[{"audio_id": "hlz0echV8zo", "text": {"hlz0echV8zo-00000-00000911-00001964": "okay", "hlz0echV8zo-00001-00001964-00002783": "[Music]", "hlz0echV8zo-00002-00002784-00003158": "x3", "hlz0echV8zo-00003-00003159-00003415": "that bmw is so beautiful my eyes are", "hlz0echV8zo-00004-00003415-00003759": "truly india right on the 20th rings", "hlz0echV8zo-00005-00003760-00004183": "this one retire", "hlz0echV8zo-00006-00004184-00005279": "so see you guys later", "hlz0echV8zo-00007-00005280-00005359": "so", "hlz0echV8zo-00008-00005360-00006247": "we're gonna go and see the heist", "hlz0echV8zo-00009-00006248-00010406": "so", "hlz0echV8zo-00010-00010407-00011399": "uh", "hlz0echV8zo-00011-00011400-00013604": "wow", "hlz0echV8zo-00012-00013605-00014166": "[Music]", "hlz0echV8zo-00013-00014168-00015583": "uh", "hlz0echV8zo-00014-00015584-00016182": "um", "hlz0echV8zo-00015-00016183-00017255": "[Music]", "hlz0echV8zo-00016-00017256-00020999": "um", "hlz0echV8zo-00017-00021000-00023855": "seems quite good", "hlz0echV8zo-00018-00023856-00024047": "as soon as possible", "hlz0echV8zo-00019-00024048-00024373": "so let's get going now", "hlz0echV8zo-00020-00024374-00025774": "[Music]", "hlz0echV8zo-00021-00025775-00026029": "hey", "hlz0echV8zo-00022-00026030-00027918": "[Music]", "hlz0echV8zo-00023-00027919-00028774": "how much", "hlz0echV8zo-00024-00028775-00029155": "bye", "hlz0echV8zo-00025-00029156-00030220": "[Music]", "hlz0echV8zo-00026-00030222-00031804": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "hlLXXWAPavU", "text": {"hlLXXWAPavU-00000-00000296-00000447": "in today's q-tips i thought about", "hlLXXWAPavU-00001-00000448-00000623": "teaching you guys a very simple", "hlLXXWAPavU-00002-00000624-00000767": "transition technique and it's called", "hlLXXWAPavU-00003-00000768-00000935": "speed ramp transition", "hlLXXWAPavU-00004-00000936-00001135": "all it is is that you just have one", "hlLXXWAPavU-00005-00001136-00001399": "speed ramp going into another speed ramp", "hlLXXWAPavU-00006-00001400-00001655": "and it just changes the scene magically", "hlLXXWAPavU-00007-00001655-00001807": "so here's how it's done", "hlLXXWAPavU-00008-00001807-00001967": "bring your footage into any of your", "hlLXXWAPavU-00009-00001968-00002175": "non-linear editing software in this case", "hlLXXWAPavU-00010-00002176-00002375": "i'm using final cut pro but you can use", "hlLXXWAPavU-00011-00002376-00002607": "any software it doesn't really matter", "hlLXXWAPavU-00012-00002608-00002799": "now once you've trimmed the footage", "hlLXXWAPavU-00013-00002800-00002918": "select where you want", "hlLXXWAPavU-00014-00002919-00003206": "speed ramp to begin press shift b and", "hlLXXWAPavU-00015-00003207-00003375": "start to adjust the speed", "hlLXXWAPavU-00016-00003376-00003615": "of the second half of the clip in this", "hlLXXWAPavU-00017-00003615-00003759": "case i usually speed it up", "hlLXXWAPavU-00018-00003760-00004063": "really fast sometimes from 10 000 to 20", "hlLXXWAPavU-00019-00004064-00004279": "000 just to make the effect look really", "hlLXXWAPavU-00020-00004280-00004399": "more pronounced but", "hlLXXWAPavU-00021-00004400-00004551": "it really depends on your footage if", "hlLXXWAPavU-00022-00004552-00004743": "your footage is already fast to begin", "hlLXXWAPavU-00023-00004744-00004935": "with you don't really need to speed it", "hlLXXWAPavU-00024-00004936-00005118": "up that quickly so you really have to", "hlLXXWAPavU-00025-00005119-00005335": "use your eye and judgment to figure out", "hlLXXWAPavU-00026-00005336-00005486": "what's the best speed for this", "hlLXXWAPavU-00027-00005487-00005622": "so once you're done with the speed ramp", "hlLXXWAPavU-00028-00005623-00005783": "of the first clip now bring over the", "hlLXXWAPavU-00029-00005784-00005991": "second clip and now do exactly the same", "hlLXXWAPavU-00030-00005992-00006134": "thing that you did for the first clip", "hlLXXWAPavU-00031-00006135-00006279": "once you've done with the speed ramp of", "hlLXXWAPavU-00032-00006280-00006359": "the second flip", "hlLXXWAPavU-00033-00006360-00006567": "now all you've got to do is place the", "hlLXXWAPavU-00034-00006568-00006783": "second clip where the speed wrap", "hlLXXWAPavU-00035-00006784-00006983": "begins on the first clip and that's", "hlLXXWAPavU-00036-00006984-00007175": "basically it it's that easy", "hlLXXWAPavU-00037-00007176-00007367": "now to make the speed ram look a lot", "hlLXXWAPavU-00038-00007368-00007574": "better you can also add some motion blur", "hlLXXWAPavU-00039-00007575-00007814": "and also add some sound to make it more", "hlLXXWAPavU-00040-00007815-00007903": "convincing", "hlLXXWAPavU-00041-00007904-00008103": "and that's basically it you have just", "hlLXXWAPavU-00042-00008104-00008327": "made yourself a speed ramp transition", "hlLXXWAPavU-00043-00008328-00008527": "so if you did find this quick tip useful", "hlLXXWAPavU-00044-00008528-00008663": "please don't forget to like share and", "hlLXXWAPavU-00045-00008664-00008751": "subscribe", "hlLXXWAPavU-00046-00008752-00010269": "and i'll see you guys in the next q-tips", "hlLXXWAPavU-00047-00010270-00011063": "[Music]", "hlLXXWAPavU-00048-00011064-00011272": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "hlPiYf546W4", "text": {"hlPiYf546W4-00000-00000000-00000175": "okay well i'm glad you two are happy at", "hlPiYf546W4-00001-00000176-00000375": "least i'm happy on the outside", "hlPiYf546W4-00002-00000376-00000559": "as we're gonna get to cast this bangit", "hlPiYf546W4-00003-00000560-00000726": "game g2 vs fanatic", "hlPiYf546W4-00004-00000727-00001231": "is always bound to be a show", "hlPiYf546W4-00005-00001232-00001407": "the addition of crown shot has been of", "hlPiYf546W4-00006-00001408-00001814": "benefit to vitality so far", "hlPiYf546W4-00007-00001816-00001998": "oh that's really well done for mickey", "hlPiYf546W4-00008-00002000-00002167": "comes around hooks", "hlPiYf546W4-00009-00002168-00002391": "into the knock-up down on the million i", "hlPiYf546W4-00010-00002392-00002607": "think if anything lands", "hlPiYf546W4-00011-00002608-00002999": "on yankees elisa put himself up on the", "hlPiYf546W4-00012-00003000-00003238": "silver platter in the control world from", "hlPiYf546W4-00013-00003239-00003406": "mickey all right that's the outplay give", "hlPiYf546W4-00014-00003407-00003438": "it", "hlPiYf546W4-00015-00003439-00003670": "give it to him he's styling so far this", "hlPiYf546W4-00016-00003671-00003799": "game looking to try and catch our crown", "hlPiYf546W4-00017-00003800-00003911": "shot remember there's no flash on the 80", "hlPiYf546W4-00018-00003911-00004006": "carry the ball is going to have to flash", "hlPiYf546W4-00019-00004007-00004191": "away show stopper used only onto schemes", "hlPiYf546W4-00020-00004192-00004343": "the flare away as well as the bob", "hlPiYf546W4-00021-00004344-00004631": "keeps his 80 calories safe onto reckless", "hlPiYf546W4-00022-00004632-00004791": "killer instinct not enough and he will", "hlPiYf546W4-00023-00004792-00004886": "go to sleep", "hlPiYf546W4-00024-00004887-00005054": "crownshot kills his enemy man and now", "hlPiYf546W4-00025-00005055-00005247": "vitality or on the front foot in the", "hlPiYf546W4-00026-00005248-00005302": "bottom lane", "hlPiYf546W4-00027-00005303-00005447": "and look for him on top alonso is going", "hlPiYf546W4-00028-00005448-00005583": "to come out caps has worked his way", "hlPiYf546W4-00029-00005584-00005702": "around the corner wonder", "hlPiYf546W4-00030-00005703-00005831": "chased off to the side as well there's", "hlPiYf546W4-00031-00005832-00005983": "the culling the block down to half hp", "hlPiYf546W4-00032-00005984-00006159": "show stopper as they try and dive in", "hlPiYf546W4-00033-00006160-00006270": "crosstalk try to survive on the back", "hlPiYf546W4-00034-00006271-00006302": "line", "hlPiYf546W4-00035-00006303-00006431": "you have to watch him but the rest of", "hlPiYf546W4-00036-00006431-00006710": "his team is gone crown shot may have", "hlPiYf546W4-00037-00006711-00006927": "lived but at what cost", "hlPiYf546W4-00038-00006928-00007078": "rekkles doesn't have the killer instinct", "hlPiYf546W4-00039-00007079-00007423": "but hits the boyd secretary", "hlPiYf546W4-00040-00007423-00007710": "and necklace takes him out 32 minutes in", "hlPiYf546W4-00041-00007711-00007863": "g2 will claim", "hlPiYf546W4-00042-00007864-00008503": "their 10th win of spring", "hlPiYf546W4-00043-00008504-00008655": "whipper still has a flash to try and get", "hlPiYf546W4-00044-00008656-00008791": "away from this one jankos looking for", "hlPiYf546W4-00045-00008792-00008967": "the undertone lands the first wonder now", "hlPiYf546W4-00046-00008968-00009110": "with a bank of its own is fnatic are", "hlPiYf546W4-00047-00009111-00009271": "going for the tp he's got a tp's in from", "hlPiYf546W4-00048-00009272-00009367": "g2", "hlPiYf546W4-00049-00009368-00009623": "and nisky nowhere to go his first blood", "hlPiYf546W4-00050-00009624-00009831": "on whitbow for g2 the only real risk", "hlPiYf546W4-00051-00009832-00009927": "they have to worry about notice that", "hlPiYf546W4-00052-00009928-00010071": "nisky is starting to roam down they're", "hlPiYf546W4-00053-00010072-00010199": "looking for the dive", "hlPiYf546W4-00054-00010200-00010342": "already underneath the tower upset", "hlPiYf546W4-00055-00010343-00010455": "trying to do the damage that he can", "hlPiYf546W4-00056-00010456-00010614": "explosive cast from wonder hillary", "hlPiYf546W4-00057-00010615-00010791": "tanking this up he's sacrificing himself", "hlPiYf546W4-00058-00010792-00010942": "for this play but the base call will get", "hlPiYf546W4-00059-00010943-00011151": "him out just in time tp's now from g2", "hlPiYf546W4-00060-00011152-00011310": "next two towers that immediately is", "hlPiYf546W4-00061-00011311-00011455": "killed wonder takes another as", "hlPiYf546W4-00062-00011456-00011670": "hillersack dives into his demise", "hlPiYf546W4-00063-00011671-00011878": "21 minutes for the soul it's a very", "hlPiYf546W4-00064-00011879-00012023": "quick infernal soul possibility for", "hlPiYf546W4-00065-00012024-00012110": "jesus flashing from hillary clinton you", "hlPiYf546W4-00066-00012111-00012223": "get to double knock up tv behind from", "hlPiYf546W4-00067-00012224-00012383": "wonder though immediately g2 going for", "hlPiYf546W4-00068-00012384-00012527": "the tp the magnet storm coming out as", "hlPiYf546W4-00069-00012528-00012735": "well and here comes wonder", "hlPiYf546W4-00070-00012736-00012886": "gragas is angry as upset flashes away", "hlPiYf546W4-00071-00012887-00012999": "but the explosive castle locked him", "hlPiYf546W4-00072-00013000-00013071": "against the wall", "hlPiYf546W4-00073-00013072-00013247": "the blast code is there for upset to try", "hlPiYf546W4-00074-00013247-00013366": "and get away self-made coming down for", "hlPiYf546W4-00075-00013368-00013455": "the fray as well", "hlPiYf546W4-00076-00013456-00013551": "hit a sign looking for the stun who", "hlPiYf546W4-00077-00013552-00013727": "wants a mickey upset just about dodging", "hlPiYf546W4-00078-00013728-00013911": "away with the cleanser able to survive", "hlPiYf546W4-00079-00013912-00014071": "shuffled back wonder goes into the back", "hlPiYf546W4-00080-00014072-00014255": "line he's put asleep hillasang knocks", "hlPiYf546W4-00081-00014256-00014375": "him up reckless comes in with a fourth", "hlPiYf546W4-00082-00014376-00014486": "shot to get one kill", "hlPiYf546W4-00083-00014487-00014607": "it's two for one in the bottom lane his", "hlPiYf546W4-00084-00014608-00014807": "jankos now joins the fight himself but", "hlPiYf546W4-00085-00014808-00014958": "instead we'll just force fnatic to back", "hlPiYf546W4-00086-00014959-00015279": "away", "hlPiYf546W4-00087-00015280-00015550": "breaker sink the axes in the back of the", "hlPiYf546W4-00088-00015551-00015615": "ox", "hlPiYf546W4-00089-00015616-00015838": "and it's another kill over the ankos tp", "hlPiYf546W4-00090-00015840-00015991": "behind by caps here self-made stepping", "hlPiYf546W4-00091-00015991-00016079": "forward looking for the", "hlPiYf546W4-00092-00016080-00016503": "lullaby for that mickey mouse", "hlPiYf546W4-00093-00016504-00016807": "magnus storm enemies fanatics hopes may", "hlPiYf546W4-00094-00016808-00016935": "be dashed against the rocks", "hlPiYf546W4-00095-00016936-00017079": "whipple going in trying to get kills for", "hlPiYf546W4-00096-00017080-00017319": "himself it's a two-for-one in favor of", "hlPiYf546W4-00097-00017320-00017630": "g2 in the bush fanatic stepping forward", "hlPiYf546W4-00098-00017631-00017847": "undergoing he lands the flash class", "hlPiYf546W4-00099-00017848-00017943": "combo", "hlPiYf546W4-00100-00017944-00018199": "and nisky hasn't got a hope in hell of", "hlPiYf546W4-00101-00018200-00018414": "surviving self made next on the menu", "hlPiYf546W4-00102-00018415-00018575": "and you can see hillary can't do too", "hlPiYf546W4-00103-00018576-00018719": "much about this before diving in gets", "hlPiYf546W4-00104-00018720-00018814": "caps that's one", "hlPiYf546W4-00105-00018815-00018958": "upset able to get away off towards the", "hlPiYf546W4-00106-00018959-00019055": "back line and yet because being chucked", "hlPiYf546W4-00107-00019056-00019119": "down as well", "hlPiYf546W4-00108-00019120-00019271": "upset dodging around as much as you can", "hlPiYf546W4-00109-00019272-00019479": "ripper will be the next to fall though", "hlPiYf546W4-00110-00019480-00019758": "and g2 is a sweep up in the mid lane", "hlPiYf546W4-00111-00019759-00019927": "double tp nisky and wipo trying to get", "hlPiYf546W4-00112-00019928-00020055": "at least one kill here because they know", "hlPiYf546W4-00113-00020056-00020214": "if at least that they can kill a yankos", "hlPiYf546W4-00114-00020215-00020391": "they can stop that baron from going down", "hlPiYf546W4-00115-00020392-00020511": "but look at the damage from just a", "hlPiYf546W4-00116-00020512-00020678": "single undertow no tower stands here", "hlPiYf546W4-00117-00020679-00020791": "peppa going in", "hlPiYf546W4-00118-00020792-00020927": "spirit clear coming out there's the", "hlPiYf546W4-00119-00020928-00021094": "ragnarok niski shuffles forward", "hlPiYf546W4-00120-00021095-00021350": "and the train comes in and comes yeah", "hlPiYf546W4-00121-00021351-00021535": "because that is disgusting", "hlPiYf546W4-00122-00021536-00021839": "that is not allowed that yone", "hlPiYf546W4-00123-00021840-00021991": "he's called the unforgotten but i'm", "hlPiYf546W4-00124-00021992-00022111": "pretty sure this performance will be", "hlPiYf546W4-00125-00022112-00022327": "forgotten very soon two and five", "hlPiYf546W4-00126-00022328-00022622": "is a whippo on the one a hitter here as", "hlPiYf546W4-00127-00022623-00022767": "they go up in the top lane but there's", "hlPiYf546W4-00128-00022768-00022871": "the unleashed power on seven he's", "hlPiYf546W4-00129-00022872-00022999": "immediately fought away mickey with a", "hlPiYf546W4-00130-00023000-00023078": "double stun", "hlPiYf546W4-00131-00023079-00023239": "the attract repel doing exactly what it", "hlPiYf546W4-00132-00023240-00023430": "says on the tin niski tries to jump", "hlPiYf546W4-00133-00023431-00023647": "in but immediately he is scattered as", "hlPiYf546W4-00134-00023648-00023830": "one of the weak nisky balls and now", "hlPiYf546W4-00135-00023831-00023903": "hillasang", "hlPiYf546W4-00136-00023904-00024135": "is next on the menu upset the last man", "hlPiYf546W4-00137-00024136-00024239": "standing", "hlPiYf546W4-00138-00024240-00024414": "and there is nowhere for him to go he's", "hlPiYf546W4-00139-00024415-00024583": "caught between a wall and the anchors", "hlPiYf546W4-00140-00024584-00024727": "and jankos wins out", "hlPiYf546W4-00141-00024728-00025071": "what a performance from g2 silencing the", "hlPiYf546W4-00142-00025072-00025191": "doubters with a", "hlPiYf546W4-00143-00025192-00025391": "dominant victory here over fnatic and", "hlPiYf546W4-00144-00025392-00025550": "they want one more they want to add", "hlPiYf546W4-00145-00025551-00025639": "another d", "hlPiYf546W4-00146-00025639-00025783": "to the column for breadboa", "hlPiYf546W4-00147-00025785-00026158": "[Music]", "hlPiYf546W4-00148-00026160-00026295": "okay wait let's see can we get this can", "hlPiYf546W4-00149-00026295-00026495": "we get this working yes there we go", "hlPiYf546W4-00150-00026495-00026687": "oh man suck the belly in wait wait i", "hlPiYf546W4-00151-00026688-00027014": "have", "hlPiYf546W4-00152-00027016-00027246": "there we go there we go how did you feel", "hlPiYf546W4-00153-00027247-00027374": "when you played blitzcrank", "hlPiYf546W4-00154-00027375-00027558": "yesterday were you like very excited", "hlPiYf546W4-00155-00027560-00027743": "that the game went so well for you and", "hlPiYf546W4-00156-00027744-00027790": "uh", "hlPiYf546W4-00157-00027791-00027943": "do you wish to ever play blitzcrank", "hlPiYf546W4-00158-00027944-00028174": "again or is it kind of on the cooler", "hlPiYf546W4-00159-00028175-00028311": "right now on top players", "hlPiYf546W4-00160-00028312-00028487": "um it definitely went really well so i'm", "hlPiYf546W4-00161-00028488-00028623": "hyped to pick it again if enemy teams", "hlPiYf546W4-00162-00028624-00028711": "leave it open of course", "hlPiYf546W4-00163-00028712-00028831": "if it's a good situation i would", "hlPiYf546W4-00164-00028832-00028990": "obviously pick it not because we played", "hlPiYf546W4-00165-00028991-00029079": "the tality", "hlPiYf546W4-00166-00029080-00029367": "and it was mostly because i was really", "hlPiYf546W4-00167-00029368-00029527": "smashing rasmus in the fighting games", "hlPiYf546W4-00168-00029527-00029614": "and", "hlPiYf546W4-00169-00029616-00029870": "i play and i was playing scorpion a lot", "hlPiYf546W4-00170-00029872-00029943": "and he got", "hlPiYf546W4-00171-00029944-00030167": "also kind of has a hook so you know i", "hlPiYf546W4-00172-00030168-00030262": "kind of picked up", "hlPiYf546W4-00173-00030263-00030470": "all the strategies from there and me and", "hlPiYf546W4-00174-00030472-00030623": "others really were together yesterday in", "hlPiYf546W4-00175-00030624-00030783": "the mid to support apartment because we", "hlPiYf546W4-00176-00030783-00030855": "played a lot of", "hlPiYf546W4-00177-00030856-00031014": "fighting games like ones and he got", "hlPiYf546W4-00178-00031016-00031143": "absolutely demolished so then he kind of", "hlPiYf546W4-00179-00031144-00031174": "knew", "hlPiYf546W4-00180-00031175-00031318": "how to demolish the enemy mid laner and", "hlPiYf546W4-00181-00031319-00031431": "we kind of read all of his moves and", "hlPiYf546W4-00182-00031432-00031527": "punish them for it", "hlPiYf546W4-00183-00031527-00031679": "because this guy could know how to block", "hlPiYf546W4-00184-00031680-00033246": "or dodge or anything", "hlPiYf546W4-00185-00033247-00033456": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "hm5Cs5Epldo", "text": {"hm5Cs5Epldo-00000-00000056-00000567": "kwai club online macaron keychain", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00001-00000568-00000782": "hi everyone", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00002-00000783-00000966": "today you're going to make a macaron", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00003-00000967-00001247": "keychain like the one here", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00004-00001248-00001511": "before you start you're going to need to", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00005-00001512-00001702": "cover your workspace with a paper towel", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00006-00001703-00001934": "or newspapers or something", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00007-00001935-00002183": "in your kits you'll find some makeup", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00008-00002184-00002367": "sponges", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00009-00002368-00002550": "a couple of keychain", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00010-00002551-00002847": "findings and some silicone", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00011-00002848-00002975": "cream", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00012-00002976-00003375": "you'll need scissors to complete this", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00013-00003376-00003583": "all right to begin", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00014-00003584-00003886": "you're going to want to start with your", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00015-00003887-00004135": "makeup sponges each one will be half of", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00016-00004136-00004311": "the macaron cookie", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00017-00004312-00004663": "like that", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00018-00004664-00004902": "you're going to start", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00019-00004903-00005022": "by", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00020-00005023-00005399": "carefully cutting off the tip", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00021-00005400-00005518": "and then we're going to use your", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00022-00005519-00005991": "scissors to shape from there", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00023-00005992-00006222": "it doesn't have to be", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00024-00006223-00006439": "completely straight or even", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00025-00006440-00006678": "because the edges of the cookie aren't", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00026-00006679-00006870": "i find it easiest", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00027-00006872-00007078": "to", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00028-00007079-00007383": "work from the outside in", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00029-00007384-00007734": "and until i get it to about the size", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00030-00007736-00008039": "that i want and the shape that i want", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00031-00008040-00008255": "and i'm just trimming big pieces first", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00032-00008256-00008383": "to get it to be", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00033-00008384-00008655": "the size that i'm looking for because", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00034-00008656-00008846": "the makeup sponge is a little thicker", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00035-00008847-00009255": "than what a cookie would be", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00036-00009256-00009414": "and if you've seen macarons they're kind", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00037-00009415-00009623": "of dome shaped and they have a little", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00038-00009624-00009823": "bit of a scalloped edge to them where", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00039-00009824-00010399": "they are sandwiched together", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00040-00010400-00010806": "so once i get it to about the right size", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00041-00010807-00011055": "i'm going to start", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00042-00011056-00011295": "just kind of trimming little gently", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00043-00011296-00011559": "small bits along the edges to make it a", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00044-00011560-00011799": "little bit of a scalloped edge", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00045-00011800-00011942": "and if i trim in", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00046-00011943-00012174": "too much the middle will be kind of", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00047-00012175-00012335": "raised and i'll have to", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00048-00012336-00012910": "get that down but that's okay", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00049-00012911-00013094": "there we go you can see how the middle", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00050-00013095-00013463": "is a little raised there", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00051-00013463-00013751": "but that's about the size that i want", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00052-00013752-00013886": "so now i'm going to do the same for the", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00053-00013887-00014111": "other half", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00054-00014112-00014271": "because a macaron is basically a", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00055-00014272-00015007": "sandwich cookie", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00056-00015008-00015135": "if you ever get to taste them they're", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00057-00015136-00015438": "delicious they're i think hbheb makes", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00058-00015440-00015558": "them in their bakery section", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00059-00015559-00015775": "occasionally", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00060-00015776-00015966": "you can also find them in other", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00061-00015968-00016166": "bakery sections they're made with almond", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00062-00016168-00016279": "flour", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00063-00016280-00016591": "and uh almond cream in the real", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00064-00016592-00016855": "the real thing", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00065-00016856-00017047": "um", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00066-00017048-00017286": "but today we're just making fake ones", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00067-00017287-00017647": "uh be sure to keep the silicone", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00068-00017648-00017830": "cream away from", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00069-00017831-00017983": "little ones that might think that it's", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00070-00017984-00018214": "actually food it's not it's not edible", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00071-00018215-00018839": "edible", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00072-00018840-00019014": "keep trimming here see the middle got a", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00073-00019015-00019230": "little raised", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00074-00019231-00019383": "see i kind of want a little bit of a", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00075-00019384-00019679": "scalloped edge like that that's good", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00076-00019680-00020558": "trim some more on this one", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00077-00020559-00020743": "and i gave you enough materials to make", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00078-00020744-00020863": "two", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00079-00020864-00021255": "uh in your kits you'll also have some", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00080-00021256-00021375": "icing", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00081-00021376-00021886": "tips if you want to use that with your", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00082-00021887-00022086": "silicone", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00083-00022087-00022255": "it's a little raised on this one so i'm", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00084-00022256-00022535": "going to lower that in a bit", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00085-00022536-00023143": "make it a little flatter", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00086-00023144-00023358": "all right let's see if that that's a", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00087-00023359-00024022": "that's pretty good", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00088-00024023-00024342": "shrink this one a little bit", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00089-00024343-00025283": "so i have room for my silicone", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00090-00025284-00025447": "okay", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00091-00025448-00025662": "open my silicone here", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00092-00025663-00025902": "and basically i'm not using a", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00093-00025904-00026102": "piping tip here but you can add it to", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00094-00026104-00026414": "the edge and if you want it to look", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00095-00026416-00026631": "fancy", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00096-00026632-00026967": "but i'm just going to spread", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00097-00026968-00027167": "an even amount", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00098-00027168-00027295": "as if i was", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00099-00027295-00028174": "icing the middle of a cookie", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00100-00028175-00028351": "your colors may differ", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00101-00028352-00028583": "because i got variety packs of the", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00102-00028583-00028767": "silicone and the", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00103-00028768-00028879": "makeup", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00104-00028880-00030374": "sponges so you'll have different colors", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00105-00030375-00031039": "all right put my silicone back on", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00106-00031039-00031214": "cap there we go", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00107-00031216-00031367": "it's now going to", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00108-00031368-00031590": "gently sandwich it together try not to", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00109-00031591-00031783": "squish it too much", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00110-00031783-00031958": "and then i'm just going to use the", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00111-00031960-00032199": "little tip of my", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00112-00032200-00032551": "keychain the little bolt there the with", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00113-00032552-00032711": "the eye pin", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00114-00032712-00032799": "and", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00115-00032800-00033055": "stick it in", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00116-00033056-00033407": "the silicone where it's still wet", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00117-00033408-00033574": "and i'm going to set it aside to dry", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00118-00033575-00033727": "it'll probably take at least a day to", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00119-00033728-00033895": "completely dry", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00120-00033896-00034095": "once it's dry it should be set in the", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00121-00034096-00034271": "silicone and", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00122-00034272-00034502": "you shouldn't have to worry about it", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00123-00034503-00034639": "but", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00124-00034640-00034862": "see i'm getting some of my fingers", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00125-00034863-00034999": "just", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00126-00035000-00035143": "wipe it off and then wash your hands", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00127-00035144-00035295": "really well", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00128-00035296-00035527": "just set it aside here to dry and you", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00129-00035528-00035711": "can make", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00130-00035712-00036262": "another one if you wish", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00131-00036263-00036607": "i hope you enjoy the craft today", "hm5Cs5Epldo-00132-00036608-00036908": "friends"}}, {"audio_id": "hmrLF3-tSay", "text": {"hmrLF3-tSay-00000-00000000-00000111": "[Music]", "hmrLF3-tSay-00001-00000112-00000430": "hey sweetie it's bird", "hmrLF3-tSay-00002-00000431-00000719": "i need you to know that if you ever felt", "hmrLF3-tSay-00003-00000720-00001023": "like you was a woman on the inside", "hmrLF3-tSay-00004-00001024-00001366": "but she's in a boy's body", "hmrLF3-tSay-00005-00001367-00001535": "if you really with all your heart and", "hmrLF3-tSay-00006-00001536-00001871": "soul feel like you're a girl", "hmrLF3-tSay-00007-00001872-00002239": "guess what baby you're a girl", "hmrLF3-tSay-00008-00002240-00002502": "i don't care what anybody says i don't", "hmrLF3-tSay-00009-00002503-00002702": "care how they judge you", "hmrLF3-tSay-00010-00002703-00002942": "i don't care how they look at you i", "hmrLF3-tSay-00011-00002943-00003150": "don't care if you're in prison", "hmrLF3-tSay-00012-00003151-00003431": "i don't care if you're a harvard honey", "hmrLF3-tSay-00013-00003432-00003583": "you gotta be", "hmrLF3-tSay-00014-00003584-00003911": "man enough to use them nuts that god", "hmrLF3-tSay-00015-00003911-00004167": "mistakenly gave you", "hmrLF3-tSay-00016-00004168-00004591": "and be a woman you are a woman", "hmrLF3-tSay-00017-00004592-00004879": "it's okay to be transgender i don't care", "hmrLF3-tSay-00018-00004880-00004975": "what they say", "hmrLF3-tSay-00019-00004976-00005295": "it's not a choice it's who we are", "hmrLF3-tSay-00020-00005296-00005575": "it's the hardest thing to admit", "hmrLF3-tSay-00021-00005576-00005759": "is that it's the truth", "hmrLF3-tSay-00022-00005760-00005975": "you think i like talking like that that", "hmrLF3-tSay-00023-00005976-00006118": "f word is dirty and i", "hmrLF3-tSay-00024-00006119-00006399": "hate dirty but i think it's important", "hmrLF3-tSay-00025-00006400-00006510": "that you know", "hmrLF3-tSay-00026-00006511-00006791": "being transgender isn't a choice it's", "hmrLF3-tSay-00027-00006792-00006863": "hard", "hmrLF3-tSay-00028-00006864-00007070": "and transitioning isn't fun and it", "hmrLF3-tSay-00029-00007072-00007198": "shouldn't be used as an", "hmrLF3-tSay-00030-00007200-00007478": "experiment or a game it should be used", "hmrLF3-tSay-00031-00007479-00007631": "as a treatment", "hmrLF3-tSay-00032-00007631-00007967": "for gender dysphoria if you don't have", "hmrLF3-tSay-00033-00007968-00008095": "gender dysphoria", "hmrLF3-tSay-00034-00008095-00008327": "you should not be able to transition", "hmrLF3-tSay-00035-00008328-00008414": "period", "hmrLF3-tSay-00036-00008415-00008751": "that's my opinion that's my", "hmrLF3-tSay-00037-00008752-00009135": "life it's hard it's not fun", "hmrLF3-tSay-00038-00009136-00009439": "it's scary but it's worth every minute", "hmrLF3-tSay-00039-00009440-00009527": "of it", "hmrLF3-tSay-00040-00009528-00009663": "because you finally get to find the", "hmrLF3-tSay-00041-00009664-00009783": "happiness you've been living for your", "hmrLF3-tSay-00042-00009784-00010023": "whole life", "hmrLF3-tSay-00043-00010024-00010511": "and i approve this message"}}, {"audio_id": "hmsFZj_dENk", "text": {"hmsFZj_dENk-00000-00000012-00000257": "Fox News settles Blockbuster defamation", "hmsFZj_dENk-00001-00000258-00000545": "lawsuit with Dominion voting systems Fox", "hmsFZj_dENk-00002-00000546-00000773": "News and its parent company foxcorp have", "hmsFZj_dENk-00003-00000774-00000941": "struck a deal averting an embarrassing", "hmsFZj_dENk-00004-00000942-00001139": "trial in the Blockbuster defamation suit", "hmsFZj_dENk-00005-00001140-00001295": "filed by the election tech company", "hmsFZj_dENk-00006-00001296-00001516": "Dominion voting systems over ridiculous", "hmsFZj_dENk-00007-00001517-00001751": "claims of fraud in the 2020 presidential", "hmsFZj_dENk-00008-00001752-00001834": "race", "hmsFZj_dENk-00009-00001835-00002023": "Fox and Dominion have reached an", "hmsFZj_dENk-00010-00002023-00002242": "historic settlement", "hmsFZj_dENk-00011-00002243-00002452": "fox has admitted to telling lies about", "hmsFZj_dENk-00012-00002453-00002573": "Dominion", "hmsFZj_dENk-00013-00002574-00002795": "that caused enormous damage to my", "hmsFZj_dENk-00014-00002796-00003089": "company our employees and the customers", "hmsFZj_dENk-00015-00003090-00003383": "that we serve Dominion started this case", "hmsFZj_dENk-00016-00003384-00003599": "because Fox's defamatory statements had", "hmsFZj_dENk-00017-00003600-00003815": "severely damaged its reputation", "hmsFZj_dENk-00018-00003815-00004019": "by largely trying its case in the court", "hmsFZj_dENk-00019-00004020-00004241": "of public opinion Dominion has gone a", "hmsFZj_dENk-00020-00004242-00004481": "long way toward restoring its good name", "hmsFZj_dENk-00021-00004482-00004751": "in the process of course Fox's own", "hmsFZj_dENk-00022-00004752-00005045": "reputation has been seriously undermined", "hmsFZj_dENk-00023-00005046-00005285": "Fox is not just any media organization", "hmsFZj_dENk-00024-00005286-00005554": "were it to Simply have apologized Fox", "hmsFZj_dENk-00025-00005555-00005686": "would have acknowledged its biggest", "hmsFZj_dENk-00026-00005687-00005879": "stars had been wrong to present Trump's", "hmsFZj_dENk-00027-00005880-00006059": "claims of election fraud and that they", "hmsFZj_dENk-00028-00006060-00006233": "the viewers had been wrong to believe", "hmsFZj_dENk-00029-00006234-00006464": "them"}}, {"audio_id": "hmedp6HLAyY", "text": {"hmedp6HLAyY-00000-00000038-00000894": "[Music]", "hmedp6HLAyY-00001-00000896-00000958": "so", "hmedp6HLAyY-00002-00000959-00001231": "george we would like to ask you to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00003-00001232-00001366": "introduce yourself", "hmedp6HLAyY-00004-00001367-00001679": "and to tell us how your", "hmedp6HLAyY-00005-00001680-00002167": "ideas developed along with your", "hmedp6HLAyY-00006-00002168-00002510": "development as an activist", "hmedp6HLAyY-00007-00002511-00002702": "so can you give us a bit of an", "hmedp6HLAyY-00008-00002703-00003087": "introduction to that sure", "hmedp6HLAyY-00009-00003088-00003447": "all right i come from a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00010-00003447-00003767": "generation of the 1960s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00011-00003768-00004143": "in the united states and my first", "hmedp6HLAyY-00012-00004144-00004551": "experience of struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-00013-00004552-00004911": "was to be found in the civil rights", "hmedp6HLAyY-00014-00004912-00005070": "movement", "hmedp6HLAyY-00015-00005071-00005551": "of the early 60s i was a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00016-00005552-00006022": "student in the universities at that time", "hmedp6HLAyY-00017-00006023-00006678": "and i went on many demonstrations", "hmedp6HLAyY-00018-00006679-00006910": "especially for the rights of african", "hmedp6HLAyY-00019-00006911-00007078": "americans", "hmedp6HLAyY-00020-00007079-00007375": "because there was a i think it would be", "hmedp6HLAyY-00021-00007376-00007567": "important for", "hmedp6HLAyY-00022-00007568-00007959": "us to say that the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00023-00007959-00008327": "60s movement experienced", "hmedp6HLAyY-00024-00008328-00008583": "a revolution actually within the united", "hmedp6HLAyY-00025-00008584-00008863": "states", "hmedp6HLAyY-00026-00008864-00009159": "it's an unfinished revolution because", "hmedp6HLAyY-00027-00009160-00009246": "the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00028-00009247-00009614": "demands that were put forward have not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00029-00009615-00010055": "have legally been approved but in actual", "hmedp6HLAyY-00030-00010056-00010199": "fact", "hmedp6HLAyY-00031-00010200-00010463": "there's still a substantial struggle to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00032-00010464-00010551": "be made", "hmedp6HLAyY-00033-00010552-00010903": "and uh for me", "hmedp6HLAyY-00034-00010904-00011206": "it was the the beginning", "hmedp6HLAyY-00035-00011207-00011638": "where i got arrested a number of times", "hmedp6HLAyY-00036-00011639-00011991": "around demonstration", "hmedp6HLAyY-00037-00011992-00012414": "issues and i was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00038-00012415-00012719": "able to study the first experiences of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00039-00012720-00012943": "organization", "hmedp6HLAyY-00040-00012944-00013263": "both indiana in in new york city", "hmedp6HLAyY-00041-00013263-00013566": "where i was born and brought up", "hmedp6HLAyY-00042-00013568-00013911": "and in ohio", "hmedp6HLAyY-00043-00013912-00014175": "in fact in southern ohio which was more", "hmedp6HLAyY-00044-00014176-00014238": "or less", "hmedp6HLAyY-00045-00014240-00014822": "a segregated place and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00046-00014823-00015166": "well from that beginning i immediately", "hmedp6HLAyY-00047-00015168-00015358": "went into the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00048-00015359-00015766": "anti-war vietnamese war", "hmedp6HLAyY-00049-00015768-00016358": "story and it was there that i began to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00050-00016359-00016903": "look for some theoretical basis", "hmedp6HLAyY-00051-00016904-00017271": "for my activism and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00052-00017272-00017639": "it was a time in the mid 60s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00053-00017640-00018086": "when there was a revival of marxism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00054-00018087-00018343": "and here is something i'd like to say", "hmedp6HLAyY-00055-00018344-00018479": "something about", "hmedp6HLAyY-00056-00018480-00019063": "because there's a certain kind of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00057-00019064-00019527": "determinism about past experiences that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00058-00019528-00019894": "is not accurate", "hmedp6HLAyY-00059-00019895-00020199": "because in the 1960s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00060-00020200-00020463": "preceding the revolutionary upsurge in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00061-00020464-00020671": "the united states", "hmedp6HLAyY-00062-00020672-00021086": "the it was a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00063-00021087-00021303": "one of the most reactionary times in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00064-00021304-00021494": "american history", "hmedp6HLAyY-00065-00021495-00021791": "and everybody predicted that every that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00066-00021792-00021822": "the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00067-00021823-00022094": "students who are going through high", "hmedp6HLAyY-00068-00022095-00022255": "school and college", "hmedp6HLAyY-00069-00022256-00022686": "at that time would come out to be robots", "hmedp6HLAyY-00070-00022687-00023143": "right-wing robots", "hmedp6HLAyY-00071-00023144-00023486": "speaking the reactionary lines anyway", "hmedp6HLAyY-00072-00023487-00023694": "but in fact turned to be the exact", "hmedp6HLAyY-00073-00023695-00023903": "opposite", "hmedp6HLAyY-00074-00023904-00024214": "at least not only i but so many", "hmedp6HLAyY-00075-00024215-00024478": "literally millions of young young folks", "hmedp6HLAyY-00076-00024479-00024591": "who have been told", "hmedp6HLAyY-00077-00024592-00024999": "that mccarthy is a great guy and that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00078-00025000-00025375": "the capitalism is the best way to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00079-00025376-00025519": "organize", "hmedp6HLAyY-00080-00025520-00025974": "society these", "hmedp6HLAyY-00081-00025975-00026262": "young people who came out of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00082-00026263-00026423": "colleges and universities", "hmedp6HLAyY-00083-00026424-00026727": "at that time did not end up", "hmedp6HLAyY-00084-00026727-00027031": "becoming these little right-wing robots", "hmedp6HLAyY-00085-00027032-00027335": "on the contrary we joined the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00086-00027336-00027558": "revolutionary movement in the southern", "hmedp6HLAyY-00087-00027560-00027751": "part of the united states", "hmedp6HLAyY-00088-00027752-00027927": "and not only the southern part but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00089-00027927-00028199": "actually throughout the country", "hmedp6HLAyY-00090-00028200-00028502": "to demand that there be fundamental", "hmedp6HLAyY-00091-00028504-00028646": "change", "hmedp6HLAyY-00092-00028647-00029111": "and so as a consequence", "hmedp6HLAyY-00093-00029112-00029743": "i began to study with comrades", "hmedp6HLAyY-00094-00029744-00030199": "the works of revolutionaries before us", "hmedp6HLAyY-00095-00030200-00030614": "and i at that time became part of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00096-00030616-00031023": "study groups which were very much part", "hmedp6HLAyY-00097-00031024-00031079": "of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00098-00031080-00031735": "education of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00099-00031736-00032255": "young young activists and militants", "hmedp6HLAyY-00100-00032256-00032574": "and it was in that route that i began to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00101-00032575-00032670": "develop", "hmedp6HLAyY-00102-00032672-00033095": "my ideas", "hmedp6HLAyY-00103-00033096-00033431": "it's a long story but maybe i i", "hmedp6HLAyY-00104-00033432-00033846": "hopefully i gave you some sense of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00105-00033847-00034279": "what happens in the 1960s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00106-00034280-00034623": "that eventually led to the kind of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00107-00034624-00034974": "politics that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00108-00034975-00035527": "i ended up with and still adhere to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00109-00035528-00035718": "maybe you can talk a little bit also", "hmedp6HLAyY-00110-00035719-00035830": "about you know", "hmedp6HLAyY-00111-00035831-00036030": "the encounter more with also some", "hmedp6HLAyY-00112-00036031-00036151": "italian", "hmedp6HLAyY-00113-00036152-00036367": "they work on zero work and they", "hmedp6HLAyY-00114-00036368-00036567": "encounter with some of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00115-00036568-00036790": "theories that were coming out of italy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00116-00036791-00037359": "in the 1960s late 60s early 70s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00117-00037360-00037646": "yes i can talk about it because it was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00118-00037647-00037895": "very important part of my", "hmedp6HLAyY-00119-00037896-00038318": "uh because what happened was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00120-00038319-00038695": "that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00121-00038696-00039127": "the kind of theory that i", "hmedp6HLAyY-00122-00039128-00039527": "begin to develop with others in the 19", "hmedp6HLAyY-00123-00039528-00039990": "late 60s early 70s was a very", "hmedp6HLAyY-00124-00039991-00040239": "orthodox if you want to call it that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00125-00040240-00040559": "marxism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00126-00040560-00041007": "of the time and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00127-00041008-00041335": "i began to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00128-00041336-00041839": "in the in the early 70s i began to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00129-00041840-00042255": "question some of the pr", "hmedp6HLAyY-00130-00042256-00042655": "the principal um ideas that were", "hmedp6HLAyY-00131-00042656-00043071": "coming out of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00132-00043072-00043415": "communist movements and the socialist", "hmedp6HLAyY-00133-00043416-00043815": "movements of the of the time", "hmedp6HLAyY-00134-00043816-00044158": "and i began to look", "hmedp6HLAyY-00135-00044159-00044623": "for other sources of theoretical", "hmedp6HLAyY-00136-00044624-00045095": "depth and to do that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00137-00045096-00045423": "i came upon", "hmedp6HLAyY-00138-00045424-00045767": "the work of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00139-00045768-00046102": "sylvia and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00140-00046103-00046455": "a number of other comrades from italy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00141-00046456-00046751": "that had uh found their way to new york", "hmedp6HLAyY-00142-00046752-00046886": "city", "hmedp6HLAyY-00143-00046887-00047207": "and uh who were part of the radical", "hmedp6HLAyY-00144-00047208-00047427": "scene of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00145-00047428-00047846": "1970s and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00146-00047847-00048239": "their", "hmedp6HLAyY-00147-00048240-00048646": "their way of interpreting marx", "hmedp6HLAyY-00148-00048647-00049118": "struck me as making a lot of sense", "hmedp6HLAyY-00149-00049119-00049446": "because what happened was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00150-00049447-00049807": "that in the 1960s in italy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00151-00049808-00050207": "there was an attempt to create a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00152-00050208-00050727": "an understanding of marxism that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00153-00050728-00050943": "begins to look at the working class not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00154-00050944-00051446": "as a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00155-00051447-00051854": "fixed and given entity", "hmedp6HLAyY-00156-00051855-00052166": "but actually was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00157-00052167-00052438": "a dependent variable of development that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00158-00052439-00052519": "was the world", "hmedp6HLAyY-00159-00052520-00052703": "not as a dependent variable of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00160-00052704-00052903": "development", "hmedp6HLAyY-00161-00052904-00053282": "and in the process in studying this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00162-00053283-00053694": "non-dependent and autonomous", "hmedp6HLAyY-00163-00053695-00054119": "conception of the working class", "hmedp6HLAyY-00164-00054120-00054430": "we began to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00165-00054432-00054823": "also enter into the development of some", "hmedp6HLAyY-00166-00054824-00055023": "important ideas", "hmedp6HLAyY-00167-00055024-00055479": "in the wages for housework campaign", "hmedp6HLAyY-00168-00055479-00055847": "so if you want to put it this way", "hmedp6HLAyY-00169-00055848-00056087": "if we're going to kind of shake things", "hmedp6HLAyY-00170-00056088-00056215": "out", "hmedp6HLAyY-00171-00056216-00056582": "the political thinking that affected", "hmedp6HLAyY-00172-00056583-00057038": "me at this time was a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00173-00057039-00057582": "combination of the workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00174-00057583-00057903": "interpretation of marx", "hmedp6HLAyY-00175-00057904-00058215": "in the 1960s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00176-00058216-00058671": "that came from italy and uh the work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00177-00058672-00059207": "of silvia and others and others", "hmedp6HLAyY-00178-00059208-00059615": "around the wages for housework campaign", "hmedp6HLAyY-00179-00059616-00060111": "that brought together to the first", "hmedp6HLAyY-00180-00060112-00060454": "theoretical break of that time", "hmedp6HLAyY-00181-00060455-00060782": "for me which was the development of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00182-00060783-00060942": "ideas around", "hmedp6HLAyY-00183-00060944-00061311": "zero work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00184-00061312-00061575": "which attempted to bring wages for", "hmedp6HLAyY-00185-00061576-00062142": "housework and the workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00186-00062144-00062511": "streams that were developing at this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00187-00062512-00062694": "time", "hmedp6HLAyY-00188-00062695-00063287": "and so this leads to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00189-00063288-00063823": "my the point of my own development", "hmedp6HLAyY-00190-00063824-00064150": "that is much more continuous", "hmedp6HLAyY-00191-00064151-00064503": "so we we would like to ask you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00192-00064504-00064847": "about your concept of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00193-00064848-00065182": "energy work slash energy you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00194-00065183-00065550": "exist in keeping these two uh words or", "hmedp6HLAyY-00195-00065551-00065782": "these two concepts together can you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00196-00065783-00065943": "explain us that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00197-00065944-00066271": "how what's what what", "hmedp6HLAyY-00198-00066272-00066575": "what are you aiming at by keeping these", "hmedp6HLAyY-00199-00066576-00066950": "two ideas together", "hmedp6HLAyY-00200-00066951-00067294": "well uh the ideas", "hmedp6HLAyY-00201-00067295-00067687": "of work energy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00202-00067688-00068038": "work slash energy was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00203-00068039-00068543": "developed by", "hmedp6HLAyY-00204-00068544-00068982": "comrades and myself in the early", "hmedp6HLAyY-00205-00068983-00069294": "1980s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00206-00069295-00069719": "to first deal with", "hmedp6HLAyY-00207-00069720-00070247": "the notion of an energy crisis", "hmedp6HLAyY-00208-00070248-00070582": "i i and others", "hmedp6HLAyY-00209-00070583-00070887": "in my group that had formed", "hmedp6HLAyY-00210-00070888-00071482": "in the journal", "hmedp6HLAyY-00211-00071483-00072031": "of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00212-00072032-00072671": "midnight notes would be", "hmedp6HLAyY-00213-00072672-00073111": "responding to the attempt to understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00214-00073112-00073415": "the crisis of the late 70s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00215-00073416-00073791": "as a result of an energy crisis", "hmedp6HLAyY-00216-00073792-00074126": "and so we felt", "hmedp6HLAyY-00217-00074127-00074471": "that that was not an", "hmedp6HLAyY-00218-00074472-00074782": "adequate way of understanding", "hmedp6HLAyY-00219-00074783-00075094": "the situation we were", "hmedp6HLAyY-00220-00075095-00075423": "looking at an attempt to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00221-00075424-00075999": "bring together the notions", "hmedp6HLAyY-00222-00076000-00076406": "of marxism with the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00223-00076407-00076767": "theoretical developments of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00224-00076768-00077087": "the workers and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00225-00077088-00077687": "um", "hmedp6HLAyY-00226-00077688-00078055": "and the wages for housework campaign", "hmedp6HLAyY-00227-00078056-00078438": "bring them all together and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00228-00078439-00078782": "develop a conception of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00229-00078783-00079159": "what the crisis is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00230-00079160-00079471": "was involving not energy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00231-00079472-00079882": "because energy as a physical", "hmedp6HLAyY-00232-00079883-00080479": "quality was endless", "hmedp6HLAyY-00233-00080480-00080823": "but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00234-00080824-00081423": "the crisis of the 1980s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00235-00081424-00081806": "that capitalism was facing", "hmedp6HLAyY-00236-00081807-00082287": "involved a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00237-00082288-00082838": "a work crisis the ability to use energy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00238-00082839-00083326": "to extract surplus value from", "hmedp6HLAyY-00239-00083327-00083655": "the working class of the time", "hmedp6HLAyY-00240-00083656-00084055": "and as a consequence it was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00241-00084056-00084462": "not a crisis of energy but a crisis of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00242-00084463-00084662": "how much", "hmedp6HLAyY-00243-00084663-00084926": "work could be gotten from a particular", "hmedp6HLAyY-00244-00084927-00085135": "type of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00245-00085136-00085559": "arrangement of energy production", "hmedp6HLAyY-00246-00085560-00085882": "and this this began a process of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00247-00085883-00086191": "re-understanding what was", "hmedp6HLAyY-00248-00086192-00086638": "a uh very important", "hmedp6HLAyY-00249-00086639-00087103": "characteristic of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00250-00087104-00087423": "which is that if", "hmedp6HLAyY-00251-00087424-00087806": "the work that can be", "hmedp6HLAyY-00252-00087807-00088135": "developed i would have a particular", "hmedp6HLAyY-00253-00088136-00088199": "energy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00254-00088200-00088735": "structure begins to fall", "hmedp6HLAyY-00255-00088736-00089335": "if that ratio becomes less and less", "hmedp6HLAyY-00256-00089336-00089823": "profitable yeah profitable then", "hmedp6HLAyY-00257-00089824-00090206": "there would be a crisis of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00258-00090207-00090631": "of a serious nature which would require", "hmedp6HLAyY-00259-00090632-00090950": "a change in the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00260-00090951-00091367": "energy of a work regime", "hmedp6HLAyY-00261-00091368-00091703": "which capitalism needs to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00262-00091704-00092103": "use to replace an older", "hmedp6HLAyY-00263-00092104-00092718": "relationship between energy and work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00264-00092719-00093143": "so for example", "hmedp6HLAyY-00265-00093144-00093479": "the transition from", "hmedp6HLAyY-00266-00093480-00093847": "coal to oil as being the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00267-00093848-00094182": "s central kinds of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00268-00094183-00094606": "energy that are being used when", "hmedp6HLAyY-00269-00094607-00094894": "miners coal miners around the world", "hmedp6HLAyY-00270-00094895-00094943": "begin", "hmedp6HLAyY-00271-00094944-00095343": "to become", "hmedp6HLAyY-00272-00095344-00095799": "rejection of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00273-00095800-00096062": "which was increasingly beginning to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00274-00096063-00096279": "appear", "hmedp6HLAyY-00275-00096280-00096759": "then the shift from coal to oil", "hmedp6HLAyY-00276-00096760-00097191": "was pushed ahead", "hmedp6HLAyY-00277-00097192-00097511": "to create a new relationship between", "hmedp6HLAyY-00278-00097512-00097903": "energy and work and we began to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00279-00097904-00098335": "look at the various kinds of transitions", "hmedp6HLAyY-00280-00098336-00098655": "that have occurred and the other kinds", "hmedp6HLAyY-00281-00098656-00098831": "of transitions that didn't", "hmedp6HLAyY-00282-00098832-00099247": "occur so for example", "hmedp6HLAyY-00283-00099248-00099671": "the energy crisis of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00284-00099672-00099894": "going from cold to oil was was a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00285-00099895-00100111": "successful one", "hmedp6HLAyY-00286-00100112-00100511": "and far from over by the way", "hmedp6HLAyY-00287-00100512-00100703": "but the the transition that was supposed", "hmedp6HLAyY-00288-00100704-00100838": "to take place from the capitalist", "hmedp6HLAyY-00289-00100839-00100911": "viewpoint", "hmedp6HLAyY-00290-00100912-00101359": "yeah indeed", "hmedp6HLAyY-00291-00101360-00101767": "but i would", "hmedp6HLAyY-00292-00101768-00102103": "say that the assumption that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00293-00102104-00102335": "there would be another transition from", "hmedp6HLAyY-00294-00102336-00102454": "oil", "hmedp6HLAyY-00295-00102455-00102766": "to nuclear power", "hmedp6HLAyY-00296-00102767-00103351": "has not been successfully concluded", "hmedp6HLAyY-00297-00103352-00103702": "and it was very", "hmedp6HLAyY-00298-00103703-00104166": "important for us to point out", "hmedp6HLAyY-00299-00104167-00104527": "that if you want to understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00300-00104528-00104910": "the crises that are taking place in this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00301-00104911-00105302": "in the 20th century you have to see them", "hmedp6HLAyY-00302-00105303-00105654": "as transitions to different", "hmedp6HLAyY-00303-00105655-00105975": "kinds of relationships between", "hmedp6HLAyY-00304-00105976-00106366": "energy and work so could you say that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00305-00106367-00106558": "you know one another way of putting it", "hmedp6HLAyY-00306-00106559-00106686": "is you know", "hmedp6HLAyY-00307-00106688-00106871": "showing that the whole issue of energy", "hmedp6HLAyY-00308-00106872-00107054": "is connected with class struggling in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00309-00107055-00107310": "terms of more traditional terms", "hmedp6HLAyY-00310-00107311-00107510": "that you can understand the so-called", "hmedp6HLAyY-00311-00107511-00107710": "energy crisis without", "hmedp6HLAyY-00312-00107711-00107975": "connecting it to a whole process of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00313-00107976-00108119": "struggles", "hmedp6HLAyY-00314-00108120-00108390": "that you know are essential in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00315-00108391-00108510": "determining", "hmedp6HLAyY-00316-00108511-00108847": "the crisis yes as usual sylvia", "hmedp6HLAyY-00317-00108848-00109190": "you you put your", "hmedp6HLAyY-00318-00109191-00109575": "finger on an excellent way of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00319-00109576-00109975": "just well i've read your word", "hmedp6HLAyY-00320-00109976-00110534": "okay", "hmedp6HLAyY-00321-00110535-00110743": "there's a lot of work that has come out", "hmedp6HLAyY-00322-00110744-00111047": "of this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00323-00111048-00111495": "this energetic connection", "hmedp6HLAyY-00324-00111496-00111990": "so it would be the beginning of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00325-00111991-00112175": "understanding i think it's a very rich", "hmedp6HLAyY-00326-00112176-00112343": "concept", "hmedp6HLAyY-00327-00112344-00112623": "and it's only now that it's beginning to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00328-00112624-00112719": "be understood", "hmedp6HLAyY-00329-00112720-00113134": "i think and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00330-00113135-00113319": "you're going to begin you're beginning", "hmedp6HLAyY-00331-00113320-00113471": "to see the notion of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00332-00113472-00113783": "work energy as being", "hmedp6HLAyY-00333-00113783-00114143": "used more often", "hmedp6HLAyY-00334-00114144-00114719": "so i hope this helps yeah", "hmedp6HLAyY-00335-00114720-00114966": "in relation to that we would like to ask", "hmedp6HLAyY-00336-00114967-00115190": "you about", "hmedp6HLAyY-00337-00115191-00115551": "the notion of refusal work and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00338-00115552-00115927": "how it relates to valorization creation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00339-00115928-00116031": "of value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00340-00116032-00116366": "in particular you part of your work is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00341-00116367-00116583": "on machines and how", "hmedp6HLAyY-00342-00116583-00116975": "relative surplus value uh is a result", "hmedp6HLAyY-00343-00116976-00117295": "of a previous struggle against", "hmedp6HLAyY-00344-00117296-00117623": "absolute surplus value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00345-00117624-00117934": "so what's the the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00346-00117935-00118263": "the place of of uh the refusal of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00347-00118264-00118510": "in the creation of value and capital if", "hmedp6HLAyY-00348-00118511-00118647": "you can elaborate on that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00349-00118648-00118919": "and how it relates to two machines and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00350-00118920-00119083": "and the different generations of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00351-00119083-00119263": "machines", "hmedp6HLAyY-00352-00119264-00119702": "well let's see the most important", "hmedp6HLAyY-00353-00119703-00120071": "first response is to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00354-00120072-00120431": "point out that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00355-00120432-00120814": "work is not for work for capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00356-00120815-00121302": "is not a natural state of being", "hmedp6HLAyY-00357-00121303-00121639": "that when you look at", "hmedp6HLAyY-00358-00121640-00121958": "capitalism and it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00359-00121959-00122502": "roughly 500 years of history you see", "hmedp6HLAyY-00360-00122503-00122831": "class struggle continually finding", "hmedp6HLAyY-00361-00122832-00123095": "itself", "hmedp6HLAyY-00362-00123096-00123423": "revealed in many", "hmedp6HLAyY-00363-00123424-00123743": "different guises", "hmedp6HLAyY-00364-00123744-00124286": "and having many different forms", "hmedp6HLAyY-00365-00124288-00124663": "so for example there is a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00366-00124664-00125063": "an important", "hmedp6HLAyY-00367-00125064-00125399": "refusal of work that takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00368-00125400-00125710": "in the conditions", "hmedp6HLAyY-00369-00125711-00126078": "under which capitalism was involved", "hmedp6HLAyY-00370-00126079-00126751": "with extensive slavery", "hmedp6HLAyY-00371-00126752-00127175": "it was also important", "hmedp6HLAyY-00372-00127176-00127486": "to understand that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00373-00127488-00127910": "the struggle against slavery was not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00374-00127911-00128351": "only the product of some gentleman", "hmedp6HLAyY-00375-00128352-00128678": "in london working with", "hmedp6HLAyY-00376-00128679-00129039": "the parliament but the slave rebellions", "hmedp6HLAyY-00377-00129040-00129414": "which took place all over the planet", "hmedp6HLAyY-00378-00129415-00129799": "in the 18th and 19th", "hmedp6HLAyY-00379-00129800-00130134": "early 19th centuries that was the basis", "hmedp6HLAyY-00380-00130135-00130286": "of the end of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00381-00130288-00130871": "formal slavery and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00382-00130872-00131175": "this point is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00383-00131176-00131614": "very important first for just", "hmedp6HLAyY-00384-00131615-00131935": "getting your orientation in history", "hmedp6HLAyY-00385-00131936-00132102": "of beginning to understand why things", "hmedp6HLAyY-00386-00132103-00132247": "happen why", "hmedp6HLAyY-00387-00132248-00132566": "why capitalism changes", "hmedp6HLAyY-00388-00132567-00132927": "is because and this is the refusal of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00389-00132928-00133102": "work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00390-00133103-00133535": "that you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00391-00133536-00133823": "don't understand fundamental changes in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00392-00133824-00134031": "capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00393-00134032-00134511": "unless you see them as responses to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00394-00134512-00134727": "important changes within the working", "hmedp6HLAyY-00395-00134728-00134951": "class itself", "hmedp6HLAyY-00396-00134952-00135383": "and uh this is not a this this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00397-00135384-00135719": "very simple methodological point is now", "hmedp6HLAyY-00398-00135720-00135883": "beginning to be a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00399-00135884-00136190": "taken seriously", "hmedp6HLAyY-00400-00136191-00136599": "by many scholars", "hmedp6HLAyY-00401-00136600-00137023": "of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00402-00137024-00137478": "so and but then there's the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00403-00137479-00137687": "there's a point about the relationship", "hmedp6HLAyY-00404-00137688-00137959": "between refusal of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00405-00137960-00138683": "and it's in the way it gets expressed", "hmedp6HLAyY-00406-00138684-00139127": "in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00407-00139128-00139383": "it get well let's see it gets i'm trying", "hmedp6HLAyY-00408-00139384-00139590": "to find", "hmedp6HLAyY-00409-00139591-00139878": "that if you want to understand what the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00410-00139879-00139983": "value of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00411-00139984-00140359": "work comes from it has its", "hmedp6HLAyY-00412-00140360-00140663": "deep roots in the ability of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00413-00140664-00141047": "workers to say no", "hmedp6HLAyY-00414-00141048-00141239": "it's an essential part of the value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00415-00141240-00141751": "producing valorization process", "hmedp6HLAyY-00416-00141752-00142023": "can you explain that in what way saying", "hmedp6HLAyY-00417-00142024-00142295": "produces value in what sense", "hmedp6HLAyY-00418-00142296-00142575": "like can you go elaborate that a little", "hmedp6HLAyY-00419-00142576-00142631": "bit more", "hmedp6HLAyY-00420-00142632-00143199": "it's only when yeah it's only when", "hmedp6HLAyY-00421-00143200-00143502": "capitalism faces", "hmedp6HLAyY-00422-00143503-00144326": "the fact that work is not an automatic", "hmedp6HLAyY-00423-00144327-00144726": "process that it begins to value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00424-00144727-00144983": "it's only when workers begin to be able", "hmedp6HLAyY-00425-00144984-00145223": "to say no to work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00426-00145224-00145583": "that the work itself becomes valuable", "hmedp6HLAyY-00427-00145584-00145871": "you see what i mean and i think it's an", "hmedp6HLAyY-00428-00145872-00145971": "important point", "hmedp6HLAyY-00429-00145972-00146359": "methodologically and it gives a sense of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00430-00146360-00146431": "what it is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00431-00146432-00146854": "to create value what is essential about", "hmedp6HLAyY-00432-00146855-00147119": "the creation of value is not that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00433-00147120-00147463": "it's you create beautiful things", "hmedp6HLAyY-00434-00147464-00147790": "or useful things but that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00435-00147791-00148175": "you are able to see that the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00436-00148176-00148551": "production process is being run", "hmedp6HLAyY-00437-00148552-00148895": "by beings who can say no to the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00438-00148896-00149126": "production process", "hmedp6HLAyY-00439-00149127-00149543": "if that was not there then", "hmedp6HLAyY-00440-00149544-00149959": "work would become totally machine", "hmedp6HLAyY-00441-00149960-00150231": "production and the difference between", "hmedp6HLAyY-00442-00150232-00150375": "machines", "hmedp6HLAyY-00443-00150376-00150959": "and human beings would be lost", "hmedp6HLAyY-00444-00150960-00151263": "so", "hmedp6HLAyY-00445-00151264-00151590": "the refusal of work getting back to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00446-00151591-00151766": "becomes an essential part of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00447-00151767-00151935": "valorization process", "hmedp6HLAyY-00448-00151936-00152271": "of the degree to which labor the process", "hmedp6HLAyY-00449-00152272-00152390": "of expectation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00450-00152391-00152759": "it's organized yes", "hmedp6HLAyY-00451-00152760-00153071": "and i think it's an important", "hmedp6HLAyY-00452-00153072-00153390": "for me it it changed my", "hmedp6HLAyY-00453-00153391-00153839": "understanding the the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00454-00153840-00154166": "there's one there's a couple of steps", "hmedp6HLAyY-00455-00154167-00154543": "here one is that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00456-00154544-00154823": "one of the famous insights that we get", "hmedp6HLAyY-00457-00154824-00154975": "from reading marx", "hmedp6HLAyY-00458-00154976-00155254": "is that we begin to see human labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00459-00155255-00155375": "behind", "hmedp6HLAyY-00460-00155376-00155759": "the commodity form", "hmedp6HLAyY-00461-00155760-00156023": "and the value of the commodities coming", "hmedp6HLAyY-00462-00156024-00156247": "from human labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00463-00156248-00156526": "and that changes everything we begin to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00464-00156527-00156647": "understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00465-00156648-00156919": "why there's a particular screw that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00466-00156920-00157014": "takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00467-00157015-00157295": "that's being used to keep this piece of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00468-00157296-00157526": "machinery", "hmedp6HLAyY-00469-00157527-00157975": "stable and and i'm just using this as a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00470-00157976-00158366": "just throw away everything", "hmedp6HLAyY-00471-00158367-00158711": "was decided by somebody", "hmedp6HLAyY-00472-00158712-00159087": "to say that the screw goes clockwise", "hmedp6HLAyY-00473-00159088-00159159": "instead of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00474-00159160-00159502": "counterclockwise", "hmedp6HLAyY-00475-00159503-00159926": "right and that that insight", "hmedp6HLAyY-00476-00159927-00160278": "is an is more than enough for many", "hmedp6HLAyY-00477-00160279-00160647": "to say wow this world is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00478-00160648-00160902": "that that surrounds us with all the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00479-00160903-00161023": "little different", "hmedp6HLAyY-00480-00161024-00161399": "aspects of life", "hmedp6HLAyY-00481-00161400-00161702": "and we see that that's that's one of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00482-00161703-00161759": "great", "hmedp6HLAyY-00483-00161760-00162063": "contributions in marxism to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00484-00162064-00162343": "our understanding of class struggle but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00485-00162344-00162559": "then there's another part", "hmedp6HLAyY-00486-00162560-00162895": "that santa marx was not understanding", "hmedp6HLAyY-00487-00162896-00163287": "of it but did not make it central to his", "hmedp6HLAyY-00488-00163288-00163447": "analysis", "hmedp6HLAyY-00489-00163448-00163838": "which was and is the part that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00490-00163839-00164151": "not only is the decision to make that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00491-00164152-00164343": "particular screw", "hmedp6HLAyY-00492-00164344-00164711": "go clockwise but also the ability", "hmedp6HLAyY-00493-00164712-00165095": "of the workers and the designers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00494-00165096-00165638": "of this particular piece of machinery", "hmedp6HLAyY-00495-00165639-00166102": "who are able to say no", "hmedp6HLAyY-00496-00166103-00166683": "to the process of this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00497-00166684-00167047": "labor that takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00498-00167048-00167399": "and that puts into action", "hmedp6HLAyY-00499-00167400-00167623": "the forging of this particular little", "hmedp6HLAyY-00500-00167624-00167935": "piece of machinery", "hmedp6HLAyY-00501-00167936-00168199": "which then requires a whole area a whole", "hmedp6HLAyY-00502-00168200-00168271": "regime", "hmedp6HLAyY-00503-00168272-00168647": "of a organizational work of exploitation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00504-00168648-00168951": "so it's it's a side of things", "hmedp6HLAyY-00505-00168952-00169254": "that also is exciting", "hmedp6HLAyY-00506-00169255-00169559": "so i", "hmedp6HLAyY-00507-00169560-00169966": "in my post um", "hmedp6HLAyY-00508-00169967-00170335": "orthodox marxism situation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00509-00170336-00170590": "i began to have two conceptual", "hmedp6HLAyY-00510-00170591-00170719": "revolutions", "hmedp6HLAyY-00511-00170720-00171271": "one in the early 70s where i begin to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00512-00171272-00171559": "study marxism and the labor what's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00513-00171560-00171983": "called the labor theory of value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00514-00171984-00172283": "and then add to that labor theory of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00515-00172284-00172559": "value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00516-00172560-00172902": "the ability for workers to refuse to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00517-00172903-00173119": "work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00518-00173120-00173535": "and this opens up", "hmedp6HLAyY-00519-00173536-00173935": "another question which has to do with", "hmedp6HLAyY-00520-00173936-00174311": "the development of machines", "hmedp6HLAyY-00521-00174312-00174799": "machines yes and the recognition", "hmedp6HLAyY-00522-00174800-00175159": "that machinery", "hmedp6HLAyY-00523-00175160-00175463": "is the if we want to understand where", "hmedp6HLAyY-00524-00175464-00175638": "they come in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00525-00175639-00175854": "has to do with the response to workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00526-00175855-00176231": "struggles", "hmedp6HLAyY-00527-00176232-00176566": "these struggles are what make things", "hmedp6HLAyY-00528-00176567-00176959": "change and lead to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00529-00176960-00177278": "changes in machinery and also", "hmedp6HLAyY-00530-00177279-00177759": "the energy that drives these machines", "hmedp6HLAyY-00531-00177760-00178335": "and they come in response to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00532-00178336-00178566": "refusal of work which is a way of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00533-00178567-00178783": "speaking about", "hmedp6HLAyY-00534-00178784-00179135": "class struggle that brings out the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00535-00179136-00179335": "elements", "hmedp6HLAyY-00536-00179336-00179759": "the essential elements of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00537-00179760-00180078": "and what we describe as the class", "hmedp6HLAyY-00538-00180079-00180366": "struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-00539-00180367-00180759": "okay the next question we have", "hmedp6HLAyY-00540-00180760-00181190": "is about a concept that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00541-00181191-00181495": "in some way it puzzles us uh when", "hmedp6HLAyY-00542-00181496-00181590": "reading it because", "hmedp6HLAyY-00543-00181591-00181935": "it's difficult to translate into spanish", "hmedp6HLAyY-00544-00181936-00182263": "the idea of the manifold of work that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00545-00182264-00182575": "you talk about in in at least", "hmedp6HLAyY-00546-00182576-00182919": "in two of your books uh so we would like", "hmedp6HLAyY-00547-00182920-00183078": "to know what what what do you mean by", "hmedp6HLAyY-00548-00183079-00183223": "the manifold of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00549-00183224-00183599": "uh what's the the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00550-00183600-00183838": "the relationship between the different", "hmedp6HLAyY-00551-00183839-00183983": "kinds of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00552-00183984-00184487": "and this sort of uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-00553-00184488-00184790": "form of funneling work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00554-00184791-00185223": "towards capitalist accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00555-00185224-00185638": "yes the manifold of work is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00556-00185639-00185950": "a term that i'm not sure who exactly", "hmedp6HLAyY-00557-00185951-00186183": "used it first", "hmedp6HLAyY-00558-00186184-00186543": "but there's a point behind it", "hmedp6HLAyY-00559-00186544-00186887": "which is to say that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00560-00186888-00187214": "work that is essential for understanding", "hmedp6HLAyY-00561-00187215-00187495": "capitalism in the class struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-00562-00187496-00187743": "is not something that takes place alone", "hmedp6HLAyY-00563-00187744-00188047": "in a factory", "hmedp6HLAyY-00564-00188048-00188463": "there's not one form of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00565-00188464-00188814": "and there this this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00566-00188815-00189254": "conception of work that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00567-00189255-00189583": "we developed in the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00568-00189584-00190078": "early 1980s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00569-00190079-00190399": "we called manifold of work is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00570-00190400-00190911": "the fact that much work takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00571-00190912-00191247": "in areas where the word work was never", "hmedp6HLAyY-00572-00191248-00191319": "used", "hmedp6HLAyY-00573-00191320-00191702": "to and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00574-00191703-00192023": "so for example much of the work that is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00575-00192024-00192414": "involved in the reproduction of workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00576-00192415-00192647": "and this is a point that sylvia's made", "hmedp6HLAyY-00577-00192648-00192831": "no not syria the women's movement", "hmedp6HLAyY-00578-00192832-00193150": "the women's sylvia through the women's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00579-00193151-00193207": "movement", "hmedp6HLAyY-00580-00193208-00193383": "yeah yes you get through the women's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00581-00193384-00193511": "movement", "hmedp6HLAyY-00582-00193512-00194478": "and others see another women's movement", "hmedp6HLAyY-00583-00194479-00194887": "yes and also cognitive work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00584-00194888-00195143": "for example the work of cognition etc", "hmedp6HLAyY-00585-00195144-00195263": "which has usually", "hmedp6HLAyY-00586-00195264-00195559": "traditionally been more recognized but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00587-00195560-00195623": "it has", "hmedp6HLAyY-00588-00195624-00195943": "yeah student work exactly in fact george", "hmedp6HLAyY-00589-00195944-00196302": "was very involved in a whole struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-00590-00196303-00196607": "about wages for students yes", "hmedp6HLAyY-00591-00196608-00196823": "saying and in italy too there was a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00592-00196824-00196914": "whole movement", "hmedp6HLAyY-00593-00196915-00197295": "presalado like saying studying", "hmedp6HLAyY-00594-00197296-00197575": "his work because we don't study because", "hmedp6HLAyY-00595-00197576-00197599": "we", "hmedp6HLAyY-00596-00197600-00197902": "like it but you're forcing us to take a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00597-00197903-00198023": "degree", "hmedp6HLAyY-00598-00198024-00198247": "in order to become more productive", "hmedp6HLAyY-00599-00198248-00198519": "workers so we are working already", "hmedp6HLAyY-00600-00198520-00198831": "in preparing ourselves for future work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00601-00198832-00199135": "so we should be entitled to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00602-00199136-00199383": "remuneration and to be supported", "hmedp6HLAyY-00603-00199384-00199487": "economically", "hmedp6HLAyY-00604-00199488-00199678": "and it's been a big defeat in united", "hmedp6HLAyY-00605-00199679-00199838": "states when in fact", "hmedp6HLAyY-00606-00199839-00200207": "they have forced the students to pay", "hmedp6HLAyY-00607-00200208-00200414": "it's like paying you know to prepare", "hmedp6HLAyY-00608-00200415-00200614": "yourself to be exploited", "hmedp6HLAyY-00609-00200615-00200775": "or to prepare yourself to be more", "hmedp6HLAyY-00610-00200776-00200919": "productive", "hmedp6HLAyY-00611-00200920-00201214": "so yeah the work has many but i think", "hmedp6HLAyY-00612-00201215-00201438": "it's important this concept that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00613-00201439-00201766": "it work the manifold refers to forms of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00614-00201767-00201799": "work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00615-00201800-00202102": "that will never recognize this work yes", "hmedp6HLAyY-00616-00202103-00202150": "and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00617-00202151-00202575": "it's the the most important example", "hmedp6HLAyY-00618-00202576-00202766": "is the reproductive work that takes", "hmedp6HLAyY-00619-00202767-00202983": "place in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00620-00202984-00203278": "preparing workers both generationally", "hmedp6HLAyY-00621-00203279-00203311": "and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00622-00203312-00203871": "daily to return to work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00623-00203872-00204483": "and it's very much a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00624-00204484-00204919": "manifold it has many different", "hmedp6HLAyY-00625-00204919-00205231": "forms of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00626-00205232-00205542": "and that we begin to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00627-00205544-00206103": "expand in the nineteen", "hmedp6HLAyY-00628-00206104-00206455": "and into the 80s", "hmedp6HLAyY-00629-00206456-00206814": "so that we begin for example to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00630-00206815-00207206": "see that there's a tremendous amount of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00631-00207207-00207358": "work that takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00632-00207359-00207655": "in fact most of the work of the planet", "hmedp6HLAyY-00633-00207656-00207798": "takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00634-00207800-00208086": "in trying to get in creating a new", "hmedp6HLAyY-00635-00208087-00208390": "generation of workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00636-00208391-00208855": "and sex work emotional work this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00637-00208856-00208966": "[Music]", "hmedp6HLAyY-00638-00208967-00209310": "yeah raising of children all of that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00639-00209311-00209679": "it's a vast area of work i think that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00640-00209680-00209846": "the women's movement has really", "hmedp6HLAyY-00641-00209848-00210094": "contributed immensely", "hmedp6HLAyY-00642-00210096-00210455": "to showing the manifold of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00643-00210456-00210694": "but it also helps explain the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00644-00210696-00210887": "relationship between", "hmedp6HLAyY-00645-00210888-00211358": "uh work that creates value in the upper", "hmedp6HLAyY-00646-00211359-00211527": "levels of capital", "hmedp6HLAyY-00647-00211528-00211742": "and in the lower levels like that right", "hmedp6HLAyY-00648-00211744-00211927": "the higher composition", "hmedp6HLAyY-00649-00211928-00212110": "like the organic composition and the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00650-00212111-00212294": "lower the transfer", "hmedp6HLAyY-00651-00212296-00212519": "yeah maybe you can talk about that maybe", "hmedp6HLAyY-00652-00212519-00212703": "like would it be interesting if you can", "hmedp6HLAyY-00653-00212704-00212910": "explain how", "hmedp6HLAyY-00654-00212911-00213271": "there's a sentence that i will never", "hmedp6HLAyY-00655-00213271-00213375": "forget", "hmedp6HLAyY-00656-00213376-00213767": "that you you write something like uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-00657-00213767-00214046": "the in order to have a cyborg we need a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00658-00214048-00214282": "slave", "hmedp6HLAyY-00659-00214283-00214551": "um i think that's an interesting", "hmedp6HLAyY-00660-00214552-00214894": "idea like if you if you could elaborate", "hmedp6HLAyY-00661-00214896-00214942": "on that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00662-00214944-00215310": "yeah the high level uh the sectors are", "hmedp6HLAyY-00663-00215311-00215455": "high level exploitation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00664-00215456-00215742": "suck up some other what you call the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00665-00215744-00215798": "transfer", "hmedp6HLAyY-00666-00215800-00216167": "problem yes there's one of the things", "hmedp6HLAyY-00667-00216167-00216558": "that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00668-00216559-00216887": "i i myself begin to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00669-00216888-00217175": "take seriously after recognizing that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00670-00217176-00217423": "there's been a tremendous", "hmedp6HLAyY-00671-00217423-00217831": "hidden work that that takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00672-00217832-00218119": "and is not used and it's not referred to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00673-00218119-00218182": "as work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00674-00218183-00218494": "as for example the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00675-00218496-00218775": "work that goes into bringing up a child", "hmedp6HLAyY-00676-00218776-00218975": "for example", "hmedp6HLAyY-00677-00218976-00219287": "so we began to see that the formal", "hmedp6HLAyY-00678-00219288-00219694": "work that is presented as real work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00679-00219696-00220158": "is waged work that is openly", "hmedp6HLAyY-00680-00220159-00220663": "recognized by workers and capitalists", "hmedp6HLAyY-00681-00220664-00220982": "in often legal", "hmedp6HLAyY-00682-00220983-00221382": "their laws that tell us what is legally", "hmedp6HLAyY-00683-00221383-00221639": "considered work or not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00684-00221640-00221839": "whereas and for in fact there's a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00685-00221840-00222063": "tremendous amount of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00686-00222064-00222415": "that is not understood", "hmedp6HLAyY-00687-00222416-00222879": "as work but in fact is essential", "hmedp6HLAyY-00688-00222880-00223351": "for the creation of surplus value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00689-00223352-00223663": "okay now here hold on to your hats", "hmedp6HLAyY-00690-00223664-00224006": "and here we go to the very important", "hmedp6HLAyY-00691-00224007-00224342": "i think use", "hmedp6HLAyY-00692-00224344-00224823": "that the concept of organic composition", "hmedp6HLAyY-00693-00224823-00225158": "can be used to understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00694-00225159-00225534": "the nature of capitalism and why", "hmedp6HLAyY-00695-00225535-00225903": "capitalism is such a subtle", "hmedp6HLAyY-00696-00225904-00226223": "system where so much", "hmedp6HLAyY-00697-00226223-00226534": "is hidden from us so much", "hmedp6HLAyY-00698-00226535-00226863": "is tran is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00699-00226864-00227206": "a matter of transformation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00700-00227207-00227510": "in fact at this time", "hmedp6HLAyY-00701-00227511-00227951": "at the time of um", "hmedp6HLAyY-00702-00227952-00228271": "the writing of of capital", "hmedp6HLAyY-00703-00228271-00228742": "by marx i counted there were", "hmedp6HLAyY-00704-00228744-00229046": "23 chapter", "hmedp6HLAyY-00705-00229048-00229398": "and chapter titles that include the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00706-00229400-00229806": "notion of transformation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00707-00229807-00230063": "of which of course the transformation of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00708-00230064-00230294": "value into prices", "hmedp6HLAyY-00709-00230296-00230687": "is the can is the most well-known one", "hmedp6HLAyY-00710-00230688-00231246": "but if you open up a volume of capital", "hmedp6HLAyY-00711-00231248-00231582": "volume one you'd see that there's a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00712-00231583-00231734": "tremendous number of other", "hmedp6HLAyY-00713-00231735-00232055": "uses of the term transformation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00714-00232056-00232471": "and it's this transformation that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00715-00232471-00232782": "creates a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00716-00232783-00233110": "level of hiddenness", "hmedp6HLAyY-00717-00233111-00233398": "in the system so that if you try to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00718-00233400-00233567": "follow", "hmedp6HLAyY-00719-00233567-00233951": "where this particular work takes place", "hmedp6HLAyY-00720-00233952-00234406": "and how its value is created", "hmedp6HLAyY-00721-00234407-00234863": "and where it ends up in the system", "hmedp6HLAyY-00722-00234864-00235151": "you see it's not an easy process it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00723-00235152-00235334": "not a direct process", "hmedp6HLAyY-00724-00235335-00235679": "most commodities", "hmedp6HLAyY-00725-00235680-00236510": "have value that is not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00726-00236511-00236798": "equivalent to the amount of labor that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00727-00236800-00236975": "goes into", "hmedp6HLAyY-00728-00236976-00237391": "the production of that commodity", "hmedp6HLAyY-00729-00237392-00237894": "and it's it's very important to say", "hmedp6HLAyY-00730-00237896-00238198": "to look into where does it go", "hmedp6HLAyY-00731-00238200-00238542": "because this it's it's this fact", "hmedp6HLAyY-00732-00238544-00238703": "it makes it difficult for us to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00733-00238704-00238910": "understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00734-00238911-00239342": "where where the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00735-00239344-00239806": "particular form of labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00736-00239807-00240006": "that goes into the production of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00737-00240007-00240167": "commodity", "hmedp6HLAyY-00738-00240167-00240567": "gets transformed", "hmedp6HLAyY-00739-00240567-00240903": "into other parts of the system", "hmedp6HLAyY-00740-00240904-00241239": "and a simple way", "hmedp6HLAyY-00741-00241240-00241494": "a simple way of understanding that is by", "hmedp6HLAyY-00742-00241496-00241623": "using the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00743-00241623-00241967": "classic marxist conception of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00744-00241967-00242606": "organic composition of constant capital", "hmedp6HLAyY-00745-00242607-00242919": "which is a technical way of saying", "hmedp6HLAyY-00746-00242919-00243279": "that if you want to understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00747-00243280-00243751": "machines if you want to understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00748-00243752-00243942": "the capitalist system as a whole you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00749-00243944-00244103": "have to see", "hmedp6HLAyY-00750-00244104-00244487": "that the commodities that are", "hmedp6HLAyY-00751-00244488-00244791": "being produced with a lot of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00752-00244792-00245151": "machinery and very little", "hmedp6HLAyY-00753-00245152-00245575": "human labor as you can see and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00754-00245576-00246079": "for example in the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00755-00246080-00246382": "platforms that are used", "hmedp6HLAyY-00756-00246383-00246798": "for the extraction of oil", "hmedp6HLAyY-00757-00246800-00247119": "from ocean", "hmedp6HLAyY-00758-00247119-00247471": "from the oceans", "hmedp6HLAyY-00759-00247471-00247863": "when we see that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00760-00247864-00248382": "20 30 men and a few women", "hmedp6HLAyY-00761-00248383-00248798": "would work in a platform", "hmedp6HLAyY-00762-00248800-00249198": "that is used for extracting oil", "hmedp6HLAyY-00763-00249200-00249694": "in the sub-ocean", "hmedp6HLAyY-00764-00249696-00250223": "localities", "hmedp6HLAyY-00765-00250223-00250767": "are have a very high organic composition", "hmedp6HLAyY-00766-00250767-00251310": "whereas the work of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00767-00251311-00251791": "for example the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00768-00251792-00252310": "workers in the coal mines of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00769-00252311-00252863": "britain in the time of marx", "hmedp6HLAyY-00770-00252864-00253023": "would have a very low organic", "hmedp6HLAyY-00771-00253023-00253391": "composition", "hmedp6HLAyY-00772-00253392-00253887": "can i maybe um", "hmedp6HLAyY-00773-00253888-00254294": "use this example to to to to nail down", "hmedp6HLAyY-00774-00254296-00254606": "the concept because it seems to me that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00775-00254607-00254910": "you know in your work they", "hmedp6HLAyY-00776-00254911-00255142": "you have used over and over they you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00777-00255144-00255255": "know", "hmedp6HLAyY-00778-00255256-00255606": "the way all companies the whole oil", "hmedp6HLAyY-00779-00255607-00255758": "industry extracted", "hmedp6HLAyY-00780-00255759-00256087": "it's accumulating surplus right it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00781-00256088-00256639": "in fact being one of the richest", "hmedp6HLAyY-00782-00256640-00256919": "enterprises capitalist enterprises in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00783-00256919-00257094": "the planet", "hmedp6HLAyY-00784-00257096-00257398": "it's accumulating is a good example of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00785-00257400-00257519": "this transfer", "hmedp6HLAyY-00786-00257519-00257855": "right because it employs very few", "hmedp6HLAyY-00787-00257856-00257967": "workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00788-00257967-00258182": "and so in many ways is a kind of an", "hmedp6HLAyY-00789-00258183-00258294": "enigma", "hmedp6HLAyY-00790-00258296-00258455": "how they are accumulating so much", "hmedp6HLAyY-00791-00258456-00258679": "surplus if they actually employ", "hmedp6HLAyY-00792-00258680-00258982": "relatively speaking very few workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00793-00258983-00259175": "whereas i think much of your work has", "hmedp6HLAyY-00794-00259176-00259358": "shown that yes", "hmedp6HLAyY-00795-00259359-00259775": "because of this transfer that labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00796-00259776-00260182": "is in capitalism is often transferred", "hmedp6HLAyY-00797-00260183-00260334": "from sectors", "hmedp6HLAyY-00798-00260335-00260623": "with a very low level of technological", "hmedp6HLAyY-00799-00260623-00260782": "development", "hmedp6HLAyY-00800-00260783-00261006": "into the sectors who have a higher level", "hmedp6HLAyY-00801-00261007-00261182": "of technological development", "hmedp6HLAyY-00802-00261183-00261423": "which basically have the capacity to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00803-00261423-00261567": "extract", "hmedp6HLAyY-00804-00261567-00261806": "and to force this transfer so that for", "hmedp6HLAyY-00805-00261807-00261919": "example", "hmedp6HLAyY-00806-00261919-00262263": "your companies", "hmedp6HLAyY-00807-00262264-00262615": "accumulate an immense amount of value", "hmedp6HLAyY-00808-00262616-00263030": "not because of the labor on the platform", "hmedp6HLAyY-00809-00263031-00263343": "on the oil rig but accumulate", "hmedp6HLAyY-00810-00263344-00263679": "the labor and the surplus value from all", "hmedp6HLAyY-00811-00263680-00263806": "the people", "hmedp6HLAyY-00812-00263807-00264103": "while paying for electricity bills or", "hmedp6HLAyY-00813-00264104-00264334": "every time for instance", "hmedp6HLAyY-00814-00264335-00264710": "an increase they have to work more", "hmedp6HLAyY-00815-00264711-00265015": "to pays for the new gas bill", "hmedp6HLAyY-00816-00265016-00265319": "electricity bill etc etc so they have", "hmedp6HLAyY-00817-00265320-00265567": "millions of little spots", "hmedp6HLAyY-00818-00265568-00265782": "you know a little restaurant a little", "hmedp6HLAyY-00819-00265783-00265887": "kitchen a little", "hmedp6HLAyY-00820-00265888-00266134": "with a very low low level of and yet", "hmedp6HLAyY-00821-00266135-00266287": "nevertheless", "hmedp6HLAyY-00822-00266288-00266575": "you know i mean you've talked many times", "hmedp6HLAyY-00823-00266576-00266743": "that we are all the oil workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00824-00266744-00266871": "proletariat", "hmedp6HLAyY-00825-00266872-00267095": "that you all work as politicians is not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00826-00267096-00267271": "only the people are working on their", "hmedp6HLAyY-00827-00267272-00267358": "eggs", "hmedp6HLAyY-00828-00267359-00267671": "because we are all paying all our labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00829-00267672-00267975": "in so far as we are paying gas bills", "hmedp6HLAyY-00830-00267976-00268230": "electricity bill all of this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00831-00268231-00268382": "we are all contributing to the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00832-00268383-00268551": "accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00833-00268552-00268791": "of the old companies and this again", "hmedp6HLAyY-00834-00268792-00268895": "shows", "hmedp6HLAyY-00835-00268896-00269151": "that you know the point you were making", "hmedp6HLAyY-00836-00269152-00269271": "now", "hmedp6HLAyY-00837-00269272-00269671": "that in capitalism it's very deceptive", "hmedp6HLAyY-00838-00269672-00269991": "where the surplus value is coming from", "hmedp6HLAyY-00839-00269992-00270295": "it doesn't necessarily come", "hmedp6HLAyY-00840-00270296-00270534": "live from the labor that produces a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00841-00270535-00270671": "particular commodity", "hmedp6HLAyY-00842-00270672-00271047": "immediately right but behind the labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00843-00271048-00271271": "that produces this commodity there is a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00844-00271272-00271430": "whole other", "hmedp6HLAyY-00845-00271431-00271767": "yeah which also in my view i mean i've", "hmedp6HLAyY-00846-00271768-00272158": "thought about i've applied that concept", "hmedp6HLAyY-00847-00272159-00272406": "also to the question of housework for", "hmedp6HLAyY-00848-00272407-00272527": "instance", "hmedp6HLAyY-00849-00272528-00272903": "that you know the accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-00850-00272904-00273223": "of surplus value by", "hmedp6HLAyY-00851-00273224-00273606": "in any particular place of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-00852-00273607-00273910": "it's not dependent only on the labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00853-00273911-00274134": "that is done by those particular workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-00854-00274135-00274271": "but is dependent on", "hmedp6HLAyY-00855-00274272-00274582": "also by the reproductive work that is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00856-00274583-00274782": "done in the kitchen in the bedroom in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00857-00274783-00275134": "the communities etc etc in the schools", "hmedp6HLAyY-00858-00275135-00275447": "and so that they yeah we tend to have a", "hmedp6HLAyY-00859-00275448-00275695": "very mechanical view", "hmedp6HLAyY-00860-00275696-00275975": "of the way you know capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00861-00275976-00276191": "accumulates", "hmedp6HLAyY-00862-00276192-00276591": "wealth and value that in fact", "hmedp6HLAyY-00863-00276592-00276863": "it's much more complicated and it's not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00864-00276864-00277047": "so localized", "hmedp6HLAyY-00865-00277048-00277391": "and that's why in a way the struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-00866-00277392-00277519": "it's a struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-00867-00277520-00277879": "really it's more and more difficult", "hmedp6HLAyY-00868-00277880-00278247": "to to win you know by by", "hmedp6HLAyY-00869-00278248-00278695": "when it is localized yeah", "hmedp6HLAyY-00870-00278696-00279015": "but anyway i did them as usual no but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00871-00279016-00279175": "when you talk about how organic", "hmedp6HLAyY-00872-00279176-00279382": "composition i think it's also there is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00873-00279383-00279623": "something in marks that the sectors with", "hmedp6HLAyY-00874-00279624-00279751": "higher level", "hmedp6HLAyY-00875-00279752-00279934": "of organic composition have this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00876-00279935-00280063": "capacity", "hmedp6HLAyY-00877-00280064-00280391": "to suck to draw labor from", "hmedp6HLAyY-00878-00280392-00280655": "other sectors you know that's why you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00879-00280656-00280743": "know", "hmedp6HLAyY-00880-00280744-00281182": "then in order to have a nuclear worker", "hmedp6HLAyY-00881-00281183-00281375": "you need to have a slave in order to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00882-00281376-00281567": "have an industrial worker you need to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00883-00281568-00281630": "have", "hmedp6HLAyY-00884-00281631-00281823": "and that sounds very very interesting", "hmedp6HLAyY-00885-00281824-00282103": "because then the whole question i", "hmedp6HLAyY-00886-00282104-00282419": "of hierarchies and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00887-00282420-00282758": "ideologies that are just defined", "hmedp6HLAyY-00888-00282759-00283110": "in a hierarchical life you can see like", "hmedp6HLAyY-00889-00283111-00283399": "racism and sexism there's also ways", "hmedp6HLAyY-00890-00283400-00283782": "of hiding right this transfer", "hmedp6HLAyY-00891-00283783-00284095": "hiding those transfers yes as base", "hmedp6HLAyY-00892-00284096-00284399": "not only of keeping people divided", "hmedp6HLAyY-00893-00284400-00284791": "creating antagonism etc but also as", "hmedp6HLAyY-00894-00284792-00285151": "part of a machinery of hiding", "hmedp6HLAyY-00895-00285152-00285471": "of occupation okay", "hmedp6HLAyY-00896-00285472-00285743": "oh yes yeah we're speaking english i", "hmedp6HLAyY-00897-00285744-00285815": "think that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00898-00285816-00286175": "yeah this is well", "hmedp6HLAyY-00899-00286176-00286519": "well put and i i think that it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00900-00286520-00286791": "important for us to understand this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00901-00286792-00286863": "point for", "hmedp6HLAyY-00902-00286864-00287247": "for all sorts of struggles", "hmedp6HLAyY-00903-00287248-00287606": "and to look at the the kind of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00904-00287607-00287943": "alliances that are possible right", "hmedp6HLAyY-00905-00287944-00288279": "instead of beginning to look at this is", "hmedp6HLAyY-00906-00288280-00288487": "my work and i'll struggle around", "hmedp6HLAyY-00907-00288488-00288806": "this particular piece of the pie", "hmedp6HLAyY-00908-00288807-00289071": "without recognizing that there's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00909-00289072-00289287": "actually a much larger struggle the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00910-00289288-00289527": "capitalists are fighting", "hmedp6HLAyY-00911-00289528-00289951": "and so it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-00912-00289952-00290319": "it's very important that we understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00913-00290320-00290679": "and be able to integrate pieces of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00914-00290680-00290982": "marxism with other parts other ways", "hmedp6HLAyY-00915-00290983-00291303": "and new concepts that are", "hmedp6HLAyY-00916-00291304-00291703": "important and that uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-00917-00291704-00292119": "we can begin to integrate into the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00918-00292120-00292439": "21st century because it took a little", "hmedp6HLAyY-00919-00292440-00292567": "time for", "hmedp6HLAyY-00920-00292568-00292910": "it took about 40 years i think", "hmedp6HLAyY-00921-00292911-00293247": "for these ideas to begin to enter into", "hmedp6HLAyY-00922-00293248-00293406": "the mainstream", "hmedp6HLAyY-00923-00293407-00293703": "now i mean even our gathering here this", "hmedp6HLAyY-00924-00293704-00293823": "morning", "hmedp6HLAyY-00925-00293824-00294134": "is an example of the increasing", "hmedp6HLAyY-00926-00294135-00294582": "interest in these ideas", "hmedp6HLAyY-00927-00294583-00294910": "and uh hopefully", "hmedp6HLAyY-00928-00294911-00295158": "at least i have the hope yeah nobody", "hmedp6HLAyY-00929-00295159-00295303": "there's a new understanding the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00930-00295304-00295615": "coloniality of racism sexism i'm not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00931-00295616-00295799": "you know then it's not like what is the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00932-00295800-00295958": "relation with the class struggle which", "hmedp6HLAyY-00933-00295959-00296079": "has been the traditional", "hmedp6HLAyY-00934-00296080-00296367": "conception lie as if they were outside", "hmedp6HLAyY-00935-00296368-00296423": "of it", "hmedp6HLAyY-00936-00296424-00296575": "as if they had nothing to do with", "hmedp6HLAyY-00937-00296576-00296806": "exploitation of labor and well", "hmedp6HLAyY-00938-00296807-00297127": "something else right and now that in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00939-00297128-00297327": "fact coloniality for example as", "hmedp6HLAyY-00940-00297328-00297575": "a essential structural dimension or", "hmedp6HLAyY-00941-00297576-00297734": "capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00942-00297735-00298143": "or a season being and an unpaid labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-00943-00298144-00298430": "slave labor force labour being all", "hmedp6HLAyY-00944-00298431-00298703": "essential structural element capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00945-00298704-00298999": "that i think is becoming much more part", "hmedp6HLAyY-00946-00299000-00299223": "of the general discourse", "hmedp6HLAyY-00947-00299224-00299527": "yeah so our next question", "hmedp6HLAyY-00948-00299528-00299782": "is in relation to the category of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00949-00299783-00299943": "neoliberalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00950-00299944-00300230": "you don't use much this category we", "hmedp6HLAyY-00951-00300231-00300367": "would like to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00952-00300368-00300654": "if you can explain us why are you not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00953-00300655-00300767": "interested in", "hmedp6HLAyY-00954-00300768-00301006": "talking about neoliberalism or or you", "hmedp6HLAyY-00955-00301007-00301110": "have other", "hmedp6HLAyY-00956-00301111-00301375": "ways of explaining the same phenomenon", "hmedp6HLAyY-00957-00301376-00301495": "that probably add", "hmedp6HLAyY-00958-00301496-00301847": "some more nuances to to the problem", "hmedp6HLAyY-00959-00301848-00302199": "to explaining the problem", "hmedp6HLAyY-00960-00302200-00302582": "well it's not that i'm not", "hmedp6HLAyY-00961-00302583-00302958": "interested in this notion", "hmedp6HLAyY-00962-00302959-00303319": "but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00963-00303320-00303679": "i wanted to i've dealt with the notion", "hmedp6HLAyY-00964-00303680-00303743": "of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00965-00303744-00304127": "neoliberalism under a different title", "hmedp6HLAyY-00966-00304128-00304510": "which is capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00967-00304511-00304839": "in other words as far as i understand", "hmedp6HLAyY-00968-00304840-00305158": "what neoliberalism is is the attempt to", "hmedp6HLAyY-00969-00305159-00305367": "totalize", "hmedp6HLAyY-00970-00305368-00305679": "the concepts of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00971-00305680-00306006": "the liberal tradition of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00972-00306007-00306582": "18th century and 19th centuries", "hmedp6HLAyY-00973-00306583-00306991": "it was the attempt to presumably say", "hmedp6HLAyY-00974-00306992-00307382": "that commodities", "hmedp6HLAyY-00975-00307383-00307687": "ought to be free free", "hmedp6HLAyY-00976-00307688-00308039": "freely exchanged but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00977-00308040-00308358": "there were limits as to what", "hmedp6HLAyY-00978-00308359-00308919": "could be freely exchanged and", "hmedp6HLAyY-00979-00308920-00309230": "what neoliberalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-00980-00309231-00309558": "as far as i understand it is is an", "hmedp6HLAyY-00981-00309559-00309871": "attempt to totalize", "hmedp6HLAyY-00982-00309872-00310406": "is to say that all forms of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00983-00310407-00310719": "transactions are really commodity", "hmedp6HLAyY-00984-00310720-00310934": "transactions", "hmedp6HLAyY-00985-00310935-00311343": "so that the state operates", "hmedp6HLAyY-00986-00311344-00311654": "as a purveyor of particular kinds of", "hmedp6HLAyY-00987-00311655-00311863": "commodities", "hmedp6HLAyY-00988-00311864-00312175": "and that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00989-00312176-00312647": "in a way what neoliberalism is about", "hmedp6HLAyY-00990-00312648-00312967": "is to say that", "hmedp6HLAyY-00991-00312968-00313682": "all forms of social interactions", "hmedp6HLAyY-00992-00313683-00314087": "are", "hmedp6HLAyY-00993-00314088-00314487": "are basically commodities", "hmedp6HLAyY-00994-00314488-00315082": "and um", "hmedp6HLAyY-00995-00315083-00315247": "mercenary", "hmedp6HLAyY-00996-00315248-00315623": "yeah it's commodities but", "hmedp6HLAyY-00997-00315624-00316039": "so there's this similarity", "hmedp6HLAyY-00998-00316040-00316527": "between the", "hmedp6HLAyY-00999-00316528-00316958": "the concept of of neoliberalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01000-00316959-00317479": "with the notions that we developed", "hmedp6HLAyY-01001-00317480-00317799": "but with a very different meaning", "hmedp6HLAyY-01002-00317800-00318206": "and a very different consequence", "hmedp6HLAyY-01003-00318207-00318782": "capitalism is neoliberalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01004-00318783-00319282": "and that's why in a way it's not been", "hmedp6HLAyY-01005-00319283-00319399": "our", "hmedp6HLAyY-01006-00319400-00319767": "uh is that totalizing", "hmedp6HLAyY-01007-00319768-00320119": "capitalism yeah and also the concept of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01008-00320120-00320263": "the new enclosure", "hmedp6HLAyY-01009-00320264-00320758": "it's also part of that that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01010-00320759-00321015": "it's it's part of it's been part of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01011-00321016-00321167": "categories that has been used to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01012-00321168-00321367": "describe this new form", "hmedp6HLAyY-01013-00321368-00321695": "this new phase of capitalistic that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01014-00321696-00322006": "um you know whereas", "hmedp6HLAyY-01015-00322007-00322251": "generally the accent is placed on", "hmedp6HLAyY-01016-00322252-00322415": "neoliberalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01017-00322416-00322799": "you know also this new phase also", "hmedp6HLAyY-01018-00322800-00323079": "you and also i've been using a lot the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01019-00323080-00323558": "notion of the new enclosure", "hmedp6HLAyY-01020-00323559-00323863": "yes there's such it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-01021-00323864-00324158": "that's a very important part of the way", "hmedp6HLAyY-01022-00324159-00324271": "in which", "hmedp6HLAyY-01023-00324272-00324654": "we've developed concepts", "hmedp6HLAyY-01024-00324655-00324958": "in the 1990s and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01025-00324959-00325263": "it's it's important for", "hmedp6HLAyY-01026-00325264-00325823": "us to understand it because we see that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01027-00325824-00326351": "there's a relationship between the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01028-00326352-00326815": "the development of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01029-00326816-00327239": "the expulsion of people from the means", "hmedp6HLAyY-01030-00327240-00327406": "of production", "hmedp6HLAyY-01031-00327407-00327815": "and the means of reproduction", "hmedp6HLAyY-01032-00327816-00328158": "as an essential part of the creation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01033-00328159-00328734": "of a society in which all forms of life", "hmedp6HLAyY-01034-00328735-00329082": "are commodified", "hmedp6HLAyY-01035-00329083-00329430": "life yeah we could does it by enclosure", "hmedp6HLAyY-01036-00329431-00329582": "of also", "hmedp6HLAyY-01037-00329583-00329854": "not only land but in closure of social", "hmedp6HLAyY-01038-00329855-00329919": "relations", "hmedp6HLAyY-01039-00329920-00330287": "urban spaces bodies etc", "hmedp6HLAyY-01040-00330288-00330487": "so this has been a way in which you", "hmedp6HLAyY-01041-00330488-00330710": "we've been another way of describing the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01042-00330711-00330927": "class struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-01043-00330928-00331106": "because on the one side is a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01044-00331107-00331327": "commodification", "hmedp6HLAyY-01045-00331328-00331615": "that is called neoliberalism and on the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01046-00331616-00331703": "other side", "hmedp6HLAyY-01047-00331704-00332151": "we developed the notion of the commons", "hmedp6HLAyY-01048-00332152-00332527": "as being the uh what in fact is being", "hmedp6HLAyY-01049-00332528-00332727": "struggled over", "hmedp6HLAyY-01050-00332728-00333047": "this is a very i think it would be", "hmedp6HLAyY-01051-00333048-00333423": "it's been a useful way of understanding", "hmedp6HLAyY-01052-00333424-00333871": "the way class struggle operates", "hmedp6HLAyY-01053-00333872-00334303": "and the new forms of antagonism and the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01054-00334304-00334406": "new forms of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01055-00334407-00334758": "changing social relations and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01056-00334759-00335158": "and as a consequence also the struggles", "hmedp6HLAyY-01057-00335159-00335495": "around the commons because we we", "hmedp6HLAyY-01058-00335496-00335830": "hearken back to the origins of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01059-00335831-00335958": "capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01060-00335959-00336367": "now we use term that mox uses", "hmedp6HLAyY-01061-00336368-00336806": "but in a different and more generalized", "hmedp6HLAyY-01062-00336807-00337478": "fashion of the new enclosures", "hmedp6HLAyY-01063-00337479-00337782": "so our next question was precisely about", "hmedp6HLAyY-01064-00337783-00338278": "comments and enclosures um", "hmedp6HLAyY-01065-00338279-00338503": "maybe we can divide the question in two", "hmedp6HLAyY-01066-00338504-00338663": "parts", "hmedp6HLAyY-01067-00338664-00339110": "one first we would like to ask you about", "hmedp6HLAyY-01068-00339111-00339375": "the history of this discussion uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01069-00339376-00339519": "because", "hmedp6HLAyY-01070-00339520-00339823": "marx talks about", "hmedp6HLAyY-01071-00339824-00340282": "the legislation of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01072-00340283-00340567": "that begins to create enclosures", "hmedp6HLAyY-01073-00340568-00340910": "in britain and elsewhere in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01074-00340911-00341358": "the capital uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01075-00341359-00341551": "and there's a discussion of primitive", "hmedp6HLAyY-01076-00341552-00341687": "accumulation in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01077-00341688-00342006": "the uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01078-00342007-00342263": "we would like to ask you how this uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01079-00342264-00342391": "discussion", "hmedp6HLAyY-01080-00342392-00342695": "reappears or resurfaces in the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01081-00342696-00343047": "80s or or around the 80s", "hmedp6HLAyY-01082-00343048-00343519": "and uh because it it is a very", "hmedp6HLAyY-01083-00343520-00343863": "important uh point in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01084-00343864-00344271": "in in in in the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01085-00344272-00344558": "in your work and also in the work of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01086-00344559-00344639": "celia", "hmedp6HLAyY-01087-00344640-00344887": "and peter linebaugh other people that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01088-00344888-00345006": "are related to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01089-00345007-00345391": "to you so we would like to ask you how", "hmedp6HLAyY-01090-00345392-00345599": "it appears reappears", "hmedp6HLAyY-01091-00345600-00345943": "in after so many years", "hmedp6HLAyY-01092-00345944-00346158": "and also the second part of the question", "hmedp6HLAyY-01093-00346159-00346278": "would be", "hmedp6HLAyY-01094-00346279-00346678": "how can we relate today", "hmedp6HLAyY-01095-00346679-00347030": "uh this is more of a what is to be done", "hmedp6HLAyY-01096-00347031-00347439": "question uh what how can we relate today", "hmedp6HLAyY-01097-00347440-00347839": "the struggle for higher wages or", "hmedp6HLAyY-01098-00347840-00348206": "working class struggles to the struggles", "hmedp6HLAyY-01099-00348207-00348471": "for both keeping the comments and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01100-00348472-00348682": "commenting like creating new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01101-00348683-00348991": "comments more so uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01102-00348992-00349343": "that you you is in somewhere you say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01103-00349344-00349606": "that one way that way of relating these", "hmedp6HLAyY-01104-00349607-00349806": "two struggles could be", "hmedp6HLAyY-01105-00349807-00350127": "finding alliances between", "hmedp6HLAyY-01106-00350128-00350399": "working class struggles and the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01107-00350400-00350510": "community", "hmedp6HLAyY-01108-00350511-00350815": "and solidarity economics like", "hmedp6HLAyY-01109-00350816-00351130": "economic economics based on on", "hmedp6HLAyY-01110-00351131-00351558": "cooperatives or", "hmedp6HLAyY-01111-00351559-00351887": "different sorts of commons um", "hmedp6HLAyY-01112-00351888-00352206": "more so taking into account that uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01113-00352207-00352630": "on this is a dispute with with the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01114-00352631-00353054": "the way capital uh leads consumerism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01115-00353055-00353110": "towards", "hmedp6HLAyY-01116-00353111-00353423": "the big brands and to other kinds of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01117-00353424-00353830": "uh like away from from these uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01118-00353831-00354158": "common space economics so", "hmedp6HLAyY-01119-00354159-00354423": "how the first question the first part of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01120-00354424-00354534": "the question is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01121-00354535-00354710": "a little bit of history of of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01122-00354711-00354878": "commons and clausures", "hmedp6HLAyY-01123-00354879-00355127": "discussion and second part would be how", "hmedp6HLAyY-01124-00355128-00355254": "to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01125-00355255-00355575": "uh how can we", "hmedp6HLAyY-01126-00355576-00355982": "use this struggle for the commons", "hmedp6HLAyY-01127-00355983-00356430": "and in relation to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01128-00356431-00356630": "class struggle other forms of class", "hmedp6HLAyY-01129-00356631-00356895": "struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-01130-00356896-00357295": "okay let me just", "hmedp6HLAyY-01131-00357296-00357558": "say that the concept of primitive", "hmedp6HLAyY-01132-00357559-00357695": "accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01133-00357696-00357999": "it's not exactly a marxist concept", "hmedp6HLAyY-01134-00358000-00358303": "marx says that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01135-00358304-00358695": "this is a concept that was developed by", "hmedp6HLAyY-01136-00358696-00359239": "adam smith and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01137-00359240-00359591": "it involved a particular kind of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01138-00359592-00359958": "accumulation of capital", "hmedp6HLAyY-01139-00359959-00360263": "that took place", "hmedp6HLAyY-01140-00360264-00360551": "in order to satisfy the essential", "hmedp6HLAyY-01141-00360552-00360710": "conditions for the development of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01142-00360711-00360878": "capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01143-00360879-00361399": "and marx develops", "hmedp6HLAyY-01144-00361400-00361743": "the notion of primitive accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01145-00361744-00362047": "to point out that this process", "hmedp6HLAyY-01146-00362048-00362351": "of satisfying the initial conditions for", "hmedp6HLAyY-01147-00362352-00362703": "the creation of a capitalist society", "hmedp6HLAyY-01148-00362704-00363319": "uh is rooted in a tremendous violence", "hmedp6HLAyY-01149-00363320-00363671": "that took place", "hmedp6HLAyY-01150-00363672-00364134": "in britain", "hmedp6HLAyY-01151-00364135-00364487": "in the 18th century", "hmedp6HLAyY-01152-00364488-00364830": "and basically was a way", "hmedp6HLAyY-01153-00364831-00365351": "in which the means of production", "hmedp6HLAyY-01154-00365352-00365775": "were were taken away", "hmedp6HLAyY-01155-00365776-00366223": "from the agricultural", "hmedp6HLAyY-01156-00366224-00366575": "proletariat of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01157-00366576-00367087": "previous historical period", "hmedp6HLAyY-01158-00367088-00367487": "and instead of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01159-00367488-00367847": "talking about", "hmedp6HLAyY-01160-00367848-00368199": "enclosures and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01161-00368200-00368654": "of the time of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01162-00368655-00369503": "17th and 18th centuries", "hmedp6HLAyY-01163-00369504-00369903": "it was discussed a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01164-00369904-00370199": "form of satisfying the conditions for", "hmedp6HLAyY-01165-00370200-00370439": "capitalism to take off", "hmedp6HLAyY-01166-00370440-00370758": "the claim is that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01167-00370759-00371110": "it was a one-time affair", "hmedp6HLAyY-01168-00371111-00371415": "it happened once capitalism was", "hmedp6HLAyY-01169-00371416-00371902": "shaped and primitive accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01170-00371903-00372487": "is done for what we did is to say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01171-00372488-00372815": "that the process of primitive", "hmedp6HLAyY-01172-00372816-00372982": "accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01173-00372983-00373310": "the violence that goes into it is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01174-00373311-00373710": "uh an ongoing process", "hmedp6HLAyY-01175-00373711-00374006": "and there's been a big debate about this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01176-00374007-00374175": "in different", "hmedp6HLAyY-01177-00374176-00374519": "venues in in this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01178-00374520-00374958": "last 20 years or so", "hmedp6HLAyY-01179-00374959-00375282": "and what we i", "hmedp6HLAyY-01180-00375283-00375734": "and others have", "hmedp6HLAyY-01181-00375735-00376175": "said is that whenever capitalism enters", "hmedp6HLAyY-01182-00376176-00376478": "into a crisis", "hmedp6HLAyY-01183-00376479-00376815": "there is a period of primitive", "hmedp6HLAyY-01184-00376816-00377023": "accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01185-00377024-00377295": "because the crises are usually the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01186-00377296-00377351": "result", "hmedp6HLAyY-01187-00377352-00377678": "of efforts", "hmedp6HLAyY-01188-00377679-00377902": "by the working class and successful", "hmedp6HLAyY-01189-00377903-00378015": "efforts", "hmedp6HLAyY-01190-00378016-00378334": "to reduce the commodification of their", "hmedp6HLAyY-01191-00378335-00378727": "lives", "hmedp6HLAyY-01192-00378728-00379182": "and as a consequence the new enclosures", "hmedp6HLAyY-01193-00379183-00379743": "are forever as long as capitalism exists", "hmedp6HLAyY-01194-00379744-00380023": "there's always a moment of primitive", "hmedp6HLAyY-01195-00380024-00380254": "accumulation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01196-00380255-00380671": "to deal with the crisis", "hmedp6HLAyY-01197-00380672-00381039": "see and it's in so", "hmedp6HLAyY-01198-00381040-00381439": "what we're saying and we use these terms", "hmedp6HLAyY-01199-00381440-00381743": "to hearken back", "hmedp6HLAyY-01200-00381744-00382167": "to the earlier phase of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01201-00382168-00382510": "and to say that capitalism never loses", "hmedp6HLAyY-01202-00382511-00382630": "its", "hmedp6HLAyY-01203-00382631-00383078": "youth you might say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01204-00383079-00383439": "and i would add that we use those terms", "hmedp6HLAyY-01205-00383440-00383758": "also because starting in the 80s we", "hmedp6HLAyY-01206-00383759-00383919": "almost saw it developing", "hmedp6HLAyY-01207-00383920-00384278": "under our eyes you know yeah both george", "hmedp6HLAyY-01208-00384279-00384534": "and i were in africa for example", "hmedp6HLAyY-01209-00384535-00384847": "i mean george much longer than i but we", "hmedp6HLAyY-01210-00384848-00384951": "saw", "hmedp6HLAyY-01211-00384952-00385247": "you know in the early 80s the beginning", "hmedp6HLAyY-01212-00385248-00385334": "you know as", "hmedp6HLAyY-01213-00385335-00385678": "a response to the so-called debt crisis", "hmedp6HLAyY-01214-00385679-00385951": "we saw a whole attack coming from the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01215-00385952-00386087": "world bank and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01216-00386088-00386399": "the fmai the international monetary fund", "hmedp6HLAyY-01217-00386400-00386719": "against communitarian relations communal", "hmedp6HLAyY-01218-00386720-00386927": "forms of land property", "hmedp6HLAyY-01219-00386928-00387127": "in different parts of africa to hold", "hmedp6HLAyY-01220-00387128-00387278": "this big drive", "hmedp6HLAyY-01221-00387279-00387687": "to privatizing then in the 90s latin", "hmedp6HLAyY-01222-00387688-00387791": "america", "hmedp6HLAyY-01223-00387792-00388078": "the zapatista struggle also both the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01224-00388079-00388278": "attack on the commons they come", "hmedp6HLAyY-01225-00388279-00388591": "with the neoliberalism with the 19 the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01226-00388592-00388943": "structural adjustment part of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01227-00388944-00389167": "you know the the organizational", "hmedp6HLAyY-01228-00389168-00389343": "structure adjustment was", "hmedp6HLAyY-01229-00389344-00389663": "the idea of putting an end legally and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01230-00389664-00389999": "and with violence to communal forms of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01231-00390000-00390158": "land property", "hmedp6HLAyY-01232-00390159-00390447": "you know and then the response the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01233-00390448-00390647": "struggle of indigenous people", "hmedp6HLAyY-01234-00390648-00390934": "it's not an accident in the 90s you have", "hmedp6HLAyY-01235-00390935-00391191": "a whole intensification of struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-01236-00391192-00391471": "the zapatistas i think the zapatista", "hmedp6HLAyY-01237-00391472-00391710": "also brought the idea of the commons", "hmedp6HLAyY-01238-00391711-00391934": "into the move into a much broader world", "hmedp6HLAyY-01239-00391935-00392199": "movement right into the social movement", "hmedp6HLAyY-01240-00392200-00392415": "the anti-globalization movement i think", "hmedp6HLAyY-01241-00392416-00392647": "was very much effective", "hmedp6HLAyY-01242-00392648-00393063": "and also i think in the 90s you have", "hmedp6HLAyY-01243-00393064-00393343": "on the other hand on the other hand of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01244-00393344-00393599": "the discourse on the commons you know", "hmedp6HLAyY-01245-00393600-00393934": "and because the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01246-00393935-00394319": "all new theories coming from", "hmedp6HLAyY-01247-00394320-00394767": "italian autonomous the negri heart", "hmedp6HLAyY-01248-00394768-00395078": "about the digital commons", "hmedp6HLAyY-01249-00395079-00395430": "about the internet and um", "hmedp6HLAyY-01250-00395431-00395791": "to be in new forms you know of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01251-00395792-00396199": "cooperative you know work reconstituting", "hmedp6HLAyY-01252-00396200-00396439": "new forms of communitarianism on another", "hmedp6HLAyY-01253-00396440-00396510": "level", "hmedp6HLAyY-01254-00396511-00396710": "so you had the digital commons the land", "hmedp6HLAyY-01255-00396711-00396895": "commons and you know", "hmedp6HLAyY-01256-00396896-00397102": "i've been also doing work around the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01257-00397103-00397223": "question of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01258-00397224-00397534": "company reproduction the work itself", "hmedp6HLAyY-01259-00397535-00397847": "not only in terms of recuperating land", "hmedp6HLAyY-01260-00397848-00398095": "but also in terms of creating new forms", "hmedp6HLAyY-01261-00398096-00398182": "of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01262-00398183-00398399": "which also was inspired by things that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01263-00398400-00398502": "have been happening", "hmedp6HLAyY-01264-00398503-00398734": "in latin america you know the commodores", "hmedp6HLAyY-01265-00398735-00398943": "popular", "hmedp6HLAyY-01266-00398944-00399263": "so it's i think the the discussion of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01267-00399264-00399430": "the commons is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01268-00399431-00399830": "coming from two sides that on one side", "hmedp6HLAyY-01269-00399831-00400247": "the attack on communitarian relation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01270-00400248-00400615": "you know starting in the 80s late 17 and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01271-00400616-00400791": "continuing", "hmedp6HLAyY-01272-00400792-00401047": "through the present and the other the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01273-00401048-00401223": "new forms of struggles that have been", "hmedp6HLAyY-01274-00401224-00401375": "developing", "hmedp6HLAyY-01275-00401376-00401710": "right by you know the defense", "hmedp6HLAyY-01276-00401711-00402015": "the defense of communal lands", "hmedp6HLAyY-01277-00402016-00402302": "and the defense and the creation not", "hmedp6HLAyY-01278-00402303-00402575": "only the defense of communal land", "hmedp6HLAyY-01279-00402576-00402782": "but also the creation of new forms of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01280-00402783-00402927": "reproduction", "hmedp6HLAyY-01281-00402928-00403230": "i think this is which i think is really", "hmedp6HLAyY-01282-00403231-00403439": "one of the most important things that is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01283-00403440-00403847": "happening", "hmedp6HLAyY-01284-00403848-00404175": "yes", "hmedp6HLAyY-01285-00404176-00404567": "and i think it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-01286-00404568-00404895": "we're at a particular moment in the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01287-00404896-00405263": "in the story of the class struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-01288-00405264-00405591": "which is very decisive because through", "hmedp6HLAyY-01289-00405592-00405678": "all this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01290-00405679-00406143": "rig of a role about trump and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01291-00406144-00406454": "uh johnson personally and bolsonaro and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01292-00406455-00406551": "all this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01293-00406552-00406854": "is that what's not seen is the fact that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01294-00406855-00406991": "capitalism itself", "hmedp6HLAyY-01295-00406992-00407327": "is facing a very serious", "hmedp6HLAyY-01296-00407328-00407758": "prophets crisis", "hmedp6HLAyY-01297-00407759-00407999": "when interest rates reach negative", "hmedp6HLAyY-01298-00408000-00408158": "levels", "hmedp6HLAyY-01299-00408159-00408471": "when growth rates reach", "hmedp6HLAyY-01300-00408472-00408854": "negative levels together", "hmedp6HLAyY-01301-00408855-00409134": "we're looking at a system that is not on", "hmedp6HLAyY-01302-00409135-00409287": "its own terms", "hmedp6HLAyY-01303-00409288-00409415": "we don't have to wait for george", "hmedp6HLAyY-01304-00409416-00409607": "defenses to say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01305-00409608-00410078": "you've got a problem uh this is a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01306-00410079-00410422": "a period when in fact it's exactly", "hmedp6HLAyY-01307-00410423-00410614": "because", "hmedp6HLAyY-01308-00410615-00410799": "there is this crisis that we have at", "hmedp6HLAyY-01309-00410800-00410918": "trump", "hmedp6HLAyY-01310-00410919-00411263": "not the other way around", "hmedp6HLAyY-01311-00411264-00411887": "so i think that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01312-00411888-00412247": "at least in this particular moment", "hmedp6HLAyY-01313-00412247-00412655": "we have a serious", "hmedp6HLAyY-01314-00412656-00412951": "consequence of the operation of this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01315-00412952-00413078": "system", "hmedp6HLAyY-01316-00413079-00413399": "an opportunity because i think that in a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01317-00413400-00413455": "way", "hmedp6HLAyY-01318-00413456-00413774": "if you if you recognize that you also", "hmedp6HLAyY-01319-00413775-00414087": "recognize that the alternative you know", "hmedp6HLAyY-01320-00414088-00414270": "struggling and hoping that there's going", "hmedp6HLAyY-01321-00414271-00414647": "to be a capitalism with the human face", "hmedp6HLAyY-01322-00414647-00414974": "why the idea of a kind of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01323-00414975-00415230": "that can implement reforms", "hmedp6HLAyY-01324-00415231-00415582": "that can humanize expectation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01325-00415583-00415959": "i it's very much an illusion and that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01326-00415960-00416174": "the question of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01327-00416175-00416503": "you know beginning to organizing in ways", "hmedp6HLAyY-01328-00416504-00416782": "that presumes that we have to move that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01329-00416783-00417039": "we have to change the system", "hmedp6HLAyY-01330-00417039-00417334": "they begin to organize a london line", "hmedp6HLAyY-01331-00417335-00417455": "then it becomes", "hmedp6HLAyY-01332-00417456-00417766": "you know life and death matter", "hmedp6HLAyY-01333-00417767-00418174": "a matter of you know because um", "hmedp6HLAyY-01334-00418175-00418430": "yeah the option of a reform is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01335-00418431-00418647": "capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01336-00418647-00418878": "at this point i think it's out to the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01337-00418879-00419047": "question that's like listing", "hmedp6HLAyY-01338-00419047-00419255": "to where we both in different ways come", "hmedp6HLAyY-01339-00419256-00419447": "from", "hmedp6HLAyY-01340-00419447-00419670": "one last question we've been talking", "hmedp6HLAyY-01341-00419671-00419799": "about", "hmedp6HLAyY-01342-00419800-00420070": "primitive accumulation question refusal", "hmedp6HLAyY-01343-00420071-00420135": "of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-01344-00420135-00420399": "crisis of capitalism in this year's", "hmedp6HLAyY-01345-00420400-00420599": "commoning", "hmedp6HLAyY-01346-00420600-00420870": "many fold of work and you you've been", "hmedp6HLAyY-01347-00420871-00421047": "saying about bolsonaro", "hmedp6HLAyY-01348-00421047-00421343": "and trump as an expression of actual", "hmedp6HLAyY-01349-00421343-00421487": "crisis of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01350-00421488-00421710": "so what is your reflection or your", "hmedp6HLAyY-01351-00421712-00421847": "thoughts on", "hmedp6HLAyY-01352-00421847-00422095": "another form of expression of political", "hmedp6HLAyY-01353-00422096-00422295": "expression nowadays in the states", "hmedp6HLAyY-01354-00422296-00422679": "on the great new deal of the proposal of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01355-00422680-00423014": "these socialist young americans about", "hmedp6HLAyY-01356-00423015-00423303": "this the transformation or fair", "hmedp6HLAyY-01357-00423304-00423470": "transition just transition that is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01358-00423471-00423527": "emerging", "hmedp6HLAyY-01359-00423528-00423870": "also from the union sector um", "hmedp6HLAyY-01360-00423871-00424151": "maybe some opinion more on these days", "hmedp6HLAyY-01361-00424152-00424439": "from the present days", "hmedp6HLAyY-01362-00424439-00424895": "okay um the two parts of the question", "hmedp6HLAyY-01363-00424896-00424943": "one", "hmedp6HLAyY-01364-00424943-00425375": "having to deal with uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01365-00425376-00425687": "can you see look at me please okay", "hmedp6HLAyY-01366-00425688-00426087": "okay all right", "hmedp6HLAyY-01367-00426088-00426399": "thank you okay yeah", "hmedp6HLAyY-01368-00426400-00426718": "the the part of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01369-00426719-00427031": "the question that deals with", "hmedp6HLAyY-01370-00427032-00427439": "the new enclosures is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01371-00427439-00427814": "something that i think is very um", "hmedp6HLAyY-01372-00427815-00428135": "the choice of of terms", "hmedp6HLAyY-01373-00428135-00428439": "is not an innocent process of course", "hmedp6HLAyY-01374-00428439-00428783": "and the reason why the notion of a new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01375-00428784-00428863": "enclosure", "hmedp6HLAyY-01376-00428864-00429239": "is used is to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01377-00429239-00429614": "bring about the recognition that there's", "hmedp6HLAyY-01378-00429615-00429883": "a solidarity", "hmedp6HLAyY-01379-00429884-00430231": "between the struggles of today", "hmedp6HLAyY-01380-00430232-00430559": "and the struggles against", "hmedp6HLAyY-01381-00430560-00430910": "capitalism before it was begin", "hmedp6HLAyY-01382-00430912-00431214": "before it had formed itself", "hmedp6HLAyY-01383-00431215-00431535": "and that there was a notion", "hmedp6HLAyY-01384-00431535-00431822": "that there were many struggles against", "hmedp6HLAyY-01385-00431823-00431959": "capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01386-00431960-00432431": "before there was even capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01387-00432432-00432895": "i think this is an important point", "hmedp6HLAyY-01388-00432896-00433263": "it should be understood because it", "hmedp6HLAyY-01389-00433264-00433455": "also lays the foundations for something", "hmedp6HLAyY-01390-00433456-00433687": "else", "hmedp6HLAyY-01391-00433688-00434014": "see the the idea that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01392-00434015-00434422": "we can find a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01393-00434423-00435014": "an alternative to capitalism is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01394-00435015-00435318": "when we speak of the new enclosures we", "hmedp6HLAyY-01395-00435319-00435366": "speak", "hmedp6HLAyY-01396-00435367-00435847": "not only of capitalism having to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01397-00435847-00436222": "destroy the means of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01398-00436223-00436559": "the access of workers the means of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01399-00436560-00436743": "production", "hmedp6HLAyY-01400-00436743-00437270": "is very much", "hmedp6HLAyY-01401-00437271-00437703": "a recognition that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01402-00437704-00438014": "there has been a long-term", "hmedp6HLAyY-01403-00438015-00438383": "struggle to repress the initial", "hmedp6HLAyY-01404-00438384-00438559": "conditions of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01405-00438560-00438959": "to exist", "hmedp6HLAyY-01406-00438960-00439710": "so as a consequence this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01407-00439712-00440047": "this terminology this terminological", "hmedp6HLAyY-01408-00440047-00440407": "dispute is important because", "hmedp6HLAyY-01409-00440408-00440718": "i think it really brings out the fact", "hmedp6HLAyY-01410-00440719-00440895": "that there isn't", "hmedp6HLAyY-01411-00440896-00441407": "that capitalism is not some natural", "hmedp6HLAyY-01412-00441408-00441759": "uh product of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01413-00441760-00442127": "historical transformation but that it", "hmedp6HLAyY-01414-00442128-00442518": "has been repressed for many", "hmedp6HLAyY-01415-00442519-00442855": "centuries", "hmedp6HLAyY-01416-00442856-00443214": "and that there have been various efforts", "hmedp6HLAyY-01417-00443215-00443639": "over the history oh it's been", "hmedp6HLAyY-01418-00443639-00443991": "more than repressed yeah it's being", "hmedp6HLAyY-01419-00443992-00444310": "the attempt to develop in that direction", "hmedp6HLAyY-01420-00444312-00444655": "has been um", "hmedp6HLAyY-01421-00444656-00444999": "fought against for a long time", "hmedp6HLAyY-01422-00445000-00445214": "and continues to be fought against in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01423-00445215-00445535": "terms of new areas new areas", "hmedp6HLAyY-01424-00445535-00445863": "where capitalist relations are advancing", "hmedp6HLAyY-01425-00445864-00446166": "and trying to take over", "hmedp6HLAyY-01426-00446167-00446359": "that's like also the solidarity between", "hmedp6HLAyY-01427-00446360-00446551": "the past and the present", "hmedp6HLAyY-01428-00446552-00446759": "yeah that's what i'm i i think it's", "hmedp6HLAyY-01429-00446760-00446935": "important politically", "hmedp6HLAyY-01430-00446935-00447255": "and also just the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01431-00447256-00447647": "from the from the heart might say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01432-00447647-00448110": "that we recognize our our own solidarity", "hmedp6HLAyY-01433-00448112-00448407": "with those who struggled even before", "hmedp6HLAyY-01434-00448408-00448510": "there was", "hmedp6HLAyY-01435-00448512-00448983": "capitalism against capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01436-00448984-00449287": "and the existence of another logic", "hmedp6HLAyY-01437-00449288-00449510": "you continue in existence of another", "hmedp6HLAyY-01438-00449512-00449599": "logic", "hmedp6HLAyY-01439-00449600-00449831": "that they are never able to completely", "hmedp6HLAyY-01440-00449832-00450007": "destroy", "hmedp6HLAyY-01441-00450008-00450366": "and at times that we've been using the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01442-00450367-00450414": "term", "hmedp6HLAyY-01443-00450415-00450743": "commons to bring out this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01444-00450743-00451118": "fact that the human capacities", "hmedp6HLAyY-01445-00451119-00451583": "for being able to organize", "hmedp6HLAyY-01446-00451584-00451887": "collectively", "hmedp6HLAyY-01447-00451888-00452222": "for the reproduction of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01448-00452223-00452543": "of social life is uh", "hmedp6HLAyY-01449-00452543-00453063": "something that is quite crucial", "hmedp6HLAyY-01450-00453064-00453455": "to the development of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01451-00453456-00453822": "of another kind of society", "hmedp6HLAyY-01452-00453823-00454231": "and so i would say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01453-00454232-00454622": "that it's a term that i think would be", "hmedp6HLAyY-01454-00454623-00454822": "useful", "hmedp6HLAyY-01455-00454823-00455022": "and a concept that i think would be", "hmedp6HLAyY-01456-00455023-00455175": "useful", "hmedp6HLAyY-01457-00455176-00455543": "for our", "hmedp6HLAyY-01458-00455543-00455943": "brothers and sisters and in fact", "hmedp6HLAyY-01459-00455943-00456168": "beyond that to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01460-00456170-00456559": "[Music]", "hmedp6HLAyY-01461-00456560-00456870": "the living creatures that we now", "hmedp6HLAyY-01462-00456871-00457191": "are increasingly taking part in our", "hmedp6HLAyY-01463-00457192-00457295": "understanding of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01464-00457296-00457631": "the struggles that take place", "hmedp6HLAyY-01465-00457632-00457943": "that are that are", "hmedp6HLAyY-01466-00457943-00458383": "in fact speak to a generation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01467-00458384-00458703": "of militants who", "hmedp6HLAyY-01468-00458704-00458935": "are now beginning to put on their", "hmedp6HLAyY-01469-00458935-00459079": "banners", "hmedp6HLAyY-01470-00459080-00459503": "stop the extinction of species", "hmedp6HLAyY-01471-00459504-00459775": "it's a it's an important change that's", "hmedp6HLAyY-01472-00459776-00460287": "taking place", "hmedp6HLAyY-01473-00460288-00460470": "you say the space of solidarity the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01474-00460471-00460766": "extent of solidarity is expanding", "hmedp6HLAyY-01475-00460767-00461175": "also yes with the the animal world and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01476-00461176-00461407": "nature and so on in ways that certainly", "hmedp6HLAyY-01477-00461408-00461487": "was not true", "hmedp6HLAyY-01478-00461488-00461895": "in the what is not in the traditional", "hmedp6HLAyY-01479-00461896-00462327": "conception of the clastragon so", "hmedp6HLAyY-01480-00462328-00462535": "so there was a second part which had to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01481-00462535-00462751": "do with what you think about united", "hmedp6HLAyY-01482-00462752-00462935": "states now what are these", "hmedp6HLAyY-01483-00462935-00463135": "alternatives they seem to become enough", "hmedp6HLAyY-01484-00463135-00463622": "from a more institutional space", "hmedp6HLAyY-01485-00463623-00464183": "uh getting new deals and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01486-00464184-00464527": "yes the the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01487-00464528-00464879": "most of these are attempts to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01488-00464880-00465375": "try to fix the problems of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01489-00465376-00465695": "in a way that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01490-00465696-00466103": "would not violate", "hmedp6HLAyY-01491-00466104-00466503": "the essentials of a capitalist society", "hmedp6HLAyY-01492-00466504-00466831": "and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01493-00466832-00467239": "i i know that there are", "hmedp6HLAyY-01494-00467239-00467551": "very fine militants who are taking up", "hmedp6HLAyY-01495-00467552-00467966": "let's say the the terminology of a new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01496-00467967-00468118": "deal", "hmedp6HLAyY-01497-00468119-00468487": "but we must remember that the old new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01498-00468488-00468775": "deal", "hmedp6HLAyY-01499-00468776-00469303": "was never a victory of the proletariat", "hmedp6HLAyY-01500-00469304-00469639": "i think we have to recognize that it was", "hmedp6HLAyY-01501-00469639-00469727": "not", "hmedp6HLAyY-01502-00469728-00470183": "in fact it was built to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01503-00470184-00470535": "escape the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01504-00470535-00470991": "confrontation with revolution", "hmedp6HLAyY-01505-00470992-00471351": "and revolutionary transformation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01506-00471352-00471743": "so as a consequence i would say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01507-00471743-00472039": "the green new deal like i'm not sure", "hmedp6HLAyY-01508-00472039-00472166": "what color one would", "hmedp6HLAyY-01509-00472167-00472583": "put with the fdr form", "hmedp6HLAyY-01510-00472584-00473199": "recognize put would put together", "hmedp6HLAyY-01511-00473200-00473510": "if we put them together we see a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01512-00473512-00473766": "particular outcome", "hmedp6HLAyY-01513-00473767-00474295": "that is not", "hmedp6HLAyY-01514-00474296-00474535": "if that's what we can do at this point", "hmedp6HLAyY-01515-00474535-00474718": "in history", "hmedp6HLAyY-01516-00474719-00475159": "i would say that it was", "hmedp6HLAyY-01517-00475160-00475463": "it was", "hmedp6HLAyY-01518-00475464-00475822": "not able we still are not able", "hmedp6HLAyY-01519-00475823-00476166": "if that's what we have to presumably say", "hmedp6HLAyY-01520-00476167-00476510": "is the effort", "hmedp6HLAyY-01521-00476512-00476847": "that we we collectively", "hmedp6HLAyY-01522-00476847-00477239": "are together forming", "hmedp6HLAyY-01523-00477239-00477679": "for the future of human life on the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01524-00477680-00477783": "planet", "hmedp6HLAyY-01525-00477784-00478295": "and not only human life but beyond that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01526-00478296-00478679": "i would like to just", "hmedp6HLAyY-01527-00478680-00479022": "point out that a deal", "hmedp6HLAyY-01528-00479023-00479399": "in u.s language", "hmedp6HLAyY-01529-00479400-00479759": "is an effort", "hmedp6HLAyY-01530-00479760-00479943": "to make an agreement that is somewhat", "hmedp6HLAyY-01531-00479943-00480318": "suspicious", "hmedp6HLAyY-01532-00480319-00480662": "i have a deal for you means someone", "hmedp6HLAyY-01533-00480663-00481039": "is going to give you something that is", "hmedp6HLAyY-01534-00481039-00481366": "you know somewhat", "hmedp6HLAyY-01535-00481367-00481559": "questionable what is being exchanged", "hmedp6HLAyY-01536-00481560-00481743": "what is there is being exchanged", "hmedp6HLAyY-01537-00481743-00482062": "like in the deal yeah so", "hmedp6HLAyY-01538-00482063-00482414": "if anyone offers you a deal in new york", "hmedp6HLAyY-01539-00482415-00482814": "you better be careful", "hmedp6HLAyY-01540-00482815-00483135": "see what i mean and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01541-00483135-00483462": "i think it would be", "hmedp6HLAyY-01542-00483463-00483759": "as with most of these kinds of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01543-00483760-00483991": "transitional", "hmedp6HLAyY-01544-00483992-00484799": "claims and demands and formulations", "hmedp6HLAyY-01545-00484800-00485191": "one must study them and not dismiss", "hmedp6HLAyY-01546-00485192-00485759": "people who are involved in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01547-00485760-00486407": "material struggles but at the same time", "hmedp6HLAyY-01548-00486408-00486895": "i think that the the terminology", "hmedp6HLAyY-01549-00486896-00487283": "of new enclosures and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01550-00487284-00487599": "commons is useful", "hmedp6HLAyY-01551-00487600-00487935": "for us to continue", "hmedp6HLAyY-01552-00487935-00488239": "recognition", "hmedp6HLAyY-01553-00488239-00488407": "yeah for instance what is the green new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01554-00488408-00488566": "deal i mean for example what are the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01555-00488567-00488703": "green we have seen", "hmedp6HLAyY-01556-00488704-00488910": "we know that across the latin american", "hmedp6HLAyY-01557-00488912-00489095": "continent there is a tremendous struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-01558-00489096-00489207": "against the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01559-00489208-00489495": "you know new forms of green energy you", "hmedp6HLAyY-01560-00489496-00489551": "know the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01561-00489552-00489903": "aortic plants and so on they presumably", "hmedp6HLAyY-01562-00489904-00490031": "all is clean", "hmedp6HLAyY-01563-00490032-00490287": "but actually they need to buy a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01564-00490288-00490455": "tremendous amount of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01565-00490456-00490718": "electricity and displacement like we", "hmedp6HLAyY-01566-00490719-00490927": "know in mexico for instance huge amount", "hmedp6HLAyY-01567-00490928-00491047": "of struggle against", "hmedp6HLAyY-01568-00491047-00491407": "the creation of these territories full", "hmedp6HLAyY-01569-00491408-00491599": "of aeolic plants", "hmedp6HLAyY-01570-00491600-00491903": "because they are displacing people", "hmedp6HLAyY-01571-00491904-00492079": "they are destroying animals they are", "hmedp6HLAyY-01572-00492080-00492343": "destroying crop plants", "hmedp6HLAyY-01573-00492343-00492727": "and so what what is and same thing with", "hmedp6HLAyY-01574-00492728-00492862": "the green gasoline", "hmedp6HLAyY-01575-00492863-00493118": "i know in brazil for instance a lot a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01576-00493119-00493262": "lot with the greenhouse", "hmedp6HLAyY-01577-00493263-00493566": "in africa you know thousands of hectares", "hmedp6HLAyY-01578-00493567-00493639": "of land", "hmedp6HLAyY-01579-00493639-00493943": "been expropriated in order to", "hmedp6HLAyY-01580-00493943-00494343": "create a green plant elephant grass", "hmedp6HLAyY-01581-00494343-00494670": "for the green gasoline so we have to be", "hmedp6HLAyY-01582-00494671-00494839": "very very careful", "hmedp6HLAyY-01583-00494839-00495095": "particularly when the you know green new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01584-00495096-00495255": "deal is supposed to create these new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01585-00495256-00495455": "economies that are still capitalist", "hmedp6HLAyY-01586-00495456-00495591": "economies", "hmedp6HLAyY-01587-00495592-00495847": "and the question is you know who this", "hmedp6HLAyY-01588-00495847-00496087": "has been the history of capitalism", "hmedp6HLAyY-01589-00496088-00496543": "right that you uh pacify the struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-01590-00496543-00496759": "right by responding to the need of a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01591-00496760-00497039": "particular sector of the population", "hmedp6HLAyY-01592-00497039-00497383": "you know whereas uh hidden", "hmedp6HLAyY-01593-00497384-00497607": "others were being you know those are", "hmedp6HLAyY-01594-00497608-00497879": "being displaced by the green gasoline", "hmedp6HLAyY-01595-00497880-00498159": "you know and it was like the new deal of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01596-00498160-00498222": "the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01597-00498223-00498535": "of the 1930s most most", "hmedp6HLAyY-01598-00498535-00498766": "african-american workers were