[{"audio_id": "cmkCSw0AKNk", "text": {"cmkCSw0AKNk-00000-00000012-00000095": "foreign", "cmkCSw0AKNk-00001-00000096-00001496": "[Music]", "cmkCSw0AKNk-00002-00001497-00002629": "[Music]", "cmkCSw0AKNk-00003-00002630-00003167": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "cmDFg-g6IFo", "text": {"cmDFg-g6IFo-00000-00000008-00000151": "i'm going to spend the next three", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00001-00000152-00000390": "minutes talking to you about", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00002-00000391-00000638": "24-hour credit inquiry and whether or", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00003-00000639-00000831": "not that's legitimate and if it's", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00004-00000832-00001007": "something that you should consider doing", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00005-00001008-00001166": "for those of you who don't know me i am", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00006-00001167-00001454": "tanya taylor and i teach people how to", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00007-00001455-00001702": "repair their credit budget", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00008-00001703-00001934": "manage their debt and invest as well as", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00009-00001935-00002071": "a host of other wealth building", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00010-00002072-00002287": "strategies in every video that i do you", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00011-00002288-00002550": "will get an implementable strategy that", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00012-00002551-00002726": "you can start putting in place right", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00013-00002727-00002839": "away", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00014-00002840-00003087": "for this video i have a completely free", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00015-00003088-00003351": "guide on how to dispute item on your", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00016-00003352-00003590": "credit report if you are interested in", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00017-00003592-00003863": "that just put a comment below", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00018-00003864-00004063": "free guide and i will get that over to", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00019-00004064-00004319": "you so as i said before i'm going to be", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00020-00004320-00004454": "talking about", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00021-00004455-00004719": "24-hour credit repair and whether or not", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00022-00004720-00005118": "it's legal so one it really is legal but", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00023-00005119-00005391": "there is a caveat so first of all there", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00024-00005392-00005622": "are really only two scenarios under", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00025-00005623-00005918": "which you can have that 24 hour credit", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00026-00005919-00006111": "repair work for you and i want you to", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00027-00006112-00006334": "listen carefully because it's very", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00028-00006335-00006575": "important that you follow these steps", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00029-00006576-00006910": "and these have to do with hard inquiry", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00030-00006911-00007095": "that's on your credit report", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00031-00007095-00007270": "so generally when you get your credit", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00032-00007272-00007463": "report if you take a look at it you will", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00033-00007464-00007574": "see", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00034-00007575-00007814": "two different types of inquiry one is", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00035-00007815-00008063": "called a soft incorrect and it has no", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00036-00008064-00008214": "impact on your credit report so you", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00037-00008215-00008359": "really don't need to do anything about", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00038-00008360-00008559": "it and then there is what's called a", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00039-00008560-00008839": "hard inquiry and how that comes about is", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00040-00008840-00009223": "generally if you authorize a company to", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00041-00009224-00009383": "look at your credit file so if you're", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00042-00009384-00009591": "applying for a mortgage or if you are", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00043-00009592-00009855": "applying for a new loan or something of", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00044-00009856-00010078": "that nature but you have given", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00045-00010079-00010351": "authorization to have your credit report", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00046-00010352-00010542": "pulled now if you look at your credit", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00047-00010543-00010831": "report and you see hard inquiries that", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00048-00010832-00011078": "you did not authorize it could mean that", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00049-00011079-00011335": "you are a victim of identity that or or", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00050-00011336-00011574": "a company just pulled your credit report", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00051-00011575-00011855": "without your authorization and you can", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00052-00011856-00012142": "actually have that removed", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00053-00012143-00012423": "and the process that you go through is", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00054-00012424-00012542": "as follows", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00055-00012543-00012631": "one", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00056-00012632-00012943": "you cannot pay someone to do this a lot", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00057-00012944-00013094": "of times you see people online and", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00058-00013095-00013271": "they're saying we can repair your credit", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00059-00013272-00013486": "in 24 hours and they're charging you a", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00060-00013487-00013575": "fee", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00061-00013576-00013830": "if you try to pay someone to do it the", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00062-00013831-00014103": "person is going to be impersonating you", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00063-00014104-00014463": "you contact the company yourself because", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00064-00014463-00014735": "the company will only speak to you so", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00065-00014736-00014903": "make sure that you are doing this", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00066-00014904-00015158": "yourself that's the first criteria you", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00067-00015159-00015391": "do not need to pay anyone to do this and", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00068-00015391-00015694": "the second criteria is that you must", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00069-00015695-00016071": "have a legitimate reason for calling the", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00070-00016072-00016335": "company to have this removed and your", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00071-00016336-00016599": "reason could be i did not authorize this", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00072-00016600-00016863": "company to pull my credit file or i am a", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00073-00016864-00017047": "victim of identity theft", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00074-00017048-00017335": "my identification was stolen so once you", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00075-00017336-00017422": "call", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00076-00017423-00017647": "you call yourself and you have your", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00077-00017648-00017991": "legitimate reason they will remove this", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00078-00017992-00018167": "hard inquiry from your credit report", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00079-00018168-00018543": "within 24 hours now heart inquiry does", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00080-00018544-00018839": "pull your credit score down if you have", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00081-00018840-00019158": "too many so if you are having a number", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00082-00019159-00019430": "of those removed you can see an increase", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00083-00019431-00019647": "in your credit score in a very short", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00084-00019648-00019814": "period of time so in this video i", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00085-00019815-00019975": "promised that i would talk to you about", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00086-00019976-00020271": "whether or not 24 hour credit repair is", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00087-00020272-00020591": "legitimate and or legal and as i have", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00088-00020592-00020830": "demonstrated to you it is", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00089-00020831-00021063": "so you definitely want to pull your", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00090-00021064-00021271": "credit report check to see if there's a", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00091-00021272-00021503": "lot of inquiries on it that you did not", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00092-00021504-00021758": "authorize and get those removed so that", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00093-00021759-00021967": "you can increase your credit score again", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00094-00021968-00022303": "i have this free guide on how you can", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00095-00022304-00022543": "dispute item on your credit report just", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00096-00022544-00022703": "put in the comments below if you'd like", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00097-00022704-00022911": "to have this report and i will be happy", "cmDFg-g6IFo-00098-00022912-00023192": "to share it with you"}}, {"audio_id": "cmIOeUYao1u", "text": {"cmIOeUYao1u-00000-00000006-00000161": "if you want to land the quarter Circle", "cmIOeUYao1u-00001-00000162-00000503": "forward one after the crew kick it's a", "cmIOeUYao1u-00002-00000504-00000916": "micro side step right and I mean micro", "cmIOeUYao1u-00003-00000917-00001253": "as you can see by this replay here this", "cmIOeUYao1u-00004-00001254-00001487": "is the only repeatable version", "cmIOeUYao1u-00005-00001488-00001691": "um there's another angle off a side step", "cmIOeUYao1u-00006-00001692-00001895": "left but you have to be like", "cmIOeUYao1u-00007-00001896-00002123": "within like a two degree", "cmIOeUYao1u-00008-00002124-00002476": "variance for it to even hit so yeah this", "cmIOeUYao1u-00009-00002477-00002710": "is strictly combo video stuffed don't", "cmIOeUYao1u-00010-00002711-00002926": "bother trying to set up this thing in a", "cmIOeUYao1u-00011-00002927-00003206": "match you're gonna fail"}}, {"audio_id": "cn7Py3K7NU4", "text": {"cn7Py3K7NU4-00000-00000504-00000703": "where are we right now we're excellent", "cn7Py3K7NU4-00001-00000704-00000983": "part what's really going on here kids", "cn7Py3K7NU4-00002-00000984-00001166": "jumping", "cn7Py3K7NU4-00003-00001167-00002918": "getting up from this life", "cn7Py3K7NU4-00004-00002919-00003379": "everywhere and crashing into each other"}}, {"audio_id": "cnjA0IiwiDk", "text": {"cnjA0IiwiDk-00000-00000048-00000231": "for this problem we want to graph the", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00001-00000231-00000366": "circle with the equation", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00002-00000367-00000711": "x minus 4 squared plus y minus 4 squared", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00003-00000712-00000975": "equals 16. by taking a look at the", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00004-00000976-00001095": "standard form", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00005-00001096-00001350": "we know that our h is equal to 4 k is", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00006-00001351-00001462": "equal to 4", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00007-00001463-00001663": "which means that the center is located", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00008-00001664-00001798": "at 4 4.", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00009-00001800-00002014": "now we take a look at r squared which is", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00010-00002016-00002151": "equal to 16.", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00011-00002152-00002367": "this means that the radius r is equal to", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00012-00002368-00002550": "the square root of 16", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00013-00002551-00002791": "which is equal to 4. now we can graph", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00014-00002792-00002887": "our circle", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00015-00002888-00003215": "the center is at 4 4", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00016-00003215-00003454": "and since the radius is equal to 4 our", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00017-00003455-00003599": "outside points are at 4", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00018-00003600-00003919": "8 8 4 4 0", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00019-00003920-00004135": "and 0 4. connecting the points we get", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00020-00004136-00004270": "the graph of the circle", "cnjA0IiwiDk-00021-00004271-00004687": "and this is the final answer"}}, {"audio_id": "cnAOSJl9GUu", "text": {"cnAOSJl9GUu-00000-00000008-00000354": "through the impossible dream", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00001-00000355-00001262": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00002-00001263-00001566": "there's no escape for you the high table", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00003-00001567-00003269": "wants your life", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00004-00003270-00004222": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00005-00004223-00005854": "i can't help you to reach", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00006-00005855-00006058": "do you expect me to make it out", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00007-00006059-00006806": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00008-00006808-00007078": "a 14 million dollar bounty on his head", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00009-00007079-00008199": "and", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00010-00008200-00008510": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00011-00008511-00008660": "dark five seconds", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00012-00008661-00009317": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00013-00009318-00009710": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00014-00009711-00010063": "in effect in three two", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00015-00010064-00010511": "one rick is", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00016-00010512-00010630": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00017-00010631-00011076": "[Applause]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00018-00011077-00011351": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00019-00011352-00013991": "and here we go", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00020-00013991-00015750": "to follow stars", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00021-00015751-00016883": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00022-00016884-00017358": "oh", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00023-00017359-00018021": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00024-00018022-00018739": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00025-00018740-00019487": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00026-00019488-00019683": "[Applause]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00027-00019684-00019935": "sofia we're not going in like the old", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00028-00019936-00020758": "days", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00029-00020759-00021103": "it's the conversation nothing's ever", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00030-00021104-00021322": "just a conversation with you john", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00031-00021323-00021719": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00032-00021720-00022896": "you and you're with me", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00033-00022897-00024270": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00034-00024271-00025110": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00035-00025111-00025900": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00036-00025901-00027149": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00037-00027150-00027675": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00038-00027676-00028505": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00039-00028506-00029446": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00040-00029447-00030320": "this is canal street", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00041-00030322-00030918": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00042-00030919-00032688": "the next stop is", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00043-00032689-00034472": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00044-00034473-00035626": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00045-00035627-00036639": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00046-00036640-00038087": "this is rector street", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00047-00038088-00040081": "this is", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00048-00040082-00041244": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00049-00041245-00042083": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00050-00042084-00044672": "so", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00051-00044673-00044883": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00052-00044884-00045399": "uh", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00053-00045400-00047564": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00054-00047565-00049083": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00055-00049084-00049734": "uh", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00056-00049735-00052228": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00057-00052229-00053282": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00058-00053283-00053847": "uh", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00059-00053848-00055271": "nyc we hope", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00060-00055272-00056719": "allowing for a new perspective", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00061-00056720-00058375": "you are now exiting", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00062-00058376-00058671": "the blade is in your aorta you pull it", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00063-00058672-00059209": "out you will bleed and you will die", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00064-00059210-00060159": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00065-00060160-00062447": "consider this a professional curtiss", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00066-00062448-00064790": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00067-00064791-00066382": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00068-00066383-00069163": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00069-00069164-00070082": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00070-00070083-00070221": "hmm", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00071-00070222-00071196": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00072-00071197-00071712": "[Music]", "cnAOSJl9GUu-00073-00071713-00072028": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "cnLY1hno0BE", "text": {"cnLY1hno0BE-00000-00000003-00000329": "and finally new rules since this is our", "cnLY1hno0BE-00001-00000330-00000503": "last show before the holidays let's", "cnLY1hno0BE-00002-00000504-00000659": "remember to never lose sight of the true", "cnLY1hno0BE-00003-00000660-00000932": "meaning of the season it's not about", "cnLY1hno0BE-00004-00000933-00001162": "presents and fruitcake and putting up", "cnLY1hno0BE-00005-00001163-00001370": "extra lights to show that you love Jesus", "cnLY1hno0BE-00006-00001371-00001646": "more than your neighbor it's about a", "cnLY1hno0BE-00007-00001647-00002089": "teenage virgin getting knocked up by God", "cnLY1hno0BE-00008-00002090-00002507": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "cnQsyB8Z74g", "text": {"cnQsyB8Z74g-00000-00000343-00001020": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00001-00001021-00001237": "thank you", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00002-00001238-00001902": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00003-00001903-00002771": "[Applause]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00004-00002772-00003497": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00005-00003497-00006583": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00006-00006584-00006970": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00007-00006972-00007275": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00008-00007276-00010091": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00009-00010092-00010327": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00010-00010328-00013157": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00011-00013158-00014477": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00012-00014478-00021853": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00013-00021854-00022628": "thank you", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00014-00022629-00025081": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00015-00025082-00025656": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00016-00025657-00025925": "thank you", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00017-00025926-00027032": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00018-00027033-00028012": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00019-00028013-00028189": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00020-00028191-00028955": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00021-00028956-00029633": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00022-00029635-00033457": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00023-00033458-00033732": "thank you", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00024-00033733-00036523": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00025-00036524-00036796": "thank you", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00026-00036797-00037181": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00027-00037182-00038885": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00028-00038886-00039859": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00029-00039860-00040778": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00030-00040779-00041965": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00031-00041966-00042635": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00032-00042636-00042769": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00033-00042770-00043646": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00034-00043647-00044794": "[Applause]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00035-00044795-00045479": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00036-00045480-00045738": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00037-00045739-00046467": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00038-00046468-00047083": "[Applause]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00039-00047084-00048126": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00040-00048127-00048820": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00041-00048821-00049392": "[Applause]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00042-00049393-00049817": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00043-00049818-00050124": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00044-00050125-00051836": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00045-00051837-00055499": "[Music]", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00046-00055500-00057774": "foreign", "cnQsyB8Z74g-00047-00057775-00058130": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "cnaPYKsV4cU", "text": {"cnaPYKsV4cU-00000-00000043-00000461": "William Bell Waite 1839 to 1916 was a", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00001-00000462-00000653": "teacher in the New York Institute for", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00002-00000654-00000848": "the education of the blind who invented", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00003-00000849-00001049": "New York point a system of writing for", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00004-00001050-00001244": "the blind that was adopted widely in the", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00005-00001245-00001450": "United States before the Braille system", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00006-00001451-00001732": "was universally adopted there mr. Waide", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00007-00001734-00001889": "also applied the New York point", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00008-00001889-00002101": "principles to adapt them for use in over", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00009-00002102-00002345": "20 languages created a form of New York", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00010-00002346-00002546": "point to notate music and invented a", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00011-00002547-00002743": "number of devices to better type and", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00012-00002744-00002939": "print embossed material for the visually", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00013-00002940-00003492": "impaired", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00014-00003493-00004116": "topic education and early life", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00015-00004117-00004325": "wait grew up in New York and attended", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00016-00004326-00004550": "the Albany Academy and later the Albany", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00017-00004551-00004902": "normal College in 1859 subsequent to", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00018-00004903-00005079": "graduating he obtained a teaching", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00019-00005080-00005268": "position at the New York Institute for", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00020-00005269-00005445": "the education of the blind where he", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00021-00005446-00005691": "spent two years he then went on to study", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00022-00005692-00006000": "under tremon in Peckham in Albany he was", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00023-00006001-00006318": "called to the bar in 1862 he was acting", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00024-00006319-00006495": "first Superintendent of the City of", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00025-00006495-00006866": "Kingston NY School District in 1863 in", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00026-00006867-00007223": "October 1863 he was appointed principal", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00027-00007225-00007377": "of the New York Institute for the", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00028-00007378-00007518": "education of the blind", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00029-00007519-00007770": "he served in this capacity until March", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00030-00007770-00008043": "1905 he was subsequently appointed", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00031-00008044-00008255": "emeritus principal and served until his", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00032-00008256-00008916": "death in 1916", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00033-00008917-00009437": "topic inventions", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00034-00009438-00009778": "you", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00035-00009779-00010344": "topic New York point system", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00036-00010345-00010589": "we developed a keen interested in raised", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00037-00010590-00010788": "letters and tried to devise a tangible", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00038-00010789-00011039": "printing and writing system he later", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00039-00011040-00011232": "developed the New York point system in", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00040-00011233-00011355": "which points were used to represent", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00041-00011356-00011639": "letters or their sound this system", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00042-00011640-00011952": "contained 26 capitals 26 small letters", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00043-00011953-00012192": "numerals punctuation marks and short", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00044-00012193-00012352": "forms for diphthongs triphthongs", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00045-00012353-00012578": "syllables and four words and parts of", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00046-00012579-00012824": "words in common use he was awarded", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00047-00012825-00013032": "medals at the Chilean exposition an", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00048-00013033-00013335": "international exposition in 1873 for", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00049-00013336-00013578": "these accomplishments before his death", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00050-00013579-00013803": "Wade oversaw the adaptation of his point", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00051-00013804-00013955": "system to more than 20 different", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00052-00013956-00014178": "languages including Hebrew Arabic", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00053-00014179-00014816": "Japanese and Chinese", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00054-00014816-00015349": "topic other inventions", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00055-00015350-00015538": "he followed his inventions with a", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00056-00015538-00015900": "tangible musical notation system in 1872", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00057-00015901-00016234": "he completed the Claddagh graph in 1894", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00058-00016235-00016468": "this machine is much like a typewriter", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00059-00016469-00016639": "which could be used for embossing the", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00060-00016640-00016798": "raised letters of the New York point", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00061-00016799-00017125": "system onto paper he invented the stereo", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00062-00017126-00017347": "graph this machine was used for metal", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00063-00017348-00017542": "plate embossing to facilitate bulk", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00064-00017543-00017698": "printing of books for the visually", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00065-00017699-00017758": "impaired", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00066-00017759-00017974": "he received the john scott most", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00067-00017975-00018127": "deserving medal from the Franklin", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00068-00018128-00018397": "Institute of Philadelphia in 1904 his", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00069-00018398-00018712": "inventions he later developed a printing", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00070-00018713-00018919": "press which used a breakthrough process", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00071-00018920-00019084": "which allowed for embossing on dual", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00072-00019085-00019414": "sides of a book page he also formulated", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00073-00019415-00019630": "more economic and durable methods of", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00074-00019631-00019819": "book binding reducing the long term", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00075-00019820-00020416": "costs of printing", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00076-00020417-00020996": "topic other accomplishments", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00077-00020997-00021260": "William B wait founded the following", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00078-00021261-00021596": "organizations American Association of", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00079-00021597-00021998": "instructors of the blind 1871 Society", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00080-00021999-00022190": "for providing evangelical religious", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00081-00022191-00022841": "literature for the blind 1874", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00082-00022842-00023392": "topic publications", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00083-00023393-00023700": "William B wait wrote the following books", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00084-00023701-00023978": "the normal course of piano technique", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00085-00023979-00024574": "1887 harmonic notation 1888 phases of", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00086-00024575-00024775": "Punk'd ography in relation to visual", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00087-00024776-00025030": "typography writing printing bookbinding", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00088-00025031-00025405": "and other features 1900 the uniform type", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00089-00025406-00025642": "question an examination of the report of", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00090-00025643-00025937": "the uniform type committee of June 1913", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00091-00025938-00026317": "1915 new aspects of the uniform type", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00092-00026318-00026877": "folly 1916", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00093-00026877-00027408": "topic see also", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00094-00027408-00027838": "blindness and education Braille Braille", "cnaPYKsV4cU-00095-00027839-00028270": "music Perkins Brailler"}}, {"audio_id": "cnb9s1I4NT0", "text": {"cnb9s1I4NT0-00000-00000003-00000356": "naxi autumn IPA and i also known as nike", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00001-00000357-00000743": "nasi loamy moso Mosu is a sino-tibetan", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00002-00000744-00000986": "language or group of languages spoken by", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00003-00000986-00001178": "some three hundred ten thousand people", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00004-00001179-00001403": "most of whom live in or around li jiang", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00005-00001404-00001670": "city you long naxi autonomous county you", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00006-00001671-00001868": "long gnocchi's whose is he and you long", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00007-00001869-00002150": "now she's Uzi ji Xian of the province of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00008-00002151-00002459": "Yunnan China Nike is also the ethnic", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00009-00002460-00002648": "group that speaks it although in detail", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00010-00002649-00002846": "officially defined ethnicity and", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00011-00002847-00003034": "linguistic reality do not coincide", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00012-00003035-00003269": "neatly there are speakers of naxi who", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00013-00003270-00003500": "are not registered as naxi and citizens", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00014-00003501-00003710": "who are officially naxi but do not speak", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00015-00003711-00003965": "it classification it is commonly", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00016-00003965-00004190": "proposed in Chinese scholarship that the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00017-00004191-00004420": "NAIC languages are low low Burmese", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00018-00004421-00004711": "languages for instance zero Lama 2012", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00019-00004712-00004954": "classifies naxi as part of AD noxus", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00020-00004955-00005254": "branch of low lowish however as early as", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00021-00005255-00005585": "1975 sino-tibetan linguist David Bradley", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00022-00005586-00005756": "pointed out that nah she does not", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00023-00005757-00005942": "partake in the shared innovations that", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00024-00005943-00006226": "define low lowish third good and LaToya", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00025-00006227-00006491": "2003 state that the position of nah she", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00026-00006492-00006673": "is still unclear despite much", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00027-00006675-00006887": "speculation and leave it in classified", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00028-00006888-00007142": "within sino-tibetan Guillaume Jacques", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00029-00007143-00007439": "and Alexis me show 2011 classified naxi", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00030-00007440-00007648": "within the national or level subgroup of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00031-00007650-00007895": "sino-tibetan in turn Nash is part of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00032-00007895-00008167": "NAIC itself part of a proposed not", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00033-00008168-00008471": "changing branch dialects naxi in the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00034-00008472-00008696": "broad sense including not masuo was", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00035-00008697-00008876": "initially split by the linguists he", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00036-00008877-00009077": "Gyrene and John GE into two major", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00037-00009078-00009317": "clusters Western naxi and Eastern naxi", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00038-00009318-00009626": "Western naxi naxi ueshiba Fang Yan is", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00039-00009627-00009908": "fairly homogeneous it is spoken mainly", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00040-00009909-00010205": "in Li Jiang Zhang dyin shangri-la like C", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00041-00010206-00010451": "and yunxiang counties smaller", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00042-00010452-00010703": "populations of Western naxi speakers are", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00043-00010704-00010921": "found in hacking Jansch Wan land ping", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00044-00010922-00011183": "Deacon GaN Xiang Ning glean in Babbage", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00045-00011184-00011426": "Engvall edge Bop hi John conn-young in", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00046-00011427-00011687": "Township Yong Ming Chang Liu Li in E yaa", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00047-00011688-00011992": "yaa Yanbian down judo Jiu and Tibet in", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00048-00011993-00012299": "banking Bangkok there are over 240", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00049-00012300-00012542": "thousand speakers total Western naxi", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00050-00012543-00012796": "consists of the Diane Lee Jenga and Bao", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00051-00012797-00012913": "Shan Zhou dialects", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00052-00012914-00013394": "Nachi you Jan zp 752 Dian Dian", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00053-00013394-00013643": "within li-jiang County this dialect is", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00054-00013644-00013922": "spoken in Diane town Diane Jenn and also", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00055-00013922-00014186": "in Vizag II by shaji a shoe shoe", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00056-00014187-00014455": "hey Jia Axius she thousand ouch in", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00057-00014456-00014549": "dal-gu Zane", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00058-00014550-00014794": "dal-gu Jaya and Glen's a Duong Jai by", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00059-00014795-00015104": "just over 50,000 people Li Jiang will", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00060-00015105-00015341": "leave John Baum spoken mostly within Li", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00061-00015341-00015515": "Jiang County and in the counties of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00062-00015516-00015818": "Zhang Jian Wieck C yunxiang Deacon GaN", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00063-00015819-00016235": "Xiang etc by 180 thousand people baoshan", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00064-00016236-00016490": "Zhao Gao Xiang Jo spoken in baoshan", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00065-00016491-00016750": "baoshan in Gulu Gulu Oh in li jiang", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00066-00016751-00016988": "county by just over ten thousand people", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00067-00016989-00017228": "Eastern no she not she you dongbu Fang", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00068-00017229-00017422": "yen consists of several mutually", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00069-00017423-00017699": "unintelligible varieties it is spoken", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00070-00017700-00017936": "mainly in Yan Yu and Liu Li and Yandy", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00071-00017937-00018212": "and counties Eastern nah she is also", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00072-00018213-00018430": "spoken by smaller populations in Yong", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00073-00018431-00018703": "Cheng in zunzun and John Zi Dan like see", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00074-00018704-00018950": "in Kazan cheese on and Li Jiang inhale", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00075-00018951-00019180": "on high long and faint funky counties", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00076-00019181-00019514": "there is a total of over 40,000 speakers", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00077-00019515-00019900": "nah see you Jan's EP 750 for young", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00078-00019901-00020228": "England in BA on annum and 13 nah spoken", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00079-00020229-00020438": "in mingling in yawning by Yong Ming ba", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00080-00020439-00020714": "and Yan Yu and there is also a group of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00081-00020715-00020966": "about 100 naxi households in Wieck C", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00082-00020967-00021272": "County who have the on mmm 33 leaf 55 m", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00083-00021273-00021631": "33 33 this language is referred to in", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00084-00021632-00021844": "English language scholarship as now or", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00085-00021845-00021893": "Narula", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00086-00021894-00022361": "by Cuba Bay Cuba onam and 33 she 33 now", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00087-00022362-00022592": "ain't spoken in mingling in by Cuba Bay", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00088-00022593-00022828": "Cuba and yunxiang in Chao Feng shaofeng", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00089-00022829-00023209": "and zunzun and Johnse Dan guava guava a", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00090-00023210-00023609": "Onam and 33 z33 Naru spoken in Yanbian", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00091-00023610-00023903": "in guava guava a and muli in Bow Wow Bow", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00092-00023904-00024227": "Wow and Li Li AO usage according to the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00093-00024228-00024472": "2000 Chinese census three hundred ten", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00094-00024473-00024680": "thousand people speak na ki and one", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00095-00024681-00024784": "hundred thousand of those are", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00096-00024785-00025202": "monolingual approximately 170,000 speak", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00097-00025203-00025450": "Chinese to bed and by or English as a", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00098-00025451-00025555": "second language", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00099-00025556-00025837": "almost all speakers live in Yunnan but", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00100-00025838-00026024": "some are in Tibet and it is possible", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00101-00026025-00026134": "that some live in Burma", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00102-00026135-00026408": "the language is commonly spoken among", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00103-00026408-00026612": "naki people in everyday life and the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00104-00026613-00026780": "language is in little danger of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00105-00026781-00026933": "I'm out soon although the riddim", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00106-00026933-00027187": "literacy is still a rare skill the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00107-00027188-00027340": "language can be written in the gemba", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00108-00027341-00027545": "syllabary latin script or Frazer", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00109-00027545-00027727": "alphabet but they are rarely used in", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00110-00027729-00027932": "everyday life and few people are able to", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00111-00027933-00028331": "read naxi the 1932 naxi Gospel of Mark", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00112-00028332-00028514": "was published by the British and foreign", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00113-00028514-00028881": "Bible Society in Frazer script", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00114-00028882-00029130": "the three most common dialects are Li", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00115-00029131-00029460": "Jiang lapel and lutein Li Jiang which is", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00116-00029461-00029631": "spoken in the western parts of the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00117-00029632-00029852": "languages range is the most uniform of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00118-00029854-00030039": "the three and it is heavily influenced", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00119-00030039-00030207": "by standard Chinese and young amis", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00120-00030208-00030432": "dialects proved by its huge volume of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00121-00030433-00030693": "loanwords from Chinese the Eastern", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00122-00030694-00030900": "dialects which are much more native and", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00123-00030901-00031233": "have many dialectal differences", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00124-00031233-00031833": "phonology the alphabet used here is the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00125-00031833-00032268": "1957 pinyin alphabet", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00126-00032269-00032612": "consonants", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00127-00032613-00033162": "bowels in the Li Jiang dialect there are", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00128-00033163-00033662": "nine vowels as well as syllabic V ie a", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00129-00033663-00034215": "you.3 deny a I a you ii ii o you there", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00130-00034216-00034537": "is also a final written ER", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00131-00034538-00035114": "tones there are four tones high level", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00132-00035115-00035371": "with level low level or falling and in a", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00133-00035372-00035639": "few words high rising they are ridden", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00134-00035640-00035921": "lqf", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00135-00035922-00036773": "bibliography Bradley David 1975 nasi and", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00136-00036774-00037106": "prota Burmese lolo linguistics of the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00137-00037107-00037681": "tibeto-burman area to to 1.93 to 150", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00138-00037682-00038097": "Bradlee David 1997 tibeto-burman", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00139-00038098-00038458": "languages in classification papers in", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00140-00038459-00038647": "Southeast Asian linguistics number", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00141-00038648-00038884": "fourteen tibeto-burman languages of the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00142-00038885-00039286": "himalayas EDID bradley one 264 Canberra", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00143-00039287-00039490": "Department of linguistics research", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00144-00039491-00039676": "school of Pacific and Asian Studies", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00145-00039677-00040046": "Australian National University", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00146-00040047-00040320": "thank will you Fang will you and he Joe", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00147-00040321-00040462": "whoo hey jiwu", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00148-00040463-00040836": "1995 naxi shan chuen zebu a dictionary", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00149-00040837-00041076": "of naxi pictographic characters nosh", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00150-00041077-00041354": "Shan Shan when Z could mean you non-rem", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00151-00041355-00041594": "in Chewbacca", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00152-00041595-00041987": "foom algae 1944 a study of the Mosul", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00153-00041988-00042263": "high ROI glyphic manuscript the Genesis", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00154-00042264-00042611": "and history of mankind from licking Lee", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00155-00042612-00042866": "Jong Misha Shan Shan when gooshie", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00156-00042867-00043175": "Jianhua chang cube a watching university", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00157-00043176-00043469": "Woojin Woojin does a Zhang hua man gross", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00158-00043470-00043745": "and Chi Chi yen", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00159-00043746-00044171": "foom algae 1984 naxi you to hua when Z", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00160-00044172-00044608": "by beyond fuku Jing Zhi Yan ji eun-ah", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00161-00044609-00045026": "she you to wall when z5 en fuku Jing ji", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00162-00045027-00045326": "y Anju a study of annachi pictographic", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00163-00045327-00045637": "manuscript white bat search for sacred", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00164-00045638-00046203": "books volume to Tokyo CA a al", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00165-00046204-00046500": "Luda libro de Lyonne hee-joo whoo hey", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00166-00046501-00046863": "jiwu 1999 nah she's Russia nah she's", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00167-00046864-00047082": "ushi a history of the naxi people", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00168-00047083-00047410": "Sichuan minzu to Badshah", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00169-00047411-00047761": "he Gyrene Renan Zhang Zhizhong Zhu", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00170-00047762-00048136": "ye 1985 not she you Jan's - nah she you", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00171-00048137-00048405": "g ng a presentation of the naxi language", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00172-00048406-00048776": "beijing min Zhu Chewbacca", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00173-00048777-00049199": "heejoo whoo hey jiwu 1987 naughty Yugi", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00174-00049200-00049465": "to euthanize she you Jeju you fought the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00175-00049466-00049718": "basic grammar of nah she could name you", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00176-00049719-00050017": "nan minzu Chewbacca", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00177-00050018-00050326": "Lee Lincoln Leland can John Kuhn John", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00178-00050327-00050767": "Kuhn and he kayak I 1953 Moxie Shawn", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00179-00050768-00050992": "Ching winsy ziddi and mochi a Chang", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00180-00050993-00051264": "Sheng wen Zi Zi Dian a dictionary of nah", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00181-00051265-00051540": "she picked a graphs Hong Kong Xuan che", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00182-00051541-00051763": "new edition published by Yunnan min Zhu", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00183-00051764-00052167": "Chewbacca in 2001's nasi Shan Shan be a", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00184-00052169-00052719": "lien when ZZ Dian Mikhailovsky Boyd me", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00185-00052720-00053154": "show alexis 2006 syllabic inventory of a", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00186-00053155-00053425": "Western naxi dialect and correspondence", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00187-00053426-00053744": "with Joseph F rocks transcriptions", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00188-00053745-00054138": "Kanye's de linguistique AC Orion tau 35", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00189-00054139-00054298": "1 3 2 21", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00190-00054299-00054523": "though a ten point three four zero six", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00191-00054524-00054796": "cloud point two zero zero six point one", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00192-00054797-00055212": "seven four five me show Alexis 2006", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00193-00055213-00055479": "replicating in naxi tibeto-burman an", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00194-00055480-00055675": "experiment designed for Yoruba and", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00195-00055676-00055891": "approach two prominent sensitive prosody", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00196-00055891-00056151": "versus calculated prosody Proceedings of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00197-00056152-00056526": "speech prosody 2006 dresden available", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00198-00056527-00056575": "online", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00199-00056576-00056989": "misho alexis 2006 three extreme cases of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00200-00056990-00057255": "neutralization nasality ret reflection", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00201-00057257-00057538": "and lip rounding and naxi kanye's de", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00202-00057539-00057951": "linguistique AC oriental 35:23 255", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00203-00057952-00058171": "available online news show", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00204-00058172-00058525": "alexis 2006 three extreme cases of", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00205-00058526-00058684": "neutralization nasality", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00206-00058685-00058932": "ret reflection and lip rounding and naxi", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00207-00058933-00059325": "calle de linguistique AC orient au 35", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00208-00059326-00059713": "123 255 doe a ten point three four zero", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00209-00059714-00059991": "six clown point two zero zero six point", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00210-00059992-00060426": "one seven four six me show alexis 2006", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00211-00060427-00060715": "tunnel reassociation and rising tunnel", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00212-00060716-00060954": "contours in naxi linguistics of the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00213-00060955-00061429": "tibeto-burman area 2961 294 available", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00214-00061429-00061788": "online me show alexis 2006 and he zoo", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00215-00061789-00062011": "buen reassociate 'add tones and", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00216-00062012-00062163": "coalescent syllables in naxi", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00217-00062164-00062359": "tibeto-burman Journal of the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00218-00062360-00062705": "International Phonetic Association 37 3", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00219-00062707-00063294": "237 to 255 2007 available online Ramsay", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00220-00063295-00063380": "Ezra", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00221-00063382-00063712": "1987 the languages of China Princeton", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00222-00063713-00063927": "University Press Princeton New Jersey", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00223-00063928-00064264": "ISBN oh six nine one zero six six nine", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00224-00064265-00064828": "four 9 rock Joseph 1963 to 1972 a not", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00225-00064829-00065116": "key English encyclopedic dictionary romo", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00226-00065116-00065383": "instituto italiano / el medio and", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00227-00065384-00065755": "Estrella Oriente monosoff James 8 2003", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00228-00065756-00066055": "handbook of prota to Beto Berman system", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00229-00066056-00066207": "and philosophy of sino-tibetan", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00230-00066208-00066523": "reconstruction Berkeley and Los Angeles", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00231-00066524-00066799": "University of California Press Thurgood", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00232-00066800-00067084": "Graham 2003 a sub grouping of the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00233-00067085-00067309": "sino-tibetan languages the interaction", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00234-00067310-00067516": "between language contact change and", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00235-00067517-00067738": "inheritance the sino-tibetan languages", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00236-00067739-00068082": "ed by G Thurgood and ARLA Pola 3 221", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00237-00068083-00068436": "london route Lynch references Chen Jian", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00238-00068437-00068761": "1994 the nachi language in Stuart our", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00239-00068762-00069010": "Millikan and silicon alloys on the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00240-00069011-00069343": "minority languages of China 125 235", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00241-00069344-00069634": "Summer Institute of linguistics Lidz", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00242-00069635-00069901": "Liberty aid 2010 a descriptive grammar", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00243-00069902-00070015": "of young phenom", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00244-00070016-00070366": "masuo PhD dissertation Austin University", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00245-00070367-00070534": "of Texas Austin", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00246-00070535-00070903": "Nisha Alexis 2017 tone and young Nina", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00247-00070904-00071119": "lexical tones and more photo nology", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00248-00071120-00071458": "berlin language science press nine seven", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00249-00071459-00071725": "eight three nine four six two three four", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00250-00071726-00072049": "eight six nine HTTP colon slash slash", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00251-00072050-00072337": "lang she - pressed org slash catalog", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00252-00072338-00072715": "slash book / 109 external links open", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00253-00072716-00072913": "access recordings of naxi from the", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00254-00072914-00073144": "Pangloss collection world digital", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00255-00073145-00073507": "library presentation of 185 New Zealand", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00256-00073508-00073696": "Dollars romance and love related", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00257-00073697-00074032": "ceremonies Library of Congress primary", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00258-00074033-00074323": "source 19th and 20th century manuscripts", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00259-00074324-00074473": "from the naxi people yunnan province", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00260-00074474-00074770": "china only pictographic writing system", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00261-00074771-00075165": "still in use anywhere in the world", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00262-00075166-00075471": "moso manuscripts john rylands library", "cnb9s1I4NT0-00263-00075472-00075805": "university of manchester"}}, {"audio_id": "do8rXZLM6PI", "text": {"do8rXZLM6PI-00000-00000186-00000371": "um you know I feel like we've prepared", "do8rXZLM6PI-00001-00000372-00000659": "for this moment playing the AL East face", "do8rXZLM6PI-00002-00000660-00000857": "the lineups we Face seems like playing", "do8rXZLM6PI-00003-00000858-00001031": "in a Yankees uniform in Yankee Stadium", "do8rXZLM6PI-00004-00001032-00001181": "every game's a big game so I feel like", "do8rXZLM6PI-00005-00001182-00001349": "we're ready for it", "do8rXZLM6PI-00006-00001350-00001582": "um yeah it's a big opportunity", "do8rXZLM6PI-00007-00001583-00001780": "um props to Garrett for just pushing the", "do8rXZLM6PI-00008-00001782-00001997": "ball forward getting us back home", "do8rXZLM6PI-00009-00001998-00002189": "um you know we go back with a rested", "do8rXZLM6PI-00010-00002190-00002326": "Bullpen and I'm ready to go for game", "do8rXZLM6PI-00011-00002327-00002410": "five", "do8rXZLM6PI-00012-00002411-00002626": "how do you prepare for this considering", "do8rXZLM6PI-00013-00002627-00002723": "this week has been a little bit", "do8rXZLM6PI-00014-00002724-00002837": "different for you you spent the last", "do8rXZLM6PI-00015-00002838-00002987": "three games essentially in the bullpen", "do8rXZLM6PI-00016-00002988-00003155": "yeah it's definitely been a little", "do8rXZLM6PI-00017-00003156-00003274": "different but", "do8rXZLM6PI-00018-00003275-00003467": "I mean I know it's cliche but at the end", "do8rXZLM6PI-00019-00003468-00003611": "of the day it's just about executing my", "do8rXZLM6PI-00020-00003611-00003838": "pitches to my areas and that's as simple", "do8rXZLM6PI-00021-00003839-00004079": "as I can try to keep it so look at the", "do8rXZLM6PI-00022-00004079-00004211": "scouting reports figure out where my", "do8rXZLM6PI-00023-00004212-00004379": "safe areas are to go and just attack", "do8rXZLM6PI-00024-00004380-00004583": "those with my best stuff", "do8rXZLM6PI-00025-00004584-00004763": "um that's kind of what my game plan is", "do8rXZLM6PI-00026-00004764-00004931": "going to be I'm not going to have", "do8rXZLM6PI-00027-00004932-00005117": "anything in mind other than just", "do8rXZLM6PI-00028-00005118-00005279": "attacking with my best stuff to my best", "do8rXZLM6PI-00029-00005280-00005561": "areas Bullpen or starter that's that's", "do8rXZLM6PI-00030-00005562-00005711": "kind of something that carries over to", "do8rXZLM6PI-00031-00005712-00005854": "both jobs", "do8rXZLM6PI-00032-00005855-00006083": "uh Eric in the second row Jameson", "do8rXZLM6PI-00033-00006084-00006281": "realizing that it won't be your call but", "do8rXZLM6PI-00034-00006282-00006418": "if you still feel stretched out enough", "do8rXZLM6PI-00035-00006419-00006617": "to where you could give 90 100 pitches", "do8rXZLM6PI-00036-00006618-00006910": "yeah yeah definitely definitely", "do8rXZLM6PI-00037-00006911-00007163": "um you know that's kind of I don't even", "do8rXZLM6PI-00038-00007164-00007289": "know the last time I made a start maybe", "do8rXZLM6PI-00039-00007290-00007625": "12 days ago 13 days ago but", "do8rXZLM6PI-00040-00007626-00007817": "um you know I've kept working in the", "do8rXZLM6PI-00041-00007818-00008020": "weight room the training room uh the", "do8rXZLM6PI-00042-00008022-00008231": "staff keeping me ready The Long Toss", "do8rXZLM6PI-00043-00008232-00008507": "Program the bullpens I definitely still", "do8rXZLM6PI-00044-00008508-00008864": "feel built up for whatever they need"}}, {"audio_id": "do9ky0eXy9I", "text": {"do9ky0eXy9I-00000-00000003-00000320": "oh we've been talking about dealing with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00001-00000321-00000611": "disappointments now this is the third", "do9ky0eXy9I-00002-00000612-00000841": "week and this is going to be the final", "do9ky0eXy9I-00003-00000842-00001412": "week because so it's going to be the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00004-00001413-00001714": "last part we talked about sickness and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00005-00001716-00001901": "we talked about this last week we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00006-00001902-00002249": "started talking about betrayal and we're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00007-00002250-00002549": "gonna pick back up right there so the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00008-00002550-00002720": "first thing that I wanted to emphasize", "do9ky0eXy9I-00009-00002721-00002933": "this kind of I ended on last week", "do9ky0eXy9I-00010-00002934-00003350": "don't seek revenge when people do you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00011-00003351-00003409": "wrong", "do9ky0eXy9I-00012-00003410-00003929": "don't seek revenge I mean this this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00013-00003929-00004120": "sounds like yeah I know that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00014-00004121-00004486": "but then every single time somebody does", "do9ky0eXy9I-00015-00004487-00004852": "your honor and it's like I really feel", "do9ky0eXy9I-00016-00004853-00005000": "like getting the back or proving my", "do9ky0eXy9I-00017-00005001-00005216": "pointer or showing to other people that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00018-00005217-00005492": "I'm not you know I'm not what they said", "do9ky0eXy9I-00019-00005493-00005759": "I am you know and so we go on this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00020-00005760-00005909": "vendetta of trying to prove our", "do9ky0eXy9I-00021-00005910-00006143": "innocence and and in the process trying", "do9ky0eXy9I-00022-00006144-00006509": "to improve their guilt and so we go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00023-00006509-00006703": "through this long you know just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00024-00006704-00006959": "destructive process and eventually we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00025-00006959-00007169": "take up to Facebook and social media you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00026-00007170-00007363": "start posting stupid stuff and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00027-00007364-00007583": "vindicating ourselves and it's just it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00028-00007584-00007709": "not a good idea", "do9ky0eXy9I-00029-00007709-00008116": "it's just not a good idea it's just not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00030-00008117-00008318": "another thing we do is we start", "do9ky0eXy9I-00031-00008319-00008474": "gossiping about them because they", "do9ky0eXy9I-00032-00008475-00008615": "started gossiping about us", "do9ky0eXy9I-00033-00008616-00008846": "see it's easy with you when it's one and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00034-00008847-00008996": "done somebody betrayed you you move on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00035-00008997-00009269": "right but when somebody keeps on and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00036-00009270-00009626": "keeps on he sounds like okay I was good", "do9ky0eXy9I-00037-00009627-00010021": "at first now now it's all mine", "do9ky0eXy9I-00038-00010022-00010289": "that's very actually very common and the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00039-00010290-00010628": "thing is you have to you have to start", "do9ky0eXy9I-00040-00010629-00011027": "well but you also have to finish it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00041-00011028-00011384": "easy to do not easy doing the right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00042-00011385-00011624": "thing is a victory well you know we've", "do9ky0eXy9I-00043-00011625-00011768": "retreated wrong and we do the right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00044-00011769-00012060": "thing it's like a hide it so then don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00045-00012061-00012482": "lose ground in that victories bye okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00046-00012483-00012632": "well this I thought it was this battle", "do9ky0eXy9I-00047-00012633-00012785": "was gonna end but it just keeps going on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00048-00012786-00012991": "so now I'm gonna start gossiping about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00049-00012992-00013550": "them don't start a race well and then", "do9ky0eXy9I-00050-00013551-00013863": "throw it away in the last flap I mean", "do9ky0eXy9I-00051-00013865-00014174": "that's hard but this is something you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00052-00014175-00014309": "just kind of do another thing is bad", "do9ky0eXy9I-00053-00014310-00014638": "purse sometimes we cloak our prayers to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00054-00014640-00014837": "make it sound the better and maybe even", "do9ky0eXy9I-00055-00014838-00015025": "a customer from a genuine heart I'll", "do9ky0eXy9I-00056-00015026-00015383": "give you an example the Bible says to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00057-00015384-00015838": "pray for man is okay God I know that if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00058-00015840-00016034": "you would punish them they would just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00059-00016035-00016222": "turn they would they would hear and they", "do9ky0eXy9I-00060-00016223-00016565": "would they return God if you'd strike", "do9ky0eXy9I-00061-00016566-00016724": "their children as sickness they would", "do9ky0eXy9I-00062-00016725-00016949": "they would know in their hearts hey I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00063-00016950-00017162": "messing up and then they would turn and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00064-00017163-00017285": "it smells good not head", "do9ky0eXy9I-00065-00017286-00017633": "that sounds good it's like yes smite", "do9ky0eXy9I-00066-00017634-00017878": "them so they won't be you good idea and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00067-00017879-00017947": "it sounds good", "do9ky0eXy9I-00068-00017948-00018155": "and we convince ourselves we are so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00069-00018156-00018440": "spiritual there were praying for theirs", "do9ky0eXy9I-00070-00018441-00018767": "for their better see if we start", "do9ky0eXy9I-00071-00018768-00018917": "twisting things up because we're hurt", "do9ky0eXy9I-00072-00018918-00019097": "and I don't know we think that were real", "do9ky0eXy9I-00073-00019098-00019259": "smart and were prideful and arrogant and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00074-00019260-00019577": "so he thinks surely you know God can use", "do9ky0eXy9I-00075-00019578-00019802": "a bad thing to make a good thing so okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00076-00019803-00019940": "because they've done this bad thing and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00077-00019941-00020180": "they aren't changing god needs to stop", "do9ky0eXy9I-00078-00020181-00020327": "blessing them so I need to pray for God", "do9ky0eXy9I-00079-00020328-00020483": "to Southwest them so they'll know hey", "do9ky0eXy9I-00080-00020484-00020744": "the blessing of God has been removed so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00081-00020745-00020969": "I need to repent ha and then they'll", "do9ky0eXy9I-00082-00020970-00021101": "okay and then everything will be better", "do9ky0eXy9I-00083-00021102-00021401": "see I mean we start justifying stupid", "do9ky0eXy9I-00084-00021402-00021530": "prayers and that's what I mean by that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00085-00021531-00021599": "prayers", "do9ky0eXy9I-00086-00021600-00021746": "well the Bible says to bless those who", "do9ky0eXy9I-00087-00021747-00021938": "curse you literally means that bless", "do9ky0eXy9I-00088-00021939-00022187": "them Laura I pray you give them peace I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00089-00022188-00022436": "pray to you continue talking and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00090-00022437-00022727": "continue working in them and you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00091-00022728-00022886": "maybe you and there may be this Lord", "do9ky0eXy9I-00092-00022887-00023347": "help them is there that's more of God", "do9ky0eXy9I-00093-00023348-00023582": "communing with their heart okay alright", "do9ky0eXy9I-00094-00023583-00023807": "well when you start saying they're so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00095-00023808-00023972": "prideful that they will never see the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00096-00023973-00024104": "truth so you have to strike them with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00097-00024105-00024242": "the curse that they will see the truth", "do9ky0eXy9I-00098-00024243-00024515": "that takes us out of what Jesus told", "do9ky0eXy9I-00099-00024516-00024740": "students see and it's a very great", "do9ky0eXy9I-00100-00024741-00025003": "library you think okay we're on the side", "do9ky0eXy9I-00101-00025004-00025238": "we're the good guys and then somewhere", "do9ky0eXy9I-00102-00025239-00025433": "you get muddied in you're like oh man", "do9ky0eXy9I-00103-00025434-00025615": "by the time you realize that you have", "do9ky0eXy9I-00104-00025616-00025840": "become the bad guy you're like I don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00105-00025841-00026114": "know I couldn't possibly be because they", "do9ky0eXy9I-00106-00026114-00026501": "were wrong they brought me so okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00107-00026502-00026855": "Matthew 26 53 and we're just gonna look", "do9ky0eXy9I-00108-00026856-00027014": "at a few scriptures tonight and then I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00109-00027014-00027224": "just gonna have a few things that we tie", "do9ky0eXy9I-00110-00027225-00027382": "in from what we looked at", "do9ky0eXy9I-00111-00027383-00027712": "the past two weeks Matthew 26 starting", "do9ky0eXy9I-00112-00027713-00028876": "in verse 53 says this or do you think", "do9ky0eXy9I-00113-00028877-00029133": "that I cannot until to my father and he", "do9ky0eXy9I-00114-00029135-00029356": "will at once put at my disposal more", "do9ky0eXy9I-00115-00029357-00029608": "than twelve legions of angels how then", "do9ky0eXy9I-00116-00029608-00029802": "will the Scriptures be fulfilled which", "do9ky0eXy9I-00117-00029804-00030082": "say that it must happen this way at that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00118-00030083-00030262": "time jesus said to the crowd have you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00119-00030263-00030460": "come out with swords and clubs to arrest", "do9ky0eXy9I-00120-00030461-00030706": "me as you would against a robber every", "do9ky0eXy9I-00121-00030707-00030874": "time used to sit in the temple teaching", "do9ky0eXy9I-00122-00030875-00031123": "and he did not seize me but all this has", "do9ky0eXy9I-00123-00031124-00031288": "taken place to fulfill the scriptures of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00124-00031289-00031480": "the prophets then all the disciples left", "do9ky0eXy9I-00125-00031481-00031717": "him and fled so do you see how many", "do9ky0eXy9I-00126-00031718-00031957": "times he said scriptures there he's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00127-00031958-00032125": "getting ready to be arrested and look", "do9ky0eXy9I-00128-00032126-00032305": "what he says pay attention this for this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00129-00032306-00032545": "this type fool for that do you think I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00130-00032545-00032727": "cannot appeal to my father okay that was", "do9ky0eXy9I-00131-00032729-00032875": "written in Scripture so this is a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00132-00032876-00033124": "reference to Scripture and he wants what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00133-00033125-00033250": "if I disclose more than twelve legions", "do9ky0eXy9I-00134-00033251-00033472": "of angels how then will the Scriptures", "do9ky0eXy9I-00135-00033473-00033712": "now he clearly says Scriptures be", "do9ky0eXy9I-00136-00033713-00033919": "fulfilled now ask two references to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00137-00033920-00034180": "God's promises at that time jesus said", "do9ky0eXy9I-00138-00034181-00034333": "to the crowd have you come out with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00139-00034334-00034468": "swords and clubs to arrest me as you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00140-00034469-00034681": "would against a robber every day I used", "do9ky0eXy9I-00141-00034682-00034846": "to sit in the temple teaching you didn't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00142-00034847-00035059": "seize me but all this has taken place to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00143-00035060-00035227": "fulfill the scriptures of the prophets I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00144-00035228-00035488": "began he says that three times in just a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00145-00035489-00035704": "few verses that make it the idea is very", "do9ky0eXy9I-00146-00035705-00036087": "simple even when you're betrayed hold on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00147-00036088-00036415": "hold on to God's promises Jesus knew", "do9ky0eXy9I-00148-00036416-00036634": "that he could get out of the pickle but", "do9ky0eXy9I-00149-00036635-00036850": "the problem is if you got out of the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00150-00036851-00037134": "pickle then we wouldn't have a Savior", "do9ky0eXy9I-00151-00037135-00037417": "see because that's what whole reason why", "do9ky0eXy9I-00152-00037418-00037927": "you came so what we do when we go into", "do9ky0eXy9I-00153-00037928-00038110": "troubles as we just kind of start to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00154-00038111-00038368": "forget they God has a plan", "do9ky0eXy9I-00155-00038369-00038515": "and we're gonna start to forget to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00156-00038516-00038824": "listen to God because boy hurts I mean", "do9ky0eXy9I-00157-00038825-00039103": "it once again disappointments are", "do9ky0eXy9I-00158-00039104-00039277": "something that we face all the time", "do9ky0eXy9I-00159-00039278-00039550": "and as we pointed out last week these", "do9ky0eXy9I-00160-00039551-00039766": "three specific areas that we're talking", "do9ky0eXy9I-00161-00039767-00040150": "about sickness death and betrayal the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00162-00040151-00040342": "lessons that we're looking at I'll find", "do9ky0eXy9I-00163-00040343-00040474": "out other areas of life of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00164-00040475-00040702": "disappointment because everybody's going", "do9ky0eXy9I-00165-00040703-00040810": "to face disappointment disappointment", "do9ky0eXy9I-00166-00040811-00040969": "it's kind of it's gonna blindside you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00167-00040970-00041185": "and it's gonna be something that you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00168-00041186-00041365": "personally struggle with it's just gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-00169-00041366-00041866": "happen the 2334 says but Jesus was", "do9ky0eXy9I-00170-00041867-00042013": "saying Father forgive them for they do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00171-00042014-00042253": "not know what they're doing and they", "do9ky0eXy9I-00172-00042254-00042604": "catch my god maybe they don't know that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00173-00042605-00042799": "what they're doing is wrong if you would", "do9ky0eXy9I-00174-00042800-00043018": "just show them by giving them terrors in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00175-00043019-00043288": "the night and panic attacks and that you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00176-00043289-00043486": "would that you would bring sickness on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00177-00043487-00043609": "them so they would know that what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00178-00043610-00043840": "they're doing is wrong that somebody", "do9ky0eXy9I-00179-00043841-00044173": "said okay let's read again when he said", "do9ky0eXy9I-00180-00044174-00044398": "because well we're in pain we forget", "do9ky0eXy9I-00181-00044399-00044608": "when Jesus actually said for the sake of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00182-00044609-00044901": "our pain but Jesus was saying", "do9ky0eXy9I-00183-00044902-00045208": "continually saying not instead saying", "do9ky0eXy9I-00184-00045209-00045400": "Father forgive them for they do not know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00185-00045401-00045643": "what they are doing and they cast lots", "do9ky0eXy9I-00186-00045644-00045754": "dividing up his garments among", "do9ky0eXy9I-00187-00045755-00045979": "themselves so Europe comes to a very", "do9ky0eXy9I-00188-00045980-00046318": "interesting point move on when somebody", "do9ky0eXy9I-00189-00046319-00046489": "betrays you when you've been hurt just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00190-00046490-00047320": "move on now what I don't mean this well", "do9ky0eXy9I-00191-00047321-00047554": "they done me wrong so now I'm gonna just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00192-00047555-00047890": "go and have a next lads we just forget", "do9ky0eXy9I-00193-00047891-00048160": "you I didn't say forget you I said move", "do9ky0eXy9I-00194-00048161-00048406": "on Jesus still has something to do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00195-00048407-00048763": "didn't he he wasn't done yet right move", "do9ky0eXy9I-00196-00048764-00048967": "on what else God has you to do I'm not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00197-00048968-00049555": "saying forget them I'm saying Matthew", "do9ky0eXy9I-00198-00049556-00050848": "10:34 to 37", "do9ky0eXy9I-00199-00050849-00051098": "do you not think that I came to bring", "do9ky0eXy9I-00200-00051099-00051299": "peace on the earth I did not come to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00201-00051300-00051449": "bring peace but a sword", "do9ky0eXy9I-00202-00051450-00051689": "Triana said a man against his father and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00203-00051690-00051821": "a daughter against her mother and a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00204-00051822-00051914": "daughter-in-law against her", "do9ky0eXy9I-00205-00051915-00052061": "mother-in-law and a man's enemies will", "do9ky0eXy9I-00206-00052062-00052396": "be the members of his household he who", "do9ky0eXy9I-00207-00052397-00052583": "loves father or mother more than me is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00208-00052584-00052799": "not worthy of me and he who loves son or", "do9ky0eXy9I-00209-00052800-00053000": "daughter more than me is not worthy of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00210-00053001-00053264": "you again we have here Jesus told us we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00211-00053265-00053576": "would be betrayed he told his movie", "do9ky0eXy9I-00212-00053577-00054071": "between even by our family still it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00213-00054072-00054371": "still catches us by surprise Lee but", "do9ky0eXy9I-00214-00054372-00054509": "they were closer to me than anybody", "do9ky0eXy9I-00215-00054510-00054742": "Jesus told us it was time and I mean", "do9ky0eXy9I-00216-00054744-00055028": "this camp can't surprise you that bad I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00217-00055029-00055403": "mean it does good at the same time it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00218-00055404-00056800": "should ok Matthew 5 10 through 12", "do9ky0eXy9I-00219-00056801-00057028": "blessed are those who have been", "do9ky0eXy9I-00220-00057029-00057184": "persecuted for the sake of righteousness", "do9ky0eXy9I-00221-00057185-00057345": "for theirs is the kingdom of heaven", "do9ky0eXy9I-00222-00057346-00057577": "let's start you when people insult you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00223-00057578-00057727": "and persecute you and falsely say all", "do9ky0eXy9I-00224-00057728-00057942": "kinds of evil against you because of me", "do9ky0eXy9I-00225-00057944-00058174": "now notice though and I know pastors", "do9ky0eXy9I-00226-00058175-00058266": "mention this but it's worth mentioning", "do9ky0eXy9I-00227-00058267-00058537": "again because of me", "do9ky0eXy9I-00228-00058538-00058744": "not because you did stupid stuff and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00229-00058745-00059038": "it's catching up to you okay he's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00230-00059039-00059182": "saying that he's saying when you are", "do9ky0eXy9I-00231-00059183-00059602": "treated unjustly okay you did the right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00232-00059603-00059904": "thing they did the wrong thing okay just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00233-00059905-00060010": "the wrong fair", "do9ky0eXy9I-00234-00060011-00060208": "rejoice and be glad for your reward in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00235-00060209-00060361": "heaven is great from the same way they", "do9ky0eXy9I-00236-00060362-00060487": "persecuted the prophets who were before", "do9ky0eXy9I-00237-00060488-00060675": "you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00238-00060676-00061017": "which brings us to a very difficult part", "do9ky0eXy9I-00239-00061019-00061237": "of betrayal now remember last week we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00240-00061238-00061366": "were talking about the five stages of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00241-00061366-00061597": "grief and the last of the five stages", "do9ky0eXy9I-00242-00061598-00061939": "was acceptance and that kind of applies", "do9ky0eXy9I-00243-00061940-00062236": "to a lot of situations you'll find that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00244-00062237-00062365": "you go through the five stages of grief", "do9ky0eXy9I-00245-00062366-00062629": "in minor parts not just in big parts as", "do9ky0eXy9I-00246-00062629-00062967": "well like for instance you go to watch", "do9ky0eXy9I-00247-00062969-00063180": "your favorite show on Netflix it's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00248-00063182-00063463": "there deny it it has to be here then", "do9ky0eXy9I-00249-00063464-00063802": "anger they took it off what and then", "do9ky0eXy9I-00250-00063803-00063942": "finally you know you work through the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00251-00063944-00064111": "five stages need to that's okay the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00252-00064112-00064261": "Netflix doesn't have my show on any more", "do9ky0eXy9I-00253-00064262-00064435": "LP other sites that HealthWatch so I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00254-00064436-00064594": "mean it happens almost throughout life", "do9ky0eXy9I-00255-00064595-00064801": "and in other is not just in in wife or", "do9ky0eXy9I-00256-00064802-00065038": "death situations but in everything so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00257-00065039-00065241": "with that being said my sake betrays you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00258-00065241-00065517": "there's a certain part of you that will", "do9ky0eXy9I-00259-00065519-00065779": "try and just hold on to a lake this can", "do9ky0eXy9I-00260-00065780-00066034": "actually be happening in to really be", "do9ky0eXy9I-00261-00066035-00066262": "able to work through the situation and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00262-00066263-00066520": "forgive them and move on you have to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00263-00066521-00067194": "accept it it happened yeah it did", "do9ky0eXy9I-00264-00067195-00067477": "we really do like to deny the reality of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00265-00067478-00067752": "the situation in front of his league", "do9ky0eXy9I-00266-00067753-00068014": "maybe I misunderstood it or you know we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00267-00068015-00068212": "wake up I'm like that was just a bad a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00268-00068213-00068326": "bad week", "do9ky0eXy9I-00269-00068327-00068482": "sure that maybe things aren't as bad as", "do9ky0eXy9I-00270-00068483-00068608": "I thought they were it's like oh no", "do9ky0eXy9I-00271-00068609-00069070": "their word but okay and then Matthew", "do9ky0eXy9I-00272-00069071-00069763": "6:12 and forgive us our debts as we also", "do9ky0eXy9I-00273-00069764-00069919": "have forgiven our debtors", "do9ky0eXy9I-00274-00069920-00070186": "no one can heal if you keep picking at", "do9ky0eXy9I-00275-00070187-00071016": "it okay so that's the first thing a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00276-00071017-00071362": "wound is kind of like a blister okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00277-00071363-00071824": "that's a great image as long as you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00278-00071825-00071943": "leave it alone", "do9ky0eXy9I-00279-00071944-00072388": "it'll help but the problem is it starts", "do9ky0eXy9I-00280-00072389-00072649": "healing and then it's something reminds", "do9ky0eXy9I-00281-00072650-00072889": "us of it and so we start picking at it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00282-00072890-00073180": "again and then we say we track three for", "do9ky0eXy9I-00283-00073181-00073381": "ourselves too as we say no I'm okay with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00284-00073382-00073675": "this now so now I can talk louder and so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00285-00073676-00073792": "you start picking at it again it starts", "do9ky0eXy9I-00286-00073793-00074017": "bleeding in you kind of get what I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00287-00074018-00074197": "saying I think God has these though", "do9ky0eXy9I-00288-00074198-00074452": "hidden hidden messages for his all", "do9ky0eXy9I-00289-00074453-00074587": "throughout his creation and I think that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00290-00074588-00074773": "scabs are one of those ways and he gives", "do9ky0eXy9I-00291-00074774-00075034": "in his own hidden messages like for", "do9ky0eXy9I-00292-00075035-00075325": "instance scars you know a scar is a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00293-00075326-00075763": "proof that killing is happening now we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00294-00075764-00075889": "might have look at our scars and say", "do9ky0eXy9I-00295-00075890-00076096": "that looks ugly and hideous it's a part", "do9ky0eXy9I-00296-00076097-00076264": "of who we are though it shows that we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00297-00076265-00076450": "have field it shows that we have lived", "do9ky0eXy9I-00298-00076451-00076906": "and it shows that we didn't die but when", "do9ky0eXy9I-00299-00076907-00077110": "we see scars on our person we think this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00300-00077111-00077257": "is the worst thing in the world that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00301-00077258-00077392": "that had that happen in the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00302-00077393-00077718": "please you know and well I did have them", "do9ky0eXy9I-00303-00077719-00078310": "okay so there's just a few things we're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00304-00078311-00078604": "gonna work through we're not really", "do9ky0eXy9I-00305-00078605-00078754": "gonna look at any more Scripture because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00306-00078755-00078949": "I'm just kind of drawing more principles", "do9ky0eXy9I-00307-00078950-00079048": "from the stuff that we've already looked", "do9ky0eXy9I-00308-00079049-00079267": "at over the past few weeks so if we keep", "do9ky0eXy9I-00309-00079268-00079399": "going back and forth we're just gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-00310-00079400-00079675": "kind of spend a lot of time rereading", "do9ky0eXy9I-00311-00079676-00079786": "the things that we've already read the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00312-00079787-00080032": "first thing pray for them and bless them", "do9ky0eXy9I-00313-00080033-00080497": "I can't say this enough when people do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00314-00080498-00080722": "you wrong pray for when somebody's in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00315-00080723-00080779": "pain", "do9ky0eXy9I-00316-00080780-00081117": "when somebody's sick there's this idea", "do9ky0eXy9I-00317-00081118-00081418": "pray for them and we've lost a lot of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00318-00081419-00081988": "that in today you have all these", "do9ky0eXy9I-00319-00081989-00082258": "Christians who don't like President", "do9ky0eXy9I-00320-00082259-00082435": "Trump so they think that that frees them", "do9ky0eXy9I-00321-00082436-00082903": "from the obligation of pray for well no", "do9ky0eXy9I-00322-00082904-00083335": "no it doesn't you see we have to pray", "do9ky0eXy9I-00323-00083336-00083461": "for our leaders that was actually the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00324-00083462-00083668": "specific thing that Paul said there's a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00325-00083669-00084067": "matter if you bite them remind you I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00326-00084068-00084310": "mean we give ourselves little excuses", "do9ky0eXy9I-00327-00084311-00084514": "for not for listening to what God said", "do9ky0eXy9I-00328-00084515-00084724": "it's like I don't like this president", "do9ky0eXy9I-00329-00084725-00084910": "well you don't have to like them you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00330-00084911-00085039": "have to pray for them there's a big", "do9ky0eXy9I-00331-00085040-00085465": "difference there okay don't spiritualize", "do9ky0eXy9I-00332-00085466-00085645": "this obedience show it's okay for me", "do9ky0eXy9I-00333-00085646-00085918": "because I'm more spiritual other people", "do9ky0eXy9I-00334-00085919-00086065": "need to pray for the president whatever", "do9ky0eXy9I-00335-00086066-00086296": "but me I'm I'm more spiritual I've come", "do9ky0eXy9I-00336-00086297-00086545": "to a higher sense of reality with God", "do9ky0eXy9I-00337-00086546-00086824": "and he understands you know what I or my", "do9ky0eXy9I-00338-00086825-00086919": "beef is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00339-00086920-00087159": "and how it's an umbilical this man is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00340-00087160-00087528": "and so it's okay for me to not do what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00341-00087529-00087930": "God said because I'm above the rolls I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00342-00087931-00088676": "more mature than other people now go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00343-00088677-00088830": "tell your spouse's because they're gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-00344-00088831-00088935": "look at you like this is they're gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-00345-00088936-00089097": "say you need to change your attitude Oh", "do9ky0eXy9I-00346-00089098-00089409": "me but we don't so we just keep it in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00347-00089410-00089634": "our heart to know people don't need to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00348-00089635-00089724": "know how great I am", "do9ky0eXy9I-00349-00089725-00089961": "as long as I know how great I am we'll", "do9ky0eXy9I-00350-00089962-00090828": "all wrong with it sometimes you come to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00351-00090829-00090954": "come to a place that you can sing", "do9ky0eXy9I-00352-00090955-00091128": "something on a more similar God be the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00353-00091129-00091266": "command for the stupid people who", "do9ky0eXy9I-00354-00091267-00091568": "couldn't figure it out not like me so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00355-00091569-00091725": "that's for the general people then", "do9ky0eXy9I-00356-00091726-00091923": "there's me I'm God's gift", "do9ky0eXy9I-00357-00091924-00092106": "we don't say like that we say like this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00358-00092107-00092375": "you know I that's more of an", "do9ky0eXy9I-00359-00092376-00092624": "introductory idea a general principle", "do9ky0eXy9I-00360-00092625-00092912": "but then you know once you want you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00361-00092913-00093135": "God like I do so you know maybe we cloak", "do9ky0eXy9I-00362-00093136-00093366": "it we don't call it right we call", "do9ky0eXy9I-00363-00093367-00093699": "something else don't repeat the error", "do9ky0eXy9I-00364-00093700-00094131": "let them know sometimes and I'm talking", "do9ky0eXy9I-00365-00094132-00094371": "a large part about repeating the error", "do9ky0eXy9I-00366-00094372-00094581": "in your mind and in your memory just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00367-00094582-00094913": "keep going over and over it don't go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00368-00094914-00095118": "repeat it interlink you have to just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00369-00095119-00095280": "kind of clear from your head it's kind", "do9ky0eXy9I-00370-00095281-00095406": "of like this you know what are you doing", "do9ky0eXy9I-00371-00095407-00095600": "a computer when you're gonna reuse a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00372-00095601-00095840": "program and so you don't want to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00373-00095841-00096074": "the bother of having to restart it again", "do9ky0eXy9I-00374-00096075-00096280": "and all that you leave the program", "do9ky0eXy9I-00375-00096281-00096613": "running in the background like for", "do9ky0eXy9I-00376-00096614-00096791": "instance let's say you're on the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00377-00096792-00096937": "internet in the internet ok and you have", "do9ky0eXy9I-00378-00096938-00097111": "multiple tabs over well I'm going to go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00379-00097112-00097280": "back there yeah so I'll leave it open on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00380-00097281-00097547": "a new computer now connector kind of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00381-00097548-00097726": "like that that's kind of like what we do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00382-00097727-00098038": "with betrayal sometimes well I'm not on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00383-00098039-00098317": "that to have right now but you still", "do9ky0eXy9I-00384-00098318-00098696": "haven't running in the background you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00385-00098697-00098861": "still have it running in the background", "do9ky0eXy9I-00386-00098862-00099913": "close the tab you know what happens when", "do9ky0eXy9I-00387-00099914-00100199": "you open on your computer it starts", "do9ky0eXy9I-00388-00100200-00100655": "doing this moving real slow in the mail", "do9ky0eXy9I-00389-00100656-00101024": "starts go on roll same thing happens to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00390-00101025-00101147": "you spiritually too", "do9ky0eXy9I-00391-00101148-00101287": "you can't keep it running in the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00392-00101288-00101471": "background expected not to mess with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00393-00101472-00101840": "your operation ok and then another thing", "do9ky0eXy9I-00394-00101841-00102023": "is don't repeat the error what I mean by", "do9ky0eXy9I-00395-00102024-00102610": "that and another way is don't allow the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00396-00102611-00102841": "same thing to happen over again you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00397-00102842-00103057": "what I mean yeah I'm sure you do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00398-00103058-00103180": "understand what I mean so I'm just gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-00399-00103181-00103603": "skip past the next thing one of the very", "do9ky0eXy9I-00400-00103604-00103763": "most difficult things you will ever", "do9ky0eXy9I-00401-00103764-00104102": "learn to do forgive and forget because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00402-00104103-00104249": "when somebody betrays you you're gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-00403-00104250-00104677": "see betrayal and everyone especially if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00404-00104678-00104830": "the person betrays you is someone who is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00405-00104831-00104983": "really close to you see betrayal and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00406-00104984-00105257": "everyone it's behind every tree you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00407-00105258-00105413": "all of a sudden if you have the smallest", "do9ky0eXy9I-00408-00105414-00105541": "disagree with someone it's because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00409-00105542-00105797": "they're plotting on you too you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00410-00105798-00105991": "what I mean and we just get ourselves to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00411-00105992-00106274": "notice it is constant paranoia where", "do9ky0eXy9I-00412-00106275-00106558": "it's like well who's gonna leave me next", "do9ky0eXy9I-00413-00106558-00106919": "who's next on the list you know it's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00414-00106920-00106994": "it's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00415-00106995-00107291": "we live in fact I wouldn't say guru food", "do9ky0eXy9I-00416-00107292-00107918": "it's impossible to live there it's what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00417-00107919-00108290": "I mean by forget it's not that it's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00418-00108291-00108533": "that and forgive me forget what happened", "do9ky0eXy9I-00419-00108533-00109105": "in the past and it's not that you don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00420-00109106-00109485": "leave room to repeat the error it's that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00421-00109486-00109708": "you embrace it as something that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00422-00109709-00110591": "happened this happened it's no longer in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00423-00110592-00110807": "your operation you closed down that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00424-00110808-00111269": "window that make sense okay so another", "do9ky0eXy9I-00425-00111270-00111476": "thing is gossiping and complaining I've", "do9ky0eXy9I-00426-00111477-00112097": "been so unfairly treated maybe you were", "do9ky0eXy9I-00427-00112098-00112379": "but you're not gonna get anywhere by", "do9ky0eXy9I-00428-00112380-00112714": "complaining about it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00429-00112715-00112940": "everybody's condemned like you guys all", "do9ky0eXy9I-00430-00112941-00113059": "know what I'm talking yeah it's been a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00431-00113060-00113240": "rough rough week huh", "do9ky0eXy9I-00432-00113241-00113507": "I get it guys I really do but when you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00433-00113508-00113681": "complain about stuff it really is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00434-00113682-00113864": "counterproductive because you're using", "do9ky0eXy9I-00435-00113865-00114176": "up your energy and when it does you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00436-00114177-00114314": "they did a lot of amazing Studies on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00437-00114315-00114484": "this that when you when you complain it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00438-00114485-00114644": "actually tells you're bringing to stop", "do9ky0eXy9I-00439-00114645-00114851": "looking for a solution to a problem and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00440-00114852-00115094": "so you start being less productive in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00441-00115095-00115352": "other areas too they give you let me", "do9ky0eXy9I-00442-00115353-00115514": "give you a hypothetical situation which", "do9ky0eXy9I-00443-00115515-00115691": "isn't so hypothetical you and your wife", "do9ky0eXy9I-00444-00115692-00115984": "get in a fight you need to ask man you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00445-00115985-00116405": "get to work you can't think a solution", "do9ky0eXy9I-00446-00116406-00116768": "and the problem at work why because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00447-00116769-00117023": "you're still upset", "do9ky0eXy9I-00448-00117024-00117533": "you're still mad it literally takes away", "do9ky0eXy9I-00449-00117533-00117985": "your brains efficiency so now a men men", "do9ky0eXy9I-00450-00117986-00118376": "hate to be inefficient I mean they wish", "do9ky0eXy9I-00451-00118377-00118553": "everything could just be worked out into", "do9ky0eXy9I-00452-00118554-00118781": "little boxes when I come home I want", "do9ky0eXy9I-00453-00118782-00118967": "this done and this done is done the kids", "do9ky0eXy9I-00454-00118968-00119132": "you have to be perfect and this and this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00455-00119133-00119324": "and this and wife you have to have this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00456-00119325-00119492": "dinner this another you know we're going", "do9ky0eXy9I-00457-00119493-00119630": "to cast more need we went to work", "do9ky0eXy9I-00458-00119631-00119833": "everything if it was a perfect tool you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00459-00119834-00120131": "know a set of boxes and an old man that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00460-00120132-00120283": "would look great if you can have okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00461-00120284-00120458": "see when I get home if you could have a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00462-00120458-00120788": "pie chart of how the day was worked with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00463-00120789-00121025": "the kids and that'd be great that's how", "do9ky0eXy9I-00464-00121026-00121328": "men think today I mean there's a lot of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00465-00121329-00121711": "life that happens off of that pie chart", "do9ky0eXy9I-00466-00121713-00122132": "stop talking about them good or bad what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00467-00122133-00122396": "I family for me I don't know this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00468-00122397-00122531": "applies to you guys but it does to me", "do9ky0eXy9I-00469-00122532-00122741": "even if you're not talking bad about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00470-00122742-00122978": "them just talking about them even in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00471-00122979-00123779": "like let's say for instance um John we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00472-00123780-00123934": "don't keep up with each other that's you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00473-00123935-00124664": "know okay now if I say let's say I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00474-00124665-00124861": "playing someone else like hey Nicole", "do9ky0eXy9I-00475-00124863-00125099": "you know John used to work over at this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00476-00125100-00125282": "place where he was able to get good", "do9ky0eXy9I-00477-00125283-00125453": "deals for on whatever it is that you're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00478-00125454-00125678": "buying on a new new vacuum suit I mean", "do9ky0eXy9I-00479-00125679-00125894": "just talking an instant way like that it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00480-00125895-00126197": "opens the door it opens the door and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00481-00126198-00126323": "here's the thing about your hearts it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00482-00126324-00126535": "very deceitful your heart will tell you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00483-00126536-00126709": "that you find what's not and it's better", "do9ky0eXy9I-00484-00126710-00126875": "just close the door gently closed", "do9ky0eXy9I-00485-00126876-00127133": "does that make sense don't let your", "do9ky0eXy9I-00486-00127133-00127319": "heart fool you into thinking hey I can", "do9ky0eXy9I-00487-00127320-00127528": "handle it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00488-00127529-00127740": "don't be stupid you're not sorry", "do9ky0eXy9I-00489-00127741-00128047": "if you open that door again yeah", "do9ky0eXy9I-00490-00128048-00128361": "how many times does Jesus talk about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00491-00128363-00128661": "Judas after the night that Judas", "do9ky0eXy9I-00492-00128663-00128883": "betrayed him and left not one single", "do9ky0eXy9I-00493-00128884-00129265": "time no Melissa go then he isn't talk", "do9ky0eXy9I-00494-00129266-00129493": "about him after the resurrection is a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00495-00129494-00129688": "talk about it in the book of Revelation", "do9ky0eXy9I-00496-00129689-00129844": "which was a whole vision and dream that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00497-00129845-00130198": "God gave to John that Judas has never", "do9ky0eXy9I-00498-00130199-00130417": "mentioned why because it wasn't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00499-00130418-00130939": "productive it was off topic in fact the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00500-00130940-00131137": "the New Testament writers only mentioned", "do9ky0eXy9I-00501-00131138-00131362": "him to roots for a very simple point and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00502-00131363-00131647": "then they move on but Jesus himself the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00503-00131648-00131880": "one who gave the mission didn't say hey", "do9ky0eXy9I-00504-00131881-00132097": "you know here's the Great Commission go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00505-00132098-00132268": "at all the role bit and don't be like", "do9ky0eXy9I-00506-00132269-00132378": "Judas", "do9ky0eXy9I-00507-00132379-00132778": "he kept them moving forth so once again", "do9ky0eXy9I-00508-00132779-00132955": "stop talking about than just even in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00509-00132956-00133108": "passing just just let it go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00510-00133109-00133366": "another thing is he'll for whatever", "do9ky0eXy9I-00511-00133367-00133717": "reason we we try and get a mortal wound", "do9ky0eXy9I-00512-00133718-00134118": "and play it off like it's not a mortal", "do9ky0eXy9I-00513-00134119-00134476": "imagine let's let's imagine a war", "do9ky0eXy9I-00514-00134477-00134599": "scenario okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00515-00134600-00134878": "you're in the trenches bombs are falling", "do9ky0eXy9I-00516-00134879-00135310": "guns are firing and you get shot in the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00517-00135311-00135625": "other and your artery starts going off", "do9ky0eXy9I-00518-00135626-00135745": "you like it's fine", "do9ky0eXy9I-00519-00135746-00136078": "I'll be fine I'll be fine so you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00520-00136079-00136267": "that artillery starts bombing you and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00521-00136268-00136471": "the arm gets blown off completely I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00522-00136472-00136789": "fine all bounced back really it's gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-00523-00136790-00137095": "be okay and Glenn is just going", "do9ky0eXy9I-00524-00137096-00137329": "everywhere and you're losing strength", "do9ky0eXy9I-00525-00137330-00137638": "but I find I find it if we do the exact", "do9ky0eXy9I-00526-00137639-00137986": "same thing in our spirits we do the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00527-00137987-00138180": "exact same thing with our mental health", "do9ky0eXy9I-00528-00138181-00138451": "you know we start having having serious", "do9ky0eXy9I-00529-00138452-00138634": "problems we're up all night worrying", "do9ky0eXy9I-00530-00138635-00138718": "about stuff", "do9ky0eXy9I-00531-00138719-00138862": "can't see straight we can't solve", "do9ky0eXy9I-00532-00138863-00139015": "problems anymore we're not parenting", "do9ky0eXy9I-00533-00139016-00139201": "right we're not being a good spouse we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00534-00139202-00139426": "problem after problem and yet we still", "do9ky0eXy9I-00535-00139427-00139804": "deny that there's a problem you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00536-00139805-00140134": "most times that women go to divorce", "do9ky0eXy9I-00537-00140135-00140323": "their husbands most of the time the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00538-00140324-00140637": "husband answers with this what why", "do9ky0eXy9I-00539-00140638-00141001": "bullying is to the probably wha", "do9ky0eXy9I-00540-00141002-00141334": "the majority of the time that happens do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00541-00141335-00141697": "you ever wonder why tell you it okay so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00542-00141698-00141982": "some ways you can help read books", "do9ky0eXy9I-00543-00141983-00142249": "this will definitely open your eyes to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00544-00142250-00142522": "problems solutions that can stuff it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00545-00142523-00142690": "just a good idea there's lots of good", "do9ky0eXy9I-00546-00142691-00142795": "books out there there's a lot of bad", "do9ky0eXy9I-00547-00142796-00143047": "books to you know have some discretion I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00548-00143048-00143308": "read a lot of books this year so far", "do9ky0eXy9I-00549-00143309-00143578": "I've read over under goes what I do is I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00550-00143579-00143962": "give it about a hundred pages to impress", "do9ky0eXy9I-00551-00143963-00144394": "me give me your best book and if I get", "do9ky0eXy9I-00552-00144395-00144553": "some bad feelings within the first like", "do9ky0eXy9I-00553-00144554-00144826": "ten pages on there I'll give you a good", "do9ky0eXy9I-00554-00144827-00145057": "example Game of Thrones the first book I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00555-00145058-00145153": "forget what it's called I think it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00556-00145154-00145275": "actually called the game of feminists", "do9ky0eXy9I-00557-00145276-00145531": "yeah I started reading it was like that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00558-00145532-00145651": "was a really good story and then there", "do9ky0eXy9I-00559-00145652-00145819": "was a lot of seven so I was like okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00560-00145820-00145969": "well we'll just trance get past those", "do9ky0eXy9I-00561-00145970-00146152": "parts but it was like everywhere you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00562-00146153-00146422": "can't skip pass unless entire book so I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00563-00146423-00146677": "got the page like 115 or 200 and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00564-00146678-00146797": "something that this book has seven", "do9ky0eXy9I-00565-00146798-00147004": "hundred seven pages so at that point I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00566-00147005-00147387": "did an evaluation cost-benefit nope", "do9ky0eXy9I-00567-00147388-00147646": "another book it's on leadership I start", "do9ky0eXy9I-00568-00147647-00147784": "reading hey this has some great stuff in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00569-00147785-00147973": "it and to do then I hit it apart that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00570-00147974-00148180": "just surround us totally off so I kept", "do9ky0eXy9I-00571-00148181-00148381": "going because I had a good feeling about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00572-00148382-00148606": "this book and I was right it was it had", "do9ky0eXy9I-00573-00148607-00148807": "some bad stuff in it but I also had some", "do9ky0eXy9I-00574-00148808-00149146": "good stuff see what I mean do you don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00575-00149147-00149293": "don't just read things I mean you have", "do9ky0eXy9I-00576-00149294-00149658": "limited time but do do do read things", "do9ky0eXy9I-00577-00149659-00149893": "counselling for some reason people are", "do9ky0eXy9I-00578-00149894-00150043": "scared of this for natives because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00579-00150044-00150116": "they're so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00580-00150117-00150335": "counselors out there find a good", "do9ky0eXy9I-00581-00150336-00150596": "counselor and then go to them it's okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00582-00150597-00150752": "to talk about your problems you know I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00583-00150753-00150962": "mean think of it like this your spouse", "do9ky0eXy9I-00584-00150963-00151178": "is kinda like a counselor you talk about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00585-00151179-00151286": "your other things you shouldn't talk", "do9ky0eXy9I-00586-00151287-00151592": "about your problems your spouse and you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00587-00151593-00151721": "know you work towards a solution", "do9ky0eXy9I-00588-00151722-00152021": "together that's a smaller form of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00589-00152022-00152257": "counseling a pastor as a counselor away", "do9ky0eXy9I-00590-00152258-00152531": "maybe not in the same way as as you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00591-00152532-00152873": "someone with a license but I mean in a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00592-00152874-00153146": "way we are still counselors so it's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00593-00153147-00153326": "it shouldn't really bow is that much out", "do9ky0eXy9I-00594-00153327-00153470": "of proportion so you could professional", "do9ky0eXy9I-00595-00153471-00153530": "counselor", "do9ky0eXy9I-00596-00153531-00153746": "I'll read the Bible for some reason when", "do9ky0eXy9I-00597-00153747-00153965": "we go through hard times we kind of just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00598-00153966-00154178": "operating the Bible maybe you feel like", "do9ky0eXy9I-00599-00154179-00154406": "God won't hear as me we'll just shame to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00600-00154407-00154574": "the situation maybe we just build to her", "do9ky0eXy9I-00601-00154575-00154763": "maybe we just are kind of holding back", "do9ky0eXy9I-00602-00154764-00155054": "from God because we're like I know what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00603-00155055-00155275": "he's gonna say and I don't want to say I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00604-00155276-00155516": "know I've been that when you go through", "do9ky0eXy9I-00605-00155517-00155735": "a time of just deep deep hurt you're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00606-00155736-00155936": "like God I know what you're I know what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00607-00155937-00156161": "you're gonna say I know what you're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00608-00156162-00156406": "gonna say just don't want to hear it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00609-00156407-00156692": "you're gonna tell me that I'll get", "do9ky0eXy9I-00610-00156693-00157049": "through this and I don't think I will so", "do9ky0eXy9I-00611-00157050-00157322": "you said it's okay I'll just I'll just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00612-00157323-00157510": "ignore it it'll pick up where I left off", "do9ky0eXy9I-00613-00157511-00158230": "and you sit there waiting", "do9ky0eXy9I-00614-00158231-00158399": "okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00615-00158400-00158842": "prayer for some reason Christians", "do9ky0eXy9I-00616-00158843-00159152": "drastically will just miss the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00617-00159153-00159341": "opportunities of this prayer and we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00618-00159342-00159476": "don't know how powerful prayers because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00619-00159477-00159647": "no rain you know I was reading something", "do9ky0eXy9I-00620-00159648-00159929": "the other day half half of America has", "do9ky0eXy9I-00621-00159930-00160117": "never read the Bible all the way through", "do9ky0eXy9I-00622-00160118-00160511": "but a large majority I'm sorry I said", "do9ky0eXy9I-00623-00160512-00160856": "that wrong 11% of America has", "do9ky0eXy9I-00624-00160857-00161029": "all the way through I said that wrong", "do9ky0eXy9I-00625-00161030-00161350": "yet almost half of America believes that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00626-00161351-00161953": "the Bible is not having work it doesn't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00627-00161954-00162212": "apply to your life it's not really", "do9ky0eXy9I-00628-00162213-00162550": "beneficial but yet well not only 11%", "do9ky0eXy9I-00629-00162551-00162887": "hasn't read it do you see the problem", "do9ky0eXy9I-00630-00162888-00163157": "here we like to say oh there's power in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00631-00163158-00163288": "the word but then we don't like to read", "do9ky0eXy9I-00632-00163289-00163474": "the word well I'd say many prayers a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00633-00163475-00163586": "good idea but don't you don't actually", "do9ky0eXy9I-00634-00163587-00163832": "like to pray why don't have time to do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00635-00163833-00164089": "that I get the wife is busy but I get to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00636-00164090-00164294": "Jesus was pretty busy doing it said the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00637-00164295-00164495": "he got I was afraid dad tells me that if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00638-00164496-00164803": "Jesus you know God was praying hey maybe", "do9ky0eXy9I-00639-00164804-00165166": "I should do so and then support groups", "do9ky0eXy9I-00640-00165167-00165386": "you know when I talk about some support", "do9ky0eXy9I-00641-00165387-00165521": "groups I'm not talking about a bunch of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00642-00165522-00165688": "people who have a bad nest add to the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00643-00165689-00165845": "person who you have to bend an attitude", "do9ky0eXy9I-00644-00165846-00166003": "with and you all get together in the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00645-00166004-00166136": "same house and start talking about how", "do9ky0eXy9I-00646-00166137-00166390": "terrible they are that's not supportive", "do9ky0eXy9I-00647-00166391-00166639": "I mean like for instance a group where", "do9ky0eXy9I-00648-00166640-00166738": "you actually get help", "do9ky0eXy9I-00649-00166739-00167116": "counselors do this often times one", "do9ky0eXy9I-00650-00167117-00167282": "example would be maybe like an AAA group", "do9ky0eXy9I-00651-00167283-00167416": "I think that's kind of technically", "do9ky0eXy9I-00652-00167417-00167558": "considered a support group something", "do9ky0eXy9I-00653-00167559-00167779": "like that there are such things as", "do9ky0eXy9I-00654-00167780-00167962": "grieving support groups and you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00655-00167963-00168206": "they're they're after", "do9ky0eXy9I-00656-00168207-00168773": "so anyways now here's just a real quick", "do9ky0eXy9I-00657-00168774-00169437": "thing", "do9ky0eXy9I-00658-00169438-00169645": "you might look at the things I said", "do9ky0eXy9I-00659-00169646-00169852": "about forgiving them went on saying well", "do9ky0eXy9I-00660-00169853-00170092": "that means if they come on they mosey on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00661-00170093-00170362": "by I just need to open them I'll open", "do9ky0eXy9I-00662-00170363-00170503": "them and second to accept them with with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00663-00170504-00170659": "open arms", "do9ky0eXy9I-00664-00170660-00171039": "Trust is earned Trust is earned", "do9ky0eXy9I-00665-00171040-00171349": "never forget that Trust is earned before", "do9ky0eXy9I-00666-00171350-00171586": "God gives us something big he tests us", "do9ky0eXy9I-00667-00171587-00172006": "visiting he tests us and then according", "do9ky0eXy9I-00668-00172007-00172321": "to our tests he gives us something else", "do9ky0eXy9I-00669-00172322-00172846": "and then he tests us if God Himself who", "do9ky0eXy9I-00670-00172847-00173091": "already knows her going to act test us", "do9ky0eXy9I-00671-00173092-00173353": "don't you think that maybe you would be", "do9ky0eXy9I-00672-00173354-00173976": "wise not to just blindly believe someone", "do9ky0eXy9I-00673-00173977-00174193": "especially if someone has a history of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00674-00174194-00174415": "betrayal you just I'm not saying you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00675-00174416-00174673": "know they can never you know move on and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00676-00174674-00174865": "the healing can never come with just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00677-00174866-00175291": "don't be stupid about it you know if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00678-00175292-00175609": "they apologize at a time and watch", "do9ky0eXy9I-00679-00175610-00176170": "observe just kind of see if they live", "do9ky0eXy9I-00680-00176171-00176437": "what they're saying would be with no I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00681-00176438-00176608": "not saying wait for them to stumble and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00682-00176609-00176710": "then it's thinking that they have a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00683-00176711-00176995": "slight as you know a misstep don't don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00684-00176996-00177124": "believe like Francis did you guys know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00685-00177125-00177678": "that Kanye West released a Christian", "do9ky0eXy9I-00686-00177679-00177994": "well I wouldn't listen to it and it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00687-00177995-00178279": "not my style music his sound really has", "do9ky0eXy9I-00688-00178280-00178326": "never", "do9ky0eXy9I-00689-00178327-00178557": "music but I will see this it's it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00690-00178558-00178860": "there's a lot of preaching in there you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00691-00178861-00179082": "just I mean I listen to Christian music", "do9ky0eXy9I-00692-00179083-00179196": "and I was thinking around this is a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00693-00179197-00179478": "preach heavy you know and in fact the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00694-00179479-00179655": "last song and it's just called Jesus is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00695-00179656-00179940": "Lord and it has like four lines in it or", "do9ky0eXy9I-00696-00179941-00180282": "two lines in it you'd think that I'd be", "do9ky0eXy9I-00697-00180283-00180426": "able to remember it I just listened", "do9ky0eXy9I-00698-00180427-00180648": "turned this afternoon you basically says", "do9ky0eXy9I-00699-00180649-00180876": "every knee will bow Jesus is Lord it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00700-00180877-00181227": "the whole song the whole thing and this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00701-00181228-00181374": "is Kanye West Siemens the same guy who", "do9ky0eXy9I-00702-00181375-00181767": "said hey I'm God is you know I don't I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00703-00181768-00181902": "don't know how to feel about it but I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00704-00181903-00182115": "know that this I know I know that that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00705-00182116-00182331": "album was his attempt to learn by God", "do9ky0eXy9I-00706-00182332-00182559": "and you can tell through the lyrics that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00707-00182560-00182727": "they were heartfelt regardless of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00708-00182728-00183152": "whether he sticks within a nine and I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00709-00183153-00183348": "guess that's all I have to say about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00710-00183349-00183855": "that so anyways if they cost a church", "do9ky0eXy9I-00711-00183856-00184196": "conflicts just stay out of it", "do9ky0eXy9I-00712-00184197-00184508": "you know how many people I've seen think", "do9ky0eXy9I-00713-00184509-00184827": "that's between you and them I'm so good", "do9ky0eXy9I-00714-00184828-00184971": "with them and so they still get with", "do9ky0eXy9I-00715-00184972-00185256": "them and then the attitude spreads it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00716-00185257-00185501": "like it's like cancer or gangrene or", "do9ky0eXy9I-00717-00185502-00185697": "something else that spreads grab the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00718-00185698-00185979": "leash is not it's not good it never ends", "do9ky0eXy9I-00719-00185980-00186135": "well and we always tire so it won't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00720-00186136-00186318": "happen to me because that wasn't part of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00721-00186319-00186480": "the problem and I'm smart enough I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00722-00186481-00186696": "mature enough you know is they okay well", "do9ky0eXy9I-00723-00186697-00186924": "after you don't smell it your farts you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00724-00186925-00187194": "might wanna go ahead and let some", "do9ky0eXy9I-00725-00187195-00187395": "distance devolve there don't hang around", "do9ky0eXy9I-00726-00187396-00187619": "people who cause the problems in church", "do9ky0eXy9I-00727-00187620-00187842": "because here's the thing it will spread", "do9ky0eXy9I-00728-00187843-00188190": "guys it does it really really does and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00729-00188191-00188442": "that's that is biblical so just you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00730-00188443-00188664": "remember that and keep your distance", "do9ky0eXy9I-00731-00188665-00188901": "from them here's the thing everybody has", "do9ky0eXy9I-00732-00188902-00189278": "good stories everybody has been stories", "do9ky0eXy9I-00733-00189279-00189528": "you know they can they can they can tell", "do9ky0eXy9I-00734-00189529-00189664": "you quite the you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-00735-00189665-00189826": "quite the yarn about how they were the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00736-00189827-00190063": "victim in people mistreated you you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00737-00190064-00190213": "shouldn't you should adhere to hear some", "do9ky0eXy9I-00738-00190214-00190351": "of the things that hear people will come", "do9ky0eXy9I-00739-00190352-00190495": "to us and say did you really do that to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00740-00190496-00191041": "them Emily what what what this story", "do9ky0eXy9I-00741-00191042-00191254": "gets so warped and stuff were there the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00742-00191255-00191437": "victim and they've been so wronged by", "do9ky0eXy9I-00743-00191438-00191614": "everybody asleep that's not what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00744-00191615-00191815": "happened at all I mean this is none of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00745-00191816-00191947": "your business so we're not talking about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00746-00191948-00192304": "of it that's why there have been some", "do9ky0eXy9I-00747-00192305-00192466": "times Woodson went when somebody say", "do9ky0eXy9I-00748-00192467-00192643": "well they said that he did it and I had", "do9ky0eXy9I-00749-00192644-00193093": "to like sit and think about it because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00750-00193094-00193528": "it was so far off from the truth but", "do9ky0eXy9I-00751-00193529-00193669": "anyways you know it makes a good story", "do9ky0eXy9I-00752-00193670-00194053": "anyhow and I love fiction I guess that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00753-00194054-00194200": "they should have just written it in a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00754-00194201-00194373": "book that we got to enjoy it to me", "do9ky0eXy9I-00755-00194374-00194980": "anyway so remember that now jeepers does", "do9ky0eXy9I-00756-00194981-00195136": "tell us that that when there's someone", "do9ky0eXy9I-00757-00195137-00195436": "who abandons the place that there is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00758-00195437-00195726": "nothing you can do to win them back", "do9ky0eXy9I-00759-00195727-00196099": "remember that when somebody turns away", "do9ky0eXy9I-00760-00196100-00196267": "from the face you can't win them with an", "do9ky0eXy9I-00761-00196268-00196372": "argument cuz what are you gonna say", "do9ky0eXy9I-00762-00196373-00196528": "Jesus they already know about Jesus", "do9ky0eXy9I-00763-00196529-00196762": "that's Jesus that they rejected now not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00764-00196763-00197050": "saying God can't do something but you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00765-00197051-00197266": "can't do anything and remember if the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00766-00197267-00197413": "Holy Spirit hasn't gotten through to", "do9ky0eXy9I-00767-00197414-00197617": "them yet why do you think that you would", "do9ky0eXy9I-00768-00197618-00197914": "be able to it just it's some kind of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00769-00197915-00198046": "trying to say that I'm more powerful", "do9ky0eXy9I-00770-00198047-00198196": "than the Holy Spirit himself", "do9ky0eXy9I-00771-00198197-00198439": "I mean just throwing that out there if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00772-00198440-00198694": "you were wrong as situation even if you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00773-00198695-00198826": "were only partially wrong", "do9ky0eXy9I-00774-00198827-00199201": "honestly just apologize conduct yourself", "do9ky0eXy9I-00775-00199202-00199909": "with integrity there may be a person of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00776-00199910-00200146": "integrity where people know maybe you're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00777-00200147-00200236": "gonna do the right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00778-00200237-00200391": "because that's who you are even when", "do9ky0eXy9I-00779-00200392-00200518": "people are out other people are doing", "do9ky0eXy9I-00780-00200519-00200647": "the wrong thing you're still going to do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00781-00200648-00200893": "the right thing and what we'd like to do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00782-00200894-00201003": "is we'd like to make ourselves to the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00783-00201004-00201279": "victim and everything so that everybody", "do9ky0eXy9I-00784-00201280-00201538": "feels right for us and we all do it if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00785-00201539-00201709": "you think no I don't do that yes it may", "do9ky0eXy9I-00786-00201710-00202101": "be that we hope they'll do it when", "do9ky0eXy9I-00787-00202102-00202452": "somebody betrays you it is their fault", "do9ky0eXy9I-00788-00202453-00202747": "not yours for some reason as Christians", "do9ky0eXy9I-00789-00202748-00202963": "we like to shift the blame because we're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00790-00202964-00203107": "Christians it has to be our fault on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00791-00203108-00203526": "time if somebody betrays you it was", "do9ky0eXy9I-00792-00203527-00203800": "their fault you see a lot of patience is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00793-00203801-00203944": "hard to do with this if I would have", "do9ky0eXy9I-00794-00203945-00204421": "done this about it on this event it was", "do9ky0eXy9I-00795-00204422-00204769": "their fault they made the choice okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00796-00204770-00205054": "they made the choice it's like this if a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00797-00205055-00205296": "man cheats on the wife is it the Y spot", "do9ky0eXy9I-00798-00205298-00205563": "because she didn't have sex with them no", "do9ky0eXy9I-00799-00205564-00205951": "it's his fault he too feels to her right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00800-00205952-00206292": "before God if he cheated it's his fault", "do9ky0eXy9I-00801-00206294-00206575": "if you're in a loveless sexless marriage", "do9ky0eXy9I-00802-00206576-00206755": "that doesn't give you the right to lie", "do9ky0eXy9I-00803-00206756-00207094": "to God I mean goodness sakes you took an", "do9ky0eXy9I-00804-00207094-00207315": "oath as a man be a man and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00805-00207316-00207567": "I will die if I never have sex with you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00806-00207569-00207775": "again I will die I will go to the grave", "do9ky0eXy9I-00807-00207776-00207957": "being faithful because that is the man", "do9ky0eXy9I-00808-00207958-00208080": "that I am because that's the man God", "do9ky0eXy9I-00809-00208081-00208185": "called me to be", "do9ky0eXy9I-00810-00208186-00208515": "that is being a manatee being a man is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00811-00208516-00208771": "not demanding sex being a man is not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00812-00208771-00208971": "saying hey you have to surrender your", "do9ky0eXy9I-00813-00208973-00209154": "body to me because I own sex that's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00814-00209155-00209382": "nothing man it's being invaded saying", "do9ky0eXy9I-00815-00209383-00209583": "even if my desires are fulfilled I will", "do9ky0eXy9I-00816-00209584-00209866": "still work for your own desires that is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00817-00209867-00210148": "being a man that is hard but as being a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00818-00210148-00210198": "minute", "do9ky0eXy9I-00819-00210200-00210571": "anyways don't beat yourself up for", "do9ky0eXy9I-00820-00210571-00210778": "loving and serving people what we do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00821-00210779-00211003": "sometimes is we do everything right and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00822-00211004-00211177": "then something goes wrong and we say I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00823-00211178-00211641": "shouldn't deplore the time into them", "do9ky0eXy9I-00824-00211642-00211959": "never never never beat yourself up for", "do9ky0eXy9I-00825-00211960-00212200": "loving and serving people you will love", "do9ky0eXy9I-00826-00212201-00212355": "and serve some people who will spit in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00827-00212356-00212803": "your face never ever ever regret it and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00828-00212804-00213073": "God has more people for you to spit in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00829-00213073-00213417": "your face God will breed by more people", "do9ky0eXy9I-00830-00213419-00213723": "that will also spit in your face but", "do9ky0eXy9I-00831-00213723-00214114": "remember Jesus where you really see him", "do9ky0eXy9I-00832-00214115-00214396": "going to everyone not just the people", "do9ky0eXy9I-00833-00214396-00214612": "who would accept him and I remember one", "do9ky0eXy9I-00834-00214613-00214864": "key part when everyone who is following", "do9ky0eXy9I-00835-00214865-00215046": "him left and he lost many of his", "do9ky0eXy9I-00836-00215048-00215310": "disciples and I don't know who else was", "do9ky0eXy9I-00837-00215311-00215512": "there but it seems like only the twelve", "do9ky0eXy9I-00838-00215513-00215706": "were there possibly a few others but", "do9ky0eXy9I-00839-00215707-00215907": "mostly just the twelve in the state", "do9ky0eXy9I-00840-00215908-00216171": "level going from hundreds to twelve hey", "do9ky0eXy9I-00841-00216173-00216432": "that's a real church boom right there", "do9ky0eXy9I-00842-00216433-00216867": "okay keep loving and serving regardless", "do9ky0eXy9I-00843-00216869-00217015": "of the situation and actually something", "do9ky0eXy9I-00844-00217016-00217419": "you need to remember regardless don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00845-00217421-00217635": "get people on your side this is what we", "do9ky0eXy9I-00846-00217636-00217813": "do and I mention this again as I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00847-00217814-00218017": "mentioned this before in the last week", "do9ky0eXy9I-00848-00218017-00218307": "it's worth mentioning again I did what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00849-00218308-00218488": "was right and they keep doing what's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00850-00218489-00218781": "wrong so now I need to get people on my", "do9ky0eXy9I-00851-00218782-00219064": "side so they see that I I did what was", "do9ky0eXy9I-00852-00219065-00219442": "right that makes sense in your head", "do9ky0eXy9I-00853-00219442-00219819": "somewhere but once again so we did what", "do9ky0eXy9I-00854-00219821-00219952": "was right at first", "do9ky0eXy9I-00855-00219953-00220378": "was wrong see that doesn't that doesn't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00856-00220379-00220579": "fit just because you did what was right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00857-00220580-00220723": "in and didn't pay off and they're still", "do9ky0eXy9I-00858-00220723-00220948": "going at it oh no no no not everybody", "do9ky0eXy9I-00859-00220948-00221137": "you talk to has a new rumor for you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00860-00221138-00221305": "about how terrible the person you are", "do9ky0eXy9I-00861-00221306-00221448": "when you didn't do any of those things", "do9ky0eXy9I-00862-00221450-00221873": "that that doesn't give you the right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00863-00221875-00222109": "guys I'm saying that I've seen this from", "do9ky0eXy9I-00864-00222110-00222328": "experience it doesn't give you the right", "do9ky0eXy9I-00865-00222329-00222610": "to start doing what's wrong because of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00866-00222611-00222746": "they're wrong", "do9ky0eXy9I-00867-00222748-00223023": "that's a hard lesson to learn when you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00868-00223025-00223483": "know imagine this when somebody mistreat", "do9ky0eXy9I-00869-00223484-00223798": "you and then you pray and craft God and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00870-00223798-00224125": "he says hey I'm working medium working", "do9ky0eXy9I-00871-00224126-00224523": "in me I was a victim god organ them", "do9ky0eXy9I-00872-00224523-00224844": "they're still doing it and God's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00873-00224846-00225133": "meanwhile saying I'm working you I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00874-00225134-00225569": "working patients in you for instance the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00875-00225571-00225859": "audacity of you god I cannot believe", "do9ky0eXy9I-00876-00225860-00225916": "this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00877-00225917-00226144": "I need patients when they're the ones", "do9ky0eXy9I-00878-00226144-00226492": "whose be evil see how God works he does", "do9ky0eXy9I-00879-00226492-00226663": "things were even if we think that they", "do9ky0eXy9I-00880-00226664-00226837": "need it more than we needed God still", "do9ky0eXy9I-00881-00226838-00227140": "works and you know what I