[{"audio_id": "5040v1wwYmc", "text": {"5040v1wwYmc-00000-00000033-00000327": "[Music]", "5040v1wwYmc-00001-00000328-00000599": "in theory there are only four styles of", "5040v1wwYmc-00002-00000600-00000754": "parenting", "5040v1wwYmc-00003-00000755-00001007": "authoritarian parents are controlling", "5040v1wwYmc-00004-00001008-00001278": "and demand obedience without considering", "5040v1wwYmc-00005-00001279-00001487": "the child's point of view", "5040v1wwYmc-00006-00001488-00001734": "permissive parents are loving but don't", "5040v1wwYmc-00007-00001735-00001926": "exert any control", "5040v1wwYmc-00008-00001927-00002134": "there are no rules", "5040v1wwYmc-00009-00002135-00002383": "authoritative parents are firm but", "5040v1wwYmc-00010-00002384-00002663": "loving they encourage independence", "5040v1wwYmc-00011-00002664-00002847": "within limits", "5040v1wwYmc-00012-00002848-00003110": "neglecting parents are uninvolved and", "5040v1wwYmc-00013-00003111-00003447": "often uninterested in their own child", "5040v1wwYmc-00014-00003447-00003719": "recently a fifth style was proposed but", "5040v1wwYmc-00015-00003720-00004086": "we will come back to that later", "5040v1wwYmc-00016-00004087-00004327": "the styles range from controlling and", "5040v1wwYmc-00017-00004328-00004606": "demanding to complete freedom and from", "5040v1wwYmc-00018-00004607-00004879": "cold and unresponsive to loving and", "5040v1wwYmc-00019-00004880-00005015": "receptive", "5040v1wwYmc-00020-00005016-00005286": "each authoritative permissive", "5040v1wwYmc-00021-00005287-00005591": "authoritarian and neglectful parents", "5040v1wwYmc-00022-00005592-00005863": "have their place to understand what it", "5040v1wwYmc-00023-00005864-00006095": "means to grow up with parents from each", "5040v1wwYmc-00024-00006096-00006334": "end of the spectrum we can imagine the", "5040v1wwYmc-00025-00006335-00006570": "lives of four children", "5040v1wwYmc-00026-00006570-00006727": "[Music]", "5040v1wwYmc-00027-00006728-00007046": "sarah's parents are authoritarian they", "5040v1wwYmc-00028-00007047-00007263": "love their girl but they believe that", "5040v1wwYmc-00029-00007264-00007534": "strict rules are important to make sarah", "5040v1wwYmc-00030-00007536-00007887": "become well-behaved and fit into society", "5040v1wwYmc-00031-00007888-00008223": "if sarah cries she's told to stop if she", "5040v1wwYmc-00032-00008224-00008495": "talks back she is sent to the corner for", "5040v1wwYmc-00033-00008496-00008791": "time out if she forgets to take care of", "5040v1wwYmc-00034-00008792-00009055": "her chores around the house she is not", "5040v1wwYmc-00035-00009056-00009478": "allowed to play with her toys", "5040v1wwYmc-00036-00009479-00009678": "sara learns that suppressing her", "5040v1wwYmc-00037-00009679-00009942": "emotions and following her duties is the", "5040v1wwYmc-00038-00009943-00010167": "way to get through the day", "5040v1wwYmc-00039-00010168-00010383": "to get the love of her parents and to", "5040v1wwYmc-00040-00010384-00010646": "avoid making them upset she becomes", "5040v1wwYmc-00041-00010647-00010783": "obedient", "5040v1wwYmc-00042-00010784-00011046": "however because sarah was never allowed", "5040v1wwYmc-00043-00011047-00011303": "to decide for herself or follow her", "5040v1wwYmc-00044-00011304-00011606": "intrinsic interests as an adult she", "5040v1wwYmc-00045-00011607-00011870": "doesn't know what she really wants", "5040v1wwYmc-00046-00011871-00012087": "she begins living a life that seems", "5040v1wwYmc-00047-00012088-00012367": "perfect to her parents and society but", "5040v1wwYmc-00048-00012368-00012815": "might leave her unhappy on the inside", "5040v1wwYmc-00049-00012816-00013094": "permissive parents like those of peter", "5040v1wwYmc-00050-00013095-00013343": "enjoy their little boys so much that", "5040v1wwYmc-00051-00013344-00013591": "they believe they should fulfill all his", "5040v1wwYmc-00052-00013591-00013919": "wishes give him full freedom and never", "5040v1wwYmc-00053-00013919-00014071": "say no", "5040v1wwYmc-00054-00014072-00014319": "peter enjoys full control over his", "5040v1wwYmc-00055-00014319-00014591": "parents and gets whatever he wants if he", "5040v1wwYmc-00056-00014591-00014855": "doesn't want to walk he'll be carried if", "5040v1wwYmc-00057-00014856-00015191": "he wants ice cream ice cream he gets if", "5040v1wwYmc-00058-00015191-00015430": "he wants to play games he'll be playing", "5040v1wwYmc-00059-00015431-00015775": "them all night", "5040v1wwYmc-00060-00015776-00015991": "peter grows up completely without", "5040v1wwYmc-00061-00015991-00016222": "borders and does whatever he thinks is", "5040v1wwYmc-00062-00016223-00016311": "right", "5040v1wwYmc-00063-00016312-00016575": "he never coped with conflict and he did", "5040v1wwYmc-00064-00016576-00016863": "not learn to control his emotions", "5040v1wwYmc-00065-00016864-00017039": "the fact that he always got what he", "5040v1wwYmc-00066-00017040-00017319": "wanted made him a bad loser", "5040v1wwYmc-00067-00017320-00017543": "as he grows older he often acts", "5040v1wwYmc-00068-00017544-00017775": "inconsiderate and doesn't know his", "5040v1wwYmc-00069-00017776-00018047": "limits", "5040v1wwYmc-00070-00018048-00018319": "arthur's authoritative parents respect", "5040v1wwYmc-00071-00018320-00018550": "their child's needs but believe that", "5040v1wwYmc-00072-00018551-00018879": "kids need freedom within certain limits", "5040v1wwYmc-00073-00018880-00019119": "arthur can freely play but when he's", "5040v1wwYmc-00074-00019120-00019430": "done he needs to help tidy up he is", "5040v1wwYmc-00075-00019431-00019683": "allowed to eat ice cream but only on", "5040v1wwYmc-00076-00019684-00019999": "sundays screen time is limited to 30", "5040v1wwYmc-00077-00020000-00020143": "minutes a day", "5040v1wwYmc-00078-00020144-00020367": "there may be conflict but the parents", "5040v1wwYmc-00079-00020368-00020607": "listen to what arthur has to say and", "5040v1wwYmc-00080-00020608-00020983": "then lay down the rules", "5040v1wwYmc-00081-00020984-00021150": "arthur learns that some things are", "5040v1wwYmc-00082-00021151-00021391": "difficult but his parents give him all", "5040v1wwYmc-00083-00021392-00021678": "the support he needs to get through it", "5040v1wwYmc-00084-00021679-00021919": "he develops the strength to endure", "5040v1wwYmc-00085-00021920-00022183": "hardships and to continue following his", "5040v1wwYmc-00086-00022184-00022383": "interests and passions", "5040v1wwYmc-00087-00022384-00022678": "in class he bravely expresses his own", "5040v1wwYmc-00088-00022679-00022975": "opinions in an appropriate manner during", "5040v1wwYmc-00089-00022976-00023263": "breaks he can show his emotions and act", "5040v1wwYmc-00090-00023264-00023375": "freely", "5040v1wwYmc-00091-00023376-00023639": "as an adult he agrees to rules only", "5040v1wwYmc-00092-00023640-00023855": "after they have been discussed and he", "5040v1wwYmc-00093-00023856-00024263": "feels like he understands them", "5040v1wwYmc-00094-00024264-00024486": "neglectful parents are usually not", "5040v1wwYmc-00095-00024487-00024711": "present in their children's life", "5040v1wwYmc-00096-00024712-00024991": "nora often feels completely alone in the", "5040v1wwYmc-00097-00024992-00025078": "world", "5040v1wwYmc-00098-00025079-00025319": "she experiences full freedom to do", "5040v1wwYmc-00099-00025320-00025542": "anything she wants to and has plenty of", "5040v1wwYmc-00100-00025543-00025831": "imagination but she never receives any", "5040v1wwYmc-00101-00025832-00026231": "feedback or even attention", "5040v1wwYmc-00102-00026232-00026439": "nora realizes that it doesn't matter", "5040v1wwYmc-00103-00026439-00026662": "what she does because no one cares", "5040v1wwYmc-00104-00026663-00026951": "anyway the lack of attention leads to a", "5040v1wwYmc-00105-00026952-00027246": "lack of trust in herself and others", "5040v1wwYmc-00106-00027247-00027535": "she becomes insecurely attached unable", "5040v1wwYmc-00107-00027536-00027767": "to form healthy relationships and", "5040v1wwYmc-00108-00027768-00028062": "develops a negative image of herself", "5040v1wwYmc-00109-00028063-00028343": "to stop feeling unworthy of love she", "5040v1wwYmc-00110-00028344-00028799": "tries not to feel anything at all", "5040v1wwYmc-00111-00028800-00029102": "in recent years over-involved parents", "5040v1wwYmc-00112-00029104-00029351": "who are present in every aspect of their", "5040v1wwYmc-00113-00029352-00029607": "child's life are often referred to as", "5040v1wwYmc-00114-00029608-00029767": "the fifth style", "5040v1wwYmc-00115-00029768-00029967": "these parents are also known as", "5040v1wwYmc-00116-00029968-00030262": "snowplows removing obstacles out of", "5040v1wwYmc-00117-00030263-00030599": "their kid's path or helicopter parents", "5040v1wwYmc-00118-00030600-00030902": "who hover about and micromanage every", "5040v1wwYmc-00119-00030903-00031143": "aspect of their child's life", "5040v1wwYmc-00120-00031144-00031335": "since they won't let their children do", "5040v1wwYmc-00121-00031336-00031574": "anything alone the children can't learn", "5040v1wwYmc-00122-00031575-00031887": "to overcome challenges by themselves", "5040v1wwYmc-00123-00031888-00032102": "research infers that these children", "5040v1wwYmc-00124-00032103-00032351": "don't like to solve difficult problems", "5040v1wwYmc-00125-00032352-00032590": "like perseverance and may even", "5040v1wwYmc-00126-00032591-00032839": "procrastinate in protest when something", "5040v1wwYmc-00127-00032840-00033231": "requires a lot of effort", "5040v1wwYmc-00128-00033232-00033479": "since most research on parenting is", "5040v1wwYmc-00129-00033480-00033743": "based on self-reports and was done in", "5040v1wwYmc-00130-00033744-00034062": "the us and europe it is not clear how", "5040v1wwYmc-00131-00034063-00034302": "strongly the observed effects will hold", "5040v1wwYmc-00132-00034303-00034518": "up in controlled observational", "5040v1wwYmc-00133-00034519-00034774": "experiments or in other parts of the", "5040v1wwYmc-00134-00034775-00035046": "world", "5040v1wwYmc-00135-00035047-00035262": "the four parenting styles were first", "5040v1wwYmc-00136-00035263-00035487": "introduced by psychologist diana", "5040v1wwYmc-00137-00035488-00035607": "baumrind", "5040v1wwYmc-00138-00035608-00035879": "for good parenting she advised balance", "5040v1wwYmc-00139-00035880-00036174": "of demandingness and responsiveness add", "5040v1wwYmc-00140-00036175-00036390": "to that the wise words of maria", "5040v1wwYmc-00141-00036391-00036687": "montessori to never help a child with", "5040v1wwYmc-00142-00036688-00036862": "the task at which he feels he can", "5040v1wwYmc-00143-00036863-00037135": "succeed and parents should do pretty", "5040v1wwYmc-00144-00037136-00037367": "well", "5040v1wwYmc-00145-00037368-00037630": "what do you think should parents resort", "5040v1wwYmc-00146-00037631-00037902": "to a specific style or should they", "5040v1wwYmc-00147-00037903-00038143": "decide what's best to do in a given", "5040v1wwYmc-00148-00038144-00038399": "situation as long as they don't neglect", "5040v1wwYmc-00149-00038400-00038607": "or abuse their child", "5040v1wwYmc-00150-00038608-00038790": "to download this video without", "5040v1wwYmc-00151-00038791-00039015": "background music and learn more about", "5040v1wwYmc-00152-00039016-00039211": "the topic visit", "5040v1wwYmc-00153-00039212-00039367": "sproutschools.com", "5040v1wwYmc-00154-00039368-00039599": "for a free masterclass on attachment", "5040v1wwYmc-00155-00039600-00039774": "parenting see the link in the", "5040v1wwYmc-00156-00039775-00040051": "description below", "5040v1wwYmc-00157-00040052-00041415": "[Music]", "5040v1wwYmc-00158-00041416-00041599": "sprouts videos are published under the", "5040v1wwYmc-00159-00041600-00041830": "creative commons license that means our", "5040v1wwYmc-00160-00041831-00042095": "videos are free and anyone can download", "5040v1wwYmc-00161-00042096-00042367": "edit and play them for personal use and", "5040v1wwYmc-00162-00042368-00042599": "public schools governments and", "5040v1wwYmc-00163-00042600-00042830": "non-profit organizations can also use", "5040v1wwYmc-00164-00042831-00043039": "them for training online courses or", "5040v1wwYmc-00165-00043040-00043302": "designing new curriculums", "5040v1wwYmc-00166-00043303-00043518": "to help us stay independent and support", "5040v1wwYmc-00167-00043519-00043718": "our work you can join our patrons and", "5040v1wwYmc-00168-00043719-00044015": "contribute just visit patreon.com", "5040v1wwYmc-00169-00044016-00044255": "sprouts even one dollar can make a", "5040v1wwYmc-00170-00044256-00044556": "difference"}}, {"audio_id": "50h83yWhW7M", "text": {"50h83yWhW7M-00000-00000074-00000350": "assume a push-up position with the arms", "50h83yWhW7M-00001-00000351-00000584": "completely straight position your hands", "50h83yWhW7M-00002-00000585-00000833": "slightly wider than your shoulders your", "50h83yWhW7M-00003-00000834-00001010": "body should form a straight line from", "50h83yWhW7M-00004-00001011-00001361": "head to your ankles if your foot off the", "50h83yWhW7M-00005-00001362-00001523": "floor and raise your knees close to your", "50h83yWhW7M-00006-00001524-00001784": "chest as you can without allowing your", "50h83yWhW7M-00007-00001785-00002800": "lower back to ramp alternating back and", "50h83yWhW7M-00008-00002801-00003167": "forth as quickly as you can"}}, {"audio_id": "50I_6hSVNYg", "text": {"50I_6hSVNYg-00000-00000019-00001082": "[Music]", "50I_6hSVNYg-00001-00001083-00001914": "[Applause]", "50I_6hSVNYg-00002-00001916-00002162": "hello everybody I'm boys father I'm an", "50I_6hSVNYg-00003-00002163-00002363": "evolutionary astrologer and I'm here", "50I_6hSVNYg-00004-00002364-00002540": "with the evolutionary astrology message", "50I_6hSVNYg-00005-00002541-00002890": "for the week between October 6th and 13", "50I_6hSVNYg-00006-00002891-00003338": "2018 we are reaching peak times when it", "50I_6hSVNYg-00007-00003339-00003747": "comes to changes and transformation", "50I_6hSVNYg-00008-00003748-00003986": "regarding Venusian subjects regarding", "50I_6hSVNYg-00009-00003986-00004247": "relationships regarding our own", "50I_6hSVNYg-00010-00004248-00004493": "satisfaction regarding our own value and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00011-00004494-00004793": "the value of the people we hold in our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00012-00004794-00005218": "lives and this is a time that is not", "50I_6hSVNYg-00013-00005219-00005926": "made for them harsh and thought-through", "50I_6hSVNYg-00014-00005927-00006281": "decisions that might impact our life for", "50I_6hSVNYg-00015-00006282-00006589": "the long term manner first of all I want", "50I_6hSVNYg-00016-00006590-00006923": "to apologize a minute because my eye is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00017-00006923-00007334": "tearing I have I think it's a viral", "50I_6hSVNYg-00018-00007334-00007526": "thing but I'm not sure I think I got it", "50I_6hSVNYg-00019-00007527-00007678": "for my daughter you know how the first", "50I_6hSVNYg-00020-00007679-00007970": "days of kindergarten are it's like a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00021-00007970-00008417": "petri dish and I think she brought", "50I_6hSVNYg-00022-00008418-00008624": "something over but hopefully we'll get", "50I_6hSVNYg-00023-00008625-00008992": "better in a few days let's go down to", "50I_6hSVNYg-00024-00008993-00009224": "the weekdays but just to finish up what", "50I_6hSVNYg-00025-00009225-00009460": "I what I had to say the summary of this", "50I_6hSVNYg-00026-00009461-00009785": "week so if you are I know some some of", "50I_6hSVNYg-00027-00009786-00009953": "you are translating this message into", "50I_6hSVNYg-00028-00009954-00010306": "other languages so just a summary peak", "50I_6hSVNYg-00029-00010307-00010526": "time when it comes to relationships when", "50I_6hSVNYg-00030-00010527-00010817": "it comes to how I find my own value and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00031-00010818-00011021": "how I find value within the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00032-00011022-00011180": "relationships with other people in my", "50I_6hSVNYg-00033-00011181-00011408": "life of course income and the way I", "50I_6hSVNYg-00034-00011409-00011803": "bring in money and generally my peace", "50I_6hSVNYg-00035-00011804-00012067": "harmony and satisfaction in life this is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00036-00012068-00012346": "not a time to make harsh unthought", "50I_6hSVNYg-00037-00012347-00012683": "through decisions this is the time to", "50I_6hSVNYg-00038-00012684-00013058": "put question marks on everything that we", "50I_6hSVNYg-00039-00013059-00013338": "were so sure is steadfast and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00040-00013338-00013605": "and and true in our lives and maybe see", "50I_6hSVNYg-00041-00013606-00013884": "things from a different angle especially", "50I_6hSVNYg-00042-00013885-00014112": "by the way I have Georgia by my side", "50I_6hSVNYg-00043-00014113-00014412": "here just that you know this is a mirror", "50I_6hSVNYg-00044-00014413-00014652": "reflecting light to the other side of my", "50I_6hSVNYg-00045-00014653-00015126": "face so it won't be half dark half", "50I_6hSVNYg-00046-00015127-00015435": "Lytton so Georgia is just here by my", "50I_6hSVNYg-00047-00015436-00015872": "side let me just fix this yes anyway so", "50I_6hSVNYg-00048-00015874-00016769": "I would say that there could be a lot of", "50I_6hSVNYg-00049-00016770-00016938": "tribulation so there could be some", "50I_6hSVNYg-00050-00016939-00017217": "challenges that are coming up now this", "50I_6hSVNYg-00051-00017218-00017424": "is the time to actually question things", "50I_6hSVNYg-00052-00017425-00017592": "this is the time to see things from a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00053-00017593-00017850": "different light but it's not yet the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00054-00017851-00018102": "time to make any long-term decisions", "50I_6hSVNYg-00055-00018103-00018722": "let's go down to the weekdays vi vi is a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00056-00018723-00019122": "Saturday it has a grand earth trine in", "50I_6hSVNYg-00057-00019123-00019392": "the sky it's a time that could help us", "50I_6hSVNYg-00058-00019393-00019740": "formulate substantiate and deepen things", "50I_6hSVNYg-00059-00019741-00020181": "that are needed to be more rooted in in", "50I_6hSVNYg-00060-00020182-00020447": "our life on the one hand on the other", "50I_6hSVNYg-00061-00020448-00020622": "hand it's a great time for innovation", "50I_6hSVNYg-00062-00020623-00020925": "for bringing new things in to our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00063-00020926-00021278": "subjective point of view to the way we", "50I_6hSVNYg-00064-00021279-00021615": "step out to life to what we include", "50I_6hSVNYg-00065-00021616-00022008": "within our selves and who we are so all", "50I_6hSVNYg-00066-00022009-00022406": "kinds of regimes and and and I don't", "50I_6hSVNYg-00067-00022407-00022587": "want to say habits because habits in", "50I_6hSVNYg-00068-00022588-00023090": "English have a negative tendency but", "50I_6hSVNYg-00069-00023091-00023475": "things that we do consistently new", "50I_6hSVNYg-00070-00023476-00023672": "things can be integrated into that", "50I_6hSVNYg-00071-00023673-00024069": "consistent system right now the evening", "50I_6hSVNYg-00072-00024070-00024339": "of the Saturday of Saturday the 6th is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00073-00024340-00024653": "is really nice there's a moon sextile", "50I_6hSVNYg-00074-00024654-00024915": "Venus it could be a fun night with", "50I_6hSVNYg-00075-00024916-00025164": "people around you or eating drinking and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00076-00025165-00025352": "just having fun", "50I_6hSVNYg-00077-00025353-00025749": "remember I'm speaking in Central", "50I_6hSVNYg-00078-00025750-00026043": "European Time it's about nine hours back", "50I_6hSVNYg-00079-00026044-00026406": "if you are in Eastern Eastern Time in", "50I_6hSVNYg-00080-00026407-00026637": "the US and if you are in the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00081-00026638-00026839": "Pacific in Australia New Zealand it's", "50I_6hSVNYg-00082-00026839-00027223": "about ten hours ahead the seventh Sunday", "50I_6hSVNYg-00083-00027224-00027577": "is a tremendously energetic morning and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00084-00027577-00027799": "just it could be a very beautiful day", "50I_6hSVNYg-00085-00027800-00028048": "it's a great day to study it's a great", "50I_6hSVNYg-00086-00028049-00028201": "day to do anything connecting with", "50I_6hSVNYg-00087-00028202-00028596": "spirit there's a sextile to Jupiter and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00088-00028597-00029035": "there is a trying to Pluto making it a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00089-00029036-00029367": "good day for intimacy and sex and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00090-00029368-00029652": "introspection as well but the energies", "50I_6hSVNYg-00091-00029653-00029854": "are going to be a little too high for", "50I_6hSVNYg-00092-00029855-00030120": "introspection so I would say go outside", "50I_6hSVNYg-00093-00030121-00030370": "on that day the Sun conjunct Ceres", "50I_6hSVNYg-00094-00030370-00030693": "Demeter as well this is a wonderful time", "50I_6hSVNYg-00095-00030694-00031024": "to give out of love you know", "50I_6hSVNYg-00096-00031025-00031330": "without asking anything in return but on", "50I_6hSVNYg-00097-00031331-00031561": "the other hand if we are givers already", "50I_6hSVNYg-00098-00031562-00031830": "this is a good time to examine if what", "50I_6hSVNYg-00099-00031831-00032014": "we're giving and how we're giving is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00100-00032014-00032358": "actually producing results on the ground", "50I_6hSVNYg-00101-00032359-00032707": "is it actually fruitful is it actually", "50I_6hSVNYg-00102-00032708-00033140": "the developmental are our gifts", "50I_6hSVNYg-00103-00033141-00033517": "appreciated this is a time of these", "50I_6hSVNYg-00104-00033518-00034108": "matters could be on the table and the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00105-00034109-00034308": "eight is a sensitive day it's a time", "50I_6hSVNYg-00106-00034309-00034537": "that we need to be aware for own pains", "50I_6hSVNYg-00107-00034538-00034714": "and aches and not to act out of our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00108-00034715-00034999": "post-traumatic place and really be", "50I_6hSVNYg-00109-00035000-00035214": "sensitive with other people around us as", "50I_6hSVNYg-00110-00035215-00035389": "well the evening time is really", "50I_6hSVNYg-00111-00035390-00035640": "energetic I suggest you do something", "50I_6hSVNYg-00112-00035641-00035787": "some kind of activity and here's a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00113-00035788-00036064": "suggestion for you early evening on the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00114-00036065-00036345": "8th is a great time to see the Dragonoid", "50I_6hSVNYg-00115-00036346-00036630": "meteor shower it's not one of the most", "50I_6hSVNYg-00116-00036631-00036907": "dense meteor showers we have each year", "50I_6hSVNYg-00117-00036908-00037282": "it's about 10 10 meteors an hour", "50I_6hSVNYg-00118-00037283-00037593": "approximately coming from the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00119-00037594-00038037": "constellation Draco mainly and unlike", "50I_6hSVNYg-00120-00038038-00038332": "other meteor showers that are mostly", "50I_6hSVNYg-00121-00038333-00038539": "seen there late at night or before", "50I_6hSVNYg-00122-00038540-00038836": "sunrise this one is the the best time to", "50I_6hSVNYg-00123-00038837-00039085": "view this one is just at the early", "50I_6hSVNYg-00124-00039086-00039274": "evening and there's not going to be any", "50I_6hSVNYg-00125-00039275-00039546": "moon in the sky which makes it perfect", "50I_6hSVNYg-00126-00039547-00039823": "if you have no clouds to look up and see", "50I_6hSVNYg-00127-00039824-00040015": "some falling stars", "50I_6hSVNYg-00128-00040016-00040207": "long as you are away from light", "50I_6hSVNYg-00129-00040208-00040711": "pollution and city lights of course the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00130-00040712-00041242": "9th is a new moon day it's remember that", "50I_6hSVNYg-00131-00041243-00041395": "whenever we're talking about new moons", "50I_6hSVNYg-00132-00041396-00041659": "the day before the day after in the day", "50I_6hSVNYg-00133-00041660-00041875": "itself are kind of an imprinting", "50I_6hSVNYg-00134-00041876-00042100": "energetic emotional imprinting for the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00135-00042101-00042427": "next lunar cycle so if I'm happy gay and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00136-00042428-00042634": "very satisfied something of that is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00137-00042635-00042937": "going to go on with me to that lunar", "50I_6hSVNYg-00138-00042938-00043327": "cycle and if I'm angry and vengeful and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00139-00043328-00043717": "and and unappreciative of things around", "50I_6hSVNYg-00140-00043718-00043921": "me something of that is going to go with", "50I_6hSVNYg-00141-00043922-00044218": "me through that lunar cycle so be aware", "50I_6hSVNYg-00142-00044219-00044442": "of that energetic sponge that you are", "50I_6hSVNYg-00143-00044443-00044704": "this is a new moon in 15 degrees of", "50I_6hSVNYg-00144-00044705-00044935": "Libra 48 minutes it has to do a lot", "50I_6hSVNYg-00145-00044936-00045121": "again with Venusian subjects with our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00146-00045122-00045349": "relationships and how we find balance", "50I_6hSVNYg-00147-00045350-00045706": "harmony satisfaction and tranquility", "50I_6hSVNYg-00148-00045707-00045913": "through our connections with others", "50I_6hSVNYg-00149-00045914-00046201": "about justice within those relationships", "50I_6hSVNYg-00150-00046202-00046531": "and not giving in or sacrificing too", "50I_6hSVNYg-00151-00046532-00046816": "much this is a new moon that squares", "50I_6hSVNYg-00152-00046817-00047434": "Pluto so it's a level of combustion it's", "50I_6hSVNYg-00153-00047435-00048253": "a possible it's it's it's um it just got", "50I_6hSVNYg-00154-00048254-00048472": "a lot let's just say it just got a lot", "50I_6hSVNYg-00155-00048473-00048709": "more dramatic with that Square to Pluto", "50I_6hSVNYg-00156-00048710-00048901": "when Pluto is involved the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00157-00048902-00049135": "transformational processes of death and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00158-00049136-00049447": "rebirth are heightened and the highs and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00159-00049448-00049702": "lows are heightened we could go through", "50I_6hSVNYg-00160-00049703-00049986": "so many emotions on the 9th and the 10th", "50I_6hSVNYg-00161-00049987-00050335": "we could be happy one moment and angry", "50I_6hSVNYg-00162-00050336-00050650": "the next exhilarated the other moment", "50I_6hSVNYg-00163-00050651-00050974": "and then unsatisfied a moment later so", "50I_6hSVNYg-00164-00050975-00051175": "we really have to watch it and if we", "50I_6hSVNYg-00165-00051176-00051417": "actually try to move away from our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00166-00051419-00051610": "emotions and be in a more logical place", "50I_6hSVNYg-00167-00051611-00051933": "we can because of other transits in the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00168-00051934-00052104": "sky that I mentioned the second in a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00169-00052105-00052380": "second but the thing is to work", "50I_6hSVNYg-00170-00052382-00052675": "harmoniously between the heart and the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00171-00052676-00052914": "mind at that time and not be too", "50I_6hSVNYg-00172-00052915-00053232": "disconnected from one system or the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00173-00053233-00053439": "other", "50I_6hSVNYg-00174-00053440-00053698": "it can be challenging it can be a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00175-00053699-00053866": "challenging new moon it can be that", "50I_6hSVNYg-00176-00053866-00054463": "things come to us unexpectedly the tent", "50I_6hSVNYg-00177-00054464-00054823": "itself is a day that mercury moves into", "50I_6hSVNYg-00178-00054824-00055126": "Scorpio the moon is in Scorpio conjunct", "50I_6hSVNYg-00179-00055127-00055408": "mercury then the moon conjunct Uranus", "50I_6hSVNYg-00180-00055409-00055765": "then uranus conjunct mercury so it's a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00181-00055766-00056061": "lot about communication fast-moving", "50I_6hSVNYg-00182-00056062-00056216": "[Music]", "50I_6hSVNYg-00183-00056217-00056592": "electronic advanced futuristic", "50I_6hSVNYg-00184-00056594-00056794": "communication it's about thinking but", "50I_6hSVNYg-00185-00056795-00056979": "not just any thinking thinking outside", "50I_6hSVNYg-00186-00056980-00057310": "the box thinking in an innovative manner", "50I_6hSVNYg-00187-00057311-00057571": "in an avant-garde manner it's about", "50I_6hSVNYg-00188-00057572-00057832": "allowing yourselves to be different it's", "50I_6hSVNYg-00189-00057833-00058108": "about knowing that that difference can", "50I_6hSVNYg-00190-00058109-00058336": "actually mean you're unique and ahead of", "50I_6hSVNYg-00191-00058337-00058510": "your time and you could progress people", "50I_6hSVNYg-00192-00058511-00058828": "around you as well and but it's about", "50I_6hSVNYg-00193-00058829-00059077": "bringing that out in a positive manner", "50I_6hSVNYg-00194-00059078-00059257": "that could actually be swallowed by", "50I_6hSVNYg-00195-00059258-00059527": "other people could actually be ingested", "50I_6hSVNYg-00196-00059528-00059749": "by other people and not in a way that", "50I_6hSVNYg-00197-00059750-00059944": "would either be too painful and hurtful", "50I_6hSVNYg-00198-00059945-00060103": "to other people and remind you that", "50I_6hSVNYg-00199-00060104-00060346": "Scorpio and Mercury together can produce", "50I_6hSVNYg-00200-00060347-00060649": "words that hit you underneath your belt", "50I_6hSVNYg-00201-00060650-00060928": "and and and make you fall apart because", "50I_6hSVNYg-00202-00060929-00061270": "they have some cruelty and some truth to", "50I_6hSVNYg-00203-00061271-00061594": "them so we have to be careful it's about", "50I_6hSVNYg-00204-00061595-00061864": "power within our communication power", "50I_6hSVNYg-00205-00061865-00062112": "within our thoughts power and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00206-00062113-00062359": "introspection regarding how we do things", "50I_6hSVNYg-00207-00062360-00062734": "and how we can maintain and and actually", "50I_6hSVNYg-00208-00062735-00063001": "better our situation in our health and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00209-00063002-00063612": "life so the 10th is a very fast-paced", "50I_6hSVNYg-00210-00063613-00064090": "day and as I said allow yourself to walk", "50I_6hSVNYg-00211-00064091-00064354": "away step from your emotions into that", "50I_6hSVNYg-00212-00064354-00064576": "logical space and allow that logical", "50I_6hSVNYg-00213-00064577-00064837": "space to be free and innovative but try", "50I_6hSVNYg-00214-00064838-00065341": "and balance the two and the 11th is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00215-00065341-00066238": "Thursday on that day the square between", "50I_6hSVNYg-00216-00066239-00066568": "Venus and Mars is exact it's a day with", "50I_6hSVNYg-00217-00066569-00066650": "a lot of put", "50I_6hSVNYg-00218-00066651-00066886": "for combustion within our relationships", "50I_6hSVNYg-00219-00066887-00067220": "as well within work environments it's a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00220-00067221-00067388": "day that we could feel that we need our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00221-00067389-00067766": "satisfaction faster we needed now we", "50I_6hSVNYg-00222-00067767-00068129": "can't wait with it pushing away our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00223-00068130-00068339": "desires could be a problem on that day", "50I_6hSVNYg-00224-00068340-00069215": "and the 11th the moon conjuncts the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00225-00069216-00069701": "Venus and then on the 12th a conjunct", "50I_6hSVNYg-00226-00069702-00069914": "Jupiter when the moon is between Jupiter", "50I_6hSVNYg-00227-00069915-00070124": "and Venus it's a blessed time it's a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00228-00070125-00070331": "time that we could feel much more", "50I_6hSVNYg-00229-00070332-00070484": "tranquility in harmony", "50I_6hSVNYg-00230-00070485-00070838": "and benevolence and basically that we're", "50I_6hSVNYg-00231-00070839-00071249": "lucky but these are in Scorpio and they", "50I_6hSVNYg-00232-00071250-00071684": "are squaring marks so the need to", "50I_6hSVNYg-00233-00071685-00071897": "challenge ourselves or the challenges", "50I_6hSVNYg-00234-00071898-00072236": "coming from our surroundings and the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00235-00072237-00072524": "field of just building in life that is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00236-00072525-00072767": "more satisfactory to ourselves within", "50I_6hSVNYg-00237-00072768-00073060": "our relationships bringing it to a more", "50I_6hSVNYg-00238-00073061-00073577": "balanced a place of equilibrium is a lot", "50I_6hSVNYg-00239-00073578-00074096": "of what these energies are about on", "50I_6hSVNYg-00240-00074097-00074408": "Friday we have that's in 12 we have the", "50I_6hSVNYg-00241-00074409-00074788": "moon conjunct Jupiter and the Sun Co", "50I_6hSVNYg-00242-00074789-00075053": "squaring Pluto and when the Sun squares", "50I_6hSVNYg-00243-00075054-00075380": "Pluto all the days before like five days", "50I_6hSVNYg-00244-00075381-00075683": "before five days after are more intense", "50I_6hSVNYg-00245-00075684-00075932": "we have to be careful from subjects of", "50I_6hSVNYg-00246-00075933-00076481": "ego pride and and and and again not", "50I_6hSVNYg-00247-00076482-00076808": "being taking dominance being cruel or", "50I_6hSVNYg-00248-00076809-00077045": "trying to exert power over others or", "50I_6hSVNYg-00249-00077046-00077537": "letting others do that to us and it's a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00250-00077538-00077744": "day these are days that we could see our", "50I_6hSVNYg-00251-00077745-00078106": "hidden shadows we could transform", "50I_6hSVNYg-00252-00078107-00078410": "throughout these days who we are and how", "50I_6hSVNYg-00253-00078411-00078932": "we shed light in this world the 10th is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00254-00078933-00079259": "a Saturday it's a beautiful day it's", "50I_6hSVNYg-00255-00079260-00079577": "very energetic I suggest you do", "50I_6hSVNYg-00256-00079578-00079789": "something with it you go outside and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00257-00079790-00079988": "nature is", "50I_6hSVNYg-00258-00079989-00080199": "wonderful on that day if you have good", "50I_6hSVNYg-00259-00080200-00080553": "weather and the afternoon is a little", "50I_6hSVNYg-00260-00080554-00080919": "lethargic tired and forgetful it's", "50I_6hSVNYg-00261-00080920-00081216": "better for being either involved in art", "50I_6hSVNYg-00262-00081217-00081699": "or music or listening or eating those", "50I_6hSVNYg-00263-00081700-00081926": "things and we're just being at home and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00264-00081927-00082203": "or relaxing and this is not a great time", "50I_6hSVNYg-00265-00082204-00082515": "to exert mental effort or physical", "50I_6hSVNYg-00266-00082516-00082791": "effort Saturday afternoon anyway that", "50I_6hSVNYg-00267-00082792-00083088": "was about it we're opening up a group", "50I_6hSVNYg-00268-00083089-00083361": "for practicing natal charts if you want", "50I_6hSVNYg-00269-00083362-00083460": "enjoyed let me know", "50I_6hSVNYg-00270-00083461-00083711": "and of course beginners group and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00271-00083712-00084000": "intermediate group if you still want to", "50I_6hSVNYg-00272-00084001-00084273": "join us let us know anyway thank you for", "50I_6hSVNYg-00273-00084274-00084447": "listening and commenting and sharing", "50I_6hSVNYg-00274-00084448-00084759": "this and and liking this because it", "50I_6hSVNYg-00275-00084760-00084999": "exposes this video to more people have a", "50I_6hSVNYg-00276-00085000-00085179": "beautiful week this is boys fighter and", "50I_6hSVNYg-00277-00085180-00085521": "I'm Astaire and goodbye"}}, {"audio_id": "50aI0RjBfFA", "text": {"50aI0RjBfFA-00000-00000019-00002430": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00001-00002431-00005634": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00002-00005635-00007536": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00003-00007537-00011143": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00004-00011144-00012744": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00005-00012745-00015366": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00006-00015366-00020035": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00007-00020036-00027027": "[Music]", "50aI0RjBfFA-00008-00027028-00027993": "you", "50aI0RjBfFA-00009-00027994-00029331": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "519fl8hrQm0", "text": {"519fl8hrQm0-00000-00000096-00000295": "today we'll be solving the equation two", "519fl8hrQm0-00001-00000296-00000383": "to the three x", "519fl8hrQm0-00002-00000384-00000711": "plus one equals six since six", "519fl8hrQm0-00003-00000712-00000919": "can't be written as an exponent with a", "519fl8hrQm0-00004-00000919-00001023": "base of two", "519fl8hrQm0-00005-00001024-00001231": "we have to take the log base two of both", "519fl8hrQm0-00006-00001232-00001495": "sides which gives us the log base two", "519fl8hrQm0-00007-00001496-00001823": "of 2 to the 3x plus 1 equals the log", "519fl8hrQm0-00008-00001823-00001902": "base 2", "519fl8hrQm0-00009-00001903-00002207": "of 6. now when we have an exponent", "519fl8hrQm0-00010-00002208-00002383": "inside of a log we can bring it out", "519fl8hrQm0-00011-00002384-00002615": "front and make it multiplication", "519fl8hrQm0-00012-00002616-00002887": "so this becomes 3x plus 1 times the log", "519fl8hrQm0-00013-00002888-00003031": "base 2 of 2", "519fl8hrQm0-00014-00003032-00003359": "equals the log base 2 of 6. the log base", "519fl8hrQm0-00015-00003360-00003559": "2 of 2 is equal to 1", "519fl8hrQm0-00016-00003560-00003847": "so this gives us 3x plus 1 equals the", "519fl8hrQm0-00017-00003847-00003975": "log base 2", "519fl8hrQm0-00018-00003976-00004359": "of 6. solving for x first we'll subtract", "519fl8hrQm0-00019-00004360-00004622": "one from each side this gives us three x", "519fl8hrQm0-00020-00004623-00004743": "equals negative one", "519fl8hrQm0-00021-00004744-00005079": "plus the log base two of six dividing", "519fl8hrQm0-00022-00005080-00005191": "both sides by three", "519fl8hrQm0-00023-00005192-00005486": "gives us x equals negative one plus the", "519fl8hrQm0-00024-00005487-00005679": "log base two of six", "519fl8hrQm0-00025-00005680-00006070": "all over three now we can reduce", "519fl8hrQm0-00026-00006071-00006422": "the log base two of six", "519fl8hrQm0-00027-00006423-00006759": "six is the product of two and three", "519fl8hrQm0-00028-00006759-00006967": "and we can break up these products with", "519fl8hrQm0-00029-00006968-00007191": "addition so this becomes the log base", "519fl8hrQm0-00030-00007192-00007263": "two", "519fl8hrQm0-00031-00007264-00007591": "of two plus the log base two", "519fl8hrQm0-00032-00007592-00007878": "of three the log base two of two is", "519fl8hrQm0-00033-00007879-00007919": "again", "519fl8hrQm0-00034-00007920-00008151": "one so this becomes one plus the log", "519fl8hrQm0-00035-00008152-00008295": "base two of three", "519fl8hrQm0-00036-00008296-00008527": "plugging that back into our equation", "519fl8hrQm0-00037-00008528-00008623": "gives us x", "519fl8hrQm0-00038-00008624-00008919": "equals negative one plus one plus the", "519fl8hrQm0-00039-00008920-00009119": "log base two of three", "519fl8hrQm0-00040-00009120-00009463": "all divided by three negative one plus", "519fl8hrQm0-00041-00009464-00009503": "one", "519fl8hrQm0-00042-00009504-00009863": "is zero so our final answer is the log", "519fl8hrQm0-00043-00009864-00010023": "base two of three", "519fl8hrQm0-00044-00010024-00010847": "divided by three"}}, {"audio_id": "51RhDNZSgII", "text": {"51RhDNZSgII-00000-00000011-00000329": "the Ministry of Education and science is", "51RhDNZSgII-00001-00000330-00000494": "a Ministry of the government of the", "51RhDNZSgII-00002-00000495-00000746": "Republic of North Macedonia by virtue of", "51RhDNZSgII-00003-00000747-00001019": "section 23 of the law of organization", "51RhDNZSgII-00004-00001019-00001190": "and acting of the organs of state", "51RhDNZSgII-00005-00001191-00001427": "administration law Gazette of Republic", "51RhDNZSgII-00006-00001428-00001964": "of Macedonia no 59 mm from 21 July 2000", "51RhDNZSgII-00007-00001964-00002226": "the ministry does the work concerning", "51RhDNZSgII-00008-00002227-00002516": "upbringing and/or education of any type", "51RhDNZSgII-00009-00002517-00002870": "or degree organization financing", "51RhDNZSgII-00010-00002871-00003047": "development and upgrading of the", "51RhDNZSgII-00011-00003048-00003295": "upbringing education and science", "51RhDNZSgII-00012-00003296-00003569": "upbringing and education of Macedonian", "51RhDNZSgII-00013-00003570-00003859": "workers children in foreign countries", "51RhDNZSgII-00014-00003860-00004063": "verification of different professions", "51RhDNZSgII-00015-00004064-00004270": "and all profiles in the field of", "51RhDNZSgII-00016-00004271-00004717": "Education pupils and students standards", "51RhDNZSgII-00017-00004718-00004979": "technological advances it information", "51RhDNZSgII-00018-00004980-00005236": "systems and technical culture", "51RhDNZSgII-00019-00005237-00005456": "international scientific and/or", "51RhDNZSgII-00020-00005457-00005900": "technical collaboration etc as sectors", "51RhDNZSgII-00021-00005901-00006095": "of the ministry exists the following", "51RhDNZSgII-00022-00006096-00006498": "institutions pedagogical services office", "51RhDNZSgII-00023-00006500-00006856": "bureau for development of the education", "51RhDNZSgII-00024-00006856-00007117": "authority for development and upgrading", "51RhDNZSgII-00025-00007118-00007384": "the education in the ethnicities tongues", "51RhDNZSgII-00026-00007384-00007769": "national educational Inspectorate equals", "51RhDNZSgII-00027-00007770-00008068": "equals ministers"}}, {"audio_id": "52t4cmWC910", "text": {"52t4cmWC910-00000-00000065-00002580": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00001-00002581-00003148": "[Applause]", "52t4cmWC910-00002-00003149-00003335": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00003-00003336-00003532": "so", "52t4cmWC910-00004-00003533-00004332": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00005-00004333-00007436": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00006-00007437-00007598": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00007-00007600-00008598": "so", "52t4cmWC910-00008-00008599-00009332": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00009-00009333-00012281": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00010-00012282-00012584": "[Applause]", "52t4cmWC910-00011-00012585-00013647": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00012-00013649-00014903": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00013-00014904-00018450": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00014-00018451-00019550": "[Music]", "52t4cmWC910-00015-00019551-00019759": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "52AHholD_rQ", "text": {"52AHholD_rQ-00000-00000000-00000451": "[Music]", "52AHholD_rQ-00001-00000452-00000682": "once you've started the software start", "52AHholD_rQ-00002-00000683-00000914": "by specifying the size of the area on", "52AHholD_rQ-00003-00000915-00001120": "the screen the recommendation is that", "52AHholD_rQ-00004-00001121-00001354": "the size on the screen matches the real", "52AHholD_rQ-00005-00001355-00001574": "size of the item you want to work with", "52AHholD_rQ-00006-00001575-00001796": "if you cut into a piece of plywood that", "52AHholD_rQ-00007-00001797-00002125": "is 50 times 50 centimeters indicate the", "52AHholD_rQ-00008-00002126-00002387": "same size in the program select page", "52AHholD_rQ-00009-00002388-00002632": "settings on the config and specify width", "52AHholD_rQ-00010-00002633-00002932": "and height to 500 millimeters which is", "52AHholD_rQ-00011-00002933-00003415": "equivalent to 50 centimeters the", "52AHholD_rQ-00012-00003417-00003611": "following shows how to engrave and cut", "52AHholD_rQ-00013-00003611-00003904": "start by inserting a rectangle and then", "52AHholD_rQ-00014-00003906-00004142": "the text using the tools in the menu on", "52AHholD_rQ-00015-00004143-00004931": "the left", "52AHholD_rQ-00016-00004932-00005283": "then click on the rectangle lines so", "52AHholD_rQ-00017-00005284-00005522": "they are selected and then choose a", "52AHholD_rQ-00018-00005523-00005838": "color in this example I select blue at", "52AHholD_rQ-00019-00005839-00006168": "the bottom left click on your text so", "52AHholD_rQ-00020-00006169-00006345": "it's highlighted and click on an another", "52AHholD_rQ-00021-00006346-00006593": "color in this example I choose red", "52AHholD_rQ-00022-00006594-00006855": "you've now created two different layers", "52AHholD_rQ-00023-00006856-00007116": "that you can work with in the window in", "52AHholD_rQ-00024-00007117-00007349": "the upper right a click on the blue", "52AHholD_rQ-00025-00007350-00007629": "layer opens a window and here are a few", "52AHholD_rQ-00026-00007630-00007995": "things that you should focus on set", "52AHholD_rQ-00027-00007995-00008459": "speed to 20 power to 35 and remember", "52AHholD_rQ-00028-00008460-00008766": "specify if the laser has to scan or to", "52AHholD_rQ-00029-00008767-00009432": "cut in this case it has to cut now click", "52AHholD_rQ-00030-00009433-00009696": "on the red layer your text to set the", "52AHholD_rQ-00031-00009697-00010041": "laser to engrave here you choose speed", "52AHholD_rQ-00032-00010042-00010443": "300 and power 15 and set the laser to", "52AHholD_rQ-00033-00010444-00010737": "scan see more about settings and", "52AHholD_rQ-00034-00010738-00011113": "materials on our website", "52AHholD_rQ-00035-00011114-00011582": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "52Hv6JgqBBM", "text": {"52Hv6JgqBBM-00000-00000000-00000155": "I guess it's no time for members Davis", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00001-00000156-00000311": "the member from debian Carlton thank you", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00002-00000312-00000590": "very much speaker last year I decided to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00003-00000591-00000776": "adopt a program called girls in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00004-00000777-00001007": "government and leadership for grades 5", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00005-00001008-00001310": "through 8 students in a peon Carlton and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00006-00001311-00001516": "I was able to hold a one-day program at", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00007-00001517-00001705": "my own daughters school victorious at", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00008-00001707-00001907": "Manor Dale public school we talked about", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00009-00001907-00002198": "advocacy and how girls and women can", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00010-00002199-00002429": "have the ability to make change I was", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00011-00002430-00002608": "maced to see the impact it had on so", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00012-00002609-00002926": "many young girls and including my", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00013-00002927-00003107": "daughter's best friend Jaden croucher", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00014-00003108-00003311": "she's 11 years old just had her birthday", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00015-00003311-00003595": "last week she spent Friday evening with", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00016-00003596-00003806": "my family and she decided that she", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00017-00003807-00003983": "wanted to advocate on an issue that", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00018-00003984-00004175": "recently came up across the province and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00019-00004176-00004381": "I know her class is watching right now", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00020-00004382-00004636": "she wrote to the local media and to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00021-00004637-00004841": "myself I'll read you part of her letter", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00022-00004842-00005143": "my name is Jaden I'm here to protest the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00023-00005144-00005390": "10 months of suspension for dr. mahir", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00024-00005391-00005713": "singh recchi I think dr. mahaveer should", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00025-00005714-00005977": "at least get his license revoked forever", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00026-00005978-00006295": "due to his abuse of animals just because", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00027-00006296-00006472": "animals don't have a voice doesn't mean", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00028-00006473-00006701": "they can be abused animals don't have a", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00029-00006702-00006983": "voice so who will speak for them and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00030-00006984-00007198": "Jaden concludes her letter I'm hoping", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00031-00007200-00007342": "that my concern will make it to the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00032-00007343-00007603": "court and they'll rethink their decision", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00033-00007604-00007877": "and everyone can write an email to their", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00034-00007878-00008198": "MPP Jade's brave and she's also very", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00035-00008199-00008453": "sweet and she's willing to be", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00036-00008454-00008649": "interviewed and talk about this issue", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00037-00008650-00008945": "for the next generation and I stand in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00038-00008946-00009113": "this house to say that I'm extremely", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00039-00009114-00009349": "proud of Jaden and all the girls at", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00040-00009350-00009566": "Manor Dale public school who've taken a", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00041-00009567-00010139": "stand for what they believe in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00042-00010140-00010348": "further member states member from", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00043-00010349-00010516": "Toronto Danforth Thank You speaker", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00044-00010517-00010741": "speaker today I will be reintroducing", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00045-00010742-00011020": "Jonathan's law Jonathan's law will make", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00046-00011021-00011227": "it possible for an employee whose child", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00047-00011228-00011449": "has died to have an unpaid leave of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00048-00011450-00011655": "absence for up to fifty two weeks", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00049-00011656-00011908": "currently parents are entitled to a", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00050-00011909-00012106": "leave while a child is critically ill or", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00051-00012107-00012371": "for child dies as a result of a crime", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00052-00012372-00012652": "but when a child dies as a result of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00053-00012653-00012852": "illness or accident the parents supposed", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00054-00012853-00013038": "to be ready to go back to work after 10", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00055-00013039-00013447": "days speaker that does not work the bill", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00056-00013447-00013600": "is named Jonathan's law in tribute to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00057-00013601-00013800": "Jonathan late ow who died of cancer in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00058-00013801-00014257": "2014 he was 16 Jonathan's father Vince", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00059-00014258-00014431": "late Alan his mother s polite how are", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00060-00014432-00014691": "with us today and they spearheaded the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00061-00014693-00014911": "work to pull together this bill I want", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00062-00014912-00015061": "to thank jonathan miles and Meegan", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00063-00015062-00015325": "Ferris miles also bereaved parents of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00064-00015326-00015565": "their young son who worked on this bill", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00065-00015566-00015772": "and Carolyn ball toss who is the chair", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00066-00015772-00015997": "of bereaved families of Ontario and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00067-00015997-00016174": "thank all of them for the work they did", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00068-00016175-00016417": "on background the work they did pull", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00069-00016418-00016644": "together the law and the courage they've", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00070-00016645-00016966": "shown when presenting this issue to the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00071-00016967-00017500": "public Thank You speaker remember from", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00072-00017501-00017815": "back handspring toe mr. speaker two", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00073-00017816-00017989": "weeks ago as I do each year the pleasure", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00074-00017990-00018225": "of attending the 32nd annual the United", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00075-00018226-00018412": "achievers clubs scholarship brand", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00076-00018413-00018650": "recognition awards dinner on September", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00077-00018651-00018862": "1715 recipients were recognized for", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00078-00018863-00019030": "scholarships in Brampton with", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00079-00019031-00019186": "approximately 200 guests in attendance", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00080-00019187-00019417": "the kuna the keynote address was", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00081-00019418-00019612": "delivered by ms Tanya Walker a Law", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00082-00019613-00019771": "Society of Upper Canada bent row and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00083-00019772-00020053": "lawyer the United achievers club was", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00084-00020054-00020269": "established in Brampton in 1980 and gave", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00085-00020270-00020518": "its first scholarship in 1985 this", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00086-00020519-00020680": "year's scholarship recipients recognized", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00087-00020681-00020830": "at the dinner were shanita Anderson", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00088-00020831-00021121": "kamina Carter hey Anna Crawford Matthews", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00089-00021122-00021424": "Vashti Darko Jordan grey Sydney huset", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00090-00021425-00021694": "Brunell Manning just jalesa Martin", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00091-00021695-00021956": "Benjamin McDonald Justin Mackenzie", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00092-00021957-00022297": "achacha whoo Caitlyn pert Danny", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00093-00022298-00022540": "pellington Sanjeev Prasad could and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00094-00022541-00022722": "Katrina Phillips recognized for", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00095-00022723-00022939": "outstanding service to the community for", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00096-00022940-00023086": "all of the free-for-all foundation", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00097-00023087-00023378": "United she was seniors group and John", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00098-00023379-00023581": "cockburn a past president of the Kiwanis", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00099-00023582-00023767": "Club of Brampton and an active member", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00100-00023768-00023980": "for more than 50 years Thank You mr.", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00101-00023981-00024692": "speaker London Thank You speaker speaker", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00102-00024693-00024875": "I'm pleased to rise today to acknowledge", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00103-00024876-00025108": "breast cancer awareness month breast", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00104-00025109-00025261": "cancer is the most common cancer among", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00105-00025262-00025466": "canadian women mrs. second leading cause", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00106-00025467-00025889": "of death is estimated that 2015 25,000", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00107-00025889-00026020": "women were diagnosed with breast cancer", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00108-00026022-00026337": "among those 25,000 cancer diagnosis", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00109-00026338-00026539": "5,000 women died a result of this", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00110-00026541-00026818": "disease breast cancer occurs most", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00111-00026819-00027052": "frequently women between ages of 15 69", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00112-00027053-00027317": "although it can occur at any age breast", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00113-00027318-00027623": "cancer is not gender-specific in 2015", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00114-00027624-00027836": "220 men were diagnosed with the disease", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00115-00027837-00028130": "and 60 died as a result is important to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00116-00028131-00028283": "be mindful of the signs and symptoms of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00117-00028283-00028427": "breast cancer which include a lump in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00118-00028427-00028649": "the breast or armpit changes in the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00119-00028650-00028924": "breast shape size or skin changes some", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00120-00028925-00029120": "risk factors may include family history", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00121-00029120-00029330": "exposure to ionizing radiation oral", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00122-00029331-00029515": "contraceptives alcohol or high", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00123-00029516-00029758": "socioeconomic status breast cancer", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00124-00029759-00029936": "screenings available and recommended for", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00125-00029937-00030190": "women between the ages of 50 and 69 it's", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00126-00030191-00030332": "also recommended that women within this", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00127-00030333-00030548": "age drain receive a mammogram every two", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00128-00030549-00030725": "years mr. speaker I'd like to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00129-00030726-00030883": "acknowledge and thank John Baines and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00130-00030884-00031100": "his daughter Kelly from my writing each", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00131-00031101-00031262": "year they organize bowling for boobs &", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00132-00031263-00031412": "st. Thomas for years they've been", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00133-00031413-00031589": "fundraising and raising awareness around", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00134-00031589-00031814": "breast cancer mr. speaker the Canadian", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00135-00031814-00031931": "Cancer Society has also created", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00136-00031932-00032120": "wonderful support program and funding", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00137-00032120-00032273": "initiative called the women to women", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00138-00032274-00032527": "movement it creates ambassadors that", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00139-00032528-00032695": "empowers women to educate other women", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00140-00032697-00032849": "about breast cancer screening and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00141-00032850-00033050": "raising funds at the same time mr.", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00142-00033051-00033170": "speaker is October is Breast Cancer", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00143-00033171-00033335": "Awareness Month I encourage all", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00144-00033336-00033439": "Ontarians get involved with the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00145-00033440-00033581": "community to raise awareness regarding", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00146-00033582-00034036": "this terrible disease thank you", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00147-00034037-00034250": "primarily for a molten thank you very", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00148-00034251-00034442": "much mr. speaker mr. speaker today is", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00149-00034443-00034664": "World Architecture day and I want to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00150-00034665-00034820": "thank the Ontario Association of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00151-00034821-00035027": "architects are hosting a breakfast this", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00152-00035028-00035236": "morning at the legislative dining room", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00153-00035237-00035638": "world architecture day was founded to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00154-00035639-00035960": "remind were the world of the importance", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00155-00035961-00036155": "of architects for building cities of the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00156-00036156-00036380": "future and it's important to acknowledge", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00157-00036381-00036584": "that moving forward there are certain", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00158-00036585-00036788": "principles that we will need to rely on", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00159-00036789-00037031": "architects to ensure that our cities are", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00160-00037032-00037214": "more sustainable are built in a way", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00161-00037215-00037424": "that's environmentally friendly and are", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00162-00037425-00037568": "built in ways that work with the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00163-00037569-00037700": "environments that they are built in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00164-00037701-00037892": "there's also an ever increasing", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00165-00037893-00038063": "importance of ensuring their architects", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00166-00038064-00038303": "continue to build more affordable", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00167-00038304-00038552": "housing as well as create density and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00168-00038553-00038786": "effective ways by myself and working", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00169-00038787-00038981": "with an architect on a project that's", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00170-00038982-00039146": "near and dear to me which is my home and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00171-00039147-00039398": "in the members gallery I would like to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00172-00039399-00039545": "introduce all of our dang who's my", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00173-00039546-00039785": "architect thank you very much and a", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00174-00039786-00040081": "special shout out to Canucks designers", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00175-00040082-00040319": "Sarah and Lindsay who are the design", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00176-00040320-00040571": "team it is extremely important for us to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00177-00040572-00040703": "acknowledge the great work of many", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00178-00040704-00040880": "people our society to make our societies", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00179-00040881-00041006": "better but I think it's particularly", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00180-00041007-00041150": "important given the direction we're", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00181-00041151-00041315": "headed in a society to acknowledge the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00182-00041316-00041519": "work of architects to do what they are", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00183-00041520-00041654": "attached to do under the architect that", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00184-00041655-00041891": "to promote public appreciation of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00185-00041892-00042065": "architecture and the Allied Arts and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00186-00042066-00042221": "Sciences and to ensure that we build", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00187-00042222-00042455": "cities that are based on buildings and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00188-00042456-00042641": "houses that are sustainable and that", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00189-00042642-00043069": "lead the way thank you so much thank you", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00190-00043070-00043363": "make sure Thank You mr. speaker and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00191-00043364-00043636": "indeed today is World Architecture day", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00192-00043637-00043993": "the first Monday of October of each year", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00193-00043994-00044191": "has been deemed to be this very", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00194-00044192-00044590": "important day when we do consider the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00195-00044591-00044884": "contributions made to our communities to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00196-00044885-00045130": "our cities to our daily lives by", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00197-00045131-00045421": "architects mr. speaker what drew me to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00198-00045422-00045625": "study architecture into that profession", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00199-00045626-00045958": "was the ability to help improve our", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00200-00045959-00046381": "community and improve my neighbors lives", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00201-00046382-00046618": "and architects throughout this province", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00202-00046619-00047008": "are collaborators artists and ultimately", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00203-00047009-00047299": "problem solvers solving the problems of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00204-00047300-00047491": "how to make our communities or cities", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00205-00047492-00047863": "more livable how to make our grand", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00206-00047864-00048318": "places and our more humble places viable", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00207-00048319-00048606": "pleasant to live in pleasant to work in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00208-00048607-00048961": "mr. speaker World Architecture day is", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00209-00048962-00049159": "important because it focuses our", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00210-00049160-00049402": "everyone's attention on what are some", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00211-00049403-00049801": "core human needs of shelter of community", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00212-00049802-00050151": "of space that is livable that is", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00213-00050152-00050395": "inspiring and that helps us achieve", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00214-00050396-00050740": "those things we aspire to so mr. speaker", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00215-00050741-00051025": "today we're very grateful to the Ontario", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00216-00051026-00051267": "Association of architects it's president", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00217-00051269-00051520": "tune Driessen who's here to inform us", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00218-00051521-00051754": "about these issues and today mr. speaker", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00219-00051754-00052045": "it's important that all NPP's recognize", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00220-00052046-00052607": "that architecture matters thank you", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00221-00052608-00052775": "the member from Lambton Kent", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00222-00052776-00052959": "middle-sized Thank You mr. speaker I'm", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00223-00052960-00053136": "pleased today to have the opportunity to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00224-00053137-00053330": "recognize your great work being done by", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00225-00053331-00053525": "junior achievement in my writing of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00226-00053526-00053687": "Lambton Kent Middlesex and right across", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00227-00053688-00053979": "Ontario Junior Achievement is a largest", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00228-00053979-00054222": "youth business education organization in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00229-00054223-00054455": "Canada and for over 60 years they've", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00230-00054456-00054678": "been preparing young people to succeed I", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00231-00054679-00054917": "was fortunate enough to participate in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00232-00054918-00055055": "junior achievement when I was in high", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00233-00055056-00055236": "school so I can personally appreciate", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00234-00055237-00055448": "the impact of their work and how they", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00235-00055449-00055718": "can inspire young entrepreneurs today", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00236-00055719-00055856": "thousands of dedicated volunteers", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00237-00055857-00056087": "continue to deliver financial literacy", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00238-00056088-00056304": "work readiness in entrepreneurship", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00239-00056304-00056507": "programs that give students the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00240-00056508-00056666": "knowledge and confidence to meet the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00241-00056667-00056888": "personal and professional challenges of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00242-00056889-00057165": "their future the interior OPC caucus", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00243-00057166-00057366": "recognizes that financial literacy is", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00244-00057366-00057621": "critical we applaud junior achievement's", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00245-00057622-00057773": "work to give the development of these", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00246-00057774-00058041": "vital real life skills such as budgeting", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00247-00058041-00058284": "and investing a greater presence in our", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00248-00058285-00058572": "public education system with the recent", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00249-00058573-00058785": "revelation that half of Ontario's grade", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00250-00058786-00058991": "6 students are failing to meet the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00251-00058992-00059154": "provincial standards for math and the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00252-00059154-00059366": "news that household and government debt", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00253-00059367-00059547": "have reached all-time highs in our", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00254-00059548-00059786": "province financial literacy is clearly", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00255-00059787-00060137": "more important than ever Mr Speaker I", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00256-00060138-00060329": "want to encourage all students and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00257-00060330-00060522": "parents to explore the opportunities", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00258-00060523-00060822": "offered by junior achievement as well as", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00259-00060823-00061007": "to commend the businesses and thousands", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00260-00061008-00061209": "of volunteers who make these educational", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00261-00061210-00061503": "opportunities possible thank you thank", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00262-00061504-00061740": "you for your members statements the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00263-00061741-00062030": "member from nickel Milton people", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00264-00062031-00062201": "district school board announced that", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00265-00062202-00062397": "significant decline and provincial", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00266-00062398-00062628": "funding has trigger accommodation", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00267-00062629-00062867": "reviews for many of their schools but", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00268-00062868-00063062": "does that mean for my writing where in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00269-00063063-00063251": "the valley they will move kids from", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00270-00063252-00063429": "Grade seven and eight from one school to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00271-00063429-00063787": "a school further away they will provide", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00272-00063788-00064094": "and that's for the seven and eight the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00273-00064095-00064505": "other ones the juniors 25 will be moved", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00274-00064506-00064761": "into another school what does that mean", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00275-00064762-00064961": "for the people in jamesburg well the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00276-00064962-00065172": "chance for transferred high school would", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00277-00065173-00065379": "be closed the kids would be bussed", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00278-00065379-00065660": "either to Val Caron or to a school", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00279-00065661-00065915": "in Sudbury then the kids from", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00280-00065916-00066203": "transferred from dowling from on ping", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00281-00066204-00066503": "from levac would all be bused to the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00282-00066504-00066941": "empty secondary school in gems furred", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00283-00066942-00067253": "for little kids aged 4 and 5 that go", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00284-00067254-00067456": "from ginebra leak in my writing to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00285-00067457-00067657": "chance heard that means they will spend", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00286-00067658-00067925": "more time in the bus than in the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00287-00067926-00068182": "classroom in the Western of my writings", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00288-00068183-00068444": "the news is no better they are planning", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00289-00068445-00068771": "to close the lively high school all of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00290-00068772-00069001": "the kids from lively will be bussed you", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00291-00069002-00069323": "guessed it to schools in Sudbury and the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00292-00069324-00069530": "seven and eight would be moved into the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00293-00069531-00069779": "already tight for space Walden public", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00294-00069780-00069959": "school I've seen this movie before", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00295-00069960-00070217": "speaker and it always worked the same", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00296-00070218-00070529": "way kids in rural school in nickel Bell", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00297-00070530-00070825": "get bus to big urban school in Sudbury", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00298-00070826-00071054": "you know what that means that means that", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00299-00071055-00071378": "the school is there to teach kids but", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00300-00071379-00071504": "it's theirs to build healthy communities", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00301-00071505-00071744": "and we're losing all of that thank you", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00302-00071745-00072072": "thank you", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00303-00072073-00072312": "remember from Huntington marks Thank You", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00304-00072313-00072500": "speaker today a monitor commemorate Rosh", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00305-00072501-00072867": "Hashanah a very important High Holy Day", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00306-00072868-00073151": "for members of the Jewish community all", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00307-00073152-00073386": "over Ontario and in my riding back in", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00308-00073387-00073704": "Lawrence and all over the world as", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00309-00073705-00073856": "members of the Jewish faith come", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00310-00073857-00074012": "together to celebrate Rosh Hashanah", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00311-00074013-00074211": "marking a time of year in their lives to", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00312-00074212-00074493": "reflect on the year ahead this past", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00313-00074494-00074712": "Sunday evening marked the first day of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00314-00074713-00074912": "rosh hashanah translated as the head of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00315-00074913-00075174": "the year also means the jewish new year", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00316-00075175-00075459": "and is one of the High Holy Day holidays", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00317-00075460-00075699": "on this day Jews are called to examine", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00318-00075700-00076056": "their lives focus on pendants and plan", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00319-00076057-00076431": "for the new year some of the observances", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00320-00076432-00076617": "during rosh hashanah include blowing the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00321-00076618-00076965": "shofar a hollowed-out ram's horn blowing", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00322-00076966-00077178": "of the shofar is meant to wake up the", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00323-00077179-00077438": "soul and motivate repentance during rosh", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00324-00077439-00077760": "hashanah eating sweet foods like apple", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00325-00077761-00078017": "dipped in honey pomegranates holla", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00326-00078018-00078257": "symbolizing the hope for a sweet new", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00327-00078258-00078537": "year and a special prayer is recited", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00328-00078538-00078834": "thereafter may it be thy will the Lord", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00329-00078835-00079094": "our God to grant us a year that is good", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00330-00079095-00079490": "and is sweet and I wish to wish all of", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00331-00079491-00079874": "the Jews in my community a sweet and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00332-00079875-00080115": "happy and healthy new year and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00333-00080116-00080366": "especially to my good friend Mel corn", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00334-00080367-00080829": "who had a bicycle accident yesterday and", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00335-00080830-00081030": "was taken to Humber River Hospital but", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00336-00081031-00081285": "is doing fine so I want to wish", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00337-00081286-00081603": "everybody shana tova umetukah to all my", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00338-00081604-00081834": "friends in my community thank you thank", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00339-00081835-00082169": "you i Tanko members for their statements", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00340-00082170-00082513": "it's now time for reports by committee's", "52Hv6JgqBBM-00341-00082514-00082883": "report spine committee"}}, {"audio_id": "52NTKu2MK5I", "text": {"52NTKu2MK5I-00000-00000194-00000503": "bless you bless you bless you in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00001-00000504-00000749": "mighty name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth", "52NTKu2MK5I-00002-00000750-00001108": "my name is Apostle Peter Daniel by the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00003-00001109-00001439": "grace of God you are worship me in Life", "52NTKu2MK5I-00004-00001440-00001775": "program Heaven and Hell the one we used", "52NTKu2MK5I-00005-00001776-00002051": "to do every Monday to Friday Monday to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00006-00002052-00002399": "Friday Monday to Friday from 9 A.M", "52NTKu2MK5I-00007-00002400-00003047": "to 10 30 a.m ah Nigeria time by the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00008-00003048-00003281": "special grace of God we are going to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00009-00003282-00003863": "speak deeply about what uh is uh what", "52NTKu2MK5I-00010-00003864-00004138": "the Lord is saying uh about some things", "52NTKu2MK5I-00011-00004139-00004354": "in the family so the Lord will help us", "52NTKu2MK5I-00012-00004355-00004553": "in the mighty name of Jesus Christ of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00013-00004554-00004895": "Nazareth please let us pray father in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00014-00004896-00005309": "the name of Jesus father in the name of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00015-00005310-00005706": "Jesus father is the mighty name of Jesus", "52NTKu2MK5I-00016-00005707-00006004": "internal Rock of Aging we bless your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00017-00006005-00006293": "name we give you the glory honor power", "52NTKu2MK5I-00018-00006294-00006550": "like Majesty we want to thank you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00019-00006551-00006809": "because you have never Faith us for once", "52NTKu2MK5I-00020-00006809-00007055": "you have never disappointed us you have", "52NTKu2MK5I-00021-00007056-00007360": "been faithful forever more in the name", "52NTKu2MK5I-00022-00007361-00007775": "of Jesus our lord and our savior Our", "52NTKu2MK5I-00023-00007776-00008134": "Redeemer we pray this uh money we ask", "52NTKu2MK5I-00024-00008136-00008489": "you Jesus Christ to fill our art with", "52NTKu2MK5I-00025-00008490-00008771": "your present to fill our heart with your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00026-00008772-00009046": "understanding to open our eyes to see", "52NTKu2MK5I-00027-00009047-00009299": "your God to open our eyes to see the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00028-00009300-00009539": "things of the spirit thank you Father", "52NTKu2MK5I-00029-00009540-00009863": "because you have answered our prayers in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00030-00009864-00010421": "Jesus mighty name we pray amen", "52NTKu2MK5I-00031-00010422-00010637": "the Lord bless you in the mighty name of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00032-00010638-00010853": "Jesus Christ of Nazareth", "52NTKu2MK5I-00033-00010854-00011038": "are there are some things you want to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00034-00011039-00011249": "talk about this money by the grace of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00035-00011250-00011333": "God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00036-00011334-00011524": "we want to speak", "52NTKu2MK5I-00037-00011525-00012017": "on the matter of marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-00038-00012018-00012299": "there are some error that is going on in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00039-00012300-00012551": "marriage that God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00040-00012552-00012778": "is angry about", "52NTKu2MK5I-00041-00012779-00013007": "if you have not married this is for you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00042-00013008-00013247": "whether you are married or you are not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00043-00013247-00013379": "married", "52NTKu2MK5I-00044-00013380-00013474": "it is for you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00045-00013475-00013594": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00046-00013595-00013853": "it is two things because it has it is an", "52NTKu2MK5I-00047-00013854-00014219": "error that is why you keep on seeing um", "52NTKu2MK5I-00048-00014219-00014585": "uh broken home everywhere you keep on", "52NTKu2MK5I-00049-00014586-00014986": "seeing problems and Satan is be able to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00050-00014987-00015221": "penetrate into the marriage of the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00051-00015222-00015503": "Christian the Saints because of this", "52NTKu2MK5I-00052-00015504-00015803": "error that is going on right all over", "52NTKu2MK5I-00053-00015804-00015971": "the world", "52NTKu2MK5I-00054-00015972-00016307": "I prayed the Lord God will help us in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00055-00016308-00016649": "the mighty name of Jesus Christ", "52NTKu2MK5I-00056-00016650-00016871": "one of the things that God I want to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00057-00016872-00017158": "talk about right now is the issue of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00058-00017159-00017353": "women in the house", "52NTKu2MK5I-00059-00017354-00017629": "God is angrily", "52NTKu2MK5I-00060-00017630-00018071": "ah is angry with a woman of nades", "52NTKu2MK5I-00061-00018072-00018299": "because of the way they treat their", "52NTKu2MK5I-00062-00018300-00018544": "husband the way they related to their", "52NTKu2MK5I-00063-00018545-00018715": "husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00064-00018716-00019067": "many US banned who has not planned to be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00065-00019068-00019343": "a boxer has become a boxer", "52NTKu2MK5I-00066-00019344-00019619": "many man who has not planned to be a bad", "52NTKu2MK5I-00067-00019620-00019877": "person has become a bad person because", "52NTKu2MK5I-00068-00019878-00020136": "of the way the wife treat their husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00069-00020137-00020429": "because of the way the wife take their", "52NTKu2MK5I-00070-00020430-00020644": "husband they have pushed them to the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00071-00020645-00020957": "left whereby they have no choice than to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00072-00020958-00021299": "make their wife a punching bag", "52NTKu2MK5I-00073-00021300-00021677": "so God himself is not happy with that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00074-00021678-00022067": "don't forget that God is the uh uh is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00075-00022068-00022361": "the one that formed marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-00076-00022362-00022685": "is the one that constitute marriage so", "52NTKu2MK5I-00077-00022686-00022883": "it's always interested in marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-00078-00022884-00023200": "whether you wanted to marry or you are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00079-00023201-00023471": "already in marriage is always interested", "52NTKu2MK5I-00080-00023472-00023753": "in marriage you want to know he want to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00081-00023754-00023939": "know he want to know what is going there", "52NTKu2MK5I-00082-00023940-00024205": "so he's always interested", "52NTKu2MK5I-00083-00024206-00024517": "especially in the believer's marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-00084-00024518-00024833": "believer believer marriage he is always", "52NTKu2MK5I-00085-00024834-00025147": "interested in hearing it to be there", "52NTKu2MK5I-00086-00025148-00025433": "so if you have your home like this and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00087-00025434-00025594": "you have your home you have your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00088-00025595-00025775": "you have your children and you not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00089-00025776-00025943": "believe that you are the controller of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00090-00025944-00026225": "everybody nobody can say anything I'm", "52NTKu2MK5I-00091-00026226-00026393": "telling you are a liar", "52NTKu2MK5I-00092-00026394-00026711": "because after you remember there's e who", "52NTKu2MK5I-00093-00026712-00026914": "constitute that marriage he is going to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00094-00026916-00027083": "judge you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00095-00027083-00027299": "so I'm going to talk on the side of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00096-00027300-00027479": "women and I'm going to talk on the side", "52NTKu2MK5I-00097-00027480-00027683": "of husband and I'm going to talk on the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00098-00027683-00027952": "side of sexual intercourse", "52NTKu2MK5I-00099-00027954-00028235": "another mistakes mistake that is going", "52NTKu2MK5I-00100-00028236-00028535": "on in the home", "52NTKu2MK5I-00101-00028536-00028739": "one of the things that God talked about", "52NTKu2MK5I-00102-00028739-00029068": "marriage yeah is that he said women", "52NTKu2MK5I-00103-00029069-00029290": "should be submitted", "52NTKu2MK5I-00104-00029291-00029537": "this is the point of the offer he said", "52NTKu2MK5I-00105-00029538-00029783": "my husband is a wicked man my husband is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00106-00029783-00029993": "a this and this is not listening to me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00107-00029994-00030202": "it's not this and that the truth of the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00108-00030204-00030443": "fact is this if you are able to respect", "52NTKu2MK5I-00109-00030444-00030712": "your husband if you are able to submit", "52NTKu2MK5I-00110-00030713-00031007": "your husband your own will be settled", "52NTKu2MK5I-00111-00031008-00031318": "but if you are not submissive your home", "52NTKu2MK5I-00112-00031319-00031516": "can never be searched", "52NTKu2MK5I-00113-00031517-00031805": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00114-00031806-00031967": "Hallelujah", "52NTKu2MK5I-00115-00031968-00032212": "let us look at Ephesians chapter 5 and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00116-00032213-00032537": "see what God is saying about marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-00117-00032538-00032957": "Ephesians chapter 5.", "52NTKu2MK5I-00118-00032958-00033245": "verses 22.", "52NTKu2MK5I-00119-00033246-00033545": "listen he said wife submit yourself", "52NTKu2MK5I-00120-00033546-00033989": "until your own husband as unto the Lord", "52NTKu2MK5I-00121-00033990-00034301": "for the the husband is the end of the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00122-00034302-00034696": "wife even as the Christ is the head of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00123-00034697-00035027": "the church and he is the savior of the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00124-00035028-00035167": "body", "52NTKu2MK5I-00125-00035168-00035471": "now go compare my", "52NTKu2MK5I-00126-00035472-00035773": "to women as", "52NTKu2MK5I-00127-00035774-00036083": "Jesus Christ to the touch", "52NTKu2MK5I-00128-00036084-00036317": "you know one thing now", "52NTKu2MK5I-00129-00036318-00036593": "you already know that nobody can disobey", "52NTKu2MK5I-00130-00036594-00036773": "Jesus Christ Our Lord", "52NTKu2MK5I-00131-00036774-00037031": "if he asks you to go to Lagos today or", "52NTKu2MK5I-00132-00037032-00037271": "if he asks you to go to U.S today and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00133-00037272-00037540": "you are in Nigeria for example and you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00134-00037541-00037702": "are telling him that you cannot go you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00135-00037703-00038002": "know in the process you can get punished", "52NTKu2MK5I-00136-00038003-00038237": "in the process if you die you are going", "52NTKu2MK5I-00137-00038238-00038459": "to have for Disobedience for the act of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00138-00038460-00038640": "disobedience", "52NTKu2MK5I-00139-00038641-00038939": "the gravity of God taking a man", "52NTKu2MK5I-00140-00038940-00039215": "disobeying God is the same gravity he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00141-00039216-00039418": "took for a wife who is disobeying his", "52NTKu2MK5I-00142-00039419-00039724": "husband her husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00143-00039725-00040133": "if God can charge anybody with a child", "52NTKu2MK5I-00144-00040134-00040385": "of sin that you disobey my commandment", "52NTKu2MK5I-00145-00040386-00040589": "for that you are going to have the same", "52NTKu2MK5I-00146-00040590-00041015": "way God can send anybody to Hell on the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00147-00041016-00041269": "touch of you disobeying your husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00148-00041270-00041509": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00149-00041510-00041746": "and do you not know the problem of the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00150-00041747-00041855": "whole matter", "52NTKu2MK5I-00151-00041856-00042089": "if you and your husband is talking about", "52NTKu2MK5I-00152-00042090-00042299": "something and your husband said I want", "52NTKu2MK5I-00153-00042300-00042461": "you to do this thing", "52NTKu2MK5I-00154-00042462-00042737": "and you insist that you are not going to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00155-00042738-00042893": "do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00156-00042894-00043151": "or let's say that you insist that what", "52NTKu2MK5I-00157-00043152-00043312": "your husband say you should do is not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00158-00043313-00043451": "the right way", "52NTKu2MK5I-00159-00043452-00043685": "but your husband insist he said do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00160-00043686-00043805": "this way", "52NTKu2MK5I-00161-00043806-00044008": "but you as insisting that it's not the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00162-00044009-00044135": "right way", "52NTKu2MK5I-00163-00044136-00044399": "now and then finally your husband keep", "52NTKu2MK5I-00164-00044400-00044561": "quiet he didn't talk anymore", "52NTKu2MK5I-00165-00044562-00044812": "this thing is commonly happening in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00166-00044813-00045077": "Christian home because the husband does", "52NTKu2MK5I-00167-00045078-00045280": "not want problem if he's the husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00168-00045281-00045467": "that is much stronger in the Lord or the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00169-00045468-00045646": "wife that is mostly like the law because", "52NTKu2MK5I-00170-00045647-00045917": "he's surely open I'm talking about woman", "52NTKu2MK5I-00171-00045918-00046229": "now to man now so if the man the husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00172-00046230-00046517": "that keep quiet for you and because she", "52NTKu2MK5I-00173-00046518-00046667": "is keep quiet you will not believe that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00174-00046668-00046901": "he has accepted what you said", "52NTKu2MK5I-00175-00046902-00047074": "you know it's normal when you must be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00176-00047075-00047212": "quiet if you do things that he has", "52NTKu2MK5I-00177-00047213-00047417": "accepted what you said so you now go", "52NTKu2MK5I-00178-00047418-00047617": "ahead with your own personal plan plan", "52NTKu2MK5I-00179-00047618-00047951": "God not doing your husband plan if you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00180-00047952-00048185": "die that day you are going to help", "52NTKu2MK5I-00181-00048186-00048455": "because your husband did not agree with", "52NTKu2MK5I-00182-00048456-00048701": "him so to Angel who is writing it he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00183-00048702-00049043": "will write it as a disobedient wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00184-00049044-00049349": "which can take you to hell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00185-00049350-00049702": "God doesn't God doesn't he doesn't he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00186-00049703-00049979": "doesn't have uh how should I call it it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00187-00049980-00050380": "doesn't have options for disobedience", "52NTKu2MK5I-00188-00050381-00050596": "this is the point the angel of the Lord", "52NTKu2MK5I-00189-00050597-00050843": "spoke to Lord and his wife he said go do", "52NTKu2MK5I-00190-00050844-00050968": "not look back", "52NTKu2MK5I-00191-00050969-00051190": "that's the instructions", "52NTKu2MK5I-00192-00051191-00051664": "go wrong to that Monty do not look back", "52NTKu2MK5I-00193-00051665-00051940": "and why they were running the wife of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00194-00051941-00052157": "lot looked back just to people because", "52NTKu2MK5I-00195-00052158-00052349": "he was seeing the way the fact was", "52NTKu2MK5I-00196-00052350-00052516": "coming he was singing from the front it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00197-00052517-00052804": "was like and he's coming to our city he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00198-00052805-00053050": "said let me just look at it small I will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00199-00053051-00053285": "not look it much just more and by", "52NTKu2MK5I-00200-00053286-00053500": "looking at it tomorrow it become a short", "52NTKu2MK5I-00201-00053501-00053759": "people have shot", "52NTKu2MK5I-00202-00053760-00054088": "now it's just a small Disobedience it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00203-00054089-00054232": "doesn't matter whether it is a big", "52NTKu2MK5I-00204-00054233-00054526": "Disobedience or is it just a little", "52NTKu2MK5I-00205-00054527-00054754": "disobedience is enough to destroy your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00206-00054755-00054988": "life as a woman as a wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00207-00054989-00055204": "a small one", "52NTKu2MK5I-00208-00055205-00055444": "the husband tell you I want to eat candy", "52NTKu2MK5I-00209-00055445-00055654": "yeah you are saying that you wanted to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00210-00055655-00055835": "reach Attack Base", "52NTKu2MK5I-00211-00055836-00056135": "and the husband insist he said cook me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00212-00056136-00056435": "Panda yeah you say that uh you know", "52NTKu2MK5I-00213-00056436-00056687": "yummy for you to be me good night you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00214-00056688-00056938": "know the people have slept uh so if I", "52NTKu2MK5I-00215-00056939-00057185": "find you to know that uh people we uh", "52NTKu2MK5I-00216-00057186-00057400": "people will hear it and it can be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00217-00057401-00057557": "disturbing them while they are sleeping", "52NTKu2MK5I-00218-00057558-00057713": "and they also keep quiet and start", "52NTKu2MK5I-00219-00057714-00057929": "looking at you in that night you went", "52NTKu2MK5I-00220-00057929-00058144": "back to Christ Our Beast if you died", "52NTKu2MK5I-00221-00058145-00058379": "that night God will not say to me it's a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00222-00058379-00058679": "smarty no the issue of Heaven is not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00223-00058679-00059179": "there's nothing like it's a small thing", "52NTKu2MK5I-00224-00059179-00059519": "let's Overlook it no", "52NTKu2MK5I-00225-00059520-00059850": "everything is a sin", "52NTKu2MK5I-00226-00059851-00060161": "immediately if you die you are going to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00227-00060162-00060394": "hell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00228-00060395-00060730": "if you died you are going to hell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00229-00060732-00060953": "it is just sometimes you and your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00230-00060954-00061175": "husband can be making a joke", "52NTKu2MK5I-00231-00061176-00061559": "and on on