[{"audio_id": "iisR695c5m4", "text": {"iisR695c5m4-00000-00000019-00001082": "[Music]", "iisR695c5m4-00001-00001083-00001857": "[Applause]", "iisR695c5m4-00002-00001859-00002129": "hello everybody I'm was father I'm an", "iisR695c5m4-00003-00002130-00002309": "evolutionary astrologer and I'm here", "iisR695c5m4-00004-00002310-00002485": "with the evolutionary astrology message", "iisR695c5m4-00005-00002486-00002822": "for the week between 14th and 21st of", "iisR695c5m4-00006-00002823-00003458": "September 2019 so this is more turbulent", "iisR695c5m4-00007-00003459-00003602": "week coming and if I want to", "iisR695c5m4-00008-00003603-00003990": "characterize it I want to say that", "iisR695c5m4-00009-00003992-00004295": "basically we're moving towards the", "iisR695c5m4-00010-00004296-00004751": "autumn equinox and the autumnal equinox", "iisR695c5m4-00011-00004752-00005131": "setting no even globe side of the globe", "iisR695c5m4-00012-00005132-00005438": "it's the vernal equinox at the southern", "iisR695c5m4-00013-00005439-00005704": "end of the globe it's a time that the", "iisR695c5m4-00014-00005705-00006113": "Sun would enter the sign of Libra 23rd", "iisR695c5m4-00015-00006114-00006326": "of September if I'm not mistaking that's", "iisR695c5m4-00016-00006327-00006752": "next week as we move as we move upon on", "iisR695c5m4-00017-00006753-00007034": "to that date into that time more and", "iisR695c5m4-00018-00007034-00007277": "more planets are heading into Libra and", "iisR695c5m4-00019-00007278-00007592": "we're moving into this autumn feeling", "iisR695c5m4-00020-00007593-00007921": "this feeling of change and in the", "iisR695c5m4-00021-00007922-00008170": "southern hemisphere this feeling of", "iisR695c5m4-00022-00008172-00008813": "blooming and regeneration and I would", "iisR695c5m4-00023-00008814-00009031": "say that Saturday the 14th has the", "iisR695c5m4-00024-00009032-00009442": "special energy it's the full moon it's a", "iisR695c5m4-00025-00009443-00009817": "full moon at the 21st degree of Pisces", "iisR695c5m4-00026-00009818-00010067": "I've talked a lot about that full moon", "iisR695c5m4-00027-00010068-00010399": "in my previous video so if you want to", "iisR695c5m4-00028-00010400-00010724": "see how these energies come into play", "iisR695c5m4-00029-00010725-00010973": "but this is such a fruitful full moon", "iisR695c5m4-00030-00010974-00011276": "that really calls us to come together", "iisR695c5m4-00031-00011277-00011573": "that the droplets would understand that", "iisR695c5m4-00032-00011574-00011985": "they make the waves rise that only by", "iisR695c5m4-00033-00011986-00012299": "connecting together we become oceanic", "iisR695c5m4-00034-00012300-00012491": "currents and", "iisR695c5m4-00035-00012492-00012788": "that that is our power and if not would", "iisR695c5m4-00036-00012789-00013463": "only be teardrops in the rain as Rutger", "iisR695c5m4-00037-00013463-00014087": "Hauer rest his soul this beautiful", "iisR695c5m4-00038-00014088-00014399": "monologue in Blade Runner my really", "iisR695c5m4-00039-00014400-00015287": "Scott so um this is a full moon that has", "iisR695c5m4-00040-00015288-00015512": "a lot of these energies and I recommend", "iisR695c5m4-00041-00015513-00015707": "that if you haven't seen last week's", "iisR695c5m4-00042-00015708-00016133": "video Lou go and watch it Sunday the", "iisR695c5m4-00043-00016134-00016463": "15th is a sensitive day and so is Monday", "iisR695c5m4-00044-00016464-00016688": "and Tuesday up to really", "iisR695c5m4-00045-00016689-00017140": "Wednesday midday Eastern European time", "iisR695c5m4-00046-00017141-00017393": "that means that the first end of the", "iisR695c5m4-00047-00017394-00017753": "week is much more sensitive and needs to", "iisR695c5m4-00048-00017754-00018014": "be addressed as such it means that we", "iisR695c5m4-00049-00018015-00018287": "could act we could get hurt more easily", "iisR695c5m4-00050-00018288-00018581": "we can act out from our own hurt place", "iisR695c5m4-00051-00018582-00019031": "or hurt each other or other people and", "iisR695c5m4-00052-00019032-00019265": "without thinking about it too much", "iisR695c5m4-00053-00019266-00019505": "before or recognizing that we're going", "iisR695c5m4-00054-00019506-00019822": "to hurt them by saying or doing what we", "iisR695c5m4-00055-00019823-00020210": "so hastily did or said and then that's", "iisR695c5m4-00056-00020211-00020447": "Sunday for you you know that's a Chiron", "iisR695c5m4-00057-00020448-00020786": "moon conjunction opposing a Mercury and", "iisR695c5m4-00058-00020787-00021128": "Venus and then Monday we have a square", "iisR695c5m4-00059-00021129-00021392": "from the moon to Saturn and Pluto so", "iisR695c5m4-00060-00021393-00021631": "watch out for judgment and self judgment", "iisR695c5m4-00061-00021632-00022159": "then Tuesday we have all kinds of", "iisR695c5m4-00062-00022160-00022415": "unpleasant things little unpleasant", "iisR695c5m4-00063-00022416-00022565": "things happening in the sky that can", "iisR695c5m4-00064-00022566-00022766": "take away a bit of the satisfaction it", "iisR695c5m4-00065-00022767-00023081": "is a moon in Taurus and that certainly", "iisR695c5m4-00066-00023082-00023500": "can crown things and help us find that", "iisR695c5m4-00067-00023501-00024161": "find some condolences in food and drink", "iisR695c5m4-00068-00024162-00024533": "and a nourishment and also central and", "iisR695c5m4-00069-00024534-00024836": "emotional nourishment and Wednesday the", "iisR695c5m4-00070-00024837-00025127": "moon is conjunct Uranus it's a great day", "iisR695c5m4-00071-00025128-00025382": "to be flexible and you know change who", "iisR695c5m4-00072-00025383-00025700": "you are but be careful not to be", "iisR695c5m4-00073-00025701-00025844": "intolerant", "iisR695c5m4-00074-00025845-00026049": "and however it's also the day that", "iisR695c5m4-00075-00026050-00026310": "Saturn will be starting to move direct", "iisR695c5m4-00076-00026311-00026655": "and we could see um issues connecting to", "iisR695c5m4-00077-00026656-00026973": "Authority in our lives and status in our", "iisR695c5m4-00078-00026974-00027214": "life and taking responsibility and", "iisR695c5m4-00079-00027216-00027564": "maturing in our lives start to work", "iisR695c5m4-00080-00027564-00027924": "better faster and as they should it's as", "iisR695c5m4-00081-00027925-00028167": "if we've done a lot of work and finally", "iisR695c5m4-00082-00028168-00028401": "we're getting recognized for it as the", "iisR695c5m4-00083-00028402-00028733": "day's move on from Wednesday onward the", "iisR695c5m4-00084-00028734-00029108": "moon is going to be trying that Saturn", "iisR695c5m4-00085-00029109-00029436": "on Wednesday afternoon Eastern European", "iisR695c5m4-00086-00029437-00029751": "Time that means that this is the cold", "iisR695c5m4-00087-00029752-00030006": "sign for the next part of the week which", "iisR695c5m4-00088-00030007-00030276": "is much nicer in the sky and could give", "iisR695c5m4-00089-00030277-00030587": "us all a feeling of inner strength of a", "iisR695c5m4-00090-00030588-00030873": "need for intimacy and feeling alive", "iisR695c5m4-00091-00030874-00031101": "squeezing dust that zest and", "iisR695c5m4-00092-00031102-00031340": "understanding that we are more powerful", "iisR695c5m4-00093-00031341-00031499": "than we thought we were that we've", "iisR695c5m4-00094-00031500-00031824": "reached a higher plateau a stronger base", "iisR695c5m4-00095-00031825-00032139": "on which we could build our structure on", "iisR695c5m4-00096-00032139-00032371": "we have all these shrines happening", "iisR695c5m4-00097-00032372-00032574": "including between the Sun and the moon", "iisR695c5m4-00098-00032575-00032958": "on Thursday and between Mars and Pluto", "iisR695c5m4-00099-00032959-00033299": "and that is really about inner strength", "iisR695c5m4-00100-00033300-00033501": "it could be about intimacy and passion", "iisR695c5m4-00101-00033502-00034039": "as well it could be about managing", "iisR695c5m4-00102-00034040-00034892": "harmoniously my actions and my motives", "iisR695c5m4-00103-00034893-00035337": "what is pulling me into action beneath", "iisR695c5m4-00104-00035338-00035645": "the surface and what is actually", "iisR695c5m4-00105-00035646-00035904": "happening about it these mechanisms", "iisR695c5m4-00106-00035905-00036285": "could be in a way blessed with divine", "iisR695c5m4-00107-00036286-00036962": "light and we could achieve a wider", "iisR695c5m4-00108-00036963-00037308": "understanding of how it is that we", "iisR695c5m4-00109-00037309-00037514": "interact within these two rooms the", "iisR695c5m4-00110-00037515-00037695": "conscious and the unconscious or the", "iisR695c5m4-00111-00037696-00037803": "conscious and the same", "iisR695c5m4-00112-00037804-00038519": "I'm just the emotional and the physical", "iisR695c5m4-00113-00038520-00038778": "and then there's trines to the moon", "iisR695c5m4-00114-00038779-00039033": "between the moon and Venus and Mercury", "iisR695c5m4-00115-00039034-00039330": "on Friday great evening for", "iisR695c5m4-00116-00039331-00039498": "communication afternoon for", "iisR695c5m4-00117-00039499-00039717": "communication with loved ones Friday the", "iisR695c5m4-00118-00039718-00040182": "20th Eastern European time and remember", "iisR695c5m4-00119-00040183-00040440": "you have to take it eight hours before", "iisR695c5m4-00120-00040441-00040752": "if you are in New York to get nine hours", "iisR695c5m4-00121-00040753-00041015": "ahead if you are in Sydney Australia", "iisR695c5m4-00122-00041016-00041339": "Saturday the 21st we're having a grand", "iisR695c5m4-00123-00041340-00041891": "mutable Square in the sky involving", "iisR695c5m4-00124-00041892-00042438": "Neptune the moon in Gemini the Sun Mars", "iisR695c5m4-00125-00042439-00043170": "and Jupiter and Ceres really calling us", "iisR695c5m4-00126-00043171-00043578": "to understand the situation of the world", "iisR695c5m4-00127-00043579-00043854": "the universe of nature to actually", "iisR695c5m4-00128-00043855-00044249": "harness our communion harness our and", "iisR695c5m4-00129-00044250-00044685": "hope harness our as I said communal", "iisR695c5m4-00130-00044686-00044994": "power and and see ourselves as the", "iisR695c5m4-00131-00044995-00045356": "masses see yourself as something unified", "iisR695c5m4-00132-00045357-00045705": "with nature with the world and not", "iisR695c5m4-00133-00045706-00046016": "separated from it see ourselves as", "iisR695c5m4-00134-00046017-00046395": "spiritual beings that are a part of a", "iisR695c5m4-00135-00046396-00046851": "spiritual network of life and believing", "iisR695c5m4-00136-00046852-00047139": "in hope believing in our ability to", "iisR695c5m4-00137-00047140-00047423": "change fighting for what is right", "iisR695c5m4-00138-00047424-00048005": "fighting for home the more fighting Mars", "iisR695c5m4-00139-00048006-00048396": "son we are fighting who we are our self", "iisR695c5m4-00140-00048397-00049057": "manifestation moon home family our", "iisR695c5m4-00141-00049058-00049510": "ability to stay emotionally sane Neptune", "iisR695c5m4-00142-00049511-00049786": "and Jupiter both talk about God faith", "iisR695c5m4-00143-00049787-00050158": "the nature and how it was before it was", "iisR695c5m4-00144-00050159-00050440": "corrupted by men and then adapt series", "iisR695c5m4-00145-00050441-00050761": "to that Jupiter the goddess of nature", "iisR695c5m4-00146-00050762-00050941": "the Great Mother the matter", "iisR695c5m4-00147-00050942-00051226": "bringing off the grain and the fruit and", "iisR695c5m4-00148-00051227-00051862": "the flowering the the the initiator of", "iisR695c5m4-00149-00051863-00052419": "spring you know of the bloom of spring", "iisR695c5m4-00150-00052420-00052726": "believing that we could actually realign", "iisR695c5m4-00151-00052727-00053084": "nature or help nature to realign if we", "iisR695c5m4-00152-00053085-00053524": "walk a communal path if we believe in", "iisR695c5m4-00153-00053525-00054053": "Hope if we give up something of our own", "iisR695c5m4-00154-00054054-00054691": "needs to a higher cause that Mars nepto", "iisR695c5m4-00155-00054692-00055101": "opposition giving up something person", "iisR695c5m4-00156-00055102-00055480": "for a higher cause without feeling too", "iisR695c5m4-00157-00055481-00055766": "much of a martyr about it understanding", "iisR695c5m4-00158-00055766-00055987": "that this is the only way that we could", "iisR695c5m4-00159-00055988-00056206": "actually save ourselves the world would", "iisR695c5m4-00160-00056207-00056554": "go on nature would go on it's mankind", "iisR695c5m4-00161-00056555-00056791": "and all the living creatures that are", "iisR695c5m4-00162-00056792-00057112": "currently on this earth that are going", "iisR695c5m4-00163-00057113-00057337": "to suffer the worst end of these", "iisR695c5m4-00164-00057338-00058066": "consequences so yeah may then may the", "iisR695c5m4-00165-00058067-00058274": "droplets understand that they're the", "iisR695c5m4-00166-00058275-00058634": "waves and they're the currents indeed", "iisR695c5m4-00167-00058635-00059009": "they are the ocean itself and that", "iisR695c5m4-00168-00059010-00059232": "epidemic note", "iisR695c5m4-00169-00059233-00059541": "sending you off to spread the light and", "iisR695c5m4-00170-00059542-00059868": "may I spread the light myself and may we", "iisR695c5m4-00171-00059869-00060403": "never fail ourselves nor all of the rest", "iisR695c5m4-00172-00060404-00061029": "of us may we all live long and prosper", "iisR695c5m4-00173-00061029-00061604": "[Music]", "iisR695c5m4-00174-00061604-00063409": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "iiBVTzCzkJy", "text": {"iiBVTzCzkJy-00000-00000011-00000684": "[Music]", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00001-00000685-00000908": "hi mr. robear", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00002-00000909-00001141": "I miss red man how you doing I'm doing", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00003-00001142-00001331": "really good it's nice to see you and I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00004-00001332-00001574": "see you have your mask on I usually", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00005-00001575-00001754": "don't wear it inside but to start off", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00006-00001755-00001927": "this video I thought I'd wear it I love", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00007-00001928-00002209": "your mask Thank You mr. robear I just", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00008-00002210-00002414": "got back from the store I bought myself", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00009-00002415-00002663": "some lima beans because I want to start", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00010-00002664-00002860": "a garden so when I was inside the store", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00011-00002861-00003100": "I wore my mask very safe for you and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00012-00003101-00003286": "safe for everybody else who was around", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00013-00003288-00003524": "you yeah shall we get started", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00014-00003525-00003938": "sounds great hey mr. robear Amos Redman", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00015-00003939-00004142": "can I tell you about what I went to the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00016-00004143-00004397": "store to buy my lima beans", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00017-00004398-00004685": "I love lima beans tell me about it okay", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00018-00004686-00004945": "I went to the store and I knew that I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00019-00004946-00005468": "had cash big money mm-hmm but I didn't", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00020-00005469-00005743": "realize that each one of these bills", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00021-00005744-00005995": "that I had well most of them some of", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00022-00005996-00006145": "them had the same number but they have", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00023-00006146-00006334": "different numbers on them and that means", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00024-00006335-00006506": "that they're worth different amounts oh", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00025-00006506-00006664": "you got to know how much money you have", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00026-00006665-00006846": "before you go to the store miss Bradman", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00027-00006847-00007135": "exactly right mr. robear so when I got", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00028-00007136-00007423": "to the cashier and she started ringing", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00029-00007425-00007673": "me up for my lima beans I didn't really", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00030-00007673-00007838": "know how much money I had and I had to", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00031-00007839-00008278": "get myself together hmm glad you did", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00032-00008279-00008516": "okay friends when I got to the counter", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00033-00008517-00008699": "at the gardening store I put my lima", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00034-00008700-00009096": "beans down she said your lima beans cost", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00035-00009097-00009605": "$3 each now notice that I have two packs", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00036-00009606-00010409": "of beans so I had one bill that had 20", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00037-00010410-00010742": "on it that's worth $20 I had two bills", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00038-00010743-00011288": "that had fives so that's 5 $10 and then", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00039-00011289-00011753": "I had 2 3 4 and 5", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00040-00011754-00012263": "I had 5 bills with one on him 1 2 3 4", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00041-00012264-00012944": "and 5 so I had a 20 I had 5 10 so I had", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00042-00012944-00013175": "two fines and then I had 5 ones", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00043-00013176-00013363": "altogether I had 20", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00044-00013365-00014102": "25 30 36 37 38 39 40 dollars and that's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00045-00014103-00014281": "what I had all righty", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00046-00014282-00014644": "so these beans costed $3 each", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00047-00014645-00015125": "I didn't quite have enough to give one", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00048-00015126-00015713": "two three four one pass and four five I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00049-00015713-00016013": "didn't have another one so I had to", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00050-00016013-00016274": "think about how I could use my money to", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00051-00016275-00016514": "buy three dollars for this pack and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00052-00016515-00016759": "three dollars for this pack so I needed", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00053-00016760-00017483": "six dollars what would you use what I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00054-00017484-00017861": "decided to use was I decided to give my", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00055-00017862-00018355": "one five dollar bill and a one dollar", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00056-00018356-00018641": "bill 5 plus 1 is 6 and I gave this one", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00057-00018642-00018880": "away Shh I gave us one week away because", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00058-00018881-00019049": "I had like a little rip in it", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00059-00019050-00019381": "and I wasn't really sure if I was able", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00060-00019382-00019708": "to use it so I was kind of testing out", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00061-00019709-00019958": "if I was able to use it and I was so $6", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00062-00019959-00020450": "spot two packs of beans hey there miss", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00063-00020451-00020678": "Redman hey there mister row beggar so", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00064-00020679-00020965": "you got your lima beans I did and what", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00065-00020966-00021133": "are you gonna do with those beans now", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00066-00021134-00021397": "well I was thinking I would plant them", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00067-00021398-00021562": "down in my garden but there's all these", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00068-00021563-00021752": "little bunny rabbits running around I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00069-00021753-00021886": "think they might try to eat my lima", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00070-00021887-00022318": "beans so I had a different yes so I have", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00071-00022319-00022522": "a different idea that I want to plant", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00072-00022523-00022850": "them in boxes on my balcony oh that's a", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00073-00022851-00023083": "great idea so you've already measured", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00074-00023084-00023233": "and you know that the boxes will fit on", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00075-00023234-00023633": "your balcony no I didn't think of that", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00076-00023634-00023950": "oh okay well do you have a ruler to", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00077-00023951-00024805": "measure no no ruler give a yardstick no", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00078-00024806-00025047": "but I know that my boxes are about like", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00079-00025048-00025336": "they're about as long as my arm that's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00080-00025337-00025600": "how long they are on one side uh-huh", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00081-00025601-00025868": "well that's well if you don't have", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00082-00025869-00026083": "anything to measure with maybe you could", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00083-00026084-00026452": "use body parts to help you estimate in", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00084-00026453-00026666": "your measurement", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00085-00026667-00027149": "more about that mr. robear well so this", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00086-00027150-00027652": "is my ruler and it's one foot long and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00087-00027654-00027895": "it's got 12 inches you can see the the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00088-00027897-00028310": "numbers on here one inch there's two", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00089-00028311-00028535": "inches there there's three inches there", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00090-00028536-00028945": "and this whole ruler is about the same", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00091-00028947-00029377": "length as my arm from the elbow to the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00092-00029379-00030014": "wrist so my arm is that long I bet your", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00093-00030014-00030320": "arm is that long as well so from the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00094-00030320-00030583": "elbow elbow wrist", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00095-00030585-00030830": "your wrist is about one foot long it's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00096-00030831-00031027": "about one foot long that's good to know", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00097-00031029-00031304": "thank you yeah so you could actually use", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00098-00031305-00031574": "that part of your body to help you", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00099-00031575-00031870": "measure I mean it might take a while but", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00100-00031872-00032177": "if you don't have a ruler handy you can", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00101-00032177-00032405": "use your arm to help you measure it's a", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00102-00032406-00032558": "great idea I'm gonna use my arm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00103-00032558-00032843": "yeah now if you've got something that's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00104-00032844-00033137": "smaller and you wanted to measure in", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00105-00033138-00033419": "inches instead of how many feet you know", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00106-00033420-00033605": "the arm would tell you how many feet you", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00107-00033606-00033911": "need right or how many feet something is", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00108-00033912-00034076": "long but if you wanted to talk about", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00109-00034077-00034406": "inches is there a body part that you", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00110-00034407-00034637": "think is about the same size as an inch", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00111-00034638-00035354": "oh I know mr. Rovere what about my thumb", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00112-00035355-00035981": "from this sort of hand here today let's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00113-00035982-00036704": "see ah is that about one-inch yeah there", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00114-00036705-00036740": "you go", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00115-00036741-00036974": "so if you needed to measure something", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00116-00036975-00037295": "that was small you could use from the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00117-00037296-00037484": "tip of your thumb to the first knuckle", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00118-00037485-00038051": "as one inch uh-huh is that called like", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00119-00038052-00038273": "the approximate it's not gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00120-00038274-00038486": "necessarily be exactly an inch but it's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00121-00038487-00038642": "gonna be pretty close to it it's gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00122-00038643-00038906": "get you close to the accurate amount", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00123-00038907-00039122": "it's not gonna be exact but it is an", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00124-00039123-00039482": "approximation perfect all right miss", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00125-00039483-00039848": "Redman we're in my kitchen you want to", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00126-00039849-00039965": "practice some", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00127-00039966-00040232": "estimating of measurement I am excited", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00128-00040233-00040391": "to practice okay", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00129-00040392-00040691": "so I've got three things and I'm gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00130-00040692-00040934": "have you estimate on let's start with", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00131-00040935-00041312": "this first can you see that mm-hmm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00132-00041313-00041804": "a toothpick okay let me see let me I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00133-00041805-00042062": "would say that toothpick is definitely", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00134-00042063-00042257": "smaller than my arm okay I would", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00135-00042258-00042743": "probably want to estimate using my thumb", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00136-00042744-00043031": "the top of my thumb as an inch so I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00137-00043032-00043604": "would say that that toothpick is one I'm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00138-00043605-00043778": "gonna guess that that toothpick is two", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00139-00043779-00043886": "inches long", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00140-00043887-00044264": "oh so two of these from you up to the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00141-00044265-00044414": "knuckle the tip of the thumb to the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00142-00044415-00044627": "first knuckle you think that's two of", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00143-00044628-00044981": "those would be as a right I'm gonna I'm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00144-00044982-00045244": "gonna measure using my ruler okay okay", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00145-00045245-00045845": "there's the ruler and I'm putting the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00146-00045846-00046433": "end of the toothpick mmm see that bring", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00147-00046434-00046574": "it really close to the camera mister", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00148-00046575-00047041": "robear I can see that that is actually", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00149-00047042-00047513": "two and a half inches long but that was", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00150-00047514-00047636": "pretty close that was pretty good", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00151-00047637-00048065": "estimate thank you good job so that was", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00152-00048066-00048275": "great estimate very close all right you", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00153-00048276-00048344": "ready for another one", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00154-00048345-00049343": "I'm ready all right mr. robear will you", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00155-00049344-00049856": "please hold that spot right down to your", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00156-00049857-00050012": "elbow just so I can see", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00157-00050013-00050902": "Oh mister over there I can see that is", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00158-00050903-00051614": "just same lip your one foot plus two", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00159-00051615-00052303": "maybe all right", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00160-00052304-00053338": "ooh I changed my estimation that's gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00161-00053339-00053932": "be 1 foot plus 1 inch yeah if you go", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00162-00053933-00054172": "from the middle of your spoon and not", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00163-00054173-00054366": "the edge cuz your spoon has a circle at", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00164-00054367-00054642": "the end how about if I use my yardstick", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00165-00054644-00055339": "okay place that at the end all right I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00166-00055340-00055636": "see that it's at the 13 wait a minute", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00167-00055637-00055854": "mister robear how many inches is one", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00168-00055855-00056575": "foot one foot this ruler is one foot and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00169-00056576-00057516": "it is 12 inches inches mr. gros barrel", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00170-00057517-00058201": "is correct one foot and one inch there", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00171-00058202-00058858": "you go one foot twelve plus one 13 I'm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00172-00058859-00059082": "feeling confident about my gardening box", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00173-00059083-00059446": "one more okay your burning bus it's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00174-00059447-00059953": "gonna be I don't know maybe the width of", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00175-00059954-00060433": "the length of this is gonna be as wide", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00176-00060434-00060613": "as your garden boxes what do you think", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00177-00060614-00060905": "about this cabinet door", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00178-00060907-00061216": "well mr. Ebert I'm thinking that your", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00179-00061216-00061479": "cabinet door is definitely longer than a", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00180-00061480-00061680": "foot because I know that your cabin is", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00181-00061682-00062277": "not as small as my elbow to my wrist and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00182-00062278-00062653": "arm up there so let me see that's gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00183-00062654-00062911": "be two of your arms so that's gonna be", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00184-00062912-00063394": "two feet what about two feet two and a", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00185-00063395-00063778": "half feet you're happy yeah I think two", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00186-00063779-00064167": "and a half feet that means one foot two", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00187-00064169-00064435": "foot yeah and then half of 12 is 6 so", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00188-00064436-00064782": "maybe it's gonna be 12 plus 12 plus 6", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00189-00064783-00065496": "which is let me see 24 25 26 27 28 29 30", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00190-00065497-00065665": "inches", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00191-00065666-00066034": "okay I'm gonna put the tip of the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00192-00066035-00066387": "yardstick here at the top and I'm gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00193-00066388-00067131": "put my thumb right here at the bottom", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00194-00067132-00067562": "[Laughter]", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00195-00067563-00067811": "have you been stalking in my kitchen", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00196-00067812-00068037": "maybe if you're cooking something good", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00197-00068038-00068393": "over there I'm a cook some lima beans oh", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00198-00068394-00068734": "you ain't you tell them you have to wait", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00199-00068735-00068953": "a long time for my to grow but maybe we", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00200-00068954-00069229": "can buy some from the store that's good", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00201-00069230-00069472": "good job estimating and measuring mr.", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00202-00069473-00069681": "radmann Thank You mr. robe and now we", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00203-00069682-00069811": "know how to count our money", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00204-00069812-00070117": "and we know how to measure absolutely", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00205-00070118-00070423": "we're ready for some lima beans how", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00206-00070424-00070660": "about a game now that's a good idea", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00207-00070661-00071001": "let's go play a game all right hey miss", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00208-00071002-00071157": "Redman what game are we gonna play today", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00209-00071158-00071404": "we're gonna play a game called Pico", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00210-00071405-00071629": "Fermi Bay go have you ever played that", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00211-00071630-00071844": "before I've never played that game", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00212-00071845-00072124": "before but I'm excited to learn yay", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00213-00072125-00072393": "well with Pico Fermi bagel it's a", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00214-00072394-00072618": "guessing game I'm gonna write down a", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00215-00072619-00072829": "number that you cannot see that I made", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00216-00072830-00073012": "you have to either cover your eyes or", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00217-00073013-00073291": "put your head down no peeking I won't", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00218-00073292-00073706": "peek and you have to guess what number I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00219-00073707-00073984": "wrote down so I'm gonna tell you that", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00220-00073985-00074173": "we're gonna write something that's in", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00221-00074174-00074287": "the hundreds place", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00222-00074288-00074473": "so we're just gonna be three digits", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00223-00074474-00074740": "three-digit number okay and the way I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00224-00074741-00074947": "give you you're gonna guess my correct", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00225-00074948-00075300": "number is that I'm gonna say Pico that", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00226-00075301-00075634": "means that you have a correct digit but", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00227-00075635-00075904": "it's in the wrong place value okay and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00228-00075905-00076449": "if you say if I say Fermi that means you", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00229-00076450-00076692": "have a correct digit in the correct", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00230-00076693-00076903": "place so that's almost like I'm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00231-00076904-00077041": "confirming that's correct", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00232-00077042-00077484": "Fermi got it Fermi mr. Roberge Fermi and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00233-00077485-00077941": "then bago if I say bagel that means none", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00234-00077942-00078097": "of those digits that you said are", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00235-00078098-00078468": "correct it's almost like a zero Oh kind", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00236-00078469-00078756": "of like a bagel bagel yeah all right are", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00237-00078757-00079046": "you ready to play I'm ready to try Oh", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00238-00079047-00079217": "hey yeah I want you to cover your eyes", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00239-00079218-00079412": "our turn to the side whatever you want", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00240-00079413-00079643": "to do can I keep my head focused down", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00241-00079644-00079784": "absolutely", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00242-00079785-00079982": "I'm gonna write down my guess is here so", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00243-00079983-00080116": "I'll be just looking down the whole time", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00244-00080117-00080309": "why are you writing down your guesses", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00245-00080310-00080858": "mr. robear um so that when you say pico", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00246-00080859-00081194": "Fermi or bagel then I'll remember what I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00247-00081195-00081362": "had said and then I can kind of I may", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00248-00081363-00081473": "have to play with different combinations", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00249-00081474-00081767": "to figure out which one is correct which", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00250-00081768-00081926": "one is in the right place and stuff like", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00251-00081927-00082199": "that okay great idea here we go", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00252-00082200-00082387": "all right I'm not looking anymore", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00253-00082388-00082643": "alright friends let's not tell mr.", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00254-00082644-00082886": "robear what number I wrote down you see", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00255-00082887-00083246": "that all right Shh", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00256-00083247-00083555": "go ahead and take a guess mr. robear all", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00257-00083556-00084611": "right my first guess is 478 478 well mr.", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00258-00084612-00085016": "robear I'm gonna have to say bagel bagel", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00259-00085017-00085355": "bagel for your ones place ten place and", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00260-00085356-00085445": "hundreds place", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00261-00085446-00085766": "okay so nothing's correct so I will not", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00262-00085767-00085982": "guess any numbers with the four a seven", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00263-00085983-00086255": "or an eight all right perfect so he", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00264-00086256-00088025": "loves okay 123 123 okay mr. Robie before", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00265-00088026-00088621": "your hundreds plays I'm gonna say Fermi", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00266-00088622-00089012": "confirmed or your tens place I'm gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00267-00089013-00089843": "say Fermi correct or one place you can", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00268-00089844-00090451": "say Fermi I don't know I'm gonna say", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00269-00090452-00090827": "bagel for you ones place okay are you", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00270-00090828-00091168": "all telling mr. Roubini answers here hmm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00271-00091169-00091379": "remind me of what number you guessed", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00272-00091380-00091838": "again you said 123 right okay all right", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00273-00091839-00092099": "so I know 100 is correct I know 20 is", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00274-00092100-00092224": "correct", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00275-00092225-00092542": "and that last number can't be a three it", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00276-00092543-00092737": "also can't be a four or a seven or an", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00277-00092738-00092899": "eight because you told me bagel before", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00278-00092900-00093799": "on 478 so I'm gonna say 125 you have fer", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00279-00093800-00094326": "me fer me bagel okay", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00280-00094327-00095407": "126 you have fer me fer me fer me thanks", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00281-00095408-00095700": "red man that was fun", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00282-00095701-00096195": "your turn now yes okay all right", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00283-00096196-00096493": "do not tell miss Redmond are you gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00284-00096494-00096625": "cover your eyes or you're gonna look", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00285-00096626-00096817": "down what are you gonna do okay", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00286-00096818-00097066": "put my shades on and promise to have my", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00287-00097067-00097684": "eyes shut all right let me ask the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00288-00097685-00097933": "question can sum of the digits be the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00289-00097934-00098161": "same absolutely", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00290-00098162-00099283": "okay um all right here is my number", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00291-00099284-00099715": "don't say anything to miss Redmond all", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00292-00099716-00099820": "right what's your first guess miss", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00293-00099821-00100503": "retina my first guest mr. robear is 444", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00294-00100504-00101167": "bagel bagel bagel ah okay my next guess", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00295-00101168-00102061": "is 312 bagel bagel bagel all right I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00296-00102062-00102304": "gotta make myself some notes so I know", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00297-00102305-00102691": "that there are no force and there's no", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00298-00102692-00103045": "three there's no one and no to your", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00299-00103046-00103366": "right friends this is what I'm gonna do", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00300-00103367-00103971": "0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 & 9", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00301-00103972-00104416": "mr. robear really quickly I want to show", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00302-00104417-00104647": "something in the camera oh you can look", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00303-00104648-00104781": "up I'm not showing anything right now", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00304-00104782-00105199": "okay can you see what I'm holding up so", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00305-00105200-00105424": "you wrote all the numbers from 0 to 9", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00306-00105425-00105607": "and so", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00307-00105608-00106120": "I am going to get rid of the four I'm", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00308-00106121-00106357": "gonna get rid of the three I'm gonna get", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00309-00106358-00106549": "rid of the wine and I'm gonna get rid of", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00310-00106550-00106800": "the two so now I know these are the only", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00311-00106801-00107013": "ones I can guess that's helping you keep", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00312-00107014-00107308": "track that's helping me keep track okay", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00313-00107308-00107753": "what's your next guess my next guest is", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00314-00107754-00108939": "567 bagel bagel bagel Wow", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00315-00108940-00109128": "keep looking down miss Redmond I'm gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00316-00109129-00109515": "show and to remind everybody here's the", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00317-00109516-00109776": "number that I chose and here her guests", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00318-00109777-00110083": "is so far and you can see it's bagel", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00319-00110083-00110368": "every time all right you can look up", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00320-00110369-00110770": "again okay mr. Roper bear my next guest", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00321-00110771-00111525": "is um 890 can I can I show these guys", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00322-00111526-00111729": "really quickly while I'm choosing 890", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00323-00111730-00112249": "sure I'm choosing 890 because I crossed", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00324-00112250-00112715": "out all the only ones left", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00325-00112716-00113528": "okay 890 bagel Piko Piko", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00326-00113529-00114213": "okay 890 bagel Piko Piko", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00327-00114214-00114772": "so I know that my 8 is in the wrong it's", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00328-00114773-00115420": "the wrong place in the wrong number Piko", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00329-00115421-00116439": "Piko correct wrong place so we're gonna", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00330-00116440-00118168": "do 900 and okay 908 now remember when", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00331-00118169-00118563": "you guessed 890 before for that I said", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00332-00118564-00118986": "bagel also there's no", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00333-00118988-00119290": "nothing correct when you said I'm sorry", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00334-00119291-00119668": "no when you said 894 the first digit I", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00335-00119669-00120274": "said bagel for the eat right okay so", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00336-00120275-00120478": "okay mister robear", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00337-00120479-00121833": "what about 909 good job miss Redman", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00338-00121834-00122149": "good job to Mister robear this has been", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00339-00122150-00122440": "so much fun thank you so much for", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00340-00122441-00122626": "playing with me and I can't wait to grow", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00341-00122627-00122857": "my lima beans I can't wait to eat your", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00342-00122858-00123169": "lima beans have a good mass when you go", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00343-00123170-00123454": "out stay safe absolutely I've kept it", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00344-00123455-00123838": "very close take care of miss Redman take", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00345-00123839-00124357": "care mr. robear bye", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00346-00124358-00125408": "[Music]", "iiBVTzCzkJy-00347-00125409-00125616": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "iiNB0bJ2u_4", "text": {"iiNB0bJ2u_4-00000-00000026-00000655": "I was young for a moment in our Cabana", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00001-00000656-00000958": "Sabrina and omakase Eugenia I will go", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00002-00000959-00001195": "Presbyterian Hospital Children's Ward", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00003-00001196-00001591": "sort of em yeah by a notch si yeah Bobby", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00004-00001592-00001901": "Bois any pbi only be a boy we are say", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00005-00001902-00002134": "away nipple area on one not just our", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00006-00002135-00002405": "chakra and you know Children's Ward me", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00007-00002406-00002615": "about Madrid a blowhard and Ababa a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00008-00002616-00002900": "Serbia say orbit Lucrezia", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00009-00002901-00003146": "I'm alpha Danny you know chronic aqua SM", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00010-00003147-00003386": "ent so tell me any opinion for you by", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00011-00003386-00003761": "Anna sage mono and yeah ba ba ba ba na", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00012-00003761-00004031": "ya WOM WOM woman me be you know obeah", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00013-00004032-00004244": "bad i asabi apna watch your back when i", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00014-00004245-00004438": "watch em you know ultimately a component", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00015-00004439-00004786": "campus a well free a cofee UNT yeah by", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00016-00004787-00005038": "myself or no and yeah babe wah-wah-wah", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00017-00005039-00005276": "Amani amici miei Col Tigh Adama woman", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00018-00005277-00005593": "since Union won if you chica can Jones", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00019-00005594-00005836": "means your mobiles and a vpat sincere", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00020-00005837-00005951": "llamo bites on my body", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00021-00005952-00006317": "neva church in Como among how any m AI", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00022-00006318-00006545": "bi CI Ohio's audience I mean she s", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00023-00006545-00007449": "anyone beats me up well until now by", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00024-00007450-00008378": "noon Allison knew who Allison Java foods", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00025-00008379-00009500": "McCarty", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00026-00009501-00009831": "Children's Hospital yes we are glad to", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00027-00009832-00010479": "have you around so a lot of the parents", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00028-00010480-00010881": "here usually afford in medical bills for", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00029-00010882-00011058": "the children it's a headache", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00030-00011059-00011324": "yes so most of them come and then", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00031-00011325-00011588": "medication general able to get their", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00032-00011589-00011829": "money even if we have to do some", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00033-00011830-00012012": "procedures and all that's quite a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00034-00012013-00012270": "challenge they have enough in taxes", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00035-00012271-00012477": "where we have to do some small survive", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00036-00012478-00012677": "collection you know just to be luci how", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00037-00012678-00012950": "about some of them yes so it's good I", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00038-00012951-00013300": "are here and you'll really benefit a lot", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00039-00013301-00013991": "yeah so for this boy so he had what we", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00040-00013993-00014340": "call a bone infection okay so sometimes", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00041-00014341-00014535": "the children gets these infections and", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00042-00014536-00014682": "yeah bones by his wound", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00043-00014683-00014868": "I've been going on for a very long time", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00044-00014869-00015081": "I said he had to actually send into", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00045-00015082-00015455": "tiata then go and make a very huge", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00046-00015456-00015681": "incision and seek also lots of the dead", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00047-00015682-00015894": "bone that's when I just waiting for the", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00048-00015894-00016253": "wind to look very clean then he also go", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00049-00016254-00016472": "back to theater again because the way", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00050-00016473-00016650": "the wound is so quick you will not be", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00051-00016651-00016833": "able to heal by itself they have to go", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00052-00016834-00017037": "and do something that we called a skin", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00053-00017038-00017319": "graft and we're also having some skin", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00054-00017320-00017478": "from some other hearing is it too close", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00055-00017479-00017703": "they won't wait to do so he still has a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00056-00017704-00018047": "long way to go yes for several months", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00057-00018048-00018591": "now in your opinion what is the lady's", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00058-00018592-00018953": "challenge it's mainly yes so mainly", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00059-00018954-00019244": "finances in terms of being able to", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00060-00019245-00019447": "afford his medications", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00061-00019448-00019692": "they having been a few instances which", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00062-00019693-00019844": "is actually confided in a few of us", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00063-00019845-00020064": "seeing with money to get food sweets and", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00064-00020065-00020374": "all that is a challenge yeah", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00065-00020375-00020853": "to be double cool what's on your frozen", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00066-00020854-00021883": "face Allison kind of I said I want you", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00067-00021884-00022324": "like a cow to all community nearby until", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00068-00022325-00022824": "Veronica cry between the Warren Report", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00069-00022825-00022956": "honestly", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00070-00022957-00023247": "okay declare war baby icy sandwich", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00071-00023248-00023707": "million", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00072-00023708-00025384": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00073-00025385-00026206": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00074-00026207-00027833": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00075-00027833-00028462": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00076-00028463-00028632": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00077-00028633-00029676": "[Applause]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00078-00029677-00030030": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00079-00030031-00030395": "OSHA for will mommy or the Faizal", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00080-00030395-00030710": "al-hasan nah the back Abba daya sabi", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00081-00030711-00030932": "almost a week", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00082-00030933-00031385": "nein nein oh sure acronym Maya three", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00083-00031386-00031558": "months here's a three months cry let's", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00084-00031559-00031876": "say one more other hand watch a nice", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00085-00031877-00032176": "accustomed any I've been to crack on", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00086-00032177-00032467": "when she not just say a ma me mi Olivet", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00087-00032468-00032773": "mi a-- sorts media GHB drew Harvell", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00088-00032774-00033201": "Nemea Daruma how much me each year a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00089-00033202-00033526": "chronica am i a castle crab roe a biack", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00090-00033527-00034186": "HD and the faisal an ordinary fighter", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00091-00034187-00034286": "okay", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00092-00034287-00034573": "Adina or burqa at the a chair salts", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00093-00034574-00035655": "medium pinafore idea all my ammo okay no", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00094-00035656-00035968": "BB sir National War and it does should", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00095-00035969-00036208": "be say be disabled to me se walkway new", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00096-00036209-00037174": "prepare because a surprise mama by OSHA", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00097-00037175-00037661": "OSHA Iran wha nummy geodon America but", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00098-00037662-00038026": "all the same no yeah me Adorama swords", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00099-00038027-00038357": "media gh opinion for Ababa Chia one an", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00100-00038358-00038701": "abandon haka and you know Nadia involved", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00101-00038702-00039086": "in an accident and with the way he", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00102-00039087-00039382": "presents it in bigger facilities well he", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00103-00039383-00039795": "needs us any emergency head CT scan", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00104-00039796-00040067": "where if he's bleeding into the brain", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00105-00040068-00040321": "then do be able to rush into theater and", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00106-00040322-00040586": "be able to do some surgery to decompress", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00107-00040587-00040799": "but because we don't have that's", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00108-00040800-00041054": "facility here yes I would sorry Farrell", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00109-00041055-00041182": "for them said they could take it to", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00110-00041183-00041279": "confirm not sure", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00111-00041280-00041630": "so you could get it done but the cost of", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00112-00041631-00041996": "a CT scan today for a child is expensive", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00113-00041997-00042254": "so they couldn't afford this at all so", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00114-00042255-00042562": "the object stay here and for us to", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00115-00042563-00042727": "manage in a conservative way which", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00116-00042728-00042896": "really really wasn't the best for him", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00117-00042897-00043220": "so by God's grace in seems to have", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00118-00043221-00043474": "recovered a little bird and I stole some", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00119-00043475-00043757": "neurological and deficit when he's on", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00120-00043758-00043961": "the ward if you don't watch and you just", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00121-00043962-00044290": "get out leave the word you just say that", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00122-00044291-00045227": "he's going home and it's a challenge", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00123-00045228-00045508": "yeah that's why and what Children's Ward", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00124-00045509-00045845": "hey I will go praise be hospital and or", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00125-00045846-00046160": "share my mu in schwa HSN the back nabob", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00126-00046161-00046414": "way I would say hey when your accident", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00127-00046415-00046643": "and I didn't Emma be brave yeah Cassie", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00128-00046644-00046892": "crevasse a or more it just convenient a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00129-00046893-00047149": "nice accustomed and also Shopify a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00130-00047150-00047504": "problem and won't you know salt media gh", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00131-00047505-00047717": "opinion for such as a mommy will Union", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00132-00047718-00047987": "is Appa a barrister a Kabir", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00133-00047988-00048260": "and I said CK be our new here our", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00134-00048261-00048485": "developer yes I am an honest or the", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00135-00048486-00048643": "mission even oh you betcha", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00136-00048644-00049090": "Amarante on also you Chiana capodanno a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00137-00049091-00049339": "doctor forbidden a national I'm an", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00138-00049340-00049742": "admission it Adam mommy my dream you a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00139-00049743-00050068": "at the fair fire swords media gh opinion", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00140-00050069-00051112": "for I you know at da and I be controlled", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00141-00051113-00051419": "I and I saw no Bay our hey number we", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00142-00051420-00051779": "need a so baby say socata for crappy", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00143-00051779-00052025": "idea Chakradhar no now when he does", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00144-00052026-00052276": "should be say on sample a Becca Nadia", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00145-00052277-00052853": "Shobhana you and scheana DN a croc", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00146-00052854-00053129": "runner I didn't have a catchy Pena what", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00147-00053129-00053992": "that edge make we know what about you", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00148-00053994-00054701": "you can't Dennis a enemy number one baby", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00149-00054702-00055276": "for me", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00150-00055277-00055948": "yeah and she had a say mommy", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00151-00055949-00056368": "Mucha for mojo no no more choir", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00152-00056369-00056769": "Juma know China be area their de arriba", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00153-00056770-00056980": "she actually believe idea", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00154-00056982-00057254": "9si they will be decremented Muni but", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00155-00057254-00058234": "Rogers a shaman an iguana a branch is so", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00156-00058235-00058618": "New Year a and then a BA a cranny yeah", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00157-00058619-00058918": "moja seeker some see calm debate so", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00158-00058919-00059218": "moosa' and they a drugs and Murayama", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00159-00059219-00059431": "Cochran and also see a problem and", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00160-00059432-00059719": "results media gh Symphony for suicide by", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00161-00059720-00060031": "winner in China or no media BBB ominous", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00162-00060032-00060319": "are many PhD across a or drew via alpha", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00163-00060320-00060596": "a second ocean conveyor Jima now a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00164-00060597-00060866": "branch a Chino adding and you know I", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00165-00060866-00061175": "received mushroom say or the shots media", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00166-00061176-00061523": "GNP new finance a Nami animo casino", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00167-00061524-00061772": "instrument which me Ababa bueno", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00168-00061773-00061963": "I was up in a whistle I wish I have for", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00169-00061964-00062092": "a day", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00170-00062094-00062423": "yeah donation Nibbana be a source media", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00171-00062424-00062561": "GH oh my back", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00172-00062562-00062774": "I will go Presbyterian Hospital oh my", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00173-00062775-00063013": "bap a year donation Ababa Bank rafflesia", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00174-00063014-00063319": "bin Omicron multimedia Omata edema Becca", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00175-00063320-00063503": "the Alpha at the Feria", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00176-00063504-00063899": "oppose we your pajama dance in u.s.", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00177-00063900-00064126": "embassy Erica mmm oh it's here for new", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00178-00064127-00064412": "Asha for Nina agile now yesterday so be", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00179-00064413-00064669": "a behind me a waka video the VI Acosta", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00180-00064670-00064831": "bicep you can Co V do handsome because", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00181-00064832-00065088": "even by a very simple save a boy home by", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00182-00065089-00065341": "mechanics area not matter make us a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00183-00065342-00065648": "salts media GH now come on Jerome oh let", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00184-00065649-00065869": "me say Astarte nyan nyan cat song da", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00185-00065870-00066230": "chakra anytime via an amoeba Schiano", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00186-00066231-00066487": "a Anaya same day and I say good news", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00187-00066488-00066757": "comedy by a South media for Baja", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00188-00066758-00066866": "I may add", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00189-00066867-00067178": "be brave I know mommy Brian sumir Papa", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00190-00067179-00067355": "because it's me you sudhi boy a home", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00191-00067356-00067643": "buyer for a long time the South media da", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00192-00067644-00067865": "Amadeu Komatsu Panama nice a hospital", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00193-00067866-00068165": "sue Adama Camacho muy bien esta mañana", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00194-00068166-00068300": "ha ha", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00195-00068301-00068624": "Johanna mobis a banana Nasri baby on", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00196-00068625-00068882": "koala premature foreign a UN Kofi in", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00197-00068883-00069242": "Temenos idioma to ammonia DNI be mama no", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00198-00069243-00069422": "Massa common bacteria need Akana", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00199-00069423-00069680": "Eddie and Sue no source media for ba", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00200-00069681-00069902": "Hanauma Bay Oh Madre invested enormous", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00201-00069903-00070157": "spending cycle more than 100 old Ghana", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00202-00070158-00070373": "Cedis hundred million men who Jeremy", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00203-00070374-00070643": "Pargo Sankofa by Adobe Adobe are doing", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00204-00070644-00070958": "but nahyun visa a de ensino a Nozomi a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00205-00070959-00071297": "Inanna a big milestone NNN soy baa baa", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00206-00071298-00071558": "hainkai be Quan Chi Yan Zi Shi a mobile", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00207-00071559-00071906": "app a koala Bao anh cried Emma Hikari OC", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00208-00071907-00072113": "- coke Inferno cheap-ass DeCosta Munna", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00209-00072114-00072164": "eating", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00210-00072165-00072479": "Sun media abba-abba-abba be bueno tea", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00211-00072480-00072731": "cozy on coupons result media anonym", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00212-00072732-00073067": "painting for Madonna - inna dimension", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00213-00073068-00073310": "movie Bree nah baby para muy sacani a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00214-00073311-00073583": "hoarding free knock open somos an emo", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00215-00073584-00073811": "legend a hospital in a pen a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00216-00073812-00074123": "misallocation general manager enemy boss", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00217-00074124-00074426": "me seduce any hospital telephone - inna", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00218-00074427-00074708": "animo Andaman Sea epidermis - because", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00219-00074709-00074936": "sometimes it's me o be everywhere", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00220-00074937-00075251": "absconded patients so Coco chef Odessa", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00221-00075252-00075536": "Google Anissa cazuca do drunk of orogeny", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00222-00075537-00075815": "Obama nominee Serbia needs immunity", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00223-00075816-00076121": "nevada new Abuna be ocean alba da da da", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00224-00076122-00076229": "da da NHS a", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00225-00076230-00076544": "Oh Kofi decide any - Adama bah bah", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00226-00076545-00076796": "estimate see absconded patient will need", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00227-00076797-00077066": "to be a my Jacuzzi on coupon in sham", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00228-00077067-00077378": "esta casa da Xia even rebel yeah one", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00229-00077379-00077627": "person cry I'm a Bahama do ye na kabhi", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00230-00077628-00077939": "na Midori sue Nonya or da who crowns me", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00231-00077940-00077990": "Nancy", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00232-00077991-00078218": "I met Mia pajamas on eBay are the BIA", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00233-00078219-00078632": "conscience them na mano a casa da NE", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00234-00078633-00078936": "insurer income", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00235-00078937-00080039": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00236-00080040-00080929": "[Music]", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00237-00080930-00081209": "you", "iiNB0bJ2u_4-00238-00081210-00081573": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "ij3zg_Vz_SE", "text": {"ij3zg_Vz_SE-00000-00002458-00002700": "to a really special event that's being", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00001-00002701-00003033": "held in in Khartoum Sudan this is the", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00002-00003034-00003224": "first TEDx event that will be held in", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00003-00003225-00003393": "Sudan they're actually planning for a", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00004-00003394-00003629": "full-fledged TEDx later this year in", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00005-00003630-00003897": "November the TEDx organizer who's doing", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00006-00003897-00004140": "this is a very close to our heart his", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00007-00004141-00004374": "name is on Mars alpha Allah he has", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00008-00004375-00004614": "single-handedly translated or than 500", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00009-00004615-00005018": "TED talks into Arabic and so let's go", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00010-00005019-00005867": "out to all more now", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00011-00005868-00006311": "you", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00012-00006312-00006556": "on Warren everyone in cartoon we're", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00013-00006558-00006784": "thinking about you and with you we just", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00014-00006786-00007096": "we are so admire your just your your", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00015-00007097-00007345": "courage and grace and we're just feel so", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00016-00007347-00007589": "energized just seeing you out there so", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00017-00007590-00007771": "we'll keep in touch through the", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00018-00007772-00007939": "conference and well done we're so", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00019-00007940-00008106": "grateful for your work and we're", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00020-00008108-00008381": "thinking of you and wishing you sapien", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00021-00008382-00008558": "and lose a fortune through the", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00022-00008559-00010683": "conference", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00023-00010684-00012036": "No", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00024-00012037-00013559": "oh my", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00025-00013560-00014969": "none of the high pitches", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00026-00014969-00017385": "good", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00027-00017386-00018681": "No", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00028-00018682-00020354": "and in with an admin", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00029-00020355-00021226": "7-11 370 group", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00030-00021227-00022424": "oh yeah", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00031-00022425-00022580": "Oh", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00032-00022581-00029462": "Wow", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00033-00029463-00030168": "you", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00034-00030169-00030451": "is the cool okay allo volunteers coolin", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00035-00030452-00030763": "ajinomoto in bass ana pasaron volunteers", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00036-00030764-00030973": "well-organized restaurant is a photo", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00037-00030974-00037247": "unionization boom sushi bar", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00038-00037248-00040508": "uh", "ij3zg_Vz_SE-00039-00040509-00040715": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "ijjyZHD0d10", "text": {"ijjyZHD0d10-00000-00000913-00001136": "hey guys welcome back to the channel my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00001-00001137-00001289": "name is Brad from Kinder Martina cross", "ijjyZHD0d10-00002-00001290-00001472": "nation and today we're having a bit of a", "ijjyZHD0d10-00003-00001473-00001739": "small update video in order to go over", "ijjyZHD0d10-00004-00001739-00002138": "the avatar boards I came out today which", "ijjyZHD0d10-00005-00002139-00002508": "came with some very much needed skills", "ijjyZHD0d10-00006-00002509-00003191": "for us as well as a small error update", "ijjyZHD0d10-00007-00003192-00003458": "that that has gone on because you're", "ijjyZHD0d10-00008-00003459-00003634": "starting off with the error and that", "ijjyZHD0d10-00009-00003635-00003974": "that happened ok Senna has made a small", "ijjyZHD0d10-00010-00003975-00004388": "update regarding towards the VIP for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00011-00004389-00004583": "this week and as you can see here they", "ijjyZHD0d10-00012-00004584-00005167": "even updated the current weekly VIP deal", "ijjyZHD0d10-00013-00005168-00005447": "notice to include the the update error", "ijjyZHD0d10-00014-00005448-00005615": "and stuff like that and they basically", "ijjyZHD0d10-00015-00005616-00005891": "mentioned in this error update that pick", "ijjyZHD0d10-00016-00005892-00006100": "us a fact that they placed the wrong", "ijjyZHD0d10-00017-00006101-00006397": "multiplier for the tune axle and Pluto", "ijjyZHD0d10-00018-00006398-00006760": "metal for this week's VIP but because of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00019-00006761-00006953": "the fact that they mistype that by", "ijjyZHD0d10-00020-00006954-00007088": "accident they're gonna be sending", "ijjyZHD0d10-00021-00007089-00007466": "everyone who purchased the VIP deal and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00022-00007467-00007723": "everyone else who will purchase the VIP", "ijjyZHD0d10-00023-00007725-00007942": "deal for any time this week so even if", "ijjyZHD0d10-00024-00007943-00008120": "you did it by already if you buy any", "ijjyZHD0d10-00025-00008120-00008270": "time throughout the week you will still", "ijjyZHD0d10-00026-00008271-00008692": "get a Fantasia McBee medal and we will", "ijjyZHD0d10-00027-00008693-00008867": "be getting the Fantasia make it be metal", "ijjyZHD0d10-00028-00008868-00009149": "on the 21st which is the monday ok one", "ijjyZHD0d10-00029-00009150-00009371": "when via when the week resets basically", "ijjyZHD0d10-00030-00009372-00009530": "but there at least I think it was very", "ijjyZHD0d10-00031-00009531-00009764": "generous of them to do so and at the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00032-00009765-00009935": "release I'm appreciative of the fact", "ijjyZHD0d10-00033-00009936-00010055": "that they're giving that out to", "ijjyZHD0d10-00034-00010056-00010238": "everybody so I wanted to cover that at", "ijjyZHD0d10-00035-00010239-00010481": "the very least but aside from that so", "ijjyZHD0d10-00036-00010482-00010799": "this week's captain goofy avatar boards", "ijjyZHD0d10-00037-00010800-00011138": "alright there are 2500 rules a piece for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00038-00011139-00011378": "each board which honestly for what we're", "ijjyZHD0d10-00039-00011379-00011552": "getting I honestly don't think like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00040-00011553-00011689": "that's actually pretty good that's", "ijjyZHD0d10-00041-00011690-00012095": "pretty decent but this is what we get ok", "ijjyZHD0d10-00042-00012096-00012299": "so ignoring all the other other stuff", "ijjyZHD0d10-00043-00012300-00012512": "okay so like who cares like not caring", "ijjyZHD0d10-00044-00012513-00012739": "about the magic mirrors and brooms and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00045-00012740-00012890": "whatnot the gems whatever good the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00046-00012891-00013016": "skills that we're actually getting in", "ijjyZHD0d10-00047-00013016-00013328": "this is a tech boost 6 max", "ijjyZHD0d10-00048-00013329-00013655": "gage - along with attack boost 5x and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00049-00013656-00014144": "Lux + + that's new as well as defense", "ijjyZHD0d10-00050-00014144-00014395": "boost for skills okay that's where", "ijjyZHD0d10-00051-00014396-00014603": "you're getting at each of the Avatar", "ijjyZHD0d10-00052-00014604-00014774": "boards so essentially if you can get", "ijjyZHD0d10-00053-00014775-00015013": "both avatar boards you'll be getting 4", "ijjyZHD0d10-00054-00015015-00015296": "attack boost max skills which is very", "ijjyZHD0d10-00055-00015297-00015538": "much needed and as well as one of them", "ijjyZHD0d10-00056-00015540-00015766": "being a Lux + + skill which is a", "ijjyZHD0d10-00057-00015768-00016117": "completely new type of like a ability or", "ijjyZHD0d10-00058-00016118-00016355": "a completely new type of skill within", "ijjyZHD0d10-00059-00016356-00016742": "the game which I know lot lots of Lux", "ijjyZHD0d10-00060-00016743-00016889": "farmers out there are gonna be going", "ijjyZHD0d10-00061-00016890-00017131": "absolutely nuts for and honestly I'm", "ijjyZHD0d10-00062-00017132-00017434": "excited doubt it if maybe even next week", "ijjyZHD0d10-00063-00017435-00017803": "we might see another avatar another set", "ijjyZHD0d10-00064-00017804-00018036": "of Avatar boards featuring like the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00065-00018037-00018350": "magician Donald avatar boards cuz I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00066-00018351-00018677": "believe JP got that like within the same", "ijjyZHD0d10-00067-00018678-00018961": "time period that the captain goofy", "ijjyZHD0d10-00068-00018962-00019294": "avatar boys came out so this this might", "ijjyZHD0d10-00069-00019295-00019727": "honestly be Senna's way of helping us", "ijjyZHD0d10-00070-00019728-00019969": "get our skills back which I mean on my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00071-00019970-00020225": "part I feel a little bad cuz I spent I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00072-00020226-00020378": "spent a little bit of time putting", "ijjyZHD0d10-00073-00020379-00020693": "together this meme for this for our next", "ijjyZHD0d10-00074-00020694-00021074": "Twitter raid if needed but I figured I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00075-00021075-00021452": "would wait until the near the end of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00076-00021453-00021758": "when the stained-glass avatar banners", "ijjyZHD0d10-00077-00021759-00022009": "are going to end first because I I kind", "ijjyZHD0d10-00078-00022010-00022237": "of already thira theorized that some", "ijjyZHD0d10-00079-00022238-00022378": "avatar boards would be coming near the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00080-00022379-00022574": "end of the time when the stained-glass", "ijjyZHD0d10-00081-00022575-00022871": "metals would be ending anyways and I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00082-00022872-00022981": "wanted to wait to the end of the week", "ijjyZHD0d10-00083-00022982-00023180": "because especially since they already", "ijjyZHD0d10-00084-00023181-00023324": "announced that they're that like these", "ijjyZHD0d10-00085-00023325-00023455": "boards were to come out so I wanted to", "ijjyZHD0d10-00086-00023456-00023614": "see what was coming out first before I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00087-00023615-00023872": "before I start any new type of Twitter", "ijjyZHD0d10-00088-00023873-00024164": "raid but these do contain if you get", "ijjyZHD0d10-00089-00024165-00024527": "both you do get four new attack boost", "ijjyZHD0d10-00090-00024528-00024817": "mexico´s which is very much needed we", "ijjyZHD0d10-00091-00024818-00025021": "still have a lot of metals that they", "ijjyZHD0d10-00092-00025022-00025289": "popped out at us that we would still", "ijjyZHD0d10-00093-00025290-00025699": "need attack skills for but at the very", "ijjyZHD0d10-00094-00025700-00026002": "least yeah we're not like at a constant", "ijjyZHD0d10-00095-00026003-00026243": "drought anymore it's more like we're", "ijjyZHD0d10-00096-00026244-00026470": "still a little dehydrated", "ijjyZHD0d10-00097-00026472-00026699": "but the very least we're not like on the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00098-00026700-00027272": "brink of death of thirst but in terms of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00099-00027273-00027470": "the skills this is what I want to", "ijjyZHD0d10-00100-00027470-00027733": "suggest about it depending on where you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00101-00027735-00027929": "are right now like as it right now for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00102-00027930-00028235": "me I personally I'm going to personally", "ijjyZHD0d10-00103-00028236-00028570": "save these attack blues max skills", "ijjyZHD0d10-00104-00028570-00028841": "solely because well because it's like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00105-00028842-00029051": "couple reasons um the first one being", "ijjyZHD0d10-00106-00029052-00029213": "that's solely because the effect I have", "ijjyZHD0d10-00107-00029214-00029608": "absolutely no idea as to when is going", "ijjyZHD0d10-00108-00029610-00029993": "to be the next time that they're gonna", "ijjyZHD0d10-00109-00029994-00030197": "release an avatar board with good skills", "ijjyZHD0d10-00110-00030198-00030320": "like this one all right", "ijjyZHD0d10-00111-00030320-00030527": "I have absolutely no idea they could", "ijjyZHD0d10-00112-00030527-00030872": "take two months again like they did last", "ijjyZHD0d10-00113-00030873-00031250": "time until you know just now to release", "ijjyZHD0d10-00114-00031251-00031466": "more avatar skills so it's like I I'm", "ijjyZHD0d10-00115-00031467-00031615": "gonna be saving these and I'm only gonna", "ijjyZHD0d10-00116-00031616-00031864": "be using them when I actually need to", "ijjyZHD0d10-00117-00031866-00032117": "use them all right so just to kind of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00118-00032118-00032399": "give you guys an example let me let me", "ijjyZHD0d10-00119-00032400-00032555": "look at let me show you guys something", "ijjyZHD0d10-00120-00032556-00032675": "that like kind of happened to me", "ijjyZHD0d10-00121-00032676-00032954": "recently after I got these avatar boy", "ijjyZHD0d10-00122-00032955-00033146": "skills okay so like let's look let's", "ijjyZHD0d10-00123-00033147-00033284": "look at this okay actually I'm gonna", "ijjyZHD0d10-00124-00033285-00033548": "look at all my medals right just", "ijjyZHD0d10-00125-00033549-00033764": "recently I was looking at potentially", "ijjyZHD0d10-00126-00033765-00034034": "giving either one or two of my medals", "ijjyZHD0d10-00127-00034035-00034375": "the attack boost Max and Lux + + skill", "ijjyZHD0d10-00128-00034376-00034715": "pick team to help out my raid boss luck", "ijjyZHD0d10-00129-00034716-00034994": "setups and whatnot okay so let me show", "ijjyZHD0d10-00130-00034995-00035302": "you guys this so if I organize this by", "ijjyZHD0d10-00131-00035303-00035596": "raid boss treats alright and I'm only", "ijjyZHD0d10-00132-00035597-00035777": "gonna look at my tier six and seven", "ijjyZHD0d10-00133-00035778-00035987": "medals because that's what I want to try", "ijjyZHD0d10-00134-00035988-00036206": "to use it possible or my six my six and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00135-00036207-00036332": "up metal is it possible because that's", "ijjyZHD0d10-00136-00036333-00036467": "what I wanted to use for raid boss", "ijjyZHD0d10-00137-00036468-00036680": "setups now in terms of damage medals", "ijjyZHD0d10-00138-00036681-00036932": "anyways and these are all my medals as", "ijjyZHD0d10-00139-00036933-00037232": "of right now that have that are tier 6", "ijjyZHD0d10-00140-00037233-00037442": "or higher that have raid boss traits", "ijjyZHD0d10-00141-00037443-00037664": "alright now there's a few medals in here", "ijjyZHD0d10-00142-00037665-00037865": "that I actually was particularly", "ijjyZHD0d10-00143-00037866-00038186": "interested in possibly giving some luck", "ijjyZHD0d10-00144-00038187-00038479": "skills to alright one of them being my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00145-00038480-00038774": "my Kingdom Hearts 3 King Mickey X", "ijjyZHD0d10-00146-00038775-00038963": "because he does have two raid boss", "ijjyZHD0d10-00147-00038964-00039265": "traits on him and he doesn't have a", "ijjyZHD0d10-00148-00039266-00039461": "Mexico on him so I could very easily", "ijjyZHD0d10-00149-00039462-00039737": "just give him the lux + + skill because", "ijjyZHD0d10-00150-00039738-00039827": "it is a Mexico", "ijjyZHD0d10-00151-00039828-00040178": "- alright and same thing would be said", "ijjyZHD0d10-00152-00040179-00040490": "for my HD final form sore as well", "ijjyZHD0d10-00153-00040491-00040673": "because he also has to raid boss traits", "ijjyZHD0d10-00154-00040674-00041114": "on him and but and like having a Lux + +", "ijjyZHD0d10-00155-00041115-00041306": "skill on it will just be like absolutely", "ijjyZHD0d10-00156-00041307-00041620": "fantastic for like Lux set up some stuff", "ijjyZHD0d10-00157-00041621-00041894": "however what I kind of want to point out", "ijjyZHD0d10-00158-00041895-00042212": "for this is the fact that like don't", "ijjyZHD0d10-00159-00042213-00042464": "just because you have the skills don't", "ijjyZHD0d10-00160-00042465-00042782": "just waste them automatically I know", "ijjyZHD0d10-00161-00042783-00042971": "some people like because the fact that", "ijjyZHD0d10-00162-00042972-00043172": "we finally got skills after a long-ass", "ijjyZHD0d10-00163-00043173-00043580": "time you might start being a little", "ijjyZHD0d10-00164-00043581-00043727": "trigger-happy and just wasting your", "ijjyZHD0d10-00165-00043728-00043922": "skills of a sudden and this is kind of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00166-00043923-00044057": "like the kind of example I want to show", "ijjyZHD0d10-00167-00044058-00044296": "you guys so one thing in the idea and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00168-00044297-00044525": "that you guys should also do when you're", "ijjyZHD0d10-00169-00044526-00044684": "trying to figure out what type of raid", "ijjyZHD0d10-00170-00044685-00044951": "boss or Lux setups and stuff that you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00171-00044952-00045080": "should they want to try and put together", "ijjyZHD0d10-00172-00045081-00045488": "is first of all go to your keyblades", "ijjyZHD0d10-00173-00045489-00045740": "okay and you want to basically try and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00174-00045741-00045980": "construct what you would hopefully would", "ijjyZHD0d10-00175-00045981-00046352": "want your future luck setups to be and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00176-00046353-00046700": "I'll be making a future raid boss Lux", "ijjyZHD0d10-00177-00046701-00046973": "setup guide in the future but they vary", "ijjyZHD0d10-00178-00046974-00047069": "at least I'm gonna give you some like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00179-00047070-00047564": "quick tips for this at least for this so", "ijjyZHD0d10-00180-00047565-00047702": "because the fact there's three different", "ijjyZHD0d10-00181-00047703-00047846": "attributes in the game three main", "ijjyZHD0d10-00182-00047847-00048005": "attributes in the game power speed and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00183-00048006-00048346": "magic you want to try and hopefully", "ijjyZHD0d10-00184-00048347-00048650": "create at least one Keyblade set up", "ijjyZHD0d10-00185-00048651-00048977": "towards each of those attributes if", "ijjyZHD0d10-00186-00048978-00049196": "possible if you have enough medals to do", "ijjyZHD0d10-00187-00049197-00049430": "so if you don't you can obviously go", "ijjyZHD0d10-00188-00049431-00049592": "down to two or even just one and just", "ijjyZHD0d10-00189-00049593-00049796": "use that one for like everything but", "ijjyZHD0d10-00190-00049797-00049898": "there at least you want to try and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00191-00049899-00050162": "create setups in advance so that way you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00192-00050163-00050312": "already have an idea as to like which", "ijjyZHD0d10-00193-00050313-00050594": "medals would you prefer to add Lux +", "ijjyZHD0d10-00194-00050595-00050906": "skills and such - alright so like for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00195-00050907-00051127": "example right here I have on my sleeping", "ijjyZHD0d10-00196-00051128-00051407": "line a possible Lux a future", "ijjyZHD0d10-00197-00051408-00051602": "Lux setup that I could possibly use", "ijjyZHD0d10-00198-00051603-00051836": "based off like what my medals currently", "ijjyZHD0d10-00199-00051837-00052073": "have and I haven't put any new skills on", "ijjyZHD0d10-00200-00052074-00052325": "them just yet okay and one thing I want", "ijjyZHD0d10-00201-00052326-00052591": "to basically point out is that like my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00202-00052592-00052907": "key art 16x plus has the raid boss trait", "ijjyZHD0d10-00203-00052908-00052961": "on it", "ijjyZHD0d10-00204-00052962-00053229": "alright my just like a chef", "ijjyZHD0d10-00205-00053230-00053449": "or ht5 for someone has to raid boss", "ijjyZHD0d10-00206-00053450-00053659": "traits on it and then in my spirits lot", "ijjyZHD0d10-00207-00053660-00053938": "I have an illustrated Neku who has to", "ijjyZHD0d10-00208-00053939-00054289": "raid boss trades on him okay so out of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00209-00054290-00054501": "these metals oh oh oh uh so state that", "ijjyZHD0d10-00210-00054502-00054763": "Mikey our buns already has a max uh has", "ijjyZHD0d10-00211-00054764-00054904": "a Lux plus skill on it it doesn't have", "ijjyZHD0d10-00212-00054904-00055116": "any raid boss traits but it does have a", "ijjyZHD0d10-00213-00055117-00055291": "looks plus go so I can use that in my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00214-00055291-00055696": "setup my HD empty forum sword doesn't", "ijjyZHD0d10-00215-00055697-00055969": "have either a lux plus trait or raid", "ijjyZHD0d10-00216-00055970-00056170": "boss but because of the fact that I want", "ijjyZHD0d10-00217-00056171-00056464": "to use this HT ante form store to get", "ijjyZHD0d10-00218-00056465-00056941": "the extra upright debuff off my key art", "ijjyZHD0d10-00219-00056941-00057241": "16x plus I put him there and to set up", "ijjyZHD0d10-00220-00057241-00057388": "as well as because of the fact that like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00221-00057389-00057700": "I'm using our an upright setup and like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00222-00057701-00057879": "that third slots are reversible so I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00223-00057880-00058024": "might as well just put like an C forms", "ijjyZHD0d10-00224-00058025-00058423": "for in that slot in my case oh yeah like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00225-00058424-00058617": "out of these metals in this setup I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00226-00058619-00058954": "would preferably want to put my HT final", "ijjyZHD0d10-00227-00058954-00059200": "form Sora or my illustrator", "ijjyZHD0d10-00228-00059201-00059584": "Neku with the since they both have like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00229-00059585-00059800": "double raid boss traits on them with the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00230-00059801-00060169": "lux + + skill form okay however what you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00231-00060170-00060373": "gotta take into consideration is the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00232-00060374-00060661": "possibility of like other setups as well", "ijjyZHD0d10-00233-00060662-00060850": "so like even though this is my setup", "ijjyZHD0d10-00234-00060851-00061141": "right now I could very easily still run", "ijjyZHD0d10-00235-00061141-00061529": "a like somewhat speeds type setup on my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00236-00061530-00061777": "fairy stars for example as well so like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00237-00061778-00062041": "in this case alright so taking my fairy", "ijjyZHD0d10-00238-00062041-00062269": "stars for example okay this is a", "ijjyZHD0d10-00239-00062270-00062580": "possible luck setups like that I could", "ijjyZHD0d10-00240-00062582-00062794": "use against raid bosses okay and I left", "ijjyZHD0d10-00241-00062795-00062965": "that speed slot open for this like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00242-00062966-00063241": "little example a presentation okay but", "ijjyZHD0d10-00243-00063241-00063514": "all of my metals in this setup aside for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00244-00063515-00063694": "my main buff or debuff for metals right", "ijjyZHD0d10-00245-00063695-00063865": "here in the first two slots if they if", "ijjyZHD0d10-00246-00063866-00064069": "you if like you can give it a luxe plus", "ijjyZHD0d10-00247-00064070-00064254": "kill while having still having second", "ijjyZHD0d10-00248-00064255-00064510": "chance and such that's awesome but you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00249-00064511-00064663": "know it's not required for the first two", "ijjyZHD0d10-00250-00064664-00064984": "medals but the rest of my medals do have", "ijjyZHD0d10-00251-00064985-00065251": "a Lux + skill on them so ideally what I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00252-00065252-00065410": "would want to do for my setup right here", "ijjyZHD0d10-00253-00065411-00065686": "is I would want to put a speed up right", "ijjyZHD0d10-00254-00065687-00065976": "medal right here that has both a raid", "ijjyZHD0d10-00255-00065977-00066181": "boss trait and a Lux Plus skill if", "ijjyZHD0d10-00256-00066182-00066367": "possible and because the fact I am", "ijjyZHD0d10-00257-00066368-00066604": "looking to put a lock + skill", "ijjyZHD0d10-00258-00066605-00066868": "one of my metals I want to look at like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00259-00066869-00067069": "what are the best candidates to put in", "ijjyZHD0d10-00260-00067070-00067267": "that slot so as of right now these are", "ijjyZHD0d10-00261-00067268-00067429": "all my medals all my speed up right", "ijjyZHD0d10-00262-00067430-00067636": "metals that have a raid boss trait on", "ijjyZHD0d10-00263-00067637-00067948": "them now now out of these five medals my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00264-00067949-00068175": "illustrate aqua B already has a Lux +", "ijjyZHD0d10-00265-00068176-00068313": "kill and that has two raid boss traits", "ijjyZHD0d10-00266-00068314-00068647": "my aqua and stitch has a Lux + kill is", "ijjyZHD0d10-00267-00068648-00068860": "not the best attack max skill so I'm", "ijjyZHD0d10-00268-00068861-00069051": "like maybe that could be upgraded but it", "ijjyZHD0d10-00269-00069052-00069310": "does have a raid boss trait but out of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00270-00069311-00069501": "the ones that don't have a Lux + kill", "ijjyZHD0d10-00271-00069502-00069685": "I'll be my HT final form Sora it might", "ijjyZHD0d10-00272-00069686-00069811": "list rated neck you all right", "ijjyZHD0d10-00273-00069812-00069975": "however this is where things get", "ijjyZHD0d10-00274-00069976-00070125": "interesting and this is why I say you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00275-00070126-00070332": "gotta be like you got to start kind of", "ijjyZHD0d10-00276-00070333-00070540": "like taking into account like other", "ijjyZHD0d10-00277-00070541-00070762": "setups and like actually paying", "ijjyZHD0d10-00278-00070763-00070981": "attention to what you put skills on", "ijjyZHD0d10-00279-00070982-00071157": "because the fact that like just because", "ijjyZHD0d10-00280-00071158-00071485": "the metal would be a good like damage", "ijjyZHD0d10-00281-00071486-00071674": "metal for rate for Lux setup doesn't", "ijjyZHD0d10-00282-00071675-00071844": "mean that that's like actually the metal", "ijjyZHD0d10-00283-00071845-00072094": "you would want to have that Lux + skill", "ijjyZHD0d10-00284-00072095-00072322": "on alright and let me show you this for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00285-00072323-00072538": "example okay so like if I put this HD", "ijjyZHD0d10-00286-00072539-00072778": "final form store right here yeah this", "ijjyZHD0d10-00287-00072779-00073000": "setup will still do a lot of damage", "ijjyZHD0d10-00288-00073001-00073267": "however ideally in a normal setup so", "ijjyZHD0d10-00289-00073268-00073429": "outside of a look setup I would", "ijjyZHD0d10-00290-00073430-00073669": "typically want to have my key art 16", "ijjyZHD0d10-00291-00073670-00073866": "right here in the fifth slot instead", "ijjyZHD0d10-00292-00073867-00074188": "because it does provide that upright", "ijjyZHD0d10-00293-00074189-00074481": "defense down debuff okay even helps that", "ijjyZHD0d10-00294-00074482-00074686": "Mont has an extra text so I get like I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00295-00074687-00075006": "get minus four just from himself on top", "ijjyZHD0d10-00296-00075007-00075205": "of I have my Shion copying it and when", "ijjyZHD0d10-00297-00075206-00075373": "it comes to luck setups you guys have to", "ijjyZHD0d10-00298-00075374-00075634": "keep in mind that the more damage that", "ijjyZHD0d10-00299-00075635-00075979": "you can do per metal the more Luck's you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00300-00075980-00076291": "can get as well kind of similar to like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00301-00076292-00076453": "how the high score challenges work the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00302-00076454-00076615": "more damage you can do with the metal", "ijjyZHD0d10-00303-00076616-00076893": "high score challenges more by hits raid", "ijjyZHD0d10-00304-00076894-00077110": "bosses are more alike just in general", "ijjyZHD0d10-00305-00077111-00077215": "the more damage you can do with the", "ijjyZHD0d10-00306-00077216-00077493": "metal the more Luck's you can get so in", "ijjyZHD0d10-00307-00077494-00077668": "this case like I want to try and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00308-00077669-00077872": "maximize my damage output as much as", "ijjyZHD0d10-00309-00077873-00078103": "possible on my setup while still being", "ijjyZHD0d10-00310-00078104-00078367": "able to get like raid boss traits and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00311-00078368-00078493": "putting luck skills on it", "ijjyZHD0d10-00312-00078494-00078799": "so for in this case because of fact that", "ijjyZHD0d10-00313-00078800-00079021": "this set up is just going to naturally", "ijjyZHD0d10-00314-00079022-00079321": "do more damage solely because effect I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00315-00079322-00079738": "have -6 upright defense down d-bus just", "ijjyZHD0d10-00316-00079739-00079926": "from these last two medals right here", "ijjyZHD0d10-00317-00079927-00080040": "that I have and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00318-00080041-00080278": "this setup will do more damage and", "ijjyZHD0d10-00319-00080279-00080578": "potentially get me more lux if I put a", "ijjyZHD0d10-00320-00080579-00080908": "Lux Plus skill on my key art 16 even", "ijjyZHD0d10-00321-00080909-00081055": "though only has one raid boss trait", "ijjyZHD0d10-00322-00081056-00081385": "instead of two compared to using my HT", "ijjyZHD0d10-00323-00081386-00081625": "final form Sora whose ability isn't", "ijjyZHD0d10-00324-00081626-00081886": "gonna do anything besides give me the +1", "ijjyZHD0d10-00325-00081887-00082087": "upright buff because the fact I already", "ijjyZHD0d10-00326-00082088-00082294": "have all my upper uh my general defense", "ijjyZHD0d10-00327-00082295-00082561": "down D buffs maxed out it would just", "ijjyZHD0d10-00328-00082562-00082798": "literally be there for damage so it's", "ijjyZHD0d10-00329-00082799-00082927": "it's those type of things you have to", "ijjyZHD0d10-00330-00082928-00083161": "take into account so because of this", "ijjyZHD0d10-00331-00083162-00083374": "because the fact that like this right", "ijjyZHD0d10-00332-00083375-00083671": "here is a thing we're providing upright", "ijjyZHD0d10-00333-00083672-00083848": "defense down is going to be important", "ijjyZHD0d10-00334-00083849-00084070": "from now and even in the future for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00335-00084071-00084259": "future raid boss setups and such I would", "ijjyZHD0d10-00336-00084260-00084526": "probably want to consider putting a Lux", "ijjyZHD0d10-00337-00084527-00084910": "Plus setup on my key art 16 out of all", "ijjyZHD0d10-00338-00084911-00085120": "of my other speed up right medals", "ijjyZHD0d10-00339-00085121-00085405": "instead even though my other speed up", "ijjyZHD0d10-00340-00085406-00085642": "right Meadows might have more raid boss", "ijjyZHD0d10-00341-00085643-00085987": "traits on them okay so it's it's it's", "ijjyZHD0d10-00342-00085988-00086164": "these type of things they take into", "ijjyZHD0d10-00343-00086165-00086389": "consideration when you get new skills", "ijjyZHD0d10-00344-00086390-00086647": "and such and I'm honestly gonna be", "ijjyZHD0d10-00345-00086648-00087010": "holding on to my Luck's + skills until I", "ijjyZHD0d10-00346-00087011-00087277": "actually need to use a speed setup for", "ijjyZHD0d10-00347-00087278-00087493": "whatever reason and also partially", "ijjyZHD0d10-00348-00087494-00087652": "because the fact that like I'd like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00349-00087653-00087829": "right now Mikey are at 16 already has", "ijjyZHD0d10-00350-00087830-00088012": "they attacked with 6 max and I don't", "ijjyZHD0d10-00351-00088013-00088165": "want to replace it with a lower", "ijjyZHD0d10-00352-00088166-00088333": "attacking skill because it is attack", "ijjyZHD0d10-00353-00088334-00088684": "boost 5 Max and lux + + so I don't want", "ijjyZHD0d10-00354-00088685-00088900": "to downgrade it so I'm actually gonna", "ijjyZHD0d10-00355-00088901-00089110": "wait it out and see when I actually need", "ijjyZHD0d10-00356-00089111-00089368": "to use a speed setup before I make any", "ijjyZHD0d10-00357-00089369-00089632": "changes so take those into account", "ijjyZHD0d10-00358-00089633-00089881": "remember it's probably best if you can", "ijjyZHD0d10-00359-00089882-00090049": "already plan out in advance what you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00360-00090050-00090283": "would like your future raid boss looks", "ijjyZHD0d10-00361-00090284-00090469": "setups to be just because the fact that", "ijjyZHD0d10-00362-00090470-00090616": "that right there what can actually help", "ijjyZHD0d10-00363-00090617-00090775": "you figure out which of your medals you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00364-00090776-00091003": "would actually want to use Lux + skills", "ijjyZHD0d10-00365-00091004-00091363": "on or or find out which of the modes you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00366-00091364-00091540": "would want to try and get great boss", "ijjyZHD0d10-00367-00091541-00091729": "traits on as well one of the two or both", "ijjyZHD0d10-00368-00091730-00091996": "but other than that those of today guys", "ijjyZHD0d10-00369-00091997-00092188": "I just wanted to give that quick little", "ijjyZHD0d10-00370-00092189-00092452": "review overview and such but if you", "ijjyZHD0d10-00371-00092453-00092584": "enjoyed the episode please leave a like", "ijjyZHD0d10-00372-00092585-00092785": "and subscribe and hit that Bell button", "ijjyZHD0d10-00373-00092786-00092872": "is the best way to know when I upload", "ijjyZHD0d10-00374-00092873-00093100": "new videos such as this one other net my", "ijjyZHD0d10-00375-00093101-00093271": "name is Brian 15 Watson you cross nation", "ijjyZHD0d10-00376-00093272-00093349": "and I will see", "ijjyZHD0d10-00377-00093350-00093574": "in the next video peace", "ijjyZHD0d10-00378-00093575-00095784": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "ije-nlQfqQE", "text": {"ije-nlQfqQE-00000-00001937-00005860": "[Music]", "ije-nlQfqQE-00001-00005861-00024955": "[Music]", "ije-nlQfqQE-00002-00024956-00025256": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "ijDdC_uXSlI", "text": {"ijDdC_uXSlI-00000-00000505-00001491": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00001-00001492-00003470": "oh", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00002-00003471-00004331": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00003-00004332-00005173": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00004-00005174-00005683": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00005-00005684-00006311": "uh", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00006-00006312-00007338": "you're doing fantastic", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00007-00007339-00008483": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00008-00008484-00008651": "up", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00009-00008652-00009883": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00010-00009884-00010638": "oh", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00011-00010639-00011672": "you are doing phantom", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00012-00011673-00014083": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00013-00014084-00015483": "vision", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00014-00015484-00016883": "rubbish", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00015-00016884-00017430": "it's", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00016-00017431-00019683": "when you just guys", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00017-00019684-00020783": "so", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00018-00020784-00021083": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00019-00021084-00023883": "um", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00020-00023884-00024190": "um", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00021-00024191-00025283": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00022-00025284-00025458": "patience", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00023-00025459-00025911": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00024-00025912-00026895": "this one", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00025-00026895-00029014": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00026-00029016-00029842": "birthday cake", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00027-00029843-00030883": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00028-00030883-00031262": "um", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00029-00031263-00032283": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00030-00032283-00032470": "oh", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00031-00032472-00033891": "birthday chaos", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00032-00033892-00035558": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00033-00035559-00036423": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00034-00036424-00036819": "you need", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00035-00036820-00037718": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00036-00037719-00038086": "you're doing fantastic", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00037-00038087-00039620": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00038-00039621-00040683": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00039-00040684-00042083": "hmm", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00040-00042084-00043483": "is", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00041-00043484-00044583": "what", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00042-00044584-00046283": "very much", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00043-00046284-00047683": "oh", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00044-00047684-00048677": "uh", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00045-00048678-00049083": "[Applause]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00046-00049084-00049510": "um", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00047-00049511-00050483": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00048-00050484-00051701": "chaos", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00049-00051702-00051882": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00050-00051883-00053282": "yes", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00051-00053283-00054682": "so", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00052-00054683-00057482": "so", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00053-00057483-00058662": "so", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00054-00058663-00059126": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00055-00059127-00060023": "chaos", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00056-00060024-00060282": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00057-00060283-00061022": "enjoy", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00058-00061023-00061854": "[Music]", "ijDdC_uXSlI-00059-00061854-00062901": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "ikdiabPsR3k", "text": {"ikdiabPsR3k-00000-00000065-00000488": "well John it has to be done it's not a", "ikdiabPsR3k-00001-00000488-00000900": "Google I can both sit on that one yeah", "ikdiabPsR3k-00002-00000901-00001133": "that is great", "ikdiabPsR3k-00003-00001134-00001651": "what's this more than there are yes this", "ikdiabPsR3k-00004-00001652-00002939": "is something else right here", "ikdiabPsR3k-00005-00002940-00003365": "all right II know it's been two weeks", "ikdiabPsR3k-00006-00003367-00003600": "since lost recording this time keep", "ikdiabPsR3k-00007-00003601-00003801": "coming back to your right", "ikdiabPsR3k-00008-00003802-00004140": "what o'clock that's exactly our wiring", "ikdiabPsR3k-00009-00004141-00004359": "because I don't even remember where I am", "ikdiabPsR3k-00010-00004360-00005497": "at a game at this point", "ikdiabPsR3k-00011-00005498-00006296": "okay that I tell my camera good yep", "ikdiabPsR3k-00012-00006297-00008171": "Mike good okay good how's everything", "ikdiabPsR3k-00013-00008172-00008755": "Oh", "ikdiabPsR3k-00014-00008756-00011047": "Oh", "ikdiabPsR3k-00015-00011048-00011327": "I'm not going that way I don't trust", "ikdiabPsR3k-00016-00011328-00011809": "that way", "ikdiabPsR3k-00017-00011810-00012384": "I know how to cook in here deliver Oh", "ikdiabPsR3k-00018-00012385-00013863": "what what", "ikdiabPsR3k-00019-00013863-00014112": "okay maybe going out with my defense at", "ikdiabPsR3k-00020-00014113-00015053": "IKEA", "ikdiabPsR3k-00021-00015054-00015247": "so I don't look ahead maybe I can't get", "ikdiabPsR3k-00022-00015248-00015394": "junket I don't know why I'm thinking", "ikdiabPsR3k-00023-00015395-00015560": "that because I'd not work at all last", "ikdiabPsR3k-00024-00015561-00015608": "night", "ikdiabPsR3k-00025-00015609-00016447": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00026-00016448-00017254": "now trust it", "ikdiabPsR3k-00027-00017255-00018685": "oh crap it's popping again", "ikdiabPsR3k-00028-00018686-00018895": "ah", "ikdiabPsR3k-00029-00018896-00019379": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00030-00019380-00020477": "oh here yeah that's fun I grabbed my ax", "ikdiabPsR3k-00031-00020478-00021244": "e on", "ikdiabPsR3k-00032-00021245-00021767": "operator it's more hitting you guys only", "ikdiabPsR3k-00033-00021768-00022119": "have major to simple place I can do that", "ikdiabPsR3k-00034-00022120-00022541": "hello hello oh thank god you're alive", "ikdiabPsR3k-00035-00022542-00022772": "I need you to stay calm we're going to", "ikdiabPsR3k-00036-00022773-00022835": "get you help", "ikdiabPsR3k-00037-00022836-00023069": "we'll get you out of there I want you to", "ikdiabPsR3k-00038-00023070-00023297": "find a place to hide someplace safe", "ikdiabPsR3k-00039-00023298-00023480": "where you can remember the case of her", "ikdiabPsR3k-00040-00023481-00023719": "kiss when you felt her neck breaker", "ikdiabPsR3k-00041-00023720-00025742": "[__] okay no I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00042-00025743-00026643": "headcrab I help", "ikdiabPsR3k-00043-00026644-00027908": "I'm not", "ikdiabPsR3k-00044-00027908-00029374": "I'm here", "ikdiabPsR3k-00045-00029375-00030757": "I forgot say why these doors work okay", "ikdiabPsR3k-00046-00030758-00032073": "no they don't", "ikdiabPsR3k-00047-00032074-00032380": "for a variable Heidi are you hey she's", "ikdiabPsR3k-00048-00032381-00032841": "right height", "ikdiabPsR3k-00049-00032842-00033247": "well thank you oh well your girl my", "ikdiabPsR3k-00050-00033248-00034242": "heart actually racing", "ikdiabPsR3k-00051-00034243-00034713": "okay nine", "ikdiabPsR3k-00052-00034714-00038546": "not making pain mistake look as left", "ikdiabPsR3k-00053-00038547-00039249": "um at I don't I don't know one someone I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00054-00039250-00039408": "was watching this and try to lay back", "ikdiabPsR3k-00055-00039409-00041157": "then please that's creepy you met you", "ikdiabPsR3k-00056-00041158-00042371": "miss again that's a first time what what", "ikdiabPsR3k-00057-00042372-00043095": "what is happening where where am I okay", "ikdiabPsR3k-00058-00043096-00045924": "hug heaven there", "ikdiabPsR3k-00059-00045925-00046734": "crap", "ikdiabPsR3k-00060-00046735-00047012": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00061-00047013-00048035": "what okay I was shape", "ikdiabPsR3k-00062-00048036-00049560": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00063-00049561-00049625": "[Applause]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00064-00049626-00049729": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00065-00049730-00049860": "[Applause]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00066-00049861-00052126": "here okay there God how many times hit", "ikdiabPsR3k-00067-00052127-00053705": "my soul in fact I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00068-00053706-00055563": "good okay okay I was getting and this is", "ikdiabPsR3k-00069-00055564-00056316": "cheaper we gave you it's okay", "ikdiabPsR3k-00070-00056317-00058767": "we have you", "ikdiabPsR3k-00071-00058769-00067191": "thank you jumpin is it", "ikdiabPsR3k-00072-00067192-00069273": "okay then Fermi right well", "ikdiabPsR3k-00073-00069274-00069847": "okay so I saw for some time", "ikdiabPsR3k-00074-00069848-00071033": "I was like", "ikdiabPsR3k-00075-00071034-00071302": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00076-00071303-00072076": "oh they are the Nick let well that's not", "ikdiabPsR3k-00077-00072077-00072334": "unfortunate names that's just stupid", "ikdiabPsR3k-00078-00072335-00073568": "names", "ikdiabPsR3k-00079-00073569-00073820": "after him because they're shrining", "ikdiabPsR3k-00080-00073821-00074389": "filming edges everyone else in the city", "ikdiabPsR3k-00081-00074390-00076347": "village or asking", "ikdiabPsR3k-00082-00076348-00077025": "oh crap there god no unit I fight lizard", "ikdiabPsR3k-00083-00077026-00077469": "them know I'm being attacked by lizards", "ikdiabPsR3k-00084-00077470-00078204": "and my batteries Ryan whoa hey so I will", "ikdiabPsR3k-00085-00078205-00078702": "finish recording this later all right", "ikdiabPsR3k-00086-00078703-00079107": "so square root of life if your your", "ikdiabPsR3k-00087-00079108-00079377": "headset uses batteries make sure the", "ikdiabPsR3k-00088-00079378-00079595": "spiders are sufficiently sharp before", "ikdiabPsR3k-00089-00079596-00080150": "trying to record anything help all right", "ikdiabPsR3k-00090-00080151-00080562": "are we getting another short video or", "ikdiabPsR3k-00091-00080563-00081071": "this is going to be a longer video and", "ikdiabPsR3k-00092-00081072-00081471": "I'll find my way to mind we're starting", "ikdiabPsR3k-00093-00081472-00081648": "this video of not at all concerned about", "ikdiabPsR3k-00094-00081649-00082335": "batteries great", "ikdiabPsR3k-00095-00082336-00082584": "and now where's those people that I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00096-00082585-00082928": "mistakenly calls lizards in the last", "ikdiabPsR3k-00097-00082929-00083210": "recording session I was going to save", "ikdiabPsR3k-00098-00083211-00083468": "last episode but I there is a very good", "ikdiabPsR3k-00099-00083469-00083792": "chance that session will get grouped in", "ikdiabPsR3k-00100-00083793-00086157": "with this one", "ikdiabPsR3k-00101-00086158-00086989": "I am no longer concerned about batteries", "ikdiabPsR3k-00102-00086990-00088027": "what a friggin Bible", "ikdiabPsR3k-00103-00088028-00088559": "thank you I no longer feel overly", "ikdiabPsR3k-00104-00088560-00088970": "concerned my life well I mean I do buy", "ikdiabPsR3k-00105-00088971-00089327": "the loose like McEnroe camera and I can", "ikdiabPsR3k-00106-00089328-00089651": "run our batteries and I'm not going to", "ikdiabPsR3k-00107-00089652-00089830": "bleed to them", "ikdiabPsR3k-00108-00089831-00091514": "I'm surprised I have not already though", "ikdiabPsR3k-00109-00091515-00091799": "I don't know it's the sparsity to go it", "ikdiabPsR3k-00110-00091800-00092075": "on fire but for this is our game so", "ikdiabPsR3k-00111-00092076-00092471": "we're not exactly a lot of money the", "ikdiabPsR3k-00112-00092472-00093364": "decisions is like you I've made already", "ikdiabPsR3k-00113-00093365-00093617": "okay yeah if you cut the taxes you get", "ikdiabPsR3k-00114-00093618-00094154": "hurt as you can expect which what I'm", "ikdiabPsR3k-00115-00094155-00094667": "doing it again I mean it's better to", "ikdiabPsR3k-00116-00094668-00094817": "hurt yourself when you're not being", "ikdiabPsR3k-00117-00094818-00094991": "chased and it actually depends on your", "ikdiabPsR3k-00118-00094992-00095591": "life it always comes on your life for", "ikdiabPsR3k-00119-00095592-00096032": "the hell Li saying right now what I'm", "ikdiabPsR3k-00120-00096033-00098571": "saying is I've just gone [__] insane", "ikdiabPsR3k-00121-00098572-00099297": "okay", "ikdiabPsR3k-00122-00099298-00102653": "yeah we're not doing like", "ikdiabPsR3k-00123-00102654-00103593": "turn left front yes the titleist rolls", "ikdiabPsR3k-00124-00103594-00103876": "round town with a college guys so you", "ikdiabPsR3k-00125-00103877-00104118": "buy behind you hon night now sounds like", "ikdiabPsR3k-00126-00104119-00104541": "a smart idea that sounds like an even", "ikdiabPsR3k-00127-00104542-00104769": "smarter idea just run the writing cover", "ikdiabPsR3k-00128-00104770-00105150": "when you meet bring the papers - yeah", "ikdiabPsR3k-00129-00105151-00105538": "that's personal stuff completely weird", "ikdiabPsR3k-00130-00105539-00105763": "about this hotel", "ikdiabPsR3k-00131-00105764-00106305": "[Applause]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00132-00106306-00106515": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00133-00106516-00108453": "what the data table", "ikdiabPsR3k-00134-00108454-00110555": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00135-00110556-00110928": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00136-00110929-00112011": "yep I hate it up chuckling give your", "ikdiabPsR3k-00137-00112013-00112480": "hands touch discussion starter you right", "ikdiabPsR3k-00138-00112481-00114296": "thanks no okay", "ikdiabPsR3k-00139-00114297-00115443": "okay well there's yeah you know if just", "ikdiabPsR3k-00140-00115444-00115802": "casually of course that may at least", "ikdiabPsR3k-00141-00115803-00116021": "anyways they're gone", "ikdiabPsR3k-00142-00116022-00116247": "that's what Alexa fine better worry", "ikdiabPsR3k-00143-00116248-00117171": "about around here nope okay love with", "ikdiabPsR3k-00144-00117172-00118541": "them me thank you", "ikdiabPsR3k-00145-00118542-00118766": "guess when I thought I'd escaped the", "ikdiabPsR3k-00146-00118767-00119260": "hell school that phrase me right [__]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00147-00119261-00120415": "back [__] typical ass [__]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00148-00120416-00121613": "so what's up okay when I was cheap just", "ikdiabPsR3k-00149-00121614-00121881": "want to get you while I mean you can't", "ikdiabPsR3k-00150-00121882-00122678": "teleport teleport very well actually yes", "ikdiabPsR3k-00151-00122679-00123431": "hi", "ikdiabPsR3k-00152-00123432-00123734": "stop why did I I was I about to run that", "ikdiabPsR3k-00153-00123735-00130695": "way", "ikdiabPsR3k-00154-00130696-00131821": "any more bad [__] find me", "ikdiabPsR3k-00155-00131822-00132333": "is anymore", "ikdiabPsR3k-00156-00132334-00132741": "do not let me go that's what that says", "ikdiabPsR3k-00157-00132742-00133103": "oh [__]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00158-00133104-00133395": "why my fainting record ition I probably", "ikdiabPsR3k-00159-00133396-00133557": "should be gained a plug out of here but", "ikdiabPsR3k-00160-00133558-00133809": "ya ain't recording nothing with this", "ikdiabPsR3k-00161-00133810-00135033": "spot IDC Jessica all right good okay", "ikdiabPsR3k-00162-00135034-00135423": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00163-00135424-00137445": "I like okay Mike back in reality well I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00164-00137446-00137874": "mean I I frankly wish this was want", "ikdiabPsR3k-00165-00137875-00138606": "reality is if anything is worth", "ikdiabPsR3k-00166-00138607-00139472": "that's a tactic", "ikdiabPsR3k-00167-00139473-00141558": "Lake get to the other side of the lake", "ikdiabPsR3k-00168-00141559-00142124": "oh [__]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00169-00142125-00142907": "[__] talk", "ikdiabPsR3k-00170-00142908-00143328": "there's our boat or am I gonna get fries", "ikdiabPsR3k-00171-00143329-00143671": "14 so I do", "ikdiabPsR3k-00172-00143672-00144781": "what", "ikdiabPsR3k-00173-00144782-00145067": "okay yeah but why do I need to encourage", "ikdiabPsR3k-00174-00145068-00145997": "this left let's just recording the guy", "ikdiabPsR3k-00175-00145998-00146194": "who going into water first", "ikdiabPsR3k-00176-00146195-00147993": "now what I was trying to have me do", "ikdiabPsR3k-00177-00147994-00150532": "good night here", "ikdiabPsR3k-00178-00150533-00151073": "all right some minds again where I'll", "ikdiabPsR3k-00179-00151074-00151481": "find my wife if he even still alive", "ikdiabPsR3k-00180-00151482-00152045": "anyone he's probably not oh you know I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00181-00152046-00153157": "couldn't hold Santa", "ikdiabPsR3k-00182-00153158-00153402": "if I learn today from you a soft game I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00183-00153403-00153666": "will select that if I've learned", "ikdiabPsR3k-00184-00153667-00153903": "anything from science however I will not", "ikdiabPsR3k-00185-00153904-00154823": "so we're not trying that", "ikdiabPsR3k-00186-00154824-00155307": "or again they go to take it out", "ikdiabPsR3k-00187-00155308-00156784": "well safe-ish way down", "ikdiabPsR3k-00188-00156785-00157067": "okay sure yes now don't let me be", "ikdiabPsR3k-00189-00157068-00157649": "obsessed oh my god the chasing after", "ikdiabPsR3k-00190-00157650-00161689": "someone else and not me", "ikdiabPsR3k-00191-00161690-00166617": "okay okay", "ikdiabPsR3k-00192-00166618-00167000": "how's that", "ikdiabPsR3k-00193-00167001-00167671": "probably", "ikdiabPsR3k-00194-00167672-00169418": "I guess Hey", "ikdiabPsR3k-00195-00169419-00172317": "I forget the most arresting breath", "ikdiabPsR3k-00196-00172318-00172666": "where those humming how things are", "ikdiabPsR3k-00197-00172667-00173917": "talking about actually okay what why why", "ikdiabPsR3k-00198-00173918-00174085": "are we paddling this way I'm trying to", "ikdiabPsR3k-00199-00174086-00175356": "go that way we're not going in this I I", "ikdiabPsR3k-00200-00175357-00175573": "don't think I have control those anymore", "ikdiabPsR3k-00201-00175574-00175780": "we are not even going in the same", "ikdiabPsR3k-00202-00175781-00176134": "direction I'm trying to go we are", "ikdiabPsR3k-00203-00176135-00176389": "actually going the complete opposite", "ikdiabPsR3k-00204-00176390-00176551": "direction of sort of recognized trying", "ikdiabPsR3k-00205-00176552-00177366": "to go", "ikdiabPsR3k-00206-00177367-00178278": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00207-00178279-00178745": "first ayah the apocalypse hope the god", "ikdiabPsR3k-00208-00178746-00179106": "I'm losing my [__]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00209-00179107-00180623": "little why grow oh god that's a body", "ikdiabPsR3k-00210-00180624-00181861": "kind of her body", "ikdiabPsR3k-00211-00181862-00183340": "and I get help way", "ikdiabPsR3k-00212-00183341-00183749": "hi clearly", "ikdiabPsR3k-00213-00183750-00184070": "I can tell be playing the wreck of my", "ikdiabPsR3k-00214-00184071-00184489": "life behind padded walls if I even get", "ikdiabPsR3k-00215-00184490-00185271": "out of here alive but that", "ikdiabPsR3k-00216-00185272-00185536": "okay just title size there Blake man", "ikdiabPsR3k-00217-00185537-00185660": "seriously", "ikdiabPsR3k-00218-00185661-00186913": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00219-00186914-00186969": "you", "ikdiabPsR3k-00220-00186970-00189522": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00221-00189523-00190425": "get through this god great", "ikdiabPsR3k-00222-00190426-00190671": "all right tell most listen how do we cut", "ikdiabPsR3k-00223-00190672-00192177": "out use my boat come on hop [__] [__]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00224-00192178-00193275": "come on Oh God why Michael better off", "ikdiabPsR3k-00225-00193276-00193918": "this running", "ikdiabPsR3k-00226-00193919-00194503": "the woman basic win come close almost", "ikdiabPsR3k-00227-00194504-00194960": "barely", "ikdiabPsR3k-00228-00194961-00195577": "copal dick good Christmas God but you", "ikdiabPsR3k-00229-00195578-00196007": "had to die Harrison thing we want her to", "ikdiabPsR3k-00230-00196008-00196547": "have the baby my god they do when", "ikdiabPsR3k-00231-00196548-00197282": "there's no baby what happened good", "ikdiabPsR3k-00232-00197283-00197551": "I don't know when we were able to do", "ikdiabPsR3k-00233-00197552-00197923": "because they've got the strength on that", "ikdiabPsR3k-00234-00197924-00198298": "side and the knives and possibly", "ikdiabPsR3k-00235-00198299-00198933": "everything too", "ikdiabPsR3k-00236-00198934-00200744": "god", "ikdiabPsR3k-00237-00200745-00200975": "okay now the month babies are full grown", "ikdiabPsR3k-00238-00200976-00203072": "people", "ikdiabPsR3k-00239-00203073-00203324": "am I am i close to getting off this", "ikdiabPsR3k-00240-00203325-00203723": "piece of [__] and please I'd like to end", "ikdiabPsR3k-00241-00203724-00204398": "the episode soon and okay Blake you were", "ikdiabPsR3k-00242-00204399-00204573": "not even paddling in the direction I'm", "ikdiabPsR3k-00243-00204574-00204716": "trying to tell you to go right now", "ikdiabPsR3k-00244-00204717-00207242": "thank you", "ikdiabPsR3k-00245-00207242-00207654": "it didn't in this part then or enemy", "ikdiabPsR3k-00246-00207655-00208565": "episode", "ikdiabPsR3k-00247-00208566-00209935": "oh thank freakin God", "ikdiabPsR3k-00248-00209936-00210552": "[__] [__] the rest will be there I don't", "ikdiabPsR3k-00249-00210553-00210782": "I don't want it there any more ideas", "ikdiabPsR3k-00250-00210783-00211942": "watching TV outro", "ikdiabPsR3k-00251-00211942-00213132": "[Music]", "ikdiabPsR3k-00252-00213133-00213859": "get up we have to go"}}, {"audio_id": "ik4p_IHjBGY", "text": {"ik4p_IHjBGY-00000-00000608-00000823": "hi in this video we will discuss", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00001-00000824-00001054": "exponents and radicals exponents and", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00002-00001055-00001223": "radicals appear frequently in", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00003-00001224-00001407": "computations and mathematical", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00004-00001408-00001535": "expressions", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00005-00001536-00001695": "in order to simplify a complicated", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00006-00001696-00001902": "expression we may need to use certain", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00007-00001903-00002142": "properties of exponents and radicals now", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00008-00002143-00002823": "here are some important ones", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00009-00002824-00003238": "exponent laws x to the n times x to the", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00010-00003239-00003663": "m equals x to the m plus n", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00011-00003664-00004006": "x to the m divided by x to the n", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00012-00004007-00004375": "equals x to the m minus n", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00013-00004376-00004622": "x to the m to the n", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00014-00004623-00005022": "equals x to the m times n", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00015-00005023-00005295": "x times y all to the n", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00016-00005296-00005686": "equals x to the n times y to the n", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00017-00005687-00005911": "radical laws", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00018-00005912-00006047": "a times b", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00019-00006048-00006334": "all to the nth root equals a to the nth", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00020-00006335-00006663": "root times b to the nth root", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00021-00006664-00006975": "a divided by b all to the nth root", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00022-00006976-00007255": "equals a to the nth root divided by b to", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00023-00007256-00007455": "the nth root", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00024-00007456-00007774": "a to the nth root to the mth root equals", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00025-00007775-00008631": "a to the n times m root", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00026-00008632-00008919": "in our first example we will evaluate 2", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00027-00008920-00009174": "cubed times 2 squared plus cube root of", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00028-00009175-00009439": "27 plus root 18.