found it's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00882-00227141-00227326": "necessarily that God isn't weren't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00883-00227327-00227539": "working in them it's that mind your own", "do9ky0eXy9I-00884-00227540-00227941": "business see we like to put ourselves in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00885-00227942-00228241": "the place of God God let me tell you how", "do9ky0eXy9I-00886-00228242-00228406": "to do your job right because you're not", "do9ky0eXy9I-00887-00228407-00228655": "doing it right currently meanwhile God", "do9ky0eXy9I-00888-00228656-00228913": "is saying okay let me tell you I'm the", "do9ky0eXy9I-00889-00228914-00229146": "master of all this just because you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00890-00229148-00229276": "don't understand what everybody doesn't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00891-00229277-00229389": "mean acting sit there", "do9ky0eXy9I-00892-00229390-00229614": "you imagine this you have a", "do9ky0eXy9I-00893-00229615-00229764": "three-year-old who follows you around", "do9ky0eXy9I-00894-00229765-00229923": "all day telling you how everything you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00895-00229923-00230054": "do is wrong", "do9ky0eXy9I-00896-00230055-00230294": "daddy I saw you go to work and you did", "do9ky0eXy9I-00897-00230296-00230535": "this that was wrong okay you don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00898-00230536-00230688": "understand the intricacies of work", "do9ky0eXy9I-00899-00230689-00230867": "little man and I mean I've got a lot of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00900-00230869-00231048": "stuff going on here I have to do this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00901-00231048-00231096": "like this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00902-00231096-00231282": "and you try to explain to them it well", "do9ky0eXy9I-00903-00231283-00231492": "okay daddy you shouldn't know this it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00904-00231492-00231636": "like you're three years old what do you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00905-00231637-00231912": "know about the world I take your diaper", "do9ky0eXy9I-00906-00231913-00232233": "six months ago is you see what I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00907-00232234-00232505": "saying that's what we do with God God", "do9ky0eXy9I-00908-00232506-00232923": "I'm holding you accountable because I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-00909-00232923-00233304": "God in this situation as they yeah no no", "do9ky0eXy9I-00910-00233305-00233490": "God so God even if he's doing something", "do9ky0eXy9I-00911-00233491-00233802": "you don't like God is still God even if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00912-00233803-00234066": "he's doing something you don't want okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00913-00234067-00234309": "if they continue to talk bad about you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00914-00234310-00234513": "okay they say it was just a one-time", "do9ky0eXy9I-00915-00234514-00234651": "betrayal but then they keep they just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00916-00234652-00234986": "keep spreading something just let it go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00917-00234987-00235298": "let it go even if they're still going if", "do9ky0eXy9I-00918-00235300-00235413": "they're still talking bad about you let", "do9ky0eXy9I-00919-00235414-00235830": "it go people will eventually see your", "do9ky0eXy9I-00920-00235831-00236178": "actions or they'll hear about your", "do9ky0eXy9I-00921-00236179-00236339": "actions not cause them to think twice", "do9ky0eXy9I-00922-00236340-00236648": "either way the person who is meaningful", "do9ky0eXy9I-00923-00236650-00236867": "that kind of attitude is pretty obvious", "do9ky0eXy9I-00924-00236867-00237216": "eventually people will catch on and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00925-00237217-00237381": "they'll have less and less people that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00926-00237382-00237516": "are close to them and that's that's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00927-00237517-00237861": "really as a tragedy because you'll find", "do9ky0eXy9I-00928-00237862-00238059": "that a lot of the times when you invent", "do9ky0eXy9I-00929-00238060-00238209": "evil for someone else", "do9ky0eXy9I-00930-00238210-00238389": "God just has a way of bringing it back", "do9ky0eXy9I-00931-00238390-00238689": "on you a lot of times that you intend", "do9ky0eXy9I-00932-00238690-00238973": "evil for someone so really don't don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00933-00238975-00239187": "don't rejoice when somebody else gets", "do9ky0eXy9I-00934-00239188-00239334": "their comeuppance", "do9ky0eXy9I-00935-00239335-00239558": "that's a stupidest thing you could do", "do9ky0eXy9I-00936-00239559-00240185": "because you should desire mercy for them", "do9ky0eXy9I-00937-00240186-00240414": "think about the people who wronged did", "do9ky0eXy9I-00938-00240415-00240558": "you really want them to go to hell and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00939-00240559-00240861": "burn for eternity that's a terrible", "do9ky0eXy9I-00940-00240862-00241104": "thing to want on somebody just because", "do9ky0eXy9I-00941-00241105-00241217": "they did you wrong", "do9ky0eXy9I-00942-00241219-00241467": "geez grow up in your brain I mean", "do9ky0eXy9I-00943-00241467-00241606": "there's more to life than", "do9ky0eXy9I-00944-00241607-00241744": "one person you're wrong do you there's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00945-00241744-00241885": "billions of people on the planet guys", "do9ky0eXy9I-00946-00241886-00242176": "billions goodness sakes if you find one", "do9ky0eXy9I-00947-00242177-00242344": "who betrays you or doesn't like you go", "do9ky0eXy9I-00948-00242344-00242592": "find another eight billion out there", "do9ky0eXy9I-00949-00242594-00243028": "goodness sakes anyways never defend", "do9ky0eXy9I-00950-00243029-00243166": "yourself on social media I know I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00951-00243167-00243310": "already said that so why did I say again", "do9ky0eXy9I-00952-00243311-00243655": "because we always do if you're mad stay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00953-00243656-00243853": "off social media stop texting people", "do9ky0eXy9I-00954-00243854-00244285": "it's okay to be quiet it's alright you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00955-00244286-00244501": "know when the Bible talks about um you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00956-00244502-00244842": "know being quiet and dignified that is", "do9ky0eXy9I-00957-00244844-00245107": "before God that's good advice that's", "do9ky0eXy9I-00958-00245108-00245206": "real good advice", "do9ky0eXy9I-00959-00245207-00245455": "how big a fight it is to keep your mouth", "do9ky0eXy9I-00960-00245456-00245871": "shut don't be defensive or argumentative", "do9ky0eXy9I-00961-00245871-00246117": "you don't have to prove you're right and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00962-00246119-00246337": "when you get in that attitude it starts", "do9ky0eXy9I-00963-00246338-00246487": "seeping into your other relationships", "do9ky0eXy9I-00964-00246488-00246696": "you start getting defensive about", "do9ky0eXy9I-00965-00246698-00247042": "everything you know and then you're on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00966-00247042-00247225": "edge and your wife says hey can you take", "do9ky0eXy9I-00967-00247226-00247825": "the trash out oh why because we're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00968-00247826-00248014": "already on edge because romulan we're", "do9ky0eXy9I-00969-00248015-00248236": "still in fight mode it's like have you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00970-00248237-00248392": "ever seen somebody who goes and gets in", "do9ky0eXy9I-00971-00248392-00248539": "a serious fight on Facebook or YouTube", "do9ky0eXy9I-00972-00248540-00248713": "and then they get off their computer", "do9ky0eXy9I-00973-00248714-00248848": "they're there huffing and puffing and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00974-00248848-00249035": "they're walking back and forth", "do9ky0eXy9I-00975-00249036-00249323": "like geez don't talk to them they're on", "do9ky0eXy9I-00976-00249325-00249521": "fire you might catch on fire yourself", "do9ky0eXy9I-00977-00249523-00249777": "don't be defensive argumentative just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00978-00249778-00250035": "just let it go and this is where some", "do9ky0eXy9I-00979-00250036-00250196": "serious soul-searching comes and you", "do9ky0eXy9I-00980-00250198-00250394": "really have to ask yourself where am i", "do9ky0eXy9I-00981-00250396-00250584": "and then you have to go to people who", "do9ky0eXy9I-00982-00250585-00250734": "tell you the truth and say look guys", "do9ky0eXy9I-00983-00250735-00250971": "where am i where am I", "do9ky0eXy9I-00984-00250971-00251553": "get real in your core you that's just", "do9ky0eXy9I-00985-00251554-00251838": "terrible if the problem doesn't die down", "do9ky0eXy9I-00986-00251839-00252098": "address it only if you must and willing", "do9ky0eXy9I-00987-00252100-00252542": "to who you must only if you must and", "do9ky0eXy9I-00988-00252544-00252873": "only to who you must let's say for", "do9ky0eXy9I-00989-00252873-00253116": "instance an entire community saves that", "do9ky0eXy9I-00990-00253117-00253746": "I I think Nicole there's a good example", "do9ky0eXy9I-00991-00253746-00253994": "now obviously that's not true and Nicole", "do9ky0eXy9I-00992-00253996-00254136": "can just say hey you know he didn't hit", "do9ky0eXy9I-00993-00254137-00254331": "me but some people when they make up", "do9ky0eXy9I-00994-00254332-00254658": "their mind they just run I mean don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-00995-00254659-00254856": "don't tell me about the facts man this", "do9ky0eXy9I-00996-00254857-00255105": "is this is clearly my decision of", "do9ky0eXy9I-00997-00255106-00255402": "reality it is 100 on you stick with okay", "do9ky0eXy9I-00998-00255403-00255617": "so then eventually it's gonna probably", "do9ky0eXy9I-00999-00255619-00255971": "start to die down but this is an example", "do9ky0eXy9I-01000-00255973-00256116": "of when it might might start to be", "do9ky0eXy9I-01001-00256117-00256380": "beneficial to address it Ricky comes to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01002-00256381-00256488": "me and he starts giving me a speech", "do9ky0eXy9I-01003-00256489-00256716": "about how I need to stop hitting the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01004-00256717-00256908": "hitting a golf and how unbiblical is an", "do9ky0eXy9I-01005-00256909-00257064": "Aries called the cops and I think Simon", "do9ky0eXy9I-01006-00257065-00257301": "happens might be a good idea to address", "do9ky0eXy9I-01007-00257302-00257577": "that okay hold on I love your heart I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-01008-00257578-00257862": "glad you're willing to defend people ask", "do9ky0eXy9I-01009-00257863-00258309": "Nicole yourself I didn't do it only the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01010-00258310-00258711": "who you list okay and only and only if", "do9ky0eXy9I-01011-00258712-00258969": "you must don't get distracted from your", "do9ky0eXy9I-01012-00258969-00259278": "mission so we do is because because", "do9ky0eXy9I-01013-00259279-00259416": "something happened we get distracted I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01014-00259417-00259590": "mean okay so my mission is no longer to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01015-00259591-00259767": "do this for God now I talk hey I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-01016-00259767-00259946": "putting out little fires well before you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01017-00259948-00260112": "know it all your attention is putting on", "do9ky0eXy9I-01018-00260113-00260244": "out on all these little fires and you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01019-00260244-00260498": "forgot what your mission in life was why", "do9ky0eXy9I-01020-00260500-00260617": "am I even here anymore", "do9ky0eXy9I-01021-00260619-00260864": "surely I wasn't created", "do9ky0eXy9I-01022-00260865-00261464": "all day no you weren't a big Christian", "do9ky0eXy9I-01023-00261465-00261596": "doesn't mean you have to put yourself in", "do9ky0eXy9I-01024-00261596-00261733": "bad situations I'm obviously talking", "do9ky0eXy9I-01025-00261734-00262016": "about abuse here if you or someone you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01026-00262017-00262289": "know is in physical danger please do get", "do9ky0eXy9I-01027-00262290-00262538": "help I know that yeah I really have time", "do9ky0eXy9I-01028-00262539-00262697": "to talk about this in great detail but", "do9ky0eXy9I-01029-00262698-00263028": "there are confidential ways to get help", "do9ky0eXy9I-01030-00263029-00263243": "especially for children don't go", "do9ky0eXy9I-01031-00263244-00263404": "continually subject your children to an", "do9ky0eXy9I-01032-00263405-00263680": "abusive situation I see a lot of times", "do9ky0eXy9I-01033-00263681-00263864": "very unfortunately people who are on", "do9ky0eXy9I-01034-00263865-00263915": "drugs", "do9ky0eXy9I-01035-00263916-00264074": "I date people who are just not good for", "do9ky0eXy9I-01036-00264075-00264299": "their kids I to the point of law station", "do9ky0eXy9I-01037-00264300-00264587": "or abuse and because they're so hungry", "do9ky0eXy9I-01038-00264588-00264812": "for love they're willing to continue to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01039-00264813-00265132": "subject their child to this terrible get", "do9ky0eXy9I-01040-00265133-00265330": "help get help do it for you and do it", "do9ky0eXy9I-01041-00265331-00265678": "for the kids seriously that's you can", "do9ky0eXy9I-01042-00265679-00265796": "get help from a master very", "do9ky0eXy9I-01043-00265797-00265997": "confidentially you can even say you're", "do9ky0eXy9I-01044-00265998-00266162": "going in for something else and then", "do9ky0eXy9I-01045-00266163-00266476": "just tell the pastor that you lied about", "do9ky0eXy9I-01046-00266477-00266851": "that it was necessary to you there's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01047-00266852-00267019": "ways of getting cops involved without", "do9ky0eXy9I-01048-00267020-00267289": "the person knowing there's ways of", "do9ky0eXy9I-01049-00267290-00267548": "getting there there's ways of doing it", "do9ky0eXy9I-01050-00267549-00267839": "just don't give up and if he says he's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01051-00267840-00268303": "sorry for the 500th time he's lying ok", "do9ky0eXy9I-01052-00268304-00268451": "so we're just gonna move on from there", "do9ky0eXy9I-01053-00268452-00268691": "but really don't don't just live with", "do9ky0eXy9I-01054-00268692-00268724": "that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01055-00268725-00268901": "if you ever trade you will go right back", "do9ky0eXy9I-01056-00268902-00269141": "to it and someone else if you don't heal", "do9ky0eXy9I-01057-00269142-00269372": "I cannot tell you how many sir present", "do9ky0eXy9I-01058-00269373-00269578": "surprisingly only Joe just happens a", "do9ky0eXy9I-01059-00269579-00269825": "woman goes from an abusive situation to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01060-00269826-00269993": "another reason situations think but you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01061-00269994-00270310": "just got out of that one it's really", "do9ky0eXy9I-01062-00270311-00270496": "really really essential that you deal", "do9ky0eXy9I-01063-00270497-00270733": "because if you don't and you are", "do9ky0eXy9I-01064-00270734-00270877": "betrayed you will literally go right", "do9ky0eXy9I-01065-00270878-00271105": "back to it and they're not just talking", "do9ky0eXy9I-01066-00271106-00271319": "about women here - we all do the same", "do9ky0eXy9I-01067-00271320-00271537": "things and not just abusive", "do9ky0eXy9I-01068-00271538-00271765": "chips you know somebody with traces and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01069-00271766-00271978": "we're so hurt that we immediately go to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01070-00271979-00272062": "another", "do9ky0eXy9I-01071-00272063-00272209": "let me get try and get your hypothetical", "do9ky0eXy9I-01072-00272210-00272512": "situation now let's say I'm a pastor the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01073-00272513-00272704": "senior pastor I'm an eighth house or not", "do9ky0eXy9I-01074-00272705-00272925": "a pastor let's say I'm the pastor and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01075-00272926-00273316": "Ricky does something he betrays me in", "do9ky0eXy9I-01076-00273317-00273502": "some way and it just really crosses a", "do9ky0eXy9I-01077-00273503-00273832": "big stink in the church so let's say Tim", "do9ky0eXy9I-01078-00273833-00274066": "was his right-hand man in it and I say", "do9ky0eXy9I-01079-00274067-00274300": "oh man well Tim still here I'm gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-01080-00274301-00274513": "point him as Marianne yeah so yeah I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01081-00274514-00274750": "would just exasperation out of hurt", "do9ky0eXy9I-01082-00274751-00274924": "appointing someone who is the same", "do9ky0eXy9I-01083-00274925-00275149": "problem said I mean and we do this in", "do9ky0eXy9I-01084-00275150-00275317": "lots of different ways in life and I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01085-00275318-00275473": "hope that you can see how it applies to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01086-00275474-00275596": "me because they don't have time delivery", "do9ky0eXy9I-01087-00275597-00275890": "to much more on that and I will say this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01088-00275891-00276115": "divorce doesn't bring healing it stops", "do9ky0eXy9I-01089-00276116-00276252": "the damage from getting worse and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01090-00276253-00276508": "healing from coming while causing more", "do9ky0eXy9I-01091-00276509-00276763": "damage that's a lot so let me kind of", "do9ky0eXy9I-01092-00276764-00276970": "break it down first off there's this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01093-00276971-00277231": "idea about divorce in pop culture that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01094-00277232-00277711": "it fixes all the problems it doesn't out", "do9ky0eXy9I-01095-00277712-00277975": "of out of 100% of all the divorces that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01096-00277976-00278172": "I've ever seen it never ends well", "do9ky0eXy9I-01097-00278173-00278509": "indifference I have never once seen a", "do9ky0eXy9I-01098-00278510-00278722": "divorce go well I've never once seen a", "do9ky0eXy9I-01099-00278723-00278842": "divorce where the people don't get", "do9ky0eXy9I-01100-00278843-00279103": "change from it know after saying that it", "do9ky0eXy9I-01101-00279104-00279385": "doesn't it stops that damage from", "do9ky0eXy9I-01102-00279386-00279589": "getting worse but it also stops healing", "do9ky0eXy9I-01103-00279590-00279724": "through in a situation from happening", "do9ky0eXy9I-01104-00279725-00280141": "and it brings new harm that you didn't", "do9ky0eXy9I-01105-00280142-00280477": "know existed all your married and what I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01106-00280478-00280747": "mean by that well let's say let's say", "do9ky0eXy9I-01107-00280748-00280912": "you're in a situation where the husband", "do9ky0eXy9I-01108-00280913-00281161": "is just very mean he talks down to me", "do9ky0eXy9I-01109-00281162-00281371": "and so rather than going to help or", "do9ky0eXy9I-01110-00281372-00281439": "anything like that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01111-00281440-00281806": "use divorce him and now although that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01112-00281807-00282016": "problem hasn't gotten any worse or", "do9ky0eXy9I-01113-00282017-00282277": "better now you find yourself dealing", "do9ky0eXy9I-01114-00282278-00282332": "with", "do9ky0eXy9I-01115-00282333-00282523": "an attitude problem of hardness apart", "do9ky0eXy9I-01116-00282524-00282872": "see it brought another problem to see", "do9ky0eXy9I-01117-00282873-00283079": "how that works it's something worried", "do9ky0eXy9I-01118-00283080-00283301": "divorce always gives another problem", "do9ky0eXy9I-01119-00283302-00283628": "divorce always gives another problem now", "do9ky0eXy9I-01120-00283629-00283850": "I'm not saying that I'm not commenting", "do9ky0eXy9I-01121-00283851-00283982": "on whether or not anyone has ever", "do9ky0eXy9I-01122-00283983-00284185": "validated in getting a better care", "do9ky0eXy9I-01123-00284186-00284402": "that's not my point at all I don't care", "do9ky0eXy9I-01124-00284403-00284693": "what I'm talking about is don't think", "do9ky0eXy9I-01125-00284694-00285029": "that divorce is this cure-all just", "do9ky0eXy9I-01126-00285030-00285155": "because the pop culture tells you that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01127-00285156-00285488": "you will have more problems and that's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01128-00285489-00285656": "just how that's going to go be ready for", "do9ky0eXy9I-01129-00285657-00286019": "that ideally every every married person", "do9ky0eXy9I-01130-00286020-00286316": "will get home but we as men they don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-01131-00286317-00286574": "like getting help we don't tell me what", "do9ky0eXy9I-01132-00286575-00286838": "to do I know anything no here's another", "do9ky0eXy9I-01133-00286839-00287000": "thing I will say this your spouse will", "do9ky0eXy9I-01134-00287001-00287150": "betray you and what I mean by that is", "do9ky0eXy9I-01135-00287151-00287267": "they will they will let you down they", "do9ky0eXy9I-01136-00287268-00287456": "will offend you because that people will", "do9ky0eXy9I-01137-00287457-00287534": "let you down", "do9ky0eXy9I-01138-00287535-00287846": "a strong marriage is dependent on", "do9ky0eXy9I-01139-00287847-00288179": "forgiving in rebuilding I know I talked", "do9ky0eXy9I-01140-00288180-00288341": "about abuse now we're not talking about", "do9ky0eXy9I-01141-00288342-00288440": "abuse we're talking about a regular", "do9ky0eXy9I-01142-00288441-00288731": "marriage situation a strong marriage is", "do9ky0eXy9I-01143-00288732-00288914": "dependent on forgiving and rebuilding", "do9ky0eXy9I-01144-00288915-00289178": "it's dependent on it because your spouse", "do9ky0eXy9I-01145-00289179-00289313": "will do something offends you you have", "do9ky0eXy9I-01146-00289314-00289481": "to rebuild you will get mad at your", "do9ky0eXy9I-01147-00289482-00289703": "spouse to enter a bill that's what", "do9ky0eXy9I-01148-00289704-00290072": "marriage is now and I will see this I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01149-00290073-00290231": "know that some people think it's it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01150-00290232-00290549": "two people giving fifty-fifty I know", "do9ky0eXy9I-01151-00290550-00290708": "some people say no it's two people you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01152-00290709-00290945": "think I understand the answer is that of", "do9ky0eXy9I-01153-00290946-00291149": "those things real marriage is usually", "do9ky0eXy9I-01154-00291150-00291326": "various between you giving absolutely", "do9ky0eXy9I-01155-00291327-00291569": "nothing to you giving others that's how", "do9ky0eXy9I-01156-00291570-00291752": "real marriage works the husband is gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-01157-00291753-00291917": "have his act together one day then not", "do9ky0eXy9I-01158-00291918-00292106": "the next day the wife is gonna be crazy", "do9ky0eXy9I-01159-00292107-00292304": "one day and then completely loving the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01160-00292305-00292652": "next that's how people are do you ever", "do9ky0eXy9I-01161-00292653-00293405": "have an off day so the few things when", "do9ky0eXy9I-01162-00293406-00293669": "you are betrayed now catch on to this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01163-00293670-00293792": "because this is the very last thing", "do9ky0eXy9I-01164-00293793-00293835": "we're going", "do9ky0eXy9I-01165-00293836-00294156": "say then we're closing with this when", "do9ky0eXy9I-01166-00294157-00294342": "you have been betrayed people become", "do9ky0eXy9I-01167-00294343-00294858": "plus and minus signs how can they", "do9ky0eXy9I-01168-00294859-00295059": "benefit me and how can they take away", "do9ky0eXy9I-01169-00295060-00295248": "from me do I have the energy for this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01170-00295249-00295512": "person because I've been hurt with this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01171-00295513-00295686": "person now other people become plus and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01172-00295687-00295767": "minuses", "do9ky0eXy9I-01173-00295768-00296049": "let me give you an example Kurt and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01174-00296050-00296244": "Renee are not here they are in helpful", "do9ky0eXy9I-01175-00296245-00296469": "now they do a lot of the cleaning of the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01176-00296470-00296850": "church so if I've been betrayed my", "do9ky0eXy9I-01177-00296851-00297039": "probable reaction is gonna be something", "do9ky0eXy9I-01178-00297040-00297096": "like this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01179-00297097-00297549": "I really wish they were here to clean", "do9ky0eXy9I-01180-00297550-00297855": "because now I had to do it see they", "do9ky0eXy9I-01181-00297856-00297978": "become nothing more to me than a", "do9ky0eXy9I-01182-00297979-00298254": "pleasant - like I'm not interested about", "do9ky0eXy9I-01183-00298255-00298443": "tennis people I've been interested in", "do9ky0eXy9I-01184-00298444-00298584": "them so much as they can benefit you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01185-00298585-00298716": "know why did we do that we were hurt", "do9ky0eXy9I-01186-00298717-00299213": "because I'm trying to see you can know", "do9ky0eXy9I-01187-00299214-00299556": "so you can know for Jesus people were", "do9ky0eXy9I-01188-00299557-00299979": "people and preservation - so just three", "do9ky0eXy9I-01189-00299980-00300192": "three last things here about betrayal", "do9ky0eXy9I-01190-00300193-00300402": "and disappointments this actually is for", "do9ky0eXy9I-01191-00300403-00300615": "all just all disappointments any time", "do9ky0eXy9I-01192-00300616-00300789": "you've been done with disappointments", "do9ky0eXy9I-01193-00300790-00300993": "remember this you need the three sacred", "do9ky0eXy9I-01194-00300994-00301329": "things first off is sacred places this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01195-00301330-00301476": "is something where you miss and this is", "do9ky0eXy9I-01196-00301477-00301623": "a place where you get along to be with", "do9ky0eXy9I-01197-00301624-00301968": "God it has no technology in it it has no", "do9ky0eXy9I-01198-00301969-00302193": "distractions there's no TV there's no", "do9ky0eXy9I-01199-00302194-00302334": "anything it's just a place for you and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01200-00302335-00302619": "God I know some people who literally", "do9ky0eXy9I-01201-00302620-00303012": "made a closet in their house and they go", "do9ky0eXy9I-01202-00303013-00303242": "in there to shut the door", "do9ky0eXy9I-01203-00303243-00303543": "that's fine just as long as you can get", "do9ky0eXy9I-01204-00303544-00303756": "there excuse me and you can get there in", "do9ky0eXy9I-01205-00303757-00303978": "the daily basis I wouldn't pick", "do9ky0eXy9I-01206-00303979-00304353": "somewhere like Canada because you can't", "do9ky0eXy9I-01207-00304354-00304551": "go there today I mean unless you live", "do9ky0eXy9I-01208-00304552-00304754": "there in which case I'm sorry", "do9ky0eXy9I-01209-00304755-00305123": "you know the second sacred sacred times", "do9ky0eXy9I-01210-00305124-00305460": "this time of each day is forgotten", "do9ky0eXy9I-01211-00305461-00305710": "there's something that happens guys", "do9ky0eXy9I-01212-00305711-00305917": "special there's something that happens", "do9ky0eXy9I-01213-00305918-00306118": "you have sacred places and sacred times", "do9ky0eXy9I-01214-00306119-00306367": "you feel it in your spirit and you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-01215-00306368-00306508": "I'm going to meet with God right now I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01216-00306509-00306688": "know God with us all the time I got", "do9ky0eXy9I-01217-00306689-00306937": "better but there's just something", "do9ky0eXy9I-01218-00306938-00307305": "special about that secret a secret place", "do9ky0eXy9I-01219-00307306-00307654": "this is what this is my place this is my", "do9ky0eXy9I-01220-00307655-00307807": "place this is my time I'm going to be", "do9ky0eXy9I-01221-00307808-00308119": "with God now for most of people who have", "do9ky0eXy9I-01222-00308120-00308452": "kids if you're gonna do the morning you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01223-00308453-00308656": "ask me real early because kids wake up", "do9ky0eXy9I-01224-00308657-00309124": "by crackin off for no Perry it's like", "do9ky0eXy9I-01225-00309125-00309355": "okay you guys went to bed last night at", "do9ky0eXy9I-01226-00309356-00309784": "11 you should be in bed till night why", "do9ky0eXy9I-01227-00309785-00310102": "are you awake right now yes I speak from", "do9ky0eXy9I-01228-00310103-00314674": "my last night do you never sleep Gracie", "do9ky0eXy9I-01229-00314675-00315225": "literally says she said", "do9ky0eXy9I-01230-00315226-00315745": "anyways so if you're gonna if you have", "do9ky0eXy9I-01231-00315746-00315898": "kids in the house you need to think this", "do9ky0eXy9I-01232-00315899-00315952": "one through", "do9ky0eXy9I-01233-00315953-00316141": "you really do has to be at that time", "do9ky0eXy9I-01234-00316142-00316264": "when you know the kids aren't going to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01235-00316265-00316555": "be up because here's the thing guys it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01236-00316556-00316672": "good to play with your kids and not", "do9ky0eXy9I-01237-00316673-00316858": "saying that make time for your kids that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01238-00316859-00317058": "is job number one as a father your your", "do9ky0eXy9I-01239-00317059-00317202": "wife and your kids that's job number one", "do9ky0eXy9I-01240-00317203-00317692": "however however you need to make time", "do9ky0eXy9I-01241-00317693-00317977": "forgotten ok gods like gods not on the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01242-00317978-00318022": "list", "do9ky0eXy9I-01243-00318023-00318241": "God is above the list your whole life", "do9ky0eXy9I-01244-00318242-00318613": "and Mozart guy on the list wife commits", "do9ky0eXy9I-01245-00318614-00319246": "wife takes primary over kids ok so ok", "do9ky0eXy9I-01246-00319247-00319507": "it's not gonna make sense ok so with", "do9ky0eXy9I-01247-00319508-00319765": "that being said you have to give a", "do9ky0eXy9I-01248-00319766-00320014": "little bit of God I mean you need that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01249-00320015-00320206": "now you can't do late at night have to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01250-00320207-00320341": "everyone's gonna see you can't do that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01251-00320342-00320557": "here's the problem if sometimes gets a", "do9ky0eXy9I-01252-00320558-00320733": "little bit hard to think when you've", "do9ky0eXy9I-01253-00320734-00320908": "been working all day and your brain is", "do9ky0eXy9I-01254-00320909-00321367": "right if you have some of those mentally", "do9ky0eXy9I-01255-00321368-00321532": "challenging jobs if you have one that's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01256-00321533-00321672": "physically challenging that's part two", "do9ky0eXy9I-01257-00321673-00321898": "that's hard too because like you sit", "do9ky0eXy9I-01258-00321899-00322032": "down on your bar just like ok but", "do9ky0eXy9I-01259-00322033-00322195": "diamond but if you have a mentally", "do9ky0eXy9I-01260-00322196-00322375": "challenging job like teaching or writing", "do9ky0eXy9I-01261-00322376-00322635": "or you know that kind of it your brain", "do9ky0eXy9I-01262-00322636-00322873": "is just not there you talk to your wife", "do9ky0eXy9I-01263-00322874-00323208": "about the same thing 15 anyways so the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01264-00323209-00323365": "sacred place is a sacred sacred times", "do9ky0eXy9I-01265-00323366-00323500": "and the third singer things sacred", "do9ky0eXy9I-01266-00323501-00323808": "people now there are different kinds of", "do9ky0eXy9I-01267-00323809-00323980": "people that fit into this life some", "do9ky0eXy9I-01268-00323981-00324153": "people they would love your passion", "do9ky0eXy9I-01269-00324154-00324466": "they're behind you all the way to soak", "do9ky0eXy9I-01270-00324467-00324796": "up not to contribute to you as a person", "do9ky0eXy9I-01271-00324797-00324991": "these are the know occurs they're the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01272-00324992-00325141": "pieces of the cereal that are left in", "do9ky0eXy9I-01273-00325142-00325327": "the milk they just absorb the milk and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01274-00325328-00325474": "they just they don't have any flavor to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01275-00325475-00326475": "them usually you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01276-00326476-00326652": "it's not that they're against you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01277-00326653-00327240": "they're just not with you Chris songs", "do9ky0eXy9I-01278-00327241-00327405": "inputs like this the difference between", "do9ky0eXy9I-01279-00327406-00327795": "agreement and alignment hey they may be", "do9ky0eXy9I-01280-00327796-00328029": "how you doing great things I'm not going", "do9ky0eXy9I-01281-00328030-00328179": "to help you with those great things but", "do9ky0eXy9I-01282-00328180-00328428": "you doing great things like adoption you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01283-00328429-00328551": "see people loose a lot guys you should", "do9ky0eXy9I-01284-00328552-00328728": "adopt so then we're done pink we have", "do9ky0eXy9I-01285-00328729-00329178": "any home no no I mean it's not it's not", "do9ky0eXy9I-01286-00329179-00329304": "that they're against you they think what", "do9ky0eXy9I-01287-00329305-00329457": "you're doing is great they're just not", "do9ky0eXy9I-01288-00329458-00329652": "going to help you in the direction then", "do9ky0eXy9I-01289-00329653-00329796": "there's some people who are negatives", "do9ky0eXy9I-01290-00329797-00330069": "all these do is draining energy they've", "do9ky0eXy9I-01291-00330070-00330255": "always got problems every day", "do9ky0eXy9I-01292-00330256-00330501": "now obviously friends help each other", "do9ky0eXy9I-01293-00330502-00330645": "promising that but there are some people", "do9ky0eXy9I-01294-00330646-00330864": "just training people and then no matter", "do9ky0eXy9I-01295-00330865-00330996": "how much you help them you're still the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01296-00330997-00331137": "bad guy they go and talk bad about you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01297-00331138-00331353": "and then they need you the next day it's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01298-00331354-00331812": "like we just did this guys I know what I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01299-00331813-00331968": "mean the people we just drain you and", "do9ky0eXy9I-01300-00331969-00332121": "you know those kinds of people you know", "do9ky0eXy9I-01301-00332122-00332334": "now here's the thing those kinds of", "do9ky0eXy9I-01302-00332335-00332469": "people will always get killed Trippi", "do9ky0eXy9I-01303-00332470-00332661": "those safe you need to be here for me", "do9ky0eXy9I-01304-00332662-00332996": "24/7 and if you're knocking like cranks", "do9ky0eXy9I-01305-00332997-00333401": "I'm sorry that's a little little hogwash", "do9ky0eXy9I-01306-00333402-00333591": "that's just a little hogwash you're", "do9ky0eXy9I-01307-00333592-00333702": "gonna have to find your peace with that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01308-00333703-00333948": "move on however you find your peace of", "do9ky0eXy9I-01309-00333949-00334080": "things probably if you can be turned in", "do9ky0eXy9I-01310-00334081-00334245": "prayer but you can't give your constant", "do9ky0eXy9I-01311-00334246-00334359": "attention to people who are just", "do9ky0eXy9I-01312-00334360-00334548": "draining all the time said taste is too", "do9ky0eXy9I-01313-00334549-00334707": "sacred people these are people who will", "do9ky0eXy9I-01314-00334708-00334913": "actually pry into the person as a mentor", "do9ky0eXy9I-01315-00334914-00335112": "everyone needs people in their life", "do9ky0eXy9I-01316-00335113-00335352": "important to them you are not an island", "do9ky0eXy9I-01317-00335353-00335541": "and you do not have all figured out", "do9ky0eXy9I-01318-00335542-00335913": "you need you need mentors or repair job", "do9ky0eXy9I-01319-00335914-00336069": "you need mentors with your ministry you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01320-00336070-00336214": "need mentoring spiritual", "do9ky0eXy9I-01321-00336215-00336499": "development you need mentors you need", "do9ky0eXy9I-01322-00336500-00336801": "mentors ok another another group is an", "do9ky0eXy9I-01323-00336802-00336940": "encourage these are people who are", "do9ky0eXy9I-01324-00336941-00337302": "useful but not overly this is why they", "do9ky0eXy9I-01325-00337303-00337471": "encourage you to keep going they remind", "do9ky0eXy9I-01326-00337472-00337624": "you in their mind you today why you're", "do9ky0eXy9I-01327-00337625-00337819": "doing all that stuff but at the end of", "do9ky0eXy9I-01328-00337820-00337996": "the day if you don't get your crap", "do9ky0eXy9I-01329-00337997-00338242": "together you're gonna just need the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01330-00338243-00338403": "truth the same thing they said to you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01331-00338404-00338662": "yesterday again tomorrow it's just gonna", "do9ky0eXy9I-01332-00338663-00338901": "be a thing of they always had to pour", "do9ky0eXy9I-01333-00338902-00338995": "into you and then you become the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01334-00338996-00339217": "negative person encourages are good for", "do9ky0eXy9I-01335-00339218-00339360": "getting you when you're often but when", "do9ky0eXy9I-01336-00339361-00339603": "you're on your feet don't stab me though", "do9ky0eXy9I-01337-00339604-00339820": "see how encouragers have a very limited", "do9ky0eXy9I-01338-00339821-00340273": "limited benefit to your future ok I'm", "do9ky0eXy9I-01339-00340274-00340410": "not once again I'm not trying to reduce", "do9ky0eXy9I-01340-00340411-00340632": "people but I'm just kind of making", "do9ky0eXy9I-01341-00340633-00340765": "simplify this then the next thing that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01342-00340766-00340975": "you need it is correctors these are", "do9ky0eXy9I-01343-00340976-00341276": "people who say you're adding new stings", "do9ky0eXy9I-01344-00341277-00341484": "however they say it to do whatever I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01345-00341485-00341778": "don't care you need to change ok but you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01346-00341779-00341923": "don't understand the situation I don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-01347-00341924-00342159": "understand a situation you are right by", "do9ky0eXy9I-01348-00342160-00342490": "you understand gratitude the next the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01349-00342491-00342742": "preggers whoever they are you know that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01350-00342743-00343012": "they're gonna pray about it you know you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01351-00343013-00343203": "need these people in your life you don't", "do9ky0eXy9I-01352-00343204-00343390": "need people who will kick your purpose", "do9ky0eXy9I-01353-00343391-00343615": "and then talk about it or talk to you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01354-00343616-00343830": "about your purpose or talk about other", "do9ky0eXy9I-01355-00343831-00343965": "talk to other good brother", "do9ky0eXy9I-01356-00343966-00344181": "you need somebody who actually prays", "do9ky0eXy9I-01357-00344182-00344587": "about ok the next one is a partner", "do9ky0eXy9I-01358-00344588-00344725": "somebody who will come song and come", "do9ky0eXy9I-01359-00344726-00344899": "alongside with you and do the thing with", "do9ky0eXy9I-01360-00344900-00345139": "you hopefully this is your spouse but", "do9ky0eXy9I-01361-00345140-00345322": "obviously you need other people besides", "do9ky0eXy9I-01362-00345323-00345504": "your spouse you can't expect your new", "do9ky0eXy9I-01363-00345505-00345681": "spouse with your medicine all day long", "do9ky0eXy9I-01364-00345682-00346096": "it's just too much weight and then the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01365-00346097-00346270": "last group is pastors these are", "do9ky0eXy9I-01366-00346271-00346366": "necessarily", "do9ky0eXy9I-01367-00346367-00346659": "official pastors a good official pastors", "do9ky0eXy9I-01368-00346660-00346830": "are good idea but when I say use the", "do9ky0eXy9I-01369-00346831-00346999": "term pastor I mean somebody who's", "do9ky0eXy9I-01370-00347000-00347251": "willing to disciple you and work with", "do9ky0eXy9I-01371-00347252-00347614": "you in a more intimate setting that", "do9ky0eXy9I-01372-00347615-00347869": "makes sense okay so remember those three", "do9ky0eXy9I-01373-00347870-00348028": "sacred things whenever you're done with", "do9ky0eXy9I-01374-00348029-00348193": "disappointments remember those three", "do9ky0eXy9I-01375-00348194-00348360": "sacred things they will get you through", "do9ky0eXy9I-01376-00348361-00348643": "any disappointment in life save your", "do9ky0eXy9I-01377-00348644-00348700": "places", "do9ky0eXy9I-01378-00348701-00348984": "save your times sacred people never", "do9ky0eXy9I-01379-00348985-00349162": "forget that as that's the conclusion to", "do9ky0eXy9I-01380-00349163-00349270": "all this done with disappointment", "do9ky0eXy9I-01381-00349271-00349492": "remember those three sacred because you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01382-00349493-00349629": "know faces disappointment in your life", "do9ky0eXy9I-01383-00349630-00349854": "and you won't have these three sacred", "do9ky0eXy9I-01384-00349855-00350044": "things we'll get you through it remember", "do9ky0eXy9I-01385-00350045-00350328": "them guard them invest in them you might", "do9ky0eXy9I-01386-00350329-00350452": "say I don't have those people in my life", "do9ky0eXy9I-01387-00350453-00350749": "find them find them in your life you", "do9ky0eXy9I-01388-00350750-00350947": "need them in your life you might say I", "do9ky0eXy9I-01389-00350948-00351250": "don't have a place make a place you need", "do9ky0eXy9I-01390-00351251-00351376": "these three sacred things in your life", "do9ky0eXy9I-01391-00351377-00351640": "and we'll stop there"}}, {"audio_id": "doDjVJ_F3VI", "text": {"doDjVJ_F3VI-00000-00000030-00000375": "George Elwood Smith born May 10th 1930", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00001-00000376-00000579": "is an American scientist applied", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00002-00000580-00000750": "physicists and co-inventor of the", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00003-00000751-00001089": "charge-coupled device CCD he was awarded", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00004-00001090-00001416": "a 1/4 share in the 2009 Nobel Prize in", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00005-00001417-00001662": "Physics for the invention of an imaging", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00006-00001663-00001995": "semiconductor circuit the CCD sensor", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00007-00001996-00002214": "which has become an electronic eye in", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00008-00002215-00002676": "almost all areas of photography in 2017", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00009-00002677-00002895": "Smith was announced as one of 4 winners", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00010-00002896-00003059": "of the Queen Elizabeth Prize for", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00011-00003060-00003245": "engineering for his contribution to the", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00012-00003246-00003753": "creation of digital imaging sensors", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00013-00003754-00004259": "topic biography", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00014-00004260-00004529": "Smith was born in White Plains New York", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00015-00004530-00004782": "Smith served in the US Navy and", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00016-00004783-00005025": "subsequently obtained his BSC degree", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00017-00005026-00005234": "from the University of Pennsylvania in", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00018-00005235-00005508": "1955 and his PhD degree from the", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00019-00005509-00005787": "University of Chicago in 1959 with a", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00020-00005788-00005979": "dissertation of only eight pages", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00021-00005980-00006237": "he worked at Bell Labs in Murray Hill", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00022-00006238-00006518": "New Jersey from 1959 to his retirement", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00023-00006519-00006825": "in 1986 where he led research into novel", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00024-00006826-00007109": "lasers and semiconductor devices during", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00025-00007111-00007341": "his tenure Smith was awarded dozens of", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00026-00007342-00007575": "patents and eventually headed the VLSI", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00027-00007576-00007887": "device department in 1969 Smith and", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00028-00007888-00008025": "Willard Boyle invented the", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00029-00008026-00008292": "charge-coupled device ccd for which they", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00030-00008293-00008457": "have jointly received the Franklin", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00031-00008458-00008678": "Institute Stewart ballantine medal in", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00032-00008679-00009066": "1973 the 1974 I Triple E Morris and", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00033-00009067-00009363": "Liebman memorial award the 2006 Charles", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00034-00009364-00009639": "stark Draper prize and the 2009 Nobel", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00035-00009640-00009971": "Prize in Physics both Boyle and Smith", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00036-00009972-00010170": "were avid sailors who took many trips", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00037-00010171-00010458": "together after retirement Smith sailed", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00038-00010459-00010620": "around the world with his life partner", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00039-00010621-00010917": "Janet for 17 years eventually giving up", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00040-00010918-00011235": "his hobby in 2003 to spare his creaky", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00041-00011236-00011532": "bones from further storms he currently", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00042-00011533-00011730": "resides in the where town section of", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00043-00011731-00011916": "Ocean Township Ocean County New Jersey", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00044-00011917-00012087": "in 2015", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00045-00012088-00012294": "Smith was awarded the progress medal and", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00046-00012295-00012447": "honorary fellowship of the Royal", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00047-00012448-00012969": "Photographic Society", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00048-00012969-00013482": "topic references", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00049-00013483-00014035": "topic external links", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00050-00014036-00014426": "invention Hall of Fame biography amateur", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00051-00014427-00014753": "radio licensee interview in Czech TV", "doDjVJ_F3VI-00052-00014754-00015224": "December 2013 in English in Czech"}}, {"audio_id": "doGI9TeEB0y", "text": {"doGI9TeEB0y-00000-00000000-00000782": "I", "doGI9TeEB0y-00001-00000783-00001107": "the role of the teacher is very pivotal", "doGI9TeEB0y-00002-00001108-00001302": "and the growth and development of", "doGI9TeEB0y-00003-00001303-00001511": "students there proudly one of the most", "doGI9TeEB0y-00004-00001512-00001751": "important and influential people in a", "doGI9TeEB0y-00005-00001752-00002073": "pupils life they spend a lot of time", "doGI9TeEB0y-00006-00002074-00002289": "with them each and every day and they're", "doGI9TeEB0y-00007-00002290-00002532": "really there to support nurture and", "doGI9TeEB0y-00008-00002533-00002792": "challenges students not necessarily to", "doGI9TeEB0y-00009-00002793-00002933": "coddle them and give them the answers", "doGI9TeEB0y-00010-00002934-00003189": "but to get them to continue to push", "doGI9TeEB0y-00011-00003190-00003486": "farther to dream big and to support", "doGI9TeEB0y-00012-00003486-00003795": "their aspirations and desires for", "doGI9TeEB0y-00013-00003796-00004116": "professional career growth often I would", "doGI9TeEB0y-00014-00004117-00004383": "find myself to be the only female in the", "doGI9TeEB0y-00015-00004384-00004611": "classroom and sometimes the boardroom", "doGI9TeEB0y-00016-00004612-00004890": "and various meetings so just not", "doGI9TeEB0y-00017-00004891-00005097": "necessarily having the same support and", "doGI9TeEB0y-00018-00005098-00005343": "network group from other females present", "doGI9TeEB0y-00019-00005344-00005532": "the turn to I've had to be more creative", "doGI9TeEB0y-00020-00005533-00005790": "in seeking out female mentors female", "doGI9TeEB0y-00021-00005791-00006108": "role models in addition to learning how", "doGI9TeEB0y-00022-00006109-00006291": "to communicate with all the different", "doGI9TeEB0y-00023-00006292-00006708": "genders ethnicities the way guys often", "doGI9TeEB0y-00024-00006709-00006959": "have different styles of communications", "doGI9TeEB0y-00025-00006961-00007206": "as well and just trying to learn and", "doGI9TeEB0y-00026-00007206-00007395": "adapt to those environments have been", "doGI9TeEB0y-00027-00007395-00007731": "very eye-opening and challenging I'm a", "doGI9TeEB0y-00028-00007731-00008021": "big firm believer in the importance of", "doGI9TeEB0y-00029-00008022-00008288": "industry coming into the classroom and", "doGI9TeEB0y-00030-00008289-00008709": "to help promote and really get teachers", "doGI9TeEB0y-00031-00008710-00008898": "and students excited about what we do", "doGI9TeEB0y-00032-00008899-00009113": "because I can't expect teachers and know", "doGI9TeEB0y-00033-00009114-00009317": "all the various facets of the space", "doGI9TeEB0y-00034-00009318-00009576": "program or what for example my employer", "doGI9TeEB0y-00035-00009577-00009720": "Lockheed Martin does at all our", "doGI9TeEB0y-00036-00009721-00009912": "different business units but when I can", "doGI9TeEB0y-00037-00009913-00010094": "do is make sure I spend time", "doGI9TeEB0y-00038-00010095-00010352": "enlightening them and sharing them all", "doGI9TeEB0y-00039-00010353-00010566": "the different ways that the exciting", "doGI9TeEB0y-00040-00010567-00010742": "projects we work on whether spacecraft", "doGI9TeEB0y-00041-00010743-00011035": "or aircraft or underwater you know", "doGI9TeEB0y-00042-00011036-00011309": "autonomous vehicles can be applied and", "doGI9TeEB0y-00043-00011310-00011502": "that kids can do all these exciting", "doGI9TeEB0y-00044-00011503-00011744": "career opportunities we have first", "doGI9TeEB0y-00045-00011745-00011996": "robotics programs that bring robotics", "doGI9TeEB0y-00046-00011997-00012164": "into some of the schools and communities", "doGI9TeEB0y-00047-00012165-00012371": "and there's a whole variety of different", "doGI9TeEB0y-00048-00012372-00012638": "different clubs and organizations that", "doGI9TeEB0y-00049-00012639-00012843": "kind of tie into that and it's just kind", "doGI9TeEB0y-00050-00012844-00012984": "of how you spend your time and energy", "doGI9TeEB0y-00051-00012985-00013269": "and volunteering and not only giving it", "doGI9TeEB0y-00052-00013269-00013494": "back but really paying it forward I try", "doGI9TeEB0y-00053-00013494-00013688": "to do all the different things that I", "doGI9TeEB0y-00054-00013690-00013841": "wish would have been around", "doGI9TeEB0y-00055-00013841-00014069": "and when I was that age at a good", "doGI9TeEB0y-00056-00014069-00014330": "example of a project you could perhaps", "doGI9TeEB0y-00057-00014331-00014540": "do in the classroom does not have to be", "doGI9TeEB0y-00058-00014541-00014758": "something very complex I mean how many", "doGI9TeEB0y-00059-00014759-00014891": "of you have students who have ever", "doGI9TeEB0y-00060-00014891-00015065": "perhaps made and folded as something as", "doGI9TeEB0y-00061-00015066-00015296": "simple as a paper airplane well that", "doGI9TeEB0y-00062-00015297-00015455": "could be turned into an innovative", "doGI9TeEB0y-00063-00015456-00015707": "classroom project I know I for one like", "doGI9TeEB0y-00064-00015708-00015965": "to be hands-on as a student and the days", "doGI9TeEB0y-00065-00015966-00016121": "we got to touch and work on things were", "doGI9TeEB0y-00066-00016122-00016259": "some of my favorites and some of the", "doGI9TeEB0y-00067-00016260-00016400": "best lessons that stuck with me", "doGI9TeEB0y-00068-00016401-00016658": "throughout my life and career have them", "doGI9TeEB0y-00069-00016659-00016841": "choose from different types of paper so", "doGI9TeEB0y-00070-00016842-00016994": "they can understand the importance of", "doGI9TeEB0y-00071-00016995-00017225": "material selection see if they have any", "doGI9TeEB0y-00072-00017226-00017408": "tips or tricks and how they want to fold", "doGI9TeEB0y-00073-00017409-00017647": "it and you can see how the changing in", "doGI9TeEB0y-00074-00017648-00017864": "the way you fold the paper will also", "doGI9TeEB0y-00075-00017865-00017999": "generate what you're trying to", "doGI9TeEB0y-00076-00018000-00018188": "accomplish is it to soar high is it just", "doGI9TeEB0y-00077-00018189-00018383": "get the most distance is it have the", "doGI9TeEB0y-00078-00018384-00018602": "most air time or perhaps to do", "doGI9TeEB0y-00079-00018603-00018839": "acrobatics and tricks well are there any", "doGI9TeEB0y-00080-00018840-00018992": "other things that you can add to it put", "doGI9TeEB0y-00081-00018993-00019196": "it out with you perhaps put a paperclip", "doGI9TeEB0y-00082-00019197-00019415": "towards the nose of it change the", "doGI9TeEB0y-00083-00019416-00019628": "waiting and the center of gravity how", "doGI9TeEB0y-00084-00019629-00019886": "would that make it fly what can students", "doGI9TeEB0y-00085-00019887-00020105": "do with something as simple as the tools", "doGI9TeEB0y-00086-00020106-00020378": "you have easily readily available to you", "doGI9TeEB0y-00087-00020379-00020719": "that you can then tie into well gray you", "doGI9TeEB0y-00088-00020720-00020915": "saw how this works well why don't we", "doGI9TeEB0y-00089-00020916-00021100": "look at some of the equations behind it", "doGI9TeEB0y-00090-00021101-00021278": "and kind of lead in and segue to the", "doGI9TeEB0y-00091-00021279-00021524": "maths and physics that support it what", "doGI9TeEB0y-00092-00021525-00021697": "would I like to see is an ideal", "doGI9TeEB0y-00093-00021698-00021986": "classroom in 10 years from now well I", "doGI9TeEB0y-00094-00021987-00022169": "think I'd like to have some of the", "doGI9TeEB0y-00095-00022170-00022478": "different tools that I've seen in the", "doGI9TeEB0y-00096-00022479-00022658": "European Schoolnet future classroom", "doGI9TeEB0y-00097-00022659-00022897": "laboratory they have a lot of more", "doGI9TeEB0y-00098-00022898-00023131": "hands-on type things that can take", "doGI9TeEB0y-00099-00023132-00023414": "applied learning and really bring some", "doGI9TeEB0y-00100-00023415-00023558": "of the stuff we do and work with an", "doGI9TeEB0y-00101-00023559-00023759": "industry right there to get students", "doGI9TeEB0y-00102-00023760-00023959": "touching and dealing with technology", "doGI9TeEB0y-00103-00023960-00024250": "from an early age dream big and then", "doGI9TeEB0y-00104-00024251-00024422": "have the courage to go turn those dreams", "doGI9TeEB0y-00105-00024423-00024671": "into reality as an engineer as a", "doGI9TeEB0y-00106-00024672-00024902": "scientist that's what we do we learned", "doGI9TeEB0y-00107-00024903-00025088": "the critical thinking and the conceptual", "doGI9TeEB0y-00108-00025089-00025271": "skills you need to turn anything you can", "doGI9TeEB0y-00109-00025272-00025597": "dream into reality and it's amazing to", "doGI9TeEB0y-00110-00025598-00025805": "be able to take the stuff you put your", "doGI9TeEB0y-00111-00025806-00026047": "hard work into and your time which is", "doGI9TeEB0y-00112-00026048-00026287": "your most precious commodity and finding", "doGI9TeEB0y-00113-00026288-00026423": "something that is worth your time", "doGI9TeEB0y-00114-00026424-00026602": "talents and abilities that you truly", "doGI9TeEB0y-00115-00026603-00026821": "believe in our passionate about and then", "doGI9TeEB0y-00116-00026822-00026993": "turning that into your job in your", "doGI9TeEB0y-00117-00026994-00027541": "career", "doGI9TeEB0y-00118-00027542-00027748": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "doQCUQo7teY", "text": {"doQCUQo7teY-00000-00000062-00000364": "power-to-weight ratio or specific power", "doQCUQo7teY-00001-00000365-00000634": "or power to mass ratio is a calculation", "doQCUQo7teY-00002-00000635-00000872": "commonly applied to engines and mobile", "doQCUQo7teY-00003-00000873-00001106": "power sources to enable the comparison", "doQCUQo7teY-00004-00001107-00001329": "of one unit or designed to another", "doQCUQo7teY-00005-00001330-00001583": "power-to-weight ratio as a measurement", "doQCUQo7teY-00006-00001584-00001817": "of actual performance of any engine or", "doQCUQo7teY-00007-00001818-00002108": "power source it is also used as a", "doQCUQo7teY-00008-00002109-00002318": "measurement of performance of a vehicle", "doQCUQo7teY-00009-00002319-00002551": "as a whole with the engines power output", "doQCUQo7teY-00010-00002552-00002768": "being divided by the weight or mass of", "doQCUQo7teY-00011-00002769-00002942": "the vehicle to give a metric that is", "doQCUQo7teY-00012-00002943-00003174": "independent of the vehicle size", "doQCUQo7teY-00013-00003175-00003415": "power-to-weight is often quoted by", "doQCUQo7teY-00014-00003417-00003655": "manufacturers at the peak value but the", "doQCUQo7teY-00015-00003656-00003868": "actual value may vary in use and", "doQCUQo7teY-00016-00003869-00004193": "variations will affect performance the", "doQCUQo7teY-00017-00004194-00004393": "inverse of power to weight weight to", "doQCUQo7teY-00018-00004394-00004595": "power ratio power loading is a", "doQCUQo7teY-00019-00004596-00004861": "calculation commonly applied to aircraft", "doQCUQo7teY-00020-00004862-00005137": "cars and vehicles in general to enable", "doQCUQo7teY-00021-00005138-00005300": "the comparison of one vehicles", "doQCUQo7teY-00022-00005301-00005563": "performance to another power-to-weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00023-00005564-00005827": "ratio is equal to thrust per unit mass", "doQCUQo7teY-00024-00005828-00006028": "multiplied by the velocity of any", "doQCUQo7teY-00025-00006029-00006166": "vehicle", "doQCUQo7teY-00026-00006167-00006432": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00027-00006433-00006600": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00028-00006601-00007306": "topic power-to-weight specific power", "doQCUQo7teY-00029-00007308-00007604": "the power-to-weight ratio specific power", "doQCUQo7teY-00030-00007605-00007880": "formula for an engine power plant is the", "doQCUQo7teY-00031-00007881-00008108": "power generated by the engine divided by", "doQCUQo7teY-00032-00008109-00008516": "the mass weight in this context as a", "doQCUQo7teY-00033-00008517-00008882": "colloquial term for mass to see this", "doQCUQo7teY-00034-00008883-00009082": "note that what an engineer means by the", "doQCUQo7teY-00035-00009083-00009416": "power-to-weight ratio of an electric", "doQCUQo7teY-00036-00009417-00009611": "motor is not infinite in a zero gravity", "doQCUQo7teY-00037-00009612-00009743": "environment", "doQCUQo7teY-00038-00009744-00010118": "a typical turbocharged v8 diesel engine", "doQCUQo7teY-00039-00010119-00010361": "might have an engine power of 250", "doQCUQo7teY-00040-00010362-00010682": "kilowatts 340 horsepower and a mass of", "doQCUQo7teY-00041-00010683-00010862": "380 kilograms", "doQCUQo7teY-00042-00010863-00011126": "840 pounds giving it a power-to-weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00043-00011127-00011563": "ratio of 0.65 kilowatts per kilogram", "doQCUQo7teY-00044-00011564-00011987": "0.40 horsepower per pound examples of", "doQCUQo7teY-00045-00011988-00012233": "high power-to-weight ratios can often be", "doQCUQo7teY-00046-00012234-00012518": "found in turbines this is because of", "doQCUQo7teY-00047-00012519-00012704": "their ability to operate at very high", "doQCUQo7teY-00048-00012705-00013046": "speeds for example the space shuttles", "doQCUQo7teY-00049-00013047-00013288": "main engines used turbo pumps machines", "doQCUQo7teY-00050-00013290-00013535": "consisting of a pump driven by a turbine", "doQCUQo7teY-00051-00013536-00013751": "engine to feed the propellants liquid", "doQCUQo7teY-00052-00013752-00013972": "oxygen and liquid hydrogen into the", "doQCUQo7teY-00053-00013973-00014269": "engines combustion chamber the original", "doQCUQo7teY-00054-00014270-00014513": "liquid hydrogen turbo pump is similar in", "doQCUQo7teY-00055-00014513-00014726": "size to an automobile engine weighing", "doQCUQo7teY-00056-00014727-00015069": "approximately 352 kilograms", "doQCUQo7teY-00057-00015070-00015428": "775 pounds and produces 72,000", "doQCUQo7teY-00058-00015429-00015538": "horsepower", "doQCUQo7teY-00059-00015538-00015794": "53.6 megawatts for a power-to-weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00060-00015794-00016235": "ratio of 153 kilowatts per kilogram 93", "doQCUQo7teY-00061-00016236-00016862": "horsepower per pound", "doQCUQo7teY-00062-00016863-00017450": "topic physical interpretation", "doQCUQo7teY-00063-00017451-00017738": "in classical mechanics instantaneous", "doQCUQo7teY-00064-00017739-00017930": "power as the limiting value of the", "doQCUQo7teY-00065-00017931-00018152": "average work done per unit time as the", "doQCUQo7teY-00066-00018153-00018422": "time interval delta T approaches 0 ie", "doQCUQo7teY-00067-00018423-00018644": "the derivative with respect to time of", "doQCUQo7teY-00068-00018645-00019683": "the work done P equals lim delta t 0", "doQCUQo7teY-00069-00019684-00021308": "delta w t delta T equals lim delta T 0 P", "doQCUQo7teY-00070-00021309-00022922": "a V G equals D D T W T display style P", "doQCUQo7teY-00071-00022923-00023194": "equals Lim underscore delta T right", "doQCUQo7teY-00072-00023195-00023696": "arrow 0 T frac Delta W T delta T equals", "doQCUQo7teY-00073-00023697-00024025": "Lim underscore delta T right arrow 0 P", "doQCUQo7teY-00074-00024026-00024455": "underscore mathroom avg equals frac d dt", "doQCUQo7teY-00075-00024456-00024893": "w t the typically used metrical unit of", "doQCUQo7teY-00076-00024894-00025402": "the power-to-weight ratio is w", "doQCUQo7teY-00077-00025403-00026008": "k:g display style tea frac w kilogram", "doQCUQo7teY-00078-00026008-00026975": "which equals m2 s3 display style tea", "doQCUQo7teY-00079-00026976-00027482": "frac m carrot to s carrot 3 this fact", "doQCUQo7teY-00080-00027483-00027701": "allows one to express the power to", "doQCUQo7teY-00081-00027702-00028018": "weight ratio purely by SI base units a", "doQCUQo7teY-00082-00028019-00028304": "vehicle's power-to-weight ratio equals", "doQCUQo7teY-00083-00028305-00028564": "its acceleration times its velocity so", "doQCUQo7teY-00084-00028566-00028802": "at twice the velocity it experiences", "doQCUQo7teY-00085-00028802-00029018": "half the acceleration all else being", "doQCUQo7teY-00086-00029019-00029389": "equal", "doQCUQo7teY-00087-00029391-00029537": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00088-00029538-00029764": "topic propulsive power", "doQCUQo7teY-00089-00029764-00030080": "[Music]", "doQCUQo7teY-00090-00030081-00030302": "if the work to be done is rectilinear", "doQCUQo7teY-00091-00030302-00030730": "motion of a body with constant mass M", "doQCUQo7teY-00092-00030731-00031130": "display style M whose center of mass has", "doQCUQo7teY-00093-00031131-00031358": "to be accelerated along a possibly non", "doQCUQo7teY-00094-00031358-00031958": "straight to a speed V T display style", "doQCUQo7teY-00095-00031958-00032654": "math b FV t an angle Phi display style", "doQCUQo7teY-00096-00032655-00032969": "Phi with respect to the centre and", "doQCUQo7teY-00097-00032970-00033203": "radial of a gravitational field by an", "doQCUQo7teY-00098-00033204-00033401": "onboard power plant then the Associated", "doQCUQo7teY-00099-00033402-00034750": "kinetic energy is e K equals 1 to M V T", "doQCUQo7teY-00100-00034751-00035303": "to display style e underscore k equals t", "doQCUQo7teY-00101-00035304-00036133": "frac 1 to m math b FV t carat to where m", "doQCUQo7teY-00102-00036134-00036874": "display style m is mass of the body v t", "doQCUQo7teY-00103-00036875-00037379": "display style math b FV t his speed of", "doQCUQo7teY-00104-00037380-00037598": "the center of mass of the body changing", "doQCUQo7teY-00105-00037599-00037751": "with time the work-energy principle", "doQCUQo7teY-00106-00037752-00038012": "states that the work done to the object", "doQCUQo7teY-00107-00038013-00038227": "over a period of time as equal to the", "doQCUQo7teY-00108-00038228-00038435": "difference in its total energy over that", "doQCUQo7teY-00109-00038436-00038660": "period of time so the rate at which work", "doQCUQo7teY-00110-00038661-00038864": "is done is equal to the rate of change", "doQCUQo7teY-00111-00038865-00039080": "of the kinetic energy in the absence of", "doQCUQo7teY-00112-00039081-00039490": "potential energy changes the work done", "doQCUQo7teY-00113-00039491-00039809": "from time T to time T plus delta-t along", "doQCUQo7teY-00114-00039810-00040010": "the path C as defined as the line", "doQCUQo7teY-00115-00040011-00040156": "integral", "doQCUQo7teY-00116-00040157-00042201": "C F D X equals T t plus delta t f v t d", "doQCUQo7teY-00117-00042202-00042697": "t display style int underscore see math", "doQCUQo7teY-00118-00042698-00043141": "BF f CDO TD math BF x equals int", "doQCUQo7teY-00119-00043142-00043507": "underscore t caret T plus delta-t math", "doQCUQo7teY-00120-00043508-00044125": "BFF c do t math b FV t dt so the", "doQCUQo7teY-00121-00044126-00044350": "fundamental theorem of calculus has that", "doQCUQo7teY-00122-00044351-00045810": "power is given by F T V T equals M a T V", "doQCUQo7teY-00123-00045811-00046888": "T equals tau T Omega T display style", "doQCUQo7teY-00124-00046889-00047461": "math bfft C do t math be F V T equals M", "doQCUQo7teY-00125-00047462-00048007": "math be f-80c do t math be FV t equals", "doQCUQo7teY-00126-00048008-00048654": "math be f tau T C do t math be F Omega T", "doQCUQo7teY-00127-00048655-00048862": "where", "doQCUQo7teY-00128-00048863-00050189": "a T equals D D T V T display style math", "doQCUQo7teY-00129-00050190-00050824": "bf8 e equals frac D DT math b FV t his", "doQCUQo7teY-00130-00050825-00051040": "acceleration of the center of mass of", "doQCUQo7teY-00131-00051041-00051650": "the body changing with time f t display", "doQCUQo7teY-00132-00051651-00052108": "style math BF f t his linear force or", "doQCUQo7teY-00133-00052109-00052342": "thrust applied upon the center of mass", "doQCUQo7teY-00134-00052344-00052881": "of the body changing with time v t", "doQCUQo7teY-00135-00052882-00053416": "display style math b FV t is velocity of", "doQCUQo7teY-00136-00053417-00053644": "the center of mass of the body changing", "doQCUQo7teY-00137-00053645-00054269": "with time tau t display style math b f", "doQCUQo7teY-00138-00054270-00054659": "tau t his torque applied upon the center", "doQCUQo7teY-00139-00054660-00054928": "of mass of the body changing with time", "doQCUQo7teY-00140-00054929-00055605": "omega t display style math BF omega t", "doQCUQo7teY-00141-00055607-00055900": "his angular velocity of the center of", "doQCUQo7teY-00142-00055901-00056135": "mass of the body changing with time in", "doQCUQo7teY-00143-00056136-00056378": "propulsion power is only delivered if", "doQCUQo7teY-00144-00056379-00056566": "the powerplant is in motion and is", "doQCUQo7teY-00145-00056567-00056762": "transmitted to cause the body to be in", "doQCUQo7teY-00146-00056763-00057053": "motion it is typically assumed here that", "doQCUQo7teY-00147-00057054-00057278": "mechanical transmission allows the power", "doQCUQo7teY-00148-00057279-00057516": "plant to operate at peak output power", "doQCUQo7teY-00149-00057517-00057821": "this assumption allows engine tuning to", "doQCUQo7teY-00150-00057822-00058025": "trade power band width and engine mass", "doQCUQo7teY-00151-00058026-00058303": "for transmission complexity and mass", "doQCUQo7teY-00152-00058304-00058562": "electric motors do not suffer from this", "doQCUQo7teY-00153-00058563-00058760": "trade-off instead trading their high", "doQCUQo7teY-00154-00058761-00059041": "torque for traction at low speed the", "doQCUQo7teY-00155-00059042-00059242": "power advantage are powered to weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00156-00059244-00060166": "ratio as then P 2 W equals a t", "doQCUQo7teY-00157-00060167-00060735": "v-t display style mbox p 2w equals math", "doQCUQo7teY-00158-00060736-00061638": "BF 80 math BF V T where V T display", "doQCUQo7teY-00159-00061639-00062079": "style math b FV t is linear speed of the", "doQCUQo7teY-00160-00062079-00062544": "center of mass of the body", "doQCUQo7teY-00161-00062545-00062691": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00162-00062692-00063357": "topic engine power the actual useful", "doQCUQo7teY-00163-00063358-00063547": "power of any traction engine can be", "doQCUQo7teY-00164-00063548-00063778": "calculated using a dynamometer to", "doQCUQo7teY-00165-00063779-00064005": "measure torque and rotational speed with", "doQCUQo7teY-00166-00064006-00064176": "peak power sustained when the", "doQCUQo7teY-00167-00064177-00064404": "transmission and or operator keeps the", "doQCUQo7teY-00168-00064405-00064609": "product of torque and rotational speed", "doQCUQo7teY-00169-00064610-00064944": "maximized for jet engines there is EB", "doQCUQo7teY-00170-00064945-00065173": "usefully calculated there for rockets", "doQCUQo7teY-00171-00065174-00065410": "there is typically no cruise speed so it", "doQCUQo7teY-00172-00065411-00065712": "is less meaningful peak power of a", "doQCUQo7teY-00173-00065713-00065937": "traction engine occurs at a rotational", "doQCUQo7teY-00174-00065938-00066144": "speed higher than the speed when torque", "doQCUQo7teY-00175-00066145-00066366": "is maximized and at or below the maximum", "doQCUQo7teY-00176-00066367-00066819": "rated rotational speed max rpm a rapidly", "doQCUQo7teY-00177-00066820-00067023": "falling torque curve would correspond", "doQCUQo7teY-00178-00067024-00067246": "with sharp torque and power curve Peaks", "doQCUQo7teY-00179-00067247-00067410": "around their Maxima at similar", "doQCUQo7teY-00180-00067411-00067654": "rotational speed for example a small", "doQCUQo7teY-00181-00067655-00067812": "lightweight engine with a large", "doQCUQo7teY-00182-00067813-00068134": "turbocharger a slowly falling or near", "doQCUQo7teY-00183-00068135-00068355": "flat torque curve would correspond with", "doQCUQo7teY-00184-00068356-00068578": "a slowly rising power curve up to a", "doQCUQo7teY-00185-00068579-00068838": "maximum at a rotational speed close to", "doQCUQo7teY-00186-00068839-00069111": "max rpm for example a large heavy", "doQCUQo7teY-00187-00069112-00069375": "multi-cylinder engine suitable for cargo", "doQCUQo7teY-00188-00069376-00069657": "hauling a falling torque curve could", "doQCUQo7teY-00189-00069658-00069882": "correspond with a near flat power curve", "doQCUQo7teY-00190-00069883-00070098": "across rotational speeds for smooth", "doQCUQo7teY-00191-00070099-00070293": "handling at different vehicle speeds", "doQCUQo7teY-00192-00070294-00070863": "such as a traction electric motor", "doQCUQo7teY-00193-00070864-00071026": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00194-00071027-00071600": "topic examples", "doQCUQo7teY-00195-00071601-00071912": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00196-00071913-00072426": "topic engines", "doQCUQo7teY-00197-00072427-00072735": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00198-00072736-00073326": "topic heat engines and heat pumps", "doQCUQo7teY-00199-00073327-00073591": "thermal energy is made up from molecular", "doQCUQo7teY-00200-00073592-00073857": "kinetic energy and latent phase energy", "doQCUQo7teY-00201-00073858-00074146": "heat engines are able to convert thermal", "doQCUQo7teY-00202-00074147-00074335": "energy in the form of a temperature", "doQCUQo7teY-00203-00074336-00074560": "gradient between a hot source and a cold", "doQCUQo7teY-00204-00074561-00074794": "sink into other desirable mechanical", "doQCUQo7teY-00205-00074795-00075106": "work heat pumps take mechanical work to", "doQCUQo7teY-00206-00075107-00075283": "regenerate thermal energy in a", "doQCUQo7teY-00207-00075284-00075565": "temperature gradient care should be made", "doQCUQo7teY-00208-00075566-00075736": "when interpreting propulsive power", "doQCUQo7teY-00209-00075737-00075990": "especially for jet engines and rockets", "doQCUQo7teY-00210-00075991-00076204": "deliverable from heat engines to a", "doQCUQo7teY-00211-00076205-00076572": "vehicle", "doQCUQo7teY-00212-00076573-00076719": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00213-00076720-00077049": "topic electric motors and electro-motive", "doQCUQo7teY-00214-00077050-00077450": "generators", "doQCUQo7teY-00215-00077451-00077753": "an electric motor uses electrical energy", "doQCUQo7teY-00216-00077754-00077945": "to provide mechanical work usually", "doQCUQo7teY-00217-00077946-00078137": "through the interaction of a magnetic", "doQCUQo7teY-00218-00078138-00078464": "field and current-carrying conductors by", "doQCUQo7teY-00219-00078465-00078689": "the interaction of mechanical work on an", "doQCUQo7teY-00220-00078690-00078901": "electrical conductor in a magnetic field", "doQCUQo7teY-00221-00078902-00079229": "electrical energy can be generated", "doQCUQo7teY-00222-00079230-00079459": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00223-00079460-00079609": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00224-00079610-00080241": "topic fluid engines and fluid pumps", "doQCUQo7teY-00225-00080242-00080524": "fluids liquid and gas can be used to", "doQCUQo7teY-00226-00080525-00080758": "transmit and/or store energy using", "doQCUQo7teY-00227-00080759-00081006": "pressure and other fluid properties", "doQCUQo7teY-00228-00081007-00081256": "hydraulic liquid and pneumatic gas", "doQCUQo7teY-00229-00081257-00081490": "engines convert fluid pressure into", "doQCUQo7teY-00230-00081491-00081721": "other desirable mechanical or electrical", "doQCUQo7teY-00231-00081722-00082069": "work fluid pumps convert mechanical or", "doQCUQo7teY-00232-00082070-00082246": "electrical work into movement or", "doQCUQo7teY-00233-00082247-00082486": "pressure changes of a fluid or storage", "doQCUQo7teY-00234-00082487-00082685": "in a pressure vessel", "doQCUQo7teY-00235-00082686-00082915": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00236-00082916-00083065": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00237-00083066-00083383": "topic thermoelectric generators and", "doQCUQo7teY-00238-00083384-00083899": "electrodermal actuators", "doQCUQo7teY-00239-00083900-00084133": "a variety of effects can be harnessed to", "doQCUQo7teY-00240-00084134-00084331": "produce thermal electricity thermionic", "doQCUQo7teY-00241-00084332-00084562": "emission pyroelectricity and", "doQCUQo7teY-00242-00084563-00084898": "piezoelectricity electrical resistance", "doQCUQo7teY-00243-00084899-00085129": "in ferromagnetism of materials can be", "doQCUQo7teY-00244-00085130-00085297": "harnessed to generate thermoacoustic", "doQCUQo7teY-00245-00085298-00085589": "energy from an electric current", "doQCUQo7teY-00246-00085590-00085992": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00247-00085993-00086331": "topic electrochemical galvanic and", "doQCUQo7teY-00248-00086332-00086888": "electrostatic cell systems", "doQCUQo7teY-00249-00086889-00087035": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00250-00087036-00087185": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00251-00087186-00087759": "topic closed cell batteries", "doQCUQo7teY-00252-00087760-00088017": "all electrochemical cell batteries", "doQCUQo7teY-00253-00088018-00088206": "deliver a changing voltage as their", "doQCUQo7teY-00254-00088207-00088574": "chemistry changes from charged to", "doQCUQo7teY-00255-00088575-00088947": "discharged a nominal output voltage in a", "doQCUQo7teY-00256-00088948-00089178": "cut-off voltage are typically specified", "doQCUQo7teY-00257-00089179-00089475": "for a battery by its manufacturer the", "doQCUQo7teY-00258-00089476-00089679": "output voltage falls to the cutoff", "doQCUQo7teY-00259-00089680-00089897": "voltage when the battery becomes", "doQCUQo7teY-00260-00089898-00090258": "discharged the nominal output voltage is", "doQCUQo7teY-00261-00090259-00090447": "always less than the open circuit", "doQCUQo7teY-00262-00090448-00090644": "voltage produced when the battery is", "doQCUQo7teY-00263-00090645-00091002": "charged the temperature of a battery can", "doQCUQo7teY-00264-00091003-00091197": "affect the power it can deliver where", "doQCUQo7teY-00265-00091198-00091512": "lower temperatures reduce power total", "doQCUQo7teY-00266-00091513-00091710": "energy delivered from a single charge", "doQCUQo7teY-00267-00091711-00091914": "cycle is affected by both the battery", "doQCUQo7teY-00268-00091915-00092159": "temperature and the power it delivers if", "doQCUQo7teY-00269-00092160-00092424": "the temperature lowers or the power", "doQCUQo7teY-00270-00092425-00092622": "demand increases the total energy", "doQCUQo7teY-00271-00092623-00092886": "delivered at the point of discharge is", "doQCUQo7teY-00272-00092887-00093143": "also reduced", "doQCUQo7teY-00273-00093144-00093382": "battery discharge profiles are often", "doQCUQo7teY-00274-00093383-00093562": "described in terms of a factor of", "doQCUQo7teY-00275-00093563-00093917": "battery capacity for example a battery", "doQCUQo7teY-00276-00093918-00094166": "with a nominal capacity quoted in ampere", "doQCUQo7teY-00277-00094167-00094468": "hours on a c10 rated discharge current", "doQCUQo7teY-00278-00094469-00094721": "derived in amperes may safely provide a", "doQCUQo7teY-00279-00094722-00094930": "higher discharge current and therefore", "doQCUQo7teY-00280-00094931-00095155": "higher power to weight ratio but only", "doQCUQo7teY-00281-00095156-00095386": "with a lower energy capacity", "doQCUQo7teY-00282-00095387-00095660": "power-to-weight ratio for batteries is", "doQCUQo7teY-00283-00095661-00095810": "therefore less meaningful without", "doQCUQo7teY-00284-00095811-00096037": "reference to corresponding energy to", "doQCUQo7teY-00285-00096038-00096337": "weight ratio and cell temperature this", "doQCUQo7teY-00286-00096338-00096856": "relationship is known as pukers law", "doQCUQo7teY-00287-00096857-00097004": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00288-00097005-00097362": "topic electrostatic electrolytic and", "doQCUQo7teY-00289-00097363-00097872": "electrochemical capacitors", "doQCUQo7teY-00290-00097873-00098134": "capacitors store electric charge unto", "doQCUQo7teY-00291-00098135-00098373": "two electrodes separated by an electric", "doQCUQo7teY-00292-00098374-00098717": "field semi insulating dielectric medium", "doQCUQo7teY-00293-00098718-00098973": "electrostatic capacitors feature planar", "doQCUQo7teY-00294-00098974-00099186": "electrodes unto which electric charge", "doQCUQo7teY-00295-00099187-00099498": "accumulates electrolytic capacitors use", "doQCUQo7teY-00296-00099499-00099679": "a liquid electrolyte as one of the", "doQCUQo7teY-00297-00099680-00099873": "electrodes in the electric double layer", "doQCUQo7teY-00298-00099874-00100060": "effect upon the surface of the", "doQCUQo7teY-00299-00100061-00100267": "dielectric electrolyte boundary to", "doQCUQo7teY-00300-00100268-00100467": "increase the amount of charge stored per", "doQCUQo7teY-00301-00100468-00100734": "unit volume electric double layer", "doQCUQo7teY-00302-00100735-00101004": "capacitors extend both electrodes with a", "doQCUQo7teY-00303-00101005-00101256": "nano porous material such as activated", "doQCUQo7teY-00304-00101257-00101467": "carbon to significantly increase the", "doQCUQo7teY-00305-00101468-00101704": "surface area upon which electric charge", "doQCUQo7teY-00306-00101705-00101941": "can accumulate reducing the dielectric", "doQCUQo7teY-00307-00101942-00102160": "medium to nano pores and a very thin", "doQCUQo7teY-00308-00102161-00102456": "high permittivity separator while", "doQCUQo7teY-00309-00102457-00102697": "capacitors tend not to be as temperature", "doQCUQo7teY-00310-00102698-00102858": "sensitive as batteries they are", "doQCUQo7teY-00311-00102859-00103116": "significantly capacity constrained and", "doQCUQo7teY-00312-00103117-00103300": "without the strength of chemical bonds", "doQCUQo7teY-00313-00103301-00103502": "suffer from self discharge", "doQCUQo7teY-00314-00103503-00103798": "power-to-weight ratio of capacitors is", "doQCUQo7teY-00315-00103799-00104014": "usually higher than batteries because", "doQCUQo7teY-00316-00104015-00104227": "charge transport units within the cell", "doQCUQo7teY-00317-00104228-00104478": "are smaller electrons rather than ions", "doQCUQo7teY-00318-00104479-00104677": "however energy to weight ratio is", "doQCUQo7teY-00319-00104678-00105182": "conversely usually lower", "doQCUQo7teY-00320-00105183-00105329": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00321-00105330-00105671": "topic fuel cell stacks and flow cell", "doQCUQo7teY-00322-00105672-00106247": "batteries fuel cells and flow cells", "doQCUQo7teY-00323-00106248-00106493": "although perhaps using similar chemistry", "doQCUQo7teY-00324-00106494-00106697": "to batteries have the distinction of not", "doQCUQo7teY-00325-00106698-00106916": "containing the energy storage medium or", "doQCUQo7teY-00326-00106917-00107240": "fuel with a continuous flow of fuel and", "doQCUQo7teY-00327-00107241-00107485": "oxidant available fuel cells and flow", "doQCUQo7teY-00328-00107486-00107696": "cells continue to convert the energy", "doQCUQo7teY-00329-00107697-00107918": "storage medium into electric energy and", "doQCUQo7teY-00330-00107919-00108239": "waste products fuel cells distinctly", "doQCUQo7teY-00331-00108240-00108482": "contain a fixed electrolyte whereas flow", "doQCUQo7teY-00332-00108483-00108728": "cells also require a continuous flow of", "doQCUQo7teY-00333-00108729-00109052": "electrolyte flow cells typically have", "doQCUQo7teY-00334-00109053-00109696": "the fuel dissolved in the electrolyte", "doQCUQo7teY-00335-00109697-00110261": "topic photovoltaics", "doQCUQo7teY-00336-00110263-00110599": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00337-00110600-00111104": "topic vehicles", "doQCUQo7teY-00338-00111105-00111371": "powered to weight ratios for vehicles", "doQCUQo7teY-00339-00111372-00111596": "are usually calculated using kerb weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00340-00111597-00111869": "for cars or wet weight for motorcycles", "doQCUQo7teY-00341-00111870-00112064": "that is excluding weight of the driver", "doQCUQo7teY-00342-00112065-00112358": "and any cargo this could be slightly", "doQCUQo7teY-00343-00112358-00112561": "misleading especially with regard to", "doQCUQo7teY-00344-00112563-00112783": "motorcycles where the driver might weigh", "doQCUQo7teY-00345-00112784-00112991": "one-third to one-half as much as the", "doQCUQo7teY-00346-00112992-00113240": "vehicle itself in the sport of", "doQCUQo7teY-00347-00113241-00113468": "competitive cycling athletes performance", "doQCUQo7teY-00348-00113469-00113710": "is increasingly being expressed in vamps", "doQCUQo7teY-00349-00113711-00113927": "and thus as a power-to-weight ratio in", "doQCUQo7teY-00350-00113928-00114179": "with kilogram this can be measured", "doQCUQo7teY-00351-00114180-00114374": "through the use of a bicycle power meter", "doQCUQo7teY-00352-00114375-00114608": "or calculated from measuring incline of", "doQCUQo7teY-00353-00114608-00114800": "a road climb and the riders time to", "doQCUQo7teY-00354-00114801-00114935": "ascend it", "doQCUQo7teY-00355-00114936-00115170": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00356-00115171-00115320": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00357-00115321-00115958": "topic utility and practical vehicles", "doQCUQo7teY-00358-00115958-00116173": "most vehicles are designed to meet", "doQCUQo7teY-00359-00116174-00116389": "passenger comfort and cargo carrying", "doQCUQo7teY-00360-00116390-00116698": "requirements different designs trade-off", "doQCUQo7teY-00361-00116699-00116906": "power-to-weight ratio to increase", "doQCUQo7teY-00362-00116907-00117139": "comfort cargo space fuel economy", "doQCUQo7teY-00363-00117140-00117439": "emissions control energy security and", "doQCUQo7teY-00364-00117440-00117751": "endurance reduced drag and lower rolling", "doQCUQo7teY-00365-00117752-00117973": "resistance in a vehicle design can", "doQCUQo7teY-00366-00117974-00118208": "facilitate increased cargo space without", "doQCUQo7teY-00367-00118208-00118387": "increase in the zero cargo", "doQCUQo7teY-00368-00118388-00118547": "power-to-weight ratio", "doQCUQo7teY-00369-00118548-00118844": "this increases the role flexibility of", "doQCUQo7teY-00370-00118845-00119053": "the vehicle energy security", "doQCUQo7teY-00371-00119054-00119254": "considerations can trade-off power", "doQCUQo7teY-00372-00119255-00119488": "typically decreased and weight typically", "doQCUQo7teY-00373-00119489-00119681": "increased and therefore power-to-weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00374-00119682-00119986": "ratio for fuel flexibility or drivetrain", "doQCUQo7teY-00375-00119987-00120337": "hybridization some utility and practical", "doQCUQo7teY-00376-00120338-00120577": "vehicle variants such as hot hatches and", "doQCUQo7teY-00377-00120578-00120806": "sports utility vehicles reconfigure", "doQCUQo7teY-00378-00120807-00121036": "power typically increased and weight to", "doQCUQo7teY-00379-00121037-00121223": "provide the perception of sports car", "doQCUQo7teY-00380-00121224-00121382": "like performance or for other", "doQCUQo7teY-00381-00121383-00121699": "psychological benefit a locomotive", "doQCUQo7teY-00382-00121700-00121966": "generally must be very heavy in order to", "doQCUQo7teY-00383-00121967-00122176": "develop enough adhesion on the rails to", "doQCUQo7teY-00384-00122177-00122449": "start a train as the coefficient of", "doQCUQo7teY-00385-00122450-00122665": "friction between steel wheels and rails", "doQCUQo7teY-00386-00122666-00122998": "seldom exceeds 0.25 in most cases", "doQCUQo7teY-00387-00122999-00123223": "improving a locomotives power-to-weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00388-00123224-00123577": "ratio is often counterproductive however", "doQCUQo7teY-00389-00123578-00123823": "the choice of power transmission system", "doQCUQo7teY-00390-00123824-00124082": "such as variable frequency drive versus", "doQCUQo7teY-00391-00124083-00124298": "direct current drive may support a", "doQCUQo7teY-00392-00124299-00124516": "higher power to weight ratio by better", "doQCUQo7teY-00393-00124517-00125231": "managing propulsion power topic", "doQCUQo7teY-00394-00125232-00125954": "notable low ratio", "doQCUQo7teY-00395-00125955-00126743": "topic common power", "doQCUQo7teY-00396-00126744-00127122": "topic performance luxury roadsters and", "doQCUQo7teY-00397-00127123-00127492": "mild sports", "doQCUQo7teY-00398-00127493-00127717": "increased engine performance as a", "doQCUQo7teY-00399-00127718-00127933": "consideration but also other features", "doQCUQo7teY-00400-00127933-00128244": "associated with luxury vehicles", "doQCUQo7teY-00401-00128245-00128518": "longitudinal engines are common bodies", "doQCUQo7teY-00402-00128519-00128800": "vary from hot-hatches sedans saloons", "doQCUQo7teY-00403-00128801-00129081": "coupes convertibles and roadsters", "doQCUQo7teY-00404-00129082-00129316": "mid-range dual-sport and Cruiser", "doQCUQo7teY-00405-00129317-00129486": "motorcycles tend to have similar", "doQCUQo7teY-00406-00129488-00129748": "power-to-weight ratios", "doQCUQo7teY-00407-00129749-00129981": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00408-00129982-00130128": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00409-00130129-00130663": "topic sports vehicles", "doQCUQo7teY-00410-00130664-00130934": "power-to-weight ratio as an important", "doQCUQo7teY-00411-00130935-00131153": "vehicle characteristic that affects the", "doQCUQo7teY-00412-00131154-00131440": "acceleration of sports vehicles", "doQCUQo7teY-00413-00131441-00131673": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00414-00131674-00131820": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00415-00131821-00132309": "topic aircraft", "doQCUQo7teY-00416-00132310-00132551": "aircraft depend on high power-to-weight", "doQCUQo7teY-00417-00132552-00132834": "ratio to generate sufficient thrust to", "doQCUQo7teY-00418-00132835-00133037": "achieve sustained flight and then to fly", "doQCUQo7teY-00419-00133038-00133529": "fast", "doQCUQo7teY-00420-00133530-00134088": "topic for us to weight ratio", "doQCUQo7teY-00421-00134089-00134681": "jet aircraft produced thrust directly", "doQCUQo7teY-00422-00134682-00134816": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00423-00134817-00135306": "topic human", "doQCUQo7teY-00424-00135307-00135574": "power-to-weight ratio as important in", "doQCUQo7teY-00425-00135575-00135826": "cycling since it determines acceleration", "doQCUQo7teY-00426-00135827-00136120": "and the speed during hill climbs since a", "doQCUQo7teY-00427-00136121-00136309": "cyclists power-to-weight output", "doQCUQo7teY-00428-00136310-00136459": "decreases with fatigue", "doQCUQo7teY-00429-00136460-00136657": "it is normally discussed with relation", "doQCUQo7teY-00430-00136658-00136822": "to the length of time that he or she", "doQCUQo7teY-00431-00136823-00137104": "maintains that power a professional", "doQCUQo7teY-00432-00137105-00137308": "cyclist can produce over 20 with", "doQCUQo7teY-00433-00137309-00137637": "kilogram as a 5 second maximum a", "doQCUQo7teY-00434-00137638-00137791": "225-pound", "doQCUQo7teY-00435-00137792-00137974": "touring cyclist coasting down an", "doQCUQo7teY-00436-00137975-00138214": "exhilarating 10 degree Mountain slope at", "doQCUQo7teY-00437-00138215-00138523": "35 miles per hour rate 62 pounds per", "doQCUQo7teY-00438-00138524-00138778": "horsepower the calculation is", "doQCUQo7teY-00439-00138779-00138934": "demonstrative and does not imply", "doQCUQo7teY-00440-00138935-00139297": "terminal speed the power figure is 3.6", "doQCUQo7teY-00441-00139298-00139669": "horsepower in ISO units this is 27 with", "doQCUQo7teY-00442-00139670-00139990": "kilogram in 60 seconds of such coasting", "doQCUQo7teY-00443-00139991-00140287": "therefore 39 kilo calories are lost or", "doQCUQo7teY-00444-00140288-00140632": "45 watt hours climbing is the major", "doQCUQo7teY-00445-00140633-00140839": "impediment to progress on Road when", "doQCUQo7teY-00446-00140840-00141218": "cycling", "doQCUQo7teY-00447-00141219-00141382": "you", "doQCUQo7teY-00448-00141383-00141929": "topic see also", "doQCUQo7teY-00449-00141930-00142458": "energy density engine power propulsive", "doQCUQo7teY-00450-00142459-00142928": "efficiency specific output thrust to", "doQCUQo7teY-00451-00142929-00143406": "weight ratio vehicle metrics von Karman", "doQCUQo7teY-00452-00143407-00143729": "Gabrielli diagram"}}, {"audio_id": "d07S9PLLxN0", "text": {"d07S9PLLxN0-00000-00000017-00000388": "hi my name is Debra Spinoza and I am", "d07S9PLLxN0-00001-00000389-00000623": "both an artist and an attorney my", "d07S9PLLxN0-00002-00000624-00000911": "preferred means of advocacy is through", "d07S9PLLxN0-00003-00000911-00001136": "visual storytelling multimedia", "d07S9PLLxN0-00004-00001137-00001361": "storytelling so today I'm going to share", "d07S9PLLxN0-00005-00001362-00001544": "with you a bit about the my work and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00006-00001545-00001772": "about my project called living with", "d07S9PLLxN0-00007-00001773-00002000": "conviction sentenced to death for life", "d07S9PLLxN0-00008-00002001-00002291": "in Washington State so but first before", "d07S9PLLxN0-00009-00002292-00002537": "they do that I'm going to also share", "d07S9PLLxN0-00010-00002538-00002879": "with you a few examples of in going back", "d07S9PLLxN0-00011-00002880-00003100": "in time in which photography in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00012-00003101-00003449": "particular has been used as examples for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00013-00003450-00003881": "a variety of legal advocacy efforts okay", "d07S9PLLxN0-00014-00003882-00004127": "so I'm going to share my screen I'm", "d07S9PLLxN0-00015-00004128-00004352": "gonna try to and at one point I'm gonna", "d07S9PLLxN0-00016-00004353-00004570": "flip over to a really quick three-minute", "d07S9PLLxN0-00017-00004571-00004772": "video so hopefully that will be seamless", "d07S9PLLxN0-00018-00004773-00005038": "okay so hold that bot I'm gonna share my", "d07S9PLLxN0-00019-00005039-00005347": "screen and then and we'll get started", "d07S9PLLxN0-00020-00005348-00005563": "thank you thank you for your patience", "d07S9PLLxN0-00021-00005564-00005686": "okay", "d07S9PLLxN0-00022-00005687-00006339": "sharing screen oh sure and we'll start", "d07S9PLLxN0-00023-00006340-00006737": "the there we go okay so like I said my", "d07S9PLLxN0-00024-00006738-00006920": "project is called living with conviction", "d07S9PLLxN0-00025-00006920-00007117": "sentenced to death for life in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00026-00007118-00007246": "Washington State", "d07S9PLLxN0-00027-00007247-00007573": "and I'm gonna start out with this quote", "d07S9PLLxN0-00028-00007575-00007826": "which to my in my mind really sums up", "d07S9PLLxN0-00029-00007827-00008216": "the overall purpose of the project", "d07S9PLLxN0-00030-00008217-00008471": "really and that is a quote from Mahatma", "d07S9PLLxN0-00031-00008472-00008855": "Gandhi and the quote is an unjust law is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00032-00008856-00009170": "itself a species of violence arrest for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00033-00009171-00009478": "its breach is more so so you're going to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00034-00009479-00009713": "hear about when I first heard about this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00035-00009714-00009905": "particular issue and that I really", "d07S9PLLxN0-00036-00009906-00010160": "needed to do something about it so just", "d07S9PLLxN0-00037-00010161-00010445": "a quick overview we're gonna do focus on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00038-00010446-00010738": "a few examples of the historical use of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00039-00010739-00011038": "visual media for legal advocacy and then", "d07S9PLLxN0-00040-00011039-00011198": "I'm gonna talk about the legal issue", "d07S9PLLxN0-00041-00011199-00011456": "that I learned about and was frankly", "d07S9PLLxN0-00042-00011457-00011726": "appalled by and then I had to do some", "d07S9PLLxN0-00043-00011727-00011969": "thing about it and then I'll share with", "d07S9PLLxN0-00044-00011970-00012116": "you what has done about it and then", "d07S9PLLxN0-00045-00012117-00012362": "we'll talk about what's next okay okay", "d07S9PLLxN0-00046-00012363-00012542": "and like I said in the middle of this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00047-00012543-00012703": "I'm gonna try to flip over to a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00048-00012704-00012896": "three-minute video that's online we'll", "d07S9PLLxN0-00049-00012897-00013096": "see how that goes okay so just bear with", "d07S9PLLxN0-00050-00013097-00013363": "me okay so first", "d07S9PLLxN0-00051-00013363-00013638": "my guess is there's people out there", "d07S9PLLxN0-00052-00013640-00013947": "watching this who have recognized this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00053-00013949-00014209": "image or at least recognized what the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00054-00014210-00014461": "image is and this is Yosemite Valley", "d07S9PLLxN0-00055-00014462-00014922": "this image was taken in 1864 by a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00056-00014924-00015130": "gentleman named Carleton Watkins and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00057-00015131-00015493": "this image of Yosemite Valley and Half", "d07S9PLLxN0-00058-00015494-00015850": "Dome made its way because Carleton", "d07S9PLLxN0-00059-00015851-00016006": "Watkins really felt like this was a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00060-00016007-00016255": "beautiful beautiful place that needed to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00061-00016256-00016633": "preserve be preserved his images made", "d07S9PLLxN0-00062-00016634-00016894": "their way via a California senator to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00063-00016895-00017110": "president at the time Abraham Lincoln", "d07S9PLLxN0-00064-00017111-00017305": "and as you can imagine I think about it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00065-00017306-00017727": "1864 that's during the Civil War and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00066-00017728-00018229": "despite that President Lincoln when", "d07S9PLLxN0-00067-00018230-00018484": "these images arrived on his desk in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00068-00018485-00018763": "Washington DC he was so moved by the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00069-00018764-00019069": "imagery he was the first president to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00070-00019070-00019321": "set aside any land actually in the world", "d07S9PLLxN0-00071-00019322-00019681": "for preservation and enjoyment by future", "d07S9PLLxN0-00072-00019682-00019966": "populations so that was the beginning he", "d07S9PLLxN0-00073-00019967-00020158": "didn't in fact establish the National", "d07S9PLLxN0-00074-00020159-00020347": "Park at that point but that was the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00075-00020348-00020494": "precursor it was like a basically a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00076-00020495-00020809": "set-aside and then later on the National", "d07S9PLLxN0-00077-00020810-00020944": "Park was established I think by", "d07S9PLLxN0-00078-00020945-00021222": "Roosevelt but that was that was a really", "d07S9PLLxN0-00079-00021223-00021543": "central example of the use of media", "d07S9PLLxN0-00080-00021544-00021760": "impacting somebody who actually cannot", "d07S9PLLxN0-00081-00021761-00022033": "be present to enjoy it or to do anything", "d07S9PLLxN0-00082-00022034-00022099": "about it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00083-00022100-00022422": "okay another example and this is now", "d07S9PLLxN0-00084-00022423-00022725": "we're going over to New York City this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00085-00022726-00023008": "is an image by Jacob Riis and Jacob Riis", "d07S9PLLxN0-00086-00023009-00023359": "was an immigrant to the United States to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00087-00023360-00023790": "New York from Europe and he basically", "d07S9PLLxN0-00088-00023791-00024219": "was living in tenements and he ended up", "d07S9PLLxN0-00089-00024220-00024412": "because he was so appalled by these", "d07S9PLLxN0-00090-00024413-00024643": "conditions tenement housing which", "d07S9PLLxN0-00091-00024644-00024894": "actually housed over two-thirds of New", "d07S9PLLxN0-00092-00024895-00025030": "York City population", "d07S9PLLxN0-00093-00025031-00025243": "he started documenting it and he", "d07S9PLLxN0-00094-00025244-00025434": "actually created a book called how the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00095-00025435-00025709": "other half lives and in this book he", "d07S9PLLxN0-00096-00025710-00026080": "documented the living conditions and the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00097-00026081-00026233": "living work conditions were such that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00098-00026233-00026494": "these enormous tenement housing was", "d07S9PLLxN0-00099-00026495-00026629": "going up", "d07S9PLLxN0-00100-00026630-00026827": "the only place where they had any", "d07S9PLLxN0-00101-00026827-00027180": "windows was on the front side of the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00102-00027181-00027411": "street side right but because the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00103-00027412-00027621": "buildings were built less than an inch", "d07S9PLLxN0-00104-00027622-00027927": "apart on the sides and in the back there", "d07S9PLLxN0-00105-00027928-00028186": "was no other window access except for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00106-00028187-00028408": "the front to the street they also in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00107-00028408-00028599": "addition to not having any windows in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00108-00028600-00028893": "the vast majority of the apartments or", "d07S9PLLxN0-00109-00028894-00029115": "the homes they're inside they also had", "d07S9PLLxN0-00110-00029116-00029421": "zero ventilation and so the child infant", "d07S9PLLxN0-00111-00029422-00029636": "mortality at the time was horrific", "d07S9PLLxN0-00112-00029637-00029937": "because you know one juror in particular", "d07S9PLLxN0-00113-00029938-00030183": "would just run rabbit through out the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00114-00030184-00030520": "this these communities these families", "d07S9PLLxN0-00115-00030520-00030730": "who are living under extremely terrible", "d07S9PLLxN0-00116-00030731-00031083": "circumstances so Jacob Riis does work", "d07S9PLLxN0-00117-00031084-00031374": "his photography got the attention of the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00118-00031375-00031633": "mayor of New York City at the time who", "d07S9PLLxN0-00119-00031633-00031890": "was Theodore Roosevelt and Theodore", "d07S9PLLxN0-00120-00031891-00032098": "Roosevelt was appalled by the conditions", "d07S9PLLxN0-00121-00032099-00032293": "that he had no idea because he's from", "d07S9PLLxN0-00122-00032294-00032618": "the elite upper class and so upon", "d07S9PLLxN0-00123-00032619-00033055": "becoming governor of Washington's excuse", "d07S9PLLxN0-00124-00033056-00033304": "me governor of New York State Theodore", "d07S9PLLxN0-00125-00033305-00033757": "Roosevelt then was started and pushed", "d07S9PLLxN0-00126-00033758-00033982": "for the tenement Housing Act which", "d07S9PLLxN0-00127-00033983-00034218": "basically prohibited these types of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00128-00034219-00034561": "housing this inferior public housing for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00129-00034562-00034918": "poor people and basically required that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00130-00034919-00035276": "every single new building going up had", "d07S9PLLxN0-00131-00035277-00035658": "sunlight as well as air ventilation so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00132-00035659-00035901": "that this these conditions would would", "d07S9PLLxN0-00133-00035902-00036079": "go away so that was an example really", "d07S9PLLxN0-00134-00036080-00036454": "about a housing justice issue okay and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00135-00036455-00036664": "next is where we are going to try to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00136-00036665-00037108": "flip over to a three minute video and so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00137-00037109-00037467": "bear with me I am going to unshare and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00138-00037468-00037902": "then I'm going to share again okay to go", "d07S9PLLxN0-00139-00037903-00038121": "to the video and like I said it's about", "d07S9PLLxN0-00140-00038122-00038329": "three minutes so it's not too bad so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00141-00038330-00038545": "this video we are going to share is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00142-00038546-00039069": "about the photographer Jacob Riis okay", "d07S9PLLxN0-00143-00039070-00039390": "and I am hoping that use of volume", "d07S9PLLxN0-00144-00039391-00040125": "you'll be able to hear the video in the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00145-00040126-00040383": "early 1900's the general population in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00146-00040384-00040530": "those years had very little", "d07S9PLLxN0-00147-00040531-00040749": "understanding of what was meant by child", "d07S9PLLxN0-00148-00040750-00042417": "labor and child exploitation the kinds", "d07S9PLLxN0-00149-00042418-00042585": "of jobs you would find children working", "d07S9PLLxN0-00150-00042586-00042930": "in ranged from the mines the factories", "d07S9PLLxN0-00151-00042931-00043179": "the cotton mills to working out on the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00152-00043180-00043710": "streets selling newspapers injuries even", "d07S9PLLxN0-00153-00043711-00043953": "deaths who are very common among", "d07S9PLLxN0-00154-00043954-00044445": "children the parents would often say", "d07S9PLLxN0-00155-00044446-00044649": "that they needed the income that their", "d07S9PLLxN0-00156-00044650-00044811": "children brought in that that was what", "d07S9PLLxN0-00157-00044812-00045203": "allowed them to continue to survive a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00158-00045204-00045546": "number of parents were advocates for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00159-00045547-00045702": "child labor and their children thought", "d07S9PLLxN0-00160-00045703-00046248": "that that was the way life was one of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00161-00046249-00046377": "the first things the national child", "d07S9PLLxN0-00162-00046378-00046587": "labor committee did was to hire a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00163-00046588-00046700": "photographer", "d07S9PLLxN0-00164-00046701-00047007": "they hired Lewis Hine who was then their", "d07S9PLLxN0-00165-00047008-00047219": "photographer for the next two decades", "d07S9PLLxN0-00166-00047220-00047544": "they sent him around the country to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00167-00047545-00047859": "identify find and photograph children in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00168-00047860-00048561": "exploitative situations", "d07S9PLLxN0-00169-00048562-00048851": "he promoted himself as a Bible salesman", "d07S9PLLxN0-00170-00048852-00049055": "he said he was bringing his camera along", "d07S9PLLxN0-00171-00049056-00049280": "so he could photograph kids reading", "d07S9PLLxN0-00172-00049281-00049823": "Bibles a boy would say he was 13 when in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00173-00049824-00050065": "fact he was 11 or a girl would say she", "d07S9PLLxN0-00174-00050066-00050615": "was 12 when in fact she might be 9", "d07S9PLLxN0-00175-00050616-00050962": "[Music]", "d07S9PLLxN0-00176-00050963-00051273": "the photograph is of a young girl ten or", "d07S9PLLxN0-00177-00051274-00051375": "eleven years old", "d07S9PLLxN0-00178-00051376-00051629": "her name was Sadie Pfeiffer at a cotton", "d07S9PLLxN0-00179-00051630-00052119": "mill in Lancaster South Carolina she's", "d07S9PLLxN0-00180-00052120-00052287": "standing in front of a large loom on a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00181-00052288-00052557": "long hallway staring at and working hard", "d07S9PLLxN0-00182-00052558-00052839": "on the job of selecting the quality", "d07S9PLLxN0-00183-00052840-00053141": "product", "d07S9PLLxN0-00184-00053141-00053403": "she's probably worked most of the night", "d07S9PLLxN0-00185-00053404-00053717": "it's nearing the end of her shift she", "d07S9PLLxN0-00186-00053719-00054051": "stands there iconic as a representative", "d07S9PLLxN0-00187-00054052-00054341": "of hundreds of other girls who are being", "d07S9PLLxN0-00188-00054342-00054585": "treated just like her and who have no", "d07S9PLLxN0-00189-00054586-00054938": "choice", "d07S9PLLxN0-00190-00054939-00055329": "that photograph raised the consciousness", "d07S9PLLxN0-00191-00055329-00055557": "immediately you see that photograph and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00192-00055558-00055935": "you cannot look away from it it doesn't", "d07S9PLLxN0-00193-00055936-00056844": "say America Lewis Hine stark photographs", "d07S9PLLxN0-00194-00056845-00057162": "influence legislation over a period of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00195-00057163-00057801": "roughly 35 years this body of work on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00196-00057802-00058007": "child labor represented how he thought", "d07S9PLLxN0-00197-00058008-00058236": "and how he felt the children must not be", "d07S9PLLxN0-00198-00058237-00058947": "exploited he represents the most", "d07S9PLLxN0-00199-00058948-00059148": "important photographer in terms of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00200-00059149-00059382": "social advocacy and social change in the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00201-00059383-00059592": "first half of the 20th century", "d07S9PLLxN0-00202-00059594-00060954": "[Music]", "d07S9PLLxN0-00203-00060955-00061591": "okay whoops oh I gotta stop that hold on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00204-00061591-00061748": "sorry about that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00205-00061749-00061992": "okay so now we're gonna go back to my", "d07S9PLLxN0-00206-00061994-00062603": "slide and that is Lewis Hine um and so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00207-00062604-00063487": "here we go from current slide and uh oh", "d07S9PLLxN0-00208-00063488-00063769": "sorry I'm not sharing my screen yet I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00209-00063770-00063979": "have to remember to share my screen", "d07S9PLLxN0-00210-00063980-00064544": "right share screen and now go back to my", "d07S9PLLxN0-00211-00064545-00064709": "powerpoint thank you for bearing with me", "d07S9PLLxN0-00212-00064710-00065491": "I got this down and now I'm going to do", "d07S9PLLxN0-00213-00065492-00065735": "I want to go into slideshow and I want", "d07S9PLLxN0-00214-00065736-00066053": "to I don't want to hear current slide", "d07S9PLLxN0-00215-00066054-00066268": "there we go okay so that's Lewis Hine", "d07S9PLLxN0-00216-00066269-00066680": "and I find these examples really", "d07S9PLLxN0-00217-00066681-00067078": "inspiring really compelling and that a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00218-00067079-00067547": "long time ago I to embrace the power of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00219-00067548-00067997": "photography in order to change minds and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00220-00067998-00068435": "for social change and so as I said I'm", "d07S9PLLxN0-00221-00068436-00068648": "both an artist and a photographer I'm a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00222-00068649-00068993": "photographer and an attorney and so for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00223-00068994-00069221": "a good portion of my career I was", "d07S9PLLxN0-00224-00069222-00069440": "working for an international NGO or", "d07S9PLLxN0-00225-00069441-00069632": "international nonprofit organization as", "d07S9PLLxN0-00226-00069633-00069857": "both staff attorney and staff", "d07S9PLLxN0-00227-00069858-00070364": "photographer and we were we advocated", "d07S9PLLxN0-00228-00070365-00070667": "for poor people in the global salves to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00229-00070668-00070934": "have rights to land because in the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00230-00070935-00071084": "global south if you don't have a right", "d07S9PLLxN0-00231-00071085-00071360": "to land you are not going to survive and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00232-00071361-00071639": "your children aren't going to survive so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00233-00071640-00071896": "this is an example of a photograph that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00234-00071897-00072116": "my organization former organization", "d07S9PLLxN0-00235-00072117-00072532": "called land s I used hugely and this is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00236-00072533-00072812": "a photo of her name is Berta and she is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00237-00072813-00073127": "a widow and a mother of eight and Rwanda", "d07S9PLLxN0-00238-00073128-00073493": "was the first country to undertake", "d07S9PLLxN0-00239-00073494-00073721": "leet titling of all the land in the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00240-00073722-00073955": "country most of the land in Africa is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00241-00073956-00074234": "not titled at all it's just undocumented", "d07S9PLLxN0-00242-00074235-00074492": "land but there are very there's informal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00243-00074493-00074753": "claims to it so Rwanda is that was the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00244-00074754-00074954": "first country that basically titled all", "d07S9PLLxN0-00245-00074955-00075200": "the land and here Bertha is standing", "d07S9PLLxN0-00246-00075201-00075407": "there and she's showing the title to her", "d07S9PLLxN0-00247-00075408-00075671": "land clearly she's really proud and what", "d07S9PLLxN0-00248-00075672-00076010": "this eminent and so I was interviewing a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00249-00076011-00076211": "group of women about their experiences", "d07S9PLLxN0-00250-00076212-00076463": "in this titling process and I said does", "d07S9PLLxN0-00251-00076464-00076649": "anybody have their title with them or", "d07S9PLLxN0-00252-00076650-00076871": "did anybody receive a title and then", "d07S9PLLxN0-00253-00076872-00077120": "does anybody have a copy of their title", "d07S9PLLxN0-00254-00077121-00077255": "with them and darts out you know raised", "d07S9PLLxN0-00255-00077256-00077539": "her hand and she was like you know I I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00256-00077540-00077756": "carried around with me in the pocket of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00257-00077757-00078041": "my skirt and that is an indication of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00258-00078042-00078173": "how important to her", "d07S9PLLxN0-00259-00078174-00078386": "it is so after the meeting I said hey", "d07S9PLLxN0-00260-00078387-00078566": "let's go outside can I talk to you more", "d07S9PLLxN0-00261-00078567-00078893": "can I photograph you any in the end this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00262-00078894-00079145": "image has been used for fundraising it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00263-00079146-00079385": "has been used for advocacy it has been", "d07S9PLLxN0-00264-00079386-00079703": "used the New York Times I mean it's it's", "d07S9PLLxN0-00265-00079704-00080018": "so you know she's a moding and basically", "d07S9PLLxN0-00266-00080019-00080438": "through photography you can show our", "d07S9PLLxN0-00267-00080439-00080717": "common humanity you know someone on the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00268-00080718-00081077": "other side of the planet who supposedly", "d07S9PLLxN0-00269-00081078-00081404": "is very different from us is in fact", "d07S9PLLxN0-00270-00081405-00081680": "completely the same and wants to just", "d07S9PLLxN0-00271-00081681-00081869": "take care of the children right lead a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00272-00081870-00082102": "good life so anyway so that's Bertha", "d07S9PLLxN0-00273-00082103-00082436": "then move over to Brazil I was also", "d07S9PLLxN0-00274-00082437-00082643": "doing some work this I did leave Linda I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00275-00082644-00082964": "started freelancing and consulting and I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00276-00082965-00083233": "did some work in Brazil and Brazil has a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00277-00083234-00083486": "constitutional right to housing", "d07S9PLLxN0-00278-00083487-00083804": "despite that in anticipation of the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00279-00083805-00084101": "World Cup coming to Brazil they were", "d07S9PLLxN0-00280-00084102-00084344": "basically evicting forcibly evicting", "d07S9PLLxN0-00281-00084345-00084581": "people from their homes leased homes are", "d07S9PLLxN0-00282-00084582-00084875": "primarily called slums or favelas and so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00283-00084876-00085166": "this is John Paolo who shared with me", "d07S9PLLxN0-00284-00085167-00085382": "share with our team that he had been", "d07S9PLLxN0-00285-00085383-00085697": "forcibly evicted by gunpoint", "d07S9PLLxN0-00286-00085698-00085973": "with no notice to vacate his home and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00287-00085974-00086255": "he's standing in this photo in front of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00288-00086256-00086462": "a variety of images of the actual", "d07S9PLLxN0-00289-00086463-00086696": "eviction and you can see just above his", "d07S9PLLxN0-00290-00086697-00086831": "left shoulder there", "d07S9PLLxN0-00291-00086832-00087128": "that there's police officers holding a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00292-00087129-00087380": "man on his knees at gunpoint so this was", "d07S9PLLxN0-00293-00087381-00087935": "a very forcible eviction contrary to the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00294-00087936-00088097": "constitutional right so these images", "d07S9PLLxN0-00295-00088098-00088428": "were used and us and Jean Paul's story", "d07S9PLLxN0-00296-00088429-00088850": "was used to kind of advocate for wait", "d07S9PLLxN0-00297-00088851-00089105": "this isn't right he's homeless he's", "d07S9PLLxN0-00298-00089106-00089411": "standing there with just some clothes", "d07S9PLLxN0-00299-00089412-00089624": "that was the extent to which he was able", "d07S9PLLxN0-00300-00089625-00089888": "to grab him and his family's belongings", "d07S9PLLxN0-00301-00089889-00090185": "and get out of the way before you know", "d07S9PLLxN0-00302-00090186-00090356": "he and his family were harmed now", "d07S9PLLxN0-00303-00090357-00090662": "ironically Jean Paolo had come to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00304-00090663-00090956": "Fortaleza City on the northern coast of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00305-00090957-00091174": "Brazil had come too far Alissa because", "d07S9PLLxN0-00306-00091175-00091448": "for construction job so it's those", "d07S9PLLxN0-00307-00091449-00091679": "construction jobs are coming up because", "d07S9PLLxN0-00308-00091680-00091937": "of the tourism industry because the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00309-00091938-00092097": "World Cup was coming so it's kind of a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00310-00092098-00092351": "vicious circle um so anyway", "d07S9PLLxN0-00311-00092352-00092571": "that's another example of you know you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00312-00092572-00092843": "bring to life an issue you bring to life", "d07S9PLLxN0-00313-00092844-00093050": "and injustice through photography but", "d07S9PLLxN0-00314-00093051-00093274": "also personalizing a legal issue", "d07S9PLLxN0-00315-00093275-00093680": "personalising and injustice okay so so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00316-00093681-00093915": "this slide is to remind me now to switch", "d07S9PLLxN0-00317-00093916-00094148": "over so as I mentioned I am an attorney", "d07S9PLLxN0-00318-00094149-00094412": "I am licensed in the state of Washington", "d07S9PLLxN0-00319-00094413-00094604": "I do maintain that license just in case", "d07S9PLLxN0-00320-00094605-00094847": "right just increases the global pandemic", "d07S9PLLxN0-00321-00094848-00094985": "and I can't travel or something so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00322-00094986-00095354": "anyway so as an attorney I'm required to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00323-00095355-00095744": "maintain my license by taking continuing", "d07S9PLLxN0-00324-00095745-00096078": "legal education courses or cles so in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00325-00096079-00096215": "August of 2014", "d07S9PLLxN0-00326-00096216-00096660": "I took a CLE by the ACLU and in 2014 you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00327-00096661-00096968": "know the ACLU was quite not very I mean", "d07S9PLLxN0-00328-00096969-00097335": "not a lot going on but I took a one-hour", "d07S9PLLxN0-00329-00097336-00097610": "CLE and it was on debtors prisons and I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00330-00097611-00097748": "thought debtors prisons", "d07S9PLLxN0-00331-00097749-00097925": "there's no debtors prisons in this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00332-00097926-00098072": "country there's debtors prisons in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00333-00098073-00098297": "Africa there's debtors prisons in Latin", "d07S9PLLxN0-00334-00098298-00098474": "American countries but not where I have", "d07S9PLLxN0-00335-00098475-00098780": "worked but I was wrong and so on that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00336-00098781-00099251": "day I basically to be perfectly", "d07S9PLLxN0-00337-00099252-00099431": "melodramatic my life changed", "d07S9PLLxN0-00338-00099432-00099830": "okay so debtors prisons this one our CLE", "d07S9PLLxN0-00339-00099831-00100169": "was all about what are called legal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00340-00100170-00100209": "funding", "d07S9PLLxN0-00341-00100210-00100437": "obligations and that's what my project", "d07S9PLLxN0-00342-00100438-00100655": "is about so I'm gonna give you really", "d07S9PLLxN0-00343-00100656-00100838": "basic information about it so you know", "d07S9PLLxN0-00344-00100839-00101057": "what we're talking about okay okay it's", "d07S9PLLxN0-00345-00101058-00101294": "just going to take a second so legal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00346-00101295-00101513": "financial obligations are the costs", "d07S9PLLxN0-00347-00101514-00101793": "fines fees and victim restitution which", "d07S9PLLxN0-00348-00101794-00101997": "I will explain but a variety of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00349-00101998-00102348": "different types of debt that are imposed", "d07S9PLLxN0-00350-00102349-00102602": "on a criminal defendant at the time of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00351-00102603-00102830": "criminal sentencing so for example you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00352-00102831-00103034": "might get a five year prison sentence", "d07S9PLLxN0-00353-00103035-00103385": "you also might get $5,000 in quote legal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00354-00103386-00103661": "financial obligations or LFOs okay", "d07S9PLLxN0-00355-00103663-00103821": "those are imposed at the time of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00356-00103822-00104006": "sentencing nobody really pays attention", "d07S9PLLxN0-00357-00104007-00104322": "to them but some of them are mandatory", "d07S9PLLxN0-00358-00104323-00104613": "the average amount in Washington State", "d07S9PLLxN0-00359-00104614-00105221": "people receive is about $2,500 in LFOs", "d07S9PLLxN0-00360-00105222-00105602": "but significantly those LFOs accrue a 12", "d07S9PLLxN0-00361-00105603-00105831": "percent interest up until 2018 which", "d07S9PLLxN0-00362-00105832-00106143": "we'll talk about 12% interest like who", "d07S9PLLxN0-00363-00106144-00106316": "gets that right the state of Washington", "d07S9PLLxN0-00364-00106317-00106524": "has been getting that for decades twelve", "d07S9PLLxN0-00365-00106525-00106766": "percent annual interest significantly", "d07S9PLLxN0-00366-00106767-00107076": "this interest would start accruing from", "d07S9PLLxN0-00367-00107077-00107325": "the date that you're convicted so those", "d07S9PLLxN0-00368-00107326-00107504": "five years that you might be sitting in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00369-00107505-00107724": "prison you're also about five thousand", "d07S9PLLxN0-00370-00107725-00107997": "dollars you've also been assessed is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00371-00107998-00108152": "also occurring interest while you're", "d07S9PLLxN0-00372-00108153-00108290": "sitting in prison and can't do much", "d07S9PLLxN0-00373-00108291-00108629": "about it okay and so yep it cruise while", "d07S9PLLxN0-00374-00108630-00108807": "we're in prison so I want to give you a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00375-00108808-00108983": "couple examples I hope you can see this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00376-00108984-00109289": "a couple examples they take a DNA", "d07S9PLLxN0-00377-00109290-00109464": "collect what's that shouldn't happen", "d07S9PLLxN0-00378-00109465-00109800": "they take a DNA collection fee of $100", "d07S9PLLxN0-00379-00109801-00110054": "there's a mandatory victimís penalty", "d07S9PLLxN0-00380-00110055-00110322": "assessment and that is for $500 and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00381-00110323-00110658": "that's regardless regardless it's $500", "d07S9PLLxN0-00382-00110658-00111021": "per felony then there's also in some", "d07S9PLLxN0-00383-00111022-00111278": "counties you are assessed $100 per day", "d07S9PLLxN0-00384-00111279-00111531": "for every day that they have sentenced", "d07S9PLLxN0-00385-00111532-00111752": "you to prison so you know every day of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00386-00111753-00111831": "incarceration", "d07S9PLLxN0-00387-00111832-00112068": "there's also user fees and sometimes", "d07S9PLLxN0-00388-00112069-00112334": "many of these are mandatory and these", "d07S9PLLxN0-00389-00112335-00112565": "are user fees like court costs public", "d07S9PLLxN0-00390-00112566-00112853": "defender use of a criminal lab to run", "d07S9PLLxN0-00391-00112854-00113118": "some you know", "d07S9PLLxN0-00392-00113119-00113439": "chemical tests you might be charged if", "d07S9PLLxN0-00393-00113440-00113711": "you have a six-person jury you might be", "d07S9PLLxN0-00394-00113713-00113895": "charged if you have a 12-person jury you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00395-00113896-00114189": "might be charged by witness or for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00396-00114190-00114434": "witness fee do see Department of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00397-00114435-00114771": "Correction supervision etc etc okay and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00398-00114772-00114957": "then also there's crime specific fees", "d07S9PLLxN0-00399-00114958-00115296": "and what the acronym there is the Buxa", "d07S9PLLxN0-00400-00115297-00115557": "the vu csa it's the violation of the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00401-00115558-00115886": "Uniform Controlled Substances Act so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00402-00115888-00116022": "when you get a drug offense you're", "d07S9PLLxN0-00403-00116023-00116367": "likely to get a additional fee related", "d07S9PLLxN0-00404-00116368-00116526": "to whatever that is so like there's a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00405-00116527-00116727": "whole there's a very expensive meth", "d07S9PLLxN0-00406-00116728-00116955": "cleanup fee stuff like that and then", "d07S9PLLxN0-00407-00116956-00117171": "there's victim restitution Biggs and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00408-00117172-00117386": "restitution isn't always applied the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00409-00117388-00117693": "victim restitution is intended to make", "d07S9PLLxN0-00410-00117694-00117942": "the victim whole if that's possible so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00411-00117943-00118184": "for example let's say you have stolen", "d07S9PLLxN0-00412-00118185-00118419": "some of these car and you completely", "d07S9PLLxN0-00413-00118420-00118743": "destroy it in the police pursuit and you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00414-00118744-00119013": "run into a dump truck you know and that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00415-00119014-00119355": "car is damaged they will assess the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00416-00119356-00119631": "value of that car to you and you will oh", "d07S9PLLxN0-00417-00119632-00119988": "then you know $25,000 if that's how much", "d07S9PLLxN0-00418-00119989-00120174": "the car was worth okay so those are just", "d07S9PLLxN0-00419-00120175-00120321": "some examples there's over like a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00420-00120322-00120552": "hundred and fifty of them so don't get", "d07S9PLLxN0-00421-00120553-00120717": "bogged down in the details just know", "d07S9PLLxN0-00422-00120718-00120986": "these lfos come in a variety of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00423-00120988-00121283": "different types and different reasons", "d07S9PLLxN0-00424-00121284-00121440": "etc okay", "d07S9PLLxN0-00425-00121441-00121815": "so then for LFOs once you get okay so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00426-00121816-00121974": "while you're in prison and you know that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00427-00121975-00122322": "interest is occurring da-da-da-da-da if", "d07S9PLLxN0-00428-00122323-00122523": "you're making like 25 cents an hour", "d07S9PLLxN0-00429-00122524-00122745": "doing something the Department of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00430-00122746-00122933": "Corrections is going to deduct a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00431-00122934-00123236": "percentage from those prison wages they", "d07S9PLLxN0-00432-00123238-00123608": "also will deduct eighty seventy-eight", "d07S9PLLxN0-00433-00123609-00123864": "percent of any amount that your family", "d07S9PLLxN0-00434-00123865-00124044": "member gives you if you're on the inside", "d07S9PLLxN0-00435-00124045-00124269": "and they want to give you a hundred", "d07S9PLLxN0-00436-00124270-00124467": "dollars for your account so you can go", "d07S9PLLxN0-00437-00124468-00124886": "to the commissary or you can go to get", "d07S9PLLxN0-00438-00124888-00125108": "some something inside they will deduct", "d07S9PLLxN0-00439-00125109-00125367": "that as well okay so that's why you're", "d07S9PLLxN0-00440-00125368-00125577": "in prison now once you get out you have", "d07S9PLLxN0-00441-00125578-00125775": "thirty days to make the first monthly", "d07S9PLLxN0-00442-00125776-00125952": "payments okay", "d07S9PLLxN0-00443-00125953-00126294": "the monthly payments can vary hugely but", "d07S9PLLxN0-00444-00126295-00126453": "hopefully it's not more than", "d07S9PLLxN0-00445-00126454-00126633": "five dollars because usually went up", "d07S9PLLxN0-00446-00126633-00126858": "when you as you know you likely know", "d07S9PLLxN0-00447-00126858-00127017": "when you get out of prison it's hard to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00448-00127018-00127184": "find a job it's hard to find housing", "d07S9PLLxN0-00449-00127185-00127446": "it's hard to get an ID I mean it's just", "d07S9PLLxN0-00450-00127447-00127572": "like goes on and on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00451-00127573-00128055": "okay so importantly these lfos are legal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00452-00128056-00128241": "financial obligations they cannot be", "d07S9PLLxN0-00453-00128242-00128478": "discharged in bankruptcy like credit", "d07S9PLLxN0-00454-00128479-00128718": "card debt right but you cannot defer", "d07S9PLLxN0-00455-00128719-00128970": "them while you're in college so a lot of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00456-00128971-00129150": "people after going to prison will go to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00457-00129151-00129525": "college and they get no relief then then", "d07S9PLLxN0-00458-00129526-00129696": "if you also have a job and you haven't", "d07S9PLLxN0-00459-00129697-00129972": "been paying you also can get your wages", "d07S9PLLxN0-00460-00129973-00130151": "garnished and that's super common", "d07S9PLLxN0-00461-00130152-00130392": "they've you know people who's they've", "d07S9PLLxN0-00462-00130393-00130746": "taken as much as $500 per paycheck from", "d07S9PLLxN0-00463-00130747-00130905": "them if they're making that much money", "d07S9PLLxN0-00464-00130906-00131256": "and lastly and importantly if you if and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00465-00131257-00131445": "when you miss monthly payments which is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00466-00131446-00131733": "quite common for this population with so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00467-00131734-00132102": "many barriers to successful reentry you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00468-00132103-00132393": "can get arrested for failure to make", "d07S9PLLxN0-00469-00132394-00132564": "those payments and that's because you're", "d07S9PLLxN0-00470-00132565-00132848": "either held in contempt of court for not", "d07S9PLLxN0-00471-00132849-00133077": "complying with the court order for you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00472-00133078-00133371": "to pay or you are found in violation of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00473-00133372-00133539": "your sentence either way they can issue", "d07S9PLLxN0-00474-00133540-00133857": "an arrest warrant and arrest you for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00475-00133858-00134199": "failure to pay your LFOs okay so this is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00476-00134200-00134454": "my reaction right I'm like wait a second", "d07S9PLLxN0-00477-00134455-00134688": "what you've got to be kidding me", "d07S9PLLxN0-00478-00134689-00135210": "I was like this was an hour and I'm like", "d07S9PLLxN0-00479-00135211-00135426": "what is wrong with this world", "d07S9PLLxN0-00480-00135427-00135771": "so in my mind I've seen a lot of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00481-00135772-00136005": "injustice in other parts of the world I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00482-00136006-00136248": "had no idea that this was happening here", "d07S9PLLxN0-00483-00136249-00136470": "most people don't and that's one of the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00484-00136471-00136734": "main reasons for the project is to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00485-00136735-00136977": "educate the public and policymakers", "d07S9PLLxN0-00486-00136978-00137256": "about the fact that these even exist and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00487-00137257-00137537": "then the impacts of that legal debt on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00488-00137538-00137823": "communities who are trying to rebuild", "d07S9PLLxN0-00489-00137824-00138006": "their lives or individuals who are on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00490-00138007-00138132": "them rebuild their lives", "d07S9PLLxN0-00491-00138133-00138510": "so this LFO policy which nobody knows", "d07S9PLLxN0-00492-00138511-00138693": "about is both inequitable and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00493-00138694-00139026": "unconscionable and I use that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00494-00139027-00139243": "that is a really strong word and you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00495-00139244-00139377": "don't really use that very often but", "d07S9PLLxN0-00496-00139378-00139533": "that's in fact what this is I mean I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00497-00139534-00139785": "just like my whole body reacted to it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00498-00139786-00140025": "because it's just ridiculous and that's", "d07S9PLLxN0-00499-00140026-00140308": "in part because 80 to 90% of criminal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00500-00140309-00140518": "defendants are indigent and what that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00501-00140519-00140829": "means is their income is less than a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00502-00140830-00141093": "hundred and twenty five percent of the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00503-00141094-00141735": "federal poverty level so these are low", "d07S9PLLxN0-00504-00141736-00141975": "low income people that are primarily", "d07S9PLLxN0-00505-00141976-00142278": "criminal defendants so as someone said", "d07S9PLLxN0-00506-00142279-00142497": "the state of Washington in trying to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00507-00142498-00142784": "collect on these LFOs they are spending", "d07S9PLLxN0-00508-00142785-00143295": "dimes in order to collect pennies so not", "d07S9PLLxN0-00509-00143296-00143499": "just from my perspective but never", "d07S9PLLxN0-00510-00143500-00143724": "anybody who hears about this it's this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00511-00143725-00143937": "is a serious punishment for the poor", "d07S9PLLxN0-00512-00143938-00144213": "because what happens is if you are rich", "d07S9PLLxN0-00513-00144214-00144420": "and you're convicted you typically have", "d07S9PLLxN0-00514-00144421-00144573": "a private attorney instead of a public", "d07S9PLLxN0-00515-00144574-00144844": "defense attorney and but a public", "d07S9PLLxN0-00516-00144845-00145059": "defender and your private attorney will", "d07S9PLLxN0-00517-00145060-00145282": "say pay those off before you go to jail", "d07S9PLLxN0-00518-00145283-00145464": "before you go to prison and I've known", "d07S9PLLxN0-00519-00145465-00145650": "people and I've interviewed people who", "d07S9PLLxN0-00520-00145651-00145894": "have criminal records and yet have no", "d07S9PLLxN0-00521-00145895-00146070": "LFOs and that's because they hired a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00522-00146071-00146259": "private attorney and we're able to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00523-00146260-00146557": "afford to pay that off before they went", "d07S9PLLxN0-00524-00146558-00146847": "into prison and before they that 12%", "d07S9PLLxN0-00525-00146848-00147195": "started accrue so because of that this", "d07S9PLLxN0-00526-00147196-00147465": "policy that has both inequitable and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00527-00147466-00147633": "unconscionable disproportionately", "d07S9PLLxN0-00528-00147634-00147983": "impacts the poor and people of color", "d07S9PLLxN0-00529-00147984-00148182": "those are the people who can't afford", "d07S9PLLxN0-00530-00148183-00148444": "pay those are the people who are not", "d07S9PLLxN0-00531-00148445-00148578": "going to be able to get out from their", "d07S9PLLxN0-00532-00148579-00148807": "criminal convictions because of it those", "d07S9PLLxN0-00533-00148808-00148993": "are the people who are going to be under", "d07S9PLLxN0-00534-00148994-00149281": "constant financial supervision from the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00535-00149282-00149763": "criminal justice system and with a 12%", "d07S9PLLxN0-00536-00149764-00149932": "interest rate they will not be able to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00537-00149933-00150270": "pay it off right so studies also show", "d07S9PLLxN0-00538-00150271-00150423": "for Washington state the highest", "d07S9PLLxN0-00539-00150424-00150672": "proportion of LFOs are imposed on Latino", "d07S9PLLxN0-00540-00150673-00151069": "males I have I have my own guesses as to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00541-00151070-00151287": "why that's the case we do know that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00542-00151288-00151554": "rural counties tend to be county courts", "d07S9PLLxN0-00543-00151555-00151809": "tend to be more aggressive in imposing", "d07S9PLLxN0-00544-00151810-00152154": "these LFOs and of that you know a great", "d07S9PLLxN0-00545-00152155-00152380": "deal of vast majority of the team", "d07S9PLLxN0-00546-00152381-00152713": "live in rural areas", "d07S9PLLxN0-00547-00152714-00152917": "dude that being in the agricultural", "d07S9PLLxN0-00548-00152918-00153340": "sector so anyway so that yeah that's", "d07S9PLLxN0-00549-00153341-00153697": "LFOs so here I am I'm like oh my gosh", "d07S9PLLxN0-00550-00153698-00153904": "I've been doing all this work on the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00551-00153905-00154138": "other side of the world and here I feel", "d07S9PLLxN0-00552-00154139-00154363": "somewhat complicit in this I you know I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00553-00154364-00154660": "don't practice law in the United States", "d07S9PLLxN0-00554-00154661-00154831": "or in Washington State but as a member", "d07S9PLLxN0-00555-00154832-00155017": "of the State Bar I felt like I needed to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00556-00155018-00155137": "do something about it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00557-00155138-00155470": "for some reason it just slipped a switch", "d07S9PLLxN0-00558-00155471-00155827": "in me and so you know my skill set you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00559-00155828-00156087": "know I'm a lawyer but I also I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00560-00156088-00156313": "photograph and interview people and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00561-00156314-00156580": "generate stories about people's lives", "d07S9PLLxN0-00562-00156581-00156966": "and also the in justices that are", "d07S9PLLxN0-00563-00156967-00157225": "impacting individuals because the law is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00564-00157226-00157501": "supposed to be there to serve us it's", "d07S9PLLxN0-00565-00157502-00157666": "not supposed to be there to hold us down", "d07S9PLLxN0-00566-00157667-00157909": "and hold us back but in this case it is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00567-00157910-00158311": "and I say us on purpose so what I did is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00568-00158312-00158719": "it took me three years two years to gain", "d07S9PLLxN0-00569-00158720-00158905": "access to this community and because", "d07S9PLLxN0-00570-00158906-00159241": "there's a lot of trust that's needed in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00571-00159242-00159445": "order to have very open conversations", "d07S9PLLxN0-00572-00159446-00159673": "with people for people who may feel a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00573-00159674-00159970": "great deal of shame about their criminal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00574-00159971-00160498": "history and so this led to my project", "d07S9PLLxN0-00575-00160499-00160636": "living with conviction sentenced to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00576-00160637-00160834": "death for life in Washington State and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00577-00160835-00161220": "what I do is I seek volunteers", "d07S9PLLxN0-00578-00161221-00161461": "volunteers who are willing to sit down", "d07S9PLLxN0-00579-00161462-00161737": "with me and we do a pretty long", "d07S9PLLxN0-00580-00161738-00162028": "interview and then multiple photoshoots", "d07S9PLLxN0-00581-00162029-00162217": "depending on the person and depending on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00582-00162218-00162487": "a variety of things and so if you want", "d07S9PLLxN0-00583-00162488-00162640": "to take a look at the living with", "d07S9PLLxN0-00584-00162641-00162958": "conviction website under stories each", "d07S9PLLxN0-00585-00162959-00163213": "person you can click on and like this is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00586-00163214-00163432": "Sabrina Kushina and Michael you can", "d07S9PLLxN0-00587-00163433-00163660": "click on those and it'll bring up their", "d07S9PLLxN0-00588-00163661-00163855": "story it'll bring that personal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00589-00163856-00164107": "narrative some of them have audio some", "d07S9PLLxN0-00590-00164108-00164401": "of them don't but this way my goal is to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00591-00164402-00164610": "have a hundred people on the website and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00592-00164611-00164926": "my goal is to really show the volume of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00593-00164927-00165364": "the problem but also the various factors", "d07S9PLLxN0-00594-00165365-00165580": "that went into the person entering the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00595-00165581-00165762": "criminal justice system and that way", "d07S9PLLxN0-00596-00165763-00166050": "they can't get out so that's the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00597-00166051-00166340": "websites I love for you to take a look", "d07S9PLLxN0-00598-00166341-00166599": "at it but what was happening is I wanted", "d07S9PLLxN0-00599-00166600-00166764": "to create a short film because I've done", "d07S9PLLxN0-00600-00166765-00167007": "some filmmaking while I was you know in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00601-00167008-00167370": "my other work but at this point they're", "d07S9PLLxN0-00602-00167371-00167744": "about to launch the next legislative", "d07S9PLLxN0-00603-00167745-00167988": "legislative session in Washington State", "d07S9PLLxN0-00604-00167989-00168276": "and they're going to advocate for legal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00605-00168277-00168621": "reform of their LFOs of our LFO laws", "d07S9PLLxN0-00606-00168622-00168825": "again so all of a sudden I had to stop", "d07S9PLLxN0-00607-00168826-00169032": "wanting to create a film and slip over", "d07S9PLLxN0-00608-00169033-00169311": "and basically get the website going and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00609-00169312-00169494": "so I want to give you an example this is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00610-00169495-00169845": "Michael Michael when I met him was a 60", "d07S9PLLxN0-00611-00169846-00170169": "something-year-old Vietnam veteran who", "d07S9PLLxN0-00612-00170170-00170598": "is living on his he was living on his VA", "d07S9PLLxN0-00613-00170599-00170799": "pension of one thousand and seventy", "d07S9PLLxN0-00614-00170800-00170844": "dollars", "d07S9PLLxN0-00615-00170845-00171101": "he has three criminal convictions and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00616-00171102-00171479": "because of that he makes a total of $75", "d07S9PLLxN0-00617-00171480-00171819": "payments to the county courts so that he", "d07S9PLLxN0-00618-00171820-00172034": "won't get arrested", "d07S9PLLxN0-00619-00172035-00172395": "here's $1,070 VA pension is his only", "d07S9PLLxN0-00620-00172396-00172722": "source of income and every month he'll", "d07S9PLLxN0-00621-00172723-00172952": "go and get money orders in order to make", "d07S9PLLxN0-00622-00172953-00173126": "those payments", "d07S9PLLxN0-00623-00173127-00173453": "he says when I took my guilty plea I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00624-00173454-00173583": "didn't think that I was going to be", "d07S9PLLxN0-00625-00173584-00173804": "doing a life sentence the interest on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00626-00173805-00173997": "these fines makes it where a person on a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00627-00173998-00174264": "limited income will never be able to get", "d07S9PLLxN0-00628-00174265-00174582": "out from the wreckage of the past and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00629-00174583-00174803": "Michael is Native American as indicated", "d07S9PLLxN0-00630-00174804-00175284": "by his his tattoo and you know so anyway", "d07S9PLLxN0-00631-00175285-00175529": "I'll move on about Michael and this is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00632-00175530-00175776": "Brianna Brianna is also in the short", "d07S9PLLxN0-00633-00175777-00175935": "multi media piece that I've prepared for", "d07S9PLLxN0-00634-00175936-00176286": "you Rhian shares that these LFOs stop", "d07S9PLLxN0-00635-00176287-00176472": "people from succeeding your whole", "d07S9PLLxN0-00636-00176473-00176637": "objective is to keep people the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00637-00176638-00176852": "community safe but you're trying to keep", "d07S9PLLxN0-00638-00176853-00177039": "the community safe from people that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00639-00177040-00177369": "you're forcing to be failures and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00640-00177370-00177669": "brianna is a father of two teenage girls", "d07S9PLLxN0-00641-00177670-00177890": "and at the time that I met him he was", "d07S9PLLxN0-00642-00177891-00178286": "commuting three hours to go to college", "d07S9PLLxN0-00643-00178287-00178726": "and and they", "d07S9PLLxN0-00644-00178727-00179101": "luckily working two jobs a father etc", "d07S9PLLxN0-00645-00179102-00179308": "etc and he was barely able to make his", "d07S9PLLxN0-00646-00179309-00179805": "elephants so because this legislative", "d07S9PLLxN0-00647-00179806-00180106": "this legislative session was opening up", "d07S9PLLxN0-00648-00180107-00180340": "there was I was part of a coalition that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00649-00180341-00180757": "was advocating for LFO reform so we", "d07S9PLLxN0-00650-00180758-00180997": "generated a magazine of all these", "d07S9PLLxN0-00651-00180998-00181471": "stories and photographs we created", "d07S9PLLxN0-00652-00181472-00181776": "postcards and a whole lot of different", "d07S9PLLxN0-00653-00181777-00181990": "nonprofit organizations throughout the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00654-00181991-00182260": "state were purchasing these postcards to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00655-00182261-00182539": "share with their state legislators to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00656-00182540-00182965": "advocate for the