst of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00448-00107311-00107607": "uh in the midst of our our suffering and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00449-00107608-00107758": "our grief and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00450-00107759-00108007": "and uh and so we have a reference to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00451-00108008-00108319": "salvation or god's saving in isaiah and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00452-00108320-00108623": "then then of course again in the psalm", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00453-00108624-00108766": "they will receive blessing from the lord", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00454-00108767-00108943": "and vindication from god the god of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00455-00108944-00109166": "their salvation and i'm not sure if i", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00456-00109167-00109375": "would go here but you know the way in", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00457-00109376-00109551": "which we uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00458-00109552-00109758": "that that frequently salvation is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00459-00109759-00109966": "connected to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00460-00109967-00110071": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00461-00110072-00110166": "either", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00462-00110167-00110471": "either jesus death or or the you know or", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00463-00110472-00110663": "jesus resurrection or the way in which", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00464-00110664-00110910": "we tie salvation or what is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00465-00110911-00111199": "toward a kind of future reality", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00466-00111200-00111471": "uh in terms of we also will be raised", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00467-00111472-00111647": "from the dead just as jesus was raised", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00468-00111648-00111766": "from the dead", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00469-00111767-00111895": "uh and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00470-00111896-00112078": "and yet what we're getting in these", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00471-00112079-00112319": "texts and then i think in this in in our", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00472-00112320-00112495": "conversation here", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00473-00112496-00112702": "uh is a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00474-00112703-00112847": "a uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00475-00112848-00113047": "a way to think about salvation that is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00476-00113048-00113319": "here and now that that part of our god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00477-00113320-00113623": "is a saving god that that's not uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00478-00113624-00113831": "postponed to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00479-00113832-00113910": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00480-00113911-00114319": "a post-death existence but uh that that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00481-00114320-00114615": "inbreaking of god's salvific activity", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00482-00114616-00114823": "uh that we think of the salvation and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00483-00114824-00114975": "we're really gonna get that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00484-00114976-00115271": "i think a little bit in in revelation as", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00485-00115272-00115527": "well that that salvation is very much", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00486-00115528-00115766": "tied to the dwelling of god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00487-00115767-00116119": "um in our grief and in that presence and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00488-00116120-00116383": "um so it just it just i think breaks", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00489-00116383-00116615": "open a little bit to like what does it", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00490-00116616-00116934": "mean that we have a god of salvation", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00491-00116935-00117358": "uh and that that our god is a saving god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00492-00117359-00117671": "and engages in salvific acts", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00493-00117672-00117775": "and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00494-00117776-00117919": "i don't know if that's going to be a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00495-00117920-00118151": "direction that the preacher takes but i", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00496-00118152-00118327": "think it's one aspect of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00497-00118328-00118590": "of uh all saints and one aspect of these", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00498-00118591-00118766": "texts that one could explore", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00499-00118767-00118902": "theologically", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00500-00118903-00119199": "all right so thanks caroline um all", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00501-00119200-00119343": "right let me go in a weird direction at", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00502-00119344-00119599": "first it's going somewhere just trust me", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00503-00119600-00119831": "so um as i said we've had a bunch of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00504-00119832-00120047": "family uh funerals lately it's at my", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00505-00120048-00120214": "uncle's committal", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00506-00120215-00120423": "um i got to the chapel and this is one", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00507-00120424-00120639": "of these big um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00508-00120640-00120807": "cemetery uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00509-00120808-00120951": "operations that they have multiple", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00510-00120952-00121078": "chapels", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00511-00121079-00121151": "so", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00512-00121152-00121327": "and they're used by all different kinds", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00513-00121328-00121702": "of faith and non-faith and so uh one", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00514-00121703-00121934": "i got to the chapel early of course and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00515-00121935-00122078": "um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00516-00122079-00122343": "there was a stack of uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00517-00122344-00122566": "little um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00518-00122567-00122807": "folders for a jewish funeral that had", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00519-00122808-00123031": "happened and it had the uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00520-00123032-00123271": "uh it had the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00521-00123272-00123486": "the funeral the morning the mourner's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00522-00123488-00123599": "kadish", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00523-00123600-00123927": "uh which i had never looked at before um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00524-00123928-00124183": "and the mourner's kadesh um doesn't", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00525-00124183-00124327": "mention death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00526-00124328-00124590": "what it does is simply praises god uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00527-00124591-00124951": "for god's greatness and uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00528-00124952-00125071": "it's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00529-00125072-00125383": "the the idea is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00530-00125383-00125519": "when we're in the midst of things we", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00531-00125520-00125695": "cannot understand", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00532-00125696-00125990": "like the death of a loved one that part", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00533-00125991-00126263": "of the mourning in grief is nonetheless", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00534-00126264-00126510": "to bear witness to god's greatness", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00535-00126511-00126631": "and that's what's i think that's what", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00536-00126632-00126871": "psalm 24 does here at the end it may", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00537-00126872-00127110": "seem like a really odd thing to do", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00538-00127111-00127358": "to uh on all saints when we remember", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00539-00127359-00127599": "death to talk about how great god is but", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00540-00127600-00127671": "that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00541-00127672-00127814": "it does actually have a function in", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00542-00127815-00128078": "mourning uh that i learned from this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00543-00128079-00128214": "little folder", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00544-00128215-00128447": "should we um move on to revelation we", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00545-00128448-00128614": "were making the connection of course", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00546-00128615-00128710": "between", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00547-00128711-00129039": "isaiah and revelation that uh god will", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00548-00129040-00129190": "wipe away", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00549-00129191-00129454": "uh every tear from their eyes and death", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00550-00129455-00129647": "will be no more", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00551-00129648-00129927": "uh and uh and i think there's a good", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00552-00129928-00130095": "connection to what you were just talking", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00553-00130096-00130366": "about ralph is that we hear in this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00554-00130367-00130495": "passage", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00555-00130496-00130783": "uh words of promise see i am making all", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00556-00130783-00130951": "things new", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00557-00130952-00131135": "and uh and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00558-00131136-00131447": "and the promise of of the way in which", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00559-00131448-00131823": "god it god is our beginning and our end", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00560-00131824-00131943": "uh that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00561-00131944-00132183": "that going back to the beginning of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00562-00132184-00132335": "revelation where", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00563-00132336-00132639": "i am the alpha the omega the one who is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00564-00132640-00132839": "it's always interesting that the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00565-00132840-00133071": "that the first verb tense is present", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00566-00133072-00133343": "tense the one who is and who was and who", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00567-00133344-00133487": "is to come", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00568-00133488-00133783": "and and which really then emphasizes", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00569-00133784-00134031": "uh the promise of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00570-00134032-00134119": "of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00571-00134120-00134335": "uh i heard a loud voice from the throne", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00572-00134336-00134502": "saying seeing the home of god is among", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00573-00134503-00134695": "mortals he will dwell", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00574-00134696-00134935": "god will dwell with them that that's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00575-00134936-00135166": "that verbs", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00576-00135167-00135247": "which", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00577-00135248-00135647": "is used in of course john 1 14.", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00578-00135648-00135847": "and this is the only two places actually", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00579-00135848-00136047": "in the new testament that the verb is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00580-00136048-00136335": "used of this promise of god's dwelling", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00581-00136336-00136639": "and so you know going back to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00582-00136640-00136751": "john", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00583-00136752-00136863": "uh the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00584-00136864-00137207": "the the raising of lazarus and then here", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00585-00137208-00137495": "that that the promise we praise god or", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00586-00137496-00137814": "we rejoice because god is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00587-00137815-00138071": "is dwelling tabernacling", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00588-00138072-00138423": "tenting with us uh in in everything in", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00589-00138424-00138566": "the in this", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00590-00138567-00138639": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00591-00138640-00138895": "in our grief and in our", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00592-00138896-00138990": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00593-00138991-00139102": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00594-00139103-00139335": "trying to make sense of what how to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00595-00139336-00139590": "navigate that that that's the and that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00596-00139591-00139783": "and that that that promise in that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00597-00139784-00139943": "reality is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00598-00139944-00140127": "uh what is our response going to be to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00599-00140128-00140343": "that uh and that and then", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00600-00140344-00140575": "it can be joy can be rejoicing in the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00601-00140576-00140711": "midst of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00602-00140712-00140943": "in the midst of what we're experiencing", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00603-00140944-00141159": "and i think also see i am making all", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00604-00141160-00141302": "things new", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00605-00141303-00141519": "i find that to be really", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00606-00141520-00141663": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00607-00141664-00141831": "really", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00608-00141832-00141983": "inviting", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00609-00141984-00142254": "in that uh there's a promise in that too", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00610-00142255-00142399": "that i think some people might need to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00611-00142400-00142502": "hear", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00612-00142503-00142671": "where uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00613-00142672-00142887": "where", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00614-00142888-00143095": "are we looking for that newness even in", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00615-00143096-00143351": "the midst of what we're experiencing now", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00616-00143352-00143607": "uh are we are we do we have a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00617-00143608-00143863": "perspective of fear and foreboding uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00618-00143864-00144039": "that the sky is falling sort of the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00619-00144040-00144199": "chicken little syndrome", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00620-00144200-00144471": "uh and not to discount that truth in", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00621-00144472-00144631": "that reality but", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00622-00144632-00144814": "uh but are we looking for the newness of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00623-00144815-00145031": "god do we have that perspective that god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00624-00145032-00145135": "might be", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00625-00145136-00145463": "up to something uh something new", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00626-00145464-00145743": "uh not not not that the trauma will go", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00627-00145744-00146023": "away that's i think that's an important", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00628-00146024-00146278": "aspect that uh shelley rambo says there", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00629-00146279-00146447": "is no going back to life before the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00630-00146448-00146559": "storm", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00631-00146560-00146902": "uh but but part of the christian promise", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00632-00146903-00147119": "of reality is there is no going back to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00633-00147120-00147478": "life uh before an empty tomb", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00634-00147479-00147790": "and but that but that empty tomb remains", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00635-00147791-00147926": "in our present", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00636-00147927-00148014": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00637-00148015-00148343": "and uh and so i i guess part of where i", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00638-00148344-00148511": "would go with the sermon on revelation", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00639-00148512-00148583": "is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00640-00148584-00148854": "is thinking about some of those", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00641-00148855-00149119": "some of those truths that this text is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00642-00149120-00149399": "promising", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00643-00149400-00149799": "in this idea also of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00644-00149800-00150095": "this is not something that is", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00645-00150096-00150311": "in the pot in the sky", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00646-00150312-00150447": "by and by", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00647-00150448-00150878": "um i i'm struck by verse two um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00648-00150879-00150975": "that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00649-00150976-00151326": "uh the new jerusalem comes down", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00650-00151327-00151511": "out of heaven", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00651-00151512-00151831": "so often when i was taught to think", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00652-00151832-00152119": "about the presence of god in the promise", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00653-00152120-00152535": "of of you know death no more", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00654-00152536-00152943": "of us being in full community it was", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00655-00152944-00153087": "after i die", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00656-00153088-00153311": "somewhere out there", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00657-00153312-00153439": "and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00658-00153440-00153751": "this text actually points to the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00659-00153752-00153911": "foretaste", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00660-00153912-00154375": "of when christ returns and it's here and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00661-00154376-00154471": "now", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00662-00154472-00154790": "uh just as we talked about the communion", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00663-00154791-00155166": "meal uh is is a foretaste of the feast", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00664-00155167-00155366": "the banquet that we're actually singing", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00665-00155367-00155471": "about", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00666-00155472-00155566": "uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00667-00155567-00155902": "how how do we live out", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00668-00155903-00156087": "practices", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00669-00156088-00156311": "today here and now in the communities", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00670-00156312-00156599": "where we are where people experience a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00671-00156600-00156790": "glimpse of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00672-00156791-00157311": "of of community a glimpse of um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00673-00157312-00157678": "relief from sorrow a glimpse of", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00674-00157679-00157854": "of uh", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00675-00157855-00158151": "removal of pain", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00676-00158152-00158454": "the capacity to laugh in the in the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00677-00158455-00158775": "midst of of sadness", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00678-00158776-00158999": "every time that happens we get a glimpse", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00679-00159000-00159207": "of god we get a glimpse of god's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00680-00159208-00159390": "intention for the world", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00681-00159391-00159695": "and uh dean trulier a harold dean", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00682-00159696-00160078": "trulier preached a sermon that i stole", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00683-00160079-00160399": "for him stole from him with permission", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00684-00160400-00160583": "though i'm sure he doesn't remember that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00685-00160584-00160726": "i asked but", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00686-00160727-00160966": "i've just given a shout out here where", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00687-00160967-00161254": "he talks about the kingdom of heaven not", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00688-00161255-00161471": "being ready yet", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00689-00161472-00161919": "and so we have this foretaste every time", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00690-00161920-00162271": "we experience community here on earth", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00691-00162272-00162478": "that heaven comes down", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00692-00162479-00162799": "and he ends it by saying this is why we", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00693-00162800-00163126": "sing blessed assurance", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00694-00163127-00163439": "jesus is mine oh what a", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00695-00163440-00163614": "foretaste", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00696-00163615-00164014": "and he uses this image of baking a cake", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00697-00164015-00164271": "and how great it is at least when i was", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00698-00164272-00164511": "a kid to um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00699-00164512-00164671": "to um", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00700-00164672-00164847": "you can't do this now because it's not", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00701-00164848-00165038": "safe but to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00702-00165039-00165271": "to eat the dough while you're waiting", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00703-00165272-00165454": "for the cake to bake", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00704-00165455-00165743": "and that that sometimes it's it's better", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00705-00165744-00166063": "to sometimes kids wait to eat that dough", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00706-00166064-00166326": "before you know more than eating that", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00707-00166327-00166799": "cake and that for taste that expectation", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00708-00166800-00166999": "i think it's something we lose and", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00709-00167000-00167271": "revelations is that promise", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00710-00167272-00167495": "uh and i just", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00711-00167496-00167719": "hearing him preach that sermon", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00712-00167720-00168007": "changed the way i expect to hear anyone", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00713-00168008-00168254": "preach from revelations and that is to", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00714-00168255-00168343": "say", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00715-00168344-00168647": "where do we see glimpses of the city the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00716-00168648-00168951": "new city here on earth and i think", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00717-00168952-00169366": "that's what jesus did in the tears", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00718-00169367-00169654": "before raising of lazarus i think that's", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00719-00169655-00169895": "what all of the promises of scripture", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00720-00169896-00170111": "are as we wait", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00721-00170112-00170390": "for the coming of the presence of god", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00722-00170391-00170559": "and that's what gives us hope in the", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00723-00170560-00170783": "distractions of the storms and trauma", "MS5WTlN4-Y8-00724-00170784-00171184": "that is our reality now"}}, {"audio_id": "MSFrI8iNhTk", "text": {"MSFrI8iNhTk-00000-00000000-00000214": "howdy howdy my beautiful Capricorn how", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00001-00000215-00000377": "are you doing darling my name is simply", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00002-00000378-00000497": "valka and today I'm going to be getting", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00003-00000498-00000671": "into your weekly tarot reading Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00004-00000672-00000911": "for August so when it comes to consuming", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00005-00000911-00001061": "my tarot readings here today Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00006-00001062-00001235": "let me know in the comments below how my", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00007-00001236-00001391": "readings help you out that's how I keep", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00008-00001392-00001493": "up with you and be sure to give this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00009-00001494-00001667": "video a like And subscribe it helps me", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00010-00001668-00001834": "out Capricorn more than you ever", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00011-00001835-00001991": "possibly could know darling and I really", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00012-00001992-00002134": "appreciate those who take the extra step", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00013-00002135-00002326": "to do that all right and so today", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00014-00002327-00002471": "Capricorn we're going to be getting into", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00015-00002472-00002723": "three rows for you they're our first row", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00016-00002724-00002825": "we're gonna be talking about the person", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00017-00002826-00003016": "that is on your mind right now today", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00018-00003017-00003251": "Capricorn all right and then in your", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00019-00003252-00003365": "second row we're going to be talking", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00020-00003365-00003575": "about what you need to hear today all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00021-00003576-00003833": "right Capricorn and then in your third", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00022-00003834-00004001": "row darling we're going to be getting", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00023-00004002-00004288": "into just your predictions uh today if", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00024-00004289-00004463": "you continue down the same path that you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00025-00004464-00004649": "have been going Capricorn I can make", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00026-00004650-00004781": "some pretty solid predictions about", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00027-00004782-00004943": "what's