not", "hmedp6HLAyY-01599-00498767-00498903": "included", "hmedp6HLAyY-01600-00498904-00499247": "you know in uh in the new deal", "hmedp6HLAyY-01601-00499247-00499551": "and and we're now beginning to see for", "hmedp6HLAyY-01602-00499552-00499687": "instance i think which is very", "hmedp6HLAyY-01603-00499688-00499799": "interesting", "hmedp6HLAyY-01604-00499800-00500055": "you know there's work that is being done", "hmedp6HLAyY-01605-00500056-00500239": "which is showing", "hmedp6HLAyY-01606-00500239-00500614": "that before the new deal that legalized", "hmedp6HLAyY-01607-00500615-00500891": "the union with the wagner act in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01608-00500892-00501222": "1935 there was supposed to be a big", "hmedp6HLAyY-01609-00501223-00501447": "union victory because the union were", "hmedp6HLAyY-01610-00501447-00501575": "recognized the whole", "hmedp6HLAyY-01611-00501576-00501807": "contract system became part of the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01612-00501808-00501983": "institution", "hmedp6HLAyY-01613-00501984-00502327": "and workers were not shot at when they", "hmedp6HLAyY-01614-00502328-00502583": "went up to demonstrate", "hmedp6HLAyY-01615-00502584-00502775": "now is beginning to recognize that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01616-00502776-00502935": "before that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01617-00502935-00503255": "you had forms of labor organization", "hmedp6HLAyY-01618-00503256-00503503": "that actually dealt with the whole life", "hmedp6HLAyY-01619-00503504-00503647": "of the worker", "hmedp6HLAyY-01620-00503647-00503910": "not only with the workplace defined", "hmedp6HLAyY-01621-00503912-00504055": "strictly", "hmedp6HLAyY-01622-00504056-00504318": "in terms of the production place but", "hmedp6HLAyY-01623-00504319-00504527": "you're a type of organization labor", "hmedp6HLAyY-01624-00504528-00504743": "organization they dealt with", "hmedp6HLAyY-01625-00504743-00505062": "health dealt with pension work", "hmedp6HLAyY-01626-00505063-00505431": "accident and in there they had very deep", "hmedp6HLAyY-01627-00505432-00505639": "roots in the community", "hmedp6HLAyY-01628-00505639-00505862": "you know and so that that division that", "hmedp6HLAyY-01629-00505863-00506022": "really begins", "hmedp6HLAyY-01630-00506023-00506359": "to accentuate between", "hmedp6HLAyY-01631-00506360-00506543": "the workplace which is the only one", "hmedp6HLAyY-01632-00506543-00506775": "recognized and the community and more", "hmedp6HLAyY-01633-00506776-00506975": "and more the community", "hmedp6HLAyY-01634-00506976-00507295": "falls out of the moment of struggle", "hmedp6HLAyY-01635-00507296-00507495": "between workers and capital so the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01636-00507496-00507670": "struggle between workers and capital", "hmedp6HLAyY-01637-00507671-00507718": "becomes", "hmedp6HLAyY-01638-00507719-00508066": "isolated becomes in a way", "hmedp6HLAyY-01639-00508067-00508503": "refocused relocalized in the community", "hmedp6HLAyY-01640-00508504-00508799": "you know and and isolated from that in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01641-00508800-00509062": "in the in the in the factories", "hmedp6HLAyY-01642-00509063-00509399": "uh the places of wage work either all of", "hmedp6HLAyY-01643-00509400-00509559": "that we begin to see", "hmedp6HLAyY-01644-00509560-00509887": "that perhaps the new deal was also", "hmedp6HLAyY-01645-00509888-00510295": "a way of undermining", "hmedp6HLAyY-01646-00510296-00510583": "that kind of forms of organization which", "hmedp6HLAyY-01647-00510584-00510791": "was very powerful", "hmedp6HLAyY-01648-00510792-00511079": "because when you know factory workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-01649-00511080-00511343": "went inside the whole community", "hmedp6HLAyY-01650-00511343-00511527": "worked with them the whole community", "hmedp6HLAyY-01651-00511528-00511718": "went on strike with them", "hmedp6HLAyY-01652-00511719-00511975": "you know and organized around that and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01653-00511976-00512110": "then it becomes more", "hmedp6HLAyY-01654-00512112-00512414": "the contract the union or negotiate and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01655-00512415-00512607": "they pull out the workers in the street", "hmedp6HLAyY-01656-00512608-00512695": "in the square", "hmedp6HLAyY-01657-00512696-00512910": "for their one day and it becomes a very", "hmedp6HLAyY-01658-00512912-00513087": "it's like a dance", "hmedp6HLAyY-01659-00513088-00513327": "you know and it's you know and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01660-00513328-00513479": "everything is exchanged", "hmedp6HLAyY-01661-00513480-00513735": "in equal terms more money more", "hmedp6HLAyY-01662-00513735-00513903": "productivity more money more", "hmedp6HLAyY-01663-00513904-00514031": "exploitation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01664-00514032-00514470": "etc you know and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01665-00514471-00514807": "so i think that we have to rethink", "hmedp6HLAyY-01666-00514808-00515151": "also that history and the way the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01667-00515152-00515447": "the new deal has been celebrated as a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01668-00515447-00515695": "great working class victory", "hmedp6HLAyY-01669-00515696-00515951": "and to see how in fact it has redefined", "hmedp6HLAyY-01670-00515952-00516143": "and for instance", "hmedp6HLAyY-01671-00516143-00516503": "another example what kind of work", "hmedp6HLAyY-01672-00516504-00516822": "have been recognized as work in the new", "hmedp6HLAyY-01673-00516823-00517007": "labor legislation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01674-00517008-00517343": "not only left out you know", "hmedp6HLAyY-01675-00517343-00517655": "reproductive work in the home but for", "hmedp6HLAyY-01676-00517656-00517999": "instance the new deal never recognize", "hmedp6HLAyY-01677-00518000-00518303": "domestic work done for wages", "hmedp6HLAyY-01678-00518304-00518543": "domestic workers who work outside the", "hmedp6HLAyY-01679-00518543-00518662": "home", "hmedp6HLAyY-01680-00518663-00519127": "were catalogued classified as companions", "hmedp6HLAyY-01681-00519128-00519447": "in the new deal like domestic work", "hmedp6HLAyY-01682-00519447-00519751": "done for wages was not", "hmedp6HLAyY-01683-00519752-00520055": "was not recognized is only starting in", "hmedp6HLAyY-01684-00520056-00520214": "2000", "hmedp6HLAyY-01685-00520215-00520599": "and more than 2010 the domestic workers", "hmedp6HLAyY-01686-00520600-00520743": "in the united states", "hmedp6HLAyY-01687-00520743-00520999": "according to the labor legislation of a", "hmedp6HLAyY-01688-00521000-00521135": "number of states", "hmedp6HLAyY-01689-00521135-00521414": "have been recognized as workers and", "hmedp6HLAyY-01690-00521415-00521791": "entitled to some union benefits like", "hmedp6HLAyY-01691-00521792-00522183": "a limit on the hours of work vacation", "hmedp6HLAyY-01692-00522184-00522518": "severance pay until then for", "hmedp6HLAyY-01693-00522519-00522870": "all the legislation of the 1930s", "hmedp6HLAyY-01694-00522871-00523143": "they were not recognized as workers so", "hmedp6HLAyY-01695-00523143-00523422": "we have to keep that in mind also to put", "hmedp6HLAyY-01696-00523423-00523735": "the new deal in perspective", "hmedp6HLAyY-01697-00523735-00524079": "yeah thank you yes", "hmedp6HLAyY-01698-00524080-00525230": "okay thank you so much thank you", "hmedp6HLAyY-01699-00525231-00525679": "[Music]", "hmedp6HLAyY-01700-00525680-00525888": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "hmeXq69j9_I", "text": {"hmeXq69j9_I-00000-00000000-00000214": "people in Keene Senator McCarthy", "hmeXq69j9_I-00001-00000215-00000356": "questions without notice", "hmeXq69j9_I-00002-00000357-00000770": "senator wall Thank You mr. president my", "hmeXq69j9_I-00003-00000771-00000932": "question is to the Minister representing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00004-00000933-00001073": "the Minister for the environment senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00005-00001074-00001225": "Birmingham and I referred to as later", "hmeXq69j9_I-00006-00001226-00001448": "today responding to questions from me he", "hmeXq69j9_I-00007-00001449-00001574": "took on notice in question time", "hmeXq69j9_I-00008-00001575-00001834": "yesterday in his letter he states and I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00009-00001835-00002129": "quote Minister Minister Taylor has", "hmeXq69j9_I-00010-00002130-00002359": "always declared his interests as", "hmeXq69j9_I-00011-00002360-00002534": "required under both the house register", "hmeXq69j9_I-00012-00002535-00002723": "of interests and the ministerial code of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00013-00002724-00002870": "conduct end quote", "hmeXq69j9_I-00014-00002871-00003182": "does the Minister stand by his statement", "hmeXq69j9_I-00015-00003183-00003365": "as set out in that letter", "hmeXq69j9_I-00016-00003365-00003481": "the minister representing the Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00017-00003482-00003694": "for the environment senator Birmingham", "hmeXq69j9_I-00018-00003695-00003860": "mr. president to the best of my", "hmeXq69j9_I-00019-00003861-00004036": "knowledge mr. Taylor has always declared", "hmeXq69j9_I-00020-00004037-00004325": "his interests senator one with", "hmeXq69j9_I-00021-00004326-00004565": "supplementary questions Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00022-00004566-00004622": "president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00023-00004623-00004822": "why does Minister Taylor's statement of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00024-00004823-00005020": "registerable interests under the house", "hmeXq69j9_I-00025-00005021-00005252": "register of interests found to declare", "hmeXq69j9_I-00026-00005253-00005527": "his interest in jamb land proprietary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00027-00005528-00006026": "limited Senator Birmingham Oh mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00028-00006027-00006229": "president mr. president senator Warren", "hmeXq69j9_I-00029-00006230-00006457": "is making an assertion there and it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00030-00006458-00006734": "insertion that is one of course I can", "hmeXq69j9_I-00031-00006734-00006953": "take on notice in terms of having mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00032-00006954-00007198": "Taylor respond to as to whether or not", "hmeXq69j9_I-00033-00007200-00007403": "the assertion has invalidity or not I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00034-00007404-00007820": "would of course not not take senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00035-00007820-00007853": "Wong's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00036-00007854-00008144": "word for that Senator Warren the final", "hmeXq69j9_I-00037-00008145-00008278": "supplementary I hope Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00038-00008279-00008513": "president I have in front of me a seek", "hmeXq69j9_I-00039-00008514-00008749": "extracts that demonstrate that Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00040-00008750-00008912": "Taylor is a director of Goffe", "hmeXq69j9_I-00041-00008913-00009167": "proprietary limited a joint holder of a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00042-00009168-00009338": "one-third interest in jamb land", "hmeXq69j9_I-00043-00009339-00009614": "proprietary limited given these extracts", "hmeXq69j9_I-00044-00009615-00009842": "clearly show that Minister Taylor's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00045-00009843-00010010": "interest in jamb land proprietary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00046-00010011-00010228": "limited will Senator Birmingham now", "hmeXq69j9_I-00047-00010229-00010427": "correct the record and apologize for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00048-00010428-00010713": "misleading the Senate senator burr me", "hmeXq69j9_I-00049-00010714-00010946": "mr. president I've already indicated I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00050-00010947-00011185": "don't take the Senators assertions at", "hmeXq69j9_I-00051-00011186-00011539": "face value I have already taken already", "hmeXq69j9_I-00052-00011540-00011780": "tailored in a moment senator Birmingham", "hmeXq69j9_I-00053-00011781-00011956": "Senator Wong's seeking a point of order", "hmeXq69j9_I-00054-00011957-00012181": "order on my left Senator Wong's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00055-00012182-00012542": "I seek leave to table the assic document", "hmeXq69j9_I-00056-00012543-00012587": "can", "hmeXq69j9_I-00057-00012588-00012844": "firming that Minister Tyler is has an", "hmeXq69j9_I-00058-00012845-00013337": "interest in jamming senator Corman on a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00059-00013338-00013513": "on a point of order", "hmeXq69j9_I-00060-00013515-00013947": "no senator Wong has is a long-serving", "hmeXq69j9_I-00061-00013948-00014341": "senior senator senator one knows about", "hmeXq69j9_I-00062-00014343-00014494": "the conventions in this place when it", "hmeXq69j9_I-00063-00014495-00014719": "comes to seeking lave two type of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00064-00014719-00014950": "documents and like if the appropriate", "hmeXq69j9_I-00065-00014951-00015250": "courtesies are displayed then the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00066-00015251-00015437": "government will give leave but not in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00067-00015438-00015665": "the absence of complying with the normal", "hmeXq69j9_I-00068-00015666-00015760": "courtesies", "hmeXq69j9_I-00069-00015761-00016085": "senator it's not a point of order to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00070-00016086-00016262": "seek leave i grant later the opposition", "hmeXq69j9_I-00071-00016263-00016532": "some liberality and application I'm not", "hmeXq69j9_I-00072-00016533-00016669": "a point of order though I call senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00073-00016670-00016903": "burning him to continue thanks mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00074-00016904-00016949": "president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00075-00016950-00017174": "and mr. president as I indicated I've", "hmeXq69j9_I-00076-00017175-00017330": "already taken on notice that the first", "hmeXq69j9_I-00077-00017331-00017537": "supplementary and the assertions that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00078-00017538-00017762": "senator Wong is making if there is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00079-00017763-00017878": "anything to be brought back to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00080-00017879-00018011": "chamber in relation to those assertions", "hmeXq69j9_I-00081-00018012-00018293": "I will bring it back as I responded from", "hmeXq69j9_I-00082-00018294-00018406": "leader the questions that I took I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00083-00018407-00018542": "noticed yesterday on behalf of mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00084-00018543-00018908": "Taylor senator antek Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00085-00018909-00019022": "president my question is to the Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00086-00019023-00019231": "for trade tourism and investment senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00087-00019232-00019499": "Birmingham can the minister please", "hmeXq69j9_I-00088-00019500-00019669": "update the Senate on how the government", "hmeXq69j9_I-00089-00019670-00019822": "is on the side of Australian workers", "hmeXq69j9_I-00090-00019823-00020030": "including by helping Australians export", "hmeXq69j9_I-00091-00020031-00020225": "to the world the minister for trade", "hmeXq69j9_I-00092-00020226-00020359": "tourism and investment senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00093-00020360-00020575": "Birmingham thanks mr. president I thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-00094-00020576-00020719": "Senator antic for his question and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00095-00020720-00020869": "congratulate him on his first question", "hmeXq69j9_I-00096-00020870-00021109": "to to the chamber I welcome him to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00097-00021110-00021331": "Senate and note that perhaps unlike some", "hmeXq69j9_I-00098-00021332-00021497": "others senator rounding is happy to come", "hmeXq69j9_I-00099-00021498-00021628": "into this question and ask questions", "hmeXq69j9_I-00100-00021629-00021893": "about policies and ask questions about", "hmeXq69j9_I-00101-00021894-00022094": "issues that matter to Australians in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00102-00022095-00022297": "terms of job creation for Australians in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00103-00022298-00022469": "terms of business growth for Australians", "hmeXq69j9_I-00104-00022470-00022702": "in terms of the types of opportunities", "hmeXq69j9_I-00105-00022703-00023059": "that that are important to keeping our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00106-00023060-00023297": "economy strong - keeping Australian safe", "hmeXq69j9_I-00107-00023298-00023519": "and secure economically and indeed the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00108-00023520-00023722": "trade policies of this government have", "hmeXq69j9_I-00109-00023723-00023993": "been central to providing those types of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00110-00023994-00024227": "enhanced opportunities to Australians", "hmeXq69j9_I-00111-00024228-00024437": "right around the country especially in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00112-00024438-00024683": "our home state of South Australia is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00113-00024684-00024853": "wonderful as always to have a new", "hmeXq69j9_I-00114-00024854-00025069": "liberal senator here from the state of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00115-00025070-00025213": "South Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00116-00025214-00025591": "mr. president mr. president our trade", "hmeXq69j9_I-00117-00025592-00025864": "policies have seen successive agreements", "hmeXq69j9_I-00118-00025864-00026109": "sealed and delivered and they stand in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00119-00026110-00026295": "stark contrast to the record of those", "hmeXq69j9_I-00120-00026297-00026545": "opposite who are unable to commence and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00121-00026545-00026758": "conclude trade agreements when they are", "hmeXq69j9_I-00122-00026758-00026958": "in office our government has been able", "hmeXq69j9_I-00123-00026960-00027130": "to get on with it agreements with China", "hmeXq69j9_I-00124-00027131-00027439": "with Japan with Korea with the ten", "hmeXq69j9_I-00125-00027439-00027568": "economies of the trans-pacific", "hmeXq69j9_I-00126-00027569-00027847": "partnership are pursued indeed of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00127-00027848-00028087": "pace of Plus agreement our agreements", "hmeXq69j9_I-00128-00028088-00028333": "with Indonesia with Peru with Hongkong", "hmeXq69j9_I-00129-00028333-00028525": "all of these agreements have enhanced", "hmeXq69j9_I-00130-00028526-00028702": "the opportunity for Australia's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00131-00028702-00028948": "businesses to be able to export more to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00132-00028949-00029170": "be able to grow and ultimately to be", "hmeXq69j9_I-00133-00029170-00029364": "able to contribute to the record levels", "hmeXq69j9_I-00134-00029366-00029554": "of jobs growth that we've seen in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00135-00029555-00029818": "Australia it is no coincidence mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00136-00029819-00030043": "president that the trade growth and the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00137-00030044-00030256": "expanded market access that the liberal", "hmeXq69j9_I-00138-00030257-00030448": "national government has delivered for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00139-00030449-00030607": "Australia's farmers and Australia's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00140-00030608-00030820": "businesses has helped to fuel an", "hmeXq69j9_I-00141-00030820-00030976": "increase in the number of businesses or", "hmeXq69j9_I-00142-00030977-00031189": "export an increase in the volume of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00143-00031189-00031377": "exports and increasing the value of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00144-00031379-00031608": "exports from Australia and ultimately", "hmeXq69j9_I-00145-00031610-00031918": "more job opportunities for Australians", "hmeXq69j9_I-00146-00031919-00032104": "and it's those job opportunities that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00147-00032105-00032265": "are central and that's why we are going", "hmeXq69j9_I-00148-00032266-00032470": "to continue to work to expand those", "hmeXq69j9_I-00149-00032470-00032686": "opportunities for Australia's exporters", "hmeXq69j9_I-00150-00032687-00032818": "senator Hann take a supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00151-00032819-00032968": "question okay mr. president will the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00152-00032969-00033106": "Minister inform the Senate about any", "hmeXq69j9_I-00153-00033107-00033295": "recent achievements especially in wine", "hmeXq69j9_I-00154-00033296-00033463": "which is very important to my home state", "hmeXq69j9_I-00155-00033464-00033553": "of South Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00156-00033554-00033919": "senator Birmingham mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00157-00033920-00034096": "industry of course in our great state of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00158-00034097-00034219": "South Australia there is the wine", "hmeXq69j9_I-00159-00034220-00034420": "industry South Australian wines I'm sure", "hmeXq69j9_I-00160-00034421-00034645": "are enjoyed by nearly every member of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00161-00034646-00034819": "this chamber I would hope by every", "hmeXq69j9_I-00162-00034820-00035071": "member indeed I know that Senator Farrow", "hmeXq69j9_I-00163-00035072-00035287": "has a strong and abiding interest in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00164-00035288-00035473": "South Australian wine industry and one", "hmeXq69j9_I-00165-00035474-00035721": "that one that we share and Australia's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00166-00035722-00035926": "exports of wine to key trading nations", "hmeXq69j9_I-00167-00035927-00036181": "such as China Korea and Japan continues", "hmeXq69j9_I-00168-00036182-00036388": "to grow export data from wine Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00169-00036389-00036592": "shows that Australian wine exports to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00170-00036593-00036844": "China reached a record high during the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00171-00036845-00037189": "1819 financial year of 1.2 billion", "hmeXq69j9_I-00172-00037190-00037578": "dollars increasing by some 7% in value", "hmeXq69j9_I-00173-00037579-00037903": "Australia now exports more wine by value", "hmeXq69j9_I-00174-00037904-00038176": "to China than any other nation around", "hmeXq69j9_I-00175-00038177-00038346": "the world now this is a proud", "hmeXq69j9_I-00176-00038347-00038533": "accomplishment for Australia's great", "hmeXq69j9_I-00177-00038534-00038605": "wine", "hmeXq69j9_I-00178-00038606-00038797": "making industry and they've been able to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00179-00038798-00039001": "do that and part because of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00180-00039002-00039190": "china-australia free trade agreement", "hmeXq69j9_I-00181-00039191-00039421": "which has seen stray lien wine exports", "hmeXq69j9_I-00182-00039422-00039649": "to China grow by more than one hundred", "hmeXq69j9_I-00183-00039650-00039826": "and eighty percent since coming into", "hmeXq69j9_I-00184-00039827-00040102": "force massive opportunities for business", "hmeXq69j9_I-00185-00040103-00040297": "antic a final supplementary question", "hmeXq69j9_I-00186-00040298-00040450": "here mr. president Minister how to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00187-00040451-00040627": "Australia's free trade agreements create", "hmeXq69j9_I-00188-00040628-00040765": "more opportunities for Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00189-00040766-00040936": "businesses and exporters senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00190-00040937-00041182": "Birmingham mr. president they create the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00191-00041183-00041401": "opportunity for Australia's businesses", "hmeXq69j9_I-00192-00041402-00041602": "and exporters to be able to land their", "hmeXq69j9_I-00193-00041603-00041830": "goods their services their products in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00194-00041831-00042087": "markets at a more competitive rate than", "hmeXq69j9_I-00195-00042088-00042286": "their competitors and that is the key", "hmeXq69j9_I-00196-00042287-00042484": "thing here to be able to get into the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00197-00042485-00042730": "market with the least amount of cost", "hmeXq69j9_I-00198-00042731-00043015": "imposed or barriers for those exporters", "hmeXq69j9_I-00199-00043016-00043210": "that's why we continue to pursue new", "hmeXq69j9_I-00200-00043211-00043369": "market opportunities that's what we'll", "hmeXq69j9_I-00201-00043370-00043558": "be doing in the negotiations for the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00202-00043559-00043662": "regional comprehensive economic", "hmeXq69j9_I-00203-00043663-00043885": "partnership agreement it's what we will", "hmeXq69j9_I-00204-00043886-00044104": "be doing in our negotiations with the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00205-00044105-00044365": "European Union and I do warmly welcome", "hmeXq69j9_I-00206-00044366-00044587": "the statement of the incoming president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00207-00044588-00044839": "of the European Commission who in her", "hmeXq69j9_I-00208-00044840-00045034": "policy agenda has stated very clearly", "hmeXq69j9_I-00209-00045035-00045313": "the priority that the EC places on", "hmeXq69j9_I-00210-00045314-00045595": "finalizing quickly an agreement with", "hmeXq69j9_I-00211-00045596-00045832": "Australia we stand ready willing and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00212-00045833-00046077": "able to negotiate quickly and to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00213-00046078-00046246": "finalize an ambitious and comprehensive", "hmeXq69j9_I-00214-00046247-00046515": "agreement with the European Union as we", "hmeXq69j9_I-00215-00046516-00046699": "do with the UK should circumstances", "hmeXq69j9_I-00216-00046700-00046902": "allow as we do with our regional trading", "hmeXq69j9_I-00217-00046903-00047119": "partners all of it to keep creating more", "hmeXq69j9_I-00218-00047120-00047329": "job opportunities for Australian senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00219-00047330-00047727": "O'Neill senator one I understand the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00220-00047728-00047905": "government will give leave on I seek", "hmeXq69j9_I-00221-00047906-00048240": "leave to table two assets that show mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00222-00048241-00048577": "Minister Taylor's relationship to guffy", "hmeXq69j9_I-00223-00048578-00048762": "proprietary limited and the ownership of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00224-00048763-00048931": "Jan lamb propriety limited a third", "hmeXq69j9_I-00225-00048932-00049140": "ownership being in the hands of Goffe", "hmeXq69j9_I-00226-00049141-00049312": "proprietary limited mr. Taylor's company", "hmeXq69j9_I-00227-00049313-00049446": "leave is granted", "hmeXq69j9_I-00228-00049447-00049693": "senator O'Neill Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00229-00049694-00049858": "my question is to the Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00230-00049859-00050059": "representing the Prime Minister senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00231-00050060-00050281": "Corman in question time yesterday", "hmeXq69j9_I-00232-00050282-00050455": "Minister Taylor told the House of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00233-00050456-00050764": "Representatives that and I quote I have", "hmeXq69j9_I-00234-00050765-00050929": "no association and have remained at", "hmeXq69j9_I-00235-00050930-00051073": "arm's length at all times from the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00236-00051074-00051298": "company jamb land does the Prime", "hmeXq69j9_I-00237-00051299-00051469": "Minister accepted Minister Taylor's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00238-00051470-00051714": "assertion the minister representing the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00239-00051715-00051902": "Prime Minister senator Corman", "hmeXq69j9_I-00240-00051903-00052214": "thank you very much mr. president yes he", "hmeXq69j9_I-00241-00052215-00052294": "does", "hmeXq69j9_I-00242-00052295-00052571": "senator O'Neil supplementary question", "hmeXq69j9_I-00243-00052572-00052859": "Thank You mr. president mr. Taylor is a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00244-00052860-00052928": "director of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00245-00052929-00053246": "guffy proprietary limited a joint holder", "hmeXq69j9_I-00246-00053247-00053471": "of a one-third interest in Jam land", "hmeXq69j9_I-00247-00053472-00053738": "propriety limited a company under", "hmeXq69j9_I-00248-00053739-00053905": "investigation by the Department of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00249-00053907-00054122": "Environment and energy for allegedly", "hmeXq69j9_I-00250-00054123-00054344": "poisoning hectares of critically", "hmeXq69j9_I-00251-00054345-00054659": "endangered grasslands how is this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00252-00054660-00054880": "consistent with Minister Taylor's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00253-00054882-00055165": "assertion that he has and I quote no", "hmeXq69j9_I-00254-00055166-00055366": "association and have remained at", "hmeXq69j9_I-00255-00055367-00055562": "arm-length arm's length at all times", "hmeXq69j9_I-00256-00055563-00055814": "from the company Jam land senator Corman", "hmeXq69j9_I-00257-00055815-00056077": "thank you very much mr. president the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00258-00056078-00056297": "Minister has addressed these matters in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00259-00056298-00056564": "detail yesterday no doubt no doubt the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00260-00056565-00056738": "opposition has the opportunity I asked", "hmeXq69j9_I-00261-00056739-00056905": "Minister questions on these matters", "hmeXq69j9_I-00262-00056907-00057134": "directly in the House of Representatives", "hmeXq69j9_I-00263-00057135-00057509": "today also both ministers Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00264-00057510-00057749": "birmingham and myself have made relevant", "hmeXq69j9_I-00265-00057750-00057935": "statements to the Senate I can again", "hmeXq69j9_I-00266-00057936-00058129": "confirm that the Prime Minister has", "hmeXq69j9_I-00267-00058130-00058436": "confidence in Minister Tyler senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00268-00058437-00058649": "O'Neill final supplementary questions in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00269-00058650-00058855": "question time yesterday Minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-00270-00058857-00059027": "told the House of Representatives that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00271-00059028-00059384": "and I quote I have always disclosed my", "hmeXq69j9_I-00272-00059385-00059597": "interests and they've been very clear", "hmeXq69j9_I-00273-00059598-00059897": "about those interests if Minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-00274-00059898-00060191": "had disclosed his interest how could it", "hmeXq69j9_I-00275-00060191-00060476": "be possible that his own secretary was", "hmeXq69j9_I-00276-00060477-00060725": "not aware senator Corman", "hmeXq69j9_I-00277-00060726-00061054": "thank you very much mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00278-00061055-00061283": "the Honorable senator is indeed right", "hmeXq69j9_I-00279-00061284-00061604": "that is what Minister Taylor has made", "hmeXq69j9_I-00280-00061604-00061790": "very clear that he is always declared", "hmeXq69j9_I-00281-00061791-00062017": "his interests obviously you know the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00282-00062019-00062166": "interests have to be declared", "hmeXq69j9_I-00283-00062167-00062357": "inappropriate why consistent with the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00284-00062358-00062530": "rules in relevant chambers and I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-00285-00062532-00062816": "confident that that's what's happened", "hmeXq69j9_I-00286-00062816-00063198": "senator de Natali Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00287-00063199-00063305": "president my question is to the Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00288-00063306-00063599": "for Foreign Affairs Minister last week", "hmeXq69j9_I-00289-00063600-00063755": "four corners showed the heartbreaking", "hmeXq69j9_I-00290-00063756-00063944": "stories of families torn apart by", "hmeXq69j9_I-00291-00063945-00064197": "China's mass incarceration of wages and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00292-00064198-00064429": "other Muslim minorities in Xin Jiang", "hmeXq69j9_I-00293-00064430-00064655": "more than 1 million people have been", "hmeXq69j9_I-00294-00064656-00064817": "putting massive internment camps", "hmeXq69j9_I-00295-00064818-00064994": "including those who call Australia home", "hmeXq69j9_I-00296-00064995-00065230": "and those with relatives in Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00297-00065231-00065492": "Minister I welcome your intervention to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00298-00065493-00065687": "request that said in Abu Salam whose", "hmeXq69j9_I-00299-00065688-00065946": "wife and baby son be allowed to travel", "hmeXq69j9_I-00300-00065947-00066204": "to Australia as far as the government is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00301-00066205-00066465": "aware how many Australian citizens are", "hmeXq69j9_I-00302-00066466-00066741": "currently in xingyang and what is your", "hmeXq69j9_I-00303-00066742-00066897": "government doing to secure the release", "hmeXq69j9_I-00304-00066898-00067140": "of other Australians and their families", "hmeXq69j9_I-00305-00067141-00067449": "like fast-tracking visa processes the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00306-00067450-00067599": "Minister for Foreign Affairs senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00307-00067600-00067763": "Paine thank you very much mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00308-00067764-00067998": "I think senator Dean Italia for his", "hmeXq69j9_I-00309-00067999-00068430": "question in relation to the numbers of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00310-00068431-00068588": "Australian citizens or permanent", "hmeXq69j9_I-00311-00068589-00068934": "residents of Australia who may be in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00312-00068935-00069143": "Xinjiang we are aware of a number of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00313-00069144-00069650": "cases where people had traveled to to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00314-00069651-00070017": "the region some of those also have", "hmeXq69j9_I-00315-00070018-00070361": "Australian connections such as spouse", "hmeXq69j9_I-00316-00070362-00070763": "visas or associations like that which", "hmeXq69j9_I-00317-00070764-00070947": "Australian family members have requested", "hmeXq69j9_I-00318-00070948-00071201": "us to do so we have made inquiries with", "hmeXq69j9_I-00319-00071202-00071438": "Chinese authorities regarding the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00320-00071439-00071772": "whereabouts of those individuals I won't", "hmeXq69j9_I-00321-00071773-00072206": "go into further specifics mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00322-00072207-00072324": "because our of course privacy", "hmeXq69j9_I-00323-00072325-00072530": "obligations are attached to these", "hmeXq69j9_I-00324-00072531-00072788": "matters it is also important to note", "hmeXq69j9_I-00325-00072789-00072962": "that where we are talking about", "hmeXq69j9_I-00326-00072963-00073272": "non-citizens so those who have", "hmeXq69j9_I-00327-00073273-00073469": "Australian connections or a permanent", "hmeXq69j9_I-00328-00073470-00073694": "residents but are not citizens there are", "hmeXq69j9_I-00329-00073695-00073931": "limits to some degree about what", "hmeXq69j9_I-00330-00073932-00074190": "Australia is able to do for in terms of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00331-00074191-00074351": "the level of consular assistance that we", "hmeXq69j9_I-00332-00074352-00074686": "are able to provide to those individuals", "hmeXq69j9_I-00333-00074687-00074886": "senator Dean entirely a supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00334-00074887-00075068": "question I I just wanted a point of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00335-00075069-00075216": "order I might have stood up just before", "hmeXq69j9_I-00336-00075217-00075498": "the minister stood well said ministers", "hmeXq69j9_I-00337-00075499-00075798": "concluded her answer opportunity for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00338-00075799-00075926": "stop electric well perhaps", "hmeXq69j9_I-00339-00075927-00076151": "that could clarify the question of just", "hmeXq69j9_I-00340-00076152-00076296": "how many citizens there are I think you", "hmeXq69j9_I-00341-00076297-00076461": "mentioned several but if you've got a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00342-00076462-00076619": "number I'd appreciate that now the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00343-00076620-00076748": "Chinese government are committing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00344-00076749-00076947": "cultural genocide against the Weger", "hmeXq69j9_I-00345-00076948-00077165": "people we're seeing unjust incarceration", "hmeXq69j9_I-00346-00077166-00077357": "force per little political", "hmeXq69j9_I-00347-00077358-00077606": "indoctrination restrictions on movement", "hmeXq69j9_I-00348-00077607-00077837": "intrusive surveillance and religious", "hmeXq69j9_I-00349-00077838-00078096": "oppression following a joint statement", "hmeXq69j9_I-00350-00078097-00078342": "at the UN Human Rights Council what are", "hmeXq69j9_I-00351-00078343-00078585": "the next steps and how he's Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00352-00078586-00078824": "with countries in the region to generate", "hmeXq69j9_I-00353-00078825-00078992": "action through the United Nations", "hmeXq69j9_I-00354-00078993-00079347": "senator Paine thank you very much mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00355-00079348-00079517": "president I thank Senator Dean Italia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00356-00079518-00079751": "for his questions I don't have a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00357-00079752-00080166": "confirmed number of individuals and it", "hmeXq69j9_I-00358-00080167-00080640": "does move around because different cases", "hmeXq69j9_I-00359-00080641-00080837": "are notified to us at different times so", "hmeXq69j9_I-00360-00080838-00081123": "I would not like to to venture an", "hmeXq69j9_I-00361-00081124-00081342": "inaccurate number in terms of that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00362-00081343-00081654": "Australia has taken this situation and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00363-00081655-00081875": "raised this situation mr. president in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00364-00081876-00082136": "the most serious of ways and the minute", "hmeXq69j9_I-00365-00082137-00082286": "the senator has referred to our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00366-00082287-00082479": "statement in the Human Rights Council of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00367-00082480-00082799": "which we are a member we continue to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00368-00082800-00082993": "engage with the Chinese authorities", "hmeXq69j9_I-00369-00082994-00083207": "particularly in relation to consular", "hmeXq69j9_I-00370-00083208-00083478": "matters and any support that we seek for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00371-00083479-00083661": "those who are not Australian citizens as", "hmeXq69j9_I-00372-00083662-00083904": "well but associated with China and in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00373-00083905-00084240": "terms of next steps we seek support of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00374-00084241-00084512": "the government in China and have", "hmeXq69j9_I-00375-00084513-00084759": "continued to do so for an opportunity to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00376-00084760-00085088": "visit to the region and also to enable", "hmeXq69j9_I-00377-00085089-00085406": "others to visit the region which they", "hmeXq69j9_I-00378-00085407-00085640": "have indicated in the past there is some", "hmeXq69j9_I-00379-00085641-00085994": "some preparedness to do senator Dean", "hmeXq69j9_I-00380-00085995-00086150": "Italia final supplementary questions", "hmeXq69j9_I-00381-00086151-00086288": "Thank You Vince I'd ask that you take", "hmeXq69j9_I-00382-00086289-00086429": "the question of the number of strange", "hmeXq69j9_I-00383-00086430-00086599": "citizens currently in general notice", "hmeXq69j9_I-00384-00086600-00086900": "Minister given the devastating scale of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00385-00086901-00086987": "repression", "hmeXq69j9_I-00386-00086988-00087155": "when will the Australian government", "hmeXq69j9_I-00387-00087156-00087399": "imposed targeted sanctions like visa", "hmeXq69j9_I-00388-00087400-00087735": "bans and asset freezes against those", "hmeXq69j9_I-00389-00087736-00088031": "linked to abuses in Xinjiang Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00390-00088032-00088193": "what will it take for the government to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00391-00088194-00088382": "take action in the face of these", "hmeXq69j9_I-00392-00088383-00088824": "horrific gross violations senator Paine", "hmeXq69j9_I-00393-00088825-00089042": "thank you very much mr. president I will", "hmeXq69j9_I-00394-00089043-00089302": "take senator de natales question about", "hmeXq69j9_I-00395-00089303-00089509": "was unnoticed and see what information I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00396-00089510-00089800": "am able to to provide and I've already", "hmeXq69j9_I-00397-00089801-00090154": "indicated mr. president the steps that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00398-00090155-00090319": "the government is taking the issues that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00399-00090320-00090730": "the government has raised I have don't", "hmeXq69j9_I-00400-00090731-00090916": "agree with the approach that the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00401-00090917-00091120": "Australian Greens are suggests in this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00402-00091121-00091330": "regard I think it is very important for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00403-00091331-00091495": "the government to work in the way that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00404-00091496-00091704": "we are and we will continue to do so", "hmeXq69j9_I-00405-00091705-00092011": "senator Patterson mr. president my", "hmeXq69j9_I-00406-00092012-00092128": "question is to the Minister for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00407-00092129-00092295": "resources and northern Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00408-00092296-00092515": "Minister as you know no doubt know", "hmeXq69j9_I-00409-00092516-00092710": "Australia's resources and energy export", "hmeXq69j9_I-00410-00092711-00092940": "earnings are on track to reach a record", "hmeXq69j9_I-00411-00092941-00093219": "285 billion dollars this financial year", "hmeXq69j9_I-00412-00093220-00093496": "can the Minister update the centres on", "hmeXq69j9_I-00413-00093497-00093655": "how the liberal national government is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00414-00093656-00093808": "on the side of Australian workers", "hmeXq69j9_I-00415-00093809-00094018": "including by ensuring that Australia's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00416-00094019-00094258": "energy export industry remains strong", "hmeXq69j9_I-00417-00094259-00094465": "into the future particularly in my home", "hmeXq69j9_I-00418-00094466-00094693": "state of Victoria Minister for resources", "hmeXq69j9_I-00419-00094694-00094858": "in northern Australia Senator canavan", "hmeXq69j9_I-00420-00094859-00094993": "well thank you mr. president I thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-00421-00094994-00095215": "senator Patterson for his question and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00422-00095216-00095419": "and recognized that his home state of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00423-00095420-00095656": "Victoria has made a proud contribution", "hmeXq69j9_I-00424-00095657-00095890": "to our nation's resources history indeed", "hmeXq69j9_I-00425-00095891-00096211": "in some respects is a home of resources", "hmeXq69j9_I-00426-00096212-00096394": "industry going back to the days of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00427-00096395-00096709": "gold rushers a more recent times the the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00428-00096710-00096958": "use of its extensive brown coal", "hmeXq69j9_I-00429-00096959-00097177": "resources and oil and gas resources it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00430-00097178-00097315": "played an enormous role in developing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00431-00097316-00097537": "our nation we are also seeking to make", "hmeXq69j9_I-00432-00097538-00097717": "sure that Victoria in particular", "hmeXq69j9_I-00433-00097718-00097975": "continues to contribute to the future", "hmeXq69j9_I-00434-00097976-00098125": "strength of our resources sector and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00435-00098126-00098305": "that's why it was so great last week to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00436-00098306-00098434": "join my good friend and colleague", "hmeXq69j9_I-00437-00098435-00098686": "senator Birmingham and and Minister Tim", "hmeXq69j9_I-00438-00098687-00098845": "palace from the Victorian Government to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00439-00098846-00099094": "turn the first side on the hydrogen", "hmeXq69j9_I-00440-00099095-00099361": "energy supply chain project in Victoria", "hmeXq69j9_I-00441-00099362-00099610": "an extremely exciting project for our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00442-00099611-00099840": "country it's a 500 million dollar", "hmeXq69j9_I-00443-00099841-00100066": "project which builds on the best of what", "hmeXq69j9_I-00444-00100067-00100225": "we have done in the past to develop our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00445-00100226-00100435": "resources sector to create future", "hmeXq69j9_I-00446-00100436-00100675": "opportunities it is involving the best", "hmeXq69j9_I-00447-00100676-00100882": "science and technology that we have in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00448-00100883-00101137": "this country the CSIRO has been involved", "hmeXq69j9_I-00449-00101138-00101431": "our chief scientist was there as well at", "hmeXq69j9_I-00450-00101432-00101563": "dr. Ellen Finkel and he has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-00451-00101564-00101725": "involved we have a proud history of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00452-00101726-00101920": "being at the cutting edge of developing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00453-00101921-00102112": "resources and energy for the world and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00454-00102113-00102271": "we have a new opportunity here in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00455-00102272-00102496": "hydrogen it also builds on our record of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00456-00102497-00102733": "working with other countries to supply", "hmeXq69j9_I-00457-00102733-00102970": "their energy and resource and it needs", "hmeXq69j9_I-00458-00102971-00103174": "this 500 million dollar project is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00459-00103175-00103348": "jointly funded by the Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00460-00103349-00103603": "Victorian Government's and Kawasaki", "hmeXq69j9_I-00461-00103604-00103852": "Heavy Industries from Japan the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00462-00103853-00103969": "Victorian Australian governments are", "hmeXq69j9_I-00463-00103970-00104133": "both contributing 50 million dollars to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00464-00104134-00104398": "the innovative project and the Kawasaki", "hmeXq69j9_I-00465-00104399-00104599": "heavy industry company the balance so", "hmeXq69j9_I-00466-00104600-00104743": "we're working with our partners to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00467-00104744-00104920": "supply the region to develop stronger", "hmeXq69j9_I-00468-00104921-00105115": "relationships to the north as well and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00469-00105116-00105301": "of course it is using our natural", "hmeXq69j9_I-00470-00105302-00105526": "resources to create jobs to create", "hmeXq69j9_I-00471-00105527-00105739": "opportunities for Australians that has", "hmeXq69j9_I-00472-00105740-00105940": "allowed us build a prosperous nation in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00473-00105941-00106161": "this country and we will continue to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00474-00106163-00106375": "support and do that in this liberal", "hmeXq69j9_I-00475-00106376-00106513": "national government the hydrogen", "hmeXq69j9_I-00476-00106514-00106761": "industry could potentially creates a new", "hmeXq69j9_I-00477-00106763-00106908": "opportunity for those brown coal", "hmeXq69j9_I-00478-00106909-00107146": "resources in Latrobe Valley and jobs in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00479-00107147-00107356": "Victoria so it passed in a supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00480-00107357-00107503": "question Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00481-00107504-00107716": "Minister what else is the government", "hmeXq69j9_I-00482-00107717-00107869": "doing to support the development of a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00483-00107870-00108193": "hydrogen export industry and create more", "hmeXq69j9_I-00484-00108194-00108430": "jobs in regional Australia senator Kent", "hmeXq69j9_I-00485-00108431-00108711": "even well thank you mr. president and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00486-00108713-00109057": "this project while very exciting and a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00487-00109058-00109308": "world-first project the first time", "hmeXq69j9_I-00488-00109309-00109519": "creating a liquefied transport of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00489-00109520-00109747": "hydrogen to the world it's not all what", "hmeXq69j9_I-00490-00109748-00109957": "the government is doing the Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00491-00109958-00110128": "Government recently has also contributed", "hmeXq69j9_I-00492-00110129-00110334": "another almost 50 million dollars in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00493-00110335-00110641": "funds for 16 different hydrogen projects", "hmeXq69j9_I-00494-00110642-00110878": "that have been funded by arena 26", "hmeXq69j9_I-00495-00110879-00111009": "million dollars has been provided to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00496-00111010-00111229": "future fuels CIC to undertake research", "hmeXq69j9_I-00497-00111230-00111481": "and development on how to adapt existing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00498-00111482-00111739": "infrastructure to hydrogen and dr. Alan", "hmeXq69j9_I-00499-00111740-00111889": "Finkel our chief scientist has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-00500-00111890-00112093": "tasked with developing a national", "hmeXq69j9_I-00501-00112094-00112291": "hydrogen strategy both for the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00502-00112292-00112444": "Australian Government but also to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00503-00112445-00112635": "contribute to the Council of Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00504-00112636-00112792": "governments when working with other", "hmeXq69j9_I-00505-00112793-00112951": "resources energy ministers across", "hmeXq69j9_I-00506-00112952-00113227": "Australia to jointly develop our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00507-00113228-00113361": "hydrogen resources and grow this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00508-00113363-00113533": "industry for our country is a very", "hmeXq69j9_I-00509-00113533-00113644": "exciting opportunity that will take", "hmeXq69j9_I-00510-00113645-00114022": "decades of work to deliver on the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00511-00114023-00114183": "potential promise of hydrogen and we", "hmeXq69j9_I-00512-00114184-00114313": "have committed to that and will", "hmeXq69j9_I-00513-00114314-00114451": "committed to continue to build with", "hmeXq69j9_I-00514-00114452-00114565": "other like-minded countries in the world", "hmeXq69j9_I-00515-00114566-00114694": "to develop this industry for Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00516-00114695-00114883": "Senator Patterson final supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00517-00114883-00115000": "question Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00518-00115001-00115233": "Minister what are the risks to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00519-00115234-00115447": "Australia's strong resources and energy", "hmeXq69j9_I-00520-00115448-00115825": "export sector Senator Canavan well thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-00521-00115826-00116104": "you mr. president well mr. president did", "hmeXq69j9_I-00522-00116105-00116359": "these types of industries we need strong", "hmeXq69j9_I-00523-00116360-00116539": "political support obviously and as I did", "hmeXq69j9_I-00524-00116540-00116870": "mention it was good to join a Victorian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00525-00116871-00117076": "Minister Tim palace there in Victorian I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00526-00117077-00117214": "recognised their support for this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00527-00117215-00117391": "project there are those that oppose this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00528-00117392-00117526": "project though and saying we shouldn't", "hmeXq69j9_I-00529-00117527-00117743": "use our ground coal resources they're", "hmeXq69j9_I-00530-00117744-00117883": "terrible and evil and all these sort of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00531-00117884-00118075": "things and this project will generate", "hmeXq69j9_I-00532-00118076-00118378": "around hundred tons of carbon dioxide I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00533-00118379-00118658": "was told or advised last week that that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00534-00118658-00118933": "would be about 15 to 20 trips from", "hmeXq69j9_I-00535-00118934-00119120": "Melbourne to London on a business class", "hmeXq69j9_I-00536-00119121-00119297": "flight so you know it's one sort of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00537-00119298-00119404": "climate change conference this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00538-00119405-00119560": "particular project have so much less", "hmeXq69j9_I-00539-00119561-00119803": "from that it's a very important", "hmeXq69j9_I-00540-00119804-00119957": "innovation that we do this and support", "hmeXq69j9_I-00541-00119958-00120112": "these projects and I also call the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00542-00120113-00120233": "Victorian Government support the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00543-00120233-00120409": "development their gas resources not just", "hmeXq69j9_I-00544-00120410-00120577": "their hydrogen resources hydrogen", "hmeXq69j9_I-00545-00120578-00120746": "potentially has enormous potential for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00546-00120747-00120806": "decades to come", "hmeXq69j9_I-00547-00120807-00121007": "but we need Victorian gas to develop and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00548-00121008-00121213": "soon rather than later to make sure we", "hmeXq69j9_I-00549-00121214-00121375": "protect the thousands of manufacturing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00550-00121376-00121573": "jobs that exist in Victoria today and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00551-00121574-00121706": "hopefully will exist in the future", "hmeXq69j9_I-00552-00121707-00121909": "providing we have common sense from the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00553-00121910-00122389": "Victorian Government soon Patrick thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-00554-00122390-00122551": "you mr. president my question is to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00555-00122552-00122785": "Minister for defence is it not the case", "hmeXq69j9_I-00556-00122786-00123028": "that the woman prohibited area the WPA", "hmeXq69j9_I-00557-00123029-00123371": "is a unique national security asset for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00558-00123372-00123581": "testing advanced defence capabilities", "hmeXq69j9_I-00559-00123582-00123811": "for Australia our allies is it not the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00560-00123812-00123998": "case that the review of access", "hmeXq69j9_I-00561-00123999-00124153": "arrangements for mining and other", "hmeXq69j9_I-00562-00124154-00124510": "activities within the WPA undertaken but", "hmeXq69j9_I-00563-00124511-00124816": "for defense by dr. Gordon de Brouwer", "hmeXq69j9_I-00564-00124817-00125083": "recommended and I quote a key record", "hmeXq69j9_I-00565-00125084-00125266": "consideration for defence when it", "hmeXq69j9_I-00566-00125267-00125551": "assesses WPA access applications should", "hmeXq69j9_I-00567-00125552-00125744": "be whether companies have substantial", "hmeXq69j9_I-00568-00125745-00125957": "Australian ownership control and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00569-00125958-00126214": "influence what then is the government's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00570-00126215-00126463": "approach to the expansion of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00571-00126464-00126623": "magnetite mining and transport", "hmeXq69j9_I-00572-00126624-00126874": "operations in the WPA being planned by", "hmeXq69j9_I-00573-00126875-00127114": "Chinese owned companies C River mining", "hmeXq69j9_I-00574-00127115-00127358": "and it's Chinese own partner you yang", "hmeXq69j9_I-00575-00127358-00127609": "mining Australia the minister to defense", "hmeXq69j9_I-00576-00127610-00127844": "senator Reynolds thank you very much", "hmeXq69j9_I-00577-00127845-00128050": "senator Patrick for your question and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00578-00128051-00128233": "thanks very much for your interest in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00579-00128234-00128377": "Australia's most important weapons", "hmeXq69j9_I-00580-00128378-00128626": "testing range and which is also a very", "hmeXq69j9_I-00581-00128627-00128833": "significant national security asset for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00582-00128834-00129085": "this nation we raised two main issues", "hmeXq69j9_I-00583-00129086-00129142": "and I've got", "hmeXq69j9_I-00584-00129143-00129415": "first one in terms of the area itself", "hmeXq69j9_I-00585-00129416-00129697": "the area provides defense with a unique", "hmeXq69j9_I-00586-00129698-00129826": "capability for the testing and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00587-00129827-00130045": "evaluation of capabilities because of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00588-00130046-00130252": "its size its remoteness its low", "hmeXq69j9_I-00589-00130253-00130509": "population density and also its quiet", "hmeXq69j9_I-00590-00130510-00130801": "electromagnetic environments defense is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00591-00130802-00131041": "the primary user of the area however in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00592-00131042-00131287": "2014 a coexistence framework was", "hmeXq69j9_I-00593-00131288-00131662": "introduced and under and under this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00594-00131663-00131830": "framework any non defense used and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00595-00131831-00132070": "wishing to access the WPA must hold the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00596-00132071-00132271": "relevant permits or permission to do so", "hmeXq69j9_I-00597-00132272-00132493": "under defenses legislative framework and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00598-00132494-00132730": "this does include defences permission", "hmeXq69j9_I-00599-00132731-00132937": "for any variations sought under existing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00600-00132938-00133207": "permits now in relation to though part", "hmeXq69j9_I-00601-00133208-00133554": "of the question about dr. dubrow's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00602-00133555-00133882": "review I can confirm that on the 11th of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00603-00133883-00134191": "May 2018 dr. dubrow it was appointed to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00604-00134192-00134425": "lead a review of the woma prohibited", "hmeXq69j9_I-00605-00134426-00134611": "area coexistence framework that you", "hmeXq69j9_I-00606-00134612-00134854": "referred to this review builds on the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00607-00134855-00135061": "establishment in 2014 of the existing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00608-00135062-00135247": "coexistent framework that seeks to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00609-00135248-00135445": "balance interests of all users in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00610-00135446-00136003": "wpa now the this review did reaffirm the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00611-00136004-00136345": "need to restrict access and access only", "hmeXq69j9_I-00612-00136346-00136594": "in relation to foreign investment", "hmeXq69j9_I-00613-00136595-00136942": "proposals now on the 29th of March this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00614-00136943-00137077": "year the government announced it", "hmeXq69j9_I-00615-00137078-00137200": "supports the findings and the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00616-00137201-00137509": "recommendations of his review now these", "hmeXq69j9_I-00617-00137510-00137710": "findings do reflect the enduring and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00618-00137711-00137851": "critical importance of the war a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00619-00137852-00138043": "prohibited area too as I've said to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00620-00138044-00138262": "national security while also recognizing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00621-00138263-00138454": "the considerable value of the area holds", "hmeXq69j9_I-00622-00138455-00138682": "for Aboriginal cultural heritage mineral", "hmeXq69j9_I-00623-00138683-00138880": "resources pastoral operations and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00624-00138881-00139054": "environmental research and other", "hmeXq69j9_I-00625-00139055-00139225": "scientific activity so yes we did", "hmeXq69j9_I-00626-00139226-00139456": "support all the recommendations senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00627-00139457-00139606": "patrick a supplementary question yes", "hmeXq69j9_I-00628-00139607-00139777": "sorry minister didn't really go to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00629-00139778-00140115": "intersection of sea river mining", "hmeXq69j9_I-00630-00140116-00140449": "operations in the woma prohibited area", "hmeXq69j9_I-00631-00140450-00140767": "but i'm also interested in sea river", "hmeXq69j9_I-00632-00140768-00140983": "mining have procured an area near Port", "hmeXq69j9_I-00633-00140984-00141241": "Augusta for transshipment that may", "hmeXq69j9_I-00634-00141242-00141478": "involve the introduction of Chinese", "hmeXq69j9_I-00635-00141479-00141817": "vessels into the Spencer Gulf noting", "hmeXq69j9_I-00636-00141818-00142071": "that Cole Turner training area is is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00637-00142072-00142362": "nearby are there any risks and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00638-00142363-00142548": "what does defense doing in respect of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00639-00142549-00142812": "that risk senator Reynolds well thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-00640-00142813-00142935": "you very much senator patrick for that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00641-00142936-00143277": "question and in relation to the cultura", "hmeXq69j9_I-00642-00143278-00143532": "training area all applications for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00643-00143533-00143742": "access are assessed on a case-by-case", "hmeXq69j9_I-00644-00143743-00143985": "basis given the sensitivity of the area", "hmeXq69j9_I-00645-00143986-00144195": "and the safety and security of defense", "hmeXq69j9_I-00646-00144196-00144381": "personnel and facilities are regularly", "hmeXq69j9_I-00647-00144382-00144624": "reviewed for any potential changes in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00648-00144625-00144810": "circumstances so I can confirm that is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00649-00144811-00145065": "the case in relation to that question in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00650-00145066-00145365": "relation to Cu River all applications", "hmeXq69j9_I-00651-00145366-00145560": "for access to the WPA are assessed on a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00652-00145561-00145791": "case-by-case basis given the sensitivity", "hmeXq69j9_I-00653-00145792-00146073": "of the area defense determines the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00654-00146074-00146229": "access conditions based on its", "hmeXq69j9_I-00655-00146230-00146382": "legislative framework and they need to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00656-00146383-00146553": "preserve safety and the security of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00657-00146554-00146901": "defense activities in the area defense", "hmeXq69j9_I-00658-00146902-00147045": "also considers the security implications", "hmeXq69j9_I-00659-00147046-00147312": "of any foreign ownership control or", "hmeXq69j9_I-00660-00147313-00147480": "influence that an applicant may have", "hmeXq69j9_I-00661-00147481-00147816": "before granting access Cu River has an", "hmeXq69j9_I-00662-00147817-00147990": "existing mining permits for operations", "hmeXq69j9_I-00663-00147991-00148227": "at Cane Hill within the WPA which", "hmeXq69j9_I-00664-00148228-00148632": "remains in force until August 2024 Cu", "hmeXq69j9_I-00665-00148633-00148824": "River does not have defenses permission", "hmeXq69j9_I-00666-00148825-00149240": "to access its exploration tenements", "hmeXq69j9_I-00667-00149241-00149475": "senator Patrick a final supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00668-00149476-00149673": "question noting you mentioned foreign", "hmeXq69j9_I-00669-00149674-00149883": "interference one of the directors of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00670-00149884-00150135": "yooyung mining Australia is a former", "hmeXq69j9_I-00671-00150136-00150354": "cabinet minister and Senator Nick bolsa", "hmeXq69j9_I-00672-00150355-00150648": "focus and he's recently registered under", "hmeXq69j9_I-00673-00150649-00150870": "the foreign interference transparency", "hmeXq69j9_I-00674-00150871-00151029": "scheme effectively acknowledging that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00675-00151030-00151433": "you yang mining Australia is a company", "hmeXq69j9_I-00676-00151434-00151811": "with a foreign government related entity", "hmeXq69j9_I-00677-00151812-00152205": "noting that what are your concerns in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00678-00152206-00152382": "respect of their operations in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00679-00152383-00152814": "double PA Sarah Reynolds well thank you", "hmeXq69j9_I-00680-00152815-00152976": "very much senator Patrick for that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00681-00152977-00153249": "question and what I would say is as", "hmeXq69j9_I-00682-00153250-00153420": "you've indicated that Senator Baucus", "hmeXq69j9_I-00683-00153421-00153696": "senator Baucus has done is that all", "hmeXq69j9_I-00684-00153697-00153843": "companies consider their obligations", "hmeXq69j9_I-00685-00153844-00154074": "under the scheme now whether a person or", "hmeXq69j9_I-00686-00154075-00154230": "an entity itself is required to register", "hmeXq69j9_I-00687-00154231-00154419": "will depend of course on who the foreign", "hmeXq69j9_I-00688-00154420-00154611": "principle is the nature of the activity", "hmeXq69j9_I-00689-00154612-00154797": "is undertaken the purpose for which the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00690-00154798-00155037": "activity is undertaken and also in some", "hmeXq69j9_I-00691-00155038-00155235": "cases whether the person has held a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00692-00155236-00155574": "senior public position in Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-00693-00155575-00155841": "the foreign interference transparency", "hmeXq69j9_I-00694-00155842-00156033": "scheme commenced on the 10th of December", "hmeXq69j9_I-00695-00156034-00156261": "last year as we know and its purpose is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00696-00156262-00156432": "to provide for the public and government", "hmeXq69j9_I-00697-00156433-00156609": "decision-makers with visibility of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00698-00156610-00156810": "nature level and extent of foreign", "hmeXq69j9_I-00699-00156811-00157023": "influence on Australia's government and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00700-00157024-00157233": "political processes order senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00701-00157234-00157359": "Reynolds senator Patrick on a point of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00702-00157360-00157518": "order just on a point of order I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-00703-00157519-00157746": "trying to get to the concerns that you", "hmeXq69j9_I-00704-00157747-00157926": "have in respect of the established", "hmeXq69j9_I-00705-00157927-00158106": "foreign influence in this particular", "hmeXq69j9_I-00706-00158107-00158469": "case on the on the WPA on the point of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00707-00158470-00158661": "order Senator Patrick that was the final", "hmeXq69j9_I-00708-00158662-00158808": "part of your question and the minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00709-00158809-00158952": "is allowed to address in other parts of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00710-00158953-00159153": "the question you've reminded her of that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00711-00159154-00159402": "I called the minister and mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00712-00159403-00159624": "what I have done is advise Senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00713-00159625-00159836": "Patrick of the process which applies to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00714-00159837-00160215": "all applicants and anybody so the same", "hmeXq69j9_I-00715-00160216-00160364": "rules for everybody under the fits so", "hmeXq69j9_I-00716-00160365-00160626": "what I've said stands immolation to see", "hmeXq69j9_I-00717-00160627-00160998": "you senator faucet Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00718-00160999-00161187": "president my question also is to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00719-00161188-00161391": "Minister for defence minister given the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00720-00161392-00161666": "unprecedented investment in Australia's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00721-00161667-00161928": "naval capability and specifically the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00722-00161929-00162132": "continuous shipbuilding program under a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00723-00162133-00162429": "naval shipbuilding plan can you update", "hmeXq69j9_I-00724-00162430-00162566": "the Senate on how this benefits", "hmeXq69j9_I-00725-00162567-00162834": "Australian workers Minister for defence", "hmeXq69j9_I-00726-00162835-00163041": "Senator Reynolds well thank you very", "hmeXq69j9_I-00727-00163042-00163206": "much mr. president and I think Senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00728-00163207-00163398": "Forsett for that question and I also", "hmeXq69j9_I-00729-00163399-00163593": "congratulate him for his deep and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00730-00163594-00163824": "enduring support and engagement in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00731-00163825-00164082": "delivery of defense capability and in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00732-00164083-00164306": "particular a shipbuilding program", "hmeXq69j9_I-00733-00164307-00164508": "Australian Government I came confirmed", "hmeXq69j9_I-00734-00164509-00164604": "to the Senate that the Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00735-00164605-00164703": "Government is investing and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00736-00164704-00164841": "unprecedented ninety billion dollars", "hmeXq69j9_I-00737-00164842-00165029": "through the naval shipbuilding program", "hmeXq69j9_I-00738-00165030-00165366": "in new naval capability for this nation", "hmeXq69j9_I-00739-00165367-00165621": "as our region and our oceans become more", "hmeXq69j9_I-00740-00165622-00165981": "contestants increasingly so we need new", "hmeXq69j9_I-00741-00165982-00166182": "capable and marine platforms that will", "hmeXq69j9_I-00742-00166183-00166437": "deter threats to our interests and also", "hmeXq69j9_I-00743-00166438-00166725": "provide for our security this is why we", "hmeXq69j9_I-00744-00166726-00166848": "are investing in the largest", "hmeXq69j9_I-00745-00166849-00167100": "regeneration of our Navy since World War", "hmeXq69j9_I-00746-00167101-00167388": "two and I'm delivering a plan that will", "hmeXq69j9_I-00747-00167389-00167646": "see Australia deliver 12 attack class", "hmeXq69j9_I-00748-00167647-00167925": "submarines 12 Arafura class offshore", "hmeXq69j9_I-00749-00167926-00168279": "patrol vessels 900 class frigates 21", "hmeXq69j9_I-00750-00168280-00168537": "Guardian class patrol boats to mine", "hmeXq69j9_I-00751-00168538-00168771": "countermeasure support ships and one", "hmeXq69j9_I-00752-00168772-00168876": "hydrographic", "hmeXq69j9_I-00753-00168877-00169233": "vessel this government is building 57", "hmeXq69j9_I-00754-00169234-00169473": "navels vessels in Australia by", "hmeXq69j9_I-00755-00169474-00169809": "Australians with Australian still the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00756-00169810-00170007": "major invest this major investment will", "hmeXq69j9_I-00757-00170008-00170169": "provide capability for the surveillance", "hmeXq69j9_I-00758-00170170-00170397": "protection of our maritime approaches", "hmeXq69j9_I-00759-00170398-00170655": "and the ability to operate with our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00760-00170656-00170943": "partners seamlessly the capability will", "hmeXq69j9_I-00761-00170944-00171126": "make a real contribution to peace in our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00762-00171127-00171308": "region for decades to come", "hmeXq69j9_I-00763-00171309-00171543": "also it will enhance the ATF's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00764-00171544-00171741": "capability for regional humanitarian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00765-00171742-00171966": "relief and disaster relief which is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00766-00171967-00172224": "crucial to our support and work with our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00767-00172225-00172488": "partners in the indo-pacific to deliver", "hmeXq69j9_I-00768-00172489-00172731": "this capability we are taking a whole of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00769-00172732-00172980": "nation whole of Industry approach which", "hmeXq69j9_I-00770-00172981-00173184": "is exactly what is required for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00771-00173185-00173442": "Australia to succeed in this important", "hmeXq69j9_I-00772-00173443-00173697": "national endeavor I've also had the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00773-00173698-00173838": "opportunity in recent weeks to visit", "hmeXq69j9_I-00774-00173839-00174051": "South Australia and to see the work", "hmeXq69j9_I-00775-00174052-00174267": "already underway to build our air", "hmeXq69j9_I-00776-00174268-00174501": "warfare destroyers and the first of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00777-00174502-00174816": "offshore patrol vessels it is fabulous", "hmeXq69j9_I-00778-00174817-00175035": "and wonderful and I'm so proud to see", "hmeXq69j9_I-00779-00175036-00175230": "the progress and the work that has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-00780-00175231-00175442": "achieved", "hmeXq69j9_I-00781-00175443-00175728": "Forsett a supplementary question Thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-00782-00175729-00175917": "You mr. president convinced to outline", "hmeXq69j9_I-00783-00175918-00176124": "what recent steps have been taken to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00784-00176125-00176340": "build Australia's sovereign industrial", "hmeXq69j9_I-00785-00176341-00176550": "capability to support this naval", "hmeXq69j9_I-00786-00176551-00176795": "shipbuilding endeavor senator Reynolds", "hmeXq69j9_I-00787-00176796-00177077": "well thank you very much senator for sit", "hmeXq69j9_I-00788-00177078-00177294": "mr. president this government is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00789-00177295-00177441": "transforming the relationship between", "hmeXq69j9_I-00790-00177442-00177663": "defense and the defense industry here in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00791-00177664-00177927": "Australia through a clear long-term plan", "hmeXq69j9_I-00792-00177928-00178164": "to strengthen Australia's industrial", "hmeXq69j9_I-00793-00178165-00178452": "base already the implementation of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00794-00178453-00178629": "ninety billion naval shipbuilding plan", "hmeXq69j9_I-00795-00178630-00178851": "is well underway as I've said with", "hmeXq69j9_I-00796-00178852-00179004": "construction of the Arafura class", "hmeXq69j9_I-00797-00179005-00179223": "offshore patrol vessels and also I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-00798-00179224-00179373": "very pleased to say the Guardian class", "hmeXq69j9_I-00799-00179374-00179595": "Pacific patrol boats in my own home", "hmeXq69j9_I-00800-00179596-00179880": "state of Western Australia the Morison", "hmeXq69j9_I-00801-00179881-00180078": "government is making a 1 billion dollar", "hmeXq69j9_I-00802-00180079-00180276": "investment to construct the world's most", "hmeXq69j9_I-00803-00180277-00180471": "advanced shipyards in both South", "hmeXq69j9_I-00804-00180472-00180819": "Australia and in Western Australia this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00805-00180820-00181052": "work is well underway in creating", "hmeXq69j9_I-00806-00181053-00181365": "approximately 15,000 skilled and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00807-00181366-00181608": "professional jobs across these programs", "hmeXq69j9_I-00808-00181609-00181808": "real jobs", "hmeXq69j9_I-00809-00181809-00182144": "in Australia unlike what you did not", "hmeXq69j9_I-00810-00182145-00183349": "deliver it so happen so for the answer", "hmeXq69j9_I-00811-00183350-00183823": "has expired senator Carr senator forced", "hmeXq69j9_I-00812-00183824-00183987": "to the final supplementary question", "hmeXq69j9_I-00813-00183988-00184244": "Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00814-00184245-00184433": "can the minister update the Senate on", "hmeXq69j9_I-00815-00184434-00184608": "other elements of this capability", "hmeXq69j9_I-00816-00184609-00184765": "renewal plan", "hmeXq69j9_I-00817-00184766-00184990": "senator Reynolds senator Fawcett's I'd", "hmeXq69j9_I-00818-00184991-00185221": "be delighted to this government is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00819-00185222-00185386": "transforming the relationship between", "hmeXq69j9_I-00820-00185387-00185599": "defense and defense industry and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00821-00185600-00185803": "recently I had the opportunity to visit", "hmeXq69j9_I-00822-00185804-00185932": "the BAE Systems", "hmeXq69j9_I-00823-00185933-00186170": "Govan shipyard in Glasgow in the United", "hmeXq69j9_I-00824-00186171-00186403": "Kingdom where I experienced firsthand", "hmeXq69j9_I-00825-00186404-00186620": "the build progress on the city class", "hmeXq69j9_I-00826-00186621-00186883": "type 26 River frigates for the Royal", "hmeXq69j9_I-00827-00186884-00187228": "Navy the design that will form the basis", "hmeXq69j9_I-00828-00187229-00187588": "of our new hunter class frigate during", "hmeXq69j9_I-00829-00187589-00187747": "this visit I announced the latest", "hmeXq69j9_I-00830-00187748-00187927": "Australian supplier at the Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00831-00187928-00188095": "supplier to be awarded work through the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00832-00188096-00188389": "20 type 26 supply chain the Adelaide", "hmeXq69j9_I-00833-00188390-00188543": "based company airspeeds", "hmeXq69j9_I-00834-00188544-00188906": "this is just one of many examples of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00835-00188907-00189061": "government's support to the australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-00836-00189062-00189399": "defence export sector and i'm also", "hmeXq69j9_I-00837-00189400-00189685": "pleased and i was very proud to travel", "hmeXq69j9_I-00838-00189686-00189907": "to Cherbourg in france to attend the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00839-00189908-00190123": "launch of France's first barracuda class", "hmeXq69j9_I-00840-00190124-00190396": "submarine with president macron and my", "hmeXq69j9_I-00841-00190397-00190672": "counterpart Minister Polly strong", "hmeXq69j9_I-00842-00190673-00190895": "engagement with France is critical as we", "hmeXq69j9_I-00843-00190896-00191053": "embark on delivering a strategically", "hmeXq69j9_I-00844-00191054-00191413": "vital capability strong industrial unit", "hmeXq69j9_I-00845-00191414-00191797": "Bernard II Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00846-00191798-00191957": "my question is to the Minister for aged", "hmeXq69j9_I-00847-00191958-00192175": "care and senior Australians representing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00848-00192176-00192322": "the Minister for health senator Kohl", "hmeXq69j9_I-00849-00192323-00192565": "Beck yesterday the Australian reported", "hmeXq69j9_I-00850-00192566-00192739": "the doctors specialists and surgeons are", "hmeXq69j9_I-00851-00192740-00192937": "rotting Medicare record levels to line", "hmeXq69j9_I-00852-00192938-00193048": "their own pockets and rip off", "hmeXq69j9_I-00853-00193049-00193324": "hardworking taxpayers they stated that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00854-00193325-00193522": "last month the record of 4.5 million in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00855-00193523-00193690": "rebates for bogus health services", "hmeXq69j9_I-00856-00193691-00193970": "provided to supposedly sick patients was", "hmeXq69j9_I-00857-00193971-00194144": "identified by the professional services", "hmeXq69j9_I-00858-00194145-00194263": "review for repayment", "hmeXq69j9_I-00859-00194264-00194582": "after recouping 10 million into 2017 18", "hmeXq69j9_I-00860-00194583-00194918": "20 million in 2018 19 their Medicare", "hmeXq69j9_I-00861-00194919-00195041": "watchdog expects to reach", "hmeXq69j9_I-00862-00195042-00195271": "further 30 million this financial year", "hmeXq69j9_I-00863-00195272-00195515": "minister given these phenomenal rises in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00864-00195516-00195743": "bogus rebates claimed and recouped is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00865-00195744-00195926": "the government's increased and welcomed", "hmeXq69j9_I-00866-00195927-00196115": "compliance efforts unveiling a rotting", "hmeXq69j9_I-00867-00196116-00196316": "crisis in our long trusted system of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00868-00196317-00196517": "Medicare the minister representing the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00869-00196518-00196754": "Minister for health Senator Kovac Thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-00870-00196755-00197003": "You mr. president and thank you senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00871-00197004-00197210": "Banali for the question", "hmeXq69j9_I-00872-00197211-00197513": "fortunately senator Benari largely our", "hmeXq69j9_I-00873-00197514-00197966": "doctors do the right thing of course", "hmeXq69j9_I-00874-00197967-00198146": "those who don't do the right thing and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00875-00198147-00198503": "who overcharge we seek to as you've", "hmeXq69j9_I-00876-00198504-00198694": "quite rightly said in your question", "hmeXq69j9_I-00877-00198695-00199150": "recover funds that have been overtaken", "hmeXq69j9_I-00878-00199151-00199427": "last year we introduced to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00879-00199428-00199613": "Parliament the health legislation", "hmeXq69j9_I-00880-00199614-00199919": "amendment improved medical Medicare and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00881-00199920-00200144": "compliance and other measures bill to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00882-00200145-00200426": "implement measures announced in the 2017", "hmeXq69j9_I-00883-00200427-00200708": "budget support the integrity of Medicare", "hmeXq69j9_I-00884-00200709-00200930": "and the fairness pharmaceutical Benefits", "hmeXq69j9_I-00885-00200931-00201335": "Scheme the bill delivered savings of a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00886-00201336-00201578": "hundred and three million over four", "hmeXq69j9_I-00887-00201579-00201947": "years which aligns with the sorts of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00888-00201948-00202261": "numbers that you're quoting in your", "hmeXq69j9_I-00889-00202262-00202589": "question and those numbers are based on", "hmeXq69j9_I-00890-00202590-00202811": "increased and earlier debt collection", "hmeXq69j9_I-00891-00202812-00203033": "figures the measures in the bills", "hmeXq69j9_I-00892-00203034-00203183": "support the integrity of Medicare", "hmeXq69j9_I-00893-00203184-00203372": "through improvements to the recovery of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00894-00203373-00203702": "arrangements for Medicare debts owed by", "hmeXq69j9_I-00895-00203703-00203855": "to the Commonwealth and these", "hmeXq69j9_I-00896-00203856-00204137": "improvements will allow compulsory", "hmeXq69j9_I-00897-00204138-00204556": "offsetting of future medical Medicare", "hmeXq69j9_I-00898-00204557-00204911": "benefits scheduled MBS payments to may", "hmeXq69j9_I-00899-00204912-00205094": "not made to provide us on behalf of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00900-00205094-00205253": "patients both billing patients", "hmeXq69j9_I-00901-00205254-00205577": "introduced garnishee arrangements for", "hmeXq69j9_I-00902-00205578-00205885": "providers who do not bill and make", "hmeXq69j9_I-00903-00205886-00206057": "administrative arrangements more", "hmeXq69j9_I-00904-00206058-00206228": "consistent across the three acts and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00905-00206229-00206387": "deal with businesses billing approaches", "hmeXq69j9_I-00906-00206388-00206608": "that impact on claiming by providers", "hmeXq69j9_I-00907-00206609-00206801": "Senator Bernardi a supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00908-00206802-00206954": "question Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00909-00206955-00207086": "Minister the article reported that a", "hmeXq69j9_I-00910-00207087-00207271": "sleep specialist billed to say Medicare", "hmeXq69j9_I-00911-00207273-00207523": "item number more than 5,000 times in 12", "hmeXq69j9_I-00912-00207525-00207734": "months to claim 1 million dollars in", "hmeXq69j9_I-00913-00207735-00207958": "bogus rebates a surgeon billed more than", "hmeXq69j9_I-00914-00207959-00208212": "17,000 services and a GP more than", "hmeXq69j9_I-00915-00208213-00208416": "fifteen thousand services in one year", "hmeXq69j9_I-00916-00208417-00208584": "both clocking up around half a million", "hmeXq69j9_I-00917-00208585-00208908": "dollars in stolen taxpayers money can", "hmeXq69j9_I-00918-00208909-00209061": "the minister shed further light on the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00919-00209062-00209205": "nature and patterns of those growing", "hmeXq69j9_I-00920-00209206-00209391": "Medicare abuses and the states and", "hmeXq69j9_I-00921-00209392-00209610": "communities most prone to such crooked", "hmeXq69j9_I-00922-00209611-00210354": "activity senator copic Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00923-00210355-00210590": "president thank you senator Benari I", "hmeXq69j9_I-00924-00210591-00210833": "think the point that I would make is", "hmeXq69j9_I-00925-00210834-00211283": "that we have put in place measures to", "hmeXq69j9_I-00926-00211284-00211689": "continue to enforce compliance with the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00927-00211690-00212021": "Medicare schedule process if anyone has", "hmeXq69j9_I-00928-00212023-00212309": "specific cases that are being raised", "hmeXq69j9_I-00929-00212310-00212589": "we're happy to hear from them because we", "hmeXq69j9_I-00930-00212590-00212891": "have processes in place that we can", "hmeXq69j9_I-00931-00212892-00213273": "undertake to make sure that debt", "hmeXq69j9_I-00932-00213273-00213465": "recovery is undertaken and I've", "hmeXq69j9_I-00933-00213466-00213690": "mentioned that in my answer to your", "hmeXq69j9_I-00934-00213691-00213944": "primary questions we do have capacity", "hmeXq69j9_I-00935-00213946-00214323": "mr. president to make reference to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00936-00214323-00214716": "AFP and their Medicare fraud squad", "hmeXq69j9_I-00937-00214717-00214998": "within the AFP that can undertake", "hmeXq69j9_I-00938-00214998-00215280": "investigations and there are processes", "hmeXq69j9_I-00939-00215281-00215556": "through which we can continue to work", "hmeXq69j9_I-00940-00215557-00215873": "through that through the AFP to recover", "hmeXq69j9_I-00941-00215875-00215961": "debts as well", "hmeXq69j9_I-00942-00215962-00216159": "Sarah Bernard a final supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-00943-00216160-00216419": "question Thank You Minister these", "hmeXq69j9_I-00944-00216421-00216660": "doctors are clearly rotting the system", "hmeXq69j9_I-00945-00216661-00216873": "and effectively stealing from taxpayers", "hmeXq69j9_I-00946-00216873-00217101": "so can you advise me how many Medicare", "hmeXq69j9_I-00947-00217102-00217266": "provider numbers have been removed from", "hmeXq69j9_I-00948-00217267-00217479": "these practitioners or how many have", "hmeXq69j9_I-00949-00217480-00217626": "been deregistered as medical", "hmeXq69j9_I-00950-00217627-00217791": "practitioners as a result of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00951-00217792-00218057": "investigations and this criminal conduct", "hmeXq69j9_I-00952-00218058-00218367": "senator Kohl Beck Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00953-00218367-00218406": "president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00954-00218407-00218592": "I don't have specific details on that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00955-00218592-00218925": "information with me surprisingly but I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-00956-00218926-00219150": "happy to take that on notice and we can", "hmeXq69j9_I-00957-00219151-00219269": "provide that back to you end of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00958-00219271-00219579": "chamber sorry kitchen Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00959-00219580-00219636": "president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00960-00219637-00219756": "my question is to the Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-00961-00219757-00219966": "representing the prime minister senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-00962-00219967-00220227": "Corman I refer to the report of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00963-00220228-00220367": "Secretary of the Department of the Prime", "hmeXq69j9_I-00964-00220369-00220602": "Minister and cabinet in relation to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00965-00220603-00220728": "application of the statement of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00966-00220729-00220950": "ministerial standards against former", "hmeXq69j9_I-00967-00220951-00221217": "ministers pine and Bishop does mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00968-00221217-00221419": "Morrison guarantee the accuracy of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00969-00221419-00221680": "report the minister representing the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00970-00221681-00221856": "Prime Minister senator Corman well as", "hmeXq69j9_I-00971-00221857-00222073": "I've indicated to the chamber before the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00972-00222073-00222282": "Prime Minister on the basis of dr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00973-00222283-00222802": "Parkinsons report has confirmed that", "hmeXq69j9_I-00974-00222803-00223006": "there's no breach in ministerial", "hmeXq69j9_I-00975-00223007-00223075": "standards", "hmeXq69j9_I-00976-00223076-00223269": "senator Kitchener supplementary question", "hmeXq69j9_I-00977-00223271-00223462": "Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-00978-00223463-00223809": "the report states that and I quote Mr", "hmeXq69j9_I-00979-00223810-00224044": "Pyne advised me that a why is a client", "hmeXq69j9_I-00980-00224044-00224333": "of GC advisory which is a public affairs", "hmeXq69j9_I-00981-00224334-00224578": "strategic communications advisory", "hmeXq69j9_I-00982-00224579-00224941": "company co-owned by Mr Pyne and mr. Adam", "hmeXq69j9_I-00983-00224942-00225196": "Howard mr. pines former chief of staff", "hmeXq69j9_I-00984-00225196-00225463": "the Australian Government register of", "hmeXq69j9_I-00985-00225464-00225715": "lobbyists lists Adam Howard is the sole", "hmeXq69j9_I-00986-00225716-00226032": "owner of GC advisory and does not list", "hmeXq69j9_I-00987-00226033-00226321": "ey as a client which is correct", "hmeXq69j9_I-00988-00226321-00226812": "dr. Parkinson's report or the register", "hmeXq69j9_I-00989-00226813-00227073": "thank you thank you very much mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-00990-00227075-00227340": "president the prime minister of course", "hmeXq69j9_I-00991-00227341-00227641": "completely accepts the advice provided", "hmeXq69j9_I-00992-00227642-00228016": "by dr. Parkinson senator kitchen the", "hmeXq69j9_I-00993-00228017-00228321": "final supplementary question Thank You", "hmeXq69j9_I-00994-00228323-00228646": "mr. president given the dr. Parkinson's", "hmeXq69j9_I-00995-00228646-00228877": "report it now contains at least three", "hmeXq69j9_I-00996-00228878-00229146": "errors of fact under question how can", "hmeXq69j9_I-00997-00229148-00229354": "the prime minister possibly rely on this", "hmeXq69j9_I-00998-00229355-00229656": "report senator Coleman thank you very", "hmeXq69j9_I-00999-00229657-00229912": "much mr. president I don't accept the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01000-00229913-00230159": "premise of the question senator Smith", "hmeXq69j9_I-01001-00230160-00230385": "mr. president my question is the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01002-00230386-00230566": "Minister for Foreign Affairs can the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01003-00230567-00230769": "Minister update the Senate on how the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01004-00230771-00230985": "government is delivering on its specific", "hmeXq69j9_I-01005-00230986-00231255": "step up the Minister for Foreign Affairs", "hmeXq69j9_I-01006-00231256-00231432": "senator Paine thank you very much mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01007-00231433-00231609": "president and I thank Senator Smith for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01008-00231610-00231778": "his question and he's interested in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01009-00231779-00231991": "these key issues because this government", "hmeXq69j9_I-01010-00231992-00232189": "recognizes the importance of both", "hmeXq69j9_I-01011-00232190-00232392": "meeting the challenges and the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01012-00232394-00232600": "opportunities of our blue Pacific", "hmeXq69j9_I-01013-00232601-00232828": "continent mr. president that's why in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01014-00232829-00233038": "consultation and in partnership with our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01015-00233039-00233223": "Pacific neighbors the Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-01016-00233225-00233367": "Government is implementing our Pacific", "hmeXq69j9_I-01017-00233369-00233728": "step up security economic growth closer", "hmeXq69j9_I-01018-00233729-00233938": "people-to-people links so that they can", "hmeXq69j9_I-01019-00233939-00234169": "prosper are the fundamental principles", "hmeXq69j9_I-01020-00234169-00234373": "that underpin the step up and I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-01021-00234373-00234565": "pleased to say that we are delivering on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01022-00234566-00234667": "our commitment", "hmeXq69j9_I-01023-00234667-00234873": "the office of the Pacific has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01024-00234875-00235048": "established in my department to make", "hmeXq69j9_I-01025-00235048-00235255": "sure that all arms of government are", "hmeXq69j9_I-01026-00235256-00235546": "working toward working toward this goal", "hmeXq69j9_I-01027-00235546-00235813": "together we've signed memoranda of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01028-00235814-00236041": "understanding with ten countries now mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01029-00236042-00236182": "president to join the Pacific labor", "hmeXq69j9_I-01030-00236183-00236348": "scheme which will create economic", "hmeXq69j9_I-01031-00236350-00236602": "opportunities and build skills for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01032-00236603-00236812": "Pacific island workers and support", "hmeXq69j9_I-01033-00236813-00236977": "regional and rural economies in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01034-00236978-00237321": "Australia and this month the Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-01035-00237321-00237541": "infrastructure financing facility for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01036-00237542-00237769": "the Pacific also opened for business", "hmeXq69j9_I-01037-00237769-00237976": "which will work to address the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01038-00237977-00238255": "infrastructure needs of the region they", "hmeXq69j9_I-01039-00238256-00238483": "are mr. president considerable indeed", "hmeXq69j9_I-01040-00238484-00238666": "estimated by the Asian Development Bank", "hmeXq69j9_I-01041-00238667-00238948": "to be at over forty six billion dollars", "hmeXq69j9_I-01042-00238948-00239281": "us in the period from now till 2030 the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01043-00239282-00239494": "Coral Sea cable system mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01044-00239494-00239692": "which will deliver faster cheaper and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01045-00239692-00239881": "more reliable connectivity and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01046-00239882-00240085": "communications for Papua New Guinea and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01047-00240086-00240273": "the Solomon Islands is on track to be", "hmeXq69j9_I-01048-00240275-00240436": "operational by the end of the year", "hmeXq69j9_I-01049-00240437-00240640": "indeed the cables have landed in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01050-00240641-00240913": "Solomon Islands in Honiara and in Port", "hmeXq69j9_I-01051-00240914-00241105": "Moresby in Papua New Guinea and we're", "hmeXq69j9_I-01052-00241106-00241273": "building on our people-to-people links", "hmeXq69j9_I-01053-00241273-00241558": "through our shared love of sport and our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01054-00241559-00241741": "shared love of competition in sport I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01055-00241742-00241944": "would my dad and also our church", "hmeXq69j9_I-01056-00241946-00242155": "partnerships program which is a very", "hmeXq69j9_I-01057-00242156-00242479": "powerful engagement between Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-01058-00242480-00242689": "and our neighbors both the Prime", "hmeXq69j9_I-01059-00242690-00242844": "Minister and I have demonstrated our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01060-00242846-00243001": "respective commitment to the Pacific", "hmeXq69j9_I-01061-00243002-00243142": "with our regional visits since the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01062-00243142-00243355": "election and indeed I look forward to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01063-00243356-00243514": "discussing Pacific priorities further", "hmeXq69j9_I-01064-00243515-00243715": "this week at foreign ministers meetings", "hmeXq69j9_I-01065-00243716-00243880": "in supine senator Smith the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01066-00243881-00244044": "supplementary question Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01067-00244046-00244330": "president can the Minister advise us at", "hmeXq69j9_I-01068-00244331-00244537": "how Australia is working in partnership", "hmeXq69j9_I-01069-00244538-00244732": "with Papua New Guinea to increase their", "hmeXq69j9_I-01070-00244733-00244969": "prosperity and security senator Paine", "hmeXq69j9_I-01071-00244969-00245194": "Thank You mr. president this week the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01072-00245194-00245407": "Prime Minister very proudly hosted Papua", "hmeXq69j9_I-01073-00245408-00245617": "New Guinea Prime Minister James Merapi", "hmeXq69j9_I-01074-00245617-00245794": "as a guest of government and the first", "hmeXq69j9_I-01075-00245794-00245965": "guests of government visit since the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01076-00245966-00246171": "election which speaks volumes for the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01077-00246173-00246337": "importance of this relationship a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01078-00246338-00246508": "relationship that we've also announced", "hmeXq69j9_I-01079-00246509-00246694": "we will elevate to a comprehensive", "hmeXq69j9_I-01080-00246694-00246880": "strategic and economic partnership and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01081-00246881-00247071": "I'm pleased to say that within that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01082-00247073-00247240": "Australia and Papua New Guinea have", "hmeXq69j9_I-01083-00247241-00247417": "agreed to a range of new initiatives", "hmeXq69j9_I-01084-00247417-00247585": "that will build both the breadth and the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01085-00247586-00247928": "depth of our partnership in health in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01086-00247929-00248167": "with policing and in a number of other", "hmeXq69j9_I-01087-00248169-00248398": "areas we're working in partnership to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01088-00248400-00248564": "grow Papua New Guinea's economy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01089-00248565-00248783": "including through the coral sea cable as", "hmeXq69j9_I-01090-00248784-00248975": "I mentioned in my earlier response", "hmeXq69j9_I-01091-00248976-00249110": "through the Papua New Guinea", "hmeXq69j9_I-01092-00249111-00249308": "electrification partnership and our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01093-00249309-00249563": "transport sector support programme we're", "hmeXq69j9_I-01094-00249564-00249767": "investing in a range of new projects in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01095-00249767-00249980": "Papua New Guinea's energy sector to both", "hmeXq69j9_I-01096-00249981-00250192": "reduce costs but really importantly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01097-00250194-00250406": "increase access to power we're", "hmeXq69j9_I-01098-00250407-00250541": "supporting plans to refurbish", "hmeXq69j9_I-01099-00250542-00250778": "hydroelectricity plants and to build a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01100-00250779-00250976": "new solar power plant and a new", "hmeXq69j9_I-01101-00250977-00251198": "gas-fired power plant we're committed to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01102-00251198-00251378": "working side by side with Papua New", "hmeXq69j9_I-01103-00251379-00251646": "Guinea to advance the common interest", "hmeXq69j9_I-01104-00251648-00251864": "senator Smith the final supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-01105-00251865-00252050": "question Thank You mr. president can the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01106-00252051-00252260": "minister advise how the government is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01107-00252261-00252496": "working with like-minded nations across", "hmeXq69j9_I-01108-00252498-00252736": "the region to build regional prosperity", "hmeXq69j9_I-01109-00252737-00253052": "security and stability senator Paine", "hmeXq69j9_I-01110-00253053-00253342": "thank you very much and it's fair to say", "hmeXq69j9_I-01111-00253344-00253517": "that engaging with our partners in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01112-00253517-00253730": "region is a core part of the Pacific", "hmeXq69j9_I-01113-00253731-00253973": "step up we're not alone in our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01114-00253973-00254198": "commitment to a stable prosperous and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01115-00254198-00254441": "secure region and our partners including", "hmeXq69j9_I-01116-00254442-00254663": "New Zealand the United States France", "hmeXq69j9_I-01117-00254664-00254944": "Japan multilateral agencies are strongly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01118-00254946-00255113": "committed to the development of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01119-00255114-00255305": "region we're collaborating with the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01120-00255306-00255458": "United States and Japan under our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01121-00255459-00255659": "trilateral infrastructure partnership", "hmeXq69j9_I-01122-00255660-00255898": "and the PNG puppy Nagini electrification", "hmeXq69j9_I-01123-00255900-00256058": "partnership that I referred to earlier", "hmeXq69j9_I-01124-00256059-00256294": "is a really good example of this", "hmeXq69j9_I-01125-00256296-00256517": "effective partnership approach through", "hmeXq69j9_I-01126-00256517-00256688": "which we are working with Papua New", "hmeXq69j9_I-01127-00256689-00256921": "Guinea themselves with Japan with New", "hmeXq69j9_I-01128-00256923-00257141": "Zealand in the United States to support", "hmeXq69j9_I-01129-00257142-00257303": "the Papua New Guinea government to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01130-00257304-00257494": "achieve its goal of providing", "hmeXq69j9_I-01131-00257496-00257753": "electricity to 70% of its population", "hmeXq69j9_I-01132-00257754-00258026": "from the current level of 13 percent by", "hmeXq69j9_I-01133-00258027-00258290": "the end of 2030 projects are underway to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01134-00258291-00258505": "achieve that aim and it is truly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01135-00258506-00258716": "transformative for Papua New Guinea", "hmeXq69j9_I-01136-00258717-00258932": "we're also engaging closely with the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01137-00258933-00259142": "private sector and with civil society to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01138-00259142-00259340": "ensure that we maximize the potatoe", "hmeXq69j9_I-01139-00259341-00259571": "Pacific's tempo to strengthen the region", "hmeXq69j9_I-01140-00259571-00259921": "senator Walsh my question is to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01141-00259923-00260146": "Minister representing the prime minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01142-00260148-00260398": "senator Corman the government is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01143-00260400-00260657": "undertaking a retirement incomes review", "hmeXq69j9_I-01144-00260658-00260957": "will the Prime Minister rule out any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01145-00260958-00261180": "cuts to the pension", "hmeXq69j9_I-01146-00261181-00261382": "Minister representing the Prime Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01147-00261383-00261658": "senator corner Thank You mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01148-00261659-00261865": "the answer is yes but of course the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01149-00261866-00262105": "question is the question is will the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01150-00262106-00262324": "Labour Party rule out there throughout", "hmeXq69j9_I-01151-00262325-00262498": "30 billion dollars in higher taxes on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01152-00262499-00262645": "Australians the time ensiling", "hmeXq69j9_I-01153-00262646-00262921": "oh oh oh so I've already answered the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01154-00262922-00263122": "question but of course this is a contest", "hmeXq69j9_I-01155-00263123-00263359": "this is a battle of ideas we stand for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01156-00263360-00263694": "lower taxes we stand of course for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01157-00263695-00263878": "sustainable funding of all of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01158-00263879-00264103": "essential services Australians rely on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01159-00264104-00264319": "which of course also includes our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01160-00264320-00264550": "appropriately well targeted but generous", "hmeXq69j9_I-01161-00264551-00264817": "welfare safety net we are putting it on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01162-00264818-00265036": "a sustainable fiscal foundation and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01163-00265037-00265258": "trajectory for the future through our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01164-00265259-00265480": "stronger economy through our plan to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01165-00265481-00265639": "build a stronger economy but what is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01166-00265640-00265828": "like a party doing the live apart event", "hmeXq69j9_I-01167-00265829-00266104": "is last election promising 397 billion", "hmeXq69j9_I-01168-00266105-00266326": "dollars in higher taxes there was the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01169-00266327-00266590": "retire rate tax then there was 30", "hmeXq69j9_I-01170-00266591-00266746": "billion dollars in higher taxes on soy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01171-00266747-00266914": "pot there was the higher taxes on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01172-00266915-00267160": "housing on investment on income you name", "hmeXq69j9_I-01173-00267161-00267517": "it so you know under this under under", "hmeXq69j9_I-01174-00267518-00267700": "this government yes Australian people", "hmeXq69j9_I-01175-00267701-00267874": "can be confident that the pension is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01176-00267875-00268102": "safe under the Labour Party it wouldn't", "hmeXq69j9_I-01177-00268103-00268279": "be because under the Labour Party under", "hmeXq69j9_I-01178-00268280-00268501": "the Labour Party the economy what we", "hmeXq69j9_I-01179-00268502-00268762": "wake up the economy we wake up the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01180-00268763-00268963": "budget would be wake up and of course", "hmeXq69j9_I-01181-00268964-00269185": "funding for the essential service would", "hmeXq69j9_I-01182-00269186-00269425": "be on a weaker trajectory for the future", "hmeXq69j9_I-01183-00269426-00269575": "which is of course why no doubt the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01184-00269576-00269890": "Australian people chose to reelect us to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01185-00269891-00270081": "form government at the last election", "hmeXq69j9_I-01186-00270082-00270334": "Sarah Walsh a supplementary question", "hmeXq69j9_I-01187-00270335-00270568": "Thank You mr. president will the Prime", "hmeXq69j9_I-01188-00270569-00270862": "Minister rule out increasing the pension", "hmeXq69j9_I-01189-00270863-00270958": "age beyond", "hmeXq69j9_I-01190-00270959-00271420": "67 Sarah Coleman thank you very much mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01191-00271421-00271579": "president we have absolutely no", "hmeXq69j9_I-01192-00271580-00271729": "intention of changing the pension age", "hmeXq69j9_I-01193-00271730-00271933": "and and I'm quite happy and I'm quite", "hmeXq69j9_I-01194-00271934-00272143": "happy and I'm quite happy to roll it out", "hmeXq69j9_I-01195-00272144-00272338": "I'm quite happy to roll it out but I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01196-00272339-00272422": "know", "hmeXq69j9_I-01197-00272423-00272614": "you know who increase the pension age to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01198-00272615-00272883": "67 I'm just trying to know who was that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01199-00272884-00273169": "who was that that is that the Godfather", "hmeXq69j9_I-01200-00273170-00273430": "of class warriors the Godfather of class", "hmeXq69j9_I-01201-00273431-00273631": "warriors the former member for Lilley", "hmeXq69j9_I-01202-00273632-00273856": "the former member for Lilley what was", "hmeXq69j9_I-01203-00273857-00273976": "his name again I'm just trying to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01204-00273977-00274252": "remember I think it was White Swan you", "hmeXq69j9_I-01205-00274253-00274446": "know White Swan was such an amazing", "hmeXq69j9_I-01206-00274447-00274771": "treasure such an amazing libor member", "hmeXq69j9_I-01207-00274772-00274951": "for the great style of Queens and that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01208-00274952-00275128": "light was primary vote in the cellular", "hmeXq69j9_I-01209-00275129-00275281": "Watts homestead of Queens and is down to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01210-00275282-00275548": "twenty two point six percent twenty two", "hmeXq69j9_I-01211-00275549-00275859": "point six percent twenty twenty two", "hmeXq69j9_I-01212-00275860-00276081": "point six percent that is because the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01213-00276082-00276244": "Australian people understand that under", "hmeXq69j9_I-01214-00276245-00276522": "labor and the higher taxes class warfare", "hmeXq69j9_I-01215-00276523-00276745": "anti-business agenda the country would", "hmeXq69j9_I-01216-00276746-00276865": "be weaker and they would have less", "hmeXq69j9_I-01217-00276866-00277039": "opportunities to get ahead we will", "hmeXq69j9_I-01218-00277040-00277231": "continue to build a stronger economy and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01219-00277232-00277474": "better opportunity for people watch a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01220-00277475-00277741": "final supplementary question Thank You", "hmeXq69j9_I-01221-00277742-00277944": "mr. president in an article entitled", "hmeXq69j9_I-01222-00277945-00278287": "liberal MP Craig Kelly wants family home", "hmeXq69j9_I-01223-00278288-00278634": "included in pension asset tests new", "hmeXq69j9_I-01224-00278635-00278832": "daily has reported that mr. Kelly has", "hmeXq69j9_I-01225-00278833-00279112": "spoken out in defiance of the prime", "hmeXq69j9_I-01226-00279113-00279351": "minister's call to toe the party line", "hmeXq69j9_I-01227-00279352-00279680": "will the Prime Minister exclude any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01228-00279681-00279952": "consideration of the change mr. Kelly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01229-00279953-00280342": "proposed to the point of order I'd ask", "hmeXq69j9_I-01230-00280343-00280801": "that this is her first question I would", "hmeXq69j9_I-01231-00280802-00280990": "ask that the usual courtesies in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01232-00280991-00281143": "addition to the Standing Orders be", "hmeXq69j9_I-01233-00281144-00281371": "observed I request that this senator be", "hmeXq69j9_I-01234-00281372-00281535": "allowed to recommence the second", "hmeXq69j9_I-01235-00281536-00281934": "supplementary I can I just set the rule", "hmeXq69j9_I-01236-00281935-00282027": "on the point of order", "hmeXq69j9_I-01237-00282028-00282376": "can I ask all senators there have been a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01238-00282377-00282562": "number of incidences about questions and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01239-00282563-00282715": "first speeches just to remember the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01240-00282716-00282906": "usual courtesies for senators make on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01241-00282907-00283032": "their feet for the first time in this", "hmeXq69j9_I-01242-00283033-00283281": "chamber there a quick first question or", "hmeXq69j9_I-01243-00283282-00283528": "a first speech I think that courtesy is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01244-00283529-00283789": "important without pointing fingers in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01245-00283790-00284002": "any direction senator Corman thank you", "hmeXq69j9_I-01246-00284003-00284235": "very much it was a president it is the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01247-00284236-00284578": "Honorable one quick sorry senator Walsh", "hmeXq69j9_I-01248-00284579-00284716": "hadn't finished I'll let senator Ross", "hmeXq69j9_I-01249-00284717-00284827": "recommence if she hadn't finished", "hmeXq69j9_I-01250-00284828-00285190": "because I'd lost track senator Walsh all", "hmeXq69j9_I-01251-00285191-00285456": "order I don't think anyone there's an", "hmeXq69j9_I-01252-00285457-00285585": "element of glass houses and stone", "hmeXq69j9_I-01253-00285586-00285681": "throwing about into", "hmeXq69j9_I-01254-00285682-00286002": "actions around this chamber so and it", "hmeXq69j9_I-01255-00286003-00286125": "has happened on a number of occasions", "hmeXq69j9_I-01256-00286126-00286257": "this week senator Walsh please", "hmeXq69j9_I-01257-00286258-00286419": "recommends Thank You mr. president I'll", "hmeXq69j9_I-01258-00286420-00286632": "start the question again in an article", "hmeXq69j9_I-01259-00286633-00286881": "entitled Liberal MP Craig Kelly wants", "hmeXq69j9_I-01260-00286882-00287116": "family home included in pension assets", "hmeXq69j9_I-01261-00287117-00287409": "test new Daley has reported that mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01262-00287410-00287719": "Kelly has spoken out in defiance of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01263-00287720-00287914": "Prime Minister's call to toe the party", "hmeXq69j9_I-01264-00287915-00288248": "line will the Prime Minister exclude any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01265-00288249-00288487": "consideration of the change mr. Kelly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01266-00288488-00288817": "proposed to the pension assets test from", "hmeXq69j9_I-01267-00288818-00288996": "his government's retirement incomes", "hmeXq69j9_I-01268-00288997-00289245": "review senator Corman thank you very", "hmeXq69j9_I-01269-00289246-00289422": "much mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01270-00289423-00289608": "you know the Honorable sender is asking", "hmeXq69j9_I-01271-00289609-00289833": "a first question because if it was not", "hmeXq69j9_I-01272-00289834-00289969": "her first question she would have heard", "hmeXq69j9_I-01273-00289970-00290215": "me say before don't believe everything", "hmeXq69j9_I-01274-00290216-00290376": "you read in the newspaper and even more", "hmeXq69j9_I-01275-00290377-00290610": "importantly don't believe everything you", "hmeXq69j9_I-01276-00290611-00290796": "read in a nude I mean that is what I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01277-00290797-00291081": "would say let me just say that mr. Kelly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01278-00291082-00291294": "has hotly contested the report he", "hmeXq69j9_I-01279-00291295-00291423": "disputes the report went for the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01280-00291424-00291621": "avoidance of any doubt let me also refer", "hmeXq69j9_I-01281-00291622-00291822": "you to one of those bright through", "hmeXq69j9_I-01282-00291823-00292090": "tweets from our treasurer Josh", "hmeXq69j9_I-01283-00292091-00292350": "Frydenberg when he has made very clear", "hmeXq69j9_I-01284-00292351-00292482": "that life as crime that the pension", "hmeXq69j9_I-01285-00292483-00292668": "assets nest will be changed to include", "hmeXq69j9_I-01286-00292669-00293115": "the value of the family home is a lie", "hmeXq69j9_I-01287-00293116-00293368": "Coleman plays resume your sake Senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-01288-00293369-00293652": "Wang on a point of order senator wall on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01289-00293653-00293724": "the point of order", "hmeXq69j9_I-01290-00293725-00293982": "point of order is the actual question is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01291-00293983-00294091": "whether the Prime Minister will", "hmeXq69j9_I-01292-00294092-00294306": "explicitly exclude consideration of this", "hmeXq69j9_I-01293-00294307-00294432": "policy from the review you have", "hmeXq69j9_I-01294-00294433-00294688": "announced I think with respect senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-01295-00294689-00294927": "Wong senator Corman quoting Treasury and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01296-00294928-00295093": "less portfolio responsibilities about", "hmeXq69j9_I-01297-00295094-00295237": "that matter is being directly relevant", "hmeXq69j9_I-01298-00295238-00295524": "to the question let me be very clear the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01299-00295525-00295738": "question is by some a completely false", "hmeXq69j9_I-01300-00295739-00295980": "premise which has been rejected and I've", "hmeXq69j9_I-01301-00295981-00296256": "been very I've been very explicit I've", "hmeXq69j9_I-01302-00296257-00296457": "been very explicit there will be", "hmeXq69j9_I-01303-00296458-00296692": "absolutely no change to include the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01304-00296693-00296922": "value of the family home in the a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01305-00296923-00297091": "pension asset asset test it's not our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01306-00297092-00297231": "policy and never will be and the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01307-00297232-00297396": "treasurer has made that extremely clear", "hmeXq69j9_I-01308-00297397-00297615": "on behalf the government and you newer", "hmeXq69j9_I-01309-00297616-00298087": "order Senator David order Thank You mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01310-00298088-00298138": "president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01311-00298139-00298326": "my question is to the Minister for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01312-00298327-00298639": "agriculture minister McKenzie Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01313-00298640-00298848": "can you please outline to the Senate how", "hmeXq69j9_I-01314-00298849-00298972": "the Liberals and national", "hmeXq69j9_I-01315-00298973-00299188": "government is on the side of Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-01316-00299189-00299404": "farmers and supporting our rural and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01317-00299405-00299605": "regional communities to grow their", "hmeXq69j9_I-01318-00299606-00299835": "productivity and their profitability the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01319-00299836-00299938": "Minister for agriculture", "hmeXq69j9_I-01320-00299939-00300124": "senator Mackenzie well thank you very", "hmeXq69j9_I-01321-00300125-00300340": "much senator Davy for your question and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01322-00300341-00300532": "I know as a proud New South Wales", "hmeXq69j9_I-01323-00300533-00300931": "irrigator who grows rice in on your farm", "hmeXq69j9_I-01324-00300932-00301168": "and also the occasional mongering mung", "hmeXq69j9_I-01325-00301169-00301485": "bean crop you're very interested about", "hmeXq69j9_I-01326-00301486-00301669": "our government's plans to grow the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01327-00301670-00301921": "profitability and productivity of our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01328-00301922-00302212": "primary producers regional Australia has", "hmeXq69j9_I-01329-00302213-00302413": "long been the engine room for our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01330-00302414-00302776": "economy with over 31% of our annual GDP", "hmeXq69j9_I-01331-00302777-00303018": "coming from regional Australia in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01332-00303019-00303298": "2016-17 in fact since we've come to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01333-00303299-00303484": "government Australia's total farm", "hmeXq69j9_I-01334-00303485-00303877": "production has come gone up 25% and this", "hmeXq69j9_I-01335-00303878-00304144": "is because we recognize that our farmers", "hmeXq69j9_I-01336-00304145-00304359": "can grow the best produce in the world", "hmeXq69j9_I-01337-00304360-00304744": "and feed the world 75% but the food and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01338-00304745-00305014": "fibre produced in our regional areas is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01339-00305015-00305326": "actually exported and Australian farmers", "hmeXq69j9_I-01340-00305327-00305566": "feed 40 million people across the world", "hmeXq69j9_I-01341-00305567-00305872": "in fact the value of Ag exporters has", "hmeXq69j9_I-01342-00305873-00306142": "estimated at forty eight point a nine", "hmeXq69j9_I-01343-00306143-00306487": "eight one million dollars in 1718 up", "hmeXq69j9_I-01344-00306488-00306730": "almost twenty nine percent since we've", "hmeXq69j9_I-01345-00306731-00306928": "come to office and Senator Birmingham", "hmeXq69j9_I-01346-00306929-00307144": "touched on some of the reasons for that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01347-00307145-00307405": "increase in exports for agriculture and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01348-00307406-00307612": "the subsequent increase in local jobs", "hmeXq69j9_I-01349-00307613-00307834": "around regional Australia and that is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01350-00307835-00308050": "because of the free trade agreements our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01351-00308051-00308290": "government has signed we've also", "hmeXq69j9_I-01352-00308291-00308548": "invested 50 1.3 million dollars to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01353-00308549-00308707": "continue to grow our agricultural", "hmeXq69j9_I-01354-00308708-00308938": "exports and cease market opportunities", "hmeXq69j9_I-01355-00308939-00309184": "in global food chains to support market", "hmeXq69j9_I-01356-00309185-00309433": "access request maintaining our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01357-00309434-00309649": "biosecurity though as a nation and our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01358-00309650-00309892": "pests and disease free status is the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01359-00309893-00310159": "central value proposition to underpin", "hmeXq69j9_I-01360-00310160-00310354": "that export growth and it is something", "hmeXq69j9_I-01361-00310355-00310549": "that our government has invested", "hmeXq69j9_I-01362-00310550-00310978": "significantly in we also continue to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01363-00310979-00311173": "partner with the taxpayer and levy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01364-00311174-00311479": "growers to have a world-class research", "hmeXq69j9_I-01365-00311480-00311743": "and development facility to increase", "hmeXq69j9_I-01366-00311744-00311878": "innovation on-farm", "hmeXq69j9_I-01367-00311879-00312169": "and increase proper profitability our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01368-00312170-00312276": "government is proud", "hmeXq69j9_I-01369-00312277-00312582": "hi senator Mackenzie senator day via", "hmeXq69j9_I-01370-00312583-00312888": "supplemental question Thank You Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01371-00312889-00313182": "how important is it to ensure that the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01372-00313183-00313407": "government continues to support our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01373-00313408-00313662": "farmers who are experiencing devastating", "hmeXq69j9_I-01374-00313663-00313947": "droughts senator Mackenzie well it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01375-00313948-00314127": "incredibly important because it will", "hmeXq69j9_I-01376-00314128-00314388": "rain again and we want our farmers in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01377-00314389-00314577": "drought affected areas such as your home", "hmeXq69j9_I-01378-00314578-00314784": "state of New South Wales but when the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01379-00314785-00315027": "rains do come that they can get back on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01380-00315028-00315108": "their feet", "hmeXq69j9_I-01381-00315109-00315396": "restock quickly replant quickly and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01382-00315397-00315612": "continue to grow that produce and export", "hmeXq69j9_I-01383-00315613-00315786": "to the world and that's why it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01384-00315787-00315972": "fantastic that Parliament the Senate", "hmeXq69j9_I-01385-00315973-00316245": "today passed the future droughts fund as", "hmeXq69j9_I-01386-00316246-00316458": "part of our more than seven billion", "hmeXq69j9_I-01387-00316459-00316623": "dollar drought response to rural and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01388-00316624-00316881": "regional communities delivering ongoing", "hmeXq69j9_I-01389-00316882-00317208": "immediate and future responses to assist", "hmeXq69j9_I-01390-00317209-00317499": "with overcoming impact of droughts but", "hmeXq69j9_I-01391-00317500-00317664": "for all the posturing from elected", "hmeXq69j9_I-01392-00317665-00317826": "leaders about the need to support", "hmeXq69j9_I-01393-00317827-00318039": "drought affected farmers only the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01394-00318040-00318204": "liberal national government steps up", "hmeXq69j9_I-01395-00318205-00318432": "when it counts prior to the election the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01396-00318433-00318615": "Greens announced an agricultural policy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01397-00318616-00318864": "with a 100 million dollars worth of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01398-00318865-00319035": "support for drought affected communities", "hmeXq69j9_I-01399-00319036-00319347": "each year and I quote we need a plan for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01400-00319348-00319548": "agriculture that looks below beyond the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01401-00319549-00319704": "next election cycle where you had the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01402-00319705-00319986": "chance to vote for it today and you", "hmeXq69j9_I-01403-00319987-00320127": "reject all that Senator Mike Enzi", "hmeXq69j9_I-01404-00320128-00320313": "senator davia final supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-01405-00320314-00320616": "question Thank You Minister what risks", "hmeXq69j9_I-01406-00320617-00320823": "are being faced by our agricultural", "hmeXq69j9_I-01407-00320824-00321078": "sector sector and how can the government", "hmeXq69j9_I-01408-00321079-00321276": "help to minimize these risks", "hmeXq69j9_I-01409-00321277-00321522": "senator Mackenzie well thank you I think", "hmeXq69j9_I-01410-00321523-00321645": "the Greens actually will have an", "hmeXq69j9_I-01411-00321646-00321852": "opportunity to stand up for Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-01412-00321853-00322134": "farmers when the changes to the Criminal", "hmeXq69j9_I-01413-00322135-00322209": "Code around", "hmeXq69j9_I-01414-00322210-00322470": "agricultural protections and illegal", "hmeXq69j9_I-01415-00322471-00322773": "farm activists comes to the Senate and I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01416-00322774-00322998": "look forward to them supporting us in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01417-00322999-00323208": "that the front page of the weekly times", "hmeXq69j9_I-01418-00323209-00323496": "today goes to a victorian farmer whose", "hmeXq69j9_I-01419-00323497-00323727": "family were harassed multiple times over", "hmeXq69j9_I-01420-00323728-00323961": "several weeks to the point of having to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01421-00323962-00324150": "actually take the decision to quit", "hmeXq69j9_I-01422-00324151-00324438": "farming and i quote they had hoodies on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01423-00324439-00324735": "we couldn't see their faces 70 activists", "hmeXq69j9_I-01424-00324736-00324972": "broke into our farm they said they had", "hmeXq69j9_I-01425-00324973-00325239": "an ongoing effect on the mental health", "hmeXq69j9_I-01426-00325240-00325447": "particularly of his family", "hmeXq69j9_I-01427-00325448-00325759": "and the resultant impact was that over", "hmeXq69j9_I-01428-00325760-00326118": "300 chickens the stock actually", "hmeXq69j9_I-01429-00326119-00326440": "suffocated from a result of those animal", "hmeXq69j9_I-01430-00326441-00326674": "activists enough is enough for us to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01431-00326675-00326881": "actually grow this industry increase", "hmeXq69j9_I-01432-00326882-00327121": "regional jobs in our communities we need", "hmeXq69j9_I-01433-00327122-00327325": "to support our farmers and stop the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01434-00327326-00327667": "illegal acts instead of encouraging them", "hmeXq69j9_I-01435-00327668-00328072": "as an against Isis Senator wall Thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-01436-00328073-00328258": "You mr. president my question is again", "hmeXq69j9_I-01437-00328259-00328450": "to Senator Birmingham and I referred a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01438-00328451-00328594": "minister turned a statement yesterday", "hmeXq69j9_I-01439-00328595-00328884": "that he has and I quote no association", "hmeXq69j9_I-01440-00328885-00329071": "with jämtland proprietary limited", "hmeXq69j9_I-01441-00329072-00329239": "end quote does the minister stand by", "hmeXq69j9_I-01442-00329240-00329506": "that statement minister senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-01443-00329507-00329881": "birmingham well mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01444-00329882-00330241": "firstly it was not my statement as my", "hmeXq69j9_I-01445-00330242-00330592": "statement to stand by secondly secondly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01446-00330593-00330871": "I'll check the record in terms of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01447-00330872-00331045": "whether or not and there's a direct", "hmeXq69j9_I-01448-00331046-00331326": "quote what I would say is the president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01449-00331327-00331635": "is that Minister tailors in direct", "hmeXq69j9_I-01450-00331636-00331804": "interesting Jam land has been widely", "hmeXq69j9_I-01451-00331805-00332182": "reported it is also well-known that the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01452-00332183-00332334": "minister's shareholding in guffy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01453-00332335-00332662": "proprietary limited has been recorded on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01454-00332663-00332907": "the minister's statement of interests", "hmeXq69j9_I-01455-00332908-00333244": "the fact that Guffey then holds", "hmeXq69j9_I-01456-00333245-00333478": "shareholding in gem land proprietary", "hmeXq69j9_I-01457-00333479-00333673": "limited is a matter that is on public", "hmeXq69j9_I-01458-00333674-00333868": "records such as those that senator Wong", "hmeXq69j9_I-01459-00333869-00334320": "has tabled in the Senate the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01460-00334321-00334651": "declarations as required by the house or", "hmeXq69j9_I-01461-00334652-00334891": "the Senate are for declarations of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01462-00334892-00335215": "direct interests not indirect interests", "hmeXq69j9_I-01463-00335216-00335419": "and Minister Taylor has complied with", "hmeXq69j9_I-01464-00335420-00335521": "those requirements", "hmeXq69j9_I-01465-00335522-00335737": "senator Wong a supplementary question", "hmeXq69j9_I-01466-00335738-00335968": "Thank You Minister Porter in question", "hmeXq69j9_I-01467-00335969-00336322": "time today has contradicted the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01468-00336323-00336517": "assertion that Minister Minister for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01469-00336518-00336727": "energy and emissions reduction made in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01470-00336728-00336907": "the house that he had no association", "hmeXq69j9_I-01471-00336908-00337072": "with Germany prior to that limited", "hmeXq69j9_I-01472-00337073-00337243": "saying quote there has never been any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01473-00337244-00337426": "dispute that the minister has a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01474-00337427-00337648": "relationship with a company end quote", "hmeXq69j9_I-01475-00337649-00337801": "does the Minister stand by that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01476-00337802-00337915": "statement", "hmeXq69j9_I-01477-00337916-00338229": "set it at Birmingham mr. president I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01478-00338230-00338440": "would draw the Senators attention to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01479-00338441-00338682": "declared interests that Minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-01480-00338683-00338968": "made to the house in relation to general", "hmeXq69j9_I-01481-00338969-00339129": "and proprietary limited Azure in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01482-00339130-00339268": "relation to guffy proprietary limited", "hmeXq69j9_I-01483-00339269-00339522": "which in turn holds shares in gem land", "hmeXq69j9_I-01484-00339523-00339790": "proprietary limited and the declaration", "hmeXq69j9_I-01485-00339791-00339957": "was made in accordance with the rules of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01486-00339958-00340101": "the house according to the advice I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-01487-00340102-00340363": "provided senator one final supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-01488-00340364-00340734": "Thank You Minister Taylor said shortly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01489-00340735-00340918": "short time ago in the house that his", "hmeXq69j9_I-01490-00340919-00341137": "interest in jamb land was declared in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01491-00341138-00341373": "accordance with the rules given that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01492-00341374-00341580": "ministy ministerial statements", "hmeXq69j9_I-01493-00341581-00341767": "declaration of interest and the registry", "hmeXq69j9_I-01494-00341768-00341914": "of the interest in the house made no", "hmeXq69j9_I-01495-00341915-00342030": "mention of jamming their proprietary", "hmeXq69j9_I-01496-00342031-00342225": "limited the minister please refer us to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01497-00342226-00342399": "where the minister actually declared", "hmeXq69j9_I-01498-00342400-00342843": "that interest senator Birmingham mr. roe", "hmeXq69j9_I-01499-00342844-00343122": "mr. president as I just explained to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01500-00343123-00343371": "Senate and that the rules require that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01501-00343372-00343674": "direct interests they declared minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01502-00343675-00343878": "Taylor I understand has declared his", "hmeXq69j9_I-01503-00343879-00344028": "interests engulfing proprietary limited", "hmeXq69j9_I-01504-00344029-00344191": "in accordance with the rules", "hmeXq69j9_I-01505-00344192-00344409": "guffy proprietary limited has", "hmeXq69j9_I-01506-00344410-00344610": "shareholdings in jamb land proprietary", "hmeXq69j9_I-01507-00344611-00344863": "limited declarations were made in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01508-00344864-00345069": "accordance with the rules that direct", "hmeXq69j9_I-01509-00345070-00345360": "interests that direct interests be", "hmeXq69j9_I-01510-00345361-00345603": "declared that is the case indeed I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-01511-00345604-00345924": "sure and there would be members senators", "hmeXq69j9_I-01512-00345925-00346119": "throughout the Parliament who may have", "hmeXq69j9_I-01513-00346120-00346419": "shareholdings in listed companies or", "hmeXq69j9_I-01514-00346420-00346707": "others that would have indirect interest", "hmeXq69j9_I-01515-00346708-00347028": "in in other companies the point is the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01516-00347029-00347277": "rules require declaration where you have", "hmeXq69j9_I-01517-00347278-00347515": "a direct interest Minister Taylor made", "hmeXq69j9_I-01518-00347516-00347973": "that declaration senator Stoker Thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-01519-00347974-00348168": "You mr. president my question is to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01520-00348169-00348367": "Minister representing the Minister for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01521-00348368-00348570": "employment skills and small and family", "hmeXq69j9_I-01522-00348571-00348825": "business can the Minister update the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01523-00348826-00349090": "Senate about the recent jobs fairs held", "hmeXq69j9_I-01524-00349091-00349312": "in North Queensland and how these job", "hmeXq69j9_I-01525-00349313-00349530": "fairs are helping Australians get into", "hmeXq69j9_I-01526-00349531-00349698": "jobs the Minister representing the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01527-00349699-00349848": "Minister for employment skills small and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01528-00349849-00350028": "family business senator canavan oh thank", "hmeXq69j9_I-01529-00350029-00350167": "you mr. president thank senator Stoker", "hmeXq69j9_I-01530-00350168-00350362": "for that question and recognize I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01531-00350363-00350532": "believe that Senator Stoker was there", "hmeXq69j9_I-01532-00350533-00350898": "and opened the job fair last month", "hmeXq69j9_I-01533-00350899-00351132": "and well I couldn't make it I understand", "hmeXq69j9_I-01534-00351133-00351417": "it was a terrific success around 33", "hmeXq69j9_I-01535-00351418-00351674": "exhibitors and over 700 jobs on offer", "hmeXq69j9_I-01536-00351675-00351987": "almost think 1300 people through the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01537-00351988-00352164": "doors of the jobs fair there in Kansas", "hmeXq69j9_I-01538-00352165-00352347": "one of three jobs fairs that the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01539-00352348-00352620": "government has put on in the past few", "hmeXq69j9_I-01540-00352621-00352794": "months including ones in Townsville and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01541-00352795-00353010": "wide bay and it's all part of making", "hmeXq69j9_I-01542-00353011-00353268": "sure that we connect North Queensland", "hmeXq69j9_I-01543-00353269-00353445": "and all Australians with the job", "hmeXq69j9_I-01544-00353446-00353655": "opportunities that we are growing in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01545-00353656-00353847": "North Queensland and right through our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01546-00353848-00354246": "country recently in North Queensland we", "hmeXq69j9_I-01547-00354247-00354627": "have over the past year and a bit made", "hmeXq69j9_I-01548-00354628-00354765": "significant announcements and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01549-00354766-00354867": "investments for the northern Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-01550-00354868-00355035": "for structure facility just the other", "hmeXq69j9_I-01551-00355036-00355278": "week we announced that over 600 million", "hmeXq69j9_I-01552-00355279-00355566": "dollar loan to to genex to help build a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01553-00355567-00355760": "massive power station in North", "hmeXq69j9_I-01554-00355761-00356049": "Queensland create 510 jobs we've also", "hmeXq69j9_I-01555-00356050-00356181": "made an investment of James Cook", "hmeXq69j9_I-01556-00356182-00356406": "University in a technical Technology", "hmeXq69j9_I-01557-00356407-00356709": "Innovation Centre there'll be 270 jobs", "hmeXq69j9_I-01558-00356710-00356928": "there and an investment in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01559-00356929-00357063": "Townsville Airport to upgrade to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01560-00357064-00357432": "terminal there another 267 jobs there in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01561-00357433-00357609": "addition to those investments for the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01562-00357610-00357705": "northern Australian free structure", "hmeXq69j9_I-01563-00357706-00357948": "facility the northern Australia MS he's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01564-00357949-00358160": "in the process of upgrading significant", "hmeXq69j9_I-01565-00358161-00358296": "road infrastructure in North Queensland", "hmeXq69j9_I-01566-00358297-00358476": "including the Han highlight creating the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01567-00358477-00358683": "first inland sealed roof from cans to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01568-00358684-00358839": "Melbourne cutting 8 hours off the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01569-00358840-00359070": "journey and right across northern", "hmeXq69j9_I-01570-00359071-00359220": "Australia those roads programs have", "hmeXq69j9_I-01571-00359221-00359418": "supported or are supporting more than", "hmeXq69j9_I-01572-00359419-00359742": "2,000 jobs being created Senate mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01573-00359743-00359916": "president our government is focused on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01574-00359917-00360189": "jobs it is one of our and number one", "hmeXq69j9_I-01575-00360190-00360321": "focus when it comes to the economy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01576-00360322-00360603": "because we know that having a job allows", "hmeXq69j9_I-01577-00360604-00360780": "you to provide for your children allow", "hmeXq69j9_I-01578-00360781-00360959": "us to you to pay for your home allows", "hmeXq69j9_I-01579-00360960-00361152": "you to think about other things you will", "hmeXq69j9_I-01580-00361153-00361347": "do to support your family and create a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01581-00361348-00361500": "better environment for your children it", "hmeXq69j9_I-01582-00361501-00361665": "is a prerequisite to create a better", "hmeXq69j9_I-01583-00361666-00361791": "Australia and better communities right", "hmeXq69j9_I-01584-00361792-00361908": "across the strait and that's why we", "hmeXq69j9_I-01585-00361909-00362079": "fight for jobs we create jobs and we're", "hmeXq69j9_I-01586-00362080-00362295": "doing all we can to to keep jobs job", "hmeXq69j9_I-01587-00362296-00362472": "growth strong senator Stoker a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01588-00362473-00362688": "supplementary question minister why is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01589-00362689-00362907": "it so important to focus on bringing", "hmeXq69j9_I-01590-00362908-00363215": "jobs to North Queensland senator Caravan", "hmeXq69j9_I-01591-00363216-00363626": "well mr. president in particular I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01592-00363627-00363813": "recognized and the government recognizes", "hmeXq69j9_I-01593-00363814-00364068": "that it has been a difficult few years", "hmeXq69j9_I-01594-00364069-00364168": "in in north", "hmeXq69j9_I-01595-00364169-00364501": "Queensland on the jobs front a few years", "hmeXq69j9_I-01596-00364502-00364693": "ago there was a significant mining", "hmeXq69j9_I-01597-00364694-00364837": "downturn in other parts of North", "hmeXq69j9_I-01598-00364838-00365029": "Queensland like Cannes has been it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01599-00365030-00365164": "been a tough time for the tourism", "hmeXq69j9_I-01600-00365165-00365344": "industry when there was a high", "hmeXq69j9_I-01601-00365345-00365569": "Australian dollar but there is there has", "hmeXq69j9_I-01602-00365570-00365728": "been good recent news we have been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01603-00365729-00365956": "working hard to bring job-creating", "hmeXq69j9_I-01604-00365957-00366133": "projects like the ones I mentioned in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01605-00366134-00366325": "the in the first answer and and there", "hmeXq69j9_I-01606-00366326-00366523": "has been significant improvement", "hmeXq69j9_I-01607-00366524-00366829": "recently over the past year unemployment", "hmeXq69j9_I-01608-00366830-00367045": "in Cairns is down to four point seven", "hmeXq69j9_I-01609-00367046-00367258": "percent a one point seven percentage", "hmeXq69j9_I-01610-00367259-00367483": "point reduction over the past year in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01611-00367484-00367747": "the Townsville region an area that had", "hmeXq69j9_I-01612-00367748-00367957": "high unemployment recently we the rate", "hmeXq69j9_I-01613-00367958-00368152": "has fallen recently to a bit still too", "hmeXq69j9_I-01614-00368153-00368368": "high 7.1 percent but a 2.1 percentage", "hmeXq69j9_I-01615-00368369-00368494": "point reduction over the past year and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01616-00368495-00368767": "wide bay 7 a half percent a 2 percentage", "hmeXq69j9_I-01617-00368768-00369022": "point reduction we are focused on making", "hmeXq69j9_I-01618-00369023-00369196": "sure that we target these areas of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01619-00369197-00369340": "client employment to bring more jobs to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01620-00369341-00369454": "people in them", "hmeXq69j9_I-01621-00369455-00369685": "Sarah Stoker a final supplementary", "hmeXq69j9_I-01622-00369686-00369850": "question is the minister aware of any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01623-00369851-00370105": "alternate approaches to creating jobs in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01624-00370106-00370450": "North Queensland Senator can't even well", "hmeXq69j9_I-01625-00370451-00370678": "mr. president the the biggest issue we", "hmeXq69j9_I-01626-00370679-00370933": "have in North Queensland in many areas", "hmeXq69j9_I-01627-00370934-00371089": "of our country we're seeking to grow and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01628-00371090-00371398": "develop continues to be those that want", "hmeXq69j9_I-01629-00371399-00371536": "to run an agenda that don't want to use", "hmeXq69j9_I-01630-00371537-00371719": "our resources or don't want to develop", "hmeXq69j9_I-01631-00371720-00371986": "our country those that are risk averse", "hmeXq69j9_I-01632-00371987-00372232": "and have a narrow-minded thinking and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01633-00372233-00372466": "view that we shouldn't continue to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01634-00372467-00372643": "develop our nation we shouldn't build", "hmeXq69j9_I-01635-00372644-00372940": "dams or or create new mines or help to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01636-00372941-00373168": "help grow our farming sector those those", "hmeXq69j9_I-01637-00373169-00373312": "that have those views are the biggest", "hmeXq69j9_I-01638-00373313-00373552": "barrier to job growth in North", "hmeXq69j9_I-01639-00373553-00373786": "Queensland and right across regional", "hmeXq69j9_I-01640-00373787-00373924": "Australia in particular those that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01641-00373925-00374152": "haven't supported the Adani Carmichael", "hmeXq69j9_I-01642-00374153-00374323": "mine they'll wear that like a mill stone", "hmeXq69j9_I-01643-00374324-00374467": "in North Queensland now for years", "hmeXq69j9_I-01644-00374468-00374632": "because they weren't there backing in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01645-00374633-00374785": "the del belt from the Galilee Basin when", "hmeXq69j9_I-01646-00374786-00374935": "it was crucial and needed they weren't", "hmeXq69j9_I-01647-00374936-00375082": "on the side of North Queensland they are", "hmeXq69j9_I-01648-00375083-00375274": "still not on the side mr. president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01649-00375275-00375397": "Labour Party is still not on the side of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01650-00375398-00375532": "building dams in North Queensland", "hmeXq69j9_I-01651-00375533-00375673": "they're not partnering with us to get", "hmeXq69j9_I-01652-00375674-00375832": "the big rocks we're building and bring", "hmeXq69j9_I-01653-00375833-00375982": "thousands of jobs to North Queens and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01654-00375983-00376201": "until they do until they do the people", "hmeXq69j9_I-01655-00376202-00376321": "in North Queensland know that Labor's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01656-00376322-00376419": "got on their side", "hmeXq69j9_I-01657-00376420-00376630": "senator Corman I ask that further", "hmeXq69j9_I-01658-00376631-00376771": "questions we place in the Norris", "hmeXq69j9_I-01659-00376772-00377894": "playbook", "hmeXq69j9_I-01660-00377895-00378140": "are there any motions to take note of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01661-00378141-00378437": "arc sir senator McCallister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01662-00378438-00378634": "madam acting deputy madam deputy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01663-00378635-00378866": "president my apologies I rise to take", "hmeXq69j9_I-01664-00378867-00379097": "note of the answers provided by Senators", "hmeXq69j9_I-01665-00379098-00379343": "Birmingham and Korman to the questions", "hmeXq69j9_I-01666-00379344-00379793": "asked by Senators Wong and O'Neill now", "hmeXq69j9_I-01667-00379794-00379919": "over the last two days", "hmeXq69j9_I-01668-00379920-00380123": "senators Birmingham and Korman have been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01669-00380124-00380468": "asked on multiple occasions to explain", "hmeXq69j9_I-01670-00380469-00380768": "the circumstances surrounding mr. Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-01671-00380769-00381017": "and mr. Freudenberg and the meetings", "hmeXq69j9_I-01672-00381018-00381283": "that they secured with the department", "hmeXq69j9_I-01673-00381284-00381599": "about grass clearing and grasslands of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01674-00381600-00381955": "them in our area and it is striking it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01675-00381956-00382265": "striking how unwilling they have been to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01676-00382266-00382571": "add even the tiniest amount of detail to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01677-00382572-00382855": "this story and it's a big tell I haven't", "hmeXq69j9_I-01678-00382856-00383005": "been in this Parliament in this chamber", "hmeXq69j9_I-01679-00383006-00383216": "for as long as some of these people but", "hmeXq69j9_I-01680-00383217-00383402": "I have been around long enough to know", "hmeXq69j9_I-01681-00383403-00383747": "that when you get answers like the ones", "hmeXq69j9_I-01682-00383748-00383996": "that are being provided there is a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01683-00383997-00384451": "cover-up going on people are scrambling", "hmeXq69j9_I-01684-00384452-00384701": "the Senators who've been answering", "hmeXq69j9_I-01685-00384702-00384909": "questions in this place have been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01686-00384910-00385214": "desperate to keep their hands off this", "hmeXq69j9_I-01687-00385215-00385475": "every answer they've provided has", "hmeXq69j9_I-01688-00385476-00385681": "referred to statements made by Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01689-00385682-00385879": "Taylor referred to statements made by", "hmeXq69j9_I-01690-00385880-00386069": "Minister Freudenberg they've been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01691-00386070-00386407": "completely unwilling to verify with any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01692-00386408-00386675": "confidence the set of facts asserted", "hmeXq69j9_I-01693-00386676-00386900": "around these circumstances and that is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01694-00386901-00387065": "because they are impossible to recognize", "hmeXq69j9_I-01695-00387066-00387253": "reconcile based on the available", "hmeXq69j9_I-01696-00387254-00387539": "evidence it's probably useful to set up", "hmeXq69j9_I-01697-00387540-00387653": "some of the facts as they've been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01698-00387654-00388094": "reported in October 27 16 it's reported", "hmeXq69j9_I-01699-00388095-00388292": "that almost 30 hectares of critically", "hmeXq69j9_I-01700-00388293-00388571": "endangered grasslands were cleared in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01701-00388572-00388802": "the Monaro area after the land was", "hmeXq69j9_I-01702-00388803-00388976": "bought by jam' land proprietary limited", "hmeXq69j9_I-01703-00388977-00389270": "in November a complaint is made by", "hmeXq69j9_I-01704-00389271-00389434": "neighbours to the New South Wales and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01705-00389435-00389663": "federal environmental authorities and on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01706-00389664-00389897": "the 7th of March 2017 the federal", "hmeXq69j9_I-01707-00389898-00390116": "Department of the Environment meets with", "hmeXq69j9_I-01708-00390117-00390317": "representatives of jamm land to discuss", "hmeXq69j9_I-01709-00390318-00390488": "potential contraventions of federal", "hmeXq69j9_I-01710-00390489-00390709": "Environment Force that's what's been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01711-00390710-00391013": "reported and we now know from documents", "hmeXq69j9_I-01712-00391014-00391217": "obtained under foi", "hmeXq69j9_I-01713-00391218-00391562": "that on the 9th of March just two days", "hmeXq69j9_I-01714-00391563-00391780": "after that first meeting when the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01715-00391781-00391913": "environment officers go and meet with", "hmeXq69j9_I-01716-00391914-00392291": "gem land a meeting is sought by staff", "hmeXq69j9_I-01717-00392292-00392450": "and minister Freudenberg officer's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01718-00392451-00392690": "office with officers from the department", "hmeXq69j9_I-01719-00392691-00393212": "to discuss land clearing I reiterate the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01720-00393213-00393460": "coincidence is striking isn't it within", "hmeXq69j9_I-01721-00393461-00393854": "a doe within a day of that first contact", "hmeXq69j9_I-01722-00393855-00394091": "between the Department of gem land the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01723-00394092-00394298": "minister's office is on the case seeking", "hmeXq69j9_I-01724-00394299-00394514": "a meeting from the department and an", "hmeXq69j9_I-01725-00394515-00394718": "assistant secretary the following day is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01726-00394719-00394957": "emailing his colleagues talking about", "hmeXq69j9_I-01727-00394958-00395288": "this call and quite clearly flagging", "hmeXq69j9_I-01728-00395289-00395543": "concerns and anxieties about the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01729-00395544-00395693": "position that the department is being", "hmeXq69j9_I-01730-00395694-00396017": "placed in by the minister's staff and on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01731-00396018-00396326": "the 20th of March 2017 a meeting in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01732-00396327-00396623": "Parliament House with mr. Taylor takes", "hmeXq69j9_I-01733-00396624-00396869": "place in relation to this listing of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01734-00396870-00397124": "critically endangered species and at the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01735-00397125-00397468": "request of minister Freudenberg a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01736-00397469-00397729": "compliance officer from the department", "hmeXq69j9_I-01737-00397730-00398117": "is present at the meeting well why does", "hmeXq69j9_I-01738-00398118-00398353": "it matter it's complicated isn't it but", "hmeXq69j9_I-01739-00398354-00398584": "the whole affair stinks it stinks of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01740-00398585-00398750": "kind of insider dealings that drives", "hmeXq69j9_I-01741-00398751-00399017": "people nuts and the facts as reported", "hmeXq69j9_I-01742-00399018-00399302": "give rise to very serious questions in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01743-00399303-00399488": "relation to the ministerial standards", "hmeXq69j9_I-01744-00399489-00399628": "those standards that require our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01745-00399629-00399893": "ministerial representatives to be honest", "hmeXq69j9_I-01746-00399894-00400210": "that require them to separate the public", "hmeXq69j9_I-01747-00400211-00400485": "interest from their private interests", "hmeXq69j9_I-01748-00400486-00400775": "serious questions about whether the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01749-00400776-00400952": "ministers in question were acting in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01750-00400953-00401158": "public interest or instead were acting", "hmeXq69j9_I-01751-00401159-00401474": "to protect the interests of one minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01752-00401475-00401819": "and his family and their interest in a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01753-00401820-00402188": "particular company jam land there's been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01754-00402189-00402371": "a discussion today about disclosure as", "hmeXq69j9_I-01755-00402372-00402719": "though that's enough the facts on the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01756-00402720-00402899": "table of that disclosure suggest that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01757-00402900-00403169": "not at all enough has been done not in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01758-00403170-00403391": "not all of the obligations have in any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01759-00403392-00403778": "way been met documents table today show", "hmeXq69j9_I-01760-00403779-00404096": "that Guffey the company in which", "hmeXq69j9_I-01761-00404097-00404291": "Minister Taylor is listed as a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01762-00404292-00404549": "shareholder and an officer", "hmeXq69j9_I-01763-00404550-00404927": "has a clear financial interest in gem", "hmeXq69j9_I-01764-00404928-00405182": "land something you think might have been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01765-00405183-00405488": "made public might have been made known", "hmeXq69j9_I-01766-00405489-00405773": "to the departmental officers who were", "hmeXq69j9_I-01767-00405774-00405929": "involved in a meeting between mr.", "hmeXq69j9_I-01768-00405930-00406183": "Minister Taylor and and Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01769-00406184-00406549": "Freudenberg but no because in April", "hmeXq69j9_I-01770-00406550-00406862": "during estimates the secretary of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01771-00406863-00407083": "department couldn't have been clearer he", "hmeXq69j9_I-01772-00407084-00407258": "said senator in answer to a question I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01773-00407259-00407540": "can be quite explicit about this I am", "hmeXq69j9_I-01774-00407541-00407690": "not aware that the minister is a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01775-00407691-00407867": "shareholder I do not know that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01776-00407868-00408074": "information Minister Taylor has never", "hmeXq69j9_I-01777-00408075-00408482": "raised that issue with me or not the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01778-00408483-00408626": "secretary of the department being", "hmeXq69j9_I-01779-00408627-00408932": "informed that the minister he was", "hmeXq69j9_I-01780-00408933-00409163": "meeting with had a direct financial", "hmeXq69j9_I-01781-00409164-00409400": "relationship with the company against", "hmeXq69j9_I-01782-00409401-00409726": "whom an investigation was taking place", "hmeXq69j9_I-01783-00409727-00410270": "this is not good enough thank you", "hmeXq69j9_I-01784-00410271-00410620": "senator McCallister senator fee Avanti", "hmeXq69j9_I-01785-00410621-00410930": "was thank you madam deputy president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01786-00410931-00411164": "well it's all very good the hypocrisy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01787-00411164-00411382": "senator McCallister of you to come into", "hmeXq69j9_I-01788-00411383-00411628": "this place given given the history of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01789-00411629-00411851": "the ALP and the scandals that you've", "hmeXq69j9_I-01790-00411852-00411989": "been involved in so it's pretty", "hmeXq69j9_I-01791-00411989-00412322": "hypocritical of you to come into this", "hmeXq69j9_I-01792-00412322-00412568": "place and make those sort of assertions", "hmeXq69j9_I-01793-00412568-00412849": "and I'll tell you why those opposite are", "hmeXq69j9_I-01794-00412850-00413107": "doing this because they have just", "hmeXq69j9_I-01795-00413108-00413524": "suffered a really bad defeat at the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01796-00413525-00413893": "hands of the Australian public we won", "hmeXq69j9_I-01797-00413895-00414224": "the election you lost the election and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01798-00414225-00414385": "why did you lose the election because", "hmeXq69j9_I-01799-00414387-00414574": "it's spot for those opposite they want", "hmeXq69j9_I-01800-00414575-00414716": "to come in here and they want to throw a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01801-00414717-00414889": "bit a mud they want to do this they want", "hmeXq69j9_I-01802-00414891-00415367": "to do that because because they because", "hmeXq69j9_I-01803-00415368-00415820": "because you do not want to admit that at", "hmeXq69j9_I-01804-00415821-00416063": "the last federal election you talk to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01805-00416064-00416387": "the Australian public a series of dud", "hmeXq69j9_I-01806-00416388-00416707": "policies and that's why you lost the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01807-00416708-00416935": "election and I'd like to focus on that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01808-00416937-00417149": "you don't want to talk about some of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01809-00417150-00417437": "swings that you suffered particularly in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01810-00417438-00417816": "my home state of New South Wales Oh", "hmeXq69j9_I-01811-00417817-00418010": "I'm sorry symptom one point of order", "hmeXq69j9_I-01812-00418010-00418320": "relevance said I know that there seems", "hmeXq69j9_I-01813-00418321-00418533": "to be a reluctance to defend Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01814-00418534-00418662": "Taylor but that is actually the question", "hmeXq69j9_I-01815-00418663-00418809": "of the answer on which we are taking", "hmeXq69j9_I-01816-00418810-00418937": "note", "hmeXq69j9_I-01817-00418938-00419196": "Thank You senator Wong I do remind", "hmeXq69j9_I-01818-00419197-00419477": "senators that we are taking note on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01819-00419478-00419820": "questions from Senator Wong and Senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-01820-00419821-00420042": "O'Neill to Senator Birmingham and Korman", "hmeXq69j9_I-01821-00420043-00420249": "and whilst this is a wide-ranging debate", "hmeXq69j9_I-01822-00420250-00420600": "it is appropriate to address that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01823-00420601-00420885": "subject matter if madam deputy president", "hmeXq69j9_I-01824-00420885-00421243": "and I would refer in direct answer to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01825-00421245-00421551": "that point of order to the comments that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01826-00421552-00421704": "were made and to the answers that were", "hmeXq69j9_I-01827-00421705-00422007": "given by senator Coleman and Senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-01828-00422008-00422370": "Birmingham in relation to comments that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01829-00422371-00422646": "have been made both here and in relation", "hmeXq69j9_I-01830-00422647-00422904": "to what has been said in the house I've", "hmeXq69j9_I-01831-00422905-00423087": "been here I haven't heard what has", "hmeXq69j9_I-01832-00423088-00423387": "happened in the house so madam deputy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01833-00423388-00423828": "president it is very clear that Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01834-00423829-00424284": "Taylor Minister Taylor Minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-01835-00424285-00424760": "has indicated to the Parliament that he", "hmeXq69j9_I-01836-00424762-00425243": "has complied with his obligations those", "hmeXq69j9_I-01837-00425245-00425435": "are the comments of minister Taylor and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01838-00425437-00425688": "I accept those comments and we should", "hmeXq69j9_I-01839-00425689-00425901": "accept them as well now as I was saying", "hmeXq69j9_I-01840-00425902-00426243": "those opposite are very happy now to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01841-00426243-00426756": "want to steer away from the loss at the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01842-00426757-00427008": "election and I was focusing madam deputy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01843-00427009-00427310": "president on some of the swings that", "hmeXq69j9_I-01844-00427312-00427695": "happened in some of the seats in my home", "hmeXq69j9_I-01845-00427696-00428154": "state of New South Wales and the hunt up", "hmeXq69j9_I-01846-00428155-00428696": "almost 10% simply almost 7 percent", "hmeXq69j9_I-01847-00428697-00429054": "Patterson almost 6 percent Shortland", "hmeXq69j9_I-01848-00429055-00429385": "almost five and a half percent McMahon", "hmeXq69j9_I-01849-00429387-00429714": "almost five and a half percent Blaxland", "hmeXq69j9_I-01850-00429714-00429957": "almost five percent no you don't want to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01851-00429958-00430155": "talk about that you don't want to talk", "hmeXq69j9_I-01852-00430156-00430506": "about the fact about your policies in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01853-00430507-00430722": "relation to abolishing negative gearing", "hmeXq69j9_I-01854-00430722-00430941": "where you went around Australia and you", "hmeXq69j9_I-01855-00430942-00431060": "talked about the top end", "hmeXq69j9_I-01856-00431060-00431245": "town where most of the people who", "hmeXq69j9_I-01857-00431246-00431474": "negatively geared property in this", "hmeXq69j9_I-01858-00431475-00431720": "country are on an average salary of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01859-00431721-00432137": "about $85,000 and and those people who", "hmeXq69j9_I-01860-00432138-00432434": "negatively geared properties do so to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01861-00432435-00432645": "get property for their children and for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01862-00432646-00432922": "the inheritance of their children in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01863-00432923-00433304": "most cases franking credits you were", "hmeXq69j9_I-01864-00433305-00433655": "tacking hard-working retirees but ended", "hmeXq69j9_I-01865-00433656-00433883": "do interfere Vanderbilt I have been", "hmeXq69j9_I-01866-00433884-00434072": "listening carefully and whilst you did", "hmeXq69j9_I-01867-00434072-00434405": "come back to the taking note topic I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01868-00434406-00434632": "would just remind you again that we are", "hmeXq69j9_I-01869-00434633-00435002": "taking note is about questions from", "hmeXq69j9_I-01870-00435003-00435203": "senators Wong and O'Neal two senators", "hmeXq69j9_I-01871-00435204-00435572": "Birmingham and Coleman Adam deputy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01872-00435572-00435722": "president I thought that I addressed", "hmeXq69j9_I-01873-00435722-00436001": "that quite adequately Nicaea Van tells", "hmeXq69j9_I-01874-00436002-00436193": "you did momentarily and then you well", "hmeXq69j9_I-01875-00436193-00436372": "I'm happy to do so again and as I've", "hmeXq69j9_I-01876-00436373-00436709": "said Minister Taylor has made comments", "hmeXq69j9_I-01877-00436710-00436937": "in the other place senator Corman and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01878-00436938-00437162": "senator senators Coleman and Birmingham", "hmeXq69j9_I-01879-00437163-00437514": "have made comments in this place and I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01880-00437515-00437801": "agree with what senator Corman and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01881-00437802-00438035": "Senator Birmingham have said and I would", "hmeXq69j9_I-01882-00438035-00438281": "refer the Senate to those comments and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01883-00438282-00438562": "as I was saying in particular in", "hmeXq69j9_I-01884-00438563-00438950": "relation to those opposite and their", "hmeXq69j9_I-01885-00438951-00439184": "loss at the last federal election it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01886-00439185-00439435": "interesting to see in seats like hunter", "hmeXq69j9_I-01887-00439436-00439597": "where you've had an almost ten percent", "hmeXq69j9_I-01888-00439598-00439835": "swing and your assault on the cold", "hmeXq69j9_I-01889-00439835-00440081": "industry was really interesting and as I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01890-00440082-00440239": "was standing on polling booths in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01891-00440240-00440468": "state election people came up to me when", "hmeXq69j9_I-01892-00440468-00440681": "geing about the Labor Party and this is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01893-00440682-00440876": "supposed to be your heartland it's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01894-00440877-00441131": "supposed to be a center where the cold", "hmeXq69j9_I-01895-00441132-00441335": "industry is so important and people", "hmeXq69j9_I-01896-00441335-00441593": "voted against you because of the assault", "hmeXq69j9_I-01897-00441593-00441908": "on the cold industry of course there was", "hmeXq69j9_I-01898-00441909-00442139": "the issue of religious freedom which", "hmeXq69j9_I-01899-00442139-00442460": "manifested itself also in the through", "hmeXq69j9_I-01900-00442460-00442751": "the flower second required Australians", "hmeXq69j9_I-01901-00442752-00442958": "that silent majority those quiet", "hmeXq69j9_I-01902-00442959-00443276": "Australians rejected your policies you", "hmeXq69j9_I-01903-00443277-00443528": "have to accept that you have to accept", "hmeXq69j9_I-01904-00443529-00443843": "that you lost the election so no amount", "hmeXq69j9_I-01905-00443843-00444160": "of mud raking or mudslinging is actually", "hmeXq69j9_I-01906-00444161-00444416": "going to detract from that fact that the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01907-00444417-00444493": "Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-01908-00444495-00444749": "public rejected your policies they", "hmeXq69j9_I-01909-00444750-00445205": "elected us they didn't want a return to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01910-00445206-00445447": "the fiscal vandalism that we had for six", "hmeXq69j9_I-01911-00445449-00445658": "years in this country when you were on", "hmeXq69j9_I-01912-00445659-00445838": "the Treasury benches and you senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-01913-00445839-00446018": "Wong in particular as the finance", "hmeXq69j9_I-01914-00446018-00446213": "minister gave us his thank you they know", "hmeXq69j9_I-01915-00446214-00446453": "the Avanti Wells your time has expired", "hmeXq69j9_I-01916-00446454-00446795": "I would again ask you if you're taking", "hmeXq69j9_I-01917-00446796-00447092": "note again to please remain broadly", "hmeXq69j9_I-01918-00447093-00447284": "around the topic it is not acceptable", "hmeXq69j9_I-01919-00447285-00447458": "just to make one statement and then move", "hmeXq69j9_I-01920-00447459-00447650": "completely away from the topic I think I", "hmeXq69j9_I-01921-00447651-00447922": "was quite lenient but I would ask you to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01922-00447922-00448172": "reflect on what taking note is about", "hmeXq69j9_I-01923-00448172-00448435": "Senator Gallagher thank you madam deputy", "hmeXq69j9_I-01924-00448437-00448634": "president and I too rise to take note of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01925-00448635-00448832": "the answer is given by senators Corman", "hmeXq69j9_I-01926-00448833-00449135": "and Birmingham to the questions of Wang", "hmeXq69j9_I-01927-00449135-00449627": "and O'Neill and it just it was bemusing", "hmeXq69j9_I-01928-00449628-00449801": "that contribution from Sara death fear", "hmeXq69j9_I-01929-00449802-00449981": "of Andy wells but it reminded me of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01930-00449982-00450179": "tweet from the doing of the press", "hmeXq69j9_I-01931-00450180-00450347": "gallery Michelle Bratton I think yes", "hmeXq69j9_I-01932-00450347-00450563": "that I would said when confronted by a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01933-00450564-00450785": "question answer a completely different", "hmeXq69j9_I-01934-00450785-00451028": "one that is the oldest deployment of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01935-00451029-00451259": "political tactics in the book so well", "hmeXq69j9_I-01936-00451260-00451435": "done Sarah Vandy well it's interfere", "hmeXq69j9_I-01937-00451437-00451667": "very well I'm not sure minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-01938-00451668-00451864": "would take a great deal of comfort from", "hmeXq69j9_I-01939-00451866-00452108": "your less than robust defense of his", "hmeXq69j9_I-01940-00452109-00452342": "invidious position but I listened", "hmeXq69j9_I-01941-00452343-00452522": "carefully dissented the Birmingham who", "hmeXq69j9_I-01942-00452522-00452860": "said to the best of my knowledge and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01943-00452862-00453035": "that's often the statement from the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01944-00453035-00453305": "Honourable member for North Queensland", "hmeXq69j9_I-01945-00453306-00453533": "Senator katha when asked about his", "hmeXq69j9_I-01946-00453534-00453767": "wife's interest he said well the best of", "hmeXq69j9_I-01947-00453768-00454028": "my knowledge I know nothing you know", "hmeXq69j9_I-01948-00454029-00454301": "it's it's the type of evasive answer", "hmeXq69j9_I-01949-00454302-00454502": "when in trouble try and move yourself", "hmeXq69j9_I-01950-00454503-00454760": "away from the problem and there is a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01951-00454760-00455033": "problem here and it's a discrete problem", "hmeXq69j9_I-01952-00455034-00455335": "that arises in this chamber and in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01953-00455337-00455581": "other chamber because of the quite", "hmeXq69j9_I-01954-00455582-00455882": "appropriate scrutiny of these", "hmeXq69j9_I-01955-00455883-00456122": "declarations they're important", "hmeXq69j9_I-01956-00456122-00456485": "democratic declarations people in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01957-00456485-00456725": "community need to know if there is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01958-00456726-00456956": "conflict or the potential for conflict", "hmeXq69j9_I-01959-00456957-00457196": "if you have an interest in or a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01960-00457197-00457549": "financial interest in a decision-making", "hmeXq69j9_I-01961-00457550-00457850": "portfolio and it affects your", "hmeXq69j9_I-01962-00457851-00458054": "only it's gonna be declared it's a", "hmeXq69j9_I-01963-00458055-00458279": "simple principle right through our", "hmeXq69j9_I-01964-00458280-00458522": "democratic society and good governance", "hmeXq69j9_I-01965-00458522-00458797": "and due diligence Minister Taylor seems", "hmeXq69j9_I-01966-00458798-00459103": "to attract this lack of appropriate", "hmeXq69j9_I-01967-00459104-00459422": "declaration there are allegations around", "hmeXq69j9_I-01968-00459422-00459659": "involvement in water pricing and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01969-00459660-00460000": "contracts and sales now we have clear", "hmeXq69j9_I-01970-00460001-00460355": "trail of evidence wanting to be tabled", "hmeXq69j9_I-01971-00460356-00460562": "in the Senate the the government is said", "hmeXq69j9_I-01972-00460563-00460721": "no do it through the appropriate way and", "hmeXq69j9_I-01973-00460722-00460960": "I'm sure that is exactly what will", "hmeXq69j9_I-01974-00460962-00461270": "happen that I feel out of senators", "hmeXq69j9_I-01975-00461271-00461504": "declaration of interest and it's quite", "hmeXq69j9_I-01976-00461505-00461816": "specific there's you know a handbook to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01977-00461817-00461924": "tell you how to do it", "hmeXq69j9_I-01978-00461925-00462268": "and Senator Birmingham said only direct", "hmeXq69j9_I-01979-00462270-00462512": "interest need to be mentioned well", "hmeXq69j9_I-01980-00462513-00462692": "that's not what the instructions to", "hmeXq69j9_I-01981-00462693-00463010": "members of parliament say it is any", "hmeXq69j9_I-01982-00463010-00463199": "beneficial interest where they're held", "hmeXq69j9_I-01983-00463200-00463427": "by yourself your partner your brother", "hmeXq69j9_I-01984-00463428-00463679": "through an investment in another trust", "hmeXq69j9_I-01985-00463680-00463972": "you know that the public need to know", "hmeXq69j9_I-01986-00463972-00464279": "that the ministerial standards are being", "hmeXq69j9_I-01987-00464280-00464558": "upheld and the appropriate standards for", "hmeXq69j9_I-01988-00464559-00464720": "members of parliament are there in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01989-00464721-00464888": "House of Representatives or the Senate", "hmeXq69j9_I-01990-00464889-00465221": "I've been upheld they come the period is", "hmeXq69j9_I-01991-00465222-00465287": "on now", "hmeXq69j9_I-01992-00465288-00465535": "the Parliament has restarted in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-01993-00465537-00465710": "Senate we have to love thirty thirteen", "hmeXq69j9_I-01994-00465710-00466114": "to comply with those published regional", "hmeXq69j9_I-01995-00466116-00466346": "statements of interests this Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-01996-00466347-00466607": "has a hang-up from previous Parliament's", "hmeXq69j9_I-01997-00466608-00466814": "it'll be really instructive to see", "hmeXq69j9_I-01998-00466814-00467003": "whether the new declaration", "hmeXq69j9_I-01999-00467004-00467234": "actually improves these record-keeping", "hmeXq69j9_I-02000-00467235-00467459": "and makes it a bit easier for the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02001-00467460-00467678": "manager of government business and for", "hmeXq69j9_I-02002-00467679-00467924": "the leader of the Senate to actually", "hmeXq69j9_I-02003-00467925-00468164": "defend him because I didn't see any", "hmeXq69j9_I-02004-00468164-00468497": "resenting you know defensive minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-02005-00468497-00468752": "Taylor I think he's done the right thing", "hmeXq69j9_I-02006-00468753-00468932": "to the best of my knowledge he's down", "hmeXq69j9_I-02007-00468933-00469199": "the right thing and incentive the fear", "hmeXq69j9_I-02008-00469200-00469343": "of aunty whales came in and spoke about", "hmeXq69j9_I-02009-00469343-00469543": "something completely different so she", "hmeXq69j9_I-02010-00469545-00469733": "obviously has no confidence that he's", "hmeXq69j9_I-02011-00469734-00469892": "actually done the right thing because", "hmeXq69j9_I-02012-00469893-00470063": "she never went within ask Eric of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02013-00470064-00470278": "addressing the matter before the chamber", "hmeXq69j9_I-02014-00470279-00470582": "but it is the most vitally important", "hmeXq69j9_I-02015-00470583-00470816": "thing that should be complied with at", "hmeXq69j9_I-02016-00470817-00470962": "the start of each Parliament and", "hmeXq69j9_I-02017-00470963-00471176": "maintained right throughout the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02018-00471177-00471425": "and should act in conjunction with the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02019-00471426-00471670": "ministerial standards and if we go to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02020-00471671-00471899": "the ministerial standards of conduct by", "hmeXq69j9_I-02021-00471900-00472187": "those opposite it is contended that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02022-00472188-00472550": "Minister pi the minister Bishop the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02023-00472551-00472864": "Minister Rob and the list goes on have", "hmeXq69j9_I-02024-00472866-00473108": "not exactly covered themselves in glory", "hmeXq69j9_I-02025-00473109-00473438": "in honoring those are high ministerial", "hmeXq69j9_I-02026-00473439-00473689": "standards they have left the Parliament", "hmeXq69j9_I-02027-00473691-00474022": "gone into great jobs within a really", "hmeXq69j9_I-02028-00474023-00474278": "quick timeframe which looks to be Jebus", "hmeXq69j9_I-02029-00474279-00474530": "in terms of the standard so those on the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02030-00474531-00474728": "other side don't have a good record here", "hmeXq69j9_I-02031-00474729-00475001": "and have a serving Minister have", "hmeXq69j9_I-02032-00475002-00475222": "allegations about this is not only", "hmeXq69j9_I-02033-00475223-00475505": "untidy it's completely inappropriate he", "hmeXq69j9_I-02034-00475506-00475795": "should have the professionalism the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02035-00475796-00476120": "honesty and you know transparency to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02036-00476121-00476474": "properly disclose in the hundred and ten", "hmeXq69j9_I-02037-00476475-00476624": "percent way that's required by the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02038-00476625-00476876": "Australian people all of his vegetable", "hmeXq69j9_I-02039-00476877-00477118": "interests to avoid the possibility of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02040-00477120-00477401": "these allegations of you know under an", "hmeXq69j9_I-02041-00477402-00477689": "improper interference in either the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02042-00477689-00477872": "bureaucracy or in the way that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02043-00477872-00478067": "legislation is enacted in this country", "hmeXq69j9_I-02044-00478068-00478339": "Thank You senator Gallagher immigrant", "hmeXq69j9_I-02045-00478341-00478774": "thank you that own deputy president I", "hmeXq69j9_I-02046-00478775-00479063": "think I Minister Tyler has been very", "hmeXq69j9_I-02047-00479064-00479414": "strong in defending his actions has", "hmeXq69j9_I-02048-00479414-00479705": "along with the the ministers our", "hmeXq69j9_I-02049-00479706-00479954": "corpsman and ministers Birmingham in", "hmeXq69j9_I-02050-00479955-00480118": "question Chandan I've been very very", "hmeXq69j9_I-02051-00480120-00480479": "strong in defending Minister Tyler yeah", "hmeXq69j9_I-02052-00480480-00480785": "I missed Minister Tyler stated quite", "hmeXq69j9_I-02053-00480785-00481112": "clearly quite clearly that is not made", "hmeXq69j9_I-02054-00481113-00481349": "representations to federal state minutes", "hmeXq69j9_I-02055-00481350-00481535": "is in relation to his family investment", "hmeXq69j9_I-02056-00481535-00481775": "company or to any federal or state", "hmeXq69j9_I-02057-00481776-00482006": "government Department officials but what", "hmeXq69j9_I-02058-00482007-00482399": "this shows what this shows is that that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02059-00482400-00482654": "what a labor have to ask questions about", "hmeXq69j9_I-02060-00482655-00482839": "they're not going to ask questions about", "hmeXq69j9_I-02061-00482841-00483020": "policy they're not going to ask", "hmeXq69j9_I-02062-00483021-00483305": "questions about substantive issues what", "hmeXq69j9_I-02063-00483306-00483520": "they're doing we're seeing a classic 101", "hmeXq69j9_I-02064-00483521-00483806": "from labor runaround and infer a little", "hmeXq69j9_I-02065-00483807-00483968": "bit of dirt and water and hope aterna", "hmeXq69j9_I-02066-00483968-00484226": "turns into mud and that is disappointing", "hmeXq69j9_I-02067-00484227-00484481": "disappointing that when the people of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02068-00484482-00484543": "Australia", "hmeXq69j9_I-02069-00484544-00484826": "on the 18th of May made an informed", "hmeXq69j9_I-02070-00484827-00485132": "decision about who they want to see", "hmeXq69j9_I-02071-00485133-00485357": "sitting the lodge and who they want to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02072-00485358-00485597": "see be in an executive power in this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02073-00485597-00485893": "country that that a party who failed to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02074-00485894-00486016": "win and I've been there I've lost more", "hmeXq69j9_I-02075-00486017-00486185": "elections and then most people in this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02076-00486185-00486466": "place had failed to come to terms with", "hmeXq69j9_I-02077-00486467-00486722": "the decision of the quiet Australians", "hmeXq69j9_I-02078-00486722-00486985": "and instead of understanding that what", "hmeXq69j9_I-02079-00486987-00487147": "that what they've done madam deputy", "hmeXq69j9_I-02080-00487148-00487376": "president is that they're getting this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02081-00487377-00487570": "this dirt in this water and and want to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02082-00487571-00487862": "throw some mud around in relation to -", "hmeXq69j9_I-02083-00487863-00488195": "two minutes - Taylor now Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-02084-00488196-00488429": "Taylor's indirect interest in general", "hmeXq69j9_I-02085-00488430-00488564": "and propriety limit has been widely", "hmeXq69j9_I-02086-00488564-00488759": "reported in the media and has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-02087-00488760-00488997": "declared in accordance with the rules", "hmeXq69j9_I-02088-00488998-00489329": "simple but this isn't stopping this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02089-00489330-00489584": "isn't stopping our friends in the labour", "hmeXq69j9_I-02090-00489585-00489632": "party", "hmeXq69j9_I-02091-00489633-00489932": "this isn't stopping those who because of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02092-00489933-00490295": "this this policy vacuum this vortex that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02093-00490296-00490618": "exists or on on that side of the chamber", "hmeXq69j9_I-02094-00490619-00490822": "at the moment that what they want to do", "hmeXq69j9_I-02095-00490823-00490985": "is they wanted to put a chase after", "hmeXq69j9_I-02096-00490985-00491231": "people when there is actually nothing", "hmeXq69j9_I-02097-00491232-00491539": "nothing there to look at Minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-02098-00491541-00491801": "and ministers are Corman illnesses are", "hmeXq69j9_I-02099-00491802-00492074": "Birmingham being very clear in relation", "hmeXq69j9_I-02100-00492075-00492362": "to the conduct and the compliance are", "hmeXq69j9_I-02101-00492363-00492554": "with with the rules and it is", "hmeXq69j9_I-02102-00492555-00492718": "disappointed because his Parliament in", "hmeXq69j9_I-02103-00492719-00492881": "this question time there should be", "hmeXq69j9_I-02104-00492882-00493127": "serious questions put to - - ministers", "hmeXq69j9_I-02105-00493128-00493487": "for - - to the government about policy", "hmeXq69j9_I-02106-00493488-00493778": "issues and we welcome those questions", "hmeXq69j9_I-02107-00493779-00494009": "with welcome questions in terms of of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02108-00494010-00494233": "what the government is doing to help", "hmeXq69j9_I-02109-00494234-00494516": "help Queensland us to help Australians", "hmeXq69j9_I-02110-00494517-00494741": "what we're doing in terms of cutting", "hmeXq69j9_I-02111-00494742-00494995": "taxes and how that is helping helping", "hmeXq69j9_I-02112-00494996-00495197": "Queensland as Australians what we are", "hmeXq69j9_I-02113-00495197-00495503": "doing in terms of drought what we are", "hmeXq69j9_I-02114-00495504-00495764": "doing in terms of and no drought is this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02115-00495764-00496018": "this this Robby's probably the worst", "hmeXq69j9_I-02116-00496019-00496214": "drought that that Australia has has had", "hmeXq69j9_I-02117-00496214-00496472": "in recorded history and I know in my", "hmeXq69j9_I-02118-00496472-00496859": "home state of Queensland that that there", "hmeXq69j9_I-02119-00496860-00497033": "are still some some children in in parts", "hmeXq69j9_I-02120-00497034-00497218": "of Queensland who are yet to actually", "hmeXq69j9_I-02121-00497219-00497570": "experience precipitation falling on the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02122-00497571-00497813": "head though yet to experience the magic", "hmeXq69j9_I-02123-00497814-00497893": "that is", "hmeXq69j9_I-02124-00497895-00498203": "crying because their property that their", "hmeXq69j9_I-02125-00498204-00498472": "hometown is yet to receive receive rain", "hmeXq69j9_I-02126-00498474-00498889": "and this is part of the brutality that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02127-00498891-00499052": "is the Australian climate for the no", "hmeXq69j9_I-02128-00499053-00499318": "questions about drought no questions", "hmeXq69j9_I-02129-00499320-00499505": "about how that is impacting upon rural", "hmeXq69j9_I-02130-00499506-00499697": "and regional Queensland and how it is", "hmeXq69j9_I-02131-00499697-00499937": "impacting upon upon those in the cities", "hmeXq69j9_I-02132-00499938-00500254": "instead sadly we have questions", "hmeXq69j9_I-02133-00500255-00500710": "addressed to to ministers with with with", "hmeXq69j9_I-02134-00500710-00501085": "the impugning the conduct of ministers", "hmeXq69j9_I-02135-00501087-00501329": "in relation to how they have made", "hmeXq69j9_I-02136-00501330-00501488": "declarations in their registry of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02137-00501489-00501725": "interests and n Minister Taylor has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-02138-00501726-00502124": "so clear it's so clear that the minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-02139-00502125-00502478": "has been totally in accordance with the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02140-00502479-00502735": "register of interest in mistress Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-02141-00502737-00502960": "has provided assurance that he is in no", "hmeXq69j9_I-02142-00502962-00503153": "association with the compliance action", "hmeXq69j9_I-02143-00503154-00503360": "and as never made made representation", "hmeXq69j9_I-02144-00503360-00503558": "relation to it and this was confirmed", "hmeXq69j9_I-02145-00503559-00503828": "sir confirmed that Senate estimates by", "hmeXq69j9_I-02146-00503829-00504064": "the secretary of his department in April", "hmeXq69j9_I-02147-00504066-00504392": "of this year so the secretary of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02148-00504393-00504610": "department has confirmed us the registry", "hmeXq69j9_I-02149-00504612-00504791": "of interest has been complied with and", "hmeXq69j9_I-02150-00504792-00505241": "yet yet sadly labour wish to to use", "hmeXq69j9_I-02151-00505242-00505508": "question time to fill up question time", "hmeXq69j9_I-02152-00505509-00505829": "with with these questions was waste", "hmeXq69j9_I-02153-00505830-00506021": "question time thank you senator Smith", "hmeXq69j9_I-02154-00506022-00506375": "instead of and I'm sure the front bench", "hmeXq69j9_I-02155-00506376-00506489": "will probably get annoyed with me", "hmeXq69j9_I-02156-00506489-00506741": "instead of asking serious hard questions", "hmeXq69j9_I-02157-00506742-00507014": "about about policies what we're seeing", "hmeXq69j9_I-02158-00507014-00507302": "for from Labour is the throwing the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02159-00507303-00507572": "throwing of mud the use of dirt and", "hmeXq69j9_I-02160-00507572-00507806": "water are mixing it together in the good", "hmeXq69j9_I-02161-00507807-00508210": "old a union jug and throwing it at those", "hmeXq69j9_I-02162-00508212-00508372": "evil Tories on the other side of the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02163-00508374-00508574": "chamber and that is sad there's a sad", "hmeXq69j9_I-02164-00508575-00508766": "reflection upon the modern Labour Party", "hmeXq69j9_I-02165-00508767-00508949": "and that actually is an indication of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02166-00508950-00509159": "one of the reasons why they failed to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02167-00509160-00509345": "connect with the quiet Australians on", "hmeXq69j9_I-02168-00509346-00509507": "the 18th of May Thank You senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-02169-00509508-00509825": "McGrath senator Chisholm thanks madam", "hmeXq69j9_I-02170-00509826-00509918": "deputy president", "hmeXq69j9_I-02171-00509918-00510212": "well if senator McGraw calls that a", "hmeXq69j9_I-02172-00510213-00510482": "strong performance from Senator Coleman", "hmeXq69j9_I-02173-00510483-00510656": "and Senator Birmingham I'd hate to see a", "hmeXq69j9_I-02174-00510657-00510860": "weak one because when you compare the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02175-00510860-00511037": "performance of Senator Birmingham in", "hmeXq69j9_I-02176-00511038-00511173": "senator Corman", "hmeXq69j9_I-02177-00511174-00511512": "defending Angus Taylor Minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-02178-00511513-00511762": "today compared to yesterday a vastly", "hmeXq69j9_I-02179-00511763-00511941": "different performance from senators", "hmeXq69j9_I-02180-00511942-00512239": "Birmingham and Corman they obviously", "hmeXq69j9_I-02181-00512239-00512533": "know that the Minister has been less", "hmeXq69j9_I-02182-00512534-00512695": "than truthful in terms of how he has", "hmeXq69j9_I-02183-00512696-00512970": "presented himself to the House of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02184-00512971-00513139": "Representatives on these important", "hmeXq69j9_I-02185-00513139-00513325": "issues and I think at the end of the day", "hmeXq69j9_I-02186-00513326-00513522": "what this comes down to and what we're", "hmeXq69j9_I-02187-00513523-00513696": "starting to see emerge from this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02188-00513697-00513996": "government is arrogance we know that won", "hmeXq69j9_I-02189-00513997-00514162": "the election we saw the the contribution", "hmeXq69j9_I-02190-00514163-00514477": "from Senator fear of reentry Wells where", "hmeXq69j9_I-02191-00514478-00514596": "she came in and all she could talk about", "hmeXq69j9_I-02192-00514597-00514843": "was the election win at least senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-02193-00514843-00514987": "McGrath spent a minute longer I'm", "hmeXq69j9_I-02194-00514988-00515250": "talking about McGraw but it was a very", "hmeXq69j9_I-02195-00515251-00515481": "lame defense of the minister and that's", "hmeXq69j9_I-02196-00515482-00515745": "the same that we saw from senator Corman", "hmeXq69j9_I-02197-00515746-00516052": "and Birmingham as well but this is an", "hmeXq69j9_I-02198-00516053-00516183": "arrogant government and this is an", "hmeXq69j9_I-02199-00516184-00516502": "arrogant Minister because what they", "hmeXq69j9_I-02200-00516503-00516666": "think is that the standards don't apply", "hmeXq69j9_I-02201-00516667-00516985": "to them we see that with former", "hmeXq69j9_I-02202-00516985-00517225": "ministers Pyne we see that with former", "hmeXq69j9_I-02203-00517226-00517623": "minister Julie Bishop about the way they", "hmeXq69j9_I-02204-00517624-00517833": "have behaved post the election in terms", "hmeXq69j9_I-02205-00517834-00518004": "of going about and basically", "hmeXq69j9_I-02206-00518005-00518206": "disregarding the ministerial standards", "hmeXq69j9_I-02207-00518207-00518368": "and the government have been prepared", "hmeXq69j9_I-02208-00518368-00518614": "prepared to defend them on that and then", "hmeXq69j9_I-02209-00518614-00518802": "again this week we see with Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-02210-00518803-00519075": "Taylor again the government prepared to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02211-00519076-00519337": "defend him it certainly was a different", "hmeXq69j9_I-02212-00519338-00519537": "attitude today though in the Senate", "hmeXq69j9_I-02213-00519538-00519723": "where they were certainly not as strong", "hmeXq69j9_I-02214-00519724-00520047": "in their defense of Minister Taylor in", "hmeXq69j9_I-02215-00520048-00520402": "this chamber but what we've know and", "hmeXq69j9_I-02216-00520403-00520550": "what has been established is that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02217-00520551-00520812": "there's basically two key phrases that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02218-00520813-00521035": "Minister Taylor has used over the last", "hmeXq69j9_I-02219-00521035-00521368": "couple of days the first one was he's", "hmeXq69j9_I-02220-00521368-00521614": "had no association and the second one", "hmeXq69j9_I-02221-00521614-00521881": "was he has been at arm's length and I", "hmeXq69j9_I-02222-00521882-00522025": "just wanted to go to those because I", "hmeXq69j9_I-02223-00522026-00522237": "think that they are important what we've", "hmeXq69j9_I-02224-00522238-00522387": "seen and what the evidence that has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-02225-00522388-00522618": "provided in question time today around", "hmeXq69j9_I-02226-00522619-00522931": "no Association what we now know is that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02227-00522932-00523164": "Minister Taylor was a director of coffee", "hmeXq69j9_I-02228-00523165-00523437": "which has a joint one-third interest in", "hmeXq69j9_I-02229-00523438-00523737": "jam land proprietary limited and jam", "hmeXq69j9_I-02230-00523738-00524075": "land proprietary line limited has been", "hmeXq69j9_I-02231-00524076-00524271": "investigated by the minister's own", "hmeXq69j9_I-02232-00524272-00524439": "department so the minister's own", "hmeXq69j9_I-02233-00524440-00524556": "Department", "hmeXq69j9_I-02234-00524557-00524808": "energy and environment when it comes to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02235-00524809-00525039": "illegal land clearing and the poisoning", "hmeXq69j9_I-02236-00525040-00525218": "of critically endangered native", "hmeXq69j9_I-02237-00525219-00525777": "grassland in October 2016 so it is clear", "hmeXq69j9_I-02238-00525778-00525975": "that the minister has an association", "hmeXq69j9_I-02239-00525976-00526254": "with his property so no more can the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02240-00526255-00526632": "minister rely on no association for him", "hmeXq69j9_I-02241-00526633-00526842": "to try and claim that he had no", "hmeXq69j9_I-02242-00526843-00527058": "association with this property that has", "hmeXq69j9_I-02243-00527059-00527211": "been under investigation by this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02244-00527212-00527425": "department and the second one around", "hmeXq69j9_I-02245-00527426-00527629": "arm's length now I think foreign", "hmeXq69j9_I-02246-00527630-00527718": "minister Taylor", "hmeXq69j9_I-02247-00527719-00528009": "he takes arm lengths literally in that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02248-00528010-00528175": "in the meeting he thinks I was more than", "hmeXq69j9_I-02249-00528176-00528320": "an arm links to arm's length away", "hmeXq69j9_I-02250-00528321-00528690": "obviously it is a direct vastly", "hmeXq69j9_I-02251-00528691-00528942": "different scenario when we know that he", "hmeXq69j9_I-02252-00528943-00529098": "has an interest in this property and we", "hmeXq69j9_I-02253-00529099-00529281": "also know that he organized a meeting", "hmeXq69j9_I-02254-00529282-00529504": "that he was at with his own Department", "hmeXq69j9_I-02255-00529505-00529782": "and where these issues were raised so no", "hmeXq69j9_I-02256-00529783-00530125": "longer can he rely on no association no", "hmeXq69j9_I-02257-00530126-00530377": "longer can he say that he was at arm's", "hmeXq69j9_I-02258-00530378-00530613": "length when we know that he was involved", "hmeXq69j9_I-02259-00530614-00530827": "in a meeting where this issue was", "hmeXq69j9_I-02260-00530828-00531182": "brought up so it became clear today from", "hmeXq69j9_I-02261-00531183-00531462": "the performance of Senator Birmingham", "hmeXq69j9_I-02262-00531463-00531687": "and Senator Cornyn that they changed", "hmeXq69j9_I-02263-00531688-00531804": "tack from the way they answered", "hmeXq69j9_I-02264-00531805-00532029": "questions yesterday where they tried to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02265-00532030-00532218": "appear quite confident today they were", "hmeXq69j9_I-02266-00532219-00532398": "very cautious in their defense of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02267-00532399-00532740": "Senator Minister Taylor and we also saw", "hmeXq69j9_I-02268-00532741-00533013": "senator fear of Randy Wells didn't try", "hmeXq69j9_I-02269-00533014-00533265": "and defend Minister Taylor and we also", "hmeXq69j9_I-02270-00533266-00533490": "saw with Senator McGraw he danced around", "hmeXq69j9_I-02271-00533491-00533682": "a couple of issues but wasn't prepared", "hmeXq69j9_I-02272-00533683-00533910": "to defend Minister Taylor in this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02273-00533911-00534147": "chamber as well and what we know is that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02274-00534148-00534406": "we will continue to pursue these issues", "hmeXq69j9_I-02275-00534407-00534627": "because we think that ministerial", "hmeXq69j9_I-02276-00534628-00534807": "standards are important we think that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02277-00534808-00534957": "ministerial standards and accountability", "hmeXq69j9_I-02278-00534958-00535269": "is important but we also know that this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02279-00535270-00535452": "arrogant government if we if they aren't", "hmeXq69j9_I-02280-00535453-00535686": "held to account will continue that level", "hmeXq69j9_I-02281-00535687-00535875": "of arrogance and will continue to go", "hmeXq69j9_I-02282-00535876-00536067": "down that path where they treat the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02283-00536068-00536254": "voters with contempt and they take", "hmeXq69j9_I-02284-00536255-00536502": "issues of accountability and don't treat", "hmeXq69j9_I-02285-00536503-00536715": "them seriously at all but at the end of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02286-00536716-00536871": "the day and where this will ultimately", "hmeXq69j9_I-02287-00536872-00537079": "end up with as we continue to pursue", "hmeXq69j9_I-02288-00537080-00537296": "these issues as we continue to pursue", "hmeXq69j9_I-02289-00537297-00537550": "Minister Taylor in this house and in the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02290-00537551-00537792": "other chamber as well and they will end", "hmeXq69j9_I-02291-00537793-00537900": "up with the Prime Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-02292-00537901-00538200": "and he is the one who is responsible for", "hmeXq69j9_I-02293-00538201-00538440": "this government and he is the one who", "hmeXq69j9_I-02294-00538441-00538629": "has been arrogant post his election and", "hmeXq69j9_I-02295-00538630-00538878": "result and again I think on this issue", "hmeXq69j9_I-02296-00538879-00539097": "of accountability when it comes to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02297-00539098-00539253": "Minister Taylor when it comes to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02298-00539254-00539496": "previous ministers the Prime Minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-02299-00539497-00539646": "needs to show some leadership on this", "hmeXq69j9_I-02300-00539647-00539898": "issue and ensure that this quest your", "hmeXq69j9_I-02301-00539899-00540072": "time has expired so the question is that", "hmeXq69j9_I-02302-00540073-00540219": "the motion is moved by Senator", "hmeXq69j9_I-02303-00540220-00540405": "McCallister to take note be agreed to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02304-00540406-00540645": "those of that opinion say aye against to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02305-00540646-00540753": "believe the eyes have it", "hmeXq69j9_I-02306-00540754-00541068": "senator Dino darling thank you madam", "hmeXq69j9_I-02307-00541069-00541450": "deputy president I rise to take note of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02308-00541451-00541632": "an answer given by the foreign minister", "hmeXq69j9_I-02309-00541633-00541953": "well last night the abcs four-corners", "hmeXq69j9_I-02310-00541954-00542130": "dedicated an episode to the appalling", "hmeXq69j9_I-02311-00542131-00542444": "human rights sorry last Monday night's", "hmeXq69j9_I-02312-00542445-00542667": "four-corners dedicated an episode to the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02313-00542668-00542847": "appalling human rights abuses that are", "hmeXq69j9_I-02314-00542848-00543087": "occurring in China's Xinjiang region", "hmeXq69j9_I-02315-00543088-00543461": "right now while the world watches on", "hmeXq69j9_I-02316-00543462-00543765": "xing Jiang has a Turkish Muslim", "hmeXq69j9_I-02317-00543766-00544134": "population of 13 million people out of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02318-00544135-00544418": "that 13 million approximately 1 million", "hmeXq69j9_I-02319-00544419-00544770": "arbitrarily detained without any legal", "hmeXq69j9_I-02320-00544771-00545046": "process they're detained for weeks", "hmeXq69j9_I-02321-00545047-00545508": "months and sometimes even years families", "hmeXq69j9_I-02322-00545509-00545800": "have been torn apart those incarcerated", "hmeXq69j9_I-02323-00545801-00546005": "are subject to forced labor", "hmeXq69j9_I-02324-00546006-00546270": "sometimes the torture and - forced", "hmeXq69j9_I-02325-00546271-00546625": "political indoctrination outside the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02326-00546626-00546819": "camp's we guess and other Turkish", "hmeXq69j9_I-02327-00546820-00547101": "Muslims are denied the right to freedom", "hmeXq69j9_I-02328-00547102-00547407": "of movement to privacy and to freedom of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02329-00547408-00547725": "religion the mass surveillance that is", "hmeXq69j9_I-02330-00547726-00547977": "occurring in Zhen Jiang is terrifying", "hmeXq69j9_I-02331-00547978-00548244": "people going about their lawful daily", "hmeXq69j9_I-02332-00548245-00548415": "business of watch constantly by the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02333-00548416-00548616": "state they're forced to give their", "hmeXq69j9_I-02334-00548617-00548808": "biometric data and face and voice", "hmeXq69j9_I-02335-00548809-00549048": "recognition technology is being used as", "hmeXq69j9_I-02336-00549049-00549447": "a tool of repression the revelation in 4", "hmeXq69j9_I-02337-00549448-00549645": "corners that Australian universities", "hmeXq69j9_I-02338-00549646-00549882": "seem to be complicit in the development", "hmeXq69j9_I-02339-00549883-00550233": "of this technology is even more", "hmeXq69j9_I-02340-00550234-00550488": "appalling and of course four corners", "hmeXq69j9_I-02341-00550489-00550755": "showed us the Australian human face of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02342-00550756-00551037": "this devastating repression thanks to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02343-00551038-00551305": "the bravery of those who spy", "hmeXq69j9_I-02344-00551306-00551533": "and we acknowledge them he brought us a", "hmeXq69j9_I-02345-00551534-00551841": "story of Saddam Abudu salaam whose wife", "hmeXq69j9_I-02346-00551842-00552220": "nadila and his toddler Lutfi who were", "hmeXq69j9_I-02347-00552221-00552489": "trapped in jingzhong through no fault of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02348-00552490-00552760": "their own Adela and Lutfi were separated", "hmeXq69j9_I-02349-00552761-00552982": "from Saddam before LUT Finn's birth and", "hmeXq69j9_I-02350-00552983-00553237": "the Chinese authorities have prevented", "hmeXq69j9_I-02351-00553238-00553620": "them from being reunited sadden has", "hmeXq69j9_I-02352-00553621-00553903": "never met his son he wasn't there to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02353-00553904-00554116": "support his wife through the last part", "hmeXq69j9_I-02354-00554117-00554256": "of her pregnancy", "hmeXq69j9_I-02355-00554257-00554647": "he didn't witness his son's birth he", "hmeXq69j9_I-02356-00554648-00554868": "says he's totally broken mentally", "hmeXq69j9_I-02357-00554869-00555382": "financially and physically it is a great", "hmeXq69j9_I-02358-00555383-00555535": "relief that Lutfi has been granted", "hmeXq69j9_I-02359-00555536-00555768": "Australian citizenship and that the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02360-00555769-00555960": "foreign minister has intervened to call", "hmeXq69j9_I-02361-00555961-00556170": "for Saddam's family to be permitted to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02362-00556171-00556522": "travel to Australia what is required now", "hmeXq69j9_I-02363-00556523-00556716": "is for new dealers visa to be", "hmeXq69j9_I-02364-00556717-00556984": "fast-tracked and for the government to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02365-00556985-00557170": "keep up the pressure on the Chinese", "hmeXq69j9_I-02366-00557171-00557476": "government and of course many other", "hmeXq69j9_I-02367-00557477-00557674": "Australian workers are affected by", "hmeXq69j9_I-02368-00557675-00557980": "China's and brutal crackdown almaas", "hmeXq69j9_I-02369-00557981-00558241": "Nizamuddin 'he's mum is interred in a", "hmeXq69j9_I-02370-00558242-00558510": "camp and his wife is imprisoned simply", "hmeXq69j9_I-02371-00558511-00558735": "for studying in Egypt", "hmeXq69j9_I-02372-00558736-00559057": "Amnesty International classifies her as", "hmeXq69j9_I-02373-00559058-00559347": "a prisoner of conscience and she's", "hmeXq69j9_I-02374-00559348-00559672": "waiting for a spousal visa which must", "hmeXq69j9_I-02375-00559673-00560087": "also be fast-tracked there are more than", "hmeXq69j9_I-02376-00560088-00560518": "30,000 workers in Australia in some form", "hmeXq69j9_I-02377-00560519-00560764": "or other all of these people have a", "hmeXq69j9_I-02378-00560765-00561057": "friend or relative in a camp", "hmeXq69j9_I-02379-00561058-00561349": "the Greens are calling on the government", "hmeXq69j9_I-02380-00561350-00561595": "to take urgent action in the face of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02381-00561596-00562012": "what is cultural genocide the Australian", "hmeXq69j9_I-02382-00562013-00562174": "Government's decision to sign on to a", "hmeXq69j9_I-02383-00562175-00562464": "joint statement of the UNH a UN Human", "hmeXq69j9_I-02384-00562465-00562822": "Rights Council was welcome indeed I said", "hmeXq69j9_I-02385-00562823-00563043": "that to the minister during Question", "hmeXq69j9_I-02386-00563044-00563493": "Time but we must do more it was", "hmeXq69j9_I-02387-00563494-00563632": "disappointing that the Minister was", "hmeXq69j9_I-02388-00563633-00563820": "unable to provide me with a concrete", "hmeXq69j9_I-02389-00563821-00564045": "number of Australian citizens who are", "hmeXq69j9_I-02390-00564046-00564337": "currently detained and it was also", "hmeXq69j9_I-02391-00564338-00564505": "disappointing that the Minister couldn't", "hmeXq69j9_I-02392-00564506-00564611": "detail in her", "hmeXq69j9_I-02393-00564612-00564851": "answer to my question what concrete", "hmeXq69j9_I-02394-00564852-00565103": "steps the government will be taking to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02395-00565104-00565423": "pressure China to stop this campaign of", "hmeXq69j9_I-02396-00565424-00565769": "repression of course we need to work", "hmeXq69j9_I-02397-00565770-00565964": "with other countries in our region to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02398-00565965-00566234": "make sure that independent monitors have", "hmeXq69j9_I-02399-00566235-00566696": "access to zhen jiang but we need to do", "hmeXq69j9_I-02400-00566697-00567008": "more we need to show some courage we", "hmeXq69j9_I-02401-00567009-00567305": "need to show some leadership we should", "hmeXq69j9_I-02402-00567306-00567575": "be implementing targeted sanctions like", "hmeXq69j9_I-02403-00567576-00567941": "visa bans and asset freezes against", "hmeXq69j9_I-02404-00567942-00568208": "those individuals who are linked to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02405-00568209-00568727": "these abuses Australia has in the past", "hmeXq69j9_I-02406-00568728-00569075": "they been a leading voice on human", "hmeXq69j9_I-02407-00569076-00569453": "rights in the international arena over", "hmeXq69j9_I-02408-00569454-00569858": "recent years we have been absent when it", "hmeXq69j9_I-02409-00569859-00570128": "comes to ensure ensuring that human", "hmeXq69j9_I-02410-00570129-00570404": "rights are protected around the world if", "hmeXq69j9_I-02411-00570405-00570758": "there was ever a time for Australia to", "hmeXq69j9_I-02412-00570759-00571037": "start actually leading the way on human", "hmeXq69j9_I-02413-00571038-00571466": "rights abuses it is now it is the motion", "hmeXq69j9_I-02414-00571467-00571673": "moved by Senator the Natalia be agreed", "hmeXq69j9_I-02415-00571674-00571991": "to those of that opinion say I know the", "hmeXq69j9_I-02416-00571992-00572291": "eyes have it"}}, {"audio_id": "hmSEVF30GjU", "text": {"hmSEVF30GjU-00000-00000496-00000719": "[Music]", "hmSEVF30GjU-00001-00000720-00000958": "hello everyone uh with us we have", "hmSEVF30GjU-00002-00000959-00001223": "benjamin bishop he is a test automation", "hmSEVF30GjU-00003-00001224-00001439": "engineer at trivago and today he would", "hmSEVF30GjU-00004-00001440-00001655": "be speaking speaking on the topic of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00005-00001655-00001902": "plugins and decorators travel girls", "hmSEVF30GjU-00006-00001903-00002047": "end-to-end test framework in the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00007-00002048-00002326": "spotlight welcome benjamin the stage is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00008-00002327-00002526": "on yours", "hmSEVF30GjU-00009-00002527-00002734": "thanks a lot for having me hello", "hmSEVF30GjU-00010-00002735-00002942": "everyone in the world", "hmSEVF30GjU-00011-00002943-00003247": "let's get started so this is of plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00012-00003247-00003415": "and decorators", "hmSEVF30GjU-00013-00003415-00003527": "um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00014-00003528-00003863": "it's about two major things that we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00015-00003864-00004135": "built into our uh in-house end-to-end", "hmSEVF30GjU-00016-00004136-00004431": "test framework and i thought you might", "hmSEVF30GjU-00017-00004432-00004751": "be interested to see what we did maybe", "hmSEVF30GjU-00018-00004752-00004991": "it's an inspiration to you or maybe it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00019-00004992-00005199": "inspires you to do something completely", "hmSEVF30GjU-00020-00005200-00005463": "different because you think this is not", "hmSEVF30GjU-00021-00005464-00005647": "a good idea", "hmSEVF30GjU-00022-00005648-00005727": "so", "hmSEVF30GjU-00023-00005728-00005943": "what i would like to do is give you a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00024-00005944-00006167": "little introduction", "hmSEVF30GjU-00025-00006168-00006470": "tell you why we decided to make a new", "hmSEVF30GjU-00026-00006472-00006719": "framework at all um some of the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00027-00006720-00007039": "challenges and solutions and some last", "hmSEVF30GjU-00028-00007040-00007263": "thoughts", "hmSEVF30GjU-00029-00007264-00007487": "little disclaimer here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00030-00007488-00007663": "it's very", "hmSEVF30GjU-00031-00007664-00007887": "technology heavy", "hmSEVF30GjU-00032-00007888-00008151": "very code heavy as well the code", "hmSEVF30GjU-00033-00008152-00008383": "examples are in java because that's the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00034-00008384-00008623": "language i use daily and if there are", "hmSEVF30GjU-00035-00008624-00009055": "any questions i can actually answer them", "hmSEVF30GjU-00036-00009056-00009303": "and like i said what works for us might", "hmSEVF30GjU-00037-00009304-00009487": "not work for you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00038-00009488-00009727": "because good solutions solve very", "hmSEVF30GjU-00039-00009728-00009999": "specific problems and i'll tell you what", "hmSEVF30GjU-00040-00010000-00010423": "exact problems we had", "hmSEVF30GjU-00041-00010424-00010623": "so", "hmSEVF30GjU-00042-00010624-00010887": "um that's me thanks again for the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00043-00010888-00011103": "introduction benjamin bischoff that's my", "hmSEVF30GjU-00044-00011104-00011359": "name i'm i'm a test automation engineer", "hmSEVF30GjU-00045-00011360-00011863": "at trivago so i've been working there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00046-00011864-00012063": "six years", "hmSEVF30GjU-00047-00012064-00012231": "in total i'm", "hmSEVF30GjU-00048-00012232-00012463": "22 years in tech", "hmSEVF30GjU-00049-00012464-00012767": "15 years of 100 percent", "hmSEVF30GjU-00050-00012768-00012879": "of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00051-00012880-00013143": "full developer and then i transitioned", "hmSEVF30GjU-00052-00013144-00013511": "gradually into the world of testing", "hmSEVF30GjU-00053-00013512-00013735": "so now you could call me a software", "hmSEVF30GjU-00054-00013736-00014022": "development engineer in test", "hmSEVF30GjU-00055-00014023-00014315": "and i write articles on my website", "hmSEVF30GjU-00056-00014316-00014511": "softwaretest.blog in case you're", "hmSEVF30GjU-00057-00014512-00014894": "interested to read what i have to say", "hmSEVF30GjU-00058-00014895-00015143": "on trivago", "hmSEVF30GjU-00059-00015144-00015483": "it was founded in 2005 in dusseldorf", "hmSEVF30GjU-00060-00015484-00015783": "germany and it was the first german", "hmSEVF30GjU-00061-00015784-00016103": "hotel meta search that lets you search", "hmSEVF30GjU-00062-00016104-00016319": "for your hotels based on different", "hmSEVF30GjU-00063-00016319-00016519": "criteria and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00064-00016520-00016791": "dates and filters", "hmSEVF30GjU-00065-00016792-00016958": "so that's what we do", "hmSEVF30GjU-00066-00016959-00017303": "so you might have seen our product here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00067-00017304-00017535": "that is our main", "hmSEVF30GjU-00068-00017536-00017935": "website that you can search hotels", "hmSEVF30GjU-00069-00017936-00018086": "on", "hmSEVF30GjU-00070-00018087-00018271": "so you see", "hmSEVF30GjU-00071-00018272-00018486": "at first glance that there are a lot of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00072-00018487-00018750": "components on this website there is a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00073-00018751-00018999": "lot to do a lot of filters", "hmSEVF30GjU-00074-00019000-00019630": "so it's rather challenging to test", "hmSEVF30GjU-00075-00019631-00019879": "so why a new framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00076-00019880-00020327": "when i joined the company in 2016", "hmSEVF30GjU-00077-00020328-00020607": "there was a framework already in place", "hmSEVF30GjU-00078-00020608-00020950": "um i will not mention any names because", "hmSEVF30GjU-00079-00020951-00021327": "it is still around and still used", "hmSEVF30GjU-00080-00021328-00021607": "but for us it was just too bloated there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00081-00021608-00021711": "were", "hmSEVF30GjU-00082-00021712-00021958": "too many technologies crammed into it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00083-00021959-00022255": "too many ways you could do things it was", "hmSEVF30GjU-00084-00022256-00022494": "too chaotic also because there was no", "hmSEVF30GjU-00085-00022495-00022847": "real structure to the tests", "hmSEVF30GjU-00086-00022848-00023111": "for us really important it was not able", "hmSEVF30GjU-00087-00023112-00023414": "to handle a b testing properly because", "hmSEVF30GjU-00088-00023415-00023767": "that's what we rely on heavily", "hmSEVF30GjU-00089-00023768-00024022": "and it was rather hard to solve company", "hmSEVF30GjU-00090-00024023-00024503": "specific problems", "hmSEVF30GjU-00091-00024504-00024742": "so in general when building a new", "hmSEVF30GjU-00092-00024743-00024935": "framework there are a lot of questions", "hmSEVF30GjU-00093-00024936-00025222": "you can ask like what problems should it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00094-00025223-00025358": "actually solve", "hmSEVF30GjU-00095-00025359-00025591": "who the target audience is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00096-00025592-00025790": "if there are any dependencies and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00097-00025791-00025967": "interfaces", "hmSEVF30GjU-00098-00025968-00026399": "tools that are already in the company", "hmSEVF30GjU-00099-00026400-00026607": "things like where should it run how", "hmSEVF30GjU-00100-00026608-00026814": "should it be triggered what should the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00101-00026816-00027335": "reporting be like and all of this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00102-00027336-00027590": "so we went through all those questions", "hmSEVF30GjU-00103-00027591-00027887": "and then uh did a lot of evaluations as", "hmSEVF30GjU-00104-00027888-00027967": "well", "hmSEVF30GjU-00105-00027968-00028207": "and then in the end settled on a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00106-00028208-00028462": "selenium-based framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00107-00028463-00028687": "why selenium because", "hmSEVF30GjU-00108-00028688-00028855": "it's proven", "hmSEVF30GjU-00109-00028856-00028999": "it's a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00110-00029000-00029262": "proven browser automation technology", "hmSEVF30GjU-00111-00029263-00029383": "it is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00112-00029383-00029551": "compatible with most browsers and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00113-00029552-00029751": "devices", "hmSEVF30GjU-00114-00029752-00030023": "super important for us it can handle", "hmSEVF30GjU-00115-00030024-00030414": "multiple windows and tabs a lot of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00116-00030416-00030743": "newer frameworks cannot do that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00117-00030744-00031087": "but our main web application relies on", "hmSEVF30GjU-00118-00031088-00031335": "tabs and windows so this is really", "hmSEVF30GjU-00119-00031336-00031470": "important", "hmSEVF30GjU-00120-00031472-00031711": "and it has the standardized webdriver", "hmSEVF30GjU-00121-00031712-00031990": "protocol which makes it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00122-00031991-00032495": "very nice to work with", "hmSEVF30GjU-00123-00032495-00032790": "the test framework we wrote", "hmSEVF30GjU-00124-00032791-00032935": "um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00125-00032936-00033255": "is a pure java framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00126-00033256-00033574": "like i said i started it in 2016", "hmSEVF30GjU-00127-00033575-00033790": "as a follow-up to the old framework we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00128-00033791-00033943": "were using", "hmSEVF30GjU-00129-00033944-00034190": "it's based on the latest cucumber bdd", "hmSEVF30GjU-00130-00034191-00034446": "and selenium versions so we can actually", "hmSEVF30GjU-00131-00034447-00034831": "write very descriptive tests", "hmSEVF30GjU-00132-00034832-00035087": "because it's selenium it supports", "hmSEVF30GjU-00133-00035088-00035439": "various browsers and os's and mobile", "hmSEVF30GjU-00134-00035440-00035590": "devices as well", "hmSEVF30GjU-00135-00035591-00035774": "because the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00136-00035775-00036055": "protocol that it's using is the same or", "hmSEVF30GjU-00137-00036056-00036223": "that it's used by", "hmSEVF30GjU-00138-00036224-00036511": "say appium so we can run", "hmSEVF30GjU-00139-00036512-00036911": "web tests on mobile devices as well", "hmSEVF30GjU-00140-00036912-00037023": "and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00141-00037024-00037223": "another important thing it has a plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00142-00037224-00037567": "api and this is actually the second", "hmSEVF30GjU-00143-00037568-00037999": "challenge i will talk about today", "hmSEVF30GjU-00144-00038000-00038295": "so the challenges", "hmSEVF30GjU-00145-00038296-00038583": "for us a big challenge was element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00146-00038584-00038879": "resilience and hierarchy and i will tell", "hmSEVF30GjU-00147-00038880-00039215": "you what i mean by that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00148-00039216-00039415": "but first we have to look at the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00149-00039416-00039711": "selenium web element that is something", "hmSEVF30GjU-00150-00039712-00039967": "you are probably all familiar with", "hmSEVF30GjU-00151-00039968-00040183": "because it's the building block of all", "hmSEVF30GjU-00152-00040184-00040359": "selenium code it's", "hmSEVF30GjU-00153-00040360-00040655": "the representation in code of a dom", "hmSEVF30GjU-00154-00040656-00040879": "element on the website", "hmSEVF30GjU-00155-00040880-00041183": "specifically findable via locators in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00156-00041184-00041343": "selenium that is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00157-00041344-00041527": "the buy", "hmSEVF30GjU-00158-00041528-00041695": "keyword", "hmSEVF30GjU-00159-00041696-00042039": "so it can be by tech name can we buy css", "hmSEVF30GjU-00160-00042040-00042118": "by", "hmSEVF30GjU-00161-00042119-00042239": "xpath", "hmSEVF30GjU-00162-00042240-00042439": "various methods", "hmSEVF30GjU-00163-00042440-00042671": "and it supports various interactions", "hmSEVF30GjU-00164-00042672-00043102": "like clicking on it or inserting text", "hmSEVF30GjU-00165-00043103-00043495": "so that's the basic thing", "hmSEVF30GjU-00166-00043496-00043839": "what it does not support is automatic", "hmSEVF30GjU-00167-00043840-00044055": "stale element handling", "hmSEVF30GjU-00168-00044056-00044358": "if you are using selenium on a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00169-00044359-00044567": "more complex website you might have", "hmSEVF30GjU-00170-00044568-00044727": "encountered that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00171-00044728-00044883": "if an element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00172-00044884-00045262": "flickers it is reloaded", "hmSEVF30GjU-00173-00045263-00045479": "selenium might give you a stale element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00174-00045480-00045615": "exception", "hmSEVF30GjU-00175-00045616-00045871": "that means that the element is not there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00176-00045872-00046039": "anymore", "hmSEVF30GjU-00177-00046040-00046255": "and i totally get why selenium doesn't", "hmSEVF30GjU-00178-00046256-00046527": "handle this for us because it is a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00179-00046528-00047055": "remote control for browsers nothing more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00180-00047056-00047543": "there is no real element hierarchy", "hmSEVF30GjU-00181-00047544-00047799": "it is kind of there now because you can", "hmSEVF30GjU-00182-00047800-00047902": "chain", "hmSEVF30GjU-00183-00047903-00048223": "locators you can search for locators", "hmSEVF30GjU-00184-00048224-00048430": "inside of other locators but we wanted", "hmSEVF30GjU-00185-00048431-00048871": "to have a real parent-child relationship", "hmSEVF30GjU-00186-00048872-00049015": "and a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00187-00049016-00049311": "minor point but an annoying point for us", "hmSEVF30GjU-00188-00049312-00049527": "was that there is only one fixed", "hmSEVF30GjU-00189-00049528-00049823": "standard timeout for weights", "hmSEVF30GjU-00190-00049824-00050023": "you can use fluent weights of course", "hmSEVF30GjU-00191-00050024-00050246": "with", "hmSEVF30GjU-00192-00050247-00050511": "other than default timeouts but", "hmSEVF30GjU-00193-00050512-00050743": "we wanted to have a more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00194-00050744-00051174": "automatic way to do this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00195-00051175-00051550": "so what we decided to do is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00196-00051551-00052063": "program a custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00197-00052064-00052366": "and to understand a little more of what", "hmSEVF30GjU-00198-00052367-00052654": "we're doing here's a short look into", "hmSEVF30GjU-00199-00052655-00053030": "page objects versus page components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00200-00053032-00053447": "so page objects that is a standard way", "hmSEVF30GjU-00201-00053448-00053550": "for", "hmSEVF30GjU-00202-00053551-00053791": "web-based tests", "hmSEVF30GjU-00203-00053791-00053959": "that means wrapping the page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00204-00053960-00054238": "functionality into classes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00205-00054239-00054519": "so you have everything you can do on a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00206-00054520-00054926": "page through a single entry point", "hmSEVF30GjU-00207-00054927-00055207": "and very encapsulated units of code if", "hmSEVF30GjU-00208-00055208-00055454": "you see the right side", "hmSEVF30GjU-00209-00055455-00055623": "the orange", "hmSEVF30GjU-00210-00055624-00055879": "border that is the page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00211-00055879-00056182": "and on the lower left you see search", "hmSEVF30GjU-00212-00056183-00056535": "page dot search for london search page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00213-00056536-00056750": "is the page object", "hmSEVF30GjU-00214-00056751-00057038": "and search for is the method in london", "hmSEVF30GjU-00215-00057039-00057287": "is the parameter that in this case is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00216-00057288-00057535": "entered in into the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00217-00057536-00057942": "search box", "hmSEVF30GjU-00218-00057944-00058175": "but we wanted to have page components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00219-00058176-00058415": "something that actually is mentioned on", "hmSEVF30GjU-00220-00058416-00058654": "the selenium website as well that you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00221-00058655-00058879": "can use page components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00222-00058879-00059175": "instead of page objects", "hmSEVF30GjU-00223-00059176-00059471": "that means wrapping single components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00224-00059472-00059694": "into classes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00225-00059695-00059894": "and then combine combining those", "hmSEVF30GjU-00226-00059895-00060191": "components into pages", "hmSEVF30GjU-00227-00060191-00060454": "so in this case you can delegate the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00228-00060455-00060806": "actions through a page to the specific", "hmSEVF30GjU-00229-00060807-00061015": "component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00230-00061016-00061303": "again the orange border in this case is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00231-00061304-00061535": "the component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00232-00061536-00061782": "so we have a search page which is the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00233-00061783-00061999": "page dot search", "hmSEVF30GjU-00234-00062000-00062223": "which is the search component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00235-00062224-00062326": "and then", "hmSEVF30GjU-00236-00062327-00062519": "the search for methods", "hmSEVF30GjU-00237-00062520-00062815": "that is part of the component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00238-00062816-00063175": "that's what we wanted to do", "hmSEVF30GjU-00239-00063176-00063263": "now", "hmSEVF30GjU-00240-00063264-00063503": "don't let this put you off please i will", "hmSEVF30GjU-00241-00063504-00063791": "highlight the code parts that i want to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00242-00063791-00064054": "mention", "hmSEVF30GjU-00243-00064055-00064311": "this is how it would look in our test", "hmSEVF30GjU-00244-00064312-00064438": "code", "hmSEVF30GjU-00245-00064439-00064799": "so in this case the search page extends", "hmSEVF30GjU-00246-00064800-00064911": "a page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00247-00064912-00065303": "and the page is our base page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00248-00065304-00065471": "and this page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00249-00065472-00065882": "has just access methods to all of its", "hmSEVF30GjU-00250-00065883-00066199": "component like here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00251-00066200-00066494": "in the previous example when you do", "hmSEVF30GjU-00252-00066495-00066863": "search page dot search it returns you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00253-00066864-00067103": "the search component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00254-00067104-00067326": "and for this we have the get component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00255-00067327-00067582": "method that is part of our base page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00256-00067583-00067838": "that is able to return", "hmSEVF30GjU-00257-00067839-00068255": "page components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00258-00068256-00068494": "and it can return those components that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00259-00068495-00068879": "extend our component class which is a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00260-00068880-00069487": "base component in the framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00261-00069488-00069671": "a little side note", "hmSEVF30GjU-00262-00069672-00070031": "generally we search for elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00263-00070032-00070206": "through", "hmSEVF30GjU-00264-00070207-00070438": "data test ids", "hmSEVF30GjU-00265-00070439-00070791": "so we don't really rely on any other", "hmSEVF30GjU-00266-00070792-00070926": "locators", "hmSEVF30GjU-00267-00070927-00071271": "but we have our own data test ids in the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00268-00071272-00071487": "page code so that makes it much much", "hmSEVF30GjU-00269-00071488-00071647": "easier to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00270-00071648-00072071": "access those components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00271-00072072-00072359": "and on the right side you see the find", "hmSEVF30GjU-00272-00072360-00072471": "by", "hmSEVF30GjU-00273-00072472-00072711": "with the orange border", "hmSEVF30GjU-00274-00072712-00072806": "so", "hmSEVF30GjU-00275-00072807-00073079": "the add find by annotation", "hmSEVF30GjU-00276-00073080-00073438": "that belongs typically to selenium", "hmSEVF30GjU-00277-00073439-00073711": "to search for selenium web elements but", "hmSEVF30GjU-00278-00073712-00073959": "in our case we use it to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00279-00073960-00074262": "search for our custom web element and i", "hmSEVF30GjU-00280-00074263-00074567": "will show you later in the code how we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00281-00074568-00075055": "can do this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00282-00075056-00075159": "this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00283-00075160-00075406": "is the whole component in web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00284-00075407-00075519": "flow", "hmSEVF30GjU-00285-00075520-00075911": "and don't worry i will i will try to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00286-00075912-00076191": "make it as clear as i can in this short", "hmSEVF30GjU-00287-00076192-00076519": "period of time this could actually be", "hmSEVF30GjU-00288-00076520-00076679": "many many hours", "hmSEVF30GjU-00289-00076680-00076911": "and i was struggling to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00290-00076912-00077103": "compress this down to a single", "hmSEVF30GjU-00291-00077104-00077319": "presentation", "hmSEVF30GjU-00292-00077320-00077623": "so let's try to go through this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00293-00077624-00077959": "so what happens as you saw we request a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00294-00077960-00078126": "component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00295-00078127-00078382": "from the component factory i will show", "hmSEVF30GjU-00296-00078383-00078719": "you in the next slide how this works", "hmSEVF30GjU-00297-00078720-00079023": "because we use spring in the framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00298-00079024-00079350": "we also retrieve the component and when", "hmSEVF30GjU-00299-00079351-00079694": "i say component i am page component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00300-00079695-00080023": "from the spring context", "hmSEVF30GjU-00301-00080024-00080182": "and then", "hmSEVF30GjU-00302-00080183-00080503": "to handle the find by annotation that is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00303-00080504-00080726": "typically used by selenium", "hmSEVF30GjU-00304-00080727-00080943": "we apply a custom", "hmSEVF30GjU-00305-00080944-00081238": "field decorator", "hmSEVF30GjU-00306-00081239-00081479": "and the field decorator is actually part", "hmSEVF30GjU-00307-00081480-00081959": "of selenium as well", "hmSEVF30GjU-00308-00081960-00082231": "so this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00309-00082232-00082406": "is where it starts", "hmSEVF30GjU-00310-00082407-00082550": "like i showed you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00311-00082551-00082838": "you do the get component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00312-00082839-00083118": "search dot class which would return you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00313-00083119-00083271": "the search", "hmSEVF30GjU-00314-00083272-00083694": "page component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00315-00083695-00084006": "and we have a factory class", "hmSEVF30GjU-00316-00084007-00084655": "that is able to return those components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00317-00084656-00084950": "like i said this is where it is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00318-00084951-00085271": "retrieved from the spring context", "hmSEVF30GjU-00319-00085272-00085423": "it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00320-00085424-00085599": "it's important for us it might not be", "hmSEVF30GjU-00321-00085600-00085750": "important for you if you don't use", "hmSEVF30GjU-00322-00085751-00086087": "spring or any other dependency injection", "hmSEVF30GjU-00323-00086088-00086255": "framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00324-00086256-00086479": "just ignore this line", "hmSEVF30GjU-00325-00086480-00086782": "the important one is this one", "hmSEVF30GjU-00326-00086783-00087111": "that is a field decorator that is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00327-00087112-00087462": "typically used in selenium to find", "hmSEVF30GjU-00328-00087463-00087591": "elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00329-00087592-00087759": "by custom", "hmSEVF30GjU-00330-00087760-00087894": "locators", "hmSEVF30GjU-00331-00087895-00088255": "but we use it differently", "hmSEVF30GjU-00332-00088256-00088471": "and i will show you how", "hmSEVF30GjU-00333-00088472-00088831": "the important thing here is that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00334-00088832-00089150": "we create this custom field decorator", "hmSEVF30GjU-00335-00089151-00089455": "using the current web driver", "hmSEVF30GjU-00336-00089456-00089535": "and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00337-00089536-00089894": "the properties we pass to the framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00338-00089895-00090175": "that is typically system properties to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00339-00090176-00090606": "have some specific settings", "hmSEVF30GjU-00340-00090607-00090935": "and this is where the magic happens", "hmSEVF30GjU-00341-00090936-00091031": "the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00342-00091032-00091247": "selenium page factory", "hmSEVF30GjU-00343-00091248-00091350": "init", "hmSEVF30GjU-00344-00091351-00091511": "elements method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00345-00091512-00091775": "this one initializes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00346-00091776-00092038": "the elements the components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00347-00092039-00092415": "of a page using this field decorator and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00348-00092416-00092935": "using the requested page component", "hmSEVF30GjU-00349-00092936-00093199": "if you have any questions afterwards i", "hmSEVF30GjU-00350-00093200-00093647": "will try my best to answer them and also", "hmSEVF30GjU-00351-00093648-00093894": "i will try to um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00352-00093895-00094223": "make this slide set available for you in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00353-00094224-00094711": "case you want to look something up", "hmSEVF30GjU-00354-00094712-00094935": "and the page factory that's interesting", "hmSEVF30GjU-00355-00094936-00095206": "i found this quote from simon stewart", "hmSEVF30GjU-00356-00095207-00095415": "from 2017", "hmSEVF30GjU-00357-00095416-00095671": "saying the page factory design ain't my", "hmSEVF30GjU-00358-00095672-00095894": "best work i'd recommend using it for", "hmSEVF30GjU-00359-00095895-00096174": "inspiration for something better", "hmSEVF30GjU-00360-00096175-00096447": "i have to slightly disagree here because", "hmSEVF30GjU-00361-00096448-00096735": "for us it was exactly what we needed to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00362-00096736-00097255": "solve our problem with the web elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00363-00097256-00097718": "okay so we have the field decorator", "hmSEVF30GjU-00364-00097719-00098038": "and now the magic continues", "hmSEVF30GjU-00365-00098039-00098326": "we are registering a callback", "hmSEVF30GjU-00366-00098327-00098503": "on the components", "hmSEVF30GjU-00367-00098504-00098711": "to intercept", "hmSEVF30GjU-00368-00098712-00099159": "methods", "hmSEVF30GjU-00369-00099160-00099391": "and this is where this happens this is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00370-00099392-00099615": "our custom field decorator that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00371-00099616-00099887": "implements the selenium field decorator", "hmSEVF30GjU-00372-00099888-00100262": "interface", "hmSEVF30GjU-00373-00100263-00100550": "and the important part is that this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00374-00100551-00100903": "interface has a decorate method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00375-00100904-00101126": "and this took quite some time to figure", "hmSEVF30GjU-00376-00101127-00101255": "out", "hmSEVF30GjU-00377-00101256-00101535": "but the class loader here is the web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00378-00101536-00101703": "driver", "hmSEVF30GjU-00379-00101704-00101838": "and the field", "hmSEVF30GjU-00380-00101839-00101959": "is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00381-00101960-00102079": "the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00382-00102080-00102486": "variable that is annotated by the find", "hmSEVF30GjU-00383-00102488-00102758": "by annotation", "hmSEVF30GjU-00384-00102759-00102839": "um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00385-00102840-00102982": "so here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00386-00102983-00103118": "we check", "hmSEVF30GjU-00387-00103119-00103382": "if we have a find by annotation and if", "hmSEVF30GjU-00388-00103383-00103734": "this find my annotation annotates our", "hmSEVF30GjU-00389-00103735-00104078": "custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00390-00104079-00104271": "and if it is one of our custom web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00391-00104272-00104454": "elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00392-00104455-00104566": "we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00393-00104567-00104654": "add", "hmSEVF30GjU-00394-00104655-00104902": "this callback method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00395-00104903-00105086": "for those of you who", "hmSEVF30GjU-00396-00105088-00105566": "are into java reflection we use the cg", "hmSEVF30GjU-00397-00105567-00105975": "lib library to do that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00398-00105976-00106199": "it's called an enhancer", "hmSEVF30GjU-00399-00106200-00106599": "and this enhancer makes it possible to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00400-00106600-00106902": "intercept any methods that are called on", "hmSEVF30GjU-00401-00106903-00107134": "a specific class in our case on the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00402-00107135-00107495": "custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00403-00107496-00107766": "and what that enables us to do", "hmSEVF30GjU-00404-00107767-00108071": "is whenever you interact with our custom", "hmSEVF30GjU-00405-00108072-00108223": "web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00406-00108224-00108599": "then it is initialized", "hmSEVF30GjU-00407-00108600-00108919": "it's like selenium works when you do a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00408-00108920-00109151": "add find by annotation", "hmSEVF30GjU-00409-00109152-00109319": "on a web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00410-00109320-00109519": "it is not", "hmSEVF30GjU-00411-00109520-00109863": "initialized yet it's just a proxy", "hmSEVF30GjU-00412-00109864-00110158": "that waits for interactions with a web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00413-00110159-00110431": "element and then it's being initialized", "hmSEVF30GjU-00414-00110432-00110631": "this is done to save", "hmSEVF30GjU-00415-00110632-00110727": "memory", "hmSEVF30GjU-00416-00110728-00111375": "and to make it faster and we mimic this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00417-00111376-00111534": "so this is the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00418-00111535-00111654": "intercept", "hmSEVF30GjU-00419-00111655-00111775": "that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00420-00111776-00111871": "um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00421-00111872-00111999": "you don't have to look at all the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00422-00112000-00112151": "parameters but", "hmSEVF30GjU-00423-00112152-00112327": "the way it works is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00424-00112328-00112607": "it checks if the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00425-00112608-00112727": "object", "hmSEVF30GjU-00426-00112728-00112999": "we are calling a method on", "hmSEVF30GjU-00427-00113000-00113439": "is of type custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00428-00113440-00113678": "and if it is and if", "hmSEVF30GjU-00429-00113679-00114063": "if it is not yet initialized", "hmSEVF30GjU-00430-00114064-00114302": "we set the web driver on it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00431-00114303-00114407": "we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00432-00114408-00114886": "um set the selenium web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00433-00114888-00115158": "we set all the framework properties", "hmSEVF30GjU-00434-00115159-00115486": "and we also set the by", "hmSEVF30GjU-00435-00115488-00115854": "so each custom web element knows exactly", "hmSEVF30GjU-00436-00115855-00116543": "how it was found", "hmSEVF30GjU-00437-00116544-00116815": "and then when we have done all this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00438-00116816-00117071": "we invoke super", "hmSEVF30GjU-00439-00117072-00117478": "that means we call the original method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00440-00117479-00117551": "so", "hmSEVF30GjU-00441-00117552-00117719": "this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00442-00117720-00118039": "intercept method like its name implies", "hmSEVF30GjU-00443-00118040-00118431": "it intercepts the methods call does some", "hmSEVF30GjU-00444-00118432-00118710": "of its own in this initialization", "hmSEVF30GjU-00445-00118711-00118966": "and then redirects to the original", "hmSEVF30GjU-00446-00118967-00119302": "method so it sits in between the caller", "hmSEVF30GjU-00447-00119303-00119807": "and the custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00448-00119808-00120031": "and then we execute", "hmSEVF30GjU-00449-00120032-00120327": "the methods that we want to call", "hmSEVF30GjU-00450-00120328-00120566": "using the initialize properties because", "hmSEVF30GjU-00451-00120567-00120823": "at that point we can be sure that it is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00452-00120824-00121047": "initialized", "hmSEVF30GjU-00453-00121048-00121534": "like a click", "hmSEVF30GjU-00454-00121535-00121663": "and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00455-00121664-00121883": "we do that by", "hmSEVF30GjU-00456-00121883-00122199": "passing the function as a lambda", "hmSEVF30GjU-00457-00122200-00122447": "function", "hmSEVF30GjU-00458-00122448-00122599": "so", "hmSEVF30GjU-00459-00122600-00122854": "like in this case wait until element is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00460-00122855-00122975": "clickable", "hmSEVF30GjU-00461-00122976-00123199": "and then do the web element click which", "hmSEVF30GjU-00462-00123200-00123639": "is the selenium method the original one", "hmSEVF30GjU-00463-00123640-00123958": "so our custom web element because it has", "hmSEVF30GjU-00464-00123959-00124319": "a reference to the selenium web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00465-00124320-00124431": "uses", "hmSEVF30GjU-00466-00124432-00124951": "the selenium method in the end to click", "hmSEVF30GjU-00467-00124952-00125278": "and because we pass this as a lambda", "hmSEVF30GjU-00468-00125279-00125471": "function", "hmSEVF30GjU-00469-00125472-00125607": "we can", "hmSEVF30GjU-00470-00125608-00125958": "execute it here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00471-00125959-00126158": "and if we catch a stale element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00472-00126159-00126447": "reference exception which is this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00473-00126448-00126719": "stale element exception that i talked", "hmSEVF30GjU-00474-00126720-00126878": "about before", "hmSEVF30GjU-00475-00126879-00127327": "oops i'm sorry", "hmSEVF30GjU-00476-00127328-00127654": "then we can try to refine the web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00477-00127655-00127766": "element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00478-00127767-00127895": "because", "hmSEVF30GjU-00479-00127896-00128183": "it knows how it was found so we can use", "hmSEVF30GjU-00480-00128183-00128534": "the same buy condition again", "hmSEVF30GjU-00481-00128535-00128878": "and then try to call this method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00482-00128879-00129278": "again", "hmSEVF30GjU-00483-00129279-00129575": "and refining elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00484-00129576-00129790": "that is where the parent-child", "hmSEVF30GjU-00485-00129791-00130223": "relationship comes in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00486-00130224-00130439": "we check", "hmSEVF30GjU-00487-00130440-00130519": "if", "hmSEVF30GjU-00488-00130520-00130847": "our custom web element has a parent", "hmSEVF30GjU-00489-00130848-00131119": "if it has a parent", "hmSEVF30GjU-00490-00131120-00131502": "we try to find the web element within", "hmSEVF30GjU-00491-00131503-00131639": "this parent", "hmSEVF30GjU-00492-00131640-00131839": "that is the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00493-00131840-00132175": "uh page component context the page page", "hmSEVF30GjU-00494-00132176-00132407": "component bounding box", "hmSEVF30GjU-00495-00132408-00132711": "so when we find elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00496-00132712-00132943": "inside other elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00497-00132944-00133254": "it's just searching inside this specific", "hmSEVF30GjU-00498-00133255-00133463": "dom element and not through the whole", "hmSEVF30GjU-00499-00133464-00133878": "page like it typically does", "hmSEVF30GjU-00500-00133879-00133983": "and again", "hmSEVF30GjU-00501-00133984-00134207": "if we catch a stale element with", "hmSEVF30GjU-00502-00134208-00134439": "reference exception", "hmSEVF30GjU-00503-00134440-00134766": "we try to refine its parent", "hmSEVF30GjU-00504-00134767-00135102": "so this is something that we wanted to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00505-00135103-00135295": "have this is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00506-00135296-00135487": "uh recursively", "hmSEVF30GjU-00507-00135488-00135590": "finding", "hmSEVF30GjU-00508-00135591-00135927": "elements and parents all the way back", "hmSEVF30GjU-00509-00135928-00136151": "until an element does not have a parent", "hmSEVF30GjU-00510-00136152-00136343": "anymore", "hmSEVF30GjU-00511-00136344-00136607": "and then we go back down", "hmSEVF30GjU-00512-00136608-00136895": "and try to find", "hmSEVF30GjU-00513-00136896-00137263": "the web element again", "hmSEVF30GjU-00514-00137264-00137887": "that makes it really really stable", "hmSEVF30GjU-00515-00137888-00138495": "there it is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00516-00138496-00138847": "and the last thing we did here is uh", "hmSEVF30GjU-00517-00138848-00139054": "what i talked about the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00518-00139055-00139383": "default timeout that you have", "hmSEVF30GjU-00519-00139384-00139823": "that we wanted to bypass", "hmSEVF30GjU-00520-00139824-00139990": "is this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00521-00139991-00140254": "so we have find element and find", "hmSEVF30GjU-00522-00140255-00140407": "elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00523-00140408-00140583": "for a list", "hmSEVF30GjU-00524-00140584-00140902": "methods here but we also have find", "hmSEVF30GjU-00525-00140903-00141214": "element directly and find elements", "hmSEVF30GjU-00526-00141215-00141407": "directly methods", "hmSEVF30GjU-00527-00141408-00141839": "that means that we don't want to wait", "hmSEVF30GjU-00528-00141840-00142047": "in case we are really sure an element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00529-00142048-00142311": "exists or we are really sure an element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00530-00142312-00142590": "does not exist anymore", "hmSEVF30GjU-00531-00142591-00142863": "we can set the web driver minimal weight", "hmSEVF30GjU-00532-00142864-00143231": "which in our case is 50 milliseconds", "hmSEVF30GjU-00533-00143232-00143535": "then try to find the element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00534-00143536-00143766": "and then reset", "hmSEVF30GjU-00535-00143767-00144102": "the web driver regular weight again", "hmSEVF30GjU-00536-00144103-00144375": "so this dirty trick", "hmSEVF30GjU-00537-00144376-00144647": "that's why i wrote on the right yes i", "hmSEVF30GjU-00538-00144648-00144878": "know it is a dirty trick", "hmSEVF30GjU-00539-00144879-00145223": "but that speeds up our tests", "hmSEVF30GjU-00540-00145224-00145359": "many times", "hmSEVF30GjU-00541-00145360-00145614": "because especially when an element is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00542-00145615-00145863": "not on a page and we want to check that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00543-00145864-00146031": "it's not there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00544-00146032-00146302": "we don't have to wait 20 seconds", "hmSEVF30GjU-00545-00146303-00146519": "until selenium says no the element is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00546-00146520-00146687": "not there anymore", "hmSEVF30GjU-00547-00146688-00147039": "but we can just use a directly method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00548-00147040-00147814": "and then instantly get this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00549-00147815-00147951": "yeah um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00550-00147952-00148207": "if you have subsequent interactions with", "hmSEVF30GjU-00551-00148208-00148423": "a custom web element so after it's", "hmSEVF30GjU-00552-00148424-00148607": "initialized", "hmSEVF30GjU-00553-00148608-00148814": "it's directly", "hmSEVF30GjU-00554-00148815-00149159": "invoked without the initialization phase", "hmSEVF30GjU-00555-00149160-00149390": "so we skip initialization", "hmSEVF30GjU-00556-00149391-00149654": "and then just", "hmSEVF30GjU-00557-00149655-00149966": "redirect it to the original method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00558-00149967-00150239": "that's how it looks", "hmSEVF30GjU-00559-00150240-00150590": "there's the intercept method again", "hmSEVF30GjU-00560-00150591-00150711": "and we check", "hmSEVF30GjU-00561-00150712-00151023": "is the custom web element initialized if", "hmSEVF30GjU-00562-00151024-00151295": "it is we skip all this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00563-00151296-00151678": "and we just invoke the original method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00564-00151679-00151959": "so from this point on it's exactly as", "hmSEVF30GjU-00565-00151960-00152135": "fast as", "hmSEVF30GjU-00566-00152136-00152375": "the original selenium code because we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00567-00152376-00152726": "don't have all this initialization", "hmSEVF30GjU-00568-00152727-00152895": "it's just something in the middle that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00569-00152896-00153014": "does nothing", "hmSEVF30GjU-00570-00153015-00153495": "from this point on", "hmSEVF30GjU-00571-00153496-00153631": "and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00572-00153632-00153823": "some of you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00573-00153824-00153975": "might think why", "hmSEVF30GjU-00574-00153976-00154199": "so complex", "hmSEVF30GjU-00575-00154200-00154423": "because selenium all", "hmSEVF30GjU-00576-00154424-00154654": "it has a lot of this stuff built in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00577-00154655-00154831": "already", "hmSEVF30GjU-00578-00154832-00155102": "yes but we wanted to be free", "hmSEVF30GjU-00579-00155103-00155407": "to use our own custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00580-00155408-00155519": "or", "hmSEVF30GjU-00581-00155520-00155711": "selenium's web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00582-00155712-00155959": "especially in selenium 4", "hmSEVF30GjU-00583-00155960-00156111": "when there were some", "hmSEVF30GjU-00584-00156112-00156319": "more methods available some more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00585-00156320-00156614": "locators like the relative locators", "hmSEVF30GjU-00586-00156615-00156887": "we wanted to be free to use those", "hmSEVF30GjU-00587-00156888-00157207": "without having to release new framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00588-00157208-00157431": "versions all the time", "hmSEVF30GjU-00589-00157432-00157687": "so in this case we can use a find by", "hmSEVF30GjU-00590-00157688-00157854": "annotation", "hmSEVF30GjU-00591-00157855-00158102": "but instead of using our own custom web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00592-00158103-00158335": "element we can also use", "hmSEVF30GjU-00593-00158336-00158639": "the original web element of selenium and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00594-00158640-00158854": "use the new methods there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00595-00158855-00159159": "in later framework releases we also", "hmSEVF30GjU-00596-00159160-00159399": "added those relative locators", "hmSEVF30GjU-00597-00159400-00159702": "to our custom web element so we don't", "hmSEVF30GjU-00598-00159703-00159966": "need this anymore", "hmSEVF30GjU-00599-00159967-00160159": "yeah and like i said we did not want to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00600-00160160-00160511": "introduce another annotation", "hmSEVF30GjU-00601-00160512-00160790": "to keep the usage very straightforward", "hmSEVF30GjU-00602-00160791-00161039": "and also not to confuse the users and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00603-00161040-00161302": "should we decide to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00604-00161303-00161599": "dump our custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00605-00161600-00161823": "there won't be many changes in our", "hmSEVF30GjU-00606-00161824-00162119": "framework because we can just", "hmSEVF30GjU-00607-00162120-00162502": "use selenium's web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00608-00162503-00162759": "and very important point to remember it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00609-00162760-00162959": "is only complex for the framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00610-00162960-00163095": "creators", "hmSEVF30GjU-00611-00163096-00163366": "it is not complex for the users", "hmSEVF30GjU-00612-00163367-00163623": "they don't see what's going on", "hmSEVF30GjU-00613-00163624-00163766": "on the inside", "hmSEVF30GjU-00614-00163767-00164087": "so it's very important to hide the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00615-00164088-00164543": "complexity from the users", "hmSEVF30GjU-00616-00164544-00164814": "okay that was the harder one", "hmSEVF30GjU-00617-00164815-00164935": "now yes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00618-00164936-00165183": "let's go to the easier challenge", "hmSEVF30GjU-00619-00165184-00165614": "extensibility of the framework itself", "hmSEVF30GjU-00620-00165615-00165871": "this is typically how", "hmSEVF30GjU-00621-00165872-00166271": "the tests run so we run a test scenario", "hmSEVF30GjU-00622-00166272-00166502": "open a browser in this case a local", "hmSEVF30GjU-00623-00166503-00166743": "browser performs some actions on the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00624-00166744-00167031": "website make some assertions and then", "hmSEVF30GjU-00625-00167032-00167183": "lock results", "hmSEVF30GjU-00626-00167184-00167535": "and make the test pass or fail", "hmSEVF30GjU-00627-00167536-00167735": "but later we wanted to have more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00628-00167736-00168078": "functionality we wanted to use a test", "hmSEVF30GjU-00629-00168079-00168583": "cloud first our own internal one then a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00630-00168584-00168887": "commercial vendor one", "hmSEVF30GjU-00631-00168888-00169126": "one i won't mention any names at this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00632-00169127-00169302": "point", "hmSEVF30GjU-00633-00169303-00169519": "and we also wanted to send failure", "hmSEVF30GjU-00634-00169520-00169878": "messages via slack we wanted to queue", "hmSEVF30GjU-00635-00169879-00170159": "certain tests for re-run not all of them", "hmSEVF30GjU-00636-00170160-00170375": "but certain ones", "hmSEVF30GjU-00637-00170376-00170463": "and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00638-00170464-00170763": "um this is only a snapshot like from", "hmSEVF30GjU-00639-00170764-00171247": "2017 after that we added a lot more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00640-00171248-00171566": "of those arrows and boxes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00641-00171567-00171911": "but you might spot the problem here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00642-00171912-00172135": "direct framework integration of this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00643-00172136-00172359": "functionality", "hmSEVF30GjU-00644-00172360-00172614": "it it's just too much functionality in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00645-00172615-00172895": "the core framework that leads us to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00646-00172896-00173102": "the situation we had before", "hmSEVF30GjU-00647-00173103-00173431": "like this bloated framework that does", "hmSEVF30GjU-00648-00173432-00173743": "everything", "hmSEVF30GjU-00649-00173744-00173990": "in in case of browsers and browser", "hmSEVF30GjU-00650-00173991-00174151": "clouds", "hmSEVF30GjU-00651-00174152-00174302": "if you add this directly in the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00652-00174303-00174590": "framework it might be too tightly bound", "hmSEVF30GjU-00653-00174591-00174871": "to specific cloud vendors", "hmSEVF30GjU-00654-00174872-00175078": "so for every cloud vendor you might have", "hmSEVF30GjU-00655-00175079-00175247": "to use in the future", "hmSEVF30GjU-00656-00175248-00175478": "you have you would have to add more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00657-00175479-00175719": "methods", "hmSEVF30GjU-00658-00175720-00175911": "um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00659-00175912-00176271": "if you want to add functionality to the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00660-00176272-00176502": "framework especially if you're not one", "hmSEVF30GjU-00661-00176503-00176687": "of the core contributors to the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00662-00176688-00176854": "framework you need", "hmSEVF30GjU-00663-00176855-00177183": "deep architecture knowledge to do this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00664-00177184-00177431": "and that doesn't make sense to just add", "hmSEVF30GjU-00665-00177432-00177711": "a simple thing", "hmSEVF30GjU-00666-00177712-00177935": "and also every additional feature causes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00667-00177936-00178175": "new framework releases", "hmSEVF30GjU-00668-00178176-00178278": "which", "hmSEVF30GjU-00669-00178279-00178726": "is also not a good thing", "hmSEVF30GjU-00670-00178727-00179087": "so we decided to have a plugin api", "hmSEVF30GjU-00671-00179088-00179287": "with the requirements that writing", "hmSEVF30GjU-00672-00179288-00179526": "plugins should be very simple", "hmSEVF30GjU-00673-00179527-00179751": "they should be very small separate", "hmSEVF30GjU-00674-00179752-00179975": "projects", "hmSEVF30GjU-00675-00179976-00180278": "they should not require core framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00676-00180279-00180414": "changes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00677-00180415-00180695": "and they should also not influence", "hmSEVF30GjU-00678-00180696-00180959": "core functionality", "hmSEVF30GjU-00679-00180960-00181135": "which might happen if you directly", "hmSEVF30GjU-00680-00181136-00181407": "insert your code into the core framework", "hmSEVF30GjU-00681-00181408-00181959": "repository", "hmSEVF30GjU-00682-00181960-00182135": "and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00683-00182136-00182263": "plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00684-00182264-00182431": "should just implement", "hmSEVF30GjU-00685-00182432-00182575": "interfaces", "hmSEVF30GjU-00686-00182576-00182783": "that interest them", "hmSEVF30GjU-00687-00182784-00183007": "very very small interfaces i will show", "hmSEVF30GjU-00688-00183008-00183326": "you exactly how we did this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00689-00183327-00183535": "the framework should notify matching", "hmSEVF30GjU-00690-00183536-00183790": "plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00691-00183791-00184007": "each plugin should be able to have its", "hmSEVF30GjU-00692-00184008-00184351": "own set of system properties", "hmSEVF30GjU-00693-00184352-00184726": "and plugins should be activated as", "hmSEVF30GjU-00694-00184727-00185071": "needed so even if we have those plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00695-00185072-00185326": "in our", "hmSEVF30GjU-00696-00185327-00185631": "tests as dependencies we should still be", "hmSEVF30GjU-00697-00185632-00185926": "able to enable or disable them as we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00698-00185927-00186247": "want", "hmSEVF30GjU-00699-00186248-00186375": "so here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00700-00186376-00186607": "we found the service provider interface", "hmSEVF30GjU-00701-00186608-00186926": "in java spi", "hmSEVF30GjU-00702-00186927-00187207": "it is 22 years old it's available since", "hmSEVF30GjU-00703-00187208-00187463": "java 1.3", "hmSEVF30GjU-00704-00187464-00187814": "and it did exactly what we wanted", "hmSEVF30GjU-00705-00187815-00188087": "it consists of three parts a service", "hmSEVF30GjU-00706-00188088-00188302": "interface", "hmSEVF30GjU-00707-00188303-00188750": "so that is something that providers need", "hmSEVF30GjU-00708-00188751-00189102": "to implement so it's exactly our thing a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00709-00189103-00189319": "plugin should implement a specific", "hmSEVF30GjU-00710-00189320-00189623": "interface and that's it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00711-00189624-00189847": "then we need the provider registration", "hmSEVF30GjU-00712-00189848-00190014": "api", "hmSEVF30GjU-00713-00190015-00190135": "this is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00714-00190136-00190431": "a plug-in manager that keeps track of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00715-00190432-00190726": "what plugins are currently there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00716-00190727-00191038": "and the service access api", "hmSEVF30GjU-00717-00191039-00191175": "that means", "hmSEVF30GjU-00718-00191176-00191263": "we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00719-00191264-00191583": "communicate with the plugins and this is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00720-00191584-00191702": "not", "hmSEVF30GjU-00721-00191703-00191814": "um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00722-00191815-00192078": "too important in our case because this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00723-00192079-00192375": "is not something the users use but only", "hmSEVF30GjU-00724-00192376-00192695": "the framework itself", "hmSEVF30GjU-00725-00192696-00192935": "so this is what a basic plugin interface", "hmSEVF30GjU-00726-00192936-00193143": "looks like", "hmSEVF30GjU-00727-00193144-00193238": "it has", "hmSEVF30GjU-00728-00193239-00193463": "the method get plugin name", "hmSEVF30GjU-00729-00193464-00193623": "that's it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00730-00193624-00193902": "that is the plugin interface that all", "hmSEVF30GjU-00731-00193903-00194271": "other plugin interfaces extend", "hmSEVF30GjU-00732-00194272-00194550": "because we just wanted to have each", "hmSEVF30GjU-00733-00194551-00194719": "plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00734-00194720-00194975": "to provide a specific name", "hmSEVF30GjU-00735-00194976-00195143": "that would just make it easier for", "hmSEVF30GjU-00736-00195144-00195671": "logging and also for property handling", "hmSEVF30GjU-00737-00195672-00195943": "and this is the part that makes the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00738-00195944-00196454": "magic possible a marker file", "hmSEVF30GjU-00739-00196455-00196719": "like i said this is java specific there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00740-00196720-00196966": "might be", "hmSEVF30GjU-00741-00196967-00197254": "things like this in other languages but", "hmSEVF30GjU-00742-00197255-00197519": "i'm not aware of those", "hmSEVF30GjU-00743-00197520-00197838": "so what you can do here is to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00744-00197839-00198014": "add a file", "hmSEVF30GjU-00745-00198015-00198326": "to a plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00746-00198327-00198647": "that is residing in source java", "hmSEVF30GjU-00747-00198648-00198883": "resources meta in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00748-00198884-00199287": "services and then has the whole path and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00749-00199288-00199407": "class", "hmSEVF30GjU-00750-00199408-00199663": "com torago plugin extension plugin which", "hmSEVF30GjU-00751-00199664-00199943": "is our main plugin interface", "hmSEVF30GjU-00752-00199944-00200143": "and inside this file", "hmSEVF30GjU-00753-00200144-00200326": "you have", "hmSEVF30GjU-00754-00200327-00200487": "the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00755-00200488-00200623": "class", "hmSEVF30GjU-00756-00200624-00201023": "um of your plugin the main class of your", "hmSEVF30GjU-00757-00201024-00201302": "plugin like in this case custom cloud", "hmSEVF30GjU-00758-00201303-00201495": "plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00759-00201496-00201678": "i'll show you on the next slide how this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00760-00201679-00201863": "works", "hmSEVF30GjU-00761-00201864-00202111": "and this is used by the service provider", "hmSEVF30GjU-00762-00202112-00202295": "to scan", "hmSEVF30GjU-00763-00202296-00202478": "matching plugins and find", "hmSEVF30GjU-00764-00202479-00202783": "implementations", "hmSEVF30GjU-00765-00202784-00202935": "this is the plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00766-00202936-00203150": "loader class that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00767-00203151-00203431": "just checks what plugins are currently", "hmSEVF30GjU-00768-00203432-00203623": "active", "hmSEVF30GjU-00769-00203624-00203831": "and this is the part that makes it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00770-00203832-00204183": "happen", "hmSEVF30GjU-00771-00204184-00204487": "here the service loader which is a part", "hmSEVF30GjU-00772-00204488-00204743": "of java util", "hmSEVF30GjU-00773-00204744-00204975": "so it's built into java the thing that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00774-00204976-00205038": "is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00775-00205039-00205310": "has been there for 22 years the service", "hmSEVF30GjU-00776-00205311-00205582": "loader loads", "hmSEVF30GjU-00777-00205583-00205910": "all the implementations of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00778-00205911-00206046": "dot plugin.class", "hmSEVF30GjU-00779-00206048-00206334": "that means all the classes that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00780-00206335-00206590": "implement the plugin interface", "hmSEVF30GjU-00781-00206591-00206831": "and then it has a list", "hmSEVF30GjU-00782-00206832-00207110": "of classes that's it that is the whole", "hmSEVF30GjU-00783-00207111-00207679": "thing that makes it work", "hmSEVF30GjU-00784-00207680-00207886": "and this is one of those plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00785-00207887-00208182": "interfaces i talked about", "hmSEVF30GjU-00786-00208183-00208423": "this is an interface that's called web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00787-00208423-00208719": "driver created aware", "hmSEVF30GjU-00788-00208719-00208975": "that extends plug-in so it is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00789-00208976-00209246": "discoverable", "hmSEVF30GjU-00790-00209248-00209414": "like i showed", "hmSEVF30GjU-00791-00209415-00209686": "and this passes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00792-00209687-00209958": "a web driver instance of the current web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00793-00209959-00210246": "driver to all interested plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00794-00210248-00210510": "and we use this to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00795-00210511-00210839": "take screenshots and also retrieve web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00796-00210840-00211167": "driver logs", "hmSEVF30GjU-00797-00211167-00211406": "here it is that's the only method handle", "hmSEVF30GjU-00798-00211407-00211646": "webdriver created", "hmSEVF30GjU-00799-00211648-00212215": "and it accepts the selenium webdriver", "hmSEVF30GjU-00800-00212216-00212351": "and here is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00801-00212352-00212471": "what", "hmSEVF30GjU-00802-00212471-00212703": "the framework does on the left side and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00803-00212704-00213063": "what the plugin does on the right side", "hmSEVF30GjU-00804-00213064-00213142": "so", "hmSEVF30GjU-00805-00213144-00213423": "in this case the framework creates a web", "hmSEVF30GjU-00806-00213423-00213958": "driver", "hmSEVF30GjU-00807-00213959-00214103": "and then", "hmSEVF30GjU-00808-00214104-00214327": "because this plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00809-00214328-00214582": "has the web driver created aware", "hmSEVF30GjU-00810-00214583-00214767": "interface", "hmSEVF30GjU-00811-00214767-00215006": "it has to implement the handle webdriver", "hmSEVF30GjU-00812-00215007-00215206": "created method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00813-00215207-00215767": "that accepts a web driver", "hmSEVF30GjU-00814-00215767-00215975": "and there's another interface that the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00815-00215976-00216279": "plugin implements called cucumber after", "hmSEVF30GjU-00816-00216280-00216679": "step hook aware that is triggered when", "hmSEVF30GjU-00817-00216680-00217063": "a test step is finished", "hmSEVF30GjU-00818-00217064-00217375": "and in this case in this demo plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00819-00217376-00217710": "it just takes a screenshot and stores it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00820-00217711-00217815": "somewhere", "hmSEVF30GjU-00821-00217816-00218094": "and you see um on the bottom right it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00822-00218096-00218446": "uses the web driver that was passed", "hmSEVF30GjU-00823-00218448-00218831": "in the handle webdriver created method", "hmSEVF30GjU-00824-00218832-00219119": "oh i'm sorry", "hmSEVF30GjU-00825-00219121-00219391": "[Music]", "hmSEVF30GjU-00826-00219392-00219582": "there we go", "hmSEVF30GjU-00827-00219583-00219815": "those are all the plugin interfaces we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00828-00219816-00220071": "currently have and there might be more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00829-00220071-00220334": "in the future but there are some that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00830-00220335-00220575": "are for web driver handling that are", "hmSEVF30GjU-00831-00220576-00220703": "some that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00832-00220704-00220998": "can react to certain properties to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00833-00221000-00221327": "certain cucumber events", "hmSEVF30GjU-00834-00221328-00221734": "a lot of things", "hmSEVF30GjU-00835-00221735-00221991": "so what happened through this new", "hmSEVF30GjU-00836-00221992-00222119": "mechanism", "hmSEVF30GjU-00837-00222119-00222455": "is all of this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00838-00222456-00222615": "turned to this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00839-00222616-00222839": "so we still have", "hmSEVF30GjU-00840-00222840-00223094": "a very straight line the white", "hmSEVF30GjU-00841-00223096-00223255": "boxes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00842-00223256-00223534": "but here the first step is the plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00843-00223535-00223887": "discovery that i showed", "hmSEVF30GjU-00844-00223888-00224206": "that registers the plugins in the plugin", "hmSEVF30GjU-00845-00224207-00224446": "manager so the plugin manager always", "hmSEVF30GjU-00846-00224448-00224782": "knows all the active plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00847-00224783-00225134": "and everything the framework does", "hmSEVF30GjU-00848-00225135-00225303": "um", "hmSEVF30GjU-00849-00225304-00225487": "it can", "hmSEVF30GjU-00850-00225488-00225758": "tell the plugin manager hello please", "hmSEVF30GjU-00851-00225759-00226046": "notify all the web driver interested", "hmSEVF30GjU-00852-00226048-00226191": "plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00853-00226192-00226494": "or notify all the plugins that want to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00854-00226496-00226719": "know when the web driver is destroyed or", "hmSEVF30GjU-00855-00226719-00226998": "when the properties are available and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00856-00227000-00227255": "then the plugin manager communicates", "hmSEVF30GjU-00857-00227256-00227582": "with the magic plugins", "hmSEVF30GjU-00858-00227583-00227791": "and this is how we can", "hmSEVF30GjU-00859-00227792-00227927": "inject", "hmSEVF30GjU-00860-00227928-00228039": "all", "hmSEVF30GjU-00861-00228040-00228655": "kinds of functionality here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00862-00228656-00228975": "um i'm i'm aware this was a lot and this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00863-00228976-00229279": "is rather complex", "hmSEVF30GjU-00864-00229280-00229455": "so let's give me", "hmSEVF30GjU-00865-00229456-00229910": "let's give you some last thoughts here", "hmSEVF30GjU-00866-00229911-00230110": "some of you might ask why didn't you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00867-00230111-00230575": "make a commit to selenium itself", "hmSEVF30GjU-00868-00230576-00230823": "and this is because", "hmSEVF30GjU-00869-00230823-00231134": "refining elements is out of scope of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00870-00231135-00231375": "selenium like i said it's a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00871-00231376-00231527": "remote control", "hmSEVF30GjU-00872-00231528-00231694": "for browsers", "hmSEVF30GjU-00873-00231696-00231967": "nothing more nothing less", "hmSEVF30GjU-00874-00231967-00232287": "so this refining and custom web element", "hmSEVF30GjU-00875-00232288-00232534": "stuff this is way", "hmSEVF30GjU-00876-00232535-00232710": "out of scope", "hmSEVF30GjU-00877-00232711-00233055": "and it's very specific to us", "hmSEVF30GjU-00878-00233056-00233703": "it might not be something you need", "hmSEVF30GjU-00879-00233704-00233806": "there", "hmSEVF30GjU-00880-00233807-00234006": "the selenium web page actually says it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00881-00234007-00234734": "selenium automates browsers that's it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00882-00234735-00234967": "first the problem then the tool that is", "hmSEVF30GjU-00883-00234967-00235206": "something that i had to learn the hard", "hmSEVF30GjU-00884-00235207-00235310": "way", "hmSEVF30GjU-00885-00235311-00235615": "it is absolutely crucial you understand", "hmSEVF30GjU-00886-00235616-00235846": "the problem fully first", "hmSEVF30GjU-00887-00235848-00235958": "before", "hmSEVF30GjU-00888-00235959-00236310": "jumping on any tools or any solutions", "hmSEVF30GjU-00889-00236311-00236519": "it's especially bad if you have a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00890-00236519-00236791": "solution already before", "hmSEVF30GjU-00891-00236792-00237055": "you know the problem", "hmSEVF30GjU-00892-00237056-00237279": "and you have to evaluate the tools in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00893-00237280-00237479": "regard to your problem and you have to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00894-00237480-00237758": "also re-evaluate the tools regularly", "hmSEVF30GjU-00895-00237759-00237982": "because requirements might change and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00896-00237983-00238142": "tools might change and there might be", "hmSEVF30GjU-00897-00238144-00238463": "better tools available", "hmSEVF30GjU-00898-00238464-00238767": "know your tools", "hmSEVF30GjU-00899-00238767-00239031": "before switching to other tools", "hmSEVF30GjU-00900-00239032-00239255": "you should always check if your current", "hmSEVF30GjU-00901-00239256-00239527": "one is able to solve your problem as", "hmSEVF30GjU-00902-00239528-00239767": "well and if it's", "hmSEVF30GjU-00903-00239767-00240015": "less effort to do so", "hmSEVF30GjU-00904-00240016-00240246": "and it can be very valuable to dig", "hmSEVF30GjU-00905-00240248-00240510": "deeper like we did with the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00906-00240511-00240894": "whole page object handling and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00907-00240896-00241151": "and the selenium internals that solves", "hmSEVF30GjU-00908-00241152-00241446": "exactly our problems", "hmSEVF30GjU-00909-00241448-00241815": "also don't dismiss the old solutions", "hmSEVF30GjU-00910-00241816-00242030": "uh one very", "hmSEVF30GjU-00911-00242031-00242310": "important point for me is decouple", "hmSEVF30GjU-00912-00242311-00242598": "progress from technology you can make a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00913-00242600-00242846": "lot of progress without switching to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00914-00242848-00243151": "newer technologies", "hmSEVF30GjU-00915-00243152-00243503": "because all tools oftentimes mean proven", "hmSEVF30GjU-00916-00243504-00243646": "tools", "hmSEVF30GjU-00917-00243648-00243894": "and bug free tools", "hmSEVF30GjU-00918-00243896-00244134": "and if you have older tools", "hmSEVF30GjU-00919-00244135-00244479": "you have a better chance that more of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00920-00244480-00244775": "your colleagues know about them", "hmSEVF30GjU-00921-00244776-00244919": "instead of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00922-00244919-00245127": "jumping on a new tool that", "hmSEVF30GjU-00923-00245128-00245319": "might", "hmSEVF30GjU-00924-00245319-00245542": "then it might be only you who knows", "hmSEVF30GjU-00925-00245544-00245791": "about it and that creates one of those", "hmSEVF30GjU-00926-00245792-00246071": "bus factors or like one of my colleagues", "hmSEVF30GjU-00927-00246071-00246439": "likes to call it tractor factors", "hmSEVF30GjU-00928-00246440-00246703": "like when you know about a new tool and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00929-00246704-00246958": "you get run over by a tractor", "hmSEVF30GjU-00930-00246959-00247398": "there's no one else that can maintain it", "hmSEVF30GjU-00931-00247400-00247655": "and reinventing the wheel it's often", "hmSEVF30GjU-00932-00247656-00247791": "said it's bad", "hmSEVF30GjU-00933-00247792-00248055": "but i say it's absolutely", "hmSEVF30GjU-00934-00248056-00248175": "crucial", "hmSEVF30GjU-00935-00248176-00248423": "because not all wheels perform this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00936-00248423-00248639": "the same they have to comply", "hmSEVF30GjU-00937-00248640-00248846": "with the terrain still with your", "hmSEVF30GjU-00938-00248848-00249175": "specific problem and if you recreate a", "hmSEVF30GjU-00939-00249176-00249671": "wheel you learn a lot about wheels", "hmSEVF30GjU-00940-00249671-00249991": "and with this i want to thank you", "hmSEVF30GjU-00941-00249992-00250071": "hope", "hmSEVF30GjU-00942-00250071-00250367": "uh them there was something in there of", "hmSEVF30GjU-00943-00250367-00250615": "value and uh", "hmSEVF30GjU-00944-00250616-00251030": "ready for any question you might have", "hmSEVF30GjU-00945-00251031-00251206": "uh thank you benjamin that was an", "hmSEVF30GjU-00946-00251207-00251367": "insightful session", "hmSEVF30GjU-00947-00251367-00251639": "uh so we have only one question from", "hmSEVF30GjU-00948-00251640-00251806": "parker who says", "hmSEVF30GjU-00949-00251807-00252134": "why css is stored and string and finally", "hmSEVF30GjU-00950-00252135-00252351": "and pass to at the rate fine by in later", "hmSEVF30GjU-00951-00252352-00252879": "steps any reason behind this approach", "hmSEVF30GjU-00952-00252880-00253103": "um can you can you say that again i", "hmSEVF30GjU-00953-00253104-00253303": "didn't quite get this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00954-00253304-00253446": "okay", "hmSEVF30GjU-00955-00253448-00253775": "asks why css is stored in string and", "hmSEVF30GjU-00956-00253776-00254023": "pass to at the rate find by in later", "hmSEVF30GjU-00957-00254023-00254263": "steps is there any reason behind this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00958-00254264-00254398": "approach", "hmSEVF30GjU-00959-00254400-00254639": "yes yes there is a reason behind this", "hmSEVF30GjU-00960-00254640-00254742": "approach", "hmSEVF30GjU-00961-00254744-00255063": "this was just a sample code but in our", "hmSEVF30GjU-00962-00255064-00255351": "real tests we have a lot", "hmSEVF30GjU-00963-00255352-00255471": "more", "hmSEVF30GjU-00964-00255471-00255742": "locators a lot more selectors that we", "hmSEVF30GjU-00965-00255744-00255894": "have to work with", "hmSEVF30GjU-00966-00255896-00256191": "so instead of having those all over the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00967-00256192-00256279": "code", "hmSEVF30GjU-00968-00256280-00256471": "we wanted to have them in", "hmSEVF30GjU-00969-00256471-00256775": "a central place which is the top of our", "hmSEVF30GjU-00970-00256776-00257023": "classes so we can", "hmSEVF30GjU-00971-00257023-00257198": "make changes", "hmSEVF30GjU-00972-00257200-00257406": "simply by looking at the top of the", "hmSEVF30GjU-00973-00257407-00257710": "class and then changing the string", "hmSEVF30GjU-00974-00257711-00257910": "instead of going through the whole code", "hmSEVF30GjU-00975-00257911-00258175": "and and then checking where do you use", "hmSEVF30GjU-00976-00258176-00258406": "this and where is it defined", "hmSEVF30GjU-00977-00258407-00258767": "so everybody of us who work", "hmSEVF30GjU-00978-00258767-00258958": "with the test code", "hmSEVF30GjU-00979-00258959-00259175": "they all know where to find those", "hmSEVF30GjU-00980-00259176-00259519": "strings it's always the top of the file", "hmSEVF30GjU-00981-00259519-00260105": "it's just convenient", "hmSEVF30GjU-00982-00260106-00260263": "[Music]", "hmSEVF30GjU-00983-00260264-00260527": "we don't have any other questions but if", "hmSEVF30GjU-00984-00260528-00260751": "you ha if the activities have any other", "hmSEVF30GjU-00985-00260752-00260975": "questions you can post it in the chat or", "hmSEVF30GjU-00986-00260976-00261167": "the question answers tab", "hmSEVF30GjU-00987-00261167-00261439": "uh i think there's another question", "hmSEVF30GjU-00988-00261440-00261687": "by karthik who says how can we learn", "hmSEVF30GjU-00989-00261688-00262151": "more about building better architectures", "hmSEVF30GjU-00990-00262152-00262495": "that is a very good question", "hmSEVF30GjU-00991-00262496-00262879": "um and i can tell you please", "hmSEVF30GjU-00992-00262880-00262967": "read", "hmSEVF30GjU-00993-00262968-00263382": "about design patterns please read about", "hmSEVF30GjU-00994-00263383-00263575": "code smells", "hmSEVF30GjU-00995-00263576-00263791": "and just", "hmSEVF30GjU-00996-00263792-00264047": "try to gather resources", "hmSEVF30GjU-00997-00264048-00264334": "that are typically aimed at developers", "hmSEVF30GjU-00998-00264335-00264415": "to", "hmSEVF30GjU-00999-00264416-00264630": "make your code and your architecture", "hmSEVF30GjU-01000-00264631-00264975": "better because that is one of my things", "hmSEVF30GjU-01001-00264976-00265343": "one of my missions really to promote", "hmSEVF30GjU-01002-00265344-00265567": "better code in testing", "hmSEVF30GjU-01003-00265568-00265887": "because i see a lot of bad examples", "hmSEVF30GjU-01004-00265888-00266230": "especially on platforms like linkedin", "hmSEVF30GjU-01005-00266231-00266399": "people who", "hmSEVF30GjU-01006-00266400-00266606": "say i wrote this new framework and if", "hmSEVF30GjU-01007-00266607-00266847": "you look at the code it's just a bunch", "hmSEVF30GjU-01008-00266848-00267127": "of libraries thrown together without any", "hmSEVF30GjU-01009-00267128-00267279": "thought", "hmSEVF30GjU-01010-00267280-00267358": "so", "hmSEVF30GjU-01011-00267359-00267534": "yeah", "hmSEVF30GjU-01012-00267535-00267703": "you should", "hmSEVF30GjU-01013-00267704-00267910": "if you want to", "hmSEVF30GjU-01014-00267911-00268119": "improve your architecture you should", "hmSEVF30GjU-01015-00268120-00268358": "definitely check out resources for", "hmSEVF30GjU-01016-00268359-00268767": "developers", "hmSEVF30GjU-01017-00268768-00269351": "[Music]", "hmSEVF30GjU-01018-00269352-00269559": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "hmc80t-mGPy", "text": {"hmc80t-mGPy-00000-00000008-00000199": "how much does a patent cost", "hmc80t-mGPy-00001-00000200-00000423": "let's go over this slide and cover the", "hmc80t-mGPy-00002-00000424-00000630": "cost of each step the first step is a", "hmc80t-mGPy-00003-00000631-00000854": "patent search a reliable patent search", "hmc80t-mGPy-00004-00000855-00000999": "will cost you about fifteen hundred", "hmc80t-mGPy-00005-00001000-00001223": "dollars to two thousand dollars", "hmc80t-mGPy-00006-00001224-00001399": "the patent search determines if your", "hmc80t-mGPy-00007-00001400-00001630": "invention is new or if someone else has", "hmc80t-mGPy-00008-00001632-00001871": "already thought of your idea next you", "hmc80t-mGPy-00009-00001872-00002030": "can file a provisional patent", "hmc80t-mGPy-00010-00002032-00002223": "application or a non-provisional", "hmc80t-mGPy-00011-00002224-00002487": "application the cost of a provisional", "hmc80t-mGPy-00012-00002488-00002807": "utility patent application or ppa will", "hmc80t-mGPy-00013-00002808-00002910": "be about", "hmc80t-mGPy-00014-00002911-00003118": "five hundred dollars to thirteen", "hmc80t-mGPy-00015-00003119-00003286": "thousand five hundred dollars for a", "hmc80t-mGPy-00016-00003288-00003519": "well-written provisional application", "hmc80t-mGPy-00017-00003520-00003686": "filing the provisional patent", "hmc80t-mGPy-00018-00003688-00003951": "application or ppa establishes patent", "hmc80t-mGPy-00019-00003952-00004231": "pendency for your invention you have 12", "hmc80t-mGPy-00020-00004232-00004463": "months to market your idea the cost to", "hmc80t-mGPy-00021-00004464-00004615": "upgrade the provisional to a", "hmc80t-mGPy-00022-00004616-00004831": "non-provisional is about fifteen hundred", "hmc80t-mGPy-00023-00004832-00005022": "dollars i'm assuming that your", "hmc80t-mGPy-00024-00005023-00005270": "provisional was thoroughly prepared", "hmc80t-mGPy-00025-00005271-00005479": "the fifteen hundred dollars covers the", "hmc80t-mGPy-00026-00005480-00005815": "uspto filing fee the drying cost and the", "hmc80t-mGPy-00027-00005816-00006063": "attorney fee alternatively", "hmc80t-mGPy-00028-00006064-00006318": "the cost of the non-provisional patent", "hmc80t-mGPy-00029-00006319-00006527": "application is about eight thousand", "hmc80t-mGPy-00030-00006528-00006751": "dollars to fifteen thousand dollars", "hmc80t-mGPy-00031-00006752-00006927": "after the patent office works through", "hmc80t-mGPy-00032-00006928-00007191": "its backlog the examiner will render an", "hmc80t-mGPy-00033-00007192-00007319": "office action", "hmc80t-mGPy-00034-00007320-00007534": "you have entered the examination stage", "hmc80t-mGPy-00035-00007536-00007798": "of the patent process you should budget", "hmc80t-mGPy-00036-00007800-00007998": "about five thousand to ten thousand", "hmc80t-mGPy-00037-00008000-00008263": "dollars for the examination stage", "hmc80t-mGPy-00038-00008264-00008478": "upon allowance you have to pay an issue", "hmc80t-mGPy-00039-00008479-00008742": "fee which is one thousand dollars the", "hmc80t-mGPy-00040-00008743-00008927": "total cost to get a patent would be", "hmc80t-mGPy-00041-00008928-00009223": "around fifteen thousand five hundred to", "hmc80t-mGPy-00042-00009224-00009439": "twenty eight thousand dollars if you", "hmc80t-mGPy-00043-00009440-00009606": "think a patent is expensive you can", "hmc80t-mGPy-00044-00009607-00009814": "watch my other video on how to afford a", "hmc80t-mGPy-00045-00009815-00009919": "patent", "hmc80t-mGPy-00046-00009920-00010095": "at the end of the pattern process there", "hmc80t-mGPy-00047-00010096-00010255": "is no guarantee that you would get a", "hmc80t-mGPy-00048-00010256-00010542": "patent but there are ways to increase", "hmc80t-mGPy-00049-00010543-00010856": "its likelihood"}}, {"audio_id": "hn2BI0my0CQ", "text": {"hn2BI0my0CQ-00000-00000156-00000257": "foreign", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00001-00000258-00001270": "collections", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00002-00001271-00001823": "we have a Bulbasaur", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00003-00001823-00002141": "a square oh", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00004-00002142-00002423": "finally a Charmander", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00005-00002424-00002537": "so", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00006-00002538-00002734": "about people", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00007-00002735-00003454": "go back to the beginning with Charmander", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00008-00003455-00003640": "Square to go back to the beginning with", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00009-00003642-00003925": "Squirtle", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00010-00003926-00004247": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00011-00004248-00004595": "and go back to the beginning with Bob so", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00012-00004596-00004829": "without further Ado let's get into them", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00013-00004830-00005009": "all right so let's start things off with", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00014-00005010-00005165": "the Bulbasaur guys", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00015-00005166-00005356": "here is your codes for the Pokemon Go", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00016-00005357-00005579": "Mobile app here's the Bulbasaur promo", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00017-00005580-00006299": "card", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00018-00006300-00006833": "this is the book so pin", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00019-00006834-00007055": "quite a nice spin there", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00020-00007056-00007195": "foreign", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00021-00007195-00007609": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00022-00007609-00008183": "guys Pokemon go I think I believe I need", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00023-00008184-00008446": "five more cards", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00024-00008447-00008723": "need three more rainbow rares", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00025-00008724-00008981": "and two more gold cards", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00026-00008982-00009257": "and then I have the complete Master set", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00027-00009258-00009478": "I've been waiting for this which", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00028-00009479-00009646": "by the time you see this video ever has", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00029-00009647-00009983": "released", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00030-00009984-00010228": "or should be releasing very soon", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00031-00010229-00010559": "because he was played Dragon idea is a", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00032-00010560-00011343": "first pack nice", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00033-00011344-00011633": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00034-00011634-00011795": "yeah these were supposed to release I", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00035-00011796-00012071": "believe mid August", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00036-00012072-00012364": "and then they got delayed to", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00037-00012365-00012509": "September", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00038-00012510-00012646": "I think you can have several", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00039-00012647-00012851": "mid-september and then I got delayed", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00040-00012852-00013211": "again so now the releasing I believe", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00041-00013212-00013385": "after the first or the second week of", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00042-00013386-00013715": "October", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00043-00013716-00013925": "um that's in retail stores like um", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00044-00013926-00014105": "online retail stores", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00045-00014106-00014429": "um I got these early through the Pokemon", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00046-00014430-00014711": "Center online so if you live in an area", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00047-00014712-00014861": "or country where the Pokemon Center", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00048-00014862-00015125": "Online", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00049-00015126-00015538": "is available you can get them on there", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00050-00015540-00015647": "I mean", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00051-00015647-00015808": "it's actually cheaper as one of Pokemon", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00052-00015809-00015965": "Center Online", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00053-00015966-00016300": "bye a couple of pounds or depending on", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00054-00016301-00016408": "where you live about it could be a", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00055-00016409-00016715": "couple of dollars or whatever it is", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00056-00016716-00016961": "oh nice radiant Blaster is not too bad", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00057-00016962-00017382": "of a pool and a Snorlax", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00058-00017383-00018083": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00059-00018084-00018371": "moving on we have a square tool", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00060-00018372-00018575": "here's your codes", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00061-00018576-00018783": "yes well one more card", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00062-00018784-00019325": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00063-00019326-00019607": "here with your squirrel pin badge these", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00064-00019608-00019769": "pin badges are really nice I can't I", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00065-00019770-00020021": "need to get a cork board and put it in", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00066-00020022-00020230": "the space on my all of my pin badges all", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00067-00020231-00020458": "right over so it wasn't too bad a Vienna", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00068-00020459-00020741": "radiant and three packs not too bad I", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00069-00020742-00021047": "guess not too bad", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00070-00021048-00021299": "as in Pokemon Gold for some reason pool", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00071-00021300-00021569": "rates are just disgusting like getting", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00072-00021570-00021743": "these kind of things where you only get", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00073-00021744-00021917": "three packs", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00074-00021918-00022183": "it's tough man it's tough the always", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00075-00022184-00022450": "looks terrible so you might not get", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00076-00022451-00022697": "nothing and if your luck is like mine", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00077-00022698-00022871": "with these kind of collection boxes like", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00078-00022872-00023117": "anything", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00079-00023118-00023543": "I would say blow 18 packs anything below", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00080-00023544-00023717": "18 packs", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00081-00023718-00023921": "chances are you're only gonna get", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00082-00023922-00024280": "a V at best which in my case looking at", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00083-00024281-00024533": "it now probably is going to be the case", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00084-00024534-00024803": "see will I put anything better than a v", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00085-00024804-00024983": "could I even put any of the cards I need", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00086-00024984-00025283": "for the master settings but I doubt it", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00087-00025284-00025781": "not not with nine bucks and nine packs", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00088-00025782-00026027": "chances of putting all I need a secret", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00089-00026027-00026489": "rares two Golds three rainbows", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00090-00026489-00026674": "I thought was gonna happen I thought it", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00091-00026675-00026808": "was gonna happen", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00092-00026810-00027070": "Charmeleon I mean", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00093-00027072-00027383": "without whatever pull it on camera", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00094-00027383-00027611": "not gonna be pulling it again all right", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00095-00027612-00027724": "Charmander", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00096-00027725-00027964": "there's your codes", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00097-00027966-00028685": "here's your charm and the promo", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00098-00028686-00028840": "code God", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00099-00028841-00029273": "Charmander pin badge", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00100-00029274-00029524": "Bulbasaur was a DOT", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00101-00029525-00029908": "no hits from that at all so there's", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00102-00029910-00030112": "one box which if you bought that", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00103-00030113-00030502": "randomly would have been a god", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00104-00030504-00030695": "um you always are saying the or me to", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00105-00030695-00030845": "hold that off camera probably never", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00106-00030845-00031018": "gonna put it on camera", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00107-00031019-00031133": "I mean", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00108-00031133-00031324": "the only thing left to open are the", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00109-00031325-00031601": "Pokeball tins", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00110-00031602-00031846": "and Dragon Knight", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00111-00031847-00032146": "Premium deck order yeah at least this", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00112-00032147-00032401": "one has a v", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00113-00032402-00033017": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00114-00033018-00033190": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00115-00033191-00033359": "so you have a few packs left from those", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00116-00033360-00033611": "and then that's it I'll be done", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00117-00033612-00033737": "um", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00118-00033738-00033911": "probably gonna buy", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00119-00033912-00034096": "singles for the rest of it if I don't", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00120-00034097-00034252": "pull any of those ones that I need from", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00121-00034253-00034415": "the rest of the remaining", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00122-00034416-00034631": "products to release", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00123-00034632-00034931": "then I'll just buy the singles", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00124-00034932-00035207": "and then show you the monster set", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00125-00035208-00035483": "but yeah so close guys so close", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00126-00035484-00035668": "literally I mean I saw this coming with", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00127-00035669-00035927": "these pin badge collection boxes", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00128-00035928-00036112": "anything with these", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00129-00036113-00036352": "three to four packs I never got anything", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00130-00036353-00036562": "special from them like we haven't even", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00131-00036563-00036718": "seen a fuller we haven't seen a secret", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00132-00036719-00036839": "rare", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00133-00036840-00037168": "nothing I mean a radiant is okay I guess", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00134-00037169-00037462": "but", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00135-00037463-00037679": "this in terms of a profit wise as well", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00136-00037680-00038171": "money stance not much", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00137-00038172-00038387": "and I spoke to you soon I mean I have it", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00138-00038388-00038609": "ready or it's", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00139-00038610-00038777": "nonetheless a rainbow we did pull a", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00140-00038778-00038999": "rainbow at least in this video my secret", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00141-00039000-00039227": "rare look", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00142-00039228-00039412": "it's kind of been quite nice lately now", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00143-00039413-00039580": "that I think about it", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00144-00039581-00039899": "wow okay so Candela secret rare which I", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00145-00039900-00040133": "don't need but before I mean not too bad", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00146-00040134-00040324": "guys not too bad we've got a Bulbasaur", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00147-00040325-00040546": "promo", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00148-00040547-00040745": "School promo", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00149-00040746-00040949": "trauma diploma", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00150-00040950-00041149": "Dragonite me", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00151-00041150-00041357": "Concordia V", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00152-00041358-00041651": "radiant Blastoise and a secret break", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00153-00041652-00041731": "Candela", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00154-00041732-00041951": "[Music]", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00155-00041952-00042095": "not too bad", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00156-00042096-00042257": "nothing that I needed for the master set", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00157-00042258-00042533": "but not too bad in terms of pose", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00158-00042534-00042743": "but yeah guys that was the Pokemon Gold", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00159-00042744-00043049": "Star pin collection boxes if you enjoyed", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00160-00043050-00043162": "this video and you stop putting me to", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00161-00043163-00043252": "the end I'd appreciate if you could", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00162-00043253-00043415": "leave a like subscribe turn", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00163-00043416-00043649": "notifications on for more and I'll see", "hn2BI0my0CQ-00164-00043650-00043916": "you on the next one"}}, {"audio_id": "hn8pw-wO3py", "text": {"hn8pw-wO3py-00000-00000128-00000503": "will liz trust do a good job", "hn8pw-wO3py-00001-00000504-00000599": "well", "hn8pw-wO3py-00002-00000600-00000854": "obviously it's been a momentous week for", "hn8pw-wO3py-00003-00000855-00001079": "us here we have a new king our queen", "hn8pw-wO3py-00004-00001080-00001366": "having died yesterday only two days", "hn8pw-wO3py-00005-00001367-00001630": "after liz trust became prime minister", "hn8pw-wO3py-00006-00001632-00001871": "after having beaten rishi sunak in an", "hn8pw-wO3py-00007-00001872-00002191": "election by tory party members", "hn8pw-wO3py-00008-00002192-00002407": "the various debates and meetings", "hn8pw-wO3py-00009-00002408-00002631": "accompanying the election contest have", "hn8pw-wO3py-00010-00002632-00002958": "given us some inkling of what what she's", "hn8pw-wO3py-00011-00002959-00003158": "like what she might be like as a prime", "hn8pw-wO3py-00012-00003159-00003263": "minister", "hn8pw-wO3py-00013-00003264-00003495": "and the likelihood of her doing a good", "hn8pw-wO3py-00014-00003496-00003599": "job", "hn8pw-wO3py-00015-00003600-00003806": "the challenges look a", "hn8pw-wO3py-00016-00003807-00004070": "failing economy a nearby war the", "hn8pw-wO3py-00017-00004071-00004383": "aftermath of an unprecedented pandemic", "hn8pw-wO3py-00018-00004384-00004591": "are clearly enormous challenges for", "hn8pw-wO3py-00019-00004592-00004719": "anyone", "hn8pw-wO3py-00020-00004720-00004815": "so", "hn8pw-wO3py-00021-00004816-00005095": "is she up to the job well some are", "hn8pw-wO3py-00022-00005096-00005375": "doubtful and others are optimistic so", "hn8pw-wO3py-00023-00005376-00005663": "let's take a look at both views", "hn8pw-wO3py-00024-00005664-00005902": "first of all those who say yes she is up", "hn8pw-wO3py-00025-00005903-00005991": "to it", "hn8pw-wO3py-00026-00005992-00006199": "uh well she's got a good education uh", "hn8pw-wO3py-00027-00006200-00006367": "she's a graduate of merton college", "hn8pw-wO3py-00028-00006368-00006670": "oxford she thrived in a substantial", "hn8pw-wO3py-00029-00006672-00006967": "substantial private sector job which is", "hn8pw-wO3py-00030-00006968-00007087": "a useful", "hn8pw-wO3py-00031-00007088-00007310": "real world experience for any elected", "hn8pw-wO3py-00032-00007311-00007487": "politician more of them should have it i", "hn8pw-wO3py-00033-00007488-00007614": "think", "hn8pw-wO3py-00034-00007615-00007767": "she has considerable experience of", "hn8pw-wO3py-00035-00007768-00008063": "government she's had six ministerial", "hn8pw-wO3py-00036-00008064-00008239": "jobs under three different prime", "hn8pw-wO3py-00037-00008240-00008591": "ministers including foreign secretaries", "hn8pw-wO3py-00038-00008592-00008831": "she became the first female lord", "hn8pw-wO3py-00039-00008832-00009142": "chancellor that's pretty impressive", "hn8pw-wO3py-00040-00009143-00009463": "she beat rishi sunak in the leadership", "hn8pw-wO3py-00041-00009464-00009703": "elections a very", "hn8pw-wO3py-00042-00009704-00009895": "talented candidate in the several", "hn8pw-wO3py-00043-00009896-00010135": "televised debates she presented herself", "hn8pw-wO3py-00044-00010136-00010399": "as someone with plans ideas and a game", "hn8pw-wO3py-00045-00010400-00010655": "plan for the overwhelming challenges", "hn8pw-wO3py-00046-00010656-00010855": "that we face as a nation", "hn8pw-wO3py-00047-00010856-00011127": "it'll be tough but she'll do a as good a", "hn8pw-wO3py-00048-00011128-00011446": "job as anybody could", "hn8pw-wO3py-00049-00011447-00011742": "well what about those who say no", "hn8pw-wO3py-00050-00011743-00011974": "she's probably not suited she won't do a", "hn8pw-wO3py-00051-00011975-00012183": "good job", "hn8pw-wO3py-00052-00012184-00012351": "well just to begin with she's in an", "hn8pw-wO3py-00053-00012352-00012646": "impossibly uh difficult situation", "hn8pw-wO3py-00054-00012647-00012846": "not only is there a frightening war", "hn8pw-wO3py-00055-00012847-00013063": "going on not too many miles to the east", "hn8pw-wO3py-00056-00013063-00013447": "in the aftermath of a crippling pandemic", "hn8pw-wO3py-00057-00013447-00013671": "but the outlook for the nation's economy", "hn8pw-wO3py-00058-00013672-00013966": "is as bad as it is as it has been in", "hn8pw-wO3py-00059-00013968-00014158": "recent years it'll be very difficult to", "hn8pw-wO3py-00060-00014159-00014415": "spot these problems and to do so in a", "hn8pw-wO3py-00061-00014416-00014638": "way that will impress anybody", "hn8pw-wO3py-00062-00014640-00014943": "uh perhaps impossibly difficult", "hn8pw-wO3py-00063-00014944-00015335": "uh she is seen in some quarters as a", "hn8pw-wO3py-00064-00015336-00015630": "creature of the far right even a fascist", "hn8pw-wO3py-00065-00015631-00015750": "to some", "hn8pw-wO3py-00066-00015751-00016038": "and a view like that is clearly out of", "hn8pw-wO3py-00067-00016040-00016207": "step with the with that of the general", "hn8pw-wO3py-00068-00016208-00016471": "population and such an image", "hn8pw-wO3py-00069-00016472-00016686": "will make it difficult for her to bring", "hn8pw-wO3py-00070-00016687-00017030": "the nation along with her", "hn8pw-wO3py-00071-00017031-00017375": "she had an affair with an mp mark field", "hn8pw-wO3py-00072-00017376-00017567": "which was not disclosed by the way when", "hn8pw-wO3py-00073-00017568-00017799": "she was endorsed as a candidate", "hn8pw-wO3py-00074-00017800-00018039": "her husband may have forgiven her but", "hn8pw-wO3py-00075-00018040-00018303": "for many people adultery is unacceptable", "hn8pw-wO3py-00076-00018304-00018567": "behavior and that will further diminish", "hn8pw-wO3py-00077-00018568-00018919": "her ability to lead the nation", "hn8pw-wO3py-00078-00018920-00019239": "she lacks margaret thatcher's leadership", "hn8pw-wO3py-00079-00019240-00019471": "and communication ability that's a woman", "hn8pw-wO3py-00080-00019472-00019703": "with whom she likes to compare herself", "hn8pw-wO3py-00081-00019704-00019879": "the biggest difference is that margaret", "hn8pw-wO3py-00082-00019880-00020214": "was above all a woman of principle which", "hn8pw-wO3py-00083-00020215-00020471": "was", "hn8pw-wO3py-00084-00020472-00020655": "having demonstrated her ability to", "hn8pw-wO3py-00085-00020656-00020919": "flip-flop on issues like brexit when", "hn8pw-wO3py-00086-00020920-00021143": "seemed to be to her advantage", "hn8pw-wO3py-00087-00021144-00021471": "much in the style of the fabled figure", "hn8pw-wO3py-00088-00021472-00021655": "of bray", "hn8pw-wO3py-00089-00021656-00021822": "and google that if you don't know that's", "hn8pw-wO3py-00090-00021823-00022127": "right", "hn8pw-wO3py-00091-00022128-00022358": "yesterday less than 48 hours after she", "hn8pw-wO3py-00092-00022359-00022591": "took office a big poll revealed that", "hn8pw-wO3py-00093-00022592-00022694": "quite a", "hn8pw-wO3py-00094-00022695-00022847": "large share of the", "hn8pw-wO3py-00095-00022848-00023119": "public think that that syracuse starmer", "hn8pw-wO3py-00096-00023120-00023358": "would do a better job as prime minister", "hn8pw-wO3py-00097-00023359-00023591": "so that's that's really not much of an", "hn8pw-wO3py-00098-00023592-00023711": "endorsement", "hn8pw-wO3py-00099-00023712-00023894": "and i guess we have to conclude that", "hn8pw-wO3py-00100-00023895-00024319": "she's unlikely to do a very good job", "hn8pw-wO3py-00101-00024320-00024583": "well what's my take on all of this", "hn8pw-wO3py-00102-00024584-00024711": "situation", "hn8pw-wO3py-00103-00024712-00024967": "uh liz has already put down her marker", "hn8pw-wO3py-00104-00024968-00025263": "as a populist promising huge funding for", "hn8pw-wO3py-00105-00025264-00025478": "household energy relief", "hn8pw-wO3py-00106-00025479-00025702": "the cost is enormous and perhaps", "hn8pw-wO3py-00107-00025704-00025870": "unaffordable", "hn8pw-wO3py-00108-00025872-00026039": "and thus much depends on the", "hn8pw-wO3py-00109-00026039-00026335": "chancellor's plan to fund it which is", "hn8pw-wO3py-00110-00026336-00026607": "promised shortly this is clearly an", "hn8pw-wO3py-00111-00026608-00026855": "opportunist without probably real", "hn8pw-wO3py-00112-00026856-00027167": "principles making it harder to opine her", "hn8pw-wO3py-00113-00027168-00027390": "strategy for surviving the perfect storm", "hn8pw-wO3py-00114-00027391-00027599": "of problems she faces", "hn8pw-wO3py-00115-00027600-00027799": "insanely she could do herself a big", "hn8pw-wO3py-00116-00027800-00027974": "favor and strengthen her reputation by", "hn8pw-wO3py-00117-00027975-00028158": "cracking down on the appalling tax", "hn8pw-wO3py-00118-00028160-00028383": "dodging atmosphere in london and among", "hn8pw-wO3py-00119-00028383-00028614": "tory party contributors and those that", "hn8pw-wO3py-00120-00028616-00028887": "protect offshore tax havens", "hn8pw-wO3py-00121-00028888-00029167": "she probably won't", "hn8pw-wO3py-00122-00029168-00029367": "the fact that she was selected by the", "hn8pw-wO3py-00123-00029368-00029655": "rank and file of the tory party means", "hn8pw-wO3py-00124-00029656-00029887": "little those voting represented less", "hn8pw-wO3py-00125-00029888-00030014": "than one percent of the british", "hn8pw-wO3py-00126-00030016-00030287": "electorate also they seem to prefer", "hn8pw-wO3py-00127-00030288-00030543": "boris a lawyer a narcissist and an", "hn8pw-wO3py-00128-00030544-00030790": "incompetent manager it's not an", "hn8pw-wO3py-00129-00030791-00031023": "encouraging picture and i'm not terribly", "hn8pw-wO3py-00130-00031024-00031199": "optimistic but", "hn8pw-wO3py-00131-00031200-00031358": "i wish it well", "hn8pw-wO3py-00132-00031360-00031446": "well", "hn8pw-wO3py-00133-00031447-00031623": "if you are going to like that that's how", "hn8pw-wO3py-00134-00031624-00031783": "i come out", "hn8pw-wO3py-00135-00031783-00031983": "and", "hn8pw-wO3py-00136-00031983-00032214": "you might take a look at some of", "hn8pw-wO3py-00137-00032216-00032335": "similar", "hn8pw-wO3py-00138-00032336-00032543": "views and other videos of mine and in", "hn8pw-wO3py-00139-00032544-00032932": "any case please subscribe"}}, {"audio_id": "hnhsR82koWM", "text": {"hnhsR82koWM-00000-00000024-00000223": "welcome to this video series and i'm", "hnhsR82koWM-00001-00000224-00000423": "excited to talk to you today about", "hnhsR82koWM-00002-00000424-00000591": "fiverr and i'm gonna provide you with", "hnhsR82koWM-00003-00000592-00000886": "tips so that hopefully you can earn a", "hnhsR82koWM-00004-00000888-00001262": "full-time living by selling services on", "hnhsR82koWM-00005-00001263-00001454": "fiverr there are people that are making", "hnhsR82koWM-00006-00001455-00001751": "six figures on fiverr of course i'm not", "hnhsR82koWM-00007-00001752-00001991": "going to guarantee any results i don't", "hnhsR82koWM-00008-00001992-00002159": "know what your skills are and i don't", "hnhsR82koWM-00009-00002160-00002391": "know what your work ethic is so i cannot", "hnhsR82koWM-00010-00002392-00002550": "guarantee anything", "hnhsR82koWM-00011-00002551-00002783": "here and just like anything just like in", "hnhsR82koWM-00012-00002784-00003039": "life in business this requires", "hnhsR82koWM-00013-00003040-00003286": "some hard work in the following videos i", "hnhsR82koWM-00014-00003288-00003511": "want to talk about what is fiber for", "hnhsR82koWM-00015-00003511-00003727": "those of you who are not familiar with", "hnhsR82koWM-00016-00003728-00003967": "fiber how you can use fiber for lead", "hnhsR82koWM-00017-00003968-00004086": "generation", "hnhsR82koWM-00018-00004087-00004391": "how to get more exposure to your gigs", "hnhsR82koWM-00019-00004392-00004670": "the importance of becoming a level one", "hnhsR82koWM-00020-00004671-00004895": "two and top rated seller and why you", "hnhsR82koWM-00021-00004896-00005143": "want to become a pro rated seller on", "hnhsR82koWM-00022-00005144-00005406": "fiverr i'm also gonna touch on arbitrage", "hnhsR82koWM-00023-00005407-00005622": "i'm gonna tell you what the top gigs are", "hnhsR82koWM-00024-00005623-00005886": "and finally in my conclusion i'm going", "hnhsR82koWM-00025-00005887-00006127": "to tell you what i think are the keys to", "hnhsR82koWM-00026-00006128-00006406": "success on fiverr so come join me and", "hnhsR82koWM-00027-00006408-00006784": "i'll see you in the next video"}}, {"audio_id": "hns_4Z0kEIE", "text": {"hns_4Z0kEIE-00000-00000008-00000182": "urinary incontinence as one of the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00001-00000183-00000383": "tiresome issues that many women in the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00002-00000384-00000663": "60 plus generation are confronted with", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00003-00000664-00001647": "about", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00004-00001648-00001871": "before going forward hit subscribe", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00005-00001872-00002055": "button and press bell icon for", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00006-00002056-00002326": "notification of every upcoming video", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00007-00002327-00002518": "here are some tips for self-care to make", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00008-00002519-00002726": "you mentally and physically happier and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00009-00002727-00002942": "to reduce the stress which burdens your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00010-00002943-00003126": "life", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00011-00003127-00003438": "1.