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00029-00009440-00009591": "our solution will start by first", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00030-00009592-00009823": "simplifying the expressions we get a", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00031-00009824-00010151": "times 4 from 2 cubed times 2 squared and", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00032-00010152-00010423": "cube root of 3 cubed from cube root of", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00033-00010424-00010542": "27", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00034-00010543-00010887": "and root 9 times 2 from root 18.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00035-00010888-00011127": "then we have 32 plus 3", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00036-00011128-00011351": "since the cube and cube root cancels out", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00037-00011352-00011567": "we can also express 9 as the square of", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00038-00011568-00011678": "3.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00039-00011679-00011887": "then we can use one of the radical laws", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00040-00011888-00012174": "to come up with through 3 squared times", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00041-00012175-00012278": "2.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00042-00012279-00012510": "so we can take out the 3 squared and", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00043-00012511-00012774": "then output 3 times root 2.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00044-00012775-00013030": "so in conclusion our answer will be", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00045-00013031-00013799": "35 plus 3 root 2.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00046-00013800-00014071": "in our second example we have 3 a b", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00047-00014072-00014447": "squared c times 2a squared b divided by", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00048-00014447-00014822": "c cubed all to the power of negative 2.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00049-00014823-00015038": "we would begin our solution by first", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00050-00015040-00015286": "getting rid of the negative exponent and", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00051-00015287-00015543": "end up with c cubed divided by two a", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00052-00015544-00015927": "squared b all to the power of two", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00053-00015928-00016135": "then we use another exponent law to", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00054-00016136-00016391": "expand the square and get c to the power", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00055-00016392-00016671": "of six divided by two squared times a to", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00056-00016672-00016943": "the power of four times b squared", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00057-00016944-00017143": "now we will multiply them using exponent", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00058-00017144-00017422": "laws to come up with three a b squared", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00059-00017423-00017639": "times c to the power of seven all", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00060-00017640-00017855": "divided by four times a to the power of", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00061-00017856-00018086": "four times b squared", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00062-00018087-00018279": "our last step will be to simplify and", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00063-00018280-00018527": "get a result of 3 times c to the power", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00064-00018528-00018871": "of 7 divided by 4 times a cubed", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00065-00018872-00019222": "so in conclusion our answer will be 3c", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00066-00019223-00020127": "to the power of 7 divided by 4a cubed", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00067-00020128-00020327": "in our third and last example we will", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00068-00020328-00020486": "simplify the expression", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00069-00020487-00020783": "2 times a to the power of 4 divided by 3", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00070-00020784-00021030": "times b to the power of 5 all to the", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00071-00021031-00021375": "power of 2. our solution will begin by", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00072-00021376-00021591": "first writing the expression as 2 over 3", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00073-00021592-00021839": "squared times a to the power of 4", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00074-00021840-00022030": "divided by b to the power of 5 all", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00075-00022031-00022158": "squared", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00076-00022159-00022358": "expanding the square and getting 4", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00077-00022359-00022663": "divided by 9 times a to the power of 8", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00078-00022664-00022935": "divided by b to the power of 10.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00079-00022936-00023143": "then by multiplying them together we get", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00080-00023144-00023471": "4 times a to the power of 8 divided by 9", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00081-00023472-00023727": "times b to the power of 10.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00082-00023728-00024030": "so in conclusion our answer will be 4", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00083-00024031-00024278": "times a to the power of 8 divided by 9", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00084-00024279-00025094": "times b to the power of 10.", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00085-00025095-00025278": "we have gone over some basic properties", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00086-00025279-00025478": "of exponents and radicals that we will", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00087-00025479-00025711": "need to know in order to solve questions", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00088-00025712-00025934": "however we did not mention all of them", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00089-00025935-00026158": "there are other properties some of which", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00090-00026160-00026399": "are a combination of the basic ones", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00091-00026400-00026623": "also keep in mind there are many", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00092-00026624-00026831": "different ways to simplify an algebraic", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00093-00026832-00026967": "expression", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00094-00026968-00027190": "you should feel free to use any of the", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00095-00027191-00027374": "properties when simplifying an", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00096-00027375-00027511": "expression", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00097-00027512-00027679": "now we move on to some practice", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00098-00027680-00032702": "questions", "ik4p_IHjBGY-00099-00032703-00032912": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "ik4BFAHUsbY", "text": {"ik4BFAHUsbY-00000-00000056-00000247": "this was the one where you was actually", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00001-00000248-00000390": "pissed out your brains and tried to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00002-00000391-00000991": "convince me", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00003-00000992-00001270": "don't you stop he said hope his", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00004-00001271-00001383": "brother's here and i said", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00005-00001384-00001695": "are you sure he wanted some random dude", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00006-00001696-00002359": "and i said that's not his brother", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00007-00002360-00002495": "okay because like we would actually get", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00008-00002496-00002671": "to record for about five minutes okay", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00009-00002672-00002710": "yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00010-00002711-00002942": "so uh playing your music play the music", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00011-00002943-00003095": "and that'll be it we can go we'll go get", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00012-00003096-00003767": "the raffle", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00013-00003768-00004502": "who's mine", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00014-00004503-00004631": "i think we should give a round of", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00015-00004632-00004847": "applause to my mate george who's flown", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00016-00004848-00005683": "all the way from the usa just to see", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00017-00005684-00006887": "me", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00018-00006888-00009806": "this weekend", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00019-00009807-00009983": "i've deliberately not got them because i", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00020-00009984-00015483": "don't want to look uncool", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00021-00015484-00015855": "is", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00022-00015856-00016094": "hello and welcome for a special", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00023-00016095-00016207": "recording from", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00024-00016208-00016511": "old camp which we didn't plan to do and", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00025-00016512-00016758": "welcome to the tdtrs roadshow my name is", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00026-00016759-00016879": "pete i'm matt", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00027-00016880-00017286": "i'm becky and i'm phillip yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00028-00017287-00017639": "i love the course we was expecting we", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00029-00017640-00017807": "were hoping to catch you out", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00030-00017808-00018014": "you do that that famous pause of yours", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00031-00018015-00018422": "and like oh", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00032-00018423-00018903": "there you go", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00033-00018904-00019239": "so uh what have you been up to in uh", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00034-00019240-00019367": "this is like this is like we would", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00035-00019368-00019519": "normally say like what would be done", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00036-00019520-00019599": "yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00037-00019600-00019799": "we actually mean two weeks so actually", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00038-00019800-00019911": "what we mean is", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00039-00019912-00020239": "one day two days that was well i think", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00040-00020240-00020430": "i should i thought we should talk about", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00041-00020431-00020614": "like the best things that we've seen", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00042-00020615-00020703": "this weekend", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00043-00020704-00020855": "we're probably pre-empting the guys", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00044-00020856-00021071": "later on but", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00045-00021072-00021319": "now i think we've seen the best true i", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00046-00021320-00021550": "don't know", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00047-00021551-00021927": "i don't think i've watched it", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00048-00021928-00022247": "um i think there was a guy", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00049-00022248-00022407": "on on here not too long ago who's", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00050-00022408-00022567": "talking about actor and things like that", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00051-00022568-00022647": "who um", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00052-00022648-00022830": "he was very good i liked i liked the way", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00053-00022831-00023247": "he spoke", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00054-00023248-00023383": "yeah is that anything you want to tell", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00055-00023384-00023822": "me", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00056-00023823-00024063": "but other than that no i i just um i", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00057-00024064-00024247": "just i just like meeting everyone", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00058-00024248-00024414": "that's it for me i don't really care", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00059-00024415-00024550": "about listening to people", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00060-00024551-00024775": "talk about what they're interested in i", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00061-00024776-00025007": "would listen to what i'm interested in", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00062-00025008-00025750": "i quite i just want to meet you guys", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00063-00025751-00025878": "yeah that really did it for me i thought", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00064-00025879-00026078": "that was really awesome i was hoping", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00065-00026079-00026246": "someone would uh buy me one night but", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00066-00026247-00026511": "you know visual bastard", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00067-00026512-00026655": "you might you know get your way in the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00068-00026656-00026831": "raffle i'm gonna win the raffle man now", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00069-00026832-00026983": "but i'm having the kindle and i'm having", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00070-00026983-00027095": "one of them now now", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00071-00027095-00027479": "no and then it's full", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00072-00027480-00027799": "yeah anything else anything else no no", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00073-00027800-00028079": "nothing that's the rest of us penguin", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00074-00028080-00028662": "you", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00075-00028663-00028862": "yeah so from my point of view uh", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00076-00028863-00028990": "yesterday we sat", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00077-00028991-00029302": "in on maloki's talk uh flutter", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00078-00029304-00029567": "how to um use traffic business how to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00079-00029568-00029743": "make profit from flattery yeah flat was", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00080-00029744-00029839": "pretty cool yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00081-00029839-00030158": "um we've sat in on lorna james open", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00082-00030160-00030318": "sourcing your career that was another", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00083-00030319-00030479": "good one today", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00084-00030480-00030846": "the personally i didn't enjoy", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00085-00030847-00031158": "the panel with the kaz", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00086-00031160-00031358": "is it the lady i know the panel was all", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00087-00031360-00031702": "right", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00088-00031703-00031958": "because dan was the one i just switched", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00089-00031960-00032158": "the microphone", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00090-00032160-00032431": "for me personally i didn't enjoy it it", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00091-00032432-00032583": "didn't work it didn't like", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00092-00032583-00032911": "give you know the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00093-00032912-00033102": "maybe it was a language barrier or", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00094-00033103-00033215": "stingray", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00095-00033216-00033631": "translation for me but it didn't mean", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00096-00033632-00035127": "in what respect", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00097-00035128-00035343": "yeah i mean i i mean i make no bounds", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00098-00035344-00035455": "about it i i", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00099-00035456-00035615": "really disagree with the message that", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00100-00035616-00035815": "simon picks put puts out", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00101-00035816-00036030": "i mean i've seen a version of that talk", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00102-00036031-00036223": "three times and i said this to you guys", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00103-00036224-00036351": "yesterday", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00104-00036352-00036543": "i don't know i think someone a good", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00105-00036544-00036807": "value for money", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00106-00036808-00037883": "yeah and plus", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00107-00037884-00038807": "uh", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00108-00038808-00039007": "and then the panel came along and he", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00109-00039008-00039190": "tried doing exactly the same thing", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00110-00039191-00040687": "and uh", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00111-00040688-00041583": "with", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00112-00041584-00041774": "but again this isn't about coming and", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00113-00041775-00041974": "saying that talk was better", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00114-00041975-00042279": "you know for me than another talk it's", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00115-00042280-00042343": "about you know", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00116-00042344-00042607": "we're all here we've all come here to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00117-00042608-00042815": "get out of it what we want to get out of", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00118-00042816-00042879": "it", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00119-00042880-00043055": "you know what i was saying for me", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00120-00043056-00043246": "personally because actually the talk she", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00121-00043247-00043374": "did in the morning", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00122-00043375-00043543": "about the open source software with her", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00123-00043544-00043790": "pacemaker yeah that was really good", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00124-00043791-00043999": "but for me it didn't work with her on", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00125-00044000-00044151": "the panel and maybe it was just the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00126-00044152-00044455": "subject that she was talking about", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00127-00044456-00044767": "like small applause there", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00128-00044768-00045055": "i mean it was quite a totally debated", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00129-00045056-00045190": "subject as well with the whole", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00130-00045191-00045487": "known you know immunity thing so you", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00131-00045488-00045599": "probably probably want the best", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00132-00045600-00045958": "topic to speak without maybe", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00133-00045959-00046255": "she was going to defend her corner i", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00134-00046256-00046335": "think the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00135-00046336-00046590": "participant was uh playing it down so", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00136-00046591-00046702": "probably a bit too much", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00137-00046703-00046911": "and that's maybe what got the backup but", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00138-00046912-00047023": "because i mean", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00139-00047024-00047143": "it's obvious to anybody who's got an", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00140-00047144-00047295": "interest in that topic that you know", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00141-00047296-00047455": "there is a bit of friction going on", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00142-00047456-00047662": "and to play it down completely might", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00143-00047663-00047918": "have been", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00144-00047919-00048030": "that might have caused a bit more", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00145-00048031-00048255": "friction and maybe got her back up so", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00146-00048256-00048407": "but i thought it was good it was that's", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00147-00048408-00048535": "what these pounds are for and having a", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00148-00048536-00048686": "bit of a debate", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00149-00048687-00048958": "i think well i also kind of figured that", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00150-00048959-00049143": "to some fit i mean isn't that the point", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00151-00049144-00049327": "of having a keynote it's there to get", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00152-00049328-00049590": "people talking and interested", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00153-00049591-00049695": "whether they say it's bollocks or", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00154-00049696-00049990": "whether they say oh yeah into brilliance", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00155-00049991-00050279": "needs to set the theme for the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00156-00050280-00050367": "conference and", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00157-00050368-00050567": "it should be inspiring or maybe that's", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00158-00050568-00050799": "just the profession that i come from", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00159-00050800-00051030": "i didn't particularly yes she didn't", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00160-00051031-00051135": "because i mean", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00161-00051136-00051438": "okay i find it inspiring yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00162-00051439-00051646": "well i i don't but i don't find it", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00163-00051647-00051807": "inspiring for a totally different reason", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00164-00051808-00051999": "because i just i don't think", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00165-00052000-00052375": "i i accept that we must be aware of", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00166-00052376-00052679": "potential security issues potential", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00167-00052679-00052750": "risks", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00168-00052751-00053079": "and things of that nature um", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00169-00053079-00053399": "but i don't my personal view is he you", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00170-00053400-00053438": "know he's", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00171-00053439-00053591": "sort of like built a career out of", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00172-00053591-00053775": "spreading gloom and doom", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00173-00053776-00054111": "um yeah yeah and that's that's it", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00174-00054112-00054350": "you can't it kind of you can't and then", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00175-00054351-00054471": "i mean there's quite a few people said", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00176-00054472-00054599": "you know it's all very able to stand up", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00177-00054600-00054894": "on the stage and everybody to be", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00178-00054895-00055271": "overruled by a presence and say", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00179-00055272-00055647": "for example i like the man as a person", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00180-00055648-00055847": "i think he's very intelligent i just", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00181-00055848-00055999": "don't like the message he portrays", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00182-00056000-00056247": "he stands up saying you should be for", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00183-00056248-00057482": "freedom and i'm soft and used as a mack", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00184-00057483-00058919": "next", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00185-00058920-00059279": "similar talk um and a lot of people here", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00186-00059279-00059311": "have", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00187-00059312-00059654": "uh know about actor three strike roles", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00188-00059655-00059799": "and all of that and he was given the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00189-00059800-00059991": "same talk there and", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00190-00059991-00060215": "i took issue with him because what he", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00191-00060216-00060382": "was doing at that time because he was", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00192-00060383-00060487": "concentrating", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00193-00060488-00060719": "on the three strikes and actor isn't", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00194-00060720-00060894": "just about three strikes he's about a", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00195-00060895-00060966": "lot of things", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00196-00060967-00061279": "it's about counterfeit goods counterfeit", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00197-00061279-00061335": "drugs", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00198-00061336-00061566": "it's about a lot of stuff and and i did", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00199-00061567-00061759": "pull him up and said simon look you know", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00200-00061760-00061919": "i'm not gonna", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00201-00061920-00062150": "pee on your parade here but you're being", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00202-00062151-00062287": "a bit unfair because", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00203-00062288-00062423": "you're talking to people that quite", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00204-00062424-00062687": "clearly don't know anything about actor", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00205-00062688-00062959": "and you're only focusing on a small", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00206-00062960-00063023": "portion", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00207-00063024-00063159": "you're not telling them the whole", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00208-00063160-00063406": "picture and by focusing on", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00209-00063407-00063711": "that small portion that", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00210-00063712-00063911": "wins you votes let's say well that's", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00211-00063912-00064047": "what a job isn't it yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00212-00064048-00064215": "but i mean if you if you cover the whole", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00213-00064216-00064415": "project then you allow everybody", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00214-00064416-00064591": "to make their own mind up yeah see i'm", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00215-00064591-00064759": "not i'm not sure i think", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00216-00064760-00065015": "people some people like silent vince you", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00217-00065016-00065079": "need to just", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00218-00065079-00065247": "accept that they're at the far end of", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00219-00065248-00065406": "the spectrum just let them get on with", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00220-00065407-00065463": "their job", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00221-00065464-00066006": "it sounds like somebody else", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00222-00066007-00066167": "maybe just let him get on with the job", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00223-00066168-00066447": "and uh you know i mean you know", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00224-00066448-00066638": "you know you know the half of the stuff", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00225-00066639-00066767": "that he's talking about", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00226-00066768-00066982": "or you might not agree with it all but", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00227-00066983-00067199": "if you does it", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00228-00067200-00067919": "i mean to be fair", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00229-00067920-00068111": "it's really interesting and yeah i'm not", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00230-00068112-00068279": "not for us to now have an argument but", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00231-00068280-00068479": "you sort of like defending simon phipps", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00232-00068480-00068682": "and he was quite happy to run karen", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00233-00068683-00068831": "there", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00234-00068832-00069015": "because you didn't like her talk no and", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00235-00069016-00069159": "she gave up her time", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00236-00069160-00069335": "yeah but she gave her her time and came", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00237-00069336-00069567": "here", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00238-00069568-00069735": "the contents of the panel was what i was", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00239-00069736-00069871": "saying again", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00240-00069872-00070055": "the contents of simon's talk didn't", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00241-00070056-00070199": "particularly number me you know but", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00242-00070200-00070359": "less than like i say i mean karen's had", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00243-00070360-00070526": "a long way to travel", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00244-00070527-00070975": "you know i'll defend i think yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00245-00070976-00071262": "i'm too nice yeah you're too nice i did", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00246-00071263-00072903": "say that actually i said that's too nice", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00247-00072904-00073599": "months until the next i'll come back", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00248-00073600-00073711": "and tell you how many times i've washed", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00249-00073712-00074031": "my ass today", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00250-00074032-00077082": "i mean you counted or it's zero", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00251-00077083-00080479": "is", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00252-00080480-00080694": "is there any software that anybody hates", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00253-00080695-00080999": "and i want free software", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00254-00081000-00082326": "look at that yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00255-00082327-00084126": "this is the god that is", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00256-00084127-00084391": "yeah why isn't there a decent physio", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00257-00084392-00084575": "replacement", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00258-00084576-00084918": "yeah it's called fable", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00259-00084919-00085182": "no no he's saying it's a good thing", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00260-00085183-00085567": "enscape is", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00261-00085568-00085782": "it's a good tool but to do network", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00262-00085783-00085926": "diagrams and so on you need", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00263-00085927-00086199": "templates of like booking routers and", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00264-00086200-00086343": "switches to search", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00265-00086344-00086718": "silence no it's called agreeing with", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00266-00086719-00088023": "your audience", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00267-00088024-00088247": "so why aren't we building one because", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00268-00088248-00090918": "there's good attempts", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00269-00090919-00091047": "apparently there isn't an interest", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00270-00091048-00092343": "because somebody", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00271-00092344-00092518": "and the people who write software do", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00272-00092519-00092671": "they create do you know i've heard this", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00273-00092672-00092855": "argument before and i and i really hate", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00274-00092856-00092999": "that argument i really do", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00275-00093000-00093367": "um because you round it up now yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00276-00093368-00093631": "and i understand the argument of you", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00277-00093632-00093671": "know", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00278-00093672-00093943": "developers write applications for", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00279-00093944-00094006": "themselves", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00280-00094007-00094287": "and that's that's all well but but at", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00281-00094288-00094399": "the end of the day", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00282-00094400-00094694": "you know that that's being written for", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00283-00094695-00094726": "an", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00284-00094727-00095182": "audience um and like anything else", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00285-00095183-00095294": "you know if people didn't want to come", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00286-00095295-00095503": "to work camp would have been known", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00287-00095504-00095774": "um and so i think really we should start", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00288-00095775-00095894": "to to cater", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00289-00095895-00096262": "for that audience um and so as adam said", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00290-00096263-00096318": "if they're", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00291-00096319-00096479": "i mean think of think of the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00292-00096480-00096671": "applications that can be used", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00293-00096672-00097055": "for for dire in the business environment", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00294-00097056-00097326": "i mean it's huge and that could help us", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00295-00097327-00097382": "take off", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00296-00097383-00097679": "i don't think um you know something like", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00297-00097680-00097823": "firefox is going to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00298-00097824-00098094": "uh help promote limits although he does", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00299-00098095-00098223": "i mean that's probably a bad i'm trying", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00300-00098224-00098311": "to think of something because", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00301-00098312-00098791": "if the knee was really that big", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00302-00098792-00098974": "i think the problem in the case of diet", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00303-00098975-00099206": "is it's just a hassle to make", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00304-00099207-00099374": "thousands of thousands of little icons", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00305-00099375-00100882": "for different devices", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00306-00100883-00102282": "manufacturers", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00307-00102283-00102486": "um someone and they wrote a they", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00308-00102488-00102630": "attempted to write a video replacement", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00309-00102631-00102766": "they got started with it", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00310-00102767-00102942": "and then everyone was really nasty about", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00311-00102943-00105086": "them and so they stopped", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00312-00105088-00105407": "we no what you need", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00313-00105408-00105710": "is to be nice", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00314-00105711-00106895": "you're probably right", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00315-00106896-00107023": "you've got so much free software", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00316-00107024-00107271": "available that you tend to forget that", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00317-00107272-00107463": "sometimes that there's a developer at", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00318-00107464-00107663": "the end of it that sat down on you know", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00319-00107664-00107863": "he's worked for hours and hours and days", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00320-00107864-00109199": "and months", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00321-00109200-00109366": "the guys they've given the time to help", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00322-00109367-00109678": "support your um", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00323-00109679-00110415": "who's broadcast is this yours", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00324-00110416-00110639": "you're right maybe that's the message we", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00325-00110640-00110775": "should give everybody", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00326-00110776-00111583": "just be nice be nice", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00327-00111583-00112239": "be nice", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00328-00112240-00112415": "i think that's a good point for you to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00329-00112416-00112575": "uh wrap it up yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00330-00112576-00112710": "apparently well you need to go in the", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00331-00112711-00113607": "raffles yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00332-00113608-00113823": "what we'd like to do is uh we'd like to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00333-00113824-00113958": "thank you all for listening to one of", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00334-00113959-00114023": "the most", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00335-00114024-00114366": "boring episodes ever", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00336-00114367-00114575": "very little humor there and i apologize", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00337-00114576-00114823": "for matt's behaviour", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00338-00114824-00115127": "and so it's uh goodbye from him goodbye", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00339-00115128-00115158": "from", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00340-00115159-00115278": "well no wait hang on a minute we need to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00341-00115279-00115510": "thank dan we need to fight with that", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00342-00115511-00115975": "yeah actually", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00343-00115976-00116231": "i thought it was gonna be horrible yeah", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00344-00116232-00117647": "that's what tony does", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00345-00117648-00117958": "such an awesome guy um and he didn't get", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00346-00117959-00118054": "paid for the same", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00347-00118055-00118383": "no no", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00348-00118383-00118583": "listen do you remember my apology you", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00349-00118583-00118783": "were supposed to be reported to us", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00350-00118783-00119063": "right um so yeah we'd like to thank", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00351-00119064-00119127": "popey", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00352-00119128-00119358": "and well basically everybody everybody", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00353-00119359-00119471": "for everybody", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00354-00119472-00119599": "allowed us to do this we didn't plan to", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00355-00119600-00119999": "do it so everybody thank you guys thank", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00356-00120000-00121883": "you very much", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00357-00121883-00122907": "foreign", "ik4BFAHUsbY-00358-00122908-00123208": "oh"}}, {"audio_id": "ik7tueUTC5I", "text": {"ik7tueUTC5I-00000-00000029-00000252": "foreign", "ik7tueUTC5I-00001-00000253-00001237": "[Applause]", "ik7tueUTC5I-00002-00001238-00001702": "Sims and I am from Omaha Central", "ik7tueUTC5I-00003-00001703-00001897": "school", "ik7tueUTC5I-00004-00001898-00002152": "I just wanted to give you guys a trigger", "ik7tueUTC5I-00005-00002153-00002441": "warning for suicidal ambulation", "ik7tueUTC5I-00006-00002442-00002915": "okay and my poem is titled black beans", "ik7tueUTC5I-00007-00002916-00003269": "i gaze into the harmful black beans", "ik7tueUTC5I-00008-00003270-00003553": "it's yellow glue my food in seconds past", "ik7tueUTC5I-00009-00003554-00003893": "the full gold reflected epilogue of your", "ik7tueUTC5I-00010-00003894-00004090": "sweating Health fresh", "ik7tueUTC5I-00011-00004092-00004385": "the radiant Crystal of light warms our", "ik7tueUTC5I-00012-00004386-00004643": "honey Globe skin earning while sunken", "ik7tueUTC5I-00013-00004644-00004763": "peace", "ik7tueUTC5I-00014-00004764-00005045": "our eyes are facing from the deep Indigo", "ik7tueUTC5I-00015-00005046-00005338": "of the blind the god feathers surely", "ik7tueUTC5I-00016-00005339-00005609": "rest for milliseconds their mouths full", "ik7tueUTC5I-00017-00005610-00005813": "of lost treasury", "ik7tueUTC5I-00018-00005814-00006043": "my soft hearted descendants brother", "ik7tueUTC5I-00019-00006044-00006329": "always wanting to swim into the algae", "ik7tueUTC5I-00020-00006330-00006491": "infested Lagoon", "ik7tueUTC5I-00021-00006492-00006910": "oh my God you made it look so easy to", "ik7tueUTC5I-00022-00006911-00007187": "live but I'm gonna let the salt to", "ik7tueUTC5I-00023-00007188-00007463": "absorb my lungs I wanted the waves to", "ik7tueUTC5I-00024-00007464-00007696": "impale my nostrils feeding into my", "ik7tueUTC5I-00025-00007697-00007967": "capacious Cranium I wanted my fingertips", "ik7tueUTC5I-00026-00007968-00008164": "to turn Serene blue like the waves that", "ik7tueUTC5I-00027-00008165-00008333": "downstair beat", "ik7tueUTC5I-00028-00008334-00008710": "because you and I both know my one true", "ik7tueUTC5I-00029-00008711-00008941": "love was death", "ik7tueUTC5I-00030-00008942-00009413": "so now I spare greatly in a shot of red", "ik7tueUTC5I-00031-00009414-00009533": "glass", "ik7tueUTC5I-00032-00009534-00009851": "the shards sliding down my arms into my", "ik7tueUTC5I-00033-00009852-00010055": "points of Palms struggling fresh", "ik7tueUTC5I-00034-00010056-00010313": "arterial blood onto my bleached and", "ik7tueUTC5I-00035-00010314-00010421": "carbon", "ik7tueUTC5I-00036-00010422-00010721": "The Dread washing over me these things", "ik7tueUTC5I-00037-00010722-00012046": "water coated and relax", "ik7tueUTC5I-00038-00012047-00012599": "pains", "ik7tueUTC5I-00039-00012600-00012880": "really how many of The Beatles take and", "ik7tueUTC5I-00040-00012881-00013085": "close your eyes praying to a god when", "ik7tueUTC5I-00041-00013086-00013469": "you know I'm destined to meet", "ik7tueUTC5I-00042-00013469-00013636": "you still", "ik7tueUTC5I-00043-00013637-00013894": "tears before from your already multiple", "ik7tueUTC5I-00044-00013895-00014044": "black beans", "ik7tueUTC5I-00045-00014045-00014327": "clear spiders surround me combining with", "ik7tueUTC5I-00046-00014328-00014686": "the tribe of Luke will find it once more", "ik7tueUTC5I-00047-00014687-00014921": "you say you cannot let me float Among", "ik7tueUTC5I-00048-00014922-00015149": "the Stars you do not want me to give", "ik7tueUTC5I-00049-00015150-00015407": "gentle flutters to hypnosis or pass", "ik7tueUTC5I-00050-00015408-00015683": "lightly against Orion you hold my", "ik7tueUTC5I-00051-00015684-00015916": "scarred and captive body and deeply", "ik7tueUTC5I-00052-00015918-00016229": "embrace my premise sort of likely could", "ik7tueUTC5I-00053-00016230-00016444": "put my code in the soup in the hand", "ik7tueUTC5I-00054-00016445-00016727": "brushes her droplets and I was so sweet", "ik7tueUTC5I-00055-00016728-00016961": "lullabies so that she never turns to our", "ik7tueUTC5I-00056-00016962-00017135": "identical memories", "ik7tueUTC5I-00057-00017136-00017333": "please forgive me brother", "ik7tueUTC5I-00058-00017334-00018106": "for only a fatal boy lives now and lives", "ik7tueUTC5I-00059-00018107-00018383": "[Applause]", "ik7tueUTC5I-00060-00018384-00018595": "thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "ikgkd0k1iDg", "text": {"ikgkd0k1iDg-00000-00000012-00000209": "all right we got a great episode for you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00001-00000210-00000377": "today we're talking about a whole lot of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00002-00000378-00000526": "NFL news we're talking about some", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00003-00000527-00000713": "Dynasty questions do you draft for need", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00004-00000714-00000928": "do you draft best available and we dive", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00005-00000930-00001169": "into the mailbag and ask the fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00006-00001170-00001569": "Genie to grant us a wish enjoy the show", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00007-00001570-00002218": "[Music]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00008-00002219-00002507": "fantasy footballers podcast with your", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00009-00002508-00002950": "host Andy Holloway Jason Moore and Mike", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00010-00002951-00003029": "Wright", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00011-00003030-00003775": "[Music]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00012-00003776-00004673": "welcome in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00013-00004674-00004793": "[Music]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00014-00004794-00005099": "Thursday March 30th the fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00015-00005100-00005375": "footballers podcast Jason or Mike Wright", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00016-00005376-00005788": "Andy Holloway", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00017-00005789-00006022": "pile of deucers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00018-00006023-00006406": "hot a steamy steaming pie", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00019-00006408-00006598": "how you guys doing over there inducers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00020-00006600-00006856": "alley doing great we're looking pretty", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00021-00006858-00006991": "hot all right", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00022-00006992-00007360": "oh man all right yeah gross great do", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00023-00007361-00007555": "some push-ups glad I threw it over there", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00024-00007556-00007823": "uh we've got a great way to reference a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00025-00007823-00008128": "show that a hasn't aired yet and B isn't", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00026-00008129-00008369": "this podcast yeah but but the listeners", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00027-00008370-00008524": "they'll get it eventually and then", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00028-00008525-00008764": "they'll go oh oh okay I get how he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00029-00008765-00009017": "really slandered him and then they will", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00030-00009018-00009203": "applaud me for it Al Borland best friend", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00031-00009204-00009514": "of Jason Moore yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00032-00009515-00009760": "um Big Show today some news to talk", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00033-00009761-00009959": "about", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00034-00009960-00010235": "some news for probably Mike to overreact", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00035-00010236-00010321": "to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00036-00010322-00010589": "what what could you possibly trying to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00037-00010590-00010864": "preempt that I know it's coming I can", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00038-00010865-00010960": "hear it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00039-00010961-00011249": "I can hear the train on the tracks", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00040-00011250-00011417": "uh but we'll get into it in a minute", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00041-00011418-00011759": "here a couple of headlines at the top", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00042-00011760-00011963": "you can head over to Foot Clan vote if", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00043-00011964-00012155": "you have a minute we are nominated for a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00044-00012156-00012251": "couple of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00045-00012252-00012701": "Sports podcast awards that uh frankly", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00046-00012702-00012941": "Brooks wants to win I mean it's really", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00047-00012941-00013127": "his ego that we're", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00048-00013128-00013469": "dealing with right now Brooks just the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00049-00013469-00013751": "man who has infinite wealth right what", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00050-00013752-00013985": "what do you give to that man Awards you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00051-00013986-00014141": "give him Awards yeah you give them", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00052-00014141-00014322": "something you can't just buy right", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00053-00014323-00014530": "Brooks can we do that yeah why don't you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00054-00014531-00014819": "just buy it now it has to be genuine at", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00055-00014819-00015065": "the awards okay and I need him he's a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00056-00015066-00015299": "rich man of Honor otherwise I would like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00057-00015300-00015508": "I'll take an Oscar", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00058-00015509-00015791": "can you just go to the manufacturer", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00059-00015791-00016211": "best actor Jeff Bezos no like but I mean", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00060-00016212-00016408": "you know they have like the the awards", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00061-00016409-00016625": "they give away when it's like not on air", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00062-00016626-00016811": "and I'll just be like yeah I go with", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00063-00016812-00017069": "those just just fill me in yeah I mean", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00064-00017070-00017225": "you could you could probably buy you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00065-00017226-00017350": "could probably buy some things but he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00066-00017351-00017536": "wants to earn them yeah so that's foot", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00067-00017537-00017800": "clanvote.com and then uh huge shout out", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00068-00017801-00018013": "to everybody out there that has", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00069-00018014-00018263": "subscribe to the fantasy footballers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00070-00018264-00018472": "Dynasty podcast we made made the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00071-00018473-00018761": "announcement on Tuesday I'll make it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00072-00018762-00019133": "again uh we have listened to the uh the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00073-00019134-00019980": "bellowing cries of the dynasty Community", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00074-00019981-00020435": "it's like a whale a whale cry and uh we", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00075-00020436-00020693": "have a dynasty specific show coming out", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00076-00020694-00020921": "once a week starting on Wednesday April", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00077-00020922-00021136": "5th it's gonna be hot you can go over to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00078-00021137-00021461": "Spotify Apple podcasts", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00079-00021462-00021629": "um everywhere you listen to podcasts", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00080-00021630-00021857": "follow the show the fantasy footballers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00081-00021858-00022103": "Dynasty podcast which is now at this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00082-00022104-00022325": "moment despite not having an episode the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00083-00022326-00022528": "number one sports podcast on Apple", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00084-00022529-00022793": "fantastic you did it with Foot Clan it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00085-00022794-00022997": "has an episode but that episode is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00086-00022998-00023171": "actually one minute long and it's just a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00087-00023172-00023435": "uh teaser trailer just Jason uh that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00088-00023436-00023633": "being said it is not just a teaser", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00089-00023634-00024047": "Taylor from Jason from Jason it is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00090-00024048-00024413": "fire intro music that you have made Mike", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00091-00024414-00024683": "that will be on the show uh that will be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00092-00024684-00024899": "the intro music you'll find out soon but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00093-00024900-00025097": "it is so good so thank you for uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00094-00025098-00025277": "supporting that you're going to enjoy it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00095-00025278-00025558": "it's going to be fun rookies Dynasty", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00096-00025559-00025937": "landscape news lots of good stuff and of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00097-00025938-00026087": "course the ultimate draft kit with the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00098-00026088-00026249": "dynasty pass is available right now at", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00099-00026250-00026549": "ultimate draftkit.com quick question of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00100-00026550-00026689": "the day", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00101-00026689-00026981": "it's an important one Jason is Dawning", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00102-00026982-00027227": "his dinner butter shirt today", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00103-00027227-00027479": "and um here's the quick question should", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00104-00027480-00027912": "you hungry should you dress", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00105-00027913-00028405": "stay hungry ah should you draft for need", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00106-00028406-00028852": "or best available player in Dynasty", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00107-00028854-00029243": "rookie drafts this is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00108-00029244-00029620": "in some ways maybe the worst question", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00109-00029622-00029867": "you could ever ask", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00110-00029868-00030245": "because I think everybody has stared", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00111-00030245-00030568": "this in the face and and looked at", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00112-00030569-00030827": "rookie rankings and looked at their team", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00113-00030827-00031108": "and then felt at a Crossroads between", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00114-00031110-00031451": "the do I take the player that people say", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00115-00031452-00031612": "I should take or do I take the player", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00116-00031613-00031774": "that my team really needs that I believe", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00117-00031775-00032212": "in and it's brutal I mean I think is it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00118-00032213-00032345": "fair to say that everybody's made a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00119-00032345-00032518": "mistake because they've chosen the wrong", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00120-00032519-00032705": "answer to this question yes yes and and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00121-00032706-00032962": "let's just call a spade a spade this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00122-00032963-00033245": "isn't do I draft best player available", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00123-00033246-00033502": "or position of need this is really", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00124-00033503-00033893": "specific in almost every League it's I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00125-00033894-00034157": "need a running back yes I mean that's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00126-00034158-00034331": "what it always is I really need a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00127-00034332-00034433": "running back", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00128-00034434-00034721": "and so should I draft them ahead of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00129-00034722-00034931": "these other wide receivers that you've", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00130-00034932-00035201": "got ranked ahead of the running backs", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00131-00035202-00035435": "um or you know do I fill that out my", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00132-00035436-00035590": "team is good but I'm desperate for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00133-00035591-00035801": "running back and I could tell you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00134-00035802-00036101": "straight up I have I know the correct", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00135-00036102-00036274": "answer to this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00136-00036275-00036462": "but you don't", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00137-00036463-00036827": "doing the correct answer is harder than", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00138-00036828-00037171": "it seems and I have made the egregious", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00139-00037172-00037546": "mistake and just which one are you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00140-00037547-00037745": "thinking of in particularly I'm thinking", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00141-00037746-00037912": "of when I took", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00142-00037913-00038209": "uh running back from the San Francisco", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00143-00038210-00038657": "49ers when they traded up uh for always", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00144-00038658-00038909": "a reminder there they traded up to get", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00145-00038910-00039215": "was this Trey sermon yeah I don't know I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00146-00039216-00039401": "mean you're the one who did it but yes I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00147-00039402-00039635": "remember it very clearly um it was funny", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00148-00039636-00039871": "my my team was stacked at wide receiver", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00149-00039872-00040102": "and uh had some problems with running", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00150-00040103-00040324": "back and so I I did select him do you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00151-00040325-00040445": "remember some of the people you passed", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00152-00040446-00040739": "on I remember one of them I remember the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00153-00040740-00040955": "one that I was debating between because", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00154-00040956-00041159": "I knew I should have taken who was that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00155-00041160-00041407": "I was Jalen waddle", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00156-00041408-00041771": "oh man just take the best player take", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00157-00041772-00042149": "the one that you know is really good you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00158-00042150-00042329": "know I I did think I mean full", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00159-00042330-00042496": "disclosure I thought Trey Sherman was", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00160-00042497-00042671": "going to be good his situation looked", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00161-00042672-00042755": "great", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00162-00042756-00042965": "um I I thought his film was good enough", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00163-00042966-00043090": "and when you go to the San Francisco", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00164-00043091-00043307": "49ers and Kyle Shanahan that running", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00165-00043308-00043559": "scheme uh the future did look bright so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00166-00043560-00043840": "I don't I was wrong for Elijah Mitchell", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00167-00043841-00044027": "yeah right exactly it turned out it was", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00168-00044028-00044183": "Elijah Mitchell which thankfully I did", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00169-00044184-00044530": "grab him in the third but um yeah Jalen", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00170-00044531-00044789": "waddle was a a known commodity a great", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00171-00044790-00045161": "Prospect uh first number six five five", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00172-00045162-00045467": "he was six six in the NFL draft so you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00173-00045468-00045652": "just don't pass on those guys it's a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00174-00045653-00046049": "mistake if if you in the end when you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00175-00046050-00046307": "draft a player who is good for Fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00176-00046308-00046529": "they are more valuable than when you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00177-00046530-00046696": "drop the player who is bad for Fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00178-00046697-00046877": "trade him for a running back why do I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00179-00046878-00047140": "feel like in our experience specifically", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00180-00047141-00047368": "I mean Mike you have a royce Freeman in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00181-00047369-00047555": "your past yeah Ritz a royce Freeman DJ", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00182-00047556-00047801": "Moore pretty similar and you also have a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00183-00047802-00048035": "Clyde Edwards Alara in your past yes so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00184-00048036-00048233": "is this specific to running backs", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00185-00048234-00048479": "mistakes it very much is I would I'll", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00186-00048480-00048745": "fill in a little bit here saying it's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00187-00048746-00049037": "when when the draft capital is that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00188-00049038-00049223": "egregious", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00189-00049224-00049480": "you've got to take you got to take the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00190-00049481-00049661": "and I know I've talked about the NFL", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00191-00049662-00049912": "makes mistakes but the game of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00192-00049913-00050068": "probability if a wide receiver is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00193-00050069-00050405": "drafted at number six overall versus a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00194-00050406-00050555": "running back who was selected in the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00195-00050556-00050699": "third round", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00196-00050700-00050921": "you you gotta go with the wide receiver", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00197-00050922-00051155": "there just because the odds are as", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00198-00051156-00051304": "you're moving along into you know like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00199-00051305-00051466": "the second round", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00200-00051467-00051779": "and the it and guys are in you know the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00201-00051779-00051952": "tears are emptying out and you're well", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00202-00051953-00052204": "now I'm down to a tear in my in my", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00203-00052205-00052516": "rookies you know like a tier three wide", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00204-00052517-00052642": "receiver or a tier three running back", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00205-00052644-00052882": "then go ahead and take for need but if", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00206-00052883-00053200": "there is still a top tier position like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00207-00053201-00053561": "and I don't I even if it's uh running", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00208-00053562-00053771": "back or wide receiver just whatever it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00209-00053772-00054059": "is and there's just a a huge staggering", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00210-00054060-00054323": "draft Capital difference between the two", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00211-00054324-00054449": "players", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00212-00054450-00054599": "I'm gonna I'm gonna chase the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00213-00054600-00054809": "probability and the analytics of though", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00214-00054810-00054976": "that Player working out for fantasy and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00215-00054977-00055132": "I I would add quarterbacks in a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00216-00055133-00055307": "superflex league sometimes you know you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00217-00055308-00055465": "might be in uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00218-00055466-00055732": "early second round and there's a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00219-00055733-00055876": "quarterback that pretty much isn't going", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00220-00055877-00056026": "to do anything and but you need", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00221-00056027-00056188": "quarterbacks so you you grab them over", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00222-00056189-00056350": "really good prospects there at running", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00223-00056351-00056530": "back and wide receiver", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00224-00056532-00056800": "um you've got to just take the the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00225-00056801-00057011": "highest probability hit", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00226-00057012-00057292": "of talented players versus need and I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00227-00057294-00057419": "think that yeah because I think the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00228-00057420-00057569": "running back thing specifically has to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00229-00057570-00057676": "do with", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00230-00057677-00057947": "people understand that when you have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00231-00057948-00058138": "that magical", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00232-00058139-00058379": "uh you know secret weapon at running", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00233-00058379-00058630": "back how powerful it is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00234-00058632-00058954": "and it's easier to be tempted by the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00235-00058955-00059363": "Clyde Sony Michelle Rashad Penny uh you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00236-00059364-00059585": "know there's a laundry list of Fairly", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00237-00059586-00059759": "high draft Capital running backs that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00238-00059760-00059915": "haven't panned out because everybody's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00239-00059916-00060071": "hunting for the next sequan and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00240-00060072-00060269": "McCaffrey and and so I think that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00241-00060270-00060509": "Temptation becomes the the greatest when", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00242-00060510-00060725": "it deals with a running back but you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00243-00060726-00060994": "know for those guys like looking at that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00244-00060995-00061150": "conversation", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00245-00061151-00061397": "even you know a round one versus around", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00246-00061398-00061709": "three player of probability of hitting", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00247-00061710-00061991": "it's a wide margin but you can have that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00248-00061991-00062182": "micro tier of looking in the first round", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00249-00062183-00062441": "all the Sony Rashad even though I think", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00250-00062441-00062579": "Rashad penny", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00251-00062579-00062873": "he seems like a hit as a player but his", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00252-00062874-00063066": "body doesn't want to play football", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00253-00063067-00063323": "called the fantasy bust but the uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00254-00063324-00063473": "incline Edwards of layered those are", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00255-00063474-00063742": "later second half", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00256-00063744-00063982": "uh rookie picks in the first round where", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00257-00063983-00064276": "saquon Christian McCaffrey Leonard", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00258-00064277-00064511": "fournette had his time but those were", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00259-00064512-00064775": "like top 10 picks in the NFL a much", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00260-00064776-00064966": "higher rate of hitting let me let me", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00261-00064967-00065230": "give you some data behind this uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00262-00065232-00065471": "situation of the 40 running backs", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00263-00065472-00065837": "selected since 2015 in Dynasty rookie", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00264-00065838-00066041": "drafts okay so that is player selected", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00265-00066042-00066311": "inside of Dynasty rookie drafts that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00266-00066312-00066569": "were third or later in the NFL draft so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00267-00066570-00066767": "I guess you mean third overall five", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00268-00066768-00067006": "became rb1's their first year", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00269-00067007-00067193": "so five of 40.", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00270-00067194-00067426": "yeah so third round yeah so what we're", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00271-00067427-00067588": "talking about here yeah third round or", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00272-00067589-00067732": "later like Royce Freeman type yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00273-00067733-00067865": "because it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00274-00067866-00068044": "yeah first and second round draft", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00275-00068045-00068338": "Capital matters is so much yeah so I I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00276-00068339-00068603": "mean it's just um", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00277-00068604-00068879": "you can spin yourself into", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00278-00068880-00069179": "a circle is that how is that the phrase", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00279-00069180-00069467": "yeah I would say a spiral", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00280-00069468-00069850": "but uh I lost the the idiom halfway that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00281-00069851-00070091": "works and obviously this sounds wrong I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00282-00070092-00070306": "mean a spiral is you spin yourself into", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00283-00070307-00070571": "a uh spiral is not a circle", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00284-00070572-00070888": "right it's circular but it's not a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00285-00070889-00071182": "circle a circle connects on its I guess", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00286-00071183-00071309": "I'm thinking of like when you throw a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00287-00071310-00071482": "football and it spirals do you spin", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00288-00071483-00071735": "yourself in the circular into a tizzy is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00289-00071736-00071885": "that a thing you can but that's not a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00290-00071886-00072088": "geometric shape right that's just a word", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00291-00072089-00072317": "we made up yeah I'm just I remember the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00292-00072318-00072431": "phrase", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00293-00072432-00072713": "spin yourself into oh you work yourself", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00294-00072714-00072988": "into a tizzy yes you spin yourself", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00295-00072989-00073463": "spiral", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00296-00073464-00073663": "um professionals and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00297-00073664-00073967": "uh obviously every single year the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00298-00073968-00074123": "rookies that are coming out there are", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00299-00074124-00074303": "there are differences there might be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00300-00074304-00074513": "four great wide receivers one great", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00301-00074514-00074800": "running back vice versa this year if", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00302-00074801-00074963": "you're not up to date on the rookies", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00303-00074964-00075071": "that are coming out and you're looking", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00304-00075072-00075250": "forward to them that's going to be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00305-00075251-00075443": "basically next week's shows Tuesday we", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00306-00075444-00075599": "got quarterbacks and running backs", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00307-00075600-00075803": "Thursday wide receivers and tight ends", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00308-00075804-00075953": "and if you are in the dynasty we're", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00309-00075954-00076073": "going to start with running backs next", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00310-00076074-00076265": "week dive even deeper go to more", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00311-00076266-00076450": "prospects all we're going to get you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00312-00076451-00076781": "prep for this NFL draft coming up soon", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00313-00076782-00077075": "that way you know all the players that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00314-00077076-00077279": "some succeed and some fail you know all", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00315-00077280-00077423": "of them yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00316-00077424-00077899": "all right uh great news", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00317-00077900-00078212": "news and notes from around the league", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00318-00078213-00078550": "[Music]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00319-00078551-00078791": "Falcons head coach Arthur Smith named", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00320-00078792-00078917": "Desmond Ritter the team's starting", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00321-00078918-00079031": "quarterback", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00322-00079032-00079373": "it's cool thanks Arthur it's gonna work", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00323-00079374-00079535": "real well Sean McVeigh said that Matthew", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00324-00079536-00079685": "Stafford is healthy there won't be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00325-00079686-00079985": "limitations ready to rumble that's good", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00326-00079986-00080188": "all right Eagles are bringing back the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00327-00080189-00080375": "Kelly Green alternates that's great yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00328-00080376-00080644": "everyone loves that it is one of those", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00329-00080645-00080837": "Universal things like I've never seen", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00330-00080838-00081047": "I've never seen someone with the take", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00331-00081048-00081215": "like man I hate those Kelly Green", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00332-00081216-00081406": "they're so ugly I've never heard that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00333-00081407-00081653": "one another great uh and then you know", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00334-00081654-00081821": "Brian Edwards and Marquez Callaway", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00335-00081822-00082000": "signed one-year deals yeah yeah Brian", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00336-00082001-00082162": "Edwards to the Saints", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00337-00082163-00082367": "Marcos College of the callaways it's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00338-00082368-00082565": "gonna work this time it's gonna work", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00339-00082566-00082811": "this time Edwards I mean it's funny that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00340-00082812-00083087": "he this is 100 percent", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00341-00083088-00083279": "your friend Eric are doing you a solid", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00342-00083280-00083453": "that's what that is to me", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00343-00083454-00083681": "it tells me that Derek Carr still", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00344-00083682-00083971": "believes it's going to work this time", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00345-00083972-00084221": "fourth time is the trial oh man how", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00346-00084222-00084562": "Brian Edwards keeps getting jobs and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00347-00084563-00084965": "snaps even like and do nothing with it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00348-00084966-00085162": "it's like he has the invisibility cloak", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00349-00085163-00085421": "on on the field he's on he's on the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00350-00085422-00085679": "field it's because he's he's so good he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00351-00085680-00085991": "has to play that way he he just all the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00352-00085992-00086309": "defensive coverage goes to Brian do you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00353-00086310-00086494": "think he is the best", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00354-00086495-00086794": "practice player of all time like he just", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00355-00086795-00087100": "must dominate these practices maybe he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00356-00087101-00087382": "is tired you know it's like man I did so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00357-00087383-00087532": "much work at practice I'm not ready for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00358-00087533-00087803": "this game the Cincinnati Bengals have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00359-00087804-00088061": "signed tight end Irv Smith Jr to a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00360-00088062-00088211": "one-year deal", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00361-00088212-00088468": "uh he was a second round draft pick in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00362-00088469-00088625": "2019", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00363-00088626-00088823": "he's played just eight games over the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00364-00088824-00089075": "last two years there was so much", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00365-00089076-00089255": "optimism around Irv Smith especially", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00366-00089256-00089555": "once Kyle Rudolph left two years ago in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00367-00089556-00089693": "Minnesota and it has not come to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00368-00089694-00089832": "fruition just", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00369-00089833-00090173": "24.6 years old gets an opportunity to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00370-00090174-00090406": "you know kind of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00371-00090407-00090532": "you know", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00372-00090533-00090700": "it's a good situation we talked about", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00373-00090701-00090941": "tight ends being or I'm sorry Cincinnati", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00374-00090942-00091037": "being", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00375-00091038-00091235": "one of the places where a tithing could", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00376-00091236-00091468": "go and have some success", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00377-00091469-00091709": "we the difference between I think this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00378-00091710-00091853": "and like Evan Ingram and Jacksonville", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00379-00091854-00092147": "one year deal is that obviously Evan", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00380-00092148-00092326": "Ingram had had more historical success", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00381-00092327-00092531": "on the field Irv Smith I don't think", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00382-00092532-00092671": "he's been over", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00383-00092672-00093035": "350 yards in a season maybe around there", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00384-00093036-00093232": "but obviously an athlete obviously", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00385-00093233-00093455": "somebody that can score some touchdowns", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00386-00093456-00093688": "yeah yeah I mean what was your reaction", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00387-00093689-00093988": "to this move my reaction as someone who", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00388-00093989-00094229": "I have herb Smith on one of my Dynasty", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00389-00094230-00094499": "rosters and I've liked his talent in the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00390-00094500-00094655": "past he's never been able to be on the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00391-00094656-00094955": "field this was great news uh I I think", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00392-00094956-00095147": "it's actually good for everybody Irv", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00393-00095148-00095417": "Smith was pretty much dead in the water", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00394-00095418-00095632": "value was it didn't look like he was", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00395-00095633-00095879": "going to have a situation where he could", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00396-00095880-00096106": "be fantasy relevant at all probably the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00397-00096107-00096275": "rest of his career I kind of forgot he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00398-00096276-00096503": "was a free agent exactly because you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00399-00096504-00096743": "hadn't heard a single thing and to show", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00400-00096744-00097067": "up in the vacated role of Hayden Hurst", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00401-00097068-00097300": "for a high-powered team that you know is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00402-00097301-00097529": "going to throw for 30 plus touchdowns", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00403-00097530-00097937": "like this is his chance at", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00404-00097938-00098194": "you know doing something of of relevance", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00405-00098195-00098332": "for fantasy football and then on the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00406-00098333-00098632": "flip side I actually you know I don't", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00407-00098633-00098818": "think Irv Smith is going to be a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00408-00098819-00099149": "reliable weekend week out starter no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00409-00099150-00099347": "tight ends are and I think he will not", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00410-00099348-00099605": "be as good as Hayden Hurst was so this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00411-00099606-00099868": "isn't huge but he is good enough to help", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00412-00099869-00100103": "the offense to help Joe burrow he'll", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00413-00100104-00100271": "have a few touchdowns and a couple big", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00414-00100272-00100517": "plays that can help open up the offense", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00415-00100518-00100756": "right now the the depth chart is Irv", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00416-00100757-00101124": "Smith Jr and and Devin Ozzy Ozzy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00417-00101125-00101305": "also", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00418-00101306-00101591": "several disappointments his you know at", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00419-00101592-00101723": "the tight end position but that have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00420-00101724-00101932": "athleticism", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00421-00101933-00102137": "um and for Irv Smith like if these", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00422-00102138-00102388": "Trends continue you had you know just a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00423-00102389-00102713": "couple years ago you had CJ uzama was", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00424-00102714-00102886": "the starting tight end for the Bengals", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00425-00102888-00103240": "he leaves got that sh money hey nurse", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00426-00103241-00103492": "one year repair some value goes and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00427-00103493-00103654": "signs a three-year 21 million dollar", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00428-00103655-00104092": "deal if Irv Smith can show anything of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00429-00104093-00104332": "value he's gonna make himself some money", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00430-00104333-00104554": "yeah he's still only 24 years old which", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00431-00104555-00104884": "is you know it's surprising he's a young", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00432-00104885-00105040": "young man", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00433-00105041-00105436": "all right any other news to go over no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00434-00105438-00105833": "sir no um Kyle any comments on the uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00435-00105833-00106084": "commitment to Desmond Ritter for your", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00436-00106085-00106247": "hometown team it's a weird way to say", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00437-00106248-00106552": "Lamar Jackson to me I don't know why is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00438-00106553-00106769": "that are you projecting something out", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00439-00106770-00106943": "there I mean are you hoping my heart", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00440-00106944-00107177": "does but no if they go with Ritter let's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00441-00107178-00107431": "just let's roll with it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00442-00107432-00107777": "let's roll with it like you have a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00443-00107778-00107927": "choice you'll be getting Ritter That", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00444-00107928-00108178": "season it's gonna be all over I liked it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00445-00108179-00108449": "all right we are into the mailbag here", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00446-00108450-00108692": "we go mailbag", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00447-00108693-00109189": "[Music]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00448-00109190-00109499": "all right we are into the mailbag", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00449-00109500-00109757": "answering your questions if you have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00450-00109758-00109883": "a question of your own you want to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00451-00109883-00109981": "submit go to the website the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00452-00109982-00110171": "fantasyfootballers.com click that submit", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00453-00110172-00110369": "a question button or you can dial the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00454-00110370-00110599": "voicemail hotline", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00455-00110600-00110927": "302-464-tff B", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00456-00110928-00111215": "and um let's start with a voicemail hey", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00457-00111216-00111551": "guys this is the fantasy football Genie", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00458-00111552-00111947": "I'm here granting you each one wish this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00459-00111948-00112193": "off season and I'm wondering what that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00460-00112194-00112319": "is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00461-00112320-00112595": "okay I have I have a I have a new wish", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00462-00112596-00112727": "okay", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00463-00112728-00112960": "it's a selfish selfish well of course it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00464-00112961-00113284": "is it works two ways for me", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00465-00113285-00113573": "I want DeAndre Hopkins traded to the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00466-00113574-00113639": "Buffalo Bills", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00467-00113640-00113952": "[Laughter]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00468-00113953-00114190": "you appreciate it I just can't wait to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00469-00114191-00114475": "share my wish so so this is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00470-00114476-00114784": "for a second round pick", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00471-00114785-00114958": "saw the Cardinals get their their draft", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00472-00114959-00115084": "capital", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00473-00115085-00115463": "and my Dynasty quarterback Joshua Allen", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00474-00115464-00115702": "gets a season of throwing a football to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00475-00115703-00115943": "Stefan Diggs and DeAndre Hopkins which I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00476-00115944-00116099": "think they will break records it's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00477-00116100-00116357": "pretty good if they have those two so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00478-00116358-00116657": "Hopkins I think will be fantasy relevant", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00479-00116658-00116945": "I think Alan gets better Cardinals get", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00480-00116946-00117149": "worse necessarily but better draft", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00481-00117150-00117304": "Capital that's where I'm going yeah and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00482-00117305-00117683": "I think that is not an unreasonable uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00483-00117683-00117940": "Outlook like it that could happen I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00484-00117941-00118102": "could see the bills doing that it would", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00485-00118103-00118289": "be good for everyone except for Stefon", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00486-00118290-00118399": "Diggs", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00487-00118400-00118745": "my genie wish of the off season the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00488-00118746-00118919": "reason I laughed is because it would be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00489-00118920-00119260": "that Austin Eckler is traded to the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00490-00119261-00119410": "bills", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00491-00119411-00119686": "and they draft Bijan as the replacement", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00492-00119688-00120040": "so it's a twofer because I want Austin", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00493-00120041-00120227": "Eckler to still have a lot of fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00494-00120228-00120436": "relevance if he leaves that's the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00495-00120438-00120575": "destination I'd want him to go to the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00496-00120576-00120923": "Bill's been looking for a a that this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00497-00120924-00121121": "type of back they've drafted the past", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00498-00121122-00121313": "catching backs they brought in Duke", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00499-00121314-00121486": "Johnson they were in the Christian", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00500-00121488-00121702": "McCaffrey sweepstakes they they really", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00501-00121703-00121907": "they want to do something that they have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00502-00121908-00122015": "not been able to do as an offense", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00503-00122016-00122134": "because they don't have the Personnel to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00504-00122135-00122440": "do it and Austin Eckler can do it let me", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00505-00122441-00122890": "ask you though could that be a wrong", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00506-00122891-00123107": "way to think of it because they've added", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00507-00123108-00123347": "like Duke Johnson has had success in the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00508-00123348-00123593": "NFL level catching the football you know", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00509-00123594-00123797": "who else has Naim Heinz who they traded", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00510-00123798-00124031": "for name Heinz has had historical", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00511-00124032-00124228": "Seasons catching the football still", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00512-00124229-00124421": "didn't do it in Buffalo like is there a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00513-00124422-00124636": "world where they are the Trap pass", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00514-00124638-00124852": "catching running back team because when", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00515-00124853-00125075": "the play breaks down Josh Allen for all", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00516-00125076-00125273": "the wishes and desires that we have for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00517-00125274-00125434": "him to to dump it down to a superstar", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00518-00125435-00125908": "look he he reacts like and he's got a a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00519-00125909-00126233": "body that can go and and head downfield", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00520-00126233-00126419": "instead of dropping it off like I think", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00521-00126420-00126647": "there's I think it's a trap I completely", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00522-00126648-00126815": "see what you're saying that Josh Allen", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00523-00126816-00126928": "isn't going to be the guy that checks it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00524-00126929-00127247": "down as much as he talks and runs but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00525-00127248-00127601": "the the versions of Naim Heinz and Duke", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00526-00127602-00127769": "Johnson that the Buffalo Bills received", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00527-00127770-00128116": "were not Peak uh age Peak career", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00528-00128117-00128284": "versions of those players and those", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00529-00128285-00128513": "aren't players that demand targets that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00530-00128514-00128758": "have plays drawn up in the passing game", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00531-00128759-00129101": "for them that are regularly called and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00532-00129102-00129281": "and gone to they are players who have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00533-00129282-00129460": "the ability to catch that check down", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00534-00129461-00129593": "that's probably not coming from Josh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00535-00129594-00129851": "Allen Austin Eckler if they trade for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00536-00129852-00130151": "him give him a contract they would be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00537-00130152-00130366": "putting him into the game plan in the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00538-00130367-00130583": "roles where he succeeds so I I see that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00539-00130583-00130745": "it could be a trap but I want a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00540-00130746-00131099": "high-powered offense Mike what is your", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00541-00131100-00131431": "wish for the fantasy Genie uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00542-00131432-00131789": "let's find out if treylands can actually", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00543-00131790-00131999": "play oh you just want him to be on the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00544-00132000-00132190": "field I'm not I won't I won't even say", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00545-00132191-00132461": "I'm wishing that he plays in these great", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00546-00132462-00132689": "I just want to know at this point like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00547-00132690-00133109": "I've had two full off seasons of Trey", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00548-00133110-00133354": "Lance discussion could he be this could", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00549-00133355-00133643": "he be that half of people on Twitter oh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00550-00133644-00133859": "it's clearly he sucks you're like well", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00551-00133860-00134033": "we don't know and then you got the trail", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00552-00134034-00134177": "Lans true there's no clearly he's going", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00553-00134178-00134416": "to be good well we we don't know we have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00554-00134417-00134704": "no clue what Trey Lance could do on the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00555-00134705-00134999": "field and I just would I'd like to find", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00556-00135000-00135352": "out it would be great to see because the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00557-00135353-00135766": "arguments want answers yes and I've got", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00558-00135767-00136037": "bad news for you you know I know we're", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00559-00136038-00136354": "not getting those answers I I had more", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00560-00136355-00136627": "thought on the Sam darnold", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00561-00136628-00136901": "signing okay I I think what it comes", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00562-00136902-00137093": "down to is they know already for sure", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00563-00137094-00137339": "that the early off-season programs the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00564-00137340-00137519": "beginning of when they're out there on", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00565-00137520-00137723": "the field the Brock Purdy is not going", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00566-00137724-00137993": "to be ready they're aware of that and so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00567-00137994-00138202": "their options are either", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00568-00138203-00138575": "have Trey Lance once again be the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00569-00138576-00138778": "entirety of your first team offense", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00570-00138779-00139121": "build for him and you know now you've", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00571-00139122-00139366": "got to make a tough transition or say", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00572-00139367-00139589": "hey let's bring someone else in and have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00573-00139590-00139835": "these guys compete we'll get used to you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00574-00139836-00140087": "know you know have have first reps split", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00575-00140088-00140273": "so we're not just taking it away from", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00576-00140274-00140513": "trade lands because we know we're going", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00577-00140514-00140675": "to Brock Purdy that's how it feels to me", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00578-00140676-00141016": "I feel like they are 100 and obviously", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00579-00141017-00141245": "the GM came out he said he deserves it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00580-00141246-00141497": "based on how he played last year unless", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00581-00141498-00141875": "his arm doesn't work and the surgery is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00582-00141876-00142114": "a failure Brock party will be the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00583-00142115-00142331": "starter I'm very convinced of that now", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00584-00142332-00142649": "it is interesting that the offense an", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00585-00142650-00142816": "aid for Trey Lansing made for Sam", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00586-00142817-00143069": "darnold or made for trail answer made", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00587-00143070-00143189": "for Brock party could look very", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00588-00143190-00143287": "different", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00589-00143288-00143614": "from one another good but they they uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00590-00143615-00143866": "they transitioned from they're all the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00591-00143867-00144035": "offices of planes of Lance right back to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00592-00144036-00144257": "Garoppolo perfectly fine and then that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00593-00144258-00144413": "went right into Brock Purdy perfectly", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00594-00144414-00144575": "fine I'm not concerned about the team of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00595-00144576-00144857": "okay for that but it's like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00596-00144858-00145109": "man if you just want to know that yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00597-00145110-00145301": "that's that at this point the genie can", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00598-00145302-00145559": "grant you that wish I just want to know", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00599-00145560-00146057": "and I I think Jason could be right of we", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00600-00146058-00146273": "still won't know we still and he'll just", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00601-00146274-00146549": "be a backup for the rest and of his life", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00602-00146550-00146866": "and never we will never ever know I mean", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00603-00146867-00147077": "do we know more or doing we know more", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00604-00147078-00147347": "about Jordan love than we do trailings I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00605-00147348-00147502": "think so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00606-00147503-00147713": "I mean at the very at the very least", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00607-00147714-00148097": "they have more practice we might not", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00608-00148098-00148464": "know from from you know game action live", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00609-00148465-00148709": "non-pre-season play but at the same time", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00610-00148710-00148937": "he's been practicing for years the Green", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00611-00148938-00149171": "Bay Packers know what they have Trey", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00612-00149172-00149285": "Lance hasn't been practicing while he's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00613-00149286-00149447": "been injured you know what I mean like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00614-00149448-00149693": "we he is a real unknown commodity but I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00615-00149694-00149783": "believe", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00616-00149784-00150028": "that another team out there you know", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00617-00150029-00150214": "someone like the Colts or the Falcons", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00618-00150215-00150587": "like go kick the tires on Trey Lance but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00619-00150588-00150701": "if", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00620-00150702-00150983": "any uh if if the San Francisco seasons", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00621-00150984-00151283": "of the past you know recent history are", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00622-00151284-00151409": "anything", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00623-00151410-00151697": "to be uh used as projection for moving", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00624-00151698-00152051": "forward Trey Lance will win fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00625-00152052-00152261": "titles this year", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00626-00152262-00152549": "as Brock Purdy will be the starter and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00627-00152550-00153064": "then round what week 10 week 11 he will", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00628-00153065-00153239": "go on to the IR and then Trey Lance will", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00629-00153240-00153401": "come in and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00630-00153402-00153628": "get injured and then Sam Domino's no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00631-00153629-00153802": "that's not how it works that's not how", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00632-00153803-00153971": "it works all right let's take a quick", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00633-00153972-00154066": "break and come back with another", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00634-00154067-00154901": "voicemail question", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00635-00154902-00155123": "all right by the way 83 career past", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00636-00155124-00155345": "attempts from Jordan love 102 for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00637-00155346-00155614": "veteran Trey Lance yeah I think Lance", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00638-00155615-00155885": "says three here's the three starts he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00639-00155886-00156173": "has uh four I think it's four stars but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00640-00156174-00156437": "three complete games and uh he has much", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00641-00156438-00156701": "more experience in a uh torrential", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00642-00156702-00157087": "downpour yes full game