[{"audio_id": "i4Bd5PJAq1A", "text": {"i4Bd5PJAq1A-00000-00000003-00000188": "so I like to actually see all the", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00001-00000189-00000446": "bleeding and the red tissue because", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00002-00000447-00000667": "that's how I know this skin is gonna", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00003-00000668-00001823": "eventually fill it in", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00004-00001823-00002372": "so just be patient it's a diabetic ulcer", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00005-00002373-00002634": "I mean what happens is the pressure", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00006-00002635-00003095": "causes the skin to break up in as part", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00007-00003096-00003499": "of what we do we read the womb to", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00008-00003500-00003817": "stimulate new tissue growth", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00009-00003818-00004049": "here's something moving all the", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00010-00004050-00004675": "unhealthy tissue will grow a new tissue", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00011-00004676-00004970": "a little bit so I heal from the inside", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00012-00004971-00005629": "out", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00013-00005630-00006436": "this is a new skin in four weeks I put", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00014-00006437-00009085": "this away", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00015-00009086-00009346": "so I like to actually see all the", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00016-00009347-00009605": "bleeding and the red tissue because", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00017-00009606-00009826": "that's how I know this skin is gonna", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00018-00009827-00014428": "eventually fill it in one packing when", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00019-00014429-00014972": "you take a corner piece of gauze and you", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00020-00014972-00015643": "wanna pack every last area of the wound", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00021-00015644-00016141": "so it absorbs it and then when he comes", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00022-00016143-00016571": "time to remove it as to the gauze dries", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00023-00016572-00016910": "its catches all the healthy tissue and", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00024-00016911-00017125": "the act of pulling it away ideally", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00025-00017126-00018983": "cleans the one more", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00026-00018984-00019458": "take the pressure off so please just", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00027-00019459-00019774": "here so that when he walks he doesn't", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00028-00019775-00020109": "walk on the woman walks on the pad just", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00029-00020110-00021120": "like that", "i4Bd5PJAq1A-00030-00021121-00021433": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i4eAFsdyg-0", "text": {"i4eAFsdyg-0-00000-00000000-00000982": "[Music]", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00001-00000983-00001279": "hi fancy beauties involves welcome back", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00002-00001280-00001462": "to the channel I'm coming in with", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00003-00001463-00002000": "another video for the get it or forget", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00004-00002001-00002425": "it series on the channel so today we're", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00005-00002426-00002605": "going to go ahead and feature a", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00006-00002606-00002908": "foundation and this is by hard candy", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00007-00002909-00003160": "this is what the packaging looks like", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00008-00003161-00003765": "it's a plastic bottle and on the inside", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00009-00003767-00004540": "it is a brush something or another I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00010-00004541-00004951": "don't know anyway", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00011-00004952-00005536": "is this glamoflage okay and I'll show", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00012-00005537-00005819": "you that", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00013-00005820-00006017": "[Music]", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00014-00006018-00006378": "okay so we're going to just go ahead and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00015-00006379-00006600": "jump right into it I'll go ahead and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00016-00006601-00006881": "cover the specs when I come back from", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00017-00006883-00007392": "wearing this so I'm going to try and use", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00018-00007393-00007725": "this the way they designed it and I'm", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00019-00007726-00007919": "going to give you a swatch of it first", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00020-00007920-00008442": "on hand so this is what it looks like on", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00021-00008443-00008736": "my hand and we're just going to go ahead", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00022-00008737-00009207": "and get right into just get it apply so", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00023-00009208-00009457": "I'm just not quite", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00024-00009458-00011014": "[Music]", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00025-00011015-00011435": "alright guys so it's applied and I'm", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00026-00011436-00011669": "just going to go ahead finish the rest", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00027-00011670-00011939": "of my face and I gotta get back to the", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00028-00011940-00012398": "other video but this look so yes I am", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00029-00012399-00012646": "filming this look and I will leave a", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00030-00012647-00012863": "link because I'm not sure which one is", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00031-00012863-00013181": "going to go up first but stay tuned for", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00032-00013182-00013682": "the look and stay tuned to find out my", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00033-00013683-00013940": "thoughts about this foundation ok I will", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00034-00013941-00014350": "see you in eight to nine hours", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00035-00014351-00014660": "welcome back fancy beauties and bowls I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00036-00014661-00015071": "am coming back and to give you my", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00037-00015072-00015308": "thoughts give you the specs on this", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00038-00015309-00015731": "foundation that will tell you either go", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00039-00015732-00016019": "get it or forget it so this is a no", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00040-00016019-00016569": "foundation and it is by hard candy and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00041-00016570-00017203": "it is called glamoflage so this is what", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00042-00017204-00017489": "again the body looks like this it's", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00043-00017490-00017804": "plastic there is no pump which is very", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00044-00017805-00018122": "disappointing but we will get into all", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00045-00018123-00018533": "of that in just a moment so right now I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00046-00018534-00018839": "want to go ahead and just cover what", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00047-00018840-00019366": "this foundation is supposed to do for I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00048-00019367-00020012": "will say I am giving the feel of it", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00049-00020013-00020405": "trying to transfer into a powder but", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00050-00020406-00020878": "it's not doing it a hundred percent and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00051-00020879-00021071": "I don't know if it's due to the", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00052-00021072-00021607": "moisturizer that I use which is this I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00053-00021608-00022150": "love this it reminds me of the milk of", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00054-00022151-00022486": "magnesia only in the thick of formula I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00055-00022487-00022822": "don't know if it's that or if it's just", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00056-00022823-00023060": "my oils are coming through", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00057-00023061-00023465": "alright now I will say this I am getting", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00058-00023466-00023644": "a very full coverage", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00059-00023645-00023794": "from this foundation I have", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00060-00023795-00024255": "hyperpigmentation here and that is not", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00061-00024256-00024538": "coming through at all now you guys have", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00062-00024539-00024904": "to let me know if you see it because you", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00063-00024905-00025105": "know through my viewfinder I'm not", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00064-00025106-00025350": "seeing it and I didn't see it throughout", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00065-00025351-00025930": "today the color is in deep and this was", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00066-00025931-00026410": "the darkest shade that was in my local", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00067-00026411-00026758": "Walmart so this is the best color that I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00068-00026758-00027070": "could get now I don't know if this", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00069-00027070-00027526": "foundation is too dark for me to light", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00070-00027527-00027844": "or what have you but when I first put it", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00071-00027845-00028296": "on I was getting a feeling of it being", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00072-00028297-00028683": "too light and even coming off as a great", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00073-00028685-00029002": "cast on my skin so I did the best I can", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00074-00029002-00029370": "do with my contouring and with the", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00075-00029372-00029686": "highlighting underneath eyes so", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00076-00029687-00029962": "hopefully that kind of toned everything", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00077-00029963-00030169": "down that I was experiencing with that", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00078-00030170-00030568": "okay next thing we're going to dive into", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00079-00030569-00031177": "is the longevity of the foundation I am", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00080-00031177-00031492": "and and without a doubt I am saying that", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00081-00031493-00032064": "it did last for my 10 hours of wear okay", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00082-00032064-00032395": "let's go ahead and take a look at the", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00083-00032395-00033090": "transfer because it also says that it's", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00084-00033091-00033418": "transfer resistant so let's go ahead and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00085-00033419-00033658": "put that to the test as well", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00086-00033659-00034033": "[Music]", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00087-00034034-00034564": "so I have just a white that I used this", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00088-00034565-00034927": "morning and found a clean spot on here", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00089-00034928-00035257": "so we're just going to dab our face that", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00090-00035258-00035595": "moppy", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00091-00035596-00036283": "dab your face when you put the makeup on", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00092-00036284-00036433": "[Music]", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00093-00036434-00036940": "and this is my oily area here so this is", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00094-00036941-00037417": "the transfer that I'm getting right here", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00095-00037418-00037579": "[Music]", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00096-00037580-00037723": "right here", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00097-00037724-00038117": "and to be honest guys that's really not", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00098-00038118-00038432": "that bad it really is not that at all", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00099-00038433-00038752": "and this foundation was I want to say it", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00100-00038753-00038998": "was under ten dollars my fact I know it", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00101-00038999-00039121": "was under ten dollars", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00102-00039122-00039430": "I even may want to push the envelope and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00103-00039431-00039982": "say maybe it was even under seven", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00104-00039983-00040207": "dollars I might be pushing it with that", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00105-00040208-00040564": "though I'm not real sure now as far as", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00106-00040565-00040904": "it you know pairing it with their other", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00107-00040905-00041126": "products again I don't have their", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00108-00041127-00041555": "products but I did set my foundation or", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00109-00041556-00041913": "this foundation with my infallible", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00110-00041914-00042236": "setting powder I did use that to set it", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00111-00042237-00042607": "they both work well together to me I'm", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00112-00042608-00043007": "not getting a shiny face you know I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00113-00043008-00043195": "didn't really work that hard today", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00114-00043196-00043655": "either but normally when I work hard", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00115-00043656-00043907": "enough if that foundation is not going", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00116-00043908-00044215": "to hold up I'm going to get oily in here", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00117-00044216-00044518": "no matter what even if I said it with", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00118-00044519-00044830": "the infallible or if I said it with", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00119-00044831-00045367": "Fitness poreless either way I may get", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00120-00045368-00045605": "some seepage coming through that powder", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00121-00045606-00045868": "and I'm not getting that today which", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00122-00045869-00046312": "spends a lot so all in all I would say", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00123-00046313-00046582": "go ahead and get it I know you guys are", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00124-00046583-00046817": "like Gina when you gonna do one they", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00125-00046818-00046938": "said forget it", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00126-00046939-00047055": "right", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00127-00047056-00047262": "I'm on the wrong guys whatever I'm", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00128-00047263-00047505": "picking is coming through and you guys", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00129-00047506-00047913": "know how I am I am going to tell you the", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00130-00047914-00048198": "truth if it's good or if it's not I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00131-00048199-00048420": "don't have reasons to come on here and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00132-00048421-00048663": "just say yeah honey go ahead and spin", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00133-00048664-00048957": "your coins or not no because I work hard", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00134-00048958-00049185": "for mine and I know you work hard for", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00135-00049186-00049464": "yours if it's not good", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00136-00049465-00049677": "trust and believe I'm going to tell you", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00137-00049678-00050182": "that so right now I am saying go ahead", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00138-00050183-00050436": "and get this foundation because I am", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00139-00050437-00050736": "really enjoying it as you can see the", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00140-00050737-00051067": "transfer was not bad the coverage is", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00141-00051068-00051412": "took in my opinion it cover and I use", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00142-00051413-00051663": "two coats and normally I'm a one coat", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00143-00051664-00051939": "girl I could have stopped it the one", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00144-00051940-00052194": "coat because he covered everything but I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00145-00052195-00052516": "went ahead and put in two coats", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00146-00052516-00052868": "I like the coverage that is giving me", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00147-00052869-00053173": "again only thing I would suggest is that", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00148-00053174-00053761": "they get more colors for us because I", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00149-00053762-00054016": "mean you guys have to tell me if it's", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00150-00054016-00054543": "coming off ashy or or am I just tripping", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00151-00054544-00055038": "so those are adults thank you guys so", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00152-00055039-00055281": "much for watching don't forget to", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00153-00055282-00055680": "subscribe like and welcome to all my", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00154-00055681-00055962": "fancy beauties of those that have joined", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00155-00055963-00056274": "the fancy family I really appreciate you", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00156-00056275-00056562": "guys for that don't forget if you do", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00157-00056563-00056831": "subscribe to go ahead and hit that Bell", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00158-00056832-00057168": "notification that way you do not miss a", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00159-00057169-00057606": "single video that I put up I have not", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00160-00057607-00058015": "again have not gotten my channel on a", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00161-00058016-00058312": "regimen yet but my life is starting to", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00162-00058313-00058635": "slow down and I thank you in camphor", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00163-00058636-00059128": "radness ride with me anyway go ahead and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00164-00059129-00059382": "make your comments down below check the", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00165-00059383-00059539": "Beauty drawer I have", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00166-00059540-00059734": "information in there for you in there", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00167-00059735-00060004": "and I will see you guys in the next", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00168-00060004-00060298": "video this is Gina check him out and", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00169-00060299-00060532": "helping you to always keep your fancy", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00170-00060533-00060823": "beauty I love you guys so much and I'll", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00171-00060824-00060934": "see you soon", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00172-00060935-00061954": "[Music]", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00173-00061954-00062004": "No", "i4eAFsdyg-0-00174-00062004-00062476": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i4UP_xF5BGE", "text": {"i4UP_xF5BGE-00000-00000000-00000262": "truth is there's no real right answer", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00001-00000263-00001073": "there's just what you experience this is", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00002-00001074-00001945": "wrong I should be feeling so much better", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00003-00001946-00002207": "we're not photo shoot I'm gonna do like", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00004-00002208-00002399": "a cyberpunk II type of thing you come", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00005-00002400-00002663": "with me if you want let's go in today's", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00006-00002664-00002798": "video I'm gonna show you what I've been", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00007-00002799-00003056": "doing the last week or so in Montreal", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00008-00003057-00003443": "okay something about hearing so I looked", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00009-00003444-00003604": "at the cheapest countries to fly for", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00010-00003605-00003890": "montrĂ©al and London was one of the", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00011-00003890-00004106": "cheapest ones so I booked a flight to", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00012-00004107-00004541": "London before going to London I gotten", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00013-00004542-00004697": "some photoshoots and if you want to see", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00014-00004698-00004888": "the pictures from these shoots you can", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00015-00004889-00005905": "go on my Instagram at twirl robots", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00016-00005906-00006478": "it was so cold like freezing cold but", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00017-00006479-00006609": "you gotta do what you gotta do for the", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00018-00006611-00008704": "good pics I haven't really officially", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00019-00008705-00008887": "announced a bit I got my personal", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00020-00008888-00009061": "training certificates I'm a certified", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00021-00009062-00009319": "personal trainer and I've been training", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00022-00009320-00009568": "people here and there to help with", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00023-00009569-00009771": "saving up some money and other kind of", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00024-00009772-00010292": "hits", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00025-00010293-00010508": "the push-ups", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00026-00010509-00010820": "do you push-ups alright we're gonna do", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00027-00010821-00011048": "30 seconds of not homers and we're gonna", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00028-00011049-00011292": "okay I'm just gonna be like this oh yeah", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00029-00011293-00011752": "that's how you understand yeah", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00030-00011753-00011947": "just give your all and she runs next we", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00031-00011948-00012130": "can make 30 seconds on Fitness at the", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00032-00012131-00012782": "dock and we're second mr. Connick", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00033-00012783-00013308": "got this austerity to put and stop for", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00034-00013309-00013674": "30 seconds yeah ten more seconds", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00035-00013675-00013908": "stressed feel bad because I know I'm", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00036-00013909-00013986": "torturing you", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00037-00013987-00014166": "but you'll you'll be better this", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00038-00014166-00014511": "together yes that's all the way okay we", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00039-00014512-00014894": "have to go", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00040-00014894-00016497": "[Laughter]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00041-00016498-00017224": "folks were so close", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00042-00017225-00017883": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00043-00017884-00018255": "I always hated March I used to be so", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00044-00018256-00018412": "obsessed with the weather and then we're", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00045-00018413-00018838": "gonna go to a cat cafe here they don't", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00046-00018839-00019015": "want to look at the Casa to really care", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00047-00019016-00019251": "I have experience with cat cafes already", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00048-00019252-00019510": "Montreal Canada was a really nice place", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00049-00019511-00019756": "to stay it was chill and it wasn't too", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00050-00019757-00022060": "stressful of a city super warm which is", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00051-00022061-00022765": "like 41 degrees Fahrenheit the day", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00052-00022766-00022936": "before I left I spent some time and my", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00053-00022937-00023158": "sister she's been so helpful to me", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00054-00023159-00023341": "during all this time and she's the", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00055-00023342-00023512": "reason that I came to Canada in the", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00056-00023513-00023716": "first place it's very important to have", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00057-00023717-00024300": "support of people who love you", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00058-00024301-00024903": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00059-00024904-00025210": "my life has been [__] messy and she", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00060-00025211-00032150": "doesn't judge me for it so I need to", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00061-00032151-00032452": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00062-00032453-00032907": "I think I always get like try anxiety", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00063-00032908-00033129": "before I go traveling again everything", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00064-00033130-00033308": "is hitting me at once because this is", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00065-00033309-00033571": "kind of like a new start to a new life", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00066-00033572-00033786": "because I've had to abandon a lot of", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00067-00033787-00034092": "things lately and it's all hitting me", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00068-00034093-00034418": "and it's kind of you know the first day", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00069-00034419-00034792": "of school again or just this feeling of", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00070-00034793-00035301": "loss but also this feeling of something", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00071-00035302-00035552": "new so it's really hard to process and", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00072-00035553-00035964": "realize what I've lost what I might make", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00073-00035965-00036311": "a NAND kind of accept the unknown now", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00074-00036312-00036723": "and be strong go out again and just", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00075-00036724-00036974": "accept whatever is gonna happen tomorrow", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00076-00036975-00037404": "I have to suck it all up and get", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00077-00037405-00037640": "everything done and go so I can be", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00078-00037641-00037796": "emotional tonight but tomorrow I have to", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00079-00037797-00038229": "just have to do and it's this is a good", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00080-00038230-00038330": "thing I don't you guys think it's a bad", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00081-00038331-00038552": "thing I need this I need to start my", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00082-00038553-00038608": "life again", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00083-00038609-00038814": "sometimes you're not ready sometimes you", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00084-00038815-00039030": "don't feel ready maybe you'll never feel", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00085-00039031-00039207": "ready sometimes you're very unprepared", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00086-00039208-00039526": "like physically mentally financially", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00087-00039527-00039924": "logically everything so now you just", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00088-00039925-00040161": "have to do it anyways because no bar", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00089-00040162-00040427": "lights or the sugars you don't need to", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00090-00040428-00040670": "be lonely alone this is the day where", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00091-00040671-00040826": "it's time to move on just think you know", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00092-00040827-00041315": "what last night and now we go because", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00093-00041316-00041465": "I've always wanted to go to London", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00094-00041466-00041685": "forever like it's the first place I", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00095-00041686-00041867": "wanted to go but instead I kind of", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00096-00041868-00042057": "hopped around to different to different", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00097-00042058-00042257": "places that wasn't London I'm hoping", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00098-00042258-00042426": "with this trip it will give me more", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00099-00042427-00042692": "clarity mmm I'm a type of person I don't", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00100-00042693-00042855": "know if it's cuz I'm autistic or what", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00101-00042856-00043127": "but I can't envision things unless I", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00102-00043128-00043313": "actually experience them I can't", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00103-00043314-00043445": "understand concepts unless I actually", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00104-00043446-00043712": "experience or see them so the reason I", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00105-00043713-00043851": "travel around so much is because I'm", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00106-00043852-00043988": "trying to find somewhere that really", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00107-00043989-00044276": "resonates with me and that I want to put", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00108-00044277-00044519": "a base at because it's going to take a", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00109-00044520-00044685": "lot of work to get citizenship wherever", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00110-00044686-00044854": "unless I live in", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00111-00044855-00045016": "oh I don't really want to yeah I just", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00112-00045017-00045220": "want to see what all is out there I", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00113-00045221-00045943": "found some opening on this Airbnb my", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00114-00045944-00046240": "sister gave me that potato it started to", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00115-00046241-00046402": "sprout that with the heart", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00116-00046403-00046774": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00117-00046775-00046907": "Oh", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00118-00046908-00048986": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00119-00048987-00049370": "so I just arrived in London", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00120-00049371-00049703": "grilled me parkour", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00121-00049704-00049916": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00122-00049917-00050147": "I don't know why that's the first time", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00123-00050148-00050288": "that have been questioned so hard for", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00124-00050289-00050504": "and they're like do you have a returning", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00125-00050505-00050690": "thinking you know like no they're like", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00126-00050691-00050930": "just question be like whole house how", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00127-00050931-00051050": "can you prove that you're not going to", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00128-00051051-00051515": "overstay their I'm like", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00129-00051516-00051786": "her so I don't know I had a show that my", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00130-00051787-00052086": "bank account for like you know there's", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00131-00052087-00052275": "already a guy there like you know this", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00132-00052276-00052481": "expensive he's like he's like you know", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00133-00052482-00052691": "what you need to plan better next time", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00134-00052692-00053115": "and I'm like yes yes I'm sorry I usually", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00135-00053116-00053253": "I play on things really well", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00136-00053254-00053523": "just kidding yeah yeah next I didn't", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00137-00053524-00053705": "have a good welcome here so I'm just", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00138-00053707-00053894": "like new and then like I didn't sleep at", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00139-00053895-00054107": "all and people are watching me vlog but", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00140-00054108-00054338": "I I just I don't care I need to find the", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00141-00054339-00054530": "train and I need to go if read it he's", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00142-00054532-00054747": "also like you mean it with the friends", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00143-00054748-00055142": "who's this friend boy Brian I don't know", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00144-00055144-00055296": "how to explain a friend he's like how do", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00145-00055297-00055686": "you know her and like real like a social", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00146-00055687-00056040": "media account I'm like he's like how", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00147-00056041-00056571": "many like and yeah it's like so you've", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00148-00056572-00056829": "never been a person I'm like story of my", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00149-00056829-00057068": "life it's really hard to explain you", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00150-00057069-00057341": "know my life to people it's always it", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00151-00057342-00057474": "always teaches struggle getting tuned", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00152-00057475-00057725": "from airports my body is always so", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00153-00057726-00057912": "confused in of our hop around countries", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00154-00057913-00058128": "one damn in one country the next time in", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00155-00058129-00058290": "a different one with different time", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00156-00058291-00058560": "changes and whether my initial thoughts", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00157-00058561-00058773": "on London is it's a lot louder than", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00158-00058774-00060691": "mantra", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00159-00060691-00061054": "I've had my friends great now we're", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00160-00061055-00061202": "getting coffee because I have not slept", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00161-00061203-00061514": "I got to train after in case you want to", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00162-00061515-00061741": "know how to get from the London Airport", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00163-00061742-00062165": "that way to London Victoria you take a", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00164-00062166-00062372": "train so if the train and now you're in", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00165-00062373-00062516": "a coffee and then we're gonna take the", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00166-00062516-00062716": "metro it's a lot of thoughts like what", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00167-00062717-00062822": "am i doing", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00168-00062823-00063158": "disoriented I really got to make a lot", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00169-00063159-00063817": "of videos we're topping up the MetroCard", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00170-00063819-00064100": "another little expense to get a pay and", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00171-00064101-00064364": "there's different zones here I mean in", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00172-00064365-00064654": "London sorry their zone one two three", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00173-00064655-00065291": "four okay", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00174-00065291-00065534": "we're finally onto the new adventure and", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00175-00065535-00065738": "even though I'm a hundred percent healed", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00176-00065739-00066041": "and good to go it's still good to go", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00177-00066042-00066374": "because life is short I hope you enjoy", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00178-00066375-00066626": "this adventure with me the one thing", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00179-00066627-00066779": "that I have learned is that having good", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00180-00066780-00066998": "people around you is the most important", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00181-00066999-00067219": "thing in any", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00182-00067220-00068499": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00183-00068500-00068772": "go get it", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00184-00068773-00069004": "going grocery shopping for the first", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00185-00069005-00069238": "time this is the British the British", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00186-00069239-00069520": "Walmart it's called astha you've got", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00187-00069521-00069793": "pulp no calls there's a lot of orange", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00188-00069794-00070181": "juice here impressive my good leggings", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00189-00070182-00070385": "some crashing from teacher things a copy", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00190-00070386-00070669": "and I keep getting overwhelmed by um", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00191-00070670-00071034": "people I like for the past two months", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00192-00071035-00071241": "I've literally been depressed in bed not", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00193-00071242-00071363": "really seeing a lot of people and if I", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00194-00071364-00071585": "do it's just like one person a week on", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00195-00071586-00071729": "time yeah and it's only like a couple", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00196-00071730-00072013": "hours so I'm like", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00197-00072014-00072455": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00198-00072456-00072686": "go get it", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00199-00072687-00073490": "[Music]", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00200-00073491-00073896": "so welcome to England I hope you'll stay", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00201-00073897-00073973": "around", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00202-00073974-00074474": "join me on my adventures here I know", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00203-00074475-00074636": "this vlog wasn't like a ton of", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00204-00074637-00074849": "excitement because I just got here but", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00205-00074850-00075005": "we did do some stuff and haven't slept", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00206-00075006-00075248": "for like 24 hours so I'm really tired", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00207-00075249-00075499": "and I'm gonna chill the rest of the day", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00208-00075500-00076082": "she's making some veggie burgers look at", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00209-00076083-00076987": "what she made you've outdone yourself", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00210-00076988-00077117": "okay", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00211-00077118-00077408": "that penis new vegan protein that I got", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00212-00077409-00077822": "she's gonna fatten me up I just I", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00213-00077823-00078028": "appreciate you guys and thank you for", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00214-00078029-00078373": "not knowing what we're doing with me", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00215-00078374-00078752": "stay at rest rope and I will see you in", "i4UP_xF5BGE-00216-00078753-00079091": "the next vlog okay"}}, {"audio_id": "i4aUrg1Ac-k", "text": {"i4aUrg1Ac-k-00000-00000003-00000269": "so what exactly is Universal Design for", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00001-00000270-00000337": "Learning", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00002-00000338-00000521": "well since it's based on Universal", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00003-00000522-00000676": "Design we can pretty much go with that", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00004-00000677-00000860": "same definition and just add that for", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00005-00000861-00001097": "learning but in particular UDL is based", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00006-00001098-00001310": "on two assumptions the first lies in", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00007-00001311-00001453": "research suggesting that learning", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00008-00001454-00001651": "involves three specific areas of our", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00009-00001652-00001876": "brains and the second that there's not", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00010-00001877-00002147": "only one way to learn these assumptions", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00011-00002148-00002408": "are embodied within three UDL principles", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00012-00002409-00002605": "providing multiple means of engagement", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00013-00002606-00002795": "multiple means of action and expression", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00014-00002796-00003098": "and multiple means of representation now", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00015-00003099-00003242": "usually we see these three principles", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00016-00003243-00003458": "lined up like this with three different", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00017-00003459-00003679": "images of the brains I also like to look", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00018-00003680-00003811": "at it like this because we don't have", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00019-00003812-00003956": "three different brains it's all", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00020-00003957-00004111": "different parts of the same brain and", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00021-00004112-00004283": "these are different networks that work", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00022-00004284-00004472": "together so the central networks in this", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00023-00004473-00004688": "image are the affective they are related", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00024-00004689-00004886": "to caring about why we are learning and", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00025-00004887-00005104": "at the front we can see the strategic", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00026-00005105-00005254": "networks so how we're going to go about", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00027-00005255-00005422": "learning and towards the back or the", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00028-00005423-00005579": "recognition networks and that's where we", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00029-00005580-00005759": "recognize what we're learning so these", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00030-00005760-00005984": "three principles from UDL come along", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00031-00005985-00006154": "with some guidelines that can be helpful", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00032-00006155-00006281": "when we're looking at how we're going to", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00033-00006282-00006464": "be providing choice when we design our", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00034-00006465-00006641": "learning environments and our learning", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00035-00006642-00006902": "situations and what about this idea of", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00036-00006903-00007031": "there's not only one way to learn", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00037-00007031-00007217": "because that brings along with it the", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00038-00007218-00007352": "idea that there's not only one way to", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00039-00007353-00007577": "teach so how do we address that an", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00040-00007578-00007751": "integral element of each one of those", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00041-00007752-00007967": "principles has to do with choice but", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00042-00007968-00008162": "remembering not too much because that", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00043-00008163-00008330": "can be really overwhelming however if", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00044-00008331-00008477": "you're able to provide a certain amount", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00045-00008478-00008681": "of choice in regards to why we're", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00046-00008682-00008878": "engaging with content with what we're", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00047-00008879-00009023": "learning as well as how we're going to", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00048-00009024-00009178": "be learning that I think we're really", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00049-00009179-00009364": "beginning to encompass the flexibility", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00050-00009365-00009587": "equity and accessibility that is really", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00051-00009588-00009728": "at the heart of Universal Design for", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00052-00009729-00009892": "Learning what is unique about this", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00053-00009893-00010078": "approach is that quite often in our", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00054-00010079-00010231": "classrooms you respond to different", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00055-00010232-00010406": "needs and it's very much a reactive", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00056-00010407-00010580": "approach by responding to different", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00057-00010581-00010813": "needs we create accommodations based on", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00058-00010814-00011071": "the needs that are presented to us UDL", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00059-00011072-00011285": "is very proactive in that we anticipate", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00060-00011286-00011471": "the possible needs when we are building", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00061-00011472-00011627": "our courses and learning situations", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00062-00011628-00011824": "because of this it actually relieves", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00063-00011825-00012002": "some of the pressure on the teacher so", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00064-00012003-00012139": "that while learning is happening we", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00065-00012140-00012274": "don't need to stop and try to figure out", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00066-00012275-00012403": "how to make it work for different people", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00067-00012404-00012734": "we just plan for that from the get-go by", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00068-00012735-00012968": "anticipating obstacles and planning for", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00069-00012969-00013133": "opening access to learning we can", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00070-00013134-00013297": "maintain that balance between", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00071-00013298-00013379": "instruction", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00072-00013380-00013544": "and learning that is really at the heart", "i4aUrg1Ac-k-00073-00013544-00013897": "of a student-teacher relationship"}}, {"audio_id": "i4cie5o-Knc", "text": {"i4cie5o-Knc-00000-00000057-00002883": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00001-00002884-00003066": "do", "i4cie5o-Knc-00002-00003067-00004283": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00003-00004284-00004588": "is", "i4cie5o-Knc-00004-00004589-00005313": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00005-00005314-00005683": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00006-00005684-00006187": "was", "i4cie5o-Knc-00007-00006188-00007305": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00008-00007306-00009883": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00009-00009884-00010057": "food", "i4cie5o-Knc-00010-00010058-00011548": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00011-00011549-00012227": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00012-00012228-00012683": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00013-00012684-00013755": "foreign", "i4cie5o-Knc-00014-00013756-00014083": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00015-00014084-00015103": "uh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00016-00015104-00018716": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00017-00018717-00021083": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00018-00021084-00021290": "good", "i4cie5o-Knc-00019-00021291-00022483": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00020-00022484-00022616": "um", "i4cie5o-Knc-00021-00022617-00023903": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00022-00023904-00027160": "shake it", "i4cie5o-Knc-00023-00027161-00029483": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00024-00029483-00030475": "me", "i4cie5o-Knc-00025-00030476-00031568": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00026-00031569-00032458": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00027-00032460-00033683": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00028-00033684-00034134": "this", "i4cie5o-Knc-00029-00034135-00037095": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00030-00037096-00037899": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00031-00037900-00039283": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00032-00039284-00039591": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00033-00039592-00040157": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00034-00040158-00041275": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00035-00041276-00042083": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00036-00042084-00043483": "me", "i4cie5o-Knc-00037-00043484-00043877": "oh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00038-00043878-00044883": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00039-00044884-00045196": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00040-00045197-00047553": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00041-00047554-00048614": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00042-00048615-00049083": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00043-00049084-00049210": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00044-00049211-00050272": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00045-00050273-00050819": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00046-00050820-00051691": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00047-00051692-00051854": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00048-00051855-00052283": "i think", "i4cie5o-Knc-00049-00052284-00053282": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00050-00053283-00053654": "she", "i4cie5o-Knc-00051-00053654-00054298": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00052-00054299-00055664": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00053-00055665-00057482": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00054-00057483-00058882": "uh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00055-00058883-00060900": "oh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00056-00060901-00061682": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00057-00061683-00061866": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00058-00061867-00062027": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00059-00062028-00062364": "[Applause]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00060-00062365-00063082": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00061-00063083-00063305": "foreign", "i4cie5o-Knc-00062-00063307-00063886": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00063-00063887-00064482": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00064-00065332-00065882": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00065-00065883-00066497": "this", "i4cie5o-Knc-00066-00066498-00067282": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00067-00067283-00067836": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00068-00067837-00068509": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00069-00068510-00068682": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00070-00068683-00071482": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00071-00071483-00072882": "hmm", "i4cie5o-Knc-00072-00072883-00073233": "uh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00073-00073234-00074282": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00074-00074283-00074614": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00075-00074615-00075126": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00076-00075127-00075682": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00077-00075683-00075916": "oh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00078-00075917-00077082": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00079-00077083-00077483": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00080-00077484-00079662": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00081-00079663-00079882": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00082-00079883-00082565": "uh uh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00083-00082566-00084082": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00084-00084083-00084270": "uh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00085-00084271-00085482": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00086-00085483-00085695": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00087-00085696-00086882": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00088-00086883-00088282": "uh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00089-00088283-00092243": "yes", "i4cie5o-Knc-00090-00092244-00093882": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00091-00093883-00095282": "oh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00092-00095283-00095481": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00093-00095482-00096352": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00094-00096353-00097100": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00095-00097101-00099482": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00096-00099483-00100017": "uh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00097-00100018-00101405": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00098-00101406-00101978": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00099-00101979-00102282": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00100-00102283-00103682": "yes", "i4cie5o-Knc-00101-00103683-00105644": "oh", "i4cie5o-Knc-00102-00105645-00108703": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00103-00108704-00109283": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00104-00109283-00109441": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00105-00109442-00110408": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00106-00110409-00110683": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00107-00110683-00111235": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00108-00111236-00114883": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00109-00114883-00116283": "hey", "i4cie5o-Knc-00110-00116283-00117683": "so", "i4cie5o-Knc-00111-00117683-00118051": "hey", "i4cie5o-Knc-00112-00118052-00120074": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00113-00120075-00120994": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00114-00120995-00122423": "[Music]", "i4cie5o-Knc-00115-00122424-00122632": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i527IYbIFuu", "text": {"i527IYbIFuu-00000-00000012-00001570": "the screen yes please go ahead no", "i527IYbIFuu-00001-00001571-00001775": "right so now you see the presentation", "i527IYbIFuu-00002-00001776-00002560": "only right", "i527IYbIFuu-00003-00002561-00002826": "in the slides sorry I I yeah yes yes", "i527IYbIFuu-00004-00002827-00003137": "okay yeah so it's better to double check", "i527IYbIFuu-00005-00003138-00003370": "sometimes", "i527IYbIFuu-00006-00003371-00003695": "um okay so yeah this is um end of the or", "i527IYbIFuu-00007-00003696-00003947": "almost end of the uh planner session day", "i527IYbIFuu-00008-00003947-00004175": "so you're probably really exhausted by", "i527IYbIFuu-00009-00004176-00004349": "nice and", "i527IYbIFuu-00010-00004350-00004553": "um aggressive presentations and I will", "i527IYbIFuu-00011-00004554-00004806": "try to keep this as fresh as possible", "i527IYbIFuu-00012-00004807-00005122": "the idea of this talk is to introduce", "i527IYbIFuu-00013-00005123-00005417": "our implementation of the sixth dish", "i527IYbIFuu-00014-00005418-00005554": "stack", "i527IYbIFuu-00015-00005555-00005759": "um and its application for avionic", "i527IYbIFuu-00016-00005760-00006022": "wireless sensor networks in onward plus", "i527IYbIFuu-00017-00006023-00006106": "plus", "i527IYbIFuu-00018-00006107-00006370": "we are um The Institute of communication", "i527IYbIFuu-00019-00006371-00006653": "networks from Hamburg University of", "i527IYbIFuu-00020-00006654-00006977": "Technology and my name is I'm the", "i527IYbIFuu-00021-00006978-00007091": "presenter", "i527IYbIFuu-00022-00007092-00007396": "so the agenda is pretty simple we start", "i527IYbIFuu-00023-00007397-00007631": "off with a short introduction um about", "i527IYbIFuu-00024-00007631-00007942": "the the topic where this protocol stack", "i527IYbIFuu-00025-00007943-00008242": "that I mentioned can be applied", "i527IYbIFuu-00026-00008243-00008495": "um followed by a bit of background on", "i527IYbIFuu-00027-00008496-00008669": "the challenge we had to solve with this", "i527IYbIFuu-00028-00008670-00009010": "protocol stack and then the important", "i527IYbIFuu-00029-00009011-00009269": "part implementation details a bit more", "i527IYbIFuu-00030-00009270-00009577": "in depth look at the different", "i527IYbIFuu-00031-00009578-00009905": "implemented parts and layers because", "i527IYbIFuu-00032-00009906-00010169": "this is a protocol stack and finally", "i527IYbIFuu-00033-00010170-00010423": "some hopefully entertaining demos", "i527IYbIFuu-00034-00010424-00010655": "related to the", "i527IYbIFuu-00035-00010656-00010949": "uh to the next layer mostly", "i527IYbIFuu-00036-00010950-00011381": "and some closing words uh as and future", "i527IYbIFuu-00037-00011382-00011609": "work as an Outlook", "i527IYbIFuu-00038-00011610-00011759": "so starting off with the introduction", "i527IYbIFuu-00039-00011760-00012196": "the area is the wireless sensor networks", "i527IYbIFuu-00040-00012197-00012485": "and um they are being deployed more and", "i527IYbIFuu-00041-00012486-00012742": "more in different areas such as home", "i527IYbIFuu-00042-00012743-00012983": "such as a smart home Industrial", "i527IYbIFuu-00043-00012984-00013277": "Automation different medical monitoring", "i527IYbIFuu-00044-00013278-00013643": "or agricultural monitoring use cases and", "i527IYbIFuu-00045-00013644-00013888": "all of this all of it all of the", "i527IYbIFuu-00046-00013890-00014219": "collected data has been forwarded to", "i527IYbIFuu-00047-00014219-00014380": "some gateways to the internet and", "i527IYbIFuu-00048-00014381-00014657": "finally it's available to us to the end", "i527IYbIFuu-00049-00014658-00014813": "users", "i527IYbIFuu-00050-00014813-00014927": "um however there are a number of", "i527IYbIFuu-00051-00014928-00015227": "challenges involved with deploying vsns", "i527IYbIFuu-00052-00015228-00015491": "in particular we need often high enough", "i527IYbIFuu-00053-00015491-00015707": "reliability for example for this", "i527IYbIFuu-00054-00015708-00016019": "automation scenario or a scalability if", "i527IYbIFuu-00055-00016019-00016403": "we want to cover really huge areas with", "i527IYbIFuu-00056-00016404-00016708": "some sensor nodes also interpret", "i527IYbIFuu-00057-00016709-00016925": "interoperability is a concern because", "i527IYbIFuu-00058-00016926-00017179": "there are already a lot of existing", "i527IYbIFuu-00059-00017180-00017536": "Technologies and for example tcpip stack", "i527IYbIFuu-00060-00017537-00017794": "which is deployed everywhere so it's", "i527IYbIFuu-00061-00017795-00018149": "nice that if new solutions would be", "i527IYbIFuu-00062-00018150-00018371": "backwards compatible with that and also", "i527IYbIFuu-00063-00018372-00018586": "the Energy Efficiency is often a", "i527IYbIFuu-00064-00018587-00018911": "challenge because the modes or the nodes", "i527IYbIFuu-00065-00018912-00019141": "are deployed in remote areas and", "i527IYbIFuu-00066-00019142-00019541": "frequent mappings is pretty costly", "i527IYbIFuu-00067-00019542-00019786": "in order to solve these challenges a", "i527IYbIFuu-00068-00019787-00020077": "standard has been developed namely this", "i527IYbIFuu-00069-00020078-00020443": "802.15.4 which defines the lower layers", "i527IYbIFuu-00070-00020444-00020686": "architecture that is the the data link", "i527IYbIFuu-00071-00020687-00020986": "and physical layers to operate these", "i527IYbIFuu-00072-00020987-00021311": "wireless sensor Networks and in this", "i527IYbIFuu-00073-00021312-00021527": "presentation we will be looking or", "i527IYbIFuu-00074-00021528-00021935": "taking a deeper look at the so-called", "i527IYbIFuu-00075-00021936-00022186": "Tisch Mac protocol which is a part of", "i527IYbIFuu-00076-00022187-00022367": "the 16.4 standard", "i527IYbIFuu-00077-00022368-00022625": "and one of the protocol Stacks which was", "i527IYbIFuu-00078-00022626-00022853": "developed on top of the 16.4 standard", "i527IYbIFuu-00079-00022854-00023189": "called six dish there are of course also", "i527IYbIFuu-00080-00023190-00023483": "a lot of other protocol Stacks also", "i527IYbIFuu-00081-00023484-00023764": "prominent commercial ones like ZB that", "i527IYbIFuu-00082-00023765-00024077": "are using 15.4 so I'm pretty sure", "i527IYbIFuu-00083-00024078-00024335": "um most of you have um one way or the", "i527IYbIFuu-00084-00024336-00024586": "other some kind of smart sensors or", "i527IYbIFuu-00085-00024587-00024730": "lights at home", "i527IYbIFuu-00086-00024731-00024899": "um for example Ikea ones which use", "i527IYbIFuu-00087-00024900-00025194": "zigbee under the hood", "i527IYbIFuu-00088-00025195-00025690": "so the Tish is abbreviation for time", "i527IYbIFuu-00089-00025691-00025925": "slotted Channel dropping meaning that", "i527IYbIFuu-00090-00025926-00026056": "communication does not happen", "i527IYbIFuu-00091-00026057-00026249": "sporadically so if we want to set", "i527IYbIFuu-00092-00026250-00026587": "something send something we just send no", "i527IYbIFuu-00093-00026588-00026951": "the time is slotted into these um well", "i527IYbIFuu-00094-00026952-00027287": "yeah time slots and together with a", "i527IYbIFuu-00095-00027288-00027443": "particular frequency they Define", "i527IYbIFuu-00096-00027444-00027695": "so-called cell meaning that", "i527IYbIFuu-00097-00027695-00027862": "communication between pair of nodes", "i527IYbIFuu-00098-00027863-00028157": "occur in these cells and", "i527IYbIFuu-00099-00028158-00028223": "um", "i527IYbIFuu-00100-00028224-00028601": "the hopping part means that in every", "i527IYbIFuu-00101-00028602-00028799": "cell which repeats over time", "i527IYbIFuu-00102-00028800-00029027": "periodically we do not use the same", "i527IYbIFuu-00103-00029027-00029224": "frequency but rather hop over", "i527IYbIFuu-00104-00029225-00029489": "frequencies using some predefined", "i527IYbIFuu-00105-00029489-00029735": "copying sequence this allows us to avoid", "i527IYbIFuu-00106-00029736-00029993": "some internal and external interference", "i527IYbIFuu-00107-00029994-00030251": "because if you imagine uh there is for", "i527IYbIFuu-00108-00030252-00030533": "example a Wi-Fi network deployed nearby", "i527IYbIFuu-00109-00030533-00030755": "which uses a particular Wi-Fi Channel", "i527IYbIFuu-00110-00030756-00031037": "then by changing the frequency of our", "i527IYbIFuu-00111-00031038-00031402": "own transmission on every cell we can", "i527IYbIFuu-00112-00031404-00031758": "avoid that interference", "i527IYbIFuu-00113-00031760-00031918": "now", "i527IYbIFuu-00114-00031919-00032177": "um the paths which are implemented the", "i527IYbIFuu-00115-00032177-00032339": "part of the six digit tag which are", "i527IYbIFuu-00116-00032339-00032479": "implemented", "i527IYbIFuu-00117-00032480-00032812": "By Us in and that I want to like", "i527IYbIFuu-00118-00032813-00033023": "Showcase in this presentation are the", "i527IYbIFuu-00119-00033024-00033196": "highlighting the highlighted ones here", "i527IYbIFuu-00120-00033197-00033521": "so the whole stack uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00121-00033522-00033833": "looks as follows and um you can see it", "i527IYbIFuu-00122-00033834-00033895": "um", "i527IYbIFuu-00123-00033896-00034252": "connects to some existing protocols for", "i527IYbIFuu-00124-00034253-00034439": "example it borrows the the transporter", "i527IYbIFuu-00125-00034440-00034524": "Network", "i527IYbIFuu-00126-00034525-00034877": "layers from existing stacks and defines", "i527IYbIFuu-00127-00034878-00035255": "its own routing layer which is RPL and", "i527IYbIFuu-00128-00035256-00035555": "some extra link layer controls in the", "i527IYbIFuu-00129-00035556-00035812": "form of scheduling function and six dot", "i527IYbIFuu-00130-00035813-00035993": "protocol and the idea of scaling", "i527IYbIFuu-00131-00035994-00036287": "function is clearly to manage these", "i527IYbIFuu-00132-00036288-00036407": "cells which I showed on the previous", "i527IYbIFuu-00133-00036408-00036935": "slide so install them delete and so on", "i527IYbIFuu-00134-00036936-00037162": "the RPL", "i527IYbIFuu-00135-00037163-00037390": "um this routing protocol for low power", "i527IYbIFuu-00136-00037391-00037690": "and losing networks is nothing more as a", "i527IYbIFuu-00137-00037691-00037996": "uh this tree light or it builds this", "i527IYbIFuu-00138-00037997-00038374": "tree-like structure uh for a uh almost", "i527IYbIFuu-00139-00038375-00038674": "random or any deployment of sensor nodes", "i527IYbIFuu-00140-00038675-00039023": "in order to collect data in a multi-hope", "i527IYbIFuu-00141-00039024-00039424": "fashion from every node at this sync it", "i527IYbIFuu-00142-00039425-00039665": "also supports downlink communication and", "i527IYbIFuu-00143-00039666-00040061": "each node is assigned a specific value", "i527IYbIFuu-00144-00040062-00040349": "called rank which denotes some abstract", "i527IYbIFuu-00145-00040350-00040649": "distance from this node to the sink", "i527IYbIFuu-00146-00040650-00040924": "the this tree structure is usually", "i527IYbIFuu-00147-00040925-00041230": "called uh door deck which is um which", "i527IYbIFuu-00148-00041231-00041471": "stands for Destination oriented and", "i527IYbIFuu-00149-00041472-00041752": "directed acyclic graph so intro just", "i527IYbIFuu-00150-00041753-00042118": "door deck it's easy to remember", "i527IYbIFuu-00151-00042119-00042395": "and there is one more complication or a", "i527IYbIFuu-00152-00042396-00042737": "lot of rather complexity that can be", "i527IYbIFuu-00153-00042738-00043121": "added on top of already existing uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00154-00043122-00043355": "scheduling capabilities in sixish namely", "i527IYbIFuu-00155-00043356-00043757": "the scaling function uh the standard was", "i527IYbIFuu-00156-00043758-00043961": "rather the protocol specification of six", "i527IYbIFuu-00157-00043962-00044255": "dish does not define the default scaling", "i527IYbIFuu-00158-00044256-00044507": "function but there is one which is now", "i527IYbIFuu-00159-00044508-00044657": "really close to being called a", "i527IYbIFuu-00160-00044658-00044830": "standardized and that is a minimal", "i527IYbIFuu-00161-00044831-00045073": "Skilling function which", "i527IYbIFuu-00162-00045074-00045335": "adds some features with respect to", "i527IYbIFuu-00163-00045336-00045605": "traffic adaptation interference", "i527IYbIFuu-00164-00045606-00045930": "avoidance and also has a number of", "i527IYbIFuu-00165-00045931-00046224": "distinct cell types that are scheduled", "i527IYbIFuu-00166-00046225-00046558": "in the slot frame and those being", "i527IYbIFuu-00167-00046559-00046912": "dedicated shared and minimal cell so the", "i527IYbIFuu-00168-00046913-00047099": "idea is pretty straightforward dedicated", "i527IYbIFuu-00169-00047100-00047321": "cell is reserved for unigast", "i527IYbIFuu-00170-00047322-00047596": "communication from a node to its rooting", "i527IYbIFuu-00171-00047597-00047962": "parent rooting parent the shared cell is", "i527IYbIFuu-00172-00047963-00048190": "for many to one communication and uses", "i527IYbIFuu-00173-00048191-00048485": "some back-off mechanism to resolve", "i527IYbIFuu-00174-00048486-00048821": "collisions whereas a minimal cell uses", "i527IYbIFuu-00175-00048822-00048917": "the", "i527IYbIFuu-00176-00048918-00049139": "what is used to broadcast control", "i527IYbIFuu-00177-00049140-00049379": "traffic and build the topology as you", "i527IYbIFuu-00178-00049380-00049762": "will see in the demo section", "i527IYbIFuu-00179-00049763-00049967": "the background or rather the the", "i527IYbIFuu-00180-00049968-00050189": "motivation behind developing or", "i527IYbIFuu-00181-00050190-00050386": "Implement products or implementing the", "i527IYbIFuu-00182-00050387-00050873": "60s stack in omnet was uh or is tied to", "i527IYbIFuu-00183-00050874-00051335": "a use case in avionics so there is a", "i527IYbIFuu-00184-00051336-00051604": "in standardization uh thing called", "i527IYbIFuu-00185-00051605-00051785": "Wireless ebony intro Communications", "i527IYbIFuu-00186-00051786-00052063": "which aims to replace some of the wired", "i527IYbIFuu-00187-00052064-00052264": "connections on the airplane with the", "i527IYbIFuu-00188-00052265-00052488": "wireless counterparts to save some costs", "i527IYbIFuu-00189-00052489-00052853": "maintenance time and also improve the", "i527IYbIFuu-00190-00052854-00053116": "the redundancy as you can imagine there", "i527IYbIFuu-00191-00053117-00053291": "are different types of sensors that can", "i527IYbIFuu-00192-00053291-00053591": "be placed in an aircraft namely uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00193-00053591-00053794": "non-critical ones for example some", "i527IYbIFuu-00194-00053795-00054161": "Communications internal or quality of", "i527IYbIFuu-00195-00054162-00054466": "life sensors like air quality for", "i527IYbIFuu-00196-00054467-00054773": "example or Community whatever but", "i527IYbIFuu-00197-00054774-00054899": "there's also the possibility of", "i527IYbIFuu-00198-00054900-00055123": "deploying some safety critical", "i527IYbIFuu-00199-00055124-00055553": "modes to monitor engine sensors or smoke", "i527IYbIFuu-00200-00055554-00055732": "alarms or", "i527IYbIFuu-00201-00055733-00056044": "similar things which naturally impose", "i527IYbIFuu-00202-00056045-00056429": "high quality of service requirements", "i527IYbIFuu-00203-00056429-00056632": "and to understand what kind of cultural", "i527IYbIFuu-00204-00056633-00056837": "service requirements are or challenges", "i527IYbIFuu-00205-00056838-00057041": "were present", "i527IYbIFuu-00206-00057041-00057329": "um work we which cultural service", "i527IYbIFuu-00207-00057329-00057587": "challenges we encountered while", "i527IYbIFuu-00208-00057588-00057880": "um using 60 stack for this avionic use", "i527IYbIFuu-00209-00057882-00058157": "case I will use the following picture so", "i527IYbIFuu-00210-00058158-00058432": "the first problem occurred already in", "i527IYbIFuu-00211-00058433-00058709": "the simplest communication pattern from", "i527IYbIFuu-00212-00058710-00059129": "a source node to sync in the Uplink you", "i527IYbIFuu-00213-00059129-00059453": "can see the two links with the cell", "i527IYbIFuu-00214-00059454-00059753": "location specified in the square bracket", "i527IYbIFuu-00215-00059754-00060076": "uh the first value is the slot offset", "i527IYbIFuu-00216-00060077-00060353": "the second one is the channel offset", "i527IYbIFuu-00217-00060354-00060575": "um well well that's this doesn't look", "i527IYbIFuu-00218-00060576-00060797": "like a like problematic", "i527IYbIFuu-00219-00060798-00061253": "scenario um the arrangement of these uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00220-00061254-00061553": "transfer of these cells so A to B and A", "i527IYbIFuu-00221-00061554-00061715": "B to sync", "i527IYbIFuu-00222-00061716-00061859": "um is pretty unfavorable in the sense", "i527IYbIFuu-00223-00061860-00062147": "that a node being transmitted from a I", "i527IYbIFuu-00224-00062148-00062399": "would have to wait all of this um extra", "i527IYbIFuu-00225-00062400-00062657": "time slots highlighted in red", "i527IYbIFuu-00226-00062658-00062897": "before finally reaching the sink so", "i527IYbIFuu-00227-00062898-00063047": "there is some potential or there was", "i527IYbIFuu-00228-00063048-00063323": "some potential to optimize these or", "i527IYbIFuu-00229-00063324-00063671": "these multiple paths and also if on the", "i527IYbIFuu-00230-00063672-00063887": "other hand if we consider downlink", "i527IYbIFuu-00231-00063888-00064150": "communication where a single packet has", "i527IYbIFuu-00232-00064151-00064265": "to be transmitted to multiple", "i527IYbIFuu-00233-00064266-00064432": "destinations", "i527IYbIFuu-00234-00064433-00064679": "um normally there is only one cell", "i527IYbIFuu-00235-00064679-00065009": "between every pair of nodes so uh the", "i527IYbIFuu-00236-00065010-00065200": "and the number of these cells is adapted", "i527IYbIFuu-00237-00065201-00065441": "pretty slowly which leads to congestions", "i527IYbIFuu-00238-00065441-00065759": "on some links where we have to forward a", "i527IYbIFuu-00239-00065760-00066005": "lot of the traffic", "i527IYbIFuu-00240-00066006-00066263": "in order to solve the issues and one of", "i527IYbIFuu-00241-00066264-00066419": "the like prominent features of the six", "i527IYbIFuu-00242-00066420-00066731": "dish protocol stack is that one could", "i527IYbIFuu-00243-00066732-00066988": "leverage cross-layer communication", "i527IYbIFuu-00244-00066989-00067343": "between a routing layer and this", "i527IYbIFuu-00245-00067344-00067715": "scheduling part and exchange data such", "i527IYbIFuu-00246-00067716-00067891": "as some topological information", "i527IYbIFuu-00247-00067892-00068279": "scheduling events to improve this the", "i527IYbIFuu-00248-00068280-00068609": "schedule and meet stricter quality of", "i527IYbIFuu-00249-00068610-00068782": "service requirements for example the", "i527IYbIFuu-00250-00068783-00069035": "scaling functions can then also a custom", "i527IYbIFuu-00251-00069036-00069244": "scaling function can also", "i527IYbIFuu-00252-00069245-00069749": "schedule well any kind of cell or add", "i527IYbIFuu-00253-00069750-00070025": "some extra characterization to improve", "i527IYbIFuu-00254-00070026-00070199": "the performance for selected", "i527IYbIFuu-00255-00070200-00070469": "applications", "i527IYbIFuu-00256-00070470-00070865": "and as an example what was achieved by", "i527IYbIFuu-00257-00070866-00071063": "applying all of these cross-player", "i527IYbIFuu-00258-00071064-00071321": "communication Concepts you don't have to", "i527IYbIFuu-00259-00071322-00071525": "pay too much attention to to the", "i527IYbIFuu-00260-00071526-00071723": "abbreviations here what I want to show", "i527IYbIFuu-00261-00071724-00071837": "is that", "i527IYbIFuu-00262-00071838-00072029": "each of the bars on the left hand side", "i527IYbIFuu-00263-00072030-00072329": "before this dashed line represents a", "i527IYbIFuu-00264-00072330-00072569": "particular optimization which was", "i527IYbIFuu-00265-00072570-00072761": "developed using this cross layer", "i527IYbIFuu-00266-00072762-00072955": "communication and", "i527IYbIFuu-00267-00072956-00073313": "combined they allowed to reduce the", "i527IYbIFuu-00268-00073314-00073469": "end-to-end delay of the critical", "i527IYbIFuu-00269-00073470-00073699": "application in this case a smoke alarm", "i527IYbIFuu-00270-00073700-00074105": "to a level Beyond or sorry below one", "i527IYbIFuu-00271-00074106-00074447": "second which was the Target and it came", "i527IYbIFuu-00272-00074448-00074717": "at the cost of also reducing the slot", "i527IYbIFuu-00273-00074718-00075113": "frame size a bit from 101 time slots", "i527IYbIFuu-00274-00075114-00075431": "from the purple bar to 43 time slots", "i527IYbIFuu-00275-00075432-00075688": "which also increases the duty cycle but", "i527IYbIFuu-00276-00075689-00076138": "this is kind of an acceptable trade-off", "i527IYbIFuu-00277-00076139-00076475": "now to the more like relevant part for", "i527IYbIFuu-00278-00076476-00076619": "for this", "i527IYbIFuu-00279-00076620-00076703": "um", "i527IYbIFuu-00280-00076704-00077069": "uh conference uh the implementation so", "i527IYbIFuu-00281-00077070-00077393": "um this is a like overall or rough", "i527IYbIFuu-00282-00077394-00077585": "abstract picture of the implementation", "i527IYbIFuu-00283-00077586-00077843": "and um I know there are a lot of blocks", "i527IYbIFuu-00284-00077844-00078173": "here which uh absolutely not readable on", "i527IYbIFuu-00285-00078174-00078449": "a single slide so I will also have them", "i527IYbIFuu-00286-00078450-00078694": "in a bit more uh detail on the following", "i527IYbIFuu-00287-00078695-00078929": "slides where I where I will talk about", "i527IYbIFuu-00288-00078930-00079315": "the particular uh parts or explain them", "i527IYbIFuu-00289-00079316-00079565": "in more detail but", "i527IYbIFuu-00290-00079566-00079793": "the purpose of this particular picture", "i527IYbIFuu-00291-00079794-00080123": "is to show that we tried to follow this", "i527IYbIFuu-00292-00080124-00080362": "modular structure in terms of having a", "i527IYbIFuu-00293-00080363-00080687": "lot of modules to", "i527IYbIFuu-00294-00080688-00080862": "work with like", "i527IYbIFuu-00295-00080863-00081137": "delegated UH responsibilities or", "i527IYbIFuu-00296-00081138-00081509": "functions and um allow these modules to", "i527IYbIFuu-00297-00081510-00081809": "be replaced or extended to enable a", "i527IYbIFuu-00298-00081810-00082193": "better prototyping of some custom", "i527IYbIFuu-00299-00082194-00082519": "Solutions and in particular this", "i527IYbIFuu-00300-00082520-00082871": "interface for the scaling functions is", "i527IYbIFuu-00301-00082872-00082956": "um", "i527IYbIFuu-00302-00082957-00083225": "pretty important in the sense that there", "i527IYbIFuu-00303-00083226-00083411": "is no scheduling function defined by", "i527IYbIFuu-00304-00083412-00083819": "default but uh the minimal scaling", "i527IYbIFuu-00305-00083820-00083999": "function which is implemented is an", "i527IYbIFuu-00306-00084000-00084323": "example of how one could approach uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00307-00084324-00084481": "this uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00308-00084482-00084826": "scheduling uh problem in the sixth dish", "i527IYbIFuu-00309-00084827-00085253": "so in a bit more detail RPL is pretty so", "i527IYbIFuu-00310-00085254-00085523": "screwing protocol is pretty simple", "i527IYbIFuu-00311-00085524-00085697": "has a pretty simple structure in the", "i527IYbIFuu-00312-00085698-00085912": "sense that there are just three modules", "i527IYbIFuu-00313-00085913-00086173": "which are responsible for", "i527IYbIFuu-00314-00086174-00086526": "joining or leaving this topology", "i527IYbIFuu-00315-00086527-00086806": "root Discovery via some special control", "i527IYbIFuu-00316-00086807-00087131": "messages a detection of Loops routing", "i527IYbIFuu-00317-00087132-00087341": "loops and their repair as well as", "i527IYbIFuu-00318-00087342-00087575": "maintaining uh Version Control of the", "i527IYbIFuu-00319-00087576-00087826": "whole topology which is performed by the", "i527IYbIFuu-00320-00087827-00088156": "sync node and the core RPL module is", "i527IYbIFuu-00321-00088157-00088415": "responsible for all of these tasks while", "i527IYbIFuu-00322-00088416-00088685": "the trickle timer just ensures that we", "i527IYbIFuu-00323-00088686-00088841": "do not broadcast too many control", "i527IYbIFuu-00324-00088842-00089015": "messages into the network into the", "i527IYbIFuu-00325-00089016-00089225": "network and it's kind of an assistive", "i527IYbIFuu-00326-00089226-00089488": "module in this case while the objective", "i527IYbIFuu-00327-00089489-00089932": "function defines a criteria about how to", "i527IYbIFuu-00328-00089933-00090238": "select the best preferred parent from", "i527IYbIFuu-00329-00090239-00090425": "the K from the candidate ones so like", "i527IYbIFuu-00330-00090426-00090653": "from the neighborhood basically and you", "i527IYbIFuu-00331-00090654-00090929": "can imagine we can use different metrics", "i527IYbIFuu-00332-00090930-00091223": "such as link quality hop count in a", "i527IYbIFuu-00333-00091224-00091600": "simplest case to make such a decision", "i527IYbIFuu-00334-00091601-00091943": "uh theaters implementation um comes", "i527IYbIFuu-00335-00091944-00092131": "necessarily not only with the next layer", "i527IYbIFuu-00336-00092132-00092471": "which is largely based on 15.4", "i527IYbIFuu-00337-00092472-00092675": "implementation from inet", "i527IYbIFuu-00338-00092676-00092938": "but also this six stop sub-layer which", "i527IYbIFuu-00339-00092939-00093215": "is responsible for managing the", "i527IYbIFuu-00340-00093216-00093562": "negotiations between Neighbors in terms", "i527IYbIFuu-00341-00093563-00093899": "of which cells to schedule or deschedule", "i527IYbIFuu-00342-00093900-00094241": "basically and how to handle all of the", "i527IYbIFuu-00343-00094242-00094462": "exception cases for example some", "i527IYbIFuu-00344-00094463-00094721": "inconsistencies or lost packets because", "i527IYbIFuu-00345-00094722-00094903": "there is really a lot of State", "i527IYbIFuu-00346-00094904-00095267": "maintenance there and and what you can", "i527IYbIFuu-00347-00095268-00095494": "also see is there are some also", "i527IYbIFuu-00348-00095495-00095705": "assistive classes such as this slot", "i527IYbIFuu-00349-00095706-00096011": "frame or link that are just containers", "i527IYbIFuu-00350-00096012-00096485": "to better control and visualize", "i527IYbIFuu-00351-00096486-00096881": "or organize different parts of this", "i527IYbIFuu-00352-00096882-00097438": "whole like scheduled Mac which is Tish", "i527IYbIFuu-00353-00097439-00097756": "now coming to uh more entertaining part", "i527IYbIFuu-00354-00097757-00097937": "the demos", "i527IYbIFuu-00355-00097938-00098194": "um so the very first demo is", "i527IYbIFuu-00356-00098195-00098399": "um they are not uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00357-00098400-00098668": "recorded so these are like manual", "i527IYbIFuu-00358-00098669-00098909": "animations to some extent but", "i527IYbIFuu-00359-00098910-00099238": "um I think this allows me to show a bit", "i527IYbIFuu-00360-00099239-00099532": "better particular Parts particular parts", "i527IYbIFuu-00361-00099533-00099731": "of the process and explain it so that", "i527IYbIFuu-00362-00099732-00099965": "you understand what is being actually", "i527IYbIFuu-00363-00099966-00100115": "what's actually being shown here and", "i527IYbIFuu-00364-00100116-00100456": "where to focus your attention on", "i527IYbIFuu-00365-00100457-00100649": "um the very first part what happens in", "i527IYbIFuu-00366-00100650-00100924": "the network is the bootstrapping so uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00367-00100925-00101171": "the sync node starts to build the", "i527IYbIFuu-00368-00101172-00101356": "topology by broadcasting or rather", "i527IYbIFuu-00369-00101357-00101591": "flooding control messages", "i527IYbIFuu-00370-00101592-00101879": "and this happens well gradually because", "i527IYbIFuu-00371-00101880-00102173": "in this randomly generated topology the", "i527IYbIFuu-00372-00102174-00102353": "transmission ranges are set or", "i527IYbIFuu-00373-00102354-00102604": "transmission power is set at a pretty uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00374-00102605-00102886": "small value so that we can have a really", "i527IYbIFuu-00375-00102888-00103234": "like deep multi-hop tree", "i527IYbIFuu-00376-00103235-00103492": "and while the dissemination of these", "i527IYbIFuu-00377-00103493-00103697": "control messages occurs you can also see", "i527IYbIFuu-00378-00103698-00103930": "some numbers popping up on top of a on", "i527IYbIFuu-00379-00103931-00104213": "top of nodes which are the location of", "i527IYbIFuu-00380-00104214-00104413": "the dedicated cell", "i527IYbIFuu-00381-00104414-00104686": "which a node schedules with its", "i527IYbIFuu-00382-00104688-00104825": "preferred parent", "i527IYbIFuu-00383-00104826-00105084": "because the minimal scaling function", "i527IYbIFuu-00384-00105085-00105395": "defines that once we have joined this", "i527IYbIFuu-00385-00105396-00105623": "door deck also the tree you need to have", "i527IYbIFuu-00386-00105624-00105790": "like a communication link with your", "i527IYbIFuu-00387-00105791-00106115": "parent so while the broadcast broadcast", "i527IYbIFuu-00388-00106116-00106336": "messages are being broadcasted or being", "i527IYbIFuu-00389-00106338-00106733": "provided in the minimal cell notes", "i527IYbIFuu-00390-00106733-00106901": "um which have already joined the tree", "i527IYbIFuu-00391-00106902-00107152": "are also ensuring this minimal", "i527IYbIFuu-00392-00107153-00107458": "connectivity step by step until all of", "i527IYbIFuu-00393-00107459-00107693": "the nodes that were in the range are", "i527IYbIFuu-00394-00107694-00108052": "fortunate for this note 10 and 12. have", "i527IYbIFuu-00395-00108053-00108478": "joined the door deck", "i527IYbIFuu-00396-00108479-00108815": "further on WE once the topology is", "i527IYbIFuu-00397-00108816-00108907": "created", "i527IYbIFuu-00398-00108908-00109240": "we kind of expect some application", "i527IYbIFuu-00399-00109241-00109451": "applications to be running on the nodes", "i527IYbIFuu-00400-00109452-00109690": "and for this particular example", "i527IYbIFuu-00401-00109691-00109966": "um the each node generates one packet", "i527IYbIFuu-00402-00109967-00110177": "for slot frame which roughly equals one", "i527IYbIFuu-00403-00110178-00110513": "packet per second and as we can see with", "i527IYbIFuu-00404-00110514-00110771": "time the minimal scaling function also", "i527IYbIFuu-00405-00110772-00111034": "detects this increased amount of traffic", "i527IYbIFuu-00406-00111035-00111401": "and it tries to adapt the linked layer", "i527IYbIFuu-00407-00111402-00111677": "resources that is the number of cells to", "i527IYbIFuu-00408-00111678-00111910": "handle this traffic load which is", "i527IYbIFuu-00409-00111911-00112247": "especially important for hosts which are", "i527IYbIFuu-00410-00112248-00112552": "the probability nodes for the whole sub", "i527IYbIFuu-00411-00112553-00112702": "tree", "i527IYbIFuu-00412-00112703-00112990": "so as the time goes by we schedule more", "i527IYbIFuu-00413-00112991-00113284": "sales and now to avoid this highly", "i527IYbIFuu-00414-00113285-00113771": "congested view I switched to the to", "i527IYbIFuu-00415-00113772-00113993": "representation of number of cells rather", "i527IYbIFuu-00416-00113994-00114215": "than their particular locations", "i527IYbIFuu-00417-00114216-00114515": "so as you can see the number of cell", "i527IYbIFuu-00418-00114516-00114802": "increases until finally it reaches the", "i527IYbIFuu-00419-00114803-00114989": "um sort of like hysteresis condition", "i527IYbIFuu-00420-00114990-00115177": "where", "i527IYbIFuu-00421-00115178-00115516": "the cell utilization does not exceed", "i527IYbIFuu-00422-00115517-00115804": "certain thresholds and no more cells", "i527IYbIFuu-00423-00115805-00116075": "will be added or deleted unless there is", "i527IYbIFuu-00424-00116076-00116236": "change in traffic", "i527IYbIFuu-00425-00116238-00116578": "the final example is pretty simple and", "i527IYbIFuu-00426-00116579-00116927": "is related to handling cases where there", "i527IYbIFuu-00427-00116928-00117328": "is some intra Network collisions for two", "i527IYbIFuu-00428-00117329-00117658": "cells of independent nodes but", "i527IYbIFuu-00429-00117659-00117845": "neighboring nodes have been scheduled at", "i527IYbIFuu-00430-00117846-00118175": "the exact same location which cause of", "i527IYbIFuu-00431-00118176-00118534": "course packet loss at every transmission", "i527IYbIFuu-00432-00118535-00118925": "and msf also keeps track of this", "i527IYbIFuu-00433-00118926-00119201": "performance of each cell in terms of the", "i527IYbIFuu-00434-00119202-00119549": "packet delivery ratio and is able to", "i527IYbIFuu-00435-00119550-00119927": "relocate the cell by also using this", "i527IYbIFuu-00436-00119928-00120184": "six-stop sub layer to issue", "i527IYbIFuu-00437-00120185-00120490": "corresponding requests to the parent", "i527IYbIFuu-00438-00120491-00120923": "so after relocating both cells the", "i527IYbIFuu-00439-00120924-00121157": "interference is gone and we can receive", "i527IYbIFuu-00440-00121158-00121349": "all of the packets at the sync node", "i527IYbIFuu-00441-00121350-00121523": "again", "i527IYbIFuu-00442-00121524-00121936": "as the conclusion to after all of these", "i527IYbIFuu-00443-00121938-00122249": "demos and implementation details I can", "i527IYbIFuu-00444-00122250-00122765": "say that we have or we provide this six", "i527IYbIFuu-00445-00122766-00123166": "dish stack with extra msf implementation", "i527IYbIFuu-00446-00123167-00123502": "as open source available on GitHub in", "i527IYbIFuu-00447-00123503-00123869": "the links in the references and the", "i527IYbIFuu-00448-00123870-00124027": "example with cross-play communication", "i527IYbIFuu-00449-00124028-00124333": "has been provided here to motivate", "i527IYbIFuu-00450-00124333-00124654": "its like adoption or extension if you", "i527IYbIFuu-00451-00124655-00124836": "need to meet specific quality of service", "i527IYbIFuu-00452-00124838-00125231": "requirements it is relatively extensible", "i527IYbIFuu-00453-00125232-00125440": "in the sense that as I showed you there", "i527IYbIFuu-00454-00125441-00125766": "are a lot of", "i527IYbIFuu-00455-00125767-00126119": "fine-grained or small modules which can", "i527IYbIFuu-00456-00126120-00126299": "be replaced or extended without", "i527IYbIFuu-00457-00126300-00126466": "affecting", "i527IYbIFuu-00458-00126467-00126928": "the more complicated uh part of the", "i527IYbIFuu-00459-00126929-00127066": "framework", "i527IYbIFuu-00460-00127067-00127283": "however some of the features are still", "i527IYbIFuu-00461-00127283-00127566": "missing in particular integration with", "i527IYbIFuu-00462-00127567-00127849": "inet's icmp", "i527IYbIFuu-00463-00127850-00128201": "V6 layer as well as implementation of", "i527IYbIFuu-00464-00128202-00128489": "particular layers of this 60th protocol", "i527IYbIFuu-00465-00128490-00128813": "stack and also a migration to most", "i527IYbIFuu-00466-00128814-00128933": "up-to-date", "i527IYbIFuu-00467-00128933-00129151": "omelette and inet versions would be nice", "i527IYbIFuu-00468-00129152-00129671": "as well as some testing because as you", "i527IYbIFuu-00469-00129672-00129827": "can imagine in a distributed environment", "i527IYbIFuu-00470-00129828-00130051": "where a lot of nodes", "i527IYbIFuu-00471-00130052-00130410": "are negotiating these cells in parallel", "i527IYbIFuu-00472-00130411-00130577": "there are", "i527IYbIFuu-00473-00130578-00130727": "especially with loss in medium there are", "i527IYbIFuu-00474-00130728-00131021": "a lot of conditions uh what where when", "i527IYbIFuu-00475-00131022-00131369": "can fail so testing would be necessary", "i527IYbIFuu-00476-00131370-00131681": "necessary to avoid a headache while for", "i527IYbIFuu-00477-00131682-00131878": "example migrating became different uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00478-00131879-00132089": "inet versions", "i527IYbIFuu-00479-00132090-00132263": "thank you very much for your attention", "i527IYbIFuu-00480-00132264-00132754": "and um yeah please ask questions if you", "i527IYbIFuu-00481-00132755-00132916": "have them and here are the also the", "i527IYbIFuu-00482-00132917-00133259": "reference links I promised", "i527IYbIFuu-00483-00133260-00134477": "foreign", "i527IYbIFuu-00484-00134478-00134681": "I have a question", "i527IYbIFuu-00485-00134682-00134981": "um if I may so", "i527IYbIFuu-00486-00134982-00135101": "um you mentioned that you're working", "i527IYbIFuu-00487-00135102-00135533": "with the IPv6 part of the inet framework", "i527IYbIFuu-00488-00135534-00135809": "um I was wondering if you run into any", "i527IYbIFuu-00489-00135810-00136019": "problems with that", "i527IYbIFuu-00490-00136020-00136487": "or did you have to like fix things or uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00491-00136488-00136643": "are there things missing that you would", "i527IYbIFuu-00492-00136644-00137014": "rather have in there because I know that", "i527IYbIFuu-00493-00137015-00137225": "that's a part that could be improved uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00494-00137226-00137447": "as well as much as I know", "i527IYbIFuu-00495-00137448-00137849": "yeah absolutely uh so because", "i527IYbIFuu-00496-00137850-00138071": "um this we have 60 stack as the name", "i527IYbIFuu-00497-00138072-00138275": "implies is particularly", "i527IYbIFuu-00498-00138276-00138593": "um bound to IPv6 and um what I didn't", "i527IYbIFuu-00499-00138594-00138923": "realize initially is that the uh so I", "i527IYbIFuu-00500-00138924-00139085": "was trying to", "i527IYbIFuu-00501-00139086-00139543": "have this RPL interact with the existing", "i527IYbIFuu-00502-00139544-00139835": "models for example also for IP for uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00503-00139836-00140027": "maintaining the ring rooting tables and", "i527IYbIFuu-00504-00140028-00140327": "so on and but uh turned out that some", "i527IYbIFuu-00505-00140328-00140704": "parts of IPv6 protocol especially it's", "i527IYbIFuu-00506-00140705-00141043": "like Naval Discovery stuff like that", "i527IYbIFuu-00507-00141044-00141359": "they are not really compatible with the", "i527IYbIFuu-00508-00141360-00141593": "wireless operation and there is there", "i527IYbIFuu-00509-00141594-00141857": "exists a separate standard for wireless", "i527IYbIFuu-00510-00141858-00142151": "Naval discovery which of course is not", "i527IYbIFuu-00511-00142152-00142504": "implemented yet in inet", "i527IYbIFuu-00512-00142505-00142859": "um but would be helpful", "i527IYbIFuu-00513-00142860-00143140": "okay thank you I'm sure the developers", "i527IYbIFuu-00514-00143141-00143345": "are listening", "i527IYbIFuu-00515-00143346-00143561": "and uh yeah that's something that", "i527IYbIFuu-00516-00143562-00143771": "sometimes we talk about that the IPv6", "i527IYbIFuu-00517-00143772-00144202": "part might might need a little revamp", "i527IYbIFuu-00518-00144203-00144527": "right uh Andre are you here can you uh", "i527IYbIFuu-00519-00144528-00144990": "press the red button on recording"}}, {"audio_id": "i5ChcRLKPZQ", "text": {"i5ChcRLKPZQ-00000-00000035-00000262": "hi I'm Tony welcome to sports bike shops", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00001-00000263-00000467": "video about removing and refitting the", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00002-00000468-00001204": "visor on a showy glamster helmet", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00003-00001205-00001415": "now fitting advisor to this helmet it's", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00004-00001416-00001589": "so easy I've wondered whether it's", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00005-00001590-00001817": "actually too easy so easy that we don't", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00006-00001818-00001984": "actually need to run through the process", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00007-00001985-00002279": "at all but here goes let's do it anyway", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00008-00002280-00002507": "so start with the lift advisor then we", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00009-00002508-00002705": "need a screwdriver which I've got down", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00010-00002706-00003118": "here so we remove the two well remove", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00011-00003119-00003425": "the screw from this side of the visor", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00012-00003426-00003845": "let's spin that one out from there", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00013-00003846-00004090": "set the screw aside and then this little", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00014-00004092-00004379": "collar here just pulls free sometimes", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00015-00004380-00004588": "just lifting the visor gets that out and", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00016-00004589-00004883": "then the visors Away really simple same", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00017-00004884-00005152": "on this side", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00018-00005153-00005315": "unscrew", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00019-00005316-00005686": "that there", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00020-00005687-00006011": "pull the screw and the collar away and", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00021-00006012-00006154": "the visor is clear", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00022-00006155-00006400": "now it's easier to put it back in with", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00023-00006401-00006550": "the or back on with the helmet", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00024-00006551-00006791": "horizontal because that just means the", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00025-00006792-00006983": "screws are easier to get into place so", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00026-00006984-00007114": "I'll just pop this down here to protect", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00027-00007115-00007360": "the helmet", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00028-00007361-00007739": "we'll put this top ring here over the", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00029-00007740-00008020": "outer I'm going to put the tab there in", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00030-00008022-00008405": "the top of its Runner", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00031-00008406-00008687": "now this collar has two notches on it", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00032-00008688-00008819": "which you might just be able to see", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00033-00008820-00009083": "there in close up those notches have to", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00034-00009084-00009323": "align with two grooves on the mounting", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00035-00009324-00009496": "plate so if you go in and they're", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00036-00009497-00009755": "misaligned just rotate that gently until", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00037-00009756-00009946": "they seat in place and now that collar", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00038-00009947-00010085": "won't rotate anymore and we know it's", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00039-00010086-00010241": "located properly", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00040-00010242-00010445": "pop the screw down", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00041-00010446-00010913": "into there", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00042-00010914-00011273": "a screwdriver again", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00043-00011274-00011795": "and it's just drive that home", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00044-00011796-00012046": "that's working properly rotate same on", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00045-00012047-00012269": "the other side so", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00046-00012270-00012538": "this ring over there that tab in the top", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00047-00012539-00012755": "of the runner", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00048-00012756-00013013": "so that's in place get the collar line", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00049-00013013-00013355": "up those notches with the grooves so", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00050-00013356-00013565": "that's not rotating anymore so we know", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00051-00013566-00013829": "that's aligned properly so again pop the", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00052-00013830-00014075": "screw back into the threaded section", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00053-00014076-00014327": "just there", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00054-00014328-00014572": "tighten this group", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00055-00014573-00014872": "quick check that's fine", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00056-00014873-00015130": "the visor is now lifting and lowering", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00057-00015131-00015383": "exactly as it should so that's how you", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00058-00015384-00015605": "remove and refit the visor on a showy", "i5ChcRLKPZQ-00059-00015606-00016004": "glamster helmet thanks for watching"}}, {"audio_id": "i5JWBpArgso", "text": {"i5JWBpArgso-00000-00000046-00000262": "Cartesian doubt as a form of", "i5JWBpArgso-00001-00000263-00000509": "methodological skepticism associated", "i5JWBpArgso-00002-00000509-00000674": "with the writings and methodology of", "i5JWBpArgso-00003-00000675-00001127": "Rene Descartes 1596 to 1650 Cartesian", "i5JWBpArgso-00004-00001128-00001291": "doubt has also known as Cartesian", "i5JWBpArgso-00005-00001292-00001528": "skepticism methodical methodological", "i5JWBpArgso-00006-00001529-00001829": "skepticism Universal doubt systematic", "i5JWBpArgso-00007-00001830-00002141": "doubt or hyperbolic doubt Cartesian", "i5JWBpArgso-00008-00002142-00002359": "doubt as a systematic process of being", "i5JWBpArgso-00009-00002360-00002575": "skeptical about or doubting the truth of", "i5JWBpArgso-00010-00002576-00002723": "one's beliefs which has become a", "i5JWBpArgso-00011-00002724-00003008": "characteristic method in philosophy this", "i5JWBpArgso-00012-00003009-00003235": "method of doubt was largely popularized", "i5JWBpArgso-00013-00003236-00003436": "in Western philosophy by Rene Descartes", "i5JWBpArgso-00014-00003438-00003635": "who sought to doubt the truth of all his", "i5JWBpArgso-00015-00003636-00003797": "beliefs in order to determine which", "i5JWBpArgso-00016-00003797-00004061": "beliefs he could be certain were true it", "i5JWBpArgso-00017-00004061-00004244": "is the basis for Descartes statement", "i5JWBpArgso-00018-00004245-00004738": "cogito ergo sum I think therefore I am", "i5JWBpArgso-00019-00004739-00004976": "methodological skepticism is", "i5JWBpArgso-00020-00004977-00005141": "distinguished from philosophical", "i5JWBpArgso-00021-00005142-00005293": "skepticism in that methodological", "i5JWBpArgso-00022-00005294-00005558": "skepticism as an approach that subjects", "i5JWBpArgso-00023-00005559-00005747": "all knowledge claims to scrutiny with", "i5JWBpArgso-00024-00005748-00005902": "the goal of sorting out true from false", "i5JWBpArgso-00025-00005903-00005977": "claims", "i5JWBpArgso-00026-00005978-00006200": "whereas philosophical skepticism as an", "i5JWBpArgso-00027-00006201-00006397": "approach that questions the possibility", "i5JWBpArgso-00028-00006398-00006995": "of certain knowledge", "i5JWBpArgso-00029-00006995-00007551": "topic characteristics", "i5JWBpArgso-00030-00007552-00007833": "Cartesian doubt is methodological its", "i5JWBpArgso-00031-00007834-00008024": "purpose is to use doubt as a route to", "i5JWBpArgso-00032-00008025-00008174": "certain knowledge by finding those", "i5JWBpArgso-00033-00008175-00008406": "things which could not be doubted the", "i5JWBpArgso-00034-00008407-00008639": "fal ability of sense data in particular", "i5JWBpArgso-00035-00008640-00008934": "as a subject of Cartesian doubt there", "i5JWBpArgso-00036-00008935-00009117": "are several interpretations as to the", "i5JWBpArgso-00037-00009118-00009299": "objective of descartes skepticism", "i5JWBpArgso-00038-00009300-00009464": "prominent among these as a", "i5JWBpArgso-00039-00009465-00009657": "foundationalist account which claims", "i5JWBpArgso-00040-00009658-00009855": "that descartes skepticism is aimed at", "i5JWBpArgso-00041-00009856-00010020": "eliminating all belief which it is", "i5JWBpArgso-00042-00010021-00010221": "possible to doubt thus leaving descartes", "i5JWBpArgso-00043-00010222-00010442": "with only basic beliefs also known as", "i5JWBpArgso-00044-00010443-00010667": "foundational beliefs from these", "i5JWBpArgso-00045-00010668-00010902": "indubitable basic beliefs Descartes then", "i5JWBpArgso-00046-00010903-00011073": "attempts to derive further knowledge", "i5JWBpArgso-00047-00011074-00011330": "it's an archetypal and significant", "i5JWBpArgso-00048-00011331-00011549": "example that epitomizes the Continental", "i5JWBpArgso-00049-00011550-00012227": "rationale schools of philosophy", "i5JWBpArgso-00050-00012228-00012733": "topic technique", "i5JWBpArgso-00051-00012734-00012963": "Descartes method of hyperbolic doubt", "i5JWBpArgso-00052-00012964-00013288": "included accepting only information you", "i5JWBpArgso-00053-00013288-00013552": "know to be true breaking down these", "i5JWBpArgso-00054-00013553-00013863": "truths into smaller units solving the", "i5JWBpArgso-00055-00013865-00014158": "simple problems first making complete", "i5JWBpArgso-00056-00014159-00014362": "lists of further problems hyperbolic", "i5JWBpArgso-00057-00014363-00014547": "doubt means having the tendency to doubt", "i5JWBpArgso-00058-00014548-00014779": "since it is an extreme or exaggerated", "i5JWBpArgso-00059-00014780-00014991": "form of doubt knowledge in the Cartesian", "i5JWBpArgso-00060-00014993-00015187": "sense means to know something beyond not", "i5JWBpArgso-00061-00015188-00015388": "merely all reasonable but all possible", "i5JWBpArgso-00062-00015388-00015555": "doubt in his meditations on First", "i5JWBpArgso-00063-00015556-00015904": "Philosophy 1641 Descartes resolved to", "i5JWBpArgso-00064-00015905-00016084": "systematically doubt that any of his", "i5JWBpArgso-00065-00016085-00016305": "beliefs were true in order to build from", "i5JWBpArgso-00066-00016306-00016530": "the ground up a belief system consisting", "i5JWBpArgso-00067-00016531-00016738": "of only certainly true beliefs his end", "i5JWBpArgso-00068-00016739-00017068": "goal or a major one at the least was to", "i5JWBpArgso-00069-00017069-00017230": "find an undoubtable basis for the", "i5JWBpArgso-00070-00017231-00017508": "sciences consider Descartes opening", "i5JWBpArgso-00071-00017509-00017818": "lines of the meditations several years", "i5JWBpArgso-00072-00017819-00017992": "have now elapsed since I first became", "i5JWBpArgso-00073-00017993-00018208": "aware that I had accepted even from my", "i5JWBpArgso-00074-00018209-00018433": "youth many false opinions for true and", "i5JWBpArgso-00075-00018434-00018628": "that consequently what I afterward based", "i5JWBpArgso-00076-00018629-00018835": "on such principles was highly doubtful", "i5JWBpArgso-00077-00018836-00019012": "and from that time I was convinced of", "i5JWBpArgso-00078-00019013-00019209": "the necessity of undertaking once in my", "i5JWBpArgso-00079-00019210-00019419": "life to rid myself of all the opinions I", "i5JWBpArgso-00080-00019420-00019594": "had adopted and of commencing anew the", "i5JWBpArgso-00081-00019595-00020339": "work of building from the foundation", "i5JWBpArgso-00082-00020340-00020972": "topic de cartes method Rene Descartes", "i5JWBpArgso-00083-00020973-00021218": "the originator of Cartesian doubt put", "i5JWBpArgso-00084-00021219-00021464": "all beliefs ideas thoughts and matter in", "i5JWBpArgso-00085-00021465-00021707": "doubt he showed that his grounds or", "i5JWBpArgso-00086-00021708-00021899": "reasoning for any knowledge could just", "i5JWBpArgso-00087-00021900-00022211": "as well be false sensory experience the", "i5JWBpArgso-00088-00022212-00022381": "primary mode of knowledge is often", "i5JWBpArgso-00089-00022382-00022600": "erroneous and therefore must be doubted", "i5JWBpArgso-00090-00022601-00022847": "for instance what one is seeing may very", "i5JWBpArgso-00091-00022848-00023108": "well be a hallucination there is nothing", "i5JWBpArgso-00092-00023109-00023344": "that proves it cannot be in short if", "i5JWBpArgso-00093-00023345-00023492": "there is anyway a belief can be", "i5JWBpArgso-00094-00023493-00023653": "disproved then it's grounds are", "i5JWBpArgso-00095-00023654-00023894": "insufficient from this Descartes", "i5JWBpArgso-00096-00023895-00024106": "proposed two arguments the dream and the", "i5JWBpArgso-00097-00024107-00024617": "demon", "i5JWBpArgso-00098-00024618-00025142": "topic the dream argument", "i5JWBpArgso-00099-00025143-00025369": "Descartes knowing that the context of", "i5JWBpArgso-00100-00025370-00025580": "our dreams while possibly unbelievable", "i5JWBpArgso-00101-00025581-00025808": "are often lifelike hypothesized that", "i5JWBpArgso-00102-00025808-00025958": "humans can only believe that they are", "i5JWBpArgso-00103-00025958-00026237": "awake there are no sufficient grounds by", "i5JWBpArgso-00104-00026238-00026432": "which to distinguish a dream experience", "i5JWBpArgso-00105-00026433-00026671": "from awaking experience for instance", "i5JWBpArgso-00106-00026672-00026927": "subject a sits at the computer typing", "i5JWBpArgso-00107-00026927-00027170": "this article just as much evidence", "i5JWBpArgso-00108-00027170-00027374": "exists to indicate that the act of", "i5JWBpArgso-00109-00027375-00027577": "composing this article as reality as", "i5JWBpArgso-00110-00027578-00027733": "there is evidence to demonstrate the", "i5JWBpArgso-00111-00027735-00028010": "opposite Descartes conceded that we live", "i5JWBpArgso-00112-00028011-00028205": "in a world that can create such ideas as", "i5JWBpArgso-00113-00028206-00028475": "dreams however by the end of the", "i5JWBpArgso-00114-00028476-00028667": "meditations he concludes that we can", "i5JWBpArgso-00115-00028668-00028870": "distinguish dream from reality at least", "i5JWBpArgso-00116-00028872-00029087": "in retrospect but when I distinctly see", "i5JWBpArgso-00117-00029088-00029245": "where things come from and where and", "i5JWBpArgso-00118-00029247-00029399": "when they come to me and when I can", "i5JWBpArgso-00119-00029400-00029561": "connect my perceptions of them with my", "i5JWBpArgso-00120-00029562-00029737": "whole life without a break then I can be", "i5JWBpArgso-00121-00029738-00029885": "certain that when I encounter these", "i5JWBpArgso-00122-00029886-00030142": "things I am NOT asleep but awake", "i5JWBpArgso-00123-00030143-00030389": "Descartes selected philosophical", "i5JWBpArgso-00124-00030389-00030822": "writings", "i5JWBpArgso-00125-00030823-00031327": "topic the evil demon", "i5JWBpArgso-00126-00031329-00031526": "Descartes reasoned that our very own", "i5JWBpArgso-00127-00031527-00031733": "experience may very well be controlled", "i5JWBpArgso-00128-00031733-00032027": "by an evil demon of sorts this demon is", "i5JWBpArgso-00129-00032027-00032198": "as clever and deceitful as he is", "i5JWBpArgso-00130-00032199-00032395": "powerful he could have created a", "i5JWBpArgso-00131-00032397-00032576": "superficial world that we may think we", "i5JWBpArgso-00132-00032577-00032807": "live in as a result of this doubt", "i5JWBpArgso-00133-00032808-00033008": "sometimes termed the malicious demon", "i5JWBpArgso-00134-00033009-00033209": "hypothesis Descartes found that he was", "i5JWBpArgso-00135-00033210-00033407": "unable to trust even the simplest of his", "i5JWBpArgso-00136-00033408-00033743": "perceptions in meditation I Descartes", "i5JWBpArgso-00137-00033744-00033962": "stated that if one were mad even briefly", "i5JWBpArgso-00138-00033963-00034172": "the insanity might have driven man into", "i5JWBpArgso-00139-00034173-00034322": "believing that what we thought was true", "i5JWBpArgso-00140-00034323-00034514": "could be merely our minds deceiving us", "i5JWBpArgso-00141-00034515-00034778": "he also stated that there could be some", "i5JWBpArgso-00142-00034779-00034979": "malicious powerful cunning demon that", "i5JWBpArgso-00143-00034980-00035117": "had deceived us preventing us from", "i5JWBpArgso-00144-00035118-00035441": "judging correctly Descartes argued that", "i5JWBpArgso-00145-00035442-00035630": "all his senses were lying and since your", "i5JWBpArgso-00146-00035631-00035855": "senses can easily fool you his idea of", "i5JWBpArgso-00147-00035856-00036038": "an infinitely powerful being must be", "i5JWBpArgso-00148-00036039-00036206": "true as that idea could have only been", "i5JWBpArgso-00149-00036207-00036386": "put there by an infinitely powerful", "i5JWBpArgso-00150-00036387-00036545": "being which would have no reason to be", "i5JWBpArgso-00151-00036546-00037130": "deceitful to him", "i5JWBpArgso-00152-00037131-00037733": "topic I think therefore I am", "i5JWBpArgso-00153-00037734-00038042": "while methodic when need not hold that", "i5JWBpArgso-00154-00038043-00038237": "knowledge is impossible in order to", "i5JWBpArgso-00155-00038238-00038462": "apply the method of doubt indeed", "i5JWBpArgso-00156-00038463-00038654": "Descartes attempt to apply the method of", "i5JWBpArgso-00157-00038655-00038861": "doubt to the existence of himself spun", "i5JWBpArgso-00158-00038862-00039014": "the proof of his famous saying", "i5JWBpArgso-00159-00039015-00039346": "cogito ergo sum I think therefore I am", "i5JWBpArgso-00160-00039347-00039590": "that as Descartes tried to doubt his own", "i5JWBpArgso-00161-00039591-00039764": "existence but found that even his", "i5JWBpArgso-00162-00039765-00039956": "doubting showed that he existed since he", "i5JWBpArgso-00163-00039957-00040626": "could not doubt if he did not exist", "i5JWBpArgso-00164-00040627-00041170": "topic see also", "i5JWBpArgso-00165-00041171-00041520": "egocentric predicament incontrovertible", "i5JWBpArgso-00166-00041521-00042015": "evidence theory of justification"}}, {"audio_id": "i5THVQ1MHXE", "text": {"i5THVQ1MHXE-00000-00001503-00001912": "myself for black Americans I have Creole", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00001-00001913-00002167": "roots from New Orleans from my dad's", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00002-00002168-00002365": "side and that have african american", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00003-00002366-00002722": "native roots from my mom's side can't", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00004-00002723-00002901": "just come back but have a lot of", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00005-00002902-00003099": "different mixtures from French", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00006-00003100-00003415": "experience the Creole experience have", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00007-00003415-00003625": "you ever experienced discrimination any", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00008-00003626-00003861": "kind of discrimination oh yeah oh wait", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00009-00003863-00004114": "can you tell us a little bit i think the", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00010-00004115-00004258": "majorette form of discrimination I", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00011-00004259-00004489": "experience with like in high school like", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00012-00004490-00004759": "in educational settings like I just felt", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00013-00004760-00004987": "you know I had to go to I mean I was", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00014-00004988-00005139": "privileged enough i guess to go to", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00015-00005140-00005470": "private schools but within that it was", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00016-00005471-00005752": "always like and I was just seeing those", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00017-00005753-00006130": "like either to like two black for like", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00018-00006131-00006334": "to hang out with my kids or two white", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00019-00006335-00006543": "acting's and it got with black kids you", "i5THVQ1MHXE-00020-00006544-00006759": "know"}}, {"audio_id": "i6woCyeN7-M", "text": {"i6woCyeN7-M-00000-00000021-00002179": "[Music]", "i6woCyeN7-M-00001-00002180-00002429": "[Applause]", "i6woCyeN7-M-00002-00002430-00003559": "[Music]", "i6woCyeN7-M-00003-00003560-00003690": "so", "i6woCyeN7-M-00004-00003692-00006815": "[Music]", "i6woCyeN7-M-00005-00006816-00011510": "[Music]", "i6woCyeN7-M-00006-00011511-00011720": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i6Bxt6EZcTu", "text": {"i6Bxt6EZcTu-00000-00001117-00001301": "thank you", "i6Bxt6EZcTu-00001-00001302-00002620": "[Music]", "i6Bxt6EZcTu-00002-00002621-00003150": "[Music]", "i6Bxt6EZcTu-00003-00003151-00003460": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i6eA8TTrPL0", "text": {"i6eA8TTrPL0-00000-00000068-00000380": "chronic Souls is a new age connecting", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00001-00000381-00000692": "platform for cannabis enthusiasts find", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00002-00000693-00000881": "your perfect partner based on your", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00003-00000882-00001195": "common chronic interests whether you're", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00004-00001196-00001397": "looking for love or just want to meet", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00005-00001398-00001547": "new people in the industry", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00006-00001548-00001817": "chronic Souls is your one-stop shop for", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00007-00001818-00002171": "cannabis enthusiasts chronic solace", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00008-00002172-00002384": "makes it easy for you to book dates or", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00009-00002385-00002608": "plan events either on your own or with", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00010-00002609-00002855": "your partner using the built-in Google", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00011-00002856-00003175": "Calendar you can reserve tables at your", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00012-00003176-00003400": "favorite restaurant using open table", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00013-00003401-00003725": "schedule a ride with uber have flowers", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00014-00003726-00003938": "sent or buy tickets to the hottest", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00015-00003939-00004256": "events using Ticketmaster it's all", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00016-00004257-00004544": "available on chronic Souls available", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00017-00004545-00004901": "online or as Matt subscribe today and", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00018-00004902-00005111": "we'll let you know when we go live", "i6eA8TTrPL0-00019-00005112-00005465": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i6VXz1Mxgi8", "text": {"i6VXz1Mxgi8-00000-00000035-00000323": "aqua Khaled I was a Roman colony of the", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00001-00000324-00000536": "Roman province of Mauritania caesarian", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00002-00000537-00000755": "psious the Roman city has been", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00003-00000756-00000986": "identified with ruins at Haman Riga in", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00004-00000986-00001199": "the will ire of cleff Algeria North", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00005-00001200-00001798": "Africa", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00006-00001800-00002387": "topic data the ruins are located at", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00007-00002388-00002579": "latitude thirty six point three seven", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00008-00002580-00002819": "nine four seven four n longitude two", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00009-00002820-00003005": "point three nine five six one eighty", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00010-00003006-00003217": "near the railway town at boo med far and", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00011-00003218-00003461": "is on the wet DJ er River the Roman", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00012-00003461-00003659": "colony was founded by August's and", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00013-00003660-00003926": "flourished from 30 BC to about 690 ad", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00014-00003927-00004121": "passing through the vandal Kingdom and", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00015-00004122-00004813": "Roman Empire into late antiquity", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00016-00004814-00005088": "topic history", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00017-00005089-00005306": "you", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00018-00005307-00005529": "Emperor Augustus established their a", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00019-00005530-00005697": "colony of his veterans and the city", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00020-00005698-00005927": "started to grow soon in importance", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00021-00005928-00006161": "Gustus even founded in what is now", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00022-00006162-00006368": "coastal algeria the following Roman", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00023-00006369-00006429": "colonies", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00024-00006430-00006720": "Igor Gilley Sal de Tsubasa - Russo su", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00025-00006720-00006954": "res Guney I Zuka bar table Anika and", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00026-00006955-00007212": "gonna do all these colonies were", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00027-00007213-00007385": "connected to aqua Cala died in a", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00028-00007386-00007556": "military way with strong commercial", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00029-00007558-00007881": "links the importance of aqua Khaled I as", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00030-00007881-00008043": "the name indicated was from the warm", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00031-00008044-00008271": "waters reaching nearly 50 C that were", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00032-00008272-00008524": "used for the local famous Roman thermi", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00033-00008525-00008777": "during the centuries of Roman domination", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00034-00008778-00009012": "aqua khalid i was a small but rich city", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00035-00009013-00009260": "with a forum theatre baths library and", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00036-00009261-00009462": "aqueducts but nearly all has disappeared", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00037-00009463-00009693": "only in the craw palace of the city", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00038-00009694-00009852": "walls has shown the abundance of", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00039-00009853-00010062": "evidences about aqua khaled i christian", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00040-00010063-00010377": "past occupied by the vandals in the", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00041-00010378-00010574": "fifth century and damaged the city was", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00042-00010575-00010841": "recovered to roman etus by the", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00043-00010842-00011021": "Byzantines and regained importance", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00044-00011022-00011310": "during the sixth century conquered by", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00045-00011311-00011613": "arabs around 700 AD aqua khaled I nearly", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00046-00011614-00012299": "disappeared in the next two centuries", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00047-00012300-00012818": "topic see also", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00048-00012819-00013185": "mauritania cesarean psious caldez de", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00049-00013186-00013763": "rice galicia spain", "i6VXz1Mxgi8-00050-00013763-00014099": "topic notes"}}, {"audio_id": "i7BSECsEc4y", "text": {"i7BSECsEc4y-00000-00000055-00000279": "compiz is a compositing window manager", "i7BSECsEc4y-00001-00000280-00000546": "for the X Window System using 3d", "i7BSECsEc4y-00002-00000547-00000720": "graphics hardware to create fast", "i7BSECsEc4y-00003-00000721-00000936": "compositing desktop effects for window", "i7BSECsEc4y-00004-00000936-00001173": "management effects such as a", "i7BSECsEc4y-00005-00001174-00001356": "minimization animation or a cube", "i7BSECsEc4y-00006-00001357-00001539": "workspace are implemented as loadable", "i7BSECsEc4y-00007-00001540-00001857": "plugins because it conforms to the icc", "i7BSECsEc4y-00008-00001857-00002073": "CM standard kompis can be used as a", "i7BSECsEc4y-00009-00002074-00002252": "substitute for the default Muhtar or", "i7BSECsEc4y-00010-00002253-00002450": "meta city when using gnome panel or", "i7BSECsEc4y-00011-00002451-00002714": "Quinn in KDE plasma workspaces", "i7BSECsEc4y-00012-00002715-00002951": "internally compiz uses the open GLE", "i7BSECsEc4y-00013-00002952-00003138": "library is the interface to the graphics", "i7BSECsEc4y-00014-00003139-00003318": "hardware", "i7BSECsEc4y-00015-00003319-00003693": "you", "i7BSECsEc4y-00016-00003694-00004288": "topic hardware requirements", "i7BSECsEc4y-00017-00004289-00004558": "initially compiz only worked with 3d", "i7BSECsEc4y-00018-00004559-00004897": "hardware supported by xgl most Nvidia", "i7BSECsEc4y-00019-00004898-00005077": "and RT graphics cards are known to work", "i7BSECsEc4y-00020-00005078-00005539": "with comp is on xgl since May 22nd 2006", "i7BSECsEc4y-00021-00005540-00005758": "compiz works on the standard xorg server", "i7BSECsEc4y-00022-00005759-00006112": "by using AI GL x besides Intel GMA", "i7BSECsEc4y-00023-00006113-00006418": "graphics cards AI GL x also supports", "i7BSECsEc4y-00024-00006419-00006658": "using AMD graphics cards including our", "i7BSECsEc4y-00025-00006659-00006883": "300 and newer cards using the open", "i7BSECsEc4y-00026-00006884-00007117": "source Radeon driver which supports GL X", "i7BSECsEc4y-00027-00007118-00007320": "underscore ext underscore texture", "i7BSECsEc4y-00028-00007322-00007521": "underscore from underscore pixmap since", "i7BSECsEc4y-00029-00007522-00008020": "fall 2006 MV IDI is binary drivers since", "i7BSECsEc4y-00030-00008020-00008385": "version 1.0 - 9 6 to 9 support GL X", "i7BSECsEc4y-00031-00008386-00008599": "underscore ext underscore texture", "i7BSECsEc4y-00032-00008600-00008785": "underscore from underscore pixmap on", "i7BSECsEc4y-00033-00008786-00009073": "standard xorg server RT AMD's binary", "i7BSECsEc4y-00034-00009074-00009441": "drivers do since version 8.4 -", "i7BSECsEc4y-00035-00009442-00009821": "you", "i7BSECsEc4y-00036-00009822-00010324": "topic history", "i7BSECsEc4y-00037-00010325-00010558": "the first version of compiz was released", "i7BSECsEc4y-00038-00010559-00010789": "as free software by no Val Sue's in", "i7BSECsEc4y-00039-00010790-00011077": "January 2006 in the wake of the also new", "i7BSECsEc4y-00040-00011078-00011326": "xgl it was one of the earliest", "i7BSECsEc4y-00041-00011327-00011574": "compositing window managers Forex in", "i7BSECsEc4y-00042-00011575-00011980": "March 2006 compiz was ported to AIG LX", "i7BSECsEc4y-00043-00011981-00012546": "by Red Hat", "i7BSECsEc4y-00044-00012547-00013004": "topic Beryl", "i7BSECsEc4y-00045-00013005-00013222": "Beryl was the project name for the Quinn", "i7BSECsEc4y-00046-00013224-00013412": "storm branch of compiz announced on", "i7BSECsEc4y-00047-00013413-00013763": "September 19 2006 after campus developer", "i7BSECsEc4y-00048-00013763-00013925": "Quinn storm in the development team", "i7BSECsEc4y-00049-00013926-00014122": "decided that the fork had come too far", "i7BSECsEc4y-00050-00014124-00014297": "from the original campus started by", "i7BSECsEc4y-00051-00014297-00014585": "Novell compiz vanilla after the novel", "i7BSECsEc4y-00052-00014586-00014869": "xgl kompis team mostly David Reeve Minh", "i7BSECsEc4y-00053-00014871-00015047": "refused the proposition to merge the", "i7BSECsEc4y-00054-00015047-00015236": "Quinn storm changes with compiz vanilla", "i7BSECsEc4y-00055-00015237-00015407": "the decision was made to make a real", "i7BSECsEc4y-00056-00015408-00015619": "differentiation among the differences to", "i7BSECsEc4y-00057-00015621-00015841": "kompis Beryl had a new window decorator", "i7BSECsEc4y-00058-00015843-00016109": "named emerald based on cgw D along with", "i7BSECsEc4y-00059-00016110-00016265": "a themed manager called emerald themed", "i7BSECsEc4y-00060-00016266-00016460": "manager used a flat file back-end", "i7BSECsEc4y-00061-00016461-00016682": "instead of G conf and had no known", "i7BSECsEc4y-00062-00016683-00017252": "dependencies", "i7BSECsEc4y-00063-00017253-00017528": "topic merge of the compass and barrel", "i7BSECsEc4y-00064-00017529-00017934": "communities", "i7BSECsEc4y-00065-00017935-00018285": "on March 30th 2007 discussions between", "i7BSECsEc4y-00066-00018286-00018501": "the barrel and kompis communities led to", "i7BSECsEc4y-00067-00018502-00018675": "a merger of the two communities which", "i7BSECsEc4y-00068-00018676-00018938": "results in two new software packages", "i7BSECsEc4y-00069-00018939-00019239": "kompis also kompis core which contains", "i7BSECsEc4y-00070-00019240-00019440": "only the core functionality of compiz", "i7BSECsEc4y-00071-00019441-00019719": "and based plug-ins compos fusion", "i7BSECsEc4y-00072-00019720-00019917": "consisting of the plugins decorators", "i7BSECsEc4y-00073-00019918-00020142": "settings tools in related applications", "i7BSECsEc4y-00074-00020143-00020348": "from the barrel encompass communities", "i7BSECsEc4y-00075-00020349-00020571": "kompis fusion concentrates on", "i7BSECsEc4y-00076-00020572-00020748": "installation configuration and", "i7BSECsEc4y-00077-00020749-00020913": "additional plugins to add to the core", "i7BSECsEc4y-00078-00020914-00021105": "functionalities of compiz outcomes", "i7BSECsEc4y-00079-00021106-00021270": "include plans to fund a code review", "i7BSECsEc4y-00080-00021271-00021447": "panel consisting of the best developers", "i7BSECsEc4y-00081-00021448-00021636": "from each community who will see that", "i7BSECsEc4y-00082-00021637-00021819": "any code included in a release package", "i7BSECsEc4y-00083-00021820-00021972": "meets the highest standards and is", "i7BSECsEc4y-00084-00021973-00022221": "suitable for distribution in an", "i7BSECsEc4y-00085-00022222-00022504": "officially supported package", "i7BSECsEc4y-00086-00022505-00022858": "you", "i7BSECsEc4y-00087-00022859-00023401": "topic further branches", "i7BSECsEc4y-00088-00023402-00023680": "in the fourth quarter of 2008 two", "i7BSECsEc4y-00089-00023681-00023887": "separate branches of compiz were created", "i7BSECsEc4y-00090-00023888-00024136": "kompis plus plus and nomads compiz plus", "i7BSECsEc4y-00091-00024137-00024325": "plus was geared toward the separation of", "i7BSECsEc4y-00092-00024326-00024496": "compositing and open Google layers for", "i7BSECsEc4y-00093-00024497-00024640": "the rendering of the window manager", "i7BSECsEc4y-00094-00024641-00024850": "without compositing effects and the port", "i7BSECsEc4y-00095-00024851-00025207": "from C to C++ programming language Nomad", "i7BSECsEc4y-00096-00025208-00025366": "was geared towards the improvement of", "i7BSECsEc4y-00097-00025367-00025561": "Remote Desktop performance for compiz", "i7BSECsEc4y-00098-00025562-00025777": "installations", "i7BSECsEc4y-00099-00025779-00026134": "you", "i7BSECsEc4y-00100-00026135-00026749": "topic merge of the compas branches", "i7BSECsEc4y-00101-00026750-00027094": "On February 2nd 2009 a conference call", "i7BSECsEc4y-00102-00027095-00027292": "was held between developers of compus", "i7BSECsEc4y-00103-00027293-00027580": "compost + + nomads and kompis fusion", "i7BSECsEc4y-00104-00027581-00027724": "where it was decided to merge the", "i7BSECsEc4y-00105-00027725-00027943": "projects into a unified project simply", "i7BSECsEc4y-00106-00027944-00028648": "named kompis with a unified roadmap", "i7BSECsEc4y-00107-00028649-00029308": "topic compĂ¡s 0.9 series", "i7BSECsEc4y-00108-00029308-00029637": "on July 4th 2010 Sam Spilsbury led", "i7BSECsEc4y-00109-00029638-00029812": "campus developer announced the release", "i7BSECsEc4y-00110-00029813-00030175": "of compiz 0.9.0 with a new API rewritten", "i7BSECsEc4y-00111-00030176-00030442": "in C++ canonical limited hide Spilsbury", "i7BSECsEc4y-00112-00030443-00030661": "to further develop kompis for Ubuntu in", "i7BSECsEc4y-00113-00030662-00030789": "October 2010", "i7BSECsEc4y-00114-00030791-00031051": "since then compiz development mostly", "i7BSECsEc4y-00115-00031052-00031243": "coincides with a boon to development", "i7BSECsEc4y-00116-00031244-00031468": "main development moved to Canonical's", "i7BSECsEc4y-00117-00031469-00031933": "launchpad service the 0.9.0 point nine", "i7BSECsEc4y-00118-00031933-00032143": "point five was seen as unstable beta", "i7BSECsEc4y-00119-00032144-00032425": "software with version zero point nine", "i7BSECsEc4y-00120-00032426-00032577": "point six in progress", "i7BSECsEc4y-00121-00032579-00032806": "canonical hide developer Daniel van vu", "i7BSECsEc4y-00122-00032807-00033096": "GT to work on kompis full-time while", "i7BSECsEc4y-00123-00033097-00033292": "zero point nine point six never", "i7BSECsEc4y-00124-00033293-00033580": "officially released composite 9.7 dot o", "i7BSECsEc4y-00125-00033581-00033771": "was released a month ahead of enterprise", "i7BSECsEc4y-00126-00033772-00034114": "targeted a boom to 12.04 LTS long-term", "i7BSECsEc4y-00127-00034115-00034402": "support and declared stable a few days", "i7BSECsEc4y-00128-00034403-00034557": "before the official release of Ubuntu", "i7BSECsEc4y-00129-00034558-00034867": "12.04 a new development branch zero", "i7BSECsEc4y-00130-00034868-00035080": "point nine point eight was created in", "i7BSECsEc4y-00131-00035081-00035307": "preparation for a boom to twelve point", "i7BSECsEc4y-00132-00035308-00035617": "104 kompis version zero point nine point", "i7BSECsEc4y-00133-00035618-00035785": "eight development has moved to a new", "i7BSECsEc4y-00134-00035786-00036001": "launch pad page in November 2012", "i7BSECsEc4y-00135-00036002-00036193": "Spilsbury announced that he had left", "i7BSECsEc4y-00136-00036194-00036418": "canonical and stated he had no plans