LFO reform and in the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00657-00182966-00183196": "fourth year I was involved in year three", "d07S9PLLxN0-00658-00183197-00183433": "and four in the fourth year there in", "d07S9PLLxN0-00659-00183434-00183847": "fact was LFO reform and that LFO reform", "d07S9PLLxN0-00660-00183848-00184246": "in occurred in June 2018 and what it did", "d07S9PLLxN0-00661-00184247-00184411": "it didn't go far enough but it did do", "d07S9PLLxN0-00662-00184412-00184759": "something it basically removes the 12%", "d07S9PLLxN0-00663-00184760-00185161": "interest for new convictions as of June", "d07S9PLLxN0-00664-00185162-00185632": "7th 2018 but only the ones not related", "d07S9PLLxN0-00665-00185633-00185818": "to restitution remember we talked about", "d07S9PLLxN0-00666-00185819-00186133": "this victim restitution and that's where", "d07S9PLLxN0-00667-00186134-00186349": "there's a victim who needs to be Miam", "d07S9PLLxN0-00668-00186350-00186604": "burst made whole again so these are all", "d07S9PLLxN0-00669-00186605-00186799": "those other there's no no interest right", "d07S9PLLxN0-00670-00186800-00187147": "now on 12% no 12% interest on this these", "d07S9PLLxN0-00671-00187148-00187339": "other all these other categories which", "d07S9PLLxN0-00672-00187340-00187579": "is significant it's absolutely", "d07S9PLLxN0-00673-00187580-00187846": "significant for nearly convicted", "d07S9PLLxN0-00674-00187847-00188080": "individuals as of June 7th it also", "d07S9PLLxN0-00675-00188081-00188344": "significantly stopped accrual of 12%", "d07S9PLLxN0-00676-00188345-00188683": "interest on existing Alec lfos again", "d07S9PLLxN0-00677-00188684-00188959": "excluding non restitution interest or", "d07S9PLLxN0-00678-00188960-00189184": "not restitution so that's really", "d07S9PLLxN0-00679-00189185-00189502": "exciting but it wasn't I mean it stopped", "d07S9PLLxN0-00680-00189503-00189961": "being cruel but that interest is still", "d07S9PLLxN0-00681-00189962-00190216": "sitting there right so it's just not", "d07S9PLLxN0-00682-00190217-00190435": "growing anymore except for restitution", "d07S9PLLxN0-00683-00190436-00190765": "it also removed a mandatory $100.00 DNA", "d07S9PLLxN0-00684-00190766-00190972": "fee if your DNA is already in the system", "d07S9PLLxN0-00685-00190973-00191242": "because you've reoffended that's kind of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00686-00191243-00191425": "minor but you know hundred bucks is on", "d07S9PLLxN0-00687-00191426-00191668": "the box and then it also granted a right", "d07S9PLLxN0-00688-00191669-00191974": "to a waiver of non restitution interest", "d07S9PLLxN0-00689-00191975-00192157": "for people with Elif", "d07S9PLLxN0-00690-00192158-00192387": "but only if you request it from the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00691-00192388-00192670": "court if you file a motion which pretty", "d07S9PLLxN0-00692-00192671-00192796": "much means nobody's going to do it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00693-00192797-00192954": "almost okay let's just be clear about", "d07S9PLLxN0-00694-00192955-00193374": "that so it did it did make some progress", "d07S9PLLxN0-00695-00193375-00193689": "but not go far enough so what it didn't", "d07S9PLLxN0-00696-00193690-00193923": "do this is the it's a really long name", "d07S9PLLxN0-00697-00193924-00194241": "is what does the HU HSB that's the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00698-00194242-00194808": "engrossed second house Senate bill 1783", "d07S9PLLxN0-00699-00194809-00195201": "it's not automatic waiver or reduction", "d07S9PLLxN0-00700-00195202-00195481": "of LFOs it has to be upon emotion and it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00701-00195482-00195747": "really illustrates the if you guys have", "d07S9PLLxN0-00702-00195748-00195975": "talked about rule of law issues or think", "d07S9PLLxN0-00703-00195976-00196185": "about rule of law issues really here's a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00704-00196186-00196353": "great law in the books but it's not", "d07S9PLLxN0-00705-00196354-00196584": "being implemented hey because nobody", "d07S9PLLxN0-00706-00196585-00196773": "knows about it be because nobody has any", "d07S9PLLxN0-00707-00196774-00197008": "money to do it and see because they", "d07S9PLLxN0-00708-00197009-00197136": "don't know about it it's not going to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00709-00197137-00197385": "happen right so living with conviction", "d07S9PLLxN0-00710-00197386-00197581": "also has a whole legal empowerment", "d07S9PLLxN0-00711-00197582-00197881": "initiative now related to that but I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00712-00197882-00198024": "wanted to share this this was an", "d07S9PLLxN0-00713-00198025-00198387": "unsolicited email from a person that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00714-00198388-00198687": "I've never met in person and it", "d07S9PLLxN0-00715-00198688-00198825": "basically is from a Washington state", "d07S9PLLxN0-00716-00198826-00199077": "public defender who also was a lobbyist", "d07S9PLLxN0-00717-00199078-00199318": "and he said congratulations on the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00718-00199319-00199507": "effect success of living with conviction", "d07S9PLLxN0-00719-00199508-00199677": "it's clear that your project was", "d07S9PLLxN0-00720-00199678-00199884": "instrumental in the Washington State", "d07S9PLLxN0-00721-00199885-00200097": "Legislature finally making real change", "d07S9PLLxN0-00722-00200098-00200415": "so legal financial obligations I can't", "d07S9PLLxN0-00723-00200416-00200670": "thank you enough for telling you stories", "d07S9PLLxN0-00724-00200671-00200956": "so that was a really unexpected very", "d07S9PLLxN0-00725-00200957-00201210": "kind and very generous statement and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00726-00201211-00201390": "it's really about the people who are", "d07S9PLLxN0-00727-00201391-00201706": "brave enough to share their stories so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00728-00201707-00202077": "to some extent in some way these stories", "d07S9PLLxN0-00729-00202078-00202353": "have made an impact and we're continuing", "d07S9PLLxN0-00730-00202354-00202696": "I'm continuing to collect and share", "d07S9PLLxN0-00731-00202697-00203025": "living with conviction stories but I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00732-00203026-00203281": "also want to move into there is somewhat", "d07S9PLLxN0-00733-00203282-00203565": "like a theory of change around using", "d07S9PLLxN0-00734-00203566-00203869": "storytelling whether that's visual", "d07S9PLLxN0-00735-00203870-00204135": "storytelling literature pick a variety", "d07S9PLLxN0-00736-00204136-00204396": "of different artistic works if you have", "d07S9PLLxN0-00737-00204397-00204678": "a compelling story you can use that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00738-00204679-00204973": "story to raise awareness right you start", "d07S9PLLxN0-00739-00204973-00205171": "at the top you can then raise awareness", "d07S9PLLxN0-00740-00205171-00205453": "and when you start raising awareness you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00741-00205454-00205783": "among my community my family my friends", "d07S9PLLxN0-00742-00205784-00205933": "they're like you're kidding what can I", "d07S9PLLxN0-00743-00205934-00206163": "do to help right that engagement then", "d07S9PLLxN0-00744-00206164-00206404": "generates a stronger movement and then", "d07S9PLLxN0-00745-00206405-00206571": "which eventually can lead to social", "d07S9PLLxN0-00746-00206573-00206809": "change so this is I did not make this up", "d07S9PLLxN0-00747-00206810-00206994": "this is from the fledgling fund which is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00748-00206996-00207180": "a foundation that supports", "d07S9PLLxN0-00749-00207181-00207540": "mission-driven visual storytelling and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00750-00207541-00207798": "it's from there that's called assessing", "d07S9PLLxN0-00751-00207800-00208051": "creative media's social impact so I just", "d07S9PLLxN0-00752-00208052-00208210": "kind of wanted to give you kind of some", "d07S9PLLxN0-00753-00208211-00208561": "theoretical underpinning around that so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00754-00208562-00208815": "I'm going to stop there because we're", "d07S9PLLxN0-00755-00208816-00209013": "going to get together on June 2nd at", "d07S9PLLxN0-00756-00209014-00209394": "11:00 a.m. and it basically this is a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00757-00209396-00209607": "quote from Martin Luther King jr. and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00758-00209608-00210007": "it's he says an individual has not", "d07S9PLLxN0-00759-00210008-00210334": "started living until he or she can rise", "d07S9PLLxN0-00760-00210335-00210585": "above the narrow confines of his", "d07S9PLLxN0-00761-00210586-00210865": "individualistic concerns so the broader", "d07S9PLLxN0-00762-00210866-00211189": "concerns of all humanity and I want to", "d07S9PLLxN0-00763-00211190-00211452": "stop there because I want to encourage", "d07S9PLLxN0-00764-00211453-00211921": "everybody who sees this everybody who is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00765-00211921-00212188": "even slightly interested in criminal", "d07S9PLLxN0-00766-00212189-00212496": "justice in who's watching this is that", "d07S9PLLxN0-00767-00212498-00212791": "there is a lot of there's a lot of", "d07S9PLLxN0-00768-00212792-00212989": "issues out there that needs our", "d07S9PLLxN0-00769-00212990-00213217": "attention and I say our because we are", "d07S9PLLxN0-00770-00213217-00213511": "the community our community our humanity", "d07S9PLLxN0-00771-00213512-00213846": "so I'm going to invite you to think", "d07S9PLLxN0-00772-00213848-00214242": "about what issues really annoy you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00773-00214244-00214501": "really upset you and go do something", "d07S9PLLxN0-00774-00214502-00214692": "about it and whether your skill set you", "d07S9PLLxN0-00775-00214694-00214902": "are an artist whether you're an engineer", "d07S9PLLxN0-00776-00214903-00215394": "whether you are a poet go do something", "d07S9PLLxN0-00777-00215396-00215946": "because you know we need you to okay so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00778-00215948-00216334": "that's why living with conviction the", "d07S9PLLxN0-00779-00216335-00216514": "name of the project yes it is about", "d07S9PLLxN0-00780-00216515-00216784": "living with criminal conviction a", "d07S9PLLxN0-00781-00216785-00217094": "criminal record but it's also about", "d07S9PLLxN0-00782-00217096-00217426": "living in a way that honors your beliefs", "d07S9PLLxN0-00783-00217427-00217729": "living with conviction that can what is", "d07S9PLLxN0-00784-00217730-00217990": "it the courage of your convictions so", "d07S9PLLxN0-00785-00217991-00218185": "thank you for that I do hope you'll", "d07S9PLLxN0-00786-00218186-00218389": "watch the five minute multimedia piece", "d07S9PLLxN0-00787-00218390-00218766": "created around LFO and the project and", "d07S9PLLxN0-00788-00218767-00218973": "I look forward to seeing you along with", "d07S9PLLxN0-00789-00218973-00219333": "a panel of storytellers on Tuesday June", "d07S9PLLxN0-00790-00219334-00219414": "2nd", "d07S9PLLxN0-00791-00219415-00219717": "thank you so much take care bye bye I'm", "d07S9PLLxN0-00792-00219717-00220050": "going to unshare now that's you thank", "d07S9PLLxN0-00793-00220051-00220287": "you bye bye", "d07S9PLLxN0-00794-00220288-00220494": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "d0ehexBJ3gA", "text": {"d0ehexBJ3gA-00000-00000963-00001723": "[Music]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00001-00001723-00003625": "[Music]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00002-00003626-00003809": "thank you", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00003-00003810-00004522": "has no idea", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00004-00004523-00004584": "foreign", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00005-00004585-00006340": "[Music]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00006-00006341-00006554": "[Applause]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00007-00006555-00007651": "[Music]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00008-00007652-00008014": "[Music]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00009-00008015-00011153": "foreign", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00010-00011154-00012364": "utapata", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00011-00012365-00014044": "um", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00012-00014044-00015784": "[Music]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00013-00015785-00017071": "[Applause]", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00014-00017072-00017250": "Star TV", "d0ehexBJ3gA-00015-00017251-00017563": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "d0J3KPDfzGg", "text": {"d0J3KPDfzGg-00000-00000032-00000415": "oh hey moonbug kids", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00001-00000416-00000759": "i see you started implementing 3d into", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00002-00000760-00000975": "your new mortal episode", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00003-00000976-00001127": "oh that's cool", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00004-00001128-00001415": "yeah it's just ruined the whole thing", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00005-00001416-00001726": "animation it just makes it all", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00006-00001727-00002750": "bad", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00007-00002751-00003446": "i don't know why", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00008-00003447-00003983": "[Music]", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00009-00003984-00004783": "you know what i mean", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00010-00004784-00005086": "and those are just means", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00011-00005087-00005222": "anyway", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00012-00005223-00005463": "i think that you should return to the", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00013-00005464-00005751": "two-dimensional", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00014-00005752-00007095": "[Music]", "d0J3KPDfzGg-00015-00007095-00007492": "it was [__]"}}, {"audio_id": "d0cUhPWkdsU", "text": {"d0cUhPWkdsU-00000-00000888-00002318": "all right all right all right", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00001-00002319-00002883": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00002-00002884-00003270": "so", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00003-00003271-00005670": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00004-00005671-00005907": "breaking", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00005-00005908-00006910": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00006-00006911-00009827": "imma let you go", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00007-00009828-00010371": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00008-00010372-00012239": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00009-00012240-00012527": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00010-00012528-00013331": "time to get back up", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00011-00013332-00013966": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00012-00013968-00014447": "but it doesn't mean i lost", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00013-00014447-00016124": "when my heart was on the ground", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00014-00016125-00016883": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00015-00016884-00017183": "us", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00016-00017184-00019980": "i'm tired of the pace", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00017-00019981-00022089": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00018-00022090-00022634": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00019-00022635-00026683": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00020-00026683-00028938": "oh i'm tired of the pace", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00021-00028939-00031145": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00022-00031145-00032283": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00023-00032283-00032662": "is so i could feel something", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00024-00032663-00034517": "else yeah i guess", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00025-00034518-00034807": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00026-00034808-00036483": "the king without his crown", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00027-00036484-00037135": "oh", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00028-00037136-00038593": "go away", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00029-00038594-00039283": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00030-00039284-00040708": "um", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00031-00040709-00042151": "[Music]", "d0cUhPWkdsU-00032-00042152-00042359": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "d1SFvQ3qI3g", "text": {"d1SFvQ3qI3g-00000-00000057-00000327": "around the world in 80 days sometimes", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00001-00000328-00000570": "spelled as around the world in 80 days", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00002-00000571-00000942": "is a 1956 American epic adventure comedy", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00003-00000943-00001218": "film starring Cantinflas and David Niven", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00004-00001219-00001479": "produced by the michael todd company and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00005-00001480-00001850": "released by United Artists the epic", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00006-00001851-00002099": "picture was directed by Michael Anderson", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00007-00002100-00002322": "and produced by Mike Todd with Kevin", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00008-00002323-00002558": "McClory and William Cameron Menzies as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00009-00002559-00002891": "associate producers the screenplay was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00010-00002892-00003210": "written by James Polk John Farrow and SJ", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00011-00003211-00003431": "Perelman based on the classic novel of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00012-00003432-00003765": "the same name by jules van the music", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00013-00003765-00004011": "score was composed by Victor young and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00014-00004011-00004193": "the todd-ao seventy millimeters", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00015-00004194-00004452": "cinematography shot in Technicolor was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00016-00004453-00004802": "by lionel linden the film's six-minute", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00017-00004803-00005072": "long animated title sequence shown at", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00018-00005073-00005288": "the end of the film was created by", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00019-00005289-00005513": "award-winning designer saul bass", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00020-00005514-00005723": "the film won five Academy Awards", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00021-00005724-00006409": "including Best Picture", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00022-00006411-00006947": "topic plot", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00023-00006948-00007212": "broadcast journalist Edward r murrow", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00024-00007213-00007479": "presents an onscreen prologue featuring", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00025-00007480-00007815": "footage from a trip to the moon 1902 by", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00026-00007816-00008040": "George mollies explaining that it is", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00027-00008041-00008232": "based loosely on the book from the earth", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00028-00008233-00008610": "to the moon by jules van also included", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00029-00008611-00008775": "as the launching of an unmanned rocket", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00030-00008776-00009137": "and footage of the earth receding in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00031-00009138-00009492": "1872 an English gentleman fillies fog", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00032-00009493-00009768": "David Niven claims he can circumnavigate", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00033-00009769-00010158": "the world in 80 days he makes a 20,000", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00034-00010159-00010434": "pounds wager worth about 1.8 million", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00035-00010435-00010746": "pounds in 2015 with four sceptical", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00036-00010747-00010956": "fellow members of the Reform club each", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00037-00010957-00011202": "contributing five thousand pounds to the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00038-00011203-00011451": "bet that he can arrive back 80 days from", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00039-00011452-00011877": "exactly 8:45 p.m. that evening together", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00040-00011878-00012074": "with his resourceful valet", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00041-00012075-00012338": "Passepartout Cantinflas folk goes", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00042-00012339-00012555": "hopscotching around the globe generously", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00043-00012556-00012752": "spending money to encourage others to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00044-00012753-00013019": "help him get to his destinations faster", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00045-00013020-00013221": "so he can accommodate tight steamship", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00046-00013222-00013494": "schedules they set out on the journey", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00047-00013494-00013785": "from Paris by a gas balloon named loco", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00048-00013786-00013977": "cat upon learning the mountain train", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00049-00013978-00014297": "tunnel is blocked the to accidentally", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00050-00014298-00014532": "end up in Spain where passport out", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00051-00014533-00014897": "engages in a comic bullfight next he", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00052-00014898-00015210": "goes to Brenda Z meanwhile suspicion", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00053-00015211-00015438": "grows that Fulk has stolen fifty five", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00054-00015438-00015693": "thousand pounds around four point eight", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00055-00015694-00015918": "million pounds today from the Bank of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00056-00015919-00016194": "England's a police inspector fix Robert", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00057-00016194-00016452": "Newton is sent out by Scotland Yard to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00058-00016453-00016719": "trail him starting in sewers and keeps", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00059-00016720-00016944": "waiting for a warrant to arrive so he", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00060-00016945-00017136": "can arrest Fogg in the British ports", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00061-00017137-00017427": "they visit in India Fogg and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00062-00017428-00017697": "Passepartout rescue young widow princess", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00063-00017698-00017969": "aouda Shirley MacLaine from being forced", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00064-00017970-00018156": "into a funeral pyre with her late", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00065-00018157-00018465": "husband the three visit Hong Kong", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00066-00018466-00018853": "Yokohama San Francisco and the Wild West", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00067-00018854-00019143": "after sailing across the Atlantic and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00068-00019144-00019344": "only hours short of winning his wager", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00069-00019345-00019566": "Fogg is arrested upon arrival at", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00070-00019567-00019812": "Liverpool by the diligent yet misguided", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00071-00019813-00020025": "inspector fix", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00072-00020026-00020330": "at the jail the humiliated fix informs", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00073-00020331-00020555": "Fogg that the real culprit was caught in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00074-00020556-00020903": "Brighton although he is now exculpated", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00075-00020904-00021168": "he has insufficient time to reach London", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00076-00021169-00021386": "before his deadline and thus has lost", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00077-00021387-00021588": "everything but the love of the winsome", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00078-00021589-00021947": "outer salvation is at hand when upon", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00079-00021948-00022200": "returning to London Passepartout buys a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00080-00022201-00022486": "newspaper and sees it as still Saturday", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00081-00022487-00022791": "Fogg then realises that by travelling", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00082-00022792-00022994": "east towards the Rising Sun and by", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00083-00022995-00023241": "crossing the International Dateline he", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00084-00023242-00023535": "has gained a day there is still time to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00085-00023536-00023786": "reach the Reform club and win the bet", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00086-00023787-00024093": "Fogg arrives at the club just before the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00087-00024094-00024509": "8:45 p.m. chime outter and Passepartout", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00088-00024510-00024780": "then arrived surprising everyone as no", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00089-00024781-00024963": "woman has ever entered the Reform club", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00090-00024964-00025195": "before", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00091-00025196-00025564": "you", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00092-00025565-00026112": "topic cast", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00093-00026113-00026401": "the film boasts an all-star cast with", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00094-00026402-00026643": "David Niven and Cantinflas in the lead", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00095-00026644-00026989": "roles of Fogg and Passepartout Fogg is", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00096-00026989-00027164": "the classic Victorian gentleman", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00097-00027165-00027486": "well-dressed well-spoken and extremely", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00098-00027487-00027673": "punctual whereas his servant", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00099-00027674-00027883": "Passepartout who has an eye for the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00100-00027883-00028123": "ladies provides much of the comic relief", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00101-00028124-00028495": "as a jack-of-all-trades for the film in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00102-00028495-00028776": "contrast to his masters strict formality", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00103-00028777-00029014": "joining him as Shirley MacLaine as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00104-00029014-00029239": "Princess outter and Robert Newton as the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00105-00029239-00029629": "detective fix in his last role the role", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00106-00029630-00029842": "of Passepartout was greatly expanded", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00107-00029843-00030082": "from the novel to accommodate Cantinflas", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00108-00030083-00030390": "the most famous Latin American comedian", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00109-00030391-00030627": "at the time and winds up as the focus of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00110-00030628-00030942": "the film while Passepartout describes", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00111-00030943-00031189": "himself as a Parisian in the novel this", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00112-00031189-00031423": "is unclear in the film he has a french", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00113-00031424-00031680": "name but speaks Spanish when he and his", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00114-00031681-00032023": "master arrive in Spain by balloon in the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00115-00032024-00032199": "Spanish version the name of his", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00116-00032200-00032395": "character was changed from the French", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00117-00032395-00032680": "Passepartout to the Spanish when picker", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00118-00032681-00033015": "port there is also a comic bullfighting", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00119-00033016-00033229": "sequence especially created for", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00120-00033230-00033495": "Cantinflas that is not in the novel", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00121-00033496-00033777": "indeed when the film was released in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00122-00033778-00033962": "some non-english speaking nations", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00123-00033963-00034257": "Cantinflas was billed as the lead", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00124-00034258-00034527": "according to the guidebook this was done", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00125-00034528-00034752": "because of an obstacle Todd faced in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00126-00034753-00034999": "casting Cantinflas who had never before", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00127-00035000-00035226": "appeared in an American movie and had", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00128-00035227-00035462": "turned down countless offers to do so", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00129-00035463-00035704": "Todd allowed Cantinflas", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00130-00035705-00036061": "to appear in the film as a Latin so the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00131-00036062-00036356": "actor said himself", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00132-00036357-00036671": "to my audience in latinamerica I'll", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00133-00036672-00037169": "still be Cantinflas more than 40 famous", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00134-00037170-00037363": "performers make cameo appearances", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00135-00037364-00037676": "including Marlene Dietrich Ronald Colman", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00136-00037677-00038045": "George Raft and Frank Sinatra the film", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00137-00038046-00038255": "was significant as the first of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00138-00038256-00038609": "so-called Hollyweird make-work films", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00139-00038610-00038869": "employing dozens of film personalities", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00140-00038870-00039182": "John Wayne turned down Todd's offer for", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00141-00039183-00039344": "the role of the colonel leading the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00142-00039345-00039608": "cavalry charged a role filled by Colonel", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00143-00039609-00039950": "Tim McCoy promotional material released", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00144-00039951-00040195": "at the time quoted a Screen Actors Guild", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00145-00040196-00040412": "representative looking at the shooting", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00146-00040413-00040688": "call sheet and crying good heavens", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00147-00040689-00040940": "Todd you've made extras out of all the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00148-00040941-00041405": "stars in Hollywood as of 2019 Shirley", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00149-00041406-00041606": "MacLaine and Glynis John's are the last", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00150-00041607-00042360": "surviving members of the entire cast", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00151-00042361-00042924": "topic main cast", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00152-00042925-00043383": "David Niven as Fillies fog Cantinflas as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00153-00043384-00043713": "passport out shirley maclaine as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00154-00043714-00044028": "princess outer Robert Newton as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00155-00044029-00044526": "inspector fix", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00156-00044527-00045498": "topic cameo appearances", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00157-00045499-00046072": "topic production", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00158-00046073-00046360": "around the world in 80 days was produced", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00159-00046361-00046624": "by Michael Todd a Broadway show man who", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00160-00046625-00046924": "had never before produced a film the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00161-00046925-00047212": "director he hired Michael Anderson had", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00162-00047213-00047407": "directed the highly acclaimed British", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00163-00047408-00047712": "World War two feature the dam Busters", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00164-00047713-00048241": "1955 George Orwell's 1984 feature 1956", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00165-00048242-00048604": "and other classic films Todd sold his", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00166-00048605-00048829": "interest in the todd-ao format to help", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00167-00048830-00049096": "finance the film because todd-ao ran at", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00168-00049097-00049321": "30 frames per second which was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00169-00049322-00049573": "incompatible with the 35 millimetres", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00170-00049574-00049888": "standard of 24 fps around the world in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00171-00049889-00050149": "80 days was filmed twice like the first", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00172-00050150-00050410": "feature in todd-ao Oklahoma unlike", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00173-00050411-00050653": "Oklahoma however which was filmed", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00174-00050654-00050911": "additionally in 35 millimetres cinema", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00175-00050912-00051160": "scope around the world in 80 days was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00176-00051161-00051451": "filmed simultaneously in Todd now at 24", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00177-00051452-00051642": "frames per second so that from this", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00178-00051644-00051940": "negative 35 millimetres reduction Prince", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00179-00051941-00052179": "could be produced for general release", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00180-00052179-00052522": "after these two films the specification", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00181-00052523-00052723": "for Todd Al was altered after the third", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00182-00052724-00053062": "film in the format South Pacific - 24", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00183-00053063-00053329": "FPS running making it unnecessary to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00184-00053329-00053724": "film subsequent productions twice in his", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00185-00053725-00054070": "1972 autobiographical book the moons a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00186-00054071-00054328": "balloon actor David Niven discussed his", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00187-00054329-00054520": "meeting with Todd and the subsequent", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00188-00054521-00054694": "events that led to the film being", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00189-00054695-00055033": "produced according to Livan when Todd", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00190-00055034-00055222": "asked him if he would appear as Fogg", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00191-00055223-00055522": "Niven enthusiastically replied I'd do it", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00192-00055523-00055755": "for nothing he later admitted to being", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00193-00055757-00055972": "grateful that Todd did not hold him to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00194-00055973-00056290": "his claim he also described the first", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00195-00056291-00056503": "meeting between Todd and Robert Newton", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00196-00056504-00056776": "who suffered from drinking problems when", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00197-00056777-00056944": "the latter was offered the role of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00198-00056945-00057216": "detective fix Niven alleged that Newton", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00199-00057217-00057394": "was offered the part on condition that", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00200-00057395-00057634": "he did not drink any alcohol during the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00201-00057635-00057802": "filming and that his celebration", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00202-00057803-00058036": "following the completion of his role led", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00203-00058037-00058276": "to his untimely demise he did not live", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00204-00058277-00058621": "to see the film released filming took", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00205-00058622-00058990": "place in late 1955 from August 9th to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00206-00058991-00059422": "December 20th the crew worked fast 75", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00207-00059423-00059494": "actual", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00208-00059495-00059749": "days of filming producing six hundred", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00209-00059750-00059971": "and eighty thousand feet two hundred and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00210-00059972-00060226": "ten thousand meters of film which was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00211-00060227-00060448": "edited down to twenty five thousand", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00212-00060449-00060709": "seven hundred and thirty four feet seven", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00213-00060710-00060907": "thousand eight hundred and forty four", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00214-00060908-00061242": "meters of finished film the picture cost", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00215-00061244-00061471": "just under six million dollars to make", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00216-00061472-00061663": "employing one hundred and twelve", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00217-00061664-00061921": "locations in 13 countries and one", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00218-00061922-00062266": "hundred and forty sets Todd said he and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00219-00062266-00062505": "the crew visited every country portrayed", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00220-00062507-00062749": "in the picture including England France", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00221-00062750-00063154": "India East Pakistan now Bangladesh Spain", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00222-00063154-00063523": "Thailand and Japan according to Time", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00223-00063524-00063766": "magazine's review of the film the cast", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00224-00063766-00064036": "including extras totalled sixty-eight", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00225-00064037-00064246": "thousand eight hundred and ninety four", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00226-00064247-00064504": "people it also featured seven thousand", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00227-00064504-00064730": "nine hundred and fifty nine animals", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00228-00064732-00065091": "including four ostriches six skunks", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00229-00065092-00065391": "fifteen elephants seventeen fighting", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00230-00065392-00065812": "Bulls 512 rhesus monkeys eight hundred", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00231-00065813-00066145": "horses nine hundred and fifty burros two", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00232-00066146-00066352": "thousand four hundred and forty eight", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00233-00066353-00066634": "American Buffalo three thousand eight", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00234-00066635-00066868": "hundred rocky mountain sheep and a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00235-00066869-00067194": "sacred cow that eats flowers on cue", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00236-00067195-00067483": "there is also a cat at the Reform club", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00237-00067484-00067780": "the wardrobe department spent four", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00238-00067781-00067981": "hundred and ten thousand dollars to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00239-00067982-00068188": "provide seventy four thousand six", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00240-00068189-00068485": "hundred and eighty five costumes and 36", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00241-00068486-00068821": "thousand and ninety two trinkets it has", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00242-00068822-00069007": "been alleged that this is the greatest", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00243-00069008-00069241": "number of costumes ever required for any", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00244-00069242-00069607": "Hollywood production ever made some ten", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00245-00069608-00069844": "thousand extras were used in filming the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00246-00069845-00070033": "bull fight scene in Spain with", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00247-00070034-00070333": "Cantinflas as the matador Cantinflas had", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00248-00070334-00070642": "previously done some bullfighting they", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00249-00070643-00070855": "used all six thousand five hundred", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00250-00070856-00071125": "residents of a small Spanish town called", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00251-00071126-00071461": "Chinchin forty five kilometres 28 miles", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00252-00071462-00071701": "from Madrid but todd decided there", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00253-00071702-00072093": "weren't enough spectators so he found", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00254-00072094-00072370": "3,500 more from nearby towns", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00255-00072371-00072646": "he used six hundred and fifty Indians", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00256-00072647-00072902": "for a fight on a train in the where", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00257-00072903-00073181": "many were indeed Indians but some were", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00258-00073182-00073589": "Hollywood extras all 650 had the skin", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00259-00073590-00073919": "color altered with dye Todd used about", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00260-00073920-00074435": "50 US gallons 190 L 42 M gal of orange", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00261-00074436-00074771": "colored dye for those extras Todd", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00262-00074772-00075086": "sometimes used models of boats ships and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00263-00075087-00075350": "trains in the film but he often decided", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00264-00075351-00075542": "that they didn't look realistic so he", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00265-00075543-00075713": "switched to the real thing where he", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00266-00075714-00076010": "could the scene of a collapsing train", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00267-00076011-00076286": "bridge is partly without models the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00268-00076287-00076502": "overhead shot of a train crossing a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00269-00076503-00076715": "bridge was full-scale but the bridge", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00270-00076716-00076927": "collapse was a large scale miniature", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00271-00076928-00077156": "verifiable by observing the slightly", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00272-00077157-00077402": "jerky motion of the rear passenger car", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00273-00077403-00077627": "as the train pulls away as well as the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00274-00077628-00077855": "slowed down water droplets which are out", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00275-00077856-00078058": "of scale in the splashing River below", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00276-00078059-00078353": "all the steamships shown in the first", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00277-00078354-00078545": "half are miniatures shot in an outdoor", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00278-00078546-00078869": "studio tank the exception is the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00279-00078870-00079079": "American ship shown at the intermission", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00280-00079080-00079424": "point which is real a tunnel was built", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00281-00079425-00079723": "for a train sequence out of paper mache", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00282-00079724-00080027": "after the train filming was complete the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00283-00080028-00080407": "tunnel was pushed over into the gorge", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00284-00080408-00080639": "the scenes of the crossing of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00285-00080640-00080900": "Atlantic Ocean by steamship took place", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00286-00080901-00081134": "off San Francisco and was shot on a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00287-00081135-00081398": "specially built prop steamer a converted", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00288-00081399-00081596": "barge mocked up to resemble a small", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00289-00081597-00081848": "ocean-going steamship with mock paddles", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00290-00081849-00082079": "driven by the electric motor from an old", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00291-00082080-00082448": "streetcar in his memoirs Niven described", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00292-00082449-00082643": "the whole thing as being dangerously", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00293-00082644-00082715": "unstable", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00294-00082716-00082907": "those stability improved as it was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00295-00082908-00083120": "dismantled as though to feed it into its", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00296-00083121-00083492": "own furnaces as the plot required one of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00297-00083493-00083720": "the most famous sequences in the film", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00298-00083721-00084002": "the flight by hydrogen balloon is not in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00299-00084003-00084302": "the original Jules Verne novel because", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00300-00084303-00084515": "the film was made in todd-ao the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00301-00084516-00084752": "sequence was expressly created to show", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00302-00084753-00084982": "off the locations seen on the flight as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00303-00084983-00085196": "projected on the giant curved screen", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00304-00085197-00085523": "used for the process a similar balloon", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00305-00085524-00085751": "flight can be found in an earlier Jules", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00306-00085752-00086015": "Verne novel five weeks in a balloon in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00307-00086016-00086257": "which the protagonists explore Africa", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00308-00086258-00086285": "for", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00309-00086286-00086501": "a hydrogen balloon many of the balloon", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00310-00086502-00086741": "scenes with livin and Cantinflas were", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00311-00086742-00086954": "filmed using a one hundred and sixty", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00312-00086955-00087299": "foot forty nine meters crane even that", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00313-00087300-00087515": "height bothered Niven who was afraid of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00314-00087516-00087602": "heights", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00315-00087603-00087890": "Tom burgers who was shorter than Niven", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00316-00087891-00088130": "was used as a stand-in for scenes where", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00317-00088131-00088348": "the balloon is seen from a distance", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00318-00088349-00088631": "many of the Lots used in the film are", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00319-00088632-00088862": "now on the land occupied by Century City", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00320-00088863-00089303": "an office complex in the LA area in his", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00321-00089304-00089519": "memoirs Niven related that Todd", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00322-00089520-00089738": "completed filming while in considerable", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00323-00089739-00090062": "debts the post-production work on the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00324-00090063-00090278": "film was an exercise in holding off", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00325-00090279-00090479": "Todd's creditors long enough to produce", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00326-00090480-00090716": "a saleable film and the footage was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00327-00090717-00090896": "worked upon under the supervision of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00328-00090897-00091085": "Todd's creditors and returned to a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00329-00091086-00091337": "secure vault each night as if it were in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00330-00091338-00091709": "escrow the film's release and subsequent", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00331-00091710-00091961": "success vindicated Todd's considerable", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00332-00091962-00092518": "efforts", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00333-00092519-00093072": "topic release", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00334-00093073-00093540": "the film premiered on October 17 1956 at", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00335-00093541-00093783": "the Rivoli theatre in New York City and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00336-00093784-00094143": "played two full houses for 15 months it", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00337-00094144-00094455": "ran for 102 weeks at the theater with", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00338-00094456-00094710": "one thousand five hundred and sixty four", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00339-00094711-00094965": "performances two million one hundred and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00340-00094966-00095178": "seventy three thousand two hundred and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00341-00095179-00095418": "thirty-eight patrons and a gross of four", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00342-00095419-00095601": "million eight hundred and seventy two", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00343-00095602-00095835": "thousand three hundred and twenty six", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00344-00095836-00096072": "dollars by the time of Todd's death in a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00345-00096073-00096348": "private plane crash 18 months after the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00346-00096349-00096627": "film had opened it had grossed 33", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00347-00096628-00096840": "million dollars in Spanish and Latin", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00348-00096841-00097086": "American posters and programs of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00349-00097087-00097326": "movie Cantinflas is billed above the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00350-00097327-00097482": "other players because he was very", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00351-00097483-00097739": "popular in spanish-speaking countries", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00352-00097740-00098085": "there were two souvenir programs sold in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00353-00098086-00098406": "theaters for Roadshow screenings todd-ao", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00354-00098407-00098625": "is mentioned though for general release", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00355-00098626-00098835": "those pages are not contained in the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00356-00098836-00099165": "book the program was created by Todd's", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00357-00099166-00099447": "publicist art Kohn who died in the plane", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00358-00099448-00099789": "crash with him his biography the nine", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00359-00099790-00100011": "lives of Michael Todd was published", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00360-00100012-00100230": "after their deaths which put a macabre", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00361-00100231-00100872": "spin on the title", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00362-00100873-00101788": "topic reception", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00363-00101789-00102401": "topic critical response", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00364-00102402-00102638": "Bosley Crowther called the film a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00365-00102639-00102923": "sprawling conglomeration of refined", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00366-00102924-00103216": "English comedy giant screen travel", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00367-00103217-00103475": "panoramic sand slam-bang Keystone", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00368-00103476-00103834": "burlesque and said Todd and the film's", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00369-00103835-00104134": "crew commandeered the giant screen and", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00370-00104135-00104339": "stereophonic sound as though they were", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00371-00104340-00104597": "Olson and Johnson turned loose in a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00372-00104598-00104888": "cosmic cutting room with a pipe organ in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00373-00104889-00105131": "one corner and all the movies ever made", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00374-00105132-00105544": "to toss around Time magazine called it", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00375-00105545-00105944": "brassy extravagant long-winded and funny", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00376-00105945-00106429": "and the Polyphemus of productions saying", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00377-00106430-00106745": "as a travelogue around the world is at", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00378-00106746-00106973": "least as spectacular as anything", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00379-00106974-00107351": "Cinerama has slapped together time", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00380-00107352-00107579": "highlighted the performance of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00381-00107580-00107933": "famous mexican comic Cantinflas who in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00382-00107933-00108282": "his first u.s. movie", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00383-00108283-00108528": "gives delightful evidence that he may", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00384-00108529-00108846": "well be as Charles Chaplin once said he", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00385-00108847-00109224": "was the world's greatest clown the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00386-00109225-00109467": "review aggregator website Rotten", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00387-00109468-00109797": "Tomatoes retrospectively collected 38", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00388-00109798-00110033": "reviews and gave the film an aggregate", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00389-00110034-00110408": "score of 71% with a rating average of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00390-00110409-00110771": "6/10 with the site's consensus stating", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00391-00110772-00111072": "it's undeniably shallow but it's", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00392-00111073-00111318": "cheerful lack of pretense as well as its", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00393-00111319-00111594": "grand scale and star stuff cast help", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00394-00111595-00111753": "make around the world in 80 days", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00395-00111754-00112040": "charmingly light-hearted entertainment", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00396-00112041-00112314": "the development of the film and the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00397-00112315-00112521": "personal life of actor Mario Moreno", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00398-00112522-00112773": "during that time were dramatized later", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00399-00112774-00113583": "in the 2014 film Cantinflas", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00400-00113584-00114136": "topic accolades", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00401-00114138-00114448": "you", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00402-00114449-00115028": "Topic Academy Awards", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00403-00115029-00115271": "the film was nominated for eight Oscars", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00404-00115272-00115561": "of which it was awarded five beating out", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00405-00115563-00115786": "critically and publicly praised films", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00406-00115788-00116059": "friendly persuasion the Ten Commandments", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00407-00116060-00116447": "giant and the King and I won Best", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00408-00116448-00116876": "Picture Michael Todd producer won Best", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00409-00116877-00117056": "Cinematography color", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00410-00117057-00117490": "Lionel Lyndon won best film editing Jean", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00411-00117491-00117875": "Ruggiero and Paul Weatherwax won best", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00412-00117876-00118157": "music scoring of a dramatic or comedy", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00413-00118158-00118526": "picture Victor Young won best writing", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00414-00118527-00118895": "best screenplay adapted John Farrow SJ", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00415-00118896-00119321": "Perelman and James Poe nominee best art", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00416-00119322-00119639": "direction set decoration color Ken Adam", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00417-00119640-00120083": "Ross Dowd and James W Sullivan nominee", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00418-00120083-00120490": "best costume design color miles white", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00419-00120491-00120797": "nominee Best Director Michael Anderson", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00420-00120798-00121003": "although not nominated for Best Original", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00421-00121004-00121100": "Song", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00422-00121101-00121359": "the film's theme song around the world", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00423-00121360-00121711": "music by Victor young words by Harold", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00424-00121713-00122075": "Adamson became very popular it was a hit", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00425-00122076-00122410": "for Bing Crosby in 1957 and was a staple", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00426-00122411-00122627": "of the easy listening genre for many", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00427-00122628-00122921": "years around the world I searched for", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00428-00122922-00123197": "you I traveled on when hope was gone to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00429-00123198-00123471": "keep a rendezvous", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00430-00123472-00123744": "no more will I go all around the world", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00431-00123745-00124146": "for I have found my world in you it is", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00432-00124147-00124383": "also one of the few Best Picture winners", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00433-00124383-00124593": "not to be nominated in any acting", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00434-00124594-00125138": "category", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00435-00125139-00125699": "topic Golden Globes", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00436-00125700-00125963": "the film was also nominated for three", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00437-00125964-00126295": "Golden Globes of which it was awarded to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00438-00126296-00126668": "one Best dramatic motion picture Michael", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00439-00126669-00127100": "Todd producer won Best Motion Actor in a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00440-00127101-00127538": "comedy musical film Cantinflas nominee", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00441-00127539-00128158": "Best Director Michael Anderson", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00442-00128158-00128691": "topic other Awards", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00443-00128692-00128936": "the film received the New York Film", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00444-00128938-00129147": "Critics Circle Award for Best Picture", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00445-00129148-00129396": "and Best Screenplay award for SJ", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00446-00129397-00129728": "Perelman the film won the Writers Guild", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00447-00129729-00130010": "of America best written American comedy", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00448-00130011-00130304": "award for James Poe John Farrow and SJ", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00449-00130305-00130649": "Perelman the film was screened at the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00450-00130650-00130971": "1957 can Film Festival but was not", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00451-00130972-00131672": "entered into the main competition", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00452-00131673-00132313": "topic anniversary celebration", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00453-00132314-00132568": "on the first anniversary of the film's", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00454-00132569-00132781": "release todd threw a party at the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00455-00132782-00133207": "Madison Square Garden attended by 18,000", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00456-00133208-00133503": "people Time magazine called the party a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00457-00133504-00133810": "spectacular flop though Todd shrugged", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00458-00133811-00134068": "off the remark saying you can't say it", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00459-00134069-00134711": "was a little bust", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00460-00134712-00135385": "topic distribution and ownership", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00461-00135386-00135658": "the film was originally distributed by", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00462-00135659-00135934": "United Artists in two todd-ao 70", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00463-00135935-00136227": "millimetres versions one for todd-ao 70", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00464-00136228-00136450": "millimetres release at 30 frames per", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00465-00136451-00136752": "second and an alternative 70 millimetres", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00466-00136753-00137047": "version at 24 frames per second reduced", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00467-00137048-00137363": "to 35 millimetres for general release", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00468-00137364-00137695": "the original todd-ao 70 millimetres", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00469-00137696-00137973": "running time without the extra music was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00470-00137974-00138438": "179 minutes however after the chicago", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00471-00138439-00138678": "showing todd cut four minutes out of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00472-00138679-00138915": "western sequence where Cantinflas is", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00473-00138916-00139282": "pursued by indians the 70 millimetres", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00474-00139283-00139566": "print shown at the Rivoli theatre in NYC", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00475-00139567-00140122": "was 175 minutes however the original 35", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00476-00140123-00140340": "millimetres Technicolor anamorphic", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00477-00140341-00140601": "magnetic stereo and mono optical prints", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00478-00140602-00140944": "ran the complete 179 minutes with the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00479-00140945-00141252": "chase scene intact although the leaders", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00480-00141253-00141481": "on the optical sound prints were labeled", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00481-00141482-00141793": "for perspective encoding the prints do", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00482-00141794-00142000": "not contain the signal and were standard", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00483-00142001-00142468": "mono in 1968 additional cuts were made", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00484-00142469-00142687": "including removing most of the prologue", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00485-00142688-00143025": "with the changing aspect ratios only a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00486-00143026-00143248": "brief few shots with Edward r murrow", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00487-00143249-00143544": "remained and the entire trip to the moon", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00488-00143545-00143884": "clips were cut since the opening shot of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00489-00143885-00144228": "Murrow was 1.33 window boxed in the wide", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00490-00144229-00144469": "frame they had to crop and blow up that", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00491-00144470-00144793": "shot for the 2.35 ratio which made it", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00492-00144794-00145104": "very grainy the intermission was also", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00493-00145105-00145387": "cut for the 1968 re-released which", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00494-00145388-00145585": "included the freeze-frame of the ship", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00495-00145586-00145906": "and fade into the second half the reels", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00496-00145907-00146047": "just", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00497-00146048-00146281": "jump cut with an awkward sound gap", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00498-00146282-00146605": "between the first and second half the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00499-00146606-00146782": "chase scene was missing from this", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00500-00146783-00146995": "version too which reduced the running", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00501-00146996-00147303": "time to 167 minutes", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00502-00147304-00147781": "however some uncut 179 minute 35", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00503-00147782-00147985": "millimeters Technicolor prints were", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00504-00147986-00148180": "struck too which meant at least some", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00505-00148181-00148330": "theaters played the roadshow version", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00506-00148331-00148597": "even though the vast majority showed the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00507-00148598-00148978": "shorter cut 35 millimeter zebb scope", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00508-00148979-00149466": "copies of both versions exist from 1968", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00509-00149467-00149872": "the 24 frames per second 70 millimetres", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00510-00149873-00150220": "prints were also the 167 minute version", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00511-00150221-00150601": "in that year too as a publicity stunt", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00512-00150602-00150799": "Todd jr. called the press when he", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00513-00150800-00151045": "removed a 70 millimetres copy from a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00514-00151046-00151240": "bank vault claiming it had been stored", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00515-00151241-00151576": "there since 1956 for safekeeping and was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00516-00151577-00151861": "being shown at a theater again it was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00517-00151862-00152134": "absurd since an original 70 millimetres", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00518-00152135-00152437": "would have faded to pink by 1968 and the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00519-00152438-00152745": "copy they exhibited was the cut reissue", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00520-00152746-00153325": "167 minute version around 1976 after its", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00521-00153326-00153610": "last Network television broadcast on CBS", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00522-00153611-00153931": "UA lost control of the film to Elizabeth", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00523-00153932-00154150": "Taylor who was the widow of producer", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00524-00154151-00154378": "Michael Todd and had inherited a portion", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00525-00154379-00154816": "of Todd's estate in 1983 Warner Brothers", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00526-00154817-00155008": "acquired the rights to the film from", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00527-00155009-00155179": "Taylor and reissued the film", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00528-00155180-00155536": "theatrically in a riad ative 143 minute", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00529-00155537-00155755": "version this version would subsequently", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00530-00155756-00156016": "air only once on Turner Classic Movies", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00531-00156017-00156250": "this was before any restoration on the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00532-00156251-00156529": "movie was announced in the years that", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00533-00156530-00156793": "followed a pan and scan transfer of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00534-00156794-00157138": "alternative 24 frame/s version presented", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00535-00157139-00157474": "at its full 183 minute length was shown", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00536-00157475-00157629": "on cable television", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00537-00157630-00158104": "in 2004 WB issued a digitally restored", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00538-00158105-00158440": "version of the 24 frame/s incarnation on", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00539-00158441-00158854": "DVD also at its full 183 minute length", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00540-00158855-00159037": "but also including the original", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00541-00159038-00159319": "intermission in track C and exit music", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00542-00159320-00159514": "segments that were a part of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00543-00159515-00159871": "original 1956 theatrical release and for", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00544-00159872-00160072": "the first time on home video at its", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00545-00160073-00160479": "original 2.2 one aspect widescreen ratio", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00546-00160480-00160813": "this restored version was reconstructed", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00547-00160814-00161014": "from the best available elements of the", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00548-00161015-00161392": "24 frame/s edition WB could find and was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00549-00161393-00161608": "subsequently shown on Turner Classic", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00550-00161609-00161950": "Movies the original elements from the 30", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00551-00161951-00162316": "frame/s 70 millimeters total version as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00552-00162317-00162538": "well as the original prints derived from", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00553-00162539-00162796": "these elements still exist albeit in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00554-00162797-00163018": "faded condition due to the passage of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00555-00163019-00163252": "time but remain to be formally restored", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00556-00163253-00163615": "by WB there is some missing footage in", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00557-00163616-00163816": "the India train ride where the image", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00558-00163817-00164020": "artificially fades in and out to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00559-00164021-00164355": "compensate for the missing shots", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00560-00164356-00164650": "Warner's retained Andy Pratt film labs", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00561-00164651-00164866": "who in conjunction with Eastman Kodak", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00562-00164867-00165112": "developed a method to remove the cracked", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00563-00165113-00165349": "and fading to brown clear lacquer from", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00564-00165350-00165640": "the original 65 millimetres Technicolor", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00565-00165641-00165952": "negative Warner's did nothing further to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00566-00165953-00166225": "restore the negative due to costs of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00567-00166226-00166471": "making a 70 millimetres released print", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00568-00166472-00166777": "even without magnetic striping using DTS", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00569-00166778-00167026": "discs for audio there are no immediate", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00570-00167027-00167380": "plans for any new prints the 65", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00571-00167381-00167629": "millimeters Roadshow print negative was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00572-00167630-00168022": "used for the DVD release had any 35", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00573-00168023-00168253": "millimetres anamorphic elements being", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00574-00168254-00168489": "used the aspect ratio would have been", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00575-00168490-00168970": "2.35 one Mike Todd had limited 35", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00576-00168971-00169213": "millimetres anamorphic prints made with", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00577-00169214-00169414": "a non-standard compression ratio to", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00578-00169415-00169794": "provide a 2.21 one viewing experience", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00579-00169795-00170179": "these special 35 millimetres prints are", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00580-00170180-00170392": "called sinner stage the same name of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00581-00170393-00170751": "Mike Todd's Showcase Theatre in Chicago", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00582-00170752-00171048": "best available prints of the 30 frame/s", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00583-00171049-00171329": "70 millimetres version have recently", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00584-00171330-00171564": "been exhibited in revival movie houses", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00585-00171565-00171960": "worldwide as of the present time WB", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00586-00171961-00172689": "remains the film's rights holder", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00587-00172690-00173448": "topic soundtrack and DVD releases", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00588-00173449-00173748": "the dvds for around the world in 80 days", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00589-00173749-00173976": "include four hours of supplemental", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00590-00173977-00174186": "material in addition to the restored", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00591-00174187-00174479": "three-hour widescreen presentation", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00592-00174480-00174705": "included on one of the discs is a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00593-00174706-00174975": "documentary film about 50 minutes long", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00594-00174976-00175365": "about Michael Todd the soundtrack was", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00595-00175366-00175599": "commercially released on vinyl and audio", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00596-00175600-00175947": "tape to CD versions were released as", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00597-00175948-00176199": "well including a digital remastering of", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00598-00176200-00176454": "the original Decca Records album on MCA", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00599-00176455-00176715": "in the 1980s and an expanded version", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00600-00176716-00176895": "with extra tracks on the hit parade", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00601-00176896-00177354": "Records label in Canada in 2007 there", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00602-00177355-00177585": "was also a model kit of the balloon a", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00603-00177586-00177804": "board game and a dull Comics adaptation", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00604-00177805-00178161": "a Cantinflas puppet was released", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00605-00178162-00178410": "separately dressed in an outfit similar", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00606-00178411-00179116": "to the passport out costume", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00607-00179117-00179716": "topic theme parks", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00608-00179717-00180061": "during the 1972 80s the Alton Towers", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00609-00180062-00180325": "theme park in England had a boat ride", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00610-00180326-00180979": "based on the film", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00611-00180980-00181559": "topic see also", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00612-00181560-00182032": "list of American films of 1956", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00613-00182033-00182289": "around the world in 80 days the novel by", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00614-00182290-00182690": "Jules Verne around the world in 80 days", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00615-00182691-00183114": "2004 film The Three Stooges go around", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00616-00183115-00183595": "the world in a daze the great race sati", "d1SFvQ3qI3g-00617-00183596-00183883": "practice"}}, {"audio_id": "d1Ze995Ci7U", "text": {"d1Ze995Ci7U-00000-00000046-00000369": "Niklas Luhmann German Lu man December 8", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00001-00000370-00000789": "19 27 to November 6th 1998 was a German", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00002-00000790-00001016": "sociologist philosopher of social", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00003-00001017-00001197": "science and a prominent thinker in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00004-00001198-00001398": "Systems Theory who is considered one of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00005-00001399-00001601": "the most important social theorists of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00006-00001602-00002003": "the 20th century", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00007-00002004-00002673": "topic biography lemon was born in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00008-00002674-00002868": "lüneburg Prussia where his father's", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00009-00002869-00003048": "family had been running a brewery for", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00010-00003049-00003336": "several generations after graduating", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00011-00003336-00003639": "from the johannem School in 1943 he was", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00012-00003640-00003846": "conscripted as a Luftwaffe Helfer in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00013-00003847-00004035": "World War two and served for two years", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00014-00004036-00004311": "until at the age of 17 he was taken", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00015-00004312-00004506": "prisoner of war by American troops in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00016-00004507-00004886": "1945 after the war lemon studied law at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00017-00004887-00005168": "the University of Freiburg from 1946 to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00018-00005169-00005445": "1949 when he obtained a law degree and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00019-00005446-00005667": "then began a career in luneberg's public", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00020-00005668-00005954": "administration during a sabbatical in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00021-00005955-00006243": "1961 he went to Harvard where he met and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00022-00006244-00006446": "studied under Talcott Parsons then the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00023-00006447-00006666": "world's most influential social systems", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00024-00006667-00006993": "theorist in later years Lemmon dismissed", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00025-00006994-00007199": "Parsons theory developing a rival", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00026-00007200-00007445": "approach of his own leaving the civil", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00027-00007447-00007713": "service in 1962 he lectured at the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00028-00007714-00007893": "National Deutsche hochschule fervour", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00029-00007894-00008115": "Waltons wissenschaften University for", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00030-00008116-00008301": "administrative Sciences in Speyer", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00031-00008302-00008630": "Germany until 1965 when he was offered a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00032-00008631-00008816": "position at the Sousa forcing stell", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00033-00008817-00008988": "Social Research Center of the University", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00034-00008989-00009427": "of Munster led by Helmut Schell ski", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00035-00009428-00009677": "1965-66 he studied one semester of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00036-00009678-00009944": "sociology at the University of Munster", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00037-00009945-00010221": "two earlier books were retroactively Lee", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00038-00010222-00010430": "accepted as a PhD thesis and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00039-00010431-00010613": "habilitation at the University of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00040-00010614-00010910": "Munster in 1966 qualifying him for a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00041-00010911-00011340": "university professor ship in 1968 1969", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00042-00011341-00011558": "he briefly served as a lecturer at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00043-00011559-00011748": "Theodore Adorno's former chair at the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00044-00011749-00011937": "University of Frankfurt and then was", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00045-00011938-00012180": "appointed full professor of sociology at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00046-00012181-00012338": "the newly founded University of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00047-00012339-00012702": "Bielefeld Germany until 1993 he", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00048-00012703-00012846": "continued to publish after his", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00049-00012847-00013026": "retirement when he finally found the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00050-00013027-00013233": "time to complete his magnum opus died", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00051-00013234-00013433": "gesellschaft der gazelle shaft literally", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00052-00013434-00013743": "the society of society which was", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00053-00013744-00014007": "published in 1997 and translated", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00054-00014008-00014219": "subsequently in English under the title", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00055-00014220-00014597": "theory of society vol 1 in 2012 in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00056-00014598-00015169": "volume 2 in 2013", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00057-00015169-00015551": "works", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00058-00015552-00015801": "Lemmon wrote prolifically with more than", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00059-00015802-00016047": "70 books and nearly 400 scholarly", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00060-00016047-00016227": "articles published on a variety of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00061-00016228-00016512": "subjects including law economy politics", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00062-00016513-00016830": "art religion ecology mass media and love", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00063-00016831-00017061": "while his theories have yet to make a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00064-00017062-00017313": "major mark in American sociology his", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00065-00017314-00017490": "theory is currently well known and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00066-00017491-00017736": "popular in German sociology and has also", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00067-00017737-00017934": "been rather intensively received in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00068-00017935-00018147": "Japan in Eastern Europe including Russia", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00069-00018148-00018459": "his relatively low profile elsewhere is", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00070-00018460-00018672": "partly due to the fact that translating", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00071-00018673-00018879": "his work is a difficult task since his", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00072-00018880-00019062": "writing presents a challenge even to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00073-00019063-00019238": "readers of German including many", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00074-00019239-00019727": "sociologists P XXVII social systems 1995", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00075-00019728-00020007": "much of Lemmons work directly deals with", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00076-00020008-00020202": "the operations of the legal system and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00077-00020203-00020367": "his autopoietic theory of law is", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00078-00020368-00020565": "regarded as one of the more influential", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00079-00020566-00020787": "contributions to the sociology of law", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00080-00020788-00021024": "and socio legal studies Lemmon is", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00081-00021025-00021228": "probably best known to North Americans", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00082-00021229-00021372": "for his debate with the critical", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00083-00021373-00021546": "theorist Jurgen Habermas over the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00084-00021547-00021834": "potential of social systems theory like", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00085-00021835-00021984": "his one-time mentor Talcott Parsons", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00086-00021985-00022278": "lemon is an advocate of grand theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00087-00022279-00022472": "although neither in the sense of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00088-00022473-00022707": "philosophical foundationalism nor in the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00089-00022708-00023019": "Senta meta-narrative is often invoked in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00090-00023020-00023199": "the critical works of post modernist", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00091-00023200-00023469": "writers rather lemons work tracks closer", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00092-00023470-00023703": "to complexity theory broadly speaking in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00093-00023704-00023894": "that it aims to address any aspect of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00094-00023895-00024072": "social life within a universal", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00095-00024073-00024246": "theoretical framework of which the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00096-00024247-00024444": "diversity of subjects he wrote about as", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00097-00024445-00024741": "an indication lemons theory is sometimes", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00098-00024742-00024975": "dismissed as highly abstract and complex", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00099-00024976-00025164": "particularly within the Anglophone world", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00100-00025165-00025371": "whereas his work has had a more lasting", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00101-00025372-00025536": "influence on scholars from", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00102-00025537-00025761": "german-speaking countries Scandinavia", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00103-00025762-00025983": "and Italy lemon himself described his", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00104-00025983-00026349": "theories labyrinths like or non-linear", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00105-00026350-00026586": "and claimed he was deliberately keeping", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00106-00026587-00026760": "his prose and eggmad ik to prevent it", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00107-00026761-00027051": "from being understood too quickly which", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00108-00027052-00027190": "would only produce simplistic", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00109-00027191-00027660": "misunderstandings", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00110-00027661-00028080": "pick Systems Theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00111-00028081-00028372": "lemons systems theory focuses on three", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00112-00028373-00028561": "topics which are interconnected in his", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00113-00028562-00028908": "entire work systems theory as societal", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00114-00028910-00029335": "theory communication Theory an evolution", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00115-00029336-00029542": "theory the core element of lemons theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00116-00029543-00029692": "pivots around the problem of the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00117-00029693-00029869": "contingency of the meaning and thereby", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00118-00029870-00030060": "it becomes a theory of communication", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00119-00030061-00030298": "social systems are systems of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00120-00030299-00030514": "communication and society is the most", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00121-00030514-00030766": "encompassing social system being the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00122-00030767-00030982": "social system that comprises all and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00123-00030983-00031216": "only communication today's society as a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00124-00031217-00031522": "world society a system is defined by a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00125-00031523-00031689": "boundary between itself and its", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00126-00031691-00031852": "environment dividing it from an", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00127-00031852-00032029": "infinitely complex or colloquially", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00128-00032030-00032356": "chaotic exterior the interior of the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00129-00032357-00032520": "system is the tsa's own of reduced", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00130-00032522-00032739": "complexity communication within a system", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00131-00032741-00032962": "operates by selecting only a limited", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00132-00032963-00033130": "amount of all information available", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00133-00033131-00033394": "outside this process is also called", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00134-00033395-00033715": "reduction of complexity", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00135-00033716-00033913": "The Criterion according to which", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00136-00033914-00034144": "information is selected and processed as", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00137-00034145-00034432": "meaning in German Shin both social", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00138-00034433-00034645": "systems and psychic systems see below", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00139-00034646-00034819": "for an explanation of this distinction", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00140-00034820-00035049": "operate by processing meaning", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00141-00035050-00035251": "furthermore each system has a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00142-00035252-00035467": "distinctive identity that is constantly", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00143-00035468-00035662": "reproduced in its communication and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00144-00035663-00035851": "depends on what is considered meaningful", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00145-00035852-00036109": "and what is not if a system fails to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00146-00036110-00036295": "maintain that identity it ceases to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00147-00036296-00036496": "exist as a system and dissolves back", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00148-00036497-00036690": "into the environment it emerged from", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00149-00036691-00036907": "lemon called this process of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00150-00036908-00037108": "reproduction from elements previously", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00151-00037109-00037264": "filtered from an over complex", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00152-00037265-00037524": "environment Auto poiesis pronounced Auto", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00153-00037525-00037900": "poiesis literally self creation using a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00154-00037901-00038104": "term coined in cognitive biology by", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00155-00038105-00038332": "Chilean thinkers Humberto Maturana and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00156-00038333-00038620": "Francisco Varela social systems are", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00157-00038621-00038809": "operationally closed in that while they", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00158-00038810-00039001": "use and rely on resources from their", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00159-00039002-00039190": "environment those resources do not", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00160-00039191-00039372": "become part of the system's operation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00161-00039373-00039661": "both thought and digestion are important", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00162-00039662-00039847": "preconditions for communication but", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00163-00039848-00040059": "neither appears in communication as such", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00164-00040060-00040345": "note however that matter on de argued", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00165-00040346-00040555": "very vocally that this appropriation of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00166-00040556-00040738": "autopoietic theory was conceptually", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00167-00040739-00040996": "unsound as it presupposes the autonomy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00168-00040997-00041197": "of communications from actual persons", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00169-00041198-00041500": "that is by describing social systems as", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00170-00041501-00041680": "operationally closed networks of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00171-00041681-00041821": "communications lemon", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00172-00041822-00041989": "according to matter anna ignores the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00173-00041990-00042175": "fact that communications presuppose", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00174-00042176-00042481": "human communicators Auto poiesis only", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00175-00042482-00042682": "applies to networks of processes that", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00176-00042683-00042901": "reproduce themselves but communications", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00177-00042902-00043183": "are reproduced by humans for this reason", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00178-00043184-00043440": "the analogy from biology to sociology", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00179-00043441-00043705": "does not in this case home on the other", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00180-00043706-00043939": "hand lemon explicitly stressed that he", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00181-00043940-00044152": "does not refer to a society without", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00182-00044153-00044365": "humans but to the fact that", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00183-00044366-00044550": "communication is autopoietic", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00184-00044551-00044797": "communication is made possible by human", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00185-00044798-00044989": "bodies and consciousness but this does", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00186-00044990-00045178": "not make communication operationally", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00187-00045179-00045622": "open to participate in communication one", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00188-00045623-00045778": "must be able to render one's thoughts", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00189-00045779-00045940": "and perceptions into elements of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00190-00045941-00046201": "communication this can only ever occur", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00191-00046202-00046390": "as a communicative operation thoughts", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00192-00046391-00046561": "and perceptions cannot be directly", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00193-00046562-00046792": "transmitted and must therefore satisfy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00194-00046793-00046977": "internal system conditions that are", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00195-00046978-00047110": "specific to communication", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00196-00047111-00047359": "intelligibility reaching and addressee", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00197-00047360-00047746": "and gaining acceptance lemon likens the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00198-00047747-00047968": "operation of auto poiesis the filtering", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00199-00047969-00048160": "and processing of information from the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00200-00048161-00048391": "environment to a program making a series", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00201-00048392-00048595": "of logical distinctions in german under", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00202-00048596-00048880": "Shai Duncan here lemon refers to the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00203-00048881-00049099": "British mathematician G Spencer Browns", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00204-00049100-00049315": "logic of distinctions that matter andhe", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00205-00049316-00049522": "and Varela had earlier identified as a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00206-00049523-00049663": "model for the functioning of any", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00207-00049664-00049990": "cognitive process the supreme criterion", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00208-00049991-00050302": "guiding the self creation of any given", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00209-00050303-00050563": "system as a defining binary code this", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00210-00050564-00050779": "binary code is not to be confused with", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00211-00050780-00051010": "the computer's operation lemon following", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00212-00051011-00051208": "Spencer Brown and Gregory Batterson", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00213-00051209-00051424": "assumes that Auto referential systems", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00214-00051425-00051591": "are continuously confronted with the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00215-00051592-00051811": "dilemma of disintegration continuation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00216-00051812-00052033": "this dilemma is framed with an", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00217-00052034-00052219": "ever-changing set of available choices", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00218-00052220-00052465": "every one of those potential choices can", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00219-00052466-00052660": "be the system selection or not a binary", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00220-00052661-00052992": "state selected rejected the influence of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00221-00052994-00053200": "Spencer Browns book laws of form on", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00222-00053201-00053433": "lemon can hardly be overestimated", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00223-00053434-00053667": "although lemon first developed his", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00224-00053669-00053880": "understanding of social systems theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00225-00053882-00054073": "under Parsons influence he soon moved", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00226-00054074-00054342": "away from the parson ium concept the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00227-00054344-00054484": "most important difference is that", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00228-00054485-00054697": "Parsons framed systems as forms of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00229-00054698-00054867": "action in accordance with the agile", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00230-00054869-00055167": "paradigm Parsons Systems Theory treats", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00231-00055169-00055363": "systems as operationally open and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00232-00055364-00055554": "interactive through an input and output", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00233-00055555-00055807": "schema influenced by second-order", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00234-00055808-00056059": "cybernetics lemon instead treats systems", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00235-00056060-00056322": "as autopoietic and operationally closed", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00236-00056323-00056566": "systems must continually construct", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00237-00056566-00056722": "themselves in their perspective of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00238-00056723-00056884": "reality through processing the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00239-00056885-00057037": "distinction between system and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00240-00057038-00057208": "environment and self reproduce", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00241-00057209-00057366": "themselves as the product of their own", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00242-00057367-00057658": "elements social systems are defined by", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00243-00057659-00057865": "lemon not as action but as recursive", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00244-00057866-00058174": "communication modern society is defined", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00245-00058175-00058384": "as a world system consisting of the sum", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00246-00058385-00058594": "total of all communication happening at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00247-00058595-00058807": "once and individual function systems", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00248-00058808-00059044": "such as the economy politics science", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00249-00059045-00059355": "love art the media etc are described as", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00250-00059357-00059559": "social subsystems which have how", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00251-00059560-00059824": "differentiated from the social system", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00252-00059825-00059979": "and achieve their own operational", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00253-00059980-00060265": "closure and auto places another", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00254-00060266-00060479": "difference is that parsons asks house", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00255-00060479-00060653": "certain subsystems contribute to the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00256-00060654-00060932": "functioning of overall society lemon", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00257-00060933-00061112": "starts with the differentiation of the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00258-00061113-00061304": "systems themselves out of a nondescript", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00259-00061304-00061553": "environment while he does observe how", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00260-00061554-00061760": "certain systems fulfill functions that", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00261-00061761-00062101": "contribute to society as a whole he", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00262-00062102-00062261": "dispenses with the assumption of a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00263-00062262-00062486": "priori cultural or normative consensus", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00264-00062487-00062759": "or complimentary purpose which was", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00265-00062760-00062962": "common to Durkheim and Parsons", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00266-00062963-00063160": "conceptualization of a social function", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00267-00063161-00063454": "for Lemon functional differentiation as", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00268-00063455-00063623": "a consequence of selective pressure", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00269-00063624-00063826": "under tempera lized complexity and it", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00270-00063827-00064046": "occurs as function systems independently", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00271-00064047-00064225": "established their own ecological niches", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00272-00064226-00064499": "by performing a function functions are", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00273-00064500-00064712": "therefore not the coordinated components", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00274-00064713-00064904": "of the organic social whole but rather", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00275-00064904-00065123": "contingent in selective responses to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00276-00065124-00065315": "reference problems which obey no higher", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00277-00065316-00065482": "principle of order and could have been", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00278-00065483-00065804": "responded to in other ways finally the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00279-00065805-00066013": "system's autopoietic closure is another", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00280-00066014-00066167": "fundamental difference from Parsons", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00281-00066168-00066443": "concept each system works strictly", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00282-00066444-00066656": "according to its very own code and can", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00283-00066657-00066854": "observe other systems only by applying", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00284-00066855-00067097": "its code to their operations for example", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00285-00067098-00067334": "the code of the economy involves the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00286-00067335-00067496": "application of the distinction between", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00287-00067497-00067781": "payment and non-payment other system", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00288-00067782-00067981": "operations appear within the economic", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00289-00067982-00068213": "field of references only insofar as this", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00290-00068214-00068393": "economic code can be applied to them", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00291-00068394-00068675": "hence a political decision becomes an", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00292-00068676-00068885": "economic operation when it is observed", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00293-00068886-00069100": "as a government spending money or not", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00294-00069101-00069388": "likewise a legal judgment may also be an", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00295-00069389-00069611": "economic operation when settlement of a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00296-00069612-00069836": "contractual dispute obliges one party to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00297-00069837-00070022": "pay for the goods or services they had", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00298-00070023-00070271": "acquired the codes of the economy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00299-00070272-00070463": "politics and law operate autonomously", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00300-00070464-00070817": "but their inter penetration is evident", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00301-00070818-00071048": "when observing events which", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00302-00071049-00071279": "simultaneously involve the participation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00303-00071280-00071569": "of more than one system one seemingly", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00304-00071570-00071743": "peculiar but within the overall", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00305-00071744-00071984": "framework strictly logical axiom of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00306-00071985-00072169": "lemons theory as the human beings", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00307-00072170-00072347": "position outside any social system", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00308-00072348-00072586": "initially developed by Parsons", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00309-00072587-00072893": "consisting of pure communicative actions", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00310-00072894-00073121": "a reference to Jurgen Habermas", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00311-00073122-00073334": "any social system requires human", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00312-00073335-00073529": "consciousness as personal or psychical", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00313-00073530-00073763": "systems as an obviously necessary but", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00314-00073764-00073874": "nevertheless environment", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00315-00073875-00074171": "mental resource in lemons terms human", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00316-00074172-00074378": "beings are neither part of society nor", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00317-00074379-00074591": "of any specific systems just as they are", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00318-00074592-00074837": "not part of a conversation Lemmon", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00319-00074838-00075053": "himself once said concisely that he was", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00320-00075054-00075389": "not interested in people that is not to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00321-00075390-00075557": "say that people were not a matter for", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00322-00075558-00075743": "Lemon but rather the communicative", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00323-00075744-00075953": "actions of people are constituted but", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00324-00075954-00076214": "not defined by society and society is", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00325-00076215-00076418": "constituted but not defined by the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00326-00076419-00076661": "communicative actions of people society", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00327-00076662-00076853": "is people's environment and people are", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00328-00076854-00077189": "society's environment thus sociology can", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00329-00077190-00077381": "explain how persons can change society", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00330-00077382-00077609": "the influence of the environment the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00331-00077610-00077825": "people on the system the society the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00332-00077826-00078149": "so-called structural coupling in fact", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00333-00078150-00078338": "Lemmon himself replied to the relevant", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00334-00078339-00078602": "criticism by stating that in fact the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00335-00078603-00078839": "theory of autopoietic systems could bear", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00336-00078840-00079091": "the title taking individuals seriously", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00337-00079092-00079307": "certainly more seriously than our", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00338-00079308-00079600": "humanistic tradition Niklas Luhmann", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00339-00079601-00079823": "operational closure and structural", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00340-00079824-00080009": "coupling the differentiation of the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00341-00080010-00080327": "legal system Cardozo Law Review vol 13", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00342-00080328-00080762": "to 1422 this approach has attracted", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00343-00080763-00080924": "criticism from those who argue that", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00344-00080925-00081152": "lemon has at no point demonstrated the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00345-00081153-00081392": "operational closure of social systems or", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00346-00081393-00081629": "in fact that autopoietic social systems", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00347-00081630-00081746": "actually exist", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00348-00081747-00082004": "he has instead taken this as a premise", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00349-00082005-00082184": "or presupposition resulting in the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00350-00082185-00082385": "logical need to exclude humans from", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00351-00082386-00082613": "social systems which prevents the social", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00352-00082614-00082784": "systems view from accounting for the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00353-00082785-00083018": "individual behavior action motives or", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00354-00083019-00083213": "indeed existence of any individual", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00355-00083214-00083441": "person lemon was devoted to the ideal of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00356-00083442-00083624": "non normative science introduced to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00357-00083625-00083876": "sociology in the early 20th century by", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00358-00083877-00084077": "Max Weber and later redefined and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00359-00084078-00084257": "defended against its critics by Karl", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00360-00084258-00084527": "Popper however in an academic", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00361-00084528-00084695": "environment that never strictly", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00362-00084696-00084869": "separated descriptive and normative", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00363-00084870-00085154": "theories of society lemon sociology has", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00364-00085155-00085345": "widely attracted criticism from various", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00365-00085346-00085873": "intellectuals including Jurgen Habermas", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00366-00085874-00086375": "topic Lemmons reception", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00367-00086376-00086637": "lemons systems theory is not without its", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00368-00086638-00086890": "critics his definitions of autopoietic", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00369-00086891-00087321": "and social system differ from others at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00370-00087322-00087580": "the same time his theory is being", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00371-00087581-00087755": "applied or used worldwide by", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00372-00087756-00088048": "sociologists and other scholars it is", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00373-00088049-00088251": "often used in analyses dealing with", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00374-00088252-00088437": "corporate social responsibility", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00375-00088438-00088662": "organizational legitimacy governance", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00376-00088663-00088867": "structures as well as with sociology of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00377-00088868-00089368": "line of course general sociology", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00378-00089369-00089858": "topic miscellaneous", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00379-00089859-00090114": "lemon also appears as a character in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00380-00090115-00090333": "Paul Wars work of literature das Falls", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00381-00090334-00090555": "book together with among others all Rex", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00382-00090556-00090780": "anuman Johann Georg Hammond and Richard", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00383-00090781-00091071": "Buckminster Fuller Lemmon owned a pub", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00384-00091072-00091386": "ponds in his parents house in his native", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00385-00091387-00091620": "town of Luneberg the house which also", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00386-00091621-00091824": "contained his father's brewery had been", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00387-00091825-00092374": "in his family's hands since 1857", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00388-00092375-00092909": "topic publications", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00389-00092910-00093155": "a certain number of original books and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00390-00093156-00093368": "articles are available for download see", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00391-00093369-00093767": "below external links 1963 with Franz", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00392-00093768-00093977": "Becker were Waltons feller invert", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00393-00093978-00094172": "ratchets Mowgli Katyn guess it's", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00394-00094173-00094421": "literally dûr-rugnu barkeep von ver wall", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00395-00094422-00094666": "tanks actin Berlin dunker and hum blot", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00396-00094667-00094946": "1964 function and in full gun formal", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00397-00094947-00095215": "organization Berlin dunker and hum blot", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00398-00095216-00095495": "1965 a family correct Alicia and shot", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00399-00095496-00095687": "eating Rex politician attracted Berlin", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00400-00095688-00096056": "dunker and hum blot 1965 Grund rekt ALS", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00401-00096057-00096314": "institution I'm be trakzer politician", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00402-00096315-00096586": "sociology berlin dunker and hum blot", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00403-00096587-00096863": "1966 rekt tuned automation in Deraa", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00404-00096864-00097064": "Fenley convert wall tongue I never wall", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00405-00097065-00097250": "tanks wissenschaftliche under such young", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00406-00097251-00097589": "Berlin dunker and hum blot 1966 Theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00407-00097590-00097748": "d'oeuvre wall tanks Wissenschaft", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00408-00097749-00097973": "best n zoth nummy hoon dint worth :", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00409-00097974-00098279": "Berlin 1968 vert Rowan I'm mechanism is", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00410-00098280-00098495": "der reduction so sealer complexity at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00411-00098496-00098777": "Stuttgart Anka English translation trust", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00412-00098778-00099209": "and power Chester Wylie 1979 1968", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00413-00099210-00099440": "wack beggar if une system rationality at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00414-00099441-00099674": "uber die function Vaughn's Wacken and so", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00415-00099675-00100052": "Celine system in Tubingen JCB more paul", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00416-00100053-00100394": "seebik 1969 legitimation dirtier Ferran", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00417-00100395-00100682": "knew we'd Berlin Lecter Han 1970", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00418-00100683-00100925": "sociology shock clearing Oz onto zur", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00419-00100926-00101207": "theorie solar system a : Oh Clayton West", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00420-00101208-00101429": "uh server lag English translation of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00421-00101430-00101636": "some of the articles the differentiation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00422-00101637-00101837": "of society New York Columbia University", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00423-00101838-00102068": "Press 1982", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00424-00102069-00102401": "1971 with Jurgen Habermas theory Durga's", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00425-00102402-00102650": "cell shaft odor so zeal technology was", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00426-00102651-00103082": "lysosome forcing Frankfurt sir Kemp 1971", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00427-00103083-00103193": "political and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00428-00103194-00103448": "as on Caesar sociology von palo de", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00429-00103449-00103664": "gooned ver Walton Oh Clayton West uh", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00430-00103665-00104015": "server lag 1972 rushed Susie ology two", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00431-00104016-00104083": "volumes", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00432-00104084-00104348": "Rhinebeck row bolt english translation a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00433-00104349-00104615": "sociological theory of law london route", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00434-00104616-00104983": "llege 1985 1973 with Renata mains", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00435-00104984-00105179": "personal I'm offending condensed I", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00436-00105180-00105451": "introduced carrier in baden-baden Nomos", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00437-00105452-00105749": "1974 rest system une Rex dogmatic", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00438-00105750-00106040": "Stuttgart coal hammer 1975 matched", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00439-00106041-00106291": "Stuttgart Anka English translation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00440-00106292-00106683": "trust in power Chester Wylie 1979", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00441-00106684-00107069": "1975 sociology shock luring - aza teaser", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00442-00107070-00107306": "Theory Durga cell shaft Oh Platon West", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00443-00107307-00107573": "uh server lag ISBN nine seven eight", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00444-00107574-00107827": "three five three one six one two eight", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00445-00107828-00108068": "one two English translation of some of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00446-00108069-00108257": "the articles the differentiation of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00447-00108258-00108508": "society New York Columbia University", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00448-00108509-00108916": "Press 1982 1977 function Durrell ijen", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00449-00108917-00109169": "Frankfurt sir camp English translation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00450-00109170-00109699": "of pp 72 to 181 religious dogmatix and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00451-00109700-00109895": "the evolution of societies New York", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00452-00109896-00110281": "Toronto Edwin Mellen press 1978", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00453-00110282-00110512": "organisation indent shining equals", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00454-00110513-00110696": "Rheinische West fallish akademie der", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00455-00110697-00110795": "wissenschaften", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00456-00110796-00111178": "vort rage G 232 platon West at server", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00457-00111179-00111569": "lag 1979 with Carl Everhard Shore", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00458-00111570-00111782": "reflections problem AI Mersey lang", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00459-00111783-00112208": "system stuttgart klett cada 1980 gazelle", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00460-00112208-00112433": "shaft structure in semantic studi and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00461-00112433-00112663": "zur wissen sociology der modern and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00462-00112664-00112959": "Gesellschaft ike frankfurt sewer camp", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00463-00112960-00113278": "1981 politically I'm Wolfe arts taught", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00464-00113279-00113554": "Munchen ole Zog English translation with", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00465-00113555-00113795": "essays from sociology shock luring for", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00466-00113796-00113986": "political theory in the welfare state", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00467-00113987-00114490": "Berlin de Gruyter 1990 1981 Cassell", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00468-00114491-00114719": "shaft structure in semantic studi and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00469-00114720-00114937": "zur wissen sociology der modern and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00470-00114938-00115346": "Gesellschaft to Frankfurt sir camp 1981", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00471-00115347-00115576": "hasta fur and zeroing directs beiträge", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00472-00115577-00115813": "zur rests a geology indirect theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00473-00115814-00116251": "Frankfurt sewer camp 1981 sociology", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00474-00116252-00116509": "shock luring three social system Cassell", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00475-00116510-00116764": "shaft organization Oh Platon West at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00476-00116765-00117250": "server lag 1982 liebe ALS passion zhurko", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00477-00117251-00117463": "d-ring von intimate at Frankfurt", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00478-00117464-00117695": "sewer camp English translation love is", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00479-00117696-00117896": "passion the codification of intimacy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00480-00117897-00118435": "Cambridge polity press 1986 ISBN 978 o8", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00481-00118436-00119069": "o 4 7 3 2 5 3 6 1984 sociology system a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00482-00119070-00119263": "Grund Rihanna allgemeinen theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00483-00119264-00119522": "Frankfurt sewer camp English translation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00484-00119523-00119683": "social systems Stan", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00485-00119684-00120182": "ferd Stanford University Press 1995 1985", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00486-00120183-00120433": "condi Moderne gazelle shafts it shall", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00487-00120434-00120733": "focus gaffer Dunga nine stolen equals", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00488-00120734-00120920": "Rheinische west fallish akademie der", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00489-00120921-00121016": "wissenschaften", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00490-00121017-00121376": "vort rage G 278 up Layton West Dutch", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00491-00121377-00121799": "server lag 1986 die sociology SH Bo", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00492-00121800-00122260": "backing directs Frankfurt Metzner 1986 o", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00493-00122261-00122528": "collage ish communication condi Moderne", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00494-00122529-00122771": "gazelle shafts it shall focus Jeff aired", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00495-00122772-00123020": "Unga nine stolen o played in West Dutch", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00496-00123021-00123293": "erver lag English translation ecological", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00497-00123294-00123515": "communication Cambridge polity press", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00498-00123516-00124033": "1989 1987 sociological airing for", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00499-00124034-00124234": "beiträge zur functional and difference", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00500-00124235-00124466": "iran durga cell shaft Oh Platon West", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00501-00124467-00124865": "Dutch erver lag 1987 edited by dirk", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00502-00124866-00125045": "becker and gay or extended sick", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00503-00125046-00125351": "archimedes hoon wir interviews berlin", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00504-00125352-00125795": "merv 1988 die wertshafter gazelle shaft", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00505-00125796-00126254": "frankfurt sewer kemp 1988 perkiness ALS", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00506-00126255-00126713": "construction burn mentally 1989 gazelle", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00507-00126714-00126941": "shaft structure in semantic studi and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00508-00126942-00127166": "zur wissen sociology der modern and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00509-00127167-00127585": "gazelle shaft 3 frankfurt sir kemp 1989", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00510-00127586-00127820": "with Peter Fuchs red and swaggin", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00511-00127821-00128035": "Frankfort sewer camp partial English", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00512-00128036-00128348": "translation speaking in silence new", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00513-00128349-00128932": "German critique 61 1994 PP 25 to 30 7", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00514-00128933-00129272": "1990 risiko enga fair equals olive or", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00515-00129273-00129725": "age 48 st. Gallen 1990 paradigm lost", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00516-00129726-00129947": "über die ethic reflection der Morel", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00517-00129948-00130169": "Frankfurt sewer camp partial English", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00518-00130170-00130454": "translation paradigm lost on the ethical", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00519-00130455-00130684": "reflection of morality speech on the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00520-00130685-00130906": "occasion of the award of the Hegel prize", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00521-00130907-00131447": "1988 thesis 1129 1991 PP", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00522-00131448-00131975": "82 294 1990 essays on self reference New", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00523-00131976-00132380": "York Columbia University Press 1990", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00524-00132381-00132668": "sociology shock luring 5 constructivist", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00525-00132669-00132890": "each perspective in Oh Platon West at", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00526-00132891-00133049": "server lag", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00527-00133050-00133341": "1990 died wissenschaft Jurgis L shaft", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00528-00133342-00133599": "Frankfort sewer camp English translation", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00529-00133600-00133851": "of chapter 10 the modernity of science", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00530-00133852-00134468": "new German critique 61 1994 PP 9 - 23", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00531-00134469-00134868": "1991 saw geology day riscos Berlin dig", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00532-00134869-00135096": "writer English translation risk a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00533-00135097-00135470": "sociological theory Berlin dig writer", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00534-00135471-00135810": "1992 with Raphael de Georgi teoria della", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00535-00135811-00136305": "so Chetta Milano Franco Angele 1992 Bo", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00536-00136306-00136539": "back tongan der Moderne up Layton West", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00537-00136540-00136956": "at server lag 1992 edited by Andre", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00538-00136957-00137220": "keyserling Universitat ALS milieu", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00539-00137221-00137757": "Bielefeld pox 1993 gibt es in unserer", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00540-00137758-00137934": "gazelle shaft knock-on Brazil are a", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00541-00137935-00138483": "norman Heidelberg CF Muller 1993 das", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00542-00138484-00138699": "rector gazelle shaft Frankfurt sewer", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00543-00138700-00138957": "camp English translation law as a social", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00544-00138958-00139211": "system Oxford Oxford University Press", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00545-00139212-00139635": "2004 is B&O one nine eight two six two", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00546-00139636-00140043": "three eight eight 1994 Dyess defer NZ", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00547-00140044-00140469": "rung day systems burn vent le 1995", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00548-00140470-00140676": "dye really taught dermis and median", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00549-00140677-00140925": "equals nordrhein-westfalen akademie der", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00550-00140926-00141309": "wissenschaften vort rage g 333 up late", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00551-00141310-00141687": "in 1995 second extended edition 1996", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00552-00141688-00141921": "english translation the reality of the", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00553-00141922-00142185": "mass media stanford stanford university", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00554-00142186-00142479": "press ISBN nine seven eight oh eight oh", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00555-00142480-00142865": "four seven four oh seven seven seven", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00556-00142866-00143202": "1995 sociology shock luring six died", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00557-00143203-00143475": "sociology under meant Oh played in West", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00558-00143476-00143841": "uh server lag 1995 Cassell shaft", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00559-00143842-00144054": "structure in semantics students er", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00560-00144055-00144291": "wissen sociology der modern and ghazal", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00561-00144292-00144711": "shaft for frankfurt sir camp 1995 die", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00562-00144712-00144933": "kunst der gazelle shaft frankfurt sir", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00563-00144934-00145182": "camp english translation