[{"audio_id": "3Y3QmweeDOk", "text": {"3Y3QmweeDOk-00000-00000017-00000316": "from list of national natural landmarks", "3Y3QmweeDOk-00001-00000317-00000530": "these are the national natural landmarks", "3Y3QmweeDOk-00002-00000531-00000944": "in New Mexico there are 12 in total"}}, {"audio_id": "3YGFd7iz2aA", "text": {"3YGFd7iz2aA-00000-00000224-00000351": "all right so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00001-00000352-00000599": "welcome my name is casey long and for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00002-00000600-00000678": "the last", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00003-00000679-00001015": "uh well nine years before coming to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00004-00001016-00001127": "agnes scott", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00005-00001128-00001407": "um i worked as a business researcher", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00006-00001408-00001614": "slash business librarian", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00007-00001616-00001895": "i worked at a consulting firm business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00008-00001896-00002079": "uh", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00009-00002080-00002239": "researcher at a consulting firm called", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00010-00002240-00002463": "booz allen hamilton so if you've ever", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00011-00002464-00002679": "watched the show house of lies on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00012-00002680-00002831": "showtime with", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00013-00002832-00003150": "don toodle then that book that show is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00014-00003151-00003311": "based off of a book that was written", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00015-00003311-00003470": "about the company i worked for and i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00016-00003471-00003670": "actually worked with a guy who wrote it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00017-00003671-00003847": "so that gives you an insight into kind", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00018-00003847-00003983": "of the crazy work", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00019-00003984-00004295": "that i was doing uh with that company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00020-00004296-00004470": "for a few years finding consumer", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00021-00004471-00004622": "products information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00022-00004623-00004951": "and then i came back to georgia and i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00023-00004952-00005079": "ended up working at georgia state", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00024-00005080-00005295": "university as their primary business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00025-00005296-00005383": "librarian for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00026-00005384-00005663": "seven years so i have a lot of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00027-00005664-00005822": "experience and knowledge searching for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00028-00005823-00005934": "business information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00029-00005935-00006159": "even though working here at agnes scott", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00030-00006160-00006247": "college", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00031-00006248-00006478": "there's less of a demand for it it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00032-00006479-00006646": "still something that i love to do so i'm", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00033-00006647-00006823": "really happy to be presenting", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00034-00006823-00007046": "to you today and basically there are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00035-00007047-00007191": "lots of different ways that we can go", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00036-00007192-00007287": "about doing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00037-00007288-00007551": "business research but and definitely", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00038-00007552-00007727": "lots of options for company research but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00039-00007728-00007846": "what i wanted you to walk away with", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00040-00007847-00007927": "today", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00041-00007928-00008159": "is really being able to identify three", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00042-00008159-00008231": "different", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00043-00008232-00008391": "types of information that are going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00044-00008392-00008607": "be most useful to you at the start of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00045-00008608-00008991": "any kind of project so to get started", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00046-00008992-00009063": "with that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00047-00009064-00009255": "the three sources that i like the most", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00048-00009256-00009510": "are an annual report from the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00049-00009511-00009814": "for me that an annual report is really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00050-00009815-00009942": "useful because it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00051-00009943-00010135": "really shows you what the company cares", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00052-00010136-00010303": "about the most", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00053-00010304-00010631": "to share with others so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00054-00010632-00010959": "there are some types of companies that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00055-00010960-00011127": "are required to share this information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00056-00011128-00011342": "so they try to put a nice polished spin", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00057-00011343-00011542": "on it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00058-00011543-00011774": "and there are some that are not required", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00059-00011775-00011846": "to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00060-00011847-00012038": "share this information so often with", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00061-00012039-00012199": "those companies you won't find quite as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00062-00012200-00012327": "much information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00063-00012328-00012535": "but looking for an annual report seeing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00064-00012536-00012774": "if they have one is always really useful", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00065-00012775-00012991": "it usually will highlight", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00066-00012991-00013247": "in not necessarily direct language but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00067-00013247-00013415": "it highlights what their priorities are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00068-00013416-00013583": "what they care about the most so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00069-00013584-00013758": "to me getting their perspective is one", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00070-00013759-00014022": "of the first things that i want to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00071-00014023-00014263": "the next thing that i like to do and i'm", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00072-00014263-00014447": "sad i have this misspelled here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00073-00014447-00014743": "is get a third-party company analysis so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00074-00014744-00014951": "by that i mean a market research report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00075-00014952-00015175": "or something that's rating companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00076-00015176-00015503": "so we've often seen ngos do that with", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00077-00015504-00015615": "looking at things like social", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00078-00015616-00015894": "responsibility so if you know of an ngo", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00079-00015895-00015943": "that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00080-00015944-00016215": "evaluates companies then that would be a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00081-00016216-00016391": "third party analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00082-00016392-00016622": "they might not do a big huge profile but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00083-00016623-00016815": "they would be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00084-00016816-00016983": "evaluating certain characteristics and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00085-00016984-00017150": "how well the company does", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00086-00017151-00017375": "um what a lot of business folks are more", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00087-00017376-00017647": "used to are market research reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00088-00017648-00017903": "or swot analysis swot analysis is a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00089-00017904-00017983": "strengths", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00090-00017984-00018167": "weaknesses opportunities and threat", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00091-00018168-00018286": "analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00092-00018287-00018550": "it does exactly what i just told you it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00093-00018551-00018743": "outlines all those things", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00094-00018744-00018943": "and so if you get a current one of those", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00095-00018944-00019158": "then you can really clearly see where", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00096-00019159-00019311": "some of the strengths and weaknesses are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00097-00019312-00019439": "of the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00098-00019440-00019663": "and then finally there are some basic", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00099-00019664-00019830": "company profiles that you can find out", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00100-00019831-00019983": "there one of my favorite tools which", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00101-00019984-00020127": "i'll mention here today is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00102-00020128-00020327": "hoover's it really just gives you the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00103-00020328-00020486": "background of the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00104-00020487-00020791": "but um and tells you who they think", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00105-00020792-00020943": "their competitors are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00106-00020944-00021214": "and give some basic information but what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00107-00021215-00021383": "i like about it is it's not coming from", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00108-00021384-00021567": "the company themselves so it's not what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00109-00021568-00021703": "the company's trying to sell me it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00110-00021704-00021750": "what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00111-00021751-00021950": "a third party is thinking would be most", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00112-00021951-00022111": "valuable for me to know", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00113-00022112-00022319": "so we'll go over some of those and then", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00114-00022320-00022519": "the final thing that i do in my mix", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00115-00022520-00022822": "of coming up with a company analysis is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00116-00022823-00023135": "news articles so um i look within the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00117-00023136-00023214": "last year", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00118-00023215-00023567": "r2 or even a longer span and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00119-00023568-00023678": "first i'm just looking through the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00120-00023679-00023855": "headlines seeing what kind of things are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00121-00023856-00024022": "being mentioned and i might be taking", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00122-00024023-00024103": "notes", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00123-00024104-00024478": "just to see what is being highlighted in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00124-00024479-00024622": "different types of news about the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00125-00024623-00024894": "company and that can help me", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00126-00024895-00025175": "identify what's a success what's a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00127-00025176-00025399": "problem that they're experiencing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00128-00025400-00025575": "and it just really creates another", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00129-00025576-00025750": "picture of the company so those three", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00130-00025751-00025894": "things together", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00131-00025895-00026167": "if you find some information from each", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00132-00026168-00026327": "of those it's really quick to be able to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00133-00026327-00026414": "locate", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00134-00026416-00026695": "a set of information from each of these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00135-00026695-00026879": "and then", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00136-00026880-00027031": "what that does for you is if you're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00137-00027032-00027231": "about to go in let's say for an", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00138-00027232-00027335": "interview", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00139-00027336-00027502": "and you spend some time with those", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00140-00027504-00027679": "you'll already know the answer to the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00141-00027680-00027839": "questions that most people ask the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00142-00027839-00027902": "company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00143-00027904-00028095": "and you'll be able to ask really nuanced", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00144-00028095-00028311": "things because you understand", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00145-00028312-00028446": "the problems that they've faced and you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00146-00028447-00028751": "can ask oh i understand that you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00147-00028752-00028967": "usually excel in this but you've been", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00148-00028968-00029087": "struggling with this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00149-00029088-00029367": "is there a way that you want to address", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00150-00029368-00029535": "that and how does my position", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00151-00029536-00029831": "fit into that so there's a lot of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00152-00029832-00029974": "interesting ways that you can come up", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00153-00029975-00030135": "with questions by doing this kind of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00154-00030136-00030246": "analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00155-00030247-00030558": "and really put your best foot forward", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00156-00030560-00030774": "before we get into those sources though", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00157-00030775-00030943": "the thing that i need to tell you is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00158-00030944-00031239": "that the availability of information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00159-00031239-00031599": "has some caveats so the first thing is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00160-00031600-00031855": "is that as i mentioned before some", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00161-00031856-00031911": "companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00162-00031912-00032102": "provide access to more information than", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00163-00032103-00032343": "others do and that basically comes down", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00164-00032344-00032439": "to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00165-00032439-00032590": "whether the company is considered a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00166-00032591-00032790": "public company we call", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00167-00032791-00032999": "a company a public company if it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00168-00033000-00033215": "publicly traded in the united states", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00169-00033216-00033423": "that means that every time you hear them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00170-00033424-00033559": "say that the dow", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00171-00033560-00033774": "indexes up because the stock market's up", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00172-00033775-00033911": "and it's doing well", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00173-00033912-00034174": "um it's talking about those companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00174-00034175-00034327": "that are public that are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00175-00034328-00034646": "that have um have stockholders", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00176-00034647-00035015": "shareholders and that they need to let", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00177-00035016-00035167": "their shareholders know what they're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00178-00035168-00035239": "doing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00179-00035240-00035462": "and they're required by the security", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00180-00035463-00035646": "exchange commission", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00181-00035647-00035902": "u.s government agency to let their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00182-00035903-00036062": "shareholders know what's happening and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00183-00036063-00036246": "so there's very specific information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00184-00036247-00036359": "that they", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00185-00036360-00036559": "have to release so you're going to find", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00186-00036560-00036671": "a lot of information about those", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00187-00036672-00036879": "companies but even those companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00188-00036880-00037015": "are going to be tight-lipped on some", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00189-00037016-00037215": "things i often find people really want", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00190-00037216-00037415": "to know more about the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00191-00037416-00037774": "manufacturing process or supply chain", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00192-00037775-00037846": "management", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00193-00037847-00038007": "and some of these things you have to dig", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00194-00038008-00038223": "into yourself you have to think about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00195-00038224-00038367": "okay what's going to get me to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00196-00038368-00038511": "understand their supply chain because", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00197-00038512-00038695": "they're really not needing to lay this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00198-00038696-00038767": "out for me", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00199-00038768-00039023": "in a very rudimentary fashion so if", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00200-00039024-00039135": "that's what you're looking for you're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00201-00039136-00039262": "going to have to be strategic in how", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00202-00039263-00039430": "you're thinking", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00203-00039431-00039774": "and you're lucky if you're working on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00204-00039775-00039990": "a company that is publicly traded if", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00205-00039991-00040118": "it's a non-profit", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00206-00040119-00040390": "or it's a privately held company or even", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00207-00040391-00040511": "let's say you're looking", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00208-00040512-00040799": "at playstation and that company is a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00209-00040800-00040895": "subsidiary", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00210-00040896-00041111": "of sony then you're going to have a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00211-00041112-00041287": "harder time finding information on those", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00212-00041288-00041335": "because", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00213-00041336-00041527": "they are not required to reveal anything", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00214-00041528-00041646": "about themselves", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00215-00041647-00041895": "that's not true the ngos are actually", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00216-00041896-00042007": "required to file", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00217-00042008-00042335": "a tax document so we'll talk more about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00218-00042336-00042390": "that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00219-00042391-00042551": "so you will find that it they're not", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00220-00042552-00042767": "required to reveal quite as much as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00221-00042768-00043055": "what the uh publicly traded companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00222-00043056-00043230": "are required to reveal", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00223-00043231-00043390": "so keep that in mind just because you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00224-00043391-00043630": "want it doesn't mean it's out there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00225-00043631-00044015": "and information is a hot commodity", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00226-00044016-00044215": "you'll see um when we get to the market", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00227-00044216-00044327": "research section", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00228-00044328-00044574": "that the cost of information can be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00229-00044575-00044751": "really high when i worked as a business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00230-00044752-00044830": "librarian", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00231-00044831-00045046": "an inexpensive database for us to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00232-00045047-00045255": "purchase would be ten thousand dollars a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00233-00045256-00045311": "year", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00234-00045312-00045487": "that's partially why we don't have a ton", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00235-00045488-00045646": "of business databases here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00236-00045647-00045839": "because the per cost use would be so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00237-00045840-00045999": "high um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00238-00046000-00046158": "and so we really need to see a demand", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00239-00046159-00046327": "for it uh but we do have some really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00240-00046328-00046535": "good business databases that you can use", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00241-00046536-00046799": "but just know that uh business people", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00242-00046800-00046862": "value", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00243-00046863-00047071": "information and there are certain types", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00244-00047072-00047230": "of information that they value more than", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00245-00047231-00047286": "others", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00246-00047287-00047543": "so you have to be cautious it who's your", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00247-00047544-00047679": "source of information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00248-00047680-00047990": "is it just some guy with a website who's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00249-00047991-00048190": "teaching you how to do a swot analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00250-00048191-00048311": "or has just", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00251-00048312-00048590": "does swot analysis for fun maybe they", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00252-00048591-00048758": "just write their own company profiles", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00253-00048759-00048886": "believe me that's out there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00254-00048887-00049079": "they're trying to share their skills to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00255-00049080-00049279": "future employers but that's not what you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00256-00049280-00049407": "want to be using you don't want to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00257-00049408-00049639": "be using somebody who's working on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00258-00049640-00049767": "getting their mba", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00259-00049768-00049974": "their squad their swot analysis you want", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00260-00049975-00050183": "to be able to do your own", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00261-00050184-00050367": "and use some of the more quality sources", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00262-00050368-00050511": "so be careful about what information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00263-00050512-00050607": "you're using because you don't want to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00264-00050608-00050639": "be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00265-00050640-00050911": "citing something in a job interview that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00266-00050912-00050974": "um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00267-00050975-00051207": "really isn't true so be careful about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00268-00051208-00051335": "that um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00269-00051336-00051470": "and like i said before companies are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00270-00051471-00051590": "only willing to share information that's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00271-00051591-00051687": "strategically", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00272-00051688-00051919": "strategically advanced advantageous to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00273-00051920-00052007": "do so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00274-00052008-00052382": "so um again that supply chain", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00275-00052383-00052535": "they don't want their competitors to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00276-00052536-00052735": "know what they're doing so that they can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00277-00052736-00052894": "replicate it so they'll keep things", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00278-00052895-00053126": "under wraps as much as they can so we", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00279-00053127-00053294": "have to be strategic sometimes digging", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00280-00053295-00053463": "that information out", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00281-00053464-00053694": "and finally businesses are constantly", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00282-00053695-00053823": "changing so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00283-00053824-00054054": "um currency is important when i was", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00284-00054055-00054359": "mentioning the swot analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00285-00054360-00054550": "the company's strengths and weaknesses", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00286-00054551-00054815": "can evolve over the course of six months", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00287-00054816-00054959": "it's probably likely that they're going", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00288-00054960-00055150": "to still be in the same boat", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00289-00055151-00055375": "but it can change dramatically this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00290-00055376-00055511": "whole covet thing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00291-00055512-00055887": "um that has changed how businesses", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00292-00055888-00056007": "thought that they were going to be doing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00293-00056008-00056199": "business last year in january", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00294-00056200-00056423": "so the landscape is very different", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00295-00056424-00056563": "looking at a report from", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00296-00056564-00056975": "2019 might not be as helpful as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00297-00056976-00057319": "it would have been so um so those are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00298-00057320-00057511": "some of the things that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00299-00057512-00057694": "you want to keep in mind when you are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00300-00057695-00057926": "searching for information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00301-00057927-00058175": "now in today's session we're going to be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00302-00058176-00058303": "going through those three types of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00303-00058304-00058471": "sources and i'm going to be using these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00304-00058472-00058711": "three companies as kind of a sample", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00305-00058712-00058903": "and you can see the types of information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00306-00058904-00059063": "that we just talked about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00307-00059064-00059263": "i see that we have some folks have", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00308-00059264-00059447": "joined us since", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00309-00059448-00059607": "you can see that we're looking at the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00310-00059608-00059807": "annual report annual report is one of my", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00311-00059808-00059903": "favorite sources", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00312-00059904-00060254": "to use when researching companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00313-00060255-00060471": "and that comes in the form of sec", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00314-00060472-00060599": "filings or", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00315-00060600-00060942": "in annual reports or irs filings", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00316-00060944-00061079": "so these are annual things that they", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00317-00061079-00061223": "have to file but you can see that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00318-00061224-00061399": "different types of companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00319-00061400-00061591": "are required to do things differently so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00320-00061591-00061903": "at t is our example of a public company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00321-00061904-00062103": "center for pan-asian community services", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00322-00062104-00062335": "is our example of a non-profit company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00323-00062336-00062519": "they don't file with the sac they file", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00324-00062520-00062654": "with the irs", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00325-00062655-00062991": "and the lola which is a networking", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00326-00062991-00063271": "membership organization in atlanta for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00327-00063272-00063399": "women", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00328-00063400-00063647": "they don't have an annual report that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00329-00063648-00063854": "they're putting out there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00330-00063855-00064150": "and they're not required to make their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00331-00064151-00064335": "filings public", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00332-00064336-00064566": "the only thing that i can see from them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00333-00064567-00064679": "is that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00334-00064679-00064887": "we have this business registration so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00335-00064888-00064999": "let me show you what those are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00336-00065000-00065303": "we go to the at t site and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00337-00065304-00065535": "this is their website and to get access", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00338-00065536-00065694": "to their annual reports knowing that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00339-00065695-00065799": "they're a public", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00340-00065800-00066094": "company i usually look for investor", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00341-00066095-00066191": "relations", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00342-00066192-00066471": "so i'm scrolling down to the bottom and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00343-00066472-00066647": "it takes me a minute sometimes", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00344-00066648-00066950": "it might be under about at t but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00345-00066951-00067231": "just take a look and see if you see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00346-00067232-00067406": "investor relations i don't see it right", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00347-00067407-00067759": "off so i'm going to go to about at t", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00348-00067760-00068023": "and hopefully on this page it you can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00349-00068024-00068182": "see it took us to a completely different", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00350-00068183-00068279": "website", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00351-00068280-00068606": "and here they have investors", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00352-00068607-00068767": "there's a lot of great information on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00353-00068768-00068911": "here but usually when i'm looking for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00354-00068912-00068991": "information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00355-00068992-00069126": "i'm trying to get to what's going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00356-00069127-00069303": "give me the most information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00357-00069304-00069479": "as quickly as possible so i'm going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00358-00069480-00069687": "go to their investors website", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00359-00069688-00069887": "not all of them do it this way but they", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00360-00069888-00070047": "often just call it investor relations", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00361-00070048-00070143": "but you can see here that they have", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00362-00070144-00070303": "their financial reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00363-00070304-00070663": "um and if we scroll down they're listing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00364-00070664-00070863": "here's their annual report their sec", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00365-00070864-00070967": "filings", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00366-00070968-00071126": "so this is a way you can get access to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00367-00071127-00071287": "some of the core information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00368-00071288-00071431": "you want to when you're researching a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00369-00071432-00071631": "company that's public try to think of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00370-00071632-00071775": "yourself as the investor", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00371-00071776-00071943": "how are they going to sell you on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00372-00071944-00072175": "supporting that company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00373-00072176-00072303": "and so this is how i would access the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00374-00072304-00072503": "annual reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00375-00072504-00072687": "for that public company you can see that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00376-00072688-00072879": "you can go back various years", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00377-00072880-00073055": "and that can be very helpful for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00378-00073056-00073287": "comparing how they did business one year", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00379-00073288-00073503": "versus the next and i'll come back to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00380-00073504-00073679": "this in a minute as to what you might be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00381-00073680-00073919": "looking for in this annual report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00382-00073920-00074038": "i just wanted to show you that this is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00383-00074039-00074294": "where you would find that annual report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00384-00074295-00074679": "then our other sample company the lola", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00385-00074680-00074943": "if we go to the same kind of place who", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00386-00074944-00075023": "are we", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00387-00075024-00075343": "um we can see that they don't list", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00388-00075344-00075455": "anything there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00389-00075456-00075719": "um they have their mission they tell us", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00390-00075720-00075871": "they're telling us some details about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00391-00075872-00076006": "them that's going to be helpful", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00392-00076007-00076159": "we know who the founder is we can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00393-00076160-00076343": "research more about the founders", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00394-00076344-00076567": "to understand why they formed this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00395-00076568-00076694": "company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00396-00076695-00076871": "and we can look at the mission to really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00397-00076872-00077087": "get a feel for what they value", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00398-00077088-00077247": "but they're not giving us an annual", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00399-00077248-00077423": "report so we're gonna have to rely on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00400-00077424-00077511": "their website", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00401-00077512-00077711": "and just examining their website what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00402-00077712-00077894": "kind of things do they offer", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00403-00077895-00078191": "what does a membership get you um what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00404-00078192-00078303": "is the space", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00405-00078304-00078447": "what are their what are they technically", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00406-00078448-00078599": "selling they're selling happenings", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00407-00078600-00078719": "they're selling", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00408-00078720-00078935": "uh space this is a place where you can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00409-00078936-00079087": "set up office space", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00410-00079088-00079287": "how are they selling that but so that's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00411-00079288-00079399": "their product", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00412-00079400-00079662": "so you can use their website but um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00413-00079663-00079879": "usually i'm trying to avoid having to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00414-00079880-00079999": "that and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00415-00080000-00080126": "just going to something that's going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00416-00080127-00080311": "give me a lot of information really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00417-00080312-00080455": "quickly", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00418-00080456-00080711": "and then finally our non-profit", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00419-00080712-00080926": "organization center for pan asian", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00420-00080927-00081367": "community services they are not required", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00421-00081368-00081582": "to list an annual report but a lot of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00422-00081583-00081703": "them because of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00423-00081704-00081943": "seeking out support from donors find it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00424-00081944-00082087": "advantageous to do so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00425-00082088-00082375": "so if i scroll down again i'm going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00426-00082376-00082462": "the bottom", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00427-00082463-00082655": "and sometimes it'll list annual reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00428-00082656-00082815": "here but i'm going to go to oh there it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00429-00082816-00082903": "is actually", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00430-00082904-00083094": "they're just listing it right there so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00431-00083095-00083206": "we should be able to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00432-00083207-00083375": "examine it there i think also if we", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00433-00083376-00083591": "click on who we are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00434-00083592-00083855": "it should list annual reports as well", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00435-00083856-00083991": "and so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00436-00083992-00084167": "that would be an easy way for us to get", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00437-00084168-00084350": "in so what i want you to walk away with", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00438-00084351-00084431": "knowing about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00439-00084432-00084759": "finding the annual reports is that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00440-00084760-00085118": "not every company has them um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00441-00085119-00085382": "but you have to think about what kind of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00442-00085383-00085550": "company are you looking at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00443-00085551-00085831": "and what kind of information is going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00444-00085832-00085959": "be available", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00445-00085960-00086238": "based off of that but it is useful to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00446-00086239-00086471": "look for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00447-00086472-00086743": "i mentioned before the 10k versus the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00448-00086744-00086950": "990 i'll come to that as well", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00449-00086951-00087271": "i did want to show you this though um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00450-00087272-00087518": "if you were going to be searching just", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00451-00087519-00087582": "in general", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00452-00087583-00087935": "for the 10k um you would go to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00453-00087936-00088159": "the securities exchange commission so i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00454-00088160-00088271": "would just google", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00455-00088272-00088471": "security exchange commission and i know", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00456-00088472-00088606": "that the tool to find", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00457-00088607-00088911": "all those public filings is called edgar", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00458-00088912-00089238": "they have more than the annual report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00459-00089239-00089550": "which they call the 10k that's what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00460-00089551-00089679": "they're required to file", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00461-00089680-00089894": "if i click on company search here you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00462-00089895-00090047": "can see that i can type in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00463-00090048-00090406": "my sample company at t", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00464-00090407-00090647": "and it brings up a list of companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00465-00090648-00090799": "that have those letters in it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00466-00090800-00090918": "and this is where it gets a little", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00467-00090919-00091118": "tricky you have to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00468-00091119-00091255": "figure out which one of these they're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00469-00091256-00091423": "talking about just so you know", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00470-00091424-00091726": "sometimes companies um exist", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00471-00091727-00091982": "under a different name before they merge", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00472-00091983-00092087": "with something else", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00473-00092088-00092279": "and so usually that information will", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00474-00092280-00092543": "disappear or maybe they'll operate", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00475-00092544-00092918": "multiple um variations of the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00476-00092919-00093182": "so my instinct i think on this one was", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00477-00093183-00093343": "initially to go to at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00478-00093344-00093662": "t corp so i clicked on this one and the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00479-00093663-00093855": "problem is is that all the filing dates", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00480-00093856-00094062": "are from 2007 and before", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00481-00094063-00094311": "so that's clearly the wrong answer here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00482-00094312-00094374": "if i go", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00483-00094375-00094703": "down to at t inc and try that one", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00484-00094704-00094782": "instead", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00485-00094783-00094935": "you can see that we have the most recent", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00486-00094936-00095118": "ones and here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00487-00095119-00095255": "it lists all the different types of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00488-00095256-00095511": "filings there's quarterly ones", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00489-00095512-00095743": "there is proxy information i can't", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00490-00095744-00095911": "really go into all the things that these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00491-00095912-00096135": "are but if you are really hunting for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00492-00096136-00096438": "um really insider kind of information as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00493-00096439-00096487": "much as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00494-00096488-00096662": "as close as you can get this is where", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00495-00096663-00096894": "you can go and you can see i'm typing in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00496-00096895-00096935": "10", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00497-00096936-00097215": "because 10k is their annual report that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00498-00097216-00097350": "they're required to file", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00499-00097351-00097647": "and this will give you access to that so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00500-00097648-00097823": "this is what it looks like", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00501-00097824-00098159": "um you can see that it's not that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00502-00098160-00098462": "pretty so we'll come back to this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00503-00098463-00098631": "but it does have all the information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00504-00098632-00099006": "that we would need to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00505-00099007-00099382": "examine the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00506-00099383-00099703": "but i will show you uh", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00507-00099704-00099918": "the the annual report is a lot prettier", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00508-00099919-00100150": "than this so we'll come back to that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00509-00100151-00100431": "so that's the sec and that's one source", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00510-00100432-00100543": "that you can go to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00511-00100544-00100862": "to access public companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00512-00100863-00101015": "annual reports if you can't find it on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00513-00101016-00101223": "their website or if you just want to see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00514-00101224-00101359": "what they're required to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00515-00101360-00101767": "file the nonprofit organizations are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00516-00101768-00102023": "required to file with the irs so you can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00517-00102024-00102094": "go", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00518-00102095-00102350": "to their tax exempt organization search", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00519-00102351-00102439": "page", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00520-00102440-00102630": "and then search for the organization", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00521-00102631-00102775": "that you're interested in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00522-00102776-00102982": "and it will list what their tax forms", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00523-00102983-00103142": "are this is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00524-00103143-00103382": "um probably not going to give you much", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00525-00103383-00103551": "information about their strategy but it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00526-00103552-00103702": "does tell you about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00527-00103703-00103863": "their financials and you can compare", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00528-00103864-00104006": "them year by year", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00529-00104007-00104247": "um and who some of their leadership is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00530-00104248-00104454": "so that's what that could be helpful for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00531-00104455-00104615": "in doing a little bit of an analysis on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00532-00104616-00104830": "the company and then finally", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00533-00104831-00105031": "the lola that was an interesting one to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00534-00105032-00105334": "try to track down you can see that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00535-00105335-00105534": "their business name is actually not the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00536-00105535-00105686": "lola this is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00537-00105688-00106063": "the um ceo this is who registered the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00538-00106064-00106127": "company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00539-00106128-00106271": "almost everything will be registered", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00540-00106272-00106454": "with the state so if you do want to just", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00541-00106455-00106566": "verify", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00542-00106567-00106783": "that something exists and when it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00543-00106783-00106878": "existed", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00544-00106879-00107095": "when it was when it began you can go to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00545-00107096-00107223": "business search on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00546-00107224-00107599": "the um georgia corporations division", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00547-00107600-00107639": "page", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00548-00107640-00107783": "each state it will be called something a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00549-00107783-00107966": "little bit different but each", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00550-00107967-00108086": "state should have something where you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00551-00108088-00108223": "can search for businesses that are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00552-00108224-00108327": "registered", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00553-00108328-00108647": "and i think um for this one i had to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00554-00108648-00108854": "a little research and identify", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00555-00108855-00109231": "that the officer was eileen lee", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00556-00109232-00109527": "and that's what led me to this business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00557-00109528-00109631": "name", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00558-00109632-00110007": "um which enabled me to see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00559-00110008-00110231": "at least when the where it was", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00560-00110232-00110327": "registered", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00561-00110328-00110447": "so this is the address that it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00562-00110448-00110599": "registered at it's a different address", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00563-00110600-00110683": "than", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00564-00110683-00110999": "um where it's actually located and the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00565-00111000-00111166": "date that it formed that can be very", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00566-00111167-00111254": "helpful too", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00567-00111255-00111463": "and this tells you if it's a current um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00568-00111464-00111702": "company so those are just a few things", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00569-00111703-00111823": "that you can do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00570-00111824-00112047": "to just learn some basics about the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00571-00112048-00112310": "company uh really quickly", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00572-00112311-00112623": "um and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00573-00112624-00112943": "let me pause for just a second and see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00574-00112944-00113343": "if anybody has all right so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00575-00113344-00113543": "let's take a look a little bit deeper at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00576-00113544-00113663": "our company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00577-00113664-00114078": "annual report the things that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00578-00114079-00114310": "i just reviewed showed you where to find", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00579-00114311-00114463": "the annual report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00580-00114464-00114590": "this slide will tell you a little bit", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00581-00114591-00114775": "about what you might find for those", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00582-00114776-00115023": "things we looked at edgar we looked at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00583-00115024-00115302": "the who are we section of the websites", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00584-00115303-00115495": "um the irs filings", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00585-00115496-00115734": "and looking at the business registration", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00586-00115735-00115831": "forms", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00587-00115832-00116007": "so we can see that there's a a wide", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00588-00116008-00116207": "variance in the type of information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00589-00116208-00116471": "let's start with a t looking at their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00590-00116472-00116607": "annual report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00591-00116608-00116983": "so versus the public filing so you can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00592-00116983-00117166": "unfortunately this is really small but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00593-00117167-00117343": "the first thing that you notice", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00594-00117344-00117534": "between the annual report and the public", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00595-00117535-00117766": "filing this their 10k", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00596-00117767-00117990": "is that one is extremely pretty and the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00597-00117991-00118071": "other one", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00598-00118072-00118502": "is not so um both of them have the same", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00599-00118503-00118686": "value of information though", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00600-00118688-00118910": "in fact the pretty one is probably going", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00601-00118911-00119086": "to be a little", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00602-00119088-00119319": "more misleading than just going straight", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00603-00119320-00119447": "into the 10k", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00604-00119448-00119654": "many companies though are already going", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00605-00119655-00119847": "ahead and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00606-00119848-00120143": "doing for instance what at t does their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00607-00120144-00120334": "pretty part is just their chairman's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00608-00120335-00120390": "letter", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00609-00120391-00120647": "which traditionally i've always told", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00610-00120648-00120710": "people", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00611-00120711-00120910": "start when you go to the annual report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00612-00120911-00121071": "start with the chairman's letter", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00613-00121072-00121319": "to me the chairman's letter tells you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00614-00121320-00121502": "for that year what were they proud of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00615-00121503-00121607": "they're going to highlight what they", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00616-00121608-00121790": "were proud of and what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00617-00121791-00122151": "needed to what they accomplished", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00618-00122152-00122334": "what where they felt like they had some", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00619-00122335-00122510": "errors", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00620-00122511-00122639": "you're not going to really find that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00621-00122640-00122854": "here in the 10k so that's one of the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00622-00122855-00123054": "values of going to the annual report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00623-00123055-00123358": "sometimes the 10k will contain that but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00624-00123359-00123447": "it does have its own", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00625-00123448-00123623": "elements that we can look at that would", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00626-00123624-00123783": "be useful for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00627-00123783-00123951": "getting their perspective of how well", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00628-00123952-00124143": "they're doing so let's look at the next", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00629-00124144-00124223": "slide", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00630-00124224-00124471": "um this is the for the non-profit", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00631-00124472-00124623": "organization", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00632-00124624-00124975": "their annual report versus their um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00633-00124976-00125295": "990 the form that they file with the irs", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00634-00125296-00125510": "when we go into the public filing for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00635-00125511-00125623": "the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00636-00125624-00125951": "uh public company we'll see that there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00637-00125952-00126110": "is a lot of depth there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00638-00126111-00126375": "this 990 has very little information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00639-00126376-00126519": "that it's going to share with you aside", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00640-00126520-00126654": "from being able to see current year", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00641-00126655-00126751": "finances", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00642-00126752-00126990": "and past year finances you'll be able to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00643-00126991-00127134": "verify locations", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00644-00127135-00127351": "and if you evaluate year after year of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00645-00127352-00127495": "them you can see some", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00646-00127496-00127710": "changes it'll also highlight who's on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00647-00127711-00127934": "their boards so if you're evaluating", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00648-00127935-00128263": "um diversity on their board or who is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00649-00128264-00128510": "on their board who's representing this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00650-00128511-00128647": "officers you'll probably find that in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00651-00128648-00128758": "the 990.", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00652-00128759-00129071": "so these are filed and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00653-00129072-00129399": "evaluated by foundations so they do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00654-00129400-00129478": "contain", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00655-00129479-00129678": "really important information but for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00656-00129679-00129823": "people who are just trying to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00657-00129824-00129990": "get a glimpse and understand the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00658-00129991-00130143": "strategy of the company which is what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00659-00130144-00130302": "most people are trying to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00660-00130303-00130519": "it doesn't provide as much insight there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00661-00130520-00130663": "you're going to get a letter like this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00662-00130664-00130799": "usually at the beginning of an annual", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00663-00130800-00130919": "report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00664-00130920-00131335": "from their chair person or their ceo", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00665-00131336-00131502": "and it will highlight what they feel", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00666-00131503-00131671": "like is important", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00667-00131672-00131847": "and then usually nonprofits will", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00668-00131848-00132102": "highlight uh program successes so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00669-00132103-00132319": "i always think about programs being", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00670-00132320-00132439": "again their products", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00671-00132440-00132575": "what what is it they're selling they're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00672-00132576-00132775": "selling services um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00673-00132776-00132951": "who are their customers their clients", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00674-00132952-00133087": "are their customers", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00675-00133088-00133263": "um and so what products are they", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00676-00133264-00133407": "offering to their uh", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00677-00133408-00133614": "clients that's what i'm usually looking", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00678-00133615-00133814": "in there for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00679-00133815-00133951": "so if we're looking into that annual", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00680-00133952-00134159": "report this is again the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00681-00134160-00134431": "annual report for at t remember that's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00682-00134432-00134599": "different than the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00683-00134600-00134887": "uh 10k and this is what we're seeing is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00684-00134888-00135007": "this is um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00685-00135008-00135183": "it starts off with this chairman's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00686-00135184-00135319": "letter that they've done in a really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00687-00135320-00135454": "dazzling looking form", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00688-00135455-00135559": "where they're talking about their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00689-00135560-00135847": "purpose and their market focus", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00690-00135848-00135966": "notice that they're not using the word", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00691-00135967-00136199": "strategy again you'll see hear me talk", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00692-00136200-00136366": "about it all the time because i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00693-00136367-00136575": "the big thing that stumps people who are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00694-00136576-00136702": "trying to help people with business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00695-00136703-00136814": "information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00696-00136815-00137014": "in libraries is they're like i don't", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00697-00137015-00137214": "know they came up and they said", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00698-00137215-00137439": "um they were looking for the strategy of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00699-00137440-00137519": "the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00700-00137520-00137863": "well the strategy um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00701-00137864-00138031": "can be interpreted as several different", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00702-00138032-00138231": "things and also they're usually not", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00703-00138232-00138327": "going to be just like", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00704-00138328-00138463": "blanketly open with that they're going", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00705-00138464-00138607": "to tell you their values through their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00706-00138608-00138751": "mission statement but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00707-00138752-00138999": "um what their strategy is that's really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00708-00139000-00139190": "proprietary how they go about doing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00709-00139191-00139278": "something", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00710-00139279-00139487": "and what their strategic mix is is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00711-00139488-00139671": "really proprietary and they don't really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00712-00139672-00139831": "want to reveal too much about it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00713-00139832-00140078": "but this can give you some ideas and so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00714-00140079-00140159": "we're seeing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00715-00140160-00140359": "three things that they're listing as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00716-00140360-00140566": "what they're focused on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00717-00140567-00140902": "to achieve their goals um also what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00718-00140903-00140959": "we're seeing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00719-00140960-00141151": "in there is they're highlighting", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00720-00141152-00141278": "important things they like", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00721-00141279-00141431": "so their achievements their strengths", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00722-00141432-00141639": "their values remember this is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00723-00141640-00141847": "them telling us all the great things and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00724-00141848-00142063": "why we should invest in them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00725-00142064-00142399": "now they're 10k um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00726-00142400-00142719": "what we can look for in there is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00727-00142720-00142863": "i always go to the management", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00728-00142864-00143071": "discussions section look at how", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00729-00143072-00143399": "text heavy this is it's not that pretty", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00730-00143400-00143566": "in fact actually this is the prettier", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00731-00143567-00143751": "version of it they have a much uglier", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00732-00143752-00143854": "version of this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00733-00143855-00144007": "but i tried to pull out some of the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00734-00144008-00144190": "sections that you'll see and aren't", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00735-00144191-00144278": "these exciting", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00736-00144279-00144526": "for doing an analysis of a company first", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00737-00144527-00144647": "we got their overview of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00738-00144648-00144854": "how the company is kind of defined and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00739-00144855-00145014": "what their revenues are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00740-00145015-00145359": "but learning about trends in the market", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00741-00145360-00145535": "and how they fit into that market", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00742-00145536-00145743": "looking at how regulation is affecting", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00743-00145744-00145943": "them their expected growth areas", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00744-00145944-00146023": "competition", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00745-00146024-00146207": "and risk factors these are things that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00746-00146208-00146326": "are almost annual", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00747-00146327-00146647": "in the 10k so again you could take", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00748-00146648-00146919": "um i've been a business librarian for a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00749-00146920-00147078": "while so the example i used to always", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00750-00147079-00147239": "give was 911", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00751-00147240-00147478": "when that happened and if you were to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00752-00147479-00147647": "look into the five years", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00753-00147648-00147887": "um like let's say the middle is 911 you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00754-00147888-00148023": "look at the two years before that you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00755-00148024-00148223": "looked two years after that at delta", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00756-00148224-00148366": "airlines", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00757-00148367-00148526": "and you look at their annual reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00758-00148527-00148654": "you're going to see a dramatic change in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00759-00148655-00148814": "how the business operated", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00760-00148815-00149063": "and it shows a lot of strategy so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00761-00149064-00149254": "looking at multiple annual reports over", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00762-00149255-00149414": "the course of a few years", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00763-00149415-00149607": "can give you some unique insights it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00764-00149608-00149823": "about doing the legwork", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00765-00149824-00149999": "because these things are usually fairly", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00766-00150000-00150183": "consistent and you're looking for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00767-00150184-00150487": "some changes in them so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00768-00150488-00150799": "that is what i would recommend um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00769-00150800-00151119": "in terms of the annual reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00770-00151120-00151326": "um what i would look for we're going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00771-00151327-00151607": "go into third party analysis in just a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00772-00151608-00151790": "moment but i'm going to pause this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00773-00151791-00151959": "recording for just a moment to see if", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00774-00151960-00152031": "there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00775-00152032-00152399": "are any questions all right so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00776-00152400-00152614": "we finished up a little bit of q a there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00777-00152615-00152839": "for our brief pause and we're about to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00778-00152840-00152990": "go into third party analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00779-00152991-00153183": "but one of the questions or comments", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00780-00153184-00153335": "that was actually made during our", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00781-00153336-00153439": "discussion", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00782-00153440-00153751": "was that students who are in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00783-00153752-00153919": "bridge for business a program here at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00784-00153920-00154078": "agnes scott that is done during the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00785-00154079-00154143": "summer", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00786-00154144-00154463": "where students are gaining business uh", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00787-00154464-00154799": "skills they end up using the 10ks to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00788-00154800-00155102": "a thorough analysis of the company so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00789-00155103-00155287": "this is definitely a skill set that is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00790-00155288-00155535": "highly valued in terms of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00791-00155536-00155911": "doing an analysis of companies um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00792-00155912-00156278": "so the the annual report and the 10k", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00793-00156279-00156495": "the company has a lot of a lot of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00794-00156496-00156590": "control over that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00795-00156591-00156759": "but what we're looking for usually to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00796-00156760-00156911": "complement that is a third-party", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00797-00156912-00156999": "analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00798-00157000-00157183": "and for me that's either market research", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00799-00157184-00157414": "reports or company profiles", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00800-00157415-00157583": "i'm not as detailed in these next slides", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00801-00157584-00157726": "but these are the tools that we have", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00802-00157727-00158007": "access to and that i use most frequently", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00803-00158008-00158214": "for this these are not the only ones", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00804-00158215-00158439": "so depending on what library you're at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00805-00158440-00158590": "if you're here at agnes scott", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00806-00158591-00158751": "these are going to be the two that are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00807-00158752-00158911": "best for company research we do have", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00808-00158912-00159135": "some other things that are out there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00809-00159136-00159407": "that might be useful to you but i didn't", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00810-00159408-00159575": "want to do a super big long list", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00811-00159576-00159911": "of things and then there's fee based", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00812-00159912-00159983": "tools", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00813-00159984-00160351": "and uh some charity navigating ones so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00814-00160352-00160526": "let me quickly go in i'm gonna open this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00815-00160527-00160711": "link here if you were on the library", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00816-00160712-00160783": "homepage", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00817-00160784-00161014": "you would be accessing this from the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00818-00161015-00161175": "list of databases it's called business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00819-00161176-00161287": "source complete", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00820-00161288-00161502": "and this contains a lot of different", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00821-00161503-00161663": "things we'll be coming back to it for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00822-00161664-00161975": "news but i'm going to search for at t", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00823-00161976-00162199": "and i think i was shooting myself in the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00824-00162200-00162326": "foot a little bit when i was searching", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00825-00162327-00162414": "for att", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00826-00162415-00162566": "because it's so hard to try to figure", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00827-00162567-00162814": "out how to write that name out", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00828-00162815-00162935": "there's so many different ways that it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00829-00162936-00163119": "could be searched so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00830-00163120-00163263": "the first thing i'm going to do when i'm", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00831-00163264-00163535": "doing this search is i'm probably", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00832-00163536-00163854": "hoping that it is going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00833-00163855-00164175": "guide me in some way to a list of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00834-00164176-00164263": "company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00835-00164264-00164511": "a list of results that i can then narrow", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00836-00164512-00164663": "it down to att", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00837-00164664-00164935": "so it's taken a minute to get to that um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00838-00164936-00164983": "while", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00839-00164984-00165126": "we're waiting for that to open up i'm", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00840-00165127-00165263": "just going to go ahead and open up a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00841-00165264-00165366": "couple of these other", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00842-00165367-00165678": "databases so that we can talk about them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00843-00165679-00165983": "in just a moment", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00844-00165984-00166278": "so here we are it's still working on a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00845-00166279-00166631": "tnt", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00846-00166632-00166943": "oh my goodness", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00847-00166944-00167078": "all right so while we're doing that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00848-00167079-00167431": "we'll wait and we'll go to um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00849-00167432-00167638": "i should just be patient we're gonna be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00850-00167639-00167831": "patient", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00851-00167832-00168671": "everybody take a sip of their water", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00852-00168672-00168959": "there we go okay so you can see that my", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00853-00168960-00169038": "search", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00854-00169039-00169326": "brought up a lot of random results um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00855-00169327-00169383": "but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00856-00169384-00169551": "one of the things i can do to narrow is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00857-00169552-00169702": "over here it says company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00858-00169703-00169887": "i can filter and you can see that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00859-00169888-00170054": "there's a couple of different options", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00860-00170055-00170414": "remember we talked about it before that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00861-00170415-00170566": "companies change names so that's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00862-00170567-00170702": "probably why it's listed differently", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00863-00170703-00170766": "there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00864-00170767-00171038": "if i click on show more it enables me to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00865-00171039-00171190": "be able to click on both of these rather", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00866-00171191-00171311": "than just one if i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00867-00171312-00171511": "hadn't done show more it would have", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00868-00171512-00171623": "narrowed it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00869-00171624-00171926": "down to just that one so now i can see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00870-00171927-00172151": "the types of information that is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00871-00172152-00172335": "available and you can see that that swot", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00872-00172336-00172399": "analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00873-00172400-00172590": "is right up here at the top it's a very", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00874-00172591-00172726": "current one that just happened two", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00875-00172727-00172831": "months ago", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00876-00172832-00173087": "but if that wasn't the top item in the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00877-00173088-00173287": "results i could go over here to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00878-00173288-00173623": "source types and i can scroll down", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00879-00173624-00173863": "and identify the type of information i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00880-00173864-00174014": "need you can see there's also industry", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00881-00174015-00174175": "reports here in market research reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00882-00174176-00174319": "so i might be interested in those as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00883-00174320-00174431": "well", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00884-00174432-00174526": "i'm just going to narrow it down to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00885-00174527-00174887": "these swot analysis and again you can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00886-00174888-00175023": "choose to do a couple of them if you're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00887-00175024-00175175": "doing really in-depth research to see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00888-00175176-00175302": "how things have changed over the course", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00889-00175303-00175383": "of time", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00890-00175384-00175599": "i would say that just the difference", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00891-00175600-00175695": "between these two", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00892-00175696-00175951": "is not going to be super great but it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00893-00175952-00176014": "might", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00894-00176015-00176247": "so if we go into this pdf you'll see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00895-00176248-00176383": "what that looks like", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00896-00176384-00176590": "this is frequently an assignment that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00897-00176591-00176759": "students are required to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00898-00176760-00177014": "i would not if you are ever asked to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00899-00177015-00177231": "a swot analysis i would not come in here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00900-00177232-00177454": "and then just take what information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00901-00177455-00177575": "because this is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00902-00177576-00177751": "what this company market line has", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00903-00177752-00177902": "designed", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00904-00177903-00178135": "every company can do their own analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00905-00178136-00178326": "you can do your own analysis this is not", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00906-00178327-00178423": "set in stone", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00907-00178424-00178647": "this is not universally thought oh yes", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00908-00178648-00178831": "their strength is subscriber base", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00909-00178832-00179119": "that's an argument um and they give you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00910-00179120-00179183": "the reason", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00911-00179184-00179495": "why that's their argument down here um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00912-00179496-00179687": "what are their threats currency", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00913-00179688-00179854": "fluctuations they'll give you more", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00914-00179855-00180031": "descriptions about that down here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00915-00180032-00180207": "and why that's a threat but again it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00916-00180208-00180366": "an argument so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00917-00180367-00180583": "if you are asked to do a swot analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00918-00180584-00180759": "go ahead and do the swot analysis and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00919-00180760-00180959": "you can use this for inspiration", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00920-00180960-00181335": "but if you're not doing a swot analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00921-00181336-00181502": "for class and you're just kind of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00922-00181503-00181654": "getting prepped for your interview", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00923-00181655-00181766": "you can see that this is a pretty", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00924-00181767-00181983": "awesome way to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00925-00181984-00182166": "quickly understand what you might want", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00926-00182167-00182375": "to focus in on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00927-00182376-00182511": "so that's one of the things that we can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00928-00182512-00182671": "see and again that's probably going to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00929-00182672-00182807": "be just for public companies if we", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00930-00182808-00182911": "search for the lola", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00931-00182912-00183143": "or the non-profit organization we're not", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00932-00183144-00183359": "going to find anything like that there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00933-00183360-00183663": "so that's what we can use for business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00934-00183664-00183831": "source complete for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00935-00183832-00184047": "business market research collection also", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00936-00184048-00184159": "has some", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00937-00184160-00184302": "in there and i particularly like the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00938-00184303-00184463": "hoover's company reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00939-00184464-00184671": "this is going to be a very brief basic", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00940-00184672-00184854": "profile usually what i like in there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00941-00184855-00185102": "is just their competitors list um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00942-00185103-00185238": "because sometimes when i'm doing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00943-00185239-00185471": "research on a company i like to also do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00944-00185472-00185647": "the same kind of research on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00945-00185648-00185975": "their top competitors um and so i might", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00946-00185976-00186087": "look at the annual reports of their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00947-00186088-00186223": "competitors because that shows me", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00948-00186224-00186407": "a different way that they do business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00949-00186408-00186814": "and how you could", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00950-00186815-00187207": "compare practices and imagine going into", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00951-00187208-00187511": "an interview and saying so um i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00952-00187512-00187631": "understand that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00953-00187632-00187863": "so-and-so does things this way have you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00954-00187864-00188078": "guys ever considered doing it that way", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00955-00188079-00188326": "um that shows so much insight into the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00956-00188327-00188399": "industry", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00957-00188400-00188583": "and can be super impressive so that's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00958-00188584-00188775": "why i do that it helps you see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00959-00188776-00189126": "um how they compare to others um and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00960-00189127-00189263": "the reason why hoover's is great for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00961-00189264-00189454": "that is because just like", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00962-00189455-00189759": "the swot analysis how", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00963-00189760-00190102": "the industry is defined can be um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00964-00190103-00190463": "up to the individual person who's doing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00965-00190464-00190550": "the analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00966-00190551-00190759": "and i love the competitor list that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00967-00190760-00190902": "hoover's creates", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00968-00190903-00191166": "it's again not definitive but if you're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00969-00191167-00191495": "looking at sony", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00970-00191496-00191742": "you can be able to see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00971-00191743-00191911": "[Music]", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00972-00191912-00192102": "whether it's competitors are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00973-00192103-00192231": "predominantly", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00974-00192232-00192550": "tv oriented or whether they're game", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00975-00192551-00192638": "oriented", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00976-00192639-00192878": "and what those industries are also", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00977-00192879-00193038": "hoover's has some private company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00978-00193039-00193111": "profiles", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00979-00193112-00193350": "for ones that are not publicly traded so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00980-00193351-00193759": "that's why i like that as well", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00981-00193760-00194023": "the fee based ones believe it or not if", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00982-00194024-00194175": "we go to market research", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00983-00194176-00194583": "dot com and and we were to search for at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00984-00194584-00194943": "t this is again not going to cover", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00985-00194944-00195143": "things like the lola or our center for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00986-00195144-00195271": "pan asian studies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00987-00195272-00195407": "those are just things that we're going", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00988-00195408-00195614": "to have to give up but do you see that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00989-00195615-00195775": "slot analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00990-00195776-00195966": "um this is the more recent one just by", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00991-00195967-00196214": "one month 170", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00992-00196215-00196438": "dollars it's the same thing that you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00993-00196439-00196559": "just saw", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00994-00196560-00196743": "that's how much that is and that's cheap", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00995-00196744-00196871": "that's the cheapest you're gonna get", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00996-00196872-00197054": "business information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00997-00197055-00197383": "but um if you are interested in learning", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00998-00197384-00197719": "more about um so these are the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-00999-00197720-00197847": "reports", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01000-00197848-00198063": "um you can see that you can narrow to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01001-00198064-00198214": "more industry oriented", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01002-00198215-00198590": "so if we're interested in um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01003-00198591-00198878": "gosh uh i should have come up with a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01004-00198879-00199038": "search for this one well you can see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01005-00199039-00199111": "here they're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01006-00199112-00199526": "showing um sports sponsorship", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01007-00199527-00199783": "and covid these are all also these are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01008-00199784-00199911": "if you like business research", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01009-00199912-00200047": "these are all companies you could try to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01010-00200048-00200319": "work for so they want business research", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01011-00200320-00200519": "skills and so just look for these names", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01012-00200520-00200647": "of these companies and go to their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01013-00200648-00200838": "websites and find out whether", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01014-00200839-00201102": "um they're offering a job but this is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01015-00201103-00201231": "another place that you can go", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01016-00201232-00201495": "what we would do in the business that i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01017-00201496-00201550": "worked at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01018-00201551-00201735": "is if i was interested in this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01019-00201736-00201919": "particular report", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01020-00201920-00202231": "right here the sports sponsorship you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01021-00202232-00202311": "could", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01022-00202312-00202511": "look for the table of contents and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01023-00202512-00202671": "usually you can buy", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01024-00202672-00202950": "individual pages so and if we go to the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01025-00202951-00203102": "table of contents here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01026-00203103-00203431": "we can see what their sections are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01027-00203432-00203807": "and there were usually opportunities to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01028-00203808-00204150": "buy a page not knowing what else is on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01029-00204151-00204199": "there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01030-00204200-00204383": "spend about seven dollars just for that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01031-00204384-00204535": "page so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01032-00204536-00204678": "so that's another thing about business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01033-00204679-00204886": "information out there um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01034-00204887-00205023": "and there's lots of different companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01035-00205023-00205182": "out there so it's just getting familiar", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01036-00205183-00205303": "with those names", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01037-00205304-00205510": "and this is the one that i like to go to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01038-00205511-00205614": "initially", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01039-00205615-00205879": "but some of each industry has their core", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01040-00205880-00206086": "ones and if you are doing a news search", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01041-00206087-00206286": "you'll usually hear these market", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01042-00206287-00206462": "research reports cited in there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01043-00206463-00206719": "so they'll say according to euromonitor", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01044-00206719-00206990": "the market share of this company is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01045-00206991-00207127": "so it reveals a little bit about that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01046-00207128-00207375": "but it also tells you who covers them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01047-00207376-00207646": "and that can be useful has anybody ever", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01048-00207648-00207942": "used charity navigator or guide star", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01049-00207944-00208271": "these are great um for doing an analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01050-00208271-00208327": "of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01051-00208328-00208598": "charities i don't know if i have a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01052-00208600-00208846": "preference over which one but if we do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01053-00208848-00209031": "center for pan asian studies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01054-00209032-00209271": "sorry not studies pan asian community", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01055-00209271-00209606": "services", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01056-00209607-00210023": "um i think guidestar is the one that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01057-00210023-00210310": "they go and they ask questions of the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01058-00210311-00210415": "company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01059-00210416-00210646": "um they ask them to answer some things", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01060-00210648-00210815": "so here they're listing out what the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01061-00210816-00210991": "services are that makes it really easy", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01062-00210992-00211215": "remember this is what i call their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01063-00211216-00211351": "products", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01064-00211352-00211503": "their products are counseling senior", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01065-00211504-00211727": "services housing and what they're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01066-00211728-00211967": "offering in each of them so that's a way", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01067-00211967-00212094": "to think about that and then they're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01068-00212096-00212246": "asking these questions what's the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01069-00212248-00212439": "organization aiming to accomplish", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01070-00212440-00212623": "what are their key strategies so far for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01071-00212623-00212806": "making this happen", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01072-00212807-00212903": "you might be able to find this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01073-00212904-00213110": "information someplace else but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01074-00213111-00213358": "often this is a unique response and it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01075-00213359-00213503": "can be a little bit out of date but", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01076-00213504-00213575": "we're just", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01077-00213576-00213758": "doing what we can with the information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01078-00213759-00213887": "that we can find", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01079-00213888-00214142": "even if uh it's out of date it's gonna", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01080-00214144-00214294": "give us at least the starting point to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01081-00214296-00214551": "ask some questions from", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01082-00214552-00214815": "and then charity navigator they do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01083-00214816-00214982": "similar things", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01084-00214983-00215255": "um i don't i think they might have a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01085-00215256-00215342": "different", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01086-00215344-00215694": "set of questions so here if we go to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01087-00215696-00215903": "center for pan asian community center", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01088-00215904-00216087": "oh yeah they're doing a rating system", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01089-00216088-00216239": "which is interesting", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01090-00216240-00216510": "looking at kind of how they score in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01091-00216511-00216575": "terms of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01092-00216576-00216863": "meeting certain requirements this is you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01093-00216864-00216991": "trying to decide if you want to give", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01094-00216992-00217134": "them money but it also helps you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01095-00217135-00217294": "understand a lot more about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01096-00217296-00217606": "um how well they're doing as an entity", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01097-00217607-00217934": "um and again more questions to ask so i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01098-00217935-00218031": "love these two", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01099-00218032-00218279": "both of them provide access to the 10", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01100-00218280-00218446": "the 990 forum", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01101-00218448-00218623": "so it's another way to get access to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01102-00218623-00218839": "that i have created an account you do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01103-00218840-00218887": "have to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01104-00218888-00219015": "create an account but you don't think", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01105-00219016-00219191": "you have to pay anything", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01106-00219192-00219606": "so those are those um uh", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01107-00219607-00220079": "kind of outside third party sources so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01108-00220080-00220431": "i'm going to pause and see if there is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01109-00220432-00220694": "any questions", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01110-00220696-00220919": "all right so now we've covered two", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01111-00220919-00221055": "different types of information we're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01112-00221056-00221255": "going to move into news coverage", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01113-00221256-00221534": "news coverage is my favorite to look", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01114-00221535-00221582": "through", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01115-00221583-00221879": "um and usually what i'll do is i'll do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01116-00221880-00221991": "um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01117-00221992-00222239": "the past year or two or even just six", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01118-00222240-00222310": "months", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01119-00222311-00222494": "looking at specific types of news", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01120-00222496-00222703": "coverage the databases that we're going", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01121-00222704-00222798": "to use for these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01122-00222800-00222951": "would be that business source complete", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01123-00222952-00223119": "and avim form when you're looking for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01124-00223119-00223255": "the business news", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01125-00223256-00223494": "and then you might end up using news and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01126-00223496-00223623": "newspapers or", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01127-00223623-00223951": "access world news um at this level", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01128-00223952-00224151": "being able to access news coverage is a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01129-00224152-00224294": "privilege", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01130-00224296-00224439": "even though there's a lot of things that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01131-00224440-00224694": "are available out there for free on", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01132-00224696-00224967": "the web people who are professionally", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01133-00224967-00225119": "trying to do research for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01134-00225119-00225303": "news are going to run into a lot of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01135-00225304-00225558": "paywalls so if you are associated with a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01136-00225559-00225623": "library", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01137-00225623-00225903": "it's useful to get to know the news", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01138-00225904-00226110": "sources that they have access to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01139-00226111-00226391": "um and to be able to manipulate that uh", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01140-00226392-00226655": "professional organizations will provide", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01141-00226656-00226887": "their end users that's who their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01142-00226888-00227023": "employees would be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01143-00227023-00227223": "with uh certain products usually it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01144-00227223-00227327": "not going to be these it's going to be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01145-00227328-00227558": "something like bacteva or a lexus nexus", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01146-00227559-00227719": "and that will cover all these different", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01147-00227719-00227887": "types of publications and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01148-00227888-00228063": "having that research skill is really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01149-00228064-00228282": "helpful to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01150-00228283-00228519": "um performing as", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01151-00228519-00228815": "a employee in those companies so the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01152-00228816-00228855": "three", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01153-00228856-00228991": "the four different types of news that i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01154-00228992-00229158": "would be looking at we're predominantly", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01155-00229159-00229319": "going to look at business news and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01156-00229319-00229439": "industry news", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01157-00229440-00229751": "but you should also consider how your", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01158-00229752-00229798": "company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01159-00229800-00230006": "is being portrayed in the national news", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01160-00230007-00230206": "and by national news we usually", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01161-00230207-00230358": "are always looking at new york times and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01162-00230359-00230606": "washington post a lot of the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01163-00230607-00230919": "national papers for countries", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01164-00230919-00231087": "the guardian isn't just the only one for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01165-00231088-00231310": "the uk but it's a good one to go to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01166-00231311-00231551": "if you're wanting to get a perspective", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01167-00231552-00231710": "of your company from", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01168-00231711-00232023": "the uk's perspective la times is what", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01169-00232023-00232191": "a lot of professionals use to get the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01170-00232192-00232327": "west coast perspective", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01171-00232328-00232542": "and chicago tribune for the midwest", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01172-00232544-00232646": "perspective", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01173-00232648-00232894": "these are considered to some degree the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01174-00232896-00233046": "national papers", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01175-00233048-00233271": "now local news atlanta journal and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01176-00233271-00233439": "constitution boston globe even though", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01177-00233440-00233567": "they're large papers they would be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01178-00233567-00233663": "considered local", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01179-00233664-00233806": "the reason why you'd want to look at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01180-00233807-00234006": "local for your individual companies", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01181-00234007-00234334": "is because people love their hometown", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01182-00234335-00234423": "heroes so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01183-00234423-00234591": "we're always talking about delta here in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01184-00234592-00234823": "atlanta we're always talking about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01185-00234823-00235175": "ups we will be talking about them more", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01186-00235176-00235367": "than these national newspapers so if you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01187-00235367-00235503": "can think about where the company is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01188-00235504-00235591": "located", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01189-00235592-00235758": "then you can usually learn a lot more", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01190-00235759-00235951": "from their local paper so even if it's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01191-00235952-00236063": "in savannah", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01192-00236064-00236263": "look for the savannah paper and see how", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01193-00236264-00236423": "they're talking about that company and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01194-00236423-00236487": "look for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01195-00236488-00236687": "articles that were published within the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01196-00236688-00236919": "last year or at least", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01197-00236919-00237071": "probably not too much farther back than", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01198-00237071-00237319": "that um and then you can and so our", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01199-00237319-00237494": "databases news and newspapers is really", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01200-00237496-00237606": "useful for that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01201-00237607-00237846": "um i won't go into those right now", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01202-00237848-00238015": "they're like many of our other databases", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01203-00238016-00238167": "in terms of searching so if we just go", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01204-00238167-00238327": "into business course complete", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01205-00238328-00238446": "pretty much you'll have the same", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01206-00238448-00238663": "features that you can navigate in these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01207-00238664-00238879": "other databases", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01208-00238880-00239094": "business source complete and abi inform", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01209-00239096-00239239": "are the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01210-00239240-00239519": "top level business news sources that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01211-00239519-00239775": "allow you to get access to journals", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01212-00239776-00239967": "companies wish that they had access to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01213-00239967-00240206": "these usually", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01214-00240207-00240527": "and so it is beneficial if you go into a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01215-00240528-00240719": "company that doesn't have access to them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01216-00240719-00240855": "and they provided they've made the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01217-00240856-00241079": "decision to give you factiva instead", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01218-00241080-00241263": "and you want these then you could", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01219-00241264-00241423": "probably go to your public library and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01220-00241423-00241582": "see if their public library has it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01221-00241583-00241694": "usually they have business source", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01222-00241696-00241823": "complete", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01223-00241823-00242134": "or take a class at a college and then", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01224-00242135-00242327": "you'll have access to some of their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01225-00242328-00242527": "core tools so that's another trick for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01226-00242528-00242671": "getting business information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01227-00242671-00242910": "once you're outside of this environment", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01228-00242911-00243079": "but what we're looking for there is the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01229-00243080-00243287": "main newspaper wall street journal", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01230-00243288-00243679": "that's like the bible for business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01231-00243680-00243871": "anything that's meaningful will be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01232-00243871-00243991": "mentioned there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01233-00243992-00244158": "um to some degree you're going to get", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01234-00244159-00244351": "some interesting articles about the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01235-00244352-00244551": "companies in forbes fortune in business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01236-00244552-00244655": "week and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01237-00244656-00244855": "things like fast company when you're", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01238-00244856-00245079": "searching these though you have to be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01239-00245080-00245342": "careful about the number of articles", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01240-00245344-00245479": "that are just going to be one-fourth of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01241-00245480-00245567": "a page", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01242-00245567-00245751": "you can get really bogged down so let's", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01243-00245752-00245910": "go ahead and i'm going to close a few", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01244-00245911-00246006": "things real quick", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01245-00246007-00246334": "we're going to go back to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01246-00246335-00246710": "our business course complete search when", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01247-00246711-00246798": "we were doing a t", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01248-00246800-00247103": "and t and we're going to take away", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01249-00247104-00247406": "narrowing it from swot analysis", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01250-00247407-00247582": "and we're going to narrow our date range", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01251-00247583-00247758": "here this is what we can do in almost", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01252-00247759-00247887": "all databases we're going to narrow this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01253-00247888-00248015": "date range to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01254-00248016-00248215": "pretty much the last year you can see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01255-00248216-00248358": "that i'm doing that on the left hand", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01256-00248359-00248487": "side there", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01257-00248488-00248694": "and we're going to narrow it by types of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01258-00248696-00248791": "publications", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01259-00248792-00248958": "we could narrow it by academic journals", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01260-00248959-00249142": "but really academic journals don't help", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01261-00249144-00249239": "us quite as much", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01262-00249240-00249567": "as magazines and news sources", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01263-00249567-00249791": "so i'm going to do magazines and i'm", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01264-00249792-00249887": "also going to do", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01265-00249888-00250263": "trade publications so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01266-00250264-00250663": "trade publications are going to be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01267-00250664-00250910": "these industry publications look at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01268-00250911-00251110": "these names would you ever subscribe to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01269-00251111-00251191": "any of these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01270-00251192-00251367": "maybe you're thinking women's where", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01271-00251367-00251575": "daily if you like fashion", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01272-00251576-00251758": "but really this is all about business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01273-00251759-00251951": "this is what it takes to run a business", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01274-00251952-00252206": "in one of these industries and so you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01275-00252207-00252358": "usually want to find whatever their", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01276-00252359-00252479": "trade publication is", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01277-00252480-00252703": "and look into that in addition to these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01278-00252704-00252798": "business news", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01279-00252800-00253103": "sources and so by narrowing this down we", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01280-00253104-00253158": "can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01281-00253159-00253455": "see that we've created a list of some of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01282-00253456-00253606": "the core things that are being talked", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01283-00253607-00253742": "about for this year", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01284-00253744-00253975": "i'm going to go ahead and do page", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01285-00253976-00254071": "options", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01286-00254071-00254263": "again i do this in almost all of them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01287-00254264-00254463": "i'm going to put 50 on a page here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01288-00254464-00254767": "because if i do 50 on a page", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01289-00254767-00255030": "i can get through 432 articles pretty", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01290-00255031-00255127": "quick", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01291-00255128-00255367": "just skimming the headlines and seeing", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01292-00255367-00255534": "just giving the headlines and marking", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01293-00255535-00255687": "them", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01294-00255688-00255846": "of things that look interesting to me", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01295-00255848-00256063": "will help me start understanding", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01296-00256064-00256230": "what's in the news related to this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01297-00256231-00256398": "company you can always", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01298-00256400-00256710": "resort your", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01299-00256711-00256991": "page to do the newest first you want to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01300-00256992-00257103": "see the latest stuff", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01301-00257104-00257310": "or if you want to see how a situation", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01302-00257311-00257534": "evolved you can do the oldest first so", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01303-00257535-00257639": "you can see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01304-00257640-00257775": "what does their year look like from", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01305-00257776-00257951": "beginning to end and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01306-00257952-00258223": "so we could go year by year so day by", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01307-00258223-00258398": "day month by month", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01308-00258400-00258575": "this is a large number and we don't", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01309-00258576-00258734": "really need to look at all of these", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01310-00258735-00258910": "especially since so many of them are", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01311-00258911-00259006": "going to be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01312-00259007-00259255": "short articles there's two things you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01313-00259256-00259439": "can do in this particular database", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01314-00259440-00259703": "one if we go to advanced search we can", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01315-00259704-00260006": "decide that we're going to search for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01316-00260007-00260279": "all things all articles that are greater", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01317-00260280-00260415": "than one page", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01318-00260416-00260671": "so we don't want those short snippets", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01319-00260671-00260734": "maybe", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01320-00260735-00260934": "maybe we want something in depth and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01321-00260935-00261079": "we're going to search for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01322-00261080-00261327": "just publications that are more than a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01323-00261328-00261382": "page", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01324-00261383-00261858": "we'll have to reset our date ranges", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01325-00261859-00262006": "again and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01326-00262007-00262191": "narrow down to the types of publications", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01327-00262192-00262343": "that we're interested in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01328-00262344-00262703": "but this is a way that we can um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01329-00262704-00263030": "narrow that focus", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01330-00263031-00263487": "wow there are really a lot that have um", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01331-00263488-00263703": "i must have done something weird oh i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01332-00263704-00263847": "know what it is we we're no longer", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01333-00263848-00263982": "narrowing it down to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01334-00263983-00264223": "um by company so i'm gonna use this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01335-00264224-00264430": "filter to narrow it to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01336-00264431-00264703": "company just as a quick thing so here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01337-00264704-00264910": "we're looking at one year of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01338-00264911-00265206": "uh things that mention the words at t in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01339-00265207-00265367": "the company entity", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01340-00265368-00265630": "um and so we're able to skim through and", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01341-00265631-00265767": "see if there's any valuable", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01342-00265768-00266223": "articles that would interest us here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01343-00266224-00266415": "and something else that you can do in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01344-00266416-00266599": "here is you can narrow by the name of", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01345-00266600-00266710": "the publication", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01346-00266711-00266879": "so if you want to see where it's being", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01347-00266880-00267079": "published you can click here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01348-00267080-00267351": "and then resort this and we should be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01349-00267352-00267439": "able to see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01350-00267440-00267663": "the names of the publications and things", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01351-00267664-00267815": "like bond buyer", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01352-00267816-00267927": "doesn't seem like it's going to be that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01353-00267928-00268063": "helpful to us but since we're looking at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01354-00268064-00268319": "broadcasting cable that looks helpful", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01355-00268320-00268479": "uh fortune that was one of the ones that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01356-00268480-00268743": "i was interested in", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01357-00268744-00269030": "as one of my main business ones might be", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01358-00269031-00269279": "intrigued by this hollywood reporter", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01359-00269280-00269463": "but overall those were the major ones", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01360-00269464-00269591": "that i wanted to look at", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01361-00269592-00269743": "and so that's another strategy that you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01362-00269744-00269895": "can use in terms of narrowing your", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01363-00269896-00270287": "searches to learn more about the company", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01364-00270288-00270567": "so that's pretty much it in terms of how", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01365-00270568-00270663": "i would go about", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01366-00270664-00270951": "doing searching um if you have any", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01367-00270952-00271047": "questions", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01368-00271048-00271430": "um you can oh sorry one other thing i", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01369-00271431-00271527": "wanted to show", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01370-00271528-00271927": "um is that uh", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01371-00271928-00272239": "let's go back so um these you can see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01372-00272240-00272279": "that", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01373-00272280-00272767": "for scale we created um company profiles", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01374-00272768-00273023": "for the students and i'm going to go", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01375-00273024-00273223": "ahead and put this into chat for those", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01376-00273224-00273367": "of you who are here", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01377-00273368-00273630": "so that you can see links to them this", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01378-00273631-00273791": "is only accessible for people", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01379-00273792-00274006": "in the agnes scott community but if you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01380-00274007-00274151": "want to see", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01381-00274152-00274471": "what all the sources can get you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01382-00274472-00274703": "in the extent of what would be maybe a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01383-00274704-00274895": "good profile to do if you're trying to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01384-00274896-00275006": "do an interview", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01385-00275007-00275199": "with a company this is how i would", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01386-00275200-00275358": "probably construct it", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01387-00275359-00275687": "um and so i shared with you some of the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01388-00275688-00275799": "options that we have", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01389-00275800-00276079": "for an example of how to do that so if", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01390-00276080-00276239": "you need additional help just email us", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01391-00276240-00276430": "at library agnesscott.edu", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01392-00276431-00276623": "i'm going to be your primary person for", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01393-00276624-00276847": "being able to find business information", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01394-00276848-00276991": "but anybody can help", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01395-00276992-00277158": "so