to", "i7BSECsEc4y-00137-00036419-00036687": "port compass to Wayland a small team", "i7BSECsEc4y-00138-00036688-00036882": "continues to work on kompis with version", "i7BSECsEc4y-00139-00036883-00037168": "0.9 point 1 3 being the focus of", "i7BSECsEc4y-00140-00037169-00037511": "development as of July 2016", "i7BSECsEc4y-00141-00037512-00037864": "you", "i7BSECsEc4y-00142-00037865-00038401": "topic compiz reloaded", "i7BSECsEc4y-00143-00038402-00038695": "a group thought the comp is 0.8 series", "i7BSECsEc4y-00144-00038696-00038908": "codebase and modernized it and maintains", "i7BSECsEc4y-00145-00038909-00039541": "it as of 2018", "i7BSECsEc4y-00146-00039542-00040067": "topic features", "i7BSECsEc4y-00147-00040068-00040310": "almost all available compass features", "i7BSECsEc4y-00148-00040311-00040502": "except translucency dimming and", "i7BSECsEc4y-00149-00040503-00040789": "desaturation are delivered using plugins", "i7BSECsEc4y-00150-00040790-00041039": "compĂ¡s plugins include the cube effect", "i7BSECsEc4y-00151-00041040-00041243": "all tab applications switching with live", "i7BSECsEc4y-00152-00041244-00041468": "previews or icons and a feature similar", "i7BSECsEc4y-00153-00041469-00041762": "to mitosis Mission Control the composite", "i7BSECsEc4y-00154-00041763-00041999": "extension 2x is used as is the open Gil", "i7BSECsEc4y-00155-00042000-00042265": "extension GLX underscore ext underscore", "i7BSECsEc4y-00156-00042266-00042464": "texture underscore from underscore pick", "i7BSECsEc4y-00157-00042465-00042686": "slap the compus project categorizes the", "i7BSECsEc4y-00158-00042687-00042940": "plugins into four main groups main extra", "i7BSECsEc4y-00159-00042941-00043171": "unsupported and experimental window", "i7BSECsEc4y-00160-00043172-00043373": "managers use a program called a window", "i7BSECsEc4y-00161-00043374-00043574": "decorator to provide the window borders", "i7BSECsEc4y-00162-00043575-00043765": "with the usual minimize maximize and", "i7BSECsEc4y-00163-00043766-00043882": "close buttons", "i7BSECsEc4y-00164-00043883-00044137": "unlike many window managers which have", "i7BSECsEc4y-00165-00044138-00044371": "only one window decorator compiz users", "i7BSECsEc4y-00166-00044372-00044681": "have a choice of three gtk window", "i7BSECsEc4y-00167-00044682-00044831": "decorator uses either a basic", "i7BSECsEc4y-00168-00044832-00045043": "cairo-based rendering engine or can use", "i7BSECsEc4y-00169-00045044-00045415": "meta city themes KDE window decorator", "i7BSECsEc4y-00170-00045416-00045790": "uses native quin themes emerald a custom", "i7BSECsEc4y-00171-00045791-00045983": "decorator with its own theme format that", "i7BSECsEc4y-00172-00045984-00046139": "has been ported to kompis", "i7BSECsEc4y-00173-00046140-00046883": "it used to be barrels default decorator", "i7BSECsEc4y-00174-00046884-00047423": "Topic deployments", "i7BSECsEc4y-00175-00047424-00047615": "Campos or Beryl have usually been", "i7BSECsEc4y-00176-00047616-00047843": "deployed on Linux and other x11 based", "i7BSECsEc4y-00177-00047844-00048046": "unix-like platforms together with gnome", "i7BSECsEc4y-00178-00048047-00048473": "2 and KDE 3 since version 4.2 however", "i7BSECsEc4y-00179-00048474-00048724": "KDE zone Quinn ships with capabilities", "i7BSECsEc4y-00180-00048725-00049052": "similar to kompis as such compiz is not", "i7BSECsEc4y-00181-00049053-00049235": "usually deployed with recent plasma", "i7BSECsEc4y-00182-00049236-00049612": "workspaces versions gnome version 3.0", "i7BSECsEc4y-00183-00049613-00049790": "uses gnome shell which is built as a", "i7BSECsEc4y-00184-00049791-00049970": "plugin to the mutter compositing window", "i7BSECsEc4y-00185-00049971-00050033": "manager", "i7BSECsEc4y-00186-00050034-00050285": "this means kompis cannot be used in", "i7BSECsEc4y-00187-00050286-00050477": "conjunction with gnome shell citing a", "i7BSECsEc4y-00188-00050478-00050633": "lack of maintenance on the part of the", "i7BSECsEc4y-00189-00050634-00050870": "compas developers Fedora removed compost", "i7BSECsEc4y-00190-00050871-00051056": "from the Fedora repositories from Fedora", "i7BSECsEc4y-00191-00051057-00051289": "17 however Compass has been reinstated", "i7BSECsEc4y-00192-00051290-00051541": "in the Fedora repository since Fedora 18", "i7BSECsEc4y-00193-00051542-00051790": "an official mates bin which includes", "i7BSECsEc4y-00194-00051791-00051994": "kompis has been available since Fedora", "i7BSECsEc4y-00195-00051995-00052204": "19 compiz was dropped from the Debian", "i7BSECsEc4y-00196-00052205-00052400": "repositories from Debian 7 Weezie", "i7BSECsEc4y-00197-00052401-00052657": "onwards in August 2013 due to broken", "i7BSECsEc4y-00198-00052658-00052811": "packages and a lack of upstream", "i7BSECsEc4y-00199-00052812-00052991": "development on the part of the compas", "i7BSECsEc4y-00200-00052991-00053300": "developers compiz was reintroduced into", "i7BSECsEc4y-00201-00053301-00053573": "debian in december 2016 by the hyper dot", "i7BSECsEc4y-00202-00053574-00053762": "f our team comp is was dropped from the", "i7BSECsEc4y-00203-00053763-00054034": "Arch Linux repositories in May 2013", "i7BSECsEc4y-00204-00054035-00054257": "compiz can still be installed from", "i7BSECsEc4y-00205-00054258-00054425": "packages available in the arch user", "i7BSECsEc4y-00206-00054426-00054857": "repository Ubuntu 6.06 LTS and later", "i7BSECsEc4y-00207-00054858-00055030": "included compiz in the univers", "i7BSECsEc4y-00208-00055032-00055282": "repository a limited version was", "i7BSECsEc4y-00209-00055283-00055562": "included by default 'as desktop effects", "i7BSECsEc4y-00210-00055563-00055991": "in ubuntu 7.0 for from Ubuntu 7.10", "i7BSECsEc4y-00211-00055991-00056292": "onwards compiz was enabled by default in", "i7BSECsEc4y-00212-00056294-00056546": "2010 canonical released the unity", "i7BSECsEc4y-00213-00056547-00056707": "interface which is written as a plug-in", "i7BSECsEc4y-00214-00056708-00056942": "for campers", "i7BSECsEc4y-00215-00056944-00057375": "equals equals some comp is effect 0.85", "i7BSECsEc4y-00216-00057376-00057910": "equals equals", "i7BSECsEc4y-00217-00057911-00058441": "topic see also", "i7BSECsEc4y-00218-00058441-00058811": "comparison of X window managers virtual", "i7BSECsEc4y-00219-00058812-00059399": "GL desk space project Looking Glass"}}, {"audio_id": "i7FvfTTaPgM", "text": {"i7FvfTTaPgM-00000-00000041-00000335": "Lillard tobacco company was an American", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00001-00000336-00000548": "tobacco company that marketed cigarettes", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00002-00000549-00000770": "under the brand names Newport maverick", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00003-00000771-00001579": "old gold Kent true Saturn and Mac's", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00004-00001580-00002264": "topic history the company is named for", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00005-00002265-00002476": "Pierre Abraham Lillard who founded the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00006-00002477-00002926": "company in 1760 in 1899 the American", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00007-00002927-00003142": "tobacco company organized a New Jersey", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00008-00003143-00003329": "corporation called the Continental", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00009-00003329-00003518": "tobacco company that took a controlling", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00010-00003519-00003772": "interest in many small tobacco companies", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00011-00003772-00004142": "by 1910 James Buchanan Duke controlled", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00012-00004143-00004361": "lurid and the American tobacco company", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00013-00004362-00004627": "even as it kept its original name in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00014-00004628-00004922": "1911 the US Court of Appeals found the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00015-00004923-00005179": "American tobacco company in restraint of", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00016-00005180-00005456": "trade and issued a dissolution decree to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00017-00005457-00005642": "the American tobacco company which", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00018-00005643-00005854": "created the opportunity for Lillard to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00019-00005855-00006063": "become an independent company again in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00020-00006064-00006191": "1925", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00021-00006192-00006395": "Lillard experienced great transition as", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00022-00006396-00006592": "Benjamin Lloyd belt became president", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00023-00006593-00006878": "having been with the company since 1911", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00024-00006879-00007109": "Belt made some decisions that made the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00025-00007109-00007348": "company profitable he began to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00026-00007350-00007553": "prioritize on promoting the old gold", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00027-00007554-00007735": "brand instead of beech not chewing", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00028-00007736-00007991": "tobacco using such tactics as old gold", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00029-00007992-00008224": "on Broadway and sponsoring old gold", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00030-00008225-00008464": "presents Paul Whiteman and his orchestra", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00031-00008465-00008728": "which was a weekly hour-long show on", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00032-00008729-00009023": "Tuesdays nights over CBS from station W", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00033-00009024-00009359": "ABC in New York the Whiteman Tower had", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00034-00009360-00009677": "its first broadcast on february 5th 1929", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00035-00009678-00010042": "and continued until May 6 1931 the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00036-00010043-00010231": "Whiteman band went to Hollywood in mid", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00037-00010232-00010510": "199 to make the film king of jazz old", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00038-00010511-00010727": "gold leased a special aid coach trained", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00039-00010728-00010919": "to take Whiteman and his entourage to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00040-00010920-00011224": "the west coast the train stopped at 16", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00041-00011225-00011474": "cities across the nation old gold later", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00042-00011475-00011678": "sponsored Artie Shaw's Tuesday night", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00043-00011679-00012070": "melody and madness program on CBS radio", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00044-00012071-00012392": "from November 20th 1938 until November", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00045-00012393-00012788": "14th 1939 Belt was still president when", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00046-00012789-00013015": "he died in 1937", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00047-00013016-00013286": "Lillard tobacco company opened a new", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00048-00013287-00013385": "cigarette plant", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00049-00013386-00013559": "East Market Street in Greensboro North", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00050-00013560-00013883": "Carolina in 1956 moving cigarette", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00051-00013884-00014084": "manufacturing from Jersey City New", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00052-00014085-00014378": "Jersey and Richmond Virginia Lowe's", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00053-00014379-00014766": "corporation purchased Lillet in 1968", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00054-00014768-00015040": "testifying under oath before Congress in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00055-00015041-00015368": "1994 LaRue leads CEO Andrew Tisch said", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00056-00015369-00015530": "that he didn't believe that nicotine is", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00057-00015531-00015707": "addictive nor that cigarette smoking", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00058-00015708-00016004": "causes cancer in 1997 the firm's", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00059-00016005-00016184": "headquarters moved to Greensboro from", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00060-00016185-00016502": "New York City the firm also manufactured", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00061-00016503-00016831": "cigarettes in Louisville Kentucky in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00062-00016832-00017126": "1997 Lillard was one of four entities to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00063-00017127-00017336": "initiate negotiations leading to the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00064-00017337-00017588": "1998 tobacco master settlement agreement", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00065-00017589-00018055": "between Big Tobacco and 46 US states", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00066-00018056-00018332": "Lowe's created the Carolina group as a", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00067-00018333-00018547": "holding company for its tobacco assets", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00068-00018548-00018854": "in 2002 it proceeded to sell a minority", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00069-00018855-00019076": "stake in Carolina on the New York Stock", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00070-00019077-00019367": "Exchange Carolina was controlled by", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00071-00019368-00019667": "Lowe's until May 10th 2006 when Lowe's", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00072-00019668-00019916": "corporation sold 15 million shares of", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00073-00019917-00020135": "Carolina Group lowering its holding from", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00074-00020136-00020608": "a controlling 53.7% to a plurality 46.3%", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00075-00020609-00020984": "the sale was valued at approximately 740", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00076-00020985-00021403": "million dollars in 2006 Laurel ed was", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00077-00021404-00021596": "convicted of racketeering under Rico", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00078-00021597-00021812": "along with Philip Morris and RJ Reynolds", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00079-00021813-00022118": "Tobacco Company the Supreme Court has", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00080-00022119-00022289": "upheld the verdict in which judge", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00081-00022290-00022640": "Kessler wrote W at this case is really", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00082-00022641-00023003": "about is about an industry and in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00083-00023004-00023165": "particular these defendants that", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00084-00023166-00023366": "survives and profits from selling a", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00085-00023367-00023558": "highly addictive product which causes", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00086-00023559-00023711": "diseases that lead to a staggering", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00087-00023712-00023888": "number of deaths per year and a", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00088-00023889-00024077": "measurable amount of human suffering and", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00089-00024078-00024296": "economic loss and a profound burden on", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00090-00024297-00024652": "our national healthcare system in short", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00091-00024653-00024884": "defendants have marketed and sold their", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00092-00024885-00025075": "lethal product with zeal with deception", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00093-00025076-00025283": "with a single-minded focus on their", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00094-00025284-00025502": "financial success and without regard for", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00095-00025503-00025730": "the human tragedy or social costs that", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00096-00025731-00026146": "success exacted in 2008 Louella Tobacco", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00097-00026147-00026330": "was entered into a separation agreement", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00098-00026331-00026537": "with its parent company Lowe's and", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00099-00026538-00026726": "became an independent publicly traded", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00100-00026727-00026889": "come", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00101-00026891-00027245": "in order to comply with FDA regulations", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00102-00027245-00027539": "Lillard had until June 22nd 2010 to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00103-00027539-00027743": "rebrand tobacco products marketed as", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00104-00027744-00028370": "lights ultralights medium mild full", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00105-00028370-00028667": "flavor or similar designations to pillai", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00106-00028668-00028844": "the false impression that some tobacco", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00107-00028845-00029152": "products are comparatively safe in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00108-00029154-00029455": "December 2010 a Boston jury returned the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00109-00029456-00029708": "151 million dollars verdict against", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00110-00029708-00029906": "Louella tobacco company for giving out", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00111-00029907-00030104": "free samples of cigarettes to children", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00112-00030105-00030373": "in urban housing projects in the 1950s", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00113-00030374-00030683": "the plaintiff Murray Evans was 9 when", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00114-00030683-00030848": "she first received these samples", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00115-00030849-00031045": "according to documents filed by her", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00116-00031047-00031343": "attorneys she died of lung cancer before", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00117-00031344-00031544": "trial in April 2012", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00118-00031545-00031708": "Lillard purchased privately held", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00119-00031710-00031937": "electronic cigarette company blue Essex", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00120-00031938-00032264": "for 135 million dollars in cash marking", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00121-00032264-00032440": "the first foray by the tobacco industry", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00122-00032441-00032771": "into the electronic cigarette market the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00123-00032772-00032978": "electronic cigarette company had about", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00124-00032979-00033164": "thirty million dollars in revenue in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00125-00033165-00033419": "2010 with blue essex sold in more than", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00126-00033420-00033662": "13,000 retail outlets including", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00127-00033663-00033915": "walgreens and sheets in 2014 after", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00128-00033916-00034106": "negotiations with People for the Ethical", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00129-00034107-00034292": "Treatment of Animals PETA", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00130-00034293-00034436": "Lillard announced it would no longer", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00131-00034437-00034742": "test its products on animals in a", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00132-00034743-00034975": "statement the company said they will use", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00133-00034976-00035221": "scientifically accepted or validated", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00134-00035222-00035402": "alternative test methods and", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00135-00035403-00035582": "technologies that avoid the use of", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00136-00035583-00035921": "animals such methods and tests may", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00137-00035922-00036161": "include in vitro cell culture tests", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00138-00036162-00036407": "advanced chemistry tests and computer", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00139-00036408-00036839": "modeling programs on July 15 2014", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00140-00036840-00037055": "Reynolds American agreed to Baylor illud", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00141-00037056-00037223": "for twenty seven point four billion", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00142-00037224-00037427": "dollars uniting two of the country's", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00143-00037428-00037627": "largest tobacco producers in a bet that", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00144-00037628-00037861": "bigger is safer in a declining industry", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00145-00037862-00038152": "the deal also included the sale of the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00146-00038153-00038402": "cool Winston maverick Salem and blue", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00147-00038403-00038671": "brands to Imperial Tobacco for 7.1", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00148-00038672-00038960": "billion dollars the deal was finalized", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00149-00038961-00039627": "on June 12 2015", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00150-00039628-00040334": "topic cigarette camp camp old Galt was", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00151-00040335-00040508": "one of the American army camps", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00152-00040509-00040718": "established near La Havre France in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00153-00040719-00041002": "World War two as explained in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00154-00041003-00041345": "introduction the cigarette camps at the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00155-00041346-00041605": "website the cigarette camps the US Army", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00156-00041606-00041954": "camps in the La Habra area the staging", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00157-00041955-00042112": "area camps were named after various", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00158-00042113-00042335": "brands of American cigarettes the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00159-00042336-00042527": "assembly area camps were named after", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00160-00042528-00042833": "American cities the names of cigarettes", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00161-00042834-00043037": "and cities were chosen for two reasons", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00162-00043038-00043312": "first and primarily for security", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00163-00043313-00043520": "referring to the camps without an", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00164-00043521-00043682": "indication of their geographical", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00165-00043683-00043889": "location when the long way to ensuring", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00166-00043890-00044060": "that the enemy would not know precisely", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00167-00044061-00044374": "where they were anybody eavesdropping or", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00168-00044375-00044573": "listening to radio traffic would think", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00169-00044574-00044752": "that cigarettes were being discussed or", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00170-00044753-00044936": "the camp was stateside especially", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00171-00044937-00045245": "regarding the city camps secondly there", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00172-00045246-00045443": "was a subtle psychological reason the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00173-00045444-00045623": "premise being that troops heading into", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00174-00045624-00045799": "battle wouldn't mind staying at a place", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00175-00045800-00046018": "where cigarettes must be plentiful and", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00176-00046019-00046217": "troops about to depart for combat would", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00177-00046218-00046408": "be somehow comforted in places with", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00178-00046409-00046633": "familiar names of cities back home camp", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00179-00046634-00046895": "Atlanta Camp Baltimore Camp New York and", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00180-00046896-00047201": "camp Pittsburgh among others by war's", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00181-00047202-00047395": "end however all of the cigarette and", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00182-00047396-00047623": "City camps were devoted to D parties", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00183-00047624-00047914": "many processed liberated American powers", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00184-00047915-00048118": "prisoners of war and some even held", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00185-00048119-00048886": "German powers for a while topic", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00186-00048887-00049610": "Restatement on May 8 2003 the company", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00187-00049611-00049814": "restated its financial statements in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00188-00049815-00050060": "2002 to reflect an adjustment to the", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00189-00050061-00050287": "company's historical accounting for CNAs", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00190-00050288-00050504": "investment in life settlement contracts", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00191-00050505-00050695": "and the related revenue recognition on", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00192-00050696-00051080": "May 3rd 2005 Lowe's Corp the holding", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00193-00051081-00051287": "company of Carolina Group announced to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00194-00051288-00051466": "restate results for prior years to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00195-00051467-00051670": "correct CNAs accounting for several", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00196-00051671-00052333": "reinsurance contracts", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00197-00052334-00053021": "topic electronic cigarettes in April", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00198-00053022-00053279": "2012 Blu ecigs was acquired by Lara", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00199-00053279-00053455": "Lloyd Inc and was the biggest seller in", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00200-00053457-00054287": "the United States topic purchased by", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00201-00054288-00054947": "Reynolds on July 15 2014", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00202-00054948-00055148": "Reynolds American agreed to buy Lillard", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00203-00055149-00055349": "tobacco company for twenty seven point", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00204-00055350-00055613": "four billion dollars the deal also", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00205-00055614-00055778": "included the sale of the cool", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00206-00055779-00056005": "winston-salem and blue brands to", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00207-00056007-00056464": "Imperial Tobacco for 7.1 billion dollars", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00208-00056465-00056779": "topics see also Lillard Tobacco Co V", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00209-00056780-00057362": "Reilly 533 us 525 2001 VF good and", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00210-00057363-00057616": "company leaf tobacco warehouse David H", "i7FvfTTaPgM-00211-00057616-00058025": "Miller tobacco warehouse"}}, {"audio_id": "i7YRF4V-87u", "text": {"i7YRF4V-87u-00000-00000128-00000390": "hello everyone lyndon sg here this is", "i7YRF4V-87u-00001-00000391-00000630": "your fortnight item shop update for", "i7YRF4V-87u-00002-00000631-00005022": "friday august 27 2021", "i7YRF4V-87u-00003-00005023-00007550": "so", "i7YRF4V-87u-00004-00007551-00008751": "[Music]", "i7YRF4V-87u-00005-00008752-00010205": "[Music]", "i7YRF4V-87u-00006-00010206-00011841": "[Music]", "i7YRF4V-87u-00007-00011842-00014794": "[Music]", "i7YRF4V-87u-00008-00014794-00016225": "[Music]", "i7YRF4V-87u-00009-00016226-00016964": "[Music]", "i7YRF4V-87u-00010-00016965-00017599": "[Music]", "i7YRF4V-87u-00011-00017600-00017911": "if interested in any of the items in the", "i7YRF4V-87u-00012-00017912-00018150": "fortnight shop today please consider", "i7YRF4V-87u-00013-00018151-00018422": "using code lyndon sg in the support of", "i7YRF4V-87u-00014-00018423-00018583": "creator", "i7YRF4V-87u-00015-00018584-00018830": "i'll be back tomorrow with", "i7YRF4V-87u-00016-00018831-00019103": "the saturday update", "i7YRF4V-87u-00017-00019104-00019350": "here thanks everyone for watching please", "i7YRF4V-87u-00018-00019351-00019567": "consider subscribing to the channel like", "i7YRF4V-87u-00019-00019568-00019950": "the video share the video comment", "i7YRF4V-87u-00020-00019951-00020191": "they'll be great to hear from you", "i7YRF4V-87u-00021-00020192-00020430": "until next time the coffee shops closed", "i7YRF4V-87u-00022-00020431-00020807": "you know the motto death before decaf", "i7YRF4V-87u-00023-00020808-00021187": "have a good one all"}}, {"audio_id": "i7bX4phZ46g", "text": {"i7bX4phZ46g-00000-00000000-00000534": "to the UVM extension new farmer program", "i7bX4phZ46g-00001-00000535-00000788": "webinar series which is sponsored by the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00002-00000789-00001124": "working lands enterprise program and UVM", "i7bX4phZ46g-00003-00001125-00001598": "extension today's session is on we'll", "i7bX4phZ46g-00004-00001599-00001955": "provide an introduction to farm hack", "i7bX4phZ46g-00005-00001955-00002237": "with our speakers Daniel Grover and Dan", "i7bX4phZ46g-00006-00002238-00002650": "Cox who are going to spend some time", "i7bX4phZ46g-00007-00002651-00003145": "introducing us to the services of this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00008-00003146-00003590": "really unique program and so I think", "i7bX4phZ46g-00009-00003590-00003806": "without further ado I will turn it over", "i7bX4phZ46g-00010-00003807-00004094": "to them I will let you know that if you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00011-00004095-00004297": "have questions or comments please type", "i7bX4phZ46g-00012-00004298-00004602": "them into the chat box so that we can", "i7bX4phZ46g-00013-00004603-00004870": "read them and respond to them we can't", "i7bX4phZ46g-00014-00004871-00005117": "hear you folks we hope you all can hear", "i7bX4phZ46g-00015-00005118-00005393": "us just fine and then at the end you'll", "i7bX4phZ46g-00016-00005394-00005792": "see a link for a survey if you please", "i7bX4phZ46g-00017-00005793-00006074": "write down that link so that you can", "i7bX4phZ46g-00018-00006075-00006356": "connect to it later and risk and give us", "i7bX4phZ46g-00019-00006357-00006566": "some feedback so thank you all for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00020-00006567-00006859": "joining us and I guess without further", "i7bX4phZ46g-00021-00006861-00007060": "ado I'm going to turn this over to Dan", "i7bX4phZ46g-00022-00007061-00007523": "and Dorn thank thanks Heidi it's great", "i7bX4phZ46g-00023-00007523-00007684": "to be here and be able to talk a little", "i7bX4phZ46g-00024-00007686-00008084": "bit about farm hacked and our open", "i7bX4phZ46g-00025-00008084-00008410": "source approach to agriculture Dan's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00026-00008411-00008596": "gonna do a little bit of an introduction", "i7bX4phZ46g-00027-00008597-00008837": "but first we thought we'd show a short", "i7bX4phZ46g-00028-00008838-00009185": "introductory film and then and then the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00029-00009186-00009514": "rough over viewers will go through sort", "i7bX4phZ46g-00030-00009515-00009985": "of the process that and the services our", "i7bX4phZ46g-00031-00009986-00010331": "Mac has currently and how folks can", "i7bX4phZ46g-00032-00010332-00010496": "participate and then we're really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00033-00010497-00010685": "excited about answering whatever", "i7bX4phZ46g-00034-00010686-00010994": "questions we can so I'm going to try and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00035-00010995-00011273": "transfer over to my desktop here to show", "i7bX4phZ46g-00036-00011274-00011731": "this film and and then we'll go from", "i7bX4phZ46g-00037-00011732-00012055": "there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00038-00012056-00012580": "should all be able to see this and if", "i7bX4phZ46g-00039-00012581-00013258": "you cannot see this please let us know", "i7bX4phZ46g-00040-00013259-00013513": "we'll type the link to this so you can", "i7bX4phZ46g-00041-00013513-00013725": "follow along if it for some reason", "i7bX4phZ46g-00042-00013726-00014733": "doesn't show up", "i7bX4phZ46g-00043-00014734-00015253": "you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00044-00015254-00017878": "you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00045-00017879-00018526": "I'm not sure the founders coming through", "i7bX4phZ46g-00046-00018527-00018904": "the other thing sound like it is no Chad", "i7bX4phZ46g-00047-00018905-00019478": "no right can you talk can you narrate as", "i7bX4phZ46g-00048-00019479-00020269": "you yeah sorry go ahead good", "i7bX4phZ46g-00049-00020270-00020617": "pure I could sort of narrate it a little", "i7bX4phZ46g-00050-00020618-00021050": "bit so though I will say the video is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00051-00021051-00021236": "pretty broken up too so I'm not sure if", "i7bX4phZ46g-00052-00021237-00021461": "it's it's the video itself as effective", "i7bX4phZ46g-00053-00021462-00021769": "either alright maybe we should just", "i7bX4phZ46g-00054-00021770-00022231": "continue with the slides and then ask", "i7bX4phZ46g-00055-00022232-00022456": "folks to come back to watching the video", "i7bX4phZ46g-00056-00022457-00022828": "that's great so let's put the we can put", "i7bX4phZ46g-00057-00022829-00023269": "the link in and we'll go back to the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00058-00023270-00024740": "slides here", "i7bX4phZ46g-00059-00024741-00024884": "okay", "i7bX4phZ46g-00060-00024885-00025344": "so I'll put the link in there you can", "i7bX4phZ46g-00061-00025345-00025572": "watch that at your leisure evidently the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00062-00025573-00025781": "sound is not coming to you today seem to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00063-00025782-00026033": "work yesterday", "i7bX4phZ46g-00064-00026035-00026358": "great so Daniel do you want to take off", "i7bX4phZ46g-00065-00026358-00026625": "sort of basically walking through the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00066-00026626-00026952": "overview of Carmack yeah absolutely", "i7bX4phZ46g-00067-00026952-00027402": "um so thank you all for joining us for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00068-00027402-00027588": "this webinar about far back and far back", "i7bX4phZ46g-00069-00027589-00027957": "community and thanks Heidi and UVM for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00070-00027958-00028152": "sponsoring this and making new things", "i7bX4phZ46g-00071-00028152-00028404": "available to farmers it's really great", "i7bX4phZ46g-00072-00028405-00028647": "I'm dinner Grover I'm a draft power", "i7bX4phZ46g-00073-00028648-00028835": "farmer in central New York State and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00074-00028836-00029049": "I've been involved in the farm pack", "i7bX4phZ46g-00075-00029050-00029215": "community for the past couple of years", "i7bX4phZ46g-00076-00029216-00029499": "so we're just really excited to be here", "i7bX4phZ46g-00077-00029500-00029820": "today and share a farm pack with you and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00078-00029820-00030048": "feel free to type and ask questions", "i7bX4phZ46g-00079-00030049-00030225": "whenever they come up throughout the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00080-00030226-00030737": "presentation so go ahead and get started", "i7bX4phZ46g-00081-00030738-00030981": "it's amazing today that we have these", "i7bX4phZ46g-00082-00030982-00031248": "tools that we can use to analyze and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00083-00031249-00031485": "contemplate both our soil microbiology", "i7bX4phZ46g-00084-00031486-00031854": "and global climate aims and the cost of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00085-00031855-00032058": "these technologies that were using that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00086-00032058-00032390": "are enabling us to capture and the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00087-00032391-00032589": "community it was going on on our farms", "i7bX4phZ46g-00088-00032589-00032838": "and in our communities are falling", "i7bX4phZ46g-00089-00032839-00033093": "rapidly and the technology that were", "i7bX4phZ46g-00090-00033094-00033390": "asking were accessible year by year so a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00091-00033391-00033594": "big piece of what we comes upon that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00092-00033595-00033906": "with is this concept that our tools", "i7bX4phZ46g-00093-00033907-00034155": "themselves are reflection of the way", "i7bX4phZ46g-00094-00034156-00034415": "that we see ourselves and the way that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00095-00034416-00034617": "we relate to our environment and of our", "i7bX4phZ46g-00096-00034618-00034952": "values so as farmers of course we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00097-00034953-00035145": "understand the basic difference between", "i7bX4phZ46g-00098-00035146-00035388": "Museum of biological or ecological", "i7bX4phZ46g-00099-00035389-00035736": "method of weed control and spraying", "i7bX4phZ46g-00100-00035737-00035907": "herbicides on their crop fields to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00101-00035908-00036255": "control weeds so it's just an example of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00102-00036256-00036478": "how the tools that we used to farm and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00103-00036479-00036625": "whether we use them reflect how we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00104-00036626-00036817": "understand and relate to our environment", "i7bX4phZ46g-00105-00036818-00037141": "and the tools that we choose and this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00106-00037142-00037417": "will be developed and groove on a fund", "i7bX4phZ46g-00107-00037418-00037729": "of our directory reflection of this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00108-00037730-00038317": "relationships we have with the land so", "i7bX4phZ46g-00109-00038318-00038593": "as as closer where you know the tools", "i7bX4phZ46g-00110-00038594-00038845": "that are available to us as small", "i7bX4phZ46g-00111-00038846-00039121": "farmers are primarily designed for large", "i7bX4phZ46g-00112-00039122-00039439": "parties for top-down energy capital and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00113-00039440-00040015": "chemical intensive agriculture and so in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00114-00040016-00040345": "2010 farm hack was conceived of by a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00115-00040346-00040657": "group of startup farmers and engineers", "i7bX4phZ46g-00116-00040658-00041011": "and technologists along with a couple a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00117-00041012-00041386": "couple of hundred nonprofits as a way of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00118-00041387-00041596": "reversing that power dynamic that I'm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00119-00041597-00041836": "talking about of the industrial process", "i7bX4phZ46g-00120-00041837-00042406": "and the Agri corporate structure an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00121-00042407-00042811": "oscillation of a division of farm hack", "i7bX4phZ46g-00122-00042812-00043120": "and vision of small farms brush that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00123-00043121-00043360": "every farm is a research and development", "i7bX4phZ46g-00124-00043361-00043621": "farm for new technologies methods and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00125-00043622-00044200": "ways of improving agriculture and so a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00126-00044201-00044458": "part of what we do is is this website", "i7bX4phZ46g-00127-00044459-00044653": "which is a platform where you can share", "i7bX4phZ46g-00128-00044654-00044899": "the school's ideas and insights that you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00129-00044900-00045100": "have and you can also look for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00130-00045101-00045268": "inspiration from other farmers and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00131-00045269-00045505": "adventures we've figured out you know a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00132-00045506-00045727": "good way to do things on their farms in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00133-00045728-00046320": "their particular bio resume or situation", "i7bX4phZ46g-00134-00046321-00046981": "and farm last itself is is it's built on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00135-00046982-00047284": "open source technology software and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00136-00047285-00047599": "isn't very sensible evolve courses", "i7bX4phZ46g-00137-00047600-00047980": "Wikipedia open source Apache servers run", "i7bX4phZ46g-00138-00047981-00048184": "the internet and that's how fun packed", "i7bX4phZ46g-00139-00048185-00048457": "operates - it's about reducing barriers", "i7bX4phZ46g-00140-00048458-00048747": "to knowledge exchange and designing", "i7bX4phZ46g-00141-00048748-00049183": "building evacuation technology in a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00142-00049184-00049333": "layered good appears", "i7bX4phZ46g-00143-00049334-00049629": "collaborative way", "i7bX4phZ46g-00144-00049630-00049954": "and it's built on this rich culture of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00145-00049955-00050236": "free and open-source software there are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00146-00050237-00050435": "many many open-source projects out there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00147-00050436-00050758": "and it's applied those ideas that were", "i7bX4phZ46g-00148-00050759-00050965": "that were conceived up and developed in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00149-00050966-00051400": "the open-source software community for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00150-00051401-00051706": "problems of hardware and any growing", "i7bX4phZ46g-00151-00051707-00052640": "techniques for small farms so it's it's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00152-00052641-00053101": "very much about the online presence but", "i7bX4phZ46g-00153-00053102-00053266": "it's even more so about the in-person", "i7bX4phZ46g-00154-00053267-00053504": "private presence or it's also about the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00155-00053504-00053887": "in-person presence and it's about in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00156-00053888-00054203": "person events we've had over twenty in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00157-00054204-00054353": "percent of farm hack events both", "i7bX4phZ46g-00158-00054354-00054578": "organized by a core group of organizers", "i7bX4phZ46g-00159-00054579-00054899": "and organized spontaneously by partners", "i7bX4phZ46g-00160-00054900-00055156": "around the country and these are these", "i7bX4phZ46g-00161-00055157-00055288": "are events where our folks get together", "i7bX4phZ46g-00162-00055289-00055606": "for creating mixing sharing making", "i7bX4phZ46g-00163-00055607-00055974": "growing eating and drinking together and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00164-00055975-00056269": "it's about that collaborative design", "i7bX4phZ46g-00165-00056270-00056644": "process both in person and online that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00166-00056645-00056921": "enables us to work better because we're", "i7bX4phZ46g-00167-00056922-00057316": "working together so that's a brief", "i7bX4phZ46g-00168-00057317-00057611": "overview of what farm hack is are there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00169-00057612-00057838": "any questions from anyone at this point", "i7bX4phZ46g-00170-00057839-00058042": "I'd be happy to answer any questions", "i7bX4phZ46g-00171-00058043-00058547": "that you type in and if not we'll dive", "i7bX4phZ46g-00172-00058548-00058861": "right into looking at some a tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00173-00058862-00059099": "documentation and what that actually", "i7bX4phZ46g-00174-00059100-00059630": "looks like on the farm pack website", "i7bX4phZ46g-00175-00059631-00060005": "great thanks Daniel for the overview I'm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00176-00060006-00060185": "going to bring up the website again this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00177-00060186-00060482": "is Doran Cox I'm the board president of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00178-00060483-00060779": "farm hack which is an independent 501 C", "i7bX4phZ46g-00179-00060780-00061040": "3 at this point nonprofit to oversee", "i7bX4phZ46g-00180-00061041-00061175": "this mission and to hold this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00181-00061176-00061515": "intellectual property in common and put", "i7bX4phZ46g-00182-00061516-00061856": "it into the so that we can each build on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00183-00061857-00062162": "each other's our best ideas and as", "i7bX4phZ46g-00184-00062163-00062372": "Daniel said this is about open source", "i7bX4phZ46g-00185-00062373-00062654": "technology where we're trying to not", "i7bX4phZ46g-00186-00062655-00062930": "create a product that is just better", "i7bX4phZ46g-00187-00062931-00063071": "than the competition but the best", "i7bX4phZ46g-00188-00063072-00063344": "possible product that we will actually", "i7bX4phZ46g-00189-00063345-00063701": "use ourselves and generate demand from", "i7bX4phZ46g-00190-00063702-00063887": "within our own community so really this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00191-00063888-00064067": "is about building the tools that we all", "i7bX4phZ46g-00192-00064068-00064396": "want to use ourselves and then build a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00193-00064397-00064685": "process a manufacturing process to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00194-00064686-00064907": "support that and support process so", "i7bX4phZ46g-00195-00064908-00065129": "having a Community Supported so instead", "i7bX4phZ46g-00196-00065130-00065426": "of having the consumer-related sort of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00197-00065427-00065597": "model where we depend on a dealer", "i7bX4phZ46g-00198-00065598-00065792": "network and customer support and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00199-00065793-00065996": "warranties and so forth what we have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00200-00065997-00066227": "instead is a community that's developing", "i7bX4phZ46g-00201-00066228-00066443": "and supporting each other and creating", "i7bX4phZ46g-00202-00066444-00066641": "the products that we're noticing work", "i7bX4phZ46g-00203-00066642-00066926": "best in our own in our own farms so a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00204-00066927-00067079": "lot of the best you know there's more", "i7bX4phZ46g-00205-00067080-00067241": "innovation that happens on farms", "i7bX4phZ46g-00206-00067242-00067502": "everyday than in all the universities", "i7bX4phZ46g-00207-00067503-00067688": "and research labs but most of those", "i7bX4phZ46g-00208-00067689-00067901": "ideas stay on the farm or maybe they get", "i7bX4phZ46g-00209-00067902-00068051": "to their neighbor or somebody on the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00210-00068052-00068213": "other part of the county", "i7bX4phZ46g-00211-00068214-00068453": "so we also notice that when we're at", "i7bX4phZ46g-00212-00068454-00068600": "their conferences that there's some", "i7bX4phZ46g-00213-00068601-00068798": "great ideas and some good brainstorms", "i7bX4phZ46g-00214-00068799-00069110": "but often that activity stops during", "i7bX4phZ46g-00215-00069111-00069404": "that weekend or those couple days so we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00216-00069405-00069527": "really feel that the way in which", "i7bX4phZ46g-00217-00069528-00069716": "knowledge exchange happens is to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00218-00069717-00069953": "document it and so that's what I'm going", "i7bX4phZ46g-00219-00069954-00070325": "to show you here as we jump to jump to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00220-00070326-00070814": "the website and what with what the farm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00221-00070815-00071105": "hack website is about which in itself is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00222-00071106-00071369": "daniel said is a an open source tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00223-00071370-00071615": "itself and so that's constantly evolving", "i7bX4phZ46g-00224-00071616-00071900": "to when we've recruited lots of web", "i7bX4phZ46g-00225-00071901-00072122": "developers and engineers and folks to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00226-00072123-00072452": "help improve that and the farm hack site", "i7bX4phZ46g-00227-00072453-00072788": "is all it's all user-generated content", "i7bX4phZ46g-00228-00072789-00073019": "that means the community itself", "i7bX4phZ46g-00229-00073020-00073479": "is what is responsible for the content", "i7bX4phZ46g-00230-00073480-00073890": "that's posted so myself or Daniel or any", "i7bX4phZ46g-00231-00073891-00074172": "of you are responsible for creating the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00232-00074173-00075082": "quality of the resource that's up there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00233-00075083-00075259": "and then should be", "i7bX4phZ46g-00234-00075260-00075499": "second and so what I'm going to show you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00235-00075500-00076009": "here is on the upper left hand corner of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00236-00076010-00076191": "the plant website you can see a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00237-00076192-00076678": "selection for tools and this is a list", "i7bX4phZ46g-00238-00076679-00076993": "of the over 100 tools that our users", "i7bX4phZ46g-00239-00076994-00077169": "have contributed and made open-source so", "i7bX4phZ46g-00240-00077170-00077434": "this is the opposite of patenting and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00241-00077435-00077617": "I'm going to walk through about four", "i7bX4phZ46g-00242-00077618-00077809": "different tools here at the top just to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00243-00077810-00078109": "give an example of what some of the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00244-00078110-00078280": "history of that and how this system", "i7bX4phZ46g-00245-00078281-00078600": "works so the first one I can show you is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00246-00078601-00078835": "and they range from everything from", "i7bX4phZ46g-00247-00078836-00079262": "electronics projects to welding projects", "i7bX4phZ46g-00248-00079263-00079660": "to software but I'll give you just an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00249-00079661-00080023": "example of a one of the first tools that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00250-00080024-00080199": "was posted in farm hack which is this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00251-00080200-00080525": "Fido temperature alarm for greenhouses", "i7bX4phZ46g-00252-00080526-00080884": "so this was in response to a grower who", "i7bX4phZ46g-00253-00080885-00081103": "had the issue of having a greenhouse", "i7bX4phZ46g-00254-00081104-00081298": "down the road and they had a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00255-00081299-00081640": "particularly hot spring then and they", "i7bX4phZ46g-00256-00081641-00081963": "lost a lot of their starts because they", "i7bX4phZ46g-00257-00081964-00082218": "didn't in the middle of the day and in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00258-00082219-00082443": "April it got up to eighty degrees which", "i7bX4phZ46g-00259-00082444-00082638": "oh and then which overheated the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00260-00082639-00082824": "greenhouse and they were just a couple", "i7bX4phZ46g-00261-00082825-00082999": "hours behind getting to open up the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00262-00083000-00083440": "sides so they in our one of our first", "i7bX4phZ46g-00263-00083441-00083655": "in-person PHARMAC meetings had presented", "i7bX4phZ46g-00264-00083656-00083904": "this problem and there are a number of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00265-00083905-00084156": "software engineers and and hardware", "i7bX4phZ46g-00266-00084157-00084399": "folks electronic hardware folks there he", "i7bX4phZ46g-00267-00084400-00084598": "said well we've got solutions for that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00268-00084599-00084855": "that are very low cost the cost of a lot", "i7bX4phZ46g-00269-00084856-00085204": "of the technology to both monitor and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00270-00085205-00085741": "then link into low cost shell phone has", "i7bX4phZ46g-00271-00085742-00085924": "really come down so they built for under", "i7bX4phZ46g-00272-00085925-00086406": "$100 a system which was an open-source", "i7bX4phZ46g-00273-00086407-00086712": "Hardware board with a mobile phone that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00274-00086713-00086862": "would text message when the temperature", "i7bX4phZ46g-00275-00086863-00087478": "had a range that has since merged and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00276-00087479-00087853": "and so they posted this design on to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00277-00087854-00088030": "farm hack and became a collaborative", "i7bX4phZ46g-00278-00088031-00088275": "project and since then there have been", "i7bX4phZ46g-00279-00088276-00088644": "about a half dozen variations of that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00280-00088645-00088944": "whereas technologies have has changed", "i7bX4phZ46g-00281-00088945-00089241": "which includes if you go to the the farm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00282-00089242-00089589": "hack tool site and your browse down", "i7bX4phZ46g-00283-00089590-00089829": "you'll see a whole bunch of other legacy", "i7bX4phZ46g-00284-00089830-00090093": "projects like a wireless garden field", "i7bX4phZ46g-00285-00090094-00090513": "mode sensor the if we go down here", "i7bX4phZ46g-00286-00090514-00091143": "there's a Wi-Fi farm guide a mobile", "i7bX4phZ46g-00287-00091144-00091518": "solar electric fence system a system to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00288-00091519-00091848": "attach multiple sensors a compost", "i7bX4phZ46g-00289-00091849-00092238": "monitor an electric fence monitor all of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00290-00092239-00092634": "these systems grew very quickly based on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00291-00092635-00092928": "the this initial project and the fact", "i7bX4phZ46g-00292-00092929-00093147": "that the original project was freely", "i7bX4phZ46g-00293-00093148-00093372": "shared in all the parts associated with", "i7bX4phZ46g-00294-00093373-00093558": "it all of the code to run up the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00295-00093559-00093738": "assembly instructions were all", "i7bX4phZ46g-00296-00093739-00094140": "documented documented here this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00297-00094141-00094248": "particular entry is the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00298-00094249-00094494": "second-generation Fido and you'll notice", "i7bX4phZ46g-00299-00094495-00094773": "that some of the instructions are not", "i7bX4phZ46g-00300-00094774-00095091": "yet installed one important thing to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00301-00095092-00095307": "note here on this tool and then you'll", "i7bX4phZ46g-00302-00095308-00095586": "go into this a little more is that this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00303-00095587-00095946": "is like a Wikipedia site anybody can now", "i7bX4phZ46g-00304-00095947-00096132": "edit this documentation and make it", "i7bX4phZ46g-00305-00096133-00096321": "better so the idea is to promote", "i7bX4phZ46g-00306-00096322-00096558": "collaboration in developing these", "i7bX4phZ46g-00307-00096559-00096951": "solutions these tools I'll show you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00308-00096952-00097428": "another example here so that was an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00309-00097429-00097667": "example of an away", "i7bX4phZ46g-00310-00097668-00097861": "atronics project that there was an early", "i7bX4phZ46g-00311-00097862-00098165": "one another one is this a roller cover", "i7bX4phZ46g-00312-00098166-00098390": "crop roller which was addressing some of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00313-00098391-00098767": "the issues of trying to use no-till in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00314-00098768-00099067": "an organic system now the Rodale", "i7bX4phZ46g-00315-00099068-00099571": "Institute made their plans open-source", "i7bX4phZ46g-00316-00099572-00099793": "early on and sort of set the standard", "i7bX4phZ46g-00317-00099794-00099979": "demonstrated what it's like instead of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00318-00099980-00100219": "patenting this technology that they", "i7bX4phZ46g-00319-00100220-00100569": "developed they instead said well it's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00320-00100570-00100871": "much more advantageous to put this out", "i7bX4phZ46g-00321-00100872-00101263": "in in the world and publish the the CAD", "i7bX4phZ46g-00322-00101264-00101435": "drawings so that anybody can manufacture", "i7bX4phZ46g-00323-00101436-00101776": "it there are now commercial", "i7bX4phZ46g-00324-00101777-00101956": "manufacturers that manufacture their", "i7bX4phZ46g-00325-00101957-00102136": "version but because they made it", "i7bX4phZ46g-00326-00102137-00102415": "open-source you can see here there are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00327-00102416-00102604": "multiple versions that have been", "i7bX4phZ46g-00328-00102605-00102974": "developed around not just in so the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00329-00102975-00103151": "Rodale development in Pennsylvania was", "i7bX4phZ46g-00330-00103152-00103538": "quickly copied elsewhere in Pennsylvania", "i7bX4phZ46g-00331-00103539-00104096": "in New York State this is this is a New", "i7bX4phZ46g-00332-00104097-00104464": "York State but then there are other", "i7bX4phZ46g-00333-00104465-00104659": "versions that were modified so this is a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00334-00104660-00104993": "this was a French modification that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00335-00104994-00105251": "worked better is a row Dale's version", "i7bX4phZ46g-00336-00105252-00105476": "worked great for really flat fields we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00337-00105477-00105715": "had veggie producers who are much more", "i7bX4phZ46g-00338-00105716-00105899": "interested in working with the same", "i7bX4phZ46g-00339-00105900-00106240": "technique but in raised beds or shapes", "i7bX4phZ46g-00340-00106241-00106526": "of shaped beds and so here's the same", "i7bX4phZ46g-00341-00106527-00106876": "principle not applied to a flexible", "i7bX4phZ46g-00342-00106877-00107072": "system and again this all happened", "i7bX4phZ46g-00343-00107073-00107444": "fairly quickly and not just and expanded", "i7bX4phZ46g-00344-00107445-00107600": "the conversation beyond what was", "i7bX4phZ46g-00345-00107601-00107846": "happening in Pennsylvania - as I", "i7bX4phZ46g-00346-00107847-00108395": "mentioned New Hampshire Pennsylvania and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00347-00108396-00108698": "New York State southern parts of the of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00348-00108699-00109111": "the state - in the photos I just showed", "i7bX4phZ46g-00349-00109113-00109333": "you were from France these are German", "i7bX4phZ46g-00350-00109334-00109978": "versions that were created as well and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00351-00109979-00110225": "so this just goes to show when this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00352-00110226-00110438": "knowledge is shared we get much more", "i7bX4phZ46g-00353-00110439-00110768": "rapid feedback and adaptation and create", "i7bX4phZ46g-00354-00110769-00110969": "products that are going to be much more", "i7bX4phZ46g-00355-00110970-00111005": "light", "i7bX4phZ46g-00356-00111006-00111257": "to be appropriate for our through our", "i7bX4phZ46g-00357-00111258-00111668": "own use and we bring in more people into", "i7bX4phZ46g-00358-00111669-00111848": "the conversation", "i7bX4phZ46g-00359-00111849-00112027": "and you can see some of that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00360-00112028-00112268": "documentation and changes in discussion", "i7bX4phZ46g-00361-00112269-00112611": "that happens here within within the site", "i7bX4phZ46g-00362-00112613-00112909": "then data will go into it a little bit", "i7bX4phZ46g-00363-00112910-00113057": "more but you can also see that in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00364-00113058-00113259": "addition to the documentation we have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00365-00113260-00113480": "the ability to ask the other", "i7bX4phZ46g-00366-00113481-00113714": "participants questions and submit new", "i7bX4phZ46g-00367-00113715-00113935": "information submit an idea ask questions", "i7bX4phZ46g-00368-00113936-00114206": "and report problems so it's not just", "i7bX4phZ46g-00369-00114207-00114506": "about a report about how this works but", "i7bX4phZ46g-00370-00114507-00115024": "also about constantly improving and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00371-00115025-00115229": "reporting back on how things are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00372-00115230-00115550": "actually working in the field so another", "i7bX4phZ46g-00373-00115551-00115705": "example of that sort of international", "i7bX4phZ46g-00374-00115706-00116033": "adaptation is of the triangle click", "i7bX4phZ46g-00375-00116033-00116270": "attach which is improvement on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00376-00116271-00116606": "three-point hitch system to enable a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00377-00116607-00116798": "very rapid change for multiple for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00378-00116799-00117061": "implements on farm especially applicable", "i7bX4phZ46g-00379-00117063-00117286": "and veggie operations where you often", "i7bX4phZ46g-00380-00117288-00117557": "changing equipment it also solves a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00381-00117558-00117858": "safety issue of of hitching up to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00382-00117859-00118169": "equipment one of the issues is that this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00383-00118170-00118415": "this hitch system which is commercially", "i7bX4phZ46g-00384-00118416-00118684": "available in Europe but it's not", "i7bX4phZ46g-00385-00118685-00118856": "available in the US or there's very", "i7bX4phZ46g-00386-00118857-00119015": "limited supply with a couple of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00387-00119016-00119266": "suppliers who are no longer in business", "i7bX4phZ46g-00388-00119267-00119683": "our partners to the farm hack community", "i7bX4phZ46g-00389-00119684-00119876": "in France had developed full", "i7bX4phZ46g-00390-00119877-00120251": "documentation for this system and I'd", "i7bX4phZ46g-00391-00120252-00120623": "published them and were again making", "i7bX4phZ46g-00392-00120624-00120791": "those open source and available for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00393-00120792-00121258": "sharing however not only was it in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00394-00121259-00121508": "France and French but they're steel", "i7bX4phZ46g-00395-00121508-00121718": "stock was metric so here's an example of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00396-00121719-00121994": "our community coming together to adapt", "i7bX4phZ46g-00397-00121995-00122273": "the design that can be made in an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00398-00122274-00122605": "American shop or a Canadian shop using", "i7bX4phZ46g-00399-00122606-00122930": "standard dimension steel stock and so", "i7bX4phZ46g-00400-00122931-00123056": "that's exactly what the farm hack", "i7bX4phZ46g-00401-00123057-00123436": "community did is we adapted their basic", "i7bX4phZ46g-00402-00123438-00123854": "design and documented it and with", "i7bX4phZ46g-00403-00123855-00124058": "step-by-step instructions about how to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00404-00124058-00124535": "manufacture that here in the US", "i7bX4phZ46g-00405-00124536-00124947": "and so the result is is the workdays", "i7bX4phZ46g-00406-00124948-00125175": "that we've been able to have here and a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00407-00125176-00125333": "number of farms we've had many different", "i7bX4phZ46g-00408-00125334-00125663": "variations both here in the US and in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00409-00125664-00125919": "Quebec and Canada in other provinces in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00410-00125920-00126270": "Canada that have now taken those designs", "i7bX4phZ46g-00411-00126271-00126531": "adapted them made some variations that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00412-00126532-00126843": "make it easier to manufacture in a farm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00413-00126844-00127407": "shop and and and then reported back to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00414-00127408-00127647": "the community as far as how they how", "i7bX4phZ46g-00415-00127648-00127797": "they're working and what improvements we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00416-00127798-00128066": "can make for the next farmer a few", "i7bX4phZ46g-00417-00128067-00128250": "starts to build them so for example on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00418-00128251-00128537": "our farm we are we're gonna have the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00419-00128538-00128753": "benefit this year of not being the first", "i7bX4phZ46g-00420-00128754-00128949": "out but will be the probably the fourth", "i7bX4phZ46g-00421-00128950-00129219": "or fifth farm here in the US using some", "i7bX4phZ46g-00422-00129220-00129404": "of these techniques as we manufacture", "i7bX4phZ46g-00423-00129405-00129860": "them for our own operation I'll show you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00424-00129861-00130350": "one more tool just as an example we also", "i7bX4phZ46g-00425-00130351-00130903": "have not just adapting sort of scaling", "i7bX4phZ46g-00426-00130904-00131126": "other types of tools but we have some", "i7bX4phZ46g-00427-00131127-00131291": "some new concepts that are being", "i7bX4phZ46g-00428-00131292-00131625": "developed you can see down here the show", "i7bX4phZ46g-00429-00131626-00131966": "the culture cycle which has a which is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00430-00131967-00132289": "addressing the challenge of small-scale", "i7bX4phZ46g-00431-00132290-00132602": "cultivating tractors that are no not", "i7bX4phZ46g-00432-00132603-00132918": "particularly available and then applying", "i7bX4phZ46g-00433-00132919-00133265": "some of the collaborative flexibility of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00434-00133266-00133502": "prototyping tools to the farm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00435-00133503-00133749": "manufacture environment so making a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00436-00133750-00134303": "modular pedal powered bicycle pedal", "i7bX4phZ46g-00437-00134304-00134711": "powered tractors that can be used for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00438-00134712-00135098": "garden for market garden scale", "i7bX4phZ46g-00439-00135099-00135539": "cultivation and again very low cost and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00440-00135540-00135834": "many many iterations and so this is an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00441-00135835-00136149": "example again of become an international", "i7bX4phZ46g-00442-00136150-00136332": "collaboration and we're bringing in a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00443-00136333-00136548": "number of different folks on the pedal", "i7bX4phZ46g-00444-00136549-00136734": "powered and electrification and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00445-00136735-00137089": "standardization of of cultivating", "i7bX4phZ46g-00446-00137090-00137591": "toolbars into this conversation and you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00447-00137592-00137763": "can see the basic", "i7bX4phZ46g-00448-00137764-00138076": "some of the basic documentation here", "i7bX4phZ46g-00449-00138077-00138398": "that's been posted so far and we will", "i7bX4phZ46g-00450-00138399-00138713": "have to advance the quality of this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00451-00138714-00138968": "documentation and to bring in more folks", "i7bX4phZ46g-00452-00138969-00139301": "into this conversation farm act is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00453-00139302-00139520": "helping to coordinate an event coming up", "i7bX4phZ46g-00454-00139521-00140045": "in at the end of March to to further", "i7bX4phZ46g-00455-00140046-00140333": "document and a build process for one of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00456-00140334-00140669": "these culture cycles coming up in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00457-00140670-00140964": "Cambridge Mass at the end of this month", "i7bX4phZ46g-00458-00140965-00141352": "and with that I encourage you to to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00459-00141353-00141604": "browse the tools that are available you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00460-00141605-00141770": "can looked at the top there's a search", "i7bX4phZ46g-00461-00141771-00142058": "bar but I guess with that I will I'll", "i7bX4phZ46g-00462-00142059-00142361": "turn it over to to Daniel to do a little", "i7bX4phZ46g-00463-00142362-00142544": "bit of a walkthrough of the various", "i7bX4phZ46g-00464-00142545-00142745": "elements of the of the other elements of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00465-00142746-00143208": "the farm act website and how to use it", "i7bX4phZ46g-00466-00143209-00143687": "create it into much going so I will go", "i7bX4phZ46g-00467-00143688-00144428": "ahead and scrub share my screen I'll", "i7bX4phZ46g-00468-00144429-00146566": "need to stop sharing my screen", "i7bX4phZ46g-00469-00146567-00146838": "you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00470-00146839-00147878": "oh we can see your screen okay", "i7bX4phZ46g-00471-00147879-00148487": "all set all set okay great so Thank You", "i7bX4phZ46g-00472-00148488-00148817": "Dorn for going through those tools I'll", "i7bX4phZ46g-00473-00148818-00149240": "just do a quick overview of how to get", "i7bX4phZ46g-00474-00149241-00149399": "started with documenting tools in the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00475-00149400-00149645": "far back website the first thing that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00476-00149646-00149843": "you would need to do is sign in or", "i7bX4phZ46g-00477-00149844-00149927": "create an account", "i7bX4phZ46g-00478-00149928-00150308": "I should already be signed in here so", "i7bX4phZ46g-00479-00150309-00150623": "I'll go back to the home page and and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00480-00150624-00150872": "basically the way that the way that the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00481-00150873-00151172": "farm hacked site navigation works is up", "i7bX4phZ46g-00482-00151173-00151393": "here on this top toolbar we have tools", "i7bX4phZ46g-00483-00151394-00151778": "this is just a list that is organized by", "i7bX4phZ46g-00484-00151779-00152135": "the most recently updated tool so when a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00485-00152136-00152399": "tool wiki is contributed to or a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00486-00152400-00152591": "conversation that's had about it it", "i7bX4phZ46g-00487-00152592-00152972": "jumps back to the top of the list and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00488-00152973-00153179": "then here within the conversations tab", "i7bX4phZ46g-00489-00153180-00153410": "there is actually a text search so that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00490-00153411-00153812": "you can search for for instance German", "i7bX4phZ46g-00491-00153813-00154259": "and come up with with these germ", "i7bX4phZ46g-00492-00154260-00154550": "chambers term tailor designs that have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00493-00154551-00155098": "been iterative on a couple of times", "i7bX4phZ46g-00494-00155099-00155593": "front page we have the the far back", "i7bX4phZ46g-00495-00155594-00156087": "community has developed a a template for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00496-00156088-00156316": "documenting tools and that's here that's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00497-00156317-00156520": "giving started sections or from from", "i7bX4phZ46g-00498-00156521-00156963": "page top right it's getting started and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00499-00156964-00157183": "there's in this section there's a lot of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00500-00157184-00157363": "useful information including you can", "i7bX4phZ46g-00501-00157364-00157531": "also find this the same video that's on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00502-00157532-00157978": "the front page here about how to post to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00503-00157979-00158215": "the forum how to use the website in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00504-00158216-00158548": "general and then here this is really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00505-00158549-00158716": "important these tools a template for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00506-00158717-00159016": "guiding your first post so if you click", "i7bX4phZ46g-00507-00159017-00159427": "there the tool template wiki comes up", "i7bX4phZ46g-00508-00159428-00159904": "and this wiki itself is also an adult by", "i7bX4phZ46g-00509-00159905-00160114": "the community and has been improved on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00510-00160115-00160441": "over time as we've learned new ways to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00511-00160442-00160864": "document tools the tools in web tools", "i7bX4phZ46g-00512-00160865-00161127": "that were using to insert photo albums", "i7bX4phZ46g-00513-00161128-00161728": "spreadsheets etc but basically this this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00514-00161729-00161926": "tool template would be is structuring in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00515-00161927-00162066": "the way that all of our school", "i7bX4phZ46g-00516-00162067-00162436": "documentation is so the first part of it", "i7bX4phZ46g-00517-00162437-00162727": "is a brief profile that's this first", "i7bX4phZ46g-00518-00162728-00162976": "part that you see now is easily a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00519-00162977-00163272": "thorough and a short description that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00520-00163273-00163678": "it's just a few sentences long giving a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00521-00163679-00163909": "bit of information about the tool and a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00522-00163910-00164398": "title and below that is back to a little", "i7bX4phZ46g-00523-00164399-00164650": "tool wiki which is us throwing the same", "i7bX4phZ46g-00524-00164651-00165076": "like a Wikipedia page so you can edit", "i7bX4phZ46g-00525-00165077-00165406": "this tool profile as you see this link", "i7bX4phZ46g-00526-00165407-00165811": "to do that here and you can also edit", "i7bX4phZ46g-00527-00165812-00166054": "this wiki and anyone can make edits to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00528-00166055-00166324": "any of those cells at any time and all", "i7bX4phZ46g-00529-00166325-00166762": "of the revisions are tracked here so we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00530-00166763-00167032": "can see that there are have been a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00531-00167033-00167386": "number of a number of edits over time to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00532-00167387-00167746": "to this little template and you can go", "i7bX4phZ46g-00533-00167747-00167893": "back through them and look at what each", "i7bX4phZ46g-00534-00167894-00168066": "specific and it was you can actually", "i7bX4phZ46g-00535-00168067-00168323": "look at the the evolution of the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00536-00168324-00168821": "of the tool documentation so we the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00537-00168822-00169053": "foreign community basically offers this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00538-00169054-00169363": "template as a starting place for people", "i7bX4phZ46g-00539-00169364-00169622": "to talk about their tool it's by no", "i7bX4phZ46g-00540-00169623-00169938": "means meant to be the be-all end-all", "i7bX4phZ46g-00541-00169939-00170321": "tool documentation template file it it's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00542-00170322-00170582": "kind of what what what the community has", "i7bX4phZ46g-00543-00170583-00170969": "come to agree upon has some useful", "i7bX4phZ46g-00544-00170970-00171379": "standards for getting started so as I", "i7bX4phZ46g-00545-00171380-00171809": "said starting with a title and a really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00546-00171810-00172034": "useful piece is the problem statement", "i7bX4phZ46g-00547-00172035-00172295": "which basically says you know I'm I'm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00548-00172296-00172513": "facing this problem on my farm and that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00549-00172514-00172840": "is why I why I needed to create this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00550-00172841-00173038": "tool or while I'm looking for a solution", "i7bX4phZ46g-00551-00173039-00173297": "and I should also say that you can you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00552-00173298-00173468": "can also document just a problem", "i7bX4phZ46g-00553-00173469-00173624": "statement and put that up on the farm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00554-00173625-00174047": "path website and ask for folks to you to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00555-00174048-00174335": "reflect back any ideas they have about", "i7bX4phZ46g-00556-00174336-00174821": "how you might solve that problem then we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00557-00174822-00174983": "have the functional description of herd", "i7bX4phZ46g-00558-00174984-00175208": "section and basically as we go through", "i7bX4phZ46g-00559-00175209-00175563": "this each each section is just described", "i7bX4phZ46g-00560-00175564-00176038": "in detail here how people have document", "i7bX4phZ46g-00561-00176039-00176276": "have used that section in the past what", "i7bX4phZ46g-00562-00176277-00176779": "we suggest or how to use it how the tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00563-00176780-00177071": "is used bill of materials and sourcing", "i7bX4phZ46g-00564-00177072-00177344": "which is really important when folks are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00565-00177345-00177749": "trying to get together a you know a list", "i7bX4phZ46g-00566-00177750-00178009": "of materials to document a specific tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00567-00178010-00178279": "that's really useful for them to have a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00568-00178280-00178559": "concept of how much is this tool going", "i7bX4phZ46g-00569-00178560-00178804": "to cost them to build and where can they", "i7bX4phZ46g-00570-00178805-00179104": "get those materials so you'll also see", "i7bX4phZ46g-00571-00179105-00179345": "in this section", "i7bX4phZ46g-00572-00179346-00179701": "there are some examples for example on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00573-00179702-00180188": "this water needle tool this this tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00574-00180189-00180538": "documentary used Google Docs to embed", "i7bX4phZ46g-00575-00180539-00180770": "spreadsheets into their full", "i7bX4phZ46g-00576-00180771-00180991": "documentation they also use video to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00577-00180992-00181327": "embed to embed instructional videos to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00578-00181328-00181540": "their documentation so this just gives", "i7bX4phZ46g-00579-00181541-00181924": "an example of the range of possible", "i7bX4phZ46g-00580-00181925-00182120": "documentation technologies that you can", "i7bX4phZ46g-00581-00182121-00182389": "use to get the message across about the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00582-00182390-00182645": "tool that you're trying to post and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00583-00182646-00182912": "here's some how to's how to embed from", "i7bX4phZ46g-00584-00182913-00183298": "Google Docs how to embed from onedrive", "i7bX4phZ46g-00585-00183299-00183541": "that's you know if you if you're working", "i7bX4phZ46g-00586-00183542-00183824": "in Microsoft Office and you can use a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00587-00183825-00184097": "cloud-based tool called onedrive to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00588-00184098-00184279": "embed your Excel document or whatever", "i7bX4phZ46g-00589-00184280-00184775": "and then down to the construction how to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00590-00184776-00185126": "build section we recommend you know", "i7bX4phZ46g-00591-00185127-00185629": "either using your own your own slideshow", "i7bX4phZ46g-00592-00185630-00185936": "that you created or stating one with the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00593-00185937-00186293": "tool like imager or Instructables and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00594-00186294-00186654": "then embedding it so here's an example", "i7bX4phZ46g-00595-00186655-00187078": "back to the germination chamber of tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00596-00187079-00187400": "documentation that uses imager to go", "i7bX4phZ46g-00597-00187401-00187613": "through the documentation step by step", "i7bX4phZ46g-00598-00187614-00188016": "so there's a picture and accompanying", "i7bX4phZ46g-00599-00188017-00188375": "explanation of that step in the process", "i7bX4phZ46g-00600-00188376-00188585": "and you can go through the entire", "i7bX4phZ46g-00601-00188586-00188884": "process and see how this particular", "i7bX4phZ46g-00602-00188885-00189774": "germination chamber was built", "i7bX4phZ46g-00603-00189775-00190049": "and there's also you know next steps", "i7bX4phZ46g-00604-00190050-00190244": "goals and barriers so this is an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00605-00190245-00190523": "opportunity again see the voice some of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00606-00190524-00190690": "the things that aren't working for you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00607-00190691-00191057": "in your design or working for to meeting", "i7bX4phZ46g-00608-00191058-00191614": "the design if you would like to sell a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00609-00191615-00191837": "piece of a tool or piece of equipment", "i7bX4phZ46g-00610-00191838-00192076": "that you've created and in the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00611-00192077-00192362": "open-source community then we also", "i7bX4phZ46g-00612-00192363-00192865": "welcome that and then some sections for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00613-00192866-00193075": "research and resources and all your own", "i7bX4phZ46g-00614-00193076-00193288": "projects which is another really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00615-00193289-00193610": "important section where you can link to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00616-00193611-00193994": "other tools that are that are either", "i7bX4phZ46g-00617-00193995-00194332": "using related technologies or are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00618-00194333-00194551": "branched off of the tool that has been", "i7bX4phZ46g-00619-00194552-00194749": "documented in this piece of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00620-00194750-00195091": "documentation or have some other kind of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00621-00195092-00195277": "relation maybe they're solving the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00622-00195278-00195738": "similar problem statement maybe they're", "i7bX4phZ46g-00623-00195739-00196118": "replacing replacing the tool with some", "i7bX4phZ46g-00624-00196119-00196264": "other piece of equipment there are two", "i7bX4phZ46g-00625-00196265-00196438": "different ways to replace it anything", "i7bX4phZ46g-00626-00196439-00196627": "like that those are things that can be", "i7bX4phZ46g-00627-00196628-00196863": "linked to in the ongoing projects", "i7bX4phZ46g-00628-00196864-00197284": "section and then attached to each tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00629-00197285-00197744": "profile and wiki is also a tool forum we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00630-00197745-00197887": "have a couple of different kinds of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00631-00197888-00198079": "forums on the project website there are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00632-00198080-00198356": "event forums there are general forums", "i7bX4phZ46g-00633-00198357-00198526": "that aren't attached to a specific tool", "i7bX4phZ46g-00634-00198527-00198853": "and then there are tool forums and there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00635-00198854-00199159": "are four different kind of tags for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00636-00199160-00199418": "information in the tool forum new", "i7bX4phZ46g-00637-00199419-00199856": "information ideas questions and problems", "i7bX4phZ46g-00638-00199857-00200069": "and as we can see there's been an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00639-00200070-00200362": "ongoing conversation about the best way", "i7bX4phZ46g-00640-00200363-00200704": "to document tools via farm hack and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00641-00200705-00200898": "that's the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00642-00200899-00201102": "that those are the foreign conversations", "i7bX4phZ46g-00643-00201103-00201748": "that you're seeing here", "i7bX4phZ46g-00644-00201749-00202154": "that that basically covers that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00645-00202155-00202337": "basically covers the tool documentation", "i7bX4phZ46g-00646-00202338-00202772": "section of the website and another thing", "i7bX4phZ46g-00647-00202773-00203046": "that we welcome folks to do is is to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00648-00203047-00203471": "host a farm hack event so just like we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00649-00203472-00203963": "had a tool template for for for a garden", "i7bX4phZ46g-00650-00203964-00204404": "tool we also have a tool that is about", "i7bX4phZ46g-00651-00204405-00204674": "organizing for America vents this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00652-00204675-00205052": "community in the first several years a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00653-00205053-00205256": "lot of the events were organized by core", "i7bX4phZ46g-00654-00205257-00205548": "group of organizers and what we really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00655-00205548-00205896": "welcome is for folks to you know decide", "i7bX4phZ46g-00656-00205896-00206021": "that they'd like to have a farm hack", "i7bX4phZ46g-00657-00206023-00206285": "event in their community and use the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00658-00206286-00206492": "platform and use the tools in the spirit", "i7bX4phZ46g-00659-00206494-00206879": "of open source to do that so this piece", "i7bX4phZ46g-00660-00206880-00207157": "of documentation here is designed to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00661-00207158-00207608": "help you to identify how to post a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00662-00207609-00207863": "poster PHARMAC event what what does a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00663-00207864-00208205": "farm AK event entail and and what do you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00664-00208206-00208694": "need to put it on so please feel free to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00665-00208696-00208880": "take a look at this and think about", "i7bX4phZ46g-00666-00208881-00209180": "whether whether a farm hack event would", "i7bX4phZ46g-00667-00209181-00209303": "be a thing that you'd love to have in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00668-00209304-00209984": "your community in your future so I think", "i7bX4phZ46g-00669-00209985-00210242": "that I'll I'll go ahead and open it up", "i7bX4phZ46g-00670-00210244-00210521": "again for questions if anyone has any", "i7bX4phZ46g-00671-00210523-00211164": "and and yeah I'm happy happy to answer", "i7bX4phZ46g-00672-00211165-00211583": "any questions that you you guys have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00673-00211584-00211838": "you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00674-00211839-00212066": "so and there's one question over", "i7bX4phZ46g-00675-00212067-00212592": "about if the documentation is posted", "i7bX4phZ46g-00676-00212594-00212939": "whether there's been instances of that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00677-00212940-00213316": "been being patented and protected and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00678-00213317-00213553": "McDaniel posted a couple links to follow", "i7bX4phZ46g-00679-00213554-00213898": "up on that but partly this is to protect", "i7bX4phZ46g-00680-00213900-00214108": "that once it's posted once that core", "i7bX4phZ46g-00681-00214109-00214439": "idea is posted its licensed through the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00682-00214440-00214681": "Creative Commons so they would have to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00683-00214682-00214903": "prove that it is substantially different", "i7bX4phZ46g-00684-00214904-00215501": "than what was posted and so this is sort", "i7bX4phZ46g-00685-00215502-00215738": "of it this is essentially protecting it", "i7bX4phZ46g-00686-00215739-00216184": "from being patented in essence so that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00687-00216185-00216433": "Creative Commons license is is really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00688-00216434-00216580": "the important element there and there's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00689-00216581-00216842": "an organization around protecting what", "i7bX4phZ46g-00690-00216842-00217016": "gets put into the Creative Commons and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00691-00217017-00217277": "so farm hack is being able to use that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00692-00217278-00217544": "process and so when you see that that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00693-00217544-00217894": "you can put us in the logo of farm hack", "i7bX4phZ46g-00694-00217896-00218189": "to the left facing fee and that sort of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00695-00218190-00218578": "indicate an indication of that of that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00696-00218579-00219403": "left see licensing does that I hope that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00697-00219404-00219631": "there's also been some question as far", "i7bX4phZ46g-00698-00219632-00220105": "as the process of liability of posting", "i7bX4phZ46g-00699-00220106-00220425": "these questions and that's also a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00700-00220426-00220606": "covered under the Creative Commons", "i7bX4phZ46g-00701-00220607-00220971": "license as well so there's there's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00702-00220973-00221425": "protection in that Association on that I", "i7bX4phZ46g-00703-00221426-00221659": "encourage you to and we'll we'll post a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00704-00221660-00222058": "link to the Creative Commons here on the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00705-00222059-00222946": "chat and a moment to have other sins", "i7bX4phZ46g-00706-00222946-00224488": "from the participant Heidi is there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00707-00224489-00224611": "anything else that you'd like us to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00708-00224612-00225656": "cover any questions do you have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00709-00225657-00226076": "I could well we're waiting for Haiti I", "i7bX4phZ46g-00710-00226077-00226337": "don't think your talk button is pressed", "i7bX4phZ46g-00711-00226338-00226766": "but I find out that in addition to sore", "i7bX4phZ46g-00712-00226767-00227285": "the hardware and the tools that I showed", "i7bX4phZ46g-00713-00227286-00227569": "some of the activities also on software", "i7bX4phZ46g-00714-00227571-00227744": "tools so enterprise tools and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00715-00227744-00228110": "spreadsheets and and farm management and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00716-00228111-00228440": "record-keeping systems so that's that's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00717-00228441-00228689": "very much part of some of the projects", "i7bX4phZ46g-00718-00228690-00228815": "that are getting posted and where", "i7bX4phZ46g-00719-00228816-00229160": "there's a good bit of activity and one", "i7bX4phZ46g-00720-00229161-00229294": "of the areas that I'm particularly", "i7bX4phZ46g-00721-00229296-00229586": "excited about exploring is being able to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00722-00229587-00229942": "identify not just tools but as a day you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00723-00229944-00230237": "mentioned the idea of problem statements", "i7bX4phZ46g-00724-00230238-00230558": "and being able to search by what you're", "i7bX4phZ46g-00725-00230559-00230852": "what particular issues that we're all", "i7bX4phZ46g-00726-00230853-00231065": "facing and identified different", "i7bX4phZ46g-00727-00231066-00231350": "approaches to it so for example if we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00728-00231351-00231527": "have soil compaction and we're looking", "i7bX4phZ46g-00729-00231528-00231773": "for a solution it's not just looking for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00730-00231773-00232028": "a sub soiler and a piece of steel and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00731-00232029-00232331": "and that kind of tool but also looking", "i7bX4phZ46g-00732-00232332-00232646": "for cover crop approaches that may", "i7bX4phZ46g-00733-00232646-00232921": "address the same issue before likewise", "i7bX4phZ46g-00734-00232923-00233327": "with our tractor design or cultivating", "i7bX4phZ46g-00735-00233328-00233681": "looking at alternative mulching systems", "i7bX4phZ46g-00736-00233682-00233948": "that reduce the need for cultivation and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00737-00233948-00234148": "improve soil health which are addressing", "i7bX4phZ46g-00738-00234150-00234332": "the same issue which is essentially", "i7bX4phZ46g-00739-00234333-00234635": "reducing lead pressure for the crops and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00740-00234636-00235058": "actually trying to grow I think that's a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00741-00235059-00235346": "large part of our development as we go", "i7bX4phZ46g-00742-00235346-00235628": "forward is to maybe make it easier to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00743-00235629-00235991": "find solutions and to communicate with", "i7bX4phZ46g-00744-00235992-00236162": "other folks who are working on the same", "i7bX4phZ46g-00745-00236163-00236603": "same types of problems as we explore", "i7bX4phZ46g-00746-00236604-00236789": "different ways to approach those and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00747-00236790-00237379": "improve our operations", "i7bX4phZ46g-00748-00237380-00237710": "great thanks you guys for sharing all", "i7bX4phZ46g-00749-00237711-00237965": "that information I don't think that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00750-00237966-00238144": "there's anything specific that you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00751-00238144-00238556": "haven't haven't covered hopefully folks", "i7bX4phZ46g-00752-00238557-00238750": "have found this to be a valuable", "i7bX4phZ46g-00753-00238751-00239108": "introduction to what farm hack is about", "i7bX4phZ46g-00754-00239109-00239315": "and how they can take advantage of it", "i7bX4phZ46g-00755-00239316-00239578": "and support it and participate in it and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00756-00239579-00240032": "I have typed up on the chat room a link", "i7bX4phZ46g-00757-00240033-00240307": "to the survey and I see that there's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00758-00240308-00240623": "some other links that Dan and Dorn have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00759-00240623-00241085": "put up for folks are there any questions", "i7bX4phZ46g-00760-00241086-00241358": "that folks have at this point if you do", "i7bX4phZ46g-00761-00241359-00242138": "just please type them type them in all", "i7bX4phZ46g-00762-00242139-00242339": "right anyone on here located near", "i7bX4phZ46g-00763-00242340-00242879": "Cincinnati anyone who's listening is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00764-00242880-00244005": "near Cincinnati please speak up", "i7bX4phZ46g-00765-00244006-00244865": "looking like not", "i7bX4phZ46g-00766-00244866-00245373": "dan or Dorn do any resources that might", "i7bX4phZ46g-00767-00245373-00245698": "help Cody", "i7bX4phZ46g-00768-00245700-00245964": "you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00769-00245965-00246360": "remind me hoodie in Cincinnati looks", "i7bX4phZ46g-00770-00246361-00246569": "like key must be based in Cincinnati and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00771-00246571-00246762": "is maybe looking to connect with folks", "i7bX4phZ46g-00772-00246763-00246992": "in that area no one else that's on is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00773-00246992-00247155": "indicating it they're from the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00774-00247156-00247416": "Cincinnati area studio happen to have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00775-00247417-00247844": "any contacts in that region there are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00776-00247846-00248007": "certainly folks within the farmer", "i7bX4phZ46g-00777-00248008-00248211": "community from that area I don't think", "i7bX4phZ46g-00778-00248212-00248412": "we've had a Cincinnati farm hack event", "i7bX4phZ46g-00779-00248413-00248808": "yet but the best way to identify folks", "i7bX4phZ46g-00780-00248809-00249102": "and bring them together is these to have", "i7bX4phZ46g-00781-00249103-00249375": "these meet us because inevitably there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00782-00249376-00249528": "are folks in the community who are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00783-00249529-00249810": "willing to participate in this way it's", "i7bX4phZ46g-00784-00249811-00250041": "really and so the local events are a way", "i7bX4phZ46g-00785-00250042-00250271": "to identify folks and get them together", "i7bX4phZ46g-00786-00250273-00250494": "I think Daniel mentioned it in the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00787-00250494-00250776": "introduction but how important that is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00788-00250777-00251202": "in in having this process work is that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00789-00251203-00251514": "it's it's not is that it's a social", "i7bX4phZ46g-00790-00251515-00251739": "process as well and that it's fun I", "i7bX4phZ46g-00791-00251740-00251921": "think we sort of missed we sort of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00792-00251923-00252255": "glossed over that that's one of the key", "i7bX4phZ46g-00793-00252256-00252428": "elements of this is that we get together", "i7bX4phZ46g-00794-00252429-00252771": "and with other folks and in addition to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00795-00252771-00252971": "problem solving which is fun in itself", "i7bX4phZ46g-00796-00252973-00253257": "is that you know we're talking about our", "i7bX4phZ46g-00797-00253258-00253464": "phones we're we're also involving a lot", "i7bX4phZ46g-00798-00253465-00253644": "of folks who aren't necessarily farmers", "i7bX4phZ46g-00799-00253644-00253878": "but have a lot of skills and want to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00800-00253879-00254166": "build a better agriculture system and so", "i7bX4phZ46g-00801-00254167-00254396": "this is a way to invite people to farms", "i7bX4phZ46g-00802-00254398-00254732": "or other agricultural related", "i7bX4phZ46g-00803-00254733-00255108": "establishments and bring them into the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00804-00255109-00255219": "conversation", "i7bX4phZ46g-00805-00255219-00255555": "and then so that's what's and really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00806-00255556-00255713": "great food", "i7bX4phZ46g-00807-00255714-00256037": "that we helped prepare together saying", "i7bX4phZ46g-00808-00256038-00256419": "some local some local beverages and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00809-00256421-00256700": "usually you know cooler months is", "i7bX4phZ46g-00810-00256701-00256981": "usually a bonfire Bowl usually if they", "i7bX4phZ46g-00811-00256982-00257363": "happen over a couple days to and so I", "i7bX4phZ46g-00812-00257364-00257656": "guess I would encourage if folks are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00813-00257657-00258010": "interested to reach out to the contacts", "i7bX4phZ46g-00814-00258011-00258539": "maybe and and and if if you have some", "i7bX4phZ46g-00815-00258540-00258798": "local local agricultural organizations", "i7bX4phZ46g-00816-00258800-00259115": "we're happy to help facilitate very an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00817-00259116-00259435": "event going to find other folks in your", "i7bX4phZ46g-00818-00259436-00259967": "areas we can help and develop you know", "i7bX4phZ46g-00819-00259967-00260227": "live a few problem statements that are", "i7bX4phZ46g-00820-00260228-00260564": "particular to your area and part of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00821-00260565-00260728": "what's the format community can also", "i7bX4phZ46g-00822-00260729-00260902": "help do is not only facilitate the event", "i7bX4phZ46g-00823-00260903-00261432": "but also help with the documentation", "i7bX4phZ46g-00824-00261433-00261721": "that makes the event more than just what", "i7bX4phZ46g-00825-00261723-00261934": "happens on that day and they should live", "i7bX4phZ46g-00826-00261935-00262209": "on and be able to be built upon by the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00827-00262210-00262517": "wider world and give you essentially a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00828-00262518-00262675": "return on investment in your effort to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00829-00262676-00262882": "both putting the event on and for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00830-00262883-00263257": "document documenting the projects and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00831-00263258-00263975": "the ideas that come out of that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00832-00263976-00264240": "so there's a question that if they lead", "i7bX4phZ46g-00833-00264241-00264450": "to the best way to reach out is to post", "i7bX4phZ46g-00834-00264451-00264690": "on the forum but also you can send an", "i7bX4phZ46g-00835-00264691-00264944": "email directly to info at farm hack net", "i7bX4phZ46g-00836-00264945-00265344": "and Daniel will have Daniel's role as", "i7bX4phZ46g-00837-00265345-00265803": "Network facilitator so is to help link", "i7bX4phZ46g-00838-00265804-00266031": "folks up so if you don't get we try to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00839-00266032-00266151": "make sure if you don't get an immediate", "i7bX4phZ46g-00840-00266152-00266409": "response back from the forum that that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00841-00266410-00266639": "you still that there we have some", "i7bX4phZ46g-00842-00266640-00266871": "facilitated exchange to keep the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00843-00266872-00267114": "conversations going and to help find", "i7bX4phZ46g-00844-00267115-00267377": "folks that are relevant in your area or", "i7bX4phZ46g-00845-00267378-00267675": "either geographically or relevant to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00846-00267676-00267987": "your interests your problems and/or your", "i7bX4phZ46g-00847-00267988-00268871": "tools that you're working on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00848-00268872-00269200": "you", "i7bX4phZ46g-00849-00269201-00269464": "we have uh other questions from the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00850-00269465-00269840": "criminal room from the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00851-00269841-00270608": "we're listening", "i7bX4phZ46g-00852-00270609-00271017": "I guess I also say that we are going", "i7bX4phZ46g-00853-00271018-00271212": "through right now a process of phone", "i7bX4phZ46g-00854-00271213-00271593": "hack to improve the quality of the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00855-00271594-00272210": "website and usability so I wear the what", "i7bX4phZ46g-00856-00272211-00272442": "you see right now is essentially our", "i7bX4phZ46g-00857-00272443-00272633": "first version which we're getting a lot", "i7bX4phZ46g-00858-00272634-00273071": "of learn a tremendous amount about how", "i7bX4phZ46g-00859-00273072-00273371": "to do open source tool documentation and", "i7bX4phZ46g-00860-00273372-00273792": "to go back and recognize you insert a", "i7bX4phZ46g-00861-00273793-00273932": "lot of improvements and so we've been", "i7bX4phZ46g-00862-00273933-00274331": "testing and and are in the process of", "i7bX4phZ46g-00863-00274332-00274643": "developing some improved ways to search", "i7bX4phZ46g-00864-00274644-00274917": "tools and to post and to get that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00865-00274918-00275075": "information that's relevant on the farm", "i7bX4phZ46g-00866-00275076-00275339": "attic site and to make that process", "i7bX4phZ46g-00867-00275340-00275616": "easier going forward but we'd really in", "i7bX4phZ46g-00868-00275617-00275991": "one of the it's really important for the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00869-00275992-00276284": "community to have that feedback is if", "i7bX4phZ46g-00870-00276285-00276569": "you are frustrated with various aspects", "i7bX4phZ46g-00871-00276570-00276893": "or you have suggestions there's a forum", "i7bX4phZ46g-00872-00276894-00277218": "within the forum there's a inform hack", "i7bX4phZ46g-00873-00277219-00277475": "talk area we really invite those", "i7bX4phZ46g-00874-00277476-00277727": "questions and if you are so inclined we", "i7bX4phZ46g-00875-00277728-00278135": "have an interview process for the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00876-00278136-00278303": "usability study that that's going on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00877-00278304-00278609": "that is even that is really helpful as", "i7bX4phZ46g-00878-00278610-00278852": "we set development priorities to improve", "i7bX4phZ46g-00879-00278853-00279119": "improve the website improve the services", "i7bX4phZ46g-00880-00279120-00279395": "and make it more useful for everybody", "i7bX4phZ46g-00881-00279396-00279668": "involved so we really encourage you to", "i7bX4phZ46g-00882-00279669-00279974": "if you're so inclined to provide that", "i7bX4phZ46g-00883-00279975-00280184": "feedback because that's what makes this", "i7bX4phZ46g-00884-00280185-00280823": "process a lot better", "i7bX4phZ46g-00885-00280824-00281199": "great well thanks again that if there", "i7bX4phZ46g-00886-00281200-00281514": "are no other questions I think we'll be", "i7bX4phZ46g-00887-00281515-00281763": "prepared to sign off we really", "i7bX4phZ46g-00888-00281764-00281960": "appreciate everybody joining us today", "i7bX4phZ46g-00889-00281961-00282359": "and I'll encourage you to join us if", "i7bX4phZ46g-00890-00282360-00282570": "you're interested in hops growing on", "i7bX4phZ46g-00891-00282571-00282999": "April 8th we'll have our next webinar", "i7bX4phZ46g-00892-00283000-00283346": "and it will be looking at growing hops", "i7bX4phZ46g-00893-00283347-00283614": "so thanks again for joining us everyone", "i7bX4phZ46g-00894-00283615-00284013": "and thank you to Daniel and Dorn for", "i7bX4phZ46g-00895-00284014-00284601": "sharing this information with us Thank", "i7bX4phZ46g-00896-00284602-00284708": "You Heidi", "i7bX4phZ46g-00897-00284709-00285015": "Thank You id4 for giving us the", "i7bX4phZ46g-00898-00285016-00285408": "opportunity that's our pleasure everyone", "i7bX4phZ46g-00899-00285409-00285572": "have a good afternoon", "i7bX4phZ46g-00900-00285573-00286794": "thank you you do", "i7bX4phZ46g-00901-00286795-00287001": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i8gD3fI_460", "text": {"i8gD3fI_460-00000-00000000-00000209": "where to start another week in another", "i8gD3fI_460-00001-00000210-00000449": "bank failure another region will no", "i8gD3fI_460-00002-00000450-00000682": "relief in inventory levels actually it's", "i8gD3fI_460-00003-00000683-00000881": "really gotten worse in this video we're", "i8gD3fI_460-00004-00000882-00001019": "going to go over the single family and", "i8gD3fI_460-00005-00001019-00001127": "condo markets in the state of", "i8gD3fI_460-00006-00001128-00001277": "Massachusetts we're also going to do an", "i8gD3fI_460-00007-00001278-00001415": "interest rate update as well as talk", "i8gD3fI_460-00008-00001416-00001660": "about the First Republic Bank and what", "i8gD3fI_460-00009-00001661-00001823": "that bank collapse actually means for", "i8gD3fI_460-00010-00001823-00002009": "the real estate market and for the", "i8gD3fI_460-00011-00002010-00002147": "luxury home of the week well we're", "i8gD3fI_460-00012-00002148-00002333": "heading to the seaport District take a", "i8gD3fI_460-00013-00002334-00002584": "look at a stunning condo at the scene", "i8gD3fI_460-00014-00002585-00002826": "Regis now the sellers they're asking 3", "i8gD3fI_460-00015-00002827-00003142": "824 a square foot I mean just", "i8gD3fI_460-00016-00003143-00003395": "mind-blowing hi I'm Jeff Chung I'm a", "i8gD3fI_460-00017-00003396-00003527": "recovering Investment Bank returned real", "i8gD3fI_460-00018-00003528-00003653": "estate agent and I've sold more than a", "i8gD3fI_460-00019-00003654-00003790": "thousand houses if you have any", "i8gD3fI_460-00020-00003792-00003917": "questions about the real estate market", "i8gD3fI_460-00021-00003918-00004151": "then no I'm here to help so some very", "i8gD3fI_460-00022-00004152-00004336": "quick housekeeping as you know I record", "i8gD3fI_460-00023-00004337-00004517": "these videos every Tuesday and release", "i8gD3fI_460-00024-00004518-00004756": "them on Wednesday but I just wanted to", "i8gD3fI_460-00025-00004757-00004985": "give you the heads up of the possibility", "i8gD3fI_460-00026-00004986-00005206": "of missing one in the coming weeks my", "i8gD3fI_460-00027-00005207-00005404": "wife and I will were expecting our third", "i8gD3fI_460-00028-00005405-00005597": "baby girl in the coming weeks and it", "i8gD3fI_460-00029-00005598-00005806": "might not exactly cooperate with video", "i8gD3fI_460-00030-00005807-00005993": "shooting but now let's talk about some", "i8gD3fI_460-00031-00005994-00006154": "Real Estate another week of multiple", "i8gD3fI_460-00032-00006155-00006341": "offer situations and as the weekend came", "i8gD3fI_460-00033-00006342-00006514": "to a close I was kind of thinking it", "i8gD3fI_460-00034-00006515-00006755": "felt a little slower and so was one of", "i8gD3fI_460-00035-00006756-00006959": "my clients they saw a house that they", "i8gD3fI_460-00036-00006959-00007133": "liked and figured what the heck they", "i8gD3fI_460-00037-00007134-00007313": "liked it didn't necessarily love it but", "i8gD3fI_460-00038-00007314-00007678": "still bid 40 000 or 5.6 over asking", "i8gD3fI_460-00039-00007679-00007927": "price and ended up not even being close", "i8gD3fI_460-00040-00007928-00008201": "seven offers and we were well close to", "i8gD3fI_460-00041-00008202-00008369": "the bottom but here's what I took away", "i8gD3fI_460-00042-00008370-00008537": "from this the offer that won they", "i8gD3fI_460-00043-00008538-00008674": "actually removed their mortgage", "i8gD3fI_460-00044-00008675-00008957": "contingency this is insane unless you", "i8gD3fI_460-00045-00008958-00009131": "have the money sitting in an account or", "i8gD3fI_460-00046-00009132-00009292": "a parent maybe that's willing to loan", "i8gD3fI_460-00047-00009293-00009556": "you the money you should never be", "i8gD3fI_460-00048-00009557-00009767": "removing a mortgage contingency if your", "i8gD3fI_460-00049-00009768-00009905": "agent is recommending you to do this", "i8gD3fI_460-00050-00009906-00010067": "then you should be finding a new agent", "i8gD3fI_460-00051-00010068-00010246": "they care about their next commission", "i8gD3fI_460-00052-00010247-00010427": "check more than your exposure as well as", "i8gD3fI_460-00053-00010428-00010660": "the risk of you losing possibly tens of", "i8gD3fI_460-00054-00010661-00010864": "thousands of dollars it's a tough Market", "i8gD3fI_460-00055-00010865-00011021": "out there for us real estate agents", "i8gD3fI_460-00056-00011022-00011183": "sales well they're way down but they're", "i8gD3fI_460-00057-00011184-00011381": "still being a lot more agents in the", "i8gD3fI_460-00058-00011382-00011591": "market to service that number of reduced", "i8gD3fI_460-00059-00011592-00011842": "sales buyer and seller Beware of the", "i8gD3fI_460-00060-00011843-00012083": "starving agent that will do and say", "i8gD3fI_460-00061-00012084-00012245": "anything because they need that next", "i8gD3fI_460-00062-00012246-00012473": "commission check and really quick be on", "i8gD3fI_460-00063-00012474-00012605": "the lookout for the main market report", "i8gD3fI_460-00064-00012606-00012773": "which will be hitting YouTube on", "i8gD3fI_460-00065-00012774-00013007": "Saturday some crazy things are going on", "i8gD3fI_460-00066-00013008-00013157": "you're just not going to want to miss it", "i8gD3fI_460-00067-00013158-00013301": "but now let's jump into the single", "i8gD3fI_460-00068-00013302-00013507": "family Market stats we can only have 3", "i8gD3fI_460-00069-00013508-00013763": "362 houses currently on the market now", "i8gD3fI_460-00070-00013763-00014033": "inventory grew yeah hey but the gap", "i8gD3fI_460-00071-00014034-00014236": "between the amount of inventory on the", "i8gD3fI_460-00072-00014237-00014435": "market today versus today last year is", "i8gD3fI_460-00073-00014436-00014711": "actually down to 114 units last week I'd", "i8gD3fI_460-00074-00014712-00014908": "asked if it was possible that we were", "i8gD3fI_460-00075-00014909-00015197": "going to see a drop below the record low", "i8gD3fI_460-00076-00015197-00015341": "amount of inventory levels that we saw", "i8gD3fI_460-00077-00015341-00015635": "in 2022 and it looks like that we're", "i8gD3fI_460-00078-00015636-00015863": "about to do it the absolute record low", "i8gD3fI_460-00079-00015863-00016138": "was this week of May in 2021 when there", "i8gD3fI_460-00080-00016140-00016547": "were 3088 units on the market so 114", "i8gD3fI_460-00081-00016548-00016750": "units away from the second lowest", "i8gD3fI_460-00082-00016751-00017069": "inventory time in history and 274 units", "i8gD3fI_460-00083-00017070-00017230": "away from the lowest amount of inventory", "i8gD3fI_460-00084-00017231-00017411": "in history now these inventory levels", "i8gD3fI_460-00085-00017412-00017633": "are not loosening up anytime soon and I", "i8gD3fI_460-00086-00017634-00017794": "thought we'd get some relief going into", "i8gD3fI_460-00087-00017795-00017963": "the spring Market but it's turning out", "i8gD3fI_460-00088-00017964-00018197": "that and I was well wrong we had a", "i8gD3fI_460-00089-00018198-00018449": "strong week for new listings as 1206", "i8gD3fI_460-00090-00018450-00018611": "properties came on the market this week", "i8gD3fI_460-00091-00018612-00018833": "now this was a great number and to put", "i8gD3fI_460-00092-00018834-00019019": "in perspective what we've seen in the", "i8gD3fI_460-00093-00019020-00019175": "last couple weeks before we rolling", "i8gD3fI_460-00094-00019176-00019499": "average was 932 units so this is a great", "i8gD3fI_460-00095-00019500-00019708": "number when compared to this year but we", "i8gD3fI_460-00096-00019709-00020075": "were still 450 units off of the 1656", "i8gD3fI_460-00097-00020076-00020291": "listings they came on the market this", "i8gD3fI_460-00098-00020292-00020585": "week last year that's a 27 decrease in", "i8gD3fI_460-00099-00020586-00020741": "the amount of new listings year over a", "i8gD3fI_460-00100-00020742-00020933": "year but here's some good news if you're", "i8gD3fI_460-00101-00020934-00021136": "a buyer the last time there were more", "i8gD3fI_460-00102-00021137-00021317": "houses listed was back during the week", "i8gD3fI_460-00103-00021318-00021664": "of July 25th in 2022. now another strong", "i8gD3fI_460-00104-00021665-00021839": "week for under agreements they came in", "i8gD3fI_460-00105-00021840-00022061": "at 1003. now it's a little under the", "i8gD3fI_460-00106-00022062-00022319": "last week's 1031 but a decent showing is", "i8gD3fI_460-00107-00022320-00022528": "the four week rolling average is 918", "i8gD3fI_460-00108-00022529-00022744": "units well compared to the same week in", "i8gD3fI_460-00109-00022745-00023057": "2022 under agreements were off by 26.4", "i8gD3fI_460-00110-00023058-00023393": "percent when 1 364 houses sold so", "i8gD3fI_460-00111-00023394-00023627": "inventory was down by 27 and under", "i8gD3fI_460-00112-00023628-00023830": "agreements were down by 26 so for", "i8gD3fI_460-00113-00023831-00024022": "argument's sake both under agreement its", "i8gD3fI_460-00114-00024023-00024185": "new listings are down about the same", "i8gD3fI_460-00115-00024186-00024425": "from last year now this means that yes", "i8gD3fI_460-00116-00024426-00024658": "you have less sales than last year but", "i8gD3fI_460-00117-00024659-00024839": "this is why you still have the crazy", "i8gD3fI_460-00118-00024840-00025025": "insane market conditions that we saw", "i8gD3fI_460-00119-00025026-00025271": "last year both went down about the same", "i8gD3fI_460-00120-00025272-00025511": "now there were 873 homes that closed", "i8gD3fI_460-00121-00025512-00025643": "this week for an average sales price of", "i8gD3fI_460-00122-00025644-00025949": "785 000 in a median sales price of six", "i8gD3fI_460-00123-00025950-00026093": "hundred thousand dollars and that", "i8gD3fI_460-00124-00026094-00026231": "amounts of inventory this is how we", "i8gD3fI_460-00125-00026232-00026393": "determine what type of Market we're in", "i8gD3fI_460-00126-00026394-00026585": "zero to five months being considered a", "i8gD3fI_460-00127-00026586-00026711": "seller's market with the closer you can", "i8gD3fI_460-00128-00026712-00026855": "get to zero the stronger sellers Market", "i8gD3fI_460-00129-00026856-00027046": "it is now this week months of inventory", "i8gD3fI_460-00130-00027047-00027227": "jumped to 1.8 nine months compared to", "i8gD3fI_460-00131-00027227-00027574": "last week's 1.74 months it continues to", "i8gD3fI_460-00132-00027575-00027773": "indicate that it is a strong seller's", "i8gD3fI_460-00133-00027774-00027952": "market real quick shade was plugged I", "i8gD3fI_460-00134-00027954-00028073": "just wanted to mention that if you're", "i8gD3fI_460-00135-00028074-00028211": "thinking about buying or selling house", "i8gD3fI_460-00136-00028212-00028390": "then it would be a true pleasure to help", "i8gD3fI_460-00137-00028391-00028583": "because like I said earlier I have a", "i8gD3fI_460-00138-00028583-00028787": "third baby on the way now under the", "i8gD3fI_460-00139-00028788-00029074": "condo Market we have 2155 condos on the", "i8gD3fI_460-00140-00029075-00029218": "market as of Monday now inventory", "i8gD3fI_460-00141-00029219-00029608": "dropped by 27 units we now have only 6.4", "i8gD3fI_460-00142-00029610-00029777": "percent more condos on the market today", "i8gD3fI_460-00143-00029777-00030052": "than we did 28 days ago it's Springtime", "i8gD3fI_460-00144-00030054-00030251": "we should have a bunch more inventory on", "i8gD3fI_460-00145-00030252-00030437": "the market right now like the single", "i8gD3fI_460-00146-00030438-00030593": "family Market the inventory gap between", "i8gD3fI_460-00147-00030594-00030827": "this year and last year show up to 117", "i8gD3fI_460-00148-00030827-00031205": "units and from last week's 248 units so", "i8gD3fI_460-00149-00031206-00031511": "the condo Market only has 117 more units", "i8gD3fI_460-00150-00031512-00031673": "than last year while the single family", "i8gD3fI_460-00151-00031674-00031924": "Market only has 114 more units in last", "i8gD3fI_460-00152-00031925-00032158": "year and just crazy there were 509", "i8gD3fI_460-00153-00032160-00032296": "Condors that came on the market this", "i8gD3fI_460-00154-00032297-00032440": "week now this was a little bit of a", "i8gD3fI_460-00155-00032441-00032651": "pullback from the previous two weeks but", "i8gD3fI_460-00156-00032652-00032807": "still higher than the four-week rolling", "i8gD3fI_460-00157-00032808-00033155": "average of 493 units we were still 28", "i8gD3fI_460-00158-00033156-00033424": "behind last year's numbers when 707", "i8gD3fI_460-00159-00033425-00033665": "condos came on the market we had 516", "i8gD3fI_460-00160-00033666-00033796": "Condors build our agreement this week", "i8gD3fI_460-00161-00033797-00034007": "off slightly from last week when 508", "i8gD3fI_460-00162-00034008-00034217": "went under agreement but the four-week", "i8gD3fI_460-00163-00034218-00034529": "rolling average was 431 condos so f516", "i8gD3fI_460-00164-00034530-00034745": "is a pretty great number compared now", "i8gD3fI_460-00165-00034746-00034895": "however when you compare it to the same", "i8gD3fI_460-00166-00034896-00035107": "week last year we were actually down by", "i8gD3fI_460-00167-00035108-00035459": "16.6 percent when 619 condos went under", "i8gD3fI_460-00168-00035460-00035645": "agreement while there's balance of a", "i8gD3fI_460-00169-00035646-00035771": "single family market with the new", "i8gD3fI_460-00170-00035772-00035939": "listings as well as the under agreements", "i8gD3fI_460-00171-00035940-00036131": "going down down by essentially the same", "i8gD3fI_460-00172-00036132-00036340": "melt the condo Market well they don't", "i8gD3fI_460-00173-00036341-00036599": "have that there's about 17 percent less", "i8gD3fI_460-00174-00036600-00036809": "buyer demand while seller supplies down", "i8gD3fI_460-00175-00036810-00037073": "by 28 this is something that you want to", "i8gD3fI_460-00176-00037074-00037217": "keep your eye out on for the next couple", "i8gD3fI_460-00177-00037218-00037396": "weeks is it just an outlier or is it", "i8gD3fI_460-00178-00037397-00037577": "going to become a trend please be an", "i8gD3fI_460-00179-00037578-00037840": "outlier there are 417 condos that sold", "i8gD3fI_460-00180-00037841-00037979": "this week for an average sales price of", "i8gD3fI_460-00181-00037980-00038212": "734 000 in that median sales price at", "i8gD3fI_460-00182-00038213-00038471": "570 000 now lots of inventory went down", "i8gD3fI_460-00183-00038472-00038711": "slightly to 2.44 months from last week's", "i8gD3fI_460-00184-00038712-00038915": "2.45 months do you like hearing about", "i8gD3fI_460-00185-00038916-00039040": "what's going on in the Massachusetts", "i8gD3fI_460-00186-00039041-00039293": "real estate market that I appreciate you", "i8gD3fI_460-00187-00039294-00039473": "hitting that like button as it makes a", "i8gD3fI_460-00188-00039474-00039659": "huge difference to those YouTube gods", "i8gD3fI_460-00189-00039660-00039833": "and well subscribing that one doesn't", "i8gD3fI_460-00190-00039834-00040055": "hurt either so another bank failed and a", "i8gD3fI_460-00191-00040056-00040301": "pretty big one with some local ties so", "i8gD3fI_460-00192-00040302-00040480": "the real estate market it's screwed", "i8gD3fI_460-00193-00040481-00040739": "right well not exactly and kind of yes", "i8gD3fI_460-00194-00040740-00040955": "the commercial real estate market is the", "i8gD3fI_460-00195-00040956-00041105": "one that got hurt by another big", "i8gD3fI_460-00196-00041106-00041333": "Regional player going under as we've", "i8gD3fI_460-00197-00041334-00041512": "talked about before it's the regional", "i8gD3fI_460-00198-00041513-00041699": "Banks do the majority of loans to the", "i8gD3fI_460-00199-00041700-00041885": "commercial market so another large", "i8gD3fI_460-00200-00041886-00042101": "player collapse does not necessarily", "i8gD3fI_460-00201-00042102-00042323": "spell good things for this Market is", "i8gD3fI_460-00202-00042324-00042557": "that means there are a lot more Regional", "i8gD3fI_460-00203-00042558-00042779": "players out there that are more under", "i8gD3fI_460-00204-00042780-00042995": "Financial stress If the Fed keeps", "i8gD3fI_460-00205-00042996-00043121": "increasing interest rates then be", "i8gD3fI_460-00206-00043122-00043295": "prepared there will be more banks that", "i8gD3fI_460-00207-00043296-00043451": "fail in regards to the residential", "i8gD3fI_460-00208-00043452-00043667": "Market eh the liquidity the residential", "i8gD3fI_460-00209-00043668-00043787": "Market is actually backed by the US", "i8gD3fI_460-00210-00043788-00043859": "government through the", "i8gD3fI_460-00211-00043860-00044045": "government-sponsored Enterprise of", "i8gD3fI_460-00212-00044046-00044267": "Fannie mag and Freddie Mac now Banks", "i8gD3fI_460-00213-00044268-00044429": "they can keep going under and this", "i8gD3fI_460-00214-00044430-00044602": "liquidity to the market it's still going", "i8gD3fI_460-00215-00044603-00044777": "to be there do they serve the entire", "i8gD3fI_460-00216-00044778-00045058": "Market no but based off of 2020 data", "i8gD3fI_460-00217-00045059-00045262": "they represent close to 78 percent of", "i8gD3fI_460-00218-00045263-00045412": "the Residential Mortgage market now", "i8gD3fI_460-00219-00045413-00045599": "First Republic had such a resounding", "i8gD3fI_460-00220-00045600-00045767": "effect on the mortgage Market that rates", "i8gD3fI_460-00221-00045768-00045995": "will they climb by 15 basis points on", "i8gD3fI_460-00222-00045996-00046168": "Monday well not only to give those gains", "i8gD3fI_460-00223-00046169-00046421": "back on Tuesday this Bank closure will", "i8gD3fI_460-00224-00046422-00046571": "not affect the residential real estate", "i8gD3fI_460-00225-00046572-00046835": "market again it does however continue to", "i8gD3fI_460-00226-00046836-00046990": "demonstrate that the commercial real", "i8gD3fI_460-00227-00046991-00047302": "estate market is well screwed next week", "i8gD3fI_460-00228-00047303-00047507": "we have the Consumer Price Index so that", "i8gD3fI_460-00229-00047508-00047699": "will most likely be a market mover but", "i8gD3fI_460-00230-00047700-00047890": "for now focus on the job market and", "i8gD3fI_460-00231-00047891-00048143": "check this article while labor market in", "i8gD3fI_460-00232-00048144-00048352": "free fall as job opening slide quit", "i8gD3fI_460-00233-00048353-00048533": "stumbled a two-year low now a little", "i8gD3fI_460-00234-00048534-00048761": "cool quote action here with consensus", "i8gD3fI_460-00235-00048762-00048989": "expecting only a modest drop in March", "i8gD3fI_460-00236-00048990-00049157": "job openings after the February collapse", "i8gD3fI_460-00237-00049158-00049367": "and sharp downward January revision with", "i8gD3fI_460-00238-00049368-00049589": "the BLS reported instead was yet another", "i8gD3fI_460-00239-00049590-00049817": "doozy for the third month in a row in", "i8gD3fI_460-00240-00049818-00050051": "March there were just 9.59 million job", "i8gD3fI_460-00241-00050052-00050345": "openings the lowest since April 2022 in", "i8gD3fI_460-00242-00050346-00050608": "a drop of 384 000 from the upward", "i8gD3fI_460-00243-00050609-00050795": "revised February print combined with the", "i8gD3fI_460-00244-00050796-00051046": "sharp drops in January and February the", "i8gD3fI_460-00245-00051047-00051238": "combined three month drops in job", "i8gD3fI_460-00246-00051239-00051479": "openings was the second biggest on", "i8gD3fI_460-00247-00051479-00051725": "record I know the consensus is the Fed", "i8gD3fI_460-00248-00051726-00051892": "is going to increase their rates by 25", "i8gD3fI_460-00249-00051894-00052240": "basis points but I really hope that", "i8gD3fI_460-00250-00052241-00052469": "another bank failing in the job market", "i8gD3fI_460-00251-00052470-00052679": "crashing is enough for them to take a", "i8gD3fI_460-00252-00052679-00052891": "breather the economy it's fragile", "i8gD3fI_460-00253-00052891-00053116": "systematic inflation it's hard to stamp", "i8gD3fI_460-00254-00053117-00053309": "out we saw in the 1970s and inflation", "i8gD3fI_460-00255-00053310-00053566": "dipped down to only go right back up and", "i8gD3fI_460-00256-00053567-00053753": "a lot harder by the way I talked about", "i8gD3fI_460-00257-00053754-00053944": "in my video that I did that goes over", "i8gD3fI_460-00258-00053945-00054142": "Now is really the most expensive time to", "i8gD3fI_460-00259-00054144-00054292": "buy a house you should check it out if", "i8gD3fI_460-00260-00054294-00054454": "you haven't because well that's a lot of", "i8gD3fI_460-00261-00054455-00054611": "really great information there and now", "i8gD3fI_460-00262-00054612-00054791": "under the luxury home of the week which", "i8gD3fI_460-00263-00054791-00054941": "is a condo located in the seaport", "i8gD3fI_460-00264-00054941-00055169": "District at 150 Seaport Boulevard and", "i8gD3fI_460-00265-00055170-00055373": "it's unit 17e now quick side note have", "i8gD3fI_460-00266-00055374-00055576": "you been to the seaport recently I mean", "i8gD3fI_460-00267-00055577-00055799": "I swear each time I'm there it's changed", "i8gD3fI_460-00268-00055800-00055997": "with more new builds I'm not that old", "i8gD3fI_460-00269-00055998-00056194": "but I do remember when it was just all", "i8gD3fI_460-00270-00056195-00056411": "parking lots which was actually rather", "i8gD3fI_460-00271-00056412-00056615": "recently now this guide is located on", "i8gD3fI_460-00272-00056616-00056771": "the 17th floor of this new building it's", "i8gD3fI_460-00273-00056772-00056938": "a three bedroom at three full and one", "i8gD3fI_460-00274-00056939-00057209": "half bath home the advance 2497 square", "i8gD3fI_460-00275-00057210-00057419": "feet it's got perfect unit placement in", "i8gD3fI_460-00276-00057420-00057580": "the building with the Florida ceiling", "i8gD3fI_460-00277-00057582-00057766": "Windows to match now the unit offers", "i8gD3fI_460-00278-00057767-00057976": "unparalleled views of the airport the", "i8gD3fI_460-00279-00057977-00058169": "harbor and outs of the Harbor Islands", "i8gD3fI_460-00280-00058170-00058300": "this is considered one of the most", "i8gD3fI_460-00281-00058301-00058492": "premier units in the most premier", "i8gD3fI_460-00282-00058494-00058666": "buildings of Boston now the unit Sports", "i8gD3fI_460-00283-00058667-00058894": "an open layout with a kitchen that flows", "i8gD3fI_460-00284-00058895-00059069": "into the large living room and dining", "i8gD3fI_460-00285-00059070-00059249": "area the kitchen Sports wolf and", "i8gD3fI_460-00286-00059250-00059399": "Sub-Zero appliances Italian wood", "i8gD3fI_460-00287-00059400-00059573": "cabinets and marble countertops of the", "i8gD3fI_460-00288-00059574-00059861": "waterfall Edge this is a 31 foot outdoor", "i8gD3fI_460-00289-00059862-00060023": "balcony off the living were making the", "i8gD3fI_460-00290-00060024-00060275": "views even better and more enjoyable all", "i8gD3fI_460-00291-00060276-00060509": "the accents and fit and finish is top", "i8gD3fI_460-00292-00060510-00060761": "end with stunning bathrooms especially", "i8gD3fI_460-00293-00060762-00061025": "that Master wow the unit comes with two", "i8gD3fI_460-00294-00061026-00061199": "valet parking spots and enjoys all the", "i8gD3fI_460-00295-00061200-00061349": "features that the Satan Regis has to", "i8gD3fI_460-00296-00061350-00061553": "offer this building is known as one of", "i8gD3fI_460-00297-00061554-00061763": "the most premier for a reason with its", "i8gD3fI_460-00298-00061764-00061949": "swimming pool fitness center sauna Club", "i8gD3fI_460-00299-00061950-00062188": "room in concierge but if you like those", "i8gD3fI_460-00300-00062189-00062338": "things then well you're going to pay for", "i8gD3fI_460-00301-00062339-00062615": "it and the conduit fee is 4 711 per", "i8gD3fI_460-00302-00062616-00062794": "month now this unbelievable home is", "i8gD3fI_460-00303-00062795-00062950": "being marketed with an aspen price of", "i8gD3fI_460-00304-00062951-00063130": "nine million five hundred and fifty", "i8gD3fI_460-00305-00063132-00063292": "thousand dollars let's talk about your", "i8gD3fI_460-00306-00063294-00063454": "own personal real estate needs I do the", "i8gD3fI_460-00307-00063455-00063682": "luxury house a week just for fun but my", "i8gD3fI_460-00308-00063683-00063880": "specialty here and my love quite frankly", "i8gD3fI_460-00309-00063882-00064079": "is helping the normal guy not the gal", "i8gD3fI_460-00310-00064079-00064300": "buying the 10 million dollar condo when", "i8gD3fI_460-00311-00064301-00064475": "it comes to helping people sell well my", "i8gD3fI_460-00312-00064476-00064606": "goal is to provide that same service", "i8gD3fI_460-00313-00064607-00064835": "that the 10 million dollar mansion folks", "i8gD3fI_460-00314-00064836-00065135": "yet but for us not 100 000 plus year", "i8gD3fI_460-00315-00065136-00065380": "property taxpayers every person's home", "i8gD3fI_460-00316-00065382-00065537": "well it's their castle and they deserve", "i8gD3fI_460-00317-00065538-00065699": "to be treated that way all my", "i8gD3fI_460-00318-00065700-00065825": "information it's in the description", "i8gD3fI_460-00319-00065826-00066023": "below you can also visit me YouTube Real", "i8gD3fI_460-00320-00066024-00066191": "Estate agent.com just fill out a couple", "i8gD3fI_460-00321-00066192-00066419": "uh answers you know basically your name", "i8gD3fI_460-00322-00066420-00066575": "and your phone number and then I'm gonna", "i8gD3fI_460-00323-00066576-00066749": "reach out for you it all comes down to", "i8gD3fI_460-00324-00066750-00066965": "whatever is easiest for you I'd love to", "i8gD3fI_460-00325-00066966-00067097": "talk about real estate so whether you're", "i8gD3fI_460-00326-00067098-00067229": "looking to buy or sell a house in the", "i8gD3fI_460-00327-00067230-00067397": "next nine or 90 days then I would love", "i8gD3fI_460-00328-00067398-00067631": "to chat with you and just talk to you", "i8gD3fI_460-00329-00067632-00067823": "about your real estate goals and how we", "i8gD3fI_460-00330-00067824-00068003": "can maybe help accomplish them questions", "i8gD3fI_460-00331-00068004-00068159": "or comments about any of you or all this", "i8gD3fI_460-00332-00068160-00068297": "Market data drop me a line in the", "i8gD3fI_460-00333-00068298-00068471": "comment section below you take the time", "i8gD3fI_460-00334-00068472-00068603": "to watch the video so well I'm gonna", "i8gD3fI_460-00335-00068604-00068759": "take the time to respond to you until", "i8gD3fI_460-00336-00068760-00069026": "next time"}}, {"audio_id": "i8kIqes0J54", "text": {"i8kIqes0J54-00000-00000011-00000233": "thank you so that concludes typical", "i8kIqes0J54-00001-00000234-00000524": "questions next item of business will be", "i8kIqes0J54-00002-00000525-00000740": "a statement from john sweeney on", "i8kIqes0J54-00003-00000741-00000881": "excellence and equity and Scott", "i8kIqes0J54-00004-00000882-00001087": "education and the Deputy First Minister", "i8kIqes0J54-00005-00001088-00001268": "will take questions at the end of his", "i8kIqes0J54-00006-00001269-00001469": "statement so we knew interventions or", "i8kIqes0J54-00007-00001470-00001660": "interruptions I would ask members to", "i8kIqes0J54-00008-00001661-00001780": "press the group requests to speak", "i8kIqes0J54-00009-00001782-00001917": "buttons if you wish to ask a question", "i8kIqes0J54-00010-00001918-00002372": "and I call on Johnny after the program", "i8kIqes0J54-00011-00002373-00002584": "for international student assessment run", "i8kIqes0J54-00012-00002585-00002875": "by the OECD every few years assesses the", "i8kIqes0J54-00013-00002876-00003083": "skills of fifteen-year-olds in 72", "i8kIqes0J54-00014-00003084-00003311": "countries in reading maths and science", "i8kIqes0J54-00015-00003311-00003511": "the results for the most recent", "i8kIqes0J54-00016-00003513-00003767": "assessments undertaking two years ago in", "i8kIqes0J54-00017-00003768-00004094": "March 2015 republished this morning the", "i8kIqes0J54-00018-00004095-00004238": "figures for Scott and do not make", "i8kIqes0J54-00019-00004239-00004451": "comfortable reading but they do", "i8kIqes0J54-00020-00004452-00004619": "reinforce the need for the reforms to", "i8kIqes0J54-00021-00004620-00004861": "our school system there are no under we", "i8kIqes0J54-00022-00004862-00005093": "well they sure that Scott and scores are", "i8kIqes0J54-00023-00005094-00005333": "similar to the oecd average in all three", "i8kIqes0J54-00024-00005334-00005570": "areas tasted they also show that", "i8kIqes0J54-00025-00005571-00005822": "compared to 2012 our performance and", "i8kIqes0J54-00026-00005823-00006083": "science and reading has fallen in", "i8kIqes0J54-00027-00006084-00006254": "science and math we are no below the", "i8kIqes0J54-00028-00006255-00006584": "levels at which we performed in 2006 and", "i8kIqes0J54-00029-00006584-00006695": "more countries have outperformed", "i8kIqes0J54-00030-00006695-00006956": "scotland in all three dias than at any", "i8kIqes0J54-00031-00006956-00007262": "time since Peter began that is not sure", "i8kIqes0J54-00032-00007263-00007442": "that closing the poverty-related a team", "i8kIqes0J54-00033-00007443-00007667": "and gap is a conflict a complex", "i8kIqes0J54-00034-00007668-00007838": "challenge which is not unique to", "i8kIqes0J54-00035-00007839-00008078": "Scotland the welcome improvements in", "i8kIqes0J54-00036-00008079-00008207": "performance of young people from", "i8kIqes0J54-00037-00008208-00008441": "deprived backgrounds which we saw in the", "i8kIqes0J54-00038-00008442-00008813": "previous results between 2009 and 2012", "i8kIqes0J54-00039-00008814-00009074": "have been maintained however there is", "i8kIqes0J54-00040-00009075-00009253": "still a gap between peoples in the least", "i8kIqes0J54-00041-00009254-00009485": "and the most disadvantaged