and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00643-00157088-00157439": "third of his career in physical uh rehab", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00644-00157440-00157685": "of injuries yeah he's been doing a lot", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00645-00157686-00157804": "of that different kinds of experience", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00646-00157805-00158045": "yeah all right into the uh next", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00647-00158046-00158290": "voicemail question fantasy footballers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00648-00158291-00158473": "Michael from Van Nuys California", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00649-00158474-00158752": "appreciate what you guys do my question", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00650-00158753-00159119": "would you trade Josh Jacobs for the 101", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00651-00159120-00159352": "in Dynasty I have the trade on the table", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00652-00159353-00159599": "should I pull the trigger I would be the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00653-00159600-00159749": "one trying to get the number one pick Mr", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00654-00159750-00159989": "Bijon Robinson God bless you have the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00655-00159990-00160182": "trade on the table like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00656-00160183-00160390": "[Music]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00657-00160391-00160601": "I I feel like Jason's not allowed to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00658-00160602-00160787": "answer this question I agree yeah that's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00659-00160788-00161183": "fine his face tells me how how I mean", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00660-00161184-00161381": "there's not even like there I already", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00661-00161382-00161543": "know your guy's answer I know all their", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00662-00161544-00161675": "answers I know everyone in the world's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00663-00161676-00161764": "answers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00664-00161765-00162143": "but go ahead I'm I'm out I recuse myself", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00665-00162144-00162604": "Mike oh yeah yes you should", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00666-00162605-00162995": "Josh Jacobs in year one of this trade", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00667-00162996-00163169": "is probably going to be a lot better", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00668-00163170-00163439": "than Bijan Robinson I would not put it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00669-00163440-00163685": "at probably I would say", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00670-00163686-00163864": "possibly", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00671-00163865-00164147": "certainly certainly could be I mean he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00672-00164148-00164345": "was the running back three last year he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00673-00164346-00164447": "could be the running back three again", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00674-00164448-00164621": "this year and be the rushing leader yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00675-00164622-00164843": "yeah I mean it was great I I see your", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00676-00164844-00165059": "point like this coming season Josh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00677-00165060-00165245": "Jacobs absolutely could finish better", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00678-00165246-00165551": "than Bijan yeah that's it could or", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00679-00165552-00165802": "slightly relevant or you have I mean it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00680-00165803-00166219": "was 1150 yards 1065 872", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00681-00166220-00166714": "1600 yards or that was Josh Jacobs big", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00682-00166715-00166978": "bada boom season and then you go back to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00683-00166979-00167243": "him being just being good which is I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00684-00167244-00167393": "mean over the thousand and twelve", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00685-00167394-00167609": "touchdowns that's great for fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00686-00167610-00167837": "I want to be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00687-00167838-00168064": "I want to be on the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00688-00168065-00168352": "train with you that everybody should", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00689-00168353-00168551": "just get on the Bichon buy a ticket and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00690-00168552-00168761": "we all have tickets and it just goes to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00691-00168762-00169013": "you know Paradise right that's the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00692-00169014-00169252": "destination right now it is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00693-00169253-00169457": "but that's not a guarantee", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00694-00169458-00169654": "and you should take Bijan in this trade", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00695-00169655-00169811": "because it's the best", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00696-00169812-00170111": "it's the best player in the deal in the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00697-00170112-00170416": "sense of draft Capital use age age", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00698-00170417-00170740": "Prospect could be a top 15 pick you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00699-00170741-00170975": "should do it in a dynasty League", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00700-00170976-00171101": "but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00701-00171102-00171311": "like I said year one you may be better", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00702-00171312-00171551": "off with Josh Jacobs and we got to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00703-00171552-00171761": "remember Josh Jacobs is not he's not", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00704-00171762-00172049": "like he's 25. yeah he's not very old so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00705-00172050-00172223": "there's also the world where he's the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00706-00172224-00172331": "better player", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00707-00172332-00172552": "for three years for the next three years", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00708-00172553-00172793": "that is that is a universe that exists", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00709-00172794-00173009": "without question yeah it's not a 100", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00710-00173010-00173231": "certainty that Bijan is going to be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00711-00173232-00173449": "better than Josh Jacobs it is a 100", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00712-00173450-00173687": "certainty that he's four years younger", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00713-00173688-00173987": "and it is a 100 certainty that he will", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00714-00173988-00174293": "be under contract for more years I mean", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00715-00174294-00174449": "Josh Jacobs is in a contract year", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00716-00174450-00174659": "playing under the franchise tag this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00717-00174660-00174833": "coming season so he'll have to find a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00718-00174834-00175025": "new home or a new contract somewhere and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00719-00175026-00175187": "that's not good for a 26 year old", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00720-00175188-00175426": "running back next year so situationally", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00721-00175427-00175678": "it's not it's so are you trading Javonte", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00722-00175679-00175919": "Williams for Josh Jacobs because he's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00723-00175920-00176207": "22. well Javonte Williams I don't expect", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00724-00176208-00176626": "to have a you know I I I'm not sure what", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00725-00176627-00176795": "kind of season he's gonna have I don't", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00726-00176796-00177052": "think he's going to be relevant he's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00727-00177053-00177364": "right here for Josh Jacobs I would trade", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00728-00177365-00177575": "Josh Jacobs for Bruce Hall is that what", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00729-00177576-00177701": "you're saying yeah would you do that too", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00730-00177702-00177952": "Mike yeah Josh I'd take Brees and the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00731-00177953-00178228": "the way it stands right now before the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00732-00178229-00178504": "NFL draft has happened Josh Jacobs looks", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00733-00178505-00178685": "set up for an incredible year because", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00734-00178686-00178864": "right now the depth chart is Amir", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00735-00178865-00179176": "Abdullah Brandon Bolden and last year I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00736-00179177-00179345": "think zamir white was a fourth rounder", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00737-00179346-00179525": "but I think that the Raiders found out", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00738-00179526-00179687": "everything they need to know about him", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00739-00179688-00180076": "they're going they won't go into the NFL", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00740-00180077-00180287": "season with this as their depth chart", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00741-00180288-00180443": "Josh Jacobs will have almost an", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00742-00180444-00180671": "identical season that's almost he's got", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00743-00180672-00180845": "the same head coach the same he's going", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00744-00180846-00180983": "to have the same type of offensive", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00745-00180984-00181145": "dependency John Jacobs is gonna have a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00746-00181146-00181349": "massive year but he won't have as long", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00747-00181350-00181481": "of a career as those other guys yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00748-00181482-00181697": "we'll have a good year but I don't I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00749-00181698-00181949": "would bet heavily against him hitting", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00750-00181950-00182213": "1600 rushing yards again yeah so I I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00751-00182214-00182464": "agree with both the core of what both of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00752-00182465-00182597": "you are saying Josh Jacob's gonna be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00753-00182598-00182821": "awesome this year I feel like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00754-00182822-00183293": "1210 as a rusher is near locked barring", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00755-00183294-00183545": "injury and that's awesome yeah it's a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00756-00183546-00183701": "great that's still a far cry from what", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00757-00183702-00183881": "he did last year but that is awesome and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00758-00183882-00184114": "I I think the role no matter who they", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00759-00184115-00184337": "bring in the role is going to basically", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00760-00184338-00184469": "be the same as what we saw this last", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00761-00184470-00184595": "season", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00762-00184596-00184883": "they paid they paid for it too", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00763-00184884-00184966": "um", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00764-00184967-00185176": "here's a question a couple of them", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00765-00185177-00185338": "actually about Travis Kelsey Twitter", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00766-00185339-00185573": "play action pod is this the year that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00767-00185574-00185861": "Travis Kelsey gets dethroned as the top", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00768-00185862-00185993": "tight end what are your thoughts on", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00769-00185994-00186383": "Hawkinson this year nope nope", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00770-00186384-00186593": "no he's not getting the throne oh man", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00771-00186594-00186797": "especially with Lamar Jackson like the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00772-00186798-00186928": "the one", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00773-00186929-00187157": "player that I think could", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00774-00187158-00187504": "you know maybe compete with him is Mark", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00775-00187505-00187702": "Andrews but Mark Andrews can't compete", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00776-00187703-00187961": "with him if Lamar Jackson's not a raven", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00777-00187962-00188261": "you're not nothing for TJ Hawkinson who", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00778-00188262-00188554": "let's see joining the Minnesota Vikings", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00779-00188555-00188938": "uh his Pace was not as impressive as I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00780-00188939-00189352": "thought I know that's right he was", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00781-00189353-00189733": "great for reading questions", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00782-00189734-00190025": "he was he was he was impressive because", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00783-00190026-00190271": "he he's had years of being disappointing", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00784-00190272-00190469": "he was impressive because he was so high", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00785-00190470-00190631": "in the pecking order of the offense but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00786-00190632-00190799": "when you actually look at the cumulative", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00787-00190800-00191009": "stats I'm going to remove you want to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00788-00191010-00191237": "know that was very funny I'm gonna", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00789-00191238-00191381": "remove the final week of the season", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00790-00191382-00191578": "because he he had one catch and he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00791-00191579-00191861": "played 46 percent of the snaps like I'll", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00792-00191862-00192088": "take that one out and it's still a 17", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00793-00192089-00192475": "game pace of 111 catches nice", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00794-00192476-00192857": "950 yards here's here's what's funny no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00795-00192858-00192988": "and again we're not talking about it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00796-00192989-00193145": "they just won the World Championship", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00797-00193146-00193499": "they're the top dogs the Chiefs they got", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00798-00193500-00193643": "it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00799-00193644-00193804": "and they'll probably fix some things a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00800-00193805-00193954": "wide receiver but right now the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00801-00193955-00194219": "storyline in Kansas City is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00802-00194220-00194537": "canarius Tony and Sky Moore", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00803-00194538-00195028": "and MPS okay and NBS but nmvs is the end", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00804-00195029-00195257": "of a sentence that you meant like he's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00805-00195258-00195514": "fine but they lost Nicole Hardman they", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00806-00195515-00195790": "lost Juju and it's just kind of funny", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00807-00195791-00195928": "because it's like the expectation Sky", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00808-00195929-00196073": "more is going to step up Canary's Tony's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00809-00196074-00196331": "going to step up like the history is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00810-00196332-00196552": "that Travis Kelsey steps up I mean it's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00811-00196553-00196876": "just it's like nothing in their current", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00812-00196877-00196997": "depth chart", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00813-00196998-00197195": "does anything to say he's going to take", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00814-00197196-00197428": "a step I actually I did a little bit of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00815-00197429-00197663": "research because obviously Titan age", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00816-00197664-00197957": "um is age is important for all of these", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00817-00197958-00198190": "um and when looking specific to to tight", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00818-00198191-00198319": "ends", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00819-00198320-00198533": "he's at an age that you would think", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00820-00198534-00198701": "normally is bad I talked about this a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00821-00198702-00198940": "little bit last season but if you factor", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00822-00198941-00199378": "in Greek god it's actually you know you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00823-00199379-00199685": "peek at human 50. so he's actually got", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00824-00199686-00199978": "about a decade and a half left oh if", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00825-00199979-00200123": "you're looking at God years God years", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00826-00200124-00200333": "he's going to be 50 years old when he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00827-00200334-00200464": "hits his Peak so he's actually gonna", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00828-00200465-00200645": "interesting healthier", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00829-00200646-00200885": "stronger probably an inch taller this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00830-00200886-00201154": "coming season still growing still he's a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00831-00201155-00201563": "growing young man Zeus is uh yeah no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00832-00201564-00201731": "one's dethroning Travis Kelsey unless", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00833-00201732-00201995": "Travis Kelsey gets injured and misses a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00834-00201996-00202247": "large chunk of time if he misses four", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00835-00202248-00202511": "games no one's just no one is dethroning", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00836-00202512-00202804": "him uh follow up then from McCade Gordon", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00837-00202805-00202943": "on Twitter what should I expect in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00838-00202944-00203176": "return for Kelsey in a dynasty League", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00839-00203177-00203447": "what's the least I should try to acquire", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00840-00203448-00203723": "okay so I saw this question earlier and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00841-00203724-00204059": "I I wanted I was thinking", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00842-00204060-00204347": "if I had Travis Kelsey right now", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00843-00204348-00204604": "I would go and offer him straight up for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00844-00204605-00204743": "Mark Andrews", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00845-00204744-00204988": "there's really yeah because there's a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00846-00204989-00205427": "lot of fear you don't know and horses 27", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00847-00205428-00205888": "uh sounds about right but let's let's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00848-00205889-00206146": "27. perfect", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00849-00206148-00206327": "um so he's five years younger than", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00850-00206328-00206603": "Travis Kelsey he has obviously proven", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00851-00206604-00206903": "that he can be a stud I think you're", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00852-00206904-00207016": "right about that and there's a lot of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00853-00207017-00207227": "fear over the quarterback situation you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00854-00207228-00207448": "might not have Lamar you might have the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00855-00207450-00207653": "worst situation imaginable so you could", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00856-00207654-00207862": "get in some leagues I think you could", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00857-00207863-00208055": "get the deal done Mark Andrews manager", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00858-00208056-00208205": "is probably freaking out and there is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00859-00208206-00208432": "also the world where two weeks from now", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00860-00208433-00208648": "Lamar Jackson is back and he's a raven", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00861-00208650-00208858": "and now you've you've gotten however the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00862-00208859-00209062": "position you have Travis Kelsey in your", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00863-00209063-00209182": "championship", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00864-00209183-00209398": "yes yes you train him for Mark Andrews", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00865-00209400-00209494": "no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00866-00209496-00209669": "no I will answer there's no way you'll", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00867-00209669-00209813": "do that because there's no way you'll do", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00868-00209814-00209896": "it because you want champ Champion", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00869-00209898-00210257": "that's why the Travis Kelsey trade the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00870-00210258-00210473": "value is is so interesting because if", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00871-00210473-00210653": "you have someone who anybody in here", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00872-00210654-00210832": "have Mark Andrews that wants to go send", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00873-00210833-00210958": "that offer through", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00874-00210959-00211319": "it would be it would be Damon so and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00875-00211319-00211439": "you're going to decline it I know you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00876-00211440-00211613": "will here but here's I would not Mike", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00877-00211614-00211792": "would I would and we would have to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00878-00211794-00212015": "discuss here's the way I look at Travis", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00879-00212016-00212344": "Kelsey either you are a team that can", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00880-00212346-00212471": "compete maybe you don't look at yourself", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00881-00212471-00212698": "I'm not the overwhelming favorite but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00882-00212700-00212932": "I'm going to make it into the playoffs", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00883-00212933-00213244": "then Travis Kelsey is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00884-00213246-00213521": "invaluable to the team like because he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00885-00213521-00213905": "is such a a competitive Advantage at a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00886-00213906-00214031": "position where other people are like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00887-00214032-00214301": "yeah I got four points oh yeah we did it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00888-00214302-00214510": "baby I got one yard and one one", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00889-00214511-00214703": "touchdown I got seven points the people", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00890-00214704-00214967": "are super stoked about that so either", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00891-00214967-00215182": "you can compete and you have him", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00892-00215183-00215489": "and championships are everything in a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00893-00215490-00215675": "dynasty League they are everything", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00894-00215676-00215956": "or you can't compete and you go to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00895-00215957-00216160": "someone who can compete and you make", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00896-00216161-00216671": "them pay the iron price it is it is a it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00897-00216671-00216917": "is a up and coming stud player it is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00898-00216917-00217079": "probably multiple first round picks", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00899-00217080-00217367": "because Travis Kelsey", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00900-00217367-00217673": "I think more than any other player in in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00901-00217673-00217955": "like a dynasty League can be the piece", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00902-00217956-00218189": "that turns a team that can compete into", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00903-00218190-00218387": "a championship contending team the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00904-00218388-00218591": "question being posed to Mike and I's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00905-00218592-00218891": "co-managed team that we are really", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00906-00218892-00219077": "looking for the championship champ the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00907-00219078-00219277": "fourth the fourth championship", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00908-00219278-00219539": "back-to-back title winners", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00909-00219540-00219832": "is the proof of what you're saying", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00910-00219833-00220121": "you're saying he is a Difference Maker", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00911-00220121-00220360": "to go from being a good team yes to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00912-00220361-00220553": "winning the championship which we have", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00913-00220554-00220756": "just done with Travis Kelsey the last", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00914-00220757-00220913": "three years because make strong", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00915-00220914-00221237": "arguments our team has been good our", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00916-00221238-00221441": "teams have have limped into the playoffs", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00917-00221442-00221639": "basically every year and only been a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00918-00221640-00221860": "good team and then Travis Kelsey does", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00919-00221861-00222125": "what Travis Kelsey does and we we end up", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00920-00222126-00222358": "winning championships Kyle is just", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00921-00222359-00222544": "berating your team in the slack Channel", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00922-00222546-00222775": "let me tell you what I pay for traffic", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00923-00222776-00223144": "let me let me I can tell you exactly", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00924-00223146-00223306": "what I paid to get Travis Kelsey last", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00925-00223307-00223451": "year in the dynasty League I have it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00926-00223452-00223679": "right in front of me all right I gave up", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00927-00223680-00223955": "Travis Kelsey you traded I'm sorry", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00928-00223956-00224242": "incredible how did you pull that off I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00929-00224244-00224513": "call it the boomerang I throw it out", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00930-00224514-00224723": "there and it comes right back to my", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00931-00224723-00224915": "teeth the only trade I will take for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00932-00224916-00225053": "Kelsey is I trade him to you and you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00933-00225054-00225203": "trade him back to me but I want", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00934-00225204-00225425": "something coming back on the return you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00935-00225426-00225581": "can taste him but it's gonna cost you a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00936-00225582-00225731": "third round pick", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00937-00225732-00226084": "up how it taste a little little dust for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00938-00226085-00226331": "you take a screenshot you have flex", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00939-00226332-00226642": "online and then send them back you get a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00940-00226644-00226931": "taste of a player on your team for no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00941-00226932-00227039": "games", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00942-00227040-00227303": "it's a screenshot taste yeah but it's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00943-00227304-00227494": "gonna feel real good well that didn't I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00944-00227496-00227755": "didn't do that well I gave up", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00945-00227756-00228239": "Godwin Gabe Davis dolsich Warren a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00946-00228240-00228460": "second and two-thirds", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00947-00228461-00228748": "for Kelsey and Mike Evans", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00948-00228750-00228863": "yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00949-00228864-00229151": "I feel like I won that champion it seems", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00950-00229152-00229294": "like it you were reading it do you feel", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00951-00229296-00229510": "that way now a year I mean I didn't win", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00952-00229511-00229667": "the title I went to the semi-finals yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00953-00229667-00229937": "as you were reading because like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00954-00229938-00230110": "a lot a lot of it comes down to Mike", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00955-00230111-00230296": "Evans and Chris Godwin of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00956-00230298-00230542": "what is what is going to happen in Tampa", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00957-00230544-00230939": "Bay when Jason's Champion Kyle Trask is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00958-00230940-00231367": "is the one throwing touchdowns", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00959-00231367-00231594": "it's Baker", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00960-00231596-00231946": "uh Instagram question from Trevor Naji", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00961-00231948-00232156": "Harris or saquon Barkley in a dynasty", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00962-00232157-00232505": "startup oh that's a fun that's a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00963-00232506-00232732": "I I know my answer and I think I know my", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00964-00232733-00232858": "I think my answer is going to be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00965-00232859-00232991": "different than", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00966-00232992-00233279": "consensus and majority I I would go say", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00967-00233280-00233537": "I would go Naji and I I like most people", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00968-00233538-00233813": "would go say Quan so Naji is 26. they're", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00969-00233814-00233992": "one year apart he just turned 26 now", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00970-00233994-00234125": "he's 25 because he was a little bit", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00971-00234126-00234419": "older I would go saquon Barkley", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00972-00234419-00234610": "Instagram question from Big Dog Ryan", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00973-00234611-00234760": "says can you still be friends with a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00974-00234761-00234881": "league mate if you found out they listen", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00975-00234882-00235098": "to the same fantasy football podcast", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00976-00235100-00235319": "I was gonna say best friends what you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00977-00235319-00235492": "want someone with good taste you want", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00978-00235494-00235625": "someone with a good sense of humor you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00979-00235626-00235805": "like people that dress nice yeah want", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00980-00235806-00235996": "some smell good with things in common", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00981-00235998-00236201": "and probably handsome independently", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00982-00236202-00236315": "wealthy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00983-00236316-00236584": "well you know they listen here so yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00984-00236585-00236848": "best you read lots of books what you do", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00985-00236850-00237191": "you drive a Dodge Stratus you look at", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00986-00237192-00237442": "your league mates and you go", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00987-00237444-00237779": "that goes that guy's a weirdo uh that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00988-00237780-00237977": "guy that guy's awesome yeah and then you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00989-00237978-00238163": "already know you already know they", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00990-00238164-00238337": "listen everybody that's awesome in your", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00991-00238338-00238510": "league listens to this show yeah you", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00992-00238511-00238732": "just you just I'll tell you about it and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00993-00238733-00238901": "as soon as it's revealed you become", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00994-00238902-00239165": "closer friends yeah yeah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00995-00239166-00239327": "that's a great question that's a great", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00996-00239328-00239560": "question uh Kyle on the website who is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00997-00239561-00239831": "the better keeper value Crystal Lobby", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00998-00239832-00239981": "for a sixth", "ikgkd0k1iDg-00999-00239982-00240292": "Khalil Herbert for a ninth", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01000-00240294-00240532": "that's not close no oh that was the end", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01001-00240533-00241031": "of the list yeah no that's um", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01002-00241032-00241313": "Twitter question from uh Andy Shamir", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01003-00241314-00241534": "says is it safe to drop Tom Brady in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01004-00241535-00242053": "Dynasty it's never safe", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01005-00242054-00242284": "because somehow", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01006-00242285-00242501": "somehow Trey's sermon was on our Dynasty", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01007-00242502-00242717": "waiver Jason what did you do did I miss", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01008-00242717-00242821": "that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01009-00242821-00243167": "so you were like uh I mean you're like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01010-00243167-00243346": "how did Andy get Trey sermon yeah I saw", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01011-00243348-00243551": "it today and I was I was", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01012-00243552-00243832": "I was remiss your odds of Trey sermon", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01013-00243833-00243989": "and you picked him up because there was", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01014-00243990-00244294": "a little tiny little fluff piece out of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01015-00244296-00244492": "Philadelphia of Trace sermons has a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01016-00244494-00244619": "chance to be good but that's what we", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01017-00244619-00244853": "need I mean that is our source of life", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01018-00244854-00245039": "and Dynasty over the off season it's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01019-00245040-00245255": "like wait wait the coach said something", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01020-00245256-00245491": "positive about this player", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01021-00245492-00245734": "it was the most Brian Edwards piece of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01022-00245735-00245891": "news that has ever come out about a", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01023-00245892-00246058": "player it was like Trey sermon always", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01024-00246059-00246239": "does something amazing in practice that", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01025-00246240-00246515": "makes us all turn our heads and then not", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01026-00246516-00246779": "play him you got it but you never know", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01027-00246780-00246982": "miles Sanders is gone these players need", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01028-00246983-00247246": "to be at Rashad Penny his contract it", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01029-00247248-00247396": "does not guarantee that he's going to be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01030-00247398-00247619": "on the Philadelphia Eagles if he's on", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01031-00247619-00247877": "his health the past of his health does", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01032-00247878-00247984": "not guarantee he's gonna be playing", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01033-00247985-00248260": "multiple games so yeah you add these", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01034-00248261-00248471": "people this is how you make moves in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01035-00248471-00248675": "Dynasty", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01036-00248676-00248806": "um and that's part of what makes it so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01037-00248807-00249005": "if you can get Jalen waddle on your team", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01038-00249006-00249346": "I'll swap swap sermon for him", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01039-00249348-00249646": "he has one", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01040-00249648-00249821": "said Jason just punished me by", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01041-00249821-00250037": "unplugging my charging cable on my", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01042-00250038-00250229": "laptop that's right and in a few hours", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01043-00250230-00250696": "you are going to be really upset", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01044-00250698-00250854": "it's the long con", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01045-00250855-00250991": "[Laughter]", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01046-00250992-00251158": "also while doing that I almost spilled", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01047-00251159-00251453": "my drink yes yes okay", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01048-00251454-00251675": "um here's a good one let's end with this", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01049-00251676-00251944": "one instagram question about an", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01050-00251946-00252101": "interesting player", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01051-00252102-00252377": "will Isaiah Pacheco surpass all", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01052-00252378-00252623": "expectations this upcoming season oh man", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01053-00252623-00252898": "and I I think the chant there's a chance", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01054-00252900-00253198": "the answer is is yes", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01055-00253200-00253427": "thank you thank you and there he goes", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01056-00253428-00253727": "yes there yes there's a chance", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01057-00253728-00254051": "he does and there is a chance that he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01058-00254052-00254273": "vanishes and has never heard from again", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01059-00254273-00254513": "due to being a seventh round pick so", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01060-00254514-00254621": "where", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01061-00254621-00255067": "where are you currently have the chips", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01062-00255067-00255401": "I know the feet are very fast", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01063-00255402-00255581": "um I lean on the side that I think he", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01064-00255582-00255815": "will disappoint for okay the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01065-00255816-00256096": "expectations they're not going to do", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01066-00256098-00256282": "first round pick Clyde Edwards will be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01067-00256283-00256481": "back that I was gonna say Clyde Edwards", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01068-00256482-00256660": "O'Hare will be back that's not you know", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01069-00256661-00257039": "that isn't nothing and closer right", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01070-00257040-00257255": "right now they don't have McKinnon so uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01071-00257256-00257506": "them adding a running back makes a lot", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01072-00257507-00257794": "of sense and Pacheco", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01073-00257796-00258046": "he's good but like you said Mike seventh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01074-00258048-00258179": "round running back there's just a lot of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01075-00258180-00258371": "history of these these later round guys", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01076-00258371-00258701": "that they can be impressive", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01077-00258702-00259103": "and replaced so that can happen no doubt", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01078-00259104-00259234": "about it he's being drafted in", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01079-00259235-00259487": "basketball ahead of Joe Mixon ahead of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01080-00259488-00259739": "Cam makers ahead of David Montgomery the", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01081-00259740-00260110": "Joe mix and best ball current ADP and I", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01082-00260111-00260327": "know on this show that the sentiment on", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01083-00260328-00260675": "Joe Mixon has been pretty negative of", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01084-00260676-00261017": "it sounds like is he gonna be a cap uh", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01085-00261017-00261263": "casualty for the Cincinnati Bengals", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01086-00261264-00261473": "if that happens and he's going I mean at", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01087-00261473-00261610": "that point there's going to be no", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01088-00261611-00261784": "starting jobs where he can get the type", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01089-00261785-00261941": "of work for the high-powered offense", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01090-00261942-00262121": "that he's currently on", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01091-00262121-00262482": "but going at the as the running back 24", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01092-00262483-00262727": "that to me almost sounds like they're", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01093-00262728-00262930": "saying we guarantee that this is what is", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01094-00262931-00263182": "going to happen to Joe Mixon so I just", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01095-00263183-00263380": "say if I'm playing basketball if I'm", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01096-00263381-00263584": "having the adjacent amount of teams I'm", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01097-00263585-00263806": "definitely grabbing Joe Mixon in a few", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01098-00263807-00264023": "of my drafts I just in case I like", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01099-00264024-00264155": "Pacheco", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01100-00264156-00264430": "and the situation because of Andy Reid", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01101-00264431-00264749": "and the Chiefs his loyalty is not to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01102-00264750-00265055": "draft Capital Clyde hydrogel air is not", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01103-00265056-00265295": "to age Jared McKinnon is 30 years old", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01104-00265296-00265547": "played a massive role in bringing them", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01105-00265548-00265739": "to a Super Bowl their priority is to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01106-00265740-00265943": "production into how hard a player", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01107-00265944-00266189": "practices how hard they play look if", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01108-00266190-00266315": "they add another piece of the puzzle", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01109-00266316-00266458": "I'll change my opinion completely but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01110-00266459-00266573": "today", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01111-00266574-00266789": "today I'm comfortable like I I would", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01112-00266790-00267019": "want Isaiah to check on my fantasy team", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01113-00267020-00267467": "over over miles", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01114-00267468-00267880": "Montgomery", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01115-00267881-00268080": "nope", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01116-00268081-00268360": "over cam Acres", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01117-00268361-00268582": "yeah this is turned quickly if you look", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01118-00268583-00268721": "at the light I mean I think he's I think", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01119-00268722-00268877": "he's being drafted the right place let's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01120-00268878-00269189": "put it that way I think 22-23. there's", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01121-00269190-00269555": "there's a a few colors he's not going to", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01122-00269556-00269680": "be alone in Kansas he's not going to be", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01123-00269681-00269795": "alone in Kansas City and he doesn't", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01124-00269796-00270095": "catch the ball enough to really make an", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01125-00270096-00270269": "impact the last nine games where Isaiah", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01126-00270270-00270541": "Pacheco looked great he was on Pace for", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01127-00270542-00270767": "1195 rushing yards that's great only", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01128-00270768-00271037": "seven touchdowns but those fluctuate but", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01129-00271038-00271273": "18 total receptions would have been his", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01130-00271274-00271625": "17-game Pace you know that's just barely", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01131-00271626-00271745": "more than a catch a game that's not", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01132-00271746-00271871": "enough for Fantasy when you're talking", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01133-00271872-00272075": "about guys like Montgomery and Miles", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01134-00272076-00272321": "Sanders who have done more have been", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01135-00272322-00272501": "given a lot more money in compensation", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01136-00272502-00272627": "and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01137-00272628-00272873": "um you know that the the path for their", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01138-00272874-00273106": "fantasy relevance should be easier and", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01139-00273107-00273256": "more obvious I'll take them over Alger", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01140-00273257-00273455": "does that does that help I would as well", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01141-00273456-00273743": "sure that's right we're in complete", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01142-00273744-00273893": "agreement", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01143-00273894-00274067": "that is gonna do it for today's episode", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01144-00274068-00274399": "of the fantasy footballers podcast", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01145-00274400-00274751": "please leave us a review follow us on", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01146-00274752-00275027": "Spotify Apple podcasts lots more fantasy", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01147-00275028-00275149": "football goodness coming your way", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01148-00275150-00275651": "rookies here we go goodbye", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01149-00275652-00275825": "thank you for listening to another", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01150-00275826-00276023": "episode of the fantasy footballers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01151-00276024-00276239": "podcast join our fantasy football", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01152-00276240-00276563": "community on jointhefoot.com and follow", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01153-00276564-00277038": "us on Twitter at the FF ballers", "ikgkd0k1iDg-01154-00277039-00277348": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "ikvISx4yGSM", "text": {"ikvISx4yGSM-00000-00000006-00000227": "are you looking to become a successful", "ikvISx4yGSM-00001-00000228-00000455": "nursing student and need some extra tips", "ikvISx4yGSM-00002-00000456-00000671": "and advice from a nursing professor", "ikvISx4yGSM-00003-00000672-00000916": "welcome to just like that", "ikvISx4yGSM-00004-00000917-00001175": "my name is Professor Jesse and this is", "ikvISx4yGSM-00005-00001176-00001457": "LJ I've been a registered nurse and a", "ikvISx4yGSM-00006-00001458-00001763": "nursing Professor for over 15 years I've", "ikvISx4yGSM-00007-00001764-00002063": "taught students online in a lab in the", "ikvISx4yGSM-00008-00002064-00002279": "classroom and in the clinical setting so", "ikvISx4yGSM-00009-00002280-00002537": "I've seen it all I created this channel", "ikvISx4yGSM-00010-00002538-00002717": "to support nursing and Healthcare", "ikvISx4yGSM-00011-00002718-00002926": "students like you who want to be", "ikvISx4yGSM-00012-00002927-00003118": "successful in school and in their future", "ikvISx4yGSM-00013-00003119-00003226": "careers", "ikvISx4yGSM-00014-00003227-00003485": "nowadays students learn Beyond The Four", "ikvISx4yGSM-00015-00003486-00003713": "Walls of the traditional classroom and", "ikvISx4yGSM-00016-00003714-00003965": "they're going to places like YouTube and", "ikvISx4yGSM-00017-00003965-00004204": "other social media platforms to learn", "ikvISx4yGSM-00018-00004205-00004493": "I also know the challenges that some", "ikvISx4yGSM-00019-00004494-00004649": "students face when they feel like they", "ikvISx4yGSM-00020-00004650-00004841": "don't belong or they simply don't see", "ikvISx4yGSM-00021-00004842-00005069": "Role Models around them that look like", "ikvISx4yGSM-00022-00005070-00005152": "them", "ikvISx4yGSM-00023-00005153-00005404": "representation matters and I want to do", "ikvISx4yGSM-00024-00005405-00005735": "my part I wanted to find a unique way of", "ikvISx4yGSM-00025-00005736-00005933": "connecting with all types of diverse", "ikvISx4yGSM-00026-00005934-00006202": "students and offer practical ways to", "ikvISx4yGSM-00027-00006203-00006322": "support them", "ikvISx4yGSM-00028-00006323-00006664": "my content is relatable simple and", "ikvISx4yGSM-00029-00006665-00006923": "offers Professor approved tips and", "ikvISx4yGSM-00030-00006923-00007133": "strategies to help you navigate the", "ikvISx4yGSM-00031-00007134-00007439": "highs and lows of nursing school I post", "ikvISx4yGSM-00032-00007440-00007667": "videos every week so make sure to", "ikvISx4yGSM-00033-00007668-00007883": "subscribe and turn on notifications now", "ikvISx4yGSM-00034-00007884-00008092": "so you don't miss a beat thanks for", "ikvISx4yGSM-00035-00008093-00008278": "watching and hope to see you back here", "ikvISx4yGSM-00036-00008279-00008552": "real soon"}}, {"audio_id": "ikKP0MLjwvc", "text": {"ikKP0MLjwvc-00000-00000159-00000335": "good afternoon can i remind members of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00001-00000336-00000503": "the covered related measures that are in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00002-00000504-00000647": "place and that face covering should be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00003-00000648-00000823": "worn when moving around the chamber and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00004-00000824-00001015": "across the hollywood campus", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00005-00001016-00001166": "the first item of business this", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00006-00001167-00001383": "afternoon is portfolio questions and the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00007-00001384-00001655": "first portfolio is covered 19 recovery", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00008-00001655-00001902": "and parliamentary business if a member", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00009-00001903-00002199": "wishes to ask a supplementary question", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00010-00002200-00002479": "they should indicate so by pricing the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00011-00002480-00002815": "request to speak button or by entering r", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00012-00002816-00002926": "in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00013-00002927-00003183": "chat room function and i call question", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00014-00003184-00003454": "number one alex go hamilton the deputy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00015-00003455-00003590": "presiding officer to ask the scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00016-00003592-00003727": "government what plans it has for the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00017-00003728-00003943": "future of the covet 19 certification", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00018-00003944-00004038": "scheme", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00019-00004039-00004215": "deputy first minister john smith", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00020-00004216-00004383": "president officer we've listed the legal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00021-00004384-00004543": "requirement for venues to operate a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00022-00004544-00004759": "covert certification scheme some venues", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00023-00004760-00004951": "may opt to use certification to make", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00024-00004952-00005191": "their customers and staff feel safer the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00025-00005192-00005375": "covered status app will remain in place", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00026-00005376-00005495": "for as long as it is needed to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00027-00005496-00005718": "facilitate international travel a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00028-00005719-00005879": "domestic certification scheme will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00029-00005880-00006063": "remain in our package of protective", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00030-00006064-00006295": "measures and may be used if required in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00031-00006296-00006510": "the future to manage covert outbreaks", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00032-00006511-00006631": "though we hope that will not be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00033-00006631-00006855": "necessary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00034-00006856-00007087": "alex calhampton i'm very grateful for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00035-00007088-00007334": "the deputy first minister for that reply", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00036-00007336-00007487": "presiding officer in her covered", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00037-00007488-00007710": "statement last month as the dfm has just", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00038-00007711-00007887": "said the first minister said that these", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00039-00007888-00008103": "passes would be retained on a voluntary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00040-00008104-00008319": "basis for any business that wanted to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00041-00008320-00008591": "use them this effectively creates an", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00042-00008592-00008878": "unregulated scheme with businesses free", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00043-00008879-00009110": "to refuse custom to anyone on the basis", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00044-00009111-00009231": "of them not having the right piece of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00045-00009232-00009439": "paper the correct barcode on their phone", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00046-00009440-00009599": "and there was no suggestion of when this", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00047-00009600-00009823": "would end does the deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00048-00009824-00010039": "agree that this creates a potentially", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00049-00010040-00010223": "dangerous loophole where the liberties", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00050-00010224-00010431": "and rights of scots to medical privacy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00051-00010432-00010855": "could be undermined indefinitely", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00052-00010856-00011055": "no i don't take that view because the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00053-00011056-00011246": "arrangements around the covered", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00054-00011247-00011471": "certification app and the gathering and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00055-00011472-00011678": "the handling of in processing of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00056-00011679-00011799": "information", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00057-00011800-00011991": "is all very carefully regulated and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00058-00011992-00012263": "compliant and obviously any business has", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00059-00012264-00012551": "got to be mindful of its own policies", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00060-00012552-00012767": "and decisions and legal obligations in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00061-00012768-00012999": "the way in which they would administer", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00062-00013000-00013294": "any schemes so i'm satisfied about legal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00063-00013295-00013503": "compliance and obviously the onus is on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00064-00013504-00013719": "a business to ensure that they too are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00065-00013719-00013919": "operating with legal compliance", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00066-00013919-00014111": "supplementary stephen curry", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00067-00014112-00014351": "thank you deputy presiding officer given", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00068-00014352-00014575": "that this entire debacle has cost the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00069-00014576-00014847": "taxpayer seven million pounds", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00070-00014847-00014999": "seven million pounds which went to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00071-00015000-00015207": "danish and american companies to build", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00072-00015208-00015463": "an app that many scottish companies", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00073-00015463-00015655": "including those in fourth valley could", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00074-00015656-00015903": "have made cheaper and more effectively", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00075-00015904-00016071": "what lessons has the deputy first", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00076-00016072-00016271": "minister learned from this experience", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00077-00016272-00016463": "and what does he plan to do to ensure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00078-00016464-00016679": "such a thing doesn't happen again deputy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00079-00016680-00016886": "first minister i i i just don't", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00080-00016887-00017119": "recognize the characterization that mr", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00081-00017120-00017271": "kerr puts on this there's an open", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00082-00017272-00017471": "procurement process in which the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00083-00017472-00017727": "government has to ensure that these", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00084-00017728-00017927": "services are procured properly and with", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00085-00017928-00018071": "legal compliance and that's been", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00086-00018072-00018319": "followed in these circumstances", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00087-00018320-00018607": "the scheme was expanded significantly", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00088-00018608-00018855": "beyond its original purpose which is why", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00089-00018856-00019111": "it cost more money clearly if we expand", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00090-00019112-00019319": "the scheme beyond its original concept", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00091-00019320-00019486": "it is going to cost more money i think", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00092-00019487-00019591": "that just", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00093-00019592-00019911": "is as straightforward as um as b", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00094-00019912-00020047": "following a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00095-00020048-00020167": "and so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00096-00020168-00020407": "the government subjects all of its", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00097-00020408-00020703": "decisions to careful scrutiny about", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00098-00020704-00020943": "financial handling about legal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00099-00020944-00021063": "compliance", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00100-00021064-00021263": "about compliance with other regulatory", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00101-00021264-00021471": "arrangements and this scheme has", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00102-00021472-00021743": "complied in every aspect and of course i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00103-00021744-00022119": "would stress it is a valuable tool in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00104-00022120-00022294": "ensuring that we can take the necessary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00105-00022295-00022486": "steps to suppress the circulation of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00106-00022487-00022767": "virus and for international travelers a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00107-00022768-00022927": "crucial piece", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00108-00022928-00023214": "of and of evidence to enable individuals", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00109-00023215-00023463": "to undertake international travel and if", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00110-00023464-00023599": "mr care", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00111-00023600-00023767": "wants to support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00112-00023768-00024030": "our airports in trying to attract more", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00113-00024031-00024335": "custom then of course those", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00114-00024336-00024455": "individual", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00115-00024456-00024775": "airports will require their customers to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00116-00024776-00025055": "be able to comply with the requirements", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00117-00025056-00025358": "of the coveted status app and i call a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00118-00025359-00025806": "supplementary from sharon diary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00119-00025807-00026111": "i i must die did you mr not wish to seek", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00120-00026112-00026318": "a supplementary in this no sorry it's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00121-00026319-00026407": "questioning", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00122-00026408-00026670": "the buzzard that's why i called you okay", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00123-00026672-00026927": "question number two ronan mckay", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00124-00026927-00027127": "thank you presiding officer to ask the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00125-00027127-00027302": "scottish government what work and action", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00126-00027304-00027470": "across government is undertaking to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00127-00027472-00027646": "support local authorities and local", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00128-00027647-00027846": "communities in their recovery from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00129-00027847-00028158": "covert 19 pandemic deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00130-00028160-00028302": "president officer across government we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00131-00028304-00028446": "are working closely with our partners in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00132-00028447-00028607": "local government and the third sector to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00133-00028608-00028767": "deliver outcomes that will bring about a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00134-00028768-00028983": "fairer future particularly for those who", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00135-00028983-00029118": "have been most affected during the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00136-00029119-00029327": "pandemic by working together we will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00137-00029327-00029502": "align services around the individuals", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00138-00029504-00029711": "and the families who need them the cover", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00139-00029712-00029902": "recovery strategy sets out clearly the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00140-00029904-00030158": "outcomes we will improve for communities", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00141-00030160-00030327": "we will increase financial security for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00142-00030327-00030502": "low-income households enhance the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00143-00030503-00030687": "well-being of children and young people", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00144-00030688-00030902": "and create good green jobs and fair work", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00145-00030903-00031127": "through a package of targeted actions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00146-00031127-00031335": "alongside the president of kosla i chair", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00147-00031336-00031511": "the covered recovery strategy programme", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00148-00031512-00031735": "board and last week we met to progress", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00149-00031736-00031911": "further this ambitious transformation of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00150-00031912-00032190": "public services ronan mckay", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00151-00032191-00032351": "thank the deputy first minister for the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00152-00032352-00032527": "answer and businesses will play a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00153-00032527-00032679": "crucial role in recovery of local", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00154-00032680-00032846": "communities up and down the country", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00155-00032847-00033039": "however large rises in energy bills", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00156-00033040-00033215": "increased costs for everyday essentials", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00157-00033216-00033374": "and rising interest rates will mean the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00158-00033375-00033511": "businesses will see their margins", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00159-00033512-00033623": "squeezed", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00160-00033624-00033767": "can i ask the deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00161-00033768-00033902": "whether he considers that the measure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00162-00033903-00034071": "set out in the chancellor's statement", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00163-00034072-00034295": "just hours ago will have any substantive", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00164-00034296-00034502": "effect on businesses already struggling", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00165-00034503-00034774": "with brexit-related import costs supply", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00166-00034775-00034927": "chain problems", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00167-00034928-00035079": "as the high streets that serve our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00168-00035080-00035255": "communities try to recover from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00169-00035256-00035431": "impacts of the pandemic", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00170-00035432-00035574": "deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00171-00035575-00035823": "president i haven't had a lengthy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00172-00035824-00036062": "opportunity because of other business to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00173-00036063-00036279": "take in all of the details of the spring", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00174-00036280-00036559": "statement but i don't think i heard", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00175-00036560-00036862": "enough in that statement to be confident", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00176-00036863-00037079": "that businesses have been protected from", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00177-00037080-00037239": "the challenges that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00178-00037240-00037390": "are being faced there will be some", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00179-00037391-00037527": "measures that will have an effect such", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00180-00037528-00037655": "as the reduction", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00181-00037656-00037887": "in fuel duty but the implications of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00182-00037888-00038071": "brexit and particularly on the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00183-00038072-00038318": "availability of labour are absolutely", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00184-00038319-00038511": "colossal challenges for the business", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00185-00038512-00038759": "sector i hear about it every week in my", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00186-00038760-00039039": "constituency from organizations that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00187-00039040-00039223": "cannot recruit enough staff because of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00188-00039224-00039527": "the removal of free movement of eu", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00189-00039528-00039767": "citizens so i don't think what i've", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00190-00039768-00039967": "heard so far today will give me", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00191-00039968-00040118": "confidence that the business community", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00192-00040119-00040390": "has been given the support that it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00193-00040391-00040630": "requires to address the challenges that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00194-00040631-00040823": "are currently faced by business", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00195-00040824-00041087": "supplements mercedes bialba", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00196-00041088-00041302": "thank you universities are a vital part", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00197-00041303-00041471": "of many local communities and we must", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00198-00041472-00041646": "ensure they recover from the pandemic in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00199-00041647-00041783": "a way which protects the health of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00200-00041784-00041983": "students and staff but in light of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00201-00041984-00042183": "rising covert cases nationally we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00202-00042184-00042318": "continue to see outbreaks at", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00203-00042319-00042495": "universities like st andrews where over", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00204-00042496-00042743": "450 students tested positive in a single", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00205-00042744-00042927": "week so does the scottish government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00206-00042928-00043046": "agree that we should be looking at", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00207-00043047-00043255": "continuing to mandate protections like", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00208-00043256-00043479": "face coverings testing on campuses", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00209-00043480-00043711": "social distancing and ventilation in our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00210-00043712-00044023": "universities deputy first minister i i i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00211-00044024-00044230": "acknowledge the significance of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00212-00044231-00044479": "points that mr alba puts to me because", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00213-00044480-00044662": "the we're obviously at this present", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00214-00044663-00044830": "moment going through very significant", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00215-00044831-00045071": "levels of community transmission and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00216-00045072-00045158": "that is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00217-00045159-00045335": "presenting itself in a number of ways in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00218-00045336-00045543": "university and college campuses around", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00219-00045544-00045727": "the country where it's important that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00220-00045728-00045911": "we're taking every measure to sustain", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00221-00045912-00046111": "the education of young people and to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00222-00046112-00046407": "protect their safety into the bargain so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00223-00046408-00046574": "in the strategic framework the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00224-00046575-00046727": "government has published there are a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00225-00046728-00046918": "range of baseline measures that we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00226-00046919-00047151": "expect institutions to be taking forward", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00227-00047152-00047335": "some of those will be around ventilation", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00228-00047336-00047495": "for example", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00229-00047496-00047686": "obviously we have a mandatory position", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00230-00047687-00047911": "on face coverings as mr alba will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00231-00047912-00048111": "realise that's not universally welcomed", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00232-00048112-00048311": "within parliament the conservative party", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00233-00048312-00048495": "had vigorously opposed", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00234-00048496-00048671": "our extension of the face coverings", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00235-00048672-00048783": "measures but i think they are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00236-00048784-00049007": "appropriate for this moment given the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00237-00049008-00049174": "significance of the challenges that we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00238-00049175-00049255": "face", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00239-00049256-00049415": "and of course the cabinet will consider", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00240-00049416-00049615": "these measures for review at its meeting", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00241-00049616-00049790": "on tuesday and there'll be a statement", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00242-00049791-00049943": "to parliament next week about these", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00243-00049944-00050030": "issues", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00244-00050031-00050199": "and supplementary pam duncan glancy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00245-00050200-00050535": "who's joining us remotely", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00246-00050536-00050702": "thank you deputy president officer the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00247-00050703-00050846": "additional funding given to the third", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00248-00050847-00051015": "sector during the pandemic was much", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00249-00051016-00051190": "needed and essential to allow them to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00250-00051191-00051358": "offer the crew support to families that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00251-00051359-00051614": "they did but this year's budget hands a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00252-00051615-00051775": "cut of around one million pounds to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00253-00051776-00051999": "third sector organizations the need for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00254-00052000-00052190": "their advice and services has never been", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00255-00052191-00052463": "more required particularly as as we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00256-00052464-00052671": "recover from the pandemic but also in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00257-00052672-00052935": "the cost of living crisis and of course", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00258-00052936-00053175": "um as a result of the war in ukraine and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00259-00053176-00053407": "people coming here to take refuge what", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00260-00053408-00053550": "engagement is the scottish government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00261-00053551-00053726": "having with the fed sector to ensure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00262-00053727-00053894": "that adequate funding arrangements are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00263-00053895-00054103": "in place and can it provide an update on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00264-00054104-00054279": "any further consideration it's given to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00265-00054279-00054535": "developing multi-year funding models", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00266-00054536-00054671": "first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00267-00054672-00054863": "the quest of multi-year funding models", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00268-00054864-00055159": "is obviously an issue which arises from", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00269-00055160-00055430": "the degree of um perspective information", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00270-00055432-00055638": "we have on the financial arrangements", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00271-00055639-00055823": "from the united kingdom government we're", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00272-00055824-00056023": "now in a different situation at this", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00273-00056024-00056271": "moment because we now have a longer um", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00274-00056272-00056415": "line of sight than we've had for a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00275-00056416-00056623": "number of years and obviously the france", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00276-00056624-00056830": "secretary will reflect on those points", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00277-00056832-00057079": "because it is desirable for us to give", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00278-00057079-00057311": "multi-year settlements and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00279-00057312-00057471": "i i know that's a position that the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00280-00057472-00057703": "foreign secretary has shared with the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00281-00057704-00057919": "third sector i would encourage pam", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00282-00057920-00058150": "duncan glancey to look at all budget", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00283-00058151-00058303": "lines not just", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00284-00058304-00058494": "individual budget lines where there may", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00285-00058495-00058711": "be changes that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00286-00058712-00058894": "members would like to see", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00287-00058895-00059119": "reversed there's a range of different", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00288-00059120-00059271": "funding streams the government is making", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00289-00059272-00059479": "available to third sector organizations", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00290-00059479-00059591": "and indeed", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00291-00059591-00059782": "within the covert recovery strategy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00292-00059783-00059935": "there's a very heavy emphasis on the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00293-00059936-00060175": "role of the third sector in supporting", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00294-00060176-00060438": "the work on covert recovery there will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00295-00060439-00060679": "be more said of course tomorrow when the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00296-00060679-00060911": "social justice secretary sets out to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00297-00060912-00061111": "approach on the child poverty", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00298-00061112-00061366": "implementation plan and that information", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00299-00061367-00061550": "will be shared with parliament tomorrow", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00300-00061551-00061750": "and obviously the third sector is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00301-00061751-00061950": "critical in supporting our work to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00302-00061951-00062199": "eliminate child poverty in our country", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00303-00062200-00062359": "question number three not lost question", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00304-00062360-00062606": "number four edward mountain", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00305-00062607-00062766": "guiding officer to ask the scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00306-00062767-00063023": "government what percentage of foi", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00307-00063024-00063303": "requests made to it were answered within", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00308-00063304-00063535": "20 working days within the last 12", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00309-00063536-00063630": "months", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00310-00063632-00063766": "minister george adams thank you", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00311-00063767-00063926": "president often i thank the member for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00312-00063927-00064215": "his question over the 2021 calendar you", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00313-00064216-00064471": "have responded to over 4 000 foi", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00314-00064472-00064775": "requests 86 of which were answered", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00315-00064776-00064999": "within the statutory deadline this is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00316-00065000-00065206": "broadly in line with the average of uh", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00317-00065207-00065366": "for other scottish public authorities", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00318-00065367-00065591": "and represents continued recovery of our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00319-00065592-00065735": "performance since the start of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00320-00065736-00065871": "pandemic", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00321-00065872-00066038": "edward mountain", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00322-00066039-00066175": "well that's interesting presiding", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00323-00066176-00066294": "officer and i thank the minister for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00324-00066295-00066526": "that answer i've had numerous examples", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00325-00066527-00066775": "perhaps it's just me where foi requests", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00326-00066776-00066959": "have not been responded to within time", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00327-00066960-00067055": "limits", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00328-00067056-00067279": "even ones which i've had to appeal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00329-00067280-00067519": "even such a simple question as when will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00330-00067520-00067871": "vessels 801 and 802 be delivered has", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00331-00067872-00068167": "been left unanswered for over four weeks", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00332-00068168-00068335": "surely a government minister with their", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00333-00068336-00068479": "finger on the pulse should know the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00334-00068480-00068679": "answer that and will the minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00335-00068680-00068967": "undertake to look at the 14 which didn't", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00336-00068968-00069319": "make uh the cut um find out why", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00337-00069320-00069519": "minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00338-00069520-00069735": "thank you president officer a simple", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00339-00069736-00069919": "answer to the question asked by mr", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00340-00069920-00070094": "mountain i would say there are other", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00341-00070095-00070279": "ways of parliamentary scrutiny you can", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00342-00070280-00070463": "ask questions by a parliamentary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00343-00070464-00070694": "question should he wish a pq you could", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00344-00070695-00070975": "do that as well uh so there are there", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00345-00070976-00071119": "are opportunities mister could you", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00346-00071120-00071311": "assume you see a second could we please", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00347-00071312-00071582": "have less sedentary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00348-00071583-00071847": "comment a question has been asked please", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00349-00071848-00072015": "let the minister answer that is the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00350-00072016-00072182": "courteous way to proceed minister please", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00351-00072183-00072391": "resume", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00352-00072392-00072575": "just in summary presiding officer there", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00353-00072576-00072823": "are more than uh adequate measures for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00354-00072824-00072967": "members to be able to ask questions of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00355-00072968-00073262": "anything they wish within this chamber", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00356-00073263-00073567": "question number five sharon die", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00357-00073568-00073719": "thank you presenting officer to ask the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00358-00073720-00073911": "scottish government how its policies and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00359-00073912-00074103": "actions across government will support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00360-00074104-00074279": "south easter to recover from the covert", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00361-00074280-00074559": "19 pandemic deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00362-00074560-00074726": "preserves the priorities for recovery", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00363-00074727-00074879": "will vary by location and we are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00364-00074880-00075031": "committed across government to working", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00365-00075032-00075191": "with communities to understand local", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00366-00075192-00075415": "needs and tailor support to set services", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00367-00075416-00075543": "to support them", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00368-00075544-00075694": "we announced an 80 million pounds", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00369-00075695-00075887": "covered economic recovery fund for local", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00370-00075888-00076038": "authorities to target support for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00371-00076039-00076247": "businesses and communities and south", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00372-00076248-00076511": "asia will receive more than 1.68 million", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00373-00076512-00076703": "pounds and will have full discretion", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00374-00076704-00076911": "over how to target support to maximize", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00375-00076912-00077119": "economic recovery further to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00376-00077120-00077294": "scottish government is investing 103", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00377-00077295-00077447": "million pounds in the ayrshire growth", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00378-00077448-00077638": "deal which will see transformational", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00379-00077639-00077847": "investment in projects across the asia", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00380-00077848-00078087": "to support long-term inclusive growth", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00381-00078088-00078255": "regional partners estimate the deal will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00382-00078256-00078519": "create 7 000 new jobs and unlock an", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00383-00078520-00078679": "additional three hundred million pounds", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00384-00078680-00078919": "from the private sector serendi", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00385-00078920-00079143": "thank you in my constituency i was proud", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00386-00079144-00079335": "to see both communities and third sector", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00387-00079336-00079543": "organizations coming together to support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00388-00079544-00079726": "south eastern lifeline when the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00389-00079727-00079959": "pandemic began that allowed them to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00390-00079960-00080150": "expand services like their helpline or", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00391-00080151-00080294": "their prescription collection and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00392-00080295-00080494": "distribution network but this wouldn't", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00393-00080495-00080679": "be possible without people going above", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00394-00080680-00080879": "and beyond for their communities", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00395-00080880-00081071": "well the deputy first minister outlined", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00396-00081072-00081199": "how the scottish government will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00397-00081200-00081423": "continue to fund the third sector and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00398-00081424-00081671": "retain people in local organisations", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00399-00081672-00081871": "deputy first minister i think this is a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00400-00081872-00082126": "very important issue and the type of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00401-00082127-00082367": "services that sharon dowie talks about", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00402-00082368-00082599": "are increasingly evident within our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00403-00082600-00082847": "communities and increasingly developing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00404-00082848-00083062": "because capacity has been built within", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00405-00083063-00083279": "communities to make sure these services", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00406-00083280-00083431": "and support can be available on an", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00407-00083432-00083567": "ongoing basis", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00408-00083568-00083750": "i had a very helpful conversation just", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00409-00083751-00083959": "last week with the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00410-00083960-00084126": "with a number of community development", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00411-00084127-00084247": "organizations", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00412-00084248-00084479": "to establish how the very good example", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00413-00084480-00084679": "that sharon dowd puts to me", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00414-00084680-00084935": "can be replicated in other parts of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00415-00084936-00085103": "country there are many other comparable", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00416-00085104-00085311": "examples that are working well", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00417-00085312-00085631": "so i'm keen to explore how we can ensure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00418-00085632-00085815": "that capacity exists not just to deal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00419-00085816-00086015": "with a covert situation but it may be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00420-00086016-00086150": "relevant for a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00421-00086151-00086350": "winter weather situation or a flooding", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00422-00086351-00086599": "situation or other examples where we can", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00423-00086600-00086815": "build community capacity to assist the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00424-00086816-00087006": "public services and addressing need", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00425-00087007-00087175": "within communities so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00426-00087176-00087431": "a welcome information about the example", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00427-00087432-00087655": "that sharon dowie has put to me and i'm", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00428-00087656-00087815": "sure the government is very keen to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00429-00087816-00087999": "build that community capacity a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00430-00088000-00088191": "supplementary stephon prime", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00431-00088192-00088423": "thank you deputy presiding officer can i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00432-00088424-00088615": "ask cabinet secretary how much money the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00433-00088616-00088791": "scottish government has spent in south", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00434-00088792-00088999": "asia to mitigate the uk government's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00435-00089000-00089231": "policies that are hitting families in my", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00436-00089232-00089487": "constituency hard as we recover from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00437-00089488-00089862": "pandemic debt minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00438-00089863-00090038": "there's a number of funding streams that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00439-00090039-00090231": "the government has made available in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00440-00090232-00090391": "south australia area overseeing the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00441-00090392-00090623": "local government foreign settlement the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00442-00090624-00090782": "local authority in south asia is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00443-00090783-00091035": "receiving funding of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00444-00091036-00091350": "247.6 million pounds which represents a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00445-00091351-00091631": "real terms increase of 8.2 percent for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00446-00091632-00091855": "south asia and there's also cost of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00447-00091856-00092135": "living support um of nearly 5 million", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00448-00092136-00092399": "pounds and which will be made available", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00449-00092400-00092487": "to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00450-00092488-00092647": "south asia", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00451-00092648-00092871": "in addition to that southeastern council", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00452-00092872-00093206": "was allocated 533 000 pounds from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00453-00093207-00093462": "flexible element of the winter support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00454-00093463-00093623": "fund and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00455-00093624-00093894": "we also allocated more than 1.7 million", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00456-00093895-00094087": "pounds in discretionary housing payment", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00457-00094088-00094350": "to south asia council to fully mitigate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00458-00094351-00094623": "against the damaging effects of the uk", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00459-00094624-00094823": "government's bedroom tax", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00460-00094824-00095094": "question number six emirotic", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00461-00095095-00095262": "thank you presiding officer to ask the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00462-00095263-00095423": "scottish government what steps were", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00463-00095424-00095606": "being taken with ministerial colleagues", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00464-00095607-00095750": "across government to ensure that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00465-00095751-00095950": "scotland's recovery from the covet 19", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00466-00095951-00096159": "pandemic addresses the reported", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00467-00096160-00096382": "disproportionate impact of the pandemic", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00468-00096383-00096567": "on low-income households", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00469-00096568-00096774": "deputy first minister president officer", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00470-00096775-00096903": "our strategy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00471-00096904-00097143": "is focused on those most affected during", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00472-00097144-00097374": "the pandemic and on creating a fairer", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00473-00097375-00097503": "future for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00474-00097504-00097735": "everyone affected we will do this by", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00475-00097736-00097935": "transforming public services to ensure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00476-00097936-00098103": "that they are person-centered in design", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00477-00098104-00098311": "and delivery working closely with our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00478-00098312-00098471": "partners including kosovo local", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00479-00098472-00098647": "government the third sector and the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00480-00098648-00098879": "private sector this will multiply the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00481-00098880-00099047": "impact of our actions and support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00482-00099048-00099231": "communities and the most vulnerable to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00483-00099232-00099335": "thrive", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00484-00099336-00099479": "the government has declared tackling", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00485-00099480-00099694": "child poverty and national mission and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00486-00099695-00099903": "is working to mobilize all of scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00487-00099904-00100111": "to help us achieve this goal we will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00488-00100112-00100303": "publish the second tackling child", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00489-00100304-00100518": "poverty delivery plan tomorrow which", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00490-00100519-00100687": "will outcome the transformational", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00491-00100688-00100847": "actions we will take alongside our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00492-00100848-00101047": "delivery partners to tackle child", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00493-00101048-00101287": "poverty which lies at the very heart of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00494-00101288-00101615": "the covert recovery strategy emerald", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00495-00101616-00101815": "i i thank the deputy first minister for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00496-00101816-00102062": "that response recent polling suggests", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00497-00102063-00102231": "that more than 80 percent of people in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00498-00102232-00102430": "scotland are worried about the tory cost", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00499-00102431-00102639": "of living crisis with food fuel and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00500-00102640-00102918": "household bills skyrocketing as", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00501-00102919-00103175": "inflation soars to a 30-year high does", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00502-00103176-00103342": "the deputy first minister consider that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00503-00103343-00103534": "the uk government's spring budget goes", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00504-00103535-00103758": "anywhere near far enough to reverse the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00505-00103759-00104039": "damage caused by a decade of tory cuts", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00506-00104040-00104239": "because without drastic action those", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00507-00104240-00104447": "low-income households will not be a part", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00508-00104448-00104615": "of scotland's recovery", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00509-00104616-00104782": "deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00510-00104783-00104983": "the emerald it makes a very fair point", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00511-00104983-00105215": "i've highlighted at the heart of our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00512-00105216-00105439": "covered recovery strategy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00513-00105440-00105758": "is the drive to tackle and eliminate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00514-00105759-00105910": "child poverty", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00515-00105911-00106086": "on the one hand the scottish government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00516-00106088-00106431": "has just taken a decision", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00517-00106432-00106615": "announced in the budget in december to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00518-00106616-00106847": "be applied in the next financial year", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00519-00106848-00106943": "to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00520-00106944-00107199": "increase the scottish child payment", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00521-00107200-00107478": "but at the same time the united kingdom", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00522-00107479-00107719": "government has removed important", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00523-00107720-00107927": "increases that were put in place on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00524-00107928-00108095": "universal credit", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00525-00108096-00108207": "so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00526-00108208-00108502": "there is one glaring example where the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00527-00108503-00108702": "scottish government is trying to act to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00528-00108703-00108943": "tackle child poverty and our efforts are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00529-00108944-00109175": "undermined by the actions of the united", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00530-00109176-00109310": "kingdom government as i said in my", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00531-00109311-00109566": "answer to ronan mckay i haven't had a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00532-00109567-00109751": "large amount of time to take in all of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00533-00109752-00109919": "the details of the spring statement but", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00534-00109920-00110063": "i've heard enough", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00535-00110064-00110278": "to and i had a very strong contribution", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00536-00110279-00110502": "from my parliamentary colleague allison", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00537-00110503-00110710": "thules in the budget statement in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00538-00110711-00110878": "spring statement", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00539-00110879-00111086": "which made the point that not nearly", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00540-00111088-00111302": "enough had been taken to to tackle the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00541-00111303-00111463": "effects of poverty on low-income", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00542-00111464-00111631": "households that is obviously at the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00543-00111632-00111758": "heart of the scottish government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00544-00111759-00111990": "strategy and we would like to be have", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00545-00111991-00112223": "our actions reinforced not undermined by", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00546-00112224-00112375": "the uk government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00547-00112376-00112615": "question number seven jackie billy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00548-00112616-00112775": "to ask the scottish government whether", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00549-00112776-00112943": "it will remove the provisions on the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00550-00112944-00113166": "extension of emergency powers from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00551-00113167-00113439": "coronavirus recovery and reform scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00552-00113440-00113695": "bill deputy first minister president the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00553-00113696-00113823": "government will of course consider", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00554-00113824-00113990": "carefully the views of parliament as it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00555-00113991-00114247": "completes stage one scrutiny of the bill", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00556-00114248-00114439": "however i must stress that removing key", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00557-00114440-00114599": "provisions from the bill in the way that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00558-00114600-00114799": "mrs bailey suggests would mean that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00559-00114800-00114943": "scotland would not have the public", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00560-00114944-00115102": "health protection measures in place", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00561-00115103-00115278": "which are needed to counter future", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00562-00115279-00115519": "public health threats i do i do not", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00563-00115520-00115766": "believe that is in the public interest", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00564-00115767-00115999": "jackie billy the deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00565-00116000-00116183": "has chosen to use the made affirmative", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00566-00116183-00116383": "procedure which means that measures can", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00567-00116383-00116575": "be routinely introduced without", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00568-00116576-00116823": "parliamentary scrutiny or approval in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00569-00116824-00117007": "advance that doesn't allow for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00570-00117008-00117190": "consultation it doesn't allow for the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00571-00117191-00117399": "voice of our constituents to be heard in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00572-00117400-00117575": "this chamber the parliament has", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00573-00117576-00117790": "demonstrated that it can operate quickly", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00574-00117791-00118023": "let me remind mr swinney of primary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00575-00118024-00118247": "legislation that we passed in a week", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00576-00118248-00118431": "indeed it was the very first bill", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00577-00118432-00118639": "considered by the parliament and covered", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00578-00118640-00118878": "bills were subsequently done in a matter", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00579-00118879-00119110": "of days so rather than risk the other", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00580-00119111-00119351": "positive measures in the bill will john", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00581-00119352-00119566": "swinney change the provisions on the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00582-00119567-00119790": "extension of emergency powers so they", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00583-00119791-00120015": "are at least subject to scrutiny in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00584-00120016-00120302": "advance deputy first minister i i i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00585-00120303-00120443": "don't think jackie bailey's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00586-00120444-00120751": "characterization of the issue and is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00587-00120752-00120886": "appropriate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00588-00120888-00121086": "in these circumstances", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00589-00121088-00121447": "the media formative procedure is only", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00590-00121448-00121607": "ever used", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00591-00121608-00121895": "where time circumstances do not allow us", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00592-00121896-00122110": "to undertake the normal consultation and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00593-00122111-00122319": "dialogue around the affirmative", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00594-00122320-00122543": "procedure and i've gone on the record", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00595-00122544-00122823": "with the delegated powers and law reform", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00596-00122824-00122999": "committee to make it clear that the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00597-00123000-00123231": "government does not routinely intend to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00598-00123232-00123495": "utilize the maid affirmative procedure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00599-00123496-00123743": "we would what we would prefer to use the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00600-00123744-00123966": "affirmative process to enable the type", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00601-00123967-00124183": "of dialogue that jackie bailey talks", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00602-00124183-00124278": "about", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00603-00124279-00124399": "so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00604-00124400-00124575": "what the government is trying to do and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00605-00124576-00124766": "i'm very keen to engage with parliament", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00606-00124767-00124910": "on this question", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00607-00124911-00125199": "is make sure that we have a statute book", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00608-00125200-00125399": "that enables us having learnt the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00609-00125400-00125663": "lessons of covert to be able to respond", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00610-00125664-00125871": "swiftly and promptly to challenges that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00611-00125872-00126031": "may come towards us and jackie bailey", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00612-00126032-00126214": "knows the issues have covered well she", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00613-00126215-00126407": "knows how quickly events have changed in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00614-00126408-00126519": "front of us", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00615-00126520-00126678": "so the legislative framework that we're", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00616-00126679-00126871": "putting in place is designed to create", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00617-00126872-00126966": "that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00618-00126967-00127286": "that that that capacity to act swiftly", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00619-00127288-00127519": "and i am very keen to make sure that i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00620-00127520-00127671": "work with parliamentary colleagues to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00621-00127672-00127934": "try to address the legitimate concerns", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00622-00127935-00128071": "on this question", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00623-00128072-00128278": "but fundamentally we must have a statute", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00624-00128279-00128471": "book that is fit to deal with the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00625-00128472-00128614": "challenge of the pandemic and that's my", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00626-00128615-00128814": "objective in this legislation", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00627-00128815-00128975": "i have received a number of requests for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00628-00128976-00129214": "supplementaries i intend to take each of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00629-00129215-00129599": "them uh and firstly from sunday kohani", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00630-00129600-00129766": "thank you deputy officer cabinet", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00631-00129767-00129951": "secretary to ensure parliament able to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00632-00129952-00130207": "scrutinize in advance of emergency", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00633-00130208-00130471": "powers being acted could we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00634-00130472-00130807": "agree a raft of emergency powers leave", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00635-00130808-00130983": "them dormant", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00636-00130983-00131190": "and then if the need arises we can get a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00637-00131191-00131447": "statement either virtual or in person", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00638-00131448-00131614": "and within the time it would take to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00639-00131615-00131799": "play a football match we'd be able to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00640-00131800-00131983": "grant the government the powers", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00641-00131984-00132166": "deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00642-00132167-00132359": "well that's a rather interesting", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00643-00132360-00132583": "development of the conservative position", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00644-00132584-00132775": "which i am going to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00645-00132776-00133031": "say i'm very happy to explore with the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00646-00133032-00133254": "conservatives since we're now talking", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00647-00133255-00133502": "turkey about this issue i think this