just email us and they'll get you to", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01396-00277159-00277303": "the", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01397-00277304-00277519": "i'm right person sharing and thank you", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01398-00277520-00277623": "and have a", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01399-00277624-00277895": "great day i'm gonna end this recording", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01400-00277896-00277991": "now", "3YGFd7iz2aA-01401-00277992-00278328": "so let's see"}}, {"audio_id": "3YROjDxNPyI", "text": {"3YROjDxNPyI-00000-00000000-00000548": "is also impossible and foundation these", "3YROjDxNPyI-00001-00000549-00001079": "subsets is captured by the local", "3YROjDxNPyI-00002-00001080-00001453": "journalists community of what you are", "3YROjDxNPyI-00003-00001454-00001807": "concerning both towards the improved", "3YROjDxNPyI-00004-00001809-00002482": "sanitation situation sanitation s as", "3YROjDxNPyI-00005-00002483-00003098": "some low-cost simple the sanitation", "3YROjDxNPyI-00006-00003099-00003578": "technologies are infused into them by", "3YROjDxNPyI-00007-00003579-00003781": "the way are you using a microphone two", "3YROjDxNPyI-00008-00003782-00005054": "points or three point yeah yeah you PR", "3YROjDxNPyI-00009-00005055-00005452": "among other stakeholders become very", "3YROjDxNPyI-00010-00005453-00005813": "supportive as it as result of our", "3YROjDxNPyI-00011-00005814-00006256": "efforts to work then circulated some", "3YROjDxNPyI-00012-00006257-00006721": "instructions which orders towards the", "3YROjDxNPyI-00013-00006722-00007395": "concerns stabs or communities as well", "3YROjDxNPyI-00014-00007397-00007888": "support of six types of of the EP", "3YROjDxNPyI-00015-00007889-00008647": "established technologies as well are you", "3YROjDxNPyI-00016-00008648-00009227": "if not they will take the action as", "3YROjDxNPyI-00017-00009228-00009917": "their respected judge or it to join as", "3YROjDxNPyI-00018-00009918-00010120": "the technologies are", "3YROjDxNPyI-00019-00010121-00010669": "environment-friendly so it was accepted", "3YROjDxNPyI-00020-00010670-00011213": "and low cost some steps were taken to", "3YROjDxNPyI-00021-00011214-00011468": "towards conversion of non Senate", "3YROjDxNPyI-00022-00011469-00012068": "relating to Senator yawns so II results", "3YROjDxNPyI-00023-00012069-00012891": "was amplified some obstacles were pissed", "3YROjDxNPyI-00024-00012892-00013393": "as you everybody knows they're there", "3YROjDxNPyI-00025-00013394-00014005": "remains a long-term unexpected political", "3YROjDxNPyI-00026-00014006-00014521": "situation they are took place heavy and", "3YROjDxNPyI-00027-00014522-00015085": "Langley in poll last year you know", "3YROjDxNPyI-00028-00015086-00015536": "suitable points40 safe we are not", "3YROjDxNPyI-00029-00015537-00015965": "available as the inhabitants of the of", "3YROjDxNPyI-00030-00015966-00016275": "the of that community", "3YROjDxNPyI-00031-00016276-00016657": "widely consciousness they are not", "3YROjDxNPyI-00032-00016658-00017143": "willing to leave a pond for thinking per", "3YROjDxNPyI-00033-00017144-00017464": "person so he said could not be", "3YROjDxNPyI-00034-00017465-00017814": "established as respected as planting", "3YROjDxNPyI-00035-00017815-00018289": "prevalence of rocks at sub surface level", "3YROjDxNPyI-00036-00018290-00018733": "and razon you know so we could not do", "3YROjDxNPyI-00037-00018734-00019111": "stuff that you will get"}}, {"audio_id": "3Z36Xd1-zhy", "text": {"3Z36Xd1-zhy-00000-00002032-00003068": "[Music]", "3Z36Xd1-zhy-00001-00003069-00003806": "[Music]", "3Z36Xd1-zhy-00002-00003807-00005084": "phenomenon", "3Z36Xd1-zhy-00003-00005085-00005695": "[Music]", "3Z36Xd1-zhy-00004-00005696-00007511": "[__] phenomenon", "3Z36Xd1-zhy-00005-00007512-00008317": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3ZoT8rurb2Q", "text": {"3ZoT8rurb2Q-00000-00000013-00000663": "[Music]", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00001-00000664-00001100": "you fought well as did you forget what", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00002-00001101-00001345": "happened before we are alive because of", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00003-00001346-00002193": "you don't need to thank me make a case", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00004-00002194-00002450": "I'm just glad the people of honest are", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00005-00002451-00002717": "safe you may not want thanks but you", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00006-00002718-00002800": "deserve it", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00007-00002801-00003029": "I promised everything in the Treasury", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00008-00003030-00003226": "and that's what you're getting now I", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00009-00003227-00003481": "need to find my impersonator I can help", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00010-00003482-00003692": "I found this note on the pirate leader", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00011-00003693-00003977": "they owe him a lot of directly he was", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00012-00003978-00004178": "hired to sabotage the town making", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00013-00004179-00004424": "invasion easier the plan would've worked", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00014-00004425-00004679": "if the real Eagle bearer hadn't shown up", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00015-00004680-00005063": "what will you do when you find him don't", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00016-00005064-00007468": "think of something", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00017-00007469-00007870": "[Applause]", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00018-00007872-00008273": "the actual Eagle Bearer", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00019-00008274-00008656": "that explains why the invasion failed", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00020-00008657-00008866": "[Music]", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00021-00008867-00009131": "I've been stuck cleaning up your mess", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00022-00009132-00009645": "since I got here what a glorious mess it", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00023-00009646-00009992": "was when the Pirates paid me to soften", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00024-00009993-00010305": "the town's defences I didn't think it", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00025-00010306-00010566": "would be so easy people are dead because", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00026-00010567-00011089": "of you I didn't kill anyone but you did", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00027-00011090-00011538": "we make a great team that way I steal", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00028-00011539-00011852": "some tools or blow up an old man's Forge", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00029-00011853-00012128": "send some young idiot independent", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00030-00012129-00012541": "invested mountains lose a generals steed", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00031-00012542-00013153": "then watch you turn it into pure chaos", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00032-00013154-00013400": "the fact that make Ackley's and the", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00033-00013401-00013619": "Pirates both paid you is just a bonus", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00034-00013619-00014019": "everyone pays to hear lies they want to", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00035-00014019-00014541": "believe I'm impressed", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00036-00014541-00014750": "even I don't play both sides like that I", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00037-00014751-00015246": "can be even more impressive you never", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00038-00015247-00015525": "thought about it what it would be like", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00039-00015526-00015918": "to be with the Eagle Bearer you're not", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00040-00015919-00016311": "even a little curious", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00041-00016312-00016455": "[Music]", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00042-00016456-00016947": "time for justice me bring down on both", "3ZoT8rurb2Q-00043-00016948-00017190": "of us"}}, {"audio_id": "3ZpcJujsjp8", "text": {"3ZpcJujsjp8-00000-00000291-00000991": "[Music]", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00001-00000992-00001143": "hi everybody", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00002-00001144-00001295": "well my name is", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00003-00001296-00001566": "jesus gallardo and i'm an associate", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00004-00001567-00001775": "professor of theological physics", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00005-00001776-00001991": "at the university of aragosa", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00006-00001992-00002342": "and i'm all i i am also the director of", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00007-00002343-00002550": "the liberties foundation", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00008-00002551-00002758": "which is a spanish institution devoted", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00009-00002759-00003047": "to the promotion of digital science", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00010-00003048-00003247": "from that point of view i'm a special", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00011-00003247-00003479": "type of researcher since i'm perfectly", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00012-00003479-00003735": "aware of the power and capabilities of", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00013-00003736-00004983": "citizen science to describe", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00014-00004984-00005215": "okay the research project", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00015-00005216-00005654": "we present", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00016-00005655-00005831": "combines two different scientific", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00017-00005832-00005943": "disciplines", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00018-00005944-00006206": "on one side biology", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00019-00006207-00006646": "the other side computer science", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00020-00006647-00006910": "as a project it is rooted in a formal", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00021-00006911-00007119": "project of us", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00022-00007120-00007534": "developed around 2014 2015", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00023-00007536-00007887": "hussain was to create a", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00024-00007888-00008110": "computer platform", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00025-00008111-00008271": "allowing", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00026-00008272-00008510": "volunteers in that case also high school", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00027-00008511-00008927": "students to help biologists to analyze", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00028-00008928-00009310": "microscopic images", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00029-00009311-00009623": "coming from", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00030-00009624-00009751": "different", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00031-00009752-00010046": "cell cultures reacting to the addition", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00032-00010047-00010199": "of chemical compounds", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00033-00010200-00010606": "of different chemical compounds", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00034-00010607-00010863": "okay we decided to", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00035-00010864-00011127": "use those resources okay that computer", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00036-00011128-00011374": "platform we had", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00037-00011375-00011623": "and build on top of it", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00038-00011624-00011863": "a machine learning platform", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00039-00011864-00012095": "which", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00040-00012096-00012342": "should be trained", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00041-00012343-00012599": "with the information provided by the", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00042-00012600-00012902": "students so the students analyze", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00043-00012903-00013046": "the images", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00044-00013047-00013199": "they", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00045-00013200-00013303": "create", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00046-00013304-00013543": "some information and that information", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00047-00013544-00013927": "trains the computer", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00048-00013928-00014143": "which at the end of the process should", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00049-00014144-00014407": "be able to analyze", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00050-00014408-00014615": "automatically", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00051-00014616-00014838": "the images from the microscope", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00052-00014840-00015022": "in the same way as", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00053-00015023-00015335": "humans in this case the students do", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00054-00015336-00015943": "right", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00055-00015944-00016022": "okay", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00056-00016023-00016255": "from that point of view", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00057-00016256-00016439": "the project", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00058-00016440-00016663": "can be implemented at the school from", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00059-00016664-00016863": "two different perspectives", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00060-00016864-00016958": "either", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00061-00016959-00017191": "as a my", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00062-00017192-00017407": "project in a biological i am in a", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00063-00017408-00017550": "biology class", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00064-00017551-00017814": "or in a computer science world", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00065-00017815-00017991": "okay both", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00066-00017992-00018271": "approaches are perfect perfectly", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00067-00018272-00018439": "feasible and actually they have been", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00068-00018440-00018703": "implemented in this in this", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00069-00018704-00019014": "project of us in madrid", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00070-00019015-00019430": "and both have been have", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00071-00019431-00019789": "proved very successful", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00072-00019790-00020343": "[Music]", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00073-00020344-00020455": "okay", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00074-00020456-00020958": "implementation in the", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00075-00020959-00021367": "schools in madrid has been", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00076-00021368-00021558": "fantastic i mean", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00077-00021559-00021863": "the attitude of the students", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00078-00021864-00022135": "the attitude of the teachers were was", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00079-00022136-00022367": "absolutely great i mean", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00080-00022368-00022478": "helpful", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00081-00022479-00022727": "very very very committed", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00082-00022728-00022975": "and also students i had", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00083-00022976-00023263": "less contact with them just", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00084-00023264-00023471": "one interview at the beginning and one", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00085-00023472-00023663": "interview at the end", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00086-00023664-00023807": "but the process", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00087-00023808-00023950": "was", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00088-00023951-00024078": "as", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00089-00024079-00024591": "good as i expected or even better i mean", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00090-00024592-00024894": "as i mentioned at the beginning i happen", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00091-00024895-00025055": "to have some experience with citizen", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00092-00025056-00025191": "science projects", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00093-00025192-00025478": "and okay in that case i'm", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00094-00025479-00025870": "particularly happy with the result", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00095-00025872-00026127": "also at the end the", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00096-00026127-00026270": "system has", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00097-00026272-00026518": "proved to be", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00098-00026519-00026974": "very powerful", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00099-00026975-00027135": "also i mean", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00100-00027136-00027351": "everything can be improved when we are", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00101-00027352-00027527": "working in in", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00102-00027527-00027679": "a new", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00103-00027680-00027943": "version of the software but right now it", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00104-00027944-00028343": "is able to identify with a high", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00105-00028344-00028607": "success", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00106-00028608-00028935": "all cells in the in the picture", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00107-00028936-00029127": "and", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00108-00029127-00029335": "identify the state", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00109-00029336-00029543": "with a very very high", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00110-00029544-00029727": "efficiency", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00111-00029727-00029990": "okay so", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00112-00029991-00030223": "that is it", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00113-00030224-00030487": "hope you enjoy", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00114-00030488-00030807": "the video that you could follow", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00115-00030808-00031064": "the process a bit and", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00116-00031064-00031214": "[Music]", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00117-00031216-00031383": "hope to see you around", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00118-00031383-00031608": "bye", "3ZpcJujsjp8-00119-00031610-00032213": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3ZaZaVQgFtc", "text": {"3ZaZaVQgFtc-00000-00000000-00003517": "I", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00001-00003518-00004047": "what I don't remember sleeping here", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00002-00004048-00004592": "Victoria you better let me go what do", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00003-00004593-00004853": "you want with me I promise I'm not doing", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00004-00004854-00005153": "anything bad I have to tell you that", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00005-00005154-00005513": "everyone is dying you and I are the only", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00006-00005514-00005810": "ones who are left on this earth but", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00007-00005811-00006122": "we're about to die too how'd you figure", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00008-00006123-00006484": "that out everyday people just get", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00009-00006486-00007168": "disappearing and I think or about to die", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00010-00007169-00007541": "it can happen any moment all right", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00011-00007542-00008129": "Sophia Sophia owe me now she died i", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00012-00008130-00009801": "guess i'll have to wait till i die", "3ZaZaVQgFtc-00013-00009802-00010382": "there'll be there calling me baby"}}, {"audio_id": "3Zb-Esb4e5u", "text": {"3Zb-Esb4e5u-00000-00007031-00016743": "um", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00001-00016744-00017567": "foreign", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00002-00017568-00019711": "foreign", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00003-00019712-00019919": "from the renovations and i i'm not sure", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00004-00019920-00020214": "how many meters deep the excavation was", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00005-00020215-00020375": "but i'm going to have hopefully somebody", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00006-00020376-00020535": "in my ear shout out and be very very", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00007-00020536-00020735": "sure many people always ask about the", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00008-00020736-00020927": "pure earthquake it's very hard to get", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00009-00020928-00021022": "hold of", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00010-00021023-00021175": "you you could go on the streets of", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00011-00021176-00021358": "karbala they will sell for example torah", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00012-00021359-00021591": "or moors and so on but the pure pure", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00013-00021592-00021743": "earth is hard to get hold of this is a", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00014-00021744-00021886": "jug of pure", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00015-00021887-00022191": "earth from around the grave rather than", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00016-00022192-00022414": "from the outskirts for example i'd like", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00017-00022415-00022797": "to add floors", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00018-00022798-00023239": "[Applause]", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00019-00023240-00023486": "right so there is a reserve on the item", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00020-00023487-00023655": "and inshallah the bidding goes that you", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00021-00023656-00023807": "can probably see", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00022-00023808-00023983": "from the size of this vial it's", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00023-00023984-00024158": "considerably large", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00024-00024159-00024455": "so i would want tables to help bid with", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00025-00024456-00024583": "each other for this vial because you", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00026-00024584-00024807": "could split that really really easily", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00027-00024808-00024919": "right and you could have a piece of", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00028-00024920-00025063": "carburetor in your home so we're not", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00029-00025064-00025175": "going to start", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00030-00025176-00025327": "that high on this one because i want to", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00031-00025328-00025527": "encourage bidders and you can bid as a", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00032-00025528-00025678": "table so if there's 10 sisters that want", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00033-00025679-00025902": "to throw in 50 pound each we're going to", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00034-00025904-00026158": "start the bidding this on this vial of", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00035-00026160-00026470": "pure dust from karbala only 500 pounds", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00036-00026472-00026614": "i've got a thousand pounds you've got a", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00037-00026616-00026727": "thousand pounds we're going gonna start", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00038-00026727-00026918": "a thousand pounds", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00039-00026919-00027167": "table of ten that's only a hundred each", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00040-00027168-00027637": "we're going up to one 250.", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00041-00027638-00027974": "[Music]", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00042-00027975-00028113": "um", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00043-00028114-00028901": "[Music]", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00044-00028902-00029932": "[Music]", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00045-00029933-00032383": "[Music]", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00046-00032385-00034220": "[Music]", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00047-00034221-00048727": "[Music]", "3Zb-Esb4e5u-00048-00048728-00049028": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "3a1b7FQ5Ob4", "text": {"3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00000-00000003-00000649": "I'm a family how are you guys doing so I", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00001-00000650-00001216": "really do you guys want me to be a", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00002-00001217-00001418": "hundred percent honest I really need to", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00003-00001419-00001735": "get some lighting for my videos and I've", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00004-00001736-00001984": "honestly been slacking on that with my", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00005-00001985-00002150": "remotes is so loud and I'm watching", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00006-00002151-00002624": "anime so oh it's hot in here", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00007-00002625-00003010": "skirt no you guys think right here", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00008-00003011-00003361": "how cute right I just I'm in love with", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00009-00003363-00003877": "this with this skirt you know I hear", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00010-00003878-00004570": "which is also so freakin cute", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00011-00004571-00004847": "other ones that I'll have to like bring", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00012-00004848-00005084": "out for you guys but let's start out by", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00013-00005085-00005435": "trying these out okay guys so this is", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00014-00005436-00005668": "the first outfit and I swear this", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00015-00005669-00005927": "lighting thing is such a problem cuz I", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00016-00005928-00006233": "almost can't see what I'm showing you", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00017-00006234-00006542": "guys but how cute is this skirt it's so", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00018-00006543-00007025": "flowy and it's actually quite long so it", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00019-00007026-00007538": "goes all the way like past of course my", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00020-00007539-00007802": "knees and everything else it just kind", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00021-00007803-00008134": "of flows and then the shirt it's just", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00022-00008136-00008438": "like so cute guys like I don't know like", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00023-00008439-00008585": "I don't know to target unless I know", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00024-00008586-00008710": "that I have a couple of hundred dollars", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00025-00008711-00008807": "to spend", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00026-00008808-00009263": "because I know that usually I will find", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00027-00009264-00009458": "something that I like do you try things", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00028-00009459-00009746": "out at the store most of the time like", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00029-00009747-00010081": "98% of the time I'll try it at the store", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00030-00010082-00010271": "prior to purchase", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00031-00010272-00010706": "to make sure that I like it so yeah this", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00032-00010707-00010937": "is kind of like what that looks like and", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00033-00010938-00011108": "it's like super cute I love the cleavage", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00034-00011109-00011335": "action hey if you guys know you know I", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00035-00011336-00011495": "don't have anything against cleavage", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00036-00011496-00011845": "action okay like it's all good just you", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00037-00011846-00012056": "know it just depends on how you work it", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00038-00012057-00012310": "okay you guys and this is the second", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00039-00012311-00012599": "outfit I really love this outfit like I", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00040-00012600-00012889": "love this girl", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00041-00012890-00013302": "like I'm like there's like a little like", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00042-00013303-00013661": "slit right here I'm just dying for this", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00043-00013662-00013895": "outfit I just think it's so cute", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00044-00013896-00014363": "it comes [__] really nicely with my", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00045-00014365-00014900": "shape and it's flowy kinda and it's just", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00046-00014901-00015075": "like super cute I love it", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00047-00015076-00015347": "it was really kind of pricey this skirt", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00048-00015348-00016337": "was almost $60 and this skirt right here", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00049-00016338-00016839": "was a little bit over 45 so and then", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00050-00016840-00017231": "this shirt was also a little bit over 45", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00051-00017232-00017758": "so you can see how you know the prices", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00052-00017759-00018296": "run up quite quickly and these aren't", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00053-00018297-00018483": "outfits that I plan on returning", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00054-00018484-00018708": "obviously because I like I said I try", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00055-00018709-00018842": "them on at the store and I really love", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00056-00018843-00019139": "them so it's so freakin cute I just love", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00057-00019140-00019328": "what do you guys think", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00058-00019329-00019736": "okay you guys so here's one of the lust", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00059-00019737-00020069": "outfits or the last outfit that I got I", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00060-00020070-00020274": "just got some cute shirts in addition", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00061-00020275-00020465": "sold separately so I had to buy this", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00062-00020466-00020705": "shirt separately from the skirt but I", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00063-00020706-00020925": "really really loved it I felt like of", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00064-00020926-00021197": "course I needed both pieces like the", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00065-00021198-00021422": "matching you know especially when I go", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00066-00021423-00021621": "to work like during the week and stuff", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00067-00021622-00021761": "like that it's something that's like", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00068-00021762-00022172": "super cute and like easy to just pick", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00069-00022173-00022436": "out of the closet wear and go to where I", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00070-00022437-00022568": "don't have to think about it too much", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00071-00022569-00022864": "and it looks like I thought about it", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00072-00022865-00023108": "quite a bit but I didn't I just kind of", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00073-00023109-00023306": "picked it out of my closet so I really", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00074-00023307-00023534": "love this outfit I don't know let me let", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00075-00023535-00023789": "me know what you guys think I think it's", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00076-00023790-00024209": "super cute there's this like lacy like", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00077-00024210-00024399": "bottom right here and if you guys can", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00078-00024400-00024890": "see it but I might have exposed too much", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00079-00024891-00025136": "there so but there's this like lacy", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00080-00025137-00025415": "bottom see like the bottom is like lace", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00081-00025416-00025706": "and", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00082-00025707-00026078": "and it's pretty long but not like granny", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00083-00026079-00026892": "long so you know it's I just I think", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00084-00026893-00027236": "this is pretty cute shirt alone you guys", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00085-00027237-00027514": "the shirt alone was almost 50 bucks as", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00086-00027515-00027792": "was the skirt so they were priced at", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00087-00027793-00028061": "about the same thing and very very", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00088-00028062-00028508": "pricey but I really love like Target and", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00089-00028508-00028833": "you know their [__] so I I'm willing to", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00090-00028833-00029058": "spend on it because I'm like you know", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00091-00029058-00029226": "like I don't go to Target unless I know", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00092-00029227-00029607": "that I can so instead of going to target", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00093-00029608-00029760": "I should have just ordered some light so", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00094-00029761-00030020": "but it's okay I'll have to do that you", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00095-00030022-00030218": "guys I have to do that like today and", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00096-00030219-00030368": "you guys let me know in the comments", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00097-00030369-00030755": "below if you like this video or these", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00098-00030756-00030945": "types of video don't forget to subscribe", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00099-00030945-00031193": "and support like I go shopping quite", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00100-00031194-00031410": "often and especially online shopping so", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00101-00031411-00031757": "I think like it's really really fun so", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00102-00031758-00032124": "we'll catch you guys later thanks for", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00103-00032125-00032195": "joining me", "3a1b7FQ5Ob4-00104-00032196-00032508": "bye bye"}}, {"audio_id": "3ahQsR8OULy", "text": {"3ahQsR8OULy-00000-00000042-00000278": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "3aoWJMUnZYo", "text": {"3aoWJMUnZYo-00000-00000090-00000325": "foreign", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00001-00000326-00001199": "[Music]", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00002-00001200-00004288": "[Music]", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00003-00004289-00007337": "um", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00004-00007338-00007559": "foreign", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00005-00007561-00008440": "[Music]", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00006-00008441-00008921": "[Applause]", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00007-00008922-00009087": "[Music]", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00008-00009088-00009201": "[Applause]", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00009-00009202-00010049": "[Music]", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00010-00010050-00010132": "foreign", "3aoWJMUnZYo-00011-00010133-00012405": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3apUOLe09dE", "text": {"3apUOLe09dE-00000-00000008-00000262": "my name is charlie freund i'm 64 years", "3apUOLe09dE-00001-00000263-00000311": "old", "3apUOLe09dE-00002-00000312-00000615": "i live in the state of florida and my", "3apUOLe09dE-00003-00000616-00000759": "whole adult life", "3apUOLe09dE-00004-00000760-00001070": "i've been a republican and have voted on", "3apUOLe09dE-00005-00001071-00001254": "republican lines especially for the", "3apUOLe09dE-00006-00001255-00001415": "president of the united states", "3apUOLe09dE-00007-00001416-00001782": "until 2016. when i voted", "3apUOLe09dE-00008-00001784-00002118": "for hillary clinton because", "3apUOLe09dE-00009-00002119-00002455": "i couldn't vote for donald trump", "3apUOLe09dE-00010-00002456-00002734": "to me it was obvious right away that he", "3apUOLe09dE-00011-00002735-00002887": "lacked both the character and the", "3apUOLe09dE-00012-00002888-00003039": "experience", "3apUOLe09dE-00013-00003040-00003215": "to be president of the united states and", "3apUOLe09dE-00014-00003215-00003367": "to lead this country", "3apUOLe09dE-00015-00003368-00003670": "and i think i've been proven right about", "3apUOLe09dE-00016-00003671-00003743": "that", "3apUOLe09dE-00017-00003744-00004079": "um yeah but also importantly a number of", "3apUOLe09dE-00018-00004079-00004238": "issues have cropped up", "3apUOLe09dE-00019-00004239-00004463": "over the last uh particularly over the", "3apUOLe09dE-00020-00004464-00004606": "last year", "3apUOLe09dE-00021-00004607-00004935": "where i wanted more from my congressman", "3apUOLe09dE-00022-00004936-00005295": "uh as well as from donald trump", "3apUOLe09dE-00023-00005296-00005638": "and uh the first issue was donald's use", "3apUOLe09dE-00024-00005639-00005934": "of emergency powers or funding to", "3apUOLe09dE-00025-00005935-00006286": "divert money to pay for the border wall", "3apUOLe09dE-00026-00006287-00006463": "with mexico", "3apUOLe09dE-00027-00006464-00006751": "and i contacted my representatives in", "3apUOLe09dE-00028-00006752-00006855": "congress", "3apUOLe09dE-00029-00006856-00007134": "and told them i expected them to vote", "3apUOLe09dE-00030-00007136-00007198": "against that", "3apUOLe09dE-00031-00007200-00007398": "in order to retain you know the", "3apUOLe09dE-00032-00007400-00007606": "integrity of the balance of power", "3apUOLe09dE-00033-00007608-00007910": "in our government but obviously i lost", "3apUOLe09dE-00034-00007911-00008023": "that battle", "3apUOLe09dE-00035-00008023-00008167": "then again with the impeachment", "3apUOLe09dE-00036-00008168-00008374": "proceedings where all but", "3apUOLe09dE-00037-00008375-00008710": "one republican voted along party lines", "3apUOLe09dE-00038-00008711-00009014": "that was very disappointing after having", "3apUOLe09dE-00039-00009015-00009239": "written my representatives", "3apUOLe09dE-00040-00009240-00009478": "i finally followed through then on my", "3apUOLe09dE-00041-00009479-00009574": "threat", "3apUOLe09dE-00042-00009575-00009903": "to leave the republican party and i", "3apUOLe09dE-00043-00009904-00010214": "did that officially and i'm now", "3apUOLe09dE-00044-00010215-00010431": "a registered democrat and i'm not happy", "3apUOLe09dE-00045-00010432-00010614": "about it i'd love to be back in the", "3apUOLe09dE-00046-00010615-00010783": "republican party", "3apUOLe09dE-00047-00010784-00011014": "here we now have a new issue and that", "3apUOLe09dE-00048-00011015-00011214": "has to do with the funding of the", "3apUOLe09dE-00049-00011215-00011438": "u.s postal service so that every", "3apUOLe09dE-00050-00011439-00011591": "american can", "3apUOLe09dE-00051-00011592-00011942": "safely vote and", "3apUOLe09dE-00052-00011943-00012287": "i'm pleading with my", "3apUOLe09dE-00053-00012288-00012591": "republican representatives to", "3apUOLe09dE-00054-00012592-00012863": "do the right thing and get the post", "3apUOLe09dE-00055-00012863-00013086": "office funded and make sure that we have", "3apUOLe09dE-00056-00013087-00013127": "a", "3apUOLe09dE-00057-00013128-00013430": "credible election where every vote and", "3apUOLe09dE-00058-00013431-00013671": "voter who every person who wants to vote", "3apUOLe09dE-00059-00013672-00014087": "can vote and get that vote counted"}}, {"audio_id": "3a-9EBNms3c", "text": {"3a-9EBNms3c-00000-00000105-00000919": "[Music]", "3a-9EBNms3c-00001-00000921-00001215": "organizing and mobilizing to understand", "3a-9EBNms3c-00002-00001216-00001398": "organizing we must evaluate what it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00003-00001399-00001650": "isn't in order to do that something nice", "3a-9EBNms3c-00004-00001651-00001802": "in [__] editorial team will be", "3a-9EBNms3c-00005-00001803-00001907": "examining the difference between", "3a-9EBNms3c-00006-00001909-00002148": "organizing and mobilizing in the first", "3a-9EBNms3c-00007-00002149-00002388": "of a new series of podcasts talking shop", "3a-9EBNms3c-00008-00002389-00002691": "as way of an introduction we'd like to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00009-00002692-00002832": "introduce the terms we'll be using in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00010-00002833-00003083": "the podcast terms like organizing and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00011-00003084-00003263": "mobilizing are thrown around regularly", "3a-9EBNms3c-00012-00003264-00003453": "within union circles but are often", "3a-9EBNms3c-00013-00003454-00003750": "misunderstood and conflated the most", "3a-9EBNms3c-00014-00003751-00003927": "concise definitions we've seen have come", "3a-9EBNms3c-00015-00003928-00004269": "from Jane maca Levy's no shortcuts maca", "3a-9EBNms3c-00016-00004270-00004445": "levy suggests that mobilizing is based", "3a-9EBNms3c-00017-00004446-00004656": "on a staff intensive model where goals", "3a-9EBNms3c-00018-00004657-00004811": "are set with little or no input from", "3a-9EBNms3c-00019-00004812-00004974": "members and Winsor declared after", "3a-9EBNms3c-00020-00004975-00005172": "minimal progress is made towards an", "3a-9EBNms3c-00021-00005173-00005427": "often overly ambitious goal the strategy", "3a-9EBNms3c-00022-00005428-00005597": "has little or no base of meaningful", "3a-9EBNms3c-00023-00005598-00005834": "supports often using what she describes", "3a-9EBNms3c-00024-00005835-00006047": "as authentic messengers to represent a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00025-00006048-00006234": "campaign who do not have any say over", "3a-9EBNms3c-00026-00006235-00006386": "the way in which the campaign is run", "3a-9EBNms3c-00027-00006387-00006588": "those members who are involved of the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00028-00006589-00006746": "usual suspects such as already", "3a-9EBNms3c-00029-00006747-00006989": "established political activists this can", "3a-9EBNms3c-00030-00006990-00007200": "often lead to burnout the process of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00031-00007201-00007383": "mobilizing run by staff", "3a-9EBNms3c-00032-00007384-00007628": "establish activists is about using those", "3a-9EBNms3c-00033-00007629-00007833": "pre-existing engaged members to build", "3a-9EBNms3c-00034-00007834-00007998": "visibility and a campaign that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00035-00007998-00008199": "ultimately concludes in a backroom deal", "3a-9EBNms3c-00036-00008200-00008469": "with only limited enforceability recent", "3a-9EBNms3c-00037-00008470-00008624": "examples of this in the british trade", "3a-9EBNms3c-00038-00008625-00008828": "union movement include the public sector", "3a-9EBNms3c-00039-00008829-00009153": "strikes of 2014 in this example we saw", "3a-9EBNms3c-00040-00009154-00009321": "huge numbers of political activists", "3a-9EBNms3c-00041-00009322-00009492": "brought onto the streets demands nen to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00042-00009493-00009684": "austerity a dispute which was not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00043-00009685-00009846": "followed up and led entirely from the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00044-00009847-00009899": "top", "3a-9EBNms3c-00045-00009900-00010131": "McAuliffe he describes organizing as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00046-00010132-00010449": "mass inclusive and collective this is a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00047-00010450-00010644": "process which changes power structures", "3a-9EBNms3c-00048-00010645-00010944": "leading to long-term impact this is part", "3a-9EBNms3c-00049-00010945-00011151": "of a larger strategy focused on building", "3a-9EBNms3c-00050-00011152-00011337": "power members are involved throughout", "3a-9EBNms3c-00051-00011338-00011588": "specifically organic leaders operating", "3a-9EBNms3c-00052-00011589-00011828": "independently of staff they help build a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00053-00011829-00012045": "strategy the goals analysis of the power", "3a-9EBNms3c-00054-00012046-00012255": "structures and negotiate any settlement", "3a-9EBNms3c-00055-00012256-00012428": "the strategy is one of targeted", "3a-9EBNms3c-00056-00012429-00012591": "recruitment of specific and large", "3a-9EBNms3c-00057-00012592-00012788": "numbers leading to the withdrawal of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00058-00012789-00012983": "labour through coordinated majority", "3a-9EBNms3c-00059-00012984-00013238": "strikes luckily he suggests that this", "3a-9EBNms3c-00060-00013240-00013375": "does not mean mobilizing should", "3a-9EBNms3c-00061-00013376-00013600": "ignored and can in fact be used as a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00062-00013601-00013803": "tactic but then it should never be the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00063-00013804-00014074": "strategy we've seen very limited", "3a-9EBNms3c-00064-00014075-00014191": "examples of this in the trade union", "3a-9EBNms3c-00065-00014191-00014386": "movement in the UK and recent times", "3a-9EBNms3c-00066-00014387-00014569": "there have been elements of this in the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00067-00014569-00014841": "recent ucu strikes but ultimately that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00068-00014843-00015010": "was led from the top and settled behind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00069-00015011-00015264": "closed doors the stronger examples have", "3a-9EBNms3c-00070-00015265-00015421": "been in smaller scale campaigns such as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00071-00015422-00015688": "delivery the largest scale example has", "3a-9EBNms3c-00072-00015688-00015835": "been a picture house where reps have", "3a-9EBNms3c-00073-00015836-00016038": "taken the lead role despite a lot of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00074-00016040-00016244": "control still being held by officials", "3a-9EBNms3c-00075-00016245-00016477": "during our discussions we'll analyze", "3a-9EBNms3c-00076-00016478-00016705": "both of these definitions examining", "3a-9EBNms3c-00077-00016706-00016867": "where the gray areas are and looking", "3a-9EBNms3c-00078-00016868-00017181": "over some recent campaigns hi I'm Lydia", "3a-9EBNms3c-00079-00017182-00017633": "I'm the women's officer for the London", "3a-9EBNms3c-00080-00017634-00018202": "IWW GMB recently I've been involved with", "3a-9EBNms3c-00081-00018203-00018577": "organizing fire workers in Southland hi", "3a-9EBNms3c-00082-00018578-00018984": "I'm Dave Pike I am a regional official", "3a-9EBNms3c-00083-00018985-00019147": "for the National Education Union and a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00084-00019148-00019436": "longtime member of the IWW also myself", "3a-9EBNms3c-00085-00019437-00019669": "the thing I've noticed recently being", "3a-9EBNms3c-00086-00019670-00020115": "organized in is organizing strikes in a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00087-00020116-00020675": "school in Sheffield and also against", "3a-9EBNms3c-00088-00020676-00021100": "redundancies at whole College hi I'm", "3a-9EBNms3c-00089-00021101-00021418": "Chris I am the IWW", "3a-9EBNms3c-00090-00021419-00021667": "lead education organizer that's because", "3a-9EBNms3c-00091-00021668-00021793": "also I am a teacher", "3a-9EBNms3c-00092-00021794-00022033": "secretary school teacher I think the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00093-00022034-00022215": "last thing that I've been involved with", "3a-9EBNms3c-00094-00022216-00022483": "although we do a lot of it in education", "3a-9EBNms3c-00095-00022484-00022812": "is probably organising or helping the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00096-00022813-00023000": "organization of a health and social care", "3a-9EBNms3c-00097-00023001-00023412": "company in Sheffield and sort of doing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00098-00023413-00023683": "work on flexibility issues and contract", "3a-9EBNms3c-00099-00023684-00023977": "issues there what are you doing you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00100-00023978-00024165": "actual organize are you doing your own", "3a-9EBNms3c-00101-00024166-00024878": "job there's no just get this very apply", "3a-9EBNms3c-00102-00024879-00025371": "this is hard to do it wrong you're a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00103-00025372-00025590": "school teacher in education we're the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00104-00025591-00025750": "Union yeah and you're organising", "3a-9EBNms3c-00105-00025751-00026156": "elsewhere yeah already", "3a-9EBNms3c-00106-00026157-00026951": "yeah so this is the first episode of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00107-00026952-00027324": "talking shop which is a podcast and from", "3a-9EBNms3c-00108-00027325-00027467": "the new syndicalist", "3a-9EBNms3c-00109-00027468-00027879": "the purpose of the podcast is to kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00110-00027880-00028110": "have some discussion about key concepts", "3a-9EBNms3c-00111-00028111-00028689": "for organizers we're starting off with a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00112-00028689-00029070": "discussion about mobilizing versus", "3a-9EBNms3c-00113-00029070-00029622": "organizing so I think the first thing to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00114-00029623-00029943": "think about is why are we making why do", "3a-9EBNms3c-00115-00029944-00030063": "you think it's important to make a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00116-00030064-00030357": "distinction and to really understand the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00117-00030358-00030779": "difference between these two concepts um", "3a-9EBNms3c-00118-00030780-00031317": "I think of it as something that we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00119-00031318-00031467": "should be considering when we're", "3a-9EBNms3c-00120-00031468-00031800": "planning a campaign so that we can kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00121-00031801-00032102": "of identify what it is that we're doing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00122-00032104-00032427": "like what our what our aims are and kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00123-00032427-00033066": "of what is gonna take us there so if we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00124-00033067-00033261": "if we realize that what we're planning", "3a-9EBNms3c-00125-00033262-00033507": "is more of a kind of mobilisation than a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00126-00033508-00033705": "kind of long-term organizing strategy", "3a-9EBNms3c-00127-00033706-00034035": "just being able to identify that and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00128-00034036-00034227": "think about whether that's actually what", "3a-9EBNms3c-00129-00034228-00034506": "we want to be doing and is it a tactic", "3a-9EBNms3c-00130-00034507-00034721": "that we're using within like a broader", "3a-9EBNms3c-00131-00034722-00035058": "organizing strategy or are we just", "3a-9EBNms3c-00132-00035059-00035256": "trying to go for a kind of quick easy", "3a-9EBNms3c-00133-00035257-00035583": "win which might make us feel good and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00134-00035584-00035961": "you know it's good to win but might not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00135-00035962-00036231": "necessarily kind of shift the balance of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00136-00036232-00036513": "power long term or kind of move us", "3a-9EBNms3c-00137-00036514-00037095": "forward more generally and so thinking", "3a-9EBNms3c-00138-00037096-00037404": "about how we can identify what it is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00139-00037405-00037500": "that we're doing whether we're", "3a-9EBNms3c-00140-00037501-00037797": "mobilizing or or doing organizing work", "3a-9EBNms3c-00141-00037798-00038064": "there are some things that we can look", "3a-9EBNms3c-00142-00038065-00038457": "out for so one of the things is thinking", "3a-9EBNms3c-00143-00038458-00038694": "about whether the actions we're planning", "3a-9EBNms3c-00144-00038695-00038892": "a symbolic or whether they're aimed at", "3a-9EBNms3c-00145-00038893-00039171": "disrupting capital and shifting the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00146-00039172-00039515": "balance of power in a work place", "3a-9EBNms3c-00147-00039516-00039789": "is the campaign being led by union", "3a-9EBNms3c-00148-00039790-00040029": "activists or a massive workers who", "3a-9EBNms3c-00149-00040030-00040421": "choose their own leadership and a third", "3a-9EBNms3c-00150-00040422-00040680": "thing kind of among many other things is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00151-00040681-00041087": "is the campaign supported by kind of the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00152-00041088-00041355": "wider community like via connection to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00153-00041356-00041754": "workers themselves rather than kind of a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00154-00041755-00041967": "less organic way of pulling in kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00155-00041968-00042504": "other grassroots organizations so I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00156-00042505-00042765": "think it's useful to think of organizing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00157-00042766-00043386": "as strategy and mobilizing as kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00158-00043387-00043917": "one tactic within that that's been", "3a-9EBNms3c-00159-00043918-00044102": "that's been a really helpful way for me", "3a-9EBNms3c-00160-00044103-00044289": "to think about these things especially", "3a-9EBNms3c-00161-00044290-00044427": "because people tend to get strategy and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00162-00044428-00044652": "tactics confused as well so I think it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00163-00044653-00044874": "kind of tidies both of those things up", "3a-9EBNms3c-00164-00044875-00045075": "in quite a nicely I mean I personally", "3a-9EBNms3c-00165-00045076-00045537": "found these categories I found them", "3a-9EBNms3c-00166-00045538-00045780": "incredibly useful but when I read the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00167-00045781-00045906": "book which we have mentioned the book", "3a-9EBNms3c-00168-00045907-00046068": "actually a lot of these ideas have been", "3a-9EBNms3c-00169-00046069-00046458": "drawn from jameth V's book no shortcuts", "3a-9EBNms3c-00170-00046459-00046637": "which is very good book and we'd", "3a-9EBNms3c-00171-00046638-00046796": "recommend it we have talks about it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00172-00046797-00047133": "before a new symbolist but she makes you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00173-00047134-00047508": "this key categorization and as well as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00174-00047509-00047604": "finding it very useful", "3a-9EBNms3c-00175-00047605-00047970": "it immediately clarified for me a lot of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00176-00047971-00048215": "things that I've been doing and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00177-00048216-00048564": "experiencing for a long time in the left", "3a-9EBNms3c-00178-00048565-00048795": "and in the trade union movement and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00179-00048796-00049112": "immediately kind of understanding what", "3a-9EBNms3c-00180-00049113-00049287": "was wrong about them in a really like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00181-00049288-00049593": "surgical way in the sense that like I've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00182-00049594-00049815": "been on so many demonstrations I've been", "3a-9EBNms3c-00183-00049816-00050087": "on so many protests or even organized", "3a-9EBNms3c-00184-00050088-00050436": "protests and demonstrations where the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00185-00050437-00050640": "goal was to get like people into the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00186-00050641-00050793": "street like oh we need X number of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00187-00050794-00050967": "people and then it's successful or we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00188-00050968-00051090": "just need like a big crowd and it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00189-00051091-00051341": "successful or we need like X number of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00190-00051342-00051501": "speakers and then it's successful and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00191-00051502-00051750": "actually like having having a theory", "3a-9EBNms3c-00192-00051751-00052052": "that very clearly articulates what", "3a-9EBNms3c-00193-00052053-00052335": "actually doing these things doesn't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00194-00052336-00052527": "actually challenge the structures of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00195-00052528-00052609": "power", "3a-9EBNms3c-00196-00052610-00052854": "and I think like it's very incisive in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00197-00052855-00052984": "that sense like out she says very", "3a-9EBNms3c-00198-00052985-00053295": "clearly if we want to transform society", "3a-9EBNms3c-00199-00053296-00053632": "then we need to do things that actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00200-00053633-00053920": "do shift the balance of power yeah and I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00201-00053921-00054091": "would totally agree with that as well I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00202-00054091-00054342": "think the reality is one of the real", "3a-9EBNms3c-00203-00054344-00054688": "strengths of JaMychal v's understanding", "3a-9EBNms3c-00204-00054689-00054940": "of this difference is that she's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00205-00054941-00055252": "bringing together ideas from a lot of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00206-00055253-00055645": "different people and really explaining", "3a-9EBNms3c-00207-00055646-00056008": "in a clear fashion and in a way that's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00208-00056009-00056239": "accessible not just to people who are", "3a-9EBNms3c-00209-00056240-00056497": "theorizing about organizing but actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00210-00056498-00056686": "organizes themselves activists on the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00211-00056687-00056817": "ground people doing stuff", "3a-9EBNms3c-00212-00056819-00057040": "how can easily access if this", "3a-9EBNms3c-00213-00057041-00057229": "information can easily understand these", "3a-9EBNms3c-00214-00057229-00057607": "these concepts and I was with you said", "3a-9EBNms3c-00215-00057608-00057748": "you know it is really important to know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00216-00057749-00057975": "these the difference between between", "3a-9EBNms3c-00217-00057976-00058498": "that tactic and strategy because the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00218-00058499-00058804": "reality is mobilizing is what the trade", "3a-9EBNms3c-00219-00058804-00059083": "union movement is currently doing it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00220-00059084-00059338": "being described as organizing it's being", "3a-9EBNms3c-00221-00059339-00059505": "talked about as organizing but the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00222-00059507-00059722": "reality is we are looking at mobilizing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00223-00059723-00060025": "and you know it is very rarely", "3a-9EBNms3c-00224-00060026-00060235": "organizing yes there is some as we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00225-00060236-00060405": "talked about in the introduction there", "3a-9EBNms3c-00226-00060407-00060688": "is some organizing going on you know we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00227-00060689-00060853": "look at the pitch house campaign you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00228-00060854-00061080": "know delivery you know I think it's a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00229-00061082-00061303": "really good example of that as well but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00230-00061304-00061498": "they are small-scale in the grand scheme", "3a-9EBNms3c-00231-00061499-00061615": "of things we're not look we're not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00232-00061616-00061990": "seeing mass organizing going on and as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00233-00061991-00062140": "Jay Michael levy talked about in her", "3a-9EBNms3c-00234-00062141-00062290": "book as well a lot of that is based", "3a-9EBNms3c-00235-00062291-00062626": "around experience of communists in the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00236-00062627-00062935": "20s and 30s mmm not stuff that was go", "3a-9EBNms3c-00237-00062936-00063129": "that's going on today unfortunately", "3a-9EBNms3c-00238-00063129-00063562": "there's a lot of talk in in the book", "3a-9EBNms3c-00239-00063563-00063985": "about kind of like paid organizers and I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00240-00063986-00064191": "think there's a danger that in unions", "3a-9EBNms3c-00241-00064192-00064309": "like the IWW", "3a-9EBNms3c-00242-00064310-00064491": "because we don't have paid organizers", "3a-9EBNms3c-00243-00064492-00064645": "and there's reasons we don't have paid", "3a-9EBNms3c-00244-00064646-00064822": "organizers that you could kind of think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00245-00064823-00065029": "that some of this stuff doesn't apply", "3a-9EBNms3c-00246-00065029-00065280": "and that somehow because you're all", "3a-9EBNms3c-00247-00065282-00065497": "there's volunteers and notionally", "3a-9EBNms3c-00248-00065498-00065661": "there's this kind of horizontal", "3a-9EBNms3c-00249-00065662-00065862": "structure that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00250-00065863-00066176": "that these issues around mobilizing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00251-00066177-00066429": "these symbolic actions with you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00252-00066430-00066717": "people that are just parachuted in that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00253-00066718-00067016": "those things don't apply to us but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00254-00067017-00067349": "definitely some of the things that we've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00255-00067350-00067541": "been doing that we've done in London", "3a-9EBNms3c-00256-00067542-00067775": "have been mobilizations and they you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00257-00067776-00067974": "know not to say that and they haven't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00258-00067975-00068268": "been kind of effective and you know not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00259-00068269-00068391": "to say we shouldn't have done them but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00260-00068392-00068580": "it's yeah like you saying it's it's good", "3a-9EBNms3c-00261-00068581-00068934": "to have a tool for us to analyze what", "3a-9EBNms3c-00262-00068935-00069096": "we're doing especially because we can", "3a-9EBNms3c-00263-00069097-00069234": "get a little bit complacent I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00264-00069235-00069378": "without because we don't have paid", "3a-9EBNms3c-00265-00069379-00069656": "organizers because I think we think that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00266-00069657-00069834": "what we're doing is organizing all the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00267-00069835-00070051": "time and this is quite a good way to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00268-00070052-00070406": "ground what you're doing and identify it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00269-00070407-00070592": "I think that's true and actually like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00270-00070593-00070848": "one like bringing it back to that point", "3a-9EBNms3c-00271-00070849-00071130": "of kind of power structures a lot of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00272-00071131-00071421": "mobilizing can often feel like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00273-00071422-00071701": "organizing like if you are for example", "3a-9EBNms3c-00274-00071702-00071946": "like getting people out to like give out", "3a-9EBNms3c-00275-00071947-00072287": "leaflets or run a stall or get get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00276-00072288-00072437": "people on the street to do a protest", "3a-9EBNms3c-00277-00072438-00072650": "like you do have to do like a certain", "3a-9EBNms3c-00278-00072651-00072857": "degree of like one-to-one conversations", "3a-9EBNms3c-00279-00072858-00073086": "you're like trying to activate people", "3a-9EBNms3c-00280-00073087-00073179": "you're trying to make them enthusiastic", "3a-9EBNms3c-00281-00073180-00073392": "about something like you have to do", "3a-9EBNms3c-00282-00073393-00073619": "practical stuff like you know scheduling", "3a-9EBNms3c-00283-00073620-00073769": "when you're all going to do the tasks", "3a-9EBNms3c-00284-00073770-00073942": "and you have to play that kind of role", "3a-9EBNms3c-00285-00073943-00074282": "but it's that kind of idea of actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00286-00074283-00074555": "if you're not sort of directly", "3a-9EBNms3c-00287-00074556-00074835": "increasing participation and that's the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00288-00074836-00074960": "key isn't it like if you're not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00289-00074961-00075246": "improving the level of participation in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00290-00075247-00075518": "a workplace in a way that then allows", "3a-9EBNms3c-00291-00075519-00075776": "you to challenge the power structures", "3a-9EBNms3c-00292-00075777-00076169": "within it then that organisation is any", "3a-9EBNms3c-00293-00076170-00076341": "kind of you know skin deep", "3a-9EBNms3c-00294-00076342-00076544": "it doesn't actually it won't provide it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00295-00076545-00076805": "it's busy work I mean maybe that's been", "3a-9EBNms3c-00296-00076806-00076980": "like I don't know they're being solving", "3a-9EBNms3c-00297-00076981-00077172": "but it it's keeping a little busy", "3a-9EBNms3c-00298-00077173-00077531": "without changing anything and also on", "3a-9EBNms3c-00299-00077532-00077681": "the flip side of that as well I would", "3a-9EBNms3c-00300-00077682-00077865": "also say that actually paid staff can", "3a-9EBNms3c-00301-00077866-00078123": "actually be a real strength to actual", "3a-9EBNms3c-00302-00078124-00078348": "organizing as well I don't think I don't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00303-00078349-00078506": "think that also means that you're not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00304-00078507-00078699": "organizing if you have paid staff it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00305-00078700-00078834": "doesn't also mean you automatically", "3a-9EBNms3c-00306-00078835-00078914": "organize it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00307-00078915-00079085": "and that's clear from what maka levy is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00308-00079086-00079322": "saying as well that there is a really", "3a-9EBNms3c-00309-00079323-00079559": "important role for paid staff in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00310-00079560-00079876": "organizing and that's about supporting", "3a-9EBNms3c-00311-00079877-00080114": "the work of members on the ground who", "3a-9EBNms3c-00312-00080115-00080294": "are doing it themselves you know you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00313-00080295-00080534": "were there as a support you are there to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00314-00080535-00080789": "make things happen in the background to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00315-00080790-00080954": "help them do things for themselves and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00316-00080955-00081266": "um you know and it's I think it's fair", "3a-9EBNms3c-00317-00081267-00081479": "to say that the best the best trade", "3a-9EBNms3c-00318-00081480-00081671": "union officials do do that you know they", "3a-9EBNms3c-00319-00081672-00081842": "work really hard to try and make that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00320-00081843-00082085": "happen but often sometimes what they", "3a-9EBNms3c-00321-00082086-00082355": "actually achieve is mobilizing and I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00322-00082356-00082526": "don't think it's set through you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00323-00082527-00082817": "it's not for any kind of- intense or", "3a-9EBNms3c-00324-00082818-00083072": "through any kind of malice or try to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00325-00083073-00083300": "disempower people it's big it often", "3a-9EBNms3c-00326-00083301-00083573": "comes down to and the same from the IWW", "3a-9EBNms3c-00327-00083574-00083837": "as well often comes down to real", "3a-9EBNms3c-00328-00083838-00084149": "practical concerns like we need to get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00329-00084150-00084407": "this thing done by X date we need to get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00330-00084408-00084572": "this piece of work done if we don't get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00331-00084573-00084800": "this piece of work done we don't get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00332-00084801-00084974": "these people to this meeting we don't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00333-00084975-00085286": "get someone attending this this", "3a-9EBNms3c-00334-00085287-00085496": "negotiation with the employer we don't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00335-00085497-00085673": "win something in this negotiation with", "3a-9EBNms3c-00336-00085674-00085871": "the employer it's gonna end badly for", "3a-9EBNms3c-00337-00085872-00086009": "members and we cannot have egg on our", "3a-9EBNms3c-00338-00086010-00086267": "face you know it's always it think I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00339-00086268-00086417": "think it's almost always linked to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00340-00086418-00086723": "concerns like that and obviously", "3a-9EBNms3c-00341-00086724-00086876": "unfortunately there is bad cases well", "3a-9EBNms3c-00342-00086877-00086996": "where it isn't linked to that and what", "3a-9EBNms3c-00343-00086997-00087317": "we're talking maybe about officials", "3a-9EBNms3c-00344-00087318-00087539": "protecting their position but actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00345-00087540-00087914": "you know I think a lot of the time we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00346-00087915-00088118": "are see you know there are people trying", "3a-9EBNms3c-00347-00088119-00088304": "to organize and then accidentally", "3a-9EBNms3c-00348-00088305-00088529": "stepping into mobilizing I mean it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00349-00088530-00088751": "interesting you say that because I've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00350-00088752-00088871": "never really thought about it from this", "3a-9EBNms3c-00351-00088872-00089099": "angle before but there is something like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00352-00089100-00089407": "quite frantic about mobilizing who's in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00353-00089408-00089540": "there like this sentence that like you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00354-00089541-00089750": "have to kind of always react to event", "3a-9EBNms3c-00355-00089751-00089900": "you always have to kind of do something", "3a-9EBNms3c-00356-00089901-00090094": "you always have to be seen to be doing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00357-00090095-00090335": "since Austin yeah and actually like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00358-00090336-00090473": "there's a certain degree of like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00359-00090474-00090707": "patience to what he's been proposed with", "3a-9EBNms3c-00360-00090708-00090914": "the organizing here maybe like and I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00361-00090915-00091043": "suppose that's where the no shortcuts", "3a-9EBNms3c-00362-00091044-00091328": "kind of thing comes from right the idea", "3a-9EBNms3c-00363-00091329-00091661": "that there is there actually that kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00364-00091662-00091805": "of movement and emotion that you're", "3a-9EBNms3c-00365-00091806-00091944": "doing were mobilizing is kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00366-00091945-00092110": "I'm running in the spa a lot of the time", "3a-9EBNms3c-00367-00092111-00092382": "and to make like to do substantive", "3a-9EBNms3c-00368-00092383-00092635": "things takes a long time", "3a-9EBNms3c-00369-00092636-00092832": "I know suppose we'll probably discuss", "3a-9EBNms3c-00370-00092833-00092979": "this more at the end it's whether like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00371-00092980-00093235": "whether we can afford to wait is often", "3a-9EBNms3c-00372-00093236-00093379": "the questions it's a yes you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00373-00093380-00093904": "because it it is it can be agonizing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00374-00093905-00094230": "this photo organizing and I think it you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00375-00094231-00094398": "know that's that's very true when you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00376-00094399-00094704": "look at unions dealing with high", "3a-9EBNms3c-00377-00094705-00094990": "turnover industries as well so you look", "3a-9EBNms3c-00378-00094991-00095205": "at all store for example and the amount", "3a-9EBNms3c-00379-00095206-00095424": "of members that they have to recruit on", "3a-9EBNms3c-00380-00095425-00095751": "a constant basis to even just a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00381-00095752-00095815": "standstill", "3a-9EBNms3c-00382-00095816-00096079": "is unbelievable you know the recruiting", "3a-9EBNms3c-00383-00096080-00096393": "thousands of members constantly to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00384-00096394-00096591": "actually just stand still and it is it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00385-00096592-00096837": "it's that it's the attitude that comes", "3a-9EBNms3c-00386-00096838-00097072": "from we just have to keep going because", "3a-9EBNms3c-00387-00097073-00097362": "if we don't do this mobilizing if we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00388-00097363-00097551": "don't get out and recruit and just get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00389-00097552-00097806": "faces that we just get bums on seats", "3a-9EBNms3c-00390-00097807-00098185": "unless we do that then then it all sorts", "3a-9EBNms3c-00391-00098186-00098463": "of fall apart and and organizing is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00392-00098464-00098694": "long-term it is about it's about as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00393-00098695-00098835": "you've got a rattly set changing these", "3a-9EBNms3c-00394-00098836-00099081": "power of dynamics it is about altering", "3a-9EBNms3c-00395-00099082-00099528": "things in the long term and there's a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00396-00099529-00099726": "nervousness about that about that long", "3a-9EBNms3c-00397-00099727-00100112": "term ideology I think the idea about", "3a-9EBNms3c-00398-00100113-00100329": "mobilizing being this like quite", "3a-9EBNms3c-00399-00100330-00100506": "reactive thing is interesting as well I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00400-00100507-00100779": "think and because a lot of their kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00401-00100780-00101199": "and grassroots unions particularly in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00402-00101200-00101359": "London that have been getting kind of a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00403-00101360-00101791": "lot of um kind of lot of attention and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00404-00101792-00101982": "like well deserved like praise over the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00405-00101983-00102438": "last five years or so is is that kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00406-00102439-00102735": "like very fast-moving reactive stuff", "3a-9EBNms3c-00407-00102736-00103317": "like it's less kind of a long term like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00408-00103318-00103509": "just kind of people getting into", "3a-9EBNms3c-00409-00103510-00103740": "workplaces and kind of developing these", "3a-9EBNms3c-00410-00103741-00103953": "things long term and more reacting so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00411-00103954-00104360": "kind of um you know dramatic pay cuts or", "3a-9EBNms3c-00412-00104361-00104658": "contract changes and things and so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00413-00104659-00104826": "they've got these kind of it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00414-00104827-00105031": "interesting that it's kind of popping up", "3a-9EBNms3c-00415-00105032-00105426": "in these kind of like hot shops and be I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00416-00105427-00105625": "think a lot of the actions that are", "3a-9EBNms3c-00417-00105626-00105837": "being taken in these kind of small", "3a-9EBNms3c-00418-00105838-00106125": "unions are these like very quick", "3a-9EBNms3c-00419-00106126-00106437": "mobilizations and I do like that's a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00420-00106438-00106768": "worry that I think I have about some of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00421-00106769-00106945": "the organizing like some of the cleaner", "3a-9EBNms3c-00422-00106946-00107214": "organizing for instance that like they", "3a-9EBNms3c-00423-00107215-00107470": "win the dispute and that and then that's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00424-00107471-00107916": "that kind of squared away yeah you kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00425-00107917-00108111": "of think like what's gonna be there in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00426-00108113-00108326": "like 10 years", "3a-9EBNms3c-00427-00108327-00108627": "think about these timescales yeah", "3a-9EBNms3c-00428-00108628-00108765": "because there wasn't anything there", "3a-9EBNms3c-00429-00108766-00109140": "before yeah it like it it kind of it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00430-00109141-00109300": "happened because it was a kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00431-00109301-00109522": "hotshot something dramatic had happened", "3a-9EBNms3c-00432-00109523-00109839": "and so my concern is kind of what", "3a-9EBNms3c-00433-00109840-00110211": "happens after yeah you know it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00434-00110213-00110395": "resolved that's exactly right I mean", "3a-9EBNms3c-00435-00110396-00110545": "that is that's that's what's been", "3a-9EBNms3c-00436-00110546-00110725": "happening in these cases is is they've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00437-00110726-00111106": "just been getting the usual suspects out", "3a-9EBNms3c-00438-00111107-00111279": "to showing their support", "3a-9EBNms3c-00439-00111280-00111526": "make a scene get a lot of publicity do", "3a-9EBNms3c-00440-00111527-00111745": "it extremely well yeah but then on the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00441-00111746-00112065": "other side of it what is left actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00442-00112066-00112351": "what's left is just the same old faces", "3a-9EBNms3c-00443-00112352-00112756": "mm-hm and actually that feeds in very", "3a-9EBNms3c-00444-00112757-00112926": "nicely to the next section", "3a-9EBNms3c-00445-00112927-00113229": "yeah that's a good opportunity to talk", "3a-9EBNms3c-00446-00113230-00113754": "about pizza yeah yeah yeah so I'll say", "3a-9EBNms3c-00447-00113755-00114708": "that getting a more serious question yes", "3a-9EBNms3c-00448-00114709-00114951": "so that feeds really nicely into my own", "3a-9EBNms3c-00449-00114952-00115284": "experiences and I think is a shortcoming", "3a-9EBNms3c-00450-00115285-00115531": "for the IDW on how we've approached", "3a-9EBNms3c-00451-00115532-00116098": "things as well so um how I sort of broke", "3a-9EBNms3c-00452-00116099-00116299": "my teeth organizing for the idea really", "3a-9EBNms3c-00453-00116300-00116722": "was organizing in peacefull and actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00454-00116723-00117022": "we started out there I started organized", "3a-9EBNms3c-00455-00117023-00117213": "and as a member of the IWW", "3a-9EBNms3c-00456-00117214-00117550": "I held no official position I've worked", "3a-9EBNms3c-00457-00117551-00117840": "in Pietra on-and-off ten years end to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00458-00117841-00118199": "end and I've been organizing there", "3a-9EBNms3c-00459-00118200-00118433": "I think in total for about two years", "3a-9EBNms3c-00460-00118433-00118769": "solidly and as a you know as an employee", "3a-9EBNms3c-00461-00118770-00119236": "of Peter and the focus at that point was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00462-00119238-00119507": "very much around building membership in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00463-00119508-00119741": "that store where I worked and in a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00464-00119742-00119969": "couple of other ones close by it was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00465-00119970-00120346": "about winning lots of small battles", "3a-9EBNms3c-00466-00120347-00120815": "getting new activists involved which you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00467-00120816-00121325": "know was works very well and to be one", "3a-9EBNms3c-00468-00121326-00121481": "where actually fairly easy from within", "3a-9EBNms3c-00469-00121482-00121703": "you know out having that grounding have", "3a-9EBNms3c-00470-00121704-00121840": "been there for a long time and also", "3a-9EBNms3c-00471-00121841-00122341": "knowing those people on a personal level", "3a-9EBNms3c-00472-00122342-00122951": "and I think sorry you were one of the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00473-00122952-00123136": "good ways that this played out is that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00474-00123138-00123401": "you were there for every occurrence you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00475-00123402-00123610": "know every little thing that happens you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00476-00123611-00123811": "were involved in it yeah yeah you had", "3a-9EBNms3c-00477-00123813-00123980": "all those opportunities to organize", "3a-9EBNms3c-00478-00123981-00124133": "because you didn't have to wait two or", "3a-9EBNms3c-00479-00124133-00124298": "three days until you'd heard about it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00480-00124299-00124481": "you would have been there when something", "3a-9EBNms3c-00481-00124482-00125000": "happens so for example a guy who had", "3a-9EBNms3c-00482-00125001-00125264": "been quite involved with the Union had", "3a-9EBNms3c-00483-00125265-00125470": "been a member but really done nothing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00484-00125471-00125750": "found himself in trouble of getting to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00485-00125751-00126017": "work late for a really legitimate reason", "3a-9EBNms3c-00486-00126018-00126239": "that tractor bollock him for it and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00487-00126240-00126407": "actually it gave me a really good", "3a-9EBNms3c-00488-00126408-00126559": "opportunity to step in with a couple of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00489-00126560-00126776": "a couple of other members and stand up", "3a-9EBNms3c-00490-00126777-00126968": "for him and have like a march on the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00491-00126969-00127133": "boss there and then and do something", "3a-9EBNms3c-00492-00127133-00127532": "about it and you know but on the flip", "3a-9EBNms3c-00493-00127533-00127700": "side of that you've also got all of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00494-00127701-00127808": "those pressures as someone who's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00495-00127808-00127952": "actually working in there you know it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00496-00127953-00128165": "not it's also hell of a lot more", "3a-9EBNms3c-00497-00128166-00128339": "stressful a hell of a lot more difficult", "3a-9EBNms3c-00498-00128340-00128696": "in a lot of other different ways and how", "3a-9EBNms3c-00499-00128697-00128945": "that changed I guess is I will add left", "3a-9EBNms3c-00500-00128946-00129083": "piece what's not working for peace or", "3a-9EBNms3c-00501-00129083-00129353": "and took on a role of an official in the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00502-00129354-00129665": "edge of the W so I became regional", "3a-9EBNms3c-00503-00129666-00129886": "organizer and for the north of England", "3a-9EBNms3c-00504-00129888-00130358": "and that shifted my focus personally to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00505-00130358-00130570": "something a bit more region-wide", "3a-9EBNms3c-00506-00130571-00130933": "building for big wins breaking into new", "3a-9EBNms3c-00507-00130934-00131141": "stores outside of Sheffield where we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00508-00131142-00131331": "started", "3a-9EBNms3c-00509-00131332-00131569": "while also and I think this is really", "3a-9EBNms3c-00510-00131570-00131710": "important and something that comes into", "3a-9EBNms3c-00511-00131711-00132025": "it being really distracted by internal", "3a-9EBNms3c-00512-00132026-00132265": "Union politics you know I think I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00513-00132266-00132478": "that's where when we're talking about", "3a-9EBNms3c-00514-00132479-00132849": "that franticness that comes from", "3a-9EBNms3c-00515-00132850-00133072": "mobilizing I do think part of that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00516-00133073-00133363": "frantic frantic attitude actually comes", "3a-9EBNms3c-00517-00133364-00133590": "from our own mindset inside the inside", "3a-9EBNms3c-00518-00133591-00133801": "of our own unions because we'll get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00519-00133802-00133999": "stressed inside my home Union and get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00520-00134000-00134227": "and end up focusing on quick wins and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00521-00134228-00134647": "quick gains yeah and it did make it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00522-00134648-00134860": "easier once you've got that distance as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00523-00134861-00135073": "well to be damaged by turnover be", "3a-9EBNms3c-00524-00135074-00135364": "damaged by things that people regularly", "3a-9EBNms3c-00525-00135365-00135535": "point to his issues and service sector", "3a-9EBNms3c-00526-00135536-00135793": "organizing it also meant that you quit", "3a-9EBNms3c-00527-00135794-00135949": "lost connection with that workforce as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00528-00135950-00136099": "well once you've got that distance and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00529-00136100-00136336": "it quickly did it really did then", "3a-9EBNms3c-00530-00136337-00136594": "refocus itself to become mobilizing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00531-00136595-00136984": "because it really changed how how the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00532-00136985-00137182": "work was going on inside peace or at", "3a-9EBNms3c-00533-00137183-00137581": "that point it was good for the Union on", "3a-9EBNms3c-00534-00137582-00137773": "a wider scale because it meant that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00535-00137774-00138163": "those activists who got involved with me", "3a-9EBNms3c-00536-00138164-00138378": "also took on other roles inside the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00537-00138379-00138639": "branch and and at a national level I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00538-00138640-00138903": "fought the bad side of that though it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00539-00138904-00139075": "wasn't very long term you know there's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00540-00139076-00139297": "those people didn't stay involved for", "3a-9EBNms3c-00541-00139298-00139477": "evidence they involved in the long term", "3a-9EBNms3c-00542-00139478-00139786": "it really energized the Sheffield branch", "3a-9EBNms3c-00543-00139787-00139918": "and I think that still plays out to a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00544-00139919-00140281": "certain extent but it really made the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00545-00140282-00140521": "Union a third party think and start at", "3a-9EBNms3c-00546-00140522-00140695": "that distance and made it bigger and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00547-00140696-00141051": "bigger as it went along and so I guess", "3a-9EBNms3c-00548-00141052-00141322": "coming back to the to the wider question", "3a-9EBNms3c-00549-00141323-00141586": "is how do we how do we make sure we keep", "3a-9EBNms3c-00550-00141587-00141856": "that organizing focus because we we can", "3a-9EBNms3c-00551-00141857-00142171": "and also we shouldn't be discouraging", "3a-9EBNms3c-00552-00142172-00142552": "our organizers and activists on the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00553-00142553-00142744": "ground from taking on roles as officials", "3a-9EBNms3c-00554-00142745-00142927": "obviously we want people to be doing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00555-00142928-00143086": "that we want people to be working the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00556-00143087-00143293": "way up inside the Union and taking on", "3a-9EBNms3c-00557-00143294-00143440": "different roles taking on different", "3a-9EBNms3c-00558-00143441-00143677": "stuff but how do we make sure that that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00559-00143678-00143865": "doesn't break down now I think part of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00560-00143866-00144127": "that is that we do need to maintain that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00561-00144128-00144351": "focus of building wider committees and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00562-00144352-00144606": "we're places we need to be building more", "3a-9EBNms3c-00563-00144607-00144813": "than just one rep or one organizer or", "3a-9EBNms3c-00564-00144814-00145071": "just going in and supporting that one", "3a-9EBNms3c-00565-00145072-00145209": "person we need to be building something", "3a-9EBNms3c-00566-00145210-00145386": "bigger I know it's kind of like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00567-00145387-00145695": "repeating old all that stuff about how", "3a-9EBNms3c-00568-00145696-00145875": "what organizing means but that is what", "3a-9EBNms3c-00569-00145876-00146271": "we need to be remain that's what we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00570-00146272-00146442": "would need to remain focused on that's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00571-00146443-00146700": "where we need to keep our focus building", "3a-9EBNms3c-00572-00146701-00146874": "those workplace committees not just one", "3a-9EBNms3c-00573-00146875-00147351": "shop steward so I wonder mmm because", "3a-9EBNms3c-00574-00147352-00147570": "this is a this story is something that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00575-00147571-00147888": "is at least trim like base unions", "3a-9EBNms3c-00576-00147889-00148062": "perspective something that's repeated", "3a-9EBNms3c-00577-00148063-00148347": "quite often I think in more recent", "3a-9EBNms3c-00578-00148348-00148734": "history a lot of the delivery staff has", "3a-9EBNms3c-00579-00148735-00148950": "faced this challenge always immediately", "3a-9EBNms3c-00580-00148951-00149295": "like really active organizing committees", "3a-9EBNms3c-00581-00149296-00149736": "in Bristol Bradford doing good work and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00582-00149737-00150168": "then stepping up often seems to be the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00583-00150169-00150432": "thing that presents the challenge and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00584-00150433-00150636": "then leads to kind of a weakening of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00585-00150637-00150896": "that kind of organizing base ultimately", "3a-9EBNms3c-00586-00150897-00151299": "and I do wonder if like yes scalability", "3a-9EBNms3c-00587-00151300-00151803": "is often what draws us into those kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00588-00151804-00152273": "of bad tactics in the sense that like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00589-00152274-00152541": "maintaining like an organized committee", "3a-9EBNms3c-00590-00152542-00152811": "in one shop it was hard work it was a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00591-00152812-00152988": "lot of hard work a lot of energy a lot", "3a-9EBNms3c-00592-00152989-00153447": "of effort into that now for any other", "3a-9EBNms3c-00593-00153448-00153531": "business", "3a-9EBNms3c-00594-00153532-00153651": "we could probably could have walked away", "3a-9EBNms3c-00595-00153652-00153840": "with that as a win right but pizza is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00596-00153841-00154458": "like a global chain right so you like in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00597-00154459-00154779": "through the kind of like absolute sheer", "3a-9EBNms3c-00598-00154780-00154983": "size of that company in their power that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00599-00154984-00155235": "that and they don't say this to be like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00600-00155236-00155439": "cynic or in sawing it sounds pretty fab", "3a-9EBNms3c-00601-00155440-00155634": "like no thetic right yeah yeah like it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00602-00155635-00155886": "like you organized a shop no in like but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00603-00155887-00156123": "we know how much effort they write and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00604-00156124-00156318": "we know we know how hard that was and I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00605-00156319-00156456": "think yet delivery routes kind of a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00606-00156457-00156654": "comparable thing that you have like to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00607-00156655-00156819": "maintain that for a group of careers in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00608-00156820-00157071": "a city it was probably like you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00609-00157072-00157377": "huge amounts of effort but then it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00610-00157378-00157572": "yeah it's a knowingly a national company", "3a-9EBNms3c-00611-00157573-00157647": "but an", "3a-9EBNms3c-00612-00157648-00158090": "company as well so scale presents", "3a-9EBNms3c-00613-00158091-00158361": "yourself as a real problem I think given", "3a-9EBNms3c-00614-00158362-00158589": "the challenges that we're facing and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00615-00158590-00158919": "he's natural when we're kind of facing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00616-00158920-00159102": "these bear moth-like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00617-00159103-00159453": "companies to think we need to try and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00618-00159454-00159648": "act bigger than we are right we need to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00619-00159649-00159810": "mobilize because that makes us look big", "3a-9EBNms3c-00620-00159811-00160127": "or makes us feel bigger rather than", "3a-9EBNms3c-00621-00160128-00160440": "concentrating on maybe the less exciting", "3a-9EBNms3c-00622-00160441-00160650": "stuff but the stuff that actually gets", "3a-9EBNms3c-00623-00160651-00161052": "us where we want to go yeah and I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00624-00161053-00161289": "and I think how this is then played out", "3a-9EBNms3c-00625-00161290-00161553": "in in other trade unions as well and I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00626-00161554-00161736": "think you know the other thing this is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00627-00161737-00162053": "gonna happen in unions like back to and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00628-00162054-00162303": "it's also gonna happen for the Baker's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00629-00162304-00162738": "union as well is that very quickly those", "3a-9EBNms3c-00630-00162739-00162929": "people who have been involved in the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00631-00162930-00163194": "picturehouse dispute those people who", "3a-9EBNms3c-00632-00163195-00163304": "have been involved in the McDonald's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00633-00163305-00163677": "dispute they are gonna be they are gonna", "3a-9EBNms3c-00634-00163678-00163995": "be snapped up for paid positions inside", "3a-9EBNms3c-00635-00163996-00164265": "those organizations because because", "3a-9EBNms3c-00636-00164266-00164397": "they've got you know because I've got", "3a-9EBNms3c-00637-00164398-00164589": "ideas because they've got because", "3a-9EBNms3c-00638-00164590-00164793": "they're young because they're you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00639-00164794-00165276": "they're much more diverse than the the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00640-00165277-00165594": "current stock of paid officials in those", "3a-9EBNms3c-00641-00165595-00165885": "organizations and and there's a real", "3a-9EBNms3c-00642-00165886-00166028": "attractiveness to getting those people", "3a-9EBNms3c-00643-00166029-00166224": "into those and for good reason as well", "3a-9EBNms3c-00644-00166225-00166371": "it's not it's not something that should", "3a-9EBNms3c-00645-00166372-00166515": "be discouraged so it's great that they", "3a-9EBNms3c-00646-00166516-00166707": "want those people to take on roles and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00647-00166708-00166856": "it will happen very quickly and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00648-00166857-00167184": "obviously people work in minimum wage", "3a-9EBNms3c-00649-00167185-00167579": "jobs or there abouts will obviously one", "3a-9EBNms3c-00650-00167580-00167951": "a thirty to forty five grand a year", "3a-9EBNms3c-00651-00167952-00168231": "salaried position with good terms and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00652-00168232-00168438": "conditions it's you know it's completely", "3a-9EBNms3c-00653-00168439-00168707": "natural that they would want that but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00654-00168708-00169068": "what then happens is all of those good", "3a-9EBNms3c-00655-00169069-00169248": "people get sucked up into the internal", "3a-9EBNms3c-00656-00169249-00169602": "Union machinery and will end up doing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00657-00169603-00169790": "something else or we'll end up do you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00658-00169791-00170066": "know being somewhere else and those", "3a-9EBNms3c-00659-00170067-00170321": "committees that formed around those", "3a-9EBNms3c-00660-00170322-00170676": "people with a natural talent for", "3a-9EBNms3c-00661-00170677-00170891": "leadership or a natural talent for", "3a-9EBNms3c-00662-00170892-00171233": "encouraging others will will be gone and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00663-00171234-00171425": "those committees that fall apart", "3a-9EBNms3c-00664-00171426-00171641": "yeah around them so I think it's it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00665-00171642-00172103": "it's you know it it's different it's a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00666-00172104-00172271": "difficult call isn't it because you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00667-00172272-00172433": "inside the IWW we don't want to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00668-00172434-00172571": "discourage people from taking on other", "3a-9EBNms3c-00669-00172572-00172736": "roles inside the wider trade union", "3a-9EBNms3c-00670-00172737-00172886": "movement obviously we don't want to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00671-00172887-00173051": "discourage people from moving into those", "3a-9EBNms3c-00672-00173052-00173201": "jobs if they if that's what they want to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00673-00173202-00173609": "do and but we need to build those wider", "3a-9EBNms3c-00674-00173610-00173768": "committees that we need to there needs", "3a-9EBNms3c-00675-00173769-00173954": "to be more strength and I think it does", "3a-9EBNms3c-00676-00173955-00174053": "come back to that point that you were", "3a-9EBNms3c-00677-00174054-00174346": "making earlier that actually ultimately", "3a-9EBNms3c-00678-00174347-00174674": "the biggest problem here is actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00679-00174675-00174830": "that we are sorry you didn't make that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00680-00174831-00175526": "you made that before we ice you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00681-00175527-00175838": "that twice make up for trade unions it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00682-00175839-00175949": "a point you're going to make in the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00683-00175950-00176573": "future I will make that case I won't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00684-00176574-00177116": "make this point though because I've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00685-00177117-00177305": "experienced anything comparable in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00686-00177306-00177479": "London video in terms of the campaign's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00687-00177480-00177659": "like have you found it difficult to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00688-00177660-00178189": "maintain organizing as the focus over", "3a-9EBNms3c-00689-00178190-00178955": "mobilizing um I think in London we've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00690-00178956-00179123": "made I think we've been making a real", "3a-9EBNms3c-00691-00179124-00179543": "effort around strategy like I mean just", "3a-9EBNms3c-00692-00179544-00179798": "over a year ago we had a big strategy", "3a-9EBNms3c-00693-00179799-00180224": "meeting and that's where we decided that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00694-00180225-00180463": "we were going to focus on West London", "3a-9EBNms3c-00695-00180464-00180821": "and there and an organizing campaign in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00696-00180822-00181010": "the factories and warehouses in West", "3a-9EBNms3c-00697-00181011-00181430": "London where some some members worked", "3a-9EBNms3c-00698-00181431-00181682": "and had been like doing a bit of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00699-00181683-00181958": "organizing well actually a lot of good", "3a-9EBNms3c-00700-00181959-00182332": "organizing over a number of years and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00701-00182333-00182737": "the problem I guess the problem we found", "3a-9EBNms3c-00702-00182738-00183176": "is just I guess it's the age-old problem", "3a-9EBNms3c-00703-00183177-00183353": "of people are like very enthusiastic", "3a-9EBNms3c-00704-00183354-00183692": "about it initially but it's just a real", "3a-9EBNms3c-00705-00183693-00184130": "and it's quite it can be a bit of a slog", "3a-9EBNms3c-00706-00184131-00184313": "it's a lot of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00707-00184314-00184538": "hard work like you know a lot of kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00708-00184539-00184799": "try finding people that can do", "3a-9EBNms3c-00709-00184800-00185084": "translations for leaflets and standing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00710-00185085-00185354": "out in the freezing cold at like 6:00 in", "3a-9EBNms3c-00711-00185355-00185534": "the morning in a bit of London which is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00712-00185535-00185711": "really difficult to get to you for lots", "3a-9EBNms3c-00713-00185712-00186116": "of members and actually what we could do", "3a-9EBNms3c-00714-00186117-00186479": "is is like a bit of a kind of nice quick", "3a-9EBNms3c-00715-00186480-00186812": "mobilization and you know to kind of win", "3a-9EBNms3c-00716-00186813-00186986": "something and have something kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00717-00186987-00187427": "exciting happen to kind of galvanize", "3a-9EBNms3c-00718-00187428-00187799": "people and it's interesting there isn't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00719-00187800-00187952": "at the moment there hasn't been an", "3a-9EBNms3c-00720-00187953-00188150": "opportunity for that it's this kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00721-00188151-00188393": "early stage and I think what's happening", "3a-9EBNms3c-00722-00188394-00188681": "is really good but it does make it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00723-00188682-00188912": "difficult to kind of get keep people", "3a-9EBNms3c-00724-00188913-00189080": "interested and I think that's the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00725-00189081-00189203": "problem we've been having in the branch", "3a-9EBNms3c-00726-00189204-00189653": "is kind of people are looking at what's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00727-00189654-00189974": "happening in some of the other these", "3a-9EBNms3c-00728-00189975-00190175": "like grass grassroots unions these like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00729-00190176-00190469": "really inspiring demos and these a mate", "3a-9EBNms3c-00730-00190470-00190685": "like amazing winds like you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-00731-00190686-00191075": "transforming you know lies for sort of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00732-00191076-00191264": "outsourced workers formerly outsourced", "3a-9EBNms3c-00733-00191265-00191522": "workers now and universities in London", "3a-9EBNms3c-00734-00191523-00191771": "and actually what what we're doing at", "3a-9EBNms3c-00735-00191772-00192268": "the moment is cold and a bit dreary and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00736-00192269-00192542": "but really important and it's I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00737-00192543-00192737": "it's like keeping the enthusiasm up for", "3a-9EBNms3c-00738-00192738-00193027": "these like long term strategic", "3a-9EBNms3c-00739-00193028-00193229": "organizing campaigns that can be quite", "3a-9EBNms3c-00740-00193230-00193532": "difficult do you think so obviously like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00741-00193533-00193927": "with the West London campaign it was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00742-00193928-00194213": "well look you may be correct me here are", "3a-9EBNms3c-00743-00194214-00194318": "any of the people involved in the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00744-00194319-00194554": "campaign like working in the in a way", "3a-9EBNms3c-00745-00194555-00194894": "okay yeah so that's what that's kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00746-00194895-00195131": "why we went with that there were kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00747-00195132-00195440": "a few different options that people had", "3a-9EBNms3c-00748-00195441-00195614": "brought along to the strategy meeting", "3a-9EBNms3c-00749-00195615-00195839": "but the thing that made this so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00750-00195840-00196226": "appealing was that we have yeah a number", "3a-9EBNms3c-00751-00196227-00196502": "of and more and more and people that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00752-00196503-00196685": "work in the warehouse and the factories", "3a-9EBNms3c-00753-00196686-00197108": "and live in the area as well so so they", "3a-9EBNms3c-00754-00197109-00197297": "kind of had a really good sense of the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00755-00197298-00197480": "conditions there they've been kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00756-00197481-00197531": "published", "3a-9EBNms3c-00757-00197532-00197837": "a really great newsletter called workers", "3a-9EBNms3c-00758-00197838-00198092": "Wild West for a number of years and so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00759-00198093-00198299": "there was really basically a lot of the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00760-00198300-00198695": "research had been done by by a couple of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00761-00198696-00198941": "people in the branch and that's laid a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00762-00198942-00199148": "foundation for us to kind of so we knew", "3a-9EBNms3c-00763-00199149-00199550": "where to focus which has really helped", "3a-9EBNms3c-00764-00199551-00199820": "so yeah that's why we decided to go with", "3a-9EBNms3c-00765-00199821-00200114": "with West London and I suppose that that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00766-00200115-00200357": "then because because going back to Peter", "3a-9EBNms3c-00767-00200358-00200540": "one of the central problems like he's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00768-00200541-00200954": "saying and a lot of campaigns is well", "3a-9EBNms3c-00769-00200955-00201152": "it's the difficulty of taking this step", "3a-9EBNms3c-00770-00201153-00201338": "up but also the fact like you say that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00771-00201339-00201503": "the people were central to the effort", "3a-9EBNms3c-00772-00201504-00201689": "tend to be picked off all drawn", "3a-9EBNms3c-00773-00201690-00201961": "elsewhere or just naturally leave right", "3a-9EBNms3c-00774-00201962-00202292": "so hopefully with that project those", "3a-9EBNms3c-00775-00202293-00202472": "people at least provide you with like an", "3a-9EBNms3c-00776-00202473-00202838": "anchor that will keep things going in an", "3a-9EBNms3c-00777-00202839-00203102": "organic way even if kind of the formal", "3a-9EBNms3c-00778-00203103-00203342": "efforts are kind of kind of more of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00779-00203343-00203582": "intense and dipping offers and periods", "3a-9EBNms3c-00780-00203583-00203849": "of time yeah it's really soon that you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00781-00203850-00204101": "talk about like a strategy bein like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00782-00204102-00204269": "that because because actually that was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00783-00204270-00204467": "something we did in Sheffield as well", "3a-9EBNms3c-00784-00204468-00204755": "after the the peaceful campaign sort of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00785-00204756-00205250": "dipped off and I think it was as I was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00786-00205251-00205465": "leaving his regional organizer at the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00787-00205466-00205658": "time we actually held a strategy meeting", "3a-9EBNms3c-00788-00205659-00205844": "got a lot of people from across the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00789-00205844-00206096": "whole of the northern region together to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00790-00206096-00206330": "discuss what what we're gonna do you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00791-00206331-00206582": "know because it was felt that we needed", "3a-9EBNms3c-00792-00206583-00206866": "needed that kind of actual focus that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00793-00206867-00207101": "kind of there needs to be that campaign", "3a-9EBNms3c-00794-00207102-00207389": "in focus and again it came back to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00795-00207390-00207794": "similar sort of folk they have similar", "3a-9EBNms3c-00796-00207794-00208031": "sort of ideas of actually need to be", "3a-9EBNms3c-00797-00208032-00208157": "looking where we are because there was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00798-00208158-00208298": "some really great ideas you know about", "3a-9EBNms3c-00799-00208298-00208634": "organizing around a big curry chain up", "3a-9EBNms3c-00800-00208635-00209044": "here and our another suggestion was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00801-00209044-00209546": "organizing in agriculture the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00802-00209546-00209792": "agricultural industry and but then that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00803-00209792-00210059": "the one that that people suggested was", "3a-9EBNms3c-00804-00210060-00210404": "the best ones get for was reinvesting an", "3a-9EBNms3c-00805-00210405-00210664": "effort into organizing and pizza", "3a-9EBNms3c-00806-00210665-00210876": "again it was more like mobilizing but at", "3a-9EBNms3c-00807-00210877-00211042": "least at the time it was saying right we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00808-00211042-00211263": "need to go for that one because actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00809-00211264-00211467": "that's where we do our members that's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00810-00211469-00211725": "where we've got people you know is the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00811-00211726-00211896": "other ones are great ideas and great", "3a-9EBNms3c-00812-00211897-00212178": "campaigns but actually we don't have", "3a-9EBNms3c-00813-00212179-00212406": "anyone there you know it's it's a nice", "3a-9EBNms3c-00814-00212407-00212644": "theoretical idea but actually all would", "3a-9EBNms3c-00815-00212644-00212850": "be doing will just be mobilizing the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00816-00212851-00213047": "same old faces with no actual", "3a-9EBNms3c-00817-00213048-00213345": "constituents see to build on I was just", "3a-9EBNms3c-00818-00213346-00213677": "gonna say that um it's been interesting", "3a-9EBNms3c-00819-00213678-00214042": "having a strategic focus I think there", "3a-9EBNms3c-00820-00214042-00214250": "was a bit of a worry in the branch that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00821-00214251-00214470": "everything would be focused around West", "3a-9EBNms3c-00822-00214471-00214650": "London that's all we do and because it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00823-00214651-00215046": "quite I mean London's massive and this", "3a-9EBNms3c-00824-00215047-00215349": "is really really far out west and so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00825-00215350-00215529": "people were kind of concerned that if it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00826-00215530-00215751": "wasn't viable for them to get over there", "3a-9EBNms3c-00827-00215752-00215946": "that you know how were they going to be", "3a-9EBNms3c-00828-00215947-00216364": "involved in in organising more generally", "3a-9EBNms3c-00829-00216365-00216541": "actually what's happened is it's like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00830-00216542-00216917": "really helped to revive the kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00831-00216919-00217141": "organizing in all kinds of different", "3a-9EBNms3c-00832-00217142-00217446": "workplaces so there was a bit of a slump", "3a-9EBNms3c-00833-00217447-00217707": "and actually I think since we started", "3a-9EBNms3c-00834-00217708-00217983": "the West London campaign we've been", "3a-9EBNms3c-00835-00217984-00218194": "doing an awful lot more organizing I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00836-00218194-00218464": "mean there are the factors as well it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00837-00218465-00218598": "kind of there's a confluence of things", "3a-9EBNms3c-00838-00218599-00218871": "but I do think having something that's", "3a-9EBNms3c-00839-00218872-00219244": "like very focused around organizing has", "3a-9EBNms3c-00840-00219244-00219579": "kind of changed the way people think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00841-00219580-00219747": "about what we should be doing and we've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00842-00219748-00220104": "got lots of really promising promising", "3a-9EBNms3c-00843-00220105-00220308": "things on the horizon and and just like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00844-00220309-00220596": "a lot of enthusiasm in the branch which", "3a-9EBNms3c-00845-00220597-00221016": "there was a lack of before so it's um", "3a-9EBNms3c-00846-00221017-00221217": "it's hard because I think at the moment", "3a-9EBNms3c-00847-00221219-00221427": "we're still early stages with West", "3a-9EBNms3c-00848-00221428-00221627": "London and we have you know there's a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00849-00221628-00222054": "like oh saying is it feels like a kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00850-00222055-00222278": "of a grind rather than a kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00851-00222279-00222538": "something that's you can be kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00852-00222539-00222783": "super enthusiastic about but it's just", "3a-9EBNms3c-00853-00222784-00223005": "people are kind of people are getting", "3a-9EBNms3c-00854-00223006-00223288": "organized in the branch now which you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00855-00223289-00223428": "know wasn't happening before I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00856-00223429-00223752": "part of it is just kind of we've got a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00857-00223753-00223963": "bit of a model for right now well since", "3a-9EBNms3c-00858-00223964-00223987": "we're", "3a-9EBNms3c-00859-00223988-00224209": "sort of moved on to kind of strategy and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00860-00224210-00224377": "tactics and orientation it probably", "3a-9EBNms3c-00861-00224378-00224614": "makes sense to move on to the final", "3a-9EBNms3c-00862-00224615-00225034": "section which we told if it's so good", "3a-9EBNms3c-00863-00225035-00225288": "why don't we do it all the time", "3a-9EBNms3c-00864-00225289-00225889": "organizing that the because so far we've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00865-00225890-00226221": "made mobilizing some really good oh yeah", "3a-9EBNms3c-00866-00226221-00226675": "so yeah there's there's two there's two", "3a-9EBNms3c-00867-00226676-00227017": "angles that that I wanted to come out", "3a-9EBNms3c-00868-00227017-00227503": "this the first is kind of to make I've", "3a-9EBNms3c-00869-00227504-00227805": "got a basic kind of political point that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00870-00227806-00228117": "the trade union leadership or trade", "3a-9EBNms3c-00871-00228119-00228421": "unionism as ideological construct as a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00872-00228421-00228601": "way of kind of interacting with the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00873-00228602-00228769": "world as a way of organizing workers", "3a-9EBNms3c-00874-00228769-00229060": "like is a social partnership model it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00875-00229061-00229296": "kind of organizes on the basis that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00876-00229296-00229564": "workers have rights are entitled to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00877-00229565-00229837": "certain benefits in work that they need", "3a-9EBNms3c-00878-00229838-00230094": "to be treated well but ultimately is not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00879-00230096-00230317": "transformative like it doesn't want to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00880-00230317-00230527": "get rid of the the way they does want to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00881-00230528-00230725": "change the way the economy is organized", "3a-9EBNms3c-00882-00230726-00230896": "it doesn't want to get rid of the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00883-00230896-00231109": "concepts of the manager and a boss and a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00884-00231110-00231280": "worker and it doesn't want to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00885-00231281-00231502": "fundamentally shift the balance of power", "3a-9EBNms3c-00886-00231503-00231694": "in the workplace and that kind of so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00887-00231694-00232098": "social partnership model tends to as a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00888-00232100-00232312": "tendency and it's difficult because I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00889-00232313-00232435": "don't want a black-and-white statements", "3a-9EBNms3c-00890-00232436-00232765": "here because I think there's there's not", "3a-9EBNms3c-00891-00232766-00232915": "a single trade union even the most", "3a-9EBNms3c-00892-00232916-00233092": "right-wing ones that fit into this", "3a-9EBNms3c-00893-00233092-00233434": "absolute analysis but there's a tendency", "3a-9EBNms3c-00894-00233435-00233860": "within all trade unions to push towards", "3a-9EBNms3c-00895-00233861-00234073": "an area where something can be", "3a-9EBNms3c-00896-00234073-00234361": "negotiated and for that reason like an", "3a-9EBNms3c-00897-00234362-00234640": "active and a militant base is ultimately", "3a-9EBNms3c-00898-00234641-00234873": "only as useful as it can give you a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00899-00234875-00235156": "negotiating position and that means that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00900-00235157-00235381": "ultimate limit of kind of rank-and-file", "3a-9EBNms3c-00901-00235382-00235789": "is kind of you can't you can go to the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00902-00235790-00235990": "negotiation ago she ate some table but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00903-00235991-00236185": "no further that there can't be any kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-00904-00236186-00236428": "of fundamental challenge to who does the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00905-00236429-00236598": "negotiation for what end", "3a-9EBNms3c-00906-00236600-00236892": "in happen so for that reason I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-00907-00236894-00237040": "there is a tendency to push towards", "3a-9EBNms3c-00908-00237041-00237384": "mobilizing because mobilizing presents", "3a-9EBNms3c-00909-00237385-00237546": "the image of a very kind of active", "3a-9EBNms3c-00910-00237548-00237778": "rank-and-file present the image of a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00911-00237779-00237964": "very Medicine Union but in reality as", "3a-9EBNms3c-00912-00237965-00238219": "we've talked about is not like it", "3a-9EBNms3c-00913-00238219-00238339": "doesn't activate the base it doesn't", "3a-9EBNms3c-00914-00238340-00238548": "present any kind of transformative", "3a-9EBNms3c-00915-00238550-00238750": "alternatives to like how we could", "3a-9EBNms3c-00916-00238751-00238935": "organize social goods or the economy or", "3a-9EBNms3c-00917-00238936-00239146": "your workplace or change the management", "3a-9EBNms3c-00918-00239146-00239646": "of of capitalism essentially now so I", "3a-9EBNms3c-00919-00239648-00239823": "think that's that's one thing that at", "3a-9EBNms3c-00920-00239825-00239980": "one point asked me why don't the trade", "3a-9EBNms3c-00921-00239981-00240123": "unions do this all the time well because", "3a-9EBNms3c-00922-00240125-00240304": "fundamentally it's not within that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00923-00240305-00240439": "ideology least not being the net", "3a-9EBNms3c-00924-00240440-00240703": "interest to do it however having said", "3a-9EBNms3c-00925-00240704-00240883": "that as we as we talked about throughout", "3a-9EBNms3c-00926-00240884-00241156": "the course of this discussion many", "3a-9EBNms3c-00927-00241157-00241675": "well-meaning libertarian anti-capitalist", "3a-9EBNms3c-00928-00241676-00241996": "Marxist activists will mobilize instead", "3a-9EBNms3c-00929-00241996-00242152": "of organizing and we've set ourselves", "3a-9EBNms3c-00930-00242153-00242377": "that we've had the temptation to be", "3a-9EBNms3c-00931-00242378-00242598": "drawn into these things or we've ended", "3a-9EBNms3c-00932-00242600-00242769": "up in these places for various reasons", "3a-9EBNms3c-00933-00242771-00243088": "and I think there maybe is kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00934-00243089-00243253": "something else going on here which is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00935-00243254-00243625": "important to consider and that is that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00936-00243626-00244027": "actually organizing as an alternative to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00937-00244028-00244300": "mobilizing is very slow it's very", "3a-9EBNms3c-00938-00244301-00244567": "difficult it can be very draining and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00939-00244567-00244978": "it's often as little even go for the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00940-00244979-00245217": "perfect example can be very hard and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00941-00245219-00245476": "boring and a slog and cold and wet right", "3a-9EBNms3c-00942-00245477-00245982": "so and I think this is something that so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00943-00245983-00246196": "maybe maybe it's simply that this is", "3a-9EBNms3c-00944-00246196-00246550": "kind of like a political battle there", "3a-9EBNms3c-00945-00246551-00246730": "has to be one amongst like like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00946-00246731-00246957": "activists and leftist the like actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-00947-00246958-00247219": "this is what we should be doing or you", "3a-9EBNms3c-00948-00247219-00247351": "know maybe there is kind of this thing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00949-00247352-00247603": "of like is there a way that we can", "3a-9EBNms3c-00950-00247604-00247860": "reformulate our models of organizing to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00951-00247861-00248137": "address a sense of urgency because the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00952-00248138-00248334": "this is the problem we have that we're", "3a-9EBNms3c-00953-00248335-00248596": "in a position where a lot of people want", "3a-9EBNms3c-00954-00248596-00248892": "in trade unions clapping a trade unions", "3a-9EBNms3c-00955-00248894-00249115": "have been defeated historically for 20", "3a-9EBNms3c-00956-00249116-00249513": "30 years now and yet we have like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00957-00249514-00249875": "skyrocketing poverty austerity condition", "3a-9EBNms3c-00958-00249876-00250083": "increasingly precarious work like we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00959-00250084-00250512": "need to act and you know saying well we", "3a-9EBNms3c-00960-00250513-00250707": "might be able to do something in five", "3a-9EBNms3c-00961-00250708-00250863": "years 10 years 15 years", "3a-9EBNms3c-00962-00250864-00251048": "doesn't seem like an adequate response", "3a-9EBNms3c-00963-00251050-00251280": "if that's the timescale we were working", "3a-9EBNms3c-00964-00251281-00251583": "with I I didn't say at the beginning I'm", "3a-9EBNms3c-00965-00251584-00251790": "a history teacher but he is a historical", "3a-9EBNms3c-00966-00251791-00252119": "example - let's take this point just to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00967-00252121-00252419": "finish off so general Fabius he was like", "3a-9EBNms3c-00968-00252421-00252639": "an ancient Roman general and he's then", "3a-9EBNms3c-00969-00252640-00252858": "he's the general where the Fabian's get", "3a-9EBNms3c-00970-00252859-00253077": "a name from Fabian's are like a", "3a-9EBNms3c-00971-00253078-00253404": "socialist reform Society and general", "3a-9EBNms3c-00972-00253405-00253581": "Fabius said patience is a virtue that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00973-00253582-00253857": "was his famous thing and he had that he", "3a-9EBNms3c-00974-00253858-00254112": "had that as his slogan because to defeat", "3a-9EBNms3c-00975-00254113-00254421": "the Carthaginian general Hannibal he", "3a-9EBNms3c-00976-00254421-00254631": "decided the best way of doing it was to", "3a-9EBNms3c-00977-00254632-00254991": "not engage him in an outright battle but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00978-00254992-00255298": "too slowly wear him down with skirmishes", "3a-9EBNms3c-00979-00255300-00255504": "skirmishes that would take years and", "3a-9EBNms3c-00980-00255505-00255819": "years and years and years now he lost", "3a-9EBNms3c-00981-00255819-00256062": "his job the Senate got rid of him okay", "3a-9EBNms3c-00982-00256063-00256236": "they got rid of him and they said you're", "3a-9EBNms3c-00983-00256237-00256401": "not doing a good job he's not going", "3a-9EBNms3c-00984-00256402-00256554": "quick enough every historian of", "3a-9EBNms3c-00985-00256555-00256785": "knowledge is that general Fabius had the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00986-00256786-00257079": "right way of being Hannibal but at the", "3a-9EBNms3c-00987-00257080-00257321": "time it was deemed completely inadequate", "3a-9EBNms3c-00988-00257323-00257538": "and he lost the support of everyone", "3a-9EBNms3c-00989-00257539-00257784": "around him so like this is the thing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00990-00257785-00258023": "that we don't want to turn into that", "3a-9EBNms3c-00991-00258025-00258242": "general Fabius and just be nothing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00992-00258242-00258615": "afterwards afterwards we were right but", "3a-9EBNms3c-00993-00258616-00258786": "no one is listening to us", "3a-9EBNms3c-00994-00258787-00259041": "yeah we're completely isolated cuz", "3a-9EBNms3c-00995-00259042-00259263": "that's that's like the classic Marxist", "3a-9EBNms3c-00996-00259264-00259467": "position anyway isn't it right knowing", "3a-9EBNms3c-00997-00259467-00259785": "you're right but no one's listening so", "3a-9EBNms3c-00998-00259786-00259902": "what you're saying is everyone will", "3a-9EBNms3c-00999-00259903-00260088": "think we're inadequate until maybe like", "3a-9EBNms3c-01000-00260089-00260327": "three hundred years the future exactly", "3a-9EBNms3c-01001-00260328-00260648": "so so yeah how can we how come we had to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01002-00260650-00260913": "feed into that sense of urgency and that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01003-00260914-00261092": "need that willingness of their need to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01004-00261094-00261390": "act in a now yeah I think I think firmly", "3a-9EBNms3c-01005-00261391-00261603": "enough this actually reminds me very", "3a-9EBNms3c-01006-00261604-00261879": "well of an article myself and Chris", "3a-9EBNms3c-01007-00261880-00262121": "wrote a number of years ago called", "3a-9EBNms3c-01008-00262123-00262406": "give up cluster vism and it was", "3a-9EBNms3c-01009-00262407-00262832": "published", "3a-9EBNms3c-01010-00262833-00263060": "where did we start where did we focus I", "3a-9EBNms3c-01011-00263061-00263237": "think when I look calm labor joy oh yeah", "3a-9EBNms3c-01012-00263238-00263456": "which is a like a libertarian website", "3a-9EBNms3c-01013-00263457-00263642": "yes perhaps his articles and has a forum", "3a-9EBNms3c-01014-00263643-00263999": "yeah and and that was making a comment", "3a-9EBNms3c-01015-00264000-00264437": "about a campaign that was basically", "3a-9EBNms3c-01016-00264438-00264641": "mobilizing men as well I'm basically", "3a-9EBNms3c-01017-00264642-00264869": "making that statement there and then", "3a-9EBNms3c-01018-00264870-00265160": "saying that you know actually what they", "3a-9EBNms3c-01019-00265161-00265370": "were doing was just winning winning a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01020-00265371-00265700": "lot of publicity getting people send", "3a-9EBNms3c-01021-00265701-00265880": "more faces stuff outside of a shop and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01022-00265881-00266084": "you know was very well thought of at the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01023-00266085-00266309": "time and I think you know garnered a lot", "3a-9EBNms3c-01024-00266310-00266489": "of attention and garnered a lot of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01025-00266490-00266765": "publicity but actually what's the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01026-00266766-00266954": "long-term outcome of that being no not", "3a-9EBNms3c-01027-00266955-00267211": "very much there isn't there isn't", "3a-9EBNms3c-01028-00267212-00267428": "organizing going on in Holland and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01029-00267429-00267461": "Barrett", "3a-9EBNms3c-01030-00267462-00267662": "there isn't any noticeable Union", "3a-9EBNms3c-01031-00267663-00267827": "presence in any of the places where they", "3a-9EBNms3c-01032-00267828-00268121": "were where those standing outside of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01033-00268122-00268322": "shots for for communism were going on", "3a-9EBNms3c-01034-00268323-00268868": "from and it does play into a real", "3a-9EBNms3c-01035-00268869-00269111": "dynamic in the trade union movement and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01036-00269112-00269392": "that even comes out I think in in", "3a-9EBNms3c-01037-00269393-00269624": "JaMychal if he's oh right and when she's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01038-00269625-00269858": "comparing there's a really there's a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01039-00269859-00270011": "really key passage I think is really", "3a-9EBNms3c-01040-00270012-00270214": "important in this where she's comparing", "3a-9EBNms3c-01041-00270215-00270443": "she what she hasn't actually comparing", "3a-9EBNms3c-01042-00270444-00270683": "them but when I've read it I used as a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01043-00270684-00271061": "comparison between Bob mollenkamp who", "3a-9EBNms3c-01044-00271062-00271274": "was a organizing director for the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01045-00271275-00272120": "National 1199 and Bernie Minter who was", "3a-9EBNms3c-01046-00272121-00272663": "a another official for a different Union", "3a-9EBNms3c-01047-00272664-00273020": "and actually may have been for the same", "3a-9EBNms3c-01048-00273021-00273452": "one actually but basically they whereas", "3a-9EBNms3c-01049-00273453-00273664": "Bob was was focusing on saying", "3a-9EBNms3c-01050-00273665-00273899": "organizing never stops we can't afford", "3a-9EBNms3c-01051-00273900-00274148": "to stop you know there actually there", "3a-9EBNms3c-01052-00274149-00274412": "can be a there can be a mentality fed", "3a-9EBNms3c-01053-00274413-00274574": "into organizing that it's essential that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01054-00274575-00274787": "it's got to be that you've got that time", "3a-9EBNms3c-01055-00274788-00274931": "pressure there as well but it's that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01056-00274932-00275240": "longer-term thing to where Bernie", "3a-9EBNms3c-01057-00275241-00275495": "then talks about maximum mobilization", "3a-9EBNms3c-01058-00275496-00275687": "it's just about you know that's the real", "3a-9EBNms3c-01059-00275688-00275903": "strength there and actually I think it", "3a-9EBNms3c-01060-00275904-00276153": "is it is it's really that that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01061-00276154-00276543": "Nanuk is really real that actually the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01062-00276544-00276846": "difference between organizing and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01063-00276847-00277074": "mobilizing isn't realized but actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-01064-00277075-00277269": "there is a real dynamic there inside the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01065-00277270-00277545": "trade union movement where people will", "3a-9EBNms3c-01066-00277546-00277779": "just want to get faces out that will", "3a-9EBNms3c-01067-00277780-00277968": "want to hold those protests will want to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01068-00277969-00278253": "make it seem like there's lots of people", "3a-9EBNms3c-01069-00278254-00278442": "around even if there's not necessarily", "3a-9EBNms3c-01070-00278443-00278817": "that the grounding to it whereas others", "3a-9EBNms3c-01071-00278818-00279000": "will say you know no we need to focus on", "3a-9EBNms3c-01072-00279001-00279201": "this we focus on we need to focus on", "3a-9EBNms3c-01073-00279202-00279663": "building in a workplace hmm and as we", "3a-9EBNms3c-01074-00279664-00279954": "sort of admit to in the in the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01075-00279955-00280329": "introduction the idea that organizing", "3a-9EBNms3c-01076-00280330-00280506": "can be got rounds can be got round if", "3a-9EBNms3c-01077-00280507-00280698": "we've got authentic voices if we've got", "3a-9EBNms3c-01078-00280699-00280878": "those people there that is definitely", "3a-9EBNms3c-01079-00280879-00280995": "there and I've definitely experienced", "3a-9EBNms3c-01080-00280996-00281349": "that one as an official for you know for", "3a-9EBNms3c-01081-00281350-00281586": "every union I've worked for where you", "3a-9EBNms3c-01082-00281587-00281922": "know people always want to make sure", "3a-9EBNms3c-01083-00281923-00282069": "there's an authentic voice speaking", "3a-9EBNms3c-01084-00282070-00282333": "about a campaign you know that's not a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01085-00282334-00282441": "bad thing they're not saying that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01086-00282442-00282630": "because that they're trying to hide the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01087-00282631-00282786": "fact that they don't have organizing on", "3a-9EBNms3c-01088-00282787-00282891": "the ground they're saying that because", "3a-9EBNms3c-01089-00282892-00283053": "they genuinely want someone in that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01090-00283054-00283392": "workplace to have their say but that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01091-00283393-00283581": "doesn't necessarily then translate into", "3a-9EBNms3c-01092-00283582-00283917": "them having their say about what's going", "3a-9EBNms3c-01093-00283918-00284076": "on in that campaign what's going on in", "3a-9EBNms3c-01094-00284077-00284292": "that workplace what kind of organize you", "3a-9EBNms3c-01095-00284293-00284430": "doing what kind of industrial action", "3a-9EBNms3c-01096-00284431-00284604": "you're looking at you know like all of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01097-00284605-00284772": "those things don't necessarily connect", "3a-9EBNms3c-01098-00284773-00284931": "to those authentic voices don't", "3a-9EBNms3c-01099-00284932-00285180": "necessarily also have power and I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-01100-00285181-00285357": "I think that's where the problem is and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01101-00285358-00285669": "and it's partly a shift in members", "3a-9EBNms3c-01102-00285670-00285945": "relationship with their unions that has", "3a-9EBNms3c-01103-00285946-00286368": "caused that because actually officials", "3a-9EBNms3c-01104-00286369-00286661": "should be [__] scared of their members I", "3a-9EBNms3c-01105-00286662-00287112": "love having workplaces where I have to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01106-00287113-00287274": "ask to go in that is the way it should", "3a-9EBNms3c-01107-00287275-00287295": "be", "3a-9EBNms3c-01108-00287296-00287718": "it should not be the reps and members", "3a-9EBNms3c-01109-00287719-00287964": "are like subservient to an official it's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01110-00287965-00288162": "completely the other way around and it", "3a-9EBNms3c-01111-00288163-00288305": "should always be thought about that way", "3a-9EBNms3c-01112-00288306-00288725": "and the best branches in any union", "3a-9EBNms3c-01113-00288726-00289035": "operate that way that they have they", "3a-9EBNms3c-01114-00289036-00289443": "have a positive but adversarial relation", "3a-9EBNms3c-01115-00289444-00289596": "[__] with their officials and it should", "3a-9EBNms3c-01116-00289597-00289740": "be like I'm we should encourage that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01117-00289741-00289995": "because actually that's that's members", "3a-9EBNms3c-01118-00289996-00290151": "of power and members with the ability to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01119-00290152-00290430": "hold their union and they employ it to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01120-00290431-00290705": "account at the same time so you're", "3a-9EBNms3c-01121-00290706-00290921": "saying you're kind of almost saying that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01122-00290922-00291414": "it's almost like this this kind of so", "3a-9EBNms3c-01123-00291415-00291570": "the way that we make it more urgent is", "3a-9EBNms3c-01124-00291571-00291824": "this needs to be transformed into a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01125-00291825-00292095": "movement at the base of the existing", "3a-9EBNms3c-01126-00292096-00292385": "trade union movement like as in that's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01127-00292386-00292692": "how yeah because I think that it often", "3a-9EBNms3c-01128-00292693-00292980": "we we kind of often perceive things just", "3a-9EBNms3c-01129-00292981-00293166": "in terms of our own organizing right but", "3a-9EBNms3c-01130-00293167-00293304": "actually there's a whole trade union", "3a-9EBNms3c-01131-00293305-00293529": "movement out there that's that's engaged", "3a-9EBNms3c-01132-00293530-00293732": "in various different practices most of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01133-00293733-00293973": "which are kind of incredibly depressing", "3a-9EBNms3c-01134-00293974-00294426": "in which is raining and actually yeah", "3a-9EBNms3c-01135-00294427-00294555": "there may be there should be more", "3a-9EBNms3c-01136-00294556-00294789": "engagement with that from this", "3a-9EBNms3c-01137-00294790-00295340": "perspective yeah hmm I think in terms of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01138-00295341-00295677": "how do we kind of when things feel like", "3a-9EBNms3c-01139-00295678-00295920": "so politically urgent like in people's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01140-00295921-00296081": "workplaces with you know things like", "3a-9EBNms3c-01141-00296082-00296381": "zero hour contracts and you know other", "3a-9EBNms3c-01142-00296382-00296748": "kinds of kind of precarious work on the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01143-00296749-00296994": "rise but then also just kind of like", "3a-9EBNms3c-01144-00296995-00297317": "cuts and and things like that that and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01145-00297318-00297734": "that's