backgrounds", "i8kIqes0J54-00042-00009486-00009689": "are on three years worth of schooling", "i8kIqes0J54-00043-00009690-00010003": "according to the OECD peoples in", "i8kIqes0J54-00044-00010004-00010187": "Scotland are generally more positive but", "i8kIqes0J54-00045-00010188-00010376": "the value of learning science at school", "i8kIqes0J54-00046-00010377-00010624": "that is the case across the OECD", "i8kIqes0J54-00047-00010625-00010871": "classroom disruptions general or than", "i8kIqes0J54-00048-00010872-00011102": "average and relationships with teachers", "i8kIqes0J54-00049-00011103-00011356": "more positive those relationships are", "i8kIqes0J54-00050-00011357-00011705": "crucial to improving outcomes that is", "i8kIqes0J54-00051-00011706-00012010": "also consistent with the 2014 Scottish", "i8kIqes0J54-00052-00012011-00012156": "survey of literacy and numeracy", "i8kIqes0J54-00053-00012157-00012517": "published in april 2015 which told us we", "i8kIqes0J54-00054-00012518-00012698": "needed to do more to take to make our", "i8kIqes0J54-00055-00012699-00012932": "education system amongst the based in", "i8kIqes0J54-00056-00012933-00013019": "the world", "i8kIqes0J54-00057-00013021-00013221": "since that summer was published we have", "i8kIqes0J54-00058-00013222-00013458": "set out and are pursuing a range of", "i8kIqes0J54-00059-00013459-00013758": "actions to improve Scottish education if", "i8kIqes0J54-00060-00013759-00013947": "any more than any doubt about the need", "i8kIqes0J54-00061-00013947-00014127": "for the reforms which we have introduced", "i8kIqes0J54-00062-00014128-00014331": "and the improvements on which we are", "i8kIqes0J54-00063-00014332-00014556": "currently consulting these results", "i8kIqes0J54-00064-00014557-00014859": "should dispel that don't these reforms", "i8kIqes0J54-00065-00014860-00015087": "are based on the 2015 review of", "i8kIqes0J54-00066-00015088-00015312": "Education and Scott and carried out by", "i8kIqes0J54-00067-00015313-00015594": "the OECD the same body was runs the", "i8kIqes0J54-00068-00015594-00015897": "pieces assessments published today the", "i8kIqes0J54-00069-00015897-00016091": "OECD's positive he was commissioned by", "i8kIqes0J54-00070-00016093-00016236": "the scottish government", "i8kIqes0J54-00071-00016237-00016455": "its purpose was to inform the ongoing", "i8kIqes0J54-00072-00016456-00016689": "development of education policy practice", "i8kIqes0J54-00073-00016690-00016971": "and leadership and scotland by providing", "i8kIqes0J54-00074-00016972-00017202": "an independent review of the direction", "i8kIqes0J54-00075-00017203-00017523": "of the curriculum for excellence in its", "i8kIqes0J54-00076-00017524-00017700": "review report published this time last", "i8kIqes0J54-00077-00017701-00017976": "year the OECD said that curriculum for", "i8kIqes0J54-00078-00017977-00018234": "excellence was unimportant reformed that", "i8kIqes0J54-00079-00018235-00018489": "was the right approach for Scotland the", "i8kIqes0J54-00080-00018490-00018708": "OECD say that we've got the design right", "i8kIqes0J54-00081-00018709-00018909": "but that we needed to take further steps", "i8kIqes0J54-00082-00018910-00019110": "to secure the benefits of this new", "i8kIqes0J54-00083-00019111-00019343": "approach in all parts of the country", "i8kIqes0J54-00084-00019344-00019584": "that report went on to make a number of", "i8kIqes0J54-00085-00019585-00019793": "recommendations on how we should do this", "i8kIqes0J54-00086-00019794-00020088": "i want to focus on five of the key", "i8kIqes0J54-00087-00020089-00020373": "recommendations made by the OECD and how", "i8kIqes0J54-00088-00020374-00020580": "a response to those recommendations is", "i8kIqes0J54-00089-00020581-00020796": "driving the reform that is needed to", "i8kIqes0J54-00090-00020797-00021126": "improve education in Scotland the oecd", "i8kIqes0J54-00091-00021127-00021297": "report said that there needs to be a", "i8kIqes0J54-00092-00021298-00021525": "more robust evidence piece right across", "i8kIqes0J54-00093-00021526-00021762": "the system especially about learning", "i8kIqes0J54-00094-00021763-00022056": "outcomes and progress that is precisely", "i8kIqes0J54-00095-00022057-00022221": "why we have developed the National", "i8kIqes0J54-00096-00022222-00022446": "improvement framework and standardized", "i8kIqes0J54-00097-00022447-00022755": "assessments for our children and p 1 p 4", "i8kIqes0J54-00098-00022756-00023064": "p-7 and h3 to support teachers", "i8kIqes0J54-00099-00023065-00023349": "professional judgments this will provide", "i8kIqes0J54-00100-00023350-00023517": "us with a complete picture of her", "i8kIqes0J54-00101-00023518-00023667": "children are progressing with our", "i8kIqes0J54-00102-00023668-00023862": "learning covering the full range of", "i8kIqes0J54-00103-00023863-00024090": "school years so that we can see that", "i8kIqes0J54-00104-00024091-00024315": "progress and national local authority", "i8kIqes0J54-00105-00024316-00024627": "and school levels is being need it will", "i8kIqes0J54-00106-00024628-00024837": "close to plan targeted interventions to", "i8kIqes0J54-00107-00024838-00025068": "tackle the team and gap between children", "i8kIqes0J54-00108-00025069-00025287": "from the most and the least disadvantage", "i8kIqes0J54-00109-00025288-00025578": "Parkins next week we launched the", "i8kIqes0J54-00110-00025579-00025782": "first-ever national improvement plan for", "i8kIqes0J54-00111-00025783-00026037": "education based on the widest range of", "i8kIqes0J54-00112-00026038-00026238": "performance information ever gathered on", "i8kIqes0J54-00113-00026239-00026394": "Scott education", "i8kIqes0J54-00114-00026395-00026550": "as part of the National improvement", "i8kIqes0J54-00115-00026551-00026802": "framework it is also why we have", "i8kIqes0J54-00116-00026802-00027014": "committed to providing teachers with", "i8kIqes0J54-00117-00027016-00027201": "benchmarks on assessing children's", "i8kIqes0J54-00118-00027202-00027480": "progress these benchmarks will set up", "i8kIqes0J54-00119-00027481-00027711": "with absolute clarity the standards that", "i8kIqes0J54-00120-00027712-00027972": "are visitors within the curriculum this", "i8kIqes0J54-00121-00027973-00028113": "is not to constrain teacher", "i8kIqes0J54-00122-00028114-00028368": "professionalism or to create a series of", "i8kIqes0J54-00123-00028369-00028650": "boxes to take it is to provide the two", "i8kIqes0J54-00124-00028651-00028814": "which will be of genuine use in", "i8kIqes0J54-00125-00028816-00029079": "classrooms will help ensure consistency", "i8kIqes0J54-00126-00029080-00029264": "and the judgments which teachers meek", "i8kIqes0J54-00127-00029266-00029466": "and substantially reduced the", "i8kIqes0J54-00128-00029467-00029658": "bureaucratic button carried by the", "i8kIqes0J54-00129-00029658-00029858": "teaching profession", "i8kIqes0J54-00130-00029858-00030210": "secondly the OECD also said that CFE", "i8kIqes0J54-00131-00030211-00030498": "needs to be a dynamic highly equitable", "i8kIqes0J54-00132-00030499-00030723": "curriculum being built constantly in", "i8kIqes0J54-00133-00030724-00030993": "schools networks and communities with a", "i8kIqes0J54-00134-00030994-00031257": "key role for strengthen the middle that", "i8kIqes0J54-00135-00031258-00031449": "is why we have launched a wide-ranging", "i8kIqes0J54-00136-00031450-00031692": "review of Education governs together", "i8kIqes0J54-00137-00031693-00031863": "views from pins peoples and", "i8kIqes0J54-00138-00031864-00032142": "professionals on higher education from", "i8kIqes0J54-00139-00032143-00032343": "any years to secondary school level", "i8kIqes0J54-00140-00032344-00032558": "should be run at the heart of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00141-00032560-00032766": "governance review is the presumption", "i8kIqes0J54-00142-00032767-00032940": "that decisions about children's learning", "i8kIqes0J54-00143-00032941-00033180": "and school life should be made at the", "i8kIqes0J54-00144-00033181-00033519": "school level thought that the governor", "i8kIqes0J54-00145-00033520-00033714": "of you also responds to a third", "i8kIqes0J54-00146-00033715-00033972": "recommendation from the OECD about the", "i8kIqes0J54-00147-00033973-00034110": "need to strengthen professional", "i8kIqes0J54-00148-00034111-00034347": "leadership we have invested in", "i8kIqes0J54-00149-00034348-00034581": "leadership capacity in our schools by", "i8kIqes0J54-00150-00034582-00034743": "establishing and funding the Scottish", "i8kIqes0J54-00151-00034744-00034974": "college for educational leadership who", "i8kIqes0J54-00152-00034975-00035151": "have delivered a new qualification for", "i8kIqes0J54-00153-00035152-00035355": "headship which is fully funded by the", "i8kIqes0J54-00154-00035356-00035565": "scottish government the government will", "i8kIqes0J54-00155-00035566-00035709": "take forward further measures to enhance", "i8kIqes0J54-00156-00035710-00035889": "leadership and professional development", "i8kIqes0J54-00157-00035890-00036264": "within education a fourth area covered", "i8kIqes0J54-00158-00036265-00036501": "by the OECD report was the need to be", "i8kIqes0J54-00159-00036502-00036729": "rigorous in our focus on closing their", "i8kIqes0J54-00160-00036730-00036945": "team and gap for are produced pupils", "i8kIqes0J54-00161-00036946-00037170": "that is why we have launched and", "i8kIqes0J54-00162-00037171-00037476": "subsequently expanded the 750 million", "i8kIqes0J54-00163-00037477-00037725": "Scottish attainment challenge and taking", "i8kIqes0J54-00164-00037726-00037893": "the lead in showcasing the bass practice", "i8kIqes0J54-00165-00037894-00038217": "in closing the attainment gap we have", "i8kIqes0J54-00166-00038218-00038385": "also announced plans to double the three", "i8kIqes0J54-00167-00038386-00038541": "entitlement to any learning and", "i8kIqes0J54-00168-00038542-00039039": "childcare to 1140 hours per year by 2020", "i8kIqes0J54-00169-00039040-00039303": "this will help to know the vocabulary", "i8kIqes0J54-00170-00039304-00039552": "gap which can be up to 30 months by the", "i8kIqes0J54-00171-00039553-00039591": "time", "i8kIqes0J54-00172-00039592-00039837": "child starts plainly school and helped", "i8kIqes0J54-00173-00039838-00039996": "ensure that all children arrive at", "i8kIqes0J54-00174-00039997-00040296": "school ready to learn", "i8kIqes0J54-00175-00040297-00040503": "finally the OECD advice that we take", "i8kIqes0J54-00176-00040504-00040725": "steps to simplify and clarify the", "i8kIqes0J54-00177-00040726-00040962": "curriculum in response to this", "i8kIqes0J54-00178-00040963-00041229": "recommendation in August we published a", "i8kIqes0J54-00179-00041230-00041460": "definitive statement on CFE and", "i8kIqes0J54-00180-00041461-00041760": "benchmarks for literacy and numeracy the", "i8kIqes0J54-00181-00041761-00041943": "statement said so what every teacher", "i8kIqes0J54-00182-00041944-00042111": "needs to do in order to achieve the", "i8kIqes0J54-00183-00042112-00042411": "potential of CFE these definitive", "i8kIqes0J54-00184-00042412-00042651": "documents will provide clarity and", "i8kIqes0J54-00185-00042652-00042849": "replace thousands of pages of advice", "i8kIqes0J54-00186-00042850-00043104": "guidance and case studies that had", "i8kIqes0J54-00187-00043105-00043365": "created a quad landscape", "i8kIqes0J54-00188-00043366-00043533": "we've also knows changes to national", "i8kIqes0J54-00189-00043534-00043755": "qualifications which will address the", "i8kIqes0J54-00190-00043756-00043923": "bottom of our assessment for young", "i8kIqes0J54-00191-00043924-00044205": "people and and teachers as part of a", "i8kIqes0J54-00192-00044206-00044406": "relentless drive that I am leading to", "i8kIqes0J54-00193-00044407-00044598": "reduce red tape and ensure that teachers", "i8kIqes0J54-00194-00044599-00044969": "are freed up to concentrate on teaching", "i8kIqes0J54-00195-00044970-00045234": "as well as responding to the OECD's", "i8kIqes0J54-00196-00045235-00045378": "recommendations", "i8kIqes0J54-00197-00045379-00045543": "the government has also taken a range of", "i8kIqes0J54-00198-00045544-00045720": "measures to drive improvement in the", "i8kIqes0J54-00199-00045721-00046020": "areas of reading math and science and", "i8kIqes0J54-00200-00046021-00046185": "the period since the pieces assesses", "i8kIqes0J54-00201-00046186-00046446": "were undertaken in 2015 and the", "i8kIqes0J54-00202-00046447-00046731": "publication of their results today we", "i8kIqes0J54-00203-00046732-00046872": "have launched the read/write count", "i8kIqes0J54-00204-00046873-00047151": "campaign we've established making masks", "i8kIqes0J54-00205-00047152-00047361": "count group which recently published a", "i8kIqes0J54-00206-00047362-00047508": "report of its findings and", "i8kIqes0J54-00207-00047509-00047739": "recommendations to boost mathematics", "i8kIqes0J54-00208-00047740-00047964": "achievement and Scott and we're", "i8kIqes0J54-00209-00047965-00048123": "currently consulting on a strategy to", "i8kIqes0J54-00210-00048124-00048324": "reach levels of enthusiasm for and", "i8kIqes0J54-00211-00048325-00048468": "knowledge about science technology", "i8kIqes0J54-00212-00048469-00048771": "engineering and mathematics and the", "i8kIqes0J54-00213-00048772-00048906": "First Minister launched her reading", "i8kIqes0J54-00214-00048907-00049083": "challenge to promote and support reading", "i8kIqes0J54-00215-00049084-00049326": "for pleasure amongst plainly for two", "i8kIqes0J54-00216-00049327-00049641": "primary seven pupils one of my early", "i8kIqes0J54-00217-00049642-00049818": "action is presiding officer on taking up", "i8kIqes0J54-00218-00049819-00049980": "office as cabinet secretary for", "i8kIqes0J54-00219-00049981-00050250": "education and skills was to establish an", "i8kIqes0J54-00220-00050251-00050481": "international council of Education", "i8kIqes0J54-00221-00050482-00050805": "advisors professor Andy Hargreaves one", "i8kIqes0J54-00222-00050806-00051027": "of the International advisors and a", "i8kIqes0J54-00223-00051028-00051303": "member of the OECD review team revisted", "i8kIqes0J54-00224-00051304-00051596": "scotland in 2015 has said that he is", "i8kIqes0J54-00225-00051597-00051774": "very impressed with the richness and the", "i8kIqes0J54-00226-00051775-00051975": "boldness of the curriculum the", "i8kIqes0J54-00227-00051976-00052188": "confidence of Scottish learners the", "i8kIqes0J54-00228-00052189-00052326": "professionalism of the country's", "i8kIqes0J54-00229-00052327-00052554": "teachers and the collective will to be", "i8kIqes0J54-00230-00052554-00052725": "even better to provide equitable", "i8kIqes0J54-00231-00052726-00052887": "opportunities", "i8kIqes0J54-00232-00052888-00053166": "the outcomes for young people others", "i8kIqes0J54-00233-00053167-00053359": "have commanded our belief and continuous", "i8kIqes0J54-00234-00053360-00053568": "improvement are foresight and our", "i8kIqes0J54-00235-00053569-00053793": "patients in relation to education", "i8kIqes0J54-00236-00053794-00053941": "those are qualities which are much", "i8kIqes0J54-00237-00053941-00054198": "needed know these highly regarded", "i8kIqes0J54-00238-00054199-00054391": "expects from a range of countries across", "i8kIqes0J54-00239-00054391-00054622": "the world are credible independent", "i8kIqes0J54-00240-00054623-00054837": "voices they are not describing an", "i8kIqes0J54-00241-00054838-00055098": "education system in crisis they are", "i8kIqes0J54-00242-00055099-00055326": "describing a system which is striving to", "i8kIqes0J54-00243-00055327-00055590": "meet significant channel yesterday", "i8kIqes0J54-00244-00055591-00055788": "afternoon i held a teleconference with", "i8kIqes0J54-00245-00055789-00056037": "several of our international advisors to", "i8kIqes0J54-00246-00056038-00056265": "discuss the latest set of Pisa results", "i8kIqes0J54-00247-00056266-00056523": "they recognize that the challenges faced", "i8kIqes0J54-00248-00056524-00056778": "by Scotland are not unique a great many", "i8kIqes0J54-00249-00056779-00056997": "other countries are having to reflate on", "i8kIqes0J54-00250-00056998-00057176": "deteriorations in their pc results", "i8kIqes0J54-00251-00057177-00057410": "particularly in relation to science", "i8kIqes0J54-00252-00057411-00057628": "however the anonymous advice I received", "i8kIqes0J54-00253-00057629-00057906": "from our international advisors wish to", "i8kIqes0J54-00254-00057907-00058122": "remain focused on taking forward the", "i8kIqes0J54-00255-00058123-00058356": "careful plans that we formulated in", "i8kIqes0J54-00256-00058357-00058662": "response to the sln data as part of our", "i8kIqes0J54-00257-00058663-00058950": "journey of reform i consider that to be", "i8kIqes0J54-00258-00058951-00059301": "so advice and I intend to follow it the", "i8kIqes0J54-00259-00059302-00059469": "government's plans for the former set", "i8kIqes0J54-00260-00059470-00059676": "out in the delivery plant delivering", "i8kIqes0J54-00261-00059677-00059853": "excellence and equity in Scottish", "i8kIqes0J54-00262-00059854-00060063": "education which was published in june", "i8kIqes0J54-00263-00060064-00060285": "fall in the national education summit", "i8kIqes0J54-00264-00060286-00060660": "this program is bald ambitious and in", "i8kIqes0J54-00265-00060661-00060888": "parts controversial a strength of", "i8kIqes0J54-00266-00060889-00061125": "Scotland's education system has always", "i8kIqes0J54-00267-00061126-00061338": "been in collaboration a sense of", "i8kIqes0J54-00268-00061339-00061572": "national shared endeavor but we know", "i8kIqes0J54-00269-00061573-00061897": "must be clear reform is required this", "i8kIqes0J54-00270-00061898-00062088": "data reinforces the case for radical", "i8kIqes0J54-00271-00062089-00062253": "change that the government is determined", "i8kIqes0J54-00272-00062254-00062674": "to pursue", "i8kIqes0J54-00273-00062675-00062957": "the Deputy First Minister will notate", "i8kIqes0J54-00274-00062958-00063192": "questions on the issues reason statement", "i8kIqes0J54-00275-00063194-00063482": "and shallow around 20 minutes for", "i8kIqes0J54-00276-00063483-00063773": "questions and would you please place", "i8kIqes0J54-00277-00063774-00063932": "your request to speak button if you wish", "i8kIqes0J54-00278-00063933-00064097": "to ask the question and I call on", "i8kIqes0J54-00279-00064098-00064405": "lisseth Thank You deputy presiding", "i8kIqes0J54-00280-00064407-00064658": "officer and grateful to the cabinet", "i8kIqes0J54-00281-00064659-00064787": "secretary for prior state of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00282-00064788-00065017": "statement although as I am sure the keys", "i8kIqes0J54-00283-00065019-00065189": "for every teacher parent and people", "i8kIqes0J54-00284-00065190-00065402": "across Scotland there will be great", "i8kIqes0J54-00285-00065403-00065561": "regret about the circumstances in which", "i8kIqes0J54-00286-00065562-00065822": "the statement has had to be issued not", "i8kIqes0J54-00287-00065823-00066035": "only are we know below the oecd average", "i8kIqes0J54-00288-00066036-00066230": "in the three measurements when we were", "i8kIqes0J54-00289-00066231-00066365": "above the average in all three", "i8kIqes0J54-00290-00066366-00066593": "measurements in the year 2000 but the", "i8kIqes0J54-00291-00066594-00066806": "most recent trains since the last set of", "i8kIqes0J54-00292-00066807-00067088": "Pisa results in 2012 tell us that", "i8kIqes0J54-00293-00067089-00067292": "Scotland is actually heading backwards", "i8kIqes0J54-00294-00067293-00067562": "into measurements with the cabinet", "i8kIqes0J54-00295-00067563-00067742": "secretary except that the statistics", "i8kIqes0J54-00296-00067743-00067955": "have been published 2 d.r a damning", "i8kIqes0J54-00297-00067956-00068120": "indictment of the SNP's education", "i8kIqes0J54-00298-00068121-00068357": "policies in our schools and we accept", "i8kIqes0J54-00299-00068358-00068534": "that they call into question the", "i8kIqes0J54-00300-00068535-00068744": "effective delivery of the curriculum for", "i8kIqes0J54-00301-00068745-00069026": "excellence and we tell us why when the", "i8kIqes0J54-00302-00069027-00069239": "promotion of STEM subjects is supposed", "i8kIqes0J54-00303-00069240-00069497": "to be a top priority for the SMP there", "i8kIqes0J54-00304-00069498-00069671": "are fundamental weaknesses and Scott", "i8kIqes0J54-00305-00069672-00069899": "ensuring and science in comparison with", "i8kIqes0J54-00306-00069900-00070335": "competitor nations johnsonii", "i8kIqes0J54-00307-00070336-00070672": "the first point see to it Elizabeth is", "i8kIqes0J54-00308-00070673-00070863": "that the government has been carefully", "i8kIqes0J54-00309-00070864-00071161": "prepared to have its approach to the", "i8kIqes0J54-00310-00071162-00071524": "delivery of curriculum for excellence at", "i8kIqes0J54-00311-00071525-00071797": "tasted by external advisors and nobody", "i8kIqes0J54-00312-00071798-00072055": "could do that from the commissioning of", "i8kIqes0J54-00313-00072056-00072505": "the report by the we CD in 2015 and as", "i8kIqes0J54-00314-00072506-00072792": "an assessment and that review was an", "i8kIqes0J54-00315-00072793-00073011": "assessment of the policy direction which", "i8kIqes0J54-00316-00073012-00073246": "had been started before this government", "i8kIqes0J54-00317-00073247-00073431": "came to office of the design of", "i8kIqes0J54-00318-00073432-00073617": "curriculum for excellence which this", "i8kIqes0J54-00319-00073618-00073780": "government continued when it came to", "i8kIqes0J54-00320-00073781-00074049": "office and has no applied in consort", "i8kIqes0J54-00321-00074050-00074292": "with outlook authority partners with the", "i8kIqes0J54-00322-00074293-00074550": "professional associations with education", "i8kIqes0J54-00323-00074551-00074718": "agencies and with the broad", "i8kIqes0J54-00324-00074719-00074971": "cross-section of organizations that have", "i8kIqes0J54-00325-00074972-00075213": "been actively involved in the design and", "i8kIqes0J54-00326-00075214-00075363": "the delivery of curriculum for", "i8kIqes0J54-00327-00075364-00075699": "excellence within Scotland and m1 look", "i8kIqes0J54-00328-00075700-00075867": "at the curriculum for excellence", "i8kIqes0J54-00329-00075868-00076107": "management board will demonstrate the", "i8kIqes0J54-00330-00076108-00076267": "point that I've made in the concluding", "i8kIqes0J54-00331-00076268-00076591": "part of my statement that the scottish", "i8kIqes0J54-00332-00076592-00076800": "education system has been taken forward", "i8kIqes0J54-00333-00076801-00077137": "and in an atmosphere of collaboration", "i8kIqes0J54-00334-00077138-00077280": "yes of course the government has been in", "i8kIqes0J54-00335-00077281-00077548": "the lead I accept our unreservedly but", "i8kIqes0J54-00336-00077549-00077722": "it has been a process of collaboration", "i8kIqes0J54-00337-00077723-00078012": "in reaching in involving a whole range", "i8kIqes0J54-00338-00078013-00078262": "of different bodies when we asked the", "i8kIqes0J54-00339-00078263-00078630": "OECD to consider the approach to the", "i8kIqes0J54-00340-00078631-00078898": "implementation of CFE and this the", "i8kIqes0J54-00341-00078899-00079135": "condition of Scottish education have put", "i8kIqes0J54-00342-00079136-00079390": "on record that we see these view and the", "i8kIqes0J54-00343-00079391-00079537": "view was that curriculum for excellence", "i8kIqes0J54-00344-00079538-00079857": "was the correct reform to be undertaken", "i8kIqes0J54-00345-00079858-00080173": "they said that they said that curriculum", "i8kIqes0J54-00346-00080174-00080388": "for excellence was the right curriculum", "i8kIqes0J54-00347-00080389-00080631": "for Scotland under it created many", "i8kIqes0J54-00348-00080632-00080829": "strengths for Scotland at this stage in", "i8kIqes0J54-00349-00080830-00081087": "our education system but they also set", "i8kIqes0J54-00350-00081088-00081310": "out for us a range of father measures to", "i8kIqes0J54-00351-00081311-00081537": "ensure that we achieve the true", "i8kIqes0J54-00352-00081538-00081685": "potential of curriculum for excellence", "i8kIqes0J54-00353-00081686-00081886": "which is what the government reform", "i8kIqes0J54-00354-00081887-00082254": "agenda is focused entirely on deliver on", "i8kIqes0J54-00355-00082255-00082488": "Christmas final point in relation to", "i8kIqes0J54-00356-00082489-00082879": "science I would see this and I I", "i8kIqes0J54-00357-00082880-00083076": "absolutely have been absolutely upfront", "i8kIqes0J54-00358-00083077-00083242": "with Parliament about the deterioration", "i8kIqes0J54-00359-00083243-00083412": "in the performance I don't make any", "i8kIqes0J54-00360-00083413-00083548": "attempt to deny that", "i8kIqes0J54-00361-00083549-00083809": "but what list with has to do is to look", "i8kIqes0J54-00362-00083810-00084088": "at the data across the board and there", "i8kIqes0J54-00363-00084089-00084276": "is a general deterioration and", "i8kIqes0J54-00364-00084277-00084463": "participation and performance and", "i8kIqes0J54-00365-00084464-00084732": "science across many jurisdictions and", "i8kIqes0J54-00366-00084733-00084991": "the oecd average itself has fallen as a", "i8kIqes0J54-00367-00084992-00085294": "consequence of that performance and our", "i8kIqes0J54-00368-00085295-00085486": "performances for that don't make any", "i8kIqes0J54-00369-00085487-00085753": "attempt to deny that but I'm simply", "i8kIqes0J54-00370-00085754-00086026": "putting it into the fear context that", "i8kIqes0J54-00371-00086027-00086212": "there is a way that question that the", "i8kIqes0J54-00372-00086213-00086538": "pcr analysis highlights off and the", "i8kIqes0J54-00373-00086539-00086776": "wider participation and performance of", "i8kIqes0J54-00374-00086777-00087016": "young people within science now we and", "i8kIqes0J54-00375-00087017-00087262": "Scotland can already the actions that we", "i8kIqes0J54-00376-00087263-00087403": "need to take to address these issues", "i8kIqes0J54-00377-00087404-00087651": "which is why my statement i went through", "i8kIqes0J54-00378-00087652-00087850": "a range of different measures that the", "i8kIqes0J54-00379-00087851-00088099": "government is taking to strengthen the", "i8kIqes0J54-00380-00088100-00088294": "participation within the STEM subjects", "i8kIqes0J54-00381-00088295-00088488": "and particularly encouraged more", "i8kIqes0J54-00382-00088489-00088729": "teachers to come into the STEM subjects", "i8kIqes0J54-00383-00088730-00088954": "and list will be familiar that just last", "i8kIqes0J54-00384-00088955-00089218": "week I announced new and swifter routes", "i8kIqes0J54-00385-00089219-00089407": "into the teaching profession from", "i8kIqes0J54-00386-00089408-00089611": "individuals who will have a standby", "i8kIqes0J54-00387-00089612-00089785": "current to enable them to be", "i8kIqes0J54-00388-00089786-00090025": "participants in Scottish education and", "i8kIqes0J54-00389-00090026-00090213": "help us to work together to ensure that", "i8kIqes0J54-00390-00090214-00090363": "we improve the performance of Scottish", "i8kIqes0J54-00391-00090364-00090606": "education including on the same subject", "i8kIqes0J54-00392-00090607-00090979": "in three thank you and thanks the", "i8kIqes0J54-00393-00090980-00091156": "cabinet secretary for their lease eight", "i8kIqes0J54-00394-00091157-00091419": "of his statement thanks to present", "i8kIqes0J54-00395-00091420-00091573": "mention that these results do not make", "i8kIqes0J54-00396-00091574-00091810": "comfortable reading I just think that is", "i8kIqes0J54-00397-00091811-00091996": "quite the understatement", "i8kIqes0J54-00398-00091997-00092242": "these results are the legacy of 10 years", "i8kIqes0J54-00399-00092243-00092566": "of SNP government 10 years of cuts to", "i8kIqes0J54-00400-00092567-00092773": "education budget cuts the council", "i8kIqes0J54-00401-00092774-00093019": "funding and cuts to teach your numbers", "i8kIqes0J54-00402-00093020-00093301": "now bout to no one in my respect for the", "i8kIqes0J54-00403-00093302-00093565": "professionalism dedication and", "i8kIqes0J54-00404-00093566-00093880": "inspiration of our teachers our schools", "i8kIqes0J54-00405-00093881-00094180": "cry out for is enough of them with", "i8kIqes0J54-00406-00094181-00094453": "enough time enough support staff and", "i8kIqes0J54-00407-00094454-00094813": "enough resources to do their job that is", "i8kIqes0J54-00408-00094814-00095215": "the key reform these results demand and", "i8kIqes0J54-00409-00095216-00095437": "the budget comes forward next week they", "i8kIqes0J54-00410-00095438-00095734": "must protect education spending and", "i8kIqes0J54-00411-00095735-00095953": "begin to reinstate the cuts of the past", "i8kIqes0J54-00412-00095954-00096207": "decade with the cabinet secretary", "i8kIqes0J54-00413-00096208-00096598": "promise that reform but first we just", "i8kIqes0J54-00414-00096599-00096898": "say sorry to the parents children", "i8kIqes0J54-00415-00096899-00097365": "and teachers of this country john cenni", "i8kIqes0J54-00416-00097366-00097632": "presenting officer and the first thing I", "i8kIqes0J54-00417-00097633-00097900": "want to see is that I have come to", "i8kIqes0J54-00418-00097901-00098299": "Parliament and willingly to explain the", "i8kIqes0J54-00419-00098300-00098590": "PCR results and to acknowledge that the", "i8kIqes0J54-00420-00098591-00098809": "contents of these results make", "i8kIqes0J54-00421-00098810-00099043": "uncomfortable reading for all of us in", "i8kIqes0J54-00422-00099044-00099432": "Scotland and all of these issues all of", "i8kIqes0J54-00423-00099433-00099643": "those comments i put on the record to", "i8kIqes0J54-00424-00099644-00099856": "sum up the government response to what", "i8kIqes0J54-00425-00099857-00100135": "are the statistics and performance that", "i8kIqes0J54-00426-00100136-00100336": "is unacceptable and which we have to", "i8kIqes0J54-00427-00100337-00100642": "improve and I accept the responsibility", "i8kIqes0J54-00428-00100643-00100794": "to make sure that happens and that's", "i8kIqes0J54-00429-00100795-00101029": "what will dominate my term in office as", "i8kIqes0J54-00430-00101030-00101251": "education secretary now let me just", "i8kIqes0J54-00431-00101252-00101509": "answer the particular points that angry", "i8kIqes0J54-00432-00101510-00101899": "at least first of all and must agree his", "i8kIqes0J54-00433-00101900-00102154": "need reference to the issues on local", "i8kIqes0J54-00434-00102155-00102466": "authority and budgets and simply fair", "i8kIqes0J54-00435-00102467-00102741": "mr. great to the report by order its", "i8kIqes0J54-00436-00102742-00102885": "cotton on behalf of the accounts", "i8kIqes0J54-00437-00102886-00103078": "Commission and which was published last", "i8kIqes0J54-00438-00103079-00103315": "week who said this", "i8kIqes0J54-00439-00103316-00103654": "taking into account 2016 17 funding", "i8kIqes0J54-00440-00103655-00103873": "councils have experienced a real-terms", "i8kIqes0J54-00441-00103874-00104139": "reduction in funding of 8.4 percent is", "i8kIqes0J54-00442-00104140-00104440": "2010-11 this is approximately the same", "i8kIqes0J54-00443-00104441-00104610": "as the reduction in the scottish", "i8kIqes0J54-00444-00104611-00104781": "government's total budget over the same", "i8kIqes0J54-00445-00104782-00105163": "period so it puts that and it's mr.", "i8kIqes0J54-00446-00105164-00105427": "Grayson point into the proper context", "i8kIqes0J54-00447-00105428-00105829": "now the my long-serving experience as", "i8kIqes0J54-00448-00105830-00106020": "the finance minister in this Parliament", "i8kIqes0J54-00449-00106021-00106383": "enables me to no one to understand that", "i8kIqes0J54-00450-00106384-00106602": "when the Labour Party come along here", "i8kIqes0J54-00451-00106603-00106833": "complaining up a lack of money for", "i8kIqes0J54-00452-00106834-00107038": "particular areas of policy", "i8kIqes0J54-00453-00107039-00107188": "they're not very good and they have", "i8kIqes0J54-00454-00107189-00107299": "weren't very good and of course they", "i8kIqes0J54-00455-00107300-00107518": "weren't very good over the long period", "i8kIqes0J54-00456-00107519-00107691": "of time which I was the finance minister", "i8kIqes0J54-00457-00107692-00107875": "of telling ask where the money would", "i8kIqes0J54-00458-00107876-00108106": "come from to meet good any of the issues", "i8kIqes0J54-00459-00108107-00108354": "that have been raised in the statement", "i8kIqes0J54-00460-00108355-00108877": "today so the so the answer the answer to", "i8kIqes0J54-00461-00108878-00109054": "us degrees point on local authority", "i8kIqes0J54-00462-00109055-00109329": "budget is contained in the detail of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00463-00109330-00109581": "audit Scotland results as a consequence", "i8kIqes0J54-00464-00109582-00109868": "now an equation of teacher numbers", "i8kIqes0J54-00465-00109869-00110138": "mr. grey will of course be familiar that", "i8kIqes0J54-00466-00110139-00110414": "with some contract within surrounded by", "i8kIqes0J54-00467-00110415-00110681": "some controversy I had to apply certain", "i8kIqes0J54-00468-00110682-00110927": "constraints on local authorities to", "i8kIqes0J54-00469-00110928-00111032": "avoid them", "i8kIqes0J54-00470-00111033-00111358": "reducing teacher numbers even father and", "i8kIqes0J54-00471-00111359-00111586": "I put in place those constraints much to", "i8kIqes0J54-00472-00111588-00111803": "the opposition of the convention of", "i8kIqes0J54-00473-00111804-00112019": "Scottish local authorities and I have to", "i8kIqes0J54-00474-00112020-00112295": "see it bluntly many labor councils in", "i8kIqes0J54-00475-00112296-00112561": "the country who wanted to reduce teacher", "i8kIqes0J54-00476-00112563-00112838": "numbers and I stop them from doing Joe", "i8kIqes0J54-00477-00112839-00113123": "and I make no apology whatsoever for", "i8kIqes0J54-00478-00113124-00113345": "protecting teacher numbers when Labour", "i8kIqes0J54-00479-00113346-00113584": "councillors wanted to reduce them and", "i8kIqes0J54-00480-00113585-00113864": "finally in relation to the question of", "i8kIqes0J54-00481-00113865-00114017": "the budget obviously the finance", "i8kIqes0J54-00482-00114018-00114242": "minister will set out the details of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00483-00114243-00114484": "budget in Parliament next week but the", "i8kIqes0J54-00484-00114485-00114719": "government has given its commitments to", "i8kIqes0J54-00485-00114720-00115043": "invest 750 million pounds in tackling", "i8kIqes0J54-00486-00115044-00115217": "the attainment challenge that we face as", "i8kIqes0J54-00487-00115218-00115406": "a country that is exactly what the", "i8kIqes0J54-00488-00115407-00115574": "government will bring forward as part of", "i8kIqes0J54-00489-00115575-00115783": "its proposals and the finance minister", "i8kIqes0J54-00490-00115784-00116027": "will set out a strong settlement which", "i8kIqes0J54-00491-00116028-00116231": "will enable us to tackle the issues that", "i8kIqes0J54-00492-00116232-00116450": "exist within Scottish education and to", "i8kIqes0J54-00493-00116451-00116773": "deliver for the young people of Scotland", "i8kIqes0J54-00494-00116774-00117020": "I have my doubts that will get through", "i8kIqes0J54-00495-00117021-00117233": "all the questions and for which people", "i8kIqes0J54-00496-00117233-00117443": "have requested it so good we have", "i8kIqes0J54-00497-00117444-00117671": "shorter answers plz cabinet secretary", "i8kIqes0J54-00498-00117672-00117875": "and can i have james jordan and followed", "i8kIqes0J54-00499-00117876-00118006": "by restrooms", "i8kIqes0J54-00500-00118007-00118210": "thank you saying off so the cabinet", "i8kIqes0J54-00501-00118211-00118418": "secretaries rate that these results do", "i8kIqes0J54-00502-00118419-00118622": "not make comfortable reading but they", "i8kIqes0J54-00503-00118623-00118772": "clearly do underlying the case for the", "i8kIqes0J54-00504-00118773-00118984": "form of an education system yet some", "i8kIqes0J54-00505-00118985-00119110": "have suggested the scottish government", "i8kIqes0J54-00506-00119111-00119318": "should slow the stone but the Deputy", "i8kIqes0J54-00507-00119319-00119453": "First Minister agree with me that we", "i8kIqes0J54-00508-00119454-00119624": "need in fact pick up the pieces of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00509-00119625-00119804": "form and where I will ensure that the", "i8kIqes0J54-00510-00119805-00119975": "education skills committee places for", "i8kIqes0J54-00511-00119976-00120116": "all particularly in monitoring", "i8kIqes0J54-00512-00120117-00120323": "scrutinizing employment implementation", "i8kIqes0J54-00513-00120324-00120494": "of the governments of you that you also", "i8kIqes0J54-00514-00120495-00120656": "agree that there's no more reason for", "i8kIqes0J54-00515-00120657-00120848": "groups and members of this chamber to", "i8kIqes0J54-00516-00120849-00121091": "come together to support reform just as", "i8kIqes0J54-00517-00121092-00121238": "it doesn't connect for excellence was", "i8kIqes0J54-00518-00121239-00121445": "introduced helping it to succeed and", "i8kIqes0J54-00519-00121446-00121769": "international fees Johnson tea set of", "i8kIqes0J54-00520-00121770-00121901": "some of the door makes a field", "i8kIqes0J54-00521-00121902-00122042": "observation that curriculum for", "i8kIqes0J54-00522-00122043-00122201": "excellence has been way they supported", "i8kIqes0J54-00523-00122202-00122399": "across this parliamentary chamber and", "i8kIqes0J54-00524-00122400-00122663": "widely supported within the Scottish", "i8kIqes0J54-00525-00122664-00122833": "community into the bargain and", "i8kIqes0J54-00526-00122833-00123029": "implemented as i explained the mines", "i8kIqes0J54-00527-00123030-00123150": "until his Smith", "i8kIqes0J54-00528-00123151-00123354": "em in a collaborative we across the", "i8kIqes0J54-00529-00123355-00123645": "country and i have set in my statement", "i8kIqes0J54-00530-00123646-00123908": "at the government's response which is to", "i8kIqes0J54-00531-00123909-00124140": "reinforce the lessons we learned from", "i8kIqes0J54-00532-00124141-00124539": "the sln Sophie in 2015 of the need for", "i8kIqes0J54-00533-00124540-00124719": "us to progress with reform that is", "i8kIqes0J54-00534-00124720-00124881": "exactly the agenda the government is", "i8kIqes0J54-00535-00124882-00125154": "pursuing and i can assume mr. Dorn and", "i8kIqes0J54-00536-00125155-00125322": "the government will be pursuing that", "i8kIqes0J54-00537-00125323-00125577": "with peace and with urgency to improve", "i8kIqes0J54-00538-00125578-00125940": "Scottish education was Thomson followed", "i8kIqes0J54-00539-00125941-00126177": "by daniel johnson Thank You deputy", "i8kIqes0J54-00540-00126178-00126318": "presiding officer would also like to", "i8kIqes0J54-00541-00126319-00126474": "find the cabinet secretary for prior", "i8kIqes0J54-00542-00126475-00126771": "sites of his statement on page 4 of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00543-00126772-00126933": "cabinet secretary statement under the", "i8kIqes0J54-00544-00126933-00127191": "key recommendation to hear affairs to", "i8kIqes0J54-00545-00127192-00127361": "the education governance review", "i8kIqes0J54-00546-00127363-00127605": "involving education practitioners", "i8kIqes0J54-00547-00127606-00127821": "however cabinet secretary speaking to", "i8kIqes0J54-00548-00127822-00128022": "teachers in my region many of whom", "i8kIqes0J54-00549-00128023-00128193": "attended a recent consultation event", "i8kIqes0J54-00550-00128194-00128352": "that between exhibition conference", "i8kIqes0J54-00551-00128353-00128415": "center", "i8kIqes0J54-00552-00128416-00128574": "they've said to me to review", "i8kIqes0J54-00553-00128575-00128864": "consultation itself is too bureaucratic", "i8kIqes0J54-00554-00128865-00129201": "filled with too much jargon and teachers", "i8kIqes0J54-00555-00129202-00129408": "were specific with me that in some cases", "i8kIqes0J54-00556-00129408-00129726": "they had no idea what some of the review", "i8kIqes0J54-00557-00129727-00129990": "questions were actually asking with", "i8kIqes0J54-00558-00129991-00130149": "teachers already expressing little", "i8kIqes0J54-00559-00130150-00130377": "confidence in the review process how can", "i8kIqes0J54-00560-00130378-00130539": "the cabinet secretary possibly deliver", "i8kIqes0J54-00561-00130540-00130779": "the reforms he has articulated if he", "i8kIqes0J54-00562-00130780-00131105": "cannot take teachers with them John Tony", "i8kIqes0J54-00563-00131106-00131445": "and well all I can see to mr. Thompson", "i8kIqes0J54-00564-00131446-00131685": "is that the government is engaging very", "i8kIqes0J54-00565-00131686-00131847": "actively in detail and many", "i8kIqes0J54-00566-00131848-00132066": "conversations and many parts of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00567-00132067-00132249": "country about the details of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00568-00132250-00132456": "government's view my number of Ministers", "i8kIqes0J54-00569-00132457-00132735": "involved in those conversations and I've", "i8kIqes0J54-00570-00132736-00132998": "taken partner myself I find them to be", "i8kIqes0J54-00571-00132999-00133245": "rewarding and thoughtful conversations", "i8kIqes0J54-00572-00133246-00133419": "and which a lot of different views", "i8kIqes0J54-00573-00133420-00133605": "expressed and the government oversee", "i8kIqes0J54-00574-00133606-00133842": "takes those views enter code and coming", "i8kIqes0J54-00575-00133843-00134109": "to its conclusions so all I would see to", "i8kIqes0J54-00576-00134110-00134364": "mr. Thompson is that we need to", "i8kIqes0J54-00577-00134365-00134607": "encourage participation in the", "i8kIqes0J54-00578-00134608-00134799": "discussions around the government review", "i8kIqes0J54-00579-00134800-00135084": "and add the government book and ensure", "i8kIqes0J54-00580-00135085-00135324": "that that is the case and ensure that we", "i8kIqes0J54-00581-00135325-00135597": "take a set of focus decisions which are", "i8kIqes0J54-00582-00135598-00135822": "designed to strengthen us college", "i8kIqes0J54-00583-00135823-00135990": "education as a consequence of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00584-00135991-00136164": "information we hear from everyone that", "i8kIqes0J54-00585-00136165-00136366": "participates in that process", "i8kIqes0J54-00586-00136367-00136705": "daniel johnson followed by General Thank", "i8kIqes0J54-00587-00136706-00136879": "You presiding officer and I'd like to", "i8kIqes0J54-00588-00136880-00137035": "add my thanks for the prior site of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00589-00137036-00137290": "statement i'm glad the cabinet secretary", "i8kIqes0J54-00590-00137291-00137464": "acknowledges the gravity of these", "i8kIqes0J54-00591-00137465-00137641": "results but is it not the case that", "i8kIqes0J54-00592-00137642-00137791": "since the SNP form the government", "i8kIqes0J54-00593-00137792-00138067": "Scotland we lost to stem teachers every", "i8kIqes0J54-00594-00138068-00138274": "week there are twenty percent fewer", "i8kIqes0J54-00595-00138275-00138520": "technicians and lab assistants have", "i8kIqes0J54-00596-00138521-00138643": "reduced by half", "i8kIqes0J54-00597-00138644-00138826": "what impact has this reduction of", "i8kIqes0J54-00598-00138827-00139057": "resources in our schools had on our P's", "i8kIqes0J54-00599-00139058-00139537": "rankings johnsonii and what and what we", "i8kIqes0J54-00600-00139538-00139813": "have to address as a government is the", "i8kIqes0J54-00601-00139814-00140059": "resources that are available to us and", "i8kIqes0J54-00602-00140060-00140317": "have been available to us it to address", "i8kIqes0J54-00603-00140318-00140446": "the challenges across the public", "i8kIqes0J54-00604-00140447-00140797": "services and we've delivered over the", "i8kIqes0J54-00605-00140798-00141103": "course of the last nine years very", "i8kIqes0J54-00606-00141104-00141355": "strong fear settlements for local", "i8kIqes0J54-00607-00141356-00141583": "authorities which are evidenced by the", "i8kIqes0J54-00608-00141584-00141799": "court that shared with mr. agree as a", "i8kIqes0J54-00609-00141800-00142090": "consequence of the audit Scotland report", "i8kIqes0J54-00610-00142091-00142405": "and the government itself does not", "i8kIqes0J54-00611-00142406-00142639": "choose how many technicians that our", "i8kIqes0J54-00612-00142640-00142849": "schools we do not choose to the teachers", "i8kIqes0J54-00613-00142850-00143098": "are schools these decisions are taken by", "i8kIqes0J54-00614-00143099-00143344": "local authorities and I simply point out", "i8kIqes0J54-00615-00143345-00143614": "to mr. Johnson once again if i had not", "i8kIqes0J54-00616-00143615-00143896": "stepped in to stop local authorities", "i8kIqes0J54-00617-00143897-00144199": "many of them run by his own party from", "i8kIqes0J54-00618-00144200-00144427": "wishing to reduce teacher numbers father", "i8kIqes0J54-00619-00144428-00144622": "then we would have we would have had few", "i8kIqes0J54-00620-00144623-00144868": "teachers in our schools then we have to", "i8kIqes0J54-00621-00144869-00145270": "D that is the uncomfortable truth for", "i8kIqes0J54-00622-00145271-00145531": "the Labour Party that I had to stand it", "i8kIqes0J54-00623-00145532-00145768": "to step in to stop labor local", "i8kIqes0J54-00624-00145769-00146020": "authorities reducing teacher numbers and", "i8kIqes0J54-00625-00146021-00146290": "i'm very glad that I did sue general", "i8kIqes0J54-00626-00146291-00146509": "rule followed by Ra's clear thank you", "i8kIqes0J54-00627-00146510-00146761": "saying officer the OECD rightly", "i8kIqes0J54-00628-00146762-00146932": "highlighted the role of leadership and", "i8kIqes0J54-00629-00146933-00147097": "our skills and I welcome the rule that", "i8kIqes0J54-00630-00147098-00147274": "the scottish college for educational", "i8kIqes0J54-00631-00147275-00147508": "leadership is playing in that regard and", "i8kIqes0J54-00632-00147509-00147688": "the cabinet secretary explain how the", "i8kIqes0J54-00633-00147689-00147886": "college seeks to empower metal leaders", "i8kIqes0J54-00634-00147887-00148117": "who will be key to driving improvement", "i8kIqes0J54-00635-00148118-00148317": "in classrooms across the country", "i8kIqes0J54-00636-00148318-00148567": "johnsonii I think the question of", "i8kIqes0J54-00637-00148568-00148876": "leadership is a", "i8kIqes0J54-00638-00148877-00149086": "is a well demonstrated point within the", "i8kIqes0J54-00639-00149087-00149365": "OECD review of Scottish education but", "i8kIqes0J54-00640-00149366-00149566": "it's also very visible illustration of", "i8kIqes0J54-00641-00149567-00149716": "their strength comes from in the", "i8kIqes0J54-00642-00149717-00150019": "education system and and I was in a", "i8kIqes0J54-00643-00150020-00150271": "secondary school yesterday in glasgow", "i8kIqes0J54-00644-00150272-00150463": "and John Paul academy and some of them", "i8kIqes0J54-00645-00150464-00150727": "which is a fantastically well late", "i8kIqes0J54-00646-00150728-00151093": "school and with very clear direction and", "i8kIqes0J54-00647-00151094-00151264": "with with with a tremendous learning", "i8kIqes0J54-00648-00151265-00151504": "environment and leadership demonstrated", "i8kIqes0J54-00649-00151505-00151681": "are all levels within the particular", "i8kIqes0J54-00650-00151682-00151930": "school so i think the point i would make", "i8kIqes0J54-00651-00151931-00152227": "to generate growth on leadership is that", "i8kIqes0J54-00652-00152228-00152419": "we have to recognize the importance of", "i8kIqes0J54-00653-00152420-00152617": "leadership right through the school", "i8kIqes0J54-00654-00152618-00152791": "community not just a headteacher level", "i8kIqes0J54-00655-00152792-00152980": "but rite throughout the school community", "i8kIqes0J54-00656-00152981-00153223": "so that there is a constant focus on how", "i8kIqes0J54-00657-00153224-00153448": "we strengthen and improve Scott", "i8kIqes0J54-00658-00153449-00153667": "education at every level in which", "i8kIqes0J54-00659-00153668-00154036": "teaching and learning has been delivered", "i8kIqes0J54-00660-00154037-00154336": "roscrea followed by filter greater thank", "i8kIqes0J54-00661-00154337-00154456": "you for saying officer like college", "i8kIqes0J54-00662-00154457-00154585": "would like to thank the Deputy First", "i8kIqes0J54-00663-00154586-00154768": "Minister for advanced copy of this", "i8kIqes0J54-00664-00154769-00154879": "statement", "i8kIqes0J54-00665-00154880-00155053": "today's report on their piece of figures", "i8kIqes0J54-00666-00155054-00155251": "air coincides with another report from", "i8kIqes0J54-00667-00155252-00155419": "enable Scotland it doesn't make for", "i8kIqes0J54-00668-00155420-00155659": "comfortable reading either at found that", "i8kIqes0J54-00669-00155660-00155791": "far too many young people with", "i8kIqes0J54-00670-00155792-00155992": "additional support needs fuel and indeed", "i8kIqes0J54-00671-00155993-00156214": "are excluded in school", "i8kIqes0J54-00672-00156215-00156406": "this has an unavoidable impact on their", "i8kIqes0J54-00673-00156407-00156664": "attainment given the links between the", "i8kIqes0J54-00674-00156665-00156811": "attainment gap in the prevalence of", "i8kIqes0J54-00675-00156812-00156997": "additional support needs the government", "i8kIqes0J54-00676-00156998-00157195": "use the powers of this Parliament to", "i8kIqes0J54-00677-00157196-00157393": "bring forward a budget the local", "i8kIqes0J54-00678-00157394-00157570": "government to reverse the cuts of", "i8kIqes0J54-00679-00157571-00157729": "hundreds of additional support needs", "i8kIqes0J54-00680-00157730-00157942": "teachers and support staff in recent", "i8kIqes0J54-00681-00157943-00158185": "years and in addition to adapt the First", "i8kIqes0J54-00682-00158186-00158359": "Minister outline what evidence the", "i8kIqes0J54-00683-00158360-00158554": "government has of any educational", "i8kIqes0J54-00684-00158555-00158773": "benefits of moving control of education", "i8kIqes0J54-00685-00158774-00158958": "from a local level to regional board", "i8kIqes0J54-00686-00158959-00159265": "John's money on the first point to", "i8kIqes0J54-00687-00159266-00159436": "oversee the finance minister will set to", "i8kIqes0J54-00688-00159437-00159631": "the provisions of the budget next year", "i8kIqes0J54-00689-00159632-00159898": "mr. gear wouldn't expect me to empty", "i8kIqes0J54-00690-00159899-00160090": "judge that but i would simply see that", "i8kIqes0J54-00691-00160091-00160303": "the that the point trees by enable", "i8kIqes0J54-00692-00160304-00160567": "Scotland are and important points about", "i8kIqes0J54-00693-00160568-00160876": "the importance of and including every", "i8kIqes0J54-00694-00160877-00161164": "young person in our education system and", "i8kIqes0J54-00695-00161165-00161443": "assume that the and achieve fulfillment", "i8kIqes0J54-00696-00161444-00161674": "and when the government sets out and", "i8kIqes0J54-00697-00161675-00161752": "have me", "i8kIqes0J54-00698-00161753-00161862": "this point clear the Parliament before", "i8kIqes0J54-00699-00161863-00162226": "then the centrality of the agenda of", "i8kIqes0J54-00700-00162227-00162397": "getting a record of the child that has", "i8kIqes0J54-00701-00162398-00162608": "to mean for every single child and we", "i8kIqes0J54-00702-00162609-00162833": "have to meet their needs and then", "i8kIqes0J54-00703-00162834-00163019": "secondly at the point I would make two", "i8kIqes0J54-00704-00163020-00163459": "at mr. hear about em educational regions", "i8kIqes0J54-00705-00163460-00163747": "is this and I have and it's well", "i8kIqes0J54-00706-00163748-00164071": "published information a data from audit", "i8kIqes0J54-00707-00164072-00164432": "Scotland which significantly questions", "i8kIqes0J54-00708-00164433-00164653": "the ability of individual local", "i8kIqes0J54-00709-00164654-00164921": "authorities to add value to education", "i8kIqes0J54-00710-00164922-00165088": "within the schools within their areas of", "i8kIqes0J54-00711-00165089-00165541": "responsibility and this data tells us", "i8kIqes0J54-00712-00165542-00165835": "that we've got to enhance and support", "i8kIqes0J54-00713-00165836-00165988": "the enhancement of learning and teaching", "i8kIqes0J54-00714-00165989-00166336": "within Scotland we must do that and it's", "i8kIqes0J54-00715-00166337-00166537": "clear from the data I have published", "i8kIqes0J54-00716-00166538-00166759": "data that some local authorities are not", "i8kIqes0J54-00717-00166760-00167023": "able to add that value and what we have", "i8kIqes0J54-00718-00167024-00167183": "to therefore confront is the hard", "i8kIqes0J54-00719-00167184-00167383": "reality that we have to make sure that", "i8kIqes0J54-00720-00167384-00167551": "is available to every single student", "i8kIqes0J54-00721-00167552-00167779": "countries it's not good enough for me to", "i8kIqes0J54-00722-00167780-00168004": "ponder blind item in certain parts of", "i8kIqes0J54-00723-00168005-00168229": "the country and some local authorities", "i8kIqes0J54-00724-00168230-00168439": "are able to do that and others are not", "i8kIqes0J54-00725-00168440-00168751": "so what I want to make sure is that we", "i8kIqes0J54-00726-00168752-00168961": "have an educational development resource", "i8kIqes0J54-00727-00168962-00169193": "which is available in every part of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00728-00169194-00169423": "country that can add value to the", "i8kIqes0J54-00729-00169424-00169595": "educational experience of young people", "i8kIqes0J54-00730-00169596-00169840": "that is the point of cooperation between", "i8kIqes0J54-00731-00169841-00170134": "local authorities to create educational", "i8kIqes0J54-00732-00170135-00170452": "regions note i simply make the point", "i8kIqes0J54-00733-00170453-00170821": "that we're making choices in difficult", "i8kIqes0J54-00734-00170822-00171008": "circumstances about the resources that", "i8kIqes0J54-00735-00171009-00171206": "are available to us we must be prepared", "i8kIqes0J54-00736-00171207-00171494": "to work a crossbone that is to do but we", "i8kIqes0J54-00737-00171495-00171719": "see he said to us to what collaborative", "i8kIqes0J54-00738-00171720-00171908": "across boundaries and to share good", "i8kIqes0J54-00739-00171909-00172183": "practice and to ensure that that can", "i8kIqes0J54-00740-00172184-00172450": "have an impact a profound impart on the", "i8kIqes0J54-00741-00172451-00172621": "educational experience of young people", "i8kIqes0J54-00742-00172622-00172846": "in Scotland that's the justification for", "i8kIqes0J54-00743-00172847-00173008": "education educational regions in", "i8kIqes0J54-00744-00173009-00173260": "Scotland Phil McGregor followed by", "i8kIqes0J54-00745-00173261-00173365": "Travis Scott", "i8kIqes0J54-00746-00173366-00173587": "Thank You presiding officer has been", "i8kIqes0J54-00747-00173588-00173827": "highlighted progress including the team", "i8kIqes0J54-00748-00173828-00174115": "gap has been maintained and the impact", "i8kIqes0J54-00749-00174116-00174298": "of deprivation is around we see the", "i8kIqes0J54-00750-00174299-00174533": "average but with the cabinet secretary", "i8kIqes0J54-00751-00174534-00174722": "agree with me that maintaining through", "i8kIqes0J54-00752-00174723-00174920": "this isn't enough to make the changes we", "i8kIqes0J54-00753-00174921-00175026": "all want to see", "i8kIqes0J54-00754-00175027-00175146": "and that we should be striving for", "i8kIqes0J54-00755-00175147-00175495": "higher than average johnsonii except", "i8kIqes0J54-00756-00175496-00175731": "that point and that's the focus of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00757-00175732-00175947": "recommendations that we received from", "i8kIqes0J54-00758-00175948-00176148": "the OECD review is the focus of what", "i8kIqes0J54-00759-00176149-00176424": "we're taking forward as part of the and", "i8kIqes0J54-00760-00176425-00176628": "the National improvement framework and", "i8kIqes0J54-00761-00176629-00176829": "the the government's work on attainment", "i8kIqes0J54-00762-00176830-00177135": "and features in the states we've already", "i8kIqes0J54-00763-00177136-00177453": "taken over the last 18 months or to", "i8kIqes0J54-00764-00177454-00177636": "advance this agenda and take every step", "i8kIqes0J54-00765-00177637-00177891": "that we can to close the attainment gap", "i8kIqes0J54-00766-00177892-00178290": "within Scottish education tabish Scott", "i8kIqes0J54-00767-00178291-00178545": "followed by Jeremy mouth when you're not", "i8kIqes0J54-00768-00178546-00178707": "ships on your skin also thank the", "i8kIqes0J54-00769-00178708-00178935": "cabinet secretary for his statement will", "i8kIqes0J54-00770-00178936-00179127": "be Deputy First Minister except that he", "i8kIqes0J54-00771-00179128-00179340": "is the fourth SMP education secretary in", "i8kIqes0J54-00772-00179341-00179547": "nine years and under his government's", "i8kIqes0J54-00773-00179548-00179751": "watch and no one else these results are", "i8kIqes0J54-00774-00179752-00179970": "shocking will agree that he has to do", "i8kIqes0J54-00775-00179971-00180145": "much much more to allow Scotland's", "i8kIqes0J54-00776-00180146-00180351": "teachers to actually teach his", "i8kIqes0J54-00777-00180352-00180546": "government's education quango has issued", "i8kIqes0J54-00778-00180547-00180789": "to 20,000 pages of guidance on", "i8kIqes0J54-00779-00180790-00180948": "curriculum for excellence to every", "i8kIqes0J54-00780-00180949-00181161": "school that has simply not worked how", "i8kIqes0J54-00781-00181162-00181393": "many of those 20,000 pages will actually", "i8kIqes0J54-00782-00181394-00181681": "go does except that no parent teacher or", "i8kIqes0J54-00783-00181682-00181854": "people will accept financial cuts to", "i8kIqes0J54-00784-00181855-00182139": "schools after today so we meet local", "i8kIqes0J54-00785-00182140-00182340": "authority leaders before the budget next", "i8kIqes0J54-00786-00182341-00182586": "week to agree how to maintain spending", "i8kIqes0J54-00787-00182587-00182956": "in Scotland schools and sunny in", "i8kIqes0J54-00788-00182957-00183258": "relation to the the point mr. Scott", "i8kIqes0J54-00789-00183259-00183486": "makes on on guidance and over the course", "i8kIqes0J54-00790-00183487-00183670": "of the implementation of curriculum for", "i8kIqes0J54-00791-00183671-00184029": "excellence that have been various and a", "i8kIqes0J54-00792-00184030-00184284": "discussions and dialogue within the", "i8kIqes0J54-00793-00184285-00184449": "collaborative structures for taking", "i8kIqes0J54-00794-00184450-00184602": "forward curriculum development through", "i8kIqes0J54-00795-00184603-00184815": "the collections management board that", "i8kIqes0J54-00796-00184816-00185037": "affair to with their in my response to", "i8kIqes0J54-00797-00185038-00185403": "Smith which has resulted in the drafting", "i8kIqes0J54-00798-00185404-00185678": "of guidance to provide greater clarity", "i8kIqes0J54-00799-00185679-00186114": "to the teaching profession I accept the", "i8kIqes0J54-00800-00186115-00186453": "cumulative burden of that guidance has", "i8kIqes0J54-00801-00186454-00186834": "become em unnavigable for the teaching", "i8kIqes0J54-00802-00186835-00187057": "profession which is why I've said about", "i8kIqes0J54-00803-00187058-00187377": "reducing it that's why the definitive", "i8kIqes0J54-00804-00187378-00187638": "guidance that I should to every school", "i8kIqes0J54-00805-00187639-00187827": "teacher in the country in late August", "i8kIqes0J54-00806-00187828-00188085": "was designed to give absolute clarity of", "i8kIqes0J54-00807-00188086-00188241": "what was expected of the teaching", "i8kIqes0J54-00808-00188242-00188310": "profession", "i8kIqes0J54-00809-00188311-00188484": "and it was followed by a simplification", "i8kIqes0J54-00810-00188485-00188652": "agenda for the chief inspector of", "i8kIqes0J54-00811-00188653-00188916": "Education know there will be a huge", "i8kIqes0J54-00812-00188917-00189213": "reduction in the volume of people work", "i8kIqes0J54-00813-00189214-00189381": "and guidance that is available to the", "i8kIqes0J54-00814-00189382-00189627": "teaching profession as we move to a much", "i8kIqes0J54-00815-00189628-00189957": "simpler and more crystallized approach", "i8kIqes0J54-00816-00189958-00190233": "to and to advise on the curriculum", "i8kIqes0J54-00817-00190234-00190401": "through the benchmarks that I talked", "i8kIqes0J54-00818-00190402-00190587": "about in the statement now seated mr.", "i8kIqes0J54-00819-00190588-00190797": "Scott the feedback that I've hide from", "i8kIqes0J54-00820-00190798-00191013": "the teaching profession on the literacy", "i8kIqes0J54-00821-00191014-00191187": "and numeracy benchmarks that were issued", "i8kIqes0J54-00822-00191188-00191421": "has been very good feedback from members", "i8kIqes0J54-00823-00191422-00191652": "of the teaching profession who believed", "i8kIqes0J54-00824-00191653-00191838": "it to be valuable and that's the spirit", "i8kIqes0J54-00825-00191839-00192051": "in which will take forward our approach", "i8kIqes0J54-00826-00192052-00192261": "to the benchmark information in the", "i8kIqes0J54-00827-00192262-00192333": "future", "i8kIqes0J54-00828-00192334-00192543": "the final point that mr. Scott raised", "i8kIqes0J54-00829-00192544-00192720": "about local authorities and obviously", "i8kIqes0J54-00830-00192721-00192915": "there are ongoing discussions with local", "i8kIqes0J54-00831-00192916-00193128": "governments around and the whole issue", "i8kIqes0J54-00832-00193129-00193353": "of the public finances Mr McKay the", "i8kIqes0J54-00833-00193354-00193553": "finance minister is taking forward those", "i8kIqes0J54-00834-00193554-00193778": "discussions and understanding us some", "i8kIqes0J54-00835-00193779-00193953": "further meetings are not planned for", "i8kIqes0J54-00836-00193954-00194303": "today I can squeeze into more quick", "i8kIqes0J54-00837-00194304-00194484": "questions please from jamie bell for a", "i8kIqes0J54-00838-00194485-00194778": "monocle in Thank You presiding officers", "i8kIqes0J54-00839-00194779-00194949": "can find the cabinet secretary for each", "i8kIqes0J54-00840-00194950-00195165": "statement i think the clear message from", "i8kIqes0J54-00841-00195166-00195408": "the jobs today about this government has", "i8kIqes0J54-00842-00195409-00195624": "filled a generation in regard to", "i8kIqes0J54-00843-00195625-00195870": "education and we in Scotland or place", "i8kIqes0J54-00844-00195871-00196089": "for that in future years ahead", "i8kIqes0J54-00845-00196090-00196413": "looking ahead would be cabinet so could", "i8kIqes0J54-00846-00196414-00196679": "you give me but we know Lee mutually got", "i8kIqes0J54-00847-00196680-00196940": "having specific science teachers in", "i8kIqes0J54-00848-00196941-00197151": "plane which girls who are trained in", "i8kIqes0J54-00849-00197152-00197427": "change and who can blame that education", "i8kIqes0J54-00850-00197428-00197637": "to the children so that we don't see", "i8kIqes0J54-00851-00197638-00197832": "another generation falling further", "i8kIqes0J54-00852-00197833-00197910": "behind", "i8kIqes0J54-00853-00197911-00198438": "johnsonii and I i'm quite happy to", "i8kIqes0J54-00854-00198439-00198753": "concede that this the detail here is", "i8kIqes0J54-00855-00198754-00198950": "uncomfortable reading but I have to see", "i8kIqes0J54-00856-00198951-00199241": "mr. ball first characterization of the", "i8kIqes0J54-00857-00199242-00199647": "situation is absolutely over the top at", "i8kIqes0J54-00858-00199648-00200022": "the OECD analysis does not be alone mr.", "i8kIqes0J54-00859-00200023-00200298": "Balfour's analysis the view of a number", "i8kIqes0J54-00860-00200299-00200559": "of international education advisors does", "i8kIqes0J54-00861-00200560-00200844": "not be about mr. Balfour's analysis and", "i8kIqes0J54-00862-00200845-00201029": "I don't think we do i'm quite happy to", "i8kIqes0J54-00863-00201030-00201243": "have an honest to beat about where we", "i8kIqes0J54-00864-00201244-00201479": "are but we have got to have that to be", "i8kIqes0J54-00865-00201480-00201570": "in the spin", "i8kIqes0J54-00866-00201571-00201921": "bit of decent quality information which", "i8kIqes0J54-00867-00201922-00202202": "the OECD and our international advisors", "i8kIqes0J54-00868-00202203-00202388": "have given us and I don't think the beat", "i8kIqes0J54-00869-00202389-00202671": "is well served by the characterization", "i8kIqes0J54-00870-00202672-00202904": "that mr. Balfour has given to today", "i8kIqes0J54-00871-00202905-00203160": "now I think the Conservatives know", "i8kIqes0J54-00872-00203161-00203346": "because I've made this point to them", "i8kIqes0J54-00873-00203347-00203711": "before that the idea of specialists", "i8kIqes0J54-00874-00203712-00203970": "science teachers in the primary sector", "i8kIqes0J54-00875-00203971-00204254": "would run contrary to the whole approach", "i8kIqes0J54-00876-00204255-00204423": "to the delivery of primary education", "i8kIqes0J54-00877-00204424-00204696": "within curriculum for excellence", "i8kIqes0J54-00878-00204697-00204986": "now I accept the importance of young", "i8kIqes0J54-00879-00204987-00205208": "people being captivated by an interest", "i8kIqes0J54-00880-00205209-00205431": "in science and it has to happen at the", "i8kIqes0J54-00881-00205432-00205632": "earliest possible stage and their", "i8kIqes0J54-00882-00205633-00205848": "educational journey and i have seen in", "i8kIqes0J54-00883-00205848-00206039": "countless occasions around the country", "i8kIqes0J54-00884-00206040-00206298": "fabulous examples of how that can be", "i8kIqes0J54-00885-00206298-00206532": "done not by specialist science teachers", "i8kIqes0J54-00886-00206533-00206723": "taught by teachers who are motivated to", "i8kIqes0J54-00887-00206725-00206966": "the over the broad curriculum that will", "i8kIqes0J54-00888-00206967-00207194": "enhance the educational opportunities of", "i8kIqes0J54-00889-00207196-00207614": "our young people monocle and thank you", "i8kIqes0J54-00890-00207615-00207780": "for dating officer that has been no", "i8kIqes0J54-00891-00207781-00207959": "acknowledgement of the cuts to local", "i8kIqes0J54-00892-00207960-00208206": "authorities and skills but apology from", "i8kIqes0J54-00893-00208207-00208388": "the Scottish Government been shes to", "i8kIqes0J54-00894-00208389-00208548": "young people and their teacher some of", "i8kIqes0J54-00895-00208548-00208821": "her and the chamber to the it seems", "i8kIqes0J54-00896-00208821-00209082": "government is only presentation cleared", "i8kIqes0J54-00897-00209083-00209400": "it and never blame me about the cabinet", "i8kIqes0J54-00898-00209401-00209546": "secretaries government initially and", "i8kIqes0J54-00899-00209548-00209744": "then identity to quickly placed before", "i8kIqes0J54-00900-00209746-00209937": "the essential ization of funding for", "i8kIqes0J54-00901-00209938-00210173": "setting school budgets what shouldn't", "i8kIqes0J54-00902-00210175-00210390": "sees can decapitate HD go to teach", "i8kIqes0J54-00903-00210391-00210564": "pupils and their families that has", "i8kIqes0J54-00904-00210565-00210762": "planned well ensure that all skills will", "i8kIqes0J54-00905-00210763-00210966": "get the funding that they need to answer", "i8kIqes0J54-00906-00210967-00211038": "me", "i8kIqes0J54-00907-00211039-00211307": "I think I I don't wear a monocle and has", "i8kIqes0J54-00908-00211308-00211460": "been for the last half an hour because", "i8kIqes0J54-00909-00211461-00211677": "I've given a pretty candid account of", "i8kIqes0J54-00910-00211678-00211832": "things to Parliament about the", "i8kIqes0J54-00911-00211833-00212100": "challenges that we face there on the", "i8kIqes0J54-00912-00212101-00212340": "issue of funding i'll tell you what i", "i8kIqes0J54-00913-00212341-00212571": "want to send funding i want to send", "i8kIqes0J54-00914-00212571-00212798": "funding direct into the schools of", "i8kIqes0J54-00915-00212800-00213023": "Scotland so that our leading teachers", "i8kIqes0J54-00916-00213025-00213216": "can take decisions about the needs of", "i8kIqes0J54-00917-00213217-00213390": "the children in their schools", "i8kIqes0J54-00918-00213391-00213582": "that's what I want to do and I want to", "i8kIqes0J54-00919-00213583-00213746": "make sure that we have a debate in", "i8kIqes0J54-00920-00213748-00213978": "Parliament about the way in which we", "i8kIqes0J54-00921-00213979-00214157": "could do that and i hope the Labour", "i8kIqes0J54-00922-00214158-00214344": "Party will engage constructively in that", "i8kIqes0J54-00923-00214344-00214452": "discussion", "i8kIqes0J54-00924-00214453-00214665": "here to be the case that concludes", "i8kIqes0J54-00925-00214666-00215021": "questions on the statement people could", "i8kIqes0J54-00926-00215023-00215433": "quietly receipt them"}}, {"audio_id": "i8qYmAVl-gy", "text": {"i8qYmAVl-gy-00000-00000008-00000279": "lars and james are geniuses", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00001-00000280-00000534": "they're also adults they liked with", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00002-00000535-00000774": "people's brains with their music and", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00003-00000775-00001079": "here's how metallica has so far released", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00004-00001080-00001311": "10 studio albums now that's a lot of", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00005-00001312-00001503": "music and they've definitely had to try", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00006-00001504-00001814": "some new stuff many many times they have", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00007-00001816-00002023": "always been down to experiment and", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00008-00002023-00002175": "innovate they've been down with your", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00009-00002176-00002375": "head every now and then as well there", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00010-00002376-00002655": "are some metallica songs on which there", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00011-00002656-00002895": "are certain moments that are confusing", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00012-00002896-00003126": "as hell they are misleading to the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00013-00003127-00003327": "listener's ear and today we're looking", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00014-00003328-00003575": "at eight times metallica confused us", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00015-00003576-00003727": "with their songs", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00016-00003728-00004031": "number one fight fire with fire no they", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00017-00004032-00004191": "weren't so musically sophisticated on", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00018-00004192-00004399": "kill em all anyway there's actually", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00019-00004400-00004559": "nothing about the song it's just where", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00020-00004560-00004791": "the cymbals hit at the beginning and the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00021-00004792-00005015": "very high tempo which forces you to", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00022-00005016-00005199": "follow the snare instead of the kick", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00023-00005200-00005391": "speaking of which i also think the drum", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00024-00005392-00005615": "mixing and the low volume of the kick", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00025-00005616-00005976": "play a factor here", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00026-00005977-00006279": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00027-00006280-00006439": "the symbols at the beginning make it", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00028-00006440-00006586": "sound like this", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00029-00006587-00007159": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00030-00007159-00007302": "but it's in fact like this", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00031-00007303-00008023": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00032-00008023-00008303": "number two ride the lightning this one's", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00033-00008304-00008471": "genius and it's the reason why lars", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00034-00008472-00008631": "counts to 3 instead of 4 when they", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00035-00008632-00008895": "played live when the toms hit they are", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00036-00008896-00009159": "not the first beat but the 4th when", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00037-00009160-00009399": "james and kirk play the harmony the c", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00038-00009400-00009591": "and g are the first beat this is the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00039-00009592-00010095": "wrong way to play it one one", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00040-00010096-00010559": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00041-00010560-00010742": "see how the count is incorrect now", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00042-00010743-00011149": "here's the correct way to play it", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00043-00011150-00011759": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00044-00011760-00011903": "now it's correct", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00045-00011904-00012167": "number three trapped under ice again", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00046-00012168-00012374": "like on fight fire with fire there's the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00047-00012375-00012678": "poor drum mixing also this time there's", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00048-00012679-00012919": "inconsistent tempo the only way to hear", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00049-00012919-00013094": "this one correctly is to follow the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00050-00013095-00013358": "guitar riff which goes like this one two", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00051-00013359-00013562": "three four", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00052-00013563-00014127": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00053-00014128-00014447": "number four master of puppets gotta love", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00054-00014447-00014566": "it when a band makes you think they're", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00055-00014568-00014775": "playing in 28 over 64", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00056-00014776-00015007": "but it's just four over four the clean", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00057-00015008-00015238": "interlude riff from master of puppets", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00058-00015240-00015430": "once again it's lars doing his thing", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00059-00015431-00015599": "somehow lars makes you think he's", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00060-00015600-00015766": "starting a new bar every time he hits", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00061-00015768-00016038": "the symbols thanks lars count with me", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00062-00016040-00017319": "one two three four", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00063-00017320-00017630": "number five leper messiah the pre-count", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00064-00017631-00017863": "in leper messiah is 100", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00065-00017864-00018167": "incorrect and unnecessary he counts the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00066-00018168-00018367": "five to start a song that's in four over", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00067-00018368-00018439": "four", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00068-00018440-00018535": "what", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00069-00018536-00018671": "and good luck if you try to count the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00070-00018672-00018886": "intro in five over four to see if it's", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00071-00018887-00019150": "counting correctly or not number six", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00072-00019151-00019439": "blackened oh yeah this one", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00073-00019440-00019599": "blackened was the most difficult song", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00074-00019600-00019767": "for me to follow when i was younger and", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00075-00019768-00020107": "again it's the snare you know this riff", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00076-00020108-00020279": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00077-00020280-00020439": "the snare makes you think it starts on", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00078-00020440-00020583": "the high e", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00079-00020584-00021199": "while in fact it starts on the lower one", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00080-00021200-00021335": "but again one of the most difficult", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00081-00021336-00021494": "things you'll ever do is try to keep up", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00082-00021495-00021735": "with the song and we're not done yet", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00083-00021736-00021958": "there's also the part after the solo aka", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00084-00021959-00022143": "the post solo treatment i used to think", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00085-00022144-00022343": "there was a mistake here turned out the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00086-00022344-00022494": "mistake was here", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00087-00022495-00022727": "at the end of the solo lars hit the tom", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00088-00022728-00022839": "and snare", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00089-00022840-00023335": "17 times not 16. at the 17th time which", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00090-00023336-00023630": "is actually the first time in a new bar", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00091-00023631-00023871": "the main riff is played again", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00092-00023872-00023958": "but", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00093-00023959-00024222": "the new beat starts on the high e not", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00094-00024223-00024439": "the low one so now you think it's played", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00095-00024440-00024574": "like this", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00096-00024575-00024830": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00097-00024831-00025646": "and then this happens", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00098-00025647-00025927": "because the seventeenth beat is not a", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00099-00025927-00026174": "seventeenth beat it's the first one in a", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00100-00026175-00026302": "new bar", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00101-00026304-00026695": "fulars number seven and justice for all", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00102-00026695-00026895": "the very next track i will not talk", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00103-00026895-00027079": "about it today though instead i'm gonna", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00104-00027080-00027335": "address it in a future video for a very", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00105-00027336-00027502": "specific reason", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00106-00027504-00027695": "skip into number eight and the last one", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00107-00027695-00027911": "we're gonna talk about today eye of the", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00108-00027912-00028095": "beholder and this one's really simple", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00109-00028095-00028287": "you know how the song fades in", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00110-00028288-00028718": "[Music]", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00111-00028719-00029318": "i won't start the riffles like this", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00112-00029319-00029470": "but then when the drum beat started i", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00113-00029472-00029639": "realized it was the other way", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00114-00029639-00029823": "that's all for today but i am gonna make", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00115-00029824-00030039": "a part 2 video because there are many", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00116-00030039-00030270": "many more confusing metallica songs to", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00117-00030272-00030414": "talk about thanks a lot for watching", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00118-00030416-00030518": "please like the video share and", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00119-00030519-00030702": "subscribe to the channel let's get more", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00120-00030703-00030846": "and more subscribers let me turn this", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00121-00030847-00030927": "down", "i8qYmAVl-gy-00122-00030927-00031324": "and i'll see you next time"}}, {"audio_id": "i8ykgpLSP3k", "text": {"i8ykgpLSP3k-00000-00000065-00000332": "did you know trees have been fun growing", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00001-00000333-00000661": "inside of people's lungs hello my name", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00002-00000662-00000833": "is Ferris and I'm here to present my", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00003-00000834-00001070": "dissertation proposal which is titled", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00004-00001071-00001300": "easy hydroponics so what's with the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00005-00001301-00001565": "scary news articles earlier well I", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00006-00001566-00001784": "wanted to show that plants can grow even", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00007-00001785-00001955": "without soil and this is what", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00008-00001955-00002183": "hydroponics is all about the plant is", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00009-00002184-00002312": "suspended in a liquid solution", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00010-00002313-00002531": "containing all the necessary nutrients", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00011-00002532-00002798": "this allows the plants to grow closer to", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00012-00002799-00002963": "each other making it very space", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00013-00002964-00003191": "efficient and although you can't plant", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00014-00003192-00003386": "trees or big plants with hydroponics", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00015-00003386-00003659": "your yield is usually much better than", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00016-00003660-00003878": "normal gardening and this is a big", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00017-00003879-00004088": "advantage in places where land space is", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00018-00004089-00004415": "a premium and with social distancing", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00019-00004416-00004631": "being a big thing now what better time", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00020-00004632-00004844": "to take up gardening right you get to", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00021-00004845-00005036": "have something relaxing to do can", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00022-00005037-00005245": "increase your self-sufficiency and help", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00023-00005246-00005551": "the environment by planting more trees", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00024-00005552-00005801": "but having a home garden that is big", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00025-00005802-00005956": "enough to be useful in Brunei is", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00026-00005957-00006213": "difficult for most people on average", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00027-00006214-00006563": "homeowners own 0.14 acres of land and", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00028-00006564-00006764": "most of that space is covered up by the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00029-00006765-00007067": "house driveway and garage what's left is", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00030-00007068-00007325": "pretty much death so having a garden", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00031-00007326-00007510": "that doesn't need much space would make", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00032-00007511-00007733": "a home garden viable and even on a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00033-00007734-00007834": "national level", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00034-00007836-00008056": "Brunei only has 0.4 percent of its land", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00035-00008058-00008339": "opened up for agriculture this leads to", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00036-00008340-00008599": "my project is it possible to automate", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00037-00008600-00008819": "the labor-intensive parts of hydroponics", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00038-00008820-00009092": "is the hydroponics is a robot that will", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00039-00009093-00009328": "be maintaining the water conditions of a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00040-00009329-00009649": "hydroponic setup namely the water pH the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00041-00009650-00009851": "electrolyte concentration which is how", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00042-00009852-00010030": "much fertilizer is in the water and", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00043-00010031-00010373": "maintaining the water levels the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00044-00010374-00010580": "ultimate aim of easy outro phonics is to", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00045-00010581-00010774": "create a commercially viable product", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00046-00010775-00010934": "which will ultimately promote", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00047-00010935-00011180": "hydroponics in Brunei I'm hoping to", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00048-00011181-00011351": "achieve this by making hydroponics", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00049-00011352-00011531": "easier and more accessible to Bruneian", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00050-00011532-00011770": "farmers by making easy hydroponics easy", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00051-00011771-00012041": "to use and cheap for my dissertation", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00052-00012042-00012349": "project my objectives are to design a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00053-00012350-00012628": "robot to build a robot and website and", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00054-00012629-00012890": "Android app which controls the robot and", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00055-00012891-00013094": "finally to test the system by growing", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00056-00013094-00013269": "cucumbers", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00057-00013269-00013458": "in order to ensure the project stays on", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00058-00013459-00013677": "track I will be setting the following", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00059-00013678-00014007": "scopes I'm using Arduino because it's", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00060-00014008-00014199": "fairly easy to obtain and there's a lot", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00061-00014200-00014361": "of documentation to help guide my", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00062-00014362-00014630": "building and programming I'm using unity", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00063-00014631-00014871": "3d because unity has the potential of", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00064-00014872-00015155": "building the app in iOS and it's also a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00065-00015156-00015380": "powerful engine that allows for easier", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00066-00015381-00015675": "graphics and 3d modeling and finally", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00067-00015676-00015978": "I'll be using asp.net MVC 5 which is the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00068-00015979-00016178": "next-gen of what we learned in previous", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00069-00016179-00016494": "years although I plan to borrow the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00070-00016495-00016713": "rooftop of Laksmana College this might", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00071-00016714-00016947": "need to be changed to my own garage this", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00072-00016948-00017075": "will have the added benefit of", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00073-00017076-00017274": "demonstrating a hydroponics can be", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00074-00017275-00017531": "performed at home I will be using a 1", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00075-00017532-00017744": "meter cube vat of water as a testing bed", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00076-00017745-00017943": "as this is a fair size to have in a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00077-00017944-00018171": "typical household and I will be planting", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00078-00018172-00018336": "here combos for testing as this is a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00079-00018337-00018546": "fast growing plant and doesn't require a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00080-00018547-00018813": "greenhouse environment automating", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00081-00018814-00019094": "hydroponics is not a new concept such a", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00082-00019095-00019305": "famous system is called vez con and is", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00083-00019306-00019410": "fully automated", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00084-00019411-00019631": "this system controls everything but", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00085-00019632-00019833": "costs millions of US dollars and took", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00086-00019834-00020055": "many years to develop on a smaller scale", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00087-00020056-00020286": "is the hydro bot this Kickstarter is", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00088-00020287-00020555": "similar to easy hydroponics however each", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00089-00020556-00020825": "of this units costs between 600 to 900", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00090-00020826-00021071": "u.s. dollars which is still quite pricy", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00091-00021072-00021342": "hyderabad seems to have been developed", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00092-00021343-00021537": "in less than a year therefore it should", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00093-00021538-00021687": "be possible to complete my project", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00094-00021688-00021953": "within a timeframe of 8 months a big", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00095-00021954-00022092": "concern is whether or not the system", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00096-00022093-00022347": "would actually be useful especially says", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00097-00022348-00022559": "that it is sufficient currently in", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00098-00022560-00022778": "Brunei industrial hydroponic farmers", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00099-00022779-00023028": "maintain water conditions manually which", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00100-00023029-00023337": "is labour heavy thus by using my system", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00101-00023338-00023534": "this burden can be reduced and they are", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00102-00023535-00023771": "able to expand their operations unless", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00103-00023772-00023981": "mentioned earlier although there are", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00104-00023982-00024225": "several systems already for automating", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00105-00024226-00024497": "hydroponics they're quite expensive one", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00106-00024498-00024719": "would expect such first system could be", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00107-00024720-00024900": "acquired cheaply from China but", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00108-00024901-00025053": "unfortunately I couldn't find anything", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00109-00025054-00025365": "online as eight months is rather short", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00110-00025366-00025605": "for a project of this size I am electing", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00111-00025606-00025842": "to use an agile approach the project", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00112-00025843-00026055": "will be divided into 10 major sprints", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00113-00026056-00026189": "corresponding to the following", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00114-00026190-00026454": "milestones here is the projected", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00115-00026455-00026673": "timeline the estimated project", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00116-00026674-00026961": "thirty weeks I should not hear that each", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00117-00026962-00027164": "sprint is expected to last two to three", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00118-00027166-00027402": "weeks except for testing which takes up", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00119-00027402-00027705": "to 15 weeks the main limitation I", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00120-00027706-00027861": "predict are the time constraints", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00121-00027862-00028074": "monetary constraints and technical", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00122-00028075-00028355": "constraints assisting depends on growing", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00123-00028356-00028568": "actual crops this might take longer than", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00124-00028569-00028737": "expected and would affect the final", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00125-00028738-00028962": "testing sprint and since I'm working", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00126-00028963-00029180": "alone and have no prior experience", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00127-00029181-00029429": "I might take more time than expected and", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00128-00029430-00029765": "finally financially I will not be able", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00129-00029766-00029948": "to afford professional grade materials", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00130-00029949-00030215": "in conclusion although there are several", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00131-00030216-00030449": "limitations having to work on the budget", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00132-00030450-00030651": "can be seen as an advantage as the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00133-00030652-00030867": "system is meant to be cheap and with the", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00134-00030868-00031110": "potential of hydroponics in Brunei it is", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00135-00031111-00031343": "quite practical and would be in demand", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00136-00031344-00031614": "for further queries please contact me", "i8ykgpLSP3k-00137-00031614-00032094": "via Emma's teams thank you for listening"}}, {"audio_id": "i8MKKVyK4Hc", "text": {"i8MKKVyK4Hc-00000-00000042-00000343": "foreign", "i8MKKVyK4Hc-00001-00000344-00001620": "[Music]", "i8MKKVyK4Hc-00002-00001621-00002309": "[Music]", "i8MKKVyK4Hc-00003-00002310-00002631": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i8Qm3t_Pf3c", "text": {"i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00000-00000000-00000320": "ah", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00001-00000321-00002965": "[Laughter]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00002-00002966-00003329": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00003-00003329-00004006": "um", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00004-00004007-00004277": "look there's so many religions", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00005-00004278-00004751": "and every person has to ask God where", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00006-00004752-00004991": "are you which is the right way", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00007-00004992-00005315": "every person because so many religions", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00008-00005316-00005627": "everyone says oh yeah uh", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00009-00005628-00005884": "we have this you know we know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00010-00005885-00006220": "but religion is like tradition yeah", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00011-00006221-00006587": "you know it's um", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00012-00006588-00006910": "it's like tradition it's not", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00013-00006911-00007098": "there's no God in it", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00014-00007100-00007409": "you know what I mean God is God is not", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00015-00007409-00007673": "not in a religion not in Muslim not in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00016-00007673-00007919": "Catholic not in Buddhist", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00017-00007920-00008209": "capiche", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00018-00008210-00008537": "it's always", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00019-00008538-00009306": "getting every religion so inside", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00020-00009307-00009539": "you know so different", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00021-00009540-00009869": "different sector you know once upon a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00022-00009870-00010151": "time I asked God I said where are you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00023-00010152-00010349": "where is the truth", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00024-00010350-00010621": "where is the right way", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00025-00010622-00010973": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00026-00010974-00011175": "foreign", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00027-00011176-00011453": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00028-00011454-00011573": "[Applause]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00029-00011574-00013855": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00030-00013856-00014015": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00031-00014016-00014255": "foreign", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00032-00014256-00015841": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00033-00015843-00016446": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00034-00016447-00017403": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00035-00017404-00017657": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00036-00017658-00017903": "foreign", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00037-00017904-00017930": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00038-00017931-00018197": "[Applause]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00039-00018198-00018775": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00040-00018776-00018971": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00041-00018972-00019536": "we are in a Turkish city of Antalya", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00042-00019537-00019805": "where Apostle Paul", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00043-00019806-00020225": "also was here yes 2 000 years ago 2000", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00044-00020226-00020383": "years ago", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00045-00020384-00020891": "ramazan is a pastor of a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00046-00020892-00021205": "Protestant Church yes", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00047-00021206-00021605": "Turkish church and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00048-00021606-00021886": "um I think it's the Omni Turkish", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00049-00021887-00022019": "Christian Church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00050-00022020-00022319": "in this town there is a couple of other", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00051-00022320-00022547": "ones too but they are more like small", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00052-00022548-00022933": "churches Turkish churches okay", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00053-00022934-00023158": "we've just been talking a moment ago", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00054-00023159-00023447": "about the fact that everyone thinks that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00055-00023448-00023705": "Christianity started from maybe Europe", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00056-00023706-00024011": "but they actually started from this area", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00057-00024012-00024203": "the area of Turkey", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00058-00024204-00024455": "yes yes when we look at the Bible", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00059-00024456-00024689": "actually we see that Apostle Paul and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00060-00024690-00025133": "barnaba yes started a lot of churches in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00061-00025134-00025541": "Turkey 2000 years ago actually when you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00062-00025542-00025696": "look at the history you see that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00063-00025697-00026027": "Christianity is spread and grow from the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00064-00026027-00026345": "internet of turkey yes and that's the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00065-00026345-00026681": "truth you know but in Turkey many", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00066-00026682-00026890": "Turkish people they don't know the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00067-00026891-00027151": "history okay they don't know this", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00068-00027152-00027461": "information and they think that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00069-00027462-00027658": "Christianity is a more like a western", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00070-00027660-00027946": "religion okay and in Turkey there is", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00071-00027947-00028187": "this mindset that you know if you were a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00072-00028188-00028481": "turd you're supposed to be a Muslim you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00073-00028482-00028824": "know and if you're a western person", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00074-00028825-00029081": "European person you're supposed to be a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00075-00029082-00029333": "Christian because they look at the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00076-00029333-00029507": "Christianity kind of like the Western", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00077-00029508-00029812": "religion you know but actually that's", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00078-00029813-00030089": "not the truth and that's why you know in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00079-00030089-00030473": "Turkey if you come and visit as a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00080-00030474-00030779": "tourist you know from Europe they will", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00081-00030780-00030989": "accept you as a Christian and they will", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00082-00030989-00031295": "show you great hospitality and respect", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00083-00031295-00031558": "to you even that they know that you're a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00084-00031560-00031931": "Christian you know because that's who", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00085-00031932-00032183": "it's you supposed to be you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00086-00032183-00032458": "but if you are", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00087-00032460-00032818": "jerk and coming from Islamic background", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00088-00032819-00033029": "to Christ", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00089-00033030-00033262": "and if you're a Christian from the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00090-00033263-00033605": "Islamic background you know then you're", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00091-00033606-00033971": "treated you know and you betrayed your", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00092-00033972-00034218": "country you betrayed your culture and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00093-00034219-00034685": "you are brainwashed and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00094-00034686-00035111": "you reject your heritage and the culture", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00095-00035112-00035483": "then they treat you as a Trader you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00096-00035484-00035740": "that they don't respect you that you are", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00097-00035741-00036133": "a Christian okay and what are the main", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00098-00036134-00036389": "misconceptions they have Turkish people", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00099-00036390-00036646": "have about Christians you said that they", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00100-00036647-00036935": "think that they drink alcohol there's a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00101-00036936-00037295": "lot and like there is a logical cultural", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00102-00037296-00037535": "and historical misinformation for", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00103-00037536-00037762": "example the theological misinformation", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00104-00037763-00038129": "is they think that you know Bible has", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00105-00038130-00038387": "been changed you know and it's not", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00106-00038388-00038962": "trustworthy anymore and yeah and also uh", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00107-00038963-00039202": "they think that Christians believe in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00108-00039203-00039496": "between Gods you know and they can't", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00109-00039497-00039821": "understand the concept of Trinity you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00110-00039822-00040217": "know and they think that Christian has", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00111-00040218-00040517": "to go to priest to repent", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00112-00040518-00040680": "you know the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00113-00040681-00040955": "same and there is a lot of", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00114-00040956-00041171": "misinformation and also they think that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00115-00041172-00041608": "it's okay to sleep with anyone you want", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00116-00041609-00041740": "you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00117-00041741-00042023": "because they are most of them they are", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00118-00042024-00042208": "learning the Christianity from the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00119-00042209-00042502": "Islamic society which in Islamic society", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00120-00042503-00042802": "and the TV many Islamic leaders or", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00121-00042803-00043007": "nationalist leaders they spoke up", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00122-00043008-00043357": "against Christians they spoke they don't", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00123-00043358-00043612": "tell the truth about the Christianity", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00124-00043613-00043883": "what we believe and they represent", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00125-00043884-00044161": "really bad about us you know and then", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00126-00044162-00044501": "also they see a lot of tourists coming", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00127-00044502-00044849": "from Europe and they have like you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00128-00044850-00045137": "they sleep with many people and they can", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00129-00045138-00045395": "cross on their neck and then they do a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00130-00045396-00045649": "lot of crazy okay you know celebration", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00131-00045650-00046037": "drugs and stuff like that and then and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00132-00046038-00046301": "also they look at the movies and they", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00133-00046302-00046499": "see all these like Hollywood movies that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00134-00046500-00046690": "people has crossed on their neck and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00135-00046691-00047207": "then they you know uh make porn and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00136-00047208-00047530": "things like that you know and that's why", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00137-00047531-00047735": "they are learning the Christian", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00138-00047736-00048040": "narrative from those kind of things yes", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00139-00048041-00048395": "and those are not the right resources to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00140-00048396-00048743": "them you know and then they think that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00141-00048744-00048996": "Christianity is a immoral", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00142-00048997-00049546": "and bad culture you know and that's why", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00143-00049547-00049873": "they don't believe anything", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00144-00049874-00050230": "and a lot of misinformation", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00145-00050231-00050446": "and the government is using this", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00146-00050447-00050621": "information right it's not the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00147-00050622-00050812": "government I I would not say the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00148-00050813-00051167": "government but the people that who has", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00149-00051168-00051400": "power on", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00150-00051401-00051749": "you know Society they go up to the TV", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00151-00051750-00052049": "and some programs that they tell all", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00152-00052050-00052308": "these lies to people about Christians", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00153-00052309-00052630": "but those are not the truth that we", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00154-00052632-00052879": "believe okay and that's why actually", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00155-00052879-00053200": "like when people come and visit our", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00156-00053201-00053311": "church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00157-00053312-00053537": "sometimes people come with different", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00158-00053538-00053938": "expectations you know and then when they", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00159-00053939-00054125": "come to the church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00160-00054126-00054388": "and then when they start talking with us", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00161-00054389-00054832": "and you know when they is start getting", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00162-00054833-00055199": "to or getting to know us", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00163-00055200-00055535": "than their ideas change okay and then", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00164-00055536-00055757": "most of the people wow you believe like", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00165-00055758-00056057": "this oh you are like this you know okay", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00166-00056058-00056261": "and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00167-00056262-00056573": "interesting", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00168-00056574-00056915": "now what's the population of turkey and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00169-00056916-00057232": "what's the population of Christians in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00170-00057233-00057491": "Turkey now the population of Turkey is", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00171-00057491-00057887": "85 million 99 of the population are", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00172-00057888-00058049": "muslim okay", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00173-00058050-00058513": "and the Turkish Christians we are about", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00174-00058514-00059053": "seven to eight thousand jokes", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00175-00059054-00059561": "80 million 85 million 85 million and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00176-00059562-00059813": "only seven to eight thousand Christians", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00177-00059814-00060203": "that's amazing it's shocking", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00178-00060204-00060497": "yeah but you know the Turkish Church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00179-00060498-00060826": "actually this is better because when you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00180-00060827-00061138": "look at the history 50 years ago there", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00181-00061139-00061385": "was no Turkish Christians there was no", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00182-00061386-00061775": "Turkish churches in Turkey but some", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00183-00061776-00062044": "people came to Christ at that time and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00184-00062045-00062309": "Faithfully they shared their life and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00185-00062310-00062513": "faith with others", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00186-00062514-00062735": "and then some people became a Christian", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00187-00062736-00062963": "and then Turkish Church started you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00188-00062964-00063382": "and now uh there's seven or eight", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00189-00063383-00063611": "thousand Turkish Believers in the whole", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00190-00063612-00063899": "country it's better than 50 years ago", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00191-00063900-00064187": "and I believe that you know it's kind of", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00192-00064188-00064463": "like uh same like the Bible you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00193-00064464-00064711": "when you look at the biblical time", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00194-00064712-00065116": "uh when Paul and barnaba you know when", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00195-00065117-00065338": "they came to this land there was nothing", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00196-00065339-00065579": "at that time yes and then they shared", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00197-00065580-00065794": "the gospel people came to Christ they", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00198-00065795-00066100": "started churches and before the Roman", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00199-00066101-00066353": "Empire accepted Christianity the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00200-00066354-00066659": "churches in this land it was like small", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00201-00066660-00066905": "house churches you know like what we", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00202-00066906-00067235": "have now sure but then look what God did", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00203-00067236-00067463": "two thousand years ago and he can do it", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00204-00067464-00067805": "once again now yes that's great now um", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00205-00067806-00068026": "Rams and told me about persecution you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00206-00068027-00068225": "said that you knew some people that were", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00207-00068226-00068350": "actually killed", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00208-00068351-00068759": "for day five like turkey is a Democrat", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00209-00068760-00069005": "and secular country according to law we", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00210-00069006-00069256": "have freedom to believe what we want to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00211-00069257-00069538": "believe and also we have freedom to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00212-00069539-00069773": "share our faith with others on the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00213-00069774-00070067": "people you know but those rights are not", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00214-00070068-00070463": "really supported by a society very much", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00215-00070464-00070649": "because there is a lot of people that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00216-00070650-00070813": "they don't like", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00217-00070814-00071221": "uh Christians or the churches", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00218-00071222-00071465": "and uh", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00219-00071466-00071687": "like we are", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00220-00071688-00071999": "according to law we have freedom to go", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00221-00072000-00072329": "out and do open evangelism you know but", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00222-00072330-00072544": "when you do that you will face some", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00223-00072545-00072838": "difficulties that they will stop you and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00224-00072839-00073132": "then uh like if you compare to turkey", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00225-00073133-00073553": "with Europe you know we are so short you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00226-00073554-00073829": "know for our democracy you know but if", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00227-00073830-00074056": "you compare turkey to other Middle", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00228-00074057-00074356": "Eastern countries Afghanistan Iran you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00229-00074357-00074543": "know we have so much Freedom as a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00230-00074544-00074806": "Christian here you know we can still go", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00231-00074807-00075005": "and share the gospel with people you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00232-00075006-00075155": "know and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00233-00075156-00075359": "yes like", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00234-00075360-00075737": "we have some difficulties we don't like", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00235-00075738-00076079": "for a common persecution that most of", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00236-00076080-00076361": "the Christians face in Turkey when they", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00237-00076362-00076523": "come to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00238-00076524-00076715": "believe Jesus", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00239-00076716-00076955": "most of them they've been reject by", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00240-00076956-00077194": "their own family okay you know and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00241-00077195-00077494": "because family look at them as a treaty", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00242-00077495-00077915": "you know and also Turkish culture is", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00243-00077916-00078149": "more like an honor and shame culture and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00244-00078150-00078394": "when you became a Christian you became", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00245-00078395-00078688": "your brain actually shame on your family", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00246-00078689-00078923": "and that's why they reject you you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00247-00078924-00079211": "and it did not happen to me my all my", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00248-00079212-00079421": "relatives and friends they rejected me", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00249-00079422-00079673": "after I became a Christian but I still", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00250-00079674-00080026": "have a relationship with my mom and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00251-00080027-00080279": "sister stay longer and I love them we", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00252-00080280-00080431": "have a good relationship", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00253-00080432-00080776": "no but most of the people in my church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00254-00080777-00081023": "they've been rejected even by their own", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00255-00081024-00081221": "family you know after they come to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00256-00081222-00081503": "Christ and then you might lose your job", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00257-00081504-00081941": "you know and it's really hard to find a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00258-00081942-00082165": "job as a Christian", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00259-00082166-00082517": "and sometimes you know not all the time", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00260-00082518-00082715": "but sometimes the country change", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00261-00082716-00083075": "something changing the country and in in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00262-00083076-00083435": "those chaos time like there's a lot of", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00263-00083436-00083675": "outside group religious organizational", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00264-00083676-00083909": "spirit that sometimes they take", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00265-00083910-00084112": "advantage of the situation and they", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00266-00084113-00084323": "attack the churches and the Christians", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00267-00084324-00084665": "in the past we lost some of our brothers", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00268-00084666-00084955": "and sisters you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00269-00084956-00085229": "got killed because of they were a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00270-00085230-00085529": "Christian you know but they don't yeah", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00271-00085530-00085738": "but they don't kill us every day you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00272-00085739-00086011": "know we have you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00273-00086012-00086350": "uh still in a good shape when you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00274-00086351-00086567": "compare turkey to other Middle Eastern", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00275-00086568-00086753": "countries and you personally had some", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00276-00086754-00087161": "threats as well yeah in the past like a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00277-00087162-00087406": "lot of people threatening me and many", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00278-00087407-00087875": "times and also a couple times I had a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00279-00087876-00087947": "life", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00280-00087948-00088325": "tracking situation and one of the person", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00281-00088326-00088800": "in 2008 he came to our Christmas service", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00282-00088801-00089206": "to assassinate me you know and but the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00283-00089207-00089494": "police catch him okay and they put him", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00284-00089495-00089837": "in the jail because every service that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00285-00089838-00089941": "we have", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00286-00089942-00090203": "in our church we have the police", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00287-00090204-00090473": "protection okay and because the police", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00288-00090474-00090673": "doesn't yeah", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00289-00090674-00091006": "yes you have police outside yes yeah", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00290-00091007-00091282": "because they are trying to protect the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00291-00091283-00091553": "Christians because if something happened", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00292-00091554-00091705": "to Christians", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00293-00091706-00092159": "might affect the turkey reputation for", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00294-00092160-00092382": "tourism and the other things", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00295-00092383-00092779": "and that's why they protect us okay", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00296-00092780-00092968": "yeah okay", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00297-00092969-00093250": "and how did you come to Christ what", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00298-00093251-00093473": "happened I grew up in a Muslim family", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00299-00093474-00093917": "and I believed in Islam many years but I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00300-00093918-00094303": "did not search Islam about uh by myself", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00301-00094304-00094717": "I did not read the Quran or I did not", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00302-00094718-00094979": "you know research by myself I just", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00303-00094980-00095231": "didn't believe what people taught me", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00304-00095232-00095543": "about my case you know and I believed in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00305-00095544-00095776": "Islam like that I was a very devoided", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00306-00095777-00096256": "Muslim and then uh One Day end of my", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00307-00096257-00096532": "school I had friends that they were", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00308-00096533-00096923": "dazed and atheist and then I when I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00309-00096924-00097091": "spent time with them they told me that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00310-00097092-00097282": "there is a lot of contradiction in the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00311-00097283-00097481": "Quran there's a lot of wrong things", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00312-00097482-00097823": "about Islam and then what they told me", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00313-00097824-00098074": "about Islam it brought lots of questions", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00314-00098075-00098488": "and doubts to me and I thought that if I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00315-00098489-00098788": "read the Quran the Quran will give", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00316-00098789-00099023": "answers to all my questions and now", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00317-00099024-00099323": "okay and but after I read the Quran the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00318-00099324-00099479": "opposite happened", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00319-00099480-00099832": "and I had more questions and more doubts", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00320-00099833-00100193": "and I asked those questions to my", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00321-00100194-00100379": "spiritual leaders they gave me answers", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00322-00100380-00100643": "but those answers did not satisfy me and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00323-00100644-00100762": "then", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00324-00100763-00101068": "I read different books about Islam that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00325-00101069-00101356": "it's it was criticizing Islam and then", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00326-00101357-00101573": "related by little I lost my faith in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00327-00101574-00101831": "Islam and I became a deist like my", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00328-00101832-00102065": "friends you know during that time my", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00329-00102066-00102329": "lifestyle changed a lot I had a very", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00330-00102330-00102694": "simple life and then I was working at", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00331-00102695-00102994": "one company and when I was working there", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00332-00102995-00103258": "I met a guy that we became a very good", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00333-00103259-00103492": "friends each other one day he told me", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00334-00103493-00103708": "that he's a Christian and he was a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00335-00103709-00103936": "Turkish guy and became a Christian", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00336-00103938-00104092": "leader you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00337-00104093-00104273": "and he told me that he's a Christian", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00338-00104274-00104536": "when he said that that was the first", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00339-00104538-00104680": "time I met", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00340-00104681-00105004": "Christians you know and we start to talk", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00341-00105005-00105310": "about religion and he told me I did not", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00342-00105311-00105604": "like it actually his attitude he told me", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00343-00105605-00105827": "that Christianity is right all the other", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00344-00105828-00106073": "religions are wrong you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00345-00106074-00106331": "and then I kind of got angry to him and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00346-00106332-00106636": "I wanted to show him that Christianity", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00347-00106638-00106865": "is wrong too and I started telling him", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00348-00106866-00107128": "all these like things that I learned", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00349-00107129-00107375": "from my Society about Christianity and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00350-00107376-00107554": "then he told me no we don't believe like", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00351-00107555-00107771": "that look this is what the Bible says no", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00352-00107772-00107945": "we don't believe like that this is what", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00353-00107946-00108166": "the Bible says and then I thought you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00354-00108167-00108449": "know I I hate like losing the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00355-00108450-00108577": "conversation", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00356-00108578-00108952": "and then I thought okay if I study the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00357-00108953-00109258": "Bible you know maybe I can show him that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00358-00109259-00109433": "his faith is wrong too yeah you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00359-00109433-00109702": "that's why I got Bible from him and then", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00360-00109703-00110015": "I started read the Bible and we talk a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00361-00110016-00110249": "lot yeah and then one day he invited me", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00362-00110250-00110383": "to the church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00363-00110383-00110686": "I told him okay I can come but when I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00364-00110688-00110897": "said that my goal", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00365-00110898-00111125": "wasn't searching about Christians or", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00366-00111126-00111316": "learning about Jesus I thought that if I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00367-00111317-00111563": "go to church maybe I can match with some", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00368-00111564-00111802": "girls you know because I was very young", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00369-00111803-00112043": "and my brain was working only for that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00370-00112044-00112204": "reason and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00371-00112205-00112577": "and also we learn from society that you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00372-00112578-00112834": "know Christian Girls Are Easy you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00373-00112835-00113063": "and that's why I went to church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00374-00113064-00113302": "but when I went to church I thought that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00375-00113303-00113507": "we were going to go to some church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00376-00113508-00113758": "building but it took me to the somehow", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00377-00113759-00114010": "or some people's house because at that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00378-00114011-00114299": "time they were they were a house Church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00379-00114300-00114436": "and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00380-00114438-00114815": "and what I went into the house and I saw", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00381-00114816-00115134": "like 10 15 people", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00382-00115135-00115397": "and they were all like families there", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00383-00115398-00115649": "was no girls like my age you know and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00384-00115650-00116002": "then I thought like oh I cannot reach", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00385-00116003-00116273": "out my goal here you know but I stayed", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00386-00116274-00116501": "and I really like that the relationship", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00387-00116502-00116843": "each other how they worshiped God it was", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00388-00116844-00117071": "very different and unusual", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00389-00117072-00117340": "it touched my heart but I did not", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00390-00117341-00117839": "believe and then I went to church uh", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00391-00117840-00118036": "following weeks again and then in other", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00392-00118038-00118223": "weeks again and then in other weeks", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00393-00118224-00118289": "again", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00394-00118290-00118510": "I went to church basically two and a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00395-00118511-00118702": "half years without believing Jesus", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00396-00118703-00118895": "Christ but every time when I went to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00397-00118896-00118984": "church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00398-00118985-00119236": "I learned something about Christianity I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00399-00119238-00119383": "learned something", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00400-00119383-00119699": "something about Jesus you know but", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00401-00119700-00119951": "nothing worked in my heart until I went", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00402-00119952-00120221": "to the military and when I went with", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00403-00120222-00120431": "Europe you have to go to Mediterranean", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00404-00120432-00120658": "when I went to military I had a really", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00405-00120659-00120947": "big depression okay", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00406-00120948-00121054": "um", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00407-00121055-00121336": "I was so like", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00408-00121338-00121723": "feeling bad and I didn't know what to do", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00409-00121724-00122051": "and I had a lot of crazy thoughts one", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00410-00122052-00122214": "night when I had a night Duty", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00411-00122215-00122339": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00412-00122340-00122584": "and I started to remember", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00413-00122585-00122933": "a lot of verses from the Bible you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00414-00122933-00123154": "that I learned from the church two and a", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00415-00123155-00123304": "half years you know", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00416-00123305-00123527": "and then first time in my life that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00417-00123528-00123875": "night I felt that God presence near