Sunday or you know in just in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00232-00061560-00061775": "a particular point he can say that he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00233-00061776-00062032": "said they are yeah you want to wear this", "52NTKu2MK5I-00234-00062033-00062309": "clothes to me I wish you wear this one", "52NTKu2MK5I-00235-00062310-00062626": "me I'm telling you where this one", "52NTKu2MK5I-00236-00062627-00062861": "and they said no no no he said that is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00237-00062862-00062963": "what I want", "52NTKu2MK5I-00238-00062964-00063119": "wear this color", "52NTKu2MK5I-00239-00063120-00063329": "and you say I'm the one that wants to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00240-00063329-00063635": "wear it is my body so because of that me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00241-00063636-00063850": "I wish you are telling me to wear white", "52NTKu2MK5I-00242-00063851-00064019": "me I want to wear blue", "52NTKu2MK5I-00243-00064020-00064313": "and therefore okay no problem", "52NTKu2MK5I-00244-00064314-00064594": "in as much the husband did not agree", "52NTKu2MK5I-00245-00064595-00064949": "with your your idea is for you to go", "52NTKu2MK5I-00246-00064950-00065200": "back and do what they want you to do you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00247-00065201-00065375": "might say that well this team doesn't", "52NTKu2MK5I-00248-00065376-00065647": "matter if it's ordinary clothes", "52NTKu2MK5I-00249-00065648-00066100": "you forget you are under a man", "52NTKu2MK5I-00250-00066101-00066341": "you are no more your head you have a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00251-00066342-00066623": "head in your head so once you it should", "52NTKu2MK5I-00252-00066624-00066815": "be eat you might say it doesn't matter", "52NTKu2MK5I-00253-00066816-00067025": "you might say this is monthly you might", "52NTKu2MK5I-00254-00067026-00067288": "say you need to have to consider now", "52NTKu2MK5I-00255-00067289-00067499": "but the truth is that when you die you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00256-00067500-00067625": "are going to help", "52NTKu2MK5I-00257-00067626-00067961": "he said just as they did you say just as", "52NTKu2MK5I-00258-00067962-00068303": "Christ is the head of the church", "52NTKu2MK5I-00259-00068304-00068537": "imagine the holy spirit is telling you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00260-00068538-00068669": "pass this way you are passing of that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00261-00068670-00068849": "direction how will you be feeling your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00262-00068850-00069088": "conscience will not rest", "52NTKu2MK5I-00263-00069089-00069406": "you might nothing might happen there", "52NTKu2MK5I-00264-00069407-00069569": "might be nothing that happened there but", "52NTKu2MK5I-00265-00069570-00069694": "God purple person I want you to pass", "52NTKu2MK5I-00266-00069695-00069917": "that probably there is a particular", "52NTKu2MK5I-00267-00069918-00070187": "reason to him that you did not know", "52NTKu2MK5I-00268-00070188-00070403": "and you did not pass there if you pass", "52NTKu2MK5I-00269-00070404-00070600": "another Direction number one you get", "52NTKu2MK5I-00270-00070601-00070781": "your punishment number two your your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00271-00070782-00071044": "conscience will not leave you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00272-00071045-00071243": "you must say but I'm the one I want to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00273-00071244-00071435": "go I feel like going shortcut I feel", "52NTKu2MK5I-00274-00071436-00071644": "like going wrong way even as much you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00275-00071645-00071909": "God cries is the end of the church you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00276-00071910-00072253": "as a Christian you ought to obey", "52NTKu2MK5I-00277-00072254-00072623": "to be and to give your full attentions", "52NTKu2MK5I-00278-00072624-00072863": "to every instructions", "52NTKu2MK5I-00279-00072864-00073025": "he says", "52NTKu2MK5I-00280-00073026-00073217": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00281-00073218-00073553": "number two this is commonly done in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00282-00073554-00073781": "in the Christian home which the Lord is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00283-00073782-00074213": "telling me now that as you also tell you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00284-00074214-00074525": "it happened very well in sense of where", "52NTKu2MK5I-00285-00074526-00074776": "the wife is very tired", "52NTKu2MK5I-00286-00074777-00075076": "and the husband is asking for sexual", "52NTKu2MK5I-00287-00075077-00075317": "intercourse", "52NTKu2MK5I-00288-00075318-00075581": "he said I will let us have intercourse", "52NTKu2MK5I-00289-00075582-00075832": "you know I'm very very tired we will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00290-00075833-00075959": "have it tomorrow", "52NTKu2MK5I-00291-00075960-00076247": "because I said are you sixth you see", "52NTKu2MK5I-00292-00076248-00076456": "there's a problem when a man is saying I", "52NTKu2MK5I-00293-00076457-00076675": "exist", "52NTKu2MK5I-00294-00076676-00077123": "you have to obey it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00295-00077124-00077411": "that number two thing is that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00296-00077412-00077806": "and I said Hey sir what if I'm sick if", "52NTKu2MK5I-00297-00077807-00077999": "your sickness is something that you can", "52NTKu2MK5I-00298-00078000-00078167": "still walk around", "52NTKu2MK5I-00299-00078168-00078341": "it's something that is not talkable", "52NTKu2MK5I-00300-00078342-00078449": "because there's some secret that you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00301-00078450-00078665": "just it's like headache like all those", "52NTKu2MK5I-00302-00078666-00078994": "musliment sickness God requires you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00303-00078995-00079450": "she give your husband sex", "52NTKu2MK5I-00304-00079451-00079667": "don't forget we are talking about", "52NTKu2MK5I-00305-00079668-00079931": "marriage here marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-00306-00079932-00080185": "number one I talk about full obedience", "52NTKu2MK5I-00307-00080186-00080525": "women are to give their husband full", "52NTKu2MK5I-00308-00080526-00080644": "obedience", "52NTKu2MK5I-00309-00080645-00080915": "it's not even proper for you it can if", "52NTKu2MK5I-00310-00080916-00081221": "we say Act of a heart of arrogance when", "52NTKu2MK5I-00311-00081222-00081509": "your husband said do this thing", "52NTKu2MK5I-00312-00081510-00081719": "and you are saying sir do let us do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00313-00081720-00081935": "it's a arrogant", "52NTKu2MK5I-00314-00081936-00082199": "the question is if God can say Christ is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00315-00082200-00082385": "the head of the church if Christ is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00316-00082386-00082600": "asking you to preach is it proper for", "52NTKu2MK5I-00317-00082601-00082799": "you to be saying God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00318-00082800-00083050": "don't let me preach tomorrow it's not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00319-00083051-00083297": "proper", "52NTKu2MK5I-00320-00083298-00083656": "everybody is with different Grace", "52NTKu2MK5I-00321-00083657-00083819": "there are some people that God will be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00322-00083820-00083975": "talking to and telling do and go and do", "52NTKu2MK5I-00323-00083976-00084119": "this and they will not answer and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00324-00084120-00084250": "nothing will happen", "52NTKu2MK5I-00325-00084251-00084455": "and there are some things that some", "52NTKu2MK5I-00326-00084456-00084599": "people that when God said go and eat", "52NTKu2MK5I-00327-00084600-00084893": "this thing as he say it and you say Assa", "52NTKu2MK5I-00328-00084894-00085156": "let's say I'm very tired I cannot do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00329-00085157-00085391": "immediately when you say it you will not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00330-00085392-00085505": "talk again", "52NTKu2MK5I-00331-00085506-00085762": "the next thing is punishment", "52NTKu2MK5I-00332-00085763-00086003": "to Grace our David", "52NTKu2MK5I-00333-00086004-00086200": "but the truth of the fact is that God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00334-00086201-00086435": "expected us to be very humble to our", "52NTKu2MK5I-00335-00086436-00086567": "husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00336-00086568-00086800": "in what reason must you raise your voice", "52NTKu2MK5I-00337-00086801-00086938": "against your husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00338-00086939-00087256": "as a Christian in what reason must you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00339-00087257-00087503": "start against your husband as a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00340-00087504-00087749": "Christian in what reason must you shall", "52NTKu2MK5I-00341-00087750-00087971": "lend the authority of your husband as a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00342-00087972-00088211": "Christian", "52NTKu2MK5I-00343-00088212-00088349": "do you know what it means to surrender", "52NTKu2MK5I-00344-00088350-00088582": "the authority of husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00345-00088583-00088853": "your husband did something", "52NTKu2MK5I-00346-00088854-00089068": "probably let me just use an example a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00347-00089069-00089344": "sample he beat one of the chat and the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00348-00089345-00089543": "child came and reported to the mother if", "52NTKu2MK5I-00349-00089544-00089705": "I teach I want to be held Us in the top", "52NTKu2MK5I-00350-00089706-00089873": "in the house of God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00351-00089874-00090143": "husband beat a type the child come and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00352-00090144-00090287": "reported the mother and the monster", "52NTKu2MK5I-00353-00090288-00090635": "called me and was not working", "52NTKu2MK5I-00354-00090636-00090868": "sir what what did I do that you beat him", "52NTKu2MK5I-00355-00090869-00090988": "like that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00356-00090989-00091175": "how dare you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00357-00091176-00091535": "hey how dare you these are literary", "52NTKu2MK5I-00358-00091536-00091781": "teachers that take Christian to hell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00359-00091782-00091949": "this you didn't count as something", "52NTKu2MK5I-00360-00091950-00092159": "important", "52NTKu2MK5I-00361-00092160-00092506": "how dare you to tell God that why I mean", "52NTKu2MK5I-00362-00092507-00092825": "to tell your husband why did you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00363-00092826-00093232": "why did you beat him like that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00364-00093233-00093503": "in fact as the child is coming to report", "52NTKu2MK5I-00365-00093504-00093725": "you this dress is supposed to give us", "52NTKu2MK5I-00366-00093726-00094012": "love you are reporting your father to me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00367-00094013-00094355": "that he beats you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00368-00094356-00094523": "there are some cases that the children", "52NTKu2MK5I-00369-00094524-00094841": "reported to their mother not in case of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00370-00094842-00095003": "their mother to fight for them but", "52NTKu2MK5I-00371-00095004-00095182": "probably even be the child has something", "52NTKu2MK5I-00372-00095183-00095399": "from the father and the father doesn't", "52NTKu2MK5I-00373-00095400-00095518": "want to give", "52NTKu2MK5I-00374-00095519-00095711": "he can he can tell the mother and say a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00375-00095712-00095873": "mommy I have this for my daddy that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00376-00095874-00096023": "didn't want to give and the wife will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00377-00096024-00096268": "just reached the wisdom of wife and God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00378-00096269-00096529": "my dear how are you doing", "52NTKu2MK5I-00379-00096530-00096803": "they are pleased now and this boy need", "52NTKu2MK5I-00380-00096804-00096982": "this thing is going to school for", "52NTKu2MK5I-00381-00096983-00097162": "example he need this thing he wanted to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00382-00097163-00097391": "buy this is very important please my dad", "52NTKu2MK5I-00383-00097392-00097535": "please I'm begging you please help me to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00384-00097536-00097685": "give it to him", "52NTKu2MK5I-00385-00097686-00097918": "it's not the art of you believing that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00386-00097919-00098141": "he must", "52NTKu2MK5I-00387-00098142-00098465": "he must so that actually leading the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00388-00098466-00098668": "authority", "52NTKu2MK5I-00389-00098669-00098999": "many Christian wife let me say remind me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00390-00099000-00099275": "women have end up in hell because of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00391-00099276-00099481": "this", "52NTKu2MK5I-00392-00099482-00099731": "especially when they come to the marker", "52NTKu2MK5I-00393-00099732-00100000": "of husband you have to be extremely very", "52NTKu2MK5I-00394-00100001-00100199": "careful", "52NTKu2MK5I-00395-00100200-00100565": "you have to be 100 represent obedience", "52NTKu2MK5I-00396-00100566-00100829": "to the extent that your husband will be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00397-00100830-00101147": "happy with you and may always do", "52NTKu2MK5I-00398-00101148-00101279": "something that will make your husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00399-00101280-00101591": "happy immediately your husband is sad", "52NTKu2MK5I-00400-00101592-00101824": "because of you it touched God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00401-00101825-00101993": "immediately", "52NTKu2MK5I-00402-00101994-00102215": "he touched God immediately", "52NTKu2MK5I-00403-00102216-00102592": "and which is very dangerous", "52NTKu2MK5I-00404-00102593-00102875": "nevertheless this is one of the also", "52NTKu2MK5I-00405-00102876-00103108": "arrow that is in the house of I in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00406-00103109-00103303": "house of Christians that the husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00407-00103304-00103601": "unbeliever husband tell you as the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00408-00103602-00103834": "Holiness Christian sister to start using", "52NTKu2MK5I-00409-00103835-00104094": "the ring", "52NTKu2MK5I-00410-00104095-00104315": "because God said we should be our", "52NTKu2MK5I-00411-00104316-00104513": "husband we start using your ring and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00412-00104514-00104897": "wearing trousers it is against God's way", "52NTKu2MK5I-00413-00104898-00105190": "in that point if you die you are going", "52NTKu2MK5I-00414-00105191-00105436": "to work you see it has become too now", "52NTKu2MK5I-00415-00105438-00105719": "if God is asking you to obey your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00416-00105720-00106043": "husband and to submit God didn't mean", "52NTKu2MK5I-00417-00106044-00106325": "that if he asks you to go and do wrong", "52NTKu2MK5I-00418-00106326-00106763": "things you should go and do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00419-00106764-00107093": "you have to add the letter identify what", "52NTKu2MK5I-00420-00107094-00107290": "is wrong and what is right", "52NTKu2MK5I-00421-00107291-00107584": "you know this thing is not biblical God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00422-00107585-00107945": "said we should not wear these things God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00423-00107946-00108190": "said we should not steal but he insists", "52NTKu2MK5I-00424-00108191-00108352": "that you want to take", "52NTKu2MK5I-00425-00108353-00108599": "if you disobey him God will be happy to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00426-00108600-00108821": "sleep he will not be angry with you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00427-00108822-00109013": "well if you bring him I said on the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00428-00109014-00109289": "point of my husband said both of you are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00429-00109290-00109481": "going to help", "52NTKu2MK5I-00430-00109482-00109804": "for the people of of people for the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00431-00109805-00110002": "people now who is having issue with", "52NTKu2MK5I-00432-00110003-00110290": "their husbands because of her where", "52NTKu2MK5I-00433-00110291-00110507": "Holiness are not holiness", "52NTKu2MK5I-00434-00110508-00110734": "the husband is not very angry that you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00435-00110735-00110957": "are wearing trousers the husband is not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00436-00110958-00111125": "very ugly not that because because your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00437-00111126-00111425": "only life now has that's become a high", "52NTKu2MK5I-00438-00111426-00111707": "level now is now very highly received", "52NTKu2MK5I-00439-00111708-00111958": "now this is the advice I'm going to tell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00440-00111959-00112343": "you now you are to obey God why you are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00441-00112344-00112565": "obeying God you are putting his heart in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00442-00112566-00112775": "God's hand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00443-00112776-00113008": "that God's Grant worship because the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00444-00113009-00113213": "truth is that if you didn't obey him", "52NTKu2MK5I-00445-00113214-00113465": "when he asked you to commit a sin he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00446-00113466-00113716": "will he will take it at a big offense", "52NTKu2MK5I-00447-00113717-00114010": "and begin to threaten you with that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00448-00114011-00114352": "but you cannot obey man because on the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00449-00114353-00114586": "process of you saying let me test it and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00450-00114588-00114851": "just obey it for once tomorrow I will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00451-00114852-00115169": "not be again in that process if death", "52NTKu2MK5I-00452-00115170-00115314": "comes you are going to hell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00453-00115315-00115686": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00454-00115688-00116069": "so you have to be extremely careful in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00455-00116070-00116507": "these two sides", "52NTKu2MK5I-00456-00116508-00116831": "now another things I want to talk about", "52NTKu2MK5I-00457-00116832-00117233": "is the issue of raising children", "52NTKu2MK5I-00458-00117233-00117581": "a woman God required you to raise your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00459-00117582-00117808": "time in a very", "52NTKu2MK5I-00460-00117809-00118019": "Godly way", "52NTKu2MK5I-00461-00118020-00118271": "if you are not able to raise your tithe", "52NTKu2MK5I-00462-00118272-00118636": "God is going to require it from you and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00463-00118638-00118960": "that can lead you to hell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00464-00118961-00119454": "foreign", "52NTKu2MK5I-00465-00119455-00119699": "we have questions", "52NTKu2MK5I-00466-00119700-00119908": "if you have questions you want to ask", "52NTKu2MK5I-00467-00119909-00120166": "you can come to ask me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00468-00120167-00120407": "on June you can join our Zoom program", "52NTKu2MK5I-00469-00120408-00120575": "which we need to do that is where we", "52NTKu2MK5I-00470-00120576-00120881": "attack questions", "52NTKu2MK5I-00471-00120882-00121108": "now if", "52NTKu2MK5I-00472-00121109-00121373": "ah now I want to come to the husband now", "52NTKu2MK5I-00473-00121374-00121697": "husband the Bible talk about husband to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00474-00121698-00121793": "wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00475-00121794-00121970": "now listen very well", "52NTKu2MK5I-00476-00121971-00122099": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00477-00122100-00122543": "in verse 25", "52NTKu2MK5I-00478-00122544-00122927": "husband love your wife even as Christ", "52NTKu2MK5I-00479-00122928-00123347": "also loved the church and gave himself", "52NTKu2MK5I-00480-00123348-00123658": "for heat", "52NTKu2MK5I-00481-00123659-00123928": "husband love your wife even as Christ", "52NTKu2MK5I-00482-00123929-00124228": "loved the church did you know how much", "52NTKu2MK5I-00483-00124229-00124493": "God Christ loved the church", "52NTKu2MK5I-00484-00124494-00124697": "is there even us", "52NTKu2MK5I-00485-00124698-00124939": "he was comparing the love of the husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00486-00124940-00125416": "with the love of the church", "52NTKu2MK5I-00487-00125417-00125686": "husband you have to love your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00488-00125688-00126034": "now let me tell you the meaning of love", "52NTKu2MK5I-00489-00126035-00126233": "when you love your wife you will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00490-00126233-00126431": "Overlook many of thanks that your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00491-00126432-00126557": "do", "52NTKu2MK5I-00492-00126558-00126766": "you really correct her", "52NTKu2MK5I-00493-00126767-00127013": "there are two things there are two", "52NTKu2MK5I-00494-00127014-00127375": "things about about overlooking", "52NTKu2MK5I-00495-00127376-00127583": "overlooking doesn't mean that he's doing", "52NTKu2MK5I-00496-00127583-00127745": "the wrong thing and you didn't look a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00497-00127746-00128051": "place no you know that what he's doing", "52NTKu2MK5I-00498-00128052-00128321": "is wrong instead of you to get angry", "52NTKu2MK5I-00499-00128322-00128677": "with her you call her in love", "52NTKu2MK5I-00500-00128678-00128986": "now if eventually it did something that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00501-00128988-00129214": "is extremely very hungry that can cause", "52NTKu2MK5I-00502-00129215-00129407": "somebody to be very angry instead of it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00503-00129408-00129604": "to be extremely very angry he can just", "52NTKu2MK5I-00504-00129605-00129760": "talk to her and tell her that you are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00505-00129761-00129995": "not happy with it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00506-00129996-00130193": "this thing I'm not happy with it you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00507-00130194-00130433": "have really messed up things", "52NTKu2MK5I-00508-00130433-00130589": "you're not supposed to do something in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00509-00130590-00130847": "fact what it is very good is only part", "52NTKu2MK5I-00510-00130848-00131189": "you can you can just express your kind", "52NTKu2MK5I-00511-00131190-00131719": "of unhappiness to him not in anger", "52NTKu2MK5I-00512-00131720-00131975": "you are not supposed to do that that is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00513-00131976-00132166": "not love", "52NTKu2MK5I-00514-00132167-00132383": "when you come to a level where my", "52NTKu2MK5I-00515-00132384-00132659": "husband begin to shout on the wife is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00516-00132660-00132928": "not love", "52NTKu2MK5I-00517-00132929-00133199": "so your husband you ought to love your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00518-00133200-00133433": "wife number two you ought to understand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00519-00133434-00133769": "love usually understand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00520-00133770-00133937": "in the book of First Corinthians chapter", "52NTKu2MK5I-00521-00133938-00134139": "13. you talk about love there", "52NTKu2MK5I-00522-00134140-00134345": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00523-00134346-00134490": "fore", "52NTKu2MK5I-00524-00134491-00134743": "is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00525-00134744-00134975": "it love", "52NTKu2MK5I-00526-00134976-00135190": "it doesn't matter the kind of tattoo you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00527-00135191-00135352": "carry it doesn't matter the kind of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00528-00135353-00135587": "anointing you carry you ought to love", "52NTKu2MK5I-00529-00135588-00135761": "your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00530-00135762-00135935": "pray for your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00531-00135936-00136231": "understand your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00532-00136232-00136547": "understanding matters and one of the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00533-00136548-00136828": "reasons that that cause couples always", "52NTKu2MK5I-00534-00136829-00137002": "fight is because they don't understand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00535-00137003-00137213": "each other this is the truth of the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00536-00137214-00137452": "whole matter women will always offend", "52NTKu2MK5I-00537-00137453-00137669": "you in fact in a day that can offend me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00538-00137670-00137873": "10 times Maybe", "52NTKu2MK5I-00539-00137874-00138064": "but it's not everything you will talk", "52NTKu2MK5I-00540-00138065-00138328": "about we just Overlook some things", "52NTKu2MK5I-00541-00138329-00138533": "we just overlooked some things you just", "52NTKu2MK5I-00542-00138534-00138664": "Overlook some things", "52NTKu2MK5I-00543-00138665-00138869": "you might talk in one place and just", "52NTKu2MK5I-00544-00138870-00139013": "keep quiet", "52NTKu2MK5I-00545-00139014-00139295": "you have to overlook them you have to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00546-00139296-00139540": "understand that they are women", "52NTKu2MK5I-00547-00139541-00139823": "the Bible call them the weak virtue", "52NTKu2MK5I-00548-00139824-00140002": "because they are women", "52NTKu2MK5I-00549-00140003-00140327": "the kind of mentality they have is just", "52NTKu2MK5I-00550-00140328-00140573": "a ethnic mentality", "52NTKu2MK5I-00551-00140574-00140759": "there are two things that God is talking", "52NTKu2MK5I-00552-00140760-00141089": "about the mind is calling and you and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00553-00141090-00141389": "they and the woman who is going to Earth", "52NTKu2MK5I-00554-00141390-00141652": "now somebody who is helping you cannot", "52NTKu2MK5I-00555-00141653-00141875": "have the kind of knowledge of the person", "52NTKu2MK5I-00556-00141876-00142093": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00557-00142094-00142445": "for example I built my house", "52NTKu2MK5I-00558-00142446-00142763": "I beat my whole house clear and clean I", "52NTKu2MK5I-00559-00142764-00143021": "know every corner of my whole house now", "52NTKu2MK5I-00560-00143022-00143195": "and now where to go and collect ask me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00561-00143196-00143447": "I'm just example just for example and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00562-00143448-00143602": "I'm going to go and connect an a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00563-00143603-00143807": "housemate to come and help me in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00564-00143808-00144052": "house do you know that not everything", "52NTKu2MK5I-00565-00144053-00144299": "the housemates will know about the house", "52NTKu2MK5I-00566-00144300-00144611": "if I know every corner of the house it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00567-00144612-00144809": "might know the rooms in the house he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00568-00144810-00145019": "might know every area where they push it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00569-00145020-00145277": "it might know where to ship but he will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00570-00145278-00145427": "know he was not there when I was", "52NTKu2MK5I-00571-00145428-00145709": "building it it was not there when I was", "52NTKu2MK5I-00572-00145710-00145943": "praying on that ground it was not there", "52NTKu2MK5I-00573-00145944-00146164": "when I was building foundations there", "52NTKu2MK5I-00574-00146165-00146290": "are things he doesn't know about the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00575-00146291-00146597": "house that is the same way women is to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00576-00146598-00146723": "husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00577-00146724-00147023": "God called them he helped meat they are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00578-00147024-00147328": "not the one that is sent as the husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00579-00147329-00147611": "the husband is the head of the whole the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00580-00147612-00147863": "kind of wisdom the kind of anointing the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00581-00147864-00148114": "kind of Grace women doesn't carry it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00582-00148115-00148397": "they have the area They Carried and the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00583-00148398-00148577": "kind of women carry mad because they", "52NTKu2MK5I-00584-00148578-00148864": "carry it now the kind of ability they", "52NTKu2MK5I-00585-00148865-00149002": "help me out", "52NTKu2MK5I-00586-00149003-00149285": "to walk in the house do that you are the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00587-00149286-00149543": "owner of the house you might not do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00588-00149544-00149819": "you might be so busy to do it you might", "52NTKu2MK5I-00589-00149820-00150004": "be so tired to go around it they will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00590-00150005-00150202": "sleep they will cook they will wash they", "52NTKu2MK5I-00591-00150203-00150413": "will do this because that is the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00592-00150414-00150628": "anointing they have I am not trying to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00593-00150629-00151013": "qualify wife as a ethnic but I say as as", "52NTKu2MK5I-00594-00151014-00151319": "a I'm just trying to make an example", "52NTKu2MK5I-00595-00151320-00151540": "that the kind of Grace they have is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00596-00151541-00151799": "totally divert there are different kind", "52NTKu2MK5I-00597-00151800-00151895": "of Grace", "52NTKu2MK5I-00598-00151896-00152116": "so the grace the wife asks you doesn't", "52NTKu2MK5I-00599-00152117-00152393": "have it why the grace you have the wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00600-00152394-00152669": "doesn't have it so now the grace God is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00601-00152670-00152885": "giving you at the end of The Hope is the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00602-00152886-00153197": "kind of art of understanding", "52NTKu2MK5I-00603-00153198-00153401": "there are sometimes they will misbehave", "52NTKu2MK5I-00604-00153402-00153497": "in words", "52NTKu2MK5I-00605-00153498-00153635": "there are some time there will be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00606-00153636-00153863": "misbehave in actions there are some", "52NTKu2MK5I-00607-00153864-00154121": "times that we misbehave in behaviors you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00608-00154122-00154397": "as a man if you did not understand God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00609-00154398-00154613": "will see you as somebody who is not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00610-00154614-00154889": "capital of handling your own and that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00611-00154890-00155135": "can lead you to hell", "52NTKu2MK5I-00612-00155136-00155513": "because our God is a Justice God who", "52NTKu2MK5I-00613-00155514-00155975": "judge accordingly he don't accordingly", "52NTKu2MK5I-00614-00155976-00156263": "he draw thoroughly between the man and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00615-00156264-00156599": "the woman especially this if this they", "52NTKu2MK5I-00616-00156600-00156989": "are the house is a home of a Christian", "52NTKu2MK5I-00617-00156990-00157235": "a Christian oh he will judge them", "52NTKu2MK5I-00618-00157236-00157601": "accordingly", "52NTKu2MK5I-00619-00157602-00157895": "as a man he will judge them accordingly", "52NTKu2MK5I-00620-00157896-00158111": "so you as a man you ought to understand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00621-00158112-00158237": "your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00622-00158238-00158687": "then you ought to care for your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00623-00158688-00158969": "pray is very important there are little", "52NTKu2MK5I-00624-00158970-00159149": "little things you do to women that makes", "52NTKu2MK5I-00625-00159150-00159304": "women love you people", "52NTKu2MK5I-00626-00159305-00159473": "they are literally teaching that he", "52NTKu2MK5I-00627-00159474-00159676": "doesn't have many at all that will be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00628-00159677-00159857": "due to a woman that woman else will be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00629-00159858-00160078": "rising", "52NTKu2MK5I-00630-00160079-00160271": "you can simply call and tell her you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00631-00160272-00160433": "love her without anything doing anything", "52NTKu2MK5I-00632-00160434-00160714": "for you for you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00633-00160715-00160840": "don't say that just say I want you to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00634-00160841-00161075": "tell you that I love you God know I love", "52NTKu2MK5I-00635-00161076-00161297": "you will be reading on a bridge it can", "52NTKu2MK5I-00636-00161298-00161471": "take a week or two weeks before that in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00637-00161472-00161716": "a race", "52NTKu2MK5I-00638-00161717-00161951": "just telling her not he didn't do you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00639-00161952-00162052": "are just everybody is working", "52NTKu2MK5I-00640-00162053-00162226": "you just call her take her come there I", "52NTKu2MK5I-00641-00162227-00162352": "want you to see you for something yeah", "52NTKu2MK5I-00642-00162353-00162514": "yes what do you want to say I just want", "52NTKu2MK5I-00643-00162515-00162719": "to tell you that I love it that will be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00644-00162720-00162964": "linking you can just be walking past and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00645-00162965-00163073": "you work", "52NTKu2MK5I-00646-00163074-00163307": "you can just call Dua you can just kiss", "52NTKu2MK5I-00647-00163308-00163564": "her you can just pick her just tell you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00648-00163565-00163769": "thank you I just thank you I appreciate", "52NTKu2MK5I-00649-00163770-00163973": "God that you are my wife all this kind", "52NTKu2MK5I-00650-00163974-00164171": "of things is very important he makes", "52NTKu2MK5I-00651-00164172-00164401": "home to stand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00652-00164402-00164616": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00653-00164617-00164921": "don't be too big to play with your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00654-00164922-00165185": "say that I'm anointed the grace of God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00655-00165186-00165383": "is too big so you cannot play with your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00656-00165384-00165545": "wife I'm not talking about sexual", "52NTKu2MK5I-00657-00165546-00165773": "intercourse I'm talking about normal", "52NTKu2MK5I-00658-00165774-00166001": "play in the house", "52NTKu2MK5I-00659-00166002-00166247": "you are this one now it's not a matter", "52NTKu2MK5I-00660-00166248-00166463": "of trust now you are not playing in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00661-00166464-00166601": "house in sense of her maybe you are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00662-00166602-00166823": "making jokes no no no this one is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00663-00166824-00167093": "between you and your wife God expected", "52NTKu2MK5I-00664-00167094-00167428": "you to have a communication beautiful", "52NTKu2MK5I-00665-00167429-00167633": "minutes beautiful hours together", "52NTKu2MK5I-00666-00167634-00167831": "together", "52NTKu2MK5I-00667-00167832-00168071": "smile always to your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00668-00168072-00168431": "even though you are busy She's Mine", "52NTKu2MK5I-00669-00168432-00168640": "even so even though what he said it's", "52NTKu2MK5I-00670-00168641-00168964": "not that funny smile laugh", "52NTKu2MK5I-00671-00168965-00169193": "just make sure that they laugh and the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00672-00169194-00169385": "communication is going on the beauty", "52NTKu2MK5I-00673-00169386-00169637": "moment is there it doesn't when that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00674-00169638-00169793": "kind of thing is going on it doesn't", "52NTKu2MK5I-00675-00169794-00170081": "allow Satan to penetrate", "52NTKu2MK5I-00676-00170082-00170728": "your body said", "52NTKu2MK5I-00677-00170729-00170999": "the English is that if the world doesn't", "52NTKu2MK5I-00678-00171000-00171131": "open mouth", "52NTKu2MK5I-00679-00171132-00171419": "it doesn't crack it doesn't open mouth a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00680-00171420-00171749": "loser cannot enter it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00681-00171750-00172025": "so if you didn't give such for the Devil", "52NTKu2MK5I-00682-00172026-00172211": "the devil cannot hurt your marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-00683-00172212-00172499": "you'll be surprised that it is possible", "52NTKu2MK5I-00684-00172500-00172685": "to have a beautiful home", "52NTKu2MK5I-00685-00172686-00173023": "it is possible to have a peaceful family", "52NTKu2MK5I-00686-00173024-00173225": "everybody's shouting marriage is not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00687-00173226-00173464": "easy it's a lesson it's not easy it's", "52NTKu2MK5I-00688-00173465-00173813": "not it's you it's you and your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00689-00173814-00174011": "you are the ones it's not making it easy", "52NTKu2MK5I-00690-00174012-00174190": "for yourself if the work can understand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00691-00174191-00174401": "your husband and they will also can", "52NTKu2MK5I-00692-00174402-00174623": "understand the wife and everything is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00693-00174624-00174947": "going on if the old wife is able to give", "52NTKu2MK5I-00694-00174948-00175169": "honor to the husband and the wife is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00695-00175170-00175439": "able to give back the love the own", "52NTKu2MK5I-00696-00175440-00175757": "coming from the crack", "52NTKu2MK5I-00697-00175758-00176135": "the home can never be cracked but", "52NTKu2MK5I-00698-00176136-00176452": "because you have allowed the devil", "52NTKu2MK5I-00699-00176453-00176704": "into your hope you have allowed the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00700-00176705-00176926": "devil into your home it it makes the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00701-00176927-00177178": "devil to work hard", "52NTKu2MK5I-00702-00177179-00177671": "to attack you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00703-00177672-00177976": "it makes him to work hard to attack him", "52NTKu2MK5I-00704-00177977-00178240": "you have to make sure that all your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00705-00178241-00178607": "space are clean and clear and closed", "52NTKu2MK5I-00706-00178608-00179104": "I went to one of my my uh my uh my one", "52NTKu2MK5I-00707-00179105-00179326": "of my father's uncle", "52NTKu2MK5I-00708-00179327-00179549": "the my father spoke with that man has", "52NTKu2MK5I-00709-00179550-00179759": "died he died at the age of 93 years old", "52NTKu2MK5I-00710-00179760-00179854": "or so", "52NTKu2MK5I-00711-00179855-00180113": "so the wife is still alive but one of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00712-00180114-00180388": "the things I saw is this is that during", "52NTKu2MK5I-00713-00180389-00180647": "the time he was alive", "52NTKu2MK5I-00714-00180648-00180911": "during the time he was alive I witnessed", "52NTKu2MK5I-00715-00180912-00181066": "them by you we used to go there to their", "52NTKu2MK5I-00716-00181067-00181138": "house", "52NTKu2MK5I-00717-00181139-00181390": "the man the old man and his wife they", "52NTKu2MK5I-00718-00181391-00181738": "never quoted before one number two if", "52NTKu2MK5I-00719-00181739-00181913": "the the man is the man of God the uncle", "52NTKu2MK5I-00720-00181914-00182221": "is a man of God and where is an icon", "52NTKu2MK5I-00721-00182222-00182501": "this Mark whenever he's solving people's", "52NTKu2MK5I-00722-00182502-00182837": "problem his wife must stay with him", "52NTKu2MK5I-00723-00182838-00183040": "his wife will stay beside it everything", "52NTKu2MK5I-00724-00183041-00183214": "you want to tell him and you cannot say", "52NTKu2MK5I-00725-00183215-00183376": "it in his wife present you carry your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00726-00183377-00183616": "problem go", "52NTKu2MK5I-00727-00183617-00183893": "you carry your problem go", "52NTKu2MK5I-00728-00183894-00184169": "your wife will say we think and one of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00729-00184170-00184414": "the things I noticed that there is no", "52NTKu2MK5I-00730-00184415-00184709": "day I repeat there is no day this man", "52NTKu2MK5I-00731-00184710-00184990": "will go out without whether it's at home", "52NTKu2MK5I-00732-00184991-00185243": "whether it's inside the house or going", "52NTKu2MK5I-00733-00185244-00185452": "out they will always wear the same", "52NTKu2MK5I-00734-00185453-00185711": "clothes even till the time he was on his", "52NTKu2MK5I-00735-00185712-00185909": "bed about to die they are wearing the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00736-00185910-00186287": "same clothes", "52NTKu2MK5I-00737-00186288-00186502": "and before you answer anything we say", "52NTKu2MK5I-00738-00186503-00186676": "you say Mommy what do you have to say to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00739-00186677-00186833": "this", "52NTKu2MK5I-00740-00186834-00187019": "there's no matter you want to bring", "52NTKu2MK5I-00741-00187020-00187175": "before him you will first say Mommy what", "52NTKu2MK5I-00742-00187176-00187337": "do you want to have to say before this", "52NTKu2MK5I-00743-00187338-00187619": "because he want to hear from her the the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00744-00187620-00187864": "statements of his wife we were we're not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00745-00187865-00188033": "there whether he will make things easy", "52NTKu2MK5I-00746-00188034-00188249": "for you maybe he will not be angry or", "52NTKu2MK5I-00747-00188250-00188306": "you'll be angry", "52NTKu2MK5I-00748-00188307-00188531": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00749-00188532-00188728": "if the our wife is saying something", "52NTKu2MK5I-00750-00188729-00188981": "maybe the wife the Judgment of the wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00751-00188982-00189251": "is that what you do is very wrong", "52NTKu2MK5I-00752-00189252-00189676": "so he's going to judge you the award is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00753-00189677-00190031": "always very unrelated", "52NTKu2MK5I-00754-00190032-00190331": "no disagreement and they judge quietly", "52NTKu2MK5I-00755-00190332-00190619": "like cleanly", "52NTKu2MK5I-00756-00190620-00190961": "the attack I see the man whenever where", "52NTKu2MK5I-00757-00190962-00191147": "somebody do something that is wrong I've", "52NTKu2MK5I-00758-00191148-00191363": "seen him correcting the person in anger", "52NTKu2MK5I-00759-00191364-00191566": "tell me get out of my get out of my", "52NTKu2MK5I-00760-00191567-00191854": "presence he's a man of God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00761-00191855-00192071": "the wife will see her daddy he's", "52NTKu2MK5I-00762-00192072-00192185": "forgiving", "52NTKu2MK5I-00763-00192186-00192407": "no matter whether it is two of them they", "52NTKu2MK5I-00764-00192408-00192616": "might abuse they will be the ones to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00765-00192617-00192773": "still apologize", "52NTKu2MK5I-00766-00192774-00192995": "to sit outside you know we are you know", "52NTKu2MK5I-00767-00192996-00193216": "it's your child do we know that he has", "52NTKu2MK5I-00768-00193217-00193438": "abused both of you me and you but let's", "52NTKu2MK5I-00769-00193439-00193595": "forgive him", "52NTKu2MK5I-00770-00193596-00193763": "and the white the husband will look at", "52NTKu2MK5I-00771-00193764-00194014": "the wife like this so it's all right", "52NTKu2MK5I-00772-00194015-00194302": "this kind of teach if you keep on doing", "52NTKu2MK5I-00773-00194303-00194525": "it in fact the the mentality of people", "52NTKu2MK5I-00774-00194526-00194752": "is that after the man died the wife who", "52NTKu2MK5I-00775-00194753-00194957": "died like that because their love is so", "52NTKu2MK5I-00776-00194958-00195263": "great then after the incident of the man", "52NTKu2MK5I-00777-00195264-00195647": "the Man's dead I went to the wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00778-00195648-00195935": "me and my sister my sister and I we went", "52NTKu2MK5I-00779-00195936-00196181": "there to go and ask our question I said", "52NTKu2MK5I-00780-00196182-00196547": "Ma there's something we notice", "52NTKu2MK5I-00781-00196548-00196828": "I told her I said there's something I", "52NTKu2MK5I-00782-00196829-00197213": "noticed before Baba died that both of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00783-00197214-00197501": "you your love is very chronic", "52NTKu2MK5I-00784-00197502-00197740": "have you two faced I like this before or", "52NTKu2MK5I-00785-00197741-00198059": "what or you have face challenges and you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00786-00198060-00198214": "are fight and fight and fight you now", "52NTKu2MK5I-00787-00198215-00198359": "come to 11 wherever you begin to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00788-00198360-00198587": "understand yourself", "52NTKu2MK5I-00789-00198588-00198766": "you will be surprised as the statement", "52NTKu2MK5I-00790-00198767-00199013": "of the mother the answer of the woman", "52NTKu2MK5I-00791-00199014-00199151": "the old woman", "52NTKu2MK5I-00792-00199152-00199511": "your woman said if I will tell you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00793-00199512-00199763": "that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00794-00199764-00200093": "I am Baba my husband we have never fight", "52NTKu2MK5I-00795-00200094-00200399": "before I said Ma I'm so sorry to say", "52NTKu2MK5I-00796-00200400-00200559": "this it's not possible", "52NTKu2MK5I-00797-00200560-00201343": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00798-00201344-00201707": "I said because once I was hearing is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00799-00201708-00201935": "that you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00800-00201936-00202331": "I mean that marriage is not easy", "52NTKu2MK5I-00801-00202332-00202625": "that marriage is not easy now you are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00802-00202626-00202931": "not telling me that both of you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00803-00202932-00203116": "have never fight before how is it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00804-00203117-00203357": "possible there's no way even this tongue", "52NTKu2MK5I-00805-00203358-00203561": "can teach that they fight he tell me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00806-00203562-00203788": "that he said my son I cannot lie to you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00807-00203789-00204161": "I mean the level I have now I am above", "52NTKu2MK5I-00808-00204162-00204745": "never fight before that's okay okay", "52NTKu2MK5I-00809-00204746-00205042": "he said never", "52NTKu2MK5I-00810-00205044-00205175": "ah", "52NTKu2MK5I-00811-00205176-00205475": "it's okay okay okay like what age did", "52NTKu2MK5I-00812-00205476-00205757": "you money about money are at the age of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00813-00205758-00206003": "around 18 years age", "52NTKu2MK5I-00814-00206004-00206164": "but you are still very young so you'll", "52NTKu2MK5I-00815-00206165-00206398": "be doing mistake instead if you do have", "52NTKu2MK5I-00816-00206400-00206600": "the mistake we understand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00817-00206601-00206814": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00818-00206815-00207125": "okay what is the secret I still remember", "52NTKu2MK5I-00819-00207126-00207466": "I said he said the secret is that if", "52NTKu2MK5I-00820-00207467-00207736": "Papa asked me to sit down one place even", "52NTKu2MK5I-00821-00207737-00207958": "my father my mother cannot tell me to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00822-00207959-00208225": "stand up", "52NTKu2MK5I-00823-00208226-00208584": "you see it you see this statement", "52NTKu2MK5I-00824-00208585-00208979": "inverted ER sit down here nobody in this", "52NTKu2MK5I-00825-00208980-00209212": "world can tell us stand up that should", "52NTKu2MK5I-00826-00209213-00209453": "be listening to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00827-00209454-00209717": "as he said she this is the attitude you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00828-00209717-00209987": "should begin with to be a good age", "52NTKu2MK5I-00829-00209988-00210244": "and they have never he said now if I", "52NTKu2MK5I-00830-00210246-00210467": "have obeyed him what will make at him to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00831-00210467-00210665": "be angry with", "52NTKu2MK5I-00832-00210666-00210898": "he said Babas never tell me to do", "52NTKu2MK5I-00833-00210900-00211198": "something and I tell him no never I will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00834-00211200-00211444": "always repeat", "52NTKu2MK5I-00835-00211446-00211732": "this is the kind of life God wants us to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00836-00211733-00211865": "live", "52NTKu2MK5I-00837-00211866-00212189": "as husband and wife who wanted to make", "52NTKu2MK5I-00838-00212190-00212417": "effort I am not talking about just", "52NTKu2MK5I-00839-00212417-00212639": "energy husband I'm talking about the two", "52NTKu2MK5I-00840-00212640-00212831": "couples who are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00841-00212832-00213226": "you know try to make it to heaven", "52NTKu2MK5I-00842-00213227-00213508": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00843-00213509-00213887": "so as a husband you ought to understand", "52NTKu2MK5I-00844-00213888-00214079": "there are some times to follow your wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00845-00214080-00214391": "to the kitchen help out", "52NTKu2MK5I-00846-00214392-00214594": "where you know you are free", "52NTKu2MK5I-00847-00214596-00215021": "just go there they appreciate it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00848-00215021-00215231": "they used to appreciate it there it made", "52NTKu2MK5I-00849-00215232-00215405": "them to love you the more it makes them", "52NTKu2MK5I-00850-00215406-00215627": "to see you like okay too true you care", "52NTKu2MK5I-00851-00215628-00215789": "for them", "52NTKu2MK5I-00852-00215790-00216005": "they go there to the kitchen help them", "52NTKu2MK5I-00853-00216006-00216208": "with some things", "52NTKu2MK5I-00854-00216209-00216473": "laugh together they are even while", "52NTKu2MK5I-00855-00216473-00216646": "walking in the kitchen all that they are", "52NTKu2MK5I-00856-00216648-00216803": "playing with her", "52NTKu2MK5I-00857-00216804-00217139": "laugh together cook it if you make", "52NTKu2MK5I-00858-00217140-00217265": "mistake", "52NTKu2MK5I-00859-00217266-00217613": "putting a lot of Maggi or a lot of salt", "52NTKu2MK5I-00860-00217614-00217955": "to do abuse you eat it you try you try", "52NTKu2MK5I-00861-00217956-00218141": "you try you know you try you try you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00862-00218142-00218242": "laugh together", "52NTKu2MK5I-00863-00218244-00218760": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00864-00218761-00219023": "your wife is like the Bible said it's", "52NTKu2MK5I-00865-00219023-00219155": "you yourself", "52NTKu2MK5I-00866-00219156-00219455": "he said the two have become one", "52NTKu2MK5I-00867-00219456-00219665": "so if the two have become one what will", "52NTKu2MK5I-00868-00219666-00220048": "make the problem to rise", "52NTKu2MK5I-00869-00220050-00220325": "then one of the things", "52NTKu2MK5I-00870-00220326-00220631": "that also is that also is a serious", "52NTKu2MK5I-00871-00220632-00220805": "issue", "52NTKu2MK5I-00872-00220806-00221177": "because of time I want you to just", "52NTKu2MK5I-00873-00221178-00221496": "is the issue of sex", "52NTKu2MK5I-00874-00221498-00221789": "there's a message God gave to me that is", "52NTKu2MK5I-00875-00221790-00221896": "very clear", "52NTKu2MK5I-00876-00221898-00222256": "he spoke to my ear very clearly", "52NTKu2MK5I-00877-00222257-00222592": "and he also warned me he said I should I", "52NTKu2MK5I-00878-00222594-00222856": "should tell the people the whole world", "52NTKu2MK5I-00879-00222857-00223163": "the reason why the reason you always", "52NTKu2MK5I-00880-00223164-00223384": "find your wife you should be huge let me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00881-00223385-00223594": "tell you it's your fault it's both of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00882-00223596-00223667": "you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00883-00223667-00223967": "not all women are bad", "52NTKu2MK5I-00884-00223967-00224260": "there are some women that are good but", "52NTKu2MK5I-00885-00224261-00224446": "because you have entered into a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00886-00224448-00224748": "spiritual course", "52NTKu2MK5I-00887-00224750-00225131": "spiritual cause it makes the woman to be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00888-00225132-00225305": "bad", "52NTKu2MK5I-00889-00225306-00225508": "and start disrespecting you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00890-00225509-00225941": "do you know that as a man", "52NTKu2MK5I-00891-00225942-00226367": "it is a cause for a man to build on the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00892-00226367-00226744": "bed lying down why the wife having", "52NTKu2MK5I-00893-00226746-00227310": "intercourse with him on the top", "52NTKu2MK5I-00894-00227311-00227621": "God told me it's not a matter of it's", "52NTKu2MK5I-00895-00227621-00227963": "not because me I have been hearing it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00896-00227964-00228731": "anything", "52NTKu2MK5I-00897-00228732-00228923": "it's one of the things that I will talk", "52NTKu2MK5I-00898-00228923-00229163": "very well even my wife will talk about", "52NTKu2MK5I-00899-00229164-00229408": "it that people say that I said I'll be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00900-00229409-00229642": "hearing it it's better we don't do such", "52NTKu2MK5I-00901-00229644-00229792": "a thing but", "52NTKu2MK5I-00902-00229794-00230063": "God have not spoken to me don't let us", "52NTKu2MK5I-00903-00230064-00230248": "do it one people are saying it is a sin", "52NTKu2MK5I-00904-00230250-00230567": "but if God speak to me that I cannot say", "52NTKu2MK5I-00905-00230567-00230789": "God speak to me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00906-00230790-00231023": "and not quite long the Lord spoke to me", "52NTKu2MK5I-00907-00231023-00231292": "and it's what a Clarity but it's a clear", "52NTKu2MK5I-00908-00231294-00231532": "voice I have of God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00909-00231533-00231844": "he told me that whenever a man", "52NTKu2MK5I-00910-00231846-00232156": "sleep on the bed and the wife the woman", "52NTKu2MK5I-00911-00232157-00232492": "is on the top of the man having sex", "52NTKu2MK5I-00912-00232494-00232787": "so it is not the woman having sex with", "52NTKu2MK5I-00913-00232788-00232960": "the man now it's not the man having sex", "52NTKu2MK5I-00914-00232961-00233123": "with the woman he's a woman having sex", "52NTKu2MK5I-00915-00233123-00233489": "with a manner he said after he says it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00916-00233490-00233819": "makes the woman have a bad spirit", "52NTKu2MK5I-00917-00233819-00233981": "you will just see that automatically", "52NTKu2MK5I-00918-00233982-00234191": "woman will be rooting you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00919-00234192-00234455": "you'll be ruling your life you'll be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00920-00234456-00234706": "disrespecting you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00921-00234707-00234965": "then we want to stop it but it will be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00922-00234966-00235319": "hard for them", "52NTKu2MK5I-00923-00235319-00235553": "it will be half of them", "52NTKu2MK5I-00924-00235554-00235775": "that it's not that they will they really", "52NTKu2MK5I-00925-00235776-00236015": "want it it they will be good to feed his", "52NTKu2MK5I-00926-00236016-00236237": "writing but by the time we want to study", "52NTKu2MK5I-00927-00236238-00236489": "but we feel like no no no no I will not", "52NTKu2MK5I-00928-00236490-00236794": "respect this man", "52NTKu2MK5I-00929-00236796-00236939": "by the time I begin to talk to you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00930-00236940-00237196": "anyhow do you believe it is the Lord", "52NTKu2MK5I-00931-00237198-00237334": "told me he said this is the cause of", "52NTKu2MK5I-00932-00237335-00237737": "many marriage how are we going to do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00933-00237738-00238753": "foreign", "52NTKu2MK5I-00934-00238754-00239003": "peace of mind at all", "52NTKu2MK5I-00935-00239004-00239321": "women riding on you having sex with you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00936-00239321-00239710": "you are giving him your cry", "52NTKu2MK5I-00937-00239711-00240010": "you are giving the woman your crying on", "52NTKu2MK5I-00938-00240011-00240064": "the head", "52NTKu2MK5I-00939-00240065-00240275": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00940-00240276-00240496": "so that he she will become the husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-00941-00240498-00240887": "while you will become the wife", "52NTKu2MK5I-00942-00240888-00241156": "then the boss will begin to enter her to", "52NTKu2MK5I-00943-00241157-00241439": "begin to be misbehaving", "52NTKu2MK5I-00944-00241440-00241727": "not only that is also an Abomination", "52NTKu2MK5I-00945-00241728-00242081": "before God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00946-00242082-00242392": "I didn't believe it when people were", "52NTKu2MK5I-00947-00242394-00242651": "saying that uh when you have stuck in", "52NTKu2MK5I-00948-00242652-00242915": "style with your wife you saying you say", "52NTKu2MK5I-00949-00242916-00243089": "this and this I didn't believe it I said", "52NTKu2MK5I-00950-00243090-00243377": "I said well I said but we should be", "52NTKu2MK5I-00951-00243378-00243569": "careful", "52NTKu2MK5I-00952-00243569-00243851": "I said it's what God told me that I know", "52NTKu2MK5I-00953-00243852-00244198": "but this is the truth of the offered", "52NTKu2MK5I-00954-00244200-00244510": "the approved Style", "52NTKu2MK5I-00955-00244511-00244829": "you can use just make sure", "52NTKu2MK5I-00956-00244830-00245183": "that one He Didn't Do It Against Time", "52NTKu2MK5I-00957-00245184-00245441": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00958-00245442-00245639": "I don't know about what one thing I know", "52NTKu2MK5I-00959-00245640-00245825": "is that man must be the one working for", "52NTKu2MK5I-00960-00245826-00246046": "the work woman", "52NTKu2MK5I-00961-00246048-00246329": "not by douglasa anyway", "52NTKu2MK5I-00962-00246330-00246706": "rumors Muslim why the man must be on top", "52NTKu2MK5I-00963-00246707-00247127": "the man must be the one walking it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00964-00247128-00247391": "not the woman being the one doing the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00965-00247392-00247546": "work", "52NTKu2MK5I-00966-00247548-00247853": "that is how God has created it I might", "52NTKu2MK5I-00967-00247854-00248027": "not be able to go far than what I'm", "52NTKu2MK5I-00968-00248028-00248213": "saying", "52NTKu2MK5I-00969-00248214-00248471": "but what I just want you to be aware and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00970-00248471-00248831": "be sure is that intercourse as a secret", "52NTKu2MK5I-00971-00248832-00249113": "and a spiritual", "52NTKu2MK5I-00972-00249114-00249598": "ah spiritual penalty", "52NTKu2MK5I-00973-00249600-00250031": "is something that is very delicate", "52NTKu2MK5I-00974-00250032-00250210": "it's something you have to be very very", "52NTKu2MK5I-00975-00250211-00250339": "careful about", "52NTKu2MK5I-00976-00250340-00250608": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00977-00250609-00250781": "no no no no", "52NTKu2MK5I-00978-00250782-00250942": "then she will be there's a way the Bible", "52NTKu2MK5I-00979-00250944-00251267": "wanted us to do it the Lord wants us the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00980-00251267-00251464": "Lord himself wants us to do it", "52NTKu2MK5I-00981-00251465-00251627": "[Music]", "52NTKu2MK5I-00982-00251628-00251879": "I pray the Lord will help us in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-00983-00251880-00252281": "mighty name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth", "52NTKu2MK5I-00984-00252282-00252496": "one of the things I also want to warn", "52NTKu2MK5I-00985-00252498-00252832": "women off is this", "52NTKu2MK5I-00986-00252833-00253205": "if you do want to suffer", "52NTKu2MK5I-00987-00253206-00253456": "and if you do want your house to be a", "52NTKu2MK5I-00988-00253457-00253775": "coursed house don't always cry when your", "52NTKu2MK5I-00989-00253776-00254260": "husband offends you", "52NTKu2MK5I-00990-00254261-00254453": "do you hear what I said", "52NTKu2MK5I-00991-00254454-00254710": "Because by the time God's anger before", "52NTKu2MK5I-00992-00254711-00254831": "your family", "52NTKu2MK5I-00993-00254832-00255005": "is going", "52NTKu2MK5I-00994-00255006-00255329": "to affect you affect your children that", "52NTKu2MK5I-00995-00255330-00255575": "is innocent", "52NTKu2MK5I-00996-00255576-00255869": "if your wife if your husband committed", "52NTKu2MK5I-00997-00255869-00256234": "any offense to you don't always cry and", "52NTKu2MK5I-00998-00256235-00256421": "talk to God", "52NTKu2MK5I-00999-00256421-00256775": "reporting him to God don't do it oh evil", "52NTKu2MK5I-01000-00256776-00256955": "sit in a crying they do is you are", "52NTKu2MK5I-01001-00256956-00257203": "pleasing cause of me", "52NTKu2MK5I-01002-00257204-00257555": "except if it does not offend you is", "52NTKu2MK5I-01003-00257556-00257692": "innocent", "52NTKu2MK5I-01004-00257694-00258142": "that God can bounce back to you", "52NTKu2MK5I-01005-00258144-00258521": "but if it's not his innocent he is his", "52NTKu2MK5I-01006-00258521-00258730": "sin against you intentionally and is", "52NTKu2MK5I-01007-00258731-00258827": "aware", "52NTKu2MK5I-01008-00258828-00259103": "and you are doing it you are not helping", "52NTKu2MK5I-01009-00259104-00259234": "the whole matter", "52NTKu2MK5I-01010-00259235-00259630": "you are only placing cause on him", "52NTKu2MK5I-01011-00259631-00259889": "it is also good for husband and wife to", "52NTKu2MK5I-01012-00259890-00260153": "bless themselves always for no reason", "52NTKu2MK5I-01013-00260154-00260392": "must you curse your husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-01014-00260394-00260651": "if you cause your husband and your", "52NTKu2MK5I-01015-00260652-00260915": "husband later sleep with you you both of", "52NTKu2MK5I-01016-00260916-00261239": "you share it because", "52NTKu2MK5I-01017-00261240-00261551": "if in the process you are pregnant the", "52NTKu2MK5I-01018-00261552-00261725": "child that is coming to we share in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-01019-00261726-00261796": "course", "52NTKu2MK5I-01020-00261798-00262001": "these are the secret of marriage you", "52NTKu2MK5I-01021-00262002-00262289": "never know", "52NTKu2MK5I-01022-00262290-00262751": "I am not true if a woman will want to", "52NTKu2MK5I-01023-00262752-00262979": "cause the husband and make sure that", "52NTKu2MK5I-01024-00262980-00263182": "he's not sleeping with you again because", "52NTKu2MK5I-01025-00263183-00263615": "every time in Me Is Something On You you", "52NTKu2MK5I-01026-00263616-00263837": "partake in the course because the", "52NTKu2MK5I-01027-00263838-00264113": "connection come back", "52NTKu2MK5I-01028-00264114-00264353": "the blood has missed together", "52NTKu2MK5I-01029-00264354-00264856": "you partake in the course", "52NTKu2MK5I-01030-00264857-00265043": "you partake", "52NTKu2MK5I-01031-00265044-00265265": "so one of the things you have to be very", "52NTKu2MK5I-01032-00265266-00265541": "aware of is that you must not try it in", "52NTKu2MK5I-01033-00265542-00265775": "fact no women", "52NTKu2MK5I-01034-00265776-00265991": "that is blessing cause on their husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-01035-00265992-00266206": "we make it to heaven", "52NTKu2MK5I-01036-00266207-00266393": "there's no way", "52NTKu2MK5I-01037-00266394-00266656": "there are women should learn to say", "52NTKu2MK5I-01038-00266657-00266843": "sorry always", "52NTKu2MK5I-01039-00266844-00267155": "so sorry to your husband", "52NTKu2MK5I-01040-00267156-00267358": "no matter whether you are the right", "52NTKu2MK5I-01041-00267359-00267569": "person there are some time women will", "52NTKu2MK5I-01042-00267570-00267737": "always stand on their right saying that", "52NTKu2MK5I-01043-00267738-00268025": "I'm this one I'm not the faulty he's the", "52NTKu2MK5I-01044-00268026-00268277": "one that is 40. whether you are the 41", "52NTKu2MK5I-01045-00268278-00268697": "or the husband is the 41. say sorry", "52NTKu2MK5I-01046-00268698-00268943": "when you say son you cannot die", "52NTKu2MK5I-01047-00268944-00269219": "say sorry", "52NTKu2MK5I-01048-00269220-00269537": "I pray the Lord God will help us in the", "52NTKu2MK5I-01049-00269538-00269795": "mighty name of Jesus", "52NTKu2MK5I-01050-00269796-00270023": "for now this is a short thing I want to", "52NTKu2MK5I-01051-00270024-00270113": "say", "52NTKu2MK5I-01052-00270114-00270299": "about marriage", "52NTKu2MK5I-01053-00270300-00270521": "especially take note", "52NTKu2MK5I-01054-00270522-00270803": "sexual intercourse should be very very", "52NTKu2MK5I-01055-00270804-00271156": "careful in doing essential intercourse", "52NTKu2MK5I-01056-00271157-00271319": "through sexual intercourse the demons", "52NTKu2MK5I-01057-00271320-00271595": "has entered the child that", "52NTKu2MK5I-01058-00271596-00271901": "was produced when they have wrong", "52NTKu2MK5I-01059-00271902-00272110": "sexual intercourse the church will", "52NTKu2MK5I-01060-00272111-00272495": "produce to we we we we we also have the", "52NTKu2MK5I-01061-00272496-00272749": "demons", "52NTKu2MK5I-01062-00272750-00272993": "so I pray the Lord God will help us in", "52NTKu2MK5I-01063-00272994-00273106": "Jesus name", "52NTKu2MK5I-01064-00273107-00273395": "God bless you share this program to", "52NTKu2MK5I-01065-00273396-00273660": "everyone then subscribe to the channel", "52NTKu2MK5I-01066-00273661-00273869": "subscribe to the channel", "52NTKu2MK5I-01067-00273870-00274006": "and press", "52NTKu2MK5I-01068-00274007-00274337": "notification button so that whenever I", "52NTKu2MK5I-01069-00274338-00274715": "send video you too can be notified and", "52NTKu2MK5I-01070-00274716-00274877": "you can watch it because there are more", "52NTKu2MK5I-01071-00274878-00275080": "revelation of God coming to the church", "52NTKu2MK5I-01072-00275081-00275532": "to save the church from the problem", "52NTKu2MK5I-01073-00275533-00275956": "I pray God Almighty we bless you and we", "52NTKu2MK5I-01074-00275957-00276389": "be with you forever in Jesus name amen", "52NTKu2MK5I-01075-00276390-00276599": "bye-bye thank you", "52NTKu2MK5I-01076-00276600-00277272": "foreign", "52NTKu2MK5I-01077-00277273-00278186": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "52P4DQWjX5E", "text": {"52P4DQWjX5E-00000-00000136-00000327": "well just so you know too uh this", "52P4DQWjX5E-00001-00000328-00000551": "expires next week okay yes sir i already", "52P4DQWjX5E-00002-00000552-00000911": "have booked uh uh 54", "52P4DQWjX5E-00003-00000911-00001150": "in balboa on 28th perfect this month i", "52P4DQWjX5E-00004-00001151-00001319": "just don't want you to get in trouble", "52P4DQWjX5E-00005-00001320-00001599": "for that yes sir okay so i just marked", "52P4DQWjX5E-00006-00001600-00001830": "down those three defects yeah okay so", "52P4DQWjX5E-00007-00001832-00001982": "just when you get back", "52P4DQWjX5E-00008-00001984-00002087": "take uh", "52P4DQWjX5E-00009-00002088-00002255": "have the shop look at it", "52P4DQWjX5E-00010-00002256-00002431": "once it's fixed the mechanical sign", "52P4DQWjX5E-00011-00002432-00002599": "there yeah the employer will sign the", "52P4DQWjX5E-00012-00002600-00002775": "fax back to the office of winnipeg okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00013-00002776-00002934": "okay okay okay i'll put your trailer", "52P4DQWjX5E-00014-00002935-00003134": "paperwork back for you i already fixed", "52P4DQWjX5E-00015-00003135-00003599": "the thing in there", "52P4DQWjX5E-00016-00003600-00005743": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00017-00005744-00005886": "i'll just get you to step out for a sec", "52P4DQWjX5E-00018-00005887-00006159": "okay just step up", "52P4DQWjX5E-00019-00006160-00006391": "two small issues that i found yes sir", "52P4DQWjX5E-00020-00006392-00006534": "okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00021-00006536-00006916": "so you're burgundy", "52P4DQWjX5E-00022-00006917-00007119": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00023-00007120-00007353": "and guys", "52P4DQWjX5E-00024-00007354-00007767": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00025-00007768-00007927": "i began", "52P4DQWjX5E-00026-00007928-00008199": "my level two inspection", "52P4DQWjX5E-00027-00008200-00008319": "emerson", "52P4DQWjX5E-00028-00008320-00008888": "uh scale", "52P4DQWjX5E-00029-00008889-00009614": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00030-00009615-00009862": "foreign", "52P4DQWjX5E-00031-00009863-00011110": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00032-00011111-00015422": "i know", "52P4DQWjX5E-00033-00015423-00015652": "foreign", "52P4DQWjX5E-00034-00015653-00016894": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00035-00016895-00017598": "automatic vegan", "52P4DQWjX5E-00036-00017599-00017743": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00037-00017744-00017927": "state order ahead", "52P4DQWjX5E-00038-00017928-00018094": "station ahead", "52P4DQWjX5E-00039-00018095-00019519": "of", "52P4DQWjX5E-00040-00019520-00021094": "50 meters", "52P4DQWjX5E-00041-00021095-00021350": "okay so we'll have 11 hours and 27", "52P4DQWjX5E-00042-00021351-00021792": "minutes of remaining drive time", "52P4DQWjX5E-00043-00021793-00022335": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00044-00022336-00022859": "changed", "52P4DQWjX5E-00045-00022860-00026590": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00046-00026591-00026683": "yes sir", "52P4DQWjX5E-00047-00026683-00026958": "266 one second", "52P4DQWjX5E-00048-00026960-00027279": "i'm not that fast", "52P4DQWjX5E-00049-00027280-00027690": "i was thinking about it yes 266", "52P4DQWjX5E-00050-00027691-00028070": "518 266 thousand five hundred eighteen", "52P4DQWjX5E-00051-00028072-00028718": "okay kilometers miles uh kilometers okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00052-00028719-00028951": "all right uh release your brakes", "52P4DQWjX5E-00053-00028952-00029231": "uh yeah push man we'll see them in okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00054-00029232-00029487": "insert the truck up", "52P4DQWjX5E-00055-00029488-00030879": "oh", "52P4DQWjX5E-00056-00030880-00031046": "you know what let's close the door and", "52P4DQWjX5E-00057-00031047-00031655": "just roll down the window okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00058-00031656-00031846": "okay you want me to make break", "52P4DQWjX5E-00059-00031847-00032039": "applications and lower warning comes on", "52P4DQWjX5E-00060-00032039-00032214": "okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00061-00032216-00032318": "all right so you want me to make", "52P4DQWjX5E-00062-00032319-00032807": "application now yeah just keep pushing", "52P4DQWjX5E-00063-00032808-00032921": "yeah keep going", "52P4DQWjX5E-00064-00032922-00033390": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00065-00033391-00033623": "until it goes to the", "52P4DQWjX5E-00066-00033624-00034367": "60 okay until the warnings come on okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00067-00034368-00034559": "okay good now build it back up until the", "52P4DQWjX5E-00068-00034560-00036407": "compressor kicks off okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00069-00036408-00036646": "where are you coming from winnipeg sir", "52P4DQWjX5E-00070-00036647-00036935": "oh where are you going uh i'm going to", "52P4DQWjX5E-00071-00036936-00037167": "new new york okay what kind of things we", "52P4DQWjX5E-00072-00037168-00037367": "have brooklyn", "52P4DQWjX5E-00073-00037368-00037583": "it's just assaulted sir that's what it's", "52P4DQWjX5E-00074-00037584-00037759": "already load pre-loaded when i get to", "52P4DQWjX5E-00075-00037760-00037990": "the yard so i don't know like like", "52P4DQWjX5E-00076-00037991-00038159": "winnipeg fisher", "52P4DQWjX5E-00077-00038160-00038687": "i guess so okay yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00078-00038688-00038846": "it's not that important i'm just curious", "52P4DQWjX5E-00079-00038847-00040815": "yeah yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00080-00040816-00041087": "why would he pass on that side", "52P4DQWjX5E-00081-00041088-00041335": "i don't know yeah he's suppose", "52P4DQWjX5E-00082-00041336-00041495": "you're probably thinking about just", "52P4DQWjX5E-00083-00041496-00041751": "because you're there i'm not sure", "52P4DQWjX5E-00084-00041752-00041902": "yeah i don't know either", "52P4DQWjX5E-00085-00041903-00042062": "you can give it a little bit", "52P4DQWjX5E-00086-00042063-00042199": "you can idle a little bit higher if you", "52P4DQWjX5E-00087-00042200-00044143": "want yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00088-00044144-00044358": "do you have a youtube channel yes sir i", "52P4DQWjX5E-00089-00044359-00044607": "have youtube this is my youtube channel", "52P4DQWjX5E-00090-00044608-00044743": "in my", "52P4DQWjX5E-00091-00044744-00044983": "uh my cup lock your trucker yeah it's", "52P4DQWjX5E-00092-00044984-00045279": "like tracker okay it's all about life of", "52P4DQWjX5E-00093-00045280-00045502": "a truck driver so just being honest", "52P4DQWjX5E-00094-00045503-00046062": "doing this thing so", "52P4DQWjX5E-00095-00046063-00046302": "okay push break and hold it", "52P4DQWjX5E-00096-00046303-00046511": "break and hold yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00097-00046512-00046662": "okay not leaking there okay you can turn", "52P4DQWjX5E-00098-00046663-00047086": "the truck off", "52P4DQWjX5E-00099-00047087-00047286": "and then once this resets", "52P4DQWjX5E-00100-00047287-00047479": "yeah let's turn it off and let it", "52P4DQWjX5E-00101-00047480-00047783": "cycle okay turn it off yeah okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00102-00047784-00047927": "something like that yeah and just wait", "52P4DQWjX5E-00103-00047928-00048062": "for this to", "52P4DQWjX5E-00104-00048063-00048223": "okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00105-00048224-00048367": "and then just turn the power on now", "52P4DQWjX5E-00106-00048368-00048623": "power on", "52P4DQWjX5E-00107-00048624-00048983": "there", "52P4DQWjX5E-00108-00048984-00049295": "gauges warning device yeah all good okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00109-00049296-00049590": "turn your lights on lights on", "52P4DQWjX5E-00110-00049591-00050374": "uh yeah so i think it's already in there", "52P4DQWjX5E-00111-00050375-00051262": "high beams", "52P4DQWjX5E-00112-00051263-00053711": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00113-00053712-00054094": "push the breaker holder", "52P4DQWjX5E-00114-00054095-00055182": "okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00115-00055183-00056766": "foreign", "52P4DQWjX5E-00116-00056767-00058542": "foreign", "52P4DQWjX5E-00117-00058544-00059416": "okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00118-00059417-00061399": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00119-00061400-00061999": "hey", "52P4DQWjX5E-00120-00062000-00064335": "all right", "52P4DQWjX5E-00121-00064336-00067122": "remaining drive time on", "52P4DQWjX5E-00122-00067123-00067638": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00123-00067639-00069338": "my equipment", "52P4DQWjX5E-00124-00069339-00069950": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00125-00069951-00071482": "let me", "52P4DQWjX5E-00126-00071483-00071750": "yeah hey yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00127-00071751-00071871": "so just", "52P4DQWjX5E-00128-00071872-00072094": "two small issues that i found yes sir", "52P4DQWjX5E-00129-00072095-00072247": "okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00130-00072248-00072423": "so your emergency glass right here", "52P4DQWjX5E-00131-00072424-00072567": "there's a bit of a leak so it might just", "52P4DQWjX5E-00132-00072568-00072838": "be a bad seat or could be a", "52P4DQWjX5E-00133-00072839-00073062": "chewed up rubber okay not a big deal", "52P4DQWjX5E-00134-00073063-00073199": "just get it fixed when you get back yes", "52P4DQWjX5E-00135-00073200-00073279": "sir", "52P4DQWjX5E-00136-00073280-00073438": "and then", "52P4DQWjX5E-00137-00073439-00073559": "oh yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00138-00073560-00073855": "and then this shock here is loose", "52P4DQWjX5E-00139-00073856-00074094": "okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00140-00074095-00074367": "again not a big deal which one side sir", "52P4DQWjX5E-00141-00074368-00074567": "the the axle two", "52P4DQWjX5E-00142-00074568-00074782": "okay okay the shock", "52P4DQWjX5E-00143-00074783-00074950": "this one here yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00144-00074951-00075126": "a little loose okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00145-00075127-00075359": "okay sure when you get back again not a", "52P4DQWjX5E-00146-00075360-00075575": "big deal when you get back just take it", "52P4DQWjX5E-00147-00075576-00075726": "to the shop haven't fixed it yes sir yes", "52P4DQWjX5E-00148-00075727-00075887": "sir okay you set your brakes right okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00149-00075888-00076047": "yeah i did sir okay i'm just gonna go", "52P4DQWjX5E-00150-00076048-00076159": "for this paperwork and then you're on", "52P4DQWjX5E-00151-00076160-00076303": "your way okay thank you sir give me a", "52P4DQWjX5E-00152-00076304-00076768": "couple minutes okay", "52P4DQWjX5E-00153-00076769-00078367": "[Applause]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00154-00078368-00079215": "foreign", "52P4DQWjX5E-00155-00079216-00082207": "guys", "52P4DQWjX5E-00156-00082208-00083181": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00157-00083182-00084910": "[Applause]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00158-00084911-00088436": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00159-00088437-00091382": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00160-00091383-00093359": "is", "52P4DQWjX5E-00161-00093360-00094862": "oh", "52P4DQWjX5E-00162-00094863-00095471": "something nothing she said", "52P4DQWjX5E-00163-00095472-00095718": "you have 11 hours and 27 minutes of", "52P4DQWjX5E-00164-00095719-00097919": "remaining drive time yes", "52P4DQWjX5E-00165-00097920-00098215": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00166-00098216-00099725": "know", "52P4DQWjX5E-00167-00099726-00100887": "[Applause]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00168-00100888-00103686": "uh", "52P4DQWjX5E-00169-00103688-00103927": "oh just so you know too uh this expires", "52P4DQWjX5E-00170-00103928-00104127": "next week eh yes sir i already have", "52P4DQWjX5E-00171-00104128-00104463": "booked uh uh 54", "52P4DQWjX5E-00172-00104464-00104702": "in balboa on 28th perfect this month i", "52P4DQWjX5E-00173-00104703-00104871": "just don't want you to get in trouble", "52P4DQWjX5E-00174-00104872-00105158": "for that yes sir okay so i just marked", "52P4DQWjX5E-00175-00105159-00105390": "down those three defects yeah okay so", "52P4DQWjX5E-00176-00105391-00105543": "just when you get back", "52P4DQWjX5E-00177-00105544-00105647": "take uh", "52P4DQWjX5E-00178-00105648-00105815": "have the shop look at it", "52P4DQWjX5E-00179-00105816-00105990": "once it's fixed the mechanical sign", "52P4DQWjX5E-00180-00105991-00106151": "there yeah the employer will sign there", "52P4DQWjX5E-00181-00106152-00106310": "the fax back to the office of winnipeg", "52P4DQWjX5E-00182-00106311-00106471": "okay okay okay okay i'll put your", "52P4DQWjX5E-00183-00106472-00106663": "trailer paperwork back for you i already", "52P4DQWjX5E-00184-00106664-00106934": "fixed the thing in there", "52P4DQWjX5E-00185-00106935-00107163": "yeah", "52P4DQWjX5E-00186-00107164-00108183": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00187-00108183-00108447": "you got it sir", "52P4DQWjX5E-00188-00108448-00108583": "all right thank you thank you sir thank", "52P4DQWjX5E-00189-00108583-00109023": "you yeah you too", "52P4DQWjX5E-00190-00109024-00109134": "cool", "52P4DQWjX5E-00191-00109135-00109549": "all right you guys", "52P4DQWjX5E-00192-00109550-00111751": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00193-00111752-00112031": "vanilla", "52P4DQWjX5E-00194-00112032-00117180": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00195-00117181-00118781": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00196-00118782-00120881": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00197-00120882-00122485": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00198-00122486-00123031": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00199-00123032-00123322": "bye for now", "52P4DQWjX5E-00200-00123323-00124047": "[Music]", "52P4DQWjX5E-00201-00124048-00124288": "tracker"}}, {"audio_id": "52WKAbQE_RM", "text": {"52WKAbQE_RM-00000-00000096-00000279": "from the cube studios in palo alto in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00001-00000280-00000351": "boston", "52WKAbQE_RM-00002-00000352-00000487": "connecting with thought leaders all", "52WKAbQE_RM-00003-00000488-00000703": "around the world this is a cube", "52WKAbQE_RM-00004-00000704-00000797": "conversation", "52WKAbQE_RM-00005-00000798-00000991": "[Music]", "52WKAbQE_RM-00006-00000992-00001207": "welcome to the cube and this special ibm", "52WKAbQE_RM-00007-00001208-00001350": "brocade panel", "52WKAbQE_RM-00008-00001351-00001550": "i'm lisa martin and i'm having a great", "52WKAbQE_RM-00009-00001551-00001687": "opportunity here to sit down for the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00010-00001688-00001887": "next 20 minutes with three gentlemen", "52WKAbQE_RM-00011-00001888-00002039": "please welcome brian sherman", "52WKAbQE_RM-00012-00002039-00002247": "distinguished engineer from ibm brian", "52WKAbQE_RM-00013-00002248-00002439": "great to have you joining us", "52WKAbQE_RM-00014-00002440-00002710": "thanks for having me and matt key is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00015-00002711-00002750": "here", "52WKAbQE_RM-00016-00002751-00003095": "flash systems sme from ibm matt happy", "52WKAbQE_RM-00017-00003096-00003166": "friday", "52WKAbQE_RM-00018-00003167-00003367": "happy friday lisa thanks for having us", "52WKAbQE_RM-00019-00003368-00003590": "oh our pleasure and aj costamento", "52WKAbQE_RM-00020-00003592-00003686": "solutioneer", "52WKAbQE_RM-00021-00003688-00003967": "from brocade is here aj welcome thanks", "52WKAbQE_RM-00022-00003968-00004103": "for having me along", "52WKAbQE_RM-00023-00004104-00004327": "and aj we're going to stick with you ibm", "52WKAbQE_RM-00024-00004328-00004495": "and brocade have had a very long you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00025-00004496-00004679": "said about 22-year", "52WKAbQE_RM-00026-00004680-00004886": "strategic partnership there's some new", "52WKAbQE_RM-00027-00004887-00005047": "news in terms of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00028-00005048-00005279": "the evolution of that talk to us about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00029-00005280-00005502": "what's going on with with brocade ibm", "52WKAbQE_RM-00030-00005503-00005831": "and what is new in the storage industry", "52WKAbQE_RM-00031-00005832-00006102": "yeah so the the newest thing for us at", "52WKAbQE_RM-00032-00006103-00006270": "the moment is that ibm just in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00033-00006271-00006518": "uh mid-october launched our gen 7", "52WKAbQE_RM-00034-00006519-00006678": "platform so this is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00035-00006679-00006855": "you know think about the stresses that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00036-00006856-00007006": "are going on in the um", "52WKAbQE_RM-00037-00007008-00007214": "in the it environments this is our", "52WKAbQE_RM-00038-00007215-00007383": "attempt to keep pace with", "52WKAbQE_RM-00039-00007384-00007559": "uh with the performance levels that the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00040-00007559-00007710": "ibm teams are now putting into their", "52WKAbQE_RM-00041-00007711-00007846": "storage environments", "52WKAbQE_RM-00042-00007847-00008087": "um the all-flash data centers and the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00043-00008088-00008223": "new technologies around non-volatile", "52WKAbQE_RM-00044-00008224-00008303": "memory express", "52WKAbQE_RM-00045-00008304-00008663": "so that's really um what's driving this", "52WKAbQE_RM-00046-00008664-00008799": "along with the desire to say you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00047-00008800-00008983": "what people aren't allowed to be in the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00048-00008984-00009055": "data center", "52WKAbQE_RM-00049-00009056-00009183": "and so if they can't be in the data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00050-00009184-00009406": "center then the fabrics actually have to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00051-00009407-00009487": "be able to figure out", "52WKAbQE_RM-00052-00009488-00009703": "what's going on and and basically", "52WKAbQE_RM-00053-00009704-00009903": "provide a lot of the automation pieces", "52WKAbQE_RM-00054-00009904-00010023": "so something we're referring to as the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00055-00010024-00010214": "autonomous sam", "52WKAbQE_RM-00056-00010215-00010414": "and we're going to dig into nvme over", "52WKAbQE_RM-00057-00010415-00010599": "fabrics in a second but i do want to aj", "52WKAbQE_RM-00058-00010600-00010838": "continue with you in terms of um of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00059-00010839-00010974": "industries", "52WKAbQE_RM-00060-00010975-00011367": "financial services healthcare airlines", "52WKAbQE_RM-00061-00011368-00011774": "yeah so um biggest need", "52WKAbQE_RM-00062-00011775-00011942": "yeah pretty much pretty much across the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00063-00011943-00012142": "board so if you look at the global 2000", "52WKAbQE_RM-00064-00012143-00012231": "as an example", "52WKAbQE_RM-00065-00012232-00012455": "something on the order of about 96 97", "52WKAbQE_RM-00066-00012456-00012719": "percent of the global 2000 make use of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00067-00012720-00012983": "of fiber channel environments and in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00068-00012984-00013127": "portions of their of their world", "52WKAbQE_RM-00069-00013128-00013263": "generally tends to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00070-00013263-00013430": "a lot of the high-end financial guys a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00071-00013431-00013558": "lot of the pharmaceutical guys the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00072-00013559-00013807": "automotive the telcos", "52WKAbQE_RM-00073-00013808-00014119": "you know pretty much if the if the data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00074-00014119-00014263": "matters you know and it's and it's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00075-00014263-00014438": "something that's you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00076-00014440-00014622": "critical whether we talk about payment", "52WKAbQE_RM-00077-00014623-00014838": "card information or healthcare", "52WKAbQE_RM-00078-00014840-00014983": "uh environments you know data that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00079-00014984-00015166": "absolutely has to be retained has to get", "52WKAbQE_RM-00080-00015168-00015303": "there has to perform", "52WKAbQE_RM-00081-00015304-00015486": "then it's this combination that we're", "52WKAbQE_RM-00082-00015487-00015703": "that we're bringing together today", "52WKAbQE_RM-00083-00015704-00015791": "around", "52WKAbQE_RM-00084-00015791-00016063": "the the new storage elements and and the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00085-00016063-00016111": "the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00086-00016112-00016294": "functionalities they have there and then", "52WKAbQE_RM-00087-00016295-00016479": "our ability in the in the fabric so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00088-00016480-00016750": "the the concept of a 64 gig you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00089-00016751-00016847": "environment", "52WKAbQE_RM-00090-00016848-00017103": "to help basically not be the bottleneck", "52WKAbQE_RM-00091-00017104-00017215": "in in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00092-00017216-00017383": "in the application demands because one", "52WKAbQE_RM-00093-00017384-00017535": "thing i can promise you after", "52WKAbQE_RM-00094-00017536-00017703": "40 years in this industry is the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00095-00017704-00017871": "software guys always figure out how to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00096-00017872-00018039": "consume all the performance that the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00097-00018040-00018207": "hardware guys put on the shelf", "52WKAbQE_RM-00098-00018208-00018686": "right every single time", "52WKAbQE_RM-00099-00018687-00018894": "well there's gauntlet thrown down there", "52WKAbQE_RM-00100-00018895-00019030": "matt let's go to you i want to get", "52WKAbQE_RM-00101-00019031-00019247": "ibm's perspective on this again as we", "52WKAbQE_RM-00102-00019248-00019503": "said a 22-year strategic partnership", "52WKAbQE_RM-00103-00019504-00019671": "as as we look at things like not being", "52WKAbQE_RM-00104-00019672-00019847": "able to get into the data center", "52WKAbQE_RM-00105-00019848-00020063": "during these unprecedented times and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00106-00020064-00020279": "also the need to be able to remove some", "52WKAbQE_RM-00107-00020280-00020463": "of those bottlenecks how does ibm do", "52WKAbQE_RM-00108-00020464-00020686": "this yeah it's certainly a case of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00109-00020687-00020767": "raising the bar", "52WKAbQE_RM-00110-00020768-00021014": "right so we have to as a as a vendor", "52WKAbQE_RM-00111-00021015-00021167": "continue to evolve in terms of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00112-00021168-00021358": "performance in terms of capacity cost", "52WKAbQE_RM-00113-00021359-00021486": "density", "52WKAbQE_RM-00114-00021487-00021735": "escalating simplicity because it's not", "52WKAbQE_RM-00115-00021736-00021839": "just a case of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00116-00021840-00021975": "not being able to touch the arrays but", "52WKAbQE_RM-00117-00021976-00022150": "there's fewer people not being able to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00118-00022151-00022311": "touch the arrays right it's a case where", "52WKAbQE_RM-00119-00022312-00022367": "our", "52WKAbQE_RM-00120-00022368-00022558": "operational density continues to have to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00121-00022559-00022703": "evolve", "52WKAbQE_RM-00122-00022704-00022822": "being able to raise the bar on the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00123-00022823-00022991": "network and be able to still saturate", "52WKAbQE_RM-00124-00022992-00023150": "those line rates and be able to provide", "52WKAbQE_RM-00125-00023151-00023375": "essentially a cost efficiency that gets", "52WKAbQE_RM-00126-00023376-00023567": "us to a utilization that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00127-00023568-00023758": "you know raises the bar from our per", "52WKAbQE_RM-00128-00023759-00023975": "capita ratio from not just talking about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00129-00023976-00024239": "you know 200 300 terabytes per admin", "52WKAbQE_RM-00130-00024240-00024439": "but going beyond the petabyte scale per", "52WKAbQE_RM-00131-00024440-00024655": "admin and we can't do that unless people", "52WKAbQE_RM-00132-00024656-00024791": "have access to the data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00133-00024792-00024958": "right we have to provide the resiliency", "52WKAbQE_RM-00134-00024959-00025135": "we have to provide the simplicity of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00135-00025136-00025311": "presentation and automation from our", "52WKAbQE_RM-00136-00025312-00025375": "side", "52WKAbQE_RM-00137-00025376-00025527": "and then this collaboration that we do", "52WKAbQE_RM-00138-00025528-00025711": "with our network brother and mike brook", "52WKAbQE_RM-00139-00025712-00025958": "like brocade here continue to stay out", "52WKAbQE_RM-00140-00025960-00026087": "of the discussion when it comes to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00141-00026088-00026214": "talking about networks and throughput", "52WKAbQE_RM-00142-00026216-00026311": "bottlenecks", "52WKAbQE_RM-00143-00026312-00026518": "so we truly appreciate this gen 7 launch", "52WKAbQE_RM-00144-00026519-00026614": "that they're doing", "52WKAbQE_RM-00145-00026616-00026751": "we're happy to come in and fill that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00146-00026752-00026990": "pipe on the flash side forward", "52WKAbQE_RM-00147-00026991-00027127": "excellent brian as a distinguished", "52WKAbQE_RM-00148-00027127-00027214": "engineer i'd love to get your", "52WKAbQE_RM-00149-00027216-00027383": "perspectives on the evolution of the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00150-00027383-00027487": "technology", "52WKAbQE_RM-00151-00027488-00027839": "over this 22-year partnership oh", "52WKAbQE_RM-00152-00027839-00028118": "thanks lisa and it certainly has been a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00153-00028119-00028270": "long-standing you know great", "52WKAbQE_RM-00154-00028272-00028470": "relationship great partnership", "52WKAbQE_RM-00155-00028472-00028687": "all the way from you know in inventing", "52WKAbQE_RM-00156-00028688-00028918": "joint things to developing to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00157-00028919-00029158": "testing and and deploying the different", "52WKAbQE_RM-00158-00029160-00029311": "technologies through", "52WKAbQE_RM-00159-00029312-00029558": "through the course of time and it's been", "52WKAbQE_RM-00160-00029560-00029639": "one of those", "52WKAbQE_RM-00161-00029639-00029823": "that you know where where we are today", "52WKAbQE_RM-00162-00029824-00029999": "like aj had talked about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00163-00030000-00030311": "you know being able to sustain what the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00164-00030312-00030455": "applications require", "52WKAbQE_RM-00165-00030456-00030718": "today in in this always-on type of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00166-00030719-00030823": "environment", "52WKAbQE_RM-00167-00030824-00031031": "and as as matt said bringing together", "52WKAbQE_RM-00168-00031032-00031199": "the the density and operational", "52WKAbQE_RM-00169-00031200-00031358": "simplicity to make that happen", "52WKAbQE_RM-00170-00031360-00031511": "because we have to make it easier from", "52WKAbQE_RM-00171-00031512-00031751": "the storage side for operations to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00172-00031752-00031999": "able to manage this volume of data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00173-00032000-00032262": "that we have coming at us and in our our", "52WKAbQE_RM-00174-00032263-00032439": "due diligence is to be able to serve the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00175-00032439-00032623": "data up as fast as we can and as", "52WKAbQE_RM-00176-00032624-00032687": "resilient", "52WKAbQE_RM-00177-00032688-00033023": "as we can and sticking with you brian", "52WKAbQE_RM-00178-00033024-00033183": "that simplicity is key because as we", "52WKAbQE_RM-00179-00033184-00033255": "know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00180-00033256-00033446": "as we get more and more advances in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00181-00033447-00033662": "technology the it environments only", "52WKAbQE_RM-00182-00033663-00033879": "becoming more complex", "52WKAbQE_RM-00183-00033880-00034190": "so really truly enabling organizations", "52WKAbQE_RM-00184-00034191-00034327": "in any industry", "52WKAbQE_RM-00185-00034328-00034790": "to simplify is absolute table stakes", "52WKAbQE_RM-00186-00034791-00034999": "yeah it definitely is and that that's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00187-00035000-00035199": "core to to what we're focused", "52WKAbQE_RM-00188-00035200-00035455": "on and how do we make the storage", "52WKAbQE_RM-00189-00035456-00035535": "environment", "52WKAbQE_RM-00190-00035536-00035718": "simple you know it's been one of those", "52WKAbQE_RM-00191-00035719-00035823": "through through the years and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00192-00035824-00035918": "historically", "52WKAbQE_RM-00193-00035919-00036135": "you know we've had entry level us and in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00194-00036136-00036295": "the industry as a whole has had entry", "52WKAbQE_RM-00195-00036296-00036439": "level products mid lane", "52WKAbQE_RM-00196-00036440-00036630": "mid-range level products high-end level", "52WKAbQE_RM-00197-00036631-00036815": "products and earlier this year we said", "52WKAbQE_RM-00198-00036816-00036887": "enough", "52WKAbQE_RM-00199-00036888-00037111": "enough of that it's it's one product", "52WKAbQE_RM-00200-00037112-00037215": "portfolio", "52WKAbQE_RM-00201-00037216-00037407": "so it's the same software stack it's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00202-00037408-00037543": "just okay", "52WKAbQE_RM-00203-00037544-00037718": "small medium and large in terms of the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00204-00037719-00037959": "appliances that get delivered", "52WKAbQE_RM-00205-00037960-00038151": "and you know again building on what matt", "52WKAbQE_RM-00206-00038152-00038327": "said you know from a density perspective", "52WKAbQE_RM-00207-00038328-00038487": "where we can have a petabyte of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00208-00038488-00038702": "uncompressed un-data reduced storage in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00209-00038703-00038846": "a 2u enclosure", "52WKAbQE_RM-00210-00038847-00039143": "so it's it becomes from an overall", "52WKAbQE_RM-00211-00039144-00039335": "administration perspective", "52WKAbQE_RM-00212-00039336-00039567": "again one software stack one automation", "52WKAbQE_RM-00213-00039568-00039799": "stack one way to do point in time copies", "52WKAbQE_RM-00214-00039800-00039918": "replication", "52WKAbQE_RM-00215-00039919-00040230": "so in in focusing on how to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00216-00040231-00040446": "you know make that as simple for the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00217-00040447-00040830": "operations as we possibly can simplicity", "52WKAbQE_RM-00218-00040831-00040943": "i think we'd all take a little bit of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00219-00040944-00041023": "that right now", "52WKAbQE_RM-00220-00041024-00041223": "matt let's go to you and then aj let's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00221-00041224-00041351": "talk a little bit more dig", "52WKAbQE_RM-00222-00041352-00041639": "into the ibm storage arrays i mean we're", "52WKAbQE_RM-00223-00041640-00041718": "we're talking about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00224-00041719-00041918": "advances in flash we're talking about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00225-00041919-00042127": "nvme as a forcing function", "52WKAbQE_RM-00226-00042128-00042390": "for applications to change and evolve", "52WKAbQE_RM-00227-00042391-00042487": "with the storage", "52WKAbQE_RM-00228-00042488-00042695": "matt give us your thoughts on that no we", "52WKAbQE_RM-00229-00042696-00042918": "saw we saw a monumental leap", "52WKAbQE_RM-00230-00042919-00043167": "in where we take some simplicity pieces", "52WKAbQE_RM-00231-00043168-00043374": "uh from how we deliver our rays but also", "52WKAbQE_RM-00232-00043375-00043639": "the technology with the the arrays", "52WKAbQE_RM-00233-00043640-00043823": "about nine months ago here in february", "52WKAbQE_RM-00234-00043824-00043990": "we launched into the latest generation", "52WKAbQE_RM-00235-00043991-00044151": "of nand technology", "52WKAbQE_RM-00236-00044152-00044302": "and with that and following the story of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00237-00044303-00044462": "simplicity one of the pieces that we've", "52WKAbQE_RM-00238-00044463-00044518": "been", "52WKAbQE_RM-00239-00044519-00044718": "happily essentially negating a value", "52WKAbQE_RM-00240-00044719-00044951": "prop is storage level tiering", "52WKAbQE_RM-00241-00044952-00045118": "and be able to say hey well we still", "52WKAbQE_RM-00242-00045119-00045311": "support the idea of going down to an", "52WKAbQE_RM-00243-00045312-00045367": "airline", "52WKAbQE_RM-00244-00045368-00045599": "nearline sas and enterprise disk and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00245-00045600-00045790": "different flavors of solid state whether", "52WKAbQE_RM-00246-00045791-00045918": "it's you know tier one", "52WKAbQE_RM-00247-00045919-00046143": "short usage to tier zero high", "52WKAbQE_RM-00248-00046144-00046295": "performance high usage all the way up to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00249-00046296-00046430": "storage class memory", "52WKAbQE_RM-00250-00046431-00046599": "while we support those technologies in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00251-00046600-00046807": "the automated tiering this elegance of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00252-00046808-00046967": "what we've done as latest generation", "52WKAbQE_RM-00253-00046968-00047135": "technology that we launched nine months", "52WKAbQE_RM-00254-00047136-00047215": "ago", "52WKAbQE_RM-00255-00047216-00047399": "has been able to essentially homogenize", "52WKAbQE_RM-00256-00047400-00047599": "the environments to really deliver that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00257-00047600-00047846": "that petabyte per rack unit ratio that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00258-00047847-00047983": "brian was mentioning", "52WKAbQE_RM-00259-00047984-00048311": "be able to deliver it over into a all", "52WKAbQE_RM-00260-00048312-00048543": "tier zero solution that doesn't have to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00261-00048544-00048679": "go through lows of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00262-00048680-00048943": "of software managed data reduction or", "52WKAbQE_RM-00263-00048944-00049111": "any kind of software managed hearing", "52WKAbQE_RM-00264-00049112-00049167": "just to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00265-00049168-00049502": "always fast always essentially