where Jane Mack Levy's concept of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01146-00297735-00297992": "kind of whole work organizing is quite", "3a-9EBNms3c-01147-00297993-00298355": "interesting because I think obviously", "3a-9EBNms3c-01148-00298356-00298755": "you know the o wwr focus is and should", "3a-9EBNms3c-01149-00298756-00299135": "be on workplace organizing but I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-01150-00299136-00299550": "all of us you know we understand the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01151-00299551-00299945": "links between kind of low pay and and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01152-00299946-00300281": "housing and you know cuts to services", "3a-9EBNms3c-01153-00300282-00300492": "and cuts to benefits and things like", "3a-9EBNms3c-01154-00300493-00300528": "that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01155-00300529-00300798": "I think being kind of workplace", "3a-9EBNms3c-01156-00300799-00301146": "organizing can be a little bit invisible", "3a-9EBNms3c-01157-00301147-00301326": "especially when it is organizing rather", "3a-9EBNms3c-01158-00301327-00301551": "than these kind of big mobilizations and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01159-00301552-00302154": "I think being quite like vocal about the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01160-00302155-00302397": "links between kind of what happens in", "3a-9EBNms3c-01161-00302398-00302568": "your workplace and what happens in your", "3a-9EBNms3c-01162-00302569-00302853": "community is a way of kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01163-00302854-00302964": "[Music]", "3a-9EBNms3c-01164-00302965-00303196": "making people feel like something's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01165-00303197-00303501": "happening and that they can and should", "3a-9EBNms3c-01166-00303502-00303832": "get involved with it so I think kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01167-00303833-00304087": "breaking like our focus in the IWW", "3a-9EBNms3c-01168-00304088-00304324": "should be on the workplace but kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01169-00304325-00304570": "making these links kind of back to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01170-00304571-00304768": "people's communities and I think that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01171-00304769-00304930": "will I mean I think that makes people", "3a-9EBNms3c-01172-00304931-00305194": "feel like yeah something is being done", "3a-9EBNms3c-01173-00305195-00305475": "about the things that they're you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-01174-00305476-00305881": "experiencing every day because I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-01175-00305882-00306049": "what there's people feel that there's a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01176-00306050-00306229": "high barrier to entry for workplace", "3a-9EBNms3c-01177-00306230-00308254": "organizing you have to have a really", "3a-9EBNms3c-01178-00308255-00308979": "good quality coat like outerwear is", "3a-9EBNms3c-01179-00308980-00309550": "branded max but I think a lot of people", "3a-9EBNms3c-01180-00309551-00309871": "and I think people would appreciate that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01181-00309872-00310162": "these links being made and I think it", "3a-9EBNms3c-01182-00310163-00310528": "would be a kind of good way to to kind", "3a-9EBNms3c-01183-00310529-00310744": "of not just to bring people in but to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01184-00310745-00310966": "kind of deepen the organizing that's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01185-00310967-00311125": "happening and I mean in West London", "3a-9EBNms3c-01186-00311126-00311475": "what's kind of happening along side and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01187-00311476-00311779": "the stuff that's focused around the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01188-00311780-00311950": "factories and the warehouses is a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01189-00311951-00312379": "solidarity network so it's predominantly", "3a-9EBNms3c-01190-00312380-00312787": "migrant workers in those factories and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01191-00312788-00313057": "warehouses and they have problems with", "3a-9EBNms3c-01192-00313058-00313524": "their visa status with their landlords", "3a-9EBNms3c-01193-00313525-00313834": "all kinds of things and they're often", "3a-9EBNms3c-01194-00313835-00314011": "cross over and might intersect with", "3a-9EBNms3c-01195-00314012-00314173": "what's happening in their workplaces as", "3a-9EBNms3c-01196-00314174-00314551": "well and so what they're kind of the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01197-00314552-00314722": "crew that are kind of living in West", "3a-9EBNms3c-01198-00314723-00314952": "London if me really good at doing is", "3a-9EBNms3c-01199-00314953-00315154": "it's kind of helping people through that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01200-00315155-00315385": "solidarity network and making the links", "3a-9EBNms3c-01201-00315386-00315592": "between you know what they're", "3a-9EBNms3c-01202-00315593-00315730": "experiencing from the landlord and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01203-00315731-00315955": "what's happening in their workplace I", "3a-9EBNms3c-01204-00315956-00315992": "think", "3a-9EBNms3c-01205-00315993-00316289": "like those those spheres are like a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01206-00316290-00316582": "source of power as well mm only like if", "3a-9EBNms3c-01207-00316583-00316879": "you can yeah I mean like if you have a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01208-00316880-00317077": "degree of economic and disruptive power", "3a-9EBNms3c-01209-00317078-00317329": "with your landlord like in the kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01210-00317330-00317749": "Community Affairs distribution of food", "3a-9EBNms3c-01211-00317750-00318065": "distribution of care and child care like", "3a-9EBNms3c-01212-00318066-00318464": "all of these things create a web which", "3a-9EBNms3c-01213-00318465-00318725": "potentially could be used as a basis of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01214-00318726-00318965": "kind of social power that feeds very", "3a-9EBNms3c-01215-00318966-00319223": "very well into the workplace and yeah", "3a-9EBNms3c-01216-00319224-00319412": "you're absolutely right like in times of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01217-00319413-00319646": "struggle particularly these things", "3a-9EBNms3c-01218-00319647-00319862": "organically happen anyway like if you", "3a-9EBNms3c-01219-00319863-00320053": "look at kind of what was happening in", "3a-9EBNms3c-01220-00320054-00320270": "South Yorkshire drew the miners strike", "3a-9EBNms3c-01221-00320271-00320495": "like it was women it was it was whole", "3a-9EBNms3c-01222-00320496-00320794": "families were mobilized to support", "3a-9EBNms3c-01223-00320795-00321103": "striking family so I think naturally", "3a-9EBNms3c-01224-00321104-00321301": "naturally those things happen in times", "3a-9EBNms3c-01225-00321302-00321553": "of struggle and it's good to cultivate", "3a-9EBNms3c-01226-00321554-00321791": "those as a source of kind of strength", "3a-9EBNms3c-01227-00321792-00322064": "and maybe something that can like say", "3a-9EBNms3c-01228-00322065-00322322": "meet the urgency of of what's happening", "3a-9EBNms3c-01229-00322323-00322766": "yeah and I think a strong community base", "3a-9EBNms3c-01230-00322767-00323101": "is exactly why previous models of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01231-00323102-00323335": "organizing of words because they've been", "3a-9EBNms3c-01232-00323336-00323525": "able to be long-term because they've had", "3a-9EBNms3c-01233-00323526-00323738": "such a strong community base you know", "3a-9EBNms3c-01234-00323739-00324074": "like like like Jay Michael if he talks", "3a-9EBNms3c-01235-00324075-00324202": "about in her own book which talks about", "3a-9EBNms3c-01236-00324203-00324443": "communists she talks about civil rights", "3a-9EBNms3c-01237-00324444-00324650": "movement you know you could also talk", "3a-9EBNms3c-01238-00324651-00324829": "about the Black Panthers as you rightly", "3a-9EBNms3c-01239-00324830-00325110": "pointed out to you know the N um and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01240-00325111-00325421": "organize among mining communities you", "3a-9EBNms3c-01241-00325422-00325616": "know these are all really great examples", "3a-9EBNms3c-01242-00325617-00325879": "of organizing with unbelievably strong", "3a-9EBNms3c-01243-00325880-00326165": "bases and and maybe you know maybe", "3a-9EBNms3c-01244-00326166-00326404": "that's but if we're talking about what's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01245-00326405-00326683": "what's not working in the minute I think", "3a-9EBNms3c-01246-00326684-00326825": "it is that you know that there isn't", "3a-9EBNms3c-01247-00326826-00327140": "that base yeah isn't that base that that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01248-00327141-00327593": "that embedded embedded solitary that", "3a-9EBNms3c-01249-00327594-00327869": "embedded community you know and actually", "3a-9EBNms3c-01250-00327870-00328006": "that's the sort of thing that takes", "3a-9EBNms3c-01251-00328007-00328234": "decades to Bill you know you don't just", "3a-9EBNms3c-01252-00328235-00328606": "get that overnight but actually having", "3a-9EBNms3c-01253-00328607-00328766": "an active role in in community and", "3a-9EBNms3c-01254-00328767-00329144": "having a home I think is is in his way", "3a-9EBNms3c-01255-00329145-00329420": "well that seems like a good natural", "3a-9EBNms3c-01256-00329421-00329684": "point to bring this discussion to a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01257-00329685-00329935": "close and also talk about the theme of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01258-00329936-00330095": "the next podcast which we're kind of", "3a-9EBNms3c-01259-00330096-00330467": "moving on to already which is we talked", "3a-9EBNms3c-01260-00330468-00330647": "about what does a successful trade union", "3a-9EBNms3c-01261-00330648-00330875": "movement actually look like and we've", "3a-9EBNms3c-01262-00330876-00330995": "kind of already talked about some", "3a-9EBNms3c-01263-00330996-00331268": "examples of past struggles that seem to", "3a-9EBNms3c-01264-00331269-00331415": "be good models so we'll be talking a", "3a-9EBNms3c-01265-00331416-00331709": "little bit more about that as well so I", "3a-9EBNms3c-01266-00331710-00331964": "this was the first using the CLA's", "3a-9EBNms3c-01267-00331965-00332159": "podcast in our new series called talking", "3a-9EBNms3c-01268-00332160-00332584": "shop so we all could say by individually", "3a-9EBNms3c-01269-00332585-00332749": "I don't know other ways to do that I", "3a-9EBNms3c-01270-00332750-00333032": "don't know you do that that's how the", "3a-9EBNms3c-01271-00333033-00333467": "cookie we need like a really cheesy sign", "3a-9EBNms3c-01272-00333468-00335354": "oh yeah I would just say solidarity", "3a-9EBNms3c-01273-00335355-00335540": "forever keeping struggle our fellow", "3a-9EBNms3c-01274-00335541-00335899": "workers that's how the cookie crumb", "3a-9EBNms3c-01275-00335900-00336224": "see you later"}}, {"audio_id": "3aImn1q4ZLI", "text": {"3aImn1q4ZLI-00000-00000032-00000199": "today i'm going to share with you a", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00001-00000200-00000526": "really unique way of solving problems or", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00002-00000527-00000807": "issues that arise in your organization", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00003-00000808-00001079": "this is called the six thinking hats", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00004-00001080-00001231": "technique", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00005-00001232-00001415": "what the six thinking hats technique", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00006-00001416-00001655": "does gets you to look at a problem in", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00007-00001655-00001839": "six different ways", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00008-00001839-00002055": "it takes you and your team beyond", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00009-00002056-00002279": "instinctive positions so that you can", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00010-00002280-00002567": "explore a range of perspectives", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00011-00002568-00002783": "that way you can carefully consider each", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00012-00002784-00003087": "one without having to argue your case", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00013-00003088-00003311": "make snap decisions about what's right", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00014-00003311-00003470": "or wrong", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00015-00003471-00003767": "let's look at these six hats", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00016-00003768-00004054": "the very first hat is the white hat", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00017-00004055-00004335": "this hat covers facts figures", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00018-00004336-00004606": "information needs and other objective", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00019-00004607-00004831": "elements of a problem", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00020-00004832-00005063": "so if i was wearing my white hat", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00021-00005064-00005222": "my thinking would be", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00022-00005223-00005454": "let's drop all these arguments", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00023-00005455-00005631": "and let's look at the facts", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00024-00005632-00005791": "what is the facts and figures telling", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00025-00005792-00005902": "her", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00026-00005903-00006175": "the second hat is the red hat and this", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00027-00006176-00006406": "hat covers intuition", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00028-00006408-00006719": "feelings and emotions about the problem", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00029-00006720-00006934": "the red hat gives the thinker permission", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00030-00006936-00007191": "to put forward their feelings about the", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00031-00007192-00007406": "problem without having to justify any", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00032-00007408-00007503": "logic", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00033-00007504-00007719": "so if i was putting on my red hat i", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00034-00007720-00007903": "would say something like i feel like", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00035-00007904-00008191": "this is a terrible project or it's a", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00036-00008192-00008327": "poor proposal", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00037-00008328-00008631": "we go into the black hat and this hat", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00038-00008632-00009014": "represents judgment analysis and caution", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00039-00009015-00009174": "it should not be seen as a negative", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00040-00009175-00009471": "perspective but rather as a logical way", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00041-00009472-00009639": "to establish when", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00042-00009640-00009942": "projects don't fit into facts or", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00043-00009943-00010167": "information don't fit into facts", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00044-00010168-00010391": "where there is any shortcomings", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00045-00010392-00010638": "or there's a lack of experience or", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00046-00010639-00011055": "issues in the system or in the concept", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00047-00011056-00011295": "the black hat can come into case", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00048-00011296-00011535": "well you can use a black hat in worst", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00049-00011536-00011695": "case scenarios", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00050-00011696-00011774": "so", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00051-00011775-00011983": "if i was putting on the black hat for a", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00052-00011984-00012223": "moment i would say something like", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00053-00012224-00012551": "let's play devil's advocate here", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00054-00012552-00012830": "an example of putting on the black hat", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00055-00012831-00013094": "we then move on to the yellow hat", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00056-00013095-00013263": "the yellow hat is the opposite of the", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00057-00013263-00013511": "black hat in some ways", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00058-00013512-00013727": "the yellow hat perspective considers the", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00059-00013728-00013919": "positive aspects and advantages in the", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00060-00013919-00014030": "situation", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00061-00014031-00014327": "it looks at why projects or proposals or", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00062-00014328-00014607": "ideas will work and will be beneficial", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00063-00014608-00014935": "or it finds aspects of past actions that", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00064-00014936-00015166": "have been positive as well", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00065-00015168-00015422": "so from a yellow hat perspective we", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00066-00015423-00015663": "would say something like i can see some", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00067-00015663-00016094": "really great outcomes from this approach", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00068-00016095-00016343": "let's move on to the green hat and this", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00069-00016344-00016630": "hat is the hat of creativity", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00070-00016631-00016863": "alternatives interesting concepts and", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00071-00016864-00016967": "ideas", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00072-00016968-00017222": "things that are you know provocative", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00073-00017223-00017415": "the purpose of the green hat perspective", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00074-00017416-00017727": "is to look at problems in new ways", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00075-00017728-00017983": "so thinking outside of the square in", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00076-00017984-00018207": "another blog i shared i talk about", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00077-00018208-00018455": "thinking as if there's no square so this", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00078-00018456-00018703": "is totally out of left field it's like", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00079-00018704-00019030": "what if concepts and ideas", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00080-00019031-00019255": "let's come to the blue hat now and this", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00081-00019256-00019519": "hat represents the overview of the", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00082-00019520-00019727": "process of control", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00083-00019728-00019943": "its purpose is to sum up everything that", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00084-00019944-00020319": "has been learned or presented", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00085-00020320-00020527": "so if we were to look at product", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00086-00020528-00020775": "development as an example and we take", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00087-00020776-00021111": "these six hats and we then divide up our", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00088-00021112-00021391": "team into different groups the white hat", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00089-00021392-00021655": "group the red hat group the black hat", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00090-00021656-00021935": "group etc and each group talks about the", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00091-00021936-00022278": "product from that hats perspective i.e", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00092-00022279-00022575": "logical components emotional components", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00093-00022576-00022863": "devil advocate and so on", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00094-00022864-00023167": "right it allows for the team to be more", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00095-00023168-00023430": "focused and collaborate in these smaller", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00096-00023431-00023686": "groups and then they can then rejoin", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00097-00023687-00023975": "with stronger ideas and you know meeting", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00098-00023976-00024294": "the goals and objectives", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00099-00024295-00024550": "the six thinking hats concept and", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00100-00024551-00024783": "technique is a simple and effective", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00101-00024784-00025030": "parallel thinking process that helps", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00102-00025031-00025247": "people be more productive", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00103-00025248-00025342": "focus", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00104-00025343-00025591": "and mindfully involved", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00105-00025592-00025950": "this skill set or this technique is very", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00106-00025951-00026174": "powerful and once you and your team", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00107-00026175-00026351": "learn how to use it you guys can", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00108-00026352-00027358": "implement it almost immediately", "3aImn1q4ZLI-00109-00027360-00027568": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "3aS42mTgEhY", "text": {"3aS42mTgEhY-00000-00000032-00000214": "because travel so if you're watching my", "3aS42mTgEhY-00001-00000215-00000399": "lifestyle channel welcome back to", "3aS42mTgEhY-00002-00000400-00000686": "rebecca's lifestyle uh today the weather", "3aS42mTgEhY-00003-00000687-00001174": "in the uk um it's dry but um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00004-00001175-00001491": "and it's not windy um but it is", "3aS42mTgEhY-00005-00001492-00001671": "cloudy and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00006-00001672-00001847": "if you haven't subscribed to my channel", "3aS42mTgEhY-00007-00001848-00002110": "please subscribe um hi my name is", "3aS42mTgEhY-00008-00002111-00002239": "rebecca", "3aS42mTgEhY-00009-00002240-00002487": "and i love talking about travel and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00010-00002488-00002758": "lifestyle and today i'm going to be", "3aS42mTgEhY-00011-00002759-00003087": "doing a travel news uk five exciting", "3aS42mTgEhY-00012-00003088-00003251": "facts october", "3aS42mTgEhY-00013-00003252-00003495": "2021 part three", "3aS42mTgEhY-00014-00003496-00003806": "so i'm going to fire away with the five", "3aS42mTgEhY-00015-00003807-00004159": "fabulous facts and kicking off with", "3aS42mTgEhY-00016-00004160-00004286": "number one", "3aS42mTgEhY-00017-00004287-00004399": "let's c", "3aS42mTgEhY-00018-00004400-00004543": "and and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00019-00004544-00004863": "dot com", "3aS42mTgEhY-00020-00004864-00005270": "says how the uk became bottom of the", "3aS42mTgEhY-00021-00005271-00005406": "european", "3aS42mTgEhY-00022-00005407-00005670": "uh tourism sector", "3aS42mTgEhY-00023-00005671-00005927": "has crashed due to the combination of", "3aS42mTgEhY-00024-00005928-00006238": "the pandemic and political problems i", "3aS42mTgEhY-00025-00006239-00006454": "can understand that", "3aS42mTgEhY-00026-00006455-00006839": "um people obviously not wanting to", "3aS42mTgEhY-00027-00006840-00007078": "come to the uk because of the", "3aS42mTgEhY-00028-00007079-00007383": "pandemic and political problems", "3aS42mTgEhY-00029-00007384-00007574": "now um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00030-00007575-00007791": "again i hope it gets better for the", "3aS42mTgEhY-00031-00007792-00007903": "future", "3aS42mTgEhY-00032-00007904-00008295": "number two bbc news says carved booster", "3aS42mTgEhY-00033-00008296-00008439": "doors", "3aS42mTgEhY-00034-00008440-00008542": "um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00035-00008543-00008959": "and will be um offered to the over 40s", "3aS42mTgEhY-00036-00008960-00009246": "all over 40s in the uk will be offered a", "3aS42mTgEhY-00037-00009247-00009646": "third dose of the covid vaccine after", "3aS42mTgEhY-00038-00009647-00009735": "for", "3aS42mTgEhY-00039-00009736-00009974": "advice from the government scientists to", "3aS42mTgEhY-00040-00009975-00010295": "move uh ward top up the protection and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00041-00010296-00010567": "help limit the spread of the virus over", "3aS42mTgEhY-00042-00010568-00010727": "the winter", "3aS42mTgEhY-00043-00010728-00011014": "and which obviously is a really good", "3aS42mTgEhY-00044-00011015-00011159": "thing there", "3aS42mTgEhY-00045-00011160-00011287": "the three", "3aS42mTgEhY-00046-00011288-00011591": "doses will cut the risk of infection by", "3aS42mTgEhY-00047-00011592-00011974": "more than 93 according to the new data", "3aS42mTgEhY-00048-00011975-00012670": "from the uk health services agency", "3aS42mTgEhY-00049-00012671-00013046": "and he said um third dose would probably", "3aS42mTgEhY-00050-00013047-00013399": "make for foreign travel easier and there", "3aS42mTgEhY-00051-00013400-00013622": "were plans to add it to", "3aS42mTgEhY-00052-00013623-00014063": "the nhs at covered travel pass and as", "3aS42mTgEhY-00053-00014063-00014407": "well uh this should be offered at six", "3aS42mTgEhY-00054-00014408-00014647": "months after the second dose the prime", "3aS42mTgEhY-00055-00014647-00014911": "minister boris johnson says", "3aS42mTgEhY-00056-00014912-00015199": "uh nothing in the data to suggest a", "3aS42mTgEhY-00057-00015200-00015527": "lockdown or plan b was needed at the", "3aS42mTgEhY-00058-00015528-00015855": "moment despite the storm of", "3aS42mTgEhY-00059-00015856-00016071": "um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00060-00016072-00016358": "gathering in europe", "3aS42mTgEhY-00061-00016359-00016583": "of covered cases", "3aS42mTgEhY-00062-00016584-00016879": "uh where the cases are climbing", "3aS42mTgEhY-00063-00016880-00017047": "and again", "3aS42mTgEhY-00064-00017048-00017343": "in my opinion and everybody needs to be", "3aS42mTgEhY-00065-00017344-00017703": "careful and if you can get at", "3aS42mTgEhY-00066-00017704-00017975": "um the coveted um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00067-00017976-00018191": "booster", "3aS42mTgEhY-00068-00018192-00018447": "especially if you're over 40 then i", "3aS42mTgEhY-00069-00018448-00018679": "would definitely do it", "3aS42mTgEhY-00070-00018680-00018799": "um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00071-00018800-00019030": "especially if you're wanting to travel", "3aS42mTgEhY-00072-00019031-00019183": "abroad", "3aS42mTgEhY-00073-00019184-00019439": "and also for extra protection in this", "3aS42mTgEhY-00074-00019440-00019683": "country number three", "3aS42mTgEhY-00075-00019684-00019935": "independent um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00076-00019936-00020183": "can i travel to austria the latest", "3aS42mTgEhY-00077-00020184-00020463": "restrictions and advice", "3aS42mTgEhY-00078-00020464-00020550": "as", "3aS42mTgEhY-00079-00020551-00020791": "a partial lockdown is imposed in the", "3aS42mTgEhY-00080-00020792-00020911": "country", "3aS42mTgEhY-00081-00020912-00021230": "austria will accept the uk proof of", "3aS42mTgEhY-00082-00021231-00021558": "covered recovery and vaccination record", "3aS42mTgEhY-00083-00021559-00021807": "if you are traveling with", "3aS42mTgEhY-00084-00021808-00021983": "a printed pf", "3aS42mTgEhY-00085-00021984-00022503": "a pdf proof of vaccination", "3aS42mTgEhY-00086-00022504-00022767": "austria has introduced severe", "3aS42mTgEhY-00087-00022768-00023071": "restrictions for unvaccinated people", "3aS42mTgEhY-00088-00023072-00023447": "following a spike of new covered cases", "3aS42mTgEhY-00089-00023448-00023686": "um around 2 million", "3aS42mTgEhY-00090-00023687-00023814": "and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00091-00023815-00024086": "i have to yet to be fully vaccinated", "3aS42mTgEhY-00092-00024087-00024414": "have been put on the lockdown as", "3aS42mTgEhY-00093-00024415-00024871": "at monday the 15th of november only", "3aS42mTgEhY-00094-00024872-00025078": "uh committed to leave", "3aS42mTgEhY-00095-00025079-00025207": "um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00096-00025208-00025486": "for a slim number of reasons such as", "3aS42mTgEhY-00097-00025487-00025743": "food shopping and work so", "3aS42mTgEhY-00098-00025744-00026031": "basically essential um stuff", "3aS42mTgEhY-00099-00026032-00026327": "unfortunately", "3aS42mTgEhY-00100-00026327-00026511": "and but i hope these people get", "3aS42mTgEhY-00101-00026512-00026743": "vaccinated and can leave for other", "3aS42mTgEhY-00102-00026744-00026855": "reasons", "3aS42mTgEhY-00103-00026856-00027079": "moving on to number four um the", "3aS42mTgEhY-00104-00027080-00027390": "financial times post-brexit immigration", "3aS42mTgEhY-00105-00027391-00027735": "rules lead to collapse of eu school", "3aS42mTgEhY-00106-00027736-00027983": "trips uh to the uk", "3aS42mTgEhY-00107-00027983-00028527": "again it is understandable", "3aS42mTgEhY-00108-00028527-00028614": "um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00109-00028616-00028895": "obviously with the politics and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00110-00028895-00029118": "everything and coveted", "3aS42mTgEhY-00111-00029119-00029487": "last but not least bbc news and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00112-00029488-00029902": "the uk village that has lost its cheese", "3aS42mTgEhY-00113-00029904-00030262": "now um an award-winning uh dairy putting", "3aS42mTgEhY-00114-00030263-00030574": "cheddar in england back on the map and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00115-00030575-00030702": "cheddar is", "3aS42mTgEhY-00116-00030703-00031046": "the most popular cheese in the uk", "3aS42mTgEhY-00117-00031047-00031287": "and accounting for nearly half of", "3aS42mTgEhY-00118-00031288-00031583": "british cheese sales and according to", "3aS42mTgEhY-00119-00031583-00031767": "recent polls", "3aS42mTgEhY-00120-00031768-00031887": "um", "3aS42mTgEhY-00121-00031888-00032174": "it is a favor among the", "3aS42mTgEhY-00122-00032175-00032551": "americans and the australians and also", "3aS42mTgEhY-00123-00032552-00032807": "the canadians too wow", "3aS42mTgEhY-00124-00032808-00033062": "that's a fabulous fact and cheddar", "3aS42mTgEhY-00125-00033063-00033199": "cheese actually", "3aS42mTgEhY-00126-00033200-00033383": "comes from", "3aS42mTgEhY-00127-00033384-00033679": "wales and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00128-00033680-00033887": "so i would like to say thank you for", "3aS42mTgEhY-00129-00033888-00034287": "watching and i'll see you tomorrow", "3aS42mTgEhY-00130-00034288-00034431": "um for", "3aS42mTgEhY-00131-00034432-00034774": "a video um which is a budget travel", "3aS42mTgEhY-00132-00034775-00035055": "special and i hope you have um a good", "3aS42mTgEhY-00133-00035056-00035343": "day and tonight i love you all you all", "3aS42mTgEhY-00134-00035344-00035630": "mean the world to me and thank you and", "3aS42mTgEhY-00135-00035631-00036116": "bye for now thank you bye"}}, {"audio_id": "3aTF5bzIe0A", "text": {"3aTF5bzIe0A-00000-00000000-00000512": "like now to introduce our our last but", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00001-00000513-00000858": "not least speaker Daniel Perrin is", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00002-00000859-00001220": "United Nations representative of the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00003-00001221-00001607": "Baha'i international community I've", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00004-00001607-00001976": "myself had the chance to to to work with", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00005-00001977-00002218": "a special rupture on freedom of religion", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00006-00002219-00002558": "and and we did interact a lot with the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00007-00002559-00003001": "the bahai office who's been amazing in", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00008-00003002-00003299": "in its contribution to the work on", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00009-00003300-00003470": "humanoids not only on freedom of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00010-00003471-00003838": "religion that many other issues and we", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00011-00003839-00004106": "very grateful for that daniel is going", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00012-00004107-00004513": "to talk to us today about freedom of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00013-00004514-00004981": "worship you have the floor Daniel thank", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00014-00004982-00005186": "you very much I must say my name never", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00015-00005187-00005351": "sounded as beautiful as when you just", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00016-00005352-00005572": "read it out so I really appreciate that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00017-00005573-00005801": "and thank you for the kind of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00018-00005802-00006109": "introduction as well so I would like to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00019-00006110-00006400": "speak today about one of the root causes", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00020-00006401-00006721": "or one of the solutions to too many of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00021-00006722-00006859": "these issues that we've seen before us", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00022-00006861-00007013": "today but before getting started I do", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00023-00007014-00007285": "want to thank dpi as well as all my", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00024-00007286-00007684": "prior speakers and singers as well but", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00025-00007686-00007948": "I've been asked to speak on the freedom", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00026-00007950-00008117": "of worship which was one of the four", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00027-00008118-00008296": "freedoms mentioned by franklin roosevelt", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00028-00008297-00008666": "in 1941 and in the time i have i'd like", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00029-00008667-00008852": "to focus on three issues in particular", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00030-00008853-00009071": "the first is that we have to expand what", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00031-00009072-00009346": "freedom of worship means and the second", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00032-00009347-00009556": "is that this freedom is really what what", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00033-00009557-00009821": "makes human beings human and the third", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00034-00009822-00009998": "is that protecting this freedom is", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00035-00009999-00010210": "central to achieving the kind of world", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00036-00010211-00010388": "we all wish to see and in fact", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00037-00010389-00010546": "addressing the very concerns that we've", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00038-00010547-00010808": "been hearing about this morning so", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00039-00010809-00011006": "regarding the first point discourse", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00040-00011007-00011192": "around the issue of freedom of worship", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00041-00011193-00011444": "can often times be quite narrow if it", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00042-00011445-00011695": "focuses on what garb people can wear or", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00043-00011696-00011896": "what buildings they can go to on certain", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00044-00011897-00012145": "days for prayer it could remain so", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00045-00012146-00012424": "narrow but the freedom of worship at its", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00046-00012425-00012664": "essence is far richer than this at its", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00047-00012665-00012871": "heart it's ultimately an expression of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00048-00012872-00013127": "the freedom to investigate truth and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00049-00013128-00013337": "reality for oneself", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00050-00013338-00013516": "enjoying the freedom of worship means", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00051-00013518-00013733": "having the opportunity to investigate", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00052-00013734-00014038": "without prejudice bias fear or", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00053-00014040-00014306": "harassment the deepest questions of self", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00054-00014307-00014633": "and society so Who am I what is my", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00055-00014634-00014879": "purpose what are my responsibilities to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00056-00014880-00015146": "others how can our collective welfare be", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00057-00015147-00015434": "best pursued can we imagine what kind of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00058-00015435-00015613": "world we would be living in if we didn't", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00059-00015615-00015800": "have the freedom to explore these", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00060-00015801-00016043": "realities for ourselves what would our", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00061-00016044-00016219": "individual paths of personal development", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00062-00016221-00016520": "and fulfillment look like how would our", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00063-00016521-00016667": "collective journey toward a better will", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00064-00016668-00017014": "be impacted could it possibly advance", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00065-00017015-00017261": "out of the second point which is that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00066-00017262-00017453": "this capacity and logging to search for", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00067-00017454-00017651": "truth wherever it may be found is", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00068-00017652-00017869": "intrinsic to the human spirit itself", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00069-00017870-00018113": "freedom of worship speaks to the most", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00070-00018114-00018314": "fundamental aspects of what it means to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00071-00018315-00018599": "be a human being as my organization the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00072-00018600-00018731": "Baha'i international community once", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00073-00018732-00019019": "wrote quote the activity most intimately", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00074-00019020-00019193": "linked to the consciousness that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00075-00019194-00019406": "distinguishes human nature is the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00076-00019407-00019628": "individuals exploration of reality for", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00077-00019629-00019853": "him or herself the freedom to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00078-00019854-00020090": "investigate the purpose of existence and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00079-00020091-00020348": "to develop the endowments of human", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00080-00020349-00020528": "nature that make it achievable requires", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00081-00020529-00020819": "protection human beings must be free to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00082-00020820-00021104": "know in practical terms this means that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00083-00021105-00021311": "the freedom of worship or religion", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00084-00021312-00021560": "encompasses a wide range of activity and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00085-00021561-00021770": "endeavor it includes the freedom to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00086-00021771-00021968": "worship as one sees fit as I mentioned", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00087-00021969-00022157": "before and the freedom to not worship", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00088-00022158-00022379": "the freedom to seek and engage new", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00089-00022380-00022583": "systems of meaning and purpose and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00090-00022584-00022829": "activity and the freedom to define by", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00091-00022830-00022997": "what terms one would like to live one's", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00092-00022998-00023288": "life and as we are unfortunately seeing", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00093-00023289-00023522": "today denial of these freedoms of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00094-00023523-00023786": "worship can do great damage particularly", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00095-00023787-00023993": "in terms of enjoyment of the freedom", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00096-00023994-00024365": "from fear or the freedom of speech it is", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00097-00024366-00024509": "for these reasons I'm convinced that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00098-00024510-00024659": "studies show that greater religious", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00099-00024660-00024797": "freedom and greater religious diversity", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00100-00024798-00025075": "are correlated with peaceful societies", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00101-00025076-00025340": "the Institute for economics and peace", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00102-00025341-00025562": "for example recently noted that quote", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00103-00025563-00025688": "countries with greater religious", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00104-00025689-00025862": "freedoms are generally more peaceful", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00105-00025863-00026027": "where are the countries with less", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00106-00026027-00026186": "religious freedom are generally less", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00107-00026187-00026456": "peaceful when one is free to explore the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00108-00026457-00026664": "nature of reality and his or her own", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00109-00026666-00026887": "way and importantly when one sees how", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00110-00026888-00027067": "others and that others are doing the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00111-00027068-00027355": "same we begin to see the strength that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00112-00027356-00027697": "lies behind our diversity and as this", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00113-00027698-00027877": "happens the idea of committing terrible", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00114-00027877-00028051": "acts on to another in the name of belief", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00115-00028052-00028330": "or race creed social class what have you", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00116-00028331-00028594": "that diminishes this brings me to my", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00117-00028595-00028852": "third point in this sense freedom of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00118-00028852-00029041": "worship understood is the freedom to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00119-00029042-00029191": "investigate the full range of human", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00120-00029192-00029533": "existence stands not just as a right but", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00121-00029533-00029727": "also as a means to explore understand", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00122-00029729-00029950": "more fully and actively address the many", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00123-00029951-00030108": "challenges and opportunities facing", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00124-00030110-00030439": "humanity today as someone born and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00125-00030439-00030619": "raised in a Jewish family I certainly", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00126-00030620-00030852": "benefited from this freedom and after", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00127-00030854-00031036": "great personal exploration i became a", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00128-00031037-00031333": "Baha'i now as a representative of the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00129-00031333-00031651": "Baha'i faith I could provide excuse me", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00130-00031652-00031843": "all too many examples of what it means", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00131-00031844-00032017": "at a very practical level to have", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00132-00032018-00032226": "freedoms denied on the basis of religion", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00133-00032227-00032461": "but what may be more important than that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00134-00032462-00032683": "is how active exploration of one's", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00135-00032683-00032920": "higher nature and of human purpose as a", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00136-00032921-00033154": "whole allows one to respond in ways that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00137-00033155-00033349": "are constructed and productive", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00138-00033350-00033673": "regardless of circumstances this is how", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00139-00033674-00033865": "we can all move forward even in the grip", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00140-00033866-00034186": "in the face of great challenges so many", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00141-00034187-00034318": "around the world religion and the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00142-00034319-00034549": "freedom of worship can inspire souls to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00143-00034550-00034792": "build unity to endeavor for material and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00144-00034793-00035020": "spiritual betterment of all to see their", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00145-00035021-00035209": "own happiness and that of others as we", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00146-00035210-00035410": "just saw in that video to advanced", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00147-00035411-00035590": "learning and science to be an instrument", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00148-00035591-00035851": "of true joy and to revive the body of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00149-00035852-00036196": "humankind it can offer an understanding", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00150-00036197-00036400": "of human existence that lifts the eye", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00151-00036401-00036571": "from the rocky path to the distant", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00152-00036572-00036802": "horizon and when true to the spirit of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00153-00036803-00037060": "its transcendent founders it has been", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00154-00037061-00037231": "one of the most powerful forces for the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00155-00037232-00037453": "creation of new and beneficial patterns", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00156-00037454-00037774": "of individual and collective life so I", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00157-00037775-00037927": "would posit that the next stages of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00158-00037928-00038115": "freedom of worship will lead us to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00159-00038116-00038311": "investigate more deeply the link between", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00160-00038312-00038551": "religious conviction and service to the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00161-00038552-00038833": "common good so this afternoon I've tried", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00162-00038834-00038983": "to shed at least a little light on three", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00163-00038984-00039184": "central premises that freedom of worship", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00164-00039185-00039477": "is much larger and more profound than", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00165-00039478-00039739": "just the act of worship that is central", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00166-00039740-00039955": "to what it means to be human", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00167-00039956-00040153": "and that it is also central to efforts", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00168-00040154-00040402": "to better society in the last point I", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00169-00040403-00040510": "would like to make involve the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00170-00040511-00040726": "relationship between freedoms of various", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00171-00040727-00040972": "kinds and the ongoing advancement of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00172-00040973-00041260": "human civilization in the nineteen forty", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00173-00041261-00041410": "one state of the union address then", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00174-00041411-00041551": "President of the United States Franklin", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00175-00041552-00041758": "Roosevelt spoke of a world founded upon", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00176-00041759-00042022": "four essential freedoms these of course", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00177-00042023-00042202": "are the very freedoms we are exploring", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00178-00042203-00042390": "here today and it is clear that", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00179-00042391-00042664": "seventy-five years later we as a global", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00180-00042665-00042895": "community still find them to be of great", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00181-00042896-00043177": "importance it is perhaps with", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00182-00043178-00043324": "remembering though that these freedoms", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00183-00043325-00043552": "were articulated not in the abstract and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00184-00043553-00043711": "not as standalone self-contained", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00185-00043712-00043915": "concepts they were framed within the", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00186-00043916-00044173": "context of the moral order in relation", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00187-00044174-00044350": "to the concept of the good society and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00188-00044351-00044587": "importantly in 1941 they were", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00189-00044588-00044800": "articulated during a World War whose", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00190-00044801-00045025": "legacy could very well be identified as", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00191-00045026-00045250": "the ultimate result of the lack of", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00192-00045251-00045517": "freedom of worship it seems to get to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00193-00045518-00045667": "the heart of why freedom of religion is", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00194-00045668-00045852": "more important in the contemporary world", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00195-00045853-00046075": "religion pertains to our deepest beliefs", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00196-00046076-00046309": "values and convictions about ourselves", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00197-00046310-00046570": "our role in the world and the way our", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00198-00046571-00046720": "collective life should be ordered and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00199-00046721-00046999": "arranged in this sense it is central to", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00200-00047000-00047176": "our collective striving after the good", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00201-00047177-00047434": "society and this striving to understand", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00202-00047435-00047692": "what we can be at our best both", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00203-00047693-00047917": "individually and collectively is", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00204-00047918-00048082": "something that must be preserved and", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00205-00048083-00048379": "protected if humanity's to advance so", "3aTF5bzIe0A-00206-00048380-00048613": "thank you again"}}, {"audio_id": "3acJnvWArDI", "text": {"3acJnvWArDI-00000-00000000-00002030": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00001-00002032-00002191": "hi everybody so we're back off", "3acJnvWArDI-00002-00002192-00002447": "and we're going to another event but", "3acJnvWArDI-00003-00002448-00002591": "just pulled into the garage", "3acJnvWArDI-00004-00002592-00002839": "and spotted something really cool look", "3acJnvWArDI-00005-00002840-00003160": "at this", "3acJnvWArDI-00006-00003161-00008483": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00007-00008484-00008807": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00008-00008808-00009816": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00009-00009817-00010142": "[Applause]", "3acJnvWArDI-00010-00010143-00012335": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00011-00012336-00012503": "hi everybody welcome back to bill noble", "3acJnvWArDI-00012-00012504-00012670": "campus", "3acJnvWArDI-00013-00012671-00012983": "we're away again for the weekend", "3acJnvWArDI-00014-00012984-00013111": "getting a bit much this in it throughout", "3acJnvWArDI-00015-00013112-00013286": "the workshop too much", "3acJnvWArDI-00016-00013287-00013679": "especially when there's so much to do", "3acJnvWArDI-00017-00013680-00013886": "so where we're going today we are off to", "3acJnvWArDI-00018-00013887-00014086": "hereford", "3acJnvWArDI-00019-00014087-00014358": "and we're going to the hereford rowing", "3acJnvWArDI-00020-00014359-00014583": "club", "3acJnvWArDI-00021-00014584-00014807": "so as usual i'm bringing you along for", "3acJnvWArDI-00022-00014808-00015022": "the ride", "3acJnvWArDI-00023-00015023-00015343": "the weather is scorching hot and", "3acJnvWArDI-00024-00015344-00015503": "listening to the radio just now", "3acJnvWArDI-00025-00015504-00015750": "we've got this for the next three days", "3acJnvWArDI-00026-00015751-00015975": "so anyway today's saturday", "3acJnvWArDI-00027-00015976-00016350": "um the time is now at", "3acJnvWArDI-00028-00016351-00016775": "five to one and we're literally", "3acJnvWArDI-00029-00016776-00017103": "38 minutes away so", "3acJnvWArDI-00030-00017104-00017455": "it thanks me but i'm gonna get", "3acJnvWArDI-00031-00017456-00017830": "okay i've got two different times on two", "3acJnvWArDI-00032-00017831-00018079": "different clocks so ignore me going by", "3acJnvWArDI-00033-00018080-00018286": "the sat nav we've got 38 minutes to go", "3acJnvWArDI-00034-00018287-00018407": "and we're going to get there at half", "3acJnvWArDI-00035-00018408-00018950": "past one just in time sorry to eat", "3acJnvWArDI-00036-00018951-00019230": "um looking at the list we have got a", "3acJnvWArDI-00037-00019231-00019471": "huge amount of names there", "3acJnvWArDI-00038-00019472-00019830": "and in total roughly about 70 people", "3acJnvWArDI-00039-00019831-00020135": "70 bands let's see if i can name a few", "3acJnvWArDI-00040-00020136-00020255": "remember a few", "3acJnvWArDI-00041-00020256-00020447": "and you've got steve lindsey redford", "3acJnvWArDI-00042-00020448-00020599": "from the roman rapids", "3acJnvWArDI-00043-00020600-00021111": "he's organized this um you have", "3acJnvWArDI-00044-00021112-00021511": "and neil from urban explorer", "3acJnvWArDI-00045-00021512-00021703": "uh floor of the novice explorers luke", "3acJnvWArDI-00046-00021704-00021847": "from luke's van life", "3acJnvWArDI-00047-00021848-00022214": "myself don't forget me but", "3acJnvWArDI-00048-00022215-00022350": "i'm not sure if we're going to be doing", "3acJnvWArDI-00049-00022351-00022614": "an actual proper video this weekend", "3acJnvWArDI-00050-00022615-00022983": "i should give you a show around the", "3acJnvWArDI-00051-00022984-00023230": "site and everything when we get there", "3acJnvWArDI-00052-00023231-00023478": "apparently it's really nice", "3acJnvWArDI-00053-00023479-00024111": "it's a long mad mental drive up there", "3acJnvWArDI-00054-00024112-00024630": "but he's good it's very warm", "3acJnvWArDI-00055-00024631-00024719": "we're gonna have a good laugh this", "3acJnvWArDI-00056-00024720-00025014": "weekend as usual get the old fire pits", "3acJnvWArDI-00057-00025015-00025167": "going", "3acJnvWArDI-00058-00025168-00025503": "a few drinks out maybe a bit of music", "3acJnvWArDI-00059-00025504-00025727": "we won't be showing that i don't want to", "3acJnvWArDI-00060-00025727-00026143": "cross any copyright boundaries here", "3acJnvWArDI-00061-00026144-00026495": "that wouldn't be good", "3acJnvWArDI-00062-00026495-00026646": "right so i'm going to face you back to", "3acJnvWArDI-00063-00026647-00026823": "the road so you can get a little bit of", "3acJnvWArDI-00064-00026824-00027023": "the journey", "3acJnvWArDI-00065-00027024-00027302": "and get the video when we actually get", "3acJnvWArDI-00066-00027304-00027535": "on site", "3acJnvWArDI-00067-00027536-00028469": "and i'll speak to you in a bit", "3acJnvWArDI-00068-00028470-00029483": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00069-00029483-00029583": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00070-00029585-00029656": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00071-00029657-00029763": "[Applause]", "3acJnvWArDI-00072-00029764-00035083": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00073-00035084-00035565": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00074-00035566-00039623": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00075-00039624-00039783": "saying oh we're doing one on monday and", "3acJnvWArDI-00076-00039784-00039943": "wednesday this week and then thursday", "3acJnvWArDI-00077-00039944-00040015": "next week", "3acJnvWArDI-00078-00040016-00040359": "be consistent don't do what it is", "3acJnvWArDI-00079-00040360-00040535": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00080-00040536-00040887": "hardly ever shoot anything and then", "3acJnvWArDI-00081-00040888-00041079": "i have no consistency as to when we're", "3acJnvWArDI-00082-00041080-00041262": "releasing it", "3acJnvWArDI-00083-00041263-00041615": "consistency is the key so it's always", "3acJnvWArDI-00084-00041616-00041773": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00085-00041774-00042083": "[Laughter]", "3acJnvWArDI-00086-00042084-00042446": "now", "3acJnvWArDI-00087-00042447-00042758": "always never always but", "3acJnvWArDI-00088-00042759-00042951": "yeah that that's the thing people will", "3acJnvWArDI-00089-00042952-00043111": "say about the always", "3acJnvWArDI-00090-00043112-00043483": "why they all got three cameras", "3acJnvWArDI-00091-00043484-00043990": "there's", "3acJnvWArDI-00092-00043991-00044111": "because people will do that they'll", "3acJnvWArDI-00093-00044112-00044302": "deliver information like", "3acJnvWArDI-00094-00044303-00044630": "never forget to stretch your window yeah", "3acJnvWArDI-00095-00044631-00044687": "never", "3acJnvWArDI-00096-00044688-00044830": "there you go that's the best bit of", "3acJnvWArDI-00097-00044831-00044990": "advice you're gonna get well we shoot", "3acJnvWArDI-00098-00044991-00045279": "your windows before yeah", "3acJnvWArDI-00099-00045280-00045462": "as you'll lose and they'll fly off very", "3acJnvWArDI-00100-00045463-00045895": "definitely", "3acJnvWArDI-00101-00045896-00046118": "how big is it it's about it's about up", "3acJnvWArDI-00102-00046119-00046895": "to there on you where you are", "3acJnvWArDI-00103-00046896-00047207": "right is that enough you want more deer", "3acJnvWArDI-00104-00047208-00048951": "good girl coming in one boy when you get", "3acJnvWArDI-00105-00048952-00049071": "don't know what you're missing you lot", "3acJnvWArDI-00106-00049072-00051254": "up there", "3acJnvWArDI-00107-00051255-00053223": "here we go", "3acJnvWArDI-00108-00053224-00053654": "are you wanting to", "3acJnvWArDI-00109-00053654-00055599": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00110-00055600-00056063": "uh well here we are at camp creator 2021", "3acJnvWArDI-00111-00056064-00056279": "which steve and lindsey radford from the", "3acJnvWArDI-00112-00056279-00056654": "roman records have kindly put on", "3acJnvWArDI-00113-00056655-00056975": "and i must admit they've done an amazing", "3acJnvWArDI-00114-00056976-00057150": "job", "3acJnvWArDI-00115-00057151-00057471": "all the youtubers under the van lifer", "3acJnvWArDI-00116-00057472-00057559": "planet", "3acJnvWArDI-00117-00057560-00057838": "are here not all of them but a hell of a", "3acJnvWArDI-00118-00057839-00057959": "lot", "3acJnvWArDI-00119-00057960-00058454": "especially those that could make it and", "3acJnvWArDI-00120-00058455-00058799": "made some great content today um", "3acJnvWArDI-00121-00058800-00059223": "so as you can see by this video", "3acJnvWArDI-00122-00059224-00059391": "we couldn't have picked a perfect more", "3acJnvWArDI-00123-00059391-00059599": "perfect weekend", "3acJnvWArDI-00124-00059600-00059879": "to hold such an event and the location", "3acJnvWArDI-00125-00059879-00060111": "as well is absolutely amazing", "3acJnvWArDI-00126-00060112-00060342": "um we've been here at hereford rowing", "3acJnvWArDI-00127-00060344-00060542": "club", "3acJnvWArDI-00128-00060544-00060694": "as you can see went for a little swim", "3acJnvWArDI-00129-00060695-00060959": "earlier and", "3acJnvWArDI-00130-00060960-00061215": "thoroughly enjoying it i have literally", "3acJnvWArDI-00131-00061216-00061454": "just been here for the afternoon", "3acJnvWArDI-00132-00061455-00061671": "and it sounds like we've got a few more", "3acJnvWArDI-00133-00061672-00061991": "couple more days of some good fun", "3acJnvWArDI-00134-00061991-00062303": "rubbish holders with other youtubers um", "3acJnvWArDI-00135-00062304-00062623": "swapping ideas hopefully", "3acJnvWArDI-00136-00062624-00062871": "creating some collaborations some ideas", "3acJnvWArDI-00137-00062872-00063023": "for videos", "3acJnvWArDI-00138-00063024-00063166": "and maybe i'm chatting about the next", "3acJnvWArDI-00139-00063167-00063463": "event", "3acJnvWArDI-00140-00063464-00063847": "anyway so not on the beers just yet", "3acJnvWArDI-00141-00063848-00064199": "although i have had one uh it's just so", "3acJnvWArDI-00142-00064200-00064503": "hot the sun is unbelievable and jumping", "3acJnvWArDI-00143-00064504-00064654": "in the river it felt like i was jumping", "3acJnvWArDI-00144-00064655-00064766": "into the mediterranean", "3acJnvWArDI-00145-00064767-00065103": "it was so warm", "3acJnvWArDI-00146-00065104-00065430": "anyway i'm sat down relaxing just for a", "3acJnvWArDI-00147-00065432-00065591": "moment", "3acJnvWArDI-00148-00065592-00065871": "and later on we'll get the camera out", "3acJnvWArDI-00149-00065872-00066023": "and get it going again", "3acJnvWArDI-00150-00066024-00066455": "and see what else we can catch on video", "3acJnvWArDI-00151-00066456-00066519": "eh", "3acJnvWArDI-00152-00066520-00067453": "i'll catch you shortly", "3acJnvWArDI-00153-00067454-00069436": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00154-00069437-00070031": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00155-00070032-00074282": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00156-00074283-00074743": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00157-00074744-00079882": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00158-00079883-00080535": "yep", "3acJnvWArDI-00159-00080536-00081323": "[Laughter]", "3acJnvWArDI-00160-00081324-00082682": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00161-00082683-00083402": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00162-00083403-00084082": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00163-00084083-00084286": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00164-00084287-00086657": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00165-00086658-00088282": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00166-00088283-00088689": "do", "3acJnvWArDI-00167-00088690-00091789": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00168-00091790-00094386": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00169-00094387-00095282": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00170-00095283-00095577": "do", "3acJnvWArDI-00171-00095578-00100726": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00172-00100727-00102047": "right so we stood up at the balcony here", "3acJnvWArDI-00173-00102048-00102255": "so we're quite lucky this weekend it", "3acJnvWArDI-00174-00102256-00102542": "might be the creator's weekend but", "3acJnvWArDI-00175-00102543-00102654": "we're also going to get a little bit of", "3acJnvWArDI-00176-00102655-00102927": "entertainment with these raft races", "3acJnvWArDI-00177-00102928-00103199": "and later on we'll be in the water", "3acJnvWArDI-00178-00103200-00103342": "having a swim as well because it is", "3acJnvWArDI-00179-00103343-00103518": "so hot this weekend it's unbelievably", "3acJnvWArDI-00180-00103519-00103806": "hot and we're up here now i'm stood here", "3acJnvWArDI-00181-00103807-00103902": "with charlie", "3acJnvWArDI-00182-00103903-00104094": "hello mate all right charlie and lauren", "3acJnvWArDI-00183-00104095-00104254": "yeah on instagram lauren's in there", "3acJnvWArDI-00184-00104255-00104342": "somewhere she's", "3acJnvWArDI-00185-00104343-00104639": "lauren there's lauren and behind his", "3acJnvWArDI-00186-00104640-00104839": "will from wheels", "3acJnvWArDI-00187-00104840-00105086": "so yeah we call him will now we're going", "3acJnvWArDI-00188-00105088-00105271": "to change the name of this channel", "3acJnvWArDI-00189-00105272-00105486": "so what we'll do is i'll put links to", "3acJnvWArDI-00190-00105488-00105590": "the", "3acJnvWArDI-00191-00105591-00105815": "links in the comment in the description", "3acJnvWArDI-00192-00105816-00105951": "below oh my god i can't even get the", "3acJnvWArDI-00193-00105952-00106007": "words out", "3acJnvWArDI-00194-00106008-00106254": "links will be in the description below", "3acJnvWArDI-00195-00106255-00106407": "to charlie and lauren's instagram", "3acJnvWArDI-00196-00106408-00106590": "account and to wheels whereabouts", "3acJnvWArDI-00197-00106591-00106799": "youtube channel", "3acJnvWArDI-00198-00106800-00107047": "so it looks like they're all getting", "3acJnvWArDI-00199-00107048-00107199": "ready over there", "3acJnvWArDI-00200-00107200-00107390": "to race off i'm not quite sure how", "3acJnvWArDI-00201-00107391-00107543": "they're going to do it", "3acJnvWArDI-00202-00107544-00107766": "but let's see what's going on shall we", "3acJnvWArDI-00203-00107767-00109633": "and let's cue the music", "3acJnvWArDI-00204-00109634-00111182": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00205-00111183-00114241": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00206-00114242-00114883": "[Applause]", "3acJnvWArDI-00207-00114883-00117683": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00208-00117683-00117875": "wow", "3acJnvWArDI-00209-00117876-00119083": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00210-00119083-00119234": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00211-00119235-00119734": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00212-00119735-00121847": "i've got to get me one of these yeah", "3acJnvWArDI-00213-00121848-00122686": "hang on", "3acJnvWArDI-00214-00122688-00123278": "that's amazing", "3acJnvWArDI-00215-00123279-00123923": "balls trapped", "3acJnvWArDI-00216-00123924-00124508": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00217-00124509-00128883": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00218-00128883-00129374": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00219-00129375-00130715": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00220-00130716-00133231": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00221-00133232-00133471": "right so there you go i'll do anything", "3acJnvWArDI-00222-00133472-00133551": "literally", "3acJnvWArDI-00223-00133552-00133814": "within reason so as you can see i'm a", "3acJnvWArDI-00224-00133815-00133943": "little bit nutter sometimes when i'm out", "3acJnvWArDI-00225-00133944-00134047": "and about", "3acJnvWArDI-00226-00134048-00134175": "if there's anything you want to see me", "3acJnvWArDI-00227-00134176-00134599": "do challenge me to do it or have a good", "3acJnvWArDI-00228-00134600-00134975": "leave your comments below so yeah", "3acJnvWArDI-00229-00134976-00135463": "i'm asking my subscribers as a challenge", "3acJnvWArDI-00230-00135464-00135719": "to tell me what you're meant to do and", "3acJnvWArDI-00231-00135720-00135831": "i'm not going to spend thousands of", "3acJnvWArDI-00232-00135832-00135895": "pounds on", "3acJnvWArDI-00233-00135896-00136087": "god knows whatever to do it anything", "3acJnvWArDI-00234-00136088-00136199": "i'll have a go at things and bits and", "3acJnvWArDI-00235-00136200-00136295": "pieces if there's something out there", "3acJnvWArDI-00236-00136296-00136463": "you'd like to see me do", "3acJnvWArDI-00237-00136464-00138683": "let me know in the comments below oh", "3acJnvWArDI-00238-00138684-00138954": "bliss", "3acJnvWArDI-00239-00138955-00141483": "[Applause]", "3acJnvWArDI-00240-00141484-00142006": "guys", "3acJnvWArDI-00241-00142007-00142883": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00242-00142884-00143108": "so", "3acJnvWArDI-00243-00143109-00144478": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00244-00144479-00144678": "right that's it for another video for", "3acJnvWArDI-00245-00144679-00144839": "another week", "3acJnvWArDI-00246-00144840-00145047": "we've enjoyed the weekend away we've", "3acJnvWArDI-00247-00145048-00145143": "enjoyed a bit of sun", "3acJnvWArDI-00248-00145144-00145454": "a bit of swimming loads of fun", "3acJnvWArDI-00249-00145455-00145654": "especially meeting up with all the other", "3acJnvWArDI-00250-00145655-00145799": "uh content creators from", "3acJnvWArDI-00251-00145800-00146063": "instagram from youtube it's been a", "3acJnvWArDI-00252-00146064-00146166": "fantastic weekend", "3acJnvWArDI-00253-00146167-00146351": "i'm glad you've managed to see some of", "3acJnvWArDI-00254-00146352-00146671": "the highlights of what we've experienced", "3acJnvWArDI-00255-00146672-00146863": "please hit that subscribe button please", "3acJnvWArDI-00256-00146864-00146999": "hit the like button", "3acJnvWArDI-00257-00147000-00147239": "hit the notification bell and you'll get", "3acJnvWArDI-00258-00147240-00147399": "all the videos as they come out", "3acJnvWArDI-00259-00147400-00147783": "straight away and you won't miss them", "3acJnvWArDI-00260-00147784-00147983": "if you do enjoy the video please make", "3acJnvWArDI-00261-00147984-00148143": "sure you give it a thumbs up", "3acJnvWArDI-00262-00148144-00148319": "got any comments on the video leave them", "3acJnvWArDI-00263-00148320-00148551": "below in the comment section", "3acJnvWArDI-00264-00148552-00148807": "and that's it so i will see you in the", "3acJnvWArDI-00265-00148808-00148902": "next one", "3acJnvWArDI-00266-00148903-00149039": "i hope you're staying safe i hope you're", "3acJnvWArDI-00267-00149040-00149263": "staying well and that's afraid that's", "3acJnvWArDI-00268-00149264-00149515": "all it's time for now and it's bye from", "3acJnvWArDI-00269-00149516-00149883": "[Music]", "3acJnvWArDI-00270-00149884-00152311": "me", "3acJnvWArDI-00271-00152312-00152520": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "3b85DPS1pBE", "text": {"3b85DPS1pBE-00000-00000107-00000356": "and you ask to be tuning a bucket I get", "3b85DPS1pBE-00001-00000357-00001712": "Sam back on my rubber GD now I'm getting", "3b85DPS1pBE-00002-00001713-00001814": "me okay", "3b85DPS1pBE-00003-00001814-00002042": "I just checked it was a team that wanted", "3b85DPS1pBE-00004-00002043-00002333": "each other isn't it nuclear he also left", "3b85DPS1pBE-00005-00002334-00003038": "I was I get a seat on the woman is a", "3b85DPS1pBE-00006-00003039-00003604": "geeky women my Turkish harem Amara it", "3b85DPS1pBE-00007-00003605-00003965": "was very much Yoko Bush work with our", "3b85DPS1pBE-00008-00003965-00004127": "gove Akane honey", "3b85DPS1pBE-00009-00004128-00004475": "yes genius master teacher mmm because", "3b85DPS1pBE-00010-00004476-00005488": "you're a demonic a tricycle deity I mean", "3b85DPS1pBE-00011-00005489-00005824": "Alan and I will remove my disc jockey", "3b85DPS1pBE-00012-00005825-00006167": "awesome I get along but you went down", "3b85DPS1pBE-00013-00006168-00006339": "[Music]", "3b85DPS1pBE-00014-00006340-00007492": "hahaha Miyagi checkity check the dryer", "3b85DPS1pBE-00015-00007493-00007730": "detail almost achieve a manual emotion", "3b85DPS1pBE-00016-00007731-00008023": "argot I'll meet a girl you will meet a", "3b85DPS1pBE-00017-00008025-00008296": "little my transit women animal most", "3b85DPS1pBE-00018-00008297-00008623": "Omata", "3b85DPS1pBE-00019-00008624-00008899": "requesting I see curry almost like worse", "3b85DPS1pBE-00020-00008900-00009356": "a manga Java each other dangerous ie", "3b85DPS1pBE-00021-00009357-00009848": "and analyzing sqc quarryman maybe you", "3b85DPS1pBE-00022-00009849-00010249": "see charity that was your motion to be", "3b85DPS1pBE-00023-00010250-00010646": "saying when you are dominick ADA", "3b85DPS1pBE-00024-00010647-00011071": "mmm yes Mabel reliability and what would", "3b85DPS1pBE-00025-00011072-00011149": "you know hey Gavin", "3b85DPS1pBE-00026-00011150-00011363": "mmm I mean harm each other does it", "3b85DPS1pBE-00027-00011364-00011567": "matter as India kill you but yet were", "3b85DPS1pBE-00028-00011568-00011906": "creativity I am I making I would work", "3b85DPS1pBE-00029-00011907-00012437": "and all the God would he do - Donny you", "3b85DPS1pBE-00030-00012438-00012851": "gonna make usually I was actually do to", "3b85DPS1pBE-00031-00012852-00013274": "worry down a community that we are", "3b85DPS1pBE-00032-00013275-00013349": "raised", "3b85DPS1pBE-00033-00013350-00013624": "Moscow manual application now I'm happy", "3b85DPS1pBE-00034-00013625-00013871": "with the challenges I guess how manual", "3b85DPS1pBE-00035-00013872-00014144": "of we don't happen yet have I'm neither", "3b85DPS1pBE-00036-00014144-00015157": "a bun my mom while I'm a quandary", "3b85DPS1pBE-00037-00015158-00015626": "I'm already that one you are noble Anika", "3b85DPS1pBE-00038-00015627-00015854": "Virginia watch another work mom you need", "3b85DPS1pBE-00039-00015855-00016478": "your hair mm mm I wasn't acting like a", "3b85DPS1pBE-00040-00016479-00016703": "couple or Sukumar rolled up yourself", "3b85DPS1pBE-00041-00016704-00016968": "I don't know he did do a normal", "3b85DPS1pBE-00042-00016969-00017350": "[Music]", "3b85DPS1pBE-00043-00017351-00017669": "situation when no man will have seeded", "3b85DPS1pBE-00044-00017670-00017903": "I'm game on your negative she data me go", "3b85DPS1pBE-00045-00017904-00018701": "and me go me I'm naughty", "3b85DPS1pBE-00046-00018702-00018869": "you see the millennium almost waiting on", "3b85DPS1pBE-00047-00018870-00019415": "good lefty oh honey no we're saying I", "3b85DPS1pBE-00048-00019416-00019637": "see I'm under only his I was worried", "3b85DPS1pBE-00049-00019638-00020062": "when I'm at when do I know it happens", "3b85DPS1pBE-00050-00020063-00020404": "but you know"}}, {"audio_id": "3bDVeSy1TsU", "text": {"3bDVeSy1TsU-00000-00000142-00000391": "blakeley's I'd sold under the brand name", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00001-00000392-00000607": "dye a micron among others is an anti", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00002-00000608-00000782": "diabetic medication used to treat", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00003-00000783-00001127": "diabetes mellitus type 2 it is used when", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00004-00001128-00001387": "dietary changes exercise and weight loss", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00005-00001388-00001697": "are not enough it is taken by mouth side", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00006-00001698-00001882": "effects may include low blood sugar", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00007-00001884-00002162": "vomiting abdominal pain rash and liver", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00008-00002163-00002462": "problems used by those with significant", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00009-00002463-00002687": "kidney problems liver problems or who", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00010-00002688-00002841": "are pregnant is not recommended", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00011-00002842-00003142": "gliclazide is in the sulfonylurea family", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00012-00003143-00003374": "of medications it works mostly by", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00013-00003375-00003506": "increasing the release of insulin", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00014-00003507-00003833": "gliclazide was patented in 1966 and", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00015-00003834-00004193": "approved for medical use in 1972 it is", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00016-00004194-00004370": "on the World Health Organization's list", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00017-00004371-00004556": "of essential medicines the most", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00018-00004557-00004766": "effective and safe medicines needed in a", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00019-00004767-00005036": "health system the wholesale cost in the", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00020-00005037-00005249": "developing world is about two point four", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00021-00005250-00005474": "six to three United States dollars and", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00022-00005475-00005711": "ninety two cents per month in the United", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00023-00005712-00005963": "Kingdom a month of medication costs the", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00024-00005964-00006299": "NHS about two point one two pounds it is", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00025-00006300-00006493": "not available for sale in the United", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00026-00006494-00006704": "States", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00027-00006705-00007305": "medical uses gliclazide is used for", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00028-00007306-00007514": "control of hyperglycemia in gliclazide", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00029-00007515-00007794": "responsive diabetes mellitus of stable", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00030-00007795-00008078": "mild non ketosis prone type-2 diabetes", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00031-00008079-00008373": "it is used when diabetes cannot be", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00032-00008374-00008559": "controlled by proper dietary management", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00033-00008560-00008817": "and exercise or when insulin therapy is", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00034-00008818-00009063": "not appropriate", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00035-00009064-00009358": "National Kidney Foundation 2012 update", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00036-00009359-00009544": "claims that Blick Lezyne does not", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00037-00009545-00009769": "require dosage of titration even in", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00038-00009770-00010075": "end-stage kidney disease", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00039-00010076-00010909": "contraindications type 1 diabetes", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00040-00010910-00011363": "hypersensitivity to sulfonylureas severe", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00041-00011364-00011600": "renal or hepatic failure but relatively", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00042-00011601-00011987": "useful in mild renal impairment eg CKD", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00043-00011988-00012561": "stage 3 pregnancy and lactation", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00044-00012562-00013159": "adverse effects hypoglycemia", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00045-00013160-00013297": "while it was shown to have the same", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00046-00013297-00013510": "efficacy as glimepiride one of the newer", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00047-00013511-00013759": "sulfonylureas the European guide study", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00048-00013760-00013975": "has shown that it has approximately 50%", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00049-00013976-00014257": "less hypoglycemic confirmed episodes in", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00050-00014258-00014703": "comparison with glimepiride", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00051-00014704-00015291": "interactions hyperglycemic action may be", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00052-00015293-00015519": "caused by Dan Issel core promising", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00053-00015519-00015636": "glucocorticoids", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00054-00015637-00016005": "progestogen x' or veda - - agonists it's", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00055-00016006-00016266": "hypoglycemic action maybe potentiated by", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00056-00016268-00016561": "phenylbutazone alcohol fluconazole beta", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00057-00016562-00016867": "blockers and possibly ace inhibitors it", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00058-00016868-00017080": "has been found that rifampin increases", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00059-00017081-00017497": "gliclazide metabolism in humans in vivo", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00060-00017498-00018097": "overdose lickle azide overdose may cause", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00061-00018098-00018328": "severe hypoglycemia requiring urgent", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00062-00018329-00018560": "administration of glucose by IV and", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00063-00018561-00018891": "monitoring", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00064-00018892-00019429": "mechanism of action blakeley's I'd", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00065-00019430-00019639": "selectively binds to sulfonylurea", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00066-00019640-00019864": "receptors sir one on the surface of the", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00067-00019865-00020011": "pancreatic beta-cells", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00068-00020012-00020293": "it was shown to provide cardiovascular", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00069-00020294-00020464": "protection as it does not bind to", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00070-00020465-00020698": "sulfonylurea receptors as you are to a", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00071-00020699-00020992": "in the heart this binding effectively", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00072-00020993-00021244": "closes the k plus ion channels this", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00073-00021245-00021466": "decreases the efflux of potassium from", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00074-00021467-00021589": "the cell which leads to the", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00075-00021590-00021868": "depolarization of the cell this causes", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00076-00021869-00022114": "voltage dependent CA plus plus ion", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00077-00022115-00022354": "channels to open increasing the CA plus", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00078-00022355-00022456": "plus influx", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00079-00022457-00022708": "the calcium can then bind to and", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00080-00022709-00022921": "activate calmodulin which in turn leads", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00081-00022922-00023155": "to exocytosis of insulin vesicles", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00082-00023156-00023407": "leading to insulin release the mouse", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00083-00023408-00023656": "model of mode II diabetes suggested that", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00084-00023657-00023854": "the reduced gliclazide clearance stands", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00085-00023855-00024049": "behind their therapeutic success in", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00086-00024050-00024265": "human mode II patients but urban OVA at", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00087-00024266-00024475": "all found that human mode II patients", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00088-00024476-00024646": "respond differently and that there was", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00089-00024647-00024820": "no consistent decrease in gliclazide", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00090-00024821-00025129": "clearance in randomly selected hnf 1a", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00091-00025130-00025408": "Modi'in hnf for a mo d patients its", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00092-00025409-00025624": "classification has been ambiguous as", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00093-00025625-00025809": "literature uses it as both a first", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00094-00025810-00025977": "generation and second generation", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00095-00025977-00026256": "sulfonylurea", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00096-00026257-00026755": "properties according to the", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00097-00026756-00027004": "biopharmaceutical classification system", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00098-00027005-00027289": "VCS likley Zayed falls under the BCS", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00099-00027289-00027550": "class 2 drug which is poorly soluble and", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00100-00027551-00027805": "highly permeable water solubility equals", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00101-00027806-00028068": "zero point zero to seven milligrams per", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00102-00028069-00028480": "liter hypoglycemic sulfonylurea", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00103-00028481-00028668": "restoring first peak of insulin", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00104-00028669-00029160": "secretion increasing insulin sensitivity", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00105-00029161-00029425": "glycaemia independent hemo vascular", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00106-00029426-00029745": "effects antioxidant effect", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00107-00029745-00030167": "no active circulating metabolites", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00108-00030168-00030739": "metabolism gliclazide undergoes", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00109-00030741-00030958": "extensive metabolism to several and", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00110-00030960-00031148": "active metabolites in human beings", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00111-00031149-00031376": "mainly methyl hydroxy gliclazide in", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00112-00031377-00031823": "carboxy gliclazide cyp2c9 is involved in", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00113-00031824-00032048": "the formation of hydroxy gliclazide in", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00114-00032049-00032276": "human liver microsomes and in a panel of", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00115-00032277-00032654": "recombinant human p450s in vitro but the", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00116-00032655-00032879": "pharmacokinetics of gliclazide mr are", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00117-00032880-00033218": "affected mainly by cyp2c19 genetic", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00118-00033219-00033557": "polymorphism instead of cyp2c9 genetic", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00119-00033558-00034005": "polymorphism", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00120-00034006-00034409": "references", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00121-00034410-00035232": "external links servire advanced clinical", "3bDVeSy1TsU-00122-00035233-00035547": "trial on diabetes"}}, {"audio_id": "3csKQXNfoMg", "text": {"3csKQXNfoMg-00000-00000006-00000337": "we were interested in the stories that", "3csKQXNfoMg-00001-00000338-00000532": "had come out about case series of", "3csKQXNfoMg-00002-00000533-00000883": "patients who took these drugs for", "3csKQXNfoMg-00003-00000884-00001112": "Parkinson's disease who developed", "3csKQXNfoMg-00004-00001113-00001366": "compulsive gambling or hypersexuality", "3csKQXNfoMg-00005-00001367-00001616": "there were several different case", "3csKQXNfoMg-00006-00001617-00001780": "reports from the case series from Mayo", "3csKQXNfoMg-00007-00001782-00002101": "Clinic that pointed out shocking things", "3csKQXNfoMg-00008-00002102-00002222": "that had happened people who'd lost", "3csKQXNfoMg-00009-00002223-00002404": "hundreds of thousands of dollars or", "3csKQXNfoMg-00010-00002405-00002883": "engaged in in all kinds of very damaging", "3csKQXNfoMg-00011-00002884-00003238": "sexual indiscretions as a result of", "3csKQXNfoMg-00012-00003239-00003469": "being on these dopamine agonists drugs", "3csKQXNfoMg-00013-00003470-00003719": "so we were trying to figure out a way to", "3csKQXNfoMg-00014-00003720-00004058": "look at a local population and see how", "3csKQXNfoMg-00015-00004059-00004328": "frequent these behaviors occurred in", "3csKQXNfoMg-00016-00004329-00004640": "such population basically one in almost", "3csKQXNfoMg-00017-00004641-00004847": "five people on these therapeutic", "3csKQXNfoMg-00018-00004848-00005113": "dopamine agonists ended up in developing", "3csKQXNfoMg-00019-00005114-00005488": "compulsive behaviors what we suspect", "3csKQXNfoMg-00020-00005489-00005642": "it's probably an underestimate because", "3csKQXNfoMg-00021-00005643-00005843": "this was a retrospective study meaning", "3csKQXNfoMg-00022-00005844-00006115": "we looked at charts to see what had been", "3csKQXNfoMg-00023-00006116-00006421": "bad enough or upsetting enough that the", "3csKQXNfoMg-00024-00006422-00006575": "patient told the doctor and the doctor", "3csKQXNfoMg-00025-00006576-00006830": "wrote it in the chart so we didn't do", "3csKQXNfoMg-00026-00006831-00007052": "any kind of systematic searching we just", "3csKQXNfoMg-00027-00007053-00007309": "read the records and out of these", "3csKQXNfoMg-00028-00007311-00007559": "records popped these seven people who", "3csKQXNfoMg-00029-00007559-00008117": "had gambling issues or sex issues I", "3csKQXNfoMg-00030-00008118-00008252": "think the most important thing for a", "3csKQXNfoMg-00031-00008253-00008381": "clinician to be aware of with these", "3csKQXNfoMg-00032-00008382-00008732": "medications is that there is based on", "3csKQXNfoMg-00033-00008733-00009077": "our study of high proportion of patients", "3csKQXNfoMg-00034-00009078-00009431": "who potentially could develop new onset", "3csKQXNfoMg-00035-00009432-00009774": "gambling or new onset hypersexuality", "3csKQXNfoMg-00036-00009775-00010139": "these were tended to come on over weeks", "3csKQXNfoMg-00037-00010140-00010417": "or months and it emphasizes the", "3csKQXNfoMg-00038-00010418-00010633": "importance in follow-up appointments of", "3csKQXNfoMg-00039-00010634-00010844": "checking to see if the patient has", "3csKQXNfoMg-00040-00010845-00011096": "developed behaviors they never had", "3csKQXNfoMg-00041-00011097-00011170": "before", "3csKQXNfoMg-00042-00011171-00011428": "likewise it's good to warn patients and", "3csKQXNfoMg-00043-00011429-00011764": "families that this could happen and if", "3csKQXNfoMg-00044-00011765-00012026": "it does happen it could be due to the", "3csKQXNfoMg-00045-00012027-00012292": "drug if a 65 year old man with", "3csKQXNfoMg-00046-00012293-00012472": "Parkinson's disease who's never had", "3csKQXNfoMg-00047-00012473-00012700": "with gambling before suddenly become", "3csKQXNfoMg-00048-00012701-00012880": "someone compelled to go to the casinos", "3csKQXNfoMg-00049-00012881-00013513": "every day that's worth noting if mumait", "3csKQXNfoMg-00050-00013513-00013849": "jure change in behavior the and the", "3csKQXNfoMg-00051-00013850-00013944": "person has been started on these", "3csKQXNfoMg-00052-00013946-00014131": "dopamine agus drugs they could be the", "3csKQXNfoMg-00053-00014132-00014371": "cause of the trouble any physician who", "3csKQXNfoMg-00054-00014372-00014560": "sees a patient on a dopamine agonist", "3csKQXNfoMg-00055-00014561-00014838": "should be aware of the potential of", "3csKQXNfoMg-00056-00014840-00015031": "these drugs in therapeutic doses to", "3csKQXNfoMg-00057-00015032-00015343": "cause problems like this with gambling", "3csKQXNfoMg-00058-00015344-00015519": "and hypersexuality and other compulsive", "3csKQXNfoMg-00059-00015521-00015715": "behaviors these drugs only came into", "3csKQXNfoMg-00060-00015716-00015955": "wide use in the past decade and as", "3csKQXNfoMg-00061-00015956-00016369": "sometimes happens with with medications", "3csKQXNfoMg-00062-00016369-00016606": "we don't really know about some of them", "3csKQXNfoMg-00063-00016607-00016768": "were egregious side effects until", "3csKQXNfoMg-00064-00016769-00016978": "they've been used for several years it", "3csKQXNfoMg-00065-00016979-00017205": "doesn't necessarily mean that if you", "3csKQXNfoMg-00066-00017206-00017473": "develop these symptoms on the drug you", "3csKQXNfoMg-00067-00017474-00017755": "have to come off of it completely we had", "3csKQXNfoMg-00068-00017756-00017941": "at least one case where the person was", "3csKQXNfoMg-00069-00017942-00018151": "able to drop the dose by about a third", "3csKQXNfoMg-00070-00018152-00018703": "and the symptoms permitted so the", "3csKQXNfoMg-00071-00018704-00018892": "important point is to recognize what's", "3csKQXNfoMg-00072-00018893-00019111": "happening before you've squandered your", "3csKQXNfoMg-00073-00019112-00019312": "retirement or emptied your bank account", "3csKQXNfoMg-00074-00019313-00019732": "or gone broke"}}, {"audio_id": "3cbn6euc88A", "text": {"3cbn6euc88A-00000-00000064-00000254": "hi i'm ashley this is noah this is luke", "3cbn6euc88A-00001-00000256-00000399": "brother donation goals we're here so", "3cbn6euc88A-00002-00000400-00000823": "they're going to hit some food", "3cbn6euc88A-00003-00000824-00001103": "at the same time exactly oh at the same", "3cbn6euc88A-00004-00001104-00001166": "time", "3cbn6euc88A-00005-00001167-00002322": "yeah i mean how is he going to dig", "3cbn6euc88A-00006-00002323-00002710": "[Laughter]", "3cbn6euc88A-00007-00002711-00002992": "all right"}}, {"audio_id": "3d4zGi8tqYU", "text": {"3d4zGi8tqYU-00000-00001184-00001374": "iron throne of the gods", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00001-00001375-00001574": "well it looks like the iron throne is", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00002-00001575-00001718": "actually very real", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00003-00001719-00001910": "and experts the world over are", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00004-00001911-00002055": "suggesting that the void", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00005-00002056-00002302": "found within the great pyramid could", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00006-00002303-00002407": "actually house", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00007-00002408-00002710": "this ancient alien artifact wait", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00008-00002711-00002942": "till you hear this one guys the void", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00009-00002943-00003015": "that has been", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00010-00003016-00003279": "recently discovered in the great pyramid", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00011-00003279-00003479": "is so old that the dynastic", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00012-00003479-00003775": "egyptians probably did not even know it", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00013-00003776-00003879": "was there", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00014-00003879-00004111": "unlike the ark of the covenant that was", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00015-00004112-00004206": "stripped and", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00016-00004207-00004438": "shipped about all over the place when it", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00017-00004439-00004535": "was looted", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00018-00004536-00004806": "from the king's chamber the ancient", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00019-00004807-00005054": "relics that are hypothesized to exist", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00020-00005055-00005311": "in the unreachable mystery void are", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00021-00005312-00005422": "untouched", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00022-00005423-00005647": "so it gets you wondering is there a", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00023-00005648-00005751": "really ancient", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00024-00005752-00006006": "advanced technology still present here", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00025-00006007-00006127": "we say yes", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00026-00006128-00006343": "and we are just about to tell you why", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00027-00006344-00006439": "guys", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00028-00006440-00006663": "the iron throne has confounded experts", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00029-00006664-00006895": "for ages it is mentioned countless times", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00030-00006895-00007078": "in the ancient text of egypt", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00031-00007079-00007310": "but has it has never been properly", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00032-00007311-00007414": "associated", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00033-00007415-00007687": "with any particular place or time it", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00034-00007688-00007855": "came to earth as a meteorite", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00035-00007856-00008151": "and was carved into a throne pieces that", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00036-00008152-00008335": "were hacked away from the throne were", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00037-00008336-00008542": "made into ceremonial daggers", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00038-00008543-00008791": "and were gifted to pharaohs as the ages", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00039-00008792-00008878": "passed", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00040-00008879-00009135": "it is believed the iron throne sits in", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00041-00009136-00009223": "the chamber", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00042-00009224-00009478": "which is at least 30 meters long when", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00043-00009479-00009695": "the void was discovered in 2017", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00044-00009696-00009903": "researchers said it constituted the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00045-00009904-00010110": "first major inner structure", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00046-00010111-00010319": "found in the great pyramid since the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00047-00010320-00010495": "19th century", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00048-00010496-00010727": "using an imaging method and a robot", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00049-00010728-00010903": "based on cosmic rays", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00050-00010904-00011071": "scientists uncovered one of the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00051-00011072-00011295": "mysteries of the great pyramid", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00052-00011296-00011510": "further exploration is needed of course", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00053-00011511-00011727": "but it can't be denied that this pyramid", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00054-00011728-00011983": "the most mysterious place on earth the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00055-00011984-00012183": "only surviving wonder of the ancient", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00056-00012184-00012238": "world", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00057-00012239-00012510": "and the most accurate structure on earth", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00058-00012511-00012623": "still has secrets", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00059-00012624-00012886": "waiting to be uncovered the size and", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00060-00012887-00013038": "scale of the pyramid project", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00061-00013039-00013247": "is unthinkable in modern times and you", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00062-00013247-00013391": "just have to suggest", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00063-00013391-00013671": "that it is trying to tell us something", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00064-00013672-00013863": "when will we start listening", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00065-00013863-00014079": "for the moment the prospections are to", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00066-00014080-00014247": "approximate to allow us", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00067-00014247-00014486": "any definitive conclusions however the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00068-00014487-00014551": "existing", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00069-00014552-00014719": "information together with what we know", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00070-00014719-00014951": "about the funerary religions of ancient", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00071-00014952-00015022": "egypt", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00072-00015023-00015191": "are sufficient to attempt at an", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00073-00015191-00015358": "explanation of the void", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00074-00015359-00015591": "which has been shown to exist inside the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00075-00015591-00015743": "pyramid of khufu", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00076-00015744-00015958": "it appears indeed that this void is not", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00077-00015959-00016191": "a failure in the construction", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00078-00016191-00016358": "neither can be interpreted as a", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00079-00016359-00016583": "structural feature such as a reliving", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00080-00016584-00016655": "chamber", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00081-00016656-00016847": "we proposed here that the void", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00082-00016848-00017094": "corresponds to a non-functional copy", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00083-00017095-00017327": "of the great gallery beginning at the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00084-00017328-00017471": "egress of the northern", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00085-00017472-00017703": "lower shaft and built to contain a", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00086-00017704-00017822": "symbolic object", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00087-00017823-00018071": "located under the apex of the pyramid", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00088-00018072-00018279": "the object might be a throne and down", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00089-00018280-00018519": "with sheets of meteoritic iron", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00090-00018520-00018775": "in accordance with some resurrection", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00091-00018776-00018847": "passages", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00092-00018848-00019079": "of the pyramid text what do you guys", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00093-00019080-00019230": "think of the mysterious void at the", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00094-00019231-00019311": "great pyramid", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00095-00019312-00019567": "of giza could an iron throne made of", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00096-00019568-00019655": "meteoric", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00097-00019656-00019911": "iron really exists within this chamber", "3d4zGi8tqYU-00098-00019912-00020623": "comment below and thank you for watching"}}, {"audio_id": "3dha4FoZ5WA", "text": {"3dha4FoZ5WA-00000-00000003-00000200": "the London borough of Hounslow as a", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00001-00000200-00000377": "peripheral London borough in the", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00002-00000378-00000614": "southwest of the conurbation as such", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00003-00000615-00000857": "part of the Metropolitan Greenbelt lies", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00004-00000858-00001157": "within its boundaries it has one of", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00005-00001158-00001412": "London's largest nature reserves as well", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00006-00001413-00001634": "as many smaller gardens and sports", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00007-00001635-00001979": "grounds the major areas are red font", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00008-00001980-00002221": "Lakes Country Park near Heathrow Airport", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00009-00002222-00002582": "created 1995 Blenheim Park Feltham", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00010-00002583-00002714": "Boston Manor Park", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00011-00002715-00002975": "and Nature Reserve a historic park which", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00012-00002976-00003254": "includes the 17th century boston manor", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00013-00003254-00003719": "house purchased 1923 by Hounslow council", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00014-00003720-00003995": "it has an ornamental lake with waterfowl", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00015-00003996-00004265": "3 tennis courts a modern well-equipped", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00016-00004266-00004640": "children's play area and cafeteria open", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00017-00004641-00004963": "8 a.m. till dusk Chizik common Chyzyk", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00018-00004964-00005060": "house grounds", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00019-00005061-00005320": "historic landscaped gardens crane park", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00020-00005321-00005585": "six miles ten kilometres linear", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00021-00005586-00005818": "Riverside Park Cranford Park duke's", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00022-00005819-00006086": "meadows a Riverside Park in Chyzyk which", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00023-00006087-00006361": "includes a play area sports clubs and a", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00024-00006362-00006828": "health and fitness centre Feltham Park", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00025-00006829-00007123": "Gunnar's buri Park Estate which includes", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00026-00007125-00007428": "Gunnar's buri Park House now a museum", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00027-00007429-00007735": "Han Werth Park or London air park a", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00028-00007736-00007981": "former airfield converted into a green", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00029-00007983-00008360": "open space Hounslow Heath a local nature", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00030-00008361-00008867": "reserve in wood Park pounds low Hounslow", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00031-00008868-00009110": "urban farm a rare breed centre and", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00032-00009111-00009425": "London's largest community farm", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00033-00009426-00009653": "Lampton Park one of the largest green", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00034-00009654-00009973": "areas and public parks in West London", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00035-00009974-00010333": "Austral apart a National Trust property", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00036-00010334-00010739": "red Lee's Park Isleworth Sian house", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00037-00010740-00011011": "residence of the Duke of Northumberland", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00038-00011012-00011609": "turn home green", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00039-00011610-00012143": "topic see also", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00040-00012144-00012688": "Hounslow", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00041-00012689-00013325": "topic notes", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00042-00013326-00013558": "you", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00043-00013559-00014125": "topic external links", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00044-00014126-00014463": "Hounslow parks and open spaces Hounslow", "3dha4FoZ5WA-00045-00014463-00014763": "info"}}, {"audio_id": "3dsvk5FGzPE", "text": {"3dsvk5FGzPE-00000-00000019-00000257": "the following is a list of the", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00001-00000258-00000473": "casualties count in battles in world", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00002-00000474-00000805": "history the list includes both sieges", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00003-00000806-00001028": "not technically battles but usually", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00004-00001029-00001237": "yielding similar combat related deaths", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00005-00001238-00001466": "and civilian casualties during the", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00006-00001467-00001810": "battles large battle casualty counts are", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00007-00001811-00002056": "almost impossible to calculate precisely", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00008-00002057-00002333": "many of these figures are estimates and", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00009-00002334-00002575": "where possible a range of estimates is", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00010-00002576-00002900": "presented figures display numbers of all", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00011-00002901-00003095": "types of casualties when available", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00012-00003096-00003368": "killed wounded missing and sick but may", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00013-00003369-00003635": "only include number killed where", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00014-00003636-00003884": "possible the list specifies whether or", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00015-00003885-00004099": "not prisoners are included in the count", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00016-00004100-00004397": "this list does not include bombing runs", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00017-00004398-00004640": "such as the attack on Pearl Harbor and", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00018-00004641-00004879": "the bombing of Tokyo or massacres such", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00019-00004880-00005108": "as The Rape of Nanking which despite", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00020-00005109-00005338": "potentially massive casualties are not", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00021-00005339-00005686": "typically classified as battles since", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00022-00005687-00005927": "they are usually one-sided engagements", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00023-00005928-00006143": "or the nation attack is not officially", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00024-00006144-00006464": "at war with the attackers tactical or", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00025-00006465-00006742": "strategic strikes however may form part", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00026-00006743-00006920": "of larger engagements which are", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00027-00006920-00007756": "themselves battles topic classical", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00028-00007758-00008405": "formation battles these refer to battles", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00029-00008406-00008648": "in which armies met on a single field of", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00030-00008649-00008819": "battle and fought each other for", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00031-00008820-00009073": "anywhere from one to several days", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00032-00009074-00009356": "military formations lost their impact", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00033-00009357-00009566": "and use of this type of battle died out", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00034-00009567-00010369": "in favor of grandeur military operations", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00035-00010370-00011105": "topic sieges and urban combat this list", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00036-00011106-00011335": "includes sieges as well as modern", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00037-00011336-00011528": "battles that were fought primarily in", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00038-00011529-00011891": "urban areas major military operations", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00039-00011892-00012103": "that included city fighting a listed", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00040-00012104-00012338": "below the battles included here", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00041-00012339-00013099": "inflicted at least 50,000 casualties", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00042-00013100-00013218": "topic", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00043-00013219-00013851": "major operations this list includes", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00044-00013852-00014118": "major operations and prolonged battles", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00045-00014119-00014369": "or operations fought over a large area", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00046-00014371-00014727": "or for a long time the duration of some", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00047-00014728-00014979": "operations like the Battle of Moscow are", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00048-00014980-00015222": "disputed so numbers found in various", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00049-00015222-00015986": "sources may differ for that reason alone", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00050-00015987-00016671": "topic see also list of wars and", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00051-00016672-00017141": "disasters by death toll list of battles", "3dsvk5FGzPE-00052-00017142-00017520": "equals equals notes"}}, {"audio_id": "3dA0JAtkdak", "text": {"3dA0JAtkdak-00000-00000000-00000221": "of course I teach every semester is art", "3dA0JAtkdak-00001-00000222-00000548": "259 history of art and I teach it in", "3dA0JAtkdak-00002-00000549-00000841": "many modalities I teach it completely in", "3dA0JAtkdak-00003-00000842-00001181": "the classroom in spring semester in fall", "3dA0JAtkdak-00004-00001182-00001408": "I teach at hybrid and in many summer", "3dA0JAtkdak-00005-00001409-00001687": "sessions I teach it completely online", "3dA0JAtkdak-00006-00001688-00002014": "lecture capture is very useful for", "3dA0JAtkdak-00007-00002016-00002246": "making sure that everybody has access to", "3dA0JAtkdak-00008-00002247-00002525": "the material it's also very useful for", "3dA0JAtkdak-00009-00002526-00002677": "students for whom English is not their", "3dA0JAtkdak-00010-00002678-00003050": "first language for going over the", "3dA0JAtkdak-00011-00003051-00003367": "material and helping with comprehension", "3dA0JAtkdak-00012-00003368-00003590": "walking into the first class room in", "3dA0JAtkdak-00013-00003590-00003772": "which i used it i would hear my voice", "3dA0JAtkdak-00014-00003773-00003992": "coming from four or five laptops with", "3dA0JAtkdak-00015-00003993-00004181": "people listening to and i thought oh my", "3dA0JAtkdak-00016-00004182-00004385": "goodness they actually do use this I", "3dA0JAtkdak-00017-00004386-00004601": "know that when I was an undergraduate", "3dA0JAtkdak-00018-00004602-00004769": "student and there was a professor", "3dA0JAtkdak-00019-00004770-00005075": "speaking at the front of the classroom I", "3dA0JAtkdak-00020-00005076-00005302": "think even the most engaged student can", "3dA0JAtkdak-00021-00005303-00005677": "occasionally drift off and so for exam", "3dA0JAtkdak-00022-00005678-00005872": "review I think it would have been a", "3dA0JAtkdak-00023-00005873-00006068": "lovely thing to have been able to look", "3dA0JAtkdak-00024-00006069-00006383": "not at entire lectures but at parts of", "3dA0JAtkdak-00025-00006384-00006692": "lectures to to be able to be really", "3dA0JAtkdak-00026-00006693-00007091": "certain of things I was sick a couple of", "3dA0JAtkdak-00027-00007092-00007262": "weeks ago and I knew I had those", "3dA0JAtkdak-00028-00007263-00007478": "lectures recorder from past time so I", "3dA0JAtkdak-00029-00007479-00007708": "just said this is it we're going to use", "3dA0JAtkdak-00030-00007709-00008042": "pre-recorded lectures I walk into the", "3dA0JAtkdak-00031-00008043-00008270": "classroom that is that is set up for", "3dA0JAtkdak-00032-00008271-00008483": "media site I just turn on my regular", "3dA0JAtkdak-00033-00008484-00008810": "projector I put on a microphone and I", "3dA0JAtkdak-00034-00008811-00009151": "just click on the media site panel and", "3dA0JAtkdak-00035-00009152-00009571": "turn on the cameras and it is", "3dA0JAtkdak-00036-00009572-00009806": "automatically scheduled to record and", "3dA0JAtkdak-00037-00009807-00010130": "when I have to do a relay recording I", "3dA0JAtkdak-00038-00010131-00010487": "have to hook up the microphone I also", "3dA0JAtkdak-00039-00010488-00010888": "have to enter the TechSmith relay site", "3dA0JAtkdak-00040-00010889-00011270": "put in my name and my password as well", "3dA0JAtkdak-00041-00011271-00011480": "as get my powerpoint set up and that", "3dA0JAtkdak-00042-00011481-00011687": "takes a lot of minutes when the", "3dA0JAtkdak-00043-00011688-00011831": "beginning of the class when students are", "3dA0JAtkdak-00044-00011832-00012023": "asking questions and if I don't do it", "3dA0JAtkdak-00045-00012024-00012253": "correctly and hit the record button and", "3dA0JAtkdak-00046-00012254-00012455": "make sure that the microphone is", "3dA0JAtkdak-00047-00012456-00012674": "functioning properly then it won't", "3dA0JAtkdak-00048-00012675-00012886": "record so TechSmith takes a little bit", "3dA0JAtkdak-00049-00012887-00013108": "relay takes a little bit more calm", "3dA0JAtkdak-00050-00013109-00013408": "centration the media site one has the", "3dA0JAtkdak-00051-00013409-00013725": "capacity in both relay and media site", "3dA0JAtkdak-00052-00013726-00014107": "you can scroll up and down if you want", "3dA0JAtkdak-00053-00014108-00014332": "to and just pick up any part of the", "3dA0JAtkdak-00054-00014333-00014547": "lecture and as long as it's loaded it", "3dA0JAtkdak-00055-00014548-00014803": "will start speaking it you can make the", "3dA0JAtkdak-00056-00014804-00015055": "image is quite large with a real a", "3dA0JAtkdak-00057-00015056-00015394": "recording so students with laptops can", "3dA0JAtkdak-00058-00015394-00015568": "resize it and the image comes up nice", "3dA0JAtkdak-00059-00015569-00015783": "and big and nice and clear with the text", "3dA0JAtkdak-00060-00015784-00016069": "nice and big nice and clear with media", "3dA0JAtkdak-00061-00016069-00016485": "site this is the size of the image you", "3dA0JAtkdak-00062-00016486-00016783": "can click the button in the top right", "3dA0JAtkdak-00063-00016784-00017055": "hand corner and you can zoom in which is", "3dA0JAtkdak-00064-00017056-00017181": "a very nice feature because when you", "3dA0JAtkdak-00065-00017182-00017481": "zoom in it's very clear you can make the", "3dA0JAtkdak-00066-00017482-00017697": "whole thing bigger but there's a big", "3dA0JAtkdak-00067-00017698-00017905": "difference in the size of the image and", "3dA0JAtkdak-00068-00017906-00018261": "this is my only beef with media site for", "3dA0JAtkdak-00069-00018262-00018499": "my particular content in general people", "3dA0JAtkdak-00070-00018500-00018703": "will are able to become more familiar", "3dA0JAtkdak-00071-00018704-00019021": "with the images and and the way I", "3dA0JAtkdak-00072-00019022-00019267": "analyze the images and helping them to", "3dA0JAtkdak-00073-00019268-00019552": "learn how to look and see one of the big", "3dA0JAtkdak-00074-00019553-00019753": "assignments in the class is to go to a", "3dA0JAtkdak-00075-00019754-00020019": "local museum and find a work of art that", "3dA0JAtkdak-00076-00020020-00020184": "fits in with the time scheme and", "3dA0JAtkdak-00077-00020185-00020368": "geographical area of the course and", "3dA0JAtkdak-00078-00020369-00020683": "analyzed using the tools learning class", "3dA0JAtkdak-00079-00020684-00020994": "and so if people have missed classes or", "3dA0JAtkdak-00080-00020995-00021381": "are not understanding things as I say", "3dA0JAtkdak-00081-00021382-00021669": "them it allows them to to go back at", "3dA0JAtkdak-00082-00021670-00021853": "their own pace and think of how did", "3dA0JAtkdak-00083-00021854-00022231": "actually she talked about this material"}}, {"audio_id": "3deVH68jsGA", "text": {"3deVH68jsGA-00000-00000527-00000743": "and you know this is the second largest", "3deVH68jsGA-00001-00000744-00000991": "shopping complex of bangladesh so i'm", "3deVH68jsGA-00002-00000992-00001166": "here and most of you guys know the", "3deVH68jsGA-00003-00001167-00001319": "shopping mall because it is really", "3deVH68jsGA-00004-00001320-00001462": "popular among you", "3deVH68jsGA-00005-00001463-00001655": "and many of you come here during eid or", "3deVH68jsGA-00006-00001655-00001798": "puja so", "3deVH68jsGA-00007-00001800-00002030": "for shopping this is a best place and", "3deVH68jsGA-00008-00002032-00002239": "i'm gonna today talk about my experience", "3deVH68jsGA-00009-00002240-00002471": "in bush university as well as", "3deVH68jsGA-00010-00002472-00002758": "its formation and what you can find here", "3deVH68jsGA-00011-00002759-00002999": "so let's start", "3deVH68jsGA-00012-00003000-00003327": "generally it was made in 2003", "3deVH68jsGA-00013-00003328-00003631": "6th of august and in bush university you", "3deVH68jsGA-00014-00003632-00003822": "can get any kind of thing you need for", "3deVH68jsGA-00015-00003823-00003975": "your daily activities", "3deVH68jsGA-00016-00003976-00004167": "here the most important and most", "3deVH68jsGA-00017-00004168-00004415": "interesting thing i think is star", "3deVH68jsGA-00018-00004416-00004519": "cineplex", "3deVH68jsGA-00019-00004520-00004822": "i love movies and i adore them a lot and", "3deVH68jsGA-00020-00004823-00004879": "so", "3deVH68jsGA-00021-00004880-00005079": "i come to star cineplex at bush", "3deVH68jsGA-00022-00005080-00005270": "university for watching movies", "3deVH68jsGA-00023-00005271-00005559": "it's a really great place where you can", "3deVH68jsGA-00024-00005560-00005815": "enjoy in a theater or in a 3d", "3deVH68jsGA-00025-00005816-00006167": "way so it's really interesting and", "3deVH68jsGA-00026-00006168-00006431": "in both universities you can do any kind", "3deVH68jsGA-00027-00006431-00006614": "of shopping like you can get sarees", "3deVH68jsGA-00028-00006615-00006846": "jewelries cosmetics shoes", "3deVH68jsGA-00029-00006847-00007070": "mobile phones and whatnot in bush", "3deVH68jsGA-00030-00007072-00007206": "university you're also getting", "3deVH68jsGA-00031-00007208-00007495": "the facility of a very nice and amazing", "3deVH68jsGA-00032-00007495-00007695": "playground which is called toggy world", "3deVH68jsGA-00033-00007695-00007983": "it's really amazing for the children so", "3deVH68jsGA-00034-00007984-00008159": "children those who are watching", "3deVH68jsGA-00035-00008159-00008342": "i hope you'll come to troggy world next", "3deVH68jsGA-00036-00008343-00008487": "time you hear my", "3deVH68jsGA-00037-00008488-00008742": "presentation so bush university is", "3deVH68jsGA-00038-00008743-00008823": "really", "3deVH68jsGA-00039-00008824-00009142": "really a great place for shopping", "3deVH68jsGA-00040-00009143-00009367": "and the food course here are really", "3deVH68jsGA-00041-00009368-00009446": "healthy and", "3deVH68jsGA-00042-00009447-00009727": "hygienic so you can visit anytime this", "3deVH68jsGA-00043-00009728-00009895": "is my first time during this foreign", "3deVH68jsGA-00044-00009896-00010110": "pandemic i'm visiting bush university", "3deVH68jsGA-00045-00010111-00010399": "inshallah i will visit bush university", "3deVH68jsGA-00046-00010400-00010478": "next time", "3deVH68jsGA-00047-00010479-00010703": "after this foreign epidemic ends so", "3deVH68jsGA-00048-00010704-00010838": "thank you so much for watching this", "3deVH68jsGA-00049-00010839-00010983": "video i hope you guys", "3deVH68jsGA-00050-00010984-00011167": "will enjoy this video in bhushan", "3deVH68jsGA-00051-00011168-00012535": "harassing so", "3deVH68jsGA-00052-00012536-00012879": "bangladesh online school we shape", "3deVH68jsGA-00053-00012880-00013207": "future for admission please", "3deVH68jsGA-00054-00013208-00013535": "call our sms two zero one six two zero", "3deVH68jsGA-00055-00013536-00013575": "zero", "3deVH68jsGA-00056-00013576-00014056": "zero four two double zero"}}, {"audio_id": "3dNjNEi7EFk", "text": {"3dNjNEi7EFk-00000-00000022-00002407": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00001-00002408-00002597": "thank you", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00002-00002598-00002857": "foreign", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00003-00002858-00003593": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00004-00003594-00003765": "foreign", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00005-00003765-00004878": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00006-00004879-00006078": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00007-00006079-00006989": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00008-00006990-00007136": "foreign", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00009-00007137-00007604": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00010-00007605-00007717": "[Applause]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00011-00007718-00011406": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00012-00011407-00011833": "thank you", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00013-00011834-00012379": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00014-00012380-00013438": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00015-00013440-00013946": "foreign", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00016-00013947-00014249": "[Music]", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00017-00014250-00014366": "foreign", "3dNjNEi7EFk-00018-00014368-00014753": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3dTcbR1_Mfc", "text": {"3dTcbR1_Mfc-00000-00000071-00000311": "uh yeah so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00001-00000312-00000591": "i actually um for me this is going to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00002-00000592-00000711": "a very useful", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00003-00000712-00001047": "um exercise since i am", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00004-00001048-00001439": "shallowly knowledgeable of maybe some of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00005-00001440-00001759": "the that's relevant proposals um so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00006-00001760-00002014": "alex when you provided this uh it are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00007-00002016-00002102": "these all of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00008-00002103-00002447": "the pending proposals to cc 39 at any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00009-00002448-00002558": "stage", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00010-00002559-00002855": "no um what they are are a list of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00011-00002856-00002999": "proposals that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00012-00003000-00003199": "i went through i went through the list", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00013-00003200-00003503": "of tc39 proposals in all stages", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00014-00003504-00003854": "um primarily trying to match names of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00015-00003855-00004319": "various sponsors to our group here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00016-00004320-00004622": "and that was my only criteria was okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00017-00004623-00004951": "is somebody that i recognize on that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00018-00004952-00005143": "list", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00019-00005144-00005567": "okay so this is a good place to start um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00020-00005568-00005767": "and if i'm missing one that you guys", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00021-00005768-00005967": "want to champion here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00022-00005968-00006318": "by all means add it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00023-00006319-00006742": "cool i think maybe a good way to start", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00024-00006743-00006887": "this exercise would be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00025-00006888-00007231": "to ask somebody more familiar", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00026-00007231-00007639": "to um uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00027-00007640-00008070": "to go through this list", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00028-00008072-00008383": "might be relevant to cess okay are these", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00029-00008384-00008487": "were these gathered", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00030-00008488-00008799": "from their proposals the overall", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00031-00008800-00008910": "proposals", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00032-00008911-00009231": "or these gathered from the agenda these", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00033-00009232-00009455": "were gathered from the tc39", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00034-00009456-00009783": "proposals page okay we only want to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00035-00009784-00010055": "to cover those that are on the tce 39", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00036-00010056-00010238": "agenda", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00037-00010239-00010414": "uh anything that's not being brought up", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00038-00010415-00010542": "at this meeting we don't need to talk", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00039-00010543-00010823": "about it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00040-00010824-00011199": "uh i hope that we could i think there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00041-00011200-00011391": "two different exercises that are being", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00042-00011392-00011599": "conflated here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00043-00011600-00011799": "okay i was thinking we were talking", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00044-00011800-00011967": "about these in preparation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00045-00011968-00012327": "for this tc39 that was not my intention", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00046-00012328-00012391": "sir", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00047-00012392-00012606": "i see i see i did not understand that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00048-00012607-00012767": "okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00049-00012768-00013022": "okay we can talk about these that said", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00050-00013023-00013094": "there's no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00051-00013095-00013343": "the only ordering that i put there was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00052-00013344-00013575": "stage three first stage two next stage", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00053-00013576-00013647": "one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00054-00013647-00013815": "if there's one that's coming up for the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00055-00013816-00013951": "next meeting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00056-00013952-00014127": "but and you want to do that one first by", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00057-00014128-00014486": "all means there's no ordering to this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00058-00014487-00014622": "prioritizing things that are on the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00059-00014623-00014783": "agenda for the next meeting seems like a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00060-00014784-00014919": "sensible", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00061-00014919-00015222": "okay and and among them prioritizing the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00062-00015223-00015375": "things at later stages", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00063-00015376-00015558": "also does make sense because they're the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00064-00015559-00015783": "ones that are that we're in more danger", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00065-00015784-00015863": "of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00066-00015863-00016038": "uh if there's something that needs to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00067-00016040-00016215": "fixed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00068-00016216-00016671": "um okay so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00069-00016672-00017007": "have we actually started recording yes", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00070-00017008-00017367": "yes all right well let's um mark", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00071-00017368-00017550": "do you know where to look to find out", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00072-00017551-00017694": "what's on the agenda for the next", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00073-00017695-00017847": "meeting and so we can prioritize", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00074-00017848-00017943": "accordingly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00075-00017944-00018230": "yes i'm i'm trying to get there right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00076-00018231-00018271": "now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00077-00018272-00018503": "really i have i have that page up i have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00078-00018504-00018663": "that page open i can just grab", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00079-00018664-00019022": "okay we can post it okay um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00080-00019023-00019271": "and uh you're gonna put it in the link", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00081-00019272-00021083": "in chat", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00082-00021084-00022278": "okay um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00083-00022279-00022591": "okay so i'm just going to starting at", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00084-00022592-00022807": "section 12", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00085-00022808-00023127": "i'm going to read the names and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00086-00023128-00023430": "um uh for mo for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00087-00023431-00023671": "many of these i think i'll claim that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00088-00023672-00023839": "they're not relevant and if anybody else", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00089-00023840-00023871": "has", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00090-00023872-00024239": "information to stop me", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00091-00024240-00024550": "so string.prototype.replaceall i believe", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00092-00024551-00024742": "is not relevant", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00093-00024743-00025119": "um named evaluation i actually don't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00094-00025120-00025311": "know what that is but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00095-00025312-00025591": "certainly sounds i can't not know what", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00096-00025592-00025758": "it is if it's stage three", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00097-00025760-00026070": "um somebody know what that is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00098-00026072-00026599": "it's the uh name inference for functions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00099-00026600-00026974": "oh oh okay um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00100-00026975-00027327": "uh okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00101-00027327-00027502": "i don't think there's anything scary", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00102-00027504-00027695": "there um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00103-00027695-00027999": "uh promise dot any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00104-00028000-00028327": "and aggregate error", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00105-00028327-00028670": "is uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00106-00028672-00028943": "there's this this was driven by the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00107-00028944-00029199": "attempt to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00108-00029200-00029527": "sort of complete around", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00109-00029527-00029895": "the duels of various things so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00110-00029895-00030418": "um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00111-00030419-00030918": "promise.all uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00112-00030919-00031327": "succeeds if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00113-00031327-00031695": "any of the components um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00114-00031695-00032023": "uh fulfill the promise. that all", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00115-00032024-00032190": "fulfills if any of the components", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00116-00032191-00032423": "fulfill or it rejects", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00117-00032424-00032735": "of any of the components for rejects so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00118-00032736-00032774": "the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00119-00032775-00033135": "dual is one that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00120-00033136-00033327": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00121-00033328-00033687": "rejects if any of the components rejects", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00122-00033688-00033902": "i'm sorry reject the other way around", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00123-00033903-00034015": "reject if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00124-00034016-00034383": "all of the components rejects and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00125-00034384-00034702": "accepts if any of the components", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00126-00034703-00035083": "except and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00127-00035084-00035551": "i i don't find this a tremendously well", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00128-00035552-00035918": "motivated uh operation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00129-00035919-00036207": "um but uh you know it's there for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00130-00036208-00036390": "symmetry and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00131-00036391-00036807": "um uh but the new", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00132-00036808-00037167": "issue that it raises is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00133-00037168-00037543": "in the case where everything rejects", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00134-00037544-00037807": "what do you report in the case of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00135-00037808-00038015": "promise.all when everything", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00136-00038016-00038151": "accepts i'm sorry when everything", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00137-00038152-00038343": "fulfills", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00138-00038344-00038574": "the thing you report is an array of the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00139-00038575-00038839": "fulfillments", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00140-00038840-00039215": "in the case where everything rejects", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00141-00039216-00039446": "you still have to report a rejection a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00142-00039447-00039727": "rejection is a single error", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00143-00039728-00039951": "but you've got multiple errors to report", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00144-00039952-00040174": "so this aggregate error was this new", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00145-00040175-00040390": "concept that's introduced", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00146-00040391-00040702": "to jointly report", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00147-00040703-00040943": "all the component errors as components", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00148-00040944-00041239": "of the aggregate error", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00149-00041240-00041599": "and that led to a very long discussion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00150-00041600-00041983": "about whether that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00151-00041984-00042358": "new aggregation is in a own property", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00152-00042359-00042774": "or an internal a new internal slot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00153-00042775-00043199": "i objected on security grounds to a new", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00154-00043200-00043567": "exotic internal slot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00155-00043568-00043783": "carries an object reference all the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00156-00043784-00043895": "existing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00157-00043896-00044302": "262 