is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00648-00133503-00133743": "very welcome and maybe jackie bailey", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00649-00133744-00133935": "will be catching up with the new", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00650-00133936-00134166": "reformers thinking of the conservatives", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00651-00134167-00134423": "once again have moved ahead and dumped", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00652-00134424-00134639": "jackie bailey from the better together", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00653-00134640-00134983": "alliance but i i i welcome dr gahani's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00654-00134984-00135102": "suggestion", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00655-00135103-00135263": "what we're trying to do", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00656-00135264-00135383": "and i come back to what i said", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00657-00135384-00135607": "manchester jackie barry is to make sure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00658-00135608-00135814": "there is a parliamentary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00659-00135815-00136071": "a framework of legislation in place that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00660-00136072-00136319": "enables parliament to act quickly where", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00661-00136320-00136751": "we require to do so dr gahani offers a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00662-00136752-00136951": "an interesting perspective on that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00663-00136952-00137102": "obviously something that can be advanced", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00664-00137103-00137359": "within the legislative process and if he", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00665-00137360-00137511": "would care to write to me and i'd be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00666-00137512-00137654": "very happy to have a meeting with him", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00667-00137655-00137863": "and his colleagues to explore what might", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00668-00137864-00138023": "be involved in some of these questions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00669-00138024-00138287": "because as always i am very keen to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00670-00138288-00138583": "build consensus within this parliament", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00671-00138584-00138823": "supplementary really ready well that's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00672-00138824-00138983": "that's a very interesting development of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00673-00138984-00139151": "the government's position because when i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00674-00139152-00139359": "asked the very same question to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00675-00139360-00139575": "education secretary in the education", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00676-00139576-00139878": "committee she rejected it out of hand so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00677-00139879-00140102": "i would suggest that coordination on the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00678-00140103-00140223": "government side the children's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00679-00140224-00140495": "commissioner gave some very important", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00680-00140496-00140711": "evidence to the education committee", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00681-00140712-00141063": "about this bill the commissioner said", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00682-00141064-00141302": "that re considerable concerns", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00683-00141303-00141495": "that permanent powers", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00684-00141496-00141902": "may not be lawful under article 15", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00685-00141903-00142087": "of the echr", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00686-00142088-00142335": "so why is the deputy first minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00687-00142336-00142583": "ignoring the concerns of the children's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00688-00142584-00142814": "commissioner", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00689-00142815-00143023": "i'm not ignoring them i'm addressing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00690-00143024-00143351": "them because what ministers have to do", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00691-00143352-00143623": "and i understand the perspective of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00692-00143624-00143854": "commentators and commissioners but", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00693-00143855-00144102": "ministers have duties to protect public", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00694-00144103-00144207": "health", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00695-00144208-00144447": "and people like mr rennie come here and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00696-00144448-00144687": "complain if ministers don't act quick", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00697-00144688-00144902": "enough to protect public health and he", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00698-00144903-00145087": "shakes his head i've sat here and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00699-00145088-00145207": "listened to him complaining about", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00700-00145208-00145399": "ministers not acting quickly enough to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00701-00145400-00145566": "do certain things", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00702-00145567-00145639": "so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00703-00145640-00145926": "i'm very happy to engage in discussion", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00704-00145927-00146126": "and dialogue about the provisions of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00705-00146127-00146431": "bill but there is one point which is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00706-00146432-00146790": "absolutely fundamental we must have a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00707-00146791-00147039": "legislative framework in place that will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00708-00147040-00147295": "allow us to act quickly should the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00709-00147296-00147614": "circumstances arise and that is the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00710-00147615-00147831": "purpose of this legislation and that's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00711-00147832-00147943": "what the government will engage", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00712-00147944-00148111": "constructively with parliament to try to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00713-00148112-00148383": "achieve and supplementary journalism", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00714-00148384-00148583": "hey thank you the opposition members are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00715-00148584-00148783": "often whining when scotland is a little", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00716-00148784-00148966": "bit different from england so can the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00717-00148967-00149151": "deputy first minister clarify would", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00718-00149152-00149311": "these provisions move us closer to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00719-00149312-00149543": "provisions in england or further away", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00720-00149544-00149759": "deputy first minister the the the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00721-00149760-00149943": "statute book in england and wales", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00722-00149944-00150151": "contains many of these provisions which", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00723-00150152-00150383": "have enabled the united kingdom", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00724-00150384-00150543": "government and the welsh assembly", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00725-00150544-00150831": "government to act within their legal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00726-00150832-00150959": "framework", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00727-00150960-00151135": "to to to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00728-00151136-00151495": "in a swift and immediate fashion so one", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00729-00151496-00151719": "of the points that is you mr mason", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00730-00151720-00151959": "characterized how the opposition parties", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00731-00151960-00152214": "sometimes contribute to the debate i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00732-00152215-00152454": "will not i will not uh", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00733-00152455-00152654": "comment on his assessment but what i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00734-00152655-00152863": "will say is that the opposition often", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00735-00152864-00153151": "come here and ask us to learn lessons", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00736-00153152-00153278": "and we've learned a lesson from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00737-00153279-00153535": "pandemic and that is that our statutory", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00738-00153536-00153902": "framework was not adequate to deal with", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00739-00153903-00154126": "these issues and that's what i'm trying", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00740-00154127-00154271": "to address in the legislation that's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00741-00154272-00154454": "before parliament and question number", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00742-00154455-00154678": "eight pauline mcneil", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00743-00154679-00154839": "to ask the scottish government how its", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00744-00154840-00155047": "policies across government will support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00745-00155048-00155271": "people living in glasgow to recover from", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00746-00155272-00155535": "the covet 19 pandemic deputy first", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00747-00155536-00155735": "minister president officer by working", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00748-00155736-00155878": "collaboratively with our partners in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00749-00155879-00156031": "local government business and the third", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00750-00156032-00156214": "sector we will deliver a strong recovery", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00751-00156215-00156471": "that meets the needs to each specific to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00752-00156472-00156590": "each area", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00753-00156591-00156775": "for example the glasgow city region deal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00754-00156776-00156943": "in powers glasgow and its city region", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00755-00156944-00157199": "partners to identify manage and deliver", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00756-00157200-00157383": "a programme of investments to stimulate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00757-00157384-00157614": "economic growth and create jobs in their", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00758-00157615-00157807": "areas supporting the region to achieve", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00759-00157808-00157999": "its shared long-term vision for the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00760-00158000-00158254": "local economy the government is actively", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00761-00158255-00158471": "involved in dialogue with the glasgow", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00762-00158472-00158654": "city region deal and we will continue", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00763-00158655-00158919": "that dialogue with our focus on recovery", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00764-00158920-00159271": "from the covert 19 pandemic polly mcnew", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00765-00159272-00159459": "a report published last week by", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00766-00159460-00159631": "pricewaterhousecooper said that glasgow", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00767-00159632-00159839": "had slower growth in aberdeen", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00768-00159840-00160063": "and edinburgh in 2021 and that will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00769-00160064-00160263": "continue this year", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00770-00160264-00160471": "uk average goes across 50 cities", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00771-00160472-00160695": "measured in the report with 7.4 percent", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00772-00160696-00160990": "but worryingly glasgow is only at 4.4", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00773-00160991-00161111": "percent", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00774-00161112-00161302": "yesterday the house of commons scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00775-00161303-00161431": "affairs committee and an excellent", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00776-00161432-00161583": "report published", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00777-00161584-00161799": "um their support and highlighted the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00778-00161800-00162031": "airports in scotland the bosses of egs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00779-00162032-00162311": "who own glasgow and aberdeen noted that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00780-00162312-00162511": "the pandemic had set their sights back", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00781-00162512-00162623": "decades", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00782-00162624-00162854": "not just for the loss of passengers but", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00783-00162855-00163143": "the loss of connectivity to the whole of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00784-00163144-00163399": "glasgow and city region so therefore", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00785-00163400-00163566": "what more evidence does the government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00786-00163567-00163831": "need that glasgow is in trouble and it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00787-00163832-00164102": "needs more assistance special attention", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00788-00164103-00164278": "so could the government elaborate a bit", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00789-00164279-00164454": "more and what intervention they would", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00790-00164455-00164702": "seek to help glasgow city region trip to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00791-00164703-00164823": "christmas", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00792-00164824-00165087": "i i acknowledge the importance of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00793-00165088-00165335": "ensuring that every part of the country", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00794-00165336-00165623": "is supported to recover and it's vital", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00795-00165624-00165766": "that that's the case in the city of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00796-00165767-00165887": "glasgow", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00797-00165888-00166175": "and and in the city region area", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00798-00166176-00166431": "so the government is engaged with the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00799-00166432-00166623": "city region partnership", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00800-00166624-00166823": "we obviously take a range of different", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00801-00166824-00167063": "interventions and measures to enhance", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00802-00167064-00167287": "the the transport infrastructure to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00803-00167288-00167407": "ensure that there is adequate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00804-00167408-00167631": "connectivity ministerial colleagues are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00805-00167632-00167831": "actively involved in discussions on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00806-00167832-00168083": "these questions with the relevant", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00807-00168084-00168278": "organizations we have a skills", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00808-00168279-00168526": "investment in the college and university", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00809-00168527-00168663": "sector in glasgow and the west of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00810-00168664-00168887": "scotland which is very significant to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00811-00168888-00169047": "make sure the skills that are required", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00812-00169048-00169295": "for the future are adequately delivered", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00813-00169296-00169551": "and also that we are supporting the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00814-00169552-00169702": "recovery of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00815-00169703-00169935": "some key sectors that are affected by", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00816-00169936-00170151": "the pandemic now if we look at the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00817-00170152-00170438": "overall position on economic recovery", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00818-00170439-00170711": "the economy is broadly back to where it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00819-00170712-00170966": "was pre-pandemic and the key challenge", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00820-00170967-00171135": "is to make sure that the many strengths", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00821-00171136-00171302": "of the city of glasgow and its", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00822-00171303-00171559": "surrounding areas are built upon to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00823-00171560-00171814": "ensure that all citizens can appreciate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00824-00171815-00171943": "and enjoy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00825-00171944-00172190": "the the the proceeds of economic growth", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00826-00172191-00172359": "and opportunity and that's at the heart", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00827-00172360-00172502": "of the dialogue between the government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00828-00172503-00172671": "and local authorities and brief", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00829-00172672-00172895": "supplementary please book it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00830-00172896-00173071": "thank you very much presiding officer", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00831-00173072-00173287": "kindly dfm touching how much glasgow", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00832-00173288-00173438": "stands to benefit from the regional", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00833-00173439-00173663": "economic partnership fund and how the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00834-00173664-00173847": "scottish government envisions that that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00835-00173848-00174063": "funding will support glasgow's economic", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00836-00174064-00174207": "recovery", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00837-00174208-00174326": "minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00838-00174327-00174566": "obviously the the funding that to which", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00839-00174567-00174823": "mr kid refers is important", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00840-00174824-00175111": "we have to consider the the ways in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00841-00175112-00175423": "which that can have an effect on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00842-00175424-00175614": "economic opportunities within the city", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00843-00175615-00175847": "of glasgow and applications are in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00844-00175848-00176038": "process of being assessed by officials", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00845-00176039-00176247": "and i can confirm that glasgow have", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00846-00176248-00176423": "submitted an application and decisions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00847-00176424-00176623": "will be made in due course um and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00848-00176624-00176935": "notified but the objective of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00849-00176936-00177263": "um the the the partnership is about uh", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00850-00177264-00177495": "supporting the internationalisation of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00851-00177496-00177743": "the regional economy and ensuring that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00852-00177744-00177959": "the long-term foundations of the city", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00853-00177960-00178183": "and regional economy are secure and that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00854-00178184-00178359": "will lie at the heart of decision making", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00855-00178360-00178566": "around the fund thank you", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00856-00178567-00178751": "and that concludes portfolio questions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00857-00178752-00178935": "on covered 19 recovery in parliamentary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00858-00178936-00179183": "business there'll be a very short pause", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00859-00179184-00179414": "before we move on to the next portfolio", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00860-00179415-00179575": "questions in the event that front bench", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00861-00179576-00180521": "teams wish to change position thank you", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00862-00180522-00181063": "[Applause]", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00863-00181064-00181278": "zero energy and transport if a member", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00864-00181279-00181478": "wishes to request a supplementary uh", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00865-00181479-00181687": "question they should press their request", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00866-00181688-00181823": "to speak button", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00867-00181824-00182007": "during the relevant question or enter", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00868-00182008-00182190": "the letter r are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00869-00182191-00182423": "in the chat function during the relevant", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00870-00182424-00182599": "question i call question number one", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00871-00182600-00182999": "annie wells who's joining us remotely", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00872-00183000-00183207": "thank you presiding officer i asked the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00873-00183208-00183326": "scottish government whether it will", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00874-00183327-00183487": "provide an update on when it is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00875-00183488-00183647": "scheduled to meet with uk government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00876-00183648-00183895": "ministers to discuss the implementation", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00877-00183896-00184078": "of the energy company obligation for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00878-00184079-00184254": "scheme in scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00879-00184255-00184438": "minister patrick harvey", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00880-00184439-00184614": "thank you presiding officer the energy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00881-00184615-00184878": "company obligation is a uk government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00882-00184879-00185175": "scheme although it's scheduled to begin", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00883-00185176-00185407": "in april this year the design of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00884-00185408-00185726": "eco-4 scheme has not been confirmed by", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00885-00185727-00185895": "the uk government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00886-00185896-00186166": "since june last year we've repeatedly", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00887-00186167-00186366": "attempted to engage with uk ministers on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00888-00186367-00186599": "the future of both the warm home", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00889-00186600-00186871": "discount and eco but our approaches have", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00890-00186872-00187111": "not been answered i would welcome a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00891-00187112-00187302": "meeting with uk government ministers to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00892-00187303-00187454": "discuss how eco", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00893-00187455-00187638": "can better tackle fuel poverty and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00894-00187639-00187863": "deliver a just transition in scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00895-00187864-00188071": "annie wells", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00896-00188072-00188231": "i've been in touch with energy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00897-00188232-00188431": "businesses across glasgow who are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00898-00188432-00188607": "extremely concerned about the lack of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00899-00188608-00188799": "communication from the snp green", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00900-00188800-00189063": "government regarding a transition period", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00901-00189064-00189390": "between the eco3 and eco4 schemes", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00902-00189391-00189559": "they've revealed to me that if there's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00903-00189560-00189750": "no such confirmation of a transition", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00904-00189751-00189847": "period", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00905-00189848-00190102": "with eoc due to expiring just eight days", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00906-00190103-00190383": "time they fear many jobs across glasgow", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00907-00190384-00190647": "could be relocated to england and wales", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00908-00190648-00190902": "so can the minister urgently clarify", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00909-00190903-00191223": "that an eoco 3 interim paid will apply", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00910-00191224-00191575": "in scotland to help save these jobs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00911-00191576-00191711": "minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00912-00191712-00191823": "well i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00913-00191824-00191975": "i have to say that i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00914-00191976-00192159": "very much appreciate the frustration", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00915-00192160-00192335": "that many people have with the lack of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00916-00192336-00192631": "clarity and that clarity is needed but", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00917-00192632-00192799": "it is the uk government which has", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00918-00192800-00193095": "refused still to confirm what the design", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00919-00193096-00193326": "of the eco4 scheme will be even though", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00920-00193327-00193550": "it is due to commentary force uh in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00921-00193551-00193775": "april uh we don't anticipate seeing that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00922-00193776-00194038": "the regulations laid to define it uh", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00923-00194039-00194343": "until april and some of the changes", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00924-00194344-00194566": "signaled in the uk government's response", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00925-00194567-00194783": "to the public consultation appear to be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00926-00194784-00195023": "based on the english definition of fuel", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00927-00195024-00195311": "poverty which may limit the number of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00928-00195312-00195550": "eligible scottish properties just for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00929-00195551-00195775": "clarity presiding officer we've known", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00930-00195776-00195943": "for a long time that this change was", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00931-00195944-00196254": "coming in february 2021 the scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00932-00196255-00196414": "government proposed combining the warm", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00933-00196415-00196623": "home discount and eco", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00934-00196624-00196854": "as a single more flexible fuel poverty", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00935-00196855-00197111": "scheme in scotland scottish ministers", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00936-00197112-00197375": "wrote to their uk counterparts in june", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00937-00197376-00197663": "and in october and in december asking", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00938-00197664-00197775": "whether this approach would be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00939-00197776-00197950": "acceptable to the uk government and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00940-00197951-00198190": "we're still not had an answer from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00941-00198191-00198502": "uk government one way or the other", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00942-00198503-00198831": "question number two mercedes-benber", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00943-00198832-00198990": "thank you to ask the scottish government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00944-00198991-00199183": "what steps it's taking in relation to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00945-00199184-00199414": "green scales to remove barriers facing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00946-00199415-00199566": "offshore oil and gas workers in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00947-00199567-00199743": "transitioning to green jobs in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00948-00199744-00199983": "offshore energy sector minister lawrence", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00949-00199984-00200078": "later", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00950-00200079-00200271": "thank you deputy presiding officer i am", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00951-00200272-00200463": "pleased that opito with scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00952-00200464-00200647": "government support through the energy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00953-00200648-00200823": "skills alliance is making excellent", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00954-00200824-00201014": "progress towards the enabling of a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00955-00201015-00201295": "skills passport in the coming months isa", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00956-00201296-00201447": "will publish their skills transition", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00957-00201448-00201671": "plan which will set out work to date and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00958-00201672-00201911": "next steps there has been great progress", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00959-00201912-00202111": "in what is a complicated and important", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00960-00202112-00202278": "piece of work that will support the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00961-00202279-00202447": "offshore workforce in their transition", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00962-00202448-00202535": "journey", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00963-00202536-00202711": "mercedes-benber", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00964-00202712-00202878": "thank you i thank the minister for her", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00965-00202879-00203078": "response and i look forward to meeting", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00966-00203079-00203278": "with her um tomorrow alongside trade", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00967-00203279-00203454": "unions and climate campaigners to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00968-00203455-00203599": "discuss the need for an offshore", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00969-00203600-00203790": "training passport but one of the other", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00970-00203791-00203966": "barriers facing offshore oil and gas", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00971-00203967-00204199": "workers in transitioning to green jobs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00972-00204200-00204414": "is the poor employment practices in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00973-00204415-00204663": "offshore wind supply chain the scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00974-00204664-00204806": "government often talks of its commitment", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00975-00204807-00205142": "to fair work so will it support collect", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00976-00205144-00205334": "sectoral collective bargaining in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00977-00205335-00205638": "offshore wind industry minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00978-00205639-00205766": "thank the member very much for that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00979-00205767-00205903": "question and i do look forward to seeing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00980-00205904-00206086": "her tomorrow to discuss progress on the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00981-00206087-00206334": "offshore skills passport um the scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00982-00206335-00206503": "government absolutely supports workers", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00983-00206504-00206623": "and um", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00984-00206623-00206758": "you'll see in the national strategy for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00985-00206759-00206966": "economic uh transformation that we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00986-00206967-00207094": "support collective bargaining and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00987-00207096-00207310": "workers having more of a say in in how", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00988-00207311-00207534": "their jobs are executed", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00989-00207535-00207742": "on supplementary limb care thank you", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00990-00207744-00207919": "presiding officer in a written answer to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00991-00207919-00208134": "me minister richard lockheed admitted", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00992-00208135-00208262": "that this government having only", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00993-00208263-00208462": "delivered approximately one in 20 of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00994-00208463-00208686": "offshore wind jobs that it forecast", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00995-00208687-00208958": "proposes to widen the definition of a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00996-00208959-00209182": "green job he proposes to use a different", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00997-00209183-00209390": "definition from the one the ons and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00998-00209391-00209575": "therefore the rest of the uk", "ikKP0MLjwvc-00999-00209576-00209686": "is using", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01000-00209687-00209919": "does the minister accept that widening", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01001-00209919-00210110": "the definition would give a distorted", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01002-00210111-00210319": "picture on how this government is really", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01003-00210319-00210558": "performing on the creation of green jobs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01004-00210559-00210694": "and will make it impossible to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01005-00210696-00210894": "meaningfully compare with the rest of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01006-00210896-00211006": "the uk", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01007-00211007-00211103": "minister", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01008-00211104-00211271": "i thank the member very much for that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01009-00211271-00211439": "question the discussion of what is a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01010-00211440-00211710": "green job is an absolute live one it is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01011-00211711-00211903": "fair to say that in the future all jobs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01012-00211904-00212071": "will be green jobs tackling the climate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01013-00212071-00212255": "crisis isn't something that we can put", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01014-00212256-00212423": "in a box", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01015-00212423-00212623": "isn't that everybody needs to play their", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01016-00212623-00212846": "part all sectors need to pay their part", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01017-00212848-00213031": "of course we it's useful to have a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01018-00213032-00213239": "definition into when we're looking at", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01019-00213240-00213415": "planning training and when we're looking", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01020-00213416-00213655": "at planning investment uh but i think", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01021-00213656-00213839": "it's correct", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01022-00213840-00213998": "minister minister minister please resume", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01023-00214000-00214231": "yourself again i have to please call for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01024-00214232-00214391": "some courtesy from the conservative", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01025-00214392-00214742": "benches thank you minister please resume", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01026-00214744-00214894": "i think it's absolutely appropriate the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01027-00214896-00215134": "scottish scotland develops a definition", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01028-00215135-00215279": "of green jobs that is appropriate for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01029-00215280-00215558": "our workforce and our industry here", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01030-00215559-00215767": "question number three not lost question", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01031-00215767-00215998": "number four withdrawn question number", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01032-00216000-00216271": "five michelle thompson", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01033-00216271-00216398": "government to ask the scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01034-00216400-00216582": "government what ministerial discussions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01035-00216583-00216782": "have taken place regarding whether its", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01036-00216783-00217031": "net zero ambitions could be supported", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01037-00217032-00217246": "through the introduction of new fiscal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01038-00217248-00217431": "measures government secretary michael", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01039-00217432-00217598": "matheson", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01040-00217600-00217742": "ministers regularly consider new", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01041-00217744-00218039": "policies proposals and fiscal regulatory", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01042-00218040-00218246": "measures to accelerate our transition to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01043-00218248-00218494": "net zero well scottish ministers", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01044-00218496-00218734": "endeavour to take all actions required", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01045-00218735-00218998": "to reach net zero many levels do sit", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01046-00219000-00219263": "within reserved conferences for example", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01047-00219264-00219471": "areas such as transmission charging sit", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01048-00219471-00219734": "with the uk government and presently act", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01049-00219735-00219958": "as a disincentive to renewable energy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01050-00219959-00220246": "investment in scotland therefore it's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01051-00220248-00220455": "essential that the uk government works", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01052-00220456-00220615": "within what's with the scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01053-00220616-00220767": "government to ensure that fiscal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01054-00220767-00220982": "measures support their net zero", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01055-00220983-00221255": "ambitions michelle thompson i thank the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01056-00221256-00221487": "cabinet secretary for his response the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01057-00221488-00221694": "ambitious net zero targets set by the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01058-00221696-00221823": "scottish government will not only", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01059-00221823-00222063": "require to be funded but the frameworks", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01060-00222064-00222191": "develop too", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01061-00222192-00222406": "this cannot be done in isolation without", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01062-00222407-00222646": "consideration by those with the full", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01063-00222648-00222887": "fiscal levers of what measures could be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01064-00222888-00223006": "utilized", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01065-00223007-00223175": "but given the scale of the challenge and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01066-00223176-00223382": "the fact that the majority of green tax", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01067-00223383-00223606": "powers are reserved to the uk government", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01068-00223607-00223806": "does the cabinet secretary share my", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01069-00223807-00224006": "concern that the recent westminster", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01070-00224007-00224191": "public accounts committee report that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01071-00224192-00224567": "noted the uk government has no clear", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01072-00224567-00224831": "plan for how the transition to net zero", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01073-00224832-00224998": "will be funded", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01074-00225000-00225175": "governor secretary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01075-00225176-00225358": "i've seen officer given a number of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01076-00225359-00225519": "crucial levels", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01077-00225519-00225734": "including but not limited to green tax", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01078-00225735-00225887": "pills our reserve to the uk government i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01079-00225888-00226223": "do share the members concern and in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01080-00226223-00226351": "particular the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01081-00226352-00226494": "issues that were highlighted by the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01082-00226496-00226703": "public accounts committee about the uk", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01083-00226704-00226798": "government's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01084-00226800-00227006": "lack of any clear plan on how the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01085-00227007-00227182": "transition to net zero", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01086-00227183-00227294": "will be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01087-00227296-00227398": "funded", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01088-00227400-00227591": "prior to of course the publication of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01089-00227592-00227758": "the uk government's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01090-00227759-00228071": "zero strategy we made consistent calls", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01091-00228071-00228255": "for action to be taken in a number of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01092-00228256-00228519": "crucial areas which are within within", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01093-00228519-00228734": "reserved competences and while the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01094-00228735-00229071": "strategy contained a number of positive", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01095-00229071-00229342": "uh steps to be taken to help support uh", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01096-00229344-00229446": "achieving", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01097-00229448-00229806": "zero it was a concern that there was no", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01098-00229807-00230055": "clear indication as to how these actions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01099-00230056-00230342": "would be taken forward at a fiscal", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01100-00230344-00230487": "level that's why it's absolutely", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01101-00230488-00230742": "essential that the uk government do work", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01102-00230744-00230958": "with the scottish government in ensuring", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01103-00230959-00231191": "that the fiscal measures that are within", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01104-00231192-00231279": "the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01105-00231280-00231534": "hold of the uk government that they also", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01106-00231535-00231782": "meet scotland's ambitious climate change", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01107-00231783-00231982": "targets and that's why for examples of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01108-00231983-00232263": "highlighted issues such as transmission", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01109-00232264-00232575": "charging presently act as a disincentive", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01110-00232576-00232767": "and it's therefore essential that the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01111-00232767-00232967": "fiscal measures are consistent with", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01112-00232967-00233351": "achieving net zero by 2045.", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01113-00233352-00233663": "question number six collect stephenson", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01114-00233664-00233839": "to ask the scottish government when it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01115-00233840-00234079": "last met representatives from the energy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01116-00234080-00234415": "regulator of gem and what was discussed", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01117-00234416-00234655": "my cabinet secretary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01118-00234656-00234871": "i last met with off james gas and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01119-00234871-00235151": "electricity market authority board on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01120-00235152-00235471": "the 9th of february 2022 this was a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01121-00235471-00235671": "general catch up with the board but the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01122-00235671-00235855": "main topics discussed including the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01123-00235856-00236119": "price cap announcement the outcome of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01124-00236119-00236327": "crown estate scotland's scotland leasing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01125-00236328-00236663": "round and transmission charges scottish", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01126-00236664-00236823": "government officials continue to meet", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01127-00236823-00237031": "and engage with off gym on a regular", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01128-00237032-00237198": "basis", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01129-00237200-00237382": "colette stevenson i thank the cabinet", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01130-00237383-00237606": "secretary for the answer with rising", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01131-00237607-00237767": "energy costs and the increase in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01132-00237767-00238031": "price cap the tory cost of living crisis", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01133-00238032-00238246": "about to escalate can the cabinet", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01134-00238248-00238446": "secretly set out the average cost per", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01135-00238448-00238719": "household of uk government and post va", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01136-00238719-00239039": "imposed vat and energy policy costs and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01137-00239040-00239271": "does he agree with me that the tories", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01138-00239271-00239494": "must cut that from household energy", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01139-00239496-00239775": "bills and immediately implement a fairer", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01140-00239776-00240015": "warm home discount scheme to support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01141-00240016-00240134": "people", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01142-00240135-00240327": "cabinet secretary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01143-00240328-00240671": "uh saying officer off gem have estimated", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01144-00240671-00240934": "that the vat component of the average", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01145-00240935-00241039": "household", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01146-00241040-00241255": "future fuel energy bill", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01147-00241256-00241591": "will be around 60 pounds per year and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01148-00241592-00241742": "policy costs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01149-00241744-00242182": "added are over 150 pounds more", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01150-00242183-00242367": "this is an issue which i've taken up", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01151-00242367-00242615": "with the uk government previously", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01152-00242616-00242871": "on a number of occasions to ask them to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01153-00242871-00243151": "look at a temporary cut to that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01154-00243152-00243327": "alongside that we've also asked them to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01155-00243328-00243542": "take action on warm homes discount", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01156-00243544-00243655": "scheme", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01157-00243656-00243839": "and also to review", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01158-00243840-00244079": "the socio-environmental costs which are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01159-00244080-00244327": "included on energy bills", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01160-00244328-00244567": "actions which we believe collectively", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01161-00244567-00244742": "could help to support", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01162-00244744-00245046": "families facing spiralling energy costs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01163-00245048-00245303": "which are added to the wider cost of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01164-00245304-00245471": "living crisis which the conservative", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01165-00245471-00245734": "government are responsible for which is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01166-00245735-00245982": "why it's essential that we see proper", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01167-00245983-00246175": "concerted action by the uk government to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01168-00246176-00246391": "address this crisis", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01169-00246392-00246575": "sadly that was lacking in the spring", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01170-00246576-00246775": "statement however the reality is that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01171-00246776-00246982": "households will still face these very", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01172-00246983-00247198": "considerable energy costs alongside", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01173-00247200-00247375": "rising cost of living", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01174-00247376-00247567": "a cost which the uk government are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01175-00247567-00247823": "responsible for taking action on", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01176-00247823-00247967": "and i have a number of supplementaries", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01177-00247967-00248167": "and i intend to take each of them the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01178-00248167-00248334": "first from eleanor whittam who is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01179-00248335-00248567": "joining us remotely", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01180-00248567-00248782": "thank you deputy presiding officer for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01181-00248783-00248991": "many rural households in my constituency", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01182-00248992-00249182": "who are off-grid and use oil as their", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01183-00249183-00249391": "primary source of heating there are no", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01184-00249392-00249598": "price cap protections many people seeing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01185-00249600-00249782": "price increases from around 50 pounds", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01186-00249783-00250023": "per liter to a pound 40 with minimum", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01187-00250023-00250198": "delivery quarters and payment required", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01188-00250200-00250446": "on delivery does the cabinet secretary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01189-00250448-00250639": "agree the uk government must intervene", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01190-00250640-00250879": "to tackle the unregulated heating oil", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01191-00250880-00251110": "industry to prevent uncertainty and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01192-00251111-00251287": "extreme fuel poverty for rural", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01193-00251288-00251463": "households", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01194-00251464-00251687": "cabinet secretary absolutely this is an", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01195-00251688-00251942": "area which is unregulated within the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01196-00251944-00252119": "energy market it's an issue which we", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01197-00252119-00252375": "have raised on a consistent basis with", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01198-00252376-00252606": "the uk government it particular impacts", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01199-00252607-00252871": "on those who live in rural areas in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01200-00252871-00252982": "scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01201-00252983-00253094": "and i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01202-00253096-00253310": "recognize the points which", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01203-00253311-00253455": "the members making on behalf of our", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01204-00253456-00253646": "constituents who saw very significant", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01205-00253648-00253839": "increases in the cost of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01206-00253840-00254087": "oil for oil heating systems and that's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01207-00254088-00254294": "why we believe there is a need for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01208-00254296-00254494": "proper regulation in this sector to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01209-00254496-00254687": "protect households but also to make sure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01210-00254688-00254910": "that addresses the ever-increasing costs", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01211-00254911-00255182": "uh those who rely on oil heating", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01212-00255183-00255358": "are now facing and again this is an area", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01213-00255359-00255534": "of policy which we want to see the uk", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01214-00255535-00255734": "government taking action on and to do so", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01215-00255735-00255942": "ultimately a supplementary voice of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01216-00255944-00256103": "children", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01217-00256104-00256327": "thank you for the presenting officer a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01218-00256328-00256646": "constituent has recently argued that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01219-00256648-00256887": "they believe the estimated energy bill", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01220-00256888-00257094": "they were given during the latest wave", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01221-00257096-00257358": "of the pandemic were excessive has the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01222-00257359-00257575": "scottish government had any discussion", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01223-00257576-00257846": "with ofgem on the use of estimated bills", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01224-00257848-00258071": "where meter reading were not able to be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01225-00258071-00258230": "taken", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01226-00258231-00258342": "secretary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01227-00258344-00258558": "uh saying officer this is an area which", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01228-00258559-00258846": "is regulated by uh off jam if the member", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01229-00258848-00258998": "has a particular concern about a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01230-00259000-00259239": "constituent's circumstances he can", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01231-00259240-00259463": "pursue that directly with off gym", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01232-00259464-00259687": "in order to ask them to consider the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01233-00259688-00259855": "complaint they may have", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01234-00259856-00260071": "estimated bills will have a role to play", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01235-00260071-00260287": "for some households but there is a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01236-00260288-00260487": "process which can be used for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01237-00260488-00260655": "individuals to ask for that to be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01238-00260656-00260775": "revised", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01239-00260776-00260958": "on the basis of submitting", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01240-00260959-00261206": "a reading on these matters but if the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01241-00261207-00261342": "member is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01242-00261344-00261510": "his constituent is continuing to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01243-00261511-00261703": "experience problems there is advice that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01244-00261704-00261927": "can be provided on pursuing these issues", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01245-00261928-00262167": "with their energy supplier to ensure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01246-00262168-00262447": "that their energy bill is reflected or", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01247-00262448-00262734": "is reflective of the use of energy given", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01248-00262735-00262847": "that their previous bills have been", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01249-00262848-00263015": "based upon estimates", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01250-00263016-00263230": "and supplementary morris golden", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01251-00263231-00263463": "uh thank you deputy presiding officer my", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01252-00263464-00263655": "question relates to the targeted", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01253-00263656-00263863": "charging review of transmission demand", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01254-00263864-00264175": "residual off gem analysis of domestic", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01255-00264176-00264430": "consumers highlights that the no floor", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01256-00264431-00264615": "approach could result in consumers in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01257-00264616-00264887": "north scotland receiving credits driven", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01258-00264888-00265143": "by consumption during the evening peak a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01259-00265144-00265351": "floor approach shows that this would", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01260-00265352-00265551": "result in overall decrease into the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01261-00265552-00265839": "newest charges for typical domestic", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01262-00265840-00266158": "consumers apart from those in scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01263-00266159-00266367": "for north scotland in particular they", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01264-00266368-00266567": "note that charges will increase compared", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01265-00266568-00266758": "with the current charges given the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01266-00266759-00266958": "assistance for area with high", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01267-00266959-00267223": "electricity distribution cost policy the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01268-00267224-00267471": "northeast pays more again does the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01269-00267472-00267687": "cabinet secretary agree with the floor", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01270-00267688-00267903": "with flooring the forward-looking charge", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01271-00267904-00268087": "at zero", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01272-00268088-00268303": "secretary what i do agree with the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01273-00268304-00268551": "upside officer is the existing system is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01274-00268552-00268758": "not fit for purpose which is why the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01275-00268759-00268991": "whole system needs to be changed we have", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01276-00268992-00269239": "a system which is geared to snow where", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01277-00269240-00269471": "predominantly uh the tunas", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01278-00269472-00269799": "the tunis charging regime is based upon", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01279-00269800-00270071": "uh providing energy as close to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01280-00270072-00270343": "consumer as possible whereas the reality", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01281-00270344-00270575": "is the reality is that moving to a net", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01282-00270576-00270799": "zero age is that the vast majority of it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01283-00270800-00271015": "will be much more distant from centers", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01284-00271016-00271230": "of population and that's why it's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01285-00271231-00271439": "important that any regime that we have", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01286-00271440-00271687": "in place is one which is reflective of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01287-00271688-00271879": "the need to move to net zero and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01288-00271880-00272143": "alongside that any price cap mechanisms", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01289-00272144-00272327": "which are been introduced off the back", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01290-00272328-00272551": "of that as well and alongside at these", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01291-00272552-00272775": "measures need to be reflective of the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01292-00272776-00272910": "household", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01293-00272911-00273182": "situation including within rural areas", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01294-00273183-00273439": "and as yet off gm have failed to take", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01295-00273440-00273639": "forward an approach that is reflective", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01296-00273640-00273903": "of the needs here in scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01297-00273904-00274134": "question number seven has been withdrawn", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01298-00274135-00274575": "question number eight brian hutto", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01299-00274576-00274734": "thank you deputy presenting officer to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01300-00274735-00274863": "ask the scottish government what its", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01301-00274864-00275015": "responses to the climate change", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01302-00275016-00275255": "committee's latest report is scotland", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01303-00275256-00275447": "climate ready which states that progress", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01304-00275448-00275630": "in delivering climate change adaptation", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01305-00275631-00276103": "measures in scotland has stalled", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01306-00276104-00276287": "preparing for the impacts of climate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01307-00276288-00276510": "change which are locked in forms a key", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01308-00276511-00276799": "part of our just transition and we are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01309-00276800-00277015": "making real progress on this this", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01310-00277016-00277327": "includes an extra 150 million pounds for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01311-00277328-00277543": "flood risk management and 12 million", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01312-00277544-00277791": "pounds for coastal change adaptation", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01313-00277792-00277991": "over this parliament we're pleased that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01314-00277992-00278191": "the committing climate change supports", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01315-00278192-00278382": "our vision for a climate resilient", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01316-00278383-00278655": "scotland however we accept that more", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01317-00278656-00278934": "needs to be done this is a global", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01318-00278935-00279191": "challenge and we are not alone in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01319-00279192-00279455": "needing to exhilarate progress we are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01320-00279456-00279575": "now considering the committee's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01321-00279576-00279782": "recommendations and will respond to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01322-00279783-00280082": "recommendations in due course", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01323-00280083-00280223": "brian hutter", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01324-00280224-00280406": "i thank the comment secretary", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01325-00280407-00280599": "for that answer but perhaps i can help", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01326-00280600-00280775": "the cabinet secretary give the real", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01327-00280776-00280934": "answer to michelle thompson's questions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01328-00280935-00281127": "around the concerns reaching scotland's", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01329-00281128-00281327": "net zero targets climate change", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01330-00281328-00281479": "committee's report is scathing in his", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01331-00281480-00281679": "criticism of the scottish government it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01332-00281680-00281879": "says actions is not being implemented", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01333-00281880-00282071": "with sufficient scale and urgency there", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01334-00282072-00282215": "is no credible planning to adapt", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01335-00282216-00282430": "farmland habitats and species and has a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01336-00282431-00282591": "gap in planning for maintenance a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01337-00282592-00282791": "weather resilient energy system", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01338-00282792-00282967": "insufficient inclusion of adaptation and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01339-00282968-00283127": "plans for many key infrastructure", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01340-00283128-00283239": "sectors", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01341-00283240-00283423": "and repeated criticisms of a critical", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01342-00283424-00283647": "lack of relevant data to access progress", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01343-00283648-00283895": "making it difficult to properly assess", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01344-00283896-00284151": "progress or evolving risks when the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01345-00284152-00284303": "scottish government realized that the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01346-00284304-00284503": "success of its plans doesn't come from", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01347-00284504-00284719": "good headlines but from actually doing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01348-00284720-00284903": "the hard work", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01349-00284904-00285143": "cabinet secretary sole presiding officer", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01350-00285144-00285247": "if", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01351-00285248-00285471": "the the member's interpretation of this", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01352-00285472-00285671": "report is that it is scathing on the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01353-00285672-00285910": "scottish government given the comments", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01354-00285911-00286063": "they've made about the uk government and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01355-00286064-00286191": "the fact that the scottish government is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01356-00286192-00286463": "ahead of them in climate adaptation i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01357-00286464-00286630": "wonder what it means for the uk", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01358-00286631-00286815": "government and their failure in this", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01359-00286816-00287119": "area of policy but i'm sure that member", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01360-00287120-00287303": "as you would often expect from the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01361-00287304-00287447": "opposition will be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01362-00287448-00287734": "selective on aspects of the report that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01363-00287735-00287934": "they choose to select", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01364-00287935-00288191": "so for example we can pick up on issues", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01365-00288192-00288399": "which it highlights in terms of it and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01366-00288400-00288558": "transport the progress that we are", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01367-00288559-00288639": "making", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01368-00288640-00288895": "on rail and climate change and the way", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01369-00288896-00289054": "in which we are taking forward policies", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01370-00289055-00289271": "to provide greater resilience there the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01371-00289272-00289463": "progress that's been made in planning", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01372-00289464-00289727": "for adaptation and commercial forestry", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01373-00289728-00289991": "again highlighted within the report and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01374-00289992-00290143": "in a number of other areas where it", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01375-00290144-00290334": "highlights that scotland is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01376-00290335-00290695": "demonstrating strong clear leadership in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01377-00290696-00291030": "these areas but clearly we need to do", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01378-00291031-00291247": "more and that's certainly what we intend", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01379-00291248-00291391": "to do and we'll respond to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01380-00291392-00291606": "recommendations within this report that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01381-00291607-00291847": "rightly raises a challenge that claim", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01382-00291848-00292047": "adaptation has to be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01383-00292048-00292254": "measured against the same actions that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01384-00292255-00292527": "we take when tackling climate change", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01385-00292528-00292767": "overall and the need to make sure that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01386-00292768-00293015": "they're treated in an equal fashion", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01387-00293016-00293199": "that's why the increasing funding we're", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01388-00293200-00293430": "putting into a range of areas is to help", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01389-00293431-00293630": "to support the embedding of our actions", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01390-00293631-00293871": "to tackle climate adaptation and we'll", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01391-00293872-00294023": "look to do more of that as we move", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01392-00294024-00294287": "forward and supplementing willie rennie", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01393-00294288-00294423": "i don't think most people would agree", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01394-00294424-00294551": "with the minister that the measure of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01395-00294552-00294767": "success has been marginally better than", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01396-00294768-00294999": "the conservatives but nevertheless a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01397-00295000-00295310": "vision is counts for not very much when", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01398-00295311-00295599": "the action is not delivered so in the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01399-00295600-00295799": "report it says very clearly the majority", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01400-00295800-00296127": "of scotland's shoreline is not covered", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01401-00296128-00296454": "by shoreline management plans i'm deeply", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01402-00296455-00296710": "concerned about many properties and land", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01403-00296711-00296967": "in my constituency so what is the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01404-00296968-00297271": "minister doing to make sure these plans", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01405-00297272-00297534": "get delivered and get delivered soon", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01406-00297535-00297727": "government secretary absolutely i do", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01407-00297728-00297982": "consider that measuring yourself against", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01408-00297983-00298167": "the conservative party and government of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01409-00298168-00298375": "westminster isn't a high bar to set", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01410-00298376-00298495": "yourself", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01411-00298496-00298695": "but what i can i sure remember is that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01412-00298696-00298910": "we are certainly doing more than that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01413-00298911-00299158": "low bar that they operate at on a", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01414-00299159-00299375": "consistent basis in relation to the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01415-00299376-00299663": "point the member makes he may be aware", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01416-00299664-00299871": "that we are already taking for the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01417-00299872-00300134": "second phase of the dynamic coast", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01418-00300135-00300334": "project which was launched just in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01419-00300335-00300591": "august of last year which i launched in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01420-00300592-00300815": "montrose a key part of which is the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01421-00300816-00300975": "modelling work that's been undertaken to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01422-00300976-00301151": "look at coastal erosion and the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01423-00301152-00301343": "potential risks that that could have in", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01424-00301344-00301591": "individual parts of the country no doubt", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01425-00301592-00301871": "in areas of his own constituency and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01426-00301872-00302030": "that particular piece of work is to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01427-00302031-00302230": "understand the areas of risk and the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01428-00302231-00302454": "potential mitigations that then need to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01429-00302455-00302703": "be put in place in order to manage that", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01430-00302704-00302871": "this is a piece of work that is ongoing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01431-00302872-00303047": "just now he'll appreciate the complexity", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01432-00303048-00303223": "and some of the challenges with it but", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01433-00303224-00303503": "the dynamic uh at course projects is", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01434-00303504-00303663": "specifically to try and address the type", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01435-00303664-00303823": "of concern that the member has raised", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01436-00303824-00303991": "and we're providing funding to try to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01437-00303992-00304199": "support local authorities in taking", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01438-00304200-00304382": "forward some of the mitigation measures", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01439-00304383-00304558": "that necessary in order to address the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01440-00304559-00304743": "issue of coastal erosion", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01441-00304744-00304975": "and brief supplementary jackie dunbar", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01442-00304976-00305134": "thank you president officer does the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01443-00305135-00305447": "cabinet secretary accept that well", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01444-00305448-00305671": "clearly there is much more to do the", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01445-00305672-00305815": "scottish government efforts and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01446-00305816-00306054": "ambitions on tackling the climate crisis", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01447-00306055-00306295": "has been widely recognised including", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01448-00306296-00306527": "from chris stark the ceo of the climate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01449-00306528-00306806": "change committee who told gms recently", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01450-00306807-00306958": "the scottish government has been", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01451-00306959-00307167": "noticeably better than other parts of", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01452-00307168-00307454": "the uk that put in a vision around what", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01453-00307455-00307695": "they want to do to make scotland more", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01454-00307696-00307943": "climate resilient we don't see that for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01455-00307944-00308230": "example from defra in the uk a couple", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01456-00308231-00308430": "seconds absolutely officer luke i", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01457-00308431-00308703": "recognise that um that we are making", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01458-00308704-00308910": "progress on this the report recognises", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01459-00308911-00309119": "that we are making progress on it but", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01460-00309120-00309375": "also calls for us to do more uh in order", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01461-00309376-00309582": "to show greater urgency in moving", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01462-00309583-00309799": "forward in tackling the issue of climate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01463-00309800-00310087": "adaptation yes we are doing more than", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01464-00310088-00310295": "other parts of the uk we are further", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01465-00310296-00310519": "ahead than other parts of the uk", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01466-00310520-00310679": "although i recognize that westminster", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01467-00310680-00310943": "the bar is a low measure having said", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01468-00310944-00311110": "that what we need to do is also", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01469-00311111-00311279": "recognize that there are further", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01470-00311280-00311439": "measures that we need to take forward", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01471-00311440-00311575": "and that's why as i mentioned for", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01472-00311576-00311823": "example 150 million pounds for flood", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01473-00311824-00311999": "risk management the 12 million pounds", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01474-00312000-00312239": "for coastal adaptation that i made", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01475-00312240-00312391": "reference to the investment by putting", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01476-00312392-00312534": "into areas such as people and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01477-00312535-00312734": "restoration all of these are measures", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01478-00312735-00312887": "which help to support our claim", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01479-00312888-00313039": "adaptation work", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01480-00313040-00313295": "alongside investment 60 million pounds", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01481-00313296-00313495": "and climate adaptation on our trunk road", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01482-00313496-00313710": "network but we need to look at what more", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01483-00313711-00313919": "we can do to adapt to the changing", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01484-00313920-00314103": "climate which we face and you can be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01485-00314104-00314230": "assured that this government will be", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01486-00314231-00314430": "determined to do that and to continue to", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01487-00314431-00314599": "show the leadership that's necessary not", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01488-00314600-00314791": "just here in scotland in the uk but", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01489-00314792-00314958": "internationally in tackling climate", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01490-00314959-00315151": "adaptation", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01491-00315152-00315334": "thank you that concludes portfolio", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01492-00315335-00315519": "questions on net zero energy and", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01493-00315520-00315695": "transport and there will be a very short", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01494-00315696-00315903": "pause before we move on to the next item", "ikKP0MLjwvc-01495-00315904-00316259": "of business thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "il4y7JjNabc", "text": {"il4y7JjNabc-00000-00000003-00000241": "hi I'm Philippe it's really a loser", "il4y7JjNabc-00001-00000242-00000388": "spend some time with you talking about", "il4y7JjNabc-00002-00000389-00000586": "these digital rights issues now I know", "il4y7JjNabc-00003-00000587-00000707": "you're already quite well-known in", "il4y7JjNabc-00004-00000708-00000890": "Europe for being an expert in this area", "il4y7JjNabc-00005-00000891-00001025": "but perhaps you could explain who you", "il4y7JjNabc-00006-00001026-00001136": "are and what you do here in the", "il4y7JjNabc-00007-00001137-00001361": "Parliament sure so I'm a member of the", "il4y7JjNabc-00008-00001362-00001582": "European Parliament since 2009 and since", "il4y7JjNabc-00009-00001583-00001834": "then I'm very much working on the issue", "il4y7JjNabc-00010-00001835-00002150": "of privacy and data protection we", "il4y7JjNabc-00011-00002151-00002375": "started for example by debating in how", "il4y7JjNabc-00012-00002376-00002683": "far it's proportionate to send over all", "il4y7JjNabc-00013-00002684-00002972": "our banking data to intelligence", "il4y7JjNabc-00014-00002973-00003233": "services or all our telecommunications", "il4y7JjNabc-00015-00003234-00003526": "data to intelligence services when they", "il4y7JjNabc-00016-00003527-00003988": "do analyzes and we brought in the idea", "il4y7JjNabc-00017-00003989-00004331": "of targeting surveillance which means", "il4y7JjNabc-00018-00004332-00004513": "that of course you should get their data", "il4y7JjNabc-00019-00004514-00004781": "but only if we have a real risk or", "il4y7JjNabc-00020-00004782-00005086": "suspicion whether we a person and then", "il4y7JjNabc-00021-00005087-00005363": "later on and that was my my latest big", "il4y7JjNabc-00022-00005364-00005651": "work here we proposed the general data", "il4y7JjNabc-00023-00005652-00005881": "protection regulation which now is", "il4y7JjNabc-00024-00005882-00006211": "becoming a law and safeguarding our", "il4y7JjNabc-00025-00006212-00006459": "fundamental rights as consumers also", "il4y7JjNabc-00026-00006461-00006845": "when we give our data to big IT internet", "il4y7JjNabc-00027-00006845-00007171": "companies and get a really heavy right", "il4y7JjNabc-00028-00007172-00007420": "there which we can better and force in", "il4y7JjNabc-00029-00007422-00007595": "Europe and that's a very good step so", "il4y7JjNabc-00030-00007595-00007756": "this is something that the Greens have", "il4y7JjNabc-00031-00007758-00008039": "achieved for people in Britain and it's", "il4y7JjNabc-00032-00008040-00008219": "basically to do with when you take that", "il4y7JjNabc-00033-00008220-00008339": "little box when you're buying something", "il4y7JjNabc-00034-00008340-00008549": "online and it says have you read the", "il4y7JjNabc-00035-00008550-00008681": "small print and you say yes but", "il4y7JjNabc-00036-00008682-00008795": "basically you haven't read the small", "il4y7JjNabc-00037-00008796-00009059": "print right exactly and there we get far", "il4y7JjNabc-00038-00009060-00009269": "more transparency it's clear that you", "il4y7JjNabc-00039-00009270-00009533": "can't like do lawyers text off pages and", "il4y7JjNabc-00040-00009534-00009721": "then expect to give an informed consent", "il4y7JjNabc-00041-00009722-00010052": "to it okay great so obviously there's a", "il4y7JjNabc-00042-00010053-00010262": "lot of concern across the world and in", "il4y7JjNabc-00043-00010263-00010442": "Britain about this latest hacking attack", "il4y7JjNabc-00044-00010443-00010603": "and the ransomware that's been unleashed", "il4y7JjNabc-00045-00010604-00010769": "particularly in our national health", "il4y7JjNabc-00046-00010770-00011024": "service it's a slightly techie issue so", "il4y7JjNabc-00047-00011025-00011123": "I think a lot of people don't really", "il4y7JjNabc-00048-00011124-00011263": "understand what's happened but can you", "il4y7JjNabc-00049-00011264-00011387": "explain what's happened and what we", "il4y7JjNabc-00050-00011388-00011542": "could do to protect ourselves better", "il4y7JjNabc-00051-00011543-00011899": "basically to understand what's happening", "il4y7JjNabc-00052-00011900-00012233": "we should imagine that there is traffic", "il4y7JjNabc-00053-00012234-00012491": "out there with cars on the streets but", "il4y7JjNabc-00054-00012492-00012705": "there's no seatbelt there's no real", "il4y7JjNabc-00055-00012706-00013147": "safety net of traffic lights or signs", "il4y7JjNabc-00056-00013148-00013400": "which protect us from being run over", "il4y7JjNabc-00057-00013401-00013669": "by any cars or something like that but", "il4y7JjNabc-00058-00013670-00013871": "exactly that's the reality out there in", "il4y7JjNabc-00059-00013872-00014033": "the Internet at the moment we really", "il4y7JjNabc-00060-00014034-00014191": "have a problem because there's no real", "il4y7JjNabc-00061-00014193-00014391": "safety standards and there's no", "il4y7JjNabc-00062-00014393-00014696": "liability for loopholes and we see now", "il4y7JjNabc-00063-00014697-00014956": "with the NHS that this can really", "il4y7JjNabc-00064-00014957-00015208": "threaten life in here and so we need to", "il4y7JjNabc-00065-00015209-00015380": "make sure that there's more more", "il4y7JjNabc-00066-00015381-00015605": "investment and who's taking care about", "il4y7JjNabc-00067-00015606-00015841": "the safety and security of our systems", "il4y7JjNabc-00068-00015843-00016088": "and that companies and authorities have", "il4y7JjNabc-00069-00016088-00016372": "to reveal if there is a loophole as", "il4y7JjNabc-00070-00016373-00016555": "quickly as possible so that we can close", "il4y7JjNabc-00071-00016556-00016780": "it so I think one of the debates we're", "il4y7JjNabc-00072-00016781-00016981": "having in Britain is how much a", "il4y7JjNabc-00073-00016982-00017192": "Microsoft to blame for not supporting", "il4y7JjNabc-00074-00017193-00017402": "old software and for having bad quality", "il4y7JjNabc-00075-00017403-00017642": "software that hackers can exploit the", "il4y7JjNabc-00076-00017643-00017878": "loopholes and how much is to do with tor", "il4y7JjNabc-00077-00017879-00018031": "investment in the NHS so we don't have", "il4y7JjNabc-00078-00018032-00018203": "enough money to buy the latest software", "il4y7JjNabc-00079-00018204-00018364": "where do you think the balance lies I", "il4y7JjNabc-00080-00018365-00018625": "would say that basically Microsoft did a", "il4y7JjNabc-00081-00018626-00018859": "good work in patching it so that's not", "il4y7JjNabc-00082-00018860-00019064": "really the problem in this case the real", "il4y7JjNabc-00083-00019065-00019294": "problem is that there was absolutely", "il4y7JjNabc-00084-00019295-00019400": "under-resourced", "il4y7JjNabc-00085-00019401-00019612": "stuff and me NHS and also in other", "il4y7JjNabc-00086-00019613-00019918": "systems companies authorities to patch", "il4y7JjNabc-00087-00019919-00020268": "it in time to work on really up-to-date", "il4y7JjNabc-00088-00020269-00020630": "systems and that's why it can't be", "il4y7JjNabc-00089-00020631-00020846": "really done properly if you don't have", "il4y7JjNabc-00090-00020847-00021050": "the personnel which is really skilled to", "il4y7JjNabc-00091-00021051-00021259": "do to do it you're not taking it", "il4y7JjNabc-00092-00021260-00021433": "seriously and so that needs to change", "il4y7JjNabc-00093-00021434-00021692": "but of course we also need to invest in", "il4y7JjNabc-00094-00021693-00022147": "a more secure safe environment which", "il4y7JjNabc-00095-00022148-00022361": "means that for example company like my", "il4y7JjNabc-00096-00022362-00022568": "companies like Microsoft need to be also", "il4y7JjNabc-00097-00022569-00022831": "liable if there is a loophole and they", "il4y7JjNabc-00098-00022832-00023033": "don't fix it ok great", "il4y7JjNabc-00099-00023034-00023230": "now I'm getting a lot of emails at the", "il4y7JjNabc-00100-00023231-00023483": "moment about save the link and this is", "il4y7JjNabc-00101-00023484-00023633": "to do with the freedom of information", "il4y7JjNabc-00102-00023634-00023855": "really on the Internet can you explain", "il4y7JjNabc-00103-00023856-00024022": "what greens are doing to make sure", "il4y7JjNabc-00104-00024023-00024197": "people still have free access to the", "il4y7JjNabc-00105-00024198-00024484": "news that they need the basic debate is", "il4y7JjNabc-00106-00024485-00025027": "in how far can we ask everyone to", "il4y7JjNabc-00107-00025028-00025225": "remunerated journalists or other", "il4y7JjNabc-00108-00025226-00025546": "creative workers for their works and the", "il4y7JjNabc-00109-00025547-00025870": "problem here is that the the big", "il4y7JjNabc-00110-00025872-00026122": "publishers try to get an extra write for", "il4y7JjNabc-00111-00026123-00026362": "themselves by getting money from us or", "il4y7JjNabc-00112-00026363-00026600": "other companies if they use links for", "il4y7JjNabc-00113-00026601-00026731": "example but the", "il4y7JjNabc-00114-00026732-00026895": "artists themselves the journalists", "il4y7JjNabc-00115-00026897-00027082": "themselves they don't get anything out", "il4y7JjNabc-00116-00027083-00027333": "of it and in contrary they have the", "il4y7JjNabc-00117-00027335-00027544": "damage because links are not distributed", "il4y7JjNabc-00118-00027545-00027787": "anymore so they nobody reads their", "il4y7JjNabc-00119-00027788-00028002": "articles really so what we really need", "il4y7JjNabc-00120-00028004-00028297": "is a better remuneration of journalists", "il4y7JjNabc-00121-00028298-00028599": "new schemes how they can get funding and", "il4y7JjNabc-00122-00028600-00028861": "some good examples exist where people", "il4y7JjNabc-00123-00028862-00029113": "really get together to functionalism as", "il4y7JjNabc-00124-00029114-00029281": "crowdfunding but we could also think", "il4y7JjNabc-00125-00029282-00029520": "about better funding for example by", "il4y7JjNabc-00126-00029522-00029875": "public money because real independent", "il4y7JjNabc-00127-00029876-00030100": "journalism should be worse or something", "il4y7JjNabc-00128-00030101-00030339": "okay now I agree so this is really also", "il4y7JjNabc-00129-00030341-00030493": "about fake news isn't it because if", "il4y7JjNabc-00130-00030494-00030682": "we're not paying for quality journalism", "il4y7JjNabc-00131-00030683-00030856": "this journalist can't get a livelihood", "il4y7JjNabc-00132-00030857-00031054": "for being expert in what they do then", "il4y7JjNabc-00133-00031055-00031201": "it's just a complete free-for-all out", "il4y7JjNabc-00134-00031202-00031351": "there and people might believe anything", "il4y7JjNabc-00135-00031352-00031539": "there's no way of knowing what's quality", "il4y7JjNabc-00136-00031541-00031879": "information what isn't exactly and we", "il4y7JjNabc-00137-00031880-00032155": "really have to make sure that quality", "il4y7JjNabc-00138-00032156-00032431": "journalism and news which really like", "il4y7JjNabc-00139-00032432-00032707": "transmit fact facts really still come", "il4y7JjNabc-00140-00032708-00032920": "into our bubble and in the internet", "il4y7JjNabc-00141-00032921-00033142": "that's really a huge challenge and I", "il4y7JjNabc-00142-00033143-00033319": "think a better idea then for example", "il4y7JjNabc-00143-00033320-00033634": "texting links would be to make sure that", "il4y7JjNabc-00144-00033635-00033877": "platforms like social networks like", "il4y7JjNabc-00145-00033878-00034266": "Facebook or also Google are forced to", "il4y7JjNabc-00146-00034267-00034546": "distribute quality journalism in the", "il4y7JjNabc-00147-00034547-00034891": "same way or even more than other content", "il4y7JjNabc-00148-00034892-00035047": "which they make money out of because", "il4y7JjNabc-00149-00035048-00035290": "it's just advertising or something which", "il4y7JjNabc-00150-00035291-00035503": "support the advertising system okay", "il4y7JjNabc-00151-00035504-00035566": "great", "il4y7JjNabc-00152-00035567-00035740": "oh well that's really interesting to", "il4y7JjNabc-00153-00035741-00035905": "hear from you and it's very assuring to", "il4y7JjNabc-00154-00035906-00036058": "know that we've got a green expert like", "il4y7JjNabc-00155-00036059-00036289": "you protect young people in the UK you", "il4y7JjNabc-00156-00036290-00036556": "know I wish you all the best luck and I", "il4y7JjNabc-00157-00036557-00036829": "think that the UK needs strong greens in", "il4y7JjNabc-00158-00036830-00037123": "Parliament thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "il-iGastjFc", "text": {"il-iGastjFc-00000-00000050-00000774": "[Music]", "il-iGastjFc-00001-00000775-00001031": "okay dinosaur i'd like you to meet your", "il-iGastjFc-00002-00001032-00001247": "great great great great great great", "il-iGastjFc-00003-00001248-00001734": "great grandson", "il-iGastjFc-00004-00001735-00001975": "what is that", "il-iGastjFc-00005-00001976-00002255": "it's a ticking i did not evolve into", "il-iGastjFc-00006-00002256-00002591": "that yeah dinosaurs evolved into birds", "il-iGastjFc-00007-00002592-00002871": "that's not evolving that's devolving", "il-iGastjFc-00008-00002872-00003134": "thank you i'm a terrifying ferocious", "il-iGastjFc-00009-00003135-00003415": "monster i have my days we ruled the", "il-iGastjFc-00010-00003415-00003638": "world for millions of years i late", "il-iGastjFc-00011-00003639-00003895": "breakfast for the mean apes", "il-iGastjFc-00012-00003896-00004103": "and if i don't like breakfast i get to", "il-iGastjFc-00013-00004104-00004303": "be a nugget", "il-iGastjFc-00014-00004304-00004519": "you said this would cheer me up yeah", "il-iGastjFc-00015-00004520-00004759": "well i i thought was ruined my day", "il-iGastjFc-00016-00004760-00004959": "completely thrown me off millions of", "il-iGastjFc-00017-00004960-00005215": "years evolution to be a chicken nugget", "il-iGastjFc-00018-00005216-00005535": "ridiculous i'm so sorry about him i love", "il-iGastjFc-00019-00005536-00006031": "granddad", "il-iGastjFc-00020-00006032-00006343": "you know best piece of advice i ever got", "il-iGastjFc-00021-00006344-00006510": "whenever you're feeling down in the", "il-iGastjFc-00022-00006511-00006727": "dumps and you just like nothing's going", "il-iGastjFc-00023-00006728-00006991": "your way you just got to remember", "il-iGastjFc-00024-00006992-00007663": "there's always tomorrow", "il-iGastjFc-00025-00007664-00008158": "what", "il-iGastjFc-00026-00008159-00008903": "[Music]", "il-iGastjFc-00027-00008904-00009087": "you know what", "il-iGastjFc-00028-00009088-00009367": "i'm gonna do it i i don't i'm gonna step", "il-iGastjFc-00029-00009368-00009567": "out of the water i don't know if this is", "il-iGastjFc-00030-00009568-00010119": "a good idea i'm doing it", "il-iGastjFc-00031-00010120-00010298": "i can't look", "il-iGastjFc-00032-00010299-00010774": "[Music]", "il-iGastjFc-00033-00010775-00010878": "huh", "il-iGastjFc-00034-00010879-00011223": "what's it like i'm getting a very strong", "il-iGastjFc-00035-00011224-00011626": "urge yeah to buy stuff", "il-iGastjFc-00036-00011627-00012294": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "ilHq3TJA8sg", "text": {"ilHq3TJA8sg-00000-00000003-00000196": "today what we're going to move on to is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00001-00000197-00000695": "is looking at some more of those methods", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00002-00000696-00001157": "for separating AZ tropic systems so last", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00003-00001158-00001340": "lecture as I mentioned we looked at", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00004-00001341-00001586": "pressure swing and then now we're going", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00005-00001587-00001738": "to be looking at some other examples", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00006-00001739-00002126": "where pressure swing isn't an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00007-00002127-00002465": "opportunity for us to use so remember", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00008-00002466-00002624": "when we looked at pressure swing the key", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00009-00002625-00003013": "thing we said was that for that to work", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00010-00003014-00003479": "the composition of the azeotrope has to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00011-00003479-00003749": "change when we change the pressure of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00012-00003750-00004034": "the system yep that doesn't happen with", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00013-00004035-00004231": "all azeotrope and if that doesn't happen", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00014-00004232-00004481": "then we can't use pressure swing", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00015-00004482-00004652": "distillation so we have to have some", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00016-00004653-00005272": "other tools to use in our armory and the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00017-00005273-00005513": "first the first sort of alternative", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00018-00005514-00005809": "option we can think about is is what's", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00019-00005810-00006195": "called extractive distillation okay and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00020-00006196-00006535": "the key to extractive distillation is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00021-00006536-00006764": "essentially the feed must have different", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00022-00006765-00006892": "solvent affinities", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00023-00006893-00007178": "so if if we we were to add a solvent to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00024-00007179-00007391": "this we essentially changed their", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00025-00007392-00007805": "relative volatility okay so because", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00026-00007806-00008014": "we've got a system with an azeotrope in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00027-00008015-00008353": "anyway we're likely to have a feed made", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00028-00008354-00008558": "of different types of chemicals", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00029-00008559-00008785": "potentially a polar and a non-polar", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00030-00008786-00009227": "component so there could be a solvent", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00031-00009228-00009587": "that we can find that we can add to our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00032-00009588-00009944": "system and essentially it will like one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00033-00009945-00010081": "of our components more than the other", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00034-00010082-00010466": "and that combination effect will", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00035-00010467-00010894": "actually change the relative volatility", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00036-00010895-00011360": "of our key components okay and that may", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00037-00011361-00011723": "allow us to to actually achieve a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00038-00011724-00011894": "distillation and we'll see a couple of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00039-00011895-00012262": "different examples of how that can work", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00040-00012263-00012617": "but the key the key thing for this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00041-00012618-00013038": "method is that the solvent that we pick", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00042-00013039-00013344": "not form an azeotrope with any of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00043-00013345-00013689": "feed components okay so we've got to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00044-00013690-00014028": "find a component that has our different", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00045-00014029-00014236": "affinities to our current V components", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00046-00014237-00014592": "but also doesn't form an azeotrope with", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00047-00014593-00015016": "either of those feed components and to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00048-00015016-00015283": "actually achieve those generally we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00049-00015284-00015619": "talking about using a flow rate of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00050-00015619-00015880": "solvent that's around the same order of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00051-00015881-00016089": "magnitude as a flow rate of the filles", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00052-00016090-00016338": "okay so to achieve something like this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00053-00016340-00016516": "we are actually using quite a lot of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00054-00016517-00016975": "solvent but the advantage is that we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00055-00016976-00017234": "actually try and recover our solvent and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00056-00017235-00017436": "often we were try and recover our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00057-00017437-00017694": "solvent by another distillation column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00058-00017695-00017922": "and then we would recycle our sulfur", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00059-00017923-00018505": "back to that first column and how we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00060-00018506-00018711": "include this solvent in the system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00061-00018712-00018922": "depends on what type of system we have", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00062-00018923-00019096": "so if we're dealing with a minimum", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00063-00019097-00019419": "boiling azeotrope then if you think", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00064-00019420-00019728": "about it the system is going to be most", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00065-00019729-00020071": "at the azeotrope at the top of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00066-00020072-00020478": "column yep so therefore we want to make", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00067-00020479-00020703": "sure we've got plenty of solvent at the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00068-00020704-00020931": "top of the column so we've got a minimum", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00069-00020932-00021231": "boiling azeotrope system we tend to add", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00070-00021232-00021459": "a solvent you theta solvent to the top", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00071-00021460-00021667": "of our column and we make sure our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00072-00021668-00021987": "solvent has a lower volatility than the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00073-00021988-00022269": "key components in our system and that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00074-00022270-00022437": "means we have plenty of solvent in the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00075-00022438-00022680": "top of our column but we've also got", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00076-00022681-00022930": "plenty of solvent flowing down our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00077-00022931-00023280": "column as a liquid and so we've got very", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00078-00023281-00023605": "little solvent that's actually taken off", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00079-00023606-00024081": "as a vapor in our overhead product Hey", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00080-00024082-00024421": "or the alternative is that we've got a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00081-00024422-00024714": "maximum boiling azeotrope and of course", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00082-00024715-00025033": "in that case our azeotrope is is going", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00083-00025034-00025336": "to be at the bottom of the column so in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00084-00025337-00025555": "there we can make sure we just add our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00085-00025556-00025906": "solvent in with the feed and again we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00086-00025907-00026192": "want a solvent with a lower volatility", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00087-00026193-00026393": "and the written you'll see because we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00088-00026394-00026683": "using a solvent with lower volatilities", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00089-00026685-00026971": "in both of these cases the solvent is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00090-00026972-00027245": "essentially coming out of the bottom and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00091-00027245-00028079": "that distillation column okay so I", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00092-00028080-00028333": "always think there's there's two ways of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00093-00028335-00028543": "thinking about how we can actually use", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00094-00028544-00028783": "extractive distillation and that depends", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00095-00028785-00029108": "on now on our solvent that we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00096-00029108-00029477": "actually adding to our system so the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00097-00029477-00029824": "simplest case if we've managed to find a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00098-00029825-00030262": "solvent and our solvent in our system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00099-00030263-00030707": "has a very very low volatility so an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00100-00030708-00031102": "extremely high boiling point much higher", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00101-00031103-00031402": "than any of the components in our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00102-00031403-00031610": "distillation column so of course much", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00103-00031611-00031768": "higher than really our distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00104-00031769-00032164": "column is operating at that means that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00105-00032166-00032732": "in reality ow our solvent doesn't take", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00106-00032733-00033023": "place in the it doesn't actually take", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00107-00033024-00033326": "place in the vapor liquid equilibrium it", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00108-00033327-00033533": "always stays as a liquid but the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00109-00033534-00033779": "presence of that liquid affects the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00110-00033780-00033977": "relative volatilities between hours of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00111-00033978-00034280": "components so an example of that is if", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00112-00034281-00034499": "we add something like ethylene glycol", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00113-00034500-00034745": "threaten our own water definitely", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00114-00034746-00034952": "michael has a much higher boiling point", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00115-00034953-00035212": "than either ethanol or water so pretty", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00116-00035213-00035435": "much everywhere in our column it stays", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00117-00035436-00035758": "as liquid very very small vapor fraction", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00118-00035759-00036376": "but if we then plot our X versus Y", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00119-00036377-00036821": "diagram for our ethanol versus water it", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00120-00036822-00037133": "moves from this original system here", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00121-00037134-00037651": "without azeotrope to this dashed system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00122-00037652-00037771": "okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00123-00037772-00038018": "so adding our filling glycol actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00124-00038019-00038249": "changes the relative volatilities enough", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00125-00038250-00038539": "between the water and the ethanol so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00126-00038540-00038821": "that we no longer have an azeotrope in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00127-00038822-00039357": "our system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00128-00039358-00039646": "so what we can do is essentially we have", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00129-00039647-00039847": "our new glycol which we add into our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00130-00039848-00040180": "first column and then in that first", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00131-00040181-00040474": "column we can then separate our ethanol", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00132-00040475-00040702": "and water because we're now dealing with", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00133-00040703-00041107": "this dashed equilibrium system yep so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00134-00041108-00041479": "it's a easy separation so the top of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00135-00041480-00041779": "first column we essentially get out pure", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00136-00041780-00042193": "ethanol and then at the bottom of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00137-00042194-00042445": "first column we basically collect all", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00138-00042446-00042841": "the water but we also have all of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00139-00042842-00043045": "Eponine glycol solvent in there because", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00140-00043046-00043309": "the boiling point is much higher okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00141-00043310-00043576": "so then that what that means is is our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00142-00043577-00043897": "bottom product here is water ethylene", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00143-00043898-00044191": "glycol but they have a difference in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00144-00044192-00044359": "boiling point and they don't have an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00145-00044360-00044575": "azeotrope between them because that was", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00146-00044576-00044863": "one of the criteria of picking our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00147-00044864-00045241": "solvent so we can very easily use the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00148-00045242-00045436": "second distillation column to recover", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00149-00045437-00045748": "the water and also recover that pure", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00150-00045749-00046009": "ethylene glycol which we can recycle", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00151-00046010-00046486": "back into our first distillation column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00152-00046487-00046762": "so although we've got a relatively high", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00153-00046763-00047107": "flow rate of ethylene glycol in this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00154-00047108-00047302": "case this example here you can actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00155-00047303-00047782": "see that there's three times the flow", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00156-00047783-00048079": "rate of solvent is needed to the flow", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00157-00048080-00048415": "rate of feed yeah so we've got even", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00158-00048416-00048589": "though we've got that high amount of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00159-00048590-00048811": "solvent because we're recovering the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00160-00048812-00049143": "solvent then it's actually not too bad", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00161-00049144-00049489": "it's not too expensive for this system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00162-00049490-00049795": "okay and that's the case where we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00163-00049796-00050155": "picked a solvent where the boiling point", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00164-00050156-00050436": "is much higher much less volatile and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00165-00050437-00050752": "essentially it always stays as a liquid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00166-00050753-00050989": "in our column very little vapor is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00167-00050990-00051379": "formed of our solvent an alternative way", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00168-00051379-00051715": "of looking at this is is we've managed", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00169-00051716-00051865": "to find our solvent we've managed to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00170-00051866-00052002": "find our selves up with a higher boiling", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00171-00052003-00052299": "point however it's only a little bit", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00172-00052300-00052489": "higher", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00173-00052490-00052779": "than the components in our feed so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00174-00052780-00052990": "therefore that solvent actually takes", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00175-00052991-00053251": "part in the vapor liquid equilibrium and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00176-00053252-00053482": "on each stage in our column there's", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00177-00053483-00053800": "actually some vapor solvent as well as", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00178-00053801-00054085": "some liquid solvent what that means is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00179-00054086-00054324": "is instead of using this sort of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00180-00054325-00054619": "simplified approach where we can think", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00181-00054620-00054907": "about it as the pseudo two component", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00182-00054908-00055129": "system and then just make sure all our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00183-00055129-00055291": "solvent flow rate comes out the bottom", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00184-00055291-00055600": "we have to go back to what we've been", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00185-00055601-00056004": "looking at and that's moving towards one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00186-00056005-00056572": "of our ternary diagram systems so in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00187-00056573-00056739": "this case we've got exactly the same", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00188-00056740-00057240": "side of system we've got our component a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00189-00057241-00057579": "and our component B which are present in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00190-00057580-00057850": "our feed and we've got this Daisy trope", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00191-00057851-00058111": "here between them and what we're doing", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00192-00058112-00058345": "is we're adding a solvent or we can make", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00193-00058346-00058570": "use of a solvent that has a higher", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00194-00058571-00058807": "boiling point than either of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00195-00058808-00059149": "components a or B okay and what we need", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00196-00059150-00059469": "to do is think about how we can use this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00197-00059470-00059832": "diagram here and represent a potential", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00198-00059833-00060490": "sequence of distillation columns okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00199-00060491-00060791": "so you'll notice actually that this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00200-00060791-00061138": "first