available", "52WKAbQE_RM-00266-00049503-00049718": "from 100 data availability guaranteed", "52WKAbQE_RM-00267-00049719-00049855": "that we offer through a technology", "52WKAbQE_RM-00268-00049856-00049983": "called hyperswap", "52WKAbQE_RM-00269-00049984-00050158": "but it's a it's really kind of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00270-00050159-00050302": "highlighting what we've taken from that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00271-00050303-00050479": "simplicity story by", "52WKAbQE_RM-00272-00050480-00050671": "going into that extra mile and leading", "52WKAbQE_RM-00273-00050672-00050895": "the market in technology refresh", "52WKAbQE_RM-00274-00050896-00051143": "i mean if you say the words ibm over the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00275-00051144-00051263": "thanksgiving table you're kind of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00276-00051264-00051375": "thinking oh big blue", "52WKAbQE_RM-00277-00051376-00051614": "big mainframe old iron stuff but it's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00278-00051615-00051766": "very happy to see over our distributed", "52WKAbQE_RM-00279-00051767-00051919": "systems that we are in fact leading this", "52WKAbQE_RM-00280-00051920-00051999": "pack by", "52WKAbQE_RM-00281-00052000-00052175": "you know multiple months not just the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00282-00052176-00052390": "fact that hey we've announced sooner", "52WKAbQE_RM-00283-00052391-00052582": "but actually coming to delivering", "52WKAbQE_RM-00284-00052583-00052791": "on-prem the actual solution itself", "52WKAbQE_RM-00285-00052791-00053047": "9-10 months prior to anybody else and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00286-00053048-00053223": "when that gets us into new density", "52WKAbQE_RM-00287-00053224-00053430": "flavors gets us into new uh", "52WKAbQE_RM-00288-00053432-00053630": "efficiency offerings right not just", "52WKAbQE_RM-00289-00053632-00053838": "talked about hey i can do this petabyte", "52WKAbQE_RM-00290-00053839-00053879": "scale", "52WKAbQE_RM-00291-00053879-00054007": "a couple of rack units but with the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00292-00054008-00054223": "likes of brocade hey that betty actually", "52WKAbQE_RM-00293-00054224-00054399": "equates to a terabyte per second in the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00294-00054400-00054494": "floor tile", "52WKAbQE_RM-00295-00054495-00054694": "what's that do for your analytics story", "52WKAbQE_RM-00296-00054695-00054807": "and the fact that we're now", "52WKAbQE_RM-00297-00054808-00055063": "leveraging nvme to undercut the value", "52WKAbQE_RM-00298-00055064-00055263": "prop of spinning disk in your hpc", "52WKAbQE_RM-00299-00055264-00055582": "analytics environments by 5x that's huge", "52WKAbQE_RM-00300-00055583-00055807": "right so now let's take airline sas off", "52WKAbQE_RM-00301-00055808-00055959": "the table for anything that's actually", "52WKAbQE_RM-00302-00055960-00056023": "for data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00303-00056024-00056238": "of you know such an anecdotal value to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00304-00056239-00056430": "us so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00305-00056432-00056615": "in simplicity elements what we're doing", "52WKAbQE_RM-00306-00056616-00056854": "now being able to make our own flash", "52WKAbQE_RM-00307-00056855-00057030": "we've been uh deriving from the texas", "52WKAbQE_RM-00308-00057032-00057182": "memory systems acquisition uh", "52WKAbQE_RM-00309-00057183-00057423": "eight years ago and then integrating", "52WKAbQE_RM-00310-00057424-00057526": "that into some", "52WKAbQE_RM-00311-00057527-00057687": "essentially industry proven software", "52WKAbQE_RM-00312-00057688-00057830": "solutions that we do with inspector bird", "52WKAbQE_RM-00313-00057832-00057966": "flies", "52WKAbQE_RM-00314-00057967-00058150": "that appliance form factor has been", "52WKAbQE_RM-00315-00058151-00058303": "absolutely monumental for us in the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00316-00058304-00058550": "distributed systems", "52WKAbQE_RM-00317-00058551-00058711": "and thanks for giving us a topic to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00318-00058712-00058887": "discuss at our socially distant", "52WKAbQE_RM-00319-00058888-00058959": "thanksgiving", "52WKAbQE_RM-00320-00058960-00059135": "table we'll talk about ibm i know now i", "52WKAbQE_RM-00321-00059136-00059375": "have great great fodder for conversation", "52WKAbQE_RM-00322-00059376-00059654": "aj over to you a lot of advances here", "52WKAbQE_RM-00323-00059655-00059711": "also", "52WKAbQE_RM-00324-00059712-00060038": "in such uh dynamic times i want to get", "52WKAbQE_RM-00325-00060039-00060271": "your perspective brocade's perspective", "52WKAbQE_RM-00326-00060272-00060342": "on", "52WKAbQE_RM-00327-00060344-00060479": "how you're taking advantage of these", "52WKAbQE_RM-00328-00060479-00060726": "latest technologies with ibm and also", "52WKAbQE_RM-00329-00060727-00060942": "from a customer's perspective what are", "52WKAbQE_RM-00330-00060944-00061119": "they are they feeling and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00331-00061120-00061359": "really being able to embrace and and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00332-00061360-00061430": "utilize", "52WKAbQE_RM-00333-00061432-00061687": "that simplicity that matt talked about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00334-00061688-00061750": "right", "52WKAbQE_RM-00335-00061751-00061935": "yeah so so there's a couple things that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00336-00061936-00062087": "that fall into that to be honest one of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00337-00062088-00062166": "which is that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00338-00062167-00062406": "similar to what what you heard brian", "52WKAbQE_RM-00339-00062407-00062615": "describe across the ibm portfolio for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00340-00062616-00062694": "storage", "52WKAbQE_RM-00341-00062695-00062919": "um in our san infrastructure it's a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00342-00062920-00063071": "single operating system up and down the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00343-00063072-00063223": "line so from the most entry-level", "52WKAbQE_RM-00344-00063224-00063391": "platform we have to the largest platform", "52WKAbQE_RM-00345-00063391-00063535": "we have it's a single software up and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00346-00063536-00063742": "down it's a technical management", "52WKAbQE_RM-00347-00063744-00064023": "environment up and down and it's also", "52WKAbQE_RM-00348-00064024-00064119": "intended to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00349-00064120-00064271": "extremely reliable and extremely", "52WKAbQE_RM-00350-00064272-00064415": "performant because you know here's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00351-00064416-00064559": "here's part of the challenge when", "52WKAbQE_RM-00352-00064560-00064847": "when matt's talking about um you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00353-00064848-00064959": "multiple petabytes", "52WKAbQE_RM-00354-00064960-00065191": "in a 2u rack height right but the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00355-00065191-00065326": "conversation you want to flip on its", "52WKAbQE_RM-00356-00065327-00065430": "head there a little bit is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00357-00065432-00065623": "okay exactly how many virtual machines", "52WKAbQE_RM-00358-00065624-00065767": "and how many applications are you going", "52WKAbQE_RM-00359-00065768-00065919": "to be driving out of that because it's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00360-00065920-00065999": "going to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00361-00066000-00066159": "thousands like between six and ten", "52WKAbQE_RM-00362-00066160-00066367": "thousand potentially out of that right", "52WKAbQE_RM-00363-00066368-00066631": "so imagine then if you have some sort of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00364-00066632-00066743": "little hiccup", "52WKAbQE_RM-00365-00066744-00067015": "in the connectivity to the data store", "52WKAbQE_RM-00366-00067016-00067047": "for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00367-00067048-00067215": "six thousand to ten thousand", "52WKAbQE_RM-00368-00067216-00067406": "applications that's not the kind of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00369-00067407-00067550": "thing people get forgiving about right", "52WKAbQE_RM-00370-00067551-00067631": "you know you the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00371-00067632-00067855": "the when we're all home like this when", "52WKAbQE_RM-00372-00067856-00067975": "we're when when", "52WKAbQE_RM-00373-00067976-00068094": "when you're healthcare when you're", "52WKAbQE_RM-00374-00068095-00068263": "financed when you're entertainment when", "52WKAbQE_RM-00375-00068264-00068431": "when everything is coming to you across", "52WKAbQE_RM-00376-00068432-00068559": "the network and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00377-00068560-00068759": "remotely in this fashion you know and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00378-00068760-00068975": "it's all application driven", "52WKAbQE_RM-00379-00068976-00069135": "you know the one thing that you want to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00380-00069136-00069311": "make sure of is that network doesn't", "52WKAbQE_RM-00381-00069312-00069447": "hiccup because humans have a lot of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00382-00069448-00069599": "really good characteristics patients", "52WKAbQE_RM-00383-00069600-00069631": "would", "52WKAbQE_RM-00384-00069632-00069831": "not be one of those and so you know you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00385-00069832-00069991": "you want to make sure that everything is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00386-00069992-00070167": "in fact in play and running and that's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00387-00070168-00070303": "it's one of the things that we work very", "52WKAbQE_RM-00388-00070304-00070550": "hard with with our friends at ibm to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00389-00070551-00070863": "to make sure of is that that um the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00390-00070864-00071038": "kinds of analytics that that matt was", "52WKAbQE_RM-00391-00071039-00071199": "just describing are things that you can", "52WKAbQE_RM-00392-00071200-00071359": "readily get done", "52WKAbQE_RM-00393-00071360-00071535": "it's the you know speed is the new", "52WKAbQE_RM-00394-00071536-00071711": "currency of business is a is a phrase", "52WKAbQE_RM-00395-00071712-00071862": "you hear from a quote you hear from from", "52WKAbQE_RM-00396-00071863-00072038": "mark benioff at salesforce right and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00397-00072039-00072206": "he's right you know if you can get data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00398-00072207-00072287": "out of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00399-00072288-00072438": "you know intelligence out of the data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00400-00072439-00072631": "you've been collecting that's really", "52WKAbQE_RM-00401-00072632-00072750": "cool but one of the other", "52WKAbQE_RM-00402-00072751-00072967": "sort of flip sides on the people not", "52WKAbQE_RM-00403-00072968-00073111": "being able to be in the data center and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00404-00073112-00073406": "then to matt's point not as many people", "52WKAbQE_RM-00405-00073407-00073591": "around either", "52WKAbQE_RM-00406-00073592-00073815": "is how are humans fast enough when you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00407-00073816-00073894": "look", "52WKAbQE_RM-00408-00073895-00073991": "honestly when you look at the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00409-00073992-00074143": "performance of the platforms these folks", "52WKAbQE_RM-00410-00074144-00074271": "are putting up", "52WKAbQE_RM-00411-00074272-00074494": "how is human response time going to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00412-00074495-00074679": "good enough and we all sort of have this", "52WKAbQE_RM-00413-00074680-00074871": "this headset of you know a network", "52WKAbQE_RM-00414-00074872-00075038": "operations center where you've got you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00415-00075039-00075135": "know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00416-00075136-00075350": "a couple dozen people in a half-lit room", "52WKAbQE_RM-00417-00075351-00075726": "staring at massive screens on the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00418-00075727-00075959": "something to pop right well okay if the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00419-00075960-00076135": "first time a red light pops the human", "52WKAbQE_RM-00420-00076136-00076326": "begins the investigation", "52WKAbQE_RM-00421-00076327-00076462": "at what point is that going to be good", "52WKAbQE_RM-00422-00076463-00076671": "enough and so our argument for the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00423-00076672-00076855": "autonomy piece of what we're doing in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00424-00076856-00076879": "the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00425-00076880-00077199": "in the fabrics is you can't wait", "52WKAbQE_RM-00426-00077200-00077543": "on the humans um you need to augment it", "52WKAbQE_RM-00427-00077544-00077719": "yes you know i get that that people", "52WKAbQE_RM-00428-00077720-00077838": "still want to be in charge and that's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00429-00077839-00077991": "that's good humans are still smarter", "52WKAbQE_RM-00430-00077992-00078182": "than the silicon we're not as repeatable", "52WKAbQE_RM-00431-00078183-00078447": "um but but we're still so far so far", "52WKAbQE_RM-00432-00078448-00078599": "smarter about it and so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00433-00078600-00078815": "you know we needed to be able to do that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00434-00078816-00078959": "measurement we need to be able to figure", "52WKAbQE_RM-00435-00078960-00079103": "out what normal looks like we need to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00436-00079104-00079215": "able to highlight to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00437-00079216-00079447": "the storage platform and and say the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00438-00079448-00079615": "application admins when things go", "52WKAbQE_RM-00439-00079616-00079750": "sideways", "52WKAbQE_RM-00440-00079751-00080055": "because the demand from the applications", "52WKAbQE_RM-00441-00080056-00080343": "isn't going to slow down the demands", "52WKAbQE_RM-00442-00080344-00080494": "from your environment you know whether", "52WKAbQE_RM-00443-00080495-00080606": "you want to think about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00444-00080607-00080823": "you know take the next steps with with", "52WKAbQE_RM-00445-00080824-00080999": "not just your home entertainment uh home", "52WKAbQE_RM-00446-00081000-00081135": "entertainment systems but", "52WKAbQE_RM-00447-00081136-00081391": "but learning augmented reality right", "52WKAbQE_RM-00448-00081392-00081559": "virtual reality environments for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00449-00081560-00081767": "for for for kids right how do you make", "52WKAbQE_RM-00450-00081768-00081918": "them feel like they're part and parcel", "52WKAbQE_RM-00451-00081919-00082103": "of of the of the classroom you know for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00452-00082104-00082326": "as long as we have to continue", "52WKAbQE_RM-00453-00082327-00082655": "living a modified world and perhaps past", "52WKAbQE_RM-00454-00082656-00082775": "it right you know if you can if you can", "52WKAbQE_RM-00455-00082776-00082903": "take a grade school from", "52WKAbQE_RM-00456-00082904-00083047": "you know from your local area and give", "52WKAbQE_RM-00457-00083048-00083175": "them a virtual walk through of the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00458-00083176-00083279": "louvre", "52WKAbQE_RM-00459-00083280-00083487": "where everybody's got a perfect view and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00460-00083488-00083591": "it all looks", "52WKAbQE_RM-00461-00083592-00083806": "incredibly real to them those are cool", "52WKAbQE_RM-00462-00083807-00083967": "things right those are cool applications", "52WKAbQE_RM-00463-00083968-00084079": "right if you can", "52WKAbQE_RM-00464-00084080-00084431": "figure out you know a new vaccine", "52WKAbQE_RM-00465-00084432-00084694": "faster right not a bad thing right you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00466-00084695-00084750": "know if", "52WKAbQE_RM-00467-00084751-00084950": "we can model better not a bad thing so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00468-00084951-00085126": "we need to enable those things we need", "52WKAbQE_RM-00469-00085127-00085335": "we need to not be the bottleneck which", "52WKAbQE_RM-00470-00085336-00085431": "is you know you get", "52WKAbQE_RM-00471-00085432-00085623": "get matt and brian over an adult", "52WKAbQE_RM-00472-00085624-00085767": "beverage at some point and ask them", "52WKAbQE_RM-00473-00085768-00085943": "about about the cycle time for the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00474-00085944-00086126": "silicon they're playing with", "52WKAbQE_RM-00475-00086127-00086287": "we've never had moore's law applied", "52WKAbQE_RM-00476-00086288-00086438": "external storage before", "52WKAbQE_RM-00477-00086439-00086567": "never in the history of external storage", "52WKAbQE_RM-00478-00086568-00086799": "has that been true until now", "52WKAbQE_RM-00479-00086800-00087126": "and so they're they're cycle times", "52WKAbQE_RM-00480-00087127-00087294": "matt right yeah you struck a nerve there", "52WKAbQE_RM-00481-00087295-00087479": "aj because it's it's pretty simple for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00482-00087480-00087606": "us to follow the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00483-00087607-00087855": "the linear increase in in capacity and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00484-00087856-00088023": "computational horsepower right do we", "52WKAbQE_RM-00485-00088024-00088094": "just", "52WKAbQE_RM-00486-00088095-00088359": "ride the x86 bandwagon ride the the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00487-00088360-00088423": "silicon", "52WKAbQE_RM-00488-00088424-00088623": "bandwagon but what we have to do in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00489-00088624-00088791": "order to maintain that simplicity story", "52WKAbQE_RM-00490-00088792-00088943": "is follow the more important ones the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00491-00088944-00089055": "resiliency factor", "52WKAbQE_RM-00492-00089056-00089231": "right because as we increase the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00493-00089232-00089447": "capacity as we increase the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00494-00089448-00089606": "the essentially the amount of data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00495-00089607-00089791": "responsible for each admin we have to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00496-00089792-00089967": "literally logarithmically increase the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00497-00089968-00090143": "resiliency of these boxes", "52WKAbQE_RM-00498-00090144-00090311": "because we talk about petabyte scale", "52WKAbQE_RM-00499-00090312-00090518": "systems and hosting you know really 10", "52WKAbQE_RM-00500-00090519-00090711": "000 virtual machines in the 2u form", "52WKAbQE_RM-00501-00090712-00090791": "factor", "52WKAbQE_RM-00502-00090792-00090967": "i need to be able to accommodate that to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00503-00090968-00091111": "make sure things don't blip", "52WKAbQE_RM-00504-00091112-00091279": "i need resilient networks right i need", "52WKAbQE_RM-00505-00091280-00091438": "to have redundancy and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00506-00091439-00091662": "access i need to have protection schemes", "52WKAbQE_RM-00507-00091663-00091887": "at every single layer of the stack", "52WKAbQE_RM-00508-00091888-00092047": "so we're quite happy to be able to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00509-00092048-00092271": "provide that right as we as we leapfrog", "52WKAbQE_RM-00510-00092272-00092431": "the industry and go in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00511-00092432-00092575": "literally situations that are three", "52WKAbQE_RM-00512-00092576-00092750": "times the competitive density that which", "52WKAbQE_RM-00513-00092751-00092894": "you see out there and other distributed", "52WKAbQE_RM-00514-00092895-00092967": "systems", "52WKAbQE_RM-00515-00092968-00093118": "that are still bound by the commercial", "52WKAbQE_RM-00516-00093119-00093359": "offerings then hey we also have to own", "52WKAbQE_RM-00517-00093360-00093550": "that risk from a vendor site", "52WKAbQE_RM-00518-00093551-00093767": "we have to make these things essentially", "52WKAbQE_RM-00519-00093768-00093943": "rate six protection scheme", "52WKAbQE_RM-00520-00093944-00094094": "equivalent from uh from a drive", "52WKAbQE_RM-00521-00094095-00094287": "standpoint and active active controllers", "52WKAbQE_RM-00522-00094288-00094382": "everywhere", "52WKAbQE_RM-00523-00094383-00094623": "be able to supply the performance and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00524-00094624-00094735": "consistency", "52WKAbQE_RM-00525-00094736-00094982": "uh of that service throughout even the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00526-00094983-00095159": "bad path situations", "52WKAbQE_RM-00527-00095160-00095326": "and to that point one of the things that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00528-00095327-00095487": "you talk about that's that's interesting", "52WKAbQE_RM-00529-00095488-00095550": "to me that i", "52WKAbQE_RM-00530-00095551-00095759": "i'd kind of like you to highlight is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00531-00095760-00095918": "your recovery times", "52WKAbQE_RM-00532-00095919-00096103": "right because bad things will happen", "52WKAbQE_RM-00533-00096104-00096303": "right and so you guys do something very", "52WKAbQE_RM-00534-00096304-00096503": "very different about that that's that's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00535-00096504-00096638": "critical to a lot of my customers", "52WKAbQE_RM-00536-00096639-00096831": "because they know that murphy will show", "52WKAbQE_RM-00537-00096832-00097047": "up one day", "52WKAbQE_RM-00538-00097048-00097206": "right so i mean because because it", "52WKAbQE_RM-00539-00097207-00097494": "happens right so then so then what", "52WKAbQE_RM-00540-00097495-00097679": "well speaking of that then what brian i", "52WKAbQE_RM-00541-00097680-00097831": "want to go over to you you talk", "52WKAbQE_RM-00542-00097832-00098023": "you mentioned matt mentioned resiliency", "52WKAbQE_RM-00543-00098024-00098143": "and if we think of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00544-00098144-00098487": "the situation that we're in in 2020", "52WKAbQE_RM-00545-00098488-00098767": "you know many companies are used to dr", "52WKAbQE_RM-00546-00098768-00098911": "and bc plans for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00547-00098912-00099223": "natural disasters pandemics", "52WKAbQE_RM-00548-00099224-00099471": "so as we look at the shift and then the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00549-00099472-00099694": "the volume of ransomware that's gone up", "52WKAbQE_RM-00550-00099695-00099879": "one ransomware attack every 11 seconds", "52WKAbQE_RM-00551-00099880-00100023": "this year right now", "52WKAbQE_RM-00552-00100024-00100359": "how brian are what's that change that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00553-00100360-00100526": "businesses need to make from", "52WKAbQE_RM-00554-00100527-00100903": "from cyber security to cyber resiliency", "52WKAbQE_RM-00555-00100904-00101118": "yeah you know it's it's a good point in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00556-00101119-00101262": "and i try to hammer that home with our", "52WKAbQE_RM-00557-00101263-00101343": "clients that hey", "52WKAbQE_RM-00558-00101344-00101471": "you're used to having your business", "52WKAbQE_RM-00559-00101472-00101687": "continuity disaster recovery", "52WKAbQE_RM-00560-00101688-00101903": "this whole cyber resiliency thing is a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00561-00101904-00102079": "completely separate practice", "52WKAbQE_RM-00562-00102080-00102335": "that we have to set up and think about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00563-00102336-00102463": "and go through the same", "52WKAbQE_RM-00564-00102464-00102647": "you know thought process that you did", "52WKAbQE_RM-00565-00102648-00102823": "for your dr what are you going to do", "52WKAbQE_RM-00566-00102824-00102927": "what are you going to protest how are", "52WKAbQE_RM-00567-00102928-00103063": "you going to how are you going to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00568-00103064-00103199": "you know test it how are you going to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00569-00103200-00103375": "detect whether or not you've got", "52WKAbQE_RM-00570-00103376-00103463": "ransomware", "52WKAbQE_RM-00571-00103464-00103606": "so i spent a lot of time with our", "52WKAbQE_RM-00572-00103607-00103823": "clients on that theme of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00573-00103824-00104071": "you have to think about and build your", "52WKAbQE_RM-00574-00104072-00104263": "cyber resiliency plan because", "52WKAbQE_RM-00575-00104264-00104534": "it's going to happen it's it's not like", "52WKAbQE_RM-00576-00104535-00104663": "a dr plan where", "52WKAbQE_RM-00577-00104664-00104895": "it's a pure insurance policy and when", "52WKAbQE_RM-00578-00104896-00104999": "like you said 11", "52WKAbQE_RM-00579-00105000-00105175": "every 11 seconds there's an event that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00580-00105176-00105383": "takes place it's going to be a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00581-00105383-00105727": "when not then if and then so you know we", "52WKAbQE_RM-00582-00105728-00105823": "have to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00583-00105824-00106023": "work with our customers to put in a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00584-00106024-00106183": "place uh", "52WKAbQE_RM-00585-00106183-00106407": "for cyber resiliency and then we spend a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00586-00106408-00106599": "lot of discussion on okay what does", "52WKAbQE_RM-00587-00106600-00106790": "that mean you know for my critical", "52WKAbQE_RM-00588-00106791-00106999": "applications from a restore time a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00589-00107000-00107095": "backup of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00590-00107096-00107375": "mutability what do we need for for those", "52WKAbQE_RM-00591-00107376-00107519": "types of services", "52WKAbQE_RM-00592-00107520-00107734": "right in terms of quick restore which", "52WKAbQE_RM-00593-00107735-00107951": "which are my tier zero applications that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00594-00107952-00108183": "i need to get back as fast as possible", "52WKAbQE_RM-00595-00108183-00108327": "you know what other ones can i you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00596-00108328-00108639": "stick out on tape or virtual tape in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00597-00108640-00108815": "and do things like that so again there's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00598-00108816-00109063": "a wide range of technology that we have", "52WKAbQE_RM-00599-00109064-00109278": "available in the in the portfolio for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00600-00109279-00109375": "helping", "52WKAbQE_RM-00601-00109376-00109663": "our clients from cyber resiliency and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00602-00109664-00109847": "then we try to distinguish that cyber", "52WKAbQE_RM-00603-00109848-00110095": "resiliency versus cyber security", "52WKAbQE_RM-00604-00110096-00110383": "so how do we keep everybody out from", "52WKAbQE_RM-00605-00110383-00110558": "from a cyber security view and then what", "52WKAbQE_RM-00606-00110559-00110823": "can we do from the cyber resiliency from", "52WKAbQE_RM-00607-00110824-00111015": "from a storage perspective to help them", "52WKAbQE_RM-00608-00111016-00111223": "once once it gets to us", "52WKAbQE_RM-00609-00111224-00111439": "that's a bad thing so how can we help", "52WKAbQE_RM-00610-00111440-00111631": "help our folks recover", "52WKAbQE_RM-00611-00111632-00111766": "well and at the point that you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00612-00111767-00111983": "you're making brian is that now it's not", "52WKAbQE_RM-00613-00111983-00112078": "a matter of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00614-00112079-00112271": "could this happen to us it's going to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00615-00112272-00112486": "how much can we tolerate but ultimately", "52WKAbQE_RM-00616-00112488-00112631": "we have to be able to recover we can't", "52WKAbQE_RM-00617-00112632-00112831": "restore that data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00618-00112832-00112975": "then you know you know and one of those", "52WKAbQE_RM-00619-00112976-00113175": "things when you talk about ransomware", "52WKAbQE_RM-00620-00113176-00113223": "and things", "52WKAbQE_RM-00621-00113224-00113431": "we go to that people as the weakest link", "52WKAbQE_RM-00622-00113432-00113607": "in security aj talked about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00623-00113608-00113783": "that there's the people yeah there's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00624-00113783-00113966": "probably quite a bit of lack of patience", "52WKAbQE_RM-00625-00113967-00114047": "going on", "52WKAbQE_RM-00626-00114048-00114231": "right now but as we look at asia i want", "52WKAbQE_RM-00627-00114232-00114343": "to go back over you to kind of look at", "52WKAbQE_RM-00628-00114344-00114543": "from a data center perspective and these", "52WKAbQE_RM-00629-00114544-00114775": "storage solutions being able to utilize", "52WKAbQE_RM-00630-00114776-00114895": "things to help the people", "52WKAbQE_RM-00631-00114896-00115158": "ai machine learning you talked about ar", "52WKAbQE_RM-00632-00115159-00115334": "vr talk to me a little bit more about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00633-00115335-00115383": "that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00634-00115383-00115599": "as you see say in the next you know 12", "52WKAbQE_RM-00635-00115600-00115766": "months or so as moving forward these", "52WKAbQE_RM-00636-00115767-00115871": "trends", "52WKAbQE_RM-00637-00115872-00116239": "these new solutions that are simplified", "52WKAbQE_RM-00638-00116240-00116447": "yeah so um a couple of things around", "52WKAbQE_RM-00639-00116448-00116575": "that one of which is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00640-00116576-00116839": "um this this iteration of of technology", "52WKAbQE_RM-00641-00116840-00116951": "you know the the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00642-00116952-00117190": "the storage platforms you know the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00643-00117191-00117327": "silicon they're making use of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00644-00117328-00117558": "and matt i think you're you told me 14", "52WKAbQE_RM-00645-00117559-00117647": "months is the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00646-00117648-00117878": "is roughly the silicon cycle that you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00647-00117879-00118031": "you guys are seeing right so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00648-00118032-00118175": "performance levels are going to continue", "52WKAbQE_RM-00649-00118176-00118366": "to go up this the speeds the speeds are", "52WKAbQE_RM-00650-00118367-00118558": "going to continue to go up", "52WKAbQE_RM-00651-00118559-00118695": "the scale is going to is going to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00652-00118696-00118823": "continue to shift and one of the things", "52WKAbQE_RM-00653-00118824-00118863": "that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00654-00118864-00119047": "that does for a lot of the application", "52WKAbQE_RM-00655-00119048-00119207": "owners is it lets them", "52WKAbQE_RM-00656-00119208-00119390": "think broader it lets them think bigger", "52WKAbQE_RM-00657-00119391-00119543": "and i wish i could tell you that i knew", "52WKAbQE_RM-00658-00119544-00119695": "what the next big application was going", "52WKAbQE_RM-00659-00119696-00119799": "to be but then we'd be having a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00660-00119800-00119943": "conversation about which island in the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00661-00119944-00120102": "pacific i was going to be retiring to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00662-00120103-00120158": "right", "52WKAbQE_RM-00663-00120159-00120439": "so but but but they're going to come and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00664-00120440-00120551": "they're going to they're going to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00665-00120552-00120702": "consume this performance because if you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00666-00120703-00120814": "look at the applications that you're", "52WKAbQE_RM-00667-00120815-00121023": "dealing with in your everyday life right", "52WKAbQE_RM-00668-00121024-00121190": "you know they continue to get broader", "52WKAbQE_RM-00669-00121191-00121375": "the scope of them continues to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00670-00121376-00121566": "to scale out right there's things that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00671-00121567-00121686": "we do you know i saw", "52WKAbQE_RM-00672-00121688-00121919": "i saw a um i think it was an mit", "52WKAbQE_RM-00673-00121920-00122039": "development recently where", "52WKAbQE_RM-00674-00122040-00122239": "they're talking about being able to and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00675-00122240-00122375": "they were originally doing it for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00676-00122376-00122566": "alzheimer's but uh and dementia but", "52WKAbQE_RM-00677-00122567-00122751": "they're talking about being able to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00678-00122752-00122958": "use the microphones in your smartphone", "52WKAbQE_RM-00679-00122959-00123095": "to listen to the way you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00680-00123096-00123366": "cough and use that as a predictor for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00681-00123367-00123399": "people", "52WKAbQE_RM-00682-00123400-00123654": "who have covid that are not symptomatic", "52WKAbQE_RM-00683-00123655-00123799": "yet so asymptomatic", "52WKAbQE_RM-00684-00123800-00123975": "people right so when we start talking", "52WKAbQE_RM-00685-00123976-00124110": "about where this where this", "52WKAbQE_RM-00686-00124111-00124254": "kind of technology can go and where it", "52WKAbQE_RM-00687-00124255-00124471": "can lead us right there's sort of this", "52WKAbQE_RM-00688-00124472-00124551": "unending", "52WKAbQE_RM-00689-00124552-00124727": "possibility for it but what that depends", "52WKAbQE_RM-00690-00124728-00124871": "on in part", "52WKAbQE_RM-00691-00124872-00125031": "is that the infrastructure has to be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00692-00125032-00125286": "extremely sound right the foundation has", "52WKAbQE_RM-00693-00125288-00125390": "to be there we", "52WKAbQE_RM-00694-00125391-00125654": "we have to have the the resilience the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00695-00125655-00125775": "reliability and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00696-00125776-00125902": "you know one of the points that brian", "52WKAbQE_RM-00697-00125903-00126078": "was just making you know is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00698-00126079-00126271": "is extremely key you know we we talk", "52WKAbQE_RM-00699-00126272-00126502": "about disaster tolerance right and and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00700-00126503-00126647": "you know business continuance well", "52WKAbQE_RM-00701-00126648-00126766": "business continuance is how do you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00702-00126767-00126871": "recover", "52WKAbQE_RM-00703-00126872-00127014": "cyber resilience is the same", "52WKAbQE_RM-00704-00127015-00127166": "conversation right you know so you have", "52WKAbQE_RM-00705-00127167-00127271": "the protection side of it you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00706-00127272-00127334": "here's my", "52WKAbQE_RM-00707-00127335-00127543": "here's my defenses now what happens when", "52WKAbQE_RM-00708-00127544-00127671": "they actually get in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00709-00127672-00127934": "right and you know let's let's be honest", "52WKAbQE_RM-00710-00127935-00127990": "right", "52WKAbQE_RM-00711-00127991-00128295": "humans are frequently that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00712-00128296-00128527": "weak link right for a variety of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00713-00128528-00128727": "behaviors that the humans that humans", "52WKAbQE_RM-00714-00128728-00128799": "have", "52WKAbQE_RM-00715-00128800-00129071": "um and so when when that happens you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00716-00129072-00129134": "know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00717-00129135-00129358": "where's the where's the software in the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00718-00129359-00129510": "storage that tells you hey wait there's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00719-00129511-00129558": "an odd", "52WKAbQE_RM-00720-00129559-00129751": "traffic behavior here where data's being", "52WKAbQE_RM-00721-00129752-00129902": "copied you know at", "52WKAbQE_RM-00722-00129903-00130158": "rates into locations that that are not", "52WKAbQE_RM-00723-00130159-00130278": "normal right and so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00724-00130279-00130439": "that's part of when we talk about what", "52WKAbQE_RM-00725-00130440-00130607": "we're doing in our side of the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00726-00130608-00130702": "automation is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00727-00130703-00130831": "how do you know what normal looks like", "52WKAbQE_RM-00728-00130832-00130975": "and once you know what normal looks like", "52WKAbQE_RM-00729-00130976-00131127": "you can figure out where the outliers", "52WKAbQE_RM-00730-00131128-00131183": "are", "52WKAbQE_RM-00731-00131184-00131375": "and that's one of the things that that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00732-00131376-00131511": "people use a lot for", "52WKAbQE_RM-00733-00131512-00131623": "trying to determine whether or not", "52WKAbQE_RM-00734-00131624-00131854": "ransomware is going on is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00735-00131855-00132119": "hey um this is a traffic pattern that's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00736-00132120-00132190": "new", "52WKAbQE_RM-00737-00132191-00132383": "this is a traffic pattern that's that's", "52WKAbQE_RM-00738-00132384-00132543": "different and you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00739-00132544-00132639": "are they doing this because they're", "52WKAbQE_RM-00740-00132640-00132766": "copying the data set from here to here", "52WKAbQE_RM-00741-00132767-00132927": "and encrypting it as they go", "52WKAbQE_RM-00742-00132928-00133135": "right because that's you know one of the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00743-00133136-00133271": "you know one of the challenges you gotta", "52WKAbQE_RM-00744-00133272-00133447": "you gotta watch for so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00745-00133448-00133663": "i think you're gonna see a lot of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00746-00133664-00133823": "advancement in the application space", "52WKAbQE_RM-00747-00133824-00133911": "you're gonna you know", "52WKAbQE_RM-00748-00133912-00134159": "and not just the the mit stuff which is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00749-00134160-00134247": "which is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00750-00134248-00134423": "great you know the fact that people are", "52WKAbQE_RM-00751-00134424-00134671": "actually able or i may have misspoken", "52WKAbQE_RM-00752-00134672-00134831": "maybe johns hopkins and i apologize to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00753-00134832-00135007": "the johns hopkins folks if it was but", "52WKAbQE_RM-00754-00135008-00135207": "you know that that kind of scenario", "52WKAbQE_RM-00755-00135208-00135407": "right it's there's no knowing", "52WKAbQE_RM-00756-00135408-00135687": "what they can um make use of here in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00757-00135688-00135766": "terms of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00758-00135767-00135975": "the data sets right because we're", "52WKAbQE_RM-00759-00135976-00136087": "gathering", "52WKAbQE_RM-00760-00136088-00136319": "so much data you know the the internet", "52WKAbQE_RM-00761-00136320-00136478": "of things is an overused", "52WKAbQE_RM-00762-00136479-00136790": "phrase but the the sheer volume of data", "52WKAbQE_RM-00763-00136791-00136943": "that's being generated outside of the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00764-00136944-00137078": "data center", "52WKAbQE_RM-00765-00137079-00137283": "but manipulated analyzed and stored", "52WKAbQE_RM-00766-00137284-00137407": "internally", "52WKAbQE_RM-00767-00137408-00137527": "right because you got to have it", "52WKAbQE_RM-00768-00137528-00137711": "someplace secure", "52WKAbQE_RM-00769-00137712-00137927": "right and you know that's that's one of", "52WKAbQE_RM-00770-00137928-00138095": "the things that we look at from our side", "52WKAbQE_RM-00771-00138096-00138175": "is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00772-00138176-00138407": "we've we've got to be that you know as", "52WKAbQE_RM-00773-00138408-00138575": "close to unbreakable as we can be and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00774-00138576-00138727": "then when things do break", "52WKAbQE_RM-00775-00138728-00138878": "able to figure out exactly what what", "52WKAbQE_RM-00776-00138879-00139087": "happened as rapidly as possible", "52WKAbQE_RM-00777-00139088-00139478": "um and then the recovery cycle as well", "52WKAbQE_RM-00778-00139479-00139614": "excellent and matt i want to finish with", "52WKAbQE_RM-00779-00139615-00139775": "you we just have a few seconds left but", "52WKAbQE_RM-00780-00139776-00139847": "as we as", "52WKAbQE_RM-00781-00139848-00139990": "aj was talking about this massive", "52WKAbQE_RM-00782-00139991-00140183": "evolution in applications for example we", "52WKAbQE_RM-00783-00140184-00140407": "talk about simplicity we talk about", "52WKAbQE_RM-00784-00140408-00140687": "resiliency and being able to recover", "52WKAbQE_RM-00785-00140688-00140839": "when something happens", "52WKAbQE_RM-00786-00140840-00141023": "how do these new technologies that we've", "52WKAbQE_RM-00787-00141024-00141239": "been unpacking today how do these help", "52WKAbQE_RM-00788-00141240-00141471": "the admin folks deal with all of the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00789-00141472-00141711": "dynamics that are happening today", "52WKAbQE_RM-00790-00141712-00141927": "yeah so i i think the the biggest uh", "52WKAbQE_RM-00791-00141928-00142095": "drop the mic thing we can say right now", "52WKAbQE_RM-00792-00142096-00142302": "is that we're delivering 100", "52WKAbQE_RM-00793-00142303-00142614": "tier zero nvme without", "52WKAbQE_RM-00794-00142615-00142863": "data reduction value props on top of it", "52WKAbQE_RM-00795-00142864-00142943": "at a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00796-00142944-00143302": "cost that undercuts off-prem s3 storage", "52WKAbQE_RM-00797-00143303-00143463": "so if you look at what you could do from", "52WKAbQE_RM-00798-00143464-00143678": "an off-prem solution for air gap and run", "52WKAbQE_RM-00799-00143679-00143823": "cyber resiliency", "52WKAbQE_RM-00800-00143824-00143983": "you can put your data somewhere else and", "52WKAbQE_RM-00801-00143984-00144135": "then it's going to take whatever long", "52WKAbQE_RM-00802-00144136-00144326": "time it to transfer the data back prem", "52WKAbQE_RM-00803-00144327-00144511": "to get back to your recover point", "52WKAbQE_RM-00804-00144512-00144663": "but when you work at economics that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00805-00144664-00144807": "we're doing right now in distributed", "52WKAbQE_RM-00806-00144808-00144959": "systems hey your dr", "52WKAbQE_RM-00807-00144960-00145247": "side your copies of data do not have to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00808-00145248-00145463": "wait for that off-prem bandwidth to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00809-00145464-00145599": "restore you can actually literally", "52WKAbQE_RM-00810-00145600-00145726": "restore in place", "52WKAbQE_RM-00811-00145727-00145902": "and you couple that with all the the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00812-00145903-00146071": "technology on the software side that", "52WKAbQE_RM-00813-00146072-00146190": "integrates with it", "52WKAbQE_RM-00814-00146191-00146335": "i get incremental point in time", "52WKAbQE_RM-00815-00146336-00146511": "recoveries either it's on the primary", "52WKAbQE_RM-00816-00146512-00146590": "side a dr", "52WKAbQE_RM-00817-00146591-00146839": "side wherever but the fact that we get", "52WKAbQE_RM-00818-00146840-00147039": "to approach this thing from a cost value", "52WKAbQE_RM-00819-00147040-00147087": "then", "52WKAbQE_RM-00820-00147088-00147271": "by all means i can naturally absorb a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00821-00147272-00147447": "lot of the cyber resiliency value in", "52WKAbQE_RM-00822-00147448-00147526": "that too", "52WKAbQE_RM-00823-00147527-00147671": "and because it's all getting all the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00824-00147672-00147847": "same orchestrated capabilities", "52WKAbQE_RM-00825-00147848-00148126": "regardless of the big small medium", "52WKAbQE_RM-00826-00148127-00148326": "all that stuff rise the same skill sets", "52WKAbQE_RM-00827-00148327-00148502": "and so i don't need to really learn new", "52WKAbQE_RM-00828-00148503-00148759": "platforms or new solutions to providing", "52WKAbQE_RM-00829-00148760-00148878": "cyber resiliency", "52WKAbQE_RM-00830-00148879-00149031": "it's just part of my day-to-day activity", "52WKAbQE_RM-00831-00149032-00149175": "because fundamentally all of us have to", "52WKAbQE_RM-00832-00149176-00149366": "wear that cyber resiliency hat", "52WKAbQE_RM-00833-00149367-00149590": "but as our job as a vendor is to make", "52WKAbQE_RM-00834-00149591-00149799": "that simple make it cost elegance and be", "52WKAbQE_RM-00835-00149800-00149935": "able to provide a essentially", "52WKAbQE_RM-00836-00149936-00150143": "homogeneous solutions overall", "52WKAbQE_RM-00837-00150144-00150383": "so hey as your business grows your risk", "52WKAbQE_RM-00838-00150384-00150583": "gets averted and your recovery means", "52WKAbQE_RM-00839-00150584-00150678": "also get uh", "52WKAbQE_RM-00840-00150679-00151014": "thwarted essentially by by your by your", "52WKAbQE_RM-00841-00151015-00151223": "incumbent solutions and architectures so", "52WKAbQE_RM-00842-00151224-00151335": "it's pretty cool stuff what we're doing", "52WKAbQE_RM-00843-00151336-00151495": "right now it is pretty cool and i'd say", "52WKAbQE_RM-00844-00151496-00151607": "a lot of folks would say that's the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00845-00151608-00151807": "nirvana but i think the message that the", "52WKAbQE_RM-00846-00151808-00151911": "three of you have", "52WKAbQE_RM-00847-00151912-00152102": "given in the last 20 minutes or so is", "52WKAbQE_RM-00848-00152103-00152335": "that ibm and broken together", "52WKAbQE_RM-00849-00152336-00152471": "this is a reality you guys are a", "52WKAbQE_RM-00850-00152472-00152687": "cornucopia of knowledge brian", "52WKAbQE_RM-00851-00152688-00152895": "matt aj thank you so much for joining me", "52WKAbQE_RM-00852-00152896-00153023": "on this panel i really", "52WKAbQE_RM-00853-00153024-00153247": "enjoyed our conversation thank you again", "52WKAbQE_RM-00854-00153248-00153343": "thank you", "52WKAbQE_RM-00855-00153344-00153599": "thank you my pleasure for my guests i'm", "52WKAbQE_RM-00856-00153600-00153743": "lisa martin you've been watching this", "52WKAbQE_RM-00857-00153744-00153919": "ibm brocade panel", "52WKAbQE_RM-00858-00153920-00154690": "on the cube", "52WKAbQE_RM-00859-00154691-00155175": "[Music]", "52WKAbQE_RM-00860-00155176-00155384": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "530G_wPek9g", "text": {"530G_wPek9g-00000-00000077-00000503": "[Music]", "530G_wPek9g-00001-00000504-00000663": "one of the problems we have when running", "530G_wPek9g-00002-00000664-00000734": "awards is", "530G_wPek9g-00003-00000735-00001070": "is is actually trying to fit", "530G_wPek9g-00004-00001071-00001335": "projects into categories and in true", "530G_wPek9g-00005-00001336-00001527": "experimental style we've decided to make", "530G_wPek9g-00006-00001528-00001679": "a new one this year", "530G_wPek9g-00007-00001680-00001791": "uh we've called it community", "530G_wPek9g-00008-00001792-00001918": "commendation because there was there was", "530G_wPek9g-00009-00001919-00002047": "a particular project that was entered", "530G_wPek9g-00010-00002048-00002142": "this year we", "530G_wPek9g-00011-00002143-00002487": "we felt deserve some recognition and", "530G_wPek9g-00012-00002488-00002734": "um we wanted to find a way to create", "530G_wPek9g-00013-00002735-00002815": "that so", "530G_wPek9g-00014-00002816-00003047": "um as recommended by our advisory board", "530G_wPek9g-00015-00003048-00003191": "we have created this new thing called", "530G_wPek9g-00016-00003192-00003335": "community commendation", "530G_wPek9g-00017-00003336-00003551": "um just to sort of set the context of", "530G_wPek9g-00018-00003552-00003783": "the kinds of things we were looking at", "530G_wPek9g-00019-00003784-00004095": "um these were not actually entered", "530G_wPek9g-00020-00004096-00004247": "but they're more sort of a historical", "530G_wPek9g-00021-00004248-00004454": "context a few years ago", "530G_wPek9g-00022-00004455-00004759": "maurice nicholson um", "530G_wPek9g-00023-00004760-00005006": "i think he's in the audience he is yes", "530G_wPek9g-00024-00005007-00005070": "um", "530G_wPek9g-00025-00005071-00005238": "retired pharmacist from boots if you", "530G_wPek9g-00026-00005239-00005383": "don't want me saying that", "530G_wPek9g-00027-00005384-00005718": "um maurice um helped", "530G_wPek9g-00028-00005719-00006015": "geotag i think i don't know thousands", "530G_wPek9g-00029-00006016-00006159": "and thousands of maps", "530G_wPek9g-00030-00006160-00006343": "within our collection that we found in", "530G_wPek9g-00031-00006344-00006534": "digitized books and others", "530G_wPek9g-00032-00006536-00006751": "um but this sort of gives a flavor of", "530G_wPek9g-00033-00006752-00006895": "the kinds of things we wanted to", "530G_wPek9g-00034-00006895-00007031": "recognize", "530G_wPek9g-00035-00007031-00007263": "um this is a project by keith gregson a", "530G_wPek9g-00036-00007264-00007406": "historian author", "530G_wPek9g-00037-00007408-00007710": "um who used our newspaper archive to", "530G_wPek9g-00038-00007711-00007895": "look at the social history of his", "530G_wPek9g-00039-00007895-00008134": "hometown sunderland and particularly", "530G_wPek9g-00040-00008136-00008414": "sunderland rugby club and he's also", "530G_wPek9g-00041-00008415-00008599": "published a few books", "530G_wPek9g-00042-00008600-00008767": "this is a project called the history of", "530G_wPek9g-00043-00008768-00008942": "roughly spring the pleasures of referee", "530G_wPek9g-00044-00008943-00009055": "spling by", "530G_wPek9g-00045-00009056-00009423": "spring by andrew clapham again sort of a", "530G_wPek9g-00046-00009424-00009671": "personal project a person they did that", "530G_wPek9g-00047-00009672-00009806": "in their own time and they use our", "530G_wPek9g-00048-00009807-00009927": "newspaper archive", "530G_wPek9g-00049-00009928-00010174": "and created a website on the history of", "530G_wPek9g-00050-00010175-00010359": "their local spring", "530G_wPek9g-00051-00010360-00010631": "this is netley abbey matters by brenda", "530G_wPek9g-00052-00010632-00010759": "findley", "530G_wPek9g-00053-00010760-00011142": "again she created this independently", "530G_wPek9g-00054-00011143-00011359": "using research from our newspaper", "530G_wPek9g-00055-00011360-00011463": "archives but", "530G_wPek9g-00056-00011464-00011710": "um that's kind of historical some of you", "530G_wPek9g-00057-00011711-00011855": "may have seen those entries from", "530G_wPek9g-00058-00011856-00012174": "a few years ago but um we wanted to give", "530G_wPek9g-00059-00012175-00012231": "a", "530G_wPek9g-00060-00012232-00012559": "a sort of a special recognition for", "530G_wPek9g-00061-00012560-00012902": "this award which is sorry this this", "530G_wPek9g-00062-00012903-00012974": "entry", "530G_wPek9g-00063-00012975-00013319": "which is um by leslie phillips", "530G_wPek9g-00064-00013319-00013703": "who created um a volume", "530G_wPek9g-00065-00013704-00014022": "of a detail accounts of the plays and", "530G_wPek9g-00066-00014023-00014175": "players working in the east midlands", "530G_wPek9g-00067-00014176-00014271": "theatre", "530G_wPek9g-00068-00014272-00014575": "circuit between 1843 and 1855", "530G_wPek9g-00069-00014576-00014751": "um especially with notes on the", "530G_wPek9g-00070-00014752-00014943": "background of the manager john fawcett", "530G_wPek9g-00071-00014944-00015086": "savile", "530G_wPek9g-00072-00015087-00015399": "the research uh depended heavenly or", "530G_wPek9g-00073-00015400-00015719": "sorry heavily not heavenly uh have", "530G_wPek9g-00074-00015719-00015958": "heavily on the use of online british", "530G_wPek9g-00075-00015959-00016143": "library playbills collection", "530G_wPek9g-00076-00016144-00016471": "and also the newspaper archive she used", "530G_wPek9g-00077-00016472-00016607": "transcriptions of playables and", "530G_wPek9g-00078-00016608-00016775": "newspaper articles to illustrate the", "530G_wPek9g-00079-00016776-00016919": "work", "530G_wPek9g-00080-00016920-00017063": "which has really contributed to the", "530G_wPek9g-00081-00017064-00017230": "knowledge of theater history", "530G_wPek9g-00082-00017231-00017543": "in the east midlands so i'd like to", "530G_wPek9g-00083-00017544-00017735": "invite leslie up to the stage to talk a", "530G_wPek9g-00084-00017736-00018167": "little bit about her project", "530G_wPek9g-00085-00018168-00018463": "thank you very much mahendra well as", "530G_wPek9g-00086-00018464-00018583": "mahendra said i", "530G_wPek9g-00087-00018584-00018830": "um i'll just uh explain that my project", "530G_wPek9g-00088-00018831-00018894": "was", "530G_wPek9g-00089-00018895-00019063": "to study the history of the east", "530G_wPek9g-00090-00019064-00019271": "midlands theatrical circuit", "530G_wPek9g-00091-00019272-00019494": "and as as he said it's resulted in a", "530G_wPek9g-00092-00019495-00019599": "volume", "530G_wPek9g-00093-00019600-00019814": "on giving a detailed account of the life", "530G_wPek9g-00094-00019815-00020143": "and work of one of the managers", "530G_wPek9g-00095-00020144-00020327": "if you see the east midlands circuit", "530G_wPek9g-00096-00020328-00020519": "goes as far as doncaster and down to", "530G_wPek9g-00097-00020520-00020622": "stamford it covers", "530G_wPek9g-00098-00020623-00020950": "quite a wide area i believe my work has", "530G_wPek9g-00099-00020951-00021175": "helped to shine a light on one aspect of", "530G_wPek9g-00100-00021176-00021391": "the lives of ordinary people", "530G_wPek9g-00101-00021392-00021655": "in the east midlands including the way", "530G_wPek9g-00102-00021656-00021919": "national events impacted on their lives", "530G_wPek9g-00103-00021920-00022111": "and i hope will prove to be a useful", "530G_wPek9g-00104-00022112-00022335": "resource to other researchers in the", "530G_wPek9g-00105-00022336-00022503": "future", "530G_wPek9g-00106-00022504-00022758": "i'll just say a few uh words on how i", "530G_wPek9g-00107-00022759-00022927": "came to do this", "530G_wPek9g-00108-00022928-00023263": "research um some years ago i was working", "530G_wPek9g-00109-00023264-00023439": "in chesterfield library as a local", "530G_wPek9g-00110-00023440-00023639": "studies librarian", "530G_wPek9g-00111-00023640-00023967": "and a frequent inquiry was why", "530G_wPek9g-00112-00023968-00024207": "is a small yard near the library called", "530G_wPek9g-00113-00024208-00024407": "theater yard when the theater", "530G_wPek9g-00114-00024408-00024719": "is on the other side of the town at the", "530G_wPek9g-00115-00024720-00024886": "time i was able to", "530G_wPek9g-00116-00024887-00025055": "tell people that the library was", "530G_wPek9g-00117-00025056-00025222": "actually built on the site of", "530G_wPek9g-00118-00025223-00025430": "chesterfield georgian theatre but i", "530G_wPek9g-00119-00025431-00025702": "didn't know much more about it", "530G_wPek9g-00120-00025704-00026062": "but in 2006 the", "530G_wPek9g-00121-00026063-00026270": "i was fortunate enough to be awarded a", "530G_wPek9g-00122-00026272-00026374": "bursary by", "530G_wPek9g-00123-00026375-00026655": "a combination of the british library", "530G_wPek9g-00124-00026656-00026831": "libraries and information east midlands", "530G_wPek9g-00125-00026832-00027039": "and the east midlands branch of psyllip", "530G_wPek9g-00126-00027039-00027246": "which enabled me to come and visit the", "530G_wPek9g-00127-00027247-00027399": "british library and do some more", "530G_wPek9g-00128-00027400-00027711": "research on the subject", "530G_wPek9g-00129-00027712-00027927": "this bursary was awarded with the aim of", "530G_wPek9g-00130-00027927-00028111": "raising awareness of the relevance of", "530G_wPek9g-00131-00028112-00028302": "the british library's resources", "530G_wPek9g-00132-00028304-00028551": "to these midlands and in my case", "530G_wPek9g-00133-00028552-00028831": "specifically to chesterfield", "530G_wPek9g-00134-00028832-00029031": "so of course for my project i chose to", "530G_wPek9g-00135-00029032-00029207": "investigate the history of that long", "530G_wPek9g-00136-00029208-00029483": "departed georgian theater in", "530G_wPek9g-00137-00029483-00029607": "chesterfield", "530G_wPek9g-00138-00029608-00029935": "and so here i am numerous articles", "530G_wPek9g-00139-00029936-00030223": "talks and library displays later now", "530G_wPek9g-00140-00030224-00030367": "retired", "530G_wPek9g-00141-00030368-00030527": "but still very much hooked on", "530G_wPek9g-00142-00030527-00030783": "investigating theater history", "530G_wPek9g-00143-00030783-00030967": "and i've extended my interest as you can", "530G_wPek9g-00144-00030968-00031246": "see now to encompass the whole of these", "530G_wPek9g-00145-00031247-00031414": "midland circuits", "530G_wPek9g-00146-00031416-00031687": "the digitization of newspapers books and", "530G_wPek9g-00147-00031688-00031887": "playbills over recent years", "530G_wPek9g-00148-00031888-00032055": "has really opened up a world of", "530G_wPek9g-00149-00032056-00032343": "opportunity in and inspiration", "530G_wPek9g-00150-00032344-00032718": "for individual researchers like me", "530G_wPek9g-00151-00032719-00032879": "yes i've had to travel around the", "530G_wPek9g-00152-00032880-00033102": "country to visit archives", "530G_wPek9g-00153-00033103-00033295": "but the vast quantity of british library", "530G_wPek9g-00154-00033296-00033479": "newspapers now digitised has been", "530G_wPek9g-00155-00033480-00033767": "immensely useful in saving time and", "530G_wPek9g-00156-00033768-00034046": "solving quite a few mysteries", "530G_wPek9g-00157-00034047-00034335": "and for my particular project the data", "530G_wPek9g-00158-00034336-00034471": "sets of playbills", "530G_wPek9g-00159-00034472-00034671": "once my son had unzipped them for me", "530G_wPek9g-00160-00034672-00034935": "because i don't know how to do that", "530G_wPek9g-00161-00034936-00035143": "has proved an immensely rich source of", "530G_wPek9g-00162-00035144-00035359": "information on many theaters", "530G_wPek9g-00163-00035360-00035623": "from dublin to edinburgh and those old", "530G_wPek9g-00164-00035624-00035927": "comedians really did get about", "530G_wPek9g-00165-00035928-00036135": "so it's all part of the wonderful", "530G_wPek9g-00166-00036136-00036279": "national collection", "530G_wPek9g-00167-00036280-00036479": "held at the british library that's now", "530G_wPek9g-00168-00036480-00036830": "available to you wherever you live", "530G_wPek9g-00169-00036831-00037087": "so i owe british library labs many", "530G_wPek9g-00170-00037088-00037190": "thanks", "530G_wPek9g-00171-00037191-00037455": "for allowing me even though i live 130", "530G_wPek9g-00172-00037456-00037623": "miles away from london", "530G_wPek9g-00173-00037624-00037830": "to access some of the british library's", "530G_wPek9g-00174-00037831-00037999": "wonderful collections", "530G_wPek9g-00175-00038000-00038246": "and to feed what has become something of", "530G_wPek9g-00176-00038247-00038390": "an obsession", "530G_wPek9g-00177-00038391-00038567": "an obsession which has seen me travel to", "530G_wPek9g-00178-00038568-00038735": "wolverhampton manchester", "530G_wPek9g-00179-00038736-00038967": "and norwich and even seen me in a", "530G_wPek9g-00180-00038968-00039095": "cemetery in nottingham", "530G_wPek9g-00181-00039096-00039335": "pulling ivy off a monument with my bare", "530G_wPek9g-00182-00039336-00039495": "hands", "530G_wPek9g-00183-00039496-00039679": "i feel very grateful and honored to", "530G_wPek9g-00184-00039680-00039902": "receive this community commendation", "530G_wPek9g-00185-00039903-00040927": "thank you", "530G_wPek9g-00186-00040928-00041136": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "5315HKCPavo", "text": {"5315HKCPavo-00000-00000581-00000869": "hi so", "5315HKCPavo-00001-00000869-00001162": "I am super excited about circling energy", "5315HKCPavo-00002-00001163-00001439": "I have found something I want to say", "5315HKCPavo-00003-00001440-00001793": "Eureka I found it and also say maybe", "5315HKCPavo-00004-00001794-00001984": "it's not for everybody I get caught up", "5315HKCPavo-00005-00001985-00002260": "in these tools that when I find", "5315HKCPavo-00006-00002261-00002507": "something like oh it can help everyone", "5315HKCPavo-00007-00002508-00002831": "since it helped me so much and is still", "5315HKCPavo-00008-00002832-00003076": "helping me", "5315HKCPavo-00009-00003077-00003251": "and it's", "5315HKCPavo-00010-00003252-00003503": "a way of being", "5315HKCPavo-00011-00003504-00003838": "that is integrated into my life but it's", "5315HKCPavo-00012-00003839-00004061": "also this practice", "5315HKCPavo-00013-00004061-00004270": "that is allowed", "5315HKCPavo-00014-00004271-00004615": "there's so much change that I have", "5315HKCPavo-00015-00004616-00005002": "strived for in the last 30 years", "5315HKCPavo-00016-00005003-00005470": "with very little long-term success", "5315HKCPavo-00017-00005471-00005879": "um I have", "5315HKCPavo-00018-00005880-00006238": "done several vipassana 10-day silent", "5315HKCPavo-00019-00006239-00006570": "meditations I have done certified in", "5315HKCPavo-00020-00006572-00006955": "neuro-linguistic programming hypnosis", "5315HKCPavo-00021-00006956-00007403": "intuitive massage I", "5315HKCPavo-00022-00007404-00007781": "was getting my masters and family", "5315HKCPavo-00023-00007781-00008074": "marriage and family counseling", "5315HKCPavo-00024-00008075-00008464": "and uh didn't complete that out of", "5315HKCPavo-00025-00008465-00009113": "philosophical reasons", "5315HKCPavo-00026-00009114-00009473": "Landmark Education there's a long list", "5315HKCPavo-00027-00009474-00010145": "ayahuasca", "5315HKCPavo-00028-00010146-00010289": "just", "5315HKCPavo-00029-00010290-00010595": "feels like a lifetime of seeking and", "5315HKCPavo-00030-00010596-00010871": "reading every book and asking Eckhart", "5315HKCPavo-00031-00010872-00011095": "Tolle how", "5315HKCPavo-00032-00011096-00011578": "how do I remain equanimous in the face", "5315HKCPavo-00033-00011579-00011849": "of such atrocities", "5315HKCPavo-00034-00011850-00012185": "how do I not react", "5315HKCPavo-00035-00012186-00012509": "to", "5315HKCPavo-00036-00012510-00012695": "as Oprah had to help me in the question", "5315HKCPavo-00037-00012696-00012827": "on the", "5315HKCPavo-00038-00012828-00013066": "on The Talk", "5315HKCPavo-00039-00013067-00013355": "the book club of", "5315HKCPavo-00040-00013356-00014188": "cartolis", "5315HKCPavo-00041-00014190-00014458": "and it was all philosophical it was all", "5315HKCPavo-00042-00014459-00014783": "a philosophical answer it was all like", "5315HKCPavo-00043-00014784-00015136": "this is how it works mentally", "5315HKCPavo-00044-00015137-00015455": "like Eckhart totally is there he is in", "5315HKCPavo-00045-00015456-00015863": "the presence and he's sharing from there", "5315HKCPavo-00046-00015863-00016036": "to be present", "5315HKCPavo-00047-00016037-00016625": "and in that presence you", "5315HKCPavo-00048-00016626-00016900": "aren't angry", "5315HKCPavo-00049-00016901-00017063": "about", "5315HKCPavo-00050-00017064-00017225": "issues that you're passionate about", "5315HKCPavo-00051-00017226-00017489": "where you see injustices and", "5315HKCPavo-00052-00017490-00017939": "innocence", "5315HKCPavo-00053-00017940-00018233": "not being protected", "5315HKCPavo-00054-00018234-00018958": "lives being lost", "5315HKCPavo-00055-00018959-00019175": "and then it goes bigger into like a", "5315HKCPavo-00056-00019176-00019450": "collective brief", "5315HKCPavo-00057-00019451-00019727": "we're experiencing those of us who can", "5315HKCPavo-00058-00019728-00019997": "still feel", "5315HKCPavo-00059-00019998-00020855": "into this", "5315HKCPavo-00060-00020856-00021772": "so years of seeking and here I am", "5315HKCPavo-00061-00021773-00022157": "was a new tool that", "5315HKCPavo-00062-00022158-00022522": "is keeping me", "5315HKCPavo-00063-00022523-00022858": "alive because I can still feel the pain", "5315HKCPavo-00064-00022859-00023155": "of the things that I think are", "5315HKCPavo-00065-00023156-00023489": "unjust and sad and", "5315HKCPavo-00066-00023490-00024136": "I've long to change them", "5315HKCPavo-00067-00024137-00024557": "and", "5315HKCPavo-00068-00024558-00024850": "also can hold the beauty", "5315HKCPavo-00069-00024851-00025091": "of life itself", "5315HKCPavo-00070-00025092-00025618": "of what is here", "5315HKCPavo-00071-00025619-00026170": "and that's how I'm surviving now", "5315HKCPavo-00072-00026172-00026712": "um", "5315HKCPavo-00073-00026713-00026939": "so that's", "5315HKCPavo-00074-00026939-00027377": "to answer why or how that's like", "5315HKCPavo-00075-00027377-00027629": "the results of this practice have been", "5315HKCPavo-00076-00027630-00027917": "that so this section would be like", "5315HKCPavo-00077-00027918-00028229": "somehow talking about results", "5315HKCPavo-00078-00028230-00028505": "what's so unique about circling energy", "5315HKCPavo-00079-00028506-00028852": "is it's not as concrete as say an anger", "5315HKCPavo-00080-00028854-00029068": "management class", "5315HKCPavo-00081-00029069-00029290": "or even some of the", "5315HKCPavo-00082-00029291-00029507": "practices that are very similar to", "5315HKCPavo-00083-00029508-00029824": "circling energy", "5315HKCPavo-00084-00029825-00030029": "that of structure", "5315HKCPavo-00085-00030030-00030262": "and what has drawn me into circling", "5315HKCPavo-00086-00030263-00030502": "where I found it through this circle", "5315HKCPavo-00087-00030504-00030646": "anywhere", "5315HKCPavo-00088-00030647-00030827": "which was was originally part of", "5315HKCPavo-00089-00030827-00031055": "circling Europe which are all changing", "5315HKCPavo-00090-00031056-00031229": "names now or", "5315HKCPavo-00091-00031230-00031390": "I don't know", "5315HKCPavo-00092-00031391-00031529": "but", "5315HKCPavo-00093-00031530-00032051": "I found the least amount of structure", "5315HKCPavo-00094-00032052-00032243": "I love how it was described to me in the", "5315HKCPavo-00095-00032244-00032537": "beginning as the wild west of this new", "5315HKCPavo-00096-00032538-00032885": "technology of basically re-wiring your", "5315HKCPavo-00097-00032886-00033124": "brain", "5315HKCPavo-00098-00033125-00033707": "so it's a way to rewire your brain", "5315HKCPavo-00099-00033708-00033881": "without", "5315HKCPavo-00100-00033882-00034199": "actually attempting", "5315HKCPavo-00101-00034200-00034924": "that we re-wiring", "5315HKCPavo-00102-00034925-00035107": "it's getting very", "5315HKCPavo-00103-00035108-00035374": "esoteric or psychedelic in my brain like", "5315HKCPavo-00104-00035375-00035771": "the wiring in your brain is fluid", "5315HKCPavo-00105-00035772-00036052": "but it becomes so ingrained in certain", "5315HKCPavo-00106-00036053-00036418": "ways that it becomes very", "5315HKCPavo-00107-00036419-00036640": "solid and like in my mind it's like", "5315HKCPavo-00108-00036641-00036862": "actual wires and you're you're watching", "5315HKCPavo-00109-00036863-00037031": "the movie and they're trying to rewire", "5315HKCPavo-00110-00037032-00037223": "it so the bomb doesn't go off and the", "5315HKCPavo-00111-00037224-00037462": "clock is ticking and you're wondering is", "5315HKCPavo-00112-00037463-00037673": "the clock the same clock time as the", "5315HKCPavo-00113-00037674-00037823": "actual movie time and then you're like", "5315HKCPavo-00114-00037824-00038099": "out of the movie doing meta like how did", "5315HKCPavo-00115-00038100-00038273": "they make the movie but then you go back", "5315HKCPavo-00116-00038274-00038573": "in", "5315HKCPavo-00117-00038574-00038729": "and you gotta make sure you cut the", "5315HKCPavo-00118-00038730-00038890": "white right wires or you're going to", "5315HKCPavo-00119-00038891-00039311": "blow", "5315HKCPavo-00120-00039312-00039611": "it can feel like that it can feel like", "5315HKCPavo-00121-00039612-00040007": "you're if you cut the wrong wire", "5315HKCPavo-00122-00040008-00040649": "you might explode", "5315HKCPavo-00123-00040650-00040907": "because they're so a part of us but", "5315HKCPavo-00124-00040908-00041152": "they're really", "5315HKCPavo-00125-00041153-00041429": "actually", "5315HKCPavo-00126-00041430-00041549": "fluid", "5315HKCPavo-00127-00041550-00041735": "if you can get", "5315HKCPavo-00128-00041736-00042035": "into a space of fluidity", "5315HKCPavo-00129-00042036-00042274": "and you can't get there", "5315HKCPavo-00130-00042275-00042707": "if you're trying to cut the wires", "5315HKCPavo-00131-00042708-00042952": "you can't get there if you think you", "5315HKCPavo-00132-00042953-00043151": "need to be fixed it's all these", "5315HKCPavo-00133-00043152-00043427": "oxymorons and contradictions and co-ans", "5315HKCPavo-00134-00043428-00043829": "that all fit into circling energy like", "5315HKCPavo-00135-00043830-00044261": "we don't try", "5315HKCPavo-00136-00044262-00044537": "to do anything but", "5315HKCPavo-00137-00044538-00044795": "I let you", "5315HKCPavo-00138-00044796-00045449": "change me", "5315HKCPavo-00139-00045450-00045658": "which is one of the main foundations", "5315HKCPavo-00140-00045659-00046001": "we're working on", "5315HKCPavo-00141-00046002-00046211": "and so if I started there and go into a", "5315HKCPavo-00142-00046212-00046474": "deep dive into letting you change me I'm", "5315HKCPavo-00143-00046475-00047015": "coming from this place of", "5315HKCPavo-00144-00047016-00047446": "I don't know everything", "5315HKCPavo-00145-00047447-00047795": "a little bit porous", "5315HKCPavo-00146-00047796-00048089": "and it's sometimes for me I go to the", "5315HKCPavo-00147-00048090-00048365": "extreme of I don't know anything", "5315HKCPavo-00148-00048366-00048545": "to get to", "5315HKCPavo-00149-00048546-00048884": "I don't know everything"}}, {"audio_id": "53gkn3Tgq-k", "text": {"53gkn3Tgq-k-00000-00000000-00000248": "Shepard press Sydney Shepherd press", "53gkn3Tgq-k-00001-00000249-00000578": "Sydney Shepherd press Sydney Shepard", "53gkn3Tgq-k-00002-00000579-00000853": "press Sydney Shepard press Sydney", "53gkn3Tgq-k-00003-00000855-00001136": "Shepard press Sydney Shepherd press", "53gkn3Tgq-k-00004-00001137-00001466": "Sydney Shepherd press Sydney Shepherd", "53gkn3Tgq-k-00005-00001467-00001943": "press Sydney Shepherd press Sydney"}}, {"audio_id": "53tv45Yqb5k", "text": {"53tv45Yqb5k-00000-00000383-00000644": "let's go through book maps screenshot", "53tv45Yqb5k-00001-00000645-00000872": "tool located here on the toolbar", "53tv45Yqb5k-00002-00000873-00001091": "now however before we take a screenshot", "53tv45Yqb5k-00003-00001092-00001307": "you may want to annotate your book map", "53tv45Yqb5k-00004-00001308-00001579": "chart using book map drawing tools that", "53tv45Yqb5k-00005-00001580-00001904": "are located here once annotated let's go", "53tv45Yqb5k-00006-00001905-00002101": "back and click on the screenshot tool", "53tv45Yqb5k-00007-00002102-00002345": "and up pops a thumbnail of the", "53tv45Yqb5k-00008-00002346-00002606": "screenshot now we have the options here", "53tv45Yqb5k-00009-00002607-00002956": "to post to Twitter Facebook upload or", "53tv45Yqb5k-00010-00002957-00003197": "store locally if it's stored locally", "53tv45Yqb5k-00011-00003198-00003413": "this is where it's going to be on the C", "53tv45Yqb5k-00012-00003414-00003683": "Drive here let's click post to Twitter", "53tv45Yqb5k-00013-00003684-00003997": "and click OK and up pops the browser", "53tv45Yqb5k-00014-00003999-00004256": "here now I'm already logged into my", "53tv45Yqb5k-00015-00004257-00004346": "Twitter account", "53tv45Yqb5k-00016-00004347-00004688": "ok and I have the link here as well as", "53tv45Yqb5k-00017-00004689-00004988": "the book map hashtag and I'll just put", "53tv45Yqb5k-00018-00004989-00005636": "in the text here test Twitter and let's", "53tv45Yqb5k-00019-00005637-00005930": "send the tweet ok my tweet has been", "53tv45Yqb5k-00020-00005931-00006335": "posted let's view the tweet here click", "53tv45Yqb5k-00021-00006336-00006595": "on that and you can see test Twitter is", "53tv45Yqb5k-00022-00006597-00006794": "here and here's the image that I just", "53tv45Yqb5k-00023-00006795-00007498": "uploaded let's delete this and let's go", "53tv45Yqb5k-00024-00007500-00007705": "back to the other screen shot options", "53tv45Yqb5k-00025-00007706-00008044": "click back on the screenshot tool here", "53tv45Yqb5k-00026-00008045-00008324": "will bypass posting to Facebook the", "53tv45Yqb5k-00027-00008325-00008549": "functionality is very much the same as", "53tv45Yqb5k-00028-00008550-00008831": "that of Twitter but let's upload and", "53tv45Yqb5k-00029-00008832-00009112": "copy the URL and click OK", "53tv45Yqb5k-00030-00009113-00009439": "ok so now the image has been uploaded", "53tv45Yqb5k-00031-00009440-00009758": "and the URL has been copied to my", "53tv45Yqb5k-00032-00009759-00010067": "clipboard and click OK here and we'll", "53tv45Yqb5k-00033-00010068-00010358": "demo this by opening up a separate tab", "53tv45Yqb5k-00034-00010359-00010660": "here and I'm gonna right click here and", "53tv45Yqb5k-00035-00010661-00011039": "input paste and go and here's the image", "53tv45Yqb5k-00036-00011040-00011660": "URL that we just copied let's click on", "53tv45Yqb5k-00037-00011661-00011842": "the screenshot tool once more here and", "53tv45Yqb5k-00038-00011843-00012049": "we'll go through the last icon which is", "53tv45Yqb5k-00039-00012050-00012383": "stored locally ok you also have the", "53tv45Yqb5k-00040-00012384-00012599": "option to your to remember my choice so", "53tv45Yqb5k-00041-00012600-00012802": "this window doesn't always have to pop", "53tv45Yqb5k-00042-00012803-00013183": "up if you want to very quickly post the", "53tv45Yqb5k-00043-00013184-00013475": "image to Twitter or Facebook now if you", "53tv45Yqb5k-00044-00013476-00013663": "do choose this option", "53tv45Yqb5k-00045-00013663-00013879": "you can do here let's close this window", "53tv45Yqb5k-00046-00013880-00014122": "is you can right click back on this", "53tv45Yqb5k-00047-00014122-00014344": "screenshot tool and you have the", "53tv45Yqb5k-00048-00014344-00014638": "different options that pop up here okay", "53tv45Yqb5k-00049-00014638-00014847": "now let's just left-click again and", "53tv45Yqb5k-00050-00014849-00015133": "we're going to store the image locally", "53tv45Yqb5k-00051-00015134-00015338": "and click OK", "53tv45Yqb5k-00052-00015340-00015565": "alright and then let's go to our", "53tv45Yqb5k-00053-00015566-00015835": "directory here we know that it's in the", "53tv45Yqb5k-00054-00015836-00016222": "C Drive it's in the book map folder and", "53tv45Yqb5k-00055-00016222-00016642": "it is under screenshots here and then", "53tv45Yqb5k-00056-00016643-00017080": "this is the image that I just saved"}}, {"audio_id": "53vXL_2RCGy", "text": {"53vXL_2RCGy-00000-00000180-00001902": "[Music]", "53vXL_2RCGy-00001-00001903-00002126": "in undertaking any study of the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00002-00002127-00002367": "series from a thematic point of view", "53vXL_2RCGy-00003-00002368-00002542": "it is best to commence with one of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00004-00002543-00002767": "themes that for want of a better term", "53vXL_2RCGy-00005-00002768-00003087": "permeates the entire series this is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00006-00003088-00003270": "primarily for the reason that while some", "53vXL_2RCGy-00007-00003271-00003454": "of the dominant themes perpetuate", "53vXL_2RCGy-00008-00003455-00003590": "throughout the series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00009-00003592-00003831": "others peter out to a certain extent and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00010-00003832-00004031": "while not ignored altogether", "53vXL_2RCGy-00011-00004032-00004231": "lose a sense of their prominence as the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00012-00004232-00004438": "narrative continues", "53vXL_2RCGy-00013-00004439-00004631": "this is not hard to comprehend when we", "53vXL_2RCGy-00014-00004632-00004863": "look at the enormity of the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00015-00004864-00005095": "both in terms of its actual length and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00016-00005096-00005295": "the sheer epic scale of the story", "53vXL_2RCGy-00017-00005296-00005495": "which takes place over several thousand", "53vXL_2RCGy-00018-00005496-00005631": "years", "53vXL_2RCGy-00019-00005632-00005838": "in saying that evolution as a theme", "53vXL_2RCGy-00020-00005839-00006015": "permeates the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00021-00006016-00006238": "i mean that is a theme strong at both", "53vXL_2RCGy-00022-00006239-00006478": "the beginning and the end of the series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00023-00006479-00006663": "and maintains within it the details of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00024-00006664-00006855": "the other major focal points of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00025-00006856-00006998": "story", "53vXL_2RCGy-00026-00007000-00007198": "some of the major themes do diminish as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00027-00007200-00007342": "the narrative progresses", "53vXL_2RCGy-00028-00007343-00007583": "but herbert ensures evolution remains a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00029-00007584-00007839": "constant throughout the series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00030-00007840-00008119": "evolution including eugenics and genetic", "53vXL_2RCGy-00031-00008120-00008223": "engineering", "53vXL_2RCGy-00032-00008224-00008423": "represent one of the most detailed and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00033-00008424-00008614": "lengthy thematic explorations in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00034-00008615-00008727": "june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00035-00008728-00008910": "and although tertiary to the other", "53vXL_2RCGy-00036-00008911-00009063": "dominant themes", "53vXL_2RCGy-00037-00009064-00009327": "it is to a degree much more expansive in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00038-00009328-00009463": "scope", "53vXL_2RCGy-00039-00009464-00009687": "as mentioned earlier frank herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00040-00009688-00009967": "themes are complexly intertwined", "53vXL_2RCGy-00041-00009968-00010174": "like the threads in an intricately woven", "53vXL_2RCGy-00042-00010175-00010278": "tapestry", "53vXL_2RCGy-00043-00010279-00010478": "and are difficult to tease apart upon", "53vXL_2RCGy-00044-00010479-00010703": "individual examination", "53vXL_2RCGy-00045-00010704-00010919": "towards that understanding it must be", "53vXL_2RCGy-00046-00010920-00011087": "noted that the theme of evolution and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00047-00011088-00011327": "genetic engineering does much to inform", "53vXL_2RCGy-00048-00011328-00011510": "herbert's approach to his superhuman", "53vXL_2RCGy-00049-00011511-00011638": "protagonists", "53vXL_2RCGy-00050-00011639-00011846": "themselves products of evolution through", "53vXL_2RCGy-00051-00011847-00012031": "either artificial selection based", "53vXL_2RCGy-00052-00012032-00012151": "breeding programs", "53vXL_2RCGy-00053-00012152-00012414": "genetic engineering or forced evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00054-00012415-00012638": "by symbiotic mutation", "53vXL_2RCGy-00055-00012639-00012910": "in knowing this then we can realize how", "53vXL_2RCGy-00056-00012911-00013111": "evolution and genetic engineering as a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00057-00013112-00013183": "theme", "53vXL_2RCGy-00058-00013184-00013383": "shapes and helps realize the first of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00059-00013384-00013622": "herbert's two major themes in june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00060-00013623-00013855": "that of the catastrophic hero and the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00061-00013856-00014055": "periodic messianic impulses that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00062-00014056-00014263": "overtake society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00063-00014263-00014447": "evolution and genetic engineering are", "53vXL_2RCGy-00064-00014447-00014638": "also viewed as systems", "53vXL_2RCGy-00065-00014640-00014879": "and tools of the long-term expansion and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00066-00014880-00015086": "survival of the human species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00067-00015087-00015255": "in his provision of the second of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00068-00015256-00015447": "june series major themes", "53vXL_2RCGy-00069-00015447-00015719": "that of ecology evolution as a system", "53vXL_2RCGy-00070-00015719-00015966": "for the development and survival of life", "53vXL_2RCGy-00071-00015968-00016183": "is in turn influenced by the ecology of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00072-00016184-00016311": "a given environment", "53vXL_2RCGy-00073-00016312-00016647": "and vice versa collectively all three of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00074-00016648-00016855": "these themes are seen most importantly", "53vXL_2RCGy-00075-00016856-00016958": "by herbert", "53vXL_2RCGy-00076-00016959-00017343": "as systems utilized by human beings", "53vXL_2RCGy-00077-00017344-00017558": "the importance of understanding systemic", "53vXL_2RCGy-00078-00017559-00017871": "thinking especially in a long-term scale", "53vXL_2RCGy-00079-00017872-00018094": "is crucial in realizing how these themes", "53vXL_2RCGy-00080-00018095-00018263": "interact and weave together in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00081-00018264-00018527": "narrative of the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00082-00018528-00018743": "systemic thinking is similarly important", "53vXL_2RCGy-00083-00018744-00018958": "to herbert in presenting ecology", "53vXL_2RCGy-00084-00018959-00019191": "as a subject for investigation", "53vXL_2RCGy-00085-00019192-00019383": "especially due to the differences he", "53vXL_2RCGy-00086-00019384-00019471": "perceived", "53vXL_2RCGy-00087-00019472-00019830": "between western man and tribal societies", "53vXL_2RCGy-00088-00019831-00020030": "likewise it is crucial in understanding", "53vXL_2RCGy-00089-00020031-00020230": "the socio-political trappings that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00090-00020231-00020494": "develop around charismatic leadership", "53vXL_2RCGy-00091-00020495-00020711": "herbert's examination of evolution and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00092-00020712-00020935": "genetics fundamentally adds to his", "53vXL_2RCGy-00093-00020936-00021039": "speculation", "53vXL_2RCGy-00094-00021040-00021343": "on each of these complementing topics as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00095-00021344-00021535": "evolution and genetics are themes from", "53vXL_2RCGy-00096-00021536-00021727": "subject matter in science and science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00097-00021728-00021919": "fiction from the mid to late 19th", "53vXL_2RCGy-00098-00021920-00022055": "century onwards", "53vXL_2RCGy-00099-00022056-00022263": "herbert's discourse on these topics is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00100-00022264-00022455": "in itself an evolutionary one", "53vXL_2RCGy-00101-00022456-00022607": "that we are able to witness for", "53vXL_2RCGy-00102-00022608-00022839": "ourselves as the millennia slip by", "53vXL_2RCGy-00103-00022840-00022967": "within the narrative", "53vXL_2RCGy-00104-00022968-00023294": "of the june universe frank herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00105-00023295-00023503": "examination of evolution and genetics in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00106-00023504-00023622": "the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00107-00023623-00023814": "came from his desire to subvert the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00108-00023815-00024030": "contemporary mode of science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00109-00024031-00024247": "as it was in its state of stagnancy", "53vXL_2RCGy-00110-00024248-00024599": "during the 1950s and 1960s", "53vXL_2RCGy-00111-00024600-00024863": "primarily this desire was based on two", "53vXL_2RCGy-00112-00024864-00024975": "approaches", "53vXL_2RCGy-00113-00024976-00025191": "firstly to turn the tide against the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00114-00025192-00025455": "typical nature of science fiction heroes", "53vXL_2RCGy-00115-00025456-00025687": "especially the vanvatian hero that had", "53vXL_2RCGy-00116-00025688-00025927": "been recurring since the 40s", "53vXL_2RCGy-00117-00025927-00026118": "this hero was often a mutation of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00118-00026119-00026262": "baseline humans", "53vXL_2RCGy-00119-00026263-00026455": "modeled on the concept of an evolved", "53vXL_2RCGy-00120-00026456-00026599": "ubermensch", "53vXL_2RCGy-00121-00026600-00026814": "this was in its essence an individual", "53vXL_2RCGy-00122-00026816-00026927": "protagonist", "53vXL_2RCGy-00123-00026927-00027127": "who was usually set apart from the rest", "53vXL_2RCGy-00124-00027127-00027246": "of humanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00125-00027247-00027439": "often possessing unique powers and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00126-00027439-00027639": "abilities granted to them because of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00127-00027639-00027870": "their evolutionary differences", "53vXL_2RCGy-00128-00027872-00028062": "characters from science fiction stories", "53vXL_2RCGy-00129-00028063-00028207": "that featured superman", "53vXL_2RCGy-00130-00028208-00028431": "were a favorite of john w campbell the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00131-00028432-00028711": "editor of amazing stories and analog", "53vXL_2RCGy-00132-00028712-00028895": "on the premise that science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00133-00028895-00029079": "stories were the kind of stories that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00134-00029080-00029343": "science fiction editors by many of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00135-00029344-00029551": "works featuring in these publications", "53vXL_2RCGy-00136-00029552-00029927": "began to follow this trend secondly", "53vXL_2RCGy-00137-00029927-00030135": "as this trend was tied to the future", "53vXL_2RCGy-00138-00030136-00030262": "evolution of man", "53vXL_2RCGy-00139-00030263-00030479": "and because science fiction seemed to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00140-00030480-00030631": "becoming more a literature that was", "53vXL_2RCGy-00141-00030632-00030743": "viewed as being", "53vXL_2RCGy-00142-00030744-00030974": "in the gutter herbert wanted to write a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00143-00030975-00031102": "work of some length", "53vXL_2RCGy-00144-00031103-00031311": "that was more aspiring towards quality", "53vXL_2RCGy-00145-00031312-00031590": "literature than pulp fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00146-00031591-00031783": "this was also in part to do with the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00147-00031783-00031967": "fact that herbert often had trouble", "53vXL_2RCGy-00148-00031968-00032118": "writing shorter works", "53vXL_2RCGy-00149-00032119-00032302": "his stories often going over the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00150-00032303-00032599": "prescribed word length for publication", "53vXL_2RCGy-00151-00032600-00032799": "in having evolution combined with the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00152-00032800-00033062": "dangers of society's messianic impulses", "53vXL_2RCGy-00153-00033063-00033111": "towards", "53vXL_2RCGy-00154-00033112-00033415": "unusual and highly charismatic leaders", "53vXL_2RCGy-00155-00033416-00033631": "it was towards victorian science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00156-00033632-00033807": "that he turned for his inspiration with", "53vXL_2RCGy-00157-00033808-00033918": "these themes", "53vXL_2RCGy-00158-00033919-00034118": "and in particular to the works of samuel", "53vXL_2RCGy-00159-00034119-00034359": "butler and to a lesser extent", "53vXL_2RCGy-00160-00034360-00034671": "edward bull were leighton notably it was", "53vXL_2RCGy-00161-00034672-00034823": "this kind of fiction that herbert", "53vXL_2RCGy-00162-00034824-00034959": "favored in his youth", "53vXL_2RCGy-00163-00034960-00035190": "before proudly declaring his intentions", "53vXL_2RCGy-00164-00035191-00035311": "of being an author", "53vXL_2RCGy-00165-00035312-00035646": "to his bemused family evolution has been", "53vXL_2RCGy-00166-00035647-00035846": "a popular topic for consideration from", "53vXL_2RCGy-00167-00035847-00036046": "the earliest forms of the genre", "53vXL_2RCGy-00168-00036047-00036223": "and can be found in many a work which", "53vXL_2RCGy-00169-00036224-00036423": "existed prior to the great spur of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00170-00036424-00036511": "subject", "53vXL_2RCGy-00171-00036512-00036774": "namely on the origin of species by means", "53vXL_2RCGy-00172-00036775-00036918": "of natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-00173-00036919-00037215": "by charles darwin brian's table for", "53vXL_2RCGy-00174-00037216-00037415": "gendry on evolution in the encyclopedia", "53vXL_2RCGy-00175-00037416-00037527": "of science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00176-00037528-00037783": "2nd edition sums up the relationship", "53vXL_2RCGy-00177-00037784-00037999": "between science fiction and evolutionary", "53vXL_2RCGy-00178-00038000-00038230": "theory quite elegantly when he states", "53vXL_2RCGy-00179-00038231-00038302": "that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00180-00038303-00038487": "there is inevitably an intimate", "53vXL_2RCGy-00181-00038488-00038646": "connection between the development of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00182-00038647-00038815": "evolutionary philosophy", "53vXL_2RCGy-00183-00038816-00039062": "and the history of science fiction in a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00184-00039063-00039215": "culture without an evolutionary", "53vXL_2RCGy-00185-00039216-00039318": "philosophy", "53vXL_2RCGy-00186-00039319-00039471": "most of the kinds of fiction we", "53vXL_2RCGy-00187-00039472-00039655": "categorize as science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00188-00039656-00039943": "could not develop while there is an", "53vXL_2RCGy-00189-00039944-00040127": "abundance of work within the genre", "53vXL_2RCGy-00190-00040128-00040399": "exploring issues relating to evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00191-00040400-00040615": "stableford is not so optimistic when", "53vXL_2RCGy-00192-00040616-00040815": "discussing genetics within science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00193-00040816-00041087": "fiction if not self-promoting", "53vXL_2RCGy-00194-00041088-00041262": "stableford's entry on genetic", "53vXL_2RCGy-00195-00041263-00041430": "engineering in the encyclopedia of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00196-00041431-00041527": "science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00197-00041528-00041727": "describes the genre's forays into the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00198-00041728-00041935": "subject as showing little that is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00199-00041936-00042102": "championing the cause of genetic", "53vXL_2RCGy-00200-00042103-00042399": "engineering although stableford is to a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00201-00042400-00042527": "degree correct here", "53vXL_2RCGy-00202-00042528-00042735": "when he describes the quizadz hadorak", "53vXL_2RCGy-00203-00042736-00042879": "breeding program of june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00204-00042880-00043143": "as a pedestrian affair of long-range", "53vXL_2RCGy-00205-00043144-00043246": "eugenics", "53vXL_2RCGy-00206-00043247-00043455": "he repeats the common mistake of only", "53vXL_2RCGy-00207-00043456-00043639": "looking at the first part of herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00208-00043640-00043743": "series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00209-00043744-00043958": "june may focus almost entirely on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00210-00043959-00044151": "results of the bene desert breeding", "53vXL_2RCGy-00211-00044152-00044230": "program", "53vXL_2RCGy-00212-00044231-00044423": "but in ignoring the other books in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00213-00044424-00044655": "series one fails to notice the many", "53vXL_2RCGy-00214-00044656-00044855": "other concepts of genetic engineering", "53vXL_2RCGy-00215-00044856-00045039": "and associated technologies", "53vXL_2RCGy-00216-00045040-00045327": "as they evolve throughout the series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00217-00045328-00045511": "genetic engineering is viewed as the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00218-00045512-00045767": "language of god by the bene tlilax", "53vXL_2RCGy-00219-00045768-00045990": "and the nature of their own patriarchal", "53vXL_2RCGy-00220-00045991-00046079": "society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00221-00046080-00046255": "is crucial to the development of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00222-00046256-00046399": "story it", "53vXL_2RCGy-00223-00046400-00046599": "is just unfortunate that the only part", "53vXL_2RCGy-00224-00046600-00046830": "of the series that they do not appear in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00225-00046831-00047158": "is june itself stableford ends his", "53vXL_2RCGy-00226-00047159-00047311": "article in the encyclopedia by", "53vXL_2RCGy-00227-00047312-00047415": "demonstrating", "53vXL_2RCGy-00228-00047416-00047590": "that the potential for science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00229-00047591-00047735": "stories that focus on genetic", "53vXL_2RCGy-00230-00047736-00047839": "engineering", "53vXL_2RCGy-00231-00047840-00048143": "is far from being realized", "53vXL_2RCGy-00232-00048144-00048327": "it cannot be said that science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00233-00048328-00048502": "writers have as yet explored the real", "53vXL_2RCGy-00234-00048503-00048583": "potential", "53vXL_2RCGy-00235-00048584-00048799": "which genetic engineering technologies", "53vXL_2RCGy-00236-00048800-00048983": "hold for the radical remaking of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00237-00048984-00049086": "human world", "53vXL_2RCGy-00238-00049087-00049286": "but a beginning of sorts is made by the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00239-00049287-00049479": "speculative future history", "53vXL_2RCGy-00240-00049480-00049735": "the third millennium by brian stapleford", "53vXL_2RCGy-00241-00049736-00049862": "and david langford", "53vXL_2RCGy-00242-00049863-00050055": "and by stableford's various spin-off", "53vXL_2RCGy-00243-00050056-00050223": "short stories some of which are", "53vXL_2RCGy-00244-00050224-00050311": "collected in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00245-00050312-00050558": "sexual chemistry tales of the genetic", "53vXL_2RCGy-00246-00050559-00050727": "revolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00247-00050728-00050943": "it is because of the verisimilitude that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00248-00050944-00051111": "the themes of evolution and genetic", "53vXL_2RCGy-00249-00051112-00051183": "engineering", "53vXL_2RCGy-00250-00051184-00051382": "lend to the historical backdrop of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00251-00051383-00051494": "june universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-00252-00051495-00051663": "that frank herbert's notions and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00253-00051664-00051870": "concepts of this subject matter", "53vXL_2RCGy-00254-00051871-00052070": "bolster and reinforce the other", "53vXL_2RCGy-00255-00052071-00052342": "predominant themes in the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00256-00052344-00052575": "herbert's approach to evolution as we", "53vXL_2RCGy-00257-00052576-00052663": "shall see", "53vXL_2RCGy-00258-00052664-00052863": "is not just presented to the reader as a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00259-00052864-00052982": "singular path", "53vXL_2RCGy-00260-00052983-00053182": "that humanity may take down its journey", "53vXL_2RCGy-00261-00053183-00053375": "of development as a species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00262-00053376-00053575": "but rather as something altogether more", "53vXL_2RCGy-00263-00053576-00053782": "chaotic and complex", "53vXL_2RCGy-00264-00053783-00053982": "this is often a trend in science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00265-00053983-00054215": "literature that tends to explore either", "53vXL_2RCGy-00266-00054216-00054423": "a particularly single viewpoint", "53vXL_2RCGy-00267-00054424-00054623": "for example the martians in the war of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00268-00054624-00054815": "the worlds or occasionally for the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00269-00054816-00055038": "benefit of contrast and comparison", "53vXL_2RCGy-00270-00055039-00055238": "a dual presentation of mankind's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00271-00055239-00055447": "evolution such as the eloy", "53vXL_2RCGy-00272-00055448-00055687": "and morlocks in hg wells is the time", "53vXL_2RCGy-00273-00055688-00055830": "machine", "53vXL_2RCGy-00274-00055832-00056007": "the epic scale of the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00275-00056008-00056166": "instead provides herbert", "53vXL_2RCGy-00276-00056167-00056375": "with the scope to explore many different", "53vXL_2RCGy-00277-00056376-00056550": "avenues of evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00278-00056551-00056750": "while also giving him the room to show", "53vXL_2RCGy-00279-00056751-00056879": "it as a process", "53vXL_2RCGy-00280-00056879-00057159": "which systems technology and human", "53vXL_2RCGy-00281-00057160-00057271": "conventions", "53vXL_2RCGy-00282-00057272-00057487": "continue to alter and adapt over a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00283-00057488-00057726": "lengthy time scale", "53vXL_2RCGy-00284-00057727-00057950": "at the heart of the june universe in its", "53vXL_2RCGy-00285-00057951-00058079": "cultural social", "53vXL_2RCGy-00286-00058079-00058382": "religious technological and ultimately", "53vXL_2RCGy-00287-00058383-00058550": "evolutionary spheres", "53vXL_2RCGy-00288-00058551-00058742": "is the event known as the butlerian", "53vXL_2RCGy-00289-00058744-00058894": "jihad", "53vXL_2RCGy-00290-00058895-00059111": "the butlerian jihad functions in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00291-00059112-00059263": "same manner to june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00292-00059264-00059559": "as j.r.r tolkien's history and languages", "53vXL_2RCGy-00293-00059560-00059759": "of middle earth do so with the lord of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00294-00059760-00059887": "the rings", "53vXL_2RCGy-00295-00059888-00060094": "that is it lends to the narrative a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00296-00060095-00060342": "believable and well realized historical", "53vXL_2RCGy-00297-00060344-00060438": "background", "53vXL_2RCGy-00298-00060439-00060679": "that in turn permeates effortlessly into", "53vXL_2RCGy-00299-00060679-00060919": "the narrative of the story's present day", "53vXL_2RCGy-00300-00060920-00061126": "the butlerian jihad is a long war", "53vXL_2RCGy-00301-00061127-00061263": "between humanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00302-00061264-00061559": "and thinking machines one of the results", "53vXL_2RCGy-00303-00061560-00061687": "of this holy war", "53vXL_2RCGy-00304-00061688-00061863": "is the development of the commission of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00305-00061864-00062047": "ecumenical translators", "53vXL_2RCGy-00306-00062048-00062254": "which simultaneously destroys some", "53vXL_2RCGy-00307-00062255-00062430": "religions that are resistant to its", "53vXL_2RCGy-00308-00062432-00062526": "edicts", "53vXL_2RCGy-00309-00062527-00062750": "whilst merging and integrating others", "53vXL_2RCGy-00310-00062751-00062999": "that are more open and susceptible", "53vXL_2RCGy-00311-00063000-00063247": "this action places humanity in a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00312-00063248-00063438": "downward attivistic spiral", "53vXL_2RCGy-00313-00063439-00063623": "through its prohibition of intelligent", "53vXL_2RCGy-00314-00063624-00063926": "machines or artificial intelligence", "53vXL_2RCGy-00315-00063927-00064175": "the butlerian jihad creates a universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-00316-00064176-00064382": "that exhibits many qualities of a feudal", "53vXL_2RCGy-00317-00064383-00064463": "society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00318-00064464-00064671": "where people fear what machines may", "53vXL_2RCGy-00319-00064672-00064799": "become", "53vXL_2RCGy-00320-00064800-00065015": "as the butlerian jihad retards the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00321-00065016-00065223": "development and ultimately evolution of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00322-00065224-00065366": "thinking machines", "53vXL_2RCGy-00323-00065367-00065606": "it serves to spur human evolution down", "53vXL_2RCGy-00324-00065607-00065806": "differing paths", "53vXL_2RCGy-00325-00065807-00065991": "many of the ideas presented through the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00326-00065992-00066135": "butler in jihad", "53vXL_2RCGy-00327-00066136-00066311": "show herbert understanding and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00328-00066312-00066487": "referencing quite deliberately more", "53vXL_2RCGy-00329-00066488-00066694": "traditional and earlier works of science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00330-00066695-00066775": "fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00331-00066776-00066967": "and especially the ideas of samuel", "53vXL_2RCGy-00332-00066968-00067223": "butler the victorian iconoclast and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00333-00067224-00067438": "novelist who first presented many of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00334-00067439-00067503": "notions", "53vXL_2RCGy-00335-00067504-00067806": "that are extrapolated in june butler's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00336-00067807-00068015": "fame was in part for his novels", "53vXL_2RCGy-00337-00068016-00068231": "especially the posthumously published", "53vXL_2RCGy-00338-00068232-00068406": "the way of all flesh", "53vXL_2RCGy-00339-00068407-00068694": "but also as an iconoclast he amusingly", "53vXL_2RCGy-00340-00068695-00068919": "snapped at the inadequacies of victorian", "53vXL_2RCGy-00341-00068920-00069079": "society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00342-00069080-00069335": "however butler is also well remembered", "53vXL_2RCGy-00343-00069336-00069591": "for his very public if rather one-sided", "53vXL_2RCGy-00344-00069592-00069775": "spat with charles darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-00345-00069776-00069975": "over his ideas on evolution and the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00346-00069976-00070103": "origin of species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00347-00070104-00070303": "despite having been an earlier supporter", "53vXL_2RCGy-00348-00070304-00070447": "of darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-00349-00070448-00070863": "samuel butler's erawan