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00012-00003439-00003631": "one of the most effective ways to reduce", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00013-00003632-00003879": "fatigue is to have a good sleep", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00014-00003879-00004086": "try to have a nice quality of sleep by", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00015-00004087-00004295": "going to bed early and turning off any", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00016-00004296-00004879": "electronic and communication devices", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00017-00004880-00004975": "2.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00018-00004976-00005199": "creating an art form", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00019-00005200-00005486": "hsp have the advantage of seeing details", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00020-00005487-00005686": "and connections between one thing and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00021-00005687-00005943": "another you can use this to create your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00022-00005944-00006286": "own art like music painting sculpture", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00023-00006287-00006399": "anything", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00024-00006400-00006639": "turn those exhausting energies into your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00025-00006640-00007127": "fuel to create", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00026-00007128-00007246": "three", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00027-00007247-00007439": "take a walk in nature", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00028-00007440-00007670": "to reduce the effect of daily situations", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00029-00007672-00007903": "that make you feel overwhelmed try to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00030-00007904-00008134": "take a walk in nature or spend your time", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00031-00008136-00008367": "absorbing the natural scenery and fresh", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00032-00008368-00008446": "air", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00033-00008447-00008703": "taste the quietness as a catharsis for", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00034-00008704-00009006": "your tiredness", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00035-00009007-00009110": "4.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00036-00009111-00009374": "find other hsp and make friends with", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00037-00009375-00009478": "them", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00038-00009479-00009678": "by finding other people just like you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00039-00009679-00009871": "you can share anything you can't tell to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00040-00009872-00010142": "common people they will understand your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00041-00010143-00010335": "struggle and they can also share your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00042-00010336-00010535": "thoughts and experiences", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00043-00010536-00010747": "this way you can reinforce each other", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00044-00010748-00010983": "[Music]", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00045-00010984-00011095": "five", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00046-00011096-00011414": "find your me time daily", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00047-00011415-00011670": "after a busy and exhausting day try to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00048-00011671-00011887": "find a nice and quiet time with only", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00049-00011888-00012103": "yourself alone", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00050-00012104-00012342": "use this time to recharge and bring back", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00051-00012343-00012547": "the energy you lost before", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00052-00012548-00012751": "[Music]", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00053-00012752-00012879": "six", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00054-00012880-00013038": "food", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00055-00013039-00013319": "give your body good and healthy food", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00056-00013319-00013527": "because you need energy to fulfill your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00057-00013528-00013751": "needs don't let the overwhelming", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00058-00013752-00013958": "situations affect the food supply for", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00059-00013959-00014207": "your body from healthy food you can have", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00060-00014208-00014438": "a healthy mind and body to face the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00061-00014440-00014679": "world", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00062-00014680-00014783": "7.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00063-00014784-00014991": "home sweet home", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00064-00014991-00015183": "make your house become your place to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00065-00015184-00015327": "retreat", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00066-00015328-00015503": "if you still can't relax by the time you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00067-00015504-00015694": "enter your house maybe there's still", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00068-00015695-00015894": "something that's making you tense", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00069-00015895-00016158": "find these triggers and throw them away", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00070-00016159-00016327": "they can come in many forms such as", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00071-00016328-00016599": "bills shopping notes an old picture of", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00072-00016600-00016830": "your ex the ringing doorbell which is", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00073-00016831-00017094": "too loud a promotion letter of stuff you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00074-00017095-00017399": "don't even need etc", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00075-00017400-00017519": "eight", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00076-00017520-00017799": "reading a lot", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00077-00017800-00018030": "books can be so helpful to keep you away", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00078-00018031-00018311": "from reality find a good book or novel", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00079-00018312-00018575": "that can keep your mind busy but happy", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00080-00018576-00018758": "when you get lost and carried away by", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00081-00018759-00018975": "the story in the book you are also", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00082-00018976-00019271": "recharging your mind", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00083-00019272-00019391": "9.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00084-00019392-00019583": "writing", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00085-00019584-00019855": "writing is like a best friend of reading", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00086-00019856-00020014": "if you read a lot you will have a good", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00087-00020015-00020294": "vocabulary and understanding you can use", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00088-00020295-00020486": "this to make your own material and to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00089-00020487-00020735": "make your own writing by writing you can", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00090-00020736-00020950": "have a better understanding of yourself", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00091-00020951-00021127": "and put your restlessness into a", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00092-00021128-00021383": "positive way", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00093-00021384-00021471": "10.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00094-00021472-00021878": "avoid or minimize external stimuli", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00095-00021879-00022103": "when you get home try to relax and avoid", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00096-00022104-00022311": "all the interference from the external", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00097-00022312-00022422": "world", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00098-00022423-00022607": "it's a simple yet effective way to make", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00099-00022608-00022791": "you relax", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00100-00022792-00023078": "turn off your tv lights and other things", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00101-00023079-00023350": "if your fan or ac are too noisy try to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00102-00023351-00023550": "fix it or find a new one", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00103-00023551-00023719": "this way you can have the calmness you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00104-00023720-00024047": "need to recharge your energy", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00105-00024048-00024422": "11. put aside your smartphones", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00106-00024423-00024647": "smartphones can become an energy drain", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00107-00024648-00024750": "for you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00108-00024751-00024950": "put aside your smartphone somewhere you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00109-00024951-00025167": "can't easily reach it turn off the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00110-00025168-00025447": "ringtones by using silent mode avoid", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00111-00025448-00025655": "scrolling through unnecessary celeb", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00112-00025656-00025911": "gossip or cheesy news you can find", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00113-00025912-00026127": "yourself happier when you're not fixed", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00114-00026127-00026327": "to your gadget", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00115-00026327-00026614": "12. having a nice bath", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00116-00026616-00026831": "taking a good bath or shower can really", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00117-00026832-00027007": "help to ease off the tension you have", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00118-00027008-00027207": "all day long", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00119-00027208-00027414": "if you have a bathtub you can use a nice", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00120-00027416-00027702": "salt based on your favorite scent or you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00121-00027704-00028055": "can use good warm water for a shower", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00122-00028056-00028174": "13.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00123-00028175-00028414": "playing with your pets", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00124-00028416-00028670": "pets can give unconditional love we miss", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00125-00028672-00028879": "in daily social life", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00126-00028880-00029070": "pets usually never ask for much in", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00127-00029072-00029311": "return they don't hide their feelings or", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00128-00029312-00029558": "have unimportant chit chat with you you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00129-00029560-00029767": "can feel relaxed just by seeing your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00130-00029768-00030014": "hamster running around watching the fish", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00131-00030016-00030270": "in the aquarium or hugging your cats or", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00132-00030272-00030583": "dog or any animals you like", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00133-00030583-00030711": "14.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00134-00030712-00030958": "taking care of plants", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00135-00030960-00031118": "if you don't like animals you can choose", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00136-00031119-00031318": "to take care of plants", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00137-00031319-00031502": "plants can give you the fresh air you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00138-00031503-00031718": "need and it can make your home feel more", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00139-00031719-00031823": "alive", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00140-00031824-00032007": "there are a lot of plants you can choose", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00141-00032008-00032283": "which are easy to care for", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00142-00032283-00032670": "15. eat chocolate", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00143-00032672-00032943": "chocolate is really tasty and contains", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00144-00032944-00033135": "antioxidants which are useful for your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00145-00033136-00033383": "body you can taste the sweetness and any", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00146-00033384-00033615": "flavor you like the taste will give you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00147-00033616-00033935": "a really nice sensory experience", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00148-00033936-00034127": "choose the best quality chocolate such", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00149-00034128-00034327": "as a good dark chocolate you can find in", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00150-00034328-00034495": "the market", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00151-00034496-00034623": "16.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00152-00034624-00034823": "open your window", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00153-00034824-00035015": "open your window to let the fresh air", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00154-00035016-00035335": "come in especially after a rainy day", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00155-00035336-00035543": "feel the sense of the windy breeze", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00156-00035544-00035855": "entering your room", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00157-00035856-00035999": "17.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00158-00036000-00036143": "walking", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00159-00036144-00036351": "take a few minutes to walk", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00160-00036352-00036511": "by walking you can absorb your", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00161-00036512-00036767": "surroundings and make observations of it", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00162-00036768-00037190": "to make it as your source for creativity", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00163-00037191-00037318": "18.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00164-00037319-00037655": "create a playlist of soft music", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00165-00037656-00037879": "soft music can help you to relax and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00166-00037880-00038079": "forget the loudness you take all day", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00167-00038080-00038183": "long", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00168-00038184-00038487": "use your youtube spotify google or any", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00169-00038488-00038679": "platform to create your own choice of", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00170-00038680-00038974": "relaxing music", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00171-00038975-00039111": "19.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00172-00039112-00039367": "keep away from toxic situations and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00173-00039368-00039535": "toxic people", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00174-00039536-00039718": "we all have these kinds of environments", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00175-00039719-00039911": "or people who can be toxic", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00176-00039912-00040135": "whether at the office or neighborhood", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00177-00040136-00040351": "if you get stuck with these situations", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00178-00040352-00040599": "try to avoid them or be firm to them by", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00179-00040600-00040862": "saying no", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00180-00040863-00040983": "20.", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00181-00040984-00041255": "take a deep breath", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00182-00041256-00041446": "one of the most effective ways to calm", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00183-00041447-00041711": "yourself is for you to take a good deep", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00184-00041712-00041807": "breath", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00185-00041808-00041999": "there's a lot of deep belly breathing", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00186-00042000-00042215": "training on the internet you can find", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00187-00042216-00042423": "you can use these skills in your daily", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00188-00042424-00042823": "life every time you need to relax", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00189-00042824-00042999": "being a highly sensitive person can", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00190-00043000-00043230": "sometimes be challenging but you must", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00191-00043231-00043423": "remember that your mind and body should", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00192-00043424-00043679": "be taken care of and the best person to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00193-00043680-00043958": "take care of you is yourself", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00194-00043959-00044151": "give love to yourself", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00195-00044152-00044407": "take care of your body and soul", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00196-00044408-00044558": "we hope these tips can help you to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00197-00044559-00044823": "practice self-care and change the hectic", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00198-00044824-00045055": "and overwhelming conditions to become", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00199-00045056-00045318": "your potential to be the best version of", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00200-00045319-00045455": "you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00201-00045456-00045767": "remember hsp is special and there's", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00202-00045768-00045999": "nothing wrong with being a highly", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00203-00046000-00046262": "sensitive person well the good news", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00204-00046263-00046455": "women have a relatively large number of", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00205-00046456-00046639": "ways to remedy this", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00206-00046640-00046855": "pelvic floor training through gymnastics", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00207-00046856-00047071": "or on equipment it's never too late for", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00208-00047072-00047158": "that", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00209-00047159-00047399": "this improves or cures over 50 percent", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00210-00047400-00047558": "of those affected", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00211-00047559-00047807": "weight loss even a five to ten percent", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00212-00047808-00048030": "reduction in obesity is accompanied by a", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00213-00048031-00048223": "sixty percent decrease in urinary", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00214-00048224-00048358": "incontinence", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00215-00048359-00048567": "plant-based nutrition to increase the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00216-00048568-00048735": "body's defenses and strengthen the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00217-00048736-00048855": "tissue", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00218-00048856-00049118": "food supplements with silica vitamin d", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00219-00049119-00049279": "antioxidants", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00220-00049280-00049462": "drink a lot and don't think that if you", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00221-00049463-00049607": "drink little you have to go to the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00222-00049608-00049783": "toilet less often and therefore have", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00223-00049784-00049999": "less urinary incontinence", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00224-00050000-00050207": "you only promote bladder infections and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00225-00050208-00050383": "risk deterioration", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00226-00050384-00050607": "medicinal plants can be used to improve", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00227-00050608-00050783": "the weakness of the connective tissue", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00228-00050784-00051046": "for example field horsetail shustler", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00229-00051047-00051311": "salts homeopathic complex remedies or", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00230-00051312-00051519": "constitutional remedies", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00231-00051520-00051742": "plant preparations and food supplements", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00232-00051744-00051926": "such as lingonberry or cranberry", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00233-00051927-00052199": "extracts goldenrod and barberry are also", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00234-00052200-00052390": "suitable for bladder care", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00235-00052391-00052663": "you can also try homeopathic complex and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00236-00052664-00052838": "individual remedies", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00237-00052839-00053038": "the vaginal mud treatment which you can", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00238-00053039-00053271": "do yourself at home is another sensible", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00239-00053272-00053479": "option as the blood circulation of the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00240-00053479-00053654": "entire pelvis has improved and a", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00241-00053655-00053879": "vegetative balance is created", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00242-00053879-00054071": "the weight health tips for women and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00243-00054072-00054263": "then of course the eternal problem with", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00244-00054264-00054359": "weight", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00245-00054360-00054550": "when it was easier to lose a few pounds", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00246-00054551-00054726": "with a diet when you were young it now", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00247-00054727-00054887": "means hard work", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00248-00054888-00055159": "in addition women 60 plus have to manage", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00249-00055160-00055350": "the balancing act between lowering their", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00250-00055351-00055575": "energy intake while simultaneously", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00251-00055576-00055750": "increasing their intake of important", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00252-00055751-00055959": "phytonutrients and enough protein and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00253-00055960-00056175": "increasing energy consumption", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00254-00056176-00056391": "this means gathering precise information", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00255-00056391-00056566": "about healthy eating applying the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00256-00056567-00056766": "knowledge looking after the bowels and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00257-00056767-00056950": "lots of exercises", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00258-00056951-00057119": "due to the hormonal changes after", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00259-00057120-00057391": "menopause the metabolism becomes slower", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00260-00057391-00057599": "the body fat distribution changes and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00261-00057600-00057830": "the calorie consumption is lower", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00262-00057832-00058126": "due to bad habits of the past years slag", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00263-00058127-00058366": "accumulates the liver and kidneys become", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00264-00058367-00058575": "tired so that the detoxification no", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00265-00058576-00058766": "longer works optimally", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00266-00058767-00058991": "the intestinal mucous membrane is badly", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00267-00058991-00059230": "affected by fast food environmental", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00268-00059232-00059511": "toxins preservatives and dyes so that it", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00269-00059512-00059687": "becomes full of holes and poorly", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00270-00059688-00059871": "digested food components can pass", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00271-00059872-00060063": "through which call the immune system on", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00272-00060064-00060175": "the scene", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00273-00060176-00060406": "inflammatory reactions and digestive", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00274-00060407-00060615": "disorders follow so that many women can", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00275-00060616-00060863": "no longer tolerate healthy food", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00276-00060864-00061030": "wheat or gluten intolerance is", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00277-00061032-00061238": "particularly common and far too rarely", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00278-00061239-00061406": "recognized in women", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00279-00061407-00061591": "the body suffers from want what you can", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00280-00061591-00061806": "do yourself change in diet avoid", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00281-00061807-00062015": "short-term slimming diets", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00282-00062016-00062199": "it is better and healthier in the long", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00283-00062200-00062423": "term to change your diet avoid simple", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00284-00062424-00062615": "carbohydrates and too many animal", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00285-00062616-00062742": "products", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00286-00062744-00062919": "switch from white and brown bread to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00287-00062920-00063182": "whole grain bread from meat sausage and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00288-00063183-00063438": "cheese to vegetables legumes lettuce", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00289-00063439-00063694": "fruit and healthy vegetable fats", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00290-00063695-00063854": "perhaps you will succeed in doing", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00291-00063855-00064054": "without all gluten containing products", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00292-00064055-00064350": "for 14 days on a trial basis eg types of", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00293-00064351-00064663": "grain such as wheat oats rye baked goods", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00294-00064664-00064903": "and finished products etc", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00295-00064904-00065094": "then as you start to feel better and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00296-00065095-00065287": "lose weight it will be easier for you to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00297-00065288-00065519": "make friends with this type of diet", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00298-00065520-00065743": "green smoothie replace a meal with a", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00299-00065744-00065887": "green smoothie", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00300-00065888-00066111": "it saturates and supplies your organism", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00301-00066112-00066303": "with an abundance of phytochemicals that", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00302-00066304-00066519": "stimulate the metabolism replenish the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00303-00066520-00066743": "vitamin stores and give the power plants", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00304-00066744-00067079": "of our cells the mitochondria new energy", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00305-00067080-00067279": "bowel care without a healthy", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00306-00067280-00067471": "well-functioning bowel you will find it", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00307-00067472-00067647": "difficult to lose weight", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00308-00067648-00067879": "the millions of intestinal bacteria not", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00309-00067880-00068071": "only help with our digestion but are", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00310-00068072-00068247": "also involved in the functioning of our", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00311-00068248-00068391": "immune system and in our mental", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00312-00068392-00068511": "well-being", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00313-00068512-00068694": "so it is worthwhile to find out more", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00314-00068695-00068926": "about what is actually going on", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00315-00068927-00069126": "help from the vegetable kingdom there is", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00316-00069127-00069311": "some help from the vegetable kingdom to", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00317-00069312-00069550": "help you burn fat more easily egb", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00318-00069551-00069719": "artichoke tincture", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00319-00069720-00070023": "bitter substances make digestion easier", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00320-00070024-00070263": "or a trick to fill you up faster drink a", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00321-00070264-00070511": "glass of water just before you eat", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00322-00070512-00070831": "movement finally energy consumption", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00323-00070832-00071062": "do not miss any opportunity to move", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00324-00071063-00071271": "exercise your circulation by walking", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00325-00071272-00071526": "quickly walking or jogging swimming", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00326-00071527-00071782": "dancing whatever movement you enjoy", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00327-00071783-00071999": "make a goal of doing real exercise at", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00328-00072000-00072199": "least three times a week for one hour", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00329-00072200-00072367": "sweating encouraged", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00330-00072368-00072582": "use bikes and feet instead of cars and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00331-00072583-00072782": "elevators as often as possible health", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00332-00072783-00072999": "tips for women getting older also has", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00333-00073000-00073150": "its good points", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00334-00073151-00073399": "in many women for example the psyche", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00335-00073400-00073550": "stabilizes", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00336-00073551-00073743": "calm and serenity are attributes that", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00337-00073744-00073959": "one often only attains with increasing", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00338-00073960-00074143": "years and that has something to do with", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00339-00074144-00074279": "mindfulness", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00340-00074280-00074438": "therefore one can learn calm and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00341-00074439-00074623": "serenity at any age", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00342-00074624-00074806": "the sooner you start using techniques", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00343-00074807-00074982": "that bring you calm the better", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00344-00074983-00075182": "mindfulness exercises breathing", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00345-00075183-00075479": "exercises yoga autogenic training and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00346-00075480-00075687": "more don't just think about your body", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00347-00075688-00075911": "please also your soul every woman will", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00348-00075912-00076150": "find her own individual recipe", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00349-00076151-00076343": "some like to dig in the garden and enjoy", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00350-00076344-00076591": "the plants others wander in the forest", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00351-00076592-00076847": "sing in a choir play an instrument paint", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00352-00076848-00076975": "or devote themselves to the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00353-00076976-00077111": "grandchildren", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00354-00077112-00077319": "an animal can also become an important", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00355-00077320-00077543": "center of life especially for single", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00356-00077544-00077726": "women and donate daily feelings of", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00357-00077727-00077855": "happiness", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00358-00077856-00078079": "however studies show that first and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00359-00078080-00078262": "foremost for the happy soul is being", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00360-00078263-00078438": "part of a functioning community and the", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00361-00078439-00078679": "feeling of being valued humor and", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00362-00078680-00079210": "laughter come naturally", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00363-00079211-00080294": "[Music]", "hns_4Z0kEIE-00364-00080295-00080504": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "hnMZV-4zJRc", "text": {"hnMZV-4zJRc-00000-00000000-00000142": "Microsoft", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00001-00000143-00000316": "trying to buy", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00002-00000317-00000484": "Activision", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00003-00000486-00000790": "am I against it am I for it we're going", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00004-00000791-00001012": "to talk about that today on the burning", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00005-00001013-00001258": "Mouse channel Microsoft buying uh", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00006-00001259-00001493": "Activision I'm gonna say that I am not", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00007-00001494-00001763": "for it uh some people may be like well", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00008-00001764-00001918": "you know they have the money so they", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00009-00001919-00002045": "should be able to buy it but on my", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00010-00002046-00002507": "chances when there's no competition", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00011-00002508-00002825": "I tend to not like the service of the", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00012-00002826-00003047": "entity that has the whole market share", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00013-00003048-00003311": "I'll give you a perfect um a perfect", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00014-00003311-00003622": "example I think", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00015-00003623-00003815": "Apple gets away with everything they get", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00016-00003815-00004145": "away with it's because once you're in", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00017-00004146-00004438": "you can only turn to Apple you cannot", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00018-00004439-00004654": "use any other softwares Without Really", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00019-00004655-00004972": "knowing how to uh buying", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00020-00004973-00005177": "um pieces for your Apple can be a pain", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00021-00005178-00005422": "in the butt you can't take it apart you", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00022-00005423-00005602": "can't upgrade your stuff from other", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00023-00005603-00005861": "independent um companies to try to", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00024-00005862-00006088": "upgrade the speed of your Apple or", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00025-00006089-00006238": "anything like that it's very everything", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00026-00006239-00006395": "has to go through them and I can only", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00027-00006396-00006556": "assume that if Microsoft takes over", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00028-00006558-00006755": "Activision it's gonna get that way", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00029-00006756-00007019": "that's one of the reasons why I think no", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00030-00007020-00007337": "no we need different entities there so", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00031-00007338-00007595": "y'all can you can have an option to go", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00032-00007595-00007817": "to another one is YouTube you know", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00033-00007818-00007996": "YouTube's really the only place a", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00034-00007997-00008201": "Creator gets that straight up pay type", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00035-00008202-00008513": "of situation so you're kind of sometimes", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00036-00008514-00008753": "you can feel stuck because who else", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00037-00008754-00008914": "you're gonna who is the alternative to", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00038-00008915-00009155": "YouTube there really isn't one so they", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00039-00009156-00009292": "can pretty much do whatever they want to", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00040-00009293-00009509": "do so it's one of those things where I", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00041-00009510-00009617": "do not want it to get like that when", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00042-00009618-00009785": "when they farted coming to the gaming", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00043-00009786-00010042": "stuff I did switch to PC and I'm gonna", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00044-00010043-00010217": "be gaming on this PC right here I'm", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00045-00010218-00010331": "actually gonna be upgrading this one", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00046-00010332-00010535": "soon and building an additional one so", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00047-00010536-00010792": "stay tuned for that but that's my two", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00048-00010793-00011021": "cents within it comes to Microsoft I", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00049-00011022-00011224": "don't want Microsoft owning activists", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00050-00011225-00011519": "keep it keep it keep it separate man", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00051-00011520-00011746": "keep it separately I think if they did", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00052-00011747-00011956": "own it they would start making a lot of", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00053-00011957-00012203": "things where you have to be on a Xbox or", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00054-00012204-00012395": "you have to be PC and they will try to", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00055-00012396-00012563": "shut PlayStation out do I think they", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00056-00012564-00012737": "would do that do I think a business", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00057-00012738-00012977": "would be that grimy yes", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00058-00012978-00013199": "yes that's that's exactly what it sounds", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00059-00013200-00013385": "like they would do it for it if not then", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00060-00013386-00013541": "what other reason why would you buy it", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00061-00013541-00013715": "and maybe I'm ignorant to that fact and", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00062-00013716-00013943": "comment at the bottom and let me know", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00063-00013944-00014393": "but I feel no we're okay I don't I don't", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00064-00014394-00014525": "want Microsoft own it I don't want", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00065-00014526-00014735": "PlayStation owning it I don't I don't", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00066-00014736-00014830": "want none of that and of course", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00067-00014831-00014993": "PlayStation feels that way because I", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00068-00014994-00015185": "mean we can't get God of War on the next", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00069-00015186-00015263": "box", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00070-00015263-00015497": "so yeah you know that type of stuff is", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00071-00015497-00015791": "going to go on and um that's my two", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00072-00015791-00015935": "cents on it man let me know but yeah", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00073-00015936-00016085": "like I said we will be building also", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00074-00016086-00016294": "we're doing a review a year and a half", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00075-00016295-00016505": "with the road Caster I have to do it", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00076-00016506-00016655": "reviewed on the pro Caster microphone", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00077-00016656-00016877": "which I'm talking on right now I gotta", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00078-00016878-00017129": "do a review on my uh screens I got the", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00079-00017130-00017447": "review on the ryzen 5 I gotta do and I", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00080-00017448-00017615": "have to do the builds I have to upgrade", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00081-00017616-00017771": "this computer and I have to build a", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00082-00017772-00017915": "whole new one from scratch we're going", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00083-00017916-00018094": "to be doing that here on the Bernie", "hnMZV-4zJRc-00084-00018095-00018331": "Mouse channel"}}, {"audio_id": "io0OGuGo0qQ", "text": {"io0OGuGo0qQ-00000-00000750-00001023": "[Applause]", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00001-00001024-00001491": "[Music]", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00002-00001492-00002005": "wow", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00003-00002007-00002883": "[Applause]", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00004-00002884-00003156": "ah", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00005-00003157-00004319": "[Music]", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00006-00004320-00019683": "[Music]", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00007-00019684-00019935": "do", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00008-00019936-00029095": "[Music]", "io0OGuGo0qQ-00009-00029095-00029304": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "io-F2RmUac0", "text": {"io-F2RmUac0-00000-00000029-00000847": "foreign", "io-F2RmUac0-00001-00000848-00003904": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00002-00003906-00004635": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00003-00004636-00005540": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00004-00005541-00006355": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00005-00006356-00006926": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00006-00006927-00007528": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00007-00007529-00007648": "foreign", "io-F2RmUac0-00008-00007650-00008555": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00009-00008556-00009190": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00010-00009191-00009931": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00011-00009932-00010659": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00012-00010660-00012387": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00013-00012388-00012946": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00014-00012947-00013686": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00015-00013687-00014403": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00016-00014404-00014819": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00017-00014819-00015963": "foreign", "io-F2RmUac0-00018-00015965-00016688": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00019-00016689-00017414": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00020-00017415-00018229": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00021-00018230-00018970": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00022-00018971-00019702": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00023-00019703-00020608": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00024-00020609-00021243": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00025-00021244-00022712": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00026-00022713-00023350": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00027-00023351-00023624": "foreign", "io-F2RmUac0-00028-00023625-00024435": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00029-00024436-00024998": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00030-00024999-00025726": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00031-00025727-00027448": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00032-00027449-00028011": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00033-00028012-00028739": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00034-00028739-00029464": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00035-00029466-00029485": "foreign", "io-F2RmUac0-00036-00029486-00030217": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00037-00030218-00031024": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00038-00031025-00031761": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00039-00031762-00033229": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00040-00033230-00034039": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00041-00034040-00034770": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00042-00034771-00036492": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00043-00036493-00036755": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00044-00036756-00037050": "foreign", "io-F2RmUac0-00045-00037051-00038507": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00046-00038508-00039503": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00047-00039504-00040066": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00048-00040067-00040804": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00049-00040805-00042436": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00050-00042437-00043092": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00051-00043093-00043811": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00052-00043812-00044038": "foreign", "io-F2RmUac0-00053-00044039-00044711": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00054-00044712-00045280": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00055-00045281-00046826": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00056-00046827-00047554": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00057-00047555-00048539": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00058-00048540-00049103": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00059-00049104-00049638": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00060-00049639-00050927": "[Music]", "io-F2RmUac0-00061-00050928-00051228": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "i0sCp-zqoOA", "text": {"i0sCp-zqoOA-00000-00001784-00002063": "so one thing here like you know like", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00001-00002064-00002985": "when we are the the protection yesterday", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00002-00002986-00003224": "the gift of Dharma and gift of", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00003-00003225-00003635": "protection so is he so this thing about", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00004-00003636-00003767": "the I think these two are very beautiful", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00005-00003768-00004129": "I think they're beautiful it's a gift", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00006-00004130-00004328": "basically you have in the end of the", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00007-00004329-00004697": "practice URF you have a gift prepare it", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00008-00004698-00005033": "or you're preparing a gift and so you're", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00009-00005034-00005770": "preparing a gift to the demons of your", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00010-00005771-00006209": "ego fear you have prepared a gift to the", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00011-00006210-00006467": "manifestation of those demons you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00012-00006468-00006781": "prepare a gift a person that you don't", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00013-00006783-00007228": "like and you have your basically this a", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00014-00007229-00007492": "gift so the gift the idea of gift here", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00015-00007493-00007751": "as you can see is kind of basically", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00016-00007752-00008213": "teaching your you are teaching to them", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00017-00008214-00008702": "so in maybe you are so let's say any", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00018-00008703-00008810": "time when you're trying to teach", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00019-00008811-00009028": "somebody there's it this is two", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00020-00009029-00009326": "possibilities right you have somebody", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00021-00009327-00009796": "who who is open to you somebody who", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00022-00009797-00010123": "respects you at my shoe and somebody is", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00023-00010124-00010538": "really wanting to listen to you then", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00024-00010539-00010694": "there's one with then you have one kind", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00025-00010695-00010841": "of teaching so you just kind of you have", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00026-00010842-00011045": "a you have opportunity to talk", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00027-00011046-00011617": "communicate you say okay it's not good", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00028-00011618-00011885": "to her harm others not good to harm", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00029-00011886-00012209": "yourself every word you say you have a", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00030-00012210-00012637": "power or that being person so you teach", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00031-00012638-00012958": "the loving-kindness and compassion to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00032-00012959-00013122": "that person", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00033-00013122-00013587": "it makes sense or just saying being open", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00034-00013588-00013869": "just connection to the nature of mind so", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00035-00013871-00014047": "the teaching of the nature of mind some", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00036-00014047-00014463": "sense so or you don't have that kind of", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00037-00014465-00014824": "relationship to the person like usually", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00038-00014825-00015259": "either you are two separated like people", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00039-00015260-00015658": "who really don't like you you cannot", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00040-00015659-00016174": "teach them loving kindness there were", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00041-00016175-00016441": "they might show you I interesting mudras", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00042-00016442-00017106": "back to you alright so forget about", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00043-00017107-00017713": "talking to them or you are too close to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00044-00017714-00017893": "somebody like your husband and wife", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00045-00017894-00018121": "trying to teach loving kindness to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00046-00018122-00018571": "gather person or your child who who", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00047-00018572-00018814": "you're trying to trying to teach loving", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00048-00018815-00019096": "kindness it can be little challenging", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00049-00019097-00019444": "right so buddy-buddy you can do you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00050-00019445-00019810": "don't have to say anything be loving", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00051-00019811-00020326": "kind you don't say anything you don't", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00052-00020327-00020587": "tell them to do with loving kindness or", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00053-00020588-00021001": "you don't give them ideas schedules and", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00054-00021002-00021442": "details or nothing you just be kind to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00055-00021443-00022144": "that person in a way not only you cannot", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00056-00022145-00022561": "do but you should not do you just you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00057-00022562-00022888": "should not tell them anything like that", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00058-00022889-00023110": "so they even the demons you do not tell", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00059-00023111-00023794": "it but feel it so when you're trying to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00060-00023795-00023971": "do that you one thing you realize I", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00061-00023972-00024145": "don't know I already don't feel it what", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00062-00024146-00024414": "I can I can teach but I don't feel it", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00063-00024415-00024757": "you know I can explain them my wife how", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00064-00024758-00024922": "to do it but I cannot really feel it", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00065-00024923-00025252": "then it there's a problem there you're", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00066-00025253-00025498": "expecting from somebody something that", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00067-00025499-00026097": "you don't even have it", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00068-00026098-00026433": "and very very often many many times that", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00069-00026433-00026610": "I think one of the biggest problem and", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00070-00026611-00026811": "enter in the relationship with people", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00071-00026812-00027195": "and particularly close relationship", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00072-00027195-00027480": "people that's the biggest problem that", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00073-00027481-00027738": "you expect from somebody something that", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00074-00027739-00028177": "you don't have you expect from somebody", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00075-00028179-00028413": "to give you something that you don't", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00076-00028414-00028875": "give to yourself do you connect with", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00077-00028876-00029345": "yourself do you respect to yourself do", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00078-00029347-00029544": "you care about yourself do you love", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00079-00029545-00030027": "yourself if you do then it's okay maybe", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00080-00030027-00030249": "expecting from somebody but if you don't", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00081-00030250-00030435": "connect with yourself you don't respect", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00082-00030436-00030630": "yourself you don't love yourself and", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00083-00030631-00030858": "then you're trying to expect from", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00084-00030858-00031137": "somebody else to do and particularly get", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00085-00031138-00031564": "angry when they don't do that's not fair", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00086-00031566-00031920": "if it's the right thing to do do first", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00087-00031920-00032177": "you do first there are somebody else to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00088-00032179-00032523": "follow you so I think that's I think", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00089-00032524-00032700": "that's kind of important principle here", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00090-00032701-00033033": "this gift of protection and gift of the", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00091-00033034-00033657": "Dharma is something that you really see", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00092-00033658-00033891": "the circumstances where you can can you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00093-00033892-00034179": "communicate or can you be and of course", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00094-00034180-00034737": "both is the best but both is the best", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00095-00034738-00035103": "but clearly you don't want it to or at", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00096-00035104-00035334": "least be conscious of not expecting too", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00097-00035335-00035640": "much from somebody when you don't have", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00098-00035641-00035844": "it or when you don't give it to yourself", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00099-00035845-00036542": "not expecting from somebody too much and", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00100-00036543-00036981": "also being aware when you don't have it", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00101-00036982-00037134": "when you don't give it yourself that", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00102-00037135-00037398": "loving kindness and probably the person", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00103-00037399-00037656": "that you're living with more likely have", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00104-00037657-00037842": "problem with that also probably does not", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00105-00037843-00038319": "have it does not have that joy that your", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00106-00038320-00038478": "joy that are you expecting from that", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00107-00038479-00038739": "person for you their personal not might", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00108-00038740-00039063": "feel enough love hims for himself or", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00109-00039064-00039441": "herself than you're expecting for you so", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00110-00039442-00039474": "if", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00111-00039475-00039630": "buddy does not have for themselves", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00112-00039631-00040083": "enough how they can share with you it's", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00113-00040084-00040473": "difficult if you if your demand you're", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00114-00040474-00040743": "torturing somebody and you're torturing", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00115-00040744-00041088": "yourself by doing that so you don't want", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00116-00041089-00041502": "her to do that at least be aware not to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00117-00041503-00041730": "expect too much maybe not to ask too", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00118-00041731-00042057": "much maybe if you ask make sure that you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00119-00042058-00042300": "also contribute in the situation or", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00120-00042301-00042585": "maybe and then the truth is when you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00121-00042586-00042801": "when you do have something when you are", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00122-00042802-00042981": "able to connect with yourself and you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00123-00042982-00043230": "are able to discover in yourself when", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00124-00043231-00043377": "you feel and when you give to yourself", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00125-00043378-00043752": "you have enough then you you don't even", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00126-00043753-00044154": "ask somebody you feel you're not like", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00127-00044155-00044361": "during the middle of the practice when", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00128-00044362-00044589": "you feel full full with that sense of", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00129-00044590-00044943": "connection and want you can see your", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00130-00044944-00045189": "your expectation from somebody it's", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00131-00045190-00045440": "already loosened up or you're not", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00132-00045441-00045858": "expecting instead we turn turn the other", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00133-00045859-00046230": "way round we become the mother before we", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00134-00046231-00046415": "were a child we became the mother but", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00135-00046416-00046578": "nourishing ourselves getting ourselves", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00136-00046579-00046851": "receiving from that source in our source", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00137-00046852-00047250": "and when we feel enough you don't ask we", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00138-00047251-00047496": "are ready to give we hold our pain and", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00139-00047497-00047838": "fear as a child in our loving arms like", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00140-00047839-00048150": "the mother does to the child so we we", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00141-00048151-00048311": "play the other role rather than", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00142-00048312-00048768": "continuously asking not you know maybe", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00143-00048769-00048912": "you might say okay well good you know", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00144-00048913-00049095": "I've been asking I've been asking a lot", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00145-00049096-00049380": "from my partner I will not ask I'll give", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00146-00049381-00049512": "myself you're trying to say i'm giving", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00147-00049513-00049623": "myself", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00148-00049624-00049848": "I am giving you know myself now I'm", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00149-00049849-00050255": "ready to ask you see if you feel like", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00150-00050256-00050442": "that you have not given it up to", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00151-00050443-00050718": "yourself because you're all the time", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00152-00050719-00051239": "you're preparing to us but when you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00153-00051240-00051638": "really give yourself you feel it's okay", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00154-00051639-00052013": "not to ask also not needed instead you", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00155-00052014-00052299": "have something to give that's a gift of", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00156-00052300-00052536": "the Dharma that's the gift of the", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00157-00052537-00052866": "protection okay so that's very important", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00158-00052866-00053163": "just these two prayers to have some good", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00159-00053164-00053432": "relation to when you sing them and even", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00160-00053433-00053591": "even sometimes when you don't sing them", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00161-00053592-00053816": "as a principle of that you can always", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00162-00053817-00054730": "apply that in informally in life", "i0sCp-zqoOA-00163-00054732-00054938": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i0EncUT4T8o", "text": {"i0EncUT4T8o-00000-00000063-00000359": "[Music]", "i0EncUT4T8o-00001-00000360-00001209": "so", "i0EncUT4T8o-00002-00001210-00001703": "[Applause]", "i0EncUT4T8o-00003-00001704-00002815": "[Music]", "i0EncUT4T8o-00004-00002816-00003032": "do"}}, {"audio_id": "i0b4kSrpLFQ", "text": {"i0b4kSrpLFQ-00000-00002735-00002910": "hello and thanks for joining us welcome", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00001-00002911-00002999": "to this final", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00002-00003000-00003247": "wicked problems wolf pack solutions live", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00003-00003247-00003359": "stream", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00004-00003360-00003606": "i'm brian mallow i'll be your host i'm a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00005-00003607-00003727": "science comedian but", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00006-00003728-00003919": "this is not going to be so much about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00007-00003920-00004119": "comedy much more about science and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00008-00004120-00004222": "specifically", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00009-00004223-00004527": "citizen science joining me is karen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00010-00004528-00004599": "cooper", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00011-00004600-00004799": "she's an associate pro uh i was going to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00012-00004800-00004927": "say producer", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00013-00004928-00005206": "an associate professor of public science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00014-00005207-00005343": "in the forestry and environmental", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00015-00005344-00005551": "resources department at nc state", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00016-00005552-00005959": "karen hi dr cooper thanks for joining me", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00017-00005960-00006206": "and uh we're going to be talking about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00018-00006207-00006318": "citizen science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00019-00006319-00006527": "and crowd the tap which is a specific", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00020-00006528-00006703": "citizen science project that we really", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00021-00006704-00006863": "want you to know about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00022-00006864-00007103": "but um and i do want to encourage", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00023-00007104-00007270": "everyone to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00024-00007272-00007431": "think about and start sending in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00025-00007431-00007614": "questions to the chat", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00026-00007615-00007846": "uh because if you wait till the end we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00027-00007847-00008006": "won't get to your questions so we want", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00028-00008008-00008119": "you to think about them", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00029-00008120-00008303": "but the questions that were submitted in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00030-00008304-00008478": "advance a lot of them had to do with", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00031-00008479-00008551": "birds", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00032-00008552-00008719": "because karen's background is in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00033-00008720-00008927": "ornithology but what we really want are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00034-00008928-00009087": "questions about citizen science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00035-00009088-00009310": "and crowd the tap but tell me something", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00036-00009311-00009471": "karen so tell me about your background", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00037-00009472-00009695": "before you got into citizen science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00038-00009696-00009951": "um first of all where did you go to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00039-00009952-00010055": "undergrad", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00040-00010056-00010414": "yeah good one so yeah well first i will", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00041-00010415-00010535": "point out that i have something in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00042-00010536-00010606": "common with", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00043-00010607-00010878": "all of the everyone who's viewing here", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00044-00010879-00010983": "all the incoming", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00045-00010984-00011167": "class which is that i got my", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00046-00011168-00011310": "undergraduate degree here", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00047-00011311-00011646": "at nc state um and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00048-00011647-00011919": "uh although i grew up in chapel hill", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00049-00011920-00012214": "it's like conflicting", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00050-00012215-00012423": "but you knew you were sitting in a in a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00051-00012424-00012519": "like a target", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00052-00012520-00012855": "red chair and so you had to wear the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00053-00012856-00013079": "carolina blue exactly but yeah so i i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00054-00013080-00013294": "did my undergrad here at nc state and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00055-00013295-00013463": "and yeah i studied birds while i was", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00056-00013463-00013719": "here i studied i studied songbirds", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00057-00013719-00013919": "um in different parts of the country in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00058-00013919-00014022": "alabama", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00059-00014023-00014255": "i studied parrots in puerto rico i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00060-00014256-00014479": "studied hawks out in california", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00061-00014480-00014671": "um and then i did a master's degree at", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00062-00014672-00014807": "the university of wyoming where i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00063-00014808-00014951": "studied ducks", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00064-00014952-00015230": "and then i did dogs are just funny", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00065-00015231-00015358": "there's i know", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00066-00015359-00015519": "people chuckle when they think of them", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00067-00015519-00015758": "and then i did my phd at virginia tech", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00068-00015759-00016022": "but i did my field work overseas in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00069-00016023-00016135": "australia", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00070-00016136-00016439": "studying songbirds there so you know", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00071-00016440-00016567": "that's something that i love that i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00072-00016568-00016719": "learned about scientists if you're", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00073-00016720-00016967": "considering a career in science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00074-00016968-00017135": "so many scientists i know you know the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00075-00017136-00017311": "the nature of the job is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00076-00017312-00017550": "as you move to graduate work and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00077-00017551-00017671": "post-doc work", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00078-00017672-00017919": "that you end up sometimes traveling all", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00079-00017920-00017991": "over the world", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00080-00017992-00018214": "a lot yes exactly and i loved that i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00081-00018215-00018367": "loved doing field work for my early", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00082-00018368-00018479": "career", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00083-00018480-00018694": "but then i kind of did settle down and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00084-00018695-00018879": "that's actually what led me to citizen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00085-00018880-00018935": "science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00086-00018936-00019175": "and so then i spent about 15 years at", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00087-00019176-00019391": "the cornell lab of ornithology", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00088-00019392-00019671": "which if anyone is a bird watcher or has", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00089-00019672-00019814": "family members who are bird watchers", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00090-00019815-00019943": "they probably have heard", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00091-00019944-00020143": "of the cornell lab of ornithology or the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00092-00020144-00020279": "merlin app", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00093-00020280-00020503": "anyway and and there there's a gaggle", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00094-00020504-00020583": "horn", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00095-00020584-00021007": "there", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00096-00021008-00021878": "everyone flocks there", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00097-00021879-00022086": "yeah and there actually i stopped doing", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00098-00022087-00022247": "field work and i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00099-00022248-00022391": "let everyone else have the pleasure of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00100-00022392-00022550": "gathering the data and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00101-00022551-00022703": "and really bird watchers across the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00102-00022704-00022935": "country share the bird observations that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00103-00022936-00023014": "they see", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00104-00023015-00023214": "whether it's at their feeder or nesting", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00105-00023215-00023342": "birds and that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00106-00023343-00023655": "is my research was based on those data", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00107-00023656-00023878": "coming in from volunteers and that is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00108-00023879-00024039": "citizen science right and that is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00109-00024040-00024199": "citizen sciences okay so like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00110-00024200-00024414": "your your ornithology stuff led you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00111-00024415-00024527": "right into", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00112-00024528-00024750": "using citizen science when you didn't", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00113-00024751-00024911": "even plan it that way", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00114-00024912-00025167": "right i mean now yeah now you've written", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00115-00025168-00025311": "the book on", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00116-00025312-00025494": "you citizen it i say that as a joke but", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00117-00025495-00025614": "but you wrote a book", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00118-00025616-00025862": "and it's called citizen science that's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00119-00025863-00026046": "right yeah well what happened was", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00120-00026047-00026302": "was really as i started to explore", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00121-00026304-00026479": "citizen science in ornithology", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00122-00026480-00026783": "i started looking at other disciplines", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00123-00026783-00026943": "and i was seeing citizen science in all", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00124-00026944-00027062": "those disciplines you know in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00125-00027063-00027214": "meteorology", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00126-00027216-00027518": "in oceanography in marine biology in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00127-00027519-00027862": "even in biochemistry and microbiology", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00128-00027863-00028079": "let me cut you off and just ask you what", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00129-00028080-00028287": "is citizen science it's like before", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00130-00028288-00028502": "so like right i mean and it's it was", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00131-00028504-00028670": "formed it's really just a collaboration", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00132-00028672-00028823": "between scientists", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00133-00028824-00028990": "and members of the public who don't", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00134-00028991-00029158": "necessarily have any scientific", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00135-00029160-00029358": "training so why would a scientist", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00136-00029360-00029518": "collaborate with someone with no", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00137-00029519-00029623": "scientific training", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00138-00029624-00029814": "yeah that's a great question because", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00139-00029816-00029958": "because scientists can't be everywhere", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00140-00029960-00030031": "at once", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00141-00030032-00030335": "right so i was using observations", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00142-00030336-00030639": "across the country of bluebirds", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00143-00030639-00030943": "to see patterns in um in basically in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00144-00030944-00031031": "the clutch size", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00145-00031032-00031190": "that bluebirds in the north lay larger", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00146-00031191-00031399": "clutches than bluebirds in the south", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00147-00031400-00031535": "other people have been using citizen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00148-00031536-00031767": "science to find with rare observations", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00149-00031768-00031918": "right so others at cornell", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00150-00031919-00032062": "were looking for the nine-spotted", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00151-00032063-00032231": "ladybug right", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00152-00032232-00032343": "i mean they couldn't be everywhere to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00153-00032344-00032574": "find it it took kids everywhere you know", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00154-00032575-00032662": "looking around", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00155-00032663-00032807": "first of all finally it was discovered", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00156-00032808-00033031": "out in oregon so there's a manpower", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00157-00033032-00033279": "issue of like you can't be everywhere", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00158-00033280-00033479": "you can only gather so much data you can", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00159-00033480-00033615": "only have so many grand students", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00160-00033616-00033767": "gathering data for and not just like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00161-00033768-00033855": "spatially", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00162-00033856-00034039": "but also over time i mean we've known", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00163-00034040-00034167": "for decades now", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00164-00034168-00034423": "that that songbirds are breeding earlier", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00165-00034424-00034502": "in the season", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00166-00034503-00034671": "because of climate change but that's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00167-00034672-00034879": "because there were centuries of data", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00168-00034880-00035095": "of observations from amateur bird", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00169-00035096-00035183": "watchers", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00170-00035184-00035462": "noting when birds were breeding and so", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00171-00035463-00035527": "um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00172-00035528-00035702": "and then there's also some fields like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00173-00035703-00035927": "astronomy and biochemistry actually", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00174-00035928-00036199": "that just either have like deluges of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00175-00036200-00036383": "data that's collected automatically", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00176-00036384-00036574": "and algorithms computer algorithms", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00177-00036575-00036735": "actually are just never as good as the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00178-00036736-00036830": "human brain", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00179-00036831-00037118": "to process samples or they have just", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00180-00037119-00037327": "yeah computationally intensive puzzles", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00181-00037328-00037502": "that they need that people are just", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00182-00037503-00037646": "better at than computers", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00183-00037647-00037790": "right so i know that some of those are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00184-00037791-00037951": "like galaxy zoo", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00185-00037952-00038287": "or those protein folding ones yeah games", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00186-00038288-00038374": "where", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00187-00038375-00038727": "where just like you said like the galaxy", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00188-00038728-00038918": "ones they have so many images of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00189-00038919-00039030": "galaxies", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00190-00039031-00039207": "and if they let people look at them and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00191-00039208-00039335": "and say", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00192-00039336-00039502": "is this elliptical or is it yeah it's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00193-00039503-00039687": "like is it clockwise counterclockwise", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00194-00039688-00039887": "just simple stuff doesn't really take", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00195-00039888-00040007": "expertise to do", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00196-00040008-00040279": "but it takes a lot of time uh can you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00197-00040280-00040430": "trust the data like when you're when", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00198-00040431-00040543": "you're depending on", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00199-00040544-00040767": "is there some special when you're using", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00200-00040768-00040935": "data collected by non-scientists are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00201-00040936-00041071": "there some special concerns that you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00202-00041072-00041143": "have", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00203-00041144-00041318": "well i mean it is really important that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00204-00041319-00041462": "when people contribute in citizen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00205-00041463-00041574": "science that they understand that it's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00206-00041575-00041743": "real science right especially if it's in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00207-00041744-00041839": "a school context", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00208-00041840-00042046": "it's not just another assignment this is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00209-00042047-00042207": "real you know it's a real", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00210-00042208-00042415": "uh data used for real discovery this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00211-00042416-00042511": "isn't just science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00212-00042512-00042711": "project science fair i mean science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00213-00042712-00042879": "fairs are real too yeah but but", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00214-00042880-00043055": "these are usually yeah and there's a lot", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00215-00043056-00043215": "built into that like these ones like you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00216-00043216-00043335": "mentioned galaxy zoo", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00217-00043336-00043495": "there's a consensus tool behind the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00218-00043496-00043671": "scenes right so every image it's not", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00219-00043672-00043839": "just because one person says oh it's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00220-00043840-00043958": "clockwise galaxy", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00221-00043959-00044127": "it's like 20 people said oh it's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00222-00044128-00044295": "clockwise and then they", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00223-00044296-00044479": "okay yeah they show each one to a lot of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00224-00044480-00044599": "people", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00225-00044600-00044790": "and um you know and so to varying", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00226-00044791-00044935": "extents there's just different", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00227-00044936-00045127": "different methods like that and you know", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00228-00045128-00045295": "astronomy is a field that i just happen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00229-00045296-00045439": "to know is like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00230-00045440-00045702": "amateurs make contributions to astronomy", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00231-00045703-00045830": "all the time because", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00232-00045831-00045983": "so many amateur astronomers are the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00233-00045984-00046167": "first ones to spot um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00234-00046168-00046415": "a comet or a thing like because that's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00235-00046416-00046535": "just so many more eyes", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00236-00046536-00046751": "on the skeletons yeah probably in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00237-00046752-00046911": "natural like what uh", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00238-00046912-00047223": "same thing about monarch butterflies", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00239-00047224-00047327": "monarch i mean that's how we know", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00240-00047328-00047567": "monarch butterflies migrate 4 000 miles", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00241-00047568-00047711": "from the midwestern us", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00242-00047712-00047902": "all the way to mexico scientists didn't", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00243-00047903-00048039": "figure that out on their own it was", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00244-00048040-00048102": "actually", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00245-00048103-00048215": "it's actually teachers and their", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00246-00048216-00048390": "students putting little postage size", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00247-00048391-00048495": "stickers", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00248-00048496-00048646": "on monarchs that they would capture", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00249-00048647-00048990": "releasing them and then um finally a tag", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00250-00048991-00049174": "monarch was found so citizen science is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00251-00049175-00049367": "real science it's not", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00252-00049368-00049590": "it's not just a separate thing it's just", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00253-00049591-00049799": "it's a it's a way that you can actually", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00254-00049800-00049943": "it's kind of exciting the idea that you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00255-00049944-00050158": "can actually contribute to research", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00256-00050159-00050415": "that will be published as part of the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00257-00050416-00050543": "scientific literature", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00258-00050544-00050686": "and it's research that couldn't happen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00259-00050687-00050871": "any other way like it's really opening", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00260-00050872-00050974": "new frontiers", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00261-00050975-00051118": "because it's things that scientists", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00262-00051119-00051430": "couldn't do on their own", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00263-00051432-00051735": "so does nc state benefit from citizens", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00264-00051736-00051863": "you're involved in citizen science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00265-00051864-00052007": "there's this big movement here we are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00266-00052008-00052214": "talking all these incoming freshmen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00267-00052215-00052519": "and um um what does nc state benefit", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00268-00052520-00052559": "from", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00269-00052560-00052766": "uh yeah for sure i mean nc state has a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00270-00052767-00052894": "really nice commitment to citizen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00271-00052895-00053030": "science we're the first", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00272-00053032-00053238": "citizen science campus in the country", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00273-00053239-00053454": "there's others following suit", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00274-00053455-00053663": "and what that means really is that all", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00275-00053664-00053847": "the students coming to campus", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00276-00053848-00054079": "will have opportunities to to be", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00277-00054079-00054238": "involved in citizen science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00278-00054239-00054447": "as part of their learning as part of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00279-00054448-00054623": "coursework they'll have opportunities", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00280-00054624-00054775": "that are part of service learning", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00281-00054776-00054926": "meaning different like volunteer", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00282-00054927-00055030": "initiatives", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00283-00055032-00055207": "and then it what it means for faculty", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00284-00055208-00055407": "and research the research capacity of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00285-00055408-00055535": "the institution", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00286-00055536-00055726": "is that then there's a student body", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00287-00055727-00055847": "that's available and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00288-00055848-00056015": "all the public and others who really", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00289-00056016-00056150": "love nc state", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00290-00056151-00056335": "um who can help contribute to our", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00291-00056336-00056599": "scientific research projects", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00292-00056600-00056750": "excellent and let's give a shout out to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00293-00056751-00056926": "scistarter since we'll be talking about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00294-00056927-00057103": "your project and scisstarter what is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00295-00057104-00057319": "this collaboration what is scistard", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00296-00057320-00057566": "yeah so scisstarter is the largest hub", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00297-00057567-00057791": "of citizen science projects so it's a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00298-00057791-00057982": "searchable database of all the projects", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00299-00057983-00058103": "whether they're projects", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00300-00058104-00058263": "posted by the federal government state", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00301-00058264-00058535": "governments other academic institutions", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00302-00058536-00058726": "non-profits industry like whatever", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00303-00058727-00058919": "there's a lot of citizen science out", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00304-00058920-00058966": "there", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00305-00058967-00059111": "serving a lot of different purposes", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00306-00059112-00059279": "different research goals", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00307-00059279-00059450": "you can find it all pretty much on", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00308-00059451-00059582": "scistarter.org", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00309-00059583-00059871": "dot org yeah and um and so we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00310-00059872-00060030": "collaborate with scissor", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00311-00060032-00060366": "for our um sort of as the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00312-00060367-00060559": "cyber infrastructure like the portal the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00313-00060560-00060775": "gateway for our students", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00314-00060776-00060959": "to learn about to have a tutorial to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00315-00060960-00061119": "learn about citizen science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00316-00061120-00061335": "and to um so we can direct them to a few", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00317-00061336-00061479": "projects because honestly", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00318-00061479-00061726": "there's literally um several thousand", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00319-00061727-00061830": "projects", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00320-00061832-00061991": "that are listed on size starter it's two", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00321-00061991-00062191": "it's almost too much and so we have a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00322-00062191-00062350": "special entryway where", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00323-00062351-00062511": "we pick a few focal projects that we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00324-00062512-00062679": "think are good ones to get started with", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00325-00062679-00062903": "or that are ones that are that are nc", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00326-00062904-00063015": "state focused", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00327-00063016-00063254": "and then you know i they're really fun", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00328-00063255-00063423": "too like i've been involved in some like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00329-00063424-00063511": "you know", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00330-00063512-00063766": "uh before we started the the stream we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00331-00063767-00063847": "were talking about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00332-00063848-00064038": "i didn't get to do the one where they", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00333-00064039-00064191": "needed a bunch of people to check their", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00334-00064191-00064366": "belly buttons to check what kind of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00335-00064367-00064526": "bacteria like the actual", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00336-00064527-00064854": "ecosystem of microbiome of your body", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00337-00064855-00065054": "but i did one with the where they they", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00338-00065055-00065199": "did my the armpits", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00339-00065200-00065415": "and and another one where they took face", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00340-00065416-00065575": "mites off my face this was all at the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00341-00065576-00065703": "north carolina museum of natural", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00342-00065704-00065782": "sciences", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00343-00065783-00066159": "to see uh just to compare the face mites", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00344-00066160-00066319": "on my face to the ones people", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00345-00066320-00066511": "in every other state right and other", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00346-00066512-00066655": "countries yeah and those are all great", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00347-00066656-00066903": "they're kind of fun now so the project", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00348-00066904-00067015": "we're here to talk about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00349-00067016-00067135": "it's kind of fun to be laughing about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00350-00067136-00067343": "this it's a little more serious because", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00351-00067344-00067438": "it's it", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00352-00067439-00067694": "it's it's called crowd the tap and it", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00353-00067695-00067815": "concerns", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00354-00067816-00068055": "um the possibility of lead in our", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00355-00068056-00068143": "drinking water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00356-00068144-00068399": "right yeah um so tell me what is this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00357-00068400-00068591": "project and how did you get involved in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00358-00068592-00068638": "it and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00359-00068639-00068743": "yeah and then we're going to actually", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00360-00068744-00068967": "give you a demo um we're going to point", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00361-00068968-00069150": "you towards online resources", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00362-00069151-00069335": "and this is a project we really want you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00363-00069336-00069519": "to take part in we're right", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00364-00069520-00069711": "here yes everybody received an envelope", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00365-00069712-00069919": "like this to help them take part", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00366-00069920-00070182": "so um yeah it's a it's a project funded", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00367-00070183-00070319": "by the epa", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00368-00070320-00070519": "um because it's considered one of epa's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00369-00070520-00070663": "national priorities", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00370-00070664-00070935": "to identify where there's hot spots that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00371-00070936-00070999": "might be", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00372-00071000-00071175": "um at risk of lead and water because", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00373-00071176-00071326": "they don't want to have another flint", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00374-00071327-00071494": "right i think a lot of people heard", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00375-00071495-00071662": "about when there was a lead", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00376-00071663-00071943": "and water crisis in flint michigan um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00377-00071944-00072038": "and the problem is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00378-00072039-00072391": "is that when a lot of the the pipes that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00379-00072392-00072567": "deliver water to our homes", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00380-00072568-00072838": "when they were put into the ground a lot", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00381-00072839-00072999": "of that was before any of these students", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00382-00073000-00073135": "were born it was before there was", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00383-00073136-00073206": "computers", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00384-00073207-00073519": "yeah there's really not good records and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00385-00073520-00073694": "and there's no one keeping those records", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00386-00073695-00073887": "as to where they're located", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00387-00073888-00074167": "um and so uh so that's what crowd the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00388-00074168-00074231": "tap is try", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00389-00074232-00074406": "one of the things that it's trying to do", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00390-00074407-00074591": "is is make people aware of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00391-00074592-00074743": "that there are pipes underground and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00392-00074744-00074926": "that's the source of when there is a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00393-00074927-00075023": "lead problem", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00394-00075024-00075231": "it's not from the water body itself or", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00395-00075232-00075359": "the source of water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00396-00075360-00075591": "it's from the pipes um if there is a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00397-00075592-00075726": "problem and there's the pipes that are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00398-00075727-00075903": "outside your home coming to your home", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00399-00075904-00076038": "and then there's all the pipes within", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00400-00076039-00076247": "your home right right so it's a very", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00401-00076248-00076471": "complicated system most of it's really", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00402-00076472-00076567": "hidden", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00403-00076568-00076759": "and um but it's something and you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00404-00076760-00076919": "literally need the help of people", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00405-00076920-00076975": "because", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00406-00076976-00077175": "because this stuff some of it is on like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00407-00077176-00077431": "municipal or city or property and some", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00408-00077432-00077599": "of it is on private property right", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00409-00077600-00077775": "well yeah we want what's where we're", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00410-00077776-00077943": "actually crowd the tap is focused on", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00411-00077944-00077999": "what's in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00412-00078000-00078223": "private homes i can't go into everyone's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00413-00078224-00078350": "cellar", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00414-00078351-00078638": "and look for that and so um we do ask so", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00415-00078639-00078671": "yeah", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00416-00078672-00078838": "we're definitely this project could not", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00417-00078839-00078975": "happen so let's talk about the tap", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00418-00078976-00079262": "there's more information at crowdtap.org", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00419-00079263-00079623": "um and so it's mostly", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00420-00079624-00079879": "like what we're talking about is two", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00421-00079880-00080126": "things one is like looking at your", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00422-00080127-00080399": "pipes to see what kind of pipes they are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00423-00080400-00080462": "well i'll say", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00424-00080463-00080647": "when you go to crowdthetap.org there's a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00425-00080648-00080838": "button for reporting data", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00426-00080839-00081103": "and on that it's really five simple tabs", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00427-00081104-00081255": "five steps and one is just giving", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00428-00081256-00081326": "consent", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00429-00081327-00081526": "it's a big heavy duty kind of consent", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00430-00081527-00081759": "thing um and if you're under 18 you also", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00431-00081760-00081967": "need to have your parents give consent", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00432-00081968-00082191": "um and in that you can decide who you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00433-00082192-00082311": "want to share the data with you share it", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00434-00082312-00082431": "with the research team you can share it", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00435-00082432-00082543": "with your utility", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00436-00082544-00082871": "share it um with epa what not anyway but", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00437-00082872-00083015": "then yeah it's information about your", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00438-00083016-00083223": "home like how old is the home", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00439-00083224-00083391": "and also demographics of the home", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00440-00083392-00083494": "because we really want to know if", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00441-00083495-00083567": "there's any", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00442-00083568-00083782": "sort of economic or racial disparities", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00443-00083783-00084023": "and who has risk of lead and water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00444-00084024-00084199": "then there's one about the pipes and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00445-00084200-00084343": "that's the really important one about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00446-00084344-00084518": "what kind of pipes you have in your home", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00447-00084519-00084550": "and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00448-00084551-00084767": "for your service line and then there's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00449-00084768-00084879": "one about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00450-00084880-00085094": "the water itself like how does it taste", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00451-00085095-00085238": "how does it smell does it have little", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00452-00085239-00085479": "floaties in it like those kind of things", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00453-00085480-00085743": "and then there's the water chemistry uh", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00454-00085744-00085782": "which", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00455-00085783-00085999": "we're going to do and talk about it and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00456-00086000-00086094": "also for more", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00457-00086095-00086431": "there are some videos oh yeah a star an", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00458-00086432-00086711": "amazing science comedian", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00459-00086712-00086879": "there are some videos on the crowd the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00460-00086880-00087087": "tap sorry instructional videos", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00461-00087088-00087335": "that that'll that'll that are going to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00462-00087336-00087526": "walk you through all of that the form", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00463-00087527-00087759": "um and then here so we actually have two", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00464-00087760-00087879": "jars of water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00465-00087880-00088150": "so that we can both do this right so", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00466-00088151-00088182": "this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00467-00088183-00088391": "uh the video will explain this as well", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00468-00088392-00088655": "but there's a water chemistry test", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00469-00088656-00088918": "um that starts with these strip tests", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00470-00088919-00089047": "right that we dipped for five", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00471-00089048-00089182": "so you want to see we're not just", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00472-00089183-00089375": "testing for lead here oh we're not even", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00473-00089376-00089415": "testing", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00474-00089416-00089623": "we're not testing for lead this is about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00475-00089624-00089823": "the chemical properties of water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00476-00089824-00090111": "that help us predict and sort of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00477-00090112-00090182": "estimate", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00478-00090183-00090406": "the risk of lead in water and so that's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00479-00090407-00090535": "the challenge here", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00480-00090536-00090694": "actually i'm glad you brought that up is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00481-00090695-00090935": "that is that not everyone can test their", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00482-00090936-00091031": "water for lead", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00483-00091032-00091318": "it's really expensive it requires a lab", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00484-00091319-00091575": "um the off-the-shelf kits are really not", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00485-00091576-00091726": "accurate including this one when it", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00486-00091727-00091838": "comes to lead", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00487-00091839-00092006": "and so what we've been doing is building", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00488-00092007-00092175": "a model where if we know the type of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00489-00092176-00092303": "pipes if you tell us the type of pipes", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00490-00092304-00092431": "the type of home", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00491-00092432-00092718": "and some simple water chemistry when we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00492-00092719-00092855": "can give we're starting to be able to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00493-00092856-00093031": "give a pretty good estimate", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00494-00093032-00093167": "of whether you should go get your water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00495-00093168-00093335": "tested and whether you might have", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00496-00093336-00093550": "have leg so the basic idea is here is we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00497-00093551-00093767": "dip this uh you might you need a glass", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00498-00093768-00093982": "of water that's at least as tall as this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00499-00093983-00094047": "strip", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00500-00094048-00094335": "as all the colored marks on the strip", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00501-00094336-00094503": "and then you dip it in for about five", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00502-00094504-00094847": "seconds", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00503-00094848-00095118": "and then after the five seconds you just", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00504-00095119-00095262": "set it aside", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00505-00095263-00095447": "you kind of like lay it for about 60", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00506-00095448-00095615": "seconds", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00507-00095616-00095799": "now i'm eventually like why don't you go", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00508-00095800-00096047": "ahead and put yours in there okay", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00509-00096048-00096406": "you're really like i said we're gonna", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00510-00096407-00096687": "wait if you were really doing this you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00511-00096688-00096894": "would wait 60 seconds", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00512-00096895-00097199": "yeah let's see that's good and then you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00513-00097200-00097431": "put it in this little square so", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00514-00097432-00097831": "you'll get this form and this is a key", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00515-00097832-00098159": "um and after 60 seconds", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00516-00098160-00098343": "these may have changed to some slightly", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00517-00098344-00098462": "different shades", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00518-00098463-00098638": "and you just in each row want to match", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00519-00098639-00098774": "them", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00520-00098775-00098959": "to the yeah you're gonna you're gonna", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00521-00098960-00099126": "match it to the closest one", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00522-00099127-00099279": "and a lot of times they're gonna be low", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00523-00099280-00099503": "values so they might not change too much", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00524-00099504-00099726": "um and some might be hard to match uh", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00525-00099727-00099855": "and that's okay", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00526-00099856-00100062": "um just go to the closest do the best", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00527-00100063-00100199": "and so um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00528-00100200-00100335": "you know here i might choose i might", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00529-00100336-00100559": "choose one for most of these so far", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00530-00100560-00100791": "maybe for this one i'm gonna move over a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00531-00100792-00100935": "little bit further to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00532-00100936-00101135": "column three but anyway you look at the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00533-00101136-00101271": "column", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00534-00101272-00101399": "and then you come over here to get the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00535-00101400-00101679": "value for that row so if it's column one", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00536-00101680-00101926": "i come over here and it's a zero so my", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00537-00101927-00102094": "alkalinity", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00538-00102095-00102510": "is zero and my ph actually is probably", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00539-00102511-00102727": "um it's not even recording right but i'm", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00540-00102728-00102871": "gonna have to choose", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00541-00102872-00103190": "the um 6.0 and you go", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00542-00103191-00103542": "on down the list um matching the colors", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00543-00103543-00103686": "to the appropriate column and then", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00544-00103688-00103839": "coming over to that number and reading", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00545-00103840-00103894": "it cool", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00546-00103895-00104142": "and you'll also right here's a really", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00547-00104143-00104239": "key part", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00548-00104240-00104415": "is when you take a picture and you want", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00549-00104416-00104599": "to get that whole box", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00550-00104600-00104927": "of the key of the key and the um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00551-00104928-00105302": "the chemistry strip and then", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00552-00105303-00105583": "that you'll upload with all of your", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00553-00105583-00105743": "other information", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00554-00105744-00105966": "on the chemistry tab and crowd the tap", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00555-00105967-00106127": "and that's after you you you will have", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00556-00106128-00106190": "put your name", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00557-00106191-00106534": "in here and you will put the values um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00558-00106535-00106743": "so and and this is one way that you're", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00559-00106744-00106839": "oops", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00560-00106840-00107127": "one way that you are sort of like you're", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00561-00107128-00107278": "having the citizen science do", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00562-00107279-00107534": "test do the work but then you're getting", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00563-00107535-00107719": "this verification", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00564-00107720-00107934": "you're getting their data you're taking", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00565-00107935-00108071": "their photo", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00566-00108072-00108334": "are these any different mostly were", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00567-00108335-00108471": "these two different sources of water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00568-00108472-00108647": "what were your two water sources here", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00569-00108648-00108823": "one was fresh from the tap and one was a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00570-00108824-00109190": "brita filter", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00571-00109191-00109366": "so do we know much about does dubrota", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00572-00109367-00109519": "filters", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00573-00109520-00109719": "well they do filters like that i mean", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00574-00109720-00109847": "filters like that do help", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00575-00109848-00110151": "um yeah with uh some can help with lead", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00576-00110152-00110247": "and they also", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00577-00110248-00110390": "i mean they filter out fluorine and some", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00578-00110391-00110623": "of these things yeah", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00579-00110624-00110927": "excellent so um i wonder", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00580-00110928-00111190": "if we i know we had some questions sent", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00581-00111191-00111366": "in earlier", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00582-00111367-00111727": "um and i have a few already", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00583-00111728-00112047": "uh one there was one and i thought we'd", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00584-00112048-00112199": "ask you one bird question", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00585-00112200-00112366": "which is what bird population has", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00586-00112367-00112566": "contributed the most amount of evidence", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00587-00112567-00112783": "towards the effects of climate change in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00588-00112783-00112943": "the local community that's from jackie", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00589-00112944-00113063": "thank you for the question", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00590-00113064-00113383": "yeah okay is there any population that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00591-00113383-00113654": "i'm going to give it a tie i mean we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00592-00113655-00113799": "know it from a lot of birds have been", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00593-00113800-00113975": "used in studying climate change but i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00594-00113976-00114119": "would point out too", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00595-00114120-00114366": "in the u.s it's tree swallows trees", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00596-00114367-00114495": "swallow populations that have been", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00597-00114496-00114615": "studied across the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00598-00114616-00114863": "uh at least across yeah a lot of the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00599-00114864-00114951": "continent", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00600-00114952-00115151": "and then in europe um it's really the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00601-00115152-00115302": "pied fly catcher", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00602-00115303-00115631": "um and and so yeah i mean those and what", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00603-00115632-00115702": "is it about", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00604-00115703-00115839": "that you know what it is they're changed", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00605-00115840-00116015": "habits they're changing", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00606-00116016-00116231": "well one those two species are fairly", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00607-00116232-00116399": "easy to study because they nest", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00608-00116400-00116710": "in uh in birdhouses and so then that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00609-00116711-00116863": "just right there makes them pretty easy", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00610-00116864-00116927": "to study", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00611-00116928-00117071": "and people have been studying them for", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00612-00117072-00117310": "so many years for centuries nesting in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00613-00117311-00117407": "the top of a tree", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00614-00117408-00117583": "yeah or something yeah out on a limb", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00615-00117583-00117799": "somewhere but a birdhouse that's you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00616-00117800-00117919": "know the same height as you can just", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00617-00117920-00118095": "open it up and see what's happening", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00618-00118096-00118302": "um but yeah and so they've been", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00619-00118303-00118486": "monitored people have uh", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00620-00118488-00118719": "monitored them for so long that that's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00621-00118720-00118902": "contributed a lot to our understanding", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00622-00118903-00119039": "of climate change that the birds are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00623-00119040-00119223": "breeding earlier um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00624-00119224-00119495": "differences in uh timing of migration", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00625-00119496-00119590": "differences in", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00626-00119591-00119799": "range distributions all kinds of things", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00627-00119800-00119895": "yeah", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00628-00119896-00120110": "ryan asks what is one thing we can do", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00629-00120111-00120247": "daily to help", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00630-00120248-00120599": "fight climate change yeah okay", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00631-00120600-00120823": "so and that's that's a really good", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00632-00120824-00120902": "question", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00633-00120903-00121190": "and it is important for people to to do", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00634-00121191-00121366": "what they can to make a difference", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00635-00121367-00121607": "should we try to exhale less if we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00636-00121608-00121783": "breathe a little less", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00637-00121783-00122007": "i think um i mean some of the big things", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00638-00122008-00122183": "that give us a big carbon footprint are", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00639-00122183-00122263": "things like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00640-00122264-00122583": "air travel yeah um uh", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00641-00122583-00122943": "things uh yeah but other things can be", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00642-00122944-00123254": "like um living lower on the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00643-00123255-00123495": "food web so like less meat more", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00644-00123496-00123695": "plant-based diet can help", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00645-00123696-00123878": "um so there's things to reduce the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00646-00123879-00124031": "carbon footprint and there's a lot of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00647-00124032-00124134": "little calculations", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00648-00124135-00124271": "if you're a multi-billion dollar", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00649-00124272-00124486": "conglomerate you could what could you do", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00650-00124488-00124614": "on a daily basis", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00651-00124615-00124799": "and more important is probably to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00652-00124800-00124951": "pressure for changes", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00653-00124952-00125207": "yeah to ride the structures of our of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00654-00125208-00125310": "our economy", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00655-00125311-00125543": "yeah um once again i want to say like if", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00656-00125544-00125623": "you have a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00657-00125624-00125734": "new question we had some questions", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00658-00125735-00125943": "submitted um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00659-00125944-00126199": "uh previously but if you have any", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00660-00126200-00126439": "questions regarding citizen science", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00661-00126440-00126719": "or crowd the tap specifically what else", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00662-00126720-00126847": "do we need them to know about crowd the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00663-00126848-00126886": "tap", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00664-00126888-00127090": "by the way we want you to go to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00665-00127091-00127271": "crowdthetap.org", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00666-00127272-00127654": "um watch the instructional videos", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00667-00127655-00127775": "everybody got that yeah and i've seen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00668-00127776-00127927": "that there's been several hundred", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00669-00127928-00127990": "students", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00670-00127991-00128271": "who have already submitted data um to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00671-00128272-00128358": "crowd that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00672-00128359-00128486": "crowd the tap and they've clearly", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00673-00128488-00128614": "watched the videos because they've done", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00674-00128615-00128702": "everything", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00675-00128703-00129007": "really awesome so thank you um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00676-00129008-00129190": "and it is important can we you want to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00677-00129191-00129310": "stress that point again", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00678-00129311-00129534": "that that this isn't just that this is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00679-00129535-00129871": "real this is your research project", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00680-00129872-00130014": "and you're asking them to take this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00681-00130015-00130247": "seriously it's not", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00682-00130248-00130486": "it can be fun and everything but i mean", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00683-00130488-00130639": "it's not just my research too i mean", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00684-00130640-00130847": "it's really is for like um", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00685-00130848-00131031": "our state uh department of environmental", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00686-00131032-00131271": "quality is very interested in the data", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00687-00131272-00131454": "as part of their needs assessment right", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00688-00131455-00131583": "they go to the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00689-00131584-00131839": "epa every few years and they say hey", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00690-00131840-00131983": "these are the needs that we have in this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00691-00131984-00132047": "state", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00692-00132048-00132231": "for replacing cert you know service", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00693-00132232-00132431": "lines doing repairs and whatnot", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00694-00132432-00132678": "um so it really what we hope is that the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00695-00132679-00132847": "patterns that we can see", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00696-00132848-00133054": "um really get put into action but i do", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00697-00133055-00133214": "want to emphasize too it doesn't mean", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00698-00133215-00133399": "that you have lead and we want people to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00699-00133400-00133511": "report data", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00700-00133512-00133719": "even if they don't have lead that is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00701-00133720-00133839": "just as important", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00702-00133840-00134135": "to know who is safe from lead as knowing", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00703-00134136-00134278": "who's at risk from lead", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00704-00134279-00134463": "so we really just want to have as many", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00705-00134464-00134631": "areas of the state represented as", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00706-00134632-00134695": "possible", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00707-00134696-00134902": "you want as many data points as possible", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00708-00134903-00135054": "and that means that it's just as", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00709-00135055-00135159": "important", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00710-00135160-00135423": "whatever the result is it's a data point", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00711-00135424-00135502": "that you need", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00712-00135503-00135702": "right if you only took all the positive", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00713-00135703-00135831": "ones then you wouldn't", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00714-00135832-00136007": "that wouldn't mean it wouldn't be as", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00715-00136008-00136183": "good so yeah you might have plastic", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00716-00136184-00136399": "pipes and totally safe water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00717-00136400-00136735": "we want to know about that um i know we", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00718-00136736-00137014": "have here's another question from will", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00719-00137015-00137271": "in your experience what is the wicked", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00720-00137272-00137359": "problem", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00721-00137360-00137590": "or motivating incentive that gets the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00722-00137591-00137711": "most amount", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00723-00137712-00138047": "of everyday citizens to take action", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00724-00138048-00138327": "yeah so i mean i think now like the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00725-00138328-00138439": "biggest wicked problem", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00726-00138440-00138727": "is related to climate change and i think", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00727-00138728-00138902": "like in terms of what motivates people", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00728-00138903-00139063": "to take action really", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00729-00139064-00139247": "a lot of times it varies with age like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00730-00139248-00139454": "somebody", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00731-00139455-00139639": "yes what does that do you know it varies", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00732-00139640-00139799": "with age like people found like a lot of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00733-00139800-00139943": "really young kids", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00734-00139944-00140263": "um get very motivated by um when they", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00735-00140264-00140383": "learn that animals", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00736-00140384-00140575": "or nature is being affected by climate", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00737-00140576-00140775": "change right like polar bears or", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00738-00140776-00141007": "you know other like charismatic um you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00739-00141008-00141135": "know fauna", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00740-00141136-00141359": "but then as people get older they tend", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00741-00141360-00141519": "to get more concerned with other issues", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00742-00141520-00141766": "with other with people being displaced", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00743-00141767-00141919": "with national security issues with", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00744-00141920-00142183": "economic issues just more with about the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00745-00142184-00142375": "sort of the human theme and actually", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00746-00142376-00142519": "we've seen that with our students too", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00747-00142520-00142639": "because they're kind of", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00748-00142640-00142847": "just transitioning from like being young", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00749-00142848-00142966": "into being adults and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00750-00142967-00143190": "see them across that whole spectrum", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00751-00143191-00143311": "rohan asks", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00752-00143312-00143471": "how could we get our hands on more kits", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00753-00143472-00143711": "for crowd to tap would we be allowed to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00754-00143712-00143926": "distribute them to our friends or family", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00755-00143927-00144135": "out of state or would there be any legal", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00756-00144136-00144326": "issues is this just for north carolina", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00757-00144327-00144407": "yeah no it is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00758-00144408-00144726": "national and anyone that wants", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00759-00144727-00145063": "um more of these kits just needs to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00760-00145064-00145135": "write to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00761-00145136-00145471": "crowd the tap at ncsu.edu", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00762-00145472-00145759": "that's our email and we will send them", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00763-00145760-00145911": "um and we can send you a bunch if you", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00764-00145912-00146047": "want to distribute them", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00765-00146048-00146359": "we also have a crowd the tap we call the", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00766-00146360-00146495": "ambassador program", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00767-00146496-00146743": "which is for undergraduate students and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00768-00146744-00146807": "they can get", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00769-00146808-00147071": "um research experience uh like credits", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00770-00147072-00147199": "academic credit", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00771-00147200-00147423": "as undergraduate research experiences", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00772-00147424-00147583": "being ambassadors", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00773-00147584-00147735": "it's particularly good in summer when", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00774-00147736-00147911": "you're back home and we just ask", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00775-00147912-00148143": "people to recruit about a dozen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00776-00148144-00148263": "neighbors or", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00777-00148264-00148463": "people like in a community group that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00778-00148464-00148599": "want to do the project and then", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00779-00148600-00148871": "help them you know like distribute kits", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00780-00148872-00148983": "and whatnot", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00781-00148984-00149166": "yeah and what's the size of the you've", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00782-00149167-00149351": "been doing this a little while is it is", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00783-00149352-00149463": "there anything", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00784-00149464-00149647": "like what's the status of the project or", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00785-00149648-00149807": "do you have any results or anything", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00786-00149808-00150071": "yet um is it