going to be happening for you all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00028-00004944-00005081": "right because the future is never solid", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00029-00005082-00005249": "but if you continue down this path I'll", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00030-00005250-00005506": "tell you what's up honey so", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00031-00005507-00005741": "back of the deck energy here is the two", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00032-00005742-00005933": "of Swords Capricorn all right be sure", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00033-00005934-00006077": "when it comes to consuming tear readings", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00034-00006078-00006227": "today as well that you do more than just", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00035-00006228-00006370": "your one zodiac sign check out your Sun", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00036-00006371-00006496": "Moon Rising as well as your Venus", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00037-00006497-00006725": "styling all right so to a swords coming", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00038-00006726-00006923": "in here for you Capricorn back of the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00039-00006923-00007228": "deck energy for you all right I see this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00040-00007229-00007492": "sensor just like Winds of Change here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00041-00007493-00007673": "all right Winds of Change what is that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00042-00007673-00007864": "you and meeting Spirits here Winds of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00043-00007865-00008069": "Change you're going to be having some", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00044-00008070-00008321": "opportunity to really switch things up", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00045-00008322-00008542": "in your life here all right I want to be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00046-00008543-00008753": "saying for some of you Capricorns some", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00047-00008754-00008885": "of you guys might want might want to", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00048-00008886-00009023": "just like prepare your bags they", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00049-00009024-00009251": "pre-pack your bags right now", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00050-00009252-00009424": "because I get like the sense of just", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00051-00009425-00009677": "like the sudden move like a sudden", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00052-00009678-00009796": "vacation I don't know if some of you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00053-00009797-00009995": "guys get like this urge to just like or", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00054-00009996-00010163": "like an opportunity comes forward where", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00055-00010164-00010337": "you can do like a last minute like road", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00056-00010338-00010546": "trip somewhere or maybe moving like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00057-00010547-00010678": "environments or something like that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00058-00010679-00010864": "living environments or what have you but", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00059-00010865-00011033": "I do get like this sense of like because", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00060-00011034-00011195": "I am being shown like the suitcase still", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00061-00011196-00011399": "consistently like yeah it's like the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00062-00011400-00011585": "sense of like movement is really going", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00063-00011586-00011764": "to be happening here all right for some", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00064-00011765-00011969": "of you guys uh Capricorn is going to be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00065-00011970-00012160": "uh plucking you from one place I wanted", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00066-00012161-00012359": "to say Virgo because I feel like uh", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00067-00012360-00012569": "because Virgo had like a Sim like this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00068-00012570-00012785": "what Virgo has been craving you're", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00069-00012786-00013024": "experiencing essentially Capricorns so", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00070-00013025-00013211": "you can go rub it into Virgo's face", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00071-00013212-00013486": "essentially here but like you're going", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00072-00013487-00013799": "to be having the movements that you've", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00073-00013800-00014027": "been craving here all right some people", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00074-00014028-00014158": "would say this as like a breakthrough", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00075-00014159-00014369": "necessarily I don't I feel like this is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00076-00014369-00014572": "like a sense of like going on like a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00077-00014573-00014866": "side quest here essentially Virgo now", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00078-00014868-00015065": "there's that Virgo essentially here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00079-00015066-00015244": "Capricorn all right but what happens", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00080-00015245-00015430": "left I mean Ace of Pentacles comes in", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00081-00015431-00015575": "right afterwards it's like whatever", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00082-00015576-00015785": "switches up this is like an exciting new", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00083-00015786-00016097": "thing that pops up for you very what is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00084-00016097-00016385": "the word it's not eccentric sporadic is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00085-00016386-00016589": "not the word a spur of the moment all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00086-00016590-00016739": "right very spur of the moment here for", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00087-00016740-00016961": "you Capricorn but once it presents", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00088-00016962-00017207": "itself pays off big time for you all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00089-00017208-00017441": "right so I really like this a lot for", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00090-00017442-00017525": "you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00091-00017526-00017693": "we're going to be keeping this two of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00092-00017694-00017927": "Swords here Capricorn for all three rows", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00093-00017928-00018064": "here because that's what it's going to", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00094-00018065-00018214": "be influencing so", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00095-00018215-00018430": "keep that in mind darling all right so", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00096-00018431-00018557": "getting into your first row today", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00097-00018558-00018677": "Capricorn we're going to be talking", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00098-00018678-00018821": "about the person that's on your mind", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00099-00018822-00019103": "right now all right which happens to be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00100-00019104-00019319": "king of Wands Knight of Pentacles in the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00101-00019320-00019530": "king of Cups all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00102-00019531-00019858": "oh all right it's two stubborn people", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00103-00019859-00020158": "darling having a stare down mirroring", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00104-00020159-00020458": "each other here Capricorn all right I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00105-00020459-00020663": "feel like someone has met their match", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00106-00020664-00020836": "here all right I feel like for you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00107-00020837-00021047": "Capricorn you're educating someone on", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00108-00021048-00021335": "just who a Capricorn actually is darling", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00109-00021336-00021461": "all right some of you guys you have to", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00110-00021462-00021635": "remind them who the heck you actually", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00111-00021636-00021803": "are because they must have forgotten", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00112-00021804-00022000": "Capricorn that's the immediate thing", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00113-00022001-00022139": "that I see with this it's just like you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00114-00022140-00022289": "must not know about me either like you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00115-00022290-00022457": "must not really know how stubborn I can", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00116-00022458-00022727": "be all right someone's challenging you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00117-00022728-00023021": "you hear Capricorn I wanna I kind of get", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00118-00023022-00023194": "like this message here where it's just", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00119-00023195-00023321": "like they want to see if you're like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00120-00023322-00023633": "who's gonna like break first all right I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00121-00023634-00023783": "don't know what's going on here I feel", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00122-00023784-00024022": "like this unspoken tension that might be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00123-00024023-00024119": "something that you're going through as", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00124-00024120-00024244": "well Capricorn is where it's just like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00125-00024245-00024467": "this unexplainable just being like why", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00126-00024468-00024611": "are you acting like this why are you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00127-00024612-00024767": "feeling like this or doing this right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00128-00024768-00024922": "why are you saying these things because", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00129-00024923-00025067": "I feel like you're just really confused", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00130-00025068-00025180": "about this but at the same time", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00131-00025181-00025313": "Capricorn you're just like all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00132-00025314-00025457": "darling if you want to be switching it", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00133-00025458-00025643": "up with me honey you can switch it up", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00134-00025644-00025912": "with me all right you'll you'll respond", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00135-00025913-00026177": "now and ask questions later if you care", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00136-00026177-00026345": "enough to but right now you're just like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00137-00026345-00026446": "all right darling I don't know why", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00138-00026447-00026602": "you're switching up but I'll respond to", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00139-00026604-00026855": "it accordingly darling all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00140-00026856-00027112": "um and correct the situation all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00141-00027113-00027301": "because I get like the sense of like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00142-00027302-00027520": "almost like the sense of you want to put", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00143-00027522-00027677": "someone in their place make them realize", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00144-00027677-00027899": "like who they actually are here all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00145-00027900-00028133": "right Knight of Pentacles there I feel", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00146-00028133-00028235": "like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00147-00028236-00028433": "um eventually here there's the stare", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00148-00028433-00028673": "down is going to end all right someone", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00149-00028674-00028858": "is going to to break the silence or", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00150-00028860-00029111": "break off this stare down so let's", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00151-00029112-00029314": "expound on this more", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00152-00029316-00029561": "High Priestess energy here all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00153-00029562-00029777": "spiritually practicing either you or", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00154-00029777-00030035": "this person here Taurus all right what I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00155-00030036-00030190": "want to be just suggesting is like a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00156-00030191-00030311": "side note", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00157-00030312-00030490": "um why did I just call you Taurus now", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00158-00030491-00030683": "I'm calling you every single zodiac sign", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00159-00030683-00030917": "I apologize Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00160-00030918-00031079": "um but I wanted what I want to be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00161-00031080-00031211": "actually saying here with that high", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00162-00031212-00031529": "priestess Capricorn is just be keep like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00163-00031530-00031720": "an evil eye on you or just like some", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00164-00031722-00031973": "black tourmaline on you as well you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00165-00031974-00032135": "might be noticing them in your dreams or", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00166-00032136-00032308": "what have you I don't know I get like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00167-00032310-00032452": "this sense of just like spiritual", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00168-00032453-00032651": "influence all right I usually don't get", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00169-00032652-00032824": "something like that but I do get like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00170-00032825-00032962": "that sense of like spiritual influence", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00171-00032963-00033083": "you might need to just find yourself", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00172-00033084-00033251": "needing to just like burn some Sage", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00173-00033252-00033539": "drilling all right of their energy", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00174-00033540-00033671": "all right because I don't know if this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00175-00033672-00033833": "person is like outright trying to do", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00176-00033834-00034049": "something like that there but you know", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00177-00034050-00034283": "better safe than sorry four of Wands", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00178-00034284-00034468": "coming back in here all right so this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00179-00034469-00034631": "lets me know that y'all will find each", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00180-00034632-00034799": "other again all right this you know", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00181-00034800-00034973": "y'all having to stare down right now I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00182-00034974-00035129": "don't know what caused this is none of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00183-00035130-00035440": "my business of course here Capricorn but", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00184-00035441-00035746": "what I can tell you is that whatever at", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00185-00035747-00035885": "the end of the day y'all will end up", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00186-00035886-00036089": "finding each other y'all will end up", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00187-00036090-00036293": "yeah y'all will be good two of Cups here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00188-00036294-00036509": "y'all will be good are y'all family is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00189-00036510-00036743": "this like family Dynamic Capricorn or is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00190-00036744-00036923": "this like a best friend this is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00191-00036924-00037223": "definitely someone like I don't know", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00192-00037224-00037462": "like I get the even though you had that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00193-00037463-00037667": "king of Cups and the wands and they're", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00194-00037668-00037829": "technically you know Fire and Water", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00195-00037830-00038057": "Energy so they're technically", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00196-00038058-00038273": "um the opposite", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00197-00038274-00038477": "but I get like this sense here Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00198-00038478-00038680": "or where it's just like you know this is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00199-00038681-00038855": "like someone that you have in your life", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00200-00038856-00038962": "and you're just like you know what bless", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00201-00038963-00039161": "your heart sometimes your thoughts get", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00202-00039162-00039323": "in their way and then they get the best", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00203-00039324-00039418": "of them and then they start", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00204-00039419-00039611": "self-sabotaging what have you all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00205-00039612-00039712": "I don't know that's what I see here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00206-00039713-00040055": "Capricorn it's like the sense of like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00207-00040056-00040246": "I'm being shown like a minion now what", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00208-00040247-00040462": "does that mean it's like you're you're", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00209-00040463-00040639": "watching someone be self-destructive", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00210-00040640-00040912": "Capricorn you realize it's not about you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00211-00040913-00041099": "you're realizing it's all them you're", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00212-00041100-00041327": "watching them be self-destructive and I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00213-00041328-00041458": "feel like for you you're just like all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00214-00041459-00041651": "right darling you do that over there I'm", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00215-00041652-00041927": "not engaging with this all right I'm not", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00216-00041928-00042130": "going to allow you to lure me into that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00217-00042131-00042418": "but yes but when the time comes if you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00218-00042419-00042521": "need to correct it you're going to", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00219-00042522-00042785": "correct it and when the time comes I do", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00220-00042786-00042935": "hear like the sense of like you're", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00221-00042936-00043240": "expecting like you I hear like it's like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00222-00043241-00043445": "there's some explaining to do but I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00223-00043446-00043577": "still get the sense of like y'all still", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00224-00043578-00043774": "gonna be talking at some point in time I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00225-00043775-00043955": "don't know how y'all end up talking but", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00226-00043956-00044087": "I do definitely feel like y'all gonna be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00227-00044088-00044315": "talking all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00228-00044316-00044645": "so let's get into now these cards are", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00229-00044646-00044867": "sticking on to me Capricorn uh let's get", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00230-00044868-00045149": "into now uh what you need to hear today", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00231-00045150-00045329": "all right Capricorn what do you all need", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00232-00045330-00045580": "to hear today you have the sun eight of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00233-00045581-00045874": "Pentacles as well as the emperor energy", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00234-00045875-00046067": "all right what you need to hear right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00235-00046068-00046474": "now Capricorn is that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00236-00046475-00046690": "I mean for one this is gonna be a corny", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00237-00046691-00046889": "message here but it's gonna be working", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00238-00046890-00047158": "out here for you all right first thing I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00239-00047159-00047333": "say want to be acknowledging though is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00240-00047334-00047543": "with the semper Synergy or not Empress", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00241-00047544-00047935": "this Emperor energy no doll", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00242-00047936-00048330": "this Emperor energy Capricorn all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00243-00048331-00048635": "I really feel like for you everything", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00244-00048636-00048839": "that's happening to you right now you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00245-00048840-00049079": "excuse me you may have been feeling like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00246-00049080-00049258": "everyone and everything has been pushing", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00247-00049259-00049558": "your buttons and I mean the reason why", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00248-00049559-00049739": "you feel that way is because it has here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00249-00049740-00049936": "at Capricorn all right I feel like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00250-00049937-00050093": "you're really being pushed to this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00251-00050094-00050290": "Emperor all right you're everyone and", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00252-00050291-00050501": "everything is like pushing you to show", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00253-00050502-00050686": "your Emperor face where you're just like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00254-00050687-00050921": "let me remind you who I actually am here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00255-00050922-00051167": "all right Capricorn and it's in this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00256-00051168-00051370": "sense a year it's just like again I get", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00257-00051371-00051580": "like developments here I get things", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00258-00051582-00051850": "needing to like certain showdowns or", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00259-00051851-00052007": "certain stair-offs needed to happen", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00260-00052008-00052187": "certain confrontations needed to happen", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00261-00052188-00052426": "Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00262-00052427-00052619": "um because the path that y'all have been", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00263-00052620-00052888": "going down up until this point I feel", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00264-00052889-00053026": "like just wasn't feeling good for you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00265-00053027-00053291": "all right and so I feel like there did", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00266-00053291-00053507": "need to be like this confrontation or", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00267-00053508-00053704": "just this acknowledgment Capricorn of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00268-00053705-00053842": "Lair where you were just saying it's", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00269-00053844-00053957": "like all right something's not working", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00270-00053958-00054257": "out here all right and change is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00271-00054258-00054407": "inevitable but I feel like that change", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00272-00054408-00054569": "comes into the sense of like I don't", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00273-00054570-00054682": "know I still get the sense of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00274-00054683-00054880": "Confrontation or at the very least you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00275-00054882-00055025": "acknowledging Capricorn certain", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00276-00055026-00055187": "behaviors or certain things that you're", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00277-00055188-00055300": "just like uh", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00278-00055301-00055494": "all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00279-00055495-00055769": "clarifying this row here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00280-00055770-00056129": "let's take a look", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00281-00056129-00056423": "eight of Wands as I said here Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00282-00056424-00056573": "I feel like there's going to be a lot of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00283-00056574-00056891": "movement for you all right again I get", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00284-00056891-00057035": "like this sense for you some of you guys", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00285-00057036-00057244": "might be moving here in the coming days", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00286-00057245-00057515": "here and I feel like it's unexpected all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00287-00057516-00057665": "right I feel like whatever movement", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00288-00057666-00057880": "happens it's very last minute very", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00289-00057882-00058175": "unexpected hermit energy with the Two of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00290-00058176-00058480": "Wands here very last minute energy here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00291-00058482-00058744": "but it's really important that you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00292-00058745-00058888": "um get out of your shell this week", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00293-00058889-00059026": "Capricorn I feel like it's really", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00294-00059027-00059357": "important for you to be adventurous at", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00295-00059358-00059591": "this time here all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00296-00059591-00059794": "there is like this sense here Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00297-00059795-00060029": "where it's just like by putting", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00298-00060029-00060287": "something into the Forefront uh in your", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00299-00060288-00060556": "life here it helps you out in the long", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00300-00060557-00060754": "term so in regards to like social life", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00301-00060755-00061013": "here all right uh socially you might be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00302-00061014-00061138": "getting like a random last minute", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00303-00061139-00061379": "invitation to go out somewhere Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00304-00061379-00061456": "I feel like it would be really", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00305-00061457-00061666": "invaluable to do that for others of you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00306-00061667-00061835": "in a social way this is like a sense of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00307-00061836-00061954": "where you speak your truth about a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00308-00061955-00062129": "situation someone that you haven't been", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00309-00062129-00062279": "talking to in a little bit because you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00310-00062279-00062380": "were just like let me put my space", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00311-00062382-00062573": "between myself and them here I feel like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00312-00062574-00062747": "by you addressing the situation and", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00313-00062748-00062909": "being like hey like this needs to change", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00314-00062910-00063100": "here all right I feel like that's what", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00315-00063101-00063335": "causes like progression to finally", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00316-00063336-00063532": "happen where things were initially", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00317-00063533-00063850": "feeling pretty stale all right Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00318-00063851-00064559": "so let's get into your oracle cards now", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00319-00064560-00064894": "all right so you guys have number 44 all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00320-00064895-00065153": "right equaling to eight in numerology so", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00321-00065154-00065273": "go ahead and look up the number eight", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00322-00065274-00065471": "for me uh", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00323-00065472-00065669": "Capricorn to see how that resonates also", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00324-00065670-00065897": "the day of me uploading this here is", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00325-00065898-00066106": "going to be officially what people", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00326-00066107-00066431": "officially call the Lions portal the 888", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00327-00066432-00066593": "right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00328-00066594-00066832": "um or 888 in the sense of August 8th the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00329-00066833-00067013": "for 8th of the month what have you all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00330-00067014-00067150": "right so eight is definitely following", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00331-00067151-00067331": "you here I would definitely suggest for", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00332-00067332-00067426": "you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00333-00067427-00067703": "Capricorn to really utilize Today's", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00334-00067704-00067979": "Energy for whatever it is that you're", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00335-00067980-00068182": "trying to create all right because the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00336-00068183-00068369": "eight is aligned with you guys so this", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00337-00068370-00068621": "is pretty this is pretty insane like and", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00338-00068622-00068765": "I would even say this is like really", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00339-00068766-00068873": "like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00340-00068874-00069082": "I feel bad for the Capricorns that are", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00341-00069083-00069244": "not going to be seeing this reading on", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00342-00069245-00069587": "the day of uh the eighth because", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00343-00069588-00069755": "um eight is seemingly really powerful", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00344-00069756-00069917": "here it's all you know the lion Gates", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00345-00069918-00070055": "portal it's called the portal I don't", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00346-00070056-00070282": "really really know why personally but", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00347-00070283-00070397": "even here there's the portal there", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00348-00070398-00070619": "Capricorn so it's just like it's like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00349-00070620-00070859": "this is really like unexpectedly like a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00350-00070860-00071062": "important spiritual message for some", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00351-00071063-00071182": "folks", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00352-00071183-00071447": "all right Moon Oracle hard coming in", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00353-00071448-00071693": "here new moon in Sagittarius focusing in", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00354-00071694-00072035": "on the positive here uh Capricorn all", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00355-00072036-00072226": "right and also with that perfect storm I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00356-00072227-00072353": "never even talked about this here The", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00357-00072354-00072544": "Perfect Storm Having the courage to step", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00358-00072545-00072773": "into life here Having the courage to", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00359-00072774-00072971": "step into life here and focusing in on", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00360-00072972-00073132": "the positive for many of you guys", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00361-00073133-00073282": "Capricorn you're separating yourself", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00362-00073283-00073462": "from a lot of people and energies that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00363-00073463-00073594": "have just been making you feel down", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00364-00073595-00073775": "about yourself these people they may", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00365-00073776-00073967": "just bring forth like a lot of Dramas a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00366-00073968-00074087": "lot of stress in your life here at", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00367-00074088-00074291": "Capricorn and I feel like for you you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00368-00074292-00074465": "need to be the one to just you know", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00369-00074466-00074656": "speak from that megaphone and be like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00370-00074657-00074981": "hey fix your essentially Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00371-00074982-00075155": "that's what I hear it's like the sense", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00372-00075156-00075371": "of you just being like you know like act", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00373-00075372-00075575": "right starting up", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00374-00075576-00075803": "you have a cardinal card coming in here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00375-00075804-00075965": "this might have some this I feel like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00376-00075966-00076121": "this popped up for you we just super", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00377-00076122-00076355": "recently Capricorn as well all right the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00378-00076356-00076559": "Cardinal card I always say is it has", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00379-00076560-00076769": "usually some spiritual significance for", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00380-00076770-00076991": "somebody all right the polarities of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00381-00076992-00077129": "your spiritual Pursuits and physical", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00382-00077130-00077332": "Pleasures are out of balance so do", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00383-00077333-00077506": "whatever it is you need to do Capricorn", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00384-00077507-00077699": "to bring them back into a equal", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00385-00077700-00077987": "equilibrium oh my goodness theorem", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00386-00077988-00078161": "for some of you Capricorns I feel like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00387-00078162-00078355": "there's like this message here of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00388-00078356-00078617": "remembering you might be getting", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00389-00078618-00078875": "thoughts of like um move past on loved", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00390-00078876-00078988": "one that you haven't thought about in a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00391-00078989-00079085": "long time", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00392-00079086-00079276": "especially pets I don't know why I got", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00393-00079277-00079432": "that like especially pets you might be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00394-00079433-00079547": "dreaming of like a pet you haven't", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00395-00079548-00079762": "thought of in a long time but also", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00396-00079763-00080050": "Capricorn you might be feel I get like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00397-00080051-00080165": "this and some of you guys are feeling", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00398-00080166-00080332": "really isolated or feeling feeling", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00399-00080333-00080567": "really alone right now some of you guys", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00400-00080568-00080837": "might have felt as if you lost your way", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00401-00080838-00081005": "because you've been spending so much", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00402-00081006-00081215": "time fighting to survive that is just", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00403-00081216-00081382": "like I don't know you feel like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00404-00081383-00081532": "everything has lost some of you guys", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00405-00081533-00081682": "might be hitting like a rock bottom or", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00406-00081683-00081881": "what you feel like is a rock bottom uh", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00407-00081882-00082049": "Capricorn and what I want to be telling", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00408-00082050-00082217": "you is that there is some type of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00409-00082218-00082487": "spiritual Force trying to make its", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00410-00082488-00082679": "appearance into your life all right so", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00411-00082680-00082817": "let's get into your predictions here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00412-00082818-00083021": "today Capricorn all right you have the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00413-00083022-00083267": "Ace of Swords Two of Pentacles with that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00414-00083268-00083411": "Empress energy there's this Empress", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00415-00083412-00083555": "darling that I was talking about so much", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00416-00083556-00083909": "that I kept on uh calling the emperor", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00417-00083910-00084017": "here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00418-00084018-00084238": "uh what I see happening for you here", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00419-00084239-00084599": "Capricorn is honestly", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00420-00084600-00084838": "in the coming days for you guys I see", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00421-00084839-00085055": "inspiration I see your creative juices", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00422-00085056-00085193": "flowing some of you guys might have been", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00423-00085194-00085318": "going through like a writer's block", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00424-00085319-00085523": "Capricorn that's gonna be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00425-00085524-00085691": "um you're gonna be overcoming that but I", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00426-00085692-00085811": "feel like it's through some type of", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00427-00085812-00086015": "travel that that writer's block or that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00428-00086016-00086159": "block in general", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00429-00086160-00086362": "uh fixes itself", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00430-00086363-00086518": "for some of you Capricorns I know it", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00431-00086519-00086699": "might sound really weird but some of you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00432-00086700-00086818": "guys might be experiencing like a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00433-00086819-00086968": "financial block or just whatever you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00434-00086969-00087203": "whatever block that you want to describe", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00435-00087204-00087382": "it as darling", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00436-00087383-00087706": "um I feel as if like as weird as it", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00437-00087707-00087809": "sounds you might be going through that", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00438-00087810-00087976": "Financial block but you know spending", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00439-00087977-00088156": "money on like a little mini vacation", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00440-00088157-00088349": "even if it's just like at a hotel like a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00441-00088350-00088523": "staycation of a hotel near you for a", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00442-00088524-00088667": "couple days I don't know I feel like", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00443-00088668-00088876": "there is like this sense of importance", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00444-00088877-00089081": "for you to separate yourself from your", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00445-00089082-00089212": "current environment to getting you out", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00446-00089213-00089453": "of that hermit energy there all right", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00447-00089454-00089729": "into new energy I see though in the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00448-00089730-00089825": "coming days that you're going to be", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00449-00089826-00090094": "really busy really really busy", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00450-00090095-00090221": "um through inspiration though because", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00451-00090222-00090353": "again I keep on hearing that creative", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00452-00090354-00090568": "juices are flowing so", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00453-00090569-00090755": "all right Capricorn I love you so much", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00454-00090756-00090875": "darling hopefully this story reading", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00455-00090876-00091000": "gave you some resonance gave you some", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00456-00091001-00091187": "sense of clarity today all right if it", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00457-00091188-00091294": "did let me know in the comments below", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00458-00091295-00091432": "give this video a like And subscribe", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00459-00091433-00091618": "Capricorn and remember darling if you", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00460-00091619-00091726": "want to book a reading with me simply", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00461-00091727-00091837": "welcome", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00462-00091838-00092021": "linked down below next to my social", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00463-00092022-00092147": "medias Tick Tock Instagram and Facebook", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00464-00092148-00092291": "all of them just being simply Volcan", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00465-00092292-00092435": "dialing all right until next time the", "MSFrI8iNhTk-00466-00092436-00092886": "Khalil Capricorn I love you so much bye"}}, {"audio_id": "MSLO5etyKG4", "text": {"MSLO5etyKG4-00000-00000016-00000214": "what's up ladies and gentlemen boys and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00001-00000215-00000415": "girls jesse warden here", "MSLO5etyKG4-00002-00000416-00000519": "today we're going to talk about", "MSLO5etyKG4-00003-00000520-00000767": "providing a public api", "MSLO5etyKG4-00004-00000768-00001023": "to javascript developers from rescript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00005-00001024-00001174": "and there's a lot of interesting", "MSLO5etyKG4-00006-00001175-00001295": "challenges", "MSLO5etyKG4-00007-00001296-00001439": "in doing that and we're going to cover", "MSLO5etyKG4-00008-00001440-00001614": "the aspects some strategies you can fix", "MSLO5etyKG4-00009-00001616-00001710": "that today", "MSLO5etyKG4-00010-00001711-00001902": "namely around using a single", "MSLO5etyKG4-00011-00001903-00002071": "configuration object", "MSLO5etyKG4-00012-00002072-00002318": "to inspect it and solve a lot of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00013-00002319-00002518": "problems that javascript developers have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00014-00002519-00002726": "and in turn it allows us to inspect it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00015-00002727-00002895": "with strong types and rescript so we", "MSLO5etyKG4-00016-00002896-00003102": "still retain our strong typing abilities", "MSLO5etyKG4-00017-00003103-00003238": "but can speak in a language that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00018-00003239-00003422": "javascript developers by returning", "MSLO5etyKG4-00019-00003423-00003584": "exceptions to them in a promise", "MSLO5etyKG4-00020-00003585-00003806": "[Music]", "MSLO5etyKG4-00021-00003807-00004047": "you've developed a rescript library and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00022-00004047-00004167": "the reason you like rescript over", "MSLO5etyKG4-00023-00004168-00004343": "typescript is that you don't have no", "MSLO5etyKG4-00024-00004344-00004415": "pointers", "MSLO5etyKG4-00025-00004416-00004615": "you don't have runtime errors and you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00026-00004616-00004775": "just feel really happy with", "MSLO5etyKG4-00027-00004776-00005231": "what you've done so you go to compile it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00028-00005232-00005383": "and it comes pretty quick you feel good", "MSLO5etyKG4-00029-00005384-00005567": "so you're like alright cool so it's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00030-00005568-00005775": "got a javascript conversion of this so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00031-00005776-00006018": "demo rs will compile to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00032-00006019-00006222": "demo.bs.js and so that's what the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00033-00006223-00006383": "javascript developers consume", "MSLO5etyKG4-00034-00006384-00006503": "so you hand it to the javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00035-00006504-00006710": "developer and they go cool so they go to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00036-00006711-00006934": "test it using their sandbox", "MSLO5etyKG4-00037-00006936-00007151": "and already they have a problem now", "MSLO5etyKG4-00038-00007152-00007310": "errors runtime errors are okay in a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00039-00007311-00007455": "promise perspective because that's the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00040-00007456-00007639": "interface of the promise right is that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00041-00007640-00007798": "it'll be resolved with the value or", "MSLO5etyKG4-00042-00007800-00007998": "it'll resolve with an error the issue", "MSLO5etyKG4-00043-00008000-00008174": "is that this particular error isn't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00044-00008175-00008351": "yours this is something to do with node", "MSLO5etyKG4-00045-00008352-00008446": "fetch which means they", "MSLO5etyKG4-00046-00008447-00008695": "foobart a url somehow it doesn't really", "MSLO5etyKG4-00047-00008696-00008823": "make any sense because you've tested", "MSLO5etyKG4-00048-00008824-00008942": "this with property tests and you're a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00049-00008943-00009095": "little confused how this could possibly", "MSLO5etyKG4-00050-00009096-00009183": "happen", "MSLO5etyKG4-00051-00009184-00009351": "so all bets are off suddenly you're", "MSLO5etyKG4-00052-00009352-00009495": "getting errors that you're not expecting", "MSLO5etyKG4-00053-00009496-00009606": "and that's really frustrating because", "MSLO5etyKG4-00054-00009607-00009727": "the whole point of using rescript is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00055-00009728-00009799": "that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00056-00009800-00009919": "you know those problems go away right", "MSLO5etyKG4-00057-00009920-00010183": "but again javascript is calling rescript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00058-00010184-00010359": "so javascript has no types", "MSLO5etyKG4-00059-00010360-00010623": "has no enforcement of order of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00060-00010624-00010838": "parameters and all this other stuff", "MSLO5etyKG4-00061-00010839-00010983": "so you're a little frustrated so you say", "MSLO5etyKG4-00062-00010984-00011199": "what you would say to any coder that has", "MSLO5etyKG4-00063-00011200-00011359": "problems with code you gave me like just", "MSLO5etyKG4-00064-00011360-00011567": "show me your code so you open up their", "MSLO5etyKG4-00065-00011568-00011638": "code", "MSLO5etyKG4-00066-00011639-00011903": "and take a look and immediately you can", "MSLO5etyKG4-00067-00011904-00011942": "see", "MSLO5etyKG4-00068-00011943-00012255": "three problems the first is that their", "MSLO5etyKG4-00069-00012256-00012542": "id is first and the password is second", "MSLO5etyKG4-00070-00012543-00012663": "you can tell because most ids are", "MSLO5etyKG4-00071-00012664-00012807": "numbers and passwords are like", "MSLO5etyKG4-00072-00012808-00012974": "you know some text and they're in the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00073-00012975-00013183": "wrong order it's supposed to be", "MSLO5etyKG4-00074-00013184-00013358": "password first so if you go audit and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00075-00013359-00013575": "look at the code hint password first id", "MSLO5etyKG4-00076-00013576-00013719": "second host third so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00077-00013719-00013871": "that's problem number one problem number", "MSLO5etyKG4-00078-00013872-00014071": "two is that the types are wrong which", "MSLO5etyKG4-00079-00014072-00014351": "further confuses things maybe right is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00080-00014352-00014422": "that this is an", "MSLO5etyKG4-00081-00014423-00014599": "integer first instead of a string and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00082-00014600-00014766": "this is a string instead of an integer", "MSLO5etyKG4-00083-00014768-00014855": "second", "MSLO5etyKG4-00084-00014856-00015127": "so you may get some weird problems or", "MSLO5etyKG4-00085-00015128-00015222": "the worse", "MSLO5etyKG4-00086-00015223-00015471": "no problems such as concat or length", "MSLO5etyKG4-00087-00015472-00015615": "because string and numbers can both do", "MSLO5etyKG4-00088-00015616-00015758": "those kind of things so it's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00089-00015759-00015966": "problematic and then the last third", "MSLO5etyKG4-00090-00015968-00016183": "problem and this is a prob indicative of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00091-00016184-00016279": "javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00092-00016280-00016463": "things like python and lua python", "MSLO5etyKG4-00093-00016464-00016583": "especially get really mad about", "MSLO5etyKG4-00094-00016584-00016743": "functionarity if you have a function", "MSLO5etyKG4-00095-00016744-00016863": "with three parameters", "MSLO5etyKG4-00096-00016864-00017022": "and you only pass two python gets mad at", "MSLO5etyKG4-00097-00017023-00017239": "you and same with a function with three", "MSLO5etyKG4-00098-00017240-00017350": "parameters you pass four", "MSLO5etyKG4-00099-00017351-00017519": "again it throws an error javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00100-00017520-00017735": "doesn't sometimes it'll even work", "MSLO5etyKG4-00101-00017736-00018063": "and sometimes it'll imply undefined for", "MSLO5etyKG4-00102-00018064-00018094": "you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00103-00018095-00018399": "which is not often what you meant to do", "MSLO5etyKG4-00104-00018400-00018639": "right so there's a lot of problems with", "MSLO5etyKG4-00105-00018640-00018775": "using parameters in javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00106-00018776-00019022": "it might not have been intentional right", "MSLO5etyKG4-00107-00019023-00019222": "and that's okay javascript developers", "MSLO5etyKG4-00108-00019223-00019407": "don't have a compiler they don't have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00109-00019408-00019583": "the runtime functionarity and they don't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00110-00019584-00019703": "have any runtime type", "MSLO5etyKG4-00111-00019704-00019886": "type assertions around that kind of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00112-00019887-00020022": "stuff it's not really good", "MSLO5etyKG4-00113-00020023-00020175": "one thing javascript developers have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00114-00020176-00020358": "done to mitigate this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00115-00020359-00020543": "is they they get around too many", "MSLO5etyKG4-00116-00020544-00020686": "parameters and they", "MSLO5etyKG4-00117-00020687-00020886": "create what's called a config object now", "MSLO5etyKG4-00118-00020887-00021030": "there's no agreement on what", "MSLO5etyKG4-00119-00021031-00021271": "too many parameters are is it some will", "MSLO5etyKG4-00120-00021272-00021375": "say 2", "MSLO5etyKG4-00121-00021376-00021622": "right some will say 8 some will say 15", "MSLO5etyKG4-00122-00021623-00021799": "there's no real consensus but", "MSLO5etyKG4-00123-00021800-00021999": "they all agree is that this should be a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00124-00022000-00022127": "single", "MSLO5etyKG4-00125-00022128-00022350": "parameter which is a object right a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00126-00022351-00022494": "javascript object that has", "MSLO5etyKG4-00127-00022495-00022719": "key value pairs for your parameters so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00128-00022720-00022814": "instead of this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00129-00022815-00023158": "they go id password", "MSLO5etyKG4-00130-00023159-00023303": "and then they notice they're missing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00131-00023304-00023703": "host so they go host", "MSLO5etyKG4-00132-00023704-00024047": "now they can't screw up order because", "MSLO5etyKG4-00133-00024048-00024271": "any order that you put the key value", "MSLO5etyKG4-00134-00024272-00024478": "pairs doesn't matter whether you put id", "MSLO5etyKG4-00135-00024479-00024614": "or password first they're all in the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00136-00024615-00024750": "same object and they all have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00137-00024751-00024967": "an id that equals this a password equals", "MSLO5etyKG4-00138-00024968-00025183": "this so order suddenly goes away", "MSLO5etyKG4-00139-00025184-00025430": "type order goes away because the id is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00140-00025431-00025558": "an integer the password", "MSLO5etyKG4-00141-00025559-00025758": "is a string host is a string right so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00142-00025760-00025887": "that goes away", "MSLO5etyKG4-00143-00025888-00026118": "and then lastly there's no parameter", "MSLO5etyKG4-00144-00026119-00026351": "order problems from a number perspective", "MSLO5etyKG4-00145-00026352-00026543": "because there's only ever one", "MSLO5etyKG4-00146-00026544-00026799": "so even if they screw this up right they", "MSLO5etyKG4-00147-00026800-00026967": "pull from some dynamic configuration for", "MSLO5etyKG4-00148-00026968-00027207": "example or they misspell a variable name", "MSLO5etyKG4-00149-00027208-00027431": "javascript is going to imply undefined", "MSLO5etyKG4-00150-00027432-00027599": "anyway this is a single parameter", "MSLO5etyKG4-00151-00027600-00027814": "because javascript right so it solves a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00152-00027816-00027911": "lot of problems", "MSLO5etyKG4-00153-00027912-00028007": "doing this this is kind of why", "MSLO5etyKG4-00154-00028008-00028174": "javascript developers have kind of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00155-00028175-00028295": "adopted this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00156-00028295-00028479": "but this has a lot of advantages for the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00157-00028480-00028646": "rescript developer because these", "MSLO5etyKG4-00158-00028647-00028887": "objects and these individual properties", "MSLO5etyKG4-00159-00028888-00029039": "can be type checked", "MSLO5etyKG4-00160-00029039-00029295": "using the rescript javascript types now", "MSLO5etyKG4-00161-00029295-00029446": "you can't really depend on javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00162-00029447-00029614": "right javascript's still throwing you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00163-00029616-00029783": "stuff that you can't have a type for", "MSLO5etyKG4-00164-00029783-00030007": "this but you can rely on", "MSLO5etyKG4-00165-00030008-00030246": "rescripts types to assert on these kind", "MSLO5etyKG4-00166-00030247-00030414": "of things at compile time which is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00167-00030416-00030511": "amazing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00168-00030512-00030783": "so let's go check that out we'll keep", "MSLO5etyKG4-00169-00030783-00030879": "this now", "MSLO5etyKG4-00170-00030880-00031046": "and we'll go and rescript and we'll show", "MSLO5etyKG4-00171-00031047-00031199": "you the how to support this kind of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00172-00031200-00031302": "public api", "MSLO5etyKG4-00173-00031303-00031414": "so the first thing is we need to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00174-00031416-00031607": "acknowledge