published in 1872", "53vXL_2RCGy-00350-00070864-00071143": "is a pastoral utopia set in new zealand", "53vXL_2RCGy-00351-00071144-00071343": "and is paramount to understanding many", "53vXL_2RCGy-00352-00071344-00071559": "of the underlying concepts and dominant", "53vXL_2RCGy-00353-00071560-00071599": "themes", "53vXL_2RCGy-00354-00071600-00071823": "in june it is a novel of great", "53vXL_2RCGy-00355-00071824-00071911": "significance", "53vXL_2RCGy-00356-00071912-00072094": "not just during the early years of its", "53vXL_2RCGy-00357-00072095-00072294": "initial anonymous publication", "53vXL_2RCGy-00358-00072295-00072503": "but remains so today with the study of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00359-00072504-00072719": "science fiction as a genre", "53vXL_2RCGy-00360-00072720-00072982": "erawan presents itself as a satire that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00361-00072983-00073206": "looks into both victorian values", "53vXL_2RCGy-00362-00073207-00073359": "and the storm that brewed in that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00363-00073360-00073550": "society in the following years", "53vXL_2RCGy-00364-00073551-00073759": "after the publication of darwin's on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00365-00073760-00073903": "origin of species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00366-00073904-00074303": "in 1859 it is perhaps not only the first", "53vXL_2RCGy-00367-00074304-00074519": "book to explore the concept of machine", "53vXL_2RCGy-00368-00074520-00074606": "evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00369-00074607-00074767": "in light of the theory of natural", "53vXL_2RCGy-00370-00074768-00074975": "selection and all that implied the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00371-00074976-00075150": "victorian society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00372-00075151-00075367": "but is also probably the first work to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00373-00075368-00075591": "speculate on the nature of artificial", "53vXL_2RCGy-00374-00075592-00075694": "intelligence", "53vXL_2RCGy-00375-00075695-00076031": "on technological singularity these are", "53vXL_2RCGy-00376-00076032-00076167": "themes that have come to dominate", "53vXL_2RCGy-00377-00076168-00076359": "science fiction in recent years", "53vXL_2RCGy-00378-00076360-00076511": "especially within the realms of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00379-00076512-00076759": "cyberpunk and the recently re-emerged", "53vXL_2RCGy-00380-00076760-00076982": "and reinvigorated space operas", "53vXL_2RCGy-00381-00076983-00077223": "popularized by the likes of e m banks", "53vXL_2RCGy-00382-00077224-00077350": "alistair reynolds", "53vXL_2RCGy-00383-00077351-00077687": "and don simmons the bottlerian jihad", "53vXL_2RCGy-00384-00077688-00077903": "represents a turning point in history", "53vXL_2RCGy-00385-00077904-00078087": "for herbert's june universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-00386-00078088-00078247": "and is the palette from which he was", "53vXL_2RCGy-00387-00078248-00078438": "able to draw so many of his memorable", "53vXL_2RCGy-00388-00078439-00078662": "characters and institutions", "53vXL_2RCGy-00389-00078663-00078879": "it underlies two of herbert's key", "53vXL_2RCGy-00390-00078880-00079038": "warnings in the novels", "53vXL_2RCGy-00391-00079039-00079294": "firstly that of a society that blindly", "53vXL_2RCGy-00392-00079295-00079423": "follows leaders", "53vXL_2RCGy-00393-00079424-00079703": "and secondly the inherent dependencies", "53vXL_2RCGy-00394-00079704-00079887": "that human beings develop", "53vXL_2RCGy-00395-00079888-00080094": "specifically centered on the reliance of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00396-00080095-00080303": "machines and technology", "53vXL_2RCGy-00397-00080304-00080519": "timothy o'reilly in his book frank", "53vXL_2RCGy-00398-00080520-00080735": "herbert suggests that the butlerian", "53vXL_2RCGy-00399-00080736-00080887": "jihad comes from a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00400-00080888-00081119": "direct result of the fear of computers", "53vXL_2RCGy-00401-00081120-00081247": "in our own culture", "53vXL_2RCGy-00402-00081248-00081438": "based upon an article that frank herbert", "53vXL_2RCGy-00403-00081439-00081599": "had written from the san francisco", "53vXL_2RCGy-00404-00081600-00081679": "examiner", "53vXL_2RCGy-00405-00081680-00082023": "in 1968 this premise is incorrect", "53vXL_2RCGy-00406-00082024-00082094": "however", "53vXL_2RCGy-00407-00082095-00082223": "although the fear of machines", "53vXL_2RCGy-00408-00082224-00082423": "progressing beyond human beings in an", "53vXL_2RCGy-00409-00082424-00082575": "evolutionary advancement", "53vXL_2RCGy-00410-00082576-00082806": "was the key idea presented in butler's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00411-00082807-00082918": "error", "53vXL_2RCGy-00412-00082919-00083103": "herbert himself was interested in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00413-00083104-00083294": "computers and used them in his work as a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00414-00083295-00083367": "writer", "53vXL_2RCGy-00415-00083368-00083535": "at one point investing money into the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00416-00083536-00083747": "development of a new computer system in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00417-00083748-00083926": "1979", "53vXL_2RCGy-00418-00083927-00084150": "the events of the june series begin in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00419-00084151-00084511": "the year 10191 after guild", "53vXL_2RCGy-00420-00084512-00084975": "approximately the year 24 191 a.d", "53vXL_2RCGy-00421-00084976-00085215": "the butler in jihad itself commences in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00422-00085216-00085375": "201 bg", "53vXL_2RCGy-00423-00085376-00085631": "which is before the guild and finally", "53vXL_2RCGy-00424-00085632-00085815": "ends in the year 108", "53vXL_2RCGy-00425-00085816-00086094": "bg this period of history in the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00426-00086095-00086159": "universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-00427-00086160-00086350": "is a crucible focused around the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00428-00086351-00086526": "oppression of humanity by thinking", "53vXL_2RCGy-00429-00086527-00086631": "machines", "53vXL_2RCGy-00430-00086632-00086879": "which spurs a revolt and ultimately a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00431-00086880-00087094": "jihad to eliminate these machines", "53vXL_2RCGy-00432-00087095-00087231": "completely", "53vXL_2RCGy-00433-00087232-00087438": "it is in the upheaval that is created in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00434-00087439-00087694": "the aftermath of humanity's victory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00435-00087695-00087959": "that causes a fundamental transformation", "53vXL_2RCGy-00436-00087960-00088182": "to every single aspect of the human", "53vXL_2RCGy-00437-00088183-00088326": "universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-00438-00088327-00088591": "then came the butlerian jihad two", "53vXL_2RCGy-00439-00088592-00088782": "generations of chaos", "53vXL_2RCGy-00440-00088783-00089006": "the god of machine logic was overthrown", "53vXL_2RCGy-00441-00089007-00089126": "among the masses", "53vXL_2RCGy-00442-00089127-00089431": "and a new concept was raised man may not", "53vXL_2RCGy-00443-00089432-00089582": "be replaced", "53vXL_2RCGy-00444-00089583-00089750": "we learn a great deal of the butlerian", "53vXL_2RCGy-00445-00089751-00089991": "jihad from the second appendix of june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00446-00089992-00090294": "entitled the religion of jude the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00447-00090295-00090494": "purpose of this appendix is to highlight", "53vXL_2RCGy-00448-00090495-00090671": "the dominant religious systems in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00449-00090672-00090750": "imperium", "53vXL_2RCGy-00450-00090751-00090894": "and illustrate if there is any", "53vXL_2RCGy-00451-00090895-00091143": "similarity to the religion of moa deep", "53vXL_2RCGy-00452-00091144-00091399": "when he sits upon the golden throne", "53vXL_2RCGy-00453-00091400-00091606": "prior to the ascent of paul moadi", "53vXL_2RCGy-00454-00091607-00091759": "betrays on arrakis", "53vXL_2RCGy-00455-00091760-00091959": "on his rise to the position of emperor", "53vXL_2RCGy-00456-00091960-00092118": "and messiah of the fremen", "53vXL_2RCGy-00457-00092119-00092279": "the religious beliefs of the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00458-00092280-00092482": "universe are shaped by a number of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00459-00092483-00092735": "forces herbert tells us in the second", "53vXL_2RCGy-00460-00092736-00092815": "appendix", "53vXL_2RCGy-00461-00092816-00093135": "that these are as follows 1.", "53vXL_2RCGy-00462-00093136-00093335": "the orange catholic bible produced at", "53vXL_2RCGy-00463-00093336-00093599": "the commission of ecumenical translators", "53vXL_2RCGy-00464-00093600-00094055": "the cet 2. the bani jesuit", "53vXL_2RCGy-00465-00094056-00094318": "3. the ruling classes of the lands rand", "53vXL_2RCGy-00466-00094319-00094399": "and the guild", "53vXL_2RCGy-00467-00094400-00094631": "who are essentially agnostic and truth", "53vXL_2RCGy-00468-00094632-00094959": "but use religion as a tool of statecraft", "53vXL_2RCGy-00469-00094960-00095238": "4. the ancient teachings which include", "53vXL_2RCGy-00470-00095239-00095374": "buddhism teachings", "53vXL_2RCGy-00471-00095375-00095599": "hinduism the zen sunni wanderers", "53vXL_2RCGy-00472-00095600-00095743": "variants of islam", "53vXL_2RCGy-00473-00095744-00095974": "a variety of eastern faiths and the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00474-00095975-00096247": "butlerian jihad itself", "53vXL_2RCGy-00475-00096248-00096567": "5. space travel possibly the most", "53vXL_2RCGy-00476-00096568-00096743": "important of all", "53vXL_2RCGy-00477-00096744-00096982": "as a result of the butlerian jihad", "53vXL_2RCGy-00478-00096983-00097150": "herbert tells us that two major", "53vXL_2RCGy-00479-00097151-00097311": "developments took place within the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00480-00097312-00097535": "religious spheres of the empire", "53vXL_2RCGy-00481-00097536-00097774": "the first of these was the realization", "53vXL_2RCGy-00482-00097775-00097982": "that all religions had at least one", "53vXL_2RCGy-00483-00097983-00098150": "common commandment", "53vXL_2RCGy-00484-00098151-00098455": "thou shalt not disfigure the soul the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00485-00098456-00098615": "second of these developments was the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00486-00098616-00098903": "commission of ecumenical translators", "53vXL_2RCGy-00487-00098904-00099206": "the purpose of the cet was essentially", "53vXL_2RCGy-00488-00099207-00099415": "to examine the nature of all the faiths", "53vXL_2RCGy-00489-00099416-00099526": "in the empire", "53vXL_2RCGy-00490-00099527-00099711": "and produce a common work of religious", "53vXL_2RCGy-00491-00099712-00099999": "beliefs and after seven years of work", "53vXL_2RCGy-00492-00100000-00100150": "they eventually produced what was to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00493-00100151-00100374": "become the orange catholic bible", "53vXL_2RCGy-00494-00100375-00100687": "known as the oc bible although the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00495-00100688-00100871": "result was the oc bible", "53vXL_2RCGy-00496-00100872-00101071": "the goal was to remove a primary weapon", "53vXL_2RCGy-00497-00101072-00101303": "from the hands of disputant religions", "53vXL_2RCGy-00498-00101304-00101518": "that weapon the claim to possession of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00499-00101519-00101806": "the one and only revelation", "53vXL_2RCGy-00500-00101807-00101991": "the attempt to create an all-permeating", "53vXL_2RCGy-00501-00101992-00102231": "universal religion caused huge upheaval", "53vXL_2RCGy-00502-00102232-00102350": "and many deaths", "53vXL_2RCGy-00503-00102351-00102623": "but eventually the cet produced the oc", "53vXL_2RCGy-00504-00102624-00102686": "bible", "53vXL_2RCGy-00505-00102688-00102878": "which is described at one point as a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00506-00102879-00103015": "work created by", "53vXL_2RCGy-00507-00103016-00103278": "the hubris of reason during these", "53vXL_2RCGy-00508-00103279-00103430": "periods of transition", "53vXL_2RCGy-00509-00103431-00103654": "it is the guild the landsrad and the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00510-00103655-00103766": "bernie jesuit", "53vXL_2RCGy-00511-00103767-00103958": "who help hold the fabric of society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00512-00103959-00104102": "together", "53vXL_2RCGy-00513-00104103-00104278": "we occasionally learn of the religious", "53vXL_2RCGy-00514-00104279-00104494": "attitudes developed by the cet", "53vXL_2RCGy-00515-00104495-00104758": "through the bane desert who often take", "53vXL_2RCGy-00516-00104759-00104943": "great affront if they suspect", "53vXL_2RCGy-00517-00104944-00105102": "certain aspects of the sacred", "53vXL_2RCGy-00518-00105103-00105302": "commandments towards technological", "53vXL_2RCGy-00519-00105303-00105495": "and mechanical prohibition are being", "53vXL_2RCGy-00520-00105496-00105663": "violated", "53vXL_2RCGy-00521-00105664-00105886": "at the beginning of june when paul is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00522-00105888-00106086": "first tested with the gom jabar by the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00523-00106088-00106302": "reverend mother guy as hell and mohim", "53vXL_2RCGy-00524-00106303-00106590": "he asks her why she tests for humans her", "53vXL_2RCGy-00525-00106591-00106702": "reply being", "53vXL_2RCGy-00526-00106703-00107023": "to set you free the purpose of this test", "53vXL_2RCGy-00527-00107024-00107207": "is to create a crisis point", "53vXL_2RCGy-00528-00107208-00107439": "a gateway where one may either pass and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00529-00107440-00107527": "survive", "53vXL_2RCGy-00530-00107528-00107878": "or fail and die the very essence of this", "53vXL_2RCGy-00531-00107879-00108095": "test is not just the survival of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00532-00108096-00108199": "fittest", "53vXL_2RCGy-00533-00108200-00108423": "but also to determine if the person is a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00534-00108424-00108663": "human and more specifically", "53vXL_2RCGy-00535-00108664-00108910": "not an animal although the reverend", "53vXL_2RCGy-00536-00108911-00109119": "mother is testing paul to see if he is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00537-00109120-00109278": "the quiz at sanorak", "53vXL_2RCGy-00538-00109279-00109543": "in a moment of clarity he asks her if", "53vXL_2RCGy-00539-00109544-00109686": "the quizart's hanarak", "53vXL_2RCGy-00540-00109688-00110031": "is a human gom jabbar the crisis point", "53vXL_2RCGy-00541-00110032-00110166": "of the gom jabar", "53vXL_2RCGy-00542-00110167-00110358": "is a frequent spur of evolutionary", "53vXL_2RCGy-00543-00110359-00110543": "advancement in the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00544-00110544-00110766": "and is a key concept in reawakening the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00545-00110767-00110902": "genetic memories", "53vXL_2RCGy-00546-00110903-00111199": "of the trilaksugolas as we shall see", "53vXL_2RCGy-00547-00111200-00111358": "later", "53vXL_2RCGy-00548-00111359-00111566": "once men turned their thinking over to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00549-00111567-00111758": "machines in the hope that this would set", "53vXL_2RCGy-00550-00111759-00111854": "them free", "53vXL_2RCGy-00551-00111855-00112054": "but that only permitted other men with", "53vXL_2RCGy-00552-00112055-00112263": "machines to enslave them", "53vXL_2RCGy-00553-00112264-00112431": "thou shalt not make a machine in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00554-00112432-00112599": "likeness of a man's mind", "53vXL_2RCGy-00555-00112600-00112895": "paul quoted right out of the bottlerian", "53vXL_2RCGy-00556-00112896-00112966": "jihad", "53vXL_2RCGy-00557-00112967-00113223": "on the orange catholic bible she said", "53vXL_2RCGy-00558-00113224-00113423": "but what the oc bible should have said", "53vXL_2RCGy-00559-00113424-00113478": "is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00560-00113479-00113647": "thou shalt not make a machine to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00561-00113648-00113854": "counterfeit a human mind", "53vXL_2RCGy-00562-00113855-00114031": "have you studied the mentat in your", "53vXL_2RCGy-00563-00114032-00114383": "service i've studied with thufer howard", "53vXL_2RCGy-00564-00114383-00114615": "the great revolt took away a crutch she", "53vXL_2RCGy-00565-00114616-00114710": "said", "53vXL_2RCGy-00566-00114711-00114990": "it forced human minds to develop schools", "53vXL_2RCGy-00567-00114991-00115263": "were started to train human talents", "53vXL_2RCGy-00568-00115264-00115583": "bernie jesuit schools she nodded", "53vXL_2RCGy-00569-00115583-00115775": "we have two chief survivors of those", "53vXL_2RCGy-00570-00115776-00115895": "ancient schools", "53vXL_2RCGy-00571-00115896-00116143": "the bani jesuit and the spacing guild", "53vXL_2RCGy-00572-00116144-00116223": "the guild", "53vXL_2RCGy-00573-00116224-00116486": "so we think emphasizes almost pure", "53vXL_2RCGy-00574-00116488-00116615": "mathematics", "53vXL_2RCGy-00575-00116616-00116919": "bernie jesuit performs another function", "53vXL_2RCGy-00576-00116920-00117231": "politics he said", "53vXL_2RCGy-00577-00117232-00117590": "the old woman said the butlerian jihad", "53vXL_2RCGy-00578-00117591-00117734": "as we have seen", "53vXL_2RCGy-00579-00117735-00117934": "creates fundamental changes in the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00580-00117935-00118119": "series that lasts for several thousand", "53vXL_2RCGy-00581-00118120-00118166": "years", "53vXL_2RCGy-00582-00118167-00118463": "the consequences of which change society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00583-00118464-00118623": "and the way human beings think", "53vXL_2RCGy-00584-00118624-00118823": "in terms of their evolution and their", "53vXL_2RCGy-00585-00118824-00119023": "place in the universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-00586-00119024-00119199": "the mental physical skills that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00587-00119200-00119415": "developed out of the great revolt", "53vXL_2RCGy-00588-00119416-00119719": "such as the bane jesuit politics", "53vXL_2RCGy-00589-00119720-00119999": "and the spacing guild mathematics are", "53vXL_2RCGy-00590-00120000-00120110": "created to remove", "53vXL_2RCGy-00591-00120111-00120319": "humanity's reliance on intelligent", "53vXL_2RCGy-00592-00120320-00120647": "machinery and advanced technology", "53vXL_2RCGy-00593-00120648-00120943": "the doctrine that emerges from the cet", "53vXL_2RCGy-00594-00120944-00121151": "serves to cease the divisions amongst", "53vXL_2RCGy-00595-00121152-00121383": "human beings created by the vast range", "53vXL_2RCGy-00596-00121383-00121575": "of religions in the imperium", "53vXL_2RCGy-00597-00121576-00121807": "while simultaneously creating a common", "53vXL_2RCGy-00598-00121808-00121895": "consensus", "53vXL_2RCGy-00599-00121896-00122119": "regarding artificial intelligence and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00600-00122120-00122286": "advanced technology", "53vXL_2RCGy-00601-00122288-00122519": "which equates such things with holy", "53vXL_2RCGy-00602-00122520-00122607": "commandments", "53vXL_2RCGy-00603-00122608-00122951": "and sin the butlerian jihad's influence", "53vXL_2RCGy-00604-00122952-00123110": "throughout the imperium is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00605-00123111-00123358": "paramount and the consequences that it", "53vXL_2RCGy-00606-00123359-00123623": "creates are obvious and far-reaching", "53vXL_2RCGy-00607-00123624-00123895": "the butlerian jihad itself represents", "53vXL_2RCGy-00608-00123896-00124095": "not just an influence on frank herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00609-00124096-00124254": "most famous creation", "53vXL_2RCGy-00610-00124255-00124478": "but also created a platform for the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00611-00124479-00124623": "author to extrapolate", "53vXL_2RCGy-00612-00124624-00124895": "some very fascinating ideas from post", "53vXL_2RCGy-00613-00124896-00125095": "darwinian science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00614-00125096-00125463": "and in particular samuel butler's erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-00615-00125464-00125710": "both works are products of their times", "53vXL_2RCGy-00616-00125711-00125886": "and illustrate the fascination", "53vXL_2RCGy-00617-00125888-00126095": "that science fiction has with the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00618-00126096-00126358": "subject of evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00619-00126359-00126551": "as mentioned earlier there is a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00620-00126552-00126775": "prominent association between science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00621-00126776-00126902": "fiction literature", "53vXL_2RCGy-00622-00126903-00127143": "and the development of evolution as a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00623-00127144-00127247": "theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00624-00127248-00127414": "we are all familiar with the argument", "53vXL_2RCGy-00625-00127415-00127631": "that continues to rage hatedly in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00626-00127632-00127758": "today's society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00627-00127759-00127975": "between those that believe evolution is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00628-00127976-00128158": "an elegant and obvious theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00629-00128159-00128343": "that explains the complexities and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00630-00128344-00128534": "continued development of life on this", "53vXL_2RCGy-00631-00128535-00128599": "planet", "53vXL_2RCGy-00632-00128600-00128854": "and those who do not the flip side of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00633-00128855-00129063": "the argument follows that evolutionary", "53vXL_2RCGy-00634-00129064-00129134": "theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00635-00129135-00129343": "allows no room for the creation of life", "53vXL_2RCGy-00636-00129344-00129534": "on earth by a divine hand", "53vXL_2RCGy-00637-00129535-00129743": "and the resulting disagreement goes back", "53vXL_2RCGy-00638-00129744-00129951": "to the time of alfred russell wallace", "53vXL_2RCGy-00639-00129952-00130158": "and charles darwin's theories of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00640-00130159-00130454": "evolution by means of natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-00641-00130455-00130654": "their two papers were presented to the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00642-00130655-00131063": "linnaean society on the 1st of july 1858", "53vXL_2RCGy-00643-00131064-00131271": "and were jointly entitled on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00644-00131272-00131527": "tendency of species to form varieties", "53vXL_2RCGy-00645-00131528-00131743": "and on the perpetuation of varieties and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00646-00131744-00132007": "species by natural means of selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-00647-00132008-00132175": "and later published in august of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00648-00132176-00132454": "same year the theory of evolution by", "53vXL_2RCGy-00649-00132455-00132599": "natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-00650-00132600-00132831": "as presented in darwin's on the origin", "53vXL_2RCGy-00651-00132832-00133047": "of species which would see publication", "53vXL_2RCGy-00652-00133048-00133175": "in the following year", "53vXL_2RCGy-00653-00133176-00133447": "albeit not in its finalized form and his", "53vXL_2RCGy-00654-00133448-00133647": "later work the descent of man", "53vXL_2RCGy-00655-00133648-00133887": "and selection in relation to sex would", "53vXL_2RCGy-00656-00133888-00133999": "see the beginnings", "53vXL_2RCGy-00657-00134000-00134159": "of a heated disagreement that would", "53vXL_2RCGy-00658-00134160-00134439": "continue up to modern times", "53vXL_2RCGy-00659-00134440-00134687": "the main political arena for this debate", "53vXL_2RCGy-00660-00134688-00134854": "is generally within the sphere of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00661-00134855-00134959": "education", "53vXL_2RCGy-00662-00134960-00135111": "particularly in the united states of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00663-00135112-00135327": "america where the question of whether a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00664-00135328-00135511": "religious creationist viewpoint should", "53vXL_2RCGy-00665-00135512-00135599": "be taught", "53vXL_2RCGy-00666-00135600-00135751": "now very much in the mold of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00667-00135752-00135911": "intelligent design argument", "53vXL_2RCGy-00668-00135912-00136071": "or whether the theory of evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00669-00136072-00136343": "should have primacy in the classroom", "53vXL_2RCGy-00670-00136344-00136599": "just as it is today darwin's theories", "53vXL_2RCGy-00671-00136600-00136790": "were quite controversial during his own", "53vXL_2RCGy-00672-00136791-00136878": "times", "53vXL_2RCGy-00673-00136879-00137127": "the dominant viewpoint up until then was", "53vXL_2RCGy-00674-00137128-00137335": "what we refer to as the fixity or", "53vXL_2RCGy-00675-00137336-00137559": "immutability of species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00676-00137560-00137743": "this was combined with the concept that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00677-00137744-00137983": "the earth was only 5000 years old", "53vXL_2RCGy-00678-00137984-00138159": "and that life on earth was brought into", "53vXL_2RCGy-00679-00138160-00138439": "existence by a divine creator", "53vXL_2RCGy-00680-00138440-00138614": "prior to the publication of on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00681-00138615-00138854": "origin of species science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00682-00138855-00138990": "seemed to be able to prove the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00683-00138991-00139190": "development of life on earth very much", "53vXL_2RCGy-00684-00139191-00139463": "on a par with religious viewpoints", "53vXL_2RCGy-00685-00139464-00139711": "baron georges cuvier's essay on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00686-00139712-00139831": "theory of the earth", "53vXL_2RCGy-00687-00139832-00140190": "published in 1827 for example presents a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00688-00140191-00140375": "treat eyes on the age of our world from", "53vXL_2RCGy-00689-00140376-00140663": "an early 19th century perspective", "53vXL_2RCGy-00690-00140664-00140871": "it accounts for not only an approximate", "53vXL_2RCGy-00691-00140872-00140966": "age of the planet", "53vXL_2RCGy-00692-00140967-00141166": "but also for the nature of the species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00693-00141167-00141319": "which exist upon it", "53vXL_2RCGy-00694-00141320-00141607": "in reference to these ideas this work", "53vXL_2RCGy-00695-00141608-00141814": "comprises an attempt to examine both", "53vXL_2RCGy-00696-00141815-00141999": "anti-diluvian myths", "53vXL_2RCGy-00697-00142000-00142190": "and the post-deluge societies of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00698-00142191-00142359": "ancient world to come up with a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00699-00142360-00142607": "plausible attempt at dating the planet", "53vXL_2RCGy-00700-00142608-00142863": "cuvier's theory of a catastrophic deluge", "53vXL_2RCGy-00701-00142864-00142975": "led to this belief", "53vXL_2RCGy-00702-00142976-00143126": "in addition to explaining how the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00703-00143127-00143319": "current existing fossil records", "53vXL_2RCGy-00704-00143320-00143543": "produced examples of species no longer", "53vXL_2RCGy-00705-00143544-00143759": "surviving on the planet", "53vXL_2RCGy-00706-00143760-00144014": "i agree therefore with masseuse de luc", "53vXL_2RCGy-00707-00144015-00144119": "and dolomi", "53vXL_2RCGy-00708-00144120-00144311": "in thinking that if anything in geology", "53vXL_2RCGy-00709-00144312-00144478": "be established it is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00710-00144479-00144631": "that the surface of our globe has", "53vXL_2RCGy-00711-00144632-00144863": "undergone a great and sudden revolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00712-00144864-00145054": "the date of which cannot be referred to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00713-00145055-00145278": "a much earlier period than five or six", "53vXL_2RCGy-00714-00145279-00145447": "thousand years ago", "53vXL_2RCGy-00715-00145448-00145663": "that this revolution overwhelmed and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00716-00145664-00145847": "caused to disappear the countries which", "53vXL_2RCGy-00717-00145848-00146063": "were previously inhabited by man", "53vXL_2RCGy-00718-00146064-00146271": "and the species of animals now best", "53vXL_2RCGy-00719-00146272-00146407": "known", "53vXL_2RCGy-00720-00146408-00146687": "this however was not the only view and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00721-00146688-00146854": "discourses through the science of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00722-00146855-00147007": "natural history were beginning to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00723-00147008-00147287": "produce ideas that contradicted this", "53vXL_2RCGy-00724-00147288-00147511": "as much as evolutionary theory was not", "53vXL_2RCGy-00725-00147512-00147719": "actually seen as a taboo subject when it", "53vXL_2RCGy-00726-00147720-00147983": "was discussed in the early 19th century", "53vXL_2RCGy-00727-00147984-00148166": "no one had yet been able to provide a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00728-00148167-00148375": "solid and convincing hypothesis", "53vXL_2RCGy-00729-00148376-00148687": "that met with universal agreement early", "53vXL_2RCGy-00730-00148688-00148911": "doubters of theories such as cubies", "53vXL_2RCGy-00731-00148912-00149126": "included the likes of erasmus darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-00732-00149127-00149343": "the grandfather of charles who had", "53vXL_2RCGy-00733-00149344-00149526": "himself been one of the early pioneers", "53vXL_2RCGy-00734-00149527-00149678": "of evolutionary theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00735-00149679-00149902": "in particular with his poetical works", "53vXL_2RCGy-00736-00149903-00150054": "the loves of the plants", "53vXL_2RCGy-00737-00150055-00150319": "the economy of vegetation and the more", "53vXL_2RCGy-00738-00150320-00150454": "scientific work", "53vXL_2RCGy-00739-00150455-00150751": "zoonomia or the laws of organic life", "53vXL_2RCGy-00740-00150752-00151023": "which was published in two volumes", "53vXL_2RCGy-00741-00151024-00151207": "the botanic garden is of particular", "53vXL_2RCGy-00742-00151208-00151407": "interest not just for its ideas on", "53vXL_2RCGy-00743-00151408-00151495": "evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00744-00151496-00151663": "but also for the fact that it can be", "53vXL_2RCGy-00745-00151664-00151854": "considered a work of proto-science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00746-00151855-00151935": "fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00747-00151936-00152183": "speculating as it does on concepts such", "53vXL_2RCGy-00748-00152184-00152311": "as steam power", "53vXL_2RCGy-00749-00152312-00152671": "hard flight and submarines it was in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00750-00152672-00152926": "zoonomia that erasmus darwin put forward", "53vXL_2RCGy-00751-00152927-00153119": "some of his more detailed notions on", "53vXL_2RCGy-00752-00153120-00153207": "evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00753-00153208-00153343": "that show the strength of his", "53vXL_2RCGy-00754-00153344-00153614": "convictions and his ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-00755-00153615-00153783": "from thus meditating on the great", "53vXL_2RCGy-00756-00153784-00153951": "similarity of the structure of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00757-00153952-00154095": "warm-blooded animals", "53vXL_2RCGy-00758-00154096-00154239": "and at the same time of the great", "53vXL_2RCGy-00759-00154240-00154423": "changes they undergo both before and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00760-00154424-00154566": "after their nativity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00761-00154567-00154743": "and by considering in high minute a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00762-00154744-00154966": "portion of time many of the changes of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00763-00154967-00155047": "animals above", "53vXL_2RCGy-00764-00155048-00155271": "described have been produced would it be", "53vXL_2RCGy-00765-00155272-00155423": "too bold to imagine", "53vXL_2RCGy-00766-00155424-00155614": "that in the great length of time since", "53vXL_2RCGy-00767-00155615-00155799": "the earth began to exist", "53vXL_2RCGy-00768-00155800-00155999": "perhaps millions of ages before the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00769-00156000-00156231": "commencement of the history of mankind", "53vXL_2RCGy-00770-00156232-00156495": "would it be too bold to imagine that all", "53vXL_2RCGy-00771-00156496-00156678": "warm-blooded animals have arisen from", "53vXL_2RCGy-00772-00156679-00156831": "one living filament", "53vXL_2RCGy-00773-00156832-00157119": "which the great first cause endured with", "53vXL_2RCGy-00774-00157120-00157214": "animality", "53vXL_2RCGy-00775-00157215-00157439": "with the power of acquiring new parts", "53vXL_2RCGy-00776-00157440-00157647": "attended with new propensities", "53vXL_2RCGy-00777-00157648-00157935": "directed by irritations sensations", "53vXL_2RCGy-00778-00157936-00158023": "volitions", "53vXL_2RCGy-00779-00158024-00158302": "and associations and thus possessing the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00780-00158303-00158526": "faculty of continuing to improve by its", "53vXL_2RCGy-00781-00158527-00158702": "own inherent activity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00782-00158703-00158863": "and of delivering dying those", "53vXL_2RCGy-00783-00158864-00159063": "improvements by generation to its", "53vXL_2RCGy-00784-00159064-00159151": "posterity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00785-00159152-00159454": "world without end", "53vXL_2RCGy-00786-00159455-00159671": "john baptist lamarck was another", "53vXL_2RCGy-00787-00159672-00159759": "naturalist", "53vXL_2RCGy-00788-00159760-00159902": "who put forth some of the more", "53vXL_2RCGy-00789-00159903-00160143": "convincing arguments about evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00790-00160144-00160326": "and would in turn actually become the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00791-00160327-00160511": "proponent of the main theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00792-00160512-00160807": "which would compete against darwin's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00793-00160808-00160999": "lamarck's ideas on evolution were", "53vXL_2RCGy-00794-00161000-00161199": "primarily presented in his work", "53vXL_2RCGy-00795-00161200-00161551": "philosophy zoologic published in 1809", "53vXL_2RCGy-00796-00161552-00161759": "and it does represent the first properly", "53vXL_2RCGy-00797-00161760-00161975": "assembled and coherent theory of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00798-00161976-00162063": "evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00799-00162064-00162271": "that went against the received ideas of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00800-00162272-00162439": "the time", "53vXL_2RCGy-00801-00162440-00162695": "lamarck's ideas were focused on two key", "53vXL_2RCGy-00802-00162696-00162775": "principles", "53vXL_2RCGy-00803-00162776-00163014": "which suggested that evolution of animal", "53vXL_2RCGy-00804-00163015-00163295": "life was spurred by two natural forces", "53vXL_2RCGy-00805-00163296-00163463": "or mechanisms", "53vXL_2RCGy-00806-00163464-00163671": "the first of these was that animal life", "53vXL_2RCGy-00807-00163672-00163871": "was driven forward by a mechanism that", "53vXL_2RCGy-00808-00163872-00164014": "meant that animals evolved", "53vXL_2RCGy-00809-00164015-00164263": "from simpler forms to more complex", "53vXL_2RCGy-00810-00164264-00164463": "examples of life", "53vXL_2RCGy-00811-00164464-00164654": "however the problem with the origins of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00812-00164655-00164854": "these species according to lamarck's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00813-00164855-00164919": "ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-00814-00164920-00165151": "was that simplistic animal species were", "53vXL_2RCGy-00815-00165152-00165399": "produced by spontaneous creation a", "53vXL_2RCGy-00816-00165400-00165631": "process which continued throughout time", "53vXL_2RCGy-00817-00165632-00165902": "to create new species the second of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00818-00165903-00166023": "these principles", "53vXL_2RCGy-00819-00166024-00166183": "was that there was a mechanism which", "53vXL_2RCGy-00820-00166184-00166399": "allowed animals to adapt to their given", "53vXL_2RCGy-00821-00166400-00166607": "specific environments", "53vXL_2RCGy-00822-00166608-00166743": "depending on the nature of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00823-00166744-00166959": "environment certain species would", "53vXL_2RCGy-00824-00166960-00167054": "develop or lose", "53vXL_2RCGy-00825-00167055-00167231": "characteristics which could then be", "53vXL_2RCGy-00826-00167232-00167471": "passed on to their offspring", "53vXL_2RCGy-00827-00167472-00167663": "this idea was known as the theory of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00828-00167664-00167823": "acquired characteristics", "53vXL_2RCGy-00829-00167824-00168047": "though today it is also referred to as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00830-00168048-00168366": "soft inheritance or lamarcism", "53vXL_2RCGy-00831-00168367-00168543": "charles darwin would however fully", "53vXL_2RCGy-00832-00168544-00168687": "reject this theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00833-00168688-00168887": "saying it is not being the result of any", "53vXL_2RCGy-00834-00168888-00169135": "given natural law", "53vXL_2RCGy-00835-00169136-00169351": "charles darwin on his theory of natural", "53vXL_2RCGy-00836-00169352-00169559": "selection came to prominence after the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00837-00169560-00169647": "publication", "53vXL_2RCGy-00838-00169648-00169895": "of arguably his most famous work on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00839-00169896-00170119": "origin of species by means of natural", "53vXL_2RCGy-00840-00170120-00170207": "selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-00841-00170208-00170454": "and the subsequent the descent of man", "53vXL_2RCGy-00842-00170455-00170766": "and selection in relation to sex", "53vXL_2RCGy-00843-00170767-00170943": "with the prominence to which darwin's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00844-00170944-00171111": "theories of evolution and natural", "53vXL_2RCGy-00845-00171112-00171263": "selection arose", "53vXL_2RCGy-00846-00171264-00171454": "the validity of concepts such as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00847-00171455-00171678": "immutability and soft inheritance as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00848-00171679-00171863": "part of evolutionary theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00849-00171864-00172111": "were fast becoming moot although as long", "53vXL_2RCGy-00850-00172112-00172326": "as darwin had his detractors", "53vXL_2RCGy-00851-00172327-00172543": "these older viewpoints would continue to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00852-00172544-00172743": "have their supporters", "53vXL_2RCGy-00853-00172744-00172959": "darwin himself acknowledged lamarck's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00854-00172960-00173183": "contribution to evolutionary theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-00855-00173184-00173407": "noting that lamarck was the first man", "53vXL_2RCGy-00856-00173408-00173590": "whose conclusions on this subject", "53vXL_2RCGy-00857-00173591-00173887": "excited much attention describing him as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00858-00173888-00174190": "a justly celebrated naturalist", "53vXL_2RCGy-00859-00174191-00174423": "darwin's work fundamentally changed how", "53vXL_2RCGy-00860-00174424-00174599": "human beings view their place in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00861-00174600-00174726": "natural world", "53vXL_2RCGy-00862-00174727-00174983": "and in doing so called into question so", "53vXL_2RCGy-00863-00174984-00175207": "many ideas and preconceptions", "53vXL_2RCGy-00864-00175208-00175559": "that mankind held upon its existence", "53vXL_2RCGy-00865-00175560-00175775": "as we have seen with erasmus darwin's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00866-00175776-00175999": "work science fiction had an early", "53vXL_2RCGy-00867-00176000-00176126": "interest in evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-00868-00176127-00176366": "and in the time following on the origin", "53vXL_2RCGy-00869-00176367-00176454": "of species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00870-00176455-00176631": "it would only be within a very short", "53vXL_2RCGy-00871-00176632-00176823": "number of years that it would become", "53vXL_2RCGy-00872-00176824-00177007": "apparent how important the subject it", "53vXL_2RCGy-00873-00177008-00177087": "would become", "53vXL_2RCGy-00874-00177088-00177423": "to the genre notable examples of this", "53vXL_2RCGy-00875-00177424-00177638": "are easily found in the late 19th and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00876-00177639-00177831": "early 20th centuries", "53vXL_2RCGy-00877-00177832-00178063": "and probably none more famous than three", "53vXL_2RCGy-00878-00178064-00178238": "of hg wells's works", "53vXL_2RCGy-00879-00178239-00178526": "the time machine the war of the worlds", "53vXL_2RCGy-00880-00178527-00178814": "on the island of dr moreau", "53vXL_2RCGy-00881-00178815-00179023": "the time machine depicts the development", "53vXL_2RCGy-00882-00179024-00179263": "of two divergent human species", "53vXL_2RCGy-00883-00179264-00179511": "the eloy and the morlocks in the far", "53vXL_2RCGy-00884-00179512-00179638": "future of humanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00885-00179639-00179902": "and show mankind's evolution directed by", "53vXL_2RCGy-00886-00179903-00180126": "social darwinism", "53vXL_2RCGy-00887-00180127-00180302": "the war of the worlds again is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00888-00180303-00180511": "suggestive of human evolution through", "53vXL_2RCGy-00889-00180512-00180607": "the martians", "53vXL_2RCGy-00890-00180608-00180854": "who represent how humanity will evolve", "53vXL_2RCGy-00891-00180855-00180935": "perhaps", "53vXL_2RCGy-00892-00180936-00181238": "in a million years time the island of dr", "53vXL_2RCGy-00893-00181239-00181302": "moreau", "53vXL_2RCGy-00894-00181303-00181535": "as much as a response to the debate over", "53vXL_2RCGy-00895-00181536-00181735": "vivi's section in welles's time", "53vXL_2RCGy-00896-00181736-00181926": "shows a curious prediction of gene", "53vXL_2RCGy-00897-00181927-00182214": "splicing and genetic engineering", "53vXL_2RCGy-00898-00182215-00182551": "olaf stapleton's last and first men and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00899-00182552-00182814": "star maker are notable both for their", "53vXL_2RCGy-00900-00182815-00182959": "vast time scales", "53vXL_2RCGy-00901-00182960-00183143": "which dwarf even those of science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00902-00183144-00183278": "fiction novels such as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00903-00183279-00183575": "june glaston first man explores the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00904-00183576-00183823": "theorized evolutions of humanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00905-00183824-00184111": "saw m18 and all through eons of time", "53vXL_2RCGy-00906-00184112-00184366": "until their eventual extinction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00907-00184367-00184583": "starmaker is even greater in scope", "53vXL_2RCGy-00908-00184584-00184759": "essentially being a complete future", "53vXL_2RCGy-00909-00184760-00184902": "history of the universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-00910-00184903-00185111": "and explores numerous evolutions of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00911-00185112-00185302": "beings and civilizations", "53vXL_2RCGy-00912-00185303-00185511": "up until an omega point where the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00913-00185512-00185711": "universal collective consciousness", "53vXL_2RCGy-00914-00185712-00186007": "comes into contact with its creator many", "53vXL_2RCGy-00915-00186008-00186214": "other science fiction works continue to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00916-00186215-00186271": "produce", "53vXL_2RCGy-00917-00186272-00186511": "thoughtful and speculative viewpoints on", "53vXL_2RCGy-00918-00186512-00186695": "evolution up until today", "53vXL_2RCGy-00919-00186696-00186887": "where the question seems to focus more", "53vXL_2RCGy-00920-00186888-00186999": "on the post-human", "53vXL_2RCGy-00921-00187000-00187183": "and extropian philosophies that are", "53vXL_2RCGy-00922-00187184-00187399": "being extolled in the scientific and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00923-00187400-00187590": "philosophical communities", "53vXL_2RCGy-00924-00187591-00187775": "in regard to current thinking in medical", "53vXL_2RCGy-00925-00187776-00187926": "science", "53vXL_2RCGy-00926-00187927-00188150": "science fiction has also speculated on", "53vXL_2RCGy-00927-00188151-00188290": "natural selection from the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00928-00188291-00188478": "post-apocalyptic scenarios", "53vXL_2RCGy-00929-00188479-00188671": "that the genre often presents in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00930-00188672-00188895": "post-world war ii period", "53vXL_2RCGy-00931-00188896-00189087": "works such as john wyndham's the day of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00932-00189088-00189247": "the triffids arthur c", "53vXL_2RCGy-00933-00189248-00189526": "clarke's childhood's end walter m miller", "53vXL_2RCGy-00934-00189527-00189726": "jr's accountable for leibowitz", "53vXL_2RCGy-00935-00189727-00190023": "and pd james is the children of men all", "53vXL_2RCGy-00936-00190024-00190078": "present", "53vXL_2RCGy-00937-00190079-00190263": "quite varied and differing looks at", "53vXL_2RCGy-00938-00190264-00190519": "issues arriving from evolutionary change", "53vXL_2RCGy-00939-00190520-00190766": "natural selection and the struggle of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00940-00190767-00190926": "humanity to survive", "53vXL_2RCGy-00941-00190927-00191107": "in new and difficult often", "53vXL_2RCGy-00942-00191108-00191335": "post-apocalyptic environments", "53vXL_2RCGy-00943-00191336-00191583": "in consideration of the june series i", "53vXL_2RCGy-00944-00191584-00191735": "believe that there are two works from", "53vXL_2RCGy-00945-00191736-00191935": "the victorian era of science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00946-00191936-00192111": "which are of critical importance to", "53vXL_2RCGy-00947-00192112-00192295": "frank herbert's opus", "53vXL_2RCGy-00948-00192296-00192559": "as excellent examples of pre-golden age", "53vXL_2RCGy-00949-00192560-00192654": "science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00950-00192655-00192847": "it must be noted that they do not merely", "53vXL_2RCGy-00951-00192848-00193078": "act as an influence upon herbert's work", "53vXL_2RCGy-00952-00193079-00193271": "a mere nod to a time that he would have", "53vXL_2RCGy-00953-00193272-00193438": "viewed was producing original and", "53vXL_2RCGy-00954-00193439-00193607": "quality science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-00955-00193608-00193831": "they represent strong ideological", "53vXL_2RCGy-00956-00193832-00193983": "platforms that frank herbert would", "53vXL_2RCGy-00957-00193984-00194159": "extrapolate heavily from", "53vXL_2RCGy-00958-00194160-00194375": "and used to create an enormous cultural", "53vXL_2RCGy-00959-00194376-00194575": "and historical framework for the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-00960-00194576-00194702": "series", "53vXL_2RCGy-00961-00194703-00194878": "as i have mentioned earlier they are", "53vXL_2RCGy-00962-00194879-00195038": "samuel butler's erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-00963-00195039-00195254": "and to a lesser extent edward bulwar", "53vXL_2RCGy-00964-00195255-00195478": "lightens the coming race", "53vXL_2RCGy-00965-00195479-00195663": "the coming race is a novel which was", "53vXL_2RCGy-00966-00195664-00195854": "published anonymously at first", "53vXL_2RCGy-00967-00195855-00196063": "and presented an examination of an", "53vXL_2RCGy-00968-00196064-00196302": "advanced underground civilization", "53vXL_2RCGy-00969-00196303-00196543": "known as the vril ya who wait the day", "53vXL_2RCGy-00970-00196544-00196647": "when they will arise", "53vXL_2RCGy-00971-00196648-00196878": "and remove humanity from their place as", "53vXL_2RCGy-00972-00196879-00197087": "the dominant species in the world above", "53vXL_2RCGy-00973-00197088-00197214": "ground", "53vXL_2RCGy-00974-00197215-00197414": "the author's intentions centered on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00975-00197415-00197687": "curiosity of victorian society", "53vXL_2RCGy-00976-00197688-00197911": "over the differences between darwinism", "53vXL_2RCGy-00977-00197912-00198054": "and lamarchism", "53vXL_2RCGy-00978-00198055-00198326": "especially the darwinian proposition", "53vXL_2RCGy-00979-00198327-00198519": "that a coming race is destined", "53vXL_2RCGy-00980-00198520-00198887": "to supplant our races the vril ya are in", "53vXL_2RCGy-00981-00198888-00199014": "fact evolved from", "53vXL_2RCGy-00982-00199015-00199278": "tadpoles and the anonymous narrator is", "53vXL_2RCGy-00983-00199279-00199447": "credulous of this lineage", "53vXL_2RCGy-00984-00199448-00199743": "as presented to him by off lin one of", "53vXL_2RCGy-00985-00199744-00199831": "the vril", "53vXL_2RCGy-00986-00199832-00199983": "and his new doubt similar to the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00987-00199984-00200271": "incredulity experienced by victorians", "53vXL_2RCGy-00988-00200272-00200495": "in light of the implications of darwin's", "53vXL_2RCGy-00989-00200496-00200623": "theories presented", "53vXL_2RCGy-00990-00200624-00200831": "in on the origin of species and the", "53vXL_2RCGy-00991-00200832-00201023": "descent of man", "53vXL_2RCGy-00992-00201024-00201278": "among the pithy sayings which according", "53vXL_2RCGy-00993-00201279-00201375": "to tradition", "53vXL_2RCGy-00994-00201376-00201607": "the philosopher bequeathed to posterity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00995-00201608-00201814": "and rhythmical form and cententius", "53vXL_2RCGy-00996-00201815-00201902": "brevity", "53vXL_2RCGy-00997-00201903-00202150": "this is notably recorded humble", "53vXL_2RCGy-00998-00202151-00202326": "yourselves my descendants", "53vXL_2RCGy-00999-00202327-00202663": "the father of your race was a twat exalt", "53vXL_2RCGy-01000-00202664-00202814": "yourselves my descendants", "53vXL_2RCGy-01001-00202815-00203014": "for it was the same divine thought which", "53vXL_2RCGy-01002-00203015-00203143": "created your father", "53vXL_2RCGy-01003-00203144-00203463": "that develops itself an exalting you", "53vXL_2RCGy-01004-00203464-00203671": "i presume that none of urias even in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01005-00203672-00203847": "less enlightened ages", "53vXL_2RCGy-01006-00203848-00204071": "ever believed that the great grandson of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01007-00204072-00204150": "a frog", "53vXL_2RCGy-01008-00204151-00204423": "became a cententius philosopher or that", "53vXL_2RCGy-01009-00204424-00204543": "any section", "53vXL_2RCGy-01010-00204544-00204814": "i will not say of the lofty vril yeah", "53vXL_2RCGy-01011-00204815-00204990": "but of the meanest varieties of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01012-00204991-00205103": "human race", "53vXL_2RCGy-01013-00205104-00205431": "had its origin in a tadpole at the same", "53vXL_2RCGy-01014-00205432-00205631": "time as presenting us with an instance", "53vXL_2RCGy-01015-00205632-00205855": "of similarity to the conflict of common", "53vXL_2RCGy-01016-00205856-00206046": "descent between man and apes created by", "53vXL_2RCGy-01017-00206048-00206142": "darwin's theory of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01018-00206144-00206414": "evolution by natural selection bulwar", "53vXL_2RCGy-01019-00206415-00206462": "lighten", "53vXL_2RCGy-01020-00206463-00206694": "also describes the development of a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01021-00206696-00206855": "visible nerve on the hands of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01022-00206856-00206951": "vrillia", "53vXL_2RCGy-01023-00206952-00207158": "which is very much in the mode of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01024-00207159-00207423": "lamarckian hypothesis of evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-01025-00207423-00207606": "that is the theory of acquired", "53vXL_2RCGy-01026-00207607-00207879": "characteristics or soft inheritance", "53vXL_2RCGy-01027-00207880-00208086": "the vrillia have been consciously able", "53vXL_2RCGy-01028-00208087-00208319": "to alter their evolution over a period", "53vXL_2RCGy-01029-00208319-00208406": "of time", "53vXL_2RCGy-01030-00208407-00208703": "to facilitate their use of vril the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01031-00208704-00208903": "wondrous fluid that is the source of all", "53vXL_2RCGy-01032-00208904-00209023": "their power", "53vXL_2RCGy-01033-00209023-00209310": "this adaptation exists in the form of a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01034-00209311-00209358": "nerve", "53vXL_2RCGy-01035-00209359-00209542": "developed on their hands which", "53vXL_2RCGy-01036-00209544-00209751": "ultimately allows them to facilitate the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01037-00209752-00209879": "staffs that they use", "53vXL_2RCGy-01038-00209880-00210110": "and serve as conduits for the liquid", "53vXL_2RCGy-01039-00210111-00210231": "energy", "53vXL_2RCGy-01040-00210232-00210471": "more remarkable than all this is a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01041-00210471-00210598": "visible nerve", "53vXL_2RCGy-01042-00210600-00210863": "perceptible under the skin which starts", "53vXL_2RCGy-01043-00210864-00210975": "from the wrist", "53vXL_2RCGy-01044-00210976-00211167": "skirting the ball of the thumb and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01045-00211167-00211319": "branching fork-like", "53vXL_2RCGy-01046-00211319-00211479": "at the roots of the fore and middle", "53vXL_2RCGy-01047-00211480-00211703": "fingers with your slight formation of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01048-00211704-00211751": "thumb", "53vXL_2RCGy-01049-00211752-00211958": "said the philosophical young gee and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01050-00211959-00212151": "with the absence of the nerve which you", "53vXL_2RCGy-01051-00212152-00212342": "find more or less developed in the hands", "53vXL_2RCGy-01052-00212344-00212455": "of our race", "53vXL_2RCGy-01053-00212456-00212623": "you can never achieve other than", "53vXL_2RCGy-01054-00212623-00212815": "imperfect and feeble power over the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01055-00212816-00212967": "agency of vril", "53vXL_2RCGy-01056-00212967-00213198": "but so far as the nerve is concerned", "53vXL_2RCGy-01057-00213200-00213375": "that is not found in the hands of our", "53vXL_2RCGy-01058-00213376-00213519": "earliest progenitors", "53vXL_2RCGy-01059-00213519-00213742": "nor in those of the ruder tribes without", "53vXL_2RCGy-01060-00213744-00213927": "the pale of the villa", "53vXL_2RCGy-01061-00213928-00214087": "it has been slowly developed in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01062-00214088-00214231": "course of generations", "53vXL_2RCGy-01063-00214232-00214446": "commencing in the early achievements and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01064-00214448-00214687": "increasing with the continuous exercise", "53vXL_2RCGy-01065-00214688-00214991": "of the vril par therefore in the course", "53vXL_2RCGy-01066-00214992-00215151": "of one or two thousand years", "53vXL_2RCGy-01067-00215152-00215382": "such a nerve may possibly be engendered", "53vXL_2RCGy-01068-00215383-00215591": "in those higher beings of urias", "53vXL_2RCGy-01069-00215592-00215798": "who devote themselves to that paramount", "53vXL_2RCGy-01070-00215800-00215951": "science through which is attained", "53vXL_2RCGy-01071-00215952-00216015": "command", "53vXL_2RCGy-01072-00216016-00216263": "over all the subtler forces of nature", "53vXL_2RCGy-01073-00216264-00216479": "permeated by vril", "53vXL_2RCGy-01074-00216480-00216694": "bulwar lightens the coming race as a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01075-00216696-00216831": "particular interest here", "53vXL_2RCGy-01076-00216832-00217055": "as it provides an interesting comparison", "53vXL_2RCGy-01077-00217056-00217231": "to butler's error", "53vXL_2RCGy-01078-00217232-00217439": "both works were published anonymously at", "53vXL_2RCGy-01079-00217440-00217679": "first and their similarity in subject", "53vXL_2RCGy-01080-00217680-00217758": "matter if not", "53vXL_2RCGy-01081-00217759-00218063": "style caused a degree of speculation", "53vXL_2RCGy-01082-00218064-00218327": "on the authorship of erewa many people", "53vXL_2RCGy-01083-00218328-00218598": "speculated that erawan had in fact also", "53vXL_2RCGy-01084-00218600-00218815": "been written by bulwar leighton whose", "53vXL_2RCGy-01085-00218816-00219023": "identity as the author of the coming", "53vXL_2RCGy-01086-00219023-00219094": "race", "53vXL_2RCGy-01087-00219096-00219351": "was not a particularly well-kept secret", "53vXL_2RCGy-01088-00219352-00219534": "whereas butler's work is presented in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01089-00219535-00219775": "the tradition of a utopian satire", "53vXL_2RCGy-01090-00219776-00220006": "often remarked upon as being very much a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01091-00220007-00220215": "successor to jonathan swift's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01092-00220216-00220463": "gulliver's travels bulwar lightens is", "53vXL_2RCGy-01093-00220464-00220639": "more in the mode of the subterranean", "53vXL_2RCGy-01094-00220640-00220727": "adventure", "53vXL_2RCGy-01095-00220728-00220942": "serious in tone and sharing more", "53vXL_2RCGy-01096-00220944-00221110": "similarities to the works of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01097-00221111-00221423": "jules verne for example it was butler", "53vXL_2RCGy-01098-00221423-00221615": "who would become one of charles darwin's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01099-00221616-00221758": "fiercest critics", "53vXL_2RCGy-01100-00221759-00221998": "ultimately rejecting bitterly his ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-01101-00222000-00222175": "of natural selection which he was at", "53vXL_2RCGy-01102-00222176-00222303": "first in favor of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01103-00222304-00222471": "and later defending the work of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01104-00222471-00222671": "jean-baptiste lamarck", "53vXL_2RCGy-01105-00222671-00222894": "bulwar leighton's relationship to june", "53vXL_2RCGy-01106-00222896-00223079": "is not of any major particular", "53vXL_2RCGy-01107-00223080-00223175": "significance", "53vXL_2RCGy-01108-00223176-00223375": "with the exception of the similarities", "53vXL_2RCGy-01109-00223376-00223623": "between the ubiquitous drugs of vril", "53vXL_2RCGy-01110-00223623-00223967": "and melange however in reading erawan or", "53vXL_2RCGy-01111-00223967-00224119": "the coming race", "53vXL_2RCGy-01112-00224119-00224398": "one inevitably given any real effort and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01113-00224400-00224551": "research or interest", "53vXL_2RCGy-01114-00224552-00224839": "comes across the other work their", "53vXL_2RCGy-01115-00224840-00225039": "similarities are important", "53vXL_2RCGy-01116-00225040-00225215": "as is the fact that both books were", "53vXL_2RCGy-01117-00225216-00225398": "associated with each writer", "53vXL_2RCGy-01118-00225400-00225582": "having been published initially as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01119-00225583-00225815": "anonymous works", "53vXL_2RCGy-01120-00225816-00226094": "few drugs in science fiction share such", "53vXL_2RCGy-01121-00226096-00226294": "given and varied qualities", "53vXL_2RCGy-01122-00226296-00226582": "as vril and melange yet it is of a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01123-00226583-00226767": "significance which i do not wish to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01124-00226767-00226871": "overstate", "53vXL_2RCGy-01125-00226871-00227151": "that both drugs are tied to aspects of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01126-00227152-00227327": "evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-01127-00227328-00227646": "samuel butler also later known as erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01128-00227648-00227727": "butler", "53vXL_2RCGy-01129-00227728-00228055": "was born in 1835 at langer rectory in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01130-00228056-00228310": "nottinghamshire and died in 1902.", "53vXL_2RCGy-01131-00228311-00228494": "he was the son of a clergyman the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01132-00228496-00228727": "reverend thomas butler and received an", "53vXL_2RCGy-01133-00228728-00228823": "education at st", "53vXL_2RCGy-01134-00228823-00229023": "john's college cambridge where initially", "53vXL_2RCGy-01135-00229023-00229246": "having desired to study mathematics he", "53vXL_2RCGy-01136-00229248-00229382": "eventually achieved a first", "53vXL_2RCGy-01137-00229383-00229646": "class degree in classics the initial", "53vXL_2RCGy-01138-00229648-00229775": "intent of his family", "53vXL_2RCGy-01139-00229776-00229927": "whom butler had a reasonably", "53vXL_2RCGy-01140-00229928-00230127": "antagonistic relationship with", "53vXL_2RCGy-01141-00230128-00230351": "was to have him ordained in the anglican", "53vXL_2RCGy-01142-00230352-00230582": "clergy as almost a part of a family", "53vXL_2RCGy-01143-00230583-00230655": "tradition", "53vXL_2RCGy-01144-00230656-00230934": "his grandfather dr samuel butler also", "53vXL_2RCGy-01145-00230935-00231119": "having served the anglican church as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01146-00231119-00231263": "bishop of litchfield", "53vXL_2RCGy-01147-00231264-00231463": "butler however did not wish to enter the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01148-00231464-00231623": "clergy oddly enough", "53vXL_2RCGy-01149-00231623-00231775": "like his father who had been pressed", "53vXL_2RCGy-01150-00231776-00231958": "into religious service despite his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01151-00231959-00232158": "wishes for a career in the navy", "53vXL_2RCGy-01152-00232159-00232367": "butler did however have an intense", "53vXL_2RCGy-01153-00232367-00232487": "dislike for religion", "53vXL_2RCGy-01154-00232488-00232679": "in general particularly due to his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01155-00232680-00232894": "strict upbringing and after questioning", "53vXL_2RCGy-01156-00232896-00233094": "his faith and quarreling with his father", "53vXL_2RCGy-01157-00233096-00233327": "over his concerns via correspondence he", "53vXL_2RCGy-01158-00233328-00233519": "decided to leave england prior to his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01159-00233519-00233598": "ordination", "53vXL_2RCGy-01160-00233600-00233934": "and set forth to new zealand in 1859", "53vXL_2RCGy-01161-00233935-00234134": "in new zealand butler purchased some", "53vXL_2RCGy-01162-00234135-00234358": "land overlooking the ramji tata river on", "53vXL_2RCGy-01163-00234359-00234494": "the canterbury plains", "53vXL_2RCGy-01164-00234496-00234679": "and became a sheep farmer for the next", "53vXL_2RCGy-01165-00234680-00234855": "few years naming his land", "53vXL_2RCGy-01166-00234856-00235094": "mesopotamia it was during his time in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01167-00235096-00235271": "new zealand that butler first read", "53vXL_2RCGy-01168-00235271-00235455": "charles darwin's on the origin of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01169-00235456-00235542": "species", "53vXL_2RCGy-01170-00235544-00235719": "initially butler read the work", "53vXL_2RCGy-01171-00235719-00235934": "thoroughly developing a great interest", "53vXL_2RCGy-01172-00235935-00236182": "and respect for charge darwin's ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-01173-00236183-00236358": "this was the beginning of butler's quite", "53vXL_2RCGy-01174-00236359-00236582": "serious interest in evolutionary thought", "53vXL_2RCGy-01175-00236583-00236751": "and became one of darwin's greatest", "53vXL_2RCGy-01176-00236752-00236903": "advocates at the time", "53vXL_2RCGy-01177-00236904-00237103": "butler even wrote a dialogue and sent it", "53vXL_2RCGy-01178-00237104-00237255": "to the christ church press", "53vXL_2RCGy-01179-00237256-00237598": "in 1862 garnering a reply from a certain", "53vXL_2RCGy-01180-00237600-00237855": "dr abraham the bishop of wellington", "53vXL_2RCGy-01181-00237856-00238055": "what is of note here is that as philip", "53vXL_2RCGy-01182-00238056-00238239": "henderson points out the bishop", "53vXL_2RCGy-01183-00238240-00238471": "indicates that darwin's work had in fact", "53vXL_2RCGy-01184-00238471-00238727": "been anticipated by a number of writers", "53vXL_2RCGy-01185-00238728-00238998": "darwin's own grandfather erasmus being", "53vXL_2RCGy-01186-00239000-00239103": "amongst them", "53vXL_2RCGy-01187-00239104-00239319": "notably this would become a key point in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01188-00239319-00239582": "butler's later attacks on charles darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-01189-00239583-00239758": "and would change his viewpoint on", "53vXL_2RCGy-01190-00239759-00239934": "natural selection towards a more", "53vXL_2RCGy-01191-00239935-00240158": "lamarcian attitude", "53vXL_2RCGy-01192-00240159-00240342": "darwin himself had even written to the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01193-00240344-00240471": "christ church press", "53vXL_2RCGy-01194-00240471-00240687": "complimenting butler on his theories but", "53vXL_2RCGy-01195-00240688-00240830": "a particular note was butler's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01196-00240831-00241142": "correspondence to the press in 1863", "53vXL_2RCGy-01197-00241144-00241439": "entitled darwin among the machines this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01198-00241440-00241630": "would later form a major part of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01199-00241631-00241855": "three chapters in erawan collectively", "53vXL_2RCGy-01200-00241856-00242071": "known as the book of the machines", "53vXL_2RCGy-01201-00242071-00242215": "the article was not written under", "53vXL_2RCGy-01202-00242216-00242446": "butler's name but was rather signed by a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01203-00242448-00242503": "certain", "53vXL_2RCGy-01204-00242504-00242767": "killarius a gnome diplom that butler had", "53vXL_2RCGy-01205-00242767-00242942": "used in his articles for the eagle", "53vXL_2RCGy-01206-00242944-00243287": "magazine during his cambridge days", "53vXL_2RCGy-01207-00243288-00243463": "the key idea here was to present a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01208-00243464-00243687": "humorous approach to defending darwin's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01209-00243688-00243751": "ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-01210-00243752-00243910": "by illustrating the evolution of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01211-00243911-00244103": "machinery since the days of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01212-00244104-00244279": "industrial revolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-01213-00244280-00244527": "erawan or over the range has been", "53vXL_2RCGy-01214-00244528-00244663": "described by p.m", "53vXL_2RCGy-01215-00244664-00244894": "furbank as the most self-sufficient of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01216-00244896-00245006": "butler's books", "53vXL_2RCGy-01217-00245007-00245191": "and to my mind the most completely", "53vXL_2RCGy-01218-00245192-00245398": "satisfactory one and it's together with", "53vXL_2RCGy-01219-00245400-00245534": "the way of all flesh", "53vXL_2RCGy-01220-00245535-00245839": "his greatest literary achievement erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01221-00245840-00246071": "is a gentle satire that subtly attacks", "53vXL_2RCGy-01222-00246071-00246279": "elements of victorian society at the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01223-00246280-00246334": "time", "53vXL_2RCGy-01224-00246335-00246551": "more so than the posthumously published", "53vXL_2RCGy-01225-00246552-00246758": "the way of all flesh which was a biting", "53vXL_2RCGy-01226-00246759-00246951": "attack on the values of family life", "53vXL_2RCGy-01227-00246952-00247094": "during that era", "53vXL_2RCGy-01228-00247096-00247271": "erawan was written in the mood of a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01229-00247271-00247446": "pastoral satire", "53vXL_2RCGy-01230-00247448-00247710": "although often presented as a utopia the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01231-00247711-00247942": "society which butler presents us is a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01232-00247944-00248175": "topsy-turvy land that inverts many of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01233-00248176-00248327": "the world's realities", "53vXL_2RCGy-01234-00248328-00248510": "in order to highlight the hypocrisy of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01235-00248511-00248630": "the times", "53vXL_2RCGy-01236-00248631-00248846": "in the land of erawan for example", "53vXL_2RCGy-01237-00248848-00248991": "illness is illegal", "53vXL_2RCGy-01238-00248992-00249223": "and considered to be highly criminal and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01239-00249223-00249327": "immoral", "53vXL_2RCGy-01240-00249328-00249567": "at the same time criminality is seen as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01241-00249567-00249655": "an illness", "53vXL_2RCGy-01242-00249656-00249863": "a terrible suffering bestowed on an", "53vXL_2RCGy-01243-00249864-00250006": "unfortunate individual", "53vXL_2RCGy-01244-00250007-00250142": "and something which would require the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01245-00250144-00250327": "services of a straightener to prevent", "53vXL_2RCGy-01246-00250328-00250519": "from happening again", "53vXL_2RCGy-01247-00250519-00250719": "erwan is in the tradition of the strange", "53vXL_2RCGy-01248-00250719-00250910": "new land discovered through the journey", "53vXL_2RCGy-01249-00250911-00251015": "of an individual", "53vXL_2RCGy-01250-00251016-00251167": "who provides commentary on the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01251-00251167-00251351": "variations of society", "53vXL_2RCGy-01252-00251352-00251606": "from the viewpoint of an outsider this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01253-00251607-00251830": "was common in the literature of its kind", "53vXL_2RCGy-01254-00251831-00252039": "and popularized greatly by the likes of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01255-00252040-00252142": "jules verne", "53vXL_2RCGy-01256-00252144-00252391": "although as carl friedman points out it", "53vXL_2RCGy-01257-00252392-00252623": "was a technique quite despised by other", "53vXL_2RCGy-01258-00252623-00252758": "writers such as hg", "53vXL_2RCGy-01259-00252759-00253023": "wells the country of erawan is", "53vXL_2RCGy-01260-00253023-00253110": "discovered by", "53vXL_2RCGy-01261-00253111-00253358": "higgs during his voyage of discovery", "53vXL_2RCGy-01262-00253359-00253519": "through parts of new zealand", "53vXL_2RCGy-01263-00253519-00253727": "either similar or identical to areas", "53vXL_2RCGy-01264-00253728-00253910": "known to butler during his time living", "53vXL_2RCGy-01265-00253911-00254015": "on the south island", "53vXL_2RCGy-01266-00254016-00254263": "he eventually crosses over the range to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01267-00254264-00254439": "discover quite by accident", "53vXL_2RCGy-01268-00254440-00254734": "this strange land erwin was not just a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01269-00254735-00254934": "work that asked curious questions of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01270-00254935-00255119": "charles darwin's theory of natural", "53vXL_2RCGy-01271-00255119-00255215": "selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01272-00255216-00255463": "in doing so butler was applying what he", "53vXL_2RCGy-01273-00255464-00255671": "knew of darwin's theory to the expansion", "53vXL_2RCGy-01274-00255671-00255830": "of machine technology since the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01275-00255831-00256071": "beginnings of the industrial revolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-01276-00256071-00256351": "this was however one aspect of erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01277-00256352-00256542": "and makes up a small but significant", "53vXL_2RCGy-01278-00256544-00256719": "portion of the novel", "53vXL_2RCGy-01279-00256719-00256942": "butler felt however that the work was", "53vXL_2RCGy-01280-00256944-00257151": "more a gentler kind of attack on", "53vXL_2RCGy-01281-00257152-00257303": "victorian morality", "53vXL_2RCGy-01282-00257304-00257534": "rather than any kind of major criticism", "53vXL_2RCGy-01283-00257535-00257727": "against charles darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-01284-00257728-00257951": "what is important in erawan is that the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01285-00257952-00258134": "seeds of butler's future argument", "53vXL_2RCGy-01286-00258135-00258351": "against darwinian evolution were being", "53vXL_2RCGy-01287-00258352-00258487": "sown", "53vXL_2RCGy-01288-00258488-00258687": "in looking at the evolution of machines", "53vXL_2RCGy-01289-00258688-00258879": "by natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01290-00258880-00259039": "he realized that in gaining an", "53vXL_2RCGy-01291-00259040-00259239": "understanding of evolution as presented", "53vXL_2RCGy-01292-00259240-00259342": "by darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-01293-00259344-00259567": "mankind had been left with a mechanistic", "53vXL_2RCGy-01294-00259567-00259719": "view of the universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-01295-00259719-00259903": "something that would seem to be painful", "53vXL_2RCGy-01296-00259904-00260094": "for butler to accept", "53vXL_2RCGy-01297-00260096-00260342": "his leader works life and habit", "53vXL_2RCGy-01298-00260344-00260551": "evolution old and new", "53vXL_2RCGy-01299-00260552-00260919": "unconscious memory and luck or cunning", "53vXL_2RCGy-01300-00260919-00261151": "would solidly attack darwin's theory and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01301-00261152-00261310": "its consequences", "53vXL_2RCGy-01302-00261311-00261558": "in turn creating uproar and notoriety", "53vXL_2RCGy-01303-00261559-00261687": "for butler", "53vXL_2RCGy-01304-00261688-00261871": "this in light of his previous work was", "53vXL_2RCGy-01305-00261871-00262063": "somewhat mystifying for butler", "53vXL_2RCGy-01306-00262064-00262375": "as he mentions in his notebooks", "53vXL_2RCGy-01307-00262376-00262599": "i attacked the foundations of morality", "53vXL_2RCGy-01308-00262600-00262687": "in erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01309-00262688-00262975": "and nobody cared two straws i tore open", "53vXL_2RCGy-01310-00262976-00263175": "the wounds of my redeemer as he hung", "53vXL_2RCGy-01311-00263176-00263399": "upon the cross in the fair haven", "53vXL_2RCGy-01312-00263400-00263623": "and people rather liked it but when i", "53vXL_2RCGy-01313-00263624-00263782": "attacked mr darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-01314-00263783-00264087": "they were up in arms in a moment", "53vXL_2RCGy-01315-00264088-00264279": "samuel butler despite having been a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01316-00264280-00264519": "supporter of darwin's ideas on natural", "53vXL_2RCGy-01317-00264520-00264615": "selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01318-00264616-00264799": "eventually reeled against them because", "53vXL_2RCGy-01319-00264800-00264975": "they gave him little solace", "53vXL_2RCGy-01320-00264976-00265247": "as to the point of human existence", "53vXL_2RCGy-01321-00265248-00265447": "feeling as he did that natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01322-00265448-00265606": "provided such a bleak", "53vXL_2RCGy-01323-00265607-00265871": "mechanical and desolate landscape for", "53vXL_2RCGy-01324-00265872-00266047": "human beings to inhabit", "53vXL_2RCGy-01325-00266048-00266263": "then darwin's theory allowed no room for", "53vXL_2RCGy-01326-00266264-00266447": "the passing on of human knowledge and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01327-00266448-00266623": "achievement", "53vXL_2RCGy-01328-00266624-00266863": "his return to the ideas of inheritances", "53vXL_2RCGy-01329-00266864-00267110": "provided for an evolution by lamarck", "53vXL_2RCGy-01330-00267111-00267327": "was seemingly essential to his mental", "53vXL_2RCGy-01331-00267328-00267430": "well-being", "53vXL_2RCGy-01332-00267431-00267663": "and the notion developed an erawan and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01333-00267664-00267791": "subsequent works", "53vXL_2RCGy-01334-00267792-00268006": "of the direct passing on of traits from", "53vXL_2RCGy-01335-00268007-00268182": "parents to children", "53vXL_2RCGy-01336-00268183-00268423": "cole sums up his viewpoint of darwin and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01337-00268424-00268655": "the consequences of natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01338-00268656-00269047": "concisely he saw darwin as the destroyer", "53vXL_2RCGy-01339-00269048-00269271": "of the foundations of human liberty as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01340-00269272-00269471": "well as the recognition of any element", "53vXL_2RCGy-01341-00269472-00269639": "of purpose in human life", "53vXL_2RCGy-01342-00269640-00269815": "and he sought to give man back his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01343-00269816-00270047": "liberty by insisting that the individual", "53vXL_2RCGy-01344-00270048-00270223": "could not only learn by his own effort", "53vXL_2RCGy-01345-00270224-00270375": "to master his environment", "53vXL_2RCGy-01346-00270376-00270575": "better but could also transmit this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01347-00270576-00270767": "learning through a process of heritable", "53vXL_2RCGy-01348-00270768-00270982": "biological adoption", "53vXL_2RCGy-01349-00270983-00271199": "the notion of the man who raged against", "53vXL_2RCGy-01350-00271200-00271406": "the nature of family life in the way of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01351-00271407-00271510": "all flesh", "53vXL_2RCGy-01352-00271511-00271687": "turning to the family unit as his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01353-00271688-00271934": "defense of his beliefs about evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-01354-00271935-00272158": "is an irony that is likely lost on a few", "53vXL_2RCGy-01355-00272159-00272351": "who knew butler or his work", "53vXL_2RCGy-01356-00272352-00272599": "as cole notes butler regarded the family", "53vXL_2RCGy-01357-00272600-00272806": "as the great transmitting agency of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01358-00272807-00272999": "acquired habits", "53vXL_2RCGy-01359-00273000-00273182": "butler would come to explain his own", "53vXL_2RCGy-01360-00273183-00273415": "viewpoint of inheritance from a familial", "53vXL_2RCGy-01361-00273416-00273495": "aspect", "53vXL_2RCGy-01362-00273496-00273679": "but did not elaborate in any great", "53vXL_2RCGy-01363-00273680-00273951": "fashion as butler saw it there had to be", "53vXL_2RCGy-01364-00273952-00274199": "a direct continuation of memory between", "53vXL_2RCGy-01365-00274200-00274510": "parents and their offspring a cem", "53vXL_2RCGy-01366-00274511-00274758": "joke illustrates it was george bernard", "53vXL_2RCGy-01367-00274759-00274991": "shaw who was able to clarify and express", "53vXL_2RCGy-01368-00274992-00275215": "butler's position on the questions of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01369-00275216-00275375": "development and inheritance", "53vXL_2RCGy-01370-00275376-00275647": "in the evolutionary process we are now", "53vXL_2RCGy-01371-00275648-00275806": "in a position to enumerate", "53vXL_2RCGy-01372-00275807-00276071": "the four main heads of butler's position", "53vXL_2RCGy-01373-00276072-00276175": "they are", "53vXL_2RCGy-01374-00276176-00276447": "one the oneness of personality between", "53vXL_2RCGy-01375-00276448-00276623": "parents and offspring", "53vXL_2RCGy-01376-00276624-00276871": "two memory on the part of the offspring", "53vXL_2RCGy-01377-00276872-00277030": "of what it did in the person of its", "53vXL_2RCGy-01378-00277031-00277182": "forefathers", "53vXL_2RCGy-01379-00277183-00277447": "three the latency of this memory until", "53vXL_2RCGy-01380-00277448-00277647": "it is rekindled by a recurrence of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01381-00277648-00277847": "associated ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-01382-00277848-00278103": "4. the unconsciousness with which", "53vXL_2RCGy-01383-00278104-00278430": "habitual actions come to be performed", "53vXL_2RCGy-01384-00278431-00278655": "samuel butler's prolonged and public", "53vXL_2RCGy-01385-00278656-00278799": "argument went to the core of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01386-00278800-00278975": "disagreements over the theories of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01387-00278976-00279047": "evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-01388-00279048-00279295": "presented by various parties in the 19th", "53vXL_2RCGy-01389-00279296-00279406": "century", "53vXL_2RCGy-01390-00279407-00279671": "butler was deliberately iconoclastic and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01391-00279672-00279871": "seemed to relish in the attention his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01392-00279872-00280079": "attacks on darwin produced", "53vXL_2RCGy-01393-00280080-00280303": "charles darwin tended not to respond to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01394-00280304-00280551": "butler out of interestingly enough", "53vXL_2RCGy-01395-00280552-00280871": "a fear of the author's vehemence", "53vXL_2RCGy-01396-00280872-00281103": "ultimately samuel butler provided a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01397-00281104-00281295": "notable attack on the tenets of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01398-00281296-00281510": "natural selection from the point of view", "53vXL_2RCGy-01399-00281511-00281695": "of an interested amateur", "53vXL_2RCGy-01400-00281696-00281887": "arguing from a philosophical and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01401-00281888-00282030": "intellectual regard", "53vXL_2RCGy-01402-00282031-00282158": "that had no grounding and a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01403-00282159-00282358": "methodological scientific approach", "53vXL_2RCGy-01404-00282359-00282455": "whatsoever", "53vXL_2RCGy-01405-00282456-00282671": "his role in poking out logical problems", "53vXL_2RCGy-01406-00282672-00282879": "of darwin's theory centered on elements", "53vXL_2RCGy-01407-00282880-00283071": "of natural selection that can be found", "53vXL_2RCGy-01408-00283072-00283223": "in the works of befall", "53vXL_2RCGy-01409-00283224-00283558": "lamarck and erasmus darwin himself", "53vXL_2RCGy-01410-00283559-00283751": "from butler's viewpoint this was a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01411-00283752-00283958": "travesty that served to wipe these men's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01412-00283959-00284223": "works from the historical record", "53vXL_2RCGy-01413-00284224-00284415": "butler's other major problem came from", "53vXL_2RCGy-01414-00284416-00284551": "the fact that darwin", "53vXL_2RCGy-01415-00284552-00284791": "had not provided a satisfactory answer", "53vXL_2RCGy-01416-00284792-00284999": "to the question his work on natural", "53vXL_2RCGy-01417-00285000-00285319": "selection offered up from its very title", "53vXL_2RCGy-01418-00285320-00285591": "what exactly is the origin of species", "53vXL_2RCGy-01419-00285592-00285791": "where is the genesis point the very", "53vXL_2RCGy-01420-00285792-00285903": "beginning", "53vXL_2RCGy-01421-00285904-00286119": "finally butler's other major problem", "53vXL_2RCGy-01422-00286120-00286327": "with on the origin of species", "53vXL_2RCGy-01423-00286328-00286510": "came from the mechanistic viewpoint of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01424-00286511-00286663": "the universe that this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01425-00286664-00286854": "and other evolutionary theses were", "53vXL_2RCGy-01426-00286855-00287087": "creating it seemingly brought butler", "53vXL_2RCGy-01427-00287088-00287351": "back to the desire of having a theistic", "53vXL_2RCGy-01428-00287352-00287487": "outlook on the universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-01429-00287488-00287679": "which he had turned away from years", "53vXL_2RCGy-01430-00287680-00287927": "earlier the seeds of butler's career of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01431-00287928-00288110": "standing against darwin's view of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01432-00288111-00288239": "natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01433-00288240-00288495": "can all be found in erawan many of which", "53vXL_2RCGy-01434-00288496-00288647": "he would develop later in his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01435-00288648-00288806": "evolutionary works", "53vXL_2RCGy-01436-00288807-00288967": "it would not be until the event of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01437-00288968-00289230": "gregor mendel's work on discontinuous", "53vXL_2RCGy-01438-00289231-00289454": "inheritance which was subsequently", "53vXL_2RCGy-01439-00289455-00289687": "rediscovered by the likes of carl eric", "53vXL_2RCGy-01440-00289688-00289758": "corons", "53vXL_2RCGy-01441-00289759-00290023": "and hugo de vries that these scientists", "53vXL_2RCGy-01442-00290024-00290230": "work would see the beginnings of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01443-00290231-00290415": "science of genetics which would", "53vXL_2RCGy-01444-00290416-00290639": "ultimately put butler's arguments", "53vXL_2RCGy-01445-00290640-00291006": "finally to rest erawan presents several", "53vXL_2RCGy-01446-00291007-00291199": "key concepts which upon a closer", "53vXL_2RCGy-01447-00291200-00291319": "examination", "53vXL_2RCGy-01448-00291320-00291503": "are found to be highly important in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01449-00291504-00291647": "study of frank herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01450-00291648-00291871": "june series either as direct", "53vXL_2RCGy-01451-00291872-00291991": "extrapolations", "53vXL_2RCGy-01452-00291992-00292327": "or as major influences individually one", "53vXL_2RCGy-01453-00292328-00292519": "may look at these influences on frank", "53vXL_2RCGy-01454-00292520-00292582": "herbert", "53vXL_2RCGy-01455-00292583-00292806": "as perhaps a respectful nod from one", "53vXL_2RCGy-01456-00292807-00292943": "author to another", "53vXL_2RCGy-01457-00292944-00293143": "but collectively and through herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01458-00293144-00293310": "acknowledgement to samuel butler in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01459-00293311-00293487": "naming his butlerian jihad", "53vXL_2RCGy-01460-00293488-00293751": "after him on second glance we realize", "53vXL_2RCGy-01461-00293752-00293927": "there is a greater importance to these", "53vXL_2RCGy-01462-00293928-00294087": "concepts", "53vXL_2RCGy-01463-00294088-00294319": "in total there are five key ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-01464-00294320-00294551": "developed and explored by frank herbert", "53vXL_2RCGy-01465-00294552-00294647": "from erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01466-00294648-00294982": "and are as follows one the unborn and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01467-00294983-00295247": "their plaguing of the arrowonians", "53vXL_2RCGy-01468-00295248-00295495": "two the existence of a collective", "53vXL_2RCGy-01469-00295496-00295606": "unconscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01470-00295607-00295991": "or racial memory three prescience as an", "53vXL_2RCGy-01471-00295992-00296119": "evolutionary trait", "53vXL_2RCGy-01472-00296120-00296463": "developed through natural selection four", "53vXL_2RCGy-01473-00296464-00296687": "the evolution of machines to a level", "53vXL_2RCGy-01474-00296688-00296791": "singularity", "53vXL_2RCGy-01475-00296792-00297047": "where human beings are subjugated and no", "53vXL_2RCGy-01476-00297048-00297279": "longer the dominant species", "53vXL_2RCGy-01477-00297280-00297582": "five to a lesser extent messianism", "53vXL_2RCGy-01478-00297583-00297903": "and the origin of religious systems note", "53vXL_2RCGy-01479-00297904-00298095": "this is more through this subject being", "53vXL_2RCGy-01480-00298096-00298319": "explored by samuel butler in the sequel", "53vXL_2RCGy-01481-00298320-00298406": "to erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01482-00298407-00298767": "erawan revisited the unborn pre-born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01483-00298768-00299023": "and the collective unconscious the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01484-00299024-00299254": "nature of the unborn in erawan is", "53vXL_2RCGy-01485-00299255-00299463": "uncannily similar to that of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01486-00299464-00299647": "pre-born in june", "53vXL_2RCGy-01487-00299648-00299943": "in erawan in the chapters entitled birth", "53vXL_2RCGy-01488-00299944-00300047": "formulae", "53vXL_2RCGy-01489-00300048-00300327": "the world of the unborn and what they", "53vXL_2RCGy-01490-00300328-00300471": "mean by it", "53vXL_2RCGy-01491-00300472-00300639": "the unborn are the children of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01492-00300640-00300791": "aeromonians who live on", "53vXL_2RCGy-01493-00300792-00301047": "unknown planets in what is described as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01494-00301048-00301295": "a pre-existent state", "53vXL_2RCGy-01495-00301296-00301495": "the way the unborn come into the world", "53vXL_2RCGy-01496-00301496-00301734": "in butler's topsy-turvy country is by", "53vXL_2RCGy-01497-00301735-00301934": "the constant plaguing of potential", "53vXL_2RCGy-01498-00301935-00302199": "parents from their pre-existence state", "53vXL_2RCGy-01499-00302200-00302406": "giving them no peace either of mind or", "53vXL_2RCGy-01500-00302407-00302623": "body until they have consented to take", "53vXL_2RCGy-01501-00302624-00302806": "them under their protection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01502-00302807-00303023": "the result of which is being born as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01503-00303024-00303182": "their child", "53vXL_2RCGy-01504-00303183-00303391": "once ready to be born they then take a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01505-00303392-00303582": "potion which removes their memories and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01506-00303583-00303679": "identities", "53vXL_2RCGy-01507-00303680-00303903": "before committing a form of suicide", "53vXL_2RCGy-01508-00303904-00304151": "which then brings them into the world", "53vXL_2RCGy-01509-00304152-00304319": "the inhabitants see their children in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01510-00304320-00304495": "the light of their concocted myth of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01511-00304496-00304582": "pre-born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01512-00304583-00304863": "as a terrible imposition and it is as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01513-00304864-00304991": "part of this tradition", "53vXL_2RCGy-01514-00304992-00305175": "that they have what they call birth", "53vXL_2RCGy-01515-00305176-00305334": "formula drawn up", "53vXL_2RCGy-01516-00305335-00305591": "a document signed on behalf of the child", "53vXL_2RCGy-01517-00305592-00305743": "at birth", "53vXL_2RCGy-01518-00305744-00305975": "this document is presented in a solemn", "53vXL_2RCGy-01519-00305976-00306230": "melancholy occasion some days after the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01520-00306231-00306351": "child's birth", "53vXL_2RCGy-01521-00306352-00306543": "and states that the child takes all", "53vXL_2RCGy-01522-00306544-00306758": "responsibility for being born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01523-00306759-00306927": "as it had plagued the parents to come", "53vXL_2RCGy-01524-00306928-00307103": "into this world from a state", "53vXL_2RCGy-01525-00307104-00307295": "where it had previously been altogether", "53vXL_2RCGy-01526-00307296-00307575": "happy and looked after", "53vXL_2RCGy-01527-00307576-00307823": "these chapters represent one of butler's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01528-00307824-00307991": "typical inversions", "53vXL_2RCGy-01529-00307992-00308182": "in this case of the happiness upon the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01530-00308183-00308334": "occasion of a new birth", "53vXL_2RCGy-01531-00308335-00308527": "and illustrate effectively the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01532-00308528-00308734": "discontentment and unhappiness in his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01533-00308735-00308839": "own childhood", "53vXL_2RCGy-01534-00308840-00309071": "though again his work is more touched", "53vXL_2RCGy-01535-00309072-00309215": "with cynical humor", "53vXL_2RCGy-01536-00309216-00309415": "than being an outright attack on his own", "53vXL_2RCGy-01537-00309416-00309551": "family", "53vXL_2RCGy-01538-00309552-00309703": "that would come with the eventual", "53vXL_2RCGy-01539-00309704-00309910": "posthumous publication of the way of all", "53vXL_2RCGy-01540-00309911-00310030": "flesh", "53vXL_2RCGy-01541-00310031-00310199": "it is however meant to be a strong", "53vXL_2RCGy-01542-00310200-00310415": "enough indictment on victorian family", "53vXL_2RCGy-01543-00310416-00310534": "values", "53vXL_2RCGy-01544-00310535-00310782": "the nature of pre-existence in erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01545-00310783-00311006": "corresponds to butler's ideas of a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01546-00311007-00311167": "collective unconscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01547-00311168-00311319": "which showed the beginnings of his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01548-00311320-00311510": "doubts regarding darwin's theory of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01549-00311511-00311647": "natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01550-00311648-00311999": "as occurring by chance it is a concept", "53vXL_2RCGy-01551-00312000-00312199": "that predates those ideas young put", "53vXL_2RCGy-01552-00312200-00312391": "forward in relation to the archetypes of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01553-00312392-00312534": "collective unconscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01554-00312535-00312734": "an area of psychology that interested", "53vXL_2RCGy-01555-00312735-00312895": "frank herbert in his studies", "53vXL_2RCGy-01556-00312896-00313039": "and would account for one of june's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01557-00313040-00313423": "other major themes the catastrophic hero", "53vXL_2RCGy-01558-00313424-00313654": "in june the pre-born are those children", "53vXL_2RCGy-01559-00313655-00313830": "exposed to the water of life", "53vXL_2RCGy-01560-00313831-00314030": "while still in the womb of a bernie", "53vXL_2RCGy-01561-00314031-00314271": "jesuit as she goes through the spice", "53vXL_2RCGy-01562-00314272-00314575": "agony to become a reverend's mother the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01563-00314576-00314782": "water of life is a poison taken from the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01564-00314783-00315039": "bile of the newborn worms of arrakis", "53vXL_2RCGy-01565-00315040-00315247": "which the bernie jesuit sisters must", "53vXL_2RCGy-01566-00315248-00315439": "change at a molecular level upon", "53vXL_2RCGy-01567-00315440-00315519": "drinking", "53vXL_2RCGy-01568-00315520-00315799": "with failure bringing death this is", "53vXL_2RCGy-01569-00315800-00315910": "known as the spice", "53vXL_2RCGy-01570-00315911-00316182": "agony and those that survive it become", "53vXL_2RCGy-01571-00316183-00316358": "full reverent mothers", "53vXL_2RCGy-01572-00316359-00316558": "opening up the abilities of other memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01573-00316559-00316703": "to the bernie jesuit", "53vXL_2RCGy-01574-00316704-00316903": "who are then able to look into their", "53vXL_2RCGy-01575-00316904-00317039": "genetic past", "53vXL_2RCGy-01576-00317040-00317230": "through all the women in history who", "53vXL_2RCGy-01577-00317231-00317415": "have come before them", "53vXL_2RCGy-01578-00317416-00317595": "the pre-born are also known as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01579-00317596-00317727": "abominations", "53vXL_2RCGy-01580-00317728-00317991": "for more often than not they go insane", "53vXL_2RCGy-01581-00317992-00318191": "inheriting the same abilities as a full", "53vXL_2RCGy-01582-00318192-00318295": "reverend mother", "53vXL_2RCGy-01583-00318296-00318503": "along with full consciousness while", "53vXL_2RCGy-01584-00318504-00318695": "still in the womb", "53vXL_2RCGy-01585-00318696-00318895": "the insanity comes from the constant", "53vXL_2RCGy-01586-00318896-00319087": "plaguing of the different personalities", "53vXL_2RCGy-01587-00319088-00319158": "contained", "53vXL_2RCGy-01588-00319159-00319439": "within the female other memory who all", "53vXL_2RCGy-01589-00319440-00319719": "struggle for prominence and attention", "53vXL_2RCGy-01590-00319720-00319958": "a fully trained reverend mother is able", "53vXL_2RCGy-01591-00319959-00320167": "to control the myriad of personalities", "53vXL_2RCGy-01592-00320168-00320263": "within her", "53vXL_2RCGy-01593-00320264-00320463": "but the preborn have little experience", "53vXL_2RCGy-01594-00320464-00320599": "to save them", "53vXL_2RCGy-01595-00320600-00320823": "often losing their minds to either one", "53vXL_2RCGy-01596-00320824-00320999": "dominant personality", "53vXL_2RCGy-01597-00321000-00321310": "or else to the entire multitude", "53vXL_2RCGy-01598-00321311-00321534": "in the june series this happens to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01599-00321535-00321695": "paul's sister alia", "53vXL_2RCGy-01600-00321696-00321958": "who is eventually driven insane before", "53vXL_2RCGy-01601-00321959-00322143": "finally committing suicide in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01602-00322144-00322430": "children of june paul's twin children", "53vXL_2RCGy-01603-00322431-00322599": "are also pre-born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01604-00322600-00322823": "due to the vast amounts of melange their", "53vXL_2RCGy-01605-00322824-00322999": "mother is forced to take", "53vXL_2RCGy-01606-00323000-00323206": "during her pregnancy to counteract the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01607-00323207-00323567": "effects of a contraceptive poison", "53vXL_2RCGy-01608-00323568-00323743": "they are however spared the madness", "53vXL_2RCGy-01609-00323744-00323919": "which consumes their ant", "53vXL_2RCGy-01610-00323920-00324103": "albeit both being under the same", "53vXL_2RCGy-01611-00324104-00324303": "pressures that other memory brought", "53vXL_2RCGy-01612-00324304-00324663": "and which ultimately caused her insanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-01613-00324664-00324903": "leto the second in particular eventually", "53vXL_2RCGy-01614-00324904-00325110": "allows the personality of haram to come", "53vXL_2RCGy-01615-00325111-00325191": "to the fore", "53vXL_2RCGy-01616-00325192-00325343": "in order to help him control the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01617-00325344-00325606": "multitude but what makes him able to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01618-00325607-00325687": "deal with this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01619-00325688-00325999": "better than alia is not made clear it is", "53vXL_2RCGy-01620-00326000-00326167": "perhaps the strength that he gains from", "53vXL_2RCGy-01621-00326168-00326295": "his symbiosis", "53vXL_2RCGy-01622-00326296-00326487": "with the soundtrack that makes him the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01623-00326488-00326623": "ultimate predator", "53vXL_2RCGy-01624-00326624-00326934": "that allows him to survive this the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01625-00326935-00327167": "unborn and erawan are a primordial", "53vXL_2RCGy-01626-00327168-00327375": "collective unconscious separated from", "53vXL_2RCGy-01627-00327376-00327487": "the erroneous", "53vXL_2RCGy-01628-00327488-00327678": "and are fundamentally connected to their", "53vXL_2RCGy-01629-00327679-00327919": "views of reproduction", "53vXL_2RCGy-01630-00327920-00328103": "it raises the question of the unborn", "53vXL_2RCGy-01631-00328104-00328319": "being a kind of mass delusion", "53vXL_2RCGy-01632-00328320-00328478": "but the fact that they are from another", "53vXL_2RCGy-01633-00328479-00328671": "world and hence alien", "53vXL_2RCGy-01634-00328672-00328903": "does not bother the aeronians who are", "53vXL_2RCGy-01635-00328904-00329071": "themselves the end product of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01636-00329072-00329310": "unborn's desire to enter the world of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01637-00329311-00329463": "erwan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01638-00329464-00329687": "the unborns plaguing of the arabonians", "53vXL_2RCGy-01639-00329688-00329927": "as a multitude seeking to be born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01640-00329928-00330151": "is an obvious comparison to the preborn", "53vXL_2RCGy-01641-00330152-00330310": "of the bani jesuit gender", "53vXL_2RCGy-01642-00330311-00330551": "orientated other memory in herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01643-00330552-00330751": "june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-01644-00330752-00330943": "the multitude of personalities of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01645-00330944-00331134": "female line that the bane desert", "53vXL_2RCGy-01646-00331135-00331230": "experience", "53vXL_2RCGy-01647-00331231-00331439": "vie for attention and re-emergence", "53vXL_2RCGy-01648-00331440-00331543": "through contact", "53vXL_2RCGy-01649-00331544-00331703": "with the host personality of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01650-00331704-00331958": "reverend mother the bene desert only", "53vXL_2RCGy-01651-00331959-00332127": "experienced this after having had the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01652-00332128-00332327": "training and wisdom of many years", "53vXL_2RCGy-01653-00332328-00332478": "before going through the test of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01654-00332479-00332710": "drinking the poisonous water of life", "53vXL_2RCGy-01655-00332711-00332934": "a fully trained reverend mother who has", "53vXL_2RCGy-01656-00332935-00333063": "passed this test", "53vXL_2RCGy-01657-00333064-00333358": "then has access to this multitude and is", "53vXL_2RCGy-01658-00333359-00333406": "capable", "53vXL_2RCGy-01659-00333407-00333575": "of bringing forward either a single", "53vXL_2RCGy-01660-00333576-00333782": "personality or a selection of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01661-00333783-00333910": "collective whole", "53vXL_2RCGy-01662-00333911-00334191": "known as simuflow in order to access", "53vXL_2RCGy-01663-00334192-00334471": "their memories and experiences", "53vXL_2RCGy-01664-00334472-00334743": "the race memory or other memory or", "53vXL_2RCGy-01665-00334744-00334799": "collective", "53vXL_2RCGy-01666-00334800-00335071": "unconscious that is accessed by the bene", "53vXL_2RCGy-01667-00335072-00335151": "desert", "53vXL_2RCGy-01668-00335152-00335471": "is gender specific only providing access", "53vXL_2RCGy-01669-00335472-00335710": "to the female ancestry of the human", "53vXL_2RCGy-01670-00335711-00335854": "species", "53vXL_2RCGy-01671-00335855-00336047": "this then