too early for them it's a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00787-00150072-00150119": "little", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00788-00150120-00150495": "early to to to have that um we do have", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00789-00150496-00150711": "the beginnings of a model that predicts", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00790-00150712-00151054": "risk of lead and water we have uh", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00791-00151055-00151319": "we are beginning to see um what looks", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00792-00151320-00151399": "like", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00793-00151400-00151759": "some um some really unfortunate", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00794-00151760-00151975": "disparities related to race and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00795-00151976-00152263": "economics in terms of who's most at risk", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00796-00152264-00152526": "in certain counties that are um more", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00797-00152527-00152671": "more likely to have sort of this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00798-00152672-00152807": "environmental justice", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00799-00152808-00153119": "problems um and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00800-00153120-00153247": "i mean i guess i'll say an exciting", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00801-00153248-00153399": "thing that happened in the lab i", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00802-00153400-00153671": "mentioned that the off-the-shelf kits", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00803-00153672-00154071": "are not really that accurate and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00804-00154072-00154326": "in the lab um this is up at virginia", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00805-00154327-00154375": "tech", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00806-00154376-00154583": "researchers have developed a very simple", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00807-00154584-00154702": "little hack", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00808-00154703-00154854": "that people can do with their drinking", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00809-00154855-00155071": "water that makes those off-the-shelf", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00810-00155072-00155166": "kids", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00811-00155167-00155495": "accurate right and um and so we're", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00812-00155496-00155671": "actually going to pilot test that this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00813-00155672-00155743": "fall", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00814-00155744-00156014": "with school teachers across the country", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00815-00156015-00156166": "um because we want to make sure it works", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00816-00156167-00156231": "in the field", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00817-00156232-00156439": "it seems like it works in the lab works", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00818-00156440-00156566": "under different conditions", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00819-00156567-00156735": "but we need to field test it with real", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00820-00156736-00156959": "water systems real world conditions", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00821-00156960-00157126": "and then if that becomes the case if", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00822-00157127-00157335": "that holds up then that means that", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00823-00157336-00157575": "anybody will be able to provide get a", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00824-00157576-00157759": "really accurate test as to whether they", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00825-00157760-00157911": "have lead and water", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00826-00157912-00158102": "that's an exciting thing horizon karen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00827-00158103-00158263": "cooper thank you very much and it's", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00828-00158264-00158514": "crowd the tap uh do people want to go to", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00829-00158515-00158631": "crowdtap.org", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00830-00158632-00158943": "yep um and scisstarter and this", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00831-00158944-00159175": "is actually the final week of wicked", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00832-00159176-00159414": "problems uh wolfpack solutions and", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00833-00159415-00159647": "some people may be completing the course", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00834-00159648-00159975": "now uh as this ends so congratulations", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00835-00159976-00160214": "and and others working at their own pace", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00836-00160215-00160366": "uh we'll finish it soon", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00837-00160367-00160614": "so uh thanks for joining us uh karen", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00838-00160615-00160678": "cooper", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00839-00160679-00160871": "and does the wicked problem worldpack", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00840-00160872-00160999": "solutions team", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00841-00161000-00161214": "want to jump in here and and wrap things", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00842-00161215-00161302": "up for us", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00843-00161303-00163983": "and thank you very much", "i0b4kSrpLFQ-00844-00163984-00164191": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i1IDhV8HGuA", "text": {"i1IDhV8HGuA-00000-00000000-00000275": "welcome to practice questions Stephen", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00001-00000276-00000580": "Thames", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00002-00000581-00001212": "thank you Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00003-00001213-00001523": "Mr Speaker I know the house will join", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00004-00001524-00001655": "the nation in the Commonwealth in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00005-00001655-00001907": "sending our very best wishes to their", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00006-00001907-00002075": "majesties the king and queen", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00007-00002076-00002387": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00008-00002388-00002591": "this will be a moment of extraordinary", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00009-00002592-00002807": "national pride a demonstration of our", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00010-00002808-00003005": "country's character and an opportunity", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00011-00003006-00003233": "to look to the Future in the spirit of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00012-00003234-00003563": "service unity and hope Mr Speaker this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00013-00003564-00003713": "morning I had meetings with ministerial", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00014-00003714-00003886": "colleagues and others in addition to my", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00015-00003888-00004054": "duties in this house I shall have", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00016-00004055-00004277": "further such meetings later today so", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00017-00004278-00004393": "stupid", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00018-00004394-00004781": "question time last week column 725 the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00019-00004782-00004972": "Prime Minister referred to record", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00020-00004973-00005327": "numbers of people in work in fact as he", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00021-00005328-00005501": "knows the number of people in work at", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00022-00005502-00005651": "the moment are still less than it was", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00023-00005652-00006006": "just before the pandemic 122", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00024-00006007-00006238": "792 less according to the latest", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00025-00006239-00006605": "official figures will he reassure the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00026-00006606-00006784": "house that he's not slipping into the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00027-00006786-00007105": "bad ways of his predecessor but one", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00028-00007106-00007367": "and will he properly correct the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00029-00007368-00007655": "incorrect statement he made last week", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00030-00007656-00007937": "well Mr Mr Speaker that clarification", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00031-00007938-00008170": "has already been made uh Mr Speaker and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00032-00008172-00008309": "Hansard but there are near record", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00033-00008310-00008585": "numbers of people in work and in payroll", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00034-00008586-00008807": "and that is thanks that is thanks to the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00035-00008808-00008999": "actions of this government Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00036-00009000-00009364": "one record we're very proud of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00037-00009365-00009556": "very much Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00038-00009557-00009845": "um non-compliant hand car washes seem", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00039-00009846-00010091": "like a cheap and quick way to have our", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00040-00010092-00010306": "cars washed but unfortunately behind", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00041-00010307-00010583": "this 1.8 billion pound industry is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00042-00010584-00010864": "hidden money laundering fraud drug", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00043-00010865-00011087": "dealing prostitution labor abuse modern", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00044-00011088-00011351": "day slavery tax avoidance and many other", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00045-00011352-00011537": "Sinister crimes", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00046-00011538-00011735": "um this is an estimated half a billion", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00047-00011736-00012028": "pound lost in tax revenue a pull factor", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00048-00012029-00012281": "for illegal migration and the pollutants", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00049-00012282-00012431": "of the news are damaging to the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00050-00012432-00012587": "environment does the Prime Minister", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00051-00012588-00012773": "agree with me but it's time that we now", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00052-00012774-00012988": "step away from the voluntary scheme and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00053-00012989-00013180": "have a mandatory scheme to protect", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00054-00013181-00013261": "people", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00055-00013262-00013541": "well Mr Speaker we expect all businesses", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00056-00013541-00013769": "to follow the law including providing", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00057-00013769-00013985": "Fair pay and working conditions for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00058-00013986-00014165": "their employees we're tackling", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00059-00014166-00014308": "exploitation in the labor market", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00060-00014309-00014519": "especially by increasing funding for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00061-00014519-00014771": "enforcement bodies to over 35 million", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00062-00014772-00014975": "pounds a year and we will continue to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00063-00014976-00015155": "keep the position of hand car washes", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00064-00015156-00015419": "under close review but how come the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00065-00015419-00015829": "leader of the opposition", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00066-00015830-00016061": "thank you Mr Speaker can I join the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00067-00016062-00016283": "prime minister in his comments about the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00068-00016284-00016517": "coronation across the house we're all", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00069-00016518-00016733": "looking forward to the celebrations this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00070-00016734-00016867": "weekend", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00071-00016868-00017141": "Mr Speaker does the Prime Minister know", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00072-00017142-00017399": "how many mortgage payers are paying", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00073-00017400-00017627": "higher rates since the Tory party", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00074-00017628-00018019": "crashed the economy last autumn", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00075-00018020-00018358": "Mr Speaker our record our record on home", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00076-00018359-00018586": "ownership is crystal clear because of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00077-00018587-00018958": "our tax cuts 90 of first-time buyers now", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00078-00018959-00019222": "don't pay any stamp duty at all Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00079-00019223-00019558": "Speaker and last year we saw the largest", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00080-00019559-00019811": "number of people buying their first home", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00081-00019812-00020153": "in 20 years Mr Speaker that's a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00082-00020154-00020308": "conservative government delivering on", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00083-00020309-00020489": "people's aspirations to own their own", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00084-00020490-00020641": "home", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00085-00020642-00020879": "Mr Speaker the question was how many", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00086-00020880-00020999": "people are paying more on their", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00087-00021000-00021263": "mortgages each month and the answer that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00088-00021264-00021725": "the Prime Minister avoided giving is 850", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00089-00021726-00022019": "000. nearly a million people paying more", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00090-00022020-00022277": "on their mortgage each month because his", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00091-00022278-00022619": "party used their money as a casino chip", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00092-00022620-00022841": "that's why George Osborne called them", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00093-00022842-00023105": "economic vandals who created a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00094-00023106-00023344": "self-inflicted financial crisis", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00095-00023345-00023525": "not not for the Prime Minister and his", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00096-00023526-00023711": "non-dom thing", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00097-00023712-00023950": "not for the super wealthy they gave tax", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00098-00023951-00024263": "cuts to but for mortgage holders all", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00099-00024264-00024550": "across the country", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00100-00024551-00024863": "so does the Prime Minister know how many", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00101-00024864-00025114": "more people will be joining them on", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00102-00025115-00025378": "higher mortgage rates by the end of this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00103-00025379-00026423": "year", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00104-00026424-00026674": "of inflation have now eased to a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00105-00026675-00026939": "15-month low Mr Speaker consumer", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00106-00026939-00027118": "confidence is at the highest level that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00107-00027119-00027617": "it's been at since Russia invaded", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00108-00027618-00027857": "euclids we can see a clear way to reduce", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00109-00027858-00028049": "debt and bring interest rates down but", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00110-00028050-00028193": "Mr Speaker he keeps in this habit of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00111-00028194-00028396": "quoting the former labor Shadow chances", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00112-00028397-00028570": "we know that our plans will deliver", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00113-00028572-00028762": "lower inflation and lower interest rates", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00114-00028763-00029062": "but we know we know that his plans his", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00115-00029063-00029417": "plans just mean more debt Mr Speaker and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00116-00029418-00029729": "I quote and I quote year after year", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00117-00029730-00030017": "after year those aren't my words that's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00118-00030018-00030190": "the assessment of the former labor", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00119-00030191-00030481": "Shadow Chancellor", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00120-00030482-00030761": "Mr Speaker the question was how many", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00121-00030762-00030899": "more people this year are going to be", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00122-00030900-00031096": "paying more on their mortgages", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00123-00031097-00031252": "and the answer that he avoided giving", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00124-00031254-00031481": "again he knows these answers he's got", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00125-00031482-00031852": "the stats there in front of him 930", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00126-00031854-00032152": "000 people so by the end of this year I", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00127-00032154-00032261": "know they don't want to talk about it", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00128-00032262-00032387": "that's why he won't answer the questions", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00129-00032388-00032705": "by the end of this year nearly two", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00130-00032706-00032974": "million homeowners counting the cost of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00131-00032975-00033209": "the tourist economic vandalism with", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00132-00033210-00033461": "every mortgage payment they make", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00133-00033462-00033652": "and it's not just those who already own", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00134-00033653-00033862": "their home that are counting the cost of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00135-00033863-00034109": "Tory recklessness the average deposit", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00136-00034110-00034468": "for a first-time buyer is going up to 9", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00137-00034469-00034601": "000 pounds", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00138-00034602-00034793": "does he even know how long it would take", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00139-00034794-00035068": "an average saver to put that sort of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00140-00035069-00035680": "money aside", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00141-00035681-00036112": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00142-00036113-00036407": "Mr Speaker it's why we're helping people", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00143-00036408-00036593": "in social housing own their own home", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00144-00036594-00036815": "through our first homes and our shared", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00145-00036816-00037079": "home ownership schemes but Mr Speaker I", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00146-00037080-00037240": "said like I said these things are", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00147-00037241-00037481": "working because I said last year we had", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00148-00037482-00037762": "a record number of first-time buyers the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00149-00037763-00038009": "highest number in 20 years it was Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00150-00038010-00038285": "speaker twice the number of first-time", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00151-00038286-00038549": "buyers then labor ever managed Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00152-00038550-00038783": "Speaker so whilst labor failed", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00153-00038784-00038939": "homeowners the conservatives are", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00154-00038940-00039136": "delivering for them", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00155-00039137-00039823": "[Music]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00156-00039824-00040168": "and every week he does so he reinforces", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00157-00040169-00040439": "just how out of touch he is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00158-00040440-00040696": "nine thousand pounds hahaha nine", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00159-00040697-00040901": "thousand pounds would take four years", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00160-00040902-00041285": "they think it's funny that hope nine", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00161-00041286-00041627": "thousand four years four years for the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00162-00041628-00041837": "average saver to save nine thousand", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00163-00041838-00042017": "pounds or or to put it a different way", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00164-00042018-00042155": "in terms the Prime Minister will", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00165-00042156-00042401": "understand roughly the annual Bill to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00166-00042402-00042637": "heat his swimming pool", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00167-00042638-00043511": "but for most people for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00168-00043512-00043751": "and now he's kicking them when they're", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00169-00043752-00044033": "down because his decision to scrap", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00170-00044034-00044315": "housing targets is killing the dream of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00171-00044316-00044621": "home ownership for a generation why", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00172-00044622-00044801": "doesn't admit he got it wrong and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00173-00044802-00044983": "reverse it", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00174-00044984-00045305": "Mr Speaker I promise to put local people", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00175-00045306-00045605": "in control of new housing and I'm proud", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00176-00045606-00045749": "that that's what I delivered within six", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00177-00045750-00045995": "weeks of becoming prime minister now he", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00178-00045996-00046349": "wants to impose top-down housing targets", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00179-00046350-00046595": "he wants a concrete over the green belt", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00180-00046596-00046805": "and ride roughshod over local", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00181-00046806-00047111": "communities now previously Mr Speaker he", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00182-00047112-00047333": "did say he's on record and saying local", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00183-00047334-00047561": "people local communities should have", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00184-00047562-00047837": "more power more control now he's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00185-00047838-00048161": "u-turned just another in a long list of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00186-00048162-00048496": "broken promises", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00187-00048497-00048701": "Mr Speaker the only Power he's given to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00188-00048702-00048917": "local communities not to build houses", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00189-00048918-00049108": "and we know why he won't change course", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00190-00049109-00049445": "he admitted it last month his counselors", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00191-00049446-00049624": "simply don't want to build the houses", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00192-00049625-00049907": "local people need so he's given them a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00193-00049908-00050033": "way out", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00194-00050034-00050218": "picture of the scene as he explains this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00195-00050219-00050495": "to a family mum and dad paying", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00196-00050496-00050705": "foreground extra on the mortgage because", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00197-00050706-00050968": "the tourists tanked the economy their", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00198-00050969-00051179": "eldest paying hundreds more in rent", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00199-00051180-00051442": "their youngest still stuck in the spare", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00200-00051444-00051664": "room because they need an extra 9 000", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00201-00051665-00051964": "pounds for a deposit so then along times", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00202-00051965-00052192": "the Prime Minister and merrily tells", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00203-00052194-00052294": "them", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00204-00052295-00052535": "sorry for crashing the economy we don't", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00205-00052536-00052853": "want to talk about that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00206-00052854-00053026": "sorry I can't help you with the house", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00207-00053027-00053441": "building", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00208-00053441-00053699": "go here's a massive council tax increase", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00209-00053700-00053980": "for your troubles while Destiny stop the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00210-00053982-00054275": "excuses stop blaming everyone else and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00211-00054276-00054694": "just build some houses instead", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00212-00054695-00055091": "Mr Speaker our memories on on that short", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00213-00055091-00055229": "we all know what happened last time", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00214-00055229-00055385": "where they're in power there was no", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00215-00055386-00055847": "money left for the country", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00216-00055848-00056069": "about the record let's talk about the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00217-00056070-00056242": "labor record on house building Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00218-00056244-00056476": "Speaker in London the former", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00219-00056477-00056699": "conservative mayor built 60", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00220-00056700-00056938": "000 affordable homes in his first five", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00221-00056939-00057130": "years in office how many do the current", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00222-00057132-00057454": "labor labor mayor manage half of that Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00223-00057455-00057599": "Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00224-00057600-00057923": "in in Wales we need 12 000 new homes a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00225-00057924-00058097": "year how many of Labor built in the last", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00226-00058098-00058391": "year half of that Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00227-00058391-00058649": "as ever labor talk and the conservatives", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00228-00058650-00058701": "deliver", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00229-00058702-00058985": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00230-00058986-00059423": "speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00231-00059424-00059800": "debt doubled since 2010 growth down tax", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00232-00059801-00060041": "up the economy crashed Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00233-00060041-00060299": "they're gonna need a bigger note", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00234-00060300-00060738": "foreign", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00235-00060739-00061037": "we debate the issues facing in this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00236-00061038-00061132": "place", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00237-00061133-00061379": "but", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00238-00061379-00061594": "but looking beyond the elections", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00239-00061595-00061876": "tomorrow we also have a hugely", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00240-00061877-00062057": "significant weekend coming up with the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00241-00062058-00062207": "king's coronation", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00242-00062208-00062435": "for most this will be the first time", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00243-00062436-00062692": "they've seen a monarch crown and I hope", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00244-00062694-00062873": "and I know across the Hope House people", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00245-00062874-00063071": "will hope that people across the country", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00246-00063072-00063316": "enjoy the ceremony the street parties", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00247-00063317-00063594": "and of course the extra day off", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00248-00063595-00064007": "300 million will tune in the world will", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00249-00064008-00064229": "see our country at its best", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00250-00064229-00064469": "celebrating the beginning of a new", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00251-00064470-00064675": "chapter in our history", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00252-00064676-00064966": "but it will also be a reminder of the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00253-00064967-00065332": "loss of our late Queen Elizabeth II", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00254-00065333-00065632": "and a chance again to remember all that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00255-00065633-00065837": "she gave to our country through her", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00256-00065838-00066035": "dedicated service", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00257-00066036-00066256": "so will a prime minister join me in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00258-00066257-00066538": "honoring our late Queen and wishing the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00259-00066539-00066816": "new king a long unhappy Reign", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00260-00066817-00066949": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00261-00066950-00067361": "Mr Mr Speaker as as I said at the outset", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00262-00067362-00067594": "we're all looking very much forward to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00263-00067595-00067732": "the coronation it will be a very special", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00264-00067733-00068032": "moment in the history of our country and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00265-00068033-00068147": "I know that we will join with the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00266-00068148-00068344": "country in celebrating it but before we", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00267-00068345-00068513": "get to the coronation weekend Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00268-00068514-00068753": "we have an important day tomorrow and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00269-00068754-00069017": "the choice before the country is clear", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00270-00069018-00069263": "when they go to that Ballot Box they can", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00271-00069264-00069455": "see a party that stands for higher", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00272-00069456-00069809": "council tax higher crime and a Litany of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00273-00069810-00070121": "broken promises Mr Speaker Meanwhile", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00274-00070122-00070300": "we're getting on with delivering what we", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00275-00070301-00070559": "say with a lower council tax lower crime", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00276-00070560-00070817": "and fewer potholes the choice is clear", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00277-00070818-00071899": "vote conservative Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00278-00071900-00072091": "Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00279-00072092-00072505": "labor run kirkley's Council Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00280-00072506-00072917": "as you know have reneged on a deal to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00281-00072918-00073132": "house the national rugby league museum", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00282-00073133-00073326": "at The George Hotel", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00283-00073327-00073559": "they've also declared a climate", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00284-00073560-00073781": "emergency but they have one of the worst", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00285-00073782-00074053": "recycling rates in the country", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00286-00074054-00074332": "they're building on green fields and now", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00287-00074333-00074650": "on Green Belt they're demolishing home", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00288-00074651-00074950": "Firth indoor market we're blighted by", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00289-00074951-00075221": "litter and fly tipping and now they're", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00290-00075222-00075491": "proposing to chop down mature trees in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00291-00075492-00075838": "urban areas just oh Mr agree with me no", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00292-00075839-00076073": "you'll sit downable I presume you're", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00293-00076074-00076253": "gonna ask a question you've been a great", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00294-00076254-00076450": "escape great question that's the Prime", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00295-00076451-00076732": "Minister agree with me that local people", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00296-00076733-00077021": "can have their say on kirkley's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00297-00077022-00077326": "appalling record by voting conservative", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00298-00077327-00077682": "this week", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00299-00077683-00077975": "Mr Speaker my honorable friend is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00300-00077976-00078197": "absolutely right it's typical labor", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00301-00078198-00078461": "saying one thing and doing the other Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00302-00078462-00078550": "Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00303-00078551-00078761": "don't leave the conservatives that are", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00304-00078762-00078953": "going to protect the green belt it's a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00305-00078954-00079126": "labor party they're going to concrete", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00306-00079127-00079355": "over it and that's why in kirkles and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00307-00079356-00079599": "elsewhere tomorrow vote conservative", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00308-00079600-00079894": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00309-00079895-00080197": "SMP Stephen Flynn", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00310-00080198-00080806": "Mr Mr Speaker in 2010 David Cameron", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00311-00080807-00081094": "convinced Nick Clegg to drop his Pledge", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00312-00081095-00081419": "on University tuition fees does the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00313-00081420-00081617": "Prime Minister intend to take the credit", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00314-00081618-00081856": "for convincing the leader of the labor", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00315-00081857-00082016": "party to do likewise", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00316-00082017-00082482": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00317-00082483-00082967": "thank you", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00318-00082968-00083215": "prime minister", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00319-00083216-00083482": "well I I Thank The Honorable Jennifer", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00320-00083483-00083676": "for the question", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00321-00083677-00084029": "it I'd say it's it's hard to keep up Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00322-00084030-00084209": "Speaker with a list of broken promises", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00323-00084210-00084461": "but I would say oh on tuition fees is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00324-00084462-00084659": "I'm proud but under this government we", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00325-00084660-00084838": "now have a record number of people that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00326-00084839-00084935": "are going to University from", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00327-00084936-00085205": "disadvantaged backgrounds Mr Speaker and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00328-00085206-00085349": "that's because the efforts we've paced", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00329-00085350-00085559": "to put more money into supporting those", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00330-00085560-00085691": "people and those communities to fill", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00331-00085692-00085919": "their aspirations alongside fantastic", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00332-00085920-00086105": "new apprenticeships in every part of our", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00333-00086106-00086285": "country", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00334-00086286-00086512": "Mr Speaker for the avoidance of any", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00335-00086513-00086705": "doubt the liberal Democrats don't", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00336-00086706-00086915": "believe in abolishing tuition fees the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00337-00086916-00087106": "conservatives don't believe in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00338-00087107-00087317": "abolishing tuition fees and of course", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00339-00087318-00087503": "the labor party now with their own Nick", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00340-00087504-00087737": "Clegg moment don't believe in abolishing", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00341-00087738-00088144": "tuition fees Mr Speaker is it is it not", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00342-00088145-00088325": "the case that the main Westminster", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00343-00088326-00088517": "parties don't offer Young offer young", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00344-00088518-00088891": "people any hope at all do they", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00345-00088892-00089147": "actually actually I'll gently point out", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00346-00089148-00089405": "to The Honorable gentleman that if", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00347-00089406-00089573": "you're from a disadvantaged background", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00348-00089574-00089782": "you're far more likely to go to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00349-00089783-00089981": "university in England than you are in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00350-00089982-00090438": "Scotland", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00351-00090439-00090767": "thank you Mr Speaker the conservative", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00352-00090768-00091126": "the the conservative police and crime", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00353-00091127-00091450": "commissioner in Dorset has delivered 174", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00354-00091451-00091709": "new police officers he's quadrupled the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00355-00091710-00091967": "rural crime team and has made Dorset the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00356-00091968-00092291": "sixth safest County yeah as recorded", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00357-00092292-00092621": "crime is 34 higher under labor police", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00358-00092622-00092825": "and crime Commissioners does a prime", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00359-00092826-00093017": "minister agree with me that only", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00360-00093018-00093197": "conservatives can be trusted to keep", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00361-00093198-00093437": "local communities safe and make sure", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00362-00093438-00093838": "offenders face the Justice they deserve", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00363-00093839-00094037": "oh Mr Speaker honorable friend is right", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00364-00094038-00094325": "it's a simple statement of fact crime is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00365-00094326-00094541": "lower in areas which have conservative", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00366-00094542-00094768": "police and crime Commissioners and I'm", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00367-00094769-00094961": "delighted that doors that have been", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00368-00094962-00095159": "selected as one of the areas to Pilot", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00369-00095160-00095393": "our new immediate Justice scheme which", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00370-00095394-00095549": "will deliver Swift and visible", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00371-00095550-00095776": "punishment to victims of anti-social", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00372-00095777-00095956": "Behavior know that it will be treated", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00373-00095957-00096311": "seriously and with all urgency Caroline", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00374-00096312-00096641": "Lucas thank you very much Mr Speaker his", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00375-00096642-00096887": "government's vile and immoral Refugee", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00376-00096888-00097132": "ban bill and the toxic language coming", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00377-00097133-00097373": "from the home office isn't even dog", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00378-00097374-00097715": "whistle politics it is a giant hard ripe", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00379-00097716-00097997": "Foghorn blasting out a poisonous them in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00380-00097998-00098225": "US narrative and it plumbed new decks", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00381-00098226-00098387": "last week when the home office Minister", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00382-00098388-00098597": "claimed that people trying to come to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00383-00098598-00098879": "the UK and I quote tend to have", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00384-00098880-00099106": "completely different values to those in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00385-00099107-00099437": "the UK can he explain what he thinks are", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00386-00099438-00099629": "so different about the values held by", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00387-00099630-00099905": "the people of water torn Sudan and can", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00388-00099906-00100097": "you tell us what values are stopping him", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00389-00100098-00100355": "from creating a Sudanese family Visa", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00390-00100356-00100511": "scheme like he did for the people of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00391-00100512-00100723": "Ukraine", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00392-00100724-00100991": "Mr Speaker this country has a proud", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00393-00100992-00101176": "history of welcoming almost half a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00394-00101177-00101423": "million refugees over the past several", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00395-00101424-00101555": "years and we will always continue to do", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00396-00101556-00101843": "so but our ability to do that is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00397-00101844-00102100": "absolutely hampered when we have tens of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00398-00102101-00102311": "thousands of people illegally crossing", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00399-00102312-00102473": "the channel every year and it's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00400-00102474-00102742": "precisely because we want the help the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00401-00102743-00102910": "most vulnerable people whether they be", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00402-00102911-00103097": "in Syria and Afghanistan so down and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00403-00103098-00103330": "elsewhere we must get a grip of this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00404-00103331-00103540": "problem break the cycle of the criminal", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00405-00103541-00103756": "gangs and Target our resources and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00406-00103757-00104077": "compassion on those who most need it", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00407-00104078-00104339": "thank you Mr Speaker thanks to this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00408-00104340-00104506": "conservative government and 1.8 million", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00409-00104507-00104639": "pounds from the Brownfield land release", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00410-00104640-00104806": "fund the conservative LED solihull", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00411-00104807-00104986": "council is getting on with regenerating", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00412-00104988-00105154": "Kings Earth's Village Center creating", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00413-00105155-00105334": "space for new businesses and new homes", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00414-00105335-00105473": "but when it comes to economic", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00415-00105474-00105623": "regeneration none of the opposition", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00416-00105624-00105808": "parties have a viable plan not the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00417-00105809-00105965": "greens not the lib Dems and not the low", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00418-00105966-00106163": "party and the labor candidate has gone", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00419-00106164-00106360": "so far as to scare local people into", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00420-00106361-00106499": "thinking that the development won't go", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00421-00106500-00106678": "ahead despite Spades in the ground so", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00422-00106679-00106834": "this is probably must agree with me", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00423-00106835-00106997": "while the opposition talk down", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00424-00106998-00107165": "opportunity in the creation of jobs when", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00425-00107166-00107315": "it comes to investing in our communities", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00426-00107316-00107549": "it's only the conservative-led solihull", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00427-00107550-00107849": "council", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00428-00107850-00108071": "Mr Speaker I agree with my honorable", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00429-00108072-00108286": "friend and I'm so glad to see the local", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00430-00108288-00108473": "conservatives delivering for the people", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00431-00108474-00108743": "of solihull with dozens of new family", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00432-00108744-00109031": "homes new flexible commercial space and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00433-00109032-00109283": "a new Integrated Health social care and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00434-00109283-00109547": "Community Hub as he said it's clear for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00435-00109548-00109751": "his local area only the conservatives", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00436-00109752-00110049": "can deliver", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00437-00110050-00111073": "[Music]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00438-00111074-00111395": "to wear seat belts now this is not the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00439-00111396-00111604": "actions of a drunker reckless driver but", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00440-00111605-00111869": "more Constitution experience using Tesla", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00441-00111870-00112193": "and autopilot mode software selling beta", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00442-00112194-00112378": "phase victim suitable for cars that are", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00443-00112379-00112558": "public roads while the Prime Minister", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00444-00112559-00112763": "meet with me to discuss issues with", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00445-00112764-00113081": "Tejas autopilot and instigate an urgent", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00446-00113082-00113434": "critical safety review in terms of its", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00447-00113435-00113663": "suitability for operation and the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00448-00113664-00113975": "licensing over yeah yeah Mr Speaker I'm", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00449-00113976-00114119": "sorry to hear about what happened to the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00450-00114120-00114299": "remembrance constituent I'll ensure that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00451-00114300-00114425": "he gets a meeting with the transport", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00452-00114426-00114671": "secretary to discuss the safe regulation", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00453-00114672-00114983": "of autonomous and self-driving vehicles", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00454-00114984-00115158": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00455-00115159-00115390": "labor runs City of Lincoln Council has", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00456-00115391-00115583": "destroyed the 40-year reputation of our", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00457-00115583-00115757": "City's Christmas Market and the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00458-00115758-00115907": "Christmas cheers that Lincoln benefits", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00459-00115908-00116093": "for manually the dereliction of their", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00460-00116094-00116243": "role chooses to take the easiest option", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00461-00116244-00116423": "behind closed doors in secret in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00462-00116424-00116627": "canceling the market shows Labor's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00463-00116628-00116831": "neglect and disregard for small local", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00464-00116832-00117034": "businesses Charities and entrepreneurs", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00465-00117035-00117281": "and voters labor Kansas linkage will be", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00466-00117282-00117589": "ashamed of their actions yeah", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00467-00117590-00117893": "Mr Brennan I don't need you shouting for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00468-00117894-00118090": "the back road I've always offered a cup", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00469-00118091-00118228": "of tea to this side but it's equally", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00470-00118229-00118421": "opportunity for you to take one come on", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00471-00118422-00118673": "Connor I thank the member from the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00472-00118674-00118799": "opposite side for the extra amenities", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00473-00118800-00119004": "giving me Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00474-00119005-00119231": "tomorrow the people in Lincoln will have", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00475-00119232-00119458": "the chance to remove I will not count on", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00476-00119459-00119716": "that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00477-00119717-00119860": "tomorrow the people are linking will", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00478-00119861-00119981": "have the chance to remove from office", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00479-00119982-00120286": "the anti-business Socialist cruises and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00480-00120288-00120557": "elect local conservatives does my right", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00481-00120558-00120695": "under a friend the Prime Minister agree", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00482-00120696-00120875": "with me that for better run local", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00483-00120876-00121121": "Services business", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00484-00121122-00121313": "I think Inferno is a prime minister I", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00485-00121314-00121451": "think the text went tote I think he's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00486-00121452-00121690": "got the answer come on", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00487-00121691-00121949": "Mr Mr Speaker I share my honorable", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00488-00121950-00122171": "friends disappointment but after a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00489-00122172-00122357": "decision taken by the labor on Council", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00490-00122358-00122621": "behind as he said closed doors there", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00491-00122622-00122849": "will no longer be a Christmas Market in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00492-00122850-00123163": "Lincoln ending its 40 Years of History", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00493-00123164-00123473": "Lincoln deserves better and I urge the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00494-00123474-00123713": "people of the city to vote conservative", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00495-00123714-00124043": "hello thank you Mr Speaker ahead of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00496-00124044-00124240": "tomorrow's local elections I've been", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00497-00124241-00124481": "campaigning in Medway and Swindon the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00498-00124482-00124673": "words on the doorstep is that people are", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00499-00124674-00124858": "ready for a change and we'll be", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00500-00124859-00125008": "switching their votes from the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00501-00125009-00125191": "conservatives to labor", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00502-00125192-00125381": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00503-00125382-00125645": "forever I am concerned that only four", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00504-00125646-00125902": "percent of those without valid ID have", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00505-00125903-00126160": "applied online for a voter Authority", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00506-00126161-00126395": "certificate so will the Prime Minister", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00507-00126396-00126725": "commit to a post-election review of how", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00508-00126726-00126913": "many people have effectively been", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00509-00126914-00127102": "disenfranchised by his government", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00510-00127103-00127451": "systems to the virtually non-existent", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00511-00127452-00127698": "problem of voter frauds", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00512-00127699-00127825": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00513-00127826-00128195": "Mr Speaker 98 of people already possess", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00514-00128196-00128416": "a suitable form of voter ID and the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00515-00128417-00128554": "government made available free", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00516-00128555-00128795": "alternative ID for those that do not", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00517-00128796-00128986": "have it the pilots have demonstrated it", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00518-00128988-00129202": "hasn't it's a typically impacted turnout", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00519-00129203-00129371": "and indeed this was a policy that was", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00520-00129372-00129557": "introduced by the labor party in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00521-00129558-00129749": "Northern Ireland all those years ago", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00522-00129750-00129875": "it's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00523-00129876-00130073": "it's common it's common in European", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00524-00130074-00130277": "countries it's common in Canada and it's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00525-00130278-00130421": "absolutely right that we introduce it", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00526-00130422-00130614": "here too", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00527-00130615-00130978": "yeah thank you Mr Speaker it's getting", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00528-00130979-00131273": "elected in 2019. I've been inundated", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00529-00131274-00131483": "with correspondence my constituents and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00530-00131484-00131669": "Southwest Hertfordshire rightly", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00531-00131670-00131825": "complaining about huge speculative", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00532-00131826-00132023": "developments on our beautiful Greenbelt", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00533-00132024-00132113": "Land", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00534-00132114-00132304": "let them controlled Three Rivers", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00535-00132305-00132533": "District Council continue to dither And", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00536-00132534-00132797": "Delay their local plan does he agree", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00537-00132798-00133013": "with me that the choice tomorrow is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00538-00133014-00133252": "simple the conservative to protect our", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00539-00133253-00133451": "Green Belt although lived them for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00540-00133452-00133801": "massive developments on on sport land", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00541-00133802-00134081": "well Mr Speaker honorable friend raises", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00542-00134082-00134309": "an important point and it's always the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00543-00134310-00134543": "same with liberal Democrats saying one", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00544-00134544-00134813": "thing and doing the other we've all seen", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00545-00134814-00134987": "it Mr Speaker it's the conservatives", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00546-00134988-00135281": "that a party of local decisions taken by", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00547-00135282-00135454": "local people and it's only the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00548-00135455-00135604": "conservatives that will protect the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00549-00135605-00135911": "green belt", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00550-00135912-00136313": "thank you Mr Speaker unable to secure an", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00551-00136314-00136552": "NHS dental appointment my constituent", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00552-00136553-00136871": "Ray was forced to go private it was then", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00553-00136872-00137014": "discovered that he had a large", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00554-00137015-00137290": "aggressive tumor in his face and jaw", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00555-00137291-00137590": "which required 16 hours of grueling", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00556-00137591-00137885": "surgery to remove it if it hadn't if he", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00557-00137886-00138154": "hadn't been able to afford it Ray might", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00558-00138155-00138454": "not be with us now this is yet another", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00559-00138455-00138754": "chapter in the horror story that is the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00560-00138755-00138940": "decay of Dentistry under this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00561-00138941-00139139": "government's watch so will the Prime", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00562-00139140-00139487": "Minister accept NHS Dentistry is in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00563-00139488-00139751": "crisis and will you meet with me and the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00564-00139752-00139985": "British Dental Association to ensure", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00565-00139986-00140219": "that no one loses their life because", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00566-00140220-00140566": "they couldn't get a dental appointment", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00567-00140567-00140777": "uh Mr Speaker I'm sorry to hear what", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00568-00140778-00140890": "happened to The Honorable ladies", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00569-00140891-00141202": "constituent and that's why the NHS has", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00570-00141203-00141443": "recently reformed Dental contracts to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00571-00141444-00141671": "improve access we now invest over three", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00572-00141672-00141869": "billion pounds a year there are over 500", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00573-00141870-00142121": "more dentists working in the NHS this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00574-00142122-00142337": "year than last year and indeed", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00575-00142338-00142601": "discussions are ongoing between the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00576-00142602-00142864": "department for health and the NHS around", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00577-00142865-00143128": "dentistry and dhsc is planning to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00578-00143129-00143314": "outline further reform measures in the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00579-00143315-00143563": "near future so definitely Clifton blow", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00580-00143564-00143819": "every single young person that gets on", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00581-00143820-00143981": "the housing ladder under a conservative", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00582-00143982-00144223": "government makes our communities more", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00583-00144224-00144473": "sustainable when my rider will a friend", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00584-00144474-00144671": "agree that in order to build the right", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00585-00144672-00144916": "type of Housing and speed it up we need", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00586-00144917-00145090": "to fund planning authorities properly", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00587-00145091-00145314": "through Innovative funding", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00588-00145315-00145589": "well Mr Speaker my uh honorable friend", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00589-00145590-00145733": "as ever makes an excellent point and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00590-00145734-00145913": "that's why the reforms that we introduce", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00591-00145914-00146140": "will provide incremental resources to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00592-00146141-00146333": "planning authorities to make sure that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00593-00146334-00146531": "planning decisions can be taken quicker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00594-00146532-00146740": "but all also we've strengthened the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00595-00146741-00146921": "ability of local communities to put in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00596-00146922-00147166": "place local plans Mr Speaker this is the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00597-00147167-00147425": "best way for our town cities villages to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00598-00147426-00147575": "have control over development in their", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00599-00147576-00147749": "area and make sure that it happens in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00600-00147750-00147857": "the way that they are comfortable with", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00601-00147858-00148013": "and I know that he's supportive of that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00602-00148014-00148277": "too absolutely thank you very much Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00603-00148278-00148523": "Speaker the recent ITV documentary life", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00604-00148524-00148714": "and death stories from the edge followed", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00605-00148715-00148978": "Halifax mum Izzy her pre-term and energy", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00606-00148979-00149171": "bills have tripled and she was relying", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00607-00149172-00149369": "on a local Primary School ash green", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00608-00149370-00149573": "we're providing free breakfast budget", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00609-00149574-00149825": "cooking classes and a hardship fund for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00610-00149826-00150047": "their families when head teacher", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00611-00150048-00150221": "Shepherd is asked does he worry about", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00612-00150222-00150371": "the children at school when he goes home", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00613-00150372-00150689": "at night he says all the time it never", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00614-00150690-00150916": "leaves you does the Prime Minister think", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00615-00150917-00151145": "it's right that things are so bad that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00616-00151146-00151343": "schools are having to become the fourth", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00617-00151344-00151633": "emergency service for the families", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00618-00151634-00151966": "well Mr Mr Speaker because of the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00619-00151967-00152135": "actions we've taken a typical family", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00620-00152136-00152333": "including those like Izzy's will be", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00621-00152334-00152531": "seeing half of their energy bills paid", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00622-00152532-00152704": "for by by the government that is the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00623-00152705-00153023": "port worth 1500 pounds extended in the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00624-00153024-00153161": "most recent budget for the most", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00625-00153162-00153287": "vulnerable in our society there's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00626-00153288-00153545": "additional support and 900 pounds for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00627-00153546-00153766": "those on welfare Mr Speaker and through", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00628-00153767-00153916": "the holiday activity and food program", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00629-00153917-00154169": "support for families with the cost and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00630-00154170-00154349": "support for food during the holidays but", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00631-00154350-00154528": "I would also say for Izzy and others", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00632-00154529-00154654": "there in particular need they should", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00633-00154655-00154799": "talk to their Council because the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00634-00154800-00154961": "chancellor has provided over a billion", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00635-00154962-00155116": "pounds of funding to the household", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00636-00155117-00155321": "support fund it's there to help families", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00637-00155322-00155459": "like that that need a little bit of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00638-00155460-00155639": "extra assistance during this time so", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00639-00155640-00155843": "John witting there thank you Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00640-00155844-00156064": "as my original friend will be aware", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00641-00156065-00156485": "today is World Press Freedom day at a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00642-00156486-00156749": "time when the need for professional and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00643-00156750-00156959": "factual journalism has never been", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00644-00156960-00157195": "greater well my my right-handled friend", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00645-00157196-00157385": "reaffirmed the government's commitment", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00646-00157386-00157709": "to defending media Freedom worldwide and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00647-00157710-00157901": "will he redouble the efforts of the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00648-00157902-00158185": "government to obtain the release of Evan", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00649-00158186-00158525": "gershkovich and Vladimir caramurza in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00650-00158526-00158975": "Russia and of Jimmy Lai in Hong Kong", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00651-00158976-00159173": "uh Mr Speaker the government is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00652-00159174-00159352": "committed to defending media Freedom", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00653-00159353-00159587": "worldwide because thriving independent", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00654-00159588-00159821": "journalism is one of the cornerstones of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00655-00159822-00160085": "democracy we absolutely condemn the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00656-00160086-00160247": "politically motivated sentencing of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00657-00160248-00160426": "journalists across the world and our", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00658-00160427-00160649": "embassies and missions work every day to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00659-00160650-00160871": "protect media Freedom where they are", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00660-00160872-00161045": "based and I know that this is something", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00661-00161046-00161219": "that my right honorable friend has been", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00662-00161220-00161404": "a right champion of throughout his", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00663-00161405-00161537": "career and I will look forward him", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00664-00161538-00161699": "continuing to do so from a different", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00665-00161700-00161878": "perch as I take rather fewer questions", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00666-00161879-00162059": "from him over the next few months from", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00667-00162060-00162839": "this position the kennel", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00668-00162840-00163078": "the country this weekend to support the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00669-00163079-00163385": "coronation events but police numbers in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00670-00163386-00163552": "the Northeast are down eight percent", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00671-00163553-00163823": "since 2010 and I know the prime", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00672-00163824-00164057": "minister's keen on his maths so here's a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00673-00164058-00164321": "sum if northumber police has lost a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00674-00164322-00164561": "thousand to police officers since 2010", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00675-00164562-00164933": "but gained the funding to put back 615", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00676-00164934-00165193": "by how much have the conservatives", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00677-00165194-00165483": "shortchanged the Northeast", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00678-00165484-00165529": "[Music]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00679-00165530-00165652": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00680-00165653-00165823": "so Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00681-00165824-00166301": "Mr Mr Speaker Mr Speaker as we saw last", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00682-00166302-00166535": "week there are now a record number of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00683-00166536-00166751": "police officers across the country", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00684-00166752-00166966": "thanks to the actions of this government", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00685-00166967-00167273": "and crime is 50 lower than it was when", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00686-00167274-00167507": "we took office she talks about investing", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00687-00167508-00167626": "she talks about investing in the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00688-00167627-00167776": "Northeast you know when we when we", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00689-00167777-00167945": "invested leveling up Fund in her", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00690-00167946-00168185": "constituency 20 million pounds she said", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00691-00168186-00168466": "it was transformational Mr Speaker she", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00692-00168467-00168640": "said it would play an important role in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00693-00168641-00168928": "rejuvenating her local area that's this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00694-00168929-00169097": "conservative government delivering not", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00695-00169098-00169259": "just for the Northeast but for her", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00696-00169260-00169476": "constituents too", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00697-00169477-00169781": "Mr Speaker I was pleased to welcome the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00698-00169782-00169943": "Secretary of State for transport to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00699-00169944-00170152": "Newsome recently this was to see the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00700-00170153-00170345": "progress on the Northumberland line with", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00701-00170346-00170513": "my right honorable friend agreed with me", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00702-00170514-00170752": "that this conservative government and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00703-00170753-00170957": "conservative government only is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00704-00170958-00171131": "committed to development of this line", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00705-00171132-00171349": "keeping leveling up on track", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00706-00171350-00171593": "well Mr Speaker honorable friend has", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00707-00171594-00171857": "been a fantastic fantastic Champion for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00708-00171858-00172073": "the restoration of this line indeed it", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00709-00172074-00172301": "was one of the first deliveries from the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00710-00172302-00172504": "restoring your Railways fund and it will", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00711-00172505-00172666": "be fantastic for his local communities", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00712-00172667-00172864": "because that connectivity will provide", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00713-00172865-00173033": "jobs opportunity and employment", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00714-00173034-00173189": "particularly for young people in his", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00715-00173190-00173428": "local area and after years if not", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00716-00173429-00173602": "Decades of neglect it's this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00717-00173603-00173735": "conservative government that is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00718-00173736-00173902": "delivering for the people in his local", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00719-00173903-00174049": "area", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00720-00174050-00174371": "thank you Mr Speaker over 3.6 million", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00721-00174372-00174628": "women born in the 1950s had their", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00722-00174629-00174887": "pension age increased without their", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00723-00174888-00175139": "knowledge and many like my constituent", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00724-00175140-00175439": "unknowingly gave up work at 60 only to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00725-00175440-00175661": "realize they had no income they couldn't", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00726-00175662-00175901": "pay their bills and some have even lost", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00727-00175902-00176164": "their homes so my constituent asked the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00728-00176165-00176459": "Prime Minister today will he commit to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00729-00176460-00176675": "the fair and fast payment of any", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00730-00176676-00176957": "compensation that is recommended by the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00731-00176958-00177131": "Parliamentary and Health Service", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00732-00177132-00177401": "Ombudsman to 1950s women for the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00733-00177402-00177635": "Injustice they have suffered due to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00734-00177636-00177838": "Administration by the department for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00735-00177839-00178026": "work and pensions", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00736-00178027-00178343": "yeah Mr Speaker this issue has been long", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00737-00178344-00178511": "discussed in this place and obviously", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00738-00178512-00178673": "The Honorable lady knows there's an", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00739-00178674-00178852": "ongoing process which I can't comment on", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00740-00178853-00179021": "but rest assured of course we will", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00741-00179022-00179183": "respond appropriately to any", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00742-00179184-00179628": "recommendations that come our way", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00743-00179629-00180076": "[Applause]", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00744-00180077-00180214": "to draw the attention of the prime", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00745-00180215-00180437": "minister so the dangers must best Us in", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00746-00180438-00180659": "workplace buildings please when you back", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00747-00180660-00180826": "the don't let the dust settle campaign", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00748-00180827-00181073": "for the Miso Tea Leoni UK charity in my", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00749-00181074-00181313": "constituency by setting up a register of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00750-00181314-00181535": "all workplaces in the country that", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00751-00181536-00181721": "contain asbestos and determine a", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00752-00181722-00181888": "timetable of eradication of this", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00753-00181889-00182147": "terrible substance", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00754-00182148-00182333": "oh Mr Speaker can I thank my honorable", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00755-00182334-00182531": "friend for raising this important issue", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00756-00182532-00182776": "the law does require Duty holders to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00757-00182777-00182975": "assess whether asbestos is present what", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00758-00182976-00183178": "condition it is in and whether it gives", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00759-00183179-00183413": "rise to a risk of exposure and they must", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00760-00183414-00183671": "drop a plan to manage this risk which", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00761-00183672-00183887": "must include removal if it can't be", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00762-00183888-00184078": "safely managed where it is located but I", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00763-00184079-00184259": "commend her for a continuing campaigning", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00764-00184260-00184504": "on this important issue", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00765-00184505-00184763": "thank you very much Mr Speaker Nick", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00766-00184764-00184985": "swims regularly in the Thames at", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00767-00184986-00185261": "shepparton but after a recent dip he", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00768-00185262-00185488": "found himself hospitalized with", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00769-00185489-00185885": "cellulitis for 13 days his doctors think", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00770-00185886-00186221": "this was caused by polluted water Mr", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00771-00186222-00186419": "Speaker what caused that polluted water", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00772-00186420-00186737": "well because Thames water dumped filthy", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00773-00186738-00187097": "sewage just days earlier nearby so can", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00774-00187098-00187331": "the Prime Minister tell Nick and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00775-00187332-00187571": "everybody else why does he think it's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00776-00187572-00187793": "okay for water companies to keep", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00777-00187794-00188002": "polluting our Rivers for another 25", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00778-00188003-00188449": "years", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00779-00188450-00188819": "Mr Speaker it was just last week but it", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00780-00188820-00188993": "was clear there's only one party that's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00781-00188994-00189137": "going to protect the environment and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00782-00189138-00189449": "it's the conservative party", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00783-00189450-00189671": "that's that's why we've given the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00784-00189672-00189821": "environment agency more powers of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00785-00189822-00189995": "enforcement that's why we're moving to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00786-00189996-00190204": "unlimited fines and that's why we've got", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00787-00190205-00190421": "a clear plan to increase investment and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00788-00190422-00190637": "increase monitoring as sewage overflows", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00789-00190638-00190859": "it was all right cynicism and hypocrisy", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00790-00190860-00191128": "of the party opposite the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00791-00191129-00191369": "they could not even show up to support", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00792-00191370-00191687": "those plans Mr Speaker", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00793-00191688-00192011": "okay Mr Speaker Albert constituents face", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00794-00192012-00192275": "host pipe fans after a torrential spring", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00795-00192276-00192616": "stalls and asking me why water catching", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00796-00192617-00192875": "plans have not prevented this reservoirs", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00797-00192876-00193073": "desalination plants and other natural", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00798-00193074-00193295": "catchment structures require citing", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00799-00193296-00193552": "where geography and geology allows is", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00800-00193553-00193714": "there a natural strategy and", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00801-00193715-00193954": "implementation plan to increase water", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00802-00193955-00194225": "catchment and enable cross-water company", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00803-00194226-00194561": "water transfer to match Regional demand", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00804-00194562-00194707": "to supply", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00805-00194708-00195004": "yes look Mr Speaker water companies", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00806-00195005-00195275": "publish Water Resources management plans", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00807-00195276-00195490": "which show how they will continue to", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00808-00195491-00195676": "provide a secure supply of water for", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00809-00195677-00195833": "customers and I understand that they", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00810-00195834-00196019": "have been Consulting on their latest", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00811-00196020-00196276": "drafts of these plans and in my", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00812-00196277-00196469": "honorable friends particular area of", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00813-00196470-00196619": "Devon and Cornwall where temporary use", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00814-00196620-00196811": "bands are in place defra and the water", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00815-00196812-00196990": "Regulators are closely working with", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00816-00196991-00197171": "Southwest water to ensure that the", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00817-00197172-00197309": "company is taking all appropriate", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00818-00197310-00197519": "precaution reaction to ensure that water", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00819-00197520-00197687": "supplies remain resilient this year", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00820-00197688-00197945": "that's all for now on prime minister's", "i1IDhV8HGuA-00821-00197946-00198164": "questions"}}, {"audio_id": "i1P0QIPIeh0", "text": {"i1P0QIPIeh0-00000-00000000-00000191": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00001-00000192-00000407": "good morning everyone dr salt here in", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00002-00000408-00000543": "beverly hills", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00003-00000544-00000767": "we're starting the week right with this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00004-00000768-00001007": "nice beautiful young lady", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00005-00001008-00001287": "who has done a magnificent job of losing", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00006-00001288-00001407": "a lot of weight", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00007-00001408-00001710": "so she's here for a little makeover", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00008-00001711-00002039": "we're gonna tighten some things up she's", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00009-00002039-00002110": "beautiful", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00010-00002111-00002455": "we're just gonna enrich the beauty today", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00011-00002456-00002683": "so one thing we're doing is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00012-00002684-00002942": "brachioplasty brachioplasty is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00013-00002943-00003231": "when we do the arms you can see she's", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00014-00003232-00003303": "lost weight", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00015-00003304-00003631": "very thin but what we're going to do is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00016-00003632-00003751": "take off the skin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00017-00003752-00003954": "what i'm going to do for her is a jade", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00018-00003955-00004086": "brachioplasty", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00019-00004087-00004375": "it's going to tighten her sides too as", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00020-00004376-00004543": "you can see i'm going to take all this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00021-00004544-00004663": "extra skin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00022-00004664-00004815": "and it's going to come right in the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00023-00004816-00004967": "crease here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00024-00004968-00005238": "and do i'm going to do perfect suturing", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00025-00005239-00005311": "for her", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00026-00005312-00005567": "so the scar is minimized so we're going", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00027-00005568-00005775": "to do the same thing on the other side", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00028-00005776-00005991": "the left is a little bit bigger you", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00029-00005992-00006102": "could see but", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00030-00006103-00006422": "everyone is a little bit asymmetrical", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00031-00006423-00006646": "so that's why so we're going to take all", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00032-00006647-00006783": "that out coming here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00033-00006784-00007167": "into the jig that's number one", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00034-00007168-00007367": "you can put your arms down number two is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00035-00007368-00007510": "we're going to do some lipo of the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00036-00007511-00007703": "flanks in pubic", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00037-00007704-00007974": "that's going to give her some shape here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00038-00007975-00008046": "give her an", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00039-00008047-00008431": "hourglass look then number three is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00040-00008432-00008671": "we're going to do it super extended", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00041-00008672-00008767": "tummy tuck", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00042-00008768-00008974": "which is going to go almost to where her", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00043-00008975-00009078": "buttock is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00044-00009079-00009399": "what i'm going to do is my line is low", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00045-00009400-00009671": "and it comes high so it'll pull up on", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00046-00009672-00009863": "the skin a little bit like this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00047-00009864-00010127": "we're going to take as much as we can", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00048-00010128-00010206": "we're going to take", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00049-00010207-00010438": "all this out this point is going to come", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00050-00010439-00010574": "down here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00051-00010575-00010814": "and we're going to go all the way across", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00052-00010815-00010942": "all the way there", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00053-00010943-00011199": "it's going to look very nice everything", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00054-00011200-00011327": "is going to be low", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00055-00011328-00011623": "but it's going to lift things up also if", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00056-00011624-00011838": "she turns around", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00057-00011839-00012095": "you can see um usually i don't come this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00058-00012096-00012183": "far but", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00059-00012184-00012478": "we make exceptions for everyone for her", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00060-00012479-00012687": "we're coming all the way back here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00061-00012688-00012974": "to her skin in the back is good i think", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00062-00012975-00013086": "she's going to retract", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00063-00013087-00013319": "very nicely so i'm going to limit my", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00064-00013319-00013407": "incision", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00065-00013408-00013663": "so not do extra scars if we don't need", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00066-00013663-00013719": "to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00067-00013719-00014047": "to for the icing on the cake the fat we", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00068-00014047-00014199": "take out here and here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00069-00014200-00014399": "we're gonna put here on top of the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00070-00014400-00014503": "breast", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00071-00014504-00014743": "her breast she has large breasts but the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00072-00014744-00014847": "thing is that", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00073-00014847-00015150": "up in the superior pole i can feel her", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00074-00015151-00015222": "ribs", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00075-00015223-00015486": "so the prudent thing to do is just add", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00076-00015487-00015550": "the fat", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00077-00015551-00015830": "up here so it gives her more volume up", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00078-00015831-00015927": "top because", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00079-00015928-00016222": "fall down down here she has quite amount", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00080-00016223-00016311": "of volume", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00081-00016312-00016527": "but what's lacking volume is up here you", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00082-00016528-00016694": "can see the green arrows", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00083-00016695-00016935": "and that's where the fat will go so this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00084-00016936-00017003": "is going to be a", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00085-00017004-00017330": "fantabulous case stay tuned till we", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00086-00017331-00017494": "fantabulize her", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00087-00017495-00017735": "so we're getting started on the case", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00088-00017736-00017983": "what i'm doing right now is just taking", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00089-00017984-00018086": "out all the fat", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00090-00018087-00018255": "because what we're going to do is we're", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00091-00018256-00018471": "going to take out the skin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00092-00018472-00018743": "without disturbing the lymphatics and", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00093-00018744-00018807": "the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00094-00018808-00019039": "arteries the veins and everything so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00095-00019040-00019279": "we're trying to get this area as thin as", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00096-00019280-00019358": "possible", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00097-00019359-00019550": "you can see i'm taking out all the fat", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00098-00019551-00019791": "in the area so it's basically just going", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00099-00019792-00019967": "to be skin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00100-00019968-00020143": "and this is the fat we're going to also", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00101-00020144-00020350": "transfer to her breast", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00102-00020351-00020575": "so you guys never see me get it this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00103-00020576-00020727": "thin when i'm doing it", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00104-00020728-00020911": "in an area where we're not doing", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00105-00020912-00021078": "excision look at how thin it is you", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00106-00021079-00021319": "could basically see my instrument", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00107-00021320-00021471": "the only reason i'm doing this is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00108-00021472-00021678": "because we're gonna take this off and i", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00109-00021679-00021807": "want this to be", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00110-00021808-00022086": "as thin as possible i want it to be just", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00111-00022087-00022158": "purely", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00112-00022159-00022430": "skin which you can see i'm already", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00113-00022431-00022678": "pinching it together you can see my", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00114-00022679-00022911": "marks my hash marks going around", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00115-00022912-00023094": "and that's what's going to happen so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00116-00023095-00023455": "here we go we're cutting the skin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00117-00023456-00023807": "it's all you know what we say", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00118-00023808-00024127": "measure twice cut once", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00119-00024128-00024503": "we already measured twice so there we", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00120-00024504-00024814": "are", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00121-00024815-00025503": "perfect okay ready for this part", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00122-00025504-00027225": "you ready yep", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00123-00027226-00028087": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00124-00028088-00028311": "so here look at this this is the this is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00125-00028312-00028511": "a superficial vein this is the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00126-00028512-00028631": "lymphatics", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00127-00028632-00028918": "this is the muscle fascia all the good", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00128-00028919-00028990": "contents", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00129-00028991-00029262": "it's still in here we didn't take any of", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00130-00029263-00029318": "it out", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00131-00029319-00029479": "let me have a pick up so we could put it", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00132-00029480-00029687": "together but you could see all the major", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00133-00029688-00029823": "veins and stuff were not", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00134-00029824-00030055": "cut the lymphatics were not cut so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00135-00030056-00030270": "she'll have less swelling", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00136-00030272-00030558": "and everything after surgery so here's", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00137-00030560-00030831": "this side to our mark", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00138-00030832-00031167": "green to green right there", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00139-00031168-00031543": "here we go another", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00140-00031544-00033327": "blue to blue", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00141-00033328-00034551": "let's get one down here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00142-00034552-00034862": "so this was from her arm going to the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00143-00034863-00034990": "lateral area", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00144-00034991-00035174": "you can see how thin it is it's not", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00145-00035175-00035295": "thick because we already", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00146-00035296-00035479": "liped it out look at how thin it is but", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00147-00035480-00035687": "it's just excess skin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00148-00035688-00035846": "and she's not going to sweat anymore", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00149-00035847-00036062": "because we got all her sweat glands", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00150-00036063-00036311": "so here we are on this on the left side", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00151-00036312-00036502": "look at how thin it is again", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00152-00036503-00036774": "you want this super thin because we're", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00153-00036775-00037023": "gonna just take off the skin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00154-00037024-00037255": "and leave the lymphatics and everything", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00155-00037256-00037343": "behind", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00156-00037344-00037535": "you usually don't want to be this thin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00157-00037536-00037767": "when you're doing lyco because it's not", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00158-00037768-00038071": "good form to get it so thin", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00159-00038072-00038318": "but because we're taking all this off", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00160-00038319-00038374": "we're just", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00161-00038375-00038687": "i'm coming very superficial regularly", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00162-00038688-00038807": "you don't want this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00163-00038808-00039046": "this much superficial lipo you can see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00164-00039047-00039135": "my", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00165-00039136-00039439": "instrument almost through the skin and", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00166-00039440-00039774": "it's all connected watch this let's see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00167-00039775-00040327": "all of this is connected", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00168-00040328-00040567": "so you guys can see how thin she is just", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00169-00040568-00040630": "just", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00170-00040631-00040887": "skin look at how thin that is compared", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00171-00040888-00041087": "to here how big she is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00172-00041088-00042510": "so we're just gonna go ahead and start", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00173-00042511-00044230": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00174-00044231-00045558": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00175-00045559-00045767": "so then when it's separated it should", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00176-00045768-00045879": "just", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00177-00045880-00046135": "peel off because we've already lipo good", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00178-00046136-00046215": "enough", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00179-00046216-00046399": "so it should just be peeling off like", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00180-00046400-00047174": "that", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00181-00047175-00047479": "wow just you see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00182-00047480-00047702": "all these lymphatics and stuff that need", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00183-00047703-00047902": "to stay back they stay back", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00184-00047903-00048143": "you see all those these are lymphatic", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00185-00048144-00048351": "channels that stay back", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00186-00048352-00048974": "now let's uh give me the clap", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00187-00048975-00052292": "then we go our hash mark to hash mark", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00188-00052294-00052615": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00189-00052616-00052838": "so you can see it's just it's just by", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00190-00052839-00053119": "the deep dermis that it's connected", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00191-00053120-00053326": "you see all the all that honeycomb", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00192-00053327-00053511": "that's from the lipo you can see there's", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00193-00053512-00053607": "no fat", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00194-00053608-00053911": "these are just lymphatics and veins and", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00195-00053912-00054900": "stuff that need to stay back", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00196-00054901-00056082": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00197-00056083-00056291": "ready", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00198-00056291-00057119": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00199-00057120-00058882": "come together", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00200-00058883-00060038": "clap", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00201-00060039-00061682": "okay let me get the monkey pen", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00202-00061683-00063082": "clamp", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00203-00063083-00064482": "okay", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00204-00064483-00065735": "knife", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00205-00065736-00068682": "i need three things", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00206-00068683-00069044": "oh", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00207-00069045-00070082": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00208-00070083-00071084": "um", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00209-00071085-00071550": "[Music]", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00210-00071551-00071862": "so this one all the way from here all", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00211-00071863-00072071": "the way across here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00212-00072072-00072287": "so what we're going to do is we're going", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00213-00072288-00072494": "to isolate", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00214-00072495-00072871": "the belly button so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00215-00072872-00073126": "you go around it stays and everyone is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00216-00073127-00073343": "everyone's favorite question is do i get", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00217-00073344-00073391": "a", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00218-00073392-00073662": "new belly button technically no because", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00219-00073663-00073750": "it's your old", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00220-00073751-00074055": "old one and we just pull it through", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00221-00074056-00074423": "a different hole in your optics so it's", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00222-00074424-00074719": "but it does look different because we do", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00223-00074720-00074879": "make the whole", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00224-00074880-00075247": "uh however you desire so it does look", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00225-00075248-00075455": "different but it is your own belly", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00226-00075456-00075623": "button", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00227-00075624-00075903": "so here i am isolating it it's on a", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00228-00075904-00075959": "stock", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00229-00075960-00076223": "and it's attached to the abdominal wall", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00230-00076224-00076511": "so it doesn't go any higher or lower", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00231-00076512-00076735": "it stays at the same area where it's", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00232-00076736-00076887": "been so you guys", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00233-00076888-00077094": "uh here for you guys at home we've", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00234-00077095-00077343": "isolated the belly button there it is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00235-00077344-00077591": "this is the hole it's already on a stock", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00236-00077592-00077662": "ready", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00237-00077663-00077943": "we're going to start going down here to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00238-00077944-00078119": "the fascia", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00239-00078120-00078367": "the fascia is what covers muscles that", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00240-00078368-00078503": "white sheath", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00241-00078504-00078823": "all muscle practically in the body with", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00242-00078824-00079062": "some exceptions have a fascia around", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00243-00079063-00079215": "them there are only a few", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00244-00079216-00079462": "in the face that that don't have a", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00245-00079463-00079575": "fascia but", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00246-00079576-00079847": "most muscle in the body do have a fascia", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00247-00079848-00079950": "covering them", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00248-00079951-00080271": "so here we are you can see the abdominal", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00249-00080272-00080479": "muscle fascia right here this white", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00250-00080480-00080662": "thing is what we call fascia", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00251-00080663-00080935": "you can see how it's nice how gently if", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00252-00080936-00080967": "i", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00253-00080968-00081279": "even use my fingers i could push it back", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00254-00081280-00081543": "gentle movement on my fingers and once", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00255-00081544-00081782": "in a while i use my boby pen", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00256-00081783-00082038": "and then push it back it's enough it's", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00257-00082039-00082103": "in a", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00258-00082104-00082375": "layer where there is no blood vessel so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00259-00082376-00082543": "it's a vascular", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00260-00082544-00082775": "so you don't have to worry as much about", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00261-00082776-00082991": "bleeding when you're in the right level", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00262-00082992-00083199": "so now that we've cleared all the way to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00263-00083200-00083335": "the belly button", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00264-00083336-00083671": "this is uh one of our favorite parts is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00265-00083672-00083991": "when we split it in half down the middle", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00266-00083992-00084206": "and we go all the way to belly button", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00267-00084207-00084335": "because we know we're going to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00268-00084336-00087726": "be able to get that amount of skin off", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00269-00087727-00087950": "so here we are here's the belly button", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00270-00087951-00088055": "you can see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00271-00088056-00088318": "that it's on a stock so it doesn't move", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00272-00088319-00088487": "it's connected through", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00273-00088488-00088806": "the abdominal fascia abdominal muscle it", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00274-00088807-00088862": "goes", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00275-00088863-00089150": "to the inside so we're here we're just", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00276-00089151-00089206": "going", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00277-00089207-00089535": "up until we get to the zyphoid you can", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00278-00089536-00089703": "see we're right here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00279-00089704-00089918": "we're getting some fluid and that's all", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00280-00089919-00090055": "the numbing fluid i", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00281-00090056-00090262": "injected of course you're going to get", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00282-00090263-00090359": "some bleeding", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00283-00090360-00090615": "we're doing such a big surgery it's not", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00284-00090616-00090911": "a big deal as long as it's controlled", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00285-00090912-00091223": "and we have good anesthesia today so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00286-00091224-00091438": "we've dissected you can see these this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00287-00091439-00091638": "is her six-pack muscle", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00288-00091639-00091879": "she's actually a tiny girl you can see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00289-00091880-00092087": "her pelvic bone right here and right", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00290-00092088-00092150": "here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00291-00092151-00092479": "she has very little visceral fat that", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00292-00092480-00092599": "means fat around her", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00293-00092600-00092911": "organs you can see how tiny she is i'm", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00294-00092912-00093087": "going to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00295-00093088-00093374": "close up her her defect right here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00296-00093375-00093503": "although it's small", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00297-00093504-00093759": "i want to give her that internal corset", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00298-00093760-00093815": "look", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00299-00093816-00094055": "so we're going to start doing that so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00300-00094056-00094150": "once again", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00301-00094151-00094423": "this is the belly button it's on a stock", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00302-00094424-00094511": "you see it goes", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00303-00094512-00094759": "through the muscle and it's connected to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00304-00094760-00094823": "the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00305-00094824-00095167": "internal abdomen you can see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00306-00095168-00095374": "what i've drawn up what we're going to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00307-00095375-00095471": "do is take", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00308-00095472-00095806": "this side of the muscle and approximate", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00309-00095807-00095887": "it to depth", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00310-00095888-00096150": "to the other side which is an internal", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00311-00096151-00096271": "corset", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00312-00096272-00096823": "you can see as i'm going through", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00313-00096824-00097118": "i like to do this multi-layer closure", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00314-00097119-00097367": "because i just like it to be reinforced", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00315-00097368-00097423": "so i do", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00316-00097424-00097743": "two layers your surgeon might do one two", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00317-00097744-00098079": "i'm not sure but here we always do two", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00318-00098080-00098494": "just in case you have a backup", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00319-00098495-00098767": "if you pop a stitch which is you know", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00320-00098768-00099006": "it's a suture it could be popped so", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00321-00099007-00099311": "we like to be cautious so you can see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00322-00099312-00099382": "here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00323-00099383-00099655": "it approximates it so what we're going", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00324-00099656-00099726": "to do now", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00325-00099727-00101367": "is we want to get a knot", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00326-00101368-00101591": "so you can see the the lines are", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00327-00101592-00101815": "together if you remember they were apart", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00328-00101816-00101894": "they were about", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00329-00101895-00102126": "inch and a half to two inches apart now", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00330-00102127-00102294": "they're all in one line", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00331-00102295-00102518": "now for the second layer we're going to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00332-00102519-00102686": "do a running suture", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00333-00102688-00102958": "a running suture we tie up top and we", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00334-00102959-00103142": "just run it all the way and tie it", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00335-00103143-00103415": "at the bottom this just reinforces the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00336-00103416-00103527": "incision", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00337-00103528-00103766": "and reinforces the internal core set", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00338-00103767-00103878": "that we have", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00339-00103879-00104110": "so here we are we're done you can see", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00340-00104111-00104390": "the abdominal wall is nice and tight", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00341-00104391-00104606": "we fixated our belly button so it", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00342-00104607-00104871": "doesn't move around all over the place", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00343-00104872-00105254": "and now it's time for the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00344-00105255-00105654": "skin excision so we measured both sides", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00345-00105655-00105854": "equal distance and now we're going to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00346-00105855-00106007": "make the cut on the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00347-00106008-00106407": "left side of the tummy tuck and here we", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00348-00106408-00106483": "go", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00349-00106483-00107551": "and", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00350-00107552-00107934": "there we are all the way one swing of", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00351-00107935-00108078": "the bat", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00352-00108079-00108302": "so here we are this is it this is the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00353-00108303-00108702": "midline there it goes we got it all off", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00354-00108703-00109086": "celebration let's pop the shirt", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00355-00109088-00109454": "pop the champagne whoa", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00356-00109455-00110575": "wow that's a great piece", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00357-00110576-00110871": "so we measure out where the belly button", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00358-00110872-00111119": "is i feel it from underneath i see where", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00359-00111120-00111183": "it is", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00360-00111183-00111366": "so what i do is i'm going to make her a", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00361-00111367-00111551": "nice classic incision", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00362-00111552-00112054": "for the belly button right here", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00363-00112055-00112247": "and that's how a belly button is made", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00364-00112248-00112439": "it's brought out through", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00365-00112440-00112758": "a incision and it's your actual", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00366-00112759-00113215": "own belly button", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00367-00113216-00113447": "so you can see i tunnel it all the way", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00368-00113448-00113702": "down the thickness of the whole abdomen", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00369-00113703-00113919": "so there's a tunnel made between the", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00370-00113920-00114063": "anterior wall", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00371-00114064-00114286": "and where the belly button is so it", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00372-00114288-00114423": "could be pulled through", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00373-00114424-00114663": "so everyone our marathon case is over we", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00374-00114664-00114807": "did bilateral", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00375-00114808-00115095": "j brachioplasty you can see it started", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00376-00115096-00115295": "out here the elbow comes in", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00377-00115296-00115639": "and really contours the chest we did", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00378-00115640-00115943": "600 cc's of that to each breast they", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00379-00115944-00115986": "look", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00380-00115988-00116302": "rejuvenated and for the main", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00381-00116303-00116534": "course this was pretty big i wanted to", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00382-00116535-00116686": "see how long this", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00383-00116688-00116902": "is actually this was the old belly", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00384-00116903-00117095": "button look at how it goes from", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00385-00117096-00117383": "side to side and let's see how the new", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00386-00117383-00117510": "one looks", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00387-00117511-00117854": "whoa look at that beautiful thin scar", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00388-00117855-00118119": "everything's stretched out she has she", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00389-00118120-00118158": "has", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00390-00118159-00118390": "curves where she didn't have curves her", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00391-00118391-00118566": "incision is down low", "i1P0QIPIeh0-00392-00118567-00119383": "she looks fantabulous"}}, {"audio_id": "i2dMRUeJqik", "text": {"i2dMRUeJqik-00000-00000888-00001039": "welcome to the songwriters panel", "i2dMRUeJqik-00001-00001040-00001231": "songwriting panel", "i2dMRUeJqik-00002-00001232-00001535": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00003-00001536-00001663": "so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00004-00001664-00001855": "who likes songs who likes songs who hear", "i2dMRUeJqik-00005-00001855-00001991": "like songs and who here likes writing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00006-00001992-00002175": "well turns out you can combine those two", "i2dMRUeJqik-00007-00002176-00002591": "interests reese's peanut butter cup like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00008-00002592-00002839": "uh i am an ill-prepared moderator", "i2dMRUeJqik-00009-00002840-00002983": "because i figured everybody's smart and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00010-00002984-00003118": "interesting and we're going to throw to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00011-00003119-00003390": "questions very early but first just to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00012-00003392-00003847": "throw throw something out there because", "i2dMRUeJqik-00013-00003847-00004070": "we have a combination of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00014-00004071-00004311": "writing styles and combinations here on", "i2dMRUeJqik-00015-00004312-00004559": "the stage we have a number of duos", "i2dMRUeJqik-00016-00004560-00004799": "member of a trio some individual artists", "i2dMRUeJqik-00017-00004800-00005167": "and an artist who does not write lyrics", "i2dMRUeJqik-00018-00005168-00005295": "uh and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00019-00005296-00005486": "while it's a cliched question to ask", "i2dMRUeJqik-00020-00005487-00005727": "about what your process is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00021-00005728-00005870": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00022-00005871-00005951": "for", "i2dMRUeJqik-00023-00005952-00006143": "uh so actually go quickly introduce", "i2dMRUeJqik-00024-00006144-00006295": "yourselves we're paul storm hi you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00025-00006296-00006383": "us", "i2dMRUeJqik-00026-00006384-00006759": "i'm ben from jukeblocks the ghost", "i2dMRUeJqik-00027-00006759-00006846": "sergeant", "i2dMRUeJqik-00028-00006847-00008342": "thank you so much", "i2dMRUeJqik-00029-00008343-00008478": "i'm going to start this question with", "i2dMRUeJqik-00030-00008479-00008663": "ben the storm and i are a songwriting", "i2dMRUeJqik-00031-00008664-00008887": "duo and our process is pretty", "i2dMRUeJqik-00032-00008888-00009078": "collaborative although you know usually", "i2dMRUeJqik-00033-00009079-00009287": "one of us brings in at least the kernel", "i2dMRUeJqik-00034-00009288-00009535": "of an idea but very quickly", "i2dMRUeJqik-00035-00009536-00009735": "usually over google docs since we live", "i2dMRUeJqik-00036-00009736-00009878": "in two different places it's sort of a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00037-00009879-00009999": "collaborative thing sometimes we're on", "i2dMRUeJqik-00038-00010000-00010159": "the phone with each other sometimes just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00039-00010160-00010319": "typing at each other", "i2dMRUeJqik-00040-00010320-00010471": "for you guys i know there are multiple", "i2dMRUeJqik-00041-00010472-00010671": "songwriters in the group are you is it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00042-00010672-00010878": "sort of a london mccartney kind of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00043-00010879-00011055": "mishmash you each bring in your own", "i2dMRUeJqik-00044-00011056-00011287": "thing and tweak it how does your process", "i2dMRUeJqik-00045-00011288-00011478": "work generally yeah i think uh so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00046-00011479-00011678": "there's there's i mean we all we all", "i2dMRUeJqik-00047-00011679-00011846": "write there's three members in our band", "i2dMRUeJqik-00048-00011847-00012167": "drums uh tommy does guitar and sings and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00049-00012168-00012406": "i do piano and thing and blah blah blah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00050-00012407-00012727": "but um we sort of each will start with", "i2dMRUeJqik-00051-00012728-00012951": "our own idea and i think usually trying", "i2dMRUeJqik-00052-00012952-00013191": "to get it as far along as we can so that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00053-00013191-00013399": "when we bring it into the band it's a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00054-00013400-00013630": "easier sell you know because otherwise", "i2dMRUeJqik-00055-00013631-00013815": "you bring in hey i have this great lyric", "i2dMRUeJqik-00056-00013816-00014007": "idea and someone else has a fully", "i2dMRUeJqik-00057-00014008-00014215": "fledged song there's no way that that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00058-00014216-00014455": "lyric is ever gonna see the light of day", "i2dMRUeJqik-00059-00014456-00014535": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00060-00014536-00014743": "so yeah i in each song you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00061-00014744-00014935": "sometimes you bring it in and and you've", "i2dMRUeJqik-00062-00014936-00015071": "you know i've worked on it worked on it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00063-00015072-00015263": "and then the guys get there and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-00064-00015263-00015558": "completely fix it and change it and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00065-00015559-00015855": "get angry and we fuss", "i2dMRUeJqik-00066-00015856-00015999": "and it usually ends up being a lot", "i2dMRUeJqik-00067-00016000-00016191": "better than i in my brain that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00068-00016191-00016558": "perfection uh was or was not um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00069-00016559-00016727": "every song every song is different every", "i2dMRUeJqik-00070-00016728-00016991": "song has its own weird path do you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00071-00016992-00017135": "generally", "i2dMRUeJqik-00072-00017136-00017350": "is there is it generally there at first", "i2dMRUeJqik-00073-00017351-00017535": "or music first or is it obviously it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00074-00017536-00017727": "will depend on the song but is there a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00075-00017728-00017950": "one more than the other guys i'm a music", "i2dMRUeJqik-00076-00017951-00018263": "first person like like a classical piano", "i2dMRUeJqik-00077-00018264-00018447": "background like i live there and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-00078-00018448-00018719": "try to find the song and then tommy is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00079-00018720-00018983": "usually lyric in concept first so that's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00080-00018984-00019127": "sort of how we end up meeting in the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00081-00019128-00019222": "middle", "i2dMRUeJqik-00082-00019223-00019686": "and uh zoey lyric or music first", "i2dMRUeJqik-00083-00019687-00019822": "i'm very interested in sort of your", "i2dMRUeJqik-00084-00019823-00019967": "writing process as well given that you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00085-00019968-00020167": "are a solo artist and looping do you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00086-00020168-00020350": "what where's the core", "i2dMRUeJqik-00087-00020351-00020575": "where your songs come from", "i2dMRUeJqik-00088-00020576-00020791": "there are words for my songs but only i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00089-00020792-00020935": "know them", "i2dMRUeJqik-00090-00020936-00021319": "are they in a secret language", "i2dMRUeJqik-00091-00021320-00021503": "well no no they are actually in english", "i2dMRUeJqik-00092-00021504-00021743": "and some songs are based on sort of a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00093-00021744-00022047": "phrase that i have in my head and um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00094-00022048-00022303": "and i might actually be sort of singing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00095-00022304-00022575": "that phrase as i'm playing so it's like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00096-00022576-00022791": "a secret extra lyric you know that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00097-00022792-00023127": "doesn't exist um and then other ones um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00098-00023128-00023214": "you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00099-00023215-00023375": "i uh", "i2dMRUeJqik-00100-00023376-00023647": "i know that they don't have words but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00101-00023648-00023894": "for me they definitely have words you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00102-00023895-00024022": "know even even if they're not worth", "i2dMRUeJqik-00103-00024023-00024271": "words they're they're music and um i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00104-00024272-00024567": "have like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00105-00024568-00024745": "the words are just in musical form", "i2dMRUeJqik-00106-00024746-00025214": "[Music]", "i2dMRUeJqik-00107-00025215-00025486": "me i want to be in your brain well like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00108-00025487-00025702": "um i'm gonna have a song called sunwall", "i2dMRUeJqik-00109-00025704-00025927": "set and uh", "i2dMRUeJqik-00110-00025927-00026150": "for me that has very specific words but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00111-00026151-00026383": "they're just musical words you know the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00112-00026383-00026590": "words are the music is the words and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00113-00026591-00026767": "always write everything in song format", "i2dMRUeJqik-00114-00026768-00027046": "like just like everybody else but um and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00115-00027047-00027231": "i write the chorus first and then i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00116-00027232-00027383": "write backwards from there to create the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00117-00027383-00027646": "song out of the chorus", "i2dMRUeJqik-00118-00027647-00027839": "do you have like an actual vocabulary", "i2dMRUeJqik-00119-00027839-00028079": "like from one song to another will you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00120-00028080-00028270": "have like a no no it's unique it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00121-00028272-00028446": "unique to the song so there's like a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00122-00028447-00028639": "sugar rose kind of thing where it's sort", "i2dMRUeJqik-00123-00028639-00028831": "of not quite word words or they're", "i2dMRUeJqik-00124-00028832-00028958": "actually kind of there are actually", "i2dMRUeJqik-00125-00028960-00029174": "words yeah and they're very personal and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00126-00029175-00029399": "so i i don't usually share them the fact", "i2dMRUeJqik-00127-00029400-00029527": "that i never share those with anyone", "i2dMRUeJqik-00128-00029527-00029614": "except", "i2dMRUeJqik-00129-00029616-00029895": "share them with our audience right now", "i2dMRUeJqik-00130-00029895-00030070": "we'll put them on the screen", "i2dMRUeJqik-00131-00030072-00030335": "yeah and sometimes i feel like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00132-00030336-00030470": "you know i'm always slightly worried", "i2dMRUeJqik-00133-00030472-00030679": "that somebody might learn what the words", "i2dMRUeJqik-00134-00030680-00030927": "are for my song the secret words and so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00135-00030927-00031151": "i will in that case give it a title that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00136-00031152-00031358": "is a red herring", "i2dMRUeJqik-00137-00031360-00031495": "wow", "i2dMRUeJqik-00138-00031495-00031670": "so is it like a rumpelstiltskin thing if", "i2dMRUeJqik-00139-00031672-00031807": "someone guessed the name you would never", "i2dMRUeJqik-00140-00031808-00031999": "do that song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00141-00032000-00032199": "probably that's never happened if they", "i2dMRUeJqik-00142-00032200-00032414": "can make it on the subject luckily elon", "i2dMRUeJqik-00143-00032416-00032639": "musk's thing to like read your minds is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00144-00032639-00032823": "not a thing yet right because as soon as", "i2dMRUeJqik-00145-00032824-00033118": "that happens i won't be able to perform", "i2dMRUeJqik-00146-00033119-00033302": "that's why you will never allow elon", "i2dMRUeJqik-00147-00033303-00033527": "musk to attend one of your concerts no", "i2dMRUeJqik-00148-00033528-00033839": "no uh and desa again to ask the overly", "i2dMRUeJqik-00149-00033840-00034127": "broad question for you is it uh you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00150-00034128-00034374": "do you have sort of a core concept are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00151-00034375-00034655": "you lyrics first versus music where", "i2dMRUeJqik-00152-00034656-00034823": "where do your songs usually come from to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00153-00034824-00034990": "the extent that there's a pattern", "i2dMRUeJqik-00154-00034991-00035151": "um i would say that you know when i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00155-00035152-00035374": "started in music it was essentially as", "i2dMRUeJqik-00156-00035375-00035567": "like a as a failed writer who'd been", "i2dMRUeJqik-00157-00035568-00035718": "trying to get published for a long time", "i2dMRUeJqik-00158-00035719-00035927": "couldn't get a deal and a friend of mine", "i2dMRUeJqik-00159-00035928-00036118": "suggested that i try slam poetry and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00160-00036119-00036335": "from there i met a bunch of rappers and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00161-00036336-00036415": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00162-00036416-00036623": "rap works i sometimes describe as kind", "i2dMRUeJqik-00163-00036624-00036774": "of like legos", "i2dMRUeJqik-00164-00036775-00036999": "it's a very modular writing form usually", "i2dMRUeJqik-00165-00037000-00037079": "so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00166-00037080-00037239": "you would ask like if we were all going", "i2dMRUeJqik-00167-00037240-00037399": "to do a show and there was a beat on", "i2dMRUeJqik-00168-00037400-00037615": "somebody would say who's got 16s", "i2dMRUeJqik-00169-00037616-00037855": "so you can kind of snap a verse", "i2dMRUeJqik-00170-00037856-00038102": "you know over any", "i2dMRUeJqik-00171-00038103-00038415": "reasonably bpm range um you know beats", "i2dMRUeJqik-00172-00038416-00038583": "per minute range at a reasonable tempo", "i2dMRUeJqik-00173-00038584-00038846": "and so usually in rap music", "i2dMRUeJqik-00174-00038847-00039023": "it's very much like your job as the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00175-00039024-00039230": "writer or your job is the beat maker and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00176-00039231-00039359": "even if you do both roles you don't do", "i2dMRUeJqik-00177-00039360-00039535": "them at the same time you know and in a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00178-00039536-00039735": "collaborative way it's really easy in", "i2dMRUeJqik-00179-00039736-00039823": "that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00180-00039824-00039974": "you can meet someone for the first time", "i2dMRUeJqik-00181-00039975-00040151": "on stage and really", "i2dMRUeJqik-00182-00040152-00040335": "quickly generate a song together by", "i2dMRUeJqik-00183-00040336-00040559": "saying i need something at about 70 ppm", "i2dMRUeJqik-00184-00040560-00040830": "and then we'll just do burst passes", "i2dMRUeJqik-00185-00040831-00040974": "somebody got a chorus can you teach it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00186-00040975-00041095": "to us we could all do the chorus", "i2dMRUeJqik-00187-00041096-00041311": "together um so that was how i learned", "i2dMRUeJqik-00188-00041312-00041518": "which is kind of in 16", "i2dMRUeJqik-00189-00041519-00041727": "barn chunks like that but when i started", "i2dMRUeJqik-00190-00041728-00041871": "as is the case for a lot of rappers i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00191-00041872-00042111": "think i didn't know what a bar was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00192-00042112-00042295": "i didn't know what a measure was or a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00193-00042296-00042535": "snare and so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00194-00042536-00042711": "i was hiding that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00195-00042712-00042918": "because i didn't want to you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00196-00042919-00043167": "reveal my ignorance um and so a lot of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00197-00043168-00043302": "us i think the beginning we're writing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00198-00043303-00043815": "like hot 17 and a half bar verses", "i2dMRUeJqik-00199-00043816-00044007": "that was a lot of like no", "i2dMRUeJqik-00200-00044008-00044158": "yo", "i2dMRUeJqik-00201-00044159-00044439": "every verse until the one came around", "i2dMRUeJqik-00202-00044440-00044574": "now um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00203-00044575-00044839": "as a as you know now that i have a role", "i2dMRUeJqik-00204-00044840-00044999": "in music but i would say that i'm also", "i2dMRUeJqik-00205-00045000-00045167": "like aware of what i think my strengths", "i2dMRUeJqik-00206-00045168-00045343": "are and what my", "i2dMRUeJqik-00207-00045344-00045423": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00208-00045424-00045623": "what my weaknesses are like you know the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00209-00045624-00045790": "people with whom i collaborate are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00210-00045791-00045911": "better at", "i2dMRUeJqik-00211-00045912-00046111": "um writing percussion than i am i just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00212-00046112-00046262": "don't have a natural gift for that at", "i2dMRUeJqik-00213-00046263-00046502": "least not what i've developed um but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00214-00046503-00046695": "yeah for me i would say words and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00215-00046696-00046958": "concept are are almost almost always", "i2dMRUeJqik-00216-00046959-00047118": "first", "i2dMRUeJqik-00217-00047119-00047351": "i have a question for paul and storm yes", "i2dMRUeJqik-00218-00047352-00047855": "um so in your songs um do you uh tend to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00219-00047856-00048095": "divide like somebody does music more", "i2dMRUeJqik-00220-00048096-00048327": "than lyrics or do you do you do it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00221-00048328-00048551": "evenly or one can you can your fans", "i2dMRUeJqik-00222-00048552-00048767": "identify oh that's a storm song or", "i2dMRUeJqik-00223-00048768-00048967": "that's what it sounds like that's a very", "i2dMRUeJqik-00224-00048968-00049183": "good question that i'm not sure like for", "i2dMRUeJqik-00225-00049184-00049383": "to my mind it tends to be kind of a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00226-00049384-00049615": "mishmash anymore like i think storm", "i2dMRUeJqik-00227-00049616-00049790": "probably", "i2dMRUeJqik-00228-00049791-00049943": "i mean storm's one who plays an", "i2dMRUeJqik-00229-00049944-00050190": "instrument consistently i'm a terrible", "i2dMRUeJqik-00230-00050191-00050399": "keyboard player and that's the ex i play", "i2dMRUeJqik-00231-00050400-00050558": "trumpet i play trumpet for 12 years but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00232-00050559-00050743": "that's not great for performing and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00233-00050744-00050855": "singing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00234-00050856-00051143": "um so i you know i will come at things", "i2dMRUeJqik-00235-00051144-00051335": "melodically i like to think i have a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00236-00051336-00051487": "pretty good", "i2dMRUeJqik-00237-00051488-00051750": "ear for a melody and a hook and such not", "i2dMRUeJqik-00238-00051751-00051966": "that storm doesn't but i you know far", "i2dMRUeJqik-00239-00051967-00052182": "more so than the sort of underlying", "i2dMRUeJqik-00240-00052183-00052342": "chord structure i'll hear something but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00241-00052344-00052447": "i can't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00242-00052448-00052687": "verbalize it or if i pluck away long", "i2dMRUeJqik-00243-00052688-00052854": "enough in a piano i can plug it out but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00244-00052855-00053054": "storm's certainly much more adept at", "i2dMRUeJqik-00245-00053055-00053207": "sort of hearing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00246-00053208-00053423": "how an actual arrangement can hold oh", "i2dMRUeJqik-00247-00053424-00053687": "yeah like like chord changes uh come", "i2dMRUeJqik-00248-00053688-00053847": "very easily in hooks and things like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00249-00053848-00054094": "that and i naturally tend towards the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00250-00054095-00054287": "music more i'll say if something is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00251-00054288-00054438": "outrageously funny it's more likely to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00252-00054439-00054630": "be fun", "i2dMRUeJqik-00253-00054632-00054830": "i get mine in there too uh but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00254-00054832-00055007": "definitely", "i2dMRUeJqik-00255-00055008-00055199": "it's mishmash yeah we're uh i mean", "i2dMRUeJqik-00256-00055200-00055350": "obviously we're being especially sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00257-00055351-00055663": "a comedy music act for the most part", "i2dMRUeJqik-00258-00055664-00055926": "uh the the metaphor i always use in my", "i2dMRUeJqik-00259-00055927-00056199": "own brain for how i construct songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-00260-00056200-00056463": "especially lyrics is it's part", "i2dMRUeJqik-00261-00056464-00056615": "part sculpture", "i2dMRUeJqik-00262-00056616-00056719": "and part", "i2dMRUeJqik-00263-00056720-00056926": "jigsaw puzzle like you know you got the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00264-00056927-00057087": "big piece of marble and you chip away", "i2dMRUeJqik-00265-00057088-00057279": "all the pieces that aren't the horse so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00266-00057279-00057423": "you know i'll often sort of know the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00267-00057424-00057607": "shape of the song like it's got to do", "i2dMRUeJqik-00268-00057608-00057847": "this kind of thing story wise or", "i2dMRUeJqik-00269-00057848-00058087": "joke-wise here and then it's gotta do", "i2dMRUeJqik-00270-00058088-00058294": "this by the bridge but then as you start", "i2dMRUeJqik-00271-00058295-00058519": "to chip away the pieces and and you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00272-00058520-00058750": "i guess i think of you know rhymes and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00273-00058751-00058926": "words as these puzzle pieces that i get", "i2dMRUeJqik-00274-00058927-00059103": "to play around with and oh i found this", "i2dMRUeJqik-00275-00059104-00059294": "one but that means but it's so it's the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00276-00059295-00059447": "shitty puzzles that are like they're all", "i2dMRUeJqik-00277-00059448-00059607": "the same shape", "i2dMRUeJqik-00278-00059608-00059726": "and you got to find the ones that fit", "i2dMRUeJqik-00279-00059727-00059863": "together right not just the ones that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00280-00059864-00060087": "fit together and it's heartbreaking when", "i2dMRUeJqik-00281-00060088-00060335": "you find this awesome awesome rhyme and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00282-00060336-00060591": "but it just doesn't work with the feel", "i2dMRUeJqik-00283-00060591-00060719": "because you have to worry about the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00284-00060720-00060999": "rhythms and timing of not just the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00285-00061000-00061238": "the uh of the rhythms the timing and the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00286-00061239-00061454": "changes but also