exotic internal slots carry only", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00158-00044303-00044455": "data", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00159-00044456-00044755": "like date and therefore they're", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00160-00044756-00044974": "confidentiality holes", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00161-00044975-00045167": "but they're not uh they they're not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00162-00045168-00045335": "capability leaks", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00163-00045336-00045639": "um so that was successful but it is now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00164-00045640-00045911": "going forward by proposing that's an own", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00165-00045912-00046007": "property", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00166-00046008-00046230": "uh i think that's all there is to say", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00167-00046231-00046430": "about that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00168-00046431-00046679": "i actually have a follow-up question on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00169-00046680-00046807": "that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00170-00046808-00047230": "um it's true that there are no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00171-00047231-00047495": "object bearing internal slots that i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00172-00047496-00047655": "could find in 262", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00173-00047656-00047902": "but there's at least one in 402 and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00174-00047903-00048151": "maybe more i'm not i'm not done looking", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00175-00048152-00048479": "how do we feel about that tell me what's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00176-00048480-00048527": "the one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00177-00048528-00048830": "and 40 tip i the the uh i find it very", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00178-00048831-00048943": "scary", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00179-00048944-00049286": "yeah well i mean um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00180-00049287-00049646": "so i i'm part way through", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00181-00049647-00049783": "through the search the one that i found", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00182-00049784-00050030": "so far is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00183-00050031-00050483": "the compare method of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00184-00050484-00050983": "uh intel collater instances", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00185-00050984-00051326": "um it's it manifests as a getter on the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00186-00051327-00051487": "prototype", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00187-00051488-00051942": "and when upon first invocation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00188-00051944-00052263": "it creates a bound function and puts it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00189-00052264-00052623": "in a slot and then and every subsequent", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00190-00052624-00052900": "invocation returns that bound function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00191-00052901-00053282": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00192-00053283-00053694": "it's truly bizarre from my perspective", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00193-00053695-00054047": "but um but is published uh can you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00194-00054048-00054359": "um uh send a link to that just send it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00195-00054360-00054463": "to the scs", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00196-00054464-00054942": "strategy mailing list a link to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00197-00054944-00055150": "to the um to the problem to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00198-00055151-00055303": "definition of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00199-00055304-00055775": "to the definition okay yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00200-00055776-00056087": "uh for the record what was what was the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00201-00056088-00056135": "name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00202-00056136-00056487": "of this feature", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00203-00056488-00056863": "it was the compare of the collaters", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00204-00056864-00057254": "right so when when you create a collater", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00205-00057255-00057654": "instance and then you try to access the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00206-00057655-00057815": "compare method", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00207-00057816-00058126": "of it that runs a getter", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00208-00058127-00058463": "which which will return you a function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00209-00058464-00059094": "bound to the receiver", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00210-00059095-00059335": "and it stores that and it will return", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00211-00059336-00059454": "the same one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00212-00059455-00059742": "on subsequent calls uh which it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00213-00059744-00059919": "accomplishes by storing it in an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00214-00059920-00060103": "internal slot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00215-00060104-00060438": "does that mean if i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00216-00060439-00060871": "if i wrap the collater and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00217-00060872-00061279": "do the getter with a different receiver", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00218-00061279-00061591": "it could store a different receiver than", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00219-00061591-00062071": "the collater itself", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00220-00062072-00062559": "it might because that sounds like a bug", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00221-00062560-00062919": "i uh yeah actually so let me let me put", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00222-00062920-00063015": "the link in the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00223-00063016-00064391": "in the chat here as well", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00224-00064391-00064775": "let's see no so um it captures", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00225-00064776-00065111": "captures the receiver binds a function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00226-00065112-00065350": "to it and then stores it as a slot on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00227-00065351-00065719": "the receiver", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00228-00065720-00065967": "yeah but it only does a require internal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00229-00065968-00066055": "slot on it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00230-00066056-00066263": "so you could mask it with a different", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00231-00066264-00066399": "collater", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00232-00066400-00066623": "and bind it to a different collater", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00233-00066624-00066782": "right but if you did so then it would", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00234-00066783-00066879": "set this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00235-00066880-00067223": "like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00236-00067224-00067479": "it's not going to cross the wires oh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00237-00067480-00067526": "yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00238-00067527-00067863": "because it it's on co later it's not on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00239-00067864-00068199": "right okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00240-00068200-00068391": "uh but it is an instance and i and i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00241-00068392-00068631": "confirmed that the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00242-00068632-00068894": "um that the implementations conform to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00243-00068895-00069047": "it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00244-00069048-00069326": "okay so so you could yeah you could", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00245-00069327-00069526": "obviously use this as a communications", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00246-00069527-00069575": "channel", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00247-00069576-00070359": "uh if you had intel on both sides", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00248-00070360-00070655": "okay so we definitely need to worry", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00249-00070656-00070719": "about this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00250-00070720-00070748": "um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00251-00070749-00071343": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00252-00071344-00071503": "okay all right so that's that's the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00253-00071504-00071647": "relevant information that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00254-00071648-00071903": "um that i wanted from it is basically", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00255-00071904-00072038": "like yes 402", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00256-00072039-00072231": "is in play yes it's a concern there as", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00257-00072232-00072423": "well um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00258-00072424-00072711": "and uh and that actually affects one of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00259-00072712-00072838": "the changes that i'm making now to a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00260-00072839-00073023": "current proposal um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00261-00073024-00073382": "for segmentation do you know", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00262-00073383-00073855": "if there's a reason why they save it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00263-00073856-00074238": "uh presumably so that the um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00264-00074239-00074606": "so it compares equal on subsequent gets", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00265-00074607-00074887": "so if you do like collateral.compare", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00266-00074888-00075079": "equals equals equals cooler.compare that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00267-00075080-00075871": "you'll get a true result i just don't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00268-00075872-00076294": "know if that's useful in reality", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00269-00076295-00076647": "well i to be frank what i think is not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00270-00076648-00076894": "useful is having a getter at all", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00271-00076895-00077135": "like this should have been just an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00272-00077136-00077223": "ordinary", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00273-00077224-00077503": "data property on the instances in my", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00274-00077504-00077631": "opinion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00275-00077632-00077959": "do you know well i guess we can figure", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00276-00077960-00078111": "out maybe it would be better to go on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00277-00078112-00078406": "the 402 call and ask", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00278-00078407-00078711": "well i do i think", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00279-00078712-00078919": "i think probably yes and it's something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00280-00078920-00079062": "that i just found today", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00281-00079063-00079511": "but i was rereading the the thread from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00282-00079512-00079935": "uh the promise any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00283-00079936-00080238": "discussion and it seems like there is at", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00284-00080239-00080335": "least", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00285-00080336-00080671": "at least one person probably more", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00286-00080672-00081167": "on the tc39 committee that that has this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00287-00081168-00081487": "affinity for prototype hosted", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00288-00081488-00081743": "accessors and and that to me feels like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00289-00081744-00081879": "the real", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00290-00081880-00082238": "source of this kind of bug", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00291-00082239-00082471": "yeah uh jordan harban has a very very", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00292-00082472-00082718": "strong affinity for that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00293-00082719-00083150": "right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00294-00083151-00083335": "so and that's the reason why i brought", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00295-00083336-00083455": "it up today also yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00296-00083456-00083767": "just just wanting to it i i think it is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00297-00083768-00083918": "not harmless", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00298-00083919-00084326": "is to summarize the position but i think", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00299-00084327-00084615": "this might actually be changeable in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00300-00084616-00084782": "reality yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00301-00084783-00085103": "like beyond the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00302-00085104-00085455": "object descriptor is there anything that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00303-00085456-00085687": "we would actually observe by", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00304-00085688-00086006": "change this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00305-00086007-00086423": "access accessory in an actual function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00306-00086424-00086775": "property um from from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00307-00086776-00087047": "ecmascript code it would be observable i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00308-00087048-00087143": "believe only", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00309-00087144-00087503": "off the descriptor so like it is it is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00310-00087504-00087638": "an observable change", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00311-00087639-00087943": "um but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00312-00087944-00088343": "it's in a very minor space also yeah the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00313-00088344-00088662": "people actually using collater compare", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00314-00088663-00088687": "is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00315-00088688-00089094": "not as high as it could be unfortunately", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00316-00089095-00089303": "but again i suspect there are um there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00317-00089304-00089526": "are probably one or two other instances", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00318-00089527-00089855": "i will send them all in a bulk email any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00319-00089856-00089991": "any others that come up are going to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00320-00089992-00090318": "similar to this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00321-00090319-00090750": "or it'll be an accessor on the prototype", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00322-00090751-00091031": "and um and one way or another interacts", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00323-00091032-00091326": "with a slot on the instance", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00324-00091327-00091750": "are there any collateral instances", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00325-00091751-00092079": "among the primordials no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00326-00092080-00092471": "no okay and the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00327-00092472-00092775": "collateral prototype is an is a regular", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00328-00092776-00092959": "object that does not have the internal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00329-00092960-00093087": "slot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00330-00093088-00093767": "correct okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00331-00093768-00094238": "okay so i'm good with that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00332-00094239-00094671": "sounds like a good find yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00333-00094672-00094959": "yeah thanks for finding that is this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00334-00094960-00095118": "thing with the collector", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00335-00095119-00095447": "in the agenda for the meeting no uh but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00336-00095448-00095735": "what what i so i i missed i missed the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00337-00095736-00095935": "normal time window um but what is going", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00338-00095936-00096071": "to be on the agenda what i am going to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00339-00096072-00096167": "bring up", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00340-00096168-00096471": "uh is uh intel dot segmenter", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00341-00096472-00096974": "where there is an instance", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00342-00096975-00097271": "that uh should have a link back to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00343-00097272-00097399": "thing that created it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00344-00097400-00097623": "and i want to avoid this pattern i want", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00345-00097624-00097838": "to use just regular", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00346-00097839-00098055": "data properties rather than prototype", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00347-00098056-00098279": "hosted accessors", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00348-00098280-00098518": "well you have the plus one from the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00349-00098519-00098599": "editor", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00350-00098600-00098935": "of vacuum 402.", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00351-00098936-00099247": "thank you um i'll put that change in now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00352-00099248-00099382": "i'm actually i'm working on it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00353-00099383-00099694": "simultaneously with this meeting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00354-00099695-00100015": "okay so good", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00355-00100016-00100294": "for the records same for modifying this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00356-00100295-00100367": "collateral", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00357-00100368-00100911": "compare yeah like there is my plus one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00358-00100912-00101143": "should um should i try to put that on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00359-00101144-00101359": "the agenda", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00360-00101360-00101799": "i think as a distinct topic yes", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00361-00101800-00102103": "i think it fits into either a bug or", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00362-00102104-00102406": "editorial issue but editorial", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00363-00102407-00102582": "i would say because we just don't have a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00364-00102583-00102871": "clear guideline for proposals on this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00365-00102872-00103239": "uh what is it oh sure yeah like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00366-00103240-00103518": "procedural aspects notwithstanding is is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00367-00103519-00103663": "this a discussion that we wish to have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00368-00103664-00103839": "in the upcoming tc39 meeting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00369-00103840-00104039": "i think it needs to be there just so we", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00370-00104040-00104142": "can document it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00371-00104143-00104471": "and have it for future reference okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00372-00104472-00105083": "i will do that as well", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00373-00105083-00105275": "good so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00374-00105276-00105607": "decorators uh so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00375-00105608-00105943": "uh i don't know uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00376-00105944-00106310": "what the status is now uh whatever it is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00377-00106311-00106483": "i can guarantee you is security", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00378-00106483-00106615": "significant", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00379-00106616-00106966": "um they're still doing weekly calls", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00380-00106967-00107183": "there's nothing really to report as they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00381-00107183-00107278": "kind of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00382-00107279-00107558": "are discussing use cases again um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00383-00107559-00107823": "they're trying to strip it down a lot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00384-00107824-00108071": "it got stripped down far enough at one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00385-00108072-00108207": "point they were only gonna", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00386-00108208-00108423": "talk about having three decorators and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00387-00108424-00108654": "not custom decorators", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00388-00108655-00108951": "uh the participants on the call uh been", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00389-00108952-00109039": "following", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00390-00109040-00109375": "um wanted to do more but for now there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00391-00109376-00109431": "just", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00392-00109432-00109878": "it's nothing to talk about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00393-00109879-00110263": "okay i find it intriguing they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00394-00110264-00110478": "they only set in five minutes for the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00395-00110479-00110639": "creators", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00396-00110640-00110783": "i think they're just going to say go to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00397-00110783-00111039": "the phone call", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00398-00111040-00111390": "okay right with a five-minute time box", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00399-00111391-00111702": "um they're not expecting to get into", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00400-00111703-00112239": "anything controversial um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00401-00112240-00112399": "all right so yuyo is going to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00402-00112400-00112543": "speaking about iteration", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00403-00112544-00112743": "helpers which i know i think i know what", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00404-00112744-00112847": "iteration helpers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00405-00112848-00113134": "are or at least used to be uh but then", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00406-00113135-00113319": "in her title she says", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00407-00113320-00113647": "what to do about generator steps", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00408-00113648-00113958": "so i don't know what that is about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00409-00113959-00114239": "so iterator helpers were looking to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00410-00114240-00114310": "reuse", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00411-00114311-00114558": "the generator infrastructure within ecma", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00412-00114559-00114678": "262.", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00413-00114679-00114854": "um the generator infrastructure in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00414-00114855-00115110": "ecma-262 however has things like dot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00415-00115111-00115190": "throw", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00416-00115191-00115575": "or dot return on generator results", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00417-00115576-00115895": "um so this is just a discussion on what", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00418-00115896-00116047": "to do about it because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00419-00116048-00116263": "for iterator helpers some stuff doesn't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00420-00116264-00116478": "make sense um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00421-00116479-00116743": "i see yeah i think generators are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00422-00116744-00116839": "bi-directional", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00423-00116840-00117095": "iterators are unidirectional is that the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00424-00117096-00117207": "issue", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00425-00117208-00117439": "uh that's at least part of the issue the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00426-00117440-00117527": "other is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00427-00117528-00117886": "abrupt return like using dot return or", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00428-00117888-00117966": "dot throw", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00429-00117967-00118334": "it um some stuff just there is a lot of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00430-00118335-00118495": "boilerplate to handle that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00431-00118496-00118678": "bi-directional push", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00432-00118679-00118847": "into an iterator and it may not make", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00433-00118848-00119083": "sense to reuse it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00434-00119083-00119407": "okay okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00435-00119408-00119734": "um may i ask if uh i i i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00436-00119735-00119927": "saw that observers are on the list of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00437-00119928-00120054": "proposals that uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00438-00120055-00120423": "that alex brought up is uh did observers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00439-00120424-00120734": "emerge as the duel of iterator and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00440-00120735-00121054": "that the generators are both so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00441-00121055-00121510": "uh observables were", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00442-00121511-00121871": "quite lively for a long time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00443-00121872-00122095": "and uh then they languished it was when", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00444-00122096-00122327": "i saw observables on the previous list", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00445-00122328-00122510": "that triggered that was what triggered", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00446-00122511-00122751": "the question are these on the agenda", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00447-00122752-00123054": "uh because if somebody was picking up", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00448-00123055-00123239": "observables and trying to advance them", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00449-00123240-00123414": "again that would be very very", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00450-00123415-00123743": "interesting the observables", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00451-00123744-00124631": "were", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00452-00124632-00124847": "were very well designed very well", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00453-00124848-00124975": "thought out", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00454-00124976-00125358": "uh and most of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00455-00125359-00125743": "the um most of the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00456-00125744-00125975": "the wind behind observables was taken", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00457-00125976-00126239": "out by asynchronous iterators", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00458-00126240-00126439": "uh even though they're not quite the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00459-00126440-00126686": "same thing uh there just was no longer", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00460-00126688-00126871": "energy to try to advance observables", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00461-00126872-00126966": "once we had this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00462-00126967-00127310": "asynchronous iterators", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00463-00127311-00127654": "okay well that answers the question", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00464-00127655-00127783": "well i think another thing about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00465-00127783-00127999": "observables is the the main", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00466-00128000-00128366": "person who was the the the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00467-00128367-00128751": "jaffar yeah jafar um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00468-00128752-00129086": "has kind of dropped off of the tc39", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00469-00129088-00129278": "radar i'm not quite sure what the story", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00470-00129279-00129502": "is there whether he was discouraged by", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00471-00129503-00129719": "not making progress or whether his work", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00472-00129720-00129958": "responsibilities took him elsewhere or i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00473-00129959-00130127": "don't know the story but in any case he", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00474-00130128-00130247": "was the main", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00475-00130248-00130558": "force behind that and and since he", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00476-00130559-00130751": "stopped participating it stopped moving", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00477-00130752-00131047": "yeah yeah i i i felt some of that force", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00478-00131048-00131247": "he called me on my phone once to talk", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00479-00131248-00131463": "about him", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00480-00131464-00131799": "but that was five years ago", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00481-00131800-00132063": "yeah yeah what chip said is exactly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00482-00132064-00132223": "right i think i'm actually listed as a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00483-00132224-00132343": "co-champion on it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00484-00132344-00132583": "and really helped jafar a lot in the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00485-00132584-00132695": "design but once", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00486-00132696-00132902": "he's no longer there there was you know", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00487-00132903-00133111": "no picking up the momentum from him", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00488-00133112-00133375": "okay yeah yeah i expect that to come", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00489-00133376-00133599": "back at some point but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00490-00133600-00133766": "it's good to have one thing to think", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00491-00133767-00133927": "about at a time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00492-00133928-00134287": "okay uh temporal update", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00493-00134288-00134711": "um so the uh the relevant issue", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00494-00134712-00134966": "here the i'm hoping that the only", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00495-00134967-00135111": "relevant issue here is the one that's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00496-00135112-00135407": "sort of already been negotiated", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00497-00135408-00135766": "which is that almost", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00498-00135767-00136078": "all of the temper temporal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00499-00136079-00136431": "is just computational it does not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00500-00136432-00136727": "involve any io does not involve", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00501-00136728-00136887": "knowledge of the current", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00502-00136888-00137111": "of the current time to avoid the date", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00503-00137112-00137311": "mistake", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00504-00137312-00137623": "but it's obviously still useful", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00505-00137624-00138023": "to have a privileged api", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00506-00138024-00138335": "uh for finding out what the current date", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00507-00138336-00138743": "is uh and it's useful to have one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00508-00138744-00139007": "given the the nature of temporal it was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00509-00139008-00139159": "apparently useful to have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00510-00139160-00139535": "one other than date.now uh so that it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00511-00139536-00139575": "could", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00512-00139576-00139751": "compose more easily with rest of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00513-00139752-00139887": "temporal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00514-00139888-00140207": "so if i recall correctly there's one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00515-00140208-00140463": "property on to that temporal itself is a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00516-00140464-00140631": "namespace object", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00517-00140632-00140878": "there's one property of it that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00518-00140879-00141071": "represents the privilege to know the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00519-00141072-00141231": "current time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00520-00141232-00141431": "and that all of the rest of it leads to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00521-00141432-00141583": "things that are only purely", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00522-00141584-00141727": "computational", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00523-00141728-00142095": "and and that means that um assess still", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00524-00142096-00142390": "needs to tame it like it tame's date", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00525-00142391-00142726": "but it's a clean split that enables us", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00526-00142727-00142919": "to cleanly tame it and leave all the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00527-00142920-00143111": "computational parts", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00528-00143112-00143287": "implicitly shared by everyone in the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00529-00143288-00143526": "realm", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00530-00143527-00143847": "uh there are there are two", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00531-00143848-00144190": "others that i can think of so there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00532-00144191-00144423": "the temporal dot now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00533-00144424-00144775": "which exposes the local information", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00534-00144776-00144871": "including", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00535-00144872-00145343": "what time is it and there are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00536-00145344-00145726": "date time and calendar", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00537-00145727-00145935": "lookups which also reach out into the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00538-00145936-00146119": "host although for information that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00539-00146120-00146271": "changes far less frequently", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00540-00146272-00146671": "than the date and time um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00541-00146672-00147031": "what information does it reach out for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00542-00147032-00147366": "the uh it reaches", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00543-00147367-00147831": "uh the easier one to understand is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00544-00147832-00148047": "uh time zone which reaches into the t", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00545-00148048-00148231": "local tz database", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00546-00148232-00148502": "to to determine whether uh whether", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00547-00148503-00148607": "whether it is known", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00548-00148608-00148951": "at all uh and if so what the particular", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00549-00148952-00149190": "transitions are of a time zone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00550-00149191-00149495": "uh and then similarly for calendar what", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00551-00149496-00149702": "uh what calendar is the system aware of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00552-00149703-00149878": "and you know what awareness does it have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00553-00149879-00150111": "of the particular details of that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00554-00150112-00150207": "calendar", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00555-00150208-00150439": "okay it's like gregorian versus jewelry", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00556-00150440-00150583": "that kind of calendar", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00557-00150584-00150902": "uh yeah so particularly we're looking at", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00558-00150903-00151454": "um hebrew and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00559-00151455-00151678": "few others that are escaping me at the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00560-00151679-00151783": "moment", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00561-00151784-00152087": "julian is still used quite a bit", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00562-00152088-00152375": "yeah so the um so that's the thing to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00563-00152376-00152478": "watch out for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00564-00152479-00152751": "especially when it comes to uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00565-00152752-00152951": "de-serializing strings", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00566-00152952-00153239": "which runs the risk of privileged access", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00567-00153240-00153454": "to those lookups", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00568-00153455-00153678": "in the in the current representation i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00569-00153679-00153878": "believe there is no such privileged", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00570-00153879-00153983": "access", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00571-00153984-00154295": "that um that the spec", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00572-00154296-00154543": "when uh even when deserializing a string", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00573-00154544-00154726": "or doing arithmetic or anything", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00574-00154727-00155087": "will cut will invoke the from method", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00575-00155088-00155359": "on the constructor of the calendar or", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00576-00155360-00155663": "the time zone or whatever so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00577-00155664-00155983": "uh that makes it i believe that makes it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00578-00155984-00156151": "tameable certainly you can monkey patch", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00579-00156152-00156263": "the from method", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00580-00156264-00156526": "uh and have those effects realized so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00581-00156527-00156678": "the the question", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00582-00156679-00157071": "the the the taming issue is um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00583-00157072-00157359": "uh not just whether we can replace it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00584-00157360-00157526": "with something tame", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00585-00157527-00157847": "uh but whether the thing that needs to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00586-00157848-00158023": "be tamed because it represents", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00587-00158024-00158326": "some kind of of privilege or iio", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00588-00158327-00158702": "is um is well", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00589-00158703-00159087": "separated from the stuff that's shared", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00590-00159088-00159271": "what i mean by that is that let's say", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00591-00159272-00159439": "you've got multiple compartments in a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00592-00159440-00159495": "realm", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00593-00159496-00159683": "and you want to give each of the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00594-00159684-00159871": "compartments let's say", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00595-00159872-00160102": "a different time zone as far as temporal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00596-00160103-00160271": "was concerned", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00597-00160272-00160559": "but share all of the prototypes and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00598-00160560-00160623": "methods", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00599-00160624-00160895": "that are all of the computational", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00600-00160896-00160975": "aspects", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00601-00160976-00161326": "of temporal uh you you don't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00602-00161327-00161559": "you that's what you would like to have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00603-00161560-00161663": "is that the only", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00604-00161664-00161983": "things that have to be um separated per", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00605-00161984-00162135": "compartment", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00606-00162136-00162335": "are these special privilege things and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00607-00162336-00162575": "everything that's just about computing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00608-00162576-00162959": "with those things is in shared objects", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00609-00162960-00163254": "right so i believe i believe that is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00610-00163255-00163551": "achievable", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00611-00163552-00163902": "if you controlled client access", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00612-00163903-00164487": "to temporal.now temporal.timezone.from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00613-00164488-00164783": "and temporal.calendar.from that you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00614-00164784-00164943": "should not need to override anything", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00615-00164944-00165038": "else", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00616-00165039-00165423": "oh okay um temporal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00617-00165424-00165702": "okay uh so the problem is if in order to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00618-00165703-00165871": "have a temporal dot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00619-00165872-00166238": "time zone is times on a constructor or", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00620-00166239-00166623": "is timezone a namespace", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00621-00166624-00166878": "it is mostly a constructor but from is a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00622-00166879-00167054": "static method on it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00623-00167055-00167287": "okay so so that so that's exactly the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00624-00167288-00167487": "kind of problem i was worried about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00625-00167488-00167783": "which is in order to have different time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00626-00167784-00167838": "zone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00627-00167839-00168151": "froms in different compartments", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00628-00168152-00168375": "you have to have different time zone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00629-00168376-00168551": "constructor objects in different", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00630-00168552-00168695": "compartments", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00631-00168696-00168911": "that's exactly the separation we were", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00632-00168912-00169063": "trying to avoid", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00633-00169064-00169254": "i mean the the intermingling we were", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00634-00169255-00169414": "trying to avoid", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00635-00169415-00169623": "i i want to be able to share the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00636-00169624-00169775": "constructor", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00637-00169776-00169983": "if the constructor doesn't have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00638-00169984-00170111": "privilege", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00639-00170112-00170359": "and have only the privilege be the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00640-00170360-00170495": "things that have to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00641-00170496-00170735": "uh separately populated on a per", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00642-00170736-00170878": "compartment basis", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00643-00170879-00171063": "to have each compartment have to have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00644-00171064-00171319": "its own time zone constructor", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00645-00171320-00171590": "when the time zone constructor mostly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00646-00171591-00171695": "leads", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00647-00171696-00172014": "only to powerless", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00648-00172015-00172343": "computational things is weird", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00649-00172344-00172711": "and it's especially weird because um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00650-00172712-00172999": "uh there's if everyone's sharing the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00651-00173000-00173038": "same", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00652-00173039-00173311": "time zone prototype that time zone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00653-00173312-00173407": "prototype", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00654-00173408-00173719": "has a dot constructor property that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00655-00173720-00174007": "points at some time zone constructor", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00656-00174008-00174214": "that one has to be shared", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00657-00174215-00174431": "and therefore that one can't have this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00658-00174432-00174854": "from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00659-00174855-00175151": "right if you wanted to solve it in the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00660-00175152-00175247": "current model", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00661-00175248-00175390": "you'd have to get really fancy with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00662-00175391-00175590": "proxies i think", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00663-00175591-00175911": "uh we're not going to do that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00664-00175912-00176071": "okay so it sounds like it's worth", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00665-00176072-00176214": "bringing that up uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00666-00176215-00176454": "right there's a pattern that we're using", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00667-00176455-00176599": "that we use for example on the date", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00668-00176600-00176878": "constructor so we understand the pattern", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00669-00176879-00176990": "to recover", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00670-00176991-00177254": "but this is exactly what the purpose of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00671-00177255-00177463": "the prior negotiation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00672-00177464-00177775": "with the temporal advocates was about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00673-00177776-00178063": "these security concerns is to make them", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00674-00178064-00178183": "separable", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00675-00178184-00178687": "okay and i think that as it went forward", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00676-00178688-00179007": "they must not have realized that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00677-00179008-00179283": "uh privileged access to current time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00678-00179284-00179410": "zone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00679-00179411-00179526": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00680-00179527-00179871": "it was among the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00681-00179872-00180214": "the issues to worry about so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00682-00180215-00180783": "from my understanding and having", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00683-00180784-00181159": "the separation concerns it seems like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00684-00181160-00181463": "uh this could be addressed by remo by", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00685-00181464-00181766": "taking off the from static methods from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00686-00181767-00181847": "the constructor", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00687-00181848-00182111": "and instead having siblings which you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00688-00182112-00182231": "know something like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00689-00182232-00182478": "instead of temporal.timezone.from it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00690-00182479-00182583": "would be like temporal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00691-00182584-00182911": "dot resolve time zone exactly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00692-00182912-00183190": "exactly that would be perfect it is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00693-00183191-00183335": "definitely worth bringing that up", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00694-00183336-00183671": "uh in the meeting and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00695-00183672-00183926": "given the simplicity of the change", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00696-00183927-00184135": "probably there's not a big issue with it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00697-00184136-00184238": "either", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00698-00184239-00184687": "okay good", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00699-00184688-00185007": "good okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00700-00185008-00185390": "um uh function implementation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00701-00185391-00185766": "hiding um uh i'm one of the reviewers on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00702-00185767-00185863": "that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00703-00185864-00186199": "uh and that was uh proposing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00704-00186200-00186511": "two different knobs that were not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00705-00186512-00186871": "orthogonal and it was proposing the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00706-00186872-00187119": "second knob called sensor the two knobs", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00707-00187120-00187199": "were called", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00708-00187200-00187511": "hide source and sensitive", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00709-00187512-00187943": "and sensitive was being proposed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00710-00187944-00188271": "to address security concerns uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00711-00188272-00188438": "and the security concerns it's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00712-00188439-00188726": "addressing are not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00713-00188727-00188959": "uh i you know are genuine security", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00714-00188960-00189135": "concerns they're not my security", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00715-00189136-00189238": "concerns", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00716-00189239-00189663": "so it was hard for me to reason about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00717-00189664-00189902": "the rationale for it as i understand it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00718-00189903-00189990": "what they're now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00719-00189991-00190311": "proposing is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00720-00190312-00190766": "only hide source so the difference is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00721-00190767-00191219": "that hide source means that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00722-00191220-00191423": "function.prototype.2string", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00723-00191424-00191863": "on a function whose source is hidden", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00724-00191864-00192047": "the idea would be a hide source", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00725-00192048-00192263": "directive like a used script", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00726-00192264-00192599": "use strict directive that can be on a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00727-00192600-00192647": "per", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00728-00192648-00192966": "function or per module basis uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00729-00192967-00193287": "if the function's source is hidden", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00730-00193288-00193590": "then a function.prototype.2string", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00731-00193591-00194023": "on it gives you the same kind of string", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00732-00194024-00194214": "that gives for a native function the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00733-00194215-00194390": "built-in function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00734-00194391-00194695": "which is a a something that sort of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00735-00194696-00194887": "looks like a function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00736-00194888-00195087": "except that it has this funny syntax", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00737-00195088-00195375": "inside the body that does not parse", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00738-00195376-00195654": "um it's this square bracket native", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00739-00195655-00195766": "something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00740-00195767-00196126": "um the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00741-00196127-00196366": "uh so that's all that's being proposed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00742-00196367-00196478": "and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00743-00196479-00196783": "i don't see any problem with that so uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00744-00196784-00197007": "i approved it on the review", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00745-00197008-00197375": "uh the other part was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00746-00197376-00197647": "hiding stack entries and there are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00747-00197648-00197711": "basically", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00748-00197712-00197926": "two approaches to it that were being", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00749-00197927-00198054": "discussed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00750-00198055-00198302": "there's the orthogonal form that alan", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00751-00198303-00198478": "worst brock and i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00752-00198479-00198847": "um prefer which is there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00753-00198848-00199078": "there's a similar directive called hide", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00754-00199079-00199207": "stack", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00755-00199208-00199614": "and if it's present then stack frames", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00756-00199615-00200031": "of this function do not appear in the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00757-00200032-00200343": "error stack proposal that is yet to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00758-00200344-00200783": "you know yet to be um uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00759-00200784-00201007": "uh moved i think it's still in stage one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00760-00201008-00201263": "so so that proposal has been languishing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00761-00201264-00201575": "um but the idea is that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00762-00201576-00201790": "whatever way there is of accessing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00763-00201791-00202183": "stacks those stack frames will be hidden", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00764-00202184-00202471": "the other one was a sensitive directive", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00765-00202472-00202559": "and the idea is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00766-00202560-00202887": "sensitive would both hide stack", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00767-00202888-00203254": "and hide source and the rationale there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00768-00203255-00203375": "is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00769-00203376-00203623": "this function just wants to disappear", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00770-00203624-00203935": "with regard to reflective examination", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00771-00203936-00204238": "uh because it's sensitive and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00772-00204239-00204414": "trying to pin down what the security", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00773-00204415-00204631": "concern is that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00774-00204632-00204958": "sensitive addresses uh is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00775-00204959-00205175": "uh not one that i've clearly understood", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00776-00205176-00205286": "i'm not saying it's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00777-00205287-00205471": "it's not a good concern i'm just saying", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00778-00205471-00205710": "that i didn't understand it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00779-00205711-00205919": "this feels like something that people", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00780-00205919-00206031": "are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00781-00206032-00206390": "uh this feels like more of a developer", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00782-00206391-00206558": "experience related feature than a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00783-00206559-00206710": "security feature", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00784-00206711-00206958": "so i i know that we were motivated to do", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00785-00206959-00207166": "something similar in queue to hide", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00786-00207167-00207638": "cue stack frames um in long stack traces", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00787-00207639-00207846": "but yeah just just to make them less", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00788-00207848-00207982": "confusing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00789-00207983-00208303": "right and likewise with membranes alex", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00790-00208304-00208471": "and i have talked about and alex talked", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00791-00208471-00208590": "to the committee", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00792-00208591-00208951": "about it would be nice to be able to uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00793-00208952-00209342": "have the membrane part membrane crossing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00794-00209344-00209414": "part of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00795-00209415-00209598": "computation to be able to have that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00796-00209600-00209846": "disappear from stack frames", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00797-00209848-00210231": "and neither of these uses uh imply", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00798-00210232-00210591": "a desire to hide sources of those same", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00799-00210592-00210687": "functions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00800-00210688-00210910": "so that so the developer experience", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00801-00210911-00211039": "argues for the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00802-00211040-00211271": "orthogonal hide source and height stack", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00803-00211271-00211391": "in any case", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00804-00211392-00211615": "since only height source is being", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00805-00211616-00211782": "proposed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00806-00211783-00212023": "in this proposal and any concern with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00807-00212023-00212175": "stack is to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00808-00212176-00212463": "postponed to a later proposal i think", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00809-00212464-00212655": "that's fine and i think the concerns", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00810-00212656-00212775": "with the stack", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00811-00212776-00213023": "should in fact be merged into the error", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00812-00213023-00213431": "stack proposal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00813-00213432-00213758": "the chain which i do hope i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00814-00213759-00214110": "uh to see advancement uh as i proceed to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00815-00214111-00214206": "shim it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00816-00214207-00214751": "uh as part of the session", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00817-00214752-00215063": "okay um realms", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00818-00215064-00215310": "uh i think we all know what's up what's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00819-00215311-00215431": "up there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00820-00215432-00215798": "um uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00821-00215800-00216255": "number format i have no idea", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00822-00216256-00216623": "it's just a way of uh joining numbers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00823-00216623-00216815": "uh there are different separators in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00824-00216816-00217055": "different locales", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00825-00217056-00217287": "this is really the key point uh there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00826-00217288-00217382": "a few things about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00827-00217383-00217671": "having long or short forms similar to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00828-00217671-00217719": "how", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00829-00217719-00218094": "days of the week can be abbreviated", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00830-00218096-00218342": "um there's nothing i i don't think", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00831-00218344-00218487": "there's anything we", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00832-00218488-00218751": "actually are concerned about okay if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00833-00218752-00218823": "there were", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00834-00218823-00219191": "anything it would be um it would pertain", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00835-00219192-00219327": "similarly to temporal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00836-00219328-00219615": "in order to find out what the the host", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00837-00219616-00219679": "locale", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00838-00219680-00219991": "is right um uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00839-00219992-00220287": "i don't yes i think it defaults does it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00840-00220288-00220455": "i think you always need to provide it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00841-00220456-00220558": "something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00842-00220559-00220815": "it it has the same problem as uh as", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00843-00220816-00220887": "every other", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00844-00220888-00221079": "formatter in intel there's nothing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00845-00221080-00221255": "specific to this one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00846-00221256-00221551": "right the the intel with regard to time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00847-00221552-00221719": "with regard to time zone and such", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00848-00221719-00222055": "things uh intel is hopeless uh we've", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00849-00222056-00222367": "kind of given up with regard to intel", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00850-00222367-00222567": "uh but just hoping to avoid those", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00851-00222567-00223087": "mistakes with temporal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00852-00223088-00223623": "and the um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00853-00223623-00223951": "intel itself is not on the cess white", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00854-00223952-00224103": "list", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00855-00224104-00224423": "for that reason", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00856-00224423-00224606": "it's unfortunate if we if we'd", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00857-00224607-00224742": "understood this going in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00858-00224744-00224958": "we could have we could have designed an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00859-00224959-00225119": "intel that could be on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00860-00225119-00225482": "the cess white list but it was just too", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00861-00225483-00225727": "helpless", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00862-00225728-00225982": "okay uh ergonomic brand checks uh for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00863-00225983-00226182": "private fields i really like this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00864-00226183-00226319": "uh i don't think there's any security", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00865-00226319-00226534": "significance here basically", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00866-00226535-00226934": "um uh if you do uh food", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00867-00226935-00227134": "in the in the private fields proposal if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00868-00227135-00227294": "you do uh foo", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00869-00227296-00227598": "uh doc sharp uh bar", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00870-00227600-00227855": "to access the bar private field on food", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00871-00227856-00228046": "and food doesn't have a bar private", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00872-00228048-00228239": "field it throws", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00873-00228240-00228503": "uh so this one is basically saying that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00874-00228504-00228575": "um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00875-00228576-00228815": "since you can already detect it to ask", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00876-00228816-00228951": "the question", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00877-00228952-00229310": "um uh and since private fields", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00878-00229311-00229694": "are syntactically sort of cleaned of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00879-00229696-00229951": "following some kind of analogy with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00880-00229952-00230119": "properties", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00881-00230119-00230455": "provide a syntax involving in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00882-00230456-00230655": "for being able to ask the bullying", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00883-00230656-00230791": "question", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00884-00230792-00231094": "about whether this object has this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00885-00231096-00231351": "private field which enables you to just", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00886-00231352-00231567": "do an if rather than a try catch so i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00887-00231567-00231687": "think that's great i don't think there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00888-00231688-00231919": "any security significance", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00889-00231919-00232158": "um before we move on i just wanna i just", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00890-00232159-00232327": "noticed something here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00891-00232328-00232687": "um i noticed the syntax here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00892-00232688-00232982": "hash brand hash method etc is very", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00893-00232983-00233167": "similar to the syntax being proposed for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00894-00233167-00233455": "records and tuples", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00895-00233456-00233815": "yes so in records and tuples calls", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00896-00233816-00234006": "they've clarified their reasoning for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00897-00234007-00234246": "wanting to reuse it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00898-00234248-00234551": "they're trying to mark things which", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00899-00234552-00234815": "are syntactic features attempting to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00900-00234816-00234934": "have some", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00901-00234935-00235215": "model of integrity with the hashes they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00902-00235216-00235263": "view", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00903-00235264-00235510": "private fields as having a model for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00904-00235511-00235606": "integrity", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00905-00235607-00235910": "about them they want to preserve that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00906-00235911-00236327": "for records and tuples particularly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00907-00236328-00236646": "for tuples they want to have integrity", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00908-00236648-00237191": "around index access numeric index access", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00909-00237192-00237431": "and for records they want it around", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00910-00237432-00237694": "string based keys", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00911-00237696-00237982": "okay i apologize i just realized records", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00912-00237983-00238063": "start with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00913-00238064-00238446": "uh curly brace and tuples", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00914-00238448-00238734": "with um square brackets so there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00915-00238735-00238855": "there's no conflict there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00916-00238856-00239087": "i apologize right no no it was still a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00917-00239088-00239206": "good question because there's no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00918-00239207-00239375": "syntactic conflict", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00919-00239376-00239710": "but it's still occupying similar mind", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00920-00239711-00239934": "space so the fact that there's one story", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00921-00239935-00240071": "that covers both", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00922-00240071-00240294": "was really important because otherwise", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00923-00240296-00240391": "it's just", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00924-00240392-00240655": "two unrelated uses of the same glyph", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00925-00240656-00240742": "which would be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00926-00240744-00241463": "unpleasant not fatal but unpleasant", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00927-00241464-00241855": "okay um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00928-00241856-00242198": "so let's see", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00929-00242200-00242487": "okay that was a duration format i assume", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00930-00242488-00242534": "that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00931-00242535-00242846": "that is does that have any um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00932-00242848-00243079": "uh any intel issue that we didn't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00933-00243080-00243230": "already that's not like what we already", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00934-00243231-00243423": "talked about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00935-00243423-00243879": "it's more of the same", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00936-00243880-00244239": "okay good uh records and tuples um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00937-00244240-00244663": "uh there's uh there's a controversy that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00938-00244664-00244751": "has really", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00939-00244752-00245071": "blown up on the issue thread uh and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00940-00245071-00245342": "it well it doesn't look like there's any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00941-00245344-00245567": "signs that it will settle soon", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00942-00245567-00245734": "uh so i'm sure it'll still be a live", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00943-00245735-00245934": "controversy at the meeting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00944-00245935-00246071": "note that by the way that they're not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00945-00246071-00246239": "proposing stage advancement just an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00946-00246240-00246358": "update", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00947-00246359-00246679": "okay uh nevertheless uh i'm sure we will", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00948-00246680-00246751": "take", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00949-00246752-00247046": "uh as much time as uh it takes to fill a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00950-00247048-00247151": "time box", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00951-00247152-00247294": "with this controversy because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00952-00247296-00247534": "everybody's gonna be passionate about it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00953-00247535-00247782": "including me so we've had two phone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00954-00247783-00247855": "calls", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00955-00247856-00248071": "for i think a total of two and a half", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00956-00248071-00248303": "hours over the last two weeks on it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00957-00248304-00248646": "um so far the the real", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00958-00248648-00248951": "crux of the matter comes down to uh the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00959-00248952-00249063": "ability to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00960-00249064-00249455": "do a brand check on records", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00961-00249456-00249639": "um i don't think tuples actually have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00962-00249640-00249855": "much controversy on them", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00963-00249856-00250182": "um oh uh uh so i don't know what the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00964-00250183-00250430": "brand check controversy is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00965-00250431-00250742": "okay um so the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00966-00250744-00251015": "origin of the controversy comes down to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00967-00251016-00251055": "for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00968-00251056-00251415": "a record record.prototype needs to have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00969-00251416-00251527": "a value", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00970-00251528-00251839": "should that value be an object", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00971-00251840-00252175": "null or something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00972-00252176-00252479": "um so we can't use", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00973-00252480-00252806": "instance of for its instance of it's not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00974-00252807-00253110": "super reliable uh to determine", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00975-00253111-00253446": "if something a box form of a record", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00976-00253448-00253758": "is a record um so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00977-00253759-00254110": "if we box a record um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00978-00254111-00254271": "there are various ways to do this it's a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00979-00254271-00254439": "primitive you can do this with any other", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00980-00254440-00254534": "kind of primitive", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00981-00254535-00254727": "every single other kind of primitive has", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00982-00254728-00254942": "a way of detecting that it is a boxed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00983-00254944-00255087": "primitive", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00984-00255088-00255382": "um without the ability to do a brand", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00985-00255383-00255510": "check on it because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00986-00255511-00255887": "let's say the box itself has a null", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00987-00255888-00256023": "prototype", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00988-00256023-00256327": "um you get into awkward situations that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00989-00256328-00256510": "you don't know how to do", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00990-00256511-00256751": "so one of the things on the calls was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00991-00256752-00256998": "potentially introducing a record dot", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00992-00257000-00257327": "is static method um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00993-00257328-00257558": "to determine if something is a boxed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00994-00257559-00257742": "record", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00995-00257744-00258142": "well wow that's awful", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00996-00258144-00258510": "okay um and um wow", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00997-00258511-00258663": "this is a much more substantial", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00998-00258664-00258798": "controversy than the one i've been", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-00999-00258800-00258959": "obsessing on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01000-00258960-00259082": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01001-00259083-00259279": "um the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01002-00259280-00259623": "the other controversy is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01003-00259623-00260030": "uh what the equality semantics are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01004-00260031-00260391": "on records and tuples the problem is the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01005-00260392-00260551": "javascript", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01006-00260552-00260903": "has so many different", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01007-00260904-00261094": "even among the well-behaved equalities", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01008-00261096-00261430": "i.e everything other than double equals", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01009-00261431-00261742": "they take different stances with regard", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01010-00261744-00261887": "to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01011-00261888-00262230": "minus zero and that so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01012-00262231-00262582": "uh the question is uh when you compare", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01013-00262583-00262847": "records and tuples that somewhere deep", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01014-00262848-00262927": "within them", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01015-00262928-00263255": "might be a minus zero or a nand uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01016-00263256-00263447": "how should the record of the tuples", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01017-00263448-00263567": "compare", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01018-00263568-00263871": "um and uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01019-00263872-00264303": "this one's all over the place", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01020-00264304-00264503": "i'd agree that is probably the bigger", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01021-00264504-00264719": "controversy the ability to detect", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01022-00264720-00265079": "if something is box tuple uh is more", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01023-00265080-00265230": "something that we just need to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01024-00265231-00265415": "mindful of if we're caring about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01025-00265416-00265551": "membranes", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01026-00265552-00265999": "um i know a rave was in a semi-semi", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01027-00266000-00266310": "similar situation um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01028-00266311-00266519": "but i i don't think this is new", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01029-00266520-00266615": "territory", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01030-00266616-00267055": "at least for the brand check", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01031-00267056-00267310": "okay definitely something for this group", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01032-00267311-00267615": "to pay attention to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01033-00267616-00267847": "uh do expressions is this there there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01034-00267848-00267999": "was a very old proposal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01035-00268000-00268119": "you didn't say what the other", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01036-00268120-00268367": "controversy was well it was uh it was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01037-00268368-00268463": "the equality", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01038-00268464-00268734": "um it was a brand check and equality", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01039-00268735-00268934": "were the two controversies", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01040-00268935-00269206": "yeah equality of equality around minus", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01041-00269207-00269367": "zero and man", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01042-00269368-00269671": "oh okay never mind yeah um the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01043-00269672-00269919": "the the problems with minus zero and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01044-00269920-00270079": "then and the need to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01045-00270080-00270399": "to repeatedly uh argue about them will", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01046-00270400-00271255": "survive humanity", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01047-00271256-00271567": "yeah i i i think it's the joker of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01048-00271568-00271727": "international standards", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01049-00271728-00271999": "right yeah the in the end it'll be keith", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01050-00272000-00272182": "richards and a cockroach arguing about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01051-00272183-00272399": "it you can see my minus zero and nan", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01052-00272400-00272655": "yeah maybe you might go past the heat", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01053-00272656-00273087": "death of the universe", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01054-00273088-00273471": "yeah uh so okay so do expressions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01055-00273472-00273695": "uh there was an old do expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01056-00273696-00273815": "proposal that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01057-00273816-00274071": "seemed clean except for one thing which", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01058-00274072-00274151": "i'm", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01059-00274152-00274382": "which at the time uh i didn't think to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01060-00274383-00274495": "argue about but if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01061-00274496-00274647": "they're reviving it i want to argue", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01062-00274648-00274887": "about it um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01063-00274888-00275271": "the idea with do expressions is that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01064-00275272-00275551": "right now it's very awkward to say", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01065-00275552-00275758": "statementy things", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01066-00275759-00276071": "like a switch statement in an expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01067-00276072-00276199": "context", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01068-00276200-00276495": "uh the only way you can do that is with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01069-00276496-00276606": "an iffy", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01070-00276607-00276791": "with a immediately invoked function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01071-00276792-00277023": "expression which with arrow functions is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01072-00277024-00277127": "much", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01073-00277128-00277406": "less unpleasant than it used to be but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01074-00277407-00277463": "it's still", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01075-00277464-00277799": "quite unpleasant compared to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01076-00277800-00278103": "if you just had this thing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01077-00278104-00278439": "for writing statements in expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01078-00278440-00278606": "context", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01079-00278607-00278943": "the problem", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01080-00278944-00279167": "that i'm now going to flag that i did", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01081-00279168-00279391": "not flag at the time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01082-00279392-00279751": "was uh if what's going on in a do", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01083-00279752-00279823": "expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01084-00279824-00280158": "is just a statement body is where all", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01085-00280159-00280206": "the code", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01086-00280207-00280487": "is where does the value of the due", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01087-00280488-00280558": "expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01088-00280559-00280903": "come from and the answer", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01089-00280904-00281327": "last time was use the completion value", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01090-00281328-00281510": "rules", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01091-00281511-00281751": "and uh the completion value rules right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01092-00281752-00281830": "now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01093-00281831-00282143": "are operational only for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01094-00282144-00282487": "eval and they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01095-00282488-00282830": "uh they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01096-00282831-00283167": "and in my experience uh there's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01097-00283168-00283479": "two uses of the vowel in practice", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01098-00283480-00283751": "then there's evaluating statements for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01099-00283752-00283871": "effect", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01100-00283872-00284199": "or there's evaluating one expressions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01101-00284200-00284567": "statement for value where realistically", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01102-00284568-00284647": "you think of it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01103-00284648-00285054": "as evaluating an expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01104-00285055-00285399": "the result is that people", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01105-00285400-00285719": "do not often encounter the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01106-00285720-00286054": "bizarre rules for completion value", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01107-00286055-00286303": "the rules are bizarre they will surprise", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01108-00286304-00286391": "people", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01109-00286392-00286639": "i do not want to put those rules in a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01110-00286640-00286799": "place where a normal programmer will", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01111-00286800-00286958": "encounter", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01112-00286959-00287287": "um so um that is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01113-00287288-00287534": "still the case but there is a different", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01114-00287535-00287743": "spin on it this time around", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01115-00287744-00288063": "um okay or a lot of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01116-00288064-00288399": "the completion values there is somewhat", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01117-00288400-00288558": "general agreement that there are a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01118-00288559-00288710": "variety of ways you can produce a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01119-00288711-00288879": "completion value which is for the most", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01120-00288880-00289151": "part surprising", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01121-00289152-00289495": "but the syntax", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01122-00289496-00289758": "that produces surprising values is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01123-00289759-00289919": "actually somewhat limited", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01124-00289920-00290271": "and so the idea is you explicitly error", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01125-00290272-00290687": "if a if the last statement", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01126-00290688-00291023": "of a do expression is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01127-00291024-00291406": "a essentially surprising syntax so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01128-00291407-00291471": "things like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01129-00291472-00291830": "variable declaration loops", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01130-00291831-00292175": "and that would uh be an error to have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01131-00292176-00292551": "in the tail position of a do expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01132-00292552-00293358": "that probably solves my problem", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01133-00293359-00293510": "obviously we need to look at what the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01134-00293511-00293671": "specific rules are but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01135-00293672-00294006": "but certainly something uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01136-00294007-00294215": "something that followed those rules to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01137-00294216-00294367": "the point that there was no longer a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01138-00294368-00294527": "nasty surprise", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01139-00294528-00294903": "i would find fine um so this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01140-00294904-00295071": "does have some precedent in other", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01141-00295072-00295230": "languages uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01142-00295231-00295447": "which don't use the idea of completion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01143-00295448-00295671": "values but they use the idea of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01144-00295672-00295991": "lack of terminator as lack of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01145-00295992-00296351": "terminator sigil as a completion point", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01146-00296352-00296823": "within a source text body", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01147-00296824-00297095": "one thing that was surprising was there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01148-00297096-00297127": "is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01149-00297128-00297471": "a need to do a what looks like web", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01150-00297472-00297687": "compatible change to the spec", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01151-00297688-00298054": "in 2015 there was a accidental change", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01152-00298055-00298175": "during a refactoring to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01153-00298176-00298439": "specification about completion values", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01154-00298440-00298799": "and the break keyword uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01155-00298800-00299223": "and also to if else expressions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01156-00299224-00299606": "um and that just needs to be cleared up", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01157-00299607-00299943": "because right now that is surprising and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01158-00299944-00300158": "i think everybody who's seen the code is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01159-00300159-00300799": "surprised by it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01160-00300800-00301071": "okay well very good i'm expecting that i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01161-00301072-00301327": "will end up happy on that one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01162-00301328-00301639": "um module attributes we've talked about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01163-00301640-00301903": "that in a previous one of these sessions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01164-00301904-00302230": "that's going to be a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01165-00302231-00302534": "pain and annoyance but only i think i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01166-00302535-00302743": "think only a pain and an annoyance i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01167-00302744-00302871": "don't think there's a fundamental", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01168-00302872-00302967": "problem here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01169-00302968-00303151": "they just yet more bookkeeping that has", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01170-00303152-00303351": "to be threaded through", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01171-00303352-00303639": "all of the module specifier handling", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01172-00303640-00303743": "logic", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01173-00303744-00303958": "and it's not a place where it's pleasant", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01174-00303959-00304103": "to thread a whole bunch of new", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01175-00304104-00304215": "information through", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01176-00304216-00304527": "uh chris is that about your assessment", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01177-00304528-00304830": "yeah yeah it's it's doable", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01178-00304831-00305282": "it would complicate the compartments api", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01179-00305283-00305471": "um it's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01180-00305472-00305687": "dubious it's dubious in my opinion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01181-00305688-00305863": "whether it's useful", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01182-00305864-00306175": "um i think that the i think that the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01183-00306176-00306343": "security concerns that were", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01184-00306344-00306654": "cited that motivated the change", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01185-00306655-00306847": "motivated this proposal could be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01186-00306848-00307095": "addressed other ways", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01187-00307096-00307439": "yeah the the um the idea that it's the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01188-00307440-00307599": "consumer", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01189-00307600-00307782": "the consuming code that gets to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01190-00307783-00307958": "determine the type", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01191-00307959-00308319": "of the data being consumed seems exactly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01192-00308320-00308495": "backward from the security point of view", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01193-00308496-00308734": "uh no it's an assertion check that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01194-00308735-00308854": "they're asking for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01195-00308855-00309391": "it is not a change of evaluation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01196-00309392-00309558": "i gotta raise a small point here that i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01197-00309559-00309719": "just noticed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01198-00309720-00310023": "um i'm looking at the module", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01199-00310024-00310206": "attributes proposal under the import", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01200-00310207-00310399": "statement section", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01201-00310400-00310699": "um they have the line import json from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01202-00310700-00310999": "food.json with type json", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01203-00311000-00311271": "i'm worried about the possibility of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01204-00311272-00311334": "some", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01205-00311335-00311639": "turkey putting in a semicolon", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01206-00311640-00311967": "before the width line", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01207-00311968-00312247": "before the keyword with because as you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01208-00312248-00312303": "recall", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01209-00312304-00312654": "with that actually has some meaning in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01210-00312655-00313039": "non-strict javascript yeah but there are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01211-00313040-00313254": "there is no no such thing as non-strict", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01212-00313255-00313415": "module", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01213-00313416-00313719": "right so the the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01214-00313720-00314047": "so with the import expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01215-00314048-00314463": "uh um you might i i think you're right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01216-00314464-00314599": "i'm sorry", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01217-00314600-00314895": "yeah so um and i think alex would you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01218-00314896-00315006": "agree that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01219-00315007-00315182": "that there is a width that appears in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01220-00315183-00315327": "the import expression", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01221-00315328-00315510": "in this proposal but it's not one that's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01222-00315511-00315687": "subject to the confusion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01223-00315688-00315879": "because that's just you know normal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01224-00315880-00316103": "expression syntax", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01225-00316104-00316382": "right i'm i go so far back that i still", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01226-00316383-00316582": "think in sloppy mode a lot of the time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01227-00316583-00316727": "so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01228-00316728-00316999": "yeah uh bradley what's your take on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01229-00317000-00317110": "module attributes", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01230-00317111-00317295": "is this something that you'd like to see", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01231-00317296-00317471": "land in its current form", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01232-00317472-00317671": "or make progress basically from its", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01233-00317672-00317839": "current form i have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01234-00317840-00318054": "no personal desire to ever use this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01235-00318055-00318151": "thing uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01236-00318152-00318503": "but i don't see it harming me in any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01237-00318504-00318958": "particularly strong fashion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01238-00318959-00319182": "so let me double check that i understood", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01239-00319183-00319319": "what you said about it being an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01240-00319320-00319503": "assertion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01241-00319504-00319827": "it has no role in determining the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01242-00319828-00319999": "interpretation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01243-00320000-00320375": "of the content that was fetched", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01244-00320376-00320703": "it just okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01245-00320704-00321030": "that is a huge relief it's a very", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01246-00321031-00321343": "different take than the one that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01247-00321344-00321743": "we last conversed about though i think", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01248-00321744-00322071": "that was a very argumentative fight", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01249-00322072-00322382": "but yes um there are two categories", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01250-00322383-00322695": "of module attributes being discussed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01251-00322696-00322991": "one are going to be temporarily called", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01252-00322992-00323103": "the evaluators", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01253-00323104-00323399": "and one is the assertions they are only", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01254-00323400-00323791": "interested in the assertions right now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01255-00323792-00324023": "so you could for example have an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01256-00324024-00324254": "integrity check that does a shaw", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01257-00324255-00324591": "uh check against the body or things like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01258-00324592-00324823": "that okay they are only proposing type", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01259-00324824-00325134": "and only type with a value of json", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01260-00325135-00325671": "to the spec", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01261-00325672-00325847": "and that that's the pardon that's the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01262-00325848-00326087": "sole evaluator", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01263-00326088-00326447": "semantics are no evaluator semantics", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01264-00326448-00326743": "being purple okay so the same type json", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01265-00326744-00326871": "is to say", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01266-00326872-00327191": "that uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01267-00327192-00327415": "that the module loader presumably the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01268-00327416-00327534": "compartment", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01269-00327535-00327878": "will need to be able to compare", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01270-00327879-00328239": "um what the module advertises its type", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01271-00328240-00328319": "to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01272-00328320-00328806": "to the type that they intend it to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01273-00328807-00329167": "correct so in the web context", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01274-00329168-00329471": "this requires", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01275-00329472-00329775": "the provider of the content", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01276-00329776-00330175": "to properly identify the content", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01277-00330176-00330527": "presumably with a mime header", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01278-00330528-00330919": "or um well are we assuming", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01279-00330920-00331278": "that json contact content", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01280-00331279-00331623": "is served with the proper mind headers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01281-00331624-00331863": "yes that is the assumption for the web", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01282-00331864-00331999": "context i do not know", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01283-00332000-00332254": "if they intend to send an accept header", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01284-00332255-00332495": "though", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01285-00332496-00332799": "so the oh i see that's fascinating", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01286-00332800-00333087": "yeah yeah yeah uh because yeah okay so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01287-00333088-00333215": "what what this implies for the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01288-00333216-00333327": "compartment api", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01289-00333328-00333615": "if it were to go forward is that for the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01290-00333616-00333791": "purposes of assertions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01291-00333792-00334039": "um the import hook would need to see", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01292-00334040-00334103": "what those", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01293-00334104-00334591": "assertions are and it would need to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01294-00334592-00334830": "it might not need to do anything special", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01295-00334831-00334951": "um actually i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01296-00334952-00335134": "my initial thought was that the module", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01297-00335135-00335327": "static record might need to carry", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01298-00335328-00335575": "an arbitrary bag of things but it sounds", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01299-00335576-00335799": "to me like the import hook would need to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01300-00335800-00336247": "uh to receive the the bag of asserted uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01301-00336248-00336447": "things and then it would be up to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01302-00336448-00336687": "import hook to implement the assertion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01303-00336688-00336910": "uh and map the type for example to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01304-00336911-00337054": "corresponding mime type", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01305-00337055-00337327": "possibly possibly translate that to an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01306-00337328-00337463": "accept header", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01307-00337464-00337743": "and then possibly also verify that the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01308-00337744-00337799": "the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01309-00337800-00337982": "response content type matches the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01310-00337983-00338143": "assertion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01311-00338144-00338319": "yes the important part about the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01312-00338320-00338519": "assertions are they are not part of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01313-00338520-00338871": "any cash key algorithm that is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01314-00338872-00339095": "evaluators are being punted on they may", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01315-00339096-00339575": "be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01316-00339576-00339887": "okay um that is not what i understood it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01317-00339888-00339943": "to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01318-00339944-00340310": "um and that is that is less", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01319-00340311-00340567": "problematic than what i assume i i still", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01320-00340568-00340727": "kind of think that it's gross because i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01321-00340728-00340854": "think people are going to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01322-00340855-00341167": "leap to the same assumption i did um and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01323-00341168-00341343": "that this will lead to a proliferation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01324-00341344-00341510": "of possibly compliance that is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01325-00341511-00341730": "the majority of the issue tracker from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01326-00341731-00341999": "non-tc39 members", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01327-00342000-00342375": "so everybody is everybody on the issue", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01328-00342376-00342510": "tracker who is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01329-00342511-00342823": "casually glancing seems to assume it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01330-00342824-00343143": "alters the uh response", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01331-00343144-00343447": "interpretation i would agree yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01332-00343448-00344167": "that is yeah okay common okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01333-00344168-00344703": "okay next one is yours", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01334-00344704-00345054": "sure so apparently uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01335-00345055-00345295": "module records in the javascript spec", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01336-00345296-00345430": "don't actually have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01337-00345431-00345927": "a limit on the exported names", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01338-00345928-00346310": "they can be any string", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01339-00346311-00346582": "they can be invalid javascript strings", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01340-00346583-00346806": "fun", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01341-00346807-00347191": "but wasm modules in particular", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01342-00347192-00347463": "and some of the things in wazom modules", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01343-00347464-00347495": "are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01344-00347496-00347910": "exporting non-identifier name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01345-00347911-00348271": "bindings which are visible in javascript", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01346-00348272-00348647": "they are visible via export star from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01347-00348648-00348927": "or if you import a wasm module namespace", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01348-00348928-00349078": "object", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01349-00349079-00349319": "so this is just saying basically we", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01350-00349320-00349591": "should have some syntax that we can", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01351-00349592-00349863": "do all the other operations that we can", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01352-00349864-00350082": "do with identifier names with arbitrary", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01353-00350083-00350391": "strings", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01354-00350392-00350654": "is this adding new syntax yes", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01355-00350655-00350751": "unfortunately", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01356-00350752-00351015": "whereas right now you could import curly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01357-00351016-00351071": "brace", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01358-00351072-00351478": "foo from bar", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01359-00351479-00351782": "that foo must be an identifier name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01360-00351783-00352134": "um this is adding a syntax where", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01361-00352135-00352351": "you basically can put a string literal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01362-00352352-00352567": "in the place of the identifier name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01363-00352568-00352719": "being imported", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01364-00352720-00353054": "and uh import under that um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01365-00353055-00353495": "this also uncovered something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01366-00353496-00353799": "does does it follow the general", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01367-00353800-00354191": "um rules elsewhere in the language for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01368-00354192-00354503": "uh uh quoted versus unquoted property", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01369-00354504-00354551": "names", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01370-00354552-00355182": "like in object literals", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01371-00355183-00355503": "i believe so yes okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01372-00355504-00355671": "i am not actually proposing the exact", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01373-00355672-00356015": "syntax i'm i'm stage zero", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01374-00356016-00356303": "but that is michael obviously the the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01375-00356304-00356399": "these", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01376-00356400-00356734": "these funny strings cannot also name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01377-00356735-00357071": "variables so you can't import", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01378-00357072-00357358": "uh you know blah blah blah uh from but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01379-00357359-00357519": "you can import blah blah blah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01380-00357520-00357854": "as variable name is that correct correct", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01381-00357855-00358175": "and you can already export in pure", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01382-00358176-00358343": "javascript non-identifiers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01383-00358344-00358782": "you can export as function which is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01384-00358783-00359087": "weird", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01385-00359088-00359327": "you can rename your identifiers to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01386-00359328-00359423": "things that are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01387-00359424-00359734": "invalid binding identifiers such as the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01388-00359735-00359882": "function", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01389-00359883-00360191": "token okay currently", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01390-00360192-00360463": "currently in uh in javascript the export", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01391-00360464-00360567": "names", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01392-00360568-00360727": "must match the identifier name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01393-00360728-00360991": "production right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01394-00360992-00361278": "uh identifier name yes not identified so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01395-00361279-00361375": "like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01396-00361376-00361571": "right so you can you can export", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01397-00361572-00361727": "non-identifier", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01398-00361728-00361934": "identifier names but you can't export", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01399-00361935-00362143": "like punctuation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01400-00362144-00362334": "uh correct which is the same rules for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01401-00362335-00362519": "object literals", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01402-00362520-00362854": "right but is not that's not the rules", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01403-00362855-00362919": "for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01404-00362920-00363143": "arbitrary modules just for the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01405-00363144-00363454": "ecmascript ones", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01406-00363455-00363710": "correct non-ecmascript modules can have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01407-00363711-00363895": "any string", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01408-00363896-00364254": "okay okay well good", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01409-00364255-00364734": "uh next is intel enumeration is that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01410-00364735-00364871": "just another intel", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01411-00364872-00365230": "same story", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01412-00365231-00365566": "oh we're now at stage zeros um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01413-00365567-00366367": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01414-00366368-00366567": "so i'm just reading the list to myself", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01415-00366568-00366695": "i'll just read it out loud", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01416-00366696-00367006": "async context the path", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01417-00367007-00367191": "properties and random literals okay that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01418-00367192-00367447": "was actually interesting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01419-00367448-00367703": "security significant um intel number", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01420-00367704-00367791": "format", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01421-00367792-00368119": "um from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01422-00368120-00368439": "dot dot dot import bradley uh that's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01423-00368440-00368575": "just a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01424-00368576-00368919": "secondary grammar so instead of import", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01425-00368920-00369191": "being the first word from would be the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01426-00369192-00369303": "first word and i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01427-00369304-00369630": "import this has to deal with a variety", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01428-00369631-00369775": "of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01429-00369776-00370015": "basically user experience issues it's no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01430-00370016-00370247": "new semantics", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01431-00370248-00370551": "better completion in editors i did not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01432-00370552-00370695": "understand what is the syntax being", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01433-00370696-00370815": "proposed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01434-00370816-00371134": "from foo import", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01435-00371135-00371447": "bar instead of import", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01436-00371448-00371830": "bar from foo and the reason for this is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01437-00371831-00372182": "better inflation yeah so it actually", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01438-00372183-00372454": "stabilizes the location of tokens", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01439-00372455-00372727": "it gives you better editor completion it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01440-00372728-00372847": "matches", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01441-00372848-00373191": "many more languages um but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01442-00373192-00373510": "there there are preliminary like shots", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01443-00373511-00373630": "fired and that's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01444-00373631-00373927": "probably never gonna go through okay why", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01445-00373928-00374134": "didn't we do that in the first place", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01446-00374135-00374478": "uh that is lost to time i have found out", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01447-00374479-00374847": "in 2009 that was the ordering", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01448-00374848-00375102": "that was being looked at and then at", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01449-00375103-00375206": "some point", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01450-00375207-00375487": "around 2011 it started with import as", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01451-00375488-00375615": "the first keyword and it was never", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01452-00375616-00375734": "looked at again", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01453-00375735-00376015": "uh we have some guesswork feedback of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01454-00376016-00376158": "people participating at the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01455-00376159-00376406": "time it was to simplify the grammar to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01456-00376407-00376495": "not use a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01457-00376496-00377478": "no line terminator here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01458-00377479-00377887": "yeah of course all right okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01459-00377888-00378167": "um yeah i can see how that would have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01460-00378168-00378278": "been how we got there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01461-00378279-00378767": "okay uh generic comparison", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01462-00378768-00379054": "uh the spaceship operator and other uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01463-00379055-00379182": "languages exists", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01464-00379183-00379719": "it is essentially the tie fighter", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01465-00379720-00379927": "but the proposal isn't to add the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01466-00379928-00380119": "spaceship operator directly although", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01467-00380120-00380295": "it's tied to it it is to add", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01468-00380296-00380608": "a method to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01469-00380609-00380934": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01470-00380935-00381182": "arrays that serves the same purpose as", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01471-00381183-00381406": "the spaceship operator", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01472-00381407-00381567": "what is the spaceship operator i don't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01473-00381568-00381727": "believe i've heard this term before it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01474-00381728-00381815": "is a three-way", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01475-00381816-00382399": "comparison operator um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01476-00382400-00382854": "is very hard to explain i cannot do so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01477-00382855-00383204": "all right i'ma get it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01478-00383205-00383543": "[Laughter]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01479-00383544-00383806": "now that one yeah it's it's literally", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01480-00383807-00383991": "the comparison is the compare operator", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01481-00383992-00384087": "from perl", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01482-00384088-00384406": "um which which as", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01483-00384407-00384591": "as a concept exists in javascript", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01484-00384592-00384775": "already since that's the that's the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01485-00384776-00384943": "it is the type it is the operator that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01486-00384944-00385119": "corresponds to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01487-00385120-00385319": "the the type of a compare function that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01488-00385320-00385502": "you would pass to sort", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01489-00385503-00385734": "i i probably am going to be sorry to ask", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01490-00385735-00385823": "this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01491-00385824-00386063": "but what does it do on man's and minus", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01492-00386064-00386334": "zeros", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01493-00386335-00386806": "well it's always false because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01494-00386807-00387119": "yeah um no for negative zero", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01495-00387120-00387430": "false isn't even one of the outputs here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01496-00387431-00387734": "um oh yes uh so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01497-00387735-00388047": "because nan compared to anything is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01498-00388048-00388391": "false um it's always going to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01499-00388392-00388775": "take a path in which", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01500-00388776-00389334": "oh that's interesting we should ask that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01501-00389335-00389502": "the funny thing about the spaceship", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01502-00389503-00389806": "operator is that for the type of numbers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01503-00389807-00390630": "it is equivalent to subtraction", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01504-00390631-00390799": "and we know what subtraction does with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01505-00390800-00391030": "nands can the output of the spaceship", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01506-00391031-00391358": "operator be and then", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01507-00391359-00391871": "uh it is always negative one zero or one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01508-00391872-00392119": "okay then i yeah i really don't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01509-00392120-00392254": "understand what this thing does with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01510-00392255-00392399": "nans", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01511-00392400-00393482": "that is why i was suddenly confused", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01512-00393483-00393606": "okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01513-00393607-00393878": "item is just give a dot item method to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01514-00393879-00394134": "erase", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01515-00394135-00394527": "what is it uh it's just an index lookup", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01516-00394528-00394823": "it's for ease of transitioning between", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01517-00394824-00394943": "dom apis and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01518-00394944-00395278": "real javascript", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01519-00395279-00395734": "okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01520-00395735-00396039": "oh yeah this next one subclassing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01521-00396040-00396230": "support for built-in methods", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01522-00396231-00396558": "uh delendast um uh that one", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01523-00396559-00396902": "is fascinating and i i am very very much", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01524-00396903-00397071": "in favor of it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01525-00397072-00397265": "uh glenda nest is some", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01526-00397266-00397375": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01527-00397376-00397751": "yeah uh this is some ancient phrase", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01528-00397752-00398087": "uh meaning must be destroyed carthago de", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01529-00398088-00398287": "lenda asked", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01530-00398288-00398719": "carthage right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01531-00398720-00398943": "yeah there was there was uh i forget", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01532-00398944-00399030": "which was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01533-00399031-00399247": "one of the famous roman orators would", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01534-00399248-00399581": "always end every single speech with that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01535-00399582-00399871": "[Laughter]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01536-00399872-00400175": "yeah that orator", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01537-00400176-00400482": "was was dug except that it was i.e must", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01538-00400483-00400630": "die", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01539-00400631-00400951": "and the other thing which is mildly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01540-00400952-00401015": "interesting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01541-00401016-00401543": "is is julia is the one using that phrase", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01542-00401544-00401830": "i i think people a little bit i'm sorry", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01543-00401831-00401958": "i'm a little bit confused by what", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01544-00401959-00402102": "they're asking for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01545-00402103-00402606": "yeah i want to get rid of that species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01546-00402607-00402927": "there's there's three levels of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01547-00402928-00403206": "subclassing weirdness that the current", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01548-00403207-00403358": "spec", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01549-00403359-00403702": "commits the language to all three of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01550-00403703-00403806": "which", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01551-00403807-00404095": "make the language incredibly harder to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01552-00404096-00404278": "implement correctly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01553-00404279-00404678": "and the history of bugs against v8", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01554-00404679-00404999": "also show that um uh being hard to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01555-00405000-00405054": "implement", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01556-00405055-00405319": "correctly often people don't so they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01557-00405320-00405367": "have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01558-00405368-00405623": "seven security bugs in the last two", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01559-00405624-00405695": "years", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01560-00405696-00406119": "more from the presentation in 2018.", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01561-00406120-00406423": "yeah um so uh and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01562-00406424-00406654": "the the weird subclassing semantics", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01563-00406655-00406823": "that's so hard to implement", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01564-00406824-00407182": "is also approximately useless", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01565-00407183-00407471": "and more than that is as far as we can", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01566-00407472-00407515": "tell", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01567-00407516-00407863": "approximately unused", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01568-00407864-00408151": "so this is one of those rare things", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01569-00408152-00408239": "where", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01570-00408240-00408406": "even though it's been shipping", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01571-00408407-00408639": "compatibly on all of the engines", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01572-00408640-00409030": "for years now conforming to the spec", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01573-00409031-00409327": "uh we actually think we can remove it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01574-00409328-00409510": "without breaking anything which would be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01575-00409511-00409582": "a stone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01576-00409583-00409887": "honey i i remember dominic fighting so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01577-00409888-00410166": "hard for promise subclass ability", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01578-00410167-00410470": "oh yeah oh yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01579-00410471-00410799": "yeah that was that was one where um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01580-00410800-00411063": "allen works brock coming for you elmer's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01581-00411064-00411230": "brock and i both come from a small talk", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01582-00411231-00411334": "background", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01583-00411335-00411695": "but he was very very much enamored", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01584-00411696-00412063": "of the subclassing mechanics", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01585-00412064-00412382": "of being able to override uh portions of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01586-00412383-00412591": "operations and having