is the real purpose of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01672-00336048-00336199": "quizadz hadarac breeding", "53vXL_2RCGy-01673-00336200-00336510": "program to create a male bannet desert", "53vXL_2RCGy-01674-00336511-00336727": "who is capable of accessing the memories", "53vXL_2RCGy-01675-00336728-00336975": "and experiences of the male ancestry", "53vXL_2RCGy-01676-00336976-00337303": "of the human species problems unforeseen", "53vXL_2RCGy-01677-00337304-00337558": "a rise in accessing this racial memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01678-00337559-00337895": "in two key aspects first of all", "53vXL_2RCGy-01679-00337896-00338167": "the quiz at saddarac is seemingly able", "53vXL_2RCGy-01680-00338168-00338263": "to access", "53vXL_2RCGy-01681-00338264-00338503": "all genetic memories and experiences", "53vXL_2RCGy-01682-00338504-00338630": "following the ingestion", "53vXL_2RCGy-01683-00338631-00338903": "and transmutation of the water of life", "53vXL_2RCGy-01684-00338904-00339110": "however in addition to accessing the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01685-00339111-00339334": "pre-existing and subconsciously hidden", "53vXL_2RCGy-01686-00339335-00339463": "racial memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01687-00339464-00339687": "the additional side effect of near or", "53vXL_2RCGy-01688-00339688-00339934": "total prescience is observed in such an", "53vXL_2RCGy-01689-00339935-00340095": "individual", "53vXL_2RCGy-01690-00340096-00340327": "the second unforeseen problem arises", "53vXL_2RCGy-01691-00340328-00340510": "when a banana jezerite takes the water", "53vXL_2RCGy-01692-00340511-00340575": "of life", "53vXL_2RCGy-01693-00340576-00340919": "whilst pregnant this causes the fetus to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01694-00340920-00341143": "enter the state known as preborn", "53vXL_2RCGy-01695-00341144-00341319": "where the collective unconscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01696-00341320-00341527": "available to the bane desert", "53vXL_2RCGy-01697-00341528-00341727": "immediately becomes accessible to the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01698-00341728-00341863": "unborn child", "53vXL_2RCGy-01699-00341864-00342054": "bringing the fetus to full awareness in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01700-00342055-00342206": "the womb", "53vXL_2RCGy-01701-00342207-00342463": "this happens to alia paul's sister when", "53vXL_2RCGy-01702-00342464-00342687": "jessica undergoes the ritual", "53vXL_2RCGy-01703-00342688-00342910": "the bene jesuit forbids this under", "53vXL_2RCGy-01704-00342911-00343078": "normal circumstances", "53vXL_2RCGy-01705-00343079-00343263": "referring to such a child as an", "53vXL_2RCGy-01706-00343264-00343439": "abomination", "53vXL_2RCGy-01707-00343440-00343647": "such children are often feared because", "53vXL_2RCGy-01708-00343648-00343839": "of their unnatural maturity", "53vXL_2RCGy-01709-00343840-00344143": "and knowledge in addition the experience", "53vXL_2RCGy-01710-00344144-00344375": "of having the multitude of other memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01711-00344376-00344399": "at", "53vXL_2RCGy-01712-00344400-00344671": "such a young age often results in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01713-00344672-00344887": "madness and death", "53vXL_2RCGy-01714-00344888-00345087": "interestingly and despite the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01715-00345088-00345295": "differences in other memory available to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01716-00345296-00345423": "the bernie jesuit", "53vXL_2RCGy-01717-00345424-00345678": "female and the quiz arts hadarank", "53vXL_2RCGy-01718-00345679-00345847": "predominantly meal", "53vXL_2RCGy-01719-00345848-00346119": "herbert shows alia's growing insanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-01720-00346120-00346303": "due to the clamoring of the multitude", "53vXL_2RCGy-01721-00346304-00346471": "within her conscious mind", "53vXL_2RCGy-01722-00346472-00346758": "turning to a male aspect within other", "53vXL_2RCGy-01723-00346759-00346878": "memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01724-00346879-00347039": "this is of course her maternal", "53vXL_2RCGy-01725-00347040-00347230": "grandfather the villainous", "53vXL_2RCGy-01726-00347231-00347543": "baron vladimir harkonnen this is not", "53vXL_2RCGy-01727-00347544-00347751": "really explained by frank herbert in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01728-00347752-00347878": "june messiah or", "53vXL_2RCGy-01729-00347879-00348054": "children of june but it could be", "53vXL_2RCGy-01730-00348055-00348239": "suggestive that as part of the same", "53vXL_2RCGy-01731-00348240-00348463": "generation of the bene jesuit breeding", "53vXL_2RCGy-01732-00348464-00348527": "program", "53vXL_2RCGy-01733-00348528-00348791": "and having the same parents as paul that", "53vXL_2RCGy-01734-00348792-00349015": "alia is at least a potential quizet's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01735-00349016-00349087": "hadarach", "53vXL_2RCGy-01736-00349088-00349415": "despite being female herbert viewed alia", "53vXL_2RCGy-01737-00349416-00349647": "together with paul as a representation", "53vXL_2RCGy-01738-00349648-00349823": "of the janus aspect", "53vXL_2RCGy-01739-00349824-00350087": "one looking forward one looking back as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01740-00350088-00350310": "well as a representation of the jungian", "53vXL_2RCGy-01741-00350311-00350534": "archetype of the syzygy", "53vXL_2RCGy-01742-00350535-00350775": "here herbert has paul looking forward", "53vXL_2RCGy-01743-00350776-00350887": "into the future", "53vXL_2RCGy-01744-00350888-00351151": "using prescience and is fully conscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01745-00351152-00351303": "of time and space", "53vXL_2RCGy-01746-00351304-00351575": "whereas alia is the direct antithesis", "53vXL_2RCGy-01747-00351576-00351639": "that looks", "53vXL_2RCGy-01748-00351640-00351903": "backward through other memory this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01749-00351904-00352127": "slowly but eventually subverts her own", "53vXL_2RCGy-01750-00352128-00352230": "personality", "53vXL_2RCGy-01751-00352231-00352478": "both consciously and subconsciously to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01752-00352479-00352654": "the point where the baron is able to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01753-00352655-00352782": "undertake action", "53vXL_2RCGy-01754-00352783-00353127": "by controlling her body alia continues", "53vXL_2RCGy-01755-00353128-00353263": "to expose herself", "53vXL_2RCGy-01756-00353264-00353503": "to large doses of melange in order to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01757-00353504-00353719": "increase her prescient abilities which", "53vXL_2RCGy-01758-00353720-00353847": "are similar to paul's", "53vXL_2RCGy-01759-00353848-00354167": "but significantly inferior this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01760-00354168-00354399": "continued exposure to large doses of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01761-00354400-00354543": "melange continues to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01762-00354544-00354799": "exaggerate her ever-increasing fragile", "53vXL_2RCGy-01763-00354800-00354871": "state", "53vXL_2RCGy-01764-00354872-00355047": "leading her to rely on the personality", "53vXL_2RCGy-01765-00355048-00355182": "of the baron heart conan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01766-00355183-00355343": "to not just help her control the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01767-00355344-00355543": "multitude in her other memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01768-00355544-00355710": "but also to help her in the real", "53vXL_2RCGy-01769-00355711-00355919": "conscious world giving her advice and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01770-00355920-00356127": "guiding her actions in the intrigues of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01771-00356128-00356319": "moa deeb's court", "53vXL_2RCGy-01772-00356320-00356527": "herbert having the baron as the dominant", "53vXL_2RCGy-01773-00356528-00356687": "personality in her mind", "53vXL_2RCGy-01774-00356688-00356878": "is difficult to explain in the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-01775-00356879-00357119": "series as there should only be female", "53vXL_2RCGy-01776-00357120-00357239": "personalities within", "53vXL_2RCGy-01777-00357240-00357558": "alia the seemingly obvious explanation", "53vXL_2RCGy-01778-00357559-00357751": "that herbert leaves us to ponder", "53vXL_2RCGy-01779-00357752-00357951": "is that the baron harkonnen is most", "53vXL_2RCGy-01780-00357952-00358206": "likely a manifestation of alia's growing", "53vXL_2RCGy-01781-00358207-00358310": "insanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-01782-00358311-00358599": "and not a product of other memory after", "53vXL_2RCGy-01783-00358600-00358710": "all", "53vXL_2RCGy-01784-00358711-00358934": "it also gives frank herbert an excuse to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01785-00358935-00359143": "bring back an interesting character", "53vXL_2RCGy-01786-00359144-00359367": "that he had killed off in june having", "53vXL_2RCGy-01787-00359368-00359615": "done something similar with duncan idaho", "53vXL_2RCGy-01788-00359616-00359830": "who also proved to be very popular in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01789-00359831-00360006": "the first novel", "53vXL_2RCGy-01790-00360007-00360303": "leto ii and ganama are also born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01791-00360304-00360399": "pre-born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01792-00360400-00360582": "and have the similar multitudes within", "53vXL_2RCGy-01793-00360583-00360710": "their memories", "53vXL_2RCGy-01794-00360711-00360910": "again both characters represent the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01795-00360911-00361191": "archetype of the syzygy amongst others", "53vXL_2RCGy-01796-00361192-00361519": "c chapter 3. but herbert does not really", "53vXL_2RCGy-01797-00361520-00361743": "explore how ganama is able to maintain", "53vXL_2RCGy-01798-00361744-00361878": "her sanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-01799-00361879-00362134": "instead the focus of how this is managed", "53vXL_2RCGy-01800-00362135-00362367": "centers on litho ii", "53vXL_2RCGy-01801-00362368-00362551": "both of the twins are able to hide the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01802-00362552-00362767": "fact that they are abominations", "53vXL_2RCGy-01803-00362768-00363063": "but this is through deceit on their part", "53vXL_2RCGy-01804-00363064-00363254": "they are seemingly able to exhibit a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01805-00363255-00363471": "level of control over the multitude", "53vXL_2RCGy-01806-00363472-00363719": "but as leader ii goes through his slow", "53vXL_2RCGy-01807-00363720-00363943": "transformation into the god emperor", "53vXL_2RCGy-01808-00363944-00364119": "he reveals that he has chosen one", "53vXL_2RCGy-01809-00364120-00364351": "dominant individual personality", "53vXL_2RCGy-01810-00364352-00364599": "from within the multitude to suppress", "53vXL_2RCGy-01811-00364600-00364782": "all the other voices clamoring for", "53vXL_2RCGy-01812-00364783-00364887": "attention", "53vXL_2RCGy-01813-00364888-00365119": "this is the personality of haram the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01814-00365120-00365191": "egyptian", "53vXL_2RCGy-01815-00365192-00365487": "pharaoh the collective unconscious as", "53vXL_2RCGy-01816-00365488-00365687": "perceived by samuel butler", "53vXL_2RCGy-01817-00365688-00365887": "is different from the representations of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01818-00365888-00366030": "jungian archetypes", "53vXL_2RCGy-01819-00366031-00366310": "and as indicated earlier is largely to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01820-00366311-00366495": "do with the author's attitudes to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01821-00366496-00366782": "darwinian evolutionary theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01822-00366783-00366982": "herbert successfully blends the two", "53vXL_2RCGy-01823-00366983-00367239": "concepts most notably in the character", "53vXL_2RCGy-01824-00367240-00367327": "of alia", "53vXL_2RCGy-01825-00367328-00367543": "whom he uses to explore the nature of a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01826-00367544-00367678": "collective unconscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01827-00367679-00368023": "and racial memory in addition alia is in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01828-00368024-00368263": "herself a study of an individual in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01829-00368264-00368430": "messianic complex", "53vXL_2RCGy-01830-00368431-00368639": "and as such represents a number of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01831-00368640-00368830": "archetypes of the jungian collective", "53vXL_2RCGy-01832-00368831-00368927": "unconscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01833-00368928-00369151": "at different parts of the first june", "53vXL_2RCGy-01834-00369152-00369287": "trilogy", "53vXL_2RCGy-01835-00369288-00369575": "these include the virgin the harlot one", "53vXL_2RCGy-01836-00369576-00369703": "half of the syzygy", "53vXL_2RCGy-01837-00369704-00370015": "the heroine the mother the child", "53vXL_2RCGy-01838-00370016-00370327": "and the hierophant alia is not the only", "53vXL_2RCGy-01839-00370328-00370510": "character used by herbert to explore", "53vXL_2RCGy-01840-00370511-00370623": "these concepts", "53vXL_2RCGy-01841-00370624-00370951": "with paul jessica leto the second", "53vXL_2RCGy-01842-00370952-00371223": "ghanama and most of the bani jesuit", "53vXL_2RCGy-01843-00371224-00371310": "characters", "53vXL_2RCGy-01844-00371311-00371567": "exploring racial memory in some form or", "53vXL_2RCGy-01845-00371568-00371678": "another", "53vXL_2RCGy-01846-00371679-00371975": "the bereich lilacs also explore this but", "53vXL_2RCGy-01847-00371976-00372215": "directly through genetic manipulation", "53vXL_2RCGy-01848-00372216-00372430": "with the final incarnation of duncan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01849-00372431-00372527": "idaho", "53vXL_2RCGy-01850-00372528-00372719": "perhaps representing the ultimate", "53vXL_2RCGy-01851-00372720-00372927": "combination of these ideas", "53vXL_2RCGy-01852-00372928-00373078": "where his other memory becomes a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01853-00373079-00373295": "personal one based on his various", "53vXL_2RCGy-01854-00373296-00373415": "incarnations", "53vXL_2RCGy-01855-00373416-00373751": "over thousands of years the nature", "53vXL_2RCGy-01856-00373752-00374102": "of time and prescience samuel butler", "53vXL_2RCGy-01857-00374103-00374143": "also", "53vXL_2RCGy-01858-00374144-00374375": "notably comments on the nature of time", "53vXL_2RCGy-01859-00374376-00374478": "in the chapter", "53vXL_2RCGy-01860-00374479-00374719": "the world of the unborn and presents us", "53vXL_2RCGy-01861-00374720-00374902": "with an interesting evolutionary", "53vXL_2RCGy-01862-00374903-00375030": "quandary", "53vXL_2RCGy-01863-00375031-00375175": "in the back to front nature of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01864-00375176-00375391": "erymonians we discover that they", "53vXL_2RCGy-01865-00375392-00375454": "perceive", "53vXL_2RCGy-01866-00375455-00375751": "time and life's place therein as moving", "53vXL_2RCGy-01867-00375752-00375854": "backwards", "53vXL_2RCGy-01868-00375855-00376143": "butler's narrator higgs discovers the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01869-00376144-00376454": "existence of a pre-erumonian race of men", "53vXL_2RCGy-01870-00376455-00376647": "that died out long before the present", "53vXL_2RCGy-01871-00376648-00376871": "society came into place", "53vXL_2RCGy-01872-00376872-00377102": "he has shown a text on the mythology", "53vXL_2RCGy-01873-00377103-00377263": "presented to him by one of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01874-00377264-00377510": "professors of unreason before", "53vXL_2RCGy-01875-00377511-00377702": "discovering the erramonian attitude to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01876-00377703-00377782": "the unborn", "53vXL_2RCGy-01877-00377783-00377999": "he comes across an entry on a previous", "53vXL_2RCGy-01878-00378000-00378119": "race of man", "53vXL_2RCGy-01879-00378120-00378358": "that existed according to their myths", "53vXL_2RCGy-01880-00378359-00378591": "before the aramonians", "53vXL_2RCGy-01881-00378592-00378943": "the entry is as follows sometimes", "53vXL_2RCGy-01882-00378944-00379167": "again they say that there was a race of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01883-00379168-00379391": "men tried upon the earth once", "53vXL_2RCGy-01884-00379392-00379647": "who knew the future better than the past", "53vXL_2RCGy-01885-00379648-00379815": "but they died in a 12 month", "53vXL_2RCGy-01886-00379816-00379975": "from the misery which their knowledge", "53vXL_2RCGy-01887-00379976-00380247": "caused them and if any were to be born", "53vXL_2RCGy-01888-00380248-00380502": "too prescient now he would be called out", "53vXL_2RCGy-01889-00380503-00380654": "by natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01890-00380655-00380902": "before he had time to transmit so peace", "53vXL_2RCGy-01891-00380903-00381271": "destroying a faculty to his descendants", "53vXL_2RCGy-01892-00381272-00381502": "similarly prescience is very much a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01893-00381503-00381702": "problem for those who possess it in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01894-00381703-00381815": "june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-01895-00381816-00382054": "from the guild stairsmen and navigators", "53vXL_2RCGy-01896-00382055-00382247": "who use a limited form of prescience to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01897-00382248-00382527": "help navigate their ships through space", "53vXL_2RCGy-01898-00382528-00382767": "to the almost ubiquitous and stifling", "53vXL_2RCGy-01899-00382768-00382854": "prescience", "53vXL_2RCGy-01900-00382855-00383119": "that is experienced by paul and his son", "53vXL_2RCGy-01901-00383120-00383287": "lito ii", "53vXL_2RCGy-01902-00383288-00383567": "it is an inversion in itself that frank", "53vXL_2RCGy-01903-00383568-00383823": "herbert presents the idea of prescience", "53vXL_2RCGy-01904-00383824-00384095": "as an almost accidental side effect of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01905-00384096-00384287": "the creation of a superhuman", "53vXL_2RCGy-01906-00384288-00384471": "who is supposed to be able to see into", "53vXL_2RCGy-01907-00384472-00384639": "the collective unconscious", "53vXL_2RCGy-01908-00384640-00384991": "of the male genetic line's race memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01909-00384992-00385215": "those atreides males that possess this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01910-00385216-00385375": "ability in the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-01911-00385376-00385615": "also have the gift of prescience with", "53vXL_2RCGy-01912-00385616-00385719": "leto ii", "53vXL_2RCGy-01913-00385720-00386039": "almost having complete prescience", "53vXL_2RCGy-01914-00386040-00386263": "the nature of their controlled evolution", "53vXL_2RCGy-01915-00386264-00386463": "through artificial selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-01916-00386464-00386639": "almost suggests that it is with the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01917-00386640-00386782": "quizadz sadarak", "53vXL_2RCGy-01918-00386783-00387015": "that humanity has reached almost a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01919-00387016-00387278": "telhardian omega point", "53vXL_2RCGy-01920-00387279-00387471": "this is not actually the case as we", "53vXL_2RCGy-01921-00387472-00387687": "discover in heretics of june", "53vXL_2RCGy-01922-00387688-00387910": "when the character of miles tag and", "53vXL_2RCGy-01923-00387911-00388110": "atreides descendant and product of a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01924-00388111-00388367": "renewed bani jesuit breeding program", "53vXL_2RCGy-01925-00388368-00388551": "evolves the nature of the quizad", "53vXL_2RCGy-01926-00388552-00388719": "saddarach even further", "53vXL_2RCGy-01927-00388720-00388999": "when undergoing torture it is in fact", "53vXL_2RCGy-01928-00389000-00389119": "because of the apparent", "53vXL_2RCGy-01929-00389120-00389391": "apex of human evolution which creates", "53vXL_2RCGy-01930-00389392-00389639": "the tyrant god emperor leader ii", "53vXL_2RCGy-01931-00389640-00389823": "that factions within the worlds of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01932-00389824-00390063": "imperium begin to advance forbidden", "53vXL_2RCGy-01933-00390064-00390206": "technologies", "53vXL_2RCGy-01934-00390207-00390415": "this in turn creates machines that are", "53vXL_2RCGy-01935-00390416-00390623": "capable of hiding from someone so", "53vXL_2RCGy-01936-00390624-00390695": "powerful", "53vXL_2RCGy-01937-00390696-00390934": "they can see every action anyone is", "53vXL_2RCGy-01938-00390935-00391239": "going to take before it occurs to them", "53vXL_2RCGy-01939-00391240-00391502": "the end point of evolution regardless of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01940-00391503-00391767": "what path it takes in human development", "53vXL_2RCGy-01941-00391768-00391958": "is surely to ultimately create the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01942-00391959-00392167": "equivalent of a living god", "53vXL_2RCGy-01943-00392168-00392415": "like the race of prescient men in erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-01944-00392416-00392606": "who die out with the sheer misery that", "53vXL_2RCGy-01945-00392607-00392791": "their foreknowledge brings them", "53vXL_2RCGy-01946-00392792-00393191": "both paul and leto ii learn very swiftly", "53vXL_2RCGy-01947-00393192-00393406": "that complete prescience is indeed a", "53vXL_2RCGy-01948-00393407-00393495": "curse", "53vXL_2RCGy-01949-00393496-00393799": "if not an evolutionary dead end leaving", "53vXL_2RCGy-01950-00393800-00393927": "them virtually no", "53vXL_2RCGy-01951-00393928-00394271": "joy or surprise in life the desire to", "53vXL_2RCGy-01952-00394272-00394351": "escape this", "53vXL_2RCGy-01953-00394352-00394591": "and become a normal man is the major", "53vXL_2RCGy-01954-00394592-00394751": "motivating force behind", "53vXL_2RCGy-01955-00394752-00395054": "paul's abandonment of the golden path", "53vXL_2RCGy-01956-00395055-00395302": "the revelation of a tilaksu quizad", "53vXL_2RCGy-01957-00395303-00395391": "sadarank by", "53vXL_2RCGy-01958-00395392-00395702": "skytale in june messiah is notably", "53vXL_2RCGy-01959-00395703-00395902": "reminiscent of the pressian beings from", "53vXL_2RCGy-01960-00395903-00396215": "butler's pre-eramonian race of men", "53vXL_2RCGy-01961-00396216-00396367": "in discussion with his fellow", "53vXL_2RCGy-01962-00396368-00396630": "conspirators the princess ireland", "53vXL_2RCGy-01963-00396631-00396927": "asks the face dancer how the bene chilax", "53vXL_2RCGy-01964-00396928-00397223": "overcame their quizad sadarak", "53vXL_2RCGy-01965-00397224-00397406": "a creature who has spent his life", "53vXL_2RCGy-01966-00397407-00397630": "creating one particular representation", "53vXL_2RCGy-01967-00397631-00397751": "of his selfdom", "53vXL_2RCGy-01968-00397752-00397910": "will die rather than become the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01969-00397911-00398143": "antithesis of that representation", "53vXL_2RCGy-01970-00398144-00398471": "skytale said i do not understand", "53vXL_2RCGy-01971-00398472-00398751": "edrick ventured he killed himself the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01972-00398752-00398967": "reverend mother growled", "53vXL_2RCGy-01973-00398968-00399191": "the quiz out sadarack has a dominating", "53vXL_2RCGy-01974-00399192-00399423": "control over time and space", "53vXL_2RCGy-01975-00399424-00399606": "and we note one of the appellations", "53vXL_2RCGy-01976-00399607-00399806": "applied to this term refers to someone", "53vXL_2RCGy-01977-00399807-00399910": "who can be", "53vXL_2RCGy-01978-00399911-00400175": "in many places at once the use of", "53vXL_2RCGy-01979-00400176-00400327": "prescience by both paul", "53vXL_2RCGy-01980-00400328-00400615": "and later leader ii in combination with", "53vXL_2RCGy-01981-00400616-00400710": "other memory", "53vXL_2RCGy-01982-00400711-00400902": "gives them a sense of the possibilities", "53vXL_2RCGy-01983-00400903-00401151": "and probabilities of future history", "53vXL_2RCGy-01984-00401152-00401319": "together with an all-encompassing", "53vXL_2RCGy-01985-00401320-00401519": "knowledge of the past", "53vXL_2RCGy-01986-00401520-00401695": "this has led some to comment that the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01987-00401696-00401854": "character of paula tritis and his", "53vXL_2RCGy-01988-00401855-00402015": "messianic prescience", "53vXL_2RCGy-01989-00402016-00402230": "is a response to the character of harry", "53vXL_2RCGy-01990-00402231-00402495": "selden and his psycho history in isaac", "53vXL_2RCGy-01991-00402496-00402823": "asimov's original foundation trilogy", "53vXL_2RCGy-01992-00402824-00403127": "in that sense lido ii may also be viewed", "53vXL_2RCGy-01993-00403128-00403319": "as a response to the character of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-01994-00403320-00403567": "mule from foundation and empire", "53vXL_2RCGy-01995-00403568-00403854": "and second foundation in donald e", "53vXL_2RCGy-01996-00403855-00404054": "palumbo's discussion of chaos theory in", "53vXL_2RCGy-01997-00404055-00404167": "the june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-01998-00404168-00404391": "he notes that james gunn suggests", "53vXL_2RCGy-01999-00404392-00404567": "herbert's june is a critique of the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02000-00404568-00404710": "foundation trilogy", "53vXL_2RCGy-02001-00404711-00404934": "and subsequently prelude to foundation", "53vXL_2RCGy-02002-00404935-00405110": "as a response to june", "53vXL_2RCGy-02003-00405111-00405287": "though this is from the perspective of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02004-00405288-00405527": "an ecological and political viewpoint", "53vXL_2RCGy-02005-00405528-00405734": "which i shall discuss further in chapter", "53vXL_2RCGy-02006-00405735-00405910": "four", "53vXL_2RCGy-02007-00405911-00406102": "herbert did not acknowledge any direct", "53vXL_2RCGy-02008-00406103-00406399": "response to azamos foundation trilogy", "53vXL_2RCGy-02009-00406400-00406543": "although there are a number of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02010-00406544-00406799": "interesting parallels and dichotomies", "53vXL_2RCGy-02011-00406800-00407071": "asimov's foundation trilogy owes many of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02012-00407072-00407278": "its attributes to edward gibbons", "53vXL_2RCGy-02013-00407279-00407471": "the history and the decline and fall of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02014-00407472-00407623": "the roman empire as", "53vXL_2RCGy-02015-00407624-00407887": "similarly does herbert's june though it", "53vXL_2RCGy-02016-00407888-00407967": "can also", "53vXL_2RCGy-02017-00407968-00408215": "seem to be influenced greatly by t.e", "53vXL_2RCGy-02018-00408216-00408447": "lawrence's seven pillars of wisdom", "53vXL_2RCGy-02019-00408448-00408782": "as well as butler's erwan both series", "53vXL_2RCGy-02020-00408783-00408999": "feature a number of similarities from", "53vXL_2RCGy-02021-00409000-00409199": "their huge expanse of empires", "53vXL_2RCGy-02022-00409200-00409391": "the use of introductory historical", "53vXL_2RCGy-02023-00409392-00409607": "documents and characters who work to", "53vXL_2RCGy-02024-00409608-00409839": "alter the future of mankind", "53vXL_2RCGy-02025-00409839-00410078": "in the foundation trilogy the use of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02026-00410079-00410303": "psycho history by its inventor harry", "53vXL_2RCGy-02027-00410304-00410366": "selden", "53vXL_2RCGy-02028-00410367-00410639": "and his fellow scientists is put into", "53vXL_2RCGy-02029-00410639-00410751": "place to preserve", "53vXL_2RCGy-02030-00410752-00411030": "humanity and its knowledge as its vast", "53vXL_2RCGy-02031-00411031-00411182": "interstellar empire", "53vXL_2RCGy-02032-00411183-00411510": "goes into a predicted long decline", "53vXL_2RCGy-02033-00411512-00411734": "psycho history then is a combination of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02034-00411735-00411855": "statistics", "53vXL_2RCGy-02035-00411856-00412174": "mathematics and historical observations", "53vXL_2RCGy-02036-00412175-00412399": "used to make almost completely accurate", "53vXL_2RCGy-02037-00412400-00412599": "future predictions", "53vXL_2RCGy-02038-00412600-00412863": "in foundation asimov describes psycho", "53vXL_2RCGy-02039-00412864-00412943": "history as", "53vXL_2RCGy-02040-00412943-00413151": "that branch of mathematics which deals", "53vXL_2RCGy-02041-00413152-00413287": "with the reactions of human", "53vXL_2RCGy-02042-00413288-00413391": "conglomerates", "53vXL_2RCGy-02043-00413392-00413743": "to fixed social and economic stimuli", "53vXL_2RCGy-02044-00413743-00413966": "within this definition there are two", "53vXL_2RCGy-02045-00413967-00414166": "provisions applied in order for psycho", "53vXL_2RCGy-02046-00414167-00414303": "history to work", "53vXL_2RCGy-02047-00414304-00414543": "namely that the human conglomerate being", "53vXL_2RCGy-02048-00414543-00414607": "dealt with", "53vXL_2RCGy-02049-00414608-00414830": "is sufficiently large for valid", "53vXL_2RCGy-02050-00414831-00414991": "statistical treatment", "53vXL_2RCGy-02051-00414992-00415166": "and that the human conglomerate be", "53vXL_2RCGy-02052-00415167-00415374": "itself unaware of psycho-history", "53vXL_2RCGy-02053-00415375-00415447": "analysis", "53vXL_2RCGy-02054-00415447-00415647": "in order that its reaction be truly", "53vXL_2RCGy-02055-00415647-00415799": "random", "53vXL_2RCGy-02056-00415800-00416022": "herbert's paula treaty seeks to prevent", "53vXL_2RCGy-02057-00416023-00416214": "a cataclysmic event through the use of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02058-00416215-00416326": "his prescience", "53vXL_2RCGy-02059-00416327-00416503": "which offers up a number of future", "53vXL_2RCGy-02060-00416504-00416630": "possibilities", "53vXL_2RCGy-02061-00416631-00416791": "many of which culminate in the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02062-00416792-00417022": "destruction of humanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-02063-00417023-00417255": "it is only through one particular route", "53vXL_2RCGy-02064-00417256-00417447": "into the future provided for", "53vXL_2RCGy-02065-00417447-00417782": "by his prescience called the golden path", "53vXL_2RCGy-02066-00417783-00418055": "that mankind is able to survive this", "53vXL_2RCGy-02067-00418056-00418247": "universal apocalypse", "53vXL_2RCGy-02068-00418247-00418478": "from paul's point of view this is a hard", "53vXL_2RCGy-02069-00418479-00418574": "thing indeed", "53vXL_2RCGy-02070-00418575-00418847": "for it is essentially a root that means", "53vXL_2RCGy-02071-00418847-00419022": "crushing much of humanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-02072-00419023-00419214": "to ensure that those who emerge from the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02073-00419215-00419399": "tyranny of the attritis empire", "53vXL_2RCGy-02074-00419400-00419710": "are strong enough to survive", "53vXL_2RCGy-02075-00419712-00419966": "this forms the basis of an imposed order", "53vXL_2RCGy-02076-00419967-00420110": "of natural selection", "53vXL_2RCGy-02077-00420112-00420383": "that goes beyond social darwinism and as", "53vXL_2RCGy-02078-00420384-00420447": "such", "53vXL_2RCGy-02079-00420447-00420639": "paul is unable to bring himself to", "53vXL_2RCGy-02080-00420639-00420783": "complete the task", "53vXL_2RCGy-02081-00420784-00421087": "abandoning the golden path it is only", "53vXL_2RCGy-02082-00421088-00421231": "through leto ii", "53vXL_2RCGy-02083-00421232-00421455": "who abandons much of his humanity to", "53vXL_2RCGy-02084-00421456-00421599": "become the god emperor", "53vXL_2RCGy-02085-00421600-00421887": "that the golden path is taken up again", "53vXL_2RCGy-02086-00421888-00422031": "as palumbo notes", "53vXL_2RCGy-02087-00422032-00422287": "asimov's meta series champions a chaos", "53vXL_2RCGy-02088-00422288-00422439": "to order perspective", "53vXL_2RCGy-02089-00422439-00422607": "in its desire to bring about the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02090-00422608-00422775": "re-emergence of empire", "53vXL_2RCGy-02091-00422776-00423110": "after a period of stagnation and rot", "53vXL_2RCGy-02092-00423112-00423359": "frank herbert's june series champions an", "53vXL_2RCGy-02093-00423360-00423551": "order to chaos perspective", "53vXL_2RCGy-02094-00423552-00423710": "in that the atreides following the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02095-00423712-00423879": "golden path must", "53vXL_2RCGy-02096-00423880-00424151": "destabilize and scatter their own empire", "53vXL_2RCGy-02097-00424152-00424366": "in order for humanity to survive the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02098-00424367-00424543": "apocalyptic scenario", "53vXL_2RCGy-02099-00424543-00424887": "their prescience predicts palumbo's", "53vXL_2RCGy-02100-00424888-00425014": "insightful work", "53vXL_2RCGy-02101-00425015-00425270": "establishes the use of reoccurring chaos", "53vXL_2RCGy-02102-00425271-00425383": "theory motifs", "53vXL_2RCGy-02103-00425384-00425566": "throughout the june series as an", "53vXL_2RCGy-02104-00425567-00425735": "accompaniment to the development of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02105-00425735-00425918": "herbert's theme of ecology", "53vXL_2RCGy-02106-00425919-00426207": "in that dynamic systems produce feedback", "53vXL_2RCGy-02107-00426208-00426375": "loops that either maintain the status", "53vXL_2RCGy-02108-00426376-00426447": "quo", "53vXL_2RCGy-02109-00426447-00426647": "or destabilize and change the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02110-00426647-00426887": "pre-existing systems", "53vXL_2RCGy-02111-00426888-00427087": "the reversal of these feedbacks is seen", "53vXL_2RCGy-02112-00427088-00427263": "by palumbo inherently", "53vXL_2RCGy-02113-00427264-00427591": "in the fact that paul and lito ii embody", "53vXL_2RCGy-02114-00427592-00427870": "positive or destabilizing feedback", "53vXL_2RCGy-02115-00427871-00428047": "comparing paul to the mule", "53vXL_2RCGy-02116-00428047-00428318": "he notes the following like the mule", "53vXL_2RCGy-02117-00428319-00428479": "paul is a mutation who", "53vXL_2RCGy-02118-00428480-00428751": "shifted the old balance and amplified", "53vXL_2RCGy-02119-00428752-00428855": "disorder", "53vXL_2RCGy-02120-00428856-00429191": "and so is lato ii who paul calls", "53vXL_2RCGy-02121-00429192-00429383": "the ultimate feedback on which our", "53vXL_2RCGy-02122-00429384-00429527": "species depends", "53vXL_2RCGy-02123-00429528-00429814": "and who enforces a rigid order expressly", "53vXL_2RCGy-02124-00429815-00429887": "to provoke", "53vXL_2RCGy-02125-00429888-00430214": "chaos it is through this observation", "53vXL_2RCGy-02126-00430215-00430399": "that we have the dichotomies presented", "53vXL_2RCGy-02127-00430400-00430614": "between the two characters", "53vXL_2RCGy-02128-00430615-00430927": "both mutants paul and leto ii are our", "53vXL_2RCGy-02129-00430928-00431070": "dangerous heroes", "53vXL_2RCGy-02130-00431071-00431343": "seeking to bring chaos out of order so", "53vXL_2RCGy-02131-00431343-00431647": "that in turn they can save humanity", "53vXL_2RCGy-02132-00431647-00431918": "they will be hated and despised for it", "53vXL_2RCGy-02133-00431919-00431975": "but their", "53vXL_2RCGy-02134-00431976-00432214": "intentions and motivations ultimately", "53vXL_2RCGy-02135-00432215-00432318": "difficult", "53vXL_2RCGy-02136-00432319-00432518": "are inevitably viewed by the reader with", "53vXL_2RCGy-02137-00432519-00432687": "the benefit of hindsight", "53vXL_2RCGy-02138-00432688-00433055": "as praiseworthy this is ultimately a", "53vXL_2RCGy-02139-00433056-00433310": "paradoxical viewpoint of these heroes", "53vXL_2RCGy-02140-00433312-00433487": "when we consider frank herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-02141-00433488-00433718": "attitude that such men are destructive", "53vXL_2RCGy-02142-00433719-00433879": "to society", "53vXL_2RCGy-02143-00433880-00434087": "the mule however is a villain who rules", "53vXL_2RCGy-02144-00434088-00434255": "by the aid of his mutation", "53vXL_2RCGy-02145-00434256-00434543": "an ability to mentally coerce anyone and", "53vXL_2RCGy-02146-00434543-00434775": "brings chaos to the desired effect of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02147-00434776-00434855": "order", "53vXL_2RCGy-02148-00434856-00435039": "the goal of the prediction of psycho", "53vXL_2RCGy-02149-00435039-00435366": "history and harry selden's foundation", "53vXL_2RCGy-02150-00435367-00435566": "differences aside from these two great", "53vXL_2RCGy-02151-00435567-00435751": "science fiction masterpieces", "53vXL_2RCGy-02152-00435752-00435943": "it is with interest that inherently", "53vXL_2RCGy-02153-00435943-00436118": "within their similarities", "53vXL_2RCGy-02154-00436119-00436327": "the association with chaos theory is a", "53vXL_2RCGy-02155-00436328-00436535": "fundamental part of the nature of human", "53vXL_2RCGy-02156-00436535-00436614": "systems", "53vXL_2RCGy-02157-00436615-00436903": "whether they be historical political or", "53vXL_2RCGy-02158-00436904-00437014": "ecological", "53vXL_2RCGy-02159-00437015-00437318": "is what sets them apart frank herbert's", "53vXL_2RCGy-02160-00437319-00437407": "june series", "53vXL_2RCGy-02161-00437408-00437647": "is seen as importantly anticipating the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02162-00437647-00437831": "development of chaos theory", "53vXL_2RCGy-02163-00437832-00438039": "especially in relation to ecological", "53vXL_2RCGy-02164-00438039-00438159": "science", "53vXL_2RCGy-02165-00438160-00438351": "donald e palumbo looks at various", "53vXL_2RCGy-02166-00438352-00438591": "aspects of chaos motifs in the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-02167-00438592-00438655": "series", "53vXL_2RCGy-02168-00438656-00438927": "and the foundation series but especially", "53vXL_2RCGy-02169-00438928-00438975": "so", "53vXL_2RCGy-02170-00438976-00439214": "when examining june's themes of ecology", "53vXL_2RCGy-02171-00439215-00439366": "and the destructive hero", "53vXL_2RCGy-02172-00439367-00439566": "that incorporates joseph campbell's", "53vXL_2RCGy-02173-00439567-00439727": "monomyth", "53vXL_2RCGy-02174-00439728-00440007": "as mutations and the end results of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02175-00440008-00440222": "millennial long breeding programs", "53vXL_2RCGy-02176-00440223-00440470": "the characters of paul and lito ii can", "53vXL_2RCGy-02177-00440471-00440670": "also be seen as feedback loops", "53vXL_2RCGy-02178-00440671-00440870": "when viewed as part of evolution as a", "53vXL_2RCGy-02179-00440871-00441039": "dynamic system", "53vXL_2RCGy-02180-00441039-00441214": "hence the prescient mutations of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02181-00441215-00441351": "herbert's universe", "53vXL_2RCGy-02182-00441352-00441543": "deal with the chaos of balancing the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02183-00441543-00441718": "golden path", "53vXL_2RCGy-02184-00441719-00441918": "additionally herbert according to", "53vXL_2RCGy-02185-00441919-00442118": "palumbo complements this with", "53vXL_2RCGy-02186-00442119-00442318": "interlacing the architecture of the june", "53vXL_2RCGy-02187-00442319-00442422": "series itself", "53vXL_2RCGy-02188-00442423-00442639": "with recurring fractal patterns", "53vXL_2RCGy-02189-00442639-00442895": "something he also sees as part of joseph", "53vXL_2RCGy-02190-00442896-00443095": "campbell's monomyth", "53vXL_2RCGy-02191-00443096-00443255": "in dealing with the chaos that the", "53vXL_2RCGy-02192-00443256-00443455": "evolutionary advanced ability of", "53vXL_2RCGy-02193-00443456-00443670": "prescience creates in the hands of paul", "53vXL_2RCGy-02194-00443671-00443807": "and leader ii", "53vXL_2RCGy-02195-00443808-00444022": "herbert has taken another idea from", "53vXL_2RCGy-02196-00444023-00444166": "butler's erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-02197-00444167-00444414": "and developed it with great skill", "53vXL_2RCGy-02198-00444415-00444479": "herbert", "53vXL_2RCGy-02199-00444480-00444670": "in showing us two characters who are", "53vXL_2RCGy-02200-00444671-00444807": "able to deal with the curse that", "53vXL_2RCGy-02201-00444808-00444959": "prescience brings", "53vXL_2RCGy-02202-00444960-00445095": "together with its terrible", "53vXL_2RCGy-02203-00445096-00445335": "responsibility and stagnation", "53vXL_2RCGy-02204-00445335-00445503": "shows us an example of what is", "53vXL_2RCGy-02205-00445504-00445687": "fundamental to science fiction", "53vXL_2RCGy-02206-00445688-00445791": "literature", "53vXL_2RCGy-02207-00445792-00446095": "the what if and does so by extrapolating", "53vXL_2RCGy-02208-00446096-00446351": "this brief segment in butler's erawan", "53vXL_2RCGy-02209-00446352-00446614": "about the first race that inhabited his", "53vXL_2RCGy-02210-00446615-00452895": "topsy-turvy world", "53vXL_2RCGy-02211-00452896-00453104": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "53Jh62_As3A", "text": {"53Jh62_As3A-00000-00000021-00000211": "we are here today to announce the", "53Jh62_As3A-00001-00000212-00000371": "results of the investigation into", "53Jh62_As3A-00002-00000372-00000491": "whether the Portland Police Bureau", "53Jh62_As3A-00003-00000492-00000740": "engages in a pattern and practice of", "53Jh62_As3A-00004-00000741-00001043": "excessive force that violates the", "53Jh62_As3A-00005-00001044-00001277": "Constitution of the United States the", "53Jh62_As3A-00006-00001278-00001556": "investigation began in June of 2011 and", "53Jh62_As3A-00007-00001557-00001772": "was jointly conducted by my office and", "53Jh62_As3A-00008-00001773-00001922": "the Civil Rights Division of the", "53Jh62_As3A-00009-00001923-00002222": "Department of Justice what we have found", "53Jh62_As3A-00010-00002223-00002467": "is that the Portland Police Bureau does", "53Jh62_As3A-00011-00002468-00002718": "in fact engage in a pattern and practice", "53Jh62_As3A-00012-00002719-00002974": "of an excessive use of force", "53Jh62_As3A-00013-00002975-00003211": "specifically in its dealings with people", "53Jh62_As3A-00014-00003213-00003454": "who suffer from mental illness or people", "53Jh62_As3A-00015-00003455-00003638": "who are experiencing a mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00016-00003639-00003893": "crisis and that this pattern or practice", "53Jh62_As3A-00017-00003894-00004094": "does violate the Constitution of the", "53Jh62_As3A-00018-00004095-00004661": "United States this has been tough I have", "53Jh62_As3A-00019-00004662-00004888": "the utmost respect for the men and the", "53Jh62_As3A-00020-00004889-00005111": "women in the Portland Police Bureau who", "53Jh62_As3A-00021-00005112-00005270": "put their lives on the line in the name", "53Jh62_As3A-00022-00005271-00005540": "of Public Safety every day these", "53Jh62_As3A-00023-00005541-00005750": "findings don't change the fact that this", "53Jh62_As3A-00024-00005751-00005984": "is one of the finest investigative", "53Jh62_As3A-00025-00005985-00006302": "police agencies in the nation as the", "53Jh62_As3A-00026-00006303-00006464": "United States Attorney for the District", "53Jh62_As3A-00027-00006465-00006703": "of Oregon I am proud to work with the", "53Jh62_As3A-00028-00006704-00006833": "men and women of the Portland Police", "53Jh62_As3A-00029-00006834-00007076": "Bureau and to have their partnership on", "53Jh62_As3A-00030-00007077-00007360": "so many important complex cases that are", "53Jh62_As3A-00031-00007361-00007510": "handled in the United States Attorney's", "53Jh62_As3A-00032-00007511-00007814": "Office from gangs and drugs to terrorism", "53Jh62_As3A-00033-00007815-00007992": "and national security", "53Jh62_As3A-00034-00007993-00008264": "these are grave and serious findings and", "53Jh62_As3A-00035-00008265-00008435": "they must be understood within some", "53Jh62_As3A-00036-00008436-00008792": "broader context first the vast majority", "53Jh62_As3A-00037-00008793-00009010": "of the uses of force that the Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00038-00009011-00009305": "Police Bureau in agent are appropriate", "53Jh62_As3A-00039-00009306-00009658": "and within constitutional limits second", "53Jh62_As3A-00040-00009659-00009956": "these findings come in the context of", "53Jh62_As3A-00041-00009957-00010202": "another investigation that was opened in", "53Jh62_As3A-00042-00010203-00010520": "the fall of 2010 which examined Oregon's", "53Jh62_As3A-00043-00010521-00010738": "failure to deliver adequate services to", "53Jh62_As3A-00044-00010739-00011021": "people suffering from mental illness we", "53Jh62_As3A-00045-00011022-00011237": "identified large gaps in the state", "53Jh62_As3A-00046-00011238-00011521": "whole system including people who are in", "53Jh62_As3A-00047-00011522-00011780": "crisis those gaps are currently being", "53Jh62_As3A-00048-00011781-00011948": "addressed through provisions put in", "53Jh62_As3A-00049-00011949-00012149": "place as part of Governor Phips offers", "53Jh62_As3A-00050-00012150-00012460": "healthcare transformation and we are", "53Jh62_As3A-00051-00012461-00012662": "continuing to monitor compliance with", "53Jh62_As3A-00052-00012663-00012824": "greed upon metrics as that", "53Jh62_As3A-00053-00012825-00013147": "transformation is rolled out at the same", "53Jh62_As3A-00054-00013148-00013372": "time the findings against the Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00055-00013373-00013604": "Police Bureau lay the framework for us", "53Jh62_As3A-00056-00013605-00013819": "to make meaningful changes that will not", "53Jh62_As3A-00057-00013820-00014012": "only make us safer but will empower", "53Jh62_As3A-00058-00014013-00014279": "Portland's police officers to be more", "53Jh62_As3A-00059-00014280-00014510": "effective as trusted public servants in", "53Jh62_As3A-00060-00014511-00014830": "fact this week when we examined when we", "53Jh62_As3A-00061-00014831-00015002": "explained the findings to the chief and", "53Jh62_As3A-00062-00015003-00015266": "the mayor they immediately asked where", "53Jh62_As3A-00063-00015266-00015572": "do we go from here I think to some", "53Jh62_As3A-00064-00015572-00015749": "extent that people from DC were a little", "53Jh62_As3A-00065-00015750-00016007": "surprised but I wasn't because that is", "53Jh62_As3A-00066-00016008-00016303": "how we roll in Portland I want to thank", "53Jh62_As3A-00067-00016304-00016490": "Tom Perez for understanding that", "53Jh62_As3A-00068-00016491-00016697": "different communities call for different", "53Jh62_As3A-00069-00016698-00016978": "approaches for empowering us and his", "53Jh62_As3A-00070-00016979-00017253": "team to create some preliminary", "53Jh62_As3A-00071-00017254-00017450": "agreements that are going to inform the", "53Jh62_As3A-00072-00017451-00017734": "process moving forward at one point when", "53Jh62_As3A-00073-00017735-00017947": "I was talking to Tom on the phone after", "53Jh62_As3A-00074-00017948-00018113": "meetings with the chief of the mayor and", "53Jh62_As3A-00075-00018114-00018308": "I said I really think we can make some", "53Jh62_As3A-00076-00018309-00018503": "meaningful progress towards what it", "53Jh62_As3A-00077-00018504-00018674": "might look like in the future for it to", "53Jh62_As3A-00078-00018675-00018925": "implement some reforms he thought for a", "53Jh62_As3A-00079-00018926-00019118": "minute he said yes sometimes you've got", "53Jh62_As3A-00080-00019119-00019330": "a call inaudible and I told him in", "53Jh62_As3A-00081-00019331-00019490": "Oregon we're all about the no-huddle", "53Jh62_As3A-00082-00019491-00019865": "offense and I know that the chief and", "53Jh62_As3A-00083-00019866-00020087": "the mayor and the city attorney my", "53Jh62_As3A-00084-00020088-00020244": "office and the team from civil rights", "53Jh62_As3A-00085-00020245-00020530": "along with the community and the people", "53Jh62_As3A-00086-00020531-00020693": "of the city of Portland are going to", "53Jh62_As3A-00087-00020694-00020837": "continue to move that ball down the", "53Jh62_As3A-00088-00020838-00021094": "field as we look for a better way to do", "53Jh62_As3A-00089-00021095-00021137": "things", "53Jh62_As3A-00090-00021138-00021357": "the Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00091-00021358-00021558": "we all agree with the fundamental", "53Jh62_As3A-00092-00021559-00021759": "principle that all citizens and", "53Jh62_As3A-00093-00021760-00022026": "especially our most vulnerable must be", "53Jh62_As3A-00094-00022027-00022164": "able to trust the police to protect", "53Jh62_As3A-00095-00022165-00022449": "their civil rights in the coming days", "53Jh62_As3A-00096-00022450-00022635": "and weeks I'll be meeting with community", "53Jh62_As3A-00097-00022636-00022809": "groups along with people from the team", "53Jh62_As3A-00098-00022810-00022907": "from the Civil Rights Division", "53Jh62_As3A-00099-00022908-00023106": "throughout Portland to hear your", "53Jh62_As3A-00100-00023107-00023346": "concerns and your ideas about what you", "53Jh62_As3A-00101-00023347-00023547": "think we need to have as part of the", "53Jh62_As3A-00102-00023548-00023762": "solution moving forward", "53Jh62_As3A-00103-00023763-00024024": "we have great momentum on which to build", "53Jh62_As3A-00104-00024025-00024276": "and there's no city in America with a", "53Jh62_As3A-00105-00024277-00024450": "better track record for working together", "53Jh62_As3A-00106-00024451-00024693": "to find real solutions to problems such", "53Jh62_As3A-00107-00024694-00025056": "as these finally I want to say that I", "53Jh62_As3A-00108-00025057-00025221": "acknowledge that police officers have", "53Jh62_As3A-00109-00025222-00025407": "one of the most difficult jobs in the", "53Jh62_As3A-00110-00025408-00025632": "world they're sworn to serve and protect", "53Jh62_As3A-00111-00025633-00025820": "and to uphold the Constitution that", "53Jh62_As3A-00112-00025822-00026031": "welcomes a requirement in the United", "53Jh62_As3A-00113-00026032-00026292": "States these findings highlight our", "53Jh62_As3A-00114-00026293-00026472": "there have been a breakdown in that", "53Jh62_As3A-00115-00026473-00026772": "solemn battle but more importantly they", "53Jh62_As3A-00116-00026773-00027030": "signal an opportunity a chance to work", "53Jh62_As3A-00117-00027031-00027174": "together to lead the way and", "53Jh62_As3A-00118-00027175-00027474": "implementing reforms that will ensure", "53Jh62_As3A-00119-00027475-00027627": "that our most vulnerable citizens are", "53Jh62_As3A-00120-00027627-00027861": "protected and served I'm confident that", "53Jh62_As3A-00121-00027862-00028131": "we will be successful and the man who is", "53Jh62_As3A-00122-00028132-00028380": "the main reason for my optimism that we", "53Jh62_As3A-00123-00028381-00028595": "could is that its chief reads because we", "53Jh62_As3A-00124-00028597-00028767": "couldn't have a more committed partner", "53Jh62_As3A-00125-00028768-00029037": "and a more committed change agent in the", "53Jh62_As3A-00126-00029038-00029256": "state of Oregon to carry out these", "53Jh62_As3A-00127-00029257-00029495": "reforms which I believe will be a model", "53Jh62_As3A-00128-00029497-00029929": "for the rest of the nation", "53Jh62_As3A-00129-00029930-00030227": "thank you very much good morning my name", "53Jh62_As3A-00130-00030227-00030410": "is Tom Perez I in assistant trained", "53Jh62_As3A-00131-00030411-00030593": "channel for civil rights the US", "53Jh62_As3A-00132-00030594-00030914": "Department of Justice it is an honor to", "53Jh62_As3A-00133-00030914-00031132": "be back here in Portland and to join", "53Jh62_As3A-00134-00031133-00031418": "mayor Adams chief priests and my", "53Jh62_As3A-00135-00031419-00031592": "colleague the United States attorney", "53Jh62_As3A-00136-00031593-00031835": "Amanda Marshall to report on the results", "53Jh62_As3A-00137-00031836-00032014": "of our investigation that the Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00138-00032016-00032330": "Police Bureau and to discuss the road", "53Jh62_As3A-00139-00032331-00032549": "ahead civil rights enforcement of the", "53Jh62_As3A-00140-00032550-00032708": "federal level is always a joint venture", "53Jh62_As3A-00141-00032708-00032996": "between the Department of Justice Civil", "53Jh62_As3A-00142-00032997-00033140": "Rights Division and the United States", "53Jh62_As3A-00143-00033141-00033386": "Attorneys offices across the country and", "53Jh62_As3A-00144-00033387-00033719": "I am very honored to have Amanda", "53Jh62_As3A-00145-00033720-00033914": "Marshall as a wonderful partner and the", "53Jh62_As3A-00146-00033915-00034175": "dedicated career staff in her office and", "53Jh62_As3A-00147-00034176-00034475": "I'm people blessed with the wonderful", "53Jh62_As3A-00148-00034476-00034613": "career staff here in the Civil Rights", "53Jh62_As3A-00149-00034614-00034880": "Division and I want to thank all of them", "53Jh62_As3A-00150-00034881-00035027": "for their hard work and I also want to", "53Jh62_As3A-00151-00035028-00035438": "thank chief Reese and mayor Adams for", "53Jh62_As3A-00152-00035439-00035690": "your remarkable collaboration and I'm", "53Jh62_As3A-00153-00035691-00035981": "very very pleased to announce that while", "53Jh62_As3A-00154-00035982-00036284": "we have indeed identified serious", "53Jh62_As3A-00155-00036285-00036518": "deficiencies in the use of force context", "53Jh62_As3A-00156-00036519-00036692": "we have also reached a preliminary", "53Jh62_As3A-00157-00036693-00036929": "agreement on the road forward a road", "53Jh62_As3A-00158-00036930-00037198": "forward that will improve the ability to", "53Jh62_As3A-00159-00037199-00037558": "protect public safety and to ensure that", "53Jh62_As3A-00160-00037559-00037928": "the Constitution is indeed respected and", "53Jh62_As3A-00161-00037929-00038171": "throughout as Amanda Marshall pointed", "53Jh62_As3A-00162-00038172-00038507": "out the mayor and the chief have been", "53Jh62_As3A-00163-00038508-00038681": "extremely cooperative when we announced", "53Jh62_As3A-00164-00038682-00038933": "our investigation chief priests observed", "53Jh62_As3A-00165-00038934-00039179": "that this is a quote unique opportunity", "53Jh62_As3A-00166-00039180-00039475": "to be at the forefront of best practices", "53Jh62_As3A-00167-00039476-00039785": "chief you correctly noted that Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00168-00039786-00040016": "is not the only city that is addressing", "53Jh62_As3A-00169-00040017-00040214": "the difficult issue of providing police", "53Jh62_As3A-00170-00040215-00040433": "services to people with mental illness", "53Jh62_As3A-00171-00040434-00040709": "mayor when we met and we announced this", "53Jh62_As3A-00172-00040710-00040928": "back in June of last year you noted that", "53Jh62_As3A-00173-00040929-00041129": "you were quote humble in the knowledge", "53Jh62_As3A-00174-00041130-00041381": "that we haven't figured it all out", "53Jh62_As3A-00175-00041382-00041726": "and I appreciate that spirit in which", "53Jh62_As3A-00176-00041727-00041794": "you approach", "53Jh62_As3A-00177-00041795-00041991": "investigation you both had a", "53Jh62_As3A-00178-00041992-00042235": "understandable and very well founded Fri", "53Jh62_As3A-00179-00042236-00042433": "the new department and you pledged your", "53Jh62_As3A-00180-00042434-00042781": "total cooperation they have delivered on", "53Jh62_As3A-00181-00042782-00042976": "that pledge and we're consistently", "53Jh62_As3A-00182-00042977-00043237": "responsive to our document requests and", "53Jh62_As3A-00183-00043238-00043474": "maintained an open door and an open file", "53Jh62_As3A-00184-00043475-00043672": "policies throughout our site visits and", "53Jh62_As3A-00185-00043673-00043864": "they've been very receptive to our", "53Jh62_As3A-00186-00043865-00044098": "feedback they have not waited for a", "53Jh62_As3A-00187-00044099-00044347": "report to implement perform the reform", "53Jh62_As3A-00188-00044348-00044656": "process has been ongoing I would also", "53Jh62_As3A-00189-00044657-00044866": "like to thank the frontline officers in", "53Jh62_As3A-00190-00044867-00045013": "the Portland Police Bureau for their", "53Jh62_As3A-00191-00045014-00045304": "cooperation and feedback our job is to", "53Jh62_As3A-00192-00045305-00045561": "make your job safer and more rewarding", "53Jh62_As3A-00193-00045562-00045829": "finally I'd like to thank the community", "53Jh62_As3A-00194-00045830-00045988": "we have spent a lot of time in the", "53Jh62_As3A-00195-00045989-00046213": "community we held a town-hall meeting we", "53Jh62_As3A-00196-00046214-00046441": "conducted dozens and dozens of", "53Jh62_As3A-00197-00046442-00046657": "interviews we listened and learn from so", "53Jh62_As3A-00198-00046658-00046882": "many community members your perspective", "53Jh62_As3A-00199-00046883-00047080": "was absolutely indispensable and", "53Jh62_As3A-00200-00047081-00047260": "continues to be critical and we will", "53Jh62_As3A-00201-00047261-00047554": "continue to seek your views as a result", "53Jh62_As3A-00202-00047555-00047761": "of the cooperation that we received", "53Jh62_As3A-00203-00047762-00047926": "throughout the investigation we made", "53Jh62_As3A-00204-00047927-00048247": "remarkable progress in record time as", "53Jh62_As3A-00205-00048248-00048400": "the United States attorney pointed out", "53Jh62_As3A-00206-00048401-00048586": "we have completed our review we have", "53Jh62_As3A-00207-00048587-00048823": "diagnosed the problem identified its", "53Jh62_As3A-00208-00048824-00049006": "root causes and reached a preliminary", "53Jh62_As3A-00209-00049007-00049306": "agreement with the city of Portland and", "53Jh62_As3A-00210-00049307-00049492": "the Portland Police Bureau which will", "53Jh62_As3A-00211-00049493-00049675": "remedy the problems and enhance both", "53Jh62_As3A-00212-00049676-00049951": "officer safety and public safety while", "53Jh62_As3A-00213-00049952-00050233": "allowing the Police Bureau to in your", "53Jh62_As3A-00214-00050234-00050491": "words chief priests be at the forefront", "53Jh62_As3A-00215-00050492-00050782": "of best practices as the United States", "53Jh62_As3A-00216-00050783-00050980": "attorney outline we've been at this for", "53Jh62_As3A-00217-00050981-00051274": "over a year and our focus has been on", "53Jh62_As3A-00218-00051275-00051478": "use of force issues with a particular", "53Jh62_As3A-00219-00051479-00051792": "focus on interactions with people with", "53Jh62_As3A-00220-00051794-00051952": "mental illness or in mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00221-00051953-00052261": "crisis our review was prompted by the", "53Jh62_As3A-00222-00052262-00052387": "high number of officer-involved", "53Jh62_As3A-00223-00052388-00052564": "shootings of people with mental illness", "53Jh62_As3A-00224-00052565-00052912": "the investigation was driven by a single", "53Jh62_As3A-00225-00052913-00053212": "goal to ensure that Portland is served", "53Jh62_As3A-00226-00053213-00053440": "by an effective accountable a Police", "53Jh62_As3A-00227-00053441-00053679": "Bureau that controls crime respects the", "53Jh62_As3A-00228-00053680-00053983": "Constitution and enjoys the trust of the", "53Jh62_As3A-00229-00053984-00054160": "public that it protects our", "53Jh62_As3A-00230-00054161-00054388": "investigation was exhaustive and it was", "53Jh62_As3A-00231-00054389-00054550": "conducted by Department attorneys", "53Jh62_As3A-00232-00054551-00054802": "investigators and subject matter expert", "53Jh62_As3A-00233-00054803-00055024": "including police practices expert", "53Jh62_As3A-00234-00055025-00055270": "including a psychiatrist who specializes", "53Jh62_As3A-00235-00055271-00055471": "in working with law enforcement agencies", "53Jh62_As3A-00236-00055472-00055672": "to develop models for effective", "53Jh62_As3A-00237-00055673-00055905": "interaction with people who have mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00238-00055907-00056110": "illness we conducted a thorough review", "53Jh62_As3A-00239-00056111-00056434": "of use of force by ppb officers which", "53Jh62_As3A-00240-00056435-00056674": "included reviewing thousands of pages of", "53Jh62_As3A-00241-00056675-00056872": "documents and conducting its extensive", "53Jh62_As3A-00242-00056873-00057034": "outreach to the community through", "53Jh62_As3A-00243-00057035-00057151": "hundreds of interviews that I have", "53Jh62_As3A-00244-00057152-00057394": "outlined we looked at a range of police", "53Jh62_As3A-00245-00057395-00057601": "interactions including encounters with", "53Jh62_As3A-00246-00057602-00057775": "people who have mental illness or are", "53Jh62_As3A-00247-00057776-00057994": "perceived to have mental illness and let", "53Jh62_As3A-00248-00057995-00058147": "me focus for a moment on the problem we", "53Jh62_As3A-00249-00058148-00058404": "identified based on our review we", "53Jh62_As3A-00250-00058405-00058696": "concluded that while most uses of force", "53Jh62_As3A-00251-00058697-00058912": "were lawful let me underscore while most", "53Jh62_As3A-00252-00058913-00059116": "uses of force were lawful there is", "53Jh62_As3A-00253-00059116-00059407": "reasonable cause to believe that ppb is", "53Jh62_As3A-00254-00059408-00059614": "engaged in a pattern or practice of", "53Jh62_As3A-00255-00059615-00059821": "using excessive force against people", "53Jh62_As3A-00256-00059822-00060066": "with mental illness or those perceived", "53Jh62_As3A-00257-00060067-00060322": "to have mental illness we found that", "53Jh62_As3A-00258-00060323-00060640": "encounters between ppb officers and", "53Jh62_As3A-00259-00060641-00060874": "persons living with mental illness too", "53Jh62_As3A-00260-00060875-00061186": "frequently result in the unnecessary use", "53Jh62_As3A-00261-00061187-00061459": "of force or in a higher level of force", "53Jh62_As3A-00262-00061460-00061723": "that was necessary we further found that", "53Jh62_As3A-00263-00061724-00061879": "when dealing with people who have mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00264-00061879-00062173": "illness ppb officers use electronic", "53Jh62_As3A-00265-00062174-00062404": "control weapons for Tasers in", "53Jh62_As3A-00266-00062404-00062587": "circumstances where the use of Tasers", "53Jh62_As3A-00267-00062588-00062880": "was not justified or they deploy them", "53Jh62_As3A-00268-00062882-00063091": "more times than is necessary", "53Jh62_As3A-00269-00063091-00063357": "finally in situations where ppb officers", "53Jh62_As3A-00270-00063358-00063579": "and arrest people with mental illness", "53Jh62_As3A-00271-00063580-00063829": "for low-level offenses we found that", "53Jh62_As3A-00272-00063829-00063982": "there is a pattern or practice of using", "53Jh62_As3A-00273-00063983-00064213": "more force than necessary in these", "53Jh62_As3A-00274-00064214-00064477": "circumstances it is important in the", "53Jh62_As3A-00275-00064478-00064684": "imperative I believe to reiterate the", "53Jh62_As3A-00276-00064685-00064861": "challenges we identified here in", "53Jh62_As3A-00277-00064862-00065074": "Portland are not unique to Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00278-00065075-00065338": "police work has transformed dramatically", "53Jh62_As3A-00279-00065339-00065605": "in recent years I remember vividly a", "53Jh62_As3A-00280-00065606-00065830": "portland police officer who described", "53Jh62_As3A-00281-00065831-00066184": "how years ago encounters with people who", "53Jh62_As3A-00282-00066185-00066409": "have mental illness were few and far", "53Jh62_As3A-00283-00066410-00066721": "between today that person pointed out it", "53Jh62_As3A-00284-00066722-00067000": "is a daily occurrence for most officers", "53Jh62_As3A-00285-00067001-00067288": "and often times it is occurring more", "53Jh62_As3A-00286-00067289-00067564": "than once per day communities across the", "53Jh62_As3A-00287-00067565-00067753": "country are wrestling with how to", "53Jh62_As3A-00288-00067754-00067837": "deliver", "53Jh62_As3A-00289-00067838-00068035": "effective police services and public", "53Jh62_As3A-00290-00068036-00068281": "safety services to people with mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00291-00068282-00068494": "illness we have seen and are working", "53Jh62_As3A-00292-00068495-00068728": "with these with other communities on", "53Jh62_As3A-00293-00068729-00068968": "these very issues and believe that the", "53Jh62_As3A-00294-00068969-00069151": "work we do here in Portland will serve", "53Jh62_As3A-00295-00069152-00069349": "as an important guideposts for", "53Jh62_As3A-00296-00069350-00069555": "communities facing similar challenges", "53Jh62_As3A-00297-00069556-00069793": "let me turn to root causes", "53Jh62_As3A-00298-00069794-00070123": "we conclude the deficiencies in policy", "53Jh62_As3A-00299-00070124-00070348": "training and supervision contribute to", "53Jh62_As3A-00300-00070349-00070537": "the problems that we identified these", "53Jh62_As3A-00301-00070538-00070786": "underlying deficiencies have existed for", "53Jh62_As3A-00302-00070787-00071035": "many years and to proceed the tenure of", "53Jh62_As3A-00303-00071036-00071257": "Mayor Adams and chief priests while they", "53Jh62_As3A-00304-00071258-00071473": "have not created the problem they own", "53Jh62_As3A-00305-00071474-00071617": "the problem and they have indeed", "53Jh62_As3A-00306-00071618-00071857": "accepted ownership of both the problem", "53Jh62_As3A-00307-00071858-00072070": "and the solutions that lie ahead", "53Jh62_As3A-00308-00072071-00072286": "and as US attorney marshal correctly", "53Jh62_As3A-00309-00072287-00072511": "pointed out they have wasted no time in", "53Jh62_As3A-00310-00072512-00072754": "beginning the process of improvement a", "53Jh62_As3A-00311-00072755-00072916": "number of critical improvements are", "53Jh62_As3A-00312-00072917-00073132": "already in place when we presented our", "53Jh62_As3A-00313-00073133-00073228": "findings to them", "53Jh62_As3A-00314-00073229-00073432": "we immediately pivoted to the", "53Jh62_As3A-00315-00073433-00073645": "brainstorming and problem solving phase", "53Jh62_As3A-00316-00073646-00074062": "and we are indeed able to announce that", "53Jh62_As3A-00317-00074063-00074254": "we have reached a preliminary agreement", "53Jh62_As3A-00318-00074255-00074488": "with the city and the ppb about the path", "53Jh62_As3A-00319-00074489-00074740": "forward we have developed a blueprint", "53Jh62_As3A-00320-00074741-00074938": "for sustainable reform that will enhance", "53Jh62_As3A-00321-00074939-00075178": "public and officer safety ensure", "53Jh62_As3A-00322-00075179-00075388": "constitutional policing and enhance", "53Jh62_As3A-00323-00075389-00075679": "public confidence in ppb the blueprint", "53Jh62_As3A-00324-00075680-00075883": "which we are in the process of", "53Jh62_As3A-00325-00075884-00076126": "memorializing into a binding court", "53Jh62_As3A-00326-00076127-00076420": "enforceable agreement will require ppb", "53Jh62_As3A-00327-00076421-00076684": "to do the following to develop", "53Jh62_As3A-00328-00076685-00076858": "state-of-the-art policies and protocols", "53Jh62_As3A-00329-00076859-00077047": "for interacting with people who have", "53Jh62_As3A-00330-00077048-00077227": "mental illness or are perceived to have", "53Jh62_As3A-00331-00077228-00077476": "mental illness to dramatically expand", "53Jh62_As3A-00332-00077477-00077725": "its capacity to serve provide services", "53Jh62_As3A-00333-00077726-00077911": "to people with mental illness by", "53Jh62_As3A-00334-00077912-00078105": "expanding its mobile crisis view", "53Jh62_As3A-00335-00078106-00078370": "establishing a mental health desk at the", "53Jh62_As3A-00336-00078371-00078649": "Bureau of emergency services so that 911", "53Jh62_As3A-00337-00078650-00078847": "calls are properly funneled to the", "53Jh62_As3A-00338-00078848-00079114": "appropriate response team and assist in", "53Jh62_As3A-00339-00079115-00079294": "leading efforts to increase community", "53Jh62_As3A-00340-00079295-00079507": "mental health treatment options such as", "53Jh62_As3A-00341-00079508-00079711": "24-hour walkins centers and other", "53Jh62_As3A-00342-00079712-00079945": "facilities that expand options for", "53Jh62_As3A-00343-00079946-00080167": "police officers seeking to assist a", "53Jh62_As3A-00344-00080168-00080244": "person", "53Jh62_As3A-00345-00080245-00080456": "who is experiencing a mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00346-00080457-00080736": "crisis we will revamp and expand", "53Jh62_As3A-00347-00080737-00080892": "training related to crisis intervention", "53Jh62_As3A-00348-00080893-00081200": "and use of force enhance usage of its", "53Jh62_As3A-00349-00081201-00081362": "early warning system to better identify", "53Jh62_As3A-00350-00081363-00081662": "officers whose actions may require for", "53Jh62_As3A-00351-00081663-00081948": "the review to ensure that effective", "53Jh62_As3A-00352-00081949-00082155": "supervisory and accountability systems", "53Jh62_As3A-00353-00082156-00082398": "are in place to review the use of force", "53Jh62_As3A-00354-00082399-00082643": "and finally to create a mechanism for", "53Jh62_As3A-00355-00082644-00082868": "ensuring that community stakeholders and", "53Jh62_As3A-00356-00082869-00083069": "frontline officers have a meaningful", "53Jh62_As3A-00357-00083070-00083331": "opportunity to weigh in on critical", "53Jh62_As3A-00358-00083332-00083598": "improvements before we finalize any", "53Jh62_As3A-00359-00083599-00083831": "agreement we are going back to the", "53Jh62_As3A-00360-00083832-00084072": "community to hear again from them and to", "53Jh62_As3A-00361-00084073-00084212": "hear from other critical stakeholders", "53Jh62_As3A-00362-00084213-00084459": "including police officers I had the", "53Jh62_As3A-00363-00084460-00084666": "opportunity and indeed the privilege of", "53Jh62_As3A-00364-00084667-00084875": "meeting with senior command staff this", "53Jh62_As3A-00365-00084876-00085062": "morning to begin that conversation and", "53Jh62_As3A-00366-00085063-00085362": "these conversations will be continuing", "53Jh62_As3A-00367-00085363-00085530": "and to all those who have weighed in", "53Jh62_As3A-00368-00085531-00085787": "during this process I recognize that", "53Jh62_As3A-00369-00085788-00085986": "this is your agreement this is your", "53Jh62_As3A-00370-00085987-00086061": "department", "53Jh62_As3A-00371-00086062-00086262": "this is your community and we want to", "53Jh62_As3A-00372-00086263-00086468": "continue to ensure that your voice is", "53Jh62_As3A-00373-00086469-00086697": "heard I am very excited about this", "53Jh62_As3A-00374-00086698-00086835": "blueprint and look forward to hearing", "53Jh62_As3A-00375-00086836-00087072": "the feedback from key stakeholders in", "53Jh62_As3A-00376-00087073-00087261": "the days and weeks ahead because our", "53Jh62_As3A-00377-00087262-00087474": "goal is indeed to complete our work in", "53Jh62_As3A-00378-00087475-00087738": "the next month and I am acutely mindful", "53Jh62_As3A-00379-00087739-00087921": "of the fact that this agreement alone", "53Jh62_As3A-00380-00087922-00088221": "will not solve the problem its entirety", "53Jh62_As3A-00381-00088222-00088479": "our findings take place against the", "53Jh62_As3A-00382-00088480-00088746": "backdrop of a statewide mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00383-00088747-00088931": "infrastructure that has a number of key", "53Jh62_As3A-00384-00088932-00089172": "deficiencies the absence of a", "53Jh62_As3A-00385-00089173-00089361": "comprehensive community based mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00386-00089362-00089543": "health infrastructure means that", "53Jh62_As3A-00387-00089544-00089784": "frontline officers confronting a person", "53Jh62_As3A-00388-00089785-00089961": "experiencing a mental health crisis", "53Jh62_As3A-00389-00089962-00090246": "frequently have only two options take", "53Jh62_As3A-00390-00090247-00090492": "the person to jail or take the person to", "53Jh62_As3A-00391-00090493-00090713": "the emergency room in communities across", "53Jh62_As3A-00392-00090714-00090963": "this country the largest mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00393-00090964-00091266": "facility is the jail that's wrong and we", "53Jh62_As3A-00394-00091267-00091418": "need to change that we need to", "53Jh62_As3A-00395-00091419-00091727": "prove that as a nation and the largest", "53Jh62_As3A-00396-00091728-00091922": "mental health facility in a state or", "53Jh62_As3A-00397-00091923-00092246": "county should not be the jail officers", "53Jh62_As3A-00398-00092247-00092402": "must have additional options and people", "53Jh62_As3A-00399-00092403-00092648": "in crisis must have additional options", "53Jh62_As3A-00400-00092649-00092828": "we have worked successfully in other", "53Jh62_As3A-00401-00092829-00093029": "states such as Delaware to build a", "53Jh62_As3A-00402-00093030-00093239": "community a comprehensive community", "53Jh62_As3A-00403-00093240-00093503": "based mental health infrastructure as US", "53Jh62_As3A-00404-00093504-00093662": "attorney Marshall mentioned we are", "53Jh62_As3A-00405-00093663-00093869": "working here in Oregon with state", "53Jh62_As3A-00406-00093870-00094049": "officials in a very collaborative", "53Jh62_As3A-00407-00094050-00094247": "fashion on the development and", "53Jh62_As3A-00408-00094248-00094451": "implementation of a holistic community", "53Jh62_As3A-00409-00094452-00094652": "based mental health infrastructure that", "53Jh62_As3A-00410-00094653-00094892": "will indeed when implemented enhanced", "53Jh62_As3A-00411-00094893-00095114": "both officer safety and public safety", "53Jh62_As3A-00412-00095115-00095345": "and provide those options those critical", "53Jh62_As3A-00413-00095346-00095579": "options for people who are in mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00414-00095580-00095927": "health crisis our formal findings in", "53Jh62_As3A-00415-00095928-00096125": "this case are focused as we have", "53Jh62_As3A-00416-00096126-00096410": "discussed on ppb's interactions with", "53Jh62_As3A-00417-00096411-00096698": "people who have mental illness and while", "53Jh62_As3A-00418-00096699-00096926": "the bulk of our investigation focused on", "53Jh62_As3A-00419-00096927-00097139": "this area it was not limited to this", "53Jh62_As3A-00420-00097140-00097397": "area a number of additional concerns", "53Jh62_As3A-00421-00097398-00097631": "were brought to our attention by", "53Jh62_As3A-00422-00097632-00097850": "community members and while we did not", "53Jh62_As3A-00423-00097851-00098117": "make any formal findings regarding these", "53Jh62_As3A-00424-00098118-00098417": "additional issues it is impossible to", "53Jh62_As3A-00425-00098418-00098648": "ignore the tensions that exist between", "53Jh62_As3A-00426-00098649-00098900": "ppb and certain communities of color", "53Jh62_As3A-00427-00098901-00099236": "here important last year mayor Adams", "53Jh62_As3A-00428-00099237-00099470": "noted that one reason he welcomed our", "53Jh62_As3A-00429-00099471-00099671": "presence in the community was that he", "53Jh62_As3A-00430-00099672-00099860": "hoped that it would help to lead to", "53Jh62_As3A-00431-00099861-00100109": "improved relationships between ppb and", "53Jh62_As3A-00432-00100110-00100358": "Portland's communities of color and he", "53Jh62_As3A-00433-00100359-00100598": "has made this a very strong priority and", "53Jh62_As3A-00434-00100599-00100862": "as has the chief we have heard", "53Jh62_As3A-00435-00100863-00101102": "consistent serious concerns from across", "53Jh62_As3A-00436-00101103-00101537": "the community that it's and and I would", "53Jh62_As3A-00437-00101538-00101702": "note that our we had many conversations", "53Jh62_As3A-00438-00101703-00101932": "with people in the african-american", "53Jh62_As3A-00439-00101933-00102128": "community who felt that they were", "53Jh62_As3A-00440-00102129-00102395": "subject to bias cops and use the support", "53Jh62_As3A-00441-00102396-00102704": "that were based on their race and I", "53Jh62_As3A-00442-00102705-00102859": "would note that while these these", "53Jh62_As3A-00443-00102860-00103229": "tensions a long predate chief Lisa's", "53Jh62_As3A-00444-00103230-00103507": "tenure and Mayor Adams his tenure they", "53Jh62_As3A-00445-00103508-00103654": "persist in many corner", "53Jh62_As3A-00446-00103655-00103927": "this community to this day and our", "53Jh62_As3A-00447-00103928-00104109": "agreement the preliminary agreement that", "53Jh62_As3A-00448-00104110-00104296": "I've outlined will begin to address", "53Jh62_As3A-00449-00104297-00104605": "these important issues in two ways first", "53Jh62_As3A-00450-00104606-00104788": "of all the new policies procedures", "53Jh62_As3A-00451-00104789-00105004": "training and accountability surrounding", "53Jh62_As3A-00452-00105005-00105292": "force will help ensure that unnecessary", "53Jh62_As3A-00453-00105293-00105475": "and unreasonable force is eliminated", "53Jh62_As3A-00454-00105476-00105697": "plain and simple and secondly a", "53Jh62_As3A-00455-00105698-00105982": "community body will be created to help", "53Jh62_As3A-00456-00105983-00106168": "with this agreement and its", "53Jh62_As3A-00457-00106169-00106359": "implementation to collect feedback from", "53Jh62_As3A-00458-00106360-00106513": "the community and to provide", "53Jh62_As3A-00459-00106514-00106906": "recommendations to ppb the mechanism for", "53Jh62_As3A-00460-00106907-00107085": "community engagement and input that we", "53Jh62_As3A-00461-00107086-00107341": "are creating as part of this agreement", "53Jh62_As3A-00462-00107342-00107484": "will not be limited to mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00463-00107485-00107542": "issues", "53Jh62_As3A-00464-00107543-00107811": "rather it is deliberately designed to", "53Jh62_As3A-00465-00107813-00107980": "create an opportunity for dialogue and", "53Jh62_As3A-00466-00107981-00108331": "action between ppb and communities of", "53Jh62_As3A-00467-00108332-00108508": "color and that dialogue has already", "53Jh62_As3A-00468-00108508-00108763": "begun but we recognize and the chief and", "53Jh62_As3A-00469-00108764-00108997": "the mayor recognize that we can and must", "53Jh62_As3A-00470-00108998-00109255": "do more and so I recognize that moving", "53Jh62_As3A-00471-00109256-00109576": "forward and while I am very excited that", "53Jh62_As3A-00472-00109577-00109789": "we have made so much progress", "53Jh62_As3A-00473-00109790-00109986": "in such a short time we recognize fully", "53Jh62_As3A-00474-00109988-00110278": "that considerable work lies ahead change", "53Jh62_As3A-00475-00110279-00110575": "is not easy change requires time it", "53Jh62_As3A-00476-00110576-00110854": "requires persistence partnership a sound", "53Jh62_As3A-00477-00110855-00111202": "plan resources an effective leadership", "53Jh62_As3A-00478-00111203-00111400": "and sustained community engagement and", "53Jh62_As3A-00479-00111401-00111667": "the reason I've come here today with a", "53Jh62_As3A-00480-00111668-00111933": "deep reservoir of optimism is that all", "53Jh62_As3A-00481-00111934-00112198": "of these ingredients all of them are", "53Jh62_As3A-00482-00112199-00112383": "here in Portland I've been around the", "53Jh62_As3A-00483-00112384-00112618": "country I've seen communities working", "53Jh62_As3A-00484-00112619-00112858": "together with law enforcement to build", "53Jh62_As3A-00485-00112858-00113095": "better models of effective policing and", "53Jh62_As3A-00486-00113096-00113350": "you indeed have all of these ingredients", "53Jh62_As3A-00487-00113351-00113641": "of progress here in Portland and you", "53Jh62_As3A-00488-00113642-00113859": "have indeed made progress and I am very", "53Jh62_As3A-00489-00113860-00114142": "confident that we will in fact working", "53Jh62_As3A-00490-00114143-00114336": "together and the we is not simply the", "53Jh62_As3A-00491-00114338-00114577": "department of justice and city officials", "53Jh62_As3A-00492-00114578-00114826": "that we is everybody the community", "53Jh62_As3A-00493-00114827-00115045": "because we're all in this together and", "53Jh62_As3A-00494-00115046-00115249": "we will achieve the goal the chief", "53Jh62_As3A-00495-00115250-00115468": "resource outlined of placing the", "53Jh62_As3A-00496-00115469-00115675": "Portland Police Bureau at the forefront", "53Jh62_As3A-00497-00115676-00115921": "of best practices this is a great", "53Jh62_As3A-00498-00115922-00116167": "community I see that immediate", "53Jh62_As3A-00499-00116168-00116358": "every time I come and when these", "53Jh62_As3A-00500-00116359-00116668": "improvements are fully in place a great", "53Jh62_As3A-00501-00116669-00116956": "community will become even better I have", "53Jh62_As3A-00502-00116957-00117175": "great confidence in that and with that I", "53Jh62_As3A-00503-00117176-00117526": "will turn it over to the mayor thank you", "53Jh62_As3A-00504-00117527-00118030": "very much good morning I'm Sam Adams I'm", "53Jh62_As3A-00505-00118031-00118185": "the police commissioner for the city of", "53Jh62_As3A-00506-00118186-00118378": "Portland two years ago", "53Jh62_As3A-00507-00118379-00118606": "community leaders Commissioner Dan", "53Jh62_As3A-00508-00118607-00118870": "Saltzman and myself asked the US", "53Jh62_As3A-00509-00118871-00119020": "Department of Justice Civil Rights", "53Jh62_As3A-00510-00119021-00119278": "Division to review the important Police", "53Jh62_As3A-00511-00119279-00119569": "Bureau for bias regardless of whether or", "53Jh62_As3A-00512-00119570-00119925": "not it was intentional unconscious or", "53Jh62_As3A-00513-00119926-00120232": "institutional bias any kind of bias", "53Jh62_As3A-00514-00120233-00120523": "during this federal investigations we", "53Jh62_As3A-00515-00120524-00120763": "sought to open our books our doors and", "53Jh62_As3A-00516-00120764-00121165": "our minds yesterday we received the 42", "53Jh62_As3A-00517-00121166-00121426": "page letter detailing the findings of", "53Jh62_As3A-00518-00121427-00121888": "this 14 month investigation it includes", "53Jh62_As3A-00519-00121889-00122116": "as you've heard a critique of our", "53Jh62_As3A-00520-00122117-00122299": "financial East our community-based", "53Jh62_As3A-00521-00122300-00122749": "mental health system it states it states", "53Jh62_As3A-00522-00122750-00122980": "one of our key findings takes place", "53Jh62_As3A-00523-00122981-00123193": "against the backdrop of a mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00524-00123194-00123451": "infrastructure that has a key number of", "53Jh62_As3A-00525-00123452-00123697": "deficiencies with insufficient options", "53Jh62_As3A-00526-00123698-00123904": "for adequate community-based mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00527-00123905-00124240": "health services what I'm quote given our", "53Jh62_As3A-00528-00124241-00124441": "anemic community-based mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00529-00124442-00124639": "system I appreciate that the findings", "53Jh62_As3A-00530-00124640-00124990": "note that the already tough job of being", "53Jh62_As3A-00531-00124991-00125242": "a portland police officer has gotten", "53Jh62_As3A-00532-00125243-00125518": "even tougher with these conditions and", "53Jh62_As3A-00533-00125519-00125818": "with situations that often again quoting", "53Jh62_As3A-00534-00125819-00126064": "from the findings shifts the law", "53Jh62_As3A-00535-00126065-00126322": "enforcement agencies the burden of being", "53Jh62_As3A-00536-00126323-00126568": "the first responders to individuals and", "53Jh62_As3A-00537-00126569-00126898": "mental health crisis and my last budget", "53Jh62_As3A-00538-00126899-00127161": "it is because of the mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00539-00127163-00127570": "system crisis that a key reason why did", "53Jh62_As3A-00540-00127571-00127819": "not cut sworn police officers and did", "53Jh62_As3A-00541-00127820-00128136": "not cut sworn firefighter positions even", "53Jh62_As3A-00542-00128138-00128317": "though we had to make significant cuts", "53Jh62_As3A-00543-00128318-00128610": "from the city's budget and I too want to", "53Jh62_As3A-00544-00128611-00128779": "add my thanks to the hard-working", "53Jh62_As3A-00545-00128780-00128967": "officers of the Portland Police Bureau", "53Jh62_As3A-00546-00128968-00129303": "for working in a very tough situation", "53Jh62_As3A-00547-00129304-00129580": "I'm pleased at the finding states that", "53Jh62_As3A-00548-00129581-00129810": "quote most uses of Forestry reviewed", "53Jh62_As3A-00549-00129811-00130083": "were constitutional and that quote many", "53Jh62_As3A-00550-00130084-00130315": "of the systemic decision deficiencies", "53Jh62_As3A-00551-00130316-00130443": "discussed in the letter", "53Jh62_As3A-00552-00130444-00130705": "originated prior to the current ppb", "53Jh62_As3A-00553-00130706-00131038": "administration and I agree that we have", "53Jh62_As3A-00554-00131039-00131233": "an improvement minded chief of police", "53Jh62_As3A-00555-00131234-00131569": "that is very well situated along with", "53Jh62_As3A-00556-00131570-00131884": "his management team and this Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00557-00131885-00132103": "Police Bureau to move forward on", "53Jh62_As3A-00558-00132104-00132484": "solutions but the findings as you heard", "53Jh62_As3A-00559-00132485-00132790": "are also very blunt in their assessment", "53Jh62_As3A-00560-00132791-00133090": "that we get a failing grade for dealing", "53Jh62_As3A-00561-00133091-00133285": "with the growing number of Portlanders", "53Jh62_As3A-00562-00133286-00133669": "who face serious mental health issues we", "53Jh62_As3A-00563-00133670-00133945": "occasionally use quote unnecessary and", "53Jh62_As3A-00564-00133946-00134209": "unreasonable force during interactions", "53Jh62_As3A-00565-00134210-00134470": "with people who have or are perceived to", "53Jh62_As3A-00566-00134471-00134875": "have mental illness without defensive", "53Jh62_As3A-00567-00134876-00135154": "Nisour finger-pointing we all need to", "53Jh62_As3A-00568-00135155-00135418": "absorb the seriousness of this critique", "53Jh62_As3A-00569-00135419-00135859": "an urgent need is chain urgent need for", "53Jh62_As3A-00570-00135860-00136228": "change we all need to take our portion", "53Jh62_As3A-00571-00136229-00136513": "of the responsibility to improve the", "53Jh62_As3A-00572-00136514-00136828": "situation and as Police Commissioner I", "53Jh62_As3A-00573-00136829-00137143": "intend to do my part we will improve and", "53Jh62_As3A-00574-00137144-00137422": "we will begin to do it quickly some", "53Jh62_As3A-00575-00137423-00137662": "needed changes have already been put in", "53Jh62_As3A-00576-00137663-00137902": "place as we have learned through the", "53Jh62_As3A-00577-00137903-00138187": "questions and the dialogue with the", "53Jh62_As3A-00578-00138188-00138442": "great team of the Civil Rights Division", "53Jh62_As3A-00579-00138443-00138676": "and the US Attorney's Office and I want", "53Jh62_As3A-00580-00138677-00138919": "to thank you and your teams for the", "53Jh62_As3A-00581-00138920-00139165": "great work that you've brought to this", "53Jh62_As3A-00582-00139166-00139408": "effort and for bringing the expertise", "53Jh62_As3A-00583-00139409-00139858": "from around the nation this is really an", "53Jh62_As3A-00584-00139859-00140140": "amazing opportunity for us some of the", "53Jh62_As3A-00585-00140141-00140428": "work that is already underway is for", "53Jh62_As3A-00586-00140429-00140629": "example the new Police Training Center", "53Jh62_As3A-00587-00140630-00140935": "and training citizen Advisory Council", "53Jh62_As3A-00588-00140936-00141237": "that was included in this year's budget", "53Jh62_As3A-00589-00141238-00141498": "success and some of the most diverse", "53Jh62_As3A-00590-00141499-00141713": "recruitment classes", "53Jh62_As3A-00591-00141714-00141878": "in the history of the Portland Police", "53Jh62_As3A-00592-00141879-00142139": "Bureau drug testing and officer", "53Jh62_As3A-00593-00142140-00142433": "evaluations they're in place or underway", "53Jh62_As3A-00594-00142434-00142751": "and as you heard from the assistant", "53Jh62_As3A-00595-00142752-00143012": "attorney general agreement on a letter", "53Jh62_As3A-00596-00143013-00143213": "of intent to move forward to make", "53Jh62_As3A-00597-00143214-00143395": "improvements around the use of force", "53Jh62_As3A-00598-00143396-00143741": "crisis intervention early intervention", "53Jh62_As3A-00599-00143742-00144054": "system for employees misconduct", "53Jh62_As3A-00600-00144055-00144278": "investigations and community engagement", "53Jh62_As3A-00601-00144279-00144731": "and outreach these reforms will require", "53Jh62_As3A-00602-00144732-00145109": "new resources but together they will", "53Jh62_As3A-00603-00145110-00145262": "propel the Portland Police Bureau", "53Jh62_As3A-00604-00145263-00145622": "further down the path as it becomes the", "53Jh62_As3A-00605-00145623-00145897": "best local law enforcement and", "53Jh62_As3A-00606-00145898-00146212": "peacekeeping agency in the nation you", "53Jh62_As3A-00607-00146213-00146653": "might ask how we can move so quickly in", "53Jh62_As3A-00608-00146654-00146936": "30 days to come up with meaningful", "53Jh62_As3A-00609-00146937-00147190": "programs and reforms and I would ask", "53Jh62_As3A-00610-00147191-00147371": "that Commissioner Amanda fridge join me", "53Jh62_As3A-00611-00147372-00147679": "very briefly if I might if I might I", "53Jh62_As3A-00612-00147680-00148037": "assigned Commissioner Fritz the issue of", "53Jh62_As3A-00613-00148038-00148340": "looking at through safer PDX that", "53Jh62_As3A-00614-00148341-00148649": "includes providers police a whole host", "53Jh62_As3A-00615-00148650-00148964": "of partners focused on this issue they", "53Jh62_As3A-00616-00148965-00149174": "have been focused on this issue and", "53Jh62_As3A-00617-00149175-00149363": "looking at solutions for the past three", "53Jh62_As3A-00618-00149364-00149594": "years and I'd like her to just touch on", "53Jh62_As3A-00619-00149595-00149810": "our ability to move quickly into", "53Jh62_As3A-00620-00149811-00150016": "solutions it's because of the benefit of", "53Jh62_As3A-00621-00150017-00150302": "the Bazelon project and safer PDX", "53Jh62_As3A-00622-00150303-00150749": "Commissioner Amanda Fritz I'm really", "53Jh62_As3A-00623-00150750-00150971": "pleased with this statement of intent", "53Jh62_As3A-00624-00150972-00151153": "and the settlement approach and thank my", "53Jh62_As3A-00625-00151154-00151432": "fellow members of that safer PDX project", "53Jh62_As3A-00626-00151433-00151629": "particularly dr. Maggie Bennington Davis", "53Jh62_As3A-00627-00151630-00151912": "my chief medical officer of Cascadia", "53Jh62_As3A-00628-00151913-00152074": "behavioral health who's been", "53Jh62_As3A-00629-00152075-00152275": "spearheading that at that effort which", "53Jh62_As3A-00630-00152276-00152446": "has been truly currently collaborative", "53Jh62_As3A-00631-00152447-00152640": "for every month for the last three years", "53Jh62_As3A-00632-00152641-00152785": "we've been looking at these issues", "53Jh62_As3A-00633-00152786-00152940": "knowing that indeed we do have", "53Jh62_As3A-00634-00152941-00153157": "challenges with gaps in our mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00635-00153158-00153366": "health system I was a registered nurse", "53Jh62_As3A-00636-00153367-00153586": "for 27 years before I was elected to the", "53Jh62_As3A-00637-00153587-00153871": "council in 2009 and I worked for 22", "53Jh62_As3A-00638-00153872-00154123": "years that OHSU into patient psychiatry", "53Jh62_As3A-00639-00154124-00154447": "dr. Bennington Davis pioneered changing", "53Jh62_As3A-00640-00154448-00154693": "use of force inside hospitals with", "53Jh62_As3A-00641-00154694-00154873": "respect to our model which is now the", "53Jh62_As3A-00642-00154874-00155028": "standard of care throughout the United", "53Jh62_As3A-00643-00155029-00155221": "States and similarly that's what we're", "53Jh62_As3A-00644-00155222-00155362": "looking to do in our community that's", "53Jh62_As3A-00645-00155363-00155565": "all we've been working on with all of", "53Jh62_As3A-00646-00155566-00155862": "our partners and this settlement", "53Jh62_As3A-00647-00155863-00156082": "includes many of the things we've been", "53Jh62_As3A-00648-00156083-00156327": "working on it also includes the work", "53Jh62_As3A-00649-00156328-00156481": "that the mayor and I have been working", "53Jh62_As3A-00650-00156482-00156631": "on with the Portland plan and", "53Jh62_As3A-00651-00156632-00156874": "establishing a new office of equity and", "53Jh62_As3A-00652-00156875-00157156": "human rights we very intentionally are", "53Jh62_As3A-00653-00157157-00157314": "staffing the Human Rights Commission", "53Jh62_As3A-00654-00157315-00157474": "within the new office of equity and", "53Jh62_As3A-00655-00157475-00157561": "human rights", "53Jh62_As3A-00656-00157562-00157764": "we're also staffing the community and", "53Jh62_As3A-00657-00157765-00157950": "police relations committee that is the", "53Jh62_As3A-00658-00157951-00158062": "subcommittee of the Human Rights", "53Jh62_As3A-00659-00158063-00158284": "Commission and the mayor alluded to the", "53Jh62_As3A-00660-00158285-00158470": "training that is going to be happening", "53Jh62_As3A-00661-00158471-00158613": "and the training Advisory Committee", "53Jh62_As3A-00662-00158614-00158790": "three members of the community and", "53Jh62_As3A-00663-00158791-00158976": "police relations committee we've been", "53Jh62_As3A-00664-00158977-00159201": "working officers community members", "53Jh62_As3A-00665-00159202-00159351": "humans rights commissioners for the last", "53Jh62_As3A-00666-00159352-00159547": "three years will be part of that", "53Jh62_As3A-00667-00159548-00159899": "training group", "53Jh62_As3A-00668-00159900-00160128": "we're working on multiple different", "53Jh62_As3A-00669-00160129-00160344": "aspects and I'm very pleased that the", "53Jh62_As3A-00670-00160345-00160611": "things that we have through the sake of", "53Jh62_As3A-00671-00160612-00160872": "the TX project realized should be done", "53Jh62_As3A-00672-00160873-00161151": "now must be done and the challenge will", "53Jh62_As3A-00673-00161152-00161406": "be to find out funding but we know what", "53Jh62_As3A-00674-00161407-00161595": "should be done and this statement of", "53Jh62_As3A-00675-00161596-00161925": "attempt reflects that we have a new", "53Jh62_As3A-00676-00161926-00162117": "computer aided dispatch system early", "53Jh62_As3A-00677-00162118-00162363": "alert emergency communications it has", "53Jh62_As3A-00678-00162364-00162666": "formal capacity to be searchable to", "53Jh62_As3A-00679-00162667-00162861": "enter data to retrieve data quickly and", "53Jh62_As3A-00680-00162862-00163107": "the tray up triage desk which captain", "53Jh62_As3A-00681-00163108-00163365": "Sara Westbrook and director Lisa Charlie", "53Jh62_As3A-00682-00163366-00163626": "have been working on regarding the", "53Jh62_As3A-00683-00163627-00163851": "Bureau of emergency communications and", "53Jh62_As3A-00684-00163852-00164082": "how we take those crisis calls and", "53Jh62_As3A-00685-00164083-00164316": "quickly determine who is the best", "53Jh62_As3A-00686-00164317-00164625": "provider to get to the scene and the", "53Jh62_As3A-00687-00164626-00164799": "background of the person who is in", "53Jh62_As3A-00688-00164800-00165057": "crisis it's coming Wednesday we'll be", "53Jh62_As3A-00689-00165058-00165303": "announcing a new partnership with lights", "53Jh62_As3A-00690-00165304-00165522": "for life are in partnership but we'll be", "53Jh62_As3A-00691-00165523-00165717": "publicizing a new number that people can", "53Jh62_As3A-00692-00165718-00165789": "call", "53Jh62_As3A-00693-00165790-00166083": "that's not 900 if they are family member", "53Jh62_As3A-00694-00166084-00166269": "are in crisis where they can talk with", "53Jh62_As3A-00695-00166270-00166479": "qualified mental health professionals", "53Jh62_As3A-00696-00166480-00166761": "and volunteers rather than calling for", "53Jh62_As3A-00697-00166762-00166977": "the police or fire or medical dispatch", "53Jh62_As3A-00698-00166978-00167247": "that we believe will be another option", "53Jh62_As3A-00699-00167248-00167478": "for citizens in our community where we", "53Jh62_As3A-00700-00167479-00167757": "do lack there are some huge gaps in the", "53Jh62_As3A-00701-00167758-00167937": "mental health care system as it's been", "53Jh62_As3A-00702-00167938-00168108": "alluded to which is a trickle-down", "53Jh62_As3A-00703-00168109-00168231": "effect from the state", "53Jh62_As3A-00704-00168232-00168344": "so this", "53Jh62_As3A-00705-00168345-00168627": "investigation a concert with the results", "53Jh62_As3A-00706-00168628-00168846": "of the state investigation should lead", "53Jh62_As3A-00707-00168847-00169095": "to a whole new way of taking care of", "53Jh62_As3A-00708-00169096-00169272": "people rather than not taking care of", "53Jh62_As3A-00709-00169273-00169506": "people which will be must move both more", "53Jh62_As3A-00710-00169507-00169685": "compassionate and more cost-effective", "53Jh62_As3A-00711-00169686-00169934": "and finally I'm very pleased to see the", "53Jh62_As3A-00712-00169935-00170214": "emphasis on community engagement and", "53Jh62_As3A-00713-00170215-00170400": "outreach both the office of neighborhood", "53Jh62_As3A-00714-00170401-00170580": "involvement and the office of equity and", "53Jh62_As3A-00715-00170581-00170730": "human rights have been working", "53Jh62_As3A-00716-00170731-00170964": "diligently to make sure that everybody", "53Jh62_As3A-00717-00170965-00171162": "who is in Portland is welcome at the", "53Jh62_As3A-00718-00171163-00171369": "table is represented at the table and is", "53Jh62_As3A-00719-00171370-00171561": "part of these extremely important", "53Jh62_As3A-00720-00171562-00172481": "discussions thanks to everybody", "53Jh62_As3A-00721-00172482-00172622": "good morning I'm going to keep my", "53Jh62_As3A-00722-00172623-00172895": "remarks short I want to thank the", "53Jh62_As3A-00723-00172896-00173024": "Department of Justice Civil Rights", "53Jh62_As3A-00724-00173025-00173276": "Division including Assistant Attorney", "53Jh62_As3A-00725-00173277-00173567": "General Thomas Perez and his staff for", "53Jh62_As3A-00726-00173568-00173816": "working with us to past 14 months and", "53Jh62_As3A-00727-00173817-00173996": "thank you also to mayor Adams for his", "53Jh62_As3A-00728-00173997-00174212": "guidance and support throughout this", "53Jh62_As3A-00729-00174213-00174569": "process every day important police", "53Jh62_As3A-00730-00174570-00174752": "officers are working to protect and", "53Jh62_As3A-00731-00174753-00175007": "serve our community last year we had", "53Jh62_As3A-00732-00175008-00175253": "approximately 400,000 contacts with", "53Jh62_As3A-00733-00175254-00175499": "community members and too many of these", "53Jh62_As3A-00734-00175500-00175649": "were the result of homelessness", "53Jh62_As3A-00735-00175650-00176036": "addiction mental health issues as a law", "53Jh62_As3A-00736-00176037-00176234": "enforcement agency over the last decade", "53Jh62_As3A-00737-00176235-00176456": "we have had a dynamic shift and the", "53Jh62_As3A-00738-00176457-00176717": "spawning to criminal issues to", "53Jh62_As3A-00739-00176718-00176980": "responding to social disorder", "53Jh62_As3A-00740-00176981-00177224": "unfortunately our system has given", "53Jh62_As3A-00741-00177225-00177518": "officers less options to help people who", "53Jh62_As3A-00742-00177519-00177698": "are afflicted with mental health issues", "53Jh62_As3A-00743-00177699-00177968": "and sometimes concurrent drug and", "53Jh62_As3A-00744-00177969-00178193": "alcohol problems we have not been", "53Jh62_As3A-00745-00178194-00178421": "adequately prepared for the changing", "53Jh62_As3A-00746-00178422-00178691": "circumstances in our community related", "53Jh62_As3A-00747-00178692-00179048": "to mental health the situations we're", "53Jh62_As3A-00748-00179049-00179324": "talking about today are complex and", "53Jh62_As3A-00749-00179325-00179600": "difficult for officers to resolve there", "53Jh62_As3A-00750-00179601-00179897": "are no easy answers or guarantee", "53Jh62_As3A-00751-00179898-00179975": "outcomes", "53Jh62_As3A-00752-00179976-00180242": "I believe that thoughtful people can", "53Jh62_As3A-00753-00180243-00180425": "respectfully disagree with the legal", "53Jh62_As3A-00754-00180426-00180761": "conclusions however we all agreed that", "53Jh62_As3A-00755-00180762-00181016": "this Bureau and our community and", "53Jh62_As3A-00756-00181017-00181244": "improve the way we serve and protect", "53Jh62_As3A-00757-00181245-00181492": "Portland's most vulnerable populations", "53Jh62_As3A-00758-00181493-00181751": "that's why as the Department of Justice", "53Jh62_As3A-00759-00181752-00181895": "has provided us with recommendations", "53Jh62_As3A-00760-00181896-00182192": "during their investigation this Bureau", "53Jh62_As3A-00761-00182193-00182447": "has already implemented changes in the", "53Jh62_As3A-00762-00182448-00182723": "way we investigate use of force embark", "53Jh62_As3A-00763-00182724-00182927": "on reducing unnecessary interactions", "53Jh62_As3A-00764-00182928-00183163": "with people in mental health crisis and", "53Jh62_As3A-00765-00183164-00183437": "for having an inspector position that", "53Jh62_As3A-00766-00183438-00183647": "reviews all use of force incidents", "53Jh62_As3A-00767-00183648-00183866": "looking for trends or patterns that may", "53Jh62_As3A-00768-00183867-00184049": "be problematic", "53Jh62_As3A-00769-00184050-00184299": "there were the recommendations contained", "53Jh62_As3A-00770-00184300-00184464": "in this letter from the Department of", "53Jh62_As3A-00771-00184465-00184725": "Justice provide us with a foundation for", "53Jh62_As3A-00772-00184726-00184941": "additional enhancements that we believe", "53Jh62_As3A-00773-00184942-00185247": "are valuable ways to ensure that our use", "53Jh62_As3A-00774-00185248-00185433": "of force means the community's", "53Jh62_As3A-00775-00185434-00185667": "expectations I want to make it very", "53Jh62_As3A-00776-00185668-00185922": "clear there is no daylight between what", "53Jh62_As3A-00777-00185923-00186087": "the Department of Justice is asking us", "53Jh62_As3A-00778-00186088-00186285": "to do and what we want to do as a", "53Jh62_As3A-00779-00186286-00186603": "Portland Police Bureau as we move to", "53Jh62_As3A-00780-00186604-00186768": "implement these recommendations we are", "53Jh62_As3A-00781-00186769-00186918": "fortunate to have close relationships", "53Jh62_As3A-00782-00186919-00187107": "with leaders in the mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00783-00187108-00187392": "community including Cascadia which", "53Jh62_As3A-00784-00187393-00187602": "provides project respond workers who", "53Jh62_As3A-00785-00187603-00187793": "assist on many calls for service", "53Jh62_As3A-00786-00187794-00188148": "regarding people in crisis dr. Gerald", "53Jh62_As3A-00787-00188149-00188424": "Walker CEO of Cascadia is here today and", "53Jh62_As3A-00788-00188425-00188595": "I want to personally thank him and his", "53Jh62_As3A-00789-00188596-00188769": "staff for the tremendous support they", "53Jh62_As3A-00790-00188770-00189089": "give police officers each and every day", "53Jh62_As3A-00791-00189090-00189348": "if we are to be successful in meeting", "53Jh62_As3A-00792-00189349-00189618": "these challenges then police officers", "53Jh62_As3A-00793-00189619-00189729": "will need to have better relationships", "53Jh62_As3A-00794-00189730-00190089": "with our social service partners can we", "53Jh62_As3A-00795-00190090-00190482": "do with jail staff we all agree that we", "53Jh62_As3A-00796-00190483-00190620": "as a Police Department and as a", "53Jh62_As3A-00797-00190621-00190842": "community can do better I am looking", "53Jh62_As3A-00798-00190843-00190971": "forward to a collaborative relationship", "53Jh62_As3A-00799-00190972-00191217": "with the Department of Justice and our", "53Jh62_As3A-00800-00191218-00191451": "social service partners as we make", "53Jh62_As3A-00801-00191452-00191661": "improvements that provide officers and", "53Jh62_As3A-00802-00191662-00191942": "our community more options and resources", "53Jh62_As3A-00803-00191943-00192189": "to effectively help people in a male", "53Jh62_As3A-00804-00192190-00192597": "health crisis finally what we're talking", "53Jh62_As3A-00805-00192598-00192815": "about today our processes and systems", "53Jh62_As3A-00806-00192816-00193245": "not about our police officers", "53Jh62_As3A-00807-00193246-00193546": "they they took an oath to uphold the", "53Jh62_As3A-00808-00193547-00193729": "Constitution of the United States and", "53Jh62_As3A-00809-00193730-00193972": "they're not the folks to blame they are", "53Jh62_As3A-00810-00193973-00194116": "out in the community doing their very", "53Jh62_As3A-00811-00194117-00194350": "best and the majority of cases are", "53Jh62_As3A-00812-00194351-00194605": "highly successful saving lives and", "53Jh62_As3A-00813-00194606-00194923": "making a positive difference I support", "53Jh62_As3A-00814-00194924-00195256": "them and the work they do the Portland", "53Jh62_As3A-00815-00195257-00195514": "Police Bureau continues to evolve to", "53Jh62_As3A-00816-00195515-00195601": "learn and improve", "53Jh62_As3A-00817-00195602-00195862": "I believe the resulting agreement from", "53Jh62_As3A-00818-00195863-00195997": "our efforts with the department of", "53Jh62_As3A-00819-00195998-00196234": "justice who made best are there a better", "53Jh62_As3A-00820-00196235-00196423": "Portland Police Bureau thank you very", "53Jh62_As3A-00821-00196424-00196483": "much", "53Jh62_As3A-00822-00196484-00196675": "with respect to questions the police say", "53Jh62_As3A-00823-00196676-00196902": "they'd like to ask and identify yourself", "53Jh62_As3A-00824-00196903-00197698": "we'd like to start", "53Jh62_As3A-00825-00197699-00198208": "a question about the fact that we've", "53Jh62_As3A-00826-00198209-00198394": "talked a lot about local partnerships", "53Jh62_As3A-00827-00198395-00198753": "for food in your department and", "53Jh62_As3A-00828-00198754-00199360": "but I was wondering kind of are they out", "53Jh62_As3A-00829-00199361-00199653": "of this where do you stand with this", "53Jh62_As3A-00830-00199654-00199989": "thing we continue we continue to work", "53Jh62_As3A-00831-00199990-00200165": "very collaboratively with the state on", "53Jh62_As3A-00832-00200166-00200518": "the broader systems issue of creating as", "53Jh62_As3A-00833-00200519-00200731": "part of the governor's health