the rhythms and timing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00287-00061455-00061679": "the timing of the comment well i think i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00288-00061679-00061879": "just went sorry that i just went my son", "i2dMRUeJqik-00289-00061879-00062015": "experienced your concert for the first", "i2dMRUeJqik-00290-00062016-00062142": "time i like that you put it as", "i2dMRUeJqik-00291-00062144-00062375": "experienced", "i2dMRUeJqik-00292-00062376-00062703": "he experienced it a lot yeah yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00293-00062704-00062838": "and we were talking about it afterwards", "i2dMRUeJqik-00294-00062839-00062942": "and said not only do you have to write", "i2dMRUeJqik-00295-00062944-00063159": "the music and the lyrics but the jokes", "i2dMRUeJqik-00296-00063160-00063359": "and what is the reveal of the joke", "i2dMRUeJqik-00297-00063360-00063479": "that's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00298-00063479-00063726": "that's the magic that's what makes us", "i2dMRUeJqik-00299-00063727-00064087": "the awesome comedy musicians that we are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00300-00064088-00064254": "uh but it is actually", "i2dMRUeJqik-00301-00064255-00064430": "we", "i2dMRUeJqik-00302-00064432-00064711": "it's the timing of a musical joke is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00303-00064712-00064903": "different than the timing of just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00304-00064904-00065094": "regular jokes we over the course of our", "i2dMRUeJqik-00305-00065095-00065319": "career have played a number of comedy", "i2dMRUeJqik-00306-00065320-00065415": "clubs", "i2dMRUeJqik-00307-00065416-00065591": "and it's weird and difficult because a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00308-00065592-00065806": "comedy club is expecting a very specific", "i2dMRUeJqik-00309-00065807-00065903": "pace", "i2dMRUeJqik-00310-00065904-00066071": "of stand up and then we come up there", "i2dMRUeJqik-00311-00066072-00066247": "and it's just by nature of the music and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00312-00066248-00066423": "certainly if you want to make the music", "i2dMRUeJqik-00313-00066424-00066582": "good quality music that you can listen", "i2dMRUeJqik-00314-00066583-00066743": "to more than once when it's not solely", "i2dMRUeJqik-00315-00066744-00066950": "about the joke the pacing is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00316-00066951-00067143": "more slack than that and but finding", "i2dMRUeJqik-00317-00067144-00067279": "that balance is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00318-00067280-00067606": "always really difficult", "i2dMRUeJqik-00319-00067607-00067775": "jonathan knows jonathan writes funny", "i2dMRUeJqik-00320-00067776-00067879": "songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-00321-00067880-00068126": "yeah yeah sometimes sometimes yeah no", "i2dMRUeJqik-00322-00068127-00068294": "it's true and i've i've had the same", "i2dMRUeJqik-00323-00068295-00068455": "experience with comedy", "i2dMRUeJqik-00324-00068456-00068623": "a comedy context coming out there and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00325-00068624-00068903": "doing a song and it's like you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00326-00068904-00069063": "there's not there's only a couple of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00327-00069064-00069199": "jokes in the song and it takes a while", "i2dMRUeJqik-00328-00069200-00069367": "to get to them and for me", "i2dMRUeJqik-00329-00069368-00069471": "for me", "i2dMRUeJqik-00330-00069472-00069591": "i think that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00331-00069592-00069806": "you know to do comedy music you need to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00332-00069807-00069911": "have", "i2dMRUeJqik-00333-00069912-00070223": "uh music and solid songwriting behind it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00334-00070224-00070447": "like i don't i don't like music comedy", "i2dMRUeJqik-00335-00070448-00070694": "music that does not also work as a piece", "i2dMRUeJqik-00336-00070695-00070799": "of music", "i2dMRUeJqik-00337-00070800-00071055": "yeah so yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00338-00071056-00071215": "and you know like i always i always", "i2dMRUeJqik-00339-00071216-00071471": "could not stand at adam sandler's stick", "i2dMRUeJqik-00340-00071472-00071647": "because it's it's kind of like you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00341-00071648-00071791": "it's much more on the comedian end of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00342-00071792-00071982": "things yeah and it's like you know that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00343-00071983-00072159": "could be that could be that also could", "i2dMRUeJqik-00344-00072160-00072287": "be a great song if you worked on it a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00345-00072288-00072487": "little harder", "i2dMRUeJqik-00346-00072488-00072775": "uh and honks flat yeah hong kong splat", "i2dMRUeJqik-00347-00072776-00072862": "exactly", "i2dMRUeJqik-00348-00072863-00073023": "that's one of the things i love both", "i2dMRUeJqik-00349-00073024-00073238": "about des music and jukebox the ghost", "i2dMRUeJqik-00350-00073239-00073431": "it's the kind of music i'm drawn to it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00351-00073432-00073623": "not comedy music by any stretch but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00352-00073624-00073894": "there's a lot of humor humor smartness", "i2dMRUeJqik-00353-00073895-00074079": "in there that draws you memory yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00354-00074080-00074238": "tickles your brain and you know i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00355-00074239-00074423": "appreciate that you know is are you is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00356-00074424-00074567": "that a conscious thing are you sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00357-00074568-00074799": "your personality coming to the work are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00358-00074800-00074959": "you like this song should be funnier i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00359-00074960-00075071": "could get something a little more", "i2dMRUeJqik-00360-00075072-00075255": "amusing in here clever and clever is a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00361-00075256-00075447": "terrible word no that you do want to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00362-00075448-00075655": "have it be interesting i always wanted", "i2dMRUeJqik-00363-00075656-00075847": "to be like musically interesting i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00364-00075848-00076031": "wanted to be able to stand the song to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00365-00076032-00076199": "stand on its own the chords to be", "i2dMRUeJqik-00366-00076200-00076415": "interesting whatever and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-00367-00076416-00076655": "play musical jokes i love a build up", "i2dMRUeJqik-00368-00076656-00076806": "that doesn't land or a chord that's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00369-00076807-00077006": "unpredictable or a change that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00370-00077007-00077215": "modulation is great well the modulation", "i2dMRUeJqik-00371-00077216-00077375": "we love a key change", "i2dMRUeJqik-00372-00077376-00077550": "writing songs and keys that i can't sing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00373-00077551-00077703": "so then we have to drop it down after", "i2dMRUeJqik-00374-00077704-00077926": "you record it live", "i2dMRUeJqik-00375-00077927-00078055": "that's just a joke", "i2dMRUeJqik-00376-00078056-00078231": "for us", "i2dMRUeJqik-00377-00078232-00078406": "and then you know writing songs that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00378-00078407-00078575": "might seem", "i2dMRUeJqik-00379-00078576-00078775": "one way in terms of like the musical", "i2dMRUeJqik-00380-00078776-00078919": "tone and the energy and then you get", "i2dMRUeJqik-00381-00078920-00079094": "into the lyrics and it's dark or", "i2dMRUeJqik-00382-00079095-00079343": "subversive or angry or", "i2dMRUeJqik-00383-00079344-00079471": "whatever it happens to be and playing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00384-00079472-00079694": "with those sorts of expectations so that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00385-00079695-00079847": "when you actually dig into it there's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00386-00079848-00080023": "more than just a pop song because when", "i2dMRUeJqik-00387-00080024-00080182": "you work in the pop song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00388-00080183-00080350": "world whether it's comedy or record", "i2dMRUeJqik-00389-00080351-00080494": "whatever there's a formula and there are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00390-00080495-00080767": "things that you sort of have to tip off", "i2dMRUeJqik-00391-00080768-00080926": "that then you want a little more", "i2dMRUeJqik-00392-00080927-00081191": "substance to it if you can i i i just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00393-00081192-00081359": "have so many questions it's like maybe i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00394-00081360-00081631": "should just ask you all later", "i2dMRUeJqik-00395-00081632-00081791": "and by the way if any of you do have", "i2dMRUeJqik-00396-00081792-00081926": "questions we have a microphone down here", "i2dMRUeJqik-00397-00081927-00082047": "we're going to throw the questions very", "i2dMRUeJqik-00398-00082048-00082247": "soon or if you have any mobility issues", "i2dMRUeJqik-00399-00082248-00082359": "just raise your hand we'll make sure it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00400-00082360-00082535": "gets brought to you but uh what yeah if", "i2dMRUeJqik-00401-00082536-00082735": "you've got another one", "i2dMRUeJqik-00402-00082736-00082887": "i was wondering this question for all of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00403-00082888-00083167": "you um say you've you know you've you've", "i2dMRUeJqik-00404-00083168-00083350": "written your perfect song you're ready", "i2dMRUeJqik-00405-00083351-00083559": "to go perform it and you get up there", "i2dMRUeJqik-00406-00083560-00083679": "and you've", "i2dMRUeJqik-00407-00083680-00083831": "do you feel it has it ever been a time", "i2dMRUeJqik-00408-00083832-00083999": "you feel it just doesn't work in front", "i2dMRUeJqik-00409-00084000-00084082": "of the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00410-00084083-00084182": "audience and then do you go back and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00411-00084183-00084303": "change it what do you do then do you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00412-00084304-00084455": "ditch it like how does that happen you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00413-00084456-00084623": "know that wasn't sort of my question", "i2dMRUeJqik-00414-00084624-00084782": "and um i wanted to ask that first to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00415-00084783-00084903": "desa", "i2dMRUeJqik-00416-00084904-00085006": "um like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00417-00085007-00085231": "i love the way when you're performing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00418-00085232-00085375": "you sort of would", "i2dMRUeJqik-00419-00085376-00085647": "step aside and step out of the song and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00420-00085648-00085815": "talk to the audience and i was wondering", "i2dMRUeJqik-00421-00085816-00086079": "if that came as part of the song or as a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00422-00086080-00086238": "performer or", "i2dMRUeJqik-00423-00086239-00086494": "there was a lot of questions in there", "i2dMRUeJqik-00424-00086495-00086638": "i mean i think like when you guys were", "i2dMRUeJqik-00425-00086639-00086782": "talking about you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00426-00086783-00086991": "comedic or songwriting with a comedic", "i2dMRUeJqik-00427-00086992-00087126": "element like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00428-00087127-00087335": "i haven't i've just i've got maybe three", "i2dMRUeJqik-00429-00087336-00087503": "songs that are funny", "i2dMRUeJqik-00430-00087504-00087831": "or that are intentionally funny um and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00431-00087832-00088006": "think i've always been like leaned", "i2dMRUeJqik-00432-00088007-00088094": "pretty", "i2dMRUeJqik-00433-00088095-00088303": "hard into like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00434-00088304-00088543": "existential sad girl literary feminist", "i2dMRUeJqik-00435-00088544-00088750": "hip-hop and then to maybe offset that i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00436-00088751-00088935": "had i was getting like increasingly", "i2dMRUeJqik-00437-00088936-00089223": "goofy banter you know but then i thought", "i2dMRUeJqik-00438-00089224-00089375": "at times people would meet me and were", "i2dMRUeJqik-00439-00089376-00089606": "surprised and i wasn't like really goth", "i2dMRUeJqik-00440-00089607-00089718": "or really", "i2dMRUeJqik-00441-00089719-00089911": "sad all the time if you just listen to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00442-00089912-00090055": "the recorded stuff", "i2dMRUeJqik-00443-00090056-00090262": "um but i was like listening to you guys", "i2dMRUeJqik-00444-00090263-00090503": "i'm so just like viscerally jealous", "i2dMRUeJqik-00445-00090504-00090735": "because mine is quantized", "i2dMRUeJqik-00446-00090736-00090918": "which", "i2dMRUeJqik-00447-00090919-00091182": "is it's like inoculates a joke against", "i2dMRUeJqik-00448-00091183-00091471": "itself you know it's like um it prevents", "i2dMRUeJqik-00449-00091472-00091662": "you essentially meaning that the tempo", "i2dMRUeJqik-00450-00091663-00091887": "is unchanging right because i'm working", "i2dMRUeJqik-00451-00091888-00092167": "with uh electronically produced music", "i2dMRUeJqik-00452-00092168-00092367": "almost all the time as opposed to like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00453-00092368-00092535": "that great fluidity when something's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00454-00092536-00092703": "working you know and somebody", "i2dMRUeJqik-00455-00092704-00092967": "throws a masked pair of underwear at you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00456-00092968-00093126": "like you can", "i2dMRUeJqik-00457-00093127-00093343": "milk that moment so he gets that lock", "i2dMRUeJqik-00458-00093344-00093647": "you know what i mean", "i2dMRUeJqik-00459-00093648-00093774": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00460-00093775-00093991": "so yeah i think the banter for me was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00461-00093992-00094231": "also just like um maybe a product of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00462-00094232-00094359": "asthma in that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00463-00094360-00094615": "um in hip hop you dance and we would", "i2dMRUeJqik-00464-00094616-00094926": "just pogo the whole show but i can't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00465-00094927-00095231": "pogo the whole show and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00466-00095232-00095431": "also be a musician it's kind of one of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00467-00095432-00095687": "the other and so i learned i think to do", "i2dMRUeJqik-00468-00095688-00095903": "a lot of bodily stuff to look like i was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00469-00095904-00096087": "still moving i was like i'm a laser", "i2dMRUeJqik-00470-00096088-00096271": "pointer too you know what i mean with", "i2dMRUeJqik-00471-00096272-00096431": "the cat because i can't jump with the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00472-00096432-00096623": "guys who are who don't have pitch", "i2dMRUeJqik-00473-00096624-00096774": "responsibilities they have rap", "i2dMRUeJqik-00474-00096775-00096959": "responsibilities but they don't you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00475-00096960-00097118": "have to worry about like their larynx", "i2dMRUeJqik-00476-00097119-00097447": "jogging and missing a note", "i2dMRUeJqik-00477-00097448-00097599": "oh and then back to the thing of like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00478-00097600-00097718": "things that haven't worked can you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00479-00097719-00097918": "change the song to make it work yeah i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00480-00097919-00098111": "mean i think first my", "i2dMRUeJqik-00481-00098112-00098262": "my first impulse if i really believe in", "i2dMRUeJqik-00482-00098263-00098487": "the song is to try to perform it really", "i2dMRUeJqik-00483-00098488-00098655": "differently you know so i mean there's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00484-00098656-00098791": "things where", "i2dMRUeJqik-00485-00098792-00098950": "try it really mean", "i2dMRUeJqik-00486-00098951-00099150": "try it like um like sometimes like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00487-00099151-00099399": "fembot you know just tone like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00488-00099400-00099518": "expression", "i2dMRUeJqik-00489-00099519-00099759": "um sit down on the edge of the thing i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00490-00099760-00100006": "stand on the backs of chairs a lot um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00491-00100007-00100182": "and just ask people to like kill all the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00492-00100183-00100382": "house lights you know like does it help", "i2dMRUeJqik-00493-00100383-00100591": "if i'm", "i2dMRUeJqik-00494-00100592-00100791": "in an aqua box or something", "i2dMRUeJqik-00495-00100792-00100950": "yeah and then if the song is really", "i2dMRUeJqik-00496-00100951-00101047": "broken", "i2dMRUeJqik-00497-00101048-00101303": "i i'll try to but usually i i don't know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00498-00101304-00101471": "i think i trust my compass maybe two", "i2dMRUeJqik-00499-00101472-00101615": "thoughts and i'm like i know this song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00500-00101616-00101926": "is good maybe it's just not good live", "i2dMRUeJqik-00501-00101927-00102087": "let me let me throw the question back at", "i2dMRUeJqik-00502-00102088-00102247": "you zombie have you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00503-00102248-00102374": "when you bring out", "i2dMRUeJqik-00504-00102375-00102551": "a new work have you found things that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00505-00102552-00102815": "just to your mind just haven't worked", "i2dMRUeJqik-00506-00102816-00103039": "pretty much every day okay yeah and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-00507-00103040-00103142": "what is your response to it the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00508-00103143-00103327": "alternative", "i2dMRUeJqik-00509-00103328-00103534": "some of them i have a couple songs that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00510-00103535-00103782": "could have kept roughly the same and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00511-00103783-00103999": "then i change them out of just personal", "i2dMRUeJqik-00512-00104000-00104175": "boredom because i get bored with them", "i2dMRUeJqik-00513-00104176-00104558": "eventually um and i don't i can't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00514-00104559-00104871": "drop out of my own band so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00515-00104872-00105095": "so i have to change the songs to keep", "i2dMRUeJqik-00516-00105096-00105334": "myself interested but other times", "i2dMRUeJqik-00517-00105335-00105447": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00518-00105448-00105686": "i'll keep changing it until it works and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00519-00105688-00105919": "then if it doesn't work then i just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00520-00105920-00106102": "think well maybe this can't work live", "i2dMRUeJqik-00521-00106103-00106295": "because i have to do things sequentially", "i2dMRUeJqik-00522-00106296-00106599": "like i have to play a little bit like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00523-00106600-00106766": "you know there are no jokes in my song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00524-00106767-00106983": "but whatever is like the musical point i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00525-00106983-00107231": "have to achieve it myself incrementally", "i2dMRUeJqik-00526-00107232-00107423": "because i have to play all the parts and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00527-00107424-00107583": "sometimes the audience doesn't have", "i2dMRUeJqik-00528-00107583-00107815": "patience to wait for all those parts to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00529-00107816-00107919": "be played", "i2dMRUeJqik-00530-00107920-00108086": "until i can stack them all up into a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00531-00108088-00108199": "song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00532-00108200-00108343": "and so sometimes i have to think about", "i2dMRUeJqik-00533-00108344-00108502": "like well is there a different way i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00534-00108503-00108686": "could execute it or", "i2dMRUeJqik-00535-00108688-00108799": "you know it's like a public point", "i2dMRUeJqik-00536-00108800-00108958": "because the way the way your music works", "i2dMRUeJqik-00537-00108959-00109175": "it's not the song is not", "i2dMRUeJqik-00538-00109176-00109375": "the thing that you're performing is not", "i2dMRUeJqik-00539-00109376-00109543": "the and even the song of the recorded", "i2dMRUeJqik-00540-00109544-00109727": "versions are not the destination it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00541-00109728-00109878": "the journey to the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00542-00109879-00110158": "thing so the piece is a is a time-based", "i2dMRUeJqik-00543-00110159-00110247": "piece", "i2dMRUeJqik-00544-00110248-00110415": "that builds itself yeah and sometimes it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00545-00110416-00110551": "might be that like it's just not", "i2dMRUeJqik-00546-00110552-00110686": "interesting enough to take that whole", "i2dMRUeJqik-00547-00110688-00110871": "journey right and i have to either", "i2dMRUeJqik-00548-00110872-00111095": "change it or", "i2dMRUeJqik-00549-00111096-00111231": "do something different", "i2dMRUeJqik-00550-00111232-00111415": "when when actually it's a question for", "i2dMRUeJqik-00551-00111416-00111510": "everybody", "i2dMRUeJqik-00552-00111511-00111710": "when when you are writing or do you have", "i2dMRUeJqik-00553-00111711-00111902": "an audience in mind or is it coming from", "i2dMRUeJqik-00554-00111903-00112247": "just a pure place of creating um i would", "i2dMRUeJqik-00555-00112248-00112383": "like to say it's just a pure place of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00556-00112383-00112678": "creating but i'm a people pleaser", "i2dMRUeJqik-00557-00112679-00112823": "and the moment that that actually", "i2dMRUeJqik-00558-00112824-00113015": "crystallized was when i was on tour with", "i2dMRUeJqik-00559-00113016-00113254": "the wonderful engineer who you all know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00560-00113255-00113654": "and um my first tour with her was 2006", "i2dMRUeJqik-00561-00113655-00113927": "and uh i had just started bringing a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00562-00113928-00114086": "computer on stage with me and it was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00563-00114088-00114271": "continually crashing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00564-00114272-00114510": "and um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00565-00114511-00114743": "i had come out of a you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00566-00114744-00115023": "an environment playing 20-minute long", "i2dMRUeJqik-00567-00115024-00115278": "free cello odysseys you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00568-00115279-00115590": "for a horizontal audience and um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00569-00115591-00115799": "but her audience they were all teenagers", "i2dMRUeJqik-00570-00115800-00115975": "and they had like less than 30 second", "i2dMRUeJqik-00571-00115976-00116119": "intention spans", "i2dMRUeJqik-00572-00116120-00116358": "and so i had to get them in those first", "i2dMRUeJqik-00573-00116359-00116519": "30 seconds or else they would just be", "i2dMRUeJqik-00574-00116520-00116631": "chattering and i would be totally", "i2dMRUeJqik-00575-00116632-00116863": "humiliated as her opening act", "i2dMRUeJqik-00576-00116864-00116943": "and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00577-00116944-00117166": "so really quickly i figured out how to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00578-00117167-00117319": "do a couple songs where i would just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00579-00117320-00117583": "execute things really fast", "i2dMRUeJqik-00580-00117583-00117663": "and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00581-00117664-00117902": "and that became like a fun puzzle like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00582-00117903-00118239": "oh how could i turn this 20-minute long", "i2dMRUeJqik-00583-00118240-00118399": "cello jam", "i2dMRUeJqik-00584-00118400-00118671": "band of one person into a three-minute", "i2dMRUeJqik-00585-00118672-00118807": "song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00586-00118808-00119039": "so yeah ben", "i2dMRUeJqik-00587-00119040-00119215": "does the band keep the audience in mind", "i2dMRUeJqik-00588-00119216-00119366": "first last", "i2dMRUeJqik-00589-00119367-00119639": "i think not at all uh no i'm kidding", "i2dMRUeJqik-00590-00119640-00119990": "obsessively so um i do think every", "i2dMRUeJqik-00591-00119991-00120102": "you know there are songs that you write", "i2dMRUeJqik-00592-00120103-00120295": "just to be a song and then you have this", "i2dMRUeJqik-00593-00120296-00120534": "moment of you put it in a set and it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00594-00120535-00120743": "doesn't work or you know you can only", "i2dMRUeJqik-00595-00120744-00120999": "have so many like mid tempo ballots and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00596-00121000-00121334": "like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00597-00121335-00121583": "but like a song that you love i don't i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00598-00121583-00121847": "this is a question for you all does the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00599-00121848-00122071": "way that an audience perceives a song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00600-00122072-00122239": "like retroactively affects your", "i2dMRUeJqik-00601-00122240-00122414": "perception of that song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00602-00122415-00122575": "and how do you battle against that i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00603-00122576-00122719": "mean it's the hardest thing in the world", "i2dMRUeJqik-00604-00122720-00122831": "and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00605-00122832-00123086": "you know i have songs because it's it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00606-00123088-00123310": "there's a temptation when you know you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00607-00123311-00123495": "have a bunch of songs that work and you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00608-00123496-00123695": "know exactly how they work", "i2dMRUeJqik-00609-00123696-00123910": "it's it's very easy to just rely on", "i2dMRUeJqik-00610-00123911-00124078": "those as the tools that you bring out", "i2dMRUeJqik-00611-00124079-00124263": "over and over again and then there are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00612-00124264-00124431": "all these other songs that might have", "i2dMRUeJqik-00613-00124432-00124607": "their moments and have their places but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00614-00124608-00124734": "if they don't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00615-00124735-00124878": "you know if they haven't been thought of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00616-00124879-00125078": "in a while they kind of shrink", "i2dMRUeJqik-00617-00125079-00125231": "and they get smaller and farther and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00618-00125232-00125534": "farther away so it's it's uh", "i2dMRUeJqik-00619-00125535-00125734": "i think it's i don't know it's it's a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00620-00125735-00125910": "struggle when i write when i write i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00621-00125911-00126063": "certainly am not thinking of the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00622-00126064-00126263": "audience as an end goal in mind but but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00623-00126264-00126454": "then what what happens is that there are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00624-00126455-00126566": "some songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-00625-00126567-00126799": "that succeed easily in a live context", "i2dMRUeJqik-00626-00126800-00126919": "and those are the ones i play all the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00627-00126920-00127095": "time and there are other songs that are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00628-00127096-00127343": "harder to play that are a slower burn", "i2dMRUeJqik-00629-00127344-00127558": "for people who don't already know them", "i2dMRUeJqik-00630-00127559-00127799": "that are you know two i mean i have so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00631-00127800-00127990": "many sad songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-00632-00127991-00128223": "and i would love to do like a 90-minute", "i2dMRUeJqik-00633-00128224-00128886": "concert of sad songs but that's like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00634-00128888-00129575": "2023", "i2dMRUeJqik-00635-00129576-00129719": "you know but that's not that's not", "i2dMRUeJqik-00636-00129720-00129839": "always the experience that every", "i2dMRUeJqik-00637-00129840-00130031": "audience member wants to have so it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00638-00130032-00130166": "it's it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00639-00130167-00130327": "you know and i think that i think that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00640-00130328-00130502": "the songwriting for me is a very selfish", "i2dMRUeJqik-00641-00130503-00130743": "process and the performing thing is a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00642-00130744-00130847": "very", "i2dMRUeJqik-00643-00130848-00130999": "much more sort of collaborative thinking", "i2dMRUeJqik-00644-00131000-00131327": "about the audience our uh with concrete", "i2dMRUeJqik-00645-00131328-00131519": "example of that from the concert uh we", "i2dMRUeJqik-00646-00131520-00131695": "just did a couple nights ago our song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00647-00131696-00132031": "you left me uh is sort of thank you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00648-00132032-00132166": "that's a great i love that song i like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00649-00132167-00132383": "that yeah it was fun to write it was an", "i2dMRUeJqik-00650-00132384-00132678": "interesting challenge but it also works", "i2dMRUeJqik-00651-00132679-00132847": "kind of against our audience's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00652-00132848-00133054": "expectations because we're a comedy act", "i2dMRUeJqik-00653-00133055-00133254": "and you're expecting a certain pace even", "i2dMRUeJqik-00654-00133255-00133478": "there and when we first wrote that song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00655-00133479-00133631": "it was the fun challenge of like can we", "i2dMRUeJqik-00656-00133632-00133743": "do this thing where all of a sudden", "i2dMRUeJqik-00657-00133744-00133895": "halfway through the song the metaphor", "i2dMRUeJqik-00658-00133896-00134047": "becomes clear and the whole meaning", "i2dMRUeJqik-00659-00134048-00134287": "changes but there's not a lot of jokes", "i2dMRUeJqik-00660-00134288-00134487": "in that first minute and a half or so", "i2dMRUeJqik-00661-00134488-00134654": "and we would perform it a few times and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00662-00134655-00134839": "it would go over okay but people were", "i2dMRUeJqik-00663-00134840-00134975": "just it felt like people were waiting", "i2dMRUeJqik-00664-00134976-00135302": "around for the funny part and we it was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00665-00135303-00135566": "a kind of a clue the introduction that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00666-00135567-00135759": "we gave like the smart audiences get", "i2dMRUeJqik-00667-00135760-00135887": "this song", "i2dMRUeJqik-00668-00135888-00136119": "was you know it's it's a bit of a cheat", "i2dMRUeJqik-00669-00136120-00136278": "but it also sets up the audience to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00670-00136279-00136487": "realize okay well maybe this song isn't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00671-00136488-00136623": "just full of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00672-00136624-00137078": "you know fart joke far check part joke", "i2dMRUeJqik-00673-00137079-00137247": "and that's that's one way you know the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00674-00137248-00137414": "song itself maybe hasn't changed but our", "i2dMRUeJqik-00675-00137415-00137583": "method of presenting it changes a little", "i2dMRUeJqik-00676-00137584-00137759": "bit to help it work for the people who", "i2dMRUeJqik-00677-00137760-00137951": "are here yes i kind of get a perverse", "i2dMRUeJqik-00678-00137952-00138071": "thrill out of that kind of thing though", "i2dMRUeJqik-00679-00138072-00138287": "like that my song millionaire girlfriend", "i2dMRUeJqik-00680-00138288-00138566": "which when i do for audiences who don't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00681-00138567-00138683": "know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00682-00138684-00138847": "me", "i2dMRUeJqik-00683-00138848-00139023": "you know the first like it doesn't tip", "i2dMRUeJqik-00684-00139024-00139239": "its hand until the until the chorus and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00685-00139240-00139478": "so the whole verse is this really", "i2dMRUeJqik-00686-00139479-00139831": "syrupy trickly sincere thing about being", "i2dMRUeJqik-00687-00139832-00140007": "in love with someone and it's like this", "i2dMRUeJqik-00688-00140008-00140102": "folky", "i2dMRUeJqik-00689-00140103-00140271": "finger picky thing and i often see", "i2dMRUeJqik-00690-00140272-00140463": "audiences like all right and sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00691-00140464-00140671": "like reaching for their phones", "i2dMRUeJqik-00692-00140672-00140863": "but i love it because i know that at", "i2dMRUeJqik-00693-00140864-00141063": "some point it's gonna it's gonna like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00694-00141064-00141278": "tip over and they're like oh and that is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00695-00141279-00141495": "really it's really nice", "i2dMRUeJqik-00696-00141496-00141647": "and the challenge is like when you wait", "i2dMRUeJqik-00697-00141648-00141823": "that much longer into", "i2dMRUeJqik-00698-00141824-00141999": "a song like that it's got to be real", "i2dMRUeJqik-00699-00142000-00142271": "good to earn the payoff yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00700-00142272-00142431": "uh if anyone has questions we're going", "i2dMRUeJqik-00701-00142432-00142839": "to feel free to throw the questions", "i2dMRUeJqik-00702-00142840-00143111": "hi my name is rex anderson all right uh", "i2dMRUeJqik-00703-00143112-00143407": "so about 50 years ago a band that toured", "i2dMRUeJqik-00704-00143408-00143575": "quite a bit stopped and went into the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00705-00143576-00143678": "studio", "i2dMRUeJqik-00706-00143679-00143871": "and uh really the rest of your career", "i2dMRUeJqik-00707-00143872-00144039": "was in the studio for the most part", "i2dMRUeJqik-00708-00144040-00144151": "until", "i2dMRUeJqik-00709-00144152-00144447": "they all broke up in their various parts", "i2dMRUeJqik-00710-00144448-00144654": "my question is did you guys have an", "i2dMRUeJqik-00711-00144655-00144887": "opportunity to watch to get back film", "i2dMRUeJqik-00712-00144888-00145119": "and what was the most surprising things", "i2dMRUeJqik-00713-00145120-00145326": "that you saw as songwriters in that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00714-00145327-00145526": "process watching that film", "i2dMRUeJqik-00715-00145527-00145719": "the sheer amount of work", "i2dMRUeJqik-00716-00145720-00145975": "uh he's talking about the beatles yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00717-00145976-00146239": "a little band but you think of the bands", "i2dMRUeJqik-00718-00146240-00146511": "that that that are part of your fabric", "i2dMRUeJqik-00719-00146512-00146726": "as oh they must have just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00720-00146727-00146966": "they must be operating this other level", "i2dMRUeJqik-00721-00146967-00147078": "and they are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00722-00147079-00147247": "but that the amount of work that goes", "i2dMRUeJqik-00723-00147248-00147399": "into it where you see just this little", "i2dMRUeJqik-00724-00147400-00147663": "seed of an idea and when first watching", "i2dMRUeJqik-00725-00147664-00147839": "that you hear it and say oh they're", "i2dMRUeJqik-00726-00147840-00148102": "riffing on their song that is a big hit", "i2dMRUeJqik-00727-00148103-00148343": "it's oh no no no this is where it starts", "i2dMRUeJqik-00728-00148344-00148535": "and then you see it time and again", "i2dMRUeJqik-00729-00148536-00148678": "coming back and the ones that are", "i2dMRUeJqik-00730-00148679-00148871": "completed just how much work it is", "i2dMRUeJqik-00731-00148872-00149111": "sometimes to get it out", "i2dMRUeJqik-00732-00149112-00149278": "i would add to that i think there was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00733-00149279-00149454": "that clip that was going around on the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00734-00149455-00149607": "internet for a while and it was showing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00735-00149608-00149839": "like the the groove from get back yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00736-00149840-00150014": "like being made", "i2dMRUeJqik-00737-00150015-00150263": "yeah and i loved seeing that on camera", "i2dMRUeJqik-00738-00150264-00150366": "because", "i2dMRUeJqik-00739-00150367-00150502": "you know every time i've ever played", "i2dMRUeJqik-00740-00150503-00150623": "with a band like you're you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00741-00150624-00150799": "somebody's got an idea and it takes some", "i2dMRUeJqik-00742-00150800-00150975": "time and you you riff on it and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00743-00150976-00151087": "hopefully", "i2dMRUeJqik-00744-00151088-00151223": "you're lucky enough that something like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00745-00151224-00151439": "that would come out but it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00746-00151440-00151711": "that thing of them being so comfortable", "i2dMRUeJqik-00747-00151712-00151878": "with each other that they can be", "i2dMRUeJqik-00748-00151879-00151999": "vulnerable", "i2dMRUeJqik-00749-00152000-00152214": "enough to have like the two hours that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00750-00152215-00152447": "didn't work that isn't on camera", "i2dMRUeJqik-00751-00152448-00152599": "you know i think that sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00752-00152600-00152790": "vulnerability and comfortableness like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00753-00152791-00152951": "that was really great to see yeah and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00754-00152952-00153190": "it's exciting to watch that show because", "i2dMRUeJqik-00755-00153191-00153383": "you already know the ending of like he's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00756-00153384-00153526": "sitting there noodling around at the end", "i2dMRUeJqik-00757-00153527-00153702": "of two and a half minutes he's got all", "i2dMRUeJqik-00758-00153703-00153863": "the bones of get back", "i2dMRUeJqik-00759-00153864-00153999": "but you don't know that during the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00760-00154000-00154143": "process you're just sitting around for", "i2dMRUeJqik-00761-00154144-00154326": "two hours just messing with stuff and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00762-00154327-00154551": "hoping it's good yeah i love that but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00763-00154552-00154719": "that was like you know it's not always", "i2dMRUeJqik-00764-00154720-00154919": "just like amazing inspiration and genius", "i2dMRUeJqik-00765-00154920-00155039": "sometimes it's just like being", "i2dMRUeJqik-00766-00155040-00155190": "comfortable with your mates and you can", "i2dMRUeJqik-00767-00155191-00155351": "like rip on something and keep building", "i2dMRUeJqik-00768-00155352-00155502": "on it yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-00769-00155503-00155559": "the that was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00770-00155560-00155711": "i want to put on that like being in a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00771-00155712-00155919": "three-piece band the amount of like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00772-00155920-00156278": "bickering and brotherly like levels of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00773-00156279-00156463": "like annoyance and whatever and the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00774-00156464-00156678": "jostling that they're doing was both", "i2dMRUeJqik-00775-00156679-00156902": "like disconcerting and comforting at the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00776-00156903-00157159": "same time like okay everyone does this", "i2dMRUeJqik-00777-00157160-00157366": "there's you get into this like circular", "i2dMRUeJqik-00778-00157367-00157535": "language and you've spent you know your", "i2dMRUeJqik-00779-00157536-00157726": "entire adult life with the same people", "i2dMRUeJqik-00780-00157727-00157911": "working a common goal and you don't know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00781-00157912-00158199": "how you got there really um but is both", "i2dMRUeJqik-00782-00158200-00158414": "that and the work that they were doing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00783-00158415-00158575": "and how good it was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00784-00158576-00158766": "and i was i mean for me it was how", "i2dMRUeJqik-00785-00158767-00158926": "quickly that happened yeah like those", "i2dMRUeJqik-00786-00158927-00159078": "melodies are just on the tip of holes", "i2dMRUeJqik-00787-00159079-00159199": "tongue", "i2dMRUeJqik-00788-00159200-00159375": "seemingly all the time which is like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00789-00159376-00159559": "everything he does is like i don't know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00790-00159560-00159878": "magic to me yeah i i found uh i really", "i2dMRUeJqik-00791-00159879-00160014": "enjoyed it but i also had a lot of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00792-00160015-00160375": "anxiety because they wasted so much time", "i2dMRUeJqik-00793-00160376-00160519": "they had a deadline that was coming up", "i2dMRUeJqik-00794-00160520-00160639": "really soon they were just messing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00795-00160640-00160959": "around with the money money flowing out", "i2dMRUeJqik-00796-00160960-00161343": "oh my god you'd be so nervous", "i2dMRUeJqik-00797-00161344-00161559": "will they make it in time i know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00798-00161560-00162054": "i haven't seen it yet so no spoilers", "i2dMRUeJqik-00799-00162055-00162223": "we'll tell her how the rooftop concert", "i2dMRUeJqik-00800-00162224-00162447": "turns out", "i2dMRUeJqik-00801-00162448-00162839": "another question", "i2dMRUeJqik-00802-00162840-00162990": "oh hi", "i2dMRUeJqik-00803-00162991-00163254": "i'll just be short for now um i know the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00804-00163255-00163478": "last couple years for myself and some of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00805-00163479-00163639": "my other songwriter friends has been", "i2dMRUeJqik-00806-00163640-00163775": "creatively", "i2dMRUeJqik-00807-00163776-00163887": "rough", "i2dMRUeJqik-00808-00163888-00164135": "that's a slight understatement um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00809-00164136-00164278": "regardless of whether this time felt", "i2dMRUeJqik-00810-00164279-00164454": "really productive for you or not i would", "i2dMRUeJqik-00811-00164455-00164695": "love for everybody to talk about like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00812-00164696-00164951": "how you address times of creative", "i2dMRUeJqik-00813-00164952-00165207": "lull and how you take care of yourself", "i2dMRUeJqik-00814-00165208-00165366": "and also like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00815-00165367-00165502": "rekindle that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00816-00165503-00165678": "a lot of crying", "i2dMRUeJqik-00817-00165679-00165838": "me too", "i2dMRUeJqik-00818-00165839-00166031": "boy", "i2dMRUeJqik-00819-00166032-00166263": "uh i mean yeah i had a terrible time", "i2dMRUeJqik-00820-00166264-00166399": "these last two years i haven't been able", "i2dMRUeJqik-00821-00166400-00166502": "to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00822-00166503-00166807": "really get a lot of creative work done", "i2dMRUeJqik-00823-00166808-00167014": "because i'm just not i just not have not", "i2dMRUeJqik-00824-00167015-00167247": "been in a like a safe emotional space", "i2dMRUeJqik-00825-00167248-00167487": "for something i don't know i can't even", "i2dMRUeJqik-00826-00167488-00167799": "describe it um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00827-00167800-00168063": "but you know i've had i've had periods", "i2dMRUeJqik-00828-00168064-00168247": "in the past where it was hard to write", "i2dMRUeJqik-00829-00168248-00168447": "for whatever reason and i always like to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00830-00168448-00168726": "give that space and sort of honor that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00831-00168727-00168823": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00832-00168824-00169063": "uh it's it's there's a bit of a duality", "i2dMRUeJqik-00833-00169064-00169183": "because on the one hand i do want to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00834-00169184-00169302": "honor that and say like all right", "i2dMRUeJqik-00835-00169303-00169495": "sometimes the field needs to lie fallow", "i2dMRUeJqik-00836-00169496-00169663": "for a little while and you need to be", "i2dMRUeJqik-00837-00169664-00169823": "okay with that and you can do other", "i2dMRUeJqik-00838-00169824-00169911": "things", "i2dMRUeJqik-00839-00169912-00170087": "and wait for something to come along but", "i2dMRUeJqik-00840-00170088-00170295": "then there comes a certain point where i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00841-00170296-00170390": "think", "i2dMRUeJqik-00842-00170391-00170599": "it is really constructive i mean it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00843-00170600-00170838": "boring but because it's totally true", "i2dMRUeJqik-00844-00170839-00171031": "it's really constructive to just show up", "i2dMRUeJqik-00845-00171032-00171175": "every day", "i2dMRUeJqik-00846-00171176-00171263": "and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00847-00171264-00171407": "and write", "i2dMRUeJqik-00848-00171408-00171687": "something or just play something for 20", "i2dMRUeJqik-00849-00171688-00171911": "minutes you know and i find that when", "i2dMRUeJqik-00850-00171912-00172143": "i'm stuck in that place and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00851-00172144-00172351": "i've let it sit for a while and i'm like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00852-00172352-00172502": "i really want to get back to it the only", "i2dMRUeJqik-00853-00172503-00172823": "way to get back to it is to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00854-00172824-00172983": "is to do that thing where i'm like i'm", "i2dMRUeJqik-00855-00172984-00173135": "not going to write a song today but i am", "i2dMRUeJqik-00856-00173136-00173447": "going to sit and play for 20 minutes and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00857-00173448-00173654": "see what happens and more often than not", "i2dMRUeJqik-00858-00173655-00173887": "some idea percolates to the surface and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00859-00173888-00174119": "and it goes from there let me uh i was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00860-00174120-00174247": "going to throw the rest of the panel", "i2dMRUeJqik-00861-00174248-00174414": "actually do you all", "i2dMRUeJqik-00862-00174415-00174590": "have say", "i2dMRUeJqik-00863-00174591-00174871": "a schedule or a time or a place", "i2dMRUeJqik-00864-00174872-00175135": "uh or any you know process for writing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00865-00175136-00175351": "it was an everyday thing or this much", "i2dMRUeJqik-00866-00175352-00175551": "per week or you sort of as the muse", "i2dMRUeJqik-00867-00175552-00175775": "takes you you have any particular", "i2dMRUeJqik-00868-00175776-00176014": "personal system for yourself i have a i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00869-00176015-00176190": "have this elementary school schedule", "i2dMRUeJqik-00870-00176191-00176414": "that i work on", "i2dMRUeJqik-00871-00176415-00176543": "you know so like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00872-00176544-00176663": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00873-00176664-00176831": "that which was totally disrupted by the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00874-00176832-00177023": "pandemic so you know my son goes off to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00875-00177024-00177311": "school and i try to have certain days", "i2dMRUeJqik-00876-00177312-00177495": "that are admin days and then some days", "i2dMRUeJqik-00877-00177496-00177823": "where i am i am a composer and i'm going", "i2dMRUeJqik-00878-00177824-00177990": "into the studio even if it is only to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00879-00177991-00178238": "organize my cables you know it's like i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00880-00178239-00178423": "have to be in there and i don't have any", "i2dMRUeJqik-00881-00178424-00178663": "internet in there so um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00882-00178664-00178831": "but i do find that that helps and you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00883-00178832-00179078": "know my pandemic was divided between", "i2dMRUeJqik-00884-00179079-00179343": "the horror of like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00885-00179344-00179590": "how do i be a composer while also being", "i2dMRUeJqik-00886-00179591-00179702": "a full", "i2dMRUeJqik-00887-00179703-00179919": "stay-at-home pandemic parent and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-00888-00179920-00180102": "the other half of when i was a film", "i2dMRUeJqik-00889-00180103-00180231": "composer", "i2dMRUeJqik-00890-00180232-00180359": "all right", "i2dMRUeJqik-00891-00180360-00180631": "so i had like a big period of like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00892-00180632-00180863": "identity crisis and trying to figure out", "i2dMRUeJqik-00893-00180864-00181031": "how to that the only way through is to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00894-00181032-00181214": "separate your identity from like i am a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00895-00181215-00181326": "composer", "i2dMRUeJqik-00896-00181327-00181495": "because if you do that that's a sure way", "i2dMRUeJqik-00897-00181496-00181647": "to beat yourself up because if you're if", "i2dMRUeJqik-00898-00181648-00181799": "you're not composing and then the second", "i2dMRUeJqik-00899-00181800-00182102": "half of doing a lot of composing i mean", "i2dMRUeJqik-00900-00182103-00182302": "and tessa do you have any like a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00901-00182303-00182526": "schedule at all or process i mean you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00902-00182527-00182711": "know the the past year and a half and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-00903-00182712-00182895": "was standing like i spent a lot of time", "i2dMRUeJqik-00904-00182896-00183135": "on the road which um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00905-00183136-00183326": "and in a van to be clear like there's a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00906-00183327-00183543": "real big difference between when you're", "i2dMRUeJqik-00907-00183544-00183775": "making enough money to tour in a van", "i2dMRUeJqik-00908-00183776-00183999": "making enough money to tour in a bus", "i2dMRUeJqik-00909-00184000-00184166": "it's counter-intuitive how much of a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00910-00184167-00184414": "difference of your life makes because", "i2dMRUeJqik-00911-00184415-00184678": "you become diurnal again", "i2dMRUeJqik-00912-00184679-00184878": "because if you make enough money to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00913-00184879-00185207": "travel in a bus you travel at night", "i2dMRUeJqik-00914-00185208-00185454": "which means that you wake up in a city", "i2dMRUeJqik-00915-00185455-00185583": "and you get to spend your life in that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00916-00185584-00185838": "city if you travel in a van it means you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00917-00185839-00186087": "drive during the day right so you really", "i2dMRUeJqik-00918-00186088-00186199": "are like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00919-00186200-00186407": "you're a commuter with a really intense", "i2dMRUeJqik-00920-00186408-00186599": "schedule you know where it's like you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00921-00186600-00186750": "drive eight hours a day to your one and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00922-00186751-00186935": "a half hour a day job", "i2dMRUeJqik-00923-00186936-00187071": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00924-00187072-00187366": "so that kind of schedule for me anyway", "i2dMRUeJqik-00925-00187367-00187511": "i'm not disciplined enough to have like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00926-00187512-00187663": "a really great writing schedule and also", "i2dMRUeJqik-00927-00187664-00187766": "i feel like a lot of people who write", "i2dMRUeJqik-00928-00187767-00187950": "when they're on the road like that third", "i2dMRUeJqik-00929-00187951-00188143": "album was all about like we're in the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00930-00188144-00188335": "van in bangkok", "i2dMRUeJqik-00931-00188336-00188583": "like mine's not about like you know like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00932-00188584-00188750": "a couple of those go our way you don't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00933-00188751-00188836": "need a record", "i2dMRUeJqik-00934-00188837-00188999": "[Music]", "i2dMRUeJqik-00935-00189000-00189319": "but but i will say that", "i2dMRUeJqik-00936-00189320-00189559": "not being you know appall with a melody", "i2dMRUeJqik-00937-00189560-00189735": "like constantly", "i2dMRUeJqik-00938-00189736-00189943": "you know available to be plucked from", "i2dMRUeJqik-00939-00189944-00190159": "the ether that um when a good turn of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00940-00190160-00190263": "phrase", "i2dMRUeJqik-00941-00190264-00190614": "does come or or i ease drop it you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-00942-00190615-00190726": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00943-00190727-00190966": "i try to be disciplined enough even if", "i2dMRUeJqik-00944-00190967-00191214": "it's like low-key socially rude to say", "i2dMRUeJqik-00945-00191215-00191383": "excuse me for a moment and it looks like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00946-00191384-00191590": "i'm texting somebody you know but i do", "i2dMRUeJqik-00947-00191591-00191775": "i'm texting me i'm texting myself", "i2dMRUeJqik-00948-00191776-00191990": "whatever that rad turn or phrase was", "i2dMRUeJqik-00949-00191991-00192150": "because i know it's gone you know it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-00950-00192151-00192302": "lost if i don't", "i2dMRUeJqik-00951-00192303-00192502": "get it down so i'm trying to be better", "i2dMRUeJqik-00952-00192503-00192743": "at that like yo when it happens", "i2dMRUeJqik-00953-00192744-00192966": "lean into that moment because it happens", "i2dMRUeJqik-00954-00192967-00193271": "less frequently than probably all of us", "i2dMRUeJqik-00955-00193272-00193511": "then uh both so both individually and as", "i2dMRUeJqik-00956-00193512-00193654": "a band i'm going to ask both for your", "i2dMRUeJqik-00957-00193655-00193863": "personal performance process and also", "i2dMRUeJqik-00958-00193864-00193983": "like you have sort of a rehearsal", "i2dMRUeJqik-00959-00193984-00194078": "schedule we're like we're getting", "i2dMRUeJqik-00960-00194079-00194278": "together once a week or x or y or which", "i2dMRUeJqik-00961-00194279-00194431": "we get accumulate enough songs and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-00962-00194432-00194535": "we'll get something i'll answer that one", "i2dMRUeJqik-00963-00194536-00194759": "first we've been a band for 15 years and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00964-00194760-00194902": "have been touring for most of those 15", "i2dMRUeJqik-00965-00194903-00195119": "years and we've barely rehearsed", "i2dMRUeJqik-00966-00195120-00195271": "like if there's a tour or the thing", "i2dMRUeJqik-00967-00195272-00195383": "that's the rehearsal the show is the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00968-00195384-00195559": "rehearsal like we'll show a little like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00969-00195560-00195743": "like before we you know we've been apart", "i2dMRUeJqik-00970-00195744-00195919": "for like three months we've all sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-00971-00195920-00196159": "moved around and we got to rehearsal and", "i2dMRUeJqik-00972-00196160-00196359": "we're like playing the set and like we", "i2dMRUeJqik-00973-00196360-00196575": "we know these songs it's hard not to", "i2dMRUeJqik-00974-00196576-00196711": "know these songs but the problem is you", "i2dMRUeJqik-00975-00196712-00196847": "get complacent and then forget lyrics", "i2dMRUeJqik-00976-00196848-00197078": "and a fault apart but um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00977-00197079-00197247": "we don't do the rehearsal thing we get", "i2dMRUeJqik-00978-00197248-00197511": "in we we sort of hyper focus to make an", "i2dMRUeJqik-00979-00197512-00197711": "album or hyper focus to get ready for a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00980-00197712-00197926": "tour but we're not the band that gets", "i2dMRUeJqik-00981-00197927-00198071": "together once a week in jams it's just", "i2dMRUeJqik-00982-00198072-00198399": "never been our our mo um but also on", "i2dMRUeJqik-00983-00198400-00198566": "that like you know i can't write on the", "i2dMRUeJqik-00984-00198567-00198743": "road either i can't i've never written a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00985-00198744-00198887": "song on the road i've barely written a", "i2dMRUeJqik-00986-00198888-00199183": "lyric it's uh you get into this um", "i2dMRUeJqik-00987-00199184-00199366": "you know self-protection mode of how can", "i2dMRUeJqik-00988-00199367-00199478": "i like", "i2dMRUeJqik-00989-00199479-00199647": "just be a person", "i2dMRUeJqik-00990-00199648-00199863": "totally you have to build a shell around", "i2dMRUeJqik-00991-00199864-00200126": "yes yeah put on your armor um but when", "i2dMRUeJqik-00992-00200127-00200335": "i'm so when i'm home i almost have this", "i2dMRUeJqik-00993-00200336-00200502": "like feverish like i have to work i have", "i2dMRUeJqik-00994-00200503-00200726": "to work which also doesn't really work", "i2dMRUeJqik-00995-00200727-00200854": "all that well because there's all this", "i2dMRUeJqik-00996-00200855-00201063": "extra pressure of i'm home for a week", "i2dMRUeJqik-00997-00201064-00201311": "how do i write a song um but a lot of it", "i2dMRUeJqik-00998-00201312-00201575": "is just sort of showing up and i think", "i2dMRUeJqik-00999-00201576-00201719": "maybe you all relate to this i think the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01000-00201720-00201983": "longer i've been in it the less often", "i2dMRUeJqik-01001-00201984-00202135": "that one just did a piano and this", "i2dMRUeJqik-01002-00202136-00202302": "magical song happens and 20 minutes", "i2dMRUeJqik-01003-00202303-00202575": "later it's done experience which", "i2dMRUeJqik-01004-00202576-00202695": "when i think when you're young and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01005-00202696-00202838": "starting to write like it happens all", "i2dMRUeJqik-01006-00202839-00203038": "the time it's like it's this drug it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-01007-00203039-00203295": "it's easy and it's there and it still", "i2dMRUeJqik-01008-00203296-00203535": "happens but it's rarer and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01009-00203536-00203726": "um you get into this like you know this", "i2dMRUeJqik-01010-00203727-00203926": "is my job this is how i do it this is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01011-00203927-00204166": "how i work what i need to do and and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01012-00204167-00204359": "have a lot of like projects that a song", "i2dMRUeJqik-01013-00204360-00204495": "has to be written or thing has to be", "i2dMRUeJqik-01014-00204496-00204695": "composed and that's nice because that i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01015-00204696-00204879": "can sit down like oh in three days if i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01016-00204880-00205086": "don't turn this in i'm in trouble and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01017-00205087-00205271": "that's a good feeling whereas like with", "i2dMRUeJqik-01018-00205271-00205471": "songwriting you just sort of i don't i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01019-00205471-00205631": "wait you know it is the appliance to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01020-00205632-00205798": "chair but you wait and what's crazy is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01021-00205800-00205934": "that when you i was gonna say the same", "i2dMRUeJqik-01022-00205935-00206079": "thing when you have an assignment and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01023-00206080-00206262": "somebody's like you have to do do a song", "i2dMRUeJqik-01024-00206263-00206366": "like this", "i2dMRUeJqik-01025-00206367-00206575": "i have this i have the same", "i2dMRUeJqik-01026-00206576-00206694": "feeling that i have when i start to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01027-00206696-00206814": "write which is like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01028-00206815-00206958": "it's going to be", "i2dMRUeJqik-01029-00206959-00207142": "whatever it is and then i just do it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01030-00207144-00207310": "because it has to get done yeah and it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-01031-00207311-00207455": "usually pretty good and then like why", "i2dMRUeJqik-01032-00207456-00207606": "don't i just do that for myself for my", "i2dMRUeJqik-01033-00207607-00207871": "own songs well i find that's the hardest", "i2dMRUeJqik-01034-00207871-00208046": "thing is what should i be writing and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01035-00208048-00208223": "when someone gives you the assignments", "i2dMRUeJqik-01036-00208223-00208351": "yeah yes at least you know what you're", "i2dMRUeJqik-01037-00208352-00208575": "aiming for and not okay here i am", "i2dMRUeJqik-01038-00208576-00208846": "jonathan you were talking about um", "i2dMRUeJqik-01039-00208848-00209071": "that process of just breaking through", "i2dMRUeJqik-01040-00209071-00209151": "and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01041-00209152-00209334": "it's like exercise like you know you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01042-00209335-00209462": "have to do it you've been off of it for", "i2dMRUeJqik-01043-00209463-00209686": "a while and on the but um by that third", "i2dMRUeJqik-01044-00209687-00209879": "day like you get the energy return and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01045-00209880-00210063": "it all comes back i keep trying to give", "i2dMRUeJqik-01046-00210064-00210239": "myself artificial deadlines because like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01047-00210240-00210375": "you know i write home scores and so", "i2dMRUeJqik-01048-00210376-00210591": "those are incredibly effective deadlines", "i2dMRUeJqik-01049-00210592-00210815": "that are you know make some good music", "i2dMRUeJqik-01050-00210816-00211015": "but i just can't figure out a way to be", "i2dMRUeJqik-01051-00211016-00211215": "so severe with myself yeah that's the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01052-00211216-00211415": "deadline i'm a terrible boss with myself", "i2dMRUeJqik-01053-00211416-00211598": "i can't give myself those i will write a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01054-00211600-00211791": "song by friday and instead i'm going to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01055-00211792-00212127": "go eat ice cream", "i2dMRUeJqik-01056-00212128-00212246": "do we have any other", "i2dMRUeJqik-01057-00212248-00212582": "questions", "i2dMRUeJqik-01058-00212583-00212767": "um i was wondering if you guys have any", "i2dMRUeJqik-01059-00212767-00212863": "like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01060-00212864-00213055": "methods to kick-start your creative", "i2dMRUeJqik-01061-00213056-00213246": "processes or like if there's a way if", "i2dMRUeJqik-01062-00213248-00213431": "you like you have um", "i2dMRUeJqik-01063-00213432-00213694": "a way to keep it going like instead of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01064-00213696-00213879": "like if you see a wall coming is there a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01065-00213880-00214175": "way to like get over that wall", "i2dMRUeJqik-01066-00214176-00214542": "this sounds like a joke answer but i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01067-00214544-00214798": "eat a lot of sugar like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01068-00214800-00215015": "smarties the american smarties little", "i2dMRUeJqik-01069-00215016-00215151": "like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01070-00215152-00215294": "like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01071-00215296-00215439": "sugar yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-01072-00215440-00215567": "which are fine", "i2dMRUeJqik-01073-00215567-00215727": "but no it's not a chocolate thing i need", "i2dMRUeJqik-01074-00215728-00215934": "i just like eat sweet tarts or smarties", "i2dMRUeJqik-01075-00215935-00216158": "or a handful of peanut m m's like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01076-00216159-00216310": "sometimes that's sort of the thing i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01077-00216311-00216527": "need to power me through", "i2dMRUeJqik-01078-00216528-00216751": "alone it's not two cups of coffee yeah i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01079-00216752-00216815": "mean", "i2dMRUeJqik-01080-00216816-00217023": "it's actually it's so crazy it's silly", "i2dMRUeJqik-01081-00217023-00217223": "but it actually does i don't know change", "i2dMRUeJqik-01082-00217223-00217446": "your brain i'll i'll play something that", "i2dMRUeJqik-01083-00217448-00217663": "i know and know and really like and that", "i2dMRUeJqik-01084-00217664-00217855": "can re-energize the part of the brain", "i2dMRUeJqik-01085-00217856-00218031": "that goes oh that's cool", "i2dMRUeJqik-01086-00218032-00218223": "sometimes for writing like when i feel", "i2dMRUeJqik-01087-00218223-00218385": "like if i'm feeling like the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01088-00218386-00218534": "[Music]", "i2dMRUeJqik-01089-00218535-00218767": "the editorial voice is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01090-00218767-00218951": "in my head too early in the process i'm", "i2dMRUeJqik-01091-00218952-00219110": "already like halfway done with something", "i2dMRUeJqik-01092-00219111-00219231": "and kind of thinking how is this going", "i2dMRUeJqik-01093-00219232-00219391": "to play or what are people going to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01094-00219392-00219527": "think which i think is too soon to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01095-00219528-00219719": "welcome that voice in sometimes i'll", "i2dMRUeJqik-01096-00219719-00219903": "just play a rap song", "i2dMRUeJqik-01097-00219904-00220103": "that i really like and i would just wrap", "i2dMRUeJqik-01098-00220104-00220279": "over it with my own lyrics and for some", "i2dMRUeJqik-01099-00220280-00220398": "reason just the pressures off this", "i2dMRUeJqik-01100-00220400-00220551": "doesn't count right do you know what i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01101-00220552-00220727": "mean like this is just for prac this is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01102-00220728-00220846": "just fun", "i2dMRUeJqik-01103-00220848-00221031": "and so in some way like doing something", "i2dMRUeJqik-01104-00221032-00221215": "that i know won't be committed to tape", "i2dMRUeJqik-01105-00221216-00221471": "in the same way i know i get my i get my", "i2dMRUeJqik-01106-00221471-00221679": "sweet 17 and a half bar that i can take", "i2dMRUeJqik-01107-00221680-00221846": "back to myself", "i2dMRUeJqik-01108-00221848-00222071": "john klansberg has a technique that i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01109-00222071-00222310": "love which is from the mic giants uh", "i2dMRUeJqik-01110-00222311-00222567": "which is that he turns on the recorder", "i2dMRUeJqik-01111-00222567-00222758": "when he sits with a guitar and the rule", "i2dMRUeJqik-01112-00222759-00222839": "is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01113-00222840-00223127": "write a song for 15 minutes and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-01114-00223128-00223406": "stop and then write a new song for 15", "i2dMRUeJqik-01115-00223407-00223623": "minutes and then stop with that song and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01116-00223623-00223823": "then write it and do that for two hours", "i2dMRUeJqik-01117-00223823-00224079": "and at the end of it you will have eight", "i2dMRUeJqik-01118-00224080-00224271": "ideas that are maybe good or maybe bad", "i2dMRUeJqik-01119-00224271-00224455": "but you've also gone through the process", "i2dMRUeJqik-01120-00224456-00224655": "of starting a thing and then not", "i2dMRUeJqik-01121-00224656-00224846": "worrying about finishing it eight times", "i2dMRUeJqik-01122-00224848-00225046": "and it's a really nice like it sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01123-00225048-00225198": "loosens up all these muscles it's really", "i2dMRUeJqik-01124-00225200-00225455": "crazy i have a very specific one which", "i2dMRUeJqik-01125-00225456-00225734": "is that's often for me i'll have too", "i2dMRUeJqik-01126-00225735-00225934": "many ideas in one song and i need to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01127-00225935-00226103": "remove a bunch of them in order to make", "i2dMRUeJqik-01128-00226104-00226382": "the songs accessible and what i do is i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01129-00226383-00226623": "play the song on the crappiest speaker", "i2dMRUeJqik-01130-00226623-00226855": "that i have so i go downstairs and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01131-00226856-00227055": "have this like little kind of like bad", "i2dMRUeJqik-01132-00227056-00227327": "old you know sound system and i you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-01133-00227328-00227551": "that i plug the song through that and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01134-00227552-00227791": "then i hear the song for what it is you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01135-00227792-00228023": "know because it compresses it so badly", "i2dMRUeJqik-01136-00228023-00228223": "that you hear the gist", "i2dMRUeJqik-01137-00228223-00228398": "and that sometimes tells me what i need", "i2dMRUeJqik-01138-00228400-00228615": "to take away to make it reveal something", "i2dMRUeJqik-01139-00228616-00228879": "else do you do any of you oh yeah i was", "i2dMRUeJqik-01140-00228880-00229079": "just going to say write something stupid", "i2dMRUeJqik-01141-00229080-00229246": "like read something that's objectively", "i2dMRUeJqik-01142-00229248-00229327": "bad", "i2dMRUeJqik-01143-00229328-00229479": "and don't worry about it and it sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01144-00229480-00229639": "unlocks the part of your brain that's", "i2dMRUeJqik-01145-00229640-00229863": "censoring and editorializing it's just", "i2dMRUeJqik-01146-00229864-00230103": "like it doesn't matter like take the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01147-00230104-00230319": "pressure away and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-01148-00230319-00230463": "maybe you get to something great maybe", "i2dMRUeJqik-01149-00230464-00230655": "not but either way similarly at least", "i2dMRUeJqik-01150-00230656-00230903": "you're writing something do any of you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01151-00230904-00231206": "have for lyrics or music you keep either", "i2dMRUeJqik-01152-00231207-00231494": "like a journal of rhymes or an idea or a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01153-00231496-00231679": "concept or a musical hook that you sort", "i2dMRUeJqik-01154-00231680-00231863": "of keep in the back", "i2dMRUeJqik-01155-00231864-00232015": "backpack somewhere and sort of pull", "i2dMRUeJqik-01156-00232016-00232191": "through that your iphone is full of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01157-00232192-00232391": "voice memos because i've always come up", "i2dMRUeJqik-01158-00232392-00232534": "with things while i'm walking and i'm", "i2dMRUeJqik-01159-00232535-00232734": "singing and i'm like oh this is amazing", "i2dMRUeJqik-01160-00232735-00232871": "it's incredible and then i never listen", "i2dMRUeJqik-01161-00232871-00233127": "to them", "i2dMRUeJqik-01162-00233128-00233319": "i can't find the one it's like oh dude", "i2dMRUeJqik-01163-00233319-00234582": "the trumpet's gone", "i2dMRUeJqik-01164-00234583-00234703": "i find that's how you know they're the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01165-00234704-00234879": "good ones because i record them but the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01166-00234880-00235046": "one that gets caught in your head like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01167-00235048-00235279": "yeah that's the matter but for like so i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01168-00235280-00235510": "keep on my on my phone i guess you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-01169-00235511-00235758": "since phone era like i keep like four", "i2dMRUeJqik-01170-00235759-00236006": "notes documents that i'll end in r and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01171-00236007-00236134": "rough materials like song rough", "i2dMRUeJqik-01172-00236135-00236287": "materials screen play work material", "i2dMRUeJqik-01173-00236288-00236439": "culture book material programs rough", "i2dMRUeJqik-01174-00236440-00236631": "material and just like do you know when", "i2dMRUeJqik-01175-00236632-00236831": "an idea comes quick class it and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-01176-00236832-00236934": "put it there", "i2dMRUeJqik-01177-00236935-00237079": "but yeah it looks like when you said", "i2dMRUeJqik-01178-00237080-00237327": "that the the heartbreak was to have like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01179-00237328-00237527": "this great line that didn't go anywhere", "i2dMRUeJqik-01180-00237528-00237655": "i mean like do you have like an", "i2dMRUeJqik-01181-00237656-00237934": "invisible map sack of like punch lines", "i2dMRUeJqik-01182-00237935-00238110": "that that you finally get to place and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01183-00238111-00238319": "it's like yes", "i2dMRUeJqik-01184-00238319-00238615": "after five years of carrying around", "i2dMRUeJqik-01185-00238616-00238742": "you're not eating really politely but i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01186-00238744-00238919": "don't know if that's your answer also i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01187-00238919-00239151": "didn't hear the question wow", "i2dMRUeJqik-01188-00239152-00239287": "i heard the comment but it was not a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01189-00239288-00239455": "microphone when you have", "i2dMRUeJqik-01190-00239456-00240586": "the songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-01191-00240587-00240823": "[Music]", "i2dMRUeJqik-01192-00240823-00241255": "on the stick", "i2dMRUeJqik-01193-00241256-00241398": "you're looking for the garlic press but", "i2dMRUeJqik-01194-00241400-00241575": "you get the skewer instead you say screw", "i2dMRUeJqik-01195-00241576-00242494": "it i'm making kebabs", "i2dMRUeJqik-01196-00242496-00242710": "uh so some of you were talking about how", "i2dMRUeJqik-01197-00242711-00242894": "it's difficult to keep to solve with", "i2dMRUeJqik-01198-00242896-00243030": "those deadlines", "i2dMRUeJqik-01199-00243031-00243182": "uh i don't know if you know there's this", "i2dMRUeJqik-01200-00243183-00243398": "guy in front of people who did a thing a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01201-00243400-00243889": "week project", "i2dMRUeJqik-01202-00243890-00244551": "[Applause]", "i2dMRUeJqik-01203-00244552-00244703": "that was an external death it was a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01204-00244704-00244823": "personal deadline but he made an", "i2dMRUeJqik-01205-00244823-00245030": "external by promising the internet i'm", "i2dMRUeJqik-01206-00245031-00245487": "going to put this thing out once a week", "i2dMRUeJqik-01207-00245488-00245703": "but yes absolutely", "i2dMRUeJqik-01208-00245704-00245903": "um yeah that was what the hell were you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01209-00245904-00246119": "thinking i don't know man i mean i you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01210-00246119-00246358": "know i went back i went back uh i think", "i2dMRUeJqik-01211-00246359-00246567": "like five years after i did that i went", "i2dMRUeJqik-01212-00246567-00246719": "back and sort of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01213-00246719-00247006": "did a did a like a weekly blog where i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01214-00247007-00247167": "would listen to the song that i had", "i2dMRUeJqik-01215-00247167-00247375": "written five years ago that week and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01216-00247376-00247542": "read what i had written about it and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01217-00247544-00247823": "wrote again and i was struck by how", "i2dMRUeJqik-01218-00247823-00248023": "how difficult an emotional journey it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01219-00248023-00248263": "was like it was and when at the time i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01220-00248264-00248406": "was like we this is fun i'm writing", "i2dMRUeJqik-01221-00248407-00248582": "songs and then the five years later", "i2dMRUeJqik-01222-00248583-00248815": "version was like man i was so depressed", "i2dMRUeJqik-01223-00248816-00249071": "at this point i was so frustrated by you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01224-00249071-00249310": "know i just had three weeks of and none", "i2dMRUeJqik-01225-00249311-00249479": "of those songs were good and i had no", "i2dMRUeJqik-01226-00249480-00249639": "iron i remember writing the song and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01227-00249640-00249903": "had no idea i had to do this thing and i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01228-00249904-00250055": "didn't like how it came out and i was", "i2dMRUeJqik-01229-00250056-00250263": "really bummed out so it was it was a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01230-00250264-00250463": "real it was a real struggle and i wish i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01231-00250464-00250671": "could say that it cured me of all of my", "i2dMRUeJqik-01232-00250671-00250871": "all of my blockages but it did not do a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01233-00250871-00251382": "damn thing", "i2dMRUeJqik-01234-00251383-00251719": "so you talked earlier about", "i2dMRUeJqik-01235-00251719-00252030": "managing getting started but", "i2dMRUeJqik-01236-00252031-00252294": "when you have ideas that", "i2dMRUeJqik-01237-00252296-00252463": "aren't working", "i2dMRUeJqik-01238-00252464-00252655": "do you have like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01239-00252656-00252839": "a place where you set aside things to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01240-00252840-00253015": "come back to later", "i2dMRUeJqik-01241-00253016-00253358": "uh and if so how do you manage that like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01242-00253359-00253615": "storage so there's a lot of half-filled", "i2dMRUeJqik-01243-00253616-00253823": "google docs", "i2dMRUeJqik-01244-00253823-00254006": "and half completed or quarter completed", "i2dMRUeJqik-01245-00254007-00254271": "it's the the trucks and cars on block uh", "i2dMRUeJqik-01246-00254271-00254446": "blocks in the front and backyard yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-01247-00254448-00254639": "they're all over scattered i also feel", "i2dMRUeJqik-01248-00254640-00254751": "like you do this with the best", "i2dMRUeJqik-01249-00254752-00254942": "intentions you write a song and you have", "i2dMRUeJqik-01250-00254944-00255142": "this initial idea this is the most", "i2dMRUeJqik-01251-00255144-00255294": "magical thing ever it doesn't work you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01252-00255296-00255455": "think i'll come back to it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01253-00255456-00255551": "and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01254-00255552-00255734": "i don't know one out of 50 times in my", "i2dMRUeJqik-01255-00255735-00255975": "experience if we i ever go back to it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01256-00255976-00256230": "when it happens it's awesome and uh if", "i2dMRUeJqik-01257-00256231-00256463": "we have a song on our this is record", "i2dMRUeJqik-01258-00256464-00256727": "number six that we had before our first", "i2dMRUeJqik-01259-00256728-00256982": "record that we finally rehashed", "i2dMRUeJqik-01260-00256983-00257230": "but that does not happen this is this is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01261-00257231-00257527": "one in 15 years so um usually they just", "i2dMRUeJqik-01262-00257528-00257734": "go away and that's okay and there's this", "i2dMRUeJqik-01263-00257735-00257951": "you know graveyard of forgotten songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-01264-00257952-00258134": "but uh which is part of the process i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01265-00258135-00258327": "guess yeah i'd agree that like it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01266-00258328-00258575": "doesn't feel as problematic to me unless", "i2dMRUeJqik-01267-00258576-00258727": "you really know like this one has", "i2dMRUeJqik-01268-00258728-00258863": "promised and it's really grating i knew", "i2dMRUeJqik-01269-00258864-00259103": "that it's not complete i think", "i2dMRUeJqik-01270-00259104-00259271": "some songwriters when they're let's say", "i2dMRUeJqik-01271-00259271-00259391": "they're making an album some people", "i2dMRUeJqik-01272-00259392-00259671": "record 25 songs then pick their whatever", "i2dMRUeJqik-01273-00259671-00259871": "13 best i think some people they'll pull", "i2dMRUeJqik-01274-00259871-00260039": "the plug earlier it's like okay i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01275-00260040-00260206": "recorded the demo this one isn't going", "i2dMRUeJqik-01276-00260207-00260423": "to make it it's not viable unveiling or", "i2dMRUeJqik-01277-00260423-00260558": "i recorded the first verse in the first", "i2dMRUeJqik-01278-00260559-00260727": "chorus this one wasn't that tight so a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01279-00260728-00260879": "lot of times i think it's just kind of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01280-00260880-00261119": "like the natural", "i2dMRUeJqik-01281-00261119-00261367": "darwinian songwriting process", "i2dMRUeJqik-01282-00261367-00261551": "i agree with that i have whole drives of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01283-00261552-00261727": "like you know things that never made it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01284-00261728-00261894": "to the album or actually full albums", "i2dMRUeJqik-01285-00261896-00262071": "that i just didn't finish", "i2dMRUeJqik-01286-00262071-00262271": "and that's just how it is and maybe", "i2dMRUeJqik-01287-00262272-00262399": "they'll resurrect some of them but", "i2dMRUeJqik-01288-00262400-00262575": "probably not", "i2dMRUeJqik-01289-00262576-00262791": "yeah i've used i've used pieces of those", "i2dMRUeJqik-01290-00262792-00262879": "lost", "i2dMRUeJqik-01291-00262880-00263143": "things uh you know there will be a chord", "i2dMRUeJqik-01292-00263144-00263358": "change that i like or a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01293-00263359-00263591": "little melody snippet you know i can", "i2dMRUeJqik-01294-00263592-00263743": "think of things where like i started to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01295-00263744-00263951": "write a song and it didn't go", "i2dMRUeJqik-01296-00263952-00264047": "and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-01297-00264048-00264199": "later i was writing a song and i needed", "i2dMRUeJqik-01298-00264200-00264351": "like a b section", "i2dMRUeJqik-01299-00264352-00264430": "and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01300-00264431-00264582": "oh i kind of like that piece how does", "i2dMRUeJqik-01301-00264583-00264830": "that work in here and that's that's one", "i2dMRUeJqik-01302-00264831-00264999": "of my favorite parts of the songwriting", "i2dMRUeJqik-01303-00265000-00265206": "process is the actual construction like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01304-00265207-00265415": "once you have a certain skeleton", "i2dMRUeJqik-01305-00265416-00265606": "and you can actually start putting the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01306-00265607-00265799": "pieces together and refining them and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01307-00265800-00265991": "smoothing things like that is my", "i2dMRUeJqik-01308-00265992-00266143": "that is the most enjoyable part of it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01309-00266144-00266334": "for me because it's past the difficult", "i2dMRUeJqik-01310-00266335-00266455": "like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01311-00266456-00266791": "inspiration and self-loathing and like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01312-00266792-00266943": "you know get getting through that level", "i2dMRUeJqik-01313-00266944-00267095": "trusting yourself to make something good", "i2dMRUeJqik-01314-00267096-00267263": "and once you have it up on its feet i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01315-00267264-00267406": "just love the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01316-00267407-00267599": "tinkering and the massaging and the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01317-00267600-00267839": "fixing that's my favorite part uh for", "i2dMRUeJqik-01318-00267840-00268055": "all the lyricists up here do you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01319-00268056-00268271": "hand write do you type or write on key", "i2dMRUeJqik-01320-00268272-00268671": "you have a preference", "i2dMRUeJqik-01321-00268672-00268982": "for for um writing type because cut and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01322-00268983-00269215": "paste and delete um", "i2dMRUeJqik-01323-00269216-00269399": "but for recording", "i2dMRUeJqik-01324-00269400-00269647": "because at least for rap versus because", "i2dMRUeJqik-01325-00269648-00269879": "it happens at speed and very often like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01326-00269880-00270063": "a song is way better", "i2dMRUeJqik-01327-00270064-00270247": "after the first tour of it because you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01328-00270248-00270423": "just wrote the like you're figuring out", "i2dMRUeJqik-01329-00270424-00270703": "when to inhale you know and so inhaling", "i2dMRUeJqik-01330-00270704-00270855": "is a really big part of trying to figure", "i2dMRUeJqik-01331-00270856-00271047": "out um", "i2dMRUeJqik-01332-00271048-00271223": "yeah both recording and live performance", "i2dMRUeJqik-01333-00271224-00271439": "for sure hence you know like with aviva", "i2dMRUeJqik-01334-00271440-00271639": "and joshua on stage like you know that", "i2dMRUeJqik-01335-00271640-00271903": "heightening wrap land is when you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-01336-00271904-00272023": "the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01337-00272024-00272191": "lead usually takes a second and everyone", "i2dMRUeJqik-01338-00272192-00272334": "else goes and then you know those", "i2dMRUeJqik-01339-00272335-00272519": "heights are designed for", "i2dMRUeJqik-01340-00272520-00272815": "oxygen intake you know um and so i'll", "i2dMRUeJqik-01341-00272816-00272999": "try to hand write before i go into the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01342-00273000-00273158": "studio sometimes because it's just like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01343-00273159-00273423": "the last layer of like committing it to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01344-00273424-00273630": "total memory yeah", "i2dMRUeJqik-01345-00273631-00273806": "and there's a romanticism to writing it", "i2dMRUeJqik-01346-00273807-00274015": "and i think i i want in my brain to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01347-00274016-00274151": "always be writing", "i2dMRUeJqik-01348-00274152-00274343": "and it just depends if it's happening", "i2dMRUeJqik-01349-00274344-00274575": "fast and it's like little ideas and and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01350-00274576-00274782": "structural stuff all handwriting i'm", "i2dMRUeJqik-01351-00274783-00274958": "sitting at the piano but when it comes", "i2dMRUeJqik-01352-00274959-00275191": "time to do the the work it's always get", "i2dMRUeJqik-01353-00275192-00275406": "it onto a document and chop it up and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01354-00275407-00275703": "copy and paste", "i2dMRUeJqik-01355-00275704-00275791": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-01356-00275792-00275910": "unless there are any more quick", "i2dMRUeJqik-01357-00275911-00276063": "questions that's about all the time we", "i2dMRUeJqik-01358-00276064-00276247": "have thank you so much thank you to all", "i2dMRUeJqik-01359-00276248-00277350": "of our panelists zoe jonathan", "i2dMRUeJqik-01360-00277351-00278558": "[Music]", "i2dMRUeJqik-01361-00278559-00278799": "what's your ratio like how many songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-01362-00278800-00278982": "you write versus how many songs someone", "i2dMRUeJqik-01363-00278983-00279191": "else has heard versus how many you've", "i2dMRUeJqik-01364-00279192-00279391": "actually performed live versus how many", "i2dMRUeJqik-01365-00279392-00279463": "you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01366-00279464-00279543": "before", "i2dMRUeJqik-01367-00279544-00279782": "good question actually", "i2dMRUeJqik-01368-00279783-00280023": "personally i tend to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01369-00280024-00280119": "not", "i2dMRUeJqik-01370-00280120-00280287": "we don't finish a lot of songs that we", "i2dMRUeJqik-01371-00280288-00280519": "don't bring for we will abandon a song", "i2dMRUeJqik-01372-00280520-00280695": "we'll know if it will mostly know if", "i2dMRUeJqik-01373-00280696-00280871": "it's good or not during the process and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01374-00280872-00281063": "rather than finish it and throw it out", "i2dMRUeJqik-01375-00281064-00281206": "we'll just move on to something else or", "i2dMRUeJqik-01376-00281207-00281415": "determine that this isn't a full song", "i2dMRUeJqik-01377-00281416-00281591": "this is a 30-second bit yeah we do have", "i2dMRUeJqik-01378-00281592-00281767": "that we have that luxury that we can", "i2dMRUeJqik-01379-00281768-00282006": "just do a bit or do like a one-sentence", "i2dMRUeJqik-01380-00282007-00282167": "thing or something", "i2dMRUeJqik-01381-00282168-00282399": "but i also write stuff that that isn't", "i2dMRUeJqik-01382-00282400-00282567": "funny necessarily and that ratio is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01383-00282568-00282703": "nearly as good", "i2dMRUeJqik-01384-00282704-00282958": "it's probably 20 or 25 to 1.", "i2dMRUeJqik-01385-00282959-00283199": "i'd say like one out of 10 ideas and", "i2dMRUeJqik-01386-00283200-00283295": "then", "i2dMRUeJqik-01387-00283296-00283471": "maybe one out of two or three finished", "i2dMRUeJqik-01388-00283472-00283815": "songs ever make it out into the world", "i2dMRUeJqik-01389-00283816-00283958": "um i'd say that usually i do pull the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01390-00283959-00284127": "plug before a song is done so most of", "i2dMRUeJqik-01391-00284128-00284295": "them that like get full written get", "i2dMRUeJqik-01392-00284296-00284519": "recorded but as far as performance i'm a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01393-00284520-00284671": "little gun-shy i'm a little cautious", "i2dMRUeJqik-01394-00284672-00284830": "maybe in constructing sub-lists and i'm", "i2dMRUeJqik-01395-00284831-00284999": "kind of scared to do the slow ones you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01396-00285000-00285263": "know so probably one out of every three", "i2dMRUeJqik-01397-00285264-00285430": "one out of every four would have any", "i2dMRUeJqik-01398-00285431-00285599": "kind of regular rotation", "i2dMRUeJqik-01399-00285600-00285879": "yeah i definitely feel like i i use", "i2dMRUeJqik-01400-00285880-00286119": "every part of the buffalo i like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01401-00286120-00286439": "i if i uh if i can manage to finish a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01402-00286440-00286615": "song it usually means", "i2dMRUeJqik-01403-00286616-00286727": "it's", "i2dMRUeJqik-01404-00286728-00286934": "i've i've judged it good enough to", "i2dMRUeJqik-01405-00286935-00287143": "actually record at least you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-01406-00287144-00287343": "whether or not it makes it into the", "i2dMRUeJqik-01407-00287344-00287510": "frequent rotation law this sort of a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01408-00287511-00287671": "different different measure but yeah i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01409-00287672-00287919": "kind of i songs for me kind of peter out", "i2dMRUeJqik-01410-00287920-00288087": "if i don't if i'm not into them and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-01411-00288088-00288310": "i just don't finish", "i2dMRUeJqik-01412-00288311-00288558": "some of my songs i can't actually play", "i2dMRUeJqik-01413-00288559-00288719": "live anymore or", "i2dMRUeJqik-01414-00288720-00288927": "so and i change them anyway so", "i2dMRUeJqik-01415-00288928-00289079": "they're only sometimes tangentially", "i2dMRUeJqik-01416-00289080-00289310": "related to the originals but so i would", "i2dMRUeJqik-01417-00289311-00289430": "say", "i2dMRUeJqik-01418-00289431-00289654": "i would say there's like some maybe way", "i2dMRUeJqik-01419-00289655-00289871": "less than half then i play live and then", "i2dMRUeJqik-01420-00289872-00290127": "as for what i write i think", "i2dMRUeJqik-01421-00290128-00290287": "less than a quarter of the songs that i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01422-00290288-00290430": "write actually", "i2dMRUeJqik-01423-00290431-00290758": "make it somewhere you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-01424-00290759-00290903": "is that is there two more questions", "i2dMRUeJqik-01425-00290904-00291054": "there", "i2dMRUeJqik-01426-00291055-00291254": "okay so one more question degree when", "i2dMRUeJqik-01427-00291255-00291839": "you guys finish", "i2dMRUeJqik-01428-00291840-00292039": "yeah i wrote some legally sensitive", "i2dMRUeJqik-01429-00292040-00292127": "stuff", "i2dMRUeJqik-01430-00292128-00292215": "um", "i2dMRUeJqik-01431-00292216-00292415": "run it run it by people but also once i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01432-00292416-00292630": "didn't and i tried to just change names", "i2dMRUeJqik-01433-00292631-00292910": "and pronouns enough and uh", "i2dMRUeJqik-01434-00292911-00293167": "and was confronted after a show you know", "i2dMRUeJqik-01435-00293168-00293367": "and to my discredit i mean like i did", "i2dMRUeJqik-01436-00293368-00293510": "obviously i didn't", "i2dMRUeJqik-01437-00293511-00293775": "do enough you know um but at some point", "i2dMRUeJqik-01438-00293776-00294023": "too i think", "i2dMRUeJqik-01439-00294024-00294239": "you know that the songwriting was really", "i2dMRUeJqik-01440-00294240-00294351": "good", "i2dMRUeJqik-01441-00294352-00294606": "i'm glad it's recorded", "i2dMRUeJqik-01442-00294607-00294775": "that would not have passed muster you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01443-00294776-00294887": "know what i mean can i write a song", "i2dMRUeJqik-01444-00294888-00295287": "about your wife it's not gonna work", "i2dMRUeJqik-01445-00295288-00295606": "uh yeah i i don't uh i don't play them", "i2dMRUeJqik-01446-00295607-00295799": "for my family because their response is", "i2dMRUeJqik-01447-00295800-00296254": "generally underwhelming", "i2dMRUeJqik-01448-00296255-00296847": "i feel like my mom likes everything", "i2dMRUeJqik-01449-00296848-00297079": "yeah i wouldn't say i run the songs past", "i2dMRUeJqik-01450-00297080-00297254": "my family but like if i feel like you", "i2dMRUeJqik-01451-00297255-00297423": "got a really good one going i might sort", "i2dMRUeJqik-01452-00297424-00297687": "of say i think this one might actually i", "i2dMRUeJqik-01453-00297688-00298015": "i was writing music for a major video", "i2dMRUeJqik-01454-00298016-00298343": "game last year and um i did play those", "i2dMRUeJqik-01455-00298344-00298519": "for my son because i think he had a", "i2dMRUeJqik-01456-00298520-00298703": "better sense of like yeah i was like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01457-00298704-00298910": "does this sound like a combat scene", "i2dMRUeJqik-01458-00298911-00299175": "maybe like no it's too mellow or like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01459-00299176-00299358": "whereas i would just be like oh it's so", "i2dMRUeJqik-01460-00299359-00300167": "you know i just had no sense of like", "i2dMRUeJqik-01461-00300168-00300334": "okay there you go", "i2dMRUeJqik-01462-00300335-00300519": "so it sounds like you run all your songs", "i2dMRUeJqik-01463-00300520-00300839": "past ben's mom because she's the best", "i2dMRUeJqik-01464-00300840-00301419": "thank you very much", "i2dMRUeJqik-01465-00301420-00301677": "[Applause]", "i2dMRUeJqik-01466-00301678-00302511": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i2kt8kCiu-g", "text": {"i2kt8kCiu-g-00000-00000282-00000743": "[Music]", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00001-00000744-00000815": "hi", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00002-00000816-00001054": "i'm peter wright i'm an ag engineer and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00003-00001055-00001247": "really been working with manure all my", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00004-00001248-00001374": "life but", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00005-00001375-00001599": "now we're looking more deeply and how we", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00006-00001600-00001823": "might treat that manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00007-00001823-00002014": "perhaps to our advantage", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00008-00002016-00002159": "you can imagine", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00009-00002160-00002407": "where we were and everybody wants to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00010-00002408-00002583": "move on from this you can see in the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00011-00002584-00002791": "background there's a building hopefully", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00012-00002792-00002958": "they'll do a better job of manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00013-00002959-00003175": "management but maybe then manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00014-00003176-00003415": "treatment we're doing this", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00015-00003415-00003638": "dairy manure management", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00016-00003639-00003822": "because we want to move the dairy farms", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00017-00003823-00004086": "towards sustainability", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00018-00004087-00004238": "sustainability includes both the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00019-00004239-00004463": "environment we think of water quality", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00020-00004464-00004543": "and then", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00021-00004544-00004775": "air emissions which reflect on climate", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00022-00004776-00004943": "change there certainly are other", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00023-00004944-00005167": "environmental issues", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00024-00005168-00005367": "sustainability also includes society and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00025-00005368-00005599": "that includes odors which might have a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00026-00005600-00005815": "impact on manure management and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00027-00005816-00005911": "treatment", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00028-00005912-00006151": "and also economics if the farm can't", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00029-00006152-00006359": "afford to do it they can't do it and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00030-00006360-00006663": "cost control is a big issue for farms", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00031-00006664-00006742": "and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00032-00006743-00006959": "the value", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00033-00006959-00007183": "added by the treatment will have to come", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00034-00007184-00007398": "into play uh whether they can afford to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00035-00007400-00007631": "do it or not", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00036-00007631-00007927": "um there's any number of reasons uh for", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00037-00007928-00008127": "additional treatment and you can read", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00038-00008128-00008295": "them here and try to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00039-00008296-00008527": "pick which ones you might go forward", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00040-00008528-00008655": "with", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00041-00008656-00008942": "i think the main ones for dairy farms", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00042-00008943-00009214": "are phosphorus removal", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00043-00009215-00009406": "many nutrient management plans restrict", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00044-00009407-00009551": "the amount of phosphorus that can be", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00045-00009552-00009831": "applied and therefore if you're over", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00046-00009832-00010039": "those limits in the soil already you're", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00047-00010040-00010214": "going to have to move the phosphorus off", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00048-00010215-00010335": "in some way", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00049-00010336-00010631": "and sorting it out so you can", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00050-00010632-00010838": "move it and move it further", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00051-00010839-00011046": "might be useful", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00052-00011047-00011231": "many farms are very interested in mass", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00053-00011232-00011414": "removal they know that the dairy manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00054-00011415-00011631": "comes with a huge mass", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00055-00011632-00011927": "with a lot of water attached and so", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00056-00011928-00012159": "you'd save time and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00057-00012160-00012463": "costs and reduction in compaction if you", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00058-00012464-00012551": "could", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00059-00012552-00012719": "move the mass", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00060-00012720-00012910": "there is some ideas that we're going to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00061-00012911-00013127": "add food waste", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00062-00013128-00013430": "utilize food waste both get tipping fees", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00063-00013431-00013607": "from that and to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00064-00013608-00013855": "extract the energy from it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00065-00013856-00014079": "but if you do that on farms that produce", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00066-00014080-00014263": "their own forage you're going to need to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00067-00014263-00014471": "move the nutrients off so again you're", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00068-00014472-00014855": "looking at ways for minority treatment", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00069-00014856-00015079": "well here's the conclusion", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00070-00015080-00015311": "treatments are possible", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00071-00015312-00015583": "but they have a high tablet cost", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00072-00015584-00015830": "typically a high o m cost and they take", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00073-00015831-00015991": "management", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00074-00015991-00016366": "so unless you can justify it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00075-00016368-00016591": "through those purposes we just mentioned", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00076-00016592-00016871": "or through byproduct sales", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00077-00016872-00017127": "we're probably not ready yet for manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00078-00017128-00017375": "treatment but um there are some", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00079-00017376-00017615": "treatments available and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00080-00017616-00017767": "we're still interested so we're going to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00081-00017768-00018007": "go on and examine it even though now you", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00082-00018008-00018247": "know the conclusion", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00083-00018248-00018422": "we also typically run it through an", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00084-00018423-00018599": "anaerobic digester when we think of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00085-00018600-00018743": "treatment um", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00086-00018744-00018911": "not only do we get the energy out when", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00087-00018912-00019086": "we do that but we end up with a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00088-00019087-00019319": "homogenized digestate", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00089-00019320-00019479": "we reduced", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00090-00019480-00019639": "uh", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00091-00019640-00019927": "the odor we've reduced the pathogens uh", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00092-00019928-00020207": "we've made it more liquid and uh and we", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00093-00020208-00020430": "got the energy", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00094-00020431-00020630": "there's any number of things that we can", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00095-00020631-00020919": "actually do though uh with a manure any", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00096-00020920-00021207": "number and it gets quite complex and a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00097-00021208-00021383": "lot of choices and that's what we really", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00098-00021384-00021486": "want to do", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00099-00021487-00021711": "is to characterize some of these such", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00100-00021712-00021950": "that farms can pick", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00101-00021951-00022175": "um and and find out which", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00102-00022176-00022414": "ones or which series of uh treatments", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00103-00022415-00022799": "might be might become suitable for them", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00104-00022800-00023214": "there's also a number of ideas out there", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00105-00023215-00023486": "that haven't come to pass yet but might", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00106-00023487-00023703": "here's one that we're working on", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00107-00023704-00023894": "and we're actually converting carbon", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00108-00023895-00024078": "dioxide", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00109-00024079-00024383": "through biomethanation into", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00110-00024384-00024519": "methane", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00111-00024520-00024767": "and we're also taking the digestate and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00112-00024768-00024919": "running it through a hydrothermal", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00113-00024920-00025142": "liquefication process", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00114-00025143-00025503": "and the resulting uh system", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00115-00025504-00025718": "might be one that", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00116-00025719-00025974": "could work for firearms", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00117-00025975-00026134": "in the future", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00118-00026135-00026535": "but we do remember that there's a cost", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00119-00026536-00026774": "per cow the further further we move", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00120-00026775-00026895": "material", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00121-00026895-00027190": "if we can pump it um we it's more", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00122-00027191-00027399": "efficient but if we have to haul it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00123-00027400-00027718": "either with a a tank tractor mounted one", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00124-00027719-00027902": "or a truck mounted one the costs go up", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00125-00027904-00028111": "considerably and this would be why we'd", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00126-00028112-00028343": "be interested in reducing the mass", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00127-00028344-00028495": "here's another", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00128-00028495-00028679": "what a surprise as the distance", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00129-00028680-00029055": "increases so does the cost", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00130-00029056-00029231": "when we look at our dairy farms this is", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00131-00029232-00029495": "in new york state on a smaller sample of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00132-00029495-00029911": "farms but the costs vary tremendously", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00133-00029912-00030039": "so the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00134-00030039-00030246": "acres per hour", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00135-00030247-00030551": "varies depends on the size of the farm", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00136-00030552-00030807": "depends on where the fields are", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00137-00030808-00030967": "depends on how much you're putting on", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00138-00030968-00031095": "per acre", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00139-00031095-00031295": "and then your total cost", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00140-00031295-00031543": "um ranges from", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00141-00031544-00031855": "uh half a cent almost one cent to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00142-00031856-00032062": "almost two cents a gallon", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00143-00032063-00032239": "however that's still a relatively low", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00144-00032239-00032455": "cost when you consider the cost of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00145-00032456-00032718": "treatment that could", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00146-00032719-00032911": "you know that manure has intangible", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00147-00032912-00033111": "values right the organic matter is worth", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00148-00033112-00033199": "something", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00149-00033200-00033343": "the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00150-00033344-00033623": "disadvantages of compaction and the time", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00151-00033624-00033887": "it takes and the problems that can occur", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00152-00033888-00034118": "are also present with manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00153-00034119-00034343": "here's another scheme that they came up", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00154-00034344-00034583": "with this is called wet gasification", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00155-00034584-00034823": "unfortunately you actually need to put", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00156-00034824-00035062": "in 25 solids and as you know dairy", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00157-00035063-00035335": "manure is 10 salads so already we're", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00158-00035336-00035615": "only treating a portion of the manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00159-00035616-00035799": "uh but the farm was interested in this", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00160-00035800-00035974": "would it help them move towards", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00161-00035975-00036239": "sustainability could it reduce the cost", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00162-00036240-00036446": "of hauling would it produce a byproduct", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00163-00036447-00036518": "and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00164-00036519-00036751": "wasn't economically feasible", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00165-00036752-00036846": "um", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00166-00036847-00037015": "actually in the end", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00167-00037016-00037215": "it did request hot", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00168-00037216-00037390": "reduce hauling costs a little bit but", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00169-00037391-00037527": "not very much", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00170-00037528-00037815": "um it did produce a low-grade heat but", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00171-00037816-00038055": "not very useful on the farm", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00172-00038056-00038174": "and the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00173-00038175-00038446": "potential sales", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00174-00038447-00038615": "weren't as much as you might wish they", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00175-00038616-00038702": "were", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00176-00038703-00038902": "um or as", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00177-00038903-00039087": "you weren't as confident in them as you", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00178-00039088-00039262": "might be and there was a huge capital", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00179-00039263-00039415": "cost", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00180-00039416-00039679": "another issue that farms face is sand as", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00181-00039680-00039871": "a bedding is a wonderful wonderful", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00182-00039872-00039983": "material", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00183-00039984-00040279": "but sand as a part of a manure treatment", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00184-00040280-00040535": "system creates an extra step", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00185-00040536-00040862": "so maybe you have to use a mechanism to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00186-00040863-00041071": "sort the sand out", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00187-00041072-00041230": "also reclaiming the sand this would be a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00188-00041231-00041527": "good thing but additional capital cost", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00189-00041528-00041655": "to do it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00190-00041656-00041855": "so our project", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00191-00041856-00042190": "put together by kurt gooch", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00192-00042191-00042383": "was to do applied research and look at", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00193-00042384-00042583": "different manure treatment options and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00194-00042584-00042702": "then", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00195-00042703-00042927": "bring this out to the public again we're", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00196-00042928-00043095": "trying to help dairy farms move towards", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00197-00043096-00043302": "sustainability", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00198-00043303-00043607": "we pretty much start with uh separation", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00199-00043608-00043895": "separate the solids with a screw press", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00200-00043896-00043999": "we", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00201-00044000-00044239": "picked a wonderful farm to cooperate", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00202-00044240-00044495": "with", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00203-00044496-00044651": "you can see though it's", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00204-00044652-00044943": "semi-complex which way the manure flows", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00205-00044944-00045118": "and they're actually in the winter time", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00206-00045119-00045302": "recycling some of the manure to make the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00207-00045303-00045558": "gravity channels work but it all feeds", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00208-00045559-00045862": "to an anaerobic digester and then a a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00209-00045863-00046158": "screw pressed operation and what we had", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00210-00046159-00046358": "hoped to do was to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00211-00046359-00046655": "get a baseline of how much manure was", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00212-00046656-00046767": "coming in", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00213-00046768-00046951": "and then therefore", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00214-00046952-00047246": "configure and use examples either on", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00215-00047247-00047390": "farm or", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00216-00047391-00047607": "from other other sources of what would", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00217-00047608-00047918": "happen with different treatment options", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00218-00047919-00048207": "so here's the system as it exists", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00219-00048208-00048318": "now", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00220-00048319-00048671": "and we were going to put in a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00221-00048672-00048871": "a system to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00222-00048872-00049071": "ultimately utilize much more get more of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00223-00049072-00049335": "the solids try to pelletilize them and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00224-00049336-00049574": "try to have them so that they could", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00225-00049575-00049935": "either be exported or used in a further", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00226-00049936-00050183": "on further fields", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00227-00050184-00050439": "it relied on an aerobic composter which", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00228-00050440-00050662": "we were promised would reduce the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00229-00050663-00050862": "moisture content", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00230-00050863-00051062": "in an effective and efficient efficient", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00231-00051063-00051238": "way", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00232-00051239-00051558": "it did reduce the moisture content we", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00233-00051559-00051758": "are quite excited", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00234-00051759-00051830": "they", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00235-00051832-00052175": "added a mysterious inoculant they put it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00236-00052176-00052287": "into a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00237-00052288-00052591": "aerobic composter in vessel", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00238-00052591-00052871": "um and in three days time they uh you", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00239-00052872-00053063": "can see they had considerable reduction", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00240-00053064-00053319": "in moisture content is a good thing", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00241-00053320-00053494": "unfortunately when we looked at the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00242-00053495-00053871": "energy expended we found out that it was", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00243-00053872-00054215": "costing us a lot in energy so 11 cents a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00244-00054216-00054366": "pound of moisture", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00245-00054367-00054535": "and you know there's about seven pounds", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00246-00054536-00054838": "of moisture per gallon of manure and so", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00247-00054839-00055015": "this", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00248-00055016-00055223": "no you just can't do it this way they", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00249-00055224-00055375": "actually were", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00250-00055376-00055679": "using electricity on not only mixing but", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00251-00055679-00055903": "also to heat the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00252-00055904-00056054": "and drive off", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00253-00056055-00056319": "the moisture so we were back with what", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00254-00056320-00056471": "are we going to do with the existing", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00255-00056472-00056663": "system", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00256-00056664-00056950": "um and we have ideas that will take the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00257-00056951-00057111": "screw press solids and run it through a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00258-00057112-00057359": "bedding recovery unit a pelletizer and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00259-00057360-00057647": "then a dryer but also then take some of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00260-00057648-00057926": "the liquids and run it through", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00261-00057927-00058038": "different", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00262-00058039-00058175": "either uh", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00263-00058176-00058350": "operations to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00264-00058351-00058687": "further sort out the solids", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00265-00058688-00058882": "so we might come up with a system like", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00266-00058883-00059238": "this i'm using a dissolved air flotation", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00267-00059239-00059542": "or a belt press we might come up with a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00268-00059544-00059799": "ultimately a system", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00269-00059800-00060030": "one of these paths to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00270-00060032-00060326": "finally find out what is the optimum", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00271-00060327-00060823": "meanwhile we were taking um", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00272-00060824-00061103": "sample results from each of the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00273-00061104-00061542": "from the flows in the in the digester", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00274-00061544-00061750": "so we we were taking these samples and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00275-00061751-00061871": "getting flow", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00276-00061872-00062119": "we also have ideas that the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00277-00062120-00062375": "nutrient planning going into the cow the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00278-00062376-00062599": "feed going into the cow would give us a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00279-00062600-00062775": "result of the manure coming out of the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00280-00062776-00062854": "cow", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00281-00062855-00063038": "remember there was some recycling which", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00282-00063039-00063150": "had to occur", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00283-00063151-00063399": "and then if we run this through", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00284-00063400-00063638": "and even on an excel spreadsheet and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00285-00063639-00063838": "come up with the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00286-00063839-00064126": "mass flows and nutrient flows", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00287-00064127-00064366": "um going in as well you know the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00288-00064367-00064550": "moisture content and solid content we", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00289-00064551-00064830": "could come up with uh what would happen", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00290-00064832-00064911": "so", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00291-00064912-00065103": "different schemes", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00292-00065104-00065206": "um", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00293-00065207-00065399": "more sampling", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00294-00065400-00065535": "and we", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00295-00065536-00065679": "have thought of these treatments the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00296-00065680-00065919": "dissolved deer flotation centrifuges", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00297-00065920-00066143": "sequencing batch reactor", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00298-00066144-00066399": "pyrolysis a pelletizer or maybe of a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00299-00066400-00066606": "belt press", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00300-00066607-00066791": "there's a dissolved air flotation the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00301-00066792-00067103": "farm actually has a grant to put in a a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00302-00067104-00067350": "partial dissolved air flotation system", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00303-00067351-00067582": "to handle some of the liquids and sort", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00304-00067583-00067823": "more solids out", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00305-00067824-00068071": "there's ideas of a centrifuge", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00306-00068072-00068199": "there's", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00307-00068200-00068447": "and also ideas of a sequencing batch", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00308-00068448-00068735": "reactor that might work", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00309-00068736-00068959": "there's any number of schemes though", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00310-00068960-00069303": "that people have come up with", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00311-00069304-00069526": "also there could be a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00312-00069527-00069606": "even", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00313-00069607-00069887": "more efficient drying operation that", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00314-00069888-00069999": "could work", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00315-00070000-00070087": "um", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00316-00070088-00070311": "all of which might take energy the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00317-00070312-00070511": "energy might be available of course for", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00318-00070512-00070831": "the anaerobic digester", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00319-00070832-00071126": "um we know it is possible you can run it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00320-00071127-00071391": "through a system and actually uh end up", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00321-00071392-00071550": "with pure water", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00322-00071551-00071806": "on a dairy farm particularly in new york", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00323-00071807-00072031": "state where we have plenty of water you", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00324-00072032-00072215": "really got to ask why would you take it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00325-00072216-00072511": "all the way to water but you might take", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00326-00072512-00072775": "it to a uh", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00327-00072776-00072991": "where most of the nutrients are taken", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00328-00072992-00073279": "out so you can spray irrigate the", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00329-00073280-00073382": "liquids", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00330-00073383-00073647": "as they uh to reduce the mass close to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00331-00073648-00073855": "the farm and then haul all the other", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00332-00073856-00074062": "nutrients further away", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00333-00074063-00074271": "again there's any number of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00334-00074272-00074575": "systems out there that", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00335-00074576-00074687": "do this", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00336-00074688-00074823": "however", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00337-00074824-00075038": "you've got to ask what's the capital", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00338-00075039-00075255": "cost what's the o m cost and how much", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00339-00075256-00075479": "management does it take", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00340-00075480-00075662": "we put together some fact sheets and", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00341-00075663-00076031": "they're available at our website", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00342-00076032-00076303": "we uh talk about manure basics", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00343-00076304-00076494": "we also look at specifically if you want", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00344-00076495-00076694": "to require phosphorus if you want to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00345-00076695-00076871": "recover nitrogen", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00346-00076872-00077182": "and energy extraction so you can go to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00347-00077183-00077350": "our website and look at those fact", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00348-00077351-00077455": "sheets", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00349-00077456-00077711": "ultimately we'd like to have each of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00350-00077712-00077806": "these", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00351-00077807-00077959": "components", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00352-00077960-00078262": "addressed in the in the nutrient catalog", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00353-00078263-00078535": "and for those of you familiar with", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00354-00078536-00078743": "not familiar with nutrients", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00355-00078744-00078975": "um it's a", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00356-00078976-00079231": "they want to encourage business", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00357-00079232-00079415": "development for both", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00358-00079416-00079671": "energy fertilizer and bedding and soil", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00359-00079672-00079775": "amendment", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00360-00079776-00079935": "from manure", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00361-00079936-00080206": "and as well as", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00362-00080207-00080471": "develop ecosystem services either", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00363-00080472-00080703": "nutrient trading or carbon trading such", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00364-00080704-00080806": "that", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00365-00080807-00081006": "you can", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00366-00081007-00081191": "increase the byproducts that could", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00367-00081192-00081543": "develop out of manure but their catalog", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00368-00081544-00081726": "asks that each", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00369-00081727-00081855": "component", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00370-00081856-00081982": "that you might", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00371-00081983-00082287": "include in a manure treatment system", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00372-00082288-00082687": "would get scored based on", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00373-00082688-00082862": "different criteria", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00374-00082863-00083094": "um such that if you had all nine of", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00375-00083095-00083262": "these you pretty much could tell what", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00376-00083263-00083431": "you were going to get into", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00377-00083432-00083711": "so i think this would be a a useful", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00378-00083712-00084031": "thing um", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00379-00084032-00084359": "for farms to do and and and for farms to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00380-00084360-00084926": "know that they that they have done that", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00381-00084927-00085159": "um my conclusions", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00382-00085160-00085518": "um storage needs will increase", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00383-00085519-00085703": "um", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00384-00085704-00085935": "technology will advance", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00385-00085936-00086247": "um policies will continue to change", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00386-00086248-00086503": "but as you think about manure treatment", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00387-00086504-00086759": "you need to know and control your costs", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00388-00086760-00086999": "and you certainly need to be careful out", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00389-00087000-00087087": "there", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00390-00087088-00087326": "before you invest", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00391-00087327-00087511": "make sure one it will work on dairy", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00392-00087512-00087750": "manure and how much will it cost and how", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00393-00087751-00087918": "much of your management time will it", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00394-00087919-00088126": "take", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00395-00088127-00088359": "this time i'll be certainly willing to", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00396-00088360-00088630": "take any questions you might have", "i2kt8kCiu-g-00397-00088631-00089149": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i2sQc_lw1yQ", "text": {"i2sQc_lw1yQ-00000-00005684-00007083": "foreign", "i2sQc_lw1yQ-00001-00007084-00008239": "today", "i2sQc_lw1yQ-00002-00008240-00008447": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i2w-4qwlZQc", "text": {"i2w-4qwlZQc-00000-00000328-00000471": "hello everyone", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00001-00000472-00000678": "good afternoon and welcome to the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00002-00000679-00000958": "january 10th special meeting of the art", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00003-00000959-00001166": "and public places committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00004-00001167-00001358": "i'd like to call this meeting to order", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00005-00001359-00001543": "at this time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00006-00001544-00001710": "a little bit of housekeeping before we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00007-00001711-00001902": "start the meeting a reminder to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00008-00001903-00002102": "committee members to keep your audio on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00009-00002103-00002526": "mute unless you are speaking", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00010-00002527-00002767": "uh pursuant to government code section", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00011-00002768-00003047": "54953", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00012-00003048-00003206": "and the recommendation of the health", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00013-00003207-00003463": "officer of county of sonoma", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00014-00003464-00003647": "art and public places committee will be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00015-00003647-00003895": "participating in this meeting via zoom", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00016-00003896-00004038": "webinar", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00017-00004039-00004206": "members of the public may view and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00018-00004207-00004406": "listen to the meeting as noted on the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00019-00004407-00004767": "city's website and noted on the agenda", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00020-00004768-00004967": "eileen will you please review how the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00021-00004968-00005159": "public may comment and participate in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00022-00005160-00005302": "today's meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00023-00005303-00005391": "yes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00024-00005392-00005559": "the committee appreciates the public's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00025-00005560-00005743": "participation for those members of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00026-00005744-00005943": "public who submitted written comment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00027-00005944-00006118": "those comments have been attached to the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00028-00006119-00006334": "agenda reviewed by the committee and are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00029-00006335-00006518": "accessible to the public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00030-00006519-00006703": "members of the public are allowed one", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00031-00006704-00006934": "comment per item which includes written", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00032-00006936-00007206": "phone and in-person comments a single", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00033-00007208-00007470": "email constitutes a comment on an item", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00034-00007472-00007703": "so additional emails phone messages or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00035-00007704-00007942": "in-person comments cannot be added", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00036-00007943-00008110": "members of the public who wish to speak", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00037-00008111-00008351": "during item 3 public comment or during", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00038-00008352-00008591": "any of the scheduled items may do so by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00039-00008592-00008846": "utilizing the raised hand feature or if", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00040-00008847-00009087": "calling in please press star 9.", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00041-00009088-00009239": "individuals will then be given the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00042-00009240-00009439": "ability to address the committee thank", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00043-00009440-00009883": "you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00044-00009884-00010167": "great eileen will you next please take", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00045-00010168-00010374": "roll call", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00046-00010375-00010527": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00047-00010528-00010999": "member baumgartner", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00048-00011000-00011103": "president", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00049-00011104-00011519": "remember at syria", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00050-00011520-00011606": "yes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00051-00011607-00011942": "i see you vice chair jones carter", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00052-00011943-00012103": "present", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00053-00012104-00012263": "chair keeper", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00054-00012264-00012399": "present", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00055-00012400-00012535": "please let the record reflect that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00056-00012536-00012735": "member apprentice and member nathanson", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00057-00012736-00013422": "are unable to attend today's meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00058-00013423-00013830": "next item item three got public comment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00059-00013831-00014022": "this is the time when any person may", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00060-00014023-00014263": "address matters not listed on the agenda", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00061-00014263-00014447": "but are within the subject matter of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00062-00014447-00014583": "jurisdiction", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00063-00014584-00014807": "the public may comment on agenda items", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00064-00014808-00015015": "when each item is called", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00065-00015016-00015294": "each speaker is allowed three minutes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00066-00015295-00015479": "eileen are there any public comments", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00067-00015480-00015775": "waiting we have no raised hands at this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00068-00015776-00016007": "time nor were there any voicemails um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00069-00016008-00016183": "and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00070-00016184-00016375": "pardon me eileen it looks like david", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00071-00016376-00016583": "harris wishes to make a public comment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00072-00016584-00016871": "in non-agenda items thank you i will i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00073-00016872-00017039": "apologize i will", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00074-00017040-00017183": "david if you could hold on just one", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00075-00017184-00018119": "moment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00076-00018120-00018303": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00077-00018304-00018543": "yes i pushed the unmute button so am i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00078-00018544-00018822": "being heard you are thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00079-00018823-00019039": "are you able to see the screen", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00080-00019040-00019279": "my name is david harris and i've been a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00081-00019280-00019639": "long time resident of santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00082-00019640-00019727": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00083-00019728-00020030": "have served on uh city commissions uh i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00084-00020031-00020191": "was actually", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00085-00020192-00020383": "uh for a time the representative of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00086-00020384-00020694": "redevelopment on art and public places", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00087-00020695-00020886": "so i do have a little history", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00088-00020887-00021039": "but i want to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00089-00021040-00021303": "raise my concern about the climate", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00090-00021304-00021407": "crisis", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00091-00021408-00021583": "and it's something that you would not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00092-00021584-00021814": "normally think is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00093-00021815-00022086": "directly related to public art", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00094-00022087-00022255": "but i want to raise the issue that i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00095-00022256-00022455": "believe we need to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00096-00022456-00022694": "if we're going to meet our goals and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00097-00022695-00022983": "protect the future of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00098-00022984-00023207": "for our future generations that we need", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00099-00023208-00023455": "to be taking every action we can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00100-00023456-00023735": "to communicate to the public the urgency", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00101-00023736-00023958": "of the climate crisis", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00102-00023959-00024239": "and that leads me to think that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00103-00024240-00024519": "even public art to should be thinking", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00104-00024520-00024607": "about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00105-00024608-00024750": "what it can do", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00106-00024751-00024958": "to motivate the public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00107-00024959-00025247": "to change", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00108-00025248-00025391": "behaviors", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00109-00025392-00025542": "in the interest of protecting the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00110-00025543-00025670": "climate", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00111-00025672-00025999": "and uh certainly knowing that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00112-00026000-00026078": "our", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00113-00026079-00026318": "large uh source of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00114-00026319-00026614": "carbon footprint is transportation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00115-00026616-00026727": "i would", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00116-00026727-00026958": "i'm raising this question for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00117-00026960-00027295": "your long-term consideration that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00118-00027295-00027702": "how might public art be used to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00119-00027704-00027902": "affect the public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00120-00027904-00028102": "in the near-term in the medium-term and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00121-00028104-00028279": "in the long term", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00122-00028280-00028446": "in their", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00123-00028447-00028799": "use of alternatives to our long-standing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00124-00028800-00029023": "fossil fuel industry", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00125-00029024-00029223": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00126-00029224-00029390": "you know what that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00127-00029391-00029623": "might mean i just started to think about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00128-00029624-00029831": "it but certainly i do have a specific", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00129-00029832-00029951": "interest", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00130-00029952-00030095": "in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00131-00030095-00030431": "communications that can be made", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00132-00030432-00030735": "to the highways and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00133-00030736-00030951": "there is a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00134-00030952-00031295": "project in process for a 101 over", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00135-00031295-00031399": "crossing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00136-00031400-00031718": "that i believe offers an opportunity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00137-00031719-00031918": "to communicate", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00138-00031919-00032199": "to multiple generations who travel", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00139-00032200-00032527": "underneath that it is a high exposure", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00140-00032527-00032767": "and you know the efforts that took so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00141-00032768-00032967": "many years to get public transit in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00142-00032968-00033151": "form of smart", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00143-00033152-00033231": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00144-00033232-00033431": "you know started back", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00145-00033432-00033711": "before 1990 and now", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00146-00033712-00033990": "with the compounding effect of covid", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00147-00033991-00034311": "i would say we have to be concerned that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00148-00034312-00034423": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00149-00034424-00034583": "will another", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00150-00034584-00034774": "ballot measure pass", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00151-00034775-00035031": "and we just need to do everything we can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00152-00035032-00035262": "to raise the visibility", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00153-00035263-00035543": "of what alternatives we do have because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00154-00035544-00035671": "most people", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00155-00035672-00035959": "are living unaware of a lot of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00156-00035960-00036230": "alternatives that do exist and i would", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00157-00036231-00036487": "raise this challenge to art and public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00158-00036488-00036895": "places to consider that issue thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00159-00036896-00037279": "thank you mr heron", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00160-00037280-00037551": "we have an additional commenter of mr", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00161-00037552-00038039": "jack smaringen", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00162-00038040-00038367": "and mr swearingen um are you able i have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00163-00038368-00038502": "given you permission to talk are you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00164-00038503-00038711": "able to see the timer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00165-00038712-00038911": "i do and i am", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00166-00038912-00039183": "can you hear me yes we can i am the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00167-00039184-00039479": "local chair of a citizens group called", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00168-00039480-00039639": "friends of smart", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00169-00039640-00039759": "and i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00170-00039760-00040055": "picking up where david harris paused", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00171-00040056-00040239": "because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00172-00040240-00040567": "public art is an environmental", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00173-00040568-00040655": "issue", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00174-00040656-00040823": "of course it has to do with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00175-00040824-00041046": "aesthetic part of our environment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00176-00041047-00041295": "but david brought up the other", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00177-00041296-00041599": "aspects especially environmental but", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00178-00041600-00041815": "there's also economic", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00179-00041816-00041911": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00180-00041912-00042158": "forensic smart's mission is to help", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00181-00042159-00042302": "the smart", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00182-00042303-00042558": "rail and trail be successful and means", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00183-00042559-00042702": "getting people out of their private", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00184-00042703-00042990": "vehicles and on to active or public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00185-00042991-00043127": "transportation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00186-00043128-00043318": "and this is a chance to do that by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00187-00043319-00043511": "promoting making visible the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00188-00043512-00043655": "alternatives", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00189-00043656-00043927": "so this is a perfect place to combine", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00190-00043928-00044158": "sense of place with sense of what's out", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00191-00044159-00044246": "there", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00192-00044247-00044527": "and i have actually developed a cartoon", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00193-00044528-00044727": "form of sign showing snoopy and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00194-00044728-00044967": "woodstock riding a tandem bicycle and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00195-00044968-00045118": "then science putting to the smart", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00196-00045119-00045207": "station", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00197-00045208-00045399": "from both directions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00198-00045400-00045718": "and what a great publicity opportunity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00199-00045719-00046015": "not just hey we're the home of snoopy", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00200-00046016-00046239": "but also we have a smart train that goes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00201-00046240-00046486": "through here and goes where you're going", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00202-00046487-00046767": "so uh i will send that to all of you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00203-00046768-00046990": "after this webinar is complete just for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00204-00046991-00047215": "your entertainment and the purpose