art as a social", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00564-00145183-00145419": "system Stanford Stanford University", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00565-00145420-00145854": "Press 2000 1996 die new site leaked and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00566-00145855-00146076": "wissenschaften une die phenomenology", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00567-00146077-00146285": "Wien pikas", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00568-00146286-00146603": "1996 edited by Cayuga Helmand protest", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00569-00146604-00146859": "system theory in sociology engine", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00570-00146860-00147318": "Frankfort sewer camp 1996 modern society", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00571-00147319-00147546": "shocked by its risks equals University", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00572-00147547-00147737": "of Hong Kong Department of Sociology", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00573-00147738-00148086": "occasional papers 17 Hong Kong available", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00574-00148087-00148518": "via HK you scholars hub 1997 died", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00575-00148519-00148743": "gesellschaft der gazelle shaft Frankfort", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00576-00148744-00148991": "sewer camp English translation theory of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00577-00148992-00149259": "society Stanford Stanford University", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00578-00149260-00149670": "Press 1998 die politic durga cell shaft", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00579-00149671-00149814": "frankfort sir camp", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00580-00149815-00150006": "heraus coachman van andre keyserling", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00581-00150007-00150450": "2000 1998 died religion durga cell shaft", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00582-00150451-00150693": "frankfort sir camp Harris coachman van", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00583-00150694-00151140": "Andrei keyserling 2000 1998 dossers e", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00584-00151141-00151338": "hung system Berga cell shaft Frankfort", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00585-00151339-00151551": "sewer camp Harris gage Ben von dieter", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00586-00151552-00151965": "lens in 2002 articles 2006 system as", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00587-00151966-00152411": "difference organization vol 13 1 January", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00588-00152412-00153090": "2006 PP 37 to 57", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00589-00153091-00153610": "topic references", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00590-00153611-00154126": "topic further reading", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00591-00154127-00154474": "Detlef horse sir 1997 Niklas lemon", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00592-00154475-00154804": "münchen David Seidel and Kai Helga", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00593-00154805-00155026": "Becker Niklas lemon and organization", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00594-00155027-00155335": "studies Copenhagen Business School press", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00595-00155336-00155704": "Copenhagen 2005 ISBN nine seven eight", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00596-00155705-00156081": "eight seven six 300 one six two five", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00597-00156082-00156469": "Michelle Infante 2012 teoria system", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00598-00156470-00156879": "Academy dia lemon Eli comunicaciones p12", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00599-00156880-00157279": "262 Arachne editrice Roma ISBN nine", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00600-00157280-00157477": "seven eight eight eight five four eight", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00601-00157478-00157807": "four seven two three one Michelle", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00602-00157808-00158221": "Infante 2013 codification signal canal", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00603-00158222-00158566": "noise encoding and decoding in New", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00604-00158567-00158839": "Atlantis nature and human sciences and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00605-00158840-00159094": "complexity Journal year 28th and degree", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00606-00159095-00159622": "2 July December 2013 P 57 to 60 is SN 2", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00607-00159623-00160057": "2 8 1 9 4 9 5 ISBN nine seven eight", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00608-00160058-00160318": "eight eight five four eight six six one", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00609-00160319-00160600": "one nine doy ten point four three nine", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00610-00160601-00160938": "nine ninety seven trillion 888 billion", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00611-00160939-00161218": "548 million six hundred sixty one", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00612-00161219-00161667": "thousand 198 Michelle Infante 2013", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00613-00161668-00161929": "information in New Atlantis", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00614-00161930-00162178": "nature and human sciences and complexity", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00615-00162179-00162469": "Journal year 28th and degree 2 July Dec", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00616-00162470-00162955": "201 3 P 61 264 Arachne editrice joy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00617-00162956-00163171": "ten point four three nine nine ninety", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00618-00163172-00163552": "seven trillion 888 billion 548 million", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00619-00163553-00163762": "six hundred sixty one thousand one", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00620-00163763-00164050": "hundred ninety nine Michelle Infante", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00621-00164051-00164404": "2013 systemic boundary in New Atlantis", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00622-00164405-00164707": "nature and human sciences and complexity", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00623-00164708-00164965": "Journal year 28th and degree 2 July", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00624-00164966-00165118": "December 2013", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00625-00165119-00165589": "Arachne editrice is SN 2 to 8 1 9 4 9 5", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00626-00165590-00166276": "is B and 9 7 8 8 8 5 4 8 6 6 1 1 9 p 65", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00627-00166277-00166408": "to 68 doy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00628-00166409-00166696": "ten four thousand three hundred ninety", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00629-00166697-00166894": "nine nine hundred seventy eight trillion", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00630-00166895-00167110": "eight hundred eighty-five billion four", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00631-00167111-00167296": "hundred eighty six million six hundred", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00632-00167297-00167460": "eleven thousand nine", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00633-00167461-00167889": "tense Michelle Infante 2013 media", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00634-00167890-00168128": "construction of fair and social risk in", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00635-00168129-00168444": "the late-2000s financial crisis New", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00636-00168445-00168693": "Atlantis nature and human sciences and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00637-00168694-00168957": "complexity Journal year 28th and degree", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00638-00168958-00169134": "1 Dec June 2013", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00639-00169135-00169602": "Arachne editrice vol 1 P 59 to 78 is SN", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00640-00169603-00170031": "2 to 8 1 9 4 9 5 joy boy ten point four", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00641-00170032-00170252": "three nine nine ninety seven trillion", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00642-00170253-00170854": "888 billion 548 million six hundred 1559", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00643-00170855-00171249": "Alana Gershon 2005 seeing like a system", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00644-00171250-00171500": "lemon for anthropologists", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00645-00171501-00171974": "anthropological theory 5 299 to 116", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00646-00171975-00172316": "giorgio man Frey blah so chedda della so", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00647-00172317-00172818": "Jetta Quatro venti Urbino 2008 giorgio", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00648-00172819-00173175": "man frey arrows ysou chedda mondo lemon", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00649-00173176-00173629": "Marx Freud Quattro venti Urbino 2004", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00650-00173630-00173988": "honks Gehrig molar 2012 the radical", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00651-00173989-00174348": "lemon New York Javier Torres Navarrete", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00652-00174349-00174621": "wide Dario Rodriguez Mencia 2008", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00653-00174622-00174834": "introducion allottee Oriya de la", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00654-00174835-00175115": "sociedad de Nikolas lemon medica", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00655-00175116-00175518": "editorial herder oliver Joris armin NASA", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00656-00175519-00175857": "he at all 2012 lemon hand Beck Leben", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00657-00175858-00176214": "work working stuttgart georg near and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00658-00176215-00176591": "Armin nasa he 2004 Niklas lemon ina I'm", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00659-00176592-00176913": "Frank münchen Alexander Riegler and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00660-00176914-00177282": "Armin Scholl EDS 2012 lemons relation to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00661-00177283-00177432": "and relevance for constructivist", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00662-00177433-00177771": "approaches special issue constructivist", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00663-00177772-00178119": "foundations 8 1 1 to 116 freely", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00664-00178120-00178352": "available at the journals website", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00665-00178353-00178553": "magdalena zan Eva edy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00666-00178554-00178829": "macht flug der you'll get egg back soon", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00667-00178830-00179145": "15 toda Stagg von Niklas Luhmann Berlin", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00668-00179146-00179460": "2013 Alberto semolina", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00669-00179461-00179646": "where does Nicholas lemons card index", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00670-00179647-00179889": "come from erudition and the Republic of", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00671-00179890-00180565": "Letters vol 3 n 4 2018 PP 392 420 joy", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00672-00180566-00180840": "10.1 163 to 4", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00673-00180841-00181554": "five 506 900 300 400 to", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00674-00181555-00181943": "topic external links", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00675-00181944-00182125": "you", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00676-00182126-00182434": "system thinking a mind map presenting", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00677-00182435-00182616": "selected links on lemon", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00678-00182617-00182905": "socio-cyberneering sailing list mailing", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00679-00182906-00183070": "list concerning nicholas lemons", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00680-00183071-00183397": "theoretical work sistema sociales", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00681-00183398-00183754": "scientific divide ia's of lemons theory", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00682-00183755-00184038": "of autopoietic social systems in spanish", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00683-00184039-00184303": "soft copies of original books and", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00684-00184304-00184519": "articles available for download password", "d1Ze995Ci7U-00685-00184520-00184885": "George Spencer Brown"}}, {"audio_id": "d20oeX9LLFY", "text": {"d20oeX9LLFY-00000-00001107-00001912": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00001-00001913-00003775": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00002-00003776-00004411": "um", "d20oeX9LLFY-00003-00004412-00005372": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00004-00005373-00005450": "[Applause]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00005-00005451-00005564": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00006-00005565-00005846": "[Applause]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00007-00005847-00006887": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00008-00006888-00007039": "foreign", "d20oeX9LLFY-00009-00007040-00008319": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00010-00008320-00008694": "me", "d20oeX9LLFY-00011-00008695-00008771": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00012-00008772-00008822": "[Applause]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00013-00008823-00010751": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00014-00010752-00011812": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00015-00011813-00012061": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00016-00012062-00012368": "[Applause]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00017-00012369-00012663": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00018-00012664-00012833": "me", "d20oeX9LLFY-00019-00012834-00013772": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00020-00013772-00013799": "[Applause]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00021-00013800-00015047": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00022-00015047-00015251": "is", "d20oeX9LLFY-00023-00015252-00016143": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00024-00016144-00017150": "[Applause]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00025-00017151-00017470": "let me see", "d20oeX9LLFY-00026-00017471-00019058": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00027-00019059-00020550": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00028-00020551-00021095": "foreign", "d20oeX9LLFY-00029-00021096-00022111": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00030-00022112-00022489": "hey", "d20oeX9LLFY-00031-00022490-00023767": "[Music]", "d20oeX9LLFY-00032-00023768-00024048": "is"}}, {"audio_id": "d25RNa4k_GQ", "text": {"d25RNa4k_GQ-00000-00000027-00000912": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00001-00000913-00001292": "thank you", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00002-00001293-00003208": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00003-00003209-00003385": "let's go", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00004-00003386-00005553": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00005-00005554-00006325": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00006-00006326-00007056": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00007-00007058-00007481": "foreign foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00008-00007481-00010595": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00009-00010596-00010949": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00010-00010950-00011550": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00011-00011551-00013108": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00012-00013109-00013535": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00013-00013536-00014072": "thank you", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00014-00014072-00014501": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00015-00014502-00014977": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00016-00014978-00017052": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00017-00017053-00018058": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00018-00018059-00018273": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00019-00018274-00019766": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00020-00019767-00020097": "[Applause]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00021-00020098-00020855": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00022-00020856-00021003": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00023-00021004-00022199": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00024-00022200-00022304": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00025-00022305-00023847": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00026-00023848-00026081": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00027-00026082-00026975": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00028-00026976-00029005": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00029-00029006-00029549": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00030-00029550-00029824": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00031-00029825-00030881": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00032-00030882-00032519": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00033-00032520-00033437": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00034-00033438-00033707": "foreign", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00035-00033708-00035429": "[Music]", "d25RNa4k_GQ-00036-00035430-00035653": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "d2f8mWyK6ty", "text": {"d2f8mWyK6ty-00000-00000059-00000476": "foreign", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00001-00000478-00001497": "[Music]", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00002-00001498-00003103": "[Music]", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00003-00003104-00003486": "don't know", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00004-00003488-00004145": "Amar awarded", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00005-00004146-00006527": "um", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00006-00006528-00007739": "inshallah", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00007-00007740-00008547": "myself", "d2f8mWyK6ty-00008-00008548-00008865": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "d2fchiHGwtE", "text": {"d2fchiHGwtE-00000-00000003-00000305": "live from Boston Massachusetts", "d2fchiHGwtE-00001-00000306-00000703": "it's the cube covering AWS reinforce", "d2fchiHGwtE-00002-00000704-00000836": "2019", "d2fchiHGwtE-00003-00000836-00001064": "brought to you by Amazon Web Services", "d2fchiHGwtE-00004-00001065-00001565": "and its ecosystem partners okay welcome", "d2fchiHGwtE-00005-00001566-00001742": "back everyone we are here live in Boston", "d2fchiHGwtE-00006-00001743-00001901": "with the cubes coverage of AWS Amazon", "d2fchiHGwtE-00007-00001902-00002141": "Web Services reinforced their inaugural", "d2fchiHGwtE-00008-00002142-00002312": "conference getting into the security", "d2fchiHGwtE-00009-00002313-00002635": "event business because the customers are", "d2fchiHGwtE-00010-00002636-00002783": "here and there's growing like crazy I'm", "d2fchiHGwtE-00011-00002784-00002959": "John far with DES Volante we're here to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00012-00002960-00003224": "guests of a hot start up pub Alex", "d2fchiHGwtE-00013-00003225-00003556": "Vishal Jain CEO and Brian Nasir chief", "d2fchiHGwtE-00014-00003557-00003806": "product offers Baltics you guys just", "d2fchiHGwtE-00015-00003807-00003979": "launched out of stealth congratulations", "d2fchiHGwtE-00016-00003980-00004193": "thank you guys got some good pedigree I", "d2fchiHGwtE-00017-00004194-00004367": "here in the company yeah", "d2fchiHGwtE-00018-00004368-00004517": "welcome to the cube thank you so much", "d2fchiHGwtE-00019-00004518-00004672": "John okay so first of all before we get", "d2fchiHGwtE-00020-00004673-00004775": "to the conference which i think is very", "d2fchiHGwtE-00021-00004776-00004967": "relevant you guys are getting out there", "d2fchiHGwtE-00022-00004968-00005170": "what do you guys do what is vault it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00023-00005171-00005443": "all about what is the core problem you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00024-00005444-00005633": "solve why start this company what's the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00025-00005634-00005893": "value proposition yeah so building the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00026-00005894-00006113": "first cloud native network security", "d2fchiHGwtE-00027-00006114-00006334": "platform so before shall accompany you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00028-00006335-00006517": "talk a lot of customers we talk to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00029-00006518-00006776": "customers and we saw the clouds real you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00030-00006777-00007045": "can see here crowd is real and we saw", "d2fchiHGwtE-00031-00007047-00007325": "that network security have challenges in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00032-00007326-00007531": "how the scale in the cloud and that's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00033-00007533-00007730": "mainly because of three things to look", "d2fchiHGwtE-00034-00007731-00007955": "at that main thing is that the cloud is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00035-00007956-00008012": "sprawling", "d2fchiHGwtE-00036-00008013-00008221": "the data center used to be like three", "d2fchiHGwtE-00037-00008222-00008459": "and four now the customers as is hard in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00038-00008460-00008614": "the morning in the keynote they have", "d2fchiHGwtE-00039-00008615-00008945": "certainly one than 10 103 PCs there's a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00040-00008946-00009083": "new logical parameter you are seeing", "d2fchiHGwtE-00041-00009084-00009281": "second thing we saw was that the apps", "d2fchiHGwtE-00042-00009282-00009473": "are a child and the third thing is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00043-00009474-00009703": "security is always falling behind DevOps", "d2fchiHGwtE-00044-00009704-00009956": "so if you want to make new security to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00045-00009957-00010283": "be scaled with apps so you're saying", "d2fchiHGwtE-00046-00010284-00010531": "level up the security apps piece to the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00047-00010532-00010766": "DevOps pace so DevOps is kind of pushing", "d2fchiHGwtE-00048-00010767-00010859": "things really fast", "d2fchiHGwtE-00049-00010860-00011096": "you mentioned cloud comes a new way I", "d2fchiHGwtE-00050-00011097-00011273": "mean I remember the conversations around", "d2fchiHGwtE-00051-00011274-00011474": "software-defined data center Brian that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00052-00011475-00011708": "was the Holy Grail for the on-premises", "d2fchiHGwtE-00053-00011709-00011912": "activity was gonna put some software", "d2fchiHGwtE-00054-00011913-00012121": "around the storage and virtualization", "d2fchiHGwtE-00055-00012122-00012349": "we're done yeah in comes the cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00056-00012350-00012537": "change the game on", "d2fchiHGwtE-00057-00012538-00012771": "Hadoop ecosystem change the game on the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00058-00012772-00013044": "on-premises ecosystem so what is it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00059-00013044-00013251": "actually done differently where is it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00060-00013252-00013425": "going where's that where's the game", "d2fchiHGwtE-00061-00013426-00013635": "happening now for security with kind of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00062-00013636-00013847": "because software is key to it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00063-00013847-00014085": "what do you see it yeah we definitely", "d2fchiHGwtE-00064-00014086-00014291": "see that I mean DevOps is doing such a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00065-00014293-00014421": "great job in the public cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00066-00014422-00014625": "I mean DevOps is just there they're", "d2fchiHGwtE-00067-00014626-00014796": "really doing a great job with the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00068-00014797-00015041": "tooling the teamwork the you know", "d2fchiHGwtE-00069-00015043-00015230": "automation aspects in traditional", "d2fchiHGwtE-00070-00015231-00015372": "security has always had a little bit of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00071-00015372-00015615": "a lag to that and in the cloud that that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00072-00015616-00015755": "distance is much greater than ever has", "d2fchiHGwtE-00073-00015756-00015954": "before you know so the security teams", "d2fchiHGwtE-00074-00015955-00016088": "particular we do which is network", "d2fchiHGwtE-00075-00016090-00016400": "security they are struggling and so we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00076-00016401-00016665": "we focus on providing them a really good", "d2fchiHGwtE-00077-00016666-00016854": "platform for that and that platform", "d2fchiHGwtE-00078-00016855-00017069": "includes the firewall so we are building", "d2fchiHGwtE-00079-00017070-00017289": "a cloud based firewall that goes in the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00080-00017290-00017502": "customers premise it's all structured", "d2fchiHGwtE-00081-00017503-00017622": "around a controller so we have a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00082-00017623-00017775": "cloud-based controller that manages the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00083-00017776-00017958": "firewall gives them their central place", "d2fchiHGwtE-00084-00017959-00018216": "to configure things and also that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00085-00018217-00018339": "controller is very aware of the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00086-00018340-00018657": "applications so we're keen on giving", "d2fchiHGwtE-00087-00018658-00018909": "them that cloud like experience with a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00088-00018910-00019038": "vendor like us that comes over the top", "d2fchiHGwtE-00089-00019039-00019260": "and it can provide that capability as", "d2fchiHGwtE-00090-00019261-00019461": "they grow and the status of the product", "d2fchiHGwtE-00091-00019462-00019746": "is what shipping yeah this is a service", "d2fchiHGwtE-00092-00019747-00020091": "what's its nightly product so last week", "d2fchiHGwtE-00093-00020092-00020358": "we did launch we announced our funding", "d2fchiHGwtE-00094-00020359-00020519": "and we launched the availability of the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00095-00020520-00020814": "product and it is built as assessed so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00096-00020815-00021044": "the controller is a SAS model the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00097-00021045-00021206": "customer does own the firewall it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00098-00021207-00021381": "where a software company so the software", "d2fchiHGwtE-00099-00021382-00021522": "goes into their their their cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00100-00021523-00021753": "premise and it has all the services that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00101-00021754-00021933": "they need for protecting their network", "d2fchiHGwtE-00102-00021934-00022224": "edge so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00103-00022225-00022452": "what are the finer aspects what are the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00104-00022453-00022704": "real differences of network security in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00105-00022705-00022887": "the cloud relative to traditional", "d2fchiHGwtE-00106-00022888-00023154": "network security yeah so what we saw was", "d2fchiHGwtE-00107-00023155-00023472": "that the enterprise's try to bring their", "d2fchiHGwtE-00108-00023473-00023730": "own Prem evander to the cloud bill just", "d2fchiHGwtE-00109-00023731-00023922": "boxes and as you said a software-defined", "d2fchiHGwtE-00110-00023923-00024171": "environment you need to bring up", "d2fchiHGwtE-00111-00024172-00024411": "something more so what we do is we bring", "d2fchiHGwtE-00112-00024412-00024603": "the whole lifecycle and three or", "d2fchiHGwtE-00113-00024604-00024864": "elements so that is visibility if you do", "d2fchiHGwtE-00114-00024865-00025077": "the inventory of the apps across your", "d2fchiHGwtE-00115-00025078-00025317": "account across your regions across the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00116-00025318-00025544": "cloud even and second thing is how to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00117-00025545-00025808": "plumb your cell in the path and how to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00118-00025810-00026049": "build an unified enforcement solution", "d2fchiHGwtE-00119-00026050-00026280": "which is what we call a firewall so and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00120-00026281-00026527": "built on three principles cloud native", "d2fchiHGwtE-00121-00026529-00026889": "unification and performance and the the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00122-00026889-00027020": "purpose of the company when was the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00123-00027022-00027192": "origination how much you get the idea", "d2fchiHGwtE-00124-00027193-00027363": "was it like decided to start a company", "d2fchiHGwtE-00125-00027364-00027660": "what was the motivation yeah the big", "d2fchiHGwtE-00126-00027661-00027849": "motivation was that again we talked a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00127-00027850-00028050": "lot us to Mertz and we saw the cloud is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00128-00028051-00028386": "real but security is a big impediment to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00129-00028387-00028545": "the public or adoption and that's why we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00130-00028545-00028713": "have this conference here as well and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00131-00028714-00028956": "then we notice the network security is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00132-00028957-00029183": "not scaling in the cloud we like the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00133-00029185-00029583": "problem be on a team our team has the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00134-00029583-00029771": "networking background security", "d2fchiHGwtE-00135-00029772-00029913": "background and the cloud background and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00136-00029914-00030069": "we like the problem you like the team", "d2fchiHGwtE-00137-00030070-00030219": "and we said ok let's attack this problem", "d2fchiHGwtE-00138-00030220-00030377": "and go out to the market so the blocker", "d2fchiHGwtE-00139-00030379-00030620": "scale right and agility", "d2fchiHGwtE-00140-00030622-00030977": "ok so in a couple of like Cisco is not", "d2fchiHGwtE-00141-00030979-00031185": "solving this problem yeah so what they", "d2fchiHGwtE-00142-00031186-00031299": "did was that they tried to bring the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00143-00031300-00031575": "appliances to the cloud in a virtual", "d2fchiHGwtE-00144-00031576-00031779": "form factor so in but in this new world", "d2fchiHGwtE-00145-00031780-00032114": "of the cloud getting sprawl Giles at", "d2fchiHGwtE-00146-00032116-00032436": "agile you need kind of centralized", "d2fchiHGwtE-00147-00032437-00032846": "control model to secure this new logical", "d2fchiHGwtE-00148-00032847-00032987": "parameter", "d2fchiHGwtE-00149-00032988-00033173": "bring up lines there plans to secure the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00150-00033174-00033359": "perimeter you need to have a more here", "d2fchiHGwtE-00151-00033360-00033584": "four bounces around yeah right whether", "d2fchiHGwtE-00152-00033585-00033743": "whether it's physical or virtual yeah", "d2fchiHGwtE-00153-00033744-00033914": "yeah exactly that that's the time in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00154-00033915-00034064": "with wit Vishal's pointing out to is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00155-00034065-00034316": "that we want one aspect of what we do is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00156-00034317-00034541": "that there's this super elegance to that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00157-00034542-00034754": "day zero you can just click a button and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00158-00034755-00034868": "we deploy the gateway through the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00159-00034869-00035033": "controller and that gateway is your", "d2fchiHGwtE-00160-00035034-00035219": "firewall it's right there I mean it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00161-00035220-00035447": "almost instantaneous so that even that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00162-00035448-00035615": "level reflects the cloud native", "d2fchiHGwtE-00163-00035616-00035819": "capabilities and that that really gets", "d2fchiHGwtE-00164-00035820-00035987": "people excited because the alternative", "d2fchiHGwtE-00165-00035988-00036248": "is they they gradually have to go and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00166-00036249-00036464": "you know get the license and build it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00167-00036465-00036668": "and you know build their their functions", "d2fchiHGwtE-00168-00036669-00036845": "to scale it and we we handle all that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00169-00036846-00037235": "and I get why the the hardware box model", "d2fchiHGwtE-00170-00037236-00037484": "doesn't scale yeah why doesn't the sort", "d2fchiHGwtE-00171-00037485-00037724": "of software-defined virtual appliance", "d2fchiHGwtE-00172-00037725-00038030": "scale yeah yeah well the the the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00173-00038031-00038264": "background is that they a lot of we we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00174-00038265-00038420": "see a couple competitors I mean we see", "d2fchiHGwtE-00175-00038421-00038633": "the the classic kind of ng firewall", "d2fchiHGwtE-00176-00038634-00038861": "players and we see the cloud native", "d2fchiHGwtE-00177-00038862-00039068": "capabilities on the cloud native side", "d2fchiHGwtE-00178-00039069-00039299": "they they made efforts to get into a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00179-00039300-00039437": "virtual form factor but it's still", "d2fchiHGwtE-00180-00039438-00039737": "basically a box it's a VM form factor", "d2fchiHGwtE-00181-00039738-00040073": "and it's it's the instrumentation for in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00182-00040074-00040334": "a cloud environment it's it's not it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00183-00040335-00040508": "subpar and there's still a lot of kind", "d2fchiHGwtE-00184-00040509-00040676": "of manual effort to get these things up", "d2fchiHGwtE-00185-00040677-00041015": "and running the plumbing it's not I mean", "d2fchiHGwtE-00186-00041016-00041231": "the user experience is very cool it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00187-00041232-00041402": "really bring your own box as opposed", "d2fchiHGwtE-00188-00041403-00041612": "yeah it's to be a solid form factor", "d2fchiHGwtE-00189-00041613-00041780": "there were security we heard yesterday", "d2fchiHGwtE-00190-00041781-00042062": "at the partner event I attended I heard", "d2fchiHGwtE-00191-00042063-00042239": "the folks from Amazon up there and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00192-00042240-00042347": "they're getting serious about this", "d2fchiHGwtE-00193-00042348-00042506": "because they see the big enterprise", "d2fchiHGwtE-00194-00042507-00042686": "opportunity on channel marketing all", "d2fchiHGwtE-00195-00042687-00042845": "kinds of new thing but network security", "d2fchiHGwtE-00196-00042846-00043073": "kind of has that same vibe that DevOps", "d2fchiHGwtE-00197-00043074-00043262": "had which was you're gonna you have", "d2fchiHGwtE-00198-00043263-00043451": "different consumption mechanisms that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00199-00043452-00043640": "customers are buying services the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00200-00043641-00043931": "pricing is different the scale is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00201-00043932-00044054": "different", "d2fchiHGwtE-00202-00044055-00044399": "you have policy api's so is pretty very", "d2fchiHGwtE-00203-00044400-00044708": "cloud native our customers ready for", "d2fchiHGwtE-00204-00044709-00045017": "that or is your control or Baltics", "d2fchiHGwtE-00205-00045018-00045302": "control or the gateway drug to the cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00206-00045303-00045554": "because so to speak or because certainly", "d2fchiHGwtE-00207-00045555-00045730": "if all those things are changing yeah", "d2fchiHGwtE-00208-00045731-00045880": "that means the old just can't be", "d2fchiHGwtE-00209-00045881-00046099": "retrofitted to the new you got to have", "d2fchiHGwtE-00210-00046100-00046418": "something from scratch and not a lot of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00211-00046419-00046552": "people are lifting and shifting beyond", "d2fchiHGwtE-00212-00046553-00046727": "infrastructures of service that's easy", "d2fchiHGwtE-00213-00046728-00046871": "that kind of replicate in the cloud but", "d2fchiHGwtE-00214-00046872-00047015": "when you get into some of the nuances of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00215-00047016-00047233": "like the apps like you mentioning these", "d2fchiHGwtE-00216-00047234-00047446": "new dynamics have to be pure play", "d2fchiHGwtE-00217-00047447-00047798": "features correctly is the yours are you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00218-00047799-00047971": "a solution to that are you a gateway to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00219-00047972-00048221": "that role where it's the controller", "d2fchiHGwtE-00220-00048222-00048362": "right yeah so Viera solutions for", "d2fchiHGwtE-00221-00048363-00048587": "example as I said like we do the full", "d2fchiHGwtE-00222-00048588-00048779": "lifecycle we have a controller will", "d2fchiHGwtE-00223-00048780-00048962": "discover all your apps so an enterprise", "d2fchiHGwtE-00224-00048963-00049145": "can have apps across your accounts", "d2fchiHGwtE-00225-00049146-00049424": "across your cloud even and we discover", "d2fchiHGwtE-00226-00049425-00049652": "all the apps second thing is once you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00227-00049653-00049823": "discover the apps how do you put", "d2fchiHGwtE-00228-00049824-00050071": "yourself in the path of security and we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00229-00050072-00050258": "do that automatically and third thing is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00230-00050259-00050486": "enforcement for that we have two poor", "d2fchiHGwtE-00231-00050487-00050668": "engines as I said a proprietary", "d2fchiHGwtE-00232-00050669-00050821": "dellaplane which we call a cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00233-00050822-00051068": "firewall from Baltics and second is our", "d2fchiHGwtE-00234-00051069-00051220": "cloud controller which sees everything", "d2fchiHGwtE-00235-00051221-00051413": "so it's a global view of the entire", "d2fchiHGwtE-00236-00051414-00051631": "enterprise infrastructure in your", "d2fchiHGwtE-00237-00051632-00051802": "marketing documentation you talk about", "d2fchiHGwtE-00238-00051803-00052004": "the trade-offs that people have to make", "d2fchiHGwtE-00239-00052004-00052195": "between security and agility yeah that's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00240-00052196-00052426": "always been a trade-off do you solve", "d2fchiHGwtE-00241-00052427-00052657": "that problem and if so yeah so again", "d2fchiHGwtE-00242-00052658-00052867": "when you saw the customer to talk to and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00243-00052869-00052997": "then when they bring their watch our", "d2fchiHGwtE-00244-00052998-00053210": "plans on appliances to the cloud then", "d2fchiHGwtE-00245-00053211-00053488": "the two choices they have one is that as", "d2fchiHGwtE-00246-00053489-00053819": "agile but then you cannot secure or", "d2fchiHGwtE-00247-00053820-00053996": "using the flash model so you kind of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00248-00053997-00054176": "insecure or naked we call it the other", "d2fchiHGwtE-00249-00054177-00054329": "option is that you must have word", "d2fchiHGwtE-00250-00054329-00054517": "security source way down so you kind of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00251-00054519-00054674": "become a secure and rigid so every time", "d2fchiHGwtE-00252-00054675-00054904": "we have a new app and you VPC you open a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00253-00054905-00055180": "ticket and you install a new firewall so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00254-00055182-00055361": "what we are giving the third option", "d2fchiHGwtE-00255-00055362-00055522": "because the both the options are give", "d2fchiHGwtE-00256-00055523-00055772": "possible today are bad choices so we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00257-00055773-00055937": "give you a third option which is agile", "d2fchiHGwtE-00258-00055938-00056182": "and secure and that's what centralized", "d2fchiHGwtE-00259-00056183-00056375": "controller and a faulty firewall give", "d2fchiHGwtE-00260-00056376-00056417": "you that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00261-00056419-00056613": "Michelle for shaumbra I want to get your", "d2fchiHGwtE-00262-00056614-00056934": "thoughts on why you guys suck he's a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00263-00056935-00057155": "devil's advocate you guys just start up", "d2fchiHGwtE-00264-00057157-00057288": "although sorry was actually doing well", "d2fchiHGwtE-00265-00057289-00057498": "in the cloud environment because I", "d2fchiHGwtE-00266-00057499-00057663": "haven't being a skeptic trying to shoot", "d2fchiHGwtE-00267-00057664-00057801": "my own own narrative here but the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00268-00057802-00057957": "reality is you guys are young company", "d2fchiHGwtE-00269-00057958-00058095": "you want to get the attention the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00270-00058096-00058323": "enterprise our customers what's it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00271-00058324-00058446": "what's it what's the pitch", "d2fchiHGwtE-00272-00058447-00058616": "why you guys what what's your", "d2fchiHGwtE-00273-00058617-00058800": "backgrounds pedigrees the backgrounds", "d2fchiHGwtE-00274-00058801-00058902": "you guys bring to the table to the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00275-00058903-00059091": "software talk about why you guys what's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00276-00059091-00059262": "the differentiator yeah so in time a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00277-00059263-00059487": "team I would say there are three core", "d2fchiHGwtE-00278-00059488-00059816": "pillars networking security and cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00279-00059817-00060017": "right so this team has built a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00280-00060019-00060228": "billion-dollar product line in deployed", "d2fchiHGwtE-00281-00060229-00060447": "in thousand enterprises and there are", "d2fchiHGwtE-00282-00060448-00060732": "two core expertise in the initial team", "d2fchiHGwtE-00283-00060733-00060960": "was building fast performance pipelines", "d2fchiHGwtE-00284-00060961-00061161": "second thing is decoupling the control", "d2fchiHGwtE-00285-00061162-00061287": "plane yellow plane I mentioned some of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00286-00061288-00061437": "that so those are some of the aspects", "d2fchiHGwtE-00287-00061438-00061614": "and then you built a team around network", "d2fchiHGwtE-00288-00061615-00061839": "expertise security expertise and cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00289-00061840-00061994": "expertise has a Jennifer for just", "d2fchiHGwtE-00290-00061995-00062121": "multiple time", "d2fchiHGwtE-00291-00062122-00062319": "fix the team team is right now 20 people", "d2fchiHGwtE-00292-00062320-00062529": "20 people and you get just raised 14", "d2fchiHGwtE-00293-00062529-00062766": "million over 40 or 40 million raised and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00294-00062766-00062973": "we announced that last week yeah right", "d2fchiHGwtE-00295-00062974-00063171": "gratulations you know the backgrounds of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00296-00063172-00063501": "the team members yeah I mean there's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00297-00063502-00063854": "there's cisco juniper paul to Google", "d2fchiHGwtE-00298-00063855-00064304": "cloud 49 CMV f-14s there's it's kind of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00299-00064305-00064527": "that that bench strength of security in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00300-00064528-00064725": "a networking and cloud and then I think", "d2fchiHGwtE-00301-00064726-00064899": "the other component to that is that we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00302-00064900-00065103": "all come from a common denominator of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00303-00065104-00065409": "building like hands on building shipping", "d2fchiHGwtE-00304-00065410-00065516": "and marketing products that are", "d2fchiHGwtE-00305-00065517-00065682": "transformative and so that that's also", "d2fchiHGwtE-00306-00065683-00065862": "excited we see doesn't say this is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00307-00065863-00066072": "clearly transformative for this you know", "d2fchiHGwtE-00308-00066073-00066246": "big market opportunity to help customers", "d2fchiHGwtE-00309-00066247-00066367": "and we're", "d2fchiHGwtE-00310-00066368-00066537": "we're like you know this the cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00311-00066538-00066703": "really get and sounds like to me you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00312-00066704-00066904": "guys have a real holistic systems view", "d2fchiHGwtE-00313-00066905-00067117": "of the world because I mean the cloud is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00314-00067118-00067350": "essentially an operating system or you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00315-00067351-00067518": "know large distributed computer and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00316-00067519-00067736": "decentralized with crypto and blockchain", "d2fchiHGwtE-00317-00067737-00067962": "it's the system thinking that's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00318-00067963-00068098": "interesting right you guys have like", "d2fchiHGwtE-00319-00068099-00068248": "that because if you know the network's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00320-00068249-00068511": "gotta know the system yeah and you need", "d2fchiHGwtE-00321-00068512-00068661": "to get into the apps you get an unsent", "d2fchiHGwtE-00322-00068662-00068781": "that middle layer that's developing with", "d2fchiHGwtE-00323-00068782-00069016": "kubernetes and containers with cloud", "d2fchiHGwtE-00324-00069017-00069334": "native that's developing really fast so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00325-00069335-00069646": "to see that end to end is more of a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00326-00069647-00069918": "systems kind of mindset bloggers are", "d2fchiHGwtE-00327-00069919-00070048": "lacking that because they've outsourced", "d2fchiHGwtE-00328-00070049-00070498": "everything to global s eyes and now they", "d2fchiHGwtE-00329-00070499-00070765": "got to rebuild Capital One CAC so said", "d2fchiHGwtE-00330-00070766-00070972": "we're investing everything building", "d2fchiHGwtE-00331-00070973-00071223": "we're building more so that builders", "d2fchiHGwtE-00332-00071224-00071404": "their their systems guys what's your", "d2fchiHGwtE-00333-00071405-00071566": "reaction to that yeah so basically we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00334-00071567-00071706": "also noticed that lot of the enterprise", "d2fchiHGwtE-00335-00071707-00071988": "we talked to told that they lost point", "d2fchiHGwtE-00336-00071989-00072135": "products what we're building the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00337-00072136-00072336": "platform so if we starting off with the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00338-00072337-00072543": "few services but the platform so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00339-00072544-00072778": "holistic platform to do the full network", "d2fchiHGwtE-00340-00072779-00073009": "security in the public cloud that's what", "d2fchiHGwtE-00341-00073010-00073090": "we are working towards", "d2fchiHGwtE-00342-00073091-00073246": "what's the differentiate why you guys", "d2fchiHGwtE-00343-00073247-00073423": "what's what's the what's the main value", "d2fchiHGwtE-00344-00073424-00073566": "proposition then you guys bring to the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00345-00073567-00073609": "table", "d2fchiHGwtE-00346-00073610-00073723": "correct a meaning for the customer", "d2fchiHGwtE-00347-00073724-00073869": "correct the main value proposition is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00348-00073870-00074079": "like the team can build it and second", "d2fchiHGwtE-00349-00074080-00074236": "thing is we have taken up cloud little", "d2fchiHGwtE-00350-00074237-00074521": "approach to this problem we are building", "d2fchiHGwtE-00351-00074522-00074766": "for the cloud and we are building using", "d2fchiHGwtE-00352-00074767-00074898": "the cloud leader principles so you just", "d2fchiHGwtE-00353-00074899-00075004": "went through a array so all these", "d2fchiHGwtE-00354-00075005-00075172": "answers to the questions are fresh in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00355-00075173-00075207": "your mind", "d2fchiHGwtE-00356-00075208-00075381": "but Brian talked about a large market I", "d2fchiHGwtE-00357-00075382-00075547": "mean yeah help us understand it because", "d2fchiHGwtE-00358-00075548-00075693": "the market is enormous I was like a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00359-00075694-00075843": "hundred billion dollars or whatever it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00360-00075844-00076009": "is but it's so fragmented there's so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00361-00076010-00076171": "many different segments how do you guys", "d2fchiHGwtE-00362-00076172-00076459": "look at the Tam and then the serve", "d2fchiHGwtE-00363-00076460-00076638": "market you know for you guys that you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00364-00076639-00076709": "can go after", "d2fchiHGwtE-00365-00076710-00076997": "our goal is to protect their their data", "d2fchiHGwtE-00366-00076998-00077183": "center this new data center basically", "d2fchiHGwtE-00367-00077184-00077309": "everything that going in and out of the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00368-00077310-00077498": "data center on the network side that's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00369-00077499-00077753": "our focus and and we even mentioned some", "d2fchiHGwtE-00370-00077754-00078035": "of these services but we in the product", "d2fchiHGwtE-00371-00078036-00078173": "we're shipping right now it does", "d2fchiHGwtE-00372-00078174-00078371": "decryption of TLS traffic it does", "d2fchiHGwtE-00373-00078372-00078572": "firewall it does intrusion prevention it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00374-00078573-00078845": "does laughs so it has this and more so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00375-00078846-00079094": "there's a set of things that the when we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00376-00079095-00079379": "talk to the the customers will say my my", "d2fchiHGwtE-00377-00079380-00079544": "blueprint for the cloud is like the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00378-00079545-00079595": "creme", "d2fchiHGwtE-00379-00079596-00079721": "I have to stack all these things", "d2fchiHGwtE-00380-00079722-00079877": "together you know risk and risk of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00381-00079878-00080057": "security says you have to emulate that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00382-00080058-00080189": "environment it's worked well here", "d2fchiHGwtE-00383-00080190-00080384": "make it happen out there and so that's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00384-00080385-00080570": "where you see people getting a little", "d2fchiHGwtE-00385-00080571-00080789": "bit amped up it's hard to do that and so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00386-00080790-00080972": "we have a platform that consolidates", "d2fchiHGwtE-00387-00080973-00081128": "that really well and knows the system", "d2fchiHGwtE-00388-00081129-00081371": "level things that Tom was mentioning but", "d2fchiHGwtE-00389-00081372-00081710": "it is covering a lot of space but we we", "d2fchiHGwtE-00390-00081711-00081896": "are very optimistic we're making good", "d2fchiHGwtE-00391-00081897-00082052": "rounds would subside form approach", "d2fchiHGwtE-00392-00082053-00082289": "versus buying six products exactly it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00393-00082290-00082505": "an old Asian story connect well what's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00394-00082506-00082640": "the most important story that needs to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00395-00082641-00082823": "be told in the security industry today", "d2fchiHGwtE-00396-00082824-00083006": "that in your opinion what do you think", "d2fchiHGwtE-00397-00083007-00083270": "is that that customers should know about", "d2fchiHGwtE-00398-00083271-00083606": "that the media end or the industry", "d2fchiHGwtE-00399-00083607-00083843": "should be discussing yeah the main thing", "d2fchiHGwtE-00400-00083844-00084158": "is that we talk about DevOps the DevOps", "d2fchiHGwtE-00401-00084159-00084389": "is very agile so one thing is the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00402-00084390-00084509": "concept security slowing me down", "d2fchiHGwtE-00403-00084510-00084746": "security has to be agile in space in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00404-00084747-00084899": "network security we have heard in the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00405-00084900-00085157": "past slows it down so that's in the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00406-00085158-00085355": "cloud world the main reason people go in", "d2fchiHGwtE-00407-00085356-00085493": "the cloud is because of the agility and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00408-00085494-00085715": "network security should not stop that", "d2fchiHGwtE-00409-00085716-00085979": "and that the security slowing down yeah", "d2fchiHGwtE-00410-00085980-00086183": "and we don't want that become a deep", "d2fchiHGwtE-00411-00086184-00086408": "bottleneck for mass adoption I mean", "d2fchiHGwtE-00412-00086409-00086534": "we're seeing that more and more and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00413-00086535-00086741": "that's in that problem statement is it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00414-00086742-00086942": "there's a lot of ops angles to this it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00415-00086943-00087206": "understanding like multi a-z deploys and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00416-00087207-00087395": "the transit gateway the new you know the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00417-00087396-00087551": "new transit gateway from Amazon and how", "d2fchiHGwtE-00418-00087552-00087710": "does this all work together and we're on", "d2fchiHGwtE-00419-00087711-00087823": "top of that from the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00420-00087824-00087991": "security perspective worrying about the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00421-00087992-00088216": "show here Amazon's inaugural reinforced", "d2fchiHGwtE-00422-00088217-00088435": "not it's not a summit they this summits", "d2fchiHGwtE-00423-00088436-00088701": "are regional reinvents this is its own", "d2fchiHGwtE-00424-00088702-00088782": "name", "d2fchiHGwtE-00425-00088783-00088981": "just like reinvents different for the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00426-00088982-00089173": "customers reinvent this is reinforced", "d2fchiHGwtE-00427-00089174-00089382": "pretty important pretty strategic for", "d2fchiHGwtE-00428-00089383-00089566": "Amazon Web Services what do you guys", "d2fchiHGwtE-00429-00089567-00089767": "think yeah it's great I mean we have", "d2fchiHGwtE-00430-00089768-00089953": "been using the alternatives like plans", "d2fchiHGwtE-00431-00089954-00090438": "it they're a multi ad support the s3", "d2fchiHGwtE-00432-00090439-00090706": "buckets we use all the infrastructure", "d2fchiHGwtE-00433-00090707-00090949": "provide so it's always good to know what", "d2fchiHGwtE-00434-00090950-00091105": "they are doing because like in the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00435-00091106-00091255": "reinvent around transit gateway and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00436-00091256-00091474": "being incorporate that enable product so", "d2fchiHGwtE-00437-00091475-00091630": "that's why you want to be always ahead", "d2fchiHGwtE-00438-00091631-00091765": "of what they are announcing and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00439-00091766-00091903": "incorporate that and giving your", "d2fchiHGwtE-00440-00091904-00092056": "customers what they need as a whole", "d2fchiHGwtE-00441-00092057-00092200": "solution so Brian here running the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00442-00092201-00092413": "product chief product officer what's on", "d2fchiHGwtE-00443-00092414-00092886": "the roadmap", "d2fchiHGwtE-00444-00092887-00093144": "is your request coming in and their", "d2fchiHGwtE-00445-00093145-00093292": "services you just bang them out no big", "d2fchiHGwtE-00446-00093293-00093826": "deal so easy 2008 did a year Amazon does", "d2fchiHGwtE-00447-00093827-00094006": "it you could do sure a couple hundred a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00448-00094007-00094107": "year no problem", "d2fchiHGwtE-00449-00094108-00094288": "there's be a couple of things one one is", "d2fchiHGwtE-00450-00094289-00094492": "that we we will continue to expand to", "d2fchiHGwtE-00451-00094493-00094672": "you know other clouds because there are", "d2fchiHGwtE-00452-00094673-00094869": "customers want you know that but it's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00453-00094870-00095088": "also just the about more more", "d2fchiHGwtE-00454-00095089-00095236": "capabilities so they're they're seeing", "d2fchiHGwtE-00455-00095237-00095422": "what we can do today there's a lot it", "d2fchiHGwtE-00456-00095423-00095674": "can do and they're there with us like", "d2fchiHGwtE-00457-00095675-00095779": "they're on the journey with us and", "d2fchiHGwtE-00458-00095780-00096088": "saying we want more help and you know", "d2fchiHGwtE-00459-00096089-00096292": "the show is an example of that I mean a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00460-00096293-00096456": "cloud is becoming you know more than a", "d2fchiHGwtE-00461-00096457-00096610": "thing and Security's getting emphasized", "d2fchiHGwtE-00462-00096611-00096793": "you know literally it's emphasized here", "d2fchiHGwtE-00463-00096794-00097042": "and so we're happy to help our customers", "d2fchiHGwtE-00464-00097043-00097176": "along well you guys are launched what's", "d2fchiHGwtE-00465-00097177-00097351": "the priority actually hiring what kind", "d2fchiHGwtE-00466-00097352-00097516": "of culture do you have what are some you", "d2fchiHGwtE-00467-00097517-00097669": "need share would put a plug for the", "d2fchiHGwtE-00468-00097670-00097816": "company in real quick so in terms of", "d2fchiHGwtE-00469-00097817-00097978": "hiring the initially the most of hiring", "d2fchiHGwtE-00470-00097979-00098119": "well or injuring building the product", "d2fchiHGwtE-00471-00098120-00098380": "because there's the core engine but now", "d2fchiHGwtE-00472-00098381-00098485": "we are expanding into the go-to-market", "d2fchiHGwtE-00473-00098486-00098794": "team we have sales marketing and we're", "d2fchiHGwtE-00474-00098795-00098941": "going to expand on both the sites like", "d2fchiHGwtE-00475-00098942-00099271": "sell and build more and sell more yeah", "d2fchiHGwtE-00476-00099272-00099444": "get the revenue man", "d2fchiHGwtE-00477-00099445-00099705": "congratulations not startup good job", "d2fchiHGwtE-00478-00099706-00099878": "well done thanks for coming on the cube", "d2fchiHGwtE-00479-00099879-00100125": "experiments outtakes launching but new", "d2fchiHGwtE-00480-00100126-00100278": "product out of stealth with funding", "d2fchiHGwtE-00481-00100279-00100550": "getting off the off the runway here at", "d2fchiHGwtE-00482-00100551-00100757": "Amazon Webster's reinvents cube coverage", "d2fchiHGwtE-00483-00100758-00101006": "I'm Jeffrey devil anthe Stevens or more", "d2fchiHGwtE-00484-00101007-00101268": "after this short break"}}, {"audio_id": "d2ki7KaPfm0", "text": {"d2ki7KaPfm0-00000-00000010-00000221": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00001-00000222-00000606": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00002-00000607-00003034": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00003-00003035-00003339": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00004-00003340-00004183": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00005-00004184-00007806": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00006-00007808-00008051": "thank you", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00007-00008052-00008803": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00008-00008804-00011741": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00009-00011742-00011860": "come on", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00010-00011861-00015311": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00011-00015312-00015743": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00012-00015744-00019108": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00013-00019109-00019231": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00014-00019232-00022367": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00015-00022368-00022907": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00016-00022908-00025558": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00017-00025559-00025632": "Christmas", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00018-00025633-00028889": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00019-00028889-00029338": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00020-00029339-00030179": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00021-00030180-00030283": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00022-00030283-00034145": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00023-00034146-00034666": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00024-00034667-00037840": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00025-00037841-00038452": "foreign", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00026-00038453-00040961": "[Music]", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00027-00040962-00041000": "thank you", "d2ki7KaPfm0-00028-00041001-00041982": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "d2lm3K7P8qE", "text": {"d2lm3K7P8qE-00000-00000000-00000264": "foreign", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00001-00000265-00001543": "[Music]", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00002-00001544-00001817": "contributions and memberships", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00003-00001818-00002267": "so you can call me friend race I mean it", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00004-00002268-00002447": "was my nickname", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00005-00002448-00002718": "for in RAC", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00006-00002719-00003005": "and I'm one of the Ubuntu membership", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00007-00003006-00003142": "board", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00008-00003143-00003479": "uh luckily I'm", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00009-00003479-00003743": "managed to extend my United terms for", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00010-00003744-00004067": "another two years I just been re-elected", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00011-00004068-00004336": "as a Ubuntu membership board", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00012-00004337-00004583": "so about me", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00013-00004584-00004835": "so from the past I was around the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00014-00004836-00005149": "engineer at the one of the agency", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00015-00005150-00005518": "Malaysian agency which managing the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00016-00005519-00005722": "ICT", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00017-00005723-00006059": "and I'm also the advisors and consultant", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00018-00006060-00006431": "for government agency related to OSS", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00019-00006431-00006820": "I'm a part of it I mean I move on to be", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00020-00006822-00007037": "a business development and a project", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00021-00007038-00007360": "manager for a few private companies that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00022-00007361-00007798": "involve with governments projects", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00023-00007800-00008009": "so this is uh some of my previous", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00024-00008009-00008219": "employer", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00025-00008220-00008741": "and currently I'm still a Ubuntu members", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00026-00008742-00009091": "since 20 2008", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00027-00009092-00009521": "and like I said just now I'm", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00028-00009522-00009749": "still lucky to be on board as a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00029-00009750-00010006": "membership board and I started being", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00030-00010007-00010306": "with him a machine board since 2012. I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00031-00010307-00010409": "feel like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00032-00010410-00010603": "a very old", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00033-00010604-00011021": "persons being with the with being with", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00034-00011022-00011135": "you guys", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00035-00011136-00011351": "and still involved with a various", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00036-00011352-00011591": "project with Ubuntu primarily focused on", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00037-00011592-00011837": "community educations government and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00038-00011838-00011951": "Enterprise", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00039-00011952-00012167": "so I'm a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00040-00012168-00012377": "I'm also one of the members of the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00041-00012378-00012538": "general foundations", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00042-00012539-00012857": "and a part of it I'm also an organizing", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00043-00012858-00013066": "committee members for your book on and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00044-00013067-00013258": "goodness sesame", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00045-00013259-00013565": "and as of now I still coordinate and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00046-00013566-00013822": "lead the Ubuntu Malaysia local team and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00047-00013823-00014044": "Malaysia open State User Group", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00048-00014045-00014266": "and a part of it my daily job is", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00049-00014268-00014494": "basically writing and operates my own", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00050-00014495-00014783": "startups", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00051-00014784-00014944": "okay", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00052-00014945-00015191": "so uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00053-00015191-00015371": "may I know", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00054-00015372-00015641": "from the floor is these are all from", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00055-00015641-00015941": "Ubuntu Community or just coming to be", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00056-00015941-00016391": "joined into the Ubuntu event", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00057-00016392-00016672": "anyone anyone on the floor he saw all", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00058-00016673-00016997": "the OSS users or I mean like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00059-00016998-00017315": "from the different operating system as", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00060-00017316-00017441": "well", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00061-00017442-00017722": "okay no worries okay the contributions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00062-00017723-00018100": "so who contributed contributed now", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00063-00018101-00018311": "so there is a company's interested in", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00064-00018312-00018497": "developments of product to fit their", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00065-00018498-00018653": "industry needs", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00066-00018654-00018875": "company with profit from supporting", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00067-00018876-00019097": "their open source program", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00068-00019098-00019283": "volunteer professionals doing", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00069-00019284-00019541": "development in their free times for fine", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00070-00019542-00019780": "or to advance their career", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00071-00019781-00020075": "and there is a hobbies and students who", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00072-00020076-00020483": "enjoy their works so these guys are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00073-00020484-00020843": "basically now currently contributing to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00074-00020844-00021125": "open source I mean like for example like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00075-00021126-00021367": "our principal I mean like the canonical", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00076-00021368-00021767": "so who actively I mean as a main", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00077-00021768-00022030": "contributing to the our Ubuntu projects", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00078-00022031-00022271": "I mean like to make the the software", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00079-00022272-00022547": "runs smoothly on the Securities on the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00080-00022548-00022835": "pictures and everything", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00081-00022836-00023021": "so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00082-00023022-00023344": "most of the communities or the peoples", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00083-00023345-00023603": "on the public it means like thinking how", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00084-00023604-00023908": "we need or how to get involved right", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00085-00023909-00024263": "so they are keep asking why would I want", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00086-00024264-00024353": "to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00087-00024354-00024844": "what can I do and how do I start so this", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00088-00024845-00025258": "is uh some questions that uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00089-00025259-00025486": "flying around in their heads it means", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00090-00025487-00025840": "like yeah what can I do", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00091-00025841-00026267": "right so and a part of it and then what", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00092-00026268-00026596": "I can do is like why I'm need to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00093-00026597-00026711": "contribute", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00094-00026712-00026849": "so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00095-00026850-00027274": "yeah why I need for me if you guys are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00096-00027275-00027562": "why you need to contribute his voice", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00097-00027563-00027881": "for knowledge right so with like this", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00098-00027882-00028127": "conference or the summit you guys can", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00099-00028127-00028420": "gain knowledge", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00100-00028422-00028757": "and then of course you guys can uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00101-00028758-00029002": "making a friends I mean like from for me", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00102-00029004-00029374": "I mean like I just meet all the Ubuntu", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00103-00029375-00029639": "Koreans local at the product last two", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00104-00029639-00029867": "weeks and nice to meet you all and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00105-00029868-00030220": "as for today I also meeting a new uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00106-00030222-00030407": "participant for this conference maybe", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00107-00030408-00030670": "after the I'm finishing my sessions that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00108-00030672-00030851": "we can have a chit chat if you have any", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00109-00030852-00031055": "questions on the community", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00110-00031056-00031318": "and then of course we can have fines", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00111-00031319-00031552": "instead of after we have our friends I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00112-00031554-00031739": "mean like yeah I'm not talking about", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00113-00031739-00032008": "only this circle of friends I mean it's", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00114-00032010-00032177": "like actually", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00115-00032177-00032518": "Ubuntu have make I mean I mean given me", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00116-00032519-00032705": "an experience", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00117-00032706-00032968": "like lifetime experience I mean like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00118-00032969-00033262": "it's not about you can manage to get a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00119-00033263-00033557": "friend in your local I mean a local", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00120-00033558-00033815": "community but you can have your friends", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00121-00033816-00034096": "worldwide I mean when you go Summits or", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00122-00034097-00034265": "you can have a conference you can meet a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00123-00034266-00034552": "new friends and have fun with it and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00124-00034553-00034673": "then of course", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00125-00034674-00034996": "if you like a good contributors or", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00126-00034997-00035261": "something like that this is like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00127-00035262-00035495": "a token for you the kind of positions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00128-00035496-00035717": "for you maybe like the the sponsors", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00129-00035718-00036118": "might flew you to any of the country or", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00130-00036119-00036377": "any regions that you managed to get", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00131-00036378-00036724": "right so like us also managed to be", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00132-00036725-00036995": "sponsored by canonical last two weeks in", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00133-00036996-00037217": "the prep so I have a chance to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00134-00037218-00037555": "sightseeing in the product as well", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00135-00037556-00037996": "another opportunity for the community to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00136-00037997-00038273": "advance in career in Connecticut as well", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00137-00038274-00038579": "so you guys can see because right now", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00138-00038580-00038730": "technical uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00139-00038731-00039071": "opening more posts and you can see on", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00140-00039072-00039209": "the career page", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00141-00039210-00039635": "and then after all those things that you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00142-00039636-00039733": "can make", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00143-00039734-00040049": "your friends into a body I mean because", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00144-00040050-00040385": "like this is one example that babani I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00145-00040386-00040649": "mean like I haven't met him last past a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00146-00040650-00040961": "decade so managed to meet him again in", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00147-00040962-00041309": "Prague so this is uh Me and Bobby and of", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00148-00041310-00041573": "course our founder right Marcia to us so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00149-00041574-00041861": "I met about any in last", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00150-00041862-00042101": "Ubuntu developer Summit which is a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00151-00042102-00042461": "decade ago so then this is basically why", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00152-00042462-00042796": "you need to contribute", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00153-00042797-00042940": "okay", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00154-00042941-00043259": "and then of course just now we are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00155-00043260-00043589": "questioning so what can I do so this is", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00156-00043590-00043840": "basically what can you contribute of", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00157-00043841-00044123": "course uh you can contribute in the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00158-00044124-00044387": "codes right I mean like if among the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00159-00044388-00044765": "flaws is a programmers or everything so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00160-00044766-00044974": "they can contribute to the codes", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00161-00044975-00045239": "and then you can also contribute into", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00162-00045240-00045533": "the bug fixing", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00163-00045534-00045749": "after you do about these things you can", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00164-00045750-00045977": "a part of it you can do the software", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00165-00045978-00046133": "testing", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00166-00046134-00046558": "and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00167-00046559-00046799": "it's not about only technical things", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00168-00046800-00047111": "that you can contribute so basically you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00169-00047112-00047411": "can contribute into the documentation as", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00170-00047412-00047705": "well so there is like a lot of Open", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00171-00047706-00048071": "Source projects out there that need like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00172-00048072-00048252": "a technical", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00173-00048253-00048712": "writings feedbacks or blogs or something", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00174-00048713-00049090": "I mean like uh writing on the projects", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00175-00049091-00049373": "and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00176-00049374-00049657": "this is like another", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00177-00049658-00049936": "key contribution that you can give like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00178-00049937-00050236": "giving the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00179-00050237-00050585": "I mean like improving the UI or the ux", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00180-00050586-00050896": "of the applications on the graphics and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00181-00050897-00051179": "then this is one of basically how you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00182-00051180-00051526": "can support uh Ubuntu communities for", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00183-00051527-00051658": "example", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00184-00051659-00052061": "for supporting me like if we if you join", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00185-00052062-00052252": "the local and then there is some", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00186-00052253-00052513": "problems with the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00187-00052514-00052847": "uh new members that need help so this is", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00188-00052848-00053111": "a part of it that you can contribute it", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00189-00053112-00053338": "means like assisting the new members to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00190-00053339-00053687": "be uh get no well of the open source", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00191-00053688-00053980": "projects especially Ubuntu", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00192-00053982-00054179": "and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00193-00054179-00054400": "but last but not least at least you can", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00194-00054401-00054479": "do", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00195-00054479-00054797": "the promotions right I mean maybe some", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00196-00054798-00054923": "of their", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00197-00054924-00055204": "users on the proprietary softwares and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00198-00055205-00055432": "then you can help to do like the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00199-00055433-00055691": "advocate or enthusiasts of the each of", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00200-00055691-00055999": "the open source project and for this", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00201-00056000-00056350": "conference I mean especially Ubuntu", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00202-00056351-00056729": "as the operating system", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00203-00056729-00056999": "okay so after", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00204-00057000-00057263": "I'm sharing what you can contribute so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00205-00057264-00057563": "of course what is the next step so the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00206-00057564-00057838": "next steps you need to have like a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00207-00057839-00058259": "account in the our portal so a single", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00208-00058260-00058547": "sign on account that you can you need to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00209-00058548-00058741": "have this in order for you to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00210-00058741-00059003": "participate in the middle if you want to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00211-00059004-00059338": "push the codes or you want to report a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00212-00059339-00059561": "box on the Launchpad and everything so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00213-00059562-00059976": "yeah you need to have this account", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00214-00059977-00060304": "then like I said just now I mean like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00215-00060305-00060576": "you can go to this website", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00216-00060577-00060988": "local.ubuntu.com teams it might list all", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00217-00060989-00061235": "the local", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00218-00061236-00061529": "community so basically I will use the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00219-00061529-00061721": "word local I mean local stand for local", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00220-00061722-00062050": "community so from the uh portal that you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00221-00062051-00062482": "can have all uh countries of the local", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00222-00062483-00062704": "that have participate I mean have a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00223-00062705-00062969": "representative so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00224-00062970-00063203": "I am basically the photos is basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00225-00063204-00063413": "where Ubuntu Malaysia logo so I'm a part", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00226-00063414-00063629": "of the I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00227-00063629-00063976": "so you can directly choose and join the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00228-00063977-00064294": "team like I say if you are in the Korean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00229-00064295-00064516": "there is a Korean as well I mean like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00230-00064517-00064744": "the current team listed then you can", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00231-00064745-00064961": "join the team and follow the instruction", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00232-00064962-00065213": "on the LaunchPad", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00233-00065214-00065375": "once you join", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00234-00065376-00065500": "try it out", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00235-00065501-00065885": "try to reach the members of the teams or", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00236-00065886-00066293": "the admin either in Ric mailing list", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00237-00066294-00066694": "oh inside the discourse", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00238-00066695-00067085": "okay uh I mean how to begin right so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00239-00067086-00067193": "basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00240-00067194-00067373": "like I say after you have an account", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00241-00067374-00067631": "everything's you you go and find the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00242-00067632-00067841": "projects that which which project that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00243-00067842-00068026": "you want to contribute", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00244-00068027-00068356": "and then you find the mailing list so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00245-00068357-00068603": "you subscribe to the availing list and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00246-00068604-00068819": "then you'll find the channel I mean like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00247-00068820-00068944": "the RSC Channel", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00248-00068945-00069221": "still currently uh they are commuting", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00249-00069222-00069611": "through ricc but in the last Summit the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00250-00069612-00069911": "community teams from Connecticut are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00251-00069912-00070432": "looking away I mean new methods that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00252-00070433-00070667": "match our currentness", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00253-00070668-00070931": "scenarios I mean like which is the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00254-00070932-00071213": "platform that make life instead of using", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00255-00071214-00071585": "the old school RSC Communications", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00256-00071586-00071938": "and then after you have joined and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00257-00071939-00072185": "you have find the projects then you need", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00258-00072186-00072425": "to feel me like what's up being a part", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00259-00072426-00072653": "of the projects all right I mean either", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00260-00072654-00072875": "you feel comfortable with the kind of", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00261-00072876-00073049": "projects or maybe you need to find", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00262-00073050-00073288": "another project which is more suitable", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00263-00073289-00073511": "for you I mean like if you are a techie", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00264-00073512-00073675": "guy", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00265-00073676-00073979": "then you might goes into the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00266-00073980-00074269": "uh technical", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00267-00074270-00074543": "projects and then if you feel like you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00268-00074544-00074831": "are more like a designer's technical", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00269-00074832-00075149": "writers and everything I mean like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00270-00075150-00075305": "then you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00271-00075306-00075556": "can contribute on that as well after you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00272-00075557-00075761": "have a feel of that and then start", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00273-00075762-00075923": "taking up the tasks and start", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00274-00075924-00076097": "contributings right", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00275-00076098-00076685": "so yeah", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00276-00076686-00077117": "so after you have all", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00277-00077118-00077393": "doing all the contributions I mean it's", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00278-00077394-00077597": "like people like from the community will", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00279-00077598-00077843": "acknowledge about your contributions and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00280-00077844-00077938": "everything", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00281-00077939-00078209": "uh then I take this opportunity as well", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00282-00078210-00078503": "I mean like specifically for the Ubuntu", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00283-00078504-00078749": "projects that you apply for Ubuntu", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00284-00078750-00079073": "memberships so basically we have uh the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00285-00079074-00079367": "memberships", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00286-00079368-00079637": "so the application process which is", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00287-00079638-00080062": "basically first you need to write your", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00288-00080063-00080291": "contributions I mean what projects and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00289-00080292-00080506": "every uh your contribution to which", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00290-00080507-00080855": "projects the Ubuntu or other open source", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00291-00080856-00081149": "project either on discourse or the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00292-00081150-00081371": "on your Wiki", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00293-00081372-00081815": "then you need to sign up the Ubuntu code", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00294-00081816-00081953": "of conduct", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00295-00081954-00082235": "and then we need to add there with the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00296-00082236-00082385": "uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00297-00082386-00082606": "code of conduct", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00298-00082607-00082847": "and after that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00299-00082848-00083131": "you will be reviewed and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00300-00083132-00083471": "interviewed by the membership board", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00301-00083472-00083717": "so yeah like I said just now so the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00302-00083718-00083825": "process will be prepared your", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00303-00083826-00084155": "application in discourse or Wiki", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00304-00084156-00084461": "and then sign code of conducts so a part", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00305-00084462-00084706": "of after you sign up for good or conduct", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00306-00084707-00085091": "so when you contributes to the projects", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00307-00085092-00085265": "right so you might know the main", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00308-00085266-00085576": "contributors of the project so and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00309-00085577-00085805": "the community will give you a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00310-00085806-00086212": "testimonial like either if you have for", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00311-00086213-00086503": "example you being in the Ubuntu security", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00312-00086504-00086843": "projects you keep reporting about a bus", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00313-00086844-00087065": "then you meeting marks right so maybe", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00314-00087066-00087394": "then later Mark will go to your page for", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00315-00087395-00087688": "the wiki and give some testimonial so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00316-00087689-00087941": "that will help us on the membership", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00317-00087942-00088432": "board to actually not so-called uh just", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00318-00088433-00088835": "just to get uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00319-00088836-00089153": "evaluations your contributions that give", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00320-00089154-00089476": "you marks we we currently doesn't have a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00321-00089477-00089579": "specific", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00322-00089580-00089682": "um", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00323-00089683-00090088": "marking schema to evaluate so it's up to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00324-00090089-00090287": "the boards to evaluate how they'll", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00325-00090288-00090550": "contribute either technically or", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00326-00090551-00090737": "non-technical", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00327-00090738-00090976": "and then this testimonial is basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00328-00090977-00091391": "really helps us to to prove that you are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00329-00091392-00091649": "contributing to the projects", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00330-00091650-00091949": "so yeah you need to have like a recipe", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00331-00091950-00092159": "with a registered name a registered", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00332-00092160-00092429": "nickname so we know that this basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00333-00092430-00092788": "is you who are we interviewing inside", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00334-00092789-00093071": "the uh interview sessions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00335-00093072-00093250": "and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00336-00093251-00093605": "after all this uh processes I mean it's", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00337-00093606-00093797": "not like a tedious process it's really", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00338-00093798-00094217": "like uh it's uh very straightforward I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00339-00094218-00094373": "mean if you are comply and then you are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00340-00094374-00094859": "contributing so we evaluate and then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00341-00094860-00095050": "last but not least", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00342-00095051-00095405": "you will be after the reviews and the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00343-00095406-00095656": "book The Board is voting for you and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00344-00095657-00095873": "then you are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00345-00095874-00096155": "already certified as one of our Ubuntu", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00346-00096156-00096400": "memberships so I think the canonical", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00347-00096401-00096671": "wheel I mean this one the certificate", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00348-00096672-00096965": "you can apply online then Connecticut", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00349-00096966-00097373": "will send a certificate straight away to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00350-00097374-00097549": "you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00351-00097550-00097955": "so I'm not sure I mean like I have much", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00352-00097956-00098291": "to see but I think I want to open up", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00353-00098292-00098537": "into the floor you mean like if you have", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00354-00098538-00098975": "some questions or any inquiries how you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00355-00098976-00099221": "still have a how to how you want to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00356-00099222-00099312": "start", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00357-00099313-00099581": "to join the community or how you're", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00358-00099582-00099718": "going to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00359-00099719-00100006": "to contribute to community so can I just", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00360-00100007-00100306": "open up to the floors I mean like for", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00361-00100307-00100655": "questions or any inquiries", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00362-00100656-00100991": "anyone", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00363-00100992-00101332": "oh yeah sure", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00364-00101333-00101668": "what what chat protocols besides IRC", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00365-00101669-00101849": "were they looking into", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00366-00101850-00101962": "oh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00367-00101963-00102287": "currently uh they are I mean like we are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00368-00102288-00102628": "bridging from Isis to the metrics so you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00369-00102629-00102899": "can join some of the projects either", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00370-00102900-00103051": "Ubuntu or you're able to develop", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00371-00103052-00103265": "development everything is already", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00372-00103266-00103594": "available on the metrics so this uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00373-00103595-00103739": "two-way I mean like we are bridging", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00374-00103740-00104116": "between RSC and Metric so both channels", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00375-00104117-00104351": "that might have uh getting the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00376-00104352-00104597": "communications", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00377-00104598-00104981": "thank you you're welcome so any anyone I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00378-00104982-00105245": "mean like from the local and for any", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00379-00105246-00105515": "questions I mean like have you met the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00380-00105516-00105754": "all the organizers or the local", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00381-00105755-00106066": "organizers I mean maybe if not now I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00382-00106067-00106325": "mean after this if you are new to to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00383-00106326-00106583": "this project you can meet with the human", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00384-00106583-00106763": "being I mean like the rest of the local", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00385-00106764-00107177": "organizers after I mean these two days", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00386-00107178-00107734": "okay any more questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00387-00107735-00107884": "no", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00388-00107885-00108227": "okay", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00389-00108228-00108708": "I think I have lots of time inside", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00390-00108709-00109066": "so if not so she can I'll just end my", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00391-00109067-00109319": "session so you still have questions I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00392-00109320-00109504": "mean any questions that means you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00393-00109505-00109745": "related if I cannot unsay I might try to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00394-00109746-00110099": "find someone that can answer I mean your", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00395-00110100-00110416": "questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00396-00110417-00110669": "anyway you mean how we get questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00397-00110670-00111239": "from the online participant", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00398-00111240-00111502": "okay", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00399-00111503-00111845": "so yeah like this event we have a hybrid", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00400-00111846-00112163": "as well so we have a in person here you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00401-00112164-00112384": "guys and then we also have our online so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00402-00112385-00112654": "maybe there is a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00403-00112655-00112925": "people person from the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00404-00112926-00113236": "uh online can share the questions in the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00405-00113238-00113416": "telegrams or something like that in the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00406-00113417-00113723": "book and I share a telegram so I can", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00407-00113724-00113902": "mean the organizer can have the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00408-00113903-00114154": "questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00409-00114155-00114833": "oh yeah mister", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00410-00114833-00115186": "oh thank you I'm not very familiar with", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00411-00115188-00115319": "this", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00412-00115320-00115799": "the kind of this event and I I don't", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00413-00115800-00116158": "have experience to uh coming contribute", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00414-00116159-00116621": "this like Ubuntu so I don't know about", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00415-00116622-00116995": "the code of conduct so can you explain", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00416-00116996-00117473": "what is that oh okay thank you so the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00417-00117474-00117658": "questions I mean like the new people", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00418-00117659-00117995": "want to know about the code of conduct", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00419-00117996-00118265": "so good questions I mean first of all I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00420-00118266-00118528": "would like to congratulate you I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00421-00118529-00118834": "you have many spirits to join and to get", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00422-00118835-00119069": "to know and continue I mean maybe in the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00423-00119070-00119189": "future you could be thinking into the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00424-00119190-00119471": "open open source so basically what's is", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00425-00119472-00119754": "inside the code of conduct is basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00426-00119755-00119969": "you are like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00427-00119970-00120257": "believe being applied with like you are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00428-00120258-00120521": "not like not being a racist you're not", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00429-00120522-00120773": "like harming others peoples I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00430-00120774-00120983": "there's some clouds inside because I'm", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00431-00120983-00121252": "so quite some time I'm so sorry I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00432-00121253-00121649": "like basically uh it's more on we are", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00433-00121650-00121793": "not like humming I mean like the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00434-00121794-00122057": "projects it's not not like uh saying bad", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00435-00122058-00122257": "words or meaning commenting a bad words", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00436-00122258-00122723": "I mean we just because why the code is", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00437-00122724-00123095": "being uh produce is why it's too many", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00438-00123096-00123395": "because like we are working uh in a few", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00439-00123396-00123652": "regions and continent right so we need", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00440-00123653-00123760": "to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00441-00123761-00124031": "being a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00442-00124032-00124445": "a good languages and Main behaviors I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00443-00124446-00124666": "mean when we when we do the contributing", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00444-00124667-00124895": "of the projects it means like you are we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00445-00124896-00125075": "are not allowed to batch it means that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00446-00125076-00125254": "if because we have a different different", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00447-00125255-00125590": "opinions right it means that even uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00448-00125591-00125813": "technical I mean all the programmers so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00449-00125814-00126049": "as well I mean like having their own", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00450-00126050-00126365": "opinions and how do they write quotes", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00451-00126366-00126593": "and everything so with this code of", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00452-00126594-00126899": "conduct basically uh it will help to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00453-00126900-00127252": "manage that right", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00454-00127253-00127666": "okay so the uh I I'm answering your", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00455-00127667-00128086": "question sir", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00456-00128088-00128333": "sorry yeah I think", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00457-00128333-00128549": "that's it I think that's in my you know", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00458-00128550-00128807": "okay yeah okay thank you so basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00459-00128808-00129028": "yeah you are I mean why I'm", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00460-00129029-00129316": "congratulating you is right you come to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00461-00129317-00129545": "join I mean you are new so it's not", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00462-00129546-00129814": "basically you must sign that first in", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00463-00129815-00130049": "order for you to contribute so for", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00464-00130050-00130271": "example that today you're coming to this", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00465-00130272-00130475": "uh conference as well you're already", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00466-00130476-00130673": "contributing to the projects and it's", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00467-00130674-00130984": "like it's non-technical things I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00468-00130985-00131273": "something that conduct is not compulsory", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00469-00131274-00131428": "unless you're going to further", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00470-00131429-00131578": "contribute", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00471-00131579-00132059": "right yeah but uh before 10 years ago I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00472-00132060-00132635": "don't see such agreements in the like uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00473-00132636-00132935": "only I can't I see it was the copyright", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00474-00132936-00133151": "agreement that all the end user", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00475-00133152-00133540": "agreement like something like that but I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00476-00133541-00133895": "just I just didn't understand why I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00477-00133896-00134237": "should Ultraman agree such uh argument", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00478-00134238-00134464": "of code of conduct", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00479-00134465-00134902": "so yeah yeah like for example this is a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00480-00134903-00135202": "code of conduct version 2.0 right so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00481-00135203-00135485": "this is where he explains about the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00482-00135486-00135827": "community and what we strive to I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00483-00135828-00136054": "like be considerate our work will be", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00484-00136055-00136264": "used by other peoples and we will turn", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00485-00136265-00136409": "out will depends on the work of the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00486-00136410-00136757": "others like I need be respectful I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00487-00136758-00137099": "we need to be respect with all the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00488-00137100-00137231": "peoples", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00489-00137232-00137471": "either we we also have a disagreement", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00490-00137472-00137663": "like I said earlier right so we need to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00491-00137664-00137933": "respect each uh each uh people", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00492-00137934-00138197": "contributions and take responsibility", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00493-00138198-00138575": "for our words and our actions and be", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00494-00138576-00138709": "collaborative", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00495-00138710-00138989": "valued deceiveness validity and", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00496-00138990-00139361": "concesses ask for help when unsure", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00497-00139362-00139619": "step down considerately", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00498-00139620-00139852": "and this is also like leaderships", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00499-00139853-00140116": "Authority and responsibility like us we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00500-00140117-00140375": "need to adhere with the code of conducts", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00501-00140376-00140663": "and then the delegations from the tops", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00502-00140664-00140969": "support for delegation is measured", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00503-00140970-00141221": "so there is like a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00504-00141222-00141487": "line by lines that so this is basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00505-00141488-00141863": "the uh code of conducts uh content so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00506-00141864-00142199": "you can just go to the page and then go", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00507-00142200-00142528": "through the code of conduct so this", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00508-00142529-00142781": "the Teamworks and the credits of course", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00509-00142782-00143051": "after you're contributing see that we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00510-00143052-00143219": "need to respect as well the credits we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00511-00143220-00143404": "need to give for credits if we are using", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00512-00143405-00143957": "their codes or we are using anyone's uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00513-00143958-00144383": "uh informations courage that considerate", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00514-00144384-00144599": "completely all the interest so basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00515-00144600-00144833": "all this basically it's not like a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00516-00144834-00145289": "a hit a very rigid uh contract or", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00517-00145290-00145516": "something it's just like to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00518-00145517-00145864": "to help us to communicate as a local", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00519-00145865-00146039": "community or the worldwide community", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00520-00146040-00146273": "that we can work together", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00521-00146274-00146435": "smoothly", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00522-00146436-00146945": "so it's basically not a law or rules so", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00523-00146946-00147454": "but it it is easy like don't worry or be", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00524-00147455-00147725": "gentle yeah yeah yeah thank you you're", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00525-00147726-00147971": "welcome", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00526-00147972-00148685": "Oh you mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00527-00148686-00149009": "thanks so we have a question from the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00528-00149010-00149314": "online participants okay uh he want uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00529-00149315-00149507": "the participant want to know about the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00530-00149508-00149747": "some more details on the the ilc", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00531-00149748-00149975": "membership interview something like what", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00532-00149976-00150154": "kind of questions the membership would", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00533-00150155-00150437": "have or how he schedules like that oh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00534-00150438-00150749": "okay", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00535-00150750-00150952": "so the questions from the online", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00536-00150953-00151193": "audience will be like the details what", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00537-00151194-00151402": "are the questions so basically like I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00538-00151403-00151721": "said earlier so we we doesn't have like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00539-00151722-00151993": "a schema questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00540-00151994-00152351": "uh or marking I mean giving a marriage", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00541-00152352-00152771": "to the contributors basically what we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00542-00152772-00153095": "will interview on the question will be", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00543-00153096-00153389": "based on what you wrote on your personal", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00544-00153390-00153737": "Wiki or discourse applications so from", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00545-00153738-00154109": "your applications then we can see what", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00546-00154110-00154433": "are the projects and uh and how you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00547-00154434-00154714": "contributes and everything so yeah to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00548-00154715-00154931": "answer that specifically we doesn't have", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00549-00154932-00155140": "a like a liquid questions that we're", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00550-00155141-00155302": "going to give a membership so it's", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00551-00155303-00155599": "basically just a human", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00552-00155600-00155878": "Communications and just get to know you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00553-00155879-00156221": "I mean like the applicant and then we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00554-00156222-00156497": "might questions based on what you have", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00555-00156498-00156814": "contributed so for example I mean that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00556-00156815-00157211": "so when when you have like a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00557-00157212-00157573": "sum of testimonials so it's basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00558-00157574-00157883": "for us it's my getting less questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00559-00157884-00158176": "because that testimonial is basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00560-00158177-00158447": "already uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00561-00158448-00158764": "confirm I mean like and then if me like", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00562-00158765-00158975": "giving you a valuations from the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00563-00158976-00159161": "community or the project itself based on", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00564-00159162-00159431": "the testimonial so when we read about", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00565-00159432-00159814": "the testimonial so yeah it might we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00566-00159815-00160031": "might have less questions to questions I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00567-00160032-00160283": "mean on their interview sessions I hope", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00568-00160284-00160733": "that answers the online audience", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00569-00160734-00160961": "okay", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00570-00160962-00161501": "I think any more questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00571-00161502-00161921": "okay I think if", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00572-00161922-00162311": "no question I think I need to uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00573-00162312-00162551": "end my sessions but if you have any", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00574-00162552-00162785": "questions I will be available this two", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00575-00162786-00163151": "days at the summit and it goes to the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00576-00163152-00163357": "online", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00577-00163358-00163661": "participant you can just give questions", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00578-00163662-00163990": "or find me in the telegram or the metric", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00579-00163991-00164195": "as well so you can give a question then", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00580-00164196-00164393": "I will try my best to answer the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00581-00164394-00164626": "questions so I think that's all from me", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00582-00164627-00164885": "and I would like to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00583-00164886-00165083": "thanks the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00584-00165084-00165551": "I'm not sure", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00585-00165552-00165869": "thanks the community I mean like the uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00586-00165870-00166247": "especially the yubicon organizer I think", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00587-00166248-00166523": "I would like to give her Applause I mean", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00588-00166524-00166702": "like from the floor as well give the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00589-00166703-00166931": "good Applause to an organizer that", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00590-00166932-00167099": "managed to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00591-00167100-00167254": "to", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00592-00167255-00167573": "Host this event and I foresee there's a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00593-00167574-00167801": "really uh", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00594-00167802-00168064": "some challenges that we Face these two", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00595-00168065-00168304": "years I mean like last year's that we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00596-00168305-00168599": "when I'm also I mean involved with the", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00597-00168600-00168983": "European organizer as well and we have a", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00598-00168984-00169199": "pandemic so we have online so basically", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00599-00169200-00169481": "online it's a less headache so managing", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00600-00169482-00169876": "the logistics and traveling but this", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00601-00169877-00170345": "year that's why I congratulate uh you've", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00602-00170346-00170602": "been Ubuntu Korea local teams that we", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00603-00170603-00171023": "basically managed to host this event I", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00604-00171024-00171299": "think it's a good event okay so I would", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00605-00171300-00171611": "like to give a plus to to the organizers", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00606-00171612-00171869": "okay", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00607-00171870-00172259": "that's all I think for me uh hamsa", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00608-00172260-00172480": "Hamida thank you", "d2lm3K7P8qE-00609-00172481-00172870": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "d2p4BCNiYsE", "text": {"d2p4BCNiYsE-00000-00001492-00001767": "me the ann arbor t-shirt company is a", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00001-00001768-00001982": "screen print and embroidery shop located", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00002-00001984-00002191": "in ann arbor michigan about 40 miles", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00003-00002192-00002399": "west of detroit", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00004-00002400-00002550": "we started in a dorm room at the", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00005-00002551-00002783": "university of michigan in 2008 and have", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00006-00002784-00003039": "been adding friends ever since", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00007-00003040-00003311": "in 2018 we retrofitted an 80 year old", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00008-00003311-00003495": "machine shop into a cutting edge print", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00009-00003496-00003703": "and sew facility where we bring art to", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00010-00003704-00003975": "life for customers all over the world", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00011-00003976-00004183": "we use top of the line m r presses", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00012-00004184-00004391": "manufactured in illinois to allow our", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00013-00004392-00004551": "skilled printers to work extremely", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00014-00004552-00004791": "efficiently that lets us keep costs low", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00015-00004792-00004991": "without compromising quality which means", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00016-00004992-00005183": "we can sell good stuff at a reasonable", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00017-00005184-00005438": "price", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00018-00005439-00005615": "we train and keep good people with an", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00019-00005616-00005895": "internal apprentice program provide 401k", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00020-00005896-00006118": "matches catered lunches and healthcare", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00021-00006119-00006247": "we think it's the right thing to do", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00022-00006248-00006446": "anyway and as a bonus it turns out that", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00023-00006447-00006663": "happy people make better apparel", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00024-00006664-00006814": "we take a ton of pride in making good", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00025-00006815-00006975": "shirts with some great people if you", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00026-00006976-00007110": "ever find yourself in our corner of", "d2p4BCNiYsE-00027-00007111-00007572": "michigan please stop by for a tour"}}, {"audio_id": "d2sXYljzVNA", "text": {"d2sXYljzVNA-00000-00000006-00000204": "foreign", "d2sXYljzVNA-00001-00000204-00002641": "[Music]", "d2sXYljzVNA-00002-00002642-00004888": "thank you", "d2sXYljzVNA-00003-00004889-00005497": "baby", "d2sXYljzVNA-00004-00005498-00006070": "on me", "d2sXYljzVNA-00005-00006071-00006418": "me", "d2sXYljzVNA-00006-00006419-00007019": "Airheads", "d2sXYljzVNA-00007-00007020-00007139": "baby", "d2sXYljzVNA-00008-00007140-00007867": "[Music]", "d2sXYljzVNA-00009-00007868-00008320": "upon me", "d2sXYljzVNA-00010-00008321-00008687": "[Music]", "d2sXYljzVNA-00011-00008688-00008890": "here", "d2sXYljzVNA-00012-00008891-00012024": "[Music]", "d2sXYljzVNA-00013-00012025-00014263": "thank you", "d2sXYljzVNA-00014-00014263-00014977": "baby baby", "d2sXYljzVNA-00015-00014978-00015761": "[Music]", "d2sXYljzVNA-00016-00015762-00015859": "foreign", "d2sXYljzVNA-00017-00015860-00020297": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "d2OU5FeQQGo", "text": {"d2OU5FeQQGo-00000-00000866-00001111": "I think my questions will be very simple", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00001-00001112-00001848": "because the point is to be microphone or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00002-00001850-00002122": "report to you so it will be very curious", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00003-00002123-00002550": "if you could very simply comment maybe", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00004-00002551-00002932": "how from your personal perspective but", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00005-00002933-00003097": "mainly from the perspective of your", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00006-00003098-00003322": "field of study and especially I would", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00007-00003322-00003682": "say more precisely from your approach to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00008-00003683-00003970": "know gravity and anthropology you would", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00009-00003971-00004257": "commence this conference of Martin's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00010-00004258-00004689": "because he is actually representing or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00011-00004690-00005299": "kind of almost walking the one who say", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00012-00005300-00005707": "the archaic r-ky colonizer or the person", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00013-00005708-00005956": "that that would come into the in Africa", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00014-00005957-00006268": "ladies this role of white canals are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00015-00006269-00006411": "coming to Congo so I would be curious", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00016-00006412-00006826": "how would you kind of unfold the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00017-00006827-00007395": "and what would be your more precise", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00018-00007395-00007934": "comment or specialist from your field I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00019-00007936-00009564": "don't want to start thank you it's great", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00020-00009565-00009994": "to to be here and I stayed up late", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00021-00009995-00010321": "outside watching that film many", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00022-00010322-00010774": "consequence I didn't sleep much it was a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00023-00010775-00011249": "very it's a very engaging and difficult", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00024-00011250-00011632": "at one level it picks out some", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00025-00011633-00012471": "recognizable in a sense flaws in the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00026-00012472-00012783": "logic of international development I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00027-00012784-00013147": "think I have worked on development", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00028-00013147-00013438": "projects not in Africa mostly must be in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00029-00013438-00013755": "Asia immersed in India and I think this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00030-00013756-00014346": "fundamental point about those who are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00031-00014347-00014803": "honored as the givers are they are the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00032-00014804-00015234": "most the greatest beneficiaries of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00033-00015235-00015427": "international aid I think that's a point", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00034-00015428-00015719": "that is that it's well made and remains", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00035-00015720-00016144": "remains true I did research and looked", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00036-00016144-00016417": "at worked on an eight a project and you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00037-00016418-00016781": "could say precisely the percentage of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00038-00016782-00017134": "resources that went through you remember", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00039-00017135-00017344": "that moment when he's on the phone to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00040-00017345-00017475": "somebody who's written and asked will", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00041-00017476-00017703": "talk about technical assistance and it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00042-00017704-00017944": "true a lot of aid was going to technical", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00043-00017945-00017995": "assistance", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00044-00017996-00018297": "because people were funding UK", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00045-00018298-00018592": "institutions in my case to develop", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00046-00018593-00018844": "consultancies and provide support and so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00047-00018845-00019737": "on the the irony of a being though the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00048-00019738-00020191": "gift of aid being given when when the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00049-00020192-00020380": "primary beneficiary saw those quote or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00050-00020381-00020695": "acknowledged as as the givers so I think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00051-00020696-00021154": "that's something that is that is it's an", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00052-00021155-00021523": "aspect that that's picked out also I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00053-00021524-00021757": "think something that becomes very clear", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00054-00021758-00022165": "in the film is that aid agencies operate", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00055-00022166-00022576": "in a sphere of their own making their", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00056-00022577-00022966": "own self marketing and their own self", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00057-00022967-00023289": "referencing and that the world", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00058-00023290-00023512": "understood and defined in terms of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00059-00023513-00023983": "aid agency world has blinded intent and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00060-00023984-00024304": "unknowing an ignorant an ignorance of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00061-00024305-00024598": "the realities that it is engaging with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00062-00024599-00024739": "and I think there are various structures", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00063-00024740-00025066": "that perpetuate in a sense encourage", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00064-00025067-00025434": "organizations to have or invest in a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00065-00025435-00025872": "simplified version of the problems that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00066-00025873-00026133": "they're addressing so as the version of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00067-00026135-00026452": "the world that they want to live operate", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00068-00026452-00026689": "within is one that's consistent with the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00069-00026689-00026950": "sorts of solutions or the sorts of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00070-00026951-00027217": "inputs or the sorts of resources that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00071-00027218-00027477": "are that can be delivered through aid", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00072-00027477-00027793": "programs so I think there's the the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00073-00027794-00028364": "creation of artificial worlds that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00074-00028366-00028810": "justify and validate interventions now", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00075-00028811-00029077": "these are quite easy characterizations", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00076-00029077-00029376": "to to make of the eight industry and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00077-00029377-00029620": "having worked with in aid industry I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00078-00029620-00029872": "think many within it would also", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00079-00029873-00029987": "recognize", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00080-00029988-00030413": "even while endeavoring to to not be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00081-00030414-00030656": "found and constrained by them so I think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00082-00030657-00030887": "there's an element of simplification", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00083-00030888-00031220": "that one has to take on board when when", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00084-00031220-00031589": "when when watching the film and then", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00085-00031589-00031805": "probably maybe say something more about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00086-00031806-00031979": "that sort of thing they thought let me", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00087-00031980-00032222": "not hold this microphone for too long", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00088-00032223-00032591": "Thanks okay I'll just make a few quick", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00089-00032592-00032831": "comments and I I will admit that I am", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00090-00032832-00033014": "one of those people who was guilty of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00091-00033015-00033251": "providing technical assistance it wasn't", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00092-00033252-00033377": "particularly well paid technical", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00093-00033378-00033671": "assistance but I haven't part of this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00094-00033672-00034088": "aid industry as well I think as it as I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00095-00034089-00034238": "was watching this and and I don't know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00096-00034239-00034460": "how it escaped me but I saw for the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00097-00034461-00034688": "first time a couple of days ago and as I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00098-00034689-00034892": "was watching it I was completely in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00099-00034893-00035024": "agreement with a lot of these critiques", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00100-00035025-00035288": "this is these are things we know very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00101-00035289-00035470": "well these are things which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00102-00035471-00035663": "anthropologists have researched and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00103-00035664-00036197": "written very nuanced folks about and I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00104-00036198-00036494": "can't argue with the the substance of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00105-00036495-00036902": "the critique except to say that I think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00106-00036903-00037211": "what really required a delicate and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00107-00037212-00037400": "nuanced touch is sort of given the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00108-00037401-00037646": "treatment of a sledgehammer in in this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00109-00037647-00038138": "instance and as I said in in some", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00110-00038139-00038324": "instances it's oversimplifications and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00111-00038325-00038834": "some instances I think in failure to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00112-00038835-00039008": "recognize that there are actually a lot", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00113-00039009-00039191": "of folks within this aid industry who", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00114-00039192-00039392": "are desperately trying to change it I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00115-00039393-00039719": "would be one included who who has taken", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00116-00039720-00039857": "part in these projects mainly in Eastern", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00117-00039858-00040187": "Europe and has tried to sort of avoid", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00118-00040188-00040502": "these things and as David mentioned this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00119-00040503-00041212": "idea of the donor priorities and how", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00120-00041213-00041504": "things are set and and whatever what I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00121-00041505-00041747": "would pull down here is basically this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00122-00041748-00041969": "difference between what is needed and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00123-00041970-00042350": "what is fundable what is something that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00124-00042351-00042572": "a donor can say this is a priority and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00125-00042573-00042711": "we want to fund", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00126-00042712-00042936": "in order for that to happen you have to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00127-00042937-00043200": "have a set of the herbal and you have to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00128-00043201-00043374": "be able to check the box to say that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00129-00043375-00043590": "this has happened and in terms of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00130-00043591-00043812": "kind of aid which is really necessary in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00131-00043813-00044205": "this case I I do I do work in public", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00132-00044206-00044393": "health and infectious disease what is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00133-00044394-00044601": "usually needed is complicated and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00134-00044602-00044970": "difficult to to simply check a box", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00135-00044971-00045189": "whereas what as oftentimes delivered is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00136-00045190-00045543": "something for example a building there's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00137-00045544-00045714": "a building which is constructed and on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00138-00045715-00045903": "this date you can say that this has been", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00139-00045904-00046128": "given but is is the building what was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00140-00046129-00046269": "actually needed or is there something", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00141-00046270-00046512": "that's much more complicated and and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00142-00046513-00046773": "more difficult to give that that's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00143-00046774-00047102": "missing so I think in this instance", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00144-00047103-00047427": "there there's a mismatch between what in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00145-00047428-00047610": "some instances is sort of able to be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00146-00047611-00047784": "delivered and the sort of aid which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00147-00047785-00048051": "would be most useful as determined by", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00148-00048052-00048371": "the folks who are actually living there", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00149-00048372-00049043": "and and this was I this is something", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00150-00049044-00049230": "that I think we maybe we don't spend", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00151-00049231-00049509": "enough time thinking about it is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00152-00049510-00049806": "actually what do people see as being", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00153-00049807-00050177": "actually needed in a place the technical", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00154-00050178-00050373": "assistance industry is very strong that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00155-00050374-00050586": "would provide all the lots of things", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00156-00050587-00050802": "which we say that other places need but", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00157-00050803-00051069": "oftentimes this is a one-way loop and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00158-00051070-00051254": "we're not receiving what it is that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00159-00051255-00051474": "people actually want and if he truly is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00160-00051475-00051735": "supposed to other people's lives then", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00161-00051736-00051879": "there has to be this two-way", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00162-00051879-00052067": "communication and I think this is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00163-00052069-00052329": "something where we do need to have a lot", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00164-00052329-00052611": "more input but I'll save other comments", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00165-00052612-00053865": "for later I think this was for me you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00166-00053866-00054084": "know we know the critiques that were", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00167-00054085-00054335": "presented of international humanitarian", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00168-00054336-00054775": "of development and so on but it was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00169-00054776-00055174": "nevertheless pretty overwhelming partly", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00170-00055175-00055616": "because of the way that the the visual", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00171-00055616-00055987": "images in some ways especially of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00172-00055988-00056459": "children for malnutrition and the you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00173-00056460-00056719": "know ability in some ways to show what a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00174-00056720-00057043": "wound actually looks like versus just", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00175-00057044-00057448": "reading about the moon in some ways is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00176-00057449-00057787": "what I call a kind of inordinate", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00177-00057788-00058129": "knowledge that is it's overwhelming in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00178-00058130-00058369": "some ways that you know one doesn't", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00179-00058370-00058717": "quite know what to do with that and I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00180-00058718-00059311": "like I like to take that which is other", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00181-00059312-00059546": "than maybe but I still think that two", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00182-00059547-00059828": "very important parts of the critique you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00183-00059829-00060088": "know what is of course the whole idea of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00184-00060089-00060313": "the white man is the one who comes to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00185-00060314-00060790": "rescue so happy ways talk about the fact", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00186-00060791-00060971": "that when they boil I have a time it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00187-00060972-00061237": "happened you know we had a huge number", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00188-00061238-00061579": "of people taking you know everyone named", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00189-00061580-00062068": "names but basically saying we were moms", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00190-00062069-00062692": "we let the entire try to contain the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00191-00062693-00062992": "epidemic and there was no mention of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00192-00062993-00063187": "fact that the majority of doctors who", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00193-00063188-00063365": "actually work during the Ebola epidemic", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00194-00063366-00063706": "or you can dance right and so this is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00195-00063707-00063916": "something very interesting about the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00196-00063917-00064234": "manner in which the critique it's also", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00197-00064235-00064555": "the particular narrative structure of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00198-00064556-00064702": "the right mark", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00199-00064703-00065263": "you know providing in some ways rescue", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00200-00065264-00065512": "I believe requests been very interested", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00201-00065513-00065815": "in thinking that now for example you do", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00202-00065816-00066286": "have huge aid projects from China you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00203-00066287-00066553": "have in the Middle East the entire issue", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00204-00066554-00066835": "of Islamic humanitarianism in which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00205-00066836-00067117": "Saudi Arabia's being reactive in terms", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00206-00067118-00067363": "of Turkey being very active in terms of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00207-00067364-00067669": "you know in terms of not humanitarian", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00208-00067670-00067912": "aid of the international humanitarian", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00209-00067913-00068179": "saw sought but certainly a particular", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00210-00068180-00068449": "kind of the monetary aid and I think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00211-00068450-00068659": "these are very interesting questions", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00212-00068660-00068944": "that will emerge that once you displace", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00213-00068945-00069246": "or who make more through these", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00214-00069247-00069505": "humanitarian structures which are in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00215-00069506-00069820": "place what will actually get the second", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00216-00069821-00070168": "point I want to make and that's faster", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00217-00070169-00070390": "which is is that you know in some ways", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00218-00070391-00070807": "it renounce as itself as a film now we", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00219-00070808-00071137": "know that in unlike a painting the kind", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00220-00071138-00071563": "of frame in the film is much more mobile", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00221-00071564-00071893": "so you can you know you can just see", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00222-00071894-00072127": "that there is a certain sense in with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00223-00072128-00072415": "whatever scene is already seen through", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00224-00072416-00072631": "the camera and so that kind of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00225-00072632-00072937": "distancing in a certain sense of the the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00226-00072938-00073198": "intimacy with the image but the idea", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00227-00073199-00073522": "that this is cinema itself telling you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00228-00073523-00073738": "art cinema now we know that this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00229-00073739-00074062": "technique of placing that within the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00230-00074063-00074404": "frame is a very effective way by which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00231-00074405-00074692": "in some ways the illusion of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00232-00074693-00074781": "intimacy", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00233-00074782-00075017": "the narrative element the image is often", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00234-00075018-00075261": "destroyed for example to make classic", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00235-00075262-00075552": "films you know classic Hollywood films", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00236-00075553-00075789": "you would have to scream and the scream", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00237-00075790-00076113": "might receive impressions within within", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00238-00076114-00076350": "the cinematic scream itself right here", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00239-00076351-00076650": "what was very interesting was the kind", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00240-00076651-00076965": "of ironies with also performed so you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00241-00076966-00077385": "had enjoy poverty as you know written in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00242-00077386-00077652": "ways in which it becomes part of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00243-00077653-00077961": "cinematic structure itself and also the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00244-00077962-00078339": "creation in a certain way or particular", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00245-00078340-00078696": "kinds of ironies in which the filmmakers", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00246-00078697-00079145": "own presence is something which is also", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00247-00079146-00079593": "severely problematized sales event so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00248-00079594-00079824": "that you don't end up and that's what I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00249-00079825-00080037": "liked about it was that you don't", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00250-00080038-00080349": "actually end up thinking oh I've had a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00251-00080350-00080550": "documentary which has showed me exactly", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00252-00080551-00080796": "how things are over there you know that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00253-00080797-00081018": "in a certain sense this is a commentary", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00254-00081019-00081243": "but it's a commentary in which false", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00255-00081244-00081489": "intimacy is also in some ways being", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00256-00081490-00081765": "created so I could say more on it but I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00257-00081766-00081936": "think that what for me was very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00258-00081937-00082215": "interesting was to think of this not", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00259-00082216-00082464": "just as not like how I read the same", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00260-00082465-00082782": "things in academic papers or in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00261-00082783-00083067": "newspaper reports so what was it let the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00262-00083068-00083565": "medium of the film actually and you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00263-00083566-00083760": "I think a very interesting thing there", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00264-00083761-00084045": "was you know we could go into the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00265-00084046-00084429": "specific scenes in something that the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00266-00084430-00084675": "very interesting thing was the way in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00267-00084676-00085056": "which are constantly being teased into", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00268-00085057-00085314": "thinking what what is it that not in the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00269-00085315-00085560": "frame you know so that there is a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00270-00085561-00085749": "question of what is you know one thing", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00271-00085750-00085995": "for example when this there there's a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00272-00085996-00086280": "scene where you know where this man says", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00273-00086281-00086542": "yes we know that man", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00274-00086543-00086884": "children are much more in the common", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00275-00086885-00087121": "workers employed by the company and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00276-00087122-00087313": "outside with other farms you don't", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00277-00087314-00087520": "actually get that many miles to shoot", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00278-00087521-00087724": "you there is a reference to something", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00279-00087725-00088009": "outside the frame and it would actually", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00280-00088010-00088384": "be very very interesting to think in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00281-00088385-00088597": "what kind of way links which are outside", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00282-00088598-00088825": "the frame are both kind of brought", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00283-00088826-00089115": "closer to us but also something which is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00284-00089116-00089382": "excluded in some ways because of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00285-00089383-00089694": "manner in which the cinematic screen so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00286-00089695-00090031": "to say actually operates and the manner", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00287-00090032-00090325": "in which the the shifting angles of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00288-00090326-00092548": "camera for example really perspective of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00289-00092549-00092851": "somebody with examples how films are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00290-00092852-00093436": "made and how how how they construct the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00291-00093437-00093676": "narrative and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00292-00093677-00093943": "this film is quite precious for me", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00293-00093944-00094357": "because it's in constant dialogue with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00294-00094358-00094976": "our expectations with our spectator", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00295-00094977-00095497": "spectators expectations and it offers", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00296-00095498-00095831": "really wide", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00297-00095832-00096230": "possibilities to question the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00298-00096231-00096351": "problematics", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00299-00096352-00096969": "of images an industry of poverty and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00300-00096970-00097424": "industry of poverty with the images and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00301-00097425-00097722": "for me this film is a really very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00302-00097723-00098109": "precise gesture very consciousness chair", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00303-00098110-00098613": "of somebody who knows that to show the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00304-00098614-00098910": "poverty to the world has a long duration", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00305-00098911-00099284": "and this duration has been kind of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00306-00099285-00099723": "exploited we know now that the things we", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00307-00099724-00100056": "see are not as such as we see them and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00308-00100057-00100365": "we know that a camera and somebody", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00309-00100366-00100923": "behind frame the reality and the reality", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00310-00100924-00101472": "is much more complicated than what's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00311-00101473-00101799": "being showing to us and I think Renzo", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00312-00101800-00102206": "Martins is very well they were of that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00313-00102207-00102569": "so this gesture really could be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00314-00102570-00103047": "discussed for others but to make it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00315-00103048-00103389": "simple I think he believed in the first", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00316-00103390-00103943": "half of the film offers offers us to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00317-00103944-00105338": "think actually how the images of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00318-00105339-00107427": "which is how the images", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00319-00107428-00108177": "if in the first half where he stands or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00320-00108178-00108724": "his two cameras are more used to say of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00321-00108725-00109452": "serratus he confronts us with which it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00322-00109453-00110010": "affect how how or how are the images of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00323-00110011-00110518": "poverty and of the third-world part of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00324-00110519-00110920": "our our first world both are the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00325-00110921-00111571": "connections of of the images of the of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00326-00111572-00111997": "the third world how did we inhabit them", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00327-00111998-00112335": "how did we make them alive how how did", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00328-00112336-00112657": "we came to this tradition and it's his", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00329-00112658-00113004": "playing with it because he is he is the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00330-00113005-00113296": "motorizing Miglia as such and that's a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00331-00113297-00113638": "very important level of the film another", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00332-00113639-00113904": "important level and that's again the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00333-00113905-00114210": "question I'm talking about is is that he", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00334-00114211-00114786": "is constantly showing as the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00335-00114788-00115052": "problematics of representations", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00336-00115053-00115324": "representations of media presentations", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00337-00115325-00115476": "of alter of him", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00338-00115477-00115779": "so and often I think we get and of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00339-00115780-00115983": "sense we get from that and that's very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00340-00115983-00116256": "important and I think he is very brave", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00341-00116257-00116652": "to do this guest chair up to the point", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00342-00116653-00117131": "where he examines the possibility of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00343-00117132-00117610": "engaged art or of engaged meant as such", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00344-00117611-00118047": "he as somebody made a camera or anybody", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00345-00118048-00118530": "with the camera when when we start to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00346-00118531-00118608": "shoot", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00347-00118608-00118977": "we already exploit the reality we", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00348-00118978-00119234": "already exploit and that's the that's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00349-00119235-00119466": "the question of a father of somebody who", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00350-00119467-00119799": "is taking pictures and he is really", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00351-00119800-00120024": "talking about that so I think for me", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00352-00120025-00120378": "this film is a lot about how can we talk", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00353-00120379-00120461": "about it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00354-00120463-00120779": "how can we talk about Congo and this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00355-00120780-00121154": "terrible Holocaust happening there", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00356-00121155-00121524": "hundred years what might be the question", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00357-00121525-00121840": "of art is going there and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00358-00121841-00123341": "[Music]", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00359-00123342-00123552": "[Music]", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00360-00123553-00123823": "she can maybe add something if I see", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00361-00123824-00124318": "something wrong and our research project", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00362-00124319-00124803": "is concentrated to contemporary", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00363-00124804-00124986": "documentaries amor took matter", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00364-00124988-00125320": "strategies in contemporary media and for", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00365-00125321-00125658": "this research is Nubian this art piece", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00366-00125659-00126247": "is pretty crucial because as was already", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00367-00126248-00126579": "mentioned here he's showing the position", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00368-00126580-00127000": "of himself the media and for me coming", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00369-00127001-00127278": "from the art world is very important", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00370-00127279-00127606": "that he's showing also how this works in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00371-00127607-00127950": "relation the relationship to art world", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00372-00127951-00128175": "itself so you can find there many", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00373-00128176-00128773": "references to visual science but also", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00374-00128774-00129258": "himself as a persona like artist some", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00375-00129259-00129625": "kind of dramatic romantic traveling on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00376-00129626-00130099": "the black river so feminine and the last", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00377-00130100-00130341": "thing which is very important and it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00378-00130342-00130577": "creating these connections between the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00379-00130578-00130897": "subject object", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00380-00130898-00131153": "the author and the last thing is the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00381-00131154-00131635": "organs so for me it's very important to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00382-00131636-00132003": "see how Martin's is referring to the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00383-00132004-00132622": "audience itself and how he is making", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00384-00132623-00132940": "visible the secondary fevers in Europe", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00385-00132941-00133276": "so he's super developer and also that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00386-00133277-00133576": "can he's showing you that this film is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00387-00133577-00133897": "not made from the object of the film", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00388-00133898-00134083": "it's made for the people who are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00389-00134084-00134322": "watching interview are becoming", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00390-00134323-00134628": "participant of this you are and that's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00391-00134629-00134827": "the point that he's showing you that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00392-00134828-00135103": "become being the participant on being", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00393-00135104-00135274": "the river you are becoming the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00394-00135275-00135562": "participant of the whole complex network", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00395-00135563-00135871": "of this relationships that are creating", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00396-00135872-00137275": "also the poverty you can you were", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00397-00137276-00137476": "mentioning shortly but my question would", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00398-00137477-00137865": "be if there's a whole new a copy of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00399-00137866-00138259": "actually the methodology the way how he", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00400-00138260-00138603": "approaches people and how he improved", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00401-00138604-00139087": "his poor people and dying child and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00402-00139088-00139341": "suffering humans because this was a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00403-00139342-00139597": "subject of critique of certain of course", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00404-00139598-00139989": "especially of courses ethnographers and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00405-00139990-00140184": "which is the methodology and how to how", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00406-00140185-00140558": "to actually behave in whatever codes and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00407-00140559-00140748": "methodologies of course it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00408-00140749-00140937": "transgressed because we can claim it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00409-00140938-00141195": "an artistic piece it's art but because", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00410-00141196-00141381": "it is something that was very highly", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00411-00141382-00141585": "discussed also in articles you know even", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00412-00141586-00141819": "art it should be it should have a kind", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00413-00141820-00142079": "of autonomy in terms of transgressing", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00414-00142080-00142332": "certain tuition taboos etcetera but", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00415-00142333-00142767": "there is a kind of inner side LLC", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00416-00142768-00143004": "morality in art field we don't think for", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00417-00143005-00143175": "example this is transgressing you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00418-00143176-00143429": "because there was also another case of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00419-00143430-00143673": "Canada character I know the case of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00420-00143674-00143996": "those South African photographer who", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00421-00143997-00144243": "actually waited 20 minutes to take a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00422-00144244-00144507": "picture of dying child then he took the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00423-00144508-00144699": "picture and he got the Pulitzer Prize in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00424-00144700-00144939": "Veda you know he was a big activist and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00425-00144940-00145194": "a really big person and a year after", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00426-00145195-00145326": "Pulitzer Prize he committed suicide", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00427-00145327-00145614": "because all the people are kind of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00428-00145615-00145863": "pointing at him saying you know you were", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00429-00145864-00146091": "watching this child dying for 20 minutes", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00430-00146092-00146253": "and he couldn't bear it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00431-00146254-00146466": "he couldn't have to one year so again", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00432-00146467-00146694": "this this vegetables brought when when", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00433-00146695-00146886": "Martin films came out because people", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00434-00146887-00147132": "were criticizing very much its kind of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00435-00147133-00147491": "cynical bunny human approach to to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00436-00147492-00147708": "suffering so what would be your comment", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00437-00147709-00147924": "and also maybe in connection with the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00438-00147925-00148290": "tradition of documentary in entrepreneur", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00439-00148291-00148686": "congrat they actually well I'm probably", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00440-00148687-00148882": "not", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00441-00148883-00149191": "that'll move along the line but just to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00442-00149192-00149497": "say one thing that did strike me is that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00443-00149498-00149851": "this is presented to us as a parody it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00444-00149852-00150265": "presented to us as as a Western audience", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00445-00150266-00150589": "for our education for our self parody", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00446-00150590-00150995": "bruh and in a sense if it loops in a way", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00447-00150996-00151222": "that the background and others are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00448-00151223-00151513": "certainly used for that purpose I mean X", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00449-00151514-00151844": "basically the business of honesty about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00450-00151845-00152168": "that but that honesty doesn't remove or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00451-00152169-00152602": "exalt the filmmaker from the costs of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00452-00152603-00153356": "that that silikal use of those in the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00453-00153357-00153673": "process so in a way although it era days", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00454-00153674-00154162": "the the white Western aid worker", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00455-00154163-00154528": "it also reproduces the white Western", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00456-00154529-00154832": "actor communicating and producing", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00457-00154833-00155093": "something for consumption by the white", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00458-00155094-00155323": "Western audience and therefore in a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00459-00155324-00155618": "sense rather than just critiquing it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00460-00155619-00155957": "also reproduces what it's critiquing and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00461-00155958-00156206": "doesn't let any point engage except", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00462-00156207-00156644": "ironically and lovably and in a sense", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00463-00156645-00156884": "misleadingly with the real life by", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00464-00156885-00157300": "levers and issues but those who are the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00465-00157301-00157662": "backdrop of the film's concerns that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00466-00157663-00157885": "confront their lives so I think that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00467-00157886-00158449": "would be one thing that strikes me I was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00468-00158450-00158800": "thinking of something similar that and I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00469-00158801-00158993": "think as I've nog refers were this is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00470-00158994-00159190": "something that were very very sensitive", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00471-00159191-00159616": "to is how we represent other folks and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00472-00159617-00159821": "and how we try to preserve people's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00473-00159822-00160007": "dignity and humanity and as I was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00474-00160008-00160261": "watching this when I was what I was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00475-00160262-00160451": "seeing was that he", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00476-00160452-00160754": "these people as props this person is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00477-00160755-00161090": "here to to fulfill some role so he's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00478-00161091-00161261": "stretching the skin of the malnourished", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00479-00161262-00161510": "child he's taking the clothes off of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00480-00161511-00161825": "one to show this wound and whatever that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00481-00161826-00162143": "mean thinking was is is this all that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00482-00162144-00162446": "that we get that this child is here to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00483-00162447-00162668": "demonstrate this point and didn't have", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00484-00162669-00162968": "humanity outside of this as an as an", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00485-00162969-00163106": "ethnographer this is something that I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00486-00163107-00163346": "really a ganache about to show people as", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00487-00163347-00163583": "full human beings and and to try to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00488-00163584-00163787": "preserve that dignity so for me this was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00489-00163788-00164129": "particularly troubling to watch people", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00490-00164130-00164342": "who are suffering that being reduced and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00491-00164343-00164543": "so used to prove it as I said before", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00492-00164544-00164744": "very legitimate point but nonetheless", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00493-00164745-00165370": "one about me feeling uncomfortable and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00494-00165371-00165776": "disappointed by the use of these things", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00495-00165777-00166000": "without providing any context other than", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00496-00166001-00166325": "this is a dying child this is an", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00497-00166326-00167273": "impoverished person so let me say when", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00498-00167274-00167591": "you are looking at something with it is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00499-00167592-00168251": "no way so it's not just the filmmaker", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00500-00168252-00168545": "it's the anthropologist estate mogul so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00501-00168546-00168788": "you know who's they", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00502-00168789-00169085": "can I take that as such a fundamental", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00503-00169086-00169861": "point you know Gandhi used to say that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00504-00169862-00170090": "if your hands are completely clean", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00505-00170091-00170297": "you've never actually done anything", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00506-00170298-00170840": "right so in that sense I'm you know I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00507-00170841-00171083": "come at it at a different angle because", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00508-00171084-00171224": "I think if it makes you feel", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00509-00171225-00171515": "uncomfortable precisely what it's meant", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00510-00171516-00171795": "to do it seems to me that it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00511-00171796-00172411": "you know its impact that okay let me", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00512-00172412-00172563": "step back first I don't think it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00513-00172564-00172894": "representational categories are that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00514-00172895-00173161": "clear to me I don't think it's really", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00515-00173162-00173452": "about representation it seems to me that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00516-00173453-00173794": "it's much more in a certain sense about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00517-00173795-00174124": "what kind of cinematic distance and what", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00518-00174125-00174373": "kind of cinematic closeness skeletal", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00519-00174374-00174601": "actually created to these particular", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00520-00174602-00175014": "images and so the feeling of nausea that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00521-00175015-00175456": "overtakes you in actually looking at", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00522-00175457-00175723": "these particular images is exactly what", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00523-00175724-00175993": "happens in a field work situation you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00524-00175994-00176245": "know so you know that there are these", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00525-00176246-00176494": "things that are happening you also know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00526-00176495-00176703": "that it's sometimes you are going to go", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00527-00176704-00176977": "away and you know what my problems in my", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00528-00176978-00177247": "field is always being then I can't move", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00529-00177248-00177676": "so I tend to do fever for 15 or 16 years", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00530-00177677-00178060": "of 17 years I just cannot dissociate man", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00531-00178061-00178453": "you know I said this is not a solution", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00532-00178454-00178878": "to the problem it's simply that I think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00533-00178879-00179236": "that the demand in a certain sense on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00534-00179237-00180049": "the film to somehow be you know catered", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00535-00180050-00180276": "in some ways to well-defined", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00536-00180277-00180571": "sensitivities is precisely what to me it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00537-00180572-00181348": "was actually questioning bringing to the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00538-00181349-00181650": "fore or you know I think what as", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00539-00181651-00181939": "anthropologists and ethnographers we", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00540-00181940-00182221": "experience every day which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00541-00182222-00182524": "that and should I really be writing", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00542-00182525-00182766": "about this you know why should I be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00543-00182767-00182962": "writing about this how should I be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00544-00182963-00183181": "writing about this but more than writing", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00545-00183182-00183499": "I mean it's also say anthropological", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00546-00183500-00183839": "knowledge is secreted in several", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00547-00183840-00184132": "contexts and some places it's not just", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00548-00184133-00184345": "the act of writing so I mean I think I'd", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00549-00184346-00184569": "be very interested in the question of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00550-00184570-00184864": "what the making of the film itself", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00551-00184865-00185194": "actually did so I'm not sure that these", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00552-00185195-00185410": "are people who were prompts in that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00553-00185411-00185829": "sense so at least for me I think it left", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00554-00185830-00186270": "me with much more complicated emotions", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00555-00186271-00186589": "then the ones and you know this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00556-00186590-00186820": "particular reference that you made to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00557-00186821-00187126": "the film with the dime child and the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00558-00187127-00187727": "what you're waiting to I mean the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00559-00187728-00188299": "critical question there was that you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00560-00188300-00188614": "know how do you actually deal with this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00561-00188615-00188884": "kind of overwhelming reality and that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00562-00188885-00189228": "there is this kind of reality maybe you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00563-00189229-00189489": "could save this one child but you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00564-00189490-00189654": "you know that they can go to be a things", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00565-00189655-00189877": "child about whom you probably are not", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00566-00189878-00190219": "going to be able to do anything so I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00567-00190220-00190782": "think maybe my relation to it was more", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00568-00190783-00191044": "ambivalent that might be wishing to have", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00569-00191045-00191311": "to apologize who have never them so in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00570-00191312-00191569": "some ways these tend to kind of you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00571-00191570-00191974": "I did they tend to mirror that kind of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00572-00191975-00192262": "discomfort that I have with the fact", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00573-00192263-00192538": "which is a simple fact of existence that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00574-00192539-00192798": "I live in a world where these things are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00575-00192799-00192975": "happening", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00576-00192976-00193233": "time and however I might protect myself", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00577-00193234-00193500": "from thinking oh you know I'm not the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00578-00193501-00193820": "one who's done this the fact of once", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00579-00193821-00196400": "complicity in a certain sense was yeah I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00580-00196401-00196644": "have to focus", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00581-00196645-00196860": "actually that your question was about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00582-00196861-00197169": "the methodology because what you're", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00583-00197170-00197634": "saying is bringing me new new", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00584-00197635-00197889": "perspectives and very interesting how to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00585-00197890-00198344": "have to look at the film and I would", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00586-00198345-00198741": "talk about his documentary stick", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00587-00198742-00199143": "methodology I think it's quite clear", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00588-00199144-00199449": "from the very beginning that his", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00589-00199450-00200151": "methodology is exposing himself in the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00590-00200152-00200628": "middle of the frame and that he is the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00591-00200629-00201039": "white man who comes to black Africa and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00592-00201040-00201384": "this white man decided to make up the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00593-00201385-00201804": "story about that encounter and his", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00594-00201805-00202227": "methodology is to make the film for West", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00595-00202228-00202857": "audience so by watching his film we are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00596-00202858-00203280": "supposed to enjoy the poverty his", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00597-00203281-00203592": "message is for us and I think it is the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00598-00203593-00203989": "second reading of the film that we are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00599-00203990-00204211": "at the film about Congo and about the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00600-00204212-00204484": "terrible Missouri where all of us we do", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00601-00204485-00204873": "take a daily part just by by having", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00602-00204875-00205188": "telephones just by having computers", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00603-00205189-00205729": "using water whatever and so his", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00604-00205730-00206098": "methodology is in a way quite romantic", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00605-00206098-00206614": "because he is on the journey and he", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00606-00206615-00206863": "takes his journey quite dramatically I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00607-00206864-00207373": "think for all of you you it's it's so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00608-00207375-00207646": "significant how much he reminds us of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00609-00207648-00208063": "Klaus Kinski and how much the the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00610-00208064-00208469": "neurotic is is like like when an ER doc", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00611-00208469-00208882": "spells or there is it's obvious you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00612-00208883-00209144": "cannot miss that also with this heavy", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00613-00209144-00209500": "luggage going through the charcoal and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00614-00209501-00209803": "and behind that the methodology is heart", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00615-00209804-00210325": "of the darkness and it's it's this is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00616-00210326-00210931": "this deep way how to deal with the guilt", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00617-00210932-00211399": "we can never have a clean hands not", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00618-00211400-00211669": "possible not now not tomorrow not today", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00619-00211671-00211921": "after tomorrow not in one year because", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00620-00211923-00212200": "of this whole industry which is so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00621-00212201-00212502": "structured that we are really a small", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00622-00212503-00213048": "way of playing a small part of it so and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00623-00213050-00213457": "again his methodology is he explains", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00624-00213458-00213775": "that quite clearly in the beginning when", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00625-00213776-00214316": "he he says that he he was composed to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00626-00214317-00214723": "set this this line up and he wants", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00627-00214725-00214981": "people to enjoy the moment they are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00628-00214982-00215298": "there with joy in their mind", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00629-00215300-00215541": "in their heart and that's this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00630-00215542-00215992": "methodology how to create images about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00631-00215992-00216454": "Congo and himself what I find as a big", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00632-00216455-00216853": "point is that I really do not know why", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00633-00216854-00217294": "he goes to Congo and why he chose to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00634-00217294-00217950": "make a film as such there he is that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00635-00217951-00218254": "he's such I thought that two of these -", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00636-00218255-00219217": "no I was thinking for me you said that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00637-00219217-00219694": "his methodology is his his irony or is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00638-00219694-00219937": "cynical I don't think it's cynical I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00639-00219938-00220173": "don't agree with the little point I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00640-00220175-00220615": "think he is really making self", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00641-00220616-00222054": "references to this industry of poverty", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00642-00222055-00222510": "no no I don't think that I think it too", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00643-00222511-00223369": "seriously and his methodology is quite I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00644-00223369-00223719": "was about to say that is quite tough for", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00645-00223721-00224179": "me the hardest scene was when he feeds", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00646-00224180-00224444": "the family and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00647-00224446-00224817": "and first thing you know that this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00648-00224819-00225198": "gesture really warms them up they're so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00649-00225200-00225433": "happy they can heat and you can feel it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00650-00225434-00225751": "and you can see it from their faces but", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00651-00225752-00226000": "you know that there is a huge village", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00652-00226001-00226394": "around which is not being feeling it and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00653-00226396-00226756": "I really I was shocked by the fact that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00654-00226757-00227179": "he had Mirage to soothe this Walker on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00655-00227180-00227614": "the shirt of this girl that was so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00656-00227615-00227889": "astonishing for me and disgusting", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00657-00227890-00228277": "actually disgusting and I had to think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00658-00228278-00228585": "about it all and I was thinking when", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00659-00228586-00228985": "will about second had Congo like his", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00660-00228986-00229225": "heritage I think this was a guest to the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00661-00229226-00229635": "village that you know but Renzo is not", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00662-00229636-00230223": "darshan 30 so methodology yeah I remain", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00663-00230225-00231544": "I remain references", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00664-00231546-00232164": "first I agree the erroneous idea because", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00665-00232165-00232788": "I think when we look further from the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00666-00232789-00233139": "content or the objects of the film which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00667-00233140-00233319": "is real interesting for me money when we", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00668-00233319-00233771": "see this piece of video in the context", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00669-00233773-00234104": "of documentary movies or in cinema but", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00670-00234105-00234366": "he's tripping in samarkand strictly", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00671-00234367-00234723": "assassin many interviews this is an art", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00672-00234723-00235289": "piece it's very important just because", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00673-00235290-00235773": "the context or the realm of art allows", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00674-00235773-00236458": "you to do things that are actually and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00675-00236459-00236846": "which is problematic or see he is very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00676-00236848-00237146": "erotic because he kind of he said", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00677-00237148-00237638": "various audiences and me he has you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00678-00237639-00237881": "he has his contract with audience which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00679-00237882-00238169": "is very literal this contract is one", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00680-00238171-00238355": "side on one side and he can do anything", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00681-00238356-00238865": "he can shoot images that are really", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00682-00238866-00239144": "devastating for people about Union and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00683-00239144-00239483": "the other signs of this contract is the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00684-00239484-00239756": "audience which can do anything can do", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00685-00239757-00240246": "something that doesn't have to go so for", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00686-00240246-00240396": "me it's important this relationship to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00687-00240396-00240701": "audience and some very open question of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00688-00240702-00241109": "ethics and the changing of context", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00689-00241110-00241235": "because when you see it in the context", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00690-00241236-00241523": "of government you know natural looking", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00691-00241524-00241700": "and the medium itself but then you're", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00692-00241701-00242042": "looking at this context of yeah", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00693-00242044-00242271": "so-called documentary movie it could be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00694-00242271-00242474": "really different so you will see the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00695-00242475-00242675": "content you will see the property with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00696-00242676-00242960": "city conditions for economic emissions", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00697-00242961-00243237": "of Congo but I don't think it's this is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00698-00243238-00243390": "something what he wanted to show because", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00699-00243391-00243605": "I think in terms of they're going to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00700-00243606-00243840": "documentary movie it's something I would", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00701-00243841-00244041": "say very bad movie because it shows you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00702-00244042-00244235": "something that you really know you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00703-00244236-00244607": "these images you know the situation of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00704-00244608-00244847": "the people so for me it's more important", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00705-00244848-00245121": "to stick with the with the medium of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00706-00245121-00245776": "video itself and with the ethic and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00707-00245777-00246446": "agenda I think Forenza Martin's may be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00708-00246446-00246848": "making this movie would on was also the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00709-00246849-00247010": "bus say to me because as you probably", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00710-00247011-00247341": "know this was one of his last movies and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00711-00247342-00247569": "then he moves to Congo and he started", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00712-00247569-00247839": "his own initiative working with the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00713-00247840-00248030": "people there are making offices with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00714-00248031-00248337": "them and sending them in the Western art", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00715-00248338-00248646": "markets which is also a question for me", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00716-00248646-00248957": "quite problematic because this stuff's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00717-00248958-00249366": "more visible in the movie is that you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00718-00249367-00249960": "have your own agenda oh man if you can", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00719-00249961-00251250": "response the emancipation process", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00720-00251251-00251536": "comment because I think it will be we", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00721-00251537-00251815": "will try to open up the floor for the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00722-00251816-00252085": "questions and comment because we all", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00723-00252086-00252337": "sort of fail and we all I think feel a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00724-00252338-00252664": "certain need to enter to say something", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00725-00252665-00253065": "so if you still have a comment", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00726-00253066-00253375": "interesting to share your comment on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00727-00253376-00254356": "what has been said here still some", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00728-00254357-00254823": "questions but it's I think to engage", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00729-00254823-00259509": "because you are just comments concerning", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00730-00259510-00260039": "our international NGOs which are obliged", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00731-00260040-00260369": "to donors and cultivate us name they", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00732-00260369-00260560": "have strict eye on how much they can", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00733-00260561-00260879": "take on college you guys the ten fifteen", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00734-00260880-00261256": "percent the movie a little bit that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00735-00261257-00263264": "stayed overseas yes they have their own", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00736-00263265-00263509": "strict rules how much they can take out", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00737-00263510-00263747": "of the money or how much they can take", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00738-00263748-00264985": "and back to the comment you have a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00739-00264986-00265285": "naturist now imagine sector from Turkey", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00740-00265286-00265840": "China from India thank you that is that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00741-00265841-00266192": "they are not obliged if you went to a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00742-00266193-00266513": "loss you might have a chart and they are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00743-00266514-00266789": "not even obliged to the new tool which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00744-00266790-00267089": "is called like grandpa gain which is to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00745-00267090-00267692": "from from from Istanbul Sunday to enter", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00746-00267693-00267995": "and summit in 2070 which again Sates you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00747-00267996-00268343": "by how much money can be used for", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00748-00268344-00268640": "program part of project for from program", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00749-00268641-00268988": "part and also for supporting cost so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00750-00268989-00269380": "it's there are new actors it started to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00751-00269381-00269612": "work and big money are going into the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00752-00269613-00269840": "business however the question is Porsha", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00753-00269841-00270180": "native and neutrality of those sectors", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00754-00270181-00270505": "so that is the question actually what is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00755-00270506-00270832": "better if the NGOs do that as to NGOs to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00756-00270833-00271097": "death already taped on that and what", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00757-00271098-00271782": "will be the consequences for", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00758-00271783-00274005": "I think your and I'm not shouting or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00759-00274006-00274564": "disputing the fact that there are let's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00760-00274565-00274977": "say that if USA gives you money the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00761-00274978-00275290": "kinds of conditionalities that come with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00762-00275291-00275388": "it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00763-00275389-00275921": "giver especially right now for example", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00764-00275922-00276367": "anyone who is dealing with even local", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00765-00276368-00276876": "NGOs who are providing health care but", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00766-00276877-00277224": "are also providing abortion cannot", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00767-00277225-00277653": "actually use US aid money at all so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00768-00277654-00277918": "those kinds of conditionalities in a way", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00769-00277919-00278375": "have their ripple effects on you know on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00770-00278376-00278895": "forms of local activism in pretty strong", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00771-00278896-00279088": "ways I think the point that I was trying", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00772-00279089-00279300": "to make was that there is an interesting", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00773-00279301-00279852": "difference between the underlying so you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00774-00279853-00280104": "said about the heart that kind of missed", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00775-00280105-00280219": "the dimension", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00776-00280220-00280649": "for example so there is a kind of longer", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00777-00280650-00281045": "more stable narrative of the manner in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00778-00281046-00281380": "which it's the Vice but they are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00779-00281381-00281827": "ionization of the underlying deeper", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00780-00281828-00282220": "narrative of the white man as the savior", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00781-00282221-00282596": "seems to me to be the point about this I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00782-00282597-00282779": "think that whatever what I was trying to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00783-00282780-00283094": "say well it's very interesting how the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00784-00283095-00283379": "other forms of humanitarianism it's very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00785-00283380-00283652": "like I mean if you are you know if you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00786-00283653-00283962": "think about Saudi humanitarianism in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00787-00283963-00284153": "Islamic countries or if you think about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00788-00284154-00284380": "the fact that in Turkey for example", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00789-00284381-00284744": "refugees you know you could only get", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00790-00284745-00284951": "legally refugee status if you had a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00791-00284952-00285200": "European passport right so you have been", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00792-00285201-00285527": "a new kind of humanitarianism which had", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00793-00285528-00285743": "to be invented which was Islamic", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00794-00285744-00285987": "humanitarianism and the obligation which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00795-00285988-00286226": "goes because of the fact that some", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00796-00286227-00286508": "Muslims and have a saying that in one", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00797-00286509-00286863": "interesting question for me would be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00798-00286864-00287105": "that there is a critique in a certain", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00799-00287106-00287340": "sense of the stability of the white man", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00800-00287341-00287602": "category as a rescuer but there are no", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00801-00287603-00287903": "stable narratives about these other", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00802-00287904-00288143": "forms of humanity reserve which are also", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00803-00288144-00288371": "being brought into existence it'll be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00804-00288372-00288695": "very interesting to compare yeah I'm not", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00805-00288696-00288864": "saying the film should have done it but", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00806-00288865-00289004": "I think that it's a very interesting", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00807-00289005-00289287": "question for me as to you know what", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00808-00289288-00289604": "kinds of comparisons would become", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00809-00289605-00290057": "possible in in in making those persons I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00810-00290058-00290318": "don't know if I answered understood your", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00811-00290319-00290535": "question of whether", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00812-00290536-00290833": "[Music]", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00813-00290834-00291195": "you brethren this scene as something", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00814-00291196-00291701": "like from white man coming somewhere -", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00815-00291702-00292056": "it was also dirtied up in if with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00816-00292057-00292554": "medicine xx in past maybe that was the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00817-00292555-00292914": "message on the other hand you know you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00818-00292915-00293612": "have like 90% of all employees in humans", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00819-00293613-00294051": "who work in the country they know the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00820-00294052-00294467": "country even though of course from", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00821-00294468-00294798": "fundraising perspective I mean", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00822-00294799-00295029": "definitely it's better to shoot pictures", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00823-00295030-00295784": "of white people helping back people so I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00824-00295785-00296070": "understand your point however in the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00825-00296071-00296301": "movie form and we are talking about the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00826-00296302-00296847": "movie now it is a lot of oversimplified", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00827-00296848-00297110": "stick for album oversimplification for", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00828-00297111-00297798": "me okay so when I see you moving in and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00829-00297799-00297963": "first I don't think this is a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00830-00297964-00298224": "documentary in the strict sense of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00831-00298225-00298484": "term right so when I say that I don't", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00832-00298485-00298937": "actually think it's about a transparent", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00833-00298938-00299292": "explicit message I think it's probably", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00834-00299293-00299547": "about creating a certain kind or at", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00835-00299548-00299712": "least that's how it seemed to me that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00836-00299713-00299955": "there's a swirl of effects which are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00837-00299956-00300417": "created light from disgust to you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00838-00300418-00301143": "to to sorrow to shame to you know that I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00839-00301144-00301397": "could name these and say that it's not a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00840-00301398-00301619": "explicit message it's the swirl of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00841-00301620-00301881": "effects that seem to me to be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00842-00301882-00301974": "interesting", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00843-00301975-00302298": "whether that is free successfully", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00844-00302299-00302362": "created", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00845-00302363-00302815": "it is a question for me but hey you know", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00846-00302816-00303049": "I wouldn't judge it in terms of is it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00847-00303050-00303313": "does it have a simplicity of message or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00848-00303314-00303622": "a complexity of message because it seems", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00849-00303623-00303880": "to mean that that would be zooming a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00850-00303881-00304312": "certain kind of you know cinema or", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00851-00304313-00304531": "Verity or something of that kind which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00852-00304532-00304828": "is precisely what it is saying it's not", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00853-00304829-00305044": "which is why the example that I gave", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00854-00305045-00305443": "them let's say so if you took a classic", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00855-00305444-00305770": "film like letter from a dead woman the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00856-00305771-00306097": "signature of the woman is overwritten by", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00857-00306098-00306352": "the signature of the director right so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00858-00306353-00306598": "you know that this is she's not the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00859-00306599-00306901": "author in some way similarly it seems to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00860-00306902-00307138": "me that what it put into question for me", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00861-00307139-00307579": "is really the the manner in which the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00862-00307580-00307981": "way he puts himself into in a film and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00863-00307982-00308431": "thereby also makes a certain parity to", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00864-00308432-00308728": "use David's time I would have preferred", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00865-00308729-00309007": "irony maybe because it creates that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00866-00309008-00309286": "distance in a certain sense that irony", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00867-00309287-00309616": "allows you to do and I think what's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00868-00309617-00309781": "interesting is that the conceptual", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00869-00309782-00310018": "soundings which come come from the moods", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00870-00310019-00310284": "that it creates and not from its", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00871-00310285-00312431": "representational", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00872-00312432-00312715": "the context in a certain sense of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00873-00312716-00312876": "fact that this is calling about the fact", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00874-00312877-00313079": "that these are companies the fact that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00875-00313080-00313410": "300 years 200 years back you know the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00876-00313411-00313650": "name you believed you could find people", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00877-00313651-00313878": "with their hands cut because they were", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00878-00313879-00314103": "not you know in order to send a message", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00879-00314104-00314301": "about a particular kind of discipline", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00880-00314302-00314596": "and so I so to mean that some deeper of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00881-00314597-00314968": "genealogy over here then you know then", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00882-00314969-00315201": "what is there on the surface and I was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00883-00315202-00315424": "trying to get to that deeper genealogy", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00884-00315425-00315712": "would you might keep kind of say it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00885-00315713-00316002": "not really representation in the strict", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00886-00316003-00316431": "sense it brings back you know the swirl", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00887-00316432-00316902": "of memories so to say of what the nature", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00888-00316903-00317310": "of Cruelty and poverty and juxtaposing", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00889-00317311-00317535": "it will be imperative and he says at one", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00890-00317536-00317835": "place you know when he's translating", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00891-00317836-00318223": "enjoy poverty into the French you know I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00892-00318224-00318600": "think and he said none of its the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00893-00318601-00318888": "imperative right and that's a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00894-00318889-00319134": "fantastically interesting moment in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00895-00319135-00319533": "which you as an audience you know are in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00896-00319534-00319854": "a certain sense being marshal through an", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00897-00319855-00320191": "imperative in relationship to the issue", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00898-00320192-00320515": "of what is overwhelming poverty is about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00899-00320516-00320794": "which is why I don't agree we do that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00900-00320795-00321000": "and the first item would relate it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00901-00321001-00321260": "about a message in you know in a very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00902-00321261-00321664": "mechanical communicative model but also", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00903-00321665-00321807": "it's not simple I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00904-00321808-00322170": "it's the the the specificities of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00905-00322171-00322323": "details", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00906-00322324-00322587": "it seemed to me create and what does it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00907-00322588-00323010": "mean to say enjoy is an imperative I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00908-00323011-00323259": "think you know think about it in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00909-00323260-00323433": "everyday life you know the waiter coming", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00910-00323434-00323568": "and putting something down when they", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00911-00323569-00324234": "update and say enjoy it like Wonder and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00912-00324235-00324408": "don't keep playing on both popular", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00913-00324409-00324708": "culture it is also touching on the deep", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00914-00324709-00325092": "registers of language over here as well", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00915-00325093-00325362": "as memory now I really do that they're", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00916-00325363-00325656": "places where if you know can't maintain", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00917-00325657-00325962": "it whether we do yet we could have a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00918-00325963-00326256": "longer discussion very much touch the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00919-00326257-00328187": "Attic but Hank you don't worry", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00920-00328188-00328715": "hello really", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00921-00328716-00329223": "yes I'm sorry but I'm really interested", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00922-00329224-00329442": "in the answer because I'm a little", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00923-00329443-00329820": "secret so I'm really interested in the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00924-00329821-00330093": "answer of yours because I'm a PhD", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00925-00330094-00330534": "student and concerns with application of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00926-00330535-00330860": "lately constants ideas in methodology of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00927-00330861-00331209": "ethnography and anthropology and my", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00928-00331210-00331851": "question is can we apply late with", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00929-00331852-00332154": "instance idea into methodology of this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00930-00332155-00332403": "film because for example there was a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00931-00332404-00332922": "scene in when the director is explaining", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00932-00332923-00333134": "the concept of rationality and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00933-00333135-00333513": "traditional approach to locals and I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00934-00333514-00333897": "think it's really funny because there is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00935-00333898-00334242": "a whole rationality debates around this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00936-00334243-00334765": "concept and your opinion", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00937-00334766-00335467": "[Music]", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00938-00335468-00335864": "today that's a wonderful question", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00939-00335865-00336131": "but that's actually very crucial scene", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00940-00336132-00336395": "right because even they can't tell you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00941-00336396-00336848": "what you have is a certain kind of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00942-00336849-00337280": "parody of what rationality can become", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00943-00337281-00337673": "when if what the vet says is that it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00944-00337674-00337946": "becomes demonic right so the whole", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00945-00337947-00338243": "appearance of skepticism in Wittgenstein", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00946-00338244-00338510": "happens because rationality turns on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00947-00338511-00338750": "itself so when you see this particular", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00948-00338751-00338930": "thing and you're doing all this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00949-00338931-00339167": "cost-benefit analysis and saying instead", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00950-00339168-00339389": "of doing parties you should really be", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00951-00339390-00339704": "taking photographs of more women and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00952-00339705-00340444": "more you know more malnutrition children", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00953-00340445-00340655": "right and then they're going to this", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00954-00340656-00340877": "office in missing white on this being a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00955-00340878-00341132": "journalistic enterprise if you can see", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00956-00341133-00341366": "over there that it is in a certain sense", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00957-00341367-00341792": "a particular way in which rationality", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00958-00341793-00342191": "you know turns demonic I mean think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00959-00342192-00342611": "about the flight from anything", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00960-00342612-00343024": "recognizable as human when you're", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00961-00343025-00343412": "commerce becomes a commerce of being", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00962-00343413-00343718": "able to assimilate or to accumulate more", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00963-00343719-00344168": "and more pictures of raped women or more", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00964-00344169-00344408": "and more pictures of manner to show", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00965-00344409-00344531": "children right", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00966-00344532-00344756": "so it's performing in a certain sense", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00967-00344757-00345083": "that critique of the way reality that is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00968-00345084-00345395": "selling to the you know to the villagers", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00969-00345396-00345866": "at that particular moment and it's you", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00970-00345867-00346091": "know it had very strong the soundings", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00971-00346092-00346517": "for me with even more than the consent", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00972-00346518-00346627": "to well is treating", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00973-00346628-00346969": "instead where he says you know but he", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00974-00346970-00347290": "says that what is happening over here is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00975-00347291-00347611": "not a contrast between rationality and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00976-00347612-00347920": "irrationality with rationality turning", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00977-00347921-00348247": "demonic on itself so yes thanks that's a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00978-00348248-00348567": "very I think that's a very perceptive", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00979-00348568-00349008": "just arresting a comment on that about", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00980-00349009-00349291": "not so much better ashen algebra picking", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00981-00349292-00349594": "up from that particular scene or the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00982-00349595-00349870": "scenes before to contrast the the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00983-00349871-00350113": "photographs of the marriages of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00984-00350114-00350431": "festival's and so on where it's clear", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00985-00350432-00350749": "that the question of ownership where the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00986-00350750-00350980": "ownership of the image is in a sense", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00987-00350981-00351304": "with the families and the photographer", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00988-00351305-00351724": "is the as it were the client and so it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00989-00351725-00351859": "not the rationality is one which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00990-00351860-00352225": "switches the nature of property and very", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00991-00352226-00352441": "explicitly that does so and I think that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00992-00352442-00352648": "said that's another source of elements", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00993-00352649-00352831": "of that particular kind of rationality", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00994-00352832-00353044": "in relation to property ownership and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00995-00353045-00353395": "the power evolve one more element like", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00996-00353396-00353614": "this demonic you said is demonic and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00997-00353615-00353821": "then you see also this reproduction of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00998-00353822-00354013": "the system exploitation of Natural", "d2OU5FeQQGo-00999-00354014-00354193": "Resources gold and everything that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01000-00354194-00354406": "capitalism brings and he actually", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01001-00354407-00354580": "predicts the same principle into the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01002-00354581-00354766": "dealing with the image right so he", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01003-00354767-00354994": "brings the capitalistic logic ceiling", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01004-00354995-00355213": "disturbs the image of the suffering so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01005-00355214-00355955": "this is this demonic also very important", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01006-00355956-00357995": "[Music]", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01007-00357996-00358758": "so salt is a better thing for suffering", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01008-00358759-00358992": "phenomena so midnight oven which is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01009-00358993-00359193": "really interesting so he's taking their", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01010-00359194-00359271": "own image", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01011-00359272-00359799": "maintenance culture salt here there's a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01012-00359800-00360189": "difference between making sculpture and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01013-00360190-00360570": "selling it and you know assuming that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01014-00360571-00360837": "what is saleable is pictures of raped", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01015-00360838-00361176": "women yo man don't you share anything so", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01016-00361177-00361425": "that is big turning that I thought was", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01017-00361426-00361626": "very yeah that's what I mean by", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01018-00361627-00362154": "effective Banach yeah finishing yeah I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01019-00362155-00362298": "think this is very important because", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01020-00362299-00362466": "that's what you were talking about the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01021-00362467-00362763": "property of who is the young owner he's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01022-00362764-00363024": "taking her they are not anymore the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01023-00363025-00363312": "objects of the photographs but they are", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01024-00363313-00363573": "making their images and they are selling", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01025-00363574-00364529": "it and you can you can buy its website", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01026-00364530-00364944": "no no I just wanted to add that the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01027-00364945-00365259": "rationality which turns to where it's", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01028-00365260-00365616": "rationally there becomes demonic that in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01029-00365617-00366005": "this particular this particular scene", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01030-00366006-00366330": "with the boys look at the cameras and", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01031-00366331-00366791": "they are trying to make", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01032-00366792-00367193": "I think important the the meaning of", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01033-00367194-00367774": "this team beside the others is that it", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01034-00367775-00368291": "ends with an aesthetic it ends with the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01035-00368292-00368684": "fact that the director or the main", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01036-00368685-00369071": "doctor says but while look at the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01037-00369072-00369359": "pictures you know the taking pictures is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01038-00369360-00369839": "not just about clicking the button and I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01039-00369840-00370085": "think that's the point which is being", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01040-00370086-00370436": "timid iess than the whole film the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01041-00370437-00370688": "aesthetic the the image is the way we", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01042-00370689-00370985": "perceive them and the power of that as", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01043-00370986-00374230": "well governance the governments of the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01044-00374231-00374563": "circuits over anything", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01045-00374564-00375308": "- anathema T's also it is the question", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01046-00375309-00375638": "of aesthetics and is the question in", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01047-00375639-00376067": "Western culture tradition and I think", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01048-00376068-00376349": "you in in this point you would say a lot", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01049-00376350-00376808": "of that you know how human or the black", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01050-00376809-00377302": "people were introduced to Western people", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01051-00377303-00377514": "during the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01052-00377515-00378073": "what were the images there is a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01053-00378074-00378321": "difference between an image and a", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01054-00378322-00378969": "picture right so that in one way I guess", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01055-00378970-00379304": "my question here would be that there is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01056-00379305-00379623": "of course a different aesthetic plant is", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01057-00379624-00379982": "being introduced that where the camera", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01058-00379983-00380359": "is and what is it going for personal on", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01059-00380360-00380673": "but this is a question over here whether", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01060-00380674-00381050": "that kind of aesthetic is not premised", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01061-00381051-00381393": "on what we will send call a picture", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01062-00381394-00381704": "other than an image of the saleability", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01063-00381705-00382298": "or you know so so it comes in a way I", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01064-00382299-00382478": "think the closeness of that the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01065-00382479-00382751": "pornography which is not shown but which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01066-00382752-00382958": "seems to win to be part of that is that", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01067-00382959-00383450": "a rag is is what is at stake with which", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01068-00383451-00383616": "is why I think it's normal", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01069-00383617-00383900": "Oh me it's not so much about ownership", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01070-00383901-00384182": "as about circulation you know and the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01071-00384183-00384369": "fact that they show yourselves", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01072-00384370-00386582": "yeah but the questions you can ask the", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01073-00386583-00386906": "father is come to the end I would like", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01074-00386907-00387883": "to see you very much for coming through", "d2OU5FeQQGo-01075-00387884-00388205": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "d2PeeONT8sI", "text": {"d2PeeONT8sI-00000-00000038-00000278": "Ritwik Ghatak listen the fourth of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00001-00000279-00000586": "November 1925 to the sixth of February", "d2PeeONT8sI-00002-00000587-00000866": "1976 was a Bengali filmmaker and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00003-00000867-00001106": "scriptwriter along with prominent", "d2PeeONT8sI-00004-00001107-00001366": "contemporary Bengali filmmakers Satyajit", "d2PeeONT8sI-00005-00001367-00001565": "Ray and rental Sen his cinema is", "d2PeeONT8sI-00006-00001566-00001763": "primarily remembered for its meticulous", "d2PeeONT8sI-00007-00001764-00002002": "depiction of social reality although", "d2PeeONT8sI-00008-00002003-00002227": "their roles were often adversarial they", "d2PeeONT8sI-00009-00002228-00002392": "were ardent admirers of each other's", "d2PeeONT8sI-00010-00002393-00002626": "work and in doing so the three directors", "d2PeeONT8sI-00011-00002627-00002813": "charted the independent trajectory of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00012-00002814-00003029": "parallel cinema as a counterpoint to the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00013-00003030-00003256": "mainstream fare of Hindi cinema in India", "d2PeeONT8sI-00014-00003257-00003506": "ghatak received many awards in his", "d2PeeONT8sI-00015-00003507-00003731": "career including national film awards", "d2PeeONT8sI-00016-00003732-00004070": "Rajat Kamal award for best story in 1974", "d2PeeONT8sI-00017-00004071-00004343": "for his juk T taco aar gap oh and best", "d2PeeONT8sI-00018-00004344-00004550": "directors award from Bangladesh cine", "d2PeeONT8sI-00019-00004551-00004754": "Journalists Association for tight a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00020-00004755-00005000": "Shakti nadir naam the Government of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00021-00005001-00005159": "India honoured him with the Padma Shri", "d2PeeONT8sI-00022-00005160-00005854": "for Arts in 1970", "d2PeeONT8sI-00023-00005855-00006556": "topic early life Ritwik Ghatak was born", "d2PeeONT8sI-00024-00006558-00006805": "in dhaka in east bengal now bangladesh", "d2PeeONT8sI-00025-00006806-00007114": "god x father suresh chandra ghatak was a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00026-00007115-00007309": "district magistrate and a poet and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00027-00007311-00007498": "playwright his mother's name was Indu", "d2PeeONT8sI-00028-00007500-00007813": "Bala Devi he and his twin sister / DT", "d2PeeONT8sI-00029-00007814-00008066": "were the youngest of nine children the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00030-00008067-00008282": "other children were Manish Sudesh -", "d2PeeONT8sI-00031-00008283-00008603": "potty Sam Preeti roto T Ashish Chandra", "d2PeeONT8sI-00032-00008604-00008849": "and Lokesh Chandra he and his family", "d2PeeONT8sI-00033-00008850-00009091": "moved to Bern poor Murshidabad and then", "d2PeeONT8sI-00034-00009092-00009320": "to Calcutta now Kolkata just before", "d2PeeONT8sI-00035-00009321-00009499": "millions of other refugees from East", "d2PeeONT8sI-00036-00009500-00009683": "Bengal began to flood into the city", "d2PeeONT8sI-00037-00009684-00009889": "fleeing the catastrophic Bengal famine", "d2PeeONT8sI-00038-00009890-00010198": "of 1943 and the partition of Bengal in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00039-00010199-00010529": "1947 identification with this tide of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00040-00010530-00010733": "refugees was to define his practice", "d2PeeONT8sI-00041-00010734-00010937": "providing an overriding metaphor for", "d2PeeONT8sI-00042-00010938-00011108": "cultural dismemberment and exile that", "d2PeeONT8sI-00043-00011109-00011424": "unified his subsequent creative work the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00044-00011425-00011749": "1971 Bangladesh Liberation war which led", "d2PeeONT8sI-00045-00011750-00011971": "to more refugees fleeing to India was to", "d2PeeONT8sI-00046-00011972-00012646": "have a similar impact on his work", "d2PeeONT8sI-00047-00012647-00013366": "topic family ritwik married sarama Devi", "d2PeeONT8sI-00048-00013368-00013597": "niece of active left-wing member sadhana", "d2PeeONT8sI-00049-00013598-00013871": "roy chowdhury they separated and she", "d2PeeONT8sI-00050-00013872-00014066": "went to her ancestral place Shillong", "d2PeeONT8sI-00051-00014066-00014269": "after ritwik was temporarily sent to a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00052-00014270-00014522": "mental hospital they had three children", "d2PeeONT8sI-00053-00014522-00014738": "a son ribbon and two daughters", "d2PeeONT8sI-00054-00014738-00015133": "Sumida and Suja Smita writ a band as a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00055-00015134-00015305": "filmmaker in his own right and is", "d2PeeONT8sI-00056-00015306-00015599": "involved in the ritwik memorial trust he", "d2PeeONT8sI-00057-00015600-00015853": "has restored Rix bagel our Banga darshan", "d2PeeONT8sI-00058-00015854-00016037": "wrong or golem and completed his", "d2PeeONT8sI-00059-00016038-00016333": "unfinished documentary on RAM concur he", "d2PeeONT8sI-00060-00016334-00016541": "has also made a film titled unfinished", "d2PeeONT8sI-00061-00016542-00016790": "ritwik he is now working on adapting by", "d2PeeONT8sI-00062-00016791-00016991": "Buddha Bhushan Bandopadhyay s novel I", "d2PeeONT8sI-00063-00016992-00017264": "kamati Rick's elder daughter samhita has", "d2PeeONT8sI-00064-00017265-00017497": "made a document I'd old no bone agaric", "d2PeeONT8sI-00065-00017498-00017930": "his younger daughter died in 2009 God", "d2PeeONT8sI-00066-00017931-00018119": "excelled ur brother Manish ghatak was a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00067-00018120-00018341": "radical writer of his time a professor", "d2PeeONT8sI-00068-00018342-00018539": "of English and a social activist who was", "d2PeeONT8sI-00069-00018540-00018772": "deeply involved with the IPTA theatre", "d2PeeONT8sI-00070-00018773-00018941": "movement in its heyday and later on", "d2PeeONT8sI-00071-00018942-00019124": "headed the toboggan Andolan of north", "d2PeeONT8sI-00072-00019125-00019391": "bengal manish gothics daughter as the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00073-00019392-00020080": "writer and activist mahasweta devi", "d2PeeONT8sI-00074-00020081-00020638": "topic creative career", "d2PeeONT8sI-00075-00020639-00020980": "in 1948 gothic wrote his first play kale", "d2PeeONT8sI-00076-00020981-00021244": "OCR the dark Lake and participated in a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00077-00021245-00021507": "revival of the landmark play Nibbana in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00078-00021508-00021850": "1951 gothic Indian people's theatre", "d2PeeONT8sI-00079-00021851-00022015": "Association IPTA", "d2PeeONT8sI-00080-00022016-00022330": "he wrote directed and acted in plays and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00081-00022331-00022549": "translated Bertolt Brecht and Gogol into", "d2PeeONT8sI-00082-00022550-00022912": "Bengali in the early 1970s he wrote and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00083-00022913-00023149": "directed his last play Jolla the burning", "d2PeeONT8sI-00084-00023150-00023431": "the music director was Darbar bhaduri", "d2PeeONT8sI-00085-00023432-00023743": "who is called by God ah or guru God ik", "d2PeeONT8sI-00086-00023744-00023950": "was greatly inspired by Darbar bhaduri", "d2PeeONT8sI-00087-00023951-00024313": "in Rajshahi bangladesh his homeland", "d2PeeONT8sI-00088-00024314-00024522": "ritwik had lived next door to be burries", "d2PeeONT8sI-00089-00024523-00024796": "house dhadak entered the film industry", "d2PeeONT8sI-00090-00024797-00025093": "with me my Ghosh's Chinna Mille 1950 as", "d2PeeONT8sI-00091-00025094-00025267": "actor and assistant director", "d2PeeONT8sI-00092-00025268-00025531": "Chinna mol was followed in two years by", "d2PeeONT8sI-00093-00025532-00025750": "gothics first completed film Nagar in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00094-00025751-00026028": "1952 both major breakthroughs for the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00095-00026029-00026299": "Indian cinema ghatak surly work sought", "d2PeeONT8sI-00096-00026300-00026506": "theatrical and literary precedent in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00097-00026507-00026713": "bringing together a documentary realism", "d2PeeONT8sI-00098-00026714-00026935": "a stylized performance often drawn from", "d2PeeONT8sI-00099-00026936-00027133": "the folk theatre and a Brechtian use of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00100-00027133-00027412": "the filmic apparatus God X first", "d2PeeONT8sI-00101-00027413-00027685": "commercial release was a John Trick 1958", "d2PeeONT8sI-00102-00027686-00027895": "a comedy-drama film with science fiction", "d2PeeONT8sI-00103-00027895-00028189": "themes it was one of the earliest Indian", "d2PeeONT8sI-00104-00028189-00028411": "films to portray an inanimate object in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00105-00028412-00028627": "this case an automobile as a character", "d2PeeONT8sI-00106-00028627-00028914": "in the story God exists", "d2PeeONT8sI-00107-00028916-00029125": "success as a scriptwriter was for", "d2PeeONT8sI-00108-00029126-00029374": "madhumathi 1958 one of the earliest", "d2PeeONT8sI-00109-00029375-00029508": "films to deal with the theme of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00110-00029510-00029770": "reincarnation it was a hindi film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00111-00029770-00029977": "directed by another Bengali filmmaker", "d2PeeONT8sI-00112-00029977-00030262": "Bimal Roy it earned God ik his first", "d2PeeONT8sI-00113-00030263-00030475": "Award nomination for the Filmfare best", "d2PeeONT8sI-00114-00030476-00030799": "story award Ritwik Ghatak directed", "d2PeeONT8sI-00115-00030800-00031020": "eighth full-length films his best-known", "d2PeeONT8sI-00116-00031022-00031326": "films Meghdoot era the cloud-capped star", "d2PeeONT8sI-00117-00031327-00031440": "1960", "d2PeeONT8sI-00118-00031441-00031740": "Komal Gandhari flat 1961 and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00119-00031741-00032052": "Subarnarekha golden lining 1962 a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00120-00032054-00032293": "trilogy based in Calcutta and addressing", "d2PeeONT8sI-00121-00032294-00032476": "the condition of refugee hood proved", "d2PeeONT8sI-00122-00032477-00032662": "controversial and the commercial failure", "d2PeeONT8sI-00123-00032663-00032923": "of Komal Gandhari flat and Subarnarekha", "d2PeeONT8sI-00124-00032924-00033109": "prevented him from making features", "d2PeeONT8sI-00125-00033110-00033325": "through the remainder of the 1960s in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00126-00033326-00033621": "all three he used a basic and at times", "d2PeeONT8sI-00127-00033622-00033862": "starkly realistic storyline upon which", "d2PeeONT8sI-00128-00033863-00034036": "he inscribed a range of mythic", "d2PeeONT8sI-00129-00034037-00034207": "references especially of the mother", "d2PeeONT8sI-00130-00034208-00034378": "deliver through a dense overlay of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00131-00034379-00034702": "visual and oral registers Gajic moved", "d2PeeONT8sI-00132-00034703-00035017": "briefly to pune in 1966 where he taught", "d2PeeONT8sI-00133-00035018-00035212": "at the film and television Institute of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00134-00035213-00035568": "India FTII his students included film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00135-00035569-00035871": "makers Monty Colin Kumar Shahani during", "d2PeeONT8sI-00136-00035872-00036127": "his year at FTII he was involved in the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00137-00036128-00036328": "making of two student films fear and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00138-00036329-00036532": "rendezvous ghatak returned to filmmaking", "d2PeeONT8sI-00139-00036533-00036823": "in the 1970s when a Bangladeshi producer", "d2PeeONT8sI-00140-00036824-00037137": "financed the 1973 epic tight a Shakti", "d2PeeONT8sI-00141-00037138-00037437": "nadir Nam a river called Titus making", "d2PeeONT8sI-00142-00037438-00037627": "films became difficult because of his", "d2PeeONT8sI-00143-00037628-00037849": "poor health due to extreme alcoholism", "d2PeeONT8sI-00144-00037850-00038140": "and consequent diseases his last film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00145-00038141-00038380": "was the autobiographical Chuck T taco", "d2PeeONT8sI-00146-00038381-00038776": "aar gappa reason debate and story 1974", "d2PeeONT8sI-00147-00038777-00038998": "in which he portrayed milk and milk on", "d2PeeONT8sI-00148-00038999-00039286": "the lead character he also had a number", "d2PeeONT8sI-00149-00039287-00039496": "of incomplete feature and short films in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00150-00039497-00040024": "his credit", "d2PeeONT8sI-00151-00040025-00040626": "topic bagel our baingan", "d2PeeONT8sI-00152-00040627-00041010": "bagel our Banga darshan 1964 Bengali", "d2PeeONT8sI-00153-00041011-00041211": "bagel Arab Angad her Santa as an", "d2PeeONT8sI-00154-00041212-00041421": "incomplete Bengali film created by", "d2PeeONT8sI-00155-00041422-00041702": "legendary filmmaker Ritwik Ghatak the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00156-00041703-00041898": "film was shot for one week only and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00157-00041899-00042065": "later it was abandoned and the film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00158-00042066-00042336": "remained incomplete recently ritwik", "d2PeeONT8sI-00159-00042337-00042504": "Memorial Trust has collected the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00160-00042505-00042702": "available reels of the film and after", "d2PeeONT8sI-00161-00042703-00042876": "their work of re-editing they published", "d2PeeONT8sI-00162-00042877-00043065": "four reels of the film which has six", "d2PeeONT8sI-00163-00043066-00043233": "songs which were recorded before the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00164-00043234-00043512": "shooting Ritwik Ghatak not only was the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00165-00043513-00043692": "director of the film he also wrote the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00166-00043693-00043962": "story in the screenplay the plot of the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00167-00043963-00044154": "story was inspired by a film of an", "d2PeeONT8sI-00168-00044155-00044758": "Italian director blue Sethi", "d2PeeONT8sI-00169-00044759-00045289": "topic cast and crew", "d2PeeONT8sI-00170-00045290-00045554": "you", "d2PeeONT8sI-00171-00045555-00046011": "topic cast", "d2PeeONT8sI-00172-00046012-00046274": "you", "d2PeeONT8sI-00173-00046275-00046723": "topic Furio", "d2PeeONT8sI-00174-00046724-00047011": "you", "d2PeeONT8sI-00175-00047012-00047474": "topic script", "d2PeeONT8sI-00176-00047475-00047739": "days publishing Kolkata has published", "d2PeeONT8sI-00177-00047740-00047930": "the script in the form of a book titled", "d2PeeONT8sI-00178-00047931-00048389": "same as the film ISBN 81 to 290 505 to", "d2PeeONT8sI-00179-00048390-00048958": "4x", "d2PeeONT8sI-00180-00048959-00049554": "topic impact an influence", "d2PeeONT8sI-00181-00049555-00049880": "at the time of his death February 1976", "d2PeeONT8sI-00182-00049881-00050096": "God X prime area influence would seem to", "d2PeeONT8sI-00183-00050097-00050318": "have been through former students though", "d2PeeONT8sI-00184-00050319-00050555": "his stint teaching film at FTII was", "d2PeeONT8sI-00185-00050556-00050805": "brief one time students Monty Hall John", "d2PeeONT8sI-00186-00050806-00051033": "Abraham and especially Kumar Shahani", "d2PeeONT8sI-00187-00051034-00051266": "among many others carried ghatak side is", "d2PeeONT8sI-00188-00051267-00051413": "and theories which were further", "d2PeeONT8sI-00189-00051414-00051654": "elaborated upon in his book cinema and I", "d2PeeONT8sI-00190-00051654-00051851": "into the mainstream of Indian art film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00191-00051852-00052130": "other students of his at the FTII", "d2PeeONT8sI-00192-00052132-00052352": "included the acclaimed filmmakers Syed", "d2PeeONT8sI-00193-00052353-00052538": "actor Mirza and Adoor Gopalakrishnan", "d2PeeONT8sI-00194-00052539-00052794": "Ghatak stood entirely outside the world", "d2PeeONT8sI-00195-00052795-00053054": "of Indian commercial film none of the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00196-00053055-00053196": "elements of the commercial cinema", "d2PeeONT8sI-00197-00053197-00053466": "singing and dancing melodrama stars", "d2PeeONT8sI-00198-00053466-00053751": "glitz featured in his work he was", "d2PeeONT8sI-00199-00053752-00053919": "watched by students and intelligentsia", "d2PeeONT8sI-00200-00053920-00054216": "not by the masses his students have", "d2PeeONT8sI-00201-00054216-00054404": "tended to work in the art cinema or", "d2PeeONT8sI-00202-00054405-00054704": "independent cinema tradition while other", "d2PeeONT8sI-00203-00054705-00054948": "neo-realist directors like satyajit ray", "d2PeeONT8sI-00204-00054949-00055130": "succeeded in creating an audience", "d2PeeONT8sI-00205-00055132-00055311": "outside india during their lifetime", "d2PeeONT8sI-00206-00055312-00055584": "Ghatak was not so fortunate while he was", "d2PeeONT8sI-00207-00055585-00055781": "alive his films were appreciated", "d2PeeONT8sI-00208-00055782-00056091": "primarily within India satyajit ray did", "d2PeeONT8sI-00209-00056091-00056241": "what he could to promote his colleague", "d2PeeONT8sI-00210-00056241-00056400": "but Ray's generous praise did not", "d2PeeONT8sI-00211-00056401-00056622": "translate into international fame forgot", "d2PeeONT8sI-00212-00056623-00056997": "'ok for example god' ixnay gur at 1952", "d2PeeONT8sI-00213-00056998-00057219": "was perhaps the earliest example of a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00214-00057220-00057459": "bengali art film preceding ray's Pather", "d2PeeONT8sI-00215-00057460-00057648": "Panchali by three years but was not", "d2PeeONT8sI-00216-00057649-00057911": "released until after his death in 1977", "d2PeeONT8sI-00217-00057912-00058181": "his first commercial release a John", "d2PeeONT8sI-00218-00058182-00058428": "Trick 1955 was one of the earliest", "d2PeeONT8sI-00219-00058429-00058616": "Indian films to portray an inanimate", "d2PeeONT8sI-00220-00058617-00058866": "object an automobile as a character in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00221-00058866-00059061": "the story many years before the Herbie", "d2PeeONT8sI-00222-00059062-00059487": "films God expiry take a Paley 1958 had a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00223-00059488-00059715": "similar plot to Francois Truffaut at the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00224-00059716-00060069": "400 blows 1959 the god X film remained", "d2PeeONT8sI-00225-00060070-00060246": "obscure while true fat's went on to", "d2PeeONT8sI-00226-00060247-00060411": "become one of the most famous of the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00227-00060412-00060830": "French new-wave one of God Xfinity may", "d2PeeONT8sI-00228-00060832-00061140": "tear naam 1973 is one of the earliest to", "d2PeeONT8sI-00229-00061141-00061353": "be told in a hyperlink format featuring", "d2PeeONT8sI-00230-00061354-00061554": "multiple characters in a collection of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00231-00061554-00061781": "interconnected stories predating Robert", "d2PeeONT8sI-00232-00061782-00062216": "Altman's Nashville 1975 by two years God", "d2PeeONT8sI-00233-00062217-00062429": "Excel major commercial success was", "d2PeeONT8sI-00234-00062430-00062721": "madhumathi 1958 a hindi film which he", "d2PeeONT8sI-00235-00062722-00062891": "wrote the screenplay for", "d2PeeONT8sI-00236-00062892-00063090": "it was one of the earliest to deal with", "d2PeeONT8sI-00237-00063091-00063251": "the theme of reincarnation and is", "d2PeeONT8sI-00238-00063252-00063390": "believed to have been the source of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00239-00063391-00063615": "inspiration for many later works dealing", "d2PeeONT8sI-00240-00063616-00063791": "with reincarnation in Indian cinema", "d2PeeONT8sI-00241-00063792-00064007": "Indian television and perhaps world", "d2PeeONT8sI-00242-00064008-00064251": "cinema it may have been the source of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00243-00064252-00064449": "inspiration for the American film the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00244-00064450-00064769": "reincarnation of peter proud 1975 and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00245-00064770-00065037": "the hindi film cars 1980 both of which", "d2PeeONT8sI-00246-00065038-00065219": "dealt with reincarnation and have been", "d2PeeONT8sI-00247-00065220-00065426": "influential in their respective cultures", "d2PeeONT8sI-00248-00065427-00065718": "cars in particular was remade several", "d2PeeONT8sI-00249-00065719-00065975": "times as the Kannada film Yuga Purusha", "d2PeeONT8sI-00250-00065976-00066275": "1989 the tamil film in nicole or even", "d2PeeONT8sI-00251-00066276-00066537": "1984 and more recently the Bollywood", "d2PeeONT8sI-00252-00066538-00066891": "Cars 2008 cars in the reincarnation of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00253-00066892-00067065": "peter proud may have inspired the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00254-00067066-00067388": "american chances are 1989 the most", "d2PeeONT8sI-00255-00067389-00067596": "recent film to be directly inspired by", "d2PeeONT8sI-00256-00067597-00067812": "madhumathi was the hit Bollywood film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00257-00067813-00067917": "ohm shanthi ohm", "d2PeeONT8sI-00258-00067918-00068181": "2007 which led to the late Bimal Roy's", "d2PeeONT8sI-00259-00068182-00068403": "daughter rinky Bhattacharya accusing it", "d2PeeONT8sI-00260-00068404-00068571": "of plagiarism and threatening legal", "d2PeeONT8sI-00261-00068572-00068811": "action against its producers god X works", "d2PeeONT8sI-00262-00068812-00069006": "as a director influenced many later", "d2PeeONT8sI-00263-00069007-00069210": "Indian filmmakers including those from", "d2PeeONT8sI-00264-00069211-00069440": "the Bengali film industry and elsewhere", "d2PeeONT8sI-00265-00069441-00069696": "gothic is said to have influences on", "d2PeeONT8sI-00266-00069697-00069954": "Kumar Shahani money call Ketan Mehta and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00267-00069955-00070272": "Adoor Gopalakrishnan for example Mira", "d2PeeONT8sI-00268-00070273-00070497": "Nair has cited gothic as well as ray as", "d2PeeONT8sI-00269-00070498-00070700": "the reason she became a filmmaker", "d2PeeONT8sI-00270-00070701-00070980": "gothics influences a director began to", "d2PeeONT8sI-00271-00070981-00071199": "spread beyond India much later beginning", "d2PeeONT8sI-00272-00071200-00071466": "in the 1990s a project to restore God", "d2PeeONT8sI-00273-00071467-00071700": "exfils was undertaken and international", "d2PeeONT8sI-00274-00071701-00071943": "exhibitions and subsequent DVD releases", "d2PeeONT8sI-00275-00071944-00072174": "have belatedly generated an increasingly", "d2PeeONT8sI-00276-00072175-00072456": "global audience in a critics poll of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00277-00072457-00072669": "all-time greatest films conducted by the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00278-00072670-00072969": "Asian film magazine cinema in 1998", "d2PeeONT8sI-00279-00072970-00073206": "Subarnarekha was ranked at number 11 in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00280-00073207-00073526": "the 2002 sight and sound critics and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00281-00073527-00073701": "directors poll for all-time greatest", "d2PeeONT8sI-00282-00073702-00073943": "films Meghdoot era was ranked at number", "d2PeeONT8sI-00283-00073944-00074438": "231 in Komal Gondar at number 346 in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00284-00074439-00074715": "2007 a river named teeta's topped the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00285-00074716-00074946": "list of ten best Bangladeshi films as", "d2PeeONT8sI-00286-00074947-00075147": "chosen in the audience and critics polls", "d2PeeONT8sI-00287-00075148-00075356": "conducted by the british film institute", "d2PeeONT8sI-00288-00075357-00075666": "russia born german actress elena kazan", "d2PeeONT8sI-00289-00075667-00075932": "once said god expect a taco Guapo has", "d2PeeONT8sI-00290-00075933-00076131": "the most profound influence on her view", "d2PeeONT8sI-00291-00076132-00076224": "about world sin", "d2PeeONT8sI-00292-00076225-00076476": "Bangladeshi filmmaker shahnawaz Coco Lee", "d2PeeONT8sI-00293-00076477-00076671": "said she has been greatly influenced by", "d2PeeONT8sI-00294-00076672-00076896": "Ritwik Ghatak films and regarded ghatak", "d2PeeONT8sI-00295-00076897-00077205": "as her idol she said like all Bengalis I", "d2PeeONT8sI-00296-00077206-00077379": "too have grown up watching movies of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00297-00077380-00077571": "Satyajit Ray and Ghatak though I like", "d2PeeONT8sI-00298-00077572-00077829": "God ik more and I idolize him I am", "d2PeeONT8sI-00299-00077830-00078034": "greatly inspired by him and consequently", "d2PeeONT8sI-00300-00078035-00078294": "my movie Butare sir northern symphony", "d2PeeONT8sI-00301-00078295-00078960": "too is influenced by gothic", "d2PeeONT8sI-00302-00078961-00079460": "topic works", "d2PeeONT8sI-00303-00079461-00079681": "though Ghatak is mainly known as film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00304-00079682-00079885": "director he wrote many stories and plays", "d2PeeONT8sI-00305-00079886-00080200": "in his creative career gothic made 8", "d2PeeONT8sI-00306-00080201-00080410": "full-length feature films and few short", "d2PeeONT8sI-00307-00080411-00080554": "films and documentaries", "d2PeeONT8sI-00308-00080555-00080834": "he also wrote many short stories plays", "d2PeeONT8sI-00309-00080835-00081103": "and poetry's Ghatak wrote more than 50", "d2PeeONT8sI-00310-00081104-00081730": "articles and essays on film", "d2PeeONT8sI-00311-00081731-00082272": "topic ideology", "d2PeeONT8sI-00312-00082273-00082542": "ghatak was not only a film director he", "d2PeeONT8sI-00313-00082543-00082791": "was a theorist to his views and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00314-00082792-00082998": "commentaries on films have been parts of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00315-00082999-00083253": "scholarly studies and researches as a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00316-00083254-00083487": "filmmaker his main concentration was on", "d2PeeONT8sI-00317-00083488-00083655": "men and life and especially the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00318-00083656-00083928": "day-to-day struggle of ordinary men he", "d2PeeONT8sI-00319-00083929-00084087": "could never accept the partition of", "d2PeeONT8sI-00320-00084088-00084414": "India of 1947 which divided Bengal into", "d2PeeONT8sI-00321-00084415-00084714": "two countries in almost all his film he", "d2PeeONT8sI-00322-00084715-00084906": "dealt with this theme filmmaking was not", "d2PeeONT8sI-00323-00084907-00085185": "only art for him in his opinion it was", "d2PeeONT8sI-00324-00085186-00085353": "only a means to the end of serving", "d2PeeONT8sI-00325-00085354-00085554": "people it was only a means of expressing", "d2PeeONT8sI-00326-00085555-00085707": "his anger at the sorrows and sufferings", "d2PeeONT8sI-00327-00085708-00085893": "of his people he was a lifelong", "d2PeeONT8sI-00328-00085894-00086172": "communist and actively supported CPI in", "d2PeeONT8sI-00329-00086173-00086415": "his earlier life he believed that the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00330-00086416-00086604": "film was just a medium of his larger", "d2PeeONT8sI-00331-00086605-00086841": "thoughts about the society he could", "d2PeeONT8sI-00332-00086842-00087015": "easily leave filmmaking and adopt", "d2PeeONT8sI-00333-00087016-00087195": "another form of art if that could better", "d2PeeONT8sI-00334-00087196-00087387": "represent his unique vision of both the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00335-00087388-00087582": "individual self in the society as a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00336-00087583-00087849": "whole but due to his independent nature", "d2PeeONT8sI-00337-00087850-00088083": "the CPI Calcutta District Committee", "d2PeeONT8sI-00338-00088084-00088556": "expelled him in the 21st of October 1955", "d2PeeONT8sI-00339-00088557-00088842": "Topic Awards honors and recognitions", "d2PeeONT8sI-00340-00088843-00089109": "Padma Shri for Arts in 1970 by the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00341-00089110-00089403": "Government of India Musafir had won the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00342-00089404-00089586": "certificate of merit for third best", "d2PeeONT8sI-00343-00089587-00089972": "feature film at v awards in 1957", "d2PeeONT8sI-00344-00089973-00090255": "madhumathi nominated for Filmfare best", "d2PeeONT8sI-00345-00090256-00090561": "story award National Film Awards Rajat", "d2PeeONT8sI-00346-00090562-00090882": "Kamal Award for Best story in 1974 for", "d2PeeONT8sI-00347-00090883-00091239": "Chuck T taco aar gaba best directors", "d2PeeONT8sI-00348-00091240-00091464": "award from Bangladesh cine Journalists", "d2PeeONT8sI-00349-00091465-00091707": "Association for type A Shakti nadir naam", "d2PeeONT8sI-00350-00091708-00091977": "a John Trick got special entry in the", "d2PeeONT8sI-00351-00091978-00092316": "Venice Film Festival in 1959 in a", "d2PeeONT8sI-00352-00092317-00092532": "critics poll of all-time greatest films", "d2PeeONT8sI-00353-00092533-00092775": "conducted by Asian film magazine cinema", "d2PeeONT8sI-00354-00092776-00093054": "in 1998 Subarnarekha was ranked at", "d2PeeONT8sI-00355-00093055-00093189": "number 11 on the list", "d2PeeONT8sI-00356-00093190-00093519": "in the 2002 sight and sound critics and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00357-00093520-00093696": "directors poll for all-time greatest", "d2PeeONT8sI-00358-00093697-00093938": "films Meghdoot era was ranked at number", "d2PeeONT8sI-00359-00093939-00094350": "231 and Komal Gondar at number 346 on", "d2PeeONT8sI-00360-00094351-00094719": "the list in 2007 a river named teeta's", "d2PeeONT8sI-00361-00094720-00094926": "topped the list of ten best Bangladeshi", "d2PeeONT8sI-00362-00094927-00095130": "films as chosen in the audience and", "d2PeeONT8sI-00363-00095131-00095298": "critics polls conducted by the British", "d2PeeONT8sI-00364-00095299-00095507": "Film Institute", "d2PeeONT8sI-00365-00095508-00095773": "Kirra Prajapati had won the Best", "d2PeeONT8sI-00366-00095774-00095980": "children's film award prime ministers", "d2PeeONT8sI-00367-00095981-00096253": "gold medal at 16th National Film Awards", "d2PeeONT8sI-00368-00096254-00096564": "in 1970"}}, {"audio_id": "d3oOnY75bec", "text": {"d3oOnY75bec-00000-00000181-00000492": "one feature of akiba solo is to allow", "d3oOnY75bec-00001-00000493-00000705": "you to automatically store the backup on", "d3oOnY75bec-00002-00000706-00001065": "a remote location Dropbox is a very", "d3oOnY75bec-00003-00001066-00001278": "popular option as it provides you with", "d3oOnY75bec-00004-00001279-00001482": "two gigabytes of cloud storage space", "d3oOnY75bec-00005-00001483-00001741": "free of charge and it is very simple", "d3oOnY75bec-00006-00001742-00001963": "with akiba solo to configure your", "d3oOnY75bec-00007-00001964-00002197": "backups to be stored into your Dropbox", "d3oOnY75bec-00008-00002198-00002652": "folder to begin select configuration and", "d3oOnY75bec-00009-00002653-00002839": "scroll down to the data processing", "d3oOnY75bec-00010-00002840-00003177": "engine here you can see many options", "d3oOnY75bec-00011-00003178-00003583": "including upload to dropbox once that's", "d3oOnY75bec-00012-00003584-00004000": "selected choose configure in order for", "d3oOnY75bec-00013-00004001-00004246": "our website to talk to Dropbox we need", "d3oOnY75bec-00014-00004247-00004861": "to do a two-step authentication", "d3oOnY75bec-00015-00004862-00005176": "once the first step is complete close", "d3oOnY75bec-00016-00005177-00005440": "the pop-up window and go to the second", "d3oOnY75bec-00017-00005441-00005917": "step as you can see the token and the", "d3oOnY75bec-00018-00005918-00006389": "secret key been automatically completed", "d3oOnY75bec-00019-00006390-00006648": "the directory then we want to store it", "d3oOnY75bec-00020-00006650-00006898": "it is by default the root of our dropbox", "d3oOnY75bec-00021-00006898-00007156": "account but we can store it anywhere we", "d3oOnY75bec-00022-00007156-00007603": "want including a subdirectory once you", "d3oOnY75bec-00023-00007604-00007824": "have configured Dropbox save and close", "d3oOnY75bec-00024-00007825-00008070": "your configuration and you are now ready", "d3oOnY75bec-00025-00008072-00008271": "to perform your first back up with the", "d3oOnY75bec-00026-00008272-00008593": "files being saved in dropbox once the", "d3oOnY75bec-00027-00008594-00008821": "backup has completed we can go to our", "d3oOnY75bec-00028-00008822-00009060": "manage backups and here we can see the", "d3oOnY75bec-00029-00009061-00009343": "backup that just took place is a remote", "d3oOnY75bec-00030-00009344-00009774": "backup the file is stored remotely from", "d3oOnY75bec-00031-00009775-00009958": "this link we are able to bring the", "d3oOnY75bec-00032-00009959-00010191": "backup back from drop box directly onto", "d3oOnY75bec-00033-00010192-00010614": "our web server now every time a backup", "d3oOnY75bec-00034-00010615-00010888": "is performed by akiba solo the backup", "d3oOnY75bec-00035-00010889-00011119": "file itself is being stored remotely in", "d3oOnY75bec-00036-00011120-00011442": "our dropbox accounts"}}, {"audio_id": "d3_x7ssEuJk", "text": {"d3_x7ssEuJk-00000-00000000-00003194": "foreign", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00001-00003195-00003224": "[Applause]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00002-00003225-00003446": "[Music]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00003-00003447-00003725": "[Applause]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00004-00003726-00004920": "um", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00005-00004921-00005506": "every day", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00006-00005507-00006503": "cheese", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00007-00006504-00009149": "everywhere", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00008-00009150-00009731": "daughter", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00009-00009732-00010687": "boom", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00010-00010688-00011381": "myself yeah", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00011-00011382-00013229": "I think when you come I get the boys", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00012-00013230-00013511": "hey Damion", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00013-00013512-00013701": "yeah", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00014-00013702-00020671": "[Applause]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00015-00020672-00023375": "don't get your body baby by myself", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00016-00023376-00024077": "designer", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00017-00024078-00026314": "foreign", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00018-00026316-00027389": "[Music]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00019-00027389-00027533": "yeah", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00020-00027533-00030533": "okay", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00021-00030533-00031840": "everyday", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00022-00031841-00033814": "foreign", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00023-00033815-00034955": "[Applause]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00024-00034956-00035221": "[Music]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00025-00035222-00037445": "it is", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00026-00037446-00041279": "awesome", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00027-00041280-00042200": "baby I'll be on my bedroom", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00028-00042201-00043641": "[Applause]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00029-00043642-00044058": "[Applause]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00030-00044059-00044440": "what's up my people", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00031-00044441-00044668": "in practice and if you want to go crazy", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00032-00044669-00048839": "on this yeah", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00033-00048840-00049601": "honey", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00034-00049602-00051790": "my eyes", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00035-00051791-00052073": "together", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00036-00052074-00055223": "foreign", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00037-00055224-00058247": "foreign", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00038-00058248-00059157": "foreign", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00039-00059158-00062366": "[Applause]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00040-00062367-00063294": "[Music]", "d3_x7ssEuJk-00041-00063295-00063573": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "d3M7FsKWLTg", "text": {"d3M7FsKWLTg-00000-00000104-00000487": "coming up on around kern county the 2022", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00001-00000488-00000767": "election season is almost here we're", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00002-00000768-00000991": "showing how residents can get involved", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00003-00000992-00001295": "in this important democratic process by", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00004-00001296-00001623": "volunteering to be at poll workers and", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00005-00001623-00001830": "kern county wants to hear from the", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00006-00001832-00002079": "community we're sharing how residents", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00007-00002080-00002295": "can make their voices heard on what", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00008-00002296-00002623": "services matter most to them one around", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00009-00002624-00003034": "kern county starts now", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00010-00003035-00003654": "[Music]", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00011-00003655-00003854": "welcome to this week's around kern", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00012-00003855-00004159": "county i'm your host ellie soper the", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00013-00004160-00004479": "2022 state primary election is right", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00014-00004480-00004751": "around the corner and you can help be a", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00015-00004752-00005038": "part of democracy by volunteering to be", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00016-00005039-00005183": "a poll worker", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00017-00005184-00005399": "the kern county elections division is", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00018-00005400-00005615": "inviting the community to take part in", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00019-00005616-00005863": "this rewarding experience as an", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00020-00005864-00006159": "opportunity to do something good for our", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00021-00006160-00006270": "country", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00022-00006271-00006575": "a poll worker also known as an elections", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00023-00006576-00006855": "officer is a volunteer who works at a", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00024-00006856-00007134": "local poll site on election day", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00025-00007136-00007375": "partaking in everything from welcoming", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00026-00007376-00007559": "voters and guiding them through the", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00027-00007559-00007878": "voting process to assisting with closing", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00028-00007879-00008142": "polls at the end of the night people", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00029-00008143-00008295": "should volunteer to be poll workers", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00030-00008296-00008471": "because obviously it's a great volunteer", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00031-00008472-00008671": "opportunity and you get to assist the", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00032-00008672-00008919": "voters of kern county", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00033-00008920-00009055": "and you really get to play an active", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00034-00009056-00009287": "role in the process our volunteers are", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00035-00009288-00009495": "really on the front line assisting our", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00036-00009496-00009759": "voters at the poll sites so they're just", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00037-00009760-00009999": "serving as an extension of the elections", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00038-00010000-00010119": "office", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00039-00010120-00010463": "we have over 150 poll sites throughout", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00040-00010464-00010719": "kern county so we staff them with", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00041-00010720-00010919": "volunteers so we really rely on our", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00042-00010920-00011231": "volunteers poll workers will also earn a", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00043-00011232-00011495": "stipend for their time to see if you're", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00044-00011496-00011799": "eligible to volunteer and to apply", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00045-00011800-00012159": "please visit kernvote.com", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00046-00012160-00012374": "there's a new way for residents to get", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00047-00012375-00012623": "involved with their local government", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00048-00012624-00012822": "right now kern county is seeking", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00049-00012823-00013046": "feedback from our community", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00050-00013047-00013327": "we want to know about your priorities", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00051-00013328-00013630": "and what services matter most to you", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00052-00013631-00013855": "residents are invited to join in on a", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00053-00013856-00014158": "community conversation and provide input", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00054-00014159-00014447": "on local services right now you can", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00055-00014447-00014663": "visit our kern county website to fill", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00056-00014663-00014958": "out the maintaining safety local control", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00057-00014959-00015230": "and essential services feedback form", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00058-00015231-00015438": "your comments will help ensure kern", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00059-00015440-00015686": "county's tradition of responsive and", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00060-00015687-00015966": "accountable planning as we prioritize", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00061-00015968-00016263": "the needs of our community this year and", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00062-00016263-00016558": "for future generations to get involved", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00063-00016559-00016735": "please visit our website at", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00064-00016736-00016999": "kerncounty.com", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00065-00017000-00017294": "the kern county library is encouraging", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00066-00017295-00017583": "reading to local newborns infants and", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00067-00017584-00017879": "toddlers with a free literacy program", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00068-00017880-00018271": "for pre-readers the goal is 1 000 books", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00069-00018272-00018543": "before kindergarten and to help parents", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00070-00018544-00018822": "understand