distillation column here doesn't", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00201-00061139-00061637": "have any solvent yep so where we've not", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00202-00061638-00062084": "added any solvent yet and what this is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00203-00062085-00062413": "is what's called a pre concentrator okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00204-00062414-00062810": "and the reason that we sometimes use one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00205-00062811-00063311": "of these in our system is that if we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00206-00063312-00063526": "adding our solvent the important thing", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00207-00063527-00063698": "with our solvent is actually the ratio", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00208-00063699-00064063": "of the solvent to the field so if we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00209-00064064-00064492": "actually reduce some of our feed volume", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00210-00064494-00064738": "already some of the flow rate of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00211-00064739-00065009": "feeds then that means we can reduce the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00212-00065010-00065263": "amount of solvent we need so it's a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00213-00065264-00065700": "cheaper it's a cheaper separation okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00214-00065701-00065903": "but of course because we've only got a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00215-00065904-00066143": "and B in our system we're essentially", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00216-00066144-00066463": "limited to a distillation column on this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00217-00066464-00066751": "axis here and of course we are limited", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00218-00066752-00067049": "by our azeotrope so in this example", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00219-00067050-00067391": "let's take let's take our feed position", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00220-00067392-00067831": "of a and B here okay so what we've got", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00221-00067832-00068656": "is what about 63% a remainder B okay so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00222-00068657-00068981": "in our pre concentrated column we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00223-00068982-00069169": "essentially draw that on our ternary", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00224-00069170-00069607": "diagram like this so remember thinking", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00225-00069608-00069959": "back what did we need to plot a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00226-00069960-00070154": "distillation column on our ternary", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00227-00070155-00070460": "diagram so the first the first rule is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00228-00070461-00070831": "that a distillation column the top", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00229-00070832-00071176": "product the bottom product and the feed", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00230-00071177-00071747": "all lie on a straight line yep and the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00231-00071748-00072056": "bottom product and our top product lie", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00232-00072057-00072481": "on the same residue curve okay so in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00233-00072482-00072742": "this case we can have our straight line", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00234-00072743-00073085": "with the bottom product here of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00235-00073086-00073505": "essentially pure a and a top product", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00236-00073506-00073762": "here very near our azeotrope", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00237-00073763-00074181": "okay and also we've got this residue", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00238-00074182-00074562": "curve that goes round the outside of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00239-00074563-00074832": "ternary diagram so we've satisfied both", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00240-00074833-00075180": "of our criteria but we can represent", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00241-00075181-00075421": "that distillation column have that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00242-00075422-00075598": "straight line on the system as we were", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00243-00075599-00076240": "doing previously okay now of course when", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00244-00076241-00076516": "we're when we're thinking about design", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00245-00076517-00076735": "of these systems in this case we've got", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00246-00076736-00077185": "a pre concentrator but of course the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00247-00077186-00077472": "location of this feed point here is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00248-00077473-00077866": "going to affect whether it's economical", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00249-00077867-00078237": "to have so although you're removing some", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00250-00078238-00078612": "of the a from the system and reducing", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00251-00078613-00078859": "the flow rate that actually you have to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00252-00078860-00079135": "add solvent to you are happening to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00253-00079136-00079449": "build an extra distillation column yep", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00254-00079450-00079786": "so you've got a trade-off in costs", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00255-00079787-00080043": "between is it worthwhile building this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00256-00080044-00080280": "column to reduce the amount of solvent I", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00257-00080281-00080773": "needs yep or shall I not have one okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00258-00080774-00081054": "and of course that very much depends on", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00259-00081055-00081340": "the costs of all the components are", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00260-00081341-00081634": "solvent the distillation column but also", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00261-00081635-00081918": "how much a you can actually remove from", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00262-00081919-00082222": "the system so in this case because our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00263-00082223-00082500": "feed is quite equidistant between the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00264-00082501-00082816": "azeotrope and a we're removing quite a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00265-00082817-00083140": "lot of a from the system approximately", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00266-00083141-00083282": "if you think of the lever arm rule", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00267-00083283-00083712": "approximately 50% of the flow rate yep", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00268-00083713-00083907": "is a because it's about in the middle", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00269-00083908-00084174": "but if this feed point here was very", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00270-00084175-00084501": "close to our azeotrope already then the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00271-00084502-00084705": "amount of a we'd actually extract from", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00272-00084706-00084875": "that first column would be very small", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00273-00084876-00085384": "yeah", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00274-00085385-00085603": "so what do we have so let's say we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00275-00085604-00085768": "got puree coming out the bottom of this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00276-00085769-00086098": "column and then coming out at the top of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00277-00086099-00086314": "our first column is essentially", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00278-00086315-00086641": "something around the composition of the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00279-00086642-00086821": "azeotrope okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00280-00086822-00086986": "so the clothes that we can get to the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00281-00086987-00087238": "azeotrope the better because that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00282-00087239-00087475": "removes as much a as possible but of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00283-00087476-00087634": "course the closer we get to the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00284-00087635-00087832": "azeotrope the more difficult the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00285-00087833-00088114": "separation is so potentially the higher", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00286-00088115-00088324": "reflux ratio we need in the column and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00287-00088325-00088489": "the high number of trays in the column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00288-00088490-00088995": "another trade off for us to think about", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00289-00088996-00089185": "hopefully we're quite close to our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00290-00089186-00089389": "azeotrope composition and if we look at", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00291-00089390-00089728": "our sequence here essentially we add our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00292-00089729-00090133": "pure solvent to the mixture that comes", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00293-00090134-00090460": "out of the first column okay so again if", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00294-00090461-00090715": "you remember you think back when we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00295-00090716-00091062": "adding two streams on a ternary diagram", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00296-00091063-00091363": "we can add two streams by drawing a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00297-00091364-00091525": "straight line between the two streams", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00298-00091526-00091902": "that we add and then the combined", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00299-00091903-00092290": "mixture of that stream lie somewhere on", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00300-00092291-00092608": "our straight line so what we know is our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00301-00092609-00092929": "f2 which is the mixture of our d1 and s", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00302-00092930-00093346": "lies somewhere on this dashed green line", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00303-00093347-00093685": "okay but we don't know where because in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00304-00093686-00093955": "this particular case we're not told how", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00305-00093956-00094621": "much solvent we need to add okay now the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00306-00094622-00094984": "next thing that we know is we have a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00307-00094985-00095419": "distillation column and we have one top", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00308-00095420-00095757": "product which must be one of our pure", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00309-00095758-00095971": "components coming out of our system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00310-00095972-00096124": "because it's one of our final products", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00311-00096125-00096418": "and then we have a bottom product that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00312-00096419-00096625": "goes into our third distillation column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00313-00096626-00097117": "okay so we have a choice what do we try", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00314-00097118-00097327": "and take as a product from our first", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00315-00097328-00097609": "column do we try and take a or do we try", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00316-00097610-00097930": "and take B as our as our top product", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00317-00097931-00098173": "from the first column okay so what do we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00318-00098174-00098506": "do to work this out so we rely on our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00319-00098507-00098676": "residue curve", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00320-00098677-00099127": "okay so we could we could think about", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00321-00099128-00099520": "some particular positions on here as our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00322-00099521-00099751": "feeds and draw some very tight regions", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00323-00099752-00100146": "and see what's available to us yeah or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00324-00100147-00100414": "we can actually look at we can think", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00325-00100415-00100651": "about this in a thought experiment okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00326-00100652-00101059": "based on our two rules the distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00327-00101060-00101434": "column must be a straight line and the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00328-00101435-00101776": "top and the bottom thus lie on the same", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00329-00101777-00102208": "residue curve okay so for instance if we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00330-00102209-00102625": "have a as our top product can we draw a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00331-00102626-00102951": "straight line where our top product is a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00332-00102952-00103276": "we have a we have a straight line that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00333-00103277-00103579": "passes through this dashed line and then", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00334-00103580-00103768": "we have a bottom product somewhere down", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00335-00103769-00104211": "here but does our top and our bottom", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00336-00104213-00104502": "product lie on the same residue curve", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00337-00104503-00104896": "okay no that's impossible because you", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00338-00104897-00105091": "can see these residue curves go like", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00339-00105092-00105373": "this so it's impossible to draw a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00340-00105374-00105718": "straight line in this direction that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00341-00105719-00106099": "lies on the same residue curve okay so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00342-00106100-00106507": "our other option is having B yep so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00343-00106508-00106738": "let's think about having B or almost", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00344-00106739-00107014": "pure B so essentially we want something", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00345-00107015-00107299": "over here so we need to draw a straight", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00346-00107300-00107620": "line that passes through our dashed line", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00347-00107621-00107971": "that lies on the same residue curve so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00348-00107972-00108169": "let's think about this residue curve at", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00349-00108170-00108466": "the bottom here and we basically got", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00350-00108467-00108622": "this corner of it that's very close to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00351-00108623-00108918": "pure B can we draw a straight line from", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00352-00108919-00109333": "this part the residue curve through this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00353-00109333-00109584": "dashed line that also is on this residue", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00354-00109585-00110050": "curve and essentially yes we can okay we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00355-00110051-00110344": "can draw something like this red line", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00356-00110345-00110683": "here yep", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00357-00110683-00111027": "so what that's telling us is we can now", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00358-00111028-00111252": "have a distillate product a top product", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00359-00111253-00111639": "that's almost pure B and then we've got", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00360-00111640-00112132": "a bottom product here which is a mixture", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00361-00112133-00112938": "of our a and our solvent okay and what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00362-00112939-00113178": "we can also do if we need to is when you", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00363-00113179-00113419": "can now see that the feed point is f2", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00364-00113420-00113656": "must be the point where our red line", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00365-00113657-00114123": "crosses our dashed green line yep so we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00366-00114124-00114406": "can use the lever arm rule now on our -", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00367-00114407-00114783": "green line to work out how much solvent", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00368-00114783-00115171": "we would have to add to our feed so we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00369-00115172-00115491": "can now calculate our solvent yep our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00370-00115492-00115914": "solvent flow rate needed for for this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00371-00115915-00116309": "separation to occur okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00372-00116310-00116698": "so we've now got our pure B coming out", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00373-00116699-00117036": "of one column and then we've got our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00374-00117037-00117358": "mixture of a and solvent but we've still", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00375-00117358-00117627": "got our final column so what we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00376-00117628-00117801": "essentially need to do is we already", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00377-00117802-00118069": "know that the bottom product here must", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00378-00118070-00118428": "be uh pure solvent and realistically our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00379-00118429-00118582": "top product here must be the other", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00380-00118583-00119073": "component we want which is pure a so we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00381-00119074-00119226": "can think about having a distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00382-00119227-00119593": "column that goes down this side here the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00383-00119594-00119857": "straight line through this feed like", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00384-00119858-00120183": "this and it lies on the same residue", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00385-00120184-00120373": "curve the residue curve that runs down", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00386-00120374-00120772": "this axis here and separates our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00387-00120773-00121048": "essentially pure a as a top product and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00388-00121049-00121297": "our pure solvent as a bottom product", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00389-00121298-00122008": "which we can then recycle back in front", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00390-00122008-00122412": "of our second column okay so what we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00391-00122413-00122751": "done there is we've taken our potential", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00392-00122752-00123135": "distillation sequence and we've used the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00393-00123136-00123429": "knowledge of the residue curve and our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00394-00123430-00123801": "distillation rules to plot that uh now", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00395-00123802-00124065": "ternary diagram yep", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00396-00124066-00124386": "and then has commented what we can do is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00397-00124387-00124599": "like say use the leaver armor-all", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00398-00124600-00124875": "to calculate the amount of solvent we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00399-00124876-00125148": "can read off the compositions of each of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00400-00125149-00125484": "our our streams and get the flow rates", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00401-00125485-00125743": "of each of our streams with the liter", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00402-00125744-00126193": "armful okay and then of course if we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00403-00126194-00126372": "were going to do a full design on that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00404-00126373-00126573": "we now have our rough design which we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00405-00126574-00126793": "could then first of all think about", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00406-00126794-00127008": "looking at a shortcut method to get some", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00407-00127009-00127372": "of the minimum reflux ratios or minimum", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00408-00127373-00127638": "number of stages and then we could put", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00409-00127639-00127914": "that into a simulator like Aspen or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00410-00127915-00128427": "hisis to then actually perform our main", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00411-00128428-00128799": "simulation and then look at the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00412-00128800-00129009": "optimization of that system so for", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00413-00129010-00129421": "instance you know do where do we where", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00414-00129422-00129615": "do we actually do the separation of the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00415-00129616-00129861": "pre concentrator to do we leave it up", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00416-00129862-00130038": "here or do we move it closer to the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00417-00130039-00130452": "azeotrope for cost benefits okay but", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00418-00130453-00130626": "this technique allows us to get that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00419-00130627-00130941": "initial design which we need to progress", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00420-00130942-00131283": "forward to actually do the full", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00421-00131284-00131583": "calculation and design for our system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00422-00131584-00131916": "okay so does that make sense as a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00423-00131917-00132613": "technique yeah", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00424-00132614-00132968": "so the big issue with extractive", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00425-00132969-00133454": "distillation is that one one clause that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00426-00133455-00133853": "I said we must pick a solvent that does", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00427-00133854-00134183": "not form an azeotrope with any of the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00428-00134184-00134333": "complete either of the components in the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00429-00134334-00134807": "feed okay but Alfie it's because that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00430-00134808-00135017": "has an azeotrope there likes you to be", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00431-00135018-00135218": "I've very different chemically", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00432-00135219-00135476": "potentially a polar or nonpolar so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00433-00135477-00135755": "finding a solvent that have different", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00434-00135756-00135986": "interactions with the components but", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00435-00135987-00136328": "also doesn't form an azeotrope and then", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00436-00136329-00136718": "of course added classifications on top", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00437-00136719-00136955": "exactly like we had we liquid liquid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00438-00136956-00137225": "extraction so things like the solvent", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00439-00137226-00137630": "isn't really really toxic the solvent is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00440-00137631-00137960": "cheap enough to use okay limits our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00441-00137961-00138224": "choices so maybe we can't find a solvent", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00442-00138225-00138479": "that doesn't form an azeotrope with one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00443-00138480-00139004": "of our components okay but if it does", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00444-00139005-00139142": "form an azeotrope with one of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00445-00139143-00139432": "components we can essentially use a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00446-00139433-00139844": "modified version of extractive", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00447-00139845-00140042": "distillation which is generally classed", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00448-00140043-00140228": "as this homogeneous azeotropic", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00449-00140229-00140663": "distillation okay and in this case what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00450-00140664-00141140": "we do is we still run the same style of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00451-00141141-00141389": "system but we don't need a solvent or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00452-00141390-00141608": "any trainer that subject to the search", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00453-00141609-00142067": "the restriction of no agent rope it can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00454-00142068-00142520": "form an azeotrope with one of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00455-00142521-00143027": "components okay and instead of recycling", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00456-00143028-00143279": "that pure solvent or that pure entrainer", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00457-00143280-00143635": "we can then think about recycling the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00458-00143636-00144152": "azeotrope okay so let's think about an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00459-00144153-00144491": "example system for that so you might", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00460-00144492-00144869": "recognize our ternary diagram from the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00461-00144870-00145067": "other week the one that we looked at", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00462-00145068-00145352": "drawing our proximate residue curve", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00463-00145353-00145709": "technique for so in this case what we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00464-00145710-00145880": "got is we've got a feed", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00465-00145881-00146254": "here which is a mixture of a and B and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00466-00146255-00146552": "we've got an azeotrope between a and b", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00467-00146553-00146801": "and also just to make it a bit more", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00468-00146802-00146951": "difficult we've got this ternary", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00469-00146952-00147251": "azeotrope that has this little apart", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00470-00147252-00147650": "distillation boundary in the way we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00471-00147651-00147923": "managed to find our extract our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00472-00147924-00147998": "entrainer", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00473-00147999-00148322": "or our solvent but we've got an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00474-00148323-00148637": "azeotrope between e and our component a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00475-00148638-00148886": "which happens to form this distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00476-00148887-00149360": "boundary between that azeotrope and the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00477-00149361-00149755": "pure component B so using distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00478-00149756-00150095": "to actually get our pure entrainer", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00479-00150096-00150341": "is impossible because we can't cross", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00480-00150342-00150824": "that distillation boundary okay so what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00481-00150825-00151055": "we can do is something very similar to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00482-00151056-00151340": "what we did before so in this case", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00483-00151341-00151703": "you'll notice I'm not bothered with the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00484-00151704-00152012": "pre concentrator okay so we're just", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00485-00152013-00152435": "going to start from our initial feed so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00486-00152436-00152582": "we've got our initial feed of a being", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00487-00152583-00152705": "and what we're doing instead of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00488-00152706-00152891": "recycling that priori entrainer", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00489-00152892-00153302": "we're recycling the azeotrope about one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00490-00153303-00153596": "of our components and our solvent and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00491-00153597-00153902": "trainer okay so in this case we know", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00492-00153903-00154184": "that we can represent this mass balance", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00493-00154185-00154439": "as essentially between that azeotrope", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00494-00154440-00154769": "and our feed exactly the same as what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00495-00154770-00155273": "we've just done okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00496-00155274-00155679": "so again thinking about the same process", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00497-00155680-00155965": "we now know we've got to feed into our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00498-00155966-00156379": "first column that lies somewhere on this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00499-00156380-00156754": "line and in this case we're told that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00500-00156755-00157093": "it'll actually be we won't be to be the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00501-00157094-00157331": "pure component that comes out of the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00502-00157332-00157704": "bottom of our color", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00503-00157705-00157973": "so can we essentially draw a straight", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00504-00157974-00158384": "line from component B that passes", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00505-00158385-00158803": "through our green dashed line and lies", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00506-00158804-00159241": "on the same residue curve yes we can and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00507-00159242-00159506": "we can actually draw something like this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00508-00159507-00159766": "so this is going on this residue curve", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00509-00159767-00160027": "that goes all the way around the outside", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00510-00160028-00160598": "of our distillation region okay now", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00511-00160599-00161077": "again here we take in a decision we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00512-00161078-00161329": "taken a decision to draw this red line", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00513-00161330-00161525": "here we could have drawn it slightly", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00514-00161526-00161747": "higher up it would still work or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00515-00161748-00162052": "slightly lower down or slightly shorter", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00516-00162053-00162422": "okay and that will change", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00517-00162423-00162698": "that's essentially related to the amount", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00518-00162699-00163015": "of our azeotrope that we're recycling", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00519-00163016-00163227": "around and that is an optimization", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00520-00163228-00163615": "decision we can do at that we've got our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00521-00163616-00164053": "initial design okay so in this case", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00522-00164054-00164348": "we've now got our pure B as that bottom", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00523-00164349-00164681": "product and our mix of a and E as our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00524-00164682-00164921": "top product which we're putting into", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00525-00164922-00165272": "another distillation column where we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00526-00165273-00165632": "know we're getting a as a top product", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00527-00165633-00165959": "and we must have our AE azeotrope to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00528-00165960-00166484": "recycle so we can represent that by this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00529-00166485-00166832": "line here again straight line bottom", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00530-00166833-00167375": "feed top products and the bottom product", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00531-00167376-00167698": "and the top product on the same", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00532-00167699-00167921": "distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00533-00167922-00168300": "curve okay the same residue curve should", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00534-00168301-00168639": "get our petition yep that's the two key", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00535-00168640-00168855": "things okay so now we've represented", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00536-00168856-00169250": "this system also on our ternary diagram", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00537-00169251-00169980": "yeah okay so what I want to do is to is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00538-00169981-00170583": "anything well what if what if we can't", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00539-00170584-00170964": "use the the methods that we've currently", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00540-00170965-00171345": "looked at so for the first one with the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00541-00171346-00171663": "extractive distillation we have to find", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00542-00171664-00172169": "a solvent that didn't have any azeotrope", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00543-00172170-00172560": "to use the homogeneous azeotropic", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00544-00172561-00172866": "distillation technique we had to find a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00545-00172867-00173250": "solvent that formed an AZ that had an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00546-00173251-00173442": "azeotrope with basically our components", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00547-00173443-00174083": "however to actually form the pattern of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00548-00174084-00174348": "residue curves needed to apply that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00549-00174349-00174729": "technique the azeotrope that was formed", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00550-00174730-00175197": "actually has to be a maximum boiling", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00551-00175198-00175593": "azeotrope okay so for the last technique", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00552-00175594-00175818": "that homogeneous azeotropic distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00553-00175819-00176154": "to work the azeotrope that's actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00554-00176155-00176493": "formed has to be a maximum boiling", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00555-00176494-00176597": "azeotrope", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00556-00176598-00177000": "however maximum boiling azeotrope SAR", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00557-00177001-00177204": "quite rare in comparison to minimum", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00558-00177205-00177495": "boiling azeotropes so the likelihood of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00559-00177496-00177798": "finding a solvent that forms that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00560-00177799-00178068": "maximum boiling azeotrope is no so maybe", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00561-00178069-00178380": "for many systems we can't find one of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00562-00178381-00179007": "those AZ tropes but actually we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00563-00179008-00179322": "think about a different technique that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00564-00179323-00179571": "we can also use so you see what we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00565-00179572-00179814": "doing is we're essentially moving up in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00566-00179815-00180098": "how difficult these techniques are and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00567-00180099-00180477": "likely to be how costly these techniques", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00568-00180478-00180678": "are so that pressure swing is quite", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00569-00180679-00180960": "simple only needs two columns we don't", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00570-00180961-00181206": "need a solvent then we move on to one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00571-00181207-00181261": "where we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00572-00181262-00181633": "solvent yep so we're essentially trying", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00573-00181634-00181918": "to rule out as we go along these these", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00574-00181919-00182050": "techniques which are likely to be", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00575-00182051-00182659": "cheaper so if we can't get one that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00576-00182660-00183015": "forms a maximum boiling azeotrope we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00577-00183016-00183187": "probably find a solvent that forms the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00578-00183188-00183588": "minimum boiling azeotrope and in fact", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00579-00183589-00183937": "often we can find a solvent or an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00580-00183938-00184261": "entrainer that forms either a binary or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00581-00184262-00185090": "a ternary heterogeneous azeotrope okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00582-00185091-00185635": "and we've got a big advantage by forming", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00583-00185636-00186025": "a heterogeneous azeotrope okay and that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00584-00186026-00186409": "big advantage is we immediately have a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00585-00186410-00186871": "second separation technique which we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00586-00186872-00187213": "use and that second separation technique", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00587-00187214-00187488": "is essentially what you were looking at", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00588-00187489-00187693": "at the start of the course which is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00589-00187694-00187984": "liquid liquid extraction so where that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00590-00187985-00188364": "heterogeneous azeotrope Falls it has two", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00591-00188365-00188715": "liquid phases which also separate so you", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00592-00188716-00189088": "can actually look at a second separation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00593-00189089-00189622": "as well as our distillation and what we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00594-00189623-00189832": "tend to do is we tend to set the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00595-00189833-00190095": "overhead vapor from one of our columns", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00596-00190096-00190450": "as close as we can for that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00597-00190451-00190657": "heterogeneous azeotrope and that means", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00598-00190658-00191031": "when we condense that we form two", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00599-00191032-00191263": "separate liquid phases which we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00600-00191264-00191553": "decant and then we've also got an added", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00601-00191554-00192043": "separation and the big advantage of that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00602-00192044-00192476": "is that often the two two liquid phases", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00603-00192477-00192879": "lying different distillation regions yep", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00604-00192880-00193060": "so the thing that we've been struggling", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00605-00193061-00193357": "with all along is that we've got Asia", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00606-00193358-00193546": "tropes of distillation boundaries in the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00607-00193547-00194023": "way and we can't cross those with just", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00608-00194024-00194368": "distillation columns yep so we've been", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00609-00194369-00194608": "limited to the separation so like", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00610-00194609-00194836": "with the 8 with the homogenious", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00611-00194837-00195058": "azeotropic distillation we were limited", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00612-00195059-00195444": "and had to recycle our azeotrope round", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00613-00195445-00195714": "ok and we could because we couldn't get", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00614-00195715-00196018": "through our pure in training because of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00615-00196019-00196389": "that distillation boundary but now if", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00616-00196390-00196726": "we've got this option because we've got", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00617-00196727-00196957": "this added liquid phase which actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00618-00196958-00197098": "gives us products in different", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00619-00197099-00197485": "distillation regions we can now start to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00620-00197486-00197763": "move more around our ternary diagram and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00621-00197764-00198112": "actually look at separating to get", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00622-00198113-00198223": "components which are in different", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00623-00198224-00198681": "distillation regions okay so without", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00624-00198682-00199018": "heterogeneous what we get as our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00625-00199019-00199198": "products they don't all need to be in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00626-00199199-00199387": "the same distillation region because", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00627-00199388-00199513": "we've got this liquid liquid extraction", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00628-00199514-00200026": "step ok so for example let's take this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00629-00200027-00200418": "system here so we've got our component a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00630-00200419-00200746": "we've got our component B and we've got", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00631-00200747-00200908": "our solvent or entrainer that we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00632-00200909-00201184": "added here we of course weren't able to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00633-00201185-00201579": "do our original a B separation because", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00634-00201580-00201871": "we've got this azeotrope in the way but", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00635-00201872-00202038": "we found this in Trainor that could", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00636-00202039-00202276": "potentially work but actually what it", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00637-00202277-00202488": "still got is it's formed a ternary", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00638-00202489-00202653": "azeotrope here and we've got a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00639-00202654-00202975": "distillation boundary that is now", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00640-00202976-00203299": "between a and B so who are just using", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00641-00203300-00203518": "distillation columns we wouldn't be able", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00642-00203519-00203746": "to cross that boundary but that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00643-00203747-00203932": "distillation boundary is only a problem", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00644-00203933-00204175": "two distillation a different separation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00645-00204176-00204513": "technique and get past it one would be", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00646-00204514-00204837": "liquid liquid extraction so we can make", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00647-00204838-00205062": "use of a liquid liquid extraction here", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00648-00205063-00205434": "so if we produce a product that's", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00649-00205435-00205669": "basically a Tao ternary azeotrope here", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00650-00205669-00205951": "when we condense this it forms two", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00651-00205952-00206250": "liquid phases one of this composition", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00652-00206251-00206598": "and one of this composition and you can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00653-00206600-00206886": "see that these are already in two", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00654-00206887-00207244": "different distillation regions so if we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00655-00207244-00207516": "have a distillation column on this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00656-00207517-00207789": "product here we can get anything in this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00657-00207790-00207901": "region", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00658-00207902-00208105": "and if we have a distillation column on", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00659-00208106-00208327": "this product here we can get anything in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00660-00208328-00208633": "this region yep so ready", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00661-00208634-00209294": "we've got more options available to us", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00662-00209296-00209557": "so this is is typically what a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00663-00209558-00209896": "heterogeneous system looks like so we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00664-00209896-00210178": "got our column which forms out goes", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00665-00210179-00210412": "towards our ternary a heterogeneous", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00666-00210413-00210706": "azeotrope and then we've got our added", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00667-00210707-00210969": "decanter to give us our two liquid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00668-00210971-00211335": "phases and then we potentially have one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00669-00211336-00211555": "or two of the columns depending off", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00670-00211556-00211825": "we've got a pre concentrator or not in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00671-00211826-00212638": "our system okay so because this systems", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00672-00212639-00212980": "a little bit more complicated we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00673-00212981-00213229": "actually just need to think about a bit", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00674-00213230-00213571": "of a rearrangement before we actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00675-00213571-00213805": "can start to plot these on our ternary", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00676-00213806-00214101": "diagram because our now ternary diagram", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00677-00214102-00214339": "what we've been plotting because what's", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00678-00214340-00214657": "easy for us to product is distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00679-00214658-00215034": "columns that have one feed and a top", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00680-00215035-00215435": "product in the bottom product and and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00681-00215436-00215769": "mass balances so essentially two feeds", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00682-00215771-00216127": "joining together to form one feed okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00683-00216128-00216382": "or the opposite one being separated to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00684-00216383-00216744": "form two okay but if we look at this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00685-00216746-00216919": "system here so let's take this column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00686-00216919-00217237": "for an example we have one feed going in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00687-00217238-00217494": "here because it's based on our decanter", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00688-00217496-00217717": "and we also have a second feed so we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00689-00217717-00218152": "actually got two two feeds so that's how", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00690-00218153-00218341": "we would physically build the system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00691-00218342-00218548": "mechanically build the system but we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00692-00218548-00218766": "can't think about a simple rearrangement", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00693-00218767-00219204": "to allow us to draw them on our system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00694-00219205-00219478": "so the first rearrangement we can think", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00695-00219479-00219925": "about is round our reflux and a decanter", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00696-00219926-00220273": "so it what we may typically do this have", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00697-00220273-00220600": "is condensed into our decanter and then", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00698-00220601-00220869": "you can see that we've got some of one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00699-00220871-00221089": "of our phases go back into our column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00700-00221090-00221278": "and some of the other phase or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00701-00221279-00221551": "so going back into the column okay and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00702-00221552-00221914": "that's acting as both of reflux but also", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00703-00221915-00222316": "a liquid stream but what we can do is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00704-00222317-00222529": "just separate that out so first of all", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00705-00222530-00222841": "we have our reflux and then we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00706-00222842-00223117": "separately go into a decanter so we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00707-00223117-00223296": "just simplifying what we physically", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00708-00223298-00223542": "build to what we want to look at", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00709-00223544-00224179": "designing okay the second stages as I", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00710-00224180-00224353": "mentioned because of that we've got two", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00711-00224354-00224776": "fields okay but we can't mix those two", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00712-00224777-00224965": "feeds before they get to the column so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00713-00224966-00225184": "we just have one feed into the column so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00714-00225185-00225417": "in this case we can do that and we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00715-00225419-00225775": "still just taking our l2 and our d1 and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00716-00225776-00226078": "mixing them together so now you can see", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00717-00226079-00226312": "what we've done is we've actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00718-00226313-00226690": "changed this column back so it's got one", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00719-00226691-00226984": "feed and just our two standards top and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00720-00226985-00227198": "bottom product but it's exactly the same", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00721-00227200-00227616": "in terms of separation okay okay and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00722-00227617-00227890": "then finally we've got to think about", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00723-00227891-00228144": "the same for our last column well we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00724-00228146-00228340": "got one feed and then this is a feed", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00725-00228341-00228652": "going in and again we can just combine", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00726-00228653-00228921": "them before this column so we've got a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00727-00228923-00229173": "standard column so all we've done is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00728-00229175-00229542": "looked at is essentially looked at what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00729-00229544-00230092": "we would build versus what we would what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00730-00230092-00230353": "we're actually going to to draw to help", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00731-00230354-00230694": "us design it okay and then when we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00732-00230696-00230896": "got that and we've identified the flow", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00733-00230896-00231061": "rates and the composition for all these", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00734-00231062-00231325": "streams we can then just do the process", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00735-00231326-00231648": "back to turn it back into what we would", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00736-00231650-00231928": "actually build okay so it's just a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00737-00231929-00232207": "little trick that we need to do to help", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00738-00232208-00232473": "us use this technique to design these", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00739-00232475-00232951": "heterogeneous systems okay so now we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00740-00232952-00233239": "got this rearranged system we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00741-00233240-00233619": "actually think about drawing that on on", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00742-00233621-00234228": "our diagram okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00743-00234229-00234792": "and what I'm hopefully going to do is to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00744-00234794-00235273": "actually draw this for you so instead of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00745-00235273-00235563": "just seeing the sort of animated version", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00746-00235564-00235831": "you can see the example a bit more like", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00747-00235832-00236019": "when when you're trying to do these", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00748-00236021-00236608": "systems so what we really need to think", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00749-00236609-00236929": "about is what information we've got for", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00750-00236930-00237205": "our system because we don't always have", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00751-00237206-00237358": "all the information when we're drawing", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00752-00237359-00237787": "these and so in this case we're given", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00753-00237788-00238063": "our feed our f1 which is our feed into", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00754-00238064-00238492": "the system ok but what do we do first is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00755-00238492-00238861": "actually start thinking about how where", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00756-00238862-00239146": "we're going to draw the system well if", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00757-00239146-00239359": "you remember what we said what we really", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00758-00239360-00239911": "want to do is try and get a product from", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00759-00239912-00240046": "the top of one of our distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00760-00240046-00240313": "columns there's very near to that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00761-00240314-00240604": "ternary azeotrope okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00762-00240605-00240931": "and the reason that we do that is first", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00763-00240932-00241153": "of all is that turning azeotrope splits", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00764-00241154-00241315": "into two that could phase us which is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00765-00241316-00241798": "good and useful for us but also if we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00766-00241798-00242215": "in this region this region or this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00767-00242216-00242677": "region that turning Asia trope is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00768-00242678-00242896": "available to us from a distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00769-00242896-00243232": "column yep so we're not actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00770-00243233-00243619": "limiting how we have to access that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00771-00243619-00244002": "ternary azeotrope so we're not defining", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00772-00244003-00244264": "what separation is occurring in this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00773-00244265-00244486": "distillation column we're just thinking", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00774-00244487-00245035": "about this decanter separation okay so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00775-00245036-00245260": "in that case we can essentially start", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00776-00245261-00245765": "with an estimate for our system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00777-00245766-00246466": "and say that we can basically draw a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00778-00246467-00246791": "liquid liquid separation whose exits", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00779-00246792-00247262": "across here and we can define this as an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00780-00247263-00247771": "e rich and we can define this as an e", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00781-00247773-00248042": "lean so basically the e rich has lots of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00782-00248042-00248327": "been trainer in and the e lean has very", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00783-00248328-00248680": "little and trainer in okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00784-00248681-00249167": "and now after now as we then start to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00785-00249167-00249536": "develop the system further on we may", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00786-00249537-00249908": "find that we need to move exactly which", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00787-00249909-00250238": "point we're separating okay but we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00788-00250239-00250514": "do that later if we need to but to start", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00789-00250515-00250865": "with we always access our ternary", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00790-00250866-00251228": "azeotrope that goes across the the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00791-00251229-00251719": "liquid liquid region okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00792-00251721-00251996": "so if we look at our system here we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00793-00251996-00252157": "essentially have one of our liquid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00794-00252158-00252685": "phases that goes into one of our columns", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00795-00252686-00252969": "and one that goes to our second color", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00796-00252971-00253214": "one of them is mixed with our initial", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00797-00253215-00253555": "feeds and one of them is mixed with what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00798-00253556-00254063": "is being recycled from our labeled here", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00799-00254064-00254600": "column one now logically if you're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00800-00254601-00255004": "mixing something with the feed you would", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00801-00255005-00255248": "want to mix something with the feed that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00802-00255248-00255517": "is of a similar composition that is what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00803-00255519-00255783": "you'd want to try and do first okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00804-00255784-00256244": "also this column here column two is the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00805-00256244-00256423": "column that has the azeotropic", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00806-00256425-00256742": "separation right so that's typically the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00807-00256742-00256901": "column where we want lots of the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00808-00256902-00257317": "entrainer so our orig we would also like", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00809-00257319-00257627": "you put into our column that actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00810-00257628-00258146": "has has the azeotrope it okay so that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00811-00258146-00258373": "means that the system is that way round", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00812-00258373-00258817": "then because we know our F 1 and we know", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00813-00258819-00259219": "our in this case lean phase or au liquid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00814-00259221-00259462": "liquid phase is very similar to the feed", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00815-00259463-00259855": "then we can actually mix those two", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00816-00259856-00260519": "together which of course is a straight", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00817-00260519-00260987": "line drawn between our F 1 and our alene", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00818-00260988-00261617": "point okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00819-00261617-00262064": "so then continuing to look at our system", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00820-00262065-00262480": "essentially that mixture is what we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00821-00262481-00262743": "actually distilling in our first column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00822-00262744-00263124": "and in this column one we essentially", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00823-00263125-00263592": "want B as our bottom product and then we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00824-00263593-00263826": "want something as our top product which", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00825-00263827-00264444": "we can then mix okay so if we've got a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00826-00264445-00264825": "feed somewhere on this blue line and we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00827-00264826-00265452": "want B as our bottom product then we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00828-00265453-00265689": "would be looking at a distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00829-00265690-00266037": "column that essentially is somewhere", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00830-00266038-00266493": "like this okay so let's just draw that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00831-00266494-00267141": "in for now and that would be our now", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00832-00267142-00267584": "column one okay and we would end up", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00833-00267585-00268307": "without our bottom product and our top", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00834-00268308-00268950": "product okay now in this case where", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00835-00268951-00269547": "we've drawn our d1 then what we have to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00836-00269548-00269745": "think about it's the same things that we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00837-00269746-00269889": "had to think about when we're looking at", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00838-00269890-00270209": "this method before so if we had residue", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00839-00270210-00270551": "curves on this diagram we would need to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00840-00270552-00270900": "make sure that the distillate and our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00841-00270901-00271071": "bottom product light lay on the same", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00842-00271072-00271478": "residue curve and also the exact point", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00843-00271479-00271875": "of this d1 here do we go closer to this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00844-00271876-00272124": "distillation boundary do your slightly", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00845-00272125-00272412": "further away do we go slightly closer to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00846-00272413-00272613": "the age of tray do we go slightly closer", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00847-00272614-00273422": "away okay so those questions are due to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00848-00273423-00273741": "optimization questions yes so this part", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00849-00273742-00273942": "gives us our initial design and when", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00850-00273943-00274178": "we've got that we can then look at the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00851-00274179-00274425": "exact composition of d1 to see what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00852-00274426-00274848": "gives us an optimum cheap design yep but", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00853-00274849-00275063": "this process is giving us our initial", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00854-00275064-00275472": "design what we do want to do however is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00855-00275473-00275816": "we do want to try and avoid ow", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00856-00275817-00276334": "d1 being in this two-phase region", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00857-00276335-00276618": "because if we're inside the two-phase", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00858-00276619-00277064": "region then in our distillation column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00859-00277065-00277550": "on our stages we can have essentially", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00860-00277551-00277859": "two liquids forming on our stages which", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00861-00277860-00278247": "reduces the efficiency of our plates in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00862-00278248-00278388": "our distillation column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00863-00278389-00278627": "so we kind of want to avoid going into", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00864-00278628-00279492": "the two-phase region if we can okay so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00865-00279493-00279651": "the next thing that we have on our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00866-00279652-00280073": "diagram is we now have d1 and we know d1", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00867-00280074-00280457": "and we know our l2 which we've also", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00868-00280458-00280787": "referred to as P rich okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00869-00280788-00281115": "and what we do is we have to mix those", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00870-00281116-00281646": "two together so essentially to mix those", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00871-00281647-00282369": "two together we just represent that by", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00872-00282370-00282567": "our straight line again I'll blue", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00873-00282568-00282908": "straight line and then really we only", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00874-00282909-00283130": "have one thing left that we need to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00875-00283131-00283559": "think about for the system and that is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00876-00283560-00283965": "our column two and that is the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00877-00283966-00284329": "distillation column that gives us our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00878-00284330-00284568": "ternary azeotrope at the top and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00879-00284569-00284919": "hopefully gives us pure a at the bottom", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00880-00284920-00285206": "okay so now is really the crucial point", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00881-00285207-00285482": "so hopefully we've done everything okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00882-00285483-00285675": "at this point so we need to be able to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00883-00285676-00285971": "draw a straight line on our diagram that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00884-00285972-00286550": "goes from our pure component a to our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00885-00286551-00286930": "ternary azeotrope which passes through", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00886-00286931-00287488": "this blue line that we've just drawn yep", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00887-00287489-00288001": "and hopefully you can see that we can do", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00888-00288002-00288619": "that with a straight line like that so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00889-00288620-00289135": "that would be a column to in this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00890-00289136-00289920": "situation okay I take that back to a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00891-00289921-00290296": "multicolored version of that process but", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00892-00290297-00290569": "you can see what we did is we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00893-00290570-00290824": "essentially find exactly the same things", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00894-00290825-00291160": "as we were doing before but in this case", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00895-00291161-00291391": "we've just got the added difficulty or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00896-00291392-00291757": "in fact an added advantage that we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00897-00291758-00292087": "got that liquid liquid extraction step", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00898-00292088-00292438": "so we've got our two distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00899-00292439-00292774": "columns we've got our blue column and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00900-00292775-00293236": "our orange column doing a sort of main", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00901-00293237-00293464": "part of the separation and then we're", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00902-00293465-00293935": "taking advantage of one our liquid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00903-00293936-00294304": "liquid region the red line here to move", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00904-00294305-00294514": "us around the distillation column to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00905-00294515-00294718": "move us around our ternary diagram and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00906-00294719-00295033": "also we're taking advantage of being", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00907-00295034-00295450": "able to mix those streams together to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00908-00295451-00295903": "create feeds in the distillation regions", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00909-00295904-00296155": "that we need to allow us to use a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00910-00296156-00296347": "distillation column to get the products", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00911-00296348-00296863": "that we want okay and then as mentioned", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00912-00296864-00297250": "what we can do is we can then take we", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00913-00297251-00297415": "could then read these compositions off", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00914-00297416-00297676": "we could use a leave ROM rule or mass", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00915-00297677-00297976": "balances to look at getting some of the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00916-00297977-00298315": "compositions which we can then put onto", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00917-00298316-00298558": "our system here which we could then go", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00918-00298559-00298852": "on to put into a program like Aspen or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00919-00298853-00299134": "hisis to then allow us to do the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00920-00299135-00299503": "optimization of the system but of course", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00921-00299504-00299835": "Aspen or hisis requires us to have an", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00922-00299836-00300208": "initial guess for that to actually be", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00923-00300209-00300508": "able to solve the the system we put in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00924-00300509-00300841": "and the more complicated the system the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00925-00300842-00301093": "that initial guess essentially needs to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00926-00301094-00301588": "be for it to actually solve okay and the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00927-00301589-00301792": "other advantages is you can also use", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00928-00301793-00302074": "this to check that your solution is", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00929-00302075-00302317": "giving you your solution in aspirin your", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00930-00302318-00302518": "solution hisis is giving you something", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00931-00302519-00303422": "that's sensible okay and really works", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00932-00303423-00303653": "so there's one remaining technique that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00933-00303654-00304190": "I want to mention as well so there's a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00934-00304191-00304424": "more a newer sort of technique in the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00935-00304425-00304826": "distillation and the distillation family", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00936-00304827-00305134": "and that's reactive distillation so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00937-00305135-00305345": "reactive distillation is essentially a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00938-00305346-00305557": "simultaneous chemical reaction and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00939-00305558-00305915": "distillation together okay and the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00940-00305916-00306082": "reaction normally takes place in the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00941-00306083-00306358": "liquid phase and we perhaps need a solid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00942-00306359-00306695": "catalyst to do that so instead of just", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00943-00306696-00307046": "having our our trays in our distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00944-00307047-00307337": "column we can potentially have our trays", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00945-00307338-00307480": "with catalyst on or", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00946-00307481-00307844": "we can have a packed distillation column", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00947-00307845-00308147": "where that packing also contains our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00948-00308148-00308666": "catalysts within that and it can be used", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00949-00308667-00308959": "so to essentially separate our Asia", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00950-00308960-00309278": "tropic mixture of a and B but instead of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00951-00309279-00309566": "just adding our solvent that affects our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00952-00309567-00309818": "vapor liquid equilibrium we add a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00953-00309819-00310265": "solvent that actually reacts with with", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00954-00310266-00310616": "one of our components in the system to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00955-00310617-00311005": "form a new chemical which has a more", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00956-00311006-00311267": "advantageous vapor liquid equilibrium", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00957-00311268-00311680": "for us to work with but hopefully the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00958-00311681-00311864": "sole we've picked and the reaction that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00959-00311865-00312140": "we do is reversible so then we can", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00960-00312141-00312629": "recover our initial component so for", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00961-00312630-00313156": "example in this case we've got our a and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00962-00313157-00313412": "B as our initial feed and you can see", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00963-00313413-00313630": "based on their relative volatilities", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00964-00313631-00313882": "that they're incredibly close together", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00965-00313883-00314363": "and very difficult to separate but what", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00966-00314364-00314627": "we've managed to find we managed to find", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00967-00314628-00314825": "an inn trainer that we can add e our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00968-00314826-00315416": "solvent that reacts with component B in", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00969-00315417-00315671": "a reversible reaction to form component", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00970-00315672-00316199": "C and component C has a very different", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00971-00316200-00316529": "relative volatility to our component a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00972-00316530-00316754": "so separating a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00973-00316755-00317252": "and see is relatively easy to do and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00974-00317253-00317468": "also the solvent or entrainer we've", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00975-00317469-00317720": "picked also has a different relative", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00976-00317721-00318086": "volatility so it's also needed easier to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00977-00318087-00318683": "separate e and a as well so as well as", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00978-00318684-00318872": "our vapor liquid equilibrium we also", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00979-00318873-00319172": "have our reaction so as we move up the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00980-00319173-00319478": "column essentially B is being reactive", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00981-00319479-00319790": "to C so our C separates so our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00982-00319791-00320201": "separation is now actually on a a and C", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00983-00320202-00320606": "rather than a and B and then we have our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00984-00320607-00320912": "pure a essentially separated and at the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00985-00320913-00321245": "bottom of our column we have en C but", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00986-00321246-00321770": "because E and C a part of a reversible", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00987-00321771-00322004": "reaction we can then change the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00988-00322005-00322417": "conditions see that C then reacts back", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00989-00322418-00323021": "to form our original component B and our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00990-00323022-00323273": "in trainer or solvent a again and then", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00991-00323274-00323594": "we could recycle e back to our column so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00992-00323595-00323849": "what we're taking advantage of is that", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00993-00323850-00324158": "we also could have a reaction in our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00994-00324159-00324605": "system okay but as you can imagine this", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00995-00324606-00324842": "is obviously quite complex system and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00996-00324843-00325007": "can be very expensive because we need a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00997-00325008-00325199": "solvent we need a catalyst", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00998-00325200-00325466": "we then need the reversible reaction so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-00999-00325467-00325682": "this is kind of used in systems where", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01000-00325683-00325886": "some of the other separation techniques", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01001-00325887-00326072": "that we've already talked about are just", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01002-00326073-00326411": "not possible okay but this reactive", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01003-00326412-00326681": "distillation is is is a new technique", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01004-00326682-00326899": "that sort of becoming more popular", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01005-00326900-00327200": "within industry to tackle some of the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01006-00327201-00327593": "more difficult separations and it does", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01007-00327594-00328085": "have a big potential to save energy over", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01008-00328086-00328237": "some of the more complicated", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01009-00328238-00328538": "distillation sequences that we need to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01010-00328539-00328823": "separate a zeotropic distillation AZ", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01011-00328824-00329481": "Tropes a jatropha components with okay", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01012-00329482-00330169": "so we've basically covered today the", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01013-00330170-00330415": "sort of key methods for actually", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01014-00330416-00330742": "separating our Asia tropic systems so", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01015-00330743-00330884": "we've had an extractive distillation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01016-00330885-00331114": "when we can have when we can find a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01017-00331115-00331260": "solvent that doesn't form any Asia", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01018-00331261-00331579": "tropes homogeneous if we can find a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01019-00331580-00331785": "solvent that just forms a maximum", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01020-00331786-00331939": "boiling azeotrope with one of our", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01021-00331940-00332317": "components if we can't if neither of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01022-00332318-00332470": "those options that are available to us", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01023-00332471-00332674": "we've got a heterogeneous azeotropic", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01024-00332675-00333055": "distillation where we take advantage of", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01025-00333056-00333316": "that heterogeneous azeotrope and take", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01026-00333317-00333529": "advantage of that liquid liquid", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01027-00333530-00333924": "separation step without a counter and", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01028-00333925-00334354": "then finally we've just had sort of a", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01029-00334355-00334702": "quick thought to know that reactive", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01030-00334703-00334939": "distillation is a technique that is also", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01031-00334940-00335409": "possible and we couple our VLE", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01032-00335410-00335808": "separation with a reversible reaction to", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01033-00335809-00336028": "help us when we've got a potential", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01034-00336029-00336226": "azeotrope or a very difficult separation", "ilHq3TJA8sg-01035-00336227-00336622": "in our system"}}, {"audio_id": "im3OVbqBUUA", "text": {"im3OVbqBUUA-00000-00000000-00000642": "[Music]", "im3OVbqBUUA-00001-00000643-00001143": "[Music]", "im3OVbqBUUA-00002-00001144-00001487": "hello and welcome to the episode 307", "im3OVbqBUUA-00003-00001488-00001887": "what a fob day i am your host simon mass", "im3OVbqBUUA-00004-00001888-00002126": "among other things today we'll see how", "im3OVbqBUUA-00005-00002127-00002383": "the beatles performed during several", "im3OVbqBUUA-00006-00002384-00002734": "live gigs started and completed michelle", "im3OVbqBUUA-00007-00002735-00003015": "in just one session and completed the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00008-00003016-00003286": "filming of magical mystery tour for the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00009-00003288-00003422": "third time", "im3OVbqBUUA-00010-00003423-00003863": "this time is for real said little nikola", "im3OVbqBUUA-00011-00003864-00004215": "on the 3rd of november 1960 the beatles", "im3OVbqBUUA-00012-00004216-00004438": "would beat bass on drums and stuckly", "im3OVbqBUUA-00013-00004439-00004695": "from bass kept on performing at the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00014-00004696-00005038": "kaiser keller in hamburg west germany", "im3OVbqBUUA-00015-00005039-00005318": "alternating on the stage with rory storm", "im3OVbqBUUA-00016-00005319-00005606": "and the hurricanes", "im3OVbqBUUA-00017-00005607-00005967": "one year later in 1961 still featuring", "im3OVbqBUUA-00018-00005968-00006199": "pete best on drums but now with paul", "im3OVbqBUUA-00019-00006200-00006503": "mccartney on base the lads performed a", "im3OVbqBUUA-00020-00006504-00006767": "lunchtime concert at the cavern club in", "im3OVbqBUUA-00021-00006768-00006959": "liverpool their 50th", "im3OVbqBUUA-00022-00006961-00007095": "[Music]", "im3OVbqBUUA-00023-00007095-00007446": "in 1962 the beatles now with ringo starr", "im3OVbqBUUA-00024-00007447-00007727": "on drums performed at the star club in", "im3OVbqBUUA-00025-00007728-00008119": "hamburg west germany alone and backing", "im3OVbqBUUA-00026-00008120-00008359": "little richard", "im3OVbqBUUA-00027-00008360-00008655": "on this date in 1963 the beatles", "im3OVbqBUUA-00028-00008656-00008878": "continued their autumn tour at the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00029-00008879-00009095": "audience in my leads", "im3OVbqBUUA-00030-00009096-00009431": "i instead will continue to create music", "im3OVbqBUUA-00031-00009432-00009719": "related content and i will be able to do", "im3OVbqBUUA-00032-00009720-00010063": "so more fruitfully if you give me a hand", "im3OVbqBUUA-00033-00010064-00010151": "how", "im3OVbqBUUA-00034-00010152-00010438": "why find that out by visiting", "im3OVbqBUUA-00035-00010439-00010791": "www.simonmass.com", "im3OVbqBUUA-00036-00010792-00011095": "support at the end of the episode the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00037-00011096-00011283": "link is in the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00038-00011284-00011727": "description on the 3rd of november 1965", "im3OVbqBUUA-00039-00011728-00011991": "at the emi studios in abbey road the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00040-00011992-00012303": "beatles started and completed michelle a", "im3OVbqBUUA-00041-00012304-00012542": "song written sometime before by", "im3OVbqBUUA-00042-00012543-00012919": "mccartney starting from 2 30 pm and", "im3OVbqBUUA-00043-00012919-00013238": "ending up with a complete track by 11 30", "im3OVbqBUUA-00044-00013240-00013391": "pm", "im3OVbqBUUA-00045-00013391-00013743": "the first part of the session up to 7 pm", "im3OVbqBUUA-00046-00013744-00013991": "saw the band rehearsing the material and", "im3OVbqBUUA-00047-00013991-00014286": "then recording the rhythm track in just", "im3OVbqBUUA-00048-00014287-00014558": "one take with paul mccartney and george", "im3OVbqBUUA-00049-00014559-00014799": "harrison on acoustic guitars and ringo", "im3OVbqBUUA-00050-00014800-00014991": "starring drums", "im3OVbqBUUA-00051-00014991-00015327": "from 7pm instead the beatles worked on", "im3OVbqBUUA-00052-00015328-00015607": "the overdubs with john lennon adding two", "im3OVbqBUUA-00053-00015608-00015871": "more acoustic guitar parts paul", "im3OVbqBUUA-00054-00015872-00016175": "recording bass and george performing a", "im3OVbqBUUA-00055-00016176-00016343": "guitar solo", "im3OVbqBUUA-00056-00016344-00016694": "after that paul george and john recorded", "im3OVbqBUUA-00057-00016695-00016919": "all the vocals needed to complete the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00058-00016920-00017119": "song", "im3OVbqBUUA-00059-00017120-00017455": "finally on this date in 1967", "im3OVbqBUUA-00060-00017456-00017694": "the filming of magical mystery tour was", "im3OVbqBUUA-00061-00017695-00017950": "finally concluded with some sequences to", "im3OVbqBUUA-00062-00017951-00018350": "be edited into the blue jay way scene", "im3OVbqBUUA-00063-00018351-00018599": "all the filming was made at ringo", "im3OVbqBUUA-00064-00018600-00018943": "starr's country house in waybridge 19", "im3OVbqBUUA-00065-00018944-00019158": "miles from london", "im3OVbqBUUA-00066-00019159-00019422": "the main sequences featured each beetle", "im3OVbqBUUA-00067-00019423-00019639": "playing a white cello in ringo's", "im3OVbqBUUA-00068-00019640-00019767": "backyard", "im3OVbqBUUA-00069-00019768-00020039": "then george harrison was filmed walking", "im3OVbqBUUA-00070-00020040-00020335": "down some steps in the garden then the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00071-00020336-00020575": "white cello was filmed in front of some", "im3OVbqBUUA-00072-00020576-00020903": "fireworks this took care of the extra", "im3OVbqBUUA-00073-00020904-00021191": "cello part added to the song after the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00074-00021192-00021463": "main blue jay way scene had been filmed", "im3OVbqBUUA-00075-00021464-00021614": "in september", "im3OVbqBUUA-00076-00021615-00021878": "after that it was the turn of some", "im3OVbqBUUA-00077-00021879-00022127": "children playing in the garden and then", "im3OVbqBUUA-00078-00022128-00022358": "the production moved inside for another", "im3OVbqBUUA-00079-00022359-00022647": "two sequences in one the available blue", "im3OVbqBUUA-00080-00022648-00022927": "jay way footage was projected onto", "im3OVbqBUUA-00081-00022928-00023207": "beetle's assistant marl evans's bare", "im3OVbqBUUA-00082-00023208-00023303": "chest", "im3OVbqBUUA-00083-00023304-00023503": "in the other the same footage was", "im3OVbqBUUA-00084-00023504-00023814": "projected onto a white screen with each", "im3OVbqBUUA-00085-00023815-00024078": "beetle watching", "im3OVbqBUUA-00086-00024079-00024319": "tomorrow we'll further explore the", "im3OVbqBUUA-00087-00024320-00024583": "beatles working studio with a couple of", "im3OVbqBUUA-00088-00024584-00024694": "sessions", "im3OVbqBUUA-00089-00024695-00025022": "for the moment i wish you a good day and", "im3OVbqBUUA-00090-00025023-00025519": "a fob continuation", "im3OVbqBUUA-00091-00025520-00025907": "music you love"}}, {"audio_id": "imiz2qblO2E", "text": {"imiz2qblO2E-00000-00000000-00000236": "hey that I've available in Savannah Bush", "imiz2qblO2E-00001-00000237-00000499": "Tottenham nordstrom a new no stress", "imiz2qblO2E-00002-00000500-00000743": "a team of which num address", "imiz2qblO2E-00003-00000744-00001073": "Poseidon a vigil pierced nippled romania", "imiz2qblO2E-00004-00001074-00001289": "damn we will be well let's play chica", "imiz2qblO2E-00005-00001290-00001723": "horrid game era ah here Sosa when you", "imiz2qblO2E-00006-00001725-00002067": "1,000,000 Patricia cosmic analia whoa", "imiz2qblO2E-00007-00002068-00002533": "yeah pozdravlyayu seba if sickness ah", "imiz2qblO2E-00008-00002534-00003067": "but a monster attack Rupa yes Lee when", "imiz2qblO2E-00009-00003068-00003443": "is night sector tattos silca budet vnizu", "imiz2qblO2E-00010-00003444-00003734": "with the sunny oh yes idea to Nineveh", "imiz2qblO2E-00011-00003735-00003997": "put the sad stuff under this hump and", "imiz2qblO2E-00012-00003998-00004904": "I've it's a um my pace now evil nah just", "imiz2qblO2E-00013-00004905-00005356": "a congested AP that it be this video see", "imiz2qblO2E-00014-00005357-00005750": "Lucas three mystery chair is a bit irish", "imiz2qblO2E-00015-00005751-00006263": "pub aussie suppose he'll is down to boom", "imiz2qblO2E-00016-00006264-00006842": "with a Palestinian be chic of mcconnell", "imiz2qblO2E-00017-00006843-00010967": "air", "imiz2qblO2E-00018-00010968-00011541": "and above ishika don't let me go see it", "imiz2qblO2E-00019-00011542-00011892": "it's only because if I my god I've", "imiz2qblO2E-00020-00011893-00012184": "approached ad"}}, {"audio_id": "imjxRC4b1F8", "text": {"imjxRC4b1F8-00000-00000029-00000299": "talking in my sleep at night making", "imjxRC4b1F8-00001-00000300-00000428": "myself crazy", "imjxRC4b1F8-00002-00000429-00001180": "[Music]", "imjxRC4b1F8-00003-00001181-00002190": "[Music]", "imjxRC4b1F8-00004-00002191-00004056": "[Music]", "imjxRC4b1F8-00005-00004057-00006206": "in the morning", "imjxRC4b1F8-00006-00006207-00008097": "[Music]", "imjxRC4b1F8-00007-00008098-00008857": "[Music]", "imjxRC4b1F8-00008-00008858-00009218": "see the pattern"}}, {"audio_id": "imoanKwnZXE", "text": {"imoanKwnZXE-00000-00000173-00000902": "[Music]", "imoanKwnZXE-00001-00000903-00001019": "so", "imoanKwnZXE-00002-00001021-00003854": "[Music]", "imoanKwnZXE-00003-00003855-00004495": "swag", "imoanKwnZXE-00004-00004496-00004702": "open it", "imoanKwnZXE-00005-00004703-00008240": "[Music]", "imoanKwnZXE-00006-00008241-00012406": "[Music]", "imoanKwnZXE-00007-00012407-00013158": "[Music]", "imoanKwnZXE-00008-00013159-00013368": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "im_W9CoF5Qg", "text": {"im_W9CoF5Qg-00000-00000405-00001437": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00001-00001438-00002254": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00002-00002255-00003199": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00003-00003200-00004071": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00004-00004072-00004995": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00005-00004996-00005623": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00006-00005624-00007131": "[Applause]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00007-00007133-00008228": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00008-00008229-00017497": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00009-00017498-00019287": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00010-00019288-00021102": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00011-00021103-00021854": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00012-00021855-00022636": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00013-00022637-00030361": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00014-00030362-00033389": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00015-00033390-00035329": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00016-00035330-00036132": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00017-00036133-00041213": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00018-00041214-00046283": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00019-00046284-00048921": "is", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00020-00048922-00049593": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00021-00049594-00050483": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00022-00050484-00051563": "packer", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00023-00051564-00052070": "[Music]", "im_W9CoF5Qg-00024-00052071-00052279": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "imFOyZ8-I1c", "text": {"imFOyZ8-I1c-00000-00000000-00000935": "a few years ago when we have another", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00001-00000936-00001232": "wave of zombies coming at us in all", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00002-00001233-00001516": "different media I kept asking my friends", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00003-00001517-00001697": "what what what does this mean who are", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00004-00001698-00001834": "these zombies what's going on", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00005-00001835-00002075": "nobody had a sufficiently good answer", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00006-00002076-00002443": "for me and as you know if you want to", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00007-00002444-00002710": "learn something you teach it and I said", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00008-00002711-00002902": "I've got to learn this so here we are", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00009-00002903-00003098": "the name of the course is zombies and", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00010-00003099-00003713": "vampires in fact in fiction so there are", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00011-00003714-00003958": "these logical cognates to a lot of these", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00012-00003959-00004217": "things we see in vampire and zombie", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00013-00004218-00004391": "films totally gross", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00014-00004392-00004822": "absolutely engrossing there is actually", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00015-00004823-00005254": "a fungus that infects ant brains and", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00016-00005255-00005566": "what that makes the ant do is actually", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00017-00005567-00005920": "leave the nest crawl up to the tallest", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00018-00005921-00006191": "branch it can and then grasp the branch", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00019-00006192-00006467": "with its mandibles and stick there the", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00020-00006468-00006608": "reason why it does that is because at", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00021-00006609-00006800": "that point in time the fungus actually", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00022-00006801-00007130": "erupts from the ants head and that's how", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00023-00007131-00007653": "it spreads my favorite example is", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00024-00007654-00007996": "Dracula it turns out that one of the", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00025-00007997-00008191": "central issues in Dracula is", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00026-00008192-00008641": "transfusions and so that fits right into", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00027-00008642-00008933": "the biology or the biology fits right", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00028-00008934-00009199": "into the novel in interesting ways so it", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00029-00009200-00009470": "isn't just Count Dracula doing scary", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00030-00009471-00009698": "things it's also about the science at", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00031-00009699-00010021": "the time so we do a lot of history for", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00032-00010022-00010264": "example zombies and vampires of the 50s", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00033-00010265-00010456": "and 60s are very different from zombies", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00034-00010457-00010706": "and vampires of you know current day and", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00035-00010707-00011017": "that has a lot to do with the fears that", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00036-00011018-00011201": "people have and the fears have changed", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00037-00011202-00011531": "from the 50s yeah so where you might", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00038-00011532-00011956": "have originally Cold War fears or", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00039-00011957-00012352": "conflicts in Vietnam or in civil rights", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00040-00012353-00012710": "now you've got fears of epidemics you've", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00041-00012711-00012971": "also got fears about terrorism and", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00042-00012972-00013457": "different kinds of invasions I think all", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00043-00013458-00013553": "types of students should take this", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00044-00013554-00013793": "course literature women studies history", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00045-00013794-00014261": "political science biology chemistry I", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00046-00014262-00014525": "mean all over the map and everybody", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00047-00014526-00015329": "finds something interesting it's", "imFOyZ8-I1c-00048-00015330-00015705": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "imOEL8r_VLQ", "text": {"imOEL8r_VLQ-00000-00000008-00000182": "general grievous's life before the clone", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00001-00000183-00000438": "wars part one born as kwaimenji shaleel", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00002-00000440-00000607": "general grievous was a male kalish from", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00003-00000608-00000799": "the wild space planet khali who became a", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00004-00000800-00000991": "feared warlord and warrior was known for", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00005-00000992-00001183": "his lack of mercy and was obsessed with", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00006-00001184-00001383": "the glory gathered in war shaleel became", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00007-00001384-00001543": "one of the greatest military leaders of", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00008-00001544-00001695": "his people using his ruthless and", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00009-00001696-00001855": "uncompromising tactics to lead his", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00010-00001855-00002030": "fellow kellish warriors in the merciless", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00011-00002032-00002215": "war against the insectoid species the", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00012-00002216-00002399": "emery during this conflict he developed", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00013-00002400-00002575": "a personal vendetta against the galactic", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00014-00002576-00002718": "republic in the jedi order as the", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00015-00002719-00002879": "republic supported the emery and the", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00016-00002880-00003071": "jedi made a catastrophic intervention in", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00017-00003072-00003238": "the war in favor of the huk at some", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00018-00003239-00003422": "point the infamous kellish warrior took", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00019-00003423-00003615": "up the moniker grievous began to travel", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00020-00003615-00003790": "with a team of personal bodyguards known", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00021-00003792-00003983": "as the izvashra and started collecting", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00022-00003984-00004167": "weapons of his defeated enemies having", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00023-00004168-00004375": "cemented himself as a warlord of khalid", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00024-00004376-00004551": "grievous began to embark on conquest", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00025-00004552-00004719": "throughout space in the way of khalish", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00026-00004720-00004863": "warriors before him during his", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00027-00004864-00005047": "interplanetary exploits he came to", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00028-00005048-00005183": "realize that the jedi were nearly", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00029-00005184-00005399": "undefeatable in duels thus his contempt", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00030-00005400-00005575": "towards them grow even stronger more on", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00031-00005576-00005751": "grievous life before the clone wars in", "imOEL8r_VLQ-00032-00005752-00006164": "part two of this video series"}}, {"audio_id": "imZS0AM_FRA", "text": {"imZS0AM_FRA-00000-00000000-00000257": "we need to see the future for new", "imZS0AM_FRA-00001-00000258-00000419": "technologies we need to see how we're", "imZS0AM_FRA-00002-00000420-00000671": "going to upgrade our ground station how", "imZS0AM_FRA-00003-00000672-00000886": "we're going to even work on other", "imZS0AM_FRA-00004-00000888-00001162": "missions and other projects currently we", "imZS0AM_FRA-00005-00001163-00001415": "are working and supporting the hydron a", "imZS0AM_FRA-00006-00001416-00001726": "lot of Skylight developments the quantum", "imZS0AM_FRA-00007-00001727-00001901": "Technologies is something that is very", "imZS0AM_FRA-00008-00001902-00002129": "important for us so we are going also to", "imZS0AM_FRA-00009-00002130-00002399": "investigate that together with with ISC", "imZS0AM_FRA-00010-00002400-00002609": "but also look at technologies that are", "imZS0AM_FRA-00011-00002610-00002807": "related to ground stations that it's", "imZS0AM_FRA-00012-00002808-00003010": "like a cryogenic it's detectors it's", "imZS0AM_FRA-00013-00003011-00003311": "Electronics he's a so I'm sure there are", "imZS0AM_FRA-00014-00003311-00003485": "a lot of fields that we're going to to", "imZS0AM_FRA-00015-00003486-00003640": "work further together the optical", "imZS0AM_FRA-00016-00003642-00003881": "Communications what we do with Isa and", "imZS0AM_FRA-00017-00003882-00004085": "our ground station they have a lot of", "imZS0AM_FRA-00018-00004086-00004235": "applications starting from", "imZS0AM_FRA-00019-00004236-00004667": "telecommunication or all this r d and", "imZS0AM_FRA-00020-00004668-00004865": "commissioning of Hardware that we do", "imZS0AM_FRA-00021-00004866-00005056": "with European partners and with", "imZS0AM_FRA-00022-00005057-00005351": "companies also the space Safety and", "imZS0AM_FRA-00023-00005352-00005579": "Security where we can do investigations", "imZS0AM_FRA-00024-00005580-00005897": "for objects that come from the earth so", "imZS0AM_FRA-00025-00005898-00006154": "how to protect our environment and our", "imZS0AM_FRA-00026-00006155-00006431": "planet and also support for countries", "imZS0AM_FRA-00027-00006431-00006706": "that they don't have the means to do", "imZS0AM_FRA-00028-00006708-00006906": "this type of", "imZS0AM_FRA-00029-00006908-00007163": "optical Communications or to have the", "imZS0AM_FRA-00030-00007164-00007355": "infrastructures or like underdeveloped", "imZS0AM_FRA-00031-00007356-00007613": "countries where we can provide support", "imZS0AM_FRA-00032-00007614-00007868": "on that"}}, {"audio_id": "in5ceWFo57c", "text": {"in5ceWFo57c-00000-00000000-00001612": "thank you", "in5ceWFo57c-00001-00001613-00001852": "hey guys even here and in this video we", "in5ceWFo57c-00002-00001853-00001984": "have a couple of very interesting", "in5ceWFo57c-00003-00001985-00002201": "stories and we are starting with this", "in5ceWFo57c-00004-00002202-00002452": "one Brandon Harding now I talked about", "in5ceWFo57c-00005-00002453-00002657": "Brandon in my previous video I was", "in5ceWFo57c-00006-00002658-00002860": "talking about whether he made progress", "in5ceWFo57c-00007-00002861-00003137": "from last year or not and also whether", "in5ceWFo57c-00008-00003138-00003340": "he's going to win the pro card this", "in5ceWFo57c-00009-00003342-00003586": "season or not now if you want to watch", "in5ceWFo57c-00010-00003588-00003772": "that check out my previous video but in", "in5ceWFo57c-00011-00003773-00003856": "this video you're going to check out", "in5ceWFo57c-00012-00003857-00004061": "what he looked like at this show that he", "in5ceWFo57c-00013-00004061-00004361": "did and he didn't win the overall so he", "in5ceWFo57c-00014-00004362-00004709": "won his class but the overall was won by", "in5ceWFo57c-00015-00004710-00004883": "the guy standing next to him in this", "in5ceWFo57c-00016-00004884-00005111": "photo I am not sure if this show was", "in5ceWFo57c-00017-00005112-00005345": "even a Pro Qualifier or not but he", "in5ceWFo57c-00018-00005346-00005549": "didn't win a pro card now as you can see", "in5ceWFo57c-00019-00005550-00005783": "right here in the caption he says that", "in5ceWFo57c-00020-00005784-00006083": "his goal was to actually come in at 90", "in5ceWFo57c-00021-00006084-00006370": "percent I also listened to his coach who", "in5ceWFo57c-00022-00006371-00006581": "just did a podcast with Fu and abiad and", "in5ceWFo57c-00023-00006581-00006773": "he says that this was basically the plan", "in5ceWFo57c-00024-00006773-00007025": "they wanted Brandon to come in at the", "in5ceWFo57c-00025-00007026-00007277": "first show at about 90 so his", "in5ceWFo57c-00026-00007278-00007505": "conditioning can improve from show to", "in5ceWFo57c-00027-00007506-00007870": "show until he hopefully eventually wins", "in5ceWFo57c-00028-00007872-00008170": "that Pro card now he says here he was 90", "in5ceWFo57c-00029-00008172-00008405": "but I think it's pretty visible he", "in5ceWFo57c-00030-00008406-00008741": "didn't look 100 I'm gonna show you some", "in5ceWFo57c-00031-00008742-00008933": "footage I got a couple of videos of him", "in5ceWFo57c-00032-00008934-00009101": "from that stage but this is the photo", "in5ceWFo57c-00033-00009102-00009359": "where you can clearly see that he wasn't", "in5ceWFo57c-00034-00009360-00009605": "completely in and you can see it in his", "in5ceWFo57c-00035-00009606-00009851": "glutes I'm not saying that he needs to", "in5ceWFo57c-00036-00009852-00010067": "have super shredded glutes to be", "in5ceWFo57c-00037-00010068-00010241": "competitive in classic physique I'm just", "in5ceWFo57c-00038-00010242-00010445": "saying here you can see where", "in5ceWFo57c-00039-00010446-00010745": "conditioning wasn't 100 and I'm sure it", "in5ceWFo57c-00040-00010746-00011003": "was visible in person in other areas of", "in5ceWFo57c-00041-00011004-00011273": "his body as well also yeah it looks like", "in5ceWFo57c-00042-00011274-00011495": "he isn't even flexing those glutes right", "in5ceWFo57c-00043-00011496-00011759": "here in this side chest pose but you", "in5ceWFo57c-00044-00011760-00011963": "know side poses are usually the poses in", "in5ceWFo57c-00045-00011964-00012233": "which your glutes will look sharper even", "in5ceWFo57c-00046-00012234-00012419": "if they are not it's harder to have", "in5ceWFo57c-00047-00012420-00012635": "shredded loots from behind from the", "in5ceWFo57c-00048-00012636-00012893": "sides usually some separation is is", "in5ceWFo57c-00049-00012894-00013079": "visible even when you are not completely", "in5ceWFo57c-00050-00013080-00013366": "shredded and Brandon does know how to", "in5ceWFo57c-00051-00013368-00013565": "bring conditioning I think last year he", "in5ceWFo57c-00052-00013566-00013835": "was pretty field and this show he was", "in5ceWFo57c-00053-00013836-00014111": "okay but again he was at around 90 he", "in5ceWFo57c-00054-00014112-00014327": "definitely could have been sharper now", "in5ceWFo57c-00055-00014328-00014471": "in my last video I was talking about", "in5ceWFo57c-00056-00014472-00014669": "whether he made progress or not and I", "in5ceWFo57c-00057-00014669-00014825": "noticed some of you guys commented that", "in5ceWFo57c-00058-00014826-00015005": "he made a lot of progress in his back", "in5ceWFo57c-00059-00015006-00015215": "and I gotta say he's back definitely did", "in5ceWFo57c-00060-00015216-00015430": "look much better in the last time on", "in5ceWFo57c-00061-00015431-00015677": "stage but how much did it progress it", "in5ceWFo57c-00062-00015678-00015875": "sure progressed some but I think it was", "in5ceWFo57c-00063-00015876-00016085": "mainly posing he really knows how to", "in5ceWFo57c-00064-00016086-00016288": "present his physique how to make it look", "in5ceWFo57c-00065-00016290-00016600": "even better than it actually is and that", "in5ceWFo57c-00066-00016601-00016799": "is a really valuable thing in", "in5ceWFo57c-00067-00016800-00017003": "bodybuilding a really valuable skill I", "in5ceWFo57c-00068-00017004-00017308": "would say now in this update from two", "in5ceWFo57c-00069-00017309-00017555": "days out he said it he was 10 pounds", "in5ceWFo57c-00070-00017556-00017867": "heavier now I was trying to see where", "in5ceWFo57c-00071-00017868-00018094": "did he progress where did those 10", "in5ceWFo57c-00072-00018095-00018425": "pounds go did it all go to his back", "in5ceWFo57c-00073-00018426-00018707": "maybe well as you can see he's 90", "in5ceWFo57c-00074-00018708-00018977": "percent here so he will have to lose", "in5ceWFo57c-00075-00018978-00019355": "some more weight before he gets 100 his", "in5ceWFo57c-00076-00019356-00019750": "weight at this show was 213 pounds and", "in5ceWFo57c-00077-00019751-00020014": "he gets to weigh around 220 in the", "in5ceWFo57c-00078-00020015-00020344": "amateurs so he has seven more pounds to", "in5ceWFo57c-00079-00020345-00020555": "gain but he's probably gonna lose around", "in5ceWFo57c-00080-00020556-00020800": "5 pounds before he gets completely", "in5ceWFo57c-00081-00020801-00021022": "conditioned so how much did he actually", "in5ceWFo57c-00082-00021023-00021233": "progress well if you speak about the", "in5ceWFo57c-00083-00021234-00021467": "numbers he gained probably around five", "in5ceWFo57c-00084-00021468-00021719": "pounds of muscle which is a lot it's not", "in5ceWFo57c-00085-00021720-00021905": "crazy it's not like Hunter Labrada", "in5ceWFo57c-00086-00021906-00022150": "adding 20 pounds over a course of a year", "in5ceWFo57c-00087-00022151-00022378": "or Nick Walker whatever he did you know", "in5ceWFo57c-00088-00022379-00022553": "he's a classic guy he doesn't have those", "in5ceWFo57c-00089-00022554-00022805": "crazy genetics so five pounds for a guy", "in5ceWFo57c-00090-00022806-00023080": "like him over a course of a year is you", "in5ceWFo57c-00091-00023081-00023321": "know okay it's like average I don't know", "in5ceWFo57c-00092-00023322-00023555": "how much work that he actually put in in", "in5ceWFo57c-00093-00023556-00023825": "that of season but five pounds is like", "in5ceWFo57c-00094-00023826-00024071": "pretty realistic it's not great it's not", "in5ceWFo57c-00095-00024072-00024371": "terrible either so as I said he was 213", "in5ceWFo57c-00096-00024372-00024580": "pounds here let's say he loses five", "in5ceWFo57c-00097-00024581-00024713": "pounds before he gets completely", "in5ceWFo57c-00098-00024714-00025025": "shredded that's 208 pounds which means", "in5ceWFo57c-00099-00025026-00025264": "he has 12 pounds to gain before he", "in5ceWFo57c-00100-00025265-00025450": "reaches the weight cap in classic", "in5ceWFo57c-00101-00025451-00025774": "Physique in amateur first and then on", "in5ceWFo57c-00102-00025775-00026014": "top of that he has another 10 pounds to", "in5ceWFo57c-00103-00026016-00026351": "gain once he turns Pro so that's 22", "in5ceWFo57c-00104-00026352-00026596": "pounds to gain before he's actually a", "in5ceWFo57c-00105-00026597-00026807": "seriously competitive classic physique", "in5ceWFo57c-00106-00026808-00027064": "Pro if he has the right structure and if", "in5ceWFo57c-00107-00027066-00027299": "he actually maxes out his weight he's", "in5ceWFo57c-00108-00027300-00027437": "going to be I think he's going to be", "in5ceWFo57c-00109-00027438-00027593": "great I think he has all the structure", "in5ceWFo57c-00110-00027594-00027785": "but obviously his muscle building", "in5ceWFo57c-00111-00027786-00028055": "genetics aren't exactly extraordinary", "in5ceWFo57c-00112-00028056-00028258": "you can watch his YouTube videos where", "in5ceWFo57c-00113-00028260-00028540": "he talks about his Cycles openly and he", "in5ceWFo57c-00114-00028541-00028733": "is doing way more than for example Chris", "in5ceWFo57c-00115-00028733-00029045": "Bumstead who is who is gaining muscle so", "in5ceWFo57c-00116-00029045-00029243": "easily so he Brandon is definitely not", "in5ceWFo57c-00117-00029244-00029477": "that kind of a genetic freak he does", "in5ceWFo57c-00118-00029477-00029651": "have the right structure he has all the", "in5ceWFo57c-00119-00029652-00029837": "tools basically he's just gonna take him", "in5ceWFo57c-00120-00029838-00030029": "a little bit longer it's gonna take some", "in5ceWFo57c-00121-00030030-00030233": "more time take a look at this video so", "in5ceWFo57c-00122-00030233-00030377": "this is what I'm saying he has the right", "in5ceWFo57c-00123-00030377-00030545": "structure he has a very good looking", "in5ceWFo57c-00124-00030545-00030814": "shape actually and I'm sure look at the", "in5ceWFo57c-00125-00030816-00030970": "glutes here when he flexes them so yeah", "in5ceWFo57c-00126-00030972-00031211": "his loads were okay when he flexes them", "in5ceWFo57c-00127-00031212-00031385": "still they could have been sharper but", "in5ceWFo57c-00128-00031386-00031601": "his conditioning is okay the back", "in5ceWFo57c-00129-00031602-00031781": "definitely does look better but I think", "in5ceWFo57c-00130-00031782-00032074": "it's mainly a posing Improvement so this", "in5ceWFo57c-00131-00032075-00032249": "guy he really knows how to pose you know", "in5ceWFo57c-00132-00032250-00032573": "in an artistic classic way but still he", "in5ceWFo57c-00133-00032574-00032824": "knows how to present his Physique in the", "in5ceWFo57c-00134-00032825-00033124": "best light possible and again he has a", "in5ceWFo57c-00135-00033125-00033293": "pretty good structure he reminds me of", "in5ceWFo57c-00136-00033294-00033490": "Logan Franklin a little bit a smaller", "in5ceWFo57c-00137-00033491-00033695": "version of Logan Franklin and I think he", "in5ceWFo57c-00138-00033696-00033911": "has even more potential than Logan if he", "in5ceWFo57c-00139-00033912-00034139": "adds all that muscle which I'm sure he", "in5ceWFo57c-00140-00034140-00034355": "is going to do over the course of the", "in5ceWFo57c-00141-00034356-00034571": "upcoming gears I'm sure he can do it as", "in5ceWFo57c-00142-00034572-00034805": "long as he stays consistent and with", "in5ceWFo57c-00143-00034806-00035002": "this structure I think he actually has a", "in5ceWFo57c-00144-00035003-00035231": "good potential to be eventually like a", "in5ceWFo57c-00145-00035232-00035489": "top 10 Olympian in classic physique", "in5ceWFo57c-00146-00035490-00035699": "better than that like top six or", "in5ceWFo57c-00147-00035700-00035873": "something like that who the hell knows", "in5ceWFo57c-00148-00035874-00036089": "who can predict something like that do I", "in5ceWFo57c-00149-00036090-00036346": "see him being an Olympian one day I", "in5ceWFo57c-00150-00036347-00036533": "think I do I think he has all the tools", "in5ceWFo57c-00151-00036534-00036749": "necessary it's gonna take him some time", "in5ceWFo57c-00152-00036750-00037073": "can he turn pro this year this season", "in5ceWFo57c-00153-00037074-00037312": "though well that's definitely a tough", "in5ceWFo57c-00154-00037313-00037529": "question it depends on who else shows up", "in5ceWFo57c-00155-00037530-00037751": "he needs to be a little a bit lucky if", "in5ceWFo57c-00156-00037752-00037955": "you ask me for example this guy right", "in5ceWFo57c-00157-00037956-00038117": "here beat him not only because of", "in5ceWFo57c-00158-00038118-00038345": "conditioning yeah he was sharper but he", "in5ceWFo57c-00159-00038346-00038573": "has more muscle you know I think it's", "in5ceWFo57c-00160-00038574-00038830": "mainly visible in the in the legs and", "in5ceWFo57c-00161-00038831-00039046": "also in the arms look at a leg roundness", "in5ceWFo57c-00162-00039047-00039305": "here I mean it wasn't that big of a", "in5ceWFo57c-00163-00039306-00039527": "difference but still the guy had more", "in5ceWFo57c-00164-00039528-00039767": "muscle and there will be more guys like", "in5ceWFo57c-00165-00039768-00040012": "that many more guys like that who maxed", "in5ceWFo57c-00166-00040013-00040193": "out their their classic physique weight", "in5ceWFo57c-00167-00040194-00040468": "cap but we all know that it's not all", "in5ceWFo57c-00168-00040469-00040649": "about the weight if you have a better", "in5ceWFo57c-00169-00040650-00040835": "structure if you have a better shape", "in5ceWFo57c-00170-00040836-00041015": "you're gonna look more impressive you're", "in5ceWFo57c-00171-00041016-00041212": "gonna look more classic and you will", "in5ceWFo57c-00172-00041213-00041458": "beat bigger guys than you can Brandon", "in5ceWFo57c-00173-00041459-00041795": "win that