your rescript code is good", "MSLO5etyKG4-00175-00031608-00031799": "right functions that take inputs and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00176-00031800-00031935": "have outputs are fantastic", "MSLO5etyKG4-00177-00031936-00032079": "the compiler will help you with this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00178-00032080-00032335": "stuff right now yes a lot of strongly", "MSLO5etyKG4-00179-00032336-00032446": "typed programmers", "MSLO5etyKG4-00180-00032447-00032583": "who are functional look at things like", "MSLO5etyKG4-00181-00032583-00032727": "this and go are you using a string that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00182-00032727-00032871": "means it's untyped", "MSLO5etyKG4-00183-00032872-00033174": "right so strings and booleans are kind", "MSLO5etyKG4-00184-00033175-00033223": "of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00185-00033224-00033390": "not really good from a typo perspective", "MSLO5etyKG4-00186-00033391-00033567": "but let's go with it okay so one thing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00187-00033568-00033702": "we do is make this private we're going", "MSLO5etyKG4-00188-00033703-00033862": "to put an underscore in front of it now", "MSLO5etyKG4-00189-00033863-00033990": "that's just a convention it doesn't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00190-00033991-00034151": "actually do anything magic", "MSLO5etyKG4-00191-00034152-00034423": "but it implies that this is for us and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00192-00034424-00034462": "that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00193-00034463-00034743": "this is for the javascript developers", "MSLO5etyKG4-00194-00034744-00034815": "okay", "MSLO5etyKG4-00195-00034816-00034959": "so this is a very common convention is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00196-00034960-00035174": "they provide a config object", "MSLO5etyKG4-00197-00035175-00035567": "so let's verify they first sent us", "MSLO5etyKG4-00198-00035568-00035799": "a config object and the way we do that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00199-00035800-00035935": "is you switch on it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00200-00035936-00036246": "based on using the nullable to option so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00201-00036247-00036302": "no", "MSLO5etyKG4-00202-00036303-00036446": "nullable to option is kind of neat", "MSLO5etyKG4-00203-00036447-00036623": "because it'll take a null", "MSLO5etyKG4-00204-00036624-00036895": "or undefined and make it a nothing and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00205-00036896-00037095": "so we can confirm either one of those", "MSLO5etyKG4-00206-00037096-00037295": "is not going to work right and so we can", "MSLO5etyKG4-00207-00037296-00037511": "reject on that we'll do a promise reject", "MSLO5etyKG4-00208-00037512-00037583": "and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00209-00037584-00037774": "speak in the language of javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00210-00037775-00038039": "developers your config does not exist", "MSLO5etyKG4-00211-00038040-00038230": "so we make a statement that it doesn't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00212-00038231-00038430": "exist they might have thought they sent", "MSLO5etyKG4-00213-00038431-00038583": "something but it's undefined or no it's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00214-00038584-00038655": "one of the two", "MSLO5etyKG4-00215-00038656-00038815": "which means for all intents and purposes", "MSLO5etyKG4-00216-00038816-00038967": "it doesn't exist", "MSLO5etyKG4-00217-00038968-00039230": "now we tell them what to do to remediate", "MSLO5etyKG4-00218-00039231-00039383": "that problem so they got an error", "MSLO5etyKG4-00219-00039384-00039607": "fine but here's how they fix the error", "MSLO5etyKG4-00220-00039608-00039759": "that's what a lot of errors don't do is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00221-00039760-00039783": "that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00222-00039784-00039927": "they miss that second part so we're", "MSLO5etyKG4-00223-00039928-00040159": "gonna help them you need to provide an", "MSLO5etyKG4-00224-00040160-00040207": "object", "MSLO5etyKG4-00225-00040208-00040383": "but we go a step further and give them", "MSLO5etyKG4-00226-00040384-00040615": "an example right of what that is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00227-00040616-00040807": "so we show the entire configuration", "MSLO5etyKG4-00228-00040808-00040983": "needed now they might have already done", "MSLO5etyKG4-00229-00040984-00041015": "this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00230-00041016-00041127": "they might have misspelled a variable", "MSLO5etyKG4-00231-00041128-00041390": "name whatever but at least we confirm", "MSLO5etyKG4-00232-00041391-00041543": "what they were thinking so that also", "MSLO5etyKG4-00233-00041544-00041758": "helps to build and kind of quash the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00234-00041759-00041887": "insecurity right", "MSLO5etyKG4-00235-00041888-00042111": "so good air helps them out and it's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00236-00042112-00042287": "follows the same promise mentality", "MSLO5etyKG4-00237-00042288-00042487": "so we speak in a language that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00238-00042488-00042615": "javascript developers", "MSLO5etyKG4-00239-00042616-00042767": "you know on right because here's how", "MSLO5etyKG4-00240-00042768-00043015": "they work they code some stuff they go", "MSLO5etyKG4-00241-00043016-00043199": "node sandbox it doesn't work and they go", "MSLO5etyKG4-00242-00043200-00043327": "oh auto is not a function oh", "MSLO5etyKG4-00243-00043328-00043455": "and they write some code and they go oh", "MSLO5etyKG4-00244-00043456-00043639": "no this fast", "MSLO5etyKG4-00245-00043640-00043855": "feedback loop of writing code fixing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00246-00043856-00044015": "modifying and running is what", "MSLO5etyKG4-00247-00044016-00044255": "all dynamic developers love is that you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00248-00044256-00044479": "can quickly get this amazing feedback", "MSLO5etyKG4-00249-00044480-00044551": "loop", "MSLO5etyKG4-00250-00044552-00044783": "so to work with that feedback loop to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00251-00044784-00044895": "encourage it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00252-00044896-00045030": "to speak their language we need to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00253-00045031-00045246": "provide errors that tell them how to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00254-00045247-00045374": "remediate it now just because they don't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00255-00045375-00045407": "have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00256-00045408-00045590": "errors obviously doesn't mean they're", "MSLO5etyKG4-00257-00045591-00045751": "good now it doesn't work but that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00258-00045752-00045927": "that helps javascript developers you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00259-00045928-00046151": "know move forward right", "MSLO5etyKG4-00260-00046152-00046423": "so now that we have the none state", "MSLO5etyKG4-00261-00046424-00046535": "handle where they forgot", "MSLO5etyKG4-00262-00046536-00046751": "or they messed it up now we actually", "MSLO5etyKG4-00263-00046752-00046902": "have something so we're going to use", "MSLO5etyKG4-00264-00046903-00047023": "this options here", "MSLO5etyKG4-00265-00047024-00047183": "okay so we don't have to worry about", "MSLO5etyKG4-00266-00047184-00047407": "shadowing right config and options", "MSLO5etyKG4-00267-00047408-00047630": "and now that we have the options we're", "MSLO5etyKG4-00268-00047631-00047799": "going to do some very imperative", "MSLO5etyKG4-00269-00047800-00047974": "style coding here you don't have to do", "MSLO5etyKG4-00270-00047975-00048102": "it imperative but we're going to do it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00271-00048103-00048183": "because it's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00272-00048184-00048399": "it's just a little easier to go line by", "MSLO5etyKG4-00273-00048400-00048502": "line to make sure that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00274-00048503-00048743": "each one of these kind of checks have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00275-00048744-00048911": "been in play and the way we do that is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00276-00048912-00049030": "we get", "MSLO5etyKG4-00277-00049031-00049327": "the items from the options now normally", "MSLO5etyKG4-00278-00049328-00049551": "in rescript you can go like dynamic data", "MSLO5etyKG4-00279-00049552-00049679": "right and go like this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00280-00049680-00049855": "the problem is you don't know what this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00281-00049856-00050071": "is it could be an undefined it could be", "MSLO5etyKG4-00282-00050072-00050255": "a string it could be another object who", "MSLO5etyKG4-00283-00050256-00050358": "knows right", "MSLO5etyKG4-00284-00050359-00050574": "so we what we want to do is convert it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00285-00050575-00050855": "to maybe it's a piece of data or not", "MSLO5etyKG4-00286-00050856-00051086": "and again the same way you do that here", "MSLO5etyKG4-00287-00051087-00051207": "is nullable to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00288-00051208-00051423": "option so again if data is there or not", "MSLO5etyKG4-00289-00051424-00051535": "maybe it's there maybe it's not", "MSLO5etyKG4-00290-00051536-00051775": "we use that type that's built into", "MSLO5etyKG4-00291-00051776-00051870": "rescript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00292-00051871-00052063": "that embraces javascript right because", "MSLO5etyKG4-00293-00052064-00052263": "it's part of the js", "MSLO5etyKG4-00294-00052264-00052591": "right module path so now we have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00295-00052591-00052935": "it's maybe either nothing or something", "MSLO5etyKG4-00296-00052936-00053047": "and so we're going to do the same thing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00297-00053048-00053230": "with the other two instead of unsafely", "MSLO5etyKG4-00298-00053232-00053375": "accessing these objects", "MSLO5etyKG4-00299-00053376-00053582": "we now do it in a very typed way and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00300-00053583-00053807": "this is step one of removing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00301-00053808-00053975": "most all null pointers and that's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00302-00053976-00054159": "embracing the concept of a maybe", "MSLO5etyKG4-00303-00054160-00054335": "or in this case in rescript it's an", "MSLO5etyKG4-00304-00054336-00054487": "option it's either", "MSLO5etyKG4-00305-00054488-00054703": "nothing or something and so you have to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00306-00054704-00054887": "handle both scenarios", "MSLO5etyKG4-00307-00054888-00055023": "so let's go ahead and do that let's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00308-00055024-00055230": "let's verify we'll say", "MSLO5etyKG4-00309-00055232-00055599": "if option is none", "MSLO5etyKG4-00310-00055600-00055759": "for id maybe well let's handle that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00311-00055760-00055926": "scenario if it's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00312-00055927-00056142": "not there then we need to let them know", "MSLO5etyKG4-00313-00056144-00056294": "that it's not there so yes you did send", "MSLO5etyKG4-00314-00056295-00056430": "a configuration object", "MSLO5etyKG4-00315-00056432-00056582": "but it's missing a key piece of data and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00316-00056583-00056791": "that's the id reject it we'll say your", "MSLO5etyKG4-00317-00056791-00056919": "id is not defined", "MSLO5etyKG4-00318-00056920-00057087": "on your configuration object so we're", "MSLO5etyKG4-00319-00057088-00057182": "already implying that they have a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00320-00057183-00057303": "configuration object", "MSLO5etyKG4-00321-00057304-00057542": "right but it's not there and let them", "MSLO5etyKG4-00322-00057544-00057671": "know it's supposed to be an", "MSLO5etyKG4-00323-00057672-00057991": "integer of your id so you know your id", "MSLO5etyKG4-00324-00057991-00058023": "is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00325-00058024-00058223": "make sure it's an integer not a string", "MSLO5etyKG4-00326-00058224-00058366": "and make sure it's called id", "MSLO5etyKG4-00327-00058367-00058550": "and put it on the configuration object", "MSLO5etyKG4-00328-00058551-00058759": "so basic error of what went wrong", "MSLO5etyKG4-00329-00058760-00058942": "and what they need to do to fix it so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00330-00058944-00059103": "we're going to do the exact same thing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00331-00059104-00059182": "with the other two", "MSLO5etyKG4-00332-00059183-00059375": "if it's a nothing right it's an", "MSLO5etyKG4-00333-00059376-00059542": "undefined or null or just missing", "MSLO5etyKG4-00334-00059544-00059679": "maybe it's there but you misspelled it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00335-00059679-00059966": "maybe it's ids right very common mistake", "MSLO5etyKG4-00336-00059967-00060191": "and now we have two more so we've", "MSLO5etyKG4-00337-00060191-00060366": "verified if the password isn't there", "MSLO5etyKG4-00338-00060367-00060511": "it's not defined it's supposed to be a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00339-00060512-00060750": "non-empty string and host", "MSLO5etyKG4-00340-00060751-00060926": "if the host is not defined it's supposed", "MSLO5etyKG4-00341-00060927-00061087": "to be an empty string and we went a step", "MSLO5etyKG4-00342-00061088-00061191": "further we said", "MSLO5etyKG4-00343-00061191-00061438": "such as server.com because when some", "MSLO5etyKG4-00344-00061439-00061535": "people think host", "MSLO5etyKG4-00345-00061536-00061887": "they think server.com right they don't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00346-00061888-00062159": "think of a url because we didn't call it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00347-00062160-00062294": "url we called it host so there could be", "MSLO5etyKG4-00348-00062295-00062430": "some ambiguity there", "MSLO5etyKG4-00349-00062432-00062615": "so we went you know over communicated", "MSLO5etyKG4-00350-00062616-00062750": "right let them know", "MSLO5etyKG4-00351-00062751-00062959": "now sadly javascript puts the errors at", "MSLO5etyKG4-00352-00062960-00063182": "the top right not at the bottom python", "MSLO5etyKG4-00353-00063183-00063215": "will", "MSLO5etyKG4-00354-00063216-00063430": "put this kind of stuff like here's the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00355-00063432-00063566": "error it'll put at the very bottom so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00356-00063567-00063742": "the last thing you see is there so we're", "MSLO5etyKG4-00357-00063744-00063871": "just going to have faith", "MSLO5etyKG4-00358-00063872-00064142": "that the javascript developer scrolls up", "MSLO5etyKG4-00359-00064144-00064303": "and sees that but we want this very", "MSLO5etyKG4-00360-00064304-00064399": "descriptive", "MSLO5etyKG4-00361-00064400-00064591": "very helpful and to jump out of them and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00362-00064591-00064711": "make them feel comfortable that they", "MSLO5etyKG4-00363-00064712-00064791": "know how to fix it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00364-00064791-00065038": "right so now that we've verified it each", "MSLO5etyKG4-00365-00065039-00065094": "one is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00366-00065095-00065399": "not a none we can start handling", "MSLO5etyKG4-00367-00065400-00065631": "the fact that oh okay well the value is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00368-00065632-00065759": "there", "MSLO5etyKG4-00369-00065760-00065982": "so we can use those values so we can", "MSLO5etyKG4-00370-00065983-00066063": "safely", "MSLO5etyKG4-00371-00066064-00066263": "access those values without worry so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00372-00066264-00066415": "notice here i'm going", "MSLO5etyKG4-00373-00066416-00066615": "password maybe and i'm getting it and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00374-00066616-00066743": "it's if it's not there it's going to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00375-00066744-00066838": "throw an exception", "MSLO5etyKG4-00376-00066839-00066950": "we don't have to worry about it because", "MSLO5etyKG4-00377-00066951-00067103": "right up here we confirmed it's not a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00378-00067104-00067143": "none", "MSLO5etyKG4-00379-00067144-00067335": "right so we can safely do these kind of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00380-00067336-00067503": "unsafe operations", "MSLO5etyKG4-00381-00067504-00067694": "because our types keep us in track but", "MSLO5etyKG4-00382-00067695-00067879": "also we've kind of broken out to do some", "MSLO5etyKG4-00383-00067880-00068031": "imperative style", "MSLO5etyKG4-00384-00068032-00068223": "coding here so let's do that for all", "MSLO5etyKG4-00385-00068224-00068399": "three snag", "MSLO5etyKG4-00386-00068400-00069047": "out the actual item", "MSLO5etyKG4-00387-00069048-00069311": "and now we've actually got a good public", "MSLO5etyKG4-00388-00069312-00069367": "api", "MSLO5etyKG4-00389-00069368-00069582": "now you don't have to stop here some", "MSLO5etyKG4-00390-00069583-00069687": "people can", "MSLO5etyKG4-00391-00069688-00070006": "say oh the host is missing http or", "MSLO5etyKG4-00392-00070007-00070238": "the password is not the current length", "MSLO5etyKG4-00393-00070239-00070391": "maybe you do that here", "MSLO5etyKG4-00394-00070392-00070535": "maybe you let your other function make", "MSLO5etyKG4-00395-00070536-00070687": "the assumption that's really up to you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00396-00070688-00070799": "if you want to you know follow the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00397-00070800-00070959": "promise mentality of like", "MSLO5etyKG4-00398-00070960-00071143": "all errors go through that single monad", "MSLO5etyKG4-00399-00071144-00071335": "that's fine but sometimes it's helpful", "MSLO5etyKG4-00400-00071336-00071487": "here it's really up to your call", "MSLO5etyKG4-00401-00071488-00071638": "the point is at least if you're looking", "MSLO5etyKG4-00402-00071639-00071815": "for data validation sometimes it's nice", "MSLO5etyKG4-00403-00071816-00071950": "to have it on one place", "MSLO5etyKG4-00404-00071951-00072087": "but maybe you want to do it on a per", "MSLO5etyKG4-00405-00072088-00072287": "function basis that's fine too the point", "MSLO5etyKG4-00406-00072288-00072471": "is that we're speaking", "MSLO5etyKG4-00407-00072472-00072662": "the exception language of javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00408-00072663-00072855": "developers and equipping them to succeed", "MSLO5etyKG4-00409-00072856-00073143": "in a public api while retaining our nice", "MSLO5etyKG4-00410-00073144-00073182": "strong", "MSLO5etyKG4-00411-00073183-00073487": "api strongly type one for us right so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00412-00073488-00073806": "now we save this and we call our", "MSLO5etyKG4-00413-00073807-00073926": "internal one", "MSLO5etyKG4-00414-00073927-00074087": "all these are speaking the same return", "MSLO5etyKG4-00415-00074088-00074303": "value of a promise with that api so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00416-00074304-00074350": "let's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00417-00074351-00074711": "retry now that our javascript is using", "MSLO5etyKG4-00418-00074712-00074887": "the correct configuration output let's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00419-00074888-00075047": "run it again now that we have a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00420-00075048-00075406": "public api for them so we run it", "MSLO5etyKG4-00421-00075407-00075647": "and voila we have our token back", "MSLO5etyKG4-00422-00075648-00075735": "fantastic", "MSLO5etyKG4-00423-00075736-00075879": "if an http error happened they would", "MSLO5etyKG4-00424-00075880-00076062": "still get the normal http error from", "MSLO5etyKG4-00425-00076063-00076231": "node fetch and that would imply some", "MSLO5etyKG4-00426-00076232-00076399": "kind of network error that's not on us", "MSLO5etyKG4-00427-00076400-00076599": "you can't strongly type the lack of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00428-00076600-00076775": "internet away but at least you can", "MSLO5etyKG4-00429-00076776-00076855": "confirm", "MSLO5etyKG4-00430-00076856-00076999": "that it comes from that promise based", "MSLO5etyKG4-00431-00077000-00077199": "interface in the form of an error which", "MSLO5etyKG4-00432-00077200-00077303": "is fantastic", "MSLO5etyKG4-00433-00077304-00077479": "that'll mitigate all those problems", "MSLO5etyKG4-00434-00077480-00077615": "it'll speak in a language they", "MSLO5etyKG4-00435-00077616-00077687": "understand", "MSLO5etyKG4-00436-00077688-00077935": "now there's one extra thing you can do", "MSLO5etyKG4-00437-00077936-00078031": "and that is", "MSLO5etyKG4-00438-00078032-00078255": "speak in an overly verbal language a lot", "MSLO5etyKG4-00439-00078256-00078399": "of dynamic developers will sometimes", "MSLO5etyKG4-00440-00078400-00078559": "kind of include", "MSLO5etyKG4-00441-00078560-00078750": "types in the property names some people", "MSLO5etyKG4-00442-00078751-00078975": "love it some people hate it they're like", "MSLO5etyKG4-00443-00078976-00079182": "you're deviating from the whole point of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00444-00079183-00079375": "dynamic languages right that quick", "MSLO5etyKG4-00445-00079376-00079511": "you know change the code and run change", "MSLO5etyKG4-00446-00079512-00079694": "the code and run right other people say", "MSLO5etyKG4-00447-00079695-00079743": "well", "MSLO5etyKG4-00448-00079744-00080006": "it helps in some cases for example if", "MSLO5etyKG4-00449-00080007-00080111": "this is a host", "MSLO5etyKG4-00450-00080112-00080238": "why are we including this maybe this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00451-00080239-00080462": "should be url so that's when where you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00452-00080463-00080511": "can just", "MSLO5etyKG4-00453-00080512-00080847": "simply using the right word can make a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00454-00080848-00080950": "little difference", "MSLO5etyKG4-00455-00080951-00081103": "of making sure the javascript developer", "MSLO5etyKG4-00456-00081104-00081238": "gives you the right type right so you're", "MSLO5etyKG4-00457-00081239-00081382": "already dealing with danger because it's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00458-00081383-00081455": "a string", "MSLO5etyKG4-00459-00081456-00081662": "sometimes using that property name helps", "MSLO5etyKG4-00460-00081663-00081903": "but another thing you can do is say id", "MSLO5etyKG4-00461-00081904-00082135": "number instead of id string because ids", "MSLO5etyKG4-00462-00082136-00082279": "it's very unclear if they're strings", "MSLO5etyKG4-00463-00082280-00082462": "numbers right no one really knows", "MSLO5etyKG4-00464-00082463-00082655": "if you have four zeros in front that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00465-00082656-00082799": "kind of implies the string but maybe", "MSLO5etyKG4-00466-00082800-00082991": "they do it for you who knows right so", "MSLO5etyKG4-00467-00082992-00083175": "something like id string", "MSLO5etyKG4-00468-00083176-00083303": "kind of implies all right it's supposed", "MSLO5etyKG4-00469-00083304-00083494": "to be a type or id number so that's", "MSLO5etyKG4-00470-00083495-00083638": "that's one thing you can do and then", "MSLO5etyKG4-00471-00083639-00083831": "sometimes the rules", "MSLO5etyKG4-00472-00083832-00084150": "of the actual type so such as password", "MSLO5etyKG4-00473-00084151-00084455": "seven min 255 max so suddenly you've", "MSLO5etyKG4-00474-00084456-00084575": "encoded", "MSLO5etyKG4-00475-00084576-00084879": "the rules or range of the value in the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00476-00084880-00085015": "type itself so it's got to be a minimum", "MSLO5etyKG4-00477-00085016-00085150": "of seven characters 255.", "MSLO5etyKG4-00478-00085151-00085326": "so this is another thing you can do and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00479-00085327-00085494": "then this will motivate the javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00480-00085495-00085647": "developer to check their own data", "MSLO5etyKG4-00481-00085648-00085735": "sometimes", "MSLO5etyKG4-00482-00085736-00085950": "and kind of put the you know onus on", "MSLO5etyKG4-00483-00085951-00086062": "them so there's nothing wrong with", "MSLO5etyKG4-00484-00086063-00086215": "double checks of javascript developers", "MSLO5etyKG4-00485-00086216-00086350": "testing their data and then", "MSLO5etyKG4-00486-00086351-00086518": "you know obviously you with your types", "MSLO5etyKG4-00487-00086519-00086655": "so some people hate it some people don't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00488-00086656-00086750": "like it it's just", "MSLO5etyKG4-00489-00086751-00086894": "you know another option to increase that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00490-00086895-00087094": "communication we've shown you how you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00491-00087095-00087326": "can take a public api to remove", "MSLO5etyKG4-00492-00087327-00087518": "order of operations there's no longer a", "MSLO5etyKG4-00493-00087519-00087703": "problem it's only one parameter", "MSLO5etyKG4-00494-00087704-00087982": "second the types don't matter because id", "MSLO5etyKG4-00495-00087983-00088079": "will have this type", "MSLO5etyKG4-00496-00088080-00088215": "and password have this type so you don't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00497-00088216-00088406": "have to worry about an integer first and", "MSLO5etyKG4-00498-00088407-00088526": "a string second when it was supposed to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00499-00088527-00088638": "be reversed", "MSLO5etyKG4-00500-00088639-00088815": "and lastly because javascript doesn't", "MSLO5etyKG4-00501-00088816-00089023": "have arity enforcement right how many", "MSLO5etyKG4-00502-00089024-00089206": "parameters your function takes if you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00503-00089207-00089391": "just do one you never have a problem", "MSLO5etyKG4-00504-00089392-00089550": "because even if you forget it it's an", "MSLO5etyKG4-00505-00089551-00089671": "implied undefined", "MSLO5etyKG4-00506-00089672-00089855": "right so you have that away so this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00507-00089856-00089991": "solves a lot of problems using this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00508-00089992-00090071": "configuration", "MSLO5etyKG4-00509-00090072-00090303": "thing for javascript developers that way", "MSLO5etyKG4-00510-00090304-00090455": "in rescript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00511-00090456-00090662": "you can then inspect each one of those", "MSLO5etyKG4-00512-00090663-00090862": "properties individually and run either", "MSLO5etyKG4-00513-00090863-00090999": "just a simple rule to make sure it's you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00514-00091000-00091111": "know actual value", "MSLO5etyKG4-00515-00091112-00091350": "or even further validation such as", "MSLO5etyKG4-00516-00091351-00091447": "password length", "MSLO5etyKG4-00517-00091448-00091671": "host shape things like that and this", "MSLO5etyKG4-00518-00091672-00091775": "allows you to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00519-00091776-00092038": "leverage all the wonderful strong types", "MSLO5etyKG4-00520-00092039-00092182": "that rescript provides for you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00521-00092183-00092431": "for javascript right very very fantastic", "MSLO5etyKG4-00522-00092432-00092518": "but you can still", "MSLO5etyKG4-00523-00092519-00092718": "speak in the language of javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00524-00092719-00092847": "developers and that's errors", "MSLO5etyKG4-00525-00092848-00093038": "in this case runtime exceptions but only", "MSLO5etyKG4-00526-00093039-00093206": "in a promise mechanism right", "MSLO5etyKG4-00527-00093207-00093343": "if it was synchronous that's fine you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00528-00093344-00093511": "can raise an error but you're speaking", "MSLO5etyKG4-00529-00093512-00093631": "the language they do and you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00530-00093632-00093903": "only do it from the public method", "MSLO5etyKG4-00531-00093904-00094071": "exposed specifically", "MSLO5etyKG4-00532-00094072-00094231": "for the javascript developer so while", "MSLO5etyKG4-00533-00094232-00094382": "you might have your internal one for you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00534-00094383-00094535": "with all your wonderful types", "MSLO5etyKG4-00535-00094536-00094735": "this one audit is exposed so the", "MSLO5etyKG4-00536-00094736-00094918": "javascript developer can call it that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00537-00094919-00094974": "way", "MSLO5etyKG4-00538-00094975-00095167": "very very similar to aws lambda if", "MSLO5etyKG4-00539-00095168-00095303": "you've seen where you have", "MSLO5etyKG4-00540-00095304-00095479": "all the dangerous stuff like exceptions", "MSLO5etyKG4-00541-00095480-00095655": "and stuff are spoken you know mainly in", "MSLO5etyKG4-00542-00095656-00095750": "the main function", "MSLO5etyKG4-00543-00095751-00095879": "hopefully that gives you some better", "MSLO5etyKG4-00544-00095880-00096079": "ideas on how to expose", "MSLO5etyKG4-00545-00096080-00096247": "libraries that are strongly typed with", "MSLO5etyKG4-00546-00096248-00096382": "rescripts you get all the value of", "MSLO5etyKG4-00547-00096383-00096494": "rescript right no", "MSLO5etyKG4-00548-00096495-00096694": "runtime no pointer exceptions no errors", "MSLO5etyKG4-00549-00096695-00096935": "strong types super fast compiler", "MSLO5etyKG4-00550-00096936-00097135": "but you still expose it to javascript", "MSLO5etyKG4-00551-00097136-00097287": "developers and then they can use it in", "MSLO5etyKG4-00552-00097288-00097431": "ways that they feel comfortable", "MSLO5etyKG4-00553-00097432-00097647": "and you equip them with errors that", "MSLO5etyKG4-00554-00097648-00097879": "helps them you know set up to succeed", "MSLO5etyKG4-00555-00097880-00098006": "so again if you got any other questions", "MSLO5etyKG4-00556-00098007-00098143": "hit me up in the comments or twitter my", "MSLO5etyKG4-00557-00098144-00098287": "name is jesse warden more than happy to", "MSLO5etyKG4-00558-00098288-00098343": "help", "MSLO5etyKG4-00559-00098344-00098535": "and hope this is useful and gives you", "MSLO5etyKG4-00560-00098536-00098638": "some better ideas for maybe even", "MSLO5etyKG4-00561-00098639-00098767": "javascript too if you're using", "MSLO5etyKG4-00562-00098768-00098959": "you know joy or folktale to do this kind", "MSLO5etyKG4-00563-00098960-00099087": "of stuff at runtime in javascript for", "MSLO5etyKG4-00564-00099088-00099191": "example", "MSLO5etyKG4-00565-00099192-00099480": "thanks for your time"}}, {"audio_id": "MSN_YDkSf9y", "text": {"MSN_YDkSf9y-00000-00000063-00001370": "it's snowing if you see it he found some", "MSN_YDkSf9y-00001-00001371-00001930": "snow Villa de Pio", "MSN_YDkSf9y-00002-00001930-00002239": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "MSVO01J_k-0", "text": {"MSVO01J_k-0-00000-00000016-00000158": "all right so here we are at the