to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00418-00123876-00124157": "me I felt like Jesus was talking to me", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00419-00124158-00124373": "with those verses", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00420-00124374-00124678": "and I understood that that was God and I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00421-00124679-00124936": "just fell down and I opened my heart and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00422-00124938-00125183": "I gave my life to Jesus", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00423-00125183-00125590": "I accept my Lord and Savior you know and", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00424-00125591-00125801": "after that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00425-00125802-00126052": "my life started to change my goals", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00426-00126053-00126293": "started to change you know and then I", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00427-00126294-00126586": "came to the church and I got baptized", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00428-00126588-00126949": "and then I was working for one company", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00429-00126950-00127319": "and but also doing some volunteer work", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00430-00127320-00127493": "for the church", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00431-00127494-00127769": "I really liked it as I did those", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00432-00127770-00128104": "volunteer work and then I thought God is", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00433-00128105-00128375": "calling me to do something Ministry you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00434-00128376-00128789": "know and then I share my desire to my", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00435-00128790-00128986": "spiritual leader in the church and then", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00436-00128988-00129366": "they started training me yeah and then", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00437-00129367-00129784": "yeah I became a pastor in this church in", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00438-00129785-00130181": "2001 and since then I am pastoring this", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00439-00130182-00130421": "church our church is there kind of like", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00440-00130422-00130602": "Turkish Church yeah", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00441-00130603-00131093": "we are worshiped in Turkish and most of", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00442-00131094-00131278": "the people in my church they are coming", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00443-00131279-00131590": "to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00444-00131591-00131737": "Christ", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00445-00131738-00132221": "and Islamic background it's like me yeah", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00446-00132222-00132485": "amazing", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00447-00132486-00132725": "thank you so much for this and I just", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00448-00132726-00133019": "wanted to have this conversation just to", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00449-00133020-00133349": "share with everyone in Poland a little", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00450-00133350-00133697": "bit on on the Turkish church and on the", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00451-00133698-00133985": "situation here so thank you for that", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00452-00133986-00134799": "short interview", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00453-00134800-00135066": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00454-00135067-00135562": "come home", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00455-00135563-00136115": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00456-00136116-00137231": "[Applause]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00457-00137232-00137635": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00458-00137636-00138083": "[Applause]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00459-00138084-00138588": "louder", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00460-00138589-00139147": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00461-00139148-00139988": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00462-00139989-00141228": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00463-00141229-00141558": "thank you", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00464-00141559-00141683": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00465-00141684-00141999": "foreign", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00466-00142000-00142492": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00467-00142493-00142632": "[Applause]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00468-00142633-00143196": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00469-00143197-00143770": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00470-00143771-00145654": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00471-00145655-00146022": "foreign", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00472-00146023-00146622": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00473-00146623-00148003": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00474-00148004-00148662": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00475-00148663-00149104": "[Music]", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00476-00149105-00150387": "foreign", "i8Qm3t_Pf3c-00477-00150388-00150659": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "i8a4lT0rS2U", "text": {"i8a4lT0rS2U-00000-00000114-00000919": "[Music]", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00001-00000919-00001428": "hmm", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00002-00001429-00002183": "[Music]", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00003-00002184-00002942": "so", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00004-00002943-00008342": "[Music]", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00005-00008343-00010567": "foreign", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00006-00010568-00014583": "foreign", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00007-00014584-00018214": "okay", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00008-00018215-00022422": "the", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00009-00022423-00023622": "hold on", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00010-00023623-00026462": "here", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00011-00026463-00034096": "foreign", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00012-00034097-00035046": "[Applause]", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00013-00035047-00036174": "foreign", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00014-00036175-00048812": "um", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00015-00048813-00048983": "[Music]", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00016-00048984-00052202": "foreign", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00017-00052203-00055863": "[Music]", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00018-00055864-00061254": "foreign", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00019-00061255-00062615": "videos", "i8a4lT0rS2U-00020-00062616-00062824": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i99YukVcsgM", "text": {"i99YukVcsgM-00000-00000000-00005098": "[Music]", "i99YukVcsgM-00001-00005099-00006439": "[Music]", "i99YukVcsgM-00002-00006440-00006616": "so", "i99YukVcsgM-00003-00006617-00008574": "[Music]", "i99YukVcsgM-00004-00008575-00010142": "[Music]", "i99YukVcsgM-00005-00010143-00011551": "[Music]", "i99YukVcsgM-00006-00011552-00012383": "[Music]", "i99YukVcsgM-00007-00012384-00012592": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "i9kdgVQjEK4", "text": {"i9kdgVQjEK4-00000-00000084-00002884": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00001-00002885-00003461": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00002-00003461-00006245": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00003-00006246-00007084": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00004-00007086-00010277": "made me do it", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00005-00010278-00013301": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00006-00013302-00016553": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00007-00016554-00019589": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00008-00020268-00022744": "nogama", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00009-00022745-00025889": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00010-00025889-00028985": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00011-00028986-00032033": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00012-00032033-00035009": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00013-00035010-00035537": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00014-00035538-00038449": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00015-00038450-00038621": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00016-00038622-00039587": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00017-00039588-00041609": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00018-00041610-00042338": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00019-00042339-00044933": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00020-00044934-00048599": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00021-00048600-00050907": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00022-00050908-00051701": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00023-00051702-00054725": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00024-00054726-00057754": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00025-00057755-00060923": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00026-00060924-00063713": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00027-00063714-00064403": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00028-00064404-00067276": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00029-00067277-00070541": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00030-00070542-00071969": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00031-00071970-00073573": "yesterday", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00032-00073574-00076537": "edelwe a general", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00033-00076538-00076691": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00034-00076692-00079859": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00035-00079860-00083165": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00036-00083166-00086212": "to Drinker I chose", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00037-00086213-00089279": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00038-00089280-00092123": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00039-00092124-00092573": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00040-00092574-00092843": "the Wawa", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00041-00092844-00093256": "maybe say beauty", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00042-00093257-00095555": "to be New Year tomorrow", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00043-00095556-00098471": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00044-00098472-00099671": "important", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00045-00099672-00102616": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00046-00102617-00102916": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00047-00102917-00105821": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00048-00105822-00106277": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00049-00106278-00109297": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00050-00109298-00112439": "foreign foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00051-00112440-00112613": "now so may", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00052-00112614-00113308": "be busy", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00053-00113309-00113597": "later", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00054-00113598-00114310": "is", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00055-00114311-00114899": "no Soma", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00056-00114900-00115277": "the", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00057-00115278-00115510": "um", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00058-00115511-00118721": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00059-00118722-00121804": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00060-00121805-00122177": "silicone", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00061-00122178-00122554": "Eric", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00062-00122555-00125249": "Legos", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00063-00125250-00128890": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00064-00128891-00131975": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00065-00131976-00135635": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00066-00135636-00138802": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00067-00138803-00138961": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00068-00138962-00141761": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00069-00141762-00142673": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00070-00142674-00145931": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00071-00145932-00149309": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00072-00149310-00152149": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00073-00152150-00154871": "foreign foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00074-00154872-00155681": "so much", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00075-00155682-00158999": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00076-00159000-00162143": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00077-00162144-00165175": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00078-00165176-00165371": "in it", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00079-00165372-00165545": "Karma", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00080-00165546-00166259": "mama said", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00081-00166260-00168652": "hello", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00082-00168653-00171749": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00083-00171750-00174959": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00084-00174960-00177502": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00085-00177503-00178175": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00086-00178176-00180251": "Taylor horror this is", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00087-00180252-00180401": "the", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00088-00180402-00181564": "yes", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00089-00181565-00184799": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00090-00184800-00185069": "yes see", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00091-00185070-00186466": "yes", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00092-00186467-00187745": "it is", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00093-00187746-00188147": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00094-00188148-00191087": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00095-00191088-00191393": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00096-00191394-00194495": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00097-00194496-00195083": "Argentina", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00098-00195084-00195540": "Beach", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00099-00195541-00196666": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00100-00196667-00197633": "ES", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00101-00197634-00200357": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00102-00200358-00200525": "any new", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00103-00200526-00200831": "Sita", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00104-00200832-00204047": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00105-00204048-00207005": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00106-00207006-00210532": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00107-00210533-00213653": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00108-00213654-00216665": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00109-00216666-00219834": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00110-00219835-00222784": "foreign foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00111-00222785-00223210": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00112-00223211-00225964": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00113-00225965-00226542": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00114-00226544-00226805": "yes he moved", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00115-00226806-00228646": "solution", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00116-00228648-00230051": "is", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00117-00230052-00231106": "materialists", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00118-00231107-00231227": "no", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00119-00231228-00231508": "90 young logo", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00120-00231509-00231798": "development", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00121-00231798-00232529": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00122-00232530-00233075": "amazing", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00123-00233076-00233705": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00124-00233706-00236182": "[Music]", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00125-00236183-00239051": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00126-00239052-00239884": "absolutely", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00127-00239885-00242813": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00128-00242814-00245296": "located", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00129-00245298-00246719": "alone", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00130-00246719-00249694": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00131-00249696-00250355": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00132-00250356-00253096": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00133-00253098-00253439": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00134-00253440-00256096": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00135-00256098-00256546": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00136-00256548-00259265": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00137-00259266-00260284": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00138-00260285-00263351": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00139-00263352-00266339": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00140-00266340-00266710": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00141-00266711-00269525": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00142-00269526-00270149": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00143-00270150-00270401": "jacuzzi", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00144-00270402-00272753": "pet holidays", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00145-00272754-00273125": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00146-00273126-00276358": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00147-00276359-00279275": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00148-00279276-00279605": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00149-00279606-00281393": "Simeon", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00150-00281394-00281741": "yudhiana", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00151-00281742-00282329": "being", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00152-00282330-00282953": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00153-00282954-00285934": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00154-00285935-00286289": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00155-00286290-00288893": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00156-00288894-00290482": "foreign", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00157-00290483-00291934": "hello", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00158-00291935-00293543": "everybody", "i9kdgVQjEK4-00159-00293544-00293792": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "i9_0kT3Glio", "text": {"i9_0kT3Glio-00000-00000131-00000263": "foreign", "i9_0kT3Glio-00001-00000264-00001175": "[Music]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00002-00001176-00001331": "everybody", "i9_0kT3Glio-00003-00001332-00001612": "my lovely lovely imps", "i9_0kT3Glio-00004-00001613-00001852": "regarding", "i9_0kT3Glio-00005-00001853-00002387": "a a a discourse that you rap scallions", "i9_0kT3Glio-00006-00002388-00002784": "have spawned all across the internet", "i9_0kT3Glio-00007-00002785-00003107": "uh uh we're going to be talking a little", "i9_0kT3Glio-00008-00003108-00003688": "bit today about the word [__] uh as", "i9_0kT3Glio-00009-00003689-00004613": "many of you know uh uh I am [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00010-00004614-00004756": "that's it that's the segment everybody", "i9_0kT3Glio-00011-00004757-00004961": "there you go all right everybody it was", "i9_0kT3Glio-00012-00004962-00005201": "a great stream tonight uh and I'll I'll", "i9_0kT3Glio-00013-00005202-00005369": "see you all very soon don't forget to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00014-00005370-00005620": "press the like button uh don't forget to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00015-00005621-00005933": "uh press subscribe you guys uh thank you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00016-00005934-00006088": "for being here and for supporting me but", "i9_0kT3Glio-00017-00006089-00006263": "uh no I'm just kidding and that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00018-00006264-00006460": "actually not the end of the segment", "i9_0kT3Glio-00019-00006461-00006701": "um but but let's be real here for a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00020-00006702-00006941": "second okay uh this the stream title is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00021-00006942-00007210": "is [__] okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00022-00007211-00007396": "um there's been a lot of discourse about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00023-00007397-00007720": "this particular word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00024-00007722-00007984": "um uh on the internet lately and I want", "i9_0kT3Glio-00025-00007986-00008123": "to talk about it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00026-00008123-00008369": "um so I want to I want to kind of do a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00027-00008370-00008645": "little bit of of ID pull here okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00028-00008646-00008807": "uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00029-00008808-00009292": "I was called a [__] my entire life for", "i9_0kT3Glio-00030-00009293-00009545": "various reasons um I was never in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00031-00009546-00009809": "special ed when I was uh in school", "i9_0kT3Glio-00032-00009810-00010169": "um although I was put into so-called", "i9_0kT3Glio-00033-00010170-00010391": "gifted and talented programs at schools", "i9_0kT3Glio-00034-00010392-00010624": "which were basically", "i9_0kT3Glio-00035-00010625-00010889": "um they were basically a separate uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00036-00010890-00011219": "channel for autistic and ADHD kids who", "i9_0kT3Glio-00037-00011220-00011406": "weren't uh the biggest like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00038-00011407-00011681": "troublemakers in class", "i9_0kT3Glio-00039-00011682-00011921": "um whereas at least uh if you go and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00040-00011922-00012064": "look at these programs a lot of times", "i9_0kT3Glio-00041-00012065-00012238": "they were designed to basically take", "i9_0kT3Glio-00042-00012239-00012364": "kids", "i9_0kT3Glio-00043-00012365-00012424": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00044-00012425-00012874": "who uh were struggling socially uh but", "i9_0kT3Glio-00045-00012875-00013072": "not struggling scholastically and put", "i9_0kT3Glio-00046-00013073-00013313": "them in a separate room", "i9_0kT3Glio-00047-00013313-00013558": "um whereas of course special ed was", "i9_0kT3Glio-00048-00013559-00013955": "often used uh for uh kids who were", "i9_0kT3Glio-00049-00013956-00014171": "struggling scholastically but not", "i9_0kT3Glio-00050-00014172-00014344": "necessarily socially sometimes socially", "i9_0kT3Glio-00051-00014345-00014471": "as well but usually if you were", "i9_0kT3Glio-00052-00014472-00014699": "struggling scholastically", "i9_0kT3Glio-00053-00014700-00014825": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00054-00014826-00015143": "and it was a kind of it's kind of a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00055-00015144-00015305": "complicated thing and a lot of people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00056-00015306-00015485": "who are out from outside of the U.S", "i9_0kT3Glio-00057-00015486-00015671": "don't really know or have never really", "i9_0kT3Glio-00058-00015672-00015815": "heard of these gifted and talented", "i9_0kT3Glio-00059-00015816-00016025": "things there was many different names", "i9_0kT3Glio-00060-00016026-00016193": "for them in the U.S but they were a pro", "i9_0kT3Glio-00061-00016194-00016403": "a program that appeared around the 90s", "i9_0kT3Glio-00062-00016404-00016589": "and early 2000s and then disappeared", "i9_0kT3Glio-00063-00016590-00016811": "shortly after a lot of schools no longer", "i9_0kT3Glio-00064-00016812-00016955": "have them", "i9_0kT3Glio-00065-00016956-00017225": "um because they were they had very", "i9_0kT3Glio-00066-00017226-00017435": "middling results", "i9_0kT3Glio-00067-00017436-00017927": "um anyway I was diagnosed with ADHD uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00068-00017928-00018215": "pretty severe ADHD in adulthood", "i9_0kT3Glio-00069-00018216-00018493": "um when I was younger I grew up in a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00070-00018494-00018844": "anti-psychology Christian cult", "i9_0kT3Glio-00071-00018845-00019085": "um The Cult that I grew up in uh and my", "i9_0kT3Glio-00072-00019086-00019505": "family was so opposed to psychology that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00073-00019506-00019763": "they didn't even believe in therapists", "i9_0kT3Glio-00074-00019764-00019949": "um none of my family members were like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00075-00019950-00020285": "allowed to see therapists until uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00076-00020286-00020477": "significantly later on in my life when", "i9_0kT3Glio-00077-00020478-00020729": "people had started to leave the cult and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00078-00020730-00020975": "as a result there is essentially no way", "i9_0kT3Glio-00079-00020976-00021167": "that I would have ever been diagnosed", "i9_0kT3Glio-00080-00021168-00021430": "with ADHD when I was younger despite the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00081-00021431-00021694": "fact that I showed a lot of the signs", "i9_0kT3Glio-00082-00021695-00021911": "also there's no chance that I would have", "i9_0kT3Glio-00083-00021912-00022150": "been diagnosed with autism even though I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00084-00022151-00022450": "showed a lot of those signs as well", "i9_0kT3Glio-00085-00022451-00022847": "um and uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00086-00022848-00023033": "so as a result what I'm trying to do", "i9_0kT3Glio-00087-00023034-00023219": "here is point out to the fact that this", "i9_0kT3Glio-00088-00023220-00023585": "is a a word that has been used against", "i9_0kT3Glio-00089-00023586-00024203": "me a lot in my life and also that um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00090-00024204-00024671": "like I I I believe that I would meet the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00091-00024672-00024953": "criteria for what we would generally", "i9_0kT3Glio-00092-00024954-00025253": "call reclaiming a slur and we're going", "i9_0kT3Glio-00093-00025254-00025492": "to talk about all of this in great depth", "i9_0kT3Glio-00094-00025493-00025846": "in the coming uh uh section but uh I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00095-00025847-00025972": "just wanted to get that out of the way", "i9_0kT3Glio-00096-00025973-00026279": "up front like my experience with this", "i9_0kT3Glio-00097-00026280-00026657": "word uh my experience with uh being put", "i9_0kT3Glio-00098-00026658-00026981": "into alternative tracks of Education", "i9_0kT3Glio-00099-00026982-00027274": "um and my own experience with having", "i9_0kT3Glio-00100-00027275-00027493": "parents who deliberately avoided", "i9_0kT3Glio-00101-00027494-00027737": "extensively and deliberately avoided me", "i9_0kT3Glio-00102-00027738-00027989": "ever being diagnosed with anything oh I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00103-00027989-00028139": "should also point out", "i9_0kT3Glio-00104-00028139-00028337": "um this goes beyond any sort of learning", "i9_0kT3Glio-00105-00028338-00028517": "related issues", "i9_0kT3Glio-00106-00028518-00028720": "um to the point that in high school", "i9_0kT3Glio-00107-00028722-00029002": "there is no ifs ands or buts about the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00108-00029004-00029170": "fact that I had clinical depression in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00109-00029172-00029489": "high school severe clinical depression", "i9_0kT3Glio-00110-00029489-00029783": "um for all four years of high school", "i9_0kT3Glio-00111-00029783-00030155": "I was so severely depressed that like I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00112-00030156-00030455": "thought about suicide on a near-constant", "i9_0kT3Glio-00113-00030456-00030785": "basis when I was in high school it was", "i9_0kT3Glio-00114-00030786-00031090": "um incredibly incredibly difficult for", "i9_0kT3Glio-00115-00031091-00031367": "me and there was no way that I was ever", "i9_0kT3Glio-00116-00031368-00031667": "going to uh have that I have a diagnosis", "i9_0kT3Glio-00117-00031668-00031955": "for that because my family was deeply", "i9_0kT3Glio-00118-00031956-00032212": "opposed to me ever", "i9_0kT3Glio-00119-00032213-00032381": "um having any sort of treatment for that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00120-00032382-00032543": "sort of thing or even seeing somebody", "i9_0kT3Glio-00121-00032544-00032801": "about it there was just no way", "i9_0kT3Glio-00122-00032802-00032951": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00123-00032952-00033257": "so uh it does get better of course it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00124-00033258-00033401": "gets better it absolutely gets better", "i9_0kT3Glio-00125-00033402-00033695": "even with no diagnosis I held on even", "i9_0kT3Glio-00126-00033696-00033989": "with no uh assistance from any sort of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00127-00033990-00034217": "like therapist in that way I held on and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00128-00034218-00034445": "I was able to grow and and as my family", "i9_0kT3Glio-00129-00034446-00034690": "moved away from the church as I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00130-00034691-00034871": "personally chose to leave the church I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00131-00034872-00035159": "grew I got a lot like my my life got", "i9_0kT3Glio-00132-00035160-00035440": "better and I was able to deal with and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00133-00035441-00035699": "cope with depression symptoms", "i9_0kT3Glio-00134-00035700-00035945": "um above and beyond", "i9_0kT3Glio-00135-00035946-00036196": "um you know uh like medication or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00136-00036197-00036365": "anything like that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00137-00036366-00036646": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00138-00036647-00036851": "thank you Elora I really do appreciate", "i9_0kT3Glio-00139-00036852-00036971": "that a lot", "i9_0kT3Glio-00140-00036972-00037043": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00141-00037044-00037199": "so", "i9_0kT3Glio-00142-00037200-00037396": "I just wanted that to all be out there", "i9_0kT3Glio-00143-00037397-00037546": "so that you all understand the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00144-00037547-00037709": "perspective I'm coming from when we talk", "i9_0kT3Glio-00145-00037710-00037907": "about this topic", "i9_0kT3Glio-00146-00037908-00038117": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00147-00038118-00038321": "it's been a while since I've talked", "i9_0kT3Glio-00148-00038322-00038705": "about uh the word [__] it's been a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00149-00038706-00038867": "while since I've talked about what some", "i9_0kT3Glio-00150-00038868-00039149": "of you refer to as the r slur", "i9_0kT3Glio-00151-00039150-00039383": "um but it's also been a while since", "i9_0kT3Glio-00152-00039384-00039587": "we've talked about the Reclamation of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00153-00039588-00039857": "slurs in general", "i9_0kT3Glio-00154-00039858-00040151": "um now uh I'm gonna take just one second", "i9_0kT3Glio-00155-00040152-00040517": "uh after being incredibly vulnerable to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00156-00040518-00040607": "say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00157-00040608-00040955": "please support my show this section is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00158-00040956-00041201": "absolutely going to get demonetized and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00159-00041202-00041374": "there is no chance that YouTube will", "i9_0kT3Glio-00160-00041375-00041573": "give me any money for this segment", "i9_0kT3Glio-00161-00041574-00041740": "segment that I'm putting a lot of work", "i9_0kT3Glio-00162-00041741-00041999": "in into and also being very vulnerable", "i9_0kT3Glio-00163-00042000-00042215": "for so please consider donating either", "i9_0kT3Glio-00164-00042216-00042443": "through YouTube or preferably through my", "i9_0kT3Glio-00165-00042444-00042635": "website demonmama.com forward slash", "i9_0kT3Glio-00166-00042636-00042821": "subscribe or forward slash donate either", "i9_0kT3Glio-00167-00042822-00042977": "one works depending what you want to do", "i9_0kT3Glio-00168-00042978-00043133": "would deeply appreciate your support", "i9_0kT3Glio-00169-00043134-00043493": "this show is 100 viewer supported okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00170-00043494-00043696": "literally 100 I don't get any", "i9_0kT3Glio-00171-00043697-00043912": "sponsorships I don't do any of that sort", "i9_0kT3Glio-00172-00043913-00044140": "of thing it's just a free show that is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00173-00044141-00044290": "supported by the viewers so please", "i9_0kT3Glio-00174-00044291-00044477": "support me I deeply appreciate it and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00175-00044478-00044740": "also press like on the stream will ya", "i9_0kT3Glio-00176-00044741-00044957": "I appreciate that a lot okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00177-00044958-00045167": "there you go", "i9_0kT3Glio-00178-00045168-00045358": "all right so", "i9_0kT3Glio-00179-00045359-00045790": "let's talk about reclaiming slurs okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00180-00045791-00046001": "and I'm gonna I'm gonna draw comparisons", "i9_0kT3Glio-00181-00046002-00046307": "to another slur a slur that I think we", "i9_0kT3Glio-00182-00046308-00046685": "all can agree is a slur okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00183-00046686-00046930": "[__] okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00184-00046931-00047207": "uh I'm sure many of my audience because", "i9_0kT3Glio-00185-00047208-00047446": "I do have a lot of queer people in my", "i9_0kT3Glio-00186-00047447-00047740": "audience I'm sure many of you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00187-00047741-00047968": "um have had that word used against you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00188-00047969-00048208": "I'm sure you've heard that word thrown", "i9_0kT3Glio-00189-00048209-00048461": "around as a pejorative", "i9_0kT3Glio-00190-00048462-00048521": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00191-00048522-00048827": "and also as you will notice in chat you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00192-00048828-00049079": "will see a lot of people volunteering", "i9_0kT3Glio-00193-00049080-00049415": "themselves saying me that's me that's me", "i9_0kT3Glio-00194-00049416-00049583": "you're talking about when I say the word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00195-00049584-00050035": "[__] I also often uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00196-00050036-00050386": "self-describe as a [__] or a [__] or any", "i9_0kT3Glio-00197-00050387-00050645": "of these other words that you hear uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00198-00050646-00051079": "slung about uh as a slur for Trans gay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00199-00051080-00051437": "uh and non-conforming people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00200-00051438-00051623": "but I think we can all acknowledge that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00201-00051624-00051952": "it's a slur right like um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00202-00051953-00052252": "like like no ifs ands or buts about it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00203-00052253-00052444": "we all recognize that it's a slur that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00204-00052445-00052703": "it's used in media as a slur that it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00205-00052704-00052961": "used by politicians as a slur and it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00206-00052962-00053230": "not very acceptable to say that word in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00207-00053232-00053363": "public", "i9_0kT3Glio-00208-00053364-00053530": "um and the same goes by the way for", "i9_0kT3Glio-00209-00053532-00053782": "another slur the n-word which obviously", "i9_0kT3Glio-00210-00053783-00053944": "I'm not going to say I don't say the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00211-00053945-00054137": "n-word at all um and there's a couple of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00212-00054138-00054275": "reasons for that part of which what", "i9_0kT3Glio-00213-00054276-00054449": "we're talking about here I think in fact", "i9_0kT3Glio-00214-00054450-00054773": "people have remarked uh that like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00215-00054774-00055042": "um the n-word is so such a severe slur", "i9_0kT3Glio-00216-00055044-00055342": "that people won't even say it even when", "i9_0kT3Glio-00217-00055344-00055547": "they're in private and given permission", "i9_0kT3Glio-00218-00055548-00055726": "to do so", "i9_0kT3Glio-00219-00055727-00055997": "um that it has that much of a cultural", "i9_0kT3Glio-00220-00055998-00056141": "weight to it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00221-00056141-00056326": "um that that it is so universally", "i9_0kT3Glio-00222-00056327-00056638": "recognized as a hateful slur that um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00223-00056639-00056813": "people won't even use it when they're", "i9_0kT3Glio-00224-00056814-00057065": "allowed to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00225-00057066-00057163": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00226-00057164-00057479": "and uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00227-00057479-00057653": "I say the N word all the time because", "i9_0kT3Glio-00228-00057654-00057869": "I'm black well yeah but that's the thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-00229-00057870-00058157": "see that's that's the thing that's the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00230-00058158-00058319": "Reclamation part that we're about to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00231-00058320-00058463": "talk about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00232-00058464-00058553": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00233-00058554-00058726": "but um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00234-00058727-00058954": "out of curiosity", "i9_0kT3Glio-00235-00058955-00059087": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00236-00059088-00059357": "we all recognize here that with the end", "i9_0kT3Glio-00237-00059358-00059632": "with the n-word in in particular", "i9_0kT3Glio-00238-00059633-00059788": "um like that there that there's actually", "i9_0kT3Glio-00239-00059789-00060100": "a distinction between the hard R and the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00240-00060101-00060371": "a like the soft a right", "i9_0kT3Glio-00241-00060372-00060616": "um even among black people uh it is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00242-00060617-00060976": "considered uh a pretty serious thing to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00243-00060977-00061379": "use the hard R towards someone else", "i9_0kT3Glio-00244-00061379-00061673": "right so we acknowledge that there's a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00245-00061674-00061913": "difference there right", "i9_0kT3Glio-00246-00061914-00062116": "um reclamation", "i9_0kT3Glio-00247-00062117-00062537": "has never been and isn't about using a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00248-00062538-00063004": "slur against someone else like for", "i9_0kT3Glio-00249-00063005-00063238": "example let me let me let me just create", "i9_0kT3Glio-00250-00063239-00063544": "real quick a a situation for you all to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00251-00063545-00063761": "shoot like have your brains chew on real", "i9_0kT3Glio-00252-00063762-00064132": "quick okay imagine okay imagine that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00253-00064133-00064450": "there was a cop okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00254-00064451-00064685": "and you can imagine this cop however you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00255-00064686-00065021": "want but I want you to imagine him uh I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00256-00065022-00065254": "want you to imagine him as a as a guy", "i9_0kT3Glio-00257-00065255-00065699": "okay and I want you to imagine him", "i9_0kT3Glio-00258-00065700-00066131": "uh like hitting a uh like like at a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00259-00066132-00066347": "pride event okay let's say there's a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00260-00066348-00066526": "pride event and the pride event turns", "i9_0kT3Glio-00261-00066527-00066773": "into a protest and this cop", "i9_0kT3Glio-00262-00066774-00067156": "is uh hitting a gay protester and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00263-00067157-00067487": "calling that gay protester a [__] while", "i9_0kT3Glio-00264-00067488-00067817": "hitting him with a stick", "i9_0kT3Glio-00265-00067818-00068129": "and now I want you to to imagine that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00266-00068130-00068291": "situation okay that's pretty that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00267-00068292-00068513": "pretty severe right", "i9_0kT3Glio-00268-00068514-00068776": "now I want you to imagine that that cop", "i9_0kT3Glio-00269-00068777-00069055": "has a husband", "i9_0kT3Glio-00270-00069056-00069437": "has anything changed for you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00271-00069438-00069671": "did anything about the hatefulness of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00272-00069672-00069923": "that situation change at all because you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00273-00069924-00070294": "know that that cop has a husband", "i9_0kT3Glio-00274-00070295-00070600": "because for me nothing changed even a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00275-00070601-00070726": "little bit", "i9_0kT3Glio-00276-00070727-00071050": "the a cop beating a gay person and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00277-00071051-00071213": "calling them a [__] in front of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00278-00071214-00071482": "everybody else is an act of humiliation", "i9_0kT3Glio-00279-00071483-00071891": "and hatred even if that cop in his own", "i9_0kT3Glio-00280-00071892-00072203": "private life is gay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00281-00072204-00072419": "even if the cop that we're talking about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00282-00072420-00072587": "literally looks like the cop from the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00283-00072588-00073282": "Village People", "i9_0kT3Glio-00284-00073283-00073481": "and I want you to imagine the same thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-00285-00073482-00073715": "okay but this time", "i9_0kT3Glio-00286-00073716-00073906": "with the n-word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00287-00073907-00074261": "and with a cop", "i9_0kT3Glio-00288-00074262-00074525": "and maybe that cop is black did anything", "i9_0kT3Glio-00289-00074526-00074735": "change when you change the skin color of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00290-00074736-00076476": "the cop because to me nothing changes", "i9_0kT3Glio-00291-00076477-00076921": "so Reclamation of a slur in my opinion", "i9_0kT3Glio-00292-00076922-00077429": "is often about uh being able to take a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00293-00077430-00077699": "word that is used against you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00294-00077700-00078005": "and turn it into something that you take", "i9_0kT3Glio-00295-00078006-00078299": "strengthen for example when I look", "i9_0kT3Glio-00296-00078300-00078503": "directly into the camera as I am right", "i9_0kT3Glio-00297-00078504-00078893": "now and I say I am proud to be a [__] I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00298-00078894-00079241": "am proud to be a [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00299-00079242-00079435": "those are words that have been used", "i9_0kT3Glio-00300-00079436-00079732": "unironically against me in my life many", "i9_0kT3Glio-00301-00079733-00080021": "times these words have been used as a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00302-00080022-00080256": "bludgeon of hate against me in my life", "i9_0kT3Glio-00303-00080257-00080753": "me reclaiming them saying yeah so what I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00304-00080754-00080944": "am a [__] what are you gonna do about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00305-00080945-00081106": "it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00306-00081107-00081437": "to me that is what Reclamation the act", "i9_0kT3Glio-00307-00081438-00081706": "of reclamation or or a major part of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00308-00081707-00081988": "reclamation looks like it is taking a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00309-00081989-00082115": "term", "i9_0kT3Glio-00310-00082116-00082409": "that is used to hurt you and wielding it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00311-00082410-00082997": "on your own as a signal of of pride", "i9_0kT3Glio-00312-00082998-00083165": "um and I think that there are other", "i9_0kT3Glio-00313-00083166-00083387": "forms of reclamation like for example I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00314-00083388-00083591": "think that a lot of reclamation has", "i9_0kT3Glio-00315-00083592-00083921": "happened with the n-word and I think", "i9_0kT3Glio-00316-00083922-00084082": "that this like I mentioned before that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00317-00084083-00084250": "this takes two forms like first of all", "i9_0kT3Glio-00318-00084251-00084538": "there is a version of the n-word that is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00319-00084539-00084809": "a that is slightly changed the soft a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00320-00084810-00085061": "and the soft a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00321-00085062-00085331": "um is very is is treated very", "i9_0kT3Glio-00322-00085332-00085487": "differently", "i9_0kT3Glio-00323-00085488-00085715": "um between basically everybody everybody", "i9_0kT3Glio-00324-00085716-00086021": "treats the hard r that that's reason why", "i9_0kT3Glio-00325-00086022-00086303": "we have the term the hard R the hard R", "i9_0kT3Glio-00326-00086304-00086687": "is like um it signifies an almost a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00327-00086688-00086831": "different word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00328-00086832-00087112": "um but uh I want you to think about the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00329-00087113-00087275": "fact that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00330-00087276-00087712": "um that the soft a nobody even bats an", "i9_0kT3Glio-00331-00087713-00088000": "eye if you see people with you know if", "i9_0kT3Glio-00332-00088001-00088253": "you see black people using the soft a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00333-00088254-00088450": "with one another", "i9_0kT3Glio-00334-00088451-00088756": "um self referentially or otherwise no", "i9_0kT3Glio-00335-00088757-00088925": "one bats an eye but if you see a white", "i9_0kT3Glio-00336-00088926-00089206": "person to use that immediately that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00337-00089207-00089476": "person will be roasted and they should", "i9_0kT3Glio-00338-00089477-00089806": "be but that does that not indicate does", "i9_0kT3Glio-00339-00089807-00090017": "that not indicate the Reclamation in a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00340-00090018-00090244": "certain way where", "i9_0kT3Glio-00341-00090245-00090568": "wow this word that used to be seen as an", "i9_0kT3Glio-00342-00090569-00090779": "acceptable slur to put someone else down", "i9_0kT3Glio-00343-00090780-00091109": "is now seen as a taboo it has been", "i9_0kT3Glio-00344-00091110-00091318": "changed from a thing that can be used", "i9_0kT3Glio-00345-00091319-00091594": "against black people to a thing that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00346-00091595-00091900": "black people can use uh uh freely", "i9_0kT3Glio-00347-00091901-00092225": "amongst themselves with rules that they", "i9_0kT3Glio-00348-00092226-00092476": "Define that black people got to decide", "i9_0kT3Glio-00349-00092477-00092675": "the difference between the soft a and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00350-00092676-00092879": "the hard R and they also got to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00351-00092880-00093076": "determine the rules of uh sort of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00352-00093077-00093671": "collectively the rules of using it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00353-00093672-00093838": "does that make sense", "i9_0kT3Glio-00354-00093839-00094318": "and the same thing goes uh for [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00355-00094319-00094487": "um and also you can even argue that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00356-00094488-00094709": "queer is a perfect example of this let", "i9_0kT3Glio-00357-00094710-00095015": "me I want you to imagine", "i9_0kT3Glio-00358-00095016-00095249": "um if I am talking to my audience and I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00359-00095250-00095531": "say my lovely queers let us stand", "i9_0kT3Glio-00360-00095532-00095825": "together in strength that has a lot of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00361-00095826-00096031": "different that is a very very different", "i9_0kT3Glio-00362-00096032-00096431": "uh read than if say I don't know Donald", "i9_0kT3Glio-00363-00096432-00096629": "Trump walked up and said you're a bunch", "i9_0kT3Glio-00364-00096630-00096976": "of queers", "i9_0kT3Glio-00365-00096977-00097241": "right completely different context", "i9_0kT3Glio-00366-00097242-00097559": "despite us saying uh you know besite me", "i9_0kT3Glio-00367-00097560-00097703": "walking up and saying we're all a bunch", "i9_0kT3Glio-00368-00097704-00097900": "of queers here let's Stand Together", "i9_0kT3Glio-00369-00097901-00098123": "versus Donald Trump saying you're a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00370-00098124-00098249": "bunch of queers because you'll notice", "i9_0kT3Glio-00371-00098250-00098585": "that one is being used inclusively one", "i9_0kT3Glio-00372-00098586-00098794": "is being used to take strength together", "i9_0kT3Glio-00373-00098795-00099094": "to call for togetherness in some way or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00374-00099095-00099412": "another and the other", "i9_0kT3Glio-00375-00099413-00099791": "is uh you know is is that was not a good", "i9_0kT3Glio-00376-00099792-00100000": "Trump impression but please can we have", "i9_0kT3Glio-00377-00100001-00100138": "a break for just one second Jesus Christ", "i9_0kT3Glio-00378-00100139-00100493": "uh and the other one is is being used as", "i9_0kT3Glio-00379-00100494-00100817": "a a marker of Separation it is saying it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00380-00100818-00101117": "is creating an US versus them", "i9_0kT3Glio-00381-00101118-00101399": "and of course this brings us", "i9_0kT3Glio-00382-00101400-00101650": "to the word [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00383-00101651-00101771": "now", "i9_0kT3Glio-00384-00101772-00101974": "many of you will know if you've been", "i9_0kT3Glio-00385-00101975-00102149": "watching my content for a long time I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00386-00102150-00102281": "know there's a lot of people here who", "i9_0kT3Glio-00387-00102282-00102430": "haven't been if you're here you should", "i9_0kT3Glio-00388-00102431-00102580": "subscribe and you should ring the bell", "i9_0kT3Glio-00389-00102581-00102832": "because quite frankly I put out some", "i9_0kT3Glio-00390-00102833-00103060": "pretty base content", "i9_0kT3Glio-00391-00103061-00103415": "um and uh yeah uh you should subscribe", "i9_0kT3Glio-00392-00103416-00103625": "but um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00393-00103626-00103927": "I I don't use the arsler on my stream", "i9_0kT3Glio-00394-00103928-00104392": "basically ever today is literally the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00395-00104393-00104710": "most that I have ever used uh the word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00396-00104711-00104878": "[__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00397-00104879-00105215": "um in ever and and my entire stream", "i9_0kT3Glio-00398-00105216-00105413": "history you can go scrub through the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00399-00105414-00105640": "vods and you might find one or two", "i9_0kT3Glio-00400-00105641-00105845": "examples in the entire history of my", "i9_0kT3Glio-00401-00105846-00106247": "channel of me uh self-referring", "i9_0kT3Glio-00402-00106248-00106421": "as a [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00403-00106422-00106666": "and like literally for example when I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00404-00106667-00106943": "did the um when I did the uh the the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00405-00106944-00107152": "Autism test and I [__] up the Autism", "i9_0kT3Glio-00406-00107153-00107375": "test four times in a row live on stream", "i9_0kT3Glio-00407-00107376-00107519": "and I was getting increasingly", "i9_0kT3Glio-00408-00107520-00107704": "embarrassed and then I said at the end", "i9_0kT3Glio-00409-00107705-00107908": "of it I said the good news is we've", "i9_0kT3Glio-00410-00107909-00108107": "determined that I'm [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00411-00108108-00108281": "um that's the that's like probably one", "i9_0kT3Glio-00412-00108282-00108707": "of the only examples of me uh ever using", "i9_0kT3Glio-00413-00108708-00108958": "this slur", "i9_0kT3Glio-00414-00108959-00109169": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00415-00109170-00109745": "and uh part of the reason for that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00416-00109746-00109834": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00417-00109835-00110004": "is is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00418-00110005-00110302": "well I mean frankly because I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00419-00110303-00110483": "think the way that most people use the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00420-00110483-00110801": "arsler is particularly reclammatory okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00421-00110802-00111184": "I've been seeing a lot of people okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00422-00111185-00111466": "um like a lot of people basically saying", "i9_0kT3Glio-00423-00111467-00111731": "that if you have if you're Autistic or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00424-00111732-00112019": "if you have ADHD or if you have learning", "i9_0kT3Glio-00425-00112020-00112319": "disabilities that that means that you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00426-00112320-00112547": "can just sort of take the word [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00427-00112548-00112721": "and you can throw it at anybody else", "i9_0kT3Glio-00428-00112722-00112954": "whenever you want", "i9_0kT3Glio-00429-00112955-00113495": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00430-00113496-00113777": "and uh and I just", "i9_0kT3Glio-00431-00113778-00114125": "I just that's not what Reclamation means", "i9_0kT3Glio-00432-00114126-00114323": "uh and I have a problem with that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00433-00114324-00114563": "argument I think that argument is a weak", "i9_0kT3Glio-00434-00114564-00114821": "argument and interestingly I think most", "i9_0kT3Glio-00435-00114822-00115036": "of the people who use it know that it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00436-00115038-00115265": "not a good argument because you wouldn't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00437-00115266-00115528": "say the same thing about the word [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00438-00115529-00115690": "you wouldn't say the same thing about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00439-00115691-00115919": "the n-word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00440-00115920-00116165": "um and yet we see tons of people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00441-00116166-00116339": "basically say well I have ADHD which", "i9_0kT3Glio-00442-00116340-00116566": "means that I can call you a uh stupid", "i9_0kT3Glio-00443-00116567-00116752": "[__] [__] or I can say that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00444-00116753-00117047": "[__] stupid and [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00445-00117048-00117269": "but I just I don't believe that I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00446-00117270-00117449": "think that that argument holds very much", "i9_0kT3Glio-00447-00117450-00117623": "water with regard to how we treat other", "i9_0kT3Glio-00448-00117624-00117731": "slurs", "i9_0kT3Glio-00449-00117732-00117989": "now", "i9_0kT3Glio-00450-00117990-00118060": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00451-00118061-00118277": "there's there's there's a whole lot of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00452-00118278-00118390": "like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00453-00118391-00118547": "there's a whole lot of back and forth", "i9_0kT3Glio-00454-00118548-00118721": "over this issue", "i9_0kT3Glio-00455-00118722-00118978": "um and I don't want to just make a claim", "i9_0kT3Glio-00456-00118979-00119183": "out of hand so I'm going to try and end", "i9_0kT3Glio-00457-00119183-00119507": "evidence here why I think", "i9_0kT3Glio-00458-00119508-00119765": "um that people should think about this a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00459-00119766-00119945": "little bit harder", "i9_0kT3Glio-00460-00119946-00120358": "um so", "i9_0kT3Glio-00461-00120359-00120563": "a lot of people will bring up ableism", "i9_0kT3Glio-00462-00120564-00120833": "and whatever and I do think that ableism", "i9_0kT3Glio-00463-00120833-00121031": "is a huge problem okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00464-00121032-00121247": "um but at least for me when I think", "i9_0kT3Glio-00465-00121248-00121499": "about ableism most of what I think about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00466-00121500-00121745": "is the way that our society treats", "i9_0kT3Glio-00467-00121746-00121943": "people with disabilities", "i9_0kT3Glio-00468-00121944-00122284": "um the fact that like disabled people uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00469-00122285-00122651": "have a uh significantly higher rate of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00470-00122652-00122939": "early uh uh death that uh disabled", "i9_0kT3Glio-00471-00122940-00123052": "people have a higher rate of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00472-00123053-00123263": "homelessness that disabled people are", "i9_0kT3Glio-00473-00123264-00123413": "more likely to be discriminated against", "i9_0kT3Glio-00474-00123414-00123623": "on the job the disabled people are more", "i9_0kT3Glio-00475-00123624-00123857": "likely to be denied a job that disabled", "i9_0kT3Glio-00476-00123858-00124151": "people often uh do not are not", "i9_0kT3Glio-00477-00124152-00124384": "accommodated for even when the law says", "i9_0kT3Glio-00478-00124385-00124547": "that they have the legal right to be", "i9_0kT3Glio-00479-00124548-00124745": "accommodated for", "i9_0kT3Glio-00480-00124746-00125015": "um that that that there's all kinds of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00481-00125016-00125171": "things there that's what I tend to think", "i9_0kT3Glio-00482-00125172-00125386": "of when I think of ableism I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00483-00125388-00125651": "really tend to think of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00484-00125652-00125747": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00485-00125748-00126077": "of ableism through the lens of of like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00486-00126078-00126323": "insults as frequently though I do think", "i9_0kT3Glio-00487-00126324-00126508": "that it's a valid lens", "i9_0kT3Glio-00488-00126509-00126695": "and I want to bring attention to the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00489-00126696-00126910": "fact that like there are all kinds of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00490-00126911-00127258": "ableist words in our language that are", "i9_0kT3Glio-00491-00127259-00127486": "that are definitionally as far as I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00492-00127488-00127823": "could tell you know ableist stupid dumb", "i9_0kT3Glio-00493-00127824-00128278": "idiotic insane uh deranged in fact most", "i9_0kT3Glio-00494-00128279-00128501": "insults that you can think of that are", "i9_0kT3Glio-00495-00128502-00128860": "that aren't uh that aren't like um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00496-00128861-00129190": "I don't know like you Muffin you're such", "i9_0kT3Glio-00497-00129191-00129407": "a you're such a you're such a clap", "i9_0kT3Glio-00498-00129408-00129707": "cobbler you're you're a you're uh you're", "i9_0kT3Glio-00499-00129708-00129786": "a CR", "i9_0kT3Glio-00500-00129788-00130121": "[__] crustable cromulent [__] crustable", "i9_0kT3Glio-00501-00130122-00130516": "like there's no like most of the insults", "i9_0kT3Glio-00502-00130517-00130871": "have some component of implied ableism", "i9_0kT3Glio-00503-00130872-00131051": "okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00504-00131052-00131489": "nanners uh uh you know whatever there's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00505-00131490-00131675": "a million of them", "i9_0kT3Glio-00506-00131676-00131933": "um stupid idiot I mean these all have uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00507-00131934-00132190": "have aspects of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00508-00132191-00132454": "um of of ableism in them", "i9_0kT3Glio-00509-00132455-00132790": "but there's a pretty marked difference", "i9_0kT3Glio-00510-00132791-00133163": "between the word stupid and the word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00511-00133164-00133325": "[__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00512-00133326-00133547": "especially if you consider social", "i9_0kT3Glio-00513-00133548-00133673": "context", "i9_0kT3Glio-00514-00133674-00134069": "the word stupid and dumb and idiot have", "i9_0kT3Glio-00515-00134070-00134321": "not been used in any sort of like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00516-00134322-00134621": "medical terminology for a very long time", "i9_0kT3Glio-00517-00134622-00134866": "they've more or less come to mean", "i9_0kT3Glio-00518-00134867-00135137": "someone who is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00519-00135138-00135443": "um not thinking at the moment uh like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00520-00135444-00135713": "you say someone is stupid because what", "i9_0kT3Glio-00521-00135714-00135940": "you actually mean generally is that they", "i9_0kT3Glio-00522-00135941-00136175": "are they are ill-informed they are not", "i9_0kT3Glio-00523-00136176-00136414": "thinking or maybe even they're being", "i9_0kT3Glio-00524-00136415-00136673": "dishonest and it's making them behave", "i9_0kT3Glio-00525-00136674-00136966": "stupidly uh very few people when they", "i9_0kT3Glio-00526-00136967-00137243": "say the word stupid are like traveling", "i9_0kT3Glio-00527-00137244-00137525": "back in time to 1920 where they're", "i9_0kT3Glio-00528-00137526-00137885": "drawing like a a formerly medicalized", "i9_0kT3Glio-00529-00137886-00138089": "diagnosis of stupidity or something", "i9_0kT3Glio-00530-00138090-00138269": "along those lines and the same thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-00531-00138270-00138521": "goes for the word idiot uh idiot used to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00532-00138522-00138845": "be a direct reference to a certain type", "i9_0kT3Glio-00533-00138846-00139277": "of autism the idiot savant which is a a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00534-00139278-00139499": "term that is so outdated that like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00535-00139500-00139763": "multiple Generations have not lived", "i9_0kT3Glio-00536-00139764-00139937": "through a time in which it was used in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00537-00139938-00140195": "any sort of medicalized sense", "i9_0kT3Glio-00538-00140196-00140477": "um but that's not true about [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00539-00140478-00140639": "um like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00540-00140640-00140921": "[__] has been used uh medicalized", "i9_0kT3Glio-00541-00140922-00141178": "recently and what's more is that it has", "i9_0kT3Glio-00542-00141179-00141563": "been used deliberately against people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00543-00141564-00141977": "who have been medicalized even after the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00544-00141978-00142313": "end of its medicalized use nobody uses", "i9_0kT3Glio-00545-00142314-00142601": "the word mentally [__] anymore", "i9_0kT3Glio-00546-00142602-00142781": "um even though in the 90s it was", "i9_0kT3Glio-00547-00142782-00142985": "acceptable it was still considered", "i9_0kT3Glio-00548-00142986-00143177": "medically acceptable to stay to say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00549-00143178-00143393": "mentally [__] a lot of Us Alive", "i9_0kT3Glio-00550-00143394-00143633": "lived in a period in which it was still", "i9_0kT3Glio-00551-00143634-00143843": "considered medically acceptable to say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00552-00143844-00144035": "that somebody who was struggling with", "i9_0kT3Glio-00553-00144036-00144221": "learning disabilities or had Down", "i9_0kT3Glio-00554-00144222-00144359": "syndrome that they were mentally", "i9_0kT3Glio-00555-00144360-00144514": "[__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00556-00144515-00144797": "um but even that with that aside", "i9_0kT3Glio-00557-00144798-00145109": "um the word [__] has carried on in its", "i9_0kT3Glio-00558-00145110-00145469": "use directly against", "i9_0kT3Glio-00559-00145470-00145763": "people who just have a learning", "i9_0kT3Glio-00560-00145764-00145943": "disability or people who have Down", "i9_0kT3Glio-00561-00145944-00146213": "syndrome or autistic people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00562-00146214-00146537": "I mean I bet right now I could I could", "i9_0kT3Glio-00563-00146538-00146837": "do a show of hands okay do not respond", "i9_0kT3Glio-00564-00146838-00147011": "in the audience right now if you're not", "i9_0kT3Glio-00565-00147012-00147287": "Autistic or ADHD but if you are Autistic", "i9_0kT3Glio-00566-00147288-00147640": "or ADHD just just put a number one in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00567-00147641-00147887": "chat put a single one in chat if you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00568-00147888-00148139": "have had if you have had a loved one", "i9_0kT3Glio-00569-00148140-00148481": "friend teacher whatever use there we go", "i9_0kT3Glio-00570-00148482-00149183": "look just the chat's going crazy okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00571-00149184-00149777": "there is no uh there is no uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00572-00149778-00149981": "lack of clarity", "i9_0kT3Glio-00573-00149982-00150323": "with what people mean when they say the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00574-00150324-00150713": "word [__] we know like it is being", "i9_0kT3Glio-00575-00150714-00151054": "used in a way that is comparing people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00576-00151055-00151301": "to someone who shouldn't be that it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00577-00151302-00151601": "not a bad thing it's not a bad thing to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00578-00151602-00151793": "have a learning disability it's not a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00579-00151794-00151913": "bad thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-00580-00151914-00152327": "um like it's not a a a a a a a a an evil", "i9_0kT3Glio-00581-00152328-00152602": "thing it's not a morally bad thing to uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00582-00152603-00152843": "to to be autistic it's not a morally bad", "i9_0kT3Glio-00583-00152844-00153107": "thing to be ADHD it's not a morally bad", "i9_0kT3Glio-00584-00153108-00153304": "thing to have Down syndrome these are", "i9_0kT3Glio-00585-00153305-00153533": "not morally bad things", "i9_0kT3Glio-00586-00153534-00153809": "and there's no uh at least in the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00587-00153810-00154013": "colloquial there's essentially no", "i9_0kT3Glio-00588-00154014-00154175": "distinction between the way that it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00589-00154176-00154337": "used would you hold the same position", "i9_0kT3Glio-00590-00154338-00154540": "about the word lame I realize its", "i9_0kT3Glio-00591-00154541-00154678": "Origins are a bit more dated than", "i9_0kT3Glio-00592-00154679-00154913": "[__] but it's always been used in an", "i9_0kT3Glio-00593-00154914-00155113": "inflammatory way against disabled people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00594-00155114-00155404": "well if you think about what people say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00595-00155405-00155819": "with I mean okay to me uh at like going", "i9_0kT3Glio-00596-00155820-00156076": "back quite a long time the word lame", "i9_0kT3Glio-00597-00156077-00156337": "actually like doesn't really reference", "i9_0kT3Glio-00598-00156338-00156575": "uh doesn't really reference the same", "i9_0kT3Glio-00599-00156576-00156814": "thing anymore right like when people say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00600-00156815-00156983": "oh that album was kind of lame I didn't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00601-00156984-00157187": "really like it uh they mean they mean", "i9_0kT3Glio-00602-00157188-00157354": "it's kind of like boring or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00603-00157355-00157666": "uninteresting or like and I think there", "i9_0kT3Glio-00604-00157667-00157816": "are problems with it I think there are", "i9_0kT3Glio-00605-00157817-00158009": "problems with all kinds of insults I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00606-00158010-00158225": "think most insults have a problem it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00607-00158226-00158459": "means uncool yeah it means like and and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00608-00158460-00158693": "I would say that that is like a a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00609-00158694-00158914": "totally transformed meaning it's the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00610-00158915-00159173": "same word but with a completely", "i9_0kT3Glio-00611-00159174-00159425": "um transformed meaning", "i9_0kT3Glio-00612-00159426-00159676": "and same thing goes for Idiot by the way", "i9_0kT3Glio-00613-00159677-00160085": "idiot used to literally literally mean", "i9_0kT3Glio-00614-00160086-00160457": "um uh uh autistic a form of autistic and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00615-00160458-00160649": "now when people say idiot it means like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00616-00160650-00160847": "if you think of the word idiot most", "i9_0kT3Glio-00617-00160848-00161081": "people think of someone like swinging a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00618-00161082-00161314": "like swinging a big stick around and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00619-00161315-00161489": "then accidentally knocking down their", "i9_0kT3Glio-00620-00161490-00161764": "you know putting out a window or or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00621-00161765-00161939": "hitting their friend in the head or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00622-00161940-00162095": "knocking something down that's what most", "i9_0kT3Glio-00623-00162096-00162269": "people think of is like it means you're", "i9_0kT3Glio-00624-00162270-00162437": "being careless or it means you're being", "i9_0kT3Glio-00625-00162438-00162569": "thoughtless", "i9_0kT3Glio-00626-00162570-00162766": "um as opposed to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00627-00162767-00162964": "um you know literally trying to say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00628-00162965-00163151": "somebody has", "i9_0kT3Glio-00629-00163152-00163223": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00630-00163224-00163402": "uh you know", "i9_0kT3Glio-00631-00163403-00163589": "autism or whatever", "i9_0kT3Glio-00632-00163590-00163763": "I don't think the same can be said in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00633-00163764-00164021": "good faith about the word [__] the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00634-00164022-00164297": "word [__] is still to this day", "i9_0kT3Glio-00635-00164298-00164614": "weaponized by parents teachers friends", "i9_0kT3Glio-00636-00164615-00165047": "against people with extremely minor", "i9_0kT3Glio-00637-00165048-00165281": "social and intellectual uh uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00638-00165282-00165581": "disabilities and sometimes just the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00639-00165582-00165802": "perception of those things not even", "i9_0kT3Glio-00640-00165803-00166151": "necessarily an actual thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-00641-00166152-00166235": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00642-00166236-00166595": "and also there's another aspect that I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00643-00166596-00166757": "want to discuss here okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00644-00166758-00167123": "which is that I think the word [__] uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00645-00167124-00167363": "I think that I mean given the fact that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00646-00167364-00167573": "there are 800 people watching my stream", "i9_0kT3Glio-00647-00167574-00167807": "in which I titled it [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00648-00167808-00168004": "um I think that it provokes a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00649-00168005-00168263": "significantly stronger uh emotional", "i9_0kT3Glio-00650-00168264-00168502": "response from most people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00651-00168503-00168575": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00652-00168576-00168928": "in in uh in most social circumstances I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00653-00168929-00169090": "don't think that we've moved away from", "i9_0kT3Glio-00654-00169091-00169397": "the stigma of the word even a little bit", "i9_0kT3Glio-00655-00169398-00169613": "um think about this if you were sitting", "i9_0kT3Glio-00656-00169614-00169763": "I just want you to imagine something", "i9_0kT3Glio-00657-00169764-00169864": "okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00658-00169865-00170111": "hold on a second let me just just take a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00659-00170112-00170333": "second and ride with me here okay I want", "i9_0kT3Glio-00660-00170334-00170513": "all of you to honestly just take a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00661-00170514-00170693": "breath and put yourself in a situation", "i9_0kT3Glio-00662-00170694-00170885": "where you're sitting in a park okay", "i9_0kT3Glio-00663-00170886-00171119": "you're reading a book in the park and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00664-00171120-00171407": "you over here there is a kid swinging a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00665-00171408-00171616": "stick around and the kid is almost", "i9_0kT3Glio-00666-00171617-00171875": "hitting the little kid's sibling and the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00667-00171876-00172109": "kid's mom walks over and says hey would", "i9_0kT3Glio-00668-00172110-00172571": "you quit being an idiot", "i9_0kT3Glio-00669-00172572-00172840": "versus if the mom walked over and said", "i9_0kT3Glio-00670-00172841-00173140": "quit being a [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00671-00173141-00173339": "foreign", "i9_0kT3Glio-00672-00173340-00173578": "tell me honestly that you don't see how", "i9_0kT3Glio-00673-00173579-00173735": "the dip the difference in in the way", "i9_0kT3Glio-00674-00173736-00173987": "that would be uh received both by the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00675-00173988-00174287": "kid and by onlookers", "i9_0kT3Glio-00676-00174288-00174502": "can you imagine how you would feel if", "i9_0kT3Glio-00677-00174503-00174659": "you were in the I mean be honest with", "i9_0kT3Glio-00678-00174660-00174821": "yourselves okay I know there's a lot of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00679-00174822-00175031": "like like there's a lot of people out", "i9_0kT3Glio-00680-00175032-00175199": "here who would call themselves [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00681-00175200-00175402": "users you know they use the word [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00682-00175403-00175589": "a lot but but", "i9_0kT3Glio-00683-00175590-00175871": "um yeah most people here are saying that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00684-00175872-00175961": "like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00685-00175962-00176326": "there would be a pretty big difference", "i9_0kT3Glio-00686-00176327-00176549": "and I think most people would would", "i9_0kT3Glio-00687-00176550-00176699": "acknowledge that calling your kid an", "i9_0kT3Glio-00688-00176700-00176933": "idiot is already a bad thing but I think", "i9_0kT3Glio-00689-00176934-00177214": "that calling your kid a [__] would be", "i9_0kT3Glio-00690-00177215-00177695": "significantly worse", "i9_0kT3Glio-00691-00177696-00177899": "and I think that sort of speaks to the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00692-00177900-00178343": "severity of of of how how strongly that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00693-00178344-00178601": "word still has an impact on people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00694-00178602-00178901": "I mean I remember most of the times in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00695-00178902-00179069": "my life not every time because it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00696-00179070-00179266": "happened a lot especially online and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00697-00179267-00179531": "online is a totally different beast but", "i9_0kT3Glio-00698-00179532-00179699": "I remember most of the times in my life", "i9_0kT3Glio-00699-00179700-00179914": "when I was called a [__] I remember", "i9_0kT3Glio-00700-00179915-00180257": "when I had uh friends and parents call", "i9_0kT3Glio-00701-00180258-00180551": "me a [__] I also remember when friends", "i9_0kT3Glio-00702-00180552-00180928": "and and family called me a [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00703-00180929-00181126": "I don't remember being I don't remember", "i9_0kT3Glio-00704-00181127-00181319": "basically any of the times somebody said", "i9_0kT3Glio-00705-00181320-00181583": "quit being stupid or don't be an idiot I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00706-00181584-00181745": "barely remember any of those but I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00707-00181746-00181943": "remember all of the other two", "i9_0kT3Glio-00708-00181944-00182338": "and I recognize that um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00709-00182339-00182657": "uh I I I uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00710-00182658-00182999": "I recognize that like a lot of this is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00711-00183000-00183221": "going to be gray areas", "i9_0kT3Glio-00712-00183222-00183401": "um I think this is the I think this is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00713-00183402-00183833": "the uh the the I think this is just a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00714-00183834-00184019": "fact of language that there is never", "i9_0kT3Glio-00715-00184020-00184337": "going to be hard objective lines for any", "i9_0kT3Glio-00716-00184338-00184528": "of these things", "i9_0kT3Glio-00717-00184529-00184690": "um whatsoever", "i9_0kT3Glio-00718-00184691-00184954": "um you will never find like a perfect", "i9_0kT3Glio-00719-00184955-00185302": "answer to questions of of language let", "i9_0kT3Glio-00720-00185303-00185495": "alone questions of whether we should or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00721-00185496-00185704": "shouldn't use it but I think that we can", "i9_0kT3Glio-00722-00185705-00186059": "acknowledge that um that there is a at", "i9_0kT3Glio-00723-00186060-00186335": "least for most people there is still a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00724-00186336-00186563": "very strong stigma", "i9_0kT3Glio-00725-00186564-00186640": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00726-00186641-00186893": "you know a very strong stigma around", "i9_0kT3Glio-00727-00186894-00187169": "this word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00728-00187170-00187331": "and also", "i9_0kT3Glio-00729-00187332-00187709": "I want to point out that like um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00730-00187710-00187978": "there are there are people there are", "i9_0kT3Glio-00731-00187979-00188249": "people with Down Syndrome who have gone", "i9_0kT3Glio-00732-00188250-00188563": "on podcasts and given speeches", "i9_0kT3Glio-00733-00188564-00188795": "specifically talking about the use of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00734-00188796-00189143": "this word and how severely it is used to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00735-00189144-00189245": "hurt them", "i9_0kT3Glio-00736-00189246-00189533": "so on a on another level there is this", "i9_0kT3Glio-00737-00189534-00189838": "sort of Osmosis effect where", "i9_0kT3Glio-00738-00189839-00190073": "um I think that propagating a slur like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00739-00190074-00190325": "that runs the risk of of putting it into", "i9_0kT3Glio-00740-00190326-00190631": "people's common parlance which then does", "i9_0kT3Glio-00741-00190632-00190919": "get used specifically against people who", "i9_0kT3Glio-00742-00190920-00191140": "have traditionally been marginalized by", "i9_0kT3Glio-00743-00191141-00191321": "that word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00744-00191322-00191645": "and it's sad it's sad to see it's sad to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00745-00191646-00191813": "see that happen it's sad to see", "i9_0kT3Glio-00746-00191814-00192016": "someone's life", "i9_0kT3Glio-00747-00192017-00192238": "um be severely negatively impacted", "i9_0kT3Glio-00748-00192239-00192581": "because of a word of a single word for", "i9_0kT3Glio-00749-00192582-00193147": "which we have thousands of other options", "i9_0kT3Glio-00750-00193148-00193588": "and again you guys all know I am not", "i9_0kT3Glio-00751-00193589-00193745": "exactly", "i9_0kT3Glio-00752-00193746-00193828": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00753-00193829-00194152": "uh I am not exactly like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00754-00194153-00194447": "super super scoldy about anything I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00755-00194448-00194771": "don't uh go after people for using the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00756-00194772-00195035": "like certain terminology I don't I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00757-00195036-00195359": "like uh I don't like put stars in the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00758-00195360-00195701": "word stupid or or and I often say that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00759-00195702-00195928": "something is insane I do try to avoid", "i9_0kT3Glio-00760-00195929-00196169": "calling people and saying like calling", "i9_0kT3Glio-00761-00196170-00196331": "people and saying and sometimes I'll", "i9_0kT3Glio-00762-00196332-00196576": "call ideas and saying and whatever or", "i9_0kT3Glio-00763-00196577-00196859": "say this is insane but um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00764-00196860-00197183": "but uh it's it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00765-00197184-00197585": "this one the the the word [__] seems", "i9_0kT3Glio-00766-00197586-00197921": "to cross a lot of lines to me and I I I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00767-00197922-00198143": "have to say I've I've been a little", "i9_0kT3Glio-00768-00198144-00198425": "bummed to see it's the the increase in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00769-00198426-00198557": "its use", "i9_0kT3Glio-00770-00198558-00198785": "somebody in chat here says it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00771-00198786-00198976": "dismissive to say those who have have no", "i9_0kT3Glio-00772-00198977-00199126": "issue with the words have never had it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00773-00199127-00199264": "used against them some of us have just", "i9_0kT3Glio-00774-00199265-00199475": "moved past it I'm not saying it's bad", "i9_0kT3Glio-00775-00199476-00199643": "that others haven't no hold on hold on", "i9_0kT3Glio-00776-00199644-00199876": "let me be clear real quick let me be", "i9_0kT3Glio-00777-00199877-00200063": "clear about this", "i9_0kT3Glio-00778-00200064-00200333": "um I have a really thick skin I'm not", "i9_0kT3Glio-00779-00200334-00200519": "kidding you when I say that every single", "i9_0kT3Glio-00780-00200520-00200735": "day multiple slurs are used against me", "i9_0kT3Glio-00781-00200736-00201107": "if I if online specifically uh if I go", "i9_0kT3Glio-00782-00201108-00201364": "into my comments there is a guarantee", "i9_0kT3Glio-00783-00201365-00201599": "that I will re I will have at least one", "i9_0kT3Glio-00784-00201600-00201875": "comment uh every single day of somebody", "i9_0kT3Glio-00785-00201876-00202133": "calling me some slur okay it's really", "i9_0kT3Glio-00786-00202134-00202421": "common uh I don't really care and the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00787-00202422-00202595": "word [__] doesn't offend me I've said", "i9_0kT3Glio-00788-00202596-00202823": "it a hundred times this stream it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00789-00202824-00203111": "literally the title of my stream and the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00790-00203112-00203375": "word [__] doesn't offend me anymore", "i9_0kT3Glio-00791-00203376-00203549": "but that doesn't mean that I can't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00792-00203550-00203759": "acknowledge what the intent behind it is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00793-00203760-00203950": "and also it doesn't mean that I can't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00794-00203951-00204211": "acknowledge that there is a sort of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00795-00204212-00204664": "problem you know with the uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00796-00204665-00205036": "I don't know with with the normalization", "i9_0kT3Glio-00797-00205037-00205408": "of its use but also I think that we", "i9_0kT3Glio-00798-00205409-00205612": "should be honest with ourselves one of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00799-00205613-00205798": "the things that I think is most that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00800-00205800-00206086": "that I find most frustrating I've seen", "i9_0kT3Glio-00801-00206087-00206362": "this all over the the the YouTube", "i9_0kT3Glio-00802-00206363-00206573": "comments all over Twitter all over", "i9_0kT3Glio-00803-00206573-00206740": "everywhere where this discourse has been", "i9_0kT3Glio-00804-00206741-00207082": "trending uh even in Discord is that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00805-00207083-00207269": "um a lot of people simply aren't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00806-00207269-00207479": "reclaiming the word they say that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00807-00207480-00207664": "they're reclaiming the word but they're", "i9_0kT3Glio-00808-00207665-00207857": "not they're calling other people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00809-00207858-00208084": "[__] they're calling other people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00810-00208085-00208336": "retards that's not the same as", "i9_0kT3Glio-00811-00208337-00208546": "reclaiming it for yourself you are", "i9_0kT3Glio-00812-00208548-00208734": "weaponizing it against someone else", "i9_0kT3Glio-00813-00208735-00209032": "that's not what Reclamation is it just", "i9_0kT3Glio-00814-00209033-00209284": "isn't I'm sorry no matter how you feel", "i9_0kT3Glio-00815-00209285-00209608": "even if you feel that it's okay to call", "i9_0kT3Glio-00816-00209609-00209963": "other people retards", "i9_0kT3Glio-00817-00209964-00210221": "um that's not Reclamation Reclamation is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00818-00210221-00210427": "not when you call other people the word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00819-00210428-00210682": "that's not how it works", "i9_0kT3Glio-00820-00210683-00210946": "and and I find that very frustrating I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00821-00210948-00211241": "find it frustrating to see people over", "i9_0kT3Glio-00822-00211242-00211494": "and over I'm talking hundreds of people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00823-00211496-00211739": "repeating the argument that well I have", "i9_0kT3Glio-00824-00211740-00212165": "ADHD or well X person has ADHD which", "i9_0kT3Glio-00825-00212166-00212284": "means they can call other people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00826-00212285-00212555": "[__] no if we were talking about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00827-00212556-00212831": "Reclamation it would be I can call", "i9_0kT3Glio-00828-00212832-00213065": "myself [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00829-00213066-00213232": "if I want to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00830-00213233-00213484": "which I can and I strongly believe in", "i9_0kT3Glio-00831-00213485-00213665": "that I will call myself a [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00832-00213666-00213856": "trainee [__] whenever the [__] I want", "i9_0kT3Glio-00833-00213857-00213934": "to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00834-00213935-00214156": "me", "i9_0kT3Glio-00835-00214157-00214432": "and and I don't know I just it it feels", "i9_0kT3Glio-00836-00214433-00214696": "like a a mental like a intellectually", "i9_0kT3Glio-00837-00214698-00214979": "bankrupted form of the discourse to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00838-00214980-00215351": "basically uh uh I don't know it seems", "i9_0kT3Glio-00839-00215352-00215531": "like it's an intellectually bankrupted", "i9_0kT3Glio-00840-00215532-00215705": "form of discourse to make an argument", "i9_0kT3Glio-00841-00215706-00216065": "over whether or not someone has a pass", "i9_0kT3Glio-00842-00216066-00216275": "to use something that we can all", "i9_0kT3Glio-00843-00216276-00216496": "acknowledge is a slur for all intents", "i9_0kT3Glio-00844-00216498-00216641": "and purposes", "i9_0kT3Glio-00845-00216642-00216905": "and again I've made my position clear on", "i9_0kT3Glio-00846-00216906-00217073": "all kinds of other words but I think", "i9_0kT3Glio-00847-00217073-00217289": "it's I think it's fairly easy to come to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00848-00217290-00217421": "the conclusion I think it's fairly", "i9_0kT3Glio-00849-00217421-00217631": "reasonable to come to the conclusion", "i9_0kT3Glio-00850-00217632-00217960": "that uh [__] is a word that still", "i9_0kT3Glio-00851-00217961-00218189": "Bears a lot of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00852-00218190-00218471": "um systemic backing that still Bears a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00853-00218471-00218687": "lot of hateful backing in a way that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00854-00218688-00218896": "stupid or idiot doesn't", "i9_0kT3Glio-00855-00218898-00219173": "um stupid and idiot are have been", "i9_0kT3Glio-00856-00219173-00219437": "watered down in their definitions to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00857-00219438-00219719": "such a degree that even though I agree", "i9_0kT3Glio-00858-00219719-00219946": "that there are problematic elements of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00859-00219948-00220115": "those insults", "i9_0kT3Glio-00860-00220116-00220271": "um that they're just not the same they", "i9_0kT3Glio-00861-00220271-00220415": "don't function the same way that they", "i9_0kT3Glio-00862-00220416-00220721": "used to but that is definitely not true", "i9_0kT3Glio-00863-00220721-00220810": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00864-00220811-00221165": "for the word [__] oh and by the way", "i9_0kT3Glio-00865-00221166-00221375": "um if you don't believe me", "i9_0kT3Glio-00866-00221376-00221698": "just go and just just go into a next", "i9_0kT3Glio-00867-00221700-00221825": "time you're at work", "i9_0kT3Glio-00868-00221826-00222196": "uh say something is stupid versus say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00869-00222198-00222406": "something in a public place say", "i9_0kT3Glio-00870-00222407-00222592": "something is stupid versus say something", "i9_0kT3Glio-00871-00222594-00222731": "is [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00872-00222732-00223031": "see what other people like Normie I mean", "i9_0kT3Glio-00873-00223032-00223246": "I highly doubt that any person who here", "i9_0kT3Glio-00874-00223248-00223523": "works works in like the sjw capital of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00875-00223523-00223960": "the world", "i9_0kT3Glio-00876-00223961-00224219": "I have a feeling that you won't be brave", "i9_0kT3Glio-00877-00224219-00224453": "enough to [__] drop the arsler in a", "i9_0kT3Glio-00878-00224454-00224687": "public place but most people would be", "i9_0kT3Glio-00879-00224688-00224981": "like ah this stupid computer", "i9_0kT3Glio-00880-00224982-00225191": "in fact some people might get [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-00881-00225192-00225742": "fired", "i9_0kT3Glio-00882-00225744-00225946": "I'm sure some some people work in an", "i9_0kT3Glio-00883-00225948-00226115": "environment where it's acceptable I'm", "i9_0kT3Glio-00884-00226116-00226271": "sure some people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00885-00226271-00227513": "do but", "i9_0kT3Glio-00886-00227514-00227687": "question did you agree with the thought", "i9_0kT3Glio-00887-00227688-00227921": "slimes hold Nana's thing no I really", "i9_0kT3Glio-00888-00227921-00228155": "didn't because I don't think that Nana's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00889-00228156-00228551": "uh is is can be reasonably uh defined as", "i9_0kT3Glio-00890-00228552-00228646": "a slur", "i9_0kT3Glio-00891-00228648-00229067": "I don't I don't mind if thought slime", "i9_0kT3Glio-00892-00229067-00229277": "um like doesn't want to use words like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00893-00229278-00229498": "that like obviously you have every right", "i9_0kT3Glio-00894-00229500-00229708": "but I just I don't think that you can", "i9_0kT3Glio-00895-00229709-00229931": "make the same case for nanners that you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00896-00229932-00230134": "can for something else", "i9_0kT3Glio-00897-00230135-00230303": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00898-00230304-00230525": "you know", "i9_0kT3Glio-00899-00230526-00230710": "I just don't think it reaches that level", "i9_0kT3Glio-00900-00230711-00230848": "I don't even think I think it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-00901-00230850-00231089": "distanced in multiple ways like bananas", "i9_0kT3Glio-00902-00231090-00231451": "yeah like bananas yes", "i9_0kT3Glio-00903-00231452-00231706": "well I just talked about crazy I see", "i9_0kT3Glio-00904-00231707-00231958": "some people asking about crazy", "i9_0kT3Glio-00905-00231959-00232271": "um and I think uh and and I also see", "i9_0kT3Glio-00906-00232271-00232432": "people talking about idiot and stupid", "i9_0kT3Glio-00907-00232433-00232625": "and I do think that like like don't get", "i9_0kT3Glio-00908-00232626-00232823": "me wrong I think there are problems with", "i9_0kT3Glio-00909-00232823-00232996": "these insults", "i9_0kT3Glio-00910-00232998-00233158": "um but I think that the difference", "i9_0kT3Glio-00911-00233159-00233441": "between an insult is a and a slur is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00912-00233442-00233584": "generally", "i9_0kT3Glio-00913-00233585-00233681": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00914-00233682-00233898": "the there's there's a historical", "i9_0kT3Glio-00915-00233900-00234275": "precedent and there is a uh and there is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00916-00234276-00234634": "also like contextual uh elements that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00917-00234635-00234910": "matter and I I just", "i9_0kT3Glio-00918-00234911-00235151": "I think there's a very the argument I've", "i9_0kT3Glio-00919-00235152-00235355": "been making this entire time is that I I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00920-00235356-00235621": "think that the the that [__] is", "i9_0kT3Glio-00921-00235621-00235931": "severely more harsh than basically any", "i9_0kT3Glio-00922-00235932-00236171": "insult that we see thrown around and", "i9_0kT3Glio-00923-00236171-00236519": "also that it has a more significant", "i9_0kT3Glio-00924-00236519-00236884": "negative effect on random people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00925-00236885-00237232": "um that are not your target", "i9_0kT3Glio-00926-00237233-00237496": "um I don't really care if somebody calls", "i9_0kT3Glio-00927-00237498-00237803": "a Nazi a [__] uh I don't really care", "i9_0kT3Glio-00928-00237804-00238042": "what people call Nazis there's all kinds", "i9_0kT3Glio-00929-00238044-00238355": "of things but I think that um that if", "i9_0kT3Glio-00930-00238356-00238523": "you get into the habit of calling things", "i9_0kT3Glio-00931-00238523-00238805": "[__] in the same level of um of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00932-00238806-00239194": "frequency in the same level of of uh uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00933-00239196-00239482": "of of treatment as like a word like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00934-00239483-00239621": "stupid", "i9_0kT3Glio-00935-00239621-00239855": "um I think that you run the risk of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00936-00239856-00240065": "hurting more people there are a lot of", "i9_0kT3Glio-00937-00240066-00240191": "people who've been hurt by the word", "i9_0kT3Glio-00938-00240192-00240448": "[__] I mean I just did a little quick", "i9_0kT3Glio-00939-00240450-00240658": "off the hand chat poll", "i9_0kT3Glio-00940-00240659-00240815": "um which I hope that everyone who", "i9_0kT3Glio-00941-00240816-00241001": "watches this video is going to see live", "i9_0kT3Glio-00942-00241002-00241187": "you know they're gonna see it the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00943-00241188-00241379": "numbers go flying as how many people", "i9_0kT3Glio-00944-00241380-00241727": "have had it weaponized against them", "i9_0kT3Glio-00945-00241728-00241937": "posadas John says do you think that it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00946-00241938-00242129": "could become the new idiot like it once", "i9_0kT3Glio-00947-00242130-00242315": "it's not Medical Institution stop using", "i9_0kT3Glio-00948-00242316-00242465": "so did everyone else it just lost it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00949-00242466-00242705": "over time well I don't think that idiot", "i9_0kT3Glio-00950-00242706-00243029": "was ever used to the same degree", "i9_0kT3Glio-00951-00243030-00243275": "um like it never like idiot never had", "i9_0kT3Glio-00952-00243276-00243484": "the same connotation", "i9_0kT3Glio-00953-00243485-00243706": "if that makes sense", "i9_0kT3Glio-00954-00243707-00243779": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00955-00243780-00243917": "uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00956-00243917-00244265": "so I don't know if it ever will like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00957-00244266-00244546": "at the moment like there would have to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00958-00244548-00244798": "be like I don't know I feel like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00959-00244800-00245219": "I I feel like people would um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00960-00245219-00245501": "I don't know I I feel like like it would", "i9_0kT3Glio-00961-00245502-00245651": "have to there would have to be a period", "i9_0kT3Glio-00962-00245652-00245908": "where people stopped using it for it to", "i9_0kT3Glio-00963-00245909-00246131": "stop having its impact but as it stands", "i9_0kT3Glio-00964-00246132-00246394": "right now it's just like continually", "i9_0kT3Glio-00965-00246396-00246941": "coming back right", "i9_0kT3Glio-00966-00246942-00247163": "and keep in mind that like I don't even", "i9_0kT3Glio-00967-00247164-00247306": "think that people should be like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00968-00247307-00247529": "canceled over this word I just what I'm", "i9_0kT3Glio-00969-00247530-00247715": "my argument here is that I think that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00970-00247716-00247841": "people should be a little bit more", "i9_0kT3Glio-00971-00247842-00248051": "honest and not pretend that they're", "i9_0kT3Glio-00972-00248052-00248225": "reclaiming a word when they're using it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00973-00248226-00248434": "against other people and also that", "i9_0kT3Glio-00974-00248435-00248603": "people should be thoughtful about", "i9_0kT3Glio-00975-00248604-00248782": "whether or not they really want to use", "i9_0kT3Glio-00976-00248783-00249091": "that word like are we gaining that much", "i9_0kT3Glio-00977-00249092-00249425": "what's the game we have there are so", "i9_0kT3Glio-00978-00249426-00249598": "many good insults that you can use", "i9_0kT3Glio-00979-00249600-00249923": "there's tons that are super hard-hitting", "i9_0kT3Glio-00980-00249923-00250001": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00981-00250002-00250198": "and I don't know like I don't see", "i9_0kT3Glio-00982-00250200-00250565": "anybody uh trying to defend like the use", "i9_0kT3Glio-00983-00250566-00250877": "of the word [__] as an insult ever I've", "i9_0kT3Glio-00984-00250878-00251171": "never seen anyone besides like actual", "i9_0kT3Glio-00985-00251171-00251387": "Nazis trying to defend the use of the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00986-00251388-00251596": "word [__] as an insult", "i9_0kT3Glio-00987-00251598-00251806": "I think I I don't use it but that's the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00988-00251807-00251981": "intention I think when people use it it", "i9_0kT3Glio-00989-00251982-00252155": "isn't meant to call people disabled I", "i9_0kT3Glio-00990-00252156-00252346": "disagree", "i9_0kT3Glio-00991-00252348-00252581": "um and in fact it's really funny if you", "i9_0kT3Glio-00992-00252582-00252767": "guys go and watch right wing creators", "i9_0kT3Glio-00993-00252767-00252953": "look at when right look at what", "i9_0kT3Glio-00994-00252954-00253265": "right-wing creators do when they use um", "i9_0kT3Glio-00995-00253266-00253541": "when they use the word [__] because uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-00996-00253542-00253787": "you know unlike other slurs where the", "i9_0kT3Glio-00997-00253788-00253955": "left and right have been decided like", "i9_0kT3Glio-00998-00253956-00254092": "for example", "i9_0kT3Glio-00999-00254094-00254237": "um you know right Wingers don't give a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01000-00254238-00254387": "[__] about using the word [__] or", "i9_0kT3Glio-01001-00254388-00254681": "[__] right but uh because you know that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01002-00254682-00254831": "they they're decided on that the left", "i9_0kT3Glio-01003-00254832-00255046": "will not use those terminology but the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01004-00255048-00255148": "right will", "i9_0kT3Glio-01005-00255150-00255298": "um but the left right at the moment", "i9_0kT3Glio-01006-00255300-00255448": "there's a lot of lefties who will use", "i9_0kT3Glio-01007-00255450-00255581": "the word [__] and there's a lot of", "i9_0kT3Glio-01008-00255582-00255767": "righties that will use the word [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-01009-00255767-00255965": "and if you go and obviously the word", "i9_0kT3Glio-01010-00255966-00256198": "[__] is used more popularly on the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01011-00256200-00256391": "right and if you go and look at what", "i9_0kT3Glio-01012-00256392-00256589": "people do when they I mean I could", "i9_0kT3Glio-01013-00256590-00256798": "probably search it right now", "i9_0kT3Glio-01014-00256800-00256984": "um you want to know what in person what", "i9_0kT3Glio-01015-00256985-00257219": "type of impersonations people do", "i9_0kT3Glio-01016-00257219-00257489": "you want to know the noises and The", "i9_0kT3Glio-01017-00257490-00257644": "Impressions that people do when they", "i9_0kT3Glio-01018-00257646-00257873": "call people [__] you guys know", "i9_0kT3Glio-01019-00257873-00258017": "exactly what I'm talking about I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-01020-00258017-00258244": "even need I don't even have to show you", "i9_0kT3Glio-01021-00258246-00258448": "you all know exactly what I'm talking", "i9_0kT3Glio-01022-00258450-00258821": "about so I just do not think uh yep", "i9_0kT3Glio-01023-00258821-00259042": "every single yep skunksy says nearly", "i9_0kT3Glio-01024-00259044-00259241": "every time the arsler is used like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01025-00259242-00259546": "outside of like progressives who", "i9_0kT3Glio-01026-00259548-00259727": "ironically use the r word they do a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01027-00259728-00259858": "mocking voice sometimes even", "i9_0kT3Glio-01028-00259859-00260117": "progressives do that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01029-00260117-00260255": "yeah", "i9_0kT3Glio-01030-00260256-00260525": "so I just don't think that um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01031-00260526-00260825": "I I just I just don't think that the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01032-00260826-00260987": "idea that it's distanced from its", "i9_0kT3Glio-01033-00260988-00261101": "original meaning I don't think that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-01034-00261102-00261298": "true I don't think you I don't think", "i9_0kT3Glio-01035-00261300-00261508": "there's enough evidence to point that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01036-00261509-00261641": "it's been distance from its original", "i9_0kT3Glio-01037-00261642-00261923": "meaning", "i9_0kT3Glio-01038-00261923-00263406": "yeah Adam Sandler movies yeah", "i9_0kT3Glio-01039-00263407-00263675": "lithium-55 says I disagree that the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01040-00263676-00263837": "arsler would have to stop being used as", "i9_0kT3Glio-01041-00263838-00263993": "an insult for it to become not a slur", "i9_0kT3Glio-01042-00263994-00264179": "whoever would have to stop being used to", "i9_0kT3Glio-01043-00264180-00264287": "Target people because they're", "i9_0kT3Glio-01044-00264288-00264460": "neurodivergent which doesn't seem like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01045-00264461-00264593": "it's going to happen in the next decade", "i9_0kT3Glio-01046-00264594-00264760": "I don't think it will", "i9_0kT3Glio-01047-00264761-00266191": "I really don't think it will", "i9_0kT3Glio-01048-00266192-00266687": "DC DCL uh DCL Junior 33 says I think the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01049-00266688-00266891": "word I use most instead of insane or", "i9_0kT3Glio-01050-00266892-00267179": "bananas or anything like that is wild or", "i9_0kT3Glio-01051-00267180-00267334": "um yeah another one people use is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01052-00267335-00267575": "unhinged uh and and I actually think", "i9_0kT3Glio-01053-00267576-00267749": "that unhinged is usually a better", "i9_0kT3Glio-01054-00267750-00267929": "replacement for things like crazy or", "i9_0kT3Glio-01055-00267930-00268121": "insane even though I do use crazy and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01056-00268122-00268349": "insane I'll load up to that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01057-00268350-00268547": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01058-00268548-00268606": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01059-00268607-00268960": "and uh uh uh and I think the reason why", "i9_0kT3Glio-01060-00268961-00269195": "is because like unhinged means like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01061-00269196-00269471": "you're uh you're you're not under you're", "i9_0kT3Glio-01062-00269472-00269651": "you're acting at like out of your own", "i9_0kT3Glio-01063-00269652-00269837": "control you've lost control of your", "i9_0kT3Glio-01064-00269838-00270167": "emotional state it's more of a a an like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01065-00270168-00270491": "impuning someone for uh for being out of", "i9_0kT3Glio-01066-00270492-00270737": "control and and lashing out at others as", "i9_0kT3Glio-01067-00270738-00270971": "opposed to some sort of like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01068-00270972-00271306": "commentary on their state of sanity", "i9_0kT3Glio-01069-00271307-00271487": "uh the moment we start drawing lines", "i9_0kT3Glio-01070-00271488-00271667": "between what can be used and what", "i9_0kT3Glio-01071-00271668-00271799": "shouldn't be used we get people doing", "i9_0kT3Glio-01072-00271800-00271984": "bad faith arguments about what slurs", "i9_0kT3Glio-01073-00271985-00272141": "they can use well that's why I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-01074-00272142-00272369": "really care I don't really there's no", "i9_0kT3Glio-01075-00272370-00272645": "it's language there's no objective lines", "i9_0kT3Glio-01076-00272646-00272921": "that can ever be drawn like it is very", "i9_0kT3Glio-01077-00272922-00273179": "difficult to make a objective moral", "i9_0kT3Glio-01078-00273180-00273347": "argument about language so I'm not even", "i9_0kT3Glio-01079-00273348-00273677": "gonna bother I'm making a case for why I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01080-00273678-00273923": "think that calling people [__] and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01081-00273924-00274151": "calling people retards is not really", "i9_0kT3Glio-01082-00274152-00274439": "efficacious and is it is mean-spirited", "i9_0kT3Glio-01083-00274440-00274823": "and does collateral damage", "i9_0kT3Glio-01084-00274824-00275225": "um you know like I think it does uh and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01085-00275226-00275441": "and I think that people who care about", "i9_0kT3Glio-01086-00275442-00275729": "that sort of thing should pay attention", "i9_0kT3Glio-01087-00275730-00275837": "to that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01088-00275838-00276119": "and I just uh when people there I know", "i9_0kT3Glio-01089-00276120-00276227": "that there's going to be people there", "i9_0kT3Glio-01090-00276228-00276443": "who say that like oh well stupid and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01091-00276444-00276623": "idiot are the same thing but I just", "i9_0kT3Glio-01092-00276624-00276893": "don't agree I just do not think that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01093-00276894-00277265": "most people uh uh uh like have the same", "i9_0kT3Glio-01094-00277266-00277510": "attachment to those words like by far I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01095-00277511-00277751": "think that the vast majority of people I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01096-00277752-00277960": "don't think that most people that you've", "i9_0kT3Glio-01097-00277961-00278230": "met have been called an idiot in the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01098-00278231-00278465": "same way that they've been called a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01099-00278466-00278699": "[__] in their life", "i9_0kT3Glio-01100-00278700-00278951": "um because being called a [__] is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01101-00278952-00279184": "basically a universal experience for", "i9_0kT3Glio-01102-00279185-00279527": "anyone with ADHD or Autism", "i9_0kT3Glio-01103-00279528-00279725": "um being called a [__] by somebody who", "i9_0kT3Glio-01104-00279726-00279905": "you're supposed to be able to trust is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01105-00279906-00280121": "an almost Universal experience for", "i9_0kT3Glio-01106-00280122-00280384": "people who have ADHD or Autism", "i9_0kT3Glio-01107-00280385-00280577": "um to the to the degree that like idiot", "i9_0kT3Glio-01108-00280578-00280834": "and stupid is not like idiot and stupid", "i9_0kT3Glio-01109-00280835-00281080": "every single person on the planet has", "i9_0kT3Glio-01110-00281081-00281279": "been called stupid or has called someone", "i9_0kT3Glio-01111-00281280-00281560": "stupid in their entire life", "i9_0kT3Glio-01112-00281561-00281789": "um not but but not everyone on the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01113-00281790-00282082": "planet how has been called a [__] by", "i9_0kT3Glio-01114-00282083-00282419": "by somebody who uh you know it's used", "i9_0kT3Glio-01115-00282420-00282634": "for bullying it's not idiot and stupid", "i9_0kT3Glio-01116-00282635-00282910": "are like insults in general but they're", "i9_0kT3Glio-01117-00282911-00283127": "very generalized insults every single", "i9_0kT3Glio-01118-00283128-00283295": "person comes into contact with those all", "i9_0kT3Glio-01119-00283296-00283493": "the time and that's not the case for the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01120-00283494-00283649": "word [__] I just don't think it has", "i9_0kT3Glio-01121-00283650-00284410": "the same hit", "i9_0kT3Glio-01122-00284411-00284549": "I mean I feel like probably everyone has", "i9_0kT3Glio-01123-00284550-00284717": "been called a [__] at least once yeah", "i9_0kT3Glio-01124-00284718-00284867": "but I mean come on it's not the same", "i9_0kT3Glio-01125-00284868-00285851": "thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-01126-00285852-00286271": "when look to to send the point home", "i9_0kT3Glio-01127-00286272-00286373": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01128-00286374-00286582": "when I was younger a lot of people use", "i9_0kT3Glio-01129-00286583-00286841": "the word like that's [__] bro that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-01130-00286842-00287045": "[__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-01131-00287046-00287351": "um but it was it was seen as a insult", "i9_0kT3Glio-01132-00287352-00287567": "that was almost exclusively used by", "i9_0kT3Glio-01133-00287568-00287927": "older kids and it exclusively used by uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-01134-00287928-00288160": "like the edgiest kids", "i9_0kT3Glio-01135-00288161-00288551": "um uh and uh and lots of people said it", "i9_0kT3Glio-01136-00288552-00288880": "um but interestingly it was said in the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01137-00288881-00289073": "it was said in the same way that words", "i9_0kT3Glio-01138-00289074-00289277": "like [__] were said where you would", "i9_0kT3Glio-01139-00289278-00289451": "never say like it was never said when", "i9_0kT3Glio-01140-00289452-00289649": "parents were around it was never set", "i9_0kT3Glio-01141-00289650-00289871": "around like younger kids unless it was", "i9_0kT3Glio-01142-00289872-00290129": "being used to bully", "i9_0kT3Glio-01143-00290130-00290267": "yeah", "i9_0kT3Glio-01144-00290268-00290465": "and wait but also that's a great example", "i9_0kT3Glio-01145-00290466-00290615": "hold on people are bringing up that it", "i9_0kT3Glio-01146-00290616-00290747": "was that a lot of people used to say", "i9_0kT3Glio-01147-00290748-00291041": "that's gay and yet guess what a lot of", "i9_0kT3Glio-01148-00291042-00291184": "people have moved away from that too", "i9_0kT3Glio-01149-00291185-00291382": "haven't they for pretty good reasons", "i9_0kT3Glio-01150-00291383-00291665": "right because like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01151-00291666-00291910": "um calling somebody gay as if it's an", "i9_0kT3Glio-01152-00291911-00292145": "insult is generally considered it's like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01153-00292146-00292367": "almost all of society will agree that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01154-00292368-00293069": "that's not acceptable right", "i9_0kT3Glio-01155-00293070-00293267": "I just I think that people have moved", "i9_0kT3Glio-01156-00293268-00293927": "past that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01157-00293928-00294197": "and some people use it like uh some", "i9_0kT3Glio-01158-00294198-00294449": "people use it sort of facetiously uh now", "i9_0kT3Glio-01159-00294450-00294701": "but very few people like how many people", "i9_0kT3Glio-01160-00294702-00295025": "do you go and see oh that's have you", "i9_0kT3Glio-01161-00295026-00295253": "ever [__] tuned in to your favorite", "i9_0kT3Glio-01162-00295254-00295475": "like streamer or whatever and had them", "i9_0kT3Glio-01163-00295476-00295577": "go", "i9_0kT3Glio-01164-00295578-00295901": "uh this video this video game is gay as", "i9_0kT3Glio-01165-00295902-00296080": "[__] [__] it's the gayest [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-01166-00296081-00296308": "[__] you're a gay [__] [__] you", "i9_0kT3Glio-01167-00296309-00296501": "you gay ass piece of [__] you would", "i9_0kT3Glio-01168-00296502-00296687": "think that would be pretty weird I think", "i9_0kT3Glio-01169-00296688-00296897": "most people would would respond to that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01170-00296898-00297167": "pretty weird especially on the left", "i9_0kT3Glio-01171-00297168-00297455": "people would respond that to that pretty", "i9_0kT3Glio-01172-00297456-00297743": "weirdly", "i9_0kT3Glio-01173-00297744-00298693": "foreign", "i9_0kT3Glio-01174-00298694-00298919": "says I get the sense we tend to use", "i9_0kT3Glio-01175-00298920-00299182": "[__] a lot more for bullying amab kids", "i9_0kT3Glio-01176-00299183-00299387": "and it could be a difference in gendered", "i9_0kT3Glio-01177-00299388-00299597": "child culture as someone who grew up", "i9_0kT3Glio-01178-00299598-00299801": "more in childhood girl culture I heard", "i9_0kT3Glio-01179-00299802-00299987": "the word [__] used a lot less when I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01180-00299988-00300179": "was around older boys that's actually an", "i9_0kT3Glio-01181-00300180-00300395": "experience I had as well", "i9_0kT3Glio-01182-00300396-00300479": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01183-00300480-00300713": "when I was in high school you know I I'm", "i9_0kT3Glio-01184-00300714-00300906": "trans when I was in high school I lived", "i9_0kT3Glio-01185-00300907-00301163": "outwardly as a boy", "i9_0kT3Glio-01186-00301164-00301445": "um one of the the in the later uh the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01187-00301446-00301619": "latter half of high school I hung out", "i9_0kT3Glio-01188-00301620-00301847": "with a group of a friend group that was", "i9_0kT3Glio-01189-00301848-00302027": "almost entirely comprised of girls this", "i9_0kT3Glio-01190-00302028-00302255": "was in the later half they never used", "i9_0kT3Glio-01191-00302256-00302506": "the word [__] they also never called", "i9_0kT3Glio-01192-00302507-00302806": "anything gay it was very strange", "i9_0kT3Glio-01193-00302807-00303155": "um and yet uh among the the the the guy", "i9_0kT3Glio-01194-00303156-00303341": "friend groups that I had previously hung", "i9_0kT3Glio-01195-00303342-00303575": "out with uh they were really first of", "i9_0kT3Glio-01196-00303576-00303695": "all they were horrible to each other", "i9_0kT3Glio-01197-00303696-00303845": "they were physically abusive to one", "i9_0kT3Glio-01198-00303846-00304025": "another but they were also verbally", "i9_0kT3Glio-01199-00304026-00304253": "abusive to one another all the time and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01200-00304254-00304505": "calling somebody a gay [__] or calling", "i9_0kT3Glio-01201-00304506-00304787": "somebody a [__] gay [__] was really", "i9_0kT3Glio-01202-00304788-00305477": "common", "i9_0kT3Glio-01203-00305478-00305747": "use of the r slur seems really heavily", "i9_0kT3Glio-01204-00305748-00306454": "tied to hyper masculinity", "i9_0kT3Glio-01205-00306455-00306653": "I'm sure this isn't Universal but I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01206-00306654-00306869": "think it I think it speaks to the types", "i9_0kT3Glio-01207-00306870-00307127": "of I think it speaks to the types of uh", "i9_0kT3Glio-01208-00307128-00307421": "of the way that the word is used that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01209-00307422-00307732": "the word is used in sort of uh masculine", "i9_0kT3Glio-01210-00307733-00308075": "dominance uh and or I should say not", "i9_0kT3Glio-01211-00308076-00308219": "even just masculine dominance but it's", "i9_0kT3Glio-01212-00308220-00308465": "used in dominance plays more than other", "i9_0kT3Glio-01213-00308466-00308591": "words", "i9_0kT3Glio-01214-00308592-00308771": "that's why I want to use these words", "i9_0kT3Glio-01215-00308772-00308951": "they can be transmuted from lead to Gold", "i9_0kT3Glio-01216-00308952-00309197": "can they", "i9_0kT3Glio-01217-00309198-00309479": "do you genuinely believe that calling", "i9_0kT3Glio-01218-00309480-00309695": "other people [__] all the time is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01219-00309696-00309934": "actually going to reclaim the word or is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01220-00309935-00310103": "it just going to ensure that it", "i9_0kT3Glio-01221-00310104-00310397": "maintains its status as a slur that is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01222-00310398-00310553": "hurtful to people", "i9_0kT3Glio-01223-00310554-00310913": "I just uh I just don't buy it", "i9_0kT3Glio-01224-00310914-00311153": "I don't buy that it's useful I don't buy", "i9_0kT3Glio-01225-00311154-00311351": "that we get I don't buy the idea that we", "i9_0kT3Glio-01226-00311352-00311639": "gain anything from it I don't think that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01227-00311640-00311704": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01228-00311705-00311873": "I don't think that anybody gains", "i9_0kT3Glio-01229-00311874-00312137": "anything from using the arsler", "i9_0kT3Glio-01230-00312138-00312449": "like calling people [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-01231-00312450-00312610": "um I don't think anybody gains anything", "i9_0kT3Glio-01232-00312611-00312832": "from that but I do know by the way I I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01233-00312833-00313037": "am very convinced of the fact that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01234-00313038-00313282": "self-referentially using slurs can be a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01235-00313283-00313445": "rallying cry", "i9_0kT3Glio-01236-00313446-00313660": "when I stand up and say I am a proud", "i9_0kT3Glio-01237-00313661-00313889": "[__] I know that people can gain", "i9_0kT3Glio-01238-00313890-00314080": "strength from that because it's taking", "i9_0kT3Glio-01239-00314081-00314297": "an insult that's used against them and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01240-00314298-00314549": "turning it into a piece of armor a thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-01241-00314550-00314704": "that makes you stronger but I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-01242-00314705-00314867": "think that's true for just saying", "i9_0kT3Glio-01243-00314868-00315425": "calling people retards randomly", "i9_0kT3Glio-01244-00315426-00315647": "I guess we would lose a slur if it", "i9_0kT3Glio-01245-00315648-00315875": "worked yeah but I just I just don't buy", "i9_0kT3Glio-01246-00315876-00316084": "that using the slur in the exact same", "i9_0kT3Glio-01247-00316085-00316319": "way that that people who use it you know", "i9_0kT3Glio-01248-00316320-00316582": "like like what what is the can anybody", "i9_0kT3Glio-01249-00316583-00316751": "elucidate me to the difference between", "i9_0kT3Glio-01250-00316752-00317021": "Stephen Crowder calling uh liberals", "i9_0kT3Glio-01251-00317022-00317303": "[__] versus I don't know what Lefty", "i9_0kT3Glio-01252-00317304-00317489": "calling Republicans [__] isn't that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01253-00317490-00317806": "not just isn't that not just reinforcing", "i9_0kT3Glio-01254-00317807-00318065": "its use as the exact same", "i9_0kT3Glio-01255-00318066-00318880": "thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-01256-00318881-00319073": "I I don't know that there's oh the", "i9_0kT3Glio-01257-00319074-00319469": "epsler uh I mean the epsler I mean I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01258-00319470-00319625": "think the epstler has already been", "i9_0kT3Glio-01259-00319626-00319823": "reclaimed I think that the effler has", "i9_0kT3Glio-01260-00319824-00320075": "been reclaimed for a long time", "i9_0kT3Glio-01261-00320076-00320171": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01262-00320172-00320453": "even normies even like even some", "i9_0kT3Glio-01263-00320454-00320777": "conservatives like well actually no most", "i9_0kT3Glio-01264-00320778-00320993": "conservatives uh the average", "i9_0kT3Glio-01265-00320994-00321263": "conservative is not okay with calling", "i9_0kT3Glio-01266-00321264-00321473": "gay people [__] the average", "i9_0kT3Glio-01267-00321474-00321706": "conservative like if you were to go into", "i9_0kT3Glio-01268-00321707-00321965": "a workplace no one if you were in a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01269-00321966-00322175": "workplace and you called you said ah my", "i9_0kT3Glio-01270-00322176-00322499": "stupid phone uh they're they're gonna be", "i9_0kT3Glio-01271-00322500-00322721": "nobody is gonna bat an eye but if you", "i9_0kT3Glio-01272-00322722-00322906": "said this stupid [__] [__] phone", "i9_0kT3Glio-01273-00322907-00323117": "even conservatives would feel", "i9_0kT3Glio-01274-00323118-00323279": "uncomfortable with that like I'm talking", "i9_0kT3Glio-01275-00323280-00323584": "bog standard conservatives not like not", "i9_0kT3Glio-01276-00323585-00323987": "like hardliners", "i9_0kT3Glio-01277-00323988-00324089": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01278-00324090-00325247": "you know what I mean", "i9_0kT3Glio-01279-00325248-00325595": "yeah I just I just feel like", "i9_0kT3Glio-01280-00325596-00325727": "I just", "i9_0kT3Glio-01281-00325728-00327923": "I don't know", "i9_0kT3Glio-01282-00327924-00328163": "ducky Lucy hay says interestingly enough", "i9_0kT3Glio-01283-00328164-00328397": "and uh Lucy met bogg standard", "i9_0kT3Glio-01284-00328398-00328534": "conservatives from the U.S that were not", "i9_0kT3Glio-01285-00328535-00328715": "okay with the arsler oh my parents used", "i9_0kT3Glio-01286-00328716-00328943": "to get mad at me my very conservative", "i9_0kT3Glio-01287-00328944-00329104": "parents used to used to get mad at me", "i9_0kT3Glio-01288-00329105-00329267": "because it was unchristian", "i9_0kT3Glio-01289-00329268-00329560": "in their mind it was unchristian to to", "i9_0kT3Glio-01290-00329561-00329789": "use to call people [__] so they", "i9_0kT3Glio-01291-00329790-00330017": "hated it when when you know my friends", "i9_0kT3Glio-01292-00330018-00330275": "would use that word but that's kind of a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01293-00330276-00330503": "an odd example I don't know I don't know", "i9_0kT3Glio-01294-00330504-00330827": "for sure how that is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01295-00330828-00331037": "okay Capo Capo brings up something", "i9_0kT3Glio-01296-00331038-00331234": "really good Capo says the average", "i9_0kT3Glio-01297-00331235-00331451": "conservative isn't actually offended by", "i9_0kT3Glio-01298-00331452-00331637": "by the word [__] the average", "i9_0kT3Glio-01299-00331638-00331834": "conservative knows better than to not", "i9_0kT3Glio-01300-00331835-00332045": "act like they are in public but that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-01301-00332046-00332327": "the difference right isn't that exactly", "i9_0kT3Glio-01302-00332328-00332449": "what I was talking about that's that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-01303-00332450-00332645": "exactly what I was talking about with", "i9_0kT3Glio-01304-00332646-00332879": "the n-word that we've created a line", "i9_0kT3Glio-01305-00332880-00333101": "that there is a societally understood", "i9_0kT3Glio-01306-00333102-00333377": "line that is taught to people that says", "i9_0kT3Glio-01307-00333378-00333617": "hey if you are if you don't belong to", "i9_0kT3Glio-01308-00333618-00333832": "this identity group you have no right", "i9_0kT3Glio-01309-00333833-00334097": "using a word that was used to hurt that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01310-00334098-00334319": "identity group and you especially have", "i9_0kT3Glio-01311-00334320-00334487": "no right to use it against somebody else", "i9_0kT3Glio-01312-00334488-00334769": "and I think that is an important line", "i9_0kT3Glio-01313-00334770-00335375": "with regard to Reclamation", "i9_0kT3Glio-01314-00335376-00335710": "like I I think that um yeah no that's", "i9_0kT3Glio-01315-00335711-00335879": "fair Capo I was agreeing with you I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01316-00335880-00336184": "think you're right on the money there", "i9_0kT3Glio-01317-00336185-00336851": "um", "i9_0kT3Glio-01318-00336852-00337115": "Susie Q says hell now brother we have", "i9_0kT3Glio-01319-00337116-00337282": "the right to refuse service to anyone", "i9_0kT3Glio-01320-00337283-00337480": "and we do not tolerate that type of", "i9_0kT3Glio-01321-00337481-00337745": "chicanery in this fine establishment no", "i9_0kT3Glio-01322-00337746-00338297": "sir", "i9_0kT3Glio-01323-00338298-00338747": "yeah so", "i9_0kT3Glio-01324-00338748-00339095": "anyway all of this is to say uh I I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01325-00339096-00339425": "think that people should I I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01326-00339426-00339653": "I'm Never Gonna Cancel someone for", "i9_0kT3Glio-01327-00339654-00339875": "having different differences of opinion", "i9_0kT3Glio-01328-00339876-00340084": "on certain words", "i9_0kT3Glio-01329-00340085-00340373": "um I will say certain slurs I think you", "i9_0kT3Glio-01330-00340374-00340606": "deserve to get canceled over uh I don't", "i9_0kT3Glio-01331-00340607-00340804": "know that I believe that the word [__]", "i9_0kT3Glio-01332-00340805-00341273": "is is like uh if it's valuable to to", "i9_0kT3Glio-01333-00341274-00341710": "like to hyper police people on it but I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01334-00341711-00341891": "would like to urge people to think a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01335-00341892-00342137": "little bit harder and please one thing I", "i9_0kT3Glio-01336-00342138-00342377": "must insist", "i9_0kT3Glio-01337-00342378-00342743": "um uh one one thing I must insist on is", "i9_0kT3Glio-01338-00342744-00342977": "please stop [__] lying to yourselves", "i9_0kT3Glio-01339-00342978-00343277": "do not tell me that you are reclaiming a", "i9_0kT3Glio-01340-00343278-00343558": "word when you say when you call someone", "i9_0kT3Glio-01341-00343559-00343810": "else a slur you're not reclaiming a slur", "i9_0kT3Glio-01342-00343811-00344045": "by using it to [__] diminish somebody", "i9_0kT3Glio-01343-00344046-00344353": "else you're not uh you're not reclaiming", "i9_0kT3Glio-01344-00344354-00344753": "uh uh the Tesla by calling somebody else", "i9_0kT3Glio-01345-00344754-00344975": "a [__] [__] uh because you're mad", "i9_0kT3Glio-01346-00344976-00345143": "on a live stream or you're mad on", "i9_0kT3Glio-01347-00345144-00345323": "twitter.com and you're not reclaiming", "i9_0kT3Glio-01348-00345324-00345587": "the word [__] by calling other people", "i9_0kT3Glio-01349-00345588-00345958": "retards like like honestly please just", "i9_0kT3Glio-01350-00345959-00346204": "stop it's such a bad argument and it and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01351-00346205-00346439": "it makes you it makes you I know that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01352-00346440-00346595": "ninety percent of the people who are", "i9_0kT3Glio-01353-00346596-00346763": "making that argument aren't doing so", "i9_0kT3Glio-01354-00346764-00347032": "genuinely that that that they know that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01355-00347033-00347273": "that's not what Reclamation means", "i9_0kT3Glio-01356-00347274-00347501": "um I I'm I'm not gonna I'm not gonna", "i9_0kT3Glio-01357-00347502-00347729": "like not be your friend or whatever if", "i9_0kT3Glio-01358-00347730-00347956": "you if you use words that I don't agree", "i9_0kT3Glio-01359-00347957-00348154": "with necessarily", "i9_0kT3Glio-01360-00348155-00348365": "um I would like to earn urge people to", "i9_0kT3Glio-01361-00348366-00348527": "be a little more thoughtful about it and", "i9_0kT3Glio-01362-00348528-00348719": "perhaps consider whether they're", "i9_0kT3Glio-01363-00348720-00348887": "actually getting the value from it that", "i9_0kT3Glio-01364-00348888-00349049": "they seem to that they think they are", "i9_0kT3Glio-01365-00349050-00349289": "but I will get very annoyed if you have", "i9_0kT3Glio-01366-00349290-00349504": "a very shitty argument for why you're", "i9_0kT3Glio-01367-00349505-00349732": "using that thing", "i9_0kT3Glio-01368-00349733-00350114": "um God it drives me crazy"}}, {"audio_id": "i9QAWuoHye0", "text": {"i9QAWuoHye0-00000-00000056-00000367": "Ulysses us-uk is a decommissioned", "i9QAWuoHye0-00001-00000368-00000548": "robotic space probe whose primary", "i9QAWuoHye0-00002-00000549-00000751": "mission was to orbit the Sun and study", "i9QAWuoHye0-00003-00000752-00001012": "it at all latitudes it was launched in", "i9QAWuoHye0-00004-00001013-00001420": "1990 made three fast latitude scans of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00005-00001421-00001957": "the Sun in 1994 1995 2000 2001 and 2007", "i9QAWuoHye0-00006-00001959-00002293": "2008 in addition the probe studied", "i9QAWuoHye0-00007-00002294-00002549": "several comets Ulysses was a joint", "i9QAWuoHye0-00008-00002550-00002729": "venture of NASA and the European Space", "i9QAWuoHye0-00009-00002730-00003016": "Agency ESA with participation from", "i9QAWuoHye0-00010-00003017-00003299": "Canada's National Research Council the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00011-00003300-00003488": "last day for mission operations on", "i9QAWuoHye0-00012-00003489-00003809": "Ulysses was June 30th 2009 to study the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00013-00003810-00004013": "Sun at all latitudes the probe needed to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00014-00004014-00004204": "change its orbital inclination and leave", "i9QAWuoHye0-00015-00004205-00004400": "the plane of the solar system to change", "i9QAWuoHye0-00016-00004401-00004606": "the orbital inclination of a spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00017-00004607-00004838": "a large change in heliocentric velocity", "i9QAWuoHye0-00018-00004839-00005104": "as needed however the necessary amount", "i9QAWuoHye0-00019-00005105-00005291": "of velocity changed to achieve a high", "i9QAWuoHye0-00020-00005292-00005501": "inclination orbit of about 80 degrees", "i9QAWuoHye0-00021-00005502-00005711": "far exceeded the capabilities of any", "i9QAWuoHye0-00022-00005712-00005975": "launch vehicle therefore to reach the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00023-00005976-00006184": "desired orbit around the Sun a gravity", "i9QAWuoHye0-00024-00006185-00006374": "assist maneuver around Jupiter was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00025-00006375-00006578": "chosen but this Jupiter encounter meant", "i9QAWuoHye0-00026-00006579-00006745": "that Ulysses could not be powered by", "i9QAWuoHye0-00027-00006747-00006953": "solar cells the probe instead was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00028-00006954-00007142": "powered by a radioisotope thermoelectric", "i9QAWuoHye0-00029-00007143-00007531": "generator RTG the spacecraft was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00030-00007533-00007748": "originally named Odysseus because of its", "i9QAWuoHye0-00031-00007748-00007960": "lengthy and indirect trajectory to study", "i9QAWuoHye0-00032-00007961-00008258": "the solar poles it was renamed Ulysses", "i9QAWuoHye0-00033-00008259-00008630": "the Latin translation of Odysseus at ESA", "i9QAWuoHye0-00034-00008631-00008831": "Zuri quest in honor not only of Homer's", "i9QAWuoHye0-00035-00008832-00009028": "mythological hero but also with", "i9QAWuoHye0-00036-00009029-00009214": "reference to Dante's description in", "i9QAWuoHye0-00037-00009215-00009527": "Dante's Inferno Ulysses was originally", "i9QAWuoHye0-00038-00009528-00009796": "scheduled for launch in May 1986 aboard", "i9QAWuoHye0-00039-00009797-00010071": "the space shuttle Challenger on sts-61 F", "i9QAWuoHye0-00040-00010072-00010342": "due to the loss of challenger the launch", "i9QAWuoHye0-00041-00010343-00010583": "of Ulysses was delayed until October 6", "i9QAWuoHye0-00042-00010584-00011234": "1990 aboard discovery mission STS 41", "i9QAWuoHye0-00043-00011235-00011763": "topic spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00044-00011764-00012026": "the spacecraft body was roughly a box", "i9QAWuoHye0-00045-00012027-00012435": "approximately 3.2 x 3.3 times two point", "i9QAWuoHye0-00046-00012436-00012693": "one meters ten point five by ten point", "i9QAWuoHye0-00047-00012694-00013026": "eight by six point nine feet in size the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00048-00013027-00013335": "box mounted the 1.65 meters five point", "i9QAWuoHye0-00049-00013336-00013665": "four feet dish antenna and the GP HS RTG", "i9QAWuoHye0-00050-00013666-00013877": "radioisotope thermoelectric generator", "i9QAWuoHye0-00051-00013878-00014253": "RTG power source the box was divided", "i9QAWuoHye0-00052-00014254-00014522": "into noisy and quiet sections the noisy", "i9QAWuoHye0-00053-00014523-00014747": "section abutted the RTG the quiet", "i9QAWuoHye0-00054-00014748-00014984": "section has the instrument electronics", "i9QAWuoHye0-00055-00014985-00015381": "particularly loud components such as the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00056-00015382-00015561": "preamps for the radio dipole were", "i9QAWuoHye0-00057-00015562-00015732": "mounted outside the structure entirely", "i9QAWuoHye0-00058-00015733-00016016": "and the box acted as a Faraday cage", "i9QAWuoHye0-00059-00016016-00016284": "ulysses was spin-stabilized about its", "i9QAWuoHye0-00060-00016285-00016506": "z-axis which roughly coincides with the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00061-00016507-00016833": "axis of the dish antenna the RTG WIPP", "i9QAWuoHye0-00062-00016834-00017052": "antennas an instrument boom were