Pro card this year in 2022 tell", "in5ceWFo57c-00174-00041796-00041962": "me in the comment section guys what do", "in5ceWFo57c-00175-00041963-00042185": "you think if you guys are having trouble", "in5ceWFo57c-00176-00042186-00042407": "staying focused during the workout or", "in5ceWFo57c-00177-00042408-00042557": "you think you could bring it to another", "in5ceWFo57c-00178-00042558-00042767": "level as far as intensity and effort", "in5ceWFo57c-00179-00042768-00043012": "which I'm sure everybody can improve I", "in5ceWFo57c-00180-00043013-00043193": "will suggest to you vintage blast", "in5ceWFo57c-00181-00043194-00043402": "pre-workout by the old school Labs the", "in5ceWFo57c-00182-00043403-00043624": "link is down below you can choose one of", "in5ceWFo57c-00183-00043625-00043846": "so many great flavors and if you use my", "in5ceWFo57c-00184-00043847-00044177": "code even you get a 15 discount also if", "in5ceWFo57c-00185-00044178-00044357": "you guys want to support my channel by", "in5ceWFo57c-00186-00044358-00044555": "doing more than a liking and subscribing", "in5ceWFo57c-00187-00044556-00044717": "which is also a great help but if you", "in5ceWFo57c-00188-00044718-00044915": "want to do something extra this will", "in5ceWFo57c-00189-00044916-00045089": "definitely be of a great help so thank", "in5ceWFo57c-00190-00045090-00045329": "you guys alright next let's talk about", "in5ceWFo57c-00191-00045330-00045695": "our current Mr Olympia Champion big", "in5ceWFo57c-00192-00045696-00045935": "Grammy with a most recent physique", "in5ceWFo57c-00193-00045936-00046235": "update yes another one posted by Dennis", "in5ceWFo57c-00194-00046236-00046439": "James we have some training footage as", "in5ceWFo57c-00195-00046440-00046715": "well but as you can see right here at 16", "in5ceWFo57c-00196-00046716-00047008": "freaking weeks out of Mr Olympia big Ram", "in5ceWFo57c-00197-00047009-00047189": "is pretty much in shape as you can see", "in5ceWFo57c-00198-00047190-00047405": "Milo Charter says his conditioning is", "in5ceWFo57c-00199-00047406-00047771": "good for four weeks out so if he looked", "in5ceWFo57c-00200-00047772-00047927": "like this at four weeks out you would be", "in5ceWFo57c-00201-00047928-00048118": "like okay that's fine line he can get", "in5ceWFo57c-00202-00048119-00048323": "peeled in four weeks and I will agree", "in5ceWFo57c-00203-00048324-00048515": "with that he definitely does look very", "in5ceWFo57c-00204-00048516-00048808": "conditioned I mean big Grammy his issue", "in5ceWFo57c-00205-00048809-00049049": "is conditioning but right now he is", "in5ceWFo57c-00206-00049050-00049307": "really lean and it looks like he stayed", "in5ceWFo57c-00207-00049308-00049618": "very lean and he stayed very focused on", "in5ceWFo57c-00208-00049619-00049739": "training on knitting and everything", "in5ceWFo57c-00209-00049740-00050021": "throughout the entire year so this might", "in5ceWFo57c-00210-00050022-00050368": "actually be the best version of big Remy", "in5ceWFo57c-00211-00050369-00050639": "that we ever saw like Chad Nichols", "in5ceWFo57c-00212-00050640-00050890": "announced and Chad Nichols announced", "in5ceWFo57c-00213-00050891-00051161": "something similar about Ronnie and he", "in5ceWFo57c-00214-00051162-00051352": "was right that time is he gonna be right", "in5ceWFo57c-00215-00051353-00051664": "again I don't know we'll see but it", "in5ceWFo57c-00216-00051665-00051904": "looks like big Ram is not going anywhere", "in5ceWFo57c-00217-00051905-00052211": "from that Mr Olympia first spot I don't", "in5ceWFo57c-00218-00052212-00052379": "think the politics the fact that he", "in5ceWFo57c-00219-00052379-00052576": "skipped that Pittsburgh progress posing", "in5ceWFo57c-00220-00052577-00052780": "or anything like that can can really", "in5ceWFo57c-00221-00052782-00053050": "stop him from winning again and the", "in5ceWFo57c-00222-00053051-00053309": "other competitors I don't think any of", "in5ceWFo57c-00223-00053310-00053585": "them are really as complete as big and", "in5ceWFo57c-00224-00053586-00053813": "as good as big Grammys so I don't really", "in5ceWFo57c-00225-00053814-00054149": "see anybody challenging Grammy this year", "in5ceWFo57c-00226-00054150-00054376": "he's pretty established up there as long", "in5ceWFo57c-00227-00054377-00054607": "as he brings at least like 90", "in5ceWFo57c-00228-00054608-00054904": "conditioning he's probably gonna win so", "in5ceWFo57c-00229-00054905-00055073": "as you can see right here once again he", "in5ceWFo57c-00230-00055074-00055288": "is very lean I mean he has a proper", "in5ceWFo57c-00231-00055289-00055523": "eight pack you can see all the ABS and", "in5ceWFo57c-00232-00055524-00055732": "they are really prominent you can see", "in5ceWFo57c-00233-00055733-00055919": "the conditioning especially in that", "in5ceWFo57c-00234-00055920-00056213": "chest shoulder area where he really has", "in5ceWFo57c-00235-00056214-00056494": "some really nice separation some cuts", "in5ceWFo57c-00236-00056495-00056759": "his skin looks very thin you can see a", "in5ceWFo57c-00237-00056760-00056987": "lot of vascularity so I'm pretty sure", "in5ceWFo57c-00238-00056988-00057250": "big Ram is probably gonna bring the best", "in5ceWFo57c-00239-00057251-00057616": "conditioning we ever saw this year and I", "in5ceWFo57c-00240-00057617-00057821": "really doubt that they would play with", "in5ceWFo57c-00241-00057822-00058030": "his size you know I don't think Chad", "in5ceWFo57c-00242-00058032-00058271": "Nichols would downsize big Grammy for", "in5ceWFo57c-00243-00058272-00058511": "the sake of conditioning Chris aceto", "in5ceWFo57c-00244-00058512-00058859": "though did that to be Grammy in 2016 and", "in5ceWFo57c-00245-00058860-00059176": "big Remy didn't didn't look you know as", "in5ceWFo57c-00246-00059177-00059404": "as big Remy usually does he was", "in5ceWFo57c-00247-00059405-00059591": "obviously downsized he was a little bit", "in5ceWFo57c-00248-00059591-00059873": "sharper I mean he was more conditioned I", "in5ceWFo57c-00249-00059874-00060059": "have to say he was conditioned patient", "in5ceWFo57c-00250-00060060-00060341": "but wasn't worth it wasn't worth it for", "in5ceWFo57c-00251-00060341-00060599": "the Lost size it just didn't look right", "in5ceWFo57c-00252-00060600-00060875": "it didn't look like big Remy that we all", "in5ceWFo57c-00253-00060876-00061091": "knew and I remember watching Louis Marco", "in5ceWFo57c-00254-00061091-00061282": "at a time when Louis Marco was trolling", "in5ceWFo57c-00255-00061283-00061456": "big Grammy he was calling him medium", "in5ceWFo57c-00256-00061457-00061691": "Remy and I remember him saying that big", "in5ceWFo57c-00257-00061691-00061966": "Remy didn't like that at all he was mad", "in5ceWFo57c-00258-00061967-00062182": "at Louis Marco for calling him medium", "in5ceWFo57c-00259-00062183-00062465": "Remy and that was the the last and the", "in5ceWFo57c-00260-00062466-00062765": "only year of medium rammy after that he", "in5ceWFo57c-00261-00062766-00063011": "got much bigger 2017 he plays second", "in5ceWFo57c-00262-00063012-00063280": "after Phil hit so in order for big Ramy", "in5ceWFo57c-00263-00063282-00063587": "to be impressive he needs to live up to", "in5ceWFo57c-00264-00063588-00063856": "his name he needs to be big here's", "in5ceWFo57c-00265-00063857-00064049": "another photo that also Dennis James", "in5ceWFo57c-00266-00064050-00064330": "posted so again his conditioning looks", "in5ceWFo57c-00267-00064332-00064576": "great for 16 weeks out and if he is", "in5ceWFo57c-00268-00064577-00064804": "maintaining this without too much effort", "in5ceWFo57c-00269-00064805-00064949": "they're just gonna Cruise until the Mr", "in5ceWFo57c-00270-00064950-00065291": "Olympia get him slowly harder and drier", "in5ceWFo57c-00271-00065291-00065537": "while maybe even making more progress", "in5ceWFo57c-00272-00065538-00065806": "getting him even bigger more muscular so", "in5ceWFo57c-00273-00065807-00066005": "I'm expecting to see something really", "in5ceWFo57c-00274-00066006-00066311": "impressive this year again if he doesn't", "in5ceWFo57c-00275-00066312-00066544": "bring at least 90 percent he has a", "in5ceWFo57c-00276-00066545-00066767": "chance of losing and I think last year", "in5ceWFo57c-00277-00066768-00067025": "he wasn't at his best they still gave it", "in5ceWFo57c-00278-00067026-00067259": "to him like they gave to Jay Cutler in", "in5ceWFo57c-00279-00067260-00067432": "2007 even though he probably didn't", "in5ceWFo57c-00280-00067433-00067637": "deserve it however big Grammy did", "in5ceWFo57c-00281-00067638-00067841": "deserve it I think but it wasn't a", "in5ceWFo57c-00282-00067842-00068117": "clear-cut win and if he fails with", "in5ceWFo57c-00283-00068118-00068338": "conditioning or anything this year they", "in5ceWFo57c-00284-00068339-00068494": "will probably take it away from him like", "in5ceWFo57c-00285-00068495-00068687": "they took it away from Jay so in order", "in5ceWFo57c-00286-00068688-00068963": "to ensure him staying at the top he", "in5ceWFo57c-00287-00068964-00069131": "needs to bring he needs to bring", "in5ceWFo57c-00288-00069132-00069335": "something good and I think that's", "in5ceWFo57c-00289-00069336-00069515": "exactly what he plans on doing", "in5ceWFo57c-00290-00069516-00069731": "I'm really curious though what do you", "in5ceWFo57c-00291-00069732-00070067": "think is there anybody in that let's say", "in5ceWFo57c-00292-00070068-00070355": "top six or even top 10 potentially", "in5ceWFo57c-00293-00070356-00070588": "challenging big Grammys seriously this", "in5ceWFo57c-00294-00070589-00070829": "year I don't know Nick Walker had a", "in5ceWFo57c-00295-00070830-00071159": "Japan Brandon Curry William bonak Andrew", "in5ceWFo57c-00296-00071160-00071453": "jacked do you guys see anybody really", "in5ceWFo57c-00297-00071454-00071632": "challenging and beating big Remy this", "in5ceWFo57c-00298-00071633-00071837": "year or do you think big Ram will stand", "in5ceWFo57c-00299-00071838-00072035": "atop even this year whatever your", "in5ceWFo57c-00300-00072036-00072149": "thoughts are guys tell me the comment", "in5ceWFo57c-00301-00072150-00072371": "section down below alright next we have", "in5ceWFo57c-00302-00072372-00072694": "Ur skeletonski also at 16 weeks out of", "in5ceWFo57c-00303-00072695-00072917": "Mr Olympia giving us a proper physique", "in5ceWFo57c-00304-00072918-00073162": "update so as you can see he looks pretty", "in5ceWFo57c-00305-00073163-00073373": "big right I mean he looks pretty huge", "in5ceWFo57c-00306-00073374-00073612": "I'm sure this guy maxed out his weight", "in5ceWFo57c-00307-00073613-00073967": "in IBB pro league compare this size to", "in5ceWFo57c-00308-00073968-00074147": "to that of Brandon Harding for example", "in5ceWFo57c-00309-00074148-00074362": "it's not even comparable I mean this guy", "in5ceWFo57c-00310-00074363-00074662": "is so big so massive he could do the", "in5ceWFo57c-00311-00074663-00074873": "open if you really wanted to I'm not", "in5ceWFo57c-00312-00074874-00075035": "sure how much he's pushing his body", "in5ceWFo57c-00313-00075036-00075256": "right now in order to be this big but if", "in5ceWFo57c-00314-00075257-00075467": "he wanted to I'm sure he could probably", "in5ceWFo57c-00315-00075468-00075694": "do Duty open I don't know if he has a", "in5ceWFo57c-00316-00075695-00075850": "structure for it because his arms are", "in5ceWFo57c-00317-00075851-00076091": "kind of small but he has the ability to", "in5ceWFo57c-00318-00076092-00076379": "grow muscle that's for sure now as far", "in5ceWFo57c-00319-00076380-00076649": "as conditioning he he stayed very lean", "in5ceWFo57c-00320-00076650-00076859": "in the off season and I think this is", "in5ceWFo57c-00321-00076860-00077105": "great conditioning for 16 weeks out I", "in5ceWFo57c-00322-00077106-00077315": "have no doubt that he will be peeled as", "in5ceWFo57c-00323-00077316-00077543": "he usually is as he was at the Arrow", "in5ceWFo57c-00324-00077544-00077776": "Classic he was shredded I think he was", "in5ceWFo57c-00325-00077777-00077962": "probably a little bit too flat because", "in5ceWFo57c-00326-00077963-00078179": "he went a little bit overboard so I'm", "in5ceWFo57c-00327-00078180-00078335": "sure he'll fix that mistake for the Mr", "in5ceWFo57c-00328-00078336-00078550": "Olympian maybe this time around he will", "in5ceWFo57c-00329-00078551-00078767": "manage to beat somebody like Ramon Dino", "in5ceWFo57c-00330-00078768-00079019": "or Terence Ruffin but I don't think I", "in5ceWFo57c-00331-00079020-00079300": "can see that personally I have ramondino", "in5ceWFo57c-00332-00079301-00079523": "placing a head of wars and probably", "in5ceWFo57c-00333-00079524-00079841": "parents as well I think Orcs is probably", "in5ceWFo57c-00334-00079842-00080056": "going to be around the top four", "in5ceWFo57c-00335-00080057-00080321": "which I mean is a phenomenal achievement", "in5ceWFo57c-00336-00080322-00080494": "being top four in the world on classic", "in5ceWFo57c-00337-00080495-00080669": "physique that's that's freaking insane", "in5ceWFo57c-00338-00080670-00080969": "but like to be higher than that he would", "in5ceWFo57c-00339-00080970-00081173": "have to beat some of the really really", "in5ceWFo57c-00340-00081174-00081394": "talented guys like Ramon Dino Terence", "in5ceWFo57c-00341-00081395-00081575": "Ruff and Chris Brown said and there are", "in5ceWFo57c-00342-00081576-00081785": "some new guys who are looking really", "in5ceWFo57c-00343-00081786-00082049": "promising like uh that guy his ig name", "in5ceWFo57c-00344-00082050-00082343": "is classy FM his name is Fabian also", "in5ceWFo57c-00345-00082344-00082594": "Gabriella zanzanelli the Brazilian guy", "in5ceWFo57c-00346-00082595-00082882": "so there is a lot of new Talent knocking", "in5ceWFo57c-00347-00082883-00083099": "at the door trying to crack that top", "in5ceWFo57c-00348-00083100-00083417": "five top six so ORS has to bring his", "in5ceWFo57c-00349-00083418-00083693": "absolute best ever in order to just stay", "in5ceWFo57c-00350-00083694-00083909": "in that top four which I think he will", "in5ceWFo57c-00351-00083910-00084131": "succeed I think he is that good whatever", "in5ceWFo57c-00352-00084132-00084287": "you guys think though tell me in the", "in5ceWFo57c-00353-00084288-00084418": "comment section down below like this", "in5ceWFo57c-00354-00084419-00084575": "video If you enjoyed it and for more", "in5ceWFo57c-00355-00084576-00084725": "bodybuilding content like this subscribe", "in5ceWFo57c-00356-00084726-00084856": "to my channel guys thank you so much for", "in5ceWFo57c-00357-00084857-00085201": "watching all the best and bye bye"}}, {"audio_id": "inwp0BvOKDE", "text": {"inwp0BvOKDE-00000-00000000-00000340": "what is Medigap in Maine medigap helps", "inwp0BvOKDE-00001-00000341-00000518": "fill in the financial gaps where", "inwp0BvOKDE-00002-00000519-00000805": "medicare leaves off in most cases", "inwp0BvOKDE-00003-00000806-00001075": "medicare pays about 80% of your medical", "inwp0BvOKDE-00004-00001076-00001408": "expenses leaving you a gap a medigap a", "inwp0BvOKDE-00005-00001409-00001634": "medigap plan focuses on the", "inwp0BvOKDE-00006-00001635-00001807": "out-of-pocket expenses such as", "inwp0BvOKDE-00007-00001809-00002110": "copayments coinsurance and deductibles", "inwp0BvOKDE-00008-00002111-00002420": "of medicare part a and b medicare has", "inwp0BvOKDE-00009-00002421-00002729": "several parts for coverage Part A Part B", "inwp0BvOKDE-00010-00002730-00003322": "Part C and Part D and the Medigap plans", "inwp0BvOKDE-00011-00003322-00003601": "once an individual turns 65 they may", "inwp0BvOKDE-00012-00003602-00003769": "qualify for certain Medicare benefits", "inwp0BvOKDE-00013-00003770-00003942": "and services", "inwp0BvOKDE-00014-00003943-00004197": "Medigap insurance can start as soon as", "inwp0BvOKDE-00015-00004198-00004530": "Part B coverage is in place Medicare", "inwp0BvOKDE-00016-00004531-00004692": "Part A helps cover against catastrophic", "inwp0BvOKDE-00017-00004693-00004922": "events in patient care in hospital", "inwp0BvOKDE-00018-00004923-00005241": "skilled nursing facility hospice and", "inwp0BvOKDE-00019-00005242-00005511": "home health care an average knee", "inwp0BvOKDE-00020-00005512-00005703": "replacement hip replacement or heart", "inwp0BvOKDE-00021-00005704-00005907": "attack can cost you forty thousand", "inwp0BvOKDE-00022-00005908-00006117": "dollars or more in most cases leaving", "inwp0BvOKDE-00023-00006118-00006363": "you with eight thousand dollars or more", "inwp0BvOKDE-00024-00006364-00006651": "to pay let Medigap help cover that risk", "inwp0BvOKDE-00025-00006652-00006966": "for you Medicare Part B helps cover", "inwp0BvOKDE-00026-00006967-00007215": "doctors and other health care provided", "inwp0BvOKDE-00027-00007216-00007463": "services Hospital out patient care", "inwp0BvOKDE-00028-00007464-00007683": "durable medical equipment and home", "inwp0BvOKDE-00029-00007684-00007956": "health care also many preventive", "inwp0BvOKDE-00030-00007956-00008120": "services to help maintain your health", "inwp0BvOKDE-00031-00008122-00008321": "and keep certain illnesses from getting", "inwp0BvOKDE-00032-00008322-00008679": "worse Part D Medicare helps lower and", "inwp0BvOKDE-00033-00008680-00008931": "cover your drug prescription costs let's", "inwp0BvOKDE-00034-00008932-00009207": "not forget about Part C Part C or", "inwp0BvOKDE-00035-00009208-00009399": "Medicare Advantage health plan options", "inwp0BvOKDE-00036-00009400-00009594": "run by Medicare approved private", "inwp0BvOKDE-00037-00009595-00009915": "insurance companies offer benefits and", "inwp0BvOKDE-00038-00009916-00010224": "services covered in Part A Part B and", "inwp0BvOKDE-00039-00010225-00010488": "usually Part D some of these Advantage", "inwp0BvOKDE-00040-00010489-00010764": "plans may offer extra benefits for extra", "inwp0BvOKDE-00041-00010765-00010968": "costs and may offer maximum coverage", "inwp0BvOKDE-00042-00010969-00011163": "with no need for additional supplement", "inwp0BvOKDE-00043-00011164-00011396": "but for those that do get maximum", "inwp0BvOKDE-00044-00011397-00011655": "coverage with Medigap please feel free", "inwp0BvOKDE-00045-00011656-00011810": "to pause the video to view some basic", "inwp0BvOKDE-00046-00011811-00012150": "Medigap plans in me"}}, {"audio_id": "inaviyCzpvc", "text": {"inaviyCzpvc-00000-00000051-00000413": "the PlayStation 3 system software as the", "inaviyCzpvc-00001-00000413-00000719": "updatable firmware an operating system", "inaviyCzpvc-00002-00000720-00001141": "of the PlayStation 3 the base operating", "inaviyCzpvc-00003-00001142-00001468": "used by Sony for the PlayStation 3 as a", "inaviyCzpvc-00004-00001469-00001885": "fork of both FreeBSD and any T BSD", "inaviyCzpvc-00005-00001886-00002282": "called chela's the process of updating", "inaviyCzpvc-00006-00002283-00002579": "is almost identical to that of the", "inaviyCzpvc-00007-00002580-00002873": "PlayStation Portable PlayStation Vita", "inaviyCzpvc-00008-00002874-00003281": "and PlayStation 4 the software may be", "inaviyCzpvc-00009-00003282-00003536": "updated by downloading the update", "inaviyCzpvc-00010-00003536-00003781": "directly on the PlayStation 3", "inaviyCzpvc-00011-00003782-00004031": "downloading it from the users local", "inaviyCzpvc-00012-00004032-00004409": "official PlayStation website to a PC and", "inaviyCzpvc-00013-00004410-00004768": "using a USB storage device to transfer", "inaviyCzpvc-00014-00004769-00005059": "it to the PlayStation 3 or installing", "inaviyCzpvc-00015-00005060-00005281": "the update from game disks containing", "inaviyCzpvc-00016-00005282-00005857": "update data the initial slim ps3 SKU", "inaviyCzpvc-00017-00005858-00006100": "shipped with a unique firmware with new", "inaviyCzpvc-00018-00006101-00007103": "features also seen in software 3.0 0", "inaviyCzpvc-00019-00007104-00007681": "topic technology", "inaviyCzpvc-00020-00007681-00008033": "you", "inaviyCzpvc-00021-00008034-00008545": "topic system", "inaviyCzpvc-00022-00008546-00008833": "the native operating system of the", "inaviyCzpvc-00023-00008834-00009118": "PlayStation 3 as chela's which is", "inaviyCzpvc-00024-00009119-00009556": "believed to be a fork of FreeBSD tcp/ip", "inaviyCzpvc-00025-00009557-00009874": "stack fingerprinting identifies of", "inaviyCzpvc-00026-00009875-00010264": "PlayStation 3 as running FreeBSD and the", "inaviyCzpvc-00027-00010265-00010558": "PlayStation 3 is known to contain code", "inaviyCzpvc-00028-00010559-00011029": "from FreeBSD and n et BSD the 3d", "inaviyCzpvc-00029-00011030-00011428": "computer graphics API software used in", "inaviyCzpvc-00030-00011429-00011893": "the PlayStation 3 as Li BGC m and PS GL", "inaviyCzpvc-00031-00011894-00012363": "based on open --gel s and invidious CG l", "inaviyCzpvc-00032-00012364-00012919": "ib GCM as a low-level api and PS GL as a", "inaviyCzpvc-00033-00012919-00013021": "higher-level", "inaviyCzpvc-00034-00013022-00013360": "api but most developers preferred to use", "inaviyCzpvc-00035-00013361-00013702": "li b GC m due to higher levels of", "inaviyCzpvc-00036-00013703-00014072": "performance this is similar to the later", "inaviyCzpvc-00037-00014073-00014443": "PlayStation 4 console which also has two", "inaviyCzpvc-00038-00014444-00014782": "api's the low level G and M and the", "inaviyCzpvc-00039-00014783-00015085": "higher level G and M X unlike the", "inaviyCzpvc-00040-00015086-00015466": "software development kit sdk for mobile", "inaviyCzpvc-00041-00015466-00015871": "apps Sony's PlayStation 3 SDK is only", "inaviyCzpvc-00042-00015872-00016153": "available to registered game development", "inaviyCzpvc-00043-00016154-00016453": "companies and contains software tools", "inaviyCzpvc-00044-00016454-00016843": "and an integrated hardware component due", "inaviyCzpvc-00045-00016844-00017125": "to the fact that it requires a licensing", "inaviyCzpvc-00046-00017126-00017389": "agreement with Sony which is considered", "inaviyCzpvc-00047-00017390-00017677": "expensive a number of open source and", "inaviyCzpvc-00048-00017678-00018064": "homebrew ps3 SDKs are available in", "inaviyCzpvc-00049-00018065-00018969": "addition to a number of leaked ps3 SDKs", "inaviyCzpvc-00050-00018970-00019552": "topic graphical shell", "inaviyCzpvc-00051-00019553-00019924": "the PlayStation 3 uses the extras media", "inaviyCzpvc-00052-00019925-00020332": "bar XMB as its graphical user interface", "inaviyCzpvc-00053-00020333-00020620": "which is also used in the PlayStation", "inaviyCzpvc-00054-00020621-00021052": "Portable PSP handheld console a variety", "inaviyCzpvc-00055-00021053-00021451": "of sony bravia HD TVs blu-ray disc", "inaviyCzpvc-00056-00021452-00021937": "players and many more Sony products XMB", "inaviyCzpvc-00057-00021938-00022252": "displays icons horizontally across the", "inaviyCzpvc-00058-00022253-00022681": "screen that be seen as categories users", "inaviyCzpvc-00059-00022682-00022927": "can navigate through them using the left", "inaviyCzpvc-00060-00022928-00023169": "and right buttons of the d-pad which", "inaviyCzpvc-00061-00023170-00023461": "move the icons forward or back across", "inaviyCzpvc-00062-00023462-00023728": "the screen highlighting just one at a", "inaviyCzpvc-00063-00023729-00024031": "time as opposed to using any kind of", "inaviyCzpvc-00064-00024032-00024385": "pointer to select an option when one", "inaviyCzpvc-00065-00024386-00024694": "category is selected there are usually", "inaviyCzpvc-00066-00024695-00024972": "more specific options then available to", "inaviyCzpvc-00067-00024973-00025237": "select that are spread vertically above", "inaviyCzpvc-00068-00025238-00025639": "and below the selected icon users may", "inaviyCzpvc-00069-00025639-00025912": "navigate among these options by using", "inaviyCzpvc-00070-00025913-00026320": "the up and down buttons of the d-pad the", "inaviyCzpvc-00071-00026320-00026625": "basic features offered by XMB", "inaviyCzpvc-00072-00026626-00026899": "implementations varies based on device", "inaviyCzpvc-00073-00026900-00027262": "and software version apart from those", "inaviyCzpvc-00074-00027263-00027595": "appearing in the PSP console such as", "inaviyCzpvc-00075-00027595-00027939": "category icons for photos music and", "inaviyCzpvc-00076-00027941-00028408": "games the ps3 added users TV and friends", "inaviyCzpvc-00077-00028408-00028930": "to the XMB also XMB offers a degree of", "inaviyCzpvc-00078-00028931-00029338": "multitasking in-game XMB features were", "inaviyCzpvc-00079-00029339-00029650": "added to the ps3 properly with firmware", "inaviyCzpvc-00080-00029651-00030036": "version 2.4 one after causing early", "inaviyCzpvc-00081-00030037-00030493": "implementation problems while XMB proved", "inaviyCzpvc-00082-00030494-00030783": "to be a successful user interface for", "inaviyCzpvc-00083-00030785-00031210": "sony products such as PSP and ps3 the", "inaviyCzpvc-00084-00031211-00031561": "next generation sony video game consoles", "inaviyCzpvc-00085-00031562-00031815": "such as the PlayStation 4 and the", "inaviyCzpvc-00086-00031816-00032115": "PlayStation Vita no longer use this user", "inaviyCzpvc-00087-00032116-00032395": "interface", "inaviyCzpvc-00088-00032396-00032722": "you", "inaviyCzpvc-00089-00032723-00033497": "topic cooperation with handheld consoles", "inaviyCzpvc-00090-00033498-00033851": "the PlayStation 3 supports remote play", "inaviyCzpvc-00091-00033852-00034163": "with Sony's handheld game consoles the", "inaviyCzpvc-00092-00034164-00034454": "PlayStation Portable and the PlayStation", "inaviyCzpvc-00093-00034455-00034549": "Vita", "inaviyCzpvc-00094-00034550-00034885": "however unlike remote play between the", "inaviyCzpvc-00095-00034886-00035180": "PlayStation 4 and the PlayStation Vita", "inaviyCzpvc-00096-00035181-00035522": "the problem with ps3 was that it only", "inaviyCzpvc-00097-00035523-00035906": "supported a select few titles and", "inaviyCzpvc-00098-00035907-00036278": "results were often laggy however it is", "inaviyCzpvc-00099-00036279-00036611": "clear that remote play with the ps3 was", "inaviyCzpvc-00100-00036612-00036839": "the testing bed for it's much better", "inaviyCzpvc-00101-00036840-00037229": "integration with the ps4 also for users", "inaviyCzpvc-00102-00037230-00037514": "having both the PlayStation 3 and the", "inaviyCzpvc-00103-00037515-00037823": "PlayStation Vita it is possible to share", "inaviyCzpvc-00104-00037824-00038144": "media files videos music and images", "inaviyCzpvc-00105-00038145-00038414": "between them by transferring multimedia", "inaviyCzpvc-00106-00038415-00038750": "files directly from the PlayStation 3 to", "inaviyCzpvc-00107-00038751-00039082": "the PlayStation Vita or vice versa", "inaviyCzpvc-00108-00039083-00039335": "furthermore they can use a service", "inaviyCzpvc-00109-00039336-00039602": "called cross-buy which allows them to", "inaviyCzpvc-00110-00039603-00039842": "buy certain games that support this", "inaviyCzpvc-00111-00039843-00040103": "feature one time and play them in both", "inaviyCzpvc-00112-00040104-00040511": "Sony platforms not only that but in the", "inaviyCzpvc-00113-00040512-00040775": "case of most such games they're saved", "inaviyCzpvc-00114-00040776-00041099": "games actually transfer back and forth", "inaviyCzpvc-00115-00041100-00041420": "between devices allowing players to pick", "inaviyCzpvc-00116-00041421-00041645": "up from the moment they left off there", "inaviyCzpvc-00117-00041646-00041936": "is also a feature called cross play or", "inaviyCzpvc-00118-00041937-00042199": "cross-platform play covering any", "inaviyCzpvc-00119-00042200-00042512": "PlayStation Vita software title that can", "inaviyCzpvc-00120-00042513-00042809": "interact with a PlayStation 3 software", "inaviyCzpvc-00121-00042810-00043187": "title different software titles use", "inaviyCzpvc-00122-00043188-00043543": "cross play in different ways for example", "inaviyCzpvc-00123-00043544-00043985": "Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3 as a title", "inaviyCzpvc-00124-00043986-00044231": "supporting the cross play feature and", "inaviyCzpvc-00125-00044232-00044513": "the ps3 version of the game can be", "inaviyCzpvc-00126-00044514-00044818": "controlled using the PS Vita system in", "inaviyCzpvc-00127-00044819-00045266": "addition some ps3 games can be played on", "inaviyCzpvc-00128-00045267-00045557": "the PS Vita using the PlayStation now", "inaviyCzpvc-00129-00045558-00046199": "streaming service", "inaviyCzpvc-00130-00046200-00046654": "topic non-game features", "inaviyCzpvc-00131-00046655-00046823": "you", "inaviyCzpvc-00132-00046824-00047145": "similar to many other consoles the", "inaviyCzpvc-00133-00047146-00047508": "PlayStation 3 is capable of photo audio", "inaviyCzpvc-00134-00047509-00047793": "and video playback in a variety of", "inaviyCzpvc-00135-00047794-00048219": "formats it also includes various photo", "inaviyCzpvc-00136-00048220-00048504": "slideshow options and several music", "inaviyCzpvc-00137-00048505-00048801": "visualizations furthermore the", "inaviyCzpvc-00138-00048802-00049125": "PlayStation 3 is able to play blu-ray", "inaviyCzpvc-00139-00049126-00049515": "and DVD movies as well as audio CDs out", "inaviyCzpvc-00140-00049516-00049845": "of the box and also capable of adopting", "inaviyCzpvc-00141-00049846-00050111": "streaming media services such as Netflix", "inaviyCzpvc-00142-00050112-00050550": "for a web browser the ps3 uses the net", "inaviyCzpvc-00143-00050551-00050775": "front browser although unlike its", "inaviyCzpvc-00144-00050776-00051150": "successor ps4 which uses the same modern", "inaviyCzpvc-00145-00051151-00051540": "WebKit core as Safari from Apple the ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00146-00051541-00051857": "web browser receives a low score in", "inaviyCzpvc-00147-00051858-00052346": "html5 compliance testing however unlike", "inaviyCzpvc-00148-00052347-00052766": "the ps4 the ps3 is able to play Adobe", "inaviyCzpvc-00149-00052767-00053105": "Flash including full-screen flash early", "inaviyCzpvc-00150-00053107-00053363": "versions of the PlayStation 3 system", "inaviyCzpvc-00151-00053364-00053685": "software also provided a feature called", "inaviyCzpvc-00152-00053686-00053980": "atheros that was available on the ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00153-00053982-00054270": "systems prior to the slimmer models", "inaviyCzpvc-00154-00054271-00054708": "launched in September 2009 this feature", "inaviyCzpvc-00155-00054709-00054991": "enabled users to install an operating", "inaviyCzpvc-00156-00054992-00055341": "system such as Linux but due to security", "inaviyCzpvc-00157-00055341-00055458": "concerns", "inaviyCzpvc-00158-00055459-00055740": "Sony later removed this functionality", "inaviyCzpvc-00159-00055741-00055920": "through the 3.21", "inaviyCzpvc-00160-00055921-00056337": "system software update according to Sony", "inaviyCzpvc-00161-00056338-00056712": "Computer Entertainment SCE disabling", "inaviyCzpvc-00162-00056713-00057012": "this feature will help ensure that ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00163-00057013-00057246": "owners will continue to have access to", "inaviyCzpvc-00164-00057247-00057455": "the broad range of gaming and", "inaviyCzpvc-00165-00057457-00057765": "entertainment content from SCE and its", "inaviyCzpvc-00166-00057766-00058105": "content partners on a more secure system", "inaviyCzpvc-00167-00058107-00058446": "Sony was successfully sued in a class", "inaviyCzpvc-00168-00058447-00058751": "action over the removal of this feature", "inaviyCzpvc-00169-00058752-00059108": "the settlement was approved in September", "inaviyCzpvc-00170-00059109-00059652": "2016 Sony agreed to pay up to $55 to as", "inaviyCzpvc-00171-00059653-00060039": "many as 10 million ps3 owners but denied", "inaviyCzpvc-00172-00060040-00060176": "wrongdoing further", "inaviyCzpvc-00173-00060177-00060482": "more the PlayStation 3 provides printing", "inaviyCzpvc-00174-00060483-00060887": "support it can for example print images", "inaviyCzpvc-00175-00060888-00061199": "and webpages when a supported printer is", "inaviyCzpvc-00176-00061200-00061532": "connected via a USB cable or a local", "inaviyCzpvc-00177-00061533-00061929": "network however only a selection of", "inaviyCzpvc-00178-00061929-00062162": "printers from Canon Epson and", "inaviyCzpvc-00179-00062163-00062429": "hewlett-packard are compatible with the", "inaviyCzpvc-00180-00062430-00063041": "ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00181-00063041-00063692": "topic backward compatibility", "inaviyCzpvc-00182-00063694-00064062": "all PlayStation 3 consoles are able to", "inaviyCzpvc-00183-00064063-00064410": "play original PlayStation games ps1", "inaviyCzpvc-00184-00064411-00064824": "discs and downloadable classics however", "inaviyCzpvc-00185-00064825-00065127": "not all PlayStation 3 models are", "inaviyCzpvc-00186-00065128-00065325": "backwards compatible with the", "inaviyCzpvc-00187-00065326-00065856": "PlayStation 2 games in summary early ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00188-00065857-00066219": "consoles such as the 60 gigabytes and 20", "inaviyCzpvc-00189-00066220-00066546": "gigabytes lunch ps3 consoles were", "inaviyCzpvc-00190-00066547-00066846": "backwards compatible with ps2 games", "inaviyCzpvc-00191-00066847-00067254": "because they had ps2 chips in them some", "inaviyCzpvc-00192-00067255-00067524": "later models most notably the 80", "inaviyCzpvc-00193-00067525-00067962": "gigabytes Metal Gear Solid ps3 consoles", "inaviyCzpvc-00194-00067963-00068256": "are also backwards compatible through", "inaviyCzpvc-00195-00068257-00068562": "partial software emulation in this case", "inaviyCzpvc-00196-00068563-00068949": "since they no longer had the ps2 CPU in", "inaviyCzpvc-00197-00068950-00069279": "them although they do have the ps2 GPU", "inaviyCzpvc-00198-00069280-00069540": "in them allowing for reduced backward", "inaviyCzpvc-00199-00069541-00069786": "compatibility through hardware assisted", "inaviyCzpvc-00200-00069787-00070170": "software emulation all other later", "inaviyCzpvc-00201-00070171-00070575": "models such as the ps3 slim are not ps2", "inaviyCzpvc-00202-00070576-00070890": "backwards compatible though users can", "inaviyCzpvc-00203-00070891-00071360": "still enjoy ps3 and PS 1 games on them", "inaviyCzpvc-00204-00071361-00071634": "according to Sony when they removed", "inaviyCzpvc-00205-00071635-00071946": "backwards compatibility from the ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00206-00071947-00072207": "they had already been at a point where", "inaviyCzpvc-00207-00072208-00072438": "they were three years into its lifecycle", "inaviyCzpvc-00208-00072439-00072702": "by that time the vast majority of", "inaviyCzpvc-00209-00072703-00073029": "consumers that were purchasing the ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00210-00073030-00073353": "sight ps3 games as a primary reason", "inaviyCzpvc-00211-00073354-00073692": "meaning that the ps2 compatibility was", "inaviyCzpvc-00212-00073693-00074148": "no longer necessary nevertheless ps2", "inaviyCzpvc-00213-00074149-00074433": "classics which are playable on the ps3", "inaviyCzpvc-00214-00074434-00074712": "have officially been introduced to the", "inaviyCzpvc-00215-00074713-00074940": "PlayStation Network for purchase", "inaviyCzpvc-00216-00074941-00075036": "afterwards", "inaviyCzpvc-00217-00075037-00075258": "although they are only a selection of", "inaviyCzpvc-00218-00075259-00075627": "ps2 games republished in digital format", "inaviyCzpvc-00219-00075628-00075957": "and unlike ps3 games they lack of trophy", "inaviyCzpvc-00220-00075958-00076368": "support later when the PlayStation 4", "inaviyCzpvc-00221-00076369-00076683": "console was released it was not backward", "inaviyCzpvc-00222-00076684-00076995": "compatible with either PlayStation 3 or", "inaviyCzpvc-00223-00076996-00077058": "placed", "inaviyCzpvc-00224-00077059-00077388": "a Shinto games although limited ps2", "inaviyCzpvc-00225-00077389-00077643": "backward compatibility was later", "inaviyCzpvc-00226-00077644-00077979": "introduced and ps4 owners might play a", "inaviyCzpvc-00227-00077980-00078348": "selected group of ps3 games by streaming", "inaviyCzpvc-00228-00078349-00078540": "them over the Internet using the", "inaviyCzpvc-00229-00078541-00078801": "PlayStation now cloud-based gaming", "inaviyCzpvc-00230-00078802-00079374": "service", "inaviyCzpvc-00231-00079375-00080029": "topic lv0 keys", "inaviyCzpvc-00232-00080030-00080455": "the playstation three lv0 keys are a set", "inaviyCzpvc-00233-00080456-00080707": "of cryptographic keys which form the", "inaviyCzpvc-00234-00080708-00081001": "core of the playstation three security", "inaviyCzpvc-00235-00081002-00081340": "system according to a news story on", "inaviyCzpvc-00236-00081341-00081553": "polygon", "inaviyCzpvc-00237-00081554-00081931": "under normal circumstances PlayStation 3", "inaviyCzpvc-00238-00081932-00082150": "consoles are locked so that they can", "inaviyCzpvc-00239-00082151-00082468": "only run software and operating systems", "inaviyCzpvc-00240-00082469-00082852": "approved by Sony when a PlayStation 3", "inaviyCzpvc-00241-00082853-00083140": "has successfully hacked users can", "inaviyCzpvc-00242-00083141-00083365": "perform actions that would otherwise not", "inaviyCzpvc-00243-00083366-00083674": "be possible or allowed on the console", "inaviyCzpvc-00244-00083675-00083950": "such as play pirated games and run", "inaviyCzpvc-00245-00083951-00084385": "unauthorized operating systems with the", "inaviyCzpvc-00246-00084386-00084741": "lv 0 keys users are able to circumvent", "inaviyCzpvc-00247-00084742-00085021": "restrictions placed by Sony more", "inaviyCzpvc-00248-00085022-00085444": "commonly known as jailbreaking the lv 0", "inaviyCzpvc-00249-00085445-00085720": "keys were released online by a group", "inaviyCzpvc-00250-00085721-00086109": "calling themselves the three musketeers", "inaviyCzpvc-00251-00086110-00086413": "granting users access to some of the", "inaviyCzpvc-00252-00086414-00086677": "most sensitive parts of the PlayStation", "inaviyCzpvc-00253-00086678-00087124": "3 with access to these areas users can", "inaviyCzpvc-00254-00087125-00087400": "decrypt security updates and work around", "inaviyCzpvc-00255-00087401-00087796": "the authorized PlayStation firmware this", "inaviyCzpvc-00256-00087797-00088144": "allows PlayStation 3 firmware updates to", "inaviyCzpvc-00257-00088145-00088399": "be modified on a computer so that they", "inaviyCzpvc-00258-00088400-00088765": "can be run on a modified console the", "inaviyCzpvc-00259-00088766-00089059": "three musketeers decided to release the", "inaviyCzpvc-00260-00089060-00089314": "code after a group of rival hackers", "inaviyCzpvc-00261-00089315-00089598": "obtained the code and plan to sell it", "inaviyCzpvc-00262-00089599-00089899": "while this is not the first time the", "inaviyCzpvc-00263-00089900-00090130": "PlayStation 3 has been hacked", "inaviyCzpvc-00264-00090131-00090436": "according to Eurogamer the release of", "inaviyCzpvc-00265-00090437-00090849": "the new custom firmware and the lv 0", "inaviyCzpvc-00266-00090850-00091267": "decryption keys in particular poses", "inaviyCzpvc-00267-00091268-00091545": "serious issues", "inaviyCzpvc-00268-00091546-00091896": "it also says that options sony has", "inaviyCzpvc-00269-00091897-00092265": "embattled this leaked or limited since", "inaviyCzpvc-00270-00092266-00092697": "the reveal of the lv zero key basically", "inaviyCzpvc-00271-00092698-00093032": "means that any system update released by", "inaviyCzpvc-00272-00093033-00093360": "sony going forward can be decrypted with", "inaviyCzpvc-00273-00093361-00093869": "little or no effort whatsoever", "inaviyCzpvc-00274-00093870-00094200": "topic history of updates the initial", "inaviyCzpvc-00275-00094201-00094449": "release for the PlayStation 3 system", "inaviyCzpvc-00276-00094450-00094893": "software was version 1.1 0 as appeared", "inaviyCzpvc-00277-00094894-00095289": "on November 11th 2006 in Japan and", "inaviyCzpvc-00278-00095290-00095742": "November 17 2006 in North America that", "inaviyCzpvc-00279-00095743-00095942": "provided the PlayStation Network", "inaviyCzpvc-00280-00095943-00096261": "services and the remote play for the 60", "inaviyCzpvc-00281-00096262-00096828": "gigabytes model however version 1.02 was", "inaviyCzpvc-00282-00096829-00097143": "included with some games there were a", "inaviyCzpvc-00283-00097144-00097509": "number of updates in the 1x X versions", "inaviyCzpvc-00284-00097510-00097782": "which provided new features such as the", "inaviyCzpvc-00285-00097783-00098112": "account management compatibility of USB", "inaviyCzpvc-00286-00098113-00098469": "devices for PlayStation 2 format games", "inaviyCzpvc-00287-00098470-00098787": "and supports for USB webcams and", "inaviyCzpvc-00288-00098788-00099215": "Bluetooth keyboards and mice version", "inaviyCzpvc-00289-00099216-00099753": "1.80 released on May 24 2007 added a", "inaviyCzpvc-00290-00099754-00100035": "number of relatively small new features", "inaviyCzpvc-00291-00100036-00100401": "mostly related to media and videos such", "inaviyCzpvc-00292-00100402-00100740": "as the ability to upscale standard DVD", "inaviyCzpvc-00293-00100741-00101112": "videos to 1080p and to downscale blu-ray", "inaviyCzpvc-00294-00101113-00101745": "video to 720p version 1.90 released on", "inaviyCzpvc-00295-00101746-00102189": "May 24 2007 further added the wallpaper", "inaviyCzpvc-00296-00102190-00102504": "feature for the background of X MB and", "inaviyCzpvc-00297-00102505-00102780": "the ability to eject a game disc using", "inaviyCzpvc-00298-00102781-00103104": "the controller to reorder game icons by", "inaviyCzpvc-00299-00103105-00103493": "format and creation date this update", "inaviyCzpvc-00300-00103494-00103851": "also forced 24 Hertz output for blu-ray", "inaviyCzpvc-00301-00103852-00104277": "over HDMI and introduced bookmarks and a", "inaviyCzpvc-00302-00104278-00104669": "security function to the web browser the", "inaviyCzpvc-00303-00104670-00105020": "last version in the One X X series was", "inaviyCzpvc-00304-00105021-00105606": "1.9 for released on October 23 2007 that", "inaviyCzpvc-00305-00105607-00105818": "added support for DualShock 3", "inaviyCzpvc-00306-00105819-00106170": "controllers as with the version 1x X", "inaviyCzpvc-00307-00106171-00106401": "series there were a number of versions", "inaviyCzpvc-00308-00106402-00106848": "in the 2x X and 3x X series released", "inaviyCzpvc-00309-00106849-00107139": "between November 8 2000", "inaviyCzpvc-00310-00107140-00107589": "and September 20th 2011 there were quite", "inaviyCzpvc-00311-00107590-00107948": "a few noticeable changes an inversion", "inaviyCzpvc-00312-00107949-00108288": "2.10 alone there were new features such", "inaviyCzpvc-00313-00108289-00108528": "as the additions of the voice changer", "inaviyCzpvc-00314-00108529-00108765": "feature with the power to make users", "inaviyCzpvc-00315-00108766-00109002": "sound like a person using a voice", "inaviyCzpvc-00316-00109003-00109344": "changer with 5 presets over high and low", "inaviyCzpvc-00317-00109345-00109664": "tones a new music bit mapping process", "inaviyCzpvc-00318-00109665-00109998": "specifically designed for the ps3 to", "inaviyCzpvc-00319-00109999-00110298": "provide enhanced audio playback as well", "inaviyCzpvc-00320-00110299-00110658": "as supports for DivX and WMV playback", "inaviyCzpvc-00321-00110658-00111003": "and blu-ray disc profile 1.1 for", "inaviyCzpvc-00322-00111004-00111441": "picture-in-picture version 2.5 0", "inaviyCzpvc-00323-00111442-00111860": "released on october 15th 2008 was the", "inaviyCzpvc-00324-00111861-00112166": "update in the 2x acts series that", "inaviyCzpvc-00325-00112167-00112389": "contained the largest number of new", "inaviyCzpvc-00326-00112390-00112665": "features or changes among them were the", "inaviyCzpvc-00327-00112666-00112977": "support for official ps3 Bluetooth", "inaviyCzpvc-00328-00112978-00113307": "headset in-game screenshots and Adobe", "inaviyCzpvc-00329-00113308-00113799": "Flash 9 a recovery menu or safe mode was", "inaviyCzpvc-00330-00113800-00114150": "also introduced in this version later", "inaviyCzpvc-00331-00114151-00114507": "versions in the 2x act series such as", "inaviyCzpvc-00332-00114508-00115044": "the 2.7 by 2.8 5 or 2.90", "inaviyCzpvc-00333-00115045-00115408": "were distributed with the ps3 slim", "inaviyCzpvc-00334-00115409-00115821": "similar to versions such as 2.00", "inaviyCzpvc-00335-00115822-00116166": "versions such as three point zero zero", "inaviyCzpvc-00336-00116167-00116510": "three point one zero three point three", "inaviyCzpvc-00337-00116511-00116844": "zero three point four zero and three", "inaviyCzpvc-00338-00116845-00117123": "point seven zero all introduced", "inaviyCzpvc-00339-00117124-00117383": "relatively large number of new features", "inaviyCzpvc-00340-00117384-00117704": "or changes such as supports for new", "inaviyCzpvc-00341-00117705-00118020": "dynamic custom themes improvements in", "inaviyCzpvc-00342-00118021-00118332": "the internet browser trophy enhancements", "inaviyCzpvc-00343-00118333-00118619": "and a new video editor and uploader", "inaviyCzpvc-00344-00118620-00118995": "application the most noticeable change", "inaviyCzpvc-00345-00118996-00119240": "in the version four point zero zero", "inaviyCzpvc-00346-00119241-00119636": "released on November 30th 2011 was the", "inaviyCzpvc-00347-00119638-00119913": "added support for the PlayStation Vita", "inaviyCzpvc-00348-00119914-00120369": "handheld game consoles for example PS", "inaviyCzpvc-00349-00120370-00120522": "Vita system", "inaviyCzpvc-00350-00120523-00120854": "was added as an option and PSVita system", "inaviyCzpvc-00351-00120855-00121149": "application utility has been added as a", "inaviyCzpvc-00352-00121150-00121533": "feature under game with this update the", "inaviyCzpvc-00353-00121533-00121841": "PlayStation 3 also gained the ability to", "inaviyCzpvc-00354-00121842-00122238": "transfer videos images musics and game", "inaviyCzpvc-00355-00122239-00122486": "data to and from the PlayStation Vita", "inaviyCzpvc-00356-00122488-00123134": "version 4.10 released on February 8 2012", "inaviyCzpvc-00357-00123135-00123444": "also added improvements to the internet", "inaviyCzpvc-00358-00123445-00123788": "browser including some support for html5", "inaviyCzpvc-00359-00123789-00124115": "and its display speed and web page", "inaviyCzpvc-00360-00124116-00124599": "layout accuracy later versions in the 4x", "inaviyCzpvc-00361-00124600-00124923": "X series all made a few changes to the", "inaviyCzpvc-00362-00124924-00125178": "system mostly to improve the stability", "inaviyCzpvc-00363-00125179-00125516": "and operation quality during the uses of", "inaviyCzpvc-00364-00125517-00125796": "some applications in addition to adding", "inaviyCzpvc-00365-00125797-00126081": "new features such as displaying closed", "inaviyCzpvc-00366-00126082-00126477": "captions when playing B DS and DVDs and", "inaviyCzpvc-00367-00126478-00126771": "check for update to the options menu for", "inaviyCzpvc-00368-00126772-00127211": "a game the PlayStation 3 system software", "inaviyCzpvc-00369-00127213-00128043": "is currently still being updated by Sony", "inaviyCzpvc-00370-00128044-00128869": "topic withdrawal of update 2.40", "inaviyCzpvc-00371-00128870-00129133": "system software version", "inaviyCzpvc-00372-00129133-00129513": "2.40 which included the in-game XMB", "inaviyCzpvc-00373-00129514-00129904": "feature and PlayStation 3 trophies was", "inaviyCzpvc-00374-00129905-00130339": "released on July 2nd 2008 however it was", "inaviyCzpvc-00375-00130340-00130598": "withdrawn later the same day because a", "inaviyCzpvc-00376-00130599-00130837": "small number of users were unable to", "inaviyCzpvc-00377-00130838-00131140": "restart their consoles after performing", "inaviyCzpvc-00378-00131141-00131476": "the update the fault was explained to", "inaviyCzpvc-00379-00131477-00131708": "have been because of certain system", "inaviyCzpvc-00380-00131709-00131981": "administrative data being contained in", "inaviyCzpvc-00381-00131982-00132373": "the HDD the issue was addressed in", "inaviyCzpvc-00382-00132374-00132700": "version 2.4 one of the system software", "inaviyCzpvc-00383-00132701-00133543": "released on July 8 2008", "inaviyCzpvc-00384-00133544-00133913": "topic class-action suit filed over", "inaviyCzpvc-00385-00133914-00134274": "update 3.0", "inaviyCzpvc-00386-00134275-00134461": "you", "inaviyCzpvc-00387-00134462-00134836": "system software version 3.0 was released", "inaviyCzpvc-00388-00134837-00135388": "on September 1st 2009 shortly after its", "inaviyCzpvc-00389-00135389-00135658": "release a number of users complained", "inaviyCzpvc-00390-00135659-00135889": "that the system update caused their", "inaviyCzpvc-00391-00135890-00136171": "systems blu-ray drive to malfunction", "inaviyCzpvc-00392-00136172-00136543": "in addition John Kennedy of Florida", "inaviyCzpvc-00393-00136544-00136839": "filed a class-action suit against Sony", "inaviyCzpvc-00394-00136840-00137221": "Computer Entertainment America John", "inaviyCzpvc-00395-00137222-00137548": "Kennedy had purchased a PlayStation 3 in", "inaviyCzpvc-00396-00137549-00137881": "January 2009 claiming it worked", "inaviyCzpvc-00397-00137882-00138112": "perfectly until he installed the", "inaviyCzpvc-00398-00138113-00138489": "required firmware update 3.0 at which", "inaviyCzpvc-00399-00138490-00138760": "point the blu-ray drive in his system", "inaviyCzpvc-00400-00138761-00139013": "ceased functioning properly", "inaviyCzpvc-00401-00139014-00139459": "Sony later released a statement SCEA", "inaviyCzpvc-00402-00139460-00139860": "as aware of reports that ps3 owners are", "inaviyCzpvc-00403-00139861-00140166": "experiencing isolated issues with their", "inaviyCzpvc-00404-00140167-00140514": "ps3 systems since installing the most", "inaviyCzpvc-00405-00140515-00141163": "recent system software update v 3.0 0", "inaviyCzpvc-00406-00141164-00141613": "and released software update 3.0 1 on", "inaviyCzpvc-00407-00141614-00142123": "September 15th 2009 however after", "inaviyCzpvc-00408-00142124-00142519": "installing 3.0 one the plaintiff alleged", "inaviyCzpvc-00409-00142520-00142807": "the problems were not only not solved", "inaviyCzpvc-00410-00142808-00143101": "but the new update created new issues as", "inaviyCzpvc-00411-00143102-00143656": "well", "inaviyCzpvc-00412-00143657-00144034": "topic class-action suits filed over", "inaviyCzpvc-00413-00144035-00144622": "update 3.21", "inaviyCzpvc-00414-00144623-00144957": "due to the removal of the atheras", "inaviyCzpvc-00415-00144958-00145381": "feature from older models of the ps3 due", "inaviyCzpvc-00416-00145382-00145708": "to security issues possibly related to", "inaviyCzpvc-00417-00145709-00145969": "the exploit released by geohot which", "inaviyCzpvc-00418-00145970-00146212": "caused an uproar in the playstation", "inaviyCzpvc-00419-00146213-00146449": "community several lawsuits have been", "inaviyCzpvc-00420-00146450-00146827": "filed the first one was filed on behalf", "inaviyCzpvc-00421-00146828-00147289": "of ps3 owners by Anthony Ventura the", "inaviyCzpvc-00422-00147290-00147531": "suit states that removing the feature", "inaviyCzpvc-00423-00147532-00147849": "constitutes breach of contract false", "inaviyCzpvc-00424-00147850-00148093": "advertising and a handful of other", "inaviyCzpvc-00425-00148094-00148357": "business practices relating to consumer", "inaviyCzpvc-00426-00148358-00148642": "protection laws as the feature was", "inaviyCzpvc-00427-00148643-00148912": "touted by Sony when these systems were", "inaviyCzpvc-00428-00148913-00149182": "new as a way consumers could turn their", "inaviyCzpvc-00429-00149183-00149506": "machines into a basic PC and sites that", "inaviyCzpvc-00430-00149507-00149881": "the feature was extremely valuable and", "inaviyCzpvc-00431-00149882-00150193": "one of the main reasons that many people", "inaviyCzpvc-00432-00150194-00150514": "paid more for the ps3 over buying a", "inaviyCzpvc-00433-00150515-00150837": "competing console like a Wii or an Xbox", "inaviyCzpvc-00434-00150838-00151309": "360 it also elaborates that anyone who", "inaviyCzpvc-00435-00151310-00151564": "does not accept the update can no longer", "inaviyCzpvc-00436-00151565-00151858": "play future games or future blu-ray", "inaviyCzpvc-00437-00151859-00152284": "movie releases later on two more suits", "inaviyCzpvc-00438-00152285-00152557": "were also filed by other members of the", "inaviyCzpvc-00439-00152558-00152941": "PlayStation 3 community the first of", "inaviyCzpvc-00440-00152942-00153205": "these newer lawsuits was filed by Todd", "inaviyCzpvc-00441-00153206-00153505": "Dean smore and on tall hers which claims", "inaviyCzpvc-00442-00153506-00153832": "Sony has rendered several PlayStation 3", "inaviyCzpvc-00443-00153833-00154213": "features they paid for inoperable as a", "inaviyCzpvc-00444-00154214-00154603": "result of the release of firmware 3.2", "inaviyCzpvc-00445-00154604-00154930": "won the second filed was by Jason Baker", "inaviyCzpvc-00446-00154931-00155293": "Sean Basket Paul Graham and Paul Van", "inaviyCzpvc-00447-00155294-00155341": "Natta", "inaviyCzpvc-00448-00155342-00155635": "and claims among other things that they", "inaviyCzpvc-00449-00155636-00156064": "lost money by purchasing a ps3 without", "inaviyCzpvc-00450-00156065-00156274": "receiving the benefit of their bargain", "inaviyCzpvc-00451-00156275-00156589": "because the product is not what it was", "inaviyCzpvc-00452-00156590-00156880": "claimed to be a game console that would", "inaviyCzpvc-00453-00156881-00157198": "provide both the other OS feature and", "inaviyCzpvc-00454-00157199-00157453": "gaming functions", "inaviyCzpvc-00455-00157454-00157741": "a fourth lawsuit was filed by Keith", "inaviyCzpvc-00456-00157742-00158032": "Wright and seeks compensation equal to", "inaviyCzpvc-00457-00158033-00158425": "the cost of the console a fifth lawsuit", "inaviyCzpvc-00458-00158426-00158731": "was filed by Jeffrey Harper and Zachary", "inaviyCzpvc-00459-00158732-00159004": "comer which calls for a jury trial", "inaviyCzpvc-00460-00159005-00159409": "a sixth lawsuit was filed by Jonathan", "inaviyCzpvc-00461-00159410-00159658": "Huber and has quotes from both the EU", "inaviyCzpvc-00462-00159659-00160063": "and US PlayStation blogs Sony responded", "inaviyCzpvc-00463-00160064-00160291": "to the lawsuits by requesting a", "inaviyCzpvc-00464-00160292-00160585": "dismissal on the grounds that no one", "inaviyCzpvc-00465-00160586-00160897": "cared about the feature and that the", "inaviyCzpvc-00466-00160898-00161133": "filing site quotes from third-party", "inaviyCzpvc-00467-00161134-00161461": "websites the instruction manual the", "inaviyCzpvc-00468-00161462-00161752": "PlayStation website and claims they are", "inaviyCzpvc-00469-00161753-00162057": "invalid proof and that Sony can disable", "inaviyCzpvc-00470-00162058-00162388": "PSN and the other advertised features", "inaviyCzpvc-00471-00162389-00162616": "playing games that require newer", "inaviyCzpvc-00472-00162617-00163060": "firmware etc as they wish the lawyers", "inaviyCzpvc-00473-00163061-00163294": "for the plaintiffs reviewed the request", "inaviyCzpvc-00474-00163295-00163564": "and said that this is fairly common at", "inaviyCzpvc-00475-00163565-00163807": "this stage of the process and that the", "inaviyCzpvc-00476-00163808-00164062": "case would be reviewed before a judge in", "inaviyCzpvc-00477-00164063-00164554": "November 2010 in February 2011 all", "inaviyCzpvc-00478-00164555-00164851": "claims of false advertising in the case", "inaviyCzpvc-00479-00164852-00165094": "were dismissed but the plaintiffs were", "inaviyCzpvc-00480-00165095-00165373": "allowed to appeal and amend the case and", "inaviyCzpvc-00481-00165374-00165547": "the other claims that the removal", "inaviyCzpvc-00482-00165548-00165820": "violated the Computer Fraud and Abuse", "inaviyCzpvc-00483-00165821-00166207": "Act were allowed to go forward in March", "inaviyCzpvc-00484-00166208-00166495": "2011 the plaintiffs amended their", "inaviyCzpvc-00485-00166496-00166777": "complaint to refute Sony's claims that", "inaviyCzpvc-00486-00166778-00167053": "it was within its rights under the tos", "inaviyCzpvc-00487-00167054-00167269": "and warranty to remove the feature", "inaviyCzpvc-00488-00167270-00167527": "adding more details to their claims", "inaviyCzpvc-00489-00167528-00167818": "including breach of warranty breach of", "inaviyCzpvc-00490-00167819-00168091": "implied warranty breach of contract", "inaviyCzpvc-00491-00168092-00168400": "unjust enrichment and breach of several", "inaviyCzpvc-00492-00168401-00168627": "California unfair business practices", "inaviyCzpvc-00493-00168628-00169276": "laws in April 2011 SCEA again asked that", "inaviyCzpvc-00494-00169277-00169525": "the case be dismissed and made claims", "inaviyCzpvc-00495-00169526-00169782": "that the plaintiffs refiled claim was", "inaviyCzpvc-00496-00169783-00169990": "insufficient and that they were hackers", "inaviyCzpvc-00497-00169991-00170206": "and wanted to violate Sony's", "inaviyCzpvc-00498-00170207-00170464": "intellectual property and asked the", "inaviyCzpvc-00499-00170465-00170686": "judge to grant search rights on their", "inaviyCzpvc-00500-00170687-00170942": "ps3 system", "inaviyCzpvc-00501-00170943-00171303": "SCEA also made claims that they were not", "inaviyCzpvc-00502-00171304-00171579": "the division solely responsible for the", "inaviyCzpvc-00503-00171580-00171774": "removal and should not be held", "inaviyCzpvc-00504-00171775-00171963": "responsible despite conflicting", "inaviyCzpvc-00505-00171964-00172452": "information to the contrary on April 18", "inaviyCzpvc-00506-00172453-00172812": "2011 the plaintiffs fired back at Sony's", "inaviyCzpvc-00507-00172813-00173007": "renewed efforts to have the case", "inaviyCzpvc-00508-00173008-00173253": "dismissed by pointing out the fact that", "inaviyCzpvc-00509-00173254-00173517": "Sony had made many of the same claims", "inaviyCzpvc-00510-00173518-00173745": "before and that they had been dismissed", "inaviyCzpvc-00511-00173746-00173985": "by the court and also pointed out", "inaviyCzpvc-00512-00173986-00174210": "several legal precedents under", "inaviyCzpvc-00513-00174211-00174474": "California law that refuted Sony's", "inaviyCzpvc-00514-00174475-00174924": "claims in December 2011 the whole case", "inaviyCzpvc-00515-00174925-00175173": "was dismissed under the grounds that the", "inaviyCzpvc-00516-00175174-00175392": "plaintiffs had failed to prove that they", "inaviyCzpvc-00517-00175393-00175830": "could expect the other OS feature beyond", "inaviyCzpvc-00518-00175831-00176148": "the warranty of the machine however this", "inaviyCzpvc-00519-00176149-00176445": "decision was overturned in a 2014", "inaviyCzpvc-00520-00176446-00176730": "appellate court decision finding that", "inaviyCzpvc-00521-00176731-00176976": "plaintiffs had indeed made clear and", "inaviyCzpvc-00522-00176977-00177332": "sufficiently substantial claims", "inaviyCzpvc-00523-00177333-00177759": "ultimately in 2016 Sony settled with", "inaviyCzpvc-00524-00177760-00178068": "users who installed Linux or purchased a", "inaviyCzpvc-00525-00178069-00178404": "PlayStation 3 based upon the alternative", "inaviyCzpvc-00526-00178405-00179081": "OS functionality", "inaviyCzpvc-00527-00179082-00179895": "topic withdrawal of update 4.45", "inaviyCzpvc-00528-00179896-00180343": "system software version 4.45 was", "inaviyCzpvc-00529-00180344-00180747": "released on June 18th 2013 however it", "inaviyCzpvc-00530-00180748-00181011": "was withdrawn one day later because a", "inaviyCzpvc-00531-00181012-00181254": "small number of users were unable to", "inaviyCzpvc-00532-00181255-00181558": "restart their consoles after performing", "inaviyCzpvc-00533-00181559-00182037": "the update On June 21st 2013", "inaviyCzpvc-00534-00182038-00182336": "Morgan Haro a community manager for", "inaviyCzpvc-00535-00182337-00182608": "PlayStation Network announced that the", "inaviyCzpvc-00536-00182609-00182857": "issue had been identified and a new", "inaviyCzpvc-00537-00182858-00183090": "update was planned to be released to", "inaviyCzpvc-00538-00183091-00183472": "resolve the issue the system update that", "inaviyCzpvc-00539-00183473-00183903": "addressed this issue version 4.4 6 was", "inaviyCzpvc-00540-00183904-00184246": "released on June 27th 2013", "inaviyCzpvc-00541-00184247-00184536": "and a fix for those affected by system", "inaviyCzpvc-00542-00184537-00185529": "version 4.4 5 was also provided by Sony", "inaviyCzpvc-00543-00185530-00185953": "topic see also", "inaviyCzpvc-00544-00185954-00186120": "you", "inaviyCzpvc-00545-00186121-00186737": "Media Go Linux for PlayStation 3", "inaviyCzpvc-00546-00186738-00187347": "location free player cRIO City X Ross", "inaviyCzpvc-00547-00187348-00187632": "media BRR other gaming platforms from", "inaviyCzpvc-00548-00187633-00188070": "Sony Playstation 4 system software", "inaviyCzpvc-00549-00188071-00188523": "PlayStation Portable system software", "inaviyCzpvc-00550-00188524-00189009": "PlayStation Vita system software weather", "inaviyCzpvc-00551-00189010-00189252": "gaming platforms from the next", "inaviyCzpvc-00552-00189253-00189821": "generation we use system software Xbox", "inaviyCzpvc-00553-00189822-00190476": "one system software Nintendo 3ds system", "inaviyCzpvc-00554-00190477-00190899": "software Nintendo's switch system", "inaviyCzpvc-00555-00190900-00191196": "software weather gaming platforms from", "inaviyCzpvc-00556-00191197-00191840": "this generation we system software", "inaviyCzpvc-00557-00191841-00192381": "xbox360 system software Nintendo DSi", "inaviyCzpvc-00558-00192382-00192687": "system software"}}, {"audio_id": "inaSY30aifU", "text": {"inaSY30aifU-00000-00000017-00000323": "there's not a single day that passes", "inaSY30aifU-00001-00000324-00000682": "without you on my mind not even one", "inaSY30aifU-00002-00000683-00002026": "minute can end up before you come around", "inaSY30aifU-00003-00002027-00003304": "[Music]", "inaSY30aifU-00004-00003305-00004039": "we're doing foreign", "inaSY30aifU-00005-00004040-00006592": "[Music]", "inaSY30aifU-00006-00006593-00006848": "not even one minute", "inaSY30aifU-00007-00006848-00009859": "[Music]", "inaSY30aifU-00008-00009860-00010091": "thank you", "inaSY30aifU-00009-00010092-00012442": "[Music]", "inaSY30aifU-00010-00012443-00012713": "foreign", "inaSY30aifU-00011-00012714-00013302": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "jomstS0GPf0", "text": {"jomstS0GPf0-00000-00000026-00000521": "spread that this is the 14th in my", "jomstS0GPf0-00001-00000522-00000862": "series of speeches on the line item veto", "jomstS0GPf0-00002-00000863-00001199": "with particular reference to the Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00003-00001200-00001549": "Republic and the Roman Senate when I", "jomstS0GPf0-00004-00001550-00001932": "began this series of one hour speeches", "jomstS0GPf0-00005-00001934-00002701": "on may five I spoke of montesquieu the", "jomstS0GPf0-00006-00002702-00003240": "eminent French philosopher and author", "jomstS0GPf0-00007-00003242-00003593": "who had greatly influenced the founding", "jomstS0GPf0-00008-00003594-00004106": "fathers with his political theory of", "jomstS0GPf0-00009-00004107-00004345": "checks and balances and separation of", "jomstS0GPf0-00010-00004346-00005090": "powers what influenced montesquieu in", "jomstS0GPf0-00011-00005091-00005529": "his espousal of this political system", "jomstS0GPf0-00012-00005530-00005906": "Montesquieu was greatly influenced by", "jomstS0GPf0-00013-00005907-00006038": "the history of the development of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00014-00006039-00006386": "English Constitution and by the history", "jomstS0GPf0-00015-00006387-00006869": "of the people of Rome so impressed was", "jomstS0GPf0-00016-00006870-00007262": "Montesquieu with the Romans that he in", "jomstS0GPf0-00017-00007263-00007613": "fact developed and published the work of", "jomstS0GPf0-00018-00007614-00008084": "his own on the subject almost midway", "jomstS0GPf0-00019-00008084-00008545": "between the Persian letters in 1721 and", "jomstS0GPf0-00020-00008546-00008956": "the spirit of the laws in 1748", "jomstS0GPf0-00021-00008957-00009508": "Montesquieu published in 1734 his", "jomstS0GPf0-00022-00009509-00009778": "considerations on the causes of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00023-00009779-00010109": "greatness of the Romans and their", "jomstS0GPf0-00024-00010110-00010628": "decline which is the least well-known of", "jomstS0GPf0-00025-00010629-00011219": "the three I've also stated a number of", "jomstS0GPf0-00026-00011220-00011570": "times that if we are to have a better", "jomstS0GPf0-00027-00011571-00011759": "appreciation and understanding of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00028-00011760-00012113": "Constitution it's the separation of", "jomstS0GPf0-00029-00012114-00012556": "powers and checks and balances and the", "jomstS0GPf0-00030-00012557-00013007": "power of the purse then we should follow", "jomstS0GPf0-00031-00013008-00013394": "in Montesquieu's tracks and study Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00032-00013394-00013721": "history as he did and that is what we", "jomstS0GPf0-00033-00013722-00014126": "have been doing together during these", "jomstS0GPf0-00034-00014127-00014913": "past several months now what have we", "jomstS0GPf0-00035-00014915-00015527": "acquired to pay us for our pains what", "jomstS0GPf0-00036-00015528-00016154": "what do we gain that can be applicable", "jomstS0GPf0-00037-00016155-00016646": "to our own time our own country and its", "jomstS0GPf0-00038-00016647-00016868": "political questions is today concerning", "jomstS0GPf0-00039-00016869-00017141": "the checks and balances and their", "jomstS0GPf0-00040-00017142-00017632": "control over the purse well let us see", "jomstS0GPf0-00041-00017633-00018064": "mr. president I hold that human nature", "jomstS0GPf0-00042-00018065-00018825": "and a molecule of water are the thing", "jomstS0GPf0-00043-00018826-00019075": "human nature is like a molecule of water", "jomstS0GPf0-00044-00019076-00019511": "it has never changed that which was h2o", "jomstS0GPf0-00045-00019512-00019827": "at the beginning of creation when the", "jomstS0GPf0-00046-00019828-00020186": "Spirit of God moved upon the face of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00047-00020187-00020669": "waters is still h2o today two atoms of", "jomstS0GPf0-00048-00020670-00021039": "hydrogen one atom of oxygen and that", "jomstS0GPf0-00049-00021040-00021586": "which was human nature when Adam and Eve", "jomstS0GPf0-00050-00021587-00022146": "fell from grace they're still human", "jomstS0GPf0-00051-00022147-00022878": "nature today it has never changed and as", "jomstS0GPf0-00052-00022879-00023166": "human nature has not changed from the", "jomstS0GPf0-00053-00023167-00023531": "beginning but is still motivated by the", "jomstS0GPf0-00054-00023532-00023814": "same emotions and instincts and needs", "jomstS0GPf0-00055-00023815-00024281": "and drys love hate and fear and greed", "jomstS0GPf0-00056-00024282-00024836": "and hunger and so on and the history of", "jomstS0GPf0-00057-00024837-00025234": "man's actions will always have a way of", "jomstS0GPf0-00058-00025235-00025827": "repeating itself so as we who live today", "jomstS0GPf0-00059-00025827-00026283": "contribute to the flow of history's", "jomstS0GPf0-00060-00026283-00026762": "unceasing stream it would be worth our", "jomstS0GPf0-00061-00026763-00027490": "while to examine the events of past ages", "jomstS0GPf0-00062-00027491-00027948": "their causes and their consequences in", "jomstS0GPf0-00063-00027949-00028110": "order that we might better understand", "jomstS0GPf0-00064-00028111-00028352": "the causes and possible consequences of", "jomstS0GPf0-00065-00028353-00028698": "the phenomena the happenings the events", "jomstS0GPf0-00066-00028699-00029439": "in the actions of our own life and times", "jomstS0GPf0-00067-00029439-00030102": "Napoleon said let my son often read and", "jomstS0GPf0-00068-00030102-00030515": "reflect upon history this is the only", "jomstS0GPf0-00069-00030516-00031283": "true philosophy so we have elected as", "jomstS0GPf0-00070-00031285-00031912": "did montesquieu to look to Roman history", "jomstS0GPf0-00071-00031913-00032857": "for guidance", "jomstS0GPf0-00072-00032858-00033555": "Roman power derived from Roman virtue", "jomstS0GPf0-00073-00033556-00034140": "basically in other words the old Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00074-00034141-00034561": "virtues the great moral qualities the", "jomstS0GPf0-00075-00034562-00034818": "average Roman as we have noted with", "jomstS0GPf0-00076-00034819-00035324": "simple steadfast honest courageous", "jomstS0GPf0-00077-00035325-00035780": "law-abiding patriotic and reverent and", "jomstS0GPf0-00078-00035781-00036393": "his leaders remain of uncommon", "jomstS0GPf0-00079-00036394-00037086": "dedication and acumen from the earliest", "jomstS0GPf0-00080-00037087-00037764": "times the Romans possessed a profound", "jomstS0GPf0-00081-00037765-00038361": "reverence for national tradition a firm", "jomstS0GPf0-00082-00038362-00038877": "conviction of being the spec the special", "jomstS0GPf0-00083-00038878-00039264": "object of and instrument of Destiny and", "jomstS0GPf0-00084-00039265-00039517": "a strong sense of individual", "jomstS0GPf0-00085-00039518-00040204": "responsibility and obligation to be true", "jomstS0GPf0-00086-00040205-00040593": "to that tradition and fulfill that", "jomstS0GPf0-00087-00040594-00041130": "destiny their spring to mind several", "jomstS0GPf0-00088-00041131-00041545": "parallels between the history of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00089-00041546-00041782": "Romans and the history of our own", "jomstS0GPf0-00090-00041783-00042258": "Republic", "jomstS0GPf0-00091-00042259-00042926": "as we see that the same old virtues that", "jomstS0GPf0-00092-00042927-00043593": "lint sturdiness integrity to the early", "jomstS0GPf0-00093-00043594-00044145": "Romans gave stability substance and", "jomstS0GPf0-00094-00044146-00044442": "strength and character to our own", "jomstS0GPf0-00095-00044443-00044942": "national life in the early years of its", "jomstS0GPf0-00096-00044943-00045552": "formation and development Roman family", "jomstS0GPf0-00097-00045553-00046143": "was the cornerstone of the Roman social", "jomstS0GPf0-00098-00046144-00046695": "structure and the family setting", "jomstS0GPf0-00099-00046696-00047267": "instilled its members with", "jomstS0GPf0-00100-00047268-00047850": "self-discipline and with the respect for", "jomstS0GPf0-00101-00047851-00047997": "authority and the veneration of", "jomstS0GPf0-00102-00047998-00048293": "ancestors and the reverence for the gods", "jomstS0GPf0-00103-00048294-00049185": "that", "jomstS0GPf0-00104-00049186-00049577": "lindt stability to Roman society and", "jomstS0GPf0-00105-00049578-00050330": "discipline to the Roman legions", "jomstS0GPf0-00106-00050331-00050561": "the Roman family unit was a religious", "jomstS0GPf0-00107-00050562-00051014": "organization a community of worship", "jomstS0GPf0-00108-00051015-00051578": "centered around the heart the cult of", "jomstS0GPf0-00109-00051579-00051926": "the hearth and the cult of the dead each", "jomstS0GPf0-00110-00051927-00052436": "morning and evening the entire family", "jomstS0GPf0-00111-00052437-00053116": "including the slave offered prayers and", "jomstS0GPf0-00112-00053117-00053753": "sacrifices to the departed ancestors at", "jomstS0GPf0-00113-00053754-00054065": "the family hearth who's ever burning", "jomstS0GPf0-00114-00054066-00054425": "flame symbolized both the unity and the", "jomstS0GPf0-00115-00054426-00055204": "continuity of the Roman family because", "jomstS0GPf0-00116-00055205-00055633": "of the pastoral tradition of the Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00117-00055634-00056066": "the Romans like the Jews the Old", "jomstS0GPf0-00118-00056066-00056489": "Testament sacrificed animals to their", "jomstS0GPf0-00119-00056490-00056987": "gods reverence and the idea of", "jomstS0GPf0-00120-00056988-00057521": "obligation", "jomstS0GPf0-00121-00057522-00057858": "inherent in the Roman conception of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00122-00057859-00058551": "relation between gods and men inevitably", "jomstS0GPf0-00123-00058552-00058788": "developed among the Romans a strong", "jomstS0GPf0-00124-00058789-00059337": "sense of duty a moral factor of", "jomstS0GPf0-00125-00059338-00060024": "inestimable work worth", "jomstS0GPf0-00126-00060025-00060875": "mr. president we have seen that same", "jomstS0GPf0-00127-00060876-00061466": "strong tradition of family and religious", "jomstS0GPf0-00128-00061467-00062461": "values", "jomstS0GPf0-00129-00062462-00062940": "you know in the formation of our own", "jomstS0GPf0-00130-00062941-00063511": "country from colonial times down to the", "jomstS0GPf0-00131-00063512-00064315": "mid 20th century and the erosion of", "jomstS0GPf0-00132-00064316-00064822": "these values over the past 50 to 60", "jomstS0GPf0-00133-00064823-00065704": "years has signified a weakening of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00134-00065705-00065920": "moral and spiritual strength of this", "jomstS0GPf0-00135-00065921-00067063": "nation as it did in the Roman State", "jomstS0GPf0-00136-00067064-00067498": "we have seen in the Roman and American", "jomstS0GPf0-00137-00067499-00068062": "psyches a manifest destiny an urge to", "jomstS0GPf0-00138-00068063-00068765": "extend the territorial frontiers we saw", "jomstS0GPf0-00139-00068766-00069025": "in the territorial expansion of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00140-00069026-00069735": "Roman city state", "jomstS0GPf0-00141-00069736-00070175": "what amounted to an over expansion we", "jomstS0GPf0-00142-00070176-00070521": "saw the drain that was placed upon roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00143-00070522-00070775": "manpower and the burden that was imposed", "jomstS0GPf0-00144-00070776-00071060": "upon the administration of the far-flung", "jomstS0GPf0-00145-00071061-00071441": "provinces while in her own case", "jomstS0GPf0-00146-00071442-00072168": "territorial expansion has long ceased in", "jomstS0GPf0-00147-00072169-00072407": "recent years we have spent billions of", "jomstS0GPf0-00148-00072408-00072938": "dollars of spacek exploration and we", "jomstS0GPf0-00149-00072939-00073187": "stand in danger of over extending our", "jomstS0GPf0-00150-00073188-00073511": "international commitments and our", "jomstS0GPf0-00151-00073512-00073878": "financial capability to sustain and", "jomstS0GPf0-00152-00073879-00074124": "underwrite them we've been talking about", "jomstS0GPf0-00153-00074125-00074859": "that a good bit lately we've also drawn", "jomstS0GPf0-00154-00074860-00075315": "parallels in the vanishing peasantry", "jomstS0GPf0-00155-00075316-00076023": "from the land and the decline in small", "jomstS0GPf0-00156-00076024-00076469": "family farms the consequences of which", "jomstS0GPf0-00157-00076470-00076680": "have been increasing unemployment and", "jomstS0GPf0-00158-00076681-00076974": "crime and poverty in the cities and a", "jomstS0GPf0-00159-00076975-00077523": "growing welfare dependence upon the", "jomstS0GPf0-00160-00077524-00077911": "state", "jomstS0GPf0-00161-00077912-00078187": "during the centuries of the early and", "jomstS0GPf0-00162-00078188-00078879": "middle Republic public office in Rome", "jomstS0GPf0-00163-00078880-00079613": "was obtained only through virtue", "jomstS0GPf0-00164-00079614-00079952": "and it brought with it no pay no salary", "jomstS0GPf0-00165-00079953-00080519": "no benefit other than honor and the", "jomstS0GPf0-00166-00080520-00080861": "opportunity to prove oneself worthy of", "jomstS0GPf0-00167-00080862-00081479": "being preferred for further toils on", "jomstS0GPf0-00168-00081480-00082200": "behalf of the state", "jomstS0GPf0-00169-00082201-00082773": "in the last century of the Republic the", "jomstS0GPf0-00170-00082774-00083451": "old citizen soldier II and the old moral", "jomstS0GPf0-00171-00083452-00084318": "structure of integrity and dedication to", "jomstS0GPf0-00172-00084319-00084894": "the cause of country gave way to greed", "jomstS0GPf0-00173-00084895-00085253": "and graft and corruption and venality", "jomstS0GPf0-00174-00085254-00085758": "and political demagoguery much of which", "jomstS0GPf0-00175-00085759-00086454": "we see in our own time and in our own", "jomstS0GPf0-00176-00086455-00087042": "country", "jomstS0GPf0-00177-00087043-00087387": "and the self seeking ambitions of Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00178-00087388-00087888": "generals and politicians led to civil", "jomstS0GPf0-00179-00087889-00088167": "wars and violence and military", "jomstS0GPf0-00180-00088168-00088698": "domination by standing armies made up of", "jomstS0GPf0-00181-00088699-00089211": "professional soldiers and in our own", "jomstS0GPf0-00182-00089212-00089557": "Republic the military industrial complex", "jomstS0GPf0-00183-00089558-00089835": "against which President Eisenhower", "jomstS0GPf0-00184-00089836-00090865": "Warren can pose a threat", "jomstS0GPf0-00185-00090866-00091484": "to the system", "jomstS0GPf0-00186-00091485-00092165": "so mr. president", "jomstS0GPf0-00187-00092166-00093016": "there are sundry similarities between", "jomstS0GPf0-00188-00093017-00093661": "our own history and the history", "jomstS0GPf0-00189-00093662-00094312": "of the Romans", "jomstS0GPf0-00190-00094313-00095179": "now let us turn to the consideration of", "jomstS0GPf0-00191-00095180-00096275": "the Roman political system", "jomstS0GPf0-00192-00096276-00096609": "in the Roman Republic the political", "jomstS0GPf0-00193-00096610-00097088": "organization was complex and is also", "jomstS0GPf0-00194-00097089-00097587": "experimental unlike that of Lycurgus the", "jomstS0GPf0-00195-00097588-00098081": "spartan general the 9th century BC by", "jomstS0GPf0-00196-00098082-00098916": "kirkus United in his Constitution all of", "jomstS0GPf0-00197-00098917-00099438": "the good and distinctive features of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00198-00099439-00099888": "best governments so that none of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00199-00099889-00100388": "principal parts would unduly grow and", "jomstS0GPf0-00200-00100389-00101480": "predominate", "jomstS0GPf0-00201-00101481-00101756": "but in as much as the force of each part", "jomstS0GPf0-00202-00101757-00102071": "would be neutralized by that of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00203-00102072-00103010": "others", "jomstS0GPf0-00204-00103011-00103428": "none of them would prevail and out", "jomstS0GPf0-00205-00103429-00104279": "balance another therefore the", "jomstS0GPf0-00206-00104280-00104529": "Constitution would remain in the state", "jomstS0GPf0-00207-00104530-00105059": "of equilibrium Lycurgus then for seeing", "jomstS0GPf0-00208-00105060-00105773": "by a process of reasoning Quentin how", "jomstS0GPf0-00209-00105774-00106186": "events would naturally happen", "jomstS0GPf0-00210-00106188-00106931": "constructed his Constitution untaught by", "jomstS0GPf0-00211-00106932-00107465": "adversity", "jomstS0GPf0-00212-00107466-00108027": "while the Romans", "jomstS0GPf0-00213-00108028-00108559": "would achieve the same final result", "jomstS0GPf0-00214-00108560-00108843": "polybius according to paula bius they", "jomstS0GPf0-00215-00108844-00109023": "did not reach it by any process of", "jomstS0GPf0-00216-00109024-00109281": "reasoning but by the discipline of many", "jomstS0GPf0-00217-00109282-00109719": "trials and struggles and by always", "jomstS0GPf0-00218-00109720-00109968": "choosing the best in the light of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00219-00109969-00110495": "experience gained they reached the same", "jomstS0GPf0-00220-00110496-00111233": "result as Lycurgus let us then consider", "jomstS0GPf0-00221-00111233-00111633": "the Roman system as that was seen by", "jomstS0GPf0-00222-00111633-00112323": "polybius the greek historian who lived", "jomstS0GPf0-00223-00112324-00112917": "in Rome from 168 BC after the battle of", "jomstS0GPf0-00224-00112918-00113640": "fitna until after 150 bc at a time when", "jomstS0GPf0-00225-00113641-00113957": "the Roman Republic was at a pinnacle of", "jomstS0GPf0-00226-00113958-00114348": "majesty that excited his admiration and", "jomstS0GPf0-00227-00114349-00114906": "his coming", "jomstS0GPf0-00228-00114907-00115417": "Bolivia's viewed the Roman Constitution", "jomstS0GPf0-00229-00115418-00115985": "as having three elements the executive", "jomstS0GPf0-00230-00115986-00116623": "the Senate and the people with their", "jomstS0GPf0-00231-00116624-00117148": "respective the share of power in the", "jomstS0GPf0-00232-00117149-00117608": "state", "jomstS0GPf0-00233-00117608-00118010": "regulated by a scrupulous regard to", "jomstS0GPf0-00234-00118011-00119224": "equality and equilibrium", "jomstS0GPf0-00235-00119225-00119608": "so let us examine the separation of", "jomstS0GPf0-00236-00119608-00119995": "powers in the Roman Republic as", "jomstS0GPf0-00237-00119996-00120718": "explained by polybius", "jomstS0GPf0-00238-00120719-00121318": "the council representing the executive", "jomstS0GPf0-00239-00121319-00121859": "was the supreme master of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00240-00121860-00122201": "administration of the government when", "jomstS0GPf0-00241-00122202-00122621": "remaining in Rome all of the other", "jomstS0GPf0-00242-00122622-00122915": "magistrates except the tribunes were", "jomstS0GPf0-00243-00122916-00123158": "under the council's and took their", "jomstS0GPf0-00244-00123159-00123863": "orders from the council's the council's", "jomstS0GPf0-00245-00123864-00124258": "presented matters before the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00246-00124259-00124553": "required that required the deliberation", "jomstS0GPf0-00247-00124554-00124856": "of the Senate and saw to the execution", "jomstS0GPf0-00248-00124857-00125369": "of the Senate's decrees and in matters", "jomstS0GPf0-00249-00125370-00125564": "requiring the authorization of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00250-00125565-00125882": "people the council's summoned the", "jomstS0GPf0-00251-00125883-00126152": "popular meetings and presented the", "jomstS0GPf0-00252-00126153-00126434": "proposals for the decision and carried", "jomstS0GPf0-00253-00126435-00127220": "out the decrees of the majority and in", "jomstS0GPf0-00254-00127221-00127595": "matters of war the consul's imposed such", "jomstS0GPf0-00255-00127596-00127847": "levies upon the Allies as the consul's", "jomstS0GPf0-00256-00127848-00128201": "deemed appropriate and made out the role", "jomstS0GPf0-00257-00128202-00128771": "for soldiers and selected those who were", "jomstS0GPf0-00258-00128772-00129284": "suitable consoles had absolute power to", "jomstS0GPf0-00259-00129285-00129512": "inflict punishment upon all who are", "jomstS0GPf0-00260-00129513-00129830": "under their command and they had all but", "jomstS0GPf0-00261-00129831-00130043": "absolute power in the conduct of", "jomstS0GPf0-00262-00130044-00130666": "military campaigns as to the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00263-00130667-00130904": "we're talking about the separation of", "jomstS0GPf0-00264-00130905-00131384": "power as to the Senate the Senate had", "jomstS0GPf0-00265-00131385-00131901": "complete control over the Treasury", "jomstS0GPf0-00266-00131902-00132391": "and the questors", "jomstS0GPf0-00267-00132392-00132772": "the questors could not issue any public", "jomstS0GPf0-00268-00132773-00133042": "money to the various departments of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00269-00133043-00133606": "state without a decree of the Senate the", "jomstS0GPf0-00270-00133607-00133867": "Senate control the money for the repair", "jomstS0GPf0-00271-00133868-00134029": "and construction of Public Works and", "jomstS0GPf0-00272-00134030-00134449": "public buildings throughout it Italy and", "jomstS0GPf0-00273-00134450-00134752": "none of that money could become obtained", "jomstS0GPf0-00274-00134753-00135354": "by the censors who oversaw the contracts", "jomstS0GPf0-00275-00135355-00135619": "for public works in public village none", "jomstS0GPf0-00276-00135620-00135757": "that money could be obtained by the", "jomstS0GPf0-00277-00135758-00136144": "censors except by the grant of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00278-00136145-00136517": "Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00279-00136518-00136763": "the senate also had jurisdiction over", "jomstS0GPf0-00280-00136764-00137126": "all crimes requiring a public", "jomstS0GPf0-00281-00137127-00137563": "investigation such as treason conspiracy", "jomstS0GPf0-00282-00137564-00138115": "poisoning or willful murder as well as", "jomstS0GPf0-00283-00138116-00138392": "controversies between and among Allied", "jomstS0GPf0-00284-00138393-00139075": "states receptions for ambassadors and", "jomstS0GPf0-00285-00139076-00139571": "matters affecting foreign States with", "jomstS0GPf0-00286-00139572-00140261": "the business of the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00287-00140262-00140665": "well what was left in the constitution", "jomstS0GPf0-00288-00140666-00141966": "for the people", "jomstS0GPf0-00289-00141967-00142323": "the people participated in ratification", "jomstS0GPf0-00290-00142324-00142743": "of treaties and alliances and decided", "jomstS0GPf0-00291-00142744-00143244": "questions of war and peace the people", "jomstS0GPf0-00292-00143245-00144696": "passed and repealed laws", "jomstS0GPf0-00293-00144697-00145350": "and invested individuals with public", "jomstS0GPf0-00294-00145351-00145814": "office which according to police were", "jomstS0GPf0-00295-00145815-00146610": "the most honorable rewards for virtue", "jomstS0GPf0-00296-00146611-00147498": "now Olivia's having described separation", "jomstS0GPf0-00297-00147499-00148055": "of powers under the Roman Constitution", "jomstS0GPf0-00298-00148056-00148454": "how did the three parts of government", "jomstS0GPf0-00299-00148455-00149218": "check and balance one another", "jomstS0GPf0-00300-00149219-00149529": "mr. president during the past several", "jomstS0GPf0-00301-00149530-00150036": "months I have been talking about the", "jomstS0GPf0-00302-00150037-00150264": "various checks that the consoles and", "jomstS0GPf0-00303-00150265-00150609": "Tribune's the Senate and the Assembly's", "jomstS0GPf0-00304-00150610-00150840": "exercises against one another and IOUs", "jomstS0GPf0-00305-00150841-00151188": "paid particular attention to the veto", "jomstS0GPf0-00306-00151189-00152247": "power of the Senate and the tribunes", "jomstS0GPf0-00307-00152248-00153040": "Henry Clay who believed that the veto", "jomstS0GPf0-00308-00153041-00153235": "power of American presidents was", "jomstS0GPf0-00309-00153236-00153684": "despotic and ought to be circumscribed", "jomstS0GPf0-00310-00153685-00154011": "stated in a Senate floor speech that the", "jomstS0GPf0-00311-00154012-00154374": "veto originally originated in the", "jomstS0GPf0-00312-00154375-00154711": "institution of the Tribune yishun power", "jomstS0GPf0-00313-00154712-00155508": "in ancient Rome and had been introduced", "jomstS0GPf0-00314-00155509-00155794": "from the practice under the empire into", "jomstS0GPf0-00315-00155795-00156456": "the monarchies of Europe pullip eous", "jomstS0GPf0-00316-00156457-00157090": "explains the checks and balances as he", "jomstS0GPf0-00317-00157091-00157312": "had observed them firsthand remember he", "jomstS0GPf0-00318-00157313-00157987": "was a living in Rome according to Paula", "jomstS0GPf0-00319-00157988-00158365": "bia's the consul's what what were the", "jomstS0GPf0-00320-00158366-00159008": "checks upon the consoles the executive", "jomstS0GPf0-00321-00159009-00160372": "the council's whose power", "jomstS0GPf0-00322-00160373-00160589": "over the administration the government", "jomstS0GPf0-00323-00160590-00160895": "went in the city and over the military", "jomstS0GPf0-00324-00160896-00161221": "went in the field a period absolute", "jomstS0GPf0-00325-00161222-00161465": "stood in need of the support of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00326-00161466-00161897": "Senate and the people the council the", "jomstS0GPf0-00327-00161898-00162310": "council needed supplies for his legion", "jomstS0GPf0-00328-00162311-00162604": "but without a decree of the Senate if", "jomstS0GPf0-00329-00162605-00162818": "soldiers could be supplied with neither", "jomstS0GPf0-00330-00162819-00163556": "corn nor clothes nor pay and all of his", "jomstS0GPf0-00331-00163557-00163941": "plans would be futile if the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00332-00163942-00164219": "shrank from danger or if the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00333-00164220-00164546": "opposes plans are sought to to hamper", "jomstS0GPf0-00334-00164547-00165271": "them therefore whether", "jomstS0GPf0-00335-00165272-00165777": "the council could carry any undertaking", "jomstS0GPf0-00336-00165778-00166021": "to a successful conclusion dependent", "jomstS0GPf0-00337-00166022-00166300": "upon the Senate which had the absolute", "jomstS0GPf0-00338-00166301-00166768": "power at the end of his one-year term to", "jomstS0GPf0-00339-00166769-00167061": "replace him with another console law to", "jomstS0GPf0-00340-00167062-00167632": "extend his command even to the successes", "jomstS0GPf0-00341-00167633-00167910": "of the council's on the field of battle", "jomstS0GPf0-00342-00167911-00168733": "the Senate had the power to add", "jomstS0GPf0-00343-00168734-00169075": "honor and glory or to obscure their", "jomstS0GPf0-00344-00169076-00169665": "merits because unless the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00345-00169666-00170071": "concurred in the recognition the agenda", "jomstS0GPf0-00346-00170072-00170314": "in recognition of the achievements of", "jomstS0GPf0-00347-00170315-00170686": "the consoles and voted money there could", "jomstS0GPf0-00348-00170687-00171937": "be no celebration or public triumphs", "jomstS0GPf0-00349-00171938-00172476": "moreover the consoles were obliged to", "jomstS0GPf0-00350-00172477-00173047": "take into account the wishes of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00351-00173048-00173431": "people to here's the check of the people", "jomstS0GPf0-00352-00173432-00173977": "against the company", "jomstS0GPf0-00353-00173978-00174719": "part was the people who would agree to", "jomstS0GPf0-00354-00174720-00175479": "or repudiate the terms of peace", "jomstS0GPf0-00355-00175480-00175866": "but most of all the consoles when laying", "jomstS0GPf0-00356-00175867-00176106": "down their office that the conclusion of", "jomstS0GPf0-00357-00176107-00176493": "their one-year term would have to give", "jomstS0GPf0-00358-00176494-00176910": "an account of their administration both", "jomstS0GPf0-00359-00176911-00177213": "to the Senate and to the people so it", "jomstS0GPf0-00360-00177214-00177455": "was important that the council's", "jomstS0GPf0-00361-00177456-00177891": "maintain the goodwill of both the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00362-00177892-00178761": "and the people what were the checks", "jomstS0GPf0-00363-00178762-00179586": "against the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00364-00179587-00179901": "the senate had to take the multitude", "jomstS0GPf0-00365-00179902-00180244": "into account and respect the wishes of", "jomstS0GPf0-00366-00180245-00180519": "the people foreign matters directly", "jomstS0GPf0-00367-00180520-00181144": "affecting the Senators for instance in", "jomstS0GPf0-00368-00181145-00181425": "case of a law diminishing the", "jomstS0GPf0-00369-00181426-00181752": "traditional authority of the senate are", "jomstS0GPf0-00370-00181753-00182175": "depriving senators of certain dignity or", "jomstS0GPf0-00371-00182176-00182545": "even actually reducing the property of", "jomstS0GPf0-00372-00182546-00183382": "senators in such cases the people the", "jomstS0GPf0-00373-00183383-00183694": "people had the power to pass or reject", "jomstS0GPf0-00374-00183695-00184243": "such a law in their assemblies and in", "jomstS0GPf0-00375-00184244-00184447": "addition according to polybius if the", "jomstS0GPf0-00376-00184448-00184752": "tribune ition if the tribunes impose", "jomstS0GPf0-00377-00184753-00185187": "their veto the Senate would be not only", "jomstS0GPf0-00378-00185188-00185410": "be unable to pass a decree but it could", "jomstS0GPf0-00379-00185411-00185754": "not even hold a meeting and because the", "jomstS0GPf0-00380-00185755-00186360": "tribunes", "jomstS0GPf0-00381-00186361-00186719": "were required to have a regard for the", "jomstS0GPf0-00382-00186720-00187028": "people's wishes the senate stood in all", "jomstS0GPf0-00383-00187029-00187701": "of the multitude and could not neglect", "jomstS0GPf0-00384-00187702-00188384": "the feelings of the people but as a", "jomstS0GPf0-00385-00188385-00188769": "counterbalance now what what check is", "jomstS0GPf0-00386-00188770-00189078": "there was there against the people you", "jomstS0GPf0-00387-00189079-00189258": "saw the checks against the council's or", "jomstS0GPf0-00388-00189259-00189459": "so the checks against the Senate what", "jomstS0GPf0-00389-00189460-00189840": "about the people as a counterbalance the", "jomstS0GPf0-00390-00189841-00190235": "people were not entirely independent of", "jomstS0GPf0-00391-00190236-00191345": "the Senate but they were bound to", "jomstS0GPf0-00392-00191346-00191940": "observe its wishes also collectively and", "jomstS0GPf0-00393-00191941-00192628": "individually individually", "jomstS0GPf0-00394-00192629-00192902": "in a matter of contracts for example", "jomstS0GPf0-00395-00192903-00193199": "contracts were given throughout all of", "jomstS0GPf0-00396-00193200-00193611": "Italy by the sensors for repairing", "jomstS0GPf0-00397-00193612-00193853": "construction of public works and public", "jomstS0GPf0-00398-00193854-00194264": "buildings then there was the matter of", "jomstS0GPf0-00399-00194265-00194496": "the collection of revenues from rivers", "jomstS0GPf0-00400-00194497-00194723": "and harbors and mines and land", "jomstS0GPf0-00401-00194724-00195038": "everything in a word that came under the", "jomstS0GPf0-00402-00195039-00195408": "control of the Roman government and in", "jomstS0GPf0-00403-00195409-00195629": "all of these things the people were", "jomstS0GPf0-00404-00195630-00196409": "engaged either as contractors or as", "jomstS0GPf0-00405-00196410-00196686": "putting up their property as security", "jomstS0GPf0-00406-00196687-00197264": "for the contractors or in selling", "jomstS0GPf0-00407-00197265-00197690": "supplies or making loans to the", "jomstS0GPf0-00408-00197691-00197925": "contractors or as engaging in the work", "jomstS0GPf0-00409-00197926-00199015": "and in the employ of the contractors", "jomstS0GPf0-00410-00199016-00199385": "over all these transactions says", "jomstS0GPf0-00411-00199386-00200023": "polybius the senate had complete control", "jomstS0GPf0-00412-00200024-00200566": "for example it could extend the time on", "jomstS0GPf0-00413-00200567-00201343": "a contract and thus assist contractors", "jomstS0GPf0-00414-00201344-00201665": "or in case of unforeseen accident it", "jomstS0GPf0-00415-00201666-00202280": "could relieve the contractors of a", "jomstS0GPf0-00416-00202281-00202817": "portion of their obligation or it could", "jomstS0GPf0-00417-00202818-00203180": "even release them all together if they", "jomstS0GPf0-00418-00203181-00203717": "were ABS absolutely unable to fulfil the", "jomstS0GPf0-00419-00203718-00204386": "contract so in many ways the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00420-00204387-00204813": "could inflict great hardships upon the", "jomstS0GPf0-00421-00204814-00205031": "contractors or on the other hand they", "jomstS0GPf0-00422-00205032-00205321": "could grant great indulgences to the", "jomstS0GPf0-00423-00205323-00205740": "contractors but in every case the appeal", "jomstS0GPf0-00424-00205741-00206316": "came to the Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00425-00206317-00206653": "and the senate's acekard of course was", "jomstS0GPf0-00426-00206654-00207373": "its control of the purse strings also", "jomstS0GPf0-00427-00207373-00207696": "the judges were taken from the senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00428-00207698-00208038": "and chosen from the Senate and the time", "jomstS0GPf0-00429-00208039-00208281": "of Bolivia's for the majority of trials", "jomstS0GPf0-00430-00208282-00208725": "in which the charges were heavy and", "jomstS0GPf0-00431-00208726-00209173": "consequently the people were cautious", "jomstS0GPf0-00432-00209173-00209629": "about resisting or actively opposing the", "jomstS0GPf0-00433-00209630-00210057": "will of the Senate because they were", "jomstS0GPf0-00434-00210058-00210267": "uncertain as to when they might need the", "jomstS0GPf0-00435-00210269-00210927": "Senate aide and in a similar way the", "jomstS0GPf0-00436-00210928-00211377": "people were cautious about rationally", "jomstS0GPf0-00437-00211378-00211642": "rashly resisting the will of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00438-00211642-00212142": "constants because one in all might in", "jomstS0GPf0-00439-00212144-00212338": "one way or another becomes subject to", "jomstS0GPf0-00440-00212339-00212848": "the absolute power of the council's at", "jomstS0GPf0-00441-00212848-00213742": "some time", "jomstS0GPf0-00442-00213744-00214694": "Bolivia's summed it up in this way", "jomstS0GPf0-00443-00214694-00214994": "when any one of the three classes", "jomstS0GPf0-00444-00214994-00215942": "becomes puffed up and", "jomstS0GPf0-00445-00215944-00216669": "displays", "jomstS0GPf0-00446-00216671-00217794": "an inclination to be overly encroaching", "jomstS0GPf0-00447-00217794-00218140": "the mutual interdependency of all the", "jomstS0GPf0-00448-00218141-00218408": "three and the possibility of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00449-00218409-00218883": "pretensions of anyone being checked and", "jomstS0GPf0-00450-00218884-00219091": "thwarted by the others must surely check", "jomstS0GPf0-00451-00219092-00219655": "this tendency and so the proper", "jomstS0GPf0-00452-00219656-00220327": "equilibrium is maintained by the", "jomstS0GPf0-00453-00220328-00220540": "impulsive pneus of the one part being", "jomstS0GPf0-00454-00220541-00221094": "checked by its fear of the other app", "jomstS0GPf0-00455-00221096-00221457": "Olivia's account may not have been an", "jomstS0GPf0-00456-00221458-00221869": "exact representation of the true stage", "jomstS0GPf0-00457-00221869-00222277": "of the Roman system but he was on the", "jomstS0GPf0-00458-00222278-00223123": "scene and he was writing to tell us what", "jomstS0GPf0-00459-00223123-00223576": "he saw with his own eyes not through the", "jomstS0GPf0-00460-00223577-00223912": "eyes or someone else to what better", "jomstS0GPf0-00461-00223913-00224367": "witness", "jomstS0GPf0-00462-00224369-00224788": "can we have the theory of a mixed", "jomstS0GPf0-00463-00224789-00225013": "constitution that's four hours is a", "jomstS0GPf0-00464-00225014-00225253": "mixed Constitution checks and balance", "jomstS0GPf0-00465-00225254-00225514": "separation of power the theory of a", "jomstS0GPf0-00466-00225515-00225994": "mixed constitution had had it's a great", "jomstS0GPf0-00467-00225994-00226402": "measure of success in the Roman Republic", "jomstS0GPf0-00468-00226403-00227058": "and is not surprising therefore that the", "jomstS0GPf0-00469-00227059-00227494": "constitutional framers were familiar", "jomstS0GPf0-00470-00227494-00228048": "with the works of polybius or that", "jomstS0GPf0-00471-00228048-00228381": "Montesquieu should have been influenced", "jomstS0GPf0-00472-00228382-00228507": "by the checks and balances the", "jomstS0GPf0-00473-00228508-00228810": "separation of powers in the Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00474-00228811-00229080": "constitutional system a clear element of", "jomstS0GPf0-00475-00229081-00229488": "which was the control over the purse", "jomstS0GPf0-00476-00229489-00229975": "vested solely in the Senate in the", "jomstS0GPf0-00477-00229976-00230503": "heyday of the Republic so mr. president", "jomstS0GPf0-00478-00230504-00230890": "in my presentations today and here too", "jomstS0GPf0-00479-00230891-00231617": "for I have", "jomstS0GPf0-00480-00231617-00232292": "called attention to the similarity", "jomstS0GPf0-00481-00232294-00232701": "between history of the Romans and our", "jomstS0GPf0-00482-00232702-00233205": "own history I have drawn many parallels", "jomstS0GPf0-00483-00233206-00233421": "between our own republic and the", "jomstS0GPf0-00484-00233421-00233642": "historical meanderings of that ancient", "jomstS0GPf0-00485-00233644-00234167": "republic that rose and declined along", "jomstS0GPf0-00486-00234169-00234671": "the banks of the Tiber River a parallel", "jomstS0GPf0-00487-00234673-00235142": "which induced someone in an earlier", "jomstS0GPf0-00488-00235144-00235584": "American generation to name the tiny", "jomstS0GPf0-00489-00235585-00235848": "stream that once flowed across the", "jomstS0GPf0-00490-00235848-00236562": "present-day mall Tiber Creek his own MA", "jomstS0GPf0-00491-00236563-00236951": "it is my own sincere prayer however that", "jomstS0GPf0-00492-00236952-00237483": "the United States will not follow a", "jomstS0GPf0-00493-00237484-00238416": "course parallel to the Roman Republic", "jomstS0GPf0-00494-00238417-00239063": "and its inexorable and decline and", "jomstS0GPf0-00495-00239064-00239921": "decadence mr. president worthy scholars", "jomstS0GPf0-00496-00239923-00240351": "and thoughtful authors have exhausted", "jomstS0GPf0-00497-00240352-00240680": "rivers of ink and attempting to analyze", "jomstS0GPf0-00498-00240681-00240923": "the decline and fall of the Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00499-00240925-00241484": "Republic and the subsequent empire among", "jomstS0GPf0-00500-00241485-00241713": "the foremost of these author historians", "jomstS0GPf0-00501-00241714-00242219": "is Edward Gibbon Gibbons decline and", "jomstS0GPf0-00502-00242221-00242552": "fall the Roman Empire is an income", "jomstS0GPf0-00503-00242553-00243048": "incontestable historical classic and no", "jomstS0GPf0-00504-00243048-00243500": "competent grasp of Roman historiography", "jomstS0GPf0-00505-00243501-00243967": "can be achieved without taking get given", "jomstS0GPf0-00506-00243969-00244553": "into consideration Edward Gibbon if you", "jomstS0GPf0-00507-00244554-00245092": "haven't read his volumes read them", "jomstS0GPf0-00508-00245094-00245466": "whereas Polly be about the rise of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00509-00245467-00245946": "Roman Republic and its greatness given", "jomstS0GPf0-00510-00245946-00246269": "wrote about the decline and fall of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00511-00246269-00246658": "Roman Empire which followed on after the", "jomstS0GPf0-00512-00246659-00247241": "Republic however given outlines a case", "jomstS0GPf0-00513-00247242-00247617": "for Rome decline which with which few if", "jomstS0GPf0-00514-00247617-00248096": "any subsequent historians will agree", "jomstS0GPf0-00515-00248096-00248941": "Gibbon charges Christianity with", "jomstS0GPf0-00516-00248942-00249473": "the decline and fall of Rome he cites", "jomstS0GPf0-00517-00249475-00249944": "Christianity as being the major cause of", "jomstS0GPf0-00518-00249946-00250821": "declines of Rome's decline now givens", "jomstS0GPf0-00519-00250821-00251451": "assertion is not an atheist diatribe", "jomstS0GPf0-00520-00251452-00251721": "against Christianity as some people", "jomstS0GPf0-00521-00251723-00252782": "might assume Gibbons position is that", "jomstS0GPf0-00522-00252783-00253650": "the otherworldly orientation", "jomstS0GPf0-00523-00253651-00254173": "of Christianity its exclusive istic", "jomstS0GPf0-00524-00254175-00254717": "monotheism its withdraw from the larger", "jomstS0GPf0-00525-00254719-00254925": "society its condemnation of", "jomstS0GPf0-00526-00254926-00255521": "Mediterranean culture its fostering of", "jomstS0GPf0-00527-00255521-00256287": "monasticism", "jomstS0GPf0-00528-00256288-00256996": "and it's contemplative emphasis when", "jomstS0GPf0-00529-00256998-00257573": "taken together refocus the people's", "jomstS0GPf0-00530-00257575-00257876": "attention on spiritual value to the", "jomstS0GPf0-00531-00257877-00258362": "detriment of the practicality the civic", "jomstS0GPf0-00532-00258363-00258826": "activism and the aggressiveness that", "jomstS0GPf0-00533-00258827-00259184": "characterized and gave rise to the Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00534-00259185-00260104": "attitude toward life conversely", "jomstS0GPf0-00535-00260105-00260774": "while given was acquainted with and", "jomstS0GPf0-00536-00260775-00261391": "recounted the evidences of Rome's", "jomstS0GPf0-00537-00261392-00262172": "decline none of which Christianity was", "jomstS0GPf0-00538-00262173-00262594": "responsible for moral decadence", "jomstS0GPf0-00539-00262595-00262978": "tyrannical Emperor's barbarian", "jomstS0GPf0-00540-00262979-00263665": "incursions the decline of the small", "jomstS0GPf0-00541-00263666-00264133": "family farms the vanishing peasantry", "jomstS0GPf0-00542-00264134-00264506": "depletion of soils and accessible", "jomstS0GPf0-00543-00264507-00264719": "mineral resources and the collapse of", "jomstS0GPf0-00544-00264720-00265252": "the faith in the old gods Gibbon treats", "jomstS0GPf0-00545-00265253-00265490": "all of these as being merely", "jomstS0GPf0-00546-00265491-00266129": "coincidental with Rome's decline minor", "jomstS0GPf0-00547-00266130-00266609": "distractions and sideshows around the", "jomstS0GPf0-00548-00266610-00267064": "center rain main event namely", "jomstS0GPf0-00549-00267065-00267920": "Christianity is gnawing away at the", "jomstS0GPf0-00550-00267921-00268304": "Empire superstructure certainly no", "jomstS0GPf0-00551-00268305-00268766": "informed student a Roman history can", "jomstS0GPf0-00552-00268767-00269313": "ignore given achievement both as a", "jomstS0GPf0-00553-00269314-00269578": "historian and as an interpreter of", "jomstS0GPf0-00554-00269579-00270083": "ancient Roman civilization but the", "jomstS0GPf0-00555-00270084-00270793": "decline and fall of the Roman Empire an", "jomstS0GPf0-00556-00270794-00271443": "undeniable classic", "jomstS0GPf0-00557-00271444-00272565": "there's not the last word", "jomstS0GPf0-00558-00272566-00273445": "on ancient wrong", "jomstS0GPf0-00559-00273446-00274348": "because during the almost 200 years", "jomstS0GPf0-00560-00274349-00275050": "since Gibbon wrote his masterpiece we", "jomstS0GPf0-00561-00275051-00275434": "witnessed a revolution in historical", "jomstS0GPf0-00562-00275435-00275769": "methodology and a reformation in our", "jomstS0GPf0-00563-00275770-00276076": "comprehension of the causes of Rome", "jomstS0GPf0-00564-00276077-00276849": "failure for example will durant who's", "jomstS0GPf0-00565-00276850-00277515": "who had a political and cultural", "jomstS0GPf0-00566-00277516-00278089": "influence on the early part of this", "jomstS0GPf0-00567-00278090-00278416": "century broadly represents the 20th", "jomstS0GPf0-00568-00278417-00278995": "century perspective of the causes of", "jomstS0GPf0-00569-00278996-00279425": "Rome's", "jomstS0GPf0-00570-00279426-00280019": "decline and decay in the story of", "jomstS0GPf0-00571-00280020-00280400": "civilization will durant asserts that", "jomstS0GPf0-00572-00280401-00280877": "rome was already in decline when", "jomstS0GPf0-00573-00280878-00281617": "Christianity emerged on the scene and", "jomstS0GPf0-00574-00281618-00282118": "eroding faith in the Greco Roman", "jomstS0GPf0-00575-00282119-00282599": "pantheon of deities a decline in family", "jomstS0GPf0-00576-00282600-00283307": "life rotting public and individual", "jomstS0GPf0-00577-00283308-00283630": "morality the corrosion of discipline", "jomstS0GPf0-00578-00283631-00284216": "patriotism and the military esprit the", "jomstS0GPf0-00579-00284217-00284423": "abandonment of the land by the peasant", "jomstS0GPf0-00580-00284424-00284833": "classes agricultural decline", "jomstS0GPf0-00581-00284834-00285305": "deforestation Civil War class struggle", "jomstS0GPf0-00582-00285306-00285623": "international warfare Praetorian", "jomstS0GPf0-00583-00285624-00285926": "intrigues and conspiracies assassination", "jomstS0GPf0-00584-00285927-00286376": "violence civil disorder bureaucratic", "jomstS0GPf0-00585-00286377-00286694": "despotism economic depression stifling", "jomstS0GPf0-00586-00286695-00287084": "taxes in corruption in government mad", "jomstS0GPf0-00587-00287085-00287681": "Emperor's pestilences playing games &", "jomstS0GPf0-00588-00287682-00288251": "circuses free bread the welfare mom all", "jomstS0GPf0-00589-00288252-00288644": "of thee", "jomstS0GPf0-00590-00288645-00289219": "all of thee", "jomstS0GPf0-00591-00289220-00289867": "aight away from moral and spiritual and", "jomstS0GPf0-00592-00289868-00290167": "social under pending underpinnings of", "jomstS0GPf0-00593-00290168-00291037": "the Roman state and accelerated its", "jomstS0GPf0-00594-00291038-00291553": "plunge into hopeless impotence and", "jomstS0GPf0-00595-00291554-00292081": "eventual obscurity as a military power", "jomstS0GPf0-00596-00292082-00292714": "and territorial empire and against such", "jomstS0GPf0-00597-00292715-00293007": "a backdrop of crises and fecklessness", "jomstS0GPf0-00598-00293008-00293428": "and drift Christianity served not as a", "jomstS0GPf0-00599-00293429-00293893": "cause of decay and collapse but as a", "jomstS0GPf0-00600-00293894-00294772": "lifeboat for a despairing populace", "jomstS0GPf0-00601-00294773-00295266": "Rome was already a cracker shell when", "jomstS0GPf0-00602-00295267-00296687": "Christianity ascended the stage", "jomstS0GPf0-00603-00296688-00297972": "so the fate of Rome was sealed by the", "jomstS0GPf0-00604-00297973-00298392": "one by one donations of power and", "jomstS0GPf0-00605-00298393-00298662": "prerogative with the Senate plucked from", "jomstS0GPf0-00606-00298663-00299271": "its own quiver and voluntarily delivered", "jomstS0GPf0-00607-00299272-00299619": "into the hands first Julius Caesar and", "jomstS0GPf0-00608-00299620-00300366": "Octavian and then into the trust of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00609-00300367-00300651": "succession of Caligula's Nero's and", "jomstS0GPf0-00610-00300652-00301326": "comedies and elagabalus ease and all who", "jomstS0GPf0-00611-00301327-00302042": "followed until at last the ancient noble", "jomstS0GPf0-00612-00302043-00302403": "ideals of the Roman Republic had been", "jomstS0GPf0-00613-00302404-00302741": "dissolved in the stinking brew of", "jomstS0GPf0-00614-00302742-00303030": "Imperial debauchery and tyranny and", "jomstS0GPf0-00615-00303031-00303336": "megalomania and rubble into which the", "jomstS0GPf0-00616-00303337-00304011": "Roman Empire eventually sank at the", "jomstS0GPf0-00617-00304012-00304329": "height of the Republic the Roman Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00618-00304330-00304841": "was the only agency that possessed the", "jomstS0GPf0-00619-00304842-00305166": "authority the perspective and the", "jomstS0GPf0-00620-00305167-00305520": "popular aura to debate and investigate", "jomstS0GPf0-00621-00305521-00305880": "in commission and correct the problems", "jomstS0GPf0-00622-00305881-00306144": "that confronted the Roman state and its", "jomstS0GPf0-00623-00306145-00306495": "citizens but the Senate's laws of will", "jomstS0GPf0-00624-00306496-00307263": "and its eagerness its eagerness to hand", "jomstS0GPf0-00625-00307264-00307688": "over its responsibilities", "jomstS0GPf0-00626-00307689-00308012": "to a one-man government man on a white", "jomstS0GPf0-00627-00308013-00308551": "horse the dictator later an emperor", "jomstS0GPf0-00628-00308552-00309502": "doomed wrong and predestined Rome", "jomstS0GPf0-00629-00309503-00310330": "decline and ultimate fall", "jomstS0GPf0-00630-00310331-00310612": "now mr. president to those political", "jomstS0GPf0-00631-00310613-00310924": "midwives who were attendant at the birth", "jomstS0GPf0-00632-00310925-00311317": "of our own Republic George Washington", "jomstS0GPf0-00633-00311318-00311563": "Alexander Hamilton Benjamin Franklin", "jomstS0GPf0-00634-00311564-00312622": "James Madison James Wilson Elbridge", "jomstS0GPf0-00635-00312623-00313486": "Gerry and others for among the wisest", "jomstS0GPf0-00636-00313487-00313822": "men of their time and this or any other", "jomstS0GPf0-00637-00313823-00314410": "country many of them had served in the", "jomstS0GPf0-00638-00314411-00314653": "Continental and Confederation congresses", "jomstS0GPf0-00639-00314654-00314977": "and in state legislatures and all of", "jomstS0GPf0-00640-00314978-00315615": "them were exceptional and reflective men", "jomstS0GPf0-00641-00315616-00315865": "many of those constitutional framers", "jomstS0GPf0-00642-00315866-00316057": "were well acquainted with Cicero and", "jomstS0GPf0-00643-00316058-00316350": "Bolivia sand Livius and Tacitus and", "jomstS0GPf0-00644-00316351-00316639": "plutarch and with the glories of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00645-00316640-00317125": "ancient Roman Republic and those", "jomstS0GPf0-00646-00317126-00318021": "brilliant men borrowed from the", "jomstS0GPf0-00647-00318022-00318453": "best of ancient Rome they purposefully", "jomstS0GPf0-00648-00318454-00318771": "and deliberately named the upper chamber", "jomstS0GPf0-00649-00318772-00319413": "of the Congress the Senate and just as", "jomstS0GPf0-00650-00319414-00319680": "carefully they set in place a system of", "jomstS0GPf0-00651-00319681-00319971": "checks and balances and separation of", "jomstS0GPf0-00652-00319972-00320183": "powers and large the control of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00653-00320184-00320831": "purse in the people's branch to prevent", "jomstS0GPf0-00654-00320832-00321509": "the rise of a new coinage of Imperial", "jomstS0GPf0-00655-00321510-00322043": "executives in the Federation that they", "jomstS0GPf0-00656-00322044-00322934": "created mr. president ask unanimous", "jomstS0GPf0-00657-00322935-00323283": "consent that I means speak beyond the", "jomstS0GPf0-00658-00323284-00323667": "hour for no more than five minutes the", "jomstS0GPf0-00659-00323668-00324093": "senator has 56 minutes remaining in his", "jomstS0GPf0-00660-00324094-00324504": "original time I think the chair I asked", "jomstS0GPf0-00661-00324505-00324788": "that the statements show no interruption", "jomstS0GPf0-00662-00324789-00325559": "without objection mr. president in our", "jomstS0GPf0-00663-00325560-00326288": "own times we see", "jomstS0GPf0-00664-00326289-00326853": "the same problem same kinds of dilemmas", "jomstS0GPf0-00665-00326854-00327060": "that the hand of history wrote large", "jomstS0GPf0-00666-00327061-00327501": "upon Rome's slate being written upon", "jomstS0GPf0-00667-00327502-00328035": "America's sleep in difficult times and", "jomstS0GPf0-00668-00328036-00328452": "in times of crises many people grow", "jomstS0GPf0-00669-00328453-00328869": "impatient as they grew impatient during", "jomstS0GPf0-00670-00328870-00329043": "the French Revolution and elevated", "jomstS0GPf0-00671-00329044-00329348": "Napoleon to the Empress Emperor ship as", "jomstS0GPf0-00672-00329349-00329589": "they grew impatient during the Russian", "jomstS0GPf0-00673-00329590-00330036": "Revolution and elevated linen to the", "jomstS0GPf0-00674-00330037-00330372": "head of state as they grew impatient to", "jomstS0GPf0-00675-00330373-00330588": "during depression-era Germany and", "jomstS0GPf0-00676-00330589-00330876": "elevated ADA Adolf Hitler to the", "jomstS0GPf0-00677-00330877-00331148": "presidency and the chancellorship as", "jomstS0GPf0-00678-00331149-00331491": "they grew impatient in Cuba and elevated", "jomstS0GPf0-00679-00331492-00332217": "Fidel Castro to the dictatorship we seem", "jomstS0GPf0-00680-00332218-00332745": "in these times to have reached the stage", "jomstS0GPf0-00681-00332746-00333237": "where we remain in the state of crisis", "jomstS0GPf0-00682-00333238-00335730": "or semi crisis or student crisis", "jomstS0GPf0-00683-00335731-00336156": "American people have grown impatient and", "jomstS0GPf0-00684-00336157-00336459": "they're demanding solutions to the", "jomstS0GPf0-00685-00336460-00336828": "serious problem solutions that do not", "jomstS0GPf0-00686-00336829-00337383": "lend themselves to easy thinking", "jomstS0GPf0-00687-00337384-00337637": "problems that do not lend themselves to", "jomstS0GPf0-00688-00337638-00338082": "easy and quick solutions the solutions", "jomstS0GPf0-00689-00338083-00338280": "to these problems will be painful and", "jomstS0GPf0-00690-00338281-00338807": "will take time perhaps years to succeed", "jomstS0GPf0-00691-00338808-00339084": "this is not a truth that many people", "jomstS0GPf0-00692-00339085-00339534": "wanted here many people would rather", "jomstS0GPf0-00693-00339535-00339903": "believe that quack remedies such as the", "jomstS0GPf0-00694-00339904-00340584": "line-item veto and enhanced rescissions", "jomstS0GPf0-00695-00340585-00341010": "power in the hands of presidents will", "jomstS0GPf0-00696-00341011-00341355": "somehow miraculously solve the fiscal", "jomstS0GPf0-00697-00341356-00341733": "situation and eliminate the monstrous", "jomstS0GPf0-00698-00341734-00343899": "deficits that confront the nation", "jomstS0GPf0-00699-00343900-00344406": "all too many people would perhaps prefer", "jomstS0GPf0-00700-00344407-00344794": "to abolish the Congress and Institute", "jomstS0GPf0-00701-00344795-00345442": "one man government from now on some", "jomstS0GPf0-00702-00345443-00345684": "people have no patience with", "jomstS0GPf0-00703-00345685-00346165": "constitutions for that matter but mr.", "jomstS0GPf0-00704-00346166-00346848": "president let us let us study wrong", "jomstS0GPf0-00705-00346849-00347065": "suppose I'll go about another five", "jomstS0GPf0-00706-00347066-00347299": "minutes but only be interrupted ask", "jomstS0GPf0-00707-00347300-00348192": "unanimous consent I may have that time", "jomstS0GPf0-00708-00348193-00348848": "let us study Rome", "jomstS0GPf0-00709-00348849-00349091": "the important lesson that we can get", "jomstS0GPf0-00710-00349092-00349532": "from Rome for our purposes here is that", "jomstS0GPf0-00711-00349533-00350120": "when the Roman Senate gave away the", "jomstS0GPf0-00712-00350121-00350549": "power over the purse the Roman Senate", "jomstS0GPf0-00713-00350550-00350795": "gave away its power to check the", "jomstS0GPf0-00714-00350796-00351371": "executive and from that time on the", "jomstS0GPf0-00715-00351372-00351725": "Senate decline and as we have noted it", "jomstS0GPf0-00716-00351726-00352385": "was only a matter of time and when the", "jomstS0GPf0-00717-00352386-00352846": "foundation weaken the structure", "jomstS0GPf0-00718-00352847-00353855": "collapsed and the Roman Republic fail", "jomstS0GPf0-00719-00353856-00354089": "this lesson is as true today as it was", "jomstS0GPf0-00720-00354090-00354800": "2,000 years ago does anyone mr.", "jomstS0GPf0-00721-00354801-00355321": "president does anyone really imagine", "jomstS0GPf0-00722-00355322-00355583": "that the splendors of this capital city", "jomstS0GPf0-00723-00355584-00355967": "stand or fall with mentions and", "jomstS0GPf0-00724-00355968-00356273": "monuments and buildings and piles of", "jomstS0GPf0-00725-00356274-00356759": "masonry these are but brick and mortar", "jomstS0GPf0-00726-00356760-00357440": "bricks and mortar lifeless thing and", "jomstS0GPf0-00727-00357441-00357913": "whether they collapse are our", "jomstS0GPf0-00728-00357914-00358318": "rehabilitative means little or nothing", "jomstS0GPf0-00729-00358319-00358645": "when measured on the great clock tower", "jomstS0GPf0-00730-00358646-00359165": "of time", "jomstS0GPf0-00731-00359166-00359470": "but the survival of the American", "jomstS0GPf0-00732-00359471-00359888": "constitutional system the foundation", "jomstS0GPf0-00733-00359889-00360052": "upon which the superstructure of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00734-00360053-00360670": "Republic rests finds its firmus support", "jomstS0GPf0-00735-00360671-00361076": "in the continued preservation of the", "jomstS0GPf0-00736-00361077-00361492": "delicate mechanism of texts and balances", "jomstS0GPf0-00737-00361493-00361916": "separation of power and the control of", "jomstS0GPf0-00738-00361917-00362549": "the purse which was some solemnly", "jomstS0GPf0-00739-00362550-00363397": "instituted by the founding fathers", "jomstS0GPf0-00740-00363398-00363860": "and for over 200 years", "jomstS0GPf0-00741-00363861-00364092": "from the beginning of the Republic to", "jomstS0GPf0-00742-00364093-00364709": "this very hour it has survived an", "jomstS0GPf0-00743-00364710-00365298": "unbroken continuity we received it from", "jomstS0GPf0-00744-00365299-00365763": "our fathers but as this surely has a", "jomstS0GPf0-00745-00365764-00366428": "known to our son and our daughter mr.", "jomstS0GPf0-00746-00366429-00367048": "president I close my reflections on the", "jomstS0GPf0-00747-00367049-00367907": "ancient Roman Republic with the words of", "jomstS0GPf0-00748-00367908-00368524": "George Washington from his speech on the", "jomstS0GPf0-00749-00368525-00368849": "centennial anniversary of George", "jomstS0GPf0-00750-00368850-00369093": "Washington's the streets of Daniel", "jomstS0GPf0-00751-00369094-00369464": "Webster from his speech on the", "jomstS0GPf0-00752-00369465-00369680": "centennial anniversary of George", "jomstS0GPf0-00753-00369681-00370424": "Washington in 1832", "jomstS0GPf0-00754-00370425-00370709": "other misfortunes may be born or their", "jomstS0GPf0-00755-00370710-00371126": "effects overcome if disastrous war", "jomstS0GPf0-00756-00371127-00371419": "should sweep our Commerce from the ocean", "jomstS0GPf0-00757-00371420-00371987": "another generation may renew it if it", "jomstS0GPf0-00758-00371988-00372611": "exhaust our treasury future industry may", "jomstS0GPf0-00759-00372612-00372929": "replenish it if a desolated lay waste", "jomstS0GPf0-00760-00372930-00373196": "our fields still under new cultivation", "jomstS0GPf0-00761-00373197-00373478": "they would grow green again and ripen to", "jomstS0GPf0-00762-00373479-00374009": "future harvests gay but a trifle at the", "jomstS0GPf0-00763-00374010-00374251": "walls of yonder capital were a crumble", "jomstS0GPf0-00764-00374252-00374564": "if his lofty pillars should fall and", "jomstS0GPf0-00765-00374565-00374726": "they're gorgeous decorations be all", "jomstS0GPf0-00766-00374727-00374954": "covered by the dust of the valley all", "jomstS0GPf0-00767-00374955-00375413": "these may be rebuilt but who shall", "jomstS0GPf0-00768-00375414-00375752": "reconstruct the fabric of demolished", "jomstS0GPf0-00769-00375753-00376028": "government who shall rare again the well", "jomstS0GPf0-00770-00376029-00376238": "proportioned columns of constitutional", "jomstS0GPf0-00771-00376239-00377008": "liberty we shall frame together", "jomstS0GPf0-00772-00377009-00377256": "the skillful architecture that unites", "jomstS0GPf0-00773-00377257-00377500": "national soft sovereignty with state", "jomstS0GPf0-00774-00377501-00377806": "rights with individual security and with", "jomstS0GPf0-00775-00377807-00378170": "public prosperity know if these columns", "jomstS0GPf0-00776-00378171-00378678": "ever fall they'll be raised not again", "jomstS0GPf0-00777-00378679-00378995": "back to coliseum and the parthenon they", "jomstS0GPf0-00778-00378996-00379254": "would be destined to a mournful a", "jomstS0GPf0-00779-00379255-00379694": "melancholia mortality bitter tears will", "jomstS0GPf0-00780-00379695-00380045": "flow over them however then were ever", "jomstS0GPf0-00781-00380046-00380323": "shed over the monuments of Roman or", "jomstS0GPf0-00782-00380324-00380591": "Greece and part for they will be the", "jomstS0GPf0-00783-00380592-00380833": "remnants of a more glorious edifice than", "jomstS0GPf0-00784-00380834-00381229": "green Greece or Rome ever solved the", "jomstS0GPf0-00785-00381230-00381621": "edifice of constitutional American", "jomstS0GPf0-00786-00381622-00382159": "liberty but now again thank my good", "jomstS0GPf0-00787-00382160-00382487": "friends senator Stevens senator Inouye", "jomstS0GPf0-00788-00382488-00382726": "and some nickels for their patients and", "jomstS0GPf0-00789-00382727-00382988": "their indulgence I thank the chair and I", "jomstS0GPf0-00790-00382989-00383240": "thank all senators I thank the two", "jomstS0GPf0-00791-00383241-00383482": "leaders for their accommodations and", "jomstS0GPf0-00792-00383483-00383884": "their curtis's in the forest and Lula", "jomstS0GPf0-00793-00383885-00384170": "Marty and all the other you have been so", "jomstS0GPf0-00794-00384171-00384344": "helpful and so accommodating and so", "jomstS0GPf0-00795-00384345-00384740": "thoughtful during these more than five", "jomstS0GPf0-00796-00384741-00385217": "months as I have cared for this series", "jomstS0GPf0-00797-00385218-00385463": "of one hour speeches on the line item", "jomstS0GPf0-00798-00385464-00385865": "veto I yield the floor"}}, {"audio_id": "joBCDx_e8qU", "text": {"joBCDx_e8qU-00000-00001248-00001511": "why are you [__] with", "joBCDx_e8qU-00001-00001512-00001679": "my me", "joBCDx_e8qU-00002-00001680-00001934": "why why this", "joBCDx_e8qU-00003-00001935-00002199": "that's the weirdest [__] man", "joBCDx_e8qU-00004-00002200-00002607": "why he said why am i [__] with him", "joBCDx_e8qU-00005-00002608-00003638": "like [__] with this guy", "joBCDx_e8qU-00006-00003639-00003831": "why are you [__] with me uh because", "joBCDx_e8qU-00007-00003832-00004206": "we're supposed to kill each other", "joBCDx_e8qU-00008-00004207-00004591": "move hole", "joBCDx_e8qU-00009-00004592-00004939": "oh keep running"}}, {"audio_id": "joQHYdl-i8Y", "text": {"joQHYdl-i8Y-00000-00000000-00000191": "woody and bulls i crossed the grand", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00001-00000192-00000303": "canyon", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00002-00000304-00000559": "toy story hello people today i am going", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00003-00000560-00000686": "to share a theory", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00004-00000687-00000878": "he said theory because there is nothing", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00005-00000880-00001119": "to confirm it but that personally makes", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00006-00001120-00001374": "sense i found it on the hispanic channel", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00007-00001375-00001630": "el mundo desal and", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00008-00001632-00001847": "the theory says that vhs cannot be", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00009-00001848-00002055": "reversed but must be manually reversed", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00010-00002056-00002142": "to see them", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00011-00002143-00002318": "so when the television is turned on to", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00012-00002319-00002495": "prevent wadi from escaping", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00013-00002496-00002671": "instead of seeing the colors of when a", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00014-00002672-00002799": "vhs runs out", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00015-00002800-00003039": "what we see is the intro of the series", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00016-00003040-00003254": "as if it were an episode that began", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00017-00003255-00003511": "and later when wadi shows buzz that he", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00018-00003511-00003606": "had a program", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00019-00003607-00003822": "he is seen jumping the great canyon and", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00020-00003823-00003975": "in the background you can hear how", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00021-00003976-00004175": "jessie thanks wadi for coming", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00022-00004176-00004383": "then we see wadi sing the song along", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00023-00004384-00004486": "with the credits", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00024-00004487-00004686": "that is although they cancelled the", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00025-00004687-00004919": "program the final episode was produced", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00026-00004920-00005167": "and included in the vhc", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00027-00005168-00005399": "according to the comments a theory says", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00028-00005400-00005591": "that in a plot twist stinky pete the", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00029-00005592-00005783": "prospector was the villain and to avoid", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00030-00005784-00005967": "ruining the image of him he convinced", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00031-00005968-00006254": "jesse that there was no episode after it", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00032-00006255-00006446": "thank you i leave here the links of the", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00033-00006447-00007375": "original videos", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00034-00007376-00007559": "the real treasures are your friends and", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00035-00007559-00007855": "family before i go kids i want to share", "joQHYdl-i8Y-00036-00007856-00008072": "some"}}, {"audio_id": "j06z-oPyhiu", "text": {"j06z-oPyhiu-00000-00000016-00000214": "ladies and gents boys and girls hello", "j06z-oPyhiu-00001-00000215-00000407": "right i'm back", "j06z-oPyhiu-00002-00000408-00000767": "spending more money um i've bought today", "j06z-oPyhiu-00003-00000768-00001158": "uh delivered to my door today the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00004-00001159-00001278": "dual", "j06z-oPyhiu-00005-00001279-00001383": "pivot", "j06z-oPyhiu-00006-00001384-00001527": "arm from", "j06z-oPyhiu-00007-00001528-00001734": "quad lock i'm back buying quad lock", "j06z-oPyhiu-00008-00001735-00001895": "items", "j06z-oPyhiu-00009-00001896-00002134": "this i suppose is the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00010-00002135-00002263": "quad lock", "j06z-oPyhiu-00011-00002264-00002479": "equivalent then i say", "j06z-oPyhiu-00012-00002480-00002583": "to", "j06z-oPyhiu-00013-00002584-00002663": "the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00014-00002664-00002750": "ram", "j06z-oPyhiu-00015-00002751-00003095": "mount system this particular arm is off", "j06z-oPyhiu-00016-00003096-00003206": "my", "j06z-oPyhiu-00017-00003207-00003447": "double take adventure mirrors and quite", "j06z-oPyhiu-00018-00003447-00003711": "a strong robust piece of kit just a big", "j06z-oPyhiu-00019-00003711-00003822": "strong", "j06z-oPyhiu-00020-00003823-00003999": "knobbing on the end to tying up against", "j06z-oPyhiu-00021-00004000-00004238": "the balls come to that in a second", "j06z-oPyhiu-00022-00004239-00004599": "equivalent smaller lighter quad lock", "j06z-oPyhiu-00023-00004600-00004847": "version", "j06z-oPyhiu-00024-00004848-00005143": "it's actually finished off a bit nicer", "j06z-oPyhiu-00025-00005144-00005359": "than the ram stuff it's quite a nice", "j06z-oPyhiu-00026-00005360-00005511": "piece to create a bit more thought gone", "j06z-oPyhiu-00027-00005512-00005783": "into it there are some differences which", "j06z-oPyhiu-00028-00005784-00006047": "we need to understand uh of course the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00029-00006048-00006254": "clamping system here", "j06z-oPyhiu-00030-00006255-00006334": "uh", "j06z-oPyhiu-00031-00006335-00006719": "accommodates a cable so it helps tidy", "j06z-oPyhiu-00032-00006720-00006887": "things away if you're gonna be running", "j06z-oPyhiu-00033-00006888-00007191": "um a cable to your wireless charger or a", "j06z-oPyhiu-00034-00007192-00007478": "straightforward cable to your device so", "j06z-oPyhiu-00035-00007479-00007774": "that is one nice feature to it on this", "j06z-oPyhiu-00036-00007775-00007951": "side here you've got", "j06z-oPyhiu-00037-00007952-00008303": "a allen bolt for security if you'd want", "j06z-oPyhiu-00038-00008304-00008471": "just leave it on your bike and keep it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00039-00008472-00008710": "locked up and people would need tools or", "j06z-oPyhiu-00040-00008711-00009110": "you've got the option to run in the uh", "j06z-oPyhiu-00041-00009111-00009206": "thumb", "j06z-oPyhiu-00042-00009207-00009471": "bolt which will just replace that and it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00043-00009472-00009623": "goes straight in there i've done that on", "j06z-oPyhiu-00044-00009624-00009799": "my bike", "j06z-oPyhiu-00045-00009800-00010119": "now the difference is this end here and", "j06z-oPyhiu-00046-00010120-00010535": "that end basically only compatible with", "j06z-oPyhiu-00047-00010536-00010735": "the um", "j06z-oPyhiu-00048-00010736-00010846": "quad lock", "j06z-oPyhiu-00049-00010847-00011038": "handlebar mounts or mounts that you can", "j06z-oPyhiu-00050-00011039-00011319": "buy it for quad lock goods it's not", "j06z-oPyhiu-00051-00011320-00011510": "compatible with", "j06z-oPyhiu-00052-00011511-00011814": "um ram the ball is a different size