sacred", "MSVO01J_k-0-00001-00000159-00000375": "space cafe in hebton bridge", "MSVO01J_k-0-00002-00000376-00000487": "and we're going to go in and meet the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00003-00000488-00000663": "lovely star and i hear there's a special", "MSVO01J_k-0-00004-00000664-00001732": "guest here to meet me as well", "MSVO01J_k-0-00005-00001734-00002663": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00006-00002664-00002831": "it smells new in here yeah it's really", "MSVO01J_k-0-00007-00002832-00003031": "yes", "MSVO01J_k-0-00008-00003032-00003631": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00009-00003632-00003935": "oh my god we saw that every day", "MSVO01J_k-0-00010-00003936-00004663": "the more non-vegans the better yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00011-00004664-00004927": "so it took this long to get this open oh", "MSVO01J_k-0-00012-00004928-00004967": "well", "MSVO01J_k-0-00013-00004968-00005175": "so you had a flood that closed the other", "MSVO01J_k-0-00014-00005176-00005302": "one down yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00015-00005303-00005535": "all four of us all do the bird rescue so", "MSVO01J_k-0-00016-00005536-00006727": "we've just been inundated", "MSVO01J_k-0-00017-00006728-00006919": "who's joey joey the two he's going to", "MSVO01J_k-0-00018-00006920-00007206": "compete oh god joey", "MSVO01J_k-0-00019-00007208-00007519": "you look at me we saved him", "MSVO01J_k-0-00020-00007520-00007863": "two christmases ago", "MSVO01J_k-0-00021-00007864-00008223": "oh wow we took him to", "MSVO01J_k-0-00022-00008224-00008439": "an avian vet specialist about what was", "MSVO01J_k-0-00023-00008440-00008567": "it two two months ago", "MSVO01J_k-0-00024-00008568-00008799": "yeah and just to get to check out check", "MSVO01J_k-0-00025-00008800-00008935": "him over and this guy is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00026-00008936-00009078": "you know he's kind of the top quality", "MSVO01J_k-0-00027-00009079-00009303": "vet if he was to bring a bird to him and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00028-00009304-00009455": "he basically said he couldn't believe", "MSVO01J_k-0-00029-00009456-00009614": "that we've got him this far", "MSVO01J_k-0-00030-00009615-00009831": "and that he'd lost this much weight so", "MSVO01J_k-0-00031-00009832-00009967": "and he's seen him what twice i think", "MSVO01J_k-0-00032-00009968-00010078": "he's seen him twice now", "MSVO01J_k-0-00033-00010079-00010335": "so he's doing really good yeah the odds", "MSVO01J_k-0-00034-00010336-00010599": "aren't really good for", "MSVO01J_k-0-00035-00010600-00010910": "them but we want to have a big ex", "MSVO01J_k-0-00036-00010911-00011151": "factory hand broiler and turkey rescue", "MSVO01J_k-0-00037-00011152-00011535": "that's the biggest in the country", "MSVO01J_k-0-00038-00011536-00011767": "and disable birds because i'll see where", "MSVO01J_k-0-00039-00011768-00011910": "they go to at the minute locally because", "MSVO01J_k-0-00040-00011911-00012078": "no one else will take them", "MSVO01J_k-0-00041-00012079-00012270": "so this cafe is going to fund a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00042-00012271-00012399": "sanctuary is that what you're hoping to", "MSVO01J_k-0-00043-00012400-00012487": "do 100", "MSVO01J_k-0-00044-00012488-00013983": "that's why we're doing it yeah wow", "MSVO01J_k-0-00045-00013984-00014238": "what not to make money from vegan food", "MSVO01J_k-0-00046-00014240-00014335": "to help the animals", "MSVO01J_k-0-00047-00014336-00014535": "well that's a win-win because you're", "MSVO01J_k-0-00048-00014536-00014766": "actually promoting the vegan food to the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00049-00014768-00015047": "yeah it's kind of like just like the not", "MSVO01J_k-0-00050-00015047-00015191": "the coincidental thing we're passionate", "MSVO01J_k-0-00051-00015191-00015271": "about that too", "MSVO01J_k-0-00052-00015272-00015455": "but we're doing this for the sanctuary", "MSVO01J_k-0-00053-00015456-00015575": "and then everyone comes in", "MSVO01J_k-0-00054-00015576-00015727": "is you know eating vegan food enjoying", "MSVO01J_k-0-00055-00015728-00015847": "vegan food learning because we're", "MSVO01J_k-0-00056-00015847-00015999": "educating people too", "MSVO01J_k-0-00057-00016000-00016247": "so it's i think it's like mega activism", "MSVO01J_k-0-00058-00016247-00016311": "cafe", "MSVO01J_k-0-00059-00016312-00016591": "yeah tattoo as well because once people", "MSVO01J_k-0-00060-00016592-00016727": "are mature they can't escape", "MSVO01J_k-0-00061-00016728-00017255": "oh yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00062-00017256-00017375": "i was thinking to get an animal", "MSVO01J_k-0-00063-00017376-00018542": "liberation across my face", "MSVO01J_k-0-00064-00018543-00019943": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00065-00019944-00020079": "a lot of our customers have gone and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00066-00020080-00020335": "stayed vegan and doing activism wow", "MSVO01J_k-0-00067-00020336-00020558": "yeah and the last little cafe supported", "MSVO01J_k-0-00068-00020559-00020711": "the queue they all came in", "MSVO01J_k-0-00069-00020712-00021447": "so yeah it was amazing", "MSVO01J_k-0-00070-00021448-00021591": "although people think it's just full of", "MSVO01J_k-0-00071-00021592-00021758": "vegans it's actually not so there is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00072-00021759-00021903": "still a lot of work to be done", "MSVO01J_k-0-00073-00021904-00022094": "oh well yeah well i didn't even know", "MSVO01J_k-0-00074-00022095-00022255": "that it had vegans here when i", "MSVO01J_k-0-00075-00022256-00022558": "was like a vintage english town", "MSVO01J_k-0-00076-00022559-00022678": "you guys are hungry we've got we've got", "MSVO01J_k-0-00077-00022679-00022791": "food ready we can hook you up with some", "MSVO01J_k-0-00078-00022792-00022878": "food beer", "MSVO01J_k-0-00079-00022879-00023055": "latte if you've never had one wait is it", "MSVO01J_k-0-00080-00023056-00023207": "like pink milk", "MSVO01J_k-0-00081-00023208-00023391": "no so it's like it's like beetroot is in", "MSVO01J_k-0-00082-00023392-00023583": "it it's like a peat root and cacao will", "MSVO01J_k-0-00083-00023584-00023855": "like mix together in harmony and then it", "MSVO01J_k-0-00084-00023856-00023927": "creates this", "MSVO01J_k-0-00085-00023928-00024625": "luscious latte it's not caffeinated as", "MSVO01J_k-0-00086-00024626-00025283": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00087-00025284-00025431": "well", "MSVO01J_k-0-00088-00025432-00027646": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00089-00027647-00028062": "hmm", "MSVO01J_k-0-00090-00028063-00028407": "that's interesting let me try this one", "MSVO01J_k-0-00091-00028408-00028614": "this is the matcha one i had them both", "MSVO01J_k-0-00092-00028616-00028799": "which one's your favorite", "MSVO01J_k-0-00093-00028800-00028967": "i like them both for different reasons", "MSVO01J_k-0-00094-00028968-00029190": "okay this one's the earthy", "MSVO01J_k-0-00095-00029191-00029551": "beetroot creamy and this one is like", "MSVO01J_k-0-00096-00029552-00031177": "minty creamy earthy as well", "MSVO01J_k-0-00097-00031177-00031230": "[Applause]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00098-00031231-00031358": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00099-00031360-00031502": "all right so i've just been surprised", "MSVO01J_k-0-00100-00031503-00031662": "with this amazing spread of", "MSVO01J_k-0-00101-00031663-00031862": "vegan food here and i'm about to die of", "MSVO01J_k-0-00102-00031863-00032039": "happiness and um", "MSVO01J_k-0-00103-00032039-00032183": "what we're going to do is we're going to", "MSVO01J_k-0-00104-00032183-00032358": "talk through exactly what we've got here", "MSVO01J_k-0-00105-00032360-00032511": "so um", "MSVO01J_k-0-00106-00032512-00032670": "i think we'll start what should i start", "MSVO01J_k-0-00107-00032672-00032943": "with i would recommend the clock off", "MSVO01J_k-0-00108-00032944-00033023": "burger", "MSVO01J_k-0-00109-00033024-00033223": "that has been a favorite the clock off", "MSVO01J_k-0-00110-00033224-00033815": "burger that is our mock chicken which is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00111-00033816-00034151": "i love the name and what's in here", "MSVO01J_k-0-00112-00034152-00034407": "so it's oyster mushrooms fried in a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00113-00034408-00034783": "house batter made by emily secret recipe", "MSVO01J_k-0-00114-00034784-00035223": "oh dear lord that's an oyster mushroom", "MSVO01J_k-0-00115-00035224-00035399": "oh my god okay i'm gonna have a little", "MSVO01J_k-0-00116-00035400-00036039": "bite", "MSVO01J_k-0-00117-00036040-00036374": "oh my god", "MSVO01J_k-0-00118-00036375-00036855": "what is that batter it's good right", "MSVO01J_k-0-00119-00036856-00037246": "it's very crunchy amazing pluck off", "MSVO01J_k-0-00120-00037247-00037415": "that's like leave the chickens alone and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00121-00037416-00037551": "have this instead yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00122-00037552-00037911": "exactly named in honor of our ex factory", "MSVO01J_k-0-00123-00037912-00038023": "hand who we lost", "MSVO01J_k-0-00124-00038024-00038255": "during lockdown yeah she was the last", "MSVO01J_k-0-00125-00038256-00038430": "one of the ones we've saved so just you", "MSVO01J_k-0-00126-00038431-00038567": "know if someone comes in asking for a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00127-00038568-00038727": "chicken burger we can legitimately say", "MSVO01J_k-0-00128-00038728-00038881": "cluck off", "MSVO01J_k-0-00129-00038882-00039190": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00130-00039191-00039471": "okay and so i cleanse my palate and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00131-00039472-00039607": "maybe something a bit sweet to the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00132-00039608-00039783": "doughnut burgers", "MSVO01J_k-0-00133-00039784-00040102": "what so that's on a triple bacon", "MSVO01J_k-0-00134-00040103-00040399": "doughnut a triple baked italian donut", "MSVO01J_k-0-00135-00040400-00040646": "burger", "MSVO01J_k-0-00136-00040647-00040990": "and what is this vegan bacon cheese", "MSVO01J_k-0-00137-00040991-00041287": "and a beef style patty on a glazed", "MSVO01J_k-0-00138-00041288-00041367": "doughnut", "MSVO01J_k-0-00139-00041368-00041590": "oh my lord we all love this one we", "MSVO01J_k-0-00140-00041591-00041671": "weren't sure about", "MSVO01J_k-0-00141-00041672-00041846": "them on taste test and it just melted", "MSVO01J_k-0-00142-00041847-00042030": "and it's also the sauce it might sound", "MSVO01J_k-0-00143-00042031-00042158": "strange but the sauce", "MSVO01J_k-0-00144-00042159-00042495": "is a it's a maple sauce this is bad for", "MSVO01J_k-0-00145-00042496-00042639": "the old diet isn't it", "MSVO01J_k-0-00146-00042640-00043118": "you know what they say", "MSVO01J_k-0-00147-00043119-00043527": "online all right", "MSVO01J_k-0-00148-00043528-00043999": "this one here is my favorite thing ever", "MSVO01J_k-0-00149-00044000-00044174": "it's like the sweet and salty it's just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00150-00044175-00044343": "too good", "MSVO01J_k-0-00151-00044344-00044446": "it tastes like something you'd have on", "MSVO01J_k-0-00152-00044447-00044662": "your birthday right that's what i think", "MSVO01J_k-0-00153-00044663-00044790": "it's like a birthday treat but you", "MSVO01J_k-0-00154-00044791-00045167": "should have it every day", "MSVO01J_k-0-00155-00045168-00045343": "it's amazing yeah we don't eat like this", "MSVO01J_k-0-00156-00045344-00045535": "every day every other day", "MSVO01J_k-0-00157-00045536-00045783": "that's the tree burger once a week now", "MSVO01J_k-0-00158-00045784-00045935": "that is like the best of both worlds i", "MSVO01J_k-0-00159-00045936-00046158": "think it's a beautiful donut as well", "MSVO01J_k-0-00160-00046159-00046502": "soft and fresh my lord oh", "MSVO01J_k-0-00161-00046503-00046807": "you gotta try this one all right what's", "MSVO01J_k-0-00162-00046808-00046911": "the next one", "MSVO01J_k-0-00163-00046912-00047223": "the smoky one oh smoky", "MSVO01J_k-0-00164-00047224-00047446": "so you got smoked cheese some barbecue", "MSVO01J_k-0-00165-00047447-00047543": "sauce", "MSVO01J_k-0-00166-00047544-00048046": "and bacon again my lord", "MSVO01J_k-0-00167-00048047-00048255": "no slaughterhouses used in the process", "MSVO01J_k-0-00168-00048256-00048430": "of making this bacon which is the best", "MSVO01J_k-0-00169-00048431-00048902": "part let's have a look", "MSVO01J_k-0-00170-00048903-00049215": "oh this is a proper burger i wouldn't i", "MSVO01J_k-0-00171-00049216-00049367": "don't know what i would choose to be my", "MSVO01J_k-0-00172-00049368-00049486": "favorite", "MSVO01J_k-0-00173-00049487-00049718": "because they're all for different moods", "MSVO01J_k-0-00174-00049719-00049999": "it depends what your mood is eh", "MSVO01J_k-0-00175-00050000-00050279": "that's delicious the buns are beautiful", "MSVO01J_k-0-00176-00050280-00050335": "as well", "MSVO01J_k-0-00177-00050336-00050655": "these brish buns enough with the burger", "MSVO01J_k-0-00178-00050656-00050790": "love let's go on to the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00179-00050791-00050935": "which one which one should i go next", "MSVO01J_k-0-00180-00050936-00051095": "chili cheese fries well these are", "MSVO01J_k-0-00181-00051096-00051407": "our all of our favorites okay garlic are", "MSVO01J_k-0-00182-00051408-00051542": "up to grind so my favorite is the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00183-00051544-00051607": "chicken", "MSVO01J_k-0-00184-00051608-00051902": "oh wow okay well we'll try the uh we'll", "MSVO01J_k-0-00185-00051903-00051999": "try to get one with everything", "MSVO01J_k-0-00186-00052000-00052230": "on it let's start with sesame seeds and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00187-00052232-00052550": "spring onions and sriracha", "MSVO01J_k-0-00188-00052551-00052991": "oh dear", "MSVO01J_k-0-00189-00052991-00053303": "yeah it's tangy and spicy", "MSVO01J_k-0-00190-00053304-00053654": "and sweet and salty it's a good mix", "MSVO01J_k-0-00191-00053655-00054094": "oh my lord so this is chili cheese fries", "MSVO01J_k-0-00192-00054095-00054471": "nice so i've got homemade chili", "MSVO01J_k-0-00193-00054472-00054782": "vegan cheese melted on top and then", "MSVO01J_k-0-00194-00054783-00054959": "we've got our spiced rice", "MSVO01J_k-0-00195-00054960-00055254": "here we go let's do that you want some", "MSVO01J_k-0-00196-00055255-00055815": "of that", "MSVO01J_k-0-00197-00055816-00056007": "that's mexican nacho style i can't", "MSVO01J_k-0-00198-00056008-00056175": "believe this is all vegan hey it's just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00199-00056176-00056423": "well i can", "MSVO01J_k-0-00200-00056424-00056687": "i can buy now i've had a few runnings", "MSVO01J_k-0-00201-00056688-00056830": "with the amazing vegan food but this is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00202-00056832-00056863": "just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00203-00056864-00057054": "nice and this is this is what you put in", "MSVO01J_k-0-00204-00057055-00057223": "the mm-hmm", "MSVO01J_k-0-00205-00057224-00057599": "so we do them as yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00206-00057600-00057871": "these are kind of like uh less processed", "MSVO01J_k-0-00207-00057872-00057911": "than", "MSVO01J_k-0-00208-00057912-00058166": "it's a mushroom isn't it it's a mushroom", "MSVO01J_k-0-00209-00058167-00058254": "you know people saying they're not", "MSVO01J_k-0-00210-00058255-00058399": "looking for processed meats", "MSVO01J_k-0-00211-00058400-00058559": "it's not processed meat that's an oyster", "MSVO01J_k-0-00212-00058560-00058735": "mushroom so if you've not tried oyster", "MSVO01J_k-0-00213-00058736-00058942": "mushroom before they have like a quite a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00214-00058944-00059159": "uh i don't want to say meaty texture but", "MSVO01J_k-0-00215-00059160-00059294": "they do definitely have that kind of", "MSVO01J_k-0-00216-00059295-00059359": "like", "MSVO01J_k-0-00217-00059360-00059542": "more substantial texture when you bite", "MSVO01J_k-0-00218-00059544-00060303": "it let's have a try today", "MSVO01J_k-0-00219-00060304-00060687": "my lord you nailed that batter", "MSVO01J_k-0-00220-00060688-00061015": "the batter is and it's", "MSVO01J_k-0-00221-00061016-00061238": "it's been here for a little little while", "MSVO01J_k-0-00222-00061239-00061406": "on the table and it's still crunchy oh", "MSVO01J_k-0-00223-00061407-00061454": "good", "MSVO01J_k-0-00224-00061455-00061815": "that's good you're fine yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00225-00061816-00062094": "good and you've experienced this one", "MSVO01J_k-0-00226-00062095-00062254": "sort of before that's the triple baked", "MSVO01J_k-0-00227-00062255-00062647": "italian donut", "MSVO01J_k-0-00228-00062648-00062806": "oh so here we've got dessert after", "MSVO01J_k-0-00229-00062807-00063142": "having a donut burger", "MSVO01J_k-0-00230-00063144-00063438": "for the main meal this is a triple baked", "MSVO01J_k-0-00231-00063439-00063559": "italian doughnut", "MSVO01J_k-0-00232-00063560-00063863": "with chocolate so our local baker", "MSVO01J_k-0-00233-00063864-00064094": "he basically bakes them so in an italian", "MSVO01J_k-0-00234-00064095-00064175": "style so", "MSVO01J_k-0-00235-00064176-00064350": "they're baked once and then left for a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00236-00064351-00064519": "while to rise and bakes again", "MSVO01J_k-0-00237-00064520-00064726": "three times until they get whopping like", "MSVO01J_k-0-00238-00064727-00064863": "like the size they are now", "MSVO01J_k-0-00239-00064864-00065094": "whoa all right let's just get this out", "MSVO01J_k-0-00240-00065095-00065238": "so you guys can have a look at", "MSVO01J_k-0-00241-00065239-00065567": "how juicy this doughnut is look at that", "MSVO01J_k-0-00242-00065568-00065823": "i've got a quite a large head too many", "MSVO01J_k-0-00243-00065824-00065935": "people have said", "MSVO01J_k-0-00244-00065936-00066167": "and that's that's like nearly the size", "MSVO01J_k-0-00245-00066168-00066271": "of my head", "MSVO01J_k-0-00246-00066272-00066415": "now we're going to get the mouth around", "MSVO01J_k-0-00247-00066416-00066863": "that just by it", "MSVO01J_k-0-00248-00066864-00067143": "oh yeah that is amazing this is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00249-00067144-00067215": "beautiful", "MSVO01J_k-0-00250-00067216-00067663": "everyone has to come here and try this", "MSVO01J_k-0-00251-00067664-00069087": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00252-00069088-00069343": "joey the turkey like is he gonna do a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00253-00069344-00069463": "little", "MSVO01J_k-0-00254-00069464-00069687": "he's displaying it he's gonna come and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00255-00069688-00069847": "do his display he's here", "MSVO01J_k-0-00256-00069848-00070047": "basically he'll come in he might do a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00257-00070048-00070199": "little display but that's just his thing", "MSVO01J_k-0-00258-00070200-00070423": "showing you that he's the boss he's the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00259-00070424-00070591": "boss so you've got to submit", "MSVO01J_k-0-00260-00070592-00070847": "yeah he'll basically show us all right", "MSVO01J_k-0-00261-00070848-00070943": "i'll respect", "MSVO01J_k-0-00262-00070944-00071113": "joey's uh you know", "MSVO01J_k-0-00263-00071114-00071255": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00264-00071256-00071447": "i respect his hustle and i'm just gonna", "MSVO01J_k-0-00265-00071448-00071845": "submit to joey", "MSVO01J_k-0-00266-00071846-00072038": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00267-00072039-00072326": "i can pick him up from bringing me yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00268-00072327-00072399": "charlie", "MSVO01J_k-0-00269-00072400-00073855": "there he is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00270-00073856-00074023": "if you stroke on his back to begin with", "MSVO01J_k-0-00271-00074024-00074191": "just just behind his yeah just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00272-00074192-00075423": "about you can kind of", "MSVO01J_k-0-00273-00075424-00075638": "does he like the back scratch yeah yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00274-00075639-00076006": "he likes about scratches", "MSVO01J_k-0-00275-00076007-00076255": "and you can even he's in full display", "MSVO01J_k-0-00276-00076256-00076879": "now he's just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00277-00076880-00077135": "you want some corn he doesn't really", "MSVO01J_k-0-00278-00077136-00077215": "know me too", "MSVO01J_k-0-00279-00077216-00077423": "he doesn't know me well enough to let me", "MSVO01J_k-0-00280-00077424-00077559": "to eat corn out of my hand", "MSVO01J_k-0-00281-00077560-00077743": "you can get your hand like in as long as", "MSVO01J_k-0-00282-00077744-00077887": "you're going downwards like following", "MSVO01J_k-0-00283-00077888-00078135": "his feathers and you can just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00284-00078136-00078526": "calm and relax", "MSVO01J_k-0-00285-00078527-00078799": "so he's just trying to impress you he's", "MSVO01J_k-0-00286-00078800-00078879": "heard you've got", "MSVO01J_k-0-00287-00078880-00079126": "a popular youtube channel i think he's", "MSVO01J_k-0-00288-00079127-00079294": "great so he's just this is him", "MSVO01J_k-0-00289-00079295-00079743": "zoe i named my youtube channel after you", "MSVO01J_k-0-00290-00079744-00080143": "that's how special you are you know that", "MSVO01J_k-0-00291-00080144-00080679": "oh so that means you see the food", "MSVO01J_k-0-00292-00080680-00080887": "now they said he'd been ill so they were", "MSVO01J_k-0-00293-00080888-00081038": "gonna kill him because they didn't have", "MSVO01J_k-0-00294-00081039-00081175": "the room for him", "MSVO01J_k-0-00295-00081176-00081415": "so we could have him and then we went up", "MSVO01J_k-0-00296-00081416-00081519": "there and they had like a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00297-00081520-00081831": "10 acre farm and then", "MSVO01J_k-0-00298-00081832-00082071": "yeah we just re-homed him he was two", "MSVO01J_k-0-00299-00082072-00082215": "days away two or three days away from", "MSVO01J_k-0-00300-00082216-00082343": "slaughter", "MSVO01J_k-0-00301-00082344-00082694": "when we got in oh dear but he's had two", "MSVO01J_k-0-00302-00082695-00082871": "years of freedom and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00303-00082872-00083015": "that say he's doing really well he's", "MSVO01J_k-0-00304-00083016-00083247": "lost weight and he's doing he's healthy", "MSVO01J_k-0-00305-00083248-00083326": "healthy", "MSVO01J_k-0-00306-00083327-00083511": "he says it's one of the healthiest farm", "MSVO01J_k-0-00307-00083512-00083687": "turkeys ever seen", "MSVO01J_k-0-00308-00083688-00083855": "he loves he loves running around and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00309-00083856-00084015": "just just hanging out then sometimes", "MSVO01J_k-0-00310-00084016-00084094": "they'll just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00311-00084095-00084231": "sit on the sofa with us and just chill", "MSVO01J_k-0-00312-00084232-00084350": "or watch a movie or something it's", "MSVO01J_k-0-00313-00084351-00084487": "pretty cool", "MSVO01J_k-0-00314-00084488-00084767": "i'm impressed with your display i'm very", "MSVO01J_k-0-00315-00084768-00085015": "intimidated", "MSVO01J_k-0-00316-00085016-00085279": "i'm extremely intimidated by you and you", "MSVO01J_k-0-00317-00085280-00085359": "are the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00318-00085360-00085662": "alpha turkey with the alpha joey in the", "MSVO01J_k-0-00319-00085663-00085847": "room", "MSVO01J_k-0-00320-00085848-00085991": "and because i hang out with him on a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00321-00085992-00086238": "daily basis you know he's my best mate", "MSVO01J_k-0-00322-00086239-00086438": "it just to me doesn't make any sense", "MSVO01J_k-0-00323-00086439-00086606": "that someone would do that you know", "MSVO01J_k-0-00324-00086607-00086887": "to an incredibly social bird it doesn't", "MSVO01J_k-0-00325-00086888-00087055": "matter how social they are but when they", "MSVO01J_k-0-00326-00087056-00087279": "are as social as turkeys are", "MSVO01J_k-0-00327-00087280-00087438": "for me i just think it's completely", "MSVO01J_k-0-00328-00087439-00087647": "unjustifiable and i think if anyone", "MSVO01J_k-0-00329-00087648-00087879": "got to know and met a turkey on a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00330-00087880-00087999": "personal level", "MSVO01J_k-0-00331-00088000-00088182": "they'd never ever pick up a fork you", "MSVO01J_k-0-00332-00088183-00088303": "know to eat", "MSVO01J_k-0-00333-00088304-00088417": "turkey or meat again", "MSVO01J_k-0-00334-00088418-00088823": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00335-00088824-00089006": "the reason that the bread this way is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00336-00089007-00089135": "for me so", "MSVO01J_k-0-00337-00089136-00089279": "a lot like you know like broiler", "MSVO01J_k-0-00338-00089280-00089431": "chickens and stuff like that they are", "MSVO01J_k-0-00339-00089432-00089631": "bred so the front of joey's breast", "MSVO01J_k-0-00340-00089632-00089879": "is bred for you know human consumption", "MSVO01J_k-0-00341-00089880-00090006": "that's that's why", "MSVO01J_k-0-00342-00090007-00090348": "he's as big as he is", "MSVO01J_k-0-00343-00090349-00090575": "[Music]", "MSVO01J_k-0-00344-00090576-00090750": "i was just literally on the phone to a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00345-00090751-00090903": "delivery company who's", "MSVO01J_k-0-00346-00090904-00091062": "you know delivering us some food and i", "MSVO01J_k-0-00347-00091063-00091215": "just saw them in the road so i figured", "MSVO01J_k-0-00348-00091216-00091399": "if i go over and approach and can pick", "MSVO01J_k-0-00349-00091400-00091462": "them up", "MSVO01J_k-0-00350-00091463-00091718": "then they need help so we'll just you", "MSVO01J_k-0-00351-00091719-00091838": "know look him over give him some", "MSVO01J_k-0-00352-00091839-00092015": "recovery formula which is just like full", "MSVO01J_k-0-00353-00092016-00092167": "of vitamins and energy", "MSVO01J_k-0-00354-00092168-00092343": "and then if he's all right we'll just", "MSVO01J_k-0-00355-00092344-00092479": "take him back", "MSVO01J_k-0-00356-00092480-00092782": "hey nice to meet you guys thank you and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00357-00092783-00092959": "we hope that we can help out with your", "MSVO01J_k-0-00358-00092960-00093143": "adventure i think it's a great idea you", "MSVO01J_k-0-00359-00093144-00093287": "know yeah", "MSVO01J_k-0-00360-00093288-00093447": "anyone's done two rescues while we're", "MSVO01J_k-0-00361-00093448-00093838": "here", "MSVO01J_k-0-00362-00093839-00094494": "joey in the background", "MSVO01J_k-0-00363-00094495-00094631": "all right so what an amazing little", "MSVO01J_k-0-00364-00094632-00094894": "place here that's such delicious food oh", "MSVO01J_k-0-00365-00094895-00094974": "my god", "MSVO01J_k-0-00366-00094975-00095135": "and they even did two rescues while we", "MSVO01J_k-0-00367-00095136-00095350": "were here so their goal is to open up a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00368-00095351-00095503": "big sanctuary but i think it's a", "MSVO01J_k-0-00369-00095504-00095735": "fantastic idea to start a cafe to help", "MSVO01J_k-0-00370-00095736-00095911": "raise the funds and they've got a tattoo", "MSVO01J_k-0-00371-00095912-00096135": "studio there vegan tattoo studio", "MSVO01J_k-0-00372-00096136-00096279": "so if you want to support come down to", "MSVO01J_k-0-00373-00096280-00096462": "the cafe and support or", "MSVO01J_k-0-00374-00096463-00096774": "they've started a fundraiser too", "MSVO01J_k-0-00375-00096775-00096918": "to help support their sanctuary and i'll", "MSVO01J_k-0-00376-00096919-00097062": "leave that link down below and you can", "MSVO01J_k-0-00377-00097063-00097135": "support", "MSVO01J_k-0-00378-00097136-00097311": "such an amazing place with some ethical", "MSVO01J_k-0-00379-00097312-00097559": "vegans trying their best to help animals", "MSVO01J_k-0-00380-00097560-00097743": "uh a really good business idea really", "MSVO01J_k-0-00381-00097744-00097982": "good sort of activism idea as well", "MSVO01J_k-0-00382-00097983-00098255": "and yeah come down here to hebden bridge", "MSVO01J_k-0-00383-00098256-00098294": "and", "MSVO01J_k-0-00384-00098295-00100982": "say g'day", "MSVO01J_k-0-00385-00100983-00101192": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "MT6jw26h4M4", "text": {"MT6jw26h4M4-00000-00000006-00000281": "thank you for joining my talk", "MT6jw26h4M4-00001-00000282-00000457": "from", "MT6jw26h4M4-00002-00000458-00000778": "s-bombs to eye bombs know what's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00003-00000779-00001015": "happening in your clusters", "MT6jw26h4M4-00004-00001016-00001295": "first let's start with the most", "MT6jw26h4M4-00005-00001296-00001660": "important thing what's in it for you why", "MT6jw26h4M4-00006-00001661-00001834": "should you stay here and not grab the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00007-00001835-00002105": "next cup of coffee I know I had one too", "MT6jw26h4M4-00008-00002106-00002465": "many so first we start by understanding", "MT6jw26h4M4-00009-00002466-00002723": "why I bomb which stands for", "MT6jw26h4M4-00010-00002724-00003005": "infrastructure bill of materials is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00011-00003006-00003293": "crucial for security but also for any", "MT6jw26h4M4-00012-00003294-00003640": "platform efficiency then we're going to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00013-00003642-00003893": "Define ibom and understand why we should", "MT6jw26h4M4-00014-00003894-00004241": "all care about it next we'll talk about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00015-00004242-00004517": "what's the implications in terms of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00016-00004518-00004704": "attack service", "MT6jw26h4M4-00017-00004705-00005206": "for ibom and later learn how ibom can", "MT6jw26h4M4-00018-00005207-00005549": "help us all learn how to control our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00019-00005550-00005770": "clouds better", "MT6jw26h4M4-00020-00005771-00005920": "so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00021-00005921-00006299": "um who are we my name is Edo Niemann I'm", "MT6jw26h4M4-00022-00006300-00006472": "the co-founder and CEO at the company", "MT6jw26h4M4-00023-00006473-00006664": "called Firefly we're doing Cloud Asset", "MT6jw26h4M4-00024-00006665-00006934": "Management I spent almost almost 12", "MT6jw26h4M4-00025-00006936-00007114": "years in the Israeli cyber intelligence", "MT6jw26h4M4-00026-00007115-00007264": "Force", "MT6jw26h4M4-00027-00007265-00007463": "um then LED technology for a permanent", "MT6jw26h4M4-00028-00007464-00007667": "hedge fund work for a startup in in the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00029-00007668-00007855": "serverless field and with me today", "MT6jw26h4M4-00030-00007856-00008219": "should be Cindy Blake fireflies VP of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00031-00008220-00008392": "marketing but", "MT6jw26h4M4-00032-00008393-00008687": "this is the first infrastructure fail", "MT6jw26h4M4-00033-00008688-00008974": "all right so just like I bomb and s-bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00034-00008975-00009310": "we created an amazing we hope amazing", "MT6jw26h4M4-00035-00009311-00009724": "deck for you but Cindy couldn't be here", "MT6jw26h4M4-00036-00009725-00009983": "so the software the service worked well", "MT6jw26h4M4-00037-00009984-00010271": "but the infrastructure failed and if we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00038-00010272-00010505": "could do the bomb the