of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00205-00047216-00047502": "course is to broaden the idea from just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00206-00047503-00047727": "the aesthetic part of environmental", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00207-00047728-00047895": "protection but also the environmental", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00208-00047896-00048071": "and the economic", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00209-00048072-00048230": "and our", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00210-00048231-00048702": "global planet thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00211-00048703-00049023": "thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00212-00049024-00049207": "there are no additional hands-free stuff", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00213-00049208-00050662": "this time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00214-00050663-00051111": "all right thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00215-00051112-00051342": "at this time i'll move on to item four", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00216-00051344-00051582": "our scheduled items", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00217-00051583-00051782": "item 4.1", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00218-00051783-00051935": "unum sculpture", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00219-00051936-00052182": "um sculpture recommended words and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00220-00052183-00052319": "languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00221-00052320-00052550": "staff will present the recommended words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00222-00052551-00052694": "and languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00223-00052695-00052982": "for the unam for the sculpture unum by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00224-00052983-00053142": "blessing hancock the proof for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00225-00053144-00053399": "installation in courthouse square the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00226-00053400-00053591": "presentation will include the project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00227-00053591-00053815": "background and collaborative process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00228-00053816-00054071": "used to collect the submissions from the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00229-00054072-00054575": "community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00230-00054576-00054950": "uh great thank you um kristen and hello", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00231-00054951-00055103": "everyone i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00232-00055104-00055342": "am tara thompson the city's arts and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00233-00055344-00055559": "culture manager i'm here today to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00234-00055560-00055838": "present this item along with jessica", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00235-00055839-00056071": "rasmussen our art specialist", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00236-00056072-00056254": "and i wanted to mention that as you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00237-00056255-00056519": "david ward has left the city and is no", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00238-00056520-00056679": "longer working on this project as a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00239-00056679-00056830": "project manager", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00240-00056832-00057103": "and so jessica has been", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00241-00057104-00057319": "stepping in to assist with this project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00242-00057320-00057494": "and is here today", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00243-00057495-00057566": "to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00244-00057567-00057871": "chime in on the presentation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00245-00057872-00058047": "so um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00246-00058048-00058311": "i want to start off by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00247-00058312-00058447": "next slide please", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00248-00058448-00058615": "i want to start off by giving a little", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00249-00058616-00058935": "bit of background about this piece the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00250-00058936-00059087": "community engagement and the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00251-00059088-00059319": "opportunities for the public to provide", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00252-00059320-00059615": "input throughout this process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00253-00059616-00059871": "shown here are the artist renderings of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00254-00059872-00060119": "the proposed design unum by blessing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00255-00060120-00060254": "hancock", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00256-00060255-00060535": "proposed and approved for courthouse", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00257-00060536-00060735": "square the north side of courthouse", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00258-00060736-00060926": "square", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00259-00060927-00061111": "um we'll talk a little bit more about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00260-00061112-00061319": "the actual design and the artist's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00261-00061320-00061591": "intention on on the next slide", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00262-00061591-00061830": "but just to start off sorry go back go", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00263-00061832-00062038": "back um still want to talk about this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00264-00062039-00062159": "one yeah thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00265-00062160-00062482": "um this project was initiated in august", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00266-00062483-00062847": "2019 with the formation of an advisory", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00267-00062848-00063150": "committee who developed project goals", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00268-00063151-00063406": "community engagement process selection", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00269-00063407-00063742": "criteria and recommended a draft project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00270-00063744-00063935": "plan to the art and public places", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00271-00063936-00064111": "committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00272-00064112-00064254": "the art and public places committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00273-00064255-00064438": "approved the project plan and the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00274-00064439-00064638": "request for qualifications for this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00275-00064639-00064863": "project in november of that same year", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00276-00064864-00065038": "2019", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00277-00065039-00065238": "the project plan outlines the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00278-00065239-00065535": "description goals site considerations", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00279-00065536-00065735": "selection process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00280-00065736-00066015": "including selection criteria budget", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00281-00066016-00066238": "stakeholders and timeline", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00282-00066239-00066455": "a preliminary survey was also launched", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00283-00066456-00066638": "at this time for the community to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00284-00066639-00066838": "provide input on the development of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00285-00066839-00066982": "project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00286-00066983-00067247": "approximately 250 survey responses were", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00287-00067248-00067431": "collected at that time and the results", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00288-00067432-00067782": "were shared with the finalist artists", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00289-00067783-00067975": "a selection panel was formed for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00290-00067976-00068175": "project responsible for reviewing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00291-00068176-00068406": "application materials using this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00292-00068407-00068606": "established criteria", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00293-00068607-00068694": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00294-00068695-00068926": "selecting of the finalists evaluating", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00295-00068927-00069143": "the finalists proposals", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00296-00069144-00069382": "um using the established criteria and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00297-00069383-00069638": "selecting one artist for the project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00298-00069639-00069871": "then recommending their selection to the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00299-00069872-00070119": "art and public places committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00300-00070120-00070326": "once the selection panel had identified", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00301-00070327-00070526": "finalists for the project a second", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00302-00070527-00070719": "survey was launched to solicit input", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00303-00070720-00070863": "from the community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00304-00070864-00071055": "on the finalist designs", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00305-00071056-00071335": "over 700 responses were collected and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00306-00071336-00071559": "this survey results were considered by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00307-00071560-00071743": "the selection panel during their final", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00308-00071744-00071950": "selection process along with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00309-00071951-00072238": "established selection criteria", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00310-00072239-00072431": "throughout this project information was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00311-00072432-00072631": "shared via the city connections", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00312-00072632-00072879": "newsletter the city and out there san", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00313-00072880-00073087": "rosa's social media posts", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00314-00073088-00073294": "print media articles including the press", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00315-00073295-00073550": "democrat and public meetings", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00316-00073551-00073694": "the art and public places committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00317-00073695-00073862": "approved blessing hancock and her", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00318-00073863-00074175": "proposal unum at the december 2020", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00319-00074176-00074759": "meeting next slide please", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00320-00074760-00075006": "this is um the proposal language that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00321-00075007-00075271": "was submitted by the artist and approved", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00322-00075272-00075447": "by the art public places committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00323-00075448-00075719": "describing the piece unum", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00324-00075720-00076055": "meaning latin for oneness or together", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00325-00076056-00076223": "and is proposed to be a signature", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00326-00076224-00076399": "artwork that places emphasis on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00327-00076400-00076631": "innovation diversity and engagement as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00328-00076632-00076935": "leading values of santa rosa inspired by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00329-00076936-00077119": "the unified old courthouse square the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00330-00077120-00077350": "sculpture embraces themes of welcoming", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00331-00077351-00077582": "and inspiration while also relaying the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00332-00077583-00077750": "santa rosa values of innovation and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00333-00077751-00078079": "cultural inclusivity throughout its text", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00334-00078080-00078255": "collected through a community engagement", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00335-00078256-00078375": "process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00336-00078376-00078543": "during the day the sculpture cast", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00337-00078544-00078735": "shadows of the words onto the square", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00338-00078736-00078943": "using sunlight whereas in the early", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00339-00078944-00079094": "morning and evening hours it will be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00340-00079095-00079319": "illuminated by led light fixtures", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00341-00079320-00079526": "mounted within the sculpture creating a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00342-00079527-00079743": "soft diffused glow within the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00343-00079744-00079882": "structure's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00344-00079883-00080191": "form the community engagement", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00345-00080192-00080494": "outreach for the text on the sculpture", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00346-00080495-00080638": "will be collected through public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00347-00080639-00080894": "engagement opportunities with appc to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00348-00080895-00081062": "identify selected words that will", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00349-00081063-00081423": "represent inherent values to santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00350-00081424-00081623": "the dimensions will be approximately 12", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00351-00081624-00081887": "feet high by 15 feet wide and the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00352-00081888-00082103": "materials will be water jet cut", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00353-00082104-00082359": "stainless steel and led lights", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00354-00082360-00082815": "next slide", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00355-00082816-00083047": "um this slide talks about the engagement", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00356-00083048-00083279": "process to collect the words for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00357-00083280-00083382": "piece", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00358-00083383-00083655": "so beginning in late spring 2021 and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00359-00083656-00083823": "throughout the summer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00360-00083824-00084062": "the artist team and the city worked", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00361-00084063-00084262": "together to collect the community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00362-00084263-00084479": "outreach i'm sorry to design the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00363-00084480-00084687": "community outreach portion of this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00364-00084688-00084838": "project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00365-00084839-00085126": "we asked key representatives to join a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00366-00085127-00085382": "community advisory group for this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00367-00085383-00085494": "engagement", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00368-00085495-00085718": "and included individuals from the sonoma", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00369-00085719-00085959": "county library the city's office of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00370-00085960-00086247": "community engagement raises collective", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00371-00086248-00086503": "100 black men of sonoma county the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00372-00086504-00086735": "museum of sonoma county and the city's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00373-00086736-00086943": "community advisory board", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00374-00086944-00087206": "two of the members also participated", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00375-00087207-00087447": "on the original selection panel for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00376-00087448-00087615": "project and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00377-00087616-00087743": "brought", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00378-00087744-00087911": "familiarity and continuity with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00379-00087912-00088071": "project and those people were jeff", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00380-00088072-00088343": "nathanson and leslie graves", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00381-00088344-00088575": "we asked this group to design how we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00382-00088576-00088750": "approach the community with this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00383-00088751-00088879": "opportunity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00384-00088880-00089118": "how best to facilitate a process to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00385-00089119-00089318": "invite people to participate", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00386-00089319-00089550": "and once responses were gathered to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00387-00089551-00089759": "review and recommend the results to the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00388-00089760-00089982": "art and public places committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00389-00089983-00090159": "this group also looked at the most", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00390-00090160-00090382": "common languages spoken in santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00391-00090383-00090743": "and discussed translating key responses", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00392-00090744-00090935": "the engagement opportunity was presented", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00393-00090936-00091255": "both online via survey and in person", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00394-00091256-00091438": "which was collected through a flyer that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00395-00091439-00091615": "the public could fill out and return to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00396-00091616-00091726": "us", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00397-00091727-00091943": "we also partici uh partnered with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00398-00091944-00092135": "city's rec and parks department to run a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00399-00092136-00092335": "youth engagement activity through summer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00400-00092336-00092631": "camps to collect responses", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00401-00092632-00092831": "the community advisory group for this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00402-00092832-00093055": "engagement also made the following", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00403-00093056-00093279": "recommendations to include a land", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00404-00093280-00093487": "acknowledgement on site to accompany the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00405-00093488-00093750": "artwork on a plaque and to include", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00406-00093751-00093991": "southern pomo and coast miwok languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00407-00093992-00094206": "to acknowledge the land and the people", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00408-00094207-00094567": "the people the artwork will be on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00409-00094568-00095023": "next slide please", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00410-00095024-00095206": "working with the community advisory", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00411-00095207-00095423": "group and drawing from the original", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00412-00095424-00095687": "project goals of providing the community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00413-00095688-00095879": "with a prominent artistic symbol that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00414-00095880-00096047": "reflects the san rosa values of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00415-00096048-00096311": "innovation and cultural inclusivity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00416-00096312-00096574": "and that is a forward thinking and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00417-00096575-00096799": "expresses the innovation diversity and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00418-00096800-00096991": "engagement of the community the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00419-00096992-00097167": "following prompts were used in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00420-00097168-00097550": "outreach with the community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00421-00097551-00097767": "the general population survey on the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00422-00097768-00098126": "left had these four questions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00423-00098127-00098399": "and the youth engagement on the right", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00424-00098400-00098743": "had these four questions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00425-00098744-00099006": "approximately 400 total responses were", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00426-00099007-00099118": "collected", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00427-00099119-00099343": "over 300 responses were collected from", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00428-00099344-00099535": "the online survey", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00429-00099536-00099831": "and over 50 from the youth", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00430-00099832-00100199": "flyers and then about 50 more from", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00431-00100200-00100431": "artists the artist team", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00432-00100432-00100631": "doing targeted outreach to community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00433-00100632-00101071": "stakeholder groups", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00434-00101072-00101591": "next slide please", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00435-00101592-00101799": "this first chart on the left shows the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00436-00101800-00102023": "top responses to prompts in the survey", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00437-00102024-00102223": "from both the youth and general public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00438-00102224-00102447": "outreach so this is a combined list of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00439-00102448-00102751": "the top appearing words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00440-00102752-00102942": "each time one of these words appeared in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00441-00102943-00103127": "the responses either in the form of a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00442-00103128-00103302": "phrase or a single word it was tallied", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00443-00103303-00103630": "and compiled onto this list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00444-00103631-00103823": "the list of languages in the green table", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00445-00103824-00104071": "on the right are the top 15 languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00446-00104072-00104310": "spoken in san rosa as included in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00447-00104311-00104551": "city's language assistance plan which", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00448-00104552-00104782": "has original data from the u.s census", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00449-00104783-00104934": "bureau", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00450-00104935-00105134": "as i said before the community advisory", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00451-00105135-00105366": "group for this project also recommended", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00452-00105367-00105583": "including southern pomo and coast miwok", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00453-00105583-00105783": "to acknowledge and respect the southern", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00454-00105783-00105990": "pomo and miwok land and existing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00455-00105991-00106263": "communities in santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00456-00106264-00106415": "these recommended languages were", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00457-00106416-00106590": "identified through a dated driven", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00458-00106591-00106839": "process to be as equitable as possible", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00459-00106840-00107110": "and represent san rosa's residence", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00460-00107111-00107286": "there are of course other languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00461-00107288-00107463": "spoken in the community that are not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00462-00107464-00107710": "represented here however as the data", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00463-00107711-00107990": "shows these are the 15 most used", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00464-00107991-00108190": "languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00465-00108191-00108431": "other languages suggestions have been", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00466-00108432-00108702": "made by the community for consideration", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00467-00108703-00108895": "some of you will hear or have already", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00468-00108896-00109102": "read in the public comments and i just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00469-00109103-00109310": "wanted to state that as of earlier today", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00470-00109311-00109502": "the following languages have been", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00471-00109503-00109758": "suggested", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00472-00109759-00109902": "and some of them appear in public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00473-00109903-00110086": "comment some of them were made in other", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00474-00110088-00110286": "forms hebrew", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00475-00110288-00110734": "arabic japanese greek and russian", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00476-00110735-00110943": "the artist has shared that approximately", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00477-00110944-00111151": "1 000 total words will be able to fit on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00478-00111152-00111383": "the sculpture the recommendation we are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00479-00111383-00111543": "presenting here today is to use the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00480-00111544-00111766": "words seen here translated in each", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00481-00111767-00112102": "language seen here for approximately 380", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00482-00112103-00112302": "words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00483-00112303-00112478": "and then to repeat them as many times", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00484-00112479-00112719": "that will fit on the sculpture", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00485-00112720-00113007": "this is a large sculpture and so having", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00486-00113008-00113239": "the words show up in multiple places in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00487-00113240-00113423": "all of the languages i think will", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00488-00113424-00113831": "provide a better experience for a viewer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00489-00113832-00114151": "next slide please", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00490-00114152-00114343": "so the recommendation we are making here", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00491-00114344-00114527": "today is to approve the recommended", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00492-00114528-00114727": "words and languages to be included in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00493-00114728-00114983": "unum's design for the imagine art and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00494-00114983-00115334": "old courthouseware project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00495-00115335-00115575": "i just wanted to go over a few", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00496-00115576-00115799": "options for today as there's been a lot", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00497-00115800-00116054": "of conversation about it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00498-00116055-00116271": "to approve the recommended list of words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00499-00116272-00116454": "and languages as stated", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00500-00116455-00116663": "or to approve the recommended words and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00501-00116664-00116871": "languages with changes and additions as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00502-00116872-00117166": "voted on and determined by the committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00503-00117167-00117454": "or to table the item until the next", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00504-00117455-00117815": "meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00505-00117816-00118127": "the next steps are to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00506-00118128-00118375": "provide the artist with an approved list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00507-00118376-00118654": "of words and all the translations so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00508-00118655-00118871": "that she can finalize the artwork design", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00509-00118872-00119078": "and engineering that is the next", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00510-00119079-00119375": "deliverable that is due to the city", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00511-00119376-00119558": "after the final design and engineering", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00512-00119559-00119695": "are approved the artwork would be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00513-00119696-00119823": "fabricated", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00514-00119824-00119927": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00515-00119928-00120207": "the installation is expected this next", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00516-00120208-00120510": "spring", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00517-00120511-00120695": "that is all that i have today for my", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00518-00120696-00120919": "presentation i'm happy to answer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00519-00120920-00121471": "any questions thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00520-00121472-00121614": "thank you tara", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00521-00121615-00121831": "do any members have any questions for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00522-00121832-00122551": "tara or jessica", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00523-00122552-00122790": "uh seeing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00524-00122791-00122966": "none i oh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00525-00122967-00123190": "and do you have a question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00526-00123191-00123414": "great go ahead you're on me up um could", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00527-00123415-00123647": "i ask a question about the suggestions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00528-00123648-00123863": "for the extra five languages is this the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00529-00123864-00124078": "time i could ask that question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00530-00124079-00124239": "yeah i just was curious did those just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00531-00124240-00124454": "come in randomly from people that saw", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00532-00124455-00124631": "this and responded or is it coming", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00533-00124632-00124839": "through some sort of vetting that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00534-00124840-00125063": "this would be the next five or something", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00535-00125064-00125263": "like that you know that in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00536-00125264-00125390": "um order of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00537-00125391-00125495": "most", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00538-00125496-00125671": "found in our community or just like i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00539-00125672-00125790": "just wondered how that list came", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00540-00125791-00126095": "together besides the one we saw", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00541-00126096-00126399": "um the other suggestions have come", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00542-00126400-00126599": "forward from community members who have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00543-00126600-00126831": "seen the list of recommended recommended", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00544-00126832-00127071": "languages and felt that these needed to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00545-00127072-00127343": "be added in addition to those they are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00546-00127344-00127558": "not from any", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00547-00127559-00127807": "u.s census bureau data or other language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00548-00127808-00128047": "assisted plan document their suggestions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00549-00128048-00129023": "from the community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00550-00129024-00129254": "sorry i was on mute uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00551-00129255-00129431": "question would you be able to pull up", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00552-00129432-00129654": "the chart the slide that you had with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00553-00129655-00130286": "the chart of the words and the languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00554-00130288-00130447": "eileen should be able to do that so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00555-00130448-00131927": "standby", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00556-00131928-00132127": "great thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00557-00132128-00132575": "a question i had was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00558-00132576-00132911": "is the intent for all of these words to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00559-00132912-00133399": "be translated in all 15 languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00560-00133400-00133478": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00561-00133479-00133719": "i remember you said that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00562-00133720-00134071": "there was about 350 words i i'm not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00563-00134072-00134239": "doing the math in my head right now but", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00564-00134240-00134439": "wondering if that is where that number", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00565-00134440-00134854": "came from yes that is correct", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00566-00134855-00135254": "uh if we were to suggest the addition of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00567-00135255-00135447": "a couple other languages would there be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00568-00135448-00135743": "the opportunity to select maybe one or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00569-00135744-00136014": "two words to be translated instead of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00570-00136015-00136351": "the entire list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00571-00136352-00136431": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00572-00136432-00136671": "yes that's at the committee's discretion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00573-00136672-00136999": "um i would recommend though that there's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00574-00137000-00137366": "there's room on the sculpture so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00575-00137367-00137623": "what what that would effectively do is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00576-00137624-00137839": "if additional languages are added and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00577-00137840-00138039": "all of the words are translated into", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00578-00138040-00138159": "those additional", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00579-00138160-00138551": "languages that that adds you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00580-00138552-00138943": "100 perhaps or up to 200 more words um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00581-00138944-00139095": "there's still room for that there would", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00582-00139096-00139271": "just be less repetition throughout the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00583-00139272-00139431": "whole sculpture so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00584-00139432-00139711": "um that's that's one way to look at it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00585-00139712-00139854": "i think the other", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00586-00139855-00140063": "thing that we are concerned about as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00587-00140064-00140431": "well from um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00588-00140432-00140590": "an equity standpoint i guess i'm not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00589-00140591-00140790": "sure but um you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00590-00140791-00140990": "we were looking at data in terms of one", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00591-00140991-00141183": "of the most common languages spoken in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00592-00141184-00141463": "santa rosa as a second language or as a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00593-00141464-00141678": "primary language right so we're looking", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00594-00141679-00141919": "at this um and i i have to say you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00595-00141920-00142087": "we've had some discussion about some", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00596-00142088-00142366": "discomfort on um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00597-00142367-00142590": "adding languages based on personal", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00598-00142591-00142839": "preference or a desire from a personal", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00599-00142840-00142983": "perspective", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00600-00142984-00143151": "because not everybody has that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00601-00143152-00143302": "opportunity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00602-00143303-00143431": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00603-00143432-00143726": "so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00604-00143727-00143959": "i would caution that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00605-00143960-00144207": "because it would open it up i think", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00606-00144208-00144526": "to anybody but either i want my language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00607-00144527-00144743": "i want this language um and then it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00608-00144744-00144911": "could potentially open up to but how", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00609-00144912-00145063": "come i didn't know that we could add", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00610-00145064-00145343": "languages so we're looking for something", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00611-00145344-00145726": "to um land on uh one and two i have to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00612-00145727-00145975": "say i think um you know there is a thing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00613-00145976-00146175": "of this being from 2019 that we could", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00614-00146176-00146478": "review the language list um but there is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00615-00146479-00146719": "a second thing of adding", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00616-00146720-00146839": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00617-00146840-00147014": "uh i don't want to say willy-nilly but", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00618-00147015-00147278": "sort of willingly adding languages um to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00619-00147279-00148031": "the list based on that personal desire", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00620-00148032-00148254": "oh melanie you're on mute", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00621-00148255-00148478": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00622-00148479-00148654": "this is sort of a discussion point", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00623-00148655-00148783": "because i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00624-00148784-00149087": "my concern also is that you know every", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00625-00149088-00149414": "project that we that we have we set up a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00626-00149415-00149590": "advisory committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00627-00149591-00149847": "it's a broad group of people they have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00628-00149848-00150078": "specific criteria that they're working", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00629-00150079-00150287": "on they're empowered to make the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00630-00150288-00150502": "decisions and then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00631-00150503-00150663": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00632-00150664-00150887": "you know if someone's not happy with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00633-00150888-00151159": "end result", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00634-00151160-00151343": "why would people want to continue to do", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00635-00151344-00151631": "this if their work is disregarded", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00636-00151632-00151951": "um so i'm that's a concern of for me", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00637-00151952-00152047": "that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00638-00152048-00152254": "um you know people who were on this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00639-00152255-00152439": "committee made the decisions we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00640-00152440-00152590": "empowered them", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00641-00152591-00152854": "and they came to a consensus", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00642-00152855-00152990": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00643-00152991-00153190": "you're never gonna get", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00644-00153191-00153454": "a hundred percent of the people to agree", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00645-00153455-00153671": "on anything there was even controversy", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00646-00153672-00153990": "about the selection of this particular", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00647-00153991-00154295": "sculpture so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00648-00154296-00154526": "you know where do we draw a line between", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00649-00154527-00154743": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00650-00154744-00154935": "when we get some pushback", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00651-00154936-00155319": "of of uh making sure that the people who", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00652-00155320-00155631": "we are who are appointed", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00653-00155632-00155878": "are doing a good job and that let me", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00654-00155879-00156566": "stand behind their decisions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00655-00156567-00156823": "so i would ask that we stick as much as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00656-00156824-00157063": "we can to questions right now and then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00657-00157064-00157263": "um and then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00658-00157264-00157487": "there'll be public comment after that so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00659-00157488-00157695": "any any other questions i i'm happy to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00660-00157696-00158126": "answer or race or jessica can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00661-00158127-00158295": "thank you tara yeah i just wanted to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00662-00158296-00158590": "remind first we're doing questions then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00663-00158591-00158814": "we'll have public comment and then we'll", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00664-00158815-00159023": "need a motion before we can have a more", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00665-00159024-00160054": "thorough discussion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00666-00160055-00160214": "do any committee members have any", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00667-00160215-00160454": "questions about what our our potential", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00668-00160455-00161031": "actions are today um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00669-00161032-00161287": "i'm sorry what was your question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00670-00161288-00161487": "does anyone have a question about what", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00671-00161488-00161607": "our action", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00672-00161608-00161751": "could be today", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00673-00161752-00162031": "tara um outlined three options that we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00674-00162032-00162223": "could go with if we want to hear those", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00675-00162224-00162311": "again", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00676-00162312-00162663": "um that might be good for us to think", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00677-00162664-00163031": "about while we're here in public comment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00678-00163032-00163254": "yeah i think right now it's really", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00679-00163255-00163431": "yeah technical questions or follow-up", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00680-00163432-00163575": "questions on the presentation so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00681-00163576-00163775": "anything that anyone needs any clarity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00682-00163776-00164143": "on before you you as a group move into", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00683-00164144-00164311": "hearing public comments and then having", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00684-00164312-00164999": "your own discussion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00685-00165000-00165351": "and go ahead you're on mute", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00686-00165352-00165583": "um i just want to ask a question again", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00687-00165584-00165911": "about the signage and the um explanation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00688-00165912-00166119": "at the site for people looking is this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00689-00166120-00166271": "going to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00690-00166272-00166438": "potentially if we were to go with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00691-00166439-00166751": "plan that the committee has outlined in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00692-00166752-00166838": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00693-00166839-00167087": "languages they chose based on research", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00694-00167088-00167326": "would that be explained in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00695-00167327-00167487": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00696-00167488-00167702": "comments or the plaque or whatever we're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00697-00167703-00168047": "doing that um how any process behind it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00698-00168048-00168238": "or will it just strictly stand on its", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00699-00168239-00168438": "own", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00700-00168439-00168663": "that's a great question um we have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00701-00168664-00168831": "talked about adding additional", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00702-00168832-00169031": "information to this plaque", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00703-00169032-00169223": "for this piece because it will have a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00704-00169224-00169366": "lot of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00705-00169367-00169702": "thought and intention behind it however", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00706-00169703-00169943": "a lot of times a plaque", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00707-00169944-00170319": "isn't the best space in terms of amount", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00708-00170320-00170543": "of space for adding so much information", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00709-00170544-00170638": "so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00710-00170639-00170943": "we would be working on some kind of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00711-00170944-00171183": "design for a plaque that would include", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00712-00171184-00171431": "some information and then either a qr", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00713-00171432-00171654": "code or a link that someone can get to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00714-00171655-00171831": "our website and get more information", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00715-00171832-00172343": "about the project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00716-00172344-00172495": "just to follow up i i wasn't only", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00717-00172496-00172687": "strictly speaking about plaque i did say", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00718-00172688-00172831": "that but i meant just the mess the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00719-00172832-00172990": "general messages around it the way we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00720-00172991-00173214": "presented the public relation that goes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00721-00173215-00173351": "out and explaining", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00722-00173352-00173551": "and then i assume a project like this is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00723-00173552-00173766": "going to get some press is with all of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00724-00173767-00174007": "this process continue to follow", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00725-00174008-00174319": "the presentation of peace", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00726-00174320-00174590": "yes i think when this piece is kind of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00727-00174591-00174790": "unveiled to the community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00728-00174791-00175071": "in a variety of ways that we we are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00729-00175072-00175238": "planning on there would be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00730-00175239-00175438": "some context provided in terms of what", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00731-00175439-00175735": "the goals of the project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00732-00175736-00175990": "were from the beginning and how", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00733-00175991-00176183": "the process identified this artist and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00734-00176184-00176335": "these words in these languages i think", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00735-00176336-00176543": "that's an important part to understand", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00736-00176544-00177166": "about this piece", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00737-00177167-00177471": "another question i have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00738-00177472-00177726": "will the selected words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00739-00177727-00177926": "when they are repeated is there an", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00740-00177927-00178087": "opportunity for them to be different", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00741-00178088-00178263": "sizes or will they all kind of be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00742-00178264-00178423": "uniform", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00743-00178424-00178743": "throughout the piece", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00744-00178744-00178966": "i believe they are all the same font", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00745-00178967-00179247": "size so to speak because of what is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00746-00179248-00179543": "required for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00747-00179544-00179887": "keeping the structural integrity of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00748-00179888-00180126": "stainless steel material by cutting out", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00749-00180127-00180319": "all of the negative space essentially", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00750-00180320-00180543": "which will be the words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00751-00180544-00180783": "so the artist has indicated that that is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00752-00180784-00181031": "why she needs this approved", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00753-00181032-00181207": "list of words with all the translations", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00754-00181208-00181447": "ahead of time to make those final design", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00755-00181448-00181614": "and engineering", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00756-00181615-00181838": "decisions and then that will be the next", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00757-00181839-00182414": "piece that comes back to us for approval", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00758-00182415-00182526": "melanie", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00759-00182527-00182831": "yeah so how long how much longer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00760-00182832-00183054": "um what's the timeline here", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00761-00183055-00183199": "so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00762-00183200-00183447": "if she gets the war if the words are get", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00763-00183448-00183743": "given to the artists tomorrow", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00764-00183744-00183951": "what's the timeline for getting this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00765-00183952-00184295": "project implemented and are we on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00766-00184296-00184607": "time are we meeting our timeline", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00767-00184608-00184783": "our timeline has been delayed a few", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00768-00184784-00184966": "times for various reasons at the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00769-00184967-00185095": "pandemic", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00770-00185096-00185287": "first and foremost but we've also had", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00771-00185288-00185399": "fires", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00772-00185400-00185599": "and the artist has also had delays on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00773-00185600-00185847": "her end due to fabrication", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00774-00185848-00186150": "issues with fabricators and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00775-00186151-00186359": "materials and so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00776-00186360-00186447": "there's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00777-00186448-00186623": "there i think that our original timeline", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00778-00186624-00186783": "has been completely", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00779-00186784-00187078": "thrown out the window um but for a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00780-00187079-00187247": "variety of other reasons", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00781-00187248-00187478": "i think any delays at this point will", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00782-00187479-00187766": "delay but um you know getting a sense of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00783-00187767-00187975": "the timing of that is a little bit", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00784-00187976-00188087": "difficult", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00785-00188088-00188359": "i think at this point we are on track to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00786-00188360-00188550": "install this spring", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00787-00188551-00188671": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00788-00188672-00188926": "probably late spring and if there's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00789-00188927-00189031": "delays", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00790-00189032-00189319": "with approving uh today then that would", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00791-00189320-00189654": "just push that out um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00792-00189655-00189743": "so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00793-00189744-00189919": "yeah i mean it's kind of unfair to use", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00794-00189920-00190078": "our original timeline for the project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00795-00190079-00190223": "which had which had installation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00796-00190224-00190471": "happening now like january february so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00797-00190472-00190550": "that's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00798-00190551-00190847": "that's not happening", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00799-00190848-00192231": "thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00800-00192232-00192414": "thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00801-00192415-00192599": "uh seeing that there are no more", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00802-00192600-00192854": "questions or questions to clarify with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00803-00192855-00193054": "staff i would like to move on to public", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00804-00193055-00193319": "comment for this item", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00805-00193320-00193535": "eileen can you lead us through that yes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00806-00193536-00193702": "we do have two individuals to raise", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00807-00193703-00194278": "their hand for public comments", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00808-00194279-00194750": "um the first individual is david harris", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00809-00194751-00194983": "david if you have been allowed to speak", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00810-00194984-00195135": "if you could confirm your ability to see", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00811-00195136-00195295": "the screen that would be wonderful yes i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00812-00195296-00195535": "have uh hit the unmute", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00813-00195536-00195919": "so i spoke in the open comments and uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00814-00195920-00196071": "you know since you can't see me i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00815-00196072-00196302": "going to tell you that i'm in my 70s and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00816-00196303-00196471": "spent a lot of time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00817-00196472-00196719": "in school and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00818-00196720-00196926": "and worked around the world so i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00819-00196927-00197159": "unfortunately had the opportunity to to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00820-00197160-00197375": "learn multiple languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00821-00197376-00197566": "fluency in 3d", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00822-00197567-00197950": "and exposure to many others and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00823-00197951-00198247": "this is very complex uh now you start", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00824-00198248-00198502": "talking about all those languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00825-00198503-00198663": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00826-00198664-00198943": "it's a pretty daunting task", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00827-00198944-00199135": "when you need to do it either a negative", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00828-00199136-00199375": "or positive punch out and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00829-00199376-00199711": "uh but that's what hasn't been touched", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00830-00199712-00199950": "on is their different writing systems", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00831-00199951-00200199": "and i felt g how did i get to all this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00832-00200200-00200502": "education and not have uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00833-00200503-00200654": "exposure to the different writing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00834-00200655-00200895": "systems and we can largely think that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00835-00200896-00201102": "everything's written in a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00836-00201103-00201311": "a roman based", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00837-00201312-00201550": "alphabet and that is not true and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00838-00201551-00201814": "certainly for this list of languages the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00839-00201815-00202063": "mandarin arabic", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00840-00202064-00202263": "thai", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00841-00202264-00202383": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00842-00202384-00202687": "arab and the south asian", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00843-00202688-00202863": "and man", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00844-00202864-00203102": "i mean has a plan been to put in a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00845-00203103-00203407": "romanized equivalent", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00846-00203408-00203638": "to those words in those languages or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00847-00203639-00203911": "actually use the writing systems that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00848-00203912-00204199": "they are originally written in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00849-00204200-00204366": "you know they're going to be translated", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00850-00204367-00204495": "so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00851-00204496-00204687": "uh because they're gonna appear in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00852-00204688-00204927": "other languages but i i think that's a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00853-00204928-00205206": "it's a very complex task to uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00854-00205207-00205455": "illustrate these other languages korean", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00855-00205456-00205638": "uh and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00856-00205639-00205882": "and chinese in particular", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00857-00205883-00206158": "uh when you have this constraint of it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00858-00206159-00206479": "being either positive or negative", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00859-00206480-00206638": "but you know i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00860-00206639-00206846": "generally i like challenges like that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00861-00206848-00207055": "the complexity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00862-00207056-00207238": "wouldn't bother me but there's the other", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00863-00207239-00207494": "thing of unintended", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00864-00207496-00207623": "you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00865-00207623-00207838": "it's very difficult to model this well", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00866-00207839-00208127": "enough to know whether there might be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00867-00208128-00208351": "when it's lighted projections onto the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00868-00208352-00208606": "ground that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00869-00208607-00208862": "you have a different type of maybe of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00870-00208863-00209142": "graffiti by people blocking out things", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00871-00209144-00209223": "to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00872-00209223-00209486": "have it project uh something other than", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00873-00209487-00209719": "what is originally there this is a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00874-00209719-00209942": "complex piece of art that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00875-00209944-00210271": "that people can walk up to and do things", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00876-00210271-00210527": "i really", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00877-00210528-00210742": "you know you can't imagine what all the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00878-00210744-00210942": "possibilities are until it's actually", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00879-00210944-00211191": "there i mean the the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00880-00211192-00211423": "first example i heard of the things like", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00881-00211423-00211606": "that though was uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00882-00211607-00211782": "somebody studying on the east coast and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00883-00211783-00212046": "there was a big neon shell sign", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00884-00212048-00212287": "and of course one day the s went out", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00885-00212288-00212398": "well", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00886-00212400-00212639": "you now had a different word", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00887-00212640-00212998": "projected across the whole city and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00888-00213000-00213191": "this isn't going to project that far but", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00889-00213192-00213382": "there are just a lot of possibilities", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00890-00213383-00213694": "for things that we cannot foresee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00891-00213696-00213879": "being", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00892-00213880-00214046": "illustrated out of this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00893-00214048-00214406": "lovely piece of art", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00894-00214407-00214734": "thank you mr harris", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00895-00214735-00214951": "i just want to take a moment to remind", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00896-00214952-00215110": "everyone members of the public are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00897-00215111-00215294": "allowed one comment per item which", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00898-00215296-00215494": "includes written phone and in-person", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00899-00215496-00215591": "comments", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00900-00215592-00215831": "a single email constitutes a comment on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00901-00215832-00216063": "an item so additional emails phone", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00902-00216064-00216303": "messages or in-person comments cannot be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00903-00216304-00216542": "added", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00904-00216544-00216863": "with that said the next individual", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00905-00216864-00217082": "that will be speaking is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00906-00217083-00217319": "thomas thomas", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00907-00217319-00217455": "you are allowed to speak if you could", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00908-00217456-00217623": "confirm your ability to see the screen", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00909-00217623-00217879": "that would be wonderful", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00910-00217880-00218263": "hi um i'm having a problem with my", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00911-00218264-00218623": "equipment here", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00912-00218623-00218919": "it doesn't seem to be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00913-00218919-00219158": "i can't really hear you very well but i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00914-00219159-00219327": "i hope you can hear me", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00915-00219328-00219503": "we can hear you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00916-00219504-00219863": "and i'll go ahead and start the timer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00917-00219864-00220191": "uh i was hoping to be on the call", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00918-00220192-00220303": "earlier", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00919-00220304-00220439": "for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00920-00220440-00220751": "uh items not on the agenda i was also", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00921-00220752-00220951": "hoping to comment on this one", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00922-00220952-00221167": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00923-00221167-00221446": "one i didn't quite i'm not sure i heard", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00924-00221448-00221575": "all of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00925-00221576-00221871": "uh other additional languages but i was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00926-00221871-00222015": "thinking that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00927-00222016-00222119": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00928-00222119-00222231": "hindu", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00929-00222232-00222494": "there's a lot of indian people uh in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00930-00222496-00222823": "community as i'm aware and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00931-00222823-00223063": "it's a very big country with a lot of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00932-00223064-00223271": "people that speak that language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00933-00223271-00223527": "and it might be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00934-00223528-00223742": "beneficial to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00935-00223744-00223910": "be an outreach", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00936-00223911-00224158": "you know a kind of a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00937-00224159-00224303": "an opportunity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00938-00224304-00224487": "um and then of course i did hear the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00939-00224488-00224703": "other language which is russian and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00940-00224704-00224919": "there's a great uh history", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00941-00224919-00225167": "of russian people here in sonoma county", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00942-00225167-00225310": "and the speaking of russian and of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00943-00225311-00225471": "course uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00944-00225471-00225798": "fort ross and and all of that so um i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00945-00225800-00226015": "would hope you'd be open to that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00946-00226016-00226110": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00947-00226111-00226367": "the issue that i was hoping to address", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00948-00226367-00226479": "on the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00949-00226480-00226671": "uh public comment not on the agenda i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00950-00226671-00226887": "hope that there's an opportunity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00951-00226888-00227055": "for me to take the rest of my time for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00952-00227056-00227206": "that which was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00953-00227207-00227342": "about the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00954-00227344-00227423": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00955-00227423-00227606": "overcrossing of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00956-00227607-00227775": "edwards and elliott", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00957-00227776-00228231": "and the art on that and i hope that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00958-00228232-00228503": "there's an opportunity to speak to that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00959-00228504-00228694": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00960-00228696-00228958": "particularly i believe that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00961-00228959-00229063": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00962-00229064-00229342": "there has been some uh proposals to put", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00963-00229344-00229542": "a bit of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00964-00229544-00229839": "illustrated art not exactly", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00965-00229840-00230079": "uh something indicating the train of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00966-00230080-00230310": "smart in order to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00967-00230311-00230558": "uh support smart i believe", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00968-00230559-00230671": "that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00969-00230671-00230839": "having been involved for a very long", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00970-00230840-00231063": "time since the middle 90s", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00971-00231064-00231415": "involved in smart that we are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00972-00231416-00231719": "what people call a death spiral", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00973-00231719-00231998": "uh the problem is that they", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00974-00232000-00232255": "paid too much for some things", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00975-00232256-00232415": "and and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00976-00232416-00232623": "in the process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00977-00232623-00232791": "they may have to cut back service", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00978-00232792-00232927": "they've already cut back search because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00979-00232928-00233119": "the pandemic they may get some funding", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00980-00233119-00233439": "which is great to improve the service", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00981-00233440-00233687": "uh it may not come back to the service", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00982-00233688-00233894": "that we've had and that's what they call", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00983-00233896-00234119": "a death spiral when the service starts", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00984-00234119-00234358": "being cut back in order to preserve", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00985-00234359-00234527": "capital and so on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00986-00234528-00234615": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00987-00234616-00234910": "uh then people ride less and and we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00988-00234911-00235119": "really have to turn that around it's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00989-00235119-00235415": "it's a make or break and that's why we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00990-00235416-00235734": "need this on that overcrossing and i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00991-00235735-00235942": "hope you can consider that it can be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00992-00235944-00236231": "made art uh it is very important and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00993-00236232-00236431": "it's a life or death issue for smart", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00994-00236432-00236606": "really we know we seem to have some", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00995-00236607-00236694": "years", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00996-00236696-00236871": "but we have a lot of resistance to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00997-00236871-00237023": "overcome i want to thank you for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00998-00237023-00237255": "opportunity to speak", "i2w-4qwlZQc-00999-00237256-00237903": "thank you thomas", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01000-00237904-00238719": "the next individual will be paula simon", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01001-00238719-00238934": "and paula you should be able to speak", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01002-00238935-00239079": "please let me know if you're able to see", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01003-00239080-00239206": "the screen", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01004-00239207-00239482": "i can see the screen wonderful please", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01005-00239483-00239855": "proceed my name is paula simon i am", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01006-00239856-00240110": "somebody who did participate in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01007-00240111-00240423": "the outreach process and voting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01008-00240423-00240742": "i um i want to just ask a question about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01009-00240744-00240982": "the languages i my professional", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01010-00240983-00241167": "background is in community relations", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01011-00241167-00241303": "just so you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01012-00241304-00241423": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01013-00241423-00241575": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01014-00241576-00241846": "the list that you used um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01015-00241848-00242079": "the learning for the learning assistance", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01016-00242080-00242271": "of the language assistance plan that you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01017-00242271-00242503": "noted on the screen", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01018-00242504-00242703": "looks at a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01019-00242704-00243023": "limited english proficiency", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01020-00243023-00243167": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01021-00243167-00243398": "and and that's a big part in those and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01022-00243400-00243615": "i'm not sure that limited english", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01023-00243616-00243767": "proficiency", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01024-00243767-00243942": "is really", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01025-00243944-00244015": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01026-00244016-00244263": "the marker of diversity and i just want", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01027-00244264-00244510": "to think about how that understand a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01028-00244511-00244742": "little bit more about how that list and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01029-00244744-00244975": "those languages were decided i see the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01030-00244976-00245175": "list i'm looking at the list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01031-00245176-00245446": "and i see that they correlate but i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01032-00245448-00245742": "not sure that that's really um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01033-00245744-00245951": "as broad as this community or as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01034-00245952-00246175": "reflective of the community because just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01035-00246176-00246415": "if you are a limited language or you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01036-00246416-00246598": "request something or ask for another", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01037-00246600-00246894": "language doesn't necessarily mean that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01038-00246896-00247191": "you um speak another language or another", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01039-00247192-00247463": "language has meaning or identity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01040-00247464-00247639": "and i think this is all about language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01041-00247640-00247798": "as part of identity so i just want to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01042-00247800-00248023": "make sure that when you consider the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01043-00248023-00248142": "list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01044-00248144-00248391": "i noticed that for example japanese is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01045-00248392-00248575": "not on the list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01046-00248576-00248767": "but there's a large community of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01047-00248767-00248982": "japanese speakers in this community so i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01048-00248983-00249063": "just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01049-00249064-00249287": "want to be mindful that the list is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01050-00249288-00249551": "really reflective of the total community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01051-00249552-00249758": "and not just a segment of the community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01052-00249759-00249894": "that perhaps", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01053-00249896-00250071": "speaks another language as a first", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01054-00250071-00250527": "language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01055-00250528-00250710": "thank you thank you so much for your", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01056-00250711-00251103": "comment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01057-00251104-00251294": "while the name is listed as asher", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01058-00251296-00251503": "shepherd the next speaker will be ann", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01059-00251504-00251871": "shepard", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01060-00251871-00251982": "and ann", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01061-00251983-00252246": "if you could confirm your ability to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01062-00252248-00252655": "see the screen please yes i can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01063-00252656-00252927": "can you hear me yes we can thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01064-00252928-00253294": "yeah i i agree with what paula just said", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01065-00253296-00253551": "and i would like to encourage you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01066-00253552-00253710": "to please", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01067-00253711-00254103": "uh postpone the final decision", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01068-00254104-00254342": "until the next meeting you have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01069-00254344-00254471": "so that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01070-00254471-00254710": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01071-00254711-00254958": "other languages can be considered", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01072-00254959-00255151": "seriously", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01073-00255152-00255494": "that's basically it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01074-00255496-00255663": "and thank you so much for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01075-00255664-00256087": "your comment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01076-00256088-00256263": "there are no additional hands-free at", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01077-00256264-00256551": "this time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01078-00256552-00257030": "did i do okay", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01079-00257031-00257230": "thank you aileen", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01080-00257231-00257406": "all right at this time i will close", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01081-00257407-00257591": "public comment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01082-00257592-00257863": "i'll bring it back to our committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01083-00257864-00258367": "uh at this time we would need to get a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01084-00258367-00258582": "motion on the table", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01085-00258583-00258758": "uh before we can proceed with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01086-00258759-00258982": "discussion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01087-00258983-00259175": "i just if i could chime in really", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01088-00259176-00259382": "quickly i just wanted to suggest that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01089-00259383-00259582": "given the public comment regarding the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01090-00259583-00259855": "languages that one other option for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01091-00259856-00260055": "today for the committee to consider", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01092-00260056-00260198": "would be to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01093-00260200-00260367": "move forward with approving the list of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01094-00260367-00260494": "words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01095-00260496-00260806": "but table the approval of languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01096-00260807-00261046": "until there can be more", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01097-00261048-00261142": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01098-00261144-00261455": "research or information gathering and we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01099-00261456-00261630": "can come back to you at the next meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01100-00261631-00261815": "with that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01101-00261816-00262087": "yeah and um on that just as you consider", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01102-00262088-00262303": "that um you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01103-00262304-00262447": "there are a number of things that are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01104-00262448-00262647": "true in our community anti-semitism is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01105-00262648-00262903": "true in our community right um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01106-00262904-00263175": "you know other uh uh issues that we're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01107-00263176-00263375": "dealing with are true in our community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01108-00263376-00263791": "um and and um you know as staff", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01109-00263792-00264047": "you know there's tremendous value in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01110-00264048-00264223": "feedback that we're that we were given", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01111-00264224-00264527": "today in writing um daily as we walk the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01112-00264528-00264823": "you know the streets of our city", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01113-00264824-00264951": "on what unity looks like for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01114-00264952-00265079": "community and language is really", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01115-00265080-00265295": "important so that separation of words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01116-00265296-00265471": "versus language is good and this will", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01117-00265472-00265575": "give us", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01118-00265576-00265799": "a moment to go back because we we can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01119-00265800-00265975": "review the data and there's one thing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01120-00265976-00266127": "about data", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01121-00266128-00266334": "and the logistics of how to be inclusive", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01122-00266335-00266606": "knowing there are some barriers within", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01123-00266607-00266895": "the structure itself right um and then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01124-00266896-00267087": "we can come back to the committee with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01125-00267088-00267430": "um with a sort of more defined way of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01126-00267431-00267687": "what the what the languages are whether", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01127-00267688-00267975": "it be most commonly spoken", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01128-00267976-00268191": "or whatever it might be but it gives us", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01129-00268192-00268358": "a moment to look at that in a different", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01130-00268359-00269023": "way", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01131-00269024-00269303": "if i have a question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01132-00269304-00269687": "so i'm i'm a bit confused it gives the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01133-00269688-00269934": "art and public places committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01134-00269935-00270182": "time it gives the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01135-00270183-00270447": "community advisory committee it gives a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01136-00270448-00270775": "staff who", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01137-00270776-00271015": "right it would give staff a moment so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01138-00271016-00271206": "that it's not just based on these are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01139-00271207-00271343": "the most commonly spoken second", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01140-00271344-00271623": "languages or first languages or um you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01141-00271624-00271910": "know languages spoken within santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01142-00271911-00271991": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01143-00271992-00272175": "you know it is from 2019 and we can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01144-00272176-00272423": "review what that um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01145-00272424-00272647": "what the criteria of the languages are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01146-00272648-00272903": "um is should it just be the list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01147-00272904-00273191": "um based on the um i forget what that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01148-00273192-00273382": "list is called um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01149-00273383-00273606": "but it's the language requirements for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01150-00273607-00273863": "the city right should it be that or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01151-00273864-00274127": "um or should there be other uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01152-00274128-00274327": "considerations", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01153-00274328-00274527": "yeah i think that that's what it does is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01154-00274528-00274782": "it gives staff time to prepare alternate", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01155-00274783-00275006": "ways of looking at language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01156-00275007-00275271": "opportunities for this project so what", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01157-00275272-00275391": "what was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01158-00275392-00275567": "our initial approach", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01159-00275568-00275815": "which was to identify the most commonly", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01160-00275816-00276063": "spoken languages as self-identified", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01161-00276064-00276358": "through u.s census bureau data", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01162-00276359-00276519": "in santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01163-00276520-00276863": "would be to say okay that is from a plan", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01164-00276864-00277167": "the city drafted in 2019", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01165-00277168-00277358": "we can look at that see if there's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01166-00277359-00277463": "updated", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01167-00277464-00277710": "data or see if there's another way we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01168-00277711-00277910": "can categorize", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01169-00277911-00278047": "how people", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01170-00278048-00278230": "identify through use of language in our", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01171-00278231-00278471": "community that would be providing an", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01172-00278472-00278679": "additional lens of viewing this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01173-00278680-00278830": "information", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01174-00278831-00279071": "and to be clear that is your option uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01175-00279072-00279255": "if you would like", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01176-00279256-00279495": "staff to do that we can do that so we're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01177-00279496-00279703": "just giving you options on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01178-00279704-00279871": "either going together with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01179-00279872-00280110": "languages and words separate with words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01180-00280111-00280295": "and asking us to review it that's up to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01181-00280296-00280647": "the committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01182-00280648-00280815": "i think it would be helpful if our", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01183-00280816-00281006": "committee could view that slide again", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01184-00281007-00281206": "with the recommended words and then the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01185-00281207-00281495": "languages of santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01186-00281496-00281679": "and then um kristen i think you do need", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01187-00281680-00281975": "to do the um or turkey for sorry the um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01188-00281976-00282127": "the motion so that you can have the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01189-00282128-00282367": "general discussion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01190-00282368-00282679": "great thanks for the reminder", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01191-00282680-00282863": "i make a motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01192-00282864-00283158": "go ahead melanie um i would like to make", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01193-00283159-00283375": "a motion to approve", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01194-00283376-00283510": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01195-00283511-00283799": "words and language as stated", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01196-00283800-00284095": "um the advisory committee took on the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01197-00284096-00284430": "task of following the criteria that was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01198-00284431-00284671": "set up and established i believe they", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01199-00284672-00284903": "did a thorough job with that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01200-00284904-00285543": "and um so i'm making that motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01201-00285544-00286271": "can i get a second", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01202-00286272-00286553": "second we can't have a discussion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01203-00286554-00286887": "[Music]", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01204-00286888-00287182": "sorry did we get a second from nathan", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01205-00287183-00287343": "could you just repeat that one more time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01206-00287344-00287543": "sorry", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01207-00287544-00287951": "i made a motion to approve it as said as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01208-00287952-00288063": "stated", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01209-00288064-00288351": "so that we can have a discussion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01210-00288352-00288591": "so that the words in the language that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01211-00288592-00288775": "were presented", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01212-00288776-00289127": "are proved and we can have a discussion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01213-00289128-00289351": "if it is second", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01214-00289352-00289975": "i'll second that motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01215-00289976-00290199": "great thank you we can move to a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01216-00290200-00290447": "discussion now at this point", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01217-00290448-00290606": "would anyone like to kick off the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01218-00290607-00290863": "discussion i'll reserve my comments for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01219-00290864-00291471": "the last", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01220-00291472-00291679": "and i confess i can't see everyone on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01221-00291680-00291919": "the same screen so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01222-00291920-00292615": "if you're raising your hand", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01223-00292616-00293079": "and please go ahead i am feeling unsure", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01224-00293080-00293182": "about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01225-00293183-00293430": "proceeding ahead and just pushing by all", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01226-00293431-00293615": "of this information without another look", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01227-00293616-00293767": "at the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01228-00293768-00293999": "um the list and how it came about and if", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01229-00294000-00294215": "there's another list or i would like", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01230-00294216-00294310": "another", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01231-00294311-00294519": "another pass by the staff so i i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01232-00294520-00294758": "wouldn't be approving both things today", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01233-00294759-00294951": "that's my gut right now so i'm just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01234-00294952-00295095": "gonna lay that out", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01235-00295096-00295279": "it's more complex than i thought it was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01236-00295280-00295375": "coming in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01237-00295376-00295599": "and i don't feel ready to vote it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01238-00295600-00295751": "through", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01239-00295752-00295879": "is that the kind of discussion i can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01240-00295880-00296127": "have right now said", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01241-00296128-00296287": "okay this one make sure i'm not saying", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01242-00296288-00297079": "to the wrong thing at the wrong time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01243-00297080-00297391": "thanks for kicking that off", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01244-00297392-00297679": "um i i can weigh in a little bit myself", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01245-00297680-00297758": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01246-00297759-00297919": "i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01247-00297920-00298119": "i agree with ann this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01248-00298120-00298310": "item is a bit more complex than i had", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01249-00298311-00298495": "originally thought it to be when i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01250-00298496-00298791": "received the information", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01251-00298792-00299079": "and i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01252-00299080-00299479": "i'm not sure", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01253-00299480-00299639": "about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01254-00299640-00299839": "approving the list of languages as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01255-00299840-00300134": "currently written um i do like the idea", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01256-00300135-00300399": "of going forward with a unified", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01257-00300400-00300671": "consensus on on our words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01258-00300672-00300806": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01259-00300807-00301127": "i do acknowledge that at this point the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01260-00301128-00301295": "information that we have in front of us", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01261-00301296-00301543": "did accomplish the tasks that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01262-00301544-00301791": "uh tara had stated of what they had set", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01263-00301792-00301895": "out to do", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01264-00301896-00302063": "it gathered", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01265-00302064-00302334": "recommended words from a community uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01266-00302335-00302582": "outreach opportunity both online and in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01267-00302583-00302679": "person", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01268-00302680-00302910": "i applaud the city for that effort", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01269-00302911-00303039": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01270-00303040-00303271": "as in terms of the list of languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01271-00303272-00303479": "from santa rosa that really was a point", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01272-00303480-00303671": "in time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01273-00303672-00303806": "survey or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01274-00303807-00304087": "capturing of the languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01275-00304088-00304167": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01276-00304168-00304630": "as reported by the u.s census and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01277-00304631-00304958": "i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01278-00304959-00305382": "i am cognizant of how", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01279-00305383-00305591": "big of a focal point this piece will be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01280-00305592-00305806": "sitting in the heart of courthouse", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01281-00305807-00306127": "square and i want to be very mindful of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01282-00306128-00306271": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01283-00306272-00306487": "that that courthouse square was designed", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01284-00306488-00306679": "to be the living room of our community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01285-00306680-00306895": "and as such it should be a welcoming and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01286-00306896-00307110": "celebratory space for all of our", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01287-00307111-00307271": "community members", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01288-00307272-00307519": "and would be amiss if", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01289-00307520-00307710": "uh our our piece", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01290-00307711-00307895": "the the piece that we're speaking about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01291-00307896-00308047": "today um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01292-00308048-00308271": "had a hand in creating any further", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01293-00308272-00308567": "factions or disfranchising um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01294-00308568-00308679": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01295-00308680-00308879": "from from a feeling of a strong", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01296-00308880-00308999": "community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01297-00309000-00309119": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01298-00309120-00309415": "especially when the piece is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01299-00309416-00309639": "so focused on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01300-00309640-00309871": "creating a sense of unity and community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01301-00309872-00310063": "within our space", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01302-00310064-00310239": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01303-00310240-00310615": "i do really like the words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01304-00310616-00310927": "unity community people diversity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01305-00310928-00311103": "kindness", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01306-00311104-00311254": "neighborhood", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01307-00311255-00311871": "city safety respect", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01308-00311872-00312247": "love peace care resilience family", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01309-00312248-00312558": "equality equity belonging and friendship", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01310-00312559-00312782": "i think that's a great list of words and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01311-00312783-00313023": "i i currently don't have any additions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01312-00313024-00313206": "to those or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01313-00313207-00313391": "any suggestions i i think that the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01314-00313392-00313567": "public outreach", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01315-00313568-00313951": "uh effort was was very complete in that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01316-00313952-00314047": "so i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01317-00314048-00314254": "applaud staff thank you for putting this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01318-00314255-00314630": "together", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01319-00314631-00314734": "melanie", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01320-00314735-00315119": "yeah i i just reiterate my point that i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01321-00315120-00315254": "just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01322-00315255-00315575": "i have the concern about disregarding", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01323-00315576-00315823": "what the community has said that they", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01324-00315824-00315943": "want", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01325-00315944-00316030": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01326-00316031-00316215": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01327-00316216-00316423": "because that's our charge", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01328-00316424-00316663": "and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01329-00316664-00317047": "we sent this out we got support from", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01330-00317048-00317358": "not support we got input from various", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01331-00317359-00317623": "groups and i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01332-00317624-00317863": "i do have an issue with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01333-00317864-00317982": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01334-00317983-00318303": "six people or eight people coming in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01335-00318304-00318406": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01336-00318407-00318623": "at the end of the process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01337-00318624-00319023": "and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01338-00319024-00319254": "derailing this project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01339-00319255-00319567": "not derailing it delaying it so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01340-00319568-00319671": "it's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01341-00319672-00319815": "you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01342-00319816-00320863": "my two cents", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01343-00320864-00321030": "yeah i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01344-00321031-00321206": "i'm muted", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01345-00321207-00321406": "my feeling is that uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01346-00321407-00321663": "my role here is to ratify a process in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01347-00321664-00321999": "my you know personal sort of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01348-00322000-00322095": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01349-00322096-00322247": "i don't know whatever sort of aesthetic", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01350-00322248-00322503": "paradigms i tend to operate on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01351-00322504-00322782": "independently really have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01352-00322783-00323023": "no bearing on this it's a question of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01353-00323024-00323230": "the process and we're at the end of that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01354-00323231-00323439": "process and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01355-00323440-00325791": "it's a yes or no vote", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01356-00325792-00326023": "so cherokee i think what you can do is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01357-00326024-00326215": "um you know there's a there's a motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01358-00326216-00326327": "on the floor", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01359-00326328-00326654": "put forward by vice chair jones carter", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01360-00326655-00326903": "and so if nobody is going to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01361-00326904-00327127": "put for and seconded by member uh as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01362-00327128-00327375": "darren i believe um if no one will be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01363-00327376-00327615": "putting forward a second", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01364-00327616-00327799": "motion or asking for a friendly", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01365-00327800-00328015": "amendment then i believe the motion on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01366-00328016-00328957": "the floor stands", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01367-00328958-00329367": "[Music]", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01368-00329368-00329510": "hi ann yes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01369-00329511-00329927": "i'm i just i i see both sides of this i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01370-00329928-00330119": "i totally agree with you um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01371-00330120-00330487": "melanie and nathan i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01372-00330488-00330703": "i'm i'm a much more kind of as a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01373-00330704-00330895": "personality i agree i'm going with my", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01374-00330896-00331278": "own gut and emotion by pausing because i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01375-00331279-00331487": "have seen us pause before this is not i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01376-00331488-00331623": "don't feel like we always are operating", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01377-00331624-00331799": "on a well this is the way it is and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01378-00331800-00331967": "we're here just to kind of stamp i feel", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01379-00331968-00332119": "like we actually do talk about things", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01380-00332120-00332303": "and we give ourselves a moment to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01381-00332304-00332519": "breathe sometimes when we need it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01382-00332520-00332799": "and so i'm not asking for a long break", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01383-00332800-00333030": "but i even sense from what and maybe i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01384-00333031-00333167": "intuiting and it's not true but i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01385-00333168-00333375": "sensing the staff wouldn't mind a day or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01386-00333376-00333519": "two to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01387-00333520-00333671": "kind of take another look at this and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01388-00333672-00333839": "get us some more info i'm sorry i know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01389-00333840-00334054": "it talks it prolongs things and i don't", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01390-00334055-00334239": "like i've been on committees and had in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01391-00334240-00334447": "question i didn't like it either so i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01392-00334448-00334582": "hear you on that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01393-00334583-00334895": "so our next meeting is february 7th", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01394-00334896-00335134": "right so i know that's and that means", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01395-00335135-00335278": "unless we were to meet", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01396-00335279-00335615": "closer for some reason quickly um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01397-00335616-00335839": "yeah i agree it's like the next standing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01398-00335840-00336015": "meeting yes and i'm not asking to add", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01399-00336016-00336287": "meetings this is not my motivation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01400-00336288-00336463": "to prolong although i'm just seeing that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01401-00336464-00336647": "there's kind of a dead end either we go", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01402-00336648-00336943": "and we we just close it down and we say", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01403-00336944-00337103": "there's sorry it was closed and it never", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01404-00337104-00337358": "was open or we say", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01405-00337359-00337503": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01406-00337504-00337639": "i just felt there was some question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01407-00337640-00338534": "about it so that's what i was responding", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01408-00338535-00338751": "jessica did you want to chime in yeah", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01409-00338752-00338975": "thanks um i thought maybe it would be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01410-00338976-00339215": "helpful if tara you could remind us of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01411-00339216-00339399": "what the different options were because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01412-00339400-00339527": "i thought at the beginning you said", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01413-00339528-00339710": "there was one to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01414-00339711-00339895": "one option to go ahead and approve", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01415-00339896-00340134": "everything with possible changes was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01416-00340135-00340575": "that true", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01417-00340576-00340751": "yes i said that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01418-00340752-00341071": "the options conclude um but there could", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01419-00341072-00341334": "be more um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01420-00341335-00341558": "approving the recommended list of words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01421-00341559-00341847": "and languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01422-00341848-00342054": "another option would be approving the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01423-00342055-00342278": "recommended list of words and languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01424-00342279-00342534": "with additions that are made through a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01425-00342535-00342847": "friendly amendment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01426-00342848-00343078": "and then i said at that time the third", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01427-00343079-00343327": "option would be to table this item till", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01428-00343328-00343630": "the next meeting and then later i added", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01429-00343631-00343839": "a fourth option which would be to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01430-00343840-00344054": "separate the approval of words and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01431-00344055-00344351": "languages so a second motion could be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01432-00344352-00344567": "made today", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01433-00344568-00344775": "or a friendly amendment could be made to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01434-00344776-00344871": "approve", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01435-00344872-00345175": "words today and table the approval of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01436-00345176-00345487": "languages to a future meeting once", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01437-00345488-00345678": "additional information is brought to the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01438-00345679-00346119": "committee", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01439-00346120-00346223": "so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01440-00346224-00346447": "quick clarifying question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01441-00346448-00346719": "uh when we're looking at the languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01442-00346720-00346934": "of santa rosa", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01443-00346935-00347047": "there are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01444-00347048-00347319": "a number in green and then the two", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01445-00347320-00347510": "languages in blue at the bottom we've", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01446-00347511-00348143": "got southern pomo and coast miwok", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01447-00348144-00348263": "would", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01448-00348264-00348734": "if approving as red would that include", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01449-00348735-00348991": "the addition of those two languages or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01450-00348992-00349319": "what", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01451-00349320-00349487": "yes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01452-00349488-00349695": "the recommendation is to approve all of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01453-00349696-00349887": "the languages that are listed there on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01454-00349888-00350082": "that slide", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01455-00350083-00350247": "okay", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01456-00350248-00350495": "if if you approve if we approve the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01457-00350496-00350758": "words just the words does that help the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01458-00350759-00351023": "artists in the process i mean", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01459-00351024-00351327": "does that gain anything for them or do i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01460-00351328-00351591": "don't think it does not really no i mean", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01461-00351592-00351830": "she still can't do her final design", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01462-00351831-00352054": "layout with all of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01463-00352055-00352191": "essentially have to think of all of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01464-00352192-00352447": "words and all the translations", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01465-00352448-00352695": "as design elements and she has to place", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01466-00352696-00352815": "them all", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01467-00352816-00352903": "on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01468-00352904-00353134": "a rendering of the piece covering all", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01469-00353135-00353399": "the surface area calculating the size", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01470-00353400-00353567": "calculating all the different", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01471-00353568-00353758": "translations will be in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01472-00353759-00353982": "the writing systems of those languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01473-00353983-00354423": "and so the different um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01474-00354424-00354591": "the different uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01475-00354592-00354806": "fonts required and all of that has to be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01476-00354807-00355047": "um design have to be designed so that it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01477-00355048-00355215": "doesn't really get us getting us", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01478-00355216-00355471": "anything no and in the in the scope of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01479-00355472-00355727": "things i mean i i understand the desire", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01480-00355728-00355919": "to keep this moving as quickly as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01481-00355920-00356215": "possible right and not delay further", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01482-00356216-00356454": "um in the scope of all of the delays we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01483-00356455-00356758": "have this one is probably going to cause", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01484-00356759-00356847": "less", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01485-00356848-00357071": "delay than like covid overall for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01486-00357072-00357295": "instance or fires or other kinds of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01487-00357296-00357527": "crises that we've dealt with so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01488-00357528-00357695": "i just want to give the committee the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01489-00357696-00357903": "time if there's hesitation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01490-00357904-00358182": "um and a desire to take more time to do", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01491-00358183-00358415": "this that you know there is not some", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01492-00358416-00358639": "looming deadline by which we have to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01493-00358640-00358791": "complete this or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01494-00358792-00359047": "we lose our chance to do it we have we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01495-00359048-00359254": "have some flexibility there it's just a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01496-00359255-00359399": "matter of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01497-00359400-00359606": "i i would i would say communicating with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01498-00359607-00359815": "the community on what the expectations", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01499-00359816-00360015": "are so that people know that it is still", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01500-00360016-00360199": "coming", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01501-00360200-00360391": "because i don't i don't i'm sorry nathan", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01502-00360392-00360503": "go ahead", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01503-00360504-00360806": "uh no you could this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01504-00360807-00361071": "the only thing i i'm thinking about is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01505-00361072-00361495": "how do you open this up again i mean", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01506-00361496-00361830": "you know if you go down that road of yes", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01507-00361831-00362054": "we're going to add in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01508-00362055-00362143": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01509-00362144-00362303": "hebrew", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01510-00362304-00362447": "russian", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01511-00362448-00362671": "japanese", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01512-00362672-00362982": "i think there were five others", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01513-00362983-00363071": "you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01514-00363072-00363358": "how how are you going to do that and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01515-00363359-00363527": "who's going to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01516-00363528-00363687": "say that we're not going to be in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01517-00363688-00363823": "same boat", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01518-00363824-00363991": "in a month", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01519-00363992-00364230": "when we vote again because some other", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01520-00364231-00364543": "group is feeling that they were left out", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01521-00364544-00364982": "i i just i don't see an end to this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01522-00364983-00365278": "i i totally understand that um that kind", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01523-00365279-00365375": "of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01524-00365376-00365615": "thought or fear that that may happen", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01525-00365616-00365934": "what i what i would say is that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01526-00365935-00366087": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01527-00366088-00366287": "as the initial", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01528-00366288-00366527": "kind of reasoning behind the selection", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01529-00366528-00366767": "of these languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01530-00366768-00367095": "were to equitably represent the most", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01531-00367096-00367351": "commonly spoken language in san rosa it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01532-00367352-00367615": "did leave out other important languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01533-00367616-00367854": "to san rosa's history or", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01534-00367855-00368078": "our cultural traditions so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01535-00368079-00368271": "that that's what i would say is that it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01536-00368272-00368527": "does give us i i don't anticipate", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01537-00368528-00368839": "opening up any other public widespread", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01538-00368840-00369030": "public outreach regarding adding", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01539-00369031-00369239": "languages to this list what i would", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01540-00369240-00369478": "suggest is that at a staff level and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01541-00369479-00369734": "through targeted outreach we can come up", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01542-00369735-00370023": "with another filter of looking at", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01543-00370024-00370158": "important languages that should be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01544-00370159-00370358": "included on this piece and bring that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01545-00370359-00370519": "information to the committee so that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01546-00370520-00370815": "then you can you can decide", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01547-00370816-00370903": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01548-00370904-00371030": "what to include", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01549-00371031-00371287": "and if if um because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01550-00371288-00371543": "vice chair uh jones carter i 100 here", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01551-00371544-00371702": "and this is why", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01552-00371703-00371943": "the list is what it is it does not take", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01553-00371944-00372054": "you to consider", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01554-00372055-00372263": "religion or it doesn't take it to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01555-00372264-00372367": "consider", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01556-00372368-00372639": "into consideration other things um you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01557-00372640-00372975": "know such as that um so if if we do open", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01558-00372976-00373271": "it up it would be incredibly helpful for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01559-00373272-00373534": "the um for the committee then to say", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01560-00373535-00373695": "okay these are the kinds of things that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01561-00373696-00373863": "we're thinking about i mean because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01562-00373864-00374078": "otherwise it's like to your point we're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01563-00374079-00374271": "back to the same place it's staff", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01564-00374272-00374599": "deciding an arbitrary thing like uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01565-00374600-00374678": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01566-00374679-00374830": "and i'm hesitant to use language because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01567-00374831-00375047": "i know that some people it might be uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01568-00375048-00375295": "you know more personal or concerning", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01569-00375296-00375502": "some people but say you know it's this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01570-00375503-00375734": "religion but not this religion or this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01571-00375735-00376199": "culture and not this culture um and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01572-00376200-00376334": "to your point you know the staff", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01573-00376335-00376471": "certainly doesn't want to be back in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01574-00376472-00376799": "that same um same place um so the list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01575-00376800-00376967": "that we provided", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01576-00376968-00377078": "is safe", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01577-00377079-00377295": "but if we do go back and consider it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01578-00377296-00377510": "what are we considering", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01579-00377511-00377671": "what are your recommendations for us to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01580-00377672-00378127": "consider as a group", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01581-00378128-00378295": "nathan go ahead", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01582-00378296-00378447": "i'm just wondering if we have a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01583-00378448-00378767": "methodology established for proofreading", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01584-00378768-00378943": "in the various languages that are going", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01585-00378944-00379230": "to be in the sculpture", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01586-00379231-00379406": "or is that on the artist", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01587-00379407-00379630": "no we have used a translation service", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01588-00379631-00379815": "that the city has a contract with to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01589-00379816-00379991": "make sure that native speakers are doing", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01590-00379992-00380167": "all the translations we're not relying", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01591-00380168-00380415": "on any kind of automated google", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01592-00380416-00380647": "translation service or anything", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01593-00380648-00381191": "cool thanks", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01594-00381192-00381423": "clarifying question i had", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01595-00381424-00381727": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01596-00381728-00381934": "if we were to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01597-00381935-00382127": "consider the addition of another", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01598-00382128-00382558": "language would all 15 words be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01599-00382559-00382839": "necessary for reproduction or do you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01600-00382840-00383015": "think that there's an opportunity to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01601-00383016-00383134": "select", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01602-00383135-00383310": "maybe five words that could be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01603-00383311-00383591": "reproduced in multiple languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01604-00383592-00383727": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01605-00383728-00384006": "just thinking of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01606-00384007-00384191": "the space that there is on the piece and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01607-00384192-00384271": "how", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01608-00384272-00384351": "we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01609-00384352-00384478": "have been told that it would be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01610-00384479-00384647": "impactful for there to be more", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01611-00384648-00384902": "opportunities for repeated words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01612-00384903-00385006": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01613-00385007-00385087": "just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01614-00385088-00385334": "thinking of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01615-00385335-00385582": "the opportunity to represent additional", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01616-00385583-00385878": "languages but also to um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01617-00385879-00386095": "keep the piece uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01618-00386096-00386223": "or to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01619-00386224-00386319": "kind of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01620-00386320-00386582": "think about how the end products will", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01621-00386583-00386902": "look", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01622-00386903-00387191": "um i feel like that gets into a lot of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01623-00387192-00387343": "arbitrary", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01624-00387344-00387463": "decision", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01625-00387464-00387558": "making", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01626-00387559-00387743": "however i do", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01627-00387744-00388182": "think that that's a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01628-00388183-00388471": "consideration that could be discussed by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01629-00388472-00388734": "the committee if we come back to you at", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01630-00388735-00389110": "the next meeting with additional", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01631-00389111-00389343": "layers of information about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01632-00389344-00389623": "language representation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01633-00389624-00389727": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01634-00389728-00389878": "perhaps", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01635-00389879-00390071": "through whatever additional data we can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01636-00390072-00390375": "find it will make sense to have certain", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01637-00390376-00390558": "languages represented by certain", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01638-00390559-00390791": "percentages on the piece based on the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01639-00390792-00391023": "population that speaks it or i don't", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01640-00391024-00391175": "there's a variety of ways you can carve", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01641-00391176-00391430": "carve all of this up obviously", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01642-00391431-00391623": "and i think that if there was additional", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01643-00391624-00391758": "time i think that that's something that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01644-00391759-00391895": "we could provide", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01645-00391896-00392158": "some options for you to consider", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01646-00392159-00392358": "not necessarily recommending one", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01647-00392359-00392534": "language be less represented than others", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01648-00392535-00392775": "but at least providing you with some", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01649-00392776-00393071": "statistical data data that would that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01650-00393072-00393215": "could help steer", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01651-00393216-00393487": "that discussion in in our interest as", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01652-00393488-00393782": "staff is just to retain the integrity of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01653-00393783-00393927": "the process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01654-00393928-00394215": "um so that it is not scuttle that the um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01655-00394216-00394375": "you know at the end with sort of new", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01656-00394376-00394582": "ideas so if if you do make those", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01657-00394583-00394830": "recommendations how do we um ensure that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01658-00394831-00394967": "we're retaining the integrity of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01659-00394968-00396143": "process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01660-00396144-00396439": "okay so consideration we still have the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01661-00396440-00396710": "original motion on the table which was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01662-00396711-00397063": "to approve as written", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01663-00397064-00397391": "is there um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01664-00397392-00397734": "any entertaining of an", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01665-00397735-00397919": "alternative method that they would like", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01666-00397920-00397991": "to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01667-00397992-00399527": "pursue with this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01668-00399528-00399687": "are we um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01669-00399688-00399934": "if there's no other motion or friendly", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01670-00399935-00400247": "amendment being proposed then i think", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01671-00400248-00400471": "the action would be to call a vote on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01672-00400472-00400927": "that original motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01673-00400928-00401175": "so we could put a motion out", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01674-00401176-00401334": "while the other motion's sitting there i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01675-00401335-00401495": "don't really know the correct yes you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01676-00401496-00401702": "can", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01677-00401703-00401878": "yeah you can either do a totally new", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01678-00401879-00402087": "motion or you can um ask for a friendly", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01679-00402088-00402319": "amendment which the um vice chair who", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01680-00402320-00402582": "made the uh the motion could either", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01681-00402583-00402806": "accept or reject", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01682-00402807-00402958": "um and if she accepted then we would", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01683-00402959-00403110": "vote on the friendly amendment if she", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01684-00403111-00403271": "rejects it then you'd have to go through", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01685-00403272-00403367": "the vote", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01686-00403368-00403678": "of the vice as as it's on the on the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01687-00403679-00405295": "floor", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01688-00405296-00405463": "could i make a motion for a friendly", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01689-00405464-00405806": "amendment that we approve the word list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01690-00405807-00405951": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01691-00405952-00406158": "ask the staff to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01692-00406159-00406367": "re-examine", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01693-00406368-00406495": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01694-00406496-00406830": "process of finding those languages and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01695-00406831-00406991": "we can look at that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01696-00406992-00407134": "in light of some other ones that have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01697-00407135-00407287": "been proposed if we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01698-00407288-00407478": "want to accept it we can just delay this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01699-00407479-00407654": "vote i'm not saying", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01700-00407655-00407991": "that i wouldn't still go with it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01701-00407992-00408310": "is that clear not right the motion is to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01702-00408311-00408606": "uh is to approve the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01703-00408607-00409143": "words only and to review the languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01704-00409144-00409534": "uh at the um at an upcoming meeting um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01705-00409535-00409743": "but then um we would also need the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01706-00409743-00410007": "criteria in which to yeah that's what i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01707-00410008-00410326": "do", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01708-00410327-00410630": "just point of clarification", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01709-00410631-00410878": "have they have um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01710-00410879-00411070": "is the meeting the guests at the meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01711-00411071-00411374": "today is that the um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01712-00411375-00411551": "the requests that have been made to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01713-00411552-00411695": "alter the language is that the only", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01714-00411696-00411855": "instance of requests being made to all", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01715-00411856-00412182": "through the language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01716-00412183-00412478": "yes um there there were i believe six", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01717-00412479-00412743": "emailed comments that were attached to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01718-00412743-00412878": "the agenda", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01719-00412879-00413110": "um along with the public comments that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01720-00413112-00413559": "we heard today okay", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01721-00413560-00413695": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01722-00413696-00413959": "just further clarification how many how", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01723-00413960-00414247": "many people participated in the original", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01724-00414247-00414439": "survey process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01725-00414439-00414639": "to gather words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01726-00414639-00415255": "about 400.", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01727-00415256-00415470": "the languages i should say", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01728-00415471-00415759": "were not we didn't receive widespread", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01729-00415760-00415926": "public input on the selection of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01730-00415927-00416230": "languages it was the advisory", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01731-00416231-00416391": "group", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01732-00416392-00416647": "that met regarding how to do this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01733-00416647-00416839": "engagement how to collect words how to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01734-00416839-00417030": "identify representation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01735-00417031-00417351": "of the community it was that group", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01736-00417352-00417670": "that saw the list of frequently used", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01737-00417671-00417878": "languages here in santa rosa and and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01738-00417879-00418182": "approved that and then added the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01739-00418183-00418678": "southern pomo and miwok to the list", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01740-00418679-00418895": "so there wasn't i mean there if you're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01741-00418896-00419207": "trying to consider public input level", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01742-00419208-00419414": "um there was not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01743-00419415-00419695": "a huge public input request", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01744-00419696-00419910": "for the languages it was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01745-00419912-00420279": "a staff and community advisory group", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01746-00420280-00420439": "discussion on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01747-00420439-00420583": "how to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01748-00420584-00420799": "best represent the diversity of san", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01749-00420800-00421207": "rosens", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01750-00421208-00421359": "i just want to make another statement", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01751-00421360-00421695": "just just a comment i still don't feel", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01752-00421696-00421855": "that adding these", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01753-00421856-00422087": "six or whatever if we took a moment to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01754-00422088-00422310": "really decided to six even if we didn't", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01755-00422312-00422470": "add them", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01756-00422471-00422631": "50 times or whatever time everything", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01757-00422632-00422735": "else was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01758-00422735-00422975": "is taking away from the other words i i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01759-00422976-00423183": "feel like the addition could only be an", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01760-00423184-00423351": "expanse of of the arms around the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01761-00423352-00423470": "community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01762-00423471-00423670": "and i don't think that's the question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01763-00423671-00423863": "okay question is what is it taking away", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01764-00423864-00424070": "from other people who have not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01765-00424071-00424327": "had no okay yeah no i was just adding", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01766-00424328-00424463": "another comment so i'm not