operations", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01587-00412592-00412822": "delegate to self so that those portions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01588-00412823-00413078": "could be overwritten", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01589-00413079-00413422": "and you know it's an elegant theory um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01590-00413423-00413807": "uh i was skeptical at the time but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01591-00413808-00414055": "uh i wasn't skeptical enough it turned", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01592-00414056-00414326": "out much much worse than i expected", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01593-00414327-00414678": "um so in any case one of the things", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01594-00414679-00414943": "is the species thing so that if you have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01595-00414943-00415126": "a foo array", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01596-00415127-00415455": "that says that its species is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01597-00415456-00415822": "um uh named some other constructor as", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01598-00415823-00415999": "its species and then you do a map", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01599-00416000-00416303": "over the foo array that the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01600-00416304-00416622": "result of the map will be an array that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01601-00416623-00416959": "instantiates uh whatever the name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01602-00416960-00417287": "species is and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01603-00417288-00417607": "then there's things like in regex where", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01604-00417608-00417951": "the the normal normally named operations", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01605-00417952-00417982": "for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01606-00417983-00418295": "portions of them delegate to symbol", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01607-00418296-00418343": "named", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01608-00418343-00418799": "operations so that subclasses of regex", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01609-00418800-00419022": "could override the symbol named", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01610-00419023-00419182": "operation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01611-00419183-00419543": "uh in order to change the normally name", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01612-00419543-00419695": "the behavior of the normally named", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01613-00419696-00419814": "operation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01614-00419815-00420055": "on that subclass so you could change it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01615-00420056-00420303": "into more modular internal fat manner", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01616-00420304-00420566": "rather than changing the publicly named", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01617-00420567-00420718": "thing as a whole", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01618-00420719-00421070": "um and that's about it that i remember", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01619-00421071-00421159": "and i completely", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01620-00421160-00421495": "support that we should you know get rid", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01621-00421496-00421695": "of this stuff", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01622-00421696-00422095": "so we have around 400 000 sites", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01623-00422096-00422455": "or domains that are using species in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01624-00422456-00422583": "some way via", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01625-00422584-00422927": "feature tracking all", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01626-00422928-00423239": "sites we have crawled with a automated", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01627-00423239-00423335": "browser", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01628-00423335-00423631": "to get a real javascript evaluation", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01629-00423632-00423695": "exactly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01630-00423696-00424103": "none of them do any usage of species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01631-00424104-00424631": "except for feature detection to polyfill", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01632-00424632-00424935": "which is astounding", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01633-00424935-00425327": "uh yeah there are thousands of sites", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01634-00425328-00425431": "we've crawled", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01635-00425432-00425831": "and none of them hid it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01636-00425832-00426070": "unfortunately while we expected people", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01637-00426071-00426247": "to use that species for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01638-00426247-00426503": "a specific way of subclassing all of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01639-00426504-00426679": "them implement subclassing in different", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01640-00426680-00426799": "ways in particular", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01641-00426800-00427103": "angular uses at species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01642-00427104-00427414": "but it completely replaces", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01643-00427415-00427766": "all asynchronous uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01644-00427767-00428087": "things within the context it lives in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01645-00428088-00428295": "and so it cannot use the built-in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01646-00428296-00428470": "promises at species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01647-00428471-00428870": "it must recreate it in its own", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01648-00428871-00429287": "zone aware promise class", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01649-00429288-00429607": "so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01650-00429608-00429822": "nobody is actually using it the people", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01651-00429823-00429935": "using the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01652-00429935-00430214": "uh style of extending are doing it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01653-00430215-00430335": "entirely on their own", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01654-00430335-00430639": "and they never call the built-ins", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01655-00430639-00430943": "yeah so this this not only is great in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01656-00430943-00431047": "itself", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01657-00431047-00431399": "in that we can be removing uh unneeded", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01658-00431400-00431718": "problematic crap from the spec uh is it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01659-00431719-00431822": "sets a precedent", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01660-00431823-00432063": "that there might be other completely", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01661-00432064-00432199": "unused", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01662-00432200-00432407": "problematic crap that happen to be in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01663-00432408-00432543": "the language", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01664-00432543-00432870": "uh that we might be able to remove it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01665-00432871-00433207": "it makes the possibility of that um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01666-00433208-00433559": "much more realistic", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01667-00433560-00433895": "uh i highly suspect this will break", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01668-00433896-00433983": "someone", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01669-00433984-00434287": "when we do this but yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01670-00434288-00434591": "and and and then it becomes a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01671-00434592-00434822": "case-by-case basis kind of thing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01672-00434823-00435143": "uh we've had some cases before", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01673-00435143-00435455": "in other transitions where the thing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01674-00435456-00435703": "that broke uh we could just", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01675-00435704-00435895": "call somebody up and have them fix it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01676-00435896-00436183": "and it was done", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01677-00436184-00436422": "and then other things that broke were in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01678-00436423-00436535": "libraries", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01679-00436535-00436766": "in old versions of libraries that have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01680-00436767-00436895": "already been fixed in the present", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01681-00436896-00437022": "version but the old version was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01682-00437023-00437175": "distributed by copy", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01683-00437176-00437343": "and those we just gave up on there's no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01684-00437343-00437759": "way to fix it even though", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01685-00437760-00437991": "we have identified some of those uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01686-00437992-00438175": "there is a blog hosting platform that is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01687-00438176-00438399": "two percent of all usage", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01688-00438400-00438743": "uh for example and so if we can get them", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01689-00438743-00438783": "to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01690-00438784-00439063": "update a specific library which is only", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01691-00439064-00439207": "using it for feature detection they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01692-00439208-00439399": "never actually use species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01693-00439400-00439791": "it would drop it from the usage counter", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01694-00439792-00439839": "uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01695-00439839-00440199": "so uh fixing a library", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01696-00440200-00440551": "does or does not have the effect you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01697-00440552-00440655": "want depending on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01698-00440656-00441007": "how the library is distributed um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01699-00441008-00441263": "so the blog hosting platform is hosting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01700-00441264-00441551": "the javascript file that we want changed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01701-00441552-00441822": "it's a japanese blog hosting platform", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01702-00441823-00442175": "you cannot put arbitrary code in it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01703-00442176-00442870": "okay great", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01704-00442871-00443183": "uh overall this looks semi-reasonable", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01705-00443184-00443366": "we have a scraper a godaddy which i've", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01706-00443367-00443510": "been trying to get", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01707-00443512-00443870": "through fiddles uh that we have uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01708-00443871-00444239": "been trying to do this feature detection", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01709-00444239-00444407": "with higher", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01710-00444408-00444807": "confidence it is very unhappy", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01711-00444808-00445014": "doing more than scraping network traffic", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01712-00445015-00445143": "but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01713-00445143-00445335": "we might have that done after the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01714-00445335-00445463": "meeting i was hoping to have it done", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01715-00445464-00445551": "before the meeting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01716-00445552-00445775": "but for now we've just got you know 3", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01717-00445776-00445943": "000 sites crawled", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01718-00445943-00446463": "instead of that whole amount", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01719-00446464-00446895": "so is the idea of this to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01720-00446896-00447175": "alter the behavior in such a way that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01721-00447176-00447279": "for instance", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01722-00447280-00447599": "the array prototype methods when called", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01723-00447600-00447759": "on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01724-00447760-00448095": "an arbitrary object", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01725-00448096-00448407": "that derives from array", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01726-00448408-00448743": "will return array instances rather than", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01727-00448743-00448879": "a subclass", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01728-00448880-00449135": "yes okay so it's like this is like full", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01729-00449135-00449199": "on like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01730-00449200-00449607": "as dramatic a change as could be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01731-00449608-00449935": "made in this space correct and we have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01732-00449935-00449966": "been", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01733-00449967-00450279": "trying to find anybody who is actually", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01734-00450280-00450455": "using the behavior", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01735-00450456-00450910": "so i definitely experimented with that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01736-00450912-00451166": "for jquery but it never made it to a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01737-00451167-00451351": "release that i can think of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01738-00451352-00451583": "so we have found people trying to use it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01739-00451584-00451703": "but in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01740-00451704-00451935": "reality they almost never use it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01741-00451935-00452095": "correctly and so it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01742-00452096-00452407": "fails so they will replace that species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01743-00452408-00452583": "with their own thing which causes it to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01744-00452584-00452647": "not use", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01745-00452647-00452943": "the default species which returns right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01746-00452943-00453127": "and so it breaks it for all subclasses", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01747-00453128-00453255": "of theirs", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01748-00453256-00453631": "and so uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01749-00453632-00453999": "yeah i wonder if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01750-00454000-00454214": "we could actually remove the support for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01751-00454215-00454935": "subclassing promises", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01752-00454935-00455263": "um man i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01753-00455264-00455614": "don't think so with zones and angular", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01754-00455615-00455935": "usage is just too high", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01755-00455935-00456239": "okay right we can't i agree that we", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01756-00456239-00456655": "cannot break angular", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01757-00456656-00457503": "i um i want to believe in this feature", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01758-00457504-00457695": "um please try to find people who are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01759-00457696-00457839": "actually using it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01760-00457839-00458247": "um oh no no i i'm sure that there won't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01761-00458247-00458335": "be any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01762-00458335-00458639": "but this is def if i if if i were 10", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01763-00458639-00458679": "years", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01764-00458680-00458918": "15 years younger and new to the web this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01765-00458919-00459110": "is the first thing i would abuse", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01766-00459112-00459422": "i'm pretty sure i mean now that eval and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01767-00459423-00459599": "with have been thoroughly abused this is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01768-00459600-00459751": "what i would work on", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01769-00459752-00460110": "so that's the interaction um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01770-00460112-00460295": "everybody who tries to abuse it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01771-00460296-00460495": "accidentally", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01772-00460496-00460831": "destroys its behavior in a way that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01773-00460832-00461079": "for the most part this change is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01774-00461080-00461143": "actually", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01775-00461143-00461510": "a no-op so this all means that we're", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01776-00461512-00461679": "going to suddenly discover that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01777-00461680-00462083": "it's necessary for implementing the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01778-00462084-00462263": "session", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01779-00462264-00462607": "the test shim literally is firing mostly", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01780-00462608-00462831": "because it is replacing the default at", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01781-00462832-00463375": "species with the exact same source text", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01782-00463376-00463663": "and so it fires the trap because that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01783-00463664-00463991": "species has been replaced on a built-in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01784-00463992-00464151": "but it's been replaced with the exact", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01785-00464152-00464422": "same behavior", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01786-00464423-00464670": "so which piece are you talking about so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01787-00464671-00464751": "the default", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01788-00464752-00465079": "at-at species of built-ins is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01789-00465080-00465583": "a uh getter that returns this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01790-00465584-00465959": "so it returns um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01791-00465960-00466310": "everybody who is doing this to try to be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01792-00466312-00466543": "sneaky replaces it with a hard-coded", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01793-00466543-00466863": "value and break subclassing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01794-00466864-00467166": "everybody who is feature detecting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01795-00467167-00467407": "is eagerly replacing that getter with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01796-00467408-00467535": "their own getter", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01797-00467535-00467831": "that returns this so it is the same", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01798-00467832-00467975": "behavior if you're doing feature", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01799-00467976-00468159": "detection or polyfilling", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01800-00468160-00468422": "or it is just broken if you are trying", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01801-00468423-00468631": "to be smart about it is all the cases we", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01802-00468632-00469110": "have found", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01803-00469112-00469327": "i mean is it possible to use this in an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01804-00469328-00469503": "intelligent way", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01805-00469504-00469751": "yes it is yes but we have not found", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01806-00469752-00469807": "anybody", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01807-00469808-00470095": "actually doing that yeah because this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01808-00470096-00470214": "reminds me of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01809-00470215-00470422": "something i tried to do in c plus plus", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01810-00470423-00470607": "when i was in junior college i was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01811-00470608-00470710": "trying to take", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01812-00470712-00470951": "the standard i o uh from the standard", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01813-00470952-00471095": "template library", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01814-00471096-00471487": "and uh extend it such that you could put", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01815-00471488-00471718": "ansi escape sequences", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01816-00471719-00472007": "in line with uh with your stream and the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01817-00472008-00472214": "problem i ran into is that i needed to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01818-00472215-00472455": "override the extract operator to accept", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01819-00472456-00472655": "additional flag types", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01820-00472656-00473031": "um and because it wasn't polymorphic and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01821-00473032-00473087": "because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01822-00473088-00473318": "it was it was all you know template", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01823-00473319-00473422": "generics", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01824-00473423-00473751": "um if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01825-00473752-00474079": "if i if anywhere in", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01826-00474080-00474303": "the sequence of operations i did on the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01827-00474304-00474391": "stream by", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01828-00474392-00474727": "extract extract extract um i ended using", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01829-00474728-00474918": "something like endl it would have been", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01830-00474919-00475087": "it would return uh the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01831-00475088-00475359": "the original i o stream type and i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01832-00475360-00475535": "wouldn't from that point on be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01833-00475535-00475695": "able to do any of the fancy things that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01834-00475696-00475855": "i had added to um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01835-00475856-00476159": "my subclass um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01836-00476160-00476510": "so you know wise people would just give", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01837-00476512-00476583": "up but then i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01838-00476584-00476775": "decided to write my own template library", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01839-00476776-00476951": "until i found out i just couldn't make", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01840-00476952-00477110": "that work", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01841-00477112-00477447": "so this library used to properly use", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01842-00477447-00477839": "adapt species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01843-00477839-00478143": "but they remove the code", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01844-00478143-00478422": "this is this is the the canonical", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01845-00478423-00478743": "example of something that works", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01846-00478743-00479151": "um they removed it though um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01847-00479152-00479399": "this is a breaking change for the map", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01848-00479400-00479455": "filter", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01849-00479456-00479807": "and slice or no and subarray operators", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01850-00479808-00480007": "for this polyfill", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01851-00480008-00480270": "uh but since those are not actually", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01852-00480271-00480447": "things people use", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01853-00480447-00480710": "and we have searched for it because why", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01854-00480712-00480799": "would you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01855-00480800-00481683": "map you into eight array", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01856-00481684-00481799": "um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01857-00481800-00482031": "actually encountered a usage that we", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01858-00482032-00482103": "found", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01859-00482104-00482431": "uh we are still trying to find i'm", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01860-00482432-00482631": "furious", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01861-00482632-00483135": "i i'm furiously writing a case toggle", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01862-00483135-00483318": "the thing that really gets me about this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01863-00483319-00483470": "is that um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01864-00483471-00483775": "i value strongly the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01865-00483776-00484127": "the capability but species never seemed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01866-00484128-00484183": "like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01867-00484184-00484527": "a good way to deliver it yeah speech", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01868-00484528-00484559": "this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01869-00484560-00484814": "history of species is the small tall", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01870-00484815-00484903": "collection", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01871-00484904-00485151": "small talk collection classes uh did", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01872-00485152-00485295": "have a species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01873-00485296-00485599": "uh convention and did use it uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01874-00485600-00485966": "and uh all together with the menagerie", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01875-00485967-00486110": "of collection classes and how they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01876-00486112-00486270": "related to each other", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01877-00486271-00486583": "uh they actually did i mean it really", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01878-00486584-00486935": "was useful in that context", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01879-00486935-00487270": "but that was also i would say uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01880-00487271-00487479": "where brock might disagree with this but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01881-00487480-00487591": "i would say", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01882-00487592-00487799": "uh the small talk collection classes was", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01883-00487800-00487903": "the first time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01884-00487904-00488191": "anybody really tried to do a deeply", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01885-00488192-00488447": "object oriented collection library", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01886-00488447-00488807": "uh and therefore it was before we knew", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01887-00488808-00489183": "how to do it well", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01888-00489184-00489422": "so this does leak into other proposals", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01889-00489423-00489503": "uh i know", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01890-00489504-00489799": "upsert collection normalization and a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01891-00489800-00489918": "few others", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01892-00489919-00490247": "uh have talked about subclass ability", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01893-00490247-00490503": "um this would greatly simplify getting a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01894-00490504-00490670": "variety of those proposals together", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01895-00490671-00490855": "because we don't have to cater to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01896-00490856-00491295": "at species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01897-00491296-00491695": "right yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01898-00491696-00491951": "the uh the position of the of the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01899-00491952-00492079": "specification", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01900-00492080-00492310": "uh with respect to subclass ability has", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01901-00492312-00492470": "never been", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01902-00492471-00492743": "sufficiently strong for my taste anyway", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01903-00492743-00492791": "like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01904-00492792-00493007": "it'll it has throwaway lines about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01905-00493008-00493199": "intended to be subclassed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01906-00493200-00493470": "that then the the actual algorithms and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01907-00493471-00493527": "the text", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01908-00493528-00493887": "don't seem to uh fall in line with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01909-00493888-00494183": "so this partially solves that because uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01910-00494184-00494222": "the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01911-00494223-00494399": "new story the new recommendation from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01912-00494400-00494639": "the spec is to override any methods you", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01913-00494639-00494766": "want", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01914-00494767-00495070": "replaced which matches a variety of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01915-00495071-00495287": "behaviors already in the spec", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01916-00495288-00495687": "that do not delegate to ad species", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01917-00495688-00495887": "yeah the simplicity on its own will have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01918-00495888-00496183": "value", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01919-00496184-00496439": "cool i have a short amount of time left", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01920-00496439-00496614": "so if we could get to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01921-00496615-00497079": "symbols weak map keys that would be good", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01922-00497080-00497303": "so this was actually uh discussed uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01923-00497304-00497407": "last time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01924-00497408-00497735": "uh when these guys were here uh from the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01925-00497735-00498110": "um records and tuples proposal", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01926-00498112-00498462": "uh the records and total proposal has a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01927-00498463-00498703": "use case", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01928-00498704-00499087": "that becomes much easier if we simply", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01929-00499088-00499222": "allow", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01930-00499223-00499575": "symbols as weak map keys", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01931-00499576-00499831": "and there's a controversy that i started", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01932-00499832-00499966": "about whether it's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01933-00499967-00500287": "symbols as a whole or just unregistered", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01934-00500288-00500431": "symbols and i don't know where that's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01935-00500432-00500639": "going to land", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01936-00500639-00500935": "but unregistered symbol having at least", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01937-00500935-00501079": "unregistered symbols", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01938-00501080-00501351": "not keys is something that i had", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01939-00501352-00501783": "resisted previously because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01940-00501784-00502151": "it was a weird case and there was no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01941-00502152-00502303": "compelling use case", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01942-00502304-00502455": "my records and tuples give us a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01943-00502456-00502662": "compelling use case", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01944-00502663-00502983": "the compelling use case is that um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01945-00502984-00503407": "uh the symbol can", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01946-00503408-00503747": "be used as a um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01947-00503749-00503879": "[Music]", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01948-00503880-00504222": "a unforgeable token to be looked up", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01949-00504223-00504575": "in the weak map to designate other", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01950-00504576-00504847": "mutable things if you have access to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01951-00504847-00504991": "that weak map", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01952-00504992-00505143": "so there's a bunch of patterns that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01953-00505143-00505359": "follow from that where you're", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01954-00505360-00505687": "effectively storing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01955-00505688-00506103": "mutable data within a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01956-00506104-00506407": "within sort of within a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01957-00506408-00506662": "pure value structure by actually storing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01958-00506663-00506807": "these symbols", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01959-00506808-00507070": "that point through the weak map to the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01960-00507071-00507191": "non-pure values", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01961-00507192-00507447": "and from a capability perspective uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01962-00507447-00507518": "it's perfect", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01963-00507519-00507775": "because uh if you don't have access to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01964-00507776-00507903": "the side table", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01965-00507904-00508191": "then you all you see is pure values and", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01966-00508192-00508543": "you can't be referenced", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01967-00508543-00508887": "so yes i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01968-00508888-00509255": "want to make a quick case that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01969-00509256-00509575": "allowing these global symbols", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01970-00509576-00509975": "that are available with uh forge ability", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01971-00509976-00510447": "are not problematic if that's okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01972-00510447-00510735": "sure um so we have two points of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01973-00510735-00510855": "contention that i see", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01974-00510856-00511062": "on these uh there may be more please add", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01975-00511063-00511255": "them as i talk about this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01976-00511256-00511599": "one is memory leakage uh the ability to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01977-00511600-00511807": "forge a symbol means that anything we", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01978-00511808-00511999": "store in a side table", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01979-00512000-00512247": "uh must be kept alive essentially", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01980-00512247-00512399": "indefinitely", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01981-00512400-00512622": "until the context in which the forge", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01982-00512623-00512807": "ability is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01983-00512808-00513110": "garbage collected somehow for some of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01984-00513112-00513310": "those such as symbol.iterator that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01985-00513312-00513687": "are shared that's not possible", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01986-00513688-00513910": "at all so we have kind of three", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01987-00513912-00514047": "categories of symbols", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01988-00514047-00514375": "we have the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01989-00514376-00514551": "for registered symbols it's as", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01990-00514552-00514862": "impossible as it is for symbol", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01991-00514863-00515310": "correct uh yes sorry um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01992-00515312-00515647": "so we between this", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01993-00515647-00515910": "we can already create uh this kind of", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01994-00515912-00516039": "memory leak boundary", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01995-00516039-00516407": "or uh inability to ever remove something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01996-00516408-00516583": "from the side table by using the side", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01997-00516584-00516943": "table as a key uh to itself", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01998-00516943-00517247": "so that's kind of awkward or using any", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-01999-00517247-00517351": "of the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02000-00517352-00517662": "uh undeniables as keys and then", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02001-00517663-00517943": "producing a side table within that no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02002-00517943-00518047": "the the the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02003-00518047-00518318": "the side table itself is a valid point", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02004-00518319-00518487": "and i hadn't heard that one before", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02005-00518488-00518718": "uh the undeniables is not a valid point", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02006-00518719-00518822": "because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02007-00518823-00519239": "uh realms can be garbage collected", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02008-00519239-00519607": "uh fair enough uh but we do do the side", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02009-00519608-00519679": "table trick", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02010-00519680-00519847": "actually within the polyfill for the old", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02011-00519847-00520031": "composite key", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02012-00520032-00520335": "um uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02013-00520335-00520883": "proposal so i mean it is out there", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02014-00520884-00521143": "um also i don't think the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02015-00521143-00521351": "memory leakage is really the concern", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02016-00521352-00521495": "here i think that's kind of an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02017-00521496-00521583": "anti-pattern", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02018-00521584-00521775": "and we don't need to defend against that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02019-00521776-00522079": "specific anti-pattern", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02020-00522080-00522431": "um you could for example have", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02021-00522432-00522743": "a side table which references something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02022-00522743-00523062": "that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02023-00523063-00523383": "well no hold on you could have a record", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02024-00523384-00523607": "which uses a side table for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02025-00523608-00523910": "the non-registered symbols and then has", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02026-00523912-00524087": "a strong mapping", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02027-00524088-00524431": "not a side table uh for", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02028-00524432-00524599": "other things that needs to be passed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02029-00524600-00524791": "contextually around", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02030-00524792-00525103": "that is a pattern around it it can allow", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02031-00525104-00525303": "you to use registered symbols within", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02032-00525304-00525583": "records and tuples without this concern", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02033-00525584-00525662": "um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02034-00525663-00525862": "it is more difficult to do in general i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02035-00525863-00526118": "think using registered", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02036-00526119-00526335": "symbols within these is just an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02037-00526336-00526422": "anti-pattern", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02038-00526423-00526614": "that nobody nobody's really seeking to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02039-00526615-00526799": "encourage", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02040-00526800-00527103": "um people will see that it leaks they", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02041-00527104-00527303": "will stop doing it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02042-00527304-00527622": "um if they don't uh no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02043-00527623-00527918": "extra object capabilities are granted by", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02044-00527919-00528335": "doing so to my knowledge", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02045-00528336-00528622": "allowing allowing registered symbols to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02046-00528623-00528791": "be weak math keys", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02047-00528792-00529111": "um uh and just to go extreme here", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02048-00529112-00529383": "allowing numbers and strings to be weak", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02049-00529384-00529511": "map keys", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02050-00529512-00529775": "uh you know creates a permanent leak it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02051-00529776-00529879": "doesn't violate", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02052-00529880-00530199": "any object capability principles so it's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02053-00530200-00530255": "not a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02054-00530256-00530622": "object capability concern it's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02055-00530623-00530999": "more of a concern that when people", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02056-00531000-00531383": "use a weak map they're expecting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02057-00531384-00531735": "a certain relief from memory pressure", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02058-00531736-00532039": "and if once we start allowing things", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02059-00532040-00532455": "that surprisingly never get collected", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02060-00532456-00532831": "then we violate their expectations", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02061-00532832-00533239": "so i would argue that the uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02062-00533240-00533527": "expectation is based upon the lifetime", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02063-00533528-00533607": "of whatever the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02064-00533608-00533959": "key in the map is not based upon", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02065-00533960-00534255": "any sort of guarantee that during a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02066-00534256-00534543": "garbage collection it could be collected", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02067-00534544-00534975": "um so when you put something into a weak", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02068-00534976-00535014": "map", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02069-00535015-00535247": "it is drastically different from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02070-00535248-00535455": "arbitrarily adding a private field", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02071-00535456-00535711": "you are correct private fields are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02072-00535712-00535918": "unable to be removed from references", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02073-00535919-00536166": "ever even if the private field", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02074-00536167-00536439": "identifier completely is destroyed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02075-00536440-00536670": "currently in the specification so if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02076-00536671-00536814": "there is no way to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02077-00536815-00537047": "reference a private field anymore it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02078-00537048-00537239": "will stay alive still", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02079-00537240-00537718": "um and that i think is a similar concern", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02080-00537719-00537951": "where you have a way to introduce a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02081-00537952-00538111": "permanent leak", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02082-00538112-00538407": "uh it's not exactly great that you can", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02083-00538408-00538583": "create a permanent leak", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02084-00538584-00538775": "but i don't think it's something we need", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02085-00538776-00539070": "to prevent people from doing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02086-00539071-00539422": "i think limiting it to symbols is nicer", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02087-00539423-00539783": "than saying arbitrary strings or numbers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02088-00539784-00540062": "uh symbols in general are not things", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02089-00540063-00540175": "that you produce", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02090-00540176-00540479": "via an operator", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02091-00540480-00540791": "like plus or concatenation they don't", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02092-00540792-00541087": "you don't coerce to symbols generally", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02093-00541088-00541455": "um so they are much less a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02094-00541456-00541791": "threat of accidental leakage uh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02095-00541792-00542055": "they are a threat of misusage causing", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02096-00542056-00542375": "leakage though", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02097-00542376-00543031": "i think i'm buying this argument", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02098-00543032-00543287": "my key point is we can already create", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02099-00543288-00543518": "these memory leaks in a variety of ways", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02100-00543519-00543791": "and these symbols although they are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02101-00543792-00543966": "forgeable they are not forgeable", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02102-00543967-00544487": "through any kind of implicit coercion", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02103-00544488-00544855": "this point you make about private fields", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02104-00544856-00545327": "um the real the real", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02105-00545328-00545670": "problem there was when we added return", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02106-00545671-00545991": "override to the class mechanism", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02107-00545992-00546351": "um this uh thing about", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02108-00546352-00546679": "uh removing crap that nobody needs but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02109-00546680-00546903": "gets everyone in trouble", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02110-00546904-00547183": "uh i don't think we could remove return", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02111-00547184-00547287": "override but", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02112-00547288-00547551": "maybe we could restrict it in important", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02113-00547552-00547687": "ways", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02114-00547688-00548070": "i would love that personally now", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02115-00548071-00548391": "that that that does not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02116-00548392-00548718": "allow for an inherent permanent", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02117-00548719-00549087": "memory leak unless i'm quite mistaken", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02118-00549088-00549422": "uh returning override allows you to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02119-00549423-00549727": "um uh let's say that um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02120-00549728-00550151": "okay no no so what i'm saying is like um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02121-00550152-00550462": "when the when the source of the private", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02122-00550463-00550655": "field goes out of scope", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02123-00550656-00550935": "the private field on the non-instance is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02124-00550936-00551070": "itself no longer", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02125-00551071-00551375": "observable right it's no longer it's no", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02126-00551376-00551487": "longer observable", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02127-00551488-00551727": "nobody is implementing the private", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02128-00551728-00551831": "fields", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02129-00551832-00552031": "in such a way that the storage of the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02130-00552032-00552262": "private field goes away", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02131-00552263-00552470": "right right understood but but that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02132-00552471-00552622": "could change over time", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02133-00552623-00552879": "like because it is not observable yeah", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02134-00552880-00552959": "so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02135-00552960-00553495": "unless there is an extreme usage", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02136-00553496-00553695": "memory leak they are not going to patch", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02137-00553696-00553870": "that because granted", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02138-00553871-00554070": "and i don't expect it to but the point", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02139-00554071-00554207": "is that like an engine", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02140-00554208-00554614": "could still be conforming if it did so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02141-00554615-00554943": "um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02142-00554944-00555303": "i believe so", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02143-00555304-00555591": "i am unclear with regard to finalizers", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02144-00555592-00555687": "if that is", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02145-00555688-00556070": "entirely true", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02146-00556071-00556311": "what do you mean by finalizers so if i", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02147-00556312-00556414": "put some", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02148-00556415-00556695": "object so it's now strongly held in a", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02149-00556696-00556847": "private field", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02150-00556848-00557118": "um and it has a weak ref collection", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02151-00557119-00557351": "finalizer on it", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02152-00557352-00557622": "um okay i am not sure that you are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02153-00557623-00557775": "actually allowed to collect", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02154-00557776-00558087": "anything with such uh finals", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02155-00558088-00558383": "so the whole the the the weak the the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02156-00558384-00558599": "weak ref semantics", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02157-00558600-00558935": "um uh was a really interesting", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02158-00558936-00559295": "subtle piece of design to figure out", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02159-00559296-00559599": "how to have the specification be", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02160-00559600-00559935": "weak enough that it did not", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02161-00559936-00560166": "overly constrain implementers allowed", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02162-00560167-00560366": "implementers to do things like", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02163-00560367-00560822": "dead code and dead variable elimination", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02164-00560823-00561022": "structure sharing for closures because", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02165-00561023-00561199": "of shared lexical context", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02166-00561200-00561483": "there's a whole bunch of things that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02167-00561484-00561751": "cause", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02168-00561752-00562118": "the actual reachability to differ from", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02169-00562119-00562399": "any semantic account of reachability", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02170-00562400-00562631": "in a large number of ways in both", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02171-00562632-00562783": "directions both more and less", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02172-00562784-00563007": "reachability", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02173-00563008-00563191": "and this would be this would be an", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02174-00563192-00563335": "example of that", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02175-00563336-00563662": "um so we ended up with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02176-00563663-00564031": "a um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02177-00564032-00564318": "the kind of subtle spec that people use", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02178-00564319-00564399": "when they try to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02179-00564400-00564622": "specify memory models and i think that's", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02180-00564623-00564775": "actually the right", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02181-00564776-00565166": "analogy um and it has to do with", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02182-00565167-00565431": "uh comparing sort of all the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02183-00565432-00565683": "hypothetical executions", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02184-00565684-00566014": "uh under cases where something was or", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02185-00566015-00566207": "was not retained or something", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02186-00566208-00566727": "it got it got uh um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02187-00566728-00567143": "it's well thought out but um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02188-00567144-00567311": "it's not something i can retain in my", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02189-00567312-00567518": "head and certainly reason from unless", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02190-00567519-00567999": "it's fresh", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02191-00568000-00568279": "but that's that's where i would look to", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02192-00568280-00568327": "see", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02193-00568328-00568639": "if the private fields", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02194-00568640-00568951": "could be garbage collected even if", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02195-00568952-00569231": "um weak references make them make the", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02196-00569232-00569622": "garbage collection observable", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02197-00569623-00569839": "uh yeah that's the only thing i can", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02198-00569840-00570270": "think of for the leakage", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02199-00570271-00570470": "of the identity of something stored", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02200-00570471-00570647": "within the private field not the private", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02201-00570648-00570799": "field itself", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02202-00570800-00571135": "right yeah i'm surprised", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02203-00571136-00571431": "that built-in modules is not only agenda", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02204-00571432-00571622": "anywhere", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02205-00571623-00571847": "uh i think that was in the incubator", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02206-00571848-00572070": "call a little while ago and they are", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02207-00572071-00572151": "working through", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02208-00572152-00572535": "issues from that call still okay", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02209-00572536-00573007": "um gentlemen we are now well past 3 p.m", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02210-00573008-00573239": "i was about to point out thank you alex", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02211-00573240-00573318": "um", "3dTcbR1_Mfc-02212-00573319-00574096": "i propose that we stop recording"}}, {"audio_id": "3e6B5GCEigE", "text": {"3e6B5GCEigE-00000-00000071-00000335": "hi welcome back to rebecca's travels or", "3e6B5GCEigE-00001-00000336-00000455": "if you're watching my", "3e6B5GCEigE-00002-00000456-00000759": "lifestyle channel hi welcome back to", "3e6B5GCEigE-00003-00000760-00001070": "rebecca's lifestyle i hope and", "3e6B5GCEigE-00004-00001071-00001183": "everybody's", "3e6B5GCEigE-00005-00001184-00001647": "and having a happy easter", "3e6B5GCEigE-00006-00001648-00001959": "or as good day as", "3e6B5GCEigE-00007-00001960-00002302": "possible and um", "3e6B5GCEigE-00008-00002303-00002639": "today um i'm going to be doing", "3e6B5GCEigE-00009-00002640-00002999": "a vlog on my travel and lifestyle", "3e6B5GCEigE-00010-00003000-00003390": "improvements updates and more", "3e6B5GCEigE-00011-00003392-00003695": "so and please keep watching", "3e6B5GCEigE-00012-00003696-00003999": "and just before i jump right into it if", "3e6B5GCEigE-00013-00004000-00004086": "you could", "3e6B5GCEigE-00014-00004087-00004375": "press the red and white subscription", "3e6B5GCEigE-00015-00004376-00004663": "button it's free to subscribe i upload", "3e6B5GCEigE-00016-00004664-00004999": "at least five times a week on both", "3e6B5GCEigE-00017-00005000-00005327": "channels and", "3e6B5GCEigE-00018-00005328-00005654": "um i also", "3e6B5GCEigE-00019-00005655-00006015": "um deliver a free monthly", "3e6B5GCEigE-00020-00006016-00006351": "newsletter which you can all download", "3e6B5GCEigE-00021-00006352-00006791": "for free uh viewers and subscribers", "3e6B5GCEigE-00022-00006792-00007191": "and and for extra point at perks you can", "3e6B5GCEigE-00023-00007192-00007463": "uh draw or join my memberships at the", "3e6B5GCEigE-00024-00007464-00007663": "start at 99 pence", "3e6B5GCEigE-00025-00007664-00007967": "per month uh depending uh", "3e6B5GCEigE-00026-00007968-00008287": "what you want uh from", "3e6B5GCEigE-00027-00008288-00008599": "the membership channel", "3e6B5GCEigE-00028-00008600-00008951": "so and that's the red one", "3e6B5GCEigE-00029-00008952-00009135": "sorry that's the white and blue", "3e6B5GCEigE-00030-00009136-00009391": "subscription button next", "3e6B5GCEigE-00031-00009392-00009663": "uh the join button sorry next to the", "3e6B5GCEigE-00032-00009664-00009983": "subscription button", "3e6B5GCEigE-00033-00009984-00010351": "my subscribe button is the red and white", "3e6B5GCEigE-00034-00010352-00010655": "subscription button click notification", "3e6B5GCEigE-00035-00010656-00010695": "bell", "3e6B5GCEigE-00036-00010696-00011046": "so you don't miss a video and", "3e6B5GCEigE-00037-00011047-00011374": "my joint channel is the white and blue", "3e6B5GCEigE-00038-00011375-00011735": "button next to it and um", "3e6B5GCEigE-00039-00011736-00012174": "yes um and i would really appreciate", "3e6B5GCEigE-00040-00012175-00012231": "that", "3e6B5GCEigE-00041-00012232-00012567": "and it would mean the world to me", "3e6B5GCEigE-00042-00012568-00013038": "and and um", "3e6B5GCEigE-00043-00013039-00013411": "let's jump right into it for", "3e6B5GCEigE-00044-00013412-00013719": "improvements set this week i've added", "3e6B5GCEigE-00045-00013719-00014086": "instagram link to my youtube account", "3e6B5GCEigE-00046-00014087-00014599": "and my travel and", "3e6B5GCEigE-00047-00014600-00014903": "live well my travel chat channel link", "3e6B5GCEigE-00048-00014904-00015255": "to my youtube rebecca's travels", "3e6B5GCEigE-00049-00015256-00015638": "account um", "3e6B5GCEigE-00050-00015640-00015950": "and next week and i'm going to", "3e6B5GCEigE-00051-00015951-00016311": "be telling more of my followers to check", "3e6B5GCEigE-00052-00016312-00016415": "out my", "3e6B5GCEigE-00053-00016416-00016727": "travel and and lifestyle channel", "3e6B5GCEigE-00054-00016728-00017183": "um just to create more awareness", "3e6B5GCEigE-00055-00017184-00017486": "and get getting more traffic to", "3e6B5GCEigE-00056-00017487-00017863": "my travel and lifestyle um", "3e6B5GCEigE-00057-00017864-00018283": "account um and websites", "3e6B5GCEigE-00058-00018284-00018730": "um so i'm also increasing my viewers", "3e6B5GCEigE-00059-00018731-00019079": "subscriptions or um", "3e6B5GCEigE-00060-00019080-00019486": "memberships um also and there will be", "3e6B5GCEigE-00061-00019487-00019871": "a free monthly newsletter to download", "3e6B5GCEigE-00062-00019872-00020294": "april 2021 and", "3e6B5GCEigE-00063-00020295-00020599": "and that's um going to be available both", "3e6B5GCEigE-00064-00020600-00020743": "on my travel and", "3e6B5GCEigE-00065-00020744-00021047": "lifestyle channel it is going to be", "3e6B5GCEigE-00066-00021048-00021671": "travel inspiration and the newsletter", "3e6B5GCEigE-00067-00021672-00022063": "um it basically gives", "3e6B5GCEigE-00068-00022064-00022783": "latest um updates um", "3e6B5GCEigE-00069-00022784-00023127": "but basically for uk travel", "3e6B5GCEigE-00070-00023128-00023550": "in at this country", "3e6B5GCEigE-00071-00023551-00023903": "and also um travel", "3e6B5GCEigE-00072-00023904-00024247": "out of the uk which at the moment you", "3e6B5GCEigE-00073-00024248-00024375": "can only do it", "3e6B5GCEigE-00074-00024376-00024807": "um in special circumstances", "3e6B5GCEigE-00075-00024808-00025175": "um so i would like to say", "3e6B5GCEigE-00076-00025176-00025519": "thank you for watching and have", "3e6B5GCEigE-00077-00025520-00025831": "i hope you've had the best", "3e6B5GCEigE-00078-00025832-00026246": "easter sunday as possible and", "3e6B5GCEigE-00079-00026247-00026856": "bye for now thank you bye"}}, {"audio_id": "3e_R2WW-sFY", "text": {"3e_R2WW-sFY-00000-00000120-00001643": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3eKZsxsw0Tk", "text": {"3eKZsxsw0Tk-00000-00000049-00006631": "[Applause]", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00001-00006631-00006678": "okay", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00002-00006679-00006991": "so this was ticket number nine on", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00003-00006992-00007375": "the cashwort ticket and we did not find", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00004-00007376-00007487": "a winner", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00005-00007488-00007823": "we had two words in game two and we had", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00006-00007823-00008078": "two words in game one", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00007-00008079-00008463": "so no luck today thanks for watching", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00008-00008464-00010038": "see you next time bye-bye", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00009-00010039-00010695": "[Music]", "3eKZsxsw0Tk-00010-00010696-00010904": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "3eMuZp-1LDc", "text": {"3eMuZp-1LDc-00000-00000056-00000311": "hello everyone this is the second", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00001-00000312-00000567": "part of edition don't forget to like and", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00002-00000568-00000823": "subscribe and comment and if you haven't", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00003-00000824-00001079": "then watch part one the link will be in", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00004-00001080-00001239": "the description", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00005-00001240-00001407": "it'll be at the end of the video and", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00006-00001408-00001726": "it's also linked up in the cards", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00007-00001727-00002102": "okay let's jump into it let's do", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00008-00002103-00002471": "30 plus 20.", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00009-00002472-00002791": "let's do it zero plus zero", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00010-00002792-00003247": "what is that zero three plus two is", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00011-00003247-00003583": "five thirty plus twenty", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00012-00003584-00004054": "equals fifty", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00013-00004055-00004567": "let's do seventy-seven plus eighty-nine", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00014-00004568-00004943": "all right let's do this what is seven", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00015-00004944-00005302": "plus nine", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00016-00005303-00005638": "sixteen the six goes over here and where", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00017-00005639-00005815": "does the one go", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00018-00005816-00006295": "over here seven plus eight is", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00019-00006296-00006623": "fifteen plus the one", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00020-00006623-00007039": "equals sixteen sixteen goes over here", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00021-00007040-00007423": "seventy-seven plus 89 equals 166. we", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00022-00007423-00007606": "don't need the one anymore", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00023-00007608-00007942": "all right let's do", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00024-00007943-00008478": "two more easy ones", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00025-00008479-00008855": "all right 33 plus 29", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00026-00008856-00009303": "what does that equal 33", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00027-00009304-00009646": "plus 29.", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00028-00009647-00009999": "all right let's do this what is three", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00029-00010000-00010295": "plus nine", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00030-00010296-00010559": "twelve the two goes over here and the", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00031-00010560-00010727": "one goes", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00032-00010728-00011063": "up here three plus two is", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00033-00011064-00011423": "five plus the one equals", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00034-00011424-00011767": "six we don't need the one anymore", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00035-00011768-00012159": "33 plus 29 equals", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00036-00012160-00012583": "62. all right 52 plus 12", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00037-00012584-00012951": "what does that equal well", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00038-00012952-00013335": "four plus two equals six", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00039-00013336-00013663": "and then five plus one is", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00040-00013663-00014083": "six fifty-four plus twelve", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00041-00014084-00014422": "equals 66", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00042-00014423-00015399": "okay time to do some harder ones now", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00043-00015400-00015758": "all right 120 plus 62", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00044-00015759-00016127": "what does that equal", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00045-00016128-00016558": "zero plus two equals", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00046-00016559-00016958": "two two plus six equals", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00047-00016959-00017279": "eight and we can bring the one down", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00048-00017280-00017615": "to make 120", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00049-00017616-00018055": "plus 62 equals 182", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00050-00018056-00018983": "okay let's do a couple more", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00051-00018984-00019303": "all right what is seven plus eight", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00052-00019304-00019591": "it equals fifteen the five goes over", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00053-00019592-00019743": "here and the one goes", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00054-00019744-00020150": "up here now", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00055-00020151-00020527": "zero plus eight eight plus that one that", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00056-00020528-00020686": "we put up there", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00057-00020687-00021086": "nine", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00058-00021087-00021543": "okay nine plus eight what is that", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00059-00021544-00021863": "seventeen we put the seven", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00060-00021864-00022167": "down here and there's no number", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00061-00022168-00022399": "right here so we can also put the one", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00062-00022400-00022527": "down here", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00063-00022528-00023035": "907 plus 888 equals", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00064-00023036-00023286": "1795", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00065-00023287-00023614": "okay let's do", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00066-00023615-00024214": "a couple more", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00067-00024215-00024622": "all right 900 plus 77 let's do this", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00068-00024623-00024958": "what is zero plus seven seven", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00069-00024959-00025375": "what is zero plus seven seven", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00070-00025376-00025678": "now we have to bring the nine down", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00071-00025679-00025999": "nine nine hundred plus seventy-seven", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00072-00026000-00026502": "equals nine hundred seventy-seven", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00073-00026504-00026846": "okay let's do one more and then we'll", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00074-00026847-00027614": "finish", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00075-00027616-00027918": "okay what is five thousand", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00076-00027919-00028190": "six hundred seventeen plus two hundred", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00077-00028191-00028351": "we can do this", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00078-00028352-00028751": "seven plus zero seven", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00079-00028752-00029151": "one plus a zero one", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00080-00029152-00029455": "six plus two is eight and then we can", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00081-00029456-00029679": "bring the five down", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00082-00029680-00030227": "five don't forget the comma okay", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00083-00030227-00030614": "5617 plus", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00084-00030616-00031199": "200 equals 5 5817", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00085-00031200-00031567": "okay we're done thanks for watching", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00086-00031568-00031887": "goodbye oh and edition part one is right", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00087-00031888-00032283": "here", "3eMuZp-1LDc-00088-00032283-00032583": "goodbye"}}, {"audio_id": "3eOYGzUqUNQ", "text": {"3eOYGzUqUNQ-00000-00000008-00000118": "so my name is", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00001-00000119-00000335": "jira and i'm a research software", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00002-00000336-00000543": "engineer at the netherlands e-science", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00003-00000544-00000663": "center", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00004-00000664-00000871": "i am from the netherlands and i've lived", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00005-00000872-00001910": "in amsterdam for about 15 years", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00006-00001911-00002191": "so as a research software engineer i", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00007-00002192-00002431": "work on various life science related", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00008-00002432-00002718": "projects at the e-science center", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00009-00002719-00003055": "the main project i'm working on now is", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00010-00003056-00003327": "is a big data and health", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00011-00003328-00003575": "related project where i work on an", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00012-00003576-00003759": "infrastructure to", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00013-00003760-00003870": "do", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00014-00003871-00004127": "privacy preserving data analysis to", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00015-00004128-00004335": "prevent heart disease", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00016-00004336-00004551": "and other than that i also do", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00017-00004552-00004775": "teaching teaching software engineering", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00018-00004776-00004886": "skills", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00019-00004887-00005037": "to scientists", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00020-00005038-00005170": "[Music]", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00021-00005171-00005511": "[Applause]", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00022-00005512-00005767": "what it means for me to be a woman in", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00023-00005768-00005895": "science is to", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00024-00005896-00006334": "follow my own passion regardless of", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00025-00006335-00006550": "yeah what other people think and follow", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00026-00006551-00006767": "my instincts and", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00027-00006768-00007287": "also having the space for creativity and", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00028-00007288-00007639": "yeah to to to make my own judgments and", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00029-00007640-00007734": "um", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00030-00007736-00008063": "a lot of um creative problem solving and", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00031-00008064-00008271": "collaborating with others who are also", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00032-00008272-00008414": "very creative", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00033-00008415-00008710": "and trying to uh to solve the challenges", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00034-00008711-00008865": "together", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00035-00008866-00008944": "[Music]", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00036-00008945-00009214": "[Applause]", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00037-00009215-00009399": "working at the east science center for", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00038-00009400-00009591": "me means that i have a lot of creative", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00039-00009592-00009751": "freedom in", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00040-00009752-00010006": "tackling challenges and", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00041-00010007-00010142": "have a", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00042-00010143-00010383": "high level control over how we approach", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00043-00010384-00010574": "projects and", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00044-00010575-00010806": "i can always i can always ask my", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00045-00010807-00011038": "colleagues about creative input and", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00046-00011039-00011199": "brainstorm about solutions together", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00047-00011200-00011391": "which is a very", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00048-00011392-00011955": "yeah which i find very exciting to do", "3eOYGzUqUNQ-00049-00011956-00012556": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3eQ4fmsomI4", "text": {"3eQ4fmsomI4-00000-00000611-00001491": "[Music]", "3eQ4fmsomI4-00001-00001492-00001762": "that's", "3eQ4fmsomI4-00002-00001763-00028151": "[Music]", "3eQ4fmsomI4-00003-00028152-00028360": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "3f9nLWSL5l0", "text": {"3f9nLWSL5l0-00000-00000088-00000519": "banners of praise by rumi", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00001-00000520-00000902": "our fasting is over it's the feast day", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00002-00000903-00001047": "of spring", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00003-00001048-00001374": "oh dearest guest welcome", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00004-00001375-00001863": "sorrow be gone all praise be to god", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00005-00001864-00002295": "o love once forsaken abandoned heart be", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00006-00002296-00002718": "forgotten now your beloved has arrived", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00007-00002719-00003095": "and forever will remain all praise", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00008-00003096-00003415": "be to god parting", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00009-00003415-00003743": "is forever parted separation", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00010-00003744-00004070": "is severed at last union", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00011-00004071-00004415": "is united with no more delay all", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00012-00004416-00004759": "praise be to god", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00013-00004760-00005151": "flight has flown and exiles pain", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00014-00005152-00005551": "is banished distance is now distant", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00015-00005552-00005902": "our nest is filled with joy", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00016-00005903-00006270": "all praise but the moon", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00017-00006271-00006591": "in the heavens the rose in the heart", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00018-00006592-00007031": "in love's garden the king in his palace", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00019-00007031-00007334": "brow proud banners show forth", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00020-00007336-00007759": "all praise be to god life stirs", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00021-00007759-00008070": "in their root hair fluid sap", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00022-00008072-00008446": "spreads in each tiny leaf green buds", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00023-00008447-00008774": "on the branches crown his dominion", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00024-00008775-00009119": "all praise be to god", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00025-00009120-00009455": "let the despised enemy come for he'll", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00026-00009456-00009542": "meet our", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00027-00009543-00009887": "defender we challenge his approach", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00028-00009888-00010199": "for now in safety we say", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00029-00010200-00010542": "all praise be to god", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00030-00010543-00010783": "flood me completely with the fire of", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00031-00010784-00010927": "love's burning", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00032-00010928-00011278": "for now i can bear it and not burn away", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00033-00011279-00011663": "all praise be to god for now", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00034-00011664-00012006": "in certainty my soul is free", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00035-00012007-00012367": "and all of earth's sadness has dissolved", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00036-00012368-00012591": "in earth's clay", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00037-00012592-00012894": "all praise be to god", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00038-00012895-00013286": "o chalice overflowing poured out for", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00039-00013287-00013686": "these thirsty worlds we thank you", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00040-00013687-00014094": "we bless you and we drink while we pray", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00041-00014095-00014415": "all praise be to god", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00042-00014416-00014727": "the world lay parched for so long an", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00043-00014728-00015071": "open desert until the dew glistened", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00044-00015072-00015335": "and your breath came on the wings of", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00045-00015336-00015479": "mourning", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00046-00015480-00015871": "all praise be to god as we waited", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00047-00015872-00016135": "we were longing for spring's sun to", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00048-00016136-00016286": "renew this life of", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00049-00016287-00016663": "ours today our warm breath arrived from", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00050-00016664-00016815": "the east", "3f9nLWSL5l0-00051-00016816-00017464": "all praise be to god"}}, {"audio_id": "3ffUK-KODfg", "text": {"3ffUK-KODfg-00000-00001807-00002095": "so last class we have discussed the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00001-00002096-00002359": "statement of the what is called minimum", "3ffUK-KODfg-00002-00002360-00002631": "time control problem of a linear time", "3ffUK-KODfg-00003-00002632-00002815": "invariant system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00004-00002816-00003055": "let us recap this statement of the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00005-00003056-00003238": "problem", "3ffUK-KODfg-00006-00003239-00003422": "and then we explain", "3ffUK-KODfg-00007-00003423-00003670": "the solution of minimum time optimum", "3ffUK-KODfg-00008-00003671-00003975": "control problem with an example", "3ffUK-KODfg-00009-00003976-00004231": "so let us call the linear dynamic system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00010-00004232-00004511": "is given by x dot is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00011-00004512-00004895": "a x plus b u u is the control input", "3ffUK-KODfg-00012-00004896-00005031": "and x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00013-00005032-00005399": "of t 0 at time t 0 initial time t 0 is x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00014-00005400-00005631": "of 0 is given", "3ffUK-KODfg-00015-00005632-00006006": "so our problem is to drive the state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00016-00006007-00006206": "from initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-00017-00006207-00006510": "time t is equal to 0 the state value is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00018-00006511-00006831": "x 0 drive this state to a final state at", "3ffUK-KODfg-00019-00006831-00007055": "t is equal to t f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00020-00007056-00007463": "where x f is given in a minimum time", "3ffUK-KODfg-00021-00007464-00007703": "so that is our problem", "3ffUK-KODfg-00022-00007704-00007942": "so first we have to check whether the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00023-00007943-00008214": "system is completely controllable or not", "3ffUK-KODfg-00024-00008215-00008319": "by", "3ffUK-KODfg-00025-00008320-00008519": "the what is called this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00026-00008520-00008839": "rank condition we have to satisfy b a b", "3ffUK-KODfg-00027-00008840-00008959": "a square b", "3ffUK-KODfg-00028-00008960-00009119": "a n minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00029-00009120-00009255": "one b", "3ffUK-KODfg-00030-00009256-00009455": "n is the number of states involved in", "3ffUK-KODfg-00031-00009456-00009671": "the system dynamically", "3ffUK-KODfg-00032-00009672-00010023": "that rank must be n then all the states", "3ffUK-KODfg-00033-00010024-00010287": "will be controllable", "3ffUK-KODfg-00034-00010288-00010623": "and not only this we have a constraint", "3ffUK-KODfg-00035-00010624-00010774": "on the input", "3ffUK-KODfg-00036-00010775-00011055": "most of the physical system having a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00037-00011056-00011342": "definite input to the systems", "3ffUK-KODfg-00038-00011343-00011663": "agree so that constraints are given", "3ffUK-KODfg-00039-00011664-00011927": "maximum value of input to the plant u", "3ffUK-KODfg-00040-00011928-00012199": "max and minimum value of the plant is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00041-00012200-00012351": "you mean", "3ffUK-KODfg-00042-00012352-00012591": "again generally this upper and lower", "3ffUK-KODfg-00043-00012592-00012838": "limit are same with", "3ffUK-KODfg-00044-00012839-00013111": "the positive sign and negative sign this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00045-00013112-00013199": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00046-00013200-00013455": "so our problem statement is like this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00047-00013456-00013719": "way it is desired to apply an optimal", "3ffUK-KODfg-00048-00013719-00013830": "control", "3ffUK-KODfg-00049-00013831-00013991": "input u star", "3ffUK-KODfg-00050-00013991-00014263": "that satisfy the constraint and now in", "3ffUK-KODfg-00051-00014263-00014415": "case of this alpha one we have", "3ffUK-KODfg-00052-00014416-00014799": "constrained the one unit u of input", "3ffUK-KODfg-00053-00014800-00015047": "for all the input i is equal to one to m", "3ffUK-KODfg-00054-00015047-00015294": "m is the number of inputs", "3ffUK-KODfg-00055-00015295-00015615": "drives the state of the system initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-00056-00015616-00016047": "state x 0 to the desired final state x f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00057-00016047-00016294": "agree in a minimum time", "3ffUK-KODfg-00058-00016295-00016503": "so our performing index is this this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00059-00016504-00016711": "performing index we have to minimize", "3ffUK-KODfg-00060-00016712-00016839": "that means we have to find out the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00061-00016840-00017086": "minimum value of the time t f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00062-00017087-00017327": "for that one and that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00063-00017328-00017719": "is been solved by using what is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-00064-00017720-00017807": "pre", "3ffUK-KODfg-00065-00017808-00018158": "pontagion principle minimum principle p", "3ffUK-KODfg-00066-00018159-00018367": "m p", "3ffUK-KODfg-00067-00018368-00018727": "and when the x one our terminal state or", "3ffUK-KODfg-00068-00018728-00018999": "the final state is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00069-00019000-00019199": "at the origin we want to drive the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00070-00019200-00019422": "initial state to the origin then the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00071-00019423-00019599": "problem is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-00072-00019600-00019975": "optimal time optimal regulator problems", "3ffUK-KODfg-00073-00019976-00020191": "so that this is our problem statement", "3ffUK-KODfg-00074-00020192-00020447": "was that and we have shown it last class", "3ffUK-KODfg-00075-00020448-00020678": "and derived it how to approach this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00076-00020679-00020839": "by using the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00077-00020840-00021071": "pontian minimum principle", "3ffUK-KODfg-00078-00021072-00021511": "let us take our one example so that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00079-00021512-00021822": "we drive the state from initial state x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00080-00021823-00021958": "t 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00081-00021959-00022191": "u which is equal to x of 0 to the final", "3ffUK-KODfg-00082-00022192-00022286": "state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00083-00022287-00022407": "x t f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00084-00022408-00022847": "is equal to 0 in a minimum time t f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00085-00022848-00023094": "by using what is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-00086-00023095-00023327": "switching the control law", "3ffUK-KODfg-00087-00023328-00023558": "in two state either plus one or minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00088-00023559-00023639": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00089-00023640-00023878": "so that is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-00090-00023879-00024078": "bank bank control", "3ffUK-KODfg-00091-00024079-00024222": "bank", "3ffUK-KODfg-00092-00024223-00024422": "bank", "3ffUK-KODfg-00093-00024423-00024919": "control", "3ffUK-KODfg-00094-00024920-00025183": "so what is bank bank control a control", "3ffUK-KODfg-00095-00025184-00025758": "signal", "3ffUK-KODfg-00096-00025760-00026046": "which always takes", "3ffUK-KODfg-00097-00026047-00026183": "which", "3ffUK-KODfg-00098-00026183-00026683": "always", "3ffUK-KODfg-00099-00026683-00026855": "take", "3ffUK-KODfg-00100-00026856-00027062": "its", "3ffUK-KODfg-00101-00027063-00027439": "maximum", "3ffUK-KODfg-00102-00027439-00027943": "we always takes its maximum", "3ffUK-KODfg-00103-00027944-00028079": "or", "3ffUK-KODfg-00104-00028080-00028974": "minimum value", "3ffUK-KODfg-00105-00028975-00029279": "with", "3ffUK-KODfg-00106-00029280-00029774": "finitely", "3ffUK-KODfg-00107-00029775-00029967": "many", "3ffUK-KODfg-00108-00029968-00030574": "switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-00109-00030575-00031023": "between", "3ffUK-KODfg-00110-00031024-00031183": "them", "3ffUK-KODfg-00111-00031183-00031383": "between them minimum minimum and maximum", "3ffUK-KODfg-00112-00031383-00031599": "value between them", "3ffUK-KODfg-00113-00031600-00031990": "is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-00114-00031991-00032095": "a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00115-00032095-00032887": "bank bank control", "3ffUK-KODfg-00116-00032888-00033183": "so the two maximum minimum state is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00117-00033184-00033367": "there for a controlling either you", "3ffUK-KODfg-00118-00033368-00033495": "switch on", "3ffUK-KODfg-00119-00033496-00033599": "plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00120-00033600-00033846": "or you switch on minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00121-00033847-00034087": "and the state will drive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00122-00034088-00034231": "from initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-00123-00034232-00034423": "this control action will drive the state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00124-00034424-00034695": "from initial state x t is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00125-00034696-00035046": "to the final state x t f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00126-00035047-00035246": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00127-00035247-00035543": "zero when at the origin in minimum time", "3ffUK-KODfg-00128-00035544-00035911": "t f for any initial condition", "3ffUK-KODfg-00129-00035912-00036183": "x zero to a final state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00130-00036184-00036383": "x t f is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00131-00036384-00036711": "will drive the initial state to 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00132-00036712-00036823": "by", "3ffUK-KODfg-00133-00036824-00037007": "proper sequence of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00134-00037008-00037271": "control actions that means either you", "3ffUK-KODfg-00135-00037272-00037543": "switch on to plus 1 or minus 1 in this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00136-00037544-00037783": "way and many times you have to do", "3ffUK-KODfg-00137-00037784-00038079": "depending upon the order of the systems", "3ffUK-KODfg-00138-00038080-00038351": "so let us take in one example", "3ffUK-KODfg-00139-00038352-00038462": "and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00140-00038463-00038607": "illustrate", "3ffUK-KODfg-00141-00038608-00038807": "the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00142-00038808-00039030": "problem the minimum time", "3ffUK-KODfg-00143-00039031-00039215": "optimum control problems", "3ffUK-KODfg-00144-00039216-00039283": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00145-00039284-00039646": "given the dynamic system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00146-00039647-00040183": "is given the system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00147-00040184-00040446": "whose dynamics are expressed in this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00148-00040447-00040543": "form", "3ffUK-KODfg-00149-00040544-00040751": "that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00150-00040752-00040983": "x one dot of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00151-00040984-00041151": "there are two state let us call we", "3ffUK-KODfg-00152-00041152-00041255": "consider", "3ffUK-KODfg-00153-00041256-00041495": "the second order system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00154-00041496-00041711": "which is expressed in time domain and in", "3ffUK-KODfg-00155-00041712-00041974": "general we write x dot of t which has a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00156-00041975-00042302": "two states are there dimension of this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00157-00042303-00042439": "equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00158-00042440-00042607": "it is given at", "3ffUK-KODfg-00159-00042608-00042695": "0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00160-00042696-00042790": "1", "3ffUK-KODfg-00161-00042791-00043079": "0 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00162-00043080-00043239": "and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00163-00043240-00043495": "there is a x 1 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00164-00043496-00043711": "x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00165-00043712-00043846": "and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00166-00043847-00044030": "that is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00167-00044031-00044127": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00168-00044128-00044335": "of u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00169-00044336-00044655": "so our equation is this is a matrix this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00170-00044656-00044983": "is a state vector this is the b matrix", "3ffUK-KODfg-00171-00044984-00045230": "if it is single input we write generally", "3ffUK-KODfg-00172-00045231-00045367": "small b", "3ffUK-KODfg-00173-00045368-00045558": "and this is the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00174-00045559-00045679": "u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00175-00045680-00045927": "and if it is multi input capital b and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00176-00045928-00046207": "capital u this so this is our dynamic", "3ffUK-KODfg-00177-00046208-00046343": "equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00178-00046344-00046583": "with the performing index", "3ffUK-KODfg-00179-00046584-00047471": "with the performing index", "3ffUK-KODfg-00180-00047472-00047807": "j is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00181-00047808-00048262": "t 0 to t f t 0 is equal to 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00182-00048263-00048423": "and d t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00183-00048424-00048718": "which is nothing but a t f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00184-00048719-00048895": "therefore that means we have to minimize", "3ffUK-KODfg-00185-00048896-00049118": "that performing index", "3ffUK-KODfg-00186-00049119-00049239": "with the performance", "3ffUK-KODfg-00187-00049240-00049486": "minimize the performance index with", "3ffUK-KODfg-00188-00049487-00049886": "minimize the performing index", "3ffUK-KODfg-00189-00049887-00050158": "this upper bound mean", "3ffUK-KODfg-00190-00050159-00050830": "this performance index is minimized", "3ffUK-KODfg-00191-00050831-00051118": "not only minimize with the constraint", "3ffUK-KODfg-00192-00051119-00051494": "control input constant", "3ffUK-KODfg-00193-00051495-00051670": "mod of this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00194-00051671-00051887": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00195-00051888-00052175": "less than equal to one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00196-00052176-00052414": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-00197-00052415-00052687": "and this constant means", "3ffUK-KODfg-00198-00052688-00052975": "that our control input", "3ffUK-KODfg-00199-00052976-00053182": "is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00200-00053183-00053991": "plus one to minus one this constraint", "3ffUK-KODfg-00201-00053991-00054230": "means", "3ffUK-KODfg-00202-00054232-00054382": "that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00203-00054383-00054566": "the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00204-00054567-00055063": "control", "3ffUK-KODfg-00205-00055064-00055366": "input", "3ffUK-KODfg-00206-00055367-00055854": "must be", "3ffUK-KODfg-00207-00055855-00056038": "must be", "3ffUK-KODfg-00208-00056039-00056742": "controlled input magnitude", "3ffUK-KODfg-00209-00056744-00056982": "must be", "3ffUK-KODfg-00210-00056983-00057166": "within", "3ffUK-KODfg-00211-00057167-00057399": "one or not greater than one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00212-00057400-00057735": "must be within", "3ffUK-KODfg-00213-00057736-00057863": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00214-00057864-00058126": "or", "3ffUK-KODfg-00215-00058127-00058463": "not", "3ffUK-KODfg-00216-00058464-00058935": "greater than", "3ffUK-KODfg-00217-00058936-00059047": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00218-00059048-00059254": "this is one means this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00219-00059255-00059463": "that is our problem", "3ffUK-KODfg-00220-00059464-00059735": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00221-00059736-00061038": "so how to solve this problem", "3ffUK-KODfg-00222-00061039-00061175": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00223-00061176-00061694": "our basic problem is our problem", "3ffUK-KODfg-00224-00061695-00062182": "is to transfer", "3ffUK-KODfg-00225-00062183-00062550": "the state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00226-00062551-00062742": "x of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00227-00062744-00063071": "t 0 initial state transfer the initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-00228-00063072-00063247": "you can write it initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-00229-00063248-00063423": "state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00230-00063424-00063623": "state x 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00231-00063624-00063799": "to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00232-00063800-00064023": "x of 0 is this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00233-00064024-00064135": "2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00234-00064136-00064663": "the final state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00235-00064664-00064838": "x of t f", "3ffUK-KODfg-00236-00064839-00065006": "is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00237-00065007-00065326": "means origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-00238-00065327-00066055": "in minimum time", "3ffUK-KODfg-00239-00066056-00066294": "when t f must be minimum", "3ffUK-KODfg-00240-00066295-00066455": "so if you recall", "3ffUK-KODfg-00241-00066456-00066775": "it just take given the system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00242-00066776-00066926": "our problem is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00243-00066927-00067199": "to transfer the state initial state to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00244-00067200-00067519": "the final state t axle tf to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00245-00067520-00067719": "0 means origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-00246-00067720-00067943": "in a minimum time by", "3ffUK-KODfg-00247-00067944-00068182": "minimizing this performing index not", "3ffUK-KODfg-00248-00068183-00068287": "only that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00249-00068288-00068511": "subject to constrain control input", "3ffUK-KODfg-00250-00068512-00068750": "constraint that magnitude of u", "3ffUK-KODfg-00251-00068751-00069079": "cannot be greater than one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00252-00069080-00069438": "or within one so that is one so the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00253-00069439-00069655": "solution of the problem", "3ffUK-KODfg-00254-00069656-00069815": "if you follow the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00255-00069816-00070055": "what we have discussed last class first", "3ffUK-KODfg-00256-00070056-00070367": "you form a hamiltonian matrix", "3ffUK-KODfg-00257-00070368-00070703": "that our performance index if you see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00258-00070704-00070799": "that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00259-00070800-00070894": "in", "3ffUK-KODfg-00260-00070895-00071150": "integer part is one coefficient of this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00261-00071151-00071271": "is one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00262-00071272-00071455": "so one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00263-00071456-00071623": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00264-00071624-00071926": "lambda transpose of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00265-00071927-00072087": "into", "3ffUK-KODfg-00266-00072088-00072294": "a of x t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00267-00072295-00072415": "plus b", "3ffUK-KODfg-00268-00072416-00072567": "u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00269-00072568-00072775": "that is our this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00270-00072776-00072926": "and let us write", "3ffUK-KODfg-00271-00072927-00073062": "since we have a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00272-00073063-00073287": "number of states is two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00273-00073288-00073655": "so the dimension of lambda is also", "3ffUK-KODfg-00274-00073656-00073959": "two row one column so it is a transpose", "3ffUK-KODfg-00275-00073960-00074167": "so if i write the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00276-00074168-00074550": "each element of lambda lambda 1 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00277-00074551-00074879": "partition lambda 2 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00278-00074880-00075191": "right corresponding matrix a b", "3ffUK-KODfg-00279-00075192-00075511": "in this expression so our a matrix is if", "3ffUK-KODfg-00280-00075512-00075638": "you see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00281-00075639-00075943": "the our ecmo recommend is 0 1", "3ffUK-KODfg-00282-00075944-00076119": "0 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00283-00076120-00076550": "multiplied by x x means x 1 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00284-00076551-00076838": "and x 2 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00285-00076839-00077294": "so multiplied by b b is 0 1", "3ffUK-KODfg-00286-00077295-00077671": "then u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00287-00077672-00077862": "so now you simplify this one if you", "3ffUK-KODfg-00288-00077863-00078255": "simplify this one you will get it 1 plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00289-00078256-00078526": "lambda 1 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00290-00078527-00078799": "lambda 2 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00291-00078800-00079071": "then this into this this into this so it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00292-00079072-00079182": "will be a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00293-00079183-00079335": "x 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00294-00079336-00079503": "of this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00295-00079504-00079782": "and this into this this into this 0 plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00296-00079783-00080047": "u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00297-00080048-00080167": "so that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00298-00080168-00080335": "which is nothing but a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00299-00080336-00080782": "further expanding this one lambda 1 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00300-00080783-00080903": "x 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00301-00080904-00081023": "of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00302-00081024-00081282": "plus lambda 2 of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00303-00081283-00081455": "t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00304-00081456-00081638": "u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00305-00081639-00081894": "let us call this equation is one now see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00306-00081895-00082135": "there hamiltonian matrix", "3ffUK-KODfg-00307-00082136-00082271": "that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00308-00082272-00082615": "is a linear function in u", "3ffUK-KODfg-00309-00082616-00082950": "and not only that you can if you use the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00310-00082951-00083294": "what is called pontigen", "3ffUK-KODfg-00311-00083295-00083559": "minimum principle then this function", "3ffUK-KODfg-00312-00083560-00083767": "will be minimum when", "3ffUK-KODfg-00313-00083768-00083847": "this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00314-00083848-00084126": "value of this one is minimum so that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00315-00084127-00084479": "only possible by selecting the value of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00316-00084480-00084647": "u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00317-00084648-00084894": "with the knowledge of lambda of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00318-00084895-00085103": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00319-00085104-00085311": "the co state vector", "3ffUK-KODfg-00320-00085312-00085759": "the co state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00321-00085760-00086287": "equation or vector", "3ffUK-KODfg-00322-00086288-00086543": "r", "3ffUK-KODfg-00323-00086544-00086703": "so co state", "3ffUK-KODfg-00324-00086704-00086887": "equation r a what is the cost error", "3ffUK-KODfg-00325-00086888-00087135": "lambda dot is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00326-00087136-00087406": "lambda dot of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00327-00087407-00087750": "is equal to minus del h", "3ffUK-KODfg-00328-00087751-00087975": "del x of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00329-00087976-00088182": "that is our basic equation that we have", "3ffUK-KODfg-00330-00088183-00088382": "seen from calculus of variation how to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00331-00088383-00088494": "optimize", "3ffUK-KODfg-00332-00088495-00088823": "the dynamic systems this is the things", "3ffUK-KODfg-00333-00088824-00088918": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00334-00088919-00089175": "this x has a dimension of two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00335-00089176-00089438": "so lambda also dimension of two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00336-00089439-00089662": "so this we can write it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00337-00089663-00089838": "further we can write it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00338-00089839-00090006": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00339-00090007-00090223": "c h function", "3ffUK-KODfg-00340-00090224-00090406": "i have to differentiate with respect to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00341-00090407-00090687": "x so there is no x term involved in the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00342-00090688-00091126": "expression one so that will be a zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00343-00091127-00091399": "then differentiate this grain of the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00344-00091400-00091638": "this with respect to x two so this is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00345-00091639-00091926": "the only term is there so it is lambda", "3ffUK-KODfg-00346-00091927-00092071": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00347-00092072-00092303": "so lambda one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00348-00092304-00092391": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00349-00092392-00092638": "the co state vector expression is this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00350-00092639-00092743": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00351-00092744-00092911": "and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00352-00092912-00093094": "we can write it because it has a two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00353-00093095-00093318": "components and that two components is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00354-00093319-00093487": "lambda one dot", "3ffUK-KODfg-00355-00093488-00093782": "is equal to zero another is lambda two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00356-00093783-00093879": "dot", "3ffUK-KODfg-00357-00093880-00094126": "is equal to minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00358-00094127-00094367": "lambda one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00359-00094368-00094638": "so let us call this equation is two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00360-00094639-00094887": "and this equation is three", "3ffUK-KODfg-00361-00094888-00095199": "so we can easily solve the equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00362-00095200-00095391": "two and three", "3ffUK-KODfg-00363-00095392-00095726": "in general even if you get the what is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00364-00095727-00095815": "called", "3ffUK-KODfg-00365-00095816-00096015": "the matrix is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00366-00096016-00096271": "not a special structure in all elements", "3ffUK-KODfg-00367-00096272-00096623": "are there we know how to solve the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00368-00096624-00096767": "what is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-00369-00096768-00097079": "state equation here also we will come", "3ffUK-KODfg-00370-00097080-00097326": "this type of equation and we know how to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00371-00097327-00097631": "this x dot is equal to something like ax", "3ffUK-KODfg-00372-00097632-00097887": "form you will get it you can solve so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00373-00097888-00098055": "looking from this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00374-00098056-00098382": "i can write it first see from equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00375-00098383-00098615": "two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00376-00098616-00099111": "from two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00377-00099112-00099294": "what you can write it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00378-00099295-00099662": "integrate that one with respect to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00379-00099663-00099759": "that is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00380-00099760-00099967": "delta one is nothing but a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00381-00099968-00100199": "delta one dot is you know lambda lambda", "3ffUK-KODfg-00382-00100200-00100511": "one dot is nothing but a this thing", "3ffUK-KODfg-00383-00100512-00100823": "so this equal to zero so now this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00384-00100824-00101271": "implies that lambda one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00385-00101272-00101535": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00386-00101536-00101974": "lambda one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00387-00101975-00102215": "let us call this equation is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00388-00102216-00102518": "equation number four", "3ffUK-KODfg-00389-00102519-00102727": "so you take this that side then", "3ffUK-KODfg-00390-00102728-00102958": "integrate from zero to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00391-00102959-00103030": "t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00392-00103031-00103334": "so say that will come lambda one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00393-00103335-00103575": "minus lambda one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00394-00103576-00103958": "and right hand side is zero so this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00395-00103959-00104134": "is the expression", "3ffUK-KODfg-00396-00104135-00104406": "and use this expression in equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00397-00104407-00104558": "three", "3ffUK-KODfg-00398-00104559-00105054": "from equation three", "3ffUK-KODfg-00399-00105055-00105278": "lambda two dot", "3ffUK-KODfg-00400-00105279-00105375": "of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00401-00105376-00105590": "is equal to minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00402-00105591-00105815": "lambda one of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00403-00105816-00106143": "t which is equal to minus lambda one of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00404-00106144-00106263": "zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00405-00106264-00106439": "lambda one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00406-00106440-00106823": "is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00407-00106824-00107039": "replacing this is that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00408-00107040-00107310": "so what is the solution of that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00409-00107311-00107558": "the solution of that one i can get it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00410-00107559-00107695": "lambda", "3ffUK-KODfg-00411-00107696-00107895": "2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00412-00107896-00108271": "of t or you write it this lambda t of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00413-00108272-00108686": "del d of t is equal to minus lambda 1 of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00414-00108688-00108783": "0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00415-00108783-00108902": "this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00416-00108903-00109151": "so now take dt this is and then", "3ffUK-KODfg-00417-00109152-00109399": "integrate from 0 to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00418-00109400-00109478": "t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00419-00109479-00109671": "so this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00420-00109672-00109966": "this shows that lambda sorry", "3ffUK-KODfg-00421-00109967-00110134": "lambda 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00422-00110135-00110254": "of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00423-00110255-00110551": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00424-00110552-00110719": "minus lambda", "3ffUK-KODfg-00425-00110720-00111031": "1 of 0 into t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00426-00111032-00111278": "and lower limit t is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00427-00111279-00111583": "0 so this term will not be there then", "3ffUK-KODfg-00428-00111583-00111815": "another term is there lambda 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00429-00111816-00111975": "of 0.", "3ffUK-KODfg-00430-00111976-00112286": "so this is our solution of that lambda 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00431-00112288-00112527": "expression", "3ffUK-KODfg-00432-00112528-00112790": "so this expression let us call this is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00433-00112791-00113127": "equation number 5", "3ffUK-KODfg-00434-00113128-00113278": "ok", "3ffUK-KODfg-00435-00113279-00113383": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00436-00113383-00113871": "from 4 and 5 i can now", "3ffUK-KODfg-00437-00113872-00114063": "say", "3ffUK-KODfg-00438-00114064-00114271": "from equation from equation one it means", "3ffUK-KODfg-00439-00114272-00114527": "hamiltonian equation h of from equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00440-00114528-00114623": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00441-00114624-00114815": "this equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00442-00114816-00114966": "one plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00443-00114967-00115166": "lambda 1 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00444-00115167-00115407": "into x of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00445-00115408-00115519": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00446-00115520-00115727": "lambda 2 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00447-00115728-00116023": "into u of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00448-00116024-00116247": "so using", "3ffUK-KODfg-00449-00116248-00116447": "quantity and minimum principle", "3ffUK-KODfg-00450-00116448-00116551": "i can", "3ffUK-KODfg-00451-00116552-00116639": "say", "3ffUK-KODfg-00452-00116640-00116951": "that when lambda 2 is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00453-00116952-00117166": "u 2 is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00454-00117167-00117390": "we will consider then this function", "3ffUK-KODfg-00455-00117391-00117566": "value will be minimum", "3ffUK-KODfg-00456-00117567-00117831": "then when lambda 2 is negative u 2 value", "3ffUK-KODfg-00457-00117832-00118031": "is positive so what we write in the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00458-00118032-00118366": "optimal value of this u star of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00459-00118367-00118583": "is equal to 1", "3ffUK-KODfg-00460-00118583-00118695": "if", "3ffUK-KODfg-00461-00118696-00118886": "lambda 2 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00462-00118888-00119102": "is less than 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00463-00119103-00119366": "and that equal to minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00464-00119367-00119463": "if", "3ffUK-KODfg-00465-00119464-00119647": "lambda two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00466-00119648-00120007": "is greater than one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00467-00120008-00120231": "so it is just switching depending upon", "3ffUK-KODfg-00468-00120232-00120486": "the value of lambda two of t and lambda", "3ffUK-KODfg-00469-00120488-00120766": "two of t expression is this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00470-00120767-00120975": "the unfortunate part of this one we do", "3ffUK-KODfg-00471-00120976-00121223": "not know what is lambda 1 of 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00472-00121224-00121471": "and lambda 2 of 0.", "3ffUK-KODfg-00473-00121472-00121614": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00474-00121615-00121966": "this 2 equation we can", "3ffUK-KODfg-00475-00121967-00122247": "write in mathematical form by using the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00476-00122248-00122414": "signum functions", "3ffUK-KODfg-00477-00122415-00122566": "sine function sorry", "3ffUK-KODfg-00478-00122567-00122902": "sine function u star of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00479-00122903-00123047": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00480-00123048-00123214": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00481-00123215-00123566": "sine", "3ffUK-KODfg-00482-00123567-00123647": "of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00483-00123648-00124263": "lambda 2 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00484-00124264-00124527": "again", "3ffUK-KODfg-00485-00124528-00124695": "sine lambda after you know the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00486-00124696-00124927": "expression for lambda 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00487-00124928-00125190": "or sine", "3ffUK-KODfg-00488-00125191-00125423": "that lambda 2 expression is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00489-00125424-00125751": "that one lambda 1 lambda 2 of 0 minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00490-00125752-00125983": "lambda 1 of 0 into t so that i am", "3ffUK-KODfg-00491-00125983-00126078": "writing", "3ffUK-KODfg-00492-00126079-00126239": "lambda 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00493-00126240-00126334": "0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00494-00126335-00126519": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00495-00126520-00126719": "lambda 1 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00496-00126720-00126854": "into t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00497-00126855-00127078": "so this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00498-00127079-00127302": "so what is the sign function", "3ffUK-KODfg-00499-00127303-00127423": "i just", "3ffUK-KODfg-00500-00127424-00127823": "explained there is a sign of z", "3ffUK-KODfg-00501-00127824-00127934": "min", "3ffUK-KODfg-00502-00127935-00128014": "g", "3ffUK-KODfg-00503-00128015-00128183": "sign s i g n", "3ffUK-KODfg-00504-00128183-00128558": "s i g n", "3ffUK-KODfg-00505-00128559-00128943": "s i g n sign of z is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00506-00128944-00129158": "it is one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00507-00129159-00129366": "if", "3ffUK-KODfg-00508-00129367-00129495": "z", "3ffUK-KODfg-00509-00129496-00129734": "is greater than one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00510-00129735-00129975": "or sorry greater than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00511-00129976-00130263": "if it is minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00512-00130264-00130334": "if", "3ffUK-KODfg-00513-00130335-00130647": "z is less than zero so the sign function", "3ffUK-KODfg-00514-00130648-00130847": "sign of z", "3ffUK-KODfg-00515-00130848-00131014": "value will be one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00516-00131015-00131278": "if z is greater than one value will be", "3ffUK-KODfg-00517-00131279-00131502": "minus one if it is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00518-00131503-00131695": "less than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00519-00131696-00132007": "means negative so it is switching only u", "3ffUK-KODfg-00520-00132008-00132366": "is switching to plus one or minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00521-00132367-00132614": "so this quantity when it is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00522-00132615-00132927": "then u i am switching to a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00523-00132928-00133247": "minus one when this quantity is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00524-00133248-00133502": "negative that negative one one one plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00525-00133503-00133719": "i am switching to plus one so the our", "3ffUK-KODfg-00526-00133720-00134023": "control action is switching control law", "3ffUK-KODfg-00527-00134024-00134231": "either you i am switching to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00528-00134232-00134583": "plus one volt or minus one bolt or one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00529-00134584-00134943": "unit minus one unit", "3ffUK-KODfg-00530-00134944-00135199": "so it is something like sine function is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00531-00135200-00135311": "that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00532-00135312-00135559": "if you see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00533-00135560-00135766": "so let us call this is lambda two of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00534-00135767-00135854": "zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00535-00135855-00136135": "this is one u", "3ffUK-KODfg-00536-00136136-00136887": "of t this is minus one this is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00537-00136888-00137214": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00538-00137215-00137535": "now", "3ffUK-KODfg-00539-00137536-00137814": "look at this expression", "3ffUK-KODfg-00540-00137815-00138007": "when this is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00541-00138008-00138183": "u is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00542-00138184-00138319": "then", "3ffUK-KODfg-00543-00138320-00138543": "we are applying the voltage to the we", "3ffUK-KODfg-00544-00138544-00138799": "are applying the input to the system is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00545-00138800-00139031": "minus one and correspondingly system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00546-00139032-00139214": "dynamics will change", "3ffUK-KODfg-00547-00139215-00139487": "when this is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00548-00139488-00139711": "sign this negative sign of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00549-00139712-00139895": "this negative quantity is the negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00550-00139896-00140047": "negative negative positive that means we", "3ffUK-KODfg-00551-00140048-00140239": "are applying positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00552-00140240-00140566": "control signal voltage or signal", "3ffUK-KODfg-00553-00140567-00140887": "ok so again the system dynamics will", "3ffUK-KODfg-00554-00140888-00141231": "change it so now see one by one what we", "3ffUK-KODfg-00555-00141232-00141383": "are doing now", "3ffUK-KODfg-00556-00141384-00141543": "if", "3ffUK-KODfg-00557-00141544-00141783": "u star of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00558-00141784-00141911": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00559-00141912-00142095": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00560-00142096-00142326": "e star t u is one when", "3ffUK-KODfg-00561-00142327-00142543": "this quantity is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00562-00142544-00142766": "negative then sine of negative quantity", "3ffUK-KODfg-00563-00142767-00143087": "is minus sign that by definition of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00564-00143088-00143335": "so if it is one let us see our", "3ffUK-KODfg-00565-00143336-00143583": "corresponding dynamic equation of the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00566-00143584-00143726": "system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00567-00143727-00144287": "x one dot is equal to x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00568-00144288-00144735": "okay then x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00569-00144736-00145014": "then x two dot", "3ffUK-KODfg-00570-00145015-00145175": "x two dot", "3ffUK-KODfg-00571-00145176-00145278": "of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00572-00145279-00145423": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00573-00145424-00145719": "one because x two dot is equal to u u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00574-00145720-00145943": "equal to one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00575-00145944-00146199": "so now what is the solution of this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00576-00146200-00146366": "the solution of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00577-00146367-00146678": "x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00578-00146679-00146863": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00579-00146864-00147054": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00580-00147055-00147375": "this is d t t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00581-00147376-00147502": "t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00582-00147503-00147623": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00583-00147624-00147975": "x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00584-00147976-00148159": "so this is our", "3ffUK-KODfg-00585-00148160-00148399": "solution of x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00586-00148400-00148663": "so if you put in this expression", "3ffUK-KODfg-00587-00148664-00148943": "that x one of dot of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00588-00148944-00149119": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00589-00149120-00149478": "x two which you can write it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00590-00149479-00149887": "x two zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00591-00149888-00150095": "x two zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00592-00150096-00150487": "plus t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00593-00150488-00150775": "so now what is the solution of that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00594-00150776-00151102": "solution of this one x one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00595-00151103-00151295": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00596-00151296-00151559": "that x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00597-00151560-00151799": "into t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00598-00151800-00151895": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-00599-00151896-00152111": "because this lower limit is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00600-00152112-00152287": "and upper limit is t so it will be", "3ffUK-KODfg-00601-00152288-00152390": "coming t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00602-00152391-00152631": "so this one is t square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00603-00152632-00152743": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00604-00152744-00152999": "upper limit is t and lonely minimum that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00605-00153000-00153207": "lower limit term will not come from this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00606-00153208-00153359": "indication part", "3ffUK-KODfg-00607-00153360-00153575": "so plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00608-00153576-00153775": "x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00609-00153776-00154095": "so this is our solution of that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00610-00154096-00154335": "that x one you can write it x one of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00611-00154336-00154423": "zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00612-00154424-00154526": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00613-00154527-00154735": "x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00614-00154736-00154854": "into t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00615-00154855-00155231": "plus t square by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00616-00155232-00155454": "so that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00617-00155455-00155583": "now", "3ffUK-KODfg-00618-00155584-00155799": "this i can write it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00619-00155800-00155975": "into a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00620-00155976-00156143": "say", "3ffUK-KODfg-00621-00156144-00156511": "what is x one of zero i am writing this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00622-00156512-00156831": "plus x two of zero the initial condition", "3ffUK-KODfg-00623-00156832-00157095": "of this state and t what you can write", "3ffUK-KODfg-00624-00157096-00157375": "it from this expression you see t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00625-00157376-00157519": "t is what", "3ffUK-KODfg-00626-00157520-00157599": "x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00627-00157600-00157726": "t of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00628-00157727-00157983": "minus x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00629-00157984-00158271": "is equal to t is equal to this so put", "3ffUK-KODfg-00630-00158272-00158463": "the value of t here", "3ffUK-KODfg-00631-00158464-00158639": "that x t of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00632-00158640-00158831": "x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00633-00158832-00159078": "minus x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00634-00159079-00159223": "this is that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00635-00159224-00159663": "put the value of this that is x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00636-00159664-00160007": "minus x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00637-00160008-00160439": "whole square divided by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00638-00160440-00160702": "now if you simplify that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00639-00160703-00160966": "because just you simplify this one then", "3ffUK-KODfg-00640-00160967-00161311": "this equation ultimately you see this x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00641-00161312-00161502": "two square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00642-00161503-00161719": "x two a minus b whole square x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00643-00161720-00162047": "square by two so it will come x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00644-00162048-00162319": "square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00645-00162320-00162535": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00646-00162536-00162783": "and plus x two square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00647-00162784-00162911": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00648-00162912-00163126": "and here will x two square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00649-00163127-00163654": "only so it will be minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00650-00163655-00163895": "x two square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00651-00163896-00164111": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00652-00164112-00164254": "then twice", "3ffUK-KODfg-00653-00164255-00164478": "x two x zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00654-00164479-00164702": "x two x zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00655-00164703-00165014": "so that is one x two x zero here", "3ffUK-KODfg-00656-00165015-00165526": "so that will be plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00657-00165527-00165743": "x two x zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00658-00165744-00165919": "so let us write it that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00659-00165920-00166231": "next is this term is there x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00660-00166232-00166414": "i can write it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00661-00166415-00166502": "now", "3ffUK-KODfg-00662-00166503-00166951": "see this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00663-00166952-00167214": "so that will be a this into this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00664-00167215-00167447": "so minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00665-00167448-00167743": "this into this the minus x 2 square but", "3ffUK-KODfg-00666-00167744-00168078": "here is half so minus is coming", "3ffUK-KODfg-00667-00168079-00168263": "then x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00668-00168264-00168454": "zero into x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00669-00168455-00168543": "t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00670-00168544-00168663": "here is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00671-00168664-00168823": "twice", "3ffUK-KODfg-00672-00168824-00169166": "x two zero into x t divided by two so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00673-00169167-00169278": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00674-00169279-00169559": "so that will be cancel out so ultimately", "3ffUK-KODfg-00675-00169560-00169799": "we will get it this expression after", "3ffUK-KODfg-00676-00169800-00170111": "simplifying this one so active square by", "3ffUK-KODfg-00677-00170112-00170207": "two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00678-00170208-00170359": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00679-00170360-00170654": "x two square by zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00680-00170655-00170883": "and x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00681-00170884-00171151": "for u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00682-00171152-00171390": "plus one positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00683-00171391-00171599": "this let us call this equation what is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00684-00171600-00171807": "the equation we have come across up to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00685-00171808-00172190": "five last equation is up to five", "3ffUK-KODfg-00686-00172191-00172407": "this equation we have up to five so let", "3ffUK-KODfg-00687-00172408-00172702": "us call this equation is six", "3ffUK-KODfg-00688-00172703-00172919": "this is equation number six", "3ffUK-KODfg-00689-00172920-00173047": "similarly", "3ffUK-KODfg-00690-00173048-00173238": "we will see when we will apply you see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00691-00173239-00173423": "the dynamics of the closed", "3ffUK-KODfg-00692-00173424-00173623": "the solution or response of the system", "3ffUK-KODfg-00693-00173624-00173919": "is this when you put the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00694-00173920-00174190": "value of input is minus because control", "3ffUK-KODfg-00695-00174191-00174495": "action is applied different minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00696-00174496-00174687": "then what is the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00697-00174688-00174990": "solution or the trajectory of x one and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00698-00174991-00175175": "x