bill of material", "MT6jw26h4M4-00039-00010506-00010642": "for the infrastructure we could have", "MT6jw26h4M4-00040-00010643-00010883": "prepped better for this call so so it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00041-00010884-00011131": "would be only me but I'll try to make up", "MT6jw26h4M4-00042-00011132-00011477": "for Sydney's absence", "MT6jw26h4M4-00043-00011478-00011764": "so let's start with the basics for the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00044-00011765-00012028": "past few years s-bomb is being crazy", "MT6jw26h4M4-00045-00012029-00012414": "like a very hot buzzword so I'm I'm sure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00046-00012415-00012719": "most of you heard about it many many", "MT6jw26h4M4-00047-00012720-00012910": "times so I don't want to reinvent the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00048-00012911-00013138": "will and talk about what is as Mom and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00049-00013140-00013343": "why it's important so I asked the most", "MT6jw26h4M4-00050-00013344-00013661": "the smartest thing I know um chat GPT", "MT6jw26h4M4-00051-00013662-00013925": "what sbomb is all about and it gave me a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00052-00013926-00014122": "very elaborate answer so let's let's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00053-00014123-00014363": "take the key part of it it says", "MT6jw26h4M4-00054-00014363-00014536": "something about software of materials", "MT6jw26h4M4-00055-00014537-00014722": "complete inventory of all software", "MT6jw26h4M4-00056-00014723-00014957": "components it has all third-party", "MT6jw26h4M4-00057-00014958-00015179": "software open source libraries and other", "MT6jw26h4M4-00058-00015180-00015449": "components this is where most of us are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00059-00015450-00015701": "focusing our current s-bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00060-00015702-00015793": "um", "MT6jw26h4M4-00061-00015794-00016036": "efforts and Endeavors and then the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00062-00016037-00016211": "s-bomb is essential component for", "MT6jw26h4M4-00063-00016212-00016391": "software supply chain security supply", "MT6jw26h4M4-00064-00016392-00016697": "chain is fantastic personally I'm I'm", "MT6jw26h4M4-00065-00016698-00016925": "really excited about this build and you", "MT6jw26h4M4-00066-00016926-00017057": "need to list all the third-party", "MT6jw26h4M4-00067-00017058-00017315": "components right so what basically says", "MT6jw26h4M4-00068-00017316-00017555": "let's understand what our services our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00069-00017556-00017777": "software is comprised of let's list all", "MT6jw26h4M4-00070-00017778-00017975": "the open source all the dependencies and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00071-00017976-00018179": "the supply chain and understand", "MT6jw26h4M4-00072-00018180-00018358": "um what we have in our software because", "MT6jw26h4M4-00073-00018359-00018635": "open source is huge stack Overflow is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00074-00018636-00018821": "used GitHub is used and we don't really", "MT6jw26h4M4-00075-00018822-00019229": "know what our services are comprised of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00076-00019230-00019547": "and now let's try to define ibom or", "MT6jw26h4M4-00077-00019548-00019793": "infrastructure bill of materials first", "MT6jw26h4M4-00078-00019794-00020189": "and foremost it's a full inventory of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00079-00020190-00020441": "our infrastructure where do you have our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00080-00020442-00020669": "servers where do we have our storage or", "MT6jw26h4M4-00081-00020670-00020885": "do we have our Network everything that's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00082-00020886-00021085": "connected kubernetes", "MT6jw26h4M4-00083-00021086-00021472": "pods but after we um we list all the key", "MT6jw26h4M4-00084-00021473-00021725": "components we need to list an inventory", "MT6jw26h4M4-00085-00021726-00021977": "all the dependencies for example if I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00086-00021978-00022175": "have a server where is the server", "MT6jw26h4M4-00087-00022176-00022378": "storage if it's connected to a network", "MT6jw26h4M4-00088-00022379-00022630": "what's the network that it connects to I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00089-00022631-00022871": "am and so on and so forth then obviously", "MT6jw26h4M4-00090-00022872-00023039": "we're here at kubecon and cloudnativecon", "MT6jw26h4M4-00091-00023040-00023380": "we should talk about child processes and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00092-00023381-00023561": "predecessors right if I have a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00093-00023562-00023728": "kubernetes cluster I need to understand", "MT6jw26h4M4-00094-00023729-00023927": "all the child resources if I have a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00095-00023928-00024155": "replica set I need to know all the pods", "MT6jw26h4M4-00096-00024156-00024358": "that connected to it and all the storage", "MT6jw26h4M4-00097-00024359-00024569": "allowance and the scale status for", "MT6jw26h4M4-00098-00024570-00024767": "example if I have an auto scaling group", "MT6jw26h4M4-00099-00024768-00025085": "in my public Cloud then we should", "MT6jw26h4M4-00100-00025086-00025325": "understand all the in infrastructure is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00101-00025326-00025625": "code for example Helm or terraform or", "MT6jw26h4M4-00102-00025626-00025877": "ansible or pulumi that connect to this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00103-00025877-00026099": "invite or control or provision this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00104-00026100-00026333": "environment or an infrastructure and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00105-00026333-00026555": "lastly Maybe", "MT6jw26h4M4-00106-00026556-00026957": "as important as the native or the native", "MT6jw26h4M4-00107-00026958-00027143": "Cloud components but many time", "MT6jw26h4M4-00108-00027144-00027383": "overlooked is all the third-party tools", "MT6jw26h4M4-00109-00027383-00027545": "that became integral part of our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00110-00027545-00027802": "platforms but we we don't think about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00111-00027804-00028090": "our OCTA the way that we think about our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00112-00028091-00028318": "replica set we don't think about mongodb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00113-00028319-00028511": "Atlas like we think about an RDS", "MT6jw26h4M4-00114-00028512-00028870": "instance on AWS so all of those are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00115-00028872-00029014": "super critical", "MT6jw26h4M4-00116-00029016-00029273": "um and you can find your your favorite", "MT6jw26h4M4-00117-00029274-00029662": "vendor um across your infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00118-00029663-00029849": "um then after we have the entire", "MT6jw26h4M4-00119-00029850-00030118": "inventory and we understand how our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00120-00030119-00030377": "platform is built and what components", "MT6jw26h4M4-00121-00030377-00030677": "and depends are comprising it we should", "MT6jw26h4M4-00122-00030677-00030940": "understand every configuration per each", "MT6jw26h4M4-00123-00030941-00031162": "item on our inventory and each version", "MT6jw26h4M4-00124-00031163-00031564": "and the last part is have ownership I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00125-00031566-00031840": "know that in the modern era especially", "MT6jw26h4M4-00126-00031841-00032062": "you know I work a lot with sres and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00127-00032063-00032333": "platform engineering blame is something", "MT6jw26h4M4-00128-00032333-00032524": "that you can say because we're all in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00129-00032525-00032693": "together and we need to support every", "MT6jw26h4M4-00130-00032694-00032927": "production issue together to solve it as", "MT6jw26h4M4-00131-00032928-00033281": "fast as possible but ownership is super", "MT6jw26h4M4-00132-00033282-00033515": "critical for us to understand how to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00133-00033516-00033695": "manage our infrastructure and how to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00134-00033696-00033940": "really create the inventory because we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00135-00033941-00034174": "create the eye bomb for a case where we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00136-00034175-00034349": "have a problem or incident or security", "MT6jw26h4M4-00137-00034350-00034618": "issue now we need to attend to the owner", "MT6jw26h4M4-00138-00034619-00034793": "of the specific resource or environment", "MT6jw26h4M4-00139-00034794-00035009": "and handle it so we got to add it to the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00140-00035010-00035165": "inventory", "MT6jw26h4M4-00141-00035166-00035387": "so when the student", "MT6jw26h4M4-00142-00035388-00035621": "what or hopefully understood what I bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00143-00035622-00036035": "is it's a full inventory of my entire", "MT6jw26h4M4-00144-00036036-00036173": "um platform", "MT6jw26h4M4-00145-00036174-00036377": "um hopefully it runs in the cloud but", "MT6jw26h4M4-00146-00036378-00036605": "now let's see some example on how this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00147-00036606-00036839": "inventory looks like so the very basic", "MT6jw26h4M4-00148-00036840-00037139": "example is to me to write a small python", "MT6jw26h4M4-00149-00037140-00037409": "or bash script to allow me to see every", "MT6jw26h4M4-00150-00037410-00037733": "in this case it's AWS machines all the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00151-00037734-00038027": "the ec2 the servers that are older than", "MT6jw26h4M4-00152-00038028-00038321": "10 days and are running and see all the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00153-00038322-00038524": "sizes and understand how many servers I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00154-00038525-00038767": "have but very very basic", "MT6jw26h4M4-00155-00038768-00039137": "now I can go forward and list all of the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00156-00039138-00039371": "different servers servers in a specific", "MT6jw26h4M4-00157-00039372-00039580": "region and even see", "MT6jw26h4M4-00158-00039581-00039893": "um if I have some backup related to them", "MT6jw26h4M4-00159-00039894-00040199": "next version will be to create something", "MT6jw26h4M4-00160-00040200-00040595": "super complex or very complex that runs", "MT6jw26h4M4-00161-00040596-00040774": "across my entire multi-cloud", "MT6jw26h4M4-00162-00040775-00041093": "infrastructure and sasabilities and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00163-00041094-00041380": "kubernetes clusters and lists every", "MT6jw26h4M4-00164-00041381-00041735": "single resource in them have the type", "MT6jw26h4M4-00165-00041736-00042065": "associated with it its name its owner", "MT6jw26h4M4-00166-00042066-00042359": "its infrastructure is code it status its", "MT6jw26h4M4-00167-00042360-00042743": "location its properties its tags its", "MT6jw26h4M4-00168-00042744-00042905": "creation data and so on and so forth but", "MT6jw26h4M4-00169-00042906-00043109": "it's becoming super complex", "MT6jw26h4M4-00170-00043110-00043417": "and the next stage is have a dedicated", "MT6jw26h4M4-00171-00043418-00043751": "inventory or Asset Management solution", "MT6jw26h4M4-00172-00043752-00044093": "for the cloud native era", "MT6jw26h4M4-00173-00044094-00044207": "so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00174-00044208-00044351": "we understand", "MT6jw26h4M4-00175-00044352-00044687": "what the concept of ibom is and how we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00176-00044688-00044890": "can start implementing it we should", "MT6jw26h4M4-00177-00044891-00045058": "probably understand what's the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00178-00045059-00045317": "implications in terms of the attack", "MT6jw26h4M4-00179-00045318-00045599": "service service sorry so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00180-00045600-00045905": "s-bomb is huge for", "MT6jw26h4M4-00181-00045906-00046145": "for appsec right now everyone in upstick", "MT6jw26h4M4-00182-00046146-00046379": "thinks about supply chain and s-bomb and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00183-00046380-00046546": "we are very much focused on scanning all", "MT6jw26h4M4-00184-00046547-00046751": "the dependencies and let's say if we are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00185-00046752-00047015": "kubernetes Fanatics we all always want", "MT6jw26h4M4-00186-00047016-00047146": "to scan the images and understand", "MT6jw26h4M4-00187-00047147-00047621": "everything is properly run but what if I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00188-00047622-00047812": "scanned all the dependencies and I scan", "MT6jw26h4M4-00189-00047813-00047987": "the image and everything looks okay in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00190-00047988-00048112": "the configuration for this specific", "MT6jw26h4M4-00191-00048113-00048352": "container is fine but let's go back even", "MT6jw26h4M4-00192-00048353-00048640": "to 2015 I'm running this this kubernetes", "MT6jw26h4M4-00193-00048641-00048862": "spot inside a cluster which is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00194-00048863-00049229": "vulnerable and now I can I can I can do", "MT6jw26h4M4-00195-00049230-00049457": "Escape out of the container and go up", "MT6jw26h4M4-00196-00049458-00049787": "from the kernel to um the the product", "MT6jw26h4M4-00197-00049788-00050074": "that I like to take advantage of so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00198-00050075-00050429": "eye bomb allows us to really outline the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00199-00050430-00050645": "entire attack service not just the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00200-00050646-00050843": "service not just like I showed you those", "MT6jw26h4M4-00201-00050844-00051071": "slides are here but the infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00202-00051072-00051388": "Sydney is missing this is vulnerable the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00203-00051389-00051544": "the human element is almost the most", "MT6jw26h4M4-00204-00051545-00051857": "vulnerable in this case we we were so we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00205-00051858-00052120": "need to understand the entire", "MT6jw26h4M4-00206-00052121-00052408": "chain of our infrastructure in our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00207-00052409-00052661": "service so let's say say I have a piece", "MT6jw26h4M4-00208-00052662-00052937": "of software that runs on Azure and make", "MT6jw26h4M4-00209-00052938-00053123": "sure that the entire Azure configuration", "MT6jw26h4M4-00210-00053124-00053453": "is is build an inventory and secure it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00211-00053454-00053632": "and it's fine and then I ran kubernetes", "MT6jw26h4M4-00212-00053633-00053819": "on top of azure and and taking care of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00213-00053820-00054071": "the kubernetes but now I'm going out to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00214-00054072-00054299": "mongodb Atlas and mongodb Atlas is a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00215-00054300-00054437": "great service and I hope it's it's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00216-00054438-00054641": "always a cure and we I personally use it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00217-00054641-00054916": "but let's say someone manage manages to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00218-00054917-00055180": "take advantage of me shifting data in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00219-00055182-00055432": "and out of mongodb Atlas so I need to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00220-00055433-00055607": "understand that all this this traffic", "MT6jw26h4M4-00221-00055608-00055865": "goes in and out of azure and lastly I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00222-00055866-00056015": "have that dog monitor of this and I have", "MT6jw26h4M4-00223-00056016-00056225": "Cloud for using it I'm using Cloud for", "MT6jw26h4M4-00224-00056226-00056573": "for CDN to to distribute the data so if", "MT6jw26h4M4-00225-00056574-00056723": "I don't understand each and every", "MT6jw26h4M4-00226-00056724-00057035": "component across the entire service I'm", "MT6jw26h4M4-00227-00057036-00057287": "missing out so just like this image", "MT6jw26h4M4-00228-00057288-00057466": "articulate I can have a very strong", "MT6jw26h4M4-00229-00057467-00057935": "chain but if if one link is super weak", "MT6jw26h4M4-00230-00057936-00057994": "um", "MT6jw26h4M4-00231-00057995-00058276": "I'm I'm probably I'm doing something", "MT6jw26h4M4-00232-00058277-00058516": "wrong security wise", "MT6jw26h4M4-00233-00058517-00058853": "so let's see some basic example some", "MT6jw26h4M4-00234-00058854-00059080": "basic some more than basic examples of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00235-00059082-00059237": "overlooked", "MT6jw26h4M4-00236-00059238-00059429": "um eye bomb um", "MT6jw26h4M4-00237-00059429-00059863": "incidents or or um issues so for example", "MT6jw26h4M4-00238-00059864-00060142": "kubernetes I can again", "MT6jw26h4M4-00239-00060144-00060359": "scan my images know that my cluster is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00240-00060360-00060671": "correct but if I don't keep track on my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00241-00060672-00060916": "cluster version I might run out of date", "MT6jw26h4M4-00242-00060917-00061163": "and vulnerable version of kubernetes API", "MT6jw26h4M4-00243-00061164-00061385": "version pair every object in my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00244-00061386-00061709": "infrastructure the operating version and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00245-00061710-00062087": "type of every node that I run a DB", "MT6jw26h4M4-00246-00062088-00062263": "version something", "MT6jw26h4M4-00247-00062264-00062621": "that is it can be a bit tricky because", "MT6jw26h4M4-00248-00062622-00062903": "we all know that the the public Cloud", "MT6jw26h4M4-00249-00062904-00063173": "security teams are amazing and let's say", "MT6jw26h4M4-00250-00063174-00063485": "I have I'm running a managed redis by", "MT6jw26h4M4-00251-00063486-00063875": "AWS and obviously at least I can talk", "MT6jw26h4M4-00252-00063876-00064091": "um about the people I know", "MT6jw26h4M4-00253-00064091-00064385": "the AWS security team can run and Patch", "MT6jw26h4M4-00254-00064386-00064685": "vulnerabilities in in redis faster than", "MT6jw26h4M4-00255-00064686-00064882": "I can do it and I can Implement in my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00256-00064883-00065141": "production environment so it's good it's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00257-00065141-00065303": "good to have a managed service in terms", "MT6jw26h4M4-00258-00065304-00065711": "of security but if I'm not allowing Auto", "MT6jw26h4M4-00259-00065712-00065969": "upgrade to minor version I might think", "MT6jw26h4M4-00260-00065970-00066173": "that oh it's a managed service and it's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00261-00066174-00066394": "fine and I'm now patched against this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00262-00066395-00066629": "zero day that was just discovered this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00263-00066630-00066875": "morning but if I'm not allowing Auto", "MT6jw26h4M4-00264-00066876-00067247": "upgrade I'm doing a bad service to my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00265-00067248-00067529": "security team then we can talk about all", "MT6jw26h4M4-00266-00067530-00067679": "the terraform or other infrastructures", "MT6jw26h4M4-00267-00067680-00067949": "code modules that I run is it something", "MT6jw26h4M4-00268-00067950-00068176": "that we created is it something that", "MT6jw26h4M4-00269-00068177-00068525": "another team created is it a public repo", "MT6jw26h4M4-00270-00068526-00068717": "or public model because unfortunately", "MT6jw26h4M4-00271-00068718-00069082": "some Bad actors inject vulnerable repos", "MT6jw26h4M4-00272-00069083-00069269": "into public infrastructure as code", "MT6jw26h4M4-00273-00069270-00069550": "modules and I need to understand this as", "MT6jw26h4M4-00274-00069551-00070015": "part of my eyebomb and which part of my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00275-00070016-00070247": "infrastructure is consumed by each", "MT6jw26h4M4-00276-00070248-00070511": "service because in case of an incident", "MT6jw26h4M4-00277-00070512-00070715": "or in case I want to change something I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00278-00070716-00070894": "need to understand per service which", "MT6jw26h4M4-00279-00070895-00071081": "infrastructure it consumes", "MT6jw26h4M4-00280-00071082-00071273": "and we go next we can think about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00281-00071274-00071705": "security group or VPC changes I I I'll", "MT6jw26h4M4-00282-00071706-00071999": "share a quick story from our one of our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00283-00072000-00072335": "customers at Firefly so this Relentless", "MT6jw26h4M4-00284-00072336-00072635": "secops engineer", "MT6jw26h4M4-00285-00072636-00072935": "um examined a specific environment and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00286-00072936-00073253": "found that there's a server there's no", "MT6jw26h4M4-00287-00073254-00073505": "need for it anymore and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00288-00073506-00073732": "um the server uh consumes a security", "MT6jw26h4M4-00289-00073733-00073967": "group so he looked at it he saw okay", "MT6jw26h4M4-00290-00073968-00074171": "Security Group one server I don't need", "MT6jw26h4M4-00291-00074172-00074441": "the server let's do terraform destroy", "MT6jw26h4M4-00292-00074442-00074741": "destroyed it and he felt good he", "MT6jw26h4M4-00293-00074742-00074921": "minimized the attack service for the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00294-00074922-00075143": "environment he eliminated some waste and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00295-00075144-00075355": "it was fine but 15 minutes later", "MT6jw26h4M4-00296-00075356-00075700": "production started to to crumble and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00297-00075701-00075881": "some bad things happened to data", "MT6jw26h4M4-00298-00075882-00076211": "retention and why is that because this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00299-00076212-00076523": "secops team set up a security group with", "MT6jw26h4M4-00300-00076524-00076876": "a server in terraform but then another", "MT6jw26h4M4-00301-00076877-00077093": "team in the devops department", "MT6jw26h4M4-00302-00077094-00077375": "saw this Security Group and added two", "MT6jw26h4M4-00303-00077376-00077579": "additional servers to the security group", "MT6jw26h4M4-00304-00077580-00077903": "so the SEC up Engineers examined the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00305-00077904-00078256": "terraform manifest and see one server in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00306-00078257-00078388": "the security group does their form", "MT6jw26h4M4-00307-00078389-00078526": "destroy telephone doesn't see any", "MT6jw26h4M4-00308-00078527-00078762": "problem destroyed it but the two other", "MT6jw26h4M4-00309-00078763-00079025": "servers are now disconnect from the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00310-00079026-00079331": "network and to production down so this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00311-00079332-00079612": "is very bad and if they had a detailed", "MT6jw26h4M4-00312-00079613-00079955": "eye bomb they would know that if if the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00313-00079956-00080173": "security group is deleted then those two", "MT6jw26h4M4-00314-00080174-00080471": "additional servers would go down another", "MT6jw26h4M4-00315-00080472-00080699": "thing that that that we should think", "MT6jw26h4M4-00316-00080700-00080944": "about is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00317-00080945-00081359": "how do we communicate changes to the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00318-00081360-00081556": "infrastructure what's the source of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00319-00081557-00081917": "tooth if I'm the secops engineer and I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00320-00081918-00082282": "see new Ingress all into my VPC do I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00321-00082283-00082493": "allow it or not how do I know I work in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00322-00082494-00082685": "a large Enterprise with hundreds of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00323-00082686-00082876": "developers and I don't know if someone", "MT6jw26h4M4-00324-00082877-00083176": "added a new a piece of software that", "MT6jw26h4M4-00325-00083177-00083494": "need to relay and talk to across my VPC", "MT6jw26h4M4-00326-00083495-00083741": "so how do I know it if I have a detailed", "MT6jw26h4M4-00327-00083742-00083981": "I bomb I know I have now a source of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00328-00083982-00084191": "Truth for my infrastructure and there", "MT6jw26h4M4-00329-00084192-00084419": "are no questions asked it's it's not", "MT6jw26h4M4-00330-00084420-00084731": "um a game of Academy a mouse the secops", "MT6jw26h4M4-00331-00084732-00084899": "close the Ingress the devops thing model", "MT6jw26h4M4-00332-00084900-00085085": "platform range open it again to allow", "MT6jw26h4M4-00333-00085086-00085288": "Ingress for the suspenders and so on and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00334-00085289-00085397": "so forth", "MT6jw26h4M4-00335-00085398-00085805": "um moving on we can we can understand in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00336-00085806-00086194": "our eye bomb well or when all resources", "MT6jw26h4M4-00337-00086195-00086506": "were deployed so if I see lots of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00338-00086507-00086806": "pods obviously not pods I hope you don't", "MT6jw26h4M4-00339-00086807-00086993": "have Parts running from 2017 but a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00340-00086994-00087197": "compute instance is running from 2017", "MT6jw26h4M4-00341-00087198-00087425": "that are still running might get me", "MT6jw26h4M4-00342-00087426-00087569": "thinking and researching why it's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00343-00087570-00087875": "happened and as a last example at least", "MT6jw26h4M4-00344-00087876-00088043": "of all the assumed roles by SAS", "MT6jw26h4M4-00345-00088044-00088241": "providers right because I can tell you", "MT6jw26h4M4-00346-00088242-00088444": "for from some examples that are close to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00347-00088445-00088535": "me", "MT6jw26h4M4-00348-00088536-00088829": "um companies that don't remember if they", "MT6jw26h4M4-00349-00088830-00089117": "already switched from Prisma Cloud to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00350-00089118-00089315": "whiz or they're still using Cloud health", "MT6jw26h4M4-00351-00089316-00089561": "or no it's apto but should I remove this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00352-00089562-00089831": "assume all or not I don't know and it's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00353-00089832-00089987": "a mess", "MT6jw26h4M4-00354-00089988-00090137": "so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00355-00090138-00090412": "now after understanding that that we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00356-00090413-00090647": "need to map the eye bomb let's see how", "MT6jw26h4M4-00357-00090648-00091037": "it can be used in case of an incident so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00358-00091038-00091241": "let's hope it never happens but but I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00359-00091242-00091481": "remember when when Mel down inspector", "MT6jw26h4M4-00360-00091482-00091726": "hit if you remember the vulnerabilities", "MT6jw26h4M4-00361-00091727-00091991": "in in the Intel processes we were all", "MT6jw26h4M4-00362-00091992-00092135": "very scared", "MT6jw26h4M4-00363-00092136-00092344": "um for a software that runs on on", "MT6jw26h4M4-00364-00092345-00092494": "instances", "MT6jw26h4M4-00365-00092495-00092723": "um that based on those processes", "MT6jw26h4M4-00366-00092724-00093005": "but let's say and again I'm really", "MT6jw26h4M4-00367-00093006-00093143": "hoping it won't happen let's say", "MT6jw26h4M4-00368-00093144-00093412": "tomorrow morning God forbid we find the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00369-00093413-00093773": "vulnerability in graviton by AWS how do", "MT6jw26h4M4-00370-00093774-00094025": "I know which part of my software which", "MT6jw26h4M4-00371-00094026-00094438": "part of my my data set was exposed to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00372-00094439-00094675": "the compromised or the vulnerable", "MT6jw26h4M4-00373-00094676-00095135": "processes if I don't have an eye bomb to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00374-00095136-00095387": "go with it it's almost impossible or", "MT6jw26h4M4-00375-00095388-00095621": "very very complex for me to do if I have", "MT6jw26h4M4-00376-00095622-00096023": "it it's two clicks away or one command", "MT6jw26h4M4-00377-00096024-00096311": "line away for me to to output and start", "MT6jw26h4M4-00378-00096312-00096593": "investigating and have a proper", "MT6jw26h4M4-00379-00096594-00096694": "disclosure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00380-00096695-00096838": "so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00381-00096839-00097187": "apparently now we talked about how ibom", "MT6jw26h4M4-00382-00097188-00097409": "is important for the security", "MT6jw26h4M4-00383-00097410-00097565": "perspective", "MT6jw26h4M4-00384-00097566-00097829": "um of of the cloud or the infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00385-00097830-00098026": "practitioner but now let's think about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00386-00098027-00098285": "the operational point of view if I take", "MT6jw26h4M4-00387-00098286-00098476": "a service down something change I want", "MT6jw26h4M4-00388-00098477-00098681": "to take the service now the service down", "MT6jw26h4M4-00389-00098682-00098981": "how do I make sure the entire supporting", "MT6jw26h4M4-00390-00098982-00099118": "infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00391-00099119-00099353": "is really eliminated and I don't have", "MT6jw26h4M4-00392-00099354-00099532": "any waste I don't have any vulnerable", "MT6jw26h4M4-00393-00099533-00099959": "instances that kept they keep running", "MT6jw26h4M4-00394-00099960-00100247": "so if if it's so important that now we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00395-00100248-00100465": "talk about why album is so important", "MT6jw26h4M4-00396-00100466-00100906": "where is compliance right because s-bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00397-00100907-00101255": "is probably the a compliance darling in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00398-00101256-00101471": "the last two years right sock 2 loves it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00399-00101472-00101717": "the U.S federal government really loves", "MT6jw26h4M4-00400-00101718-00102106": "it fedramp adores it and now", "MT6jw26h4M4-00401-00102107-00102516": "everyone