placed", "i9QAWuoHye0-00063-00017053-00017256": "to stabilize this axis with the spin", "i9QAWuoHye0-00064-00017257-00017450": "rate nominally at five revolutions per", "i9QAWuoHye0-00065-00017451-00017742": "minute inside the body was a hydrazine", "i9QAWuoHye0-00066-00017743-00017819": "fuel tank", "i9QAWuoHye0-00067-00017820-00018057": "hydrazine mono propellant was used for", "i9QAWuoHye0-00068-00018058-00018255": "course corrections inbound to jupiter", "i9QAWuoHye0-00069-00018256-00018462": "and later used exclusively to repoint", "i9QAWuoHye0-00070-00018463-00018684": "the spin axis and thus the antenna at", "i9QAWuoHye0-00071-00018685-00018942": "earth the spacecraft was controlled by", "i9QAWuoHye0-00072-00018943-00019194": "eight thrusters in two blocks thrusters", "i9QAWuoHye0-00073-00019195-00019347": "were pulsed in the time domain to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00074-00019348-00019668": "perform rotation or translation for sun", "i9QAWuoHye0-00075-00019669-00019938": "sensors detected orientation for fine", "i9QAWuoHye0-00076-00019939-00020196": "attitude control the s-band antenna feed", "i9QAWuoHye0-00077-00020197-00020463": "was mounted slightly off access this", "i9QAWuoHye0-00078-00020464-00020655": "offset feed combined with the spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00079-00020656-00020889": "spin introduced an oscillation to an", "i9QAWuoHye0-00080-00020890-00021105": "s-band radio signal transmitted from", "i9QAWuoHye0-00081-00021106-00021261": "earth when received onboard the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00082-00021262-00021537": "spacecraft the amplitude and phase of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00083-00021538-00021731": "this oscillation was proportional to the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00084-00021732-00021966": "orientation of the spin axis relative to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00085-00021967-00022191": "the earth direction this method of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00086-00022192-00022400": "determining the relative orientation is", "i9QAWuoHye0-00087-00022401-00022647": "called Co NS CA N and was used by early", "i9QAWuoHye0-00088-00022648-00022908": "radars for automated tracking of targets", "i9QAWuoHye0-00089-00022909-00023133": "and also very common in early infrared", "i9QAWuoHye0-00090-00023134-00023459": "guided missiles the spacecraft used s", "i9QAWuoHye0-00091-00023460-00023661": "band for uplinked commands and downlink", "i9QAWuoHye0-00092-00023662-00023859": "telemetry through dual redundant five", "i9QAWuoHye0-00093-00023860-00024177": "watt transceivers the spacecraft used X", "i9QAWuoHye0-00094-00024178-00024405": "band for science returned downlink only", "i9QAWuoHye0-00095-00024406-00024755": "using dual xx WT w TAS until the failure", "i9QAWuoHye0-00096-00024756-00025041": "of the last remaining TW ta in January", "i9QAWuoHye0-00097-00025042-00025159": "2008", "i9QAWuoHye0-00098-00025160-00025414": "both bands used the dish antenna with", "i9QAWuoHye0-00099-00025415-00025614": "prime focus feeds unlike the Cassegrain", "i9QAWuoHye0-00100-00025616-00025866": "feeds of most other spacecraft dishes", "i9QAWuoHye0-00101-00025867-00026110": "dual tape recorders each of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00102-00026111-00026401": "approximately 45 megabit capacity stored", "i9QAWuoHye0-00103-00026402-00026548": "science data between the nominal", "i9QAWuoHye0-00104-00026549-00026758": "eight-hour communication sessions during", "i9QAWuoHye0-00105-00026758-00026979": "the prime and extended mission phases", "i9QAWuoHye0-00106-00026980-00027235": "the spacecraft was designed to withstand", "i9QAWuoHye0-00107-00027236-00027472": "both the heat of the inner solar system", "i9QAWuoHye0-00108-00027473-00027677": "and the cold at Jupiter's distance", "i9QAWuoHye0-00109-00027679-00027898": "extensive blanketing and electric", "i9QAWuoHye0-00110-00027899-00028087": "heaters protected the probe against the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00111-00028088-00028252": "cold temperatures of the outer solar", "i9QAWuoHye0-00112-00028252-00028362": "system", "i9QAWuoHye0-00113-00028363-00028702": "multiple computer systems CPUs micro", "i9QAWuoHye0-00114-00028702-00028933": "processors data processing units are", "i9QAWuoHye0-00115-00028933-00029110": "used in several of the scientific", "i9QAWuoHye0-00116-00029111-00029329": "instruments including several radiation", "i9QAWuoHye0-00117-00029330-00029644": "hardened RCA CDP one 802 micro", "i9QAWuoHye0-00118-00029645-00030001": "processors documented 1802 usage", "i9QAWuoHye0-00119-00030002-00030301": "includes dual redundant 1802 s in the co", "i9QAWuoHye0-00120-00030302-00030627": "spi N and at least one 1802 each in the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00121-00030629-00030939": "GRB high scale Swick's swoops and you", "i9QAWuoHye0-00122-00030941-00031117": "are AP instruments with other possible", "i9QAWuoHye0-00123-00031118-00031369": "micro processors incorporated elsewhere", "i9QAWuoHye0-00124-00031370-00031564": "total mass at launch was three hundred", "i9QAWuoHye0-00125-00031564-00031855": "sixty six point seven kilograms 808", "i9QAWuoHye0-00126-00031856-00032068": "pounds of which thirty three point five", "i9QAWuoHye0-00127-00032069-00032257": "kilograms seventy three point nine", "i9QAWuoHye0-00128-00032258-00032473": "pounds was hydrazine used for attitude", "i9QAWuoHye0-00129-00032474-00032943": "control and orbit correction", "i9QAWuoHye0-00130-00032944-00033666": "topic instruments radio plasma antennas", "i9QAWuoHye0-00131-00033667-00033912": "- beryllium copper antennas unreeled", "i9QAWuoHye0-00132-00033913-00034116": "outwards from the body perpendicular to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00133-00034117-00034437": "the RTG and spin axis together this", "i9QAWuoHye0-00134-00034438-00034806": "dipole spanned 72 metres 236 point 2", "i9QAWuoHye0-00135-00034807-00034851": "feet", "i9QAWuoHye0-00136-00034852-00035097": "a third antenna of hollow beryllium", "i9QAWuoHye0-00137-00035098-00035328": "copper deployed from the body along the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00138-00035329-00035595": "spin axis opposite the dish it was a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00139-00035596-00035976": "monopole antenna 7.5 meters 24 point 6", "i9QAWuoHye0-00140-00035977-00036243": "feet long these measured radio waves", "i9QAWuoHye0-00141-00036244-00036477": "generated by plasma releases or the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00142-00036478-00036663": "plasma itself as it passed over the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00143-00036664-00036951": "spacecraft this receiver ensemble was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00144-00036952-00037151": "sensitive from DC to 1 megahertz", "i9QAWuoHye0-00145-00037152-00037455": "experiment boom a third type of boom", "i9QAWuoHye0-00146-00037456-00037677": "shorter and much more rigid extended", "i9QAWuoHye0-00147-00037678-00037821": "from the last side of the spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00148-00037822-00038082": "opposite the RTG this was a hollow", "i9QAWuoHye0-00149-00038083-00038364": "carbon-fiber tube of 50 millimeters - in", "i9QAWuoHye0-00150-00038365-00038655": "diameter it can be seen in the photo as", "i9QAWuoHye0-00151-00038656-00038855": "the silver rod stowed alongside the body", "i9QAWuoHye0-00152-00038856-00039155": "it carried four types of instruments a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00153-00039156-00039408": "solid-state x-ray instrument which was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00154-00039409-00039621": "composed of two silicon detectors to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00155-00039622-00039813": "study x-rays from solar flares and", "i9QAWuoHye0-00156-00039814-00040143": "Jupiter's aurorae the GRB experiment", "i9QAWuoHye0-00157-00040144-00040353": "consisted of two CSI scintillator", "i9QAWuoHye0-00158-00040354-00040626": "crystals with photo multipliers two", "i9QAWuoHye0-00159-00040627-00040821": "different magnetometers were mounted a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00160-00040822-00041049": "vector helium magnetometer and a flex", "i9QAWuoHye0-00161-00041050-00041367": "gate magnetometer a two axis magnetic", "i9QAWuoHye0-00162-00041368-00041607": "search coil antenna measured AC magnetic", "i9QAWuoHye0-00163-00041608-00041898": "fields body mounted instruments", "i9QAWuoHye0-00164-00041899-00042195": "detectors for electrons ions neutral gas", "i9QAWuoHye0-00165-00042196-00042444": "dust and cosmic rays were mounted on the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00166-00042445-00042710": "spacecraft body around the quiet section", "i9QAWuoHye0-00167-00042711-00043023": "swoops solar wind observations over the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00168-00043024-00043248": "poles of the Sun measures positive ions", "i9QAWuoHye0-00169-00043249-00043338": "and electrons", "i9QAWuoHye0-00170-00043339-00043560": "lastly the radio communications link", "i9QAWuoHye0-00171-00043561-00043662": "could be used to search for", "i9QAWuoHye0-00172-00043663-00043857": "gravitational waves through Doppler", "i9QAWuoHye0-00173-00043858-00044010": "shifts and to probe the sun's atmosphere", "i9QAWuoHye0-00174-00044011-00044280": "through radio occultation no", "i9QAWuoHye0-00175-00044281-00044610": "gravitational waves were detected total", "i9QAWuoHye0-00176-00044611-00045012": "instrument mass has 55 kilograms 120 1.3", "i9QAWuoHye0-00177-00045013-00045367": "pounds", "i9QAWuoHye0-00178-00045368-00045849": "topic mission", "i9QAWuoHye0-00179-00045850-00046309": "topic planning", "i9QAWuoHye0-00180-00046310-00046576": "until Ulysses the son was only observed", "i9QAWuoHye0-00181-00046577-00046837": "from low solar latitudes the Earth's", "i9QAWuoHye0-00182-00046838-00047065": "orbit defines the ecliptic plane which", "i9QAWuoHye0-00183-00047066-00047254": "differs from the sun's equatorial plane", "i9QAWuoHye0-00184-00047255-00047490": "by only seven point two five degrees", "i9QAWuoHye0-00185-00047491-00047770": "even spacecraft directly orbiting the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00186-00047771-00047950": "Sun do so in planes close to the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00187-00047951-00048157": "ecliptic because a direct launch into a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00188-00048158-00048343": "high inclination solar orbit would", "i9QAWuoHye0-00189-00048344-00048538": "require a prohibitively large launch", "i9QAWuoHye0-00190-00048539-00048889": "vehicle several spacecraft Mariner 10", "i9QAWuoHye0-00191-00048890-00049183": "pioneer 11 and voyagers 1 and 2 had", "i9QAWuoHye0-00192-00049184-00049393": "performed gravity assist maneuvers in", "i9QAWuoHye0-00193-00049394-00049705": "the 1970s those maneuvers were to reach", "i9QAWuoHye0-00194-00049706-00049927": "other planets also orbiting close to the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00195-00049928-00050113": "ecliptic so they were mostly in-plane", "i9QAWuoHye0-00196-00050114-00050428": "changes however gravity assists are not", "i9QAWuoHye0-00197-00050429-00050647": "limited to in plane maneuvers a suitable", "i9QAWuoHye0-00198-00050648-00050827": "flyby of Jupiter could produce a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00199-00050828-00051091": "significant plane change and out of the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00200-00051092-00051301": "ecliptic mission ooe was thereby", "i9QAWuoHye0-00201-00051302-00051699": "proposed see article pioneer h", "i9QAWuoHye0-00202-00051700-00051942": "originally two spacecraft were to be", "i9QAWuoHye0-00203-00051944-00052140": "built by nasa and esa as the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00204-00052141-00052351": "International Solar polar mission one", "i9QAWuoHye0-00205-00052352-00052530": "would be sent over Jupiter then under", "i9QAWuoHye0-00206-00052532-00052762": "the Sun the other would fly under", "i9QAWuoHye0-00207-00052763-00052980": "Jupiter then over the Sun this would", "i9QAWuoHye0-00208-00052982-00053227": "provide simultaneous coverage due to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00209-00053228-00053425": "cutbacks the u.s. spacecraft was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00210-00053426-00053773": "cancelled in 1981 one spacecraft was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00211-00053774-00053971": "designed and the project recast as", "i9QAWuoHye0-00212-00053972-00054187": "Ulysses due to the indirect and untried", "i9QAWuoHye0-00213-00054188-00054439": "flight path NASA would provide the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00214-00054440-00054648": "radioisotope thermoelectric generator", "i9QAWuoHye0-00215-00054649-00054976": "RTG and launch services ESA would build", "i9QAWuoHye0-00216-00054977-00055249": "the spacecraft assigned to Astrium GmbH", "i9QAWuoHye0-00217-00055250-00055510": "Friedreich's - Germany formerly Dornier", "i9QAWuoHye0-00218-00055511-00055771": "systems the instruments would be split", "i9QAWuoHye0-00219-00055772-00055948": "into teams from universities and", "i9QAWuoHye0-00220-00055949-00056128": "research institutes in Europe in the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00221-00056129-00056434": "United States this process provided the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00222-00056435-00056722": "10 instruments on board the changes", "i9QAWuoHye0-00223-00056723-00057004": "delayed launch from February 1983 to May", "i9QAWuoHye0-00224-00057004-00057247": "1986 where it was to be deployed by the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00225-00057248-00057385": "space shuttle Challenger", "i9QAWuoHye0-00226-00057386-00057591": "however the Challenger disaster pushed", "i9QAWuoHye0-00227-00057592-00058123": "the date to October 1990", "i9QAWuoHye0-00228-00058124-00058535": "topic launched", "i9QAWuoHye0-00229-00058536-00058746": "Ulysses was deployed into low-earth", "i9QAWuoHye0-00230-00058747-00058957": "orbit from the space shuttle Discovery", "i9QAWuoHye0-00231-00058958-00059178": "from there it was propelled on a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00232-00059179-00059363": "trajectory to Jupiter by a combination", "i9QAWuoHye0-00233-00059364-00059685": "of solid rocket motors this upper stage", "i9QAWuoHye0-00234-00059686-00059940": "consisted of a two-stage Boeing I u.s.", "i9QAWuoHye0-00235-00059941-00060176": "inertial upper stage plus a McDonnell", "i9QAWuoHye0-00236-00060177-00060369": "Douglas Pam asked payload assist module", "i9QAWuoHye0-00237-00060370-00060669": "special the I us was inertially", "i9QAWuoHye0-00238-00060670-00060876": "stabilized and actively guided during", "i9QAWuoHye0-00239-00060877-00061185": "its burn the Pam s was unguided and it", "i9QAWuoHye0-00240-00061186-00061344": "in Ulysses were spun up to 80", "i9QAWuoHye0-00241-00061345-00061557": "revolutions per minute for stability at", "i9QAWuoHye0-00242-00061558-00061817": "the start of its burn on burn out of the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00243-00061819-00062073": "Pam s the motor and spacecraft stack was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00244-00062074-00062244": "yo-yo de spun weights deployed at the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00245-00062245-00062457": "end of cables to below eight revolutions", "i9QAWuoHye0-00246-00062458-00062640": "per minute prior to separation of the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00247-00062641-00062882": "spacecraft on leaving earth the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00248-00062883-00063072": "spacecraft became the fastest ever", "i9QAWuoHye0-00249-00063073-00063312": "artificially accelerated object and held", "i9QAWuoHye0-00250-00063313-00063510": "that title until the new horizons probe", "i9QAWuoHye0-00251-00063511-00063798": "was launched on its way to Jupiter the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00252-00063799-00063999": "spacecraft was in an elliptical non", "i9QAWuoHye0-00253-00064000-00064260": "Hohmann transfer orbit at this time", "i9QAWuoHye0-00254-00064261-00064497": "Ulysses had a low orbital inclination to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00255-00064498-00064830": "the ecliptic", "i9QAWuoHye0-00256-00064832-00065365": "topic Jupiter swing by", "i9QAWuoHye0-00257-00065366-00065578": "it arrived at Jupiter on the 8th of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00258-00065579-00065863": "February 1992 for a swing by maneuver", "i9QAWuoHye0-00259-00065864-00066031": "that increased its inclination to the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00260-00066032-00066355": "ecliptic by 80 point 2 degrees the giant", "i9QAWuoHye0-00261-00066356-00066562": "planets gravity bent the spacecraft's", "i9QAWuoHye0-00262-00066563-00066751": "flight path southward and away from the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00263-00066752-00067018": "ecliptic plane this put it into a final", "i9QAWuoHye0-00264-00067019-00067210": "orbit around the Sun that would take it", "i9QAWuoHye0-00265-00067211-00067452": "past the sun's North and South Poles the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00266-00067453-00067678": "size and shape of the orbit were", "i9QAWuoHye0-00267-00067679-00067876": "adjusted to a much smaller degree so", "i9QAWuoHye0-00268-00067877-00068080": "that aphelion remained at approximately", "i9QAWuoHye0-00269-00068081-00068341": "5 astronomical units Jupiter's distance", "i9QAWuoHye0-00270-00068342-00068560": "from the Sun and perihelion was somewhat", "i9QAWuoHye0-00271-00068561-00068767": "greater than one astronomical unit the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00272-00068768-00068983": "Earth's distance from the Sun the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00273-00068984-00069509": "orbital period is approximately 6 years", "i9QAWuoHye0-00274-00069510-00070079": "topic polar regions of the Sun", "i9QAWuoHye0-00275-00070080-00070496": "between 1994 and 1995 it explored both", "i9QAWuoHye0-00276-00070497-00070685": "the southern and northern polar regions", "i9QAWuoHye0-00277-00070686-00071144": "of the Sun respectively", "i9QAWuoHye0-00278-00071145-00071870": "topic comet C 1996 b2 Hyakutake", "i9QAWuoHye0-00279-00071871-00072188": "on May 1st 1996 the spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00280-00072189-00072410": "unexpectedly crossed the ion tail of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00281-00072411-00072791": "comet Hyakutake C 1996 be too revealing", "i9QAWuoHye0-00282-00072792-00073082": "the tail to be at least 3.8 astronomical", "i9QAWuoHye0-00283-00073083-00073430": "units in length", "i9QAWuoHye0-00284-00073431-00073791": "topic commits see 1990-91", "i9QAWuoHye0-00285-00073792-00074207": "make not Hartley", "i9QAWuoHye0-00286-00074208-00074456": "an encounter with a comet tail happened", "i9QAWuoHye0-00287-00074457-00074742": "again in 1999 when Ulysses flew through", "i9QAWuoHye0-00288-00074743-00075086": "the ion tailings of seat 1990-91 McNutt", "i9QAWuoHye0-00289-00075087-00075396": "Hartley a coronal mass ejection carried", "i9QAWuoHye0-00290-00075397-00075926": "the cometary material to Ulysses", "i9QAWuoHye0-00291-00075927-00076443": "topic ii Jupiter encounter", "i9QAWuoHye0-00292-00076444-00076843": "Ulysses approached aphelion in 2003-2004", "i9QAWuoHye0-00293-00076844-00077050": "and made further distant observations of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00294-00077051-00077378": "Jupiter", "i9QAWuoHye0-00295-00077379-00078084": "topic comet c 2006 p1 makhmud", "i9QAWuoHye0-00296-00078085-00078405": "in 2007 Ulysses passed through the tail", "i9QAWuoHye0-00297-00078406-00078834": "of comet C 2006 p1 mcnaught the results", "i9QAWuoHye0-00298-00078835-00079005": "were surprisingly different from its", "i9QAWuoHye0-00299-00079006-00079193": "pass-through hayaku takes tail with the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00300-00079194-00079406": "measured solar wind velocity dropping", "i9QAWuoHye0-00301-00079407-00079653": "from approximately 700 kilometers per", "i9QAWuoHye0-00302-00079654-00079896": "second 1 million five hundred sixty six", "i9QAWuoHye0-00303-00079897-00080075": "thousand miles per hour to less than", "i9QAWuoHye0-00304-00080076-00080288": "four hundred kilometers per second eight", "i9QAWuoHye0-00305-00080289-00080487": "hundred ninety five thousand miles per", "i9QAWuoHye0-00306-00080488-00080869": "hour", "i9QAWuoHye0-00307-00080870-00081389": "topic extended mission", "i9QAWuoHye0-00308-00081390-00081671": "es a science program committee approved", "i9QAWuoHye0-00309-00081672-00081845": "the forth extension of the Ulysses", "i9QAWuoHye0-00310-00081846-00082100": "mission to March 2009 thereby allowing", "i9QAWuoHye0-00311-00082101-00082304": "it to operate over the sun's poles for", "i9QAWuoHye0-00312-00082305-00082697": "the third time in 2007 and 2008 after it", "i9QAWuoHye0-00313-00082698-00082898": "became clear that the power output from", "i9QAWuoHye0-00314-00082899-00083096": "the spacecraft's RTG would be", "i9QAWuoHye0-00315-00083097-00083261": "insufficient to operate science", "i9QAWuoHye0-00316-00083262-00083393": "instruments and keep the attitude", "i9QAWuoHye0-00317-00083394-00083645": "control fuel hydrazine from freezing", "i9QAWuoHye0-00318-00083646-00083855": "instrument power sharing was initiated", "i9QAWuoHye0-00319-00083856-00084104": "up until then the most important", "i9QAWuoHye0-00320-00084105-00084254": "instruments had been kept online", "i9QAWuoHye0-00321-00084255-00084404": "constantly whilst others were", "i9QAWuoHye0-00322-00084405-00084653": "deactivated when the probe neared the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00323-00084654-00084866": "Sun its power-hungry heaters were turned", "i9QAWuoHye0-00324-00084867-00085049": "off and all instruments were turned on", "i9QAWuoHye0-00325-00085050-00085454": "on February 22nd 2008 17 years and four", "i9QAWuoHye0-00326-00085455-00085574": "months after the launch of the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00327-00085575-00085829": "spacecraft ESA and NASA announced that", "i9QAWuoHye0-00328-00085830-00086030": "the mission operations for Ulysses would", "i9QAWuoHye0-00329-00086031-00086258": "likely cease within a few months on", "i9QAWuoHye0-00330-00086259-00086570": "April 12th 2008 NASA announced that the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00331-00086571-00086822": "end date will be July 1st 2008 the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00332-00086823-00087041": "spacecraft operated successfully for", "i9QAWuoHye0-00333-00087042-00087268": "over four times its design life a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00334-00087269-00087473": "component within the last remaining", "i9QAWuoHye0-00335-00087474-00087665": "working chain of x-band downlink", "i9QAWuoHye0-00336-00087666-00088073": "subsystem failed On January 15 2008 the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00337-00088074-00088298": "other chain in the x-band subsystem had", "i9QAWuoHye0-00338-00088299-00088580": "previously failed in 2003 downlink to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00339-00088581-00088736": "earth resumed on s-band", "i9QAWuoHye0-00340-00088737-00088850": "but the beam width of the high-gain", "i9QAWuoHye0-00341-00088851-00089087": "antenna in the S band was not as narrow", "i9QAWuoHye0-00342-00089088-00089288": "as in the X band so that the received", "i9QAWuoHye0-00343-00089289-00089492": "downlink signal was much weaker hence", "i9QAWuoHye0-00344-00089493-00089777": "reducing the achievable data rate as the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00345-00089778-00089936": "spacecraft traveled on its outbound", "i9QAWuoHye0-00346-00089937-00090176": "trajectory to the orbit of Jupiter the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00347-00090177-00090326": "downlink signal would have eventually", "i9QAWuoHye0-00348-00090327-00090569": "fallen below the receiving capability of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00349-00090570-00090812": "even the largest antennas 70 meters to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00350-00090813-00091121": "220 nine point seven feet in diameter of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00351-00091122-00091424": "the deep space network even before the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00352-00091425-00091640": "downlink signal was lost due to distance", "i9QAWuoHye0-00353-00091641-00091847": "the hydrazine attitude control fuel", "i9QAWuoHye0-00354-00091848-00092054": "onboard the spacecraft was considered", "i9QAWuoHye0-00355-00092055-00092249": "likely to freeze as the radio isotope", "i9QAWuoHye0-00356-00092250-00092660": "thermal to generate enough power for the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00357-00092661-00092867": "heaters to overcome radiative heat loss", "i9QAWuoHye0-00358-00092868-00092960": "into space", "i9QAWuoHye0-00359-00092961-00093248": "once the hydrazine froze the spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00360-00093249-00093416": "would no longer be able to maneuver to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00361-00093417-00093593": "keep its high gain antenna pointing", "i9QAWuoHye0-00362-00093594-00093755": "towards Earth and the downlink signal", "i9QAWuoHye0-00363-00093756-00093946": "would then be lost in a matter of days", "i9QAWuoHye0-00364-00093947-00094250": "the failure of the x-band communications", "i9QAWuoHye0-00365-00094251-00094439": "subsystem hastened this because the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00366-00094440-00094631": "coldest part of the fuel pipe work was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00367-00094632-00094757": "routed over the x-band", "i9QAWuoHye0-00368-00094758-00095000": "TW TAS because when one of them was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00369-00095001-00095180": "operating this kept this part of the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00370-00095181-00095474": "pipework warm enough the previously", "i9QAWuoHye0-00371-00095475-00095678": "announced mission end date of July 1st", "i9QAWuoHye0-00372-00095679-00095906": "2008 came and went but mission", "i9QAWuoHye0-00373-00095907-00096119": "operations continued albeit in a reduced", "i9QAWuoHye0-00374-00096120-00096410": "capacity the availability of science", "i9QAWuoHye0-00375-00096411-00096626": "data gathering was limited to only when", "i9QAWuoHye0-00376-00096627-00096812": "Ulysses was in contact with a ground", "i9QAWuoHye0-00377-00096813-00097046": "station due to the deteriorating s-band", "i9QAWuoHye0-00378-00097047-00097259": "downlink margin no longer being able to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00379-00097260-00097484": "support simultaneous real-time data and", "i9QAWuoHye0-00380-00097485-00097736": "tape recorder playback when the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00381-00097737-00097916": "spacecraft was out of contact with a", "i9QAWuoHye0-00382-00097917-00098129": "ground station the s-band transmitter", "i9QAWuoHye0-00383-00098130-00098291": "was switched off and the power was", "i9QAWuoHye0-00384-00098292-00098477": "diverted to the internal heaters to add", "i9QAWuoHye0-00385-00098478-00098738": "to the warming of the hydrazine on June", "i9QAWuoHye0-00386-00098739-00099002": "30th 2009 ground controllers sent", "i9QAWuoHye0-00387-00099003-00099158": "commands to switch to the low gain", "i9QAWuoHye0-00388-00099159-00099425": "antennas this stopped communications", "i9QAWuoHye0-00389-00099426-00099635": "with the spacecraft in combination with", "i9QAWuoHye0-00390-00099636-00099788": "previous the commands to set the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00391-00099789-00100275": "shutdown of its transmitter entirely", "i9QAWuoHye0-00392-00100276-00100792": "topic results", "i9QAWuoHye0-00393-00100793-00101062": "during cruise phases Ulysses provided", "i9QAWuoHye0-00394-00101063-00101320": "unique data as the only spacecraft how", "i9QAWuoHye0-00395-00101321-00101451": "to be ecliptic with a gamma-ray", "i9QAWuoHye0-00396-00101452-00101688": "instrument Ulysses was an important part", "i9QAWuoHye0-00397-00101689-00101995": "of the interplanetary network IP n the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00398-00101996-00102301": "IP n detects gamma-ray bursts GRBs", "i9QAWuoHye0-00399-00102302-00102507": "since gamma rays cannot be focused with", "i9QAWuoHye0-00400-00102508-00102700": "mirrors it was very difficult to locate", "i9QAWuoHye0-00401-00102701-00102973": "GRBs with enough accuracy to study them", "i9QAWuoHye0-00402-00102974-00103284": "further instead several spacecraft can", "i9QAWuoHye0-00403-00103285-00103482": "locate the burst through triangulation", "i9QAWuoHye0-00404-00103483-00103701": "or more specifically multilateration", "i9QAWuoHye0-00405-00103702-00104016": "each spacecraft has a gamma ray detector", "i9QAWuoHye0-00406-00104017-00104244": "with readouts noted in tiny fractions of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00407-00104245-00104508": "a second by comparing the arrival times", "i9QAWuoHye0-00408-00104509-00104725": "of gamma showers with the separations of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00409-00104726-00104910": "the spacecraft a location can be", "i9QAWuoHye0-00410-00104911-00105060": "determined for follow up with other", "i9QAWuoHye0-00411-00105061-00105373": "telescopes because gamma rays travel at", "i9QAWuoHye0-00412-00105374-00105574": "the speed of light wide separations are", "i9QAWuoHye0-00413-00105575-00105633": "needed", "i9QAWuoHye0-00414-00105633-00105874": "typically a determination came from", "i9QAWuoHye0-00415-00105875-00106081": "comparing one of several spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00416-00106082-00106258": "orbiting the earth an inner solar system", "i9QAWuoHye0-00417-00106258-00106546": "probe to Mars Venus or an asteroid and", "i9QAWuoHye0-00418-00106547-00106816": "Ulysses when Ulysses crossed the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00419-00106817-00107050": "ecliptic twice per orbit many GRB", "i9QAWuoHye0-00420-00107051-00107391": "determinations lost accuracy additional", "i9QAWuoHye0-00421-00107392-00107746": "discoveries data provided by Ulysses led", "i9QAWuoHye0-00422-00107747-00107910": "to the discovery that the sun's magnetic", "i9QAWuoHye0-00423-00107911-00108157": "field interacts with the solar system in", "i9QAWuoHye0-00424-00108158-00108354": "a more complex fashion than previously", "i9QAWuoHye0-00425-00108355-00108721": "assumed data provided by Ulysses led to", "i9QAWuoHye0-00426-00108722-00108909": "the discovery that dust coming into the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00427-00108910-00109116": "solar system from deep space was 30", "i9QAWuoHye0-00428-00109117-00109291": "times more abundant than previously", "i9QAWuoHye0-00429-00109292-00109756": "expected in 2007/2008 data provided by", "i9QAWuoHye0-00430-00109757-00109963": "Ulysses led to the determination that", "i9QAWuoHye0-00431-00109964-00110160": "the magnetic field emanating from the", "i9QAWuoHye0-00432-00110161-00110308": "sun's poles is much weaker than", "i9QAWuoHye0-00433-00110308-00110626": "previously observed that the solar wind", "i9QAWuoHye0-00434-00110627-00110815": "has grown progressively weaker during", "i9QAWuoHye0-00435-00110816-00110950": "the mission and is currently at its", "i9QAWuoHye0-00436-00110951-00111543": "weakest since the start of the Space Age", "i9QAWuoHye0-00437-00111544-00112061": "topic see also", "i9QAWuoHye0-00438-00112063-00112426": "advanced composition explorer list of", "i9QAWuoHye0-00439-00112427-00112714": "missions to the outer planets Solar and", "i9QAWuoHye0-00440-00112715-00113094": "Heliospheric Observatory wind spacecraft", "i9QAWuoHye0-00441-00113095-00113674": "list of heliophysics missions", "i9QAWuoHye0-00442-00113675-00114191": "topic references", "i9QAWuoHye0-00443-00114192-00114746": "topic external links", "i9QAWuoHye0-00444-00114747-00115196": "ESA Ulysses website ESA Ulysses Mission", "i9QAWuoHye0-00445-00115197-00115602": "Operations website ESA Ulysses homepage", "i9QAWuoHye0-00446-00115603-00115962": "NASA JPL Ulysses website", "i9QAWuoHye0-00447-00115963-00116224": "Ulysses measuring mission profile by", "i9QAWuoHye0-00448-00116225-00116624": "NASA's Solar System exploration ESA NASA", "i9QAWuoHye0-00449-00116625-00116890": "JPL Ulysses subsystems and", "i9QAWuoHye0-00450-00116891-00117197": "instrumentation in high detail where is", "i9QAWuoHye0-00451-00117198-00117565": "Ulysses now Max Planck Institute Ulysses", "i9QAWuoHye0-00452-00117566-00117872": "website interview with Ulysses mission", "i9QAWuoHye0-00453-00117873-00118094": "operations manager Nigel angled on", "i9QAWuoHye0-00454-00118095-00118397": "planetary radio"}}, {"audio_id": "i9X4YYZgrlE", "text": {"i9X4YYZgrlE-00000-00000048-00001775": "the president", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00001-00001776-00001998": "members it's question time are there any", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00002-00002000-00002334": "questions", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00003-00002335-00002639": "okay thank you members", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00004-00002640-00002839": "the honorable the leader of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00005-00002840-00002958": "opposition", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00006-00002959-00003118": "uh thank you president and my question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00007-00003119-00003303": "without notice and welcome to thursday", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00008-00003304-00003454": "my question without notice of which some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00009-00003455-00003615": "notice has been given", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00010-00003615-00003751": "is to the minister for mental health", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00011-00003752-00003919": "representing the treasurer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00012-00003920-00004119": "i refer to the gst received by the state", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00013-00004120-00004263": "of western australia and the floor", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00014-00004264-00004422": "instigated by the morrison government", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00015-00004423-00004567": "and i ask one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00016-00004568-00004711": "what indication of evidence has the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00017-00004712-00004799": "government received that the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00018-00004800-00004919": "commonwealth government is considering", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00019-00004920-00005095": "altering the gst agreement struck with", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00020-00005096-00005222": "this state to implement the current", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00021-00005223-00005399": "floor in gst payments", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00022-00005400-00005527": "two has the government received any", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00023-00005528-00005647": "correspondence from the commonwealth", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00024-00005648-00005799": "government in regard to their position", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00025-00005800-00005991": "on the current gst floor agreement three", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00026-00005992-00006231": "please table that correspondence for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00027-00006232-00006343": "what evidence does the treasurer have", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00028-00006344-00006486": "that the commonwealth has any intention", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00029-00006487-00006695": "of changing the gst agreement and five", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00030-00006695-00006991": "please table that evidence", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00031-00006992-00007175": "the minister for mental health thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00032-00007176-00007310": "president and i thank the leader of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00033-00007311-00007439": "opposition for some notice of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00034-00007440-00007534": "question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00035-00007536-00007678": "one the commonwealth has been under", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00036-00007679-00007831": "sustained pressure from other states and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00037-00007831-00008127": "territories to undo the gst reforms for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00038-00008128-00008263": "example the south australian and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00039-00008264-00008446": "victorian treasurers have raised their", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00040-00008447-00008646": "concerns with the gst reforms in recent", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00041-00008647-00008742": "months", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00042-00008743-00008887": "two the prime minister and federal", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00043-00008888-00009087": "treasurer have only provided verbal", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00044-00009088-00009310": "assurances of their intention to not", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00045-00009311-00009527": "unwind the gst reforms", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00046-00009528-00009678": "the state government would welcome the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00047-00009679-00009878": "honourable members support in seeking", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00048-00009879-00010127": "formal assurance from his uh", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00049-00010128-00010319": "commonwealth counterparts three to five", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00050-00010320-00010495": "c one to two", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00051-00010496-00010774": "the leader of the opposition president", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00052-00010775-00010935": "uh my question without notice of which", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00053-00010936-00011078": "some notice has been given is to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00054-00011079-00011231": "minister for mental health representing", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00055-00011232-00011367": "the treasurer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00056-00011368-00011742": "i referred to the 2018 19 to 2021 boom", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00057-00011743-00011999": "in iron oil royalties and i ask one what", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00058-00012000-00012183": "is the current spot price of iron ore as", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00059-00012184-00012383": "measured by treasury two does the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00060-00012384-00012559": "treasury receive a nightly update on", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00061-00012560-00012727": "iron ore price from treasury to help him", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00062-00012728-00012871": "sleep as the previous threes are", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00063-00012872-00013030": "publicly acknowledged", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00064-00013031-00013166": "three what is the total government", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00065-00013168-00013503": "royalty revenue to date for the 20 20 21", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00066-00013504-00013727": "financial year and four is an iron ore", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00067-00013728-00013966": "spot price above us 150 a ton for the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00068-00013968-00014311": "rest of 2021 highly unrealistic", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00069-00014312-00014494": "the minister for mental health thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00070-00014495-00014622": "president and again i thank the leader", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00071-00014623-00014727": "of the opposition for some knowledge of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00072-00014728-00015158": "the question one uh us 191.3", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00073-00015159-00015343": "two the treasury receives an overnight", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00074-00015344-00015558": "update of the iron ore spot price", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00075-00015559-00015711": "three as stated in the answer to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00076-00015712-00015830": "legislative council question without", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00077-00015831-00016191": "notice number two on 29 april 2021 iron", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00078-00016191-00016394": "ore royalty income totaled", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00079-00016395-00016671": "5.129 billion dollars to 31 december", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00080-00016672-00016919": "2020 as shown in the latest december", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00081-00016920-00017167": "quarterly report the actual for 2020", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00082-00017168-00017383": "2021 will be published in the annual", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00083-00017384-00017591": "report on state finances in september", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00084-00017592-00017719": "2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00085-00017720-00017911": "four as stated in the answer to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00086-00017912-00018022": "legislative council question without", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00087-00018023-00018286": "notice number two on 29 april 2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00088-00018287-00018494": "annual average prices are shown in the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00089-00018495-00018686": "annual report on state finances", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00090-00018687-00018927": "published each financial year iron ore", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00091-00018928-00019111": "prices are highly volatile the mcgowan", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00092-00019112-00019303": "labor government's budgets are based on", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00093-00019304-00019535": "a prudent iron ore methodology given", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00094-00019536-00019767": "this inherent volatility", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00095-00019768-00020030": "the honourable colin de grussa", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00096-00020031-00020191": "thank you president my question without", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00097-00020192-00020327": "notice of which some notice has been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00098-00020328-00020478": "given to the minister representing the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00099-00020479-00020655": "minister for health i referred a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00100-00020656-00020871": "question c147 asked in this place on the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00101-00020872-00021158": "25th of may 2021 and i ask one will you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00102-00021159-00021414": "table all presentations reports data and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00103-00021415-00021591": "correspondence regarding concerns and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00104-00021592-00021799": "issues raised by the emergency", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00105-00021800-00021958": "department of perth children's hospital", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00106-00021959-00022143": "to the executive of the child and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00107-00022144-00022367": "adolescent health service for the period", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00108-00022368-00022655": "1 october 2020 inclusive to 30th april", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00109-00022656-00022927": "2021 inclusive including but not limited", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00110-00022928-00023230": "to information identified in the sac one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00111-00023231-00023503": "clinical incident investigation report", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00112-00023504-00023735": "contributing factors and root causes", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00113-00023736-00024039": "into aishwarya aswah's death and two if", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00114-00024040-00024222": "no to one why not", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00115-00024223-00024391": "minister for mental health thanks very", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00116-00024392-00024630": "much uh president and i thank the deaf", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00117-00024631-00024727": "leader of the opposition for some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00118-00024728-00025007": "knowledge of the question one no two an", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00119-00025008-00025199": "independent inquiry will be conducted", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00120-00025200-00025335": "into the child and adolescent health", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00121-00025336-00025519": "service in respect of all the functions", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00122-00025520-00025670": "and operations of perth children's", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00123-00025672-00026046": "hospital concerning the care of ashwaria", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00124-00026047-00026206": "as part of the terms of reference the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00125-00026207-00026423": "inquiry will investigate the roles and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00126-00026424-00026711": "responsibilities of responsibilities of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00127-00026712-00026887": "clinicians management and the executive", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00128-00026888-00027135": "at pch under escalation of issues to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00129-00027136-00027295": "child and adolescent health service", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00130-00027295-00027479": "board", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00131-00027480-00027646": "the honourable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00132-00027647-00027823": "yorn sigma thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00133-00027824-00028007": "president my question without notice of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00134-00028008-00028143": "which some notice is given is to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00135-00028144-00028302": "minister representing the minister for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00136-00028304-00028446": "environment", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00137-00028447-00028639": "i refer to the explanatory memorandum", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00138-00028639-00028807": "for the conservation and land management", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00139-00028808-00029031": "amendment bill 2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00140-00029032-00029199": "which identifies that the proposed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00141-00029200-00029367": "amendments will among other things", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00142-00029368-00029558": "provide for the laudable aim of and i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00143-00029560-00029727": "quote greater recognition of the rights", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00144-00029727-00029943": "of aboriginal people by broadening the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00145-00029944-00030118": "purpose of marine parks to include the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00146-00030119-00030302": "protection and conservation of the value", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00147-00030303-00030495": "of marine parks to the culture and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00148-00030495-00030727": "heritage of aboriginal people and i ask", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00149-00030727-00030814": "one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00150-00030816-00030983": "does the continuation of lawful", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00151-00030983-00031167": "commercial and recreational activities", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00152-00031168-00031335": "prevent or impede the protection of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00153-00031336-00031479": "aboriginal culture and heritage in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00154-00031480-00031718": "marine parks marine management areas and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00155-00031719-00031974": "or marine nature reserves and two if yes", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00156-00031975-00032231": "to one can the minister provide specific", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00157-00032232-00032367": "examples", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00158-00032368-00032518": "minister for mental health thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00159-00032519-00032670": "president on earning my money this", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00160-00032672-00032831": "afternoon i provide the following answer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00161-00032832-00032935": "on behalf of the minister for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00162-00032936-00033190": "environment one to two such matters", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00163-00033191-00033359": "would be considered on a case-by-case", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00164-00033360-00033543": "basis through the preparation or a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00165-00033544-00033711": "vision of the management plan for the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00166-00033712-00033855": "respective marine reserve under the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00167-00033856-00033990": "conservation and land management act of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00168-00033991-00034095": "1984.", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00169-00034096-00034223": "[Applause]", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00170-00034224-00034415": "the honourable nick guaran thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00171-00034416-00034599": "president uh my question without notice", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00172-00034600-00034743": "of which some notice has been given as", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00173-00034744-00034911": "the parliamentary secretary representing", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00174-00034912-00035095": "the attorney general i refer you answer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00175-00035096-00035367": "a question without notice number 973", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00176-00035368-00035655": "answered on the 5th of september 2019 in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00177-00035656-00035823": "the 40th parliament in which you inform", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00178-00035824-00036039": "the house of your commitment to table a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00179-00036040-00036159": "review into the efficiency and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00180-00036160-00036374": "effectiveness of the commencement and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00181-00036375-00036590": "conduct of prosecutions arising from", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00182-00036591-00036702": "corruption crime commission", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00183-00036703-00036967": "investigations by the 20th of september", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00184-00036968-00037167": "2019 and i asked one and what date was", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00185-00037168-00037423": "the review report completed and two and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00186-00037424-00037711": "what date was the report tabled", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00187-00037712-00037871": "uh the parliamentary secretary to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00188-00037872-00038071": "attorney general thank you president and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00189-00038072-00038239": "i thank the member for some notice of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00190-00038240-00038374": "the question i provide the following", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00191-00038375-00038567": "answer on behalf of the attorney general", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00192-00038568-00039118": "one may 2020 two not applicable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00193-00039119-00039383": "the honourable donna", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00194-00039384-00039687": "the honorable donna farraga has the call", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00195-00039688-00039862": "oh thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00196-00039863-00040055": "mr president uh", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00197-00040056-00040199": "president my question without nursing", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00198-00040200-00040359": "which some notice has been given is to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00199-00040360-00040590": "the minister for education", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00200-00040591-00040830": "i refer to the new 1.2 million program", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00201-00040831-00041055": "to be trialled at two perth schools to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00202-00041056-00041199": "support children families who speak", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00203-00041200-00041358": "english as an additional language before", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00204-00041359-00041574": "they start school and i ask one has the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00205-00041575-00041735": "trial commenced and if so what is its", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00206-00041736-00041974": "total duration two can the minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00207-00041975-00042111": "provide more information about the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00208-00042112-00042262": "program including a breakdown of how the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00209-00042263-00042495": "1.2 million dollars is to be spent and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00210-00042496-00042646": "three will an evaluation of the program", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00211-00042647-00042790": "be conducted at the completion of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00212-00042791-00042895": "trial", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00213-00042896-00043079": "uh the leader of the house thanks uh", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00214-00043080-00043255": "president i thank you member for some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00215-00043256-00043423": "notice of the question won the tribal", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00216-00043424-00043758": "commence in semester 2 2021 and continue", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00217-00043759-00044015": "until the end of 2024 two the program", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00218-00044016-00044183": "will be trialed at bentley and mylan's", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00219-00044184-00044399": "peninsula primary schools it is designed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00220-00044400-00044535": "to help the children of families from", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00221-00044536-00044702": "culturally and linguistically diverse", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00222-00044703-00044911": "backgrounds to successfully transition", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00223-00044912-00045135": "to school the breakdown of how the 1.2", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00224-00045136-00045430": "million dollars is to be spent it's 904", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00225-00045431-00045630": "000 on salaries early childhood trained", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00226-00045631-00045883": "teacher and an ethnic assistant", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00227-00045884-00046239": "243 500 school startup and program", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00228-00046240-00046335": "delivery", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00229-00046336-00046486": "fifty three thousand dollars project", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00230-00046487-00046662": "support and startup fifteen hundred", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00231-00046663-00046886": "dollars staff training and development", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00232-00046887-00047062": "three yes", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00233-00047063-00047223": "the honourable peter collier i think", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00234-00047224-00047327": "president my question with that notice", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00235-00047328-00047446": "what someone has given is the minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00236-00047447-00047630": "representing the minnesota police", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00237-00047631-00047758": "one will the minister confirm that the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00238-00047759-00047895": "mental health care response unit", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00239-00047896-00048086": "consists of four teams of nine uh police", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00240-00048087-00048215": "officers as well as the authorized", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00241-00048216-00048367": "mental health practitioners source from", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00242-00048368-00048583": "local health providers two if not one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00243-00048584-00048702": "will administer provide the exact", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00244-00048703-00048815": "composition of mental health", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00245-00048816-00049030": "correspondence unit three of any office", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00246-00049031-00049167": "has been moved from any of the four", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00247-00049168-00049390": "teams over the past 12 months and four", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00248-00049391-00049558": "if yes to three which the four teams and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00249-00049559-00049807": "how many officers have been removed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00250-00049808-00050007": "minister for mental health thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00251-00050008-00050207": "very much president and i thank the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00252-00050208-00050335": "member for some notes of the question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00253-00050336-00050471": "the following answer has been provided", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00254-00050472-00050623": "to me by the minister for police the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00255-00050624-00050807": "mcgowan government is recruiting 950", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00256-00050808-00051023": "additional police officers or 15 more", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00257-00051024-00051214": "officers the largest single increase in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00258-00051215-00051342": "police numbers in western australia's", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00259-00051344-00051519": "history the mcgowan government has also", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00260-00051520-00051654": "committed to boosting funding by an", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00261-00051655-00051870": "estimated 20.2 million dollars for the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00262-00051871-00052054": "mental health co-response program to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00263-00052055-00052199": "expand the program to bunbury and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00264-00052200-00052375": "geraldton and to provide more mental", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00265-00052376-00052566": "health teams in the metropolitan area", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00266-00052567-00052711": "one to two the western australia police", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00267-00052712-00052926": "force advise yes the authorized mental", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00268-00052927-00053079": "health practitioners are provided by the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00269-00053079-00053279": "department of health three to four", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00270-00053279-00053430": "deployment decisions are made by the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00271-00053432-00053615": "commissioner of police the wa police", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00272-00053616-00053782": "force advised that in the last 12 months", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00273-00053783-00053966": "during the state of emergency several", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00274-00053967-00054142": "officers have been temporarily deployed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00275-00054144-00054335": "to operation tired in response to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00276-00054336-00054535": "colby 19 pandemic and to the perth watch", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00277-00054536-00054694": "house further to accommodate the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00278-00054695-00054919": "temporary temporary deployments some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00279-00054920-00055071": "staff from the connington team have also", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00280-00055072-00055263": "been temporarily redeployed to other", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00281-00055264-00055471": "teams without affecting the response in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00282-00055472-00055679": "cannington the wa police force is on", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00283-00055679-00055911": "track to boost mental health co-response", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00284-00055912-00056150": "in the metropolitan and regional areas", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00285-00056151-00056359": "the honourable wilson tucker", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00286-00056360-00056550": "thank you president my question without", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00287-00056551-00056687": "notice in which some notice has been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00288-00056688-00056775": "given", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00289-00056776-00056919": "is to the minister representing the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00290-00056920-00057223": "minister for fire and emergency services", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00291-00057224-00057375": "i refer the minister to an article", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00292-00057376-00057519": "published in today's edition of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00293-00057520-00057735": "countrymen which reports on the traffic", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00294-00057736-00057903": "management and operation of roadblocks", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00295-00057904-00058119": "during the waroleu bushfires in february", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00296-00058120-00058230": "this year", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00297-00058232-00058407": "i note the article paraphrases one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00298-00058408-00058654": "resident as describing the roadblock", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00299-00058655-00058823": "experience as more stressful than the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00300-00058824-00058935": "fire", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00301-00058936-00059238": "given the january 2016 warruna fire", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00302-00059239-00059526": "special inquiry explicitly recommended a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00303-00059527-00059679": "review of the policy for traffic", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00304-00059679-00059926": "management at emergency incidents to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00305-00059927-00060175": "reflect national best practice can the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00306-00060176-00060366": "minister provide an update on the status", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00307-00060367-00060615": "of this much needed review", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00308-00060616-00060775": "leader of the house", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00309-00060776-00060950": "thanks uh president i thank honourable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00310-00060951-00061175": "member for some notice of the question a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00311-00061176-00061423": "working group was convened on the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00312-00061424-00061703": "2nd of september 2016", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00313-00061704-00061926": "to consider recommendation 14 of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00314-00061927-00062319": "january 2016 varuna fire special inquiry", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00315-00062320-00062494": "to review the policy for traffic", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00316-00062495-00062719": "management at emergency incidents the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00317-00062720-00062903": "working group revisited the policy and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00318-00062904-00063126": "guidelines in review of the ferguson", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00319-00063127-00063342": "findings the group concluded that the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00320-00063344-00063511": "existing policy did not require", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00321-00063512-00063766": "amendment but did identify the need to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00322-00063767-00064030": "improve implementation and communication", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00323-00064032-00064230": "of the processes including the newly", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00324-00064232-00064399": "developed department of fire and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00325-00064400-00064623": "emergency services restricted access", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00326-00064624-00064759": "permit system", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00327-00064760-00064926": "the working group oversaw the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00328-00064927-00065126": "development of an aid memoir for use by", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00329-00065127-00065375": "personnel at the vehicle checkpoints a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00330-00065376-00065559": "checklist describing the establishment", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00331-00065560-00065775": "and operation of the traffic management", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00332-00065776-00065919": "planning function for use by the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00333-00065920-00066103": "incident management team and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00334-00066104-00066294": "implementation of the fire and emergency", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00335-00066295-00066567": "services restricted access permit system", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00336-00066568-00066799": "including education and information for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00337-00066800-00067103": "the community and first responders", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00338-00067104-00067519": "the honourable sophia mormont", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00339-00067520-00067735": "my question without notice of which some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00340-00067736-00067982": "notice has been given is to the minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00341-00067983-00068294": "for regional development agriculture and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00342-00068295-00068423": "food", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00343-00068424-00068655": "i refer the minister to the regional dry", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00344-00068656-00068975": "crop agronomy seed cultivated trials and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00345-00068976-00069311": "harvest survey overseen by hemp grow and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00346-00069312-00069567": "financed by government funding in the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00347-00069568-00069787": "financial year", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00348-00069788-00070119": "2018-19 and i ask one does the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00349-00070120-00070271": "government intend to release the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00350-00070272-00070582": "findings of the trials and or survey or", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00351-00070583-00070775": "does it have a timetable for the release", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00352-00070776-00071079": "of that information by any third parties", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00353-00071080-00071343": "two were any similar trials or studies", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00354-00071344-00071719": "undertaken or completed since 2018 and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00355-00071720-00072119": "19 and if so what plans if any are there", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00356-00072120-00072335": "to release that information", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00357-00072336-00072575": "three are there any plans to continue", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00358-00072576-00072831": "such research into the future and is the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00359-00072832-00073047": "minister able to share those plans with", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00360-00073048-00073279": "the house", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00361-00073280-00073535": "the minister for regional development um", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00362-00073536-00073775": "i thank the member for the question i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00363-00073776-00073982": "remember yesterday i did provide", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00364-00073983-00074287": "information about uh the trials that we", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00365-00074288-00074535": "are currently doing so the answer to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00366-00074536-00074767": "that part of the question obviously is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00367-00074768-00074950": "yes as per", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00368-00074951-00075247": "the question that we provided yesterday", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00369-00075248-00075471": "in relation to those", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00370-00075472-00075671": "particular", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00371-00075672-00075855": "studies that were done under the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00372-00075856-00076143": "auspices of hemp grow", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00373-00076144-00076399": "we um i'm advised that", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00374-00076400-00076662": "this information has", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00375-00076663-00076847": "all available results to date in this", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00376-00076848-00077126": "research area have been given in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00377-00077127-00077382": "numerous forums including open forums of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00378-00077383-00077743": "growers in april 2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00379-00077744-00077935": "um an emerging industries food", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00380-00077936-00078262": "conference in darwin may 2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00381-00078263-00078567": "interviews and regional abc results were", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00382-00078568-00078759": "presented on all hemp trials at a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00383-00078760-00079215": "conference in fremantle in february 2000", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00384-00079216-00079511": "and that says 2020 in a symposium in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00385-00079512-00079782": "march 2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00386-00079783-00080135": "both events in fremantle covered media", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00387-00080136-00080375": "media coverage but remember i do think", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00388-00080376-00080582": "that this sort of information", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00389-00080583-00080894": "should be placed um on the website so", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00390-00080895-00081038": "that it is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00391-00081039-00081350": "properly available so i have today asked", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00392-00081351-00081487": "um deephead", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00393-00081488-00081671": "to make sure", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00394-00081672-00081903": "that they put these collate these", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00395-00081904-00082231": "reports and that that material will be", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00396-00082232-00082343": "um", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00397-00082344-00082550": "will be online it will be available on", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00398-00082551-00082862": "the website um obviously the work that i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00399-00082863-00083199": "referred to yesterday the 2021 work um", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00400-00083200-00083415": "is still underway but we will certainly", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00401-00083416-00083838": "be um presenting that at the march 2022", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00402-00083839-00083991": "um", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00403-00083992-00084343": "third biennial australian industrial", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00404-00084344-00084582": "hemp conference", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00405-00084583-00084791": "the honourable brian walker", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00406-00084792-00084959": "thank you president uh my question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00407-00084960-00085111": "without notice of which submitters has", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00408-00085112-00085238": "been given is to the parliamentary", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00409-00085239-00085438": "secretary to the attorney general", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00410-00085439-00085623": "i refer the parliamentary secretary to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00411-00085624-00085775": "the review of the criminal property", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00412-00085776-00085935": "confiscation act undertaken by the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00413-00085936-00086150": "honourable wayne martin which concluded", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00414-00086151-00086359": "two years ago almost to the day and was", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00415-00086360-00086503": "tabled without comment in the other", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00416-00086504-00086750": "place in december 2019", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00417-00086751-00086950": "acknowledging the many other legislative", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00418-00086951-00087118": "reforms currently in the pipeline are", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00419-00087119-00087271": "nonetheless ask", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00420-00087272-00087479": "what timetable if any is the attorney", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00421-00087480-00087662": "general working to in terms of a formal", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00422-00087663-00087894": "response to the review either in whole", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00423-00087895-00088111": "or in part and when might be reasonably", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00424-00088112-00088311": "expect to see something tabled here or", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00425-00088312-00088518": "in the other place", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00426-00088519-00088671": "uh the parliamentary secretary to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00427-00088672-00088855": "attorney general thank you president and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00428-00088856-00088999": "i thank the member for some notice of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00429-00089000-00089143": "the question and the following answer is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00430-00089144-00089294": "provided on behalf of the attorney", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00431-00089295-00089503": "general as the member rightly points out", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00432-00089504-00089703": "the government has a considerable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00433-00089704-00089887": "legislative agenda additionally for much", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00434-00089888-00090062": "of last year significant resources in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00435-00090063-00090223": "the department of justice were", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00436-00090224-00090438": "redirected to the covert 19 pandemic", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00437-00090439-00090662": "response the martin review made more", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00438-00090663-00090871": "than 60 recommendations canvassing both", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00439-00090872-00091055": "legislative and administrative matters", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00440-00091056-00091206": "with the primary recommendation being", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00441-00091207-00091335": "that the government give consideration", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00442-00091336-00091494": "to repealing and replacing the act in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00443-00091495-00091711": "its entirety the recommendations of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00444-00091712-00091871": "martin review remain under detailed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00445-00091872-00092062": "consideration by the government noting", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00446-00092063-00092231": "that criminal property confiscation", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00447-00092232-00092455": "scheme is complex and any reform should", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00448-00092456-00092655": "it be pursued would be a large body of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00449-00092656-00092791": "work", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00450-00092792-00092999": "the honourable martin aldrich thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00451-00093000-00093126": "president my question with that notice", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00452-00093127-00093311": "of which some notice has been given is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00453-00093312-00093494": "to the minister for trans uh minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00454-00093495-00093647": "representing the minister of transport i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00455-00093648-00093774": "refer to the extension of the tonkin", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00456-00093775-00093911": "highway referred to as the north link", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00457-00093912-00094118": "project and asked one since the project", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00458-00094119-00094311": "was opened to traffic how many claims of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00459-00094312-00094455": "compensation has main roads or its", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00460-00094456-00094623": "contractors received relating to damage", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00461-00094624-00094847": "caused by loose surface material two how", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00462-00094848-00094974": "many claims have been settled and what", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00463-00094975-00095111": "is the total value of compensation", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00464-00095112-00095303": "payments to date three how many noise", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00465-00095304-00095462": "complaints have been received to date", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00466-00095463-00095623": "for has the results of the noise", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00467-00095624-00095774": "monitoring survey that was undertaken at", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00468-00095775-00095974": "the end of august 2020 been publicly", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00469-00095975-00096159": "publicly released as the minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00470-00096160-00096255": "committed to an answer to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00471-00096256-00096374": "legislative council question without", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00472-00096375-00096615": "knows one two one one and five if yes to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00473-00096616-00096759": "four please table the report if not why", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00474-00096760-00096855": "not", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00475-00096856-00097023": "the leader of the house thanks president", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00476-00097024-00097143": "i thank honourable member for some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00477-00097144-00097261": "notice of the question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00478-00097262-00097391": "[Applause]", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00479-00097392-00097711": "uh one 1724", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00480-00097712-00097794": "two", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00481-00097795-00098082": "1457 claims have been resolved", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00482-00098083-00098399": "964 claims have been paid totaling nine", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00483-00098400-00098543": "hundred and forty seven thousand two", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00484-00098544-00098799": "hundred sixty one dollars three forty", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00485-00098800-00099047": "three four and five results of the noise", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00486-00099048-00099238": "monitoring survey have been provided to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00487-00099239-00099415": "the residents who lodged noise", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00488-00099416-00099535": "complaints", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00489-00099536-00099879": "and uh we will table the report", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00490-00099880-00100087": "uh this says", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00491-00100088-00100223": "tomorrow", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00492-00100224-00100518": "now this question was lodged on the 25th", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00493-00100519-00100831": "of may so i'm going", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00494-00100832-00101015": "which is what this answer says right", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00495-00101016-00101255": "yeah okay so we're all good we're on the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00496-00101256-00101391": "same page okay", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00497-00101392-00101543": "thanks president", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00498-00101544-00101831": "uh thank you can we uh the honourable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00499-00101832-00101974": "james haywood", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00500-00101975-00102262": "uh thank you president uh my question uh", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00501-00102263-00102430": "without notice to which some notice has", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00502-00102431-00102582": "been given us to the leader of the house", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00503-00102583-00102799": "representing the minister for housing or", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00504-00102800-00102999": "if it refer to the end of the rental", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00505-00103000-00103271": "moratorium on the 28th of march and i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00506-00103272-00103551": "ask one how many eviction notices have", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00507-00103552-00103758": "there been from public housing", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00508-00103759-00103990": "two further to one how many people or", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00509-00103991-00104166": "families have been evicted into", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00510-00104167-00104399": "homelessness from public housing", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00511-00104400-00104599": "three is the minister aware that a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00512-00104600-00104919": "family of five children is one of 159", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00513-00104920-00105119": "families in the magistrates court over", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00514-00105120-00105439": "the last two days facing tenancy here", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00515-00105440-00105695": "tenancy hearings and evictions and how", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00516-00105696-00105847": "many homes has the government spot", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00517-00105848-00106039": "purchased in advance of the moratorium", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00518-00106040-00106134": "lifting", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00519-00106135-00106366": "four is the minister aware", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00520-00106367-00106583": "the by name homeless count for perth", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00521-00106583-00106919": "fremantle and surrounds increased by 58", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00522-00106920-00107239": "since november 2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00523-00107240-00107486": "uh can the minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00524-00107488-00107590": "uh", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00525-00107591-00107743": "name sorry", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00526-00107744-00108007": "i'm not sure that november must be 2020", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00527-00108008-00108175": "can the minister name", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00528-00108176-00108366": "any programs currently in place to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00529-00108367-00108551": "direct", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00530-00108552-00108751": "directly increase the supply of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00531-00108752-00109007": "affordable rental properties", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00532-00109008-00109239": "the leader of the house uh president", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00533-00109240-00109399": "uh i think the honourable member for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00534-00109400-00109566": "some notice of the question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00535-00109567-00109854": "uh one to two since the 28th of march", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00536-00109855-00110110": "2021 there have been zero effect", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00537-00110111-00110319": "evictions from public housing", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00538-00110320-00110478": "three to four matters regarding the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00539-00110479-00110671": "magistrates court and the project should", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00540-00110672-00110871": "be referred to the attorney general and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00541-00110872-00111015": "the minister for community services", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00542-00111016-00111151": "respectively", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00543-00111152-00111327": "five the mcgowan government is investing", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00544-00111328-00111502": "nearly one billion dollars in social and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00545-00111503-00111766": "affordable housing programs and homeless", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00546-00111767-00112047": "support services programs including the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00547-00112048-00112286": "social housing economic recovery package", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00548-00112288-00112423": "and the housing and homelessness", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00549-00112424-00112623": "investment package in partnership with", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00550-00112624-00112758": "the commonwealth government the wa", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00551-00112759-00112951": "government is continuing to increase", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00552-00112952-00113110": "affordable rental supply through the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00553-00113111-00113327": "national rental affordability scheme", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00554-00113328-00113486": "which stimulates new privately owned", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00555-00113488-00113615": "construction to be delivered for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00556-00113616-00113863": "affordable rental purposes", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00557-00113864-00114007": "under the scheme owners receive", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00558-00114008-00114199": "incentives to rent their property to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00559-00114200-00114358": "eligible low to moderate income", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00560-00114359-00114607": "households for at least 20 below market", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00561-00114608-00114783": "rate tax incentives from the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00562-00114783-00114951": "commonwealth and financial incentives", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00563-00114952-00115166": "from the state are provided in arrears", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00564-00115167-00115375": "for ten years the mcgowan government's", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00565-00115376-00115543": "twenty thousand dollar building bonus", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00566-00115544-00115743": "grant is playing a critical role in the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00567-00115744-00115934": "significant increase of new home", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00568-00115935-00116207": "building approvals in wa with over 24", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00569-00116208-00116463": "000 applications received as at 20th of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00570-00116464-00116719": "may 2021 in the 12 months to march there", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00571-00116720-00117071": "have been 23 100 new homes approved for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00572-00117072-00117254": "construction the largest growth on", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00573-00117255-00117519": "record as new homes come online site", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00574-00117520-00117751": "supply side pressures will", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00575-00117752-00117910": "begin to ease with more properties in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00576-00117911-00118086": "the rental market", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00577-00118088-00118319": "the honourable neil thompson", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00578-00118320-00118471": "president uh my question with our", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00579-00118472-00118639": "numbers for which some notice has given", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00580-00118640-00118886": "us to the minister for education i refer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00581-00118888-00119063": "to verbal reports by local leaders and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00582-00119064-00119215": "school teachers that school attendance", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00583-00119216-00119383": "among aboriginal children has dropped", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00584-00119383-00119575": "significance since the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00585-00119576-00119863": "onset of the covert crisis uh concerns", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00586-00119864-00120039": "exist that this trend will exacerbate", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00587-00120040-00120239": "further disadvantage and i ask is the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00588-00120240-00120414": "minister aware of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00589-00120415-00120647": "reports of reduced school attendance", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00590-00120648-00120878": "and two what is the average attendance", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00591-00120879-00121078": "rates of students in each year cohort k", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00592-00121079-00121375": "to 12 in the following locations in the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00593-00121376-00121886": "years 2016 2019 2020 and 2021 and uh for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00594-00121888-00122071": "the locations of halls creek fitzroy", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00595-00122072-00122343": "crossing windham derby and canonnaire", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00596-00122344-00122478": "leader of the house thanks president i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00597-00122479-00122583": "thank the honourable member for some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00598-00122583-00122814": "notice of the question one yes two in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00599-00122815-00122990": "2020 the kimberley region received", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00600-00122991-00123110": "additional funding to support the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00601-00123111-00123383": "re-engagement of students attendance", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00602-00123383-00123614": "data for 2021 and not provided as the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00603-00123615-00123847": "semester has not been completed the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00604-00123848-00123975": "department of education's data", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00605-00123976-00124166": "verification processes are not commenced", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00606-00124167-00124407": "until term three attendance data for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00607-00124408-00124734": "2016 to 2020 are provided for semester", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00608-00124735-00124895": "one each year in accordance with the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00609-00124896-00125078": "national standards for student", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00610-00125079-00125334": "attendance data reporting the data in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00611-00125335-00125583": "2019 were affected by an early and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00612-00125583-00125831": "particularly severe flu season the data", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00613-00125832-00126095": "in 2020 were severely affected by covert", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00614-00126096-00126431": "19 particularly in weeks 7 to 10 of term", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00615-00126432-00126719": "one two data sets are provided for 2020", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00616-00126720-00126919": "actual which includes all weeks of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00617-00126920-00127190": "semester one and adjusted which excludes", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00618-00127191-00127407": "weeks seven to ten term one if we can", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00619-00127408-00127495": "just", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00620-00127496-00127614": "by way of background there's been an", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00621-00127615-00127766": "agreement at a national level about how", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00622-00127767-00127919": "we will record", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00623-00127920-00128151": "our data in some debate i'm quite happy", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00624-00128152-00128302": "for all of west australian data to be", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00625-00128303-00128463": "out there because it's one of the best", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00626-00128464-00128814": "uh in australia during the pandemic but", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00627-00128815-00129007": "there's a debate nationally about what", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00628-00129008-00129214": "the data looks like that's made public", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00629-00129215-00129471": "um as the information is provided in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00630-00129472-00129678": "tabular form i seek leave to have this", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00631-00129679-00129863": "incorporated into handset", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00632-00129864-00130078": "members the leader of the house", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00633-00130079-00130263": "seeks leave to incorporate that table", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00634-00130264-00130471": "into hand side is leave granted i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00635-00130472-00130647": "believe is granted", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00636-00130648-00130895": "um the honorable steve martin thank you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00637-00130896-00131054": "president my question without notice of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00638-00131055-00131190": "which some notice is given is to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00639-00131191-00131335": "parliamentary secretary representing the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00640-00131336-00131502": "minister for electoral affairs i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00641-00131503-00131671": "referred a response given yesterday by", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00642-00131672-00131823": "the parliamentary secretary on behalf of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00643-00131824-00131943": "the minister of electoral affairs the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00644-00131944-00132111": "honourable young sigma regarding", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00645-00132112-00132254": "electoral reform of the upper house in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00646-00132255-00132431": "which a reference was made to widely", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00647-00132432-00132654": "expressed community concern and i ask", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00648-00132655-00132871": "number one can the minister advise what", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00649-00132872-00133078": "consultation process was used to gauge", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00650-00133079-00133239": "the widespread community concern at the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00651-00133240-00133502": "election at the election result two over", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00652-00133503-00133678": "what time period did the consultation", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00653-00133679-00133766": "take", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00654-00133767-00133966": "consultation process take place and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00655-00133967-00134214": "three was the consultation undertaken in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00656-00134215-00134407": "regional wa and what percentage of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00657-00134408-00134790": "population in regional wa were concerned", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00658-00134791-00134943": "the parliamentary secretary to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00659-00134944-00135111": "attorney general thank you president and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00660-00135112-00135319": "i thank the member for some uh earnest", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00661-00135320-00135495": "of the question and i provide this", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00662-00135496-00135654": "following response on behalf of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00663-00135655-00135854": "minister for electoral affairs one to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00664-00135855-00136047": "three the march 2020 general election", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00665-00136048-00136254": "prompted widespread media coverage of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00666-00136255-00136447": "the anomalous results in the legislative", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00667-00136448-00136614": "council the government established the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00668-00136615-00136759": "ministerial expert committee the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00669-00136760-00136927": "committee on electoral reform to review", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00670-00136928-00137078": "the electoral system for the legislative", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00671-00137079-00137351": "council and provide recommendations the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00672-00137352-00137495": "committee is undertaking a wide", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00673-00137496-00137743": "consultation with the wa community it", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00674-00137744-00137847": "has asked", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00675-00137848-00138007": "interested members of the public and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00676-00138008-00138239": "organizations to make submissions on its", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00677-00138240-00138407": "terms of reference and there has been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00678-00138408-00138566": "considerable interest from the public", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00679-00138567-00138766": "regarding the review the committee has", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00680-00138767-00138966": "received over 50 submissions which it is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00681-00138967-00139166": "currently considering submissions are", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00682-00139167-00139359": "open to the public until tuesday the 8th", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00683-00139360-00139639": "of june 2021 information terms of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00684-00139640-00139799": "reference and public submissions can be", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00685-00139800-00140054": "found on the committee website at wa", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00686-00140055-00140178": "electoral", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00687-00140179-00140519": "reform.wa.gov dot ayu", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00688-00140520-00140695": "the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00689-00140696-00141047": "leader", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00690-00141048-00141183": "notice of which some notice has been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00691-00141184-00141302": "given as to the leader of the house", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00692-00141303-00141583": "representing the minister for transport", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00693-00141584-00141711": "i referred a question without notice", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00694-00141712-00142007": "1083 asked on the 14th of october 2020", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00695-00142008-00142231": "on the pfas contaminated oil extracted", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00696-00142232-00142375": "during tunneling from the firestone", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00697-00142376-00142656": "airport", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00698-00142657-00142854": "[Applause]", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00699-00142855-00143102": "they're very keen today", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00700-00143103-00143447": "are we finished now honorable members", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00701-00143448-00143599": "do you need me to start again leader of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00702-00143600-00143911": "the house i can just continue", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00703-00143912-00144111": "i think you've got it", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00704-00144112-00144263": "i ask", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00705-00144264-00144478": "one has any of the six hundred thousand", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00706-00144479-00144743": "cubic meters of spoil stockpiled at 777", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00707-00144744-00144902": "abernathy road forest field now been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00708-00144903-00145111": "reused and if so where", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00709-00145112-00145366": "two has any of the 110 000 cubic metres", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00710-00145367-00145551": "of spoil stockpiled at perth airport now", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00711-00145552-00145775": "been reused and if so where", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00712-00145776-00146031": "three has the estimated 160 000 cubic", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00713-00146032-00146223": "meters been used on the fal project as", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00714-00146224-00146375": "predicted and from what storage source", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00715-00146376-00146511": "was derived", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00716-00146512-00146687": "four how long can the government store", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00717-00146688-00146854": "the spoil on temporary storage sites", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00718-00146855-00147111": "before it is considered a waste and five", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00719-00147112-00147295": "would the same time frame apply to spoil", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00720-00147296-00147607": "accumulated by a private sector business", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00721-00147608-00147775": "leader of the house thanks president i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00722-00147776-00147895": "thank honourable member for some notice", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00723-00147896-00148087": "of the question one of the joys now", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00724-00148088-00148199": "about representing the minister for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00725-00148200-00148414": "transport is i get to answer the pfas", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00726-00148415-00148535": "questions", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00727-00148536-00148878": "so i'm delighted to answer my first one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00728-00148879-00149151": "one to two no three yes abernathy road", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00729-00149152-00149302": "four the material is not considered", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00730-00149303-00149654": "waste five not applicable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00731-00149655-00149895": "the honourable colin de grusa", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00732-00149896-00150023": "president my question without notice of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00733-00150024-00150199": "which some nice notice has been given is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00734-00150200-00150407": "the minister for agriculture and food", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00735-00150408-00150551": "i refer to the state barrier fence", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00736-00150552-00150759": "esperance extension and i ask one since", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00737-00150760-00150919": "the completion of the initial 63", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00738-00150920-00151143": "kilometers of fence in april 2020 have", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00739-00151144-00151295": "any additional sections of the fence", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00740-00151296-00151535": "being constructed two if not what has", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00741-00151536-00151775": "been the cause of the delay three have", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00742-00151776-00151926": "any materials for the construction of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00743-00151927-00152087": "the remaining sections of the fence been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00744-00152088-00152351": "procured and if so how are they stored", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00745-00152352-00152487": "four can the minister commit to a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00746-00152488-00152647": "definitive timeline within which the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00747-00152648-00152831": "remainder of the fence will be completed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00748-00152832-00153095": "if not why not", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00749-00153096-00153295": "minister for regional development i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00750-00153296-00153535": "thank the member for the question and i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00751-00153536-00153711": "think he actually probably knows the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00752-00153712-00153935": "answer because he has been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00753-00153936-00154319": "following the issue for some time but it", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00754-00154320-00154404": "is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00755-00154405-00154519": "[Applause]", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00756-00154520-00154671": "the delay", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00757-00154672-00155023": "is caused or the our inability to start", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00758-00155024-00155278": "the remainder of the project is because", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00759-00155279-00155454": "we are still", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00760-00155455-00155807": "undertaking the illum negotiations now i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00761-00155808-00156078": "can understand they are taking uh a long", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00762-00156079-00156343": "time there has been some impact of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00763-00156344-00156519": "covert in that some of the group", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00764-00156520-00156663": "meetings", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00765-00156664-00157007": "did have to be cancelled", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00766-00157008-00157254": "we certainly have looked at um what", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00767-00157255-00157543": "other ways we might be uh able to do", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00768-00157544-00157639": "this", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00769-00157640-00157839": "i think there's some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00770-00157840-00157990": "and i presume the member has been", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00771-00157991-00158263": "contacted by uh the farmers on whose", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00772-00158264-00158454": "property the um", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00773-00158455-00158726": "the fencing is stored", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00774-00158727-00158959": "they", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00775-00158960-00159239": "there is a view that 70 of the remainder", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00776-00159240-00159502": "is on freehold property and so we should", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00777-00159503-00159678": "be able to get on with it", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00778-00159679-00159895": "my understanding it's only around 25", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00779-00159896-00160119": "percent of the remainder is on freehold", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00780-00160120-00160247": "property", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00781-00160248-00160407": "and it is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00782-00160408-00160671": "very very interspersed but", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00783-00160672-00161054": "i've certainly had a letter from mr neil", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00784-00161055-00161326": "wandel talking about whether or not we", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00785-00161327-00161575": "can look at having some arrangements", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00786-00161576-00161790": "where those little bits that are there", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00787-00161791-00162071": "um can be done um", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00788-00162072-00162295": "separately while we're trying to resolve", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00789-00162296-00162551": "uh the native title for the other areas", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00790-00162552-00162726": "uh the advice from the department", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00791-00162727-00162878": "initially is that that would be too", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00792-00162879-00163087": "expensive but if we can negotiate", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00793-00163088-00163366": "something uh we're happy to do it now", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00794-00163367-00163599": "the idea that somehow other there's a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00795-00163600-00163790": "problem with this fencing being out in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00796-00163791-00163935": "the weather", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00797-00163936-00164326": "it is outside but you will know member", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00798-00164327-00164623": "that um that", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00799-00164624-00164854": "but certainly if you can assure mr", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00800-00164855-00165190": "wandel uh that this is designed to be", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00801-00165191-00165343": "out in the weather right it's our", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00802-00165344-00165463": "intention it's going to be out in the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00803-00165464-00165751": "weather for many many many decades so", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00804-00165752-00165919": "i'd hope the fact that it's out in the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00805-00165920-00166159": "weather it's galvanized", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00806-00166160-00166359": "and certainly from the pictures i've", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00807-00166360-00166663": "seen it looks quite bright and shiny", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00808-00166664-00166743": "so", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00809-00166744-00166926": "i'm not quite sure what the cause of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00810-00166927-00167214": "concern is but it look it has taken much", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00811-00167215-00167543": "longer than table the picture", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00812-00167544-00167766": "i'm quite happy to table the photograph", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00813-00167767-00167959": "of mr wandel if he would like to get", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00814-00167960-00168614": "into the pa at night get", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00815-00168615-00168807": "but i just say i look i i understand the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00816-00168808-00169099": "frustration certainly uh the illumin", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00817-00169100-00169487": "negotiations are taking uh a long time", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00818-00169488-00169735": "uh the department uh is very focused on", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00819-00169736-00169926": "trying to bring those to a resolution", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00820-00169927-00170254": "but there are processes that are really", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00821-00170255-00170478": "outside our control", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00822-00170479-00170702": "the honourable young sigma", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00823-00170703-00170863": "uh my question without notice which some", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00824-00170864-00170990": "notice has given is to the minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00825-00170991-00171095": "representing the minister for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00826-00171096-00171199": "environment", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00827-00171200-00171366": "uh i refer to the answer the minister", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00828-00171367-00171590": "provided me on 25 may concerning the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00829-00171591-00171814": "origin of information which was provided", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00830-00171815-00172054": "in an answer to an earlier question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00831-00172055-00172238": "about data relating to the diversion of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00832-00172239-00172454": "construction and demolition or c d waste", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00833-00172455-00172599": "and i ask one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00834-00172600-00172766": "does the minister's answer imply that", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00835-00172767-00172926": "official statistics derive from", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00836-00172927-00173071": "self-reporting of the operators", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00837-00173072-00173366": "themselves and two if yes to one what", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00838-00173367-00173543": "specific process does the department of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00839-00173544-00173695": "water and environmental regulation", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00840-00173696-00173854": "currently undertake to validate the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00841-00173855-00173990": "integrity of this self-reported", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00842-00173991-00174159": "information", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00843-00174160-00174335": "uh the minister for mental health thank", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00844-00174336-00174454": "you president and i thank the honourable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00845-00174455-00174551": "member for some knowledge of the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00846-00174552-00174695": "question the finances provided on behalf", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00847-00174696-00174854": "of the minister for environment", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00848-00174855-00175071": "one recyclers are required to report", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00849-00175072-00175263": "waste and recycling data annually under", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00850-00175264-00175471": "regulation 18c of the waste avoidance", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00851-00175472-00175783": "and resource recovery regulations 2008.", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00852-00175784-00176071": "regulation 18d of the regulations", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00853-00176072-00176278": "requires information to be calculated or", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00854-00176279-00176463": "estimated in accordance with gazetted", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00855-00176464-00176638": "procedures approved by the chief", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00856-00176639-00176783": "executive officer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00857-00176784-00177031": "in relation to the waste levy licensees", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00858-00177032-00177302": "must make a record under regulation 17", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00859-00177303-00177454": "of the waste avoidance and resource", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00860-00177455-00177702": "recovery regulations under under", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00861-00177703-00177887": "regulation 18", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00862-00177888-00178126": "use these records to make a return in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00863-00178127-00178359": "the approved form setting out details of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00864-00178360-00178543": "the waste received and lodged this", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00865-00178544-00178775": "return with the chief executive officer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00866-00178776-00178990": "two an audit program is undertaken each", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00867-00178991-00179254": "year to verify the integrity of the data", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00868-00179255-00179471": "reported for a sample of returns in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00869-00179472-00179678": "addition validation is undertaken for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00870-00179679-00179895": "each return returns are compared against", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00871-00179896-00180087": "data reported in the previous year", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00872-00180088-00180302": "returns are also checked against data", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00873-00180303-00180559": "reported under licensed conditions", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00874-00180560-00180671": "leon", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00875-00180672-00180838": "the leader of the house", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00876-00180839-00180935": "of the house", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00877-00180936-00181175": "the business of the house is resumed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00878-00181176-00181359": "ministers or parliamentary secretaries", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00879-00181360-00181543": "are there any further answers", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00880-00181544-00181687": "president on behalf of the minister for", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00881-00181688-00181919": "housing i'd like to provide um an answer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00882-00181920-00182047": "for the honourable", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00883-00182048-00182271": "colin de grues's question without notice", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00884-00182272-00182487": "130 and the honorable steve martin's", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00885-00182488-00182838": "question without notice 139 asked on the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00886-00182839-00183054": "25th of may and i sickly to have them", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00887-00183055-00183287": "incorporated into hansard", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00888-00183288-00183495": "the ministers sex leave to have both", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00889-00183496-00183702": "those answers incorporated into hand", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00890-00183703-00183863": "side is leave granted", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00891-00183864-00184047": "leave is granted the minister for mental", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00892-00184048-00184207": "health president i would like to provide", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00893-00184208-00184326": "an answer to the honourable donald", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00894-00184327-00184526": "farraguer's question without notice 133", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00895-00184527-00184823": "which was asked on 25 may 2021 and i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00896-00184824-00184943": "seek leave to have the answer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00897-00184944-00185166": "incorporated into hansa members the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00898-00185167-00185326": "minister sticks leave to have that", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00899-00185327-00185519": "answer incorporated into hansard is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00900-00185520-00185631": "leave granted", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00901-00185632-00185863": "believe is granted minister for mental", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00902-00185864-00186007": "health president i would like to provide", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00903-00186008-00186126": "an answer to the honourable brian", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00904-00186127-00186350": "walker's question without notice 155", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00905-00186351-00186623": "which was asked on 26 may 2021 and i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00906-00186624-00186735": "seek leave to have the answer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00907-00186736-00186935": "incorporated into hanzo members the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00908-00186936-00187119": "minister 6 leave to have that answer", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00909-00187120-00187295": "incorporated into hansard is leave", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00910-00187296-00187390": "granted", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00911-00187391-00187559": "leave his granted minister for mental", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00912-00187560-00187695": "health president i would like to provide", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00913-00187696-00187807": "an answer to the honourable wilson", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00914-00187808-00188007": "tucker's question without notice 154", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00915-00188008-00188287": "which is asked on 26 may 2021 and i seek", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00916-00188288-00188414": "leave to have the answer incorporated", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00917-00188415-00188647": "into hansard members the minister seeks", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00918-00188648-00188814": "leave to have that answer incorporated", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00919-00188815-00189047": "into hansard is leave granted i", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00920-00189048-00189223": "believe is granted president i would", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00921-00189224-00189311": "like to provide an answer to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00922-00189312-00189431": "honourable colin de grosse's question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00923-00189432-00189719": "without notice 149 which was asked on 26", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00924-00189720-00189926": "may 2021 and i seek leave to have the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00925-00189927-00190111": "answer incorporated into han so members", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00926-00190112-00190263": "the minister sex leave to have that", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00927-00190264-00190447": "answer incorporated into hansard is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00928-00190448-00190766": "leave granted leave is granted president", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00929-00190767-00190975": "uh with respect to the honorable martin", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00930-00190976-00191119": "aldridge's question with a question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00931-00191120-00191326": "without notice 156 part four which was", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00932-00191327-00191463": "asked yesterday", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00933-00191464-00191638": "i've sought clarification and can inform", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00934-00191639-00191814": "the honourable member that invoices are", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00935-00191815-00192071": "generally issued after 60 days", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00936-00192072-00192254": "however some invoices are provided", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00937-00192255-00192438": "within less than 60 days where", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00938-00192439-00192647": "passengers request priority or company", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00939-00192648-00192831": "invoices the effort to provide a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00940-00192832-00193023": "breakdown of the number by time period", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00941-00193024-00193190": "would need to be undertaken by a manual", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00942-00193191-00193414": "process and is not an effective use of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00943-00193415-00193687": "wa health resources", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00944-00193688-00193863": "are there any further", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00945-00193864-00194078": "answers from ministers or parliamentary", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00946-00194079-00194254": "secretaries the minister for regional", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00947-00194255-00194487": "development president i would like to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00948-00194488-00194590": "provide a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00949-00194591-00194831": "correction to the honourable doctor", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00950-00194832-00195102": "steve thomas's qui sorry i would like to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00951-00195103-00195366": "provide a quest a correction to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00952-00195367-00195735": "answer given to the honorable dr steve", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00953-00195736-00195999": "thomas in his question without noticed", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00954-00196000-00196438": "hansard number one to eight are", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00955-00196439-00196543": "asked", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00956-00196544-00196878": "on the 25th of may 2021", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00957-00196879-00197223": "i would like to correct my response to", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00958-00197224-00197438": "part three of the question", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00959-00197439-00197766": "the amount paid is seventy one thousand", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00960-00197767-00198054": "four hundred and sixty eight dollars the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00961-00198055-00198366": "incorrect figure of five hundred and one", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00962-00198367-00198543": "thousand dollars seven hundred and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00963-00198544-00198743": "seventy five hundred and one seven", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00964-00198744-00198926": "hundred and seventy nine", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00965-00198927-00199175": "dollars was provided to the department", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00966-00199176-00199447": "of mines industry regulation and safety", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00967-00199448-00199750": "by qbe i apologize to the house for the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00968-00199751-00199838": "error", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00969-00199839-00199990": "are there any further answers from", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00970-00199991-00200247": "ministers or parliamentary secretaries", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00971-00200248-00200478": "uh president mr honourable peter collier", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00972-00200479-00200614": "thanks president just with regard to a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00973-00200615-00200783": "question that i asked yesterday and", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00974-00200784-00201023": "there was the incorrect reference to a", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00975-00201024-00201287": "question from the premier and the leader", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00976-00201288-00201502": "of the house was going to follow up", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00977-00201503-00201631": "leader of the house on a point of", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00978-00201632-00201854": "clarification yeah if i may i think it", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00979-00201855-00202078": "was just the two different um numbers", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00980-00202079-00202326": "that are used in the council and in the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00981-00202327-00202750": "hand side and um so uh i will behind the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00982-00202751-00202959": "chair tell you which one is", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00983-00202960-00203190": "wrong but that's what it was it was just", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00984-00203191-00203390": "the different numbers that are used in", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00985-00203391-00203526": "the legislative council and that are", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00986-00203527-00203743": "then used in hansard and in answering", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00987-00203744-00204031": "the question as i re as i recall the way", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00988-00204032-00204247": "the answers are provided refers to the", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00989-00204248-00204487": "hansard number but i'll clarify for you", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00990-00204488-00204838": "that behind the chair", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00991-00204839-00204934": "um", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00992-00204935-00205071": "are there any further answers from", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00993-00205071-00205327": "ministers and parliamentary secretaries", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00994-00205328-00205462": "members we", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00995-00205463-00205703": "leader of the house i prove that we move", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00996-00205704-00206046": "to member statements", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00997-00206048-00206190": "members