allowed to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01767-00424464-00424727": "talk about that right now i get it okay", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01768-00424728-00424951": "no you can i just want to make clear", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01769-00424952-00425039": "that the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01770-00425039-00425303": "the concern from staff is not is not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01771-00425304-00425510": "that it's it our concern is who has", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01772-00425512-00425879": "access yeah knowledge to add things so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01773-00425880-00426055": "it's not that adding it where does it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01774-00426056-00426270": "stop i think that that is actually the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01775-00426271-00426503": "question that came up earlier okay yeah", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01776-00426504-00426727": "and i i respect that too so i'm not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01777-00426728-00426879": "trying to come over the top of just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01778-00426880-00427063": "that's kind of my gut of it it's like", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01779-00427064-00427214": "can we just include everyone and maybe", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01780-00427215-00427503": "that's really not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01781-00427504-00427679": "in light of i understand things can get", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01782-00427680-00427959": "way out of control and not be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01783-00427960-00428143": "equitable and set a bad precedent all", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01784-00428143-00428287": "those kind of things but on the other", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01785-00428288-00428510": "hand i kind of feel like there's room", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01786-00428512-00428751": "and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01787-00428752-00428959": "how could we make this more equitable", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01788-00428960-00429247": "and expand a bit but it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01789-00429247-00429439": "i'm trying to do a lot at one time i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01790-00429439-00429687": "realizing i'm not making it", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01791-00429688-00430918": "black and white so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01792-00430919-00431159": "it does sound like and you provided a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01793-00431160-00431343": "suggestion for a friendly amendment to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01794-00431343-00431487": "the motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01795-00431488-00431791": "to approve the words today", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01796-00431792-00432103": "and save the languages to another", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01797-00432104-00432287": "meeting right on the approval of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01798-00432288-00432455": "languages to another meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01799-00432456-00432695": "yes so the criteria which i didn't have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01800-00432696-00432855": "i don't have a criteria i felt like i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01801-00432856-00432991": "could really put out right now because i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01802-00432992-00433103": "don't feel", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01803-00433104-00433335": "like i totally understand how", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01804-00433335-00433639": "it was selected and i mean i do but i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01805-00433639-00433807": "just don't know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01806-00433808-00434039": "if this would be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01807-00434039-00434270": "nathan please take it away", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01808-00434271-00434583": "i i just want to be clear", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01809-00434584-00434831": "all of the submissions were", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01810-00434832-00435095": "uh were made in english were there any", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01811-00435096-00435318": "requests for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01812-00435319-00435510": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01813-00435512-00435735": "you know non-english languages to be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01814-00435735-00435959": "represented like like is that something", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01815-00435960-00436199": "that anyone attached to their submission", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01816-00436200-00436495": "or is that a purely editorial decision", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01817-00436496-00436847": "on the part of the staff and the artist", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01818-00436847-00437151": "uh no the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01819-00437152-00437407": "all of the outreach that we did", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01820-00437408-00437614": "was intended to gather", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01821-00437615-00437759": "words", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01822-00437760-00438022": "for the piece in english", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01823-00438023-00438231": "in any language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01824-00438232-00438399": "we were very clear that submissions", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01825-00438400-00438687": "could be put to us in any language i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01826-00438688-00438927": "think we only received a handful of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01827-00438928-00439031": "spanish", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01828-00439032-00439214": "uh entries", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01829-00439215-00439463": "the rest were submitted in english", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01830-00439464-00439683": "okay", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01831-00439684-00439943": "um the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01832-00439943-00440166": "suggestion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01833-00440167-00440495": "or or i should say the desire of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01834-00440496-00440566": "the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01835-00440567-00440663": "artist", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01836-00440664-00440951": "of the advisory group of all of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01837-00440952-00441143": "different planning bodies that have been", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01838-00441143-00441414": "a part of this project", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01839-00441415-00441599": "to uphold the original goals of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01840-00441600-00441799": "project to represent san rosa's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01841-00441800-00442007": "diversity", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01842-00442008-00442151": "and innovation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01843-00442152-00442483": "and to be a symbol for all community", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01844-00442484-00442887": "members that was has been a major part", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01845-00442888-00443166": "of all of the planning and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01846-00443167-00443343": "and has been a big", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01847-00443343-00443591": "uh kind of justification for the types", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01848-00443592-00443799": "of outreach and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01849-00443800-00444022": "recommendations we have made with this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01850-00444023-00444239": "project and so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01851-00444239-00444527": "in conversation with the advisory group", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01852-00444528-00444870": "it was determined that wouldn't it be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01853-00444871-00445103": "a great way to showcase san rosa's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01854-00445104-00445495": "diversity to honor all the different", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01855-00445496-00445687": "community members that live here by", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01856-00445688-00445863": "representing the languages that they", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01857-00445864-00446143": "speak and so that's where that came from", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01858-00446143-00446303": "that wasn't driven by the artist but", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01859-00446304-00446614": "obviously she wanted it to be a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01860-00446615-00446879": "main part of her project her other", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01861-00446880-00447103": "artworks that are very similar to what", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01862-00447104-00447391": "unum will will end up looking like", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01863-00447392-00447622": "have she's done this before", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01864-00447623-00447703": "she", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01865-00447704-00447895": "gathers she works with the community she", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01866-00447896-00448103": "gathers words and languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01867-00448104-00448270": "does the translations and puts them on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01868-00448271-00448414": "the piece so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01869-00448415-00448679": "this was obviously what she had in mind", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01870-00448680-00448855": "for the for the piece", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01871-00448856-00449063": "um and what i think the selection panel", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01872-00449064-00449263": "and the community responded to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01873-00449264-00449527": "when she was selected as the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01874-00449528-00449718": "artist for this piece", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01875-00449719-00449855": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01876-00449856-00450014": "i think that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01877-00450015-00450318": "when approaching how to decide what", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01878-00450319-00450510": "languages to to use", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01879-00450512-00450607": "it was", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01880-00450608-00450783": "it was really just well how do we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01881-00450784-00450991": "determine uh what languages are spoken", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01882-00450992-00451214": "here and so we went to the data and the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01883-00451215-00451455": "data pointed us in the direction that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01884-00451456-00451743": "ended us up making this recommendation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01885-00451743-00451918": "that doesn't mean that that's the only", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01886-00451919-00452247": "way to look at the question or this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01887-00452247-00452479": "information and so i think that that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01888-00452480-00452663": "where we are right now that if there's a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01889-00452664-00452927": "desire to look at it differently", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01890-00452928-00453103": "it would be helpful to know through what", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01891-00453104-00453270": "lenses you would like us to bring back", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01892-00453271-00453399": "information", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01893-00453400-00453703": "from right so is it is it cultural", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01894-00453704-00453959": "groups is it religions practiced in", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01895-00453960-00454247": "sonoma santa rosa is it um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01896-00454247-00454543": "is it not you know or what are the next", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01897-00454543-00454710": "if you'd rather just go back to the data", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01898-00454712-00454927": "what are the next five languages that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01899-00454928-00455166": "are on that list rather than", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01900-00455167-00455335": "what are the next five most common and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01901-00455335-00455487": "see what those are like", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01902-00455488-00455695": "there's that's the type of stuff that we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01903-00455696-00455895": "could really use your input on if", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01904-00455896-00456103": "there's a desire to to wait on the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01905-00456104-00456239": "languages and have us bring back more", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01906-00456239-00456495": "information", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01907-00456496-00456775": "that was very helpful thank you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01908-00456776-00457039": "i i my inclination is to move forward", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01909-00457039-00457247": "with the process i you know i think this", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01910-00457247-00457375": "is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01911-00457376-00457566": "i think if", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01912-00457567-00457759": "well yeah my inclination is to move", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01913-00457760-00458775": "forward", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01914-00458776-00459103": "i do i'm moving that way i i don't see", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01915-00459104-00459279": "taking this over and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01916-00459280-00459614": "and throwing a new plow through another", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01917-00459615-00459870": "field that we're gonna upturn languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01918-00459871-00459991": "in some other way i don't think that's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01919-00459992-00460175": "our work so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01920-00460176-00460287": "i'm", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01921-00460288-00460431": "can i ask the staff do you feel", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01922-00460432-00460543": "comfortable", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01923-00460543-00460631": "with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01924-00460632-00460799": "the vetting process for the languages", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01925-00460800-00460966": "does in hearing comments and coming", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01926-00460967-00461247": "around do you have a sense of this could", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01927-00461247-00461799": "stand and be solid for you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01928-00461800-00461879": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01929-00461880-00462110": "it's a hard question to answer i think", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01930-00462112-00462470": "that i stand behind the original", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01931-00462471-00462863": "data that we gathered and that a line is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01932-00462864-00463087": "drawn where we said what are the top 15", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01933-00463088-00463318": "languages spoken that that data is is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01934-00463319-00463518": "true and they don't feel like there's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01935-00463519-00463775": "anything wrong with that data however", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01936-00463776-00463991": "i don't think that it is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01937-00463992-00464110": "always", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01938-00464112-00464310": "a complete picture", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01939-00464312-00464575": "of our community and so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01940-00464576-00464735": "my", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01941-00464735-00464943": "if you want my personal", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01942-00464943-00465191": "two cents here i would say that i i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01943-00465192-00465399": "would take the time to look at it from a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01944-00465400-00465551": "few different", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01945-00465552-00465663": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01946-00465664-00465927": "from other perspectives and gather more", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01947-00465928-00466151": "information and bring it back i that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01948-00466152-00466239": "that's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01949-00466239-00466918": "my personal thanks feeling", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01950-00466919-00467175": "i had another clarifying question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01951-00467176-00467359": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01952-00467360-00467599": "when we see our list of languages there", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01953-00467600-00467839": "are a couple languages that have a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01954-00467839-00468239": "couple dialects or sub", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01955-00468239-00468487": "sub dialects within them for example", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01956-00468488-00468910": "chinese includes mandarin and cantonese", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01957-00468912-00469118": "i am curious", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01958-00469119-00469327": "would each of those languages be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01959-00469328-00469463": "represented", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01960-00469464-00469783": "represented equally um or would it kind", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01961-00469784-00470063": "of be an aggregate of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01962-00470064-00470366": "um i i might be getting too pedantic", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01963-00470367-00470634": "with this but uh i'm just curious on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01964-00470635-00470751": "[Music]", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01965-00470752-00470991": "how the artist intended to represent", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01966-00470992-00471118": "multiple", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01967-00471119-00471479": "dialects within one language", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01968-00471480-00471631": "we are still working with the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01969-00471632-00471870": "translation service to make sure that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01970-00471871-00472095": "they can provide all of the dialects", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01971-00472096-00472247": "listed they've already confirmed", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01972-00472247-00472510": "cantonese and mandarin so those would be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01973-00472512-00472775": "equally represented as two separate", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01974-00472776-00473063": "languages on the piece", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01975-00473064-00473303": "and then similarly for every other one", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01976-00473304-00473510": "as long as there's a native speaker", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01977-00473512-00474255": "translation that can be done", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01978-00474256-00474383": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01979-00474384-00474463": "yeah", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01980-00474464-00474639": "does staff", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01981-00474639-00474791": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01982-00474792-00475127": "do you have the sense that you could um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01983-00475128-00475310": "engage in the kind of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01984-00475312-00475543": "audit that you're talking about of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01985-00475543-00475910": "process uh without a formal", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01986-00475912-00476022": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01987-00476023-00476199": "friendly amendment to joan carter's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01988-00476200-00476470": "motion jones to vice chair jones", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01989-00476471-00476807": "carter's motion am i making sense", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01990-00476808-00477022": "like if you could do what you're talking", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01991-00477023-00477303": "about without a formal", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01992-00477304-00477495": "structure through the process that we're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01993-00477496-00477766": "engaged in now", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01994-00477767-00478079": "well if her motion is not amended and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01995-00478080-00478343": "it's approved as is then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01996-00478343-00478495": "i think that that's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01997-00478496-00478783": "that's where it ends right", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01998-00478784-00479022": "because there wouldn't necessarily be a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-01999-00479023-00479287": "desire to add more languages if it's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02000-00479288-00479422": "approved", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02001-00479423-00479575": "right", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02002-00479576-00479807": "right so my i believe what the process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02003-00479808-00480127": "is is um a vice chair uh you would have", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02004-00480128-00480391": "to either accept or reject remember", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02005-00480392-00480622": "baumgartner's a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02006-00480623-00480903": "friendly amendment if you reject it then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02007-00480904-00481279": "it goes to vote on your standing um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02008-00481280-00481422": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02009-00481423-00481518": "motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02010-00481519-00481751": "and if that fails then a new motion is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02011-00481752-00481903": "brought up", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02012-00481904-00482062": "and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02013-00482063-00482391": "and then that motion comes to a vote", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02014-00482392-00482518": "do we have to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02015-00482519-00482775": "does the friendly amendment have to be", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02016-00482776-00482887": "second", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02017-00482888-00483022": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02018-00483023-00483366": "i i think so yeah you're saying yes tara", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02019-00483367-00483583": "yeah i believe that that nathan because", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02020-00483584-00483791": "he seconded the original motion has to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02021-00483792-00484110": "also agree to the friendly amendment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02022-00484112-00484366": "i would agree to that", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02023-00484367-00484518": "i would agree to the friendly amendment", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02024-00484519-00484695": "and then so the question is vice chair", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02025-00484696-00484959": "uh do you um accept that friendly", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02026-00484960-00485159": "amendment and if not then we vote on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02027-00485160-00485479": "your on the amendment as it is i mean on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02028-00485480-00485727": "the um motion as it is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02029-00485728-00486007": "and no if that does not pass then we go", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02030-00486008-00486175": "to the second okay", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02031-00486176-00486327": "no we should vote", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02032-00486328-00486495": "okay so then we're at this point then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02033-00486496-00486655": "we're voting on uh vice chair jones", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02034-00486656-00486799": "carter's uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02035-00486800-00486966": "motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02036-00486967-00487191": "and only if that if that passes then", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02037-00487192-00487407": "that's that if it does not pass then a", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02038-00487408-00487599": "new motion is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02039-00487600-00487718": "is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02040-00487719-00487975": "put forward a step forward", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02041-00487976-00488518": "correct by somebody", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02042-00488519-00488751": "okay at this time", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02043-00488752-00489007": "before you i think um remember as darren", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02044-00489008-00489151": "had another question", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02045-00489152-00489351": "if push comes to shove and and we are", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02046-00489352-00489503": "not given um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02047-00489504-00489735": "and tara this is a little bit on uh you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02048-00489735-00489951": "know winging it a little bit um you know", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02049-00489952-00490159": "i think what we would do is talk with", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02050-00490160-00490583": "our equity officer and talk with our", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02051-00490584-00490775": "our public health planner who's looking", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02052-00490776-00490983": "at data", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02053-00490984-00491110": "on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02054-00491112-00491279": "between those two", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02055-00491280-00491518": "we would probably rely on data that they", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02056-00491519-00491703": "have and then bring forward something on", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02057-00491704-00491855": "terms of languages to see if they're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02058-00491856-00492087": "right if we're in the right path or not", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02059-00492088-00492366": "um but i don't think staff would uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02060-00492367-00492510": "short of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02061-00492512-00492710": "the weigh-in of those expertise the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02062-00492712-00492975": "expertise of those two people i have to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02063-00492976-00493183": "say i don't", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02064-00493184-00493351": "we could have a conversation on it but", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02065-00493352-00493518": "we would have to have some kind of", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02066-00493519-00493775": "formal thing in which in which we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02067-00493776-00493991": "understand what we're proposing to you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02068-00493992-00494318": "um if the vote doesn't happen that way", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02069-00494319-00494447": "if that makes sense", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02070-00494447-00494695": "um so sorry turkey for um i'll let you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02071-00494696-00494959": "call the vote now", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02072-00494960-00495470": "that is all right thanks for clarifying", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02073-00495471-00495695": "at this time i will call a vote for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02074-00495696-00495879": "original amendment or sorry for the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02075-00495880-00496143": "original motion", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02076-00496143-00496375": "uh to approve the recommended words and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02077-00496376-00496583": "languages to be included in unum's", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02078-00496584-00496847": "design for the imagine for the imagine", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02079-00496847-00497083": "art and courthouse square public art", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02080-00497084-00497383": "project eileen will you take a roll call", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02081-00497384-00497647": "yes chair keeper", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02082-00497647-00497870": "aye", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02083-00497871-00498047": "vice chair jones carter", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02084-00498047-00498175": "aye", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02085-00498176-00498351": "member found gartner", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02086-00498352-00498543": "dave", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02087-00498543-00498766": "member ed syrian", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02088-00498767-00499022": "i am", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02089-00499023-00499191": "the motion carries", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02090-00499192-00499431": "um with a a vote", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02091-00499432-00500222": "of three to one", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02092-00500223-00500431": "okay you guys good job if we could just", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02093-00500432-00500727": "take a moment it's difficult", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02094-00500728-00500999": "and i just want to say", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02095-00501000-00501175": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02096-00501176-00501375": "from my perspective watching you guys", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02097-00501376-00501614": "grow", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02098-00501615-00501910": "it is your conversation now", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02099-00501912-00502079": "this is the conversation that we should", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02100-00502080-00502351": "carry forward in our next", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02101-00502352-00502614": "programs in advance and i think this is", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02102-00502615-00502847": "an idea of the value", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02103-00502847-00503047": "of this group", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02104-00503047-00503335": "um and the value of your perspectives", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02105-00503335-00503614": "and i think um i know i and i don't want", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02106-00503615-00503807": "to speak for uh tara and jessica too", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02107-00503808-00504070": "much but um i definitely learned from", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02108-00504071-00504310": "this and from the concerns that you", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02109-00504312-00504447": "brought up and i think", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02110-00504447-00504670": "i think i hope that you all feel enabled", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02111-00504671-00504927": "for future discussions on uh when we", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02112-00504928-00505103": "bring these things forward and as we're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02113-00505104-00505351": "considering this in a new way at these", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02114-00505352-00505831": "project public projects in a new way", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02115-00505832-00505927": "yeah", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02116-00505928-00506103": "thanks to everyone for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02117-00506104-00506335": "being open about your thoughts on things", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02118-00506335-00506543": "i think that's kind of challenging to do", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02119-00506543-00506775": "in this format and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02120-00506776-00507062": "yeah i think it's really valuable i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02121-00507063-00507303": "really appreciate the space to process", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02122-00507304-00507455": "in the discussions and thanks for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02123-00507456-00507679": "listening and letting me not be able to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02124-00507680-00507759": "finish", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02125-00507760-00508351": "thoughts but it's helpful", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02126-00508352-00508479": "i echo", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02127-00508480-00508775": "uh sentiments from raisa and nathan and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02128-00508776-00509087": "anne thank you guys for again being", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02129-00509088-00509351": "open to an honest and um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02130-00509352-00509647": "vulnerable conversation we don't", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02131-00509647-00509903": "we don't always know how to proceed and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02132-00509904-00510135": "getting assistance from staff helps us", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02133-00510135-00510327": "kind of formulate how to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02134-00510328-00510462": "uh", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02135-00510463-00510710": "think holistically about what we're", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02136-00510712-00511083": "having a conversation", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02137-00511084-00511414": "about yeah this this made me think about", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02138-00511415-00511518": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02139-00511519-00511847": "projects moving forward and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02140-00511847-00512127": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02141-00512128-00512407": "our our involvement in the in the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02142-00512408-00512679": "process when things are being set up but", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02143-00512680-00513039": "not necessarily just on the the final", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02144-00513039-00513207": "end of it so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02145-00513208-00513422": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02146-00513423-00513614": "moving forward we might have some war", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02147-00513615-00513883": "questions so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02148-00513884-00514047": "um", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02149-00514047-00514287": "to kind of eliminate some of the", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02150-00514288-00514407": "unknown", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02151-00514408-00514951": "parts of the process so", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02152-00514952-00515158": "so that's our charge", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02153-00515159-00515566": "[Laughter]", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02154-00515567-00515903": "one on that note i would like to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02155-00515904-00516287": "close this item 4.1 unum", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02156-00516288-00516551": "uh checking in with staff i don't see", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02157-00516552-00516870": "any other items on our agenda today", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02158-00516871-00517087": "other than announcement for our next", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02159-00517088-00517343": "regularly scheduled meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02160-00517343-00517943": "which is february 2nd sorry february 7th", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02161-00517943-00518047": "and", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02162-00518047-00518327": "i greatly appreciate everyone's ability", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02163-00518328-00518495": "to", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02164-00518496-00518775": "speak up and to offer space for", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02165-00518776-00518879": "listening", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02166-00518880-00519191": "um thank you everyone and with that i", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02167-00519192-00519407": "adjourn today's meeting", "i2w-4qwlZQc-02168-00519408-00519784": "thank you hi everyone"}}, {"audio_id": "i2Otl3Xka0I", "text": {"i2Otl3Xka0I-00000-00000013-00000353": "hello and thank you for your service hi", "i2Otl3Xka0I-00001-00000354-00000602": "guys"}}, {"audio_id": "i2T49TArjEM", "text": {"i2T49TArjEM-00000-00000000-00030883": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00001-00030883-00031114": "so", "i2T49TArjEM-00002-00031116-00032283": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00003-00032283-00032385": "so", "i2T49TArjEM-00004-00032386-00033683": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00005-00033684-00033973": "um", "i2T49TArjEM-00006-00033974-00035323": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00007-00035324-00036483": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00008-00036484-00036717": "do", "i2T49TArjEM-00009-00036718-00039197": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00010-00039198-00040371": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00011-00040372-00040683": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00012-00040684-00040783": "so", "i2T49TArjEM-00013-00040784-00042939": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00014-00042940-00045267": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00015-00045268-00050048": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00016-00050049-00052926": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00017-00052927-00053711": "[Applause]", "i2T49TArjEM-00018-00053712-00055852": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00019-00055853-00057705": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00020-00057707-00060947": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00021-00060948-00063082": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00022-00063083-00063325": "do", "i2T49TArjEM-00023-00063326-00064482": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00024-00064483-00064915": "so", "i2T49TArjEM-00025-00064916-00067003": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00026-00067004-00072882": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00027-00072883-00073282": "do", "i2T49TArjEM-00028-00073283-00074282": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00029-00074283-00074428": "do", "i2T49TArjEM-00030-00074429-00075682": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00031-00075683-00075869": "do", "i2T49TArjEM-00032-00075870-00077082": "[Music]", "i2T49TArjEM-00033-00077083-00077606": "do", "i2T49TArjEM-00034-00077607-00077816": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i3nFn1SJClo", "text": {"i3nFn1SJClo-00000-00000002-00000127": "[Music]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00001-00000128-00000488": "wait", "i3nFn1SJClo-00002-00000490-00001914": "[Music]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00003-00001916-00004798": "[Music]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00004-00004799-00005352": "[Music]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00005-00005353-00005475": "[Applause]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00006-00005476-00009274": "[Music]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00007-00009275-00011910": "[Music]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00008-00011911-00012095": "so", "i3nFn1SJClo-00009-00012096-00017303": "[Music]", "i3nFn1SJClo-00010-00017304-00017512": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i43eQFbnCJU", "text": {"i43eQFbnCJU-00000-00000003-00000374": "I'm certain and the space event is out", "i43eQFbnCJU-00001-00000375-00000632": "for this room it's a slow rollout like", "i43eQFbnCJU-00002-00000633-00000890": "all of them are don't worry about if you", "i43eQFbnCJU-00003-00000891-00001094": "don't have it yet but just they they're", "i43eQFbnCJU-00004-00001095-00001232": "stupid and they like to roll it out", "i43eQFbnCJU-00005-00001233-00001574": "solely for no reason the game got bought", "i43eQFbnCJU-00006-00001575-00001826": "out by Flair Oh games so there might be", "i43eQFbnCJU-00007-00001827-00002063": "some changes coming into mystery em the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00008-00002064-00002338": "first change is that the devs new devs", "i43eQFbnCJU-00009-00002339-00002606": "and all the new publisher rather seems", "i43eQFbnCJU-00010-00002607-00002776": "to actually care about the game and is", "i43eQFbnCJU-00011-00002777-00003020": "answering comments and questions on", "i43eQFbnCJU-00012-00003021-00003290": "Facebook for the first time in about a", "i43eQFbnCJU-00013-00003290-00003454": "year and they're also going to fix the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00014-00003455-00003911": "juvenile Spadefish thing so I always", "i43eQFbnCJU-00015-00003911-00004090": "recommend if you can't find something in", "i43eQFbnCJU-00016-00004092-00004336": "the video guide check out my website so", "i43eQFbnCJU-00017-00004337-00004429": "I thought I'd you know show you", "i43eQFbnCJU-00018-00004430-00004694": "alongside this is my site you just go to", "i43eQFbnCJU-00019-00004695-00004847": "sur tap tap comm if you want to see the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00020-00004848-00005302": "guide scroll down here to the feed and", "i43eQFbnCJU-00021-00005303-00005483": "event fish and we'll just kind of follow", "i43eQFbnCJU-00022-00005484-00005816": "right along here so if you haven't", "i43eQFbnCJU-00023-00005817-00006065": "played any events before the basic loop", "i43eQFbnCJU-00024-00006066-00006383": "is that you need to tap bubbles from the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00025-00006384-00006644": "fish 20 times to power up mr. hermit", "i43eQFbnCJU-00026-00006645-00006931": "crabs mr. Krabs down here let me hide", "i43eQFbnCJU-00027-00006933-00007088": "this you can actually see it thanks", "i43eQFbnCJU-00028-00007089-00007139": "Parker", "i43eQFbnCJU-00029-00007140-00007334": "thanks for getting in my way mr. crabs", "i43eQFbnCJU-00030-00007334-00007589": "over here needs to get 20 taps and then", "i43eQFbnCJU-00031-00007590-00007769": "you cast the crab and then it's pretty", "i43eQFbnCJU-00032-00007770-00008137": "much just a loop of you cast the crab oh", "i43eQFbnCJU-00033-00008138-00008456": "wait first before anything at all what", "i43eQFbnCJU-00034-00008457-00008624": "you need to do close the main menu go to", "i43eQFbnCJU-00035-00008625-00008885": "the pilot menu and you need to buy the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00036-00008886-00009214": "die the costume and the theme don't here", "i43eQFbnCJU-00037-00009215-00009419": "they're all very cheap so don't worry", "i43eQFbnCJU-00038-00009420-00009563": "about the price of them just buy them", "i43eQFbnCJU-00039-00009564-00009724": "but start with the die cuz that gives", "i43eQFbnCJU-00040-00009725-00009920": "you the hermit crab then the other two", "i43eQFbnCJU-00041-00009921-00010237": "and then you just tap the bubbles", "i43eQFbnCJU-00042-00010238-00010463": "activate the hermit crab where it's you", "i43eQFbnCJU-00043-00010464-00010624": "know that button where it says collect", "i43eQFbnCJU-00044-00010625-00010774": "star candy will turn into lake you know", "i43eQFbnCJU-00045-00010775-00011177": "dance or whatever it is and it's pretty", "i43eQFbnCJU-00046-00011178-00011474": "pretty basic stuff so let's go right", "i43eQFbnCJU-00047-00011475-00011742": "down the list Mike my cat is", "i43eQFbnCJU-00048-00011743-00012029": "sting me assisting in like 50 air quotes", "i43eQFbnCJU-00049-00012030-00012312": "so let's uh let's just go through the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00050-00012313-00012456": "list this way shall we", "i43eQFbnCJU-00051-00012457-00012750": "so the moonlight puffer fine boy that he", "i43eQFbnCJU-00052-00012751-00013065": "is is not a hidden fish anyway the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00053-00013066-00013266": "Starlight sea slug what you need to do", "i43eQFbnCJU-00054-00013266-00013743": "is go to the shop tab and watch the ads", "i43eQFbnCJU-00055-00013744-00013980": "for the free farm materials free in like", "i43eQFbnCJU-00056-00013981-00014229": "50 potation marks just need to watch", "i43eQFbnCJU-00057-00014230-00014519": "those ads 5 times space box fish not", "i43eQFbnCJU-00058-00014520-00014868": "hidden by 5 puffers space starfish very", "i43eQFbnCJU-00059-00014869-00015102": "fine boy very pretty", "i43eQFbnCJU-00060-00015103-00015272": "share a photo of the star flower that's", "i43eQFbnCJU-00061-00015273-00015537": "part of the expand quest the expand", "i43eQFbnCJU-00062-00015538-00015975": "quest is the little thing over here at", "i43eQFbnCJU-00063-00015976-00016212": "the middle left here where you get the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00064-00016213-00016383": "spicy moon slice and stuff you just need", "i43eQFbnCJU-00065-00016384-00016509": "to take a picture of a couple items from", "i43eQFbnCJU-00066-00016510-00016743": "there all of those that those aren't", "i43eQFbnCJU-00067-00016744-00016926": "hidden so you can just read the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00068-00016927-00017096": "descriptions there", "i43eQFbnCJU-00069-00017097-00017352": "starlight Nautilus open mystery chest", "i43eQFbnCJU-00070-00017353-00017607": "three times space octopus with his", "i43eQFbnCJU-00071-00017608-00017892": "frickin laser beam reach level 5 of the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00072-00017893-00018018": "hermit crab you'll probably do that very", "i43eQFbnCJU-00073-00018019-00018269": "quickly always level up your hermit crab", "i43eQFbnCJU-00074-00018270-00018459": "as fast as you can it pays dividends", "i43eQFbnCJU-00075-00018460-00018705": "very quickly space Dumbo take five", "i43eQFbnCJU-00076-00018706-00018975": "photos of the flying UFO very cute best", "i43eQFbnCJU-00077-00018976-00019317": "Dumbo so far but buy a lot space penguin", "i43eQFbnCJU-00078-00019318-00019775": "owned 40 event fish just any 40 pretty", "i43eQFbnCJU-00079-00019776-00020136": "simple moonlight turtle create five", "i43eQFbnCJU-00080-00020137-00020355": "space penguins simple again for the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00081-00020356-00020691": "space ray use song of the moon 15 times", "i43eQFbnCJU-00082-00020692-00020886": "and have the moonlit turtle in your tank", "i43eQFbnCJU-00083-00020887-00021057": "while you use it 15 times so basically", "i43eQFbnCJU-00084-00021058-00021336": "just by just put one of these boys in", "i43eQFbnCJU-00085-00021337-00021578": "your tank keep casting on the moon it'll", "i43eQFbnCJU-00086-00021579-00021675": "happen eventually", "i43eQFbnCJU-00087-00021676-00021867": "starlight or fish take a photo of the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00088-00021868-00022028": "rocket that's again part of the expand", "i43eQFbnCJU-00089-00022029-00022453": "quest items moonlight jellyfish take use", "i43eQFbnCJU-00090-00022454-00022734": "500 sea urchins those are the farming", "i43eQFbnCJU-00091-00022735-00023061": "materials unlock those in the farm tab", "i43eQFbnCJU-00092-00023062-00023247": "which is part of the coral tab if you", "i43eQFbnCJU-00093-00023248-00023385": "haven't yet", "i43eQFbnCJU-00094-00023386-00023529": "you can spend them on anything you can", "i43eQFbnCJU-00095-00023530-00023679": "spend them on fusion fish or you can", "i43eQFbnCJU-00096-00023680-00023988": "spend them on event items also it seems", "i43eQFbnCJU-00097-00023989-00024180": "to be less than 500 I swear I spent way", "i43eQFbnCJU-00098-00024181-00024462": "less than 500 when I got it starlet", "i43eQFbnCJU-00099-00024463-00024747": "dolphin use delicious food 30 times with", "i43eQFbnCJU-00100-00024748-00024900": "moonlight jellyfish and the tank again", "i43eQFbnCJU-00101-00024901-00025229": "pretty simple just let's span that skill", "i43eQFbnCJU-00102-00025230-00025590": "the big boy moonlight whale look at how", "i43eQFbnCJU-00103-00025591-00025769": "fancy he is looks like a Final Fantasy", "i43eQFbnCJU-00104-00025770-00026181": "enemy buy one of each of the above fish", "i43eQFbnCJU-00105-00026182-00026460": "and own two took 80 total event fish", "i43eQFbnCJU-00106-00026461-00026625": "which won't be a problem at that point", "i43eQFbnCJU-00107-00026626-00026988": "the star prints very unexpected I feel", "i43eQFbnCJU-00108-00026989-00027141": "like they'd put a lot more effort into", "i43eQFbnCJU-00109-00027142-00027314": "designing these than they usually do", "i43eQFbnCJU-00110-00027314-00027567": "there's some totally original stuff in", "i43eQFbnCJU-00111-00027568-00027795": "this there's some neat stuff", "i43eQFbnCJU-00112-00027795-00028095": "his little star prints here who's got", "i43eQFbnCJU-00113-00028095-00028374": "his little sandy dome for his little", "i43eQFbnCJU-00114-00028375-00028743": "flower there that's you have to complete", "i43eQFbnCJU-00115-00028744-00029058": "the miraculous space quest which I'll", "i43eQFbnCJU-00116-00029058-00029195": "show you in a second the other one is", "i43eQFbnCJU-00117-00029197-00029475": "the red fox not to be confused with red", "i43eQFbnCJU-00118-00029476-00029751": "fox that's just that's an in-app", "i43eQFbnCJU-00119-00029752-00029892": "purchase you don't need to get it for", "i43eQFbnCJU-00120-00029893-00030111": "anything else it's sort of a separate so", "i43eQFbnCJU-00121-00030112-00030339": "juice base quest you got to go up here", "i43eQFbnCJU-00122-00030339-00030570": "tap the space quest thing and then", "i43eQFbnCJU-00123-00030570-00030764": "there's you know it tells you what you", "i43eQFbnCJU-00124-00030766-00030902": "need to do each step of the way there is", "i43eQFbnCJU-00125-00030904-00031080": "a full list of what you need to do on my", "i43eQFbnCJU-00126-00031081-00031602": "guide so let's just look at it so first", "i43eQFbnCJU-00127-00031602-00031764": "you need to equip starlight garden dye", "i43eQFbnCJU-00128-00031764-00031989": "very very simple you should have already", "i43eQFbnCJU-00129-00031989-00032264": "done that use the crab skill 30 times", "i43eQFbnCJU-00130-00032266-00032517": "that does take a little while so you can", "i43eQFbnCJU-00131-00032518-00032655": "see I've only done it eight times in the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00132-00032656-00033093": "last day for the third step you need to", "i43eQFbnCJU-00133-00033094-00033450": "collect 30,000 event currency which if", "i43eQFbnCJU-00134-00033451-00033609": "you have the crab fully upgraded that's", "i43eQFbnCJU-00135-00033610-00033996": "15 more casts so you know it's a grind", "i43eQFbnCJU-00136-00033997-00034290": "but not crazy by any means own four", "i43eQFbnCJU-00137-00034291-00034434": "kinds of fish with starlight in the name", "i43eQFbnCJU-00138-00034435-00034710": "for the next one and you need to make", "i43eQFbnCJU-00139-00034711-00034950": "five New Starlet dolphins anytime it", "i43eQFbnCJU-00140-00034951-00035247": "says make or buy a new thing in the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00141-00035248-00035481": "guide that means it doesn't count until", "i43eQFbnCJU-00142-00035482-00035640": "you've already unlocked this part of the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00143-00035641-00035871": "quest which is usually the case for", "i43eQFbnCJU-00144-00035872-00036093": "these then finally need to tap three", "i43eQFbnCJU-00145-00036094-00036246": "three hundred currency bubbles for the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00146-00036247-00036397": "jellyfish", "i43eQFbnCJU-00147-00036398-00036763": "I believe any jellyfish not just the not", "i43eQFbnCJU-00148-00036764-00036916": "just the new one from the event but I", "i43eQFbnCJU-00149-00036917-00037123": "could that could be wrong and then by", "i43eQFbnCJU-00150-00037124-00037399": "five new moonlight whales the total cost", "i43eQFbnCJU-00151-00037400-00037630": "for this event is fairly high the five", "i43eQFbnCJU-00152-00037631-00037828": "moon that whales alone will cost you", "i43eQFbnCJU-00153-00037829-00038047": "about a hundred thousand currency so", "i43eQFbnCJU-00154-00038048-00038260": "that's what that get thirty thousand it", "i43eQFbnCJU-00155-00038261-00038437": "sounds like a lot but it's unfortunately", "i43eQFbnCJU-00156-00038438-00038986": "not a lot barriers to progress are much", "i43eQFbnCJU-00157-00038987-00039301": "smaller in this one than usual I kind of", "i43eQFbnCJU-00158-00039302-00039457": "like that they spread out the ad watch", "i43eQFbnCJU-00159-00039458-00039817": "things like there's like watch five", "i43eQFbnCJU-00160-00039818-00040086": "material ads watch five you know", "i43eQFbnCJU-00161-00040087-00040335": "currency ads instead of like watch", "i43eQFbnCJU-00162-00040336-00040777": "literally what was it eighty I think or", "i43eQFbnCJU-00163-00040778-00040882": "no there was one that was like two", "i43eQFbnCJU-00164-00040883-00041236": "hundred and fifty casts there's yeah I", "i43eQFbnCJU-00165-00041237-00041419": "think in the freshwater tank there was", "i43eQFbnCJU-00166-00041420-00041626": "one the quiet required 300 AD watches", "i43eQFbnCJU-00167-00041627-00041899": "basically and so this seems much less", "i43eQFbnCJU-00168-00041900-00042019": "awful", "i43eQFbnCJU-00169-00042020-00042319": "like I said Flair Oh games is purchasing", "i43eQFbnCJU-00170-00042320-00042754": "the game and I think already is you know", "i43eQFbnCJU-00171-00042755-00042859": "think they're in the middle of the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00172-00042860-00043051": "transfer if there'll games was supposed", "i43eQFbnCJU-00173-00043052-00043195": "to be making the switch version of the", "i43eQFbnCJU-00174-00043196-00043657": "game and yeah hopefully that actually", "i43eQFbnCJU-00175-00043658-00044347": "materializes finally so yeah I think", "i43eQFbnCJU-00176-00044348-00044509": "this event is definitely better than", "i43eQFbnCJU-00177-00044510-00044692": "average considering what we've gotten", "i43eQFbnCJU-00178-00044693-00044833": "lately it's probably the best event", "i43eQFbnCJU-00179-00044834-00045100": "since I stopped completing events around", "i43eQFbnCJU-00180-00045101-00045484": "the Halloween tank event I would say", "i43eQFbnCJU-00181-00045485-00045610": "probably the best event they've had", "i43eQFbnCJU-00182-00045611-00046093": "since um maybe the pirate and Egypt", "i43eQFbnCJU-00183-00046094-00046312": "events were really good decent costs", "i43eQFbnCJU-00184-00046313-00046528": "nothing too ridiculous I really like", "i43eQFbnCJU-00185-00046529-00046912": "those but yeah that's pretty much all", "i43eQFbnCJU-00186-00046913-00047080": "there is to know check out the guide on", "i43eQFbnCJU-00187-00047081-00047290": "Sur tap tap comm if you missed anything", "i43eQFbnCJU-00188-00047291-00047497": "or anything needs clarification that", "i43eQFbnCJU-00189-00047498-00047695": "should always be the first place to", "i43eQFbnCJU-00190-00047696-00047941": "check I I use my own guide repeatedly as", "i43eQFbnCJU-00191-00047942-00048198": "I play these I it's", "i43eQFbnCJU-00192-00048199-00048324": "you know it's hard to remember", "i43eQFbnCJU-00193-00048325-00048708": "everything all at once so thanks for", "i43eQFbnCJU-00194-00048709-00049005": "watching if there's any new relevant", "i43eQFbnCJU-00195-00049006-00049190": "news on the Flair o games buyout", "i43eQFbnCJU-00196-00049191-00049490": "situation I'll probably do a video on", "i43eQFbnCJU-00197-00049491-00049943": "that it's not it's not a huge deal it's", "i43eQFbnCJU-00198-00049944-00050202": "you hear a buyout you think bad things", "i43eQFbnCJU-00199-00050203-00050349": "and the thing is that cheetah mobile", "i43eQFbnCJU-00200-00050350-00050577": "already was the soleus publisher that", "i43eQFbnCJU-00201-00050578-00050705": "bought the game away from its original", "i43eQFbnCJU-00202-00050706-00051036": "developers so the really bad buyout", "i43eQFbnCJU-00203-00051037-00051189": "situation has already happened we're", "i43eQFbnCJU-00204-00051190-00051458": "already in the worst case scenario we", "i43eQFbnCJU-00205-00051459-00051654": "can pretty much only go up from here", "i43eQFbnCJU-00206-00051654-00052004": "so I'm interested to see how it turns", "i43eQFbnCJU-00207-00052005-00052115": "out and the fact that they're actually", "i43eQFbnCJU-00208-00052116-00052391": "answering customer support seems to", "i43eQFbnCJU-00209-00052392-00052619": "indicate that things are going pretty", "i43eQFbnCJU-00210-00052620-00053144": "good so yeah cautiously very very", "i43eQFbnCJU-00211-00053145-00053357": "cautiously optimistic like more cautious", "i43eQFbnCJU-00212-00053358-00053634": "than optimistic but compared to before", "i43eQFbnCJU-00213-00053635-00054005": "it's still optimistic so hope you enjoy", "i43eQFbnCJU-00214-00054007-00054110": "the event", "i43eQFbnCJU-00215-00054111-00054779": "[Music]", "i43eQFbnCJU-00216-00054779-00055826": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i4g-WvbIuao", "text": {"i4g-WvbIuao-00000-00000042-00000262": "hello and welcome to a new video about", "i4g-WvbIuao-00001-00000263-00000484": "my studio light", "i4g-WvbIuao-00002-00000486-00000761": "I want to display the IP address", "i4g-WvbIuao-00003-00000762-00001061": "of course I could do a static IP address", "i4g-WvbIuao-00004-00001062-00001223": "as well", "i4g-WvbIuao-00005-00001224-00001493": "however I want to I want to present the", "i4g-WvbIuao-00006-00001494-00001841": "address to the user because I have a", "i4g-WvbIuao-00007-00001842-00002110": "display I want to try", "i4g-WvbIuao-00008-00002111-00002363": "so I'll try it with this what which", "i4g-WvbIuao-00009-00002364-00002621": "display do I have well this one here", "i4g-WvbIuao-00010-00002622-00002860": "look at that this is the display I'm", "i4g-WvbIuao-00011-00002861-00003187": "going to use it's an", "i4g-WvbIuao-00012-00003188-00003725": "0.93 I think inch almost one inch", "i4g-WvbIuao-00013-00003726-00004025": "um", "i4g-WvbIuao-00014-00004026-00004169": "OLED", "i4g-WvbIuao-00015-00004170-00004375": "organic LED", "i4g-WvbIuao-00016-00004376-00004786": "display and I want to use it it has four", "i4g-WvbIuao-00017-00004787-00005122": "pins plus minus for power supply and", "i4g-WvbIuao-00018-00005123-00005651": "then we have this scl and SDA pins so", "i4g-WvbIuao-00019-00005652-00006022": "it's a pass protocol from there so it", "i4g-WvbIuao-00020-00006023-00006359": "already looks like we would need a", "i4g-WvbIuao-00021-00006360-00006653": "library of course but before we use the", "i4g-WvbIuao-00022-00006654-00006833": "library we have to connect it in a", "i4g-WvbIuao-00023-00006834-00007151": "certain way so plus and minus is", "i4g-WvbIuao-00024-00007152-00007481": "hopefully clear I'm going to use three", "i4g-WvbIuao-00025-00007481-00007751": "to three volt here for plus of course", "i4g-WvbIuao-00026-00007752-00008335": "because I'm using", "i4g-WvbIuao-00027-00008336-00008723": "esp32 so that's plus good", "i4g-WvbIuao-00028-00008724-00008860": "minus", "i4g-WvbIuao-00029-00008861-00010264": "Grant", "i4g-WvbIuao-00030-00010265-00010546": "okay here we go and then I have a", "i4g-WvbIuao-00031-00010547-00010871": "problem not really a problem but this", "i4g-WvbIuao-00032-00010872-00011338": "sdl and scl lines are here 30 21 and 22", "i4g-WvbIuao-00033-00011339-00011603": "and of course I'm using one of them as", "i4g-WvbIuao-00034-00011604-00012017": "output yeah so I am now switching the", "i4g-WvbIuao-00035-00012018-00012187": "output to", "i4g-WvbIuao-00036-00012188-00012533": "25 why not", "i4g-WvbIuao-00037-00012534-00012943": "and I'm using here twin", "i4g-WvbIuao-00038-00012944-00013277": "22 and 21", "i4g-WvbIuao-00039-00013278-00013997": "this is 21. the green one is 21. 21 is", "i4g-WvbIuao-00040-00013997-00014836": "the clock line I think", "i4g-WvbIuao-00041-00014837-00015341": "21 is SDA the data line is the a", "i4g-WvbIuao-00042-00015341-00015701": "and 22", "i4g-WvbIuao-00043-00015702-00015935": "here clock", "i4g-WvbIuao-00044-00015936-00016199": "is the clock line for the bus", "i4g-WvbIuao-00045-00016200-00016672": "scl", "i4g-WvbIuao-00046-00016673-00017021": "okay and now they say", "i4g-WvbIuao-00047-00017022-00017519": "that's the how to set up", "i4g-WvbIuao-00048-00017520-00017855": "all right so let's try this", "i4g-WvbIuao-00049-00017856-00018341": "let's try this let's program this", "i4g-WvbIuao-00050-00018342-00018575": "all right so at the computer we are", "i4g-WvbIuao-00051-00018576-00018827": "going to use a library because I", "i4g-WvbIuao-00052-00018828-00019025": "honestly don't know how this is", "i4g-WvbIuao-00053-00019026-00019414": "connected i2c okay it's a i2c protocol", "i4g-WvbIuao-00054-00019415-00019672": "however there are libraries out there", "i4g-WvbIuao-00055-00019673-00019919": "and I'm using a library which is from", "i4g-WvbIuao-00056-00019920-00020458": "Adafruit uh and it's called SSD 1306", "i4g-WvbIuao-00057-00020459-00020836": "because it's a SSD 1306 display so I am", "i4g-WvbIuao-00058-00020837-00021130": "opening now the manage libraries the", "i4g-WvbIuao-00059-00021131-00021358": "library manager", "i4g-WvbIuao-00060-00021359-00021955": "and shell look for this SSD 1306", "i4g-WvbIuao-00061-00021956-00022444": "SSD 1306", "i4g-WvbIuao-00062-00022445-00022589": "this one", "i4g-WvbIuao-00063-00022590-00023135": "latest version yes install", "i4g-WvbIuao-00064-00023136-00023297": "would you like to install all the", "i4g-WvbIuao-00065-00023298-00023771": "missing dependencies yes install all", "i4g-WvbIuao-00066-00023772-00024005": "this is good", "i4g-WvbIuao-00067-00024006-00024250": "so we have installed this now", "i4g-WvbIuao-00068-00024251-00024730": "and actually there we are for sure", "i4g-WvbIuao-00069-00024731-00025192": "they are for sure some demos examples", "i4g-WvbIuao-00070-00025193-00025690": "where is this", "i4g-WvbIuao-00071-00025691-00026117": "SSD", "i4g-WvbIuao-00072-00026118-00026651": "that's the correct one", "i4g-WvbIuao-00073-00026652-00027196": "ah just uploaded", "i4g-WvbIuao-00074-00027197-00027490": "is everything correct I will just upload", "i4g-WvbIuao-00075-00027491-00028096": "this and look what is happening", "i4g-WvbIuao-00076-00028097-00029764": "nothing", "i4g-WvbIuao-00077-00029766-00031235": "hmm", "i4g-WvbIuao-00078-00031236-00031745": "no", "i4g-WvbIuao-00079-00031745-00031979": "hello", "i4g-WvbIuao-00080-00031980-00032302": "hmm", "i4g-WvbIuao-00081-00032303-00032608": "this is not working", "i4g-WvbIuao-00082-00032610-00033029": "maybe it's the", "i4g-WvbIuao-00083-00033030-00033323": "display", "i4g-WvbIuao-00084-00033324-00033802": "ah maybe it's the address", "i4g-WvbIuao-00085-00033803-00034168": "maybe it's Tetris", "i4g-WvbIuao-00086-00034169-00034661": "where is the address", "i4g-WvbIuao-00087-00034662-00035074": "what is written here 7B 7B", "i4g-WvbIuao-00088-00035075-00035524": "that's bro that's probably the case", "i4g-WvbIuao-00089-00035525-00035915": "here is the address and I think I have", "i4g-WvbIuao-00090-00035916-00036761": "to adapt it", "i4g-WvbIuao-00091-00036762-00037618": "I'm not sure", "i4g-WvbIuao-00092-00037619-00037996": "is it", "i4g-WvbIuao-00093-00037997-00038596": "no", "i4g-WvbIuao-00094-00038597-00038659": "no", "i4g-WvbIuao-00095-00038660-00039305": "so it's not that easy", "i4g-WvbIuao-00096-00039306-00040024": "use a different panel", "i4g-WvbIuao-00097-00040025-00040295": "oh let's go seven eight it's I think", "i4g-WvbIuao-00098-00040296-00040529": "it's called seven eight not seven b here", "i4g-WvbIuao-00099-00040530-00040727": "it looks like seven", "i4g-WvbIuao-00100-00040728-00041135": "p u seven eight ah let's try it", "i4g-WvbIuao-00101-00041136-00041440": "let's try eight as well", "i4g-WvbIuao-00102-00041441-00041830": "there's nothing to lose right", "i4g-WvbIuao-00103-00041831-00042239": "and if I cannot manage now then I will", "i4g-WvbIuao-00104-00042240-00042533": "try to find there is a", "i4g-WvbIuao-00105-00042534-00042839": "there is a thing", "i4g-WvbIuao-00106-00042840-00043265": "there's a thing called i2c Monitor and", "i4g-WvbIuao-00107-00043266-00043523": "then I will have a look what addresses", "i4g-WvbIuao-00108-00043524-00043817": "we can find", "i4g-WvbIuao-00109-00043818-00044207": "doesn't look too good", "i4g-WvbIuao-00110-00044208-00044651": "I hope this is even the correct", "i4g-WvbIuao-00111-00044652-00045085": "correct panel", "i4g-WvbIuao-00112-00045086-00046774": "ah it's always the same", "i4g-WvbIuao-00113-00046775-00047195": "no nothing all right so let's open", "i4g-WvbIuao-00114-00047196-00047561": "another example", "i4g-WvbIuao-00115-00047562-00047795": "i2c", "i4g-WvbIuao-00116-00047796-00049895": "wire", "i4g-WvbIuao-00117-00049896-00050183": "here we have something", "i4g-WvbIuao-00118-00050184-00050405": "file new", "i4g-WvbIuao-00119-00050406-00050968": "cope with this", "i4g-WvbIuao-00120-00050969-00051257": "upload", "i4g-WvbIuao-00121-00051258-00052187": "I don't need save", "i4g-WvbIuao-00122-00052188-00052691": "3C it's 3C", "i4g-WvbIuao-00123-00052691-00052882": "I think this was already", "i4g-WvbIuao-00124-00052883-00053237": "written all right", "i4g-WvbIuao-00125-00053238-00053404": "3C", "i4g-WvbIuao-00126-00053405-00054604": "upload this again", "i4g-WvbIuao-00127-00054605-00055409": "yes", "i4g-WvbIuao-00128-00055410-00055799": "look", "i4g-WvbIuao-00129-00055800-00056380": "something is happening", "i4g-WvbIuao-00130-00056382-00056507": "all right", "i4g-WvbIuao-00131-00056508-00056849": "so it is working so it is working", "i4g-WvbIuao-00132-00056850-00057088": "it is working I just have to find out", "i4g-WvbIuao-00133-00057089-00057563": "how to how to to to print", "i4g-WvbIuao-00134-00057564-00057791": "hahaha", "i4g-WvbIuao-00135-00057791-00058276": "all right finally so that's it 3C 3C is", "i4g-WvbIuao-00136-00058277-00058444": "the address it's good that there is", "i4g-WvbIuao-00137-00058445-00059087": "printed 7B 7 8 at the end", "i4g-WvbIuao-00138-00059088-00059441": "that's that's a nice print yeah it's", "i4g-WvbIuao-00139-00059441-00059891": "just confusing", "i4g-WvbIuao-00140-00059891-00060244": "or", "i4g-WvbIuao-00141-00060245-00060671": "okay so we got this display working and", "i4g-WvbIuao-00142-00060672-00060953": "now we'll", "i4g-WvbIuao-00143-00060954-00061475": "I will start", "i4g-WvbIuao-00144-00061476-00063953": "last version", "i4g-WvbIuao-00145-00063954-00064180": "and I will try to understand how this", "i4g-WvbIuao-00146-00064182-00064691": "code is working", "i4g-WvbIuao-00147-00064691-00064900": "yes", "i4g-WvbIuao-00148-00064901-00065116": "I will do and this I will show you next", "i4g-WvbIuao-00149-00065117-00065441": "video right for this time", "i4g-WvbIuao-00150-00065441-00065656": "thank you very much for listening", "i4g-WvbIuao-00151-00065657-00065948": "goodbye"}}, {"audio_id": "i4rhRP4OOzU", "text": {"i4rhRP4OOzU-00000-00000016-00000254": "i think oh i think when the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00001-00000256-00000438": "internet died", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00002-00000440-00000751": "yeah i was talking about being in um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00003-00000752-00000911": "in graduate school because i went back", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00004-00000911-00001207": "to school so that i could refocus on my", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00005-00001208-00001487": "studio art practice and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00006-00001488-00001687": "it's like not just calligraphy that i'm", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00007-00001688-00001863": "interested in it's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00008-00001864-00002134": "it's like using calligraphy to approach", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00009-00002135-00002607": "ecology and to approach like a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00010-00002608-00002926": "language from a dc well human language", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00011-00002927-00003215": "as a decentralized concept and you know", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00012-00003215-00003447": "i have all of these sort of lofty but", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00013-00003447-00003703": "very grounded ideals that i wanted to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00014-00003704-00003895": "explore with that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00015-00003896-00004022": "and um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00016-00004023-00004279": "that's i guess that's like my niche", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00017-00004280-00004479": "which is a pretty normal thing to have", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00018-00004480-00004791": "as a visual artist and in the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00019-00004792-00005022": "art world of today artists are really", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00020-00005023-00005295": "encouraged to to sort of find that niche", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00021-00005296-00005415": "and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00022-00005416-00005831": "um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00023-00005832-00005999": "it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00024-00006000-00006263": "or but also explore it also explore it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00025-00006264-00006351": "right", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00026-00006352-00006575": "well what do you what are those lofty", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00027-00006576-00006742": "ideals that you're talking about like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00028-00006743-00006919": "what it what do you what are you trying", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00029-00006920-00007110": "to do with that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00030-00007111-00007327": "i mean", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00031-00007328-00007567": "completely destabilize the system as it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00032-00007568-00007846": "is like yeah um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00033-00007847-00007959": "i", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00034-00007959-00008142": "well one of the reasons that i've been", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00035-00008143-00008391": "enjoying your work so much is that you", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00036-00008392-00008735": "have so many interesting uh leftists on", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00037-00008736-00008831": "and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00038-00008832-00009039": "i've been influenced by", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00039-00009040-00009174": "um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00040-00009175-00009439": "like anarcho-primitivist theory and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00041-00009440-00009591": "thought and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00042-00009592-00009839": "uh also all sorts of good stuff for a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00043-00009840-00010238": "very long time and i i i think i'm", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00044-00010239-00010406": "trying to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00045-00010407-00010695": "reckon with some of that uh", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00046-00010696-00010838": "through", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00047-00010839-00011095": "well it's in my work it's like poetry", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00048-00011096-00011455": "but it's also the inclusion of some of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00049-00011456-00011759": "this theory and the way that this theory", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00050-00011760-00012031": "sort of gets explained both in the like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00051-00012032-00012214": "the oral tradition but also down on the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00052-00012215-00012351": "page", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00053-00012352-00012446": "um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00054-00012447-00012623": "and then you know the power of visual", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00055-00012624-00012855": "art is to take these things that are a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00056-00012856-00013022": "little bit hard to wrap one's head", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00057-00013023-00013263": "around or are difficult to say in a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00058-00013263-00013407": "simple phrase", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00059-00013408-00013591": "and make that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00060-00013591-00013838": "sort of visible even if not", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00061-00013840-00014083": "fully", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00062-00014084-00014391": "legible as an image and then of course", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00063-00014391-00014671": "we have incredible visual processing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00064-00014672-00014815": "ability", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00065-00014816-00015238": "as humans so it's like leaning into", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00066-00015240-00015391": "leaning into all of the meaning that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00067-00015391-00015575": "happens outside of our language but", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00068-00015576-00015783": "using language as like a kind of primary", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00069-00015784-00016079": "focus point so the ideals have to do", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00070-00016080-00016386": "with yeah i mean it's entice system it's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00071-00016387-00016599": "anti-capitalism it's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00072-00016600-00016703": "um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00073-00016704-00016919": "and it's not just anti there's sort of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00074-00016920-00017055": "this", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00075-00017056-00017215": "feeling that there's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00076-00017216-00017375": "something to stand for and not just", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00077-00017376-00017711": "against like i call my my paintings um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00078-00017712-00017975": "gaia illuminations", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00079-00017976-00018207": "it's a shorthand i came up with when i", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00080-00018208-00018327": "was in school", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00081-00018328-00018503": "um i'm not", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00082-00018504-00018847": "like a devotee of the deity", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00083-00018848-00018999": "gaia", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00084-00019000-00019239": "but it was like sort of are you familiar", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00085-00019240-00019527": "with james lovelock yeah the guy hype", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00086-00019528-00019711": "guy yeah the guy i had yeah so it was", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00087-00019712-00019975": "sort of referencing that and letting it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00088-00019976-00020150": "be something that wanted to be both", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00089-00020151-00020343": "mythic and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00090-00020344-00020583": "um i guess like even empirical at the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00091-00020584-00020807": "same time", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00092-00020808-00020950": "okay", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00093-00020951-00021278": "that makes sense i think so i mean", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00094-00021279-00021439": "yeah well it's something to be", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00095-00021440-00021575": "i think that this is interesting because", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00096-00021576-00022094": "i think language is such a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00097-00022095-00022247": "it's like either you approach it like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00098-00022248-00022414": "when i think of calligraphy and i think", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00099-00022415-00022639": "of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00100-00022640-00022822": "this sort of classic", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00101-00022823-00023158": "idea of of taking the written word", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00102-00023159-00023511": "and artistically representing it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00103-00023512-00023775": "you know i think of these old tomes with", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00104-00023776-00023975": "this incredible you know like like one", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00105-00023976-00024191": "of the my favorite things i saw when i i", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00106-00024192-00024367": "went to um i was talking to my my", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00107-00024368-00024503": "partner about this the other day i went", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00108-00024504-00024622": "to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00109-00024623-00024767": "talk about how i went to when i was in", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00110-00024768-00024911": "new york", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00111-00024912-00025111": "last it was years and years ago but i", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00112-00025112-00025430": "went with my sister we went to the met", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00113-00025431-00025599": "and and i was just explaining like being", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00114-00025600-00025702": "almost", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00115-00025704-00025974": "center sensorially overloaded walking in", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00116-00025975-00026143": "there because there's like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00117-00026144-00026262": "you're like you're standing in front of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00118-00026263-00026455": "these like incredible works of art but", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00119-00026456-00026679": "there's so many of them", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00120-00026680-00026846": "and you can't really appreciate", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00121-00026847-00026974": "something when there's so much of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00122-00026975-00027087": "something", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00123-00027088-00027214": "it's like you're standing in front of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00124-00027216-00027358": "like i saw some paintings i really", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00125-00027360-00027535": "wanted to see but it was like crowded", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00126-00027536-00027679": "around with a bunch of other and it was", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00127-00027680-00027862": "just too much", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00128-00027863-00028151": "and uh but there was one section of the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00129-00028152-00028446": "of the met which was middle eastern", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00130-00028447-00028711": "uh art and so there were oh yeah their", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00131-00028712-00028911": "illuminated manuscripts are incredible", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00132-00028912-00029111": "yeah yeah exactly and i didn't know that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00133-00029112-00029270": "that would be there i just i think it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00134-00029272-00029518": "was one of the first", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00135-00029519-00029743": "rooms or areas that we just walked into", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00136-00029744-00029887": "and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00137-00029888-00030055": "and yeah it was like standing in front", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00138-00030056-00030239": "of something that i felt was", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00139-00030239-00030358": "the illuminati the illuminated", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00140-00030360-00030558": "manuscripts there were just these", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00141-00030560-00030727": "like arabic", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00142-00030727-00030943": "from like the 16th century or something", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00143-00030944-00031183": "these giant books", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00144-00031183-00031351": "and um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00145-00031352-00031639": "you know i can understand", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00146-00031639-00031862": "the sacredness of the written word when", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00147-00031863-00032118": "there's that much intention and thought", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00148-00032119-00032246": "put into", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00149-00032247-00032590": "producing something like that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00150-00032591-00032855": "but at the same time there's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00151-00032856-00033071": "something about the written word", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00152-00033072-00033351": "it defines and categorizes", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00153-00033352-00033599": "the world our reality in such a way that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00154-00033600-00033895": "it actually can desacralize or or not", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00155-00033896-00034127": "even really profane but but you know it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00156-00034128-00034390": "turns something into a an idea that's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00157-00034391-00034671": "contained within a definition", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00158-00034672-00034855": "and so", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00159-00034856-00035071": "there's this contradictory aspect when i", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00160-00035072-00035262": "think of you said an anarcho-primitivist", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00161-00035263-00035399": "and you're thinking about well where was", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00162-00035400-00035543": "the turn", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00163-00035544-00035790": "when human beings started to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00164-00035791-00036046": "become what they are today", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00165-00036047-00036223": "some people go back to the beginning of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00166-00036224-00036383": "agriculture you know there's always", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00167-00036384-00036543": "there the industrial revolution more", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00168-00036544-00036767": "frequent more recently", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00169-00036768-00036990": "uh but then you have like john zurzan", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00170-00036991-00037167": "who's like well it was when human beings", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00171-00037168-00037374": "started to symbolize the world around", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00172-00037375-00037630": "them and started to like orally and then", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00173-00037631-00037783": "write down", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00174-00037784-00037951": "the things they understood and started", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00175-00037952-00038143": "to categorize things", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00176-00038144-00038295": "and of course now we're in the this", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00177-00038296-00038502": "techno-industrial civilization and it's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00178-00038503-00038846": "just gone to this extreme end of that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00179-00038847-00039071": "and so i i just i just i guess when", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00180-00039072-00039199": "you're talking about these things it's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00181-00039200-00039518": "fascinating like how you play maybe i am", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00182-00039519-00039687": "putting you in a box by trying to ask", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00183-00039688-00039846": "you these questions in this way but when", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00184-00039847-00039990": "i think about it i'm like how do you", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00185-00039991-00040071": "take", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00186-00040072-00040279": "something i think calligraphy is", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00187-00040280-00040479": "incredibly beautiful and i appreciate it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00188-00040480-00040718": "when i see it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00189-00040719-00041062": "but something about writing words can", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00190-00041063-00041271": "uh", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00191-00041272-00041511": "it puts it down on paper it makes it a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00192-00041512-00041687": "definable thing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00193-00041688-00041967": "when it seems like it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00194-00041968-00042311": "fixes it in place yeah right i mean i a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00195-00042312-00042423": "lot of what you're saying really", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00196-00042424-00042574": "resonates because these are the ideas", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00197-00042575-00042887": "that excite me yeah um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00198-00042888-00042983": "the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00199-00042984-00043174": "yeah when it's written down it's both", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00200-00043175-00043439": "fixed in place and it sort of stops time", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00201-00043440-00043671": "it can't change it can't evolve it can't", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00202-00043672-00043999": "respond can't shift it's not really a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00203-00044000-00044158": "living word", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00204-00044159-00044351": "that's a completely valid argument", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00205-00044352-00044479": "i think", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00206-00044480-00044758": "that's some of what i want to rail", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00207-00044759-00045039": "against i guess i mean also a lot of the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00208-00045040-00045399": "words that are being so carefully", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00209-00045400-00045718": "written and gilded and painted and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00210-00045719-00045951": "decorated you know they're rooted and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00211-00045952-00046071": "are", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00212-00046072-00046262": "in monotheism they're rooted in sort of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00213-00046263-00046383": "like this is the way we look at the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00214-00046384-00046567": "world this is the right way there's this", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00215-00046568-00046655": "sort of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00216-00046656-00046807": "singularity that they're trying to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00217-00046808-00046967": "proclaim", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00218-00046968-00047167": "and i'm not i'm not into that either", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00219-00047168-00047471": "yeah yeah and like um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00220-00047472-00047767": "so there's like a lot about that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00221-00047768-00048079": "modality that is working against a lot", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00222-00048080-00048279": "of what i feel very passionate and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00223-00048280-00048415": "interested", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00224-00048416-00048646": "in um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00225-00048647-00048727": "so", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00226-00048728-00048983": "but i guess well so for my work there's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00227-00048984-00049430": "this constant um bleeding out into the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00228-00049431-00049646": "organic or into the texture into the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00229-00049647-00049895": "material that i'm using and so", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00230-00049896-00050190": "i play with that in my paintings like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00231-00050191-00050543": "you can read the line and then you can't", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00232-00050544-00050862": "it sort of drops off of the legible and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00233-00050863-00051183": "becomes sort of greater than our", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00234-00051184-00051470": "ability to read i was really influenced", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00235-00051471-00051607": "by this book", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00236-00051608-00051799": "the spell of the sensuous", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00237-00051800-00052142": "the david abrams in grad school and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00238-00052144-00052407": "um well actually about like seven", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00239-00052408-00052542": "eighths of the book because then i got", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00240-00052544-00052750": "to the end and it felt like somebody", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00241-00052751-00052975": "told him he had to put it into a package", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00242-00052976-00053135": "at the end and tell you what you thought", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00243-00053136-00053335": "about all the cool things he had written", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00244-00053336-00053503": "sure um i'm not sure if you're familiar", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00245-00053504-00053711": "with the book but it's awesome i've", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00246-00053712-00053879": "heard of it i haven't read it but i've", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00247-00053879-00054079": "heard it highly recommended but he was", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00248-00054079-00054407": "talking about that in that whole book of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00249-00054408-00054663": "studying magic all over the world with", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00250-00054664-00054854": "shamans and magicians and just being", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00251-00054855-00055047": "this like weirdo who wanted to travel", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00252-00055048-00055207": "and learn magic tricks", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00253-00055208-00055454": "and then sort of coming to understanding", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00254-00055455-00055775": "that the sensuous is language upon", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00255-00055776-00056023": "language and that like the little ways", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00256-00056024-00056223": "that we speak and the ways that we write", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00257-00056224-00056559": "alphabets have so limited our ability to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00258-00056560-00056791": "perceive and understand", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00259-00056791-00057071": "so much that's out there and that really", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00260-00057072-00057375": "moved me even if his conclusion was", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00261-00057376-00057719": "meaningless for my thesis and like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00262-00057720-00058063": "this concept that there's just so much", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00263-00058064-00058247": "you're only ever seeing a tiny snapshot", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00264-00058248-00058399": "of it anyway so", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00265-00058400-00058566": "little human lives", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00266-00058567-00058703": "are also", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00267-00058704-00059063": "incapable of reflecting upon um the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00268-00059064-00059366": "immensity and possibility of change and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00269-00059367-00059599": "life and meaning so we're only ever", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00270-00059600-00059687": "getting", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00271-00059688-00059863": "the same level of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00272-00059864-00060119": "fixation or snapshot that writing a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00273-00060120-00060342": "phrase down does which is kind of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00274-00060344-00060630": "interesting to sort of even think about", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00275-00060632-00060871": "like a life that way but", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00276-00060872-00061006": "i guess i'm", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00277-00061007-00061319": "pushing against calligraphy's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00278-00061320-00061526": "edges and trying to say that there's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00279-00061527-00061782": "more it can do but it's also i just", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00280-00061783-00062038": "enjoy calligraphy and i enjoy language", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00281-00062039-00062247": "and a way to share language that is", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00282-00062248-00062471": "beyond the oral is by writing it down", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00283-00062472-00062566": "and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00284-00062567-00062759": "just because things do get written down", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00285-00062760-00063006": "doesn't mean they need to become", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00286-00063007-00063303": "written in stone i guess yeah like that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00287-00063304-00063526": "is the beauty to the paper it's a living", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00288-00063527-00063830": "material it buckles and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00289-00063832-00063991": "warps and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00290-00063991-00064319": "shrugs off ink and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00291-00064320-00064719": "sucks in the ink and it's like yeah", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00292-00064720-00064935": "you're actually sort of dancing with the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00293-00064936-00065063": "with the stuff", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00294-00065064-00065359": "on the table or on the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00295-00065360-00065559": "panel well it's a it's a visceral", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00296-00065560-00065775": "experience it's what it sounds like it", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00297-00065776-00065959": "sounds like the paper and the ink and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00298-00065960-00066126": "the pressing of the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00299-00066127-00066447": "the pen or or whatever it is onto the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00300-00066448-00066847": "the paper and it's just this whole", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00301-00066848-00067103": "i i feel like probably i i think we lose", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00302-00067104-00067215": "a lot", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00303-00067216-00067463": "without that aspect to it because i", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00304-00067464-00067703": "enjoy that part of it when i write down", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00305-00067704-00067855": "and there's a good piece of paper that", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00306-00067856-00068159": "you're writing down on and the good pen", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00307-00068160-00068350": "with a good pen yeah not just some", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00308-00068351-00068591": "shitty pick which is fine for what it is", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00309-00068592-00068711": "but it's like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00310-00068712-00068926": "nothing like having a good pen that's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00311-00068927-00069167": "good ink that flows out of it you know", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00312-00069168-00069399": "feels really good yeah", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00313-00069400-00069582": "the way too that we naturally want to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00314-00069583-00069838": "write when it's feeling good you want to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00315-00069839-00070055": "like keep going with the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00316-00070056-00070150": "um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00317-00070151-00070582": "flourishes and creating doodles and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00318-00070583-00070806": "extent you're sort of always extending", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00319-00070807-00071038": "outside of the realm of the written word", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00320-00071039-00071326": "you're always drawing also so writing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00321-00071327-00071462": "and i mean i've said this a number of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00322-00071463-00071567": "times when i've tried to teach", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00323-00071568-00071743": "calligraphy or teach hand lettering like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00324-00071744-00071935": "you're not writing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00325-00071936-00072223": "letters you are drawing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00326-00072224-00072503": "words there's actually a lot of drawing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00327-00072504-00072775": "it's a completely different mind thing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00328-00072776-00072935": "you're using the same motor skills but", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00329-00072936-00073094": "you're not leaning into your muscle", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00330-00073095-00073447": "memory of writing grocery lists right so", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00331-00073448-00073615": "you're making a drawing and then there's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00332-00073616-00073823": "a lot more expressiveness and there's a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00333-00073824-00074062": "lot more body that's happening when", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00334-00074063-00074294": "you're recording calligraphy", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00335-00074295-00074550": "like a drawing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00336-00074551-00074775": "you know like this reminds me of i mean", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00337-00074776-00074975": "just the word poetry or or not the word", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00338-00074976-00075150": "poetry but the act of making poetry", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00339-00075151-00075255": "which is", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00340-00075256-00075399": "it's when you're talking about language", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00341-00075400-00075582": "and i'm thinking about", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00342-00075583-00075767": "how using the very tool that is limiting", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00343-00075768-00075975": "to break outside of the constraints of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00344-00075976-00076135": "the tool itself", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00345-00076136-00076215": "so", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00346-00076216-00076519": "you're like how can i convey", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00347-00076520-00076838": "a feeling a sensation", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00348-00076839-00077182": "and a whole experience", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00349-00077183-00077359": "not actually saying the name of the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00350-00077360-00077543": "thing itself but like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00351-00077544-00077726": "exploring the edges of what that is so", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00352-00077727-00077926": "that by the time you've gone through the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00353-00077927-00078167": "the poem and it's not just the act of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00354-00078168-00078326": "like reading it and the image that comes", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00355-00078327-00078494": "to your mind is the actual shape of the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00356-00078495-00078647": "words", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00357-00078648-00078862": "the way that it flows from beginning to", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00358-00078863-00078999": "end", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00359-00079000-00079238": "that whole experience itself draws on a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00360-00079239-00079391": "sensation", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00361-00079392-00079631": "uh which then produces maybe it pulls on", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00362-00079632-00079743": "a memory", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00363-00079744-00080119": "or pulls on something else um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00364-00080120-00080287": "and i imagine if you're", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00365-00080288-00080423": "if you're like if you're doing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00366-00080424-00080647": "calligraphy like you're describing the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00367-00080648-00080862": "act the flourishes the everything like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00368-00080863-00081038": "looking at that that'll draw on", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00369-00081039-00081255": "something as well it's like within each", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00370-00081256-00081479": "letter that you're writing down", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00371-00081480-00081638": "that you're drawing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00372-00081639-00082094": "that in of itself is producing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00373-00082095-00082350": "an experience yeah meaning", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00374-00082351-00082599": "because it's not it doesn't just mean t", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00375-00082600-00082894": "or y or the are all of those letters put", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00376-00082895-00083135": "together to make a word or a sentence", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00377-00083136-00083438": "it's the letter itself is", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00378-00083439-00083662": "expressing something", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00379-00083663-00083750": "yeah", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00380-00083751-00083926": "yeah i think in that way like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00381-00083927-00084143": "calligraphic letters become", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00382-00084144-00084238": "pictograms", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00383-00084239-00084615": "like yeah they become runes really like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00384-00084616-00084791": "yeah they become", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00385-00084792-00084903": "sigily", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00386-00084904-00085087": "single dream and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00387-00085088-00085191": "it's like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00388-00085192-00085399": "the the", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00389-00085400-00085599": "number of layers that one can actually", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00390-00085600-00085782": "put into something like that is", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00391-00085783-00086015": "limitless yeah and that's that's what's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00392-00086016-00086167": "exciting and it's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00393-00086168-00086294": "um", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00394-00086295-00086406": "i think too", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00395-00086407-00086599": "when i'm building my paintings i'm", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00396-00086600-00086775": "pulling i'm pulling from all sorts of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00397-00086776-00087094": "sources my own writing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00398-00087095-00087215": "poetry", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00399-00087216-00087494": "uh political theory like there's these", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00400-00087495-00087735": "really interesting weird mashups and", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00401-00087736-00087894": "sometimes i refer to them almost as a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00402-00087895-00088047": "visual essay", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00403-00088048-00088350": "in like the lyrical essay tradition", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00404-00088351-00088479": "because that's what they're doing", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00405-00088480-00088647": "they're trying to get", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00406-00088648-00089023": "ideas or modalities or concepts to sit", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00407-00089024-00089303": "together um very beautifully but in a", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00408-00089304-00089494": "very messy way", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00409-00089495-00089615": "and that's", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00410-00089616-00089823": "sort of the microcosm", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00411-00089824-00090071": "theory that i have about it like", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00412-00090072-00090335": "calligraphy can be this", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00413-00090336-00090711": "way of creating a microcosm of", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00414-00090712-00091471": "the whole of gaia if you want", "i4rhRP4OOzU-00415-00091472-00091680": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i4xzhL3Pdhg", "text": {"i4xzhL3Pdhg-00000-00000065-00000373": "hello Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00001-00000374-00000808": "this is your reading for December 15th", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00002-00000809-00001079": "through the 31st", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00003-00001080-00001411": "my name is Renee", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00004-00001412-00001739": "and welcome to my channel if you're", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00005-00001739-00001860": "returning", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00006-00001861-00002147": "thank you thank you thank you for your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00007-00002148-00002518": "support I appreciate you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00008-00002519-00002683": "okay", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00009-00002684-00002999": "if my readings resume please like And", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00010-00003000-00003226": "subscribe hit that Bell so you don't", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00011-00003227-00003451": "miss any uploads", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00012-00003452-00003754": "and make sure to take a look at your Sun", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00013-00003755-00004049": "Moon and Rising for more clearly on your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00014-00004050-00004217": "situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00015-00004218-00004481": "hey Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00016-00004482-00004715": "what do", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00017-00004716-00005152": "you do for Pisces instinct", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00018-00005153-00005549": "okay so yeah I feel like you could be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00019-00005550-00005836": "following your intuition you're very you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00020-00005837-00006167": "know Pisces is very intuitive anyway and", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00021-00006168-00006418": "I you also have enlightenment", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00022-00006419-00006598": "so I feel like whatever you're working", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00023-00006600-00007055": "on uh Pisces I feel like you are gaining", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00024-00007056-00007475": "a lot of wisdom from the situation but I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00025-00007476-00007625": "think spirit is letting you know to", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00026-00007626-00008039": "follow your instincts", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00027-00008040-00008423": "to become more enlightened to find out", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00028-00008424-00008710": "certain information that you're looking", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00029-00008711-00009064": "for following your instincts", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00030-00009065-00009377": "the same and you have the land in", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00031-00009378-00009478": "between", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00032-00009479-00009773": "okay so I feel like uh right now you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00033-00009774-00009941": "could be caught between a rock and a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00034-00009942-00010192": "hard place Pisces I feel like you were", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00035-00010193-00010546": "kind of in this energy where you're not", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00036-00010547-00010723": "making any decisions", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00037-00010724-00011123": "you're kind of in between thoughts but", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00038-00011124-00011417": "you need to take a deep breath", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00039-00011418-00011621": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00040-00011622-00011796": "foreign", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00041-00011797-00012023": "take some time to think about your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00042-00012024-00012256": "situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00043-00012257-00012880": "what is it that has you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00044-00012881-00013159": "in a deadlock what has you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00045-00013160-00013625": "[Music]", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00046-00013626-00014086": "not wanting to make a choice", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00047-00014087-00014230": "what do you need to follow your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00048-00014231-00014753": "instincts about um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00049-00014754-00014929": "we have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00050-00014930-00015233": "affirmation for healing the harm okay", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00051-00015234-00015401": "you may be going through some kind of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00052-00015402-00015599": "heartbreak or disappointment at the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00053-00015600-00015875": "moment Pisces there's something that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00054-00015876-00016055": "you're healing from", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00055-00016056-00016463": "and you also have change and progress so", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00056-00016464-00016733": "yeah I feel like whatever this is I feel", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00057-00016734-00017536": "like you're changing your direction", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00058-00017537-00017675": "hmm", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00059-00017676-00017927": "what do we have for Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00060-00017928-00018299": "December 15th through the 31st", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00061-00018300-00018467": "would", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00062-00018468-00018803": "What Spirit message do we have for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00063-00018804-00019235": "Pisces what does pisces need to know", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00064-00019236-00019493": "the black bear the guardian", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00065-00019494-00019925": "okay gentle and wise protector give me", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00066-00019926-00020158": "your confidence and power help me", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00067-00020159-00020513": "protect the ones I love awaken my", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00068-00020514-00020825": "intuition and guide me yes I feel like", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00069-00020826-00021055": "you're wanting some sort of protection", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00070-00021056-00021355": "you want some sort of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00071-00021356-00021629": "guidance and", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00072-00021630-00022025": "um intuitive", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00073-00022026-00022235": "information", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00074-00022236-00022517": "you also have Leo energy on the bottom", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00075-00022518-00022661": "so I feel like", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00076-00022662-00022853": "spirit is letting you know that you are", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00077-00022854-00023069": "stronger than you believe you have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00078-00023070-00023525": "strength Pisces higher calling you have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00079-00023526-00023999": "within you all the courage you need let", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00080-00024000-00024271": "go of the past and reclaim your majesty", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00081-00024272-00024605": "you will find success and contentment", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00082-00024606-00024971": "with those by your side make Noble", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00083-00024972-00025378": "choices for your life and your tribe so", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00084-00025379-00025541": "it could be that you're making choices", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00085-00025542-00025817": "not only for yourself but for people", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00086-00025818-00026075": "around you as well so you could be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00087-00026076-00026267": "taking care of a family you could have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00088-00026268-00026477": "children", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00089-00026477-00026896": "um that you are responsible for but I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00090-00026897-00027196": "feel like you know there's a lot on your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00091-00027197-00027514": "back at the moment Pisces I feel like", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00092-00027516-00027707": "you're really asking for a protection", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00093-00027708-00028133": "and guidance okay you have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00094-00028133-00028414": "Francesca", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00095-00028416-00028708": "what do you desire right now visualize", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00096-00028710-00028951": "it and it will come about", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00097-00028952-00029308": "negativity will block your progress", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00098-00029310-00029867": "okay at the bottom you have Oceana", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00099-00029868-00030064": "take action", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00100-00030066-00030395": "you're in touch with your truth in this", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00101-00030395-00030646": "situation and you need to trust your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00102-00030647-00031102": "guts and lovely assert yourself yeah use", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00103-00031104-00031474": "your intuition Pisces you usually have a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00104-00031475-00031681": "very strong intuition", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00105-00031682-00031979": "Pisces is the most intuitive of the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00106-00031980-00032231": "signs so I feel like using your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00107-00032232-00032633": "intuition following your gut instinct is", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00108-00032633-00032974": "going to help you through this situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00109-00032975-00033331": "whatever this is let's get some tarot", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00110-00033332-00033665": "for Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00111-00033666-00033905": "um let's get some tarot for Pisces for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00112-00033906-00034385": "December 15th through the 31st what does", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00113-00034386-00034757": "Tara want to tell Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00114-00034758-00035021": "first out we have the Knight of Swords", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00115-00035022-00035231": "okay", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00116-00035232-00035524": "so it could be that you're moving in a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00117-00035525-00035717": "direction I feel like you're moving", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00118-00035718-00036089": "maybe a little too hasty", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00119-00036090-00036179": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00120-00036180-00036551": "maybe you're too quick to judge you also", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00121-00036552-00036905": "have the hermit card", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00122-00036906-00037765": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00123-00037766-00038135": "you know what I think this is okay", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00124-00038136-00038705": "the night of swords and the hermit so I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00125-00038706-00039274": "think", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00126-00039275-00039552": "whatever the situation is I feel like", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00127-00039553-00039868": "resolve is Gonna Come", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00128-00039869-00040240": "swiftly", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00129-00040241-00040949": "this issue is going to be resolved", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00130-00040950-00041239": "yes you have the empress energy as well", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00131-00041240-00041561": "so yeah whatever the situation is is", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00132-00041562-00041807": "going to be resolved you've found the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00133-00041808-00041974": "wisdom", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00134-00041975-00042257": "um you've been enlightened by some sort", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00135-00042258-00042443": "of situation it could be this Empress", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00136-00042444-00042695": "energy and this could be someone around", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00137-00042696-00042983": "you who", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00138-00042984-00043301": "is helping you find the answers someone", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00139-00043302-00043693": "who is very thoughtful and very fruitful", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00140-00043694-00044074": "in this situation this could be also", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00141-00044075-00044285": "someone who's a good parent this could", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00142-00044286-00044501": "be your energy even though it's not a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00143-00044502-00044830": "Pisces this could be your energy", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00144-00044831-00044939": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00145-00044940-00045155": "what I'm feeling like with the situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00146-00045156-00045502": "you are gonna gain your balance back I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00147-00045503-00045611": "feel like you're going to be able to", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00148-00045612-00045899": "come to any decisions that you are", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00149-00045900-00046187": "needing to make you're finding your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00150-00046188-00046895": "balance", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00151-00046896-00047117": "I feel like you found", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00152-00047118-00047345": "finally found control of the situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00153-00047346-00047777": "yeah with the King of Swords the answers", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00154-00047778-00047999": "that you needed", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00155-00048000-00048295": "are coming to you or have came to you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00156-00048296-00048574": "and now it's helping you gain your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00157-00048575-00049018": "balance back this could also be a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00158-00049019-00049168": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00159-00049169-00049583": "Gemini Libra Aquarius who's", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00160-00049584-00050035": "coming towards you too but I feel like", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00161-00050036-00050327": "this energy", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00162-00050328-00050524": "is seeing you through your situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00163-00050525-00050686": "it's helping you with the answers that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00164-00050687-00050789": "you need", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00165-00050790-00051112": "and definitely and these answers that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00166-00051113-00051425": "you needed ended the situation there's", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00167-00051426-00051658": "going to be a total end to the situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00168-00051659-00052158": "that you were so worried about", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00169-00052159-00052487": "thank you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00170-00052488-00052792": "that's that transformation and change", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00171-00052794-00052954": "that you needed", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00172-00052955-00053571": "okay you have the seven of Wands", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00173-00053572-00053915": "[Applause]", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00174-00053916-00054238": "and the ten of Pentacles yeah so this", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00175-00054239-00054473": "could have been a money uh matter that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00176-00054474-00054707": "you were having and I feel like", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00177-00054708-00054973": "some kind of abundance some kind of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00178-00054974-00055325": "information that's coming to you that's", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00179-00055326-00055511": "actually", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00180-00055512-00055613": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00181-00055614-00055930": "like a protector for you you also have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00182-00055932-00056104": "the seven of Pentacles on the bottom of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00183-00056105-00056344": "the deck so I feel like whatever this", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00184-00056345-00056579": "was it was worth your effort it was", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00185-00056579-00056950": "worth your uh putting your energy into", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00186-00056951-00057257": "the situation because obviously it's", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00187-00057258-00057526": "making you very fruitful and now I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00188-00057527-00057671": "believe with the seven of Wands I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00189-00057672-00057904": "believe that this is you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00190-00057905-00058216": "um taking action on the situation this", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00191-00058217-00058438": "is you acting upon some kind of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00192-00058439-00058654": "decisions that you finally had to make", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00193-00058655-00059044": "some kind of aha moment some kind of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00194-00059045-00059249": "um Crossroads that you were going", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00195-00059250-00059566": "through but these are this is you taking", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00196-00059567-00059921": "your action and this is your return your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00197-00059922-00060287": "return has come forward as good health", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00198-00060288-00060635": "um loving family abundance this could", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00199-00060636-00060869": "also be your finances increasing this", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00200-00060870-00061097": "could be a job that you were very", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00201-00061098-00061511": "persistent about trying to obtain but I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00202-00061512-00061775": "feel like it's pushing you forward into", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00203-00061776-00061973": "the future I feel like your ships are", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00204-00061974-00062291": "coming in and you were just waiting for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00205-00062291-00062542": "this answer to come about", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00206-00062544-00062753": "you were patiently waiting on this", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00207-00062754-00062987": "situation but I feel like it's coming", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00208-00062988-00063179": "through for you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00209-00063179-00063311": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00210-00063312-00063611": "Pisces and I feel like it's going to be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00211-00063612-00064429": "a very needed very anticipated change", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00212-00064429-00064732": "what else do we have for Pisces you have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00213-00064733-00064966": "the Six of Pentacles so yeah this is", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00214-00064967-00065111": "something that you've given a lot of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00215-00065112-00065476": "energy to this is something that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00216-00065477-00065705": "you know you're gaining your return on", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00217-00065706-00065956": "and you're showing up", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00218-00065957-00066226": "yes Pisces you're showing up the high", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00219-00066227-00066611": "priestess this is your energy", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00220-00066612-00066953": "um so I feel like you are trusting", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00221-00066954-00067181": "yourself in this situation you're", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00222-00067182-00067456": "gaining your power", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00223-00067457-00068099": "you're solving your Mysteries", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00224-00068100-00068459": "and the full so yes after this ending", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00225-00068460-00068706": "with this death card after this ending", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00226-00068707-00069047": "you have this new Journey that you'll be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00227-00069048-00069232": "going on you'll be following this new", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00228-00069233-00069515": "Journey this new beginning taking new", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00229-00069516-00069676": "riffs", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00230-00069677-00069829": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00231-00069830-00070463": "wow okay", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00232-00070464-00070967": "what else do we have for Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00233-00070968-00071176": "yeah you're getting a lot of success", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00234-00071177-00071465": "Pisces you have the six of Wands so I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00235-00071466-00071909": "feel like all eyes are on Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00236-00071910-00072281": "I feel like you are being recognized but", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00237-00072282-00072529": "I feel like you're not even noticing", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00238-00072530-00072947": "that these people are recognizing you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00239-00072948-00073085": "um", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00240-00073086-00073379": "hey you're not even turning your head", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00241-00073380-00073703": "you're not even noticing that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00242-00073704-00073937": "you know you're being rewarded for the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00243-00073938-00074165": "situation your head is too far up in the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00244-00074166-00074423": "clouds but this is a wonderful change", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00245-00074424-00074681": "this is your good forward your good", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00246-00074682-00075076": "fortunes coming forward for you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00247-00075077-00075425": "wonderful wonderful", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00248-00075426-00075713": "energy for you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00249-00075714-00076097": "Pisces now it does start out a little a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00250-00076098-00076331": "little questionable but it gets better", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00251-00076332-00076576": "okay you have The Two of Pentacles on", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00252-00076577-00076847": "the bottom so what you don't expect is", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00253-00076848-00077165": "you're gaining balance in this situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00254-00077166-00077335": "you are", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00255-00077336-00077705": "making good choices and you may have a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00256-00077706-00077921": "few different options that you can take", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00257-00077922-00078287": "in order to better your situation but I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00258-00078288-00078556": "feel like you are making good choices at", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00259-00078557-00078809": "the moment Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00260-00078810-00079121": "I feel like you're on the right track", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00261-00079122-00079426": "okay what is the final outcome for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00262-00079427-00079829": "Pisces what can Pisces expect as a final", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00263-00079830-00079956": "outcome", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00264-00079957-00080203": "for December", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00265-00080204-00080485": "15th through the 31st", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00266-00080486-00080765": "[Applause]", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00267-00080766-00081011": "okay I feel like you're gonna have the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00268-00081012-00081269": "end of your worries", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00269-00081270-00081821": "the end of your worries", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00270-00081822-00082085": "yeah and you'll definitely be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00271-00082086-00082499": "moving away from the situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00272-00082500-00082691": "I feel like you're leaving the situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00273-00082692-00082991": "behind because you've planted your seed", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00274-00082992-00083387": "you watch something grow and now that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00275-00083388-00083591": "thing that's growing is now being", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00276-00083592-00083915": "fruitful it's now bearing fruit for you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00277-00083916-00084275": "it could also be your abundance", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00278-00084276-00084809": "that's coming through", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00279-00084810-00085115": "yeah definitely now if you're not open", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00280-00085116-00085337": "to love Pisces there may be love coming", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00281-00085338-00085517": "through I don't see a whole lot of love", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00282-00085518-00085859": "in your reading but it says that you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00283-00085860-00086165": "know you may have a new beginning for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00284-00086166-00086488": "love as well so", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00285-00086489-00086681": "stay on the lookout for that be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00286-00086682-00087131": "attentive be aware that that can be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00287-00087132-00087481": "coming to you as well you may have love", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00288-00087482-00087719": "definitely okay", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00289-00087720-00087935": "and you have the ten of Pentacles so", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00290-00087936-00088138": "this is your will this is your family", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00291-00088139-00088505": "this is your contentment like I said", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00292-00088506-00088726": "this also may be love is coming through", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00293-00088727-00089038": "for you as well so yeah be on the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00294-00089039-00089441": "lookout for that at the bottom you are a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00295-00089442-00089843": "boss Pisces you are the emperor you are", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00296-00089844-00090167": "powerful you are", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00297-00090168-00090575": "you know taking action being very", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00298-00090576-00090847": "assertive uh you're being a leader", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00299-00090848-00091049": "you're leading", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00300-00091050-00091529": "yourself and others into a new", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00301-00091530-00091721": "um venture", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00302-00091722-00092068": "okay let's get some manifestation cards", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00303-00092069-00092429": "let's see what Pisces is manifesting at", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00304-00092430-00092543": "the moment", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00305-00092544-00092867": "what are you manifesting Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00306-00092868-00093125": "December 15th through the 31st what are", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00307-00093126-00093400": "you manifesting", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00308-00093401-00093815": "okay full moon in Gemini embrace the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00309-00093816-00093971": "flow of life", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00310-00093972-00094276": "yeah and true Pisces nature just go with", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00311-00094277-00094475": "the flow", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00312-00094476-00094588": "stuff", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00313-00094589-00094999": "go with the flow use your intuition", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00314-00095000-00095309": "Embrace Life", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00315-00095310-00095675": "full moon in Aquarius be real", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00316-00095676-00096341": "yeah be true to yourself Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00317-00096342-00096755": "always be assertive row and be true to", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00318-00096756-00096911": "self", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00319-00096912-00097211": "and New Moon and Gemini it may be a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00320-00097212-00097367": "Gemini coming to your life you have a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00321-00097368-00097553": "lot of Gemini here", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00322-00097554-00097949": "um but think it through", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00323-00097950-00098135": "make your plans", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00324-00098136-00098699": "take action be assertive", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00325-00098700-00098855": "you have", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00326-00098856-00099403": "new moon in Virgo trust all will be well", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00327-00099404-00099761": "exactly yeah it's it's all gonna work", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00328-00099762-00099868": "out", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00329-00099869-00100373": "and yes Pisces yes first quarter moon", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00330-00100374-00100721": "and Aquarius trust the universe", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00331-00100722-00100918": "be instinctive", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00332-00100919-00101153": "use your intuition", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00333-00101154-00101843": "be assertive trust the universe", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00334-00101844-00102124": "oh great energy let's give some more", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00335-00102125-00102268": "allergy", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00336-00102269-00102677": "cards for Pisces what is coming in for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00337-00102678-00103036": "Pisces please December 15th", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00338-00103038-00103301": "through the 31st what's coming in for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00339-00103302-00103518": "Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00340-00103519-00103908": "December 15th the 31st", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00341-00103909-00104213": "adjustments are required yeah and I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00342-00104214-00104489": "think that we saw that with these cards", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00343-00104490-00104680": "that were coming out", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00344-00104681-00105034": "um third quarter moon so yeah you may", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00345-00105035-00105227": "have some obstacles that still come your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00346-00105228-00105515": "way they may there may be some", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00347-00105516-00105713": "um unseen problems that are coming", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00348-00105714-00105851": "through", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00349-00105852-00106078": "um the moon energy is what I'm feeling", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00350-00106079-00106421": "with that adjustments are required but I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00351-00106422-00106583": "feel like it's nothing that you can't", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00352-00106583-00106807": "overcome Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00353-00106808-00107147": "exactly work through your fears new moon", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00354-00107148-00107536": "and Scorpio", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00355-00107538-00107857": "work through your fears and insecurities", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00356-00107858-00108215": "and look at the bigger picture full moon", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00357-00108216-00108431": "and Sagittarius", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00358-00108432-00108760": "and one more card", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00359-00108761-00109102": "what do we have for Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00360-00109103-00109408": "your dreams need a practical plan yeah", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00361-00109409-00109697": "so plan out what is what it is that you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00362-00109698-00109913": "exactly want to do Pisces make your plan", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00363-00109914-00110219": "be assertive taking action", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00364-00110220-00110440": "um and you will be successful you're a", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00365-00110441-00110657": "Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00366-00110658-00110884": "um full moon and Taurus okay and what", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00367-00110885-00111113": "you don't see on the bottom", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00368-00111114-00111508": "all right Pisces believe in the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00369-00111509-00111683": "impossible", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00370-00111683-00111827": "yes", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00371-00111828-00112228": "anything is possible with Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00372-00112229-00112639": "what does the universe have to say for", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00373-00112640-00113002": "Pisces the mighty mighty Pisces do you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00374-00113003-00113273": "remember that movie a fish that saved", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00375-00113274-00113525": "Pittsburgh yeah I'm kind of showing the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00376-00113526-00113734": "age here but", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00377-00113735-00113908": "um yeah that's a good movie I remember", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00378-00113909-00114389": "that song mighty mighty Pisces", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00379-00114390-00114545": "okay", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00380-00114546-00115073": "energy flows where my intentions goes", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00381-00115074-00115360": "set your attention", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00382-00115361-00115633": "be assertive", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00383-00115633-00115823": "manifest", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00384-00115824-00116104": "I let go of the shadow of the past by", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00385-00116105-00116452": "seeing someone for the first time with", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00386-00116453-00116795": "The Eyes Of Love yeah so the uh maybe", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00387-00116796-00117052": "someone new coming in this also may be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00388-00117053-00117502": "someone from your past is coming in that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00389-00117503-00117697": "this", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00390-00117698-00118007": "New Passion will be reignited because", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00391-00118008-00118219": "you're seeing someone for the first time", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00392-00118220-00118458": "with The Eyes Of Love", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00393-00118459-00118990": "my Fearless Freedom lights up the world", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00394-00118991-00119465": "yes spicy to be Fearless", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00395-00119466-00119890": "and I do whatever it takes to get closer", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00396-00119891-00120204": "to consciousness", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00397-00120205-00120502": "and what you don't see on the bottom", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00398-00120503-00120923": "hope is the conduit for miracles yes", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00399-00120924-00121186": "beautiful energy now", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00400-00121188-00121547": "what does pisces need to do", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00401-00121548-00122021": "in order to overcome any challenges or", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00402-00122022-00122410": "obstacles that they face in December", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00403-00122411-00122716": "what does pisces need to do", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00404-00122717-00122843": "service", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00405-00122844-00123125": "I feel good when I can help others yeah", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00406-00123126-00123275": "and I feel like you do that already", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00407-00123276-00123497": "Pisces I feel like that you're very", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00408-00123498-00123821": "you're a very helpful spirit I feel like", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00409-00123822-00124049": "you're very generous", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00410-00124050-00124204": "um you're willing to help others in", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00411-00124205-00124439": "their time of need so yeah being of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00412-00124440-00124595": "service to other people that would", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00413-00124596-00124745": "definitely", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00414-00124746-00124993": "um help you through any tough times", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00415-00124994-00125315": "change I understand that nothing can", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00416-00125316-00125590": "grow or evolve without movement yes", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00417-00125591-00126047": "taking action at this time", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00418-00126048-00126145": "foreign", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00419-00126146-00126299": "growth", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00420-00126300-00126719": "I want to expand my consciousness", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00421-00126720-00126977": "and my awareness yeah we saw that here", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00422-00126978-00127240": "as well so yeah", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00423-00127241-00127528": "I do whatever it takes to get closer to", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00424-00127529-00127733": "my consciousness", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00425-00127733-00128051": "so yeah I feel like you know just being", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00426-00128052-00128302": "aware of", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00427-00128303-00128723": "your conscious thinking your thoughts", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00428-00128724-00128923": "um true meditation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00429-00128924-00129214": "grounding yourself that's all very", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00430-00129215-00129640": "helpful for situations Pisces and having", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00431-00129641-00129947": "patience I accept that everything", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00432-00129948-00130336": "happens in divine order", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00433-00130338-00130714": "and what you don't see on the bottom I", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00434-00130715-00131033": "possess the gifts of the soul that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00435-00131033-00131411": "benefit me and others self-esteem yes", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00436-00131412-00131693": "have your confidence be strong be", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00437-00131694-00132113": "assertive okay Pisces this is your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00438-00132114-00132328": "reading for December 15th through the", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00439-00132329-00132616": "31st if this reading resonates please", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00440-00132617-00132899": "like And subscribe hit the Bell so that", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00441-00132900-00133181": "you don't miss any uploads and make sure", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00442-00133182-00133337": "to take a look at your Sun Moon and", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00443-00133338-00133564": "Rising for more clarity on your", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00444-00133565-00133709": "situation", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00445-00133710-00133866": "and", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00446-00133867-00134285": "Pisces happy December", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00447-00134286-00134519": "many blessings to you", "i4xzhL3Pdhg-00448-00134520-00134803": "love and life"}}]