the importance of literacy", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00071-00018823-00019127": "even before a child can read reading to", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00072-00019128-00019350": "young children not only gives them the", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00073-00019351-00019575": "necessary confidence to become strong", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00074-00019576-00019839": "readers in the future but also provides", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00075-00019840-00020086": "a special way for parents to bond with", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00076-00020087-00020343": "their children it is an opportunity for", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00077-00020344-00020583": "families and caregivers to read together", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00078-00020584-00020743": "and encourage the importance of reading", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00079-00020744-00020943": "from a young age children who are read", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00080-00020944-00021199": "to when they're young are academically", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00081-00021200-00021350": "more successful when they enter", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00082-00021351-00021503": "kindergarten and so that's why the whole", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00083-00021504-00021694": "goal is to read a thousand books before", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00084-00021695-00021871": "kindergarten it's a program that we're", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00085-00021872-00022063": "offering all the way up to ages six", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00086-00022064-00022271": "years old so parents can come in with", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00087-00022272-00022503": "their kids and sign up and get a", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00088-00022504-00022678": "wonderful host of incentives to", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00089-00022679-00022927": "participate and when they're finished", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00090-00022928-00023047": "they can say that they've read a", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00091-00023048-00023191": "thousand books before kindergarten it", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00092-00023192-00023342": "sounds a little intimidating at first", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00093-00023343-00023542": "but if you read one a day it only takes", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00094-00023543-00023758": "about three years so it is a very", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00095-00023759-00023911": "achievable program if you're reading", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00096-00023912-00024094": "more per day with your child it can be", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00097-00024095-00024319": "achieved even quicker right now you can", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00098-00024320-00024542": "sign up your family to join the reading", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00099-00024543-00024847": "challenge by registering for the 1000", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00100-00024848-00025150": "books before kindergarten early literacy", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00101-00025151-00025255": "program", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00102-00025256-00025503": "anytime your child reads a book or you", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00103-00025504-00025822": "read to them you can log it online or on", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00104-00025823-00026118": "the library's paper log to sign up", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00105-00026119-00026511": "please visit kerncountylibrary.org", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00106-00026512-00026735": "kern county public works is helping", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00107-00026736-00026974": "residents get a jump on their spring", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00108-00026975-00027279": "cleaning by holding three household", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00109-00027280-00027502": "hazardous waste collection events", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00110-00027504-00027751": "throughout the month of march which if", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00111-00027752-00027999": "you can believe it is next week", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00112-00028000-00028239": "beginning saturday march 5th public", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00113-00028239-00028423": "works will hold a collection event at", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00114-00028424-00028670": "the tehachapi recycling and sanitary", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00115-00028672-00028935": "landfill from nine in the morning until", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00116-00028936-00029239": "one in the afternoon residents can also", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00117-00029239-00029502": "get rid of their waste on saturday march", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00118-00029504-00029758": "19th at the mcfarland delano transfer", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00119-00029760-00030095": "station and saturday march 26th at the", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00120-00030095-00030374": "lebec transfer station residents are", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00121-00030375-00030583": "encouraged to drop off anything that", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00122-00030583-00030799": "could be considered dangerous to fly", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00123-00030800-00031046": "around their homes such as cleaning", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00124-00031047-00031358": "products pesticides and other chemicals", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00125-00031360-00031631": "as a reminder hazardous waste can always", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00126-00031632-00031831": "be dropped off at kern county's", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00127-00031832-00032055": "permanent special waste facilities", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00128-00032056-00032358": "located in bakersfield mojave and", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00129-00032360-00032655": "ridgecrest for hours of operation and", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00130-00032656-00032879": "addresses please visit", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00131-00032880-00033127": "kernpublicworks.com", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00132-00033128-00033351": "and we're ending today with some", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00133-00033352-00033607": "gorgeous shots of kern county blanketed", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00134-00033608-00033887": "in snow this week a storm came through", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00135-00033888-00034111": "our area turning kern county mountain", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00136-00034112-00034415": "communities into winter wonderland take", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00137-00034416-00034646": "a look at these beautiful videos", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00138-00034647-00034911": "showcasing our current county mountains", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00139-00034912-00035055": "covered in snow", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00140-00035056-00035318": "also some much-needed rain drenched our", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00141-00035319-00035662": "valleys turning our hills green", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00142-00035663-00035862": "and that does it for us on this week's", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00143-00035863-00036127": "around kern county if you have a story", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00144-00036128-00036335": "you'd like to share please visit", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00145-00036336-00036495": "kerncounty.com", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00146-00036496-00036743": "and fill out our submit a story form", "d3M7FsKWLTg-00147-00036744-00037236": "we'll see you right back here next week"}}, {"audio_id": "d47r_j1VyJc", "text": {"d47r_j1VyJc-00000-00000050-00000449": "vt mobile aerospace engineering VT may", "d47r_j1VyJc-00001-00000450-00000676": "provides commercial aircraft maintenance", "d47r_j1VyJc-00002-00000677-00000983": "to passenger and cargo aircraft to many", "d47r_j1VyJc-00003-00000984-00001310": "of the world's leading airlines it is", "d47r_j1VyJc-00004-00001311-00001579": "located within the bricklayer a Plex in", "d47r_j1VyJc-00005-00001580-00001829": "Mobile Alabama and is one of the largest", "d47r_j1VyJc-00006-00001830-00002255": "employers in Mobile County Alabama the", "d47r_j1VyJc-00007-00002256-00002540": "workforce includes technical engineering", "d47r_j1VyJc-00008-00002541-00002837": "and administrative personnel consisting", "d47r_j1VyJc-00009-00002838-00003085": "largely of FAA licensed aircraft", "d47r_j1VyJc-00010-00003086-00003458": "mechanics the company was established in", "d47r_j1VyJc-00011-00003459-00003920": "September 1990 by Saint Engineering in", "d47r_j1VyJc-00012-00003921-00004283": "June of 2018 vt mobile aerospace", "d47r_j1VyJc-00013-00004284-00004565": "engineering VT may opened a second", "d47r_j1VyJc-00014-00004566-00004822": "facility at the Pensacola International", "d47r_j1VyJc-00015-00004823-00005120": "Airport in Pensacola FL to complement", "d47r_j1VyJc-00016-00005121-00005913": "the operations in Mobile Alabama", "d47r_j1VyJc-00017-00005914-00006514": "topic facilities", "d47r_j1VyJc-00018-00006515-00006790": "the facility contains nine hangars", "d47r_j1VyJc-00019-00006791-00006997": "equipped with eight wide-body in ten", "d47r_j1VyJc-00020-00006998-00007252": "narrow-body aircraft Bay's for aircraft", "d47r_j1VyJc-00021-00007253-00007650": "maintenance repair and operations MRO", "d47r_j1VyJc-00022-00007651-00008004": "MRO services are provided for Airbus", "d47r_j1VyJc-00023-00008005-00008668": "a300 a310 a320 a330 a340 and Boeing's B", "d47r_j1VyJc-00024-00008669-00009330": "seven to seven be 737 be 747 be 757 be", "d47r_j1VyJc-00025-00009331-00009916": "767 be 777 and md-11 the company also", "d47r_j1VyJc-00026-00009917-00010207": "provides passenger to freighter PTF", "d47r_j1VyJc-00027-00010208-00010651": "conversions for the b7 to 7b 757 and", "d47r_j1VyJc-00028-00010652-00010915": "McDonnell Douglas dc-10 and provides", "d47r_j1VyJc-00029-00010916-00011383": "avionics upgrades for the md80 dc9 dc-10", "d47r_j1VyJc-00030-00011384-00012031": "and md-11 the new Pensacola FL 170 3500", "d47r_j1VyJc-00031-00012032-00012421": "SF feet facility is capable of housing", "d47r_j1VyJc-00032-00012422-00013234": "two to b777 - 300 s for 4b 757s or up to", "d47r_j1VyJc-00033-00013235-00013660": "six six a320 ones"}}, {"audio_id": "d49ZuNtD5t8", "text": {"d49ZuNtD5t8-00000-00000069-00000422": "douwe also Dawa dawah Dawa Ord aqua", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00001-00000423-00000802": "Arabic invitation is the proselytizing", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00002-00000803-00001405": "of Islam", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00003-00001406-00001902": "topic etymology", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00004-00001903-00002254": "Dawid iy literally means issuing a", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00005-00002255-00002649": "summons or making an invitation", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00006-00002650-00002887": "grammatically the word represents a", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00007-00002888-00003042": "gerund of a verb with the tri", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00008-00003043-00003325": "continental root d w meaning variously", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00009-00003326-00003807": "to summon or to invite a Muslim who", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00010-00003808-00004029": "practices Dawa either as a religious", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00011-00004030-00004218": "worker or in a volunteer community", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00012-00004219-00004677": "effort is called a dye plural dois D ash", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00013-00004678-00004941": "ah die as a person who invites people to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00014-00004942-00005184": "understand Islam through dialog may be", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00015-00005185-00005413": "regarded as a missionary inviting people", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00016-00005414-00005602": "to the faith prayer and manner of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00017-00005603-00006227": "Islamic life", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00018-00006228-00006792": "topic early Islam", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00019-00006793-00007065": "the term Dawa has other senses in the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00020-00007066-00007440": "Quran in surah chapter xxxii 25 for", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00021-00007441-00007668": "example it denotes the call to the dead", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00022-00007669-00007977": "to rise on the day of judgment when used", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00023-00007978-00008187": "in the Quran it generally refers to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00024-00008188-00008409": "Allah's invitation to live according to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00025-00008410-00008484": "his will", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00026-00008485-00008781": "thus when used in the first centuries of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00027-00008782-00008991": "Islam it usually referred to that", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00028-00008992-00009165": "message and was sometimes used", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00029-00009166-00009540": "interchangeably with Sharia and in Dawa", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00030-00009541-00009752": "is also described as the duty to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00031-00009753-00010056": "actively encourage fellow Muslims in the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00032-00010057-00010287": "pursuance of Greater piety in all", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00033-00010288-00010656": "aspects of their lives a definition", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00034-00010657-00010890": "which has become central to contemporary", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00035-00010891-00011102": "Islamic thought", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00036-00011103-00011467": "you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00037-00011468-00012071": "topic during Muhammad's era", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00038-00012072-00012464": "during the expedition of al-razi in 625", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00039-00012465-00012705": "Mohammed sent some men as missionaries", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00040-00012706-00013010": "to various different tribes some men", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00041-00013011-00013203": "came to Muhammad and requested that", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00042-00013204-00013436": "Muhammad send instructors to teach them", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00043-00013437-00013665": "Islam but the men were bribed by the two", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00044-00013666-00013869": "Tribes of Coos Amma who wanted revenge", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00045-00013869-00014094": "for the assassination of Khalid bin", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00046-00014094-00014352": "Sufjan chief of the Bandula Heon tribe", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00047-00014353-00014652": "by Muhammad's followers a number of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00048-00014653-00014808": "missionaries were killed in this", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00049-00014809-00015057": "expedition either a door according to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00050-00015058-00015258": "another account 10 then during the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00051-00015259-00015505": "expedition of beer mama in July", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00052-00015506-00015800": "625 Muhammad sent some missionaries at", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00053-00015801-00015996": "the request of some men from the ban who", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00054-00015997-00016212": "a mere tribe but the Muslims were again", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00055-00016213-00016416": "killed in revenge for the assassination", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00056-00016417-00016658": "of Khalid bin Sufjan by Muhammad's", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00057-00016659-00016986": "followers 70 Muslims were killed during", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00058-00016987-00017235": "this expedition during the expedition of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00059-00017236-00017490": "Khalid ib'n Alwaleed banerjee oedema in", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00060-00017491-00017838": "January 630 Muhammad sent Khalid ib'n", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00061-00017839-00018083": "Walid to invite the bandaged edema tribe", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00062-00018084-00018393": "to Islam this is mentioned in the Sunni", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00063-00018394-00018852": "hadiths Sahih al-bukhari 559 628 news", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00064-00018853-00019089": "back quote Abba Eban back quote Umar was", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00065-00019090-00019475": "the first Muslim envoy in September 621", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00066-00019476-00019784": "he was sent to Yathrib now Medina to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00067-00019785-00019994": "teach the people the doctrines of Islam", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00068-00019995-00020612": "and give them guidance", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00069-00020613-00021151": "topic post Muhammad", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00070-00021152-00021538": "after Mohammed's death in 632 from the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00071-00021539-00021736": "available historical evidence it appears", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00072-00021737-00022009": "that after Muhammad's death Muslims did", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00073-00022010-00022210": "not immediately embarked upon Dawa", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00074-00022211-00022471": "activities during and after the rapid", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00075-00022472-00022687": "conquests of the Byzantine and Persian", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00076-00022688-00022894": "lands they ventured little if at all to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00077-00022895-00023245": "preach to local non-muslims Dawa came", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00078-00023246-00023497": "into wider usage almost a hundred years", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00079-00023498-00023686": "after Muhammad's death in the wake of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00080-00023687-00023896": "Abbasid propaganda against the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00081-00023897-00024124": "then-ruling Umayyad plan in the seven", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00082-00024125-00024496": "20s however the Abbasid Dawa ceased as", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00083-00024497-00024724": "soon as the Abbasids were in power a", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00084-00024725-00024931": "fact that attests to its political", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00085-00024932-00025267": "nature Dawa as a truly missionary", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00086-00025268-00025516": "activity albeit still within the Muslim", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00087-00025517-00025693": "Ummah appeared in the form of the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00088-00025694-00025924": "Ismaili Dawa of the 9th through 13th", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00089-00025925-00026293": "centuries as miley's in many ways can be", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00090-00026294-00026502": "seen as the pioneers of the organized", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00091-00026504-00026719": "Muslim missionary activities they're", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00092-00026720-00026902": "highly institutionalized and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00093-00026902-00027127": "sophisticated Dawa structure has hardly", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00094-00027127-00027460": "been repeated until today moreover for", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00095-00027461-00027714": "the Ismailis Dawa was a state priority", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00096-00027716-00028006": "the Ismaili Dawa encompassed extra and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00097-00028007-00028233": "in traumatic forms and blended both", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00098-00028235-00028551": "theology and politics", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00099-00028552-00028917": "you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00100-00028918-00029437": "topic purpose", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00101-00029438-00029752": "in Islamic theology the purpose of Dawa", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00102-00029753-00029962": "is to invite people Muslims and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00103-00029963-00030202": "non-muslims to understand the worship of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00104-00030203-00030410": "God as expressed in the Quran and the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00105-00030411-00030611": "Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad and to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00106-00030612-00030851": "inform them about Muhammad Dawa as the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00107-00030852-00031174": "call towards God is the means by which", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00108-00031175-00031414": "Muhammad began spreading the message of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00109-00031415-00031817": "the Quran to mankind had his followers", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00110-00031818-00032043": "in the Ummah Muslim community assumed", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00111-00032044-00032342": "responsibility for it they conveyed the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00112-00032343-00032524": "message of the Quran by providing", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00113-00032525-00032752": "information on why and how the Quran", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00114-00032753-00033107": "preaches monotheism Muhammad SAW Islam", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00115-00033108-00033314": "is the true religion and mission of all", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00116-00033315-00033611": "earlier prophets he believed that their", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00117-00033612-00033782": "call had been limited to their own", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00118-00033783-00034079": "people but that his was universal his", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00119-00034080-00034280": "mission as the final prophet was to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00120-00034281-00034489": "repeat to the whole world this call an", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00121-00034490-00034855": "invitation Dawa to Islam Muhammad wrote", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00122-00034856-00035117": "to various non Muslim rulers inviting", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00123-00035118-00035721": "them to convert", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00124-00035722-00036280": "topic proselytism", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00125-00036281-00036502": "the importance of dawah has been", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00126-00036503-00036859": "emphasized many times in the Quran who", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00127-00036860-00037057": "is better in speech than one who calls", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00128-00037058-00037282": "to Allah does righteous deeds and says", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00129-00037283-00037615": "indeed I am among the Muslims you are", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00130-00037616-00037818": "the best nation raised up for humankind", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00131-00037819-00038101": "you enjoin righteousness forbid", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00132-00038102-00038419": "corruption and you believe in Allah let", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00133-00038420-00038640": "there arise among you a group inviting", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00134-00038641-00038806": "to all that is good enjoining", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00135-00038807-00039106": "righteousness and forbidding evil those", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00136-00039107-00039451": "are the successful ones call to the way", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00137-00039452-00039607": "of your lord with wisdom and good", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00138-00039608-00039809": "preaching", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00139-00039810-00040157": "the hadith sayings of Muhammad de Waze", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00140-00040158-00040385": "mentioned to emphasize importance and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00141-00040386-00040769": "virtues whoever directs someone to do", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00142-00040770-00040991": "good will gain the same reward as the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00143-00040992-00041267": "one who does good", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00144-00041268-00041561": "whoever calls to guidance will receive", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00145-00041562-00041768": "the same reward as the one who follows", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00146-00041769-00042014": "him without any decrease in the reward", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00147-00042015-00042282": "of his follower", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00148-00042283-00042570": "for Allah to guide someone by your hand", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00149-00042571-00042833": "as better for you than having red camels", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00150-00042834-00043248": "in ancient Arabia camels especially of a", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00151-00043249-00043461": "reddish hue were considered particularly", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00152-00043462-00043902": "valuable property convey from me even if", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00153-00043903-00044301": "it be only a single verse Muhammad sent", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00154-00044302-00044552": "MOA even jabal to Yemen and told him you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00155-00044553-00044789": "will be going to Christians and Jews so", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00156-00044790-00044955": "the first thing you should invite them", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00157-00044956-00045146": "to is the assertion of the oneness of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00158-00045147-00045461": "Allah Most High if they realize that", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00159-00045462-00045654": "then inform them that Allah has made", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00160-00045655-00045920": "five daily prayers obligatory on them if", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00161-00045921-00046176": "they pray them then inform them that", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00162-00046177-00046392": "Allah has made the payment of charity", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00163-00046393-00046571": "from their wealth obligatory on their", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00164-00046572-00046851": "rich to be given to their poor if they", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00165-00046852-00047036": "accept that then take it from them and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00166-00047037-00047802": "avoid the best part of people's property", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00167-00047803-00048437": "topic proselytizing methods", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00168-00048438-00048768": "you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00169-00048769-00049290": "topic gentleness", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00170-00049291-00049572": "with regard to Muhammad's mild nature in", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00171-00049573-00049938": "preaching Islam the Quran says and by", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00172-00049939-00050121": "the mercy of Allah you dealt with them", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00173-00050122-00050346": "gently if you were harsh and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00174-00050347-00050430": "hard-hearted", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00175-00050431-00050618": "they would have fled from around you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00176-00050619-00051213": "Quran 3 - 159 the Quran says about Moses", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00177-00051214-00051416": "and Aaron who preached to Pharaoh the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00178-00051417-00051777": "claimant of God so speak to him both of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00179-00051778-00051813": "you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00180-00051814-00052040": "mildly in order that he may reflect or", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00181-00052041-00052541": "fear God Quran 2044 Muhammad was", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00182-00052542-00052791": "reported by his wife Aisha to have said", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00183-00052791-00053004": "whenever gentleness is in a thing it", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00184-00053004-00053184": "beautifies it and whenever it is", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00185-00053185-00053409": "withdrawn from something it defaces", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00186-00053410-00053646": "Mohammed was quoted by Jerry as saying", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00187-00053647-00053877": "one deprived of gentleness as deprived", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00188-00053878-00054110": "of all good", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00189-00054111-00054454": "you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00190-00054454-00055066": "topic influence in politics", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00191-00055067-00055267": "Muslims made it a part of their", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00192-00055268-00055486": "political theory through relating Dawa", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00193-00055487-00055735": "to jihad and life using the concept of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00194-00055736-00056068": "Dawa in their political agendas taken in", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00195-00056069-00056293": "general the intertwining of Dawa and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00196-00056294-00056491": "politics then has been a feature", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00197-00056492-00056684": "throughout the Muslim history though", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00198-00056685-00056899": "practical implications of this have been", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00199-00056900-00057209": "different in different ages", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00200-00057210-00057550": "you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00201-00057551-00058058": "topic wisdom", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00202-00058059-00058301": "invite to the way of your lord with", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00203-00058302-00058555": "wisdom and good instruction and argue", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00204-00058557-00058886": "with them in a way that is best indeed", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00205-00058887-00059111": "your Lord is most knowing of who has", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00206-00059112-00059297": "strayed from his way and he is most", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00207-00059298-00059696": "knowing of who is rightly guided", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00208-00059697-00060171": "Kuran 16 to 125 a classical example of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00209-00060172-00060390": "diversion in dawah can be seen in the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00210-00060391-00060615": "case of prophet youssef in prison when", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00211-00060616-00060813": "two prisoners asked him to interpret", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00212-00060814-00061125": "their dreams one of them said I saw", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00213-00061126-00061413": "myself pressing wine the other said I", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00214-00061414-00061677": "saw myself carrying Bread on my head and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00215-00061678-00061955": "birds were eating from it they asked", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00216-00061957-00062175": "inform us of the interpretation of these", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00217-00062176-00062466": "things indeed we believe you are one of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00218-00062466-00062661": "the righteous he replied", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00219-00062662-00062841": "whenever food came to you as your", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00220-00062841-00063057": "provision I informed you about it before", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00221-00063058-00063345": "it came that is from what my Lord has", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00222-00063346-00063551": "taught me", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00223-00063552-00063815": "as for one of you he will pour wine for", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00224-00063816-00064001": "his lord to drink and as for the other", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00225-00064002-00064244": "he will be crucified and birds will eat", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00226-00064245-00064523": "from his head this is the case judged", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00227-00064524-00064811": "concerning which you both inquire quran", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00228-00064812-00065464": "12 35 - 41", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00229-00065465-00066046": "topic speaking a common language", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00230-00066047-00066343": "I did not send any messenger except that", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00231-00066344-00066544": "he spoke the language of his people to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00232-00066545-00067280": "explain to them Quran 14 - 4", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00233-00067281-00067788": "topic location", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00234-00067789-00068097": "doing dawah in the right location for", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00235-00068098-00068316": "example Mount Safa in the time of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00236-00068317-00068625": "Muhammad was used for announcement so", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00237-00068626-00068880": "Muhammad went there to make his point he", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00238-00068881-00069107": "chose that particular location because", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00239-00069108-00069306": "he knew the people who he was inviting", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00240-00069307-00069569": "to Islam he knew their nature and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00241-00069570-00069838": "characteristics so he chose Mount Safa", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00242-00069839-00070082": "he climbed up to its summit and", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00243-00070083-00070313": "addressed his people saying oh people of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00244-00070314-00070518": "Quraish if I were to tell you there was", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00245-00070519-00070694": "an army behind this hill would you", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00246-00070695-00070831": "listen to me", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00247-00070832-00071124": "topic proselytizing movements modern", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00248-00071125-00071286": "dawah movements are varied in their", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00249-00071287-00071604": "objectives and activities examples", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00250-00071605-00071805": "include the Muslim Brotherhood has", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00251-00071806-00072026": "focused on a methodology of building", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00252-00072027-00072237": "grassroots institutions and funding", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00253-00072238-00072447": "welfare projects which has helped it", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00254-00072448-00072656": "survive decades of repression under", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00255-00072657-00072831": "various dictatorship in many", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00256-00072832-00073038": "middle-eastern countries with the group", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00257-00073039-00073242": "and its many offshoots still enjoying", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00258-00073243-00073463": "popular support and power", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00259-00073464-00073713": "jamaat-e-islami has focused on", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00260-00073714-00073947": "presenting Islam as a complete way of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00261-00073948-00074169": "life and on the methodology of building", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00262-00074170-00074381": "grassroots institutions and funding", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00263-00074382-00074718": "welfare projects Tablighi Jamaat works", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00264-00074719-00074931": "on trying to bring the Muslims back to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00265-00074932-00075168": "the fundamental practices of Islam such", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00266-00075169-00075366": "as worship they do this by encouraging", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00267-00075367-00075579": "members to speak and to teach them the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00268-00075580-00075891": "virtues of good actions the movement has", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00269-00075892-00076173": "a following of between 100 and 150", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00270-00076174-00076467": "million people Ahmed Deedat was a", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00271-00076468-00076706": "notable debater who was a revolutionary", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00272-00076707-00076931": "figure among Muslims for his effort in", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00273-00076932-00077256": "debating Christian polemics many Muslim", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00274-00077257-00077460": "debaters from popular debaters to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00275-00077461-00077681": "grassroots dawah campaigners use his", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00276-00077682-00077950": "books and videos as reference material", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00277-00077951-00078240": "zakir naik was a student of Ahmed Deedat", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00278-00078241-00078462": "and followed in his teachers footsteps", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00279-00078463-00078678": "by debating Christian polemics and by", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00280-00078679-00078962": "holding Q&A sessions with Christians", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00281-00078963-00079250": "zakir naik is particularly notable for", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00282-00079251-00079469": "taking the effort of debating christian", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00283-00079470-00079674": "polemics - the muslim mainstream with", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00284-00079675-00079994": "his popular channel peace TV hizb", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00285-00079995-00080241": "ut-tahrir as a movement which focuses on", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00286-00080242-00080468": "educating the muslim masses about the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00287-00080469-00080805": "caliphate and unestablished it ierra as", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00288-00080806-00081021": "a research institute based in london", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00289-00081022-00081186": "which seeks to debate Maas", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00290-00081187-00081426": "and non Muslim intellectuals help new", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00291-00081427-00081645": "Muslims train speakers and produce", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00292-00081646-00081944": "academic research papers on dawah issues", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00293-00081945-00082221": "hikmah times in Singapore there is a", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00294-00082222-00082457": "significant impact of the Islamic dawah", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00295-00082458-00082812": "invitation movement there are many local", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00296-00082813-00083091": "international organizations eg hikmah", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00297-00083092-00083400": "times the deen mohammed sheikh mission", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00298-00083401-00083700": "has converted over 110,000 Hindus to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00299-00083701-00084105": "Islam in Pakistan Al Nasr bori code of", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00300-00084106-00084363": "conduct depicts the values in which dais", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00301-00084364-00084546": "should spread the word of Islam to", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00302-00084547-00084867": "Muslims and non-muslims addresses work", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00303-00084868-00085077": "presents us with an indigenous account", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00304-00085078-00085284": "of the traditions of the Dawa and Yaman", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00305-00085285-00085545": "his account of the Nazari mistily", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00306-00085546-00085788": "succession dispute reflects the official", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00307-00085789-00086001": "view of the tayyaba's the only surviving", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00308-00086002-00086268": "mistily Ismaili community who after the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00309-00086269-00086490": "death of allomere recognized the later", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00310-00086491-00086718": "Fatimid caliph says there are moms but", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00311-00086719-00086922": "did not long survive the collapse of the", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00312-00086923-00087105": "Fatimid at the hands of the ayah bid", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00313-00087106-00087814": "state in 1171", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00314-00087815-00088387": "topic see also", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00315-00088388-00088747": "spread of Islam Islamic missionary", "d49ZuNtD5t8-00316-00088748-00089439": "activity giza equals equals footnotes"}}, {"audio_id": "d4s9MXRqjbE", "text": {"d4s9MXRqjbE-00000-00000600-00001511": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00001-00001512-00002063": "our love is so real", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00002-00002064-00002501": "or it'd take a long long time", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00003-00002502-00002726": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00004-00002727-00003460": "to let us feel", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00005-00003461-00004283": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00006-00004284-00004622": "says", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00007-00004623-00005263": "my love is so real", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00008-00005264-00006169": "baby baby baby i'll be waiting for you", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00009-00006170-00006380": "[Applause]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00010-00006381-00006831": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00011-00006831-00007310": "someone like you", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00012-00007311-00009186": "touching your face", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00013-00009187-00009774": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00014-00009775-00011078": "in my eyes", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00015-00011079-00012000": "baby baby baby", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00016-00012001-00012703": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00017-00012704-00013587": "my", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00018-00013588-00014202": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00019-00014203-00015191": "[Applause]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00020-00015191-00015626": "i know", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00021-00015627-00016639": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00022-00016640-00017373": "i'll be there", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00023-00017374-00017958": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00024-00017959-00018827": "baby baby i've been waiting", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00025-00018828-00019683": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00026-00019684-00019987": "no", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00027-00019988-00021083": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00028-00021084-00021368": "treated", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00029-00021369-00022078": "[Music]", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00030-00022079-00022255": "hi my name is alif christian and if you", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00031-00022256-00022430": "like this video please like share and", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00032-00022431-00022535": "subscribe", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00033-00022536-00022743": "and help me to fulfill my dream to make", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00034-00022744-00022950": "music to a lot of people", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00035-00022951-00023183": "and if you have any suggestions on songs", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00036-00023184-00023311": "you'd like me to cover", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00037-00023312-00023635": "please let me know in the comments", "d4s9MXRqjbE-00038-00023636-00023936": "cheerio"}}, {"audio_id": "d4tuIPeuuXE", "text": {"d4tuIPeuuXE-00000-00000000-00000399": "[Music]", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00001-00000400-00000726": "welcome to the daily samuel", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00002-00000727-00001095": "the u.s kevin 19 case total is 7 million", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00003-00001096-00001623": "30 887 people testing positive with 203", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00004-00001623-00002039": "615 deaths the world's total is 32", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00005-00002039-00002123": "million", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00006-00002124-00002502": "457 326 cases", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00007-00002503-00002847": "in other news the governor of florida", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00008-00002848-00003166": "ron desantis has signed an order that", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00009-00003167-00003399": "allows restaurants and bars to reopen in", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00010-00003400-00003463": "full", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00011-00003464-00003663": "that's all for today please subscribe", "d4tuIPeuuXE-00012-00003664-00004023": "and come back tomorrow"}}, {"audio_id": "d4P1Bq6pBFu", "text": {"d4P1Bq6pBFu-00000-00000015-00000227": "you are following the development in", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00001-00000228-00000488": "automotive technology but finding time", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00002-00000488-00000862": "for education is difficult attending a", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00003-00000863-00001099": "classroom course just isn't convenient", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00004-00001100-00001408": "with products eLearning you can take", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00005-00001409-00001624": "online courses from your working place", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00006-00001625-00002072": "on your desktop or laptop you can take", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00007-00002073-00002377": "them from home or when you are commuting", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00008-00002378-00002710": "on your tablet you can even take them", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00009-00002711-00002987": "all in times where your plans change and", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00010-00002988-00003661": "you have a moment to study these courses", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00011-00003663-00003917": "are easily to enroll and provide an", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00012-00003918-00004184": "enjoyable educational experience you'll", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00013-00004185-00004409": "learn whenever and wherever it's", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00014-00004410-00004587": "suitable for you", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00015-00004588-00005076": "[Music]", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00016-00005077-00005115": "[Applause]", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00017-00005116-00005251": "[Music]", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00018-00005252-00005629": "[Applause]", "d4P1Bq6pBFu-00019-00005630-00005947": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "d4ThOtK-aJE", "text": {"d4ThOtK-aJE-00000-00000003-00000193": "therefore it is time for question period", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00001-00000194-00000646": "the leader of Her Majesty's loyal", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00002-00000647-00000902": "speaker my question is for the Minister", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00003-00000902-00001207": "of Tourism culture and sports was a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00004-00001208-00001655": "giant rubber ducky really worth 120", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00005-00001655-00002045": "thousand dollars of hard-earned taxpayer", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00006-00002046-00002531": "dollars yes or no kind of three-person", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00007-00002532-00002798": "fault henceforth you know it's the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00008-00002799-00002972": "speaker thank you to the Honourable", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00009-00002973-00003224": "member for his question and I guess", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00010-00003225-00003419": "speaker you know this really does point", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00011-00003420-00003617": "to the differences between that party's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00012-00003618-00003824": "approach to investing in Ontarians and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00013-00003825-00004097": "re here is precisely what we're doing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00014-00004098-00004292": "and I want to use this opportunity to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00015-00004293-00004493": "get some facts on the record because I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00016-00004494-00004709": "know facts don't matter over there but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00017-00004710-00004895": "on this side of the house they do mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00018-00004896-00005347": "speaker here we go", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00019-00005348-00005666": "no speaker it's interesting that the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00020-00005667-00005879": "opposite meant the party opposite is not", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00021-00005880-00006031": "taking an interest in investing in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00022-00006032-00006242": "tourism here's why that's important", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00023-00006243-00006467": "tourism in this province generates 30", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00024-00006468-00006578": "billion dollars a year in economic", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00025-00006579-00006956": "activity X 4 percent of our GDP it's 300", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00026-00006956-00007103": "thousand jobs and if that's not enough", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00027-00007104-00007298": "for the leader of the Opposition here's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00028-00007298-00007453": "what we're doing in his own writing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00029-00007454-00007664": "speaker and here's a message senator", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00030-00007665-00007892": "Morton Jerry all you thought in the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00031-00007893-00008045": "supplementary because I look forward to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00032-00008045-00008249": "speaking as to why these investors of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00033-00008250-00008634": "course mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00034-00008635-00008874": "mr. speaker again to the minister when I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00035-00008875-00009083": "think of Canada I think of compassion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00036-00009084-00009420": "unity respect family and responsibility", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00037-00009421-00009678": "I think of freedom of speech worship and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00038-00009679-00009756": "assembly", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00039-00009757-00009978": "Mr Speaker I think of the rule of law", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00040-00009979-00010167": "when I think of Canada we think of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00041-00010168-00010431": "hockey poutine maple syrup and our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00042-00010432-00010721": "beautiful outdoors what I don't think of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00043-00010722-00011016": "mr. speaker our rubber duck never have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00044-00011017-00011118": "never will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00045-00011119-00011562": "that's not hard at Canada's all right", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00046-00011563-00011727": "both sides have had their opportunity", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00047-00011728-00012129": "and I will move in my next Inc link to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00048-00012130-00012577": "warnings if it's necessary", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00049-00012578-00013320": "we might jump right away", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00050-00013321-00013702": "that's not helpful either", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00051-00013703-00014044": "please finished leader mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00052-00014044-00014330": "putting all the government liberal spin", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00053-00014331-00014614": "aside what does a rubber duck have to do", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00054-00014615-00014825": "with celebrating candidates one hundred", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00055-00014826-00015622": "and fiftieth birthday Thank You speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00056-00015623-00015928": "you know the past three years our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00057-00015929-00016084": "government has supported the red path", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00058-00016085-00016600": "waterfront festival this year this year", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00059-00016601-00016925": "we're granting them 121 thousand dollars", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00060-00016926-00017194": "speaker it's an annual summer event that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00061-00017195-00017330": "provides on land and on water", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00062-00017331-00017533": "programming this grant has been a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00063-00017534-00017770": "normally enormous ly successful let's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00064-00017771-00017927": "talk a little bit about what it's done", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00065-00017928-00018259": "speaker in 2015 the festival entice", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00066-00018260-00018497": "tourists to spend nearly 6 million", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00067-00018498-00018944": "dollars and I also got to point out that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00068-00018945-00019150": "not only are we contributing to this but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00069-00019151-00019328": "two other important groups are number", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00070-00019329-00019519": "one the City of Toronto was given the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00071-00019520-00019693": "festival of 75 thousand dollar", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00072-00019694-00019925": "contribution speakers that's also very", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00073-00019926-00020161": "important I want to close with something", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00074-00020162-00020336": "closer to home that the member opposite", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00075-00020337-00020543": "might appreciate warden Jared Marilyn", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00076-00020544-00020786": "Simcoe County said you know I spent", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00077-00020787-00020959": "sixty thousand dollars to bring these", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00078-00020960-00021190": "four tall ships and we saw 150 dollars", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00079-00021191-00021460": "and tourism spent bring it on thank you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00080-00021461-00022083": "[Applause]", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00081-00022084-00022381": "ergonomics mr. speaker again to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00082-00022382-00022583": "minister the minister says she costs and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00083-00022584-00022853": "focusing too much on the duck well of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00084-00022854-00023119": "course she does because the Liberals are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00085-00023120-00023350": "embarrassed they're embarrassed they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00086-00023351-00023539": "signed off on one hundred and twenty one", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00087-00023540-00023812": "thousand for a giant rubber duck that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00088-00023813-00024037": "doesn't promote tourism think it hide", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00089-00024038-00024275": "behind all their lines but they know", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00090-00024276-00024494": "it's wrong and mr. speaker there is a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00091-00024495-00024728": "person in charge anymore they waste", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00092-00024729-00024992": "taxpayer dollars and then they come up", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00093-00024993-00025250": "with PR to explain why they wasted", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00094-00025251-00025531": "Ontario's precious taxpayer dollars so", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00095-00025532-00025856": "my question is again do the right thing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00096-00025857-00026293": "just apologize for wasting 121 thousand", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00097-00026294-00028711": "dollars on a rubber duck", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00098-00028712-00029126": "Minister yeah that's the leaf Thank You", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00099-00029127-00029186": "speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00100-00029187-00029374": "really speaker I can tell you soundly", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00101-00029375-00029521": "and clearly on this side of the house we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00102-00029522-00029689": "will never apologize for investing in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00103-00029690-00030802": "tourism in economics Iker this is that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00104-00030803-00031108": "this is a festival I spoke to a moment", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00105-00031109-00031321": "ago in my original response about the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00106-00031322-00031493": "six million dollars that it generated in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00107-00031494-00031714": "Toronto here's a few other places that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00108-00031715-00031955": "this this touring festival would be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00109-00031956-00032108": "going and I think the member opposite", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00110-00032108-00032236": "might find this interesting", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00111-00032237-00032468": "member from Owen Sound might find it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00112-00032469-00032611": "interesting because the traveling", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00113-00032612-00032808": "festival is going there too savory", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00114-00032809-00033104": "Midlands and interesting in the leader", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00115-00033105-00033968": "of the Opposition remember from Bruce", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00116-00033969-00034973": "great sound is Warren we're in mornings", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00117-00034974-00035412": "Finnish Minister Thank You speaker the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00118-00035413-00035643": "traveling festival is also going to jobs", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00119-00035644-00035829": "and economic development and by the way", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00120-00035830-00036132": "promote fun in amis Ferg and Brockville", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00121-00036133-00036404": "speaker Thank You Dean sighs deep", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00122-00036405-00036804": "finished good question leader of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00123-00036805-00037116": "Opposition mr. speaker my question is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00124-00037117-00037479": "for the government house leader I'm", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00125-00037480-00037650": "going to quote the head of Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00126-00037651-00037860": "Public Service Employees Union mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00127-00037861-00038265": "smokey Thomas he said and it's important", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00128-00038266-00038400": "the government actually listens to this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00129-00038401-00038858": "he said bill 1:32 is terrible terrible", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00130-00038859-00039102": "legislation and I urge you to stop and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00131-00039103-00039351": "mr. speaker will the government do just", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00132-00039352-00039624": "that will they stop there 93 billion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00133-00039625-00040290": "dollar unfair hydro scheme well figure", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00134-00040291-00040728": "of our objective on this side of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00135-00040729-00041094": "house is to cut hybrid for hard-working", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00136-00041095-00041301": "Ontarians speaker and that is why our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00137-00041302-00041529": "government the leadership of our premier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00138-00041530-00041709": "is focused and cutting the hydro rates", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00139-00041710-00042069": "by 25 percent now of course speaker from", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00140-00042070-00042231": "the opposite side we have heard that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00141-00042232-00042513": "they have had no plan whatsoever when it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00142-00042514-00042702": "comes to energy they kept talking about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00143-00042703-00042870": "that they're going to have a hydro up", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00144-00042871-00043113": "top when they go keep telling Ontarians", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00145-00043114-00043248": "and somehow they will be able to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00146-00043249-00043542": "magically cut hydro rate spontaneous but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00147-00043543-00043797": "we have seen have you have seen no plan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00148-00043798-00044043": "whatsoever speak of what we have done to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00149-00044044-00044316": "the free hydro plant act is put forward", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00150-00044317-00044709": "a concrete plan by which hybrids will be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00151-00044710-00045054": "cut by 25% and the only reasonable and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00152-00045055-00045237": "sensible thing for the opposition is to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00153-00045238-00045564": "do support that plan is to support that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00154-00045565-00045756": "legislation so that Ontarians can have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00155-00045757-00046127": "the relief they deserve so much here", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00156-00046128-00046355": "supplemented mr. speaker again to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00157-00046356-00046553": "government house leader now I know one", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00158-00046554-00046790": "of the Liberals favorite pastimes is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00159-00046791-00047042": "attacking the non partisan independent", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00160-00047043-00047330": "watchdog our esteemed Auditor General", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00161-00047331-00047525": "but she too has had an increase in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00162-00047526-00047867": "common I like to share she said we would", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00163-00047868-00048065": "recommend the government reconsider this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00164-00048066-00048347": "bill 132 mr. speaker I'll give the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00165-00048348-00048569": "government another chance to take 280th", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00166-00048570-00048896": "advice we've got we've got civil service", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00167-00048897-00049043": "workers saying this is a big problem", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00168-00049044-00049193": "you've got the otter general saying this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00169-00049194-00049397": "is a big problem Ontarians are concerned", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00170-00049398-00049612": "their bills are going to skyrocket", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00171-00049613-00049874": "because of this will you do the right", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00172-00049875-00050087": "thing take the AG's advice and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00173-00050088-00050731": "reconsider this unfair Hydra scheme", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00174-00050732-00051407": "computer please thank you broke mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00175-00051408-00051611": "speaker yesterday the leader of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00176-00051612-00051782": "Opposition said something that I think", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00177-00051783-00052030": "was historic in this legislature he", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00178-00052032-00052310": "actually made a policy declaration what", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00179-00052311-00052601": "he said yesterday mr. speaker is I will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00180-00052602-00052913": "not invest in energy infrastructure mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00181-00052914-00053219": "speaker we've heard that long before and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00182-00053220-00053477": "we saw the impacts of not investing in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00183-00053478-00053723": "energy infrastructure Mike Harrison", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00184-00053724-00053987": "Ernie II said exactly the same thing and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00185-00053988-00054209": "mr. speaker they did exactly the same", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00186-00054210-00054457": "thing they have no plan to invest in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00187-00054458-00054716": "infrastructure infrastructure and they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00188-00054716-00055042": "left this energy system in a net mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00189-00055044-00055334": "speaker not only do we have a creme and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00190-00055335-00055661": "reliable energy", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00191-00055662-00056478": "the member from Simcoe gray is Warren", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00192-00056479-00056727": "finish please stir speaker not only do", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00193-00056728-00056937": "we have a clean reliable energy system", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00194-00056938-00057126": "we're moving out and make that system", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00195-00057127-00057341": "more affordable for everyday Ontarians", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00196-00057342-00057696": "by reducing cost by 25% and our leader", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00197-00057697-00057885": "the opposition won't support that either", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00198-00057886-00058002": "thank you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00199-00058003-00058287": "final supplementary major speaker again", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00200-00058288-00058452": "to the government house leader and the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00201-00058453-00058626": "minister is right I will not invest in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00202-00058627-00058953": "bad liberal contracts it's not right", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00203-00058954-00059127": "people are pero paying too much because", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00204-00059128-00059352": "of these bad contracts the Liberals have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00205-00059353-00059532": "benefited too long and it's hurt the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00206-00059533-00059745": "people so let's hear another assessment", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00207-00059746-00059991": "on this unfair hydro scheming president", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00208-00059991-00060479": "of Treasury Board is warned", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00209-00060480-00060834": "finish please Kewpie spread hon ultimate", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00210-00060835-00061059": "some interesting comments about Bill 132", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00211-00061060-00061296": "he said the following to this government", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00212-00061297-00061476": "I want you to know that people of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00213-00061477-00061749": "Ontario will not be fooled they were", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00214-00061750-00061959": "members in the long term what you have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00215-00061960-00062220": "done to mess up our electricity future", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00216-00062221-00062441": "in the province of Ontario the unfair", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00217-00062442-00062727": "hydro scheme will not cool anyone hydro", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00218-00062728-00062970": "rates are going to skyrocket every", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00219-00062971-00063204": "independent assessment says that very", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00220-00063204-00063444": "clearly we can't afford our hydro bill", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00221-00063445-00063675": "it's not right so mr. speaker answer one", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00222-00063676-00063801": "more chance for the government house", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00223-00063802-00064050": "leader to come clean and say this is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00224-00064051-00064233": "going to cause hydrates come fight and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00225-00064234-00064764": "we're going to stop it thank you if the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00226-00064765-00064974": "member really believed what he just said", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00227-00064975-00065103": "he wouldn't have started out his", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00228-00065104-00065330": "question period talking about rubber", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00229-00065332-00065490": "ducks mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00230-00065491-00065709": "the fact is you want to talk about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00231-00065710-00065895": "ducking mr. speaker let's talk about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00232-00065896-00066147": "ducking questions on sex ed let's talk", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00233-00066148-00066336": "about ducking questions on the carbon", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00234-00066337-00066387": "tax", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00235-00066388-00066591": "luke talk about ducking questions on the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00236-00066592-00066777": "energy plan thank you we're still", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00237-00066778-00066951": "waiting to hear it just a call he", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00238-00066952-00067191": "doesn't suck every time anybody asks him", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00239-00067192-00067365": "a question on the energy plan but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00240-00067366-00067524": "starting with ducking questions about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00241-00067525-00067740": "your own caucus members let's talk about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00242-00067741-00068043": "ducking questions mr. speaker about just", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00243-00068044-00068331": "about any single substantive policy mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00244-00068332-00068481": "speaker we're moving forward with a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00245-00068482-00068736": "clean reliable energy plan that's going", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00246-00068737-00068925": "to ensure it's more affordable for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00247-00068926-00069141": "everyday Ontarians we're proud of that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00248-00069142-00069378": "plan no wonder you don't want Ontarians", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00249-00069379-00069588": "to know about it mr. speaker that might", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00250-00069589-00069846": "be best answer for you but it's good for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00251-00069847-00070582": "the people of Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00252-00070583-00072886": "she stated please in stated place no", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00253-00072887-00073006": "question the leader the third party", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00254-00073007-00073378": "Thank You speaker my question is for the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00255-00073379-00073644": "acting premier last week it became clear", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00256-00073645-00073869": "just how far the Premier's willing to go", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00257-00073870-00074094": "to try to revive her personal and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00258-00074095-00074305": "political fortunes she's planning to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00259-00074306-00074563": "force utility companies to deliver", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00260-00074564-00074788": "political inserts containing a message", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00261-00074789-00075163": "aimed at saving the Liberal Party the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00262-00075164-00075409": "premier believed that by forcing by", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00263-00075410-00075700": "regulation private companies to campaign", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00264-00075701-00075847": "on her behalf", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00265-00075848-00076056": "does she believe speaker that this is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00266-00076057-00076474": "above board and honored doctor trainer", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00267-00076475-00076717": "because of the Treasury Board mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00268-00076718-00076984": "treasurer report well thank you speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00269-00076985-00077188": "and I do need to start by reminding", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00270-00077189-00077446": "people that camp it is the only", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00271-00077447-00077757": "jurisdiction in Ontario is the only", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00272-00077758-00078043": "jurisdiction in Canada that actually has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00273-00078044-00078442": "a law that outlaws partisan advertising", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00274-00078443-00078763": "no other province in Canada has that we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00275-00078764-00079069": "are unique and or anything that we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00276-00079070-00079417": "publish any advertising is compliant", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00277-00079418-00079707": "with that law now if you want to look at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00278-00079708-00080197": "getting information remember from Duncan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00279-00080198-00080512": "Kelvin and has warned carry on if you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00280-00080513-00080701": "want to look at information that's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00281-00080702-00080962": "inserted in hydro bills one of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00282-00080963-00081181": "experiences I have in my constituency", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00283-00081182-00081403": "office and I'm sure lots of other folks", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00284-00081404-00081688": "do too is that people don't understand", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00285-00081689-00081906": "their hydro bills they call the local", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00286-00081907-00082131": "distributor they call them observe one", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00287-00082132-00082344": "they call the constant office they're", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00288-00082345-00082522": "trying to figure out their hydro bills", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00289-00082523-00082828": "they want introducing in their hydro", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00290-00082829-00082938": "bill they what", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00291-00082939-00083206": "thank you supplemental for the premier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00292-00083207-00083434": "is doing nothing more than looking out", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00293-00083435-00083498": "for her", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00294-00083499-00083648": "best interest with these political", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00295-00083649-00084029": "answers and everybody knows it by", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00296-00084030-00084305": "forcing companies to carry these ads", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00297-00084306-00084620": "during election campaign during an", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00298-00084621-00084860": "election campaign speaker she is playing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00299-00084861-00085151": "sneaky political games by it and trying", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00300-00085152-00085418": "to manipulate the very election laws", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00301-00085419-00085646": "that we're talking about will this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00302-00085647-00085943": "premier and the Liberal Party admit that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00303-00085944-00086194": "mandating politically motivated", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00304-00086195-00086495": "politically convenient insert to be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00305-00086496-00086780": "included in people's hydro bills during", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00306-00086781-00087053": "an election campaign it's just too far", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00307-00087054-00088142": "to go even electro computer please thank", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00308-00088143-00089493": "you Thank You Minister", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00309-00089494-00089700": "another thing we've discovered in my", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00310-00089701-00089943": "constituency offices a lot of people who", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00311-00089944-00090258": "would qualify for the OAS P the Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00312-00090259-00090513": "electricity support program don't know", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00313-00090514-00090750": "about it do you know speaker what's in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00314-00090751-00091116": "that partisan advertising which are what", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00315-00091117-00091389": "she wants to call partisan advertising", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00316-00091390-00091829": "it is information about the Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00317-00091830-00092154": "electricity support program we actually", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00318-00092155-00092364": "think it's important that people all", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00319-00092365-00092718": "over Ontario get information about the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00320-00092719-00093072": "Ontario electricity support program so", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00321-00093073-00093384": "that if they qualify they can get more", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00322-00093385-00093687": "than 25 percent off their high Imperial", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00323-00093688-00094032": "they can qualify for more money off if", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00324-00094033-00094299": "they are lower income and we want people", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00325-00094300-00094488": "to know that because they want to help", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00326-00094489-00094686": "the people thank you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00327-00094687-00094971": "on a supplemental speaker the next", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00328-00094972-00095271": "election is just over a year away that's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00329-00095272-00095553": "the same timeframe coincidentally that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00330-00095554-00095835": "the premier is mandating these political", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00331-00095836-00096132": "inserts appear in every household and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00332-00096133-00096543": "every business in our province does the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00333-00096544-00096762": "premier and the Liberal Party really", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00334-00096763-00096957": "think that the people of this province", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00335-00096958-00097707": "don't see what they're doing I think", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00336-00097708-00097929": "that what the people of Ontario want to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00337-00097930-00098211": "know is when they qualify for help they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00338-00098212-00098463": "want to know that if they're ever in a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00339-00098464-00098694": "rural or remote part of Ontario that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00340-00098695-00098919": "they can get extra help Hauk they're on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00341-00098920-00099252": "to their hydro bill because we recognize", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00342-00099253-00099441": "that if you live in rural or Northern", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00343-00099442-00099696": "Ontario you need extra help and you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00344-00099697-00099975": "could qualify for up to 40 to 50% off", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00345-00099976-00100254": "your hydro bill we think that people who", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00346-00100255-00100701": "are Ontario Hydro consumers deserve to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00347-00100702-00100893": "know that they should apply for the OE", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00348-00100894-00101238": "SV we don't think that's partisan we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00349-00101239-00101520": "think that's just giving people all over", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00350-00101521-00101865": "Ontario the people that the information", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00351-00101866-00102159": "that they need to reduce their hydro", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00352-00102160-00102268": "bills to the MOT", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00353-00102269-00102538": "semadar because we have a fair hydro", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00354-00102539-00102858": "plan so that we can reduce rates all", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00355-00102859-00103209": "across this second question you know in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00356-00103210-00103386": "every question for the acting cream you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00357-00103388-00103588": "speaker but I think what people want to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00358-00103589-00103782": "see is the government stop using", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00359-00103783-00104067": "precious public dollars to promote the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00360-00104068-00104752": "release clearly the electricity", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00361-00104753-00104944": "companies who will be forced to deliver", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00362-00104945-00105210": "this politically motivated message on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00363-00105211-00105402": "behalf of the premier didn't think it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00364-00105403-00105603": "was necessary speaker or else they would", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00365-00105604-00105834": "have provided the information themselves", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00366-00105835-00106041": "on their own does the premier know", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00367-00106042-00106282": "something that every electricity in the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00368-00106283-00106570": "car in the province that some some four", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00369-00106571-00106771": "somehow doesn't need to know or doesn't", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00370-00106772-00106948": "know or is there something that they are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00371-00106949-00107206": "aware of that every electricity company", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00372-00107207-00107668": "isn't aware of speaker before Accord is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00373-00107669-00107811": "a deputy premier the Minister of Finance", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00374-00107813-00108043": "is warrant carry on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00375-00108044-00108274": "Thank You speaker and I'm glad we're", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00376-00108275-00108421": "having the chance to talk about hydro", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00377-00108422-00108688": "prices today and I'm particularly", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00378-00108689-00108949": "disturbed to hear that yesterday it was", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00379-00108950-00109249": "announced that the NDP will not support", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00380-00109250-00109566": "in fact will repeal the bill that will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00381-00109567-00109914": "bring for hydro relief relief to people", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00382-00109915-00110164": "across this province they announced", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00383-00110165-00110323": "yesterday that they will actually", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00384-00110324-00110586": "increase hydro prices that they will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00385-00110588-00110944": "take the 25 percent back speaker that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00386-00110945-00111193": "the 40 percent that many people in rural", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00387-00111194-00111475": "and northern ontario relief that they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00388-00111476-00111711": "will get will be rescinded under the NDP", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00389-00111713-00111976": "they said that the Ontario electricity", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00390-00111977-00112164": "support program that provides energy", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00391-00112165-00112414": "relief for the vote most vulnerable new", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00392-00112415-00112693": "province will be repealed speaker it's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00393-00112694-00112927": "no surprise that the opposition is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00394-00112928-00113127": "asking about our insert in an envelope", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00395-00113128-00113398": "because they are not prepared to talk", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00396-00113399-00113634": "about their current to repeal this whole", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00397-00113635-00113782": "bill", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00398-00113783-00114068": "c'mon traitor Thank You seeker and we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00399-00114069-00114206": "replace it with a plan that actually", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00400-00114207-00114626": "creates systemic change the Republic has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00401-00114627-00114941": "a create saving for the long-term for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00402-00114942-00115157": "the people of Ontario look it's really", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00403-00115158-00115358": "really shocking actually we announced", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00404-00115358-00115619": "this almost a month ago and the minister", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00405-00115620-00115832": "just realized yesterday that this was", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00406-00115833-00116093": "the NDP's position shame on her look", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00407-00116094-00116297": "when the premier forces electricity", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00408-00116298-00116533": "company speaker to do something that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00409-00116534-00116852": "they deem unnecessary it's a political", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00410-00116853-00117149": "tactic plain and simple that tactic is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00411-00117150-00117385": "meant to harness the power of the Office", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00412-00117386-00117709": "of the premier for political gain there", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00413-00117710-00118007": "is no way around that fact and it's time", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00414-00118008-00118234": "the premier takes responsibility for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00415-00118235-00118502": "this manipulation will she revoke the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00416-00118503-00118748": "regulation now and apologize to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00417-00118749-00119018": "people of Ontario for misusing the power", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00418-00119019-00119151": "of her office", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00419-00119152-00119448": "[Applause]", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00420-00119449-00119564": "[Music]", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00421-00119565-00119834": "speaker let's um let's be really clear", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00422-00119835-00120177": "the the MVP wants to cancel the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00423-00120178-00120426": "decreases your hydro prices for the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00424-00120427-00120693": "people of Ontario that in my opinion is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00425-00120694-00120969": "a shameful position for the third party", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00426-00120970-00121173": "to be taking they claim they will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00427-00121174-00121352": "replace it with something but they have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00428-00121353-00121628": "no idea what they are going to replace", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00429-00121629-00121877": "it with speaker but what we do know for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00430-00121878-00122183": "sure that it will take away relief from", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00431-00122184-00122376": "the people of this province and they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00432-00122377-00122571": "will also take money from health and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00433-00122572-00122793": "from education because part of their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00434-00122794-00123063": "plan is to buy back the shares in hydro", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00435-00123064-00123294": "one speaker so let's just be really", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00436-00123295-00123543": "clear anyone who is watching anyone who", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00437-00123544-00123809": "is paying attention to this the NDP want", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00438-00123810-00124133": "to increase your hydro bill they want to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00439-00124134-00124296": "take away the support for the most", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00440-00124297-00124524": "vulnerable people they want to take away", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00441-00124525-00124904": "the delivery cost for on-reserve", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00442-00124905-00125369": "personation speaker excuse me", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00443-00125370-00126088": "the member from Essex is warned final", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00444-00126089-00126334": "supplementary I think you can bet your", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00445-00126335-00126569": "bottom dollar that a green person in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00446-00126570-00126796": "Ontario was watching the maxi liberals", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00447-00126797-00127302": "have made of our electricity system and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00448-00127303-00127643": "become the FAO the financial", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00449-00127644-00127900": "accountability officer an independent", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00450-00127901-00128128": "officer of this legislature says that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00451-00128129-00128371": "the Premier's forty five billion dollar", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00452-00128372-00128653": "hydro flooring scheme where cost i'm", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00453-00128654-00128953": "darian will cost ontario families and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00454-00128954-00129218": "businesses more money and that it will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00455-00129219-00129499": "actually drive bills up now that's not", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00456-00129500-00129721": "me as a part of an saying not that's the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00457-00129722-00129991": "financial accountability officer there", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00458-00129992-00130204": "is no hiding this fact speaker even", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00459-00130205-00130406": "though it's conveniently excluded from", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00460-00130407-00130643": "the premiers regulation forcing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00461-00130644-00130870": "companies to promote her and her", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00462-00130871-00131069": "political party the premier has decided", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00463-00131070-00131374": "to use her position her office as", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00464-00131375-00131620": "premier demanding that were general", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00465-00131621-00131781": "party's politically motivated", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00466-00131782-00132094": "description of this scheme is delivered", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00467-00132095-00132487": "to ethereal dork trip regularly now the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00468-00132488-00132946": "next election thank you a minister of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00469-00132947-00133183": "indigenous relations and reconciliation", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00470-00133184-00133516": "is warned deputy premier you know", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00471-00133517-00133846": "speaker for months india house the third", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00472-00133847-00134101": "party came with examples of people who", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00473-00134102-00134257": "were really suffering with high", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00474-00134258-00134551": "electricity prices figure we heard those", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00475-00134552-00134836": "stories in our own writings - what we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00476-00134837-00135031": "did is we went to work we rolled up our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00477-00135032-00135229": "sleeves and we developed a plan that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00478-00135230-00135523": "will provide immediate relief 25%", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00479-00135524-00135763": "reduction electricity male speaker and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00480-00135764-00136000": "more than that for people who are paying", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00481-00136001-00136276": "the highest rate we have a plan we've", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00482-00136277-00136453": "been very transparent above that plan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00483-00136454-00136732": "it's a plan that reduces electricity", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00484-00136733-00136990": "bill and to think that the NDP party", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00485-00136991-00137260": "will stand in their place day after day", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00486-00137261-00137536": "after day after day to complain about a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00487-00137537-00137704": "problem and then when we develop a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00488-00137705-00137974": "solution say no to that speaker without", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00489-00137975-00138202": "coming up with their own is just not", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00490-00138203-00138298": "okay", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00491-00138299-00139483": "we concede it thank you new question", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00492-00139484-00139657": "remember from Halliburton for Sonic's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00493-00139658-00140032": "class just taken my questions for the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00494-00140033-00140287": "Minister of the status of women as we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00495-00140288-00140427": "come to the end of sexual assault", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00496-00140428-00140604": "awareness month we see the government", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00497-00140605-00140809": "paying lip service to sexual assault", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00498-00140810-00141043": "victims while ignoring victim service", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00499-00141044-00141394": "organizations like hope 24/7 a sexual", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00500-00141395-00141649": "assault center in pealed struggles to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00501-00141650-00141835": "help its clients because of this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00502-00141836-00142113": "government's mismanagement organizations", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00503-00142114-00142290": "tell me that the government so-called", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00504-00142291-00142503": "review of the ineffective funding", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00505-00142504-00142768": "formula for victim services is taking", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00506-00142769-00143016": "place under a cloud of secrecy the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00507-00143017-00143182": "government refuses to commit to sharing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00508-00143183-00143458": "the details of the review or even to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00509-00143459-00143731": "consult affected organizations like hope", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00510-00143732-00144088": "24/7 so my question is does the minister", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00511-00144089-00144327": "think it's acceptable to exclude sexual", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00512-00144328-00144603": "assault centers the real experts from", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00513-00144604-00144775": "the conversation about the future of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00514-00144776-00145446": "services for victims of sexual assault I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00515-00145447-00145713": "want to thank the member opposite for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00516-00145714-00145861": "the question and I want to make sure", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00517-00145862-00146004": "that people understand that our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00518-00146005-00146233": "government takes the job of supporting", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00519-00146234-00146398": "women and their children who have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00520-00146399-00146640": "experienced domestic violence very", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00521-00146641-00146935": "seriously because violence against women", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00522-00146936-00147279": "is something that has a huge impact on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00523-00147280-00147576": "families and on our communities and on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00524-00147577-00147859": "our society essentially violence against", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00525-00147860-00148093": "women and the agencies provide crucial", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00526-00148094-00148302": "services and I province like emergency", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00527-00148303-00148573": "shelters counselling transition and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00528-00148574-00148756": "housing supports to help women and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00529-00148757-00148987": "children rebuild their lives the speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00530-00148988-00149245": "for women facing violence shelter is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00531-00149246-00149470": "often the first step to rebuilding their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00532-00149471-00149676": "personal and financial independence and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00533-00149677-00150003": "our government funds 96 emergency", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00534-00150004-00150271": "shelter agencies across Ontario that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00535-00150272-00150550": "operate more than 2,000 beds a year", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00536-00150551-00150775": "we've increased our investment in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00537-00150776-00151026": "violence against women services by 61", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00538-00151027-00151384": "percent since 2003 supplements", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00539-00151385-00151567": "while mr. speaker the truth is that this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00540-00151568-00151741": "government has been strolling on this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00541-00151742-00152034": "file for almost five years and so in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00542-00152035-00152302": "2013 the Auditor General reported that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00543-00152303-00152449": "the government has made little or no", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00544-00152450-00152623": "progress in meeting the demand for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00545-00152624-00152854": "victim services in our province and here", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00546-00152855-00153124": "we are in 2017 and nothing has changed", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00547-00153125-00153355": "they refuse to consult they refuse to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00548-00153356-00153526": "act and they're continuing to hide", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00549-00153527-00153760": "behind band-aid solutions and decade old", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00550-00153761-00153979": "funding formulas meanwhile victim", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00551-00153980-00154207": "services organization and survivors are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00552-00154208-00154474": "suffering mr. speaker through you to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00553-00154475-00154681": "minister what does this review actually", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00554-00154682-00154936": "entail and when can we finally expect to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00555-00154937-00155620": "hear the results Attorney General Terry", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00556-00155621-00155842": "German well thank you very much speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00557-00155843-00156157": "and let's let let's put some facts on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00558-00156158-00156391": "the table on this very important issue", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00559-00156392-00156685": "speaker first of all we obviously", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00560-00156686-00156949": "appreciate the work that hope 24/7 does", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00561-00156950-00157129": "and we are provided in funding for over", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00562-00157130-00157417": "20 years now since 2003 speaker our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00563-00157418-00157573": "funding for all sexual assault center", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00564-00157574-00157890": "programs have increased by 45 percent in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00565-00157891-00158173": "2015 speaker we increased hope 24/7", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00566-00158174-00158506": "budget by over $31,000 as part of our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00567-00158507-00158740": "it's never okay action plan to increase", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00568-00158741-00158926": "funding to all sexual assault centers by", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00569-00158927-00159229": "7 percent by that speaker hope 24/7", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00570-00159230-00159517": "currently receives almost $500,000", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00571-00159518-00159709": "that's half a million dollars the sixth", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00572-00159710-00159901": "highest funding allocation in all of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00573-00159902-00160114": "Ontario that's because we are committed", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00574-00160115-00160339": "to reviewing counseling services across", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00575-00160340-00160600": "the province in Arras hope 24/7 to be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00576-00160601-00160774": "part of this conversation and there's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00577-00160775-00160933": "also a provincial working group of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00578-00160934-00161122": "sexual assault centres that is content", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00579-00161123-00161281": "ly reviewing the program and I hope", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00580-00161282-00161473": "venture forward to the findings of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00581-00161474-00161710": "review new question remember from other", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00582-00161711-00161899": "Thank You speaker my question is to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00583-00161900-00162220": "acting premier after 14 years of liberal", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00584-00162221-00162397": "government inaction hard-working", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00585-00162398-00162718": "Ontario's Ontarians wanted real change", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00586-00162719-00162985": "now like the one in ten in this province", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00587-00162986-00163255": "to struggle on minimum wage like the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00588-00163256-00163498": "majority of new job holders who struggle", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00589-00163499-00163774": "to make ends meet part-time like the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00590-00163775-00163963": "majority of women", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00591-00163964-00164212": "who actually are juggling multiple jobs", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00592-00164213-00164494": "which is increased by 20% under the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00593-00164495-00164785": "liberal watch Union jobs are good jobs", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00594-00164786-00164992": "any Democrats believe that it should be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00595-00164993-00165331": "easier for workers to join a union not", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00596-00165332-00165394": "harder", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00597-00165395-00165562": "well the acting premier commits to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00598-00165563-00165826": "implement card based Union certification", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00599-00165827-00166147": "and first contract arbitration for all", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00600-00166148-00166429": "workers in Ontario who wish to join the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00601-00166430-00166674": "union and if not why not", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00602-00166675-00167107": "okay safety speaker and I thank the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00603-00167108-00167275": "member opposite for the question the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00604-00167276-00167524": "reality is that our economy Ontario is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00605-00167525-00167791": "growing it's the leading jurisdiction in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00606-00167792-00168012": "the country our growth is strong speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00607-00168013-00168415": "5 not everyone is sharing in that growth", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00608-00168416-00168646": "it's become very clear that in this new", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00609-00168647-00168865": "economy there are those who are doing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00610-00168866-00169054": "very very well and others who are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00611-00169055-00169330": "struggling just to prevent themselves", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00612-00169331-00169612": "from falling back which is exactly why", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00613-00169613-00169759": "we're introducing the changing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00614-00169760-00170062": "workplaces legislation speaker we are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00615-00170063-00170365": "very proud of of the work that has been", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00616-00170366-00170512": "done and the action that we are taking", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00617-00170513-00170734": "that the premier has announced today", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00618-00170735-00170959": "with the Minister of Labour speaker so", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00619-00170960-00171211": "we will be hiking the minimum wage", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00620-00171212-00171439": "speaker we will be assuring that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00621-00171440-00171682": "part-time workers are paid the same as", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00622-00171683-00171913": "full-time workers speaker we're", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00623-00171914-00172150": "introducing paid sick days for every", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00624-00172151-00172477": "worker with severe enough enforcement of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00625-00172478-00172789": "employment laws this is a very big day", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00626-00172790-00172984": "in the province speaker and I look", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00627-00172985-00173514": "through the NDP supporting these changes", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00628-00173515-00174144": "cynically you sweet idli thank you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00629-00174145-00174421": "supplementary well speaker if you're a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00630-00174422-00174610": "Bay Street trader or you're the head of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00631-00174611-00174856": "a big bank here in Ontario you've got a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00632-00174857-00175072": "lot to cheer about over the last 14", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00633-00175073-00175213": "years but if you're one of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00634-00175214-00175465": "hard-working little people to quote the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00635-00175466-00175629": "Labor Minister this morning you've", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00636-00175630-00175857": "earned your this was a disillusion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00637-00175858-00176101": "disillusionment the premier gave a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00638-00176102-00176326": "campaign speech this morning but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00639-00176327-00176506": "millions of part-time temporary and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00640-00176507-00176725": "multiple job holders are still", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00641-00176726-00176902": "struggling to support their families", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00642-00176903-00177193": "three weeks vacation is a bit of a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00643-00177194-00177412": "stretch after five years it's one of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00644-00177413-00177588": "those liberal stretch goals", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00645-00177589-00177820": "impossibility for many Ontarians who may", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00646-00177821-00178057": "not have a job after five years with the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00647-00178058-00178275": "same employer will the Acting premier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00648-00178276-00178657": "guarantee that in fact there are page 58", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00649-00178658-00178933": "for all Ontario workers under this plan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00650-00178934-00179122": "that was announced today and that in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00651-00179123-00179485": "fact every Ontarian worker will get that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00652-00179486-00180025": "three weeks of vacation katrina here at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00653-00180026-00180271": "Spieker we have we really have been", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00654-00180272-00180550": "paying attention speaker to all of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00655-00180551-00180802": "people in this province including most", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00656-00180803-00180990": "particularly those who are struggling", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00657-00180991-00181240": "the most so there has been a lot of good", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00658-00181241-00181495": "news recently on that front speaker a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00659-00181496-00181854": "free tuition for four for one-third of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00660-00181855-00182091": "our post-secondary students and better", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00661-00182092-00182415": "than free tuition for many okay plus", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00662-00182416-00182754": "free drugs for children speaker these", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00663-00182755-00183115": "are big initiatives that we are are very", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00664-00183116-00183322": "happy to champion and today's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00665-00183323-00183540": "announcement builds on that speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00666-00183541-00183793": "because we are absolutely determined to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00667-00183794-00183978": "make sure that we live in a society that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00668-00183979-00184258": "we build a society where every person", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00669-00184259-00184435": "has the opportunity to achieve their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00670-00184436-00184669": "full potential to contribute to and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00671-00184670-00184921": "participate in our wonderful life in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00672-00184922-00185134": "Ontario we need to do better speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00673-00185135-00185437": "this legislation takes us a big set of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00674-00185438-00185713": "directions reports", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00675-00185714-00185938": "Thank You mr. speaker and my question", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00676-00185939-00186138": "this morning is to the Attorney General", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00677-00186139-00186388": "yesterday I was very pleased to see the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00678-00186389-00186619": "AG defending the principle that every", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00679-00186620-00186864": "woman in this province has a fundamental", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00680-00186865-00187096": "right to make her own decisions about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00681-00187097-00187357": "her health care I am certain that every", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00682-00187358-00187525": "member in this legislature would also", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00683-00187526-00187764": "agree that women have the fundamental", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00684-00187765-00188040": "right to access health care without fear", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00685-00188041-00188325": "for her safety privacy or dignity I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00686-00188326-00188529": "speak for my constituents when I say", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00687-00188530-00188713": "that I was terribly disheartened to hear", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00688-00188714-00188899": "of the acts of the harassment and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00689-00188900-00189136": "intimidation directed at Ottawa women", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00690-00189137-00189400": "exercising the right to choose speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00691-00189401-00189607": "that kind of hatred aggression toward", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00692-00189608-00189891": "women is absolutely unacceptable that is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00693-00189892-00190060": "why I was very pleased to hear that the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00694-00190061-00190188": "government intends to introduce", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00695-00190189-00190440": "legislation that would create safe", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00696-00190441-00190708": "access zones outside abortion clinics", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00697-00190709-00190975": "and ensure women across Ontario have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00698-00190976-00191134": "safe adverse rooms to health care", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00699-00191135-00191403": "services can the Attorney General inform", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00700-00191404-00191575": "this house about the government's plan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00701-00191576-00191916": "legislation to be introduced the 12:3", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00702-00191917-00192097": "Journal thank you very much because I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00703-00192098-00192228": "really want to thank the member for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00704-00192229-00192424": "asking a very important question speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00705-00192425-00192772": "this is an important issue to me as both", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00706-00192773-00192943": "of the citizens of Ottawa and as a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00707-00192944-00193137": "person was always being a strong", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00708-00193138-00193416": "believer in a woman fundamental right to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00709-00193417-00193701": "choose speaker it is also my steadfast", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00710-00193702-00193929": "belief that every woman in Ontario has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00711-00193930-00194115": "the right to make decisions about our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00712-00194116-00194391": "own health care and she deserves to do", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00713-00194392-00194700": "so freely without fear without fear for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00714-00194701-00194833": "her safety", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00715-00194834-00195126": "privacy or dignity without fear of being", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00716-00195127-00195414": "judged or publicly humiliated because of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00717-00195415-00195687": "a choice speaker without fear of being", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00718-00195688-00195931": "threatened with violence harassment or", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00719-00195932-00196219": "any form of intimidation speaker no", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00720-00196220-00196353": "woman should have to take such things", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00721-00196354-00196537": "into account when making a whole on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00722-00196538-00196747": "health care decisions and that is why", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00723-00196748-00196993": "speaker this wall our government will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00724-00196994-00197149": "introduce legislations that were", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00725-00197150-00197410": "proposed to create safe access zones", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00726-00197411-00197604": "around specified healthcare facilities", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00727-00197605-00197806": "to protect the safety and security of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00728-00197807-00198118": "patients staff and visitors", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00729-00198119-00198331": "Thank You speaker and I would like to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00730-00198332-00198709": "thank the Attorney General in cross this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00731-00198710-00198874": "province would agree that this is an", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00732-00198875-00199126": "important issue that touches every woman", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00733-00199127-00199387": "and goes beyond economic cultural or", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00734-00199388-00199648": "Geographic differences all women across", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00735-00199649-00199867": "this province have fought and laboured", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00736-00199868-00200119": "hard throughout the years to build up", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00737-00200120-00200374": "this country and provost we canal call", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00738-00200375-00200602": "home a woman's fundamental right to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00739-00200603-00200773": "choose is one that should be enshrined", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00740-00200774-00201250": "and protected under the law in fact I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00741-00201251-00201403": "understand that Newfoundland and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00742-00201404-00201595": "Labrador and British Columbia are among", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00743-00201596-00201751": "the few jurisdictions that have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00744-00201752-00202027": "legislated safe access zones to ensure", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00745-00202028-00202231": "protection of health care centers and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00746-00202232-00202453": "women I believe that our government will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00747-00202454-00202603": "introduce strong protections that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00748-00202604-00202846": "guarantee much-needed protections for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00749-00202847-00203017": "health care centers across the province", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00750-00203018-00203269": "my hope is that the members opposite", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00751-00203270-00203494": "works report the government's actions to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00752-00203495-00203707": "ensure women in Ontario can continue to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00753-00203708-00203866": "exercise the fundamental right", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00754-00203867-00204007": "can the Attorney General and former", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00755-00204008-00204211": "House on our government's next step", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00756-00204212-00204490": "thank you 20 Journal I figure thank you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00757-00204491-00204670": "very much the member is correct British", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00758-00204671-00204853": "Columbia Newfoundland and Labrador and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00759-00204854-00205041": "province of Quebec have implemented", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00760-00205042-00205333": "similar laws in their provinces over the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00761-00205334-00205555": "past decade because these laws provide", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00762-00205556-00205819": "for protection to all women and health", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00763-00205819-00205989": "care providers in those jurisdictions", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00764-00205990-00206233": "over the summer months become my", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00765-00206234-00206428": "ministry and I will continue to look at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00766-00206429-00206616": "laws passed in other jurisdictions and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00767-00206617-00206844": "we will consult with legal and health", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00768-00206846-00207088": "care experts advocacy groups and local", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00769-00207089-00207283": "clinics to determine the details of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00770-00207284-00207577": "proposed legislation speaker we have a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00771-00207578-00207769": "lot of work ahead of us on this very", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00772-00207769-00207910": "important issue with the next few months", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00773-00207911-00208102": "and I believe that policies like this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00774-00208103-00208306": "are more important than ever", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00775-00208307-00208669": "Speaker I commend and salute all", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00776-00208669-00208936": "champions of women in this house I know", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00777-00208937-00209158": "that they all believe that this is not a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00778-00209159-00209394": "partisan issue the speaker I know that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00779-00209396-00209565": "they all believe that women have a right", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00780-00209566-00209844": "to choose to make decisions about our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00781-00209846-00210028": "own health care and I'm confident", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00782-00210029-00210187": "speaker I hope that all members will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00783-00210188-00210340": "prepare this very important legislation", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00784-00210341-00210551": "managed tables and horses", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00785-00210552-00210817": "from Cornell thank you very much mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00786-00210819-00210864": "speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00787-00210865-00211507": "[Applause]", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00788-00211508-00211673": "acknowledged", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00789-00211673-00211892": "Thank You mr. speaker my question is to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00790-00211892-00212006": "the Minister of Children and Youth", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00791-00212007-00212267": "Services autism is widely considered the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00792-00212267-00212501": "fastest-growing neurological disorder in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00793-00212502-00212798": "Canada it now impacts an estimated one", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00794-00212798-00213065": "out of 68 children individuals with", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00795-00213066-00213242": "autism and their families face unique", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00796-00213242-00213503": "challenges over their lifespan often", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00797-00213504-00213677": "leading to families in crisis situations", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00798-00213678-00213923": "and that is why today in the federal", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00799-00213923-00214091": "House of Commons there will be a vote to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00800-00214092-00214273": "increase support for families and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00801-00214275-00214517": "children with autism mr. speaker have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00802-00214517-00214688": "the government members been calling on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00803-00214689-00214928": "their cousins in Ottawa to support the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00804-00214929-00215555": "Canadian autism partnership for in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00805-00215556-00215617": "description", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00806-00215619-00215831": "well thank you mr. speaker and I'd like", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00807-00215832-00216073": "to thank the member for the the question", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00808-00216075-00216446": "as the member knows we have a new autism", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00809-00216446-00216650": "program here in the province of Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00810-00216651-00216932": "that will begin implementation in June", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00811-00216933-00217184": "of this year so that's in a few few days", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00812-00217185-00217565": "from now and we will have full", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00813-00217566-00217867": "implementation of the program in 2018", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00814-00217869-00218177": "and mr. speaker this plan is going to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00815-00218178-00218492": "create 16,000 new spaces here in Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00816-00218492-00218723": "over five years and increase the amount", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00817-00218723-00218954": "of spaces for ABA during the transition", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00818-00218955-00219215": "period and it's going to ensure that we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00819-00219216-00219469": "have a six month or less weightless", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00820-00219469-00219758": "we're also going to increase diagnosis", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00821-00219759-00219914": "we've opened up five new treatment", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00822-00219915-00220148": "centers and we're going to make sure", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00823-00220148-00220298": "that if a young person here in the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00824-00220298-00220642": "province of Ontario needs any type of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00825-00220644-00220937": "autism treatment regardless of age they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00826-00220938-00221110": "will get the treatment that they deserve", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00827-00221111-00221644": "- from mr. speaker provincial plans are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00828-00221646-00221855": "wonderful but we need to support the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00829-00221856-00222128": "federal plans for autism as well mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00830-00222129-00222306": "speaker this motion is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00831-00222307-00222534": "it calls on the federal government to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00832-00222535-00223736": "grant 19 million dollars in displacement", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00833-00223737-00224781": "this motion is simple ministers warn the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00834-00224782-00225009": "motion is simple it calls on the federal", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00835-00225010-00225194": "government to grant 19 million dollars", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00836-00225196-00225405": "over five years as requested by the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00837-00225406-00225596": "Canadian autism partnership working", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00838-00225598-00225831": "group self-advocates advisory group and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00839-00225832-00226032": "the Canadian autism spectrum disorders", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00840-00226033-00226196": "Alliance in order to establish a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00841-00226198-00226467": "Canadian autism partnership it would go", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00842-00226467-00226662": "a long way to support families and it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00843-00226663-00226796": "would address key issues such as", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00844-00226798-00227034": "information sharing and research early", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00845-00227035-00227304": "detection diagnosis and treatment mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00846-00227305-00227490": "speaker will the minister personally", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00847-00227491-00227694": "make a phone call to Ottawa for final", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00848-00227694-00227919": "call one of your liberal friends and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00849-00227919-00228167": "guaranteed liberal support of this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00850-00228169-00228564": "important motion well thank you Thank", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00851-00228565-00228702": "You mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00852-00228703-00228900": "there seems to be a difference of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00853-00228901-00229179": "opinion between the caucus and their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00854-00229180-00229617": "leader and I'll tell you why the speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00855-00229617-00229917": "because the leader of the Opposition the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00856-00229917-00230136": "leader of the official opposition and he", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00857-00230137-00230250": "was in Ottawa I believe for his", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00858-00230251-00230490": "nine-year period had an opportunity to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00859-00230491-00230688": "stand up and advocate for national", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00860-00230689-00230867": "program to do and there was an