the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00053-00011815-00012119": "ball on the quad lock is 20 millimeters", "j06z-oPyhiu-00054-00012120-00012359": "as opposed to the 25 millimeter balls", "j06z-oPyhiu-00055-00012360-00012542": "you find on", "j06z-oPyhiu-00056-00012543-00012910": "my mirror for example there the ram um", "j06z-oPyhiu-00057-00012911-00013247": "mounting system is 25 mil on", "j06z-oPyhiu-00058-00013247-00013622": "the general stuff so basically that is", "j06z-oPyhiu-00059-00013623-00013863": "the gubbins i bought two", "j06z-oPyhiu-00060-00013863-00014071": "a short one and a long one i've got the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00061-00014072-00014415": "long one installed on my t7 this one", "j06z-oPyhiu-00062-00014416-00014703": "may get used on mrs ryder guider's xt", "j06z-oPyhiu-00063-00014704-00014830": "250", "j06z-oPyhiu-00064-00014831-00014991": "so let's go and have a quick look at it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00065-00014991-00015447": "on my t7 and i'll show you why i think", "j06z-oPyhiu-00066-00015447-00015903": "i'm gonna like it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00067-00015904-00016166": "so here's my system on the bike itself", "j06z-oPyhiu-00068-00016168-00016399": "as you can see i have used here the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00069-00016400-00016750": "original mounting clamp which used to", "j06z-oPyhiu-00070-00016751-00016975": "have attached to it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00071-00016976-00017111": "direct", "j06z-oPyhiu-00072-00017112-00017327": "the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00073-00017328-00017519": "vibration dampener there", "j06z-oPyhiu-00074-00017520-00017719": "is now", "j06z-oPyhiu-00075-00017720-00017975": "installed between the mount", "j06z-oPyhiu-00076-00017976-00018214": "and the vibration dampener and my", "j06z-oPyhiu-00077-00018215-00018455": "wireless charging head as you can see", "j06z-oPyhiu-00078-00018456-00018679": "i've got the cable running down there", "j06z-oPyhiu-00079-00018680-00018847": "down the back of the clamp", "j06z-oPyhiu-00080-00018848-00019230": "and down to here now why do i like it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00081-00019231-00019414": "and i wasn't sure at first it took me a", "j06z-oPyhiu-00082-00019415-00019583": "few minutes until after i installed it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00083-00019584-00019711": "to work out", "j06z-oPyhiu-00084-00019712-00019950": "why i'd actually bought it and what the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00085-00019951-00020135": "benefits were going to be but let me", "j06z-oPyhiu-00086-00020136-00020263": "show you", "j06z-oPyhiu-00087-00020264-00020543": "so let's look at it from a non-bike view", "j06z-oPyhiu-00088-00020544-00020847": "as you can see i have my garmin zoomer", "j06z-oPyhiu-00089-00020848-00020950": "up there", "j06z-oPyhiu-00090-00020951-00021278": "my gps and that sort of all is in my eye", "j06z-oPyhiu-00091-00021279-00021503": "line with my clocks etc", "j06z-oPyhiu-00092-00021504-00021614": "now", "j06z-oPyhiu-00093-00021615-00021871": "you can see from a rider's point of view", "j06z-oPyhiu-00094-00021872-00022143": "i've got the mount i've got my wireless", "j06z-oPyhiu-00095-00022144-00022303": "charger", "j06z-oPyhiu-00096-00022304-00022519": "what it's benefited what it's allowed me", "j06z-oPyhiu-00097-00022520-00022703": "to have now is a little bit of", "j06z-oPyhiu-00098-00022704-00023022": "adjustability on the fly just by", "j06z-oPyhiu-00099-00023023-00023375": "undoing that knobbins so i can angle it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00100-00023376-00023694": "if the sun's on it or i'm just wanting a", "j06z-oPyhiu-00101-00023695-00023942": "different look different angle", "j06z-oPyhiu-00102-00023943-00024135": "um i don't want it out of the way i want", "j06z-oPyhiu-00103-00024136-00024303": "to tuck it out of the way i can easily", "j06z-oPyhiu-00104-00024304-00024414": "adjust it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00105-00024415-00024575": "and get it out of it wherever i need i'm", "j06z-oPyhiu-00106-00024576-00024775": "off-roading i don't want my phone here i", "j06z-oPyhiu-00107-00024776-00024894": "can either bang it away and put in my", "j06z-oPyhiu-00108-00024895-00025063": "pocket i can just fold", "j06z-oPyhiu-00109-00025064-00025486": "the uh the whole system away it's easily", "j06z-oPyhiu-00110-00025487-00025694": "removable um", "j06z-oPyhiu-00111-00025695-00025902": "without tools and i can say i like this", "j06z-oPyhiu-00112-00025904-00026094": "adjustability i can bring it closer", "j06z-oPyhiu-00113-00026095-00026470": "towards me i can have it there", "j06z-oPyhiu-00114-00026472-00026687": "and give you an angle like that", "j06z-oPyhiu-00115-00026688-00026902": "or i can just fold it all away nicely", "j06z-oPyhiu-00116-00026904-00027167": "without the use of tools and", "j06z-oPyhiu-00117-00027168-00027302": "depending what mood i'm in i like", "j06z-oPyhiu-00118-00027304-00027479": "everything in a line so and i've", "j06z-oPyhiu-00119-00027480-00027855": "struggled to get that with my setup", "j06z-oPyhiu-00120-00027856-00028046": "in the past and", "j06z-oPyhiu-00121-00028047-00028207": "i'm gonna like that i think it'll look", "j06z-oPyhiu-00122-00028208-00028583": "pretty decent i'll take a photo of it", "j06z-oPyhiu-00123-00028583-00028679": "with", "j06z-oPyhiu-00124-00028680-00029095": "the phone in the cradle on the actual", "j06z-oPyhiu-00125-00029095-00029262": "charging head there and show you the", "j06z-oPyhiu-00126-00029263-00029358": "whole", "j06z-oPyhiu-00127-00029360-00029535": "feel that i've got and like you see i", "j06z-oPyhiu-00128-00029536-00029695": "think it's good it's a solid piece of", "j06z-oPyhiu-00129-00029695-00029783": "kit", "j06z-oPyhiu-00130-00029783-00029999": "i like the uh micro adjustability and", "j06z-oPyhiu-00131-00030000-00030167": "it's easy to adjust", "j06z-oPyhiu-00132-00030168-00030423": "without tools now i like it a decent bit", "j06z-oPyhiu-00133-00030424-00030727": "of kit and it was only what 20", "j06z-oPyhiu-00134-00030727-00030967": "i mean about 20 about 24 quid each oh", "j06z-oPyhiu-00135-00030968-00031167": "sorry dollars i forgot where i was then", "j06z-oPyhiu-00136-00031168-00031511": "about 25 australian so not too bad all", "j06z-oPyhiu-00137-00031512-00031799": "right crack on see you again on another", "j06z-oPyhiu-00138-00031800-00031920": "one", "j06z-oPyhiu-00139-00031922-00032639": "[Music]", "j06z-oPyhiu-00140-00032639-00032847": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "j07OXDoRorY", "text": {"j07OXDoRorY-00000-00002072-00002191": "just um", "j07OXDoRorY-00001-00002192-00002391": "waiting to see if i can see myself live", "j07OXDoRorY-00002-00002392-00002639": "in the group alex doesn't know", "j07OXDoRorY-00003-00002640-00002815": "uh anything about this", "j07OXDoRorY-00004-00002816-00002991": "and he may cut me off because he might", "j07OXDoRorY-00005-00002992-00003126": "think i'm in a different in the wrong", "j07OXDoRorY-00006-00003127-00003343": "group but i wanted to come into the", "j07OXDoRorY-00007-00003344-00003575": "public group the shift to success public", "j07OXDoRorY-00008-00003576-00003670": "group", "j07OXDoRorY-00009-00003671-00003903": "and um i was thinking i was just", "j07OXDoRorY-00010-00003904-00004111": "reflecting back on my year", "j07OXDoRorY-00011-00004112-00004327": "as i'm a member of shift success and my", "j07OXDoRorY-00012-00004328-00004647": "wife and i joined success in", "j07OXDoRorY-00013-00004648-00004863": "march 2020", "j07OXDoRorY-00014-00004864-00004943": "and", "j07OXDoRorY-00015-00004944-00005102": "just been reflecting back on my year", "j07OXDoRorY-00016-00005103-00005238": "because", "j07OXDoRorY-00017-00005239-00005495": "this time last year", "j07OXDoRorY-00018-00005496-00005606": "i didn't know i was going to leave the", "j07OXDoRorY-00019-00005607-00005727": "police", "j07OXDoRorY-00020-00005728-00005918": "this time last year i didn't know i had", "j07OXDoRorY-00021-00005919-00006070": "a new um", "j07OXDoRorY-00022-00006071-00006254": "a new business idea", "j07OXDoRorY-00023-00006255-00006422": "going on and that i was going to leave", "j07OXDoRorY-00024-00006423-00006710": "the police i've been chem police for", "j07OXDoRorY-00025-00006711-00006806": "um", "j07OXDoRorY-00026-00006808-00007078": "19 years and i was really suffering and", "j07OXDoRorY-00027-00007079-00007303": "i really didn't want to um", "j07OXDoRorY-00028-00007304-00007567": "to carry on so i was very fortunate to", "j07OXDoRorY-00029-00007568-00007759": "find shift success", "j07OXDoRorY-00030-00007759-00008103": "and um shift success was gonna help me", "j07OXDoRorY-00031-00008104-00008278": "get out of the job but i had no idea", "j07OXDoRorY-00032-00008279-00008487": "this time last year", "j07OXDoRorY-00033-00008488-00008727": "that um i was going to be leaving the", "j07OXDoRorY-00034-00008728-00008895": "job so soon", "j07OXDoRorY-00035-00008896-00009063": "and i'm kind of thinking you know it's", "j07OXDoRorY-00036-00009064-00009399": "christmas and i wanted to um", "j07OXDoRorY-00037-00009400-00009759": "send alex a card uh send alex a card and", "j07OXDoRorY-00038-00009760-00009959": "um thank you", "j07OXDoRorY-00039-00009960-00010151": "and i just thought what better", "j07OXDoRorY-00040-00010152-00010414": "than to come into um", "j07OXDoRorY-00041-00010415-00010623": "the shift success group", "j07OXDoRorY-00042-00010624-00010895": "the public group and", "j07OXDoRorY-00043-00010896-00011214": "explain to you and share my", "j07OXDoRorY-00044-00011215-00011535": "my year with you you know and how shift", "j07OXDoRorY-00045-00011536-00011878": "success completely changed my life so", "j07OXDoRorY-00046-00011879-00012046": "again alex doesn't know i'm doing this", "j07OXDoRorY-00047-00012047-00012287": "i'm not sure if it's being broadcast out", "j07OXDoRorY-00048-00012288-00012487": "into the group i can't find it in the", "j07OXDoRorY-00049-00012488-00012606": "group so", "j07OXDoRorY-00050-00012607-00012774": "maybe um", "j07OXDoRorY-00051-00012775-00012958": "he'll allow this once", "j07OXDoRorY-00052-00012959-00013183": "once he's seen it and to be put into the", "j07OXDoRorY-00053-00013184-00013327": "group but", "j07OXDoRorY-00054-00013328-00013599": "so i want to sort of um", "j07OXDoRorY-00055-00013600-00013791": "explain to you what shift success did to", "j07OXDoRorY-00056-00013791-00013927": "me like i said this time last year i", "j07OXDoRorY-00057-00013928-00014038": "didn't know that i was gonna leave the", "j07OXDoRorY-00058-00014040-00014271": "police i was really miserable um and i", "j07OXDoRorY-00059-00014272-00014447": "didn't know i was about to leave the", "j07OXDoRorY-00060-00014447-00014694": "police and i left the police in march uh", "j07OXDoRorY-00061-00014695-00014999": "april 2021 um i handed my notice in in", "j07OXDoRorY-00062-00015000-00015075": "march", "j07OXDoRorY-00063-00015076-00015238": "2021", "j07OXDoRorY-00064-00015240-00015511": "and left in april 2021", "j07OXDoRorY-00065-00015512-00015671": "that day i was reflecting on that day", "j07OXDoRorY-00066-00015672-00015838": "14th of april i walked into the police", "j07OXDoRorY-00067-00015840-00016111": "station with some cakes i put the cakes", "j07OXDoRorY-00068-00016112-00016247": "on the table", "j07OXDoRorY-00069-00016247-00016454": "there was no one around and then", "j07OXDoRorY-00070-00016455-00016615": "[Music]", "j07OXDoRorY-00071-00016616-00016799": "got to about 10 o'clock i asked to leave", "j07OXDoRorY-00072-00016800-00016943": "and i went to tesco's and did my", "j07OXDoRorY-00073-00016944-00017055": "shopping and that was the end of my", "j07OXDoRorY-00074-00017056-00017335": "police career but you know 28th of", "j07OXDoRorY-00075-00017336-00017558": "december i started my new business my", "j07OXDoRorY-00076-00017559-00017775": "business with the help of everyone", "j07OXDoRorY-00077-00017776-00017863": "and", "j07OXDoRorY-00078-00017864-00018063": "shift success", "j07OXDoRorY-00079-00018064-00018319": "and since then i've grown a facebook", "j07OXDoRorY-00080-00018320-00018703": "group to almost 6 000 members i've done", "j07OXDoRorY-00081-00018704-00018999": "podcasts i've done youtube i've done", "j07OXDoRorY-00082-00019000-00019327": "almost um just over 50 000 pounds in", "j07OXDoRorY-00083-00019328-00019455": "turnover", "j07OXDoRorY-00084-00019456-00019711": "um i left the police you know i've been", "j07OXDoRorY-00085-00019712-00019871": "doing seminars", "j07OXDoRorY-00086-00019872-00020111": "um done loads and loads of personal", "j07OXDoRorY-00087-00020112-00020222": "development", "j07OXDoRorY-00088-00020223-00020630": "and um really ecstatic", "j07OXDoRorY-00089-00020631-00020967": "about 2022 2022 is just going to be", "j07OXDoRorY-00090-00020968-00021239": "an uh an awesome year", "j07OXDoRorY-00091-00021240-00021399": "so um", "j07OXDoRorY-00092-00021400-00021599": "you know we're all in this group you", "j07OXDoRorY-00093-00021600-00021743": "know because you're public sector", "j07OXDoRorY-00094-00021744-00021903": "workers and", "j07OXDoRorY-00095-00021904-00022014": "maybe you're not enjoying what you're", "j07OXDoRorY-00096-00022015-00022230": "doing you're looking for an alternative", "j07OXDoRorY-00097-00022231-00022463": "so i thought um my christmas thank you", "j07OXDoRorY-00098-00022464-00022663": "to alex and team shift success was to", "j07OXDoRorY-00099-00022664-00022878": "come into this group and sort of say", "j07OXDoRorY-00100-00022879-00023055": "you know this", "j07OXDoRorY-00101-00023056-00023294": "course that alex offers", "j07OXDoRorY-00102-00023295-00023599": "this experience this program this family", "j07OXDoRorY-00103-00023600-00023958": "that alex offers is life changing", "j07OXDoRorY-00104-00023959-00024230": "okay if you um if you've not done it or", "j07OXDoRorY-00105-00024231-00024311": "you've", "j07OXDoRorY-00106-00024312-00024511": "spoken to people about it but not signed", "j07OXDoRorY-00107-00024512-00024767": "up to it or you've been watching it or", "j07OXDoRorY-00108-00024768-00024999": "considering it you know this can really", "j07OXDoRorY-00109-00025000-00025222": "really change your life and it's changed", "j07OXDoRorY-00110-00025223-00025558": "my life in so many different ways and", "j07OXDoRorY-00111-00025559-00025774": "obviously i'm now free of the police i'm", "j07OXDoRorY-00112-00025775-00026022": "not working christmas um but i'm going", "j07OXDoRorY-00113-00026023-00026223": "to choose to work a little bit on my own", "j07OXDoRorY-00114-00026224-00026480": "business over christmas because my niche", "j07OXDoRorY-00115-00026481-00026607": "[Music]", "j07OXDoRorY-00116-00026608-00026758": "my niche is", "j07OXDoRorY-00117-00026760-00026943": "off over christmas so i want to get in", "j07OXDoRorY-00118-00026944-00027151": "touch with my niche and", "j07OXDoRorY-00119-00027152-00027239": "um", "j07OXDoRorY-00120-00027239-00027551": "you know speak to them over christmas", "j07OXDoRorY-00121-00027552-00028031": "so if you've not um you know if you're", "j07OXDoRorY-00122-00028032-00028199": "if you're considering doing shift", "j07OXDoRorY-00123-00028200-00028567": "success or you're not um quite yet on to", "j07OXDoRorY-00124-00028568-00028743": "shift to success or you're not quite", "j07OXDoRorY-00125-00028744-00029023": "sold about shift success or you're just", "j07OXDoRorY-00126-00029024-00029135": "um", "j07OXDoRorY-00127-00029136-00029495": "chilling out uh look i'm i'm live now", "j07OXDoRorY-00128-00029495-00029670": "and so i'll start again because i think", "j07OXDoRorY-00129-00029672-00029862": "i'm live in the group now so", "j07OXDoRorY-00130-00029863-00030079": "um i've just been doing some some work", "j07OXDoRorY-00131-00030080-00030327": "and i've been reflecting on um the last", "j07OXDoRorY-00132-00030327-00030599": "year year and a half um", "j07OXDoRorY-00133-00030600-00030870": "i joined shift success in with my wife", "j07OXDoRorY-00134-00030872-00031055": "march 2020", "j07OXDoRorY-00135-00031056-00031295": "and um i was thinking i was just doing", "j07OXDoRorY-00136-00031295-00031462": "some christmas stuff in the lounge and i", "j07OXDoRorY-00137-00031463-00031687": "thought you know i need to send alex and", "j07OXDoRorY-00138-00031688-00031911": "team shift to success a", "j07OXDoRorY-00139-00031912-00032046": "christmas card", "j07OXDoRorY-00140-00032047-00032399": "but that just doesn't mean enough to me", "j07OXDoRorY-00141-00032400-00032551": "that christmas card just doesn't mean", "j07OXDoRorY-00142-00032552-00032855": "enough um the the thank you and support", "j07OXDoRorY-00143-00032856-00033102": "that uh the team have given us", "j07OXDoRorY-00144-00033103-00033343": "um it it doesn't give enough so i", "j07OXDoRorY-00145-00033344-00033439": "thought", "j07OXDoRorY-00146-00033440-00033671": "alex didn't know about this i thought or", "j07OXDoRorY-00147-00033672-00033887": "i would come in live into the into the", "j07OXDoRorY-00148-00033888-00034159": "public group because we do this um a lot", "j07OXDoRorY-00149-00034160-00034351": "in the private um group with all the", "j07OXDoRorY-00150-00034352-00034535": "cohorts but i come into the public group", "j07OXDoRorY-00151-00034536-00034631": "and say", "j07OXDoRorY-00152-00034632-00034902": "a massive thank you first of all to alex", "j07OXDoRorY-00153-00034903-00035143": "and the team shift success i hope you're", "j07OXDoRorY-00154-00035144-00035295": "watching this now alex", "j07OXDoRorY-00155-00035296-00035727": "um i wanted to come in and say how much", "j07OXDoRorY-00156-00035728-00035862": "um", "j07OXDoRorY-00157-00035863-00036159": "it's changed my life how much the whole", "j07OXDoRorY-00158-00036160-00036367": "process has changed my life i've", "j07OXDoRorY-00159-00036368-00036502": "literally just", "j07OXDoRorY-00160-00036503-00036646": "unpacked a whiteboard", "j07OXDoRorY-00161-00036647-00036799": "and i've written on that whiteboard a", "j07OXDoRorY-00162-00036800-00037039": "hundred thousand pound 2022 you know", "j07OXDoRorY-00163-00037040-00037302": "hundred thousand pound turnover 2022 100", "j07OXDoRorY-00164-00037303-00037590": "000 pound business in 2022", "j07OXDoRorY-00165-00037591-00037799": "and this time last year", "j07OXDoRorY-00166-00037800-00037959": "i didn't even know that i was going to", "j07OXDoRorY-00167-00037960-00038102": "be resigning from the police i didn't", "j07OXDoRorY-00168-00038103-00038302": "even know that i was going to have a new", "j07OXDoRorY-00169-00038303-00038607": "business to um to get me out of the", "j07OXDoRorY-00170-00038608-00038711": "police", "j07OXDoRorY-00171-00038712-00038871": "and um", "j07OXDoRorY-00172-00038872-00039007": "i went into", "j07OXDoRorY-00173-00039008-00039230": "christmas last year in a horrible place", "j07OXDoRorY-00174-00039231-00039407": "you know it wasn't very nice and i", "j07OXDoRorY-00175-00039408-00039590": "started a new job within the police in", "j07OXDoRorY-00176-00039591-00039727": "january", "j07OXDoRorY-00177-00039728-00040039": "this year and by march i was just", "j07OXDoRorY-00178-00040040-00040239": "completely had enough", "j07OXDoRorY-00179-00040240-00040335": "and", "j07OXDoRorY-00180-00040336-00040551": "once again the support of my wife and", "j07OXDoRorY-00181-00040552-00040702": "alex and team", "j07OXDoRorY-00182-00040703-00040943": "shift success", "j07OXDoRorY-00183-00040944-00041143": "got me out of the police they drove me", "j07OXDoRorY-00184-00041144-00041383": "to resign they they supported me to", "j07OXDoRorY-00185-00041384-00041567": "resign they", "j07OXDoRorY-00186-00041568-00041823": "they had my back i knew that whatever i", "j07OXDoRorY-00187-00041824-00042079": "did and with my new business", "j07OXDoRorY-00188-00042080-00042246": "they were going to be there for me to", "j07OXDoRorY-00189-00042247-00042407": "give me the help that i needed to make", "j07OXDoRorY-00190-00042408-00042551": "that succeed", "j07OXDoRorY-00191-00042552-00042623": "so", "j07OXDoRorY-00192-00042624-00042711": "um", "j07OXDoRorY-00193-00042712-00042935": "so we started shift success in march", "j07OXDoRorY-00194-00042936-00043071": "2020", "j07OXDoRorY-00195-00043072-00043335": "and then um i resigned from the police", "j07OXDoRorY-00196-00043336-00043695": "in march 2021 i mean how amazing is that", "j07OXDoRorY-00197-00043696-00043918": "i wanted to come in live into your", "j07OXDoRorY-00198-00043919-00044271": "public group and sort of saying what", "j07OXDoRorY-00199-00044272-00044495": "um are people waiting for you know", "j07OXDoRorY-00200-00044496-00044799": "there's so much unhappiness out there", "j07OXDoRorY-00201-00044800-00045071": "within the public sector and there's so", "j07OXDoRorY-00202-00045072-00045351": "much um", "j07OXDoRorY-00203-00045352-00045671": "sort of mental health issues caused by", "j07OXDoRorY-00204-00045672-00045846": "being unhappy at work you know it", "j07OXDoRorY-00205-00045847-00046087": "certainly was part of the cause i now", "j07OXDoRorY-00206-00046088-00046167": "know", "j07OXDoRorY-00207-00046168-00046423": "was part of the course um causes of my", "j07OXDoRorY-00208-00046424-00046646": "my struggles and my issues", "j07OXDoRorY-00209-00046647-00046871": "why are we waiting and not taking action", "j07OXDoRorY-00210-00046872-00047135": "you know if if you've been", "j07OXDoRorY-00211-00047136-00047327": "hanging out in the group and you've been", "j07OXDoRorY-00212-00047328-00047535": "watching you know the updates and the", "j07OXDoRorY-00213-00047536-00047767": "wins that alex shares with you all you", "j07OXDoRorY-00214-00047768-00047967": "know these are all", "j07OXDoRorY-00215-00047968-00048135": "reasons why you should be joining shift", "j07OXDoRorY-00216-00048136-00048407": "success it's a life changing", "j07OXDoRorY-00217-00048408-00048518": "um", "j07OXDoRorY-00218-00048519-00048902": "opportunity for you to jump into and", "j07OXDoRorY-00219-00048903-00049118": "get a business going", "j07OXDoRorY-00220-00049119-00049351": "and then live your life on your terms", "j07OXDoRorY-00221-00049352-00049527": "and make the changes and leave the", "j07OXDoRorY-00222-00049528-00049799": "public sector and be your own boss it's", "j07OXDoRorY-00223-00049800-00049958": "a scary thing to do", "j07OXDoRorY-00224-00049959-00050230": "but alex the shift success team and", "j07OXDoRorY-00225-00050231-00050423": "everyone else that's on the courses at", "j07OXDoRorY-00226-00050424-00050711": "the moment are all there to", "j07OXDoRorY-00227-00050712-00050951": "support you and to make your dreams come", "j07OXDoRorY-00228-00050952-00051111": "true", "j07OXDoRorY-00229-00051112-00051350": "so a little pre-sale pre-see of what", "j07OXDoRorY-00230-00051351-00051654": "i've done um since joining shift success", "j07OXDoRorY-00231-00051655-00051854": "i've resigned from the police i'm my own", "j07OXDoRorY-00232-00051855-00051942": "boss", "j07OXDoRorY-00233-00051944-00052294": "and i've got a new business um passion", "j07OXDoRorY-00234-00052295-00052407": "to profit", "j07OXDoRorY-00235-00052408-00052750": "uh i've got a facebook group with almost", "j07OXDoRorY-00236-00052751-00053087": "five almost 6 000 target customers in it", "j07OXDoRorY-00237-00053088-00053279": "that i can turn to when i've got new", "j07OXDoRorY-00238-00053279-00053479": "products to release i've now got a", "j07OXDoRorY-00239-00053479-00053759": "youtube channel a podcast i've done", "j07OXDoRorY-00240-00053760-00054023": "countless numbers of interviews i coach", "j07OXDoRorY-00241-00054024-00054238": "people on a one-to-one basis and in a", "j07OXDoRorY-00242-00054239-00054391": "group basis", "j07OXDoRorY-00243-00054391-00054647": "i invest my money instead of powering it", "j07OXDoRorY-00244-00054648-00054791": "into a pension that no one actually", "j07OXDoRorY-00245-00054791-00054966": "knows when you're ever going to get it", "j07OXDoRorY-00246-00054967-00055271": "or how much it's going to be worth and", "j07OXDoRorY-00247-00055272-00055487": "i've actually um", "j07OXDoRorY-00248-00055488-00055630": "i've never heard from the pension people", "j07OXDoRorY-00249-00055632-00055782": "since i resigned", "j07OXDoRorY-00250-00055783-00055854": "so", "j07OXDoRorY-00251-00055855-00056063": "that kind of tells you how valued you", "j07OXDoRorY-00252-00056064-00056254": "are i think when it comes to that", "j07OXDoRorY-00253-00056255-00056407": "pension issue", "j07OXDoRorY-00254-00056408-00056542": "um", "j07OXDoRorY-00255-00056544-00056654": "i've", "j07OXDoRorY-00256-00056655-00056942": "done loads of personal development um", "j07OXDoRorY-00257-00056944-00057319": "i'm just a nicer better happier", "j07OXDoRorY-00258-00057320-00057542": "person to be around i believe my kids", "j07OXDoRorY-00259-00057544-00057815": "are enjoying me being around and uh my", "j07OXDoRorY-00260-00057816-00057999": "kids love the fact that i'm doing", "j07OXDoRorY-00261-00058000-00058223": "business they're really interested in", "j07OXDoRorY-00262-00058224-00058463": "like the podcast and their lives and", "j07OXDoRorY-00263-00058464-00058566": "like", "j07OXDoRorY-00264-00058567-00058759": "how we do stuff", "j07OXDoRorY-00265-00058760-00059047": "i've read so many books and opened up my", "j07OXDoRorY-00266-00059048-00059311": "mindset and um you know this is part of", "j07OXDoRorY-00267-00059312-00059559": "it i go live in facebook groups you know", "j07OXDoRorY-00268-00059560-00059782": "there's 1600 people in this facebook", "j07OXDoRorY-00269-00059783-00060023": "group and i'm now live and everyone's", "j07OXDoRorY-00270-00060024-00060150": "going to see this", "j07OXDoRorY-00271-00060151-00060366": "but i thought next year you know i've", "j07OXDoRorY-00272-00060367-00060526": "just written on my", "j07OXDoRorY-00273-00060527-00060766": "my whiteboard my goal for next year is a", "j07OXDoRorY-00274-00060767-00060966": "hundred thousand pound turnover you know", "j07OXDoRorY-00275-00060967-00061142": "a six-figure business", "j07OXDoRorY-00276-00061144-00061479": "and that is so achievable all thanks to", "j07OXDoRorY-00277-00061479-00061726": "um shift success and the people that we", "j07OXDoRorY-00278-00061727-00061950": "surround ourselves with so", "j07OXDoRorY-00279-00061951-00062166": "i thought i can send alex and shift", "j07OXDoRorY-00280-00062167-00062350": "success a christmas card", "j07OXDoRorY-00281-00062351-00062438": "and", "j07OXDoRorY-00282-00062439-00062606": "hopefully i will i'll get time make time", "j07OXDoRorY-00283-00062607-00062735": "to do that", "j07OXDoRorY-00284-00062736-00062935": "but i thought no", "j07OXDoRorY-00285-00062936-00063094": "what better way", "j07OXDoRorY-00286-00063095-00063430": "to express my gratitude my thank you my", "j07OXDoRorY-00287-00063432-00063766": "you know how um how much alex and his", "j07OXDoRorY-00288-00063767-00064015": "team have changed my life and changed my", "j07OXDoRorY-00289-00064016-00064150": "family's life", "j07OXDoRorY-00290-00064151-00064471": "and was to come in and", "j07OXDoRorY-00291-00064472-00064671": "say thank you publicly", "j07OXDoRorY-00292-00064672-00064982": "you know in his uh public facebook group", "j07OXDoRorY-00293-00064983-00065175": "if you're sitting on the fence if you've", "j07OXDoRorY-00294-00065176-00065406": "not had a discussion with any of their", "j07OXDoRorY-00295-00065407-00065671": "sales team or if you need to", "j07OXDoRorY-00296-00065672-00065847": "find out a bit more about it you know", "j07OXDoRorY-00297-00065848-00066038": "find one of us that's in the in the", "j07OXDoRorY-00298-00066039-00066303": "course and we'll sit down on a zoom call", "j07OXDoRorY-00299-00066304-00066511": "or a cup of coffee and explain exactly", "j07OXDoRorY-00300-00066512-00066623": "what you're going to get and how you're", "j07OXDoRorY-00301-00066624-00066799": "going to achieve your goals and how", "j07OXDoRorY-00302-00066800-00066991": "they're going to help you", "j07OXDoRorY-00303-00066992-00067367": "sign up change your life in 2022 you", "j07OXDoRorY-00304-00067368-00067455": "know", "j07OXDoRorY-00305-00067456-00067638": "get out of that", "j07OXDoRorY-00306-00067639-00067887": "public sector job that's destroying your", "j07OXDoRorY-00307-00067888-00068094": "your life if you're not enjoying it you", "j07OXDoRorY-00308-00068095-00068182": "know", "j07OXDoRorY-00309-00068183-00068455": "we've changed so much and that's the", "j07OXDoRorY-00310-00068456-00068591": "biggest message that i want to bring", "j07OXDoRorY-00311-00068592-00068879": "into this group is how much uh this", "j07OXDoRorY-00312-00068880-00068982": "course", "j07OXDoRorY-00313-00068983-00069263": "this company alex and alex's team can", "j07OXDoRorY-00314-00069264-00069415": "change your life", "j07OXDoRorY-00315-00069416-00069655": "so um if i'd done this at 11 o'clock at", "j07OXDoRorY-00316-00069656-00069838": "night you probably thought i was drunk", "j07OXDoRorY-00317-00069839-00070006": "but i'm not you know i was just", "j07OXDoRorY-00318-00070007-00070247": "reflecting on how how much my life has", "j07OXDoRorY-00319-00070248-00070503": "changed in the last year and i broke out", "j07OXDoRorY-00320-00070504-00070735": "and i made that change and you can too", "j07OXDoRorY-00321-00070736-00070823": "so", "j07OXDoRorY-00322-00070824-00071215": "a ginormous massive thank you to alex", "j07OXDoRorY-00323-00071216-00071535": "and alex's mentors and alex's team and", "j07OXDoRorY-00324-00071536-00071726": "what they've done for me and my family", "j07OXDoRorY-00325-00071727-00071991": "and how um they've really helped us out", "j07OXDoRorY-00326-00071992-00072223": "and pushing us forwards into", "j07OXDoRorY-00327-00072224-00072582": "2022 and beyond um massive thank you for", "j07OXDoRorY-00328-00072583-00072815": "the the people that are surround", "j07OXDoRorY-00329-00072816-00073150": "surround us within the cohorts and um if", "j07OXDoRorY-00330-00073151-00073415": "you do anything next year you know make", "j07OXDoRorY-00331-00073416-00073535": "sure you", "j07OXDoRorY-00332-00073536-00073775": "book in a call with alex and his sales", "j07OXDoRorY-00333-00073776-00074103": "team and um make sure that you speak to", "j07OXDoRorY-00334-00074104-00074303": "someone about how they can change your", "j07OXDoRorY-00335-00074304-00074575": "life because you know life's too short", "j07OXDoRorY-00336-00074576-00074743": "to be working for a boss that doesn't", "j07OXDoRorY-00337-00074744-00074967": "appreciate you paying into a pension", "j07OXDoRorY-00338-00074968-00075071": "that you just don't know when you're", "j07OXDoRorY-00339-00075072-00075199": "going to get or how much you're going to", "j07OXDoRorY-00340-00075200-00075415": "get for it you know", "j07OXDoRorY-00341-00075416-00075671": "the public sector causes so many issues", "j07OXDoRorY-00342-00075672-00075887": "within our personal lives it doesn't", "j07OXDoRorY-00343-00075888-00076111": "have to be like that okay public sector", "j07OXDoRorY-00344-00076112-00076271": "workers you don't have to put up with", "j07OXDoRorY-00345-00076272-00076526": "this there is life on the outside and", "j07OXDoRorY-00346-00076527-00076671": "you can change it", "j07OXDoRorY-00347-00076672-00076838": "so i'm gonna end", "j07OXDoRorY-00348-00076839-00077015": "i'm gonna say a massive thank you again", "j07OXDoRorY-00349-00077016-00077287": "to alex and his team and the mentors", "j07OXDoRorY-00350-00077288-00077526": "that he he brings in to help us", "j07OXDoRorY-00351-00077527-00077823": "um completely changed our lives and you", "j07OXDoRorY-00352-00077824-00078015": "need to reach out and change your life", "j07OXDoRorY-00353-00078016-00078094": "too", "j07OXDoRorY-00354-00078095-00078326": "have a fantastic christmas i hope if", "j07OXDoRorY-00355-00078327-00078526": "you're working you're staying safe i", "j07OXDoRorY-00356-00078527-00078759": "think of you all still and i reflect on", "j07OXDoRorY-00357-00078760-00078903": "the christmases that i had to work in", "j07OXDoRorY-00358-00078904-00079231": "the 19 years of policing that i did", "j07OXDoRorY-00359-00079232-00079471": "um but this year i'm at home and i've", "j07OXDoRorY-00360-00079472-00079711": "got time off and i'm doing what i want", "j07OXDoRorY-00361-00079712-00079943": "to do without anyone else telling me", "j07OXDoRorY-00362-00079944-00080182": "that i can't so that's just a massive", "j07OXDoRorY-00363-00080183-00080367": "win in itself isn't it", "j07OXDoRorY-00364-00080368-00080679": "um reach out you know make that change", "j07OXDoRorY-00365-00080680-00080943": "and reach out to alex and his team happy", "j07OXDoRorY-00366-00080944-00081126": "christmas everyone take care and", "j07OXDoRorY-00367-00081127-00081406": "hopefully i might see some of you inside", "j07OXDoRorY-00368-00081407-00081615": "the shift to success cohorts next year", "j07OXDoRorY-00369-00081616-00081799": "and we can get together and start", "j07OXDoRorY-00370-00081800-00082006": "helping each other take care everyone", "j07OXDoRorY-00371-00082007-00082255": "once again thank you alex uh thank you", "j07OXDoRorY-00372-00082256-00082431": "for your help over the last year and a", "j07OXDoRorY-00373-00082432-00082732": "bit"}}, {"audio_id": "j0AcB93vlmc", "text": {"j0AcB93vlmc-00000-00000000-00001042": "thank you", "j0AcB93vlmc-00001-00001043-00003329": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00002-00003329-00004033": "thank you", "j0AcB93vlmc-00003-00004034-00004339": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00004-00004340-00005031": "[Music]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00005-00005032-00005363": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00006-00005364-00005977": "[Music]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00007-00005978-00007714": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00008-00007715-00008452": "foreign", "j0AcB93vlmc-00009-00008453-00008723": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00010-00008724-00008817": "[Music]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00011-00008818-00009168": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00012-00009169-00009240": "[Music]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00013-00009241-00010439": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00014-00010440-00011333": "[Applause]", "j0AcB93vlmc-00015-00011334-00015058": "thank you", "j0AcB93vlmc-00016-00015059-00015359": "bizarre"}}, {"audio_id": "j0Hfl9yfnJu", "text": {"j0Hfl9yfnJu-00000-00001392-00004615": "hello", "j0Hfl9yfnJu-00001-00004616-00007687": "so", "j0Hfl9yfnJu-00002-00007688-00018822": "so", "j0Hfl9yfnJu-00003-00018823-00022478": "so", "j0Hfl9yfnJu-00004-00022479-00022687": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "j1kO_1iOKrI", "text": {"j1kO_1iOKrI-00000-00000049-00000270": "the Desert Fathers along with desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00001-00000271-00000444": "mothers were early Christian Hermits", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00002-00000445-00000666": "ascetics and monks who lived mainly in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00003-00000667-00000843": "the seats desert of Egypt beginning", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00004-00000844-00001143": "around the third century AD the apothem", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00005-00001144-00001311": "out of patra ms a collection of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00006-00001312-00001508": "wisdom of some of the early desert monks", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00007-00001509-00001685": "and nuns in print as sayings of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00008-00001686-00001950": "Desert Fathers the most well-known was", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00009-00001951-00002100": "Anthony the Great who moved to the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00010-00002101-00002487": "desert in AD 270 took 271 and became", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00011-00002488-00002657": "known as both the father and founder of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00012-00002658-00002931": "desert monasticism by the time Anthony", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00013-00002932-00003282": "died in AD 356 thousands of monks and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00014-00003283-00003440": "nuns had been drawn to living in the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00015-00003442-00003684": "desert following Anthony's example his", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00016-00003685-00003879": "biographer Athanasius of Alexandria", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00017-00003879-00004172": "wrote that the desert had become a city", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00018-00004173-00004437": "the Desert Fathers had a major influence", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00019-00004438-00004770": "on the development of Christianity the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00020-00004771-00004968": "desert monastic communities that grew", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00021-00004969-00005148": "out of the informal gathering of hermit", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00022-00005149-00005325": "monks became the model for Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00023-00005326-00005583": "monasticism the eastern monastic", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00024-00005584-00005787": "tradition at Mount Athos and the Western", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00025-00005788-00005955": "rule of Saint Benedict both were", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00026-00005956-00006141": "strongly influenced by the traditions", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00027-00006142-00006384": "that began in the desert all of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00028-00006385-00006555": "monastic revivals of the Middle Ages", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00029-00006556-00006770": "look to the desert for inspiration and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00030-00006771-00007026": "guidance much of Eastern Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00031-00007027-00007241": "spirituality including the HESI caste", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00032-00007242-00007439": "movement had its roots in the practices", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00033-00007440-00007701": "of the Desert Fathers even religious", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00034-00007702-00007926": "renewals such as the German evangelicals", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00035-00007927-00008123": "and Piatt distint ensel vania the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00036-00008124-00008298": "devotion moderna movement and the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00037-00008299-00008498": "Methodist revival in England are seen by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00038-00008499-00008696": "modern scholars as being influenced by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00039-00008697-00009181": "the Desert Fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00040-00009182-00009622": "early history", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00041-00009623-00009853": "Paul of Thieves is often credited with", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00042-00009854-00010048": "being the first hermit monk to go to the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00043-00010049-00010228": "desert but it was Anthony the Great who", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00044-00010229-00010384": "launched the movement that became the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00045-00010385-00010768": "Desert Fathers sometime around AD 270", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00046-00010769-00010981": "Anthony heard a Sunday sermon stating", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00047-00010982-00011143": "that perfection could be achieved by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00048-00011144-00011347": "selling all of one's possessions giving", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00049-00011348-00011539": "the proceeds to the poor and following", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00050-00011540-00011884": "Christ Matt 1921 he followed the advice", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00051-00011885-00012079": "and made the further step of moving deep", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00052-00012080-00012238": "into the desert to seek complete", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00053-00012239-00012433": "solitude Anthony lived in a time of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00054-00012434-00012667": "transition for Christianity the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00055-00012668-00012991": "Diocletian ik persecution in AD 303 was", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00056-00012991-00013191": "the last great formal persecution of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00057-00013193-00013480": "Christians in the Roman Empire only ten", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00058-00013481-00013708": "years later Christianity was made legal", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00059-00013709-00013918": "in Egypt by Diocletian successor", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00060-00013919-00014122": "Constantine the first those who left for", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00061-00014122-00014308": "the desert formed an alternate Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00062-00014309-00014494": "society at a time when it was no longer", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00063-00014494-00014779": "a risk to be a Christian the solitude", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00064-00014780-00015022": "austerity and sacrifice of the desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00065-00015022-00015235": "was seen by Anthony as an alternative to", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00066-00015236-00015415": "martyrdom which was formerly seen by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00067-00015416-00015594": "many Christians as the highest form of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00068-00015596-00015690": "sacrifice", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00069-00015691-00015949": "Anthony quickly gained followers eager", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00070-00015950-00016102": "to live their lives in accordance with", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00071-00016103-00016288": "this solidarity and separation from", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00072-00016288-00016540": "material goods from these prohibitions", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00073-00016541-00016783": "it is recorded by a tenacious that", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00074-00016784-00016996": "Anthony received special privileges from", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00075-00016997-00017212": "God such as the ability to heal the sick", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00076-00017213-00017419": "inspire others to have faith in healing", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00077-00017420-00017599": "through God and even converse with God", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00078-00017600-00017875": "on occasion around this time Desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00079-00017876-00018037": "monasticism appeared nearly", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00080-00018038-00018217": "simultaneously in several areas", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00081-00018218-00018496": "including Egypt and Syria over time the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00082-00018497-00018669": "model of Anthony and other Hermits", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00083-00018670-00018874": "attracted many followers who lived alone", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00084-00018875-00019057": "in the desert or in small groups", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00085-00019058-00019308": "they chose a life of extreme asceticism", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00086-00019309-00019510": "renouncing all the pleasures of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00087-00019511-00019810": "senses rich food baths rest and anything", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00088-00019811-00020050": "that made them comfortable they instead", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00089-00020051-00020247": "focus their energies on praying singing", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00090-00020248-00020469": "Psalms fasting giving arms to the needy", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00091-00020470-00020692": "and preserving love and harmony with one", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00092-00020693-00020847": "another while keeping their thoughts and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00093-00020848-00021130": "desires for God alone thousands joined", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00094-00021131-00021343": "them in the desert mostly men but also a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00095-00021344-00021655": "handful of women religious seekers also", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00096-00021656-00021856": "began going to the desert seeking advice", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00097-00021857-00022027": "and counsel from the early Desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00098-00022028-00022294": "Fathers by the time of Anthony's death", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00099-00022295-00022483": "there were so many men and women living", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00100-00022484-00022681": "in the desert that it was described as a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00101-00022682-00023002": "city by Anthony's biographer the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00102-00023003-00023227": "fathers advocated three main approaches", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00103-00023228-00023512": "to monasticism one was the austere life", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00104-00023513-00023707": "of the Hermit as practiced by Anthony", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00105-00023708-00023980": "and his followers in Lower Egypt another", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00106-00023981-00024199": "was the Sina bida Clive communities of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00107-00024200-00024403": "monks and nuns in Upper Egypt formed by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00108-00024404-00024604": "pehoe meais the third was a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00109-00024605-00024844": "semi-hermetic lifestyle seen mostly in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00110-00024845-00025080": "night ryuk Elia and setteth west of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00111-00025081-00025366": "Nile begun by Saint Amon the latter were", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00112-00025367-00025576": "small groups two to six of monks and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00113-00025577-00025831": "nuns with a common spiritual elder these", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00114-00025832-00026014": "separate groups would join together in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00115-00026014-00026175": "larger gatherings to worship on", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00116-00026176-00026476": "Saturdays and Sundays this third form of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00117-00026477-00026713": "monasticism was responsible for most of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00118-00026714-00026872": "the sayings that were compiled as the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00119-00026873-00027061": "apothem adapt at Rome sayings of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00120-00027062-00027441": "Desert Fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00121-00027442-00027695": "topic development of monastic", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00122-00027697-00028083": "communities", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00123-00028084-00028305": "the small communities founded by the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00124-00028306-00028473": "Desert Fathers were the beginning of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00125-00028474-00028767": "Christian monasticism initially Anthony", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00126-00028768-00028968": "and others lived as Hermits sometimes", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00127-00028969-00029241": "forming groups of two or three small", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00128-00029242-00029469": "informal communities began developing", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00129-00029470-00029670": "until the monk pehoe meais seeing the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00130-00029671-00029820": "need for a more formal structure", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00131-00029821-00030033": "established a monastery with rules and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00132-00030034-00030327": "organization his regulations included", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00133-00030328-00030561": "discipline obedience manual labor", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00134-00030562-00030792": "silence fasting and long periods of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00135-00030793-00031062": "Prayer some historians view the rules as", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00136-00031063-00031230": "being inspired by pehoe Mia's", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00137-00031231-00031473": "experiences as a Roman soldier the first", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00138-00031474-00031716": "fully organized monastery under peroneus", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00139-00031717-00031896": "included men and women living in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00140-00031897-00032091": "separate quarters up to three in a room", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00141-00032092-00032343": "they supported themselves by weaving", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00142-00032344-00032589": "cloth and baskets along with other tasks", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00143-00032590-00032874": "each new monk or nun had a three-year", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00144-00032875-00033069": "probationary period concluding with", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00145-00033070-00033223": "admittance in full standing to the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00146-00033224-00033483": "monastery all property was held", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00147-00033484-00033685": "communally meals were eaten together and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00148-00033686-00033907": "in silence twice a week they fasted and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00149-00033908-00034083": "they wore simple peasant clothing with a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00150-00034084-00034329": "hood several times a day they came", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00151-00034330-00034504": "together for prayer and readings and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00152-00034505-00034701": "each person was expected to spend time", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00153-00034702-00034910": "alone meditating on the scriptures", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00154-00034911-00035157": "programs were created for educating", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00155-00035158-00035352": "those who came to the monastery unable", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00156-00035353-00035589": "to read the homeys also formalized the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00157-00035590-00035814": "establishment of an Abba Father or Amma", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00158-00035815-00036018": "mother in charge of the spiritual", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00159-00036019-00036177": "welfare of their monks and nuns", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00160-00036178-00036342": "with the implication that those joining", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00161-00036343-00036537": "the monastery were also joining a new", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00162-00036538-00036813": "family members also formed smaller", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00163-00036814-00036990": "groups with different tasks in the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00164-00036991-00037170": "community and the responsibility of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00165-00037171-00037431": "looking after each other's welfare the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00166-00037432-00037593": "new approach grew to the point that", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00167-00037594-00037746": "there were tens of thousands of monks", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00168-00037747-00037941": "and nuns in these organized communities", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00169-00037942-00038223": "within decades of pehoe Mia's death one", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00170-00038224-00038412": "of the early pilgrims to the desert was", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00171-00038413-00038619": "basil of Caesarea who took the rule of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00172-00038620-00038816": "pehoe meais into the eastern church", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00173-00038817-00039117": "basil expanded the idea of community by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00174-00039118-00039304": "integrating the monks and nuns into the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00175-00039305-00039498": "wider public community with the monks", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00176-00039499-00039693": "and nuns under the authority of a bishop", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00177-00039694-00039885": "and serving the poor and needy as more", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00178-00039886-00040068": "pilgrims began visiting the monks in the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00179-00040069-00040257": "desert influence from the monastic", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00180-00040258-00040504": "communities began spreading Latin", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00181-00040505-00040704": "versions of the original Greek stories", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00182-00040705-00040887": "and sayings of the Desert Fathers along", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00183-00040888-00041104": "with the earliest monastic rules coming", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00184-00041105-00041262": "out of the desert guided the early", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00185-00041263-00041444": "monastic development in the business", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00186-00041445-00041672": "and eventually in the Western Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00187-00041673-00041960": "world John Cassian played an important", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00188-00041961-00042146": "role in mediating the influence of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00189-00042147-00042413": "Desert Fathers to the west this can be", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00190-00042414-00042623": "seen for example in the rule of Saint", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00191-00042624-00042830": "Benedict where Benedict of Nursia urged", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00192-00042831-00043001": "his monks to read the writings of John", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00193-00043002-00043253": "Cassian on the Desert Fathers the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00194-00043254-00043454": "sayings of the Desert Fathers was also", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00195-00043455-00043631": "widely read in the early Benedictine", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00196-00043632-00044089": "monasteries", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00197-00044090-00044734": "topic notable desert fathers and mothers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00198-00044735-00044974": "many of the monks and nuns developed a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00199-00044975-00045193": "reputation for holiness and wisdom with", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00200-00045194-00045352": "the small communities following a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00201-00045353-00045586": "particularly holy or wise elder who was", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00202-00045587-00045793": "their spiritual father Abba or mother", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00203-00045794-00046093": "Alma the individual Desert Fathers and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00204-00046094-00046273": "desert mothers are mostly known through", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00205-00046274-00046453": "the sayings of the Desert Fathers which", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00206-00046454-00046831": "included 1202 sayings attributed to 27", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00207-00046832-00047122": "Abbas and 3 amis the greatest number of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00208-00047123-00047296": "sayings are attributed to ABBA", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00209-00047297-00047698": "Tommen Greek for Shepard because of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00210-00047699-00047896": "wide disparity of dates for the sayings", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00211-00047897-00048118": "attributed to a blip omen some scholars", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00212-00048119-00048409": "believe that Holman was a generic name", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00213-00048410-00048598": "for a combination of different unnamed", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00214-00048599-00048841": "Abbas others conclude that the sayings", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00215-00048842-00049039": "attributed to a blip omen are accurate", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00216-00049040-00049249": "based on a notable and historical a blip", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00217-00049250-00049513": "omen among the notable desert fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00218-00049514-00049696": "and mothers with sayings in the book in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00219-00049697-00049861": "addition to Anthony the great were", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00220-00049862-00050107": "arsonists the great poem in Macarius of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00221-00050108-00050338": "Egypt Moses the black and syncretic ax", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00222-00050339-00050548": "of Alexandria other notable Desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00223-00050549-00050752": "Fathers include pehoe meais and Shinoda", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00224-00050753-00050965": "the archimandrite and many individuals", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00225-00050966-00051133": "who spent part of their lives in the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00226-00051134-00051358": "Egyptian desert including atha nation of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00227-00051359-00051574": "Alexandria John Chrysostom Evagrius", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00228-00051575-00051919": "Pontius Hilarion and John Cassian cash", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00229-00051920-00052083": "Ian's works brought the wisdom of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00230-00052084-00052573": "Desert Fathers into a wider arena", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00231-00052574-00053080": "topic practices", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00232-00053082-00053641": "topic withdrawal from society", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00233-00053641-00053887": "the legalization of Christianity by the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00234-00053888-00054178": "Roman Empire in 313 gave Anthony a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00235-00054179-00054351": "greater resolve to go out into the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00236-00054352-00054622": "desert nostalgic for the tradition of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00237-00054623-00054775": "martyrdom he saw withdrawal in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00238-00054776-00055054": "asceticism as an alternative he insisted", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00239-00055054-00055275": "on selling all his material possessions", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00240-00055276-00055504": "he left his younger sister a small", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00241-00055504-00055680": "amount of money to live her life in a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00242-00055682-00055887": "convent and donated the rest to the poor", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00243-00055888-00056149": "when members of the church began finding", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00244-00056150-00056343": "ways to work with the Roman state the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00245-00056344-00056526": "Desert Fathers saw that as a compromise", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00246-00056527-00056757": "between the things of God and the things", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00247-00056758-00057061": "of Caesar the monastic communities were", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00248-00057062-00057231": "essentially an alternate Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00249-00057232-00057448": "society the Hermits doubted that", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00250-00057449-00057634": "religion and politics could ever produce", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00251-00057635-00057942": "a truly Christian society for them the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00252-00057944-00058182": "only Christian society was spiritual and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00253-00058183-00058524": "not mundane", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00254-00058525-00059024": "topic hesychasm", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00255-00059025-00059304": "hesychasm from the Greek for stillness", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00256-00059304-00059687": "rest quiet silence is a mystical", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00257-00059688-00059871": "tradition and movement that originated", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00258-00059872-00060056": "with the Desert Fathers and was central", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00259-00060057-00060309": "to their practice of Prayer hesychasm", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00260-00060310-00060522": "for the Desert Fathers was primarily the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00261-00060523-00060755": "practice of interior silence and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00262-00060757-00061013": "continual prayer it did not become a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00263-00061014-00061232": "formal movement of specific practices", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00264-00061233-00061404": "until the 14th century Byzantine", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00265-00061404-00061631": "meditative prayer techniques when it was", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00266-00061632-00061829": "more closely identified with the prayer", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00267-00061830-00062124": "of the heart or Jesus Prayer that", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00268-00062125-00062334": "prayers origin is also traced back to", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00269-00062335-00062550": "the Desert Fathers the prayer of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00270-00062551-00062736": "heart was found inscribed in the ruins", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00271-00062737-00062894": "of a cell from that period in the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00272-00062895-00063135": "Egyptian desert the earliest written", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00273-00063136-00063317": "reference to the practice of the prayer", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00274-00063319-00063471": "of the heart may be in a discourse", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00275-00063472-00063644": "collected in the phallic alia on Abba", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00276-00063645-00063936": "philomon a desert father Hesse cast", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00277-00063937-00064130": "prayer was a meditative practice that", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00278-00064132-00064319": "was traditionally done in silence and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00279-00064320-00064556": "with eyes closed empty of mental", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00280-00064557-00064841": "pictures and visual concepts but with", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00281-00064842-00064994": "the intense consciousness of God's", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00282-00064995-00065204": "presence the words Hesse cast and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00283-00065205-00065438": "hezekiah were frequently used in 4th and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00284-00065439-00065628": "5th century writings of Desert Fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00285-00065629-00065841": "such as Macarius of Egypt Evagrius", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00286-00065842-00066171": "Pontius and gregory of nyssa the title", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00287-00066172-00066360": "Hesse caste was used in early times", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00288-00066361-00066579": "synonymously with hermit as compared to", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00289-00066580-00066793": "a Cena bite who lived in community", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00290-00066794-00067025": "hesychasm can refer to inner or outer", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00291-00067026-00067215": "stillness though in the sayings of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00292-00067216-00067374": "Desert Fathers it referred to inner", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00293-00067375-00067805": "tranquility", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00294-00067806-00068360": "topic charity and forgiveness", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00295-00068361-00068591": "the Desert Fathers gave a great deal of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00296-00068592-00068800": "emphasis to living and practicing the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00297-00068801-00068972": "teachings of Christ much more than", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00298-00068973-00069218": "theoretical knowledge their efforts to", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00299-00069219-00069368": "live the commandments were not seen as", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00300-00069369-00069605": "being easy many of the stories from that", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00301-00069606-00069788": "time recount the struggle to overcome", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00302-00069789-00069988": "negative emotions such as anger and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00303-00069989-00070238": "judgment of others helping a brother", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00304-00070239-00070442": "monk who was ill or struggling was seen", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00305-00070443-00070625": "as taking priority over any other", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00306-00070626-00070888": "consideration Hermits were frequently", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00307-00070889-00071099": "seen to break along fast when hosting", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00308-00071100-00071303": "visitors as hospitality and kindness", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00309-00071304-00071480": "were more important than keeping the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00310-00071481-00071654": "ascetic practices that were so dominant", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00311-00071655-00072163": "in the Desert Fathers lives", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00312-00072164-00072656": "topic recitation of Scripture", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00313-00072657-00072872": "the lives of the Desert Fathers that", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00314-00072873-00073085": "were organized into communities included", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00315-00073086-00073277": "frequent recitation of the scriptures", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00316-00073278-00073481": "during the week they chanted Psalms", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00317-00073482-00073673": "while performing manual labor and during", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00318-00073674-00073826": "the weekends they held liturgies and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00319-00073827-00073940": "group services", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00320-00073941-00074162": "the monks experienced in the cell", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00321-00074163-00074378": "occurred in a variety of ways including", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00322-00074379-00074687": "meditation on Scripture group practices", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00323-00074688-00074846": "were more prominent in the organized", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00324-00074847-00075122": "communities formed by pehoe meais the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00325-00075123-00075275": "purpose of these practices were", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00326-00075276-00075494": "explained by John Cassian a desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00327-00075495-00075662": "father who described the goal of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00328-00075663-00075860": "psalmody the outward recitation of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00329-00075861-00076064": "Scripture and asceticism as the ascent", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00330-00076065-00076244": "to deep mystical prayer and mystical", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00331-00076245-00076680": "contemplation", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00332-00076681-00076884": "topic excerpts from the sayings of the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00333-00076885-00077138": "Desert Fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00334-00077139-00077303": "you", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00335-00077304-00077612": "a hermit said take care to be silent", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00336-00077613-00077840": "empty your mind attend to your", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00337-00077841-00078059": "meditation in the fear of God whether", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00338-00078060-00078356": "you are resting or at work if you do", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00339-00078357-00078556": "this you will not fear the attacks of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00340-00078557-00078762": "the demons", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00341-00078763-00079083": "ABBA Moses sit in my cell and thy cell", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00342-00079084-00079310": "will teach the all", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00343-00079311-00079574": "somebody asked Anthony what shall I do", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00344-00079575-00079811": "in order to please God he replied", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00345-00079812-00079979": "do what I tell you which is this", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00346-00079980-00080213": "wherever you go keep God in mind", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00347-00080214-00080465": "whatever you do follow the example of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00348-00080466-00080696": "holy scripture wherever you are stay", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00349-00080697-00080932": "there and do not move away in a hurry if", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00350-00080933-00081226": "you keep to these guidelines you will be", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00351-00081227-00081448": "saved", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00352-00081449-00081757": "he Evagrius also said a monk was told", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00353-00081758-00082057": "that his father had died he said to the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00354-00082058-00082321": "messenger do not blaspheme my father", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00355-00082322-00082759": "cannot die abbot pastor if someone does", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00356-00082760-00082996": "evil to you you should do good to him so", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00357-00082997-00083182": "that by your good work you may drive out", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00358-00083183-00083415": "his malice", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00359-00083416-00083681": "an elder a man who keeps death before", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00360-00083682-00083912": "his eyes will at all times overcome his", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00361-00083913-00084360": "cowardliness blessed macarius said this", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00362-00084361-00084609": "is the truth if a monk regards contempt", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00363-00084610-00084869": "as praise poverty as riches and hunger", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00364-00084870-00085229": "as a feast he will never die", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00365-00085230-00085427": "it happened that as Abba Arsenio's was", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00366-00085428-00085586": "sitting in his cell that he was harassed", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00367-00085587-00085868": "by demons his servants on their return", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00368-00085869-00086054": "stood outside his cell and heard him", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00369-00086055-00086285": "praying to God in these words Oh God do", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00370-00086286-00086564": "not leave me I have done nothing good in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00371-00086565-00086699": "your sight but according to your", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00372-00086700-00086891": "goodness let me now make a beginning of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00373-00086892-00087194": "good when one desert father told another", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00374-00087195-00087395": "of his plans to shut himself into his", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00375-00087396-00087608": "cell and refused the face of men that he", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00376-00087609-00087725": "might perfect himself", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00377-00087726-00087908": "the second monk replied unless thou", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00378-00087909-00088115": "first amend the life going to and fro", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00379-00088116-00088286": "amongst men thou shall not avail to", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00380-00088287-00088571": "amend it dwelling alone Abba Anthony", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00381-00088572-00088745": "said whoever hammers a lump of iron", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00382-00088746-00088943": "first decides what he is going to make", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00383-00088944-00089288": "of it aside a sword or an axe even so we", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00384-00089289-00089459": "ought to make up our minds what kind of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00385-00089460-00089663": "virtue we want to Forge or we labor in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00386-00089664-00089966": "vain he also said obedience with", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00387-00089967-00090179": "abstinence gives men power over wild", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00388-00090180-00090503": "beasts it was said of Abidjan the dwarf", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00389-00090504-00090686": "that one day he said to his elder", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00390-00090687-00090863": "brother I should like to be free of all", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00391-00090864-00091091": "care like the angels who do not work but", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00392-00091092-00091328": "ceaselessly offer worship to God so he", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00393-00091329-00091499": "took off his cloak and went away into", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00394-00091500-00091772": "the desert after a week he came back to", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00395-00091773-00091973": "his brother when he knocked on the door", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00396-00091974-00092141": "he heard his brother say before he", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00397-00092142-00092360": "opened it who are you he said I am John", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00398-00092361-00092579": "your brother but he replied John has", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00399-00092580-00092789": "become an angel and henceforth he has no", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00400-00092790-00092969": "longer among men than the other begged", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00401-00092970-00093197": "him saying it is I however his brother", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00402-00093198-00093389": "did not let him in but left him there in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00403-00093390-00093668": "distress until morning then opening the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00404-00093669-00093866": "door he said to him you are a man and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00405-00093867-00094055": "you must once again work in order to eat", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00406-00094056-00094262": "then John made a prostration before him", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00407-00094263-00094670": "saying forgive me", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00408-00094671-00095276": "topic essential texts", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00409-00095277-00095488": "there are many different collections of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00410-00095489-00095687": "sayings of the Desert Fathers the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00411-00095688-00095888": "earliest writings were simply ordered by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00412-00095889-00096068": "the initial letter of the ABBA's name in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00413-00096069-00096311": "the order of the Greek alphabet so the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00414-00096312-00096506": "editors started with Anthony the great", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00415-00096507-00096725": "Arseniy as' and Agathon and concluded", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00416-00096726-00097031": "with chairman sent ICS and/or it was", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00417-00097032-00097211": "those first editors who used the word", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00418-00097212-00097436": "app attempts meaning saying Maxim or", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00419-00097437-00097685": "aphorism this is why this collection is", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00420-00097686-00097882": "now known as a Pithom a de Patra Malph", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00421-00097883-00098036": "abetik a-- the sayings of the Desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00422-00098037-00098326": "Fathers the alphabetic collection this", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00423-00098327-00098516": "collection contains about a thousand", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00424-00098517-00098696": "items the same editors knew there were", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00425-00098697-00098894": "also a lot of anonymous sayings and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00426-00098895-00099056": "tales of the desert fathers and mothers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00427-00099057-00099347": "circulating this material was gathered", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00428-00099348-00099530": "into a collection now known as anonymous", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00429-00099531-00099680": "Patra mapa tamada", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00430-00099681-00099874": "anonymous sayings of the Desert Fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00431-00099875-00100132": "these sayings were placed in order of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00432-00100133-00100316": "more or less similar subjects for", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00433-00100317-00100622": "instance humility charity etc this", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00434-00100623-00100880": "collection contains about 800 items the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00435-00100881-00101066": "collection now known as the systematic", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00436-00101067-00101251": "collection began to emerge a century", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00437-00101252-00101588": "later ad 500 it has sayings from the", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00438-00101589-00101753": "alphabetic collection and the anonymous", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00439-00101754-00101978": "sayings combined and systematically", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00440-00101979-00102263": "ordered under 21 chapters this", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00441-00102264-00102521": "collection contains about 1200 items and", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00442-00102522-00102698": "therefore does not completely combine", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00443-00102699-00103004": "the two older collections the sayings of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00444-00103005-00103238": "the Desert Fathers a petha mata patron", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00445-00103239-00103451": "the lives of the Desert Fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00446-00103452-00103729": "historian mana coram in Egypt ax", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00447-00103730-00104003": "Ethiopic collectio monastic ax includes", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00448-00104004-00104213": "many sayings of the Desert Fathers not", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00449-00104214-00104416": "included in the apothem aa dapat room", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00450-00104417-00104707": "the lousy AK history by Pelagius of", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00451-00104708-00104999": "Galatia the life of Saint Anthony by", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00452-00105000-00105401": "Saint Athanasius the anonymous sayings", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00453-00105402-00105620": "of the Desert Fathers anonymous a petha", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00454-00105621-00105866": "mata the sayings of the Desert Fathers", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00455-00105867-00106210": "the systematic collection fillet Kali a", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00456-00106211-00106504": "collection of texts the conferences in", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00457-00106505-00106793": "the Institute's by John Cassian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00458-00106794-00107108": "the ever jenos paradise of the desert", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00459-00107108-00107342": "fathers also known as boost an owl robe", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00460-00107343-00107659": "on", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00461-00107660-00108228": "topic C also", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00462-00108229-00108538": "cappadocia father's Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00463-00108539-00108937": "monasticism before 451 Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00464-00108938-00109232": "contemplation section theoria church", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00465-00109233-00109639": "fathers Coptic monasticism early", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00466-00109640-00109907": "Christianity Eastern Christian", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00467-00109908-00110295": "monasticism", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00468-00110296-00110843": "topic references", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00469-00110844-00111328": "topic footnotes", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00470-00111329-00111698": "topic bibliography", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00471-00111699-00111840": "you", "j1kO_1iOKrI-00472-00111841-00112047": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "j1m-cREBRdI", "text": {"j1m-cREBRdI-00000-00000008-00000247": "this is the theater of mariupol it's", "j1m-cREBRdI-00001-00000248-00000503": "been taken by the russian forces already", "j1m-cREBRdI-00002-00000504-00000726": "for two weeks and it was destroyed", "j1m-cREBRdI-00003-00000727-00001062": "according to uh the russian spokesman um", "j1m-cREBRdI-00004-00001063-00001358": "by the ukrainian forces which were uh", "j1m-cREBRdI-00005-00001359-00001566": "installed in this theater and had", "j1m-cREBRdI-00006-00001567-00001807": "hostages in the basement", "j1m-cREBRdI-00007-00001807-00002063": "we were told that", "j1m-cREBRdI-00008-00002064-00002342": "this was exploded from inside by the", "j1m-cREBRdI-00009-00002343-00002647": "retreating ukrainian forces uh trying to", "j1m-cREBRdI-00010-00002648-00002726": "uh", "j1m-cREBRdI-00011-00002727-00002910": "blame russia for the", "j1m-cREBRdI-00012-00002911-00003183": "uh this is a cultural catastrophe and", "j1m-cREBRdI-00013-00003184-00003390": "also", "j1m-cREBRdI-00014-00003392-00003663": "to slow the advancement of russian", "j1m-cREBRdI-00015-00003664-00003799": "troops", "j1m-cREBRdI-00016-00003800-00004047": "a reporter in a hamlet and art modves on", "j1m-cREBRdI-00017-00004047-00004206": "the scene is certainly a good way to", "j1m-cREBRdI-00018-00004207-00004399": "tell the story of the city of mario paul", "j1m-cREBRdI-00019-00004400-00004543": "in the dumbass", "j1m-cREBRdI-00020-00004544-00004735": "but this other simpler one is perhaps", "j1m-cREBRdI-00021-00004736-00004943": "much better", "j1m-cREBRdI-00022-00004944-00005135": "this showing continues every day and", "j1m-cREBRdI-00023-00005136-00005351": "night thank god that russia has come to", "j1m-cREBRdI-00024-00005352-00005663": "give us food and help us anyway how many", "j1m-cREBRdI-00025-00005664-00005854": "weeks they all last pretty much since", "j1m-cREBRdI-00026-00005855-00006006": "the beginning of march", "j1m-cREBRdI-00027-00006007-00006270": "things have been going downhill all the", "j1m-cREBRdI-00028-00006271-00006510": "houses around us were on fire", "j1m-cREBRdI-00029-00006511-00006839": "running all around us yes as there is a", "j1m-cREBRdI-00030-00006840-00007083": "time of destruction there is a", "j1m-cREBRdI-00031-00007084-00007383": "time hopefully after that it will be a", "j1m-cREBRdI-00032-00007384-00007574": "creation of time", "j1m-cREBRdI-00033-00007575-00007783": "but still some time", "j1m-cREBRdI-00034-00007784-00008174": "everything repeats itself", "j1m-cREBRdI-00035-00008175-00008399": "the tragedy in mario has its own name a", "j1m-cREBRdI-00036-00008400-00008631": "soft battalion neo-nazis settled in", "j1m-cREBRdI-00037-00008632-00008871": "these buildings every other floor to", "j1m-cREBRdI-00038-00008872-00009039": "shoot at russian troops", "j1m-cREBRdI-00039-00009040-00009263": "they didn't let the residents escape", "j1m-cREBRdI-00040-00009264-00009439": "and then fled to barricade themselves in", "j1m-cREBRdI-00041-00009440-00009727": "their substance steel complex", "j1m-cREBRdI-00042-00009728-00009942": "tell me are you saying that you saw", "j1m-cREBRdI-00043-00009943-00010087": "these snipers", "j1m-cREBRdI-00044-00010088-00010359": "where did they come from from the houses", "j1m-cREBRdI-00045-00010360-00010606": "from the attics usually what did they", "j1m-cREBRdI-00046-00010607-00010887": "look like yes i saw the one doing the", "j1m-cREBRdI-00047-00010888-00011135": "shooting i saw the telescopic side i", "j1m-cREBRdI-00048-00011136-00011383": "didn't see exactly how he fired the", "j1m-cREBRdI-00049-00011384-00011631": "shots but when they were coming down", "j1m-cREBRdI-00050-00011632-00011846": "from the penthouse i saw the sniper", "j1m-cREBRdI-00051-00011847-00011967": "rifle", "j1m-cREBRdI-00052-00011968-00012255": "the sniper rifles yes i saw the one", "j1m-cREBRdI-00053-00012256-00012487": "doing this shooting i saw the telescopic", "j1m-cREBRdI-00054-00012488-00012774": "sight i didn't see exactly how he fired", "j1m-cREBRdI-00055-00012775-00013046": "the shots but when they were coming down", "j1m-cREBRdI-00056-00013047-00013263": "from the penthouse i saw the sniper", "j1m-cREBRdI-00057-00013263-00013495": "rifle"}}, {"audio_id": "j1y8b4eeDog", "text": {"j1y8b4eeDog-00000-00000017-00000275": "I am sir top tech and welcome back to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00001-00000276-00000647": "one the off fangame so the last left off", "j1y8b4eeDog-00002-00000648-00000937": "we have just cleared zone one so there's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00003-00000938-00001154": "only two zones to go plus the room if", "j1y8b4eeDog-00004-00001155-00001373": "it's in this game which this is the demo", "j1y8b4eeDog-00005-00001374-00001693": "version 4.5 I don't know I don't know", "j1y8b4eeDog-00006-00001694-00001951": "how far it goes into the original game", "j1y8b4eeDog-00007-00001952-00002156": "but that's right partner", "j1y8b4eeDog-00008-00002157-00002509": "zone 2 is here I did try and go back to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00009-00002510-00002584": "that Padano", "j1y8b4eeDog-00010-00002585-00002864": "that we missed there was a call paddle", "j1y8b4eeDog-00011-00002865-00003208": "Oh button in the at nighttime area zone", "j1y8b4eeDog-00012-00003209-00003527": "place that we were at and you can't go", "j1y8b4eeDog-00013-00003528-00003656": "back there", "j1y8b4eeDog-00014-00003657-00004034": "what happens is the the way to the right", "j1y8b4eeDog-00015-00004035-00004235": "that was open at night it's not open", "j1y8b4eeDog-00016-00004236-00004420": "during the daytime when we're playing so", "j1y8b4eeDog-00017-00004421-00004592": "you can't go back there if anyone knows", "j1y8b4eeDog-00018-00004593-00004663": "what was in there", "j1y8b4eeDog-00019-00004664-00004829": "please do let me know that would be", "j1y8b4eeDog-00020-00004830-00005099": "great to know if it's super amazing", "j1y8b4eeDog-00021-00005100-00005324": "great like sugar comes back and there's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00022-00005325-00005666": "like a party and you mean nikki is there", "j1y8b4eeDog-00023-00005667-00006017": "and sans undertale there's a rave dance", "j1y8b4eeDog-00024-00006018-00006299": "is that sure if it's just like an item", "j1y8b4eeDog-00025-00006300-00006478": "just I'd like to know but I probably", "j1y8b4eeDog-00026-00006479-00006752": "won't go back for that you can't read it", "j1y8b4eeDog-00027-00006753-00006964": "because do can't read but there are no", "j1y8b4eeDog-00028-00006965-00007006": "words", "j1y8b4eeDog-00029-00007008-00007469": "ooh a little bit a little splash of", "j1y8b4eeDog-00030-00007470-00007613": "color in there", "j1y8b4eeDog-00031-00007614-00008433": "little titanium parts see how the eyes", "j1y8b4eeDog-00032-00008434-00008639": "blind you is of course they do", "j1y8b4eeDog-00033-00008640-00008927": "alright let's scan these scan these real", "j1y8b4eeDog-00034-00008928-00009138": "quick I can already guess the gimmick", "j1y8b4eeDog-00035-00009139-00009638": "but alright oh that's bad I guess you", "j1y8b4eeDog-00036-00009639-00010253": "can just use an eye okay beholder", "j1y8b4eeDog-00037-00010254-00010649": "fleshie all-seeing booth I will say the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00038-00010650-00010814": "enemy descriptions are a little plain", "j1y8b4eeDog-00039-00010815-00010967": "and that you don't have a lot of space", "j1y8b4eeDog-00040-00010968-00011252": "to work with you but I love really", "j1y8b4eeDog-00041-00011253-00011394": "detailed best areas that kind of gives", "j1y8b4eeDog-00042-00011395-00012030": "like they give a little in detail on the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00043-00012031-00012227": "enemies like what they eat what they how", "j1y8b4eeDog-00044-00012228-00012497": "they interact with the world when where", "j1y8b4eeDog-00045-00012498-00012624": "they came from I don't know just", "j1y8b4eeDog-00046-00012625-00012886": "something a little complicated but hey", "j1y8b4eeDog-00047-00012887-00013458": "it's a week to me and smoke", "j1y8b4eeDog-00048-00013459-00013868": "and Big Smoke was gonna drop a train on", "j1y8b4eeDog-00049-00013869-00015174": "hate that zero damage thing nice how", "j1y8b4eeDog-00050-00015175-00016059": "good is how good is the music off these", "j1y8b4eeDog-00051-00016060-00016533": "are all remixes of course but mostly", "j1y8b4eeDog-00052-00016534-00017022": "up-tempo generally speaking people feel", "j1y8b4eeDog-00053-00017023-00017712": "a little more excitement I suppose horse", "j1y8b4eeDog-00054-00017713-00018000": "boulders are like that all right", "j1y8b4eeDog-00055-00018001-00018269": "adversaries purified not that", "j1y8b4eeDog-00056-00018270-00018579": "experienced of cours it drops I hasty", "j1y8b4eeDog-00057-00018580-00018633": "strike", "j1y8b4eeDog-00058-00018634-00019140": "what's hasty strike do for us the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00059-00019141-00019697": "confidence right so plastic attack with", "j1y8b4eeDog-00060-00019698-00019935": "mediocre impact so funny all those", "j1y8b4eeDog-00061-00019936-00020147": "little quirks of the original English", "j1y8b4eeDog-00062-00020148-00020556": "translation became so impactful in the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00063-00020557-00020675": "community especially the English", "j1y8b4eeDog-00064-00020676-00020952": "community obviously because oh oh this", "j1y8b4eeDog-00065-00020953-00021108": "building I wrote I remember this", "j1y8b4eeDog-00066-00021109-00021390": "building", "j1y8b4eeDog-00067-00021391-00021579": "the corruptor terrifying they have no", "j1y8b4eeDog-00068-00021580-00021798": "eyes if they somehow know is going on", "j1y8b4eeDog-00069-00021799-00022320": "around them the child how'd you get to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00070-00022321-00022641": "this forsaken place do walk their savage", "j1y8b4eeDog-00071-00022642-00022869": "monsters out there mad monsters no match", "j1y8b4eeDog-00072-00022870-00023046": "for doo doo fight and beat monster with", "j1y8b4eeDog-00073-00023047-00023250": "helpless attack them maybe you can help", "j1y8b4eeDog-00074-00023251-00023475": "us out Jeff at a royal Guardians but", "j1y8b4eeDog-00075-00023476-00023739": "overthrown by an outside force since the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00076-00023740-00023952": "purification has lost his powers no one", "j1y8b4eeDog-00077-00023953-00024144": "can fight these fiends please go talk to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00078-00024145-00024387": "Jack you should be at last upstairs", "j1y8b4eeDog-00079-00024388-00024780": "fourth floor shame all the books were", "j1y8b4eeDog-00080-00024781-00025254": "wiped I imagined the ghosts just sounds", "j1y8b4eeDog-00081-00025255-00025569": "so done with like existence even though", "j1y8b4eeDog-00082-00025570-00025779": "the pages of blank still like to look at", "j1y8b4eeDog-00083-00025780-00026319": "the books I screw up the park the gods", "j1y8b4eeDog-00084-00026320-00026714": "over my ghouls it's all ghouls now the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00085-00026716-00026919": "spectres are the good guys and ghouls", "j1y8b4eeDog-00086-00026920-00027075": "are the bad guys have you noticed that", "j1y8b4eeDog-00087-00027076-00027351": "all the enemies described as ghouls they", "j1y8b4eeDog-00088-00027352-00027843": "all blank no it's not past this point", "j1y8b4eeDog-00089-00027844-00028047": "I'm sorry I have to talk to japhet about", "j1y8b4eeDog-00090-00028048-00028644": "it ah RPG gating classic let's go to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00091-00028645-00028820": "part park should be this way I remember", "j1y8b4eeDog-00092-00028822-00029136": "that much what's the question my", "j1y8b4eeDog-00093-00029137-00029422": "situation", "j1y8b4eeDog-00094-00029423-00029677": "I think it was used to be symbols and", "j1y8b4eeDog-00095-00029677-00029836": "once you purified it turned into", "j1y8b4eeDog-00096-00029837-00030268": "question marks afraid to leave here you", "j1y8b4eeDog-00097-00030269-00030631": "wanna become corrupted son has become", "j1y8b4eeDog-00098-00030632-00031077": "corrupt please help us", "j1y8b4eeDog-00099-00031079-00031320": "dumps like YouTube ghosts or something", "j1y8b4eeDog-00100-00031322-00031489": "heard the library is safe I'm too scared", "j1y8b4eeDog-00101-00031489-00031695": "to leave guys it's like this is a huge", "j1y8b4eeDog-00102-00031697-00032035": "20 feet loop pink note so I'm gonna get", "j1y8b4eeDog-00103-00032036-00032308": "a pink slip you can't have the only", "j1y8b4eeDog-00104-00032308-00032512": "piece of color on the screen and I can't", "j1y8b4eeDog-00105-00032513-00032860": "expect it all it's rude whatever -", "j1y8b4eeDog-00106-00032861-00033268": "loving tickets found a ticket for free", "j1y8b4eeDog-00107-00033269-00033871": "lovin so all the words oh this is one", "j1y8b4eeDog-00108-00033872-00034010": "way to keep me out huh", "j1y8b4eeDog-00109-00034011-00034281": "[Music]", "j1y8b4eeDog-00110-00034282-00034576": "all the words in this whole place were", "j1y8b4eeDog-00111-00034577-00034914": "just purged clean I suppose", "j1y8b4eeDog-00112-00034915-00035361": "it's interesting all the cows were gone", "j1y8b4eeDog-00113-00035362-00035638": "that's meat by the way that those lumps", "j1y8b4eeDog-00114-00035639-00035791": "those are meat for those of you there", "j1y8b4eeDog-00115-00035792-00036040": "those naughty naughty Stinky's watching", "j1y8b4eeDog-00116-00036041-00036139": "without playing the original off", "j1y8b4eeDog-00117-00036140-00036354": "honestly I think this would be", "j1y8b4eeDog-00118-00036355-00036553": "reasonably enjoyable I would definitely", "j1y8b4eeDog-00119-00036554-00036751": "play off first but I think if you're", "j1y8b4eeDog-00120-00036752-00036871": "just watching the video serious I think", "j1y8b4eeDog-00121-00036872-00037027": "you get a decent amount enjoyment I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00122-00037028-00037225": "would still definitely recommend you", "j1y8b4eeDog-00123-00037226-00037363": "want to check it out the original off", "j1y8b4eeDog-00124-00037364-00037546": "playthrough of mine or just playing it", "j1y8b4eeDog-00125-00037547-00037747": "yourself they have a full playthrough of", "j1y8b4eeDog-00126-00037748-00038038": "off I was even working on a walkthrough", "j1y8b4eeDog-00127-00038039-00038198": "and I kind of", "j1y8b4eeDog-00128-00038199-00038641": "I don't have stress it's carpet hello I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00129-00038642-00039089": "have grown alive from my mouth hole I am", "j1y8b4eeDog-00130-00039090-00039293": "going to war you with this hole in my", "j1y8b4eeDog-00131-00039294-00039356": "chest", "j1y8b4eeDog-00132-00039357-00040042": "oh right Cola and I got a I got a scared", "j1y8b4eeDog-00133-00040043-00040307": "I'm sorry but I can't see that that that", "j1y8b4eeDog-00134-00040308-00040705": "muffin felt mal draped razor-toothed", "j1y8b4eeDog-00135-00040706-00040910": "incarnation it's not a goal it's an", "j1y8b4eeDog-00136-00040911-00041328": "incarnation a drinker metal", "j1y8b4eeDog-00137-00041329-00042273": "[Music]", "j1y8b4eeDog-00138-00042274-00042410": "Dane's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00139-00042411-00042923": "both literates those guys huh we even", "j1y8b4eeDog-00140-00042924-00043277": "have metal attack no don't", "j1y8b4eeDog-00141-00043278-00043434": "[Music]", "j1y8b4eeDog-00142-00043435-00043661": "you know HUS with these critical", "j1y8b4eeDog-00143-00043662-00043947": "critical fumbles I guess where I don't", "j1y8b4eeDog-00144-00043948-00044645": "deal any damage at all", "j1y8b4eeDog-00145-00044646-00045386": "you don't smoke if I ramping up the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00146-00045387-00046148": "experience getting button 13 this world", "j1y8b4eeDog-00147-00046149-00046745": "is definitely smaller I smaller than", "j1y8b4eeDog-00148-00046746-00046895": "originally was especially with no books", "j1y8b4eeDog-00149-00046896-00047321": "I wonder if all I remember my own", "j1y8b4eeDog-00150-00047322-00047567": "reaction when we saw a certain enemy", "j1y8b4eeDog-00151-00047568-00047852": "that I really hope is referenced here if", "j1y8b4eeDog-00152-00047853-00047990": "you remember off I'm sure you know the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00153-00047991-00048415": "one I'm thinking out I'm gonna heal here", "j1y8b4eeDog-00154-00048416-00048938": "save little dance make a little bit", "j1y8b4eeDog-00155-00048939-00049479": "allah dhu-l eternally wonder what was in", "j1y8b4eeDog-00156-00049480-00049710": "a tuck the podalic all signed I can't", "j1y8b4eeDog-00157-00049711-00049923": "believe her I passed over that I just", "j1y8b4eeDog-00158-00049924-00049992": "thought it was some kind of decoration", "j1y8b4eeDog-00159-00049993-00050435": "there's a book with pictures look sad", "j1y8b4eeDog-00160-00050436-00050662": "boys", "j1y8b4eeDog-00161-00050663-00050993": "it's like hands with like a little horn", "j1y8b4eeDog-00162-00050994-00051225": "- dude face the middle is a little reef", "j1y8b4eeDog-00163-00051226-00052145": "below it leaf sub miss at tumblr the Dan", "j1y8b4eeDog-00164-00052146-00052417": "and Jacqueline oh they're buddies", "j1y8b4eeDog-00165-00052419-00052868": "nature's freaks tumblr.com Jeff it just", "j1y8b4eeDog-00166-00052869-00053012": "looks like a hand puppet honestly he", "j1y8b4eeDog-00167-00053013-00053148": "just looks like a puppet on somebody's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00168-00053149-00053405": "hand and that's like the the neck", "j1y8b4eeDog-00169-00053406-00053649": "feathers are the extent of the pup oh", "j1y8b4eeDog-00170-00053650-00054092": "god I forgot about you Enoch apparently", "j1y8b4eeDog-00171-00054094-00054390": "was his name", "j1y8b4eeDog-00172-00054391-00054554": "I had forgotten that man I was glad I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00173-00054555-00055340": "did it is do Dan is that is that do huh", "j1y8b4eeDog-00174-00055341-00055625": "they don't blank this was originally a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00175-00055626-00055985": "puzzle thing these do and there is uh", "j1y8b4eeDog-00176-00055986-00056387": "there's good old dad in his bat face and", "j1y8b4eeDog-00177-00056388-00056741": "deathclaws bomb collar death tumbler it", "j1y8b4eeDog-00178-00056742-00057022": "doin plate oh that's that's plate", "j1y8b4eeDog-00179-00057023-00057591": "or is that blight yeah I guess that's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00180-00057592-00058222": "why wait they're both with pictures", "j1y8b4eeDog-00181-00058223-00058755": "that's Zachary I guess purification in", "j1y8b4eeDog-00182-00058757-00058801": "progress", "j1y8b4eeDog-00183-00058802-00059209": "oh poor elsens though poor Elsa it's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00184-00059210-00059350": "interesting to go into more into the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00185-00059351-00059785": "Burt concept but this game does I mean", "j1y8b4eeDog-00186-00059786-00059916": "Burt was in the original game but is", "j1y8b4eeDog-00187-00059917-00060019": "interesting that this game kind of", "j1y8b4eeDog-00188-00060020-00060358": "expands on its own way need to come to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00189-00060359-00060520": "bring all this fan work together it's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00190-00060521-00060685": "got some fan art it's got some fan", "j1y8b4eeDog-00191-00060686-00060855": "remixes and obviously it's a fan game", "j1y8b4eeDog-00192-00060857-00061167": "itself so it has that fan writing and", "j1y8b4eeDog-00193-00061169-00061519": "gameplay itself it's lost a creature", "j1y8b4eeDog-00194-00061520-00061779": "wasn't dead fascinating", "j1y8b4eeDog-00195-00061779-00061984": "what's wrong blank I thought we could", "j1y8b4eeDog-00196-00061985-00062466": "draw stuff in I mean why not libraries", "j1y8b4eeDog-00197-00062467-00062679": "the only safe place from the corrupted", "j1y8b4eeDog-00198-00062679-00062923": "it's just so boring now I'm just drawing", "j1y8b4eeDog-00199-00062924-00063238": "them like the other guy only I could", "j1y8b4eeDog-00200-00063239-00063385": "leave if I leave I could become a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00201-00063386-00064009": "corrupted that doesn't sound fun this", "j1y8b4eeDog-00202-00064010-00064153": "was one of the larger puzzles like", "j1y8b4eeDog-00203-00064154-00064495": "multiple things take a quick look at all", "j1y8b4eeDog-00204-00064496-00064909": "the fan earthy the ones with shadows are", "j1y8b4eeDog-00205-00064910-00065050": "the ones of the original game that had", "j1y8b4eeDog-00206-00065051-00065551": "some puzzle elements so now they're the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00207-00065552-00066226": "ones that the fan are so bored yes this", "j1y8b4eeDog-00208-00066227-00066358": "seemed like a little boring place I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00209-00066359-00066751": "guess oh that's the Queen what's me", "j1y8b4eeDog-00210-00066752-00066984": "can't read that", "j1y8b4eeDog-00211-00066985-00067371": "love wealth from the Queen mall", "j1y8b4eeDog-00212-00067372-00067824": "it's beast in the mall mall here so do", "j1y8b4eeDog-00213-00067825-00068073": "speak then okay boo like my Specter", "j1y8b4eeDog-00214-00068074-00069147": "impression sure do buddy said that do so", "j1y8b4eeDog-00215-00069148-00069405": "some of the fell so affair I kind of", "j1y8b4eeDog-00216-00069406-00069540": "divergence the original-style I can't", "j1y8b4eeDog-00217-00069541-00069651": "really tell who's supposed to be who", "j1y8b4eeDog-00218-00069652-00069891": "it's obviously the matter and I guess", "j1y8b4eeDog-00219-00069892-00070428": "that's Zachary Zachary face was always a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00220-00070429-00070644": "bit of a mystery to me and this is", "j1y8b4eeDog-00221-00070645-00070920": "moving squares outside you see that is a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00222-00070921-00071613": "missing texture outside you gotta love", "j1y8b4eeDog-00223-00071614-00071937": "the whispers go on oh I like better it", "j1y8b4eeDog-00224-00071938-00072162": "style is very good who's the kitty", "j1y8b4eeDog-00225-00072163-00072468": "though I don't particularly remember a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00226-00072469-00072729": "kitty cat oh oh that's the judge what am", "j1y8b4eeDog-00227-00072730-00073116": "I saying the judge judge and Valerie are", "j1y8b4eeDog-00228-00073117-00073500": "so uncapped like is surreal to see them", "j1y8b4eeDog-00229-00073501-00073875": "in that kind of way this is Valerie at", "j1y8b4eeDog-00230-00073876-00074397": "the top right it's very strange to see", "j1y8b4eeDog-00231-00074398-00074574": "the off care just such a happy art style", "j1y8b4eeDog-00232-00074575-00074748": "I was like initially like what is this", "j1y8b4eeDog-00233-00074749-00075072": "the Dan is hard to miss but the others", "j1y8b4eeDog-00234-00075073-00075879": "huh Jeff it's Babu who real Jeff it's a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00235-00075880-00076128": "Phoenix so it was reborn I've never seen", "j1y8b4eeDog-00236-00076129-00076359": "him before in fact you had them playing", "j1y8b4eeDog-00237-00076360-00076547": "on a living how is that possible I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00238-00076548-00076761": "didn't want such as you get past all the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00239-00076762-00077013": "corrupted so tap that belt dude it's a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00240-00077014-00077070": "tech duck", "j1y8b4eeDog-00241-00077071-00077268": "I'm not familiar with such a name do", "j1y8b4eeDog-00242-00077269-00077544": "puppeteer help do beat monsters and help", "j1y8b4eeDog-00243-00077545-00077862": "did it did it oh you mean it in so wait", "j1y8b4eeDog-00244-00077863-00078024": "you freed someone from the corrupted", "j1y8b4eeDog-00245-00078025-00078381": "yeah but do have certain episode they", "j1y8b4eeDog-00246-00078382-00078636": "not here do probably could be this is", "j1y8b4eeDog-00247-00078637-00078867": "astounding finally someone who can help", "j1y8b4eeDog-00248-00078868-00079104": "me regain my precious zone you Jeffy", "j1y8b4eeDog-00249-00079105-00079428": "Jeff it but yes I'm the true guardian of", "j1y8b4eeDog-00250-00079429-00079488": "the zone", "j1y8b4eeDog-00251-00079489-00079707": "a creature of corrupted origin took my", "j1y8b4eeDog-00252-00079708-00079899": "place and is ruining everything I worked", "j1y8b4eeDog-00253-00079900-00080021": "so hard to create", "j1y8b4eeDog-00254-00080022-00080633": "tiny birdie poor Jeff are you sure you'd", "j1y8b4eeDog-00255-00080634-00080990": "help the Dan out I'm not just lost it", "j1y8b4eeDog-00256-00080991-00081347": "true dupe Beach out and help did it do", "j1y8b4eeDog-00257-00081348-00081608": "help Jaffe to actually hope you speak", "j1y8b4eeDog-00258-00081609-00081887": "the truth card stasher I said no chance", "j1y8b4eeDog-00259-00081888-00082175": "against the corrupt Tony took my place", "j1y8b4eeDog-00260-00082176-00082355": "ran to the residential area over there", "j1y8b4eeDog-00261-00082356-00082528": "it influences spread to cross my zone", "j1y8b4eeDog-00262-00082529-00082772": "right at residential areas blocked the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00263-00082773-00082958": "only way through it isn't a part do help", "j1y8b4eeDog-00264-00082959-00083053": "jacket party", "j1y8b4eeDog-00265-00083054-00083267": "we've been residential area can fell", "j1y8b4eeDog-00266-00083268-00083588": "through the mall but but require", "j1y8b4eeDog-00267-00083589-00083723": "assistance I can't let a child like", "j1y8b4eeDog-00268-00083724-00083831": "yourself be thrown in danger oh I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00269-00083832-00084023": "remember them all now yeah we you can", "j1y8b4eeDog-00270-00084024-00084275": "visit the mall on the original I didn't", "j1y8b4eeDog-00271-00084276-00084434": "know what I'd do if I'd let a child get", "j1y8b4eeDog-00272-00084435-00084485": "hurt", "j1y8b4eeDog-00273-00084486-00084752": "speak for yourself do not we do know how", "j1y8b4eeDog-00274-00084753-00084803": "to fight", "j1y8b4eeDog-00275-00084804-00085052": "Papa teach you don't understand there's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00276-00085053-00085181": "a mysterious Beast that dwells within", "j1y8b4eeDog-00277-00085182-00085424": "that mall every was after that dem", "j1y8b4eeDog-00278-00085425-00085795": "buildings walls vanished never return I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00279-00085796-00086695": "know I know what this damned mall is I", "j1y8b4eeDog-00280-00086696-00087278": "know it is that of which we dare not", "j1y8b4eeDog-00281-00087279-00088342": "speak the name we dare not speak", "j1y8b4eeDog-00282-00088343-00088661": "everyone else everyone who had entered", "j1y8b4eeDog-00283-00088662-00088939": "that damn buildings walls and managed", "j1y8b4eeDog-00284-00088940-00089518": "never to return", "j1y8b4eeDog-00285-00089519-00089819": "only one resident man to escape never", "j1y8b4eeDog-00286-00089820-00089996": "the same since dude we'll stop bad", "j1y8b4eeDog-00287-00089997-00090410": "monster then are you sure yeah you say", "j1y8b4eeDog-00288-00090411-00090452": "so", "j1y8b4eeDog-00289-00090453-00090835": "here take this so you enter the mall", "j1y8b4eeDog-00290-00090836-00090977": "excuse me", "j1y8b4eeDog-00291-00090978-00091178": "let's do more help I get crushed by", "j1y8b4eeDog-00292-00091179-00091373": "anything in my current state it's okay", "j1y8b4eeDog-00293-00091374-00091952": "dude be fine hmm something wrong I can't", "j1y8b4eeDog-00294-00091953-00092159": "help but wonder you remind me of someone", "j1y8b4eeDog-00295-00092160-00092780": "I knew long ago Duke it pass I was", "j1y8b4eeDog-00296-00092781-00093047": "talking with friends and discord today", "j1y8b4eeDog-00297-00093048-00093482": "about how the theory was that a curry um", "j1y8b4eeDog-00298-00093483-00093767": "kind of impressed upon Toby Fox the idea", "j1y8b4eeDog-00299-00093768-00094127": "of sands are inspired rather I would say", "j1y8b4eeDog-00300-00094128-00094361": "more the judge really the judge speaks", "j1y8b4eeDog-00301-00094362-00094547": "directly to the player even at the very", "j1y8b4eeDog-00302-00094548-00094979": "beginning the judge you know tries to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00303-00094980-00095258": "stop the player or at least tries to", "j1y8b4eeDog-00304-00095259-00095429": "stop the batter and admonish is the", "j1y8b4eeDog-00305-00095430-00095633": "player which is a thing that happens a", "j1y8b4eeDog-00306-00095634-00095843": "lot in a certain style of play through", "j1y8b4eeDog-00307-00095844-00096089": "an undertale I'm trying to be vague", "j1y8b4eeDog-00308-00096090-00096482": "because you know spoiling two games", "j1y8b4eeDog-00309-00096483-00096830": "what's basically otherwise but um if you", "j1y8b4eeDog-00310-00096831-00096989": "like to undertale you like off and if", "j1y8b4eeDog-00311-00096990-00097157": "you like off you like undertale I would", "j1y8b4eeDog-00312-00097158-00097375": "say those are", "j1y8b4eeDog-00313-00097376-00097598": "very similar in a lot of very major", "j1y8b4eeDog-00314-00097599-00097874": "veins since he had permission", "j1y8b4eeDog-00315-00097875-00098801": "this led you through our is there a save", "j1y8b4eeDog-00316-00098802-00099448": "point here ooh", "j1y8b4eeDog-00317-00099449-00099836": "what's the mall actually was the mall in", "j1y8b4eeDog-00318-00099837-00100067": "the original are my am i doing a false", "j1y8b4eeDog-00319-00100068-00100541": "memory I hate to do it to you but we're", "j1y8b4eeDog-00320-00100542-00100850": "past 15 minutes we have a nice little", "j1y8b4eeDog-00321-00100851-00101149": "cliffhanger here we have some cool music", "j1y8b4eeDog-00322-00101150-00101465": "I'm gonna call it here Oh check out one", "j1y8b4eeDog-00323-00101466-00101684": "shot too if you liked off and undertale", "j1y8b4eeDog-00324-00101685-00101855": "please check out one shot that's another", "j1y8b4eeDog-00325-00101856-00102152": "really cool RPG Mike your game - that's", "j1y8b4eeDog-00326-00102153-00102293": "I have a full playthrough on my channel", "j1y8b4eeDog-00327-00102294-00102440": "absolutely adored that game I have an", "j1y8b4eeDog-00328-00102441-00102817": "eco plush in fact but some we will enter", "j1y8b4eeDog-00329-00102818-00103255": "this ominous building next video see you", "j1y8b4eeDog-00330-00103256-00103472": "then"}}, {"audio_id": "j1ZNKxtWabc", "text": {"j1ZNKxtWabc-00000-00000000-00000599": "[Music]", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00001-00000600-00000862": "recently i just had a meeting with some", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00002-00000863-00001135": "young leaders that brought so much joy", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00003-00001136-00001335": "into my heart let me explain", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00004-00001336-00001503": "these young people just joined our", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00005-00001504-00001782": "ministry team and i was impressed by", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00006-00001784-00002014": "their faith and zeal so i said i want to", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00007-00002016-00002199": "know you better i had a meeting with", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00008-00002200-00002495": "them and asked about their background i", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00009-00002496-00002734": "was so touched because a couple of them", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00010-00002735-00003047": "two out of three said oh pastor almost", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00011-00003048-00003327": "uh i want to serve iran alive because", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00012-00003328-00003590": "when i was eight years old i was", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00013-00003592-00003863": "watching you and that's when i got saved", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00014-00003864-00004127": "and all these years i've taken your", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00015-00004128-00004319": "classes i've watched your sermons and", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00016-00004320-00004567": "have grown and always wanted to serve", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00017-00004568-00004806": "the lord with you i am so excited to", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00018-00004807-00005047": "join your team", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00019-00005048-00005367": "eight year old saved now 10 12 years", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00020-00005368-00005702": "later serving the lord with me oh my god", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00021-00005703-00006054": "what's a joy another one said i was 12.", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00022-00006055-00006270": "i was 12 and i came to christ through", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00023-00006271-00006623": "your programs and now i'm honored to", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00024-00006623-00006814": "serve the lord with you we are looking", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00025-00006815-00006983": "forward to this", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00026-00006984-00007110": "my beloved", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00027-00007111-00007270": "when we reach the", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00028-00007272-00007503": "children we are reaching out the next", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00029-00007504-00007742": "generation they brought so much joy", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00030-00007743-00008055": "because it showed me so important it is", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00031-00008056-00008327": "to reach out to children", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00032-00008328-00008542": "the children of today will be leaders of", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00033-00008543-00008663": "tomorrow", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00034-00008664-00008871": "you know there are two requests from", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00035-00008872-00009206": "underground church of iran coming in all", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00036-00009207-00009446": "the time number one they tell us okay", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00037-00009447-00009646": "our house church is growing but what do", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00038-00009647-00009863": "you have for the children how can we", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00039-00009864-00010023": "reach out to children how can we", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00040-00010024-00010255": "evangelize children how can we disciple", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00041-00010256-00010495": "children do you have any material", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00042-00010496-00010855": "number two the parents would you help us", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00043-00010856-00011046": "to disciple our kids", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00044-00011047-00011231": "would you teach us how to parent our", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00045-00011232-00011503": "kids these are two important requests", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00046-00011504-00011727": "coming from underground church in iran", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00047-00011728-00011983": "and today i want to ask you would you", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00048-00011984-00012246": "pray with me and would you join me in", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00049-00012247-00012574": "equipping not just the parents equipping", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00050-00012575-00012894": "and reaching out to children in iran", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00051-00012895-00013127": "which will help us produce new programs", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00052-00013128-00013399": "new material not just for the children", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00053-00013400-00013615": "themselves but for the leaders and for", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00054-00013616-00013830": "the parents as how to reach out to", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00055-00013831-00013983": "children", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00056-00013984-00014111": "i'm praying", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00057-00014112-00014294": "and i'm reaching out to the children of", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00058-00014295-00014591": "iran you know why because the children", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00059-00014591-00014894": "of today will be national leaders of", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00060-00014895-00015430": "iran tomorrow god bless you", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00061-00015431-00015943": "[Music]", "j1ZNKxtWabc-00062-00015944-00016151": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "j2dstLFXklo", "text": {"j2dstLFXklo-00000-00000000-00000265": "good morning everyone and welcome to", "j2dstLFXklo-00001-00000266-00000593": "this webinar on responsibilities risks", "j2dstLFXklo-00002-00000594-00000908": "and rewards of directorship my name is", "j2dstLFXklo-00003-00000909-00001085": "claire Braund i'm the executive director", "j2dstLFXklo-00004-00001086-00001399": "and founder of women on boards and we", "j2dstLFXklo-00005-00001400-00001639": "are delighted to be partnering with red", "j2dstLFXklo-00006-00001641-00001814": "beck conferencing and governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00007-00001814-00002063": "Institute of Australia in bringing you", "j2dstLFXklo-00008-00002064-00002306": "this morning's discussion before we", "j2dstLFXklo-00009-00002307-00002465": "start I would like to acknowledge", "j2dstLFXklo-00010-00002466-00002765": "country the gadigal people of the e Ora", "j2dstLFXklo-00011-00002766-00003034": "nation and in fact elders past and", "j2dstLFXklo-00012-00003035-00003386": "present across this nation of ours who", "j2dstLFXklo-00013-00003386-00003661": "for many tens of thousands of years have", "j2dstLFXklo-00014-00003663-00003935": "demonstrated leadership and and", "j2dstLFXklo-00015-00003936-00004154": "governance and really it's on those", "j2dstLFXklo-00016-00004155-00004481": "skills that we build today we've got an", "j2dstLFXklo-00017-00004482-00004720": "excellent panel all women on boards", "j2dstLFXklo-00018-00004721-00004925": "members and a number of them from", "j2dstLFXklo-00019-00004926-00005165": "governance Institute and I'd like to", "j2dstLFXklo-00020-00005166-00005413": "turn to them now to introduce themselves", "j2dstLFXklo-00021-00005414-00005783": "to you first of all Leah freaky Thank", "j2dstLFXklo-00022-00005784-00005954": "You Claire my name's Leah freaky I've", "j2dstLFXklo-00023-00005955-00006140": "been a non-executive director for around", "j2dstLFXklo-00024-00006141-00006347": "three years in the commercial space and", "j2dstLFXklo-00025-00006348-00006578": "for at least a 15 years prior to that on", "j2dstLFXklo-00026-00006579-00006910": "not-for-profit boards I was a lawyer and", "j2dstLFXklo-00027-00006911-00007064": "company secretary in my professional", "j2dstLFXklo-00028-00007065-00007325": "career my final executive role was a GM", "j2dstLFXklo-00029-00007326-00007459": "role looking after a range of", "j2dstLFXklo-00030-00007461-00007664": "operational areas in financial services", "j2dstLFXklo-00031-00007665-00007895": "I've been very fortunate to work on a", "j2dstLFXklo-00032-00007895-00008071": "number of indigenous corporation board", "j2dstLFXklo-00033-00008072-00008360": "so I echo my acknowledgment of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00034-00008361-00008588": "elders past and present across the", "j2dstLFXklo-00035-00008589-00008831": "nation and I currently work in a range", "j2dstLFXklo-00036-00008832-00009041": "of areas including medical technology", "j2dstLFXklo-00037-00009042-00009292": "and financial services thank you very", "j2dstLFXklo-00038-00009293-00009569": "much Leah and to Janet Tony thanks", "j2dstLFXklo-00039-00009570-00009788": "Claire I've been a non-executive", "j2dstLFXklo-00040-00009789-00010049": "director on a professional basis for", "j2dstLFXklo-00041-00010050-00010277": "about three years the areas that I've", "j2dstLFXklo-00042-00010278-00010505": "covered a very much in the financial", "j2dstLFXklo-00043-00010506-00010717": "services not-for-profit and to some", "j2dstLFXklo-00044-00010718-00010874": "extent in the engineering area I'm", "j2dstLFXklo-00045-00010875-00011120": "currently chairman of white helm capital", "j2dstLFXklo-00046-00011121-00011281": "which is a global infrastructure", "j2dstLFXklo-00047-00011282-00011513": "investment management business and an", "j2dstLFXklo-00048-00011514-00011759": "advisory business serving on a range of", "j2dstLFXklo-00049-00011760-00011978": "their committees and also chairing their", "j2dstLFXklo-00050-00011979-00012176": "investment committee recently been", "j2dstLFXklo-00051-00012177-00012385": "appointed to a credit union board and", "j2dstLFXklo-00052-00012386-00012512": "I'm also on the board of girl guides", "j2dstLFXklo-00053-00012513-00012776": "Australia something right to my heart I", "j2dstLFXklo-00054-00012777-00012929": "grew up through the guiding movement and", "j2dstLFXklo-00055-00012930-00013046": "that's one of the good things about", "j2dstLFXklo-00056-00013047-00013294": "boards that you actually come back to", "j2dstLFXklo-00057-00013295-00013319": "your", "j2dstLFXklo-00058-00013319-00013574": "it's very often as well as that I'm on a", "j2dstLFXklo-00059-00013575-00013844": "range of advisory boards Australian", "j2dstLFXklo-00060-00013844-00013994": "cycling executives which is a", "j2dstLFXklo-00061-00013994-00014207": "professional networking group for senior", "j2dstLFXklo-00062-00014208-00014425": "executives professional IT and", "j2dstLFXklo-00063-00014426-00014758": "investment areas also involved with as", "j2dstLFXklo-00064-00014759-00014957": "far which is the association of", "j2dstLFXklo-00065-00014958-00015275": "superannuation funds of Australia with a", "j2dstLFXklo-00066-00015276-00015472": "different hat on I have executive", "j2dstLFXklo-00067-00015473-00015680": "director roles in two smaller consulting", "j2dstLFXklo-00068-00015681-00015911": "businesses one for professional services", "j2dstLFXklo-00069-00015912-00016066": "and one in the engineering and", "j2dstLFXklo-00070-00016068-00016375": "manufacturing sector my experience in", "j2dstLFXklo-00071-00016376-00016553": "these professional roles has been built", "j2dstLFXklo-00072-00016554-00016855": "over the last 25 years in terms of", "j2dstLFXklo-00073-00016856-00017131": "directorships both in my executive", "j2dstLFXklo-00074-00017132-00017353": "career and not-for-profit community", "j2dstLFXklo-00075-00017354-00017578": "based organizations industry-based", "j2dstLFXklo-00076-00017579-00017908": "associations so overall it's with a joy", "j2dstLFXklo-00077-00017909-00018100": "that you move into the non-executive", "j2dstLFXklo-00078-00018101-00018331": "director space and that's something", "j2dstLFXklo-00079-00018332-00018452": "we're going to discuss later today", "j2dstLFXklo-00080-00018453-00018635": "thanks very much dinner it is indeed", "j2dstLFXklo-00081-00018636-00018899": "Trisha good morning Claire and good", "j2dstLFXklo-00082-00018900-00019160": "morning everyone my name is Trisha mark", "j2dstLFXklo-00083-00019161-00019369": "and I'm the current president and chair", "j2dstLFXklo-00084-00019370-00019694": "of governance Institute of Australia my", "j2dstLFXklo-00085-00019695-00019874": "journey with governance Institute began", "j2dstLFXklo-00086-00019875-00020228": "when I was a student in 2004 2006 and", "j2dstLFXklo-00087-00020229-00020372": "did the Graduate Diploma applied", "j2dstLFXklo-00088-00020373-00020615": "corporate