two you see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00699-00175176-00175375": "for", "3ffUK-KODfg-00700-00175376-00175551": "u star", "3ffUK-KODfg-00701-00175552-00175663": "of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00702-00175664-00175847": "is equal to negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00703-00175848-00176999": "the state equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00704-00177000-00177390": "is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00705-00177391-00177614": "x one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00706-00177615-00177911": "is equal to x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00707-00177912-00178143": "that equation r", "3ffUK-KODfg-00708-00178144-00178519": "this is one another is x two dot of t is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00709-00178520-00178838": "equal to u and u is minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00710-00178839-00179031": "similarly i can find out what is the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00711-00179032-00179295": "value of x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00712-00179296-00179535": "by solving simple different integrating", "3ffUK-KODfg-00713-00179536-00179695": "both side", "3ffUK-KODfg-00714-00179696-00179959": "and taking the limit t is equal to 0 to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00715-00179960-00180111": "t is equal to t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00716-00180112-00180399": "so this equal to your will be", "3ffUK-KODfg-00717-00180400-00180631": "x 2 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00718-00180632-00180726": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-00719-00180727-00181007": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00720-00181008-00181502": "x to zero minus t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00721-00181503-00181726": "so this is the solution of this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00722-00181727-00181926": "then what is this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00723-00181927-00182071": "x one t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00724-00182072-00182278": "dot is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00725-00182279-00182447": "x 2 t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00726-00182448-00182814": "and what is x 2 t is nothing but x of 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00727-00182815-00182975": "minus t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00728-00182976-00183263": "now you integrate this both side and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00729-00183264-00183447": "with the lower and upper limit t is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00730-00183448-00183743": "equal to 0 to t is equal to t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00731-00183744-00184023": "then you will get x one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00732-00184024-00184295": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00733-00184296-00184535": "that x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00734-00184536-00184702": "then it will come", "3ffUK-KODfg-00735-00184703-00184943": "plus x two of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00736-00184944-00185135": "0 into t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00737-00185136-00185559": "then t square by 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-00738-00185560-00185950": "now let us call this equation is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00739-00185951-00186254": "ok we will not now put the value of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00740-00186255-00186463": "what is t expression", "3ffUK-KODfg-00741-00186464-00186878": "t is equal to you can write it x 2 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00742-00186879-00186983": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00743-00186984-00187190": "x 2 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00744-00187191-00187407": "that is our", "3ffUK-KODfg-00745-00187408-00187614": "expression for t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00746-00187615-00187966": "x 2 0 minus x two of t so put this value", "3ffUK-KODfg-00747-00187967-00188078": "here", "3ffUK-KODfg-00748-00188079-00188254": "x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00749-00188255-00188502": "plus x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00750-00188503-00188719": "and the value of t is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00751-00188720-00188999": "just now here x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00752-00189000-00189366": "minus x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00753-00189367-00189550": "ok", "3ffUK-KODfg-00754-00189551-00189654": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00755-00189655-00189759": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00756-00189760-00189943": "t square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00757-00189944-00190143": "and x two of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00758-00190144-00190495": "minus x two of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00759-00190496-00190735": "whole square by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00760-00190736-00191007": "so after simplification this one as we", "3ffUK-KODfg-00761-00191008-00191254": "have discussed earlier that case you", "3ffUK-KODfg-00762-00191255-00191575": "will get it this value will get it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00763-00191576-00191943": "that x one of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00764-00191944-00192247": "that is x one of t you will get minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00765-00192248-00192471": "x two square of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00766-00192472-00192647": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00767-00192648-00192799": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00768-00192800-00193007": "x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00769-00193008-00193111": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00770-00193112-00193447": "x two square of two x two square of two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00771-00193448-00193607": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00772-00193608-00193895": "see the difference for", "3ffUK-KODfg-00773-00193896-00194166": "for u is equal to minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00774-00194167-00194319": "see the difference", "3ffUK-KODfg-00775-00194320-00194454": "this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00776-00194455-00194702": "if i write it in the same manner of that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00777-00194703-00194959": "one x one x two square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00778-00194960-00195271": "this expression you can say is nothing", "3ffUK-KODfg-00779-00195272-00195390": "but m", "3ffUK-KODfg-00780-00195391-00195575": "this one if i write", "3ffUK-KODfg-00781-00195576-00195887": "rewrite this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00782-00195888-00196054": "x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00783-00196055-00196383": "square of x two square of this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00784-00196384-00196543": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00785-00196544-00196831": "then", "3ffUK-KODfg-00786-00196832-00196999": "then this is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00787-00197000-00197175": "is a plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00788-00197176-00197614": "and i can rewrite it as a minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00789-00197615-00197750": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00790-00197751-00197926": "x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00791-00197927-00198111": "minus x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00792-00198112-00198263": "square of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00793-00198264-00198511": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00794-00198512-00198599": "ok", "3ffUK-KODfg-00795-00198600-00199023": "just if you see this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00796-00199024-00199223": "so this let us call this is equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00797-00199224-00199471": "number six this is equation number so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00798-00199472-00199678": "instead of this one this is six", "3ffUK-KODfg-00799-00199679-00199863": "now look this expression and this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00800-00199864-00200143": "expression this is equation number seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-00801-00200144-00200287": "so when", "3ffUK-KODfg-00802-00200288-00200535": "the control input u is applied the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00803-00200536-00200823": "solution of or trajectory of x one and x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00804-00200824-00201111": "two is how they differ this is x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00805-00201112-00201254": "square", "3ffUK-KODfg-00806-00201255-00201383": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00807-00201384-00201702": "so here is minus x two square by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00808-00201703-00201990": "then this constant term which depends on", "3ffUK-KODfg-00809-00201991-00202247": "the initial condition of the state this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00810-00202248-00202438": "x one zero plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00811-00202439-00202743": "x two square of two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00812-00202744-00203150": "agree so these are the two equation now", "3ffUK-KODfg-00813-00203151-00203495": "easily we can plot the trajectory of", "3ffUK-KODfg-00814-00203496-00203807": "what is called equation seven and eight", "3ffUK-KODfg-00815-00203808-00204063": "six and seven we can plot it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00816-00204064-00204335": "in phase plane there are two states are", "3ffUK-KODfg-00817-00204336-00204671": "there and we can plot it this and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00818-00204672-00204942": "basically this equation six and seven if", "3ffUK-KODfg-00819-00204944-00205062": "you look", "3ffUK-KODfg-00820-00205063-00205310": "equation six and seven is a parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-00821-00205311-00205486": "equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00822-00205487-00205686": "they both represent parabola equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00823-00205687-00205934": "depending upon the initial condition the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00824-00205935-00206038": "parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-00825-00206039-00206238": "will be different", "3ffUK-KODfg-00826-00206239-00206527": "but nature of this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00827-00206528-00206806": "in phase plane is a parabola so let us", "3ffUK-KODfg-00828-00206807-00207127": "see if we plotted this what what is the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00829-00207128-00207494": "nature of this curve we will get it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00830-00207496-00207894": "so from equation six and seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-00831-00207896-00208142": "from equation six", "3ffUK-KODfg-00832-00208144-00208423": "and seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-00833-00208423-00208975": "we have", "3ffUK-KODfg-00834-00208976-00209094": "one you see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00835-00209096-00209166": "x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00836-00209167-00209390": "two square of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00837-00209391-00209623": "divided by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00838-00209623-00209879": "six let us call this one i am writing", "3ffUK-KODfg-00839-00209880-00209998": "this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00840-00210000-00210679": "x two square of this is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00841-00210680-00210942": "this equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00842-00210944-00211127": "x 1 of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00843-00211128-00211263": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00844-00211264-00211967": "c 1.", "3ffUK-KODfg-00845-00211967-00212406": "agree where", "3ffUK-KODfg-00846-00212407-00212791": "c one is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00847-00212792-00213087": "c one is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00848-00213088-00213303": "say here", "3ffUK-KODfg-00849-00213304-00213527": "this i am keeping it is from equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00850-00213528-00213703": "this series this i am taking it this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00851-00213704-00214031": "whole thing i am considering as a c", "3ffUK-KODfg-00852-00214032-00214294": "so c one is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00853-00214296-00214487": "x 1 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00854-00214488-00214767": "minus x 2 square 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-00855-00214767-00215071": "by 2 so that is from equation 6 i am", "3ffUK-KODfg-00856-00215071-00215198": "writing", "3ffUK-KODfg-00857-00215200-00215503": "similarly from equation 7 i can write x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00858-00215504-00215734": "2 square of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-00859-00215735-00215855": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00860-00215856-00215998": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00861-00216000-00216287": "minus x one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00862-00216288-00216406": "plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00863-00216407-00216558": "c two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00864-00216559-00216742": "and where", "3ffUK-KODfg-00865-00216744-00217246": "c two is equal to c equation seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-00866-00217248-00217415": "this equation seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-00867-00217416-00217646": "if i take this is that side x square by", "3ffUK-KODfg-00868-00217648-00217982": "t s s square t of two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00869-00217983-00218206": "is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00870-00218207-00218527": "minus x one so and plus this is you", "3ffUK-KODfg-00871-00218528-00218782": "write it c two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00872-00218783-00219151": "and this is you write it c one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00873-00219152-00219382": "this is c one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00874-00219383-00219494": "ok", "3ffUK-KODfg-00875-00219496-00219582": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00876-00219583-00219734": "this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00877-00219735-00219967": "where c two is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00878-00219967-00220158": "x one of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00879-00220159-00220271": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00880-00220271-00220567": "plus x two square of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00881-00220567-00220806": "by two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00882-00220807-00221063": "so this is the two parabola equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00883-00221064-00221319": "the y square is equal to four a x plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00884-00221319-00221582": "some constant term when constant term is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00885-00221583-00221671": "there", "3ffUK-KODfg-00886-00221671-00221782": "that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00887-00221783-00221975": "what is is shifted to the right or left", "3ffUK-KODfg-00888-00221976-00222263": "of this one of the parabola so let us", "3ffUK-KODfg-00889-00222264-00222671": "see if you plot this one and this is for", "3ffUK-KODfg-00890-00222671-00222919": "this expression for u is equal to plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00891-00222919-00222991": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00892-00222992-00223327": "and this is is u is equal to minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00893-00223328-00223575": "this corresponding u is equal to minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00894-00223576-00223734": "one and this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00895-00223735-00224006": "corresponds this equation corresponds to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00896-00224007-00224479": "is equal to plus one um this equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-00897-00224480-00224782": "ok so let us plot it in phase plane so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00898-00224783-00225471": "there are two states are there", "3ffUK-KODfg-00899-00225471-00225694": "so x one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00900-00225696-00225927": "and x two i am showing here", "3ffUK-KODfg-00901-00225928-00226039": "x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00902-00226040-00226510": "and this is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00903-00226511-00226646": "let us call", "3ffUK-KODfg-00904-00226648-00226839": "c one is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00905-00226840-00227134": "that c one is zero then what is this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00906-00227135-00227358": "this is the equation of parabola when x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00907-00227359-00227663": "one is zero x two is also zero so it is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00908-00227664-00227887": "for a when x one is some positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00909-00227888-00228246": "quantity then x two is plus minus so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00910-00228248-00228479": "this nature of the curve is like this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00911-00228480-00229006": "way", "3ffUK-KODfg-00912-00229007-00229294": "okay and this is correspond to c one is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00913-00229296-00229463": "equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00914-00229464-00229934": "now tell me when c one is greater than", "3ffUK-KODfg-00915-00229935-00230263": "zero when c is greater than zero what", "3ffUK-KODfg-00916-00230264-00230382": "will be the", "3ffUK-KODfg-00917-00230383-00230775": "its nature of this curve when c two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00918-00230776-00230975": "c one is greater than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00919-00230976-00231423": "what will be this value so this value", "3ffUK-KODfg-00920-00231423-00231655": "now c one is greater than zero if it is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00921-00231656-00232910": "there this curve will be like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-00922-00232911-00233142": "so i am just writing in this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00923-00233144-00233239": "side", "3ffUK-KODfg-00924-00233240-00233567": "c one is greater than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00925-00233567-00233806": "but all these cases", "3ffUK-KODfg-00926-00233807-00234271": "u is c one get a u is plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00927-00234271-00234575": "and all these cases are u is you can", "3ffUK-KODfg-00928-00234576-00234775": "write it u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00929-00234776-00234951": "plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00930-00234952-00235151": "here also u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00931-00235152-00235310": "plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00932-00235311-00235582": "u is equal to u is equal to plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00933-00235583-00235758": "this c", "3ffUK-KODfg-00934-00235759-00236071": "now c one is less than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00935-00236071-00236398": "less than zero means", "3ffUK-KODfg-00936-00236400-00236591": "if you put it that side less than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00937-00236592-00236839": "is some value of x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00938-00236840-00236934": "that", "3ffUK-KODfg-00939-00236935-00238271": "this will be looks like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-00940-00238271-00238358": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00941-00238359-00238871": "in this side", "3ffUK-KODfg-00942-00238871-00239231": "c c one is equal to less than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00943-00239232-00239431": "and this is c one is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00944-00239432-00239639": "is this this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00945-00239640-00239894": "so this is corresponding to this all", "3ffUK-KODfg-00946-00239896-00240127": "these thing corresponding to u is equal", "3ffUK-KODfg-00947-00240128-00240367": "to plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00948-00240367-00240527": "now let us see", "3ffUK-KODfg-00949-00240528-00240791": "for this one when usual control input is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00950-00240792-00241039": "applied u is equal to minus one what is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00951-00241040-00241167": "this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00952-00241167-00241423": "you will get it", "3ffUK-KODfg-00953-00241423-00241775": "so again consider c c two is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00954-00241776-00241967": "if c two is zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00955-00241967-00242358": "if c two is zero then this is you see y", "3ffUK-KODfg-00956-00242359-00242655": "is equal to minus four a x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00957-00242656-00242742": "ok", "3ffUK-KODfg-00958-00242744-00243151": "when x is equal to x one is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-00959-00243152-00243471": "c two is zero when x one is equal to let", "3ffUK-KODfg-00960-00243471-00243751": "us call zero x two is zero so it will", "3ffUK-KODfg-00961-00243752-00243967": "start from this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00962-00243967-00244191": "when x one is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00963-00244192-00244471": "when x one is minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00964-00244471-00244719": "ok minus minus plus the x two is plus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00965-00244719-00244823": "minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-00966-00244823-00244903": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00967-00244904-00245151": "this will be a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00968-00245152-00245534": "curve b is like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-00969-00245535-00245694": "so this is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00970-00245696-00246030": "c two is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-00971-00246031-00246327": "again when c two is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00972-00246328-00246471": "positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00973-00246471-00246719": "when c two is proline tell me which side", "3ffUK-KODfg-00974-00246719-00246919": "i have to draw it that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00975-00246919-00247191": "c two is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00976-00247192-00247334": "but", "3ffUK-KODfg-00977-00247335-00247471": "x", "3ffUK-KODfg-00978-00247471-00247591": "x one", "3ffUK-KODfg-00979-00247592-00247798": "is negative c two is positive x one is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00980-00247800-00247975": "negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00981-00247976-00248151": "ok so this", "3ffUK-KODfg-00982-00248152-00248342": "so this will be a", "3ffUK-KODfg-00983-00248344-00248615": "because at same below of x the x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00984-00248616-00248806": "value will be more", "3ffUK-KODfg-00985-00248807-00248879": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-00986-00248880-00249023": "c two is", "3ffUK-KODfg-00987-00249023-00249158": "positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00988-00249159-00250446": "then our curve will be like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-00989-00250448-00250639": "so this side", "3ffUK-KODfg-00990-00250640-00250782": "c two", "3ffUK-KODfg-00991-00250783-00251110": "is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-00992-00251111-00251246": "and", "3ffUK-KODfg-00993-00251248-00251542": "now", "3ffUK-KODfg-00994-00251544-00251775": "c two is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00995-00251776-00251991": "c two is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00996-00251992-00252119": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-00997-00252119-00252239": "cto is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-00998-00252240-00252494": "and x two also negative so that value", "3ffUK-KODfg-00999-00252496-00253694": "will be below the c two curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01000-00253696-00253798": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01001-00253800-00254103": "this is a c two less than zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-01002-00254104-00254398": "and all this curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01003-00254400-00254551": "this curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01004-00254552-00254710": "u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01005-00254711-00254910": "minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01006-00254911-00255127": "this curve is u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01007-00255128-00255391": "minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01008-00255392-00255510": "okay", "3ffUK-KODfg-01009-00255511-00255606": "now", "3ffUK-KODfg-01010-00255607-00255871": "see our initial condition", "3ffUK-KODfg-01011-00255871-00256055": "now question is coming look at this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01012-00256056-00256375": "expression our initial condition can be", "3ffUK-KODfg-01013-00256376-00256671": "anywhere in the four quadrant", "3ffUK-KODfg-01014-00256671-00256830": "let us call our initial condition is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01015-00256831-00257046": "here i am just showing our initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-01016-00257048-00257351": "condition is here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01017-00257352-00257598": "x zero is here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01018-00257600-00257839": "then", "3ffUK-KODfg-01019-00257840-00258134": "what is the dynamic equation is that x 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-01020-00258135-00258342": "dot is equal to x 1", "3ffUK-KODfg-01021-00258344-00258510": "and x 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-01022-00258511-00258887": "sorry x x 1 dot is equal to x 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-01023-00258888-00259142": "x 1 dot is equal to x 2 and x 2 dot is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01024-00259144-00259255": "equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01025-00259256-00259663": "u and u value is your", "3ffUK-KODfg-01026-00259664-00259975": "maybe plus 1 or minus 1", "3ffUK-KODfg-01027-00259976-00260134": "again", "3ffUK-KODfg-01028-00260135-00260342": "so u 1 is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01029-00260344-00260623": "either plus 1 or minus one let us call", "3ffUK-KODfg-01030-00260623-00260742": "this is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01031-00260744-00260871": "that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01032-00260871-00261039": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01033-00261040-00261230": "it can", "3ffUK-KODfg-01034-00261231-00261582": "this point can lie either", "3ffUK-KODfg-01035-00261583-00261823": "this green", "3ffUK-KODfg-01036-00261823-00262039": "curves parabola or red parabolas", "3ffUK-KODfg-01037-00262040-00262327": "anywhere you can write it so let us call", "3ffUK-KODfg-01038-00262328-00262479": "it is here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01039-00262480-00262823": "so what is the value of x two positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-01040-00262824-00263095": "x two value is see here x two value is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01041-00263096-00263239": "positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-01042-00263240-00263591": "if x two value is positive then", "3ffUK-KODfg-01043-00263592-00263782": "x 1 dot", "3ffUK-KODfg-01044-00263783-00263958": "is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-01045-00263959-00264175": "then which direction the velocity is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01046-00264176-00264399": "positive then which direction x 1 will", "3ffUK-KODfg-01047-00264400-00264503": "move", "3ffUK-KODfg-01048-00264504-00264710": "x 1 will increase because this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01049-00264711-00264982": "derivative is positive x one is increase", "3ffUK-KODfg-01050-00264983-00265247": "that means it will go like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01051-00265248-00265671": "i as i told you it can be in the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01052-00265672-00265927": "red colored parabola or", "3ffUK-KODfg-01053-00265928-00266167": "green colored parabola so if it is red", "3ffUK-KODfg-01054-00266168-00266303": "color", "3ffUK-KODfg-01055-00266304-00266510": "or a parabola it lies", "3ffUK-KODfg-01056-00266511-00266719": "then", "3ffUK-KODfg-01057-00266720-00266823": "it", "3ffUK-KODfg-01058-00266824-00266991": "it should increase", "3ffUK-KODfg-01059-00266992-00267215": "agree so it is going away from the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01060-00267216-00267358": "origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-01061-00267359-00267534": "but if it is in the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01062-00267535-00267751": "what is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-01063-00267752-00268006": "ah that green", "3ffUK-KODfg-01064-00268007-00268119": "parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-01065-00268120-00268310": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01066-00268311-00268447": "x dot", "3ffUK-KODfg-01067-00268448-00268710": "x one dot is positive so x should", "3ffUK-KODfg-01068-00268711-00269063": "increase so the curve x is increasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01069-00269064-00269751": "along this curve see this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01070-00269752-00269958": "so if it is a so axon ingredient it is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01071-00269959-00270263": "going like this way so it is approaching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01072-00270264-00270510": "it is approaching 2", "3ffUK-KODfg-01073-00270511-00270887": "because x x 1 is increasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01074-00270888-00271006": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-01075-00271007-00271303": "but if it is if it is in this curve let", "3ffUK-KODfg-01076-00271304-00271527": "us call it is a", "3ffUK-KODfg-01077-00271528-00272055": "red curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01078-00272056-00272255": "so x one is increasing so it will move", "3ffUK-KODfg-01079-00272256-00272430": "like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01080-00272431-00272615": "it will move like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01081-00272616-00272791": "agree so it is going away from the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01082-00272792-00273047": "origin suppose it is on the green", "3ffUK-KODfg-01083-00273048-00273247": "green parabola so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01084-00273248-00273487": "x one should increase so it is going in", "3ffUK-KODfg-01085-00273488-00273591": "this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01086-00273592-00273679": "okay", "3ffUK-KODfg-01087-00273680-00273919": "and it is approaching to the origin so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01088-00273920-00274143": "if it is approach if it is like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01089-00274144-00274319": "let us call it is coming here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01090-00274320-00274406": "here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01091-00274407-00274830": "so still x 2 is positive sorry x 2 is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01092-00274831-00275095": "positive the x 1 should increase when it", "3ffUK-KODfg-01093-00275096-00275327": "comes here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01094-00275328-00275630": "when it comes here x 2 is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-01095-00275631-00275910": "x 2 is negative means what", "3ffUK-KODfg-01096-00275911-00276319": "x 1 is negative that means", "3ffUK-KODfg-01097-00276320-00276527": "x 1 should decrease and see it is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01098-00276528-00276663": "decreasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01099-00276664-00276815": "it is decreasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01100-00276816-00276943": "and decreasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01101-00276944-00277191": "in this way decreasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01102-00277192-00277519": "so when it hits here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01103-00277520-00277719": "when it hits here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01104-00277720-00277863": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-01105-00277864-00278103": "then what is this one this is the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01106-00278104-00278510": "trajectory for when u is equal to one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01107-00278511-00278903": "and this is your it is going along the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01108-00278904-00279151": "green trajectory dotted green trajectory", "3ffUK-KODfg-01109-00279152-00279479": "and u is equal to one when it hits here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01110-00279480-00279727": "that u is still", "3ffUK-KODfg-01111-00279728-00279847": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01112-00279848-00280039": "you still one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01113-00280040-00280287": "ah usual stringed one but", "3ffUK-KODfg-01114-00280288-00280423": "it hits the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01115-00280424-00280663": "that switching surface this one c is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01116-00280664-00280791": "equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-01117-00280792-00281047": "when it is zero still this u value is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01118-00281048-00281134": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01119-00281135-00281351": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-01120-00281352-00281630": "this this u value is one and this you", "3ffUK-KODfg-01121-00281631-00281758": "will is what", "3ffUK-KODfg-01122-00281759-00282063": "minus this when you are coming here the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01123-00282064-00282351": "u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01124-00282352-00282615": "minus one but when it hits here u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01125-00282616-00282767": "equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01126-00282768-00283039": "plus one so it switch here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01127-00283040-00283303": "agree and you see x two is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01128-00283304-00283423": "negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-01129-00283424-00283630": "that x one is decreasing decreasing and", "3ffUK-KODfg-01130-00283631-00283919": "it is ultimately it will come to origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-01131-00283920-00284006": "here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01132-00284007-00284303": "so if you see this one our switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01133-00284304-00284510": "surface is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01134-00284511-00284727": "at this point", "3ffUK-KODfg-01135-00284728-00284943": "at this point you see", "3ffUK-KODfg-01136-00284944-00285158": "x two is the initial condition", "3ffUK-KODfg-01137-00285159-00285415": "at this point that x two once again i am", "3ffUK-KODfg-01138-00285416-00285582": "telling you let us call our initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-01139-00285583-00285871": "condition is this one x of zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-01140-00285872-00286143": "and x of zero means x two is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01141-00286144-00286463": "positive one x two is positive c x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-01142-00286464-00286782": "is freeway x one should increase so it", "3ffUK-KODfg-01143-00286783-00287006": "may fall in this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01144-00287007-00287271": "parabolas or it may", "3ffUK-KODfg-01145-00287272-00287543": "this point may lie on this parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-01146-00287544-00287703": "i am telling you suppose it is lying on", "3ffUK-KODfg-01147-00287704-00287871": "this parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-01148-00287872-00287967": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-01149-00287968-00288199": "so x one should increase so it will go", "3ffUK-KODfg-01150-00288200-00288439": "this way it is going away from the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01151-00288440-00288639": "origin because we have to drive the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01152-00288640-00288895": "state to the towards the origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-01153-00288896-00289167": "and now if it is in the green", "3ffUK-KODfg-01154-00289168-00289406": "parabola that means equation number", "3ffUK-KODfg-01155-00289407-00289567": "seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-01156-00289568-00289758": "agree u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01157-00289759-00289934": "minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01158-00289935-00290143": "and this trajectory is u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01159-00290144-00290375": "minus so it will drive this one in this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01160-00290376-00290599": "direction because", "3ffUK-KODfg-01161-00290600-00290854": "u x is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01162-00290855-00291110": "x one dot is positive since x two is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01163-00291111-00291406": "positive so it is going and x one is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01164-00291407-00291630": "increasing increasing increasing in this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01165-00291631-00291703": "way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01166-00291704-00292110": "when it is a this at this point x two is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01167-00292111-00292303": "x two value is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-01168-00292304-00292487": "negative mean x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-01169-00292488-00292671": "x one value should decrease you see it", "3ffUK-KODfg-01170-00292672-00292951": "is decreasing this one value from here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01171-00292952-00293230": "to here x1 is decreasing decreasing when", "3ffUK-KODfg-01172-00293231-00293399": "it hits here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01173-00293400-00293663": "u value is change previously u was minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-01174-00293664-00294006": "one now you see this it hits here u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01175-00294007-00294127": "equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01176-00294128-00294310": "your", "3ffUK-KODfg-01177-00294311-00294454": "ah", "3ffUK-KODfg-01178-00294455-00294582": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01179-00294583-00294839": "it hits here also", "3ffUK-KODfg-01180-00294840-00295087": "you see it hits here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01181-00295088-00295239": "also no doubt", "3ffUK-KODfg-01182-00295240-00295334": "but", "3ffUK-KODfg-01183-00295335-00295606": "if it is it cannot go it cannot reach to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01184-00295607-00295879": "the origin it is going like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01185-00295880-00296175": "so it if if it hits here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01186-00296176-00296447": "then along this path u is equal to minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-01187-00296448-00296767": "one along this path x two is always", "3ffUK-KODfg-01188-00296768-00296879": "negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-01189-00296880-00297151": "means x one is decreasing and", "3ffUK-KODfg-01190-00297152-00297367": "approaching to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-01191-00297368-00297679": "this so our trajectory of this switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01192-00297680-00297903": "trajectory is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01193-00297904-00298079": "that one when", "3ffUK-KODfg-01194-00298080-00298182": "c", "3ffUK-KODfg-01195-00298183-00298463": "one is equal to zero this is our", "3ffUK-KODfg-01196-00298464-00298639": "trajectory", "3ffUK-KODfg-01197-00298640-00298871": "switching trajectory", "3ffUK-KODfg-01198-00298872-00299119": "now what about this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01199-00299120-00299447": "in this case suppose our point is here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01200-00299448-00299630": "our point is here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01201-00299631-00299751": "again", "3ffUK-KODfg-01202-00299752-00299910": "so our initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-01203-00299911-00300054": "point is here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01204-00300055-00300351": "so what is the value of our state x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-01205-00300352-00300447": "is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01206-00300448-00300639": "positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-01207-00300640-00300934": "x two is positive so what is this x one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01208-00300935-00301095": "should increase", "3ffUK-KODfg-01209-00301096-00301454": "so once again it may fall what is called", "3ffUK-KODfg-01210-00301455-00301758": "in the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01211-00301759-00301910": "this is the dotted line", "3ffUK-KODfg-01212-00301911-00302310": "at it may be a", "3ffUK-KODfg-01213-00302311-00302399": "fall", "3ffUK-KODfg-01214-00302400-00302534": "with this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01215-00302535-00302815": "dotted line that means", "3ffUK-KODfg-01216-00302816-00303079": "this is corresponding to the equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-01217-00303080-00303358": "six and this dotted line equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-01218-00303359-00303510": "seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-01219-00303511-00303758": "suppose it it is false on the equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-01220-00303759-00303967": "of that red line so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01221-00303968-00304151": "x two now", "3ffUK-KODfg-01222-00304152-00304343": "what is x two", "3ffUK-KODfg-01223-00304344-00304679": "x two is positive x one should increase", "3ffUK-KODfg-01224-00304680-00304839": "increase means", "3ffUK-KODfg-01225-00304840-00305199": "increase means it should go towards", "3ffUK-KODfg-01226-00305200-00305519": "this because minus one sub sums minus x", "3ffUK-KODfg-01227-00305520-00305791": "one is minus then it should go", "3ffUK-KODfg-01228-00305792-00306030": "towards direction x one so if it is go", "3ffUK-KODfg-01229-00306031-00306239": "towards this one it is going away from", "3ffUK-KODfg-01230-00306240-00306682": "the origin suppose it is coming", "3ffUK-KODfg-01231-00306683-00306887": "here now", "3ffUK-KODfg-01232-00306888-00307095": "suppose this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01233-00307096-00307551": "ok so our at this point x 2 is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-01234-00307552-00307630": "now", "3ffUK-KODfg-01235-00307631-00307871": "whether it will move along the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01236-00307872-00308047": "red", "3ffUK-KODfg-01237-00308048-00308351": "parabola or along the green parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-01238-00308352-00308639": "this that is our question now", "3ffUK-KODfg-01239-00308640-00308895": "suppose it is following like this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01240-00308896-00309119": "in the red parabola that means u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01241-00309120-00309399": "equal to our plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01242-00309400-00309687": "agree u is equal to plus one and the x", "3ffUK-KODfg-01243-00309688-00309815": "value is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01244-00309816-00309951": "increasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01245-00309952-00310151": "increasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01246-00310152-00310375": "agree it is increasing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01247-00310376-00310679": "so when it hits here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01248-00310680-00311087": "when it hits here then u value is your", "3ffUK-KODfg-01249-00311088-00311191": "negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-01250-00311192-00311327": "u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01251-00311328-00311606": "you you you you below is negative", "3ffUK-KODfg-01252-00311607-00311719": "agree", "3ffUK-KODfg-01253-00311720-00311943": "but at this moment u value was positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-01254-00311944-00312215": "when it hits here the u will be remain", "3ffUK-KODfg-01255-00312216-00312454": "that means switching occurs here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01256-00312455-00312782": "when c 2 is this is this c 2 is 0. so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01257-00312783-00313343": "our trajectory switching curve will be", "3ffUK-KODfg-01258-00313344-00313519": "that one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01259-00313520-00313806": "now one maker why not it will follow", "3ffUK-KODfg-01260-00313807-00313919": "with this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01261-00313920-00314110": "green curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01262-00314111-00314391": "why not it will follow with the green", "3ffUK-KODfg-01263-00314392-00314519": "ok", "3ffUK-KODfg-01264-00314520-00314751": "suppose it is in the green curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01265-00314752-00314991": "that means x 2 is positive", "3ffUK-KODfg-01266-00314992-00315310": "x 1 must increase", "3ffUK-KODfg-01267-00315311-00315575": "x one must increase it this one and it", "3ffUK-KODfg-01268-00315576-00315791": "is increasing so it will go like this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01269-00315792-00315999": "way this way this way", "3ffUK-KODfg-01270-00316000-00316223": "this way and it is going away from the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01271-00316224-00316343": "origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-01272-00316344-00316510": "so it has to go", "3ffUK-KODfg-01273-00316511-00316695": "in in this direction", "3ffUK-KODfg-01274-00316696-00316895": "so u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01275-00316896-00317047": "e is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01276-00317048-00317303": "plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01277-00317304-00317471": "and then is switch to e is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01278-00317472-00317782": "minus one so three so our switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01279-00317783-00317895": "curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01280-00317896-00318143": "in this ultimately", "3ffUK-KODfg-01281-00318144-00318319": "it is the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01282-00318320-00319310": "that is our switching curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01283-00319311-00319567": "so this curve is c one is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-01284-00319568-00319791": "from equation six", "3ffUK-KODfg-01285-00319792-00320047": "from six", "3ffUK-KODfg-01286-00320048-00320375": "and this is c two is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-01287-00320376-00320527": "form equation", "3ffUK-KODfg-01288-00320528-00320671": "seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-01289-00320672-00320958": "so once it is hit here it will follow", "3ffUK-KODfg-01290-00320959-00321095": "along the switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01291-00321096-00321223": "curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01292-00321224-00321391": "follow this switching curve and", "3ffUK-KODfg-01293-00321392-00321982": "ultimately it will raise to the origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-01294-00321983-00322295": "so we can write our control law", "3ffUK-KODfg-01295-00322296-00322503": "you see now", "3ffUK-KODfg-01296-00322504-00322919": "the control law", "3ffUK-KODfg-01297-00322920-00323191": "u star of t", "3ffUK-KODfg-01298-00323192-00323471": "is equal to minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-01299-00323472-00323743": "sign of", "3ffUK-KODfg-01300-00323744-00324023": "lambda 2 and lambda 2 is what", "3ffUK-KODfg-01301-00324024-00324127": "lambda", "3ffUK-KODfg-01302-00324128-00324343": "2 of 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-01303-00324344-00324606": "minus lambda 1 of 0", "3ffUK-KODfg-01304-00324607-00324743": "into t", "3ffUK-KODfg-01305-00324744-00325063": "so this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01306-00325064-00325334": "again this is our control law so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01307-00325335-00326054": "from six and seven", "3ffUK-KODfg-01308-00326055-00326215": "when", "3ffUK-KODfg-01309-00326216-00326327": "c one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01310-00326328-00326663": "is equal to c two is equal to zero", "3ffUK-KODfg-01311-00326664-00326999": "note", "3ffUK-KODfg-01312-00327000-00327279": "that", "3ffUK-KODfg-01313-00327280-00327551": "only", "3ffUK-KODfg-01314-00327552-00328054": "one parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-01315-00328055-00328310": "from each family", "3ffUK-KODfg-01316-00328311-00328558": "from each", "3ffUK-KODfg-01317-00328559-00329039": "family", "3ffUK-KODfg-01318-00329040-00329430": "passes", "3ffUK-KODfg-01319-00329431-00329615": "through", "3ffUK-KODfg-01320-00329616-00330606": "the specified terminal", "3ffUK-KODfg-01321-00330607-00330847": "from the precipitate terminal", "3ffUK-KODfg-01322-00330848-00331239": "point", "3ffUK-KODfg-01323-00331240-00331654": "x is equal to zero and zero transpose", "3ffUK-KODfg-01324-00331655-00331967": "that means if you see this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01325-00331968-00332230": "from six and seven if this initial", "3ffUK-KODfg-01326-00332231-00332391": "condition is there", "3ffUK-KODfg-01327-00332392-00332671": "anywhere in fourth quadrant anywhere in", "3ffUK-KODfg-01328-00332672-00332895": "the sorry first quadrant", "3ffUK-KODfg-01329-00332896-00333039": "then", "3ffUK-KODfg-01330-00333040-00333215": "it will move", "3ffUK-KODfg-01331-00333216-00333447": "along the u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01332-00333448-00333719": "first u is equal to minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01333-00333720-00333951": "switch is there you have to make the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01334-00333952-00334134": "switch equal to minus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01335-00334135-00334454": "then it will go continue along this path", "3ffUK-KODfg-01336-00334455-00334839": "as soon as this hit the switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01337-00334840-00334958": "curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01338-00334959-00335215": "again switching curve that means u is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01339-00335216-00335503": "equal to plus one is such it will follow", "3ffUK-KODfg-01340-00335504-00335782": "along this curve and at in reach to the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01341-00335783-00336110": "origin if it is if it is here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01342-00336111-00336406": "again if it is here again it will", "3ffUK-KODfg-01343-00336407-00336575": "switch to a", "3ffUK-KODfg-01344-00336576-00336815": "minus one flush and then it will switch", "3ffUK-KODfg-01345-00336816-00336982": "to plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01346-00336983-00337167": "control input", "3ffUK-KODfg-01347-00337168-00337310": "anywhere here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01348-00337311-00337495": "it will first switch to u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01349-00337496-00337767": "plus one and then switch to u is equal", "3ffUK-KODfg-01350-00337768-00338054": "to minus one anywhere here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01351-00338055-00338182": "suppose here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01352-00338183-00338454": "you are calling here here suppose here", "3ffUK-KODfg-01353-00338455-00338806": "it is just above the switching line", "3ffUK-KODfg-01354-00338807-00338982": "about the this is if it is here above", "3ffUK-KODfg-01355-00338983-00339199": "the switching line", "3ffUK-KODfg-01356-00339200-00339334": "if it is", "3ffUK-KODfg-01357-00339335-00339639": "initial point above the switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01358-00339640-00339751": "curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01359-00339752-00339839": "then", "3ffUK-KODfg-01360-00339840-00340023": "it will switch to u is equal to minus", "3ffUK-KODfg-01361-00340024-00340182": "one then", "3ffUK-KODfg-01362-00340183-00340447": "it will switch to e is equal to plus one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01363-00340448-00340719": "if it is below the switching line", "3ffUK-KODfg-01364-00340720-00340887": "below the switching line", "3ffUK-KODfg-01365-00340888-00341103": "first it will", "3ffUK-KODfg-01366-00341104-00341351": "switch to u is equal to", "3ffUK-KODfg-01367-00341352-00341582": "one then you will switch to e is equal", "3ffUK-KODfg-01368-00341583-00341887": "to minus one so this is the optimal time", "3ffUK-KODfg-01369-00341888-00342103": "it will required", "3ffUK-KODfg-01370-00342104-00342382": "along this trajectory of this one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01371-00342383-00343375": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01372-00343376-00343791": "so segments", "3ffUK-KODfg-01373-00343792-00344095": "of the two parabola", "3ffUK-KODfg-01374-00344096-00344239": "segments of", "3ffUK-KODfg-01375-00344240-00344399": "the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01376-00344400-00344967": "two parabolas", "3ffUK-KODfg-01377-00344968-00345615": "through origin", "3ffUK-KODfg-01378-00345616-00345758": "form", "3ffUK-KODfg-01379-00345759-00345854": "the", "3ffUK-KODfg-01380-00345855-00346230": "switching", "3ffUK-KODfg-01381-00346231-00346671": "curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01382-00346672-00346767": "so", "3ffUK-KODfg-01383-00346768-00347071": "this one segment of two parabolas two", "3ffUK-KODfg-01384-00347072-00347287": "familiar parameters that segment of this", "3ffUK-KODfg-01385-00347288-00347375": "one", "3ffUK-KODfg-01386-00347376-00347751": "once one is this one and another", "3ffUK-KODfg-01387-00347752-00348006": "parabola this is the set of parabolas", "3ffUK-KODfg-01388-00348007-00348254": "family parameters which is passing", "3ffUK-KODfg-01389-00348255-00348510": "through the origin and that intersect", "3ffUK-KODfg-01390-00348511-00348727": "and that will form the switching curve", "3ffUK-KODfg-01391-00348728-00348943": "so equation of the switching curve we", "3ffUK-KODfg-01392-00348944-00349119": "will discuss later", "3ffUK-KODfg-01393-00349120-00349382": "and we how to take the decision", "3ffUK-KODfg-01394-00349383-00349510": "when you", "3ffUK-KODfg-01395-00349511-00349806": "that u plus 1 to minus 1 how to take", "3ffUK-KODfg-01396-00349807-00349982": "will make some", "3ffUK-KODfg-01397-00349983-00350295": "logic behind this will explain this next", "3ffUK-KODfg-01398-00350296-00350596": "class"}}, {"audio_id": "3fmMNTQ_YCI", "text": {"3fmMNTQ_YCI-00000-00000174-00000375": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00001-00000376-00002336": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00002-00002337-00003388": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00003-00003389-00003904": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00004-00003905-00004156": "God", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00005-00004157-00006803": "yeah", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00006-00006804-00006938": "ingredients", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00007-00006939-00007501": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00008-00007502-00009299": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00009-00009300-00010037": "God", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00010-00010038-00010085": "God", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00011-00010086-00010433": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00012-00010434-00010777": "go go go go go go go go go go go go go", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00013-00010778-00011033": "you got a mind but even that could", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00014-00011034-00011177": "change you could fit the gray matter", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00015-00011178-00011392": "like some batter in your brain that's", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00016-00011393-00011614": "what I say fake it till you make it a", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00017-00011615-00011801": "and if you play that game then you just", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00018-00011802-00012035": "might make a change rearrange all the", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00019-00012036-00012456": "bad to okay take the worst stars", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00020-00012457-00012767": "and put them on display on repeat in the", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00021-00012768-00012919": "brain till you're feeling all my pain", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00022-00012919-00013625": "never slow yourself down", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00023-00013626-00015426": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00024-00015427-00015835": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00025-00015836-00016369": "go go go", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00026-00016369-00016865": "go go", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00027-00016866-00018330": "go go go", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00028-00018331-00018694": "I feel nauseous believe me never had a", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00029-00018695-00018989": "lot of come easy had to work hard", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00030-00018990-00019277": "struggle just to be me had to rise up", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00031-00019278-00019558": "just so they could see me did what I had", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00032-00019559-00019780": "to do just to feed me and what was left", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00033-00019781-00020080": "over I put towards my dreaming but the", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00034-00020081-00020327": "only thing in life that has meaning are", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00035-00020328-00020557": "the things you gotta work for believe me", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00036-00020558-00020843": "take into your hands to plan your own", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00037-00020844-00021130": "hands can land your own brand and damn I", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00038-00021131-00021293": "feel like no one takes accountability", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00039-00021294-00021533": "they want the credibility convincingly", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00040-00021534-00022367": "unwilling to put in the now", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00041-00022368-00023659": "theater", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00042-00023660-00023927": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00043-00023928-00026524": "afternoon", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00044-00026525-00026867": "sad", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00045-00026868-00027031": "video", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00046-00027032-00027546": "you need", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00047-00027547-00029789": "my video", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00048-00029789-00031277": "thank you", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00049-00031277-00031624": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00050-00031625-00034667": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00051-00034668-00036083": "Sydney", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00052-00036084-00036931": "um", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00053-00036932-00038296": "so guys", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00054-00038297-00038490": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00055-00038491-00039596": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00056-00039597-00040555": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00057-00040556-00042887": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00058-00042888-00043001": "technology", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00059-00043002-00045523": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00060-00045524-00045743": "until I'm buried in my", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00061-00045744-00045862": "grave", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00062-00045863-00046061": "Thunder but my body won't Decay cause my", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00063-00046062-00046229": "messages are coming so they put them on", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00064-00046230-00046445": "display oh yeah I rap with a certainty I", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00065-00046446-00046637": "have a sense of vertices a message for", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00066-00046638-00046835": "eternity for everyone internally I have", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00067-00046836-00046979": "some people burden me but now they", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00068-00046980-00047140": "learn to see I ain't the one to", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00069-00047141-00047327": "with now they looking nervously and", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00070-00047328-00047495": "I don't really care what you think of me", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00071-00047496-00047711": "respectfully you could kick rocks if you", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00072-00047712-00047879": "think you're better see I will", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00073-00047880-00048118": "not work you turn you to an enemy aren't", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00074-00048119-00048280": "you so bad that you're gonna need some", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00075-00048281-00049096": "therapy", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00076-00049097-00050728": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00077-00050729-00054176": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00078-00054177-00055061": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00079-00055062-00056880": "yeah", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00080-00056882-00057173": "don't give up on your future we All-Star", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00081-00057174-00057804": "losers", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00082-00057804-00058761": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00083-00058762-00059554": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00084-00059555-00059798": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00085-00059799-00061985": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00086-00061986-00062488": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00087-00062489-00062766": "thank you", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00088-00062766-00065599": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00089-00065600-00066282": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00090-00066283-00066404": "thank you", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00091-00066405-00066581": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00092-00066582-00066748": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00093-00066749-00067690": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00094-00067691-00068850": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00095-00068851-00070717": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00096-00070718-00070896": "shut up", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00097-00070897-00072136": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00098-00072137-00073748": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00099-00073749-00073894": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00100-00073895-00074523": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00101-00074524-00077455": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00102-00077456-00079835": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00103-00079836-00081041": "thank you", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00104-00081042-00081546": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00105-00081547-00083488": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00106-00083489-00083590": "[Applause]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00107-00083591-00084632": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00108-00084633-00086001": "[Music]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00109-00086002-00086117": "[Applause]", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00110-00086118-00086316": "foreign", "3fmMNTQ_YCI-00111-00086317-00086886": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3fv23zNvvPA", "text": {"3fv23zNvvPA-00000-00000640-00001453": "[Music]", "3fv23zNvvPA-00001-00001454-00002165": "still more sensitive young must be calm", "3fv23zNvvPA-00002-00002166-00002534": "because some of them sing baby or zoo", "3fv23zNvvPA-00003-00002535-00002888": "ringing they call the hasta tendencies", "3fv23zNvvPA-00004-00002889-00003173": "on inmates in Nam Jamie come with", "3fv23zNvvPA-00005-00003174-00003484": "a chick back in amchem found a youngster", "3fv23zNvvPA-00006-00003485-00003886": "couple of my sister he come to me comedy", "3fv23zNvvPA-00007-00003886-00004283": "Alistar caponata I'm the my sister would", "3fv23zNvvPA-00008-00004284-00004826": "already the lash take it off the you", "3fv23zNvvPA-00009-00004827-00005309": "know mama nice clear son I'll feed you", "3fv23zNvvPA-00010-00005310-00005654": "too much because I'm Jim come that's it", "3fv23zNvvPA-00011-00005655-00006071": "but you know Jim come as a youngster"}}, {"audio_id": "3fBBHh7_eby", "text": {"3fBBHh7_eby-00000-00000032-00000223": "hello everyone sherlock phantom one here", "3fBBHh7_eby-00001-00000224-00000390": "and today we will be doing a trailer", "3fBBHh7_eby-00002-00000391-00000623": "commentary slash reaction", "3fBBHh7_eby-00003-00000624-00000847": "the diary of wimpy kid new animated", "3fBBHh7_eby-00004-00000848-00001135": "movie coming out this year and also if i", "3fBBHh7_eby-00005-00001136-00001295": "sound a little sick that's because i am", "3fBBHh7_eby-00006-00001296-00001470": "i'm kind of recovering from a cold let's", "3fBBHh7_eby-00007-00001471-00001791": "just jump right in and have a great time", "3fBBHh7_eby-00008-00001792-00002079": "this is a journal not a diary tomorrow", "3fBBHh7_eby-00009-00002080-00002231": "is the first day of middle school", "3fBBHh7_eby-00010-00002232-00002399": "luckily i'm not alone in this middle", "3fBBHh7_eby-00011-00002400-00002558": "school thing i've got my best friend", "3fBBHh7_eby-00012-00002559-00002750": "rally oh my gosh look at rally here's", "3fBBHh7_eby-00013-00002751-00002902": "what you need to know watch where you", "3fBBHh7_eby-00014-00002903-00003110": "sit on the first day of school don't use", "3fBBHh7_eby-00015-00003111-00003270": "the bathroom on the second floor and", "3fBBHh7_eby-00016-00003271-00003431": "finally don't", "3fBBHh7_eby-00017-00003432-00003759": "get the cheese touch oh here", "3fBBHh7_eby-00018-00003760-00003967": "maybe my mom can homeschool me rowley", "3fBBHh7_eby-00019-00003968-00004159": "looks really weird in this", "3fBBHh7_eby-00020-00004160-00004319": "we're in middle school now don't you", "3fBBHh7_eby-00021-00004320-00004743": "think it's time to start acting our age", "3fBBHh7_eby-00022-00004744-00005199": "oh boy", "3fBBHh7_eby-00023-00005200-00005399": "frankly looks really kind of normal in", "3fBBHh7_eby-00024-00005400-00006054": "this", "3fBBHh7_eby-00025-00006055-00006486": "i love the animation style", "3fBBHh7_eby-00026-00006487-00007119": "i do not like riley uh design at all", "3fBBHh7_eby-00027-00007120-00007534": "everything will though fine", "3fBBHh7_eby-00028-00007536-00007695": "what are my thoughts", "3fBBHh7_eby-00029-00007695-00007927": "um", "3fBBHh7_eby-00030-00007928-00008119": "well i do like the animation style i", "3fBBHh7_eby-00031-00008120-00008351": "really think it's very clean and very", "3fBBHh7_eby-00032-00008352-00008487": "well done", "3fBBHh7_eby-00033-00008488-00008687": "one of my concerns is like", "3fBBHh7_eby-00034-00008688-00008910": "the story doesn't change really at all", "3fBBHh7_eby-00035-00008911-00009046": "and i know that it's like it's the same", "3fBBHh7_eby-00036-00009047-00009239": "movie but animated", "3fBBHh7_eby-00037-00009240-00009423": "um", "3fBBHh7_eby-00038-00009424-00009567": "i don't know i'll probably still go see", "3fBBHh7_eby-00039-00009568-00009703": "it to be honest with you just because", "3fBBHh7_eby-00040-00009704-00009974": "i'm a diary wimpy kid fan i really liked", "3fBBHh7_eby-00041-00009975-00010127": "the first one the second one was all", "3fBBHh7_eby-00042-00010128-00010278": "right and then after that it kind of", "3fBBHh7_eby-00043-00010279-00010438": "started going downhill i don't know i", "3fBBHh7_eby-00044-00010439-00010567": "mean what are your guys's thoughts in", "3fBBHh7_eby-00045-00010568-00010767": "the comments um do you love it do you", "3fBBHh7_eby-00046-00010768-00010887": "hate it", "3fBBHh7_eby-00047-00010888-00011006": "is it something you're probably gonna", "3fBBHh7_eby-00048-00011007-00011127": "watch is it something you'll probably", "3fBBHh7_eby-00049-00011128-00011319": "pass on let me know in the comments", "3fBBHh7_eby-00050-00011320-00011559": "below and thank you so much for watching", "3fBBHh7_eby-00051-00011560-00012124": "bye guys", "3fBBHh7_eby-00052-00012125-00012564": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3gdtPn6Elnu", "text": {"3gdtPn6Elnu-00000-00000000-00000209": "new on NFL live field you got an update", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00001-00000210-00000371": "for us related to the Rams what's going", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00002-00000372-00000509": "on", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00003-00000509-00000695": "yeah this is significant News Lauren", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00004-00000696-00000911": "it's courtesy of our own Diana Rossini", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00005-00000911-00001097": "who reported just before we got onto the", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00006-00001098-00001337": "air that Rams head coach Sean McVay has", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00007-00001338-00001558": "decided to return to the team for the", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00008-00001559-00001859": "2023 season of course McVeigh has", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00009-00001860-00002075": "contemplated walking away from coaching", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00010-00002076-00002326": "with opportunities that could include a", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00011-00002327-00002507": "career in television something he has", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00012-00002508-00002795": "been open about in the past but there", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00013-00002796-00002963": "was some uncertainty about his future", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00014-00002964-00003299": "until now as Sean McVay will return and", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00015-00003300-00003520": "try to turn things back around for the", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00016-00003521-00003695": "Rams who after winning the Super Bowl", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00017-00003696-00003965": "last season went 5 and 12 this year", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00018-00003965-00004204": "those 12 losses are the most losses by", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00019-00004205-00004522": "any defending champion in NFL history so", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00020-00004523-00004751": "Sean McVay will be a part of the Rams", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00021-00004752-00005051": "effort to get things back on track there", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00022-00005052-00005297": "are just five head coaching vacancies as", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00023-00005298-00005567": "the Rams will not have any turnover you", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00024-00005568-00005777": "know what coach TV will always be here", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00025-00005778-00005951": "so do your thing we love that you're", "3gdtPn6Elnu-00026-00005952-00006253": "back it's going to be great"}}, {"audio_id": "3gfyBsN6m6c", "text": {"3gfyBsN6m6c-00000-00000760-00006697": "[Music]", "3gfyBsN6m6c-00001-00006698-00006904": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "3gXcN0OmFfc", "text": {"3gXcN0OmFfc-00000-00000016-00000238": "you really can lower your firearm now of", "3gXcN0OmFfc-00001-00000239-00000463": "course", "3gXcN0OmFfc-00002-00000463-00000751": "the whole freaking town must be in here", "3gXcN0OmFfc-00003-00000752-00000854": "hey francine", "3gXcN0OmFfc-00004-00000855-00001688": "look how quickly i made friends"}}, {"audio_id": "3h6yHqYyvLg", "text": {"3h6yHqYyvLg-00000-00000089-00000343": "introducing a brand new cutting-edge", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00001-00000344-00000647": "approach the old ways of mental game", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00002-00000648-00001052": "training just don't cut it anymore yo", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00003-00001053-00001298": "there goes to be the best strongest", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00004-00001299-00001570": "quickest get the high school energy top", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00005-00001571-00001807": "let's get your monsters right it's time", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00006-00001809-00001988": "to get tough it's your only training", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00007-00001989-00002300": "every day it's not enough so stop jump", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00008-00002301-00002540": "in and start winning we take you step by", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00009-00002541-00002776": "step from the beginning help your field", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00010-00002777-00003005": "mental muscle it'll be our pleasure we", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00011-00003006-00003155": "give your knowledge that we know will", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00012-00003156-00003388": "last forever you wanna be your champion", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00013-00003389-00003640": "crush all the haters become number one", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00014-00003642-00003803": "with the mental toughness trainer", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00015-00003804-00004052": "perform under pressure to any kind of", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00016-00004053-00004244": "whether it's affordable to and then", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00017-00004245-00004451": "makes it even better with a one-year", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00018-00004452-00004697": "money back guarantee you're gonna build", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00019-00004698-00004934": "mental toughness trying to see so come", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00020-00004935-00005111": "on and get the mental toughness trainer", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00021-00005112-00005377": "and I know for a fact that you'll think", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00022-00005378-00006078": "we made our gear www.rentboy.com", "3h6yHqYyvLg-00023-00006079-00006484": "start your journey today"}}, {"audio_id": "3hhqkQ5x8To", "text": {"3hhqkQ5x8To-00000-00000749-00000983": "hi I'm dr. Reginald Hobbs and I'm a", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00001-00000984-00001272": "veteran I was an airman and US Air Force", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00002-00001273-00001452": "where I did information systems at", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00003-00001453-00001727": "Cheyenne Mountain in Colorado here at", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00004-00001728-00001955": "ARL i'm a senior research scientist and", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00005-00001957-00002183": "i manage a team of researchers doing", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00006-00002184-00002448": "human language technology my younger", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00007-00002449-00002633": "brother who joined the military about", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00008-00002634-00002865": "the same time I did recently retired as", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00009-00002866-00003138": "a sergeant major the thing that I get", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00010-00003139-00003357": "most satisfaction from and very proud of", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00011-00003358-00003513": "is that the research I'm doing here at", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00012-00003514-00003957": "al helps soldiers like him and I'm still", "3hhqkQ5x8To-00013-00003958-00004197": "serving"}}, {"audio_id": "3hwfqcvcLUI", "text": {"3hwfqcvcLUI-00000-00000003-00000329": "okay now the cost of mental ill health", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00001-00000330-00000593": "in the workplace first of all what are", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00002-00000594-00001073": "the obvious ones presenteeism which is", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00003-00001074-00001241": "where people are showing up at work but", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00004-00001242-00001478": "they're not all there they're not able", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00005-00001479-00001636": "to perform the lights are on but no", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00006-00001637-00001882": "one's home they might be sitting on", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00007-00001884-00002234": "Facebook all day through Facebook so", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00008-00002235-00002368": "they're present but they're not really", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00009-00002369-00002714": "producing absenteeism the other one that", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00010-00002715-00002917": "it's sometimes difficult to put a", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00011-00002918-00003260": "measure on but conflict HR issues the", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00012-00003261-00003547": "Team Dynamics and and the time and the", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00013-00003548-00003719": "energy and the effort that gets spent on", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00014-00003720-00003953": "dealing with all of those issues when I", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00015-00003954-00004109": "mean when people are stressed we all", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00016-00004110-00004288": "respond differently but one of the", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00017-00004289-00004495": "common ones is we get irritated we we", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00018-00004496-00004643": "might say something that we wouldn't", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00019-00004644-00004985": "normally say to someone so it's all of", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00020-00004986-00005266": "those things come together and create a", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00021-00005267-00005567": "downward spiral unfortunately and that's", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00022-00005568-00005708": "what we want to do is change it around", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00023-00005709-00006233": "and it's it's complex but there are", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00024-00006234-00006413": "simple things that managers can do as", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00025-00006414-00006631": "well and that's all yes we'll get to", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00026-00006633-00006920": "that in terms of of the the impact on", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00027-00006920-00007094": "workplaces we know from the research", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00028-00007095-00007316": "also that stressed-out people are more", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00029-00007317-00007613": "likely to complain of harassment and", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00030-00007614-00007942": "bullying so we talked to and I talked to", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00031-00007943-00008252": "a director of HR once and she said after", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00032-00008253-00008528": "70% of the problems that we have in HR I", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00033-00008529-00008681": "think have got a mental health issue", "3hwfqcvcLUI-00034-00008682-00009082": "behind them 70%"}}, {"audio_id": "3hxJBpM-xz0", "text": {"3hxJBpM-xz0-00000-00000142-00004945": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00001-00004946-00005910": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00002-00005911-00007289": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00003-00007290-00008000": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00004-00008001-00008478": "what a down", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00005-00008479-00009085": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00006-00009086-00009991": "she told my", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00007-00009992-00012507": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00008-00012508-00013075": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00009-00013076-00013285": "your children", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00010-00013286-00014590": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00011-00014591-00015072": "my leg", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00012-00015072-00015263": "she hope my name", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00013-00015263-00016290": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00014-00016291-00017048": "you can't go", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00015-00017049-00018151": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00016-00018152-00019268": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00017-00019269-00019593": "[Applause]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00018-00019594-00022018": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00019-00022019-00022849": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00020-00022850-00023939": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00021-00023940-00024097": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00022-00024098-00024309": "can you", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00023-00024310-00025511": "[Music]", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00024-00025512-00025672": "Oh", "3hxJBpM-xz0-00025-00025673-00026171": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3hDPRxbk_Qo", "text": {"3hDPRxbk_Qo-00000-00000016-00000231": "hey guys today we are going to paint", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00001-00000231-00000423": "this lovely christmas deer you can", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00002-00000424-00000582": "choose which color do you prefer", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00003-00000583-00000807": "white gray or you might want to use", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00004-00000808-00000991": "completely different colors", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00005-00000992-00001239": "in any case the process will be exactly", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00006-00001240-00001319": "the same", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00007-00001320-00001599": "let's do it we are going to begin here", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00008-00001600-00001910": "with a 24 by 24 inch stretched prime", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00009-00001911-00001991": "canvas", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00010-00001992-00002215": "since i'm making a red tier on a white", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00011-00002216-00002431": "background i will cover the canvas with", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00012-00002432-00002495": "white", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00013-00002496-00002710": "i'm gonna use white acrylic paint and", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00014-00002711-00002910": "mix it with some pure and medium", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00015-00002911-00003102": "if you don't have pure medium and your", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00016-00003103-00003279": "paint is thick you can dilute it with", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00017-00003279-00003390": "just water", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00018-00003392-00003590": "as you can see i'm applying paint with a", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00019-00003592-00003775": "roller so it will be faster", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00020-00003776-00003999": "and you will get a perfect solid color", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00021-00004000-00004086": "background", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00022-00004087-00004263": "if you don't have a roller use a white", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00023-00004264-00004519": "flat brush whether you are using a brush", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00024-00004520-00004591": "or roller", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00025-00004592-00004799": "apply every coat of paint in different", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00026-00004800-00005022": "direction horizontal or vertical", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00027-00005023-00005286": "this will give you an even color result", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00028-00005287-00005463": "let the first coat of paint dry", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00029-00005464-00005711": "for 30-30 minutes before applying a", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00030-00005712-00005911": "second one if you're wondering why i'm", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00031-00005912-00006095": "painting a white converse with", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00032-00006096-00006327": "white color believe me there is a huge", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00033-00006328-00006495": "difference between painted and", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00034-00006495-00006767": "unpainted canvas apply more layers as", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00035-00006768-00006951": "needed but don't forget to wait until", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00036-00006952-00007151": "the previous coat of paint is dry", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00037-00007152-00007351": "take a knit pattern stencil or a", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00038-00007352-00007559": "christmas sweater pattern stencil", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00039-00007559-00007791": "fix it with masking tape apply the red", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00040-00007792-00007863": "paint through", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00041-00007864-00008142": "the stencil with a gentle tapping motion", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00042-00008143-00008310": "using a stenciled brush", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00043-00008311-00008535": "do not use water at all don't repeat my", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00044-00008536-00008614": "mistake", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00045-00008615-00008823": "i always use water when i paint with", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00046-00008824-00009063": "acrylics so i wet the palette and brush", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00047-00009064-00009151": "automatically", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00048-00009152-00009423": "and there was a mess i had to start all", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00049-00009424-00009503": "over again", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00050-00009504-00009695": "to wash off red paint and cover the", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00051-00009696-00009831": "canvas with white", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00052-00009832-00010119": "so no water guys my stencil was folded", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00053-00010120-00010199": "and now", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00054-00010200-00010471": "it's wavy with lots of wrinkles so i", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00055-00010472-00010631": "have to press the stencil against the", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00056-00010632-00010791": "canvas with my fingers", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00057-00010792-00010991": "that the paint does not flow under the", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00058-00010992-00011214": "stencil each time grab just a small", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00059-00011215-00011319": "amount of paint", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00060-00011320-00011551": "leave some places less colored some of", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00061-00011552-00011678": "them barely painted", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00062-00011679-00011991": "as this is a painting and not a pants", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00063-00011992-00012238": "and we want it to look more creative you", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00064-00012239-00012404": "should get something like this", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00065-00012405-00012670": "[Music]", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00066-00012671-00012935": "first draw a deer with charcoal pencil", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00067-00012936-00013143": "as it erases easily once you finish the", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00068-00013144-00013207": "painting", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00069-00013208-00013399": "if you find drawing the deer yourself", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00070-00013400-00013575": "difficult", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00071-00013576-00013799": "then take a ready-made drawing and", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00072-00013800-00013975": "transfer it to the canvas", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00073-00013976-00014343": "using tracing paper then draw the deer", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00074-00014344-00014655": "with red acrylic marker use different", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00075-00014656-00014791": "size of the marker", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00076-00014791-00015036": "then your line will be more artistic and", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00077-00015037-00015483": "[Music]", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00078-00015484-00015894": "beautiful", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00079-00015896-00016883": "[Music]", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00080-00016884-00017535": "a", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00081-00017536-00017863": "hi there not only can this painting be", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00082-00017864-00018055": "a christmas present for your beloved", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00083-00018056-00018335": "ones it is also a concept art", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00084-00018336-00018599": "of animal rights the red vertical stripe", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00085-00018600-00018783": "together with the red frame essentially", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00086-00018784-00018983": "imply the prohibitory sign", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00087-00018984-00019207": "there is the deer behind the red stripe", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00088-00019208-00019414": "and it symbolizes a band of trophy", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00089-00019415-00019550": "hunting in general", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00090-00019551-00019855": "and deer hunting in particular", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00091-00019856-00020191": "i am strongly against trophic hunting", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00092-00020192-00020511": "most hunters never think about the pain", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00093-00020512-00020678": "that a wounded trapped animal", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00094-00020679-00020871": "experiences", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00095-00020872-00021135": "therefore instead of a head of a poor", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00096-00021136-00021222": "deer", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00097-00021223-00021527": "which is himself is way too creepy", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00098-00021528-00021775": "i suggest the hunters to hang a painting", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00099-00021776-00021886": "of a deer", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00100-00021887-00022214": "in this case no animal will be harmed", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00101-00022215-00022455": "we should make no one suffer especially", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00102-00022456-00022622": "just for fun", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00103-00022623-00022863": "write what you think about this concept", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00104-00022864-00023022": "in the comments below", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00105-00023023-00023303": "peace out do not be a cause of your own", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00106-00023304-00023591": "suffering and those around you", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00107-00023592-00024014": "it's better to keep calm and create on", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00108-00024015-00024199": "thank you so much for watching this", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00109-00024200-00024383": "video please share it", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00110-00024384-00024575": "let's together raise awareness about", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00111-00024576-00024839": "trophy hunting and to stop it", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00112-00024840-00025078": "small things make the biggest difference", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00113-00025079-00025278": "in the world", "3hDPRxbk_Qo-00114-00025279-00025584": "merry christmas"}}, {"audio_id": "3i0ips9fOCk", "text": {"3i0ips9fOCk-00000-00000078-00000407": "hello guys today is my birthday and I am", "3i0ips9fOCk-00001-00000408-00001007": "turning nine let's open these presents", "3i0ips9fOCk-00002-00001008-00001133": "first we're gonna start with the", "3i0ips9fOCk-00003-00001134-00001270": "smallest", "3i0ips9fOCk-00004-00001271-00003017": "two launches", "3i0ips9fOCk-00005-00003018-00003347": "huh", "3i0ips9fOCk-00006-00003347-00005328": "foreign", "3i0ips9fOCk-00007-00005329-00006436": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00008-00006437-00006628": "wow", "3i0ips9fOCk-00009-00006629-00007133": "hello wow", "3i0ips9fOCk-00010-00007134-00007367": "um bracelets I thought there were one", "3i0ips9fOCk-00011-00007368-00008207": "filters that's one I think this one", "3i0ips9fOCk-00012-00008208-00008560": "you can flip it open", "3i0ips9fOCk-00013-00008561-00009514": "oh", "3i0ips9fOCk-00014-00009515-00009685": "but magic", "3i0ips9fOCk-00015-00009686-00010085": "puzzle cubes I don't know what they are", "3i0ips9fOCk-00016-00010086-00011283": "but like yeah", "3i0ips9fOCk-00017-00011284-00011585": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00018-00011586-00011977": "okay now I think they're necklace yep", "3i0ips9fOCk-00019-00011978-00012383": "next we got a necklace and Elsa necklace", "3i0ips9fOCk-00020-00012384-00012630": "to match", "3i0ips9fOCk-00021-00012631-00012757": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00022-00012758-00013816": "and this one's next", "3i0ips9fOCk-00023-00013818-00014776": "chocolate", "3i0ips9fOCk-00024-00014777-00015586": "[Applause]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00025-00015587-00015916": "and the next this time for the next one", "3i0ips9fOCk-00026-00015918-00016271": "six thousand", "3i0ips9fOCk-00027-00016272-00018368": "foreign", "3i0ips9fOCk-00028-00018369-00018995": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00029-00018996-00019355": "[Applause]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00030-00019356-00019597": "well this is", "3i0ips9fOCk-00031-00019598-00020914": "a thread nails", "3i0ips9fOCk-00032-00020915-00022072": "[Applause]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00033-00022073-00022371": "I don't know if this came", "3i0ips9fOCk-00034-00022372-00022780": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00035-00022781-00024221": "Frozen", "3i0ips9fOCk-00036-00024222-00024544": "this one next", "3i0ips9fOCk-00037-00024545-00024814": "that's right", "3i0ips9fOCk-00038-00024815-00025127": "um", "3i0ips9fOCk-00039-00025128-00025367": "very heavy and I think I it's a heavy", "3i0ips9fOCk-00040-00025368-00025549": "cream I think", "3i0ips9fOCk-00041-00025550-00025956": "maybe or like a", "3i0ips9fOCk-00042-00025957-00026656": "thank you", "3i0ips9fOCk-00043-00026657-00026979": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00044-00026980-00027923": "[Applause]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00045-00027924-00028831": "okay now stickers", "3i0ips9fOCk-00046-00028832-00029158": "oh these are carbs", "3i0ips9fOCk-00047-00029160-00029524": "this is from my lovely sister", "3i0ips9fOCk-00048-00029525-00030058": "and this uh yeah just for you assistant", "3i0ips9fOCk-00049-00030060-00030196": "um yeah", "3i0ips9fOCk-00050-00030197-00030389": "you have to open it up", "3i0ips9fOCk-00051-00030389-00030612": "do I", "3i0ips9fOCk-00052-00030613-00030958": "uh well just for you sister on your", "3i0ips9fOCk-00053-00030960-00031529": "birthday have a lovely day", "3i0ips9fOCk-00054-00031530-00031793": "if even these", "3i0ips9fOCk-00055-00031794-00032273": "were some things someone deserve all the", "3i0ips9fOCk-00056-00032274-00032668": "love and attention a beautiful perfect", "3i0ips9fOCk-00057-00032669-00033223": "these are from my family", "3i0ips9fOCk-00058-00033224-00033437": "what's heavy", "3i0ips9fOCk-00059-00033438-00033951": "okay", "3i0ips9fOCk-00060-00033952-00035118": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00061-00035119-00035471": "there are books about animals", "3i0ips9fOCk-00062-00035472-00035771": "trust me", "3i0ips9fOCk-00063-00035772-00036107": "let's see what is inside", "3i0ips9fOCk-00064-00036108-00036307": "wow", "3i0ips9fOCk-00065-00036308-00036743": "two books and they're different it's", "3i0ips9fOCk-00066-00036744-00037469": "from the ocean this is the world", "3i0ips9fOCk-00067-00037470-00040973": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00068-00040974-00041279": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00069-00041280-00042559": "next is", "3i0ips9fOCk-00070-00042560-00043080": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00071-00043081-00043296": "the journal", "3i0ips9fOCk-00072-00043297-00043585": "oh okay", "3i0ips9fOCk-00073-00043586-00043835": "like this", "3i0ips9fOCk-00074-00043836-00044458": "thingy", "3i0ips9fOCk-00075-00044459-00044802": "second last one", "3i0ips9fOCk-00076-00044803-00045983": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00077-00045984-00046187": "this is what we have", "3i0ips9fOCk-00078-00046188-00046448": "we attach them", "3i0ips9fOCk-00079-00046449-00046583": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00080-00046584-00046735": "please", "3i0ips9fOCk-00081-00046736-00048179": "the last one", "3i0ips9fOCk-00082-00048180-00048827": "whoa", "3i0ips9fOCk-00083-00048828-00049004": "playing the ponds", "3i0ips9fOCk-00084-00049005-00049590": "[Music]", "3i0ips9fOCk-00085-00049591-00049962": "shoot it in", "3i0ips9fOCk-00086-00049963-00050267": "and these are all of my sister's gift on", "3i0ips9fOCk-00087-00050268-00050507": "her birthday and she was 29. thank you", "3i0ips9fOCk-00088-00050508-00050693": "for all of these gifts", "3i0ips9fOCk-00089-00050694-00050803": "bye", "3i0ips9fOCk-00090-00050804-00051045": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3ii1XBac8o8", "text": {"3ii1XBac8o8-00000-00000003-00000161": "it is finally time to talk about", "3ii1XBac8o8-00001-00000162-00000337": "transitive closure now that we have", "3ii1XBac8o8-00002-00000338-00000548": "composition under our belt so we're", "3ii1XBac8o8-00003-00000549-00001339": "going to let X be the set a B C D and", "3ii1XBac8o8-00004-00001340-00001998": "we're going to let R be the relation a B", "3ii1XBac8o8-00005-00002000-00003256": "BC C D and D B it's easiest to think", "3ii1XBac8o8-00006-00003257-00003431": "about transitivity when we draw the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00007-00003432-00003593": "digraph so let's go ahead and draw a", "3ii1XBac8o8-00008-00003594-00003803": "directed graph or R so we're gonna have", "3ii1XBac8o8-00009-00003804-00004385": "a b c and d an r relates a to b it", "3ii1XBac8o8-00010-00004386-00004702": "relates B to C it relates to C to D and", "3ii1XBac8o8-00011-00004703-00005318": "it relates D back to be alright we want", "3ii1XBac8o8-00012-00005319-00005534": "to make this thing transitive which", "3ii1XBac8o8-00013-00005535-00005813": "means that anytime we can eventually get", "3ii1XBac8o8-00014-00005814-00006013": "one step at a time between two vertices", "3ii1XBac8o8-00015-00006014-00006286": "we want an arrow directly connecting", "3ii1XBac8o8-00016-00006287-00006460": "them so for example the fact that we can", "3ii1XBac8o8-00017-00006461-00006796": "go from A to B via our and from B to C", "3ii1XBac8o8-00018-00006797-00007163": "via R means that via the transitive", "3ii1XBac8o8-00019-00007164-00007321": "closure we need to be able to get from A", "3ii1XBac8o8-00020-00007322-00007688": "to C so let's let the red pen be the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00021-00007689-00008048": "pair's in r2 and so we're going to get", "3ii1XBac8o8-00022-00008048-00008917": "AC in that we're going to get the pair", "3ii1XBac8o8-00023-00008918-00009139": "let's see you get from B to C and from C", "3ii1XBac8o8-00024-00009140-00009398": "to B so we need to get straight from B", "3ii1XBac8o8-00025-00009399-00010039": "to B we can get from beat it from C to D", "3ii1XBac8o8-00026-00010040-00010337": "and from C to B so to get straight from", "3ii1XBac8o8-00027-00010338-00010696": "C to B I meant to say we can get", "3ii1XBac8o8-00028-00010697-00010970": "straight from C to D and from D to B and", "3ii1XBac8o8-00029-00010971-00011260": "then likewise we can go from D to B to C", "3ii1XBac8o8-00030-00011261-00011399": "so we need to be able to go straight", "3ii1XBac8o8-00031-00011400-00011999": "from D to C so all those red arrows that", "3ii1XBac8o8-00032-00012000-00012145": "I'm going to have to introduce to make", "3ii1XBac8o8-00033-00012146-00012385": "it transitive are all pairs in r2", "3ii1XBac8o8-00034-00012386-00012638": "because they arise from paths of length", "3ii1XBac8o8-00035-00012639-00012988": "2 and R then my blue pen is going to", "3ii1XBac8o8-00036-00012989-00013237": "represent arrows rising as", "3ii1XBac8o8-00037-00013238-00013504": "result of paths of length three so I can", "3ii1XBac8o8-00038-00013505-00013783": "go from A to B to C to D therefore I", "3ii1XBac8o8-00039-00013784-00014002": "need to be able to get directly from A", "3ii1XBac8o8-00040-00014003-00014666": "to D so if pair ad is going to be there", "3ii1XBac8o8-00041-00014668-00015115": "it's a less common thing in transitivity", "3ii1XBac8o8-00042-00015116-00015322": "or a less obvious thing in transitivity", "3ii1XBac8o8-00043-00015322-00015565": "but anytime that you've got an arrow", "3ii1XBac8o8-00044-00015566-00015835": "going to and from a vertex you need to", "3ii1XBac8o8-00045-00015836-00016006": "have the loop in that vertex so for", "3ii1XBac8o8-00046-00016007-00016234": "example since I can get from B to D and", "3ii1XBac8o8-00047-00016235-00016480": "then back to B I need to be able to get", "3ii1XBac8o8-00048-00016481-00016810": "directly from B to B and so that's a", "3ii1XBac8o8-00049-00016811-00017065": "pair that our three gives us in other", "3ii1XBac8o8-00050-00017066-00017281": "words it takes three of the black arrows", "3ii1XBac8o8-00051-00017282-00017590": "to make one of the blue arrows so B to C", "3ii1XBac8o8-00052-00017591-00017965": "C to D and B gives us B B likewise we", "3ii1XBac8o8-00053-00017966-00018256": "also get CC and DD from the completion", "3ii1XBac8o8-00054-00018257-00018847": "of this triangle and now we can convince", "3ii1XBac8o8-00055-00018848-00019012": "ourselves this is it there are no more", "3ii1XBac8o8-00056-00019013-00019168": "arrows that need to be drawn there's no", "3ii1XBac8o8-00057-00019169-00019459": "our four there is an hour our four is", "3ii1XBac8o8-00058-00019460-00019750": "empty there are no paths of length four", "3ii1XBac8o8-00059-00019751-00020131": "in this relation the BCD triangle is", "3ii1XBac8o8-00060-00020132-00020269": "totally finished right there are no new", "3ii1XBac8o8-00061-00020270-00020518": "paths that can appear there and because", "3ii1XBac8o8-00062-00020519-00020743": "a comes out to be and nothing goes back", "3ii1XBac8o8-00063-00020744-00021022": "to a there are no paths to a that we", "3ii1XBac8o8-00064-00021023-00021247": "need to complete we've got the relation", "3ii1XBac8o8-00065-00021248-00021562": "R star the transitive closure which is", "3ii1XBac8o8-00066-00021563-00021811": "equal to all of the pairs that we just", "3ii1XBac8o8-00067-00021812-00022732": "found so we've got a B AC and AD we've", "3ii1XBac8o8-00068-00022733-00024680": "got b b b c d c b c c c d and DB DC DD", "3ii1XBac8o8-00069-00024681-00025001": "easier to say maybe is that our star is", "3ii1XBac8o8-00070-00025002-00025592": "also the union of our r2 and r3 that's", "3ii1XBac8o8-00071-00025593-00025742": "an easier way to write it down and", "3ii1XBac8o8-00072-00025743-00025901": "that's what this following theorem says", "3ii1XBac8o8-00073-00025902-00026122": "let R be a relation on X then the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00074-00026123-00026389": "transitive closure R is the infinite", "3ii1XBac8o8-00075-00026391-00026618": "union which is not on here denoted our", "3ii1XBac8o8-00076-00026619-00026902": "star although it should be", "3ii1XBac8o8-00077-00026902-00027341": "it's the infinite union of our r2 r3 etc", "3ii1XBac8o8-00078-00027342-00027539": "or the infant union is the set of all", "3ii1XBac8o8-00079-00027539-00027737": "ordered pairs that are at least one of", "3ii1XBac8o8-00080-00027738-00027935": "these compositions", "3ii1XBac8o8-00081-00027936-00028223": "so since r4 we kind of ran out of new", "3ii1XBac8o8-00082-00028224-00028460": "pairs we only had to take the finite", "3ii1XBac8o8-00083-00028461-00028823": "relation R r2 r3 but in general that's", "3ii1XBac8o8-00084-00028824-00029422": "still an infinite union with empty sets", "3ii1XBac8o8-00085-00029423-00029681": "all right let's have one more example", "3ii1XBac8o8-00086-00029682-00029908": "here now normally this is where I do an", "3ii1XBac8o8-00087-00029910-00030116": "example every semester about direct", "3ii1XBac8o8-00088-00030117-00030383": "flights to and from airports but given", "3ii1XBac8o8-00089-00030383-00030701": "the current situation in the world that", "3ii1XBac8o8-00090-00030702-00030845": "doesn't seem like a very appropriate", "3ii1XBac8o8-00091-00030845-00031088": "example so let's try another one let's", "3ii1XBac8o8-00092-00031089-00031252": "see an application of the transitive", "3ii1XBac8o8-00093-00031254-00032452": "closure", "3ii1XBac8o8-00094-00032453-00033488": "let X be the set a b c d e f and what", "3ii1XBac8o8-00095-00033489-00033644": "this is is this is instead of friends a", "3ii1XBac8o8-00096-00033645-00033872": "is Alice beats Bob sees Carlos he's", "3ii1XBac8o8-00097-00033873-00034250": "Derek he'll be Erica and F will be Frank", "3ii1XBac8o8-00098-00034251-00035495": "and define a relation as follows in the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00099-00035496-00036166": "past two weeks", "3ii1XBac8o8-00100-00036167-00037267": "Alice hung out with Carlos who hung out", "3ii1XBac8o8-00101-00037268-00038093": "with Derek and Erica and Erica hung out", "3ii1XBac8o8-00102-00038094-00039241": "with Bob Frank stayed Oh", "3ii1XBac8o8-00103-00039242-00039577": "let's call this relation R and we want", "3ii1XBac8o8-00104-00039578-00040303": "to find our star we have Alice let's set", "3ii1XBac8o8-00105-00040304-00040456": "our vertices up the right way we have", "3ii1XBac8o8-00106-00040457-00040546": "Alice", "3ii1XBac8o8-00107-00040547-00041016": "we have Carlos we have Derrick and Erica", "3ii1XBac8o8-00108-00041017-00041470": "we have Bob and then we have Frank all", "3ii1XBac8o8-00109-00041471-00041500": "right", "3ii1XBac8o8-00110-00041501-00041692": "so hung out with is a symmetric relation", "3ii1XBac8o8-00111-00041693-00041881": "so every time I draw an arrow I'm going", "3ii1XBac8o8-00112-00041882-00042022": "to draw another arrow pointing the other", "3ii1XBac8o8-00113-00042023-00042382": "way so Alice hung out with Carlos which", "3ii1XBac8o8-00114-00042383-00042696": "means that Carlos hung out with Alice", "3ii1XBac8o8-00115-00042697-00042937": "Derek hung out with Carlos and Carlos", "3ii1XBac8o8-00116-00042938-00043261": "hung out with Derek and likewise with", "3ii1XBac8o8-00117-00043262-00043860": "Erica and then Erica hung out with Bob", "3ii1XBac8o8-00118-00043861-00044353": "Frank oh no nobody okay", "3ii1XBac8o8-00119-00044354-00044635": "so we're trying to find the transitive", "3ii1XBac8o8-00120-00044636-00044827": "closure so now I'm going to include the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00121-00044828-00045178": "are two pairs so since Alice hung out", "3ii1XBac8o8-00122-00045179-00045313": "with Carlos and Carlos hung out with", "3ii1XBac8o8-00123-00045314-00045613": "Derek it means that Derek and Alice are", "3ii1XBac8o8-00124-00045614-00046258": "connected in our to likewise Derek and", "3ii1XBac8o8-00125-00046259-00046509": "Erica are connected in our to so are", "3ii1XBac8o8-00126-00046510-00047350": "Carlos and Bob Frank gets no additional", "3ii1XBac8o8-00127-00047351-00047767": "arrows now we're going to let the blue", "3ii1XBac8o8-00128-00047768-00048226": "pin represent all of the three paths so", "3ii1XBac8o8-00129-00048227-00048973": "that connects Alice and Bob connects", "3ii1XBac8o8-00130-00048974-00049674": "Alice and Erica", "3ii1XBac8o8-00131-00049675-00050035": "we're getting a little messy here we've", "3ii1XBac8o8-00132-00050036-00050410": "been forgetting our loops so even though", "3ii1XBac8o8-00133-00050411-00050542": "they're not super relevant in the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00134-00050543-00050857": "interpretation of this example Alice's", "3ii1XBac8o8-00135-00050858-00051013": "connected everybody's connected to", "3ii1XBac8o8-00136-00051014-00051286": "themselves in r2 because everybody's got", "3ii1XBac8o8-00137-00051287-00051502": "a double arrow leading to and from", "3ii1XBac8o8-00138-00051503-00051942": "themselves in r1 all right so this loops", "3ii1XBac8o8-00139-00051944-00052054": "on there now even though like I said", "3ii1XBac8o8-00140-00052054-00052167": "they're not super relevant to the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00141-00052169-00052459": "context of the problem so all our red", "3ii1XBac8o8-00142-00052460-00052680": "arrows sort of complete triangles all", "3ii1XBac8o8-00143-00052682-00052938": "our blue arrows sort of complete squares", "3ii1XBac8o8-00144-00052939-00053205": "so this is done and so what we notice is", "3ii1XBac8o8-00145-00053207-00053524": "that in the transitive closure Alice Bob", "3ii1XBac8o8-00146-00053525-00053803": "Carlos Erica and Derek are all kind of", "3ii1XBac8o8-00147-00053804-00054052": "now related to each other whereas Frank", "3ii1XBac8o8-00148-00054053-00054199": "who was never related to anybody in the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00149-00054200-00054502": "same who in the first place is still", "3ii1XBac8o8-00150-00054503-00054745": "separate from everybody like I said I'll", "3ii1XBac8o8-00151-00054746-00054982": "leave it to you to consider the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00152-00054983-00055339": "relevance of this example so our star", "3ii1XBac8o8-00153-00055340-00055666": "the transitive closure is equal to the", "3ii1XBac8o8-00154-00055666-00055912": "twenty five pairs that we can make from", "3ii1XBac8o8-00155-00055913-00056095": "the five elements ABCDE", "3ii1XBac8o8-00156-00056096-00056278": "but rather than write all this down I", "3ii1XBac8o8-00157-00056279-00056760": "will simply call it ABCDE times", "3ii1XBac8o8-00158-00056761-00057400": "ABCDE it's equal also to our Union r2", "3ii1XBac8o8-00159-00057401-00057910": "Union r3 hello I regret to inform you", "3ii1XBac8o8-00160-00057911-00058123": "that video had a mistake I said we were", "3ii1XBac8o8-00161-00058124-00058269": "done with the transitive closure of", "3ii1XBac8o8-00162-00058270-00058585": "ABCDEF and I was wrong so going back to", "3ii1XBac8o8-00163-00058586-00058959": "look at it it looks like the pair's", "3ii1XBac8o8-00164-00058960-00059266": "DB and BD need to be drawn in with a", "3ii1XBac8o8-00165-00059266-00059482": "blue marker and in fact you can tell", "3ii1XBac8o8-00166-00059483-00059761": "right since I said that ABCD and E had", "3ii1XBac8o8-00167-00059762-00059914": "all been related to each other in every", "3ii1XBac8o8-00168-00059915-00060148": "possible way that should have 25 arrows", "3ii1XBac8o8-00169-00060149-00060385": "and if you count it only has 23 arrows", "3ii1XBac8o8-00170-00060386-00060595": "so you need to include two more blue", "3ii1XBac8o8-00171-00060596-00061051": "arrows between D and I think I said B", "3ii1XBac8o8-00172-00061052-00061249": "right yeah be going in both directions", "3ii1XBac8o8-00173-00061250-00061641": "so I apologize for the mistake"}}, {"audio_id": "3iovJSgfJny", "text": {"3iovJSgfJny-00000-00000003-00000245": "hey guys happy July 31st it is currently", "3iovJSgfJny-00001-00000246-00000653": "4 a.m. and we are headed to Orlando we", "3iovJSgfJny-00002-00000654-00001000": "have a seven ish hour car drive ahead of", "3iovJSgfJny-00003-00001001-00001265": "us it sounds really bad but honestly", "3iovJSgfJny-00004-00001266-00001469": "usually it's really not that bad once", "3iovJSgfJny-00005-00001470-00001718": "you're like actually doing it it says", "3iovJSgfJny-00006-00001719-00001892": "we're gonna arrive at like 11:00 so", "3iovJSgfJny-00007-00001893-00002165": "let's get driving so it is almost 9 a.m.", "3iovJSgfJny-00008-00002166-00002443": "and we have two and a half hours left to", "3iovJSgfJny-00009-00002444-00002560": "go so we're gonna get there at late", "3iovJSgfJny-00010-00002561-00002783": "11:20 ish and I think our first stop is", "3iovJSgfJny-00011-00002784-00002954": "gonna be Katy we just turned on", "3iovJSgfJny-00012-00002955-00003122": "University for only a couple minutes", "3iovJSgfJny-00013-00003123-00003329": "away from the sorority house we have so", "3iovJSgfJny-00014-00003329-00003613": "much to do today basically we're gonna", "3iovJSgfJny-00015-00003614-00003878": "go there empty as much as we can out of", "3iovJSgfJny-00016-00003879-00004081": "the car try to go to her storage unit", "3iovJSgfJny-00017-00004082-00004358": "drop me off of my facial he's probably", "3iovJSgfJny-00018-00004359-00004529": "gonna do homework or like stay around", "3iovJSgfJny-00019-00004530-00004777": "the area then after my facial hopefully", "3iovJSgfJny-00020-00004778-00004994": "we can go to Home Depot and get some", "3iovJSgfJny-00021-00004995-00005404": "stuff and then we're gonna go to the", "3iovJSgfJny-00022-00005405-00005620": "Airbnb I have to finish up a twenty", "3iovJSgfJny-00023-00005621-00005900": "first side and he's probably gonna take", "3iovJSgfJny-00024-00005901-00006151": "a nap and then we're gonna go back there", "3iovJSgfJny-00025-00006152-00006460": "do more stuff empty everything out", "3iovJSgfJny-00026-00006461-00006713": "organize it's just gonna be a long day", "3iovJSgfJny-00027-00006714-00006889": "and then I just texted Laura and we're", "3iovJSgfJny-00028-00006890-00007112": "gonna get sushi later so you know of", "3iovJSgfJny-00029-00007113-00007295": "course we're gonna go to Fujiyama we are", "3iovJSgfJny-00030-00007295-00007502": "gonna get there at 11:09 and we shaped", "3iovJSgfJny-00031-00007503-00007789": "don't like a lot of time she made you", "3iovJSgfJny-00032-00007790-00008408": "are gonna get there yeah and we stopped", "3iovJSgfJny-00033-00008409-00008630": "for like a good like 20 minutes or even", "3iovJSgfJny-00034-00008631-00008777": "more because we were getting gas and", "3iovJSgfJny-00035-00008778-00009552": "like getting food and stuff", "3iovJSgfJny-00036-00009553-00010801": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00037-00010802-00011099": "this year I'm upgraded I'm living with", "3iovJSgfJny-00038-00011100-00011333": "the president so I am in the president's", "3iovJSgfJny-00039-00011334-00011525": "suite so I wanted to give you guys a", "3iovJSgfJny-00040-00011526-00011708": "room tour just because it is a little", "3iovJSgfJny-00041-00011709-00011942": "bit bigger and a little bit different so", "3iovJSgfJny-00042-00011943-00012080": "as you can see you right when you walk", "3iovJSgfJny-00043-00012081-00012230": "in there's just already so much more", "3iovJSgfJny-00044-00012231-00012452": "space like near the desks and stuff and", "3iovJSgfJny-00045-00012453-00012587": "I think we're gonna like actually ever", "3iovJSgfJny-00046-00012588-00012710": "desks together this year which is", "3iovJSgfJny-00047-00012711-00012983": "exciting and then this is gonna be", "3iovJSgfJny-00048-00012984-00013160": "Tiffany's side I'm gonna change that", "3iovJSgfJny-00049-00013161-00013463": "picture - Tiffany sorry Charlotte but", "3iovJSgfJny-00050-00013463-00013706": "that is Tiffany side and then this is my", "3iovJSgfJny-00051-00013707-00013994": "side not sure what I'm gonna do about", "3iovJSgfJny-00052-00013994-00014168": "that area but maybe put a mirror or", "3iovJSgfJny-00053-00014169-00014330": "something like that this year I have an", "3iovJSgfJny-00054-00014331-00014615": "actual closet just like that last year", "3iovJSgfJny-00055-00014616-00014780": "it was like kind of just like popped out", "3iovJSgfJny-00056-00014781-00014987": "and like a big white box kind of closet", "3iovJSgfJny-00057-00014988-00015227": "like not a built-in one which was kind", "3iovJSgfJny-00058-00015228-00015538": "of weird but yeah I have a closet this", "3iovJSgfJny-00059-00015540-00015851": "year mm-hmm this is all my stuff", "3iovJSgfJny-00060-00015852-00016058": "my rug my mattress had all that stuff", "3iovJSgfJny-00061-00016059-00016352": "they let us keep it in here this do you", "3iovJSgfJny-00062-00016353-00016571": "usually like to have it but this was so", "3iovJSgfJny-00063-00016572-00016750": "helpful so for storage we have these", "3iovJSgfJny-00064-00016751-00016964": "drawers and then we also have that one", "3iovJSgfJny-00065-00016965-00017246": "and then we have my desk over here I", "3iovJSgfJny-00066-00017247-00017546": "love this desk it's just so big and then", "3iovJSgfJny-00067-00017547-00017831": "these are the famous head boards from", "3iovJSgfJny-00068-00017832-00018100": "last year we want to paint them brown so", "3iovJSgfJny-00069-00018101-00018319": "we're gonna try to retain them and we", "3iovJSgfJny-00070-00018320-00018629": "stain them and then this is a beautiful", "3iovJSgfJny-00071-00018630-00018863": "view of the presidents room we have like", "3iovJSgfJny-00072-00018864-00019124": "a courtyard view it's super cute so we", "3iovJSgfJny-00073-00019125-00019303": "actually got everything out of my car", "3iovJSgfJny-00074-00019304-00019574": "and like probably like 15 minutes it was", "3iovJSgfJny-00075-00019575-00019757": "so fast I just found out my roommate", "3iovJSgfJny-00076-00019758-00019919": "tiffany is only moving in on Friday", "3iovJSgfJny-00077-00019920-00020072": "which is kind of nice because I have", "3iovJSgfJny-00078-00020073-00020339": "time to like get my [__] together but", "3iovJSgfJny-00079-00020340-00020537": "right now everything is all over the", "3iovJSgfJny-00080-00020538-00020600": "place", "3iovJSgfJny-00081-00020601-00020962": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00082-00020963-00021278": "we're at Morningstar storage I feel like", "3iovJSgfJny-00083-00021279-00021464": "I remember not putting that much in", "3iovJSgfJny-00084-00021465-00021689": "there so hopefully we don't have that", "3iovJSgfJny-00085-00021690-00021965": "much to bring back because that'd be", "3iovJSgfJny-00086-00021966-00022097": "really nice if we doesn't have to do", "3iovJSgfJny-00087-00022098-00022289": "multiple trips just because it is no", "3iovJSgfJny-00088-00022290-00023275": "veto minutes so we are running from", "3iovJSgfJny-00089-00023276-00023591": "packing to a facial what we are not I am", "3iovJSgfJny-00090-00023592-00023729": "getting a facial I made an appointment", "3iovJSgfJny-00091-00023730-00023984": "with my girl Molly she's so good at", "3iovJSgfJny-00092-00023985-00024203": "extractions so I'm really pumped to just", "3iovJSgfJny-00093-00024204-00024452": "get all my texture off my face just got", "3iovJSgfJny-00094-00024453-00024662": "out of my facial as you can hear and see", "3iovJSgfJny-00095-00024663-00024986": "we are at Home Depot right now and oh my", "3iovJSgfJny-00096-00024987-00025223": "god that thing is so annoying but we got", "3iovJSgfJny-00097-00025224-00025490": "stain to restain my headboard and now", "3iovJSgfJny-00098-00025491-00025631": "we're gonna get a stander while we're", "3iovJSgfJny-00099-00025632-00026504": "here we're about to get a big storm holy", "3iovJSgfJny-00100-00026505-00027433": "crap guys I have no idea where to start", "3iovJSgfJny-00101-00027433-00028833": "I think", "3iovJSgfJny-00102-00028833-00029450": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00103-00029451-00030025": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00104-00030026-00030339": "so we just had Fujiyama with Laura and", "3iovJSgfJny-00105-00030341-00030575": "Antonio so it was really great seeing", "3iovJSgfJny-00106-00030576-00030782": "you around a little southern apart but", "3iovJSgfJny-00107-00030783-00030958": "now we are gonna go pick up some Amazon", "3iovJSgfJny-00108-00030960-00031164": "packages that I ordered to here and", "3iovJSgfJny-00109-00031166-00031427": "we're gonna use the Amazon store it is", "3iovJSgfJny-00110-00031427-00031570": "like the coolest thing ever I'm so", "3iovJSgfJny-00111-00031572-00031754": "excited to show Ryan because I always", "3iovJSgfJny-00112-00031755-00037855": "talk about it with him separately", "3iovJSgfJny-00113-00037856-00040037": "2 Chainz how are you it's live on the", "3iovJSgfJny-00114-00040038-00042585": "Rhine Kim right now on these boxes", "3iovJSgfJny-00115-00042586-00042885": "we are using the same rug from last year", "3iovJSgfJny-00116-00042886-00043062": "this is literally from like my old house", "3iovJSgfJny-00117-00043063-00043292": "my dad just like wasn't using it so I", "3iovJSgfJny-00118-00043293-00043608": "was lucky enough to inherit it I guess", "3iovJSgfJny-00119-00043609-00043998": "so it is currently 944 and we are pretty", "3iovJSgfJny-00120-00043999-00044223": "much wrapping up for the day it's been a", "3iovJSgfJny-00121-00044224-00044454": "very long day but we pretty much put", "3iovJSgfJny-00122-00044455-00044712": "away all my clothes I kind of stuffed a", "3iovJSgfJny-00123-00044713-00044860": "lot of things in my closet just so I can", "3iovJSgfJny-00124-00044861-00045027": "deal with it tomorrow so now it looks a", "3iovJSgfJny-00125-00045028-00045237": "little bit better everything's like on", "3iovJSgfJny-00126-00045238-00045432": "my side not really like Tiffany's side I", "3iovJSgfJny-00127-00045433-00045654": "felt really bad about that I will start", "3iovJSgfJny-00128-00045655-00045888": "the vlog again for tomorrow I have an", "3iovJSgfJny-00129-00045889-00046123": "early appointment with experiential", "3iovJSgfJny-00130-00046124-00046305": "learning for my internship this semester", "3iovJSgfJny-00131-00046306-00046523": "also tomorrow is my two best friends", "3iovJSgfJny-00132-00046524-00046821": "21st syenite and so we're going to wind", "3iovJSgfJny-00133-00046822-00047007": "on Wednesday so that's gonna be really", "3iovJSgfJny-00134-00047008-00047154": "fun I've never personally been to", "3iovJSgfJny-00135-00047155-00047260": "learned on Wednesday and I'm very", "3iovJSgfJny-00136-00047261-00047451": "excited because he's never been downtown", "3iovJSgfJny-00137-00047452-00047658": "Orlando so signing off for the night", "3iovJSgfJny-00138-00047659-00047860": "I'll see you guys and good morning and", "3iovJSgfJny-00139-00047861-00048157": "happy August first I feel like in my", "3iovJSgfJny-00140-00048158-00048393": "mind like August 1st is kind of like a", "3iovJSgfJny-00141-00048394-00048598": "new year just because like school starts", "3iovJSgfJny-00142-00048599-00048795": "that month and stuff and like you're", "3iovJSgfJny-00143-00048796-00048967": "trying to get settled in especially like", "3iovJSgfJny-00144-00048968-00049119": "in college like everything's different", "3iovJSgfJny-00145-00049120-00049311": "it's pretty early right now because I'm", "3iovJSgfJny-00146-00049312-00049557": "an appointment with the advisor for like", "3iovJSgfJny-00147-00049558-00049761": "my internship course and that is that 9", "3iovJSgfJny-00148-00049762-00049992": "a.m. and then after that hopefully we", "3iovJSgfJny-00149-00049993-00050175": "can get started on restaining my head", "3iovJSgfJny-00150-00050176-00050335": "boards just because we're already like", "3iovJSgfJny-00151-00050336-00050611": "in are like working clothes and then", "3iovJSgfJny-00152-00050612-00050836": "after that I have to get ready for wind", "3iovJSgfJny-00153-00050837-00051123": "on Wednesday I'm super pumped I'm so", "3iovJSgfJny-00154-00051124-00051287": "excited to see my friends it's been like", "3iovJSgfJny-00155-00051288-00051540": "like 2 months or the three months or", "3iovJSgfJny-00156-00051541-00051657": "something I thought so I'm very excited", "3iovJSgfJny-00157-00051658-00051904": "to be reunited with everyone yesterday I", "3iovJSgfJny-00158-00051904-00052174": "finished up Kaelyn sign so this is what", "3iovJSgfJny-00159-00052175-00052387": "it looks like it was kind of like", "3iovJSgfJny-00160-00052388-00052648": "pixelated because it was basically like", "3iovJSgfJny-00161-00052649-00052866": "stretched out too much it just looked", "3iovJSgfJny-00162-00052867-00053116": "like very low-quality I'm not sure if", "3iovJSgfJny-00163-00053116-00053379": "you can tell that I painted it but yeah", "3iovJSgfJny-00164-00053380-00053575": "it was low-quality so I kind of wanted", "3iovJSgfJny-00165-00053576-00053742": "just like cover it up so like I painted", "3iovJSgfJny-00166-00053744-00053971": "this part this part obviously the lime", "3iovJSgfJny-00167-00053972-00054298": "and just like the bottom of this and I", "3iovJSgfJny-00168-00054299-00054471": "just like blended it out kind of and", "3iovJSgfJny-00169-00054472-00056115": "then I added some glitter to the lime", "3iovJSgfJny-00170-00056116-00056638": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00171-00056639-00057160": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00172-00057161-00057680": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00173-00057682-00058941": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00174-00058942-00059683": "it's time to unbox the stain", "3iovJSgfJny-00175-00059684-00059972": "all right", "3iovJSgfJny-00176-00059973-00060229": "well it's a little dark trick this is", "3iovJSgfJny-00177-00060230-00060512": "the color dark walnut so this is the", "3iovJSgfJny-00178-00060513-00060866": "before we did this last year we stain it", "3iovJSgfJny-00179-00060866-00061124": "gray and then this is the after will of", "3iovJSgfJny-00180-00061125-00061346": "like sanding it so it's just a little", "3iovJSgfJny-00181-00061347-00061469": "bit more distressed we couldn't get all", "3iovJSgfJny-00182-00061470-00061784": "the gray out but I like practice my", "3iovJSgfJny-00183-00061785-00062195": "little brown on there so yeah honestly", "3iovJSgfJny-00184-00062196-00062354": "we should have probably just just stress", "3iovJSgfJny-00185-00062354-00062585": "it like that cuz that looks really good", "3iovJSgfJny-00186-00062586-00062870": "but oh well we're gonna be round now so", "3iovJSgfJny-00187-00062871-00063079": "with the help of riot we retained my", "3iovJSgfJny-00188-00063080-00063260": "boards but I think we're gonna go back", "3iovJSgfJny-00189-00063261-00063437": "and try to like to stress them a little", "3iovJSgfJny-00190-00063438-00063674": "bit with the standard but while in the", "3iovJSgfJny-00191-00063675-00063824": "process of that I think I got like", "3iovJSgfJny-00192-00063825-00064127": "sawdust in my eye and it really hurts", "3iovJSgfJny-00193-00064128-00064304": "it feels so uncomfortable and like I", "3iovJSgfJny-00194-00064304-00064577": "just want to like take something so hard", "3iovJSgfJny-00195-00064578-00064829": "because it was sound like mad that this", "3iovJSgfJny-00196-00064829-00065041": "happened it feels so bad but while we", "3iovJSgfJny-00197-00065042-00065300": "wait for the stain to dry on the boards", "3iovJSgfJny-00198-00065301-00065477": "we're gonna go get my everyone's done", "3iovJSgfJny-00199-00065478-00065639": "hopefully they're like not too sensitive", "3iovJSgfJny-00200-00065640-00065954": "with the [__] in my eye but yeah so I", "3iovJSgfJny-00201-00065955-00066128": "haven't got my eyebrows done since like", "3iovJSgfJny-00202-00066129-00066263": "maybe the first week of summer I", "3iovJSgfJny-00203-00066264-00066413": "remember like going to a place in", "3iovJSgfJny-00204-00066414-00066635": "Georgia and once again they prove to my", "3iovJSgfJny-00205-00066636-00066923": "point of don't go to someone like you", "3iovJSgfJny-00206-00066924-00067067": "don't trust which is hard because like", "3iovJSgfJny-00207-00067068-00067235": "how do you even like build up a", "3iovJSgfJny-00208-00067236-00067400": "relationship without trying new people", "3iovJSgfJny-00209-00067401-00067559": "and like obviously I'm not gonna live in", "3iovJSgfJny-00210-00067560-00067745": "Orlando forever probably gonna go back", "3iovJSgfJny-00211-00067746-00067973": "to Atlanta so I'm gonna have to like", "3iovJSgfJny-00212-00067974-00068227": "find someone good but hopefully I can", "3iovJSgfJny-00213-00068228-00068492": "get recommendations from my mom and my", "3iovJSgfJny-00214-00068493-00068633": "sister when I go back so if you guys", "3iovJSgfJny-00215-00068634-00068795": "have watched my blogs before you know I", "3iovJSgfJny-00216-00068796-00069146": "go to Venus brows and I go to Layla to", "3iovJSgfJny-00217-00069147-00069290": "get them so I think the last time I", "3iovJSgfJny-00218-00069291-00069440": "talked to you guys I was like blinking", "3iovJSgfJny-00219-00069441-00069716": "like a psychopath because I had", "3iovJSgfJny-00220-00069717-00069902": "something in my eye and it was funny", "3iovJSgfJny-00221-00069903-00070064": "because it lasted for like I don't know", "3iovJSgfJny-00222-00070065-00070259": "like more than like an hour or two and", "3iovJSgfJny-00223-00070260-00070472": "then right when Ryan was like okay", "3iovJSgfJny-00224-00070473-00070622": "that's it like I'm gonna go get like an", "3iovJSgfJny-00225-00070623-00071087": "eye flush okay what to call yeah he like", "3iovJSgfJny-00226-00071088-00071249": "went to the store and got it for me", "3iovJSgfJny-00227-00071250-00071423": "and then right when he came back it", "3iovJSgfJny-00228-00071424-00071648": "magically disappeared it was so weird", "3iovJSgfJny-00229-00071649-00071888": "because literally the minute before he", "3iovJSgfJny-00230-00071889-00072164": "walked in it hurts so freakin bad it's", "3iovJSgfJny-00231-00072165-00072314": "like still a little bit uncomfortable", "3iovJSgfJny-00232-00072315-00072469": "but it just feels like there's", "3iovJSgfJny-00233-00072470-00072673": "an eyelash in my eye instead of like a", "3iovJSgfJny-00234-00072674-00072847": "whole piece of like frickin what in my", "3iovJSgfJny-00235-00072848-00073066": "eye but moving forward we are heading to", "3iovJSgfJny-00236-00073067-00073405": "my two best friends 21st 9 9 actually", "3iovJSgfJny-00237-00073406-00073603": "like sign days because like we're doing", "3iovJSgfJny-00238-00073604-00073783": "wined on Wednesday and it starts at 5:00", "3iovJSgfJny-00239-00073784-00074146": "p.m. so we are heading towards there I'm", "3iovJSgfJny-00240-00074147-00074353": "going to help with decorations and just", "3iovJSgfJny-00241-00074354-00074488": "set everything up really quick", "3iovJSgfJny-00242-00074489-00074656": "are you excited for your first time at", "3iovJSgfJny-00243-00074657-00075349": "northland versus real time no but yeah", "3iovJSgfJny-00244-00075350-00075742": "my like yes that too but like on my", "3iovJSgfJny-00245-00075743-00075910": "semi-formals and stuff like yeah they", "3iovJSgfJny-00246-00075911-00076102": "were in downtown Orlando on sorority", "3iovJSgfJny-00247-00076103-00076273": "functions you're not like really allowed", "3iovJSgfJny-00248-00076274-00076501": "to like go other places so you just stay", "3iovJSgfJny-00249-00076502-00076660": "at that venue so like yeah he's been", "3iovJSgfJny-00250-00076661-00076798": "laying downtown but like not to an", "3iovJSgfJny-00251-00076799-00077218": "actual like cool bar so I'm very excited", "3iovJSgfJny-00252-00077219-00077374": "to show around even though I've only", "3iovJSgfJny-00253-00077375-00077614": "been there like one other time like what", "3iovJSgfJny-00254-00077615-00078702": "it's not our social we are on duty a", "3iovJSgfJny-00255-00078703-00079205": "visa man I know you do", "3iovJSgfJny-00256-00079206-00079678": "kaylynn knows her sign infer am a girl", "3iovJSgfJny-00257-00079679-00080144": "like told her and you know and I thought", "3iovJSgfJny-00258-00080145-00080342": "Corona so I can cause with him oh my god", "3iovJSgfJny-00259-00080343-00080531": "I was I was thinking of getting them but", "3iovJSgfJny-00260-00080532-00080657": "I was like and she'll have him at the", "3iovJSgfJny-00261-00080658-00080894": "bar you know you're my guesses okay", "3iovJSgfJny-00262-00080895-00081817": "let's have this um my dogs Kathy or Ryan", "3iovJSgfJny-00263-00081818-00082019": "show us in her room", "3iovJSgfJny-00264-00082020-00082160": "Kaitlyn and Charlotte are living", "3iovJSgfJny-00265-00082161-00082307": "together this year so that's exciting", "3iovJSgfJny-00266-00082308-00082607": "and relative your house is a beautiful", "3iovJSgfJny-00267-00082608-00083234": "like I mean it might be a little bit odd", "3iovJSgfJny-00268-00083235-00083474": "but a there you go like eat at water", "3iovJSgfJny-00269-00083475-00083687": "through - yeah we got a lot of you're", "3iovJSgfJny-00270-00083688-00083885": "late ya know when you like you're", "3iovJSgfJny-00271-00083886-00084095": "writing your own fish right yeah that's", "3iovJSgfJny-00272-00084096-00084254": "all it was like darling right next to", "3iovJSgfJny-00273-00084255-00086114": "you Charlotte um to her should I shave", "3iovJSgfJny-00274-00086115-00089008": "or should I shave this in your chest", "3iovJSgfJny-00275-00089009-00089078": "[Applause]", "3iovJSgfJny-00276-00089079-00089764": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00277-00089765-00090074": "very City", "3iovJSgfJny-00278-00090075-00091130": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00279-00091131-00091544": "look how fancy this bathroom is I don't", "3iovJSgfJny-00280-00091545-00091763": "think I deserve this right now I think", "3iovJSgfJny-00281-00091764-00091935": "I'm just so used to like pub and live at", "3iovJSgfJny-00282-00091936-00092226": "my place Wow so we got our fruits mine I", "3iovJSgfJny-00283-00092227-00092703": "literally asked so many yeah but now", "3iovJSgfJny-00284-00092704-00094442": "it's raining I mean it's like drizzling", "3iovJSgfJny-00285-00094443-00095524": "wine now now our first stop is Joy's egg", "3iovJSgfJny-00286-00095525-00096142": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00287-00096143-00096491": "I go", "3iovJSgfJny-00288-00096492-00097175": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00289-00097176-00097800": "[Music]", "3iovJSgfJny-00290-00097801-00098105": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3iDPEzjQ-_o", "text": {"3iDPEzjQ-_o-00000-00000000-00000371": "start at and this is our teaching and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00001-00000372-00000688": "learning call for August 3rd", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00002-00000689-00000923": "I believe we're in August already this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00003-00000924-00001199": "year is just like most of them they keep", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00004-00001200-00001397": "going faster and faster every year I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00005-00001398-00001523": "think", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00006-00001524-00001630": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00007-00001632-00001768": "so let me go ahead and share my screen", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00008-00001769-00002171": "just so you guys", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00009-00002172-00002495": "um so as far as announcements go Sakai", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00010-00002496-00002710": "Khan recordings are available if you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00011-00002711-00002939": "didn't already get the email that went", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00012-00002940-00003155": "out to all attendees", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00013-00003156-00003395": "um those are up there's a playlist on", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00014-00003396-00003725": "the um Sakai YouTube channel so you can", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00015-00003726-00003983": "see all of the recordings there or if", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00016-00003984-00004379": "you go back into the Sakai Khan site on", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00017-00004380-00004691": "try to Kai we left it open for people", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00018-00004692-00004936": "um the links are embedded there so where", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00019-00004937-00005141": "the join session links used to be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00020-00005142-00005356": "there's a view recording link for the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00021-00005357-00005506": "the actual discussions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00022-00005507-00005861": "you can get to them in either location", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00023-00005862-00005951": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00024-00005952-00006125": "the oh another announcement that I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00025-00006126-00006720": "forgot to put on here is um that Sakai", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00026-00006722-00007181": "22.1 came out last week I think it was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00027-00007181-00007409": "um and so that's out and available if", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00028-00007409-00007564": "anybody was waiting on the dot One", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00029-00007565-00007720": "release", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00030-00007722-00008003": "um it's out in the wild now", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00031-00008004-00008260": "um and I think the next release is going", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00032-00008261-00008363": "to be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00033-00008364-00008596": "21 Dot", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00034-00008597-00008777": "or", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00035-00008778-00009023": "um which should be soon", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00036-00009024-00009209": "um and then there might be one more", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00037-00009210-00009527": "release in the 20 line the 20.6 will be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00038-00009528-00009695": "the last one I'm not sure exactly when", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00039-00009696-00009989": "that's coming but it should be Fairless", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00040-00009990-00010246": "um so if you were at the PMC call", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00041-00010247-00010523": "yesterday uh Earl went over all the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00042-00010524-00010745": "release dates it's just kind of a recap", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00043-00010746-00010937": "for folks", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00044-00010938-00011224": "um so those are all my announcements", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00045-00011225-00012317": "does anybody else have any announcements", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00046-00012318-00012509": "okay", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00047-00012510-00012677": "um so we'll go ahead and move on to our", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00048-00012678-00012971": "agenda um it's a fairly short agenda so", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00049-00012972-00013283": "far but I did have a section on Friday I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00050-00013284-00013421": "figured it'd probably take us maybe 10", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00051-00013422-00013607": "minutes X", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00052-00013608-00013853": "um to talk about uh Community guidelines", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00053-00013854-00014099": "for conversations and then we'll go into", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00054-00014100-00014338": "jira's so far there's only one jira", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00055-00014340-00014566": "that's been suggested but we can uh", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00056-00014568-00014771": "do look at the filter and see if there's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00057-00014772-00014915": "any others that pop up that would", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00058-00014916-00015107": "interest", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00059-00015108-00015311": "um so the conversations Community", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00060-00015312-00015599": "guidelines if you've been into the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00061-00015600-00015935": "conversations tool you may have seen", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00062-00015936-00016150": "that there's an option there for the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00063-00016151-00016319": "instructor to enable Community", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00064-00016319-00016439": "guidelines", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00065-00016440-00016691": "and um and the the instructor has", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00066-00016692-00016919": "control over what that says there's a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00067-00016920-00017177": "text box that they can edit", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00068-00017178-00017375": "um but we wanted to provide something", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00069-00017376-00017669": "for people to start with so it wasn't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00070-00017670-00017807": "just blank", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00071-00017808-00017993": "um so the team at Duke that we've been", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00072-00017994-00018221": "working with to develop", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00073-00018222-00018539": "um the uh the tool came up with this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00074-00018540-00018791": "this was largely based on some of their", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00075-00018792-00019013": "codes of conduct that they have um just", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00076-00019014-00019427": "for General use in in their courses but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00077-00019428-00019703": "we kind of distilled it down and made it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00078-00019704-00020039": "um somewhat generic so that it could fit", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00079-00020040-00020303": "you know a wide variety of use cases", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00080-00020304-00020549": "again it's customizable this would just", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00081-00020550-00020722": "be the default text", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00082-00020723-00021077": "and um it would be the default text for", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00083-00021078-00021407": "an institution but if the institution", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00084-00021408-00021605": "had their own that they wanted to be the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00085-00021606-00021797": "default and said you know you can always", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00086-00021798-00022067": "go into the message bundle manager and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00087-00022068-00022264": "change things and so potentially that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00088-00022265-00022403": "would be a place where you could put", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00089-00022404-00022625": "your custom default", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00090-00022626-00022841": "um instead but anyway so we wanted to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00091-00022842-00023171": "just kind of run this past folks on the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00092-00023172-00023447": "teaching and learning call to see if you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00093-00023448-00023663": "think this is a good default statement", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00094-00023664-00024005": "or if you think it needs any tweaks", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00095-00024006-00024335": "um so the statement here as as written", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00096-00024336-00024658": "is respect that others opinions and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00097-00024659-00024893": "beliefs may differ from your own if you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00098-00024894-00025085": "disagree May critique the idea but not", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00099-00025086-00025342": "the person use inclusive language when", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00100-00025343-00025528": "referring to others avoid assumptions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00101-00025529-00025708": "about others especially based on their", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00102-00025710-00025978": "perceived social groups and identities", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00103-00025979-00026218": "so that we just kind of left in at that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00104-00026219-00026399": "as a starter", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00105-00026400-00027161": "um so what do you guys think about that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00106-00027162-00027514": "it sounds open-ended enough", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00107-00027516-00027731": "and simple in the sense that it's not", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00108-00027732-00027893": "long and lengthy", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00109-00027894-00028001": "great", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00110-00028002-00028211": "yeah we didn't want this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00111-00028212-00028343": "Humane statement", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00112-00028344-00028505": "detailed they could certainly do so", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00113-00028506-00028714": "that's that's beautifully done whoever", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00114-00028716-00029140": "wrote it very very nice", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00115-00029141-00029405": "yep yeah Jennifer they can modify an", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00116-00029406-00029567": "individual instructor can modify it or", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00117-00029568-00029939": "the institution could modify the default", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00118-00029939-00030202": "it is per class so every instance of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00119-00030204-00030407": "conversations can have its own", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00120-00030408-00031001": "guidelines", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00121-00031002-00031127": "all right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00122-00031127-00031264": "so", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00123-00031266-00031535": "um okay good I was hoping that you guys", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00124-00031536-00031793": "would agree that it's a good statement", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00125-00031794-00031918": "um so I did have a couple of questions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00126-00031919-00032117": "for for the teaching and learning group", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00127-00032118-00032345": "about this is", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00128-00032345-00032489": "um well the first one we've kind of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00129-00032489-00032674": "already covered people seem to like it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00130-00032675-00032879": "and no suggestions for things that you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00131-00032880-00033005": "want to add", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00132-00033006-00033257": "thing missing Maybe", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00133-00033258-00033851": "you want to leave that to the instructor", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00134-00033852-00034240": "I think it sounds fine", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00135-00034241-00034518": "um one question that came up is that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00136-00034519-00034883": "they wanted to know if teaching learning", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00137-00034884-00035093": "should periodically review the default", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00138-00035094-00035285": "guideline text", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00139-00035286-00035512": "over time", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00140-00035513-00035629": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00141-00035630-00035837": "personally I didn't think that was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00142-00035838-00035999": "necessary because we don't do that for", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00143-00036000-00036396": "anything else", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00144-00036397-00036671": "yeah and I told him I'm like we're not", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00145-00036672-00036874": "that systematic", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00146-00036875-00037096": "no but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00147-00037097-00037252": "um but I you know they're like well can", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00148-00037253-00037409": "you pose the question I'm like all right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00149-00037410-00037643": "I'll ask", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00150-00037644-00037774": "um I mean yeah I guess we could review", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00151-00037775-00037937": "it every year but man that would be a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00152-00037938-00038207": "lot of yeah that's a lot of texture", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00153-00038208-00038405": "review I think well not only that but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00154-00038406-00038579": "depending upon the instance and whether", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00155-00038580-00038680": "or not people are actually using", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00156-00038681-00038873": "conversations or not at the time and we", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00157-00038874-00039071": "we still have 20.6 that's supposed to be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00158-00039072-00039227": "coming out sometime soon which doesn't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00159-00039228-00039377": "have conversations", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00160-00039378-00039593": "right you know so it's like are we", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00161-00039594-00039868": "reviewing it to eke out a Nat of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00162-00039869-00040187": "of you know usefulness", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00163-00040188-00040367": "and I mean it's pretty", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00164-00040368-00040529": "just written", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00165-00040530-00040865": "by it internally so they might not even", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00166-00040866-00041129": "be using the same one this is just the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00167-00041130-00041357": "default", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00168-00041358-00041561": "no", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00169-00041562-00041746": "anyway so I think we don't need to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00170-00041747-00041987": "review it periodically I am an agreement", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00171-00041988-00042155": "that we do not need to review it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00172-00042156-00044662": "periodically", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00173-00044663-00044915": "I'll also put it on here", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00174-00044916-00046246": "thank goodness", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00175-00046247-00046462": "um so any other thoughts on the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00176-00046463-00047195": "community guidelines before we move on", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00177-00047196-00047417": "through a readability Checker and it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00178-00047418-00047680": "kind of it has it really high on the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00179-00047681-00048011": "grade level and scale level and it's not", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00180-00048012-00048329": "very readable that's true I I do I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00181-00048330-00048449": "understand what Matthew is saying that's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00182-00048450-00048652": "true there's a lot of difficult it says", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00183-00048653-00048874": "there's almost 20 difficult words and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00184-00048875-00049087": "things like that so I don't know how", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00185-00049088-00049433": "accessible the guidelines are so usually", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00186-00049434-00049702": "it's a really good point like a fifth", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00187-00049703-00049865": "fifth or sixth grade raid level even", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00188-00049866-00050068": "though we're kind of I know Sakai is", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00189-00050069-00050249": "typically used in higher ed but it seems", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00190-00050250-00050423": "like it may be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00191-00050424-00050740": "you know a little I don't know a little", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00192-00050741-00050915": "too", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00193-00050916-00051251": "high level text that's but I don't know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00194-00051252-00051401": "how I would", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00195-00051402-00051682": "change it or you know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00196-00051683-00051916": "simplify it I guess maybe a little dude", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00197-00051917-00052073": "that's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00198-00052074-00052732": "uh uh", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00199-00052733-00053044": "just just seeing it initially I I I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00200-00053045-00053213": "understand when you read it but when I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00201-00053214-00053530": "look at it on on either pad I'm like um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00202-00053532-00053687": "it just", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00203-00053688-00053969": "a blob of text for me", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00204-00053970-00054311": "so can you think of ways to reword it or", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00205-00054312-00054461": "should we just say that we thought it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00206-00054462-00054665": "was too high low", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00207-00054666-00054863": "hmm", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00208-00054864-00055061": "we can Workshop it a little bit if we", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00209-00055062-00055313": "can come up with a better version of it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00210-00055314-00055559": "yeah I think it might be good to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00211-00055560-00055853": "Workshop it um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00212-00055854-00056194": "just because having something that's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00213-00056195-00056423": "too high level", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00214-00056424-00056711": "is likely to turn off a lot of people if", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00215-00056712-00056969": "they feel it's like okay that's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00216-00056970-00057425": "you know useless to me", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00217-00057426-00057779": "and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00218-00057779-00058066": "I I see it easier if we can", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00219-00058067-00058397": "make it at a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00220-00058398-00058811": "little more easy to understand level", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00221-00058812-00058979": "we'll find a balance there where it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00222-00058979-00059363": "not feeling you know patronizing", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00223-00059364-00059994": "yeah I'm thinking maybe some", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00224-00059995-00060376": "short short bullet statements to kind of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00225-00060377-00060742": "make it distinct points and reword them", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00226-00060744-00061313": "slightly as well but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00227-00061314-00061571": "yeah the the uh the the flesh reading", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00228-00061572-00061847": "ease I I pasted that uh a website I used", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00229-00061848-00061973": "and it says there's there's a flush", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00230-00061974-00062230": "score and it says it's it's uh it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00231-00062232-00062742": "rated as insurance document language", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00232-00062744-00063700": "highest possible language of text", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00233-00063701-00063923": "I'm looking at the netiquette guidelines", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00234-00063924-00064204": "I give our students and some of these", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00235-00064205-00064385": "might be useful to adapt I've got you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00236-00064386-00064582": "know always be polite there's no tone to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00237-00064583-00064732": "printed text on the screen so it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00238-00064733-00064919": "easier to read something as rude even if", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00239-00064920-00065135": "the writer did not intend it to be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00240-00065136-00065350": "so the easiest way to prevent this is by", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00241-00065351-00065525": "being more polite than you would be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00242-00065526-00065963": "talking in person", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00243-00065964-00066179": "that's a great rule I just I think it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00244-00066180-00066485": "a little long though yeah well I was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00245-00066486-00066826": "your fault yeah and then for as an", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00246-00066827-00067067": "alternative to that first paragraph I've", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00247-00067068-00067223": "got respect to the opinions and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00248-00067224-00067397": "experiences of others even if your own", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00249-00067398-00067949": "is completely different", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00250-00067950-00068171": "yeah I like that wording better", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00251-00068172-00068843": "it just seems to simplify it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00252-00068844-00069144": "we should keep track of our", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00253-00069145-00070619": "reworded version so let's um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00254-00070620-00070799": "I just feel like if there's a default it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00255-00070800-00071123": "should be you know pretty accessible to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00256-00071124-00071279": "whatever wants to use it because like I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00257-00071280-00071387": "think like the majority of people are", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00258-00071388-00071567": "not going to change the default", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00259-00071568-00071963": "or probably not at least not at the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00260-00071964-00072143": "system level maybe at the course level", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00261-00072144-00072569": "yeah right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00262-00072570-00072791": "okay so", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00263-00072792-00072976": "um the first sentence there respect", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00264-00072977-00073132": "others opinions in Middle East you have", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00265-00073133-00073415": "a good um alternative to that first", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00266-00073416-00073661": "was that again it was respect the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00267-00073662-00073859": "opinions and experiences of others even", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00268-00073860-00075335": "if your own is completely different", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00269-00075336-00075659": "I still think we need the list starting", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00270-00075660-00075791": "here", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00271-00075792-00076085": "I I always try to go by my I've got one", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00272-00076086-00076294": "other netiquette guideline", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00273-00076295-00076456": "I don't think there's room for it in", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00274-00076457-00076576": "here but I just feel like sharing it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00275-00076577-00076691": "because it'll probably make you guys", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00276-00076692-00076841": "chuckle too", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00277-00076842-00077062": "okay be careful about posting anything", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00278-00077063-00077273": "when you are tired sick or having a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00279-00077274-00077471": "terrible day you're just", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00280-00077472-00077632": "those times and you are more likely to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00281-00077633-00077975": "come across as angry or rude", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00282-00077976-00078244": "I like that one a lot I don't know if I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00283-00078245-00078526": "want to put it in as the default but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00284-00078527-00078815": "um but it is it is appropriate", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00285-00078816-00079169": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00286-00079170-00079312": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00287-00079313-00079511": "that's good advice does conversations", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00288-00079512-00079979": "have a safe draft and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00289-00079980-00080255": "it does have a safe draft option", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00290-00080256-00080500": "um if the school just has a um a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00291-00080501-00080747": "standard uh", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00292-00080748-00081047": "longer version of this can't they can't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00293-00081048-00081250": "we just link to it and just say you know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00294-00081251-00081431": "Please be aware that you've agreed to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00295-00081432-00081731": "the school's guidelines on X and here's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00296-00081732-00081929": "the link to the PDF that resides", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00297-00081930-00082049": "someplace else", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00298-00082050-00082259": "I mean you certainly could", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00299-00082260-00082409": "um but it requires people to actually", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00300-00082410-00082576": "click a link and go somewhere and read", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00301-00082577-00082847": "something yeah thank you usually it's a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00302-00082848-00083129": "little more apparent difficult if it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00303-00083130-00083393": "right there in your face versus having", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00304-00083394-00083573": "to go to a link to see it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00305-00083574-00083735": "could be like oh yeah okay I agree", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00306-00083736-00083950": "without reading it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00307-00083951-00084167": "I know I do that with like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00308-00084168-00084449": "stuff that do you accept all these terms", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00309-00084450-00084611": "and it's like you know yeah you've lost", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00310-00084612-00086412": "your right to actually sue somebody yep", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00311-00086413-00086753": "thank you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00312-00086754-00087047": "okay so does respect the opinions and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00313-00087048-00087221": "experiences of others even if your own", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00314-00087222-00087443": "is completely different adequately", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00315-00087444-00087647": "cover everything that's said in the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00316-00087648-00087881": "above statement", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00317-00087882-00088247": "I think there's a few things", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00318-00088248-00088505": "touched on above that are missing but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00319-00088506-00088750": "they're kind of hinted at", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00320-00088751-00089062": "so I don't know how explicit we need to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00321-00089063-00089944": "be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00322-00089945-00090137": "you could even you know add on to what", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00323-00090138-00090437": "you have there with just um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00324-00090438-00090605": "the word", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00325-00090606-00090947": "you know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00326-00090948-00091253": "remember we are yeah I I was rereading", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00327-00091254-00091387": "it three times", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00328-00091388-00091709": "so the next sentence then if you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00329-00091710-00091888": "disagree you may critique the idea but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00330-00091889-00092021": "not the person does that is that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00331-00092022-00092188": "readable enough does", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00332-00092189-00092435": "it should that I really liked that I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00333-00092436-00092650": "don't know about others but I liked it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00334-00092651-00092843": "yeah I think it's appropriate because um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00335-00092844-00092981": "I think from an educational standpoint", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00336-00092982-00093215": "you know if they're talking about Hitler", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00337-00093216-00093376": "as the content then they may talk about", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00338-00093377-00093587": "Hitler and that's fine but as we're", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00339-00093588-00093694": "talking about someone else in their", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00340-00093695-00093809": "class", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00341-00093810-00093959": "um that may that may might need to be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00342-00093960-00094121": "hedged quite a bit", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00343-00094122-00094318": "and I'll skip the con content we're", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00344-00094319-00094475": "talking about about the concepts rather", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00345-00094476-00094643": "than you know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00346-00094644-00094865": "Landing accusations individually", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00347-00094866-00095111": "in the course", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00348-00095112-00095885": "or something", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00349-00095886-00096443": "I use inclusive language", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00350-00096444-00097343": "we need to state that separately", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00351-00097344-00097529": "I think we might want to rewrite that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00352-00097530-00098194": "and I think we should rewrite it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00353-00098195-00098411": "because inclusive language if they don't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00354-00098412-00098555": "know exactly what that means if we're", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00355-00098556-00098759": "teaching them that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00356-00098760-00098885": "right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00357-00098886-00099173": "so we might want to how would we best", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00358-00099174-00099491": "Define that red country Ohio where", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00359-00099492-00100799": "inclusive language is considered ill", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00360-00100800-00101165": "how about just avoid attacking others", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00361-00101166-00101465": "uh avoid", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00362-00101466-00101632": "oh my gosh there's so many things you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00363-00101633-00101824": "could get in trouble with yeah I know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00364-00101825-00102053": "I'm trying to like stop attacking your", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00365-00102054-00102701": "friends and neighbors there", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00366-00102702-00103186": "another way to say inclusively", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00367-00103188-00103780": "without like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00368-00103781-00104027": "the definition of inclusively language", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00369-00104028-00104165": "that avoids the use of certain", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00370-00104166-00104327": "expressions or words that might be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00371-00104328-00104549": "considered", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00372-00104550-00104668": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00373-00104669-00105113": "exclude particular groups of people", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00374-00105114-00109758": "which really isn't much clearer yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00375-00109759-00110116": "foreign just like the the whole second", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00376-00110117-00110290": "half of that avoid assumptions about", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00377-00110291-00110423": "others especially based on their", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00378-00110424-00110627": "perceived social groups or identities", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00379-00110628-00111040": "it's just yeah don't discriminate I did", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00380-00111041-00111184": "I like that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00381-00111185-00111708": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00382-00111709-00112102": "as a griefest that you know be always be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00383-00112103-00112277": "polite", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00384-00112278-00112499": "even if you're talking to fifth graders", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00385-00112500-00112763": "that's right you're absolutely right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00386-00112764-00113027": "always be played", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00387-00113028-00113219": "very nicely done", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00388-00113220-00113423": "so sometimes short and simple does the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00389-00113424-00116393": "trick", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00390-00116394-00116597": "s always be polite", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00391-00116598-00116813": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00392-00116814-00117083": "cover the inclusive language point or is", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00393-00117083-00117802": "that covered in the avoid assumptions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00394-00117803-00117940": "just wondering if we need to say", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00395-00117941-00118102": "anything in there about don't use", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00396-00118103-00120367": "language that excludes others", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00397-00120368-00120775": "[Music]", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00398-00120776-00121043": "anybody else", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00399-00121044-00121228": "just stuck on that inclusive language", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00400-00121229-00126071": "term", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00401-00126072-00128584": "foreign", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00402-00128585-00128807": "but that is that too", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00403-00128808-00129058": "eyebrow I just felt like I needed", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00404-00129059-00129178": "something in there to address the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00405-00129179-00129389": "inclusivity", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00406-00129390-00130108": "treatment", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00407-00130109-00130301": "and we simplified a little inside maybe", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00408-00130302-00130578": "avoid expressions or words that may", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00409-00130579-00130852": "exclude particular people rather than", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00410-00130853-00131051": "they might be considered", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00411-00131052-00131189": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00412-00131190-00132677": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00413-00132678-00133564": "all right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00414-00133565-00134669": "are we happy with that version", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00415-00134670-00134897": "that's good", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00416-00134898-00135228": "I will pass that along to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00417-00135229-00135545": "conversations Development Group and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00418-00135546-00135766": "we'll um get that updated text and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00419-00135767-00136475": "there's the defaults", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00420-00136476-00136643": "so we have", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00421-00136644-00137140": "um a couple of jiras it looks like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00422-00137141-00137321": "what is one", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00423-00137322-00137789": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00424-00137790-00138163": "first one here here", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00425-00138164-00138454": "and Christina do you want to get us up", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00426-00138455-00138652": "to speed on this one", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00427-00138653-00139049": "um someone from triage yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00428-00139050-00139540": "um just the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00429-00139541-00139751": "the best way to describe it is actually", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00430-00139752-00140075": "through the screenshot that he attached", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00431-00140076-00140381": "if you had a assignment that's graded", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00432-00140382-00140602": "using points", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00433-00140603-00140981": "ungraded is null if you've got letter", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00434-00140982-00141275": "pass fail or check mark", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00435-00141276-00141652": "it shows on the word ungraded in the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00436-00141653-00141907": "grade column rather than null", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00437-00141908-00142283": "so he created this jira", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00438-00142284-00142589": "um this was created by uh", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00439-00142590-00142895": "but he created this jira just to uh", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00440-00142896-00143207": "suggests that the points should match", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00441-00143208-00143477": "the others I just raised the question of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00442-00143478-00143759": "you know should points match the others", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00443-00143760-00143945": "or should the others match points what", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00444-00143946-00144113": "is the desired", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00445-00144114-00144335": "if something is not graded do we want", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00446-00144336-00144514": "the grade to be null or do we want it to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00447-00144515-00144778": "show ungraded", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00448-00144779-00145090": "well it seems like the ungraded is more", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00449-00145091-00145349": "of a status than a grade", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00450-00145350-00145613": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00451-00145614-00145864": "the status of that particular submission", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00452-00145865-00146159": "is upgraded but it's a status related to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00453-00146160-00146423": "the grade not the stats related to the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00454-00146424-00146609": "submission which is what the status", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00455-00146610-00146928": "column actually is", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00456-00146929-00147383": "[Music]", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00457-00147384-00147616": "is the status column will show things", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00458-00147617-00147935": "like not submitted submitted I think", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00459-00147936-00148211": "just draft right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00460-00148212-00148421": "so that's like the student submission", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00461-00148422-00148547": "status", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00462-00148548-00148835": "hey I think that that column is for the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00463-00148836-00149033": "student not for the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00464-00149034-00149177": "I mean for the faculty it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00465-00149178-00149471": "informational but for the student and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00466-00149472-00149687": "point of view they would they see that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00467-00149688-00149933": "their item is ungraded well this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00468-00149934-00150101": "continuously you don't get this table", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00469-00150102-00150563": "okay instructor", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00470-00150564-00150827": "Jennifer just what I was asking is what", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00471-00150828-00150989": "should all of them do should we change", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00472-00150990-00151216": "points to match the others or should we", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00473-00151217-00151625": "change the other three to match points", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00474-00151626-00152221": "foreign", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00475-00152222-00152639": "I think I would probably prefer to see", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00476-00152640-00152878": "at all or maybe not", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00477-00152879-00153137": "playing maybe like the little Dash to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00478-00153138-00153526": "show that it's empty", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00479-00153527-00153785": "because it's less text on the screen it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00480-00153786-00155321": "makes this table less text Heavy", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00481-00155322-00155549": "Jennifer I don't think students see this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00482-00155550-00155819": "table at all this is the instructor", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00483-00155820-00157576": "review of the submissions correct", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00484-00157577-00157847": "yeah you have to go into the grade", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00485-00157848-00158111": "as the instructor okay yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00486-00158112-00158459": "students don't see this table", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00487-00158460-00158699": "but since they depending on the type", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00488-00158700-00159089": "then points check mark letter effect", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00489-00159090-00159426": "we would change all of them to be not", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00490-00159427-00159676": "it's nice to see the word that they", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00491-00159677-00159814": "didn't grade it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00492-00159815-00160139": "that it isn't just blank I mean or hmm", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00493-00160140-00160319": "Christina you got me on this one should", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00494-00160320-00160552": "it be blank to save screen space", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00495-00160553-00160859": "what does it look like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00496-00160860-00161111": "I'm good at asking though", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00497-00161112-00161501": "you are good questions yeah let's let's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00498-00161502-00161740": "go look and see", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00499-00161741-00161951": "I'm very good at asking the questions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00500-00161952-00162263": "that don't really have an easy answer", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00501-00162264-00163675": "I love it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00502-00163676-00163907": "uh hopefully one of these already has", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00503-00163908-00164254": "the assignments", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00504-00164255-00165169": "language", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00505-00165170-00165754": "lots of language", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00506-00165755-00166354": "all right well I'll just add it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00507-00166355-00166601": "this is bothering me I'm gonna", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00508-00166602-00166925": "again it's a different user Maybe", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00509-00166926-00167261": "courses that don't have that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00510-00167262-00167573": "I had an instructor I don't know if it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00511-00167574-00167854": "still", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00512-00167855-00168709": "foreign", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00513-00168710-00169104": "[Music]", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00514-00169105-00169457": "'s cleaner all right so um we need the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00515-00169458-00172228": "assignment tool on the Great Book", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00516-00172229-00173069": "right so if it's points", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00517-00173070-00173549": "so when you go to grade", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00518-00173550-00174113": "this here is blank", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00519-00174114-00174419": "one that's not a grid", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00520-00174420-00175319": "or not not points", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00521-00175320-00176135": "and we want this one to be letter grade", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00522-00176136-00176561": "all right so we go into this one", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00523-00176562-00178733": "it's ungraded", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00524-00178734-00179075": "and I so rarely make things non-points", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00525-00179076-00179302": "that I don't really look at that screen", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00526-00179303-00179513": "very much", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00527-00179514-00179602": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00528-00179603-00179843": "but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00529-00179844-00180113": "I recall correct like anytime there's a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00530-00180114-00180385": "submission it'll say", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00531-00180386-00180659": "submitted not graded or something like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00532-00180660-00183485": "that isn't that true", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00533-00183486-00183766": "yeah so when you submit something it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00534-00183767-00184307": "does say ungraded in the status column", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00535-00184308-00184588": "that's interesting that's very", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00536-00184589-00184775": "interesting", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00537-00184776-00185026": "so I mean it seems like having ungraded", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00538-00185027-00185243": "here is a little bit redundant redundant", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00539-00185244-00185459": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00540-00185460-00186083": "Look At You Christina making it hard", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00541-00186084-00186533": "send chocolate and I'll go away", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00542-00186534-00186652": "now we should give you chocolate for", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00543-00186653-00186887": "coming up with a really good review of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00544-00186888-00187109": "it I like it I think it gives more more", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00545-00187110-00187271": "screen space because of this and you've", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00546-00187272-00187451": "completely changed my mind so I'm now", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00547-00187452-00187547": "with", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00548-00187548-00187685": "with this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00549-00187686-00187883": "so send more chocolate and I'll keep", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00550-00187884-00187925": "looking", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00551-00187926-00188231": "[Laughter]", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00552-00188232-00188638": "yeah so I would I would say we lose the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00553-00188639-00189064": "ungraded in the grade column", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00554-00189065-00189263": "agreed", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00555-00189264-00189443": "anybody else", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00556-00189444-00190199": "hi there dissenting opinions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00557-00190200-00190595": "once going twice", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00558-00190596-00190733": "so", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00559-00190734-00194681": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00560-00194682-00195143": "foreign", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00561-00195144-00195311": "all right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00562-00195312-00195623": "so I'll I'll put a note on that jira", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00563-00195624-00196019": "after the fact", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00564-00196020-00196211": "right now so", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00565-00196212-00196421": "um we'll move on to the next one which", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00566-00196422-00196666": "is", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00567-00196667-00197273": "um I think this was one was one that was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00568-00197274-00198004": "sent To Us by the ux group Maybe", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00569-00198005-00198281": "it was and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00570-00198282-00198526": "um okay submit an attachment link broken", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00571-00198527-00198802": "in new grading page and assignments okay", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00572-00198803-00199049": "I remember this one now", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00573-00199050-00199204": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00574-00199205-00199397": "so I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00575-00199398-00199613": "think Earl was the one that had asked me", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00576-00199614-00199876": "to put this on the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00577-00199877-00200116": "end so he said that there was some", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00578-00200117-00200573": "confusion over like what the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00579-00200574-00200819": "links should look like over here when", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00580-00200820-00201076": "there's an attachment I guess people", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00581-00201077-00201388": "were trying to figure out how to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00582-00201389-00201640": "download the file versus display the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00583-00201641-00201850": "file", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00584-00201851-00202031": "um and there was one suggestion to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00585-00202032-00202193": "making buttons", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00586-00202194-00202438": "and then there was another suggestion I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00587-00202439-00202666": "think to um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00588-00202667-00202997": "did you need two links like I think this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00589-00202998-00203171": "one tells you which one you're viewing", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00590-00203172-00203531": "but this one does too", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00591-00203532-00204088": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00592-00204089-00204304": "I'm not sure what this was he said", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00593-00204305-00204431": "something about people were trying to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00594-00204432-00205084": "copy that link", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00595-00205085-00205312": "I think she was trying to figure out why", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00596-00205313-00205594": "it was broke so trying to show that it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00597-00205596-00205864": "was not giving a link to the file", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00598-00205865-00206194": "so initially I think her concern was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00599-00206196-00206458": "that link at the top Works to download", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00600-00206459-00206614": "but the link", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00601-00206615-00206903": "under submitted attachments didn't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00602-00206904-00207101": "she wasn't aware that if they submitted", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00603-00207102-00207286": "more than one attachment that submitted", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00604-00207287-00207503": "attachments was originally used just to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00605-00207504-00207694": "toggle between them", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00606-00207696-00207982": "okay I get it so I think then the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00607-00207983-00208264": "question was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00608-00208265-00208438": "the submitted attachments is a lot more", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00609-00208439-00208571": "visible", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00610-00208571-00208744": "yes", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00611-00208746-00209014": "so if someone is trying to download it's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00612-00209015-00209542": "not always obvious how they should", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00613-00209544-00209921": "but there was a picture somewhere oh", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00614-00209921-00210089": "yeah this one had like some little", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00615-00210090-00210346": "download buttons I think that was a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00616-00210348-00211360": "proposed fix to add", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00617-00211361-00211558": "so which version", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00618-00211559-00211901": "does this group prefer", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00619-00211902-00212231": "you like the the download buttons here", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00620-00212232-00212573": "or do you you like um let's see this was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00621-00212573-00213005": "another way to go", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00622-00213006-00213196": "this one still doesn't make it clear", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00623-00213198-00213479": "where you go to download right it just", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00624-00213480-00213641": "gives the name of it I like the download", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00625-00213642-00213869": "as it's a as it's a button that's used", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00626-00213869-00214169": "in Mobile as well and yeah that's a very", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00627-00214169-00214432": "obvious download button", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00628-00214433-00214655": "I like that one as well", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00629-00214656-00214960": "so um so these would still stay then as", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00630-00214961-00215231": "links for viewing does that make sense", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00631-00215232-00215573": "to people to have that be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00632-00215573-00215801": "you know you toggle between the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00633-00215802-00216173": "submission attachments or does that need", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00634-00216173-00216406": "to be called out in some way", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00635-00216407-00216779": "I to me it's kind of obvious if I was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00636-00216780-00216923": "seeing it at least a submitted", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00637-00216923-00217192": "attachments and one was showing up I'd", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00638-00217194-00217391": "click the other file to switch between", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00639-00217392-00217648": "them", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00640-00217650-00217792": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00641-00217794-00218201": "is that an issue for accessibility", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00642-00218202-00218584": "or does a screen reader indicate this is", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00643-00218585-00218891": "the file you could download", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00644-00218892-00219275": "the button here", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00645-00219276-00219539": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00646-00219540-00219973": "yeah I guess yeah that's right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00647-00219973-00220265": "it has to be labeled so that you know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00648-00220266-00220667": "which file it's downloading", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00649-00220667-00220919": "but", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00650-00220919-00221231": "um it comes right after that file so it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00651-00221232-00221375": "would read the file name and then the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00652-00221376-00221513": "download button", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00653-00221514-00221758": "right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00654-00221759-00221992": "there we have text is for that and it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00655-00221994-00222173": "does The View", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00656-00222173-00222323": "up here even though it's not super", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00657-00222323-00222532": "noticeable", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00658-00222533-00222779": "um it would also help screen readers", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00659-00222780-00222953": "know which one they're currently viewing", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00660-00222954-00223325": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00661-00223326-00223660": "yeah I like the download buttons", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00662-00223661-00223871": "I do too", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00663-00223871-00224075": "the best", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00664-00224076-00224363": "the bunch as far as", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00665-00224364-00224584": "it does make it a lot more", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00666-00224585-00225094": "clear where you go to download", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00667-00225096-00225317": "all right so we like the buttons yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00668-00225317-00225508": "Jennifer said it had came up for her", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00669-00225509-00226444": "this week too", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00670-00226446-00226673": "for it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00671-00226673-00228358": "almost", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00672-00228359-00229048": "all right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00673-00229050-00229229": "should we write up the that there was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00674-00229230-00229494": "concern about the um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00675-00229496-00229775": "accessibility on that button when that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00676-00229776-00230158": "is labeled properly", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00677-00230159-00230398": "uh how would you phrase that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00678-00230400-00230765": "review for accessibility", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00679-00230766-00230987": "review you know just that that the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00680-00230988-00231179": "screen reader goes in that order and and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00681-00231180-00232739": "that label is for that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00682-00232740-00233381": "any other thoughts", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00683-00233382-00233627": "we've got about 10 minutes left we can", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00684-00233628-00233932": "probably squeeze in one more jira", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00685-00233933-00234094": "um do you guys have a preference as to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00686-00234096-00234803": "which of these two you want to look at", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00687-00234804-00235373": "I have no preference", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00688-00235373-00235601": "let's just go right on all right let's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00689-00235602-00236092": "go to the next one", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00690-00236094-00236765": "it stats most opened file can be null", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00691-00236766-00236965": "okay", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00692-00236966-00237269": "this is another one", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00693-00237269-00237737": "um from triage the trick is if you've", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00694-00237738-00237839": "got", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00695-00237840-00238175": "say Tas looking at the site stats", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00696-00238176-00238510": "and the most open file is one that is", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00697-00238511-00238648": "from another", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00698-00238650-00238913": "section or group that that ta is not a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00699-00238914-00239087": "member of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00700-00239088-00239579": "it shows them null", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00701-00239580-00239705": "okay", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00702-00239706-00240142": "so it's so do Tas get the whole view of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00703-00240144-00240317": "site scouts or do they just see like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00704-00240317-00240610": "they're on sections besides chats I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00705-00240611-00240821": "don't know question I don't know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00706-00240821-00241294": "unknown", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00707-00241296-00241475": "I just knew from looking at the test", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00708-00241476-00241979": "plan of this one on Monday", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00709-00241980-00242231": "so um Jesus was asking he didn't know", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00710-00242232-00242392": "what would be the best option to solve", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00711-00242394-00242603": "this you know having some other string", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00712-00242604-00242891": "instead of the null or do we remove null", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00713-00242892-00243460": "entries that would appear on that table", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00714-00243461-00244134": "foreign", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00715-00244135-00244444": "do they get I mean is it just the file", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00716-00244446-00244792": "name", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00717-00244794-00245092": "I don't know I've never used ta you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00718-00245094-00245356": "never use ta so I yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00719-00245357-00245567": "I mean I'm just wondering if it could", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00720-00245567-00245789": "what it would hurt to show them the file", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00721-00245790-00245975": "name even if they don't have access to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00722-00245976-00246160": "the file", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00723-00246161-00246323": "and if they click if they did find the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00724-00246323-00246484": "file effect it links directly to the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00725-00246485-00246646": "file if I remember correctly yeah I", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00726-00246648-00246803": "think it's just the file name you can't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00727-00246804-00247013": "even open the file from there right from", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00728-00247014-00247541": "there", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00729-00247542-00248010": "foreign", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00730-00248011-00248267": "because they can't see it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00731-00248267-00248375": "yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00732-00248376-00248584": "then it should say", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00733-00248585-00248794": "um unavailable", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00734-00248796-00249346": "yeah unavailable or", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00735-00249348-00249553": "access this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00736-00249554-00249905": "access denied yeah I can't touch with", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00737-00249906-00250284": "some graphic", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00738-00250285-00250619": "it definitely looks weird", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00739-00250619-00251081": "um so maybe", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00740-00251082-00251321": "what's the message you get when you try", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00741-00251321-00251567": "to go to a site you don't have access to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00742-00251567-00251758": "say that available", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00743-00251759-00251848": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00744-00251850-00253156": "I think so maybe file unavailable", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00745-00253157-00255437": "you guys think is that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00746-00255438-00256015": "foreign", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00747-00256016-00256421": "happy with that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00748-00256421-00256679": "we want it like removed completely did", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00749-00256680-00257039": "he offer any", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00750-00257040-00257315": "we remove the null on entries", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00751-00257316-00257801": "so what would you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00752-00257802-00257956": "I don't think we're moving the null", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00753-00257957-00258077": "entries", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00754-00258078-00258269": "would be the answer because it's obvious", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00755-00258269-00258646": "there's files open so yeah it seems like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00756-00258648-00259001": "it would just introduce confusion yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00757-00259002-00259175": "so yeah we don't want to obscure the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00758-00259176-00259360": "data but you know if the person doesn't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00759-00259361-00259582": "have access then it just says", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00760-00259583-00259925": "unavailable you don't have access", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00761-00259926-00260189": "all right so I'll put um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00762-00260190-00260417": "you like file and available instead of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00763-00260417-00260801": "no", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00764-00260802-00261053": "I think that's great", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00765-00261054-00261305": "so let's see do you think we have time", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00766-00261306-00261508": "in four minutes four minutes we can do", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00767-00261509-00262067": "it let's go yeah we can look at it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00768-00262067-00262253": "rubrics", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00769-00262254-00262439": "um external salmon Go Quiz items with", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00770-00262440-00262589": "three Briggs", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00771-00262590-00262906": "bricks in the grade book I put tnl on", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00772-00262907-00263075": "this one a couple weeks ago after triage", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00773-00263076-00263341": "because I think it is actually a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00774-00263342-00263645": "non-issue that needs to be a closed as", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00775-00263646-00263819": "it won't fix", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00776-00263820-00264029": "okay", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00777-00264030-00264287": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00778-00264288-00264575": "he's saying that um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00779-00264576-00264737": "you should be able to see the rubric for", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00780-00264738-00264917": "a test in the grade book", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00781-00264918-00265139": "with the associate Gradebook item", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00782-00265140-00265360": "but in the comments Andrea and I both", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00783-00265361-00265643": "pointed out", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00784-00265644-00265895": "you know you have multiple questions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00785-00265896-00266087": "Rick so you've got multiple graded", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00786-00266088-00266195": "rubrics", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00787-00266196-00266447": "and you can have", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00788-00266448-00266639": "different rubrics for different", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00789-00266640-00266782": "questions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00790-00266783-00266980": "right", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00791-00266981-00267160": "um I think it's related to a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00792-00267161-00267365": "misunderstanding about tests and quizzes", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00793-00267366-00267713": "the other week at the core team meeting", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00794-00267714-00267832": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00795-00267833-00268141": "I kind of got to prove Earl wrong", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00796-00268142-00268439": "that doesn't happen very often you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00797-00268440-00268745": "should get like a badge or something or", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00798-00268746-00268913": "Earl was", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00799-00268914-00268979": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00800-00268980-00269171": "operating under the assumption that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00801-00269172-00269308": "tests and quizzes worked like", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00802-00269309-00269501": "assignments with rubrics that you linked", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00803-00269502-00269789": "the rubric to the test", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00804-00269790-00270058": "yeah no it's to the questions individual", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00805-00270059-00270299": "test questions that's a question and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00806-00270300-00270508": "that you could have different questions", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00807-00270509-00270677": "different rubrics for different", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00808-00270678-00270856": "questions within a single test", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00809-00270857-00271055": "yeah so let me ask a question then how", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00810-00271056-00271169": "does that work when you're providing", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00811-00271170-00271379": "assessment score on a rubric question", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00812-00271380-00271582": "when you have multiple questions that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00813-00271583-00271721": "has the assessment linked to the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00814-00271722-00271937": "gradebook", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00815-00271938-00272141": "that's where", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00816-00272142-00272356": "this that's why I think this is a needs", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00817-00272357-00272693": "to be closed as a what an issue is yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00818-00272694-00272908": "I don't think it can be done", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00819-00272909-00273077": "yeah well what I'm thinking is if you go", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00820-00273078-00273191": "through and you score something with a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00821-00273192-00273305": "rubric and you go to the next question", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00822-00273306-00273460": "it's just going to overwrite whatever", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00823-00273461-00273706": "the score is that you had in a prior", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00824-00273707-00273893": "rubric", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00825-00273894-00274139": "well wouldn't you just enter the score", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00826-00274140-00274337": "from the rubric in the points for that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00827-00274338-00274493": "question and then you move to the next", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00828-00274494-00274697": "question you get a new box for points", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00829-00274698-00274895": "yeah the the rubrics and tests and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00830-00274896-00275093": "quizzes are tied to the question so each", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00831-00275094-00275339": "question can have its own rubric", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00832-00275340-00275543": "right but then if you have a number of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00833-00275544-00275771": "points that are I assume if you're not", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00834-00275772-00275879": "thinking about how you're doing the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00835-00275880-00276191": "design and you make the rubric an amount", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00836-00276192-00276395": "of points that is over and above what", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00837-00276396-00276556": "you want the overall assessment to be", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00838-00276557-00276730": "worth I guess that's not even a problem", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00839-00276731-00276845": "is it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00840-00276846-00277001": "and", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00841-00277002-00277282": "you I mean you would end up with a weird", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00842-00277283-00277553": "score but yeah I think it would let you", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00843-00277554-00277853": "do it but yeah because also too if", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00844-00277854-00278117": "you're manually grading you can uh", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00845-00278118-00278410": "put in a point over the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00846-00278411-00278837": "holiday value yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00847-00278838-00279184": "yeah I agree I think this one's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00848-00279185-00279413": "one way to do it you can't show like 15", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00849-00279414-00279689": "rubrics for one item", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00850-00279690-00279989": "could potentially have that many in a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00851-00279990-00280223": "quiz if you had 15 questions with", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00852-00280224-00280384": "different rubrics", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00853-00280385-00280637": "well here's a idea that just popped into", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00854-00280638-00280895": "my head could you you've got the light", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00855-00280896-00281117": "box that pops up with the rubric", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00856-00281118-00281380": "so it would say rubric you know question", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00857-00281381-00281734": "one if there was next in previous arrows", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00858-00281735-00281969": "click click click see question two", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00859-00281970-00282155": "question three question four question", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00860-00282156-00282419": "five", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00861-00282420-00282665": "that would be a nice way to display it", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00862-00282666-00282934": "but I think I think Adrian's head would", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00863-00282935-00283223": "explode trying to make that happen", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00864-00283224-00283421": "because I know he's always like it needs", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00865-00283422-00283769": "to be a one-to-one Association Adrian's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00866-00283770-00283889": "the one who put in this request", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00867-00283890-00284351": "therefore he wants it oh maybe maybe", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00868-00284352-00284603": "or it's possible he was operating under", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00869-00284604-00285071": "the same assumption that Earl was yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00870-00285072-00285467": "no we can we can put that it needs to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00871-00285468-00285682": "either be closed as a non-issue if", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00872-00285683-00286001": "there's no way to do this or our", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00873-00286002-00286175": "suggestion of you know the light box", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00874-00286176-00286403": "where you go next to next next and view", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00875-00286404-00286619": "each individual", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00876-00286620-00286823": "which would be preferable because then", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00877-00286824-00287069": "you would get all the feedback", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00878-00287070-00287206": "um", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00879-00287207-00287363": "but I don't know if there's a way to do", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00880-00287364-00287699": "it mm-hmm", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00881-00287700-00287956": "if there was though that might help be a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00882-00287957-00288119": "step toward", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00883-00288120-00288245": "um a feature request that I've heard", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00884-00288246-00288449": "from a few people where they want to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00885-00288450-00289253": "attach more than one rubric to something", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00886-00289254-00289391": "yeah I have some instructors now that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00887-00289392-00289510": "when they want to have more than one", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00888-00289511-00289715": "rubric and assignments they'll actually", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00889-00289716-00289895": "just pair it together in a single large", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00890-00289896-00290153": "rubric and like with discussion forums", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00891-00290154-00290284": "so he'll go through and he'll actually", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00892-00290285-00290477": "assess their initial post but then he", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00893-00290478-00290693": "leaves a portion of the rubric blank", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00894-00290694-00290915": "until after they have actually done", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00895-00290916-00291119": "their replies and then he uses the same", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00896-00291120-00291389": "rubric to actually score the replies", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00897-00291390-00291593": "yeah it's a little weird though because", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00898-00291594-00291755": "it's well it's a little weird because", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00899-00291756-00291863": "the students don't get the feedback", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00900-00291864-00292030": "about their initial posts", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00901-00292031-00292247": "yeah until after he's actually finished", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00902-00292248-00292421": "the scoring of the whole thing", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00903-00292422-00292613": "the instructors I have who want to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00904-00292614-00292793": "attach to rubrics want to do it for", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00905-00292794-00292943": "assessment so one rubric is about", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00906-00292944-00293158": "actually giving the students a score", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00907-00293159-00293405": "and the other one is you know trying to", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00908-00293406-00293801": "match that you know final paper to the", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00909-00293802-00294010": "course learning outcomes and then yeah", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00910-00294011-00294227": "achieved those and then exporting those", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00911-00294228-00294460": "rubrics for assessment so they don't", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00912-00294461-00294623": "necessarily want the students to be able", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00913-00294624-00294851": "to see that second half because that's", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00914-00294852-00295139": "fair", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00915-00295140-00295313": "that's nice", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00916-00295314-00295567": "all right so I'll put that in as a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00917-00295568-00295847": "suggestion this is definitely our", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00918-00295848-00296110": "preferred", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00919-00296111-00296447": "solution but um if if they can't do that", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00920-00296448-00296693": "then it should be closed for now", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00921-00296694-00296915": "yeah or kind of put on hold in favor of", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00922-00296916-00297203": "the other", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00923-00297204-00297371": "all right so we are actually over time", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00924-00297372-00297605": "so um we'll go ahead and wrap up here", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00925-00297606-00297875": "because I actually have a", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00926-00297876-00298165": "minute it's late for so", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00927-00298166-00299230": "thank you everybody", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00928-00299231-00299363": "you're the only person in this", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00929-00299364-00299543": "conference", "3iDPEzjQ-_o-00930-00299544-00299844": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "3jmmEPdU7bg", "text": {"3jmmEPdU7bg-00000-00000437-00001527": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00001-00001528-00001972": "feeling it i'm not feeling it today", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00002-00001973-00002223": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00003-00002224-00002555": "i'm not feeling it", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00004-00002556-00002750": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00005-00002751-00003311": "i feel like no reason", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00006-00003311-00003992": "i don't know what i was supposed to do", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00007-00003993-00004917": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00008-00004918-00005135": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00009-00005136-00005375": "today", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00010-00005376-00007134": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00011-00007136-00007646": "but i can't let it in", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00012-00007647-00007915": "just looking for that sweet", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00013-00007916-00008729": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00014-00008730-00010759": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00015-00010760-00011066": "one more verse", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00016-00011067-00012262": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00017-00012263-00012599": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00018-00012600-00013113": "oh", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00019-00013115-00014927": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00020-00014928-00015185": "today", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00021-00015186-00015615": "[Music]", "3jmmEPdU7bg-00022-00015616-00015823": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "3jusUL3MHIc", "text": {"3jusUL3MHIc-00000-00000228-00000907": "foreign", "3jusUL3MHIc-00001-00000908-00003388": "[Music]", "3jusUL3MHIc-00002-00003389-00003765": "foreign", "3jusUL3MHIc-00003-00003767-00004497": "[Music]", "3jusUL3MHIc-00004-00004498-00005056": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "3jv_LZV7NT0", "text": {"3jv_LZV7NT0-00000-00000060-00002883": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00001-00002884-00003407": "um", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00002-00003408-00004283": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00003-00004284-00005107": "uh", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00004-00005108-00008483": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00005-00008484-00011283": "so", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00006-00011284-00012683": "so", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00007-00012684-00015959": "foreign", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00008-00015960-00016883": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00009-00016884-00017316": "so", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00010-00017317-00017451": "[Applause]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00011-00017452-00018283": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00012-00018284-00018939": "hmm", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00013-00018940-00019683": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00014-00019684-00020293": "now", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00015-00020294-00021083": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00016-00021084-00021359": "oh", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00017-00021360-00022107": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00018-00022108-00022844": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00019-00022845-00023883": "[Music]", "3jv_LZV7NT0-00020-00023884-00025272": "oh yeah"}}, {"audio_id": "3jxHUsTuly0", "text": {"3jxHUsTuly0-00000-00000903-00002518": "oh", "3jxHUsTuly0-00001-00002519-00003206": "you might need help", "3jxHUsTuly0-00002-00003207-00003854": "i see it it's glowing", "3jxHUsTuly0-00003-00003855-00004047": "okay look around because you can see", "3jxHUsTuly0-00004-00004047-00004151": "them", "3jxHUsTuly0-00005-00004152-00004295": "by the garage", "3jxHUsTuly0-00006-00004296-00004575": "i saw something by the grass oh", "3jxHUsTuly0-00007-00004576-00004783": "oh that's the one on the house that is", "3jxHUsTuly0-00008-00004784-00004943": "not the one on the house that's the one", "3jxHUsTuly0-00009-00004944-00006321": "on a plant", "3jxHUsTuly0-00010-00006322-00007110": "[Music]", "3jxHUsTuly0-00011-00007111-00007614": "don't put it in people's faces", "3jxHUsTuly0-00012-00007615-00007974": "getting free radiation", "3jxHUsTuly0-00013-00007975-00008183": "get out the old radiation king because", "3jxHUsTuly0-00014-00008184-00008503": "it's like a laser wow", "3jxHUsTuly0-00015-00008504-00008695": "okay from there you should be able to", "3jxHUsTuly0-00016-00008696-00009505": "see another one", "3jxHUsTuly0-00017-00009506-00009655": "[Music]", "3jxHUsTuly0-00018-00009656-00009927": "gotta be creepy", "3jxHUsTuly0-00019-00009928-00010103": "you gotta leopold creepy", "3jxHUsTuly0-00020-00010104-00010383": "they don't go as far as the nail ball no", "3jxHUsTuly0-00021-00010384-00010542": "they don't go as far as a mailbox and", "3jxHUsTuly0-00022-00010543-00011127": "you won't have to walk through the woods", "3jxHUsTuly0-00023-00011128-00012087": "this is this is pretty cool", "3jxHUsTuly0-00024-00012088-00013958": "you need help", "3jxHUsTuly0-00025-00013959-00014447": "cat", "3jxHUsTuly0-00026-00014447-00014607": "she's dressed as kitty cat from the", "3jxHUsTuly0-00027-00014608-00014879": "addams family", "3jxHUsTuly0-00028-00014880-00016038": "oh furry", "3jxHUsTuly0-00029-00016040-00017503": "um", "3jxHUsTuly0-00030-00017504-00018886": "um", "3jxHUsTuly0-00031-00018887-00019919": "oh", "3jxHUsTuly0-00032-00019920-00020630": "i thought it would be on there", "3jxHUsTuly0-00033-00020631-00020967": "now for the vampire chickens", "3jxHUsTuly0-00034-00020968-00021614": "the murder chickens do you", "3jxHUsTuly0-00035-00021615-00021767": "oh that was the one i didn't think you", "3jxHUsTuly0-00036-00021768-00022063": "would find", "3jxHUsTuly0-00037-00022064-00022222": "the one sitting in this like the light", "3jxHUsTuly0-00038-00022223-00022383": "in the basement shining through that", "3jxHUsTuly0-00039-00022384-00023391": "place", "3jxHUsTuly0-00040-00023392-00026006": "okay", "3jxHUsTuly0-00041-00026007-00026150": "okay you should stand here and look", "3jxHUsTuly0-00042-00026151-00026414": "around", "3jxHUsTuly0-00043-00026416-00026631": "[Music]", "3jxHUsTuly0-00044-00026632-00026839": "that's the farthest they go", "3jxHUsTuly0-00045-00026839-00027527": "that one by the shed", "3jxHUsTuly0-00046-00027527-00027817": "that's the limit", "3jxHUsTuly0-00047-00027818-00029511": "[Applause]", "3jxHUsTuly0-00048-00029512-00031279": "okay", "3jxHUsTuly0-00049-00031280-00031687": "hey it's a full moon today", "3jxHUsTuly0-00050-00031688-00032887": "and it'll be up near mars", "3jxHUsTuly0-00051-00032888-00033175": "um", "3jxHUsTuly0-00052-00033176-00033807": "[Applause]", "3jxHUsTuly0-00053-00033808-00033974": "oh people just see me walking around in", "3jxHUsTuly0-00054-00033975-00034095": "my underwear", "3jxHUsTuly0-00055-00034096-00034471": "yep", "3jxHUsTuly0-00056-00034472-00035062": "it's not going to be in the garden", "3jxHUsTuly0-00057-00035063-00035399": "right", "3jxHUsTuly0-00058-00035400-00037374": "nothing unsafe to walk in in the dark", "3jxHUsTuly0-00059-00037375-00038559": "hey", "3jxHUsTuly0-00060-00038560-00040067": "i think i'm gonna have to tell them", "3jxHUsTuly0-00061-00040068-00040199": "[Music]", "3jxHUsTuly0-00062-00040200-00040446": "just just grab it and yank it", "3jxHUsTuly0-00063-00040447-00041895": "there you go", "3jxHUsTuly0-00064-00041896-00042151": "i think that's it", "3jxHUsTuly0-00065-00042152-00042567": "that's it right i think that's it", "3jxHUsTuly0-00066-00042568-00042767": "i think that was 17.", "3jxHUsTuly0-00067-00042768-00043255": "ghost hunter", "3jxHUsTuly0-00068-00043256-00043415": "cletus made it the whole way without", "3jxHUsTuly0-00069-00043416-00044871": "dying", "3jxHUsTuly0-00070-00044872-00045174": "go inside and count", "3jxHUsTuly0-00071-00045175-00045407": "what'd you think", "3jxHUsTuly0-00072-00045408-00045824": "i liked it you liked it"}}, {"audio_id": "3jyj0VcxrOc", "text": {"3jyj0VcxrOc-00000-00000560-00000719": "hello", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00001-00000720-00000927": "my name is lina shibaru from arab", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00002-00000927-00001158": "scientific publishers", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00003-00001159-00001383": "we are the publishers of the beautiful", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00004-00001384-00001663": "children's book book what color is your", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00005-00001664-00001791": "kiss", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00006-00001792-00002151": "in arabic i discovered the book uh what", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00007-00002152-00002463": "color is your kiss by uh by", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00008-00002464-00002702": "rocio", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00009-00002703-00002791": "while", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00010-00002792-00003126": "browsing the institute ramul children", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00011-00003127-00003559": "and young adult books catalog", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00012-00003560-00003975": "what got my my attention at first is", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00013-00003976-00004183": "the title of the book", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00014-00004184-00004527": "and the attractive illustrations", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00015-00004528-00004743": "after reading it i discovered that the", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00016-00004744-00005006": "topic is very very interesting", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00017-00005007-00005415": "it targets colors objects creatures and", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00018-00005416-00005695": "and emotions", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00019-00005696-00006054": "after publishing it in in arabic our", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00020-00006055-00006446": "social media department took in hand uh", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00021-00006447-00006806": "to create a video trailer very nice one", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00022-00006808-00007119": "and post about it on our social media", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00023-00007120-00007455": "accounts", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00024-00007456-00007574": "now", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00025-00007575-00007934": "for the sales of the book a mother came", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00026-00007936-00008151": "came to us", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00027-00008152-00008503": "she already bought the book for her son", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00028-00008504-00008863": "and told us she loved when at the end of", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00029-00008864-00008983": "the book", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00030-00008984-00009231": "all the colors and the shapes were found", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00031-00009232-00009374": "in the case of", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00032-00009375-00009655": "me minimoni's mother", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00033-00009656-00009942": "so all the emotions are in one kiss of", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00034-00009943-00010071": "the mother", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00035-00010072-00010255": "showing that the mother's love", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00036-00010256-00010638": "summarizes everything around us", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00037-00010639-00010903": "now for the questions i would like to", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00038-00010904-00011038": "ask", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00039-00011039-00011310": "erosio", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00040-00011311-00011567": "the following uh questions", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00041-00011568-00011751": "i want to ask", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00042-00011752-00012063": "how did the idea of the book uh come to", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00043-00012064-00012270": "you from where did you get the idea to", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00044-00012271-00012414": "get to", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00045-00012415-00012510": "to write", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00046-00012511-00012631": "this book", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00047-00012632-00012838": "and what topic", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00048-00012839-00013022": "and what topics", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00049-00013023-00013215": "for the future would", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00050-00013216-00013391": "interest you", "3jyj0VcxrOc-00051-00013391-00013772": "thank you so much"}}, {"audio_id": "3jCwqvWCZiM", "text": {"3jCwqvWCZiM-00000-00000000-00000262": "this is web space news for Friday the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00001-00000263-00000848": "21st of October 2022 I'm Commander Burr", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00002-00000849-00001955": "[Music]", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00003-00001955-00002149": "an elite dangerous news this week", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00004-00002150-00002429": "Frontier announced the launch window for", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00005-00002430-00002771": "update 14. there's a genuinely shocking", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00006-00002772-00003107": "twist in the frontier live stream we ask", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00007-00003108-00003479": "if thyroid advocacy is doomed to failure", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00008-00003479-00003790": "a creepy horror movie styled treasure", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00009-00003792-00004109": "hunt appears in-game for Halloween and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00010-00004110-00004265": "More", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00011-00004266-00004445": "we know you get bored of hearing this", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00012-00004446-00004672": "but it really does help our Channel if", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00013-00004673-00004883": "you enjoy our stuff hit like subscribe", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00014-00004884-00005152": "and don't forget the piggy Bell bit you", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00015-00005153-00005356": "can also join our patreon which directly", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00016-00005357-00005572": "supports the work we do here as always", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00017-00005573-00005795": "you'll find links to everything you need", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00018-00005796-00005927": "below", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00019-00005928-00006083": "if you're in the market for more", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00020-00006084-00006352": "Halloween themed ship Cosmetics then", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00021-00006353-00006563": "there's multiple opportunities as we", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00022-00006564-00006827": "kick off the show this week first up all", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00023-00006828-00007073": "manner of Halloween paint jobs suits", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00024-00007073-00007391": "bobble heads and decals are on sale in", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00025-00007392-00007691": "the frontier store until the 31st of", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00026-00007692-00007981": "October with 15 to 30 percent off", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00027-00007981-00008273": "Frontera also releasing Halloween paint", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00028-00008274-00008555": "jobs via their social media channels at", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00029-00008556-00008783": "random intervals for the next week or so", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00030-00008784-00008999": "to be in with a Chance of grabbing those", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00031-00009000-00009167": "just keep your eyes on Facebook", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00032-00009168-00009455": "Instagram the official forums and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00033-00009456-00009706": "Twitter a limited number of content", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00034-00009707-00009953": "creators us included have been given", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00035-00009954-00010192": "access to five codes that will grant the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00036-00010193-00010487": "malevolent ghast exclusive ship paint", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00037-00010488-00010721": "job pack so keep an eye out for those", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00038-00010722-00011003": "your best bet for grabbing a freebie", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00039-00011004-00011296": "paint job however is via the twitch drop", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00040-00011297-00011542": "system the content creators on that", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00041-00011543-00011741": "platform that you can see listed on", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00042-00011742-00011999": "screen now have all got access to the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00043-00012000-00012305": "noctual blight paint jobs which you are", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00044-00012306-00012635": "guaranteed to get just for tuning in and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00045-00012636-00012916": "watching their streams", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00046-00012917-00013163": "my thanks to commanders home Borger and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00047-00013163-00013433": "Alec Turner for this next Gem of a story", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00048-00013434-00013649": "this week if you're in the market for", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00049-00013650-00013835": "some new Elite dangerous reading", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00050-00013836-00014122": "material then the rodent report is a new", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00051-00014123-00014465": "newspaper magazine style Journal being", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00052-00014466-00014801": "published by the fuel rats whilst only", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00053-00014802-00015047": "still in its second issue the rodent", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00054-00015047-00015258": "report is already a polished", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00055-00015259-00015455": "well-constructed and professionally", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00056-00015456-00015719": "written Journal featuring input from", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00057-00015719-00015983": "multiple writers and covering articles", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00058-00015984-00016235": "as diverse as the founding of the fuel", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00059-00016236-00016558": "rats pilot rescue organization fuel", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00060-00016559-00016835": "ratting ship builds interviews with fuel", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00061-00016836-00017153": "rats and even a recipe for a tasty", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00062-00017154-00017363": "looking lentil doll there's even", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00063-00017364-00017644": "crossword puzzles in Universe horoscopes", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00064-00017645-00017927": "and classified ads adorning the pages", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00065-00017928-00018149": "currently the magazine seems to be", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00066-00018150-00018341": "published every two weeks and is", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00067-00018342-00018617": "available to view download or print in", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00068-00018618-00018869": "PDF format to check it out for yourself", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00069-00018870-00019079": "see the links in the video description", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00070-00019080-00019258": "below", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00071-00019259-00019493": "cast your mind back one week and you'll", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00072-00019494-00019691": "likely remember that in this very", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00073-00019692-00019913": "broadcast I was reporting the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00074-00019914-00020158": "confirmation of the discovery of a fifth", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00075-00020159-00020411": "incoming stargoid what a difference a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00076-00020412-00020686": "week can make since then Not only was", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00077-00020687-00020933": "starboard number six discovered but as", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00078-00020934-00021119": "we were putting the show together today", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00079-00021120-00021461": "a seventh stargoid was identified and is", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00080-00021462-00021725": "now being tracked by commanders and the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00081-00021726-00022007": "Canon unidentified Interstellar anomaly", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00082-00022008-00022300": "tracking site a screenshot of which you", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00083-00022301-00022583": "can see on screen now and it presents a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00084-00022584-00022847": "fairly Stark image that point where all", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00085-00022848-00023083": "the lines meet that would be Soul", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00086-00023084-00023333": "arriving as they do in the wake of", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00087-00023334-00023599": "salvation's Shenanigans in", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00088-00023600-00023975": "hip22460 it's a widely accepted but not", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00089-00023976-00024275": "yet proven wisdom that the stargoids are", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00090-00024276-00024593": "thyroid in origin the community goals", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00091-00024594-00024769": "this week that kicked off on Thursday", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00092-00024770-00024953": "concern themselves with the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00093-00024954-00025235": "establishment of a proposed Zeno piece", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00094-00025236-00025517": "in Envoy vessel for use by the thyroid", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00095-00025518-00025822": "advocacy project an organization that is", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00096-00025823-00026027": "currently pushing for more communication", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00097-00026027-00026290": "with our territory neighbors and less", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00098-00026291-00026512": "well attempts to bring about their", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00099-00026513-00026777": "Extinction the prospect of communication", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00100-00026777-00026981": "with the hilariously murdery", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00101-00026982-00027268": "space-faring sour salad has long been a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00102-00027269-00027479": "requested feature in certain quarters of", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00103-00027480-00027755": "the player base and of late the idea has", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00104-00027756-00028001": "become a running theme in the game's", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00105-00028002-00028264": "narrative so is communication and a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00106-00028266-00028552": "peaceful Common Ground after so much bad", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00107-00028554-00028877": "blood and icor actually possible the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00108-00028877-00029057": "jury is very much out on that subject at", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00109-00029058-00029290": "the moment but in the text for this", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00110-00029291-00029531": "week's Community goal Pro thyroid", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00111-00029532-00029818": "advocacy liberal-minded candidate and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00112-00029819-00030124": "federal Governor Dalton chase invokes a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00113-00030125-00030346": "quote from the UK prime minister Neville", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00114-00030347-00030749": "Chamberlain in 1938 waving the Munich", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00115-00030750-00030964": "agreement in the air and claiming quote", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00116-00030966-00031295": "peace in our time unquote less than a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00117-00031295-00031462": "year later following the Munich", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00118-00031463-00031679": "agreement Europe was plunged into the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00119-00031680-00031931": "second world war I'll let you draw your", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00120-00031932-00032140": "own conclusions from that particular", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00121-00032141-00032429": "piece of signposting if indeed that's", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00122-00032430-00032602": "what it is", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00123-00032603-00032855": "the regular Discovery scanner post from", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00124-00032856-00033071": "Frontier that is released at the start", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00125-00033072-00033317": "of the week every week and sets up the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00126-00033318-00033545": "player base for the week ahead contained", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00127-00033546-00033773": "a particularly juicy morsel this week", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00128-00033774-00034085": "update 14 to Elite dangerous Odyssey", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00129-00034086-00034337": "which is the final announced update to", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00130-00034338-00034618": "the game this year is planned to arrive", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00131-00034619-00034912": "at the end of November the update was", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00132-00034913-00035159": "announced way back in May this year and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00133-00035160-00035368": "its headline feature has always been", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00134-00035369-00035668": "billed as quote the next major narrative", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00135-00035669-00035981": "phase unquote whilst back in may we had", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00136-00035982-00036227": "no idea what that narrative phase could", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00137-00036228-00036533": "possibly be referring to these days we", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00138-00036534-00036809": "are slightly more enlightened and as we", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00139-00036810-00037049": "reported earlier in this broadcast we", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00140-00037050-00037259": "are now staring down the throats of", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00141-00037260-00037529": "seven incoming stargoid Interlopers", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00142-00037530-00037805": "whatever they are so we think it's a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00143-00037806-00037985": "fairly safe bet that the new narrative", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00144-00037986-00038212": "phase will be heralded and indeed", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00145-00038213-00038507": "concern itself at least in part with the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00146-00038508-00038711": "expected arrival of of the mysterious", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00147-00038712-00038933": "swirly green whatever they are", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00148-00038934-00039167": "as we reported earlier in the week", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00149-00039168-00039418": "Frontier had announced that they had a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00150-00039419-00039605": "big couple of weeks of cosmetic", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00151-00039606-00039790": "giveaways and events planned for the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00152-00039791-00039989": "game in celebration of the Halloween", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00153-00039990-00040271": "spooky season the events and giveaways", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00154-00040272-00040445": "were all to be kicked off by a special", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00155-00040446-00040649": "Halloween themed edition of the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00156-00040650-00040883": "fortnightly frame shift live live stream", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00157-00040884-00041146": "on Thursday night as well as all the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00158-00041147-00041387": "Cosmetics giveaways and themed live", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00159-00041388-00041602": "stream Frontier had also made it clear", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00160-00041603-00041795": "that there would be a spooky themed", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00161-00041796-00041999": "in-game treasure hunt event for", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00162-00042000-00042239": "commanders to participate in that would", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00163-00042240-00042515": "also reward Cosmetics what we didn't", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00164-00042516-00042712": "realize until we watched the stream last", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00165-00042713-00042946": "night was that the treasure hunt and the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00166-00042947-00043187": "live stream were actually linked and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00167-00043188-00043402": "that the live stream would kick off the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00168-00043403-00043630": "treasure hunt in such a Spooktacular", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00169-00043631-00043846": "fashion if you missed the live stream", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00170-00043847-00044123": "I've linked to a YouTube Archive of it", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00171-00044124-00044333": "below and if you don't want the surprise", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00172-00044334-00044549": "spoiled then I'd recommend going to", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00173-00044550-00044957": "watch that first before carrying on here", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00174-00044958-00045155": "with the spoiler warning out of the way", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00175-00045156-00045383": "if you're still with us here's how it", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00176-00045384-00045658": "went down hosted by Bruce and Sally with", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00177-00045659-00045862": "producer Adam working behind the camera", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00178-00045863-00046133": "the live stream featured the regular gal", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00179-00046134-00046373": "Net News Roundup and Stellar screenshot", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00180-00046374-00046649": "sections as well as extensive details on", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00181-00046650-00046883": "how to obtain the twitch drop free paint", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00182-00046884-00047140": "jobs and cosmetics if you are watching", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00183-00047141-00047374": "live on Twitch in addition to those", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00184-00047375-00047602": "regular expected features the live", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00185-00047603-00047824": "stream also featured games such as", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00186-00047825-00048035": "Pictionary played with the watching", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00187-00048036-00048299": "audience and further cosmetic giveaways", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00188-00048300-00048496": "the real surprise in the live stream", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00189-00048497-00048743": "however was what at first at least", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00190-00048744-00049012": "appeared to be a production error early", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00191-00049013-00049252": "in the Stream the video feed of the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00192-00049253-00049499": "hosts Sally and Bruce were suddenly", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00193-00049500-00049774": "replaced by in-game footage of a ship", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00194-00049775-00050045": "landing at an odyssey settlement Sally", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00195-00050046-00050224": "and Bruce made no mention of it and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00196-00050225-00050446": "their face quickly returned as they", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00197-00050447-00050680": "continued talking later in the Stream", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00198-00050681-00050890": "their images were again replaced by", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00199-00050891-00051136": "footage this time of a nefarious looking", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00200-00051137-00051430": "character in Riva style armor walking", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00201-00051432-00051694": "slowly up to the settlement and taking a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00202-00051695-00051911": "prolonged look at the settlement name", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00203-00051912-00052199": "again the hosts made no mention of the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00204-00052200-00052390": "interruption in video and continue", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00205-00052391-00052649": "talking as if nothing untoward had", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00206-00052650-00052888": "happened it was at this point that we", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00207-00052889-00053099": "figured something else was going on and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00208-00053100-00053338": "immediately headed in-game towards the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00209-00053339-00053632": "settlement shown Henry's Pace in the ra", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00210-00053633-00053921": "system later the video was interrupted", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00211-00053922-00054166": "again showing the same dubious character", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00212-00054167-00054430": "heading toward the bar area and this", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00213-00054432-00054653": "prompted extensive searches of the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00214-00054654-00054863": "habitat and bar area of the settlement", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00215-00054864-00055223": "with nothing unusual being detected it", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00216-00055224-00055409": "was as the stream progressed however", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00217-00055410-00055666": "that proceedings took a suddenly more", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00218-00055667-00055925": "Sinister turn it's become the norm on", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00219-00055926-00056135": "fdev's live streams of late for the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00220-00056136-00056399": "hosts to be green screened into a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00221-00056400-00056644": "setting in the game somewhere some weeks", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00222-00056645-00056788": "they'll be on a fleet carrier another", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00223-00056789-00056950": "week they'll appear to be sitting in", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00224-00056951-00057263": "investor genomics Etc this week they", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00225-00057264-00057485": "were sitting in the bar area of an", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00226-00057486-00057682": "odyssey surface settlement and during", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00227-00057683-00057916": "one section of the stream the character", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00228-00057917-00058097": "that had been seen approaching the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00229-00058098-00058337": "settlement in game in oddly placed", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00230-00058338-00058625": "seemingly unconnected shots suddenly", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00231-00058626-00058853": "walked into frame behind the two F Dev", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00232-00058854-00059116": "hosts paused for a moment and then", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00233-00059117-00059399": "ominously pointed at them before slowly", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00234-00059400-00059657": "walking out of shot again it was then", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00235-00059658-00059873": "that it dawned on us here at the burpit", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00236-00059874-00060071": "that they weren't green screened into", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00237-00060072-00060323": "just any random bar somewhere in the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00238-00060324-00060587": "game they were sitting in the bar at", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00239-00060588-00060875": "Henry's piece in the ra system but the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00240-00060876-00061138": "stream had one more surprise before it", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00241-00061139-00061373": "went off air as Sally and Bruce were", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00242-00061374-00061529": "wrapping up the stream and saying their", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00243-00061529-00061780": "goodbyes the armored character again", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00244-00061782-00062032": "walked into shot behind them this time", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00245-00062033-00062344": "much closer and this is what happened", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00246-00062345-00062573": "next", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00247-00062574-00062729": "huh", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00248-00062729-00063275": "uh excuse me mate can I help you", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00249-00063276-00063526": "and just like that the stream ended", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00250-00063527-00063754": "immediately afterwards galnet news", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00251-00063755-00063988": "sparked up in-game with a story about", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00252-00063989-00064276": "three talk show hosts being murdered and", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00253-00064277-00064553": "a clue being found at the scene and that", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00254-00064554-00064816": "gel net piece starts commanders off on", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00255-00064817-00065080": "the promised Halloween treasure hunt I", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00256-00065082-00065219": "won't spoil what happens with the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00257-00065220-00065411": "treasure hunt suffice to say it's", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00258-00065412-00065699": "typically dark and somewhat Sinister as", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00259-00065700-00065938": "is a lot of Elite's law and completing", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00260-00065939-00066137": "the treasure hunt will indeed reward", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00261-00066138-00066479": "some exclusive cosmetic items all in all", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00262-00066480-00066767": "a very enjoyable stream and in-game", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00263-00066768-00066947": "event definitely one for the history", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00264-00066948-00067235": "books hugely imaginative and brilliantly", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00265-00067236-00067576": "executed on stream by the team with a", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00266-00067577-00067871": "fantastic tie into the game itself as an", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00267-00067872-00068159": "extra spooky special payoff", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00268-00068160-00068369": "have you followed up on the clues on", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00269-00068370-00068597": "galnet are you a believer in thyroid", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00270-00068598-00068837": "advocacy and do you believe the", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00271-00068838-00069143": "stargoids will stop at Lucky Seven let", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00272-00069144-00069371": "us know in the comments below that's it", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00273-00069372-00069521": "for now thanks very much for watching", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00274-00069522-00069731": "we'll be back later this week with more", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00275-00069732-00069988": "videos until then 07 commanders follow", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00276-00069989-00070181": "the greens on the way out and do keep", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00277-00070182-00070379": "clear of the toast rack we very much", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00278-00070380-00071208": "look forward to seeing you next time", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00279-00071209-00071447": "[Music]", "3jCwqvWCZiM-00280-00071448-00071707": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "3jJ3QiaKVec", "text": {"3jJ3QiaKVec-00000-00000139-00000524": "Kennan chocked i cam kak RTGS Khanum", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00001-00000525-00000808": "shocked pronounced k8 naam ta grave k is", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00002-00000809-00001066": "a local desert of Thailand the main", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00003-00001067-00001286": "ingredient of Khanum chalk is sticky", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00004-00001287-00001495": "rice flour palm sugar and shredded", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00005-00001496-00001751": "coconut it is covered by leave of an", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00006-00001752-00001951": "ephah palm and then roasts on a charcoal", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00007-00001952-00002166": "fire", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00008-00002167-00002735": "history Khanum shock can be found in", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00009-00002736-00002933": "many areas in Thailand close to the", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00010-00002934-00003096": "coastal area because all of the", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00011-00003097-00003279": "ingredients basically found in these", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00012-00003279-00003554": "areas the name of Khanum shot came from", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00013-00003555-00003768": "NEPA palm which in thailand is called", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00014-00003769-00004082": "cha tae the reason why Khanum shock you", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00015-00004083-00004239": "snippet palm leave to cover because", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00016-00004240-00004524": "nikla palm leaves make a fragment it is", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00017-00004525-00004725": "the folk wisdom that carries on for many", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00018-00004726-00004971": "centuries cannon chock is used to sacred", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00019-00004972-00005256": "ceremony the phra sama Chetty the pagoda", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00020-00005257-00005954": "in anfo phra sama Chetty Samet for con", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00021-00005955-00006902": "ingredients sticky rice flour palm sugar", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00022-00006903-00007548": "shredded coconut water meat the palm", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00023-00007548-00008091": "leaves little stick", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00024-00008092-00008910": "see also Thai cuisine list of Thai", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00025-00008911-00009253": "desserts", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00026-00009254-00009634": "references", "3jJ3QiaKVec-00027-00009635-00009840": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "3klemiqfWmu", "text": {"3klemiqfWmu-00000-00000003-00000605": "I often come to school at 8 o clock and", "3klemiqfWmu-00001-00000606-00001252": "I live 9 or 10 at night", "3klemiqfWmu-00002-00001253-00001745": "we must work for so long time I think", "3klemiqfWmu-00003-00001746-00002297": "our main task is not teaching English so", "3klemiqfWmu-00004-00002298-00002752": "helping students we must enhance ability", "3klemiqfWmu-00005-00002753-00003251": "and potential but I'm so busy so all we", "3klemiqfWmu-00006-00003252-00003536": "have is a programmatic", "3klemiqfWmu-00007-00003536-00003649": "istration", "3klemiqfWmu-00008-00003650-00004491": "[Music]", "3klemiqfWmu-00009-00004492-00004815": "japanese so behind in terms of IT", "3klemiqfWmu-00010-00004816-00005168": "adoption in education almost all", "3klemiqfWmu-00011-00005169-00005529": "students have never used tablets or any", "3klemiqfWmu-00012-00005530-00005852": "kind of IT device within class teachers", "3klemiqfWmu-00013-00005853-00006170": "in this country are so burdened so we", "3klemiqfWmu-00014-00006171-00006368": "need some kind of a tool that", "3klemiqfWmu-00015-00006369-00006783": "facilitates that change typically one", "3klemiqfWmu-00016-00006784-00007103": "teacher looks after 40 students in one", "3klemiqfWmu-00017-00007104-00007484": "class and the ratio is too low for", "3klemiqfWmu-00018-00007486-00007667": "teachers to engage in active", "3klemiqfWmu-00019-00007668-00007920": "conversations with their students by", "3klemiqfWmu-00020-00007920-00008171": "bringing inter talk we have been able to", "3klemiqfWmu-00021-00008172-00008477": "bring this power to the desk if he open", "3klemiqfWmu-00022-00008478-00008724": "up the app you are able to engage with", "3klemiqfWmu-00023-00008725-00008963": "the role-playing conversation lesson at", "3klemiqfWmu-00024-00008964-00009282": "any time complete with feedback which", "3klemiqfWmu-00025-00009283-00009488": "teachers can then review to better", "3klemiqfWmu-00026-00009489-00009863": "calibrate better plan the next class", "3klemiqfWmu-00027-00009864-00010249": "lgt what's got a euro ronamoon ani", "3klemiqfWmu-00028-00010250-00010538": "necessary acabo de comercio geodon a", "3klemiqfWmu-00029-00010539-00010931": "technology no bourbon toaster no Skynet", "3klemiqfWmu-00030-00010932-00011208": "man Paraiba war Amaka mix just a", "3klemiqfWmu-00031-00011209-00011516": "Saratoga garden agenda", "3klemiqfWmu-00032-00011517-00011813": "Google obviously is one of leading", "3klemiqfWmu-00033-00011814-00012023": "companies in artificial intelligence and", "3klemiqfWmu-00034-00012024-00012335": "also cloud technologies we have been", "3klemiqfWmu-00035-00012336-00012512": "using their technologies extensively for", "3klemiqfWmu-00036-00012513-00012734": "a product although it has had a", "3klemiqfWmu-00037-00012735-00012893": "tremendous impact some nurse other", "3klemiqfWmu-00038-00012894-00013213": "company people tend to think that", "3klemiqfWmu-00039-00013215-00013569": "technology detaches us from each other", "3klemiqfWmu-00040-00013571-00014003": "by adding feedback which is driven by", "3klemiqfWmu-00041-00014004-00014258": "artificial intelligence we are able to", "3klemiqfWmu-00042-00014259-00014537": "give more interaction more gamification", "3klemiqfWmu-00043-00014538-00014951": "and more fun into the classrooms Tara", "3klemiqfWmu-00044-00014952-00015281": "talk would be defined teachers role to", "3klemiqfWmu-00045-00015282-00015527": "the coaching role which will in effect", "3klemiqfWmu-00046-00015528-00015899": "revitalize the classrooms that's why we", "3klemiqfWmu-00047-00015900-00016094": "are using technology to humanize", "3klemiqfWmu-00048-00016094-00016325": "classrooms again because we are putting", "3klemiqfWmu-00049-00016326-00016508": "people first", "3klemiqfWmu-00050-00016509-00016658": "we're doing something very revolutionary", "3klemiqfWmu-00051-00016659-00016919": "here"}}, {"audio_id": "3krqDm4p4qg", "text": {"3krqDm4p4qg-00000-00000023-00000347": "Lynn Margulis born Lynn Petra Alexander", "3krqDm4p4qg-00001-00000348-00000749": "March 5th 1938 - November 22nd 2011 was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00002-00000750-00000950": "an American evolutionary theorist and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00003-00000951-00001208": "biologist science author educator and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00004-00001209-00001436": "popularizer and was the primary modern", "3krqDm4p4qg-00005-00001437-00001589": "proponent for the significance of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00006-00001590-00001925": "symbiosis in evolution historian Jan SAP", "3krqDm4p4qg-00007-00001926-00002185": "has said that Lynn Margulis is named as", "3krqDm4p4qg-00008-00002186-00002434": "a synonymous with symbiosis as Charles", "3krqDm4p4qg-00009-00002435-00002774": "Darwin's as with evolution in particular", "3krqDm4p4qg-00010-00002775-00003005": "Margolis transformed and fundamentally", "3krqDm4p4qg-00011-00003006-00003170": "framed current understanding of the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00012-00003171-00003397": "evolution of cells with nuclei an event", "3krqDm4p4qg-00013-00003398-00003613": "Ernst Mayr called perhaps the most", "3krqDm4p4qg-00014-00003614-00003827": "important and dramatic event in the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00015-00003828-00004151": "history of life by proposing it to have", "3krqDm4p4qg-00016-00004152-00004340": "been the result of symbiotic mergers of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00017-00004341-00004636": "bacteria Margulis was also the co", "3krqDm4p4qg-00018-00004637-00004850": "developer of the Gaia hypothesis with", "3krqDm4p4qg-00019-00004851-00005000": "the British chemist James Lovelock", "3krqDm4p4qg-00020-00005001-00005210": "proposing that the earth functions as a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00021-00005211-00005422": "single self-regulating system and was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00022-00005423-00005615": "the principal defender and promulgator", "3krqDm4p4qg-00023-00005616-00005813": "of the five kingdom classification of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00024-00005814-00006088": "robert whittaker throughout her career", "3krqDm4p4qg-00025-00006089-00006268": "Margulis work could arouse intense", "3krqDm4p4qg-00026-00006269-00006509": "objection one grant application elicited", "3krqDm4p4qg-00027-00006509-00006758": "the response your research is crap do", "3krqDm4p4qg-00028-00006759-00007006": "not bother to apply again and her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00029-00007008-00007250": "formative paper on the origin of my", "3krqDm4p4qg-00030-00007251-00007606": "dazeem cells appeared in 1967 after", "3krqDm4p4qg-00031-00007608-00007855": "being rejected by about 15 journals", "3krqDm4p4qg-00032-00007856-00008159": "still a junior faculty member at Boston", "3krqDm4p4qg-00033-00008159-00008374": "University at the time her theory that", "3krqDm4p4qg-00034-00008375-00008594": "cell organelles such as mitochondria and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00035-00008595-00008749": "chloroplasts were once independent", "3krqDm4p4qg-00036-00008750-00008992": "bacteria was largely ignored for another", "3krqDm4p4qg-00037-00008993-00009209": "decade becoming widely accepted only", "3krqDm4p4qg-00038-00009210-00009392": "after it was powerfully substantiated", "3krqDm4p4qg-00039-00009393-00009683": "through genetic evidence Margolis was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00040-00009684-00009848": "elected a member of the US National", "3krqDm4p4qg-00041-00009849-00010246": "Academy of Sciences in 1983 President", "3krqDm4p4qg-00042-00010247-00010438": "Bill Clinton presented her the National", "3krqDm4p4qg-00043-00010439-00010774": "Medal of Science in 1999 the Linnean", "3krqDm4p4qg-00044-00010775-00010991": "Society of London awarded her the Darwin", "3krqDm4p4qg-00045-00010992-00011410": "Wallace medal in 2008 called Sciences", "3krqDm4p4qg-00046-00011411-00011552": "unruly earth-mother", "3krqDm4p4qg-00047-00011553-00011938": "a vindicated heretic or a scientific", "3krqDm4p4qg-00048-00011939-00012256": "rebel margolis was a strong critic of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00049-00012257-00012496": "neo-darwinism her position sparked", "3krqDm4p4qg-00050-00012497-00012653": "lifelong debate with leading", "3krqDm4p4qg-00051-00012654-00012880": "neo-darwinian biologists including", "3krqDm4p4qg-00052-00012881-00013108": "Richard Dawkins George C Williams and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00053-00013109-00013388": "John Maynard Smith Margolis work", "3krqDm4p4qg-00054-00013388-00013630": "symbiosis and her endosymbiotic theory", "3krqDm4p4qg-00055-00013631-00013868": "had important predecessors going back to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00056-00013869-00014116": "the mid 19th century notably andreas", "3krqDm4p4qg-00057-00014118-00014351": "Franz Wilhelm schimper Constantin Mary", "3krqDm4p4qg-00058-00014352-00014675": "Schakowsky Boris Kodjoe polyansky 1890", "3krqDm4p4qg-00059-00014676-00014980": "to 1957 and Ivan Wallen and Margolis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00060-00014981-00015206": "took the unusual step of not only trying", "3krqDm4p4qg-00061-00015207-00015383": "to promote greater recognition for their", "3krqDm4p4qg-00062-00015384-00015563": "contributions but of personally", "3krqDm4p4qg-00063-00015563-00015722": "overseeing the first English translation", "3krqDm4p4qg-00064-00015722-00016043": "of kozo polyansky symbiogenesis a new", "3krqDm4p4qg-00065-00016044-00016241": "principle of evolution which appeared", "3krqDm4p4qg-00066-00016241-00016361": "the year before her death", "3krqDm4p4qg-00067-00016362-00016597": "many of her major works particularly", "3krqDm4p4qg-00068-00016598-00016802": "those intended for a general readership", "3krqDm4p4qg-00069-00016803-00016976": "were collaboratively written with her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00070-00016977-00017398": "son Dorion Sagan", "3krqDm4p4qg-00071-00017399-00017894": "topic biography", "3krqDm4p4qg-00072-00017895-00018205": "lynn margulis was born in Chicago to a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00073-00018206-00018499": "Jewish Zionist family her parents were", "3krqDm4p4qg-00074-00018500-00018682": "Morris Alexander and Leona Weis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00075-00018683-00018934": "Alexander she was the eldest of four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00076-00018935-00019171": "daughters her father was an attorney who", "3krqDm4p4qg-00077-00019172-00019386": "also ran a company that made Road pains", "3krqDm4p4qg-00078-00019387-00019744": "her mother operated a travel agency she", "3krqDm4p4qg-00079-00019745-00019918": "entered the Hyde Park Academy High", "3krqDm4p4qg-00080-00019919-00020224": "School in 1952 describing herself as