care", "53Jh62_As3A-00834-00200732-00201109": "transformation a community community", "53Jh62_As3A-00835-00201110-00201222": "based mental health infrastructure", "53Jh62_As3A-00836-00201223-00201435": "across the state we have been in contact", "53Jh62_As3A-00837-00201436-00201627": "with them I know that the US attorney", "53Jh62_As3A-00838-00201628-00201825": "spoke with Dennis recently is last night", "53Jh62_As3A-00839-00201826-00202137": "and we continue to stay in contact", "53Jh62_As3A-00840-00202138-00202383": "because we are on a parallel path", "53Jh62_As3A-00841-00202384-00202708": "strategy we are working with the police", "53Jh62_As3A-00842-00202709-00202776": "department", "53Jh62_As3A-00843-00202777-00202972": "simultaneously we're working with the", "53Jh62_As3A-00844-00202973-00203247": "state it's one holistic integrated", "53Jh62_As3A-00845-00203248-00203463": "network that is really what we're trying", "53Jh62_As3A-00846-00203464-00203734": "to build here and I'm confident that we", "53Jh62_As3A-00847-00203735-00203922": "will if you didn't do that and the state", "53Jh62_As3A-00848-00203923-00205383": "is a key stakeholder in what we expect", "53Jh62_As3A-00849-00205384-00205506": "to do in the next month first and", "53Jh62_As3A-00850-00205507-00205710": "foremost is a lot of listening we did a", "53Jh62_As3A-00851-00205711-00205979": "lot of listening throughout our", "53Jh62_As3A-00852-00205980-00206326": "investigation and as a result of that I", "53Jh62_As3A-00853-00206327-00206580": "believe that all the stakeholders will", "53Jh62_As3A-00854-00206581-00206766": "see that our findings reflect that", "53Jh62_As3A-00855-00206767-00207046": "listening and we will continue to listen", "53Jh62_As3A-00856-00207046-00207253": "to more because we are meeting with", "53Jh62_As3A-00857-00207254-00207496": "people as soon as later today we've", "53Jh62_As3A-00858-00207496-00207729": "already met with senior leadership in", "53Jh62_As3A-00859-00207730-00207946": "the department because we want to get", "53Jh62_As3A-00860-00207946-00208277": "people's feedback about the", "53Jh62_As3A-00861-00208278-00208602": "we have both the letter finding that is", "53Jh62_As3A-00862-00208603-00208838": "available for the public as well as our", "53Jh62_As3A-00863-00208839-00209232": "two-page letter that memorializes the", "53Jh62_As3A-00864-00209233-00209439": "concepts outlined in the preliminary", "53Jh62_As3A-00865-00209440-00209598": "agreement and so we're gonna reach out", "53Jh62_As3A-00866-00209598-00209775": "and again one of the things that was", "53Jh62_As3A-00867-00209776-00210057": "critically important for all of us", "53Jh62_As3A-00868-00210058-00210323": "involved in this was that there needs to", "53Jh62_As3A-00869-00210325-00210744": "be a structured approach not simply in", "53Jh62_As3A-00870-00210744-00211035": "the next month but in the improvement", "53Jh62_As3A-00871-00211036-00211394": "processes that lie ahead in the months", "53Jh62_As3A-00872-00211396-00211721": "and years ahead for active and", "53Jh62_As3A-00873-00211723-00211950": "meaningful community engagement and so", "53Jh62_As3A-00874-00211951-00212085": "we look forward to listening and money", "53Jh62_As3A-00875-00212086-00212933": "and integrating those suggestions into", "53Jh62_As3A-00876-00212934-00213288": "what were your initial reactions to the", "53Jh62_As3A-00877-00213289-00213446": "findings of the investigation were you", "53Jh62_As3A-00878-00213448-00214171": "surprised is it what you were expecting", "53Jh62_As3A-00879-00214171-00214392": "I'll be perfectly honest as a police", "53Jh62_As3A-00880-00214394-00214878": "officer it's disappointing to hear that", "53Jh62_As3A-00881-00214879-00215049": "the Department of Justice believes that", "53Jh62_As3A-00882-00215050-00215665": "you haven't got it right and we go out", "53Jh62_As3A-00883-00215666-00215907": "every day trying to do our very best in", "53Jh62_As3A-00884-00215908-00216091": "difficult circumstances and tough", "53Jh62_As3A-00885-00216092-00216354": "situations and as I said there's no easy", "53Jh62_As3A-00886-00216355-00216683": "answers for guaranteed outcomes and it's", "53Jh62_As3A-00887-00216684-00217071": "it's just hard to hear that you didn't", "53Jh62_As3A-00888-00217073-00217291": "get it right in some of those cases but", "53Jh62_As3A-00889-00217292-00217632": "I think that our officers are committed", "53Jh62_As3A-00890-00217633-00217921": "to improving their work with people in", "53Jh62_As3A-00891-00217921-00217990": "crisis", "53Jh62_As3A-00892-00217991-00218314": "I know as Chief of Police it is one of", "53Jh62_As3A-00893-00218315-00219896": "the priorities that I have", "53Jh62_As3A-00894-00219898-00220407": "well again we had a number of I think", "53Jh62_As3A-00895-00220408-00220621": "important and productive meetings with", "53Jh62_As3A-00896-00220621-00220875": "various communities here and we will", "53Jh62_As3A-00897-00220876-00221296": "continue to do so and we we believe that", "53Jh62_As3A-00898-00221296-00221496": "the structure of our preliminary", "53Jh62_As3A-00899-00221498-00221652": "agreement is going to provide", "53Jh62_As3A-00900-00221653-00222008": "opportunities to put many of these", "53Jh62_As3A-00901-00222009-00222324": "festering tensions squarely on the table", "53Jh62_As3A-00902-00222325-00222650": "and provide an opportunity to have", "53Jh62_As3A-00903-00222651-00222954": "meaningful engagement not simply on an", "53Jh62_As3A-00904-00222955-00223198": "ad-hoc basis but on a systemic basis so", "53Jh62_As3A-00905-00223198-00223650": "that we can truly ensure that everybody", "53Jh62_As3A-00906-00223651-00223819": "is part of the community and and I've", "53Jh62_As3A-00907-00223819-00223953": "observed there there are a number of", "53Jh62_As3A-00908-00223954-00224160": "things that we observe that are being", "53Jh62_As3A-00909-00224161-00224406": "done we've had conversations about", "53Jh62_As3A-00910-00224407-00224667": "hiring for instance and we've learned a", "53Jh62_As3A-00911-00224669-00224925": "lot about efforts that have been made to", "53Jh62_As3A-00912-00224926-00225381": "ensure that there is a very robust", "53Jh62_As3A-00913-00225382-00225630": "outreach to various communities and it", "53Jh62_As3A-00914-00225631-00225909": "is beginning to bear fruit but we need", "53Jh62_As3A-00915-00225910-00226066": "more input from the community about how", "53Jh62_As3A-00916-00226067-00226374": "we can sustain that progress and I've", "53Jh62_As3A-00917-00226375-00226632": "seen this this issue is not like the", "53Jh62_As3A-00918-00226633-00226867": "mental health issues this issue is not", "53Jh62_As3A-00919-00226867-00227266": "unique to Portland and it is vexing and", "53Jh62_As3A-00920-00227267-00227480": "challenging but I have seen progress in", "53Jh62_As3A-00921-00227481-00227866": "this area I have seen it in large cities", "53Jh62_As3A-00922-00227867-00228069": "like Los Angeles I've seen it in in", "53Jh62_As3A-00923-00228071-00228249": "midsize cities I've seen it in smaller", "53Jh62_As3A-00924-00228250-00228438": "communities and what it takes is", "53Jh62_As3A-00925-00228439-00228717": "sustained engagement what it takes is", "53Jh62_As3A-00926-00228719-00229097": "leaks of faith to build that trust and", "53Jh62_As3A-00927-00229098-00229380": "we've seen it work and I'm very", "53Jh62_As3A-00928-00229381-00229701": "confident here that we'll make progress", "53Jh62_As3A-00929-00229702-00229829": "in this area it won't happen overnight", "53Jh62_As3A-00930-00229830-00230314": "but I seen on the part of the community", "53Jh62_As3A-00931-00230315-00230571": "a serious commitment and I've seen in", "53Jh62_As3A-00932-00230573-00230748": "the part of the leadership a serious", "53Jh62_As3A-00933-00230749-00230812": "commitment", "53Jh62_As3A-00934-00230813-00231121": "to really improve and build additional", "53Jh62_As3A-00935-00231121-00231427": "bridges of trust and opportunity you", "53Jh62_As3A-00936-00231428-00231559": "have a question right here I'm sorry", "53Jh62_As3A-00937-00231560-00231811": "Oh with the mercury and I was wondering", "53Jh62_As3A-00938-00231812-00232027": "are there recommendations in this report", "53Jh62_As3A-00939-00232028-00232231": "are there specific timelines spelled out", "53Jh62_As3A-00940-00232232-00232387": "for Windows should be implemented and", "53Jh62_As3A-00941-00232388-00232573": "what's the follow-up here if we don't", "53Jh62_As3A-00942-00232573-00232837": "change what's what's next from your", "53Jh62_As3A-00943-00232838-00233086": "department well we all have a shared", "53Jh62_As3A-00944-00233087-00233269": "interest in implementation as soon as", "53Jh62_As3A-00945-00233269-00233567": "possible we do not want a single", "53Jh62_As3A-00946-00233569-00233929": "incident that is a preventable incident", "53Jh62_As3A-00947-00233930-00234192": "to occur in so that is why we have a", "53Jh62_As3A-00948-00234194-00234355": "shared interest with the community and", "53Jh62_As3A-00949-00234356-00234601": "with the department and making sure", "53Jh62_As3A-00950-00234602-00234826": "reforms are implemented as soon as", "53Jh62_As3A-00951-00234827-00234889": "possible", "53Jh62_As3A-00952-00234890-00235096": "we also have to confront the reality", "53Jh62_As3A-00953-00235096-00235569": "that reforms require resources and so in", "53Jh62_As3A-00954-00235569-00235773": "agreements we've done with other cities", "53Jh62_As3A-00955-00235775-00236077": "we have been very careful to reflect", "53Jh62_As3A-00956-00236078-00236473": "those fiscal realities and to have", "53Jh62_As3A-00957-00236473-00236812": "stages of implementation and obviously", "53Jh62_As3A-00958-00236813-00236977": "as we continue this discussion we're", "53Jh62_As3A-00959-00236978-00237151": "simultaneously as I mentioned earlier", "53Jh62_As3A-00960-00237152-00237519": "talking to the state and as the state", "53Jh62_As3A-00961-00237521-00237928": "reform process continues hopefully that", "53Jh62_As3A-00962-00237929-00238153": "will enhance the efforts that are", "53Jh62_As3A-00963-00238154-00238405": "underway here and and again we will", "53Jh62_As3A-00964-00238406-00238663": "demoralise this in an agreement an", "53Jh62_As3A-00965-00238664-00238912": "accord enforceable agreement and and", "53Jh62_As3A-00966-00238913-00239277": "quite frankly I'm quite confident that", "53Jh62_As3A-00967-00239278-00239623": "the agreement will will be carried out", "53Jh62_As3A-00968-00239623-00239932": "and that's because I've seen the resolve", "53Jh62_As3A-00969-00239933-00240100": "of the community here I've seen them as", "53Jh62_As3A-00970-00240101-00240286": "all the frontline officers I've seen the", "53Jh62_As3A-00971-00240287-00240588": "resolve of the police leadership and the", "53Jh62_As3A-00972-00240589-00241228": "political leadership in this race can", "53Jh62_As3A-00973-00241229-00241348": "you put us in the mind of a police", "53Jh62_As3A-00974-00241348-00241582": "officer who comes to the holy Kaba", "53Jh62_As3A-00975-00241583-00241723": "region as somebody comes out of a", "53Jh62_As3A-00976-00241723-00241978": "bathroom with an exacto knife how are", "53Jh62_As3A-00977-00241979-00242148": "they gonna act differently what's gonna", "53Jh62_As3A-00978-00242150-00242317": "happen on the ground what's going to go", "53Jh62_As3A-00979-00242317-00242535": "through that officers mind after a", "53Jh62_As3A-00980-00242536-00243103": "finding like this I don't want to talk", "53Jh62_As3A-00981-00243104-00243487": "about specific cases but I think that", "53Jh62_As3A-00982-00243488-00243730": "what we're hoping is we move forward is", "53Jh62_As3A-00983-00243731-00244060": "that and we've been working on this with", "53Jh62_As3A-00984-00244061-00244303": "Department of Justice in the last year", "53Jh62_As3A-00985-00244304-00244585": "on de-escalation strategies so how do", "53Jh62_As3A-00986-00244586-00244767": "you realize that somebody's in a mental", "53Jh62_As3A-00987-00244769-00245050": "health crisis this is hard to do you", "53Jh62_As3A-00988-00245051-00245335": "know I think experts in that field would", "53Jh62_As3A-00989-00245336-00245584": "say it's really tough with writing on", "53Jh62_As3A-00990-00245585-00245836": "scene to figure that out but if we have", "53Jh62_As3A-00991-00245837-00246181": "that information available how do we use", "53Jh62_As3A-00992-00246182-00246409": "de-escalation strategies how do we use", "53Jh62_As3A-00993-00246410-00246744": "other tactics or resources that may be", "53Jh62_As3A-00994-00246746-00247153": "available and fundamentally I think we", "53Jh62_As3A-00995-00247154-00247371": "have to treat people in mental health", "53Jh62_As3A-00996-00247373-00247642": "crisis with compassion and empathy we", "53Jh62_As3A-00997-00247642-00247783": "can't treat them the same way we do", "53Jh62_As3A-00998-00247784-00247942": "somebody that's committed a bank robbery", "53Jh62_As3A-00999-00247942-00248206": "and while people in crisis can be", "53Jh62_As3A-01000-00248207-00248473": "dangerous and unpredictable we have to", "53Jh62_As3A-01001-00248473-00248680": "treat them with compassion and empathy", "53Jh62_As3A-01002-00248681-00249037": "while protecting ourselves in it so your", "53Jh62_As3A-01003-00249038-00249246": "question raises an issue that I have", "53Jh62_As3A-01004-00249248-00249385": "observed elsewhere in the country where", "53Jh62_As3A-01005-00249386-00249706": "we're there it's an understandable", "53Jh62_As3A-01006-00249707-00249928": "question and the question is well will", "53Jh62_As3A-01007-00249929-00250117": "the frontline officer respond to our", "53Jh62_As3A-01008-00250117-00250363": "findings by simply saying in his or her", "53Jh62_As3A-01009-00250364-00250692": "car and avoiding situations where you've", "53Jh62_As3A-01010-00250694-00250900": "interacted with the public the term of", "53Jh62_As3A-01011-00250901-00251305": "art in policing is that will they engage", "53Jh62_As3A-01012-00251306-00251608": "in deep policing well the evidence has", "53Jh62_As3A-01013-00251609-00251769": "been quite the contrary you look at", "53Jh62_As3A-01014-00251771-00251953": "places like Los Angeles where we were", "53Jh62_As3A-01015-00251954-00252091": "able to work collaboratively with the", "53Jh62_As3A-01016-00252092-00252427": "police leadership there and on a day of", "53Jh62_As3A-01017-00252428-00252696": "issues that are far wider and breadth", "53Jh62_As3A-01018-00252698-00252809": "than the", "53Jh62_As3A-01019-00252810-00253016": "issues that we see here there have been", "53Jh62_As3A-01020-00253017-00253226": "study after study after study that", "53Jh62_As3A-01021-00253227-00253559": "demonstrates just the opposite what", "53Jh62_As3A-01022-00253560-00253775": "happened in the agreements that we read", "53Jh62_As3A-01023-00253776-00253919": "with Los Angeles is that we gave", "53Jh62_As3A-01024-00253919-00254119": "officers more tools so they could do", "53Jh62_As3A-01025-00254121-00254462": "their job better so in fact policing was", "53Jh62_As3A-01026-00254463-00254639": "more effective use of force was down", "53Jh62_As3A-01027-00254640-00254906": "public confidence was up and it was up", "53Jh62_As3A-01028-00254907-00255350": "across all racial demographics and as a", "53Jh62_As3A-01029-00255351-00255626": "result what I hope and what I've", "53Jh62_As3A-01030-00255627-00255871": "attempted to communicate directly with", "53Jh62_As3A-01031-00255871-00256121": "frontline officers is our goal here is", "53Jh62_As3A-01032-00256121-00256321": "to give you more tools and when you have", "53Jh62_As3A-01033-00256323-00256490": "more tools you can be a more effective", "53Jh62_As3A-01034-00256491-00256742": "problem solver police officers are", "53Jh62_As3A-01035-00256742-00257015": "problem solvers and as a result of many", "53Jh62_As3A-01036-00257016-00257189": "of the deficiencies that the chief is", "53Jh62_As3A-01037-00257190-00257398": "outline we're asking them to solve some", "53Jh62_As3A-01038-00257400-00257755": "really vexing challenges that are", "53Jh62_As3A-01039-00257756-00258107": "frankly unfair in many contexts to ask", "53Jh62_As3A-01040-00258108-00258284": "them to solve but we're going to give", "53Jh62_As3A-01041-00258285-00258500": "them more resources and when we do that", "53Jh62_As3A-01042-00258501-00258641": "and you have more tools in your arsenal", "53Jh62_As3A-01043-00258642-00258857": "you become a better problem solver", "53Jh62_As3A-01044-00258858-00259067": "Denison I had a question yeah I was", "53Jh62_As3A-01045-00259067-00259319": "wondering it there's a citizen aspect of", "53Jh62_As3A-01046-00259319-00259423": "this if you want people to come together", "53Jh62_As3A-01047-00259425-00259565": "and talk about this there are community", "53Jh62_As3A-01048-00259566-00259760": "groups now who have raised questions", "53Jh62_As3A-01049-00259761-00259901": "about how transparent a training", "53Jh62_As3A-01050-00259902-00260075": "advisory council is going to be is that", "53Jh62_As3A-01051-00260076-00260213": "something you're gonna be working with", "53Jh62_As3A-01052-00260214-00260438": "to make sure that that gonna be address", "53Jh62_As3A-01053-00260439-00260564": "those concerns so people feel like they", "53Jh62_As3A-01054-00260565-00260921": "can communicate yeah the Train Advisory", "53Jh62_As3A-01055-00260921-00261219": "Council that goes along with the new", "53Jh62_As3A-01056-00261221-00261623": "consolidated training activities or", "53Jh62_As3A-01057-00261623-00261817": "training programs officer training", "53Jh62_As3A-01058-00261819-00262025": "programs for the bureau the new training", "53Jh62_As3A-01059-00262026-00262490": "center the Proceedings of that Advisory", "53Jh62_As3A-01060-00262491-00262829": "Council will both be open door but I", "53Jh62_As3A-01061-00262830-00263221": "also want them to be exposed to every", "53Jh62_As3A-01062-00263222-00263612": "scenario training possibility and some", "53Jh62_As3A-01063-00263613-00263935": "of those scenarios need to be closed or", "53Jh62_As3A-01064-00263936-00264323": "executive session there are folks in the", "53Jh62_As3A-01065-00264324-00264611": "community who have criminal intentions", "53Jh62_As3A-01066-00264612-00264854": "who do not suffer from mental health and", "53Jh62_As3A-01067-00264855-00265097": "I don't want to give away the playbook", "53Jh62_As3A-01068-00265098-00265399": "but it'll be both public and private and", "53Jh62_As3A-01069-00265400-00265573": "I think", "53Jh62_As3A-01070-00265574-00265785": "it'll be a great value to both the", "53Jh62_As3A-01071-00265786-00265935": "community and giving us good feedback", "53Jh62_As3A-01072-00265936-00266173": "and I think it'd be a great value to the", "53Jh62_As3A-01073-00266174-00266308": "police force that concludes today's", "53Jh62_As3A-01074-00266309-00266470": "press conference but of course each", "53Jh62_As3A-01075-00266471-00266629": "person here remains for individual", "53Jh62_As3A-01076-00266630-00266743": "energies I want to thank all of you very", "53Jh62_As3A-01077-00266744-00266961": "much"}}, {"audio_id": "53YYT0p95P0", "text": {"53YYT0p95P0-00000-00000083-00001261": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00001-00001262-00001860": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00002-00001861-00001976": "hear that", "53YYT0p95P0-00003-00001977-00002765": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00004-00002766-00002960": "you 've been there", "53YYT0p95P0-00005-00002961-00003878": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00006-00003879-00004393": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00007-00004394-00005145": "Corners songs", "53YYT0p95P0-00008-00005146-00006581": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00009-00006581-00007825": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00010-00007826-00008567": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00011-00008568-00009217": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00012-00009218-00009949": "[Music]", "53YYT0p95P0-00013-00009950-00010519": "boy names", "53YYT0p95P0-00014-00010520-00011490": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "53aiKHG1nJo", "text": {"53aiKHG1nJo-00000-00001184-00001322": "b", "53aiKHG1nJo-00001-00001323-00002030": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00002-00002032-00003078": "so", "53aiKHG1nJo-00003-00003079-00004238": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00004-00004239-00021127": "any", "53aiKHG1nJo-00005-00021128-00021263": "symmetria", "53aiKHG1nJo-00006-00021264-00022886": "three million narcotics", "53aiKHG1nJo-00007-00022887-00024041": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00008-00024042-00025286": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00009-00025287-00027790": "foreign", "53aiKHG1nJo-00010-00027791-00028511": "foreign", "53aiKHG1nJo-00011-00028512-00030855": "um", "53aiKHG1nJo-00012-00030856-00032364": "canadian", "53aiKHG1nJo-00013-00032364-00032631": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00014-00032632-00035727": "nigeria", "53aiKHG1nJo-00015-00035728-00037014": "uh", "53aiKHG1nJo-00016-00037015-00038419": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00017-00038420-00039233": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00018-00039234-00040015": "[Music]", "53aiKHG1nJo-00019-00040016-00041343": "so", "53aiKHG1nJo-00020-00041344-00042918": "so", "53aiKHG1nJo-00021-00042919-00044527": "so", "53aiKHG1nJo-00022-00044528-00045702": "so", "53aiKHG1nJo-00023-00045703-00047807": "so", "53aiKHG1nJo-00024-00047808-00050311": "wow", "53aiKHG1nJo-00025-00050312-00050519": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "54jozVIUFkg", "text": {"54jozVIUFkg-00000-00000656-00000799": "number one", "54jozVIUFkg-00001-00000800-00000999": "you will be surprised to know that the", "54jozVIUFkg-00002-00001000-00001215": "most dangerous fact about this island is", "54jozVIUFkg-00003-00001216-00001254": "that", "54jozVIUFkg-00004-00001255-00001491": "it can disappear anytime in the near", "54jozVIUFkg-00005-00001492-00001767": "future a united nations report", "54jozVIUFkg-00006-00001768-00001975": "on the consequences of global warming", "54jozVIUFkg-00007-00001976-00002110": "included tocalau", "54jozVIUFkg-00008-00002111-00002271": "in the list of islands that could", "54jozVIUFkg-00009-00002272-00002495": "disappear under the sea in the 21st", "54jozVIUFkg-00010-00002496-00002567": "century", "54jozVIUFkg-00011-00002568-00002767": "if they do not take drastic measures to", "54jozVIUFkg-00012-00002768-00003095": "stop the contamination process", "54jozVIUFkg-00013-00003096-00003383": "number two one of the most surprising", "54jozVIUFkg-00014-00003384-00003583": "facts about this island is that", "54jozVIUFkg-00015-00003584-00003911": "traveling to tokulau islands is not easy", "54jozVIUFkg-00016-00003911-00004159": "the island has no airport or coastal", "54jozVIUFkg-00017-00004160-00004447": "port to facilitate movement the only", "54jozVIUFkg-00018-00004448-00004638": "means of transportation used to reach", "54jozVIUFkg-00019-00004639-00004695": "here", "54jozVIUFkg-00020-00004696-00005063": "is by a boat moreover finding a place to", "54jozVIUFkg-00021-00005064-00005247": "sleep in toccala can be quite a", "54jozVIUFkg-00022-00005248-00005318": "challenge", "54jozVIUFkg-00023-00005319-00005511": "because it has very few number of rest", "54jozVIUFkg-00024-00005512-00005654": "houses resorts", "54jozVIUFkg-00025-00005655-00006070": "and guest houses number three", "54jozVIUFkg-00026-00006071-00006295": "tocalau is one of the smallest countries", "54jozVIUFkg-00027-00006296-00006375": "of the world", "54jozVIUFkg-00028-00006376-00006719": "with an area of just 10 kilometer square", "54jozVIUFkg-00029-00006720-00007023": "yes only 10 kilometers long", "54jozVIUFkg-00030-00007023-00007206": "you can actually visit the island", "54jozVIUFkg-00031-00007208-00007383": "entirely in less than a day", "54jozVIUFkg-00032-00007384-00007583": "but if you wish to stay more you will", "54jozVIUFkg-00033-00007584-00007806": "have to negotiate with the local elders", "54jozVIUFkg-00034-00007808-00008159": "to take a refuge at their place", "54jozVIUFkg-00035-00008159-00008431": "number four all the electricity", "54jozVIUFkg-00036-00008432-00008671": "available in this country is generated", "54jozVIUFkg-00037-00008672-00008855": "by solar panels", "54jozVIUFkg-00038-00008856-00009071": "it is the only country in the world", "54jozVIUFkg-00039-00009072-00009183": "where 100", "54jozVIUFkg-00040-00009184-00009423": "of the electricity consumed comes from", "54jozVIUFkg-00041-00009424-00009551": "the sun", "54jozVIUFkg-00042-00009552-00009919": "and that's really great for the ecology", "54jozVIUFkg-00043-00009920-00010246": "number five the only crops produced in", "54jozVIUFkg-00044-00010247-00010551": "toca lau are bananas and coconuts", "54jozVIUFkg-00045-00010552-00010774": "the island produces nothing else on its", "54jozVIUFkg-00046-00010775-00011014": "own and supports itself entirely", "54jozVIUFkg-00047-00011015-00011374": "through the help provided by new zealand", "54jozVIUFkg-00048-00011375-00011678": "number six the island is so close to the", "54jozVIUFkg-00049-00011679-00011895": "ocean water that the highest point here", "54jozVIUFkg-00050-00011896-00012238": "is just five meters well that might be a", "54jozVIUFkg-00051-00012239-00012399": "nice little adventure for newbie", "54jozVIUFkg-00052-00012400-00012487": "mountaineers", "54jozVIUFkg-00053-00012488-00012807": "at least that was all about", "54jozVIUFkg-00054-00012808-00013127": "toca love for you do like share", "54jozVIUFkg-00055-00013128-00013586": "comment and subscribe to our channel", "54jozVIUFkg-00056-00013587-00013887": "explified"}}, {"audio_id": "54mx28kT384", "text": {"54mx28kT384-00000-00002319-00004006": "um", "54mx28kT384-00001-00004007-00004914": "um", "54mx28kT384-00002-00004915-00005226": "[Applause]", "54mx28kT384-00003-00005227-00006755": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00004-00006756-00007367": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00005-00007368-00007781": "hmm", "54mx28kT384-00006-00007781-00008703": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00007-00008704-00008856": "uh", "54mx28kT384-00008-00008857-00011023": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00009-00011024-00013327": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00010-00013328-00014019": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00011-00014019-00014535": "stranded in the open", "54mx28kT384-00012-00014536-00015099": "dried out tears of sorrow", "54mx28kT384-00013-00015100-00015611": "lacking all emotions", "54mx28kT384-00014-00015612-00016163": "staring down the barrel waiting for the", "54mx28kT384-00015-00016163-00016563": "final gates to", "54mx28kT384-00016-00016564-00016855": "open tomorrow", "54mx28kT384-00017-00016856-00017827": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00018-00017828-00020501": "following the light that sets me", "54mx28kT384-00019-00020502-00022770": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00020-00022771-00024759": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00021-00024760-00025572": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00022-00025573-00026105": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00023-00026106-00026827": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00024-00026829-00026927": "[Applause]", "54mx28kT384-00025-00026929-00030062": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00026-00030063-00030238": "oh", "54mx28kT384-00027-00030239-00031817": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00028-00031818-00033079": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00029-00033080-00034159": "uh", "54mx28kT384-00030-00034160-00034568": "me", "54mx28kT384-00031-00034569-00035239": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00032-00035240-00035510": "[Applause]", "54mx28kT384-00033-00035511-00038207": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00034-00038208-00038401": "oh", "54mx28kT384-00035-00038402-00039527": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00036-00039528-00039857": "is", "54mx28kT384-00037-00039858-00043846": "[Music]", "54mx28kT384-00038-00043847-00044056": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "54sfq3nieyc", "text": {"54sfq3nieyc-00000-00000213-00001909": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00001-00001910-00002245": "the x670e is different from the regular", "54sfq3nieyc-00002-00002246-00002609": "x670 it has more pcie E5 goodness and we", "54sfq3nieyc-00003-00002610-00002771": "have a separate video on that if you", "54sfq3nieyc-00004-00002772-00003342": "want to learn more", "54sfq3nieyc-00005-00003343-00003811": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00006-00003811-00004293": "thank you foreign", "54sfq3nieyc-00007-00004294-00005868": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00008-00005869-00006065": "takes the dual chamber design", "54sfq3nieyc-00009-00006066-00006304": "popularized by other brands and makes it", "54sfq3nieyc-00010-00006305-00006737": "more rugged the gt502 also still has the", "54sfq3nieyc-00011-00006738-00006989": "top straps which is a signature Hallmark", "54sfq3nieyc-00012-00006990-00007325": "of most Asus cases making them easier to", "54sfq3nieyc-00013-00007326-00007920": "carry", "54sfq3nieyc-00014-00007922-00008491": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00015-00008492-00008724": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00016-00008725-00009057": "thank you", "54sfq3nieyc-00017-00009058-00009864": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00018-00009865-00010156": "4080 and 1490 cards have significant", "54sfq3nieyc-00019-00010157-00010378": "performance advantages over the previous", "54sfq3nieyc-00020-00010379-00010691": "30 series generation this card comes", "54sfq3nieyc-00021-00010692-00010841": "with the adapter in case you don't have", "54sfq3nieyc-00022-00010842-00011159": "an ATX 3.0 PSU and it also comes with a", "54sfq3nieyc-00023-00011160-00011435": "very solid GPU support bracket you're", "54sfq3nieyc-00024-00011436-00011759": "going to need it this card's a monster", "54sfq3nieyc-00025-00011760-00012808": "foreign", "54sfq3nieyc-00026-00012809-00015658": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00027-00015659-00015941": "foreign", "54sfq3nieyc-00028-00015941-00016605": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00029-00016606-00019525": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00030-00019526-00019757": "Aces claims to be the first one to have", "54sfq3nieyc-00031-00019758-00019972": "a display on a PSU and I can believe it", "54sfq3nieyc-00032-00019973-00020177": "since they were I think also the first", "54sfq3nieyc-00033-00020178-00020530": "ones to have a display on a on an AIO", "54sfq3nieyc-00034-00020531-00021030": "CPU block with their riogen model", "54sfq3nieyc-00035-00021031-00021235": "thank you", "54sfq3nieyc-00036-00021236-00022319": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00037-00022320-00023369": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00038-00023370-00024385": "baby", "54sfq3nieyc-00039-00024386-00026640": "[Music]", "54sfq3nieyc-00040-00026641-00027067": "fully assembled rigs we clean computers", "54sfq3nieyc-00041-00027068-00027383": "excellent cable management and CPU", "54sfq3nieyc-00042-00027383-00027605": "Cooler repair things are cleaning", "54sfq3nieyc-00043-00027606-00028105": "we also clean and replace gpus", "54sfq3nieyc-00044-00028106-00028596": "and you can also buy from our site", "54sfq3nieyc-00045-00028597-00028937": "www.hwsugar.ph now 100 palagging up to", "54sfq3nieyc-00046-00028938-00029089": "date you inventory", "54sfq3nieyc-00047-00029089-00029452": "items available in society we also ship", "54sfq3nieyc-00048-00029454-00029645": "Nationwide thanks for watching and maybe", "54sfq3nieyc-00049-00029645-00030019": "one of these days mankita ties a shop"}}, {"audio_id": "54MNuZX7nX8", "text": {"54MNuZX7nX8-00000-00000049-00000342": "in mathematics non-euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00001-00000343-00000549": "consists of two geometries based on", "54MNuZX7nX8-00002-00000550-00000726": "axioms closely related to those", "54MNuZX7nX8-00003-00000727-00000974": "specifying Euclidean geometry as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00004-00000975-00001194": "Euclidean geometry lies at the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00005-00001195-00001404": "intersection of metric geometry and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00006-00001405-00001624": "affine geometry non Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00007-00001625-00001823": "arises when either the metric", "54MNuZX7nX8-00008-00001824-00002033": "requirement is relaxed or the parallel", "54MNuZX7nX8-00009-00002034-00002183": "postulate is replaced with an", "54MNuZX7nX8-00010-00002184-00002447": "alternative one in the latter case one", "54MNuZX7nX8-00011-00002448-00002690": "obtains hyperbolic geometry and elliptic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00012-00002691-00002921": "geometry the traditional non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00013-00002922-00003201": "geometries when the metric requirement", "54MNuZX7nX8-00014-00003202-00003390": "is relaxed then there are affine planes", "54MNuZX7nX8-00015-00003390-00003588": "associated with the planar algebra x'", "54MNuZX7nX8-00016-00003589-00003815": "which give rise to kinematic geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00017-00003817-00003975": "that have also been called non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00018-00003976-00004290": "geometry the essential difference", "54MNuZX7nX8-00019-00004291-00004479": "between the metric geometries is the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00020-00004480-00004761": "nature of parallel lines Euclid's fifth", "54MNuZX7nX8-00021-00004762-00004973": "postulate the parallel postulate is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00022-00004974-00005186": "equivalent to playfair's postulate which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00023-00005187-00005372": "states that within a two-dimensional", "54MNuZX7nX8-00024-00005373-00005579": "plane for any given line in a point a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00025-00005580-00005775": "which is not on there is exactly one", "54MNuZX7nX8-00026-00005776-00005943": "line through a that does not intersect", "54MNuZX7nX8-00027-00005944-00006297": "in hyperbolic geometry by contrast there", "54MNuZX7nX8-00028-00006298-00006482": "are infinitely many lines through a not", "54MNuZX7nX8-00029-00006483-00006635": "intersecting while in elliptic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00030-00006636-00007002": "any line through a intersects another", "54MNuZX7nX8-00031-00007003-00007160": "way to describe the differences between", "54MNuZX7nX8-00032-00007161-00007398": "these geometries is to consider two", "54MNuZX7nX8-00033-00007398-00007602": "straight lines indefinitely extended in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00034-00007603-00007784": "a two-dimensional plane that are both", "54MNuZX7nX8-00035-00007786-00008023": "perpendicular to a third line in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00036-00008025-00008295": "Euclidean geometry the lines remain at a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00037-00008296-00008448": "constant distance from each other", "54MNuZX7nX8-00038-00008449-00008658": "meaning that a line drawn perpendicular", "54MNuZX7nX8-00039-00008659-00008849": "to one line at any point will intersect", "54MNuZX7nX8-00040-00008850-00009014": "the other line in the length of the line", "54MNuZX7nX8-00041-00009015-00009162": "segment joining the points of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00042-00009163-00009348": "intersection remains constant and are", "54MNuZX7nX8-00043-00009349-00009617": "known as parallels in hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00044-00009618-00009938": "geometry they curve away from each other", "54MNuZX7nX8-00045-00009939-00010142": "increasing in distance as one moves", "54MNuZX7nX8-00046-00010143-00010289": "further from the points of intersection", "54MNuZX7nX8-00047-00010290-00010494": "with the common perpendicular these", "54MNuZX7nX8-00048-00010495-00010683": "lines are often called ultra parallels", "54MNuZX7nX8-00049-00010684-00011049": "in elliptic geometry the lines curved", "54MNuZX7nX8-00050-00011050-00011603": "toward each other an intersect", "54MNuZX7nX8-00051-00011604-00012084": "topic history", "54MNuZX7nX8-00052-00012085-00012544": "topic background", "54MNuZX7nX8-00053-00012545-00012752": "Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00054-00012753-00012926": "named after the Greek mathematician", "54MNuZX7nX8-00055-00012927-00013127": "Euclid includes some of the oldest known", "54MNuZX7nX8-00056-00013128-00013363": "mathematics and geometries that deviated", "54MNuZX7nX8-00057-00013365-00013553": "from this were not widely accepted as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00058-00013554-00013868": "legitimate until the 19th century the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00059-00013869-00014036": "debate that eventually led to the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00060-00014037-00014191": "discovery of the non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00061-00014193-00014405": "geometries began almost as soon as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00062-00014406-00014579": "Euclid x' work elements was written in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00063-00014580-00014869": "the elements euclid began with a limited", "54MNuZX7nX8-00064-00014870-00015149": "number of assumptions 23 definitions 5", "54MNuZX7nX8-00065-00015150-00015377": "common notions and five postulates and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00066-00015378-00015550": "sought to prove all the other results", "54MNuZX7nX8-00067-00015551-00015805": "propositions in the work the most", "54MNuZX7nX8-00068-00015806-00016007": "notorious of the postulates is often", "54MNuZX7nX8-00069-00016008-00016271": "referred to as Euclid's fifth postulate", "54MNuZX7nX8-00070-00016272-00016630": "or simply the parallel postulate which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00071-00016631-00016949": "in Euclid's original formulation as if a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00072-00016950-00017114": "straight line falls on two straight", "54MNuZX7nX8-00073-00017115-00017321": "lines in such a manner that the interior", "54MNuZX7nX8-00074-00017322-00017489": "angles on the same side are together", "54MNuZX7nX8-00075-00017490-00017690": "less than two right angles than the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00076-00017691-00017882": "straight lines if produced indefinitely", "54MNuZX7nX8-00077-00017883-00018044": "meet on that side on which are the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00078-00018045-00018244": "angles less than the two right angles", "54MNuZX7nX8-00079-00018245-00018500": "other mathematicians have devised", "54MNuZX7nX8-00080-00018501-00018674": "simpler forms of this property", "54MNuZX7nX8-00081-00018675-00018908": "regardless of the form of the postulate", "54MNuZX7nX8-00082-00018909-00019118": "however it consistently appears to be", "54MNuZX7nX8-00083-00019119-00019283": "more complicated than Euclid's other", "54MNuZX7nX8-00084-00019284-00019640": "postulates one to draw a straight line", "54MNuZX7nX8-00085-00019641-00020000": "from any point to any point two to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00086-00020001-00020225": "produce extend a finite straight line", "54MNuZX7nX8-00087-00020226-00020567": "continuously in a straight line three to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00088-00020568-00020753": "describe a circle with any center and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00089-00020754-00021103": "distance radius four that all right", "54MNuZX7nX8-00090-00021104-00021392": "angles are equal to one another for at", "54MNuZX7nX8-00091-00021393-00021590": "least a thousand years geometers were", "54MNuZX7nX8-00092-00021591-00021767": "troubled by the disparate complexity of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00093-00021768-00021938": "the fifth postulate and believed it", "54MNuZX7nX8-00094-00021939-00022084": "could be proved as a theorem from the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00095-00022085-00022369": "other for many attempted to find a proof", "54MNuZX7nX8-00096-00022370-00022555": "by contradiction including even", "54MNuZX7nX8-00097-00022556-00022844": "al-haytham alhazen 11th century Omar", "54MNuZX7nX8-00098-00022845-00023125": "Khayyam 12th century nasir al-din al", "54MNuZX7nX8-00099-00023126-00023408": "tusi 13th century and giovanni Gerolamo", "54MNuZX7nX8-00100-00023409-00023800": "Sakaki 18th century the theorems of eben", "54MNuZX7nX8-00101-00023801-00024014": "al-haytham Khayyam and al tusi on", "54MNuZX7nX8-00102-00024015-00024209": "quadrilaterals including the lambert", "54MNuZX7nX8-00103-00024210-00024425": "quadrilateral and Sakaki quadrilateral", "54MNuZX7nX8-00104-00024426-00024650": "were the first few theorems of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00105-00024651-00024887": "hyperbolic and the elliptic geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00106-00024888-00025094": "these theorems along with their", "54MNuZX7nX8-00107-00025095-00025277": "alternative postulates such as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00108-00025278-00025475": "playfair's axiom played an important", "54MNuZX7nX8-00109-00025476-00025652": "role in the later development of non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00110-00025652-00025802": "Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00111-00025804-00026037": "these early attempts at challenging the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00112-00026038-00026217": "fifth postulate had a considerable", "54MNuZX7nX8-00113-00026218-00026424": "influence on its development among later", "54MNuZX7nX8-00114-00026425-00026667": "European geometers including white a low", "54MNuZX7nX8-00115-00026668-00026961": "Levi Ben Gerson Alphonso John Wallace", "54MNuZX7nX8-00116-00026962-00027233": "and Sakaki all of these early attempts", "54MNuZX7nX8-00117-00027235-00027387": "made it trying to formulate non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00118-00027388-00027602": "Euclidean geometry however provided", "54MNuZX7nX8-00119-00027604-00027810": "flawed proofs of the parallel postulate", "54MNuZX7nX8-00120-00027811-00027960": "containing assumptions that were", "54MNuZX7nX8-00121-00027961-00028145": "essentially equivalent to the parallel", "54MNuZX7nX8-00122-00028147-00028398": "postulate these early attempts did", "54MNuZX7nX8-00123-00028399-00028626": "however provide some early properties of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00124-00028627-00028877": "the hyperbolic and elliptic geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00125-00028877-00029163": "Khayyam for example tried to derive it", "54MNuZX7nX8-00126-00029164-00029316": "from an equivalent postulate he", "54MNuZX7nX8-00127-00029317-00029535": "formulated from the principles of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00128-00029536-00029877": "philosopher Aristotle to convergent", "54MNuZX7nX8-00129-00029877-00030077": "straight lines intersect and it is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00130-00030079-00030308": "impossible for two convergent straight", "54MNuZX7nX8-00131-00030310-00030516": "lines to diverge in the direction in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00132-00030517-00030801": "which they converge Khayyam then", "54MNuZX7nX8-00133-00030802-00031029": "considered the three cases right obtuse", "54MNuZX7nX8-00134-00031030-00031220": "and acute that the summit angles of a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00135-00031222-00031416": "Sakaki quadrilateral can take and after", "54MNuZX7nX8-00136-00031417-00031599": "proving a number of theorems about them", "54MNuZX7nX8-00137-00031600-00031800": "he correctly refuted the obtuse and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00138-00031801-00032013": "acute cases based on his postulate and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00139-00032014-00032195": "hence derived the classic postulate of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00140-00032197-00032364": "Euclid which he didn't realize was", "54MNuZX7nX8-00141-00032364-00032625": "equivalent to his own postulate another", "54MNuZX7nX8-00142-00032626-00032901": "example as out to seize Sun solder Alden", "54MNuZX7nX8-00143-00032902-00033231": "sometimes known as pseudo to see who", "54MNuZX7nX8-00144-00033232-00033450": "wrote a book on the subject in 1298", "54MNuZX7nX8-00145-00033451-00033690": "based on al-tusi slater thoughts which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00146-00033691-00033906": "presented another hypothesis equivalent", "54MNuZX7nX8-00147-00033907-00034128": "to the parallel postulate he essentially", "54MNuZX7nX8-00148-00034129-00034371": "revised both the Euclidian system of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00149-00034372-00034605": "axioms and postulates and the proofs of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00150-00034606-00034932": "many propositions from the elements his", "54MNuZX7nX8-00151-00034933-00035223": "work was published in Rome in 1594 and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00152-00035224-00035409": "was studied by European geometers", "54MNuZX7nX8-00153-00035410-00035631": "including Sakaki who criticized this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00154-00035632-00035838": "work as well as that of Wallace Giordano", "54MNuZX7nX8-00155-00035839-00036090": "Vitale in his book you clydra statue of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00156-00036091-00036486": "1680 1686 used the Sicari quadrilateral", "54MNuZX7nX8-00157-00036487-00036639": "to prove that if three points are", "54MNuZX7nX8-00158-00036640-00036816": "equidistant on the base a b and the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00159-00036817-00037038": "summit c d then a B and C D are", "54MNuZX7nX8-00160-00037039-00037293": "everywhere equidistant in the work", "54MNuZX7nX8-00161-00037294-00037488": "titled Euclid E's ab omni Maeva", "54MNuZX7nX8-00162-00037489-00037569": "vindicate us", "54MNuZX7nX8-00163-00037570-00037806": "Euclid freed from all flaws published in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00164-00037807-00038136": "1733 Sakaki quickly discarded elliptic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00165-00038137-00038364": "geometry as a possibility some others of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00166-00038365-00038592": "Euclid's axioms must be modified for", "54MNuZX7nX8-00167-00038593-00038790": "elliptic geometry to work and set to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00168-00038791-00038955": "work proving a great number of results", "54MNuZX7nX8-00169-00038956-00039171": "in hyperbolic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00170-00039172-00039385": "he finally reached a point where he", "54MNuZX7nX8-00171-00039386-00039561": "believed that his results demonstrated", "54MNuZX7nX8-00172-00039562-00039804": "the impossibility of hyperbolic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00173-00039805-00040062": "his claim seems to have been based on", "54MNuZX7nX8-00174-00040063-00040270": "Euclidean presuppositions because no", "54MNuZX7nX8-00175-00040271-00040495": "logical contradiction was present in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00176-00040496-00040698": "this attempt to prove Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00177-00040699-00040983": "he instead unintentionally discovered a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00178-00040984-00041208": "new viable geometry but did not realize", "54MNuZX7nX8-00179-00041209-00041646": "it in 1766 Johan Lambert wrote but did", "54MNuZX7nX8-00180-00041647-00041842": "not publish theorie der parallel in Ian", "54MNuZX7nX8-00181-00041843-00042054": "in which he attempted as Sakaki did to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00182-00042055-00042295": "prove the fifth postulate he worked with", "54MNuZX7nX8-00183-00042296-00042474": "a figure that today we call a lambert", "54MNuZX7nX8-00184-00042475-00042696": "quadrilateral a quadrilateral with three", "54MNuZX7nX8-00185-00042697-00042895": "right angles can be considered half of a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00186-00042896-00043149": "Sakaki quadrilateral he quickly", "54MNuZX7nX8-00187-00043150-00043329": "eliminated the possibility that the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00188-00043330-00043576": "fourth angle is obtuse as had Sakaki and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00189-00043577-00043779": "Khayyam and then proceeded to prove many", "54MNuZX7nX8-00190-00043780-00043936": "theorems under the assumption of an", "54MNuZX7nX8-00191-00043937-00044012": "acute angle", "54MNuZX7nX8-00192-00044013-00044286": "unlike Sakaki he never felt that he had", "54MNuZX7nX8-00193-00044287-00044433": "reached a contradiction with this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00194-00044434-00044649": "assumption he had proved the non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00195-00044650-00044832": "Euclidean result that the sum of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00196-00044833-00045033": "angles in a triangle increases as the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00197-00045034-00045249": "area of the triangle decreases and this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00198-00045250-00045454": "led him to speculate on the possibility", "54MNuZX7nX8-00199-00045455-00045655": "of a model of the acute case on a sphere", "54MNuZX7nX8-00200-00045656-00045927": "of imaginary radius he did not carry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00201-00045928-00046143": "this idea any further at this time it", "54MNuZX7nX8-00202-00046144-00046311": "was widely believed that the universe", "54MNuZX7nX8-00203-00046312-00046470": "worked according to the principles of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00204-00046471-00046923": "Euclidian geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00205-00046924-00047108": "topic discovery of non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00206-00047109-00047530": "geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00207-00047531-00047773": "the beginning of the 19th century would", "54MNuZX7nX8-00208-00047774-00047980": "finally witness decisive steps in the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00209-00047981-00048329": "creation of non-euclidean geometry circa", "54MNuZX7nX8-00210-00048330-00048574": "1813 carl friedrich gauss and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00211-00048575-00048820": "independently around 1818 the german", "54MNuZX7nX8-00212-00048821-00049001": "professor of law ferdinand carl", "54MNuZX7nX8-00213-00049002-00049192": "Schweickart had the germinal ideas of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00214-00049193-00049408": "non Euclidean geometry worked out but", "54MNuZX7nX8-00215-00049409-00049667": "neither published any results Schweikart", "54MNuZX7nX8-00216-00049668-00049895": "snafu franz tour eNOS did publish", "54MNuZX7nX8-00217-00049896-00050054": "important results of hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00218-00050055-00050385": "trigonometry in two papers in 1825 and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00219-00050386-00050638": "1826 yet while admitting the internal", "54MNuZX7nX8-00220-00050639-00050887": "consistency of hyperbolic geometry he", "54MNuZX7nX8-00221-00050888-00051058": "still believed in the special role of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00222-00051059-00051355": "Euclidean geometry then around 1830 the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00223-00051356-00051604": "Hungarian mathematician Janos Bolyai and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00224-00051605-00051766": "the Russian mathematician Nikolai", "54MNuZX7nX8-00225-00051767-00051976": "Ivanovich Lobachevsky separately", "54MNuZX7nX8-00226-00051977-00052156": "published treatises on hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00227-00052157-00052460": "geometry consequently hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00228-00052461-00052669": "geometry is called ballet Lobachevsky", "54MNuZX7nX8-00229-00052670-00052898": "and geometry as both mathematicians", "54MNuZX7nX8-00230-00052899-00053111": "independent of each other are the basic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00231-00053112-00053404": "authors of non Euclidean geometry Gauss", "54MNuZX7nX8-00232-00053405-00053615": "mentioned to Bali's father when showing", "54MNuZX7nX8-00233-00053616-00053786": "the younger Bali's work that he had", "54MNuZX7nX8-00234-00053787-00054001": "developed such a geometry several years", "54MNuZX7nX8-00235-00054002-00054250": "before though he did not publish while", "54MNuZX7nX8-00236-00054251-00054440": "Lobachevsky created a non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00237-00054441-00054667": "geometry by negating the parallel", "54MNuZX7nX8-00238-00054669-00054856": "postulate Bolly I worked out a geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00239-00054857-00055034": "where both the Euclidean and the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00240-00055035-00055229": "hyperbolic geometry are possible", "54MNuZX7nX8-00241-00055229-00055535": "depending on the parameter K Bolyai ends", "54MNuZX7nX8-00242-00055536-00055697": "his work by mentioning that it is not", "54MNuZX7nX8-00243-00055698-00055904": "possible to decide through mathematical", "54MNuZX7nX8-00244-00055904-00056099": "reasoning alone if the geometry of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00245-00056100-00056297": "physical universe is Euclidean or non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00246-00056298-00056476": "Euclidean this is a task for the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00247-00056477-00056812": "physical sciences bernhard riemann in a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00248-00056813-00057106": "famous lecture in 1854 founded the field", "54MNuZX7nX8-00249-00057107-00057319": "of Riemannian geometry discussing in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00250-00057320-00057493": "particular the ideas now called", "54MNuZX7nX8-00251-00057494-00057762": "manifolds romanian metric and curvature", "54MNuZX7nX8-00252-00057763-00058022": "he constructed an infinite family of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00253-00058023-00058231": "geometries which are not Euclidean by", "54MNuZX7nX8-00254-00058232-00058397": "giving a formula for a family of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00255-00058398-00058594": "romanian metrics on the unit ball in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00256-00058595-00058891": "euclidean space the simplest of these is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00257-00058892-00059080": "called elliptic geometry and it is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00258-00059081-00059210": "considered to be a non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00259-00059211-00059462": "geometry due to its lack of parallel", "54MNuZX7nX8-00260-00059463-00059678": "lines by formulating the geometry in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00261-00059679-00059869": "terms of a curvature tensor riemann", "54MNuZX7nX8-00262-00059870-00060065": "allowed non Euclidean geometry to be", "54MNuZX7nX8-00263-00060066-00060487": "applied to higher dimensions", "54MNuZX7nX8-00264-00060488-00060987": "topic terminology", "54MNuZX7nX8-00265-00060988-00061236": "it was gauss who coined the term non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00266-00061237-00061545": "Euclidean geometry he was referring to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00267-00061546-00061695": "his own work which today we call", "54MNuZX7nX8-00268-00061696-00062013": "hyperbolic geometry several modern", "54MNuZX7nX8-00269-00062014-00062220": "authors still consider non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00270-00062221-00062703": "geometry and hyperbolic geometry to be", "54MNuZX7nX8-00271-00062704-00062997": "synonyms arthur cayley noted that", "54MNuZX7nX8-00272-00062998-00063204": "distance between points inside a conduct", "54MNuZX7nX8-00273-00063204-00063399": "could be defined in terms of logarithm", "54MNuZX7nX8-00274-00063400-00063605": "and the projective cross ratio function", "54MNuZX7nX8-00275-00063607-00063852": "the method has become called the Cayley", "54MNuZX7nX8-00276-00063853-00064014": "Klein metric because felix klein", "54MNuZX7nX8-00277-00064015-00064170": "exploited it to describe the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00278-00064171-00064398": "non-euclidean geometries in articles in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00279-00064399-00064803": "1871 and 73 and later in book form the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00280-00064804-00065007": "Cayley Klein metrics provided working", "54MNuZX7nX8-00281-00065008-00065226": "models of hyperbolic and elliptic metric", "54MNuZX7nX8-00282-00065227-00065516": "geometries as well as Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00283-00065516-00065789": "Klein is responsible for the terms", "54MNuZX7nX8-00284-00065790-00066207": "hyperbolic and elliptic in his system he", "54MNuZX7nX8-00285-00066208-00066486": "called Euclidean geometry parabolic a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00286-00066487-00066786": "term which generally fell out of use his", "54MNuZX7nX8-00287-00066787-00066981": "influence has led to the current usage", "54MNuZX7nX8-00288-00066982-00067245": "of the term non Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00289-00067246-00067653": "to me neither hyperbolic or elliptic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00290-00067654-00067974": "geometry there are some mathematicians", "54MNuZX7nX8-00291-00067975-00068205": "who would extend the list of geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00292-00068206-00068442": "that should be called non Euclidean in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00293-00068443-00068914": "various ways", "54MNuZX7nX8-00294-00068915-00069214": "topic axiomatic basis of non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00295-00069215-00069502": "geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00296-00069503-00069667": "you", "54MNuZX7nX8-00297-00069668-00069947": "Euclidean geometry can be axiomatically", "54MNuZX7nX8-00298-00069948-00070235": "described in several ways unfortunately", "54MNuZX7nX8-00299-00070236-00070424": "Euclid's original system of five", "54MNuZX7nX8-00300-00070425-00070676": "postulates axioms is not one of these as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00301-00070677-00070862": "his proofs relied on several unstated", "54MNuZX7nX8-00302-00070863-00071036": "assumptions which should also have been", "54MNuZX7nX8-00303-00071037-00071303": "taken as axioms Hilbert system", "54MNuZX7nX8-00304-00071304-00071546": "consisting of twenty axioms most closely", "54MNuZX7nX8-00305-00071547-00071717": "follows the approach of Euclid and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00306-00071718-00071912": "provides the justification for all of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00307-00071913-00072206": "Euclid's proofs other systems using", "54MNuZX7nX8-00308-00072207-00072416": "different sets of undefined terms obtain", "54MNuZX7nX8-00309-00072417-00072632": "the same geometry by different paths in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00310-00072633-00072935": "all approaches however there is an axiom", "54MNuZX7nX8-00311-00072936-00073091": "which is logically equivalent to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00312-00073092-00073286": "Euclid's fifth postulate the parallel", "54MNuZX7nX8-00313-00073287-00073556": "postulate Hilbert uses the Playfair", "54MNuZX7nX8-00314-00073557-00073781": "axiom form while Birkhoff for instance", "54MNuZX7nX8-00315-00073782-00073994": "uses the axiom which says that there", "54MNuZX7nX8-00316-00073995-00074198": "exists a pair of similar but not", "54MNuZX7nX8-00317-00074199-00074474": "congruent triangles in any of these", "54MNuZX7nX8-00318-00074475-00074681": "systems removal of the one axiom which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00319-00074682-00074894": "is equivalent to the parallel postulate", "54MNuZX7nX8-00320-00074895-00075095": "in whatever form it takes and leaving", "54MNuZX7nX8-00321-00075096-00075305": "all the other axioms intact produces", "54MNuZX7nX8-00322-00075306-00075560": "absolute geometry as the first", "54MNuZX7nX8-00323-00075561-00075764": "twenty-eight propositions of Euclid in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00324-00075765-00075950": "the elements do not require the use of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00325-00075951-00076121": "the parallel postulate or anything", "54MNuZX7nX8-00326-00076122-00076295": "equivalent to they are all true", "54MNuZX7nX8-00327-00076296-00076505": "statements in absolute geometry to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00328-00076506-00076724": "obtain a non Euclidean geometry the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00329-00076725-00076889": "parallel postulate or its equivalent", "54MNuZX7nX8-00330-00076890-00077113": "must be replaced by its negation", "54MNuZX7nX8-00331-00077114-00077402": "negating the playfair's axiom form since", "54MNuZX7nX8-00332-00077403-00077654": "it is a compound statement", "54MNuZX7nX8-00333-00077655-00077987": "there exists one and only one", "54MNuZX7nX8-00334-00077988-00078256": "can be done in two ways either there", "54MNuZX7nX8-00335-00078257-00078422": "will exist more than one line through", "54MNuZX7nX8-00336-00078423-00078605": "the point parallel to the given line or", "54MNuZX7nX8-00337-00078606-00078749": "there will exist no lines through the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00338-00078750-00079004": "point parallel to the given line in the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00339-00079005-00079199": "first case replacing the parallel", "54MNuZX7nX8-00340-00079200-00079375": "postulate or its equivalent with the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00341-00079376-00079646": "statement in a plane given a point P and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00342-00079647-00079859": "a line not passing through P there", "54MNuZX7nX8-00343-00079860-00080087": "exists two lines through P which do not", "54MNuZX7nX8-00344-00080088-00080399": "meet and keeping all the other axioms", "54MNuZX7nX8-00345-00080400-00080741": "yields hyperbolic geometry the second", "54MNuZX7nX8-00346-00080742-00080996": "case is not dealt with as easily simply", "54MNuZX7nX8-00347-00080997-00081187": "replacing the parallel postulate with", "54MNuZX7nX8-00348-00081188-00081455": "the statement in a plane given a point P", "54MNuZX7nX8-00349-00081456-00081700": "and a line not passing through P all the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00350-00081701-00081982": "lines through P meet does not give a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00351-00081983-00082247": "consistent set of axioms this follows", "54MNuZX7nX8-00352-00082248-00082468": "since parallel lines exist in absolute", "54MNuZX7nX8-00353-00082469-00082673": "geometry but this statement says that", "54MNuZX7nX8-00354-00082674-00082949": "there are no parallel lines this problem", "54MNuZX7nX8-00355-00082950-00083087": "was known in a different guise to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00356-00083088-00083336": "Khayyam Sakaki and lambert and was the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00357-00083337-00083504": "basis for their rejecting what was known", "54MNuZX7nX8-00358-00083505-00083857": "as the obtuse angle case in order to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00359-00083858-00084082": "obtain a consistent set of axioms which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00360-00084083-00084272": "includes this axiom about having no", "54MNuZX7nX8-00361-00084273-00084485": "parallel lines some of the other axioms", "54MNuZX7nX8-00362-00084486-00084746": "must be tweaked the adjustments to be", "54MNuZX7nX8-00363-00084747-00084971": "made depend upon the axiom system being", "54MNuZX7nX8-00364-00084972-00085247": "used among others these tweaks will have", "54MNuZX7nX8-00365-00085248-00085448": "the effect of modifying Euclid's second", "54MNuZX7nX8-00366-00085449-00085622": "postulate from the statement that line", "54MNuZX7nX8-00367-00085623-00085837": "segments can be extended indefinitely to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00368-00085838-00086031": "the statement that lines are unbounded", "54MNuZX7nX8-00369-00086032-00086309": "Riemann's elliptic geometry emerges as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00370-00086310-00086524": "the most natural geometry satisfying", "54MNuZX7nX8-00371-00086525-00086890": "this axiom", "54MNuZX7nX8-00372-00086891-00087556": "topic models of non Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00373-00087557-00087835": "two dimensional Euclidean geometry is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00374-00087836-00088387": "modeled by our notion of a flat plane", "54MNuZX7nX8-00375-00088388-00088914": "topic elliptic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00376-00088915-00089124": "the simplest model for elliptic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00377-00089125-00089391": "is a sphere where lines are great", "54MNuZX7nX8-00378-00089392-00089661": "circles such as the equator or the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00379-00089662-00089871": "meridians on a globe and points opposite", "54MNuZX7nX8-00380-00089872-00090060": "each other called antipodal points are", "54MNuZX7nX8-00381-00090061-00090249": "identified considered to be the same", "54MNuZX7nX8-00382-00090250-00090525": "this is also one of the standard models", "54MNuZX7nX8-00383-00090526-00090744": "of the real projective plane the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00384-00090745-00090888": "difference is that as a model of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00385-00090889-00091116": "elliptic geometry a metric is introduced", "54MNuZX7nX8-00386-00091117-00091272": "permitting the measurement of lengths", "54MNuZX7nX8-00387-00091273-00091434": "and angles while is a model of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00388-00091435-00091638": "projective plane there is no such metric", "54MNuZX7nX8-00389-00091639-00091947": "in the elliptic model for any given line", "54MNuZX7nX8-00390-00091948-00092163": "and a point a which is not on all lines", "54MNuZX7nX8-00391-00092164-00092650": "through a will intersect", "54MNuZX7nX8-00392-00092651-00093179": "topic hyperbolic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00393-00093180-00093471": "even after the work of Lobachevsky gauss", "54MNuZX7nX8-00394-00093472-00093719": "and bali i the question remained does", "54MNuZX7nX8-00395-00093720-00093918": "such a model exist for hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00396-00093919-00094215": "geometry the model for hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00397-00094216-00094434": "geometry was answered by a uhany o", "54MNuZX7nX8-00398-00094435-00094740": "Beltrami in 1868 who first showed that a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00399-00094741-00094931": "surface called the pseudo sphere has the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00400-00094932-00095142": "appropriate curvature to model a portion", "54MNuZX7nX8-00401-00095143-00095337": "of hyperbolic space and in a second", "54MNuZX7nX8-00402-00095338-00095541": "paper in the same year defined the Klein", "54MNuZX7nX8-00403-00095542-00095721": "model which models the entirety of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00404-00095722-00095931": "hyperbolic space and used this to show", "54MNuZX7nX8-00405-00095932-00096141": "that euclidean geometry and hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00406-00096142-00096342": "geometry were equi consistent so that", "54MNuZX7nX8-00407-00096343-00096546": "hyperbolic geometry was logically", "54MNuZX7nX8-00408-00096547-00096743": "consistent if and only if Euclidian", "54MNuZX7nX8-00409-00096744-00097031": "geometry was the reverse implication", "54MNuZX7nX8-00410-00097032-00097215": "follows from the Horace fear model of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00411-00097216-00097518": "Euclidean geometry in the hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00412-00097519-00097761": "model within a two-dimensional plane for", "54MNuZX7nX8-00413-00097762-00097974": "any given line in a point a which is not", "54MNuZX7nX8-00414-00097975-00098138": "on there are infinitely many lines", "54MNuZX7nX8-00415-00098139-00098432": "through a that do not intersect in these", "54MNuZX7nX8-00416-00098433-00098615": "models the concepts of non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00417-00098616-00098831": "geometries are being represented by", "54MNuZX7nX8-00418-00098832-00099066": "euclidean objects in a Euclidean setting", "54MNuZX7nX8-00419-00099067-00099368": "this introduces a perceptual distortion", "54MNuZX7nX8-00420-00099369-00099522": "wherein the straight lines of the non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00421-00099523-00099759": "Euclidean geometry are being represented", "54MNuZX7nX8-00422-00099760-00099975": "by euclidean curves which visually Bend", "54MNuZX7nX8-00423-00099976-00100350": "this bending is not a property of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00424-00100351-00100578": "non Euclidean lines only an artifice of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00425-00100579-00100997": "the way they are being represented", "54MNuZX7nX8-00426-00100998-00101252": "topic 3 dimensional non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00427-00101253-00101677": "geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00428-00101678-00101878": "in three dimensions there are eight", "54MNuZX7nX8-00429-00101879-00102022": "models of geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00430-00102023-00102208": "there are euclidean elliptic and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00431-00102209-00102417": "hyperbolic geometries as in the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00432-00102418-00102652": "2-dimensional case mixed geometries that", "54MNuZX7nX8-00433-00102653-00102874": "are partially euclidean and partially", "54MNuZX7nX8-00434-00102875-00103119": "hyperbolic or spherical twisted versions", "54MNuZX7nX8-00435-00103120-00103321": "of the mixed geometries and one unusual", "54MNuZX7nX8-00436-00103322-00103591": "geometry that is completely anisotropic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00437-00103592-00104159": "ie every direction behaves differently", "54MNuZX7nX8-00438-00104160-00104498": "topic uncommon properties", "54MNuZX7nX8-00439-00104499-00104699": "you", "54MNuZX7nX8-00440-00104700-00104954": "Euclidean and non-euclidean geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00441-00104955-00105170": "naturally have many similar properties", "54MNuZX7nX8-00442-00105171-00105377": "namely those which do not depend upon", "54MNuZX7nX8-00443-00105378-00105593": "the nature of parallelism this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00444-00105594-00105811": "commonality is the subject of absolute", "54MNuZX7nX8-00445-00105813-00106069": "geometry also called neutral geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00446-00106070-00106346": "however the properties which distinguish", "54MNuZX7nX8-00447-00106347-00106520": "one geometry from the others are the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00448-00106521-00106682": "ones which have historically received", "54MNuZX7nX8-00449-00106683-00106822": "the most attention", "54MNuZX7nX8-00450-00106823-00107054": "besides the behavior of lines with", "54MNuZX7nX8-00451-00107055-00107236": "respect to a common perpendicular", "54MNuZX7nX8-00452-00107238-00107417": "mentioned in the introduction we also", "54MNuZX7nX8-00453-00107418-00107659": "have the following a Lambert", "54MNuZX7nX8-00454-00107660-00107858": "quadrilateral is a quadrilateral which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00455-00107858-00108136": "has three right angles the fourth angle", "54MNuZX7nX8-00456-00108138-00108350": "of a Lambert quadrilateral is acute if", "54MNuZX7nX8-00457-00108351-00108583": "the geometry is hyperbolic a right angle", "54MNuZX7nX8-00458-00108584-00108779": "if the geometry is Euclidian or obtuse", "54MNuZX7nX8-00459-00108780-00109118": "if the geometry is elliptic consequently", "54MNuZX7nX8-00460-00109119-00109364": "rectangles exist a statement equivalent", "54MNuZX7nX8-00461-00109365-00109538": "to the parallel postulate only in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00462-00109539-00109820": "Euclidean geometry a Sakaki", "54MNuZX7nX8-00463-00109821-00110033": "quadrilateral is a quadrilateral which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00464-00110033-00110213": "has two sides of equal length both", "54MNuZX7nX8-00465-00110214-00110422": "perpendicular to a side called the base", "54MNuZX7nX8-00466-00110423-00110678": "the other two angles of a Sakaki", "54MNuZX7nX8-00467-00110679-00110836": "quadrilateral are called the summit", "54MNuZX7nX8-00468-00110838-00111095": "angles and they have equal measure the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00469-00111096-00111320": "summit angles of a Sakaki quadrilateral", "54MNuZX7nX8-00470-00111321-00111530": "are acute if the geometry is hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00471-00111531-00111725": "right angles if the geometry is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00472-00111726-00111926": "Euclidean and obtuse angles if the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00473-00111927-00112214": "geometry is elliptic the sum of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00474-00112215-00112382": "measures of the angles of any triangle", "54MNuZX7nX8-00475-00112383-00112655": "is less than 180 degrees if the geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00476-00112656-00112991": "is hyperbolic equal to 180 degrees if", "54MNuZX7nX8-00477-00112992-00113189": "the geometry is Euclidean and greater", "54MNuZX7nX8-00478-00113190-00113444": "than 180 degrees if the geometry is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00479-00113445-00113738": "elliptic the defect of a triangle is the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00480-00113739-00114026": "numerical value 180 degrees some of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00481-00114027-00114183": "measures of the angles of the triangle", "54MNuZX7nX8-00482-00114184-00114458": "this result may also be stated as the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00483-00114458-00114658": "defect of triangles in hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00484-00114659-00114886": "geometry is positive the defect of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00485-00114888-00115133": "triangles in Euclidean geometry is zero", "54MNuZX7nX8-00486-00115133-00115352": "and the defect of triangles in elliptic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00487-00115353-00115833": "geometry is negative", "54MNuZX7nX8-00488-00115833-00116280": "topic importance", "54MNuZX7nX8-00489-00116281-00116469": "before the models of a non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00490-00116470-00116733": "plane were presented by Beltrami Klein", "54MNuZX7nX8-00491-00116733-00116984": "and Poincare a Euclidean geometry stood", "54MNuZX7nX8-00492-00116985-00117180": "unchallenged as the mathematical model", "54MNuZX7nX8-00493-00117181-00117477": "of space furthermore since the substance", "54MNuZX7nX8-00494-00117478-00117705": "of the subject in synthetic geometry was", "54MNuZX7nX8-00495-00117706-00117894": "a chief exhibit of rationality the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00496-00117895-00118092": "Euclidean point of view represented", "54MNuZX7nX8-00497-00118093-00118392": "absolute authority the discovery of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00498-00118393-00118596": "non-euclidean geometries had a ripple", "54MNuZX7nX8-00499-00118597-00118758": "effect which went far beyond the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00500-00118758-00118940": "boundaries of mathematics and science", "54MNuZX7nX8-00501-00118941-00119238": "the philosopher Immanuel Kant treatment", "54MNuZX7nX8-00502-00119239-00119418": "of human knowledge had a special role", "54MNuZX7nX8-00503-00119419-00119514": "for geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00504-00119515-00119802": "it was his prime example of synthetic a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00505-00119803-00119988": "priori knowledge not derived from the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00506-00119989-00120195": "senses nor deduced through logic our", "54MNuZX7nX8-00507-00120196-00120429": "knowledge of space was a truth that we", "54MNuZX7nX8-00508-00120430-00120693": "were born with unfortunately for Conte", "54MNuZX7nX8-00509-00120694-00120903": "his concept of this unalterably true", "54MNuZX7nX8-00510-00120904-00121233": "geometry was Euclidian theology was also", "54MNuZX7nX8-00511-00121233-00121416": "affected by the change from absolute", "54MNuZX7nX8-00512-00121417-00121605": "truth to relative truth in the way that", "54MNuZX7nX8-00513-00121606-00121776": "mathematics is related to the world", "54MNuZX7nX8-00514-00121777-00121947": "around it that was a result of this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00515-00121948-00122208": "paradigm shift non Euclidean geometry is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00516-00122208-00122442": "an example of a scientific revolution in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00517-00122443-00122592": "the history of science in which", "54MNuZX7nX8-00518-00122593-00122802": "mathematicians and scientists changed", "54MNuZX7nX8-00519-00122803-00123048": "the way they view their subjects some", "54MNuZX7nX8-00520-00123049-00123245": "geometers called Lobachevsky the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00521-00123246-00123540": "Copernicus of geometry due to the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00522-00123541-00123741": "revolutionary character of his work the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00523-00123742-00123972": "existence of non-euclidean geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00524-00123973-00124143": "impacted the intellectual life of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00525-00124144-00124338": "Victorian England in many ways and in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00526-00124339-00124479": "particular was one of the leading", "54MNuZX7nX8-00527-00124480-00124707": "factors that caused a reexamination of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00528-00124708-00124883": "the teaching of geometry based on", "54MNuZX7nX8-00529-00124884-00125157": "Euclid's elements this curriculum issue", "54MNuZX7nX8-00530-00125158-00125364": "was hotly debated at the time and was", "54MNuZX7nX8-00531-00125365-00125561": "even the subject of a book Euclid and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00532-00125563-00125754": "his modern rivals written by Charles", "54MNuZX7nX8-00533-00125755-00126099": "Lutwidge Dodgson 1832 to 1898 better", "54MNuZX7nX8-00534-00126100-00126291": "known as Lewis Carroll the author of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00535-00126292-00126697": "Alice in Wonderland", "54MNuZX7nX8-00536-00126698-00127250": "topic planar algebra", "54MNuZX7nX8-00537-00127251-00127490": "in analytic geometry a plane is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00538-00127491-00128058": "described with Cartesian coordinates see", "54MNuZX7nX8-00539-00128058-00128561": "topic X Y X Y element of the points are", "54MNuZX7nX8-00540-00128562-00128753": "sometimes identified with complex", "54MNuZX7nX8-00541-00128754-00129204": "numbers Z", "54MNuZX7nX8-00542-00129205-00129549": "X plus y epsilon where epsilon - element", "54MNuZX7nX8-00543-00129550-00129912": "of - 1 0 1 the Euclidean plane", "54MNuZX7nX8-00544-00129913-00130179": "corresponds to the case epsilon 2 equals", "54MNuZX7nX8-00545-00130180-00130413": "minus 1 since the modulus of Z is given", "54MNuZX7nX8-00546-00130414-00131903": "by z z equals x plus y e x - y ee equals", "54MNuZX7nX8-00547-00131904-00132825": "x2 + y2 display style ZZ carrot asked", "54MNuZX7nX8-00548-00132826-00133128": "equals x plus y epsilon XY epsilon", "54MNuZX7nX8-00549-00133129-00133545": "equals x carrot 2 + y carrot 2 and this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00550-00133546-00133693": "quantity is the square of the Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00551-00133694-00134040": "distance between z and the origin for", "54MNuZX7nX8-00552-00134041-00134379": "instance z ZZ asterisk equals 1 is the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00553-00134380-00134691": "unit circle for planar algebra non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00554-00134692-00134907": "Euclidean geometry arises in the other", "54MNuZX7nX8-00555-00134908-00135303": "cases when epsilon 2 equals plus 1 then", "54MNuZX7nX8-00556-00135304-00135507": "Z is a split complex number and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00557-00135508-00135993": "conventionally J replaces Epsilon then Z", "54MNuZX7nX8-00558-00135994-00137657": "Z equals X plus y J X minus y J equals X", "54MNuZX7nX8-00559-00137658-00138435": "2 minus y 2 this playstyles easy carat", "54MNuZX7nX8-00560-00138436-00138870": "asked equals x plus y math bfj XY math b", "54MNuZX7nX8-00561-00138871-00139410": "FJ equals x carat 2 y carat 2 and z ZZ", "54MNuZX7nX8-00562-00139411-00139709": "asterisk equals 1 is the unit hyperbola", "54MNuZX7nX8-00563-00139710-00140076": "when epsilon 2 equals 0 then Z is a dual", "54MNuZX7nX8-00564-00140077-00140245": "number this approach to non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00565-00140246-00140470": "geometry explains the non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00566-00140471-00140709": "angles the parameters of slope in the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00567-00140710-00140895": "dual number plane and hyperbolic angle", "54MNuZX7nX8-00568-00140896-00141135": "in the split complex plane correspond to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00569-00141136-00141445": "angle in Euclidean geometry indeed they", "54MNuZX7nX8-00570-00141446-00141660": "each arise in polar decomposition of a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00571-00141661-00142090": "complex number z", "54MNuZX7nX8-00572-00142091-00142668": "topic kinematic geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00573-00142669-00142910": "hyperbolic geometry found an application", "54MNuZX7nX8-00574-00142911-00143114": "in kinematics with the physical", "54MNuZX7nX8-00575-00143115-00143295": "cosmology introduced by Hermann", "54MNuZX7nX8-00576-00143296-00143658": "Minkowski in 1908 Minkowski introduced", "54MNuZX7nX8-00577-00143659-00143861": "terms like world line and proper time", "54MNuZX7nX8-00578-00143862-00144113": "into mathematical physics he realized", "54MNuZX7nX8-00579-00144114-00144311": "that the sub manifold of events one", "54MNuZX7nX8-00580-00144312-00144473": "moment of proper time into the future", "54MNuZX7nX8-00581-00144474-00144696": "could be considered a hyperbolic space", "54MNuZX7nX8-00582-00144697-00145076": "of three dimensions already in the 1890s", "54MNuZX7nX8-00583-00145077-00145274": "Alexander McFarland was charting this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00584-00145275-00145451": "sub manifold through his algebra of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00585-00145452-00145671": "physics and hyperbolic quaternions the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00586-00145672-00145877": "MacFarlane did not use cosmological", "54MNuZX7nX8-00587-00145878-00146201": "language as Minkowski did in 1908 the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00588-00146202-00146370": "relevant structure is now called the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00589-00146371-00146645": "hyperboloid model of hyperbolic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00590-00146646-00146972": "the non Euclidean planar algebra support", "54MNuZX7nX8-00591-00146973-00147212": "kinematic geometries in the plane for", "54MNuZX7nX8-00592-00147213-00147425": "instance the split complex numbers Z", "54MNuZX7nX8-00593-00147426-00147665": "equals e AJ can represent a spacetime", "54MNuZX7nX8-00594-00147666-00147890": "event one moment into the future of a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00595-00147891-00148087": "frame of reference of rapidity a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00596-00148088-00148376": "furthermore multiplication by Z amounts", "54MNuZX7nX8-00597-00148377-00148545": "to a Lorentz boost mapping the frame", "54MNuZX7nX8-00598-00148546-00148733": "with rapidity zero to that with rapidity", "54MNuZX7nX8-00599-00148734-00149063": "a kinematic study makes use of the dual", "54MNuZX7nX8-00600-00149064-00149423": "numbers Z equals x plus y ee2 equals", "54MNuZX7nX8-00601-00149424-00149735": "zero display style z equals x plus y", "54MNuZX7nX8-00602-00149736-00150008": "epsilon quod epsilon Karen two equals", "54MNuZX7nX8-00603-00150009-00150195": "zero to represent the classical", "54MNuZX7nX8-00604-00150196-00150396": "description of motion in absolute time", "54MNuZX7nX8-00605-00150397-00150671": "and space the equations x equals x plus", "54MNuZX7nX8-00606-00150672-00151058": "VT t equals t display style X Charat", "54MNuZX7nX8-00607-00151059-00151376": "prime equals x plus VT quantity carrot", "54MNuZX7nX8-00608-00151377-00151616": "prime equals t are equivalent to a shear", "54MNuZX7nX8-00609-00151617-00151934": "mapping in linear algebra XT equals 1 vo", "54MNuZX7nX8-00610-00151935-00152315": "1 XT display style begin P matrix X T", "54MNuZX7nX8-00611-00152316-00152675": "and P matrix equals begin P matrix 1 and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00612-00152676-00152963": "V zero and one end P matrix begin P", "54MNuZX7nX8-00613-00152964-00153437": "matrix X T and P matrix with dual", "54MNuZX7nX8-00614-00153438-00154153": "numbers the mapping is T plus X e equals", "54MNuZX7nX8-00615-00154154-00154313": "1", "54MNuZX7nX8-00616-00154314-00155719": "plus v ET plus ex e equals T plus X plus", "54MNuZX7nX8-00617-00155720-00156323": "V T AE displaced idle T caret prime plus", "54MNuZX7nX8-00618-00156324-00156632": "X Karen prime epsilon equals 1 plus V", "54MNuZX7nX8-00619-00156633-00156968": "epsilon T plus X epsilon equals T plus X", "54MNuZX7nX8-00620-00156969-00157358": "plus V T Epsilon another view of special", "54MNuZX7nX8-00621-00157359-00157528": "relativity as a non Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00622-00157529-00157808": "was advanced by EB Wilson and Gilbert", "54MNuZX7nX8-00623-00157809-00157994": "Lewis in Proceedings of the American", "54MNuZX7nX8-00624-00157995-00158252": "Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1912", "54MNuZX7nX8-00625-00158253-00158483": "they revamped the analytic geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00626-00158484-00158735": "implicit in the split complex number", "54MNuZX7nX8-00627-00158736-00158939": "algebra into synthetic geometry of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00628-00158940-00159381": "premises and deductions", "54MNuZX7nX8-00629-00159382-00159895": "topic fiction", "54MNuZX7nX8-00630-00159896-00160121": "non-euclidean geometry often makes", "54MNuZX7nX8-00631-00160122-00160310": "appearances in works of science fiction", "54MNuZX7nX8-00632-00160311-00160757": "and fantasy in 1895 HG Wells published", "54MNuZX7nX8-00633-00160758-00161009": "the short story the remarkable case of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00634-00161010-00161345": "Davidson's eyes to appreciate this story", "54MNuZX7nX8-00635-00161346-00161543": "one should know how antipodal points on", "54MNuZX7nX8-00636-00161544-00161732": "a sphere are identified in a model of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00637-00161733-00161999": "the elliptic plane in the story in the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00638-00162000-00162164": "midst of the thunderstorm Sidney", "54MNuZX7nX8-00639-00162165-00162419": "Davidson sees waves and a remarkably", "54MNuZX7nX8-00640-00162420-00162656": "neat schooner while working in an", "54MNuZX7nX8-00641-00162657-00162833": "electrical laboratory at Harlow", "54MNuZX7nX8-00642-00162834-00163066": "Technical College at the story's close", "54MNuZX7nX8-00643-00163067-00163324": "Davidson proves to have witnessed HMS", "54MNuZX7nX8-00644-00163325-00163641": "foamer off Antipodes Island", "54MNuZX7nX8-00645-00163642-00163874": "non-euclidean geometry is sometimes", "54MNuZX7nX8-00646-00163875-00164072": "connected with the influence of the 20th", "54MNuZX7nX8-00647-00164073-00164273": "century horror fiction writer HP", "54MNuZX7nX8-00648-00164274-00164558": "Lovecraft in his works many unnatural", "54MNuZX7nX8-00649-00164559-00164777": "things follow their own unique laws of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00650-00164778-00165004": "geometry in Lovecraft's Cthulhu Mythos", "54MNuZX7nX8-00651-00165005-00165188": "the sunken city of R'lyeh is", "54MNuZX7nX8-00652-00165189-00165371": "characterized by its non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00653-00165372-00165653": "geometry it is heavily implied this as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00654-00165654-00165818": "achieved as a side-effect of not", "54MNuZX7nX8-00655-00165819-00165971": "following the natural laws of this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00656-00165972-00166163": "universe rather than simply using an", "54MNuZX7nX8-00657-00166164-00166366": "alternate geometric model as the sheer", "54MNuZX7nX8-00658-00166367-00166526": "innate wrongness of it is said to be", "54MNuZX7nX8-00659-00166527-00166706": "capable of driving those who look upon", "54MNuZX7nX8-00660-00166707-00167039": "it insane the main character in robert /", "54MNuZX7nX8-00661-00167040-00167159": "six zen and the art of motorcycle", "54MNuZX7nX8-00662-00167160-00167375": "maintenance mentioned Riemannian", "54MNuZX7nX8-00663-00167376-00167699": "geometry on multiple occasions in The", "54MNuZX7nX8-00664-00167700-00167803": "Brothers Karamazov", "54MNuZX7nX8-00665-00167804-00168004": "Dostoyevsky discusses non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00666-00168005-00168303": "geometry through his main character Ivan", "54MNuZX7nX8-00667-00168304-00168536": "Christopher priest's novel inverted", "54MNuZX7nX8-00668-00168537-00168725": "world describes the struggle of living", "54MNuZX7nX8-00669-00168726-00168920": "on a planet with the form of a rotating", "54MNuZX7nX8-00670-00168921-00169193": "pseudo sphere Robert Heinlein's the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00671-00169194-00169361": "number of the beast utilizes non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00672-00169362-00169550": "Euclidean geometry to explain", "54MNuZX7nX8-00673-00169551-00169745": "instantaneous transport through space", "54MNuZX7nX8-00674-00169746-00169934": "and time and between parallel and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00675-00169935-00170264": "fictional universes Alexander Bruce's", "54MNuZX7nX8-00676-00170265-00170465": "antechamber uses non Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00677-00170466-00170716": "to create a minimal assure like world", "54MNuZX7nX8-00678-00170717-00170909": "where geometry and space follow", "54MNuZX7nX8-00679-00170910-00171224": "unfamiliar rules Zeno rogue's hyper", "54MNuZX7nX8-00680-00171225-00171415": "rogue as a roguelike game set on the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00681-00171416-00171611": "hyperbolic plane allowing the player to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00682-00171612-00171806": "experience many properties of this", "54MNuZX7nX8-00683-00171807-00172106": "geometry many mechanics quests and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00684-00172107-00172322": "locations are strongly dependent on the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00685-00172323-00172634": "features of hyperbolic geometry in the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00686-00172635-00172847": "renegade Legion science-fiction setting", "54MNuZX7nX8-00687-00172848-00173099": "for FA essays war game role-playing game", "54MNuZX7nX8-00688-00173100-00173220": "and fiction fast", "54MNuZX7nX8-00689-00173221-00173421": "than light travel and communications as", "54MNuZX7nX8-00690-00173422-00173595": "possible through the use of che hosed", "54MNuZX7nX8-00691-00173596-00173847": "poly dimensional non-euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00692-00173848-00174027": "published sometime in the middle of the", "54MNuZX7nX8-00693-00174028-00174390": "22nd century in Ian Stuart's flatland", "54MNuZX7nX8-00694-00174391-00174633": "the protagonist Victoria line visits all", "54MNuZX7nX8-00695-00174634-00174945": "kinds of non-euclidean worlds", "54MNuZX7nX8-00696-00174946-00175185": "in John Pierre Pettit's here is looking", "54MNuZX7nX8-00697-00175186-00175347": "at Euclid and not looking at Euclid", "54MNuZX7nX8-00698-00175348-00175518": "Archibald Higgins stumbles upon", "54MNuZX7nX8-00699-00175519-00175857": "spherical geometry on the SCP foundation", "54MNuZX7nX8-00700-00175858-00176106": "wiki there are some contained objects", "54MNuZX7nX8-00701-00176107-00176418": "SCPs involving non-euclidean geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00702-00176419-00176883": "such as scp-186 that'll ow the user to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00703-00176884-00177033": "create their own non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00704-00177034-00177411": "geometries SCP 419 a window to an urban", "54MNuZX7nX8-00705-00177412-00177654": "landscape with non-euclidean geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00706-00177655-00177993": "an SCP 2 to 8 to a mammal similar to a", "54MNuZX7nX8-00707-00177994-00178197": "goat whose digestive tract is an array", "54MNuZX7nX8-00708-00178198-00178673": "of non-euclidean distortions", "54MNuZX7nX8-00709-00178674-00179205": "topic see also", "54MNuZX7nX8-00710-00179206-00179580": "hyperbolic space Lonard sphere", "54MNuZX7nX8-00711-00179581-00180045": "projective geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00712-00180046-00180548": "topic notes", "54MNuZX7nX8-00713-00180549-00181068": "topic references", "54MNuZX7nX8-00714-00181069-00181332": "Ocampo Norbert and Papadopoulos", "54MNuZX7nX8-00715-00181333-00181614": "Anthony's 2012 notes on hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00716-00181615-00181866": "geometry in Strasbourg masterclass on", "54MNuZX7nX8-00717-00181867-00181938": "geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00718-00181939-00182271": "pp 1 to 182 Burma lectures in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00719-00182272-00182427": "mathematics and theoretical physics", "54MNuZX7nX8-00720-00182428-00182769": "volume 18 suruc european mathematical", "54MNuZX7nX8-00721-00182770-00183249": "society ms 461 pages ISBN nine seven", "54MNuZX7nX8-00722-00183250-00183504": "eight three oh three seven one nine one", "54MNuZX7nX8-00723-00183505-00184101": "oh five seven doy 10.4 171 105 anderson", "54MNuZX7nX8-00724-00184102-00184380": "james w hyperbolic geometry second", "54MNuZX7nX8-00725-00184381-00184809": "edition springer 2005 Beltrami a uhany", "54MNuZX7nX8-00726-00184810-00185073": "OT oriya fundamental degli spa ZD", "54MNuZX7nX8-00727-00185074-00185417": "curvature accost Andi Annalee d-mat sr22", "54MNuZX7nX8-00728-00185418-00186033": "1868 232 to 255 Blumenthal Leonard M", "54MNuZX7nX8-00729-00186034-00186360": "1980 a modern view of geometry new york", "54MNuZX7nX8-00730-00186361-00186705": "dover ISBN oh four eight six six three", "54MNuZX7nX8-00731-00186706-00187125": "nine six two - Carol Lewis Euclid and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00732-00187126-00187341": "his modern rivals New York Barnes &", "54MNuZX7nX8-00733-00187342-00187698": "Noble 2009 reprint ISBN nine seven eight", "54MNuZX7nX8-00734-00187699-00187956": "one four three five one two three four", "54MNuZX7nX8-00735-00187957-00188390": "eight nine HSM coxeter 1942", "54MNuZX7nX8-00736-00188391-00188652": "non-euclidean geometry University of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00737-00188653-00188928": "Toronto press reissued 1998 by", "54MNuZX7nX8-00738-00188929-00189198": "mathematical association of america ISBN", "54MNuZX7nX8-00739-00189199-00189483": "o eight eight three eight five five two", "54MNuZX7nX8-00740-00189484-00189912": "two four Faber richard l 1983", "54MNuZX7nX8-00741-00189913-00190101": "foundations of Euclidean and non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00742-00190102-00190344": "Euclidean geometry New York Marcel", "54MNuZX7nX8-00743-00190345-00190683": "Dekker is BN o eight two four seven one", "54MNuZX7nX8-00744-00190684-00191127": "seven four eight one Jeremy gray 1989", "54MNuZX7nX8-00745-00191128-00191376": "ideas of space Euclidean non Euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00746-00191377-00191610": "and relativistic second edition", "54MNuZX7nX8-00747-00191611-00191949": "Clarendon press greenberg Marvin J", "54MNuZX7nX8-00748-00191950-00192183": "Euclidean and non-euclidean geometries", "54MNuZX7nX8-00749-00192184-00192459": "development and history 4th ed New York", "54MNuZX7nX8-00750-00192460-00192978": "WH Freeman 2007 ISBN o seven one six", "54MNuZX7nX8-00751-00192979-00193344": "seven nine nine four eight Oh Morris", "54MNuZX7nX8-00752-00193345-00193662": "klein 1972 mathematical thought from", "54MNuZX7nX8-00753-00193663-00193797": "ancient to modern times", "54MNuZX7nX8-00754-00193798-00194226": "chapter 36 non-euclidean geometry pp 861", "54MNuZX7nX8-00755-00194227-00194443": "281 Oxford University", "54MNuZX7nX8-00756-00194444-00194866": "Press Bernard H Lavin de 2012 a new", "54MNuZX7nX8-00757-00194867-00195133": "perspective on relativity an odyssey in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00758-00195134-00195445": "non-euclidean geometries world", "54MNuZX7nX8-00759-00195446-00196042": "scientific PP 696 ISBN nine trillion 789", "54MNuZX7nX8-00760-00196043-00196357": "billion 814 million three hundred forty", "54MNuZX7nX8-00761-00196358-00196572": "thousand four hundred eighty nine", "54MNuZX7nX8-00762-00196573-00196930": "nikolai Lobachevsky 2010 pan geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00763-00196931-00197173": "translator and editor a Papadopoulos", "54MNuZX7nX8-00764-00197174-00197416": "heritage of european mathematics series", "54MNuZX7nX8-00765-00197417-00197644": "volume four European mathematical", "54MNuZX7nX8-00766-00197645-00198076": "society Manning Henry Parker 1963", "54MNuZX7nX8-00767-00198077-00198343": "introductory non-euclidean geometry new", "54MNuZX7nX8-00768-00198344-00198778": "york Dover mesh Kowski herbert 1964", "54MNuZX7nX8-00769-00198779-00199063": "non-euclidean geometry New York Academic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00770-00199064-00199513": "Press Milner John W 1982 hyperbolic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00771-00199514-00199930": "geometry the first 150 years bull Amer", "54MNuZX7nX8-00772-00199931-00200568": "math SOC NS volume 6 number 1 PP 9 to 24", "54MNuZX7nX8-00773-00200569-00200950": "Richards jonell 1988 mathematical", "54MNuZX7nX8-00774-00200951-00201154": "visions the pursuit of geometry in", "54MNuZX7nX8-00775-00201155-00201409": "Victorian England Boston academic press", "54MNuZX7nX8-00776-00201410-00201751": "ISBN Oh one two five eight seven four", "54MNuZX7nX8-00777-00201752-00202273": "four five six smart James R 1997 modern", "54MNuZX7nX8-00778-00202274-00202504": "geometries 5th ed Pacific Grove", "54MNuZX7nX8-00779-00202505-00202816": "brooks/cole is B and O five three four", "54MNuZX7nX8-00780-00202817-00203161": "three five one eight eight three Stewart", "54MNuZX7nX8-00781-00203162-00203266": "Ian flat Erland", "54MNuZX7nX8-00782-00203267-00203728": "New York Perseus publishing 2001 ISBN o", "54MNuZX7nX8-00783-00203729-00204162": "seven three eight 206 7 5 X softcover", "54MNuZX7nX8-00784-00204163-00204520": "John Stillwell 1996 sources of", "54MNuZX7nX8-00785-00204521-00204718": "hyperbolic geometry american", "54MNuZX7nX8-00786-00204719-00205048": "mathematical society is B and O eight to", "54MNuZX7nX8-00787-00205048-00205419": "one eight oh five to nine o trudeau", "54MNuZX7nX8-00788-00205421-00205741": "Richard J 1987 the non-euclidean", "54MNuZX7nX8-00789-00205742-00206116": "revolution Boston birkhäuser ISBN Oh 8 1", "54MNuZX7nX8-00790-00206117-00206611": "7 6 3 3 1 1 1 a Papadopoulos at", "54MNuZX7nX8-00791-00206612-00206890": "guillaume tear a 2014 led thierry de", "54MNuZX7nX8-00792-00206891-00207082": "parallelize d johann heinrich lambert", "54MNuZX7nX8-00793-00207083-00207307": "critical edition of Lambert's memoir", "54MNuZX7nX8-00794-00207308-00207463": "with a French translation with", "54MNuZX7nX8-00795-00207464-00207673": "historical and mathematical notes and", "54MNuZX7nX8-00796-00207673-00207789": "commentaries 8", "54MNuZX7nX8-00797-00207790-00208086": "Blanchard call Sciences Dan's l'histoire", "54MNuZX7nX8-00798-00208087-00208380": "Paris ISBN nine seven eight two eight", "54MNuZX7nX8-00799-00208381-00209037": "five three six seven two six six five", "54MNuZX7nX8-00800-00209038-00209813": "topic external links Roberto bunola 1912", "54MNuZX7nX8-00801-00209814-00210069": "non-euclidean geometry open court", "54MNuZX7nX8-00802-00210069-00210432": "Chicago mactutor archive article on non", "54MNuZX7nX8-00803-00210433-00210571": "Euclidean geometry", "54MNuZX7nX8-00804-00210573-00211105": "non Euclidean geometry at planetmath.org", "54MNuZX7nX8-00805-00211106-00211302": "non-euclidean geometries from", "54MNuZX7nX8-00806-00211303-00211716": "encyclopedia of mathematics and springer", "54MNuZX7nX8-00807-00211717-00212033": "science plus business media synthetic", "54MNuZX7nX8-00808-00212034-00212277": "space-time a digest of the axioms used", "54MNuZX7nX8-00809-00212278-00212540": "and theorems proved by Wilson and Lewis", "54MNuZX7nX8-00810-00212541-00212913": "archived by website"}}, {"audio_id": "54P95QRSPVg", "text": {"54P95QRSPVg-00000-00000000-00000209": "University Police Department and this is", "54P95QRSPVg-00001-00000210-00000515": "assistant chief Don Daniels and I do", "54P95QRSPVg-00002-00000516-00000671": "have a recorder going", "54P95QRSPVg-00003-00000672-00000790": "all right", "54P95QRSPVg-00004-00000791-00001012": "let's just State for the record it is", "54P95QRSPVg-00005-00001013-00001139": "now", "54P95QRSPVg-00006-00001140-00001403": "for all", "54P95QRSPVg-00007-00001404-00001558": "9", "54P95QRSPVg-00008-00001559-00001817": "00 pm on December", "54P95QRSPVg-00009-00001818-00002195": "30 2022 this is Whitman County Supreme", "54P95QRSPVg-00010-00002196-00002452": "Court Judge Gary leiby on the record", "54P95QRSPVg-00011-00002453-00002752": "um and uh and uh would you please", "54P95QRSPVg-00012-00002753-00002968": "identify yourselves and I'll place you", "54P95QRSPVg-00013-00002969-00003142": "around your oath if you whoever's going", "54P95QRSPVg-00014-00003143-00003353": "to testify about this this assistant", "54P95QRSPVg-00015-00003354-00003611": "assistant chief Don Daniels with WSU", "54P95QRSPVg-00016-00003611-00003767": "Police Department", "54P95QRSPVg-00017-00003768-00004169": "okay would you uh please uh uh State and", "54P95QRSPVg-00018-00004170-00004343": "spell your name for the record", "54P95QRSPVg-00019-00004344-00004883": "it's Dawn d-a-w-n Daniels d-a-n-i-e-l-s", "54P95QRSPVg-00020-00004884-00005147": "and the officer would you please raise", "54P95QRSPVg-00021-00005148-00005381": "your right hand uh do you swear or", "54P95QRSPVg-00022-00005382-00005663": "reform the following testimony will be", "54P95QRSPVg-00023-00005664-00005843": "true yes I do", "54P95QRSPVg-00024-00005844-00006106": "all right please proceed okay", "54P95QRSPVg-00025-00006107-00006341": "on one two three zero two two while", "54P95QRSPVg-00026-00006342-00006751": "serving a search warrant number", "54P95QRSPVg-00027-00006752-00007067": "sw12292022a for Steptoe apartment g201", "54P95QRSPVg-00028-00007068-00007396": "we found a padlock round in shape in the", "54P95QRSPVg-00029-00007397-00007619": "living room closet based on my training", "54P95QRSPVg-00030-00007620-00007817": "experience I recognize the padlock to be", "54P95QRSPVg-00031-00007818-00007996": "the shape of locks typically used on", "54P95QRSPVg-00032-00007997-00008260": "storage units the lock is round in shape", "54P95QRSPVg-00033-00008261-00008495": "and the design limits the ability for", "54P95QRSPVg-00034-00008496-00008681": "somebody to cut the lock off", "54P95QRSPVg-00035-00008682-00008867": "a key matching the lock was also found", "54P95QRSPVg-00036-00008868-00009083": "in the living room in the TV stand next", "54P95QRSPVg-00037-00009084-00009274": "to the Keys which appeared to be for the", "54P95QRSPVg-00038-00009275-00009473": "Wilson short office which we also have a", "54P95QRSPVg-00039-00009474-00009628": "search warrant for", "54P95QRSPVg-00040-00009629-00009814": "I had officer kirschner contact the", "54P95QRSPVg-00041-00009815-00009983": "apartment coordinator who confirmed", "54P95QRSPVg-00042-00009984-00010199": "there are storage closets available to", "54P95QRSPVg-00043-00010200-00010427": "Residents located in some of the", "54P95QRSPVg-00044-00010428-00010667": "buildings or excuse me they're located", "54P95QRSPVg-00045-00010668-00010841": "in the same buildings as the laundry", "54P95QRSPVg-00046-00010842-00011038": "areas", "54P95QRSPVg-00047-00011039-00011333": "Sergeant Pat lemony went to the area and", "54P95QRSPVg-00048-00011334-00011524": "confirmed there's a storage closet with", "54P95QRSPVg-00049-00011525-00011842": "the address g201 written in black marker", "54P95QRSPVg-00050-00011843-00012119": "on the work on the wood door the storage", "54P95QRSPVg-00051-00012120-00012383": "closet is located in building f as in", "54P95QRSPVg-00052-00012384-00012599": "Frank of Steptoe Apartments", "54P95QRSPVg-00053-00012600-00012815": "the storage door is not locked and the", "54P95QRSPVg-00054-00012816-00013024": "door is slightly ajarred", "54P95QRSPVg-00055-00013025-00013229": "I believe the storage", "54P95QRSPVg-00056-00013230-00013565": "unit or closet was likely used by", "54P95QRSPVg-00057-00013566-00013901": "co-burger to