the question is will you now", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00998-00206191-00206390": "move to member statements", "i9X4YYZgrlE-00999-00206391-00206646": "all of the do we need we need to take", "i9X4YYZgrlE-01000-00206648-00206927": "that together", "i9X4YYZgrlE-01001-00206928-00207166": "uh all of those all those of that", "i9X4YYZgrlE-01002-00207167-00207327": "opinion say aye", "i9X4YYZgrlE-01003-00207328-00207527": "to the contrary say no", "i9X4YYZgrlE-01004-00207528-00207775": "their eyes have it members we now have", "i9X4YYZgrlE-01005-00207776-00207966": "member statements are there any members", "i9X4YYZgrlE-01006-00207967-00208332": "with members statements"}}, {"audio_id": "iq32OUls5pg", "text": {"iq32OUls5pg-00000-00000053-00000269": "the second congressional district of", "iq32OUls5pg-00001-00000270-00000461": "South Carolina as a congressional", "iq32OUls5pg-00002-00000462-00000608": "district in Central and southwestern", "iq32OUls5pg-00003-00000609-00000932": "South Carolina the district spans from", "iq32OUls5pg-00004-00000933-00001148": "Columbia to the South Carolina side of", "iq32OUls5pg-00005-00001149-00001384": "the Augusta Georgia metropolitan area", "iq32OUls5pg-00006-00001385-00001780": "from 1993 through 2012 it included all", "iq32OUls5pg-00007-00001782-00001946": "of Lexington Jasper", "iq32OUls5pg-00008-00001947-00002177": "Hampton Allendale and Barnwell counties", "iq32OUls5pg-00009-00002178-00002393": "most of Richland in Beaufort counties", "iq32OUls5pg-00010-00002394-00002573": "and parts of Aiken Calhoun and", "iq32OUls5pg-00011-00002574-00002855": "Orangeburg counties it was made more", "iq32OUls5pg-00012-00002856-00003050": "compact in the 2010 round of", "iq32OUls5pg-00013-00003051-00003256": "redistricting and now comprises all of", "iq32OUls5pg-00014-00003257-00003466": "Lexington Aiken and Barnwell counties", "iq32OUls5pg-00015-00003467-00003664": "most of Richland County and part of", "iq32OUls5pg-00016-00003665-00004034": "Orangeburg County besides Columbia 60%", "iq32OUls5pg-00017-00004035-00004207": "of witches in the district other major", "iq32OUls5pg-00018-00004208-00004418": "cities in the district include Aiken and", "iq32OUls5pg-00019-00004419-00004700": "North Augusta the district's current", "iq32OUls5pg-00020-00004701-00004991": "configuration dates from 1933 following", "iq32OUls5pg-00021-00004992-00005168": "South Carolina losing a seat in", "iq32OUls5pg-00022-00005169-00005395": "apportionment as a result of the 1930", "iq32OUls5pg-00023-00005396-00005536": "census showing that the state's", "iq32OUls5pg-00024-00005537-00005830": "population had declined before that time", "iq32OUls5pg-00025-00005831-00006016": "much of its territory had been within", "iq32OUls5pg-00026-00006017-00006325": "the 6th district as a Columbia based", "iq32OUls5pg-00027-00006326-00006673": "district from 1933 to the early 1990s it", "iq32OUls5pg-00028-00006675-00006872": "was a fairly compact district in the", "iq32OUls5pg-00029-00006873-00007031": "central part of the state which was", "iq32OUls5pg-00030-00007031-00007226": "largely coextensive with the columbia", "iq32OUls5pg-00031-00007227-00007505": "metropolitan area as a result of the", "iq32OUls5pg-00032-00007506-00007775": "1990 census the state legislature was", "iq32OUls5pg-00033-00007776-00007937": "required to draw a black majority", "iq32OUls5pg-00034-00007938-00008237": "district in a deal between Republicans", "iq32OUls5pg-00035-00008238-00008432": "and Democrats the 6th district", "iq32OUls5pg-00036-00008433-00008642": "previously located in the northeastern", "iq32OUls5pg-00037-00008643-00008834": "portion of the state was redefined to", "iq32OUls5pg-00038-00008835-00009014": "incorporate most of the old to ends", "iq32OUls5pg-00039-00009015-00009284": "black residents to make up for the loss", "iq32OUls5pg-00040-00009285-00009545": "in population ii was pushed as far west", "iq32OUls5pg-00041-00009546-00009737": "as the fringes of the augusta suburbs", "iq32OUls5pg-00042-00009738-00009997": "and as far south as before Hilton Head", "iq32OUls5pg-00043-00009998-00010349": "since 1965 the second district has been", "iq32OUls5pg-00044-00010350-00010562": "held by the Republican Party made up of", "iq32OUls5pg-00045-00010563-00010760": "white conservatives in the late 20th", "iq32OUls5pg-00046-00010761-00010976": "century realignment of political parties", "iq32OUls5pg-00047-00010977-00011231": "in the south in the decades after the", "iq32OUls5pg-00048-00011232-00011429": "Civil War and before disenfranchisement", "iq32OUls5pg-00049-00011430-00011744": "in 1895 under the new state constitution", "iq32OUls5pg-00050-00011745-00011963": "members of the Republican Party in South", "iq32OUls5pg-00051-00011964-00012149": "Carolina and the south were mostly", "iq32OUls5pg-00052-00012150-00012326": "African Americans including many", "iq32OUls5pg-00053-00012327-00012578": "freedmen enfranchised due to Republican", "iq32OUls5pg-00054-00012579-00012769": "support for amendments for emancipation", "iq32OUls5pg-00055-00012770-00013039": "citizenship and the franchise after", "iq32OUls5pg-00056-00013040-00013241": "white Democrats regained control of", "iq32OUls5pg-00057-00013241-00013436": "state governments across the south", "iq32OUls5pg-00058-00013437-00013666": "in the late 19th century they passed new", "iq32OUls5pg-00059-00013668-00013975": "constitutions from 1890 to 1908 to", "iq32OUls5pg-00060-00013976-00014186": "disenfranchise blacks excluding them", "iq32OUls5pg-00061-00014187-00014455": "totally from the political process the", "iq32OUls5pg-00062-00014456-00014641": "Republican Party was crippled in the", "iq32OUls5pg-00063-00014643-00014972": "region in nearly comatose as a result of", "iq32OUls5pg-00064-00014972-00015136": "the civil rights movement Congress", "iq32OUls5pg-00065-00015137-00015336": "passed the Voting Rights Act of 1965", "iq32OUls5pg-00066-00015337-00015613": "which provided for federal enforcement", "iq32OUls5pg-00067-00015615-00015808": "of blacks constitutional rights that", "iq32OUls5pg-00068-00015809-00016078": "year the second District second term", "iq32OUls5pg-00069-00016079-00016306": "Democratic congressman Albert Watson", "iq32OUls5pg-00070-00016307-00016538": "resigned then ran as a Republican in the", "iq32OUls5pg-00071-00016539-00016708": "ensuing special election and won", "iq32OUls5pg-00072-00016709-00016871": "becoming the first Republican to", "iq32OUls5pg-00073-00016872-00017063": "represent South Carolina in the house", "iq32OUls5pg-00074-00017064-00017378": "since reconstruction Watson gave up the", "iq32OUls5pg-00075-00017379-00017696": "seat to run for governor in 1970 his", "iq32OUls5pg-00076-00017697-00017921": "successor state senator Floyd Spence", "iq32OUls5pg-00077-00017922-00018214": "held the seat for more than 30 years he", "iq32OUls5pg-00078-00018215-00018361": "was chairman of the House Armed Services", "iq32OUls5pg-00079-00018362-00018722": "Committee from 1995 to 2001 and died a", "iq32OUls5pg-00080-00018723-00018953": "few months after being elected to a 16th", "iq32OUls5pg-00081-00018954-00019211": "term he was succeeded in a special", "iq32OUls5pg-00082-00019212-00019381": "election by one of his former aides", "iq32OUls5pg-00083-00019382-00019718": "State Senator Joe Wilson Wilson has", "iq32OUls5pg-00084-00019719-00019955": "since been reelected seven times in the", "iq32OUls5pg-00085-00019956-00020165": "most recent election held on November", "iq32OUls5pg-00086-00020166-00020300": "4th 2014", "iq32OUls5pg-00087-00020301-00020492": "Wilson earned almost sixty two point", "iq32OUls5pg-00088-00020493-00020693": "five percent of the vote against former", "iq32OUls5pg-00089-00020694-00020890": "Democrat phil black and Labour Party", "iq32OUls5pg-00090-00020891-00021161": "candidate Harold getting's the district", "iq32OUls5pg-00091-00021162-00021819": "has more than 69 percent white", "iq32OUls5pg-00092-00021820-00022404": "topic list of Representatives", "iq32OUls5pg-00093-00022405-00022773": "you", "iq32OUls5pg-00094-00022774-00023414": "topic historical district boundaries", "iq32OUls5pg-00095-00023415-00023780": "you", "iq32OUls5pg-00096-00023781-00024289": "topic see also", "iq32OUls5pg-00097-00024290-00024605": "South Carolina's congressional districts", "iq32OUls5pg-00098-00024606-00024864": "list of United States congressional", "iq32OUls5pg-00099-00024865-00025112": "districts"}}, {"audio_id": "iq3R6VqplMc", "text": {"iq3R6VqplMc-00000-00000047-00000101": "[Music]", "iq3R6VqplMc-00001-00000102-00000738": "foreign", "iq3R6VqplMc-00002-00000739-00003950": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "iq8PQRAaR7U", "text": {"iq8PQRAaR7U-00000-00014463-00014622": "uh good evening", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00001-00014623-00014894": "my name is doug hanto and i am", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00002-00014895-00015079": "chair of the surgical ethics working", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00003-00015080-00015247": "group at the center for bioethics at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00004-00015247-00015511": "harvard medical school and on behalf of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00005-00015512-00015703": "the surgical ethics working group at the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00006-00015704-00015927": "center i would like to welcome everyone", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00007-00015928-00016119": "to our first harvard surgical ethics", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00008-00016119-00016391": "conference ethical challenges in global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00009-00016392-00016511": "surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00010-00016512-00016727": "over 900 individuals registered for the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00011-00016728-00016886": "conference from around the world and we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00012-00016887-00017047": "would like to thank you for getting up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00013-00017048-00017335": "early staying up late and taking time", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00014-00017336-00017558": "off from work or leisure to join us this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00015-00017559-00017799": "evening i believe we have an exciting", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00016-00017800-00018094": "hour and a half ahead of us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00017-00018095-00018271": "first let me go over a couple of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00018-00018272-00018735": "housekeeping items", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00019-00018736-00018855": "we will", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00020-00018856-00019119": "have a q a feature to which you can", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00021-00019120-00019383": "submit questions at any time", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00022-00019384-00019527": "during the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00023-00019528-00019655": "lectures", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00024-00019656-00019871": "these are found in the meeting controls", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00025-00019872-00020239": "at the bottom of your screen", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00026-00020240-00020478": "we will not be answering questions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00027-00020479-00020719": "during the talks but we will be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00028-00020720-00021014": "gathering the questions and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00029-00021015-00021103": "then", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00030-00021104-00021286": "dr mira will be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00031-00021287-00021463": "asking the panelists", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00032-00021464-00021647": "questions during the discussion period", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00033-00021648-00022119": "based on your questions in the q a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00034-00022120-00022327": "you can also continue this conversation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00035-00022328-00022486": "on twitter using", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00036-00022487-00022703": "hms bioethics", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00037-00022704-00022919": "if you have any technical issues please", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00038-00022920-00023127": "use the chat feature to send a message", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00039-00023128-00023375": "to all the panelists and a staff member", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00040-00023376-00023503": "will help", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00041-00023504-00023727": "if you are interested in upcoming events", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00042-00023728-00023942": "news or education programs please", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00043-00023943-00024142": "subscribe to the center for bioethics", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00044-00024143-00024703": "emails at bioethics.hms.harvard.edu", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00045-00024704-00024855": "subscribe", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00046-00024856-00025030": "in addition", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00047-00025031-00025230": "these sessions are being recorded and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00048-00025231-00025535": "they will be available on the hms center", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00049-00025536-00025750": "for bioethics youtube", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00050-00025751-00025855": "site", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00051-00025856-00025990": "after", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00052-00025991-00026270": "the conferences are over", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00053-00026272-00026518": "so without any further ado let me", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00054-00026519-00026702": "introduce", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00055-00026704-00027007": "our first moderator dr john mara is the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00056-00027008-00027246": "plastic surgeon in chief at boston", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00057-00027247-00027487": "children's hospital and an expert in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00058-00027488-00027779": "cases of cleft lip and palate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00059-00027780-00028118": "craniosynostosis and fat encephalocele", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00060-00028119-00028318": "and complex sca", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00061-00028319-00028455": "facial cleft", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00062-00028456-00028662": "dr mir is professor of global surgery in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00063-00028663-00028799": "the department of global health and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00064-00028800-00028967": "social medicine at harvard medical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00065-00028968-00029183": "school boston children's hospital", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00066-00029183-00029390": "professor of surgery in the field of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00067-00029391-00029655": "pediatric plastic surgery and director", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00068-00029656-00029831": "of the program in global surgery and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00069-00029832-00030102": "social change at harvard medical school", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00070-00030103-00030287": "he is a leader in global surgery and was", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00071-00030288-00030479": "one of three co-chairs of the lance", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00072-00030480-00030702": "commission on global surgery that held", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00073-00030703-00030999": "its first meeting in 2014 and that led", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00074-00031000-00031167": "to the publication of the commission's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00075-00031168-00031567": "report global surgery 2030 evidence and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00076-00031568-00031870": "solutions for achieving health welfare", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00077-00031872-00032127": "and economic economic development thank", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00078-00032127-00032287": "you dr mira for joining us and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00079-00032288-00032527": "moderating this session dr mira will", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00080-00032527-00032639": "introduce", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00081-00032639-00032943": "the speakers for tonight's session", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00082-00032944-00033167": "john thank you dr hanto thank you very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00083-00033168-00033271": "much", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00084-00033272-00033462": "we have a wonderful 90 minutes coming up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00085-00033463-00033607": "and i'm looking forward to all three of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00086-00033608-00033871": "our speakers and i will first introduce", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00087-00033872-00034111": "dr bethany gauthier", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00088-00034112-00034374": "dr hett gauthier is a biostatistician", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00089-00034375-00034574": "specializing in health systems and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00090-00034575-00034759": "implementation science research in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00091-00034760-00034943": "sub-saharan africa", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00092-00034944-00035127": "she is an associate professor of global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00093-00035128-00035295": "health and social medicine at harvard", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00094-00035296-00035567": "medical school and of biostatistics at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00095-00035568-00035799": "the harvard chan school of public health", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00096-00035800-00036030": "and she is the director of research in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00097-00036031-00036207": "the program of global surgery and social", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00098-00036208-00036302": "change", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00099-00036303-00036483": "dr hett", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00100-00036484-00036702": "gauthier thank you so much and let me", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00101-00036703-00037111": "just get cued up here", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00102-00037112-00037199": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00103-00037200-00037471": "can you see slides", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00104-00037472-00037607": "great", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00105-00037608-00037951": "um so i really appreciate dr hunto and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00106-00037952-00038295": "to your team the invitation um this is a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00107-00038296-00038551": "unique lens to look at global surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00108-00038552-00038759": "and so i'm excited to explore this with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00109-00038760-00039030": "you and with my co-panelists and dr mira", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00110-00039031-00039230": "always a pleasure to be in events with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00111-00039231-00039335": "you and thank you for the kind", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00112-00039336-00039455": "introduction", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00113-00039456-00039751": "um i'm going to set the stage for the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00114-00039752-00039951": "conversation tonight really thinking", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00115-00039952-00040039": "about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00116-00040040-00040383": "why we're in this space um and and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00117-00040384-00040599": "should we be here and how do we operate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00118-00040600-00040862": "in in this context", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00119-00040863-00041271": "so just as a bit of a background um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00120-00041272-00041558": "the lancet commission in in global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00121-00041559-00041830": "surgery that dr hunter referred to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00122-00041831-00042079": "um and dr mir was a co-chair of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00123-00042080-00042335": "um was really some seminal work and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00124-00042336-00042599": "outlining the needs the global needs for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00125-00042600-00042718": "surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00126-00042719-00042983": "and it was um really something that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00127-00042984-00043151": "actually brought me to the field i'm not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00128-00043152-00043302": "a surgeon i'm a health systems", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00129-00043303-00043599": "researcher but this commission laid a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00130-00043600-00043839": "compelling case for why", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00131-00043840-00044111": "um we need to be paying more attention", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00132-00044112-00044335": "to the global surgical need um more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00133-00044336-00044583": "broadly so just a few highlights of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00134-00044584-00044711": "commission", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00135-00044712-00044846": "probably the biggest highlight five", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00136-00044847-00045023": "billion people around the world lack", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00137-00045024-00045279": "access and of course that's not evenly", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00138-00045280-00045518": "distributed there are historically", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00139-00045519-00045751": "marginalized populations that are the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00140-00045752-00045887": "most", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00141-00045888-00046302": "in need of global surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00142-00046303-00046502": "there needs to be a 143 million", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00143-00046503-00046735": "additional procedures to fill the unmet", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00144-00046736-00047015": "need for surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00145-00047016-00047327": "81 million people are at financial risk", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00146-00047328-00047495": "they would experience catastrophic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00147-00047496-00047711": "health expenditures for surgical care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00148-00047712-00047839": "every year so it's not just about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00149-00047840-00048046": "providing surgery it's about providing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00150-00048047-00048207": "affordable and accessible surgery to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00151-00048208-00048399": "these populations", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00152-00048400-00048558": "we need to invest", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00153-00048559-00048879": "350 billion into surgical and anesthesia", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00154-00048880-00049071": "systems to be able to address these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00155-00049072-00049239": "deficits", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00156-00049240-00049455": "and then finally the just really making", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00157-00049456-00049623": "the case that surgery obstetrics and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00158-00049624-00049951": "anesthesia are just integral parts of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00159-00049952-00050143": "the health care system and so we really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00160-00050144-00050399": "can't talk about primary health care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00161-00050400-00050567": "comprehensive health care universal", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00162-00050568-00050790": "healthcare without really addressing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00163-00050791-00051007": "these deficits that were outlined in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00164-00051008-00051174": "commission", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00165-00051175-00051407": "so with that in mind", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00166-00051408-00051630": "of course these are not un are not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00167-00051632-00051902": "evenly distributed these needs and so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00168-00051903-00052135": "this is showing you a graph of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00169-00052136-00052287": "global distributions of surgeons", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00170-00052288-00052542": "anesthesiologists and obstetricians 100", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00171-00052544-00052775": "000 and the target for this is to have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00172-00052776-00052999": "at least 20 per 100 000 to really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00173-00053000-00053238": "address the deficits that that i just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00174-00053239-00053487": "outlined and what you can see here is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00175-00053488-00053647": "there are many countries in the world", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00176-00053648-00053838": "that are exceeding this target of twenty", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00177-00053839-00054150": "per hundred thousand so the top um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00178-00054151-00054447": "density in this this map is eighty-five", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00179-00054448-00054687": "per hundred thousand in sweden and then", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00180-00054688-00054854": "there are many countries that are far", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00181-00054855-00055230": "far below um this target of 20. so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00182-00055232-00055391": "rwanda where much of my work is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00183-00055391-00055711": "concentrated has 0.68 per hundred", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00184-00055712-00056054": "thousand and sierra leone has 0.15 and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00185-00056055-00056230": "so it's not just about addressing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00186-00056232-00056399": "surgical needs everywhere but it's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00187-00056400-00056607": "really about prioritizing populations", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00188-00056608-00056782": "that have been historically marginalized", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00189-00056783-00057119": "and finding ways to both both address", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00190-00057120-00057311": "the short-term needs but also the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00191-00057312-00057430": "long-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00192-00057432-00057591": "needs of these systems to be able to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00193-00057591-00057799": "provide the surgical services", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00194-00057800-00058047": "so clearly there is a need for more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00195-00058048-00058230": "global surgery and so then the question", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00196-00058232-00058503": "is do we have a moral obligation to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00197-00058504-00058735": "address this need", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00198-00058736-00058950": "so are we morally obliged to respond and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00199-00058951-00059159": "i oftentimes think about my moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00200-00059160-00059430": "obligation from just a human rights", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00201-00059432-00059711": "perspective so health is a human right", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00202-00059712-00059926": "and i provide here a quote from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00203-00059927-00060263": "paul farmer who was my department chair", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00204-00060264-00060511": "and really instrumental and fine um in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00205-00060512-00060663": "the founding of the program in global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00206-00060664-00060863": "surgery and social change that john", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00207-00060864-00061119": "directs and and um dr junior walla and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00208-00061120-00061342": "dr joseph and i are members of and for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00209-00061344-00061623": "this um just this quote from paul really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00210-00061624-00061799": "brings us home for being an area of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00211-00061800-00061991": "moral clarity you're in front of someone", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00212-00061991-00062150": "who's suffering and you have the tools", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00213-00062151-00062303": "at your disposal to leave you that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00214-00062304-00062566": "suffering suffering or eradicate it and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00215-00062567-00062830": "you act so we really are from a human", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00216-00062832-00063015": "rights perspective have a moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00217-00063016-00063303": "obligation to use our skill sets to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00218-00063304-00063582": "address the global surgery deficit", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00219-00063583-00063854": "that's highlighted in the commission", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00220-00063855-00064079": "a second platform for moral obligation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00221-00064079-00064279": "is thinking about it from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00222-00064279-00064542": "our complicity and benefits from systems", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00223-00064544-00064750": "in which we are complicit so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00224-00064751-00064903": "um you know the foundation of we are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00225-00064904-00065054": "incomplicit in and benefactors of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00226-00065055-00065238": "systems that contribute to the global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00227-00065239-00065447": "surgery inequities and therefore we are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00228-00065448-00065711": "morally obliged to try and reduce those", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00229-00065712-00065903": "deficits so i wanted to give you a few", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00230-00065904-00066094": "examples of that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00231-00066095-00066511": "this is a paper that was highlighting", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00232-00066512-00066926": "the the colonial error and how", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00233-00066927-00067006": "we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00234-00067007-00067191": "globally have benefited from the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00235-00067192-00067455": "colonization of africa and also how we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00236-00067456-00067775": "in that colonization really undermined", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00237-00067776-00067935": "health systems that were already in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00238-00067936-00068119": "place and in the way that people", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00239-00068120-00068343": "traditionally access care and didn't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00240-00068344-00068535": "invest in the infrastructure as we were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00241-00068536-00068735": "extracting resources from that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00242-00068736-00068838": "infrastructure", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00243-00068839-00069087": "so that is a historical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00244-00069088-00069431": "complicity from which we benefited from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00245-00069432-00069671": "but there's even modern day examples of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00246-00069672-00069919": "this and so here's an example", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00247-00069920-00070023": "about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00248-00070024-00070367": "how we in the u.s benefit from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00249-00070368-00070550": "what how this headline", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00250-00070551-00070735": "poses at stealing doctors from other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00251-00070736-00070943": "countries and so when we think about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00252-00070944-00071215": "this sao density and the fact that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00253-00071216-00071471": "rwanda and sierra leone so are so far", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00254-00071472-00071662": "from achieving", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00255-00071663-00071862": "their density targets we have to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00256-00071863-00072062": "recognize that we benefit in our health", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00257-00072063-00072343": "care system from extracting the the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00258-00072344-00072519": "human resources from many of these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00259-00072520-00072750": "countries", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00260-00072751-00072903": "so if we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00261-00072904-00073071": "feel compelled that we have a moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00262-00073072-00073406": "obligation to address this surgical need", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00263-00073407-00073511": "my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00264-00073512-00073806": "immediately i immediately start thinking", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00265-00073807-00074071": "is moral obligation enough", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00266-00074072-00074182": "to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00267-00074183-00074359": "bring me to this space and to keep me in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00268-00074360-00074487": "this space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00269-00074488-00074743": "and some of the extreme situations we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00270-00074744-00074887": "find ourselves in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00271-00074888-00075103": "when we are only compelled by moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00272-00075104-00075223": "obligation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00273-00075224-00075471": "so here's an example of a young american", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00274-00075472-00075655": "and it's a very extreme example but a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00275-00075656-00075838": "young american who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00276-00075839-00076135": "um her in her own words it was very very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00277-00076136-00076335": "profound feeling an experience it's kind", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00278-00076336-00076503": "of hard to even describe in words it was", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00279-00076504-00076735": "like something that i was supposed to do", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00280-00076736-00076911": "so this is a young american who in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00281-00076912-00077279": "uganda started a medical mission to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00282-00077280-00077526": "treat young ugandan children and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00283-00077527-00077711": "actually under a series of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00284-00077712-00077991": "investigations found that her lack of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00285-00077992-00078206": "medical knowledge and medical care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00286-00078207-00078375": "actually was to the detriment of these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00287-00078376-00078575": "children led to many deaths and she's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00288-00078576-00078823": "currently under many lawsuits because of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00289-00078824-00078991": "that but she felt compelled to do the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00290-00078992-00079335": "work and that i would argue in that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00291-00079336-00079647": "moral drive probably had blind spots to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00292-00079648-00079919": "her own weaknesses of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00293-00079920-00080150": "how she might actually be causing more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00294-00080151-00080415": "harm than actually trying to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00295-00080416-00080582": "benefit the system she was trying to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00296-00080583-00080791": "benefit so this is a really extreme", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00297-00080792-00081006": "example i'm going to just briefly put up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00298-00081007-00081231": "one that's that's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00299-00081232-00081462": "really more something that we would see", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00300-00081463-00081711": "um often and and dr ginger wild is going", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00301-00081712-00081950": "to talk to you more about you know the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00302-00081951-00082103": "discussions around the ethics of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00303-00082104-00082359": "surgical missions and i purposely put up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00304-00082360-00082550": "mercy ships here as the screenshot", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00305-00082551-00082806": "example of short-term surgical missions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00306-00082807-00083015": "trying to address some of these deficits", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00307-00083016-00083215": "because i know one person personally who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00308-00083216-00083367": "works for mercy ships who i know is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00309-00083368-00083606": "constantly interrogating how he", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00310-00083607-00083782": "is in the space and the contributions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00311-00083783-00083935": "the mercy ship so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00312-00083936-00084223": "um it's not that i think this this group", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00313-00084224-00084343": "is bad i actually think it's a group", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00314-00084344-00084511": "that's under evolution and it's a really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00315-00084512-00084671": "exciting evolution to do but it is a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00316-00084672-00084887": "place of discussion and dr jin jawal", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00317-00084888-00085062": "will take us through that discussion", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00318-00085063-00085294": "but you know are you in mercy ships", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00319-00085295-00085471": "because of the moral obligation what are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00320-00085472-00085735": "your motivations for being there", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00321-00085736-00085959": "clearly it has very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00322-00085960-00086150": "personal benefits to individuals so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00323-00086151-00086318": "here's an article talking about one of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00324-00086319-00086487": "the patients who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00325-00086488-00086687": "recovered and received", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00326-00086688-00086879": "excellent outcomes because of the care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00327-00086880-00087087": "through mercy ships", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00328-00087088-00087350": "but i'll just put these here just the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00329-00087351-00087559": "revisiting of these surgical trips and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00330-00087560-00087638": "again", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00331-00087639-00087855": "the next speaker will speak more about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00332-00087856-00088062": "um you know these surgical missions and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00333-00088063-00088223": "their contributions and the ethics of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00334-00088224-00088447": "them", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00335-00088448-00088518": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00336-00088519-00088791": "i wanted to highlight that um dr hunter", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00337-00088792-00089023": "came to me with the proposal of you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00338-00089024-00089215": "lay out the the need for global surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00339-00089216-00089471": "and our moral obligations and again i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00340-00089472-00089591": "immediately think well is moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00341-00089592-00089743": "obligation enough to bring us to the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00342-00089744-00089847": "space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00343-00089848-00090038": "and i wanted to highlight some of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00344-00090039-00090367": "strategies that i employ or that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00345-00090368-00090559": "our teams try to employ to really think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00346-00090560-00090703": "about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00347-00090704-00091023": "how do we operate in the space in a way", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00348-00091024-00091126": "that's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00349-00091127-00091255": "contributing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00350-00091256-00091438": "and truly aligned to our moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00351-00091439-00091711": "obligation but also not um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00352-00091712-00091991": "vulnerable to our blind spots and how we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00353-00091992-00092199": "successfully operate in that this space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00354-00092200-00092399": "that pun is intended for for the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00355-00092400-00092567": "surgical crowd but i want to give you a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00356-00092568-00092815": "few solutions or a few options of how we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00357-00092816-00092974": "think about our work", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00358-00092975-00093159": "so the first is even though it's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00359-00093160-00093367": "oftentimes uncomfortable to really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00360-00093368-00093599": "interrogate the space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00361-00093600-00093838": "and this is just a slide from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00362-00093839-00094055": "two of our surgical fellows dr aliande", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00363-00094056-00094374": "and dr miranda who talk about both the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00364-00094375-00094687": "history of colonialism in in health", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00365-00094688-00095006": "systems and and um just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00366-00095007-00095259": "more broadly and then thinking about how", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00367-00095260-00095438": "neo-colonialism presents itself in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00368-00095439-00095647": "global surgery and they are challenging", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00369-00095648-00095815": "conversations to have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00370-00095816-00096055": "but having these conversations helps us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00371-00096056-00096431": "better see our blind spots and know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00372-00096432-00096887": "how we might try to counter those", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00373-00096888-00097071": "this is another article i want to point", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00374-00097072-00097326": "you to that talks a lot about the power", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00375-00097327-00097479": "relations between the different key", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00376-00097480-00097694": "players in global surgery and global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00377-00097695-00097887": "health and thinking about how those", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00378-00097888-00098055": "power relations", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00379-00098056-00098262": "manifest in the space and again", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00380-00098263-00098438": "understanding those power relations", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00381-00098439-00098582": "really help us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00382-00098583-00098791": "identify our blind spots and encounter", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00383-00098792-00098991": "them", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00384-00098992-00099215": "another second thing we try to do is not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00385-00099216-00099350": "just interrogate the space but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00386-00099351-00099550": "interrogate ourselves in this space so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00387-00099551-00099711": "why am i here", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00388-00099712-00099918": "um and i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00389-00099919-00100094": "want to point you to um this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00390-00100095-00100335": "presentation by dr erihan bua where he", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00391-00100336-00100623": "talks a lot about our identities and um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00392-00100624-00100815": "if we're just going to a community", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00393-00100816-00101103": "because we want to help solely for moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00394-00101104-00101367": "obligation that's not enough to really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00395-00101368-00101615": "do good work that we have to have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00396-00101616-00101767": "other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00397-00101768-00101967": "motivations you know how does this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00398-00101968-00102279": "benefit me how does this help", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00399-00102280-00102502": "my goals what's the alignment between my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00400-00102503-00102678": "professional goals and the communities", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00401-00102679-00102878": "that i serve how do i make sure there's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00402-00102879-00103078": "better alignment good communication", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00403-00103079-00103247": "these are all things that we need to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00404-00103248-00103430": "think about not just our moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00405-00103431-00103710": "obligation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00406-00103711-00103878": "um another", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00407-00103879-00104047": "part of interrogating ourselves in this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00408-00104048-00104199": "space is thinking about why we do the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00409-00104200-00104447": "things that we do and so these are two", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00410-00104448-00104647": "papers that i worked on as um in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00411-00104648-00104878": "last few years one that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00412-00104879-00105039": "highlights how", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00413-00105040-00105295": "our academic affiliation so specifically", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00414-00105296-00105510": "me as harvard faculty", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00415-00105511-00105702": "and the promotion systems within", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00416-00105703-00106047": "academic affiliations really motivate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00417-00106048-00106343": "what i claim to be bad practice so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00418-00106344-00106495": "um you know in a few years i'll go up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00419-00106496-00106647": "for promotion it'll count the number of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00420-00106648-00106823": "first author publications that i have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00421-00106824-00107023": "and that promotional system", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00422-00107024-00107223": "manifests in the fact that folks who are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00423-00107224-00107439": "affiliated with u.s", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00424-00107440-00107695": "high-profile institutions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00425-00107696-00107934": "their papers are less likely to include", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00426-00107935-00108063": "colleagues from the countries that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00427-00108064-00108310": "research is about they're less likely to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00428-00108311-00108478": "include those colleagues and prominent", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00429-00108479-00108671": "authorship positions and so there's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00430-00108672-00108927": "evidence of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00431-00108928-00109031": "bad", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00432-00109032-00109302": "collaborative practice that comes", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00433-00109303-00109502": "from those institutions and so one of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00434-00109503-00109751": "the solutions we put forth is if we know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00435-00109752-00109983": "that that drives", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00436-00109983-00110183": "less ethical collaboration or less", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00437-00110183-00110399": "equitable collaboration then we really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00438-00110400-00110551": "need to be addressing those promotion", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00439-00110552-00110758": "policies and trying to change those", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00440-00110759-00110983": "pressures so that we can be more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00441-00110983-00111358": "equitable and ethical in that approach", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00442-00111359-00111527": "the third thing i want to put forward is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00443-00111528-00111799": "just adopting very pragmatic strategies", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00444-00111800-00112071": "to improve the practice of how we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00445-00112072-00112310": "occupy the global surgery space so this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00446-00112311-00112486": "is just an example and it was one of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00447-00112488-00112751": "recommended readings for tonight of some", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00448-00112752-00112951": "of the very practical things that our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00449-00112952-00113247": "team does to try and make sure that yes", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00450-00113248-00113423": "we know we have blind spots yes we know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00451-00113424-00113702": "we're under pressures but how do we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00452-00113703-00114023": "try to specifically counteract that so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00453-00114024-00114158": "we do a lot of trainings that are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00454-00114159-00114302": "focused on global surgery and global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00455-00114303-00114471": "surgery research", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00456-00114472-00114583": "we do", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00457-00114583-00114671": "host", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00458-00114672-00114951": "pgsc fellows at our project sites but we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00459-00114952-00115102": "make sure that there's a joint learning", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00460-00115103-00115334": "plan that benefits both our colleagues", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00461-00115335-00115486": "in rwanda for me", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00462-00115488-00115727": "and our pgssc fellows and then we're", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00463-00115728-00115910": "really thoughtful about mapping out our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00464-00115911-00116175": "research space and making sure that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00465-00116176-00116366": "there's opportunity for everyone on our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00466-00116367-00116566": "team to grow professionally in the work", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00467-00116567-00116751": "and that again we don't have blind spots", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00468-00116752-00116934": "of people that we might exclude or not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00469-00116935-00117127": "think about for opportunities just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00470-00117128-00117471": "because of the historical power dynamics", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00471-00117472-00117678": "and then finally and i think you'll hear", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00472-00117679-00117839": "this a lot", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00473-00117840-00118039": "throughout the evening is just really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00474-00118040-00118247": "centering our work", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00475-00118248-00118566": "for and through our partners and so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00476-00118567-00118727": "you know i love the work that i do in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00477-00118728-00118927": "the global surgery space but it is at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00478-00118928-00119127": "service to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00479-00119128-00119334": "other colleagues and it's at the direct", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00480-00119335-00119519": "request of other colleagues and trying", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00481-00119520-00119663": "to make sure that i'm addressing their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00482-00119664-00119886": "requests and not just motivated", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00483-00119888-00120110": "by what i think is right by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00484-00120111-00120310": "what i feel compelled to do by my moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00485-00120311-00120478": "obligation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00486-00120479-00120695": "so just in quick summary um you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00487-00120696-00121014": "just a very brief tour about the needs", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00488-00121015-00121263": "in global surgery i do think we have a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00489-00121264-00121478": "moral obligation to be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00490-00121479-00121695": "um addressing these needs in global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00491-00121696-00121902": "surgery i don't think that moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00492-00121903-00122223": "obligation is enough to bring us to the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00493-00122224-00122423": "space and then hopefully some very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00494-00122424-00122623": "practical strategies that we can adopt", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00495-00122624-00122790": "to make sure that we're", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00496-00122791-00122990": "countering", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00497-00122991-00123175": "some of our blind spots if we just were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00498-00123176-00123295": "to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00499-00123296-00123447": "be in the space because of moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00500-00123448-00123575": "obligation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00501-00123576-00123758": "so i look forward to the discussion and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00502-00123759-00123990": "i'm going to hand it back to dr mira for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00503-00123991-00124278": "the next speaker", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00504-00124279-00124478": "dr hat guthier thank you so much that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00505-00124479-00124678": "was fantastic and i certainly have a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00506-00124679-00124966": "number of questions and i i know our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00507-00124967-00125151": "participants will as well", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00508-00125152-00125351": "um just to remind the participants", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00509-00125352-00125527": "please you know keep your questions keep", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00510-00125528-00125702": "them coming i'm", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00511-00125703-00125934": "watching the q a board here and after", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00512-00125935-00126143": "our third speaker will have a chance to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00513-00126144-00126390": "to answer all those together so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00514-00126391-00126575": "i'd like to introduce our second speaker", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00515-00126576-00126878": "now dr michelle joseph dr joseph is an", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00516-00126879-00127158": "academic trauma and orthopedic surgeon", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00517-00127159-00127351": "she's an instructor in global health and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00518-00127352-00127558": "social medicine at the program in global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00519-00127559-00127719": "surgery and social change at harvard", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00520-00127720-00127863": "medical school", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00521-00127864-00128095": "and an adjunct associate professor at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00522-00128096-00128351": "the university uniformed services walter", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00523-00128352-00128463": "reed", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00524-00128464-00128790": "at the pgssc she holds co-leadership", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00525-00128791-00129007": "as our chief strategy and health equity", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00526-00129008-00129263": "officer and she is one of the inaugural", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00527-00129264-00129454": "recipients of the american college of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00528-00129455-00129654": "surgeons board of regents innovative", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00529-00129655-00130039": "grant grant for dei and anti-racism dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00530-00130040-00130471": "joseph", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00531-00130472-00130702": "thank you very much for the introduction", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00532-00130703-00130886": "good evening uh good morning and good", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00533-00130888-00131087": "afternoon to all of you who are joining", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00534-00131088-00131183": "us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00535-00131184-00131399": "today it's a pleasure to be able to be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00536-00131400-00131639": "part of this uh panel i'm excited to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00537-00131640-00131854": "share with you some of this information", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00538-00131855-00132119": "and especially looking forward to the q", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00539-00132120-00132407": "a that we will have at the end", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00540-00132408-00132654": "so i'll get straight into this complex", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00541-00132655-00132871": "surgical procedures", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00542-00132872-00133031": "as you've heard from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00543-00133032-00133335": "dr hedgutier we have this moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00544-00133336-00133671": "obligation i need to go even beyond that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00545-00133672-00133854": "because the consequences are great when", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00546-00133855-00133943": "we don't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00547-00133944-00134183": "offer and provide the surgical care that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00548-00134184-00134383": "is required", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00549-00134384-00134535": "when we look at the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00550-00134536-00134902": "economics of this the consequences are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00551-00134903-00135039": "great", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00552-00135040-00135327": "publications in global health policy", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00553-00135328-00135487": "and those specifically related to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00554-00135488-00135654": "surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00555-00135655-00135983": "have modeled 12.3 trillion economic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00556-00135984-00136399": "consequence for not providing surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00557-00136400-00136639": "the ethics around this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00558-00136640-00136854": "have been discussed most recently in a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00559-00136855-00137263": "bmj global health publication", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00560-00137264-00137431": "focused mainly on the clinical care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00561-00137432-00137631": "delivery which will be the main focus of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00562-00137632-00137863": "this talk but also on the education", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00563-00137864-00138063": "components the training components as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00564-00138064-00138319": "well associated with the ethical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00565-00138320-00138727": "delivery of global surgical care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00566-00138728-00138990": "partnerships as you heard from uh dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00567-00138991-00139151": "hedges here", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00568-00139152-00139407": "terribly important especially making", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00569-00139408-00139599": "sure that they are equitable", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00570-00139600-00139831": "there is true collaboration and we're", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00571-00139832-00140111": "really honing in on the key uh matters", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00572-00140112-00140295": "when it comes to appropriate care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00573-00140296-00140423": "delivery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00574-00140424-00140711": "so what do we mean by complex", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00575-00140712-00140919": "well today i'll talk to you about a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00576-00140920-00141159": "definition of what complex means in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00577-00141160-00141399": "context of this particular work", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00578-00141400-00141671": "the overarching challenges that we face", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00579-00141672-00141943": "the challenges in the context of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00580-00141944-00142135": "beauchamp charges", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00581-00142136-00142414": "framework but also how it can be adapted", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00582-00142415-00142495": "to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00583-00142496-00142807": "global surgery um at large", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00584-00142808-00142959": "and then finally i'll touch on some of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00585-00142960-00143190": "the solutions which we've already uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00586-00143191-00143471": "heard to some degree", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00587-00143472-00143702": "so what is complex surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00588-00143703-00143983": "well all surgery has a propensity to be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00589-00143984-00144247": "complex and setting really matters but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00590-00144248-00144478": "there are some absolute factors", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00591-00144479-00144695": "the surgical procedure itself", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00592-00144696-00144999": "may require highly specialized surgeons", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00593-00145000-00145263": "with skills that are rare", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00594-00145264-00145526": "surgical equipment or implants that are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00595-00145527-00145759": "expensive and not readily available at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00596-00145760-00145959": "all centres", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00597-00145960-00146183": "anaesthetic requirements", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00598-00146184-00146463": "not only lengthy surgery but complex and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00599-00146464-00146614": "delivery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00600-00146615-00146839": "and then we have the relative factors", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00601-00146840-00147063": "comorbidities and i call them relative", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00602-00147064-00147159": "because", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00603-00147160-00147390": "if you could imagine in a high income", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00604-00147391-00147671": "facility in a tertiary center", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00605-00147672-00147854": "which is used to having", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00606-00147855-00148047": "patients who have significant", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00607-00148048-00148287": "co-morbidities but they are equipped", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00608-00148288-00148559": "both in resource and skill set", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00609-00148560-00148751": "in terms of the workforce they're able", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00610-00148752-00149007": "to deal with these relatively easily", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00611-00149008-00149135": "if you're in a setting where these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00612-00149136-00149311": "things are sparse then suddenly these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00613-00149312-00149590": "comorbidities can pose great problems to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00614-00149591-00149775": "delivery of surgical care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00615-00149776-00150151": "creating a complex surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00616-00150152-00150319": "procedure", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00617-00150320-00150607": "in addition adjunct requirements for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00618-00150608-00150823": "care delivery not just the surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00619-00150824-00150999": "procedure itself but the post-operative", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00620-00151000-00151143": "care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00621-00151144-00151447": "and finally the facility capabilities", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00622-00151448-00151766": "so when we think about complex surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00623-00151767-00151990": "you don't necessarily need to imagine", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00624-00151991-00152351": "the complex reconstruction of a hand or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00625-00152352-00152559": "a facial trauma", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00626-00152560-00152823": "or facial deformity but rather think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00627-00152824-00153031": "about it in the context of these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00628-00153032-00153575": "factors absolute and relative", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00629-00153576-00153863": "the overarching challenges that we face", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00630-00153864-00154087": "from the lens of the global surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00631-00154088-00154254": "practitioner and by that i'm talking", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00632-00154255-00154463": "about those of us who reside in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00633-00154464-00154702": "high-income countries that refer to it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00634-00154703-00154878": "as a global surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00635-00154879-00155087": "our perception of the challenges because", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00636-00155088-00155287": "we do not reside in these spaces day in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00637-00155288-00155390": "day out", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00638-00155391-00155702": "throughout our careers is the tip of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00639-00155703-00155926": "iceberg in terms of the knowledge", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00640-00155927-00156263": "the delivery of this complex care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00641-00156264-00156543": "really requires a good understanding of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00642-00156544-00156775": "the root causes and they can be country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00643-00156776-00157014": "specific or region specific the nuance", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00644-00157015-00157319": "complexities that you cannot simply", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00645-00157320-00157583": "gather the intel on through short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00646-00157584-00157783": "mission trips but you're really reliant", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00647-00157784-00157975": "on those who are living and working in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00648-00157976-00158263": "this space on a day day-in day-out basis", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00649-00158264-00158478": "the geopolitical components", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00650-00158479-00158783": "to the delivery of systems strengthening", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00651-00158784-00159039": "when it comes to ensuring that surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00652-00159040-00159247": "care is widely available and we are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00653-00159248-00159454": "really reaching that unmet need and the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00654-00159455-00159631": "stability in which this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00655-00159632-00159951": "care is attempting to be delivered", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00656-00159952-00160190": "if we were to summarize these uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00657-00160191-00160414": "overarching challenges there are three", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00658-00160415-00160583": "main areas i'd like to focus on the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00659-00160584-00160847": "feasibility of the delivery of this care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00660-00160848-00161039": "what is the power paradigm and that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00661-00161040-00161199": "really ties in with the development of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00662-00161200-00161463": "the partnerships that we really feel are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00663-00161464-00161687": "important for um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00664-00161688-00161863": "ethical delivery of global surgery and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00665-00161864-00162135": "the sustainability of them", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00666-00162136-00162343": "so feasibility we're really thinking", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00667-00162344-00162511": "here about the resources that are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00668-00162512-00162639": "available", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00669-00162640-00162823": "and the time that is spent", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00670-00162824-00163031": "and doctor joshua will go on to talk", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00671-00163032-00163287": "about the actual um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00672-00163288-00163583": "pros and cons of the short-term mission", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00673-00163584-00163783": "ships but time matters", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00674-00163784-00164078": "time matters from a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00675-00164079-00164199": "individual", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00676-00164200-00164375": "point of care delivery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00677-00164376-00164663": "to a systems level understanding the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00678-00164664-00164863": "barriers", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00679-00164864-00165038": "and facilitators", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00680-00165039-00165351": "at both of these levels is key to really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00681-00165352-00165487": "acknowledging the feasibility of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00682-00165488-00165759": "delivering complex surgery based on the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00683-00165760-00165975": "definition i mentioned", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00684-00165976-00166183": "and defining who owns the responsibility", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00685-00166184-00166478": "of the patient's care if you can imagine", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00686-00166479-00166663": "the delivery of care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00687-00166664-00166871": "for a patient", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00688-00166872-00167023": "if you're only there for a short space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00689-00167024-00167126": "of time", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00690-00167127-00167326": "who picks up the potential complications", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00691-00167327-00167566": "that may happen", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00692-00167567-00167790": "and therefore your ethical question is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00693-00167791-00167935": "was it wise to do the surgery in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00694-00167936-00168111": "first place", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00695-00168112-00168407": "and whose responsibility should it be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00696-00168408-00168623": "to pick up those issues should they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00697-00168624-00168807": "arise what are the clinicals appealing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00698-00168808-00168926": "we'll go on to talk about that a bit", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00699-00168927-00169095": "more later", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00700-00169096-00169263": "in terms of the power paradigm this is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00701-00169264-00169511": "really embedded in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00702-00169512-00169783": "history the the colonial history but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00703-00169784-00169999": "also the neocolonial as well and the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00704-00170000-00170175": "disconnect between", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00705-00170176-00170447": "um who makes the decisions at the table", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00706-00170448-00170702": "versus who is actually experiencing the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00707-00170703-00170926": "attempt of delivering this um these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00708-00170927-00171190": "complex surgeries on on a regular basis", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00709-00171191-00171390": "we have to try and redefine this and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00710-00171391-00171607": "when you think about the shift that is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00711-00171608-00171814": "required in this power of this power", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00712-00171815-00172063": "paradigm what we're really talking about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00713-00172064-00172151": "is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00714-00172152-00172495": "utilizing this word equity over equality", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00715-00172496-00172711": "what we want to see is that those who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00716-00172712-00173007": "are making the decisions in this space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00717-00173008-00173183": "and really driving", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00718-00173184-00173447": "what the priorities are need to be those", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00719-00173448-00173854": "who who reside in a country and are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00720-00173855-00174102": "involved in the delivery of surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00721-00174103-00174302": "care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00722-00174303-00174543": "and how do we sustain this how do we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00723-00174544-00174887": "just sustain this attempt at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00724-00174888-00175166": "delivering feasible complex surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00725-00175167-00175438": "it does come down to funding and also", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00726-00175439-00175607": "independence so you're not reliant on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00727-00175608-00175735": "these short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00728-00175736-00175999": "missions and a shift towards systems", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00729-00176000-00176302": "building and education and long-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00730-00176303-00176502": "partnerships whereby you are building up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00731-00176503-00176831": "the expertise in country essentially you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00732-00176832-00177071": "want to aim to do yourself out of a job", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00733-00177072-00177278": "when it comes to the delivery of this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00734-00177279-00177663": "healthcare type", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00735-00177664-00177847": "so when we think about this in terms of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00736-00177848-00178054": "ethical frameworks one that we're all", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00737-00178055-00178319": "familiar with are the four principles", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00738-00178320-00178583": "and how do this fit into global surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00739-00178584-00178766": "and what are the challenges so i'll", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00740-00178767-00179023": "briefly have this up autonomy", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00741-00179024-00179287": "beneficence non-maleficence and justice", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00742-00179288-00179551": "really what we're talking about here is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00743-00179552-00179887": "how much do the patients have um say in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00744-00179888-00180102": "making their decisions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00745-00180103-00180366": "uh we want them to have that level of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00746-00180367-00180583": "autonomy this is for all patients", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00747-00180584-00180759": "and doing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00748-00180760-00181023": "good and promoting that while avoiding", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00749-00181024-00181207": "harm", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00750-00181208-00181438": "maximizing the benefit of patients and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00751-00181439-00181631": "society at large", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00752-00181632-00181766": "now what does this look like in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00753-00181767-00181943": "context of global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00754-00181944-00182271": "surgery well there are some issues", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00755-00182272-00182423": "that we need to talk about there are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00756-00182424-00182790": "certain barriers that uh suddenly come", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00757-00182791-00182902": "to the fore", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00758-00182903-00183183": "cultural uh awareness", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00759-00183184-00183423": "language barriers that one may face are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00760-00183424-00183702": "you truly gaining uh full consent when", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00761-00183703-00183999": "um attempting to deliver", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00762-00184000-00184263": "complex surgery in these low-to-middle", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00763-00184264-00184454": "income settings", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00764-00184455-00184775": "what happens when there is a um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00765-00184776-00185071": "ambiguity do you proceed in life saving", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00766-00185072-00185278": "urgent events or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00767-00185279-00185543": "do you stick to the moral obligation of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00768-00185544-00185847": "ensuring that the patient is making a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00769-00185848-00186087": "fully informed decision these are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00770-00186088-00186295": "challenges that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00771-00186296-00186502": "are not fully answered by the uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00772-00186503-00186695": "framework in its entirety four", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00773-00186696-00186823": "principles", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00774-00186824-00187031": "looking at beneficence when we think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00775-00187032-00187278": "about global surgery practitioners so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00776-00187279-00187614": "surgeons from hivs going to lmics", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00777-00187615-00187878": "there is always a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00778-00187879-00188126": "chance that you may end up working", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00779-00188127-00188454": "outside of your normal scope of practice", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00780-00188455-00188671": "so the ethical question here", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00781-00188672-00188847": "is would you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00782-00188848-00189031": "want to deliver", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00783-00189032-00189326": "standard of care that is potentially", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00784-00189327-00189550": "what you may consider", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00785-00189551-00189743": "lower than the normal standard of care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00786-00189744-00189854": "that you would deliver in your home", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00787-00189855-00189999": "country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00788-00190000-00190190": "these are really hard questions to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00789-00190191-00190359": "answer particularly when it comes to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00790-00190360-00190678": "acute uh emergencies one would argue", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00791-00190679-00190854": "that the scope you should remain in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00792-00190855-00191078": "within your scope of practice", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00793-00191079-00191383": "and maintain a good high quality", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00794-00191384-00191631": "standard of care that would be the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00795-00191632-00191766": "ethical code", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00796-00191767-00191895": "challenging when you're in those", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00797-00191896-00192063": "environments", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00798-00192064-00192423": "and who manages the continuity of care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00799-00192424-00192607": "how do you manage follow-up what are the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00800-00192608-00192983": "long-term potential problems well", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00801-00192984-00193166": "there is always a problem potential for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00802-00193167-00193447": "complications that may occur the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00803-00193448-00193702": "question you should ask yourself is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00804-00193703-00193999": "was it the right choice to make to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00805-00194000-00194190": "deliver that surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00806-00194191-00194326": "knowing that there may be potential", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00807-00194327-00194519": "consequences that you will not be around", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00808-00194520-00194607": "to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00809-00194608-00194766": "take care of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00810-00194767-00195038": "in addition if you're offering", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00811-00195039-00195350": "high level uh surgery that requires um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00812-00195351-00195726": "adjunct support hdus or itu", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00813-00195727-00195847": "services", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00814-00195848-00196023": "are you exhausting", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00815-00196024-00196287": "resources from other um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00816-00196288-00196502": "areas that the facilities may offer in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00817-00196503-00196790": "terms of healthcare", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00818-00196791-00197031": "how do you balance that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00819-00197032-00197263": "real moral ground between delivering to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00820-00197264-00197575": "many versus fewer patients", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00821-00197576-00197831": "without forming these unintended", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00822-00197832-00197983": "consequences", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00823-00197984-00198263": "and finally the justice component", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00824-00198264-00198471": "the ideal scenario is that we offer", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00825-00198472-00198631": "equitable", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00826-00198632-00198735": "access", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00827-00198736-00198943": "to all in need of surgical care the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00828-00198944-00199087": "reality is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00829-00199088-00199326": "patients are selected based on the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00830-00199327-00199431": "safety", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00831-00199432-00199678": "based on the workforce that's available", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00832-00199679-00199919": "based on the resources and the location", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00833-00199920-00200238": "the facility", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00834-00200239-00200495": "capabilities", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00835-00200496-00200743": "so if we go beyond using these four", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00836-00200744-00200990": "principles and think about things more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00837-00200991-00201271": "in a systemic um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00838-00201272-00201478": "fashion i mentioned the workforce", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00839-00201479-00201847": "density issue the infrastructure is key", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00840-00201848-00202143": "systems may be isolated and not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00841-00202144-00202319": "necessarily there may not be the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00842-00202320-00202614": "necessary communication between the um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00843-00202615-00202895": "tears of a surgical care that will be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00844-00202896-00203223": "normally available or rather", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00845-00203224-00203423": "in the hic setting that does not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00846-00203424-00203631": "translate to the lmic setting or the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00847-00203632-00203783": "country or region that you are working", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00848-00203784-00204119": "in it's important to ensure that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00849-00204120-00204263": "there is a full understanding of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00850-00204264-00204535": "systemic challenges before embarking on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00851-00204536-00204814": "surgeries that may actually end up doing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00852-00204815-00205038": "um harm", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00853-00205039-00205238": "and finally as i started the talk", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00854-00205239-00205534": "talking um regarding the economic fact", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00855-00205535-00205727": "there is this ethical and economic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00856-00205728-00205846": "obligation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00857-00205848-00206223": "to mitigate the economic consequences of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00858-00206223-00206542": "um not providing surgery but at the same", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00859-00206544-00206727": "time we need to ensure that there's a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00860-00206728-00206934": "balance between working within the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00861-00206935-00207198": "existing uh structures but how do we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00862-00207200-00207414": "improve them", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00863-00207415-00207590": "so that some innovative", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00864-00207591-00207775": "work that's been", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00865-00207776-00208055": "used to tackle um this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00866-00208056-00208279": "difficult conundrum is to look at the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00867-00208280-00208623": "prevention component to this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00868-00208623-00208966": "how do we mitigate uh surgeries that may", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00869-00208967-00209134": "not need to happen if we were able to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00870-00209135-00209494": "work with civil societies or um public", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00871-00209496-00209679": "health um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00872-00209680-00209919": "departments and organizations ngos who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00873-00209919-00210071": "work in the space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00874-00210071-00210303": "of prevention and when i think of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00875-00210304-00210527": "prevention i really hone in on injury", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00876-00210528-00210734": "prevention because we know that that is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00877-00210735-00210815": "a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00878-00210816-00210951": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00879-00210952-00211110": "area that can be prevented with the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00880-00211111-00211279": "right mechanisms", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00881-00211280-00211391": "in place", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00882-00211392-00211679": "standardization of care should there be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00883-00211680-00211788": "a level of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00884-00211789-00211951": "[Music]", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00885-00211952-00212231": "standards of specific procedures that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00886-00212232-00212294": "are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00887-00212296-00212391": "really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00888-00212392-00212567": "governed by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00889-00212567-00212782": "bodies within countries", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00890-00212783-00212942": "and if that's the case", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00891-00212944-00213094": "how are they followed and how they put", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00892-00213096-00213279": "in how are they put into place it's a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00893-00213280-00213582": "challenging um proposition almost one", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00894-00213583-00213663": "that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00895-00213664-00213879": "falls into the realms of ideals", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00896-00213880-00214134": "but standardization is important to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00897-00214135-00214255": "ensure that there is some degree of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00898-00214256-00214391": "protection", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00899-00214392-00214655": "for patients", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00900-00214656-00215006": "the education and programs that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00901-00215007-00215119": "are ex", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00902-00215119-00215398": "existing in this space are a good", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00903-00215400-00215710": "solid mechanism for really building up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00904-00215711-00215967": "surgical practice in country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00905-00215967-00216198": "long-term educational programs", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00906-00216200-00216446": "really do promote the equity factor", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00907-00216448-00216671": "whereby we are ensuring that the skills", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00908-00216671-00216942": "reside in country and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00909-00216944-00217167": "the surgical procedures are are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00910-00217167-00217398": "performed by those who live and work in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00911-00217400-00217534": "these spaces", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00912-00217535-00217710": "and finally partnerships we've spoken", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00913-00217711-00217894": "about this already dr gucci has", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00914-00217896-00218039": "mentioned this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00915-00218040-00218239": "quite clearly that partnerships are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00916-00218240-00218727": "really the key to developing these um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00917-00218728-00218903": "doing this work well", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00918-00218904-00219206": "and developing ethical frameworks should", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00919-00219207-00219503": "be centered around these partnerships", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00920-00219504-00219919": "having um equity that 80 20 split", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00921-00219919-00220263": "as your as your focus so in summary", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00922-00220264-00220527": "the overarching challenges are vast", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00923-00220528-00220679": "but when you think about them under the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00924-00220680-00220942": "guise of feasibility the power paradigm", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00925-00220944-00221182": "and sustainability there are mechanisms", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00926-00221183-00221351": "and metrics for us to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00927-00221352-00221463": "really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00928-00221464-00221623": "help us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00929-00221623-00221831": "be our sort of compass if you like in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00930-00221832-00222087": "guiding how we approach them", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00931-00222088-00222310": "in terms of the key challenges when we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00932-00222311-00222575": "think about the beauchamp and children's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00933-00222576-00222806": "framework consent when we think about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00934-00222807-00223039": "autonomy the practice and benefits and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00935-00223040-00223215": "the unintended consequences that can", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00936-00223216-00223527": "occur because of the will and desire to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00937-00223528-00223806": "provide provide care which may be out of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00938-00223807-00224119": "our scope for practice normal practice", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00939-00224119-00224327": "and thinking about these things housed", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00940-00224328-00224542": "within the uh systemic challenges that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00941-00224544-00224734": "we face", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00942-00224735-00224951": "and finally the innovation factor", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00943-00224952-00225142": "how do we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00944-00225144-00225351": "really harness these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00945-00225352-00225679": "areas in order to make sure that complex", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00946-00225680-00225958": "surgery in terms of the absolute and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00947-00225959-00226294": "relative factors can be delivered and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00948-00226296-00226391": "really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00949-00226392-00226646": "move towards meeting that unmet need in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00950-00226648-00226791": "an ethical way", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00951-00226792-00227246": "thank you for listening", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00952-00227248-00227567": "thank you so much dr joseph", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00953-00227567-00227751": "boy we we're going to have a lot of uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00954-00227752-00227903": "discussion here in just a few minutes", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00955-00227904-00228039": "we're getting some good questions from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00956-00228040-00228175": "people please", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00957-00228176-00228391": "keep the q a coming i'm keeping track of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00958-00228392-00228591": "them and as soon as we're finished with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00959-00228592-00228782": "our third speaker we'll get to those", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00960-00228783-00228927": "questions so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00961-00228928-00229134": "now for our third speaker dr rashi", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00962-00229135-00229279": "jinjinwala", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00963-00229280-00229503": "she is currently a general surgery uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00964-00229504-00229671": "resident at beth israel deaconess", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00965-00229671-00229934": "medical center and she has been a paul", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00966-00229935-00230142": "farmer global surgery fellow in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00967-00230144-00230294": "program in global surgery and social", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00968-00230296-00230510": "change for the last two years", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00969-00230511-00230687": "now for her third year she will be our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00970-00230688-00230927": "chief fellow in the program", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00971-00230928-00231134": "after her chief fellow year", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00972-00231135-00231303": "she will be completing her residency", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00973-00231304-00231463": "training in general surgery and she", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00974-00231464-00231639": "plans to continue her work in global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00975-00231640-00231855": "surgery as a trauma surgeon and an", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00976-00231856-00232087": "advocate for health equity and i would", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00977-00232088-00232334": "also add she has a master's in ethics so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00978-00232335-00232606": "she's well suited for this discussion dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00979-00232607-00232975": "jinjongwala", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00980-00232976-00233175": "thank you dr mira for uh the kind", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00981-00233176-00233415": "introduction and i'm really uh glad to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00982-00233416-00233575": "be here with everybody", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00983-00233576-00233910": "um big shoes to fill but i'm our third", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00984-00233911-00234239": "speaker for this evening and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00985-00234240-00234398": "i will be talking about whether", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00986-00234400-00234598": "short-term surgical mission trips still", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00987-00234600-00234903": "have a role in 2022 and onward", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00988-00234904-00235039": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00989-00235040-00235191": "we're just going to start off with a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00990-00235192-00235519": "case so a 25 read this kind of briefly", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00991-00235519-00235742": "but a 25 year old american med student", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00992-00235744-00235894": "who's interested in global health and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00993-00235896-00236006": "surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00994-00236007-00236158": "decides to participate in a global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00995-00236159-00236310": "surgery trip at the end of her first", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00996-00236311-00236455": "year of medical school", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00997-00236456-00236646": "so she fundraises all year and in june", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00998-00236648-00236815": "she goes to haiti for a week-long", "iq8PQRAaR7U-00999-00236816-00236982": "surgical mission trip", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01000-00236983-00237287": "while there she first assists on 30-ish", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01001-00237288-00237534": "hernia repairs hydrocele repairs and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01002-00237535-00237703": "elective cholecystectomies as well as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01003-00237704-00237903": "some emergency cases", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01004-00237904-00238079": "she leaves the week with a newfound", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01005-00238080-00238239": "appreciation of the burden of surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01006-00238240-00238455": "disease in low middle-income countries a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01007-00238456-00238671": "renewed love for surgery and she has", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01008-00238671-00238806": "obtained certain technical skills that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01009-00238807-00238942": "she would not acquire during the rest of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01010-00238944-00239063": "her time as a medical student in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01011-00239064-00239231": "united states", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01012-00239232-00239398": "about six months after she returns from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01013-00239400-00239542": "the trip she finds out that one of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01014-00239544-00239727": "patients she operated on died of septic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01015-00239728-00239942": "shock after inability to arrange post-op", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01016-00239944-00240087": "care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01017-00240088-00240191": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01018-00240192-00240334": "the question is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01019-00240335-00240510": "what is the problem and what are the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01020-00240511-00240623": "problems", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01021-00240623-00240846": "so as you've heard from dr headgelthy's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01022-00240848-00241094": "talk and also from dr joseph's talk", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01023-00241096-00241223": "you're going to hear some themes kind of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01024-00241223-00241382": "reiterated but i think that just speaks", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01025-00241383-00241542": "to the importance of them", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01026-00241544-00241719": "uh the global burden of surgical disease", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01027-00241719-00241903": "disproportionately affects people in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01028-00241904-00242030": "low-income countries and low and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01029-00242031-00242151": "middle-income countries with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01030-00242152-00242334": "disproportionate challenges in managing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01031-00242335-00242487": "the surgical disease process in these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01032-00242488-00242655": "settings as well", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01033-00242656-00242823": "so not only is there a lack of timely", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01034-00242823-00243063": "surgical access in many lmacs but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01035-00243064-00243246": "there's also a catastrophic and economic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01036-00243248-00243423": "burden if one is even able to access a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01037-00243423-00243598": "surgeon or an or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01038-00243600-00243694": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01039-00243696-00243830": "many of the reasons for this is because", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01040-00243831-00243975": "of a global shortage of surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01041-00243976-00244279": "obstetric and anesthesia providers", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01042-00244280-00244534": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01043-00244535-00244710": "given the immense scale of this problem", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01044-00244711-00244887": "we have to ask as we often ask in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01045-00244888-00245175": "surgery is perfect the enemy of good", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01046-00245176-00245246": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01047-00245248-00245487": "you know in an ideal situation uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01048-00245488-00245623": "low-income and low and middle-income", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01049-00245623-00245767": "countries would train and retain their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01050-00245767-00245934": "own surgeons uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01051-00245935-00246103": "obstetricians and anesthesiologists to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01052-00246104-00246246": "provide first-class care to their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01053-00246248-00246439": "citizens the same way that we expect in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01054-00246440-00246655": "many high-income country settings", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01055-00246656-00246855": "so uh you'll see a list on the left of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01056-00246856-00247006": "numerous challenges to this ideal", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01057-00247007-00247246": "situation many of which as have been", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01058-00247248-00247494": "kind of alluded to in the previous talks", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01059-00247496-00247694": "are a result of colonialism and results", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01060-00247696-00247903": "in wealth disparities resources and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01061-00247904-00248134": "education disparities", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01062-00248135-00248367": "you'll see this graph to the right of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01063-00248367-00248615": "the screen that describes the number of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01064-00248616-00248887": "doctors nurses and midwives per 100 000", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01065-00248888-00249015": "population", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01066-00249016-00249239": "in each continent with relation to the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01067-00249240-00249455": "number of dollars or disability adjusted", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01068-00249456-00249727": "life years per 100 000 population and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01069-00249728-00249967": "you'll note that over 50 percent of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01070-00249967-00250230": "world's providers are located in europe", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01071-00250231-00250358": "and the americas", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01072-00250359-00250591": "uh whereas three percent of the world's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01073-00250592-00250751": "providers are located in sub-saharan", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01074-00250752-00250919": "africa which has the highest number of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01075-00250919-00251094": "dollars per population", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01076-00251096-00251175": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01077-00251176-00251382": "notably you'll notice that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01078-00251383-00251646": "the situation is such that there are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01079-00251648-00251855": "just not enough providers in places", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01080-00251856-00252046": "where the burden is very high of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01081-00252048-00252406": "surgical disease so given all of this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01082-00252407-00252615": "do short-term surgical missions provide", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01083-00252616-00252823": "a temporary if not imperfect real-world", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01084-00252823-00253015": "solution to the problem of inadequate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01085-00253016-00253239": "access to immediate surgical care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01086-00253240-00253406": "you heard dr joseph talk about some of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01087-00253407-00253558": "the challenges here and you heard dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01088-00253559-00253727": "hedgoth here talk about our moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01089-00253728-00253967": "responsibility but we sometimes uh you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01090-00253967-00254119": "know need to think about it terms in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01091-00254119-00254294": "terms of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01092-00254296-00254479": "in a political philosophy approach as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01093-00254480-00254727": "well so if high income countries are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01094-00254728-00254863": "obligated to provide some sort of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01095-00254864-00255063": "surgical health care to those in lmic's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01096-00255064-00255310": "without sufficient training or resources", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01097-00255311-00255487": "the question is is a short-term surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01098-00255488-00255630": "mission a reasonable way in which to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01099-00255631-00255782": "offset this responsibility with the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01100-00255783-00255951": "middle ground of sorts", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01101-00255952-00256198": "whereby surgeons can do good and offer", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01102-00256200-00256358": "some training provide some concrete", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01103-00256359-00256558": "life-saving intervention etc without", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01104-00256559-00256734": "requiring a complete upheaval of their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01105-00256735-00256894": "own life and practice", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01106-00256896-00257063": "so while i won't delve completely into", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01107-00257064-00257215": "the world of political philosophy for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01108-00257216-00257391": "this talk there are many ways in which", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01109-00257392-00257615": "nations cover their socio economic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01110-00257616-00257815": "investments so on one hand you have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01111-00257816-00257975": "countries that rely heavily on a status", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01112-00257976-00258198": "approach which they prioritize care to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01113-00258200-00258398": "their own citizen over others and only", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01114-00258400-00258598": "focuses focus on emergency port for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01115-00258600-00258751": "others when needed", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01116-00258752-00258919": "however", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01117-00258919-00259071": "countries on the other hand who rely on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01118-00259071-00259310": "a cosmopolitan approach uh focus more on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01119-00259311-00259551": "a global approach to welfare emphasizing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01120-00259552-00259751": "basic welfare all", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01121-00259752-00259975": "well fair for a while excuse me but you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01122-00259976-00260094": "know how much does this type of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01123-00260096-00260287": "investment actually cost", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01124-00260288-00260494": "and we talk about equitable distribution", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01125-00260496-00260710": "of resources what do we actually mean by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01126-00260711-00260815": "that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01127-00260816-00261079": "so the organization management in opera", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01128-00261080-00261319": "operating operating costs of short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01129-00261319-00261494": "surgical emissions requires billions of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01130-00261496-00261646": "dollars per year", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01131-00261648-00261839": "so what is the responsibility of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01132-00261840-00261967": "high-income countries that fund and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01133-00261967-00262127": "support these missions and offsetting or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01134-00262128-00262334": "displacing some of that overhead and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01135-00262335-00262503": "could they be better spent could that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01136-00262504-00262679": "money be better spent in education and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01137-00262680-00262823": "infrastructure in the areas in which", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01138-00262824-00262958": "short-term surgical mission trips", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01139-00262959-00263063": "operate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01140-00263064-00263255": "so this paper uh gives some sample", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01141-00263256-00263471": "statistics from 601 respondent", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01142-00263472-00263679": "physicians indicating an increasing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01143-00263680-00263919": "participation by u.s uh physicians and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01144-00263920-00264134": "short-term medical missions including", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01145-00264135-00264382": "the opportunity cost of lost time when", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01146-00264383-00264510": "they're not practicing in their home", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01147-00264511-00264734": "institution or their home country uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01148-00264735-00264982": "average an average total economic input", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01149-00264983-00265191": "for an individual physician pursuing a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01150-00265192-00265351": "short-term surgical mission for about a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01151-00265352-00265671": "week on average exceeds 11 000", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01152-00265672-00265887": "so composite expenditures for short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01153-00265888-00266006": "medical mission deployment from the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01154-00266007-00266310": "united states are about 3.7 billion", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01155-00266311-00266487": "dollars in annually", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01156-00266488-00266710": "and uh the resource investment equates", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01157-00266711-00266967": "with a nearly 5 800 physician full-time", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01158-00266968-00267343": "equivalents so that is a lot of money", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01159-00267344-00267447": "so given all this money that we're", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01160-00267448-00267695": "spending on short-term surgical missions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01161-00267696-00267855": "what are the benefits and harms of this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01162-00267856-00267943": "model", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01163-00267944-00268143": "uh you know we've talked about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01164-00268144-00268447": "many concepts of benefit and harm and we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01165-00268448-00268710": "have to ask who's benefiting and who's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01166-00268711-00268887": "being harmed potentially", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01167-00268888-00269239": "by uh by these trips so on the top right", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01168-00269240-00269687": "hand uh side of the slide you'll see a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01169-00269688-00269927": "blurb which is actually taken straight", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01170-00269928-00270167": "from a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01171-00270168-00270415": "group that sends high-income country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01172-00270416-00270615": "participants to medical mission trips", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01173-00270616-00270791": "and i won't read the whole thing but i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01174-00270792-00270943": "will just point your direction your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01175-00270944-00271151": "attention to the second paragraph which", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01176-00271152-00271247": "begins", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01177-00271248-00271423": "you can expect medical mission trips to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01178-00271424-00271591": "hone your knowledge skill sets and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01179-00271592-00271806": "problem solving capabilities", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01180-00271807-00271943": "these trips will provide plenty of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01181-00271944-00272119": "hands-on clinical experience and train", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01182-00272120-00272295": "you to deliver maximum care with limited", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01183-00272296-00272527": "resources in the end these trips will", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01184-00272528-00272710": "make you a better practitioner reinforce", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01185-00272711-00272855": "your passion for medicine and show", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01186-00272856-00272991": "current and future employers that your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01187-00272992-00273223": "boundless capacity for care makes hiring", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01188-00273224-00273503": "or promoting you an easy decision", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01189-00273504-00273967": "now that is in my opinion a very biased", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01190-00273968-00274199": "benefit that is focused on entirely on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01191-00274200-00274334": "the providers that are coming", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01192-00274335-00274519": "parachuting in if you will", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01193-00274520-00274687": "to provide", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01194-00274688-00274887": "what they believe is care but also to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01195-00274888-00275103": "really gain experience and knowledge at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01196-00275104-00275271": "the expense of others", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01197-00275272-00275358": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01198-00275359-00275503": "is participation in a short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01199-00275504-00275599": "surgical mission a form of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01200-00275600-00275791": "neocolonialism without any opportunity", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01201-00275792-00275958": "for redemption or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01202-00275959-00276167": "does it all an all or nothing approach", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01203-00276168-00276375": "minimize the benefits that a well-run", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01204-00276376-00276575": "longitudinal and during short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01205-00276576-00276727": "surgical mission structure could offer", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01206-00276728-00276999": "so the other paper that you see here um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01207-00277000-00277239": "is a qualitative study of uh local", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01208-00277240-00277455": "healthcare providers in port-au-prince", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01209-00277456-00277567": "haiti", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01210-00277568-00277863": "and in this study uh four themes emerged", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01211-00277864-00278047": "so general perceptions the perceived", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01212-00278048-00278279": "effect of these mission trips on the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01213-00278280-00278510": "health care system the perceived effect", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01214-00278511-00278655": "on health care workers and future", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01215-00278656-00278958": "recommendations and in general uh the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01216-00278959-00279110": "study found that local healthcare", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01217-00279111-00279255": "workers appreciated the skills and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01218-00279256-00279455": "knowledge that teams in part and they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01219-00279456-00279623": "improved access to surgical services for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01220-00279624-00279895": "the poor however workers uh volunteers", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01221-00279896-00280079": "working independently of local teams", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01222-00280080-00280279": "creates negative perceptions it stresses", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01223-00280280-00280447": "out the local health care providers and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01224-00280448-00280687": "also strains the hospital resources", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01225-00280688-00280958": "so uh not to be a broken record with my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01226-00280959-00281199": "fellow uh panelists but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01227-00281200-00281358": "we really need to be working in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01228-00281359-00281606": "collaboration with the teams that we aim", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01229-00281607-00281830": "to serve so that we can actually", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01230-00281831-00282199": "identify sustainable solutions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01231-00282200-00282439": "uh one other uh systematic review that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01232-00282440-00282687": "was published uh reviewed sixteen", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01233-00282688-00282863": "thousand sixteen hundred studies uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01234-00282864-00283015": "forty one of which met full inclusion", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01235-00283016-00283239": "criteria the studies reported a minimum", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01236-00283240-00283439": "of six months follow-up showing a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01237-00283440-00283606": "follow-up rate of 56", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01238-00283607-00283863": "and really notably a complication rate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01239-00283864-00284047": "of 22.3", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01240-00284048-00284271": "which i just want to reiterate is an", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01241-00284272-00284439": "absurdly high number compared to what", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01242-00284440-00284599": "would be deemed acceptable in many high", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01243-00284600-00284830": "income country settings", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01244-00284831-00285054": "15 out of uh 20 studies reported on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01245-00285055-00285182": "follow-up also reported