a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00081-00020225-00020430": "bad student who frequently had to stand", "3krqDm4p4qg-00082-00020431-00020662": "in the corner a precocious child she was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00083-00020663-00020833": "accepted at the University of Chicago", "3krqDm4p4qg-00084-00020834-00021189": "laboratory schools at the age of 15 in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00085-00021190-00021514": "1957 at age 19 she earned a BA from the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00086-00021515-00021739": "University of Chicago in liberal arts", "3krqDm4p4qg-00087-00021740-00021937": "and then completed a master's degree at", "3krqDm4p4qg-00088-00021938-00022150": "the University of Chicago in genetics", "3krqDm4p4qg-00089-00022151-00022474": "and zoology at age 22 she joined the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00090-00022475-00022680": "University of Wisconsin to study biology", "3krqDm4p4qg-00091-00022681-00022930": "under Hans RIS and Walter plot her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00092-00022931-00023227": "supervisor and graduated in 1960 with an", "3krqDm4p4qg-00093-00023228-00023536": "MS in genetics and zoology her first", "3krqDm4p4qg-00094-00023537-00023716": "publication was with plot on the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00095-00023717-00024010": "genetics of euglena published in 1958 in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00096-00024011-00024292": "the Journal of proto zoology she then", "3krqDm4p4qg-00097-00024293-00024478": "pursued research at the University of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00098-00024479-00024718": "California Berkeley under the zoologist", "3krqDm4p4qg-00099-00024719-00025006": "max Alford before she could complete her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00100-00025007-00025194": "dissertation she was offered research", "3krqDm4p4qg-00101-00025195-00025399": "associate chip and then lectureship at", "3krqDm4p4qg-00102-00025400-00025634": "Brandeis University in Massachusetts in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00103-00025635-00025953": "1964 it was while working there that she", "3krqDm4p4qg-00104-00025954-00026178": "obtained her PhD from the University of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00105-00026179-00026563": "California Berkeley in 1965 her thesis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00106-00026564-00026782": "was an unusual pattern of thim adenine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00107-00026783-00027133": "corporation in Euglena in 1966 she moved", "3krqDm4p4qg-00108-00027133-00027331": "to Boston University where she taught", "3krqDm4p4qg-00109-00027332-00027649": "biology for 22 years she was initially", "3krqDm4p4qg-00110-00027650-00027856": "an adjunct assistant professor and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00111-00027857-00028158": "appointed to assistant professor in 1967", "3krqDm4p4qg-00112-00028160-00028387": "she was promoted to associate professor", "3krqDm4p4qg-00113-00028388-00028852": "in 1971 to full professor in 1977 and to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00114-00028852-00029314": "university professor in 1986 in 1988 she", "3krqDm4p4qg-00115-00029314-00029500": "was appointed distinguished professor of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00116-00029501-00029646": "botany at the University of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00117-00029647-00029905": "Massachusetts at Amherst she was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00118-00029906-00030117": "distinguished professor of biology in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00119-00030118-00030487": "1993 in 1997 she transferred to the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00120-00030488-00030720": "Department of geosciences at Amherst to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00121-00030722-00030880": "become distinguished professor of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00122-00030881-00031151": "geosciences with great delight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00123-00031152-00031637": "the post which she held until her death", "3krqDm4p4qg-00124-00031638-00032162": "topic personal life", "3krqDm4p4qg-00125-00032163-00032402": "Margulis married astronomer Carl Sagan", "3krqDm4p4qg-00126-00032402-00032683": "in 1957 soon after she got her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00127-00032685-00032936": "bachelor's degree Sagan was then a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00128-00032937-00033116": "graduate student in physics at the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00129-00033117-00033389": "University of Chicago their marriage", "3krqDm4p4qg-00130-00033390-00033689": "ended in 1964 just before she completed", "3krqDm4p4qg-00131-00033690-00034025": "her PhD they had two sons Dorion Sagan", "3krqDm4p4qg-00132-00034026-00034265": "who later became a popular science", "3krqDm4p4qg-00133-00034266-00034466": "writer in her collaborator and Jeremy", "3krqDm4p4qg-00134-00034467-00034688": "Sagan software developer and founder of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00135-00034689-00035084": "Sagan technology in 1967 she married", "3krqDm4p4qg-00136-00035085-00035299": "Thomas and Margolis a crystallographer", "3krqDm4p4qg-00137-00035300-00035609": "they had a son Zachary Margolis onuma", "3krqDm4p4qg-00138-00035610-00035810": "New York City criminal defense lawyer", "3krqDm4p4qg-00139-00035811-00036026": "and a daughter Jennifer Margolis teacher", "3krqDm4p4qg-00140-00036027-00036344": "and author they divorced in 1980 she", "3krqDm4p4qg-00141-00036345-00036653": "commented I quit my job as a wife twice", "3krqDm4p4qg-00142-00036654-00036992": "and it's not humanly possible to be a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00143-00036993-00037172": "good wife a good mother and a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00144-00037173-00037484": "first-class scientist no one can do it", "3krqDm4p4qg-00145-00037485-00037874": "something has to go in mm she had a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00146-00037875-00038069": "relationship with fellow biologist", "3krqDm4p4qg-00147-00038070-00038333": "Ricardo Guerrero her sister Joan", "3krqDm4p4qg-00148-00038334-00038585": "Alexander married Nobel laureate Sheldon", "3krqDm4p4qg-00149-00038586-00038810": "Lee Glashow another sister Sharon", "3krqDm4p4qg-00150-00038811-00039046": "married mathematician Daniel kleitman", "3krqDm4p4qg-00151-00039047-00039317": "she was a religious agnostic and a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00152-00039318-00039524": "staunch evolutionist but she totally", "3krqDm4p4qg-00153-00039525-00039713": "rejected the modern evolutionary", "3krqDm4p4qg-00154-00039714-00039983": "synthesis and said I remember waking up", "3krqDm4p4qg-00155-00039984-00040244": "one day with an epiphany revelation I am", "3krqDm4p4qg-00156-00040245-00040535": "NOT a neo Darwinist I recalled an", "3krqDm4p4qg-00157-00040536-00040772": "earlier experience when I realized that", "3krqDm4p4qg-00158-00040773-00041057": "I wasn't a humanistic Jew although I", "3krqDm4p4qg-00159-00041058-00041315": "greatly admired Darwin's contributions", "3krqDm4p4qg-00160-00041316-00041534": "and agree with most of his theoretical", "3krqDm4p4qg-00161-00041535-00041795": "analysis and I am a Darwinist I am NOT a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00162-00041796-00042188": "neo Darwinist she argued that natural", "3krqDm4p4qg-00163-00042189-00042413": "selection eliminates and maybe maintains", "3krqDm4p4qg-00164-00042414-00042602": "but it doesn't create and maintain that", "3krqDm4p4qg-00165-00042603-00042803": "symbiosis was the major driver of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00166-00042804-00043043": "evolutionary change since 2013", "3krqDm4p4qg-00167-00043044-00043265": "Margolis has been listed on the Advisory", "3krqDm4p4qg-00168-00043266-00043433": "Council of the National Center for", "3krqDm4p4qg-00169-00043434-00043655": "Science education Margolis died on", "3krqDm4p4qg-00170-00043656-00043943": "November 22nd 2011 at home in Amherst", "3krqDm4p4qg-00171-00043944-00044159": "Massachusetts five days after suffering", "3krqDm4p4qg-00172-00044160-00044465": "a hemorrhagic stroke as her wish she was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00173-00044466-00044669": "cremated and her ashes were scattered in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00174-00044670-00044852": "her favorite at research areas near her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00175-00044853-00045177": "home", "3krqDm4p4qg-00176-00045178-00045723": "topic contributions", "3krqDm4p4qg-00177-00045724-00046287": "topic and NGO symbiosis theory", "3krqDm4p4qg-00178-00046288-00046632": "in 1966 as a young faculty member at", "3krqDm4p4qg-00179-00046633-00046833": "Boston University Margulis wrote a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00180-00046834-00047088": "theoretical paper titled on the origin", "3krqDm4p4qg-00181-00047089-00047388": "of mighta seam cells the paper however", "3krqDm4p4qg-00182-00047389-00047742": "was rejected by about 15 scientific", "3krqDm4p4qg-00183-00047743-00048042": "journals she recalled it was finally", "3krqDm4p4qg-00184-00048043-00048197": "accepted by Journal of theoretical", "3krqDm4p4qg-00185-00048198-00048411": "biology and is considered today a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00186-00048412-00048686": "landmark in modern endosymbiotic theory", "3krqDm4p4qg-00187-00048687-00048930": "weathering constant criticism of her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00188-00048931-00049059": "ideas for decades", "3krqDm4p4qg-00189-00049060-00049278": "Margolis was famous for her tenacity in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00190-00049279-00049473": "pushing her theory forward despite the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00191-00049474-00049731": "opposition she faced at the time the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00192-00049732-00049944": "descent of mitochondria from bacteria", "3krqDm4p4qg-00193-00049945-00050130": "and of chloroplasts from cyanobacteria", "3krqDm4p4qg-00194-00050131-00050484": "was experimentally demonstrated in 1978", "3krqDm4p4qg-00195-00050485-00050699": "by Robert Schwartz and Margaret Dayhoff", "3krqDm4p4qg-00196-00050700-00050958": "this formed the first experimental", "3krqDm4p4qg-00197-00050959-00051126": "evidence for her theory the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00198-00051127-00051327": "endosymbiosis theory of organogenesis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00199-00051328-00051645": "became widely accepted in the 1980s when", "3krqDm4p4qg-00200-00051646-00051873": "the genetic material of mitochondria and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00201-00051874-00052071": "chloroplasts was found to be different", "3krqDm4p4qg-00202-00052072-00052251": "from that of the symbionts nuclear DNA", "3krqDm4p4qg-00203-00052252-00052620": "in 1995 English evolutionary biologist", "3krqDm4p4qg-00204-00052621-00052782": "Richard Dawkins had this to say about", "3krqDm4p4qg-00205-00052783-00053085": "lynn margulis and her work I greatly", "3krqDm4p4qg-00206-00053086-00053283": "admire lynn margulis his sheer courage", "3krqDm4p4qg-00207-00053284-00053445": "and stamina in sticking by the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00208-00053446-00053658": "endosymbiosis theory and carrying it", "3krqDm4p4qg-00209-00053659-00053844": "through from being an unorthodox sea to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00210-00053845-00054135": "an orthodoxy I'm referring to the theory", "3krqDm4p4qg-00211-00054136-00054324": "that the eukaryotic cell is a symbiotic", "3krqDm4p4qg-00212-00054325-00054557": "union of primitive prokaryotic cells", "3krqDm4p4qg-00213-00054558-00054813": "this is one of the great achievements of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00214-00054814-00055053": "twentieth-century evolutionary biology", "3krqDm4p4qg-00215-00055054-00055547": "and I greatly admire her for it", "3krqDm4p4qg-00216-00055548-00056123": "topic symbiosis is evolutionary force", "3krqDm4p4qg-00217-00056124-00056399": "Margulis opposed competition oriented", "3krqDm4p4qg-00218-00056400-00056576": "views of evolution stressing the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00219-00056577-00056794": "importance of symbiotic or cooperative", "3krqDm4p4qg-00220-00056795-00056980": "relationships between species", "3krqDm4p4qg-00221-00056982-00057146": "she later formulated a theory that", "3krqDm4p4qg-00222-00057147-00057371": "proposed symbiotic relationships between", "3krqDm4p4qg-00223-00057372-00057584": "organisms of different phyla or kingdoms", "3krqDm4p4qg-00224-00057585-00057794": "as the driving force of evolution and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00225-00057795-00058016": "explained genetic variation as occurring", "3krqDm4p4qg-00226-00058016-00058175": "mainly through transfer of nuclear", "3krqDm4p4qg-00227-00058176-00058400": "information between bacterial cells or", "3krqDm4p4qg-00228-00058401-00058673": "viruses in eukaryotic cells her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00229-00058674-00058891": "organelle Genesis ideas are now widely", "3krqDm4p4qg-00230-00058892-00059135": "accepted but the proposal that symbiotic", "3krqDm4p4qg-00231-00059136-00059329": "relationships explain most genetic", "3krqDm4p4qg-00232-00059330-00059528": "variation is still something of a fringe", "3krqDm4p4qg-00233-00059529-00059782": "idea margolis also held a negative view", "3krqDm4p4qg-00234-00059783-00059932": "of certain interpretations of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00235-00059933-00060104": "neo-darwinism that she felt were", "3krqDm4p4qg-00236-00060104-00060280": "excessively focused on competition", "3krqDm4p4qg-00237-00060282-00060494": "between organisms as she believed that", "3krqDm4p4qg-00238-00060495-00060655": "history will ultimately judge them as", "3krqDm4p4qg-00239-00060657-00060907": "comprising a minor 20th century", "3krqDm4p4qg-00240-00060908-00061094": "religious sect within the sprawling", "3krqDm4p4qg-00241-00061095-00061357": "religious persuasion of anglo-saxon", "3krqDm4p4qg-00242-00061358-00061760": "biology she wrote that proponents of the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00243-00061761-00061949": "standard theory wallow in their", "3krqDm4p4qg-00244-00061950-00062224": "zoological capitalistic competitive", "3krqDm4p4qg-00245-00062225-00062482": "cost-benefit interpretation of Darwin", "3krqDm4p4qg-00246-00062483-00062757": "having mistaken him", "3krqDm4p4qg-00247-00062758-00063049": "neo-darwinism which insists on the slow", "3krqDm4p4qg-00248-00063050-00063271": "accrual of mutations by gene level", "3krqDm4p4qg-00249-00063272-00063904": "natural selection is in a complete funk", "3krqDm4p4qg-00250-00063904-00064442": "topic Gaia hypothesis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00251-00064444-00064679": "Margolis initially sought out the advice", "3krqDm4p4qg-00252-00064680-00064878": "of Lovelock for her own research she", "3krqDm4p4qg-00253-00064879-00065151": "explained that in the early 70s I was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00254-00065152-00065349": "trying to align bacteria by their", "3krqDm4p4qg-00255-00065350-00065655": "metabolic pathways I noticed that all", "3krqDm4p4qg-00256-00065656-00066027": "kinds of bacteria produced gases oxygen", "3krqDm4p4qg-00257-00066028-00066366": "hydrogen sulfide carbon dioxide nitrogen", "3krqDm4p4qg-00258-00066367-00066711": "ammonia more than 30 different gases are", "3krqDm4p4qg-00259-00066712-00066885": "given off by the bacteria whose", "3krqDm4p4qg-00260-00066886-00067101": "evolutionary history I was keen to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00261-00067102-00067413": "reconstruct why did every scientist I", "3krqDm4p4qg-00262-00067414-00067620": "asked believed that atmospheric oxygen", "3krqDm4p4qg-00263-00067621-00067893": "was a biological product but the other", "3krqDm4p4qg-00264-00067894-00068216": "atmospheric gases nitrogen methane", "3krqDm4p4qg-00265-00068217-00068634": "sulfur and so on were not go talk to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00266-00068635-00068820": "Lovelock at least four different", "3krqDm4p4qg-00267-00068821-00069126": "scientists suggested Lovelock believed", "3krqDm4p4qg-00268-00069127-00069327": "that the gases in the atmosphere were", "3krqDm4p4qg-00269-00069328-00069639": "biological margolis met with Lovelock", "3krqDm4p4qg-00270-00069640-00069858": "who explained his Gaia hypothesis to her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00271-00069859-00070038": "and very soon they began an intense", "3krqDm4p4qg-00272-00070039-00070308": "collaborative effort on the concept one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00273-00070309-00070491": "of the earliest significant publications", "3krqDm4p4qg-00274-00070492-00070845": "on Gaia was a 1974 paper co-authored by", "3krqDm4p4qg-00275-00070846-00071058": "Lovelock and Margolis which succinctly", "3krqDm4p4qg-00276-00071059-00071301": "defined the hypothesis as follows the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00277-00071302-00071529": "notion of the biosphere as an active", "3krqDm4p4qg-00278-00071530-00071748": "adaptive control system able to maintain", "3krqDm4p4qg-00279-00071749-00071994": "the earth in homeostasis we are calling", "3krqDm4p4qg-00280-00071995-00072314": "the Gaia hypothesis like other early", "3krqDm4p4qg-00281-00072315-00072528": "presentations of Lovelock's idea", "3krqDm4p4qg-00282-00072529-00072840": "the Lovelock Margolis 1974 paper seemed", "3krqDm4p4qg-00283-00072841-00073065": "to give living organisms complete agency", "3krqDm4p4qg-00284-00073066-00073281": "in creating planetary self-regulation", "3krqDm4p4qg-00285-00073282-00073533": "whereas later as the idea matured this", "3krqDm4p4qg-00286-00073534-00073755": "planetary scale self-regulation was", "3krqDm4p4qg-00287-00073756-00073950": "recognized as an emergent property of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00288-00073951-00074121": "the Earth's system life in its physical", "3krqDm4p4qg-00289-00074122-00074382": "environment taken together when", "3krqDm4p4qg-00290-00074383-00074613": "climatologist Stephen Schneider convened", "3krqDm4p4qg-00291-00074614-00074877": "the 1989 American Geophysical Union", "3krqDm4p4qg-00292-00074878-00075072": "Chapman conference around the issue of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00293-00075073-00075459": "Gaia the idea of strong Gaia and weak", "3krqDm4p4qg-00294-00075460-00075738": "Gaia was introduced by James Kirk nur", "3krqDm4p4qg-00295-00075739-00075921": "after which Margolis was sometimes", "3krqDm4p4qg-00296-00075922-00076193": "associated with the idea of weak Gaia", "3krqDm4p4qg-00297-00076194-00076506": "incorrectly her essay Gaia is a tough", "3krqDm4p4qg-00298-00076507-00076860": "dates from 1995 and it stated her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00299-00076861-00077067": "own distinction from Lovelock as she saw", "3krqDm4p4qg-00300-00077068-00077256": "it which was primarily that she did not", "3krqDm4p4qg-00301-00077257-00077427": "like the metaphor of earth as a single", "3krqDm4p4qg-00302-00077428-00077715": "organism because she said no organism", "3krqDm4p4qg-00303-00077716-00077878": "eats its own way", "3krqDm4p4qg-00304-00077879-00078184": "in her 1998 book symbiotic planet", "3krqDm4p4qg-00305-00078185-00078319": "Margolis explored the relationship", "3krqDm4p4qg-00306-00078320-00078875": "between Gaia and her work on symbiosis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00307-00078876-00079592": "topic five kingdoms of life since 1969", "3krqDm4p4qg-00308-00079593-00079835": "life on Earth was classified into five", "3krqDm4p4qg-00309-00079836-00080028": "kingdoms as introduced by Robert", "3krqDm4p4qg-00310-00080029-00080276": "Whittaker Margolis became the most", "3krqDm4p4qg-00311-00080277-00080484": "important supporter as well as critic", "3krqDm4p4qg-00312-00080485-00080678": "while supporting parts she was the first", "3krqDm4p4qg-00313-00080679-00080853": "to recognize the limitations of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00314-00080854-00081055": "Whitaker's classification of microbes", "3krqDm4p4qg-00315-00081056-00081350": "but later discoveries of new organisms", "3krqDm4p4qg-00316-00081351-00081546": "such as archaea and emergence of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00317-00081547-00081731": "molecular taxonomy challenged the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00318-00081732-00082082": "concept by the mid-2000s most scientists", "3krqDm4p4qg-00319-00082083-00082235": "began to agree that there are more than", "3krqDm4p4qg-00320-00082236-00082515": "five kingdoms margolis became the most", "3krqDm4p4qg-00321-00082516-00082706": "important defender of the five kingdom", "3krqDm4p4qg-00322-00082707-00082943": "classification she rejected the three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00323-00082944-00083153": "domain system introduced by carl woese", "3krqDm4p4qg-00324-00083154-00083513": "in 1990 which gained wide acceptance she", "3krqDm4p4qg-00325-00083514-00083750": "introduced a modified classification by", "3krqDm4p4qg-00326-00083751-00083960": "which all life forms including the newly", "3krqDm4p4qg-00327-00083961-00084143": "discovered could be integrated into the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00328-00084144-00084419": "classical five kingdoms according to her", "3krqDm4p4qg-00329-00084420-00084644": "the main problem archaea falls under the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00330-00084645-00084878": "kingdom prokaryote a alongside bacteria", "3krqDm4p4qg-00331-00084879-00085100": "in contrast to the three domain system", "3krqDm4p4qg-00332-00085101-00085323": "which treats archaea as a higher tax and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00333-00085324-00085517": "than kingdom or the six kingdom system", "3krqDm4p4qg-00334-00085518-00085667": "which holds that it is a separate", "3krqDm4p4qg-00335-00085668-00085923": "kingdom her concept is given in detail", "3krqDm4p4qg-00336-00085924-00086141": "in her book five kingdoms written with", "3krqDm4p4qg-00337-00086142-00086415": "Coleen V Schwartz it is mainly because", "3krqDm4p4qg-00338-00086416-00086606": "of her that this five kingdom system", "3krqDm4p4qg-00339-00086607-00086971": "survives", "3krqDm4p4qg-00340-00086972-00087504": "topic controversies", "3krqDm4p4qg-00341-00087505-00087729": "it has been suggested that initial", "3krqDm4p4qg-00342-00087730-00087903": "rejection of Margolis work on the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00343-00087904-00088077": "endosymbiotic theory and the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00344-00088078-00088263": "controversial nature of it as well as", "3krqDm4p4qg-00345-00088264-00088476": "Gaia theory made her identify throughout", "3krqDm4p4qg-00346-00088477-00088662": "her career with scientific mavericks", "3krqDm4p4qg-00347-00088663-00088860": "outsiders and unaccepted theories", "3krqDm4p4qg-00348-00088861-00089136": "generally in the last decade of her life", "3krqDm4p4qg-00349-00089137-00089334": "while key components of her life's work", "3krqDm4p4qg-00350-00089335-00089544": "began to be understood as fundamental to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00351-00089545-00089742": "a modern scientific viewpoint the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00352-00089743-00089931": "widespread adoption of Earth System", "3krqDm4p4qg-00353-00089932-00090117": "science and the incorporation of key", "3krqDm4p4qg-00354-00090118-00090327": "parts of endosymbiotic theory into", "3krqDm4p4qg-00355-00090328-00090597": "biology curricula worldwide Margolis if", "3krqDm4p4qg-00356-00090598-00090768": "anything became more embroiled in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00357-00090769-00091068": "controversy not less journalist John", "3krqDm4p4qg-00358-00091069-00091260": "Wilson explained this by saying that", "3krqDm4p4qg-00359-00091261-00091458": "Lynn Margulis defined herself by", "3krqDm4p4qg-00360-00091459-00091623": "oppositional science and in the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00361-00091624-00091809": "commemorative collection of essays Lynn", "3krqDm4p4qg-00362-00091810-00091863": "Margulis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00363-00091864-00092052": "the life and legacy of a scientific", "3krqDm4p4qg-00364-00092053-00092259": "rebel commentators again and again", "3krqDm4p4qg-00365-00092260-00092465": "depict her as a modern embodiment of the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00366-00092466-00092793": "scientific rebel akin to Freeman Dyson's", "3krqDm4p4qg-00367-00092794-00093087": "1995 essay the scientist is rebel a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00368-00093088-00093324": "tradition Dyson saw embodied in Benjamin", "3krqDm4p4qg-00369-00093325-00093489": "Franklin in which he believed to be", "3krqDm4p4qg-00370-00093490-00093759": "essential to good science at times", "3krqDm4p4qg-00371-00093760-00093924": "Margolis could make highly provocative", "3krqDm4p4qg-00372-00093925-00094128": "comments in interviews that appeared to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00373-00094129-00094290": "support her most strident critics", "3krqDm4p4qg-00374-00094291-00094572": "condemnation the following describes two", "3krqDm4p4qg-00375-00094573-00095026": "of these controversies", "3krqDm4p4qg-00376-00095027-00095512": "topic metamorphosis theory", "3krqDm4p4qg-00377-00095513-00095848": "in 2009 via then-standard publication", "3krqDm4p4qg-00378-00095849-00096127": "process known as communicated submission", "3krqDm4p4qg-00379-00096128-00096421": "which bypass traditional peer-review she", "3krqDm4p4qg-00380-00096422-00096562": "was instrumental in getting the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00381-00096563-00096745": "Proceedings of the National Academy of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00382-00096746-00097030": "Sciences PNAS to publish a paper by", "3krqDm4p4qg-00383-00097031-00097216": "Donald the first Williamson rejecting", "3krqDm4p4qg-00384-00097217-00097474": "the Darwinian assumption that larvae and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00385-00097475-00097642": "they're adults evolved from a single", "3krqDm4p4qg-00386-00097643-00097842": "common ancestor", "3krqDm4p4qg-00387-00097843-00098074": "Williamson's paper provoked immediate", "3krqDm4p4qg-00388-00098075-00098235": "response from the scientific community", "3krqDm4p4qg-00389-00098236-00098565": "including a countering paper in PNAS", "3krqDm4p4qg-00390-00098566-00098836": "konrad la bandera of the Smithsonian", "3krqDm4p4qg-00391-00098837-00099067": "National Museum of Natural History said", "3krqDm4p4qg-00392-00099068-00099280": "if I was reviewing Williamson's paper I", "3krqDm4p4qg-00393-00099281-00099490": "would probably opt to reject it he says", "3krqDm4p4qg-00394-00099491-00099676": "but I'm not saying it's a bad thing that", "3krqDm4p4qg-00395-00099677-00099916": "this is published what it may do is", "3krqDm4p4qg-00396-00099917-00100054": "broaden the discussion on how", "3krqDm4p4qg-00397-00100055-00100279": "metamorphosis works in on the origin of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00398-00100280-00100501": "these very radical life cycles but Duke", "3krqDm4p4qg-00399-00100502-00100702": "University insect developmental", "3krqDm4p4qg-00400-00100703-00100903": "biologist Fred neihaus said that the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00401-00100904-00101098": "paper was better suited for the National", "3krqDm4p4qg-00402-00101099-00101293": "Enquirer than the National Academy in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00403-00101294-00101524": "September it was announced that PNAS", "3krqDm4p4qg-00404-00101525-00101731": "would eliminate communicated submissions", "3krqDm4p4qg-00405-00101732-00102085": "in July 2010 PNAS stated that the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00406-00102086-00102250": "decision had nothing to do with the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00407-00102251-00102540": "Williamson controversy topic aids/hiv", "3krqDm4p4qg-00408-00102541-00102894": "theory in 2009 Margolis and seven others", "3krqDm4p4qg-00409-00102895-00103083": "authored a position paper concerning", "3krqDm4p4qg-00410-00103084-00103300": "research on the viability of round body", "3krqDm4p4qg-00411-00103301-00103549": "forms of some spirochetes syphilis Lyme", "3krqDm4p4qg-00412-00103550-00103780": "disease and AIDS resurgence of the great", "3krqDm4p4qg-00413-00103781-00103968": "imitator which states that detailed", "3krqDm4p4qg-00414-00103969-00104176": "research that correlates life histories", "3krqDm4p4qg-00415-00104177-00104401": "of symbiotic spirochetes to changes in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00416-00104402-00104575": "the immune system of associated", "3krqDm4p4qg-00417-00104576-00104773": "vertebrates as sorely needed and urging", "3krqDm4p4qg-00418-00104774-00104953": "the reinvestigation of the natural", "3krqDm4p4qg-00419-00104954-00105145": "history of mammalian tick-borne and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00420-00105146-00105364": "venereal transmission of spirochetes in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00421-00105365-00105541": "relation to impairment of the human", "3krqDm4p4qg-00422-00105542-00105721": "immune system the paper went on to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00423-00105722-00105949": "suggest that the possible direct causal", "3krqDm4p4qg-00424-00105950-00106123": "involvement of spirochetes and their", "3krqDm4p4qg-00425-00106124-00106303": "round bodies to symptoms of immune", "3krqDm4p4qg-00426-00106304-00106522": "deficiency be carefully and vigorously", "3krqDm4p4qg-00427-00106523-00106683": "investigated in a Discover Magazine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00428-00106684-00106915": "interview which was published less than", "3krqDm4p4qg-00429-00106916-00107044": "six months before her death", "3krqDm4p4qg-00430-00107045-00107275": "Margolis explained to writer dick teresi", "3krqDm4p4qg-00431-00107276-00107470": "her reason for interest in the topic of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00432-00107471-00107725": "2009 AIDS paper I'm interested in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00433-00107726-00107938": "spirochetes only because of our ancestry", "3krqDm4p4qg-00434-00107939-00108210": "I'm not interested in the diseases and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00435-00108211-00108352": "stated that she had called them", "3krqDm4p4qg-00436-00108353-00108558": "symbionts because both the spirochete", "3krqDm4p4qg-00437-00108559-00108778": "which causes syphilis Treponema and the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00438-00108779-00108889": "spirochete which", "3krqDm4p4qg-00439-00108890-00109108": "is Lyme disease Borrelia only retain", "3krqDm4p4qg-00440-00109108-00109324": "about 20% of the genes they would need", "3krqDm4p4qg-00441-00109325-00109501": "to live freely outside of their human", "3krqDm4p4qg-00442-00109502-00109690": "hosts however in the Discover Magazine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00443-00109691-00109927": "interview Margolis said that the set of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00444-00109928-00110133": "symptoms or syndrome presented by", "3krqDm4p4qg-00445-00110134-00110341": "syphilitic Sauveur lapse completely with", "3krqDm4p4qg-00446-00110342-00110563": "another syndrome AIDS and also noted", "3krqDm4p4qg-00447-00110564-00110716": "that Kary Mullis said that he went", "3krqDm4p4qg-00448-00110717-00110923": "looking for a reference substantiating", "3krqDm4p4qg-00449-00110924-00111148": "that HIV causes AIDS and discovered", "3krqDm4p4qg-00450-00111149-00111360": "there is no such document this provoked", "3krqDm4p4qg-00451-00111361-00111574": "a widespread supposition that Margolis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00452-00111575-00111766": "had been an AIDS Denia list notably", "3krqDm4p4qg-00453-00111767-00111991": "Jerry Coyne reacted on his why evolution", "3krqDm4p4qg-00454-00111992-00112222": "as true blog against his interpretation", "3krqDm4p4qg-00455-00112223-00112393": "that Margolis believed that AIDS is", "3krqDm4p4qg-00456-00112394-00112615": "really syphilis not viral in origin at", "3krqDm4p4qg-00457-00112616-00112873": "all Seth :", "3krqDm4p4qg-00458-00112874-00113092": "a social psychologist who studies", "3krqDm4p4qg-00459-00113093-00113338": "behavioral and social aspects of AIDS", "3krqDm4p4qg-00460-00113339-00113674": "cited her 2009 paper as an example of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00461-00113675-00114043": "AIDS denialism flourishing and asserted", "3krqDm4p4qg-00462-00114044-00114283": "that her endorsement of HIV AIDS", "3krqDm4p4qg-00463-00114283-00114768": "denialism defies understanding", "3krqDm4p4qg-00464-00114769-00115453": "topic 911 strewth", "3krqDm4p4qg-00465-00115454-00115723": "Margolis argued that the September 11th", "3krqDm4p4qg-00466-00115724-00115983": "attacks were a false flag operation", "3krqDm4p4qg-00467-00115984-00116208": "which has been used to justify the wars", "3krqDm4p4qg-00468-00116209-00116452": "in Afghanistan and Iraq as well as", "3krqDm4p4qg-00469-00116453-00116931": "unprecedented assault on civil liberties", "3krqDm4p4qg-00470-00116932-00117226": "she claimed that there was overwhelming", "3krqDm4p4qg-00471-00117227-00117445": "evidence that the three buildings of the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00472-00117446-00117636": "World Trade Center collapsed by", "3krqDm4p4qg-00473-00117638-00118140": "controlled demolition", "3krqDm4p4qg-00474-00118141-00118723": "Topic awards and recognitions", "3krqDm4p4qg-00475-00118724-00118929": "elected fellow of the American", "3krqDm4p4qg-00476-00118930-00119109": "Association for the Advancement of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00477-00119110-00119538": "science in 1975 Guggenheim Fellowship in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00478-00119539-00119916": "1978 elected to the National Academy of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00479-00119917-00120319": "Sciences in 1983 guests Hagee lecturer", "3krqDm4p4qg-00480-00120320-00120733": "University of Waterloo 1985 Miescher", "3krqDm4p4qg-00481-00120733-00121222": "Ishida Prize in 1986 1989 conferred the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00482-00121223-00121458": "command or de l'Ordre de Paume academics", "3krqDm4p4qg-00483-00121459-00121758": "de France has her papers permanently", "3krqDm4p4qg-00484-00121759-00121957": "archived in the Library of Congress", "3krqDm4p4qg-00485-00121958-00122383": "Washington DC 1992 recipient of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00486-00122383-00122557": "Chancellor's medal for distinguished", "3krqDm4p4qg-00487-00122558-00122709": "faculty of the University of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00488-00122710-00123115": "Massachusetts at Amherst 1995 elected", "3krqDm4p4qg-00489-00123116-00123309": "fellow of the world academy of art and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00490-00123310-00123673": "science 1997 elected to the Russian", "3krqDm4p4qg-00491-00123674-00124029": "Academy of Natural Sciences 1998", "3krqDm4p4qg-00492-00124030-00124195": "recipient of the Distinguished Service", "3krqDm4p4qg-00493-00124196-00124399": "Award of the American Institute of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00494-00124400-00124795": "Biological Sciences 1998 elected fellow", "3krqDm4p4qg-00495-00124796-00124999": "of the American Academy of Arts and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00496-00125000-00125365": "Sciences 1999 recipient of the William", "3krqDm4p4qg-00497-00125366-00125691": "Procter prize for scientific achievement", "3krqDm4p4qg-00498-00125692-00125979": "1999 recipient of the National Medal of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00499-00125980-00126214": "Science awarded by President William J", "3krqDm4p4qg-00500-00126215-00126628": "Clinton 2002 205 Alexander von Humboldt", "3krqDm4p4qg-00501-00126629-00127069": "Prize 2005 elected president of Sigma Xi", "3krqDm4p4qg-00502-00127070-00127444": "the Scientific Research Society profiled", "3krqDm4p4qg-00503-00127445-00127708": "in visionaries the 20th century's 100", "3krqDm4p4qg-00504-00127708-00127894": "most important inspirational leaders", "3krqDm4p4qg-00505-00127895-00128251": "published in 2007 founded science", "3krqDm4p4qg-00506-00128252-00128484": "writers books in 2006 with her son", "3krqDm4p4qg-00507-00128485-00128902": "Dorian was one of 13 recipients in 2008", "3krqDm4p4qg-00508-00128903-00129088": "of the Darwin Wallace medal heretofore", "3krqDm4p4qg-00509-00129089-00129325": "bestowed every 50 years by the Linnean", "3krqDm4p4qg-00510-00129326-00129708": "Society of London 2009 speaker at the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00511-00129709-00129943": "biological evolution facts and theories", "3krqDm4p4qg-00512-00129944-00130102": "conference held at the Pontifical", "3krqDm4p4qg-00513-00130103-00130333": "Gregorian University Rome aimed at", "3krqDm4p4qg-00514-00130333-00130540": "promoting dialogue between evolutionary", "3krqDm4p4qg-00515-00130541-00130894": "biology and Christianity 2010 inductee", "3krqDm4p4qg-00516-00130895-00131158": "into the leonardo da vinci society of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00517-00131159-00131356": "thinking at the university of advancing", "3krqDm4p4qg-00518-00131357-00131737": "technology in tempe arizona 2010 nasa", "3krqDm4p4qg-00519-00131738-00132061": "public service award for astrobiology", "3krqDm4p4qg-00520-00132062-00132319": "20:12 Lynn Margulis symposium", "3krqDm4p4qg-00521-00132320-00132579": "celebrating a life in science University", "3krqDm4p4qg-00522-00132580-00132913": "of Massachusetts Amherst March 23 to 25", "3krqDm4p4qg-00523-00132914-00133273": "2012 honorary Doctorate from 15", "3krqDm4p4qg-00524-00133274-00133654": "universities", "3krqDm4p4qg-00525-00133655-00134149": "topic works", "3krqDm4p4qg-00526-00134150-00134613": "topic books", "3krqDm4p4qg-00527-00134614-00134988": "Margolis Lynn 1970 origin of eukaryotic", "3krqDm4p4qg-00528-00134989-00135420": "cells yale university press ISBN o 300", "3krqDm4p4qg-00529-00135421-00135942": "Oh 1 3 5 3 1 margulis lynn 1982", "3krqDm4p4qg-00530-00135943-00136188": "early life science books international", "3krqDm4p4qg-00531-00136189-00136860": "ISBN o 8 6 72000 5/7 margulis lynn and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00532-00136861-00137298": "Dorion Sagan 1986 origins of sex 3", "3krqDm4p4qg-00533-00137299-00137466": "billion years of genetic recombination", "3krqDm4p4qg-00534-00137467-00137922": "yale university press ISBN o 300 oh 3 3", "3krqDm4p4qg-00535-00137923-00138353": "400 margulis lynn and Dorion Sagan 1987", "3krqDm4p4qg-00536-00138354-00138624": "micro cosmos 4 billion years of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00537-00138625-00138858": "evolution from our microbial ancestors", "3krqDm4p4qg-00538-00138859-00139047": "harpercollins ISBN", "3krqDm4p4qg-00539-00139048-00139530": "0:04 5 700 1 5x margulis lynn and Dorion", "3krqDm4p4qg-00540-00139531-00139875": "Sagan 1991 mystery dance on the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00541-00139876-00140109": "evolution of human sexuality Summit", "3krqDm4p4qg-00542-00140110-00140424": "books ISBN oh six seven one six three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00543-00140425-00140702": "three four one four margulis lynn Edie", "3krqDm4p4qg-00544-00140703-00141033": "1991 symbiosis as a source of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00545-00141034-00141282": "evolutionary innovation speciation and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00546-00141283-00141612": "morphogenesis the MIT press ISBN oh two", "3krqDm4p4qg-00547-00141613-00141891": "six two one three two six nine nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00548-00141892-00142281": "Margolis Lynn 1991 symbiosis in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00549-00142282-00142517": "evolution origins of cell motility in", "3krqDm4p4qg-00550-00142518-00142935": "ozawa sighs Oh Hans Oh tasuku evolution", "3krqDm4p4qg-00551-00142936-00143187": "of life fossils molecules in culture", "3krqDm4p4qg-00552-00143188-00143784": "Japan Springer pp 305 2 324 joy ten", "3krqDm4p4qg-00553-00143785-00143994": "point one zero zero seven nine seven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00554-00143995-00144258": "eight four four three one six eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00555-00144259-00144642": "three oh two five underscore 19 ISBN", "3krqDm4p4qg-00556-00144643-00144906": "nine seven eight four four three one six", "3krqDm4p4qg-00557-00144907-00145238": "eight three oh four nine margulis lynn", "3krqDm4p4qg-00558-00145239-00145566": "1992 symbiosis in cell evolution", "3krqDm4p4qg-00559-00145567-00145794": "microbial communities in the archean and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00560-00145795-00146139": "proterozoic Ian's WH Freeman is B and O", "3krqDm4p4qg-00561-00146140-00146388": "seven one six seven seven oh two eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00562-00146389-00146681": "eight Sagan Dorian and margulis lynn", "3krqDm4p4qg-00563-00146682-00147051": "1993 the garden of microbial delights a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00564-00147052-00147252": "practical guide to the sub visible world", "3krqDm4p4qg-00565-00147253-00147363": "kendall hunt", "3krqDm4p4qg-00566-00147364-00147708": "ISBN o8 403 eight five two nine three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00567-00147709-00148009": "margulis lynn Dorion Sagan and Nile", "3krqDm4p4qg-00568-00148010-00148302": "eldritch 1995 what is life simon &", "3krqDm4p4qg-00569-00148303-00148651": "schuster ISBN 978 oh six eight four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00570-00148652-00148866": "eight one oh eight seven four margulis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00571-00148867-00149275": "lynn and Dorion Sagan 1997 slanted", "3krqDm4p4qg-00572-00149276-00149326": "truths", "3krqDm4p4qg-00573-00149327-00149608": "essays on Gaia symbiosis and evolution", "3krqDm4p4qg-00574-00149609-00149875": "Copernicus books ISBN oh three eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00575-00149876-00150124": "seven nine four nine two seventy-five", "3krqDm4p4qg-00576-00150125-00150574": "margulis lynn and Dorion Sagan 1997 what", "3krqDm4p4qg-00577-00150575-00150637": "is sex", "3krqDm4p4qg-00578-00150638-00150940": "simon & schuster ISBN oh six eight four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00579-00150941-00151201": "eight two six nine one seven margulis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00580-00151202-00151594": "lynn and colleen v schwartz 1997 five", "3krqDm4p4qg-00581-00151595-00151795": "kingdoms an illustrated guide to the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00582-00151796-00152047": "phyla of life on Earth WH Freeman and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00583-00152048-00152340": "company is B and O six one three nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00584-00152341-00152548": "two three three eight three margulis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00585-00152549-00152964": "lynn 1998 symbiotic planet a new look at", "3krqDm4p4qg-00586-00152965-00153472": "evolution basic books ISBN o46 507 271", "3krqDm4p4qg-00587-00153473-00153874": "to margulis lynn a tall 2002 the ice", "3krqDm4p4qg-00588-00153875-00154077": "chronicles the quest to understand", "3krqDm4p4qg-00589-00154078-00154321": "global climate change University of New", "3krqDm4p4qg-00590-00154322-00154369": "Hampshire", "3krqDm4p4qg-00591-00154370-00154768": "ISBN one five eight four six 506 to one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00592-00154769-00155124": "margulis lynn and Dorion Sagan 2002", "3krqDm4p4qg-00593-00155125-00155364": "acquiring genomes a theory of the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00594-00155365-00155581": "origins of species Perseus Books group", "3krqDm4p4qg-00595-00155582-00155869": "is B and O four six five zero four three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00596-00155870-00156231": "nine one seven Margolis Lynn 2007", "3krqDm4p4qg-00597-00156232-00156508": "luminous fish tales of science and love", "3krqDm4p4qg-00598-00156509-00156883": "science writers books ISBN 978 one nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00599-00156884-00157135": "three three three nine two three three 2", "3krqDm4p4qg-00600-00157136-00157443": "margulis lynn and eduardo punset EDS", "3krqDm4p4qg-00601-00157444-00157764": "2007 mind life and universe", "3krqDm4p4qg-00602-00157765-00157989": "conversations with great scientists of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00603-00157990-00158277": "our time science writers books ISBN 978", "3krqDm4p4qg-00604-00158278-00158611": "one nine three three three nine two six", "3krqDm4p4qg-00605-00158612-00158901": "one five margulis lynn and Dorion Sagan", "3krqDm4p4qg-00606-00158902-00159274": "2007 dazzle gradually reflections on the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00607-00159275-00159481": "nature of nature science writers books", "3krqDm4p4qg-00608-00159482-00159844": "ISBN 978 one nine three three three nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00609-00159845-00160197": "two three one eight Margolis Lynn 2009", "3krqDm4p4qg-00610-00160198-00160479": "genome acquisition in horizontal gene", "3krqDm4p4qg-00611-00160480-00160714": "transfer symbiogenesis and macro", "3krqDm4p4qg-00612-00160715-00161028": "molecular sequence analysis Ingo garden", "3krqDm4p4qg-00613-00161029-00161338": "maria Beckles go garden Johan Peter Olin", "3krqDm4p4qg-00614-00161339-00161410": "gen Sookie", "3krqDm4p4qg-00615-00161411-00161589": "Lorain see horizontal gene transfer", "3krqDm4p4qg-00616-00161590-00161923": "genomes influx methods in molecular", "3krqDm4p4qg-00617-00161924-00162624": "biology 532 Humana press PP 181 to 191", "3krqDm4p4qg-00618-00162625-00162985": "doy 10.1 zero zero seven nine seven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00619-00162986-00163278": "eight one six zero three two seven eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00620-00163279-00163666": "five three nine underscore ten ISBN nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00621-00163667-00163915": "seven eight one six zero three two seven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00622-00163916-00164302": "eight five two two pmid nineteen million", "3krqDm4p4qg-00623-00164303-00164512": "two hundred seventy one thousand one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00624-00164513-00164829": "hundred eighty five Cs one main uses", "3krqDm4p4qg-00625-00164830-00165320": "editors parameter link", "3krqDm4p4qg-00626-00165321-00165795": "topic journals", "3krqDm4p4qg-00627-00165796-00166253": "Margolis Sagan L 1967 on the origin of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00628-00166254-00166550": "my teasing cells Journal of theoretical", "3krqDm4p4qg-00629-00166551-00167373": "biology 14 3 225 to 274 boy 10.10 1 600", "3krqDm4p4qg-00630-00167374-00167706": "2 2 5 1 9 3 6 7", "3krqDm4p4qg-00631-00167707-00168490": "900 7 9 3 pmid 11 million 540 1392", "3krqDm4p4qg-00632-00168491-00168974": "Margulis L 1976 genetic and evolutionary", "3krqDm4p4qg-00633-00168975-00169350": "consequences of symbiosis experimental", "3krqDm4p4qg-00634-00169351-00169998": "parasitology 39 to 277 to 349 boy ten", "3krqDm4p4qg-00635-00169999-00170288": "point one zero one six zero one four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00636-00170289-00170516": "four eight nine four seven six nine zero", "3krqDm4p4qg-00637-00170517-00170886": "one two seven two pmid eight hundred", "3krqDm4p4qg-00638-00170887-00171166": "sixteen thousand six hundred sixty-eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00639-00171167-00171420": "Margulis L 1980", "3krqDm4p4qg-00640-00171421-00171761": "Anjali podía flagella and cilia", "3krqDm4p4qg-00641-00171762-00172313": "Biosystems 12 one two - 105 to 108 doy", "3krqDm4p4qg-00642-00172314-00172599": "ten point one zero one six oh three oh", "3krqDm4p4qg-00643-00172600-00172838": "three two six four seven eight oh", "3krqDm4p4qg-00644-00172839-00173301": "900 four one six pmid seven million", "3krqDm4p4qg-00645-00173302-00173496": "three hundred seventy eight thousand", "3krqDm4p4qg-00646-00173497-00173796": "five hundred fifty-one Margolis l", "3krqDm4p4qg-00647-00173797-00174227": "Bermuda D 1985 symbiosis as a mechanism", "3krqDm4p4qg-00648-00174228-00174507": "of evolution status of cell symbiosis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00649-00174508-00175133": "theory symbiosis 1 to 100 1 minus 124", "3krqDm4p4qg-00650-00175134-00175461": "pmid 11 million five hundred forty-three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00651-00175462-00175809": "thousand six hundred eight sagen d", "3krqDm4p4qg-00652-00175810-00176213": "Margulis L 1987 Gaia and the evolution", "3krqDm4p4qg-00653-00176214-00176621": "of machines whole earth review 55 -", "3krqDm4p4qg-00654-00176622-00177272": "15-21 pmid 11 million 540 2100 to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00655-00177273-00177725": "Bermuda D Margulis L Zarate's amis G", "3krqDm4p4qg-00656-00177726-00178129": "1987 prokaryotic origin of Anjali podía", "3krqDm4p4qg-00657-00178130-00178376": "application of the Panda principle to", "3krqDm4p4qg-00658-00178377-00178659": "the centriole enigma annals of the New", "3krqDm4p4qg-00659-00178660-00179184": "York Academy of Sciences 503 1 187 2 1", "3krqDm4p4qg-00660-00179185-00179511": "97 bib code 1 9 8 7", "3krqDm4p4qg-00661-00179512-00180114": "nya sa point 5 0 3 187 b-boy 10 point 1", "3krqDm4p4qg-00662-00180115-00180798": "1 1 1 J dot 174 9 - 6 6 3 2 1987 TB", "3krqDm4p4qg-00663-00180799-00181538": "40,000 600 8x pmid 3 million 300 4075", "3krqDm4p4qg-00664-00181539-00182057": "Lazcano a guerrero are Margolis El Oro J", "3krqDm4p4qg-00665-00182058-00182400": "1988 the evolutionary transition from", "3krqDm4p4qg-00666-00182401-00182862": "RNA to DNA in early cells Journal of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00667-00182863-00183435": "molecular evolution 27 4 283 - 290 bib", "3krqDm4p4qg-00668-00183436-00184164": "code 1988 j/mol 0.27 283 al joy 10.1 0 0", "3krqDm4p4qg-00669-00184165-00184526": "7 b fo - 101 1 8 9", "3krqDm4p4qg-00670-00184527-00184872": "pmid 2 million four hundred sixty four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00671-00184873-00185093": "thousand six hundred ninety-eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00672-00185094-00185527": "Margulis L 1990 words as battle cries", "3krqDm4p4qg-00673-00185528-00185793": "symbiogenesis and the new field of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00674-00185794-00186764": "endocytosis 49 673 - 677 joy 10 point 2", "3krqDm4p4qg-00675-00186765-00187050": "3 0 7 1 million three hundred eleven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00676-00187051-00187514": "thousand 435 JSTOR 1 million three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00677-00187515-00187962": "hundred eleven thousand 435 pmid eleven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00678-00187963-00188187": "million five hundred forty-one thousand", "3krqDm4p4qg-00679-00188188-00188357": "two hundred ninety three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00680-00188358-00188802": "Margolis l 1996 archaea you bacterial", "3krqDm4p4qg-00681-00188803-00189011": "mergers in the origin of Eukarya", "3krqDm4p4qg-00682-00189012-00189364": "phylogenetic classification of life", "3krqDm4p4qg-00683-00189365-00189597": "Proceedings of the National Academy of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00684-00189598-00189869": "Sciences of the United States of America", "3krqDm4p4qg-00685-00189870-00190431": "93 310 71 to 1076 bib code one nine nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00686-00190432-00190708": "six P and a s", "3krqDm4p4qg-00687-00190709-00191092": "Oh point nine three 107 one em boy", "3krqDm4p4qg-00688-00191093-00191365": "ten point one zero seven three PNAS", "3krqDm4p4qg-00689-00191366-00191560": "ninety three point three point one zero", "3krqDm4p4qg-00690-00191561-00191934": "seven one pmc forty thousand thirty two", "3krqDm4p4qg-00691-00191935-00192256": "pmid eight million five hundred seventy", "3krqDm4p4qg-00692-00192257-00192507": "seven thousand seven hundred sixteen", "3krqDm4p4qg-00693-00192508-00193027": "Chapman MJ Margulis L 1998 morphogenesis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00694-00193028-00193344": "by symbiogenesis international", "3krqDm4p4qg-00695-00193345-00193918": "microbiology one for 319 226 pmid ten", "3krqDm4p4qg-00696-00193919-00194068": "million nine hundred forty-three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00697-00194069-00194316": "thousand three hundred eighty-one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00698-00194317-00194764": "Margolis L Dolan MF Guerrero our 2000", "3krqDm4p4qg-00699-00194765-00195019": "the chimeric eukaryote origin of the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00700-00195020-00195250": "nucleus from the Carrio must Egon tin a", "3krqDm4p4qg-00701-00195251-00195619": "mitochondria protists Proceedings of the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00702-00195620-00195958": "National Academy of Sciences 97 thirteen", "3krqDm4p4qg-00703-00195959-00196263": "six nine five four six nine fifty-nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00704-00196264-00196688": "bib code 200 o PNAS", "3krqDm4p4qg-00705-00196689-00196970": "Oh point nine seven six nine five four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00706-00196971-00197290": "em boy ten point one zero seven three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00707-00197291-00197573": "PNAS point nine seven point one three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00708-00197574-00197924": "point six nine fifty four pm see thirty", "3krqDm4p4qg-00709-00197925-00198131": "four thousand three hundred sixty nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00710-00198132-00198434": "pmid ten million eight hundred sixty", "3krqDm4p4qg-00711-00198435-00198637": "thousand nine hundred fifty-six", "3krqDm4p4qg-00712-00198638-00199107": "we're a Dolan M Grimaldi D Guerrero our", "3krqDm4p4qg-00713-00199108-00199613": "wagons burg J Margulis L 2002 spirochete", "3krqDm4p4qg-00714-00199614-00199877": "and protist symbionts of a termite Masto", "3krqDm4p4qg-00715-00199878-00200108": "termes electra dominica s-- in maya seen", "3krqDm4p4qg-00716-00200109-00200372": "amber Proceedings of the National", "3krqDm4p4qg-00717-00200373-00200682": "Academy of Sciences ninety nine three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00718-00200683-00200954": "fourteen ten to fourteen thirteen bib", "3krqDm4p4qg-00719-00200955-00201291": "code 200 to p and a s", "3krqDm4p4qg-00720-00201292-00201723": "point nine nine one four 100w boy ten", "3krqDm4p4qg-00721-00201724-00202017": "point one zero seven three PNAS point", "3krqDm4p4qg-00722-00202018-00202275": "zero two two six four three eight nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00723-00202276-00202902": "nine pmc100 22,200 four pmid eleven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00724-00202903-00203091": "million eight hundred eighteen thousand", "3krqDm4p4qg-00725-00203092-00203430": "five hundred thirty-four Dolan Michael f", "3krqDm4p4qg-00726-00203431-00203751": "melnitz ki Hana margulis lynn Col Niki", "3krqDm4p4qg-00727-00203752-00204111": "Robin 2002 motility proteins and the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00728-00204112-00204438": "origin of the nucleus the anatomical", "3krqDm4p4qg-00729-00204439-00205035": "record 268 3 292 301 joy ten point one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00730-00205036-00205350": "zero zero to R point one zero one six", "3krqDm4p4qg-00731-00205351-00205680": "one pmid twelve million three hundred", "3krqDm4p4qg-00732-00205681-00205857": "eighty two thousand three hundred", "3krqDm4p4qg-00733-00205858-00206348": "twenty-five Margulis L 2005 Hans wrists", "3krqDm4p4qg-00734-00206348-00206567": "1914 to 2004", "3krqDm4p4qg-00735-00206569-00206844": "Gina four chromosomes and a bacterial", "3krqDm4p4qg-00736-00206844-00207105": "origin of chloroplasts international", "3krqDm4p4qg-00737-00207106-00207402": "microbiology eight to one hundred forty", "3krqDm4p4qg-00738-00207403-00207740": "five to eight pmid sixteen million fifty", "3krqDm4p4qg-00739-00207741-00207994": "two thousand four hundred sixty-five", "3krqDm4p4qg-00740-00207996-00208465": "Margolis l Chapman M Guerrero our Hall J", "3krqDm4p4qg-00741-00208466-00208869": "2006 the last eukaryotic common ancestor", "3krqDm4p4qg-00742-00208869-00208973": "Leca", "3krqDm4p4qg-00743-00208973-00209226": "acquisition of cytoskeletal motility", "3krqDm4p4qg-00744-00209227-00209460": "from arid tolerant spirochetes in the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00745-00209461-00209675": "proterozoic eon", "3krqDm4p4qg-00746-00209676-00209907": "Proceedings of the National Academy of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00747-00209908-00210513": "Sciences 103 35 one 308 o1 308 five bib", "3krqDm4p4qg-00748-00210514-00211062": "code 200 6 P and a s103 one 308 om joy", "3krqDm4p4qg-00749-00211063-00211281": "ten point one zero seven three", "3krqDm4p4qg-00750-00211282-00211608": "PNAS point zero six zero four nine eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00751-00211609-00212028": "five one zero three PMC 1 million five", "3krqDm4p4qg-00752-00212029-00212217": "hundred fifty nine thousand seven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00753-00212217-00212571": "hundred fifty six pmid sixteen million", "3krqDm4p4qg-00754-00212571-00212766": "nine hundred thirty eight thousand eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00755-00212767-00213176": "hundred forty one Dolan MF Margulis L", "3krqDm4p4qg-00756-00213177-00213548": "2007 advances in biology revealed truth", "3krqDm4p4qg-00757-00213550-00214185": "about prokaryotes nature 445 7123", "3krqDm4p4qg-00758-00214186-00214810": "21 bib code 2007 NAT or 0.45", "3krqDm4p4qg-00759-00214811-00215317": "21d joy 10.10 three eight four four five", "3krqDm4p4qg-00760-00215319-00215750": "oh two one be pmid seventeen million two", "3krqDm4p4qg-00761-00215751-00215977": "hundred three thousand thirty nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00762-00215978-00216314": "margulis lynn chapman Michael Dolan", "3krqDm4p4qg-00763-00216315-00216671": "Michael F 2007 seems for analysis of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00764-00216671-00216952": "evolution deduce peroxisomes and Myers", "3krqDm4p4qg-00765-00216953-00217166": "hydrogenases in the sulfurous", "3krqDm4p4qg-00766-00217167-00217565": "Proterozoic Eon Nature Reviews genetics", "3krqDm4p4qg-00767-00217566-00217844": "eight ten one boy ten point one zero", "3krqDm4p4qg-00768-00217844-00218221": "three eight and our G 207 one C one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00769-00218221-00218480": "pmid seventeen million nine hundred", "3krqDm4p4qg-00770-00218481-00218660": "twenty three thousand eight hundred", "3krqDm4p4qg-00771-00218661-00218788": "fifty-eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00772-00218789-00219332": "rawson o rawson sh scythes J McAlister J", "3krqDm4p4qg-00773-00219333-00219773": "we're a Margulis L 2009 destruction of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00774-00219773-00220034": "spirochete Borrelia burgdorferi round", "3krqDm4p4qg-00775-00220035-00220259": "body propagules our bees by the", "3krqDm4p4qg-00776-00220260-00220642": "antibiotic taiga cycling Proceedings of", "3krqDm4p4qg-00777-00220644-00220862": "the National Academy of Sciences one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00778-00220863-00221081": "hundred six forty four one eight six", "3krqDm4p4qg-00779-00221082-00221438": "five six one eight six six one bib code", "3krqDm4p4qg-00780-00221439-00221786": "200 nine PNAS one O six one eight six", "3krqDm4p4qg-00781-00221787-00222164": "five six be boy ten point one zero seven", "3krqDm4p4qg-00782-00222165-00222469": "three PNAS point zero nine zero eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00783-00222471-00222866": "two three six one zero six PMC two", "3krqDm4p4qg-00784-00222867-00223064": "million seven hundred seventy four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00785-00223065-00223352": "thousand thirty pmid nineteen million", "3krqDm4p4qg-00786-00223353-00223562": "eight hundred forty three thousand six", "3krqDm4p4qg-00787-00223563-00223964": "hundred ninety one we're a.m. Sacchi L", "3krqDm4p4qg-00788-00223965-00224428": "Dolan MF Bondi C McAlister J Margulis L", "3krqDm4p4qg-00789-00224429-00224717": "2010 spirochete attachment", "3krqDm4p4qg-00790-00224717-00224810": "ultrastructure", "3krqDm4p4qg-00791-00224811-00225014": "implications for the origin and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00792-00225015-00225359": "evolution of cilia the biological", "3krqDm4p4qg-00793-00225360-00225659": "bulletin 218 one twenty five to thirty", "3krqDm4p4qg-00794-00225660-00225950": "five pmid twenty million two hundred", "3krqDm4p4qg-00795-00225951-00226225": "three thousand two hundred fifty one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00796-00226226-00226679": "Guerrero our Margulis L Berlanga M von d", "3krqDm4p4qg-00797-00226680-00227081": "c McAllister J Margulis L 2013", "3krqDm4p4qg-00798-00227082-00227392": "symbiogenesis the hallo bein Taz a unit", "3krqDm4p4qg-00799-00227394-00227741": "of evolution international microbiology", "3krqDm4p4qg-00800-00227742-00228167": "16 3 133 to 143", "3krqDm4p4qg-00801-00228167-00228464": "boy ten point two four three six twenty", "3krqDm4p4qg-00802-00228465-00228701": "point one five zero one point zero one", "3krqDm4p4qg-00803-00228702-00229040": "point one eight eight pmid twenty four", "3krqDm4p4qg-00804-00229041-00229198": "million five hundred sixty-eight", "3krqDm4p4qg-00805-00229200-00229732": "thousand twenty nine", "3krqDm4p4qg-00806-00229733-00230116": "notes", "3krqDm4p4qg-00807-00230117-00230632": "topic references", "3krqDm4p4qg-00808-00230633-00231009": "topic external links", "3krqDm4p4qg-00809-00231010-00231171": "you", "3krqDm4p4qg-00810-00231171-00231671": "Lynn Margulis biology UMass", "3krqDm4p4qg-00811-00231671-00232128": "endosymbiotic theory worksheet and 100 I", "3krqDm4p4qg-00812-00232129-00232698": "you PU I January 14 2002 Tisch field J", "3krqDm4p4qg-00813-00232698-00233159": "2004 Rutgers interview part 1 2010 on", "3krqDm4p4qg-00814-00233160-00233233": "YouTube", "3krqDm4p4qg-00815-00233234-00233751": "part 2 2010 on YouTube part 3 2010 on", "3krqDm4p4qg-00816-00233752-00233825": "YouTube", "3krqDm4p4qg-00817-00233826-00234204": "9 1 1 explosive evidence experts speak", "3krqDm4p4qg-00818-00234205-00234591": "out 2011 excerpt on YouTube works by or", "3krqDm4p4qg-00819-00234592-00234773": "about lynn margulis in library's", "3krqDm4p4qg-00820-00234775-00235103": "WorldCat catalog Lynn Margulis", "3krqDm4p4qg-00821-00235104-00235442": "San Jose science technology and society", "3krqDm4p4qg-00822-00235442-00235683": "Linus Pauling memorial lectures", "3krqDm4p4qg-00823-00235684-00235929": "institute for science engineering and", "3krqDm4p4qg-00824-00235930-00236435": "public policy March 10 2005"}}, {"audio_id": "3kDlONFDbNI", "text": {"3kDlONFDbNI-00000-00000248-00000415": "chris says i don't know if he's joking", "3kDlONFDbNI-00001-00000416-00000599": "but", "3kDlONFDbNI-00002-00000600-00000958": "they don't have retinol down here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00003-00000959-00001798": "it's an issue yeah working to resolve it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00004-00001800-00002271": "the tiny little brittle star there yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00005-00002272-00002399": "it's like good for the base would you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00006-00002400-00002567": "guys want to work out more that's good", "3kDlONFDbNI-00007-00002568-00002775": "okay thank you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00008-00002776-00002966": "okay direct me to this white one that we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00009-00002967-00003247": "want it's a white fan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00010-00003247-00003543": "right of our screen to the right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00011-00003544-00003790": "yeah it's very interesting", "3kDlONFDbNI-00012-00003792-00003983": "let's see i'll know it when i see it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00013-00003984-00004375": "yeah there it is oh yes i will", "3kDlONFDbNI-00014-00004376-00004735": "hello there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00015-00004736-00005015": "good morning good morning", "3kDlONFDbNI-00016-00005016-00005367": "how do you do today", "3kDlONFDbNI-00017-00005368-00006069": "welcome to the techtonic talkers", "3kDlONFDbNI-00018-00006070-00006575": "[Laughter]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00019-00006576-00006734": "look at that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00020-00006736-00007095": "it looks like a candelabra", "3kDlONFDbNI-00021-00007095-00007375": "oh there's another one down in the yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00022-00007376-00007663": "measure there looks to be similar", "3kDlONFDbNI-00023-00007664-00007974": "i wonder if that one down there is alive", "3kDlONFDbNI-00024-00007975-00008151": "and what kind of current is it taking", "3kDlONFDbNI-00025-00008152-00008383": "advantage of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00026-00008384-00008463": "which", "3kDlONFDbNI-00027-00008464-00008687": "wow look at the size of that bamboo", "3kDlONFDbNI-00028-00008688-00009399": "coral in the back paragorgia day", "3kDlONFDbNI-00029-00009400-00009614": "and look at the spiny thing behind that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00030-00009615-00009823": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00031-00009824-00010623": "quite a few coral species here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00032-00010624-00010846": "beautiful", "3kDlONFDbNI-00033-00010847-00011078": "okay let's get a zoom on that guy zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00034-00011079-00011174": "in", "3kDlONFDbNI-00035-00011175-00012391": "i can try i'll line them up better", "3kDlONFDbNI-00036-00012392-00012631": "there we go", "3kDlONFDbNI-00037-00012632-00013422": "go for it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00038-00013423-00013855": "wow it's polyps really stick out far", "3kDlONFDbNI-00039-00013856-00014191": "yeah okay that's oh they get out there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00040-00014191-00014351": "there's a shrimp in the background", "3kDlONFDbNI-00041-00014352-00014551": "uh-huh they make the most of their real", "3kDlONFDbNI-00042-00014552-00014638": "zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00043-00014640-00014911": "okay awesome could be a love a good full", "3kDlONFDbNI-00044-00014912-00015199": "zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00045-00015200-00017071": "gorgia species but not sure", "3kDlONFDbNI-00046-00017072-00017358": "oh i think i'll move if i don't don't", "3kDlONFDbNI-00047-00017359-00017591": "okay no need to sample", "3kDlONFDbNI-00048-00017592-00017727": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00049-00017728-00018150": "i'm good gabby thank you okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00050-00018151-00018335": "emil would this be considered oh that's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00051-00018336-00018479": "from just being over", "3kDlONFDbNI-00052-00018480-00018671": "overdoing the verts i'd say it's fairly", "3kDlONFDbNI-00053-00018672-00019103": "high density okay got it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00054-00019104-00019599": "got it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00055-00019600-00019903": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00056-00019904-00020094": "okay what's next", "3kDlONFDbNI-00057-00020095-00020486": "i'm gonna make another move", "3kDlONFDbNI-00058-00020487-00020814": "right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00059-00020815-00021071": "uh still 180", "3kDlONFDbNI-00060-00021072-00021294": "well the density should only increase as", "3kDlONFDbNI-00061-00021295-00021558": "we move upwards so let's see", "3kDlONFDbNI-00062-00021559-00021791": "look i feel like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00063-00021792-00021991": "let's follow the map for this next move", "3kDlONFDbNI-00064-00021992-00022167": "since i don't have a since it's pretty", "3kDlONFDbNI-00065-00022168-00022311": "flattened out here a little bit", "3kDlONFDbNI-00066-00022312-00022591": "southwest yeah what is your what is your", "3kDlONFDbNI-00067-00022592-00023086": "yeah i think that's a good idea", "3kDlONFDbNI-00068-00023087-00024030": "yep oh wow", "3kDlONFDbNI-00069-00024031-00024247": "bridge now", "3kDlONFDbNI-00070-00024248-00024399": "everything's always the most dramatic", "3kDlONFDbNI-00071-00024400-00024599": "when herc is above argus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00072-00024600-00024727": "i just like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00073-00024728-00025007": "this is sort of making me nauseous", "3kDlONFDbNI-00074-00025008-00025383": "30 meters bearing 2-1-0 beautiful oh my", "3kDlONFDbNI-00075-00025384-00025575": "gosh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00076-00025576-00025783": "yeah that's a good still of hercules", "3kDlONFDbNI-00077-00025783-00026006": "doing his thing thank you alex", "3kDlONFDbNI-00078-00026007-00026255": "okay what do you what's our next bearing", "3kDlONFDbNI-00079-00026256-00026551": "two one zero roger that seems like an", "3kDlONFDbNI-00080-00026552-00027927": "awesome one i think so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00081-00027927-00028990": "there's a move in at two one zero", "3kDlONFDbNI-00082-00028991-00029174": "thanks dan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00083-00029175-00029495": "sure", "3kDlONFDbNI-00084-00029495-00029695": "whoa here this is a great look you're", "3kDlONFDbNI-00085-00029695-00029879": "pretty close to stuff too dan the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00086-00029880-00030111": "hercules thrusters that we don't usually", "3kDlONFDbNI-00087-00030112-00030431": "get to see oh yeah they look cool oh my", "3kDlONFDbNI-00088-00030432-00030702": "gosh look at this", "3kDlONFDbNI-00089-00030703-00030895": "dan's got the stomach for these sort of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00090-00030895-00031158": "argus moves so i'm just gonna like i'm", "3kDlONFDbNI-00091-00031160-00031470": "gonna play it up here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00092-00031472-00031831": "i know", "3kDlONFDbNI-00093-00031832-00032007": "here look at herk is just checking out", "3kDlONFDbNI-00094-00032008-00032231": "these hair corals", "3kDlONFDbNI-00095-00032232-00032558": "and you can see it all in argus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00096-00032560-00032983": "great flying", "3kDlONFDbNI-00097-00032984-00033190": "um do you guys want to stop and look at", "3kDlONFDbNI-00098-00033191-00033407": "any of these or we set to move on from", "3kDlONFDbNI-00099-00033408-00033679": "here i think we want to get um", "3kDlONFDbNI-00100-00033680-00033862": "yeah i want to get up slope see if we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00101-00033863-00034159": "can get higher densities the ship move", "3kDlONFDbNI-00102-00034160-00034302": "is in so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00103-00034303-00034695": "we're doing it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00104-00034696-00034999": "so a viewer wants to know", "3kDlONFDbNI-00105-00035000-00035271": "what are these coral feeding on", "3kDlONFDbNI-00106-00035272-00035462": "they've heard that ocean currents are", "3kDlONFDbNI-00107-00035463-00035639": "called the ubereats for coral but", "3kDlONFDbNI-00108-00035640-00035790": "they're not quite sure what's being", "3kDlONFDbNI-00109-00035791-00036239": "delivered wow i enjoy that term", "3kDlONFDbNI-00110-00036240-00036662": "that's very funny that is good", "3kDlONFDbNI-00111-00036663-00037118": "also known as c floor dash", "3kDlONFDbNI-00112-00037119-00037287": "oh man", "3kDlONFDbNI-00113-00037288-00037511": "stephen is on fire", "3kDlONFDbNI-00114-00037512-00037711": "i might have to relinquish my title of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00115-00037712-00037927": "pun master general here i feel like i", "3kDlONFDbNI-00116-00037928-00038407": "got the watch of my dreams", "3kDlONFDbNI-00117-00038408-00038583": "so these corals are filter feeders and", "3kDlONFDbNI-00118-00038584-00038711": "they're uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00119-00038712-00038879": "filtering out small", "3kDlONFDbNI-00120-00038880-00039079": "pieces of i'm going to keep this move", "3kDlONFDbNI-00121-00039080-00039262": "going yeah let's keep it going yep i'm", "3kDlONFDbNI-00122-00039263-00039455": "going to step a little larger too yep go", "3kDlONFDbNI-00123-00039456-00039551": "for it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00124-00039552-00039662": "bridge", "3kDlONFDbNI-00125-00039663-00039935": "and if we see an angular rock that is", "3kDlONFDbNI-00126-00039936-00040174": "easy to pick up and not attach let's go", "3kDlONFDbNI-00127-00040175-00040439": "ahead and grab one okay here we go yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00128-00040440-00040830": "that might be a good opportunity here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00129-00040831-00041087": "one zero", "3kDlONFDbNI-00130-00041088-00041255": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00131-00041256-00041390": "oh you had those off for the beauty", "3kDlONFDbNI-00132-00041391-00041543": "shots", "3kDlONFDbNI-00133-00041544-00041646": "nice one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00134-00041647-00041902": "that is correct thank you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00135-00041903-00042174": "something in here looks good yeah so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00136-00042175-00042327": "these cool are feeding on something", "3kDlONFDbNI-00137-00042328-00042535": "that's called marine snow that's back to", "3kDlONFDbNI-00138-00042536-00042679": "full wide on", "3kDlONFDbNI-00139-00042680-00042935": "drifting down from above was that a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00140-00042936-00043118": "circle these are rocks you want to get", "3kDlONFDbNI-00141-00043119-00043335": "yes those are the options we want to", "3kDlONFDbNI-00142-00043336-00043574": "look at yeah okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00143-00043575-00043758": "sorry to interrupt veda can you make a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00144-00043759-00043911": "note in the log about the argus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00145-00043912-00044302": "highlights there for uh mr jonathan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00146-00044303-00044527": "uh yes i can", "3kDlONFDbNI-00147-00044528-00044727": "okay dan we've got", "3kDlONFDbNI-00148-00044728-00044999": "can you repeat that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00149-00045000-00045215": "uh data did you get that about the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00150-00045216-00045502": "highlights for jonathan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00151-00045503-00045671": "uh yeah all the video highlights yep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00152-00045672-00046062": "yeah you flagged it okay great okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00153-00046063-00046383": "thank you okay how about this guy here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00154-00046384-00046551": "yeah that guy looks good those angular", "3kDlONFDbNI-00155-00046552-00046711": "wands up there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00156-00046712-00047015": "perfect", "3kDlONFDbNI-00157-00047016-00048143": "that looks pretty angular yep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00158-00048144-00048351": "there's another one yeah drawing for me", "3kDlONFDbNI-00159-00048352-00048583": "i think the time code for those argus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00160-00048584-00049383": "shots was uh 0 0 28.", "3kDlONFDbNI-00161-00049384-00049551": "they have to get in the data log when", "3kDlONFDbNI-00162-00049552-00049735": "jonathan sees them", "3kDlONFDbNI-00163-00049736-00050095": "he's got a macro in there that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00164-00050096-00050358": "right actually scf is um", "3kDlONFDbNI-00165-00050359-00050527": "yeah that's when the ratings in that's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00166-00050528-00050830": "me dan i i gave it a four but uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00167-00050831-00051071": "i could maybe it's the spf that does it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00168-00051072-00051183": "this one here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00169-00051184-00051919": "yeah see if you can get that one yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00170-00051920-00052119": "observe the long gangly fingers that we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00171-00052120-00052526": "now have on our beak yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00172-00052527-00052742": "yeah and we at full beans we don't know", "3kDlONFDbNI-00173-00052744-00053079": "if it's soft or hard right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00174-00053079-00053215": "it doesn't have as much pressure with", "3kDlONFDbNI-00175-00053216-00053487": "starboard one of the big ones or yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00176-00053488-00053671": "but let's um can we get this in one of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00177-00053672-00053847": "the big ones and let's see if we can get", "3kDlONFDbNI-00178-00053848-00054182": "um two in the big one right and start", "3kDlONFDbNI-00179-00054183-00054535": "maximizing some of our space um", "3kDlONFDbNI-00180-00054536-00054830": "around the starboard side yeah roger", "3kDlONFDbNI-00181-00054832-00054959": "that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00182-00054960-00055166": "could get a lot more than two", "3kDlONFDbNI-00183-00055167-00055303": "into the big one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00184-00055304-00055519": "yeah this size yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00185-00055520-00055719": "because this one only looks about maybe", "3kDlONFDbNI-00186-00055720-00056007": "30 centimeters right grapefruit maybe", "3kDlONFDbNI-00187-00056008-00056599": "yeah oh i think it's smaller than that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00188-00056600-00056766": "one of the ways we tell how big uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00189-00056767-00056959": "things are the two laser dots that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00190-00056960-00057150": "you're seeing the green dots", "3kDlONFDbNI-00191-00057151-00057542": "this is nav what sample number is this", "3kDlONFDbNI-00192-00057544-00057871": "this is zero two five", "3kDlONFDbNI-00193-00057872-00058191": "we're gonna go for uh f here right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00194-00058191-00058447": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00195-00058448-00058679": "and then now that we know we have f has", "3kDlONFDbNI-00196-00058679-00058887": "a small rock let's put another one in", "3kDlONFDbNI-00197-00058888-00059094": "there oh yeah grab another one from here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00198-00059095-00059391": "um we can go well did we see another", "3kDlONFDbNI-00199-00059391-00059615": "angular one that was a little", "3kDlONFDbNI-00200-00059616-00059830": "behind i think where we were a little", "3kDlONFDbNI-00201-00059832-00060182": "closer yeah yeah a little closer to us", "3kDlONFDbNI-00202-00060183-00060542": "oh you're good okay oops", "3kDlONFDbNI-00203-00060544-00060711": "the one at the bottom of the camera", "3kDlONFDbNI-00204-00060712-00060911": "there yeah right by the porch i think we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00205-00060912-00061150": "saw one that was most angular just to", "3kDlONFDbNI-00206-00061151-00061350": "the left", "3kDlONFDbNI-00207-00061351-00061591": "a little further left", "3kDlONFDbNI-00208-00061591-00061791": "this guy here right no i think the guy", "3kDlONFDbNI-00209-00061791-00061935": "that you're moving with the porch right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00210-00061936-00062199": "now so he's to the it's just off to the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00211-00062200-00062350": "left yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00212-00062351-00062550": "he might be sitting on him", "3kDlONFDbNI-00213-00062551-00062919": "all right and left a little", "3kDlONFDbNI-00214-00062920-00063230": "yup that guy exactly so angular oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00215-00063232-00063391": "lovely yes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00216-00063391-00063623": "look at him he's like i got all the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00217-00063624-00063863": "corners baby", "3kDlONFDbNI-00218-00063864-00064166": "he cornered all the markets", "3kDlONFDbNI-00219-00064167-00064430": "two green dots are 10 centimeters apart", "3kDlONFDbNI-00220-00064432-00064630": "so when the when the two green dots", "3kDlONFDbNI-00221-00064632-00064799": "shine on the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00222-00064800-00064999": "rock sample we gotta put that one in the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00223-00065000-00065175": "same box yeah let's put that one in the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00224-00065176-00065342": "same box and then is there a way that we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00225-00065344-00065494": "can get a camera view and then see if", "3kDlONFDbNI-00226-00065495-00065703": "there's any space left in the box yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00227-00065704-00065926": "if you look at um", "3kDlONFDbNI-00228-00065927-00066071": "the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00229-00066072-00066303": "channel 3 right now you can kind of see", "3kDlONFDbNI-00230-00066304-00066455": "down in the boxes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00231-00066456-00066711": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00232-00066712-00066863": "so it looks like there's a lot of space", "3kDlONFDbNI-00233-00066864-00069006": "in there now oh yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00234-00069007-00069206": "tons of space in there yeah see those", "3kDlONFDbNI-00235-00069207-00069455": "rocks yeah so if we want to next time we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00236-00069456-00069687": "stop and we're going to go for a say a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00237-00069688-00069887": "30 centimeter diameter again i think we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00238-00069888-00070055": "could fit another one in there and make", "3kDlONFDbNI-00239-00070056-00070263": "better use of the space", "3kDlONFDbNI-00240-00070264-00070494": "we can have a hard rock box and a soft", "3kDlONFDbNI-00241-00070495-00070775": "rock box", "3kDlONFDbNI-00242-00070776-00070943": "and then i'm fairly sure we have a dr", "3kDlONFDbNI-00243-00070944-00071247": "seuss book on our hands after that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00244-00071248-00071638": "well thank you so much very very helpful", "3kDlONFDbNI-00245-00071639-00071775": "look at that one the manganese crust", "3kDlONFDbNI-00246-00071776-00072103": "just crazy to go dan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00247-00072104-00072319": "just a little push off gabby does both", "3kDlONFDbNI-00248-00072320-00072550": "one into f right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00249-00072551-00072847": "yes both samples in f", "3kDlONFDbNI-00250-00072848-00072991": "do you want separate sample numbers on", "3kDlONFDbNI-00251-00072992-00073255": "those or are those both yes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00252-00073256-00073535": "yeah we can use the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00253-00073536-00073775": "screen grabs to distinguish okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00254-00073776-00073943": "you guys are old news we're looking for", "3kDlONFDbNI-00255-00073944-00074111": "more", "3kDlONFDbNI-00256-00074112-00074326": "we have some manganese nodules here and", "3kDlONFDbNI-00257-00074327-00074519": "then in the argos view you can also see", "3kDlONFDbNI-00258-00074520-00074767": "some current ripples in the sediments", "3kDlONFDbNI-00259-00074768-00076823": "oh yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00260-00076824-00077015": "so what are your goal depths the places", "3kDlONFDbNI-00261-00077016-00077111": "where you think you're going to find the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00262-00077112-00077331": "most biodiversity", "3kDlONFDbNI-00263-00077332-00077679": "2500 at 2100 okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00264-00077680-00078031": "great close very close let's get there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00265-00078032-00078335": "let's go", "3kDlONFDbNI-00266-00078336-00078855": "and why is that experience yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00267-00078856-00079062": "a catalog thus far", "3kDlONFDbNI-00268-00079063-00079247": "roger", "3kDlONFDbNI-00269-00079248-00079391": "even though there have been no dives on", "3kDlONFDbNI-00270-00079392-00079550": "this seamount other seamounts in the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00271-00079551-00079694": "area have had", "3kDlONFDbNI-00272-00079695-00079775": "some", "3kDlONFDbNI-00273-00079776-00080038": "dives on them", "3kDlONFDbNI-00274-00080039-00080331": "and we are currently at around", "3kDlONFDbNI-00275-00080332-00080575": "2540 meters so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00276-00080576-00080871": "we'll be slowly moving uphill here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00277-00080872-00081062": "and seeing how the biology changes as we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00278-00081063-00081271": "go", "3kDlONFDbNI-00279-00081272-00081503": "looks like we have another bamboo coral", "3kDlONFDbNI-00280-00081504-00081638": "on the um", "3kDlONFDbNI-00281-00081639-00081847": "in the argus view straight ahead and", "3kDlONFDbNI-00282-00081848-00082118": "upward there's a little sponge uh-huh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00283-00082119-00082455": "maybe a little sponge that's right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00284-00082456-00082694": "no pigment though so watch leads right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00285-00082695-00082862": "now i'm going to sort of prioritize", "3kDlONFDbNI-00286-00082863-00083062": "getting up to those like goal depths but", "3kDlONFDbNI-00287-00083063-00083206": "if there's something you want me to stop", "3kDlONFDbNI-00288-00083207-00083287": "for", "3kDlONFDbNI-00289-00083288-00083662": "just say the word okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00290-00083663-00083815": "you know when we find the answer to that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00291-00083816-00084023": "question maybe we'll be able to model", "3kDlONFDbNI-00292-00084024-00085262": "where we can", "3kDlONFDbNI-00293-00085263-00085638": "there's an espresso bar right here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00294-00085639-00086103": "bridge now wait for it wait for it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00295-00086104-00086359": "can we move 40 meters bearing two one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00296-00086360-00086455": "zero", "3kDlONFDbNI-00297-00086456-00086726": "i just want to stop here i know this is", "3kDlONFDbNI-00298-00086727-00086963": "down in there between thank you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00299-00086964-00087223": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00300-00087224-00089526": "wow", "3kDlONFDbNI-00301-00089527-00089759": "is that bamboo in the background a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00302-00089760-00089967": "branching one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00303-00089968-00090279": "or those two i cannot tell", "3kDlONFDbNI-00304-00090280-00090494": "it kind of looks like one stock i mean", "3kDlONFDbNI-00305-00090495-00090726": "one base there was a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00306-00090727-00090935": "request from a scientist ashore to", "3kDlONFDbNI-00307-00090936-00091126": "prioritize branching", "3kDlONFDbNI-00308-00091127-00091367": "okay bamboo", "3kDlONFDbNI-00309-00091368-00091599": "okay it looks like one base hey it does", "3kDlONFDbNI-00310-00091600-00091950": "look like one base now that we're closer", "3kDlONFDbNI-00311-00091951-00092279": "sure does yeah i think it is a branching", "3kDlONFDbNI-00312-00092280-00092431": "yeah that that's a one that would might", "3kDlONFDbNI-00313-00092432-00092726": "be a collection target okay okay oh yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00314-00092727-00092959": "election target dan do you want to uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00315-00092960-00093182": "stop on the ship for this one yes i do", "3kDlONFDbNI-00316-00093183-00093438": "yeah yeah i'll stop the ship okay get", "3kDlONFDbNI-00317-00093439-00093615": "her down bridge oh chris", "3kDlONFDbNI-00318-00093616-00093774": "says not this one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00319-00093775-00094103": "oh oh no collection okay oh they need", "3kDlONFDbNI-00320-00094104-00094447": "the joint never mind there was okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00321-00094448-00094687": "we got excited for a second", "3kDlONFDbNI-00322-00094688-00094879": "i thought we might get to use the use", "3kDlONFDbNI-00323-00094880-00095343": "the jaws here for the first time", "3kDlONFDbNI-00324-00095344-00095518": "it's too tall", "3kDlONFDbNI-00325-00095519-00095782": "uh okay yeah that's not something i hear", "3kDlONFDbNI-00326-00095783-00096159": "very often", "3kDlONFDbNI-00327-00096160-00096367": "you are not too tall andrea you are not", "3kDlONFDbNI-00328-00096368-00097038": "too tall", "3kDlONFDbNI-00329-00097039-00097255": "is that an anemone down there or oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00330-00097256-00097487": "that's a spirally coral what do they", "3kDlONFDbNI-00331-00097488-00098079": "call it oh irrita gorgeous yeah nice", "3kDlONFDbNI-00332-00098080-00098431": "really nice guys", "3kDlONFDbNI-00333-00098432-00098687": "anyone care to spell that for me", "3kDlONFDbNI-00334-00098688-00099006": "i-r-i-d-o-r", "3kDlONFDbNI-00335-00099007-00099094": "oops", "3kDlONFDbNI-00336-00099095-00099406": "d-o-g-o", "3kDlONFDbNI-00337-00099407-00099615": "or", "3kDlONFDbNI-00338-00099616-00099743": "chris was impressed by your", "3kDlONFDbNI-00339-00099744-00100079": "identification emil", "3kDlONFDbNI-00340-00100080-00101326": "oh thank you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00341-00101327-00101703": "for wee ones you have to be farther back", "3kDlONFDbNI-00342-00101704-00101903": "so so many beautiful loretta gordy", "3kDlONFDbNI-00343-00101904-00102247": "around uh johnson atoll oh yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00344-00102248-00102542": "baker i they get so big and so long they", "3kDlONFDbNI-00345-00102543-00103399": "just wave in the current", "3kDlONFDbNI-00346-00103400-00103615": "it's they're they're so long that it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00347-00103616-00103823": "makes it obvious to me and i might be", "3kDlONFDbNI-00348-00103824-00104166": "completely wrong but that that spiral", "3kDlONFDbNI-00349-00104167-00104366": "structure allows them a greater", "3kDlONFDbNI-00350-00104367-00104654": "flexibility and to grow longer", "3kDlONFDbNI-00351-00104655-00104983": "roger maximize the exposure yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00352-00104983-00105983": "if you're going to be tall spiral up", "3kDlONFDbNI-00353-00105983-00106158": "so if you're joining us online watching", "3kDlONFDbNI-00354-00106159-00106390": "the videos you can submit your questions", "3kDlONFDbNI-00355-00106391-00106647": "or comments to our scientists here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00356-00106648-00106895": "or our rov operators or any of other", "3kDlONFDbNI-00357-00106896-00107231": "member of our corps of exploration", "3kDlONFDbNI-00358-00107232-00107343": "the website to do that is", "3kDlONFDbNI-00359-00107344-00107943": "nautiluslive.org", "3kDlONFDbNI-00360-00107944-00108143": "you're seeing what we're seeing in real", "3kDlONFDbNI-00361-00108144-00108231": "time", "3kDlONFDbNI-00362-00108232-00108583": "the first time that this area has", "3kDlONFDbNI-00363-00108583-00112519": "received an rov visitor", "3kDlONFDbNI-00364-00112520-00112727": "we'll do the next move just right on top", "3kDlONFDbNI-00365-00112728-00112999": "of this one yeah yeah i think so this is", "3kDlONFDbNI-00366-00113000-00113351": "sort of a let's make it happen yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00367-00113352-00113510": "just judging by the sonar it seems like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00368-00113511-00113671": "this is going to be a pretty chill spot", "3kDlONFDbNI-00369-00113672-00113775": "for a while", "3kDlONFDbNI-00370-00113776-00114215": "bridge now", "3kDlONFDbNI-00371-00114216-00114943": "can we move 60 meters bearing to 1-0", "3kDlONFDbNI-00372-00114944-00115119": "is that a little sponge there about", "3kDlONFDbNI-00373-00115120-00115439": "where the laser is oh yeah i guess", "3kDlONFDbNI-00374-00115440-00115639": "look doesn't look like it has pigment", "3kDlONFDbNI-00375-00115640-00115854": "but we might want to look at it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00376-00115855-00116023": "yeah chris wants to look at that little", "3kDlONFDbNI-00377-00116024-00116151": "sponge there right there where the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00378-00116152-00116775": "lasers are", "3kDlONFDbNI-00379-00116776-00116958": "we saw a similar one on the last dive", "3kDlONFDbNI-00380-00116959-00117207": "yeah i thought it looked like a skittish", "3kDlONFDbNI-00381-00117208-00117543": "a club from the flintstones maybe yes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00382-00117544-00117790": "oh look at the texture nice one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00383-00117791-00117990": "beautiful", "3kDlONFDbNI-00384-00117991-00118271": "it's like a lava lamp", "3kDlONFDbNI-00385-00118272-00118951": "a lava lamp sponge", "3kDlONFDbNI-00386-00118952-00119319": "can you get in yeah nice one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00387-00119320-00119919": "living in amongst the manganese nodules", "3kDlONFDbNI-00388-00119920-00120239": "that's cool", "3kDlONFDbNI-00389-00120240-00120631": "cinderella specie in the family of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00390-00120632-00120990": "uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00391-00120991-00121351": "pharahnoma today", "3kDlONFDbNI-00392-00121352-00121878": "okay i'm coming away", "3kDlONFDbNI-00393-00121879-00122047": "did you guys get what you needed there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00394-00122048-00122543": "yep yes thank you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00395-00122544-00122751": "so one of our viewers is asking why we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00396-00122752-00123063": "are not seeing fish yet is it too deep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00397-00123064-00123454": "for fish to live in this location", "3kDlONFDbNI-00398-00123455-00123743": "no it's not too deep but", "3kDlONFDbNI-00399-00123744-00124007": "they do like sediment more than rocky", "3kDlONFDbNI-00400-00124008-00124127": "bottoms", "3kDlONFDbNI-00401-00124128-00124334": "i guess more chances to find", "3kDlONFDbNI-00402-00124335-00124683": "invertebrates to feed upon", "3kDlONFDbNI-00403-00124683-00124943": "but be surprised to see some benthic", "3kDlONFDbNI-00404-00124944-00125063": "species", "3kDlONFDbNI-00405-00125064-00125247": "yeah and usually fish they try to move", "3kDlONFDbNI-00406-00125248-00125463": "away when they see the hercules", "3kDlONFDbNI-00407-00125464-00125614": "yeah i think that's part of the issue", "3kDlONFDbNI-00408-00125615-00125758": "the sponges and the corals have a little", "3kDlONFDbNI-00409-00125759-00126214": "bit harder time yes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00410-00126215-00126478": "we are diving at a depth of about 2600", "3kDlONFDbNI-00411-00126479-00126734": "meters there is no light at this depth", "3kDlONFDbNI-00412-00126735-00126910": "except the light that we bring with us", "3kDlONFDbNI-00413-00126911-00127031": "so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00414-00127032-00127302": "that can uh cause some", "3kDlONFDbNI-00415-00127303-00127510": "fish to", "3kDlONFDbNI-00416-00127511-00127831": "hightail it out of here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00417-00127832-00128095": "park also makes some noise that can", "3kDlONFDbNI-00418-00128096-00128271": "send them", "3kDlONFDbNI-00419-00128272-00128558": "moving in another direction", "3kDlONFDbNI-00420-00128559-00128871": "but we'll keep our eyes out and", "3kDlONFDbNI-00421-00128872-00129134": "see if we can spot some", "3kDlONFDbNI-00422-00129135-00129423": "some fish or other creatures", "3kDlONFDbNI-00423-00129424-00129790": "we did see uh a cosqui eel-like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00424-00129791-00130007": "fish the other day that remains to be", "3kDlONFDbNI-00425-00130008-00130510": "identified", "3kDlONFDbNI-00426-00130511-00130678": "dan is that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00427-00130679-00130910": "herc", "3kDlONFDbNI-00428-00130911-00131166": "yeah i guess that hurxona is correct", "3kDlONFDbNI-00429-00131167-00131566": "just seems weird given the multibeam", "3kDlONFDbNI-00430-00131567-00131759": "that we're seeing", "3kDlONFDbNI-00431-00131760-00132095": "the upslope on the port side of herc", "3kDlONFDbNI-00432-00132096-00132351": "doesn't it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00433-00132352-00132502": "does look like that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00434-00132503-00132663": "some a little bit of local", "3kDlONFDbNI-00435-00132664-00132887": "variability in the overall", "3kDlONFDbNI-00436-00132888-00133590": "both saying the same thing yeah totally", "3kDlONFDbNI-00437-00133591-00133887": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00438-00133888-00134054": "so we have a viewer asking about whales", "3kDlONFDbNI-00439-00134055-00134311": "we did see some sperm whales off the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00440-00134312-00134519": "ship earlier today they were on the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00441-00134520-00134839": "surface but they do dive quite deep but", "3kDlONFDbNI-00442-00134840-00134990": "i'm seeing some information here that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00443-00134991-00135190": "they dive about 2000 meters where we're", "3kDlONFDbNI-00444-00135191-00135366": "below that so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00445-00135367-00135551": "that might not be such a likely i'm", "3kDlONFDbNI-00446-00135552-00136031": "sorry", "3kDlONFDbNI-00447-00136032-00136119": "uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00448-00136120-00136295": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00449-00136296-00136566": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00450-00136567-00136727": "you do have to change socks a lot out", "3kDlONFDbNI-00451-00136728-00137078": "here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00452-00137079-00137287": "oh no", "3kDlONFDbNI-00453-00137288-00137551": "not in not in steel toes i couldn't", "3kDlONFDbNI-00454-00137552-00137863": "possibly", "3kDlONFDbNI-00455-00137864-00141063": "oh yeah cracks is a different matter", "3kDlONFDbNI-00456-00141064-00141207": "so we've already collected a couple of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00457-00141208-00141487": "rocks on this dive we do hope to collect", "3kDlONFDbNI-00458-00141488-00141847": "some corals we have a list with some", "3kDlONFDbNI-00459-00141848-00141990": "photos up here of things that the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00460-00141991-00142247": "scientists are most interested in", "3kDlONFDbNI-00461-00142248-00142454": "in collecting if we see something that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00462-00142455-00142775": "is unknown or very interesting", "3kDlONFDbNI-00463-00142776-00143087": "it's definitely um", "3kDlONFDbNI-00464-00143088-00143214": "definitely something that we do hope to", "3kDlONFDbNI-00465-00143215-00143607": "collect okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00466-00143608-00143807": "and possibly some sponges as well we saw", "3kDlONFDbNI-00467-00143808-00143983": "some magnificent sponges on the last", "3kDlONFDbNI-00468-00143984-00144647": "dive", "3kDlONFDbNI-00469-00144648-00144895": "that one of you were referred to as deep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00470-00144896-00145078": "sea space mushrooms which is exactly", "3kDlONFDbNI-00471-00145079-00145639": "what they look like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00472-00145640-00146007": "uh amy is asking a question on the chat", "3kDlONFDbNI-00473-00146008-00146278": "yeah so yesterday we did get a scoop of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00474-00146279-00146911": "nodules and a sediment", "3kDlONFDbNI-00475-00146912-00147159": "in a very similar setting we got a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00476-00147160-00147343": "little bit of waiting to do here we'll", "3kDlONFDbNI-00477-00147344-00147487": "check this guy out", "3kDlONFDbNI-00478-00147488-00147711": "and on the same seamount so we got a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00479-00147712-00148159": "whole scoop", "3kDlONFDbNI-00480-00148160-00148454": "that magnificent sponge we saw four four", "3kDlONFDbNI-00481-00148455-00148614": "or five of them yesterday it looks like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00482-00148615-00148887": "it's a rosella day", "3kDlONFDbNI-00483-00148888-00149031": "call of fakus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00484-00149032-00149223": "uh oh yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00485-00149224-00149407": "scene around the musicians seamounts", "3kDlONFDbNI-00486-00149408-00150143": "let's see where else", "3kDlONFDbNI-00487-00150144-00150351": "so i wonder how many nautical miles we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00488-00150352-00150639": "are from the musician seamounts here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00489-00150640-00150751": "and um", "3kDlONFDbNI-00490-00150752-00151687": "can i get a zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00491-00151688-00151854": "lovely", "3kDlONFDbNI-00492-00151855-00152759": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00493-00152760-00153031": "this is a militarist again because of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00494-00153032-00153190": "those", "3kDlONFDbNI-00495-00153191-00153575": "polyps all lined up", "3kDlONFDbNI-00496-00153576-00153714": "about", "3kDlONFDbNI-00497-00153715-00153990": "565 nautical miles from the musician's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00498-00153991-00154111": "seamounts", "3kDlONFDbNI-00499-00154112-00156895": "okay i'm going to pick up", "3kDlONFDbNI-00500-00156896-00157054": "what", "3kDlONFDbNI-00501-00157055-00157271": "oh my god", "3kDlONFDbNI-00502-00157272-00157535": "i needed a couple squeezes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00503-00157536-00157743": "they've also been seen at american samoa", "3kDlONFDbNI-00504-00157744-00157911": "and cook islands", "3kDlONFDbNI-00505-00157912-00158031": "oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00506-00158032-00159159": "widespread yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00507-00159160-00159407": "it's another one of these", "3kDlONFDbNI-00508-00159408-00159590": "i thought i just saw a tiny fish swim", "3kDlONFDbNI-00509-00159591-00160607": "under us oh a teeny fish", "3kDlONFDbNI-00510-00160608-00160775": "so we want to try to scoop some nodules", "3kDlONFDbNI-00511-00160776-00160943": "when we get a chance i think she was", "3kDlONFDbNI-00512-00160944-00161102": "okay with that because we got some we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00513-00161103-00161271": "got a scoop of them yesterday on the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00514-00161272-00161463": "same seamount", "3kDlONFDbNI-00515-00161464-00161639": "and the sediment so i think what she", "3kDlONFDbNI-00516-00161640-00161839": "wants to do is compare them to the crust", "3kDlONFDbNI-00517-00161840-00161999": "on all the rocks that we've already thus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00518-00162000-00162966": "gathered yeah yeah totally makes sense", "3kDlONFDbNI-00519-00162967-00163271": "what are those little black spots", "3kDlONFDbNI-00520-00163272-00163431": "what little black spot the left side of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00521-00163432-00163695": "the screen maybe it's just a shadow", "3kDlONFDbNI-00522-00163696-00164931": "shadow", "3kDlONFDbNI-00523-00164932-00165990": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00524-00165991-00166078": "zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00525-00166079-00166175": "steve", "3kDlONFDbNI-00526-00166176-00166287": "i think we're gonna get that already", "3kDlONFDbNI-00527-00166288-00166447": "gorgia there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00528-00166448-00166663": "or whatever it is", "3kDlONFDbNI-00529-00166664-00167311": "this one oh yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00530-00167312-00167463": "i don't know what that is maybe i think", "3kDlONFDbNI-00531-00167464-00167623": "it looks like an areta gorgio without a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00532-00167624-00167863": "lot of polyps it's got that spiral to it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00533-00167864-00168207": "young baby yes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00534-00168208-00168431": "sure oh there comes the friend from", "3kDlONFDbNI-00535-00168432-00168575": "above", "3kDlONFDbNI-00536-00168576-00168790": "on this on this feed three or you just", "3kDlONFDbNI-00537-00168791-00168975": "want to see it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00538-00168976-00170023": "already gorgeous yes okay go wide", "3kDlONFDbNI-00539-00170024-00170102": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00540-00170103-00170551": "moving on", "3kDlONFDbNI-00541-00170552-00170759": "gabby i want to keep the ship moving", "3kDlONFDbNI-00542-00170760-00170878": "maybe", "3kDlONFDbNI-00543-00170879-00171238": "bearing 195 so yeah i like a little more", "3kDlONFDbNI-00544-00171239-00171502": "south", "3kDlONFDbNI-00545-00171503-00171895": "bridge", "3kDlONFDbNI-00546-00171896-00172023": "see what you mean though gabby there's a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00547-00172024-00172223": "little disorienting up on the left", "3kDlONFDbNI-00548-00172224-00172447": "meters bearing one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00549-00172448-00172935": "nine five", "3kDlONFDbNI-00550-00172936-00175959": "thanks alex", "3kDlONFDbNI-00551-00175960-00176135": "oh that'll make the folks watching at", "3kDlONFDbNI-00552-00176136-00176319": "home happy they've been wondering if we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00553-00176320-00176926": "could zoom on their head and shoot", "3kDlONFDbNI-00554-00176927-00177735": "but that looks similar to the one we saw", "3kDlONFDbNI-00555-00177736-00177871": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00556-00177872-00178038": "steve feel free to go for a zoom if he", "3kDlONFDbNI-00557-00178039-00178238": "gets in a good spot all right this is a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00558-00178239-00178366": "good one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00559-00178367-00178551": "yeah yeah as long as he's right near the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00560-00178552-00178895": "lake nice", "3kDlONFDbNI-00561-00178896-00179687": "it's cooperating yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00562-00179688-00180631": "hello beautiful", "3kDlONFDbNI-00563-00180632-00180751": "i think the other one they saw on the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00564-00180752-00180951": "other diet was more like a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00565-00180952-00181199": "pink or peach color wasn't it it's a bit", "3kDlONFDbNI-00566-00181200-00181414": "lighter yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00567-00181415-00181495": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00568-00181496-00181871": "are we good go wide", "3kDlONFDbNI-00569-00181872-00182078": "and then get out in front of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00570-00182079-00182399": "argus again here yeah not the same as", "3kDlONFDbNI-00571-00182400-00182607": "the one we saw the other one had those", "3kDlONFDbNI-00572-00182608-00182935": "more defined lateral lines we think", "3kDlONFDbNI-00573-00182936-00183231": "i yeah perhaps right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00574-00183232-00183575": "right to the um left of hercules in the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00575-00183576-00183863": "augers view you see these ripple marks", "3kDlONFDbNI-00576-00183864-00185831": "in the sediments", "3kDlONFDbNI-00577-00185832-00186207": "get away with that close approach there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00578-00186208-00186687": "yeah yeah totally", "3kDlONFDbNI-00579-00186688-00189254": "i'm tracking", "3kDlONFDbNI-00580-00189255-00189414": "sure picked a good place to start the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00581-00189415-00189702": "dive yeah right on", "3kDlONFDbNI-00582-00189703-00190295": "what do we have here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00583-00190296-00190535": "little black coral yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00584-00190536-00190854": "can i get a zoom steve", "3kDlONFDbNI-00585-00190855-00191054": "i think you're right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00586-00191055-00191207": "interesting", "3kDlONFDbNI-00587-00191208-00191407": "interesting bass on this", "3kDlONFDbNI-00588-00191408-00191654": "chris is saying maybe it's a c pen oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00589-00191655-00191847": "yeah yeah let's see", "3kDlONFDbNI-00590-00191848-00192559": "a little more zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00591-00192560-00192919": "his base is quite different", "3kDlONFDbNI-00592-00192920-00193143": "those polyps are huge those palms are", "3kDlONFDbNI-00593-00193144-00193319": "huge", "3kDlONFDbNI-00594-00193320-00194575": "that's beautiful", "3kDlONFDbNI-00595-00194576-00194683": "rock", "3kDlONFDbNI-00596-00194684-00194854": "pen", "3kDlONFDbNI-00597-00194855-00195078": "are we good here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00598-00195079-00195726": "happy yep okay go one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00599-00195727-00196383": "onward", "3kDlONFDbNI-00600-00196384-00196623": "really big bamboo coral in front of us", "3kDlONFDbNI-00601-00196624-00197111": "and the argus view", "3kDlONFDbNI-00602-00197112-00198143": "oh yeah i see that kind of like urgency", "3kDlONFDbNI-00603-00198144-00198535": "cool", "3kDlONFDbNI-00604-00198536-00198711": "oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00605-00198712-00199031": "here's some biodiversity", "3kDlONFDbNI-00606-00199032-00200119": "look at this", "3kDlONFDbNI-00607-00200120-00200278": "this one the one that the lasers are", "3kDlONFDbNI-00608-00200279-00200599": "near", "3kDlONFDbNI-00609-00200600-00200726": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00610-00200727-00201038": "and get to it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00611-00201039-00202790": "i see the base right now", "3kDlONFDbNI-00612-00202791-00202999": "it's a real nice display of the bamboo", "3kDlONFDbNI-00613-00203000-00203150": "characteristics at the base of that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00614-00203151-00204407": "bamboo coral yeah very obvious", "3kDlONFDbNI-00615-00204408-00204799": "maybe porchlight", "3kDlONFDbNI-00616-00204800-00206590": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00617-00206591-00207175": "yeah quite fantastic", "3kDlONFDbNI-00618-00207176-00207671": "i'll see all the way up", "3kDlONFDbNI-00619-00207671-00207886": "and up", "3kDlONFDbNI-00620-00207887-00208142": "geez it just keeps going", "3kDlONFDbNI-00621-00208144-00208231": "wow", "3kDlONFDbNI-00622-00208232-00208382": "nice work", "3kDlONFDbNI-00623-00208383-00208703": "nice work that's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00624-00208704-00208951": "viewers are hilarious doing that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00625-00208952-00209590": "oops", "3kDlONFDbNI-00626-00209591-00210494": "it just kept going that was amazing", "3kDlONFDbNI-00627-00210496-00210887": "tag that highlight for you there dan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00628-00210888-00211023": "thanks", "3kDlONFDbNI-00629-00211023-00211942": "good argus shots well they're cool", "3kDlONFDbNI-00630-00211944-00212094": "i'm going to keep us moving", "3kDlONFDbNI-00631-00212096-00212287": "yes please", "3kDlONFDbNI-00632-00212288-00212806": "bridge snap", "3kDlONFDbNI-00633-00212807-00213303": "50 meters bearing 195 please", "3kDlONFDbNI-00634-00213304-00213503": "this is a very cool", "3kDlONFDbNI-00635-00213504-00213615": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00636-00213616-00213767": "in argus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00637-00213767-00214151": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00638-00214152-00214742": "sheet flows", "3kDlONFDbNI-00639-00214744-00215006": "i'm gonna have to get sort of back", "3kDlONFDbNI-00640-00215007-00215582": "underneath the ship a little bit", "3kDlONFDbNI-00641-00215583-00215846": "what is this so yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00642-00215848-00216110": "eric's heading 205. yeah that makes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00643-00216111-00216423": "sense", "3kDlONFDbNI-00644-00216423-00216951": "get up onto the ridge", "3kDlONFDbNI-00645-00216952-00217151": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00646-00217152-00217327": "i just want to make sure that i keep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00647-00217328-00218310": "myself in a reasonable place here yep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00648-00218311-00218719": "so where's the current step to uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00649-00218719-00219287": "um the last step made was burying 195", "3kDlONFDbNI-00650-00219288-00221894": "50 meters", "3kDlONFDbNI-00651-00221896-00222087": "what's this little guy here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00652-00222088-00222246": "yeah that looks like it's fractured", "3kDlONFDbNI-00653-00222248-00222398": "there looks like maybe that boulder", "3kDlONFDbNI-00654-00222400-00222567": "right next to it fell on top of it or", "3kDlONFDbNI-00655-00222567-00222703": "something", "3kDlONFDbNI-00656-00222704-00223119": "something impacted that after the fact", "3kDlONFDbNI-00657-00223119-00223342": "you see a little bit of biology in there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00658-00223344-00223519": "yeah yeah there's something down there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00659-00223519-00223751": "oh maybe a little right below the shot", "3kDlONFDbNI-00660-00223752-00224079": "yeah right below the laser yeah yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00661-00224080-00224446": "can i get a zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00662-00224448-00224831": "that's like one we saw yesterday", "3kDlONFDbNI-00663-00224832-00225342": "oh yeah it's just a baby dr seuss sponge", "3kDlONFDbNI-00664-00225344-00225482": "just a wee", "3kDlONFDbNI-00665-00225483-00227342": "one okay go ahead", "3kDlONFDbNI-00666-00227344-00227494": "there's some corals attached to the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00667-00227496-00227598": "other side of that rock because we're", "3kDlONFDbNI-00668-00227600-00227767": "swinging around they're coming in can we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00669-00227767-00227927": "uh take another look at that sponge from", "3kDlONFDbNI-00670-00227928-00228110": "this angle yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00671-00228111-00228287": "a little zoomish", "3kDlONFDbNI-00672-00228288-00229519": "totally", "3kDlONFDbNI-00673-00229519-00229758": "yep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00674-00229759-00230046": "okay go for the zoom", "3kDlONFDbNI-00675-00230048-00230791": "that's not a full one one sec", "3kDlONFDbNI-00676-00230792-00232294": "yeah there we go", "3kDlONFDbNI-00677-00232296-00232391": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00678-00232392-00232775": "i can break with tradition here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00679-00232776-00233063": "no it doesn't work that well okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00680-00233064-00233342": "go for it i just hit the tilt which i", "3kDlONFDbNI-00681-00233344-00233480": "haven't done yet", "3kDlONFDbNI-00682-00233481-00233719": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00683-00233719-00234039": "all right just a tiny", "3kDlONFDbNI-00684-00234040-00234127": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00685-00234128-00234334": "it's a califace", "3kDlONFDbNI-00686-00234335-00234494": "in the family", "3kDlONFDbNI-00687-00234496-00234591": "rosa", "3kDlONFDbNI-00688-00234592-00234798": "rosalie day which was the ones that we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00689-00234800-00235055": "saw which is a relative of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00690-00235056-00235282": "the dr zeus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00691-00235283-00235542": "bunch right different species yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00692-00235544-00235703": "different species than yesterday but i", "3kDlONFDbNI-00693-00235704-00235982": "think we did see one similar to this", "3kDlONFDbNI-00694-00235983-00236175": "at one point in our day sometimes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00695-00236176-00236358": "seems like i can just step back a little", "3kDlONFDbNI-00696-00236359-00236463": "bit or forward a little bit and", "3kDlONFDbNI-00697-00236464-00236606": "sometimes that brings it right to where", "3kDlONFDbNI-00698-00236607-00237367": "it needs to be okay go wide", "3kDlONFDbNI-00699-00237367-00237646": "right the pan yeah i think i've kind of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00700-00237648-00237806": "don't need the pan as long as i don't", "3kDlONFDbNI-00701-00237807-00237975": "have auto head on which is awesome i", "3kDlONFDbNI-00702-00237976-00238239": "like that trix trick a lot", "3kDlONFDbNI-00703-00238240-00238423": "uh do you guys want to look at any of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00704-00238423-00238687": "these corals here or i'd like to keep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00705-00238688-00238967": "moving ahead", "3kDlONFDbNI-00706-00238967-00239206": "great", "3kDlONFDbNI-00707-00239207-00239367": "i mean i would like to take a look at", "3kDlONFDbNI-00708-00239367-00239671": "every single coral right here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00709-00239671-00239967": "but", "3kDlONFDbNI-00710-00239967-00240446": "the shallows call", "3kDlONFDbNI-00711-00240448-00240630": "you're turning in on nautiluslive.org", "3kDlONFDbNI-00712-00240631-00240767": "we've got our", "3kDlONFDbNI-00713-00240767-00240975": "channel one nice one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00714-00240976-00241191": "which is the view from hercules and", "3kDlONFDbNI-00715-00241192-00241479": "channel two is the view of hercules from", "3kDlONFDbNI-00716-00241480-00241598": "argus", "3kDlONFDbNI-00717-00241600-00241734": "getting there i think it's a great first", "3kDlONFDbNI-00718-00241735-00241951": "step", "3kDlONFDbNI-00719-00241952-00242094": "and then channels three and four are", "3kDlONFDbNI-00720-00242096-00242703": "kind of dealer's choice", "3kDlONFDbNI-00721-00242704-00243006": "screen bumps what does that mean", "3kDlONFDbNI-00722-00243007-00243351": "oh yeah yeah with a yes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00723-00243352-00243710": "i am tracking", "3kDlONFDbNI-00724-00243711-00244487": "yes those are good", "3kDlONFDbNI-00725-00244488-00244919": "yeah that's pretty good", "3kDlONFDbNI-00726-00244919-00245103": "so if you hear us talking about that one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00727-00245104-00245303": "or channel one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00728-00245304-00245623": "that's something on the heart cam", "3kDlONFDbNI-00729-00245623-00245815": "i am talking on spl so it sounds like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00730-00245816-00246151": "i'm talking to myself dan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00731-00246152-00246471": "[Laughter]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00732-00246471-00246703": "sorry", "3kDlONFDbNI-00733-00246704-00246855": "there you go", "3kDlONFDbNI-00734-00246856-00247567": "welcome", "3kDlONFDbNI-00735-00247567-00248230": "i mean believe what you want it's fine", "3kDlONFDbNI-00736-00248231-00248446": "so stephen our video engineer decides", "3kDlONFDbNI-00737-00248448-00248694": "which uh i'm listening to put on three", "3kDlONFDbNI-00738-00248696-00248871": "and four yeah no that makes perfect", "3kDlONFDbNI-00739-00248871-00249119": "sense that's totally fine i just became", "3kDlONFDbNI-00740-00249119-00249375": "aware of it for the first time that i", "3kDlONFDbNI-00741-00249376-00249671": "was talking to no one no we were here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00742-00249671-00249839": "with you we were here with you buddy oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00743-00249840-00250191": "thanks thanks guys", "3kDlONFDbNI-00744-00250192-00250382": "and the viewers at home are hearing you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00745-00250383-00250455": "too", "3kDlONFDbNI-00746-00250456-00251063": "wondering why you're talking to yourself", "3kDlONFDbNI-00747-00251064-00251271": "i find if i don't leave it on spl all", "3kDlONFDbNI-00748-00251271-00251479": "the time if i make it so i have to press", "3kDlONFDbNI-00749-00251480-00251646": "the button up here i don't have to put", "3kDlONFDbNI-00750-00251648-00252775": "as many dollar bills in the cookie chart", "3kDlONFDbNI-00751-00252776-00252958": "and keep us moving", "3kDlONFDbNI-00752-00252959-00253087": "yeah do it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00753-00253088-00253503": "it's going great bridge nav", "3kDlONFDbNI-00754-00253504-00253671": "we have a tentative id on that fish can", "3kDlONFDbNI-00755-00253671-00253871": "we move 50 meters oh yeah bearing what's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00756-00253871-00254127": "happening", "3kDlONFDbNI-00757-00254128-00254527": "uh so the science chat is uh alex", "3kDlONFDbNI-00758-00254528-00254742": "coming up with a tentative id on that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00759-00254744-00255198": "fish of faso vasozitas elongatis", "3kDlONFDbNI-00760-00255200-00255375": "which is a different uh very different", "3kDlONFDbNI-00761-00255376-00255527": "than the one that was seen a couple of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00762-00255528-00255734": "days ago by the other watch so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00763-00255735-00255903": "this one does seem to have an id the one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00764-00255904-00256094": "that we saw", "3kDlONFDbNI-00765-00256096-00256439": "that's coming in as a tentative id uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00766-00256440-00256598": "that's a fish that is usually found", "3kDlONFDbNI-00767-00256600-00256727": "between two thousand and five thousand", "3kDlONFDbNI-00768-00256728-00256942": "meters deep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00769-00256944-00257110": "which makes sense because we are about", "3kDlONFDbNI-00770-00257111-00257423": "two thousand five hundred meters deep so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00771-00257423-00257663": "thanks uh thanks science chat for", "3kDlONFDbNI-00772-00257664-00259934": "sending that in", "3kDlONFDbNI-00773-00259935-00260094": "our science chat is a way for scientists", "3kDlONFDbNI-00774-00260096-00260303": "on shore who were not able to join us", "3kDlONFDbNI-00775-00260304-00260482": "for this mission to add their", "3kDlONFDbNI-00776-00260483-00260782": "expertise and allow us to share with you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00777-00260783-00261127": "in real time", "3kDlONFDbNI-00778-00261128-00261798": "it's like an international lab", "3kDlONFDbNI-00779-00261800-00261982": "we also have viewers joining us from all", "3kDlONFDbNI-00780-00261983-00262127": "around the world thanks so much for", "3kDlONFDbNI-00781-00262128-00262327": "tuning in if you have a question or a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00782-00262328-00262558": "comment you can enter it on our website", "3kDlONFDbNI-00783-00262559-00262782": "alicelife.org", "3kDlONFDbNI-00784-00262783-00263055": "we are continuing to explore for", "3kDlONFDbNI-00785-00263056-00263295": "coral sponges", "3kDlONFDbNI-00786-00263296-00263567": "interesting looking rocks", "3kDlONFDbNI-00787-00263568-00263815": "and how many viewers do we currently", "3kDlONFDbNI-00788-00263816-00263999": "have on that channel yeah so we have", "3kDlONFDbNI-00789-00264000-00264247": "over 100 viewers right now from uh from", "3kDlONFDbNI-00790-00264248-00264551": "around the world", "3kDlONFDbNI-00791-00264552-00264815": "yeah those are our land-based explorers", "3kDlONFDbNI-00792-00264816-00265358": "absolutely", "3kDlONFDbNI-00793-00265359-00265703": "andrea what do you think of those rocks", "3kDlONFDbNI-00794-00265704-00265863": "yeah those are okay you could see where", "3kDlONFDbNI-00795-00265864-00266134": "that slab just broke into there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00796-00266135-00266375": "so it came from up slope somewhere slid", "3kDlONFDbNI-00797-00266376-00266606": "down there and broken too", "3kDlONFDbNI-00798-00266607-00266847": "i think we um at some point might want", "3kDlONFDbNI-00799-00266848-00267055": "to get a rock for beth again we know", "3kDlONFDbNI-00800-00267056-00267230": "what we're looking for an altered", "3kDlONFDbNI-00801-00267231-00267487": "smaller softer rock", "3kDlONFDbNI-00802-00267488-00267782": "the manganese crust so if anybody sees", "3kDlONFDbNI-00803-00267783-00267910": "anything that's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00804-00267911-00269567": "easy to harvest and looks like that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00805-00269568-00269806": "so my wife is tuned into this uh dive", "3kDlONFDbNI-00806-00269807-00270039": "but uh it's an example of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00807-00270040-00270247": "citizen science that is possible with", "3kDlONFDbNI-00808-00270248-00270406": "the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00809-00270407-00270591": "nautilus live streaming i think we were", "3kDlONFDbNI-00810-00270592-00270799": "in galapagos and she helped identify", "3kDlONFDbNI-00811-00270800-00271055": "urela canthus this looks like an anemone", "3kDlONFDbNI-00812-00271056-00271303": "but much longer tentacles", "3kDlONFDbNI-00813-00271304-00271534": "recently classified species what's that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00814-00271535-00271719": "what's that purple thing is that it's a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00815-00271720-00272110": "cucumber", "3kDlONFDbNI-00816-00272111-00272399": "a pretty sea cucumber", "3kDlONFDbNI-00817-00272400-00272671": "another bamboo yeah that fan is that a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00818-00272672-00272887": "branching bamboo is that maybe uh oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00819-00272888-00273151": "there's turtles up there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00820-00273152-00273334": "look at this forest", "3kDlONFDbNI-00821-00273335-00273710": "a little already gorgia all right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00822-00273711-00274527": "and here's a little forest", "3kDlONFDbNI-00823-00274528-00274799": "oh that i saw that branch in bamboo yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00824-00274800-00274982": "you see you see that i know that's a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00825-00274983-00275175": "target it had three", "3kDlONFDbNI-00826-00275176-00275399": "yeah it looked much smaller than the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00827-00275400-00275710": "last one yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00828-00275711-00276396": "they wanted us it's underneath us now", "3kDlONFDbNI-00829-00276397-00276567": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00830-00276568-00276775": "uh we'll need to make a decision about", "3kDlONFDbNI-00831-00276776-00277087": "it pretty quick okay okay there it is", "3kDlONFDbNI-00832-00277088-00277271": "there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00833-00277272-00277495": "oh there it is it has a little shrimp on", "3kDlONFDbNI-00834-00277496-00277639": "it or something yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00835-00277640-00277823": "so let's see if chris thinks that's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00836-00277824-00278447": "something we want to sample", "3kDlONFDbNI-00837-00278448-00278695": "chris says it's not a bamboo not a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00838-00278696-00278903": "bamboo all clear", "3kDlONFDbNI-00839-00278904-00279182": "okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00840-00279183-00279399": "false alarm friends worth it worth", "3kDlONFDbNI-00841-00279400-00279623": "looking into", "3kDlONFDbNI-00842-00279624-00280430": "good eyes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00843-00280431-00280679": "great view on the argus camp", "3kDlONFDbNI-00844-00280680-00280815": "yeah you're really you're really", "3kDlONFDbNI-00845-00280816-00281182": "spoiling us today there dan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00846-00281183-00281430": "i've got to get out of here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00847-00281431-00281615": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00848-00281616-00281815": "sometimes i think you like making me", "3kDlONFDbNI-00849-00281816-00282334": "nervous", "3kDlONFDbNI-00850-00282335-00282582": "uh-huh okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00851-00282583-00283119": "that's great", "3kDlONFDbNI-00852-00283120-00283263": "i have a viewer checking in all the way", "3kDlONFDbNI-00853-00283264-00283471": "from new zealand i'm sure they uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00854-00283472-00283599": "probably win the prize for being", "3kDlONFDbNI-00855-00283600-00283758": "farthest from uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00856-00283759-00284279": "area right now", "3kDlONFDbNI-00857-00284280-00284710": "welcome", "3kDlONFDbNI-00858-00284711-00284863": "although some of our european friends", "3kDlONFDbNI-00859-00284864-00285143": "are i think yeah 10 hours 10 hours utc", "3kDlONFDbNI-00860-00285144-00285375": "different so", "3kDlONFDbNI-00861-00285376-00285510": "wherever you're joining us from thank", "3kDlONFDbNI-00862-00285511-00288687": "you so much for being here with us live", "3kDlONFDbNI-00863-00288688-00288871": "one thing for sure the communities that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00864-00288872-00289087": "we've seen so far today", "3kDlONFDbNI-00865-00289088-00289287": "have been um largely associated with", "3kDlONFDbNI-00866-00289288-00289447": "large rocks", "3kDlONFDbNI-00867-00289448-00289679": "i had that bridge is making a heading", "3kDlONFDbNI-00868-00289680-00289882": "change", "3kDlONFDbNI-00869-00289883-00289999": "okay little things", "3kDlONFDbNI-00870-00290000-00290127": "small i don't think it's going to bother", "3kDlONFDbNI-00871-00290128-00290791": "us", "3kDlONFDbNI-00872-00290792-00290943": "and a lot more diverse than anything", "3kDlONFDbNI-00873-00290944-00291151": "we've seen so far as well you know", "3kDlONFDbNI-00874-00291152-00291391": "tightly tightly associated diverse", "3kDlONFDbNI-00875-00291392-00294230": "species all right great", "3kDlONFDbNI-00876-00294231-00294495": "any of those rocks there look good for", "3kDlONFDbNI-00877-00294496-00294934": "beth there at the base of that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00878-00294935-00295079": "yeah those i don't know if they're easy", "3kDlONFDbNI-00879-00295080-00295263": "to get to though but those might be good", "3kDlONFDbNI-00880-00295264-00295479": "targets for best rocks okay getting", "3kDlONFDbNI-00881-00295480-00296206": "right in there", "3kDlONFDbNI-00882-00296207-00296495": "what do you think dan", "3kDlONFDbNI-00883-00296496-00296639": "these rocks here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00884-00296640-00296934": "right in front of us", "3kDlONFDbNI-00885-00296935-00297103": "and uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00886-00297104-00297271": "remember we want to get a new skin", "3kDlONFDbNI-00887-00297272-00297487": "sample whenever we get one of beth's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00888-00297488-00297823": "best samples okay", "3kDlONFDbNI-00889-00297824-00298071": "any particular rock that round one right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00890-00298072-00298575": "in front of you all right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00891-00298576-00298967": "yep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00892-00298968-00299215": "she likes the more breakable types yes", "3kDlONFDbNI-00893-00299216-00299334": "it does", "3kDlONFDbNI-00894-00299335-00299543": "but we don't have full beans on this", "3kDlONFDbNI-00895-00299544-00299671": "right it's not the same pounds of", "3kDlONFDbNI-00896-00299672-00299903": "pressure i do have full beans but i can", "3kDlONFDbNI-00897-00299904-00300167": "try and break it if you want", "3kDlONFDbNI-00898-00300168-00300630": "tap tap tap", "3kDlONFDbNI-00899-00300631-00300847": "there's a nice view of dan manipulating", "3kDlONFDbNI-00900-00300848-00300962": "the manipulator", "3kDlONFDbNI-00901-00300963-00301399": "[Laughter]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00902-00301400-00301551": "well it's nice to know that if we see", "3kDlONFDbNI-00903-00301552-00301758": "something uh scary you can throw a rock", "3kDlONFDbNI-00904-00301759-00301975": "at it looks pretty hard yeah it looks", "3kDlONFDbNI-00905-00301976-00302151": "pretty hard i don't think it's soft", "3kDlONFDbNI-00906-00302152-00302358": "enough bummer i don't think i did any", "3kDlONFDbNI-00907-00302359-00302463": "damage", "3kDlONFDbNI-00908-00302464-00302687": "well um let's put him into the box that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00909-00302688-00302847": "we already have partially full because", "3kDlONFDbNI-00910-00302848-00303047": "he's small and he's hard so he might be", "3kDlONFDbNI-00911-00303048-00303423": "crystalline yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00912-00303424-00304047": "probably don't need a niskan right nope", "3kDlONFDbNI-00913-00304048-00304127": "no", "3kDlONFDbNI-00914-00304128-00304782": "it's just a rock", "3kDlONFDbNI-00915-00304783-00305023": "so that's going in the same one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00916-00305024-00305415": "we already got two in yep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00917-00305416-00305775": "same box right same box", "3kDlONFDbNI-00918-00305776-00306095": "using these boxes efficiently today", "3kDlONFDbNI-00919-00306096-00306375": "that's right all right we still got room", "3kDlONFDbNI-00920-00306376-00306495": "throw a couple more in there the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00921-00306496-00306960": "tectonic talkers are taking it away", "3kDlONFDbNI-00922-00306961-00307582": "[Laughter]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00923-00307583-00307719": "if you find anything that crumbles", "3kDlONFDbNI-00924-00307720-00307951": "that's what she wants", "3kDlONFDbNI-00925-00307952-00308287": "not crumbly", "3kDlONFDbNI-00926-00308288-00308519": "nope does not appear to be crumbly what", "3kDlONFDbNI-00927-00308520-00308734": "about that round one uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00928-00308735-00308919": "right on that sediment", "3kDlONFDbNI-00929-00308920-00309134": "line a roundy one yeah the roundy one", "3kDlONFDbNI-00930-00309135-00310134": "let's try him yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00931-00310135-00310647": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00932-00310648-00311023": "darn it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00933-00311024-00311143": "are going to come by and be like there's", "3kDlONFDbNI-00934-00311144-00311319": "a cairn here i don't understand all", "3kDlONFDbNI-00935-00311320-00311430": "right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00936-00311431-00311687": "can failure okay well we at least we", "3kDlONFDbNI-00937-00311688-00311863": "look we'll keep looking for some softer", "3kDlONFDbNI-00938-00311864-00312167": "ones for her is that it or more poking i", "3kDlONFDbNI-00939-00312168-00312343": "think we're good yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00940-00312344-00312519": "go live video", "3kDlONFDbNI-00941-00312520-00312663": "or what", "3kDlONFDbNI-00942-00312664-00312910": "or what oh you were there great okay i'm", "3kDlONFDbNI-00943-00312911-00313110": "gonna skid out all you flew us to the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00944-00313111-00313327": "perfect spot i'll let you get in front a", "3kDlONFDbNI-00945-00313328-00313543": "little more and then call in the move", "3kDlONFDbNI-00946-00313544-00313799": "uh you can do it right now righty we'll", "3kDlONFDbNI-00947-00313800-00314023": "do it's gonna strafe the gauges too", "3kDlONFDbNI-00948-00314024-00314167": "while we're yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00949-00314168-00314287": "do it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00950-00314288-00314767": "bridge now", "3kDlONFDbNI-00951-00314768-00315623": "we move 50 meters bearing one nine", "3kDlONFDbNI-00952-00315624-00317415": "thank you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00953-00317416-00317582": "so that viewer number was just the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00954-00317583-00317727": "number of viewing on the novice live", "3kDlONFDbNI-00955-00317728-00317879": "website we also have quite a few joining", "3kDlONFDbNI-00956-00317880-00318215": "us on youtube uh youtube is uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00957-00318216-00318399": "also hosting the videos channels", "3kDlONFDbNI-00958-00318400-00318710": "separately or you can view the quad", "3kDlONFDbNI-00959-00318711-00318847": "that's how i watch at home because i", "3kDlONFDbNI-00960-00318848-00319039": "could stream it on the tv absolutely", "3kDlONFDbNI-00961-00319040-00319151": "absolutely that's what one of our", "3kDlONFDbNI-00962-00319152-00319327": "viewers just said", "3kDlONFDbNI-00963-00319328-00319503": "oh so we're getting all kinds of viewers", "3kDlONFDbNI-00964-00319504-00319767": "oh yeah we got we got folks uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00965-00319768-00320015": "tuning in to see what we find", "3kDlONFDbNI-00966-00320016-00320191": "emil are you a do you", "3kDlONFDbNI-00967-00320192-00320358": "stream channel one or do you go for the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00968-00320359-00320463": "quad", "3kDlONFDbNI-00969-00320464-00320687": "[Laughter]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00970-00320688-00321071": "i'm a channel one guys asking for and", "3kDlONFDbNI-00971-00321072-00321242": "asking for a friend", "3kDlONFDbNI-00972-00321243-00321472": "[Laughter]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00973-00321473-00321799": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00974-00321800-00321852": "ooh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00975-00321853-00322095": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-00976-00322096-00322247": "another channel chandler", "3kDlONFDbNI-00977-00322248-00322382": "nodules", "3kDlONFDbNI-00978-00322383-00322551": "and then quite a large coral there right", "3kDlONFDbNI-00979-00322552-00322687": "above it yep", "3kDlONFDbNI-00980-00322688-00323006": "coral right above it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00981-00323007-00323215": "with its fractal patterns that we like", "3kDlONFDbNI-00982-00323216-00323303": "yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-00983-00323304-00324167": "do love those fractal patterns", "3kDlONFDbNI-00984-00324168-00324310": "oh it's a nice", "3kDlONFDbNI-00985-00324311-00324519": "holiday cracking a rock on the other", "3kDlONFDbNI-00986-00324520-00324647": "side there too", "3kDlONFDbNI-00987-00324648-00324895": "precious oh yeah if you had three tvs", "3kDlONFDbNI-00988-00324896-00325167": "you could stream all all at once", "3kDlONFDbNI-00989-00325168-00325406": "me don't see the", "3kDlONFDbNI-00990-00325407-00325671": "yeah i do", "3kDlONFDbNI-00991-00325672-00325863": "can i get a quick zoom here", "3kDlONFDbNI-00992-00325864-00326079": "zoom in", "3kDlONFDbNI-00993-00326080-00326615": "oh look at that", "3kDlONFDbNI-00994-00326616-00327087": "yeah it looks like a little shrimpy", "3kDlONFDbNI-00995-00327088-00327534": "oh nice", "3kDlONFDbNI-00996-00327535-00327751": "are all the polyps withdrawn or is it", "3kDlONFDbNI-00997-00327752-00327967": "dead", "3kDlONFDbNI-00998-00327968-00328127": "uh", "3kDlONFDbNI-00999-00328128-00328271": "or is it a different type of coral than", "3kDlONFDbNI-01000-00328272-00328454": "what i'm thinking of i think they look", "3kDlONFDbNI-01001-00328455-00328719": "like they're closed but i'm not sure", "3kDlONFDbNI-01002-00328720-00328887": "i assumed they were closed until you", "3kDlONFDbNI-01003-00328888-00328999": "asked", "3kDlONFDbNI-01004-00329000-00329199": "okay go wide we're gonna go see the", "3kDlONFDbNI-01005-00329200-00329358": "feature on the other side", "3kDlONFDbNI-01006-00329359-00329719": "oh polyps are retracted okay hemi", "3kDlONFDbNI-01007-00329720-00330758": "oralium", "3kDlONFDbNI-01008-00330759-00331134": "nice little feature there", "3kDlONFDbNI-01009-00331135-00331463": "so geological", "3kDlONFDbNI-01010-00331464-00331815": "is so tectonic yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-01011-00331816-00332132": "it's got to be", "3kDlONFDbNI-01012-00332133-00332399": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-01013-00332400-00332599": "flying through features like this is so", "3kDlONFDbNI-01014-00332600-00332719": "fun", "3kDlONFDbNI-01015-00332720-00332934": "it's all like stuff in the sediment", "3kDlONFDbNI-01016-00332935-00333175": "some sponges in the uh cracker it'll be", "3kDlONFDbNI-01017-00333176-00333454": "there oh yeah corals i'm not sure which", "3kDlONFDbNI-01018-00333455-00333647": "some on the left there's another crack", "3kDlONFDbNI-01019-00333648-00333878": "on the left too oh my gosh but what", "3kDlONFDbNI-01020-00333879-00334143": "about this one", "3kDlONFDbNI-01021-00334144-00337023": "what about this one", "3kDlONFDbNI-01022-00337024-00337223": "oh and there's another one back there", "3kDlONFDbNI-01023-00337224-00337415": "please", "3kDlONFDbNI-01024-00337416-00338263": "i don't know how long that will last but", "3kDlONFDbNI-01025-00338264-00338415": "potentially another", "3kDlONFDbNI-01026-00338416-00338639": "civil gorgia", "3kDlONFDbNI-01027-00338640-00338815": "and i think the last time we saw them we", "3kDlONFDbNI-01028-00338816-00340078": "commented on how", "3kDlONFDbNI-01029-00340079-00340415": "more to your left them", "3kDlONFDbNI-01030-00340416-00340606": "yeah oh wow what are those little yellow", "3kDlONFDbNI-01031-00340607-00340854": "things are those sponges are they if", "3kDlONFDbNI-01032-00340855-00341047": "they're yellow sponges", "3kDlONFDbNI-01033-00341048-00341351": "uh chris is all about them okay chris", "3kDlONFDbNI-01034-00341352-00341487": "what do you want to do is these little", "3kDlONFDbNI-01035-00341488-00341863": "yellow things let's see what they are", "3kDlONFDbNI-01036-00341864-00342071": "attempt identification", "3kDlONFDbNI-01037-00342072-00342551": "okay let's get a zoom on yellow things", "3kDlONFDbNI-01038-00342552-00342734": "just assuming it'll be good enough just", "3kDlONFDbNI-01039-00342735-00342975": "zoom uh slurp some of those off the rock", "3kDlONFDbNI-01040-00342976-00343078": "if you want", "3kDlONFDbNI-01041-00343079-00343303": "uh he does he says they're too small to", "3kDlONFDbNI-01042-00343304-00343415": "sample", "3kDlONFDbNI-01043-00343416-00343687": "uh we can uh get them with the", "3kDlONFDbNI-01044-00343688-00343999": "we can get them with the slurp gun", "3kDlONFDbNI-01045-00344000-00344215": "uh barnacles barnacles oh they're", "3kDlONFDbNI-01046-00344216-00344687": "barnacles okay there's also this guy", "3kDlONFDbNI-01047-00344688-00345006": "off to the side here", "3kDlONFDbNI-01048-00345007-00345158": "there that guy", "3kDlONFDbNI-01049-00345159-00345303": "that looks like a pile of something", "3kDlONFDbNI-01050-00345304-00345543": "barnacle shells", "3kDlONFDbNI-01051-00345544-00345751": "falling sponges", "3kDlONFDbNI-01052-00345752-00345887": "i'm gonna look at the bucket cam for a", "3kDlONFDbNI-01053-00345888-00346247": "minute okay somebody had a picnic", "3kDlONFDbNI-01054-00346248-00346399": "okay but those ones in the back are", "3kDlONFDbNI-01055-00346400-00346575": "alert much larger", "3kDlONFDbNI-01056-00346576-00346799": "that's all right there", "3kDlONFDbNI-01057-00346800-00346967": "there's one's lying in the pocket", "3kDlONFDbNI-01058-00346968-00347206": "there's just a lot happening here oh", "3kDlONFDbNI-01059-00347207-00347406": "look at this look at this this is", "3kDlONFDbNI-01060-00347407-00347599": "amazing there you go", "3kDlONFDbNI-01061-00347600-00347854": "there we go", "3kDlONFDbNI-01062-00347855-00348030": "you want to stop you wanted some", "3kDlONFDbNI-01063-00348031-00348199": "fractals", "3kDlONFDbNI-01064-00348200-00348382": "there you go", "3kDlONFDbNI-01065-00348383-00348647": "love me some fractals me too and more", "3kDlONFDbNI-01066-00348648-00349391": "beyond that wow", "3kDlONFDbNI-01067-00349392-00349534": "the big ones", "3kDlONFDbNI-01068-00349535-00349743": "yeah those are some big ones i think i'm", "3kDlONFDbNI-01069-00349744-00349927": "just going to scoot sideways down this i", "3kDlONFDbNI-01070-00349928-00350078": "think we have okay of all these", "3kDlONFDbNI-01071-00350079-00350430": "different types", "3kDlONFDbNI-01072-00350431-00350710": "maybe it'll look cool to see", "3kDlONFDbNI-01073-00350711-00351278": "them all together", "3kDlONFDbNI-01074-00351279-00351934": "size of this colony suggests paragorgit", "3kDlONFDbNI-01075-00351935-00352223": "oh wow", "3kDlONFDbNI-01076-00352224-00352406": "another big precious coral they have my", "3kDlONFDbNI-01077-00352407-00352623": "corellium", "3kDlONFDbNI-01078-00352624-00352847": "what's on that precious coral that oh is", "3kDlONFDbNI-01079-00352848-00353087": "that just part of it that's dead i think", "3kDlONFDbNI-01080-00353088-00353223": "it might have been", "3kDlONFDbNI-01081-00353224-00354158": "dated", "3kDlONFDbNI-01082-00354159-00354334": "and all kinds of smaller guys on the", "3kDlONFDbNI-01083-00354335-00354695": "underside there", "3kDlONFDbNI-01084-00354696-00354839": "yeah they're liking the current flow", "3kDlONFDbNI-01085-00354840-00354888": "here", "3kDlONFDbNI-01086-00354889-00355439": "[Music]", "3kDlONFDbNI-01087-00355440-00355663": "these little small guys yep yep and now", "3kDlONFDbNI-01088-00355664-00355951": "you see all those barnacle shells", "3kDlONFDbNI-01089-00355952-00357063": "that are making up the sediment", "3kDlONFDbNI-01090-00357064-00357303": "and they might be those shells might be", "3kDlONFDbNI-01091-00357304-00357415": "um", "3kDlONFDbNI-01092-00357416-00357734": "creating the nucleation sites for the", "3kDlONFDbNI-01093-00357735-00358439": "manganese nodule precipitates yeah", "3kDlONFDbNI-01094-00358440-00358775": "there's a sponge oh the beautiful sponge", "3kDlONFDbNI-01095-00358776-00359063": "oh that yep i see him", "3kDlONFDbNI-01096-00359064-00359151": "dan", "3kDlONFDbNI-01097-00359152-00359391": "what do you think about see all the ones", "3kDlONFDbNI-01098-00359392-00359599": "behind your chair right as well", "3kDlONFDbNI-01099-00359600-00359823": "uh yes i do there's some big ones back", "3kDlONFDbNI-01100-00359824-00359934": "there what do you think about while i'm", "3kDlONFDbNI-01101-00359935-00360272": "looking at these taking out a wrap"}}]