store the items and likely", "54P95QRSPVg-00058-00013902-00014135": "access between the time of the murders", "54P95QRSPVg-00059-00014136-00014308": "and has traveled to Pennsylvania where", "54P95QRSPVg-00060-00014309-00014435": "he was later", "54P95QRSPVg-00061-00014436-00014699": "arrested it is also believed the storage", "54P95QRSPVg-00062-00014700-00014921": "closet could contain", "54P95QRSPVg-00063-00014922-00015172": "or contains certain trace evidence", "54P95QRSPVg-00064-00015173-00015527": "listed in number one and number five of", "54P95QRSPVg-00065-00015528-00015719": "evidence to be seized in the above name", "54P95QRSPVg-00066-00015719-00015888": "search warrant", "54P95QRSPVg-00067-00015890-00015965": "[Music]", "54P95QRSPVg-00068-00015966-00016072": "um", "54P95QRSPVg-00069-00016073-00016427": "I can read those to you number one", "54P95QRSPVg-00070-00016428-00016655": "is blood or other bodily fluid or human", "54P95QRSPVg-00071-00016656-00016871": "tissue or skin cells or items with blood", "54P95QRSPVg-00072-00016872-00017147": "or other bodily or humans tissue or skin", "54P95QRSPVg-00073-00017148-00017333": "cells on the items", "54P95QRSPVg-00074-00017334-00017585": "number five trace evidence including DNA", "54P95QRSPVg-00075-00017586-00017777": "from blutter skin cells or other source", "54P95QRSPVg-00076-00017778-00018065": "Footprints fingerprints hair whether", "54P95QRSPVg-00077-00018066-00018485": "human or animal or dog", "54P95QRSPVg-00078-00018486-00018772": "I asked the judge do you find this there", "54P95QRSPVg-00079-00018773-00018911": "to be probable cause to believe the", "54P95QRSPVg-00080-00018912-00019085": "items", "54P95QRSPVg-00081-00019086-00019330": "excuse me do you find there's probable", "54P95QRSPVg-00082-00019331-00019529": "cause to believe these items may be", "54P95QRSPVg-00083-00019530-00019727": "found in the storage unit", "54P95QRSPVg-00084-00019728-00019955": "and do you authorize the", "54P95QRSPVg-00085-00019956-00020249": "search of the unit", "54P95QRSPVg-00086-00020250-00020489": "okay thank you officer okay the court", "54P95QRSPVg-00087-00020490-00020657": "here by fines are here's probable cause", "54P95QRSPVg-00088-00020658-00020800": "to", "54P95QRSPVg-00089-00020801-00020953": "search the", "54P95QRSPVg-00090-00020954-00021247": "foreshead described storage unit for", "54P95QRSPVg-00091-00021248-00021643": "items as representing search warrant and", "54P95QRSPVg-00092-00021644-00021863": "there's probable cause in the court", "54P95QRSPVg-00093-00021864-00022303": "hereby authorizes you to sign my name", "54P95QRSPVg-00094-00022304-00022758": "Gary J leiby on a search warrant", "54P95QRSPVg-00095-00022759-00023135": "to enter the four described storage", "54P95QRSPVg-00096-00023136-00023255": "facility", "54P95QRSPVg-00097-00023256-00023608": "okay I have signed your name", "54P95QRSPVg-00098-00023609-00023953": "and it is", "54P95QRSPVg-00099-00023954-00024436": "in James l-i-b-e-y correct", "54P95QRSPVg-00100-00024437-00024707": "all right is there anything else officer", "54P95QRSPVg-00101-00024708-00024791": "to you", "54P95QRSPVg-00102-00024792-00025013": "currently that's all I have", "54P95QRSPVg-00103-00025014-00025222": "all right all right so then we will", "54P95QRSPVg-00104-00025223-00025457": "conclude this hearing you may terminate", "54P95QRSPVg-00105-00025458-00025631": "the recording and please maintain and", "54P95QRSPVg-00106-00025632-00025900": "keep the recording for reference uh for", "54P95QRSPVg-00107-00025901-00026146": "the Whitman County prosecutor in any", "54P95QRSPVg-00108-00026147-00026588": "other agency thank you thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "54U_UF4uGkU", "text": {"54U_UF4uGkU-00000-00000021-00000272": "the following is a list of United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00001-00000273-00000521": "Nations resolutions concerning Israel as", "54U_UF4uGkU-00002-00000522-00000896": "of 2013 Israel had been condemned in 45", "54U_UF4uGkU-00003-00000897-00001141": "resolutions by the United Nations Human", "54U_UF4uGkU-00004-00001142-00001424": "Rights Council since the creation of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00005-00001425-00001739": "council in 2006 it has resolved almost", "54U_UF4uGkU-00006-00001739-00001955": "more resolutions condemning Israel than", "54U_UF4uGkU-00007-00001955-00002132": "on the rest of the world combined", "54U_UF4uGkU-00008-00002133-00002506": "the 45 resolutions comprised almost half", "54U_UF4uGkU-00009-00002507-00002785": "45.9% of all country specific", "54U_UF4uGkU-00010-00002786-00003005": "resolutions passed by the council not", "54U_UF4uGkU-00011-00003006-00003203": "counting those under agenda item 10", "54U_UF4uGkU-00012-00003204-00003469": "countries requiring technical assistance", "54U_UF4uGkU-00013-00003470-00003944": "from 1967 to 1989 the UN Security", "54U_UF4uGkU-00014-00003945-00004306": "Council adopted 131 resolutions directly", "54U_UF4uGkU-00015-00004307-00004529": "addressing the arab-israeli conflict in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00016-00004530-00004777": "early Security Council practice", "54U_UF4uGkU-00017-00004778-00005002": "resolutions did not directly invoke", "54U_UF4uGkU-00018-00005003-00005254": "chapter 7 they made an explicit", "54U_UF4uGkU-00019-00005255-00005470": "determination of a threat breach of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00020-00005471-00005666": "peace or act of aggression and ordered", "54U_UF4uGkU-00021-00005667-00005900": "an action in accordance with article 39", "54U_UF4uGkU-00022-00005901-00006254": "or 40 resolution 54 determined that a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00023-00006255-00006425": "threat to peace existed within the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00024-00006426-00006644": "meaning of article 39 of the Charter", "54U_UF4uGkU-00025-00006645-00006839": "reiterated the need for a truce and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00026-00006840-00007058": "ordered a ceasefire pursuant to article", "54U_UF4uGkU-00027-00007059-00007317": "40 of the Charter although the phrase", "54U_UF4uGkU-00028-00007318-00007639": "acting under Chapter 7 was never", "54U_UF4uGkU-00029-00007640-00007792": "mentioned as the basis for the action", "54U_UF4uGkU-00030-00007793-00008035": "taken the chapter's Authority was being", "54U_UF4uGkU-00031-00008036-00008237": "used the United Nations General Assembly", "54U_UF4uGkU-00032-00008238-00008467": "has adopted a number of resolutions", "54U_UF4uGkU-00033-00008468-00008660": "saying that the strategic relationship", "54U_UF4uGkU-00034-00008661-00008876": "with the United States encourages Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00035-00008877-00009062": "to pursue aggressive and expansionist", "54U_UF4uGkU-00036-00009063-00009317": "policies and practices the ninth", "54U_UF4uGkU-00037-00009318-00009491": "emergency session of the General", "54U_UF4uGkU-00038-00009492-00009695": "Assembly was convened at the request of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00039-00009696-00009910": "the Security Council when the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00040-00009911-00010060": "States blocked efforts to adopt", "54U_UF4uGkU-00041-00010061-00010349": "sanctions against Israel the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00042-00010350-00010520": "States responded to the frequent", "54U_UF4uGkU-00043-00010521-00010766": "criticism from UN organs by adopting the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00044-00010767-00010958": "Negroponte doctrine of opposing any", "54U_UF4uGkU-00045-00010959-00011203": "Security Council resolutions criticizing", "54U_UF4uGkU-00046-00011204-00011387": "Israel that did not also denounce", "54U_UF4uGkU-00047-00011388-00012155": "Palestinian militant activity topic", "54U_UF4uGkU-00048-00012156-00012395": "United Nations General Assembly", "54U_UF4uGkU-00049-00012396-00012894": "resolutions", "54U_UF4uGkU-00050-00012894-00013516": "1947 November 29th 1947 resolution 181", "54U_UF4uGkU-00051-00013516-00013719": "recommending partition of the British", "54U_UF4uGkU-00052-00013720-00013927": "Mandate for Palestine into Arab and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00053-00013928-00014119": "Jewish states and international status", "54U_UF4uGkU-00054-00014119-00014450": "for the city of Jerusalem 0.194 8", "54U_UF4uGkU-00055-00014451-00014883": "December 11th resolution 194 establishes", "54U_UF4uGkU-00056-00014884-00015094": "conciliation commission protection of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00057-00015094-00015286": "and free access to Jerusalem and other", "54U_UF4uGkU-00058-00015287-00015519": "holy places resolves that the refugees", "54U_UF4uGkU-00059-00015520-00015697": "wishing to return to their homes and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00060-00015697-00015805": "live at peace with their neighbors", "54U_UF4uGkU-00061-00015806-00015997": "should be permitted to do so at the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00062-00015997-00016165": "earliest practicable date and that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00063-00016166-00016338": "compensation should be paid for the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00064-00016340-00016530": "property of those choosing not to return", "54U_UF4uGkU-00065-00016531-00016696": "and for loss of or damage to property", "54U_UF4uGkU-00066-00016697-00016888": "which under principles of international", "54U_UF4uGkU-00067-00016889-00017110": "law or in equity should be made good by", "54U_UF4uGkU-00068-00017111-00017250": "the governments or authorities", "54U_UF4uGkU-00069-00017251-00017828": "responsible 1949 may eleventh resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00070-00017829-00018127": "273 admission of Israel to membership in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00071-00018128-00018594": "the UN December 9th resolution 303 IV", "54U_UF4uGkU-00072-00018595-00018855": "international regime for Jerusalem", "54U_UF4uGkU-00073-00018856-00018994": "December 10th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00074-00018995-00019624": "resolution 356 Jerusalem 1950 December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00075-00019625-00020022": "14th resolution 468 reduces financing", "54U_UF4uGkU-00076-00020023-00020349": "for an international regime in Jerusalem", "54U_UF4uGkU-00077-00020350-00020944": "1952 January 26th resolution 512 report", "54U_UF4uGkU-00078-00020945-00021139": "of the United Nations consolation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00079-00021140-00021321": "Commission for Palestine", "54U_UF4uGkU-00080-00021322-00021819": "December 21st Resolution 619 takes note", "54U_UF4uGkU-00081-00021820-00022072": "of Israel's complaint against Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00082-00022073-00022600": "ceasefire violations 1956 November", "54U_UF4uGkU-00083-00022601-00022936": "second resolution 997 called for an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00084-00022937-00023155": "immediate ceasefire in the Suez Crisis", "54U_UF4uGkU-00085-00023156-00023350": "an arms embargo on the area and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00086-00023351-00023566": "condemned Israel's participation in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00087-00023567-00023812": "conflict as a violation of the 1949", "54U_UF4uGkU-00088-00023813-00024114": "Israel Egypt general armistice agreement", "54U_UF4uGkU-00089-00024115-00024519": "November 4th resolution 998 called for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00090-00024520-00024715": "the secretary-general to submit a plan", "54U_UF4uGkU-00091-00024716-00024940": "for a United Nations peacekeeping force", "54U_UF4uGkU-00092-00024941-00025171": "to secure and supervise a ceasefire in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00093-00025172-00025549": "the Suez Crisis November 4th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00094-00025550-00025797": "999 reaffirmed UN General Assembly", "54U_UF4uGkU-00095-00025798-00026194": "resolution 997 no", "54U_UF4uGkU-00096-00026195-00026508": "member v resolution 1000 UN force for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00097-00026510-00026989": "Sinai November 7th resolution 1001 UN", "54U_UF4uGkU-00098-00026989-00027377": "force for Sinai November 7th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00099-00027379-00027682": "1002 calls for an unconditional Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00100-00027683-00027876": "withdrawal from the Sinai", "54U_UF4uGkU-00101-00027877-00028270": "November 10th resolution 1003 the Suez", "54U_UF4uGkU-00102-00028270-00028756": "Crisis November 24th resolution 1120 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00103-00028757-00029170": "suez crisis November 24th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00104-00029170-00029635": "1121 the suez crisis November 26th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00105-00029636-00030100": "resolution 1122 the suez crisis November", "54U_UF4uGkU-00106-00030101-00030418": "26th resolution 1089 regarding the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00107-00030419-00030825": "United Nations emergency force UN EF", "54U_UF4uGkU-00108-00030826-00031330": "1957 January 19th resolution 11:23 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00109-00031331-00031716": "Suez Crisis february second resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00110-00031717-00032149": "1124 the suez crisis february second", "54U_UF4uGkU-00111-00032150-00032620": "resolution 1125 the suez crisis February", "54U_UF4uGkU-00112-00032620-00033078": "22nd resolution 11:26 the suez crisis", "54U_UF4uGkU-00113-00033079-00033409": "February 27th resolution 1090", "54U_UF4uGkU-00114-00033410-00033546": "administrative and financial", "54U_UF4uGkU-00115-00033547-00033970": "arrangements for the UN EF November 22nd", "54U_UF4uGkU-00116-00033971-00034636": "resolution 1151 UN EF 1958 August 21st", "54U_UF4uGkU-00117-00034637-00034960": "resolution 1237 the situation in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00118-00034961-00035076": "Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00119-00035077-00035562": "November 14th resolution 1263 UN EF", "54U_UF4uGkU-00120-00035563-00035947": "December 13th resolution 1337 cost", "54U_UF4uGkU-00121-00035948-00036445": "estimates for the UN EF 1959 December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00122-00036446-00036931": "5th resolution 1441 UN EF December 5th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00123-00036932-00037204": "resolution 1442 approvement of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00124-00037205-00037411": "major-general Gianni as commander of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00125-00037412-00038152": "UN EF 1960 December 20th resolution 1575", "54U_UF4uGkU-00126-00038153-00038637": "cost estimates for the UN EF 1961", "54U_UF4uGkU-00127-00038638-00039022": "December 20th resolution 1733 cost", "54U_UF4uGkU-00128-00039023-00039321": "estimates for the UN EF 9", "54U_UF4uGkU-00129-00039322-00040031": "1062 December 20th resolution 1864 une F", "54U_UF4uGkU-00130-00040032-00040485": "1963 June 27th UN Special Assembly", "54U_UF4uGkU-00131-00040486-00040989": "resolution 1874 June 27th un special", "54U_UF4uGkU-00132-00040990-00041448": "assembly resolution 1875 December 17th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00133-00041449-00042168": "resolution 1983 une F 1965 December 21st", "54U_UF4uGkU-00134-00042169-00042972": "resolution 2115 une F 1966 December 16th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00135-00042973-00043767": "resolution 2194 une F 1967 July 4th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00136-00043768-00044057": "resolution 2252", "54U_UF4uGkU-00137-00044058-00044435": "humanitarian assistance in the 1967 war", "54U_UF4uGkU-00138-00044436-00044976": "July 4th resolution 2253 sv condemns", "54U_UF4uGkU-00139-00044977-00045156": "Israel's measures to change the status", "54U_UF4uGkU-00140-00045157-00045335": "of Jerusalem as invalid", "54U_UF4uGkU-00141-00045336-00045905": "July 14th resolution 2254 deplores", "54U_UF4uGkU-00142-00045906-00046200": "Israel's failure to abide by UN General", "54U_UF4uGkU-00143-00046201-00046799": "Assembly resolution 2253 sv July 21st", "54U_UF4uGkU-00144-00046800-00047232": "resolution 2256 the situation in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00145-00047233-00047339": "Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00146-00047340-00047808": "September 18th resolution 2257 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00147-00047809-00048114": "situation in the Middle East December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00148-00048115-00048796": "13th resolution 2,304 une f 1968", "54U_UF4uGkU-00149-00048797-00049223": "December 19th resolution 2443", "54U_UF4uGkU-00150-00049224-00049419": "establishes the special committee to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00151-00049420-00049653": "investigate Israeli practices affecting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00152-00049654-00049821": "the human rights of the Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-00153-00049822-00049955": "people", "54U_UF4uGkU-00154-00049956-00050559": "1969 December 11th resolution 2546", "54U_UF4uGkU-00155-00050560-00050826": "condemns Israeli violations of human", "54U_UF4uGkU-00156-00050827-00051150": "rights and fundamental freedoms in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00157-00051151-00051641": "occupied territories 1970 November 4th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00158-00051642-00052014": "resolution 2000 628 urges the speedy", "54U_UF4uGkU-00159-00052015-00052232": "implementation of UN Security Council", "54U_UF4uGkU-00160-00052233-00052557": "resolution 242 and recognizes that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00161-00052558-00052701": "respect for the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00162-00052702-00052878": "rights of the Palestinians is an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00163-00052879-00053037": "indisputable element in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00164-00053038-00053204": "establishment of a just and lasting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00165-00053205-00053658": "peace in the Middle East December 5th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00166-00053659-00054048": "resolution 2727 calls on Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00167-00054049-00054254": "implement the recommendations of the UN", "54U_UF4uGkU-00168-00054255-00054467": "Special Committee investigating Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00169-00054469-00054716": "practices in the occupied territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00170-00054716-00055221": "December 15th resolution 2728 report of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00171-00055222-00055344": "the special committee to investigate", "54U_UF4uGkU-00172-00055345-00055578": "Israeli practices affecting the human", "54U_UF4uGkU-00173-00055579-00055791": "rights of the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00174-00055791-00056432": "territories 1971 December 6th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00175-00056433-00056883": "2792 UN rwa report calls for the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00176-00056884-00057063": "implementation of UN General Assembly", "54U_UF4uGkU-00177-00057064-00057467": "resolution 194 stresses the inalienable", "54U_UF4uGkU-00178-00057469-00057752": "rights of the people of Palestine and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00179-00057753-00058038": "calls on Israel to stop resettling the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00180-00058039-00058352": "inhabitants of Palestinian refugee camps", "54U_UF4uGkU-00181-00058353-00058839": "December 13th resolution 2799 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00182-00058840-00059148": "situation in the Middle East December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00183-00059149-00059562": "20th resolution 2851 report of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00184-00059563-00059772": "special committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00185-00059773-00059976": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00186-00059977-00060129": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00187-00060129-00060435": "territories condemns Israeli practices", "54U_UF4uGkU-00188-00060436-00060878": "in the occupied territories 1972", "54U_UF4uGkU-00189-00060879-00061314": "December 8th resolution 2949 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00190-00061315-00061623": "situation in the Middle East December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00191-00061624-00061683": "15th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00192-00061684-00061989": "resolution 3005 report of the special", "54U_UF4uGkU-00193-00061990-00062157": "committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00194-00062158-00062358": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00195-00062359-00062511": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00196-00062512-00063077": "territories 1973 December 7th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00197-00063078-00063357": "3090 to report of the special committee", "54U_UF4uGkU-00198-00063358-00063552": "to investigate Israeli practices", "54U_UF4uGkU-00199-00063553-00063708": "affecting the human rights of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00200-00063709-00063977": "population of the occupied territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00201-00063978-00064458": "December 11th resolution 3101 financing", "54U_UF4uGkU-00202-00064459-00065045": "of the UN EF December 17th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00203-00065046-00065313": "3,175 permanent sovereignty over natural", "54U_UF4uGkU-00204-00065314-00065502": "resources in the occupied Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00205-00065503-00066018": "territories 1974 October 31", "54U_UF4uGkU-00206-00066019-00066410": "first in November 29th resolution 3211", "54U_UF4uGkU-00207-00066411-00066678": "financing of the UN EF and the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00208-00066679-00066930": "Nations disengagement observer force UN", "54U_UF4uGkU-00209-00066931-00067497": "DOF November 29th resolution 3,240", "54U_UF4uGkU-00210-00067498-00067662": "report of the special committee to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00211-00067663-00067896": "investigate Israeli practices affecting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00212-00067897-00068079": "the human rights of the population of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00213-00068080-00068436": "the occupied territories November 29th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00214-00068437-00068868": "resolution 3246 affirms the legitimacy", "54U_UF4uGkU-00215-00068869-00069072": "of armed resistance by oppressed peoples", "54U_UF4uGkU-00216-00069073-00069195": "in pursuit of the right to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00217-00069196-00069366": "self-determination and condemns", "54U_UF4uGkU-00218-00069367-00069525": "governments which do not support that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00219-00069526-00070011": "right December 9th resolution 3263", "54U_UF4uGkU-00220-00070012-00070203": "calling for an establishment of a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00221-00070204-00070395": "nuclear weapon-free zone in the Middle", "54U_UF4uGkU-00222-00070396-00070478": "East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00223-00070479-00071007": "December 17th resolution 3336 permanent", "54U_UF4uGkU-00224-00071008-00071205": "sovereignty over national resources in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00225-00071206-00071663": "the occupied Arab territories 1975", "54U_UF4uGkU-00226-00071664-00071997": "October 30th November 28 and December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00227-00071998-00072480": "2nd resolution 3374 financing of the UN", "54U_UF4uGkU-00228-00072481-00072888": "EF and the UN dof November 10th United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00229-00072889-00073064": "Nations General Assembly resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00230-00073065-00073565": "3,000 379 equating Zionism with racism", "54U_UF4uGkU-00231-00073566-00074034": "December 5th resolution 3414 calls for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00232-00074035-00074205": "economic sanctions and an arms embargo", "54U_UF4uGkU-00233-00074206-00074445": "on Israel until it withdraws from all", "54U_UF4uGkU-00234-00074446-00074763": "territories occupied in 1967 and grants", "54U_UF4uGkU-00235-00074764-00074942": "the Palestinians their inalienable", "54U_UF4uGkU-00236-00074943-00075524": "national rights December 11th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00237-00075525-00075807": "3470 for calling for an establishment of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00238-00075808-00076011": "a nuclear weapon-free zone in the Middle", "54U_UF4uGkU-00239-00076012-00076263": "East December 15th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00240-00076264-00076659": "resolution 3516 permanent sovereignty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00241-00076660-00076869": "over national resources in the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00242-00076870-00077178": "Arab territories December 15th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00243-00077179-00077607": "resolution 3525 report of the special", "54U_UF4uGkU-00244-00077608-00077775": "committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00245-00077776-00077979": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00246-00077980-00078132": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00247-00078133-00078576": "territories 1976 Nova", "54U_UF4uGkU-00248-00078577-00078915": "ninth resolution 31 6c condemnation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00249-00078916-00079092": "the collaboration of Israel and South", "54U_UF4uGkU-00250-00079093-00079572": "Africa November 24th resolution 31 xx", "54U_UF4uGkU-00251-00079573-00079830": "expresses deep concern that no just", "54U_UF4uGkU-00252-00079831-00080247": "solution to the problem of Palestine has", "54U_UF4uGkU-00253-00080248-00080448": "been achieved refers to the problem as", "54U_UF4uGkU-00254-00080449-00080622": "the core of the Middle East conflict and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00255-00080623-00080954": "reaffirms the inalienable rights are the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00256-00080955-00081171": "Palestinians including the right of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00257-00081172-00081330": "return and the right to national", "54U_UF4uGkU-00258-00081331-00081684": "independence December 1st resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00259-00081685-00081963": "thirty-one fifths financing of the UN EF", "54U_UF4uGkU-00260-00081964-00082356": "and the UN dof December 9th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00261-00082357-00082665": "31 60 firsts reaffirms previous condemn", "54U_UF4uGkU-00262-00082666-00082851": "nations of Israel and calls for the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00263-00082852-00083088": "Security Council to take effective", "54U_UF4uGkU-00264-00083089-00083370": "measures against Israel and request", "54U_UF4uGkU-00265-00083371-00083549": "sanctions on Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00266-00083550-00083919": "December 9th resolution 31 60 seconds", "54U_UF4uGkU-00267-00083920-00084105": "calls for an international Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00268-00084106-00084291": "peace conference under the auspices of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00269-00084292-00084513": "the UN and co-chaired by the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00270-00084514-00084861": "States and Soviet Union December 10th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00271-00084862-00085155": "resolution 31 70 firsts calling for an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00272-00085156-00085329": "establishment of a nuclear weapon-free", "54U_UF4uGkU-00273-00085330-00085523": "zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00274-00085524-00085923": "December 16th resolution 31 100 sixths", "54U_UF4uGkU-00275-00085924-00086085": "report of the special committee to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00276-00086086-00086322": "investigate Israeli practices affecting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00277-00086323-00086478": "the human rights of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00278-00086479-00087020": "territories December 21st resolution 31", "54U_UF4uGkU-00279-00087021-00087300": "186 permanent sovereignty over national", "54U_UF4uGkU-00280-00087301-00087495": "resources in the occupied Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00281-00087496-00088044": "territories 1977 October 25th and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00282-00088045-00088311": "December 2nd resolution 32 quarters", "54U_UF4uGkU-00283-00088312-00088682": "financing of the UN EF and the UN DOF", "54U_UF4uGkU-00284-00088683-00089013": "October 28 resolution 32 fifths", "54U_UF4uGkU-00285-00089014-00089235": "reaffirms previous condemn nations of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00286-00089236-00089510": "Israel and stresses the urgent need to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00287-00089511-00089838": "achieve a just and lasting peace in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00288-00089839-00090306": "Middle East November 25th resolution 32", "54U_UF4uGkU-00289-00090307-00090558": "twentieths reaffirms previous calls for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00290-00090559-00090720": "a full Israeli withdrawal from the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00291-00090721-00090870": "occupied territories and an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00292-00090871-00091091": "international peace conference with PLO", "54U_UF4uGkU-00293-00091092-00091506": "participation December 2nd resolution 32", "54U_UF4uGkU-00294-00091507-00091749": "fortieths reaffirms the inalienable", "54U_UF4uGkU-00295-00091750-00091947": "rights of the Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-00296-00091948-00092219": "people including the right to national", "54U_UF4uGkU-00297-00092220-00092441": "sovereignty and the right of return", "54U_UF4uGkU-00298-00092442-00092742": "December 12th resolution 30 to 80", "54U_UF4uGkU-00299-00092743-00092967": "seconds calling for an establishment of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00300-00092968-00093165": "a nuclear weapon-free zone in the Middle", "54U_UF4uGkU-00301-00093166-00093585": "East December 13th resolution 3290", "54U_UF4uGkU-00302-00093586-00093780": "firsts report of the special committee", "54U_UF4uGkU-00303-00093781-00093975": "to investigate Israeli practices", "54U_UF4uGkU-00304-00093976-00094131": "affecting the human rights of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00305-00094132-00094355": "population of the occupied territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00306-00094356-00094629": "calls on Israel to respect the Geneva", "54U_UF4uGkU-00307-00094630-00094754": "Conventions", "54U_UF4uGkU-00308-00094755-00095213": "December 19th resolution 32 160 firsts", "54U_UF4uGkU-00309-00095214-00095397": "permanent sovereignty over national", "54U_UF4uGkU-00310-00095398-00095562": "resources in the occupied Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00311-00095563-00096042": "territories 1978 November third", "54U_UF4uGkU-00312-00096043-00096275": "resolution 33 13th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00313-00096276-00096623": "financing of the UN EF and the UN dof", "54U_UF4uGkU-00314-00096624-00096962": "December 7th resolution 33 29th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00315-00096963-00097185": "reaffirms previous calls for a full", "54U_UF4uGkU-00316-00097186-00097353": "Israeli withdrawal from the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00317-00097354-00097562": "territories and an international peace", "54U_UF4uGkU-00318-00097563-00097847": "conference with PLO participation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00319-00097848-00098190": "December 14th resolution 33 sixty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00320-00098191-00098397": "fourths calling for an establishment of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00321-00098398-00098600": "a nuclear weapon-free zone in the Middle", "54U_UF4uGkU-00322-00098601-00098684": "East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00323-00098685-00099078": "December 14th resolution 33 71st sir", "54U_UF4uGkU-00324-00099079-00099312": "expressing concern over military buildup", "54U_UF4uGkU-00325-00099313-00099465": "and attempts of acquiring nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00326-00099466-00099747": "weapons of Israel calling for arms", "54U_UF4uGkU-00327-00099748-00099943": "embargo against Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00328-00099944-00100416": "December 18th resolution 33 113th report", "54U_UF4uGkU-00329-00100417-00100543": "of the special committee to investigate", "54U_UF4uGkU-00330-00100544-00100805": "Israeli practices affecting the human", "54U_UF4uGkU-00331-00100806-00101004": "rights of the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00332-00101005-00101586": "territories 1979 January 24th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00333-00101587-00101930": "33 180 thirds D demanding that Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00334-00101931-00102141": "terminate all form of collaboration with", "54U_UF4uGkU-00335-00102142-00102536": "South Africa October 25th December 3rd", "54U_UF4uGkU-00336-00102538-00102846": "and December 17th resolution 34 7th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00337-00102847-00103219": "financing of the UN EF and the UN dof", "54U_UF4uGkU-00338-00103220-00103572": "November 16th resolution 34 29th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00339-00103573-00103824": "expressing concern over the deportation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00340-00103825-00104046": "of the Bassam Shaka mayor of Nablus by", "54U_UF4uGkU-00341-00104047-00104478": "Israel December 6 resolution 34 70th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00342-00104479-00104693": "reaffirms previous calls for a full", "54U_UF4uGkU-00343-00104694-00104858": "Israeli withdrawal from the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00344-00104859-00105072": "territories and an international peace", "54U_UF4uGkU-00345-00105073-00105356": "conference with PLO participation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00346-00105357-00105784": "December 11th resolution 34 77th calling", "54U_UF4uGkU-00347-00105785-00105946": "for an establishment of a nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00348-00105947-00106183": "weapon-free zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00349-00106183-00106343": "December 11th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00350-00106344-00106633": "resolution 34 89th Israeli nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00351-00106634-00107041": "armament December 12th resolution 34", "54U_UF4uGkU-00352-00107042-00107221": "ninetieths report of the special", "54U_UF4uGkU-00353-00107222-00107389": "committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00354-00107390-00107590": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00355-00107591-00107746": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00356-00107747-00108158": "territories December 12th resolution 34", "54U_UF4uGkU-00357-00108158-00108383": "90 thirds P demanding that Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00358-00108383-00108596": "terminate all form of collaboration with", "54U_UF4uGkU-00359-00108597-00108893": "South Africa December 14th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00360-00108894-00109297": "resolution 34 136 permanent sovereignty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00361-00109298-00109508": "over national resources in the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00362-00109508-00109978": "Arab territories 1980 December first", "54U_UF4uGkU-00363-00109979-00110347": "resolution 3540 v s-- financing of un", "54U_UF4uGkU-00364-00110348-00110824": "dof December 5th resolution 35 110th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00365-00110825-00111004": "permanent sovereignty over national", "54U_UF4uGkU-00366-00111005-00111190": "resources in the occupied Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00367-00111191-00111624": "territories December 11th resolution 35", "54U_UF4uGkU-00368-00111625-00111886": "120 seconds report of the special", "54U_UF4uGkU-00369-00111887-00112054": "committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00370-00112055-00112258": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00371-00112259-00112411": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00372-00112412-00112875": "territories December 12th resolution 35", "54U_UF4uGkU-00373-00112876-00113156": "147 calling for an establishment of a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00374-00113157-00113345": "nuclear weapon-free zone in the Middle", "54U_UF4uGkU-00375-00113346-00113433": "East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00376-00113434-00113945": "December 12th resolution 35 157 Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00377-00113946-00114245": "nuclear armament December 16th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00378-00114246-00114608": "resolution 35 206 H demanding that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00379-00114608-00114766": "Israel terminate all form of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00380-00114767-00115096": "collaboration with South Africa December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00381-00115097-00115465": "16th resolution 35 207th reaffirms", "54U_UF4uGkU-00382-00115466-00115658": "previous calls for a full Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00383-00115658-00115861": "withdrawal from the occupied territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00384-00115862-00116006": "and the establishment of a Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-00385-00116007-00116606": "state 1981 October 28 resolution 36 15", "54U_UF4uGkU-00386-00116607-00116797": "demanding that Israel desist any", "54U_UF4uGkU-00387-00116798-00117025": "archaeological excavations in the Temple", "54U_UF4uGkU-00388-00117026-00117084": "Mount", "54U_UF4uGkU-00389-00117085-00117460": "November 13th resolution 36 27th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00390-00117461-00117695": "condemns Israeli attack on Iraqi nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00391-00117696-00117910": "facilities and demands Israel to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00392-00117911-00118279": "compensate Iraq November 30th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00393-00118280-00118752": "36 60 sixths financing of UN dof to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00394-00118753-00119094": "ninth resolution 36 87 calling for an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00395-00119095-00119268": "establishment of a nuclear weapon-free", "54U_UF4uGkU-00396-00119269-00119432": "zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00397-00119433-00119841": "December 9th resolution 36 98 Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00398-00119842-00120117": "nuclear armament demands that Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00399-00120118-00120284": "renounce possession of nuclear weapons", "54U_UF4uGkU-00400-00120285-00120559": "and submit its facilities to inspection", "54U_UF4uGkU-00401-00120560-00121010": "December 16th resolution 36 140 7th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00402-00121011-00121179": "report of the special committee to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00403-00121180-00121416": "investigate Israeli practices affecting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00404-00121417-00121599": "the human rights of the population of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00405-00121600-00121929": "the occupied territories December 16th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00406-00121930-00122292": "resolution 36 150th stamens Israel to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00407-00122293-00122475": "cease planning of a canal between the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00408-00122476-00122751": "Dead Sea and the Mediterranean December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00409-00122752-00123141": "17th resolution 36 170 seconds M", "54U_UF4uGkU-00410-00123142-00123369": "demanding that Israel terminate all form", "54U_UF4uGkU-00411-00123370-00123581": "of collaboration with South Africa", "54U_UF4uGkU-00412-00123582-00124041": "December 17th resolution 36 170 thirds", "54U_UF4uGkU-00413-00124042-00124221": "permanent sovereignty over national", "54U_UF4uGkU-00414-00124222-00124409": "resources in the occupied Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00415-00124410-00124767": "territories December 17th UN General", "54U_UF4uGkU-00416-00124768-00125159": "Assembly resolutions 36 226 a and B", "54U_UF4uGkU-00417-00125160-00125373": "reaffirms previous calls for a full", "54U_UF4uGkU-00418-00125374-00125538": "Israeli withdrawal from the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00419-00125539-00125748": "territories and the establishment of a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00420-00125749-00126177": "Palestinian state 1982 February 5th 9th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00421-00126178-00126468": "emergency special session s 9 2 1 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00422-00126469-00126642": "situation in the occupied Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00423-00126643-00127038": "territories November 16th resolution 37", "54U_UF4uGkU-00424-00127039-00127272": "18th condemns Israel refusal to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00425-00127273-00127526": "implement Security Council resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00426-00127527-00127821": "487 and demands Israel to withdraw its", "54U_UF4uGkU-00427-00127822-00128019": "threat to attack nuclear facilities of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00428-00128020-00128307": "neighboring nations November 30th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00429-00128308-00128753": "resolution 37 38 financing of UN dof", "54U_UF4uGkU-00430-00128754-00129168": "December 9th resolution 37 75th calling", "54U_UF4uGkU-00431-00129169-00129330": "for an establishment of a nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00432-00129331-00129539": "weapon-free zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00433-00129540-00129903": "December 9th resolution 37 80 seconds", "54U_UF4uGkU-00434-00129904-00130211": "Israeli nuclear armament December 10th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00435-00130213-00130449": "resolution 37 88", "54U_UF4uGkU-00436-00130450-00130593": "report of the special committee to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00437-00130594-00130830": "investigate Israeli practices affecting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00438-00130831-00131013": "the human rights of the population of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00439-00131014-00131328": "the occupied territories December 16th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00440-00131329-00131739": "resolution 37 120 seconds demands Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00441-00131740-00131928": "not to build a canal between the Dead", "54U_UF4uGkU-00442-00131929-00132111": "Sea and the Mediterranean", "54U_UF4uGkU-00443-00132112-00132522": "December 16th resolution 37 120 thirds", "54U_UF4uGkU-00444-00132523-00132717": "condemnation of Israel's alleged", "54U_UF4uGkU-00445-00132718-00132912": "responsibility for the Sabra and Shatila", "54U_UF4uGkU-00446-00132913-00133164": "massacre by katara party in Beirut", "54U_UF4uGkU-00447-00133165-00133365": "Lebanon resolves that the massacre was", "54U_UF4uGkU-00448-00133366-00133581": "an act of genocide condemns acts of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00449-00133582-00133791": "plundering Palestinian cultural heritage", "54U_UF4uGkU-00450-00133792-00133989": "condemns the occupation of the West Bank", "54U_UF4uGkU-00451-00133990-00134226": "Gaza and the Golan Heights and condemns", "54U_UF4uGkU-00452-00134227-00134511": "the annexation of Jerusalem December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00453-00134512-00134589": "17th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00454-00134590-00134937": "resolution 37 130 fifths permanent", "54U_UF4uGkU-00455-00134938-00135135": "sovereignty over national resources in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00456-00135136-00135339": "the occupied Palestinian and other Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00457-00135340-00135758": "territories December 20th resolution 37", "54U_UF4uGkU-00458-00135759-00136029": "220 seconds living conditions of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00459-00136030-00136218": "Palestinian people in the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00460-00136219-00136632": "Palestinian territories 1983 November", "54U_UF4uGkU-00461-00136633-00136839": "10th resolution thirty eight ninths", "54U_UF4uGkU-00462-00136840-00137025": "reiterates the demand that Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00463-00137026-00137211": "withdraw its threat to attack nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00464-00137212-00137426": "facilities of neighboring nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00465-00137427-00137781": "December 1st Resolution 38 thirty-fifths", "54U_UF4uGkU-00466-00137782-00138132": "financing of UN dof December 5th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00467-00138133-00138447": "resolution 38 39 theft demanding that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00468-00138448-00138606": "Israel terminate all form of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00469-00138607-00138906": "collaboration with South Africa December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00470-00138907-00139260": "13th Resolution 38 64th calling for an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00471-00139261-00139440": "establishment of a nuclear weapon-free", "54U_UF4uGkU-00472-00139441-00139607": "zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00473-00139608-00140049": "December 15th Resolution 38 69th Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00474-00140050-00140322": "nuclear armament December 15th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00475-00140323-00140634": "resolutions 38 79th report of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00476-00140635-00140841": "special committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00477-00140842-00141048": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00478-00141049-00141201": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00479-00141202-00141570": "territories December 15th Resolution 38", "54U_UF4uGkU-00480-00141571-00141867": "85th demands Israel not to build a canal", "54U_UF4uGkU-00481-00141868-00142008": "between the Dead Sea and the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00482-00142009-00142272": "Mediterranean December 19th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00483-00142273-00142662": "Resolution 38 144 permanent sovereignty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00484-00142663-00142872": "over national resources in the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00485-00142873-00143111": "Palestinian and other Arab territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00486-00143112-00143274": "December 19th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00487-00143275-00143622": "Resolution 38 160 sixths living", "54U_UF4uGkU-00488-00143623-00143823": "conditions of the Palestinian people in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00489-00143824-00144161": "the occupied Palestinian territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00490-00144162-00144324": "December 19th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00491-00144325-00144681": "resolutions 38 180th calls all nation to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00492-00144682-00144885": "suspend or sever all diplomatic economic", "54U_UF4uGkU-00493-00144886-00145145": "and technological ties with Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00494-00145146-00145419": "condemnation of Israel on various topics", "54U_UF4uGkU-00495-00145420-00145494": "including", "54U_UF4uGkU-00496-00145495-00145716": "occupation of the West Bank Gaza and the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00497-00145717-00145911": "Golan Heights war in Lebanon and the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00498-00145912-00146412": "annexation of Jerusalem 1984 November", "54U_UF4uGkU-00499-00146413-00146682": "23rd resolution 39 fourteenth's", "54U_UF4uGkU-00500-00146683-00146865": "reiterates the demand that Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00501-00146866-00147054": "withdraw its threat to attack nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00502-00147055-00147296": "facilities of neighboring nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00503-00147297-00147633": "November 30th resolution 39 twenty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00504-00147634-00148017": "eighths financing of un dof December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00505-00148018-00148350": "12th resolution 3950 fourths calling for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00506-00148351-00148491": "an establishment of a nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00507-00148492-00148727": "weapon-free zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00508-00148728-00149145": "December 13th resolution 39 72nd C", "54U_UF4uGkU-00509-00149146-00149376": "demanding that Israel terminate all form", "54U_UF4uGkU-00510-00149377-00149615": "of collaboration with South Africa", "54U_UF4uGkU-00511-00149616-00149778": "December 14th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00512-00149779-00150072": "resolutions 3990 fifths report of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00513-00150073-00150282": "special committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00514-00150283-00150486": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00515-00150487-00150639": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00516-00150640-00150999": "territories December 14th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00517-00151000-00151341": "39100 firsts demands Israel not to build", "54U_UF4uGkU-00518-00151342-00151524": "a canal between the Dead Sea and the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00519-00151525-00151887": "Mediterranean December 14th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00520-00151888-00152217": "39 140 sixths reaffirmation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00521-00152218-00152556": "Resolution 38 180th condemning Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00522-00152557-00152739": "and calling all nations to cut ties with", "54U_UF4uGkU-00523-00152740-00153282": "it December 17th resolution 39 140 7th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00524-00153283-00153660": "Israeli nuclear armament December 17th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00525-00153661-00154014": "resolution 39 160 ninths living", "54U_UF4uGkU-00526-00154015-00154215": "conditions of the Palestinian people in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00527-00154216-00154481": "the occupied Palestinian territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00528-00154482-00154641": "December 18th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00529-00154642-00154992": "resolution 39 220 thirds economic", "54U_UF4uGkU-00530-00154993-00155187": "development projects in the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00531-00155188-00155703": "Palestinian territories 1985 November", "54U_UF4uGkU-00532-00155704-00155946": "first resolution 40 sixths reaffirmation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00533-00155947-00156177": "of the condemnation of Israel on its", "54U_UF4uGkU-00534-00156178-00156437": "attack on Iraqi nuclear facility", "54U_UF4uGkU-00535-00156438-00156756": "December 2nd resolution 40 59th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00536-00156757-00157152": "financing of UN dof December 10th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00537-00157153-00157446": "resolution 40 sixty fourths a demanding", "54U_UF4uGkU-00538-00157447-00157623": "that Israel terminate all form of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00539-00157624-00157853": "collaboration with South Africa", "54U_UF4uGkU-00540-00157854-00158196": "December 12th resolution 40 80 seconds", "54U_UF4uGkU-00541-00158197-00158361": "calling for an establishment of a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00542-00158362-00158556": "nuclear weapon-free zone in the Middle", "54U_UF4uGkU-00543-00158557-00158642": "East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00544-00158643-00158879": "December 12th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00545-00158880-00159194": "forty 90 thirds Israeli nuclear armament", "54U_UF4uGkU-00546-00159195-00159486": "December sixteenth resolutions forty one", "54U_UF4uGkU-00547-00159487-00159698": "hundred and sixty firsts report of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00548-00159699-00159909": "special committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00549-00159910-00160112": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00550-00160113-00160265": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00551-00160266-00160541": "territories December sixteenth", "54U_UF4uGkU-00552-00160542-00160775": "resolution forty one hundred and sixty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00553-00160776-00160986": "seventh decides to monitor Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00554-00160987-00161174": "decision to construct a canal between", "54U_UF4uGkU-00555-00161175-00161413": "the Dead Sea and the Mediterranean", "54U_UF4uGkU-00556-00161414-00161702": "December sixteenth resolution forty one", "54U_UF4uGkU-00557-00161703-00161873": "hundred and sixty eighths reaffirmation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00558-00161874-00162266": "of Resolution 38 180th condemning Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00559-00162267-00162449": "and calling all nations to cut ties with", "54U_UF4uGkU-00560-00162450-00162538": "it", "54U_UF4uGkU-00561-00162539-00162953": "December 17th resolution forty 160 ninth", "54U_UF4uGkU-00562-00162954-00163182": "economic development projects in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00563-00163183-00163433": "occupied Palestinian territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00564-00163434-00163829": "December 17th resolution 4200 firsts", "54U_UF4uGkU-00565-00163830-00164019": "living conditions of the Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-00566-00164020-00164183": "people in the occupied Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-00567-00164184-00164808": "territories 1986 October 29th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00568-00164809-00165062": "41 12th calling Israel to place its", "54U_UF4uGkU-00569-00165063-00165273": "nuclear facilities under supervision of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00570-00165274-00165449": "the International Atomic Energy Agency", "54U_UF4uGkU-00571-00165450-00166004": "IAEA November 10th resolution 41 35th C", "54U_UF4uGkU-00572-00166005-00166241": "demanding that Israel terminate all form", "54U_UF4uGkU-00573-00166242-00166481": "of collaboration with South Africa", "54U_UF4uGkU-00574-00166482-00166835": "December 3rd resolution 41 40 fourths", "54U_UF4uGkU-00575-00166836-00167216": "financing of UN dof December 3rd", "54U_UF4uGkU-00576-00167217-00167516": "resolution 41 48 calling for an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00577-00167517-00167697": "establishment of a nuclear weapon-free", "54U_UF4uGkU-00578-00167698-00167890": "zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00579-00167891-00168246": "December 3rd resolutions 4160 thirds", "54U_UF4uGkU-00580-00168247-00168437": "report of the special committee to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00581-00168438-00168657": "investigate Israeli practices affecting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00582-00168658-00168839": "the human rights of the population of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00583-00168840-00169160": "the occupied territories December 4th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00584-00169161-00169475": "resolution 41 90 thirds Israeli nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00585-00169476-00169995": "armament December 4th resolution 41 160", "54U_UF4uGkU-00586-00169996-00170266": "seconds reaffirmation of Resolution 38", "54U_UF4uGkU-00587-00170267-00170549": "180th condemning Israel and calling all", "54U_UF4uGkU-00588-00170550-00170972": "nations to cut ties with it 1987", "54U_UF4uGkU-00589-00170973-00171360": "November 20th resolution 42 23rd SD", "54U_UF4uGkU-00590-00171361-00171590": "demanding that Israel terminate all form", "54U_UF4uGkU-00591-00171591-00171835": "of collaboration with South Africa", "54U_UF4uGkU-00592-00171836-00172166": "November 30th resolution 42 twenty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00593-00172167-00172263": "eighths calling", "54U_UF4uGkU-00594-00172264-00172413": "an establishment of a nuclear", "54U_UF4uGkU-00595-00172414-00172652": "weapon-free zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00596-00172653-00172986": "November 30th resolution forty to forty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00597-00172987-00173240": "fourths Israeli nuclear armament", "54U_UF4uGkU-00598-00173241-00173580": "December third resolution forty to 70th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00599-00173581-00174024": "financing of un DOF December eighth", "54U_UF4uGkU-00600-00174025-00174372": "resolutions forty to 160th report of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00601-00174373-00174582": "special committee to investigate Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00602-00174583-00174783": "practices affecting the human rights of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00603-00174784-00174939": "the population of the occupied", "54U_UF4uGkU-00604-00174940-00175332": "territories December 11th resolution 40", "54U_UF4uGkU-00605-00175333-00175626": "to 160 sixths assistance to the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00606-00175627-00175787": "Palestinian people", "54U_UF4uGkU-00607-00175788-00176241": "December 11th resolution 42 190th living", "54U_UF4uGkU-00608-00176242-00176442": "conditions of the Palestinian people in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00609-00176443-00176711": "the occupied Palestinian territories", "54U_UF4uGkU-00610-00176712-00177084": "December 11th resolution 42 209th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00611-00177085-00177429": "reaffirmation of Resolution 38 180th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00612-00177430-00177609": "condemning Israel and calling all", "54U_UF4uGkU-00613-00177610-00177848": "nations to cut ties with it", "54U_UF4uGkU-00614-00177849-00178428": "1988 April 20th resolution 43 230 thirds", "54U_UF4uGkU-00615-00178429-00178608": "expressing shock over killing of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00616-00178609-00178956": "Palestinian civilians in Nalin November", "54U_UF4uGkU-00617-00178957-00179250": "3rd resolution 43 twenty-firsts the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00618-00179251-00179589": "first Palestinian Intifada December 5th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00619-00179590-00179889": "resolution 43 50th C demanding that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00620-00179890-00180048": "Israel terminate all form of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00621-00180049-00180375": "collaboration with South Africa December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00622-00180376-00180675": "6 resolution 43 50 fourths reaffirmation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00623-00180676-00181074": "of Resolution 38 180th condemning Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00624-00181075-00181254": "and calling all nations to cut ties with", "54U_UF4uGkU-00625-00181255-00181674": "it December 6th resolutions 4350 eighths", "54U_UF4uGkU-00626-00181675-00181845": "report of the special committee to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00627-00181846-00182085": "investigate Israeli practices affecting", "54U_UF4uGkU-00628-00182086-00182268": "the human rights of the population of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00629-00182269-00182595": "the occupied territories December 7th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00630-00182596-00182901": "resolution 43 60 fifths calling for an", "54U_UF4uGkU-00631-00182902-00183075": "establishment of a nuclear weapon-free", "54U_UF4uGkU-00632-00183076-00183266": "zone in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00633-00183267-00183663": "December 7th resolution 43 80th Israeli", "54U_UF4uGkU-00634-00183664-00184011": "nuclear armament December 15th UN", "54U_UF4uGkU-00635-00184012-00184362": "General Assembly resolution 43 170", "54U_UF4uGkU-00636-00184363-00184575": "sixths international peace conference", "54U_UF4uGkU-00637-00184576-00184935": "principles for peace December 21st", "54U_UF4uGkU-00638-00184936-00185304": "resolution 43 220 eighth's financing of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00639-00185305-00185528": "UN dof", "54U_UF4uGkU-00640-00185529-00186104": "1991 December 16th resolution 4000 686", "54U_UF4uGkU-00641-00186105-00186875": "an old res 3000 379 2012 march 29th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00642-00186876-00187295": "Resolution 66 220 fifths exploitation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00643-00187296-00187663": "Natural Resources 2017", "54U_UF4uGkU-00644-00187664-00188107": "December 21st resolution AES 10.22", "54U_UF4uGkU-00645-00188108-00188948": "criticising US policy on Jerusalem topic", "54U_UF4uGkU-00646-00188949-00189196": "United Nations Security Council", "54U_UF4uGkU-00647-00189197-00189857": "resolutions see also United Nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00648-00189858-00190054": "Security Council resolution resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00649-00190055-00190358": "42 the Palestine question the 5th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00650-00190359-00190658": "March 1948 requests recommendations for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00651-00190659-00190982": "the Palestine Commission resolution 43", "54U_UF4uGkU-00652-00190983-00191213": "the Palestine question the first of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00653-00191214-00191552": "April 1948 recognizes increasing", "54U_UF4uGkU-00654-00191553-00191827": "violence and disorder in Palestine and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00655-00191828-00192092": "requests that representatives of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00656-00192093-00192365": "Jewish Agency for Palestine and the Arab", "54U_UF4uGkU-00657-00192366-00192605": "Higher Committee arrange with the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00658-00192606-00192863": "Security Council a truce between the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00659-00192864-00193228": "Arab and Jewish communities of Palestine", "54U_UF4uGkU-00660-00193229-00193538": "calls upon Arab and Jewish armed groups", "54U_UF4uGkU-00661-00193539-00193762": "in Palestine to cease acts of violence", "54U_UF4uGkU-00662-00193763-00194267": "immediately resolution 44 the Palestine", "54U_UF4uGkU-00663-00194268-00194522": "question the first of April 1948", "54U_UF4uGkU-00664-00194523-00194756": "requests convocation of special session", "54U_UF4uGkU-00665-00194757-00195098": "of the General Assembly resolution 46", "54U_UF4uGkU-00666-00195099-00195371": "the Palestine question the 17th of April", "54U_UF4uGkU-00667-00195372-00195635": "1948 as the United Kingdom is the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00668-00195636-00195893": "mandatory power it is responsible for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00669-00195894-00196064": "the maintenance of peace and order in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00670-00196065-00196466": "Palestine the resolutions also calls", "54U_UF4uGkU-00671-00196467-00196736": "upon all persons and organizations in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00672-00196737-00197090": "Palestine to stop importing armed bands", "54U_UF4uGkU-00673-00197091-00197468": "and fighting personnel whatever their", "54U_UF4uGkU-00674-00197469-00198071": "origin weapons and war materials refrain", "54U_UF4uGkU-00675-00198072-00198254": "pending the future government of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00676-00198255-00198591": "Palestine from any police", "54U_UF4uGkU-00677-00198592-00198810": "activity which might prejudice the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00678-00198811-00199026": "rights claims or position of either", "54U_UF4uGkU-00679-00199027-00199443": "community refrain from any action which", "54U_UF4uGkU-00680-00199444-00199632": "will endanger the safety of the holy", "54U_UF4uGkU-00681-00199633-00200142": "places in Palestine resolution 48 April", "54U_UF4uGkU-00682-00200143-00200451": "23rd 1948 calls on all concerned parties", "54U_UF4uGkU-00683-00200452-00200805": "to comply with UNSC resolution 46 and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00684-00200806-00200976": "establishes a truce commission for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00685-00200977-00201156": "Palestine to assist the SC in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00686-00201157-00201435": "implementing the truce approved eight to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00687-00201436-00201693": "zero abstentions from colombia ukrainian", "54U_UF4uGkU-00688-00201694-00202308": "SSR and USSR resolution 49 May 22nd 1948", "54U_UF4uGkU-00689-00202309-00202524": "issues a ceasefire order to come into", "54U_UF4uGkU-00690-00202525-00202872": "effect at noon may 24th 1948 New York", "54U_UF4uGkU-00691-00202873-00203136": "City local time orders the truce", "54U_UF4uGkU-00692-00203137-00203364": "Commission for Palestine previously set", "54U_UF4uGkU-00693-00203365-00203667": "up to report on compliance adopted by", "54U_UF4uGkU-00694-00203668-00203901": "eight to zero abstentions from ukrainian", "54U_UF4uGkU-00695-00203902-00204485": "SSR USSR in syria resolution 50 may 29", "54U_UF4uGkU-00696-00204486-00204780": "1944 a four-week ceasefire covering", "54U_UF4uGkU-00697-00204781-00205053": "Palestine Egypt Iraq Lebanon Saudi", "54U_UF4uGkU-00698-00205054-00205428": "Arabia Syria Transjordan and Yemen urges", "54U_UF4uGkU-00699-00205429-00205605": "all to protect the holy places in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00700-00205606-00205916": "Jerusalem offers the UN mediator as many", "54U_UF4uGkU-00701-00205917-00206175": "military observers as necessary further", "54U_UF4uGkU-00702-00206176-00206394": "violations in the council would consider", "54U_UF4uGkU-00703-00206394-00206671": "action under Chapter 7 of the UN Charter", "54U_UF4uGkU-00704-00206673-00206928": "adopted in parts no voting on the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00705-00206929-00207188": "resolution as a whole", "54U_UF4uGkU-00706-00207189-00207531": "resolution 53 the Palestine question the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00707-00207532-00207989": "seventh of July 1948 resolution 54 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00708-00207990-00208396": "Palestine question the 15th of July 1948", "54U_UF4uGkU-00709-00208398-00208728": "resolution 56 the Palestine question the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00710-00208729-00209202": "19th of August 1948 resolution 57 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00711-00209203-00209444": "Palestine question the 18th of September", "54U_UF4uGkU-00712-00209446-00209862": "1948 resolution 59 the Palestine", "54U_UF4uGkU-00713-00209863-00210236": "question the 19th of October 1948", "54U_UF4uGkU-00714-00210237-00210548": "resolution 60 the Palestine question the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00715-00210550-00211041": "29th of October 1948 resolution 61 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00716-00211042-00211263": "Palestine question the 4th of November", "54U_UF4uGkU-00717-00211264-00211683": "1948 resolution 62 the Palestine", "54U_UF4uGkU-00718-00211684-00212042": "question the 16th of November 1940", "54U_UF4uGkU-00719-00212042-00212379": "resolution 66 the Palestine question the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00720-00212380-00212826": "29th of December 1948 resolution 69", "54U_UF4uGkU-00721-00212827-00213066": "Israel's admission to the UN the 4th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00722-00213067-00213540": "March 1949 resolution 72 the Palestine", "54U_UF4uGkU-00723-00213541-00213890": "question the 11th of August 1949", "54U_UF4uGkU-00724-00213891-00214227": "resolution 73 the Palestine question the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00725-00214228-00214683": "11th of August 1949 resolution 89 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00726-00214684-00214953": "17th of November 1950 regarding", "54U_UF4uGkU-00727-00214954-00215256": "armistice in 1948 arab-israeli war on", "54U_UF4uGkU-00728-00215257-00215771": "transfer of persons Resolution 92 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00729-00215773-00216152": "Palestine question the 8th of May 1951", "54U_UF4uGkU-00730-00216153-00216489": "resolution 93 the Palestine question the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00731-00216490-00216939": "18th of May 1951 resolution 95 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00732-00216940-00217151": "Palestine question the 1st of September", "54U_UF4uGkU-00733-00217152-00217578": "1951 resolution 100 the Palestine", "54U_UF4uGkU-00734-00217579-00217973": "question the 27th of October 1953", "54U_UF4uGkU-00735-00217973-00218277": "resolution 101 the Palestine question", "54U_UF4uGkU-00736-00218278-00218856": "the 24th of November 1953 resolution 106", "54U_UF4uGkU-00737-00218857-00219146": "the Palestine question the 29th of March", "54U_UF4uGkU-00738-00219146-00219517": "1955 condemns Israel for Gaza raid", "54U_UF4uGkU-00739-00219519-00219840": "resolution 107 the Palestine question", "54U_UF4uGkU-00740-00219841-00220269": "the 30th of March resolution 108 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00741-00220269-00220553": "Palestine question the 8th of September", "54U_UF4uGkU-00742-00220554-00220866": "resolution 111 the Palestine question", "54U_UF4uGkU-00743-00220867-00221469": "January 19th 1956 condemns Israel for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00744-00221469-00221923": "raid on Syria that killed 56 people", "54U_UF4uGkU-00745-00221925-00222260": "resolution 113 the Palestine question", "54U_UF4uGkU-00746-00222261-00222714": "the 4th of April resolution 114 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00747-00222715-00222992": "Palestine question the 4th of June", "54U_UF4uGkU-00748-00222992-00223367": "resolution 127 the Palestine question", "54U_UF4uGkU-00749-00223369-00223914": "January 22nd 1958 recommends Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00750-00223915-00224371": "suspends its no man Zone in Jerusalem", "54U_UF4uGkU-00751-00224373-00224856": "resolution 138 June 23rd 1960 question", "54U_UF4uGkU-00752-00224857-00225057": "relating to the case of Israel's capture", "54U_UF4uGkU-00753-00225058-00225284": "of Adolf Eichmann concerning Argentina's", "54U_UF4uGkU-00754-00225285-00225350": "complaint", "54U_UF4uGkU-00755-00225351-00225580": "Israel breached its sovereignty", "54U_UF4uGkU-00756-00225581-00225941": "resolution 162 the Palestine question", "54U_UF4uGkU-00757-00225942-00226538": "April 11 1961 urges Israel to comply", "54U_UF4uGkU-00758-00226539-00227081": "with UN decisions resolution 171 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00759-00227082-00227557": "Palestine question April 9th 1962", "54U_UF4uGkU-00760-00227558-00227870": "determines flagrant violations by Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00761-00227871-00228380": "in its attack on Syria resolution 228", "54U_UF4uGkU-00762-00228381-00228673": "the Palestine question November 25th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00763-00228674-00229169": "1966 censures Israel for its attack on", "54U_UF4uGkU-00764-00229170-00229328": "samu in the West Bank", "54U_UF4uGkU-00765-00229329-00229831": "then under Jordanian control resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00766-00229832-00230431": "233 six-day war June 6 1967 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00767-00230432-00231016": "234 six-day war June 7 1967 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00768-00231017-00231218": "235 six-day war", "54U_UF4uGkU-00769-00231219-00231776": "June 9th 1967 Resolution 236 six-day war", "54U_UF4uGkU-00770-00231777-00232367": "June 11th 1967 Resolution 237 six-day", "54U_UF4uGkU-00771-00232368-00232940": "war June 14 1967 urges Israel to allow", "54U_UF4uGkU-00772-00232941-00233345": "return of new 1967 Palestinian refugees", "54U_UF4uGkU-00773-00233346-00233657": "and called on Israel to ensure the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00774-00233658-00233849": "safety and welfare of inhabitants of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00775-00233850-00234142": "areas where fighting had taken place", "54U_UF4uGkU-00776-00234143-00234683": "resolution 242 bir 25th 1967 concerning", "54U_UF4uGkU-00777-00234684-00235004": "violations of the ceasefire resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00778-00235005-00235490": "242 november 22nd 1967 termination of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00779-00235491-00235691": "all claims or states of belligerency and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00780-00235692-00235844": "respect for an acknowledgement of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00781-00235845-00236066": "sovereignty territorial integrity and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00782-00236067-00236270": "political independence of every state in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00783-00236271-00236567": "the area calls on Israel's neighbors to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00784-00236568-00236759": "end the state of belligerency and calls", "54U_UF4uGkU-00785-00236760-00236990": "upon israel to reciprocate by withdraw", "54U_UF4uGkU-00786-00236991-00237188": "its forces from land claimed by other", "54U_UF4uGkU-00787-00237189-00237614": "parties in 1967 war interpreted commonly", "54U_UF4uGkU-00788-00237615-00237806": "today as calling for the land for peace", "54U_UF4uGkU-00789-00237807-00237949": "principle as a way to resolve", "54U_UF4uGkU-00790-00237950-00238403": "arab-israeli conflict resolution 248", "54U_UF4uGkU-00791-00238404-00238773": "March 24th 1968", "54U_UF4uGkU-00792-00238773-00239059": "condemns Israel for its massive attack", "54U_UF4uGkU-00793-00239060-00239835": "on Cara Mae in Jordan resolution 250 a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00794-00239836-00240498": "prolonged Amil eteri parade in Jerusalem", "54U_UF4uGkU-00795-00240498-00241084": "resolution 251 May 2nd deeply deplores", "54U_UF4uGkU-00796-00241085-00241371": "Israeli military parade in Jerusalem in", "54U_UF4uGkU-00797-00241373-00241971": "defiance of resolution 250 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00798-00241971-00242539": "252 May 21st declares invalid Israel's", "54U_UF4uGkU-00799-00242540-00242773": "act to unified Jerusalem as Jewish", "54U_UF4uGkU-00800-00242773-00243450": "capital resolution 256 August 16th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00801-00243451-00243744": "condemns Israeli raids on Jordan as", "54U_UF4uGkU-00802-00243746-00244242": "flagrant violation resolution 258", "54U_UF4uGkU-00803-00244244-00244636": "September 18th expressed concern with", "54U_UF4uGkU-00804-00244637-00244801": "the welfare of the inhabitants of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00805-00244802-00244978": "Israeli occupied territories and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00806-00244979-00245194": "requested a special representative to be", "54U_UF4uGkU-00807-00245194-00245389": "sent to report on the implementation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00808-00245390-00245819": "Resolution 237 and that Israel cooperate", "54U_UF4uGkU-00809-00245821-00246439": "resolution 259 September 27th deplores", "54U_UF4uGkU-00810-00246440-00246742": "Israel's refusal to accept UN mission to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00811-00246742-00247336": "probe occupation resolution 262 December", "54U_UF4uGkU-00812-00247337-00247789": "31st condemns Israel for attack on", "54U_UF4uGkU-00813-00247790-00248373": "Beirut Airport resolution 265 April 1st", "54U_UF4uGkU-00814-00248373-00248902": "1969 condemns Israel for air attacks on", "54U_UF4uGkU-00815-00248903-00249664": "salt Resolution 267 July 3rd Sanchez", "54U_UF4uGkU-00816-00249665-00249907": "Israel for administrative acts to change", "54U_UF4uGkU-00817-00249908-00250453": "the status of Jerusalem resolution 270", "54U_UF4uGkU-00818-00250454-00250921": "or ggest 26 condemns Israel for air", "54U_UF4uGkU-00819-00250921-00251298": "attacks on villages in southern Lebanon", "54U_UF4uGkU-00820-00251298-00251902": "resolution 271 September 15th condemns", "54U_UF4uGkU-00821-00251903-00252198": "Israel's failure to obey UN resolutions", "54U_UF4uGkU-00822-00252200-00252762": "on Jerusalem resolution 279 May 12th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00823-00252763-00253108": "1970 demands the immediate withdrawal of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00824-00253109-00253357": "all Israeli Armed Forces from Lebanese", "54U_UF4uGkU-00825-00253358-00253909": "territory full text resolution 280 May", "54U_UF4uGkU-00826-00253910-00254377": "19th condemns Israelis attacks against", "54U_UF4uGkU-00827-00254378-00255027": "Lebanon resolution 285 September 5th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00828-00255028-00255283": "demands immediate Israeli withdrawal", "54U_UF4uGkU-00829-00255284-00255835": "from Lebanon resolution 298 September", "54U_UF4uGkU-00830-00255836-00256392": "25th 1971 deplores Israel's changing of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00831-00256394-00256900": "the status of Jerusalem resolution 313", "54U_UF4uGkU-00832-00256901-00257442": "February 28 1972 demands that Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00833-00257444-00257723": "stop attacks against Lebanon", "54U_UF4uGkU-00834-00257725-00258360": "solution 316 June 26 condemns Israel for", "54U_UF4uGkU-00835-00258361-00258809": "repeated attacks on Lebanon resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00836-00258810-00259404": "317 July 21st deploys Israel's refusal", "54U_UF4uGkU-00837-00259405-00259766": "to release Arabs abducted in Lebanon", "54U_UF4uGkU-00838-00259767-00260309": "resolution 331 April 20th 1973", "54U_UF4uGkU-00839-00260310-00260904": "resolution 332 April 21st condemns", "54U_UF4uGkU-00840-00260905-00261123": "Israel's repeated attacks against", "54U_UF4uGkU-00841-00261123-00261806": "Lebanon Resolution 337 August 15th", "54U_UF4uGkU-00842-00261807-00262107": "condemns Israel for violating Lebanon's", "54U_UF4uGkU-00843-00262108-00262287": "sovereignty and territorial integrity", "54U_UF4uGkU-00844-00262288-00262536": "and for the forcible diversion and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00845-00262537-00262743": "seizure of a Lebanese airliner from", "54U_UF4uGkU-00846-00262744-00263313": "Lebanon's airspace resolution 338 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00847-00263314-00263829": "22nd of October 1973 calls for a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00848-00263830-00264171": "ceasefire in Yom Kippur War on the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00849-00264172-00264405": "implementation of Security Council", "54U_UF4uGkU-00850-00264406-00264933": "resolution 242 1967 in all of its parts", "54U_UF4uGkU-00851-00264934-00265284": "and decides that immediately and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00852-00265285-00265419": "concurrently with the ceasefire", "54U_UF4uGkU-00853-00265420-00265692": "negotiations shall start between the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00854-00265693-00265887": "parties concerned under appropriate", "54U_UF4uGkU-00855-00265888-00266145": "auspices aimed at establishing a just", "54U_UF4uGkU-00856-00266146-00266498": "and durable peace in the Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00857-00266499-00266994": "resolution 339 the 23rd of October 1973", "54U_UF4uGkU-00858-00266995-00267488": "confirms res 338 dispatch UN observers", "54U_UF4uGkU-00859-00267489-00267867": "Resolution 340 the 25th of October", "54U_UF4uGkU-00860-00267868-00268020": "demands that immediate and complete", "54U_UF4uGkU-00861-00268021-00268509": "ceasefire be observed / 338 and 339 and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00862-00268510-00268677": "requests to increase the number of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00863-00268678-00268955": "United Nations military observers", "54U_UF4uGkU-00864-00268956-00269355": "resolution 341 the 27th of October", "54U_UF4uGkU-00865-00269356-00269487": "approves the report on the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00866-00269488-00269966": "implementation Resolution 340 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00867-00269967-00270504": "344 the 15th of December resolution 346", "54U_UF4uGkU-00868-00270505-00271130": "April 8 1974 Resolution 347 April 21", "54U_UF4uGkU-00869-00271131-00271708": "both condemns Israeli attacks on Lebanon", "54U_UF4uGkU-00870-00271709-00272177": "resolution 350 the 31st of May 1974", "54U_UF4uGkU-00871-00272178-00272354": "established the United Nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00872-00272355-00272579": "disengagement observer force to monitor", "54U_UF4uGkU-00873-00272580-00272750": "the ceasefire between Israel and Syria", "54U_UF4uGkU-00874-00272751-00273031": "in the wake of the Yom Kippur War", "54U_UF4uGkU-00875-00273032-00273494": "resolution 362 October 23rd decides to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00876-00273495-00273704": "extend the Mandate of the United Nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00877-00273705-00273997": "emergency force for another six months", "54U_UF4uGkU-00878-00273998-00274588": "Resolution 363 November 29th resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00879-00274589-00275000": "368 April 17th 1975 called on the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00880-00275001-00275189": "parties involved in the prevailing state", "54U_UF4uGkU-00881-00275190-00275342": "of tension in the Middle East to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00882-00275343-00275728": "immediately implement resolution 338", "54U_UF4uGkU-00883-00275729-00276269": "resolution 369 May 28 1975 expressed", "54U_UF4uGkU-00884-00276270-00276443": "concern over the prevailing state of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00885-00276444-00276629": "tension in the Middle East reaffirmed", "54U_UF4uGkU-00886-00276630-00276800": "that the two previous agreements were", "54U_UF4uGkU-00887-00276801-00276938": "only a step towards the implementation", "54U_UF4uGkU-00888-00276939-00277286": "of resolution 338 and called on the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00889-00277287-00277499": "parties to implement it and extended the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00890-00277500-00277652": "Mandate of the United Nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00891-00277653-00278050": "disengagement observer force resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00892-00278051-00278306": "371 expressed concern at a lack of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00893-00278307-00278525": "progress towards a lasting peace in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00894-00278526-00278644": "Middle East", "54U_UF4uGkU-00895-00278645-00278954": "resolution 378 called for the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00896-00278955-00279242": "implementation of resolution 338 and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00897-00279243-00279440": "extended the Mandate of the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00898-00279441-00279884": "Nations emergency force resolution 381", "54U_UF4uGkU-00899-00279885-00280091": "expressed concern over continued", "54U_UF4uGkU-00900-00280092-00280280": "tensions extended the Mandate of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00901-00280281-00280499": "United Nations emergency force and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00902-00280500-00280673": "scheduled a later meeting to continue", "54U_UF4uGkU-00903-00280674-00281092": "the debate on the Middle East resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00904-00281093-00281372": "390 can sidered a report regarding the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00905-00281373-00281585": "united nations disengagement observer", "54U_UF4uGkU-00906-00281586-00281813": "force and extended its mandate noted the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00907-00281814-00282002": "efforts to establish peace in the Middle", "54U_UF4uGkU-00908-00282003-00282170": "East but expressed concern over the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00909-00282171-00282374": "prevailing state of tensions and call", "54U_UF4uGkU-00910-00282375-00282775": "for the implementation of resolution 338", "54U_UF4uGkU-00911-00282776-00283477": "resolution 396 resolution 408 Resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00912-00283478-00283985": "416 resolution 420 regarding the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00913-00283986-00284275": "Nations disengagement observer force", "54U_UF4uGkU-00914-00284276-00284481": "resolution 425", "54U_UF4uGkU-00915-00284482-00285006": "five 1978 calls on Israel to withdraw", "54U_UF4uGkU-00916-00285007-00285303": "its forces from Lebanon Israel's", "54U_UF4uGkU-00917-00285304-00285525": "withdrawal from Lebanon was completed by", "54U_UF4uGkU-00918-00285526-00286032": "the 16th of June 2000 resolution 426", "54U_UF4uGkU-00919-00286033-00286245": "established the United Nations interim", "54U_UF4uGkU-00920-00286246-00286907": "force in Lebanon unifil resolution 427", "54U_UF4uGkU-00921-00286908-00287181": "calls on Israel to complete its", "54U_UF4uGkU-00922-00287182-00287756": "withdrawal from Lebanon resolution 429", "54U_UF4uGkU-00923-00287757-00288113": "resolution 434 renewed the Mandate of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00924-00288114-00288357": "unifil and called upon Israel and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00925-00288358-00288665": "Lebanon to implement prior resolutions", "54U_UF4uGkU-00926-00288666-00289409": "resolution 438 resolution 441 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00927-00289410-00289851": "444 deplores Israel's lack of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00928-00289852-00290282": "cooperation with UN peacekeeping forces", "54U_UF4uGkU-00929-00290283-00290760": "resolution 446 1979 determines that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00930-00290761-00290916": "Israeli settlements are at serious", "54U_UF4uGkU-00931-00290917-00291153": "obstruction to peace and calls on Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00932-00291154-00291449": "to abide by the Fourth Geneva Convention", "54U_UF4uGkU-00933-00291450-00291819": "resolution 449 regarding the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00934-00291820-00292055": "Nations disengagement observer force", "54U_UF4uGkU-00935-00292056-00292671": "resolution 450 calls on Israel to stop", "54U_UF4uGkU-00936-00292672-00293379": "attacking Lebanon resolution 452 calls", "54U_UF4uGkU-00937-00293380-00293607": "on Israel to cease building settlements", "54U_UF4uGkU-00938-00293608-00294159": "in occupied territories resolution 456", "54U_UF4uGkU-00939-00294160-00294330": "regarding the united nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00940-00294331-00294713": "disengagement observer force resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00941-00294714-00295527": "459 regarding UNIFIL resolution 465 to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00942-00295528-00295770": "plaus Israel's settlements and asks all", "54U_UF4uGkU-00943-00295771-00295992": "Member States not to assist Israel's", "54U_UF4uGkU-00944-00295993-00296663": "settlements program Resolution 467", "54U_UF4uGkU-00945-00296664-00296939": "strong lead applause Israel's military", "54U_UF4uGkU-00946-00296940-00297602": "intervention in Lebanon resolution 468", "54U_UF4uGkU-00947-00297603-00297740": "calls", "54U_UF4uGkU-00948-00297741-00297995": "Israel to rescind illegal expulsion zuv", "54U_UF4uGkU-00949-00297996-00298241": "to palestinian mayors and a judge and to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00950-00298242-00298930": "facilitate their return resolution 469", "54U_UF4uGkU-00951-00298931-00299240": "strong lead applause Israel's failure to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00952-00299241-00299420": "observe the council's order not to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00953-00299421-00299978": "deport Palestinians resolution 470", "54U_UF4uGkU-00954-00299979-00300149": "regarding the united nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00955-00300150-00300553": "disengagement observer force resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00956-00300554-00301070": "471 expresses deep concern at Israel's", "54U_UF4uGkU-00957-00301071-00301259": "failure to abide by the Fourth Geneva", "54U_UF4uGkU-00958-00301260-00301874": "Convention resolution 474 regarding the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00959-00301875-00302087": "United Nations disengagement observer", "54U_UF4uGkU-00960-00302088-00302750": "force resolution 476 reiterates that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00961-00302751-00303014": "Israel's claim to Jerusalem are null and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00962-00303015-00303323": "void the altering of the status of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00963-00303324-00303530": "Jerusalem constitutes as a flagrant", "54U_UF4uGkU-00964-00303531-00303650": "violation of the Fourth Geneva", "54U_UF4uGkU-00965-00303651-00304142": "Convention resolution 478 the 20th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00966-00304143-00304424": "August 1980 censures Israel in the", "54U_UF4uGkU-00967-00304425-00304565": "strongest terms for its claim to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00968-00304566-00304942": "Jerusalem in its basic law resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00969-00304943-00305216": "481 regarding the United Nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00970-00305217-00305596": "disengagement observer force resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00971-00305597-00305957": "483 noted the continuing need for UNIFIL", "54U_UF4uGkU-00972-00305958-00306173": "given the situation between Israel and", "54U_UF4uGkU-00973-00306174-00306442": "Lebanon and extended its mandate", "54U_UF4uGkU-00974-00306443-00306944": "resolution 484 declares it imperative", "54U_UF4uGkU-00975-00306945-00307172": "that Israel readmit to deported", "54U_UF4uGkU-00976-00307173-00307589": "Palestinian mayors resolution 485", "54U_UF4uGkU-00977-00307590-00307766": "regarding the united nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-00978-00307767-00308114": "disengagement observer force Resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-00979-00308115-00308654": "487 strongly condemns Israel for its", "54U_UF4uGkU-00980-00308655-00309016": "attack on Iraq's nuclear facility", "54U_UF4uGkU-00981-00309017-00309487": "resolution 488 regarding UNIFIL", "54U_UF4uGkU-00982-00309488-00309857": "Resolution 493 regarding the united", "54U_UF4uGkU-00983-00309858-00310099": "nations disengagement observer force", "54U_UF4uGkU-00984-00310100-00310622": "resolution 497 the 17th of december 1981", "54U_UF4uGkU-00985-00310623-00310847": "decides that israel's annexation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-00986-00310848-00311027": "Syria's Golan Heights is null and void", "54U_UF4uGkU-00987-00311028-00311125": "and demands", "54U_UF4uGkU-00988-00311126-00311288": "that Israel rescinds its decision", "54U_UF4uGkU-00989-00311289-00311963": "forthwith resolution 498 calls on Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-00990-00311964-00312570": "to withdraw from Lebanon Resolution 501", "54U_UF4uGkU-00991-00312571-00312895": "calls on Israel to stop attacks against", "54U_UF4uGkU-00992-00312896-00313266": "Lebanon and withdraw its troops", "54U_UF4uGkU-00993-00313267-00313609": "resolution 506 regarding the United", "54U_UF4uGkU-00994-00313610-00313851": "Nations disengagement observer force", "54U_UF4uGkU-00995-00313852-00314206": "resolution 508 demanded an end to", "54U_UF4uGkU-00996-00314207-00314407": "hostilities between Israel and the PLO", "54U_UF4uGkU-00997-00314408-00314653": "taking place in Lebanon and called for a", "54U_UF4uGkU-00998-00314654-00315271": "ceasefire resolution 509 demands that", "54U_UF4uGkU-00999-00315272-00315520": "Israel withdraw its forces forthwith and", "54U_UF4uGkU-01000-00315521-00315981": "unconditionally from Lebanon resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01001-00315982-00316407": "511 extended the Mandate of UNIFIL", "54U_UF4uGkU-01002-00316408-00316990": "resolution 515 demands that Israel lift", "54U_UF4uGkU-01003-00316991-00317206": "its siege of Beirut and allow food", "54U_UF4uGkU-01004-00317207-00317764": "supplies to be brought in resolution 516", "54U_UF4uGkU-01005-00317765-00317965": "demanded an immediate cessation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01006-00317966-00318193": "military activities in Lebanon noting", "54U_UF4uGkU-01007-00318194-00318489": "violations of the ceasefire in Beirut", "54U_UF4uGkU-01008-00318490-00319069": "resolution 517 censures Israel for", "54U_UF4uGkU-01009-00319070-00319309": "failing to obey UN resolutions and", "54U_UF4uGkU-01010-00319310-00319513": "demands that Israel withdraw its forces", "54U_UF4uGkU-01011-00319514-00320305": "from Lebanon resolution 518 demands that", "54U_UF4uGkU-01012-00320306-00320612": "Israel cooperate fully with UN forces in", "54U_UF4uGkU-01013-00320613-00321154": "Lebanon resolution 519 extended the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01014-00321155-00321430": "Mandate of UNIFIL and authorized it to", "54U_UF4uGkU-01015-00321431-00321837": "carry out humanitarian tasks resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01016-00321838-00322339": "520 condemns Israel's attack into West", "54U_UF4uGkU-01017-00322340-00323016": "Beirut resolution 523 regards UNIFIL", "54U_UF4uGkU-01018-00323017-00323763": "resolution 524 resolution 529 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01019-00323764-00324395": "531 resolution 536 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01020-00324396-00325208": "538 resolution 543 resolution 549", "54U_UF4uGkU-01021-00325209-00325979": "resolution 551 resolution 555 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01022-00325980-00326801": "557 resolution 561 resolution 563", "54U_UF4uGkU-01023-00326802-00327312": "resolution 573 condemns Israel", "54U_UF4uGkU-01024-00327313-00327543": "vigorously for bombing Tunisia in attack", "54U_UF4uGkU-01025-00327544-00328100": "on PLO headquarters resolution 575", "54U_UF4uGkU-01026-00328101-00328883": "resolution 576 resolution 583 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01027-00328884-00329808": "584 resolution 586 resolution 587 takes", "54U_UF4uGkU-01028-00329809-00330012": "note of previous calls on Israel to", "54U_UF4uGkU-01029-00330013-00330198": "withdraw its forces from Lebanon and", "54U_UF4uGkU-01030-00330199-00330575": "urges all parties to withdraw resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01031-00330576-00331350": "590 un DOF resolution 592 strong lead", "54U_UF4uGkU-01032-00331351-00331554": "applause the killing of Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-01033-00331555-00331785": "students at BIR Zeit University by", "54U_UF4uGkU-01034-00331786-00332534": "Israeli troops resolution 594 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01035-00332535-00333311": "596 resolution 599 resolution 603", "54U_UF4uGkU-01036-00333312-00333771": "resolution 605 strong lead applause", "54U_UF4uGkU-01037-00333772-00334017": "Israel's policies and practices denying", "54U_UF4uGkU-01038-00334018-00334286": "the human rights of Palestinians", "54U_UF4uGkU-01039-00334287-00334788": "resolution 607 calls on Israel not to", "54U_UF4uGkU-01040-00334789-00334956": "deport Palestinians and strongly", "54U_UF4uGkU-01041-00334957-00335145": "requests it to abide by the Fourth", "54U_UF4uGkU-01042-00335146-00335751": "Geneva Convention resolution 608 deeply", "54U_UF4uGkU-01043-00335752-00335970": "regrets that Israel has defied the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01044-00335971-00336240": "United Nations and deported Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-01045-00336241-00337067": "civilians resolution 609 resolution 611", "54U_UF4uGkU-01046-00337068-00337173": "condemned", "54U_UF4uGkU-01047-00337174-00337383": "Israel's assassination of Khalil alwa", "54U_UF4uGkU-01048-00337384-00337566": "Xia as a flagrant violation of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01049-00337567-00338279": "Charter Resolution 613 resolution 617", "54U_UF4uGkU-01050-00338280-00339005": "resolution 624 Resolution 630 relation", "54U_UF4uGkU-01051-00339006-00339657": "633 resolution 636 deeply regrets", "54U_UF4uGkU-01052-00339658-00339876": "Israeli deportation of Palestinian", "54U_UF4uGkU-01053-00339877-00340368": "civilians resolution 639 the 31st of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01054-00340369-00340908": "July 1989 resolution 641 the 30th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01055-00340909-00341379": "August 1989 deplores Israel's continuing", "54U_UF4uGkU-01056-00341380-00341774": "deportation of Palestinians resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01057-00341775-00342329": "645 the 29th of November 1989 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01058-00342330-00342750": "648 the 31st of January 1991 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01059-00342751-00342954": "Security Council extends the Mandate of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01060-00342955-00343191": "the UN interim force in Lebanon until", "54U_UF4uGkU-01061-00343192-00343809": "July 31st 1990 resolution 655 the 31st", "54U_UF4uGkU-01062-00343810-00344360": "of May 1990 resolution 659 the 31st of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01063-00344361-00344727": "July 1990 regards UNIFIL extends the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01064-00344728-00345225": "mandate for UNIFIL resolution 672 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01065-00345226-00345746": "12th of october 1990 condemns israel for", "54U_UF4uGkU-01066-00345747-00346002": "violence against Palestinians at the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01067-00346003-00346412": "haram al-sharif/temple mount resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01068-00346413-00346965": "673 the 24th of october 1990 deplores", "54U_UF4uGkU-01069-00346966-00347187": "israel's refusal to cooperate with the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01070-00347188-00347694": "United Nations resolution 679 the 30th", "54U_UF4uGkU-01071-00347695-00348216": "of November 1990 resolution 681 the 20th", "54U_UF4uGkU-01072-00348217-00348627": "of December 1992 plaus Israel's", "54U_UF4uGkU-01073-00348628-00348795": "resumption of the deportation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01074-00348796-00349278": "Palestinians resolution 684 the 30th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01075-00349279-00349857": "January 1991 resolution 694 the 24th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01076-00349858-00350334": "May 1991 to plaus Israel's deportation", "54U_UF4uGkU-01077-00350335-00350556": "of Palestinians and calls on it to in", "54U_UF4uGkU-01078-00350557-00350804": "they're safe an immediate return", "54U_UF4uGkU-01079-00350805-00351347": "resolution 695 the 30th of May 1991", "54U_UF4uGkU-01080-00351348-00351881": "resolution 701 the 31st of July 1991", "54U_UF4uGkU-01081-00351882-00352448": "resolution 722 the 29th of November 1991", "54U_UF4uGkU-01082-00352449-00353024": "resolution 726 the 6th of January 1992", "54U_UF4uGkU-01083-00353025-00353304": "strongly condemns Israel's deportation", "54U_UF4uGkU-01084-00353305-00353814": "of Palestinians resolution 734 the 29th", "54U_UF4uGkU-01085-00353815-00354408": "of January 1992 resolution 756 the 29th", "54U_UF4uGkU-01086-00354409-00354954": "of May 1992 resolution 768 the 30th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01087-00354955-00355497": "July 1992 resolution 790 the 25th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01088-00355498-00356055": "November 1992 resolution 799 the 18th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01089-00356056-00356454": "December 1992 strongly condemns Israel's", "54U_UF4uGkU-01090-00356455-00356760": "deportation of 413 Palestinians and", "54U_UF4uGkU-01091-00356761-00356999": "calls for their immediate return", "54U_UF4uGkU-01092-00357000-00357539": "resolution 803 the 28th of January 1993", "54U_UF4uGkU-01093-00357540-00358052": "resolution 830 the 26th of May 1993", "54U_UF4uGkU-01094-00358053-00358601": "resolution 852 the 28th of July in 1993", "54U_UF4uGkU-01095-00358602-00359162": "resolution 887 the 29th of November 1993", "54U_UF4uGkU-01096-00359163-00359717": "resolution 895 the 28th of January 1994", "54U_UF4uGkU-01097-00359718-00360144": "resolution 904 the 18th of March 1994", "54U_UF4uGkU-01098-00360145-00360389": "cave of the patriarchs Massacre", "54U_UF4uGkU-01099-00360390-00360864": "resolution 938 the 28th of July 1994", "54U_UF4uGkU-01100-00360865-00361092": "extends Mandate of the United Nations", "54U_UF4uGkU-01101-00361093-00361320": "interim force in Lebanon until January", "54U_UF4uGkU-01102-00361321-00361890": "31st 1995 resolution 1039 the 29th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01103-00361891-00362196": "January 1996 extends Mandate of the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01104-00362197-00362756": "UNIFIL until the 31st of July 1996", "54U_UF4uGkU-01105-00362757-00363086": "resolution 1050 to the 18th of April", "54U_UF4uGkU-01106-00363087-00363581": "1996 resolution 10:57 the 30th of May", "54U_UF4uGkU-01107-00363582-00363912": "1996 resolution 10", "54U_UF4uGkU-01108-00363913-00364380": "68 the 30th of July 1996 resolution 10", "54U_UF4uGkU-01109-00364381-00364749": "73 the 28th of September 1996 on the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01110-00364750-00365124": "status of Jerusalem resolution 10 81 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01111-00365125-00365637": "27th of November 1996 resolution 1095", "54U_UF4uGkU-01112-00365638-00366135": "the 28th of January 1997 resolution 1109", "54U_UF4uGkU-01113-00366136-00366669": "the 28th of May 1997 resolution 11 22", "54U_UF4uGkU-01114-00366670-00367203": "the 29th of July 1997 resolution 1139", "54U_UF4uGkU-01115-00367204-00367650": "the 21st of November 1997 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01116-00367651-00368160": "1151 the 30th of January 1998 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01117-00368161-00368664": "1169 the 27th of May 1998 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01118-00368665-00369144": "1188 the 30th of July 1998 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01119-00369145-00369521": "1211 the 25th of November 1998", "54U_UF4uGkU-01120-00369522-00369861": "resolution 12 23 the 28th of January", "54U_UF4uGkU-01121-00369862-00370365": "1999 resolution 1243 the 27th of May", "54U_UF4uGkU-01122-00370366-00370889": "1999 resolution 12 54 the 30th of July", "54U_UF4uGkU-01123-00370890-00371391": "1999 resolution 12 76 the 24th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01124-00371392-00371889": "November 1999 resolution 1288 the 31st", "54U_UF4uGkU-01125-00371890-00372369": "of January 2000 resolution 1300 the 31st", "54U_UF4uGkU-01126-00372370-00372831": "of May 2000 resolution 1310 the 27th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01127-00372832-00373296": "July 2000 resolution 13 22 the 7th of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01128-00373297-00373548": "October 2000 deployed Ariel Sharon's", "54U_UF4uGkU-01129-00373549-00373704": "visit to the Temple Mount and the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01130-00373705-00374079": "violence that followed resolution 1328", "54U_UF4uGkU-01131-00374080-00374483": "the 27th of November 2000 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01132-00374484-00374991": "1337 the 30th of January 2001 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01133-00374992-00375482": "1351 the 30th of May 2001 resolution", "54U_UF4uGkU-01134-00375483-00375846": "1397 the 12th of March 2002 the first", "54U_UF4uGkU-01135-00375847-00376056": "resolution to explicitly call for a", "54U_UF4uGkU-01136-00376057-00376488": "two-state solution resolution 1435 the", "54U_UF4uGkU-01137-00376489-00376815": "24th of September 2002 demanded an end", "54U_UF4uGkU-01138-00376816-00376971": "to Israeli measures in and around", "54U_UF4uGkU-01139-00376972-00377181": "Ramallah and an Israeli withdrawal to", "54U_UF4uGkU-01140-00377182-00377301": "positions held