on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01246-00285183-00285415": "sustainability characteristics but the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01247-00285416-00285551": "12 studies that did not report on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01248-00285552-00285703": "duration and fall upright reported a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01249-00285704-00285927": "complication of rate of 1.2 percent", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01250-00285928-00286127": "which is kind of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01251-00286128-00286279": "not um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01252-00286280-00286479": "not really conceptually", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01253-00286480-00286615": "located so it's hard to kind of know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01254-00286616-00286775": "what that actually means", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01255-00286776-00286927": "so in summary when you think about the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01256-00286928-00287047": "harms of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01257-00287048-00287247": "trip like this you think of lack of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01258-00287248-00287382": "investment in buying in local", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01259-00287383-00287510": "infrastructure", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01260-00287511-00287719": "uh creation and setup and maintenance of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01261-00287720-00287887": "neo-colonial reliance on external", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01262-00287888-00288095": "funding structures and then inadequate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01263-00288096-00288303": "care potentially given by inadequately", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01264-00288304-00288454": "trained or equipped providers to deal", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01265-00288455-00288895": "with the patients that they're seeing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01266-00288896-00289015": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01267-00289016-00289182": "if short-term social commission trips", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01268-00289183-00289406": "are to persist persist what requisite", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01269-00289407-00289582": "standards or guiding principles should", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01270-00289583-00289671": "we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01271-00289672-00289903": "employ as rules for engagement", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01272-00289904-00290158": "so this is a set of seven uh guiding", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01273-00290159-00290439": "principles that was actually first um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01274-00290440-00290558": "first introduced in the world of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01275-00290559-00290854": "pediatrics uh in 2007 but i do think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01276-00290855-00290982": "that there are many of the themes that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01277-00290983-00291182": "we actually focus on in our own work", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01278-00291183-00291399": "these uh today and also would carry", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01279-00291400-00291527": "forward", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01280-00291528-00291719": "so you need to have first and foremost a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01281-00291720-00291895": "common and specific specific sense of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01282-00291896-00292063": "purpose in your mission that is based on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01283-00292064-00292303": "a collaboration that is truly based on a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01284-00292304-00292503": "community and its infrastructure", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01285-00292504-00292710": "and as has been mentioned uh most", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01286-00292711-00292951": "recently by dr joseph and her her speech", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01287-00292952-00293119": "or her talk um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01288-00293120-00293303": "education and cultural competency", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01289-00293304-00293471": "competency training for volunteers as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01290-00293472-00293630": "well as strict rules for the scope of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01291-00293631-00293734": "practice", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01292-00293735-00293927": "and emphasis on good communication", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01293-00293928-00294071": "communication and goal setting is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01294-00294072-00294327": "absolutely crucial we also need to focus", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01295-00294328-00294463": "on teamwork", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01296-00294464-00294575": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01297-00294576-00294758": "building capacity for ongoing and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01298-00294759-00294871": "sustainable", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01299-00294872-00295015": "interventions and then finally", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01300-00295016-00295182": "monitoring and evaluation frameworks for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01301-00295183-00295454": "both short and long term outcomes", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01302-00295455-00295719": "patient safety schedules and plans for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01303-00295720-00295903": "follow-up care as well as referral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01304-00295904-00296039": "networks to existing hospitals or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01305-00296040-00296206": "clinics for post-op emergencies or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01306-00296207-00296367": "issues to create actually a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01307-00296368-00296534": "comprehensive network of sustainable and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01308-00296535-00296823": "long-term care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01309-00296824-00297063": "so if we go back to the first slide of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01310-00297064-00297319": "our 25 year old med student where could", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01311-00297320-00297519": "this have been improved", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01312-00297520-00297710": "so she fundraises all year contributing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01313-00297711-00297991": "to that 3.7 billion dollar investment uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01314-00297992-00298151": "that americans", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01315-00298152-00298423": "pour into american physicians pour into", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01316-00298424-00298575": "this endeavor", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01317-00298576-00298775": "uh would that money could that money", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01318-00298776-00298943": "have been better spent elsewhere it's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01319-00298944-00299054": "possible", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01320-00299055-00299263": "she goes for a week in which time she", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01321-00299264-00299495": "hardly has the opportunity to gain any", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01322-00299496-00299743": "sort of experience or context or develop", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01323-00299744-00300030": "strong or notable partnerships", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01324-00300031-00300239": "she's first assisting on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01325-00300240-00300519": "on all these operations which uh is not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01326-00300520-00300719": "within her scope of practice", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01327-00300720-00300799": "she", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01328-00300800-00300991": "notably does develop a new", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01329-00300992-00301151": "appreciation for the burden of surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01330-00301152-00301263": "disease in low and middle income", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01331-00301264-00301439": "countries and comes away with that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01332-00301440-00301679": "appreciation which drives her career in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01333-00301680-00301887": "the future but she also came away with a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01334-00301888-00302023": "bunch of technical skills that she", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01335-00302024-00302263": "probably shouldn't have even been", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01336-00302264-00302558": "having the opportunity to develop", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01337-00302559-00302710": "most importantly", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01338-00302711-00302815": "uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01339-00302816-00303063": "the patient who died of septic shock due", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01340-00303064-00303254": "to inability to arrange post-op care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01341-00303255-00303423": "that should not should not have happened", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01342-00303424-00303543": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01343-00303544-00303806": "you know if you think about the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01344-00303807-00303991": "answer of whether we should be still", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01345-00303992-00304182": "doing short terms or surgical missions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01346-00304183-00304406": "in 2022", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01347-00304407-00304615": "um it's evident you know that the global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01348-00304616-00304782": "surgical burden of disease is massive", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01349-00304783-00304958": "and it continues to grow", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01350-00304959-00305047": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01351-00305048-00305239": "although sustainable capacity building", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01352-00305240-00305391": "and educational efforts are without a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01353-00305392-00305527": "doubt the gold standard to which we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01354-00305528-00305703": "should all be striving", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01355-00305704-00305863": "i do believe that there is a space for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01356-00305864-00306079": "an equitable short-term surgical mission", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01357-00306080-00306319": "model um for care for provision as a way", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01358-00306320-00306487": "to decrease the gap in surgical health", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01359-00306488-00306687": "care needs in health care delivery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01360-00306688-00306927": "but if we take on our communal", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01361-00306928-00307167": "responsibility our charge is to adapt", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01362-00307168-00307319": "and improve the imperfect offering that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01363-00307320-00307527": "we have with simultaneous focus on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01364-00307528-00307679": "building capacity", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01365-00307680-00307847": "we must focus both on the now and the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01366-00307848-00308079": "future so short-term surgical missions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01367-00308080-00308254": "should be integrated with monitoring and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01368-00308255-00308447": "evaluation frameworks capacity building", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01369-00308448-00308654": "and longitudinal training programs as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01370-00308655-00308782": "well as bilateral partnership", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01371-00308783-00308943": "initiatives", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01372-00308944-00309071": "thank you very much", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01373-00309072-00309295": "and i will turn it on back to dr mira", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01374-00309296-00309454": "for the discussion", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01375-00309455-00309727": "well dr junanwala thank you so much and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01376-00309728-00309903": "thank you to all three of our speakers", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01377-00309904-00310087": "that was fantastic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01378-00310088-00310175": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01379-00310176-00310334": "it's a lot to unpack", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01380-00310335-00310551": "and um i think it's gonna take us about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01381-00310552-00310719": "two and a half more hours so everybody", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01382-00310720-00310863": "get comfortable we're gonna we're gonna", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01383-00310864-00310982": "go through everything no i'm just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01384-00310983-00311079": "kidding", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01385-00311080-00311295": "we uh we have a half hour and i i'd like", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01386-00311296-00311423": "to get to some of the excellent", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01387-00311424-00311591": "questions from all of our participants", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01388-00311592-00311679": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01389-00311680-00311903": "i think i'd like to start back with dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01390-00311904-00312103": "heck gauthier because a couple questions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01391-00312104-00312206": "came in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01392-00312207-00312471": "earlier that are really quite nice and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01393-00312472-00312679": "they're in your wheelhouse so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01394-00312680-00312943": "um do you have suggestions as to how to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01395-00312944-00313215": "address promotion policies to embrace", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01396-00313216-00313399": "equity and collaboration and i know you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01397-00313400-00313551": "do because i know you've spoken", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01398-00313552-00313727": "passionately about that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01399-00313728-00313958": "and and i will tell our participants", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01400-00313959-00314039": "that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01401-00314040-00314271": "um dr heck gothier is really a thought", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01402-00314272-00314430": "leader in this area and i've learned a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01403-00314431-00314606": "great deal from her over the last five", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01404-00314607-00314758": "plus years and so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01405-00314759-00314910": "uh bethany i'll let you talk a little", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01406-00314911-00315406": "bit about that to everyone", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01407-00315407-00315695": "thanks yeah um i mean it's definitely an", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01408-00315696-00315999": "area that we are and we being a lot of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01409-00316000-00316215": "folks who are on this call both my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01410-00316216-00316503": "fellow fellow panelists um but also i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01411-00316504-00316710": "see some names in the participant list", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01412-00316711-00316863": "that i know are are chipping away at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01413-00316864-00316951": "this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01414-00316952-00317206": "you know it's for me um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01415-00317207-00317527": "it a bit touches on um dr g jawala you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01416-00317528-00317679": "had a quote in yours about the medical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01417-00317680-00317863": "mission of like you know this will help", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01418-00317864-00318103": "with your cv building and this will help", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01419-00318104-00318295": "with your future prospects", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01420-00318296-00318399": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01421-00318400-00318575": "i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01422-00318576-00318903": "you know was oftentimes finding myself", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01423-00318904-00319095": "being like well i need that first", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01424-00319096-00319367": "authorship and not thinking about my the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01425-00319368-00319679": "consequence of me pursuing my needs", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01426-00319680-00319815": "over", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01427-00319816-00319919": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01428-00319920-00320143": "you know the the residual consequence of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01429-00320144-00320358": "my other colleagues and their needs both", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01430-00320359-00320487": "you know the person down the hall but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01431-00320488-00320710": "also the person across the ocean", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01432-00320711-00320927": "for my global health work and so you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01433-00320928-00321103": "know your question is one that we've", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01434-00321104-00321358": "given a lot of thought to um the lancet", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01435-00321359-00321606": "piece that that i had in my slide we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01436-00321607-00321967": "actually outlined um that was the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01437-00321968-00322239": "product of a two two-day", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01438-00322240-00322415": "session where we had colleagues from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01439-00322416-00322575": "around the world many universities in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01440-00322576-00322758": "the us but also our collaborators", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01441-00322759-00322895": "thinking about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01442-00322896-00323054": "you know what are our pushes and pulls", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01443-00323055-00323206": "in our professional life that lead to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01444-00323207-00323430": "these consequences and then", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01445-00323431-00323679": "how can we change them um and so there's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01446-00323680-00323854": "some very specific recommendations in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01447-00323855-00324239": "there so one um for example is um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01448-00324240-00324471": "from a like promotion standpoint", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01449-00324472-00324591": "you know they count the number first", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01450-00324592-00324799": "author papers right and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01451-00324800-00325095": "um they will also not penalize me if i'm", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01452-00325096-00325287": "publishing papers without colleagues and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01453-00325288-00325503": "giving them credit so trying to put in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01454-00325504-00325687": "more checks and balances to really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01455-00325688-00325887": "evaluate not just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01456-00325888-00326095": "you know the research but the nature of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01457-00326096-00326303": "how we collaborate and that's not just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01458-00326304-00326463": "for global health collaborations that's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01459-00326464-00326639": "for any collaborations and with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01460-00326640-00326854": "community partnerships there's other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01461-00326855-00327039": "suggestions there about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01462-00327040-00327175": "like thinking about our administrative", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01463-00327176-00327287": "burden so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01464-00327288-00327510": "harvard does not want me out of boston", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01465-00327511-00327671": "for more than six weeks a year but if", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01466-00327672-00327919": "you try to really address", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01467-00327920-00328191": "um and and manifest these partnerships", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01468-00328192-00328399": "that both doctors nawala and dr joseph", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01469-00328400-00328582": "talked about like that's not something", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01470-00328583-00328782": "that can just happen overnight it really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01471-00328783-00329230": "takes time and and trust and so um you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01472-00329231-00329399": "know that administrative barrier can can", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01473-00329400-00329654": "be a limit to that so those we have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01474-00329655-00329782": "specific recommendations now the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01475-00329783-00330039": "question is how do you change", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01476-00330040-00330303": "the policies and and we're doing some", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01477-00330304-00330471": "efforts for the consortium universities", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01478-00330472-00330743": "of global health to try and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01479-00330744-00330943": "have broader position statements and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01480-00330944-00331054": "then really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01481-00331055-00331151": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01482-00331152-00331310": "sort of put the pressure on the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01483-00331311-00331630": "universities to to note that that the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01484-00331631-00331823": "norms of global health collaboration are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01485-00331824-00332063": "changing and they need to align the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01486-00332064-00332287": "promotion policies to that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01487-00332288-00332503": "so happy to share that piece in the chat", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01488-00332504-00332758": "um if if that's useful and you can also", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01489-00332759-00332999": "just find the the title of that paper in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01490-00333000-00333191": "the slides", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01491-00333192-00333351": "thank you so much and just so that our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01492-00333352-00333534": "participants know dr heckkothier has", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01493-00333535-00333758": "been a very strong advocate for changing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01494-00333759-00333919": "those policies even within our own", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01495-00333920-00334103": "university and uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01496-00334104-00334254": "it's not easy it's a little bit like", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01497-00334255-00334478": "changing the direction the titanic but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01498-00334479-00334639": "she's not going to give up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01499-00334640-00334815": "um just one follow-up question while", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01500-00334816-00334943": "we're talking about research because", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01501-00334944-00335103": "there was another excellent question", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01502-00335104-00335334": "that came to us about you know how do", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01503-00335335-00335495": "you handle grants with with your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01504-00335496-00335767": "partners and you know can can a pi from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01505-00335768-00335951": "another country you know can they be a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01506-00335952-00336215": "pi on a us grant and how do you navigate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01507-00336216-00336382": "the fairness around", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01508-00336383-00336799": "funding and who gets what", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01509-00336800-00336975": "i'll start with that and then and would", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01510-00336976-00337158": "invite others to chime in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01511-00337159-00337247": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01512-00337248-00337503": "there are some grants for which i am", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01513-00337504-00337743": "uniquely eligible and not my colleagues", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01514-00337744-00337967": "and vice versa um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01515-00337968-00338182": "so we really try and it goes back to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01516-00338183-00338334": "that comment around the administrative", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01517-00338335-00338606": "barrier so especially pre pandemic and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01518-00338607-00338823": "we're trying to resume them now to just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01519-00338824-00339078": "be proximate have colleagues here maybe", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01520-00339079-00339327": "there and spend a lot of our times just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01521-00339328-00339495": "brainstorming", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01522-00339496-00339623": "what do we want to be working on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01523-00339624-00339758": "together", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01524-00339759-00339999": "and we have a long long list of what we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01525-00340000-00340199": "want to be working on together so that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01526-00340200-00340415": "if a grant mechanism comes along that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01527-00340416-00340654": "facilitates this common goal but for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01528-00340655-00340943": "which i'm uniquely qualified i'm not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01529-00340944-00341063": "applying", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01530-00341064-00341295": "because it's my idea for me i'm applying", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01531-00341296-00341495": "to facilitate our team's work", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01532-00341496-00341591": "and so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01533-00341592-00341815": "you know there's that aspect of it um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01534-00341816-00341982": "the other aspect is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01535-00341983-00342439": "you know how do we broaden our team's um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01536-00342440-00342710": "resources our our skill base our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01537-00342711-00342943": "expertise so that other people can be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01538-00342944-00343151": "applying for grants so why am i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01539-00343152-00343263": "qualified", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01540-00343264-00343478": "for a grant and maybe a colleague isn't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01541-00343479-00343695": "and how do we make sure that in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01542-00343696-00343871": "process of implementing this grant that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01543-00343872-00344078": "we're capacitating that person to be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01544-00344079-00344287": "competitive for the next one and so it's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01545-00344288-00344487": "always thinking about you know maybe you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01546-00344488-00344678": "weren't competitive today but you can be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01547-00344679-00344847": "competitive tomorrow so let's just make", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01548-00344848-00344967": "sure that we're", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01549-00344968-00345303": "strategic in in addressing that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01550-00345304-00345503": "okay thank you so much", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01551-00345504-00345775": "let's let's uh switch to uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01552-00345776-00346063": "uh a workforce clinical question and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01553-00346064-00346303": "actually i throw it to both our uh our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01554-00346304-00346582": "clinicians dr joseph and dr chandranwala", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01555-00346583-00346799": "i have uh an excellent question here", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01556-00346800-00347023": "from teo iganusi", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01557-00347024-00347199": "i listen to the aspect of the discussion", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01558-00347200-00347406": "on brain brain will it be fair to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01559-00347407-00347630": "conclude that all workers are stolen", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01560-00347631-00347799": "when some nations do not provide", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01561-00347800-00348023": "enabling atmospheres for staff to stay", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01562-00348024-00348254": "in their own countries so dr joseph", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01563-00348255-00348430": "maybe you can offer a thought there and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01564-00348431-00348823": "then dr junior walla you can follow up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01565-00348824-00349039": "thank you for the question it's a it's a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01566-00349040-00349534": "great one and it is a reality um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01567-00349535-00349743": "it doesn't happen everywhere but it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01568-00349744-00349999": "happens almost in a systematic way in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01569-00350000-00350271": "some places i and i'm happy to give this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01570-00350272-00350430": "uh example", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01571-00350431-00350710": "uh when i was in the latter years of my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01572-00350711-00350863": "uh training", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01573-00350864-00351206": "i remember being on call and having um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01574-00351207-00351519": "seen at least eight or ten new doctors", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01575-00351520-00351695": "from nigeria", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01576-00351696-00351910": "and i wasn't i was just surprised they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01577-00351911-00352134": "were in the our emergency department", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01578-00352135-00352303": "so i got talking to them and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01579-00352304-00352471": "understanding", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01580-00352472-00352719": "uh how it came about there was a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01581-00352720-00352951": "national recruitment", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01582-00352952-00353223": "of four nigerian doctors", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01583-00353224-00353606": "to come to the uk on a contract for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01584-00353607-00353743": "24 months", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01585-00353744-00353823": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01586-00353824-00354015": "build their emergency", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01587-00354016-00354206": "medicine skills but with a view to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01588-00354207-00354375": "potentially enter into full-time", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01589-00354376-00354558": "training", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01590-00354559-00354799": "so essentially they're taking those who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01591-00354800-00354975": "have the skills", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01592-00354976-00355095": "from places", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01593-00355096-00355271": "in need and that was a systematic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01594-00355272-00355471": "program because of the doctor shortages", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01595-00355472-00355703": "that we have in the uk", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01596-00355704-00355878": "so yes there is a brain drain but the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01597-00355879-00356119": "incentives are so great and high that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01598-00356120-00356327": "it's difficult to say no and i think the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01599-00356328-00356647": "other part to that question was um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01600-00356648-00356839": "is it because there are issues in their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01601-00356840-00357015": "countries residing countries essentially", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01602-00357016-00357247": "not stable so how do you balance that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01603-00357248-00357319": "out", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01604-00357320-00357463": "well i think the answer is you support", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01605-00357464-00357687": "the systems that are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01606-00357688-00357830": "in country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01607-00357831-00358047": "to incentivize", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01608-00358048-00358263": "for doctors to stay but that's very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01609-00358264-00358391": "challenging because what you're really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01610-00358392-00358639": "talking about is financial support", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01611-00358640-00358839": "and if an individual is to travel from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01612-00358840-00359087": "that country to gain the finances that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01613-00359088-00359271": "they would um would support their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01614-00359272-00359534": "countries by working in elsewhere", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01615-00359535-00359623": "then", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01616-00359624-00359854": "are you splitting the difference", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01617-00359855-00360030": "it's a really hard question and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01618-00360031-00360151": "ultimately when you speak to the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01619-00360152-00360287": "individual who hasn't been paid for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01620-00360288-00360399": "three months", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01621-00360400-00360719": "um and can easily move country and earn", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01622-00360720-00360975": "a lot more money and continue their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01623-00360976-00361191": "skills it's very difficult to say to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01624-00361192-00361375": "that person no stay in your country and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01625-00361376-00361591": "not get paid we will build the system in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01626-00361592-00361854": "time because long-term partnerships", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01627-00361855-00362030": "take time to build systems it does not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01628-00362031-00362175": "happen overnight", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01629-00362176-00362367": "so yes there is a brain drain but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01630-00362368-00362527": "there's always there's always a reason", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01631-00362528-00362791": "to leave because of the challenges with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01632-00362792-00362910": "the health care system within the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01633-00362911-00363143": "countries in which they reside", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01634-00363144-00363310": "thank you so doctor ginger while i you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01635-00363311-00363519": "know dr joseph is talking about kind of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01636-00363520-00363758": "active poaching and i i obviously think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01637-00363759-00363999": "none of us feel good about that but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01638-00364000-00364206": "but what about the more passive nature", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01639-00364207-00364463": "of this and should high-income countries", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01640-00364464-00364758": "be erecting barriers so that so that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01641-00364759-00364975": "low-income country uh providers can't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01642-00364976-00365254": "come to high-income countries", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01643-00365255-00365447": "yeah i think that's a great question um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01644-00365448-00365606": "one of the things that i was actually", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01645-00365607-00365767": "just scrolling through the q and a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01646-00365768-00365967": "questions and there's one uh question", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01647-00365968-00366151": "that i think was i was already gonna", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01648-00366152-00366447": "talk about it so i'll answer it um which", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01649-00366448-00366575": "is that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01650-00366576-00366743": "you know when we say", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01651-00366744-00367071": "global surgery um this is something that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01652-00367072-00367287": "actually the four of us have spoken", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01653-00367288-00367519": "about many times um and we'll probably", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01654-00367520-00367775": "continue to but global surgery just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01655-00367776-00367943": "means surgery right like it means", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01656-00367944-00368143": "surgery just means", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01657-00368144-00368319": "people getting access to the care that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01658-00368320-00368519": "they need we call it global surgery", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01659-00368520-00368719": "because we are modeling it after global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01660-00368720-00368871": "health because people", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01661-00368872-00369030": "hear things that they know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01662-00369031-00369230": "and they reiterate those but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01663-00369231-00369423": "global surgery happens in the united", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01664-00369424-00369599": "states and it happens", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01665-00369600-00369767": "anywhere else it happens in sub-saharan", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01666-00369768-00369887": "africa it happens in india and it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01667-00369888-00370054": "happens in the united states right so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01668-00370055-00370239": "one of the questions i'm alluding to in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01669-00370240-00370527": "the chat was that do you see brain drain", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01670-00370528-00370854": "um as a equivalent or you know or kind", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01671-00370855-00371039": "of related to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01672-00371040-00371247": "physicians in the united states not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01673-00371248-00371495": "going to rural areas or areas that are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01674-00371496-00371710": "undersupported in financial or other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01675-00371711-00371854": "mechanisms", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01676-00371855-00372015": "and i do think that there is some sort", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01677-00372016-00372278": "of an equitable uh relationship there in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01678-00372279-00372487": "that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01679-00372488-00372734": "it's really hard to say no when you are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01680-00372735-00372943": "working you know for decades of your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01681-00372944-00373119": "life to train for something that's an", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01682-00373120-00373351": "act of service to others and then to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01683-00373352-00373510": "finally be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01684-00373511-00373695": "given an offer that you think you can't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01685-00373696-00373919": "refuse right to live in a place that you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01686-00373920-00374110": "want to live with your family that you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01687-00374111-00374247": "may or may not have been able to live", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01688-00374248-00374575": "near or with for decades uh for your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01689-00374576-00374806": "training you know potentially to have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01690-00374807-00375023": "some creature comforts that you weren't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01691-00375024-00375215": "able to have in other places", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01692-00375216-00375447": "and uh you know for sometimes what seems", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01693-00375448-00375678": "like potentially an uphill battle or a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01694-00375679-00375871": "thankless situation that you find", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01695-00375872-00376006": "yourself in so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01696-00376007-00376167": "i do think dr mayor like when you were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01697-00376168-00376430": "saying you know should we erect barriers", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01698-00376431-00376575": "i don't know that barriers are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01699-00376576-00376767": "necessarily the way to go about things", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01700-00376768-00376934": "in general", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01701-00376935-00377151": "but i do think that there is something", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01702-00377152-00377287": "there in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01703-00377288-00377558": "not only", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01704-00377559-00377767": "not only providing financial incentive", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01705-00377768-00378006": "for the more challenging of these types", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01706-00378007-00378134": "of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01707-00378135-00378439": "jobs or positions but also being really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01708-00378440-00378934": "thoughtful as high-income country um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01709-00378935-00379239": "hiring practice providers that who are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01710-00379240-00379439": "we hiring and why but then i think the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01711-00379440-00379606": "thing that gets really challenging is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01712-00379607-00379863": "who made me the boss so just because of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01713-00379864-00380063": "a miracle of birth i happen to be born", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01714-00380064-00380199": "in the united states as opposed to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01715-00380200-00380534": "somewhere else i have now been given the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01716-00380535-00380758": "responsibility potentially to choose who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01717-00380759-00380910": "does or doesn't get access to the same", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01718-00380911-00381047": "kind of education and training and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01719-00381048-00381230": "opportunity that i have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01720-00381231-00381558": "sorry excuse me um but that shouldn't be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01721-00381559-00381743": "necessarily the case so i think my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01722-00381744-00381919": "answer is i don't think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01723-00381920-00382151": "that barriers provide you know put up by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01724-00382152-00382367": "high income country participants or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01725-00382368-00382543": "practitioners is necessarily the answer", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01726-00382544-00382775": "but it's more about incentivizing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01727-00382776-00382958": "um the way that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01728-00382959-00383223": "um you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01729-00383224-00383519": "benefits are distributed elsewhere", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01730-00383520-00383710": "i don't know if that's a skirting your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01731-00383711-00383934": "answer but oh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01732-00383935-00384110": "no i i think that's i think that's very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01733-00384111-00384343": "true you know um lars gander who was one", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01734-00384344-00384519": "of the commissioners on the lancer", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01735-00384520-00384606": "commission", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01736-00384607-00384863": "did some research looking at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01737-00384864-00385095": "clinicians who had come i believe it was", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01738-00385096-00385263": "to north america but it might have been", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01739-00385264-00385495": "to all high income countries and did a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01740-00385496-00385806": "survey and and uh found that one of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01741-00385807-00386023": "main reasons um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01742-00386024-00386223": "for folks to leave their home country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01743-00386224-00386375": "was just what the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01744-00386376-00386567": "participant who asked that question", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01745-00386568-00386727": "brought up was that you know there", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01746-00386728-00386910": "aren't the local there isn't the local", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01747-00386911-00387071": "atmosphere in the local community the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01748-00387072-00387310": "local um you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01749-00387311-00387439": "folks to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01750-00387440-00387663": "work with and so i think you know on one", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01751-00387664-00387815": "hand you're talking about the fact that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01752-00387816-00388006": "people have agency and should be able to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01753-00388007-00388206": "decide what they do with their lives", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01754-00388207-00388351": "and then michelle was saying look but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01755-00388352-00388551": "what we should be doing is building", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01756-00388552-00388782": "capacity and building environments so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01757-00388783-00388967": "that people don't feel like they have to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01758-00388968-00389175": "leave so i think you know it's not one", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01759-00389176-00389367": "or the other and obviously it's not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01760-00389368-00389567": "going to happen by tomorrow but uh but i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01761-00389568-00389758": "think the answer is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01762-00389759-00389887": "all of the above", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01763-00389888-00390015": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01764-00390016-00390230": "back to research just for a moment uh dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01765-00390231-00390406": "hetgothier", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01766-00390407-00390663": "how do you enter into on a in a very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01767-00390664-00390830": "practical sense how do you enter into", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01768-00390831-00391095": "relationships with your partners so that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01769-00391096-00391343": "you know the authorship is is more fair", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01770-00391344-00391502": "because i know that's that's been", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01771-00391503-00391719": "something that you've really focused on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01772-00391720-00391895": "and i think it's really important", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01773-00391896-00392063": "because it's so easy i mean i know from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01774-00392064-00392263": "personal experience it's so easy to you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01775-00392264-00392471": "know get working on a paper and you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01776-00392472-00392639": "you know you crank it out and you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01777-00392640-00392758": "pretty soon", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01778-00392759-00392902": "you know the authorship is really not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01779-00392903-00393158": "very fair so how do you get started and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01780-00393159-00393463": "get off on the right foot", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01781-00393464-00393702": "it's a great question um i mean it's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01782-00393703-00393958": "definitely even for me a continued work", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01783-00393959-00394199": "in progress right like i do not pretend", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01784-00394200-00394487": "like every paper gets it exactly right", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01785-00394488-00394734": "um and it's complex so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01786-00394735-00394927": "i would say the first and foremost one", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01787-00394928-00395054": "of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01788-00395055-00395334": "barriers that i realized i had to this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01789-00395335-00395463": "and it was a bit", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01790-00395464-00395599": "the the point i was trying to make", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01791-00395600-00395775": "around really trying to understand who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01792-00395776-00395967": "you are in this space", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01793-00395968-00396215": "was just realizing that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01794-00396216-00396519": "um i wasn't being honest with myself or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01795-00396520-00396734": "my colleagues about what i needed out of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01796-00396735-00396982": "projects right so you know i'm here to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01797-00396983-00397239": "help i'm here to support this research", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01798-00397240-00397367": "project", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01799-00397368-00397663": "and then i found myself clamoring for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01800-00397664-00397878": "first authorship without even realizing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01801-00397879-00398143": "i was doing it and realizing why i was", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01802-00398144-00398399": "doing it and so you know for myself i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01803-00398400-00398671": "try to really think about you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01804-00398672-00398878": "what do you need what do your colleagues", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01805-00398879-00399167": "need um and it's there are our teams", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01806-00399168-00399278": "have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01807-00399279-00399599": "10 15 20 people on them so really trying", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01808-00399600-00399775": "to balance you know now as i'm more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01809-00399776-00399999": "senior in my career oftentimes serving", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01810-00400000-00400199": "in that pi role where my responsibility", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01811-00400200-00400327": "is to think about every single", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01812-00400328-00400447": "individual", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01813-00400448-00400654": "what their goals are what their needs", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01814-00400655-00400823": "are what their skills are and really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01815-00400824-00401023": "trying to balance the opportunities for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01816-00401024-00401143": "that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01817-00401144-00401302": "we keep a paper list so as soon as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01818-00401303-00401558": "someone comes up with an idea it goes on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01819-00401559-00401791": "our paper list and the first person who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01820-00401792-00402015": "gets priority for that idea is the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01821-00402016-00402206": "person who came up with it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01822-00402207-00402423": "um it doesn't always pan out that way", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01823-00402424-00402663": "but it's a conversation it's really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01824-00402664-00402871": "um thinking through", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01825-00402872-00403054": "you know so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01826-00403055-00403223": "dr joseph may have come up with an idea", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01827-00403224-00403367": "but maybe it was her 10th really good", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01828-00403368-00403551": "idea so thinking through like what are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01829-00403552-00403719": "your priorities on this and then can we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01830-00403720-00403902": "share some of those other opportunities", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01831-00403903-00404143": "and it's a constant dialogue", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01832-00404144-00404358": "um and by constant i mean i probably", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01833-00404359-00404687": "spend two to three hours a week just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01834-00404688-00404871": "navigating authorships on various", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01835-00404872-00405015": "opportunities so i think just having", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01836-00405016-00405271": "open conversation again really trusting", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01837-00405272-00405447": "that you can be honest about what you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01838-00405448-00405615": "need and that people can be honest with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01839-00405616-00405702": "you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01840-00405703-00405934": "um all of that and then just putting", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01841-00405935-00406078": "things in writing and really trying to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01842-00406079-00406278": "stick to those commitments are are some", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01843-00406279-00406478": "of the strategies we've adopted", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01844-00406479-00406671": "and so obviously the you know the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01845-00406672-00406799": "dialogue and the conversation is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01846-00406800-00406975": "important have you gotten to the point", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01847-00406976-00407182": "where you have a hard and fast rule and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01848-00407183-00407382": "you say look i'm not going to submit a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01849-00407383-00407623": "paper unless there's you know co-first", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01850-00407624-00407823": "authorship with one person from our shop", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01851-00407824-00407975": "and one person from over there or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01852-00407976-00408182": "co-senior office shipper i mean do you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01853-00408183-00408351": "get to that point where it's like hard", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01854-00408352-00408558": "and fast rules or are you still trying", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01855-00408559-00408815": "to work through it with conversation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01856-00408816-00409087": "um so i never think of a paper in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01857-00409088-00409334": "isolation right i think about a paper in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01858-00409335-00409567": "the full portfolio of work so there", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01859-00409568-00409839": "might be a situation where", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01860-00409839-00409926": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01861-00409927-00410166": "we have a balance that that someone", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01862-00410167-00410303": "might look at that single paper and say", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01863-00410304-00410439": "it's in balance", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01864-00410439-00410622": "but i think about it as like the full", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01865-00410623-00410807": "body of work and you know who brings", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01866-00410808-00411087": "what skills to the table and some papers", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01867-00411088-00411287": "like we do machine learning", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01868-00411288-00411534": "papers that really rely on an expertise", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01869-00411535-00411678": "of a colleague", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01870-00411679-00411847": "at mit and so that might have more of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01871-00411847-00412063": "his students on it and then we do papers", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01872-00412064-00412255": "that are really about clinical protocols", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01873-00412256-00412439": "and that might have more colleagues from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01874-00412439-00412647": "rwanda on it so i don't think about a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01875-00412647-00412774": "single paper", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01876-00412775-00412991": "one of the challenges i've put to myself", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01877-00412992-00413334": "is that at least half of my papers have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01878-00413335-00413591": "um the one and first authors at least", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01879-00413592-00413782": "half of them have rwandan senior authors", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01880-00413783-00413959": "for my papers from rwanda so it's more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01881-00413960-00414134": "about the full body of work not a single", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01882-00414135-00414359": "paper right and i will say", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01883-00414360-00414534": "there was recently an authorship", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01884-00414535-00414710": "reflexivity statement", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01885-00414712-00414934": "that is fantastic and so i think sitting", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01886-00414935-00415174": "down and for that paper thinking about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01887-00415175-00415414": "how did i engage partners how do they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01888-00415415-00415574": "think about this opportunity in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01889-00415575-00415807": "context of other opportunities and that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01890-00415808-00415959": "reflexivity statement is actually", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01891-00415960-00416182": "something that our teams we're adopting", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01892-00416183-00416422": "not just for papers but for how we go", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01893-00416423-00416630": "through our day-to-day research and i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01894-00416631-00416855": "put that link in because i do think it's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01895-00416856-00417191": "a helpful reflection for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01896-00417192-00417487": "my day-to-day and and how i'm engaging", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01897-00417488-00417695": "my full team no matter where they sit", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01898-00417696-00417895": "right right okay that's fantastic thank", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01899-00417896-00417999": "you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01900-00418000-00418287": "dr joseph you talked a little bit about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01901-00418288-00418510": "power and power imbalance", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01902-00418512-00418766": "just speak a little bit more to that in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01903-00418767-00419022": "the sense that you know let let's say i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01904-00419023-00419230": "uh go on one of these you know medical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01905-00419231-00419447": "missions and i'm gonna i'm all excited", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01906-00419447-00419663": "i'm gonna do some cleft flip repairs", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01907-00419664-00419879": "somewhere what what happens what what do", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01908-00419880-00420055": "you mean by power balance i show up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01909-00420056-00420391": "somewhere and what happens actually", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01910-00420392-00420614": "well one would hope that there was an", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01911-00420615-00420799": "ask to begin with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01912-00420800-00420959": "and that um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01913-00420960-00421110": "the need", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01914-00421112-00421327": "you were trying to meet", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01915-00421328-00421735": "was a request from a surgeon in country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01916-00421735-00421943": "who wanted you to assist in these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01917-00421943-00422087": "difficult cases", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01918-00422088-00422359": "one would hope that that is the scenario", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01919-00422360-00422575": "however that may not be the case", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01920-00422576-00422839": "uh and if it's not the case then", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01921-00422839-00423110": "what may happen is you are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01922-00423112-00423431": "contacted via an ngo", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01923-00423432-00423710": "to perform x number of surgeries at x", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01924-00423712-00423918": "hospital within a very short period of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01925-00423919-00424063": "time", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01926-00424064-00424207": "you may not be familiar with the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01927-00424208-00424375": "hospital built any relationships with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01928-00424376-00424663": "the surgeons and your approach may be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01929-00424664-00424943": "one that is consistent with a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01930-00424943-00425279": "hic facility or or environment but is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01931-00425280-00425399": "not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01932-00425400-00425543": "conducive to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01933-00425543-00425863": "getting the best out of people in an nic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01934-00425864-00426014": "or nmic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01935-00426015-00426383": "setting you do the surgeries um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01936-00426384-00426566": "very skilled but you don't have all the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01937-00426567-00426727": "tools that you need because you're not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01938-00426728-00426943": "used to working in that environment so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01939-00426943-00427095": "suddenly where it would have been fairly", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01940-00427096-00427191": "simple for you there may be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01941-00427192-00427383": "complications but you have to go back", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01942-00427384-00427575": "home you have to get back to bch you got", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01943-00427576-00427727": "to get back to your list", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01944-00427728-00427935": "and also the time difference so you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01945-00427935-00428087": "can't help in real time with all the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01946-00428088-00428303": "complications that may or may not occur", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01947-00428304-00428559": "so suddenly you're left with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01948-00428560-00428695": "this real", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01949-00428696-00428910": "true desire and need to do the right", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01950-00428912-00429159": "thing to help to assist because with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01951-00429160-00429391": "cleft palate cultural issues there may", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01952-00429392-00429559": "be stigmatization of someone who has a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01953-00429560-00429887": "deformity so it's not a un", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01954-00429888-00430127": "realistic or inappropriate ask", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01955-00430128-00430366": "to allow someone to be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01956-00430367-00430543": "integrated to society because you have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01957-00430543-00430775": "fixed their facial deformity however the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01958-00430776-00431031": "potential consequences may be far", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01959-00431032-00431239": "greater than the stigmatization they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01960-00431239-00431614": "would have faced that is a a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01961-00431615-00431814": "case example of what may or may not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01962-00431815-00431959": "occur", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01963-00431960-00432143": "and and uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01964-00432143-00432255": "you know pushing that a little bit", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01965-00432256-00432487": "further dr jin while so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01966-00432488-00432679": "you know i show up somewhere what", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01967-00432680-00432879": "happens in the in the hospitals in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01968-00432880-00433087": "surrounding region you know when when i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01969-00433088-00433239": "bring a big group of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01970-00433239-00433551": "you know 100 folks down to some hospital", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01971-00433552-00433710": "you know within 100 miles of that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01972-00433712-00433910": "hospital what happens in the surrounding", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01973-00433912-00434095": "area", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01974-00434096-00434351": "well i can actually give you a personal", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01975-00434352-00434639": "example of what happens uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01976-00434639-00435022": "so if it wasn't abundantly clear uh the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01977-00435023-00435239": "25 year old medical student", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01978-00435239-00435366": "was me", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01979-00435367-00435551": "that i spoke about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01980-00435552-00435839": "and when i was on that exact trip", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01981-00435839-00435943": "actually", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01982-00435943-00436375": "um people were traveling for miles miles", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01983-00436376-00436703": "to come see the american doctors right", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01984-00436704-00436918": "jokes on them there was one doctor the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01985-00436919-00437151": "rest were medical students um which you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01986-00437152-00437455": "know we have our place but um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01987-00437456-00437599": "they weren't coming to see doctors they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01988-00437600-00437879": "were coming to see the american team", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01989-00437880-00437991": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01990-00437992-00438279": "not only were people traveling for days", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01991-00438280-00438495": "sometimes to come and see us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01992-00438496-00438735": "uh they were also bypassing other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01993-00438735-00438927": "clinics and other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01994-00438928-00439279": "um like other hospitals that were in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01995-00439280-00439503": "central plateau that were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01996-00439504-00439766": "equally able to provide them with care", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01997-00439767-00439943": "that we were providing because we were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01998-00439943-00440143": "doing blood pressure checks and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-01999-00440143-00440255": "you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02000-00440256-00440527": "prenatal checks uh for pregnant pregnant", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02001-00440528-00440751": "people", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02002-00440752-00440887": "and that's something that many people", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02003-00440888-00441055": "could have done that they passed by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02004-00441056-00441263": "along the way because of the word that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02005-00441264-00441431": "had gotten out that the american doctors", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02006-00441432-00441599": "were coming and i think i would just say", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02007-00441600-00441814": "one other thing about power imbalances", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02008-00441815-00441910": "that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02009-00441912-00442207": "dr joseph touched on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02010-00442208-00442399": "a lot of times you have to think about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02011-00442400-00442495": "and this is something else we were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02012-00442496-00442622": "talking about earlier today a little bit", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02013-00442623-00442735": "you have to talk about you have to think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02014-00442735-00442870": "about what questions you're asking", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02015-00442871-00442959": "people", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02016-00442960-00443063": "because sometimes you might be not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02017-00443064-00443279": "asking the right questions and so when", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02018-00443280-00443639": "um at the start of that the same trip um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02019-00443639-00443910": "the organization took us you know to go", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02020-00443912-00444166": "see some of the family members or some", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02021-00444167-00444247": "of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02022-00444247-00444391": "families that we were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02023-00444392-00444566": "going to see later in clinic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02024-00444567-00444655": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02025-00444656-00444814": "they were like oh why don't we do a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02026-00444815-00444991": "vaccination survey to see how many of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02027-00444992-00445199": "these children have been vaccinated", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02028-00445200-00445295": "and so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02029-00445296-00445439": "you know we go down the street and we", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02030-00445439-00445647": "ask everyone like oh you know have you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02031-00445647-00445759": "been vaccinated and they're like yeah", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02032-00445760-00445887": "we've been vaccinated and then i just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02033-00445888-00446039": "asked them one of the kids i said when", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02034-00446039-00446175": "was the last time someone asked you this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02035-00446176-00446270": "question", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02036-00446271-00446455": "and they said oh last week when the last", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02037-00446456-00446607": "group came", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02038-00446608-00446687": "so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02039-00446688-00447070": "you know there is inherently this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02040-00447071-00447255": "system that's set up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02041-00447256-00447391": "to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02042-00447392-00447518": "not only", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02043-00447519-00447766": "prioritize the investment that the hic", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02044-00447767-00448022": "providers give and again not to go back", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02045-00448023-00448222": "to the same situation but you see this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02046-00448223-00448366": "in the united states as well right you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02047-00448367-00448566": "want certain some patients want a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02048-00448567-00448727": "certain type of doctor they don't want a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02049-00448728-00448863": "doctor that looks", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02050-00448864-00449079": "a certain way because they want they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02051-00449080-00449287": "think that the best doctor is the white", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02052-00449288-00449463": "male doctor they don't necessarily think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02053-00449464-00449647": "the best doctor is the person who's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02054-00449647-00449791": "taking care of them", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02055-00449792-00450055": "for many reasons right but i think that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02056-00450056-00450303": "all speaks to the same concept of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02057-00450304-00450495": "being really conscientious about what it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02058-00450496-00450631": "means to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02059-00450632-00450807": "do a short-term surgical mission trip", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02060-00450808-00451070": "and ask the right questions about like", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02061-00451071-00451239": "like dr joseph was saying i hope there", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02062-00451239-00451447": "was an ask for you to come do that cleft", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02063-00451447-00451766": "that cleft um you know cleft trip um is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02064-00451767-00451879": "that something that's aligned with the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02065-00451880-00452007": "community", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02066-00452008-00452270": "um and are you actually engaged as a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02067-00452271-00452495": "person who is a member of the community", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02068-00452496-00452814": "also or trying to help or are you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02069-00452815-00452943": "someone who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02070-00452943-00453135": "is getting the best show possible in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02071-00453135-00453414": "order to elicit further engagement so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02072-00453415-00453583": "there's a lot of things that come up", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02073-00453584-00453814": "with that power question that also you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02074-00453815-00453943": "might not even realize if you're not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02075-00453943-00454135": "asking the right questions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02076-00454135-00454295": "well you hit on something and i i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02077-00454296-00454455": "haven't prepped you for this but you hit", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02078-00454456-00454663": "you hit it on something perfectly in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02079-00454664-00454775": "that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02080-00454776-00454935": "over a decade ago", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02081-00454935-00455103": "our team and one of the local teams i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02082-00455104-00455318": "won't say where to give it away but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02083-00455319-00455503": "did a little research project looking at", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02084-00455504-00455695": "what happens at surrounding hospitals", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02085-00455696-00455879": "when a local when a team comes to one", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02086-00455880-00456031": "particular hospital", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02087-00456032-00456247": "and it's exactly what you just said but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02088-00456247-00456447": "we also looked at the clinical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02089-00456447-00456591": "throughput at those surrounding", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02090-00456592-00456735": "hospitals and what happened is the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02091-00456735-00456910": "clinical throughput dropped at all the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02092-00456912-00457087": "surrounding hospitals because everyone", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02093-00457088-00457310": "was coming to watch these folks come", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02094-00457312-00457527": "from from other places so there are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02095-00457528-00457743": "definitely some unintended consequences", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02096-00457743-00457903": "that uh that you have to be you have to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02097-00457904-00458118": "be aware of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02098-00458119-00458327": "dr heck gothia back to research just for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02099-00458328-00458510": "a moment", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02100-00458512-00458727": "if you had a magic wand how would you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02101-00458728-00459022": "restructure funding like from usaid and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02102-00459023-00459247": "gates and clinton and how do you make", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02103-00459247-00459470": "funding so that it promotes equitable", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02104-00459471-00459814": "research", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02105-00459815-00460175": "that is a hard question um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02106-00460176-00460327": "you know my knee-jerk reaction said give", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02107-00460328-00460703": "it to all of our projects", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02108-00460704-00460839": "but i mean i feel like i feel like", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02109-00460839-00461014": "sometimes the funding", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02110-00461015-00461231": "you know promotes some of these issues", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02111-00461232-00461455": "and so how how would you make the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02112-00461456-00461670": "funding mechanism such that it's it's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02113-00461671-00461814": "better and and you know what i'll i'll", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02114-00461815-00462095": "throw another part in there um that's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02115-00462096-00462295": "that's related uh because you've been", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02116-00462296-00462414": "involved and you were involved in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02117-00462415-00462583": "something in rwanda it said what are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02118-00462584-00462799": "some examples of building capacities in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02119-00462800-00463063": "lics and lmic's in lieu of short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02120-00463064-00463239": "mission trips like who is in charge of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02121-00463239-00463422": "the development so how do we change the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02122-00463423-00463647": "funding paradigm around research but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02123-00463647-00463966": "even even capacity building you know to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02124-00463967-00464199": "change the whole paradigm", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02125-00464200-00464414": "yeah you know that question", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02126-00464415-00464695": "um is really the one in the chat and and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02127-00464696-00464831": "then i'll get to you to your questions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02128-00464832-00464935": "well john", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02129-00464935-00465183": "really got me thinking and again i'm not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02130-00465184-00465295": "a surgeon so i'm not doing these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02131-00465296-00465463": "short-term medical trips but a lot of my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02132-00465464-00465670": "early career i'm a statistician a lot of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02133-00465671-00465903": "my early career was teaching short-term", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02134-00465904-00466143": "math courses", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02135-00466143-00466335": "doing a three-day logistic regression", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02136-00466335-00466463": "course and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02137-00466464-00466566": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02138-00466567-00466679": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02139-00466680-00466927": "um dr genoa i think you were the one", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02140-00466928-00467127": "commenting on this about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02141-00467128-00467422": "oftentimes what i taught when i taught", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02142-00467423-00467679": "it and the like sort of the structure of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02143-00467680-00467999": "it was all about well i have four days", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02144-00468000-00468191": "and i have some motivation to be in this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02145-00468192-00468303": "country", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02146-00468304-00468487": "and so i'm just gonna reach out to the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02147-00468488-00468670": "university and say i'm gonna i can do", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02148-00468671-00468910": "this right and it was a very specific", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02149-00468912-00469022": "ask", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02150-00469023-00469118": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02151-00469119-00469431": "that is very different now than how i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02152-00469432-00469670": "try then how now i try to approach it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02153-00469671-00469903": "which is okay these are the skill sets", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02154-00469904-00470103": "that i have this is the time frame that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02155-00470104-00470231": "i have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02156-00470232-00470335": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02157-00470335-00470543": "you know is there a value that i can", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02158-00470543-00470735": "contribute what are your needs what are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02159-00470735-00470935": "so i work a lot now with the africa", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02160-00470935-00471118": "center of excellence and data science", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02161-00471119-00471247": "what courses are coming on your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02162-00471247-00471383": "curriculum", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02163-00471384-00471479": "you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02164-00471480-00471735": "how can i help and and sometimes they", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02165-00471735-00471975": "just end with you're not useful to us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02166-00471976-00472039": "now", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02167-00472039-00472375": "right and that is like a perfectly fine", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02168-00472376-00472639": "thing for someone to say to me like your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02169-00472639-00472855": "availability and your skill sets and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02170-00472856-00473095": "your goals don't match with our needs", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02171-00473096-00473222": "and our priorities and our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02172-00473223-00473366": "infrastructure and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02173-00473367-00473518": "i have a long-term friend and colleague", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02174-00473519-00473766": "janine chanda who just always reminds me", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02175-00473767-00473879": "like", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02176-00473880-00474070": "you know we the she was at the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02177-00474071-00474207": "university of rwanda we spent so much", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02178-00474208-00474335": "time", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02179-00474335-00474703": "bowing to the the goals and the the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02180-00474704-00474839": "priorities of the people who are coming", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02181-00474839-00475007": "to teach three-day logistic regression", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02182-00475008-00475175": "courses that we never teach our survival", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02183-00475176-00475463": "analysis course because we're just doing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02184-00475464-00475631": "these other courses so i think there's a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02185-00475632-00475759": "parallel there", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02186-00475760-00475847": "to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02187-00475847-00475959": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02188-00475960-00476118": "to the surgical mission trip right and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02189-00476119-00476327": "having our approach right there i think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02190-00476328-00476503": "there are for those of you who are on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02191-00476504-00476687": "the call i think there are still", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02192-00476688-00476887": "opportunities for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02193-00476888-00477079": "if you have two weeks and a very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02194-00477080-00477318": "specific expertise i think there are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02195-00477319-00477551": "opportunities for that but it's about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02196-00477552-00477751": "doing it in a way that's not", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02197-00477752-00478014": "orthogonal to systems and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02198-00478015-00478191": "programs and and finding the right way", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02199-00478192-00478366": "to do that so to your funding question i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02200-00478367-00478479": "mean i think there's a direct line to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02201-00478480-00478639": "that right so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02202-00478639-00478759": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02203-00478760-00479087": "if my colleague wants a survival course", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02204-00479088-00479191": "don't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02205-00479192-00479327": "just say that you're only going to fund", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02206-00479328-00479535": "logistic regression right or if my", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02207-00479535-00479807": "colleague wants a two-year training", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02208-00479808-00480014": "don't only give funding mechanisms for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02209-00480015-00480222": "six months um from the research", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02210-00480223-00480399": "perspective i always call it the button", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02211-00480400-00480599": "cheer metric right funders want more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02212-00480600-00480814": "butts and chairs they don't want better", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02213-00480815-00481127": "and deeper trainings and partnerships so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02214-00481128-00481303": "um you know i think those are things", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02215-00481304-00481527": "that come to mind with funders but i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02216-00481528-00481743": "definitely think funders need to start", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02217-00481743-00482007": "adopting you know that that reflexivity", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02218-00482008-00482110": "checklist that i think is going to be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02219-00482112-00482239": "sharing with you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02220-00482239-00482455": "um you know they should be asking", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02221-00482456-00482639": "grantees to be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02222-00482639-00482862": "reflecting and really demonstrating", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02223-00482863-00483087": "their intentions in application that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02224-00483088-00483239": "should be an evaluation criteria for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02225-00483239-00483335": "sure", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02226-00483335-00483527": "thank you thank you that's great", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02227-00483528-00483718": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02228-00483719-00483935": "dr jinjin while uh go back to you again", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02229-00483935-00484095": "because you brought up the issue of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02230-00484096-00484295": "25 year old going down there i've seen a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02231-00484296-00484422": "question or two", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02232-00484423-00484743": "relating to is it you know even ethical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02233-00484743-00484918": "for us to be going over down these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02234-00484919-00485039": "short-term missions and i'll make it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02235-00485039-00485262": "more for med students because you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02236-00485263-00485439": "why would why should we be sending a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02237-00485439-00485687": "north american med student anywhere well", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02238-00485688-00485887": "how do they help what what value are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02239-00485888-00486239": "they on on any type of a mission trip", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02240-00486239-00486551": "yeah so i would say we shouldn't", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02241-00486552-00486679": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02242-00486680-00486855": "that was the only mission trip i went on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02243-00486856-00487062": "and i had such a bad taste in my mouth", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02244-00487063-00487231": "afterwards from", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02245-00487232-00487566": "kind of everything how it all went um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02246-00487567-00487735": "that i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02247-00487735-00487927": "really threw that is actually one of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02248-00487928-00488031": "reasons why", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02249-00488032-00488318": "i chose to do my masters in ethics um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02250-00488319-00488583": "because i knew i had these big questions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02251-00488584-00488695": "and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02252-00488696-00488879": "uh as bethany mentioned", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02253-00488880-00489087": "dr hacketti i mentioned a moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02254-00489088-00489318": "obligation i felt that moral obligation", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02255-00489319-00489447": "to do more", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02256-00489447-00489518": "but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02257-00489519-00489783": "i didn't know the best way to navigate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02258-00489784-00489927": "that for myself and i think there was", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02259-00489928-00490135": "another question in the chat about um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02260-00490135-00490287": "you know is there", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02261-00490288-00490407": "other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02262-00490408-00490575": "ethical frameworks rather than beechem", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02263-00490576-00490735": "and childress that you could you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02264-00490735-00490895": "apply to these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02265-00490896-00491143": "types of questions and i that's what i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02266-00491143-00491366": "wanted to learn more about in in doing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02267-00491367-00491695": "that master's program and so i would say", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02268-00491696-00491951": "to medical students uh it sounds very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02269-00491952-00492279": "fun uh to go somewhere and do something", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02270-00492280-00492487": "and maybe learn how to do a technique", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02271-00492488-00492614": "that you wouldn't be able to see", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02272-00492615-00492775": "somewhere else but", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02273-00492776-00493062": "uh i would posit that there are places", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02274-00493063-00493279": "in north america that you can get the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02275-00493280-00493503": "same experience and probably way closer", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02276-00493504-00493655": "to home than you think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02277-00493656-00493751": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02278-00493752-00493943": "and i actually got that question a lot", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02279-00493943-00494062": "when i was applying to surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02280-00494063-00494383": "residency uh you know i went to i went", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02281-00494384-00494599": "to medical school in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02282-00494600-00494903": "atlanta uh and there are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02283-00494904-00495143": "lots of disparities within the city", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02284-00495143-00495422": "itself um in boston where i'm located", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02285-00495423-00495703": "now there is you know a lot of evidence", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02286-00495704-00496055": "for life expenses dropping once you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02287-00496056-00496207": "cross a road", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02288-00496208-00496543": "um from matapan to milton", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02289-00496543-00496775": "that is not unique right it's not a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02290-00496776-00496951": "unique to boston it's not unique to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02291-00496952-00497087": "atlanta it's true for pretty much", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02292-00497088-00497222": "anywhere that you have a city with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02293-00497223-00497375": "people", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02294-00497376-00497614": "and i think that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02295-00497615-00497687": "the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02296-00497688-00497839": "advice i would give", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02297-00497839-00498070": "is to really re-examine the reasons why", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02298-00498071-00498247": "you want to do that short-term surgical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02299-00498247-00498335": "mission", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02300-00498335-00498599": "and why why you want to go to uganda or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02301-00498600-00498847": "rwanda or haiti rather than", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02302-00498847-00498999": "um down the street", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02303-00499000-00499183": "and if your answer is that you want a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02304-00499184-00499439": "trip you should just take a trip", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02305-00499439-00499543": "right", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02306-00499543-00499718": "well i i think people agree with you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02307-00499719-00499935": "i've seen a couple comments in line with", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02308-00499935-00500222": "that um dr joseph there i've noticed a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02309-00500223-00500479": "few comments and questions here about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02310-00500480-00500566": "uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02311-00500567-00500783": "how do you use technology telemedicine", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02312-00500784-00500935": "etc etc", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02313-00500935-00501183": "is that a way that can help us you know", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02314-00501184-00501327": "establish", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02315-00501328-00501551": "better longer term relationships or help", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02316-00501552-00501751": "with equity i mean how do we use new", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02317-00501752-00502031": "technology to do this better", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02318-00502032-00502247": "i think if covert has taught us anything", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02319-00502247-00502391": "for us that are working in the global", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02320-00502392-00502583": "health and global surgery spaces that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02321-00502584-00502743": "there is work to be done that can be", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02322-00502743-00502935": "done remotely if you can capitalize on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02323-00502935-00503166": "the technology that's available to you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02324-00503167-00503431": "while also being able to be utilized by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02325-00503432-00503599": "our partners in the countries in which", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02326-00503600-00503887": "we work um i think it's important for us", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02327-00503888-00504207": "to really harness technology not just in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02328-00504208-00504407": "communicating but also in training as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02329-00504408-00504487": "well", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02330-00504488-00504670": "what does it look like to be able to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02331-00504671-00504775": "deliver", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02332-00504776-00505022": "training remotely how do you push the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02333-00505023-00505222": "boundaries of what currently exists i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02334-00505223-00505431": "think one company which us at the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02335-00505432-00505622": "program global surgery and social change", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02336-00505623-00505791": "are familiar with this proximity being", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02337-00505792-00506031": "able to deliver training", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02338-00506032-00506247": "in theater in real time without having", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02339-00506247-00506487": "to be in country is really pushing the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02340-00506488-00506743": "boundaries of technology but also allows", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02341-00506743-00507159": "us to have more of a hands-off approach", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02342-00507160-00507383": "while still ensuring that training is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02343-00507384-00507639": "being delivered in an effective way i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02344-00507639-00507870": "think more of us need to start using uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02345-00507871-00508079": "technology to the advantage of our", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02346-00508080-00508431": "partners rather than to the benefit and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02347-00508432-00508687": "uh convenience of ourselves if that if", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02348-00508688-00508887": "we shift our lens i think we're able to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02349-00508888-00509095": "push the boundary further another thing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02350-00509096-00509318": "i'd like to mention is the um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02351-00509319-00509599": "intuitive foundation who are currently", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02352-00509600-00509751": "working on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02353-00509752-00509927": "really being a disruptor when it comes", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02354-00509928-00510055": "to training", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02355-00510056-00510310": "allowing access to those who typically", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02356-00510312-00510599": "wouldn't have the benefit of going to a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02357-00510600-00510862": "medical school being in those circles", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02358-00510863-00511103": "but being able to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02359-00511104-00511335": "identify that they're bright enough to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02360-00511335-00511518": "learn surgical skills", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02361-00511519-00511799": "and become surgical officers in their", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02362-00511800-00512007": "countries in which they reside by having", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02363-00512008-00512287": "the material readily available", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02364-00512288-00512414": "now there are a whole bunch of ethics", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02365-00512415-00512662": "around that you don't want anyone", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02366-00512663-00512855": "random person doing surgery but there's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02367-00512856-00513143": "an opportunity here for us to bypass the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02368-00513143-00513351": "traditional route in order to ensure", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02369-00513352-00513566": "that we are training up the numbers that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02370-00513567-00513822": "are required in order to deliver the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02371-00513823-00514279": "surgery that is needed in these spaces", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02372-00514280-00514479": "all right well gosh we have three", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02373-00514480-00514670": "minutes left so just in in the short", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02374-00514671-00514855": "time that we have maybe in the order", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02375-00514856-00515135": "that that uh the speaker spoke maybe", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02376-00515135-00515351": "i'll let each of you just", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02377-00515352-00515551": "offer a few final comments or if there's", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02378-00515552-00515703": "a specific question that you really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02379-00515704-00515862": "liked that i didn't get to because there", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02380-00515863-00516118": "were so many fantastic questions i'll go", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02381-00516119-00516335": "ahead and answer that but uh so doctor", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02382-00516335-00516510": "headquarte if you have just a comment or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02383-00516512-00516639": "two or you want to answer a question", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02384-00516639-00516887": "that i didn't get to please go ahead", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02385-00516888-00517166": "there's so many great comments in the q", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02386-00517167-00517262": "a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02387-00517263-00517599": "and questions but i i just want to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02388-00517600-00517814": "express gratitude for this space and and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02389-00517815-00518127": "i've known dr mir dr ginger and dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02390-00518128-00518414": "joseph for a long time and um i think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02391-00518415-00518703": "part of why i'm getting better and again", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02392-00518704-00518918": "not perfect is just having these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02393-00518919-00519191": "conversations and so to dr hunt on the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02394-00519192-00519399": "team just having the space and really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02395-00519400-00519622": "pushing us to think more about this i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02396-00519623-00519775": "think it's so important to have these", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02397-00519776-00520007": "conversations and and hope you continue", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02398-00520008-00520166": "it offline after these sessions for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02399-00520167-00520359": "those of you participating", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02400-00520360-00520591": "thank you dr joseph a comment or two or", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02401-00520592-00520735": "a question that you wanted to answer", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02402-00520735-00521047": "that that i didn't get to uh well first", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02403-00521047-00521175": "of all i'd like to share my thanks as", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02404-00521176-00521366": "well it's a real opportunity to share", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02405-00521367-00521583": "the panel with colleagues but also to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02406-00521584-00521759": "read all the fantastic questions in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02407-00521760-00521918": "chat there are so many that i would like", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02408-00521919-00522031": "to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02409-00522032-00522270": "answer but one that really", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02410-00522271-00522583": "stands out for me i think is important", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02411-00522584-00522807": "is um there's not one framework that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02412-00522808-00523007": "fits all", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02413-00523008-00523222": "in an ideal world you could have a four", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02414-00523223-00523343": "point system", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02415-00523343-00523575": "and apply it but that's not the reality", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02416-00523576-00523839": "these are nuanced and complex", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02417-00523839-00524118": "problems and complex problems require", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02418-00524119-00524375": "complex solutions so it's important for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02419-00524376-00524679": "us to take things in the context of", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02420-00524680-00524879": "the circumstance rather than", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02421-00524880-00525022": "utilizing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02422-00525023-00525166": "some frameworks only there was a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02423-00525167-00525311": "question regarding are there any other", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02424-00525312-00525511": "other frameworks are out there and i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02425-00525512-00525679": "would suggest the application is very", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02426-00525680-00525918": "much dependent on the circumstance", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02427-00525919-00526214": "thank you so much doctor jin jhanwala", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02428-00526215-00526455": "yeah i guess i'll just speak uh briefly", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02429-00526456-00526831": "um as the trainee and on the panel um i", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02430-00526832-00527022": "would encourage all of the medical", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02431-00527023-00527199": "students and trainees who are here", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02432-00527200-00527359": "listening to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02433-00527360-00527679": "uh really question the or undergrads", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02434-00527680-00527839": "even anyone who's thinking about a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02435-00527840-00527991": "career in surgery and is motivated by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02436-00527992-00528143": "global health", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02437-00528144-00528431": "i would just think about ways to show", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02438-00528432-00528614": "your commitment to this space and this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02439-00528615-00528759": "work without", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02440-00528760-00529047": "having to feel like you need to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02441-00529048-00529318": "be traveling somewhere that's as dr adra", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02442-00529319-00529591": "says in the chat instagramable um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02443-00529592-00529670": "you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02444-00529671-00529895": "don't have to and if you can show your", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02445-00529896-00530047": "commitment to the communities that you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02446-00530048-00530295": "want to actually work with and in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02447-00530296-00530399": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02448-00530400-00530679": "that will come through and i think it is", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02449-00530680-00530855": "important for us to keep that moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02450-00530856-00530951": "compass", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02451-00530952-00531247": "um despite what we might be swayed by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02452-00531248-00531431": "because the same pressures that exist", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02453-00531432-00531518": "when you're", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02454-00531519-00531695": "a medical student or an undergrad are", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02455-00531696-00531918": "the same pressures that dr pedgathia was", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02456-00531919-00532103": "talking about that push you to try and", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02457-00532104-00532239": "achieve something", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02458-00532240-00532479": "for promotion down the line and i think", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02459-00532480-00532639": "um i personally am just working on", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02460-00532640-00532799": "practicing", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02461-00532800-00532935": "staying true to myself and my moral", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02462-00532936-00533151": "compass on that so i would encourage you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02463-00533152-00533375": "to do the same", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02464-00533376-00533639": "then well so first of all i i want to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02465-00533640-00533759": "start out by thanking all the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02466-00533760-00533991": "participants for spending 90 minutes", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02467-00533992-00534199": "with us that was a commitment and i hope", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02468-00534200-00534366": "it was enjoyable and i'm seeing some", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02469-00534367-00534518": "very nice comments and i appreciate", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02470-00534519-00534670": "everyone's comments", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02471-00534671-00534847": "secondly i want to thank our three", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02472-00534848-00535022": "speakers they put a lot of time into", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02473-00535023-00535175": "those talks as you could tell they were", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02474-00535176-00535414": "new new lectures that they put together", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02475-00535415-00535647": "and i we really appreciate what they did", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02476-00535648-00535943": "and then i want to thank the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02477-00535944-00536207": "hms center for bioethics that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02478-00536208-00536391": "fantastic venue", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02479-00536392-00536551": "it's really an honor to be able to do", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02480-00536552-00536735": "this with all of you so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02481-00536736-00536991": "with that i'll hand it back over to uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02482-00536992-00537279": "dr hanto and and the crew and thank you", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02483-00537280-00537431": "so much this was really a wonderful", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02484-00537432-00537718": "opportunity", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02485-00537719-00537943": "well i'd just like to reiterate uh dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02486-00537944-00538214": "mirror's thanks to dr hett gauthier dr", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02487-00538215-00538455": "joseph and dr jun jawala", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02488-00538456-00538566": "uh for", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02489-00538567-00538870": "excellent presentations and discussion", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02490-00538871-00539222": "and uh also particular to dr mira for uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02491-00539223-00539391": "moderating the discussion and doing a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02492-00539392-00539575": "great job getting to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02493-00539576-00539766": "many of the questions that were in the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02494-00539767-00539991": "chat room and also thanks to all the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02495-00539992-00540287": "participants and the questions", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02496-00540288-00540551": "as dr meyers indicated the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02497-00540552-00540831": "feedback we're getting so far is that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02498-00540832-00541055": "people did really enjoy the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02499-00541056-00541303": "presentations learned a lot", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02500-00541304-00541470": "about", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02501-00541471-00541647": "global surgery and some of the", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02502-00541648-00541807": "challenges that have been brought up by", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02503-00541808-00542166": "the speakers so we'd just like to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02504-00542167-00542414": "reiterate uh our thanks", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02505-00542415-00542631": "and uh thanks to", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02506-00542632-00542839": "the center for bioethics", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02507-00542840-00543095": "and their staff uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02508-00543096-00543222": "ashley", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02509-00543223-00543691": "helen kyle for their work in making this", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02510-00543692-00543847": "technologically", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02511-00543848-00544118": "uh work and uh", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02512-00544119-00544311": "for um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02513-00544312-00544551": "helping us learn how to manage the q a", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02514-00544552-00544766": "we we couldn't have done it", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02515-00544767-00545079": "without uh without you so", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02516-00545080-00545207": "um", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02517-00545208-00545439": "to all the participants we look forward", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02518-00545440-00545703": "to hopefully seeing you next week", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02519-00545704-00545983": "um on monday we will have", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02520-00545984-00546270": "our session will be ethical issues in", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02521-00546271-00546599": "gender surgery and the moderator of that", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02522-00546600-00546822": "session will be christine mitchell who", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02523-00546823-00547007": "is the executive director of the center", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02524-00547008-00547287": "for bioethics so we hope to see you all", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02525-00547288-00547366": "here", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02526-00547367-00547487": "next week", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02527-00547488-00547831": "and godspeed", "iq8PQRAaR7U-02528-00547832-00548156": "good night"}}, {"audio_id": "iqqbWg96-jk", "text": {"iqqbWg96-jk-00000-00000000-00001170": "[Music]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00001-00001171-00001337": "thank you", "iqqbWg96-jk-00002-00001338-00001451": "everybody", "iqqbWg96-jk-00003-00001452-00002071": "[Music]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00004-00002072-00002465": "for this historic event staff and we", "iqqbWg96-jk-00005-00002466-00002950": "could help support votes", "iqqbWg96-jk-00006-00002951-00003208": "and just so you know", "iqqbWg96-jk-00007-00003209-00003604": "Rainier beats Vikings", "iqqbWg96-jk-00008-00003605-00003772": "if we could have your attention up here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00009-00003773-00003947": "at the front this is a historic moment", "iqqbWg96-jk-00010-00003947-00004049": "here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00011-00004050-00004283": "staff", "iqqbWg96-jk-00012-00004284-00004486": "students", "iqqbWg96-jk-00013-00004487-00004811": "Vikings", "iqqbWg96-jk-00014-00004812-00005356": "we are joined here today", "iqqbWg96-jk-00015-00005357-00005572": "by representatives from Seattle Public", "iqqbWg96-jk-00016-00005573-00005818": "Schools", "iqqbWg96-jk-00017-00005819-00006370": "and the planning and construction teams", "iqqbWg96-jk-00018-00006371-00006605": "that work to make this", "iqqbWg96-jk-00019-00006606-00006875": "this whole project", "iqqbWg96-jk-00020-00006876-00007084": "happened", "iqqbWg96-jk-00021-00007086-00007313": "this historic project that we've heard", "iqqbWg96-jk-00022-00007314-00007451": "about", "iqqbWg96-jk-00023-00007452-00007792": "in the assembly", "iqqbWg96-jk-00024-00007793-00008177": "so here today we have", "iqqbWg96-jk-00025-00008178-00008507": "Rainier Beach High School Legacy", "iqqbWg96-jk-00026-00008508-00008905": "basketball coach", "iqqbWg96-jk-00027-00008906-00009724": "Bethea if you give a round of applause", "iqqbWg96-jk-00028-00009725-00009905": "we also have", "iqqbWg96-jk-00029-00009906-00010163": "Rainier Beach High School alumni and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00030-00010164-00010403": "student Advocates that were at the", "iqqbWg96-jk-00031-00010404-00010577": "school board meetings", "iqqbWg96-jk-00032-00010578-00010883": "advocating for the school", "iqqbWg96-jk-00033-00010884-00011242": "Yen Rosario and Naja Ali if we could", "iqqbWg96-jk-00034-00011243-00011464": "give them a round of applause our alumni", "iqqbWg96-jk-00035-00011465-00011819": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00036-00011820-00012101": "and we can't forget about Alum or other", "iqqbWg96-jk-00037-00012102-00012388": "alumni they're the crew that helped to", "iqqbWg96-jk-00038-00012389-00012683": "make this happen and alumni and doing", "iqqbWg96-jk-00039-00012684-00012988": "great work at their universities and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00040-00012989-00013216": "soon to transition into career Pathways", "iqqbWg96-jk-00041-00013218-00013621": "so round of applause for that alumni", "iqqbWg96-jk-00042-00013622-00013943": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00043-00013944-00014458": "we've got our Legacy advocate", "iqqbWg96-jk-00044-00014459-00014699": "former School Board president", "iqqbWg96-jk-00045-00014700-00014891": "Miss Betty Patu who we heard from", "iqqbWg96-jk-00046-00014891-00015158": "earlier Round of Applause for her", "iqqbWg96-jk-00047-00015159-00015479": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00048-00015480-00015688": "we have my mentor", "iqqbWg96-jk-00049-00015690-00015919": "who I look up to in terms of leadership", "iqqbWg96-jk-00050-00015919-00016319": "our superintendent Mr Brent Jones", "iqqbWg96-jk-00051-00016319-00016807": "Dr Mr Reverend Brent Jones", "iqqbWg96-jk-00052-00016808-00017117": "my mentor", "iqqbWg96-jk-00053-00017118-00017297": "we have", "iqqbWg96-jk-00054-00017298-00017507": "capital projects and planning director", "iqqbWg96-jk-00055-00017508-00018130": "Mr Richard best", "iqqbWg96-jk-00056-00018131-00018550": "we have the seti architects", "iqqbWg96-jk-00057-00018551-00018736": "principal architect", "iqqbWg96-jk-00058-00018737-00019095": "Jordan kill", "iqqbWg96-jk-00059-00019096-00019241": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00060-00019242-00019535": "we have moody Nolan's architect", "iqqbWg96-jk-00061-00019536-00019793": "principal architect Earl Lee which by", "iqqbWg96-jk-00062-00019794-00020099": "the