is occupied with uh being a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00402-00102517-00102958": "as-bomb uh eccentric but is ibom needed", "MT6jw26h4M4-00403-00102959-00103336": "the or demanded I I I'm not sure I'm not", "MT6jw26h4M4-00404-00103338-00103523": "sure that there's a compliance that's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00405-00103524-00103954": "explicitly requires an album but", "MT6jw26h4M4-00406-00103955-00104303": "if you know how big Banks and very large", "MT6jw26h4M4-00407-00104304-00104554": "Enterprises like the fortune", "MT6jw26h4M4-00408-00104555-00104908": "um 100 Quirk you know that they are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00409-00104909-00105131": "already implementing an eye bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00410-00105132-00105371": "tracking mechanism so we need to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00411-00105372-00105593": "understand they are always a one step", "MT6jw26h4M4-00412-00105594-00105833": "ahead in terms of compliance if are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00413-00105833-00106186": "tracking I bomb did we miss anything", "MT6jw26h4M4-00414-00106188-00106534": "so I got got thinking about it and and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00415-00106535-00106840": "started to see some efforts around ibom", "MT6jw26h4M4-00416-00106841-00107281": "so Cyclone DX very hot explicitly States", "MT6jw26h4M4-00417-00107282-00107602": "s-bomb SAS bomb so bit of material for", "MT6jw26h4M4-00418-00107603-00107807": "all the stars that they use and h-bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00419-00107808-00108107": "which is Hardware bomb and now that the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00420-00108108-00108352": "new cool kid in the block salsa I think", "MT6jw26h4M4-00421-00108353-00108478": "they call it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00422-00108479-00108689": "um supply chain level for software", "MT6jw26h4M4-00423-00108690-00109007": "architecture so I don't know why I put a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00424-00109008-00109295": "picture of Elmer Fudd here", "MT6jw26h4M4-00425-00109296-00109631": "um but I'm suspecting it's more a fad", "MT6jw26h4M4-00426-00109632-00109901": "than something real", "MT6jw26h4M4-00427-00109902-00110189": "um but but if Cyclone DX which is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00428-00110190-00110399": "important they want to to list the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00429-00110400-00110602": "s-bomb and they want to list their", "MT6jw26h4M4-00430-00110603-00110831": "h-bomb the hardware bomb and I don't", "MT6jw26h4M4-00431-00110832-00110993": "have like in my company we don't have", "MT6jw26h4M4-00432-00110994-00111239": "Hardware we are Cloud native we use only", "MT6jw26h4M4-00433-00111240-00111640": "Cloud so what's the equivalent and if my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00434-00111641-00111997": "cloud is software defined", "MT6jw26h4M4-00435-00111998-00112157": "infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00436-00112158-00112504": "is it part of my s-bomb or not and SAS", "MT6jw26h4M4-00437-00112505-00112823": "bomb is just the list of SAS or when it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00438-00112824-00113165": "comes down to Atlas or services", "MT6jw26h4M4-00439-00113166-00113447": "like a NetApp sport or Aqua security", "MT6jw26h4M4-00440-00113448-00113669": "which really touches and control my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00441-00113670-00113902": "infrastructure how deep should I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00442-00113903-00114113": "understand those and list", "MT6jw26h4M4-00443-00114114-00114352": "um those resources in my in part of my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00444-00114353-00114808": "my eye bomb so fedramp is taking a step", "MT6jw26h4M4-00445-00114809-00115073": "forward and really start to ask you to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00446-00115074-00115325": "bomb everything that relates to your", "MT6jw26h4M4-00447-00115326-00115486": "service including the infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00448-00115488-00115666": "part of it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00449-00115667-00115895": "but once again", "MT6jw26h4M4-00450-00115896-00116254": "I think it's important to note that I", "MT6jw26h4M4-00451-00116255-00116597": "bomb is definitely not just for security", "MT6jw26h4M4-00452-00116598-00116921": "if you track your I bomb correctly", "MT6jw26h4M4-00453-00116922-00117202": "you can have your platform be much more", "MT6jw26h4M4-00454-00117203-00117431": "efficient and tight", "MT6jw26h4M4-00455-00117432-00117628": "and now another story", "MT6jw26h4M4-00456-00117629-00117899": "so one of our customers call us one day", "MT6jw26h4M4-00457-00117900-00118277": "and tells us that they they using", "MT6jw26h4M4-00458-00118278-00118654": "Firefly they found an environment by a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00459-00118655-00118889": "sales engineer that cost them three", "MT6jw26h4M4-00460-00118890-00119147": "thousand dollars per month but they are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00461-00119148-00119357": "a relatively large Enterprise so we ask", "MT6jw26h4M4-00462-00119358-00119531": "okay fantastic we're happy three", "MT6jw26h4M4-00463-00119532-00119813": "thousand dollars is a lot of money but", "MT6jw26h4M4-00464-00119814-00120160": "you pay your Cloud providers your mother", "MT6jw26h4M4-00465-00120161-00120508": "orders of magnitudes more per week", "MT6jw26h4M4-00466-00120509-00120677": "um so so why are you excited about it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00467-00120678-00120893": "details okay this software engineer left", "MT6jw26h4M4-00468-00120894-00121145": "the company and they did it three years", "MT6jw26h4M4-00469-00121146-00121402": "ago so for three years an entire", "MT6jw26h4M4-00470-00121403-00121565": "environment", "MT6jw26h4M4-00471-00121566-00121895": "was up and running the the company", "MT6jw26h4M4-00472-00121896-00122243": "thought that if um the HR management SAS", "MT6jw26h4M4-00473-00122244-00122604": "solution marked this employee as a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00474-00122605-00122801": "non-employee anymore he left the company", "MT6jw26h4M4-00475-00122802-00123077": "so it takes down everything but it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00476-00123078-00123221": "didn't take down the cloud", "MT6jw26h4M4-00477-00123222-00123413": "infrastructure for it so it's a security", "MT6jw26h4M4-00478-00123414-00123665": "weakness a significant security weakness", "MT6jw26h4M4-00479-00123666-00123899": "in my opinion but also just a lot of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00480-00123900-00124360": "Cloud waste which led to more than 100K", "MT6jw26h4M4-00481-00124361-00124702": "in unneeded expenses", "MT6jw26h4M4-00482-00124703-00125039": "so if if I try to wrap it up here", "MT6jw26h4M4-00483-00125040-00125404": "um I bomb really allows the devops SRE", "MT6jw26h4M4-00484-00125405-00125669": "and platform engineering and joy the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00485-00125670-00125878": "security aspects of some compliance", "MT6jw26h4M4-00486-00125879-00126107": "requirements", "MT6jw26h4M4-00487-00126108-00126358": "um and now we need to understand why was", "MT6jw26h4M4-00488-00126359-00126760": "ibom neglected why when esbom is so big", "MT6jw26h4M4-00489-00126761-00127019": "I bomb is something that we almost never", "MT6jw26h4M4-00490-00127020-00127193": "or never hear about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00491-00127194-00127583": "and this comes down to the fact that the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00492-00127583-00127883": "old world was segmented differently", "MT6jw26h4M4-00493-00127883-00128177": "right we had the software teams care", "MT6jw26h4M4-00494-00128178-00128399": "about software and ID teams care about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00495-00128400-00128645": "Hardware so software teams care about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00496-00128646-00128999": "s-bomb and it cares about h-bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00497-00129000-00129181": "but cloud is as mentioned before", "MT6jw26h4M4-00498-00129182-00129514": "software defined info where does it fall", "MT6jw26h4M4-00499-00129515-00129845": "if I manage this this infra through my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00500-00129846-00130084": "git and I'm deploying it using my CI CD", "MT6jw26h4M4-00501-00130085-00130319": "is it software I'm not sure because", "MT6jw26h4M4-00502-00130320-00130547": "appsec teams and software teams don't", "MT6jw26h4M4-00503-00130548-00130810": "care about ibom they care about s-bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00504-00130811-00131087": "but Cloud SEC they do not really care", "MT6jw26h4M4-00505-00131088-00131273": "about ibom they just chase the next", "MT6jw26h4M4-00506-00131274-00131461": "vulnerability they chase", "MT6jw26h4M4-00507-00131462-00131716": "I'm all tightening and so on and so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00508-00131717-00132040": "forth and this is why it was neglected", "MT6jw26h4M4-00509-00132041-00132311": "but what if I told you we never", "MT6jw26h4M4-00510-00132312-00132466": "neglected ibom", "MT6jw26h4M4-00511-00132467-00132664": "what if I told you", "MT6jw26h4M4-00512-00132665-00133133": "that the old Legacy I.T world has a very", "MT6jw26h4M4-00513-00133134-00133337": "detailed eye bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00514-00133338-00133540": "extremely detailed album It's called", "MT6jw26h4M4-00515-00133541-00133816": "cmdb configuration management database", "MT6jw26h4M4-00516-00133817-00134081": "some of us can remember it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00517-00134082-00134302": "um amazing companies like BMC and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00518-00134303-00134645": "servicenow built amazing products around", "MT6jw26h4M4-00519-00134646-00134801": "cmdb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00520-00134802-00135275": "but this cmdb world was designed for a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00521-00135276-00135593": "world where you have actual servers", "MT6jw26h4M4-00522-00135594-00135893": "sitting in wrecks in your basement and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00523-00135894-00136223": "the the cmdb is even list the HVAC and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00524-00136224-00136511": "the AC mechanism in your data center so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00525-00136512-00136678": "they're built for a situation where you", "MT6jw26h4M4-00526-00136679-00136925": "you change your servers once every two", "MT6jw26h4M4-00527-00136926-00137225": "years and track licenses for on-prem", "MT6jw26h4M4-00528-00137226-00137495": "MySQL and not for kubernetes spots going", "MT6jw26h4M4-00529-00137496-00137890": "up and down every 100 millisecond so the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00530-00137891-00138145": "CMD Big World this great eye bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00531-00138146-00138533": "database is missing from the cloud world", "MT6jw26h4M4-00532-00138534-00138725": "so for us here at cubecon at", "MT6jw26h4M4-00533-00138726-00138952": "cloudnativecon this is a very important", "MT6jw26h4M4-00534-00138953-00139313": "piece that is missing so I probably skip", "MT6jw26h4M4-00535-00139314-00139559": "the Shameless plug for Firefly being the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00536-00139560-00139769": "best cloud native cmdb an iPhone", "MT6jw26h4M4-00537-00139770-00140125": "generator but we should think about it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00538-00140126-00140483": "so what is cloud native cmdb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00539-00140484-00140669": "configuration management database", "MT6jw26h4M4-00540-00140670-00140951": "it's a tool to control and see", "MT6jw26h4M4-00541-00140952-00141173": "everything in my infrastructure from my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00542-00141174-00141323": "public cloud and obviously it should be", "MT6jw26h4M4-00543-00141324-00141635": "multi-cloud multi-account but also all", "MT6jw26h4M4-00544-00141636-00141875": "my relevant SAS applications like those", "MT6jw26h4M4-00545-00141876-00142102": "data dogs and two bonomic New Relic and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00546-00142103-00142259": "OCTA and so on and so forth and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00547-00142260-00142390": "obviously kubernetes serverless", "MT6jw26h4M4-00548-00142391-00142559": "openshift all the cloud native", "MT6jw26h4M4-00549-00142560-00142777": "Technologies then we need to understand", "MT6jw26h4M4-00550-00142778-00143057": "which parts of my cloud are managed with", "MT6jw26h4M4-00551-00143058-00143285": "infrastructure as code and which are not", "MT6jw26h4M4-00552-00143286-00143578": "the unmanaged resources are almost", "MT6jw26h4M4-00553-00143579-00143945": "worthless for ibom because if they are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00554-00143946-00144328": "not codified to let's say Helm or", "MT6jw26h4M4-00555-00144329-00144563": "terraform they are not scalable they are", "MT6jw26h4M4-00556-00144564-00144797": "not immutable and I can't re-replicate", "MT6jw26h4M4-00557-00144798-00145066": "them so it's problem last part I need to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00558-00145067-00145349": "understand the scale status per my", "MT6jw26h4M4-00559-00145350-00145559": "infrastructure the relationship and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00560-00145560-00145835": "dependencies and have a mindset of cloud", "MT6jw26h4M4-00561-00145836-00146099": "native it's not about listing where this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00562-00146100-00146345": "server in which physical racket lives", "MT6jw26h4M4-00563-00146346-00146602": "it's about which user deployed it who is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00564-00146603-00146711": "the owner", "MT6jw26h4M4-00565-00146712-00146999": "and what its status", "MT6jw26h4M4-00566-00147000-00147311": "so after we established the importance", "MT6jw26h4M4-00567-00147312-00147671": "of i-bomb and the cloud native cmdb we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00568-00147672-00148163": "need to understand why drifts are key or", "MT6jw26h4M4-00569-00148164-00148385": "eliminating drift remediating drift and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00570-00148386-00148709": "techno drift are key to keeping my eye", "MT6jw26h4M4-00571-00148710-00149023": "bomb always up to date and to establish", "MT6jw26h4M4-00572-00149024-00149387": "or handle deviations for my security or", "MT6jw26h4M4-00573-00149388-00149675": "my desired Baseline so a drift is every", "MT6jw26h4M4-00574-00149676-00149993": "deviation between or any gap between the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00575-00149994-00150202": "desired state of the cloud and the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00576-00150203-00150490": "actual state of the cloud right so it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00577-00150491-00150754": "means that I architected or I want to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00578-00150755-00150893": "create an architecture for my cloud to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00579-00150894-00151085": "look like a but in reality it looks like", "MT6jw26h4M4-00580-00151086-00151366": "B and what can cause this transfer from", "MT6jw26h4M4-00581-00151367-00151685": "A to B it can be someone a person doing", "MT6jw26h4M4-00582-00151686-00152002": "a change it can be a glitch in my cicd", "MT6jw26h4M4-00583-00152003-00152177": "pipeline it can be it can be enable it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00584-00152178-00152543": "can be a third party a SAS or a physical", "MT6jw26h4M4-00585-00152544-00152831": "vendor and doing changes to my cloud and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00586-00152832-00153061": "this many times is a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00587-00153062-00153407": "it creates Tech debt it it has a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00588-00153408-00153707": "production issues and errors sprawl in", "MT6jw26h4M4-00589-00153708-00153959": "and it generates a lot of hassle for the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00590-00153960-00154187": "Ops teams", "MT6jw26h4M4-00591-00154188-00154445": "so it's like Pokemons right we gotta", "MT6jw26h4M4-00592-00154446-00154589": "catch them all we gotta understand that", "MT6jw26h4M4-00593-00154590-00154811": "that if we architected the secure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00594-00154812-00155039": "baseline or a desired Baseline we need", "MT6jw26h4M4-00595-00155040-00155213": "to understand every deviation from it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00596-00155214-00155428": "and handle it as much as possible", "MT6jw26h4M4-00597-00155429-00155675": "without it ibom becomes irrelevant", "MT6jw26h4M4-00598-00155676-00155951": "become becomes out of date and this is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00599-00155952-00156173": "the whole point of eyeball always have a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00600-00156174-00156413": "detailed and accurate representation of", "MT6jw26h4M4-00601-00156414-00156647": "my infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00602-00156648-00156773": "so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00603-00156774-00157109": "final part here is after we established", "MT6jw26h4M4-00604-00157110-00157325": "i-bomb and we established how Rift", "MT6jw26h4M4-00605-00157326-00157511": "detection or remediation is important to", "MT6jw26h4M4-00606-00157512-00157613": "keep", "MT6jw26h4M4-00607-00157614-00157961": "um i-bomb efficient and updated we need", "MT6jw26h4M4-00608-00157962-00158219": "to understand we can try to think about", "MT6jw26h4M4-00609-00158220-00158669": "how we can take advantage of ibom and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00610-00158670-00158916": "one example is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00611-00158917-00159185": "ransomware resiliency", "MT6jw26h4M4-00612-00159186-00159328": "so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00613-00159329-00159569": "if everything in my infrastructure let's", "MT6jw26h4M4-00614-00159570-00159835": "say my cloud is properly configured", "MT6jw26h4M4-00615-00159836-00160090": "codified and documented", "MT6jw26h4M4-00616-00160091-00160337": "it's easy to set it up in a different", "MT6jw26h4M4-00617-00160338-00160523": "location in different clouds in the very", "MT6jw26h4M4-00618-00160524-00160763": "account in different region I'll share", "MT6jw26h4M4-00619-00160764-00160937": "another story", "MT6jw26h4M4-00620-00160938-00161237": "I think it was four weeks ago one of our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00621-00161238-00161407": "customers", "MT6jw26h4M4-00622-00161408-00161897": "tells us that they are being attacked", "MT6jw26h4M4-00623-00161898-00162185": "and there's an a ransomware incident", "MT6jw26h4M4-00624-00162186-00162376": "um for the OCTA configuration and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00625-00162377-00162545": "obviously you know if you take away our", "MT6jw26h4M4-00626-00162546-00162839": "OCTA we are locked out it's literally", "MT6jw26h4M4-00627-00162840-00163145": "the keys to production because we don't", "MT6jw26h4M4-00628-00163146-00163439": "have a kingdom just yet so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00629-00163440-00163619": "if you're", "MT6jw26h4M4-00630-00163620-00163763": "OCTA", "MT6jw26h4M4-00631-00163764-00164099": "is is being taken away from you you're", "MT6jw26h4M4-00632-00164100-00164537": "at a problem but if you made sure that", "MT6jw26h4M4-00633-00164538-00164797": "you always have your OCTA configuration", "MT6jw26h4M4-00634-00164798-00165125": "properly codified and let's say in this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00635-00165126-00165251": "case in terraform", "MT6jw26h4M4-00636-00165252-00165533": "and you can go back in time and and spin", "MT6jw26h4M4-00637-00165534-00165754": "up your telephone config your OCTA", "MT6jw26h4M4-00638-00165755-00165971": "configuration interform from two days", "MT6jw26h4M4-00639-00165972-00166193": "ago and I'll just do telephone apply for", "MT6jw26h4M4-00640-00166194-00166373": "it you're up and running and you don't", "MT6jw26h4M4-00641-00166374-00166601": "care about the ransomware attack so this", "MT6jw26h4M4-00642-00166602-00166804": "is one of the benefits of having eyebomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00643-00166805-00167026": "you're much more resilient", "MT6jw26h4M4-00644-00167027-00167387": "um to uh to ransomware and other service", "MT6jw26h4M4-00645-00167388-00167771": "failures", "MT6jw26h4M4-00646-00167772-00168089": "all right so conclusion", "MT6jw26h4M4-00647-00168090-00168587": "first part x-bomb mostly s-bomb is one", "MT6jw26h4M4-00648-00168588-00168778": "of the hottest buzzword currently on", "MT6jw26h4M4-00649-00168779-00169043": "this industrial years in security but", "MT6jw26h4M4-00650-00169044-00169264": "infrastructure and ibom was neglected", "MT6jw26h4M4-00651-00169265-00169528": "it's like we're taking our jewelry and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00652-00169529-00169781": "put it in a safe but the safe is in a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00653-00169782-00170033": "trailer and it's easy to to hijack the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00654-00170034-00170195": "trailer", "MT6jw26h4M4-00655-00170196-00170326": "so", "MT6jw26h4M4-00656-00170327-00170566": "I think we should all track our eye bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00657-00170567-00170813": "and understand how our infrastructure", "MT6jw26h4M4-00658-00170814-00171040": "looks like at any given point in time", "MT6jw26h4M4-00659-00171041-00171214": "and I think it's a professional must", "MT6jw26h4M4-00660-00171215-00171454": "from a security standpoint from a fin-up", "MT6jw26h4M4-00661-00171455-00171676": "standpoint from compliance and from just", "MT6jw26h4M4-00662-00171677-00171923": "you know being a professional I don't", "MT6jw26h4M4-00663-00171924-00172061": "need kubernetes and I don't need", "MT6jw26h4M4-00664-00172062-00172264": "serverless if I just want to to have", "MT6jw26h4M4-00665-00172265-00172481": "high scale at any cost without any", "MT6jw26h4M4-00666-00172482-00172661": "professional implications just spin up", "MT6jw26h4M4-00667-00172662-00172937": "lots of nginx servers and have any", "MT6jw26h4M4-00668-00172938-00173135": "requests handled super super quickly but", "MT6jw26h4M4-00669-00173136-00173351": "it's not a professional move to do same", "MT6jw26h4M4-00670-00173352-00173645": "goes to for ibom if you want to be", "MT6jw26h4M4-00671-00173646-00173819": "efficient I want to have a tight", "MT6jw26h4M4-00672-00173820-00174078": "platform I need an eye bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00673-00174079-00174383": "then we remember that the ogs the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00674-00174384-00174785": "original gangsters of it and and on-prem", "MT6jw26h4M4-00675-00174786-00174971": "data centers they understood the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00676-00174972-00175151": "importance of Ibraham and created the", "MT6jw26h4M4-00677-00175152-00175387": "cmdb but now let's think", "MT6jw26h4M4-00678-00175388-00175625": "which infrastructure is more complex", "MT6jw26h4M4-00679-00175626-00175961": "Legacy I.T or Cloud which changes faster", "MT6jw26h4M4-00680-00175962-00176152": "which has more technology advancement", "MT6jw26h4M4-00681-00176153-00176440": "which is touched by more and more teams", "MT6jw26h4M4-00682-00176441-00176764": "at a higher Pace I think we are much", "MT6jw26h4M4-00683-00176765-00176938": "more complex instead of just thinking", "MT6jw26h4M4-00684-00176939-00177076": "about s-bone we should all start", "MT6jw26h4M4-00685-00177077-00177311": "thinking about ibom", "MT6jw26h4M4-00686-00177312-00177676": "and the last part how to get started we", "MT6jw26h4M4-00687-00177677-00177881": "should start by inventory our Cloud", "MT6jw26h4M4-00688-00177882-00178097": "understand which part of our cloud is", "MT6jw26h4M4-00689-00178098-00178361": "properly codified which is unmanaged and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00690-00178362-00178751": "this is the basic building blocks for an", "MT6jw26h4M4-00691-00178752-00178907": "eye bomb", "MT6jw26h4M4-00692-00178908-00179164": "and with that I like to wish you all", "MT6jw26h4M4-00693-00179165-00179411": "that your infrastructure never drift and", "MT6jw26h4M4-00694-00179412-00179669": "you will never be a", "MT6jw26h4M4-00695-00179670-00180107": "hustled with a on-call in your weekend", "MT6jw26h4M4-00696-00180108-00180328": "if you like this talk you can rate it if", "MT6jw26h4M4-00697-00180329-00180502": "not you can also rate it", "MT6jw26h4M4-00698-00180503-00180725": "um I'll leave it up to you", "MT6jw26h4M4-00699-00180726-00181090": "and with that and just 15 seconds after", "MT6jw26h4M4-00700-00181091-00181426": "time I'm open to any question if any has", "MT6jw26h4M4-00701-00181427-00181588": "one", "MT6jw26h4M4-00702-00181589-00181727": "thank you", "MT6jw26h4M4-00703-00181728-00182190": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "MTkt1wx2QuE", "text": {"MTkt1wx2QuE-00000-00000000-00000286": "it is at this point that you see how", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00001-00000287-00000659": "economic theory understood as a", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00002-00000660-00001075": "framework that expels class conflict", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00003-00001076-00001457": "expels the worker as the source of value", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00004-00001458-00001834": "and instead tells us that the economy is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00005-00001835-00002134": "made up of individuals it's no longer", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00006-00002135-00002315": "the worker who counts but it's the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00007-00002316-00002549": "entrepreneur who is the driver of the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00008-00002550-00002867": "economic machine it's there that this", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00009-00002868-00003118": "economic theory that seems so apolitical", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00010-00003119-00003629": "is actually justifying the most classist", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00011-00003629-00004006": "set of economic policies of all", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00012-00004007-00004331": "hi everyone my name is Clara mate I'm", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00013-00004332-00004535": "assistant professor of Economics at the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00014-00004536-00004786": "new school for social research and my", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00015-00004787-00005077": "work focuses on the relation between", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00016-00005078-00005429": "economic theory and policy making so an", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00017-00005430-00005651": "interdisciplinary work that is both", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00018-00005652-00005909": "history of economic thought and economic", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00019-00005910-00006136": "history as well as methodology of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00020-00006137-00006487": "Economics so austerity has been", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00021-00006488-00006964": "so widely successful in shaping our", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00022-00006965-00007205": "societies and how we think about our", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00023-00007206-00007614": "society it has been fundamentally", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00024-00007615-00007991": "undetectable it is so normalized that we", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00025-00007992-00008207": "rarely Call It by name but it actually", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00026-00008208-00008477": "informs all the common tropes of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00027-00008478-00008710": "contemporary policy making from the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00028-00008711-00009035": "budget cuts specifically in welfare Cuts", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00029-00009036-00009449": "such as public spending for schools for", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00030-00009450-00009769": "universities for health care for housing", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00031-00009770-00010067": "unemployment benefits regressive", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00032-00010068-00010535": "taxation so we constantly see Cuts in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00033-00010536-00010756": "the highest brackets or Cuts in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00034-00010757-00011135": "corporate taxes and also hikes in the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00035-00011136-00011278": "interest rates which is of course", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00036-00011279-00011549": "something that we're seeing the FED is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00037-00011550-00011878": "undertaking at the present moment what I", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00038-00011879-00012287": "try to do in my work is re-problematize", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00039-00012288-00012688": "austerity austerity is everywhere it's", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00040-00012689-00012994": "all encompassing in our lives yet I", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00041-00012995-00013253": "don't think that Scholars have", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00042-00013254-00013565": "thoroughly been able to pinpoint why", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00043-00013566-00013877": "austerity is so successful and so", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00044-00013878-00014285": "enduring in a contemporary capitalism I", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00045-00014286-00014585": "wrote this book that took many years and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00046-00014586-00014807": "is coming out with Chicago University", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00047-00014808-00015130": "press beginning of November the book is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00048-00015131-00015455": "called the capital order how economists", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00049-00015456-00015725": "invented austerity and paved the wave to", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00050-00015726-00015929": "Fascism what I tried to do in this book", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00051-00015930-00016300": "is rethink austerity rethinking in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00052-00016301-00016733": "fundamentally three ways the first is to", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00053-00016734-00017086": "avoid considering austerity just as a", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00054-00017087-00017339": "matter of fiscal measures so it's not", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00055-00017340-00017663": "just about Cuts in the budget", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00056-00017664-00017933": "it's