actual", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00861-00230869-00231153": "vote that was presented in the House of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00862-00231154-00231414": "Commons to create a national autism", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00863-00231415-00231630": "program and maybe the member doesn't", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00864-00231631-00231855": "know his/her leaders records on this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00865-00231856-00232353": "issue but he voted against that Mr", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00866-00232354-00232725": "Speaker I think I think all she has to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00867-00232726-00232941": "do instead of picking up the phone maybe", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00868-00232942-00233148": "she can walk two or three rows up and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00869-00233148-00233406": "talk to her leader about his record when", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00870-00233407-00233688": "it comes to a national offices here in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00871-00233689-00234212": "the province of Ontario who seriously", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00872-00234213-00234406": "considered please", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00873-00234407-00236675": "[Applause]", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00874-00236676-00236885": "new question member from Toronto", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00875-00236886-00237138": "Danforth Thank You speakers speaker my", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00876-00237139-00237444": "question to the acting premier nearly 20", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00877-00237444-00237533": "years ago", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00878-00237534-00237738": "the Conservatives downloaded", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00879-00237739-00237944": "responsibility for social housing to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00880-00237946-00238178": "municipality they have no way to pay for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00881-00238179-00238215": "it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00882-00238216-00238544": "this action created a permanent crisis", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00883-00238546-00238829": "for affordable housing most acutely in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00884-00238830-00239075": "Toronto instead of fixing this crisis", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00885-00239076-00239423": "the premier made things worse by cutting", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00886-00239425-00239621": "a hundred and twenty nine million", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00887-00239623-00239957": "dollars per year in annual funding for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00888-00239958-00240198": "Toronto's housing programs half of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00889-00240198-00240444": "Toronto Community Housing homes will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00890-00240444-00240677": "reach full unquote critical status", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00891-00240678-00240944": "within five years due to a lack of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00892-00240946-00241301": "funding for capital repairs the NDP has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00893-00241302-00241539": "repeatedly urged the province to fund", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00894-00241540-00241863": "one third of those capital repair costs", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00895-00241864-00242156": "will the premier do that and undo at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00896-00242157-00242417": "least part of the - and her cuts have", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00897-00242419-00242726": "caused definitely near misses having", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00898-00242727-00243123": "serve healthy well thank you speaker you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00899-00243123-00243390": "know speaker every Ontarian deserves to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00900-00243391-00243639": "have an affordable and safe place to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00901-00243640-00243902": "call home we know that people's lives", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00902-00243903-00244221": "are better when they do and that's why", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00903-00244221-00244442": "speaker that's why speaker this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00904-00244444-00244826": "government has invested 1.4 billion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00905-00244827-00245102": "dollars in the City of Toronto for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00906-00245103-00245303": "affordable and sustainable housing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00907-00245304-00245585": "that's 1.4 billion dollars speaker and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00908-00245586-00245819": "we're continuing to build on these", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00909-00245821-00245988": "investments you know speaker over the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00910-00245989-00246206": "next five years we're investing an", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00911-00246207-00246521": "additional 173 million in social housing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00912-00246523-00246734": "repairs and retrofits in the City of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00913-00246735-00246971": "Toronto things like forty three million", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00914-00246973-00247173": "dollars for repairs and retrofits to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00915-00247173-00247508": "social housing another 130 million in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00916-00247509-00247737": "additional funding for social housing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00917-00247738-00247971": "repairs in Toronto over the next forty", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00918-00247971-00248234": "years so speaker this government debts", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00919-00248235-00248463": "are important this housing is to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00920-00248464-00248648": "residents of the City of Toronto we're", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00921-00248650-00248827": "on it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00922-00248828-00249292": "mr. speaker again to the acting premier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00923-00249292-00249703": "by 2019 toronto city staff estimate the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00924-00249704-00249940": "provincial funding for Toronto's housing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00925-00249941-00250354": "programs will have been cut by nearly 60", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00926-00250355-00250764": "percent from 2011 this premier is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00927-00250765-00251137": "responsible for most of these cuts the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00928-00251138-00251344": "premiers cuts mean that thousands of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00929-00251344-00251566": "Toronto families risk losing their home", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00930-00251567-00252037": "due to disrepair no other government in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00931-00252038-00252307": "Canada or the developed world ignores", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00932-00252308-00252628": "its social responsibility to fund social", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00933-00252629-00252898": "housing programs the way this premier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00934-00252898-00253336": "has will the fingers stop reverse or", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00935-00253337-00253671": "funding cuts and fund the provinces fair", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00936-00253673-00254092": "one-third share of tches capital repair", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00937-00254092-00254560": "cost Minister foot Thank You speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00938-00254561-00254973": "you know I enjoyed this opportunity to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00939-00254975-00255198": "get up and talk about the importance of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00940-00255200-00255544": "social housing affordable housing in the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00941-00255544-00255751": "City of Toronto and to reiterate time", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00942-00255752-00256006": "and again the significant massive", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00943-00256007-00256180": "investments that the province has made", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00944-00256181-00256486": "in the City of Toronto I'll just name", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00945-00256487-00256744": "the the high level one again speaker one", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00946-00256744-00257019": "point four billion dollars that's not", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00947-00257021-00257176": "anyone walking away from their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00948-00257177-00257329": "responsibility to the City of Toronto", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00949-00257330-00257701": "speaker I welcome Toronto councils can", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00950-00257702-00257994": "year commitment of about 200 million", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00951-00257996-00258205": "dollars in funding and tax exemptions", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00952-00258206-00258457": "that's good to to go towards this it's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00953-00258458-00258607": "also good to have the federal government", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00954-00258608-00258781": "at the table you know through the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00955-00258782-00258976": "National Housing Strategy they'll be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00956-00258977-00259201": "allocating eleven billion dollars over", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00957-00259202-00259450": "11 years across 13 provinces and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00958-00259451-00259684": "territories and so what we've done", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00959-00259685-00259998": "speaker is we continue to invest in fact", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00960-00260000-00260182": "we just announced a hundred million", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00961-00260183-00260569": "dollars in land energy of Toronto", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00962-00260571-00260837": "and many more I've got a question for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00963-00260838-00260990": "the Minister of Agriculture and Rural", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00964-00260991-00261067": "Affairs", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00965-00261069-00261292": "I know Minister how excited you are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00966-00261292-00261521": "because our farmers are back in the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00967-00261521-00261875": "fields for the growing season and very", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00968-00261876-00262163": "soon we will be celebrating local food", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00969-00262164-00262273": "week", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00970-00262274-00262625": "whereby we can pay tribute to our 36", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00971-00262626-00263048": "billion dollar agriculture economy which", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00972-00263049-00263483": "supports 800,000 jobs in this problem so", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00973-00263484-00263720": "on June the 5th or 11th we're going to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00974-00263721-00264035": "be celebrating our wonderful locally", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00975-00264036-00264511": "grown safe reliable tasty and affordable", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00976-00264512-00264779": "Ontario local food what are you going to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00977-00264780-00265162": "do to celebrate mr. Minister Thank You", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00978-00265163-00265403": "mr. very culture crooner", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00979-00265404-00265583": "thanks very much Mr Speaker I appreciate", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00980-00265584-00265757": "the question from the member for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00981-00265758-00265940": "Begley's Dolores is a champion for local", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00982-00265941-00266156": "food local food week is a nice", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00983-00266157-00266312": "opportunity to highlight the great work", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00984-00266313-00266498": "our partners are doing to promote local", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00985-00266499-00266750": "food for Ontarians we have the Greenbelt", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00986-00266751-00267041": "fund which is providing 340 million", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00987-00267042-00267347": "dollars to support 77 local food project", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00988-00267348-00267533": "I also want to highlight the work of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00989-00267534-00267776": "dietitians of Canada the Adaro fruit of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00990-00267777-00267983": "vegetable Growers Association for the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00991-00267984-00268190": "freshener of the farm the only school", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00992-00268191-00268388": "fundraising cell at Ontario grown fruits", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00993-00268389-00268571": "and vegetables starting this October", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00994-00268572-00268895": "schools can apply and of course the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00995-00268896-00269129": "culinary tourism alliance which is the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00996-00269130-00269294": "delivering got Gstaad program to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00997-00269295-00269462": "encourage restaurants to use more", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00998-00269463-00269705": "locally sourced ingredients wide spirit", "d4ThOtK-aJE-00999-00269706-00269909": "signers of their venues mr. speaker were", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01000-00269910-00270089": "lucky to have so many local food", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01001-00270090-00270254": "champions that are hoping to bring", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01002-00270255-00270473": "farmers food bakers and consumers", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01003-00270474-00270656": "together so that they could help us a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01004-00270657-00270821": "joint the good things that are growing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01005-00270822-00271033": "in Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01006-00271034-00271340": "supplementary as you know Minister this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01007-00271341-00271448": "afternoon", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01008-00271449-00271721": "Ontario beef farmers are going to be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01009-00271722-00271910": "having a barbecue in the front lawn and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01010-00271911-00272132": "they're going to be featuring succulent", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01011-00272133-00272585": "Ontario locally grown beef I get tired", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01012-00272586-00272771": "of people who say well I'm going to go", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01013-00272772-00273050": "get some Alberta beef or Texas beef why", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01014-00273051-00273293": "don't more people ask for Ontario beef", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01015-00273294-00273779": "when they go to the restaurant forget", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01016-00273780-00274049": "that expensive imported foreign beef", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01017-00274050-00274295": "Rover get that expensive foreign", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01018-00274296-00274688": "cauliflower buy local eat local shop", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01019-00274689-00276110": "local save local Minister Mr Speaker I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01020-00276111-00276275": "appreciate the supplementary for my good", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01021-00276276-00276425": "friend the pepper for regulars and Lord", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01022-00276426-00276725": "yes today is the beef farmers of Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01023-00276726-00276974": "agile BBQ encourage all members of their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01024-00276975-00277220": "staff to get out to a joint Theriot has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01025-00277221-00277409": "the most culturally diverse population", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01026-00277410-00277709": "in Canada from over 200 countries that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01027-00277710-00277901": "bar the tuner foods grow the province", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01028-00277902-00278081": "Terrance could have already pre called", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01029-00278082-00278279": "the world by shopping at the local", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01030-00278280-00278489": "farmers market or finding the food land", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01031-00278490-00278693": "of Terror local will be working to get", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01032-00278694-00278900": "the word out this summer about the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01033-00278901-00279128": "tremendous opportunity of the world food", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01034-00279129-00279443": "spring with this advice food and aterial", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01035-00279444-00279683": "is partnering with the culinary lights", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01036-00279684-00279950": "of Canada for a wonderful pop-up clinic", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01037-00279951-00280211": "at the ugh Dundas Square this Thursday", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01038-00280212-00280439": "June 1st I suggest everybody take the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01039-00280440-00280679": "opportunity to go there this event will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01040-00280680-00280880": "feature feast on centered restaurants", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01041-00280881-00281069": "who are part Nick was Ontario farmers", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01042-00281070-00281192": "from search showcase the diversity", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01043-00281193-00281438": "recipe that could be made with a tear of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01044-00281439-00281648": "growing food I bite you all to this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01045-00281649-00281882": "picnic a couple resonates Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01046-00281883-00282191": "dentists mr. speaker new person remember", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01047-00282192-00282355": "from peristyle Muskoka", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01048-00282356-00282563": "Thank You mr. speaker my customers the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01049-00282564-00282730": "minister of Northern Development and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01050-00282731-00283112": "mines speaker in 2011 this government", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01051-00283113-00283276": "announced the growth plan for Northern", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01052-00283277-00283514": "Ontario promising to create a stronger", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01053-00283515-00283834": "more diverse and sustainable northern", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01054-00283835-00284269": "economy Northern Ontario has lost 5,000", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01055-00284270-00284540": "full-time jobs and more than 6,000", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01056-00284541-00284968": "part-time jobs between 2011 and 2016", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01057-00284969-00285199": "during the same time the value of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01058-00285200-00285368": "building permits issued in Northern", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01059-00285369-00285754": "Ontario has declined by 25% the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01060-00285755-00286067": "minister's own quote in the 2011 news", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01061-00286068-00286252": "release which was that this plan would", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01062-00286253-00286490": "quote help ensure the development of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01063-00286491-00286637": "northern communities as places where", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01064-00286638-00286893": "people will want to live work and play", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01065-00286894-00287243": "for future generations close quote but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01066-00287244-00287458": "after the first five years of this plan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01067-00287459-00287728": "there are 10,000 fewer adults living in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01068-00287729-00287939": "Northern Ontario question speaker based", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01069-00287940-00288094": "on those statistics how with the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01070-00288095-00288334": "minister characterized the success of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01071-00288335-00288518": "the government's growth plan for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01072-00288519-00288914": "Northern Ontario minimize the speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01073-00288915-00289142": "thank you and I want to thank the member", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01074-00289143-00289510": "for the question I think it is fair to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01075-00289511-00289787": "characterize and say that northern", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01076-00289788-00290039": "communities and rural communities just", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01077-00290040-00290267": "like all communities that are small and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01078-00290268-00290497": "rural right across Canada and I would", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01079-00290498-00290674": "say right across North America are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01080-00290675-00290990": "facing a unique set of circumstances and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01081-00290991-00291259": "challenges it is not only in Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01082-00291260-00291394": "where small Northern and rural", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01083-00291395-00291593": "communities are facing these challenges", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01084-00291594-00291767": "speaker they exist in all jurisdictions", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01085-00291768-00292003": "I would say certainly in Canada it's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01086-00292004-00292187": "been a consistent problem speaker but I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01087-00292188-00292418": "would say absolutely I would say", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01088-00292419-00292627": "unequivocally that our government since", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01089-00292628-00292894": "being elected in 2003 has provided", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01090-00292895-00293098": "support to northern and rural", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01091-00293099-00293335": "communities across a broad range of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01092-00293336-00293497": "policy investments speaker that I can", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01093-00293498-00293663": "speak to more on the Supplemental the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01094-00293664-00293843": "member knows that he would suggest in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01095-00293844-00294004": "stand in his place to try and say that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01096-00294005-00294212": "these problems just occurred there has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01097-00294213-00294424": "been some population reduction speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01098-00294425-00294563": "but I would say the situation in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01099-00294564-00294740": "northern communities would have been", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01100-00294741-00294904": "much greater had it not been for the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01101-00294905-00295024": "investments that we've been making for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01102-00295025-00295108": "County government", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01103-00295109-00295432": "some years ago complementary mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01104-00295433-00295582": "the challenges he's talking about though", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01105-00295583-00295858": "the ones his government has created and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01106-00295859-00296176": "I recognize this is a 25 year plan but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01107-00296177-00296419": "were five years and so far it's a dismal", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01108-00296420-00296683": "failure the population of Northern", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01109-00296684-00296888": "Ontario is declining employment is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01110-00296889-00297106": "declining less is being built businesses", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01111-00297107-00297331": "like Great Lakes drop rates are leaving", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01112-00297332-00297559": "one of the promises of the growth plan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01113-00297560-00297847": "for Northern Ontario was was this and to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01114-00297848-00298123": "quote immediately develop a long-term", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01115-00298124-00298330": "strategy to create a more integrated", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01116-00298331-00298541": "transportation infrastructure system for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01117-00298542-00298750": "air Rail Road and water", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01118-00298751-00298999": "close quote speaker that promise was", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01119-00299000-00299315": "made six years ago and the most recent", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01120-00299316-00299516": "document is still a discussion paper", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01121-00299517-00299752": "where is the strategy and when will we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01122-00299753-00299974": "see shovels in the ground on new roads", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01123-00299975-00300191": "new rail lines new shipping docks or new", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01124-00300192-00300619": "air strips not going to mr. speaker by", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01125-00300620-00300887": "way of example one of the investments", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01126-00300888-00301006": "we've been making in Northern Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01127-00301007-00301210": "for quite some time now is to reverse a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01128-00301211-00301321": "decision that was made by the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01129-00301322-00301493": "Conservative Party when they were in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01130-00301494-00301675": "government as well and had been started", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01131-00301676-00301894": "by the NDP and that is providing support", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01132-00301895-00302039": "for forestry companies in Northern", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01133-00302040-00302278": "Ontario through a forestry roads access", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01134-00302279-00302497": "program since bringing this project back", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01135-00302498-00302728": "into investments in the province of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01136-00302729-00302983": "Ontario since 2005 we've invested about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01137-00302984-00303242": "seven hundred million dollars in primary", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01138-00303243-00303379": "and secondary forestry roads in the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01139-00303380-00303580": "province of Ontario to support forestry", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01140-00303581-00303799": "companies primarily a northern based", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01141-00303800-00304045": "operation as well speaker since coming", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01142-00304046-00304195": "into government we were investing now", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01143-00304196-00304408": "somewhere between five and six hundred", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01144-00304409-00304570": "million dollars annually through a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01145-00304571-00304807": "northern highways program speaker when", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01146-00304808-00305005": "they were in government for all eight", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01147-00305006-00305318": "years from 95 to 2003 the high-water", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01148-00305319-00305593": "mark for northern highways was 2 to 250", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01149-00305594-00305797": "million and anyone giving you we're", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01150-00305798-00306051": "going to be doing 650 million this year", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01151-00306052-00306349": "speaker that's only one more example of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01152-00306350-00306512": "the major investments that we've been", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01153-00306513-00306673": "making in Northern Ontario since forming", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01154-00306674-00306925": "government some time again - new", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01155-00306926-00307126": "question the literally up third party", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01156-00307127-00307303": "Thank You speaker my questions for the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01157-00307304-00307501": "acting premier healthcare should be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01158-00307502-00307747": "there when you need it but cuts and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01159-00307748-00307994": "underfunding by both liberals and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01160-00307995-00308267": "have pushed the zoo area hospital to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01161-00308268-00308524": "brink it's now the second most", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01162-00308525-00309815": "overcrowded Hospital any please put your", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01163-00309816-00309980": "questions now the second most", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01164-00309981-00310202": "overcrowded Hospital in the entire", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01165-00310203-00310499": "province experts tell us that occupancy", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01166-00310500-00310831": "rates over 85% put patients at risk but", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01167-00310832-00311066": "the zoo area hospital has been forced to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01168-00311067-00311450": "run at an average occupancy of 106", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01169-00311451-00311768": "percent for the past five years and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01170-00311769-00311972": "instead of fixing the problem", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01171-00311973-00312188": "the Premier's budget shortchanges", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01172-00312189-00312392": "Ontario's hospitals by over three", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01173-00312393-00312689": "hundred million dollars why is this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01174-00312690-00312920": "government forcing people and seniors", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01175-00312921-00313121": "and sue sainte-marie to pay the price", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01176-00313122-00313556": "for liberal custom house in long term", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01177-00313557-00313754": "care the serve health long term care", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01178-00313755-00313952": "well thank you mr. speaker and I have to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01179-00313953-00314249": "admit that I'm absolutely mystified at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01180-00314250-00314447": "this question deikun", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01181-00314448-00314687": "well that's what really classes some of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01182-00314688-00314888": "the comments that we're hearing but mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01183-00314889-00315140": "speaker the reality is with the SU", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01184-00315141-00315430": "hospital both the leader of the third", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01185-00315431-00315724": "party and the official opposition went", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01186-00315725-00316009": "specifically to the suit area to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01187-00316010-00316244": "criticize the fact that the government", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01188-00316245-00316534": "is providing a five percent increase to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01189-00316535-00316909": "the operating cost at that Hospital this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01190-00316910-00317147": "fiscal year so on the one hand mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01191-00317148-00317407": "speaker consistently the third party has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01192-00317408-00317648": "said we need to invest more in our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01193-00317649-00317884": "hospitals and as they go out of their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01194-00317885-00318218": "way during a by-election I might hire to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01195-00318219-00318398": "the to hospital and the leader of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01196-00318399-00318626": "third party was critical of the fact", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01197-00318627-00318994": "that unsuspicious as a factor somehow a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01198-00318995-00319280": "5% increase to the budget of that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01199-00319281-00319472": "Hospital of over six million dollars", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01200-00319473-00319664": "issue that is unnecessary or", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01201-00319665-00319877": "inappropriate i fund I nearly disagree", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01202-00319878-00320065": "Eric", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01203-00320066-00320366": "well speaker there have been nine years", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01204-00320367-00320618": "of Pat's and frozen budgets by this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01205-00320619-00320819": "Liberal government and that's something", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01206-00320820-00321011": "that this house minister and the ones", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01207-00321012-00321251": "prior to him need to fess up to but the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01208-00321252-00321470": "people in suits Amery know exactly", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01209-00321471-00321644": "what's happening to health care folks", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01210-00321645-00321920": "are waiting longer than ever admitted", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01211-00321921-00322106": "patients are waiting up to fifty three", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01212-00322107-00322334": "hours in the emergency room to get a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01213-00322335-00322589": "proper bed people who need a CT scan are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01214-00322590-00322781": "waiting three times longer than the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01215-00322782-00322973": "provincial target and this new area", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01216-00322974-00323246": "hospital it's so overcrowded they've", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01217-00323247-00323501": "actually stopped using their code for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01218-00323502-00323672": "good gridlock it's now meaningless", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01219-00323673-00323891": "because they were using their gridlock", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01220-00323892-00324215": "code every single day when will this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01221-00324216-00324407": "government stop making excuses and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01222-00324408-00324602": "actually repair the damage they've done", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01223-00324603-00324869": "to hospital and Suzy Murray and right", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01224-00324870-00325088": "across the whole province Minister", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01225-00325089-00325609": "across the whole proper chair please", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01226-00325610-00325886": "carry on Thank You mr. speaker and you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01227-00325887-00326425": "know I I am almost without words", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01228-00326426-00326747": "mr. speaker the I'm not sure what the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01229-00326748-00327050": "leader of the third party wants does she", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01230-00327051-00327434": "not want us to provide 6.6 million more", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01231-00327435-00327641": "dollars to the zoo hospital and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01232-00327642-00327926": "increased this year alone of five", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01233-00327927-00328181": "percent mr. speaker or does she", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01234-00328182-00328487": "yeah and conveniently her party has", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01235-00328488-00328703": "advocated for more funding but it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01236-00328704-00328954": "confounds me that they also voted", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01237-00328955-00329339": "against the budget that provide a five", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01238-00329340-00329537": "percent increase to the budget of this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01239-00329538-00329759": "new hospital they voted against a budget", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01240-00329760-00329942": "that provides over half a billion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01241-00329943-00330245": "dollars more to the operating costs of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01242-00330246-00330494": "budgets across this province they voted", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01243-00330495-00330710": "against the budget than Sarai's as an", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01244-00330711-00330911": "additional nine billion dollars in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01245-00330912-00331139": "capital infrastructure I don't", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01246-00331140-00331415": "understand where the party where their", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01247-00331416-00331649": "policy is mr. speaker but I know where", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01248-00331650-00331912": "we stand", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01249-00331913-00332659": "stated please you see the new partially", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01250-00332660-00332902": "remember from Bari Thank You mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01251-00332903-00333018": "my question is to the Minister", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01252-00333019-00333310": "responsible for accessibility mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01253-00333311-00333504": "speaker this is national awareness", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01254-00333505-00333788": "Awareness Week here in Ontario it's an", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01255-00333789-00334021": "important week which celebrates people", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01256-00334022-00334189": "with disabilities and raises awareness", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01257-00334190-00334444": "about supporting access in all our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01258-00334445-00334657": "communities it's a week that puts the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01259-00334658-00334906": "spotlight on the cultural shift we are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01260-00334907-00335179": "experiencing one where all people can", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01261-00335180-00335513": "participate equally in our society we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01262-00335514-00335734": "come a long way to make our province", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01263-00335735-00335963": "more inclusive and we are working hard", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01264-00335964-00336214": "to reach our goal of an accessible", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01265-00336215-00336563": "Ontario by 2025 mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01266-00336564-00336751": "but the minister tell us more about the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01267-00336752-00336952": "national access Awareness Week and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01268-00336953-00337165": "provide an update on some of the great", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01269-00337166-00337390": "work that we are doing to make Ontario", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01270-00337391-00337613": "accessible race are responsible of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01271-00337614-00337693": "accessibility", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01272-00337694-00337930": "thank you figure and I want to thank the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01273-00337931-00338224": "member from very very important question", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01274-00338225-00338512": "being national access Awareness Week", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01275-00338513-00338713": "makes a question all the more important", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01276-00338714-00338935": "because this week is of course the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01277-00338936-00339232": "chance to show what we've done and focus", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01278-00339233-00339418": "what we can do speaker to empower", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01279-00339419-00339673": "businesses enlighten communities and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01280-00339674-00339910": "embrace inclusion our government is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01281-00339911-00340159": "committed to breaking down barriers the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01282-00340160-00340450": "profile of accessibility we know seeing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01283-00340451-00340678": "of course the accessibility is far more", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01284-00340679-00340918": "than just building ramps it's the best", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01285-00340919-00341155": "small things you don't see like getting", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01286-00341156-00341347": "everyone to the places they need to be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01287-00341348-00341617": "on time and comfortably and on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01288-00341618-00341923": "accessible available transit or making", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01289-00341924-00342124": "sure we provide information that meets", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01290-00342125-00342373": "everyone's needs it's about connecting", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01291-00342374-00342571": "people with disability to the labor", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01292-00342572-00342838": "market engaging in supporting business", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01293-00342839-00343126": "or and employers I'll speak more to our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01294-00343127-00343294": "government's recent developments and how", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01295-00343295-00343635": "people can get involved when I thank you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01296-00343636-00343888": "Asian kids may grant to the Minister for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01297-00343889-00344106": "that for her answer mr. speaker national", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01298-00344107-00344334": "access Awareness Week helps to raise", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01299-00344335-00344574": "awareness and continues to promote a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01300-00344575-00344682": "cultural shift", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01301-00344683-00344920": "we need communities businesses and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01302-00344921-00345163": "individuals all across Ontario to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01303-00345164-00345373": "understand that inclusion is important", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01304-00345374-00345622": "for building a strong society and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01305-00345623-00345951": "developing a dynamic economy the Martin", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01306-00345952-00346195": "prosperity Institute report outlines", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01307-00346196-00346404": "that an inclusive Ontario would result", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01308-00346405-00346693": "in a seven point nine billion dollar", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01309-00346694-00347089": "increase to the GDP and more than 150", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01310-00347090-00347352": "billion dollars is lost in tax revenue", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01311-00347353-00347559": "annually due to the limited acute", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01312-00347560-00347842": "inclusion of persons with disabilities", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01313-00347843-00348075": "in the workforce and that seat is clear", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01314-00348076-00348333": "mr. speaker increasing accessibility and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01315-00348334-00348622": "fostering inclusions is worth it that is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01316-00348623-00348810": "why encourages many individuals", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01317-00348811-00349035": "organizations and communities fortune", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01318-00349036-00349093": "calls", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01319-00349094-00349288": "speaker could the minister explain how", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01320-00349289-00349476": "our government is working hard to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01321-00349477-00349683": "promote inclusion increase accessibility", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01322-00349684-00350146": "on Ontario's character again thanks for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01323-00350147-00350317": "the member from Barrie for the question", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01324-00350318-00350668": "and speaker under the accessibility for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01325-00350669-00350842": "hearings of Disabilities Act we've", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01326-00350843-00351003": "created a number of standards", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01327-00351004-00351402": "development committees which are either", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01328-00351403-00351694": "reviewing current standards or we're", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01329-00351695-00351994": "stablishing new ones so we have ones in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01330-00351995-00352219": "areas such as information communication", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01331-00352220-00352441": "we have review in the employment", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01332-00352442-00352701": "standard and speaker I'll be speaking", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01333-00352702-00352878": "more about the employment strategy for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01334-00352879-00353052": "persons and disabilities in the coming", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01335-00353053-00353280": "days and speaker we are currently", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01336-00353281-00353532": "developing Ontario's first accessible", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01337-00353533-00353802": "healthcare standard and last year the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01338-00353803-00353944": "premier announced we'll also be working", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01339-00353945-00354241": "on an accessible education standard and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01340-00354242-00354594": "we recently launched a survey speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01341-00354595-00354940": "Germany education standards and it vice", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01342-00354941-00355171": "people involved in that process and I'd", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01343-00355172-00355396": "like to encourage everyone to be part of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01344-00355397-00355467": "Nash", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01345-00355468-00355617": "that's Awareness Week because it's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01346-00355618-00355992": "important thank you we fortunately", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01347-00355993-00356184": "member from her sprays inside mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01348-00356185-00356379": "speaker my questions the deputy premier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01349-00356380-00356595": "Peter and Jackie nipple and Gayle and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01350-00356596-00356772": "Ralph Fullerton run independent grocery", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01351-00356773-00356976": "stores and Bruce creo and sound and they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01352-00356977-00357135": "along with other small businesses are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01353-00357136-00357276": "hurting under this Liberal government's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01354-00357277-00357465": "failed energy plans yeah they're the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01355-00357466-00357593": "electricity costs have skyrocketed", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01356-00357594-00357843": "mostly as a result of your liberal", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01357-00357844-00358095": "ideology weight and incompetence yeah", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01358-00358096-00358314": "February 23rd your premier assured the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01359-00358315-00358503": "house and I quote the small business", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01360-00358504-00358737": "grocers would receive the 8% rebate as", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01361-00358738-00358938": "part of your fair Hydro Act announcement", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01362-00358939-00359139": "sadly it turns out this was a pure", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01363-00359140-00359355": "liberal electioneering I want you know", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01364-00359356-00359541": "three used mr. speaker is it fair to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01365-00359542-00359757": "break a promise deputy primer is it fair", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01366-00359758-00359985": "to exclude small town family grocers", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01367-00359986-00360446": "from your supposed fare relief scheme", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01368-00360447-00360734": "deaf consumer the Minister of Energy", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01369-00360735-00361107": "from Energy mr. speaker pleased to be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01370-00361108-00361272": "able to stand here and talk about the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01371-00361273-00361437": "fair hydro plan which is going to be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01372-00361438-00361845": "reducing bills by 25% for small", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01373-00361846-00362076": "businesses and farms and and every", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01374-00362077-00362274": "residence right across this province mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01375-00362275-00362463": "speaker when it comes to grocery stores", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01376-00362464-00362799": "Mr Speaker we have the save on energy", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01377-00362800-00363018": "program and the save on energy program", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01378-00363019-00363297": "specifically targets and works with", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01379-00363298-00363534": "grocery stores we had Loblaws come to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01380-00363535-00363732": "Sudbury mr. speaker to make an", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01381-00363733-00364005": "announcement that their large stores and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01382-00364006-00364239": "their small stores mr. speaker are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01383-00364240-00364632": "actually saving up to 22% on their bills", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01384-00364633-00364884": "if they participate in the save on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01385-00364885-00365112": "energy program and so what Loblaws is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01386-00365113-00365367": "doing is working with all of their local", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01387-00365368-00365634": "retailers their franchisees to make sure", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01388-00365635-00365892": "mr. speaker that they take part in this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01389-00365893-00366129": "program because it's this program that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01390-00366130-00366273": "this government has brought forward on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01391-00366274-00366519": "top of the fair hydro plan that is going", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01392-00366520-00366681": "to continue to help small businesses", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01393-00366682-00366978": "right across the Robbins country Thank", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01394-00366979-00367116": "You speaker back to that group", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01395-00367117-00367260": "maybe Minister you should come to Bruce", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01396-00367261-00367392": "kalin-san to talk to these small", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01397-00367393-00367584": "independent owners and get a real taste", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01398-00367585-00367700": "of life", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01399-00367701-00367913": "Stanly groceries are an integral part of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01400-00367914-00368093": "the best of small communities across", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01401-00368094-00368345": "material we want and need them to stay", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01402-00368346-00368552": "in rural Jarrell but like 60% of all", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01403-00368553-00368693": "stores material that are independent", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01404-00368694-00368915": "small businesses the to local family", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01405-00368916-00369092": "grocers in my riding are finding it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01406-00369093-00369266": "harder and harder to stay in business", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01407-00369267-00369536": "unlike your ideology you see they can't", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01408-00369537-00369713": "turn freezers and fridges off overnight", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01409-00369714-00369893": "to qualify for the eight percent rebate", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01410-00369894-00370127": "your government promised them true you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01411-00370128-00370373": "speaker is it fair that you arbitrarily", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01412-00370374-00370640": "exclude small towns family groceries", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01413-00370641-00370826": "from relief from exorbitant rates caused", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01414-00370827-00371090": "by your mismanagement and your ideology", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01415-00371091-00371270": "miss no thank you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01416-00371271-00371486": "Thank You mr. speaker so when I was in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01417-00371487-00371834": "Bruce Owen Sound area mr. speaker and I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01418-00371835-00372092": "did talk to small business owners they", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01419-00372093-00372323": "all recognize that this fair hydro plant", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01420-00372324-00372527": "mr. speaker is going to help them and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01421-00372528-00372794": "also franceska Dobbin the executive", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01422-00372795-00373001": "director of the United Way is applauding", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01423-00373002-00373199": "this plant maybe he should talk to his", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01424-00373200-00373409": "own people and see what they think about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01425-00373410-00373649": "this plan mr. speaker when we're talking", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01426-00373650-00373853": "about plan I find it very interesting", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01427-00373854-00374108": "that it come a question comes from a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01428-00374109-00374300": "party that doesn't have an approach to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01429-00374301-00374564": "energy doesn't have an approach on how", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01430-00374565-00374723": "to lower energy bills for families", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01431-00374724-00374885": "doesn't have an approach in how it's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01432-00374886-00375077": "going to lower bills for for small", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01433-00375078-00375353": "business nothing for farms nothing for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01434-00375354-00375554": "long-term care homes nothing for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01435-00375555-00375767": "greenhouses mr. speaker we've acted", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01436-00375768-00375908": "we've heard we've listed", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01437-00375909-00376133": "we've helped greenhouses now remote", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01438-00376134-00376361": "customers conservation programs that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01439-00376362-00376547": "will continue to help others mr. speaker", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01440-00376548-00376754": "reveal the list is endless that's what", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01441-00376755-00376967": "happens when you have a plan we have a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01442-00376968-00377187": "plan mr. speaker can they go", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01443-00377188-00377697": "we are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01444-00377698-00378148": "conceited flick", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01445-00378149-00378770": "conceitedly remember from Niagara slam", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01446-00378771-00379019": "broke on a point of order mr. speaker I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01447-00379020-00379175": "didn't have the opportunity to earlier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01448-00379176-00379331": "but I wish to welcome for my writing the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01449-00379332-00379538": "Reverend Peter Holt flora and his wife", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01450-00379539-00379655": "Erica low-floor welcome to the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01451-00379656-00379891": "legislature", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01452-00379892-00380723": "mr. housing minister of housing in our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01453-00380724-00380942": "point of order Thank You speaker I just", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01454-00380943-00381293": "wanted to correct the record I misspoke", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01455-00381294-00381467": "when I said that the 130 million", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01456-00381468-00381635": "additional funding for social housing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01457-00381636-00381944": "repairs in Toronto was I said over 40", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01458-00381945-00382652": "years it's actually over four years we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01459-00382653-00382871": "have with the ferb we have a deferred", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01460-00382872-00383045": "vote on the government notice of motion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01461-00383046-00383318": "number 33 relating to allocation of time", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01462-00383319-00383561": "a bill 89 an act to enact the Child", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01463-00383562-00383873": "Youth and Family Services Act 2016 to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01464-00383874-00384008": "amend and repeal Child and Family", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01465-00384009-00384245": "Services Act and to make related", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01466-00384246-00384416": "amendments to other facts calling the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01467-00384417-00410488": "members as to be a five-minute film", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01468-00410489-00414784": "you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01469-00414785-00416249": "all members please take your seats", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01470-00416250-00418126": "while members please take your seat", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01471-00418127-00418478": "on May 29th 2007 Tina's sandals move", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01472-00418479-00418670": "government notice of motion number 33", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01473-00418671-00418843": "relating to the allocation of time on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01474-00418844-00419020": "bill 89 almost in favor of the motion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01475-00419021-00419149": "please rise one at a time to be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01476-00419150-00419324": "recognized by the clerk it's an act it's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01477-00419325-00419489": "been acting Bradley so Bradley those new", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01478-00419489-00419657": "casino news can handle the Sanders", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01479-00419658-00419801": "pursues those two students is when is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01480-00419802-00419978": "when is math is math and drops across", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01481-00419979-00420191": "Pizzarelli the Shirelles can do this to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01482-00420192-00420391": "do this with Charlie charming me just to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01483-00420392-00420608": "make me to the car to the car mr. Cole's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01484-00420609-00420818": "too cold Barnett kubernetes Delaney", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01485-00420818-00421031": "Delaney so good mr. Dillon mr. Murray", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01486-00421032-00421202": "mr. Murray a chance a chance", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01487-00421203-00421418": "Morini Maurizio so I told miss hunter", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01488-00421418-00421660": "Sunkist alleles Camille mr. Flynn's two", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01489-00421662-00421868": "plans to TiVo cattivo down the law and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01490-00421868-00422063": "along district aaj mr. Qadri prediction", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01491-00422064-00422258": "mr. Nicklaus is manga Megan's to crack", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01492-00422259-00422518": "defenses Dom Donald is McGarry mcGarry's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01493-00422519-00422720": "tomorrow's tomorrow mr. Zimmer mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01494-00422721-00422954": "Zimmer mrs. Alvin is a Javanese McMahon", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01495-00422955-00423143": "McMahon to balance the balance I do", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01496-00423143-00423343": "Harrigan here as long as Long's to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01497-00423344-00423541": "praise the Fraser Travis transistor", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01498-00423542-00423734": "Baker to bake this for dog turd on the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01499-00423735-00423956": "toe Garko guys with koalas koalas moly", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01500-00423957-00424181": "moly mark this is Mark mr. real Chester", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01501-00424182-00424339": "milk ginger pots to pass through", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01502-00424341-00424550": "knowledge mr. and old is real real time", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01503-00424551-00424889": "drugs yeah there'll get all those", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01504-00424889-00425078": "closely charts multi be recognized by", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01505-00425079-00425252": "the court you will be connecting drawing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01506-00425253-00425516": "a rain garden to the cloud the plan is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01507-00425517-00425777": "Jones Jones Dubrow dabrander Clark apart", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01508-00425778-00425849": "mr. Fedeli", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01509-00425850-00426026": "a fidelity just react Abbas Jack you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01510-00426027-00426170": "must be familiar Paris Thomas coke", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01511-00426171-00426359": "military service Copeland Thompson saw", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01512-00426360-00426575": "mr. Barrett Guevara New York a year and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01513-00426576-00426764": "sibelius convey his drums drop mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01514-00426764-00426956": "Walker to offers her necklace connect", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01515-00426957-00427145": "this is Marco Marco estimate the now", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01516-00427146-00427313": "connect annales de benefits attended", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01517-00427314-00427514": "future calls to code mr. Joe the killer", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01518-00427514-00427703": "this should be song Chevy songs Durant", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01519-00427704-00427883": "fostered anthem Jeannot Jeannot of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01520-00427884-00428047": "Gavin's too kind mr. Miller Hamilton", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01521-00428048-00428210": "each Stoney Creek near Hamilton Stoney", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01522-00428210-00428399": "Creek with salads at Miss Taylor Taylor", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01523-00428400-00428645": "Sinatra and I'm gelatin and jelly miss", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01524-00428646-00428801": "fight was playing this horse this course", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01525-00428802-00429005": "can scam both campus your montage I'm on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01526-00429006-00429139": "to Bradfield you're happy when the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01527-00429141-00429353": "Gretzky's we gave mr. gate mr. Pratt", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01528-00429354-00429514": "just cringe mr. McLaren it's going to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01529-00429516-00432655": "play", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01530-00432656-00433360": "the eyes are 62 the nays are 40 the ice", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01531-00433362-00433571": "being 52 the maze being 40 I declare the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01532-00433572-00433691": "motion carried", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01533-00433692-00433871": "we have a deferred vote on the motion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01534-00433872-00434066": "2/3 rating of bill 87 and act to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01535-00434067-00434213": "implement health measures and measures", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01536-00434214-00434426": "related to seniors by enacting amending", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01537-00434427-00434618": "and repealing various statutes calling", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01538-00434618-00434735": "the members this would be a five-minute", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01539-00434735-00436560": "belt", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01540-00436560-00438918": "[Applause]", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01541-00438918-00439230": "on May 29th 2017 mr. Hoskins movers", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01542-00439231-00439434": "ratings in 87 and act on cement health", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01543-00439435-00439589": "cleansers and measures relating seniors", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01544-00439591-00439725": "by enacting amending and repealing", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01545-00439726-00439902": "various statutes all those in favor", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01546-00439903-00440097": "police or all those officials emotion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01547-00440097-00440229": "please rise wanted time to be recognized", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01548-00440230-00440400": "by the clerk mr. Hoskins your oxygen", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01549-00440401-00440595": "action kinetics the Bradley's graduado", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01550-00440596-00440793": "glucose I'll do some tango Cassandra", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01551-00440793-00441009": "suzet receiving winds winds Matthews", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01552-00441010-00441177": "Matthews - sure Ellie - sure else to do", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01553-00441178-00441360": "this to do this with Charles it comes to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01554-00441360-00441531": "make me kick to make me kiss the car at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01555-00441532-00441732": "the car mr. Cole's two poles Barnett Eve", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01556-00441733-00441942": "Arden and Delaney cipollinis until it's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01557-00441943-00442134": "killing me mr. Murray its Tamara chat", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01558-00442135-00442364": "cancer Murray - Murray because oh go", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01559-00442366-00442578": "tell miss hunter senators allele Helios", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01560-00442579-00442793": "- Flint mr. Clinton Tebow mr. Keeble an", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01561-00442795-00442977": "anvil on and along socotra socotra", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01562-00442978-00443184": "convictions connected to the manga named", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01563-00443185-00443418": "enterprise depends Donald Thomas McGarry", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01564-00443418-00443622": "McHenry tomorrow tomorrow's news Emmer", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01565-00443622-00443949": "mr. Zimmer mrs. Albany in Albany mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01566-00443950-00444162": "Graham McMahon mr. balik's cobalamin I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01567-00444163-00444354": "do Harris 19 hands walk this moment", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01568-00444355-00444518": "appraisers appraised Granderson", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01569-00444520-00444726": "mr. Baker debate this our dogs to go on", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01570-00444727-00444879": "this Hogarth's whole gonna squall let's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01571-00444880-00445080": "koalas Molly's Mulligan Martin this is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01572-00445081-00445275": "Marcus to milchester milk into pods to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01573-00445276-00445455": "Casa rhinology turn all this video", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01574-00445456-00445707": "grinia and and zeros and arrows here mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01575-00445708-00446103": "Urich here drawn into the cloud at the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01576-00446104-00446268": "time there will sister will says Joan", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01577-00446268-00446463": "was doing sir brown the brown mr. Clark", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01578-00446464-00446649": "- Clark mr. Fedeli stupid Elmer's react", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01579-00446650-00446789": "about CD a capacitors and earlier", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01580-00446791-00446904": "periods almost over the military", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01581-00446905-00447096": "soundless Copeland Scotland strong as", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01582-00447097-00447339": "oxes Thompson Cerberus Cabarrus Sebelius", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01583-00447339-00447560": "command roast Ross mr. Hunter Walker -", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01584-00447562-00447735": "Walker - nickel disconnected mrs. March", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01585-00447735-00447945": "Oh Martellus to mix it now maconel mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01586-00447946-00448089": "Pettifer you've had a piece - Cole -", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01587-00448089-00448326": "Cole it's a joke Joe my name's Ellen", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01588-00448327-00448622": "Angelina beautiful song it should be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01589-00448624-00448785": "sown mr. van top demands Tony's been", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01590-00448785-00449013": "over de Novo's dad mr. cab is a Miller", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01591-00449014-00449214": "Hamill 323 Miller Hamilton East unique", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01592-00449214-00449406": "weakness after satlak de leurs tailors", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01593-00449407-00449553": "do not accept Amanda Shannon's fight", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01594-00449554-00449727": "this fight as far as the source to his", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01595-00449728-00449934": "camels canvas your Monza nonsense dad", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01596-00449935-00450045": "feels you're happy in the greatest", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01597-00450046-00450252": "events Pisa gave mr. gate miss French's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01598-00450253-00450413": "French", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01599-00450414-00450647": "almost pulse please twice one time be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01600-00450649-00450846": "recognized by the court mr. McClaren mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01601-00450847-00453941": "McClaren", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01602-00453942-00454560": "the icer 92 the nays are one the iSpring", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01603-00454561-00454770": "92 the Naseby want to declare the motion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01604-00454771-00454993": "carry the bill tons of nitrogen per", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01605-00454993-00455200": "gigawatt resolved at the bill you now", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01606-00455201-00455479": "pass and be entitled as in the motion we", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01607-00455480-00455610": "have a deferred vote on the motion to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01608-00455611-00455802": "third reading of bill 68 an act to amend", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01609-00455803-00455916": "various acts in relation to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01610-00455917-00456081": "municipalities calling the members will", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01611-00456082-00460116": "be a five-minute", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01612-00460117-00460531": "on May 29 2007 Venus mr. moral rule", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01613-00460532-00460741": "third reading of Bill 68 enact to them", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01614-00460742-00460854": "in various acts in relation to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01615-00460855-00460989": "municipalities all those in favor please", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01616-00460990-00461056": "rise", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01617-00461057-00461196": "one or trying to rectify the first", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01618-00461197-00461571": "tomorrow Bradley Bradley no there's no", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01619-00461572-00461748": "beacon sandals Sanders pursues those", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01620-00461749-00461929": "receiving this win is win Matthews", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01621-00461930-00462183": "masking drops mr. Shirley - Shirley to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01622-00462184-00462331": "do good - dude goes with Charles of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01623-00462332-00462537": "Charleston week media sanic weakened mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01624-00462538-00462766": "Takashi guitar mr. call two poles garden", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01625-00462767-00462991": "Edward Nettie Delaney Delaney to Dylan's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01626-00462992-00463197": "condolence turmeric America chance -", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01627-00463198-00463425": "chance - mereta squeegee photos hotel", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01628-00463426-00463635": "hunters hunters allele chili Esther", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01629-00463636-00463833": "Flynn's declare to Gebo 40 bones I'm", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01630-00463834-00463981": "alone I'm alone was to cause the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01631-00463982-00464185": "topographer Dickson's connections manga", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01632-00464185-00464410": "manga mr. crack mr. Perron is Donald", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01633-00464410-00464650": "Donald McGarry mcgarrick simmer mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01634-00464651-00464841": "Zimmer mrs. oven is Albany's McMahon", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01635-00464842-00465141": "McMahon's to balance cobalamin I do 1906", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01636-00465142-00465352": "long wall sprays work appraisal grandeur", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01637-00465353-00465522": "sister and mr. Baker mr. Baker's are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01638-00465523-00465687": "dogs to know this Hogarth old girls", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01639-00465688-00465952": "koalas koalas moly moly the Martin mrs.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01640-00465953-00466141": "Martin mr. military milchester pods to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01641-00466142-00466637": "Paul mr. Renaldi coming all this renewed", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01642-00466638-00466833": "Hatfield's your hat there it should be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01643-00466834-00467062": "sawn Chevy so mr. van pas devant on mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01644-00467063-00467298": "Oh mr. Novoa javis attack mr. Miller", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01645-00467299-00467454": "Hamilton Stony Creek Miller Hamilton", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01646-00467455-00467641": "East Stony Creek this atlas at miss de", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01647-00467642-00467868": "Lacaille analysis man I'm jealous and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01648-00467869-00468027": "and gentlemen fight let's fight as far", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01649-00468028-00468235": "as Forster mr. Campbell miss Campbell", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01650-00468235-00468375": "it's your montage the amount of penguins", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01651-00468376-00468579": "aggressive excuse agates agates this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01652-00468580-00468783": "French is French", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01653-00468784-00469039": "all those opposed please 500 time you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01654-00469039-00469204": "recognized by the clerk well mr. Hart of", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01655-00469205-00469368": "science", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01656-00469368-00469668": "the Wilson Wilson Jones Jones to brown", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01657-00469668-00469887": "to brown the Clark departed le the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01658-00469888-00470052": "fidelity yak about ski Aquabus and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01659-00470053-00470205": "Miller Perry's on Muskoka the military", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01660-00470206-00470406": "sound the scoping has got the scholars", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01661-00470407-00470604": "own sister Baris Cabarrus your history", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01662-00470605-00470856": "era mr. Bailey's tomato strawberry mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01663-00470857-00471024": "Walker to Walker's to Nikolas connect", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01664-00471025-00471225": "this is March Oh am i telling mr. Mixon", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01665-00471226-00471363": "alumns connecting now is that at biester", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01666-00471364-00471555": "canapes are called to Costa chose to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01667-00471556-00474810": "child", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01668-00474812-00475389": "the eyes are 69 the nays are 23", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01669-00475389-00475666": "the ice being 69 the knees being 23 I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01670-00475667-00475801": "declared the motion carried", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01671-00475802-00475912": "third reading the bill cause I'm", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01672-00475913-00476053": "lectures do perceive the law resolved", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01673-00476054-00476167": "with the building our path will be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01674-00476168-00476425": "entitled I haven emotion we have a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01675-00476426-00476560": "deferred vote on the motion of closure", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01676-00476560-00476734": "of the motion for third reading and bill", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01677-00476735-00476917": "65 calling the members of Sevilla five", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01678-00476918-00481087": "minutes", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01679-00481088-00481460": "make 10 2017 mr. deluca moved the third", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01680-00481461-00481641": "reading of bill 65 an act to amend the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01681-00481642-00481877": "highway traffic act and respect to speed", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01682-00481878-00482010": "limits and miss apologies and other", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01683-00482010-00482250": "matters mr. Fraser has moved that the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01684-00482251-00482460": "question be now put all those in favor", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01685-00482460-00482708": "mr. Frazier's motion will rise please", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01686-00482709-00482904": "rise one at a time to be recognized by", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01687-00482905-00483075": "the clerk mr. Mack this can act with", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01688-00483076-00483308": "Bradley Bradley the lubricant sandals", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01689-00483309-00483516": "and sand mr. Souza seasons when this win", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01690-00483517-00483683": "is Mathis Matthews for hospice your", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01691-00483684-00483912": "hospitality mr. Ellis new Keynesians", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01692-00483913-00484043": "with Charles with Charles to make me", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01693-00484044-00484244": "kids took me can mr. Takagi took the car", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01694-00484245-00484481": "mr. Cole Cole partner partner DS Delaney", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01695-00484482-00484668": "to the lenient bill mr. Dillon's for", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01696-00484668-00484820": "Murray - Murray a chance to change", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01697-00484821-00485043": "Murray visa more easy photo hotel is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01698-00485043-00485318": "hunter hunter mr. TiVo wickety bow down", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01699-00485319-00485558": "the law came along mr. Qadri mr. Cogley", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01700-00485559-00485883": "mr. Dixon Dixon Banga Banga cracks to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01701-00485884-00486071": "past with Donna McDonald Oh miss McGarry", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01702-00486072-00486260": "McGarry tomorrow tomorrow deserve", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01703-00486261-00486443": "representatives Alvin a dolphin easy", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01704-00486444-00486654": "miss McManus McManus de balón scheme", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01705-00486655-00486854": "Alan I do Erin I do here as long as", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01706-00486855-00487041": "walls to praise this appraiser brandish", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01707-00487042-00487208": "the transistor Baker's to Baker's our", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01708-00487209-00487379": "dog turd on this hoga I told got a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01709-00487380-00487610": "squall it's Cologne its moly moly smart", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01710-00487611-00487818": "mr. Martin mr. milchester no Chester pot", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01711-00487818-00487989": "mr. kosterman Oh between all these", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01712-00487989-00488048": "reveals", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01713-00488049-00488250": "Bernie Ellen and Rosie and Gary mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01714-00488251-00488708": "Flint mr. Flynn mr. Wilk Illya all those", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01715-00488709-00488852": "opposed please wise one of the time you", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01716-00488853-00489006": "recognized by the clerk mr. wills the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01717-00489007-00489206": "school foods Ron is gonna start at the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01718-00489207-00489410": "heart of the cloud I'm Tom Jones Jones", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01719-00489411-00489591": "to brown the brown mr. Clark's declare", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01720-00489592-00489735": "mr. Fedeli academic yak about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01721-00489735-00489929": "jackubowski military service or the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01722-00489930-00490110": "military smell Muskoka Scott the scone", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01723-00490110-00490283": "stops this time sister Barry's compared", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01724-00490284-00490479": "to Europe mr. years to Bailey today in", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01725-00490480-00490691": "the gross trust or mr. walktrough office", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01726-00490692-00490893": "Nichols connect this is March Oh killer", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01727-00490893-00491045": "mr. Mixon I'll connect an ounce to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01728-00491046-00491210": "better patient entities to caustic Oh", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01729-00491211-00491414": "mr. Jose - Joe we should be soft rugby", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01730-00491415-00491643": "song mr. Vance are handsome - no DiNozzo", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01731-00491643-00491964": "two tabs two cabins with that satin", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01732-00491964-00492156": "desert miss dan was denied established", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01733-00492157-00492354": "Angelica name's Ellen despite in spite", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01734-00492355-00492516": "was horses horse to his Campbell", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01735-00492517-00492737": "Campbell was your Montezuma desire had", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01736-00492738-00492920": "to arrest these Gretzky's engage again", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01737-00492921-00496439": "this frightens French mr. McClaren", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01738-00496439-00497187": "the eyes are 52 the nays are 40 the eyes", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01739-00497188-00497382": "maybe to the nation a cornea declared a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01740-00497383-00497582": "motion carried", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01741-00497583-00497868": "mr. del Duca has moved third reading and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01742-00497868-00498012": "bill 65 an act to amend the highway", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01743-00498013-00498201": "traffic back and respect to speed limits", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01744-00498202-00498429": "and municipalities and other matters is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01745-00498430-00498612": "the pleasure house the motion carried", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01746-00498613-00498858": "I heard no all those in favor of the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01747-00498859-00498978": "motion please say aye", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01748-00498979-00499206": "all those opposed to the motion please", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01749-00499207-00499514": "say nay in my opinion the eyes have it", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01750-00499514-00499718": "calling the members this will be a", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01751-00499720-00503963": "five-minute", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01752-00503964-00504218": "mr. del Duca is will third meeting until", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01753-00504220-00504447": "65 enacting the highway traffic I can", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01754-00504447-00504549": "respect the speed limits and", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01755-00504550-00504696": "municipalities and other matters all", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01756-00504697-00504831": "those in favor of the motion please rise", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01757-00504832-00504954": "one of the time you recognized by the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01758-00504955-00504993": "clerk", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01759-00504993-00505227": "how do you connect with an acrobatic", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01760-00505228-00505491": "arriving Sandra Sandra de Souza fingers", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01761-00505492-00505718": "win this win is not nasty brought your", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01762-00505720-00505887": "hospital Cherelle Cherelle is to do good", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01763-00505888-00506082": "you guys with Charles Charles doing me", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01764-00506083-00506274": "to McMicken with cigars at the car mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01765-00506275-00506499": "Cole Cole garden Eddie Jordan and Elena", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01766-00506500-00506733": "Salinas go to the Candela its emergence", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01767-00506734-00506946": "Americans to Chad mr. chance Marie Marie", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01768-00506947-00507239": "DeCoteau HL hunter centers allele Kalea", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01769-00507241-00507438": "mr. Flynn just to play him to Devo if he", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01770-00507439-00507585": "voted I'm alone I'm alone", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01771-00507585-00507743": "mr. cosmic Department addicted", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01772-00507745-00507987": "connections manga manga Christ depends", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01773-00507988-00508170": "on Allah Donald McGarry mcGarry's", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01774-00508171-00508353": "tomorrow tomorrow Zimmer mr. Simmons", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01775-00508354-00508575": "Ebenezer he'll Denise's wood man McMahon", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01776-00508576-00508764": "Ballard's cobalamin I do here is 90", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01777-00508764-00508959": "Harris Long's Walter bracelets appraiser", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01778-00508960-00509172": "and sister and mr. Baker's to bake mr.", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01779-00509172-00509334": "dog - darling this Hogarth old dog", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01780-00509335-00509532": "Wallace Cologne tamales tamales", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01781-00509533-00509660": "this is murder mr. Martin Buser", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01782-00509662-00509847": "milchester Meek Mill chip mr. Potts at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01783-00509847-00510000": "the pause the terminology communities", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01784-00510001-00510239": "revealed we kneel them zero zeros yet", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01785-00510241-00510522": "mr. Arnott pastrana sorry Hannibal about", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01786-00510522-00510813": "the time the Wilcoxes go Jones the brown", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01787-00510814-00511005": "the brown declares depart with fidelity", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01788-00511006-00511218": "fidelity a kebab piano husky Miller", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01789-00511218-00511364": "berries on the scope military sound", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01790-00511366-00511602": "spoken to Scott Thomson Thompson's are", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01791-00511603-00511677": "very very", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01792-00511678-00511926": "gr STS Sibelius today in the gross drop", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01793-00511927-00512082": "nice to have two walks go walking", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01794-00512083-00512184": "through knuckles connect ball this is", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01795-00512185-00512331": "March oh my television Victor now", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01796-00512332-00512556": "ischemic canal mr. ko mr. never better", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01797-00512557-00512810": "view canapes to go to close the Charles", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01798-00512812-00513047": "to kill mr. gate mr. gate it should be", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01799-00513049-00513228": "song to be sung to dance on commands", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01800-00513229-00513408": "good although you know one job is to", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01801-00513409-00513572": "conduct another Hamilton easterly breeze", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01802-00513574-00513750": "Camilla Hamilton East Bay treatments at", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01803-00513751-00513953": "least not with sailors Taylor", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01804-00513954-00514189": "Angela Angela inspires flight miss", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01805-00514191-00514382": "Forrest are scared miss gamble cambogia", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01806-00514383-00514682": "Montezuma dad feel happy Gretzky was", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01807-00514683-00514988": "frightened his French all those bolts", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01808-00514989-00515147": "please 400 time be recognized by the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01809-00515147-00518412": "court mr. McClaren mr. McClaren", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01810-00518413-00519143": "the eyes are 92 the nays are 1", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01811-00519145-00519363": "the ice being 92 in the knees being one", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01812-00519364-00519539": "I declare the motion carried", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01813-00519541-00519708": "the reason about positive nitrogen per", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01814-00519709-00519893": "gate all visibility now passing the", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01815-00519895-00520177": "entitled is into motion", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01816-00520178-00520479": "I would like to draw your attention I", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01817-00520480-00520743": "would like to talk to draw your", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01818-00520745-00520945": "attention and an event that's happening", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01819-00520946-00521518": "at 6 o'clock after afternoon City that", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01820-00521518-00521959": "we are celebrating 40 years of service", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01821-00521960-00524260": "for mr. Kent", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01822-00524262-00524496": "there will be plenty to say this", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01823-00524497-00524730": "afternoon but the one thing I will relay", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01824-00524731-00525117": "to you is that Harry Nixon from brand", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01825-00525118-00525599": "was is the record holder for 42 years", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01826-00525600-00525737": "Collinson", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01827-00525738-00526008": "there are motive for both the suspense", "d4ThOtK-aJE-01828-00526009-00526365": "recess until 3:00 p.m. this afternoon"}}, {"audio_id": "d4Uo3g7TDA0", "text": {"d4Uo3g7TDA0-00000-00000003-00000227": "before I start this video I want to", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00001-00000228-00000467": "thank you for watching please don't", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00002-00000468-00000688": "forget to share it with your friends and", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00003-00000689-00001049": "with the beams set to tell a noble thing", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00004-00001050-00001291": "you need to have at least four noblemen", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00005-00001292-00001507": "assuming your vessel set there is not a", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00006-00001508-00001739": "level three these noble men can be", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00007-00001739-00001973": "stationed in one of the villages or they", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00008-00001973-00002156": "can be spread out of the Empire to make", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00009-00002157-00002309": "things easier for this video", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00010-00002310-00002606": "all my noblemen are in one village first", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00011-00002607-00002677": "things first", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00012-00002678-00002950": "never ever send attacked with several no", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00013-00002951-00003005": "diamond", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00014-00003006-00003445": "the effect is the same as sending one so", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00015-00003446-00003719": "it makes sense to split them up in order", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00016-00003720-00004013": "to conquer this village over here I send", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00017-00004014-00004367": "an attack with one nobleman right after", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00018-00004368-00004717": "send another one and as an another and", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00019-00004718-00005060": "here goes the last attack in the last", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00020-00005061-00005311": "attack also send my paladin he is", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00021-00005312-00005501": "equipped with vasco scepter as you can", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00022-00005502-00005756": "see so the loyalty lost the last", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00023-00005757-00006031": "nobleman is increased with this running", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00024-00006032-00006242": "noble train i made sure a copy this", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00025-00006243-00006566": "village within a few seconds after some", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00026-00006567-00006737": "time you get more experience in the game", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00027-00006738-00006926": "and you managed to time these attacks", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00028-00006927-00007181": "really well so you can take over enemy", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00029-00007181-00007523": "village within a blink of an app I hope", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00030-00007523-00007781": "this video helped you if you liked it", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00031-00007781-00008030": "please hit that like button you can", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00032-00008031-00008267": "subscribe for more content and check out", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00033-00008268-00008576": "my other videos now get back to the game", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00034-00008577-00008867": "and crush your enemies thank you for", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00035-00008868-00009027": "watching", "d4Uo3g7TDA0-00036-00009028-00009338": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "d5npOMwDwNA", "text": {"d5npOMwDwNA-00000-00000071-00000214": "i already said too many things five", "d5npOMwDwNA-00001-00000215-00000390": "times", "d5npOMwDwNA-00002-00000391-00000655": "um my name is nina troy i'm i'm working", "d5npOMwDwNA-00003-00000656-00000847": "at concept background economy in leipzig", "d5npOMwDwNA-00004-00000848-00001087": "and together with corinna and matthias", "d5npOMwDwNA-00005-00001088-00001335": "i was one of the editors of this book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00006-00001336-00001391": "and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00007-00001392-00001599": "yeah i'm only doing this technical card", "d5npOMwDwNA-00008-00001600-00001775": "later facilitation which means i pass", "d5npOMwDwNA-00009-00001776-00001934": "them on to matias who does the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00010-00001935-00002110": "facilitation of the panel and i hope", "d5npOMwDwNA-00011-00002111-00002223": "you'll enjoy", "d5npOMwDwNA-00012-00002224-00002375": "if you have any technical questions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00013-00002376-00002550": "please put them in the chat", "d5npOMwDwNA-00014-00002551-00002726": "and the id support and i will try to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00015-00002727-00003110": "answer them", "d5npOMwDwNA-00016-00003111-00003431": "okay thank you very much nina um i hope", "d5npOMwDwNA-00017-00003432-00003551": "everything works now", "d5npOMwDwNA-00018-00003552-00003711": "very much welcome to this book launch", "d5npOMwDwNA-00019-00003711-00003886": "event for the book degrowth and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00020-00003887-00003951": "movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00021-00003952-00004279": "exploring pathways for transformation", "d5npOMwDwNA-00022-00004280-00004454": "we are very happy um to have this book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00023-00004455-00004591": "launch event today", "d5npOMwDwNA-00024-00004592-00004863": "because coincidentally today is also the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00025-00004864-00004919": "day", "d5npOMwDwNA-00026-00004920-00005118": "this book was published um and it's the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00027-00005119-00005231": "first day of this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00028-00005232-00005454": "amazing conference and it's kind of like", "d5npOMwDwNA-00029-00005455-00005583": "a perfect fit", "d5npOMwDwNA-00030-00005584-00005870": "also because this book has a lot to do", "d5npOMwDwNA-00031-00005871-00005911": "with", "d5npOMwDwNA-00032-00005912-00006222": "the theme of this degrowth conference", "d5npOMwDwNA-00033-00006223-00006534": "strategies so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00034-00006536-00006791": "we have a full lineup which you can see", "d5npOMwDwNA-00035-00006792-00007039": "hopefully on the slide", "d5npOMwDwNA-00036-00007040-00007342": "here we will start with a very short", "d5npOMwDwNA-00037-00007343-00007623": "um i'll do a very short presentation on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00038-00007623-00007719": "the book project", "d5npOMwDwNA-00039-00007720-00008046": "um what's it about then we'll have some", "d5npOMwDwNA-00040-00008047-00008310": "short inputs by some of the authors", "d5npOMwDwNA-00041-00008311-00008663": "um that are mini discussion", "d5npOMwDwNA-00042-00008664-00008919": "on the panel um about the current", "d5npOMwDwNA-00043-00008920-00009078": "situation and how this relates to this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00044-00009079-00009151": "book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00045-00009152-00009342": "and then we are open for questions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00046-00009343-00009510": "comments and everything", "d5npOMwDwNA-00047-00009511-00009759": "you want to say from the audience please", "d5npOMwDwNA-00048-00009760-00009855": "type them", "d5npOMwDwNA-00049-00009856-00010183": "in the chat so we will have uh short", "d5npOMwDwNA-00050-00010184-00010310": "inputs first from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00051-00010311-00010542": "taj miller he's a climate activist", "d5npOMwDwNA-00052-00010543-00010631": "currently working", "d5npOMwDwNA-00053-00010632-00010919": "at um the rosa luxembourg foundation um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00054-00010920-00010959": "and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00055-00010960-00011246": "he's for a long time been active around", "d5npOMwDwNA-00056-00011247-00011406": "climate justice involved tell us", "d5npOMwDwNA-00057-00011407-00011591": "something about this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00058-00011592-00011814": "then we have an input by juliana", "d5npOMwDwNA-00059-00011815-00011959": "felinger", "d5npOMwDwNA-00060-00011960-00012327": "she's going to discuss food sovereignty", "d5npOMwDwNA-00061-00012328-00012678": "um and she's um an activist", "d5npOMwDwNA-00062-00012679-00012886": "formerly with attack and now with via", "d5npOMwDwNA-00063-00012887-00013038": "campesina austria", "d5npOMwDwNA-00064-00013039-00013311": "so she and she's also a farmer so very", "d5npOMwDwNA-00065-00013312-00013366": "much", "d5npOMwDwNA-00066-00013368-00013607": "talking from the lift experience of food", "d5npOMwDwNA-00067-00013608-00013719": "sovereignty", "d5npOMwDwNA-00068-00013719-00014103": "then um the co-editor corinna burkhardt", "d5npOMwDwNA-00069-00014104-00014383": "will tell something about degrowth and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00070-00014384-00014575": "the key lessons we learned from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00071-00014576-00014711": "bringing all these different movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00072-00014712-00014951": "together and then and we're very lucky", "d5npOMwDwNA-00073-00014952-00015055": "that ototi roy", "d5npOMwDwNA-00074-00015056-00015319": "was just on the opening panel and could", "d5npOMwDwNA-00075-00015319-00015407": "join us here", "d5npOMwDwNA-00076-00015408-00015558": "because she's currently working on a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00077-00015559-00015775": "review of the book and will provide kind", "d5npOMwDwNA-00078-00015776-00015975": "of an outside perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-00079-00015976-00016279": "um already from having", "d5npOMwDwNA-00080-00016280-00016535": "read through the book and we're very", "d5npOMwDwNA-00081-00016536-00016750": "happy about this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00082-00016751-00017119": "so without further ado i will", "d5npOMwDwNA-00083-00017120-00017527": "try to change the slide but", "d5npOMwDwNA-00084-00017528-00017839": "this doesn't seem to be working oh it", "d5npOMwDwNA-00085-00017840-00018047": "does okay", "d5npOMwDwNA-00086-00018048-00018550": "so in recent years d growth has emerged", "d5npOMwDwNA-00087-00018551-00018758": "both as a widely debated political", "d5npOMwDwNA-00088-00018759-00018935": "project and a new", "d5npOMwDwNA-00089-00018936-00019111": "academic research paradigm and we've", "d5npOMwDwNA-00090-00019112-00019230": "heard a lot about this in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00091-00019231-00019335": "introduction", "d5npOMwDwNA-00092-00019336-00019527": "um in the introductory panel this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00093-00019528-00019671": "morning", "d5npOMwDwNA-00094-00019672-00019903": "and why there are a lot of publications", "d5npOMwDwNA-00095-00019904-00020111": "on the idea of d growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00096-00020112-00020486": "we know insufficient we know not a lot", "d5npOMwDwNA-00097-00020487-00020750": "about how these idea ideas of degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00098-00020751-00020919": "are actually applied in various social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00099-00020920-00020991": "movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00100-00020992-00021294": "and practical alternative projects this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00101-00021295-00021471": "is rather strange", "d5npOMwDwNA-00102-00021472-00021694": "because the growth scholars all the time", "d5npOMwDwNA-00103-00021695-00021871": "stress how intimately growth as a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00104-00021872-00021943": "concept", "d5npOMwDwNA-00105-00021944-00022167": "and also a research paradigm is linked", "d5npOMwDwNA-00106-00022168-00022319": "to alternative practices", "d5npOMwDwNA-00107-00022320-00022575": "and social movements so this book d", "d5npOMwDwNA-00108-00022576-00022703": "growth in movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00109-00022704-00022894": "is the first account of the practices", "d5npOMwDwNA-00110-00022895-00023047": "that underlie this degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00111-00023048-00023358": "discourse it's based on a two-year", "d5npOMwDwNA-00112-00023359-00023558": "interactive networking networking", "d5npOMwDwNA-00113-00023559-00023791": "process between social movements mainly", "d5npOMwDwNA-00114-00023792-00023878": "from germany", "d5npOMwDwNA-00115-00023879-00024055": "but also with strong international", "d5npOMwDwNA-00116-00024056-00024286": "international transnational links", "d5npOMwDwNA-00117-00024287-00024478": "so there's also chapters by ashish", "d5npOMwDwNA-00118-00024479-00024678": "kothari and alberto acosta", "d5npOMwDwNA-00119-00024679-00025022": "in the book the idea for this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00120-00025023-00025207": "book project emerged after the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00121-00025208-00025367": "international degrowth conference in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00122-00025368-00025639": "leipzig in 2014", "d5npOMwDwNA-00123-00025639-00025846": "where nina and corinna and i were also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00124-00025847-00026046": "involved in the organizing of it", "d5npOMwDwNA-00125-00026047-00026246": "and at this conference 3 000", "d5npOMwDwNA-00126-00026247-00026358": "participants so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00127-00026360-00026558": "maybe not as many as for this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00128-00026560-00026735": "international conference the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00129-00026736-00026958": "the online vienna conference but um a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00130-00026960-00027046": "lot of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00131-00027047-00027223": "participants joined and this was kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00132-00027224-00027390": "like a five-day activist", "d5npOMwDwNA-00133-00027391-00027751": "academic meeting um with participants", "d5npOMwDwNA-00134-00027752-00027958": "from a very wide diverse range of social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00135-00027960-00028239": "movements and projects and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00136-00028239-00028495": "from our experience we felt that there", "d5npOMwDwNA-00137-00028495-00028623": "were", "d5npOMwDwNA-00138-00028624-00028767": "um while it was really great there were", "d5npOMwDwNA-00139-00028768-00028974": "also a lot of deep misunderstandings and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00140-00028975-00029158": "misconceptions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00141-00029160-00029439": "regarding each other's approaches", "d5npOMwDwNA-00142-00029439-00029743": "proposals and strategies", "d5npOMwDwNA-00143-00029744-00029999": "and this kind of like brought about this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00144-00030000-00030095": "idea of the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00145-00030095-00030287": "so often activists and academics from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00146-00030288-00030446": "one movement or the other", "d5npOMwDwNA-00147-00030447-00030679": "did not really know what the other were", "d5npOMwDwNA-00148-00030680-00030814": "actually proposing were", "d5npOMwDwNA-00149-00030816-00031127": "doing frequent questions were what is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00150-00031127-00031287": "the proposal of degrowth what does", "d5npOMwDwNA-00151-00031288-00031431": "comments actually mean", "d5npOMwDwNA-00152-00031432-00031590": "what are the what's political about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00153-00031591-00031943": "degrowth um or urban gardening etc etc", "d5npOMwDwNA-00154-00031944-00032343": "so there was a lot of skepticism and um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00155-00032344-00032502": "not really knowing the different", "d5npOMwDwNA-00156-00032503-00032687": "political focuses of each of these", "d5npOMwDwNA-00157-00032688-00032799": "groups", "d5npOMwDwNA-00158-00032800-00033007": "so to deal with these misunderstandings", "d5npOMwDwNA-00159-00033008-00033135": "and strengthen", "d5npOMwDwNA-00160-00033136-00033327": "the possibilities for alliances and for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00161-00033328-00033527": "moving forward together", "d5npOMwDwNA-00162-00033528-00033727": "we started this this process of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00163-00033728-00033879": "collaboration", "d5npOMwDwNA-00164-00033880-00034079": "and um how it worked was basically", "d5npOMwDwNA-00165-00034080-00034183": "bringing together", "d5npOMwDwNA-00166-00034184-00034462": "around 30 activists involved in various", "d5npOMwDwNA-00167-00034463-00034583": "social movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00168-00034584-00034871": "um organizing meetings to discuss the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00169-00034872-00034974": "various chapters", "d5npOMwDwNA-00170-00034975-00035295": "um bringing out a german book and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00171-00035296-00035615": "a website that you can see on this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00172-00035616-00035807": "slide which has already been out for a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00173-00035808-00035918": "couple of years", "d5npOMwDwNA-00174-00035919-00036102": "and now this is altered in an english", "d5npOMwDwNA-00175-00036103-00036318": "book some of the chapters have been", "d5npOMwDwNA-00176-00036319-00036518": "rewritten there's also a couple of new", "d5npOMwDwNA-00177-00036519-00036927": "chapters that we've added", "d5npOMwDwNA-00178-00036928-00037311": "so d growth we argue is not just a new", "d5npOMwDwNA-00179-00037312-00037367": "term", "d5npOMwDwNA-00180-00037368-00037518": "for this ongoing discussion about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00181-00037519-00037759": "alternative or a research paradigm but d", "d5npOMwDwNA-00182-00037760-00037895": "growth is also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00183-00037896-00038167": "itself an emerging social movement that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00184-00038168-00038246": "overlaps", "d5npOMwDwNA-00185-00038247-00038407": "to a large degree with other social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00186-00038408-00038574": "movements from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00187-00038575-00038846": "anti-globalization or climate justice to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00188-00038847-00038990": "movements and alternatives such as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00189-00038991-00039143": "commons wendy veer", "d5npOMwDwNA-00190-00039144-00039430": "non-profit cooperatives care revolution", "d5npOMwDwNA-00191-00039431-00039462": "free", "d5npOMwDwNA-00192-00039463-00039767": "software diy repair cafes basic income", "d5npOMwDwNA-00193-00039768-00039974": "transition towns or even basic trade", "d5npOMwDwNA-00194-00039975-00040151": "unions which are also discussed", "d5npOMwDwNA-00195-00040152-00040462": "in the various chapters on of the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00196-00040463-00040646": "which you can hopefully see on the slide", "d5npOMwDwNA-00197-00040647-00040807": "here it's very small i know but", "d5npOMwDwNA-00198-00040808-00041183": "you can also check it out online", "d5npOMwDwNA-00199-00041184-00041527": "so in the book um we discussed", "d5npOMwDwNA-00200-00041528-00041751": "each of the authors basically yeah one", "d5npOMwDwNA-00201-00041752-00041895": "technical materials", "d5npOMwDwNA-00202-00041896-00042143": "everyone can make this really big if you", "d5npOMwDwNA-00203-00042144-00042311": "click on the full screen version", "d5npOMwDwNA-00204-00042312-00042495": "because i think people didn't see that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00205-00042496-00042671": "so you can either make materials or any", "d5npOMwDwNA-00206-00042672-00042767": "other panelists", "d5npOMwDwNA-00207-00042768-00042974": "full screen or even also the slides", "d5npOMwDwNA-00208-00042975-00043127": "sorry just but that you can get more", "d5npOMwDwNA-00209-00043128-00043351": "individual what you want to see", "d5npOMwDwNA-00210-00043352-00043758": "great thanks so each of the authors", "d5npOMwDwNA-00211-00043759-00044102": "in this book basically discussed five", "d5npOMwDwNA-00212-00044103-00044343": "different questions and these questions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00213-00044344-00044495": "were all the same for each chapter so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00214-00044496-00044639": "it's very easy kind of like to navigate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00215-00044640-00044751": "throughout the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00216-00044752-00044871": "um the questions are very", "d5npOMwDwNA-00217-00044872-00045023": "straightforward i also put them on the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00218-00045024-00045102": "slide", "d5npOMwDwNA-00219-00045103-00045262": "so what's the idea of your social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00220-00045263-00045446": "movement what's the main framework you", "d5npOMwDwNA-00221-00045447-00045695": "discuss it in what's the proposal", "d5npOMwDwNA-00222-00045696-00045902": "then secondly who's part in the social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00223-00045903-00046079": "movement and what do you actually do", "d5npOMwDwNA-00224-00046080-00046215": "what's your practice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00225-00046216-00046511": "thirdly how do you see the relationship", "d5npOMwDwNA-00226-00046512-00046679": "between your social movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-00227-00046680-00046886": "and degrowth and also the other social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00228-00046887-00046999": "movements discussed", "d5npOMwDwNA-00229-00047000-00047295": "in the book then most importantly", "d5npOMwDwNA-00230-00047296-00047374": "fourthly", "d5npOMwDwNA-00231-00047375-00047646": "which proposals does your movement the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00232-00047647-00047815": "perspectives from your movement have for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00233-00047816-00047974": "the degrowth perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-00234-00047975-00048183": "and also the other way around which", "d5npOMwDwNA-00235-00048184-00048358": "proposals from the degrowth perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-00236-00048359-00048471": "can you take on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00237-00048472-00048623": "into your social movements kind of like", "d5npOMwDwNA-00238-00048624-00048830": "what are the learning experiences what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00239-00048831-00048935": "are the pitfalls", "d5npOMwDwNA-00240-00048936-00049118": "that you can highlight from this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00241-00049119-00049286": "perspective and finally there was kind", "d5npOMwDwNA-00242-00049287-00049390": "of like space for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00243-00049391-00049671": "visions suggestions or people were often", "d5npOMwDwNA-00244-00049672-00049735": "discussing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00245-00049736-00050046": "the possibilities of common alliances", "d5npOMwDwNA-00246-00050047-00050374": "throughout this whole spectrum", "d5npOMwDwNA-00247-00050375-00050551": "finally i want to say shortly about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00248-00050552-00050830": "something about the publisher because we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00249-00050831-00051055": "do publish this book with the publisher", "d5npOMwDwNA-00250-00051056-00051135": "zero books", "d5npOMwDwNA-00251-00051136-00051382": "um it's a progressive publisher in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00252-00051383-00051519": "england", "d5npOMwDwNA-00253-00051520-00051766": "and they're very happy about this and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00254-00051767-00051935": "for a very particular reason", "d5npOMwDwNA-00255-00051936-00052158": "because this publisher has so far", "d5npOMwDwNA-00256-00052159-00052270": "largely kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00257-00052271-00052582": "published books for the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00258-00052583-00052879": "of the productivist left so those on the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00259-00052879-00053054": "left who embrace modernity", "d5npOMwDwNA-00260-00053055-00053238": "globalization and technology and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00261-00053239-00053407": "progress since so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00262-00053408-00053599": "so they argue in this like techno", "d5npOMwDwNA-00263-00053600-00053750": "optimist perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-00264-00053751-00053919": "only these create the conditions for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00265-00053920-00054087": "liberation", "d5npOMwDwNA-00266-00054088-00054287": "and lee phillips whose book you see on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00267-00054288-00054479": "the right on the slide", "d5npOMwDwNA-00268-00054479-00054791": "also published by xerobox for example", "d5npOMwDwNA-00269-00054791-00054935": "condemned degrowth as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00270-00054936-00055207": "austerity ecology and criticized the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00271-00055208-00055287": "movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00272-00055288-00055526": "promoting the growth as collapse porn", "d5npOMwDwNA-00273-00055527-00055711": "addicts", "d5npOMwDwNA-00274-00055712-00055871": "and i think that's it's a really", "d5npOMwDwNA-00275-00055872-00056094": "important debate and in contrast to this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00276-00056095-00056271": "the proponents of d growth obviously", "d5npOMwDwNA-00277-00056272-00056471": "claim that this eco-modernist", "d5npOMwDwNA-00278-00056472-00056719": "position the green ordeal or also fully", "d5npOMwDwNA-00279-00056720-00056919": "automated luxury communism", "d5npOMwDwNA-00280-00056920-00057175": "cannot provide an answer kind of like to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00281-00057176-00057335": "the most important challenges of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00282-00057336-00057479": "21st century", "d5npOMwDwNA-00283-00057479-00057863": "meaning how can we actually live well", "d5npOMwDwNA-00284-00057864-00058054": "without externalizing the cost of our", "d5npOMwDwNA-00285-00058055-00058247": "way of living onto others the planet or", "d5npOMwDwNA-00286-00058248-00058366": "future generation", "d5npOMwDwNA-00287-00058367-00058607": "generations our answers to these", "d5npOMwDwNA-00288-00058608-00058735": "questions we argue", "d5npOMwDwNA-00289-00058736-00058942": "can only be found if industrialized", "d5npOMwDwNA-00290-00058944-00059119": "countries find ways to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00291-00059120-00059438": "transcend expansionary modernity rather", "d5npOMwDwNA-00292-00059439-00059607": "than focusing on techno fixes", "d5npOMwDwNA-00293-00059608-00059791": "the expansion of productive forces or", "d5npOMwDwNA-00294-00059791-00059935": "economic growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00295-00059936-00060182": "we need to find pathways towards", "d5npOMwDwNA-00296-00060183-00060438": "post-growth societies and so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00297-00060439-00060694": "those movements in line with this letter", "d5npOMwDwNA-00298-00060695-00060838": "vision", "d5npOMwDwNA-00299-00060839-00061079": "this degrowth post-war post-growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00300-00061079-00061142": "vision are", "d5npOMwDwNA-00301-00061144-00061366": "assembled in this book and we very much", "d5npOMwDwNA-00302-00061367-00061575": "hope this that this publication in this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00303-00061576-00061663": "context of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00304-00061664-00061999": "xerobox can foster a dialogue within the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00305-00062000-00062087": "broader left", "d5npOMwDwNA-00306-00062088-00062391": "and hope this builds this helps in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00307-00062391-00062487": "building alliances", "d5npOMwDwNA-00308-00062488-00062719": "of kind of like an eco-social mosaic of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00309-00062720-00062975": "progressive forces", "d5npOMwDwNA-00310-00062976-00063287": "so this is it for a short introduction", "d5npOMwDwNA-00311-00063288-00063375": "on the background", "d5npOMwDwNA-00312-00063376-00063615": "of the book and we now go into some of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00313-00063616-00063750": "the kind of like", "d5npOMwDwNA-00314-00063751-00063975": "deeper arguments first starting with", "d5npOMwDwNA-00315-00063976-00064087": "tachometer", "d5npOMwDwNA-00316-00064088-00064247": "so what are the relationships between", "d5npOMwDwNA-00317-00064248-00064463": "climate justice and degrowth and what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00318-00064464-00064566": "was your experience", "d5npOMwDwNA-00319-00064567-00064926": "with this book um so first of all", "d5npOMwDwNA-00320-00064927-00065071": "thank you very much for editing this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00321-00065072-00065263": "book in german and in english i know it", "d5npOMwDwNA-00322-00065264-00065447": "was a lot of work and i think you guys", "d5npOMwDwNA-00323-00065448-00065559": "did a great job", "d5npOMwDwNA-00324-00065560-00065679": "in actually putting out a really", "d5npOMwDwNA-00325-00065680-00065959": "movementist account of degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00326-00065960-00066159": "which had so far and until the work you", "d5npOMwDwNA-00327-00066160-00066263": "guys did around", "d5npOMwDwNA-00328-00066264-00066447": "the conference in leipzig been more", "d5npOMwDwNA-00329-00066448-00066679": "confined to an academic discourse and as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00330-00066680-00066806": "a recovering academic", "d5npOMwDwNA-00331-00066807-00067063": "i'm always really pleased when sort of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00332-00067064-00067111": "things", "d5npOMwDwNA-00333-00067112-00067311": "move out from the world of academia and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00334-00067312-00067567": "into the world of actual", "d5npOMwDwNA-00335-00067568-00067950": "uh our movement and practice um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00336-00067951-00068126": "another and i've told this to my fellow", "d5npOMwDwNA-00337-00068127-00068326": "presenters another a a quick", "d5npOMwDwNA-00338-00068327-00068559": "caveat my husband's going to walk be", "d5npOMwDwNA-00339-00068560-00068679": "walking back and forth i'm going to make", "d5npOMwDwNA-00340-00068680-00068806": "some noise because we're planning our", "d5npOMwDwNA-00341-00068807-00068982": "second wedding day today so i'm not", "d5npOMwDwNA-00342-00068983-00069087": "entirely", "d5npOMwDwNA-00343-00069088-00069399": "uh totally 100 focused on this but i'll", "d5npOMwDwNA-00344-00069400-00069582": "do my best", "d5npOMwDwNA-00345-00069583-00069894": "in my chapter in the book i do", "d5npOMwDwNA-00346-00069895-00070191": "i think two things the first is i tried", "d5npOMwDwNA-00347-00070192-00070382": "to tell the story about climate justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00348-00070383-00070526": "because", "d5npOMwDwNA-00349-00070527-00070711": "a lot of folks in the global north have", "d5npOMwDwNA-00350-00070712-00070950": "this appallingly annoying misconception", "d5npOMwDwNA-00351-00070951-00071175": "that issues of climate change climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00352-00071176-00071271": "climatizes", "d5npOMwDwNA-00353-00071272-00071519": "are some sort of luxury middle class", "d5npOMwDwNA-00354-00071520-00071855": "latte drinking polar bear cuddling", "d5npOMwDwNA-00355-00071856-00072079": "luxury issues essentially and the first", "d5npOMwDwNA-00356-00072080-00072231": "thing i do is tell the story of climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00357-00072232-00072431": "justice as emerging from a tradition of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00358-00072432-00072567": "environmental justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00359-00072568-00072750": "which comes out of the united states", "d5npOMwDwNA-00360-00072751-00072926": "from from movement of people of color in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00361-00072927-00073031": "the united states", "d5npOMwDwNA-00362-00073032-00073199": "african-american native american", "d5npOMwDwNA-00363-00073200-00073359": "asian-american latino and latino", "d5npOMwDwNA-00364-00073360-00073455": "movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00365-00073456-00073743": "very short the story is this in the 60s", "d5npOMwDwNA-00366-00073744-00073926": "environmentalism emerged in the united", "d5npOMwDwNA-00367-00073927-00074135": "states as a movement led by wealthy", "d5npOMwDwNA-00368-00074136-00074319": "white people who didn't want dirty", "d5npOMwDwNA-00369-00074320-00074447": "industries in their neighborhood", "d5npOMwDwNA-00370-00074448-00074615": "it's a perfectly reasonable desire", "d5npOMwDwNA-00371-00074616-00074743": "because you know your kids die and that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00372-00074744-00074823": "sort of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00373-00074824-00074999": "now these white people were privileged", "d5npOMwDwNA-00374-00075000-00075111": "they were well organized and they", "d5npOMwDwNA-00375-00075112-00075247": "managed to get", "d5npOMwDwNA-00376-00075248-00075382": "the dirty industries out of their", "d5npOMwDwNA-00377-00075383-00075687": "communities but they weren't closed down", "d5npOMwDwNA-00378-00075688-00075975": "what happened was that these industries", "d5npOMwDwNA-00379-00075976-00076062": "were just", "d5npOMwDwNA-00380-00076063-00076206": "put somewhere else they were they were", "d5npOMwDwNA-00381-00076207-00076447": "moved into poorer and more marginalized", "d5npOMwDwNA-00382-00076448-00076647": "communities of color", "d5npOMwDwNA-00383-00076648-00076903": "and then in the 70s and 80s movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00384-00076904-00077023": "emerged there", "d5npOMwDwNA-00385-00077024-00077279": "and accused traditional environmentalism", "d5npOMwDwNA-00386-00077280-00077343": "of not", "d5npOMwDwNA-00387-00077344-00077623": "actually solving environmental problems", "d5npOMwDwNA-00388-00077624-00077838": "but just placing like just displacing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00389-00077839-00078023": "them further down the social ladder", "d5npOMwDwNA-00390-00078024-00078199": "and they said guys what you're doing is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00391-00078200-00078343": "you're not saving the environment you're", "d5npOMwDwNA-00392-00078344-00078494": "not doing environmentalism you're doing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00393-00078495-00078655": "environmental racism", "d5npOMwDwNA-00394-00078656-00078855": "what we need is environmental justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00395-00078856-00079006": "because those who understand", "d5npOMwDwNA-00396-00079007-00079231": "supposedly environmental problems only", "d5npOMwDwNA-00397-00079232-00079423": "as environmental problems without taking", "d5npOMwDwNA-00398-00079424-00079519": "into account", "d5npOMwDwNA-00399-00079520-00079671": "issues of social justice or social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00400-00079672-00079871": "structure of power and inequality", "d5npOMwDwNA-00401-00079872-00080111": "are condemned not to solve the problems", "d5npOMwDwNA-00402-00080112-00080191": "but to just", "d5npOMwDwNA-00403-00080192-00080455": "displace them onto others that's the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00404-00080456-00080550": "basic logic of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00405-00080551-00080791": "environmental justice and that call was", "d5npOMwDwNA-00406-00080792-00080967": "taken up in the mid 90s", "d5npOMwDwNA-00407-00080968-00081175": "by tom goldtooth an american indigenous", "d5npOMwDwNA-00408-00081176-00081287": "leader", "d5npOMwDwNA-00409-00081288-00081526": "who said in the kyoto negotiations when", "d5npOMwDwNA-00410-00081527-00081638": "the global north", "d5npOMwDwNA-00411-00081639-00081982": "pitched this appallingly stupid idea of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00412-00081983-00082094": "carbon offsets", "d5npOMwDwNA-00413-00082095-00082262": "you know we continue our dirty", "d5npOMwDwNA-00414-00082263-00082406": "lifestyles and pay somebody else to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00415-00082407-00082559": "clean up our", "d5npOMwDwNA-00416-00082560-00082791": "um and tom gold has stood up and said", "d5npOMwDwNA-00417-00082792-00082967": "what you're doing is climate racism", "d5npOMwDwNA-00418-00082968-00083135": "we need climate justice so that's the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00419-00083136-00083318": "first thing i do to tell a story about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00420-00083319-00083494": "climate activism that is not widely", "d5npOMwDwNA-00421-00083495-00083550": "known", "d5npOMwDwNA-00422-00083551-00083726": "in the global north that climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00423-00083727-00083982": "activism is justice activism", "d5npOMwDwNA-00424-00083983-00084150": "it's not something different from social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00425-00084151-00084367": "justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00426-00084368-00084518": "the first thing i do and i think that's", "d5npOMwDwNA-00427-00084519-00084687": "reasonably important story the second", "d5npOMwDwNA-00428-00084688-00084750": "thing i do", "d5npOMwDwNA-00429-00084751-00084959": "is then connect that to the questions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00430-00084960-00085071": "around degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00431-00085072-00085223": "in the climate debate and you'll know", "d5npOMwDwNA-00432-00085224-00085375": "this people usually say", "d5npOMwDwNA-00433-00085376-00085679": "yes okay maybe so far historically", "d5npOMwDwNA-00434-00085680-00085894": "it's really been capitalist growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00435-00085895-00086023": "that's the environment that's", "d5npOMwDwNA-00436-00086024-00086150": "the climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00437-00086151-00086375": "but what we can do in the future is we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00438-00086376-00086535": "can have some sort of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00439-00086536-00086743": "green growth and some sort of growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00440-00086744-00086903": "that decouples", "d5npOMwDwNA-00441-00086904-00087167": "a capitalist growth from and from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00442-00087168-00087303": "environmental destruction from climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00443-00087304-00087431": "destruction", "d5npOMwDwNA-00444-00087432-00087679": "the point however that is absolutely", "d5npOMwDwNA-00445-00087680-00087831": "clear in the historical", "d5npOMwDwNA-00446-00087832-00088087": "data and historical record is the one", "d5npOMwDwNA-00447-00088088-00088135": "thing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00448-00088136-00088343": "that reduces global greenhouse gas", "d5npOMwDwNA-00449-00088344-00088487": "emissions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00450-00088488-00088782": "is reductions in global economic growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00451-00088783-00088823": "or", "d5npOMwDwNA-00452-00088824-00089031": "economic activity you can see that in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00453-00089032-00089199": "the early 90s in the breakdown of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00454-00089200-00089423": "eastern european growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00455-00089424-00089647": "growth regimes you can see that in 2008", "d5npOMwDwNA-00456-00089648-00089806": "2009 at the height of the global", "d5npOMwDwNA-00457-00089807-00089959": "financial economic crisis", "d5npOMwDwNA-00458-00089960-00090159": "there was a flattening in the curve of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00459-00090160-00090303": "global emissions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00460-00090304-00090543": "and