way is the largest black owned", "iqqbWg96-jk-00063-00020100-00020519": "architectural firm in the country here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00064-00020520-00020717": "Round of Applause", "iqqbWg96-jk-00065-00020718-00021005": "for Mr early", "iqqbWg96-jk-00066-00021006-00021317": "we also have parametrics project manager", "iqqbWg96-jk-00067-00021318-00021580": "we meet every Friday", "iqqbWg96-jk-00068-00021581-00021785": "morning", "iqqbWg96-jk-00069-00021786-00022403": "Paul Popovich", "iqqbWg96-jk-00070-00022404-00022775": "we have lidoc in project manager and an", "iqqbWg96-jk-00071-00022776-00023057": "excellent golfer I hear Mr Patrick", "iqqbWg96-jk-00072-00023058-00023328": "McLaughlin here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00073-00023329-00023903": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00074-00023904-00024094": "and very soon", "iqqbWg96-jk-00075-00024095-00024311": "you will see", "iqqbWg96-jk-00076-00024312-00024593": "the mayor of Seattle Mr Bruce Harrell", "iqqbWg96-jk-00077-00024594-00024808": "who is coming all the way across town to", "iqqbWg96-jk-00078-00024809-00024994": "come join us here so round of applause", "iqqbWg96-jk-00079-00024995-00025336": "for the mayor now", "iqqbWg96-jk-00080-00025337-00025583": "and Round of Applause when we see him", "iqqbWg96-jk-00081-00025584-00025889": "arrive", "iqqbWg96-jk-00082-00025889-00026194": "with that being said", "iqqbWg96-jk-00083-00026195-00026543": "I want to introduce", "iqqbWg96-jk-00084-00026544-00026735": "we have", "iqqbWg96-jk-00085-00026736-00027124": "Miss Rita green who we heard from strong", "iqqbWg96-jk-00086-00027125-00027293": "advocate for Rainier Beach and making", "iqqbWg96-jk-00087-00027294-00027473": "this happen specifically our IB program", "iqqbWg96-jk-00088-00027474-00028012": "it's Rita green", "iqqbWg96-jk-00089-00028013-00028577": "and alumni from the class of 2000 and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00090-00028577-00028889": "the class of 1980 Miss uh Rita green", "iqqbWg96-jk-00091-00028889-00028966": "here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00092-00028967-00029351": "[Laughter]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00093-00029352-00029723": "and we also have a Franklin graduate who", "iqqbWg96-jk-00094-00029724-00029914": "I just happened to see while I was", "iqqbWg96-jk-00095-00029916-00030120": "playing tennis at sewer Park", "iqqbWg96-jk-00096-00030122-00030337": "remember that", "iqqbWg96-jk-00097-00030338-00030820": "yep our uh County councilman uh gurmay", "iqqbWg96-jk-00098-00030822-00031205": "Round of Applause", "iqqbWg96-jk-00099-00031206-00031367": "we got some Heavy Hitters in the", "iqqbWg96-jk-00100-00031368-00031481": "building oh you saw these people Behind", "iqqbWg96-jk-00101-00031482-00031685": "These are Heavy Hitters right here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00102-00031686-00032002": "for our community and for you", "iqqbWg96-jk-00103-00032004-00032285": "and you all could be them one day and we", "iqqbWg96-jk-00104-00032286-00032524": "need you to be them one day in terms of", "iqqbWg96-jk-00105-00032525-00032831": "continuing to lead the community in this", "iqqbWg96-jk-00106-00032832-00033023": "work", "iqqbWg96-jk-00107-00033024-00033565": "with that being said", "iqqbWg96-jk-00108-00033566-00033821": "with that being said", "iqqbWg96-jk-00109-00033822-00034217": "I am going to", "iqqbWg96-jk-00110-00034218-00034439": "transition", "iqqbWg96-jk-00111-00034440-00034511": "um", "iqqbWg96-jk-00112-00034512-00034757": "to another introduction", "iqqbWg96-jk-00113-00034758-00035327": "of our district 7 School Board director", "iqqbWg96-jk-00114-00035328-00035501": "president", "iqqbWg96-jk-00115-00035502-00036082": "of our school board Mr Brandon Hersey", "iqqbWg96-jk-00116-00036083-00037402": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00117-00037403-00037649": "thank you principal Brooks and let me", "iqqbWg96-jk-00118-00037650-00037889": "just say that I am so excited to be here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00119-00037890-00038165": "because this is a critical step I am so", "iqqbWg96-jk-00120-00038166-00038333": "proud of the work that Rainer the", "iqqbWg96-jk-00121-00038334-00038596": "Rainier Beach Community has uh put into", "iqqbWg96-jk-00122-00038597-00038801": "arriving at this moment I would be", "iqqbWg96-jk-00123-00038802-00039040": "remiss if I did not recognize a couple", "iqqbWg96-jk-00124-00039041-00039274": "of my personal mentors former School", "iqqbWg96-jk-00125-00039275-00039473": "Board president in district 7 director", "iqqbWg96-jk-00126-00039474-00039823": "Miss Betty patue and Rita green", "iqqbWg96-jk-00127-00039824-00040012": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00128-00040013-00040277": "they have definitely shown me what power", "iqqbWg96-jk-00129-00040278-00040540": "can come from when leadership actually", "iqqbWg96-jk-00130-00040541-00040817": "responds and listens to community and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00131-00040818-00041123": "advocacy this is really what we can", "iqqbWg96-jk-00132-00041124-00041387": "count on in terms of ensuring that y'all", "iqqbWg96-jk-00133-00041388-00041596": "have the educational environments that", "iqqbWg96-jk-00134-00041597-00041830": "you need to thrive survive and to be", "iqqbWg96-jk-00135-00041831-00042040": "successful in whatever it is you want to", "iqqbWg96-jk-00136-00042041-00042167": "do in life", "iqqbWg96-jk-00137-00042168-00042401": "I look forward to this new school and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00138-00042402-00042568": "one of the things that I am really proud", "iqqbWg96-jk-00139-00042569-00042749": "to say is that this is going to be one", "iqqbWg96-jk-00140-00042750-00042917": "of the first projects in Seattle public", "iqqbWg96-jk-00141-00042918-00043121": "schools that is going to benefit from", "iqqbWg96-jk-00142-00043122-00043283": "the student Community Workforce", "iqqbWg96-jk-00143-00043284-00043583": "agreement that was reached between labor", "iqqbWg96-jk-00144-00043584-00043751": "and the Seattle public school district", "iqqbWg96-jk-00145-00043752-00044002": "let me tell you what that means that", "iqqbWg96-jk-00146-00044003-00044189": "means that all of the tax dollars that", "iqqbWg96-jk-00147-00044190-00044368": "are going in to build this beautiful new", "iqqbWg96-jk-00148-00044369-00044543": "building there is going to be an", "iqqbWg96-jk-00149-00044544-00044746": "opportunity for students their families", "iqqbWg96-jk-00150-00044747-00044951": "and members of this community right here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00151-00044952-00045221": "in Rainier Beach to get good union", "iqqbWg96-jk-00152-00045222-00045443": "paying jobs that are incredibly", "iqqbWg96-jk-00153-00045444-00045623": "important during the economic crisis", "iqqbWg96-jk-00154-00045624-00045808": "that our country are in and we want to", "iqqbWg96-jk-00155-00045809-00045971": "make sure that we are not just filling", "iqqbWg96-jk-00156-00045972-00046139": "your minds but we are also doing", "iqqbWg96-jk-00157-00046140-00046324": "everything we can to fill the pockets of", "iqqbWg96-jk-00158-00046325-00046529": "you and your families because we believe", "iqqbWg96-jk-00159-00046530-00046762": "that when you invest in community not", "iqqbWg96-jk-00160-00046763-00046973": "only in the forms of buildings but also", "iqqbWg96-jk-00161-00046974-00047189": "in financial and economic Liberation", "iqqbWg96-jk-00162-00047190-00047435": "that great things are possible so I just", "iqqbWg96-jk-00163-00047436-00047585": "want to say again thank you to everybody", "iqqbWg96-jk-00164-00047586-00047849": "who made this moment possible and I am", "iqqbWg96-jk-00165-00047850-00048005": "going to go ahead and pass it over to", "iqqbWg96-jk-00166-00048006-00048227": "another one of my mentors the a person", "iqqbWg96-jk-00167-00048228-00048358": "who really honestly needs no", "iqqbWg96-jk-00168-00048359-00048562": "introduction The Honorable doctor", "iqqbWg96-jk-00169-00048563-00048805": "superintendent Brent Jones", "iqqbWg96-jk-00170-00048806-00049471": "[Applause]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00171-00049472-00049840": "I can't read I can't agree more with uh", "iqqbWg96-jk-00172-00049841-00050062": "president Hersey what he said around how", "iqqbWg96-jk-00173-00050063-00050251": "the importance of this project", "iqqbWg96-jk-00174-00050252-00050543": "and I just want to just uh Express", "iqqbWg96-jk-00175-00050544-00050830": "gratitude to all of you who have come", "iqqbWg96-jk-00176-00050831-00051143": "together to make this project happen uh", "iqqbWg96-jk-00177-00051144-00051275": "we know that this just didn't happen", "iqqbWg96-jk-00178-00051276-00051437": "overnight we know that this has been", "iqqbWg96-jk-00179-00051438-00051773": "many years of advocacy of heavy lifting", "iqqbWg96-jk-00180-00051774-00052001": "of showing up at board meetings and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00181-00052002-00052211": "showing up in Council meetings and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00182-00052212-00052396": "showing up in places to really make sure", "iqqbWg96-jk-00183-00052397-00052654": "that this endeavor is going to be", "iqqbWg96-jk-00184-00052655-00052859": "manifested so I just really appreciate", "iqqbWg96-jk-00185-00052860-00053165": "everyone involved uh I want to give a", "iqqbWg96-jk-00186-00053166-00053411": "special shout out to uh one of the first", "iqqbWg96-jk-00187-00053412-00053615": "ladies of Rainier Beach uh Miss Betty", "iqqbWg96-jk-00188-00053616-00053980": "patu uh who has been on the Forefront of", "iqqbWg96-jk-00189-00053982-00054226": "this I'd like to also just thank all of", "iqqbWg96-jk-00190-00054227-00054461": "the people uh Rainier Beach graduates", "iqqbWg96-jk-00191-00054462-00054713": "and alums who have been advocating for", "iqqbWg96-jk-00192-00054714-00054916": "this project as we go forward", "iqqbWg96-jk-00193-00054917-00055265": "so in order to do this we rely on uh", "iqqbWg96-jk-00194-00055266-00055492": "voter approved funds and one of the", "iqqbWg96-jk-00195-00055494-00055654": "voters approved funds is called the", "iqqbWg96-jk-00196-00055655-00055853": "building Excellence fund and this is", "iqqbWg96-jk-00197-00055854-00056087": "also known as the Bex Levy so the city", "iqqbWg96-jk-00198-00056088-00056350": "of Seattle the residents of Seattle have", "iqqbWg96-jk-00199-00056351-00056537": "paid tax money to make sure that this", "iqqbWg96-jk-00200-00056538-00056765": "happens and so this isn't just a Rainier", "iqqbWg96-jk-00201-00056766-00056944": "Beach Community project this is a", "iqqbWg96-jk-00202-00056945-00057173": "city-wide project that our city can be", "iqqbWg96-jk-00203-00057174-00057550": "proud of moving forward so uh so", "iqqbWg96-jk-00204-00057551-00057749": "together we are making this happen this", "iqqbWg96-jk-00205-00057750-00057965": "is a a proud moment for us to really", "iqqbWg96-jk-00206-00057966-00058288": "show uh our city what it's like to have", "iqqbWg96-jk-00207-00058289-00058547": "a a green building a building that's", "iqqbWg96-jk-00208-00058548-00058769": "innovated a building that is really", "iqqbWg96-jk-00209-00058770-00059003": "going to be one of the beacons of uh", "iqqbWg96-jk-00210-00059004-00059285": "Pride for us for this city so I just", "iqqbWg96-jk-00211-00059286-00059441": "like to encourage our students to be", "iqqbWg96-jk-00212-00059441-00059675": "invested in understanding the process", "iqqbWg96-jk-00213-00059676-00059921": "for how we got here how the how the", "iqqbWg96-jk-00214-00059922-00060244": "wheels of a power turn how politics work", "iqqbWg96-jk-00215-00060245-00060461": "so if you have a if anybody's out there", "iqqbWg96-jk-00216-00060462-00060700": "that's doing a civics class uh teachers", "iqqbWg96-jk-00217-00060701-00060911": "give give your students an opportunity", "iqqbWg96-jk-00218-00060912-00061175": "to kind of understand how this how this", "iqqbWg96-jk-00219-00061176-00061403": "worked out because you all as students", "iqqbWg96-jk-00220-00061404-00061625": "uh are going to be the ones who are", "iqqbWg96-jk-00221-00061626-00061780": "going to be the beneficiaries of this", "iqqbWg96-jk-00222-00061782-00061966": "you all will be leaders going forward", "iqqbWg96-jk-00223-00061967-00062194": "and in these type of Endeavors and so", "iqqbWg96-jk-00224-00062195-00062357": "again I just want to say thank you to", "iqqbWg96-jk-00225-00062358-00062573": "everyone involved with uh this project", "iqqbWg96-jk-00226-00062574-00062885": "and uh now what we're going to do is", "iqqbWg96-jk-00227-00062886-00063107": "we're going to turn some dirt thank you", "iqqbWg96-jk-00228-00063108-00063335": "very much", "iqqbWg96-jk-00229-00063336-00063647": "so we're all gonna", "iqqbWg96-jk-00230-00063648-00063875": "so let's go and uh grab shovels and", "iqqbWg96-jk-00231-00063876-00064097": "we're going to uh do some uh dirt", "iqqbWg96-jk-00232-00064098-00064247": "turning right here", "iqqbWg96-jk-00233-00064248-00064371": "foreign", "iqqbWg96-jk-00234-00064372-00067115": "[Music]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00235-00067116-00067600": "cameras", "iqqbWg96-jk-00236-00067601-00071023": "[Music]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00237-00071024-00071251": "thank you", "iqqbWg96-jk-00238-00071252-00072766": "[Music]", "iqqbWg96-jk-00239-00072767-00073685": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "iqHdkQvbAmI", "text": {"iqHdkQvbAmI-00000-00000000-00000305": "two things are infinite the universe and", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00001-00000306-00000593": "human stupidity and I'm not sure about", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00002-00000594-00000941": "the universe life is like riding a", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00003-00000942-00001223": "bicycle to keep your balance you must", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00004-00001224-00001565": "keep moving two things are infinite the", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00005-00001566-00001876": "universe and human stupidity and I'm not", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00006-00001877-00002201": "sure about the universe life is like", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00007-00002202-00002513": "riding a bicycle to keep your balance", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00008-00002514-00002776": "you must keep moving two things are", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00009-00002777-00002975": "infinite the universe and human", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00010-00002976-00003263": "stupidity and I'm not sure about the", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00011-00003264-00003545": "universe it has become appallingly", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00012-00003546-00003790": "obvious that our technology has exceeded", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00013-00003792-00004103": "our Humanity two things are infinite the", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00014-00004104-00004397": "universe and human stupidity and I'm not", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00015-00004398-00004685": "sure about the universe it has become", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00016-00004686-00004919": "appallingly obvious that our technology", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00017-00004920-00005219": "has exceeded our Humanity logic will get", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00018-00005220-00005561": "you from A to Z imagination will get you", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00019-00005562-00005885": "everywhere education is not the learning", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00020-00005886-00006167": "of facts it's rather the training of the", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00021-00006168-00006478": "mind to think logic will get you from A", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00022-00006479-00006834": "to Z imagination will get you everywhere", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00023-00006836-00007127": "education is not the learning of facts", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00024-00007128-00007396": "it's rather the training of the mind to", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00025-00007397-00007696": "think a ship is always safe at Shore but", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00026-00007697-00008009": "that is not what it's built for a person", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00027-00008009-00008255": "who never made a mistake never tried", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00028-00008256-00008542": "anything new a ship is always safe at", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00029-00008543-00008764": "Shore but that is not what it's built", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00030-00008765-00009071": "for a person who never made a mistake", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00031-00009072-00009287": "never tried anything new", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00032-00009288-00009467": "if you want your children to be", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00033-00009468-00009809": "intelligent read them fairy tales if you", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00034-00009810-00010049": "want them to be more intelligent read", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00035-00010050-00010264": "them more fairy tales", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00036-00010265-00010463": "Albert Einstein", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00037-00010464-00010687": "logic will get you from A to Z", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00038-00010688-00011003": "imagination will get you everywhere", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00039-00011004-00011356": "Albert Einstein life is like riding a", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00040-00011357-00011656": "bicycle to keep your balance you must", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00041-00011657-00011788": "keep moving", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00042-00011789-00012005": "Albert Einstein", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00043-00012006-00012227": "I speak to everyone in the same way", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00044-00012228-00012473": "whether he is the garbage man or the", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00045-00012474-00012683": "president of the University", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00046-00012684-00013049": "Albert Einstein life is like riding a", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00047-00013050-00013343": "bicycle to keep your balance you must", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00048-00013344-00013480": "keep moving", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00049-00013481-00013703": "Albert Einstein", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00050-00013704-00013888": "if you want your children to be", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00051-00013890-00014230": "intelligent read them fairy tales if you", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00052-00014231-00014477": "want them to be more intelligent read", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00053-00014478-00014686": "them more fairy tales", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00054-00014687-00014897": "Albert Einstein", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00055-00014897-00015133": "logic will get you from A to Z", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00056-00015134-00015430": "imagination will get you everywhere", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00057-00015431-00015803": "Albert Einstein life is like riding a", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00058-00015804-00016097": "bicycle to keep your balance you must", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00059-00016097-00016222": "keep moving", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00060-00016223-00016499": "Albert Einstein", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00061-00016500-00016739": "when you're courting a nice girl an hour", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00062-00016740-00017021": "seems like a second when you sit on a", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00063-00017022-00017249": "red hot Center a second seems like an", "iqHdkQvbAmI-00064-00017250-00017636": "hour that's relativity"}}, {"audio_id": "iqLW0lXWLm0", "text": {"iqLW0lXWLm0-00000-00000006-00000337": "foreign", "iqLW0lXWLm0-00001-00000338-00011521": "[Music]", "iqLW0lXWLm0-00002-00011522-00011891": "thank you foreign", "iqLW0lXWLm0-00003-00011892-00012192": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "iqPJfjGcFd8", "text": {"iqPJfjGcFd8-00000-00000155-00000553": "we review AP Calculus sample tests we", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00001-00000554-00000991": "will start with limits and continuity we", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00002-00000992-00001361": "are given this question which is find", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00003-00001362-00001732": "the limit of X cosecant X when X", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00004-00001734-00001973": "approaches zero right away when you see", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00005-00001973-00002270": "close second no it's not the basic three", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00006-00002271-00002659": "trigonometric functions we think to help", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00007-00002660-00003590": "ourself by converting cosecant x to fine", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00008-00003590-00004118": "so we'll be x times cosecant will be 1", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00009-00004119-00004963": "over sine X under the same limit a limit", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00010-00004964-00005297": "when X approaches zero and x times 1 is", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00011-00005298-00006517": "x over sine X if we start to substitute", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00012-00006518-00007127": "with 0 for x equals 0 so 0 over sine of", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00013-00007128-00007703": "0 which is 0 sine of 0 is 0 and if you", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00014-00007704-00008010": "see 0 over 0 or infinity over infinity", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00015-00008011-00008498": "reject this way reject the answer so we", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00016-00008499-00008687": "need to find the limits using different", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00017-00008688-00009014": "way to find the limit using different", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00018-00009015-00009596": "way we use Lobito formula which is if we", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00019-00009597-00009884": "are given limit of rational function", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00020-00009885-00010246": "consists of nominator f of X over", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00021-00010247-00010880": "general G of X when X approaches 0 what", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00022-00010881-00011278": "we could do is to find the derivative of", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00023-00011279-00011838": "numerator divided by the derivative of", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00024-00011839-00012370": "denominator under the same limit limit", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00025-00012371-00012602": "One X approaches or we could continue do", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00026-00012603-00012734": "that even find the second derivative", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00027-00012735-00013069": "over the second root for this question", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00028-00013070-00013319": "we need only the first derivative let's", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00029-00013319-00013385": "do that", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00030-00013386-00013610": "so the derivative of X as you know would", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00031-00013611-00013979": "be one so we'll be limit of X approaches", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00032-00013980-00014297": "when X approaches zero of derivative of", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00033-00014297-00014772": "X is one over derivative of sine X is", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00034-00014774-00015287": "cosine X now it's easy to substitute for", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00035-00015288-00015887": "X equal zero so we'll be 1 over cosine 0", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00036-00015888-00016421": "and as you know cosine 0 is 1 so 1 over", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00037-00016422-00016799": "1 equals 1 this is the answer of this", "iqPJfjGcFd8-00038-00016800-00017006": "question"}}, {"audio_id": "iqR-9cIiqSk", "text": {"iqR-9cIiqSk-00000-00000000-00000199": "this is travis travis thanks so much for", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00001-00000200-00000415": "calling the mark casio how you doing", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00002-00000416-00000551": "good how are you doing mark i'm good man", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00003-00000552-00000671": "what's up travis what'd you want to say", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00004-00000672-00000919": "on this whatever you want wednesday", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00005-00000919-00001087": "hey just wanted to say i love the show", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00006-00001088-00001287": "listen a long time first time calling in", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00007-00001288-00001574": "oh thanks so much i appreciate that hey", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00008-00001575-00001687": "i wanted to bring up", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00009-00001688-00002023": "so um i was raised around guns um the", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00010-00002023-00002191": "whole gun control issue is", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00011-00002192-00002495": "is a joke first off the people that", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00012-00002496-00002767": "shouldn't have the guns are not going to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00013-00002768-00002902": "gun shows and going through legal", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00014-00002903-00003039": "channels getting them i think we all", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00015-00003040-00003263": "know that absolutely yeah", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00016-00003264-00003559": "but for me i'm an amputee so like i said", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00017-00003560-00003703": "i was raised around guns i was taught", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00018-00003704-00003799": "they're not toys", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00019-00003800-00004086": "you know so i was always into guns", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00020-00004087-00004199": "before but", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00021-00004200-00004383": "since i lost my arm i can't defend", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00022-00004384-00004567": "myself i can't fight like i used to be", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00023-00004568-00004670": "able to fight so", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00024-00004671-00004919": "now it's a necessity for me and as they", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00025-00004920-00005047": "take that away they're taking", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00026-00005048-00005422": "away more of my right to uh be able to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00027-00005423-00005695": "defend myself and my family wait a", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00028-00005696-00005799": "minute you just so you", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00029-00005800-00006118": "which arm uh which arm did you lose it", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00030-00006119-00006311": "was my right arm and i was right on", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00031-00006312-00006527": "right arm dominant okay so you had to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00032-00006528-00006710": "relearn everything with your left arm", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00033-00006711-00006846": "and now because you", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00034-00006847-00007087": "have one arm you're not able to defend", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00035-00007088-00007375": "yourself unless you have a gun", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00036-00007376-00007614": "correct not not like i was able to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00037-00007615-00007863": "defend myself before", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00038-00007864-00008023": "yeah no that's something i'll be honest", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00039-00008023-00008110": "with that's something i hadn't even", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00040-00008111-00008263": "thought of", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00041-00008264-00008407": "yeah and you know i'm sure there are a", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00042-00008408-00008574": "lot of people out there in my situation", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00043-00008575-00008663": "and i just", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00044-00008664-00008927": "you know i thought about a long time and", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00045-00008928-00008974": "it", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00046-00008975-00009255": "you know the people that are pushing to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00047-00009256-00009414": "ban the guns and get rid of the guns or", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00048-00009415-00009455": "push", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00049-00009456-00009814": "ridiculous uh gun tax you know", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00050-00009815-00010023": "they're not realizing the people that", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00051-00010024-00010174": "they're putting in situations like", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00052-00010175-00010238": "myself", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00053-00010239-00010471": "yeah i know no i bet hey let me travis", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00054-00010472-00010591": "that's a great point and there are a lot", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00055-00010592-00010742": "of people out there that that", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00056-00010743-00010919": "without guns would not be able to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00057-00010920-00011055": "protect themselves at", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00058-00011056-00011231": "all and if you take away guns or if you", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00059-00011232-00011431": "limit guns or tax guns like you said or", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00060-00011432-00011503": "tax", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00061-00011504-00011823": "ammunition then you put their lives", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00062-00011824-00012070": "in jeopardy uh because a gun may be the", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00063-00012071-00012191": "the difference between life and death", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00064-00012192-00012319": "for them and travis you definitely seem", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00065-00012320-00012406": "like one of those people", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00066-00012407-00012606": "let me ask you a personal question when", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00067-00012607-00012807": "you had to relearn how to shoot with", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00068-00012808-00012943": "your left hand", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00069-00012944-00013086": "how long did it take you to like you", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00070-00013087-00013375": "know be able to hit the target", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00071-00013376-00013694": "um it took me a while you know um", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00072-00013695-00014030": "because it was not only relearning to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00073-00014031-00014255": "handle the gun left-handed but to shoot", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00074-00014256-00014343": "because i", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00075-00014344-00014543": "shot all my life i was right at dominic", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00076-00014544-00014703": "so that's the trickier part", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00077-00014704-00015055": "oh the eye too yeah yeah so no it took", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00078-00015056-00015294": "me a while you know i mean probably", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00079-00015295-00015447": "you put it together you know a week i", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00080-00015447-00015615": "probably figured it out at the gun range", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00081-00015616-00015671": "i mean", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00082-00015672-00015958": "i was able to do it that day but to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00083-00015959-00016047": "consistently", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00084-00016047-00016286": "put a good spread together you know to", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00085-00016287-00016358": "where it was very", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00086-00016359-00016583": "controlled yeah did you have to let the", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00087-00016584-00016719": "people around you know that you", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00088-00016720-00016903": "you that you're a righty shooting lefty", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00089-00016904-00017007": "is that because i feel like that's", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00090-00017008-00017111": "something that i would want to know if", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00091-00017112-00017255": "somebody in the stall next to me was", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00092-00017256-00017319": "like", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00093-00017320-00017430": "learning how to shoot with their left", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00094-00017431-00017663": "hand for the first time in their lives", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00095-00017664-00017894": "well most of people first time i went", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00096-00017895-00017975": "out", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00097-00017976-00018191": "you know they all knew my situation but", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00098-00018192-00018294": "um", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00099-00018295-00018558": "yeah they every time i go out you know", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00100-00018559-00018694": "they they know what's going on", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00101-00018695-00018822": "they're taking a couple steps back i", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00102-00018823-00018975": "understand i understand well travis", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00103-00018976-00019039": "listen", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00104-00019040-00019158": "thanks so much for calling me we", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00105-00019159-00019294": "appreciate it and we're and you bring up", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00106-00019295-00019383": "a great point", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00107-00019384-00019511": "and we really appreciate you doing that", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00108-00019512-00019727": "as well oh ready shooting lefty everyone", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00109-00019728-00019830": "step back", "iqR-9cIiqSk-00110-00019831-00020287": "there we go oh good good grouping yeah"}}, {"audio_id": "iqUL0iRTw_y", "text": {"iqUL0iRTw_y-00000-00000003-00000169": "are you thinking about investing in real", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00001-00000170-00000413": "estate if so you should really consider", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00002-00000413-00000698": "doing so through a company rather than", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00003-00000699-00001073": "individually why one it provides asset", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00004-00001074-00001375": "protection two it provides privacy three", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00005-00001376-00001570": "it provides ease of management through", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00006-00001571-00001847": "the directors and also it's easier to", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00007-00001848-00002084": "have multiple owners of a company than", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00008-00002085-00002315": "it is directly owning the real estate", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00009-00002316-00002438": "selling if you want to bring on", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00010-00002439-00002591": "additional partners down the road rather", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00011-00002592-00002891": "than selling you know 25% of the real", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00012-00002892-00003158": "estate and having to record somebody on", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00013-00003159-00003563": "title is only 25% you can just sell 25%", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00014-00003564-00003754": "of the shares of the company this also", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00015-00003755-00004004": "has huge advantages when avoiding", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00016-00004004-00004166": "transfer taxes a lot of times if you", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00017-00004167-00004429": "transfer physical real estate you have", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00018-00004430-00004700": "to pay a transfer tax but mostly shares", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00019-00004701-00004949": "don't have such a transfer tax this is a", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00020-00004950-00005195": "common strategy used by successful real", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00021-00005196-00005441": "estate investors all over the world and", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00022-00005442-00005636": "rather became international corporate", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00023-00005637-00005870": "centered companies are fantastic", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00024-00005871-00006101": "entities for this they're very flexible", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00025-00006102-00006286": "you can buy real estate anywhere in the", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00026-00006287-00006434": "world there's ease of transfer of", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00027-00006434-00006752": "ownership internationally respected if", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00028-00006753-00006892": "you're interested in setting up a Rizzo", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00029-00006893-00007037": "kmac international corporate center", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00030-00007038-00007244": "company for your real estate investment", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00031-00007245-00007471": "give us a call or check us out at", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00032-00007472-00007929": "Esquire Group calm", "iqUL0iRTw_y-00033-00007930-00008136": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "ir_HaIG0hy0", "text": {"ir_HaIG0hy0-00000-00000044-00003095": "[Music]", "ir_HaIG0hy0-00001-00003096-00003879": "now white boys"}}, {"audio_id": "irMxpnpVISU", "text": {"irMxpnpVISU-00000-00001255-00004015": "um", "irMxpnpVISU-00001-00004015-00005511": "[Music]", "irMxpnpVISU-00002-00005512-00005686": "wait a minute", "irMxpnpVISU-00003-00005687-00008342": "who", "irMxpnpVISU-00004-00008343-00009663": "loud", "irMxpnpVISU-00005-00009664-00010927": "hey", "irMxpnpVISU-00006-00010928-00011167": "[Music]", "irMxpnpVISU-00007-00011168-00011799": "foreign", "irMxpnpVISU-00008-00011800-00012591": "[Music]", "irMxpnpVISU-00009-00012592-00014158": "d", "irMxpnpVISU-00010-00014159-00014384": "my"}}, {"audio_id": "irSZCpknyBg", "text": {"irSZCpknyBg-00000-00000016-00000375": "web 3.0 a fully decentralized internet", "irSZCpknyBg-00001-00000376-00000647": "built on the blockchain some say it is a", "irSZCpknyBg-00002-00000648-00000950": "far-fetched fantasy or even a scam", "irSZCpknyBg-00003-00000951-00001199": "for others it is the foundation of a new", "irSZCpknyBg-00004-00001200-00001447": "digital age that will unlock trillions", "irSZCpknyBg-00005-00001448-00001718": "of dollars in value i would say today no", "irSZCpknyBg-00006-00001719-00001902": "no one can support a billion users no", "irSZCpknyBg-00007-00001903-00002102": "chain no ecosystem this industry still", "irSZCpknyBg-00008-00002103-00002391": "has 10x potential lee jiang ceo at", "irSZCpknyBg-00009-00002392-00002615": "harmony believes that connecting all", "irSZCpknyBg-00010-00002616-00002863": "existing blockchains is the only path", "irSZCpknyBg-00011-00002864-00003118": "towards the internet of the future you", "irSZCpknyBg-00012-00003119-00003263": "should be able to move assets very", "irSZCpknyBg-00013-00003264-00003503": "easily from one chain to another chain", "irSZCpknyBg-00014-00003504-00003735": "with good prices with good uh with good", "irSZCpknyBg-00015-00003736-00004038": "rate rates and uh very fast how far are", "irSZCpknyBg-00016-00004039-00004270": "we from the creation of a decentralized", "irSZCpknyBg-00017-00004271-00004479": "internet and what would it take to", "irSZCpknyBg-00018-00004480-00004815": "onboard the first billion users on web3", "irSZCpknyBg-00019-00004816-00005054": "welcome to our latest coin telegraph", "irSZCpknyBg-00020-00005055-00005254": "interview", "irSZCpknyBg-00021-00005255-00005343": "so i would like to start the", "irSZCpknyBg-00022-00005344-00005583": "conversation with a provocative question", "irSZCpknyBg-00023-00005584-00005870": "one of the slogans of harmony is one", "irSZCpknyBg-00024-00005871-00006079": "chain to rule them all", "irSZCpknyBg-00025-00006080-00006279": "that seems to be quite in contradiction", "irSZCpknyBg-00026-00006280-00006503": "with the principles of interoperability", "irSZCpknyBg-00027-00006504-00006703": "and decentralization", "irSZCpknyBg-00028-00006704-00006910": "that should be at the foundation of the", "irSZCpknyBg-00029-00006911-00007206": "ideal of web3 so can you explain to us", "irSZCpknyBg-00030-00007208-00007455": "this discrepancy yeah actually i would", "irSZCpknyBg-00031-00007456-00007574": "like to first say that that's a", "irSZCpknyBg-00032-00007575-00007767": "community meme", "irSZCpknyBg-00033-00007768-00008023": "it's it's not a official project a", "irSZCpknyBg-00034-00008023-00008295": "slogan but uh because we're we have the", "irSZCpknyBg-00035-00008296-00008599": "token harmony one uh we actually have a", "irSZCpknyBg-00036-00008600-00008887": "lot of great uh taglines around the word", "irSZCpknyBg-00037-00008888-00009006": "one", "irSZCpknyBg-00038-00009007-00009223": "um and uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00039-00009224-00009423": "we don't say this as a as a project", "irSZCpknyBg-00040-00009424-00009623": "slogan but we do think that we're", "irSZCpknyBg-00041-00009624-00009919": "wanting to bridge all other chains to", "irSZCpknyBg-00042-00009920-00010095": "bridge", "irSZCpknyBg-00043-00010096-00010295": "whether it's ethereum bitcoin our", "irSZCpknyBg-00044-00010296-00010495": "ethereum bridge has been launched for", "irSZCpknyBg-00045-00010496-00010735": "the last year uh more than a year and", "irSZCpknyBg-00046-00010736-00010974": "that we've uh we have bridges to finance", "irSZCpknyBg-00047-00010975-00011183": "marching to terra to", "irSZCpknyBg-00048-00011184-00011438": "a few other projects as well and", "irSZCpknyBg-00049-00011439-00011663": "actually our goal is to bridge all the", "irSZCpknyBg-00050-00011664-00011983": "layer one block chains um", "irSZCpknyBg-00051-00011984-00012206": "with us so we're a layer one but we", "irSZCpknyBg-00052-00012207-00012383": "think that the future is uh is", "irSZCpknyBg-00053-00012384-00012495": "multi-chain", "irSZCpknyBg-00054-00012496-00012735": "right um and it's cross chain that", "irSZCpknyBg-00055-00012736-00012863": "you'll be you should be able to move", "irSZCpknyBg-00056-00012863-00013055": "assets very easily from one chain to", "irSZCpknyBg-00057-00013056-00013175": "another chain", "irSZCpknyBg-00058-00013176-00013415": "with good prices with good uh with good", "irSZCpknyBg-00059-00013416-00013711": "rates and uh very fast so now let's get", "irSZCpknyBg-00060-00013712-00013991": "into the plans of harmony for building", "irSZCpknyBg-00061-00013991-00014286": "web three so um in a blog post that i", "irSZCpknyBg-00062-00014287-00014551": "recently read you said that uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00063-00014552-00014735": "in 2026", "irSZCpknyBg-00064-00014736-00015030": "harmony is planning to become a unifying", "irSZCpknyBg-00065-00015031-00015319": "web 3 platform so can you expand a bit", "irSZCpknyBg-00066-00015319-00015535": "on this on this thought and tell us what", "irSZCpknyBg-00067-00015536-00015863": "you mean by a unifying web 3 platform", "irSZCpknyBg-00068-00015863-00016007": "i think looking forward for the next", "irSZCpknyBg-00069-00016008-00016271": "four years we still think that adoption", "irSZCpknyBg-00070-00016272-00016415": "blockchain adoption is really at one", "irSZCpknyBg-00071-00016416-00016583": "percent if you think about you know how", "irSZCpknyBg-00072-00016584-00016839": "many truly people are you custoding", "irSZCpknyBg-00073-00016840-00017055": "their own funds using", "irSZCpknyBg-00074-00017056-00017247": "their own wallets using blockchain every", "irSZCpknyBg-00075-00017248-00017319": "day", "irSZCpknyBg-00076-00017320-00017455": "less than one percent of the world's", "irSZCpknyBg-00077-00017456-00017694": "population i mean as a whole right and", "irSZCpknyBg-00078-00017695-00017783": "so", "irSZCpknyBg-00079-00017784-00017999": "and the next four years is really about", "irSZCpknyBg-00080-00018000-00018247": "continuing the journey of keep building", "irSZCpknyBg-00081-00018248-00018399": "the infrastructure keep building the", "irSZCpknyBg-00082-00018400-00018743": "ecosystem uh web3 is just the catch-all", "irSZCpknyBg-00083-00018744-00018886": "word for you know blockchain for", "irSZCpknyBg-00084-00018887-00019135": "decentralization for the idea that you", "irSZCpknyBg-00085-00019136-00019319": "own your own data and you own your own", "irSZCpknyBg-00086-00019320-00019647": "money um and so we want to be the", "irSZCpknyBg-00087-00019648-00019943": "platform that allows people to allows", "irSZCpknyBg-00088-00019944-00020191": "the next billion users to come into the", "irSZCpknyBg-00089-00020192-00020447": "space right i would say today no no one", "irSZCpknyBg-00090-00020448-00020647": "can support a billion users no chain no", "irSZCpknyBg-00091-00020648-00020775": "ecosystem", "irSZCpknyBg-00092-00020776-00021039": "but the it requires innovation on the", "irSZCpknyBg-00093-00021040-00021278": "technology level it requires bridging to", "irSZCpknyBg-00094-00021279-00021527": "other chains that we can keep making", "irSZCpknyBg-00095-00021528-00021814": "this uh infrastructure layer", "irSZCpknyBg-00096-00021815-00022119": "easy for whether it's nft games dallas", "irSZCpknyBg-00097-00022120-00022383": "to join in d5 all of the above that", "irSZCpknyBg-00098-00022384-00022583": "you've been hearing about which which we", "irSZCpknyBg-00099-00022584-00022735": "just called the metaverse", "irSZCpknyBg-00100-00022736-00023030": "all of that together so that that's the", "irSZCpknyBg-00101-00023031-00023358": "vision the unifying web3 platform is a", "irSZCpknyBg-00102-00023359-00023527": "platform that allows the next billion", "irSZCpknyBg-00103-00023528-00023814": "users to come into web3 so i guess that", "irSZCpknyBg-00104-00023815-00023983": "one of the main challenges facing", "irSZCpknyBg-00105-00023984-00024183": "blockchain technology nowadays is the", "irSZCpknyBg-00106-00024184-00024455": "so-called blockchain trilemma so the", "irSZCpknyBg-00107-00024456-00024727": "trilemma of scalability", "irSZCpknyBg-00108-00024728-00024999": "decentralization and security so each", "irSZCpknyBg-00109-00025000-00025286": "protocol comes up with its own solution", "irSZCpknyBg-00110-00025287-00025414": "for this uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00111-00025415-00025511": "problem", "irSZCpknyBg-00112-00025512-00025734": "what is the harmony solution for the", "irSZCpknyBg-00113-00025735-00025918": "blockchain trilemma", "irSZCpknyBg-00114-00025919-00026190": "yes so uh good great question and that's", "irSZCpknyBg-00115-00026191-00026343": "uh that's actually a key point because", "irSZCpknyBg-00116-00026344-00026590": "everyone has to choose certain uh design", "irSZCpknyBg-00117-00026591-00026831": "and trade-offs so what we've chosen is", "irSZCpknyBg-00118-00026832-00027158": "uh sharding and proof of stake", "irSZCpknyBg-00119-00027160-00027335": "so these are these are not new ideas by", "irSZCpknyBg-00120-00027336-00027543": "the way these are uh ideas that have", "irSZCpknyBg-00121-00027544-00027918": "been around the ethereum 2.0 design and", "irSZCpknyBg-00122-00027919-00028190": "community ever since i would say 2015", "irSZCpknyBg-00123-00028191-00028383": "2016 right so", "irSZCpknyBg-00124-00028383-00028495": "um", "irSZCpknyBg-00125-00028495-00028718": "what what we've done is put those the", "irSZCpknyBg-00126-00028719-00028958": "best research into production and", "irSZCpknyBg-00127-00028960-00029158": "actually launched uh the first started", "irSZCpknyBg-00128-00029160-00029318": "and proof of stake one of the first", "irSZCpknyBg-00129-00029319-00029527": "started proof of stake maintenance back", "irSZCpknyBg-00130-00029527-00029679": "in 2019", "irSZCpknyBg-00131-00029680-00029799": "and um", "irSZCpknyBg-00132-00029800-00030007": "it actually you know works really well", "irSZCpknyBg-00133-00030008-00030335": "because of those reasons and uh we'll", "irSZCpknyBg-00134-00030336-00030558": "continue to make it better so on our", "irSZCpknyBg-00135-00030560-00030743": "roadmap is you know things like", "irSZCpknyBg-00136-00030744-00030967": "cross-chart transactions even crosstalk", "irSZCpknyBg-00137-00030968-00031231": "smart contract so i would say that we're", "irSZCpknyBg-00138-00031232-00031311": "uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00139-00031312-00031551": "probably just you know", "irSZCpknyBg-00140-00031552-00031727": "even there's still a lot long story", "irSZCpknyBg-00141-00031727-00031918": "about sharding and proof of stake that", "irSZCpknyBg-00142-00031919-00032151": "we can continue to make it better", "irSZCpknyBg-00143-00032152-00032335": "and continue to allow the protocol to", "irSZCpknyBg-00144-00032336-00032511": "scale so that's interesting because it's", "irSZCpknyBg-00145-00032512-00032687": "widely known that", "irSZCpknyBg-00146-00032688-00033031": "the in the trilama basically forces uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00147-00033032-00033207": "protocols to", "irSZCpknyBg-00148-00033208-00033407": "sort of sacrifice one of these three", "irSZCpknyBg-00149-00033408-00033631": "components so either", "irSZCpknyBg-00150-00033632-00033823": "security or decentralization or", "irSZCpknyBg-00151-00033824-00034007": "scalability for the sake of the other", "irSZCpknyBg-00152-00034008-00034343": "two but in your opinion you can preserve", "irSZCpknyBg-00153-00034344-00034679": "all the three at the same high level and", "irSZCpknyBg-00154-00034680-00034983": "just expand the triangle is that correct", "irSZCpknyBg-00155-00034984-00035287": "exactly exactly we we expand the the", "irSZCpknyBg-00156-00035288-00035502": "relationship still exists between the", "irSZCpknyBg-00157-00035503-00035743": "three components right like they're", "irSZCpknyBg-00158-00035744-00035974": "they're all moving in relation but you", "irSZCpknyBg-00159-00035975-00036287": "can open you can expand the overall", "irSZCpknyBg-00160-00036288-00036383": "um", "irSZCpknyBg-00161-00036384-00036567": "as well like for example you know we", "irSZCpknyBg-00162-00036568-00036862": "have two second finality uh while that's", "irSZCpknyBg-00163-00036863-00037039": "that's that's almost the fastest in the", "irSZCpknyBg-00164-00037040-00037318": "industry but uh we did that without you", "irSZCpknyBg-00165-00037319-00037502": "know trading off on decentralization or", "irSZCpknyBg-00166-00037503-00037759": "security and so there are ways you can", "irSZCpknyBg-00167-00037760-00038079": "get even faster you know by by you know", "irSZCpknyBg-00168-00038080-00038327": "sacrificing some of the other factors so", "irSZCpknyBg-00169-00038328-00038535": "you could be sub one second uh if you", "irSZCpknyBg-00170-00038536-00038662": "choose to be more centralized i mean", "irSZCpknyBg-00171-00038663-00038807": "that's what that's what like let's say", "irSZCpknyBg-00172-00038808-00039183": "aws assists right so um", "irSZCpknyBg-00173-00039184-00039390": "so our goal has actually been pushing on", "irSZCpknyBg-00174-00039391-00039574": "all three at the same time through", "irSZCpknyBg-00175-00039575-00039911": "engineering and expanding all of it", "irSZCpknyBg-00176-00039912-00040102": "at the same time so now i would like to", "irSZCpknyBg-00177-00040103-00040367": "touch upon one of the core aspects of", "irSZCpknyBg-00178-00040368-00040567": "harmony strategy for web 3 which is", "irSZCpknyBg-00179-00040568-00040774": "based on daos or decentralized", "irSZCpknyBg-00180-00040775-00040990": "autonomous organization so", "irSZCpknyBg-00181-00040991-00041318": "you dedicated 50 million dollars out of", "irSZCpknyBg-00182-00041319-00041687": "a total 300 million dollar fund for", "irSZCpknyBg-00183-00041688-00041935": "funding a number of dows so can you tell", "irSZCpknyBg-00184-00041936-00042207": "us why dao's play such a crucial role in", "irSZCpknyBg-00185-00042208-00042535": "harmony strategy for web3 and um what", "irSZCpknyBg-00186-00042536-00042718": "kind of dowels", "irSZCpknyBg-00187-00042719-00042958": "are you funding at the moment", "irSZCpknyBg-00188-00042959-00043079": "so so", "irSZCpknyBg-00189-00043080-00043302": "essentially we think dallas will replace", "irSZCpknyBg-00190-00043303-00043455": "companies and", "irSZCpknyBg-00191-00043456-00043702": "in the future countries it's a way of", "irSZCpknyBg-00192-00043703-00043958": "organizing all human coordination and", "irSZCpknyBg-00193-00043959-00044143": "activity um", "irSZCpknyBg-00194-00044144-00044223": "so", "irSZCpknyBg-00195-00044224-00044367": "i think you know", "irSZCpknyBg-00196-00044368-00044615": "like think about countries and", "irSZCpknyBg-00197-00044616-00044823": "companies these are all entities that we", "irSZCpknyBg-00198-00044824-00045030": "humans invented designed in the first", "irSZCpknyBg-00199-00045031-00045230": "place right like why did we have llc's", "irSZCpknyBg-00200-00045231-00045511": "or you know corporations and there was", "irSZCpknyBg-00201-00045512-00045671": "the east dutch", "irSZCpknyBg-00202-00045672-00045879": "india india company like there are all", "irSZCpknyBg-00203-00045880-00046143": "these things that uh we basically made", "irSZCpknyBg-00204-00046144-00046390": "up to be honest and even countries right", "irSZCpknyBg-00205-00046391-00046590": "we made it up like someone won a war and", "irSZCpknyBg-00206-00046591-00046727": "it became a country", "irSZCpknyBg-00207-00046728-00047086": "and so um i think with web3 with the", "irSZCpknyBg-00208-00047087-00047215": "technology", "irSZCpknyBg-00209-00047216-00047471": "with coordination um that everyone can", "irSZCpknyBg-00210-00047472-00047686": "participate and there's a natural token", "irSZCpknyBg-00211-00047687-00047951": "incentive you can design any way of", "irSZCpknyBg-00212-00047952-00048174": "coordinating humanity and that's that's", "irSZCpknyBg-00213-00048175-00048479": "the future right um and and so", "irSZCpknyBg-00214-00048480-00048607": "people won't be starting companies", "irSZCpknyBg-00215-00048608-00048846": "anymore people will start douse uh and", "irSZCpknyBg-00216-00048847-00049039": "and so that's why we think that uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00217-00049040-00049215": "almost everything can be done and", "irSZCpknyBg-00218-00049216-00049607": "created via a dao um at some level uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00219-00049608-00049895": "nob uh as we as the world becomes even", "irSZCpknyBg-00220-00049896-00050015": "more global", "irSZCpknyBg-00221-00050016-00050271": "it's a much better tool than than an llc", "irSZCpknyBg-00222-00050272-00050495": "or corporation because those can't go", "irSZCpknyBg-00223-00050496-00050711": "across borders it's very difficult uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00224-00050712-00050927": "but dao's is global dials are everywhere", "irSZCpknyBg-00225-00050928-00051135": "dallas can provide incentives as soon as", "irSZCpknyBg-00226-00051136-00051375": "you join the medal uh it's just a much", "irSZCpknyBg-00227-00051376-00051511": "more flexible", "irSZCpknyBg-00228-00051512-00051614": "way of", "irSZCpknyBg-00229-00051615-00051814": "getting anything done okay so that's", "irSZCpknyBg-00230-00051815-00051990": "interesting so can you give us some", "irSZCpknyBg-00231-00051991-00052342": "concrete examples of what dao's are you", "irSZCpknyBg-00232-00052344-00052511": "involved in and", "irSZCpknyBg-00233-00052512-00052807": "basically what role they play in the", "irSZCpknyBg-00234-00052808-00053007": "harmonies ecosystem", "irSZCpknyBg-00235-00053008-00053087": "sure", "irSZCpknyBg-00236-00053088-00053335": "we have some core dials that are are", "irSZCpknyBg-00237-00053336-00053559": "community doubt or a validator dell uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00238-00053560-00053735": "community dial is just about growing the", "irSZCpknyBg-00239-00053736-00053991": "community so what's nice about that is", "irSZCpknyBg-00240-00053991-00054182": "instead of us trying to hire 10 more", "irSZCpknyBg-00241-00054183-00054382": "people on our team to try to you know", "irSZCpknyBg-00242-00054383-00054559": "coordinate and grow community and do", "irSZCpknyBg-00243-00054560-00054687": "social media like", "irSZCpknyBg-00244-00054688-00054959": "we have dowels that do all this uh work", "irSZCpknyBg-00245-00054960-00055199": "and you know it's it's much easier like", "irSZCpknyBg-00246-00055200-00055407": "there's no management overhead there's", "irSZCpknyBg-00247-00055408-00055479": "no", "irSZCpknyBg-00248-00055479-00055775": "uh like coordination with the sub team i", "irSZCpknyBg-00249-00055776-00055982": "mean they're independent organization", "irSZCpknyBg-00250-00055983-00056191": "that you know delivers on their", "irSZCpknyBg-00251-00056191-00056382": "milestones and they can be anywhere in", "irSZCpknyBg-00252-00056383-00056559": "the world uh it doesn't matter where", "irSZCpknyBg-00253-00056560-00056719": "they live right so we don't have to like", "irSZCpknyBg-00254-00056720-00056799": "get", "irSZCpknyBg-00255-00056800-00056935": "you know we don't have to right now if", "irSZCpknyBg-00256-00056936-00057071": "you have a company and you want to hire", "irSZCpknyBg-00257-00057072-00057230": "someone in another country you have to", "irSZCpknyBg-00258-00057232-00057407": "set up an entity in that country you", "irSZCpknyBg-00259-00057408-00057535": "have to set up a bank account in that", "irSZCpknyBg-00260-00057536-00057703": "country then you have to send money to", "irSZCpknyBg-00261-00057704-00057894": "the you know your entity in that country", "irSZCpknyBg-00262-00057895-00058111": "and then and then pay that person so", "irSZCpknyBg-00263-00058112-00058311": "blockchain changes all of that right you", "irSZCpknyBg-00264-00058312-00058479": "just anybody can", "irSZCpknyBg-00265-00058479-00058726": "raise their hand and start uh the dow", "irSZCpknyBg-00266-00058727-00058966": "can be set up in one day", "irSZCpknyBg-00267-00058967-00059135": "essentially it's a multi-state with you", "irSZCpknyBg-00268-00059136-00059423": "know nine people that that uh consent to", "irSZCpknyBg-00269-00059424-00059535": "being there", "irSZCpknyBg-00270-00059536-00059750": "and and they can start doing the work so", "irSZCpknyBg-00271-00059751-00060030": "that's how flexible it can be right so", "irSZCpknyBg-00272-00060032-00060311": "another dow that we we started with a", "irSZCpknyBg-00273-00060312-00060550": "good collaborator is the harmony africa", "irSZCpknyBg-00274-00060551-00060703": "dao", "irSZCpknyBg-00275-00060704-00060975": "and their their goal is to uh you know", "irSZCpknyBg-00276-00060976-00061191": "cultivate and educate developers in", "irSZCpknyBg-00277-00061191-00061303": "africa", "irSZCpknyBg-00278-00061304-00061519": "across different countries there's five", "irSZCpknyBg-00279-00061520-00061703": "countries that they're targeting", "irSZCpknyBg-00280-00061704-00061871": "if we tried to do that as our own team", "irSZCpknyBg-00281-00061872-00062047": "that would have taken six months to a", "irSZCpknyBg-00282-00062048-00062223": "year to start right again like all the", "irSZCpknyBg-00283-00062224-00062406": "entities all the countries all the local", "irSZCpknyBg-00284-00062407-00062606": "people but as a dow it took a few weeks", "irSZCpknyBg-00285-00062607-00062759": "to get you know everybody organized and", "irSZCpknyBg-00286-00062760-00062975": "then and then we started so that's", "irSZCpknyBg-00287-00062976-00063166": "that's the power so now i would like to", "irSZCpknyBg-00288-00063167-00063430": "go deeper into your vision of web 3 and", "irSZCpknyBg-00289-00063432-00063559": "in particular", "irSZCpknyBg-00290-00063560-00063726": "your vision of the interaction between", "irSZCpknyBg-00291-00063727-00063959": "layer 1 and layer 2 protocols so of", "irSZCpknyBg-00292-00063960-00064159": "course harmony is a layer 1 solution", "irSZCpknyBg-00293-00064160-00064399": "alternative to ethereum and you think", "irSZCpknyBg-00294-00064400-00064550": "that", "irSZCpknyBg-00295-00064551-00064759": "basically the capability of harmony to", "irSZCpknyBg-00296-00064760-00064950": "create this bridge to ethereum and the", "irSZCpknyBg-00297-00064951-00065182": "blockchain makes harmony a more", "irSZCpknyBg-00298-00065183-00065494": "attractive solution than layer 2", "irSZCpknyBg-00299-00065495-00065647": "protocols that seems to be in", "irSZCpknyBg-00300-00065648-00065894": "contradiction with what", "irSZCpknyBg-00301-00065895-00066126": "analysts at coinbase say", "irSZCpknyBg-00302-00066127-00066303": "so they believe that ethereum will", "irSZCpknyBg-00303-00066304-00066655": "remain the dominant layer one", "irSZCpknyBg-00304-00066656-00066919": "and that uh the culmination of layer two", "irSZCpknyBg-00305-00066920-00067223": "scaling solutions combined with upgrades", "irSZCpknyBg-00306-00067224-00067438": "like the beacon chain uh the beacon", "irSZCpknyBg-00307-00067439-00067631": "chain merge and sharding could limit", "irSZCpknyBg-00308-00067632-00067894": "progress for alternative layer ones in", "irSZCpknyBg-00309-00067895-00068111": "their current form so what do you think", "irSZCpknyBg-00310-00068112-00068406": "about this argument um the reason why we", "irSZCpknyBg-00311-00068407-00068647": "think we're we layer one", "irSZCpknyBg-00312-00068648-00068831": "like us a harmony with a bridge to", "irSZCpknyBg-00313-00068832-00069006": "ethereum is actually better", "irSZCpknyBg-00314-00069007-00069271": "because the our bridge is much faster uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00315-00069272-00069455": "you know you can transfer assets in two", "irSZCpknyBg-00316-00069456-00069638": "or three minutes versus layer two", "irSZCpknyBg-00317-00069639-00069726": "there's", "irSZCpknyBg-00318-00069727-00069911": "there's a seven day settlement time for", "irSZCpknyBg-00319-00069912-00070175": "optimistic layer two roll-ups so there", "irSZCpknyBg-00320-00070176-00070375": "there's a lot of different um", "irSZCpknyBg-00321-00070376-00070631": "features that like essentially you can", "irSZCpknyBg-00322-00070632-00070935": "use us as a scaling solution um and", "irSZCpknyBg-00323-00070936-00071119": "transfer assets in the same way they use", "irSZCpknyBg-00324-00071120-00071343": "layer two but the experience is better", "irSZCpknyBg-00325-00071344-00071550": "uh so so there's no i'm nothing against", "irSZCpknyBg-00326-00071551-00071791": "layer two i just think the design is", "irSZCpknyBg-00327-00071792-00071975": "having a parallel layer one that's", "irSZCpknyBg-00328-00071976-00072262": "connected um because we can also connect", "irSZCpknyBg-00329-00072263-00072479": "to bitcoin and cosmos and other layer", "irSZCpknyBg-00330-00072480-00072735": "ones right it's just more flexible", "irSZCpknyBg-00331-00072736-00072950": "versus just being over there too you can", "irSZCpknyBg-00332-00072951-00073103": "you're actually only in that layer too", "irSZCpknyBg-00333-00073104-00073223": "you can't even connect to other layer", "irSZCpknyBg-00334-00073224-00073343": "twos i mean it's hard you have to go", "irSZCpknyBg-00335-00073344-00073535": "back to ethereum and then go to a", "irSZCpknyBg-00336-00073536-00073735": "different layer too so", "irSZCpknyBg-00337-00073736-00073894": "so that's the reason why i think that", "irSZCpknyBg-00338-00073895-00074215": "layer one is a better design as a bridge", "irSZCpknyBg-00339-00074216-00074431": "um and actually we want ethereum to grow", "irSZCpknyBg-00340-00074432-00074726": "right so if if ethereum grows 10 times", "irSZCpknyBg-00341-00074727-00074919": "bigger hopefully we can get 10 times", "irSZCpknyBg-00342-00074920-00075111": "bigger along with it along with the", "irSZCpknyBg-00343-00075112-00075350": "entire industry so there's really", "irSZCpknyBg-00344-00075351-00075662": "no conflict um as long as we are in the", "irSZCpknyBg-00345-00075663-00075750": "right", "irSZCpknyBg-00346-00075751-00075926": "industry and as long as this industry", "irSZCpknyBg-00347-00075927-00076150": "still has 10x potential which i think it", "irSZCpknyBg-00348-00076151-00076231": "does", "irSZCpknyBg-00349-00076232-00076431": "uh hopefully in the next", "irSZCpknyBg-00350-00076432-00076591": "you know think about the market cap of", "irSZCpknyBg-00351-00076592-00076871": "all of cryptos about 2 trillion like it", "irSZCpknyBg-00352-00076872-00076967": "should be", "irSZCpknyBg-00353-00076968-00077215": "it could easily be 20 trillion in a few", "irSZCpknyBg-00354-00077216-00077311": "years", "irSZCpknyBg-00355-00077312-00077462": "yeah it seems that the trend is going in", "irSZCpknyBg-00356-00077463-00077647": "that direction so now i would look at", "irSZCpknyBg-00357-00077648-00077855": "just to clarify it's clear your position", "irSZCpknyBg-00358-00077856-00078071": "towards ethereum but what about your", "irSZCpknyBg-00359-00078072-00078255": "view on the competition among the", "irSZCpknyBg-00360-00078256-00078503": "different layer one", "irSZCpknyBg-00361-00078504-00078759": "solutions that are competing with each", "irSZCpknyBg-00362-00078760-00079038": "other like for example i was talking to", "irSZCpknyBg-00363-00079039-00079287": "the founder of nier another layer one", "irSZCpknyBg-00364-00079288-00079494": "protocol alternative to ethereum who", "irSZCpknyBg-00365-00079495-00079743": "seem to have a very similar vision uh to", "irSZCpknyBg-00366-00079744-00079950": "yours in terms of how he sees the", "irSZCpknyBg-00367-00079951-00080199": "development web 3 and specifically how", "irSZCpknyBg-00368-00080200-00080479": "he sees his own protocol uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00369-00080480-00080726": "the role he the role his protocol will", "irSZCpknyBg-00370-00080727-00080967": "play in this web three so this bridge", "irSZCpknyBg-00371-00080968-00081199": "connecting uh all different blockchains", "irSZCpknyBg-00372-00081200-00081279": "so", "irSZCpknyBg-00373-00081280-00081438": "i was wondering", "irSZCpknyBg-00374-00081439-00081623": "what do you think uh", "irSZCpknyBg-00375-00081624-00081887": "why why would we in the future need", "irSZCpknyBg-00376-00081888-00081999": "multiple", "irSZCpknyBg-00377-00082000-00082271": "layer ones why would we need", "irSZCpknyBg-00378-00082272-00082535": "a multitude of these bridges uh couldn't", "irSZCpknyBg-00379-00082536-00082726": "we just have one bridge that works very", "irSZCpknyBg-00380-00082727-00082935": "well i would say that", "irSZCpknyBg-00381-00082936-00083167": "these ecosystems can all grow and in", "irSZCpknyBg-00382-00083168-00083415": "fact um bridging to near is something", "irSZCpknyBg-00383-00083416-00083518": "that we", "irSZCpknyBg-00384-00083519-00083703": "we will do it's just a matter of time", "irSZCpknyBg-00385-00083704-00083879": "right whether they do it or we we do it", "irSZCpknyBg-00386-00083880-00084231": "or someone a new project does it uh it", "irSZCpknyBg-00387-00084232-00084431": "will be bridge and", "irSZCpknyBg-00388-00084432-00084567": "um i think", "irSZCpknyBg-00389-00084568-00084775": "that we will live in that multi-chain", "irSZCpknyBg-00390-00084776-00085047": "world where there will be a few there", "irSZCpknyBg-00391-00085048-00085191": "will be a few chains that will keep", "irSZCpknyBg-00392-00085192-00085311": "growing and keep growing and there'll be", "irSZCpknyBg-00393-00085312-00085471": "some others that are you know slightly", "irSZCpknyBg-00394-00085472-00085638": "smaller but still relevant like", "irSZCpknyBg-00395-00085639-00085911": "it it's a very fluid landscape it's not", "irSZCpknyBg-00396-00085912-00086135": "like oh there's there can be only and", "irSZCpknyBg-00397-00086136-00086350": "it's not and it's not um zero sum it's", "irSZCpknyBg-00398-00086351-00086631": "not like oh this one chain has all this", "irSZCpknyBg-00399-00086632-00086815": "and then this other chain doesn't like", "irSZCpknyBg-00400-00086816-00086982": "there will be there are if you see", "irSZCpknyBg-00401-00086983-00087159": "applications right they live on multiple", "irSZCpknyBg-00402-00087160-00087423": "chains now like sushi", "irSZCpknyBg-00403-00087424-00087599": "curve is on", "irSZCpknyBg-00404-00087600-00087815": "many a number of different chains and", "irSZCpknyBg-00405-00087816-00088015": "that's how that's how it'll be instead", "irSZCpknyBg-00406-00088016-00088191": "of uh and then there will be native", "irSZCpknyBg-00407-00088192-00088455": "projects on every chain so i think", "irSZCpknyBg-00408-00088456-00088582": "what's going to happen is each the", "irSZCpknyBg-00409-00088583-00088791": "blockchains that will um that will grow", "irSZCpknyBg-00410-00088792-00088959": "are the ones that are great at", "irSZCpknyBg-00411-00088960-00089231": "cultivating their native projects um so", "irSZCpknyBg-00412-00089232-00089487": "for us it's like let's say d5 kingdoms", "irSZCpknyBg-00413-00089488-00089687": "or tranquil these are some great", "irSZCpknyBg-00414-00089688-00089926": "projects on harmony that have hundreds", "irSZCpknyBg-00415-00089927-00090135": "of millions if not billions of dollars", "irSZCpknyBg-00416-00090136-00090335": "in value and traction so now let's talk", "irSZCpknyBg-00417-00090336-00090638": "about your visions for 2022 so we saw", "irSZCpknyBg-00418-00090639-00090847": "that harmony experienced a massive", "irSZCpknyBg-00419-00090848-00091135": "growth in 2021 together with other layer", "irSZCpknyBg-00420-00091136-00091391": "one protocols uh because", "irSZCpknyBg-00421-00091392-00091694": "of on the wave of this uh of this", "irSZCpknyBg-00422-00091695-00091903": "bull market that we that we witnessed", "irSZCpknyBg-00423-00091904-00092015": "last year", "irSZCpknyBg-00424-00092016-00092262": "so this year the picture is a little bit", "irSZCpknyBg-00425-00092263-00092462": "less optimistic we saw a huge drop in", "irSZCpknyBg-00426-00092463-00092679": "crypto prices not long ago so what do", "irSZCpknyBg-00427-00092680-00092982": "you think can harmony uh continue grow", "irSZCpknyBg-00428-00092983-00093399": "at the same pace even in a bear market", "irSZCpknyBg-00429-00093400-00093671": "i think um that's a good question i i", "irSZCpknyBg-00430-00093672-00093774": "hope so", "irSZCpknyBg-00431-00093775-00094006": "so i think obviously like bull market", "irSZCpknyBg-00432-00094007-00094271": "everyone gets excited and uh inevitably", "irSZCpknyBg-00433-00094272-00094543": "this this happened last time too in 2017", "irSZCpknyBg-00434-00094544-00094655": "like the", "irSZCpknyBg-00435-00094656-00094918": "ico cycle on ethereum it brought in a", "irSZCpknyBg-00436-00094919-00095111": "lot of people and and then some", "irSZCpknyBg-00437-00095112-00095303": "percentage let's say at that time", "irSZCpknyBg-00438-00095304-00095487": "probably only 20 of people stayed right", "irSZCpknyBg-00439-00095488-00095631": "because the bear market was really long", "irSZCpknyBg-00440-00095632-00095847": "and crypto winter was really long", "irSZCpknyBg-00441-00095848-00096087": "um i think now like the cycles are", "irSZCpknyBg-00442-00096088-00096255": "shorter like you go up and you go down", "irSZCpknyBg-00443-00096256-00096399": "you go up you go down like it's it's", "irSZCpknyBg-00444-00096400-00096526": "more compressed", "irSZCpknyBg-00445-00096527-00096606": "um", "irSZCpknyBg-00446-00096607-00096735": "so", "irSZCpknyBg-00447-00096736-00096918": "my only prediction like", "irSZCpknyBg-00448-00096919-00097126": "of course i have lots of theories about", "irSZCpknyBg-00449-00097127-00097415": "2022 and let's say more dowels more", "irSZCpknyBg-00450-00097416-00097718": "tools more builders but my but my only", "irSZCpknyBg-00451-00097719-00097887": "thing that i think is actually more", "irSZCpknyBg-00452-00097888-00098126": "talent will come into web3 this year", "irSZCpknyBg-00453-00098127-00098303": "like the best talent like we see it", "irSZCpknyBg-00454-00098304-00098567": "everywhere um honestly i get pinged", "irSZCpknyBg-00455-00098568-00098759": "every day by people who say hello i want", "irSZCpknyBg-00456-00098760-00098991": "to i want a career in this space i want", "irSZCpknyBg-00457-00098992-00099247": "to build something i'm doing a new", "irSZCpknyBg-00458-00099248-00099431": "project like we have so many friends who", "irSZCpknyBg-00459-00099432-00099582": "just who are just coming in like", "irSZCpknyBg-00460-00099583-00099782": "flooding in as final question i would", "irSZCpknyBg-00461-00099783-00099894": "like to know", "irSZCpknyBg-00462-00099895-00100079": "what should we expect from this talent", "irSZCpknyBg-00463-00100080-00100335": "that is coming into the space in 2022", "irSZCpknyBg-00464-00100336-00100543": "what are the milestones that we should", "irSZCpknyBg-00465-00100544-00100759": "look forward to happen in terms of the", "irSZCpknyBg-00466-00100760-00101047": "development of web 3 this year", "irSZCpknyBg-00467-00101048-00101255": "yeah i think in general my big my", "irSZCpknyBg-00468-00101256-00101343": "personal", "irSZCpknyBg-00469-00101344-00101471": "biggest hope is", "irSZCpknyBg-00470-00101472-00101791": "that web3 make the user interface a lot", "irSZCpknyBg-00471-00101792-00101894": "easier", "irSZCpknyBg-00472-00101895-00101974": "for", "irSZCpknyBg-00473-00101975-00102279": "the average user so that we can onboard", "irSZCpknyBg-00474-00102280-00102542": "like the next 100 million people", "irSZCpknyBg-00475-00102543-00102775": "right so that means that wallets should", "irSZCpknyBg-00476-00102776-00103006": "be better like all the tools i mean", "irSZCpknyBg-00477-00103007-00103327": "today if you want to swap tokens uh it's", "irSZCpknyBg-00478-00103328-00103471": "not necessarily that easy right you need", "irSZCpknyBg-00479-00103472-00103727": "to know how una swap or sushi works or", "irSZCpknyBg-00480-00103728-00103951": "and and where the tokens go and how long", "irSZCpknyBg-00481-00103952-00104206": "it takes a transaction you have to wait", "irSZCpknyBg-00482-00104207-00104439": "like all these should just be so", "irSZCpknyBg-00483-00104440-00104663": "abstracted that you can just buy some", "irSZCpknyBg-00484-00104664-00104847": "tokens on your wallet on your phone and", "irSZCpknyBg-00485-00104848-00105086": "then you can swap and you can trade like", "irSZCpknyBg-00486-00105088-00105286": "all of that is in the background so so i", "irSZCpknyBg-00487-00105288-00105495": "hope like as an industry we make the", "irSZCpknyBg-00488-00105496-00105719": "whole experience easier for like your", "irSZCpknyBg-00489-00105720-00106031": "mom or my parents you know whoever right", "irSZCpknyBg-00490-00106032-00106278": "like you're like the non-crypto people", "irSZCpknyBg-00491-00106279-00106463": "awesome thanks a lot lee if that was a", "irSZCpknyBg-00492-00106464-00106623": "great conversation thanks for coming on", "irSZCpknyBg-00493-00106624-00106734": "our show", "irSZCpknyBg-00494-00106735-00106910": "yeah thank you very much had a great", "irSZCpknyBg-00495-00106911-00107211": "time"}}, {"audio_id": "is3ajY5MxVA", "text": {"is3ajY5MxVA-00000-00000128-00000311": "hi i'm luke clever", "is3ajY5MxVA-00001-00000312-00000543": "it's been a year that i last recorded", "is3ajY5MxVA-00002-00000544-00000807": "youtube videos so i want to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00003-00000808-00001183": "continue that today's i want to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00004-00001184-00001511": "teach you about the line manipulation", "is3ajY5MxVA-00005-00001512-00001782": "so let's get right to it okay three", "is3ajY5MxVA-00006-00001784-00001839": "lines", "is3ajY5MxVA-00007-00001839-00002159": "this is the first line this is", "is3ajY5MxVA-00008-00002160-00002895": "the second line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00009-00002896-00003222": "so it's it is a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00010-00003223-00003495": "very simple text file just contains", "is3ajY5MxVA-00011-00003496-00003631": "three lines", "is3ajY5MxVA-00012-00003632-00003967": "so what i wanted to do", "is3ajY5MxVA-00013-00003968-00004167": "now is that i want the third line to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00014-00004168-00004351": "become the first line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00015-00004352-00004695": "or i know and the first line to become", "is3ajY5MxVA-00016-00004696-00004870": "the second line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00017-00004871-00005199": "so what i so what should i do in this", "is3ajY5MxVA-00018-00005200-00005438": "cases because i can't just get into", "is3ajY5MxVA-00019-00005439-00005518": "enter mode", "is3ajY5MxVA-00020-00005519-00005822": "and then you know uh", "is3ajY5MxVA-00021-00005823-00006175": "press ctrl control backspace that", "is3ajY5MxVA-00022-00006176-00006559": "doesn't really do it's not a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00023-00006559-00007119": "microsoft word or even emacs like that", "is3ajY5MxVA-00024-00007120-00007414": "so in room we have special mapping for", "is3ajY5MxVA-00025-00007415-00007463": "this", "is3ajY5MxVA-00026-00007464-00007814": "which is called d so if i press t", "is3ajY5MxVA-00027-00007815-00008239": "it should delete the line but it doesn't", "is3ajY5MxVA-00028-00008240-00008567": "you can see at the bottom right", "is3ajY5MxVA-00029-00008568-00008807": "that the d is kind of stuck in there it", "is3ajY5MxVA-00030-00008808-00008999": "doesn't do anything", "is3ajY5MxVA-00031-00009000-00009239": "so we can know that d by itself doesn't", "is3ajY5MxVA-00032-00009240-00009335": "do anything", "is3ajY5MxVA-00033-00009336-00009678": "but if i press d again", "is3ajY5MxVA-00034-00009679-00009999": "it deleted the whole line but", "is3ajY5MxVA-00035-00010000-00010295": "what you really do is that it puts this", "is3ajY5MxVA-00036-00010296-00010463": "line into a temporary", "is3ajY5MxVA-00037-00010464-00010774": "register so that later you can retrieve", "is3ajY5MxVA-00038-00010775-00011055": "it it's sort of like a clipboard in a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00039-00011056-00011199": "computer", "is3ajY5MxVA-00040-00011200-00011535": "that you copy that or", "is3ajY5MxVA-00041-00011536-00011863": "even cut the line so that you can you'll", "is3ajY5MxVA-00042-00011864-00011999": "be able to cop", "is3ajY5MxVA-00043-00012000-00012246": "you could be able to paste that line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00044-00012247-00012391": "into another program", "is3ajY5MxVA-00045-00012392-00012695": "so we must kind of do the same thing", "is3ajY5MxVA-00046-00012696-00012830": "within", "is3ajY5MxVA-00047-00012831-00013143": "uh whim itself so", "is3ajY5MxVA-00048-00013144-00013455": "but it doesn't paste how do i do paste", "is3ajY5MxVA-00049-00013456-00013743": "in in winden you might set you might ask", "is3ajY5MxVA-00050-00013744-00013775": "so", "is3ajY5MxVA-00051-00013776-00014015": "let's move to the first line you can", "is3ajY5MxVA-00052-00014016-00014199": "press gg", "is3ajY5MxVA-00053-00014200-00014415": "or in this case since it is a very", "is3ajY5MxVA-00054-00014416-00014599": "simple line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00055-00014600-00014871": "uh just contains very simple simple", "is3ajY5MxVA-00056-00014872-00014927": "lines", "is3ajY5MxVA-00057-00014928-00015255": "you can just press k okay so", "is3ajY5MxVA-00058-00015256-00015622": "now if i wanted to put", "is3ajY5MxVA-00059-00015623-00015943": "the line onto the first line i can", "is3ajY5MxVA-00060-00015944-00016327": "do a capital", "is3ajY5MxVA-00061-00016328-00016686": "p it should just", "is3ajY5MxVA-00062-00016687-00017158": "do the job perfectly but what about", "is3ajY5MxVA-00063-00017159-00017486": "uh lowercase p well", "is3ajY5MxVA-00064-00017487-00017814": "if i move to the second line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00065-00017815-00018047": "which is containing the lines that say", "is3ajY5MxVA-00066-00018048-00018199": "this is the first line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00067-00018200-00018535": "the lineup pretending is the first line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00068-00018536-00018943": "if we press p slower case p in this case", "is3ajY5MxVA-00069-00018944-00019214": "you can see the third line appear at the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00070-00019215-00019279": "bottom", "is3ajY5MxVA-00071-00019280-00019622": "of the second line so we have two third", "is3ajY5MxVA-00072-00019623-00019991": "line in this case", "is3ajY5MxVA-00073-00019992-00020303": "right so what control", "is3ajY5MxVA-00074-00020304-00020550": "what capital p do here is that it would", "is3ajY5MxVA-00075-00020551-00020614": "put", "is3ajY5MxVA-00076-00020615-00021078": "the line that in the temporary register", "is3ajY5MxVA-00077-00021079-00021478": "and paste it onto that", "is3ajY5MxVA-00078-00021479-00021830": "uh that the current line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00079-00021831-00022167": "what the lower p is that you do", "is3ajY5MxVA-00080-00022168-00022407": "opposite what the control the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00081-00022408-00022567": "capitalized p", "is3ajY5MxVA-00082-00022568-00022943": "d so it's very simple", "is3ajY5MxVA-00083-00022944-00023319": "in p at least in mapping p", "is3ajY5MxVA-00084-00023320-00023630": "it is they are doing the up they are", "is3ajY5MxVA-00085-00023631-00023791": "doing the same task", "is3ajY5MxVA-00086-00023792-00024183": "in opposite direction but in capital but", "is3ajY5MxVA-00087-00024184-00024430": "you might say what about capital t", "is3ajY5MxVA-00088-00024431-00024503": "capital d", "is3ajY5MxVA-00089-00024504-00024847": "i mean um capital d", "is3ajY5MxVA-00090-00024848-00025078": "quite surprising it doesn't behave like", "is3ajY5MxVA-00091-00025079-00025311": "p", "is3ajY5MxVA-00092-00025312-00025622": "let's say i do con dd", "is3ajY5MxVA-00093-00025623-00025943": "which is delete the line right", "is3ajY5MxVA-00094-00025944-00026327": "which is your lens uh just now but", "is3ajY5MxVA-00095-00026327-00026735": "if i do uh captivity", "is3ajY5MxVA-00096-00026736-00027046": "it do different things", "is3ajY5MxVA-00097-00027047-00027662": "what i do is that", "is3ajY5MxVA-00098-00027663-00028070": "it deletes the it deletes the character", "is3ajY5MxVA-00099-00028072-00028551": "onto the end of the line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00100-00028552-00028879": "so rather than explain to this", "is3ajY5MxVA-00101-00028880-00029167": "and like like this we can say that there", "is3ajY5MxVA-00102-00029168-00029311": "is a grammar", "is3ajY5MxVA-00103-00029312-00029687": "in whim at least in vim mappy", "is3ajY5MxVA-00104-00029688-00030014": "that d serve as a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00105-00030016-00030407": "verb and what follow it", "is3ajY5MxVA-00106-00030408-00030711": "is a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00107-00030712-00031031": "object what", "is3ajY5MxVA-00108-00031032-00031487": "action you want to apply to the object", "is3ajY5MxVA-00109-00031488-00031862": "so in this case d", "is3ajY5MxVA-00110-00031863-00032223": "by itself is not it doesn't have a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00111-00032224-00032343": "minute", "is3ajY5MxVA-00112-00032344-00032679": "it actually is a alias", "is3ajY5MxVA-00113-00032680-00033111": "to the dollar sign", "is3ajY5MxVA-00114-00033112-00033462": "she's doing the same thing same task", "is3ajY5MxVA-00115-00033463-00033799": "it's the same thing how about the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00116-00033800-00034111": "w which is quite", "is3ajY5MxVA-00117-00034112-00034407": "good because the last learn about w", "is3ajY5MxVA-00118-00034408-00034446": "which", "is3ajY5MxVA-00119-00034447-00034807": "is moving to each word", "is3ajY5MxVA-00120-00034808-00035207": "right to the to the start of the word", "is3ajY5MxVA-00121-00035208-00035583": "if i do the b it deletes", "is3ajY5MxVA-00122-00035584-00036030": "the uh the the word before this", "is3ajY5MxVA-00123-00036031-00036462": "at this word so it's you can combine it", "is3ajY5MxVA-00124-00036463-00037311": "with", "is3ajY5MxVA-00125-00037312-00037630": "let's say you have a parenthesis you can", "is3ajY5MxVA-00126-00037631-00038095": "do ba b", "is3ajY5MxVA-00127-00038096-00038487": "which is really really useful where a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00128-00038488-00038830": "s is is represented as a round", "is3ajY5MxVA-00129-00038831-00039143": "and b as bracket so if you do something", "is3ajY5MxVA-00130-00039144-00039302": "like", "is3ajY5MxVA-00131-00039303-00039662": "curry bracket can just do ea", "is3ajY5MxVA-00132-00039663-00040071": "curly bracket", "is3ajY5MxVA-00133-00040072-00040367": "this is fine this is powerful but let's", "is3ajY5MxVA-00134-00040368-00040439": "say", "is3ajY5MxVA-00135-00040440-00040683": "how about i say that there's two", "is3ajY5MxVA-00136-00040684-00040799": "commands", "is3ajY5MxVA-00137-00040800-00041102": "that do can do the same thing", "is3ajY5MxVA-00138-00041103-00041423": "they have the same logic the first one", "is3ajY5MxVA-00139-00041424-00041487": "is", "is3ajY5MxVA-00140-00041488-00041830": "c so let's say this i", "is3ajY5MxVA-00141-00041831-00042079": "suppose that this first the third line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00142-00042080-00042230": "is really stupid", "is3ajY5MxVA-00143-00042231-00042479": "because it repeats what the first line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00144-00042480-00042583": "at sad", "is3ajY5MxVA-00145-00042584-00042839": "so i want to delete it but i don't want", "is3ajY5MxVA-00146-00042840-00043030": "to simply delete it like this", "is3ajY5MxVA-00147-00043031-00043318": "i want to get into insert mode i don't", "is3ajY5MxVA-00148-00043319-00043511": "want to do something like dd", "is3ajY5MxVA-00149-00043512-00043862": "and then i", "is3ajY5MxVA-00150-00043863-00044215": "and then i want to then type uh", "is3ajY5MxVA-00151-00044216-00044574": "the dummy line and then", "is3ajY5MxVA-00152-00044575-00044951": "press enter that's lots of typing right", "is3ajY5MxVA-00153-00044952-00045279": "here", "is3ajY5MxVA-00154-00045280-00045583": "so why so we can do", "is3ajY5MxVA-00155-00045584-00046190": "something very short like cc", "is3ajY5MxVA-00156-00046191-00046567": "which is really great since i can get", "is3ajY5MxVA-00157-00046568-00046815": "into the insta mode so quick", "is3ajY5MxVA-00158-00046816-00047086": "that i don't think about it so let's say", "is3ajY5MxVA-00159-00047087-00047135": "i want", "is3ajY5MxVA-00160-00047136-00047683": "a this is a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00161-00047684-00047807": "dummy", "is3ajY5MxVA-00162-00047808-00048118": "which is great and you can apply the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00163-00048119-00048246": "same logic", "is3ajY5MxVA-00164-00048247-00048574": "you can apply uh", "is3ajY5MxVA-00165-00048575-00048886": "capital c which", "is3ajY5MxVA-00166-00048887-00049158": "deletes to character onto the end of the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00167-00049159-00049383": "line and then it enter into the instant", "is3ajY5MxVA-00168-00049384-00049495": "book", "is3ajY5MxVA-00169-00049496-00049830": "like just like the um the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00170-00049831-00050143": "dollar sign you can you can use the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00171-00050144-00050607": "dollar sign sorry the dollar sign which", "is3ajY5MxVA-00172-00050608-00050735": "is great", "is3ajY5MxVA-00173-00050736-00051046": "you can do the uh carrot", "is3ajY5MxVA-00174-00051047-00051358": "you delete to the start of the line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00175-00051359-00051623": "carrot is the start uh represent the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00176-00051624-00051726": "start of the blind", "is3ajY5MxVA-00177-00051727-00052070": "if or if you do", "is3ajY5MxVA-00178-00052071-00052487": "see to underscore", "is3ajY5MxVA-00179-00052488-00052782": "you're doing the same thing as not the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00180-00052783-00052991": "same thing as the dollar sign but they", "is3ajY5MxVA-00181-00052991-00053294": "operate similarly but if you have uh", "is3ajY5MxVA-00182-00053295-00053638": "trailing white white uh white space", "is3ajY5MxVA-00183-00053639-00053830": "you can you will see differences the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00184-00053832-00053950": "trailer", "is3ajY5MxVA-00185-00053951-00054382": "space doesn't been deleted but if you do", "is3ajY5MxVA-00186-00054383-00054703": "see", "is3ajY5MxVA-00187-00054704-00054950": "a dollar percent it deleted the whole", "is3ajY5MxVA-00188-00054951-00055063": "line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00189-00055064-00055335": "uh deleted until the end of the line not", "is3ajY5MxVA-00190-00055336-00055375": "just", "is3ajY5MxVA-00191-00055376-00056082": "the last non-white space character", "is3ajY5MxVA-00192-00056083-00056319": "so", "is3ajY5MxVA-00193-00056320-00056703": "and you can do another thing that is a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00194-00056704-00056999": "another command that is is a equivalent", "is3ajY5MxVA-00195-00057000-00057103": "of control c", "is3ajY5MxVA-00196-00057104-00057454": "another text editor which is yank", "is3ajY5MxVA-00197-00057455-00057791": "in we called it", "is3ajY5MxVA-00198-00057791-00058159": "why y is yank the whole line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00199-00058160-00058471": "so we can do paste", "is3ajY5MxVA-00200-00058472-00058838": "paste let's say", "is3ajY5MxVA-00201-00058839-00059119": "on the on the first line or under the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00202-00059120-00059287": "under the first line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00203-00059288-00059623": "but there's an exception for why is that", "is3ajY5MxVA-00204-00059624-00059935": "capital y doesn't behave like", "is3ajY5MxVA-00205-00059936-00060303": "what presented in d or c", "is3ajY5MxVA-00206-00060304-00060663": "you can immediately see if that it", "is3ajY5MxVA-00207-00060664-00060991": "it actually yanked the whole line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00208-00060991-00061279": "what it should be actually in this kind", "is3ajY5MxVA-00209-00061279-00061350": "of blockchain", "is3ajY5MxVA-00210-00061351-00061575": "is to yank until the end of the line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00211-00061576-00061823": "right but it doesn't just", "is3ajY5MxVA-00212-00061824-00062087": "yeah in the whole line you can see the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00213-00062088-00062166": "difference", "is3ajY5MxVA-00214-00062167-00062479": "in here", "is3ajY5MxVA-00215-00062479-00062911": "and if i do this it doesn't", "is3ajY5MxVA-00216-00062912-00063254": "even copy the special character of", "is3ajY5MxVA-00217-00063255-00063606": "black represent the end of the line so", "is3ajY5MxVA-00218-00063607-00064111": "it's a is it's a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00219-00064112-00064479": "conflicting logic in here and you need", "is3ajY5MxVA-00220-00064479-00064511": "to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00221-00064512-00064838": "get used to these to be frankly or you", "is3ajY5MxVA-00222-00064839-00064926": "can just", "is3ajY5MxVA-00223-00064927-00065471": "set um you can just map this", "is3ajY5MxVA-00224-00065472-00066182": "to these", "is3ajY5MxVA-00225-00066183-00067079": "like crazy", "is3ajY5MxVA-00226-00067080-00067479": "you can just map this into uh", "is3ajY5MxVA-00227-00067480-00067743": "it just can just force this behavior and", "is3ajY5MxVA-00228-00067744-00067799": "then", "is3ajY5MxVA-00229-00067800-00068111": "if you do why you just", "is3ajY5MxVA-00230-00068112-00068471": "do you just do the same logic as the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00231-00068472-00068831": "what d and c do so you can do the same", "is3ajY5MxVA-00232-00068832-00068863": "thing", "is3ajY5MxVA-00233-00068864-00069263": "like um let's say if i", "is3ajY5MxVA-00234-00069264-00069655": "hold the bracket in here", "is3ajY5MxVA-00235-00069656-00070063": "not break it parenthesis um y in b", "is3ajY5MxVA-00236-00070064-00070431": "it's only yank inside the parenthesis i", "is3ajY5MxVA-00237-00070432-00070799": "indicate um", "is3ajY5MxVA-00238-00070800-00071103": "what i just pressed is y i b", "is3ajY5MxVA-00239-00071104-00071423": "where i indicated inside y i", "is3ajY5MxVA-00240-00071424-00071743": "b it included", "is3ajY5MxVA-00241-00071744-00072094": "the parenthesis but y i b doesn't", "is3ajY5MxVA-00242-00072095-00072759": "so we can see the difference in here", "is3ajY5MxVA-00243-00072760-00073567": "you can see a difference in here by a b", "is3ajY5MxVA-00244-00073568-00074038": "that's the difference so", "is3ajY5MxVA-00245-00074039-00074375": "let's say you want to just you also want", "is3ajY5MxVA-00246-00074376-00074455": "to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00247-00074456-00074759": "delete a white space it's quite", "is3ajY5MxVA-00248-00074760-00075287": "frustrating that you want to enter", "is3ajY5MxVA-00249-00075288-00075582": "a and then delete that's not going to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00250-00075583-00075647": "work", "is3ajY5MxVA-00251-00075648-00075959": "you're going to press x for this case", "is3ajY5MxVA-00252-00075960-00076335": "which um which actually um", "is3ajY5MxVA-00253-00076336-00076703": "enter to the first and", "is3ajY5MxVA-00254-00076704-00077047": "it deletes the character whatever the", "is3ajY5MxVA-00255-00077048-00077447": "character is are under the cluster", "is3ajY5MxVA-00256-00077448-00077806": "or let's say i don't like", "is3ajY5MxVA-00257-00077807-00078111": "this d i don't like this d", "is3ajY5MxVA-00258-00078112-00078423": "at all but i also want to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00259-00078424-00078615": "get into insomnia so you don't want to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00260-00078616-00078759": "do something like a", "is3ajY5MxVA-00261-00078760-00079062": "and then delete that's", "is3ajY5MxVA-00262-00079063-00079367": "that's that's just awful", "is3ajY5MxVA-00263-00079368-00079623": "what you wanted to do is that you want", "is3ajY5MxVA-00264-00079624-00079694": "to", "is3ajY5MxVA-00265-00079695-00080031": "press s which delete the line and", "is3ajY5MxVA-00266-00080032-00080319": "lead you into the insert mode so we can", "is3ajY5MxVA-00267-00080320-00080423": "press", "is3ajY5MxVA-00268-00080424-00080855": "uh you can say this is a mummy line", "is3ajY5MxVA-00269-00080856-00081182": "which is sweet so i think that's", "is3ajY5MxVA-00270-00081183-00081503": "all for the line and manipulation in rim", "is3ajY5MxVA-00271-00081504-00081823": "so if you have a interested", "is3ajY5MxVA-00272-00081824-00082167": "in this you can explore in the rim help", "is3ajY5MxVA-00273-00082168-00082215": "file", "is3ajY5MxVA-00274-00082216-00082526": "you can just press help and", "is3ajY5MxVA-00275-00082527-00082775": "type whatever command that you wanted", "is3ajY5MxVA-00276-00082776-00082959": "you are interested in", "is3ajY5MxVA-00277-00082960-00083360": "so thank you for watching"}}, {"audio_id": "iso1iN4RsOQ", "text": {"iso1iN4RsOQ-00000-00000056-00000384": "thermal decomposition or thermal assess", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00001-00000385-00000651": "is a chemical decomposition caused by", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00002-00000652-00001004": "heat the decomposition temperature of a", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00003-00001005-00001202": "substance is the temperature at which", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00004-00001203-00001598": "the substance chemically decomposes the", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00005-00001599-00001902": "reaction is usually endothermic as heat", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00006-00001903-00002142": "is required to break chemical bonds in", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00007-00002143-00002510": "the compound undergoing decomposition if", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00008-00002511-00002802": "decomposition is sufficiently exothermic", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00009-00002803-00003075": "a positive feedback loop is created", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00010-00003076-00003309": "producing thermal runaway and possibly", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00011-00003310-00003938": "an explosion", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00012-00003939-00004542": "topic examples", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00013-00004543-00004881": "calcium carbonate limestone or chalk", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00014-00004882-00005179": "decomposes into calcium oxide and carbon", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00015-00005180-00005524": "dioxide when heated the chemical", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00016-00005525-00005695": "reaction is as follows", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00017-00005696-00006129": "calcium carbonate Cao plus co2 the", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00018-00006130-00006391": "reaction is used to make quicklime which", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00019-00006392-00006689": "is an industrially important product", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00020-00006690-00007009": "some oxides especially of weakly", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00021-00007009-00007278": "electropositive metals decompose when", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00022-00007279-00007542": "heated to high enough temperature a", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00023-00007543-00007788": "classical example is the decomposition", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00024-00007789-00008116": "of mercuric oxide to give oxygen and", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00025-00008117-00008473": "Mercury metal the reaction was used by", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00026-00008474-00008737": "Joseph Priestley to prepare samples of", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00027-00008738-00009124": "gaseous oxygen for the first time when", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00028-00009125-00009399": "water is heated to well over 2,000", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00029-00009400-00009694": "degrees Celsius a small percentage of it", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00030-00009695-00009937": "will decompose into au monde atomic", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00031-00009938-00010483": "oxygen monatomic hydrogen o 2 and h2 the", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00032-00010484-00010664": "compound with the highest known", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00033-00010665-00010918": "decomposition temperature is carbon", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00034-00010919-00011181": "monoxide at approximately equals three", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00035-00011182-00011383": "thousand eight hundred and seventy", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00036-00011384-00011659": "degrees Celsius approximately equals", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00037-00011660-00012410": "seven thousand degrees Fahrenheit", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00038-00012411-00012807": "topic decomposition of nitrates nitrites", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00039-00012808-00013394": "and ammonium compounds", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00040-00013394-00013697": "ammonium dichromate on heating yields", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00041-00013698-00014138": "nitrogen water and chromium 3 oxide", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00042-00014138-00014403": "ammonium nitrate on strong heating", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00043-00014404-00014813": "yields dinitrogen oxide laughing gas and", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00044-00014815-00015305": "water ammonium nitrite on heating yields", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00045-00015306-00015559": "nitrogen gas and water", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00046-00015560-00015881": "barium azide on heating yields barrier", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00047-00015882-00016156": "metal and nitrogen gas", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00048-00016157-00016497": "sodium nitrate on heating yields sodium", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00049-00016498-00016971": "nitrite and oxygen gas organic compounds", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00050-00016972-00017237": "like tertiary amines on heating undergo", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00051-00017238-00017502": "Hofmann elimination and yields secondary", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00052-00017503-00018190": "amines and alkenes", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00053-00018191-00018836": "topic ease of decomposition", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00054-00018837-00019075": "when metals are near the bottom of the", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00055-00019076-00019325": "reactivity series their compounds", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00056-00019326-00019541": "generally decompose easily at high", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00057-00019542-00019874": "temperatures this is because stronger", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00058-00019875-00020135": "bonds form between atoms towards the top", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00059-00020136-00020390": "of the reactivity series and strong", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00060-00020391-00020697": "bonds break less easily for example", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00061-00020698-00020927": "copper is near the bottom of the", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00062-00020928-00021203": "reactivity series and copper sulphate", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00063-00021204-00021472": "copper to sulphate begins to decompose", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00064-00021473-00021830": "at about 200 degrees Celsius increasing", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00065-00021831-00022072": "rapidly at higher temperatures to about", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00066-00022073-00022514": "560 degrees Celsius in contrast", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00067-00022515-00022715": "potassium is near the top of the", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00068-00022716-00023019": "reactivity series and potassium sulfate", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00069-00023020-00023386": "k2so4 does not decompose at its melting", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00070-00023387-00023830": "point of about 1069 degrees Celsius nor", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00071-00023831-00024163": "even at its boiling point", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00072-00024164-00024537": "you", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00073-00024538-00025132": "topic see you also", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00074-00025133-00025397": "Ellingham diagram", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00075-00025398-00025736": "thermochemical cycle thermal", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00076-00025737-00026224": "depolymerization chemical thermodynamics", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00077-00026225-00026527": "pyrolysis thermolysis of organic", "iso1iN4RsOQ-00078-00026529-00027005": "material gas generator"}}, {"audio_id": "isDmkMb_jFM", "text": {"isDmkMb_jFM-00000-00000058-00000518": "okay so on I'm Henry cronquist I'm team", "isDmkMb_jFM-00001-00000519-00000994": "leader for the team in DJ employment the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00002-00000996-00001249": "Commission dealing working with the URIs", "isDmkMb_jFM-00003-00001250-00001660": "portal and I'm baska woodruff i'm a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00004-00001661-00001934": "member of Henrik's team I'm an IT", "isDmkMb_jFM-00005-00001935-00002288": "project coordinator working on different", "isDmkMb_jFM-00006-00002289-00002629": "IT projects linked to the years portal", "isDmkMb_jFM-00007-00002630-00002972": "so we have quite a challenge now we have", "isDmkMb_jFM-00008-00002973-00003235": "ten minutes to present the vision of", "isDmkMb_jFM-00009-00003236-00003570": "your services we'll do our best and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00010-00003571-00003838": "nevertheless I will spend a few seconds", "isDmkMb_jFM-00011-00003839-00004204": "just to on what is yours for those of", "isDmkMb_jFM-00012-00004205-00004463": "you I haven't yet come across u.s.", "isDmkMb_jFM-00013-00004464-00004663": "perhaps it's a cooperative network", "isDmkMb_jFM-00014-00004664-00005029": "between public employment services and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00015-00005030-00005249": "partner organizations together with the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00016-00005250-00005516": "Commission it covers the whole of the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00017-00005517-00005847": "european economic area plus switzerland", "isDmkMb_jFM-00018-00005848-00006172": "altogether 32 countries it's there to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00019-00006173-00006478": "support mobility of workers and it does", "isDmkMb_jFM-00020-00006479-00006827": "it by providing placement job search job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00021-00006828-00007130": "matching services and information and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00022-00007131-00007577": "guidance services related to that it", "isDmkMb_jFM-00023-00007578-00007823": "consists of two main pillars it's a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00024-00007823-00008131": "human network of some 900 us advisers", "isDmkMb_jFM-00025-00008133-00008387": "working in these employment services who", "isDmkMb_jFM-00026-00008388-00008627": "provide support Europe seekers and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00027-00008628-00008814": "employers then they have more than", "isDmkMb_jFM-00028-00008815-00009077": "150,000 contacts per month with job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00029-00009078-00009305": "seekers and employers and then we have", "isDmkMb_jFM-00030-00009306-00009701": "the eServices pillar that we will look", "isDmkMb_jFM-00031-00009702-00009953": "at today it's the URIs portal URIs", "isDmkMb_jFM-00032-00009954-00010319": "Europa dot EU that sees more than 3", "isDmkMb_jFM-00033-00010320-00010577": "million visitors who run 3 million", "isDmkMb_jFM-00034-00010578-00010796": "visitors per month we have a million job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00035-00010797-00011099": "seekers registered with our CVS and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00036-00011100-00011483": "30,000 employers and thanks to this", "isDmkMb_jFM-00037-00011484-00011770": "exchange of job vacancies with the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00038-00011771-00011992": "employment services that we will talk", "isDmkMb_jFM-00039-00011993-00012256": "more about we we can display more than", "isDmkMb_jFM-00040-00012257-00012620": "one it's it's even 1.8 million job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00041-00012621-00012774": "vacancies today I think", "isDmkMb_jFM-00042-00012775-00013193": "so uris was it celebrates its 20th", "isDmkMb_jFM-00043-00013194-00013469": "anniversary next year so leaving the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00044-00013469-00013697": "teens means also that you have become", "isDmkMb_jFM-00045-00013697-00013901": "more mature and can take on new", "isDmkMb_jFM-00046-00013902-00014263": "challenges one of so we are reforming", "isDmkMb_jFM-00047-00014265-00014615": "the network and some of the issues to be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00048-00014616-00014816": "addressed is to increase the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00049-00014816-00015050": "transparency on the labor markets in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00050-00015051-00015291": "terms of vacant jobs and available", "isDmkMb_jFM-00051-00015293-00015581": "jobseekers and to improve the matching", "isDmkMb_jFM-00052-00015582-00015841": "kappa capability there are some other", "isDmkMb_jFM-00053-00015843-00016222": "things but we will focus on this and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00054-00016222-00016712": "uris loves esco and why do we love esco", "isDmkMb_jFM-00055-00016713-00016916": "it's because the vision for the earth", "isDmkMb_jFM-00056-00016917-00017137": "portal is to become the European", "isDmkMb_jFM-00057-00017138-00017372": "interoperability platform semantic", "isDmkMb_jFM-00058-00017373-00017561": "interoperability platform for both job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00059-00017562-00017944": "vacancies and in order to do that we", "isDmkMb_jFM-00060-00017945-00018185": "need this common language for occupation", "isDmkMb_jFM-00061-00018186-00018436": "skills and competences qualifications", "isDmkMb_jFM-00062-00018437-00018694": "but that is not all of course we also", "isDmkMb_jFM-00063-00018695-00019001": "need other standard formats so we are", "isDmkMb_jFM-00064-00019002-00019439": "working on true European HR XML standard", "isDmkMb_jFM-00065-00019440-00019880": "formats for vacancies and series that is", "isDmkMb_jFM-00066-00019881-00020186": "also need for some gentle force and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00067-00020187-00020459": "there is an obligation on the member", "isDmkMb_jFM-00068-00020460-00020669": "states already today to exchange", "isDmkMb_jFM-00069-00020670-00020935": "vacancies this will be slightly", "isDmkMb_jFM-00070-00020936-00021284": "increased and we will also obliged the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00071-00021285-00021464": "member states to set up national", "isDmkMb_jFM-00072-00021465-00021761": "interoperability platforms connected to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00073-00021762-00022060": "yours to make it possible for other", "isDmkMb_jFM-00074-00022061-00022294": "partners than the employment services of", "isDmkMb_jFM-00075-00022295-00022460": "private employment services and other", "isDmkMb_jFM-00076-00022461-00022778": "partners to participate in this exchange", "isDmkMb_jFM-00077-00022779-00023099": "the interoperability and now Pascal will", "isDmkMb_jFM-00078-00023100-00023531": "show this in practice so I will show you", "isDmkMb_jFM-00079-00023532-00023882": "how the eServices that we currently", "isDmkMb_jFM-00080-00023883-00024161": "provide to our users work and how they", "isDmkMb_jFM-00081-00024162-00024478": "will evolve towards the vision described", "isDmkMb_jFM-00082-00024479-00024844": "by Henrik so today we provide two main", "isDmkMb_jFM-00083-00024845-00025124": "eServices to our users through the years", "isDmkMb_jFM-00084-00025125-00025453": "portal the cv search and the job search", "isDmkMb_jFM-00085-00025454-00025741": "the CD search is fairly straightforward", "isDmkMb_jFM-00086-00025742-00025964": "job seekers can create", "isDmkMb_jFM-00087-00025964-00026279": "their CV online which is stored in a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00088-00026280-00026639": "database and can then be searched by", "isDmkMb_jFM-00089-00026639-00026824": "employers using the cv search", "isDmkMb_jFM-00090-00026825-00027161": "application to find jobseekers matching", "isDmkMb_jFM-00091-00027162-00027602": "their criteria esco is used in the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00092-00027602-00027811": "structure of the cv to express", "isDmkMb_jFM-00093-00027812-00028112": "occupations and skills of the job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00094-00028113-00028586": "seekers on the job vacancy side it's a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00095-00028587-00028783": "bit more complicated because we don't", "isDmkMb_jFM-00096-00028785-00029083": "provide we don't allow employers to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00097-00029085-00029327": "create their job vacancy on the URIs", "isDmkMb_jFM-00098-00029327-00029593": "portal directly they have to go through", "isDmkMb_jFM-00099-00029594-00029858": "one of the pest the public employment", "isDmkMb_jFM-00100-00029858-00030170": "services from our network and register", "isDmkMb_jFM-00101-00030170-00030506": "their job they can see there we then", "isDmkMb_jFM-00102-00030507-00030818": "retrieve the metadata from these job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00103-00030819-00031145": "vacancies into what is called an index", "isDmkMb_jFM-00104-00031145-00031427": "to form this job vacancy", "isDmkMb_jFM-00105-00031427-00031748": "interoperability platform and then", "isDmkMb_jFM-00106-00031749-00032027": "jobseekers can search through this index", "isDmkMb_jFM-00107-00032027-00032537": "using the job search engine the full", "isDmkMb_jFM-00108-00032538-00032798": "vacancy data always remains at the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00109-00032799-00033206": "source meaning in the system in the past", "isDmkMb_jFM-00110-00033207-00033487": "system where it was originally created", "isDmkMb_jFM-00111-00033488-00033877": "now what are the next steps first of all", "isDmkMb_jFM-00112-00033878-00034189": "on the job vacancy side we will", "isDmkMb_jFM-00113-00034190-00034583": "implement esco which means quite a big", "isDmkMb_jFM-00114-00034584-00034850": "task actually because it requires all", "isDmkMb_jFM-00115-00034851-00035114": "the public employment services to adapt", "isDmkMb_jFM-00116-00035115-00035402": "their systems and to map their national", "isDmkMb_jFM-00117-00035403-00035732": "classifications to esco in order to be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00118-00035733-00036068": "compatible which they are under legal", "isDmkMb_jFM-00119-00036069-00036401": "obligation to do as Henrik explained", "isDmkMb_jFM-00120-00036402-00036796": "before we will also extend the network", "isDmkMb_jFM-00121-00036797-00037211": "of URIs partners to press private", "isDmkMb_jFM-00122-00037212-00037460": "employment services that will also", "isDmkMb_jFM-00123-00037461-00037837": "participate in the exchange system on", "isDmkMb_jFM-00124-00037838-00038186": "the seaside we will implement a similar", "isDmkMb_jFM-00125-00038187-00038539": "system as for the job vacancies meaning", "isDmkMb_jFM-00126-00038540-00038792": "jobseekers will be able to register", "isDmkMb_jFM-00127-00038793-00039225": "their CV within one of the partner", "isDmkMb_jFM-00128-00039226-00039627": "systems and we will again retrieve the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00129-00039628-00039990": "metadata from these CDs into an index to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00130-00039991-00040548": "make it searchable the cee the year SUV", "isDmkMb_jFM-00131-00040549-00040833": "database will remain but will behave as", "isDmkMb_jFM-00132-00040834-00041139": "one of the sources that will feed into", "isDmkMb_jFM-00133-00041140-00041619": "this interoperability platform now", "isDmkMb_jFM-00134-00041620-00042000": "looking further into the future we will", "isDmkMb_jFM-00135-00042001-00042282": "be able to develop a semantic matching", "isDmkMb_jFM-00136-00042283-00042576": "engine to do direct matching between the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00137-00042577-00043065": "metadata from the CD index with the job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00138-00043066-00043410": "vacancies this semantic matching engine", "isDmkMb_jFM-00139-00043411-00043776": "will use the full power of esco meaning", "isDmkMb_jFM-00140-00043777-00044187": "the occupation terms the skill terms but", "isDmkMb_jFM-00141-00044188-00044634": "also the synonyms alternative terms the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00142-00044635-00044901": "relationship between the tour the terms", "isDmkMb_jFM-00143-00044902-00045387": "in feared information and so on so the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00144-00045388-00045636": "richer esco becomes the more powerful", "isDmkMb_jFM-00145-00045637-00046140": "the semantic matching engine will be now", "isDmkMb_jFM-00146-00046141-00046500": "this semantic interoperability platform", "isDmkMb_jFM-00147-00046501-00046815": "for CVS and job vacancies will enable", "isDmkMb_jFM-00148-00046816-00047270": "the creation of many new services I", "isDmkMb_jFM-00149-00047271-00047559": "already told you about the semantic", "isDmkMb_jFM-00150-00047560-00047913": "matching we will also be able to link", "isDmkMb_jFM-00151-00047914-00048297": "skill gaps that result from a mismatch", "isDmkMb_jFM-00152-00048298-00048618": "between a cvn vacancy to learning", "isDmkMb_jFM-00153-00048619-00048891": "opportunities thanks to the third pillar", "isDmkMb_jFM-00154-00048892-00049335": "of esco we will also enable career", "isDmkMb_jFM-00155-00049336-00049761": "guidance of course the data contained in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00156-00049762-00049974": "the interoperability platform is a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00157-00049975-00050364": "wealth of information for analyzing the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00158-00050365-00050697": "european labour market forecasting skill", "isDmkMb_jFM-00159-00050698-00051162": "shortages and surpluses the free text", "isDmkMb_jFM-00160-00051163-00051390": "information contained in the CVS and the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00161-00051391-00051885": "vacancies can be used to as an input to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00162-00051886-00052160": "enrich s go in the future", "isDmkMb_jFM-00163-00052161-00052496": "and other added value services can be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00164-00052497-00052792": "developed such as mobile applications by", "isDmkMb_jFM-00165-00052794-00053554": "euros or by any of our partners now to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00166-00053555-00053740": "finish I would like to show you a small", "isDmkMb_jFM-00167-00053741-00054141": "illustration of what I just explained", "isDmkMb_jFM-00168-00054142-00054425": "with an example coming through from the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00169-00054426-00054698": "European job days portal which is a kind", "isDmkMb_jFM-00170-00054699-00054979": "of side product of the u.s. portal", "isDmkMb_jFM-00171-00054979-00055244": "specifically dedicated to events", "isDmkMb_jFM-00172-00055245-00055487": "recruitment events and in particular", "isDmkMb_jFM-00173-00055488-00056036": "virtual job fairs on this portal job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00174-00056037-00056219": "seekers can create a profile where they", "isDmkMb_jFM-00175-00056220-00056611": "can add skills coming from esco and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00176-00056612-00056963": "similarly employers can include escrow", "isDmkMb_jFM-00177-00056964-00057278": "skills into the requirements for the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00178-00057279-00057512": "jobs that they are offering in an event", "isDmkMb_jFM-00179-00057513-00057821": "and based on that we calculate a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00180-00057822-00058115": "matching score this matching score is", "isDmkMb_jFM-00181-00058116-00058366": "used to recommend jobs to the job", "isDmkMb_jFM-00182-00058367-00058663": "seekers attending the event the jobs", "isDmkMb_jFM-00183-00058664-00059035": "that are best matching their profile it", "isDmkMb_jFM-00184-00059036-00059431": "is also used as an indication before", "isDmkMb_jFM-00185-00059432-00059905": "jobseekers apply for a job to gently", "isDmkMb_jFM-00186-00059907-00060106": "discourage them from applying to jobs", "isDmkMb_jFM-00187-00060107-00060347": "that do not fully match their profile", "isDmkMb_jFM-00188-00060348-00060761": "and finally it is used by employers to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00189-00060762-00061051": "pre-select the candidates that are the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00190-00061052-00061334": "most relevant for interviews during the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00191-00061335-00061881": "event so that's all I hope we have", "isDmkMb_jFM-00192-00061882-00062213": "managed to do this in 10 minutes and we", "isDmkMb_jFM-00193-00062214-00063090": "will open the floor for questions", "isDmkMb_jFM-00194-00063091-00063526": "well ladies and gentlemen URIs loves", "isDmkMb_jFM-00195-00063527-00063736": "esco I like that that was a very good", "isDmkMb_jFM-00196-00063737-00063930": "thank you thank you both very much for", "isDmkMb_jFM-00197-00063932-00064242": "the presentation we have about five", "isDmkMb_jFM-00198-00064244-00064444": "minutes before the coffee break that's", "isDmkMb_jFM-00199-00064445-00064657": "deliberate and after the coffee break", "isDmkMb_jFM-00200-00064658-00064791": "you'll have another 10-minute", "isDmkMb_jFM-00201-00064792-00064951": "presentation followed by five-minute", "isDmkMb_jFM-00202-00064952-00065292": "question answers and a final one again", "isDmkMb_jFM-00203-00065294-00065527": "this is going through very specific", "isDmkMb_jFM-00204-00065528-00065983": "issues here it's about URIs am i", "isDmkMb_jFM-00205-00065984-00066256": "pronouncing that correctly yes and ESCO", "isDmkMb_jFM-00206-00066257-00066703": "and how this links together any", "isDmkMb_jFM-00207-00066704-00066976": "questions on anything that you saw in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00208-00066977-00067312": "the presentation any doubts or lots of", "isDmkMb_jFM-00209-00067313-00067534": "questions so we have three could you", "isDmkMb_jFM-00210-00067535-00067723": "take the gentleman at the back and then", "isDmkMb_jFM-00211-00067724-00067861": "we'll go to the lady in the middle and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00212-00067862-00068437": "then we'll go to fair hello if you have", "isDmkMb_jFM-00213-00068438-00068926": "e stand up hi my name is all modest too", "isDmkMb_jFM-00214-00068927-00069364": "and so my question is do you have any", "isDmkMb_jFM-00215-00069365-00069718": "plans to open these two to employers for", "isDmkMb_jFM-00216-00069719-00069973": "employers directly to to post to your", "isDmkMb_jFM-00217-00069974-00070303": "jobs in their their job vacancies to the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00218-00070304-00070582": "portal thank you very much let's take", "isDmkMb_jFM-00219-00070583-00071161": "the lady in the middle my name is", "isDmkMb_jFM-00220-00071162-00071460": "Claudia plan well I come from Austria", "isDmkMb_jFM-00221-00071461-00071878": "I'm puzzled by using there would be an", "isDmkMb_jFM-00222-00071879-00072142": "obligation for National Public", "isDmkMb_jFM-00223-00072143-00072442": "Employment Services to match their", "isDmkMb_jFM-00224-00072443-00072967": "national systems on to esco will this be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00225-00072968-00073213": "in the future or are you suggesting this", "isDmkMb_jFM-00226-00073214-00073540": "already now very good and then we have a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00227-00073541-00073999": "final question here at the front well", "isDmkMb_jFM-00228-00074000-00074224": "yeah here till I have a practical", "isDmkMb_jFM-00229-00074225-00074386": "question you're talking about semantic", "isDmkMb_jFM-00230-00074387-00074905": "matching engine how does in the matching", "isDmkMb_jFM-00231-00074906-00075118": "which are the criteria to decide there", "isDmkMb_jFM-00232-00075119-00075361": "is a match or not because it's semantics", "isDmkMb_jFM-00233-00075362-00075663": "based", "isDmkMb_jFM-00234-00075664-00076143": "over to you okay so first the question", "isDmkMb_jFM-00235-00076144-00076654": "of employers so your assists as i said", "isDmkMb_jFM-00236-00076655-00076788": "the cooperation between employment", "isDmkMb_jFM-00237-00076789-00077010": "services it will continue to be a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00238-00077011-00077221": "cooperation between employment services", "isDmkMb_jFM-00239-00077222-00077442": "even though we open for private", "isDmkMb_jFM-00240-00077443-00077616": "employment services there is a a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00241-00077617-00077985": "question or quality control that cannot", "isDmkMb_jFM-00242-00077986-00078160": "perhaps be done directly by the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00243-00078161-00078438": "Commission so employers will most", "isDmkMb_jFM-00244-00078439-00078634": "probably also in the future have to pass", "isDmkMb_jFM-00245-00078635-00079011": "via some kind of at least a partner", "isDmkMb_jFM-00246-00079012-00079434": "recognized by URIs so not all employers", "isDmkMb_jFM-00247-00079435-00079971": "directly but through a partner secondly", "isDmkMb_jFM-00248-00079972-00080301": "so the obligation but the obligation is", "isDmkMb_jFM-00249-00080302-00080657": "to participate in the interoperability", "isDmkMb_jFM-00250-00080658-00080935": "platform that obligation is already", "isDmkMb_jFM-00251-00080936-00081141": "there today when it comes to public", "isDmkMb_jFM-00252-00081142-00081392": "employment services and job vacancies", "isDmkMb_jFM-00253-00081393-00081696": "it's not a question of having an", "isDmkMb_jFM-00254-00081697-00082066": "obligation always to use esque we will", "isDmkMb_jFM-00255-00082067-00082354": "use esco for this for for the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00256-00082355-00082573": "interoperability and the matching but", "isDmkMb_jFM-00257-00082574-00082818": "it's not an obligation for everyone to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00258-00082819-00083112": "use a scope as such that could be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00259-00083113-00083469": "mapping made from other classifications", "isDmkMb_jFM-00260-00083470-00084347": "and economies to esco fully matching", "isDmkMb_jFM-00261-00084348-00084681": "to Eskom today it's a it's a mapping to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00262-00084682-00084969": "a scope yes but we will go a step", "isDmkMb_jFM-00263-00084970-00085238": "further we want to use at school for the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00264-00085239-00085626": "matching of course and regarding your", "isDmkMb_jFM-00265-00085627-00086028": "question geared for the the criteria", "isDmkMb_jFM-00266-00086029-00086238": "that are used in the semantic matching", "isDmkMb_jFM-00267-00086239-00086565": "engine it will be of course based on the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00268-00086566-00087000": "esco skills and occupations contained in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00269-00087001-00087348": "the cv and in the vacancy but also other", "isDmkMb_jFM-00270-00087349-00087591": "criteria such as experience level", "isDmkMb_jFM-00271-00087592-00088104": "education level language skills etc but", "isDmkMb_jFM-00272-00088105-00088437": "you will see a example of that and get", "isDmkMb_jFM-00273-00088438-00088701": "more explanation in Christoph's", "isDmkMb_jFM-00274-00088702-00088907": "presentation which is one of the next", "isDmkMb_jFM-00275-00088908-00089247": "sessions so he will give a bit more", "isDmkMb_jFM-00276-00089248-00090781": "insight into that", "isDmkMb_jFM-00277-00090782-00091031": "another question to the mapping to the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00278-00091032-00091281": "national systems are you planning to map", "isDmkMb_jFM-00279-00091282-00091530": "a version 02 national systems or is this", "isDmkMb_jFM-00280-00091531-00091676": "something that will happen with version", "isDmkMb_jFM-00281-00091677-00091899": "one for example and the second question", "isDmkMb_jFM-00282-00091900-00092172": "about the semantic matching engine or", "isDmkMb_jFM-00283-00092173-00092379": "the software behind that engine could", "isDmkMb_jFM-00284-00092380-00092562": "you maybe explain what kind of software", "isDmkMb_jFM-00285-00092563-00092760": "you're using if you're developing one of", "isDmkMb_jFM-00286-00092761-00093018": "your own or if you are using a software", "isDmkMb_jFM-00287-00093019-00093182": "that is used by other public employment", "isDmkMb_jFM-00288-00093183-00093636": "services yes sorry my name is Nicola and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00289-00093637-00094562": "I'm from Austria from TS so for the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00290-00094563-00094806": "mapping I mean the development of this", "isDmkMb_jFM-00291-00094807-00095049": "portal is something that will happen now", "isDmkMb_jFM-00292-00095050-00095348": "our step-by-step it's a gradual thing", "isDmkMb_jFM-00293-00095349-00096011": "and so it will sort of happen in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00294-00096012-00096300": "parallel with the development of risk so", "isDmkMb_jFM-00295-00096301-00096546": "we will of course we already start using", "isDmkMb_jFM-00296-00096547-00096944": "as school version 0 for 4 for the u.s.", "isDmkMb_jFM-00297-00096945-00097209": "platform and those are of course", "isDmkMb_jFM-00298-00097210-00097406": "interested in making mappings already", "isDmkMb_jFM-00299-00097407-00097725": "now are more than welcome but the final", "isDmkMb_jFM-00300-00097726-00097959": "obligation to make this may come later", "isDmkMb_jFM-00301-00097960-00098279": "the legal instruments are not in placing", "isDmkMb_jFM-00302-00098280-00098543": "very good we have a question there and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00303-00098544-00098750": "then I need to point you towards the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00304-00098751-00099000": "Twitter wall but please first we took it", "isDmkMb_jFM-00305-00099001-00099300": "from from friends is this is it an", "isDmkMb_jFM-00306-00099301-00099786": "evaluation of the system do you evaluate", "isDmkMb_jFM-00307-00099787-00100232": "this implementation in which way how is", "isDmkMb_jFM-00308-00100233-00101086": "it quality assured please", "isDmkMb_jFM-00309-00101087-00101636": "d no but I mean the technical the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00310-00101637-00102089": "evaluation how this technically the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00311-00102090-00102377": "quality for instance we are working now", "isDmkMb_jFM-00312-00102378-00102685": "very hard on improving the quality of", "isDmkMb_jFM-00313-00102686-00103019": "the the existing platform for instance", "isDmkMb_jFM-00314-00103020-00103333": "we put in place mechanisms to to check", "isDmkMb_jFM-00315-00103334-00103643": "that the data we we get is correct and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00316-00103644-00104075": "always available etc if that is what you", "isDmkMb_jFM-00317-00104076-00104933": "mean the question and we have a Twitter", "isDmkMb_jFM-00318-00104933-00105310": "wall oh it's number two now you might", "isDmkMb_jFM-00319-00105311-00105484": "need to move your head just slightly sir", "isDmkMb_jFM-00320-00105485-00105890": "thank you is the match a sliding scale", "isDmkMb_jFM-00321-00105891-00106175": "with a target match level EG eighty", "isDmkMb_jFM-00322-00106176-00106649": "percent match sk-ii you can employers", "isDmkMb_jFM-00323-00106650-00107075": "seekers set a match level the person who", "isDmkMb_jFM-00324-00107076-00107600": "wrote that tweet are they in the room no", "isDmkMb_jFM-00325-00107601-00108113": "but is the question clear to you um yes", "isDmkMb_jFM-00326-00108114-00108470": "I mean we're not quite there yet to into", "isDmkMb_jFM-00327-00108471-00108722": "the details of how the user interface", "isDmkMb_jFM-00328-00108723-00109046": "will be so that you can have a slider to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00329-00109047-00109196": "set your matching level but that's", "isDmkMb_jFM-00330-00109197-00109415": "exactly the kind of feature that we", "isDmkMb_jFM-00331-00109416-00109816": "would have in mind of course this is a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00332-00109817-00110105": "not going to be in place for for several", "isDmkMb_jFM-00333-00110106-00110318": "years so we were not into that level of", "isDmkMb_jFM-00334-00110319-00110533": "detail yet and as I said before you will", "isDmkMb_jFM-00335-00110534-00110945": "see a demo of a prototype in the next", "isDmkMb_jFM-00336-00110946-00111163": "session or the or the following one so", "isDmkMb_jFM-00337-00111164-00111404": "really patient there and you will know", "isDmkMb_jFM-00338-00111405-00111722": "more very good unless there are any", "isDmkMb_jFM-00339-00111723-00112058": "other questions I would like to release", "isDmkMb_jFM-00340-00112058-00112388": "you all for coffee oh no there is", "isDmkMb_jFM-00341-00112389-00112953": "another which one top one", "isDmkMb_jFM-00342-00112954-00113616": "okay EUC a Brussels are you in the room", "isDmkMb_jFM-00343-00113617-00113794": "interesting these tweets coming from", "isDmkMb_jFM-00344-00113795-00114059": "outside here we go in the near future", "isDmkMb_jFM-00345-00114060-00114496": "europass cv URIs services and at ske you", "isDmkMb_jFM-00346-00114497-00114786": "will be integrated european job search", "isDmkMb_jFM-00347-00114788-00115030": "and mobility goes to another level what", "isDmkMb_jFM-00348-00115031-00115484": "you have to say about that it's true aha", "isDmkMb_jFM-00349-00115485-00115783": "excellent well II you see a Brussels", "isDmkMb_jFM-00350-00115783-00115954": "whoever you are thank you for that", "isDmkMb_jFM-00351-00115955-00116242": "statement and endorsement but will", "isDmkMb_jFM-00352-00116243-00116407": "afraid we have a very last question for", "isDmkMb_jFM-00353-00116408-00116569": "you then I must release people for", "isDmkMb_jFM-00354-00116570-00116833": "coffee otherwise they will Lynch me just", "isDmkMb_jFM-00355-00116833-00117043": "specific question on timing so the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00356-00117044-00117394": "europass cv i guess is not used yet and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00357-00117395-00117810": "Eunice when will it be used next year or", "isDmkMb_jFM-00358-00117811-00118279": "it is already it has been already since", "isDmkMb_jFM-00359-00118280-00118693": "since the beginning of of the cv online", "isDmkMb_jFM-00360-00118694-00118999": "tool in on the eurosport oh the your SUV", "isDmkMb_jFM-00361-00119000-00119233": "is fully compatible with the europe SCV", "isDmkMb_jFM-00362-00119233-00119736": "the fields are completely aligned okay i", "isDmkMb_jFM-00363-00119738-00119910": "have been promised a 30-second", "isDmkMb_jFM-00364-00119911-00120289": "intervention now I'd like to specify a", "isDmkMb_jFM-00365-00120290-00120505": "little bit the Commission position when", "isDmkMb_jFM-00366-00120506-00120758": "it comes to the use of visco in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00367-00120759-00121027": "particular under urs we have no", "isDmkMb_jFM-00368-00121028-00121381": "intention whatsoever to force one way or", "isDmkMb_jFM-00369-00121382-00121540": "another one member states public", "isDmkMb_jFM-00370-00121541-00121702": "employment services even private", "isDmkMb_jFM-00371-00121703-00122101": "employment services to use esco and to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00372-00122102-00122308": "replace the national or specific", "isDmkMb_jFM-00373-00122308-00122743": "classification systems with esco we are", "isDmkMb_jFM-00374-00122744-00123169": "using and we'll be using esco in uris to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00375-00123170-00123424": "allow the interoperability between our", "isDmkMb_jFM-00376-00123425-00123799": "labor markets so it means that for the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00377-00123800-00123960": "Member States and in particular the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00378-00123961-00124381": "PSC's which are Austin us because they", "isDmkMb_jFM-00379-00124382-00124560": "have the obligation to participate in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00380-00124561-00124813": "the interoperability platform they will", "isDmkMb_jFM-00381-00124814-00125079": "eep so facto and if my letter on be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00382-00125080-00125350": "spelled out in a specific legal texts", "isDmkMb_jFM-00383-00125351-00125811": "but if so facto they will have to map to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00384-00125813-00126223": "esco and to map romesco which means that", "isDmkMb_jFM-00385-00126224-00126325": "for instance when John", "isDmkMb_jFM-00386-00126326-00126496": "to stop burnin the URIs manager from", "isDmkMb_jFM-00387-00126497-00126748": "France will be sending the French", "isDmkMb_jFM-00388-00126749-00127126": "vacancies job vacancies to your ass it", "isDmkMb_jFM-00389-00127127-00127441": "will have to map is French vacancies to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00390-00127442-00127726": "esco and in turn when he will be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00391-00127727-00127990": "retrieving the vacancies for instance", "isDmkMb_jFM-00392-00127991-00128365": "from Austria or Germany using their own", "isDmkMb_jFM-00393-00128366-00128533": "classification which is completely", "isDmkMb_jFM-00394-00128533-00128803": "different from the Rome it will have to", "isDmkMb_jFM-00395-00128804-00129157": "map from esco in order to translate them", "isDmkMb_jFM-00396-00129158-00129397": "into the language which is used in", "isDmkMb_jFM-00397-00129398-00129778": "France this is what it means correct ok", "isDmkMb_jFM-00398-00129779-00130342": "so if so facto esco will be used in your", "isDmkMb_jFM-00399-00130343-00130663": "ass and as you know your ass is growing", "isDmkMb_jFM-00400-00130664-00130849": "and growing and growing in importance", "isDmkMb_jFM-00401-00130850-00131107": "and their figures which and weaken and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00402-00131108-00131374": "Pascal I could not pass on to you", "isDmkMb_jFM-00403-00131375-00131605": "because I was not enough time but on", "isDmkMb_jFM-00404-00131606-00131989": "average every year your ass performs", "isDmkMb_jFM-00405-00131990-00132577": "some 150,000 placement so can you", "isDmkMb_jFM-00406-00132578-00132769": "imagine the number of matches behind", "isDmkMb_jFM-00407-00132770-00133024": "these figures and so forth so us will be", "isDmkMb_jFM-00408-00133025-00133269": "growing and growing in importance and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00409-00133270-00133561": "since 4 years for instance we have seen", "isDmkMb_jFM-00410-00133562-00133921": "the number of visitors to the US website", "isDmkMb_jFM-00411-00133922-00134440": "that the specific job sites x 10 so it", "isDmkMb_jFM-00412-00134441-00134763": "also gives you an indication of the", "isDmkMb_jFM-00413-00134764-00135238": "extent to which esco will be used very", "isDmkMb_jFM-00414-00135239-00135433": "good thank you very much ladies and", "isDmkMb_jFM-00415-00135434-00135673": "gentlemen Henrique and pascal thank you", "isDmkMb_jFM-00416-00135674-00135946": "very much for that"}}]