something more it's what I call the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00057-00017934-00018353": "austerity Trinity which includes the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00058-00018354-00018535": "mutual", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00059-00018536-00018965": "operation of fiscal policies so of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00060-00018966-00019139": "course both on the side of cutting and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00061-00019140-00019283": "on the side of the income through", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00062-00019284-00019685": "aggressive taxation monetary policy so", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00063-00019686-00019955": "interest rates hikes", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00064-00019956-00020236": "and Industrial policies and when I talk", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00065-00020237-00020417": "about industrial policies what I", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00066-00020418-00020783": "fundamentally mean is the fact that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00067-00020784-00021136": "there is a permanent attack on organized", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00068-00021137-00021557": "labor which can be cutting Union", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00069-00021558-00021827": "uh benefits curtailing the role of the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00070-00021828-00022157": "unions but also fundamentally securing", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00071-00022158-00022600": "wage flexibility and wage repression so", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00072-00022601-00022817": "this austerity Trinity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00073-00022818-00023122": "Works in unison and you cannot just", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00074-00023123-00023471": "focus on one aspect moreover what I try", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00075-00023472-00023644": "to say is that austerity is actually not", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00076-00023645-00023914": "just policy it's more it's actually the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00077-00023915-00024197": "amalgamation of policy and theory and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00078-00024198-00024389": "austerity is in fact very successful", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00079-00024390-00024661": "because it has a powerful set of theory", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00080-00024662-00024941": "backing it so this is the first main", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00081-00024942-00025241": "claim what austerity is it's both policy", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00082-00025242-00025480": "not just fiscal policy and it's also", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00083-00025481-00025708": "Theory and theory and policy cannot be", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00084-00025710-00026152": "separable secondly austerity is not the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00085-00026154-00026299": "product of the so-called near", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00086-00026300-00026699": "neo-liberal era of the 1970s austerity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00087-00026700-00026807": "is actually", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00088-00026808-00027064": "quite more fundamental to the operation", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00089-00027066-00027437": "of capitalism and its origin dates back", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00090-00027438-00027683": "to at least the beginning of the century", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00091-00027683-00027983": "and my claim is that austerity Finds Its", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00092-00027983-00028333": "Origins after the Great War so after", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00093-00028333-00028931": "1918 and it was a measure to react to a", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00094-00028932-00029249": "big crisis of capitalism austerity as", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00095-00029250-00029501": "the Mainstay of capitalism not just an", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00096-00029502-00029752": "exception but quite the norm", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00097-00029754-00030070": "and at this point the third claim I make", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00098-00030072-00030352": "is that austerity is not just a matter", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00099-00030354-00030661": "of irrationality of bad economic theory", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00100-00030662-00031043": "that thus informs a mistaken policy and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00101-00031044-00031318": "this is the reading of austerity that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00102-00031319-00031631": "many keynesians have but I think it's", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00103-00031632-00031877": "very simplistic because it does not", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00104-00031877-00032158": "really get to why then does austerity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00105-00032160-00032423": "persist and to really fundamentally", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00106-00032424-00032639": "understand why austerity persists we", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00107-00032639-00033046": "need to figure out its deeper logic and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00108-00033047-00033227": "this deeper logic", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00109-00033228-00033515": "is understandable if we think about", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00110-00033516-00033677": "austerity not", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00111-00033678-00034007": "as stabilizing economies necessarily", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00112-00034008-00034277": "right the reason why Mark Blythe calls", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00113-00034278-00034546": "austerity Madness it's because it has", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00114-00034547-00034824": "never really or very exceptionally", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00115-00034825-00035135": "achieved its stated goals of economic", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00116-00035136-00035243": "growth", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00117-00035244-00035621": "and debt repayment right so the tale of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00118-00035622-00035915": "expansionary austerity is certainly one", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00119-00035916-00036190": "that Economist espouse but has been", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00120-00036191-00036496": "often actually disproven by historical", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00121-00036497-00036893": "events so as I was saying austerity is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00122-00036894-00037109": "not necessarily successful in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00123-00037110-00037396": "stabilizing economies but it is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00124-00037397-00037631": "successful in something deeper and my", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00125-00037632-00037829": "bold claim in the book is that austerity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00126-00037830-00038177": "was really never about the end goal of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00127-00038178-00038435": "curtailing inflation and balanced", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00128-00038436-00038711": "budgets these were means to a greater", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00129-00038712-00038962": "end which is that of preserving the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00130-00038963-00039245": "capital order sousterity may not", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00131-00039246-00039593": "stabilize the economy but stabilizes", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00132-00039594-00039971": "what is actually the precondition for", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00133-00039972-00040205": "any capital accumulation and any", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00134-00040206-00040433": "preservation of our socio-economic", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00135-00040434-00040799": "system as a whole which is capital", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00136-00040800-00041068": "that comes from that's the title's", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00137-00041069-00041339": "motivation is the capital order what is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00138-00041340-00041555": "the capital order is the idea that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00139-00041556-00041867": "capital is not merely a commodity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00140-00041868-00042196": "so money invested to make more money", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00141-00042197-00042689": "but it's actually presupposes a specific", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00142-00042690-00043037": "social relation of production a specific", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00143-00043038-00043339": "class relation that requires", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00144-00043340-00043673": "stabilization if you don't secure the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00145-00043674-00043883": "preservation of this class relation that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00146-00043884-00044080": "is at the foundation of economic growth", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00147-00044081-00044345": "under capitalism then the system may be", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00148-00044346-00044639": "in crisis so the book explores the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00149-00044640-00044812": "origin of austerity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00150-00044813-00045029": "because I believe that in order to", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00151-00045030-00045196": "understand the logic of austerity still", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00152-00045197-00045508": "today you need to really go back after", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00153-00045509-00045689": "the first World War", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00154-00045690-00045995": "something unimaginable happened for the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00155-00045996-00046229": "people living at that time capitalism", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00156-00046230-00046571": "was shaken as at its very core the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00157-00046572-00046846": "pillars of capitalism what guarantees", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00158-00046847-00047171": "capital accumulation which is private", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00159-00047172-00047393": "property of the means of production and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00160-00047394-00047651": "wage relations so Capital as a class", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00161-00047652-00047999": "relation were shaken why were they", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00162-00048000-00048335": "shaken well because there had been a", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00163-00048336-00048473": "massive shock", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00164-00048474-00048761": "in the relation between the state and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00165-00048762-00049115": "the market the Great War the first world", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00166-00049116-00049493": "war was a moment in which the state in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00167-00049494-00049858": "order to guarantee economic Victory had", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00168-00049859-00050285": "to cross the natural boundaries of what", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00169-00050286-00050590": "it was normally meant to do the state", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00170-00050591-00050818": "became the main employer the main", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00171-00050819-00051179": "producer and actually the main regulator", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00172-00051180-00051516": "of the labor force in this way", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00173-00051517-00051894": "what used to be understood as natural", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00174-00051895-00052264": "Givens private property of the means of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00175-00052265-00052487": "production and wage relations were all", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00176-00052488-00052738": "of a sudden re-politicized what do I", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00177-00052739-00052942": "mean by this seems like a big word but", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00178-00052944-00053213": "it's actually quite simple workers and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00179-00053214-00053482": "the majority of citizens", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00180-00053483-00053735": "in Europe and I focus specifically on", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00181-00053736-00053915": "Britain and Italy and I will tell you", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00182-00053916-00054221": "why more later started realizing that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00183-00054222-00054461": "things could be different we could be", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00184-00054462-00054766": "living in a different social economic", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00185-00054767-00055103": "order capitalism was not a natural given", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00186-00055104-00055366": "it was a specific classist political", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00187-00055367-00055750": "choice in which the state was directly", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00188-00055751-00056057": "visibly intervening to coerce the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00189-00056058-00056375": "workers into greater exploitation in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00190-00056376-00056525": "order to win the war", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00191-00056526-00056741": "so after the first World War", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00192-00056741-00056915": "and this is what I discussed in the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00193-00056916-00057107": "first part of the book The Crisis of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00194-00057108-00057365": "capitalism this crisis was not just", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00195-00057366-00057604": "about an economic downturn was something", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00196-00057605-00057892": "much more it was about calls for", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00197-00057894-00058192": "economic democracy calls to overcome", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00198-00058194-00058516": "Capital as a class relation calls to", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00199-00058517-00059104": "actually regain sovereignty as producers", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00200-00059105-00059303": "um and fundamentally abolished the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00201-00059304-00059579": "profit motive and the private property", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00202-00059579-00059741": "of the means of production", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00203-00059741-00059932": "how did this happen it happened in many", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00204-00059933-00060221": "ways it happened through Guild socialism", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00205-00060222-00060394": "through", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00206-00060395-00060604": "um worker Council movements I go through", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00207-00060605-00060832": "a whole spectrum of practical", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00208-00060833-00061103": "possibilities for change that were also", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00209-00061104-00061342": "informed by different economic theory so", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00210-00061344-00061613": "Marx in economic theory that put at the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00211-00061614-00061816": "center stage the worker", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00212-00061817-00062050": "so what happens there and this is we get", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00213-00062051-00062254": "to the Crux of the matter", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00214-00062255-00062482": "in a moment in which capitalism was", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00215-00062483-00062711": "shaking in which there was deep", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00216-00062712-00062980": "uncertainty for the future", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00217-00062982-00063226": "the sense of contingency was everywhere", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00218-00063227-00063388": "not just from the side of the workers", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00219-00063389-00063538": "especially from the side of the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00220-00063539-00063838": "bourgeoisie who was really frightened on", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00221-00063839-00064109": "the news and on the Press about the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00222-00064110-00064325": "possible collapse of the socio-economic", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00223-00064326-00064516": "order and this is very clear also in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00224-00064517-00064888": "keynes's writing in 1919. this is when", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00225-00064889-00065213": "austerity is really born austerity is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00226-00065214-00065573": "born as a tool of reaction", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00227-00065574-00065944": "to prevent the collapse of capitalism as", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00228-00065945-00066221": "a classist social economic system so", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00229-00066222-00066406": "austerity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00230-00066407-00066576": "is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00231-00066577-00066929": "really a political project that was", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00232-00066930-00067306": "extremely successful in preventing", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00233-00067307-00067582": "foreclosing alternatives to capitalism", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00234-00067583-00067949": "and how did that happen well I", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00235-00067950-00068165": "reconstruct the first International", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00236-00068166-00068465": "Financial conferences in Brussels and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00237-00068466-00068599": "Genoa", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00238-00068600-00069161": "1919 1922 in which experts economists", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00239-00069162-00069529": "for the first time were called to advise", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00240-00069530-00069887": "States all over Europe and to tell them", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00241-00069888-00070253": "what was the true economic doctrine that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00242-00070254-00070475": "should be implemented in order to", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00243-00070476-00070625": "prevent the collapse", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00244-00070626-00070894": "and this is the big relationship between", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00245-00070895-00071213": "austerity and technocracy technocracy", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00246-00071214-00071513": "meaning the rule of economic experts in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00247-00071514-00071850": "advising governments but more than this", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00248-00071851-00072311": "technocracy as an epistemic stance by", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00249-00072312-00072526": "which experts", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00250-00072527-00072917": "can come up with theories that are above", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00251-00072918-00073193": "classes that are neutral objective", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00252-00073194-00073631": "without any sort of bias and thus the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00253-00073632-00073906": "expert as the guide", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00254-00073907-00074099": "to the solution", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00255-00074100-00074453": "and to the prosperity of all so very", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00256-00074454-00074675": "much apolitical Theory and of course", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00257-00074676-00074873": "this was grounded in the growing", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00258-00074874-00075106": "marginalist framework the origin of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00259-00075107-00075305": "neoclassical economics that still", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00260-00075306-00075593": "dominates to this day is really dated at", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00261-00075594-00075893": "the end of the 19th century but was", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00262-00075894-00076325": "really kind of spreading and becoming", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00263-00076326-00076517": "ingrained", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00264-00076518-00076853": "in the years of the birth of austerity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00265-00076854-00077261": "in the 1920s so it is at this point that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00266-00077262-00077617": "you see how economic theory understood", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00267-00077618-00078017": "as a framework that expels class", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00268-00078018-00078162": "conflict", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00269-00078163-00078550": "expels the worker as the source of value", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00270-00078551-00078923": "and instead tells us that the economy is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00271-00078924-00079294": "made up of individuals that are not in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00272-00079295-00079469": "conflict with one another but they're", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00273-00079470-00079781": "actually in Harmony and that it's no", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00274-00079782-00079967": "longer the worker who counts but it's", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00275-00079968-00080206": "the entrepreneur who is the driver of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00276-00080207-00080512": "the economic machine it's there that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00277-00080513-00080735": "this economic theory that seems so", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00278-00080736-00081088": "apolitical is actually justifying the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00279-00081089-00081299": "most classist", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00280-00081300-00081623": "set of economic policies of all and", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00281-00081624-00081947": "again we need this Theory that in its", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00282-00081948-00082259": "classless guise is able to justify", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00283-00082260-00082469": "policies", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00284-00082470-00082703": "the Trinity the austerity Trinity of", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00285-00082704-00082912": "fiscal monetary industrial austerity", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00286-00082913-00083225": "that serve to crush the voice of the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00287-00083226-00083521": "workers in a very material way", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00288-00083522-00083825": "susterity as a tool", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00289-00083826-00084041": "as a political project", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00290-00084042-00084250": "that is at once", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00291-00084251-00084671": "about constructing consensus for the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00292-00084672-00084911": "capitals capitalist order", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00293-00084912-00085079": "through", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00294-00085080-00085288": "mainstream economic theory that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00295-00085289-00085637": "justifies the priority of this saving", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00296-00085638-00085921": "investing Elite as the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00297-00085922-00086261": "real engine of the economic machine that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00298-00086262-00086488": "thus should be incentivized", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00299-00086489-00086806": "and austerity as coercion through these", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00300-00086807-00087005": "policies that in fact", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00301-00087006-00087394": "austerity policies are nothing but the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00302-00087395-00087725": "shifting of resources from the majority", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00303-00087726-00088055": "that at that time was empowered", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00304-00088056-00088326": "wage Shares are very high after the war", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00305-00088327-00088697": "the red biennium 1918 to 1920 in which", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00306-00088698-00088859": "the workers were raising their voices", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00307-00088860-00089159": "not just for higher wages but for a", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00308-00089160-00089399": "really different socio-economic order", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00309-00089400-00089621": "austerity serves", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00310-00089622-00090053": "to disempower them materially speaking", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00311-00090054-00090329": "and how does this happen well either", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00312-00090330-00090611": "directly through policies that actually", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00313-00090612-00090971": "make strikes illegal such as in Italy", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00314-00090972-00091217": "and curtail wages and this is what", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00315-00091218-00091499": "happens under Mussolini's Italy but also", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00316-00091500-00091859": "indirectly by creating an economic", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00317-00091860-00092188": "downturn so monetary deflation what we", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00318-00092189-00092459": "see actually being the main policy", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00319-00092460-00092656": "agenda now at the Fed", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00320-00092657-00092938": "monetary deflation together with budget", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00321-00092939-00093268": "cuts have also the indirect effect that", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00322-00093269-00093449": "very important direct effect of slowing", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00323-00093450-00093641": "down the economy creating higher", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00324-00093642-00093785": "unemployment", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00325-00093786-00094000": "which of course kills the bargaining", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00326-00094001-00094218": "power of the workers and thus", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00327-00094219-00094529": "subordinates them in a coercive way into", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00328-00094530-00094835": "accepting the capital order so we see", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00329-00094836-00095081": "how there's a direct and indirect shift", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00330-00095082-00095435": "of resources and of political power from", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00331-00095436-00095741": "the majority to the minority and in this", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00332-00095742-00096088": "austerity is successful and it has what", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00333-00096089-00096268": "I tried to show in the book is that the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00334-00096269-00096532": "origin story only really makes more", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00335-00096533-00096826": "explicit given that it is a moment in", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00336-00096827-00097073": "which everyone recognizes class conflict", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00337-00097074-00097355": "as the driving feature of the historical", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00338-00097356-00097817": "moment makes only more explicit what is", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00339-00097818-00098165": "more nuanced and hidden today", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00340-00098166-00098399": "so this is why we need to take history", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00341-00098400-00098753": "seriously is that if you understand the", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00342-00098754-00099023": "moment in which austerity was born you", "MTkt1wx2QuE-00343-00099024-00099398": "can really figure out its logic"}}]