governance then joined the", "j2dstLFXklo-00089-00020616-00020905": "council and then became representative", "j2dstLFXklo-00090-00020906-00021212": "director on the board I became vice", "j2dstLFXklo-00091-00021213-00021455": "president two years ago and was", "j2dstLFXklo-00092-00021456-00021643": "appointed president this year as", "j2dstLFXklo-00093-00021644-00021968": "president I'm the chair of the board I", "j2dstLFXklo-00094-00021969-00022172": "recently chaired board meeting on the", "j2dstLFXklo-00095-00022173-00022453": "eighth of may and the AGM as well in", "j2dstLFXklo-00096-00022454-00022900": "Adelaide and in terms of strategy key", "j2dstLFXklo-00097-00022901-00023206": "focus for me is raising awareness of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00098-00023207-00023353": "name change from chartered secretaries", "j2dstLFXklo-00099-00023354-00023644": "Australia to governance Institute more", "j2dstLFXklo-00100-00023645-00023822": "so passionate about women in governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00101-00023823-00024058": "and events like today and women on", "j2dstLFXklo-00102-00024059-00024380": "boards is very important to me finally", "j2dstLFXklo-00103-00024381-00024530": "I'd like to be known as the digital", "j2dstLFXklo-00104-00024531-00024775": "president I'm trying to move governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00105-00024776-00025153": "institute into the digital age and like", "j2dstLFXklo-00106-00025154-00025387": "my co-panelists Leah freaky and quite", "j2dstLFXklo-00107-00025388-00025661": "active on Twitter and if anybody's", "j2dstLFXklo-00108-00025662-00025864": "online at the moment please please feel", "j2dstLFXklo-00109-00025866-00026053": "free to tweet about the panel today", "j2dstLFXklo-00110-00026054-00026324": "thank you thank you very much a great", "j2dstLFXklo-00111-00026325-00026533": "point and a number of you might be on", "j2dstLFXklo-00112-00026534-00026587": "the women are", "j2dstLFXklo-00113-00026588-00026797": "boards Twitter stream as well which of", "j2dstLFXklo-00114-00026798-00027082": "course is women on boards so please feel", "j2dstLFXklo-00115-00027083-00027316": "free to tweet because you'll be sharing", "j2dstLFXklo-00116-00027317-00027577": "all of the knowledge in fact there are", "j2dstLFXklo-00117-00027577-00027904": "700 of you at last count there could be", "j2dstLFXklo-00118-00027905-00028261": "more out there listening to this so our", "j2dstLFXklo-00119-00028262-00028522": "thanks again for registering for today's", "j2dstLFXklo-00120-00028523-00028825": "conversation ok we're going to kick off", "j2dstLFXklo-00121-00028826-00029077": "you've all submitted some questions some", "j2dstLFXklo-00122-00029077-00029335": "areas that you want the panel to discuss", "j2dstLFXklo-00123-00029336-00029647": "a number of you are looking really at", "j2dstLFXklo-00124-00029648-00029854": "the first boards or looking at why you", "j2dstLFXklo-00125-00029855-00030241": "want to be a company director so really", "j2dstLFXklo-00126-00030242-00030483": "are the risks that great what are the", "j2dstLFXklo-00127-00030485-00030708": "rewards and more importantly what are", "j2dstLFXklo-00128-00030710-00030895": "the responsibilities i'm going to ask", "j2dstLFXklo-00129-00030895-00031123": "janet first off what the role of a", "j2dstLFXklo-00130-00031124-00031333": "non-executive director is and are there", "j2dstLFXklo-00131-00031333-00031543": "any really key skill sets that you think", "j2dstLFXklo-00132-00031544-00031873": "the directors need Claire one of the key", "j2dstLFXklo-00133-00031874-00032101": "things as a non exec director is to be", "j2dstLFXklo-00134-00032102-00032323": "part of a team people maybe not the", "j2dstLFXklo-00135-00032324-00032470": "first thing that people think about but", "j2dstLFXklo-00136-00032470-00032644": "as a non-executive director you're", "j2dstLFXklo-00137-00032645-00032962": "sitting around a border table it is the", "j2dstLFXklo-00138-00032963-00033313": "board's responsibility to oversee the", "j2dstLFXklo-00139-00033314-00033676": "business provide guidance set strategy", "j2dstLFXklo-00140-00033677-00033928": "make sure that you're complying with all", "j2dstLFXklo-00141-00033929-00034369": "the various risks and regulations but", "j2dstLFXklo-00142-00034370-00034564": "importantly you're part of that team in", "j2dstLFXklo-00143-00034565-00034882": "an ideal world you have actually got a", "j2dstLFXklo-00144-00034883-00035182": "skill set that combines with the others", "j2dstLFXklo-00145-00035183-00035398": "around that board to be able to provide", "j2dstLFXklo-00146-00035399-00035734": "the oversight you then come to you", "j2dstLFXklo-00147-00035735-00035944": "talked about core skill sets there's", "j2dstLFXklo-00148-00035945-00036091": "probably two things that you absolutely", "j2dstLFXklo-00149-00036092-00036337": "have to have you have to understand", "j2dstLFXklo-00150-00036338-00036535": "directors duties and responsibilities", "j2dstLFXklo-00151-00036536-00036751": "and you actually need to be understand", "j2dstLFXklo-00152-00036752-00037075": "the financials of the business there are", "j2dstLFXklo-00153-00037076-00037270": "things you can't come away away from I", "j2dstLFXklo-00154-00037271-00037426": "think we might have some discussion", "j2dstLFXklo-00155-00037427-00037612": "later they've both been tested very", "j2dstLFXklo-00156-00037613-00037882": "interestingly in some legal cases it is", "j2dstLFXklo-00157-00037883-00038101": "a collective as a board but you as", "j2dstLFXklo-00158-00038102-00038347": "individuals need to be able to take", "j2dstLFXklo-00159-00038348-00038605": "responsibility for those the other key", "j2dstLFXklo-00160-00038606-00038800": "skill sets that you're looking for is", "j2dstLFXklo-00161-00038801-00038994": "understanding your business or", "j2dstLFXklo-00162-00038995-00039169": "understanding the company you're with", "j2dstLFXklo-00163-00039170-00039442": "and then probably having a specialist", "j2dstLFXklo-00164-00039443-00039727": "skill around that board so that you can", "j2dstLFXklo-00165-00039728-00039915": "then as a collective", "j2dstLFXklo-00166-00039916-00040149": "make sure that you can deliver in terms", "j2dstLFXklo-00167-00040150-00040426": "of the other side of the business and I", "j2dstLFXklo-00168-00040427-00040626": "think will come to later again in terms", "j2dstLFXklo-00169-00040627-00040870": "of exec versus board but making sure", "j2dstLFXklo-00170-00040871-00041086": "you're not doing the work of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00171-00041087-00041251": "business but you're providing that", "j2dstLFXklo-00172-00041252-00041540": "oversight guidance and sounding board", "j2dstLFXklo-00173-00041541-00041811": "Leah would you echo those yeah I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00174-00041812-00041983": "Janet's covered off the key ones and I", "j2dstLFXklo-00175-00041984-00042162": "think that collaboration is a really", "j2dstLFXklo-00176-00042163-00042396": "important piece I think there are the", "j2dstLFXklo-00177-00042397-00042690": "skill sets of Finance strategy but once", "j2dstLFXklo-00178-00042691-00042846": "you're in the room your capacity to", "j2dstLFXklo-00179-00042847-00043011": "collaborate with others is really", "j2dstLFXklo-00180-00043012-00043167": "important and there are a couple of", "j2dstLFXklo-00181-00043168-00043415": "things aloud I think that the", "j2dstLFXklo-00182-00043416-00043683": "relationship with your CEO and your", "j2dstLFXklo-00183-00043684-00044035": "capacity to engage and encourage and", "j2dstLFXklo-00184-00044036-00044257": "monitor and nurture that relationship is", "j2dstLFXklo-00185-00044258-00044470": "important and I think the final thing", "j2dstLFXklo-00186-00044471-00044640": "which I usually say is the most", "j2dstLFXklo-00187-00044641-00044799": "important skill of the director is", "j2dstLFXklo-00188-00044800-00044986": "actually courage I think it's that", "j2dstLFXklo-00189-00044987-00045414": "capacity to have courage to do the right", "j2dstLFXklo-00190-00045415-00045732": "thing to understand when to speak when", "j2dstLFXklo-00191-00045733-00046014": "not to speak but ultimately understand", "j2dstLFXklo-00192-00046015-00046230": "that really everything stops with you", "j2dstLFXklo-00193-00046231-00046524": "and if you have the courage to do the", "j2dstLFXklo-00194-00046525-00046683": "right thing it makes an enormous", "j2dstLFXklo-00195-00046684-00046839": "difference within the organization", "j2dstLFXklo-00196-00046840-00047017": "Trisha because governance Institute of", "j2dstLFXklo-00197-00047018-00047205": "course practice is very strongly here", "j2dstLFXklo-00198-00047206-00047340": "and does a lot of work and a lot of", "j2dstLFXklo-00199-00047341-00047560": "program what do you think other piece", "j2dstLFXklo-00200-00047561-00047857": "kills well like our namesake governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00201-00047858-00048012": "Institute I would say one of the key", "j2dstLFXklo-00202-00048013-00048246": "skills is an understanding of governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00203-00048247-00048517": "is absolutely fundamental and would echo", "j2dstLFXklo-00204-00048518-00048768": "Janet's comments regarding that I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00205-00048769-00049054": "absolutely basic requirement is strong", "j2dstLFXklo-00206-00049055-00049215": "understanding of finance and of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00207-00049216-00049336": "strategy and business of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00208-00049337-00049617": "organization I'd also add that it's very", "j2dstLFXklo-00209-00049618-00049776": "important for directors to add value", "j2dstLFXklo-00210-00049777-00050139": "that's why you're there is to try and", "j2dstLFXklo-00211-00050140-00050358": "add value in whatever shape or form in", "j2dstLFXklo-00212-00050359-00050538": "terms of your learnings to be", "j2dstLFXklo-00213-00050539-00050892": "questioning of management and hopefully", "j2dstLFXklo-00214-00050893-00051132": "to also assist them with whatever", "j2dstLFXklo-00215-00051133-00051450": "projects they're working on at", "j2dstLFXklo-00216-00051451-00051642": "governance Institute we have a number of", "j2dstLFXklo-00217-00051644-00051915": "courses in relation to foundations of", "j2dstLFXklo-00218-00051916-00052140": "governance or certificate of governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00219-00052141-00052344": "practice or a not-for-profit governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00220-00052345-00052605": "certificate as well which might be", "j2dstLFXklo-00221-00052606-00052774": "helpful for those of you who are", "j2dstLFXklo-00222-00052775-00052900": "interested in learning more about", "j2dstLFXklo-00223-00052901-00053089": "governance okay", "j2dstLFXklo-00224-00053090-00053275": "which brings us to the next question", "j2dstLFXklo-00225-00053276-00053473": "because the skill sets that you talked", "j2dstLFXklo-00226-00053474-00053695": "about there were not just technical we", "j2dstLFXklo-00227-00053696-00053986": "had courage we had team players we had", "j2dstLFXklo-00228-00053987-00054154": "all of those things that in fact play", "j2dstLFXklo-00229-00054154-00054436": "more to the attributes the difference", "j2dstLFXklo-00230-00054437-00054826": "between executive and management roles", "j2dstLFXklo-00231-00054827-00055029": "particularly on boards which don't have", "j2dstLFXklo-00232-00055030-00055225": "large numbers of staff so we're not", "j2dstLFXklo-00233-00055226-00055552": "talking major ases did companies here", "j2dstLFXklo-00234-00055553-00055791": "you can muddle an up a bit in your", "j2dstLFXklo-00235-00055791-00056011": "over-enthusiasm sometimes is that", "j2dstLFXklo-00236-00056012-00056200": "something that you guys see at the", "j2dstLFXklo-00237-00056201-00056407": "governance Institute from time to time", "j2dstLFXklo-00238-00056408-00056679": "yes that perhaps board might get too", "j2dstLFXklo-00239-00056680-00056974": "involved in certain activities like when", "j2dstLFXklo-00240-00056975-00057187": "we were preparing a new certificate when", "j2dstLFXklo-00241-00057188-00057421": "we changed our name and you shouldn't", "j2dstLFXklo-00242-00057422-00057679": "have board members drafting certificate", "j2dstLFXklo-00243-00057679-00057844": "or doing marketing should leave that to", "j2dstLFXklo-00244-00057845-00058066": "management but having said that on the", "j2dstLFXklo-00245-00058066-00058315": "other hand recently we started", "j2dstLFXklo-00246-00058316-00058645": "discussing revitalizing our digitization", "j2dstLFXklo-00247-00058646-00058929": "strategy and as I'm quite a champion of", "j2dstLFXklo-00248-00058930-00059142": "digital I was one of the first key", "j2dstLFXklo-00249-00059144-00059347": "stakeholders interviewed there will be a", "j2dstLFXklo-00250-00059348-00059512": "number of other directors interviewed", "j2dstLFXklo-00251-00059513-00059665": "and I think the director of marketing", "j2dstLFXklo-00252-00059666-00059899": "found our important valuables where that", "j2dstLFXklo-00253-00059900-00060061": "bought where the management is actually", "j2dstLFXklo-00254-00060062-00060303": "seeking our import and trying to get", "j2dstLFXklo-00255-00060304-00060562": "guidance from us as to what outside", "j2dstLFXklo-00256-00060563-00060826": "third parties are experiencing and", "j2dstLFXklo-00257-00060827-00061084": "customers expect or members expect from", "j2dstLFXklo-00258-00061085-00061375": "a digital perspective we're also working", "j2dstLFXklo-00259-00061376-00061615": "on an IT transformation project and I", "j2dstLFXklo-00260-00061616-00061972": "was called in last week to meet with our", "j2dstLFXklo-00261-00061973-00062233": "IT consultant just to get a better", "j2dstLFXklo-00262-00062234-00062425": "understanding of the project and also", "j2dstLFXklo-00263-00062426-00062698": "work closely with the CFO so that we can", "j2dstLFXklo-00264-00062699-00062989": "drop the board paper in a manner that", "j2dstLFXklo-00265-00062990-00063204": "hopefully will lead to approval of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00266-00063205-00063417": "project so again they're seeking", "j2dstLFXklo-00267-00063419-00063607": "guidance from us we've obviously it's", "j2dstLFXklo-00268-00063608-00063804": "management's remit to run the project", "j2dstLFXklo-00269-00063805-00064027": "and to draft the paper but seeking", "j2dstLFXklo-00270-00064028-00064216": "guidance from us as to what information", "j2dstLFXklo-00271-00064216-00064348": "to the board need to make an informed", "j2dstLFXklo-00272-00064349-00064609": "decision talkie of guidance how does it", "j2dstLFXklo-00273-00064610-00064789": "work for an organization like go guides", "j2dstLFXklo-00274-00064790-00064972": "which of course is naturally smaller I", "j2dstLFXklo-00275-00064973-00065209": "imagine a very large volunteer group", "j2dstLFXklo-00276-00065210-00065524": "though a huge challenge and it's really", "j2dstLFXklo-00277-00065525-00065670": "interesting clear that we've actually", "j2dstLFXklo-00278-00065671-00065911": "changed over the last two years of", "j2dstLFXklo-00279-00065912-00066066": "putting in a new governance framework", "j2dstLFXklo-00280-00066067-00066289": "one of the most difficult things often", "j2dstLFXklo-00281-00066290-00066367": "with not", "j2dstLFXklo-00282-00066368-00066520": "offered some with a large volunteer base", "j2dstLFXklo-00283-00066521-00066732": "is everyone's one wants to be involved", "j2dstLFXklo-00284-00066733-00066967": "from the ground up what we did two years", "j2dstLFXklo-00285-00066968-00067213": "ago is turned around so it truly is a", "j2dstLFXklo-00286-00067214-00067423": "top-down board with a board and", "j2dstLFXklo-00287-00067424-00067606": "committees that provide oversight that", "j2dstLFXklo-00288-00067607-00067885": "can then delegate as you would for any", "j2dstLFXklo-00289-00067886-00068082": "commercial organization to the", "j2dstLFXklo-00290-00068083-00068281": "management to do the role one of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00291-00068282-00068394": "important things though with a", "j2dstLFXklo-00292-00068395-00068629": "not-for-profit is it doesn't matter", "j2dstLFXklo-00293-00068630-00068851": "whether you've got volunteer or staff", "j2dstLFXklo-00294-00068852-00069103": "paid staff it's still getting around the", "j2dstLFXklo-00295-00069104-00069328": "governance framework and actually what", "j2dstLFXklo-00296-00069329-00069538": "is the best way to run the business and", "j2dstLFXklo-00297-00069539-00069838": "what we've done in that organization and", "j2dstLFXklo-00298-00069839-00069951": "I think it applies for any organization", "j2dstLFXklo-00299-00069952-00070309": "is make sure that the board is providing", "j2dstLFXklo-00300-00070310-00070540": "the oversight and that the doing comes", "j2dstLFXklo-00301-00070541-00070732": "from the management but the board's", "j2dstLFXklo-00302-00070733-00070987": "responsibility on that is to be very", "j2dstLFXklo-00303-00070988-00071226": "clear about roles and responsibilities", "j2dstLFXklo-00304-00071227-00071494": "very clear about key performance", "j2dstLFXklo-00305-00071495-00071761": "indicators or what you're expecting from", "j2dstLFXklo-00306-00071762-00072034": "the executive the management teams on a", "j2dstLFXklo-00307-00072035-00072376": "deliverable basis and keeping people to", "j2dstLFXklo-00308-00072377-00072655": "those commitments the other thing that I", "j2dstLFXklo-00309-00072656-00072865": "think is crucial in an organization like", "j2dstLFXklo-00310-00072866-00073117": "this is use of committees because what", "j2dstLFXklo-00311-00073118-00073294": "you actually find I think one of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00312-00073295-00073492": "most effective things from a board is a", "j2dstLFXklo-00313-00073493-00073747": "board does need to be thinking strategy", "j2dstLFXklo-00314-00073748-00073957": "big picture overview in the key", "j2dstLFXklo-00315-00073958-00074188": "decisions you need a work of a board as", "j2dstLFXklo-00316-00074189-00074376": "well and that's where effective use of", "j2dstLFXklo-00317-00074377-00074619": "board delegation of responsibilities", "j2dstLFXklo-00318-00074620-00074917": "they still can't get into the detail but", "j2dstLFXklo-00319-00074918-00075126": "that can take hands on responsibility", "j2dstLFXklo-00320-00075127-00075343": "for a range of projects and that", "j2dstLFXklo-00321-00075344-00075526": "framework whether it's a not-for-profit", "j2dstLFXklo-00322-00075527-00075775": "whether it's a commercial board I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00323-00075776-00075997": "is really important and it's very", "j2dstLFXklo-00324-00075998-00076213": "dangerous when you actually turn around", "j2dstLFXklo-00325-00076214-00076435": "and get everyone getting their hands", "j2dstLFXklo-00326-00076436-00076711": "dirty at every step because you lose", "j2dstLFXklo-00327-00076712-00076900": "sight of the big picture and therefore", "j2dstLFXklo-00328-00076901-00077161": "you're not attending to your directors", "j2dstLFXklo-00329-00077162-00077401": "duties and responsibilities in", "j2dstLFXklo-00330-00077402-00077578": "committees it's there's an increasing", "j2dstLFXklo-00331-00077579-00077890": "use of them it leads to the next", "j2dstLFXklo-00332-00077891-00078169": "question too about in building your", "j2dstLFXklo-00333-00078170-00078421": "skill sets to become a better in ed or", "j2dstLFXklo-00334-00078422-00078655": "non-executive director really you need", "j2dstLFXklo-00335-00078656-00078853": "to be working out how you can serve on", "j2dstLFXklo-00336-00078854-00079084": "at least two or possibly even three", "j2dstLFXklo-00337-00079085-00079291": "committees for each board is that", "j2dstLFXklo-00338-00079292-00079525": "something that you've seen grow in your", "j2dstLFXklo-00339-00079526-00079562": "time", "j2dstLFXklo-00340-00079563-00079943": "yeah I'm a huge supporter of the concept", "j2dstLFXklo-00341-00079944-00080093": "of committees because I think they give", "j2dstLFXklo-00342-00080094-00080342": "the capacity for boards to manage their", "j2dstLFXklo-00343-00080343-00080582": "workload and to give individuals on the", "j2dstLFXklo-00344-00080583-00080858": "board and others the opportunity to use", "j2dstLFXklo-00345-00080859-00081152": "specialist skills that they don't", "j2dstLFXklo-00346-00081153-00081302": "necessarily have the opportunity to at a", "j2dstLFXklo-00347-00081303-00081518": "board level and in the boards that I've", "j2dstLFXklo-00348-00081519-00081692": "worked on I've always made sure that I", "j2dstLFXklo-00349-00081693-00081986": "am on committees where my skill set has", "j2dstLFXklo-00350-00081987-00082127": "the capacity for leadership so I've", "j2dstLFXklo-00351-00082128-00082370": "chaired committees but also on", "j2dstLFXklo-00352-00082371-00082553": "committees that might have been areas", "j2dstLFXklo-00353-00082554-00082697": "where I need to do some additional work", "j2dstLFXklo-00354-00082698-00083009": "myself so that in the committee context", "j2dstLFXklo-00355-00083010-00083219": "I have the opportunity to get into a bit", "j2dstLFXklo-00356-00083220-00083444": "more detail and to develop my skill set", "j2dstLFXklo-00357-00083445-00083653": "and I think that's more appropriate than", "j2dstLFXklo-00358-00083654-00083852": "developing your skill set out a board", "j2dstLFXklo-00359-00083853-00084065": "level and I think it's a really helpful", "j2dstLFXklo-00360-00084066-00084338": "way to broaden the work that you've done", "j2dstLFXklo-00361-00084339-00084497": "and the issues that you've done with", "j2dstLFXklo-00362-00084498-00084719": "them and I would say as well without one", "j2dstLFXklo-00363-00084720-00084926": "of the things as a director is your", "j2dstLFXklo-00364-00084927-00085148": "forever learning the notion that you", "j2dstLFXklo-00365-00085149-00085475": "don't have any more to learn I mean in", "j2dstLFXklo-00366-00085476-00085625": "any part of life but I think as a", "j2dstLFXklo-00367-00085626-00085799": "director because the issues are changing", "j2dstLFXklo-00368-00085800-00086036": "digital being a classic which were", "j2dstLFXklo-00369-00086037-00086180": "already mentioned you know there's", "j2dstLFXklo-00370-00086181-00086294": "probably a lot of people sitting around", "j2dstLFXklo-00371-00086295-00086582": "the the table who may not have come up", "j2dstLFXklo-00372-00086583-00086753": "with any you know a life skill set or", "j2dstLFXklo-00373-00086754-00086966": "experience on the digital but it's", "j2dstLFXklo-00374-00086967-00087113": "something we all need to get our mind", "j2dstLFXklo-00375-00087114-00087338": "around and I you know refer to a comment", "j2dstLFXklo-00376-00087339-00087608": "from David Gonski um a year ago he", "j2dstLFXklo-00377-00087609-00087815": "talked of reverse mentoring he", "j2dstLFXklo-00378-00087816-00088040": "recognized that he actually didn't have", "j2dstLFXklo-00379-00088041-00088241": "the skill set there so where he was", "j2dstLFXklo-00380-00088242-00088472": "mentoring a young woman within ANZ Bank", "j2dstLFXklo-00381-00088473-00088832": "he got her to mentor in reverse so that", "j2dstLFXklo-00382-00088833-00089027": "he could come up the learning curve so", "j2dstLFXklo-00383-00089028-00089249": "things will change the other thing I", "j2dstLFXklo-00384-00089250-00089408": "think one of the most valuable things in", "j2dstLFXklo-00385-00089409-00089600": "learning skill set is looking around the", "j2dstLFXklo-00386-00089601-00089822": "table at the people around you one of", "j2dstLFXklo-00387-00089823-00089951": "the things with directorship is", "j2dstLFXklo-00388-00089952-00090182": "experiential learning you can do all the", "j2dstLFXklo-00389-00090183-00090359": "court you can do all the courses and", "j2dstLFXklo-00390-00090360-00090587": "they're essential but it is you are", "j2dstLFXklo-00391-00090588-00090800": "working as a team and one of the things", "j2dstLFXklo-00392-00090801-00091043": "to always be looking at as well as", "j2dstLFXklo-00393-00091044-00091271": "contributing is observing how people are", "j2dstLFXklo-00394-00091272-00091448": "doing things and thinking if that's", "j2dstLFXklo-00395-00091449-00091688": "relevant to your skill set to the way", "j2dstLFXklo-00396-00091689-00091922": "you become a director around the table", "j2dstLFXklo-00397-00091923-00092090": "and thinking about changing and", "j2dstLFXklo-00398-00092091-00092339": "developing which speaks to excuse me a", "j2dstLFXklo-00399-00092340-00092540": "question we've got from Elizabeth", "j2dstLFXklo-00400-00092541-00092843": "Valentine thank you and the levels of", "j2dstLFXklo-00401-00092844-00092904": "paper", "j2dstLFXklo-00402-00092905-00093078": "I see that you think are evident within", "j2dstLFXklo-00403-00093079-00093396": "boards in general it in terms of", "j2dstLFXklo-00404-00093397-00093632": "providing oversight for strategy risk", "j2dstLFXklo-00405-00093633-00093930": "compliance and value and the digital", "j2dstLFXklo-00406-00093931-00094140": "factor there's been a bit of a question", "j2dstLFXklo-00407-00094141-00094356": "likely that in fact a lot of boards are", "j2dstLFXklo-00408-00094357-00094560": "not are scrambling of this arm on that", "j2dstLFXklo-00409-00094561-00094890": "new economy area and how well do you", "j2dstLFXklo-00410-00094891-00095124": "think boards are equipped in general to", "j2dstLFXklo-00411-00095125-00095367": "oversight those areas particularly the", "j2dstLFXklo-00412-00095368-00095673": "latter one I think as janet has surged", "j2dstLFXklo-00413-00095674-00095937": "the the reverse mentoring it is an", "j2dstLFXklo-00414-00095938-00096197": "excellent suggestion and that", "j2dstLFXklo-00415-00096198-00096453": "digitization skills is something that in", "j2dstLFXklo-00416-00096454-00096615": "digital skills is something that all", "j2dstLFXklo-00417-00096616-00096819": "boards and directors are going to need", "j2dstLFXklo-00418-00096820-00097113": "to do some more work on I think we've", "j2dstLFXklo-00419-00097114-00097362": "seen that recently with in terms of", "j2dstLFXklo-00420-00097363-00097556": "managing the reputation risk with just", "j2dstLFXklo-00421-00097557-00097875": "on the weekend with Woolworths and I'm", "j2dstLFXklo-00422-00097876-00098004": "not sure if you're aware there was a", "j2dstLFXklo-00423-00098005-00098298": "data breach where they sent out an email", "j2dstLFXklo-00424-00098299-00098586": "to a number of people about think about", "j2dstLFXklo-00425-00098587-00098967": "a thousand who had gift cards and it", "j2dstLFXklo-00426-00098968-00099159": "also included the passwords for those", "j2dstLFXklo-00427-00099160-00099356": "gift cards and people's email addresses", "j2dstLFXklo-00428-00099357-00099567": "so we've got a privacy breach we've got", "j2dstLFXklo-00429-00099568-00099755": "data protection breach we've got", "j2dstLFXklo-00430-00099756-00100013": "reputation issues and Woolworths also", "j2dstLFXklo-00431-00100014-00100194": "had the reputation issue not that long", "j2dstLFXklo-00432-00100195-00100524": "ago and Anzac Day which was not really a", "j2dstLFXklo-00433-00100525-00100788": "social issue but became a social media", "j2dstLFXklo-00434-00100789-00101101": "issue because it was discussed and and", "j2dstLFXklo-00435-00101102-00101388": "was there were a number of people quite", "j2dstLFXklo-00436-00101389-00101571": "passionate about it on Twitter and that", "j2dstLFXklo-00437-00101572-00101790": "it wasn't the appropriate approach what", "j2dstLFXklo-00438-00101791-00101925": "would have you done because that issue", "j2dstLFXklo-00439-00101926-00102204": "really ran and it's Natalie just really", "j2dstLFXklo-00440-00102205-00102477": "tall so as a director how do you get in", "j2dstLFXklo-00441-00102478-00102629": "and think about okay we've got to shut", "j2dstLFXklo-00442-00102630-00102873": "this dare stop this how do you get in", "j2dstLFXklo-00443-00102874-00103055": "touch with management what do you do in", "j2dstLFXklo-00444-00103056-00103254": "that in that context where you can see", "j2dstLFXklo-00445-00103255-00103532": "your reputation streaming out there how", "j2dstLFXklo-00446-00103533-00103766": "do you think about that well at", "j2dstLFXklo-00447-00103767-00103967": "governance Institute we have a PR agency", "j2dstLFXklo-00448-00103968-00104231": "that are available to us and I would", "j2dstLFXklo-00449-00104232-00104432": "hope have a crisis management planning", "j2dstLFXklo-00450-00104433-00104654": "for such thing in a social media plan", "j2dstLFXklo-00451-00104655-00104907": "was we also have a director of marketing", "j2dstLFXklo-00452-00104908-00105222": "so I guess I would as president I would", "j2dstLFXklo-00453-00105223-00105440": "call it meeting pretty quickly via", "j2dstLFXklo-00454-00105441-00105618": "teleconference or otherwise if I", "j2dstLFXklo-00455-00105619-00105795": "couldn't get face-to-face to meet with", "j2dstLFXklo-00456-00105796-00106074": "the CEO the head of marketing and our PR", "j2dstLFXklo-00457-00106075-00106195": "agency and come up with", "j2dstLFXklo-00458-00106196-00106335": "plan and a strategy of how we're going", "j2dstLFXklo-00459-00106336-00106756": "to address it and if necessary you get", "j2dstLFXklo-00460-00106757-00106953": "the CEO to come out and speak to it and", "j2dstLFXklo-00461-00106954-00107103": "try and shut it down i think you know", "j2dstLFXklo-00462-00107104-00107257": "you have to address that and sometimes", "j2dstLFXklo-00463-00107258-00107425": "if you die and you just let it snowball", "j2dstLFXklo-00464-00107426-00107731": "that can be what happens leah cuz it can", "j2dstLFXklo-00465-00107732-00107896": "happen everywhere can happen in a small", "j2dstLFXklo-00466-00107897-00108088": "financial services company doesn't have", "j2dstLFXklo-00467-00108089-00108481": "to be a major listed organization how do", "j2dstLFXklo-00468-00108482-00108663": "you think about that in terms of risk", "j2dstLFXklo-00469-00108664-00108903": "well I think there are a range of things", "j2dstLFXklo-00470-00108904-00109136": "that can go wrong I think digital is a", "j2dstLFXklo-00471-00109138-00109495": "aspect where it accelerates and", "j2dstLFXklo-00472-00109496-00109708": "increases the exposure so it's not that", "j2dstLFXklo-00473-00109708-00109866": "it's necessarily a new exposure but", "j2dstLFXklo-00474-00109867-00110032": "suddenly something that five people", "j2dstLFXklo-00475-00110033-00110163": "might know and be annoyed about 5", "j2dstLFXklo-00476-00110164-00110344": "million people can know about in under 5", "j2dstLFXklo-00477-00110345-00110626": "seconds so there's an acceleration there", "j2dstLFXklo-00478-00110627-00110932": "and I think as a board you need to", "j2dstLFXklo-00479-00110933-00111172": "actually plan in advance for how you", "j2dstLFXklo-00480-00111173-00111510": "deal with issues and how your processes", "j2dstLFXklo-00481-00111511-00111775": "work to support the outcome of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00482-00111776-00112075": "organization and you need to make sure", "j2dstLFXklo-00483-00112076-00112436": "that you have access to the right skills", "j2dstLFXklo-00484-00112438-00112744": "not just in your board but the kind of", "j2dstLFXklo-00485-00112745-00112953": "people who can get into the room when", "j2dstLFXklo-00486-00112954-00113197": "you need them and in your executive team", "j2dstLFXklo-00487-00113198-00113458": "so I think a lot of this is if you are", "j2dstLFXklo-00488-00113458-00113715": "caught by surprise by an event and you", "j2dstLFXklo-00489-00113716-00113968": "don't have a crisis management plan you", "j2dstLFXklo-00490-00113969-00114135": "don't have a risk plan you don't have a", "j2dstLFXklo-00491-00114136-00114333": "strategy you don't have every other", "j2dstLFXklo-00492-00114334-00114465": "directors number on your mobile.phone", "j2dstLFXklo-00493-00114466-00114839": "saved that's when you you cause yourself", "j2dstLFXklo-00494-00114840-00115083": "greater stress over something that could", "j2dstLFXklo-00495-00115084-00115278": "be better managed any issue that arises", "j2dstLFXklo-00496-00115279-00115491": "can be managed the question is how do", "j2dstLFXklo-00497-00115492-00115618": "you have a system in place to do that", "j2dstLFXklo-00498-00115619-00115788": "world and that's an interesting one", "j2dstLFXklo-00499-00115789-00116001": "because it speaks to the risk register", "j2dstLFXklo-00500-00116002-00116166": "at the beginning of meetings all of", "j2dstLFXklo-00501-00116167-00116313": "those kind of things that sometimes", "j2dstLFXklo-00502-00116314-00116502": "organizations in their haste to remove", "j2dstLFXklo-00503-00116503-00116824": "to the business of things overlook some", "j2dstLFXklo-00504-00116825-00117008": "of that sometimes boring process stuff", "j2dstLFXklo-00505-00117009-00117298": "they do clear and I me know that you", "j2dstLFXklo-00506-00117299-00117504": "need to have that framework and that", "j2dstLFXklo-00507-00117505-00117935": "structure there and I would say that you", "j2dstLFXklo-00508-00117936-00118171": "ideally don't want to be having to deal", "j2dstLFXklo-00509-00118172-00118335": "with those matters at the beginning of a", "j2dstLFXklo-00510-00118336-00118533": "board meeting but you need to know that", "j2dstLFXklo-00511-00118534-00118744": "they're there so you can apply them I", "j2dstLFXklo-00512-00118745-00118957": "mean I would hope the first part of a", "j2dstLFXklo-00513-00118958-00119115": "board meeting is typically about your", "j2dstLFXklo-00514-00119116-00119435": "higher level strategy and risks but", "j2dstLFXklo-00515-00119436-00119609": "one other point I would make in terms of", "j2dstLFXklo-00516-00119610-00119817": "crisis management is leadership and it", "j2dstLFXklo-00517-00119818-00119960": "really comes to the chairman of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00518-00119961-00120270": "board I think that this is where you", "j2dstLFXklo-00519-00120271-00120429": "very much are looking for that", "j2dstLFXklo-00520-00120430-00120633": "leadership you are looking for the trust", "j2dstLFXklo-00521-00120633-00120942": "that is developed it is up to the", "j2dstLFXklo-00522-00120943-00121203": "Chairman to guide both the board as", "j2dstLFXklo-00523-00121204-00121629": "their leader and also to guide the", "j2dstLFXklo-00524-00121630-00121806": "management where they're providing the", "j2dstLFXklo-00525-00121807-00122111": "oversight so that you actually can have", "j2dstLFXklo-00526-00122113-00122379": "an effective strategy to know whether", "j2dstLFXklo-00527-00122380-00122577": "this is your an issue that you need to", "j2dstLFXklo-00528-00122578-00122763": "deal with immediately or is it white", "j2dstLFXklo-00529-00122764-00122919": "noise and I think that's one of the most", "j2dstLFXklo-00530-00122920-00123129": "difficult things in scenarios now the", "j2dstLFXklo-00531-00123130-00123408": "coming back to social media the pace of", "j2dstLFXklo-00532-00123408-00123615": "that word has picked up so much and you", "j2dstLFXklo-00533-00123616-00123785": "know that is one thing whereas I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00534-00123786-00124016": "boards really are learning I don't think", "j2dstLFXklo-00535-00124017-00124203": "this is an area where you know you can", "j2dstLFXklo-00536-00124204-00124350": "say yes we've ticked the box or as", "j2dstLFXklo-00537-00124351-00124581": "people might say on strategy we've got a", "j2dstLFXklo-00538-00124582-00124827": "range of plans but i think it comes to", "j2dstLFXklo-00539-00124828-00124941": "the leadership and whoever the", "j2dstLFXklo-00540-00124942-00125196": "leadership of that matter that the", "j2dstLFXklo-00541-00125197-00125457": "boards are going to assign and just", "j2dstLFXklo-00542-00125458-00125613": "because its leadership by the chairman", "j2dstLFXklo-00543-00125614-00125769": "often they won't necessarily be the", "j2dstLFXklo-00544-00125770-00125997": "front person speaking on it but it needs", "j2dstLFXklo-00545-00125998-00126308": "to be again I come back to that team to", "j2dstLFXklo-00546-00126309-00126549": "that governance to that leadership so", "j2dstLFXklo-00547-00126550-00126734": "the three key attributes of a good chair", "j2dstLFXklo-00548-00126735-00126918": "you've been a chair pretty sure you're a", "j2dstLFXklo-00549-00126919-00127166": "good ones what are the three key", "j2dstLFXklo-00550-00127167-00127464": "attributes number one I would say trust", "j2dstLFXklo-00551-00127465-00127776": "mm-hmm I think it is important that you", "j2dstLFXklo-00552-00127777-00128001": "have the trust of everyone all your", "j2dstLFXklo-00553-00128002-00128336": "stakeholders the second one is to be a", "j2dstLFXklo-00554-00128338-00128691": "strategic listener so I think listening", "j2dstLFXklo-00555-00128692-00128976": "is really important I'm working out what", "j2dstLFXklo-00556-00128977-00129213": "is white noise or not and for chairman", "j2dstLFXklo-00557-00129214-00129393": "probably being the last voice at the", "j2dstLFXklo-00558-00129394-00129611": "table although sometimes knowing that's", "j2dstLFXklo-00559-00129613-00129822": "not the right time when to let it and", "j2dstLFXklo-00560-00129823-00130065": "the third one is being a good business", "j2dstLFXklo-00561-00130066-00130323": "manager because effective bores are", "j2dstLFXklo-00562-00130324-00130578": "boards that run well you know the basics", "j2dstLFXklo-00563-00130579-00130806": "of board papers meetings knowing when", "j2dstLFXklo-00564-00130807-00131208": "issues are so being able not as a very", "j2dstLFXklo-00565-00131209-00131535": "explicit but the smooth running of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00566-00131536-00131741": "board happens because the chairman has", "j2dstLFXklo-00567-00131742-00132045": "got it under control so trust listening", "j2dstLFXklo-00568-00132046-00132234": "business management skills or being a", "j2dstLFXklo-00569-00132235-00132420": "good business manager understanding", "j2dstLFXklo-00570-00132421-00132657": "intrinsically the operation of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00571-00132658-00132706": "organizer", "j2dstLFXklo-00572-00132707-00133074": "ocean Trisha sort of in that same theme", "j2dstLFXklo-00573-00133075-00133299": "I'd say being a first among equals", "j2dstLFXklo-00574-00133300-00133614": "because not dominating but doing the", "j2dstLFXklo-00575-00133615-00133885": "active listening and you're leading but", "j2dstLFXklo-00576-00133886-00134143": "you really are need to be collegiate and", "j2dstLFXklo-00577-00134144-00134395": "you're working with your peers I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00578-00134396-00134710": "integrity is very important and we're", "j2dstLFXklo-00579-00134711-00134988": "seeing that come up more to the fore", "j2dstLFXklo-00580-00134989-00135436": "with some recent crisis and like and I", "j2dstLFXklo-00581-00135437-00135673": "think emotional intelligence might be", "j2dstLFXklo-00582-00135674-00135975": "another one ok I have bitter VI Leah", "j2dstLFXklo-00583-00135976-00136318": "what do you think okay well I I have a", "j2dstLFXklo-00584-00136319-00136432": "couple of things that I think are", "j2dstLFXklo-00585-00136433-00136624": "important characteristics for chairs and", "j2dstLFXklo-00586-00136625-00136897": "i think i mentioned courage previously", "j2dstLFXklo-00587-00136898-00137103": "and someone the other day said that", "j2dstLFXklo-00588-00137104-00137424": "directorship is one of the forms of pure", "j2dstLFXklo-00589-00137425-00137691": "leadership you're really doing but", "j2dstLFXklo-00590-00137692-00137901": "you're actually leading and i think for", "j2dstLFXklo-00591-00137902-00138138": "a chair it's that leadership aspect of", "j2dstLFXklo-00592-00138139-00138366": "it that has combinations of integrity", "j2dstLFXklo-00593-00138367-00138636": "and courage I also think as a chair you", "j2dstLFXklo-00594-00138637-00138912": "have a role in the curation of", "j2dstLFXklo-00595-00138913-00139135": "information so an enormous amount of", "j2dstLFXklo-00596-00139136-00139333": "information is created about an", "j2dstLFXklo-00597-00139334-00139543": "organization in the market and as the", "j2dstLFXklo-00598-00139544-00139725": "chair you need to be able to personally", "j2dstLFXklo-00599-00139726-00139986": "be able to curate all of that and have", "j2dstLFXklo-00600-00139987-00140146": "it make sense to you and be able to make", "j2dstLFXklo-00601-00140147-00140412": "sense of it for others and I think the", "j2dstLFXklo-00602-00140413-00140565": "final thing that I think is important is", "j2dstLFXklo-00603-00140566-00140797": "relationships and as a chair you have a", "j2dstLFXklo-00604-00140798-00141007": "really broad range of relationships", "j2dstLFXklo-00605-00141008-00141216": "including the relationship that you have", "j2dstLFXklo-00606-00141217-00141406": "with all of your staff which has to have", "j2dstLFXklo-00607-00141407-00141661": "certain characteristics to it the", "j2dstLFXklo-00608-00141662-00141811": "relationship with your peers around the", "j2dstLFXklo-00609-00141812-00142026": "table and your relationship with your", "j2dstLFXklo-00610-00142027-00142299": "CEO so excuse me I would say they are", "j2dstLFXklo-00611-00142300-00142529": "they're the three that I would select", "j2dstLFXklo-00612-00142530-00142761": "interesting ones we've actually just had", "j2dstLFXklo-00613-00142762-00142890": "a question which I'm going to take as", "j2dstLFXklo-00614-00142891-00143161": "well from Alyssa thank you and Alyssa", "j2dstLFXklo-00615-00143162-00143443": "asks certain skill sets are more valued", "j2dstLFXklo-00616-00143444-00143707": "for boards or they appeared to be I", "j2dstLFXklo-00617-00143708-00143920": "think it's changing but I'll ask the", "j2dstLFXklo-00618-00143921-00144225": "panel accounting and law but I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00619-00144226-00144481": "we're seeing a shift to strategic", "j2dstLFXklo-00620-00144482-00144654": "marketing strategic HR there's been a", "j2dstLFXklo-00621-00144655-00144864": "being talked about understanding of", "j2dstLFXklo-00622-00144865-00145128": "digital here and ICT which naturally", "j2dstLFXklo-00623-00145129-00145423": "comes with a younger set of boom people", "j2dstLFXklo-00624-00145424-00145704": "so what are the more are unusual but", "j2dstLFXklo-00625-00145705-00145899": "still valuable skills and background", "j2dstLFXklo-00626-00145900-00146264": "you think I valuable for board rolls", "j2dstLFXklo-00627-00146265-00146604": "well I think definitely the marketing", "j2dstLFXklo-00628-00146605-00146793": "and the digital one where I think I", "j2dstLFXklo-00629-00146794-00147012": "think about a director recently", "j2dstLFXklo-00630-00147013-00147198": "appointed to the Qantas board his name", "j2dstLFXklo-00631-00147199-00147516": "escapes me but he on the television Tom", "j2dstLFXklo-00632-00147517-00147714": "thank you storing all sorts of crazy", "j2dstLFXklo-00633-00147715-00148002": "things and clearly that's the you know", "j2dstLFXklo-00634-00148003-00148134": "he said he wasn't looking for a", "j2dstLFXklo-00635-00148135-00148311": "directorship but I think because of his", "j2dstLFXklo-00636-00148312-00148473": "different way of looking at the world", "j2dstLFXklo-00637-00148474-00148893": "and background in advertising that", "j2dstLFXklo-00638-00148894-00149151": "they've seen that that's helpful for a", "j2dstLFXklo-00639-00149152-00149343": "Qantas board to understand that being a", "j2dstLFXklo-00640-00149344-00149886": "consumer business I think risk is whilst", "j2dstLFXklo-00641-00149887-00150171": "risk has always been there I'd certainly", "j2dstLFXklo-00642-00150172-00150570": "been increasingly seen as an important", "j2dstLFXklo-00643-00150571-00151026": "skill to have and for directors to need", "j2dstLFXklo-00644-00151027-00151125": "to have an understanding that", "j2dstLFXklo-00645-00151126-00151311": "particularly those in the listed space", "j2dstLFXklo-00646-00151312-00151521": "having to comply with ASX corporate", "j2dstLFXklo-00647-00151522-00151692": "governance principles principle number", "j2dstLFXklo-00648-00151693-00152067": "seven but I think any boards and any", "j2dstLFXklo-00649-00152068-00152397": "companies if we're going to be working", "j2dstLFXklo-00650-00152398-00152583": "towards best practice in governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00651-00152584-00152847": "should be a trying to comply with those", "j2dstLFXklo-00652-00152848-00153075": "principles in any event because risk is", "j2dstLFXklo-00653-00153076-00153276": "not just about legal risk is about", "j2dstLFXklo-00654-00153277-00153450": "reputation and risk is about all those", "j2dstLFXklo-00655-00153451-00153684": "kind of things too isn't it and i would", "j2dstLFXklo-00656-00153685-00153912": "agree it's it's a core skill set and the", "j2dstLFXklo-00657-00153913-00154098": "way I look at it though is that rather", "j2dstLFXklo-00658-00154099-00154352": "than risk being just a cute skill set I", "j2dstLFXklo-00659-00154353-00154593": "think as a director you need to look at", "j2dstLFXklo-00660-00154594-00154728": "everything through our risk management", "j2dstLFXklo-00661-00154729-00154968": "lens yeah there is nothing in business", "j2dstLFXklo-00662-00154969-00155139": "that you shouldn't be viewing from a", "j2dstLFXklo-00663-00155140-00155349": "risk perspective and that's a one of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00664-00155350-00155544": "things as a director as opposed to maybe", "j2dstLFXklo-00665-00155545-00155820": "in executive roles is a different way of", "j2dstLFXklo-00666-00155821-00156084": "looking at things and risk that risk", "j2dstLFXklo-00667-00156085-00156240": "management lens is one of the key ones", "j2dstLFXklo-00668-00156241-00156456": "one other thing I would say though about", "j2dstLFXklo-00669-00156457-00156597": "the skills that there's no doubt on a", "j2dstLFXklo-00670-00156598-00156801": "board you'd need people with your", "j2dstLFXklo-00671-00156802-00157059": "financial expertise and with the legal", "j2dstLFXklo-00672-00157060-00157233": "expertise I mean we've got to be very", "j2dstLFXklo-00673-00157234-00157464": "careful here that we don't think it's", "j2dstLFXklo-00674-00157465-00157722": "all into the new ways of doing it I mean", "j2dstLFXklo-00675-00157723-00157971": "they are absolutely essential you know", "j2dstLFXklo-00676-00157972-00158157": "especially on financials I mean you can", "j2dstLFXklo-00677-00158158-00158433": "go to the Centro case I mean you every", "j2dstLFXklo-00678-00158434-00158769": "individual director must understand the", "j2dstLFXklo-00679-00158770-00158991": "financials but the one other area I", "j2dstLFXklo-00680-00158992-00159231": "would say as well as digital sort of", "j2dstLFXklo-00681-00159232-00159551": "data is international skill set the", "j2dstLFXklo-00682-00159552-00159807": "ability to have that skill set around", "j2dstLFXklo-00683-00159808-00160127": "the board businesses are now global and", "j2dstLFXklo-00684-00160128-00160424": "I think you know we are part of a world", "j2dstLFXklo-00685-00160425-00160607": "but people of that had that", "j2dstLFXklo-00686-00160608-00160860": "international experience I think is a", "j2dstLFXklo-00687-00160861-00161145": "really important combination and so I", "j2dstLFXklo-00688-00161146-00161303": "suppose at the heart of this skill set", "j2dstLFXklo-00689-00161304-00161568": "question comes to diversity and I", "j2dstLFXklo-00690-00161569-00161697": "actually think one of the things we", "j2dstLFXklo-00691-00161698-00162018": "haven't chat chatted about so far is the", "j2dstLFXklo-00692-00162019-00162203": "fact that boards really do need to be", "j2dstLFXklo-00693-00162204-00162478": "diverse and diversity is not just gender", "j2dstLFXklo-00694-00162479-00162960": "diversity is geography it is experience", "j2dstLFXklo-00695-00162961-00163359": "it is industry arm and a collective", "j2dstLFXklo-00696-00163360-00163640": "board is one that brings that variety of", "j2dstLFXklo-00697-00163641-00163877": "diversity together and as I say I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00698-00163878-00164235": "if you look over the next decade gender", "j2dstLFXklo-00699-00164236-00164409": "is really important don't get me wrong", "j2dstLFXklo-00700-00164410-00164670": "but I think it is that complete", "j2dstLFXklo-00701-00164671-00164973": "diversity on a board that is going to be", "j2dstLFXklo-00702-00164974-00165168": "part of that skill set and I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00703-00165169-00165437": "that's one of the differences we can't", "j2dstLFXklo-00704-00165438-00165578": "just do things the way that you think", "j2dstLFXklo-00705-00165579-00165740": "we've done them before and hope for a", "j2dstLFXklo-00706-00165741-00165938": "different outcome it's a truism we all", "j2dstLFXklo-00707-00165939-00166175": "know it really applies around the board", "j2dstLFXklo-00708-00166176-00166415": "table interesting and I'm going to", "j2dstLFXklo-00709-00166416-00166613": "follow it up and ask Leah because", "j2dstLFXklo-00710-00166614-00166872": "Elizabeth Valentine has followed up and", "j2dstLFXklo-00711-00166873-00167099": "said is the current board process of", "j2dstLFXklo-00712-00167100-00167295": "governance by exception where the board", "j2dstLFXklo-00713-00167296-00167472": "essentially relies on the board papers", "j2dstLFXklo-00714-00167473-00167643": "for their information heading risk", "j2dstLFXklo-00715-00167644-00167852": "because of course board papers can be", "j2dstLFXklo-00716-00167853-00168096": "four hundred pages 500 pages 600 pages", "j2dstLFXklo-00717-00168097-00168318": "do we need a combination of traditional", "j2dstLFXklo-00718-00168319-00168539": "mechanisms and others that are more", "j2dstLFXklo-00719-00168540-00168771": "agile to cope with the speed of", "j2dstLFXklo-00720-00168772-00169028": "disruptive change and risk so back to", "j2dstLFXklo-00721-00169029-00169301": "your thing about things moving and are", "j2dstLFXklo-00722-00169302-00169436": "we going to see a shift in the way we", "j2dstLFXklo-00723-00169437-00169620": "think about the board structure and", "j2dstLFXklo-00724-00169621-00169896": "those forward kind of processes well I", "j2dstLFXklo-00725-00169897-00170136": "will get to that cuz I think that's an", "j2dstLFXklo-00726-00170137-00170324": "interesting issue I want to just look", "j2dstLFXklo-00727-00170325-00170535": "back to the skill set for directors and", "j2dstLFXklo-00728-00170536-00170702": "what people are recruiting for at the", "j2dstLFXklo-00729-00170703-00170887": "moment because just adding to what", "j2dstLFXklo-00730-00170888-00171191": "Tricia and Janet have said my experience", "j2dstLFXklo-00731-00171192-00171381": "in the market in the recruitment process", "j2dstLFXklo-00732-00171382-00171611": "with boards at the moment is I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00733-00171612-00171774": "there's an assumption particularly for", "j2dstLFXklo-00734-00171775-00171972": "commercial boards that your finance", "j2dstLFXklo-00735-00171973-00172229": "governance skills are expected so people", "j2dstLFXklo-00736-00172230-00172388": "don't talk to me about my legal skills", "j2dstLFXklo-00737-00172389-00172584": "my finance goes my governance skills", "j2dstLFXklo-00738-00172585-00172754": "in spite of the fact that you know", "j2dstLFXklo-00739-00172755-00172920": "governance is probably the area that I", "j2dstLFXklo-00740-00172921-00173100": "have the strongest skill set in the", "j2dstLFXklo-00741-00173101-00173235": "areas that people are interested in", "j2dstLFXklo-00742-00173236-00173465": "talking about our the work I've done in", "j2dstLFXklo-00743-00173466-00173666": "digital and technology the work I've", "j2dstLFXklo-00744-00173667-00173913": "done overseas my work in indigenous", "j2dstLFXklo-00745-00173914-00174111": "communities so the multicultural aspect", "j2dstLFXklo-00746-00174112-00174321": "and increasingly for me the", "j2dstLFXklo-00747-00174322-00174534": "transactional stuff so having shown", "j2dstLFXklo-00748-00174535-00174756": "leadership in larger transactions", "j2dstLFXklo-00749-00174757-00175026": "mergers acquisitions of other businesses", "j2dstLFXklo-00750-00175027-00175263": "sale of businesses so I think we need to", "j2dstLFXklo-00751-00175264-00175577": "recognize that the basic skill set of", "j2dstLFXklo-00752-00175578-00175889": "legal and finance and even risk to some", "j2dstLFXklo-00753-00175890-00176187": "extent in certain roles it's expected", "j2dstLFXklo-00754-00176188-00176349": "that you have all of that so they are", "j2dstLFXklo-00755-00176350-00176484": "not skill sets you bring to the table", "j2dstLFXklo-00756-00176485-00176733": "everyone at the table has that skill set", "j2dstLFXklo-00757-00176734-00176903": "and you are bringing something in", "j2dstLFXklo-00758-00176904-00177161": "addition to that so I think there's that", "j2dstLFXklo-00759-00177162-00177477": "slight adjustment in what the basics of", "j2dstLFXklo-00760-00177478-00177791": "being a director might be about on to", "j2dstLFXklo-00761-00177792-00177957": "the question about how boards inform", "j2dstLFXklo-00762-00177958-00178350": "themselves I think there are a range of", "j2dstLFXklo-00763-00178351-00178506": "challenges around the board paper", "j2dstLFXklo-00764-00178507-00178695": "process that we use at the moment and", "j2dstLFXklo-00765-00178696-00178851": "most people who are involved in board", "j2dstLFXklo-00766-00178852-00179136": "papers could spend their entire career", "j2dstLFXklo-00767-00179137-00179453": "searching for how do we present the", "j2dstLFXklo-00768-00179454-00179673": "perfect information and I have this view", "j2dstLFXklo-00769-00179674-00179816": "which I I talk to people about all the", "j2dstLFXklo-00770-00179817-00180009": "time it's a sort of the one page just", "j2dstLFXklo-00771-00180010-00180207": "the one page that tells me everything I", "j2dstLFXklo-00772-00180208-00180462": "know so that I know what I then need to", "j2dstLFXklo-00773-00180463-00180939": "focus on and I think there are fantastic", "j2dstLFXklo-00774-00180940-00181127": "opportunities with our capacity with", "j2dstLFXklo-00775-00181128-00181473": "technology to provide contemporaneous", "j2dstLFXklo-00776-00181474-00181727": "relevant helpful information to boards", "j2dstLFXklo-00777-00181728-00181860": "that can assist them in their", "j2dstLFXklo-00778-00181861-00182148": "decision-making I think the days of a", "j2dstLFXklo-00779-00182149-00182457": "printed you know hundred page hardcopy", "j2dstLFXklo-00780-00182458-00182678": "being couriered to all of your directors", "j2dstLFXklo-00781-00182679-00182832": "which was my experience as a company", "j2dstLFXklo-00782-00182833-00183057": "secretary for many years have well and", "j2dstLFXklo-00783-00183058-00183329": "truly gone and I think each company and", "j2dstLFXklo-00784-00183330-00183513": "particularly for company secretaries and", "j2dstLFXklo-00785-00183514-00183716": "four chairs who are curating and", "j2dstLFXklo-00786-00183717-00183933": "managing information for boards they", "j2dstLFXklo-00787-00183934-00184154": "need to work out the best way to get the", "j2dstLFXklo-00788-00184155-00184320": "information that's relevant for their", "j2dstLFXklo-00789-00184321-00184553": "board to give their board enough time", "j2dstLFXklo-00790-00184554-00184749": "but also to make the information as", "j2dstLFXklo-00791-00184750-00185027": "up-to-date as possible so locked that", "j2dstLFXklo-00792-00185028-00185303": "can be done with board portals with", "j2dstLFXklo-00793-00185304-00185613": "digital access and I think each company", "j2dstLFXklo-00794-00185614-00185820": "needs to work out what works best friend", "j2dstLFXklo-00795-00185821-00186075": "are you doing that we are on some of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00796-00186076-00186318": "boards others were not um you know it is", "j2dstLFXklo-00797-00186319-00186492": "a continuum one of the important things", "j2dstLFXklo-00798-00186493-00186657": "I think though is it comes back to", "j2dstLFXklo-00799-00186658-00186942": "actually understanding and knowing the", "j2dstLFXklo-00800-00186943-00187191": "business that you're in so that you can", "j2dstLFXklo-00801-00187192-00187443": "know what you don't know and also know", "j2dstLFXklo-00802-00187444-00187623": "the times as to when you actually need", "j2dstLFXklo-00803-00187624-00187893": "to make the deep dive so it's very easy", "j2dstLFXklo-00804-00187894-00188181": "for balls to get set into a a regular", "j2dstLFXklo-00805-00188182-00188451": "meeting pattern committees at all sort", "j2dstLFXklo-00806-00188452-00188625": "of goes like clockwork if you've missed", "j2dstLFXklo-00807-00188626-00188823": "the big picture of understanding what", "j2dstLFXklo-00808-00188824-00189098": "issues are on let's take an example when", "j2dstLFXklo-00809-00189099-00189351": "regulatory or government change comes", "j2dstLFXklo-00810-00189352-00189597": "through what's the responsibility the", "j2dstLFXklo-00811-00189598-00189753": "responsibility the board is to actually", "j2dstLFXklo-00812-00189754-00189977": "understand the matter not to necessarily", "j2dstLFXklo-00813-00189978-00190275": "execute it but so you need to be able to", "j2dstLFXklo-00814-00190276-00190587": "say what do I need to know and then have", "j2dstLFXklo-00815-00190588-00190785": "the framework set up as we talked about", "j2dstLFXklo-00816-00190786-00190947": "at the beginning of the conversation", "j2dstLFXklo-00817-00190948-00191229": "about knowing what matters do I think", "j2dstLFXklo-00818-00191230-00191439": "management haven't got right and that I", "j2dstLFXklo-00819-00191440-00191676": "need to do the deep dive into so it's", "j2dstLFXklo-00820-00191677-00191877": "that you know emotional intelligence", "j2dstLFXklo-00821-00191878-00192039": "you're talking in terms of understanding", "j2dstLFXklo-00822-00192040-00192384": "as well as the the IQ in terms of", "j2dstLFXklo-00823-00192385-00192600": "knowing what do I not know but you need", "j2dstLFXklo-00824-00192601-00192789": "to have that off an informed base and", "j2dstLFXklo-00825-00192790-00192981": "that's where sometimes the board's need", "j2dstLFXklo-00826-00192982-00193359": "to say we want the education as we want", "j2dstLFXklo-00827-00193360-00193581": "to get the knowledge as well as actually", "j2dstLFXklo-00828-00193582-00193743": "just dealing with the mechanics of", "j2dstLFXklo-00829-00193744-00193938": "actually a board meeting all the", "j2dstLFXklo-00830-00193939-00194175": "specific matters at hand I'm very best", "j2dstLFXklo-00831-00194176-00194451": "yeah and I think directors also part of", "j2dstLFXklo-00832-00194452-00194613": "the job is you need to take personal", "j2dstLFXklo-00833-00194614-00194835": "responsibility for being up to date in", "j2dstLFXklo-00834-00194836-00195078": "your area in your market it's not all", "j2dstLFXklo-00835-00195079-00195237": "about I've received the board pack and", "j2dstLFXklo-00836-00195238-00195450": "that's everything it's absolutely your", "j2dstLFXklo-00837-00195451-00195681": "responsibility to curate information on", "j2dstLFXklo-00838-00195682-00195870": "your own to understand the industry to", "j2dstLFXklo-00839-00195871-00196044": "understand what's going on and to ask", "j2dstLFXklo-00840-00196045-00196197": "those questions of your management team", "j2dstLFXklo-00841-00196198-00196461": "if they've not brought things to your", "j2dstLFXklo-00842-00196462-00196653": "attention yeah they're not just the", "j2dstLFXklo-00843-00196654-00196979": "boardroom in the board pack so I'm", "j2dstLFXklo-00844-00196980-00197274": "another question came in and I'm going", "j2dstLFXklo-00845-00197275-00197592": "to defer that so please I will get them", "j2dstLFXklo-00846-00197593-00197952": "all answered I'm interested in that", "j2dstLFXklo-00847-00197953-00198174": "topic because it's really interesting", "j2dstLFXklo-00848-00198175-00198348": "because people think that boards are you", "j2dstLFXklo-00849-00198349-00198525": "know just it's the oversight and it's", "j2dstLFXklo-00850-00198526-00198753": "the strategy you do need to have that", "j2dstLFXklo-00851-00198754-00198975": "big broad market knowledge you need to", "j2dstLFXklo-00852-00198976-00199065": "be really quite", "j2dstLFXklo-00853-00199066-00199284": "an expert in some areas and it's your", "j2dstLFXklo-00854-00199285-00199497": "responsibility to be keeping yourself up", "j2dstLFXklo-00855-00199498-00199807": "up to date and and then people disabled", "j2dstLFXklo-00856-00199808-00199989": "directors exercise governance well", "j2dstLFXklo-00857-00199990-00200286": "governance is a pretty big turn what do", "j2dstLFXklo-00858-00200287-00200502": "you understand by the term governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00859-00200503-00200644": "which is bandied around a whole", "j2dstLFXklo-00860-00200645-00200857": "thursdays i guess from a personal", "j2dstLFXklo-00861-00200858-00201024": "perspective Claire I think it's about", "j2dstLFXklo-00862-00201025-00201271": "what would right thinking people of the", "j2dstLFXklo-00863-00201272-00201548": "community see as appropriate stewardship", "j2dstLFXklo-00864-00201549-00201824": "stewardship in this particular situation", "j2dstLFXklo-00865-00201825-00202093": "so I guess that's all you know what does", "j2dstLFXklo-00866-00202094-00202432": "what is right at governance Institute we", "j2dstLFXklo-00867-00202433-00202904": "look at the processes regulations around", "j2dstLFXklo-00868-00202905-00203175": "an authority which is exercising", "j2dstLFXklo-00869-00203176-00203376": "controlled in a particular organization", "j2dstLFXklo-00870-00203377-00203620": "and we also have what we call our four", "j2dstLFXklo-00871-00203621-00203869": "foundations or pillars of governance", "j2dstLFXklo-00872-00203870-00204125": "which a transparency accountability", "j2dstLFXklo-00873-00204126-00204522": "integrity and stewardship okay so that's", "j2dstLFXklo-00874-00204523-00204636": "what you see is government do you", "j2dstLFXklo-00875-00204637-00204987": "because it indeed and as far as if I put", "j2dstLFXklo-00876-00204988-00205219": "another sort of layer to that I think it", "j2dstLFXklo-00877-00205219-00205539": "is as the framework is the set up that", "j2dstLFXklo-00878-00205540-00205838": "enables the business to run or the", "j2dstLFXklo-00879-00205839-00206214": "organization that has that starts with", "j2dstLFXklo-00880-00206215-00206388": "the values and the integrity as you", "j2dstLFXklo-00881-00206389-00206589": "talked about it then goes to the", "j2dstLFXklo-00882-00206590-00206851": "policies and the principles and it then", "j2dstLFXklo-00883-00206852-00207144": "goes to the processes so you know it's", "j2dstLFXklo-00884-00207146-00207498": "not just a one simple box to tick on but", "j2dstLFXklo-00885-00207500-00207732": "once you've got that overarching", "j2dstLFXklo-00886-00207733-00207952": "framework that a business or", "j2dstLFXklo-00887-00207953-00208212": "organization can run then you can have", "j2dstLFXklo-00888-00208213-00208428": "an ability to deal with any particular", "j2dstLFXklo-00889-00208429-00208675": "matters in that basis so it is the", "j2dstLFXklo-00890-00208676-00209026": "personal it's the policy it's the", "j2dstLFXklo-00891-00209027-00209269": "processes but it's putting it and it's", "j2dstLFXklo-00892-00209269-00209502": "integrating all of those into one", "j2dstLFXklo-00893-00209503-00209812": "package that is relevant for your", "j2dstLFXklo-00894-00209813-00209938": "business because the other thing is", "j2dstLFXklo-00895-00209939-00210255": "governance it's not a ones from one stop", "j2dstLFXklo-00896-00210256-00210589": "shop it actually needs to be applied to", "j2dstLFXklo-00897-00210590-00210841": "each individual organization and it will", "j2dstLFXklo-00898-00210842-00211173": "be different with each organization yes", "j2dstLFXklo-00899-00211175-00211467": "and I think of governance I guess", "j2dstLFXklo-00900-00211469-00212028": "broadly as a tool and I do an analogy to", "j2dstLFXklo-00901-00212029-00212215": "when when I was younger and fitter and", "j2dstLFXklo-00902-00212216-00212408": "competed in triathlon", "j2dstLFXklo-00903-00212409-00212627": "it's for companies is like listen I", "j2dstLFXklo-00904-00212628-00212900": "wasn't food I wasn't fast but I", "j2dstLFXklo-00905-00212901-00213196": "completed the governance for me is like", "j2dstLFXklo-00906-00213198-00213458": "breathing when you're exercising it's an", "j2dstLFXklo-00907-00213459-00213725": "essential requirement but depending on", "j2dstLFXklo-00908-00213726-00213881": "whether you're swimming or riding a bike", "j2dstLFXklo-00909-00213882-00214037": "or running the way you breathe is", "j2dstLFXklo-00910-00214038-00214223": "different and governance needs to be", "j2dstLFXklo-00911-00214223-00214382": "like that for an organization it's like", "j2dstLFXklo-00912-00214383-00214669": "an organization in taking oxygen and", "j2dstLFXklo-00913-00214671-00214946": "exhaling carbon dioxide and you need to", "j2dstLFXklo-00914-00214946-00215138": "work out the most effective way to do", "j2dstLFXklo-00915-00215139-00215366": "that so the organization achieves its", "j2dstLFXklo-00916-00215367-00215537": "objectives governance is not an", "j2dstLFXklo-00917-00215538-00215852": "objective and by itself it's a tool to", "j2dstLFXklo-00918-00215853-00216050": "achieve the organization's objectives I", "j2dstLFXklo-00919-00216051-00216287": "like the analogy I like it we've had a", "j2dstLFXklo-00920-00216288-00216611": "couple of questions around how you come", "j2dstLFXklo-00921-00216612-00216830": "from for example this skill set as a", "j2dstLFXklo-00922-00216831-00217037": "marketing at communications professional", "j2dstLFXklo-00923-00217038-00217265": "based in regional Queensland a very fine", "j2dstLFXklo-00924-00217266-00217453": "place to be based I have to point out", "j2dstLFXklo-00925-00217454-00217901": "and um how do you break into a board", "j2dstLFXklo-00926-00217902-00218153": "role or into a committee or board role", "j2dstLFXklo-00927-00218154-00218507": "um Queens I think that that could apply", "j2dstLFXklo-00928-00218508-00218753": "generally for people living in regional", "j2dstLFXklo-00929-00218754-00218951": "areas and of course government boards", "j2dstLFXklo-00930-00218952-00219188": "are quite often ones that people first", "j2dstLFXklo-00931-00219189-00219362": "look too because they have to have a", "j2dstLFXklo-00932-00219363-00219596": "proportion of people from those areas", "j2dstLFXklo-00933-00219596-00219782": "and that leads me to the second area", "j2dstLFXklo-00934-00219783-00219965": "where someone was talking about how if", "j2dstLFXklo-00935-00219966-00220151": "you're on a government board how do you", "j2dstLFXklo-00936-00220152-00220403": "sit on a commercial board can you sit on", "j2dstLFXklo-00937-00220404-00220610": "a commercial board and if you're on a", "j2dstLFXklo-00938-00220611-00220771": "commercial board how do you sit on a", "j2dstLFXklo-00939-00220773-00220889": "government board so there's quite a lot", "j2dstLFXklo-00940-00220890-00221108": "of questions around how you move and", "j2dstLFXklo-00941-00221109-00221312": "where you see do you think it is just", "j2dstLFXklo-00942-00221313-00221603": "about skill sets does geography come", "j2dstLFXklo-00943-00221604-00221855": "into play is it harder to get known as a", "j2dstLFXklo-00944-00221856-00222094": "marketing professional living in emerald", "j2dstLFXklo-00945-00222096-00222244": "or someone like that it's interesting", "j2dstLFXklo-00946-00222246-00222673": "Claire are the new premier and I can't", "j2dstLFXklo-00947-00222675-00222935": "say loss hey Shay thank you in", "j2dstLFXklo-00948-00222936-00223214": "Queensland just announced last week I", "j2dstLFXklo-00949-00223215-00223478": "believe that she wants fifty percent of", "j2dstLFXklo-00950-00223479-00223802": "women on government boards sorry fifty", "j2dstLFXklo-00951-00223803-00223940": "percent of members of boards to see", "j2dstLFXklo-00952-00223941-00224162": "women a substantial increase from the", "j2dstLFXklo-00953-00224163-00224378": "current thirty one percent so perhaps", "j2dstLFXklo-00954-00224379-00224542": "being in regional Queensland is the", "j2dstLFXklo-00955-00224544-00224746": "right time right about your board", "j2dstLFXklo-00956-00224748-00225080": "journey and regional I guess I'll", "j2dstLFXklo-00957-00225081-00225236": "probably defer to Leah to talk about", "j2dstLFXklo-00958-00225237-00225329": "whether there are opportunities", "j2dstLFXklo-00959-00225330-00225563": "particularly in indigenous sports that", "j2dstLFXklo-00960-00225564-00225653": "babies", "j2dstLFXklo-00961-00225654-00225987": "gp2 I am currently on a rural GP yes", "j2dstLFXklo-00962-00225988-00226251": "indeed I mean I've always had a I guess", "j2dstLFXklo-00963-00226252-00226496": "a rural and regional focus in the work", "j2dstLFXklo-00964-00226498-00226592": "that I do because I grow up in the", "j2dstLFXklo-00965-00226594-00226869": "country and I think there are particular", "j2dstLFXklo-00966-00226869-00227091": "attributes of people who've grown up on", "j2dstLFXklo-00967-00227092-00227229": "a property and I think there are some", "j2dstLFXklo-00968-00227230-00227396": "real strengths in that that you can", "j2dstLFXklo-00969-00227398-00227621": "bring to a board go your country girls", "j2dstLFXklo-00970-00227623-00228126": "yes and I also think that there are a", "j2dstLFXklo-00971-00228127-00228336": "range of opportunities in regional", "j2dstLFXklo-00972-00228337-00228705": "Australia in a whole raft of areas", "j2dstLFXklo-00973-00228706-00228846": "there's state government there's federal", "j2dstLFXklo-00974-00228846-00228987": "government there's local government", "j2dstLFXklo-00975-00228988-00229232": "there are a range of local tourism", "j2dstLFXklo-00976-00229233-00229533": "associations industry associations I", "j2dstLFXklo-00977-00229534-00229779": "could think of you know probably ten", "j2dstLFXklo-00978-00229780-00229902": "different opportunities if you're", "j2dstLFXklo-00979-00229903-00230178": "regionally based and also there are", "j2dstLFXklo-00980-00230179-00230475": "opportunities beyond that where your", "j2dstLFXklo-00981-00230476-00230658": "location is not the most important thing", "j2dstLFXklo-00982-00230659-00230894": "I've traveled to a large number of", "j2dstLFXklo-00983-00230896-00231129": "places for board roles that I've been on", "j2dstLFXklo-00984-00231130-00231542": "and the key aspect is not where you are", "j2dstLFXklo-00985-00231544-00231858": "but the value that you can bring and the", "j2dstLFXklo-00986-00231859-00232032": "match that you have in the recruitment", "j2dstLFXklo-00987-00232033-00232254": "process there are some aspects around", "j2dstLFXklo-00988-00232255-00232494": "hard skills that we've talked about but", "j2dstLFXklo-00989-00232494-00232694": "there are also aspects around your", "j2dstLFXklo-00990-00232696-00232941": "experience and what you bring to the", "j2dstLFXklo-00991-00232942-00233385": "room and having a regional rural remote", "j2dstLFXklo-00992-00233386-00233588": "experience brings a different", "j2dstLFXklo-00993-00233589-00233817": "characterization to what you can add in", "j2dstLFXklo-00994-00233817-00234015": "the room it's part of the diversity it", "j2dstLFXklo-00995-00234016-00234198": "is and I think one of the key things", "j2dstLFXklo-00996-00234198-00234387": "there is that you will end up on boards", "j2dstLFXklo-00997-00234388-00234648": "we've got the heart we've got a genuine", "j2dstLFXklo-00998-00234648-00234825": "interest so talking about this", "j2dstLFXklo-00999-00234826-00235038": "transition from a rural or a", "j2dstLFXklo-01000-00235039-00235304": "not-for-profit to government commercial", "j2dstLFXklo-01001-00235305-00235584": "there's no easy path and it's not as", "j2dstLFXklo-01002-00235585-00235788": "though one is going to lead to the other", "j2dstLFXklo-01003-00235789-00235992": "and there's a bit of this notion I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01004-00235992-00236196": "that if you do a regional or rule", "j2dstLFXklo-01005-00236196-00236511": "somehow we're all banal merge on ASX 100", "j2dstLFXklo-01006-00236512-00236703": "boards the reality is that's not know of", "j2dstLFXklo-01007-00236704-00236889": "spaces there's not enough spaces that's", "j2dstLFXklo-01008-00236890-00237138": "not going to happen you know number one", "j2dstLFXklo-01009-00237139-00237296": "make sure as to what your objective is", "j2dstLFXklo-01010-00237298-00237483": "going to be but the other thing is there", "j2dstLFXklo-01011-00237484-00237681": "is a need to do time and get involved", "j2dstLFXklo-01012-00237682-00237971": "this notion that the world is right for", "j2dstLFXklo-01013-00237973-00238104": "as many people want to be company", "j2dstLFXklo-01014-00238105-00238344": "directors it's hard yards lets you know", "j2dstLFXklo-01015-00238344-00238617": "not delude ourselves to think that it's", "j2dstLFXklo-01016-00238617-00238979": "an easy path people need to be patient", "j2dstLFXklo-01017-00238980-00239147": "need to do your time and build your", "j2dstLFXklo-01018-00239148-00239367": "skill set and that's where getting", "j2dstLFXklo-01019-00239367-00239546": "something whether it's in a rural area", "j2dstLFXklo-01020-00239547-00239780": "whether if it's not for profit or", "j2dstLFXklo-01021-00239781-00239999": "whatever of the government it will take", "j2dstLFXklo-01022-00240000-00240368": "time build and learn that will create", "j2dstLFXklo-01023-00240369-00240608": "the opportunities that will get you", "j2dstLFXklo-01024-00240609-00240809": "known in a variety of different areas", "j2dstLFXklo-01025-00240810-00241017": "but I would sit back on this and say", "j2dstLFXklo-01026-00241017-00241426": "what do you really want as a director", "j2dstLFXklo-01027-00241427-00241703": "directorships come in a huge variety of", "j2dstLFXklo-01028-00241704-00242018": "different sizes shapes and objectives I", "j2dstLFXklo-01029-00242019-00242190": "think it's most important that whatever", "j2dstLFXklo-01030-00242191-00242412": "you do you're doing it from the heart", "j2dstLFXklo-01031-00242413-00242579": "you've got to be able to make the", "j2dstLFXklo-01032-00242580-00242945": "contribution it isn't a one an easy path", "j2dstLFXklo-01033-00242946-00243308": "to go you will create that yourself but", "j2dstLFXklo-01034-00243309-00243564": "be prepared to put in it is no different", "j2dstLFXklo-01035-00243565-00243857": "to an executive career it's like making", "j2dstLFXklo-01036-00243858-00244073": "a career jump in an executive world", "j2dstLFXklo-01037-00244074-00244379": "making a career jump from exec to non", "j2dstLFXklo-01038-00244380-00244703": "exec and I so yeah also an and Jenna and", "j2dstLFXklo-01039-00244704-00244892": "I have talked about this before if you", "j2dstLFXklo-01040-00244893-00245064": "take the view that you're going to be on", "j2dstLFXklo-01041-00245065-00245313": "some regional and remote board and you", "j2dstLFXklo-01042-00245314-00245490": "know I slog it out for a couple of years", "j2dstLFXklo-01043-00245491-00245771": "and then make it to a sx100 you could", "j2dstLFXklo-01044-00245772-00245913": "end up doing more damage than good", "j2dstLFXklo-01045-00245914-00246131": "because if that's your intention your", "j2dstLFXklo-01046-00246132-00246341": "capacity to assist that board might be", "j2dstLFXklo-01047-00246342-00246509": "limited and particularly with indigenous", "j2dstLFXklo-01048-00246510-00246704": "organizations if you think sitting on an", "j2dstLFXklo-01049-00246705-00246860": "indigenous organization board for a", "j2dstLFXklo-01050-00246861-00246995": "couple of years is going to lead to", "j2dstLFXklo-01051-00246996-00247241": "career opportunities you actually will", "j2dstLFXklo-01052-00247242-00247406": "be doing yourself in the community and", "j2dstLFXklo-01053-00247407-00247583": "enormous disservice and so I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01054-00247584-00247721": "people need to be honest with themselves", "j2dstLFXklo-01055-00247722-00247994": "about their career objectives but if", "j2dstLFXklo-01056-00247995-00248126": "you're planning to be on a", "j2dstLFXklo-01057-00248127-00248309": "not-for-profit board a regional remote", "j2dstLFXklo-01058-00248310-00248591": "board and indigenous board you need to", "j2dstLFXklo-01059-00248592-00248729": "be doing that because you've got a heart", "j2dstLFXklo-01060-00248730-00248855": "for it and you want to make a difference", "j2dstLFXklo-01061-00248856-00249152": "my indigenous community boards I wanted", "j2dstLFXklo-01062-00249153-00249299": "to make a difference I was there because", "j2dstLFXklo-01063-00249300-00249551": "I wanted to close the gap improve", "j2dstLFXklo-01064-00249552-00249749": "indigenous health and I wasn't there", "j2dstLFXklo-01065-00249750-00249917": "thinking if I do this I'll end up on an", "j2dstLFXklo-01066-00249918-00250133": "A or 6 100 board and people can tell", "j2dstLFXklo-01067-00250134-00250421": "what your true motivation is so separate", "j2dstLFXklo-01068-00250422-00250587": "the heart and the Commerce and if you", "j2dstLFXklo-01069-00250588-00250796": "need to and don't think about your", "j2dstLFXklo-01070-00250797-00251030": "career as using not-for-profits to get a", "j2dstLFXklo-01071-00251031-00251252": "financial out coming in and of course", "j2dstLFXklo-01072-00251253-00251450": "we've always got the teleconferencing", "j2dstLFXklo-01073-00251451-00251633": "option don't worry you don't throw up to", "j2dstLFXklo-01074-00251634-00251790": "board meetings although frankly I now", "j2dstLFXklo-01075-00251791-00252020": "but I'm with the not-for-profits I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01076-00252021-00252254": "also that there are a number that are", "j2dstLFXklo-01077-00252255-00252354": "very large not", "j2dstLFXklo-01078-00252355-00252534": "profits and I think we talked about this", "j2dstLFXklo-01079-00252535-00252756": "at a women on boards events that there", "j2dstLFXklo-01080-00252757-00252975": "is almost this label that if you get the", "j2dstLFXklo-01081-00252976-00253230": "not-for-profit board first then you can", "j2dstLFXklo-01082-00253231-00253452": "use that as a stepping stone well there", "j2dstLFXklo-01083-00253453-00253677": "may well be that not-for-profit board", "j2dstLFXklo-01084-00253678-00253863": "like a world vision or something is so", "j2dstLFXklo-01085-00253864-00254082": "large that actually that might be the", "j2dstLFXklo-01086-00254083-00254325": "destination for some time and as you say", "j2dstLFXklo-01087-00254326-00254589": "you don't want to you want to contribute", "j2dstLFXklo-01088-00254590-00254816": "as much as you can and not have this", "j2dstLFXklo-01089-00254817-00255111": "using it as a stepping stone approach", "j2dstLFXklo-01090-00255112-00255294": "but yeah I think that's an interesting", "j2dstLFXklo-01091-00255294-00255453": "point because a lot of people ask that", "j2dstLFXklo-01092-00255454-00255654": "yeah there is sometimes people saying", "j2dstLFXklo-01093-00255655-00255861": "you shouldn't do a not problem because", "j2dstLFXklo-01094-00255862-00256065": "it will somehow damaged you well get", "j2dstLFXklo-01095-00256066-00256251": "labeled you know there's a lot of", "j2dstLFXklo-01096-00256252-00256431": "quality not-for-profits out there", "j2dstLFXklo-01097-00256432-00256619": "there's a large number of health funds a", "j2dstLFXklo-01098-00256621-00256875": "large number of organizations a lot of", "j2dstLFXklo-01099-00256876-00257064": "the university center there's effects", "j2dstLFXklo-01100-00257065-00257310": "some enormous organizations that come", "j2dstLFXklo-01101-00257311-00257601": "under the banner of not-for-profit David", "j2dstLFXklo-01102-00257602-00257792": "Gonski is particularly passionate about", "j2dstLFXklo-01103-00257794-00258069": "them many ASX directors in fact all have", "j2dstLFXklo-01104-00258069-00258450": "a good have a not-for-profit I guess the", "j2dstLFXklo-01105-00258451-00258588": "difference is people often think about", "j2dstLFXklo-01106-00258589-00258864": "it as community boards versus the larger", "j2dstLFXklo-01107-00258865-00258992": "not-for-profit sector where they're", "j2dstLFXklo-01108-00258994-00259200": "often running housing associations and", "j2dstLFXklo-01109-00259201-00259440": "those sorts of thing there is to think", "j2dstLFXklo-01110-00259441-00259653": "of maybe as a step is not for profit", "j2dstLFXklo-01111-00259654-00259953": "profit for members and that's a no home", "j2dstLFXklo-01112-00259954-00260121": "mutual sec drumming that's where the", "j2dstLFXklo-01113-00260121-00260412": "Federation fund set where the credit", "j2dstLFXklo-01114-00260413-00260604": "unions permanent building societies I", "j2dstLFXklo-01115-00260605-00260886": "mean into a range of ensure insurance", "j2dstLFXklo-01116-00260887-00261300": "companies and again it's there is a need", "j2dstLFXklo-01117-00261301-00261504": "to actually make a profit in those", "j2dstLFXklo-01118-00261505-00261753": "business but it's is it at the same as a", "j2dstLFXklo-01119-00261754-00261992": "commercial level so each of these are", "j2dstLFXklo-01120-00261994-00262275": "valid strategies just the Quai would say", "j2dstLFXklo-01121-00262276-00262512": "is question yourself where are you", "j2dstLFXklo-01122-00262513-00262707": "wanting you to position yourself for a", "j2dstLFXklo-01123-00262708-00262923": "period of time it's more about the skill", "j2dstLFXklo-01124-00262924-00263130": "set and experience rather than", "j2dstLFXklo-01125-00263131-00263367": "necessarily thinking there is a pathway", "j2dstLFXklo-01126-00263368-00263622": "or a journey it's you've got to work out", "j2dstLFXklo-01127-00263623-00263793": "what your outcome is because industry", "j2dstLFXklo-01128-00263794-00264084": "bodies fit into that area and yet a very", "j2dstLFXklo-01129-00264085-00264294": "large have significant turnovers and", "j2dstLFXklo-01130-00264295-00264495": "manage quite complex businesses yes we", "j2dstLFXklo-01131-00264496-00264759": "have over 7,000 members you know we have", "j2dstLFXklo-01132-00264760-00264999": "a significant revenue with serious", "j2dstLFXklo-01133-00265000-00265287": "business of three streams of education", "j2dstLFXklo-01134-00265288-00265554": "membership and training and professional", "j2dstLFXklo-01135-00265555-00265683": "development", "j2dstLFXklo-01136-00265684-00265888": "we're australia-wide we've got officers", "j2dstLFXklo-01137-00265889-00266194": "in each stage so you know it's not a", "j2dstLFXklo-01138-00266195-00266400": "straightforward business and we try to", "j2dstLFXklo-01139-00266401-00266716": "run it like an asx-listed business you", "j2dstLFXklo-01140-00266717-00266866": "would hope that the governance institute", "j2dstLFXklo-01141-00266867-00267198": "has good governance and totally publish", "j2dstLFXklo-01142-00267199-00267354": "an annual report every year which some", "j2dstLFXklo-01143-00267355-00267582": "not-for-profits don't they might do a", "j2dstLFXklo-01144-00267583-00267766": "shorter annual review or just", "j2dstLFXklo-01145-00267767-00268029": "information statement so I would say", "j2dstLFXklo-01146-00268030-00268213": "that if you it is definitely an", "j2dstLFXklo-01147-00268214-00268468": "opportunity in not-for-profits but to go", "j2dstLFXklo-01148-00268469-00268629": "back to Janet's point about having a", "j2dstLFXklo-01149-00268630-00268803": "pathway and having a strategy I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01150-00268804-00269199": "for all aspirational directors or anyone", "j2dstLFXklo-01151-00269200-00269395": "in a director journey it's very", "j2dstLFXklo-01152-00269396-00269523": "important to sit back and have a", "j2dstLFXklo-01153-00269524-00269863": "strategy and say well what is my desire", "j2dstLFXklo-01154-00269864-00270166": "in my directorship journey where would I", "j2dstLFXklo-01155-00270167-00270477": "like to go what areas interests me what", "j2dstLFXklo-01156-00270478-00270702": "companies do I think I can contribute to", "j2dstLFXklo-01157-00270703-00271085": "or what regions or what types of areas", "j2dstLFXklo-01158-00271086-00271422": "like Liam mentioned rather than just oh", "j2dstLFXklo-01159-00271423-00271602": "I just got to get on a board and it kind", "j2dstLFXklo-01160-00271603-00271800": "of seems clearly quite fashionable at", "j2dstLFXklo-01161-00271801-00272001": "the moment oh I want to be a director", "j2dstLFXklo-01162-00272002-00272274": "and I think that it goes to just really", "j2dstLFXklo-01163-00272275-00272607": "understand the potential liabilities are", "j2dstLFXklo-01164-00272608-00272887": "or risks as well as the rewards it can", "j2dstLFXklo-01165-00272888-00273054": "be extremely rewarding but you need to", "j2dstLFXklo-01166-00273055-00273255": "be remembering about joint and several", "j2dstLFXklo-01167-00273256-00273507": "liability and the like which brings me", "j2dstLFXklo-01168-00273508-00273726": "to the next question because we now have", "j2dstLFXklo-01169-00273727-00273943": "the Magnificent Australian charities and", "j2dstLFXklo-01170-00273944-00274152": "not-for-profits and Commission which the", "j2dstLFXklo-01171-00274153-00274387": "government has retained and women on", "j2dstLFXklo-01172-00274388-00274610": "boards is a very strong supporter of the", "j2dstLFXklo-01173-00274611-00275001": "acnc and it has found that clarity", "j2dstLFXklo-01174-00275002-00275247": "around good governance is not really", "j2dstLFXklo-01175-00275248-00275470": "permeating the sector and more", "j2dstLFXklo-01176-00275471-00275682": "importantly that some of these issues a", "j2dstLFXklo-01177-00275683-00275952": "quarter of the concerns raised were in", "j2dstLFXklo-01178-00275953-00276195": "fact by charities that had revenues of", "j2dstLFXklo-01179-00276196-00276459": "more than 1 million dollars and so", "j2dstLFXklo-01180-00276460-00276691": "sometimes there can be some questions", "j2dstLFXklo-01181-00276692-00276933": "around compliance and around governance", "j2dstLFXklo-01182-00276934-00277192": "in the North profit sector why do you", "j2dstLFXklo-01183-00277193-00277473": "think that is I think one of the", "j2dstLFXklo-01184-00277474-00277615": "interesting points about the complaints", "j2dstLFXklo-01185-00277616-00277987": "in the acnc report is that while there", "j2dstLFXklo-01186-00277988-00278287": "were high percentage that relate to", "j2dstLFXklo-01187-00278288-00278512": "organizations that were larger if we", "j2dstLFXklo-01188-00278513-00278740": "think about the data on the touch points", "j2dstLFXklo-01189-00278741-00278921": "of larger not-for-profits I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01190-00278922-00279140": "that may explain some of that so for", "j2dstLFXklo-01191-00279141-00279368": "example mission Australia interacts with", "j2dstLFXklo-01192-00279369-00279559": "an enormous number of Australians it's a", "j2dstLFXklo-01193-00279560-00279842": "very well-known name so therefore people", "j2dstLFXklo-01194-00279843-00280097": "notice it and are more likely to comment", "j2dstLFXklo-01195-00280098-00280301": "on the work that it does if I ran a", "j2dstLFXklo-01196-00280302-00280580": "charity out of my home where I just", "j2dstLFXklo-01197-00280581-00280775": "collected money and bought myself", "j2dstLFXklo-01198-00280776-00281018": "fabulous clothes it may not interact", "j2dstLFXklo-01199-00281019-00281180": "with many people and I may get fewer", "j2dstLFXklo-01200-00281181-00281321": "complaints but what I'm doing is", "j2dstLFXklo-01201-00281322-00281549": "actually of hauling i'm not really doing", "j2dstLFXklo-01202-00281550-00281858": "that obviously it's an example but i", "j2dstLFXklo-01203-00281859-00282077": "think the situation that we have in the", "j2dstLFXklo-01204-00282078-00282296": "not-for-profit space is it's evolving", "j2dstLFXklo-01205-00282297-00282578": "and we have people who are on", "j2dstLFXklo-01206-00282579-00282812": "not-for-profit boards who often in", "j2dstLFXklo-01207-00282813-00282950": "environments where they're very resource", "j2dstLFXklo-01208-00282951-00283139": "constrained and they're doing the best", "j2dstLFXklo-01209-00283140-00283373": "they can and they need some guidance and", "j2dstLFXklo-01210-00283374-00283697": "some help and I think the environment", "j2dstLFXklo-01211-00283698-00283877": "will improve significantly I think we're", "j2dstLFXklo-01212-00283878-00284180": "on a pathway and I think if we look back", "j2dstLFXklo-01213-00284181-00284363": "at listed companies in the early 90s I", "j2dstLFXklo-01214-00284364-00284560": "think we're on a similar path way did", "j2dstLFXklo-01215-00284561-00284780": "you agree I would in that if you think", "j2dstLFXklo-01216-00284781-00284942": "about when the ASX corporate governance", "j2dstLFXklo-01217-00284943-00285251": "principles were introduced back in 2003", "j2dstLFXklo-01218-00285252-00285497": "and you look at how far we've come went", "j2dstLFXklo-01219-00285498-00285776": "out to the third edition and I think the", "j2dstLFXklo-01220-00285777-00286114": "level of governance and the level of", "j2dstLFXklo-01221-00286115-00286388": "quality of reporting and the quality of", "j2dstLFXklo-01222-00286389-00286732": "a 06 listed companies and what is", "j2dstLFXklo-01223-00286733-00287021": "expected by the community has risen you", "j2dstLFXklo-01224-00287022-00287270": "know exponentially and I think that a", "j2dstLFXklo-01225-00287271-00287509": "CNC is wonderful in that it's kind of", "j2dstLFXklo-01226-00287510-00287707": "starting that journey now with", "j2dstLFXklo-01227-00287708-00287935": "not-for-profits by introducing these", "j2dstLFXklo-01228-00287936-00288251": "seven governance standards having them", "j2dstLFXklo-01229-00288252-00288449": "report against them having the first", "j2dstLFXklo-01230-00288450-00288665": "report come out as really as leah has", "j2dstLFXklo-01231-00288666-00288776": "said it's the beginning of the journey", "j2dstLFXklo-01232-00288777-00289103": "and whilst it is a bit concerning what's", "j2dstLFXklo-01233-00289104-00289256": "come out of the report I wasn't that", "j2dstLFXklo-01234-00289257-00289556": "surprised about it in that you're a", "j2dstLFXklo-01235-00289557-00289865": "number of not-for-profits directors", "j2dstLFXklo-01236-00289866-00290096": "they're not remunerated they're doing it", "j2dstLFXklo-01237-00290097-00290267": "it's because they're passionate about", "j2dstLFXklo-01238-00290268-00290533": "the mission of the organization or the", "j2dstLFXklo-01239-00290534-00290738": "cause and they might not have a", "j2dstLFXklo-01240-00290739-00290915": "background where they've ever had any", "j2dstLFXklo-01241-00290916-00291143": "governance or even understanding of", "j2dstLFXklo-01242-00291144-00291385": "administrative functions risk or finance", "j2dstLFXklo-01243-00291386-00291866": "illegal so there I guess they're eager", "j2dstLFXklo-01244-00291867-00292169": "amateurs if you like and perhaps part of", "j2dstLFXklo-01245-00292170-00292262": "the great", "j2dstLFXklo-01246-00292263-00292546": "work that a CNC does is that it has", "j2dstLFXklo-01247-00292547-00292820": "illuminated these issues but also gives", "j2dstLFXklo-01248-00292821-00293015": "them direction in terms of well perhaps", "j2dstLFXklo-01249-00293016-00293203": "you could do some training in this", "j2dstLFXklo-01250-00293204-00293557": "regard or gives them guidance there are", "j2dstLFXklo-01251-00293558-00293800": "a we also offer guidance in terms of", "j2dstLFXklo-01252-00293801-00293993": "good governance guidance which are", "j2dstLFXklo-01253-00293994-00294266": "freely available at our website so", "j2dstLFXklo-01254-00294267-00294430": "there's lots of tools and I guess it's", "j2dstLFXklo-01255-00294431-00294727": "about the education process and this is", "j2dstLFXklo-01256-00294728-00294992": "why it's important that the acnc is", "j2dstLFXklo-01257-00294993-00295408": "retained and your chair of a non-profit", "j2dstLFXklo-01258-00295409-00295694": "and just takes much time as being on", "j2dstLFXklo-01259-00295695-00296134": "white on guys take as much done it does", "j2dstLFXklo-01260-00296135-00296393": "when I chair that I'm treasurer there", "j2dstLFXklo-01261-00296394-00296527": "and share the Finance Committee not", "j2dstLFXklo-01262-00296528-00296714": "chairman of the ball it does take the", "j2dstLFXklo-01263-00296715-00296921": "time it probably takes more time which", "j2dstLFXklo-01264-00296922-00297124": "is why you're probably doing it from the", "j2dstLFXklo-01265-00297125-00297331": "heart yeah private is also taking it on", "j2dstLFXklo-01266-00297332-00297484": "the journey and I think one of the", "j2dstLFXklo-01267-00297485-00297703": "challenges that has come out of the the", "j2dstLFXklo-01268-00297704-00297962": "most recent a CNC report and you know", "j2dstLFXklo-01269-00297963-00298260": "circling back to comments earlier about", "j2dstLFXklo-01270-00298261-00298510": "working with volunteers and paid staff", "j2dstLFXklo-01271-00298511-00298753": "is I think there's a realization a lot", "j2dstLFXklo-01272-00298754-00298981": "of not-for-profits that not everyone is", "j2dstLFXklo-01273-00298982-00299131": "going to have the right role by Beck", "j2dstLFXklo-01274-00299132-00299353": "sitting on the board one of the things", "j2dstLFXklo-01275-00299354-00299474": "that we're seeing as you're ready to", "j2dstLFXklo-01276-00299475-00299605": "there's a learning journey and in", "j2dstLFXklo-01277-00299606-00299926": "education but it's not for everyone and", "j2dstLFXklo-01278-00299927-00300041": "I think one of the most difficult", "j2dstLFXklo-01279-00300042-00300202": "challenges you're going to find for a", "j2dstLFXklo-01280-00300203-00300413": "number of not-for-profits is actually", "j2dstLFXklo-01281-00300414-00300698": "working out how do we best harness the", "j2dstLFXklo-01282-00300699-00300955": "opportunities are the volunteers how do", "j2dstLFXklo-01283-00300956-00301112": "we maybe work with some people who", "j2dstLFXklo-01284-00301113-00301426": "aren't understanding school director", "j2dstLFXklo-01285-00301427-00301616": "schools maybe don't get that to say", "j2dstLFXklo-01286-00301617-00301748": "there are a variety of different ways", "j2dstLFXklo-01287-00301749-00301951": "that we can use those skill set and", "j2dstLFXklo-01288-00301952-00302305": "volunteers because it is not everyone", "j2dstLFXklo-01289-00302306-00302449": "can come up that learning curve because", "j2dstLFXklo-01290-00302450-00302632": "a lot of people have come to the table", "j2dstLFXklo-01291-00302633-00302830": "because of what they've done in the", "j2dstLFXklo-01292-00302831-00303085": "organization as opposed to actually", "j2dstLFXklo-01293-00303086-00303229": "understanding those directors", "j2dstLFXklo-01294-00303230-00303398": "responsibilities financial", "j2dstLFXklo-01295-00303399-00303623": "responsibilities those things still sit", "j2dstLFXklo-01296-00303624-00303829": "there whether you're a director of a", "j2dstLFXklo-01297-00303830-00304024": "not-for-profit whether it's a government", "j2dstLFXklo-01298-00304025-00304265": "board with your commercial board and you", "j2dstLFXklo-01299-00304266-00304375": "know that's I think a bit of a light", "j2dstLFXklo-01300-00304376-00304701": "bulb they're probably a number of", "j2dstLFXklo-01301-00304702-00304898": "not-for-profits a number of", "j2dstLFXklo-01302-00304899-00305114": "organizations haven't net well the", "j2dstLFXklo-01303-00305115-00305332": "organizations may have but whether it's", "j2dstLFXklo-01304-00305333-00305560": "come down to all the people sitting", "j2dstLFXklo-01305-00305561-00305596": "around", "j2dstLFXklo-01306-00305597-00305835": "table I'm not sure and I think that's", "j2dstLFXklo-01307-00305836-00306028": "one of the biggest challenges for", "j2dstLFXklo-01308-00306029-00306232": "not-for-profits probably over the next", "j2dstLFXklo-01309-00306233-00306412": "year or so and I think that goes back to", "j2dstLFXklo-01310-00306413-00306706": "the point about a chair having quiet", "j2dstLFXklo-01311-00306707-00306933": "word so to certain individuals and also", "j2dstLFXklo-01312-00306934-00307126": "succession planning and board", "j2dstLFXklo-01313-00307127-00307294": "composition generally which we haven't", "j2dstLFXklo-01314-00307295-00307434": "really had a chance to talk that much", "j2dstLFXklo-01315-00307435-00307923": "about but that oh you're smiling click", "j2dstLFXklo-01316-00307924-00308794": "how do you get rid of a number yes how", "j2dstLFXklo-01317-00308795-00308941": "do you get rid of the non-performing", "j2dstLFXklo-01318-00308942-00309295": "board member yeah at all well I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01319-00309296-00309631": "you probably have a quiet word that the", "j2dstLFXklo-01320-00309632-00309853": "Vulcans inside a fireside chat or", "j2dstLFXklo-01321-00309854-00310006": "something like that might be a nice way", "j2dstLFXklo-01322-00310007-00310237": "to start but it is sometimes challenging", "j2dstLFXklo-01323-00310238-00310410": "if somebody doesn't want to leave and", "j2dstLFXklo-01324-00310411-00310762": "they've got the right to stay what do we", "j2dstLFXklo-01325-00310763-00310954": "do you know that and that can be very", "j2dstLFXklo-01326-00310955-00311092": "hard about sites where they're often", "j2dstLFXklo-01327-00311093-00311281": "found at things well and look I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01328-00311282-00311449": "that again comes to your governance", "j2dstLFXklo-01329-00311450-00311623": "framework of the beginning it talks", "j2dstLFXklo-01330-00311624-00311878": "about sitting quite clearly what the", "j2dstLFXklo-01331-00311879-00312057": "bomb on what the bar is what are the", "j2dstLFXklo-01332-00312058-00312271": "expectations of directors what's the", "j2dstLFXklo-01333-00312272-00312526": "requirement there is no reason why not", "j2dstLFXklo-01334-00312527-00312721": "for profits are any different for now", "j2dstLFXklo-01335-00312722-00312984": "doing performance reviews mimin needs to", "j2dstLFXklo-01336-00312985-00313332": "be that framework of continual review", "j2dstLFXklo-01337-00313333-00313630": "assessment it may be if things have", "j2dstLFXklo-01338-00313631-00313939": "changed finding other opportunities or", "j2dstLFXklo-01339-00313940-00314232": "roles but it does coming to have the", "j2dstLFXklo-01340-00314233-00314416": "honors conversation you know and in that", "j2dstLFXklo-01341-00314417-00314599": "sense it's no different to a range of", "j2dstLFXklo-01342-00314600-00314818": "other roles if people are there by", "j2dstLFXklo-01343-00314819-00315121": "virtue of an election process arm or a", "j2dstLFXklo-01344-00315122-00315373": "nomination process then you may be", "j2dstLFXklo-01345-00315374-00315628": "constrained but that's too then I would", "j2dstLFXklo-01346-00315629-00315925": "say the chair finding the right role for", "j2dstLFXklo-01347-00315926-00316195": "that person so that they can contribute", "j2dstLFXklo-01348-00316196-00316482": "in the way they think and not be a", "j2dstLFXklo-01349-00316483-00316683": "constraint on the overall board", "j2dstLFXklo-01350-00316684-00316963": "performance which speaks to terms for", "j2dstLFXklo-01351-00316964-00317128": "directors which in fact was raised in", "j2dstLFXklo-01352-00317129-00317259": "the last revision of the corporate", "j2dstLFXklo-01353-00317260-00317475": "governance principles and", "j2dstLFXklo-01354-00317476-00317749": "recommendations and quite often a lot of", "j2dstLFXklo-01355-00317750-00317926": "boards don't have any terms and you", "j2dstLFXklo-01356-00317927-00318118": "suddenly turn around and find someone", "j2dstLFXklo-01357-00318119-00318277": "who's identified with that organization", "j2dstLFXklo-01358-00318278-00318631": "and they've been there 20 in 25 years so", "j2dstLFXklo-01359-00318632-00318945": "what are your thoughts on terms I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01360-00318946-00319173": "we need to be flexible around the issue", "j2dstLFXklo-01361-00319174-00319380": "on term limits I think there are some", "j2dstLFXklo-01362-00319381-00319559": "extreme examples i was asked if i would", "j2dstLFXklo-01363-00319560-00319812": "assist in organization and the chair had", "j2dstLFXklo-01364-00319813-00319958": "been chair of that organization longer", "j2dstLFXklo-01365-00319959-00320234": "than I've been alive so I felt that was", "j2dstLFXklo-01366-00320235-00320544": "a long term appointment that and you", "j2dstLFXklo-01367-00320545-00320688": "know there are some challenges that go", "j2dstLFXklo-01368-00320689-00320933": "with that and I think you know when we", "j2dstLFXklo-01369-00320934-00321158": "talk about underperforming directors I", "j2dstLFXklo-01370-00321159-00321330": "like to think about when you're starting", "j2dstLFXklo-01371-00321331-00321533": "the journey you need to talk with the", "j2dstLFXklo-01372-00321534-00321774": "end in mind so in appointing directors", "j2dstLFXklo-01373-00321775-00321942": "we need to talk about you know what is", "j2dstLFXklo-01374-00321943-00322065": "the time frame we expect you to be on", "j2dstLFXklo-01375-00322066-00322290": "this board it is not forever it's rare", "j2dstLFXklo-01376-00322291-00322440": "that there is a board that anyone should", "j2dstLFXklo-01377-00322441-00322685": "be on forever and have honest", "j2dstLFXklo-01378-00322686-00322859": "conversations about we'd like you to", "j2dstLFXklo-01379-00322860-00323082": "contribute for between five to nine", "j2dstLFXklo-01380-00323083-00323292": "years and then we would like you to open", "j2dstLFXklo-01381-00323293-00323421": "up the opportunity for others to", "j2dstLFXklo-01382-00323422-00323598": "contribute and I think that conversation", "j2dstLFXklo-01383-00323599-00323882": "an ongoing way is important i think on", "j2dstLFXklo-01384-00323883-00324176": "term limits you need to balance out the", "j2dstLFXklo-01385-00324177-00324516": "requirement for retaining some knowledge", "j2dstLFXklo-01386-00324517-00324716": "around the organization in the history", "j2dstLFXklo-01387-00324717-00325058": "in the room but also getting fresh eyes", "j2dstLFXklo-01388-00325059-00325302": "and fresh thoughts and that balance is", "j2dstLFXklo-01389-00325303-00325473": "just about a good succession planning", "j2dstLFXklo-01390-00325474-00325839": "model you may lose directors that you", "j2dstLFXklo-01391-00325840-00326019": "weren't planning to lose and you need to", "j2dstLFXklo-01392-00326020-00326298": "be flexible around how you have the", "j2dstLFXklo-01393-00326299-00326625": "right skill set the right history there", "j2dstLFXklo-01394-00326626-00326933": "is no formula that is perfect my view is", "j2dstLFXklo-01395-00326934-00327120": "if you have been on a board for six", "j2dstLFXklo-01396-00327121-00327291": "years you should probably be thinking", "j2dstLFXklo-01397-00327292-00327485": "about your exit strategy and how you", "j2dstLFXklo-01398-00327486-00327630": "will ensure that the board and the", "j2dstLFXklo-01399-00327631-00327825": "organization will be well served by", "j2dstLFXklo-01400-00327826-00328068": "someone who can replace on one of my", "j2dstLFXklo-01401-00328069-00328344": "boards I've bought someone on who will", "j2dstLFXklo-01402-00328345-00328524": "be a replacement for me in two years", "j2dstLFXklo-01403-00328525-00328760": "time and I'm hoping two years will be an", "j2dstLFXklo-01404-00328761-00328910": "apprenticeship period that will allow", "j2dstLFXklo-01405-00328911-00329190": "them to then show leadership and I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01406-00329191-00329403": "if you are have been on a board for nine", "j2dstLFXklo-01407-00329404-00329585": "years you need to start thinking about", "j2dstLFXklo-01408-00329586-00329769": "whether you could add more value", "j2dstLFXklo-01409-00329770-00329957": "elsewhere yeah until one of the", "j2dstLFXklo-01410-00329958-00330168": "challenges I think especially in some of", "j2dstLFXklo-01411-00330169-00330348": "the not-for-profit sector is it the", "j2dstLFXklo-01412-00330349-00330543": "other end of the spectrum people have", "j2dstLFXklo-01413-00330544-00330768": "terms for one year or so and that can be", "j2dstLFXklo-01414-00330769-00331113": "yes very late if as constraining on the", "j2dstLFXklo-01415-00331114-00331334": "growth of the business so I think your", "j2dstLFXklo-01416-00331335-00331626": "point on terms needs to be looked at in", "j2dstLFXklo-01417-00331627-00331887": "terms of holistically what the business", "j2dstLFXklo-01418-00331888-00332160": "arm can be about and a comic that", "j2dstLFXklo-01419-00332161-00332325": "make two people thinking of going on the", "j2dstLFXklo-01420-00332326-00332617": "director journey it is a commitment when", "j2dstLFXklo-01421-00332618-00332859": "you take on a directorship this is not", "j2dstLFXklo-01422-00332860-00333022": "one where you can go look this is the", "j2dstLFXklo-01423-00333023-00333204": "right one for me now I've got a better", "j2dstLFXklo-01424-00333205-00333391": "opportunity in six or twelve months time", "j2dstLFXklo-01425-00333392-00333592": "I mean it is one thing about choose", "j2dstLFXklo-01426-00333593-00333919": "carefully because you need to be able to", "j2dstLFXklo-01427-00333920-00334095": "make an ongoing commitment so I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01428-00334096-00334380": "organizations need to have that right", "j2dstLFXklo-01429-00334381-00334747": "combination of terms and length of terms", "j2dstLFXklo-01430-00334748-00334935": "but individuals need to have that", "j2dstLFXklo-01431-00334936-00335148": "mindset as well because it goes to your", "j2dstLFXklo-01432-00335149-00335494": "integrity as a director and it is one", "j2dstLFXklo-01433-00335495-00335760": "where circumstances will change but", "j2dstLFXklo-01434-00335761-00335955": "people need to make that emit meant the", "j2dstLFXklo-01435-00335956-00336115": "organization needs to make the", "j2dstLFXklo-01436-00336116-00336327": "commitment so I think we've got both", "j2dstLFXklo-01437-00336328-00336543": "ends of the spectrum at the moment", "j2dstLFXklo-01438-00336544-00336759": "excellent i'm just going to go to the", "j2dstLFXklo-01439-00336760-00337002": "questions one from mary who asked about", "j2dstLFXklo-01440-00337003-00337294": "monetary and non-monetary rewards from", "j2dstLFXklo-01441-00337295-00337551": "being a director that is a very long and", "j2dstLFXklo-01442-00337552-00337878": "involved answer our getting started in", "j2dstLFXklo-01443-00337879-00338100": "fact looks at that issue the short", "j2dstLFXklo-01444-00338101-00338376": "answer is is there is no definite answer", "j2dstLFXklo-01445-00338377-00338614": "some of them are fixed salaries some of", "j2dstLFXklo-01446-00338615-00338797": "them are per diem depends on whether", "j2dstLFXklo-01447-00338798-00338944": "it's government some not-for-profit", "j2dstLFXklo-01448-00338945-00339118": "space unpaid the chair of the audit and", "j2dstLFXklo-01449-00339119-00339244": "Finance Committee and don't pay the", "j2dstLFXklo-01450-00339245-00339439": "directors some reward them in other ways", "j2dstLFXklo-01451-00339440-00339624": "sports bodies for example will often", "j2dstLFXklo-01452-00339625-00339879": "send you to where the team is competing", "j2dstLFXklo-01453-00339880-00340305": "so it's a long answer but the big thing", "j2dstLFXklo-01454-00340306-00340631": "you should do is ask how directors are", "j2dstLFXklo-01455-00340632-00340918": "compensated how they service their", "j2dstLFXklo-01456-00340919-00341062": "directors in terms of looking after", "j2dstLFXklo-01457-00341063-00341347": "directors okay some organizations will", "j2dstLFXklo-01458-00341348-00341515": "send directors on training and those", "j2dstLFXklo-01459-00341516-00341682": "sorts of things so I'm going to", "j2dstLFXklo-01460-00341683-00341866": "short-circuit that one by answering it", "j2dstLFXklo-01461-00341867-00342132": "but um Rebecca Ramsey asks and I'm going", "j2dstLFXklo-01462-00342133-00342340": "to ask you for a quick and comment what", "j2dstLFXklo-01463-00342341-00342589": "about if you're in an organization is it", "j2dstLFXklo-01464-00342590-00342739": "common to shift from being an executive", "j2dstLFXklo-01465-00342740-00342957": "director to a non-executive within the", "j2dstLFXklo-01466-00342958-00343158": "same organization now I would argue that", "j2dstLFXklo-01467-00343159-00343556": "probably only on subsidiaries perhaps", "j2dstLFXklo-01468-00343557-00343795": "would that happen or on private", "j2dstLFXklo-01469-00343796-00343983": "companies and it's more common in Europe", "j2dstLFXklo-01470-00343984-00344199": "than it is here what do you say yeah the", "j2dstLFXklo-01471-00344200-00344433": "Great Recession and I think it's", "j2dstLFXklo-01472-00344434-00344569": "interesting actually I think when that", "j2dstLFXklo-01473-00344570-00344802": "does happen in listed companies", "j2dstLFXklo-01474-00344803-00345078": "sometimes people agitate for change in", "j2dstLFXklo-01475-00345079-00345258": "fact that has happened with karoon gas", "j2dstLFXklo-01476-00345259-00345474": "where there's been some shareholder", "j2dstLFXklo-01477-00345475-00345525": "active", "j2dstLFXklo-01478-00345526-00345741": "ism where they've said we've got the", "j2dstLFXklo-01479-00345742-00346092": "family too involved still has been the", "j2dstLFXklo-01480-00346093-00346221": "arguments they haven't been successful", "j2dstLFXklo-01481-00346222-00346518": "but they've said it's probably not", "j2dstLFXklo-01482-00346519-00346800": "appropriate to have the CEO be the son", "j2dstLFXklo-01483-00346801-00347070": "of the chair and the kind of movement", "j2dstLFXklo-01484-00347071-00347338": "from executive director to being also a", "j2dstLFXklo-01485-00347339-00347625": "director on the board so violence's yeah", "j2dstLFXklo-01486-00347626-00347775": "that's right independence is very", "j2dstLFXklo-01487-00347776-00347940": "important so I think it's quite unusual", "j2dstLFXklo-01488-00347941-00348204": "to move within one organization it had", "j2dstLFXklo-01489-00348205-00348417": "to be the passage of time well I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01490-00348418-00348630": "recently there's been some cause for", "j2dstLFXklo-01491-00348631-00348972": "Roger Corbett to come back to be on the", "j2dstLFXklo-01492-00348973-00349302": "board of more worse after being CEO or", "j2dstLFXklo-01493-00349303-00349542": "something like that and that there was", "j2dstLFXklo-01494-00349543-00349752": "some concern about had enough time being", "j2dstLFXklo-01495-00349753-00350145": "passed so there are exceptions but the", "j2dstLFXklo-01496-00350146-00350391": "independence argument is Windsor would", "j2dstLFXklo-01497-00350392-00350553": "you both agree that I'll agree i mean--", "j2dstLFXklo-01498-00350554-00350745": "key thing is what are the roles of each", "j2dstLFXklo-01499-00350746-00350976": "of those if you've got the ability to", "j2dstLFXklo-01500-00350977-00351198": "have the transition you probably need a", "j2dstLFXklo-01501-00351199-00351606": "passage of time it's not a one-shot stop", "j2dstLFXklo-01502-00351607-00351765": "on the whole thing but i would suggest", "j2dstLFXklo-01503-00351766-00352089": "it's a hard transition private companies", "j2dstLFXklo-01504-00352090-00352269": "are the interesting one yep I think it's", "j2dstLFXklo-01505-00352270-00352455": "a really difficult transition for most", "j2dstLFXklo-01506-00352456-00352683": "people from an executive role to a board", "j2dstLFXklo-01507-00352684-00352863": "roll it is a really different skill set", "j2dstLFXklo-01508-00352864-00353062": "it's a really different interaction and", "j2dstLFXklo-01509-00353063-00353430": "I think for people sometimes separating", "j2dstLFXklo-01510-00353431-00353589": "from where you have worked as an", "j2dstLFXklo-01511-00353590-00353812": "executive will serve you better in", "j2dstLFXklo-01512-00353813-00354126": "developing a new skill set ok i'm going", "j2dstLFXklo-01513-00354127-00354354": "to ask everybody just to sum up now on", "j2dstLFXklo-01514-00354355-00354603": "balance due the rewards of being a", "j2dstLFXklo-01515-00354604-00354788": "director outweigh the risks and", "j2dstLFXklo-01516-00354789-00354972": "responsibilities and would you recommend", "j2dstLFXklo-01517-00354973-00355239": "directorship to others Tricia I", "j2dstLFXklo-01518-00355240-00355449": "certainly think that the rewards do", "j2dstLFXklo-01519-00355450-00355641": "outweigh the risks I think it's the", "j2dstLFXklo-01520-00355642-00355899": "incredible experience working with", "j2dstLFXklo-01521-00355900-00356129": "amazing people and learning about", "j2dstLFXklo-01522-00356130-00356412": "organizations you just have to be doing", "j2dstLFXklo-01523-00356413-00356562": "it for the right reasons which I think", "j2dstLFXklo-01524-00356563-00356714": "we've talked about quite a bit", "j2dstLFXklo-01525-00356715-00357006": "absolutely but it's about choosing your", "j2dstLFXklo-01526-00357007-00357195": "portfolio and what your personal", "j2dstLFXklo-01527-00357196-00357408": "objectives are it's not the rest of the", "j2dstLFXklo-01528-00357409-00357645": "world's objectives if it's right for you", "j2dstLFXklo-01529-00357646-00358101": "I would go for it I have and I grab and", "j2dstLFXklo-01530-00358102-00358332": "I love being a director and I think that", "j2dstLFXklo-01531-00358333-00358569": "the rewards definitely outweigh the", "j2dstLFXklo-01532-00358570-00358812": "risks but I think like most aspect of", "j2dstLFXklo-01533-00358813-00358907": "risks the more", "j2dstLFXklo-01534-00358908-00359105": "understand the risks and the more you", "j2dstLFXklo-01535-00359106-00359467": "know how you are meeting expectations", "j2dstLFXklo-01536-00359468-00359747": "the more you will feel the rewards so if", "j2dstLFXklo-01537-00359748-00359954": "you think if you understand what he's", "j2dstLFXklo-01538-00359955-00360134": "required and you can do a great job of", "j2dstLFXklo-01539-00360135-00360388": "it then the rewards are awesome thank", "j2dstLFXklo-01540-00360389-00360755": "you and I know you can't applaud but i'm", "j2dstLFXklo-01541-00360756-00361046": "sure you all are so i'm going to thank", "j2dstLFXklo-01542-00361047-00361295": "the panel of trisha mock janet tawny and", "j2dstLFXklo-01543-00361296-00361615": "leah freaky on your behalfs and the", "j2dstLFXklo-01544-00361616-00361844": "transcript from this webcast will be", "j2dstLFXklo-01545-00361845-00362063": "available afterwards I noticed that one", "j2dstLFXklo-01546-00362064-00362222": "or two of you were having difficulties", "j2dstLFXklo-01547-00362223-00362396": "in accessing it so please don't worry", "j2dstLFXklo-01548-00362397-00362639": "you will be able to see us all again", "j2dstLFXklo-01549-00362640-00362792": "those of you wanting to watch this all", "j2dstLFXklo-01550-00362793-00363041": "again of course can and he will be", "j2dstLFXklo-01551-00363042-00363200": "receiving some follow up a communication", "j2dstLFXklo-01552-00363201-00363494": "to I'd just like to particularly thank", "j2dstLFXklo-01553-00363495-00363656": "read back conferencing for the", "j2dstLFXklo-01554-00363657-00363851": "opportunity I like to thank governance", "j2dstLFXklo-01555-00363852-00364082": "Institute of Australia and of course our", "j2dstLFXklo-01556-00364083-00364370": "own organization women on boards for", "j2dstLFXklo-01557-00364371-00364604": "making this available to you so I wish", "j2dstLFXklo-01558-00364605-00364808": "you all a good afternoon and thank you", "j2dstLFXklo-01559-00364809-00365075": "very much for attending"}}, {"audio_id": "j26nLPVzkoo", "text": {"j26nLPVzkoo-00000-00000368-00000899": "all right fifty common North Adams", "j26nLPVzkoo-00001-00000900-00001369": "family massive juice nuts", "j26nLPVzkoo-00002-00001370-00001609": "no I could be wrong about that", "j26nLPVzkoo-00003-00001610-00002170": "the idea is to go up route 8a for Bella", "j26nLPVzkoo-00004-00002171-00002483": "because it's a road that I think he", "j26nLPVzkoo-00005-00002484-00002952": "would like", "j26nLPVzkoo-00006-00002953-00003201": "in this first bit rugs pretty impressed", "j26nLPVzkoo-00007-00003202-00004018": "about hardcore these curves are", "j26nLPVzkoo-00008-00004019-00004681": "and we have stop sign which is weird but", "j26nLPVzkoo-00009-00004682-00004864": "it's because of this beautiful covered", "j26nLPVzkoo-00010-00004865-00005218": "bridge see not the whole thing's asphalt", "j26nLPVzkoo-00011-00005219-00005518": "this is wood here really harsh turn", "j26nLPVzkoo-00012-00005519-00005693": "right out of it see Kimberly accelerate", "j26nLPVzkoo-00013-00005694-00005965": "across the bridge", "j26nLPVzkoo-00014-00005966-00006181": "with any", "j26nLPVzkoo-00015-00006182-00006675": "captain vinegar", "j26nLPVzkoo-00016-00006676-00007216": "bigger", "j26nLPVzkoo-00017-00007217-00007714": "xxx yeah this trucks", "j26nLPVzkoo-00018-00007715-00007918": "the problem with letting cars drive on", "j26nLPVzkoo-00019-00007919-00008148": "motorcycle roads", "j26nLPVzkoo-00020-00008148-00010287": "you're right anyway", "j26nLPVzkoo-00021-00010288-00011873": "I'm Way over the center line", "j26nLPVzkoo-00022-00011874-00012328": "Rhoda's so curvy I don't think I can", "j26nLPVzkoo-00023-00012329-00013947": "pass him without doing something stupid", "j26nLPVzkoo-00024-00013949-00014207": "this driveway going straight all these", "j26nLPVzkoo-00025-00014208-00014419": "comp the driveway cool thank you", "j26nLPVzkoo-00026-00014419-00014794": "dead end drivers a public road straight", "j26nLPVzkoo-00027-00014796-00015237": "up don't like that", "j26nLPVzkoo-00028-00015238-00015732": "fellas right I've got a weight problem", "j26nLPVzkoo-00029-00015733-00017139": "I'm impatient", "j26nLPVzkoo-00030-00017140-00017817": "[Music]", "j26nLPVzkoo-00031-00017818-00018150": "and now there was a poster way over the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00032-00018151-00018955": "center line", "j26nLPVzkoo-00033-00018956-00019940": "really very", "j26nLPVzkoo-00034-00019941-00020177": "trying to dilute myself I mean delude", "j26nLPVzkoo-00035-00020178-00021632": "myself yeah that's what I meant", "j26nLPVzkoo-00036-00021633-00021821": "wasn't so bumpy right there I probably", "j26nLPVzkoo-00037-00021822-00022304": "could have gone by him but bouncing", "j26nLPVzkoo-00038-00022305-00022611": "through there barely see", "j26nLPVzkoo-00039-00022612-00023172": "Rogell one mile and shorten felt longer", "j26nLPVzkoo-00040-00023173-00023563": "reach out fella that's what happened to", "j26nLPVzkoo-00041-00023564-00023967": "us last week", "j26nLPVzkoo-00042-00023968-00025312": "New Hampshire the bridge was out", "j26nLPVzkoo-00043-00025313-00026480": "come on lady", "j26nLPVzkoo-00044-00026481-00026927": "killing Mike Baz", "j26nLPVzkoo-00045-00026929-00028004": "buzzing by you", "j26nLPVzkoo-00046-00028005-00028301": "it's not enough visibility to go past", "j26nLPVzkoo-00047-00028302-00028836": "anybody here", "j26nLPVzkoo-00048-00028837-00031020": "I was younger he's no quitter I would", "j26nLPVzkoo-00049-00031022-00031633": "and 8a goes to the left where the bridge", "j26nLPVzkoo-00050-00031635-00031937": "is out and it is out I can see the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00051-00031938-00032138": "bridge I just can't get on to its all", "j26nLPVzkoo-00052-00032139-00032348": "the barriers in the way and the bridge", "j26nLPVzkoo-00053-00032349-00032858": "is like a foot higher than all that dirt", "j26nLPVzkoo-00054-00032859-00034597": "and junk you'd have to be a trials like", "j26nLPVzkoo-00055-00034598-00034996": "what up homie so for the bridges out", "j26nLPVzkoo-00056-00034997-00036459": "don't turn that way", "j26nLPVzkoo-00057-00036460-00036902": "stupidity", "j26nLPVzkoo-00058-00036903-00037546": "signs that lie to me", "j26nLPVzkoo-00059-00037547-00037840": "say that the bridges out and to go on", "j26nLPVzkoo-00060-00037841-00038167": "the stage one and that's okay I can go", "j26nLPVzkoo-00061-00038168-00038499": "on", "j26nLPVzkoo-00062-00038500-00038692": "long as they can point me in the right", "j26nLPVzkoo-00063-00038693-00039862": "direction and I'll go on", "j26nLPVzkoo-00064-00039863-00040456": "but they don't they're lying that turned", "j26nLPVzkoo-00065-00040457-00040593": "south", "j26nLPVzkoo-00066-00040594-00041157": "excuse me homie I'm not going your way", "j26nLPVzkoo-00067-00041158-00041368": "no probably should have been in first", "j26nLPVzkoo-00068-00041369-00041743": "for that but", "j26nLPVzkoo-00069-00041744-00041977": "dirt is nicer in second gear Bella would", "j26nLPVzkoo-00070-00041978-00042130": "love this road", "j26nLPVzkoo-00071-00042131-00042709": "I mean Beyla I'm gonna have to try to", "j26nLPVzkoo-00072-00042710-00042996": "say Beyla Bella is wrong Bayla is right", "j26nLPVzkoo-00073-00042997-00043492": "so I gotta try to say Bayla", "j26nLPVzkoo-00074-00043493-00043674": "this corner he'd love right here a", "j26nLPVzkoo-00075-00043675-00043821": "little bit of banking into it he would", "j26nLPVzkoo-00076-00043822-00044364": "fly through this one even I'm like", "j26nLPVzkoo-00077-00044365-00044605": "Street tires I can move through that", "j26nLPVzkoo-00078-00044606-00045562": "corner all right", "j26nLPVzkoo-00079-00045563-00045871": "when the Impaler took this road not his", "j26nLPVzkoo-00080-00045872-00046379": "third mode but 8a years and years ago", "j26nLPVzkoo-00081-00046380-00046799": "you know 15 years of almost we took it", "j26nLPVzkoo-00082-00046800-00047230": "going south and we came down and we're", "j26nLPVzkoo-00083-00047231-00047483": "not pushing it we felt like we were", "j26nLPVzkoo-00084-00047484-00047887": "relaxed and through there like you know", "j26nLPVzkoo-00085-00047888-00048311": "kind of fast but not fast and when we", "j26nLPVzkoo-00086-00048312-00048663": "got down into that town", "j26nLPVzkoo-00087-00048664-00048873": "pulled over on this little side road", "j26nLPVzkoo-00088-00048874-00049149": "that connects back to the main road we", "j26nLPVzkoo-00089-00049150-00049431": "could see it we even come back was just", "j26nLPVzkoo-00090-00049432-00049761": "short but some houses on it uphill we", "j26nLPVzkoo-00091-00049762-00049968": "pulled off to talk about how awesome the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00092-00049969-00050091": "road was because we didn't have any", "j26nLPVzkoo-00093-00050092-00050286": "communications figured out at the time", "j26nLPVzkoo-00094-00050287-00050577": "and they didn't sell any reason why our", "j26nLPVzkoo-00095-00050578-00050919": "school didn't have any reasonable", "j26nLPVzkoo-00096-00050920-00051120": "solutions for sale unless you were on a", "j26nLPVzkoo-00097-00051121-00051453": "gold wing we pulled over to talk and", "j26nLPVzkoo-00098-00051454-00051966": "while we're it yappin about the road one", "j26nLPVzkoo-00099-00051966-00052116": "of us I don't really remember who", "j26nLPVzkoo-00100-00052116-00052278": "lighting what's Bellis his whole holy", "j26nLPVzkoo-00101-00052279-00052662": "crap I mean bailouts his holy craps look", "j26nLPVzkoo-00102-00052663-00052916": "at your tires look at my tires look at", "j26nLPVzkoo-00103-00052917-00053151": "our tires they're all pilled up like", "j26nLPVzkoo-00104-00053152-00053726": "race tires I felt a little fast there", "j26nLPVzkoo-00105-00053727-00053979": "there's roads nice it's hard pack it's", "j26nLPVzkoo-00106-00053979-00054372": "not clay whoo not even that's a little", "j26nLPVzkoo-00107-00054373-00054864": "tricky for me scary on these road tires", "j26nLPVzkoo-00108-00054865-00055304": "on gravely stuff the clay with no gravel", "j26nLPVzkoo-00109-00055305-00055602": "on it it's uh when it's when it's hard", "j26nLPVzkoo-00110-00055603-00056073": "dry there's a lot easier to ride on than", "j26nLPVzkoo-00111-00056074-00056261": "this stuff ah somebody came to here", "j26nLPVzkoo-00112-00056262-00056685": "peeling out that must have been fun to", "j26nLPVzkoo-00113-00056686-00057280": "tire tracks skittering up that hill", "j26nLPVzkoo-00114-00057282-00058955": "and this her body is 8a north", "j26nLPVzkoo-00115-00058957-00059619": "now I could have gone south just there", "j26nLPVzkoo-00116-00059620-00059965": "just to see how good the road is up", "j26nLPVzkoo-00117-00059966-00060166": "until we're the richest out and I", "j26nLPVzkoo-00118-00060166-00060409": "probably should have probably should", "j26nLPVzkoo-00119-00060410-00060721": "still do that but I'm not gonna", "j26nLPVzkoo-00120-00060722-00060904": "that's I'm already", "j26nLPVzkoo-00121-00060904-00061062": "on track to get", "j26nLPVzkoo-00122-00061063-00061462": "way after dark and that's if I take", "j26nLPVzkoo-00123-00061463-00062339": "straight boring roads that take my butt", "j26nLPVzkoo-00124-00062340-00062672": "and I've been riding today it took this", "j26nLPVzkoo-00125-00062673-00063082": "morning I was pretty hungover at the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00126-00063083-00063597": "camp", "j26nLPVzkoo-00127-00063598-00063982": "wrote it's great you know the bank into", "j26nLPVzkoo-00128-00063983-00064603": "that turn n detour that must be where", "j26nLPVzkoo-00129-00064604-00065186": "the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00130-00065187-00065597": "wait a light not just flickering off the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00131-00065598-00066039": "back to that road sign to the left", "j26nLPVzkoo-00132-00066040-00066181": "[Music]", "j26nLPVzkoo-00133-00066182-00067814": "really looks like a blue light", "j26nLPVzkoo-00134-00067815-00068441": "number nine roads to the left there", "j26nLPVzkoo-00135-00068442-00069115": "troubled", "j26nLPVzkoo-00136-00069116-00069418": "lean the bridge ahead we sneak closed", "j26nLPVzkoo-00137-00069419-00069802": "ahead but slow down in case there's no", "j26nLPVzkoo-00138-00069803-00069964": "part of its blows that's why he's down", "j26nLPVzkoo-00139-00069965-00070587": "to one lane", "j26nLPVzkoo-00140-00070588-00070836": "they could have made that morning with a", "j26nLPVzkoo-00141-00070837-00071391": "lot more seriously little chipmunk what", "j26nLPVzkoo-00142-00071392-00071868": "is that oh it's cool looks like a pretty", "j26nLPVzkoo-00143-00071869-00072790": "cool", "j26nLPVzkoo-00144-00072791-00073173": "that was a lot of break in a very short", "j26nLPVzkoo-00145-00073174-00073478": "area that was", "j26nLPVzkoo-00146-00073479-00074516": "felt pretty good", "j26nLPVzkoo-00147-00074517-00074876": "Wow nice s we heard you this is great", "j26nLPVzkoo-00148-00074877-00075476": "Oh another one tighter than there are", "j26nLPVzkoo-00149-00075477-00076687": "all at decreasing radius", "j26nLPVzkoo-00150-00076688-00078551": "I still turn", "j26nLPVzkoo-00151-00078552-00079085": "they're big decreasing radius turn", "j26nLPVzkoo-00152-00079086-00079219": "[Music]", "j26nLPVzkoo-00153-00079220-00079895": "downhill switchback what gravel in it", "j26nLPVzkoo-00154-00079896-00080288": "nice get it all chewed up", "j26nLPVzkoo-00155-00080289-00080541": "audience get the power out of a corner", "j26nLPVzkoo-00156-00080542-00082332": "when you bend over that bar", "j26nLPVzkoo-00157-00082333-00082634": "stop so i know--yeah the road just", "j26nLPVzkoo-00158-00082635-00082900": "continues okay the road much it had to", "j26nLPVzkoo-00159-00082901-00083068": "stop I didn't see it though", "j26nLPVzkoo-00160-00083069-00083611": "that's a little scary I love this I'm", "j26nLPVzkoo-00161-00083612-00083925": "leaned over the last it's pretty far", "j26nLPVzkoo-00162-00083926-00084156": "considering the speed I'm going that's", "j26nLPVzkoo-00163-00084157-00084379": "pretty good lean in the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00164-00084380-00084781": "arrow points like right hand right", "j26nLPVzkoo-00165-00084782-00085375": "angled corner as a weed or left", "j26nLPVzkoo-00166-00085376-00085630": "pretty great ah that looked like an", "j26nLPVzkoo-00167-00085631-00085830": "inversion table", "j26nLPVzkoo-00168-00085831-00086019": "on the side of the road there I really", "j26nLPVzkoo-00169-00086020-00086373": "would like to have an inverse", "j26nLPVzkoo-00170-00086374-00086628": "fitting in on this", "j26nLPVzkoo-00171-00086629-00087203": "not today I think I wouldn't put that on", "j26nLPVzkoo-00172-00087204-00087541": "85 it's fire away", "j26nLPVzkoo-00173-00087542-00087907": "fail fool one two three tractors farm", "j26nLPVzkoo-00174-00087908-00088303": "all farm all night", "j26nLPVzkoo-00175-00088304-00089063": "bring in two tractors at like", "j26nLPVzkoo-00176-00089064-00089363": "[Music]", "j26nLPVzkoo-00177-00089364-00089634": "corpus since I'm not even speeding I", "j26nLPVzkoo-00178-00089635-00090884": "think the answer by a cop", "j26nLPVzkoo-00179-00090885-00091976": "straight parts are boring", "j26nLPVzkoo-00180-00091977-00092785": "yeah", "j26nLPVzkoo-00181-00092786-00093462": "nice large heavy range", "j26nLPVzkoo-00182-00093463-00093755": "great hey Whittingham doesn't paved the", "j26nLPVzkoo-00183-00093756-00094443": "road since nice", "j26nLPVzkoo-00184-00094444-00094743": "or as crookedly", "j26nLPVzkoo-00185-00094744-00099407": "putting him where's my crooked the road", "j26nLPVzkoo-00186-00099408-00099824": "bump there was no idea he was", "j26nLPVzkoo-00187-00099825-00100107": "bump at the end of the dip force the tip", "j26nLPVzkoo-00188-00100108-00100630": "itself", "j26nLPVzkoo-00189-00100631-00100972": "as its dolphin"}}, {"audio_id": "j2mytvcK88U", "text": {"j2mytvcK88U-00000-00000035-00000307": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00001-00000308-00000849": "topic C also", "j2mytvcK88U-00002-00000850-00001286": "Hugh statistic wold Wolfowitz runs test", "j2mytvcK88U-00003-00001287-00001816": "Bruce Godfrey test Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00004-00001817-00002091": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00005-00002092-00002632": "topic C also", "j2mytvcK88U-00006-00002633-00003065": "Hugh statistic wold Wolfowitz runs test", "j2mytvcK88U-00007-00003066-00003596": "Bruce Godfrey test Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00008-00003597-00003870": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00009-00003871-00004420": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00010-00004421-00004845": "q statistic wold Wolfowitz runs test", "j2mytvcK88U-00011-00004846-00005377": "Bruce Godfrey test Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00012-00005378-00005651": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00013-00005652-00006190": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00014-00006191-00006627": "q statistic wold Wolfowitz runs test", "j2mytvcK88U-00015-00006628-00007156": "Bruce Godfrey test Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00016-00007158-00007434": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00017-00007434-00007971": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00018-00007972-00008250": "q statistic while", "j2mytvcK88U-00019-00008251-00008639": "Wolfowitz runs test brush Godfrey test", "j2mytvcK88U-00020-00008640-00008939": "Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00021-00008940-00009210": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00022-00009211-00009753": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00023-00009754-00010031": "q statistic while", "j2mytvcK88U-00024-00010032-00010420": "Wolfowitz runs test brush Godfrey test", "j2mytvcK88U-00025-00010421-00010721": "Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00026-00010722-00010994": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00027-00010995-00011535": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00028-00011536-00011969": "q statistic wold Wolfowitz runs test", "j2mytvcK88U-00029-00011970-00012501": "Bruce Godfrey test Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00030-00012502-00012776": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00031-00012777-00013322": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00032-00013324-00013751": "q statistic wold Wolfowitz runs test", "j2mytvcK88U-00033-00013752-00014282": "Bruce Godfrey test Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00034-00014283-00014555": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00035-00014556-00015097": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00036-00015099-00015532": "q statistic wold Wolfowitz runs test", "j2mytvcK88U-00037-00015533-00016063": "Bruce Godfrey test Durbin Watson test", "j2mytvcK88U-00038-00016063-00016335": "you", "j2mytvcK88U-00039-00016336-00016877": "topic see also", "j2mytvcK88U-00040-00016878-00017155": "q statistic while", "j2mytvcK88U-00041-00017156-00017544": "Wolfowitz runs tests Bruce Godfrey tests", "j2mytvcK88U-00042-00017545-00017917": "Durbin Watson tests"}}]