you can see it now in the context of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00461-00090544-00090703": "the corona lockdowns", "d5npOMwDwNA-00462-00090704-00090959": "where we have actually had governments", "d5npOMwDwNA-00463-00090960-00091103": "saying all right we're going to shut", "d5npOMwDwNA-00464-00091104-00091199": "this hellish machine", "d5npOMwDwNA-00465-00091200-00091423": "down for a while to slow down the spread", "d5npOMwDwNA-00466-00091424-00091543": "of corona", "d5npOMwDwNA-00467-00091544-00091887": "and the effect on you know air quality", "d5npOMwDwNA-00468-00091888-00092055": "on the environment has been stunning", "d5npOMwDwNA-00469-00092056-00092271": "already now i'm not saying corona is a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00470-00092272-00092415": "good thing i'm not saying the lockdown", "d5npOMwDwNA-00471-00092416-00092503": "is a good thing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00472-00092504-00092735": "but what we see in the current situation", "d5npOMwDwNA-00473-00092736-00092974": "is that reducing economic activity", "d5npOMwDwNA-00474-00092975-00093191": "reduces greenhouse gas emissions and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00475-00093192-00093303": "nothing else", "d5npOMwDwNA-00476-00093304-00093543": "has done that so far and that also in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00477-00093544-00093679": "the chapter i wrote in the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00478-00093680-00093847": "is the fundamental point where the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00479-00093848-00094015": "movement for climate justice and the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00480-00094016-00094126": "degrowth movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-00481-00094127-00094455": "meet essentially we have the same", "d5npOMwDwNA-00482-00094456-00094662": "enemy if you want to stop the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00483-00094663-00094831": "destruction of the climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00484-00094832-00095031": "you need to reduce economic activity in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00485-00095032-00095143": "dirty sectors", "d5npOMwDwNA-00486-00095144-00095350": "and that means reducing overall economic", "d5npOMwDwNA-00487-00095351-00095494": "throughput in the global capitalist", "d5npOMwDwNA-00488-00095495-00095567": "system", "d5npOMwDwNA-00489-00095568-00095782": "sure you got to expand care sectors but", "d5npOMwDwNA-00490-00095783-00095943": "you got to shut down car production you", "d5npOMwDwNA-00491-00095944-00096111": "got to shut down coal mining you got to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00492-00096112-00096367": "shut down oil you got to shut down gas", "d5npOMwDwNA-00493-00096368-00096526": "and we know from the corona lockdown", "d5npOMwDwNA-00494-00096527-00096687": "that we can actually as a society", "d5npOMwDwNA-00495-00096688-00096967": "manage that now what would that mean", "d5npOMwDwNA-00496-00096968-00097143": "currently in strategic terms", "d5npOMwDwNA-00497-00097144-00097287": "there's a big debate in the climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-00498-00097288-00097494": "movement and matthias and i who's here", "d5npOMwDwNA-00499-00097495-00097623": "we've already had this debate some", "d5npOMwDwNA-00500-00097624-00097703": "people say look", "d5npOMwDwNA-00501-00097704-00097943": "you can't positively refer to the corona", "d5npOMwDwNA-00502-00097944-00098038": "lockdown measures", "d5npOMwDwNA-00503-00098039-00098287": "they have really hurt people i mean", "d5npOMwDwNA-00504-00098288-00098399": "aside from the folks who are actually", "d5npOMwDwNA-00505-00098400-00098543": "suffering medically", "d5npOMwDwNA-00506-00098544-00098759": "from corona who are dying who have that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00507-00098760-00098862": "loved ones die", "d5npOMwDwNA-00508-00098863-00099062": "you had folks not have access to medical", "d5npOMwDwNA-00509-00099063-00099215": "care um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00510-00099216-00099455": "i i'm i'm i'm as gay as a goose but i", "d5npOMwDwNA-00511-00099456-00099599": "have a lot of friends who have young", "d5npOMwDwNA-00512-00099600-00099767": "children and i understand that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00513-00099768-00099903": "people with young children have really", "d5npOMwDwNA-00514-00099904-00100079": "been suffering in this lockdown so i'm", "d5npOMwDwNA-00515-00100080-00100311": "not saying i'm happy about the knockdown", "d5npOMwDwNA-00516-00100312-00100518": "but we need to be honest in the lockdown", "d5npOMwDwNA-00517-00100519-00100638": "we have seen", "d5npOMwDwNA-00518-00100639-00100806": "that there is something that can reduce", "d5npOMwDwNA-00519-00100807-00101094": "emissions when we as societies decide", "d5npOMwDwNA-00520-00101095-00101279": "that certain things are no longer going", "d5npOMwDwNA-00521-00101280-00101399": "to happen", "d5npOMwDwNA-00522-00101400-00101703": "like the production of cars like mining", "d5npOMwDwNA-00523-00101704-00101823": "coal", "d5npOMwDwNA-00524-00101824-00102055": "like flying around the bloody world all", "d5npOMwDwNA-00525-00102056-00102159": "the time", "d5npOMwDwNA-00526-00102160-00102399": "key enemies the airline industry the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00527-00102400-00102566": "coal industry the oil and gas industry", "d5npOMwDwNA-00528-00102567-00102654": "in the car industry", "d5npOMwDwNA-00529-00102655-00102975": "have taken massive hits in the last", "d5npOMwDwNA-00530-00102976-00103190": "months hits that we as movements would", "d5npOMwDwNA-00531-00103191-00103327": "not have been able", "d5npOMwDwNA-00532-00103328-00103615": "to deliver so my current position is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00533-00103616-00103854": "that the de-growth and climate justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00534-00103855-00104215": "movements together need to fight against", "d5npOMwDwNA-00535-00104216-00104399": "these movement these sectors being", "d5npOMwDwNA-00536-00104400-00104551": "booted up again like i said", "d5npOMwDwNA-00537-00104552-00104871": "they shut them down thank you", "d5npOMwDwNA-00538-00104872-00105039": "i am happy that there are currently no", "d5npOMwDwNA-00539-00105040-00105207": "additional cars being produced", "d5npOMwDwNA-00540-00105208-00105358": "we have too many cars in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00541-00105359-00105519": "world now", "d5npOMwDwNA-00542-00105520-00105775": "as movements we need to keep that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00543-00105776-00105847": "shut down", "d5npOMwDwNA-00544-00105848-00106054": "there's a fam famous slogan in our", "d5npOMwDwNA-00545-00106055-00106286": "movement who shuts down we shut", "d5npOMwDwNA-00546-00106288-00106478": "down but in fact it is them", "d5npOMwDwNA-00547-00106479-00106743": "who shut down much more effectively", "d5npOMwDwNA-00548-00106744-00106863": "than we can", "d5npOMwDwNA-00549-00106864-00106999": "and if what i've said right now is true", "d5npOMwDwNA-00550-00107000-00107127": "and i think the empirical record is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00551-00107128-00107215": "pretty clear on this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00552-00107216-00107423": "then it is our task as movements for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00553-00107424-00107575": "social and environmental justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00554-00107576-00107951": "to keep that shut down", "d5npOMwDwNA-00555-00107952-00108183": "and i will end here thank you very much", "d5npOMwDwNA-00556-00108183-00108351": "and now i'm mute against a week", "d5npOMwDwNA-00557-00108352-00108502": "my husband can continue preparing for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00558-00108503-00108847": "our wedding", "d5npOMwDwNA-00559-00108848-00109302": "thank you very much", "d5npOMwDwNA-00560-00109303-00109543": "the current subscribe to the kobit 19", "d5npOMwDwNA-00561-00109544-00109719": "crisis and experience", "d5npOMwDwNA-00562-00109720-00110127": "um so we further move on to juliana", "d5npOMwDwNA-00563-00110128-00110447": "okay thanks um thanks a lot for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00564-00110448-00110647": "the invitation and i also want to thank", "d5npOMwDwNA-00565-00110648-00110815": "you for the whole book and the work", "d5npOMwDwNA-00566-00110816-00110943": "you've done because", "d5npOMwDwNA-00567-00110944-00111095": "it really brought together a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00568-00111096-00111278": "these courses and it's something like a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00569-00111279-00111486": "dictionary of movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00570-00111488-00111663": "you have the english one i have the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00571-00111664-00111910": "german one still", "d5npOMwDwNA-00572-00111911-00112247": "and um my um actually i'm working in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00573-00112248-00112454": "food sovereignty movement and i've wrote", "d5npOMwDwNA-00574-00112455-00112719": "written the article or the chapter", "d5npOMwDwNA-00575-00112720-00112919": "together with yemi saltzer who used to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00576-00112920-00113119": "work at via campesina", "d5npOMwDwNA-00577-00113120-00113327": "in austria as well but and now she's in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00578-00113328-00113510": "the ministry of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00579-00113511-00113766": "infrastructure climate and and in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00580-00113767-00113878": "environment", "d5npOMwDwNA-00581-00113879-00114183": "and so we we hope that she can bring in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00582-00114183-00114375": "their their ideas there", "d5npOMwDwNA-00583-00114376-00114727": "and um what we did is to first", "d5npOMwDwNA-00584-00114728-00115063": "like mathias showed with the questions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00585-00115064-00115095": "to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00586-00115096-00115383": "introduce of course to the movement of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00587-00115383-00115695": "food sovereignty in the article", "d5npOMwDwNA-00588-00115696-00116047": "and um to show that it's really", "d5npOMwDwNA-00589-00116048-00116351": "how the movement movement evolved", "d5npOMwDwNA-00590-00116352-00116671": "that um and how it is interconnected", "d5npOMwDwNA-00591-00116672-00116743": "with the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00592-00116744-00116999": "with via campesina and a lot of other", "d5npOMwDwNA-00593-00117000-00117095": "movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00594-00117096-00117390": "and so how it was brought together and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00595-00117391-00117623": "food sovereignty itself", "d5npOMwDwNA-00596-00117624-00117990": "um means to democratically decide on how", "d5npOMwDwNA-00597-00117991-00118271": "food is produced distributed and also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00598-00118272-00118390": "consumed", "d5npOMwDwNA-00599-00118391-00118710": "and it was first presented in 1996", "d5npOMwDwNA-00600-00118711-00119047": "at the uh the world food summit of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00601-00119048-00119286": "food and agriculture organization", "d5npOMwDwNA-00602-00119288-00119695": "and um and so and today it's uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-00603-00119696-00119951": "something like a common political", "d5npOMwDwNA-00604-00119952-00120054": "framework", "d5npOMwDwNA-00605-00120055-00120366": "of social movements and also others", "d5npOMwDwNA-00606-00120367-00120686": "groups of society fighting for", "d5npOMwDwNA-00607-00120688-00120951": "for the transformation of the global", "d5npOMwDwNA-00608-00120952-00121143": "food system", "d5npOMwDwNA-00609-00121144-00121427": "and it's even um now used by", "d5npOMwDwNA-00610-00121428-00121639": "institutions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00611-00121640-00121910": "who refer in on this concept of food", "d5npOMwDwNA-00612-00121911-00122023": "surveillance", "d5npOMwDwNA-00613-00122024-00122334": "sovereignty and for example now in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00614-00122335-00122399": "kovit", "d5npOMwDwNA-00615-00122400-00122639": "19 crisis even the ministry of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00616-00122640-00122814": "agriculture in austria said", "d5npOMwDwNA-00617-00122815-00123063": "well we need food sovereignty but of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00618-00123064-00123166": "course they", "d5npOMwDwNA-00619-00123167-00123383": "mean something quite different from one", "d5npOMwDwNA-00620-00123383-00123590": "from what we are talking about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00621-00123591-00123895": "um because they captured some on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00622-00123896-00124134": "they capture it as a very national", "d5npOMwDwNA-00623-00124135-00124231": "concept", "d5npOMwDwNA-00624-00124232-00124527": "of food sovereignty just of austria or", "d5npOMwDwNA-00625-00124528-00124683": "other", "d5npOMwDwNA-00626-00124683-00125023": "countries and um what is so important", "d5npOMwDwNA-00627-00125024-00125071": "about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00628-00125072-00125495": "to learn from food sovereignty is um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00629-00125496-00125831": "that it was firstly introduced by", "d5npOMwDwNA-00630-00125832-00126047": "the far the farmers and small-scale", "d5npOMwDwNA-00631-00126048-00126214": "farmers movement and also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00632-00126215-00126502": "a movement of rural workers of fishing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00633-00126503-00126719": "communities landless and indigenous", "d5npOMwDwNA-00634-00126720-00126783": "people", "d5npOMwDwNA-00635-00126783-00127110": "of via campesina and then of course we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00636-00127111-00127278": "are going to sina noticed well", "d5npOMwDwNA-00637-00127279-00127510": "we can't struggle for food serenity on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00638-00127511-00127631": "our own we need", "d5npOMwDwNA-00639-00127632-00127878": "allies we need a lot of allies and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00640-00127879-00127943": "that's", "d5npOMwDwNA-00641-00127944-00128310": "some seems to be a bit um similar to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00642-00128311-00128502": "what the degree of movement is doing now", "d5npOMwDwNA-00643-00128503-00128575": "to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00644-00128576-00128871": "to to bringing together those networks", "d5npOMwDwNA-00645-00128872-00128951": "of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00646-00128952-00129375": "movements um and so then we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00647-00129376-00129623": "explain a lot more in the article on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00648-00129624-00129710": "what what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00649-00129711-00129999": "food sovereignty does really mean also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00650-00130000-00130110": "talking about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00651-00130111-00130399": "the movement like these forums uh which", "d5npOMwDwNA-00652-00130400-00130686": "are called nieleni forums where people", "d5npOMwDwNA-00653-00130688-00130871": "of these different kind of networks", "d5npOMwDwNA-00654-00130872-00131087": "coming together in order to discuss what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00655-00131088-00131127": "food", "d5npOMwDwNA-00656-00131128-00131463": "sovereignty does it really means what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00657-00131464-00131671": "are we talking when we say food", "d5npOMwDwNA-00658-00131672-00131871": "sovereignty it's also quite", "d5npOMwDwNA-00659-00131872-00132231": "similar to the these conferences of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00660-00132232-00132423": "degree of movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-00661-00132424-00132807": "and to yeah to bring together", "d5npOMwDwNA-00662-00132808-00133102": "the movements within the regions like in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00663-00133103-00133175": "europe", "d5npOMwDwNA-00664-00133176-00133454": "but also on this global level so food", "d5npOMwDwNA-00665-00133455-00133639": "sovereignty was always", "d5npOMwDwNA-00666-00133640-00133959": "introduced as a concept that is based on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00667-00133960-00134190": "the solidarity of the global south and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00668-00134191-00134383": "the global north because", "d5npOMwDwNA-00669-00134384-00134719": "it it's moving against this industrial", "d5npOMwDwNA-00670-00134720-00135087": "agricultural system and also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00671-00135088-00135423": "was a lot founded around the struggles", "d5npOMwDwNA-00672-00135424-00135799": "against the wto and the the neoliberal", "d5npOMwDwNA-00673-00135800-00136111": "trade agreements um which are just", "d5npOMwDwNA-00674-00136112-00136327": "undermining the possibility of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00675-00136328-00136495": "small-scale farmers", "d5npOMwDwNA-00676-00136496-00136783": "uh in order to um yeah to structure", "d5npOMwDwNA-00677-00136784-00136927": "their production in a way that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00678-00136928-00137295": "they can earn a living and they can", "d5npOMwDwNA-00679-00137296-00137647": "raise uh so so yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-00680-00137648-00138054": "they can feed their own communities", "d5npOMwDwNA-00681-00138055-00138431": "um and radical hunger", "d5npOMwDwNA-00682-00138432-00138766": "and um then and after", "d5npOMwDwNA-00683-00138767-00139095": "like introducing to this whole what does", "d5npOMwDwNA-00684-00139096-00139271": "foods already mean and where does it", "d5npOMwDwNA-00685-00139272-00139447": "come from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00686-00139448-00139735": "and how how do the networks work", "d5npOMwDwNA-00687-00139736-00139814": "together", "d5npOMwDwNA-00688-00139815-00140119": "is um what we tried to do is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00689-00140120-00140519": "and to um to see what are the com", "d5npOMwDwNA-00690-00140520-00140727": "like what is in what we share in common", "d5npOMwDwNA-00691-00140728-00140943": "with the d growth movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-00692-00140944-00141327": "and what are maybe some strategies or", "d5npOMwDwNA-00693-00141328-00141671": "discussions we have to focus on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00694-00141672-00142014": "if we want to to work together and what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00695-00142015-00142183": "are the yeah what are just major", "d5npOMwDwNA-00696-00142184-00142302": "questions we should", "d5npOMwDwNA-00697-00142303-00142687": "discuss about and um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00698-00142688-00143071": "what we found is really a common base", "d5npOMwDwNA-00699-00143072-00143295": "is that both movements the food serenity", "d5npOMwDwNA-00700-00143296-00143599": "movement and also the degrowth movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-00701-00143600-00143966": "they just envision a new kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00702-00143967-00144366": "type of prosperity and also well-being", "d5npOMwDwNA-00703-00144367-00144647": "and of course it always includes the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00704-00144648-00144790": "social ecological", "d5npOMwDwNA-00705-00144791-00145014": "like like the social and also the econ", "d5npOMwDwNA-00706-00145015-00145175": "ecological debates", "d5npOMwDwNA-00707-00145176-00145478": "and bring them together and we we said", "d5npOMwDwNA-00708-00145479-00145526": "that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00709-00145527-00145807": "um like what we discussed in our article", "d5npOMwDwNA-00710-00145808-00145895": "is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00711-00145896-00146207": "that it is one of those major questions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00712-00146208-00146487": "is how the movement can bring together", "d5npOMwDwNA-00713-00146488-00146566": "those", "d5npOMwDwNA-00714-00146567-00146878": "those questions and then we also said", "d5npOMwDwNA-00715-00146879-00147214": "well um it's also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00716-00147215-00147551": "one um it's also important", "d5npOMwDwNA-00717-00147552-00147831": "as uh how we analyze the power", "d5npOMwDwNA-00718-00147832-00147935": "structures", "d5npOMwDwNA-00719-00147936-00148166": "and also the dominant uh political", "d5npOMwDwNA-00720-00148167-00148431": "structures behind it and this is this is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00721-00148432-00148790": "uh one important question where the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00722-00148791-00149007": "food sovereignty movement can learn a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00723-00149008-00149214": "lot from the degree of movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-00724-00149215-00149583": "um because um yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-00725-00149584-00149895": "um because yeah we the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00726-00149896-00150102": "food sovereignty movement is not so much", "d5npOMwDwNA-00727-00150103-00150207": "focused", "d5npOMwDwNA-00728-00150208-00150543": "on um on how", "d5npOMwDwNA-00729-00150544-00150839": "growth is produced or why we have we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00730-00150840-00150966": "need to have growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00731-00150967-00151399": "in our society um and so but it's more", "d5npOMwDwNA-00732-00151400-00151559": "what the what the farmers and the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00733-00151560-00151735": "peasants see as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00734-00151736-00152007": "one of the major challenges in their", "d5npOMwDwNA-00735-00152008-00152175": "work", "d5npOMwDwNA-00736-00152176-00152487": "um and just to get to an end and to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00737-00152488-00152590": "summarize", "d5npOMwDwNA-00738-00152591-00152902": "um at the the end of the article um we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00739-00152903-00152975": "discussed", "d5npOMwDwNA-00740-00152976-00153311": "um is yeah how um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00741-00153312-00153495": "what we can learn from each other and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00742-00153496-00153631": "how these", "d5npOMwDwNA-00743-00153632-00153895": "what what farmers see in their daily", "d5npOMwDwNA-00744-00153896-00154023": "life that they have", "d5npOMwDwNA-00745-00154024-00154335": "they need to grow as a farm or they need", "d5npOMwDwNA-00746-00154336-00154631": "to stop farming and so this this is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00747-00154632-00154743": "those are the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00748-00154744-00154975": "just the things they can decide between", "d5npOMwDwNA-00749-00154976-00155183": "and what they are struggling against", "d5npOMwDwNA-00750-00155184-00155566": "is um that um this is can be merged with", "d5npOMwDwNA-00751-00155567-00155775": "the debates on the growth and this is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00752-00155776-00155951": "something where we can learn a lot from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00753-00155952-00156063": "each other", "d5npOMwDwNA-00754-00156064-00156319": "but the debates are still on quite", "d5npOMwDwNA-00755-00156320-00156383": "different", "d5npOMwDwNA-00756-00156384-00156678": "levels and there's a lot still needed in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00757-00156679-00156902": "order to learn from each other", "d5npOMwDwNA-00758-00156903-00157119": "yeah and so this is why we are also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00759-00157120-00157335": "happy to still be in this", "d5npOMwDwNA-00760-00157336-00157663": "debate and to also have a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00761-00157664-00157911": "discussion now on the legrove conference", "d5npOMwDwNA-00762-00157912-00158126": "we have a whole session on sunday", "d5npOMwDwNA-00763-00158127-00158399": "where um i just invite you to come to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00764-00158400-00158614": "where we're discussing um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00765-00158615-00158983": "uh kind of all the different kinds of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00766-00158984-00159302": "initiatives who already we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00767-00159303-00159526": "are in the way of transforming the food", "d5npOMwDwNA-00768-00159527-00159735": "system and the food", "d5npOMwDwNA-00769-00159736-00160119": "yeah that the other food system", "d5npOMwDwNA-00770-00160120-00160519": "so thanks a lot thank you very much", "d5npOMwDwNA-00771-00160520-00160839": "so now we kind of have insights from two", "d5npOMwDwNA-00772-00160840-00161047": "different perspectives in the book you", "d5npOMwDwNA-00773-00161048-00161231": "find many more um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00774-00161232-00161439": "kind of in these lines but each being", "d5npOMwDwNA-00775-00161440-00161575": "very very individually from the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00776-00161576-00161719": "perspective of the authors", "d5npOMwDwNA-00777-00161720-00161902": "in relation to the specific social", "d5npOMwDwNA-00778-00161903-00162023": "movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-00779-00162024-00162207": "and now corona is going to tell us a bit", "d5npOMwDwNA-00780-00162208-00162407": "about what we as editors", "d5npOMwDwNA-00781-00162408-00162599": "of this project and the book kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00782-00162600-00162943": "like learned from this experience", "d5npOMwDwNA-00783-00162944-00163247": "uh thank you mathias um i also prepared", "d5npOMwDwNA-00784-00163248-00163471": "like a very short statement uh what we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00785-00163472-00163647": "think is uh important about digross and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00786-00163648-00163854": "i think we as matthias also mentioned", "d5npOMwDwNA-00787-00163855-00163966": "earlier there's still so many", "d5npOMwDwNA-00788-00163967-00164087": "misunderstandings", "d5npOMwDwNA-00789-00164088-00164375": "about what we mean when we say degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00790-00164376-00164407": "so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00791-00164408-00164654": "even if it's repetitive i just want to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00792-00164655-00164823": "say a few words", "d5npOMwDwNA-00793-00164824-00165038": "so we're challenging the gross hijab", "d5npOMwDwNA-00794-00165039-00165151": "hygiene", "d5npOMwDwNA-00795-00165152-00165454": "with it's focused on growth profit and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00796-00165455-00165583": "competition", "d5npOMwDwNA-00797-00165584-00165766": "and um for that we need the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00798-00165767-00166038": "reorganization of society of economy of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00799-00166039-00166151": "the everyday", "d5npOMwDwNA-00800-00166152-00166375": "and uh in order to reduce the material", "d5npOMwDwNA-00801-00166376-00166543": "throughput and to enable the good life", "d5npOMwDwNA-00802-00166544-00166607": "for all i think", "d5npOMwDwNA-00803-00166608-00166871": "both tassie and juliana also highlighted", "d5npOMwDwNA-00804-00166872-00167038": "that this is an important point in their", "d5npOMwDwNA-00805-00167039-00167151": "movements and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00806-00167152-00167478": "um it is also yeah something that is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00807-00167479-00167695": "that we identified as a commonality", "d5npOMwDwNA-00808-00167696-00167887": "between these movements gabbard in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00809-00167888-00168071": "book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00810-00168072-00168375": "we we highlight core values uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-00811-00168376-00168638": "as such as awareness solidarity and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00812-00168639-00168783": "cooperation", "d5npOMwDwNA-00813-00168784-00169095": "and um to in order to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00814-00169096-00169454": "um to change to reach any form of change", "d5npOMwDwNA-00815-00169455-00169502": "that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00816-00169503-00169766": "we call for a re-politicizing of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00817-00169767-00169878": "economy of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00818-00169879-00170063": "sustainability and also how we organize", "d5npOMwDwNA-00819-00170064-00170214": "society and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00820-00170215-00170478": "again that's the commonality of many of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00821-00170479-00170695": "the or all the movements in the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-00822-00170696-00170983": "um that in order to actually to be able", "d5npOMwDwNA-00823-00170984-00171135": "to talk about the v", "d5npOMwDwNA-00824-00171136-00171414": "um that i have i've used this like the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00825-00171415-00171487": "we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00826-00171488-00171847": "um we need um an expansion of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00827-00171848-00172087": "democratic forms of decision making so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00828-00172088-00172247": "that's also something we highlight as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00829-00172248-00172399": "part of the degrees movement and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00830-00172400-00172623": "i think we also identified that as one", "d5npOMwDwNA-00831-00172624-00172790": "of the commonalities", "d5npOMwDwNA-00832-00172791-00173151": "um between the movements then um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00833-00173152-00173399": "also that has already been topic on the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00834-00173400-00173551": "panel this morning", "d5npOMwDwNA-00835-00173552-00173814": "um in the opening panel the cooperation", "d5npOMwDwNA-00836-00173815-00173871": "between", "d5npOMwDwNA-00837-00173872-00174007": "global north and global south so", "d5npOMwDwNA-00838-00174008-00174247": "de-growth being a movement coming from", "d5npOMwDwNA-00839-00174248-00174438": "the global north but", "d5npOMwDwNA-00840-00174439-00174623": "being in cooperation and dialogue with", "d5npOMwDwNA-00841-00174624-00174911": "movements from in the global south", "d5npOMwDwNA-00842-00174912-00175247": "um and then shortly um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00843-00175248-00175590": "also i think um yeah present here um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00844-00175591-00175823": "in this session um this need for mixed", "d5npOMwDwNA-00845-00175824-00175990": "strategies of uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-00846-00175991-00176343": "practical natural ps of activism", "d5npOMwDwNA-00847-00176344-00176678": "and research uh in order to foster", "d5npOMwDwNA-00848-00176679-00177031": "a movement when we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00849-00177032-00177343": "received the contributions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00850-00177344-00177663": "to to this book we also realized that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00851-00177664-00177738": "there is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00852-00177739-00177999": "misunderstandings of the degrees concept", "d5npOMwDwNA-00853-00178000-00178175": "and we had hoped to sort of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00854-00178176-00178543": "um yeah to meet or to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00855-00178544-00178799": "we had written a short summary of what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00856-00178800-00178935": "degrees means for us", "d5npOMwDwNA-00857-00178936-00179135": "and sent that to all the authors before", "d5npOMwDwNA-00858-00179136-00179326": "they wrote the chapters", "d5npOMwDwNA-00859-00179327-00179495": "and but still we encountered", "d5npOMwDwNA-00860-00179496-00179711": "misunderstandings so i'm", "d5npOMwDwNA-00861-00179712-00179919": "i want to repeat them here and say how", "d5npOMwDwNA-00862-00179920-00180078": "we sort of react", "d5npOMwDwNA-00863-00180079-00180375": "on them so one um is diggers is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00864-00180376-00180519": "criticized for being", "d5npOMwDwNA-00865-00180520-00180743": "only about individualized voluntary", "d5npOMwDwNA-00866-00180744-00180878": "simplicity", "d5npOMwDwNA-00867-00180879-00181166": "um as like this idea that um yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-00868-00181167-00181366": "individuals are responsible to reduce", "d5npOMwDwNA-00869-00181367-00181543": "their carbon footprint and that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00870-00181544-00181759": "this would be d gross but i think as i", "d5npOMwDwNA-00871-00181760-00181878": "said now and also as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00872-00181879-00182087": "bertotti already earlier introduced", "d5npOMwDwNA-00873-00182088-00182287": "heroes on the opening panel", "d5npOMwDwNA-00874-00182288-00182543": "um it's it's not that it's not just that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00875-00182544-00182695": "sufficiency is an important", "d5npOMwDwNA-00876-00182696-00182975": "core value in degrees but um there is a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00877-00182976-00183047": "lot more", "d5npOMwDwNA-00878-00183048-00183390": "to it um and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00879-00183391-00183559": "similar there is critique that divorce", "d5npOMwDwNA-00880-00183560-00183831": "would be about shrinking gdp", "d5npOMwDwNA-00881-00183832-00184119": "and um i think when it comes to ddos", "d5npOMwDwNA-00882-00184120-00184190": "drinking", "d5npOMwDwNA-00883-00184191-00184487": "gdp it can very well be a consequence of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00884-00184488-00184663": "what happens when if we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00885-00184664-00184878": "would move forward to something that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00886-00184879-00185031": "could be a deal or society", "d5npOMwDwNA-00887-00185032-00185207": "but it's really about presenting a", "d5npOMwDwNA-00888-00185208-00185407": "non-government non-growth centered", "d5npOMwDwNA-00889-00185408-00185590": "alternative to today's workings of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00890-00185591-00185702": "society", "d5npOMwDwNA-00891-00185703-00185959": "and the the third sort of critique that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00892-00185960-00186038": "we come", "d5npOMwDwNA-00893-00186039-00186207": "often here and that probably a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00894-00186208-00186343": "you who are here today", "d5npOMwDwNA-00895-00186344-00186671": "have heard us that the term degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00896-00186672-00187063": "isn't a good term to use um because it's", "d5npOMwDwNA-00897-00187064-00187119": "uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-00898-00187120-00187543": "sort of negative or focusing on yeah on", "d5npOMwDwNA-00899-00187544-00187871": "shrinking and yeah we i mean it will", "d5npOMwDwNA-00900-00187872-00187999": "probably continue to be a point of", "d5npOMwDwNA-00901-00188000-00188095": "disagreement but", "d5npOMwDwNA-00902-00188096-00188326": "um i think i can say for us editors that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00903-00188327-00188399": "we like", "d5npOMwDwNA-00904-00188400-00188638": "um this term as a provocative term but", "d5npOMwDwNA-00905-00188639-00188823": "that we're trying to fill it with", "d5npOMwDwNA-00906-00188824-00189135": "life um with other concepts", "d5npOMwDwNA-00907-00189136-00189478": "like solidarity democracy participation", "d5npOMwDwNA-00908-00189479-00189926": "equality of rights social inclusion", "d5npOMwDwNA-00909-00189927-00190271": "and then out what we further um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00910-00190272-00190575": "learned or yeah matthias mentioned these", "d5npOMwDwNA-00911-00190576-00190599": "four", "d5npOMwDwNA-00912-00190600-00190743": "questions and these five questions we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00913-00190744-00190887": "post to all the authors and the fourth", "d5npOMwDwNA-00914-00190888-00190935": "question", "d5npOMwDwNA-00915-00190936-00191295": "was uh please um share suggestions", "d5npOMwDwNA-00916-00191296-00191399": "critique ideas", "d5npOMwDwNA-00917-00191400-00191766": "um that you can sort of um voice towards", "d5npOMwDwNA-00918-00191767-00191935": "the digross movement or a digger's", "d5npOMwDwNA-00919-00191936-00192031": "perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-00920-00192032-00192319": "and then in the um in the introduction", "d5npOMwDwNA-00921-00192320-00192414": "chapter of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00922-00192415-00192719": "english book and also in the closing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00923-00192720-00192895": "chapter of the german book we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00924-00192896-00193343": "highlight four um sort of proposals that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00925-00193344-00193478": "that were mentioned frequently", "d5npOMwDwNA-00926-00193479-00193647": "throughout the text i would quickly go", "d5npOMwDwNA-00927-00193648-00193783": "through those", "d5npOMwDwNA-00928-00193784-00194166": "the first one is that we need to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00929-00194167-00194454": "keep the or yeah make the relationship", "d5npOMwDwNA-00930-00194455-00194590": "with the global sales", "d5npOMwDwNA-00931-00194591-00194871": "important that we need broad true broad", "d5npOMwDwNA-00932-00194872-00194990": "alliances", "d5npOMwDwNA-00933-00194991-00195150": "if we want to strive for global justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-00934-00195151-00195390": "and not go into some", "d5npOMwDwNA-00935-00195391-00195695": "reenacting of climate colonialism", "d5npOMwDwNA-00936-00195696-00195999": "that we need to understand each other", "d5npOMwDwNA-00937-00196000-00196263": "to not become provincial so if we um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00938-00196264-00196438": "planning some action we need to be aware", "d5npOMwDwNA-00939-00196439-00196478": "that", "d5npOMwDwNA-00940-00196479-00196719": "what what side effects might our", "d5npOMwDwNA-00941-00196720-00196863": "proposals actually", "d5npOMwDwNA-00942-00196864-00197159": "mean for other movements uh in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-00943-00197160-00197326": "global south or", "d5npOMwDwNA-00944-00197327-00197695": "yeah other communities and um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00945-00197696-00197919": "also when it comes to relationship", "d5npOMwDwNA-00946-00197920-00198095": "recently in global neuroscience", "d5npOMwDwNA-00947-00198096-00198311": "we need to be aware that alternatives", "d5npOMwDwNA-00948-00198312-00198478": "and struggles are always rooted in their", "d5npOMwDwNA-00949-00198479-00198631": "local context", "d5npOMwDwNA-00950-00198632-00198831": "so there is no one serve them all", "d5npOMwDwNA-00951-00198832-00199087": "solution um so these were", "d5npOMwDwNA-00952-00199088-00199311": "like what also is highlighted to us as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00953-00199312-00199463": "something that we need to keep in mind", "d5npOMwDwNA-00954-00199464-00199526": "when we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00955-00199527-00199750": "um striving for the growth but that we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00956-00199751-00199847": "also thought", "d5npOMwDwNA-00957-00199848-00200199": "is um is valuable for others", "d5npOMwDwNA-00958-00200200-00200414": "working in social environmental", "d5npOMwDwNA-00959-00200415-00200583": "struggles the second", "d5npOMwDwNA-00960-00200584-00200911": "point is we need to constantly be", "d5npOMwDwNA-00961-00200912-00200999": "resistant and", "d5npOMwDwNA-00962-00201000-00201263": "critical of domination and not forget", "d5npOMwDwNA-00963-00201264-00201366": "about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00964-00201367-00201519": "other hidden power structures that we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00965-00201520-00201719": "might not be addressing in our current", "d5npOMwDwNA-00966-00201720-00201831": "struggles but", "d5npOMwDwNA-00967-00201832-00202143": "yeah we do not forget about um other", "d5npOMwDwNA-00968-00202144-00202287": "struggles that are fought", "d5npOMwDwNA-00969-00202288-00202463": "the third one is that we need to be", "d5npOMwDwNA-00970-00202464-00202590": "aware to create", "d5npOMwDwNA-00971-00202591-00202878": "um and maintain material space that can", "d5npOMwDwNA-00972-00202879-00203102": "be a project like notorious but also", "d5npOMwDwNA-00973-00203103-00203366": "a space where we meet and where we can", "d5npOMwDwNA-00974-00203367-00203431": "um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00975-00203432-00203750": "build up relationships beyond um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00976-00203751-00204014": "just specific events and the third one", "d5npOMwDwNA-00977-00204015-00204078": "then i'm", "d5npOMwDwNA-00978-00204079-00204423": "and then i'm done is that we need to", "d5npOMwDwNA-00979-00204424-00204647": "overcome the barriers of our own milieus", "d5npOMwDwNA-00980-00204648-00204790": "and that means", "d5npOMwDwNA-00981-00204791-00205119": "yeah that we need a truly broad movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-00982-00205119-00205351": "and need to become better at mobilizing", "d5npOMwDwNA-00983-00205352-00205479": "diverse groups", "d5npOMwDwNA-00984-00205480-00205662": "um diverse and experience and background", "d5npOMwDwNA-00985-00205663-00205814": "and i think um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00986-00205815-00206086": "juliana and tatia are both like in", "d5npOMwDwNA-00987-00206087-00206246": "movements where this is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00988-00206248-00206398": "where it is more diverse than", "d5npOMwDwNA-00989-00206400-00206566": "individuals um", "d5npOMwDwNA-00990-00206567-00206934": "thank you", "d5npOMwDwNA-00991-00206935-00207182": "thank you very much kogana um this is", "d5npOMwDwNA-00992-00207183-00207310": "very like", "d5npOMwDwNA-00993-00207311-00207623": "to kind of like um summarize a bit what", "d5npOMwDwNA-00994-00207623-00207710": "we", "d5npOMwDwNA-00995-00207711-00207862": "like one thing that we also learned as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00996-00207863-00208079": "editors is to see degrowth net as", "d5npOMwDwNA-00997-00208080-00208319": "not as something like the emerging news", "d5npOMwDwNA-00998-00208319-00208479": "social movement that is bringing about", "d5npOMwDwNA-00999-00208480-00208655": "the larger change in society", "d5npOMwDwNA-01000-00208656-00208910": "but rather a perspective that we hope is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01001-00208911-00209006": "taken on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01002-00209007-00209238": "in many different social movements and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01003-00209239-00209342": "that will be an", "d5npOMwDwNA-01004-00209344-00209551": "integral part of kind of like a new wave", "d5npOMwDwNA-01005-00209552-00209751": "of a broader social alliance", "d5npOMwDwNA-01006-00209752-00209942": "and which doesn't have to run under the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01007-00209944-00210110": "term degrowth but should", "d5npOMwDwNA-01008-00210111-00210342": "incorporate some of the key perspectives", "d5npOMwDwNA-01009-00210344-00210494": "and critiques from the degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01010-00210496-00210631": "perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-01011-00210632-00210839": "so we now turn to prototy um for a short", "d5npOMwDwNA-01012-00210840-00210998": "kind of like outside view", "d5npOMwDwNA-01013-00211000-00211175": "um on this book from someone who has not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01014-00211176-00211375": "been involved in the project", "d5npOMwDwNA-01015-00211376-00212206": "but is an expert on degrowth in general", "d5npOMwDwNA-01016-00212207-00212767": "we cannot tell you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01017-00212767-00213142": "still not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01018-00213144-00213423": "can you try to turn on the mic at the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01019-00213423-00213894": "bottom", "d5npOMwDwNA-01020-00213896-00214175": "or can it should be within your computer", "d5npOMwDwNA-01021-00214176-00214375": "because we can't see it's turned off", "d5npOMwDwNA-01022-00214376-00214582": "i mean i can see that juliana and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01023-00214583-00215182": "coroner turned off but you aren't", "d5npOMwDwNA-01024-00215183-00215510": "oh no yes oh no", "d5npOMwDwNA-01025-00215511-00215727": "this is about your head and put it in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01026-00215728-00215903": "again maybe that could help", "d5npOMwDwNA-01027-00215904-00216103": "you probably you should look for the the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01028-00216104-00216334": "phone icon in the middle of between the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01029-00216335-00216567": "the microphone and the camera buttons", "d5npOMwDwNA-01030-00216567-00216719": "there should be like a little", "d5npOMwDwNA-01031-00216719-00216991": "audio button you don't see it okay so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01032-00216992-00217082": "maybe try", "d5npOMwDwNA-01033-00217083-00217382": "um leaving and coming back and i'll", "d5npOMwDwNA-01034-00217383-00217846": "preview again just refresh the page yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-01035-00217848-00217998": "sorry for the inconvenience guys this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01036-00218000-00218215": "work this happens sometimes oh good", "d5npOMwDwNA-01037-00218216-00218382": "that's been working pretty well for the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01038-00218383-00218806": "first session in this conference", "d5npOMwDwNA-01039-00218807-00219015": "again but thanks to everyone organizing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01040-00219016-00219191": "this wonderful conference", "d5npOMwDwNA-01041-00219192-00219391": "and thanks also to the guy you just", "d5npOMwDwNA-01042-00219392-00219598": "heard in the back that's davi he's our", "d5npOMwDwNA-01043-00219600-00219767": "i.t support without a video", "d5npOMwDwNA-01044-00219767-00219934": "thanks for you and thanks to you for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01045-00219935-00220087": "helping us out", "d5npOMwDwNA-01046-00220088-00220415": "it's a pleasure to help okay let's see", "d5npOMwDwNA-01047-00220416-00220694": "where", "d5npOMwDwNA-01048-00220696-00221023": "okay now yeah we hear you perfect", "d5npOMwDwNA-01049-00221023-00221206": "i can see you also now because i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01050-00221207-00221455": "couldn't see anybody before amazing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01051-00221456-00221998": "all right thank you so much david", "d5npOMwDwNA-01052-00222000-00222367": "okay so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01053-00222367-00222615": "i'm very happy and honored to be uh to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01054-00222616-00222767": "be reviewing the book and to talk a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01055-00222767-00222991": "little bit and give my insights from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01056-00222992-00223351": "from after reading the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-01057-00223352-00223639": "um so there were three main questions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01058-00223640-00223679": "which", "d5npOMwDwNA-01059-00223680-00223967": "i was supposed to reflect on while while", "d5npOMwDwNA-01060-00223967-00224094": "preparing for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01061-00224096-00224446": "for my reflections", "d5npOMwDwNA-01062-00224448-00224623": "the first thing is uh so the three", "d5npOMwDwNA-01063-00224623-00224767": "questions were what did i learn about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01064-00224767-00224919": "the different movements and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01065-00224919-00225191": "its relationship to d growth did i see", "d5npOMwDwNA-01066-00225192-00225358": "any alliances which could be possible", "d5npOMwDwNA-01067-00225359-00225551": "for a broader systemic transformation", "d5npOMwDwNA-01068-00225552-00225727": "and what did i like and what did i not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01069-00225728-00225894": "like about the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01070-00225896-00226191": "about the book so what i'm going to try", "d5npOMwDwNA-01071-00226192-00226294": "to do is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01072-00226296-00226487": "talk a little bit of the of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01073-00226488-00226775": "different chapters and the different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01074-00226776-00226951": "points which i found very interesting", "d5npOMwDwNA-01075-00226952-00227198": "and and all the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01076-00227200-00227351": "thoughts and new ideas that emerged", "d5npOMwDwNA-01077-00227352-00227663": "after and while i was reading the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-01078-00227664-00227934": "to begin with i i really liked the fact", "d5npOMwDwNA-01079-00227935-00228119": "that there was a very concrete focus", "d5npOMwDwNA-01080-00228119-00228294": "that we're we're going to talk to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01081-00228296-00228446": "activists who have been involved in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01082-00228448-00228567": "different movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-01083-00228567-00228782": "and i think around 20 different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01084-00228783-00228934": "movements and how", "d5npOMwDwNA-01085-00228935-00229239": "how they engage with the growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01086-00229240-00229679": "overlaps contradictions and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01087-00229680-00229815": "and there were sections specifically", "d5npOMwDwNA-01088-00229816-00229951": "talking about the differences in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01089-00229952-00230110": "moral frame of references", "d5npOMwDwNA-01090-00230111-00230223": "how they are engaging with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01091-00230223-00230479": "anti-capitalism looking at the scale", "d5npOMwDwNA-01092-00230480-00230751": "aspect of the transformation strategies", "d5npOMwDwNA-01093-00230752-00230879": "and also as you mentioned before", "d5npOMwDwNA-01094-00230880-00231142": "reflecting on the power structures and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01095-00231144-00231367": "internal hierarchies within each of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01096-00231367-00231527": "movement and how they form alliances", "d5npOMwDwNA-01097-00231528-00231846": "with each other", "d5npOMwDwNA-01098-00231848-00232198": "i i really enjoyed", "d5npOMwDwNA-01099-00232200-00232351": "how in each chapter there was a very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01100-00232352-00232534": "specific section detailing on the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01101-00232535-00232742": "overlap so you didn't have to look", "d5npOMwDwNA-01102-00232744-00232958": "you knew like how the how the section", "d5npOMwDwNA-01103-00232959-00233287": "was how each chapters was", "d5npOMwDwNA-01104-00233288-00233606": "sectionalized chapter i don't know", "d5npOMwDwNA-01105-00233607-00233863": "how each each chapter had a specific", "d5npOMwDwNA-01106-00233864-00234079": "section dedicated at the end of it after", "d5npOMwDwNA-01107-00234080-00234231": "introducing the concept to see the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01108-00234232-00234463": "commonalities", "d5npOMwDwNA-01109-00234464-00234655": "for example the chapter on basic income", "d5npOMwDwNA-01110-00234656-00234863": "very clearly gave", "d5npOMwDwNA-01111-00234864-00235063": "gave details that it engages with the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01112-00235064-00235231": "specific decode principles of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01113-00235232-00235423": "social security and redistribution", "d5npOMwDwNA-01114-00235423-00235551": "democracy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01115-00235552-00235767": "solidarity-based economy and then", "d5npOMwDwNA-01116-00235767-00235903": "individual and collective time", "d5npOMwDwNA-01117-00235904-00236087": "sovereignty", "d5npOMwDwNA-01118-00236088-00236271": "and then in other chapters such as", "d5npOMwDwNA-01119-00236271-00236439": "alberto costa's chapters on boo and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01120-00236440-00236582": "vivier it was also very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01121-00236583-00236879": "clearly mentioned that we are seeking", "d5npOMwDwNA-01122-00236880-00237063": "more of an alliance between the growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01123-00237064-00237239": "in the north and post-extractivism in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01124-00237240-00237342": "the south and not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01125-00237344-00237687": "really look finding principles from the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01126-00237688-00237855": "growth to implement in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01127-00237856-00238198": "in post extractivist uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-01128-00238200-00238503": "principles so it was very clear where", "d5npOMwDwNA-01129-00238504-00238663": "where the movements were coming from and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01130-00238664-00238815": "where the people what were the positions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01131-00238816-00239127": "that the people were writing from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01132-00239128-00239446": "um i also liked that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01133-00239448-00239623": "a lot of questions were asked coming", "d5npOMwDwNA-01134-00239623-00239831": "from from different movements for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01135-00239832-00240046": "example in the chapter on commons", "d5npOMwDwNA-01136-00240048-00240406": "the authors johannes and leslie", "d5npOMwDwNA-01137-00240407-00240687": "very uh asked this very important", "d5npOMwDwNA-01138-00240688-00240927": "question of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01139-00240928-00241175": "of whether we say commons are a part of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01140-00241176-00241342": "the degrowth movement or the other way", "d5npOMwDwNA-01141-00241344-00241471": "around", "d5npOMwDwNA-01142-00241471-00241582": "and i think these are important", "d5npOMwDwNA-01143-00241583-00241742": "questions when we start talking about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01144-00241744-00241887": "strategies", "d5npOMwDwNA-01145-00241888-00242191": "of as you all as the book already", "d5npOMwDwNA-01146-00242192-00242439": "mentions know that um", "d5npOMwDwNA-01147-00242440-00242591": "that the growth is not going to be the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01148-00242592-00242767": "social movement it is going to be one of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01149-00242767-00242951": "the perspectives which can be taken in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01150-00242952-00243119": "for a broad alliance and in all the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01151-00243119-00243303": "chapters more or less", "d5npOMwDwNA-01152-00243304-00243558": "i could find different ways in which", "d5npOMwDwNA-01153-00243559-00243630": "from their", "d5npOMwDwNA-01154-00243631-00243791": "own perspectives the writers were", "d5npOMwDwNA-01155-00243792-00244055": "questioning this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01156-00244056-00244198": "what i found also very interesting was", "d5npOMwDwNA-01157-00244200-00244406": "the chapter on trade unions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01158-00244407-00244846": "by jana fleming and norbert reuter who", "d5npOMwDwNA-01159-00244848-00245206": "who in the beginning say that how", "d5npOMwDwNA-01160-00245207-00245527": "it's it's difficult in terms of uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-01161-00245528-00245655": "so they were talking about trade unions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01162-00245656-00245823": "with the focus on fossil energy with the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01163-00245823-00245942": "focus on coal", "d5npOMwDwNA-01164-00245944-00246142": "and in the first half of the chapter you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01165-00246144-00246294": "keep thinking there is no way this can", "d5npOMwDwNA-01166-00246296-00246463": "form an alliance with the growth because", "d5npOMwDwNA-01167-00246464-00246655": "it's completely different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01168-00246656-00246798": "and then in the second half they talk", "d5npOMwDwNA-01169-00246800-00247055": "about the ways in which they see", "d5npOMwDwNA-01170-00247056-00247279": "an alliance is through walk time", "d5npOMwDwNA-01171-00247280-00247406": "reduction", "d5npOMwDwNA-01172-00247407-00247791": "and economic democracy and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01173-00247792-00247991": "and it's it was a very interesting way", "d5npOMwDwNA-01174-00247992-00248206": "of trying to look at it to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01175-00248207-00248367": "to have these people come together and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01176-00248367-00248567": "sit and then then restart the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01177-00248567-00248791": "conversation and okay but what about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01178-00248792-00249094": "what about the environment and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01179-00249096-00249415": "and whether it would be fine if if you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01180-00249416-00249503": "find proper", "d5npOMwDwNA-01181-00249504-00249679": "viable solutions to look at the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01182-00249680-00249839": "employment issues and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01183-00249840-00250151": "and how do you go beyond it uh so very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01184-00250152-00250334": "interesting things to think about and to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01185-00250335-00250534": "and to strategically work towards and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01186-00250535-00250703": "then also they say that and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01187-00250704-00250942": "the strength of this could be this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01188-00250944-00251030": "history of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01189-00251031-00251263": "political engagement that trade unions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01190-00251264-00251391": "have of asking for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01191-00251392-00251687": "rights of asking for uh like", "d5npOMwDwNA-01192-00251688-00251855": "strategically giving out policy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01193-00251856-00252071": "proposals which could be", "d5npOMwDwNA-01194-00252071-00252271": "could be a strength in forging such", "d5npOMwDwNA-01195-00252271-00252446": "certain alliances so this i found very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01196-00252448-00252734": "very interesting", "d5npOMwDwNA-01197-00252735-00253071": "uh then one of the chapter i kept", "d5npOMwDwNA-01198-00253071-00253230": "reading again and again was the chapter", "d5npOMwDwNA-01199-00253231-00253439": "on the people's global action by", "d5npOMwDwNA-01200-00253440-00253782": "frederick haberman in which she in a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01201-00253783-00253839": "very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01202-00253840-00254039": "in a very simple way with like very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01203-00254040-00254246": "specific examples", "d5npOMwDwNA-01204-00254248-00254406": "talks about how degrowth needs to be", "d5npOMwDwNA-01205-00254407-00254575": "colonial", "d5npOMwDwNA-01206-00254576-00254823": "and and the more the more you read the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01207-00254823-00254942": "more you realize that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01208-00254944-00255119": "in mainstream degraded literature these", "d5npOMwDwNA-01209-00255119-00255367": "things are not spoken about that much", "d5npOMwDwNA-01210-00255367-00255606": "very similar to what tazio was talking", "d5npOMwDwNA-01211-00255607-00255775": "about earlier about where climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-01212-00255776-00255879": "justice", "d5npOMwDwNA-01213-00255880-00256087": "movement comes from also another thing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01214-00256088-00256271": "as you mentioned it's not so obvious", "d5npOMwDwNA-01215-00256271-00256423": "it's not so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01216-00256423-00256606": "not it's it's kind of invisibilized in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01217-00256607-00256806": "some way", "d5npOMwDwNA-01218-00256807-00257023": "then there was the chapter on refugee", "d5npOMwDwNA-01219-00257023-00257151": "movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-01220-00257152-00257455": "which also in a very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01221-00257456-00257846": "in very simple way questioned about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01222-00257848-00258198": "how the the growth activist or the d", "d5npOMwDwNA-01223-00258200-00258367": "growth advocates need to come down from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01224-00258367-00258615": "the podium and join the struggle", "d5npOMwDwNA-01225-00258616-00259039": "and and how the climate camps the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01226-00259040-00259271": "participation the people who are", "d5npOMwDwNA-01227-00259271-00259646": "who are the main uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-01228-00259648-00259846": "yeah participants and activists are", "d5npOMwDwNA-01229-00259848-00260006": "remain", "d5npOMwDwNA-01230-00260007-00260358": "largely wide and so although there is a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01231-00260359-00260415": "lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01232-00260416-00260694": "scope of solidarity and there's a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01233-00260696-00260815": "questions on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01234-00260816-00261087": "the coloniality it still remains you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01235-00261088-00261142": "don't see", "d5npOMwDwNA-01236-00261144-00261391": "so many people who are non-white in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01237-00261392-00261542": "those spaces", "d5npOMwDwNA-01238-00261544-00261694": "again a very critical thing to discuss", "d5npOMwDwNA-01239-00261696-00261887": "about not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01240-00261888-00262039": "what are the strategies but who are the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01241-00262040-00262327": "people strategizing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01242-00262328-00262710": "uh also in christian's chapter on eco", "d5npOMwDwNA-01243-00262711-00262910": "villages", "d5npOMwDwNA-01244-00262911-00263134": "the self-reflection on eco-villages are", "d5npOMwDwNA-01245-00263135-00263319": "often considered to be a political", "d5npOMwDwNA-01246-00263320-00263543": "which is a which is a subject of intense", "d5npOMwDwNA-01247-00263544-00263663": "debate", "d5npOMwDwNA-01248-00263664-00263903": "and and then in a way also drawing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01249-00263904-00264071": "parallels with the discourse on care", "d5npOMwDwNA-01250-00264072-00264303": "work", "d5npOMwDwNA-01251-00264304-00264639": "um so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01252-00264640-00264823": "so yeah like each and every chapter i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01253-00264824-00265023": "found at least one new thing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01254-00265024-00265175": "that i could pick up and i could think", "d5npOMwDwNA-01255-00265176-00265415": "about and i could reflect on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01256-00265416-00265799": "um the chapter on food sovereignty by", "d5npOMwDwNA-01257-00265800-00266110": "juliana and irmi they talk about false", "d5npOMwDwNA-01258-00266111-00266223": "alternatives", "d5npOMwDwNA-01259-00266224-00266510": "and uh and it's another thing which is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01260-00266511-00266767": "not spoken about uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-01261-00266768-00266919": "so clearly when you talk about food", "d5npOMwDwNA-01262-00266920-00267087": "sovereignty and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01263-00267088-00267263": "and i quote from the chapter the essence", "d5npOMwDwNA-01264-00267264-00267439": "of both the growth and food sovereignty", "d5npOMwDwNA-01265-00267440-00267630": "however is that they seek to politicize", "d5npOMwDwNA-01266-00267631-00267806": "people and to show clearly", "d5npOMwDwNA-01267-00267807-00267982": "that supermarket selling organic", "d5npOMwDwNA-01268-00267983-00268191": "products contribute as little to saving", "d5npOMwDwNA-01269-00268192-00268423": "the world as so-called green growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01270-00268424-00268599": "another discussion which we don't see so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01271-00268600-00268903": "often and there is so much", "d5npOMwDwNA-01272-00268904-00269230": "uh like so much literature", "d5npOMwDwNA-01273-00269231-00269575": "on how avocados or quinoa", "d5npOMwDwNA-01274-00269576-00269758": "farming in a in a very industrialized", "d5npOMwDwNA-01275-00269759-00269951": "way is harming", "d5npOMwDwNA-01276-00269952-00270191": "land and is harming indigenous people in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01277-00270192-00270327": "different parts of latin america and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01278-00270328-00270567": "africa", "d5npOMwDwNA-01279-00270568-00270927": "a couple of chapters and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01280-00270928-00271223": "this is because i'm closely to the end", "d5npOMwDwNA-01281-00271224-00271351": "shortly", "d5npOMwDwNA-01282-00271352-00271599": "very very closely to the end a couple of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01283-00271600-00271830": "things that i would have liked to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01284-00271831-00272039": "see highlighted a little bit more was", "d5npOMwDwNA-01285-00272040-00272279": "the was the chapter on artism by john", "d5npOMwDwNA-01286-00272280-00272406": "jordan", "d5npOMwDwNA-01287-00272407-00272623": "in which because i don't know if you all", "d5npOMwDwNA-01288-00272624-00272767": "have heard about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01289-00272768-00273151": "earlier this week the murder of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01290-00273152-00273430": "george floyd in in minneapolis an", "d5npOMwDwNA-01291-00273431-00273582": "african-american man", "d5npOMwDwNA-01292-00273583-00273782": "because of police excesses and all the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01293-00273783-00274023": "protests that has sparked over the week", "d5npOMwDwNA-01294-00274024-00274239": "and how who are the people who are able", "d5npOMwDwNA-01295-00274240-00274399": "to do these kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01296-00274400-00274751": "artisms so so it was not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01297-00274752-00274934": "i found it a bit lacking that we we do", "d5npOMwDwNA-01298-00274935-00275063": "not talk about this that who are the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01299-00275064-00275158": "people who can be", "d5npOMwDwNA-01300-00275159-00275423": "on the front who are the people who can", "d5npOMwDwNA-01301-00275424-00275567": "who can put their bodies and do", "d5npOMwDwNA-01302-00275568-00275655": "blockadia", "d5npOMwDwNA-01303-00275656-00275823": "and this i also talk from my personal", "d5npOMwDwNA-01304-00275824-00275943": "experience because when i was in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01305-00275944-00276110": "climate camp", "d5npOMwDwNA-01306-00276111-00276423": "uh i i just couldn't", "d5npOMwDwNA-01307-00276424-00276599": "take the chance of going out although i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01308-00276600-00276863": "really wanted to go and stop the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01309-00276864-00277103": "stop the mining from from happening and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01310-00277104-00277230": "so these are questions which", "d5npOMwDwNA-01311-00277231-00277447": "needs to be needs to be highlighted", "d5npOMwDwNA-01312-00277448-00277591": "again and again when we're talking about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01313-00277592-00277710": "to other people who could be on the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01314-00277711-00277782": "forefront", "d5npOMwDwNA-01315-00277783-00277919": "and this is something which is mentioned", "d5npOMwDwNA-01316-00277920-00278095": "very explicitly in the chapter on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01317-00278096-00278334": "on care revolution in which they talk", "d5npOMwDwNA-01318-00278335-00278503": "about that we are limiting this chapter", "d5npOMwDwNA-01319-00278504-00278567": "on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01320-00278568-00278734": "germany switzerland australia and we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01321-00278735-00278958": "understand the need to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01322-00278959-00279127": "need to have a broader perspective but", "d5npOMwDwNA-01323-00279128-00279255": "we don't do it here because of this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01324-00279256-00279455": "reason even something like that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01325-00279456-00279767": "would have been would have been good", "d5npOMwDwNA-01326-00279768-00280071": "uh and one last point what i really", "d5npOMwDwNA-01327-00280072-00280223": "what i really started thinking about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01328-00280224-00280455": "after reading all these chapters", "d5npOMwDwNA-01329-00280456-00280687": "was that there's so much of linkages not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01330-00280688-00280934": "just with degrowth but within themselves", "d5npOMwDwNA-01331-00280935-00281167": "on how the list of initiatives in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01332-00281168-00281334": "solidarity economy talks about open", "d5npOMwDwNA-01333-00281335-00281495": "software and eco villages and food", "d5npOMwDwNA-01334-00281496-00281615": "sovereignty", "d5npOMwDwNA-01335-00281616-00281782": "and how food sovereignty talks with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01336-00281783-00281967": "transition initiatives and permaculture", "d5npOMwDwNA-01337-00281968-00282134": "and repair gardens and i was wondering", "d5npOMwDwNA-01338-00282135-00282175": "if", "d5npOMwDwNA-01339-00282176-00282439": "at a future project instead of all the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01340-00282440-00282679": "projects with the growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01341-00282680-00282879": "we could have like a like a collection", "d5npOMwDwNA-01342-00282880-00283071": "of all the all the movements with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01343-00283072-00283263": "themselves and seeing how that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01344-00283264-00283519": "broader lines can be made and yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-01345-00283520-00283663": "that's it i really enjoyed reading the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01346-00283664-00283719": "book", "d5npOMwDwNA-01347-00283720-00284079": "it was fantastic", "d5npOMwDwNA-01348-00284080-00284351": "thank you very much prototy also for the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01349-00284352-00284534": "critical perspectives highlighting kind", "d5npOMwDwNA-01350-00284535-00284663": "of like some of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01351-00284664-00284975": "um the blind spots so to speak in some", "d5npOMwDwNA-01352-00284976-00285079": "of the chapters", "d5npOMwDwNA-01353-00285080-00285279": "and obviously it's very important to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01354-00285280-00285463": "kind of like critically self-reflect", "d5npOMwDwNA-01355-00285464-00285671": "also in social movements to to move", "d5npOMwDwNA-01356-00285672-00285919": "forward towards emancipation", "d5npOMwDwNA-01357-00285920-00286239": "we are a bit over time so um rather than", "d5npOMwDwNA-01358-00286240-00286279": "doing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01359-00286280-00286543": "a long second round i would invite you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01360-00286544-00286654": "to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01361-00286655-00286975": "each speak maximum one minute so it's", "d5npOMwDwNA-01362-00286976-00287134": "basically one longer sentence or", "d5npOMwDwNA-01363-00287135-00287447": "a couple of sentences on the question um", "d5npOMwDwNA-01364-00287448-00287623": "how should the agenda of your social", "d5npOMwDwNA-01365-00287624-00287782": "movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-01366-00287783-00287967": "change in light of the recent", "d5npOMwDwNA-01367-00287968-00288191": "experiences after writing the chapter", "d5npOMwDwNA-01368-00288192-00288479": "maybe also the covet 19 experience and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01369-00288480-00288534": "we'll", "d5npOMwDwNA-01370-00288535-00288967": "start again with tacho", "d5npOMwDwNA-01371-00288968-00289182": "i essentially think i said that before", "d5npOMwDwNA-01372-00289183-00289358": "our traditional agenda used to be that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01373-00289359-00289534": "we are gonna try shut down that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01374-00289535-00289663": "destroys the climate", "d5npOMwDwNA-01375-00289664-00289943": "stuff that creates climate injustice now", "d5npOMwDwNA-01376-00289944-00290071": "we have understood", "d5npOMwDwNA-01377-00290072-00290254": "that which is maybe not surprising even", "d5npOMwDwNA-01378-00290255-00290406": "if you're a movement romantic", "d5npOMwDwNA-01379-00290407-00290634": "government action around the world", "d5npOMwDwNA-01380-00290635-00290758": "multi-sectoral", "d5npOMwDwNA-01381-00290759-00290943": "can achieve much greater shutdown", "d5npOMwDwNA-01382-00290944-00291095": "effects than we could ever hope to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01383-00291096-00291175": "achieve", "d5npOMwDwNA-01384-00291176-00291334": "which seems to me that the current", "d5npOMwDwNA-01385-00291335-00291495": "strategy and i'm going to say this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01386-00291496-00291743": "100 times from now has to be that we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01387-00291744-00291815": "need to keep", "d5npOMwDwNA-01388-00291816-00292103": "all our forces ready once we can be on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01389-00292104-00292375": "the street again to keep shut down", "d5npOMwDwNA-01390-00292376-00292519": "because if they start breaking their", "d5npOMwDwNA-01391-00292520-00292719": "corona rules to start producing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01392-00292720-00292806": "cars again", "d5npOMwDwNA-01393-00292807-00292991": "which we have so many and i just", "d5npOMwDwNA-01394-00292992-00293143": "wanted to say that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01395-00293144-00293327": "if they start breaking their own rules", "d5npOMwDwNA-01396-00293328-00293495": "to do completely pointless if they", "d5npOMwDwNA-01397-00293496-00293695": "can produce cars but i can't go to a gay", "d5npOMwDwNA-01398-00293696-00293791": "sex club here", "d5npOMwDwNA-01399-00293792-00293919": "that means that we're going to put all", "d5npOMwDwNA-01400-00293920-00294110": "our bodies on the street to prevent", "d5npOMwDwNA-01401-00294111-00294351": "the resumption of car production because", "d5npOMwDwNA-01402-00294352-00294471": "we can break the rules with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01403-00294472-00294575": "justification", "d5npOMwDwNA-01404-00294576-00294887": "they're breaking them for profit", "d5npOMwDwNA-01405-00294888-00295247": "thank you very much juliana", "d5npOMwDwNA-01406-00295248-00295391": "um i just want to say something", "d5npOMwDwNA-01407-00295392-00295606": "undercover crisis and that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01408-00295607-00295847": "of course for the on the perspective of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01409-00295848-00295999": "the climate movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-01410-00296000-00296206": "there is a lot of also positive aspects", "d5npOMwDwNA-01411-00296207-00296391": "but for the food sovereignty movement", "d5npOMwDwNA-01412-00296392-00296558": "and also for the members of biacombe", "d5npOMwDwNA-01413-00296559-00296719": "cena there had been a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01414-00296720-00297023": "really hard challenges", "d5npOMwDwNA-01415-00297024-00297358": "and people who are", "d5npOMwDwNA-01416-00297359-00297582": "who didn't know how to access food", "d5npOMwDwNA-01417-00297583-00297671": "especially in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01418-00297672-00298095": "in countries like india south africa or", "d5npOMwDwNA-01419-00298096-00298406": "had a lot of contact with like", "d5npOMwDwNA-01420-00298407-00298751": "a lot of um military", "d5npOMwDwNA-01421-00298752-00299087": "and police forces to do who forced them", "d5npOMwDwNA-01422-00299088-00299127": "to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01423-00299128-00299495": "to just remove to destroy even their", "d5npOMwDwNA-01424-00299496-00299895": "um products and what i want to say", "d5npOMwDwNA-01425-00299896-00300391": "is what we now witness witnesses is that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01426-00300392-00300639": "what kind of work is really important in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01427-00300640-00300758": "our society", "d5npOMwDwNA-01428-00300759-00300951": "and that had been of course the care", "d5npOMwDwNA-01429-00300952-00301215": "sector the health sector the food sector", "d5npOMwDwNA-01430-00301216-00301519": "and and there we meet with what that you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01431-00301520-00301567": "said", "d5npOMwDwNA-01432-00301568-00301767": "and there are a lot of industries we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01433-00301768-00301895": "really don't need", "d5npOMwDwNA-01434-00301896-00302079": "and i think this is more the discussion", "d5npOMwDwNA-01435-00302080-00302239": "we should be", "d5npOMwDwNA-01436-00302240-00302519": "focused on than to say well there are so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01437-00302520-00302558": "many", "d5npOMwDwNA-01438-00302559-00302895": "positive aspects on the kovit crisis", "d5npOMwDwNA-01439-00302896-00303063": "but i think that's what you also wanted", "d5npOMwDwNA-01440-00303064-00303454": "to set that yeah yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-01441-00303455-00303687": "moving on to gorina yeah i feel a bit", "d5npOMwDwNA-01442-00303688-00303839": "strange talking here for the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01443-00303840-00304023": "girls perspective since we had a digress", "d5npOMwDwNA-01444-00304024-00304199": "conference and we are somehow all", "d5npOMwDwNA-01445-00304200-00304503": "here for the degrees perspective um and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01446-00304504-00304671": "also i was so busy listening to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01447-00304672-00304854": "tasia and jirana that i couldn't really", "d5npOMwDwNA-01448-00304855-00304975": "think of any answer", "d5npOMwDwNA-01449-00304976-00305230": "but i think yeah i mean there's two", "d5npOMwDwNA-01450-00305231-00305310": "things of this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01451-00305311-00305575": "uh crisis right now and that one and it", "d5npOMwDwNA-01452-00305576-00305663": "shows us that we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01453-00305664-00305815": "all humans and they want to help each", "d5npOMwDwNA-01454-00305816-00305967": "other but on the other end it shows that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01455-00305968-00306006": "they're", "d5npOMwDwNA-01456-00306007-00306327": "it's so unjust and they i mean", "d5npOMwDwNA-01457-00306328-00306591": "the problems that we had before just", "d5npOMwDwNA-01458-00306592-00306767": "getting worse i mean except for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01459-00306768-00307127": "less um emissions right now but", "d5npOMwDwNA-01460-00307128-00307430": "i think you all know that um there's", "d5npOMwDwNA-01461-00307431-00307639": "very strong forces pushing for back to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01462-00307640-00307743": "normal and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01463-00307744-00308023": "normal was the problem right so i don't", "d5npOMwDwNA-01464-00308024-00308095": "yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-01465-00308096-00308367": "i'll leave it at this i think um i think", "d5npOMwDwNA-01466-00308368-00308543": "there's a panel actually on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01467-00308544-00308782": "degrowth and covet and i think you will", "d5npOMwDwNA-01468-00308783-00309343": "hear a lot there", "d5npOMwDwNA-01469-00309344-00309606": "thank you very much um not being an", "d5npOMwDwNA-01470-00309607-00309703": "author but still", "d5npOMwDwNA-01471-00309704-00309967": "how would you um write the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-01472-00309968-00310047": "differently", "d5npOMwDwNA-01473-00310048-00310367": "in the recent experience from the last", "d5npOMwDwNA-01474-00310368-00311006": "couple of years", "d5npOMwDwNA-01475-00311007-00311375": "no i i really think it's a very", "d5npOMwDwNA-01476-00311376-00311676": "unique contribution and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01477-00311677-00311823": "[Music]", "d5npOMwDwNA-01478-00311824-00312110": "and the only the only thing which i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01479-00312111-00312254": "would have liked to see more would have", "d5npOMwDwNA-01480-00312255-00312351": "been", "d5npOMwDwNA-01481-00312352-00312663": "to see more discussions of the different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01482-00312664-00312734": "movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-01483-00312735-00313039": "not just but among themselves", "d5npOMwDwNA-01484-00313040-00313287": "but i can imagine this was a this was a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01485-00313288-00313454": "lot of work", "d5npOMwDwNA-01486-00313455-00313623": "to collect everything together and a lot", "d5npOMwDwNA-01487-00313624-00314119": "of discussions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01488-00314120-00314327": "thanks very much and indeed um this book", "d5npOMwDwNA-01489-00314328-00314543": "is only in the project's only a start", "d5npOMwDwNA-01490-00314544-00314799": "of a much broader discussion that is an", "d5npOMwDwNA-01491-00314800-00314887": "ongoing debate", "d5npOMwDwNA-01492-00314888-00315063": "um that is also happening at these", "d5npOMwDwNA-01493-00315064-00315199": "conferences and other many other", "d5npOMwDwNA-01494-00315200-00315334": "gatherings", "d5npOMwDwNA-01495-00315335-00315558": "so we now have a lot of questions from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01496-00315559-00315719": "the audience", "d5npOMwDwNA-01497-00315720-00316023": "and nina will guide us through some of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01498-00316024-00316343": "them", "d5npOMwDwNA-01499-00316344-00316575": "yeah thank you so much for being active", "d5npOMwDwNA-01500-00316576-00316687": "on the chat and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01501-00316688-00316871": "putting your questions so martijn and i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01502-00316872-00317063": "have been discussing in the private chat", "d5npOMwDwNA-01503-00317064-00317239": "if we now ask you to turn on your mic", "d5npOMwDwNA-01504-00317240-00317503": "and video and i think actually what", "d5npOMwDwNA-01505-00317504-00317647": "might be better i just read them out", "d5npOMwDwNA-01506-00317648-00317703": "because", "d5npOMwDwNA-01507-00317704-00317934": "you we won't be able to put them all to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01508-00317935-00318151": "you and i think it's maybe better i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01509-00318152-00318358": "put the cluster question that i formed", "d5npOMwDwNA-01510-00318359-00318519": "of a couple of your comments then giving", "d5npOMwDwNA-01511-00318520-00318727": "the floor to some one person and he or", "d5npOMwDwNA-01512-00318728-00318799": "she puts his", "d5npOMwDwNA-01513-00318800-00319110": "or her question and also i think this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01514-00319111-00319279": "might be a little bit technical issues", "d5npOMwDwNA-01515-00319280-00319399": "you probably take the question", "d5npOMwDwNA-01516-00319400-00319647": "takes twice the time so i hope that's", "d5npOMwDwNA-01517-00319648-00319791": "okay for you since we're a super large", "d5npOMwDwNA-01518-00319792-00319958": "session anyways with a hundred people it", "d5npOMwDwNA-01519-00319959-00320119": "would only touch a couple of people", "d5npOMwDwNA-01520-00320120-00320406": "being to everybody else who speak so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01521-00320407-00320454": "there's", "d5npOMwDwNA-01522-00320455-00320719": "one complex of questions was around", "d5npOMwDwNA-01523-00320720-00320934": "understandings and misunderstandings", "d5npOMwDwNA-01524-00320935-00321295": "of degrowth and i would put those", "d5npOMwDwNA-01525-00321296-00321510": "particularly to karina and maybe", "d5npOMwDwNA-01526-00321511-00321623": "matthias", "d5npOMwDwNA-01527-00321624-00321943": "which is um if the growth is not about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01528-00321944-00322087": "the reduction of gdp", "d5npOMwDwNA-01529-00322088-00322247": "and related material and energy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01530-00322248-00322399": "throughput how is it different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01531-00322400-00322679": "to a growth and then that question", "d5npOMwDwNA-01532-00322680-00322767": "linked to that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01533-00322768-00322951": "grenade rotating which is about good and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01534-00322952-00323191": "bad examples in the world of degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01535-00323192-00323375": "there was a question about venezuela who", "d5npOMwDwNA-01536-00323376-00323543": "has put in the strategies", "d5npOMwDwNA-01537-00323544-00323863": "of um well i'll read out", "d5npOMwDwNA-01538-00323864-00324030": "not my words the idea from the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01539-00324031-00324206": "government was a full serenity", "d5npOMwDwNA-01540-00324207-00324415": "food included the idea of collectives", "d5npOMwDwNA-01541-00324416-00324587": "got imposed and nationalized", "d5npOMwDwNA-01542-00324588-00324823": "nationalizations happened however the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01543-00324824-00324887": "government", "d5npOMwDwNA-01544-00324888-00325223": "shows the way a populist regime now", "d5npOMwDwNA-01545-00325224-00325471": "we know the situation when it's the with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01546-00325472-00325543": "starving", "d5npOMwDwNA-01547-00325544-00325823": "population so is that the growth and is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01548-00325824-00325982": "that good", "d5npOMwDwNA-01549-00325983-00326175": "and maybe linked to that also what kind", "d5npOMwDwNA-01550-00326176-00326287": "of good examples", "d5npOMwDwNA-01551-00326288-00326543": "of degrowth we have and that leads to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01552-00326544-00326703": "the second sector that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01553-00326704-00326958": "tajiu wanted to answer to which is can", "d5npOMwDwNA-01554-00326959-00327119": "we actually", "d5npOMwDwNA-01555-00327120-00327375": "work for d growth in a capitalist system", "d5npOMwDwNA-01556-00327376-00327567": "and where are the contradictions in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01557-00327568-00327671": "there", "d5npOMwDwNA-01558-00327672-00328015": "and also um what's the energy diet we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01559-00328016-00328254": "have if we want to push 100", "d5npOMwDwNA-01560-00328255-00328606": "renewables while juliana was speaking in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01561-00328607-00328727": "the beginning there's a little debate", "d5npOMwDwNA-01562-00328728-00328919": "that developed on what are the sectors", "d5npOMwDwNA-01563-00328920-00329071": "that we should push for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01564-00329072-00329254": "and what are the sectors we should take", "d5npOMwDwNA-01565-00329255-00329503": "down and you already said well we now", "d5npOMwDwNA-01566-00329504-00329791": "saw with covet that what's important", "d5npOMwDwNA-01567-00329792-00330030": "do you think we should um degrow", "d5npOMwDwNA-01568-00330031-00330199": "industrial farming in favor of food", "d5npOMwDwNA-01569-00330200-00330351": "sovereignty and maybe also", "d5npOMwDwNA-01570-00330352-00330734": "what are kind of strategies to get there", "d5npOMwDwNA-01571-00330735-00331039": "and then a question to either matthias", "d5npOMwDwNA-01572-00331040-00331215": "or corinna is about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01573-00331216-00331375": "things that we missed in the book that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01574-00331376-00331527": "was also one of the last questions you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01575-00331528-00331687": "get says that matthias", "d5npOMwDwNA-01576-00331688-00331839": "and for example are there any other", "d5npOMwDwNA-01577-00331840-00332054": "movement struggles not feature in this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01578-00332055-00332239": "book that you think the growthers should", "d5npOMwDwNA-01579-00332240-00332310": "connect with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01580-00332311-00332575": "eg prison police and military", "d5npOMwDwNA-01581-00332576-00332830": "neurodiversity and disability rights", "d5npOMwDwNA-01582-00332831-00333015": "i can re-put those questions to you in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01583-00333016-00333230": "the chat i mean that's repetitive", "d5npOMwDwNA-01584-00333231-00333471": "and i would ask you to not answer all", "d5npOMwDwNA-01585-00333472-00333647": "the questions everyone because that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01586-00333648-00333791": "takes forever but really answer the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01587-00333792-00333951": "questions in the way that i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01588-00333952-00334206": "gave it to you and and i would like to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01589-00334207-00334295": "start out", "d5npOMwDwNA-01590-00334296-00334527": "the way i put it with corinna and then", "d5npOMwDwNA-01591-00334528-00334703": "maybe additionally matthias and then", "d5npOMwDwNA-01592-00334704-00334951": "taughty on this missus understandings", "d5npOMwDwNA-01593-00334952-00335254": "and understandings of degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01594-00335255-00335454": "yeah i can maybe start with this gdp uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-01595-00335455-00335591": "material throughput thing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01596-00335592-00335951": "so i think what i said it's not only", "d5npOMwDwNA-01597-00335952-00336215": "about reducing gp but that reduced", "d5npOMwDwNA-01598-00336216-00336391": "reduction of gdp might", "d5npOMwDwNA-01599-00336392-00336575": "well be a consequence of de-gross", "d5npOMwDwNA-01600-00336576-00336727": "politics and then", "d5npOMwDwNA-01601-00336728-00336943": "i did say that degress is about reducing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01602-00336944-00337071": "material throughput", "d5npOMwDwNA-01603-00337072-00337303": "uh in the global news so i i think maybe", "d5npOMwDwNA-01604-00337304-00337399": "that got lost", "d5npOMwDwNA-01605-00337400-00337678": "um does that answer the question", "d5npOMwDwNA-01606-00337679-00338110": "matthias do you want to add something", "d5npOMwDwNA-01607-00338111-00338415": "maybe a bit because i think um", "d5npOMwDwNA-01608-00338416-00338671": "draw is not about the reduction of gdp", "d5npOMwDwNA-01609-00338672-00338775": "that's not the goal", "d5npOMwDwNA-01610-00338776-00339015": "what we want is a good life for all", "d5npOMwDwNA-01611-00339016-00339206": "within planetary boundaries to speak", "d5npOMwDwNA-01612-00339207-00339319": "broadly", "d5npOMwDwNA-01613-00339320-00339510": "and this is only possible within the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01614-00339511-00339647": "countries of the global north", "d5npOMwDwNA-01615-00339648-00339910": "with a very strong reduction of energy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01616-00339911-00340095": "and material throughput", "d5npOMwDwNA-01617-00340096-00340343": "and this will bring as a side product", "d5npOMwDwNA-01618-00340344-00340630": "also a reduction of gdp", "d5npOMwDwNA-01619-00340631-00340847": "and one key difference to an a growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01620-00340848-00340951": "perspective is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01621-00340952-00341182": "that we think it's important before", "d5npOMwDwNA-01622-00341183-00341382": "taking on these reforms and these", "d5npOMwDwNA-01623-00341383-00341623": "radical transformations to think about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01624-00341624-00341815": "the growth dependency", "d5npOMwDwNA-01625-00341816-00342103": "within our economics and social systems", "d5npOMwDwNA-01626-00342104-00342247": "because otherwise we will never get", "d5npOMwDwNA-01627-00342248-00342319": "there", "d5npOMwDwNA-01628-00342320-00342471": "we live in a society that is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01629-00342472-00342647": "fundamentally dependent on economic", "d5npOMwDwNA-01630-00342648-00342830": "growth on many different levels", "d5npOMwDwNA-01631-00342831-00343006": "and so the welfare state needs to be", "d5npOMwDwNA-01632-00343007-00343278": "transformed to be able to deal with this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01633-00343279-00343599": "situation of a shrinking gdp and we can", "d5npOMwDwNA-01634-00343600-00343751": "go on for all the different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01635-00343752-00343943": "kind of like aspects of this growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01636-00343944-00344071": "dependency", "d5npOMwDwNA-01637-00344072-00344263": "so it is key to break the growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01638-00344264-00344487": "dependency to actually achieve", "d5npOMwDwNA-01639-00344488-00344815": "an a growth overcome the growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01640-00344816-00345087": "um kind of like overcome is it overcome", "d5npOMwDwNA-01641-00345088-00345239": "a situation in which", "d5npOMwDwNA-01642-00345240-00345534": "um growth is kind of like the only means", "d5npOMwDwNA-01643-00345535-00345887": "to create stability in our society", "d5npOMwDwNA-01644-00345888-00346110": "the crisis now really shows how it", "d5npOMwDwNA-01645-00346111-00346263": "depends", "d5npOMwDwNA-01646-00346264-00346527": "so it wouldn't lead on property and the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01647-00346528-00346606": "question about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01648-00346607-00346806": "how can we relate to growth and growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01649-00346807-00346975": "and venezuela and what are maybe good", "d5npOMwDwNA-01650-00346976-00347078": "examples about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01651-00347079-00347695": "growth about degrowth um in the world", "d5npOMwDwNA-01652-00347696-00347943": "okay one point to add to the last", "d5npOMwDwNA-01653-00347944-00348095": "question is there is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01654-00348096-00348319": "there is this uh there's this youtube", "d5npOMwDwNA-01655-00348320-00348567": "video and also a lot of discussion", "d5npOMwDwNA-01656-00348568-00348799": "or like some article exchanges between", "d5npOMwDwNA-01657-00348800-00348991": "your ghost khalees and geron vanderburgh", "d5npOMwDwNA-01658-00348992-00349030": "on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01659-00349031-00349247": "a growth degree debates so there's a lot", "d5npOMwDwNA-01660-00349248-00349334": "of literature", "d5npOMwDwNA-01661-00349335-00349503": "you can look at that and see what are", "d5npOMwDwNA-01662-00349504-00349639": "where where are the positionalities", "d5npOMwDwNA-01663-00349640-00349767": "coming from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01664-00349768-00350078": "in terms of venezuela and in terms of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01665-00350079-00350230": "what happens when nationalization", "d5npOMwDwNA-01666-00350231-00350391": "happens", "d5npOMwDwNA-01667-00350392-00350510": "so i'm not going to speak a lot about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01668-00350511-00350687": "venezuela because i don't know enough to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01669-00350688-00350839": "talk about it", "d5npOMwDwNA-01670-00350840-00351023": "but in the indian context in the context", "d5npOMwDwNA-01671-00351024-00351254": "of let's say coal because that's that's", "d5npOMwDwNA-01672-00351255-00351423": "what i work on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01673-00351424-00351710": "coal is nationalized in india and coal", "d5npOMwDwNA-01674-00351711-00352015": "india limited is the highest", "d5npOMwDwNA-01675-00352016-00352358": "earning company of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01676-00352359-00352734": "of coal national coal in the world", "d5npOMwDwNA-01677-00352735-00353110": "and and that is maybe in some sense", "d5npOMwDwNA-01678-00353111-00353263": "people can be way better than", "d5npOMwDwNA-01679-00353264-00353527": "private companies coming in and doing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01680-00353528-00353767": "much much more destruction", "d5npOMwDwNA-01681-00353768-00354087": "but nationalization doesn't", "d5npOMwDwNA-01682-00354088-00354310": "in a way mean sovereignty because it's", "d5npOMwDwNA-01683-00354311-00354463": "still people sitting in positions of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01684-00354464-00354543": "power", "d5npOMwDwNA-01685-00354544-00354823": "in the capitals deciding things and that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01686-00354824-00354878": "is not the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01687-00354879-00355303": "that is not definition of sovereignty so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01688-00355304-00355654": "so even if this even if economic growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01689-00355655-00355854": "reduced in venezuela", "d5npOMwDwNA-01690-00355855-00356015": "and population is starving that is not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01691-00356016-00356167": "the definition of good life then no", "d5npOMwDwNA-01692-00356168-00356254": "because", "d5npOMwDwNA-01693-00356255-00356527": "firstly from the question people were", "d5npOMwDwNA-01694-00356528-00356630": "not given", "d5npOMwDwNA-01695-00356631-00356871": "the choice to choose what to do and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01696-00356872-00356991": "secondly they", "d5npOMwDwNA-01697-00356992-00357247": "they are not fulfilling the basic needs", "d5npOMwDwNA-01698-00357248-00357406": "of what we understand as good life so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01699-00357407-00357527": "that is not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01700-00357528-00357871": "in any way an example of deep growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01701-00357872-00358182": "good examples of d growth i can direct", "d5npOMwDwNA-01702-00358183-00358303": "you to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01703-00358304-00358606": "to this website called which ashish", "d5npOMwDwNA-01704-00358607-00358703": "kothadi", "d5npOMwDwNA-01705-00358704-00358934": "and his team in karpov diksha works on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01706-00358935-00359134": "where they collect different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01707-00359135-00359382": "initiatives grassroot ideas and activism", "d5npOMwDwNA-01708-00359383-00359551": "from different parts of india", "d5npOMwDwNA-01709-00359552-00359751": "which work on this concept of radical", "d5npOMwDwNA-01710-00359752-00359958": "ecological democracy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01711-00359959-00360127": "which is very close to what degrade", "d5npOMwDwNA-01712-00360128-00360327": "talks about and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01713-00360328-00360623": "have multiple examples of how people", "d5npOMwDwNA-01714-00360624-00360758": "from the lowest caste", "d5npOMwDwNA-01715-00360759-00360919": "in the south of india are working on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01716-00360920-00361078": "seed banks people in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01717-00361079-00361271": "urban places are working on composting", "d5npOMwDwNA-01718-00361272-00361471": "different different examples", "d5npOMwDwNA-01719-00361472-00361678": "women's collectives workers collectives", "d5npOMwDwNA-01720-00361679-00361830": "and how", "d5npOMwDwNA-01721-00361831-00362127": "how they are trying to trying to make", "d5npOMwDwNA-01722-00362128-00362367": "sure that they have decentralized among", "d5npOMwDwNA-01723-00362368-00362575": "democracy they have solidarity they have", "d5npOMwDwNA-01724-00362576-00362758": "configurability", "d5npOMwDwNA-01725-00362759-00363087": "and and yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-01726-00363088-00363278": "they have the rights to decide what to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01727-00363279-00363439": "do with their resources and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01728-00363440-00363734": "how to how to jointly decide how that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01729-00363735-00363887": "works", "d5npOMwDwNA-01730-00363888-00364143": "yeah those are my answers there was the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01731-00364144-00364278": "question if you could write the website", "d5npOMwDwNA-01732-00364279-00364367": "in the chat now", "d5npOMwDwNA-01733-00364368-00364582": "people are really interested in and i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01734-00364583-00364782": "worked on to tell you we wanted to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01735-00364783-00364943": "respond also to this paradox of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01736-00364944-00365191": "capitalism and the growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01737-00365192-00365527": "and maybe also on the last question look", "d5npOMwDwNA-01738-00365528-00365727": "how should we engage with the green new", "d5npOMwDwNA-01739-00365728-00365910": "deal or not engage with it or what to do", "d5npOMwDwNA-01740-00365911-00366367": "with it", "d5npOMwDwNA-01741-00366368-00366623": "right i am now unmuted um okay so first", "d5npOMwDwNA-01742-00366624-00366751": "of all the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01743-00366752-00367110": "question of the um how can there be", "d5npOMwDwNA-01744-00367111-00367295": "degrowth in a capitalist society", "d5npOMwDwNA-01745-00367296-00367630": "paradox it's not at all a paradox life", "d5npOMwDwNA-01746-00367631-00368063": "is not totally subsumed under capitalism", "d5npOMwDwNA-01747-00368064-00368239": "like the total subsumption of life under", "d5npOMwDwNA-01748-00368240-00368454": "capitalism is at worst a horizon state", "d5npOMwDwNA-01749-00368455-00368639": "it is never a real state", "d5npOMwDwNA-01750-00368640-00368927": "life constantly produces interactions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01751-00368928-00369039": "that are not governed", "d5npOMwDwNA-01752-00369040-00369343": "by the cash by the commodity nexus when", "d5npOMwDwNA-01753-00369344-00369487": "i interact with my husband when i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01754-00369488-00369647": "interact with friends when i interact", "d5npOMwDwNA-01755-00369648-00369847": "with comrades in movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-01756-00369848-00370254": "we are not governed by the cash nexus", "d5npOMwDwNA-01757-00370255-00370534": "this is not a commodity interaction as a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01758-00370535-00370639": "result", "d5npOMwDwNA-01759-00370640-00370806": "we have to remember this look at like", "d5npOMwDwNA-01760-00370807-00371054": "the italian post-operative literature", "d5npOMwDwNA-01761-00371055-00371254": "don't look at german theory like", "d5npOMwDwNA-01762-00371255-00371463": "capitalism is not total", "d5npOMwDwNA-01763-00371464-00371782": "if capitalism were total i have to like", "d5npOMwDwNA-01764-00371783-00371967": "take money from my husband every time we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01765-00371968-00372054": "have sex", "d5npOMwDwNA-01766-00372055-00372199": "which would be totally inefficient and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01767-00372200-00372399": "not really sexy but it's basically just", "d5npOMwDwNA-01768-00372400-00372502": "to show", "d5npOMwDwNA-01769-00372503-00372654": "and i'm sorry i draw from these kinds of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01770-00372655-00372887": "examples but it's i i'm kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01771-00372888-00373078": "focused on sex and bodies as one of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01772-00373079-00373247": "places where our lives are different", "d5npOMwDwNA-01773-00373248-00373406": "from capital accumulation except if", "d5npOMwDwNA-01774-00373407-00373519": "you're a sex one", "d5npOMwDwNA-01775-00373520-00373647": "because so much that we do with our", "d5npOMwDwNA-01776-00373648-00373847": "bodies is not bought and sold", "d5npOMwDwNA-01777-00373848-00374063": "in friendships in love relationships", "d5npOMwDwNA-01778-00374064-00374206": "therefore of course", "d5npOMwDwNA-01779-00374207-00374454": "life can produce degrowth it is in fact", "d5npOMwDwNA-01780-00374455-00374534": "the moments", "d5npOMwDwNA-01781-00374535-00374854": "when capital imposes itself on life saps", "d5npOMwDwNA-01782-00374855-00375047": "and drains its autonomy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01783-00375048-00375263": "and makes it become functional for this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01784-00375264-00375423": "insanity that we think of as our", "d5npOMwDwNA-01785-00375424-00375543": "economic system", "d5npOMwDwNA-01786-00375544-00375775": "that it looks total but capitalism is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01787-00375776-00375871": "never total", "d5npOMwDwNA-01788-00375872-00376191": "has never been and we could do and life", "d5npOMwDwNA-01789-00376192-00376423": "constantly produces outsides to capital", "d5npOMwDwNA-01790-00376424-00376582": "and that's where we not only draw hope", "d5npOMwDwNA-01791-00376583-00376623": "from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01792-00376624-00376806": "but those are also the bases for our", "d5npOMwDwNA-01793-00376807-00377006": "resistance", "d5npOMwDwNA-01794-00377007-00377223": "secondly i'm sorry i'm a little bit high", "d5npOMwDwNA-01795-00377224-00377343": "on the pathos today but it's a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01796-00377344-00377423": "significant", "d5npOMwDwNA-01797-00377424-00377710": "an important day for me secondly 100", "d5npOMwDwNA-01798-00377711-00377847": "renewable energy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01799-00377848-00378054": "and well now of course we can do that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01800-00378055-00378206": "but you know that you could make", "d5npOMwDwNA-01801-00378207-00378415": "and mike moore just did that you could", "d5npOMwDwNA-01802-00378416-00378591": "do the exact same movie about the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01803-00378592-00378775": "extraction of the raw materials that go", "d5npOMwDwNA-01804-00378776-00378982": "into renewable energy production", "d5npOMwDwNA-01805-00378983-00379206": "as you could do about coal and oil and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01806-00379207-00379295": "gas", "d5npOMwDwNA-01807-00379296-00379534": "if we just at an expanding level of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01808-00379535-00379695": "production and consumption just", "d5npOMwDwNA-01809-00379696-00379878": "changed around that to renewable", "d5npOMwDwNA-01810-00379879-00380102": "energies look at like the the work done", "d5npOMwDwNA-01811-00380103-00380223": "by andreas exner", "d5npOMwDwNA-01812-00380224-00380415": "you you'd have to use so many fossil", "d5npOMwDwNA-01813-00380416-00380567": "fuels and so many resources", "d5npOMwDwNA-01814-00380568-00380767": "that you would definitely cross all", "d5npOMwDwNA-01815-00380768-00380943": "sorts of planetary boundaries", "d5npOMwDwNA-01816-00380944-00381119": "the point is a hundred like renewable", "d5npOMwDwNA-01817-00381120-00381271": "energies don't nothing comes from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01818-00381272-00381382": "nothing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01819-00381383-00381623": "like the materials raw materials that go", "d5npOMwDwNA-01820-00381624-00381799": "into renewable energy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01821-00381800-00381958": "into transforming sun or wind into", "d5npOMwDwNA-01822-00381959-00382143": "renewable energy are also limited", "d5npOMwDwNA-01823-00382144-00382327": "they are mined in places in the terrible", "d5npOMwDwNA-01824-00382328-00382582": "socio social ecological conditions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01825-00382583-00382854": "so therefore a just 100 renewable energy", "d5npOMwDwNA-01826-00382855-00382919": "position", "d5npOMwDwNA-01827-00382920-00383095": "does not take into account the main", "d5npOMwDwNA-01828-00383096-00383327": "problem that you simply cannot have", "d5npOMwDwNA-01829-00383328-00383567": "infinite growth on a finite planet full", "d5npOMwDwNA-01830-00383568-00383702": "stop", "d5npOMwDwNA-01831-00383703-00383999": "last point the green new deal now i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01832-00384000-00384127": "understand that the green new deal is a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01833-00384128-00384295": "really attractive proposition", "d5npOMwDwNA-01834-00384296-00384534": "because it basically says it's it's the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01835-00384535-00384806": "left wing version of the green growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01836-00384807-00385087": "story it's a win-win-win-win-win story", "d5npOMwDwNA-01837-00385088-00385367": "everybody except the one percent loses", "d5npOMwDwNA-01838-00385368-00385591": "but unfortunately and i know this is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01839-00385592-00385734": "controversial given", "d5npOMwDwNA-01840-00385735-00386030": "what we also know about the need to work", "d5npOMwDwNA-01841-00386031-00386087": "at least", "d5npOMwDwNA-01842-00386088-00386430": "engage with trading unions like", "d5npOMwDwNA-01843-00386431-00386623": "one important thing for a de-gauthetic", "d5npOMwDwNA-01844-00386624-00386727": "climate justice perspective in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01845-00386728-00386895": "global north is that stuff has to be", "d5npOMwDwNA-01846-00386896-00387078": "shut down we cannot continue producing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01847-00387079-00387239": "cars in the same way as we've done in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01848-00387240-00387367": "germany before", "d5npOMwDwNA-01849-00387368-00387582": "and the green new deal has a tendency to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01850-00387583-00387687": "produ to promise", "d5npOMwDwNA-01851-00387688-00387830": "everybody that their jobs are going to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01852-00387831-00388158": "be safe and some jobs are just not going", "d5npOMwDwNA-01853-00388159-00388239": "to be safe", "d5npOMwDwNA-01854-00388240-00388623": "if you work in oil in cars in coal in", "d5npOMwDwNA-01855-00388624-00388927": "shale in alberta and tar sands", "d5npOMwDwNA-01856-00388928-00389182": "your job's going to be shut down and if", "d5npOMwDwNA-01857-00389183-00389375": "you don't have a universal basic income", "d5npOMwDwNA-01858-00389376-00389606": "nothing good will quickly come up and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01859-00389607-00389791": "i'm a bit afraid that the green new deal", "d5npOMwDwNA-01860-00389792-00389919": "pushes that idea", "d5npOMwDwNA-01861-00389920-00390095": "that just by investing in a kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01862-00390096-00390254": "green keynesian growth program", "d5npOMwDwNA-01863-00390255-00390502": "we can make it all go away and that is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01864-00390503-00390687": "precisely the lesson that degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01865-00390688-00390751": "teaches", "d5npOMwDwNA-01866-00390752-00391095": "no that's not the case so yes work on", "d5npOMwDwNA-01867-00391096-00391263": "attractive propositions", "d5npOMwDwNA-01868-00391264-00391423": "how to package our story but the green", "d5npOMwDwNA-01869-00391424-00391582": "new deal i think has been too", "d5npOMwDwNA-01870-00391583-00391847": "much captured by trade unions and they", "d5npOMwDwNA-01871-00391848-00392030": "keep every job as it is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01872-00392031-00392343": "um discourse at this point so", "d5npOMwDwNA-01873-00392344-00392639": "i'm skeptical of the green new deal as a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01874-00392640-00392710": "framework", "d5npOMwDwNA-01875-00392711-00392878": "because i've engaged with german trade", "d5npOMwDwNA-01876-00392879-00393071": "unions and they will talk to you and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01877-00393072-00393239": "then they will screw you and in the end", "d5npOMwDwNA-01878-00393240-00393551": "they'll just be part of the growth model", "d5npOMwDwNA-01879-00393552-00393823": "thank you very much tajio um i think", "d5npOMwDwNA-01880-00393824-00394015": "that leads very well to the other set of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01881-00394016-00394167": "questions that was there for juliana", "d5npOMwDwNA-01882-00394168-00394230": "which is", "d5npOMwDwNA-01883-00394231-00394519": "what kind of sectors do need to grow", "d5npOMwDwNA-01884-00394520-00394639": "which the kind of sectors", "d5npOMwDwNA-01885-00394640-00394895": "need to degrow and how could that part", "d5npOMwDwNA-01886-00394896-00394943": "you know", "d5npOMwDwNA-01887-00394944-00395110": "be part of a bigger picture of a social", "d5npOMwDwNA-01888-00395111-00395310": "ecological transformation", "d5npOMwDwNA-01889-00395311-00395623": "yeah well things that just what i wanted", "d5npOMwDwNA-01890-00395624-00395710": "to start with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01891-00395711-00396071": "because um when we just keep on to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01892-00396072-00396334": "like if we want to have whole jobs", "d5npOMwDwNA-01893-00396335-00396415": "inside", "d5npOMwDwNA-01894-00396416-00396558": "certain kind of sectors like the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01895-00396559-00396839": "industrial sector that will not work for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01896-00396840-00397175": "for the for climate reasons but also", "d5npOMwDwNA-01897-00397176-00397430": "for biodiversity and for a lot of other", "d5npOMwDwNA-01898-00397431-00397623": "um ecological boundaries", "d5npOMwDwNA-01899-00397624-00397951": "but of course there are a lot of jobs we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01900-00397952-00398254": "never talk as climate shops like for of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01901-00398255-00398358": "course some people", "d5npOMwDwNA-01902-00398359-00398623": "have the idea of jobs in agriculture", "d5npOMwDwNA-01903-00398624-00398887": "like in a sustainable agriculture", "d5npOMwDwNA-01904-00398888-00399095": "but nobody thinks about jobs in for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01905-00399096-00399278": "example the care sector", "d5npOMwDwNA-01906-00399279-00399567": "those are of course climate jobs and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01907-00399568-00399606": "like", "d5npOMwDwNA-01908-00399607-00399927": "climate positive jobs because that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01909-00399928-00400119": "that's just what we really need that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01910-00400120-00400391": "leads to a good life for all", "d5npOMwDwNA-01911-00400392-00400678": "and that's where we have a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01912-00400679-00400878": "elderly people we have a lot of children", "d5npOMwDwNA-01913-00400879-00400934": "who", "d5npOMwDwNA-01914-00400935-00401310": "just need to have a lot more care", "d5npOMwDwNA-01915-00401311-00401630": "and um when we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01916-00401631-00401830": "like in the food sovereignty movement we", "d5npOMwDwNA-01917-00401831-00402023": "just discuss a lot about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01918-00402024-00402278": "what kind of strategies we need in order", "d5npOMwDwNA-01919-00402279-00402447": "to transform the food", "d5npOMwDwNA-01920-00402448-00402751": "system and now we also had an", "d5npOMwDwNA-01921-00402752-00403110": "a workshop and an utopian world with", "d5npOMwDwNA-01922-00403111-00403871": "together with concept work", "d5npOMwDwNA-01923-00403872-00404167": "are working and this was what came out", "d5npOMwDwNA-01924-00404168-00404230": "there was", "d5npOMwDwNA-01925-00404231-00404630": "wonderful because there are a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01926-00404631-00405047": "more people needed in a sustainable and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01927-00405048-00405367": "ecological agriculture", "d5npOMwDwNA-01928-00405368-00405591": "when we vision it in a way that we want", "d5npOMwDwNA-01929-00405592-00405734": "to have it", "d5npOMwDwNA-01930-00405735-00405975": "and i think this this can also be really", "d5npOMwDwNA-01931-00405976-00406110": "be a powerful", "d5npOMwDwNA-01932-00406111-00406351": "thing in order if we want to transform", "d5npOMwDwNA-01933-00406352-00406582": "the food system if we want to transform", "d5npOMwDwNA-01934-00406583-00406743": "the whole", "d5npOMwDwNA-01935-00406744-00407063": "economy we need to have a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01936-00407064-00407358": "people working in other sectors and this", "d5npOMwDwNA-01937-00407359-00407623": "is also a very feminist argument because", "d5npOMwDwNA-01938-00407624-00407910": "it's a lot of women's like typical", "d5npOMwDwNA-01939-00407911-00408071": "women's jobs who", "d5npOMwDwNA-01940-00408072-00408351": "which need to be pushed and it's even", "d5npOMwDwNA-01941-00408352-00408415": "there are", "d5npOMwDwNA-01942-00408416-00408799": "even a lot of um like researchers who", "d5npOMwDwNA-01943-00408800-00409095": "work on that and really show that for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01944-00409096-00409302": "little regions where you can see well if", "d5npOMwDwNA-01945-00409303-00409471": "you want to go into", "d5npOMwDwNA-01946-00409472-00409743": "sustainable and agricult ecological", "d5npOMwDwNA-01947-00409743-00409830": "agriculture", "d5npOMwDwNA-01948-00409831-00410134": "you have you will have a lot of people", "d5npOMwDwNA-01949-00410135-00410422": "working there on the farm itself but", "d5npOMwDwNA-01950-00410423-00410599": "also in the whole distribution", "d5npOMwDwNA-01951-00410600-00411022": "sector uh and if for example if we go to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01952-00411023-00411239": "supermarkets or whatever those are not", "d5npOMwDwNA-01953-00411239-00411478": "the jobs we want to have but we want to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01954-00411479-00411718": "really transform that in a way that", "d5npOMwDwNA-01955-00411719-00411822": "there are", "d5npOMwDwNA-01956-00411823-00412070": "good quality products produced and also", "d5npOMwDwNA-01957-00412071-00412239": "distributed in a way", "d5npOMwDwNA-01958-00412239-00412574": "that people can get access to it um", "d5npOMwDwNA-01959-00412575-00412807": "and are not pushed away just because", "d5npOMwDwNA-01960-00412808-00412966": "they cannot afford it", "d5npOMwDwNA-01961-00412967-00413255": "and of course this is still our like the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01962-00413256-00413439": "perspective is quite different from a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01963-00413439-00413551": "european", "d5npOMwDwNA-01964-00413552-00413878": "country than from a country from the", "d5npOMwDwNA-01965-00413879-00414159": "global south but i i think we can really", "d5npOMwDwNA-01966-00414160-00414391": "combine those struggles", "d5npOMwDwNA-01967-00414392-00414726": "and just if we want to learn more about", "d5npOMwDwNA-01968-00414727-00415039": "um how the transformation within europe", "d5npOMwDwNA-01969-00415039-00415191": "and also within uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-01970-00415192-00415478": "there's also one example we have from", "d5npOMwDwNA-01971-00415479-00415574": "egypt", "d5npOMwDwNA-01972-00415575-00415822": "how this really works and learn more", "d5npOMwDwNA-01973-00415823-00416022": "from people who are working on these", "d5npOMwDwNA-01974-00416023-00416214": "transitions you can come to our session", "d5npOMwDwNA-01975-00416215-00416526": "on sunday", "d5npOMwDwNA-01976-00416527-00416726": "and just just one more minute if you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01977-00416727-00416966": "want we will also record it and i just", "d5npOMwDwNA-01978-00416967-00416999": "put", "d5npOMwDwNA-01979-00417000-00417303": "put a link in the chat where you can you", "d5npOMwDwNA-01980-00417304-00417374": "will get", "d5npOMwDwNA-01981-00417375-00417695": "all the videos and yeah we start like a", "d5npOMwDwNA-01982-00417696-00417766": "new list", "d5npOMwDwNA-01983-00417767-00417959": "of how to bring together food", "d5npOMwDwNA-01984-00417960-00418287": "sovereignty and d growth", "d5npOMwDwNA-01985-00418288-00418596": "okay thank you so much everyone um", "d5npOMwDwNA-01986-00418597-00418726": "[Applause]", "d5npOMwDwNA-01987-00418727-00418943": "one question which i can also answer and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01988-00418943-00419070": "i don't have to basically give it to", "d5npOMwDwNA-01989-00419071-00419151": "matthias and", "d5npOMwDwNA-01990-00419152-00419351": "winner is the one about who was missing", "d5npOMwDwNA-01991-00419352-00419583": "in the book and definitely i mean i", "d5npOMwDwNA-01992-00419584-00419614": "think", "d5npOMwDwNA-01993-00419615-00419775": "matthias and colonel said that before", "d5npOMwDwNA-01994-00419776-00419991": "that is not a full list at all and for", "d5npOMwDwNA-01995-00419992-00420095": "the list of", "d5npOMwDwNA-01996-00420096-00420351": "movements that we already knew that were", "d5npOMwDwNA-01997-00420352-00420495": "close to us in some way", "d5npOMwDwNA-01998-00420496-00420679": "in that people who were part of the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-01999-00420680-00420831": "proposed to integrate", "d5npOMwDwNA-02000-00420832-00420983": "and then finally it was also people who", "d5npOMwDwNA-02001-00420984-00421143": "were willing to participate in that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02002-00421143-00421343": "project and to write that article we", "d5npOMwDwNA-02003-00421343-00421483": "asked many more but not everyone", "d5npOMwDwNA-02004-00421484-00421607": "participated", "d5npOMwDwNA-02005-00421608-00421887": "and the point that came up with police", "d5npOMwDwNA-02006-00421888-00422079": "and military abolition obviously sorry", "d5npOMwDwNA-02007-00422080-00422214": "for getting that word that's very", "d5npOMwDwNA-02008-00422215-00422327": "important in there", "d5npOMwDwNA-02009-00422328-00422559": "it was also a proposal we had but it was", "d5npOMwDwNA-02010-00422560-00422766": "uh too", "d5npOMwDwNA-02011-00422767-00422943": "late in the process so sorry for missing", "d5npOMwDwNA-02012-00422943-00423127": "out on that and yeah", "d5npOMwDwNA-02013-00423128-00423395": "in the work of concept in the last years", "d5npOMwDwNA-02014-00423396-00423583": "anti-discrimination and the question of", "d5npOMwDwNA-02015-00423584-00423791": "actually who speaks who presents who", "d5npOMwDwNA-02016-00423792-00423959": "writes and who's asked for those kinds", "d5npOMwDwNA-02017-00423960-00424047": "of articles", "d5npOMwDwNA-02018-00424047-00424343": "has become much more important and still", "d5npOMwDwNA-02019-00424343-00424439": "we're not doing", "d5npOMwDwNA-02020-00424439-00424655": "super good in that but i think we would", "d5npOMwDwNA-02021-00424656-00424855": "try to have uh like his perspective that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02022-00424856-00424991": "you said neurodiversity", "d5npOMwDwNA-02023-00424992-00425135": "or maybe from people who are", "d5npOMwDwNA-02024-00425135-00425295": "discriminated and right about that and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02025-00425296-00425447": "not just from their perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-02026-00425447-00425814": "would be bigger yeah and i think with", "d5npOMwDwNA-02027-00425815-00426022": "that i would like to lead to a closing", "d5npOMwDwNA-02028-00426023-00426087": "round", "d5npOMwDwNA-02029-00426088-00426327": "and a lot of the questions that came up", "d5npOMwDwNA-02030-00426328-00426535": "was also", "d5npOMwDwNA-02031-00426535-00426775": "related to where is our strategy", "d5npOMwDwNA-02032-00426776-00426975": "happening so this book tries to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02033-00426976-00427135": "combine movements tries to bring", "d5npOMwDwNA-02034-00427135-00427359": "together movements tries to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02035-00427360-00427607": "create more bonds between the movements", "d5npOMwDwNA-02036-00427608-00427663": "but then", "d5npOMwDwNA-02037-00427664-00427775": "i think there's a very practical", "d5npOMwDwNA-02038-00427776-00428014": "questions where do we do that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02039-00428015-00428151": "and there was a question for example is", "d5npOMwDwNA-02040-00428152-00428295": "this on the national level on the global", "d5npOMwDwNA-02041-00428296-00428359": "level", "d5npOMwDwNA-02042-00428360-00428687": "well where the space is that you you use", "d5npOMwDwNA-02043-00428688-00428910": "maybe but also the questions you the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02044-00428912-00429103": "places you put hope in", "d5npOMwDwNA-02045-00429104-00429318": "and i mean since this is a digital", "d5npOMwDwNA-02046-00429319-00429422": "conference", "d5npOMwDwNA-02047-00429423-00429622": "i think it's also really a space of a", "d5npOMwDwNA-02048-00429623-00429791": "question of do you think we need", "d5npOMwDwNA-02049-00429792-00429959": "the physical space are we waiting for", "d5npOMwDwNA-02050-00429960-00430222": "that what are kind of digital spaces", "d5npOMwDwNA-02051-00430223-00430447": "um yeah i would like to give that to you", "d5npOMwDwNA-02052-00430447-00430527": "before i then", "d5npOMwDwNA-02053-00430528-00430759": "close the session in a couple of minutes", "d5npOMwDwNA-02054-00430760-00430959": "and maybe to not always go in the same", "d5npOMwDwNA-02055-00430960-00431007": "order", "d5npOMwDwNA-02056-00431008-00431310": "we start with bertotti", "d5npOMwDwNA-02057-00431312-00431518": "and then juliana and then corinna and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02058-00431519-00431991": "then", "d5npOMwDwNA-02059-00431992-00432255": "so in terms of what are the spaces and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02060-00432256-00432303": "how", "d5npOMwDwNA-02061-00432304-00432814": "we have to rethink in", "d5npOMwDwNA-02062-00432815-00433207": "do you understand that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02063-00433208-00433551": "i think i think what i'm trying to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02064-00433552-00433759": "struggle with a lot is how", "d5npOMwDwNA-02065-00433760-00434343": "how social movements will have a lot of", "d5npOMwDwNA-02066-00434343-00434647": "challenges in trying to find ways", "d5npOMwDwNA-02067-00434647-00434759": "because the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02068-00434760-00434943": "traditional ways of engagement which was", "d5npOMwDwNA-02069-00434943-00435103": "always to go on the streets which was", "d5npOMwDwNA-02070-00435104-00435239": "always to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02071-00435239-00435431": "put your bodies to stop something is", "d5npOMwDwNA-02072-00435432-00435631": "becoming increasingly difficult", "d5npOMwDwNA-02073-00435632-00435799": "and in a lot of places in the global", "d5npOMwDwNA-02074-00435800-00435959": "south this", "d5npOMwDwNA-02075-00435960-00436287": "is being used as a very strategic", "d5npOMwDwNA-02076-00436288-00436591": "way to prevent any kind of descent", "d5npOMwDwNA-02077-00436592-00436783": "not just environment not just", "d5npOMwDwNA-02078-00436784-00436895": "anti-capitalist but", "d5npOMwDwNA-02079-00436896-00437183": "even basic basic human human rights", "d5npOMwDwNA-02080-00437184-00437351": "violations are happening", "d5npOMwDwNA-02081-00437352-00437527": "and i'm talking about not just in india", "d5npOMwDwNA-02082-00437528-00437679": "but in different parts of the global", "d5npOMwDwNA-02083-00437680-00437879": "south", "d5npOMwDwNA-02084-00437880-00438295": "so i don't have a very clear answer on", "d5npOMwDwNA-02085-00438296-00438687": "on how we would be able to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02086-00438688-00438918": "to change the way we we organize and we", "d5npOMwDwNA-02087-00438919-00439151": "do", "d5npOMwDwNA-02088-00439152-00439414": "do activism in the future because we", "d5npOMwDwNA-02089-00439415-00439647": "also have to keep in mind the fact that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02090-00439647-00439855": "the fact that all of us can sit at home", "d5npOMwDwNA-02091-00439856-00440118": "with the stable computer", "d5npOMwDwNA-02092-00440119-00440343": "stable internet and connect with so many", "d5npOMwDwNA-02093-00440343-00440463": "people is", "d5npOMwDwNA-02094-00440464-00440622": "is a privilege a lot of people don't", "d5npOMwDwNA-02095-00440623-00440766": "have this", "d5npOMwDwNA-02096-00440767-00441151": "and a lot of marginalized communities", "d5npOMwDwNA-02097-00441152-00441447": "people on the grassroots fighting don't", "d5npOMwDwNA-02098-00441447-00441735": "have it so how", "d5npOMwDwNA-02099-00441735-00442110": "it's it's very nice to think", "d5npOMwDwNA-02100-00442112-00442399": "broadly and globally about forging", "d5npOMwDwNA-02101-00442400-00442495": "alliances", "d5npOMwDwNA-02102-00442496-00442751": "but there is a lot section that we are", "d5npOMwDwNA-02103-00442752-00442879": "missing out and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02104-00442880-00443207": "and i don't have a way to to strategize", "d5npOMwDwNA-02105-00443208-00443295": "and think how", "d5npOMwDwNA-02106-00443296-00443583": "can we get those those voices heard that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02107-00443584-00443751": "whether we will always have this problem", "d5npOMwDwNA-02108-00443752-00444535": "of invisibility", "d5npOMwDwNA-02109-00444535-00444743": "well it's a difficult question you're", "d5npOMwDwNA-02110-00444743-00444999": "raising at the end", "d5npOMwDwNA-02111-00445000-00445310": "um actually um one", "d5npOMwDwNA-02112-00445312-00445566": "what it's a bit hard for me but what i", "d5npOMwDwNA-02113-00445567-00445639": "can share", "d5npOMwDwNA-02114-00445639-00445910": "is that there's a lot of discussion in", "d5npOMwDwNA-02115-00445912-00446118": "the food sovereignty movement on that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02116-00446119-00446183": "and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02117-00446184-00446470": "we have something like three strategies", "d5npOMwDwNA-02118-00446471-00446591": "the one is to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02119-00446592-00446879": "to just fight against special kind of", "d5npOMwDwNA-02120-00446880-00446991": "policies like the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02121-00446992-00447335": "actual neoliberal trade policies the the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02122-00447335-00447583": "agricultural policy so just post that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02123-00447584-00447831": "and go on the streets and say no", "d5npOMwDwNA-02124-00447832-00448151": "not like that and of course i well", "d5npOMwDwNA-02125-00448152-00448407": "that and i yeah and the second one is to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02126-00448408-00448655": "really transform the systems", "d5npOMwDwNA-02127-00448656-00449055": "to to be go also into the institutions", "d5npOMwDwNA-02128-00449056-00449270": "and to transform it in a way and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02129-00449271-00449431": "especially for the food system that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02130-00449432-00449639": "works quite well because a lot of people", "d5npOMwDwNA-02131-00449639-00449718": "think well", "d5npOMwDwNA-02132-00449719-00449991": "we need to change uh the food system i", "d5npOMwDwNA-02133-00449992-00450159": "really want to eat something that is", "d5npOMwDwNA-02134-00450160-00450214": "good for", "d5npOMwDwNA-02135-00450215-00450503": "me and my and for the health and also", "d5npOMwDwNA-02136-00450504-00450543": "for", "d5npOMwDwNA-02137-00450543-00450870": "the environment and the last one is to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02138-00450871-00451183": "to build up alternatives and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02139-00451184-00451366": "also within the food system we have", "d5npOMwDwNA-02140-00451367-00451566": "quite a lot of people who", "d5npOMwDwNA-02141-00451567-00451807": "building up alternative tips because", "d5npOMwDwNA-02142-00451808-00451935": "because it's quite", "d5npOMwDwNA-02143-00451935-00452166": "it's compared for example some", "d5npOMwDwNA-02144-00452167-00452263": "industrial", "d5npOMwDwNA-02145-00452264-00452631": "systems it's quite easy to say well i go", "d5npOMwDwNA-02146-00452632-00452951": "and start a farm or build up a food", "d5npOMwDwNA-02147-00452952-00453135": "property for stuff like that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02148-00453135-00453399": "and we need to bring that together and i", "d5npOMwDwNA-02149-00453400-00453470": "think", "d5npOMwDwNA-02150-00453471-00453775": "what we argued the the end of the book", "d5npOMwDwNA-02151-00453776-00453855": "is that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02152-00453856-00454079": "of course all those struggles need to be", "d5npOMwDwNA-02153-00454080-00454255": "in solidarity with each other", "d5npOMwDwNA-02154-00454256-00454527": "but we also need to focus on our own", "d5npOMwDwNA-02155-00454528-00454599": "struggles", "d5npOMwDwNA-02156-00454600-00454839": "that's where we are really have the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02157-00454839-00455070": "power to do it", "d5npOMwDwNA-02158-00455071-00455431": "you know what i mean i of course if", "d5npOMwDwNA-02159-00455432-00455718": "for example i myself i'm i can be much", "d5npOMwDwNA-02160-00455719-00455887": "stronger in what i'm fighting for", "d5npOMwDwNA-02161-00455888-00456135": "if i focus on the on the food", "d5npOMwDwNA-02162-00456135-00456391": "sovereignty movement than to be also", "d5npOMwDwNA-02163-00456392-00456863": "climate activists and care activists", "d5npOMwDwNA-02164-00456864-00457095": "and i think a lot of people know this", "d5npOMwDwNA-02165-00457096-00457366": "thanks", "d5npOMwDwNA-02166-00457367-00457607": "one minute to corona and tajio and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02167-00457608-00457703": "matthias", "d5npOMwDwNA-02168-00457704-00458007": "corona um yes", "d5npOMwDwNA-02169-00458008-00458351": "i want to pick up on the um alternatives", "d5npOMwDwNA-02170-00458352-00458518": "and i think uh relate to something that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02171-00458519-00458718": "susan paulson said in the opening uh", "d5npOMwDwNA-02172-00458719-00458783": "session", "d5npOMwDwNA-02173-00458784-00459047": "that i mean i think it's so deeply", "d5npOMwDwNA-02174-00459047-00459127": "ingrained", "d5npOMwDwNA-02175-00459128-00459351": "um like capitalism and it's working and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02176-00459352-00459487": "our", "d5npOMwDwNA-02177-00459488-00459807": "behavior and our thinking and our how we", "d5npOMwDwNA-02178-00459808-00460063": "are with each other so that that's also", "d5npOMwDwNA-02179-00460064-00460159": "one", "d5npOMwDwNA-02180-00460160-00460479": "um yeah something to keep in mind we", "d5npOMwDwNA-02181-00460480-00460566": "need spaces", "d5npOMwDwNA-02182-00460567-00460783": "and alternative projects not just in", "d5npOMwDwNA-02183-00460784-00460999": "order to eat better food that is better", "d5npOMwDwNA-02184-00461000-00461110": "for us and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02185-00461112-00461351": "in the environment but also to become", "d5npOMwDwNA-02186-00461352-00461495": "other people", "d5npOMwDwNA-02187-00461496-00461839": "um different yeah and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02188-00461839-00462022": "because i agree with what the other side", "d5npOMwDwNA-02189-00462023-00462199": "but just to add another", "d5npOMwDwNA-02190-00462200-00462543": "aspect", "d5npOMwDwNA-02191-00462543-00462727": "i think i can connect to that because i", "d5npOMwDwNA-02192-00462728-00462887": "mentioned before that i think", "d5npOMwDwNA-02193-00462888-00463079": "bodies and their needs and desires are", "d5npOMwDwNA-02194-00463080-00463207": "going to become much much much more", "d5npOMwDwNA-02195-00463208-00463383": "important in this corona world", "d5npOMwDwNA-02196-00463384-00463663": "like you spoke to this key problem that", "d5npOMwDwNA-02197-00463664-00463887": "we have right now that we can't gather", "d5npOMwDwNA-02198-00463888-00464087": "in the corona world all of us in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02199-00464088-00464222": "world but in the global south", "d5npOMwDwNA-02200-00464223-00464455": "spaces were already shrinking and i", "d5npOMwDwNA-02201-00464456-00464583": "think that's sort of to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02202-00464584-00464727": "understand our bodies not just as", "d5npOMwDwNA-02203-00464728-00464887": "something functional that can blockade", "d5npOMwDwNA-02204-00464888-00465063": "something or produce something", "d5npOMwDwNA-02205-00465064-00465295": "or take care of others but as something", "d5npOMwDwNA-02206-00465296-00465422": "with sort of", "d5npOMwDwNA-02207-00465423-00465695": "joyful needs and desires whose", "d5npOMwDwNA-02208-00465696-00465943": "fulfillment does not increase material", "d5npOMwDwNA-02209-00465943-00466110": "throughput through the economy", "d5npOMwDwNA-02210-00466112-00466263": "obviously i'm talking about sex again", "d5npOMwDwNA-02211-00466264-00466463": "but you know and not just", "d5npOMwDwNA-02212-00466464-00466622": "i'm also talking about cuddling and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02213-00466623-00466807": "tenderness and intimacy", "d5npOMwDwNA-02214-00466808-00467014": "and i think that those will become new", "d5npOMwDwNA-02215-00467015-00467263": "struggles and i think those places", "d5npOMwDwNA-02216-00467264-00467591": "where we are those kinds of bodies", "d5npOMwDwNA-02217-00467592-00467814": "those will be new spaces from which to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02218-00467815-00468007": "launch our assault on the total crap", "d5npOMwDwNA-02219-00468008-00468399": "that's killing us", "d5npOMwDwNA-02220-00468400-00468775": "thank you mathias you want to say a word", "d5npOMwDwNA-02221-00468776-00469022": "okay maybe maybe very shortly just to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02222-00469023-00469199": "end a bit on a more", "d5npOMwDwNA-02223-00469200-00469366": "positive note kind of like highlighting", "d5npOMwDwNA-02224-00469367-00469510": "also a potential", "d5npOMwDwNA-02225-00469512-00469863": "in of this experience from a degrowth", "d5npOMwDwNA-02226-00469864-00469935": "perspective", "d5npOMwDwNA-02227-00469935-00470143": "the question how to organize and where", "d5npOMwDwNA-02228-00470143-00470351": "to build strategies is really difficult", "d5npOMwDwNA-02229-00470352-00470447": "to answer", "d5npOMwDwNA-02230-00470447-00470766": "because we kind of like we argue for", "d5npOMwDwNA-02231-00470767-00471079": "a certain kind of deglobalization why we", "d5npOMwDwNA-02232-00471080-00471231": "need to find against", "d5npOMwDwNA-02233-00471232-00471510": "global capitalism and we do need global", "d5npOMwDwNA-02234-00471512-00471710": "strategies", "d5npOMwDwNA-02235-00471712-00471943": "without the harmful international", "d5npOMwDwNA-02236-00471943-00472022": "meetings", "d5npOMwDwNA-02237-00472023-00472191": "and this is a really difficult challenge", "d5npOMwDwNA-02238-00472192-00472383": "that we haven't really tackled so far", "d5npOMwDwNA-02239-00472384-00472614": "also one reason why almost all of the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02240-00472615-00472775": "discussions and also the conferences", "d5npOMwDwNA-02241-00472776-00472910": "have been taking place the d gross", "d5npOMwDwNA-02242-00472912-00473055": "conferences have been taken", "d5npOMwDwNA-02243-00473056-00473199": "place in the countries of the global", "d5npOMwDwNA-02244-00473200-00473510": "north totally limiting kind of like", "d5npOMwDwNA-02245-00473512-00473814": "eye level conversations with activists", "d5npOMwDwNA-02246-00473815-00474095": "from the global south when only certain", "d5npOMwDwNA-02247-00474096-00474222": "rather privileged", "d5npOMwDwNA-02248-00474223-00474375": "persons can actually come to these", "d5npOMwDwNA-02249-00474376-00474614": "conferences i think it's a totally", "d5npOMwDwNA-02250-00474615-00474743": "fundamental challenge for", "d5npOMwDwNA-02251-00474743-00474991": "advancing a degrowth agenda but maybe", "d5npOMwDwNA-02252-00474992-00475095": "the experiences", "d5npOMwDwNA-02253-00475096-00475287": "like this of online conferences can", "d5npOMwDwNA-02254-00475288-00475510": "actually we can actually turn this into", "d5npOMwDwNA-02255-00475512-00475679": "something positive", "d5npOMwDwNA-02256-00475680-00475999": "and try to find ways of", "d5npOMwDwNA-02257-00476000-00476239": "actually meeting in these spaces which", "d5npOMwDwNA-02258-00476239-00476327": "doesn't", "d5npOMwDwNA-02259-00476328-00476622": "make real life experiences bodily", "d5npOMwDwNA-02260-00476623-00476759": "connections", "d5npOMwDwNA-02261-00476760-00477070": "unnecessary but maybe we can also find", "d5npOMwDwNA-02262-00477071-00477183": "and discuss strategies", "d5npOMwDwNA-02263-00477184-00477679": "through these means wow thank you so", "d5npOMwDwNA-02264-00477680-00478039": "much everyone yeah quick clap", "d5npOMwDwNA-02265-00478039-00478303": "i think from those you can see um you", "d5npOMwDwNA-02266-00478304-00478503": "see there's a lot of questions that open", "d5npOMwDwNA-02267-00478504-00478663": "but i think that's why it was perfect to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02268-00478664-00478814": "have this session as one of the first", "d5npOMwDwNA-02269-00478815-00479031": "sessions because you can try to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02270-00479032-00479207": "we continue the reflection and the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02271-00479208-00479391": "discussion about all your questions and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02272-00479392-00479559": "now in the coming days", "d5npOMwDwNA-02273-00479560-00479727": "i hope we see you again in other", "d5npOMwDwNA-02274-00479728-00479975": "sessions and especially on discord", "d5npOMwDwNA-02275-00479976-00480222": "because even if you don't have real", "d5npOMwDwNA-02276-00480223-00480375": "bodily interaction we can", "d5npOMwDwNA-02277-00480376-00480510": "at least have interaction which is not", "d5npOMwDwNA-02278-00480512-00480743": "limited to putting questions and classes", "d5npOMwDwNA-02279-00480743-00480935": "on this chart to join us there", "d5npOMwDwNA-02280-00480935-00481103": "we have a concept back channel there", "d5npOMwDwNA-02281-00481104-00481231": "because we thought it was much easier", "d5npOMwDwNA-02282-00481232-00481439": "maybe we meet there so if you want to", "d5npOMwDwNA-02283-00481439-00481759": "meet panelists attendees and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02284-00481760-00482014": "concepted people please join us there i", "d5npOMwDwNA-02285-00482015-00482207": "would like to thank everyone who has", "d5npOMwDwNA-02286-00482208-00482359": "helped to do this session", "d5npOMwDwNA-02287-00482360-00482566": "so above all you as the presenters and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02288-00482567-00482662": "speakers", "d5npOMwDwNA-02289-00482663-00482879": "but obviously also the growth organizers", "d5npOMwDwNA-02290-00482880-00483031": "rit support and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02291-00483032-00483279": "more invisible than ever the people who", "d5npOMwDwNA-02292-00483280-00483503": "translate it in some weird other room", "d5npOMwDwNA-02293-00483504-00483710": "independent so and if i missed out", "d5npOMwDwNA-02294-00483712-00483814": "anyone um", "d5npOMwDwNA-02295-00483815-00484110": "sorry for that and thank you yeah for", "d5npOMwDwNA-02296-00484112-00484222": "joining in a", "d5npOMwDwNA-02297-00484223-00484518": "rather um frontal space i hope you get", "d5npOMwDwNA-02298-00484519-00484718": "more space for interaction later", "d5npOMwDwNA-02299-00484719-00485039": "thank you and talk soon thank you guys", "d5npOMwDwNA-02300-00485039-00485351": "have a good conference rock on", "d5npOMwDwNA-02301-00485352-00485831": "thanks everyone", "d5npOMwDwNA-02302-00485832-00486127": "i think the it person wanted to put a", "d5npOMwDwNA-02303-00486128-00486183": "little", "d5npOMwDwNA-02304-00486184-00486551": "um what do you say that um paul", "d5npOMwDwNA-02305-00486552-00486710": "if that session helped you anything if", "d5npOMwDwNA-02306-00486712-00486918": "that still pops up we're happy if you", "d5npOMwDwNA-02307-00486919-00487166": "share some feedback but if not okay as", "d5npOMwDwNA-02308-00487167-00487318": "well", "d5npOMwDwNA-02309-00487319-00487535": "no need for that just uh thank you", "d5npOMwDwNA-02310-00487535-00487662": "everyone for coming and", "d5npOMwDwNA-02311-00487663-00487814": "hope to continue the discussion at the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02312-00487815-00487999": "discord and in the coming days in the", "d5npOMwDwNA-02313-00488000-00488710": "other sessions thank you very", "d5npOMwDwNA-02314-00488712-00489152": "so nina much meet on discord"}}]