before", "54U_UF4uGkU-01141-00377302-00377778": "September 2000 resolution 1583 the 28th", "54U_UF4uGkU-01142-00377779-00378088": "of January 2005 calls on Lebanon to", "54U_UF4uGkU-01143-00378089-00378291": "assert full control over its border with", "54U_UF4uGkU-01144-00378292-00378591": "Israel it also states that the council", "54U_UF4uGkU-01145-00378592-00378783": "has recognized the blue line as valid", "54U_UF4uGkU-01146-00378784-00378964": "for the purpose of confirming Israel's", "54U_UF4uGkU-01147-00378965-00379370": "withdrawal pursuant to resolution 425", "54U_UF4uGkU-01148-00379371-00379727": "resolution 1648 the 21st of December", "54U_UF4uGkU-01149-00379728-00380214": "2005 resolution 1701 the 11th of August", "54U_UF4uGkU-01150-00380215-00380478": "2006 called for the full cessation of", "54U_UF4uGkU-01151-00380479-00380765": "hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah", "54U_UF4uGkU-01152-00380766-00381168": "resolution 1860 the 9th of January 2009", "54U_UF4uGkU-01153-00381169-00381364": "called for the full cessation of war", "54U_UF4uGkU-01154-00381365-00381972": "between Israel and Hamas resolution 2334", "54U_UF4uGkU-01155-00381973-00382266": "the 23rd of December 2016 called for an", "54U_UF4uGkU-01156-00382267-00382481": "end to Israeli settlement building", "54U_UF4uGkU-01157-00382482-00382893": "equals equals see also"}}, {"audio_id": "54XGuuII2Fu", "text": {"54XGuuII2Fu-00000-00000026-00000455": "John Sidney McCain three August 29 1936", "54XGuuII2Fu-00001-00000456-00000758": "to August 25th 2018 was an American", "54XGuuII2Fu-00002-00000759-00000947": "politician and military officer who", "54XGuuII2Fu-00003-00000948-00001157": "served as a United States Senator from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00004-00001158-00001439": "Arizona from January 1987 until his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00005-00001440-00001739": "death he previously served two terms in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00006-00001739-00001868": "the United States House of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00007-00001869-00002072": "Representatives and was the Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-00008-00002073-00002246": "nominee for president of the United", "54XGuuII2Fu-00009-00002247-00002477": "States in the 2008 election which he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00010-00002478-00002825": "lost to Barack Obama McCain graduated", "54XGuuII2Fu-00011-00002826-00003043": "from the United States Naval Academy in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00012-00003044-00003250": "1958 and was commissioned into the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00013-00003251-00003532": "United States Navy he became a naval", "54XGuuII2Fu-00014-00003533-00003731": "aviator and flew ground attack aircraft", "54XGuuII2Fu-00015-00003732-00004013": "from aircraft carriers during the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00016-00004014-00004234": "Vietnam War he was almost killed in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00017-00004235-00004606": "1967 USS Forrestal fire while on a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00018-00004607-00004795": "bombing mission during Operation Rolling", "54XGuuII2Fu-00019-00004796-00005138": "Thunder over Hanoi in October 1967 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00020-00005139-00005329": "was shot down seriously injured and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00021-00005330-00005611": "captured by the North Vietnamese he was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00022-00005612-00005918": "a prisoner of war until 1973 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00023-00005919-00006121": "experienced episodes of torture and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00024-00006122-00006293": "refused and out of sequence early", "54XGuuII2Fu-00025-00006294-00006532": "release the wounds that he sustained", "54XGuuII2Fu-00026-00006533-00006713": "during the war left him with lifelong", "54XGuuII2Fu-00027-00006714-00006995": "physical disabilities he retired from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00028-00006995-00007267": "the Navy as a captain in 1981 and moved", "54XGuuII2Fu-00029-00007268-00007563": "to Arizona where he entered politics in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00030-00007564-00007859": "1982 he was elected to the United States", "54XGuuII2Fu-00031-00007859-00008056": "House of Representatives where he served", "54XGuuII2Fu-00032-00008057-00008364": "two terms he entered the US Senate in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00033-00008365-00008627": "1987 and easily won re-election five", "54XGuuII2Fu-00034-00008628-00008981": "times the final time in 2016 while", "54XGuuII2Fu-00035-00008982-00009158": "generally adhering to conservative", "54XGuuII2Fu-00036-00009159-00009367": "principles McCain also had a media", "54XGuuII2Fu-00037-00009368-00009634": "reputation as a maverick for his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00038-00009635-00009809": "willingness to break from his party on", "54XGuuII2Fu-00039-00009810-00010045": "certain issues his stances on gun", "54XGuuII2Fu-00040-00010046-00010252": "control in LGBT issues were", "54XGuuII2Fu-00041-00010253-00010435": "significantly more progressive than the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00042-00010436-00010699": "party's base after being investigated", "54XGuuII2Fu-00043-00010700-00010952": "and largely exonerated in a political", "54XGuuII2Fu-00044-00010953-00011191": "influence scandal of the 1980s as one of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00045-00011192-00011374": "the Keating five he made campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00046-00011375-00011545": "finance reform one of his signature", "54XGuuII2Fu-00047-00011546-00011777": "concerns which eventually resulted in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00048-00011778-00011981": "passage of the mccain-feingold act in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00049-00011982-00012305": "2002 he was also known for his work in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00050-00012306-00012478": "the 1990s to restore diplomatic", "54XGuuII2Fu-00051-00012479-00012709": "relations with Vietnam and for his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00052-00012710-00012877": "belief that the Iraq war should have", "54XGuuII2Fu-00053-00012878-00013047": "been thought to a successful conclusion", "54XGuuII2Fu-00054-00013048-00013271": "he chaired the Senate Commerce Committee", "54XGuuII2Fu-00055-00013272-00013376": "and opposed", "54XGuuII2Fu-00056-00013377-00013597": "pork-barrel spending he belonged to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00057-00013599-00013937": "bipartisan gang of 14 which played a key", "54XGuuII2Fu-00058-00013938-00014119": "role in alleviating a crisis over", "54XGuuII2Fu-00059-00014121-00014453": "judicial nominations McCain entered the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00060-00014454-00014630": "race for the Republican nomination for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00061-00014631-00014872": "president in 2000 but lost a heated", "54XGuuII2Fu-00062-00014874-00015074": "primary season contest to Governor", "54XGuuII2Fu-00063-00015075-00015386": "George W Bush of Texas he secured the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00064-00015387-00015622": "nomination in 2008 after making a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00065-00015624-00015830": "comeback from early reversals but lost", "54XGuuII2Fu-00066-00015831-00016082": "the general election he subsequently", "54XGuuII2Fu-00067-00016083-00016256": "adopted more Orthodox conservative", "54XGuuII2Fu-00068-00016257-00016487": "stances and attitudes and largely", "54XGuuII2Fu-00069-00016488-00016649": "opposed actions of the Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-00070-00016650-00016874": "administration especially with regard to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00071-00016875-00017234": "foreign policy matters by 2013 he had", "54XGuuII2Fu-00072-00017235-00017414": "become a key figure in the Senate for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00073-00017415-00017636": "negotiating deals on certain issues in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00074-00017637-00017872": "an otherwise partisan environment in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00075-00017873-00018140": "2015 he became chairman of the Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-00076-00018141-00018401": "Armed Services Committee he refused to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00077-00018402-00018587": "support then Republican presidential", "54XGuuII2Fu-00078-00018588-00018929": "nominee Donald Trump in 2016 after a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00079-00018930-00019241": "diagnosis of brain cancer in 2017 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00080-00019242-00019439": "reduced his role in the Senate to focus", "54XGuuII2Fu-00081-00019440-00019685": "on treatment before dying on August 25th", "54XGuuII2Fu-00082-00019686-00019955": "2018 four days before his 82nd birthday", "54XGuuII2Fu-00083-00019956-00020174": "his family had announced the previous", "54XGuuII2Fu-00084-00020175-00020324": "day that the treatment for his cancer", "54XGuuII2Fu-00085-00020325-00020612": "would cease following McCain's death he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00086-00020613-00020777": "lay in state in the United States", "54XGuuII2Fu-00087-00020778-00020981": "Capitol rotunda and his funeral was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00088-00020982-00021167": "televised from Washington National", "54XGuuII2Fu-00089-00021168-00021571": "Cathedral", "54XGuuII2Fu-00090-00021572-00021840": "topic early life and military career", "54XGuuII2Fu-00091-00021841-00022432": "1936 to 1981", "54XGuuII2Fu-00092-00022433-00023001": "topic early life and education", "54XGuuII2Fu-00093-00023002-00023304": "John Sidney McCain 3 was born on August", "54XGuuII2Fu-00094-00023305-00023703": "29 1936 at Koko solo Naval Air Station", "54XGuuII2Fu-00095-00023704-00023889": "in the Panama Canal Zone two naval", "54XGuuII2Fu-00096-00023890-00024138": "officer John s McCain jr. and Roberta", "54XGuuII2Fu-00097-00024139-00024375": "Wright McCain he had an older sister", "54XGuuII2Fu-00098-00024376-00024663": "sandy and a younger brother Joe at that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00099-00024664-00024879": "time the Panama Canal was under US", "54XGuuII2Fu-00100-00024880-00025188": "control McCain's family tree includes", "54XGuuII2Fu-00101-00025189-00025461": "scots-irish and English ancestors his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00102-00025462-00025692": "father and his paternal grandfather John", "54XGuuII2Fu-00103-00025693-00025956": "s McCain senior were also Naval Academy", "54XGuuII2Fu-00104-00025957-00026163": "graduates and both became four-star", "54XGuuII2Fu-00105-00026164-00026463": "United States Navy Admirals the McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00106-00026464-00026670": "family followed his father to various", "54XGuuII2Fu-00107-00026670-00026892": "naval postings in the United States and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00108-00026893-00027087": "the Pacific all together he attended", "54XGuuII2Fu-00109-00027088-00027462": "about 20 schools in 1951 the family", "54XGuuII2Fu-00110-00027463-00027657": "settled in Northern Virginia and McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00111-00027658-00027860": "attended Episcopal High School a private", "54XGuuII2Fu-00112-00027861-00028052": "preparatory boarding school in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00113-00028054-00028341": "Alexandria he excelled at wrestling and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00114-00028342-00028656": "graduated in 1954 he referred to himself", "54XGuuII2Fu-00115-00028657-00028913": "as an Episcopalian as recently as June", "54XGuuII2Fu-00116-00028914-00029177": "2007 after which date he said he came to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00117-00029179-00029477": "identify as a Baptist following in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00118-00029479-00029633": "footsteps of his father and grandfather", "54XGuuII2Fu-00119-00029633-00029889": "McCain entered the United States Naval", "54XGuuII2Fu-00120-00029889-00030192": "Academy at Annapolis he was a friend an", "54XGuuII2Fu-00121-00030193-00030363": "informal leader there for many of his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00122-00030364-00030570": "classmates and sometimes stood up for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00123-00030570-00030825": "targets of bullying he also became a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00124-00030826-00031077": "lightweight boxer McCain did well in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00125-00031077-00031293": "academic subjects that interested him", "54XGuuII2Fu-00126-00031294-00031491": "such as literature in history but", "54XGuuII2Fu-00127-00031492-00031692": "studied only enough to pass subjects", "54XGuuII2Fu-00128-00031693-00031857": "that gave him difficulty such as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00129-00031858-00032127": "mathematics he came into conflict with", "54XGuuII2Fu-00130-00032127-00032313": "high-ranking personnel and did not", "54XGuuII2Fu-00131-00032314-00032544": "always obey the rules which contributed", "54XGuuII2Fu-00132-00032545-00032946": "to a low class rank 894 of 899 despite a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00133-00032947-00033670": "high IQ McCain graduated in 1958", "54XGuuII2Fu-00134-00033671-00033907": "topic naval training first marriage and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00135-00033908-00034353": "Vietnam War assignment", "54XGuuII2Fu-00136-00034354-00034617": "mccain began his early military career", "54XGuuII2Fu-00137-00034618-00034761": "when he was commissioned as an ensign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00138-00034762-00034953": "and started two and a half years of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00139-00034954-00035166": "training at Pensacola to become a naval", "54XGuuII2Fu-00140-00035167-00035400": "aviator while there he earned a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00141-00035401-00035592": "reputation as a man who partied", "54XGuuII2Fu-00142-00035593-00035922": "he completed flight school in 1960 and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00143-00035923-00036117": "became a naval pilot of ground attack", "54XGuuII2Fu-00144-00036118-00036303": "aircraft he was assigned to a-1", "54XGuuII2Fu-00145-00036304-00036513": "skyraider squadrons aboard the aircraft", "54XGuuII2Fu-00146-00036514-00036816": "carriers USS Intrepid and USS Enterprise", "54XGuuII2Fu-00147-00036817-00037046": "in the Caribbean and Mediterranean Seas", "54XGuuII2Fu-00148-00037047-00037347": "McCain began as a subpar flyer who was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00149-00037348-00037548": "at times careless and reckless during", "54XGuuII2Fu-00150-00037549-00037806": "the early to mid-1960s two of his flight", "54XGuuII2Fu-00151-00037807-00037989": "missions crashed and a third mission", "54XGuuII2Fu-00152-00037990-00038148": "collided with power lines but he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00153-00038149-00038439": "received no major injuries his aviation", "54XGuuII2Fu-00154-00038440-00038658": "skills improved over time and he was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00155-00038659-00038850": "seen as a good pilot albeit one who", "54XGuuII2Fu-00156-00038851-00039126": "tended to push the envelope in his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00157-00039127-00039627": "flying at age 28 on July 3rd 1965 became", "54XGuuII2Fu-00158-00039628-00039822": "married Karol Shep who was a model from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00159-00039823-00040101": "Philadelphia McCain adopted her two", "54XGuuII2Fu-00160-00040102-00040335": "young children Douglas Doug and Andrew", "54XGuuII2Fu-00161-00040336-00040605": "Andy he and Carol then had a daughter", "54XGuuII2Fu-00162-00040606-00040845": "named Sydney McCain requested a combat", "54XGuuII2Fu-00163-00040846-00040998": "assignment and was assigned to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00164-00040999-00041286": "aircraft carrier USS Forrestal flying a4", "54XGuuII2Fu-00165-00041287-00041607": "Skyhawks his combat duty began when he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00166-00041608-00041907": "was 30 years old in mid-1968 when", "54XGuuII2Fu-00167-00041908-00042066": "Forrestal was assigned to a bombing", "54XGuuII2Fu-00168-00042067-00042249": "campaign Operation Rolling Thunder", "54XGuuII2Fu-00169-00042250-00042567": "during the Vietnam War stationed in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00170-00042568-00042759": "Gulf of Tonkin McCain and his fellow", "54XGuuII2Fu-00171-00042760-00042927": "pilots became frustrated by", "54XGuuII2Fu-00172-00042928-00043131": "micromanagement from Washington and he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00173-00043132-00043371": "later wrote in all candor we thought our", "54XGuuII2Fu-00174-00043372-00043599": "civilian commanders were complete idiots", "54XGuuII2Fu-00175-00043600-00043791": "who didn't have the least notion of what", "54XGuuII2Fu-00176-00043792-00044241": "it took to win the war on July 29 1967", "54XGuuII2Fu-00177-00044242-00044454": "McCain was a lieutenant commander when", "54XGuuII2Fu-00178-00044455-00044613": "he was near the center of the USS", "54XGuuII2Fu-00179-00044614-00044877": "Forrestal fire he escaped from his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00180-00044878-00045036": "burning jet and was trying to help", "54XGuuII2Fu-00181-00045037-00045210": "another pilot escape when a bomb", "54XGuuII2Fu-00182-00045211-00045426": "exploded McCain was struck in the legs", "54XGuuII2Fu-00183-00045427-00045720": "and chest by fragments the ensuing fire", "54XGuuII2Fu-00184-00045721-00046068": "killed 134 sailors and took 24 hours to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00185-00046069-00046305": "control with the Forrestal out of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00186-00046306-00046476": "commission became volunteered for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00187-00046477-00046713": "assignment with the USS Oriskany another", "54XGuuII2Fu-00188-00046714-00046941": "aircraft carrier employed in Operation", "54XGuuII2Fu-00189-00046942-00047199": "Rolling Thunder there he was awarded the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00190-00047200-00047388": "Navy Commendation Medal and the Bronze", "54XGuuII2Fu-00191-00047389-00047598": "Star medal for missions flown over North", "54XGuuII2Fu-00192-00047599-00047926": "Vietnam", "54XGuuII2Fu-00193-00047927-00048436": "topic prisoner-of-war", "54XGuuII2Fu-00194-00048437-00048637": "mccain's capture and subsequent", "54XGuuII2Fu-00195-00048638-00049020": "imprisonment occurred on october 26 1967", "54XGuuII2Fu-00196-00049021-00049327": "he was flying his 23rd bombing mission", "54XGuuII2Fu-00197-00049328-00049593": "over North Vietnam when his a4e sky Hawk", "54XGuuII2Fu-00198-00049594-00049800": "was shot down by a missile over Hanoi", "54XGuuII2Fu-00199-00049801-00050089": "McCain fractured both arms in a leg when", "54XGuuII2Fu-00200-00050090-00050284": "he ejected from the aircraft and nearly", "54XGuuII2Fu-00201-00050285-00050479": "drowned after he parachuted into truck", "54XGuuII2Fu-00202-00050480-00050764": "Bock lake some North Vietnamese pulled", "54XGuuII2Fu-00203-00050765-00050923": "him ashore than others crushed his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00204-00050924-00051112": "shoulder with a rifle but and banded at", "54XGuuII2Fu-00205-00051113-00051385": "him McCain was then transported to Hanoi", "54XGuuII2Fu-00206-00051386-00051649": "'s main Wallow prison nicknamed de pano", "54XGuuII2Fu-00207-00051650-00051907": "Hilton although McCain was seriously", "54XGuuII2Fu-00208-00051908-00052132": "wounded and injured his captors refused", "54XGuuII2Fu-00209-00052133-00052389": "to treat him they beat and interrogated", "54XGuuII2Fu-00210-00052390-00052579": "him to get information and he was given", "54XGuuII2Fu-00211-00052579-00052732": "medical care only when the North", "54XGuuII2Fu-00212-00052733-00052905": "Vietnamese discovered that his father", "54XGuuII2Fu-00213-00052907-00053197": "was an admiral his status as a prisoner", "54XGuuII2Fu-00214-00053198-00053430": "of war Pao made the front pages of major", "54XGuuII2Fu-00215-00053432-00053674": "American newspapers McCain spent six", "54XGuuII2Fu-00216-00053675-00053860": "weeks in the hospital where he received", "54XGuuII2Fu-00217-00053861-00054220": "marginal care he had lost 50 pounds 23", "54XGuuII2Fu-00218-00054221-00054448": "kilograms was in a chest cast and his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00219-00054449-00054709": "gray hair had turned white McCain was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00220-00054710-00054850": "sent to a different camp on the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00221-00054851-00055201": "outskirts of Hanoi in December 1967", "54XGuuII2Fu-00222-00055202-00055416": "McCain was placed in a cell with two", "54XGuuII2Fu-00223-00055417-00055605": "other Americans who did not expect him", "54XGuuII2Fu-00224-00055607-00055929": "to live more than a week in March 1968", "54XGuuII2Fu-00225-00055930-00056134": "McCain was placed into solitary", "54XGuuII2Fu-00226-00056135-00056307": "confinement where he remained for two", "54XGuuII2Fu-00227-00056308-00056635": "years in mid-1968 his father John s", "54XGuuII2Fu-00228-00056636-00056869": "McCain jr. was named commander of all US", "54XGuuII2Fu-00229-00056870-00057066": "forces in the Vietnam Theater and the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00230-00057067-00057265": "North Vietnamese offered McCain early", "54XGuuII2Fu-00231-00057266-00057424": "release because they wanted to appear", "54XGuuII2Fu-00232-00057425-00057634": "merciful for propaganda purposes and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00233-00057635-00057807": "also to show other pals that elite", "54XGuuII2Fu-00234-00057808-00057961": "prisoners were willing to be treated", "54XGuuII2Fu-00235-00057962-00058207": "preferentially McCain refused", "54XGuuII2Fu-00236-00058208-00058450": "repatriation unless every man taken in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00237-00058451-00058732": "before him was also released such early", "54XGuuII2Fu-00238-00058733-00058915": "release was prohibited by the Pao's", "54XGuuII2Fu-00239-00058916-00059116": "interpretation of the military code of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00240-00059116-00059386": "conduct which states in article 3 I will", "54XGuuII2Fu-00241-00059387-00059659": "accept neither parole nor special favors", "54XGuuII2Fu-00242-00059660-00059929": "from the enemy to prevent the enemy from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00243-00059929-00060169": "using prisoners for propaganda officers", "54XGuuII2Fu-00244-00060170-00060322": "were to agree to be released in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00245-00060323-00060466": "order in which they were captured", "54XGuuII2Fu-00246-00060466-00060744": "beginning in August 1968 McCain was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00247-00060745-00060966": "subjected to a program of severe torture", "54XGuuII2Fu-00248-00060967-00061210": "he was bound and beaten every two hours", "54XGuuII2Fu-00249-00061211-00061407": "this punishment occurred at the same", "54XGuuII2Fu-00250-00061408-00061585": "time that he was suffering from heat and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00251-00061586-00061700": "dysentery", "54XGuuII2Fu-00252-00061701-00061940": "further injuries brought McCain to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00253-00061941-00062207": "point of suicide but his preparations", "54XGuuII2Fu-00254-00062208-00062453": "were interrupted by guards eventually", "54XGuuII2Fu-00255-00062454-00062677": "McCain made an anti-us propaganda", "54XGuuII2Fu-00256-00062678-00062972": "confession he had always felt that his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00257-00062973-00063158": "statement was dishonorable but as he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00258-00063159-00063362": "later wrote I had learned what we all", "54XGuuII2Fu-00259-00063363-00063566": "learned over there every man has his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00260-00063566-00063679": "breaking point", "54XGuuII2Fu-00261-00063680-00064034": "I had reached mine many us Powell's were", "54XGuuII2Fu-00262-00064035-00064226": "tortured and maltreated in order to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00263-00064227-00064516": "extract confessions and propaganda", "54XGuuII2Fu-00264-00064517-00064694": "statements virtually all of them", "54XGuuII2Fu-00265-00064695-00064859": "eventually yielded something to their", "54XGuuII2Fu-00266-00064860-00065141": "captors McCain received two to three", "54XGuuII2Fu-00267-00065141-00065348": "beatings weekly because of his continued", "54XGuuII2Fu-00268-00065349-00065546": "refusal to sign additional statements", "54XGuuII2Fu-00269-00065547-00065765": "McCain refused to meet various anti-war", "54XGuuII2Fu-00270-00065766-00065987": "groups seeking peace in Hanoi wanting to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00271-00065988-00066110": "give neither them nor the North", "54XGuuII2Fu-00272-00066111-00066389": "Vietnamese a propaganda victory from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00273-00066390-00066686": "late 1969 treatment of McCain and many", "54XGuuII2Fu-00274-00066687-00066893": "of the other pouce became more tolerable", "54XGuuII2Fu-00275-00066894-00067067": "while McCain continued to resist the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00276-00067068-00067304": "camp authorities McCain and other", "54XGuuII2Fu-00277-00067305-00067541": "prisoners cheered the US Christmas", "54XGuuII2Fu-00278-00067542-00067847": "bombing campaign of December 1972", "54XGuuII2Fu-00279-00067848-00068075": "viewing it as a forceful measure to push", "54XGuuII2Fu-00280-00068076-00068288": "North Vietnam to terms McCain was a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00281-00068289-00068492": "prisoner of war in North Vietnam for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00282-00068493-00068675": "five and a half years until his release", "54XGuuII2Fu-00283-00068676-00069086": "on March 14 1973 his wartime injuries", "54XGuuII2Fu-00284-00069087-00069260": "left him permanently incapable of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00285-00069261-00069485": "raising his arms above his head after", "54XGuuII2Fu-00286-00069486-00069728": "the war McCain returned to the site with", "54XGuuII2Fu-00287-00069729-00069914": "his wife Cindy and family on a few", "54XGuuII2Fu-00288-00069915-00070088": "occasions to try to come to terms with", "54XGuuII2Fu-00289-00070089-00070229": "what happened to him there during his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00290-00070230-00070553": "capture", "54XGuuII2Fu-00291-00070554-00070868": "topic commanding officer liaison to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00292-00070869-00071302": "Senate and second marriage", "54XGuuII2Fu-00293-00071303-00071563": "mccain was reunited with his family when", "54XGuuII2Fu-00294-00071564-00071743": "he returned to the united states", "54XGuuII2Fu-00295-00071744-00072025": "his wife carol had also been crippled by", "54XGuuII2Fu-00296-00072026-00072310": "an automobile accident in december 1969", "54XGuuII2Fu-00297-00072311-00072649": "as a returned POW he became a celebrity", "54XGuuII2Fu-00298-00072650-00072904": "of sorts McCain underwent treatment for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00299-00072905-00073072": "his injuries that included months of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00300-00073073-00073312": "physical therapy he attended the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00301-00073313-00073540": "National War College at Fort McNair in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00302-00073541-00074020": "Washington DC during 1973 1974 he was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00303-00074021-00074308": "rehabilitated by late 1974 and his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00304-00074309-00074713": "flight status was reinstated in 1976 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00305-00074714-00074896": "became commanding officer of a training", "54XGuuII2Fu-00306-00074897-00075103": "squadron that was stationed in Florida", "54XGuuII2Fu-00307-00075104-00075370": "he improved the unit's flight readiness", "54XGuuII2Fu-00308-00075371-00075580": "and safety records and won the squadron", "54XGuuII2Fu-00309-00075581-00075730": "its first ever Meritorious Unit", "54XGuuII2Fu-00310-00075731-00076009": "Commendation during this period in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00311-00076010-00076243": "Florida he had extramarital affairs and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00312-00076244-00076441": "his marriage began to falter about which", "54XGuuII2Fu-00313-00076442-00076633": "he later stated the blame was entirely", "54XGuuII2Fu-00314-00076634-00076879": "mine McCain served as the Navy's liaison", "54XGuuII2Fu-00315-00076880-00077199": "to the US Senate beginning in 1977 in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00316-00077200-00077458": "retrospect he said that this represented", "54XGuuII2Fu-00317-00077459-00077611": "his real entry into the world of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00318-00077612-00077824": "politics and the beginning of my second", "54XGuuII2Fu-00319-00077825-00078010": "career as a public servant his key", "54XGuuII2Fu-00320-00078011-00078157": "behind-the-scenes role gained", "54XGuuII2Fu-00321-00078158-00078364": "congressional financing for a new super", "54XGuuII2Fu-00322-00078365-00078550": "carrier against the wishes of the Carter", "54XGuuII2Fu-00323-00078551-00078883": "Administration in April 1979 McCain met", "54XGuuII2Fu-00324-00078884-00079120": "Cindy Lou Hensley a teacher from Phoenix", "54XGuuII2Fu-00325-00079121-00079330": "Arizona whose father had founded a large", "54XGuuII2Fu-00326-00079331-00079594": "beer distributorship they began dating", "54XGuuII2Fu-00327-00079595-00079813": "and he urged his wife Carol to grant him", "54XGuuII2Fu-00328-00079814-00080059": "a divorce which she did in February 1980", "54XGuuII2Fu-00329-00080060-00080278": "the uncontested divorce took effect in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00330-00080279-00080599": "April 1980 the settlement included two", "54XGuuII2Fu-00331-00080600-00080806": "houses and financial support for her", "54XGuuII2Fu-00332-00080807-00080994": "ongoing medical treatments do to her", "54XGuuII2Fu-00333-00080995-00081265": "1969 car accident they remained on good", "54XGuuII2Fu-00334-00081266-00081556": "terms McCain and Hensley were married on", "54XGuuII2Fu-00335-00081557-00081835": "May 17th 1980 with Senators William", "54XGuuII2Fu-00336-00081836-00082006": "Cohan and Gary Hart attending his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00337-00082007-00082249": "groomsmen McCain's children did not", "54XGuuII2Fu-00338-00082250-00082456": "attend and several years passed before", "54XGuuII2Fu-00339-00082457-00082744": "they reconciled John and Cindy McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00340-00082745-00082951": "entered into a prenuptial agreement that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00341-00082952-00083149": "kept most of her family's assets under", "54XGuuII2Fu-00342-00083150-00083362": "her name they kept their finances apart", "54XGuuII2Fu-00343-00083363-00083598": "and filed separate income tax returns", "54XGuuII2Fu-00344-00083599-00083902": "McCain decided to leave the Navy it was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00345-00083903-00084046": "doubtful whether he would ever be", "54XGuuII2Fu-00346-00084047-00084244": "promoted to the rank of full Admiral as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00347-00084245-00084454": "he had poor annual physicals and had not", "54XGuuII2Fu-00348-00084455-00084651": "been given a major C command", "54XGuuII2Fu-00349-00084652-00084876": "his chances of being promoted to Rear", "54XGuuII2Fu-00350-00084877-00085074": "Admiral were better but he declined that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00351-00085075-00085296": "prospect as he had already made plans to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00352-00085297-00085485": "run for Congress and said he could do", "54XGuuII2Fu-00353-00085486-00085686": "more good there McCain retired from the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00354-00085687-00086070": "Navy on April 1st 1981 as a captain he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00355-00086071-00086295": "was designated as disabled and awarded a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00356-00086296-00086523": "disability pension upon leaving the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00357-00086524-00086751": "military he moved to Arizona his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00358-00086752-00086961": "numerous military decorations and awards", "54XGuuII2Fu-00359-00086962-00087141": "include the Silver Star", "54XGuuII2Fu-00360-00087142-00087348": "- Legion of Merit Distinguished Flying", "54XGuuII2Fu-00361-00087349-00087588": "Cross three Bronze Star medals two", "54XGuuII2Fu-00362-00087589-00087780": "Purple Hearts two Navy and Marine Corps", "54XGuuII2Fu-00363-00087781-00088002": "Commendation medals and the Prisoner of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00364-00088003-00088272": "War medal topic House and Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-00365-00088273-00088629": "elections in career 1982 to 2000 topic", "54XGuuII2Fu-00366-00088630-00088851": "US Representative McCain set his sights", "54XGuuII2Fu-00367-00088852-00089043": "on becoming a representative because he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00368-00089044-00089226": "was interested in current events was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00369-00089227-00089379": "ready for a new challenge and had", "54XGuuII2Fu-00370-00089380-00089574": "developed political ambitions during his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00371-00089575-00089865": "time as Senate liaison living in Phoenix", "54XGuuII2Fu-00372-00089866-00090087": "he went to work for Hensley and Coe his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00373-00090088-00090309": "new father-in-law Jim Hensley's large", "54XGuuII2Fu-00374-00090310-00090594": "anheuser-busch beer distributorship as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00375-00090595-00090822": "vice president of public relations at", "54XGuuII2Fu-00376-00090823-00091014": "the distributorship he gained political", "54XGuuII2Fu-00377-00091015-00091170": "support among the local business", "54XGuuII2Fu-00378-00091171-00091392": "community meeting powerful figures such", "54XGuuII2Fu-00379-00091393-00091614": "as banker Charles Keating jr. real", "54XGuuII2Fu-00380-00091615-00091836": "estate developer Fife Symington three", "54XGuuII2Fu-00381-00091837-00092061": "later Governor of Arizona and newspaper", "54XGuuII2Fu-00382-00092062-00092238": "publisher Derek Duke Tully", "54XGuuII2Fu-00383-00092239-00092628": "in 1982 McCain ran as a Republican for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00384-00092629-00092799": "an open seat in Arizona's first", "54XGuuII2Fu-00385-00092800-00092976": "congressional district which was being", "54XGuuII2Fu-00386-00092977-00093213": "vacated by 30-year incumbent Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-00387-00093214-00093486": "John Jacob Rhodes a newcomer to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00388-00093487-00093678": "state McCain was hit with charges of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00389-00093679-00093978": "being a carpetbagger McCain responded to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00390-00093979-00094146": "a voter making that charge with what a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00391-00094147-00094311": "Phoenix Gazette columnist later", "54XGuuII2Fu-00392-00094312-00094545": "described as the most devastating", "54XGuuII2Fu-00393-00094546-00094752": "response to a potentially troublesome", "54XGuuII2Fu-00394-00094753-00095084": "political issue I've ever heard", "54XGuuII2Fu-00395-00095085-00095430": "listen pal I spent 22 years in the Navy", "54XGuuII2Fu-00396-00095431-00095745": "my father was in the Navy my grandfather", "54XGuuII2Fu-00397-00095746-00095967": "was in the Navy we in the military", "54XGuuII2Fu-00398-00095968-00096177": "service tend to move a lot we have to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00399-00096178-00096354": "live in all parts of the country all", "54XGuuII2Fu-00400-00096355-00096606": "parts of the world I wish I could have", "54XGuuII2Fu-00401-00096607-00096807": "had the luxury like you of growing up", "54XGuuII2Fu-00402-00096808-00097002": "and living and spending my entire life", "54XGuuII2Fu-00403-00097003-00097206": "in a nice place like the first District", "54XGuuII2Fu-00404-00097207-00097374": "of Arizona but I was doing other things", "54XGuuII2Fu-00405-00097375-00097659": "as a matter of fact when I think about", "54XGuuII2Fu-00406-00097660-00097731": "it now", "54XGuuII2Fu-00407-00097732-00097929": "the place I lived longest in my life was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00408-00097930-00098034": "Hanoi", "54XGuuII2Fu-00409-00098035-00098289": "McCain won a highly contested primary", "54XGuuII2Fu-00410-00098290-00098445": "election with the assistance of local", "54XGuuII2Fu-00411-00098446-00098685": "political endorsements his Washington", "54XGuuII2Fu-00412-00098686-00098877": "connections and money that his wife lent", "54XGuuII2Fu-00413-00098878-00098970": "to his campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00414-00098971-00099186": "he then easily won the general election", "54XGuuII2Fu-00415-00099187-00099512": "in the heavily Republican district in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00416-00099513-00099762": "1983 McCain was elected to lead the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00417-00099763-00099921": "incoming group of Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-00418-00099922-00100110": "representatives and was assigned to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00419-00100111-00100380": "House Committee on interior affairs also", "54XGuuII2Fu-00420-00100381-00100611": "that year he opposed creation of a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00421-00100612-00100842": "federal Martin Luther King jr. day but", "54XGuuII2Fu-00422-00100843-00101103": "admitted in 2008 I was wrong and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00423-00101104-00101352": "eventually realized that in time to give", "54XGuuII2Fu-00424-00101353-00101679": "full support in 1994 a state holiday in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00425-00101680-00102036": "Arizona at this point McCain's politics", "54XGuuII2Fu-00426-00102037-00102189": "were mainly in line with those of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00427-00102190-00102387": "President Ronald Reagan this included", "54XGuuII2Fu-00428-00102388-00102564": "support for Reaganomics and he was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00429-00102565-00102734": "active on Indian Affairs bills", "54XGuuII2Fu-00430-00102735-00103023": "he supported most aspects of the foreign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00431-00103024-00103215": "policy of the Reagan administration", "54XGuuII2Fu-00432-00103216-00103416": "including its hardline stance against", "54XGuuII2Fu-00433-00103417-00103614": "the Soviet Union and policy towards", "54XGuuII2Fu-00434-00103615-00103808": "Central American conflicts such as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00435-00103809-00104103": "backing the Contras in Nicaragua McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00436-00104104-00104331": "opposed keeping US Marines deployed in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00437-00104332-00104565": "Lebanon citing unattainable objectives", "54XGuuII2Fu-00438-00104566-00104783": "and subsequently criticized President", "54XGuuII2Fu-00439-00104784-00104955": "Reagan for pulling out the troops too", "54XGuuII2Fu-00440-00104956-00105185": "late in the interim the 1983 Beirut", "54XGuuII2Fu-00441-00105186-00105489": "barracks bombing killed hundreds McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00442-00105490-00105696": "won re-election to the House easily in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00443-00105697-00105927": "1984 and gained a spot on the House", "54XGuuII2Fu-00444-00105928-00106272": "Foreign Affairs Committee in 1985 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00445-00106273-00106433": "made his first return trip to Vietnam", "54XGuuII2Fu-00446-00106434-00106683": "and also traveled to Chile where he met", "54XGuuII2Fu-00447-00106683-00106893": "with its military Hutu ruler General", "54XGuuII2Fu-00448-00106894-00107330": "Augusto Pinochet", "54XGuuII2Fu-00449-00107331-00107786": "topic growing family", "54XGuuII2Fu-00450-00107788-00108120": "in 1984 McCain and Cindy had their first", "54XGuuII2Fu-00451-00108121-00108339": "child together daughter Megan followed", "54XGuuII2Fu-00452-00108340-00108576": "two years later by son John Sydney Jack", "54XGuuII2Fu-00453-00108577-00108985": "IV and in 1988 by son James Jimmy in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00454-00108986-00109272": "1991 Cindy McCain brought an abandoned", "54XGuuII2Fu-00455-00109273-00109449": "three month old girl needing medical", "54XGuuII2Fu-00456-00109450-00109641": "treatment to the u.s. from a Bangladeshi", "54XGuuII2Fu-00457-00109642-00109910": "orphanage run by mother Teresa the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00458-00109911-00110124": "McCain's decided to adopt her and named", "54XGuuII2Fu-00459-00110125-00110454": "her Bridget", "54XGuuII2Fu-00460-00110455-00111058": "topic first two terms in US Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-00461-00111059-00111338": "McCain's Senate career began in January", "54XGuuII2Fu-00462-00111339-00111632": "1987 after he defeated his Democratic", "54XGuuII2Fu-00463-00111633-00111865": "opponent former state legislator Richard", "54XGuuII2Fu-00464-00111866-00112082": "Kimble by 20 percentage points in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00465-00112083-00112394": "1986 election McCain succeeded a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00466-00112395-00112631": "longtime American conservative icon and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00467-00112632-00112861": "Arizona fixture Barry Goldwater upon the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00468-00112863-00113053": "latter's retirement as US senator from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00469-00113054-00113393": "Arizona Senator McCain became a member", "54XGuuII2Fu-00470-00113394-00113573": "of the Armed Services Committee with", "54XGuuII2Fu-00471-00113574-00113740": "which he had formerly done his Navy", "54XGuuII2Fu-00472-00113741-00113969": "liaison work he also joined the Commerce", "54XGuuII2Fu-00473-00113970-00114095": "Committee and the Indian Affairs", "54XGuuII2Fu-00474-00114096-00114160": "Committee", "54XGuuII2Fu-00475-00114161-00114383": "he continued to support the Native", "54XGuuII2Fu-00476-00114383-00114650": "American agenda as first a House member", "54XGuuII2Fu-00477-00114651-00114875": "and then a senator and as a lifelong", "54XGuuII2Fu-00478-00114876-00115076": "gambler with close ties to the gambling", "54XGuuII2Fu-00479-00115077-00115303": "industry McCain was one of the main", "54XGuuII2Fu-00480-00115304-00115547": "authors of the 1988 Indian Gaming", "54XGuuII2Fu-00481-00115548-00115727": "Regulatory act which codified rules", "54XGuuII2Fu-00482-00115728-00115946": "regarding Native American gambling", "54XGuuII2Fu-00483-00115947-00116225": "enterprises McCain was also a strong", "54XGuuII2Fu-00484-00116226-00116381": "supporter of the gramm-rudman", "54XGuuII2Fu-00485-00116382-00116588": "legislation that enforced automatic", "54XGuuII2Fu-00486-00116589-00116764": "spending cuts in the case of budget", "54XGuuII2Fu-00487-00116765-00116953": "deficits McCain soon gained national", "54XGuuII2Fu-00488-00116954-00117251": "visibility he delivered a well-received", "54XGuuII2Fu-00489-00117252-00117533": "speech at the 1988 Republican National", "54XGuuII2Fu-00490-00117533-00117739": "Convention was mentioned by the press as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00491-00117740-00117920": "a short list vice-presidential running", "54XGuuII2Fu-00492-00117921-00118157": "mate for Republican nominee George HW", "54XGuuII2Fu-00493-00118158-00118402": "Bush and was named chairman of veterans", "54XGuuII2Fu-00494-00118403-00118607": "for Bush McCain became embroiled in a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00495-00118608-00118847": "scandal during the 1980s as one of five", "54XGuuII2Fu-00496-00118848-00119075": "United States senators comprising the so", "54XGuuII2Fu-00497-00119076-00119491": "called Keating 5 between 1982 and 1987", "54XGuuII2Fu-00498-00119492-00119803": "McCain had received 112 thousand dollars", "54XGuuII2Fu-00499-00119804-00120020": "in lawful political contributions from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00500-00120021-00120241": "Charles Keating jr. and his associates", "54XGuuII2Fu-00501-00120242-00120466": "at Lincoln Savings and Loan Association", "54XGuuII2Fu-00502-00120467-00120658": "along with trips on Keating's jets that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00503-00120659-00121141": "McCain belatedly repaid in 1989 in 1987", "54XGuuII2Fu-00504-00121142-00121354": "McCain was one of the five senators whom", "54XGuuII2Fu-00505-00121355-00121540": "Keating contacted in order to prevent", "54XGuuII2Fu-00506-00121541-00121711": "the government seizure of Lincoln and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00507-00121713-00121931": "McCain met twice with federal regulators", "54XGuuII2Fu-00508-00121932-00122059": "to discuss the government's", "54XGuuII2Fu-00509-00122060-00122423": "investigation of Lincoln in 1999 McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00510-00122424-00122710": "said the appearance of it was wrong it's", "54XGuuII2Fu-00511-00122711-00122900": "a wrong appearance when a group of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00512-00122901-00123083": "senators appear in a meeting with a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00513-00123083-00123302": "group of regulators because it conveys", "54XGuuII2Fu-00514-00123303-00123527": "the impression of undue and improper", "54XGuuII2Fu-00515-00123528-00123794": "influence and it was the wrong thing to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00516-00123795-00124088": "do in the end McCain was cleared by the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00517-00124089-00124258": "Senate Ethics Committee of acting", "54XGuuII2Fu-00518-00124259-00124454": "improperly or violating any law", "54XGuuII2Fu-00519-00124455-00124679": "Senate rule but was mildly rebuked for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00520-00124680-00125046": "exercising poor judgment in his 1992", "54XGuuII2Fu-00521-00125047-00125283": "re-election bid the Keating five affair", "54XGuuII2Fu-00522-00125283-00125498": "was not a major issue and he won handily", "54XGuuII2Fu-00523-00125499-00125762": "gaining 56% of the vote to defeat", "54XGuuII2Fu-00524-00125763-00125963": "Democratic community and civil rights", "54XGuuII2Fu-00525-00125964-00126185": "activist Claire Sargent and independent", "54XGuuII2Fu-00526-00126186-00126483": "former governor Evan Mecham McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00527-00126483-00126693": "developed a reputation for independence", "54XGuuII2Fu-00528-00126694-00126938": "during the 1990s he took pride in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00529-00126939-00127124": "challenging party leadership and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00530-00127125-00127340": "establishment forces becoming difficult", "54XGuuII2Fu-00531-00127341-00127652": "to categorize politically as a member of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00532-00127653-00127976": "the 1991 to 1993 Senate Select Committee", "54XGuuII2Fu-00533-00127977-00128228": "on pow/mia Affairs chaired by fellow", "54XGuuII2Fu-00534-00128229-00128465": "Vietnam War veteran and Democrat John", "54XGuuII2Fu-00535-00128466-00128699": "Kerry McCain investigated the Vietnam", "54XGuuII2Fu-00536-00128700-00128943": "War pow/mia issue to determine the fate", "54XGuuII2Fu-00537-00128944-00129137": "of US service personnel listed as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00538-00129138-00129320": "missing in action during the Vietnam War", "54XGuuII2Fu-00539-00129321-00129611": "the committee's unanimous report stated", "54XGuuII2Fu-00540-00129612-00129848": "there was no compelling evidence that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00541-00129849-00130076": "proves that any American remains alive", "54XGuuII2Fu-00542-00130077-00130451": "in captivity in Southeast Asia helped by", "54XGuuII2Fu-00543-00130452-00130712": "McCain's efforts in 1995 the u.s.", "54XGuuII2Fu-00544-00130713-00130920": "normalized diplomatic relations with", "54XGuuII2Fu-00545-00130921-00131210": "Vietnam McCain was vilified by some", "54XGuuII2Fu-00546-00131211-00131411": "pow/mia activists who despite the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00547-00131412-00131591": "committee's unanimous report believed", "54XGuuII2Fu-00548-00131592-00131760": "large numbers of Americans were still", "54XGuuII2Fu-00549-00131761-00131943": "held against their will in Southeast", "54XGuuII2Fu-00550-00131944-00132309": "Asia from January 1993 until his death", "54XGuuII2Fu-00551-00132310-00132524": "McCain was chairman of the International", "54XGuuII2Fu-00552-00132525-00132744": "Republican Institute an organization", "54XGuuII2Fu-00553-00132745-00132950": "partly funded by the US government that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00554-00132951-00133143": "supports the emergence of political", "54XGuuII2Fu-00555-00133144-00133506": "democracy worldwide in 1993 and 1994", "54XGuuII2Fu-00556-00133507-00133707": "McCain voted to confirm President", "54XGuuII2Fu-00557-00133708-00133898": "Clinton's nominees Stephen Breyer and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00558-00133899-00134087": "Ruth Bader Ginsburg whom he considered", "54XGuuII2Fu-00559-00134088-00134300": "to be qualified for the US Supreme Court", "54XGuuII2Fu-00560-00134301-00134578": "he later explained that under our", "54XGuuII2Fu-00561-00134579-00134796": "Constitution it is the president's", "54XGuuII2Fu-00562-00134797-00135081": "called to make McCain had also voted to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00563-00135082-00135263": "confirm nominees of presidents Ronald", "54XGuuII2Fu-00564-00135264-00135536": "Reagan and George HW Bush including", "54XGuuII2Fu-00565-00135537-00135764": "Robert Bork and Clarence Thomas McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00566-00135765-00135935": "attacked what he saw as the corrupting", "54XGuuII2Fu-00567-00135936-00136088": "influence of large political", "54XGuuII2Fu-00568-00136089-00136349": "contributions from corporations labor", "54XGuuII2Fu-00569-00136350-00136598": "unions other organizations and wealthy", "54XGuuII2Fu-00570-00136599-00136802": "individuals and he made this his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00571-00136803-00137150": "signature issue starting in 1994 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00572-00137151-00137382": "worked with Democratic Wisconsin Senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-00573-00137383-00137619": "Russ Feingold on campaign finance reform", "54XGuuII2Fu-00574-00137620-00137844": "their mccain-feingold bill attempted to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00575-00137845-00138159": "limits on soft money the efforts of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00576-00138160-00138378": "McCain and Feingold were opposed by some", "54XGuuII2Fu-00577-00138379-00138552": "of the moneyed interests targeted by", "54XGuuII2Fu-00578-00138553-00138750": "incumbents in both parties by those who", "54XGuuII2Fu-00579-00138751-00138945": "felt spending limits impinged on free", "54XGuuII2Fu-00580-00138946-00139091": "political speech and might be", "54XGuuII2Fu-00581-00139092-00139287": "unconstitutional as well and by those", "54XGuuII2Fu-00582-00139288-00139455": "who wanted to counterbalance the power", "54XGuuII2Fu-00583-00139456-00139652": "of what they saw is media bias", "54XGuuII2Fu-00584-00139653-00139890": "despite sympathetic coverage in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00585-00139891-00140052": "media initial versions of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00586-00140053-00140262": "mccain-feingold act were filibustered", "54XGuuII2Fu-00587-00140263-00140430": "and never came to a vote the term", "54XGuuII2Fu-00588-00140431-00140727": "maverick Republican became a label", "54XGuuII2Fu-00589-00140728-00140931": "frequently applied to McCain and he also", "54XGuuII2Fu-00590-00140932-00141045": "used it himself", "54XGuuII2Fu-00591-00141046-00141393": "in 1993 McCain opposed military", "54XGuuII2Fu-00592-00141394-00141675": "operations in Somalia another target of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00593-00141676-00141888": "his was pork barrel spending by Congress", "54XGuuII2Fu-00594-00141889-00142107": "and he actively supported the line-item", "54XGuuII2Fu-00595-00142108-00142362": "veto Act of 1996 which gave the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00596-00142363-00142548": "president power to veto individual", "54XGuuII2Fu-00597-00142549-00142701": "spending items but was ruled", "54XGuuII2Fu-00598-00142702-00142929": "unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00599-00142930-00143283": "1998 in the 1996 presidential election", "54XGuuII2Fu-00600-00143284-00143475": "McCain was again on the short list of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00601-00143476-00143688": "possible vice-presidential picks this", "54XGuuII2Fu-00602-00143689-00143985": "time for Republican nominee Bob Dole the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00603-00143986-00144171": "following year Time magazine named", "54XGuuII2Fu-00604-00144172-00144471": "McCain as one of the 25 most influential", "54XGuuII2Fu-00605-00144472-00144909": "people in America in 1997 McCain became", "54XGuuII2Fu-00606-00144910-00145095": "chairman of the powerful Senate Commerce", "54XGuuII2Fu-00607-00145096-00145266": "Committee he was criticized for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00608-00145267-00145485": "accepting funds from corporations and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00609-00145486-00145665": "businesses under the committee's purview", "54XGuuII2Fu-00610-00145666-00145815": "but in response said the small", "54XGuuII2Fu-00611-00145816-00146022": "contributions he received were not part", "54XGuuII2Fu-00612-00146023-00146196": "of the big-money nature of the campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00613-00146197-00146457": "finance problem McCain took on the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00614-00146458-00146733": "tobacco industry in 1998 proposing", "54XGuuII2Fu-00615-00146734-00146883": "legislation that would increase", "54XGuuII2Fu-00616-00146884-00147063": "cigarette taxes in order to fund", "54XGuuII2Fu-00617-00147064-00147267": "anti-smoking campaigns discourage", "54XGuuII2Fu-00618-00147268-00147477": "teenage smokers increase money for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00619-00147478-00147660": "health research studies and help States", "54XGuuII2Fu-00620-00147661-00147840": "pay for smoking-related health care", "54XGuuII2Fu-00621-00147841-00148092": "costs supported by the Clinton", "54XGuuII2Fu-00622-00148093-00148260": "administration but opposed by the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00623-00148261-00148485": "industry and most Republicans the bill", "54XGuuII2Fu-00624-00148486-00148871": "failed to gain cloture", "54XGuuII2Fu-00625-00148872-00149147": "topic start of third term in the US", "54XGuuII2Fu-00626-00149148-00149506": "Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-00627-00149507-00149799": "in November 1998 McCain won re-election", "54XGuuII2Fu-00628-00149800-00150049": "to a third Senate term he prevailed in a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00629-00150050-00150246": "landslide over his Democratic opponent", "54XGuuII2Fu-00630-00150247-00150552": "environmental lawyer Edie Ranger in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00631-00150553-00150837": "February 1999 Senate trial following the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00632-00150838-00151024": "impeachment of Bill Clinton McCain voted", "54XGuuII2Fu-00633-00151025-00151219": "to convict the President on both the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00634-00151220-00151360": "perjury and obstruction of justice", "54XGuuII2Fu-00635-00151361-00151599": "counts saying Clinton had violated his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00636-00151600-00151929": "sworn oath of office in March 1999", "54XGuuII2Fu-00637-00151930-00152175": "McCain voted to approve the NATO bombing", "54XGuuII2Fu-00638-00152176-00152383": "campaign against the Federal Republic of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00639-00152384-00152550": "Yugoslavia saying that the ongoing", "54XGuuII2Fu-00640-00152551-00152766": "genocide of the Kosovo war must be", "54XGuuII2Fu-00641-00152767-00152974": "stopped and criticizing past Clinton", "54XGuuII2Fu-00642-00152975-00153295": "administration in action later in 1999", "54XGuuII2Fu-00643-00153296-00153489": "McCain shared the Profile in Courage", "54XGuuII2Fu-00644-00153490-00153699": "Award with Feingold for their work in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00645-00153700-00153888": "trying to enact their campaign finance", "54XGuuII2Fu-00646-00153889-00154050": "reform although the bill was still", "54XGuuII2Fu-00647-00154051-00154207": "failing repeated attempts to gain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00648-00154208-00154629": "cloture in August 1999 McCain's memoir", "54XGuuII2Fu-00649-00154630-00154827": "faith of my fathers co-authored with", "54XGuuII2Fu-00650-00154828-00155025": "Mark Salter was published a reviewer", "54XGuuII2Fu-00651-00155026-00155241": "observed that its appearance seems to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00652-00155242-00155398": "have been timed to the unfolding", "54XGuuII2Fu-00653-00155399-00155640": "presidential campaign the most", "54XGuuII2Fu-00654-00155641-00155845": "successful of his writings it received", "54XGuuII2Fu-00655-00155846-00156066": "positive reviews became a best-seller", "54XGuuII2Fu-00656-00156067-00156358": "and was later made into a TV film the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00657-00156359-00156576": "book traces McCain's family background", "54XGuuII2Fu-00658-00156577-00156753": "and childhood covers his time at", "54XGuuII2Fu-00659-00156754-00156949": "Annapolis and his service before and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00660-00156950-00157137": "during the Vietnam War concluding with", "54XGuuII2Fu-00661-00157138-00157431": "his release from captivity in 1973", "54XGuuII2Fu-00662-00157432-00157686": "according to one reviewer it describes", "54XGuuII2Fu-00663-00157687-00157957": "the kind of challenges that most of us", "54XGuuII2Fu-00664-00157958-00158182": "can barely imagine it's a fascinating", "54XGuuII2Fu-00665-00158183-00158833": "history of a remarkable military family", "54XGuuII2Fu-00666-00158834-00159474": "topic 2000 presidential campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00667-00159475-00159696": "McCain announced his candidacy for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00668-00159697-00160083": "president on September 27 1999 in Nashua", "54XGuuII2Fu-00669-00160084-00160278": "New Hampshire saying he was staging a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00670-00160279-00160494": "fight to take our government back from", "54XGuuII2Fu-00671-00160495-00160734": "the power brokers and special interests", "54XGuuII2Fu-00672-00160735-00160917": "and return it to the people and the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00673-00160918-00161151": "noble cause of freedom it was created to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00674-00161152-00161403": "serve the front-runner for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00675-00161404-00161643": "Republican nomination was Texas Governor", "54XGuuII2Fu-00676-00161644-00161883": "George W Bush who had the political and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00677-00161884-00162081": "financial support of most of the party", "54XGuuII2Fu-00678-00162082-00162288": "establishment became focused on the New", "54XGuuII2Fu-00679-00162289-00162468": "Hampshire primary where his message", "54XGuuII2Fu-00680-00162469-00162732": "appealed to independence he traveled on", "54XGuuII2Fu-00681-00162733-00162900": "a campaign bus called the Straight Talk", "54XGuuII2Fu-00682-00162901-00163194": "Express he held many town hall meetings", "54XGuuII2Fu-00683-00163195-00163431": "answering every question voters asked in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00684-00163432-00163713": "a successful example of retail politics", "54XGuuII2Fu-00685-00163714-00163989": "and he used free media to compensate for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00686-00163990-00164262": "his lack of funds one reporter later", "54XGuuII2Fu-00687-00164263-00164502": "recounted that McCain talked all day", "54XGuuII2Fu-00688-00164503-00164700": "long with reporters on his Straight Talk", "54XGuuII2Fu-00689-00164701-00164961": "Express bus he talked so much that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00690-00164962-00165123": "sometimes he said things that he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00691-00165124-00165300": "shouldn't have and that's why the media", "54XGuuII2Fu-00692-00165301-00165693": "loved him on February 1st 2000 he won", "54XGuuII2Fu-00693-00165694-00165930": "New Hampshire's primary with 49 percent", "54XGuuII2Fu-00694-00165931-00166125": "of the vote to Bush's 30 percent the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00695-00166126-00166362": "Bush campaign and the Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-00696-00166363-00166533": "establishment feared that a McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00697-00166534-00166734": "victory in the crucial South Carolina", "54XGuuII2Fu-00698-00166735-00166899": "primary might give his campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00699-00166900-00167187": "unstoppable momentum the Arizona", "54XGuuII2Fu-00700-00167188-00167364": "Republic wrote that the McCain Bush", "54XGuuII2Fu-00701-00167365-00167634": "primary contest in South Carolina has", "54XGuuII2Fu-00702-00167635-00167880": "entered national political lore as a low", "54XGuuII2Fu-00703-00167881-00168155": "watermark in presidential campaigns", "54XGuuII2Fu-00704-00168156-00168411": "while the New York Times called it a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00705-00168412-00168636": "painful symbol of the brutality of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00706-00168637-00168996": "American politics a variety of interest", "54XGuuII2Fu-00707-00168997-00169185": "groups which McCain had challenged in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00708-00169186-00169488": "the past ran negative ads Bush borrowed", "54XGuuII2Fu-00709-00169489-00169698": "McCain's earlier language of reform and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00710-00169699-00169905": "declined to dissociate himself from a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00711-00169906-00170115": "veterans activist who accused McCain in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00712-00170116-00170361": "Bush's presence of having abandoned the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00713-00170362-00170625": "veterans on pow/mia and Agent Orange", "54XGuuII2Fu-00714-00170626-00170907": "issues incensed McCain ran ads accusing", "54XGuuII2Fu-00715-00170908-00171108": "Bush of lying and comparing the governor", "54XGuuII2Fu-00716-00171109-00171285": "to Bill Clinton which Bush said was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00717-00171286-00171552": "about as low a blow as you can give in a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00718-00171553-00171791": "Republican primary", "54XGuuII2Fu-00719-00171792-00172004": "an anonymous smear campaign began", "54XGuuII2Fu-00720-00172005-00172221": "against McCain delivered by push polls", "54XGuuII2Fu-00721-00172222-00172535": "faxes emails fliers and audience plans", "54XGuuII2Fu-00722-00172536-00172790": "the smears claimed that McCain had", "54XGuuII2Fu-00723-00172791-00172940": "fathered a black child out of wedlock", "54XGuuII2Fu-00724-00172941-00173181": "the McCain's dark-skinned daughter was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00725-00173182-00173382": "adopted from Bangladesh that his wife", "54XGuuII2Fu-00726-00173383-00173568": "Cindy was a drug addict that he was a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00727-00173569-00173832": "homosexual and that he was a Manchurian", "54XGuuII2Fu-00728-00173833-00174081": "Candidate who was either a traitor or", "54XGuuII2Fu-00729-00174082-00174278": "mentally unstable from his North Vietnam", "54XGuuII2Fu-00730-00174279-00174587": "POW days the Bush campaign strongly", "54XGuuII2Fu-00731-00174588-00174761": "denied any involvement with the attacks", "54XGuuII2Fu-00732-00174762-00175025": "McCain lost South Carolina on February", "54XGuuII2Fu-00733-00175026-00175250": "19th with 42 percent of the vote to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00734-00175251-00175514": "Bush's 53 percent in part because Bush", "54XGuuII2Fu-00735-00175515-00175734": "mobilized the state's evangelical voters", "54XGuuII2Fu-00736-00175735-00176022": "and outspent McCain the win allowed Bush", "54XGuuII2Fu-00737-00176023-00176279": "to regain lost momentum McCain said of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00738-00176280-00176496": "the rumor spreaders I believe that there", "54XGuuII2Fu-00739-00176497-00176685": "is a special place in hell for people", "54XGuuII2Fu-00740-00176686-00177029": "like those according to one acquaintance", "54XGuuII2Fu-00741-00177030-00177248": "the South Carolina experience left him", "54XGuuII2Fu-00742-00177249-00177548": "in a very dark place McCain's campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00743-00177549-00177756": "never completely recovered from his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00744-00177757-00177950": "South Carolina defeat although he did", "54XGuuII2Fu-00745-00177951-00178160": "rebound partially by winning in Arizona", "54XGuuII2Fu-00746-00178161-00178434": "and Michigan a few days later he made a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00747-00178435-00178656": "speech in Virginia Beach that criticized", "54XGuuII2Fu-00748-00178657-00178838": "Christian leaders including Pat", "54XGuuII2Fu-00749-00178839-00179087": "Robertson and Jerry Falwell as divisive", "54XGuuII2Fu-00750-00179088-00179346": "conservatives declaring", "54XGuuII2Fu-00751-00179347-00179583": "we embrace the fine members of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00752-00179584-00179838": "religious conservative community but", "54XGuuII2Fu-00753-00179839-00180024": "that does not mean that we will pander", "54XGuuII2Fu-00754-00180025-00180341": "to their self-appointed leaders McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00755-00180342-00180529": "lost the Virginia primary on February", "54XGuuII2Fu-00756-00180530-00180822": "29th and on March 7th lost nine of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00757-00180823-00181032": "thirteen primaries on Super Tuesday to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00758-00181033-00181275": "Bush with little hope of overcoming", "54XGuuII2Fu-00759-00181276-00181506": "Bush's delegate lead McCain withdrew", "54XGuuII2Fu-00760-00181507-00181790": "from the race on March 9th 2000 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00761-00181791-00181881": "endorsed bush", "54XGuuII2Fu-00762-00181882-00182034": "two months later and made occasional", "54XGuuII2Fu-00763-00182035-00182240": "appearances with the texas governor", "54XGuuII2Fu-00764-00182241-00182709": "during the general election campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00765-00182710-00183414": "topic Senate career 2002 2008", "54XGuuII2Fu-00766-00183415-00184006": "topic remainder of third Senate term", "54XGuuII2Fu-00767-00184007-00184300": "mccain began 2001 by breaking with the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00768-00184301-00184531": "new george w bush administration on a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00769-00184532-00184753": "number of matters including HMO reform", "54XGuuII2Fu-00770-00184754-00184950": "climate change and gun legislation", "54XGuuII2Fu-00771-00184951-00185236": "mccain feingold was opposed by bush as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00772-00185237-00185578": "well in May 2001 McCain was one of only", "54XGuuII2Fu-00773-00185579-00185797": "two Senate Republicans to vote against", "54XGuuII2Fu-00774-00185798-00185922": "the Bush tax cuts", "54XGuuII2Fu-00775-00185923-00186166": "besides the differences with Bush on", "54XGuuII2Fu-00776-00186167-00186325": "ideological grounds there was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00777-00186326-00186544": "considerable antagonism between the two", "54XGuuII2Fu-00778-00186545-00186691": "remaining from the previous year's", "54XGuuII2Fu-00779-00186692-00187012": "campaign later when a Republican Senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-00780-00187013-00187255": "Jim Jeffords became an independent there", "54XGuuII2Fu-00781-00187256-00187432": "by throwing control of the Senate to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00782-00187433-00187642": "Democrats McCain defended Jeffords", "54XGuuII2Fu-00783-00187643-00187888": "against self-appointed enforcers of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00784-00187889-00188176": "party loyalty indeed there was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00785-00188177-00188371": "speculation at the time and in years", "54XGuuII2Fu-00786-00188372-00188581": "since about McCain himself leaving the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00787-00188582-00188788": "Republican Party but McCain had always", "54XGuuII2Fu-00788-00188789-00188995": "adamantly denied that he ever considered", "54XGuuII2Fu-00789-00188996-00189355": "doing so beginning in 2001 McCain used", "54XGuuII2Fu-00790-00189356-00189529": "political capital gain from his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00791-00189530-00189730": "presidential run as well as improved", "54XGuuII2Fu-00792-00189731-00189946": "legislative skills and relationships", "54XGuuII2Fu-00793-00189947-00190129": "with other members to become one of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00794-00190130-00190339": "Senate's most influential members after", "54XGuuII2Fu-00795-00190340-00190633": "the September 11 2001 attacks McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00796-00190634-00190849": "supported Bush in the us-led war in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00797-00190850-00191140": "Afghanistan he and Democratic Senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-00798-00191141-00191359": "Joe Lieberman wrote the legislation that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00799-00191360-00191581": "created the 9/11 Commission while he and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00800-00191582-00191748": "Democratic senator Fritz Hollings", "54XGuuII2Fu-00801-00191749-00191935": "co-sponsored the aviation and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00802-00191936-00192127": "transportation security act that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00803-00192128-00192358": "federalized airport security in March", "54XGuuII2Fu-00804-00192359-00192655": "2002 became Feingold officially known as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00805-00192656-00192886": "the bipartisan campaign Reform Act of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00806-00192887-00193156": "2002 passed in both houses of Congress", "54XGuuII2Fu-00807-00193157-00193282": "and was signed into law by President", "54XGuuII2Fu-00808-00193283-00193570": "Bush seven years in the making", "54XGuuII2Fu-00809-00193571-00193771": "it was McCain's greatest legislative", "54XGuuII2Fu-00810-00193772-00194071": "achievement meanwhile in discussions", "54XGuuII2Fu-00811-00194072-00194299": "over proposed US action against Iraq", "54XGuuII2Fu-00812-00194300-00194494": "McCain was a strong supporter of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00813-00194495-00194767": "Bush administration's position he stated", "54XGuuII2Fu-00814-00194768-00195022": "that Iraq was a clear and present danger", "54XGuuII2Fu-00815-00195023-00195274": "to the United States of America and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00816-00195275-00195498": "voted accordingly for the Iraq war", "54XGuuII2Fu-00817-00195499-00195898": "resolution in October 2002 he predicted", "54XGuuII2Fu-00818-00195899-00196084": "that US forces would be treated as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00819-00196085-00196264": "liberators by a large number of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00820-00196265-00196606": "Iraqi people in May 2003 McCain voted", "54XGuuII2Fu-00821-00196607-00196816": "against the second round of Bush tax", "54XGuuII2Fu-00822-00196817-00197038": "cuts saying it was unwise at a time of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00823-00197039-00197376": "war by November 2003 after a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00824-00197377-00197583": "to Iraq he was publicly questioning", "54XGuuII2Fu-00825-00197584-00197808": "Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld", "54XGuuII2Fu-00826-00197809-00198036": "saying that more US troops were needed", "54XGuuII2Fu-00827-00198037-00198228": "the following year McCain announced that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00828-00198229-00198435": "he had lost confidence in Rumsfeld in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00829-00198436-00198681": "October 2003 McCain and Lieberman", "54XGuuII2Fu-00830-00198682-00198915": "co-sponsored the climate stewardship Act", "54XGuuII2Fu-00831-00198916-00199083": "that would have introduced a cap and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00832-00199084-00199239": "trade system aimed at returning", "54XGuuII2Fu-00833-00199240-00199488": "greenhouse gas emissions to 2000 levels", "54XGuuII2Fu-00834-00199489-00199734": "the bill was defeated with 55 votes to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00835-00199735-00199995": "43 in the Senate they reintroduced", "54XGuuII2Fu-00836-00199996-00200184": "modified versions of the Act two", "54XGuuII2Fu-00837-00200185-00200383": "additional times for the final time in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00838-00200384-00200676": "January 2007 with the co-sponsorship of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00839-00200677-00201057": "Barack Obama among others in the 2004", "54XGuuII2Fu-00840-00201058-00201270": "u.s. presidential election campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00841-00201271-00201462": "McCain was once again frequently", "54XGuuII2Fu-00842-00201463-00201639": "mentioned for the vice presidential slot", "54XGuuII2Fu-00843-00201640-00201868": "only this time as part of the Democratic", "54XGuuII2Fu-00844-00201869-00202156": "ticket under nominee John Kerry McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00845-00202157-00202329": "said that Kerry had never formally", "54XGuuII2Fu-00846-00202330-00202491": "offered him the position and that he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00847-00202492-00202734": "would not have accepted it if he had at", "54XGuuII2Fu-00848-00202735-00202971": "the 2004 Republican National Convention", "54XGuuII2Fu-00849-00202972-00203187": "McCain supported Bush for re-election", "54XGuuII2Fu-00850-00203188-00203424": "praising Bush's management of the war on", "54XGuuII2Fu-00851-00203425-00203632": "terror since the September 11th attacks", "54XGuuII2Fu-00852-00203633-00203922": "at the same time he defended Kerry's", "54XGuuII2Fu-00853-00203923-00204282": "Vietnam war record by August 2004 McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00854-00204283-00204457": "had the best favorable to unfavorable", "54XGuuII2Fu-00855-00204458-00204828": "rating 55% to 19% of any national", "54XGuuII2Fu-00856-00204829-00205041": "politician he campaigned for Bush much", "54XGuuII2Fu-00857-00205042-00205236": "more than he had for years previously", "54XGuuII2Fu-00858-00205237-00205428": "though the two remained situational", "54XGuuII2Fu-00859-00205429-00205638": "allies rather than friends McCain was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00860-00205639-00205833": "also up for re-election as Senator in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00861-00205834-00206194": "2004 he defeated little-known Democratic", "54XGuuII2Fu-00862-00206194-00206379": "schoolteachers Stuart Starkey with his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00863-00206380-00206664": "biggest margin of victory garnering 77%", "54XGuuII2Fu-00864-00206665-00207009": "of the vote", "54XGuuII2Fu-00865-00207010-00207590": "topic start 1/4 Senate term", "54XGuuII2Fu-00866-00207591-00207878": "in May 2005 McCain led the so-called", "54XGuuII2Fu-00867-00207879-00208082": "gang of 14 in the Senate which", "54XGuuII2Fu-00868-00208083-00208278": "established a compromise that preserved", "54XGuuII2Fu-00869-00208279-00208481": "the ability of senators to filibuster", "54XGuuII2Fu-00870-00208482-00208658": "judicial nominees but only in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00871-00208659-00208979": "extraordinary circumstances the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00872-00208980-00209144": "compromise took the steam out of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00873-00209146-00209321": "filibuster movement but some Republicans", "54XGuuII2Fu-00874-00209323-00209537": "remain disappointed that the compromise", "54XGuuII2Fu-00875-00209538-00209721": "did not eliminate filibusters of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00876-00209721-00209987": "judicial nominees in all circumstances", "54XGuuII2Fu-00877-00209988-00210281": "McCain subsequently cast Supreme Court", "54XGuuII2Fu-00878-00210282-00210489": "confirmation votes in favor of John", "54XGuuII2Fu-00879-00210490-00210719": "Roberts and Samuel Alito calling them", "54XGuuII2Fu-00880-00210721-00210944": "two of the finest justices ever", "54XGuuII2Fu-00881-00210946-00211142": "appointed to the United States Supreme", "54XGuuII2Fu-00882-00211144-00211641": "Court breaking from his 2001 and 2003", "54XGuuII2Fu-00883-00211642-00211890": "votes McCain supported the Bush tax cut", "54XGuuII2Fu-00884-00211891-00212166": "extension in May 2006 saying not to do", "54XGuuII2Fu-00885-00212167-00212363": "so would amount to a tax increase", "54XGuuII2Fu-00886-00212364-00212609": "working with Democratic senator Ted", "54XGuuII2Fu-00887-00212610-00212844": "Kennedy McCain was a strong proponent of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00888-00212844-00213053": "comprehensive immigration reform which", "54XGuuII2Fu-00889-00213054-00213257": "would involve legalization guest worker", "54XGuuII2Fu-00890-00213258-00213406": "programs and border enforcement", "54XGuuII2Fu-00891-00213407-00213710": "components the secure America and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00892-00213711-00213932": "orderly Immigration Act was never voted", "54XGuuII2Fu-00893-00213933-00214169": "on in 2005 while the comprehensive", "54XGuuII2Fu-00894-00214171-00214440": "immigration reform Act of 2006 passed", "54XGuuII2Fu-00895-00214441-00214698": "the Senate in May 2006 but failed in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00896-00214698-00215103": "house in June 2007 President Bush McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00897-00215104-00215306": "and others made the strongest push yet", "54XGuuII2Fu-00898-00215307-00215487": "for such a bill the comprehensive", "54XGuuII2Fu-00899-00215488-00215769": "immigration reform Act of 2007 but it", "54XGuuII2Fu-00900-00215769-00215978": "aroused intense grassroots opposition", "54XGuuII2Fu-00901-00215979-00216171": "among talk radio listeners and others", "54XGuuII2Fu-00902-00216171-00216390": "some of whom furiously characterized the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00903-00216391-00216717": "proposal as an amnesty program and the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00904-00216717-00216908": "bill twice failed to gain cloture in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00905-00216909-00217103": "Senate by the middle of the 2000s decade", "54XGuuII2Fu-00906-00217104-00217362": "the increased Indian Gaming that McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00907-00217363-00217532": "had helped bring about was a twenty", "54XGuuII2Fu-00908-00217533-00217784": "three billion dollars industry he was", "54XGuuII2Fu-00909-00217785-00217953": "twice chairman of the Senate Indian", "54XGuuII2Fu-00910-00217954-00218325": "Affairs Committee in 1995 to 1997 and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00911-00218326-00218625": "2005 to 2007 and his committee helped", "54XGuuII2Fu-00912-00218626-00218846": "expose the Jack Abramoff Indian lobbying", "54XGuuII2Fu-00913-00218848-00219203": "scandal by 2005 in 2006", "54XGuuII2Fu-00914-00219204-00219402": "McCain was pushing for amendments to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00915-00219403-00219615": "Indian Gaming Regulatory act which would", "54XGuuII2Fu-00916-00219616-00219779": "have limited creation of off-reservation", "54XGuuII2Fu-00917-00219780-00220050": "casinos and also limited the movement of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00918-00220051-00220221": "tribes across state lines to build", "54XGuuII2Fu-00919-00220221-00220517": "casinos owing to his time as a POW", "54XGuuII2Fu-00920-00220519-00220692": "McCain was recognized for his", "54XGuuII2Fu-00921-00220692-00220866": "sensitivity to the detention and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00922-00220867-00220980": "interrogation of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00923-00220981-00221283": "in the war on terror an opponent of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00924-00221284-00221496": "Bush administration's use of torture and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00925-00221497-00221658": "detention without trial like Guantanamo", "54XGuuII2Fu-00926-00221659-00221934": "Bay saying some of these guys are", "54XGuuII2Fu-00927-00221935-00222150": "terrible terrible killers and the worst", "54XGuuII2Fu-00928-00222151-00222490": "kind of scum of humanity but one they", "54XGuuII2Fu-00929-00222491-00222688": "deserve to have some adjudication of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00930-00222689-00223080": "their cases even Adolf Eichmann got a", "54XGuuII2Fu-00931-00223081-00223241": "trial", "54XGuuII2Fu-00932-00223242-00223550": "in October 2005 McCain introduced the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00933-00223551-00223723": "McCain detainee amendment to the defense", "54XGuuII2Fu-00934-00223725-00224009": "appropriations bill for 2005 and the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00935-00224010-00224201": "Senate voted ninety to nine to support", "54XGuuII2Fu-00936-00224202-00224446": "the amendment it prohibits inhumane", "54XGuuII2Fu-00937-00224448-00224600": "treatment of prisoners including", "54XGuuII2Fu-00938-00224601-00224828": "prisoners at Guantanamo by confining", "54XGuuII2Fu-00939-00224829-00225008": "military interrogations to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00940-00225009-00225185": "techniques in the US Army Field Manual", "54XGuuII2Fu-00941-00225186-00225329": "on interrogation", "54XGuuII2Fu-00942-00225330-00225569": "although Bush had threatened to veto the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00943-00225569-00225773": "bill if McCain's amendment was included", "54XGuuII2Fu-00944-00225773-00226025": "the president announced in December 2005", "54XGuuII2Fu-00945-00226026-00226219": "that he accepted McCain's terms and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00946-00226221-00226421": "would make it clear to the world that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00947-00226421-00226628": "this government does not torture and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00948-00226629-00226805": "that we adhere to the International", "54XGuuII2Fu-00949-00226806-00227033": "Convention of torture whether it be here", "54XGuuII2Fu-00950-00227034-00227191": "at home or abroad", "54XGuuII2Fu-00951-00227192-00227489": "this stance among others led to McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00952-00227490-00227762": "being named by Time magazine in 2006 as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00953-00227763-00228071": "one of America's 10 best senators McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-00954-00228071-00228341": "voted in February 2008 against a bill", "54XGuuII2Fu-00955-00228342-00228548": "containing a ban on waterboarding which", "54XGuuII2Fu-00956-00228548-00228758": "provision was later narrowly passed and", "54XGuuII2Fu-00957-00228759-00229034": "vetoed by Bush however the bill in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00958-00229035-00229235": "question contained other provisions to", "54XGuuII2Fu-00959-00229236-00229436": "which McCain objected and his spokesman", "54XGuuII2Fu-00960-00229437-00229604": "stated this wasn't a vote on", "54XGuuII2Fu-00961-00229605-00229844": "waterboarding this was a vote on", "54XGuuII2Fu-00962-00229844-00230063": "applying the standards of the Army Field", "54XGuuII2Fu-00963-00230064-00230486": "Manual to CIA personnel meanwhile became", "54XGuuII2Fu-00964-00230487-00230666": "continued questioning the progress of", "54XGuuII2Fu-00965-00230667-00231029": "the war in Iraq in September 2005 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00966-00231030-00231194": "remarked upon chairman of the Joint", "54XGuuII2Fu-00967-00231194-00231341": "Chiefs of Staff Richard Meyers", "54XGuuII2Fu-00968-00231342-00231571": "optimistic outlook on the wars progress", "54XGuuII2Fu-00969-00231573-00231803": "things have not gone as well as we had", "54XGuuII2Fu-00970-00231804-00232042": "planned or expected nor as we were told", "54XGuuII2Fu-00971-00232044-00232106": "by you", "54XGuuII2Fu-00972-00232107-00232490": "general Meyers in August 2006 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-00973-00232491-00232673": "criticized the administration for", "54XGuuII2Fu-00974-00232673-00232802": "continually understating the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00975-00232803-00233012": "effectiveness of the insurgency we have", "54XGuuII2Fu-00976-00233013-00233201": "not told the American people how tough", "54XGuuII2Fu-00977-00233202-00233483": "and difficult this could be from the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00978-00233484-00233537": "beginning", "54XGuuII2Fu-00979-00233538-00233804": "McCain strongly supported the Iraq troop", "54XGuuII2Fu-00980-00233805-00234196": "surge of 2007 the strategy's opponents", "54XGuuII2Fu-00981-00234198-00234271": "labeled it", "54XGuuII2Fu-00982-00234273-00234611": "McCain's plan and University of Virginia", "54XGuuII2Fu-00983-00234612-00234839": "political science professor Larry Sabato", "54XGuuII2Fu-00984-00234840-00235184": "said McCain owns Iraq just as much as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00985-00235185-00235475": "Bush does now quote the surge in the war", "54XGuuII2Fu-00986-00235476-00235682": "were unpopular during most of the year", "54XGuuII2Fu-00987-00235683-00235921": "even within the Republican Party as", "54XGuuII2Fu-00988-00235923-00236186": "McCain's presidential campaign was under", "54XGuuII2Fu-00989-00236187-00236438": "way faced with the consequences became", "54XGuuII2Fu-00990-00236439-00236619": "frequently respondent", "54XGuuII2Fu-00991-00236621-00236871": "I would much rather lose a campaign than", "54XGuuII2Fu-00992-00236873-00237154": "a war in March 2008 McCain credited the", "54XGuuII2Fu-00993-00237155-00237373": "surge strategy with reducing violence in", "54XGuuII2Fu-00994-00237373-00237565": "Iraq as he made his eighth trip to that", "54XGuuII2Fu-00995-00237566-00238016": "country since the war began", "54XGuuII2Fu-00996-00238017-00238687": "topic 2008 presidential campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-00997-00238688-00238942": "mccain formally announced his intention", "54XGuuII2Fu-00998-00238942-00239103": "to run for president of the United", "54XGuuII2Fu-00999-00239104-00239427": "States on April 25th 2007 in Portsmouth", "54XGuuII2Fu-01000-00239428-00239724": "New Hampshire he stated that I'm not", "54XGuuII2Fu-01001-00239725-00239962": "running for president to be somebody but", "54XGuuII2Fu-01002-00239963-00240156": "to do something to do the hard but", "54XGuuII2Fu-01003-00240157-00240375": "necessary things not the easy and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01004-00240376-00240667": "needless things McCain's oft-cited", "54XGuuII2Fu-01005-00240667-00240892": "strengths as a presidential candidate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01006-00240892-00241125": "for 2008 included national name", "54XGuuII2Fu-01007-00241126-00241323": "recognition sponsorship of major", "54XGuuII2Fu-01008-00241325-00241546": "lobbying and campaign finance reform", "54XGuuII2Fu-01009-00241546-00241717": "initiatives his ability to reach across", "54XGuuII2Fu-01010-00241717-00241921": "the aisle his well-known military", "54XGuuII2Fu-01011-00241921-00242148": "service and experience as a pal his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01012-00242150-00242355": "experience from the 2000 presidential", "54XGuuII2Fu-01013-00242356-00242569": "campaign and an expectation that he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01014-00242569-00242769": "would capture Bush's top fundraisers", "54XGuuII2Fu-01015-00242769-00243105": "during the 2006 election cycle McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01016-00243106-00243396": "had attended 346 events and helped raise", "54XGuuII2Fu-01017-00243398-00243651": "more than 10.5 million dollars on behalf", "54XGuuII2Fu-01018-00243652-00243937": "of Republican candidates McCain also", "54XGuuII2Fu-01019-00243938-00244152": "became more willing to ask business and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01020-00244153-00244348": "industry for campaign contributions", "54XGuuII2Fu-01021-00244348-00244473": "while maintaining that such", "54XGuuII2Fu-01022-00244475-00244642": "contributions would not affect any", "54XGuuII2Fu-01023-00244642-00244921": "official decisions he would make despite", "54XGuuII2Fu-01024-00244921-00245089": "being considered the front-runner for", "54XGuuII2Fu-01025-00245090-00245373": "the nomination by pundits as 2007 began", "54XGuuII2Fu-01026-00245375-00245617": "McCain was in second place behind former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01027-00245617-00245826": "mayor of New York City Rudy Giuliani and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01028-00245827-00246042": "national Republican polls as the year", "54XGuuII2Fu-01029-00246044-00246333": "progressed McCain had fundraising", "54XGuuII2Fu-01030-00246334-00246609": "problems in the first half of 2007 due", "54XGuuII2Fu-01031-00246610-00246753": "in part to his support for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01032-00246754-00246969": "comprehensive immigration reform Act of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01033-00246971-00247216": "2007 which was unpopular among the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01034-00247217-00247489": "Republican base electorate large-scale", "54XGuuII2Fu-01035-00247490-00247741": "campaign staff downsizing took place in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01036-00247742-00247833": "early July", "54XGuuII2Fu-01037-00247834-00247974": "but McCain said that he was not", "54XGuuII2Fu-01038-00247975-00248150": "considering dropping out of the race", "54XGuuII2Fu-01039-00248151-00248416": "later that month the candidates campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-01040-00248417-00248646": "manager and campaign chief strategist", "54XGuuII2Fu-01041-00248648-00248949": "both departed McCain slumped badly in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01042-00248950-00249163": "national polls often running third or", "54XGuuII2Fu-01043-00249164-00249496": "fourth with 15% or less support the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01044-00249496-00249729": "Arizona senator subsequently resumed his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01045-00249730-00249906": "familiar position as a political", "54XGuuII2Fu-01046-00249907-00250069": "underdog riding the straight talk", "54XGuuII2Fu-01047-00250069-00250269": "Express and taking advantage of free", "54XGuuII2Fu-01048-00250271-00250462": "media such as debates and sponsored", "54XGuuII2Fu-01049-00250463-00250833": "events by December 2007 the Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01050-00250834-00251010": "race was unsettled with none of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01051-00251011-00251217": "top-tier candidates dominating the race", "54XGuuII2Fu-01052-00251219-00251371": "and all of them possessing major", "54XGuuII2Fu-01053-00251371-00251539": "vulnerabilities with different elements", "54XGuuII2Fu-01054-00251540-00251829": "of the Republican base electorate McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01055-00251830-00252040": "was showing a resurgence in particular", "54XGuuII2Fu-01056-00252041-00252081": "with Rin", "54XGuuII2Fu-01057-00252082-00252303": "dude strength in New Hampshire the scene", "54XGuuII2Fu-01058-00252304-00252562": "of his 2000 triumph and was bolstered", "54XGuuII2Fu-01059-00252563-00252723": "further by the endorsements of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01060-00252724-00252879": "Boston Globe the New Hampshire", "54XGuuII2Fu-01061-00252880-00252948": "union-leader", "54XGuuII2Fu-01062-00252949-00253122": "and almost two dozen other state", "54XGuuII2Fu-01063-00253123-00253317": "newspapers as well as from Senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-01064-00253319-00253523": "Lieberman now an independent Democrat", "54XGuuII2Fu-01065-00253524-00253758": "McCain decided not to campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-01066-00253759-00254038": "significantly in the January 3rd 2008", "54XGuuII2Fu-01067-00254039-00254298": "Iowa caucuses which saw a win by former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01068-00254299-00254525": "governor of Arkansas Mike Huckabee", "54XGuuII2Fu-01069-00254526-00254802": "McCain's comeback plan paid off when he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01070-00254803-00255009": "won the New Hampshire primary on January", "54XGuuII2Fu-01071-00255010-00255187": "8th defeating former governor of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01072-00255188-00255399": "Massachusetts Mitt Romney in a close", "54XGuuII2Fu-01073-00255400-00255606": "contest to once again become one of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01074-00255607-00255865": "frontrunners in the race in mid-january", "54XGuuII2Fu-01075-00255866-00256077": "McCain placed first in the South", "54XGuuII2Fu-01076-00256078-00256317": "Carolina primary narrowly defeating Mike", "54XGuuII2Fu-01077-00256319-00256548": "Huckabee pundits credited the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01078-00256549-00256765": "third-place finisher Tennessee's former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01079-00256766-00257046": "US senator Fred Thompson withdrawing", "54XGuuII2Fu-01080-00257047-00257244": "votes from Huckabee in South Carolina", "54XGuuII2Fu-01081-00257245-00257487": "thereby giving a narrow win to McCain a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01082-00257488-00257757": "week later McCain won the Florida", "54XGuuII2Fu-01083-00257758-00257976": "primary beating Romney again in a close", "54XGuuII2Fu-01084-00257977-00258210": "contest Giuliani then dropped out and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01085-00258211-00258453": "endorsed McCain On February 5th McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01086-00258454-00258640": "won both the majority of states and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01087-00258641-00258774": "delegates in the Super Tuesday", "54XGuuII2Fu-01088-00258775-00258978": "Republican primaries giving him a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01089-00258979-00259155": "commanding lead toward the Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01090-00259156-00259425": "nomination Romney departed from the race", "54XGuuII2Fu-01091-00259426-00259692": "on February 7th McCain's wins in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01092-00259694-00259923": "March 4th primaries clinched a majority", "54XGuuII2Fu-01093-00259924-00260082": "of the delegates and he became the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01094-00260083-00260290": "presumptive Republican nominee McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01095-00260291-00260493": "was born in the Panama Canal Zone", "54XGuuII2Fu-01096-00260494-00260721": "had he been elected he would have become", "54XGuuII2Fu-01097-00260722-00260890": "the first president who was born outside", "54XGuuII2Fu-01098-00260891-00261225": "the contiguous 48 states this raised a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01099-00261226-00261435": "potential legal issue since the United", "54XGuuII2Fu-01100-00261436-00261633": "States Constitution requires the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01101-00261634-00261841": "president to be a natural-born citizen", "54XGuuII2Fu-01102-00261842-00262143": "of the United States a bipartisan legal", "54XGuuII2Fu-01103-00262144-00262356": "review and a unanimous but non-binding", "54XGuuII2Fu-01104-00262357-00262593": "Senate resolution both concluded that he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01105-00262594-00262754": "was a natural-born citizen if", "54XGuuII2Fu-01106-00262755-00263109": "inaugurated in 2009 at the age of 72", "54XGuuII2Fu-01107-00263110-00263394": "years and 144 days he would have been", "54XGuuII2Fu-01108-00263395-00263568": "the oldest person to become president", "54XGuuII2Fu-01109-00263569-00263778": "McCain addressed concerns about his age", "54XGuuII2Fu-01110-00263779-00264057": "and past health issues stating in 2005", "54XGuuII2Fu-01111-00264058-00264345": "that his health was excellent he had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01112-00264346-00264495": "been treated for a type of skin cancer", "54XGuuII2Fu-01113-00264496-00264819": "called melanoma and an operation in 2004", "54XGuuII2Fu-01114-00264820-00265018": "that condition left a noticeable mark on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01115-00265019-00265160": "the left side of his face", "54XGuuII2Fu-01116-00265161-00265471": "McCain's prognosis appeared favorable", "54XGuuII2Fu-01117-00265472-00265651": "two independent experts especially", "54XGuuII2Fu-01118-00265652-00265852": "because he had already survived without", "54XGuuII2Fu-01119-00265853-00266014": "a recurrence for more than seven years", "54XGuuII2Fu-01120-00266015-00266401": "in May 2008 McCain's campaign briefly", "54XGuuII2Fu-01121-00266402-00266610": "let the press review his medical records", "54XGuuII2Fu-01122-00266611-00266782": "and he was described as appearing", "54XGuuII2Fu-01123-00266783-00267007": "cancer-free having a strong heart and in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01124-00267008-00267157": "general being in good health", "54XGuuII2Fu-01125-00267158-00267331": "McCain clinched enough delegates for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01126-00267332-00267544": "nomination and his focus shifted toward", "54XGuuII2Fu-01127-00267545-00267754": "the general election while Barack Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01128-00267755-00267943": "and Hillary Clinton fought a prolonged", "54XGuuII2Fu-01129-00267944-00268143": "battle for the Democratic nomination", "54XGuuII2Fu-01130-00268144-00268402": "McCain introduced various policy", "54XGuuII2Fu-01131-00268403-00268579": "proposals and sought to improve his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01132-00268580-00268873": "fundraising Cindy McCain who accounted", "54XGuuII2Fu-01133-00268874-00269034": "for most of the couple's wealth with an", "54XGuuII2Fu-01134-00269035-00269235": "estimated net worth of 100 million", "54XGuuII2Fu-01135-00269236-00269455": "dollars made part of her tax returns", "54XGuuII2Fu-01136-00269456-00269698": "public in May after facing criticism", "54XGuuII2Fu-01137-00269699-00269962": "about lobbyists on staff the McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01138-00269963-00270256": "campaign issued new rules in May 2008 to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01139-00270257-00270481": "avoid conflicts of interest causing five", "54XGuuII2Fu-01140-00270482-00270715": "top aides to leave when Obama became the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01141-00270716-00270925": "Democrats presumptive nominee in early", "54XGuuII2Fu-01142-00270926-00271141": "June McCain proposed joint townhall", "54XGuuII2Fu-01143-00271142-00271357": "meetings but Obama instead requested", "54XGuuII2Fu-01144-00271358-00271559": "more traditional debates for the fall in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01145-00271560-00271858": "July a staff shake-up put Steve Schmidt", "54XGuuII2Fu-01146-00271859-00272041": "in full operational control of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01147-00272042-00272326": "McCain campaign Rick Davis remained his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01148-00272327-00272535": "campaign manager but with a reduced role", "54XGuuII2Fu-01149-00272536-00272848": "Davis had also managed McCain's 2000", "54XGuuII2Fu-01150-00272849-00273241": "presidential campaign in 2005 in 2006 US", "54XGuuII2Fu-01151-00273242-00273421": "intelligence warned McCain's Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01152-00273422-00273640": "staff about Davis's Russian links but", "54XGuuII2Fu-01153-00273641-00273807": "gave no further warnings throughout the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01154-00273808-00274069": "summer of 2008 Obama typically led", "54XGuuII2Fu-01155-00274070-00274306": "McCain in national polls by single-digit", "54XGuuII2Fu-01156-00274307-00274513": "margins and also led him several key", "54XGuuII2Fu-01157-00274514-00274780": "swing states McCain reprised his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01158-00274781-00274999": "familiar underdog role which was due at", "54XGuuII2Fu-01159-00275000-00275197": "least in part to the overall challenges", "54XGuuII2Fu-01160-00275198-00275408": "Republicans faced in the election year", "54XGuuII2Fu-01161-00275409-00275695": "McCain accepted public financing for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01162-00275696-00275869": "general election campaign and the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01163-00275870-00276016": "restrictions that go with it while", "54XGuuII2Fu-01164-00276017-00276232": "criticizing his Democratic opponent for", "54XGuuII2Fu-01165-00276233-00276435": "becoming the first major party candidate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01166-00276436-00276613": "to opt out of such financing for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01167-00276614-00276781": "general election since the system was", "54XGuuII2Fu-01168-00276782-00277144": "implemented in 1976 the Republicans", "54XGuuII2Fu-01169-00277145-00277345": "broad campaign theme focused on his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01170-00277346-00277567": "experience and ability to lead compared", "54XGuuII2Fu-01171-00277568-00277990": "to Obama's on August 29th 2008 McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01172-00277991-00278218": "revealed Alaska governor Sarah Palin as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01173-00278219-00278415": "a surprise choice for a running mate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01174-00278416-00278733": "McCain was only the second US major", "54XGuuII2Fu-01175-00278734-00278868": "Party presidential", "54XGuuII2Fu-01176-00278869-00279093": "almani after Walter Mondale to select a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01177-00279094-00279260": "woman for his running-mate and the first", "54XGuuII2Fu-01178-00279261-00279560": "Republican to do so on September 3rd", "54XGuuII2Fu-01179-00279561-00279816": "2008 McCain and Palin became the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01180-00279817-00280034": "Republican Party's presidential and vice", "54XGuuII2Fu-01181-00280035-00280263": "presidential nominees respectively at", "54XGuuII2Fu-01182-00280264-00280500": "the 2008 Republican National Convention", "54XGuuII2Fu-01183-00280501-00280835": "in st. Paul Minnesota McCain surged", "54XGuuII2Fu-01184-00280836-00281028": "ahead of Obama in national polls", "54XGuuII2Fu-01185-00281029-00281231": "following the convention as the Palin", "54XGuuII2Fu-01186-00281232-00281454": "pick energized core Republican voters", "54XGuuII2Fu-01187-00281455-00281648": "who had previously been wary of him", "54XGuuII2Fu-01188-00281649-00281898": "however by the campaign's own later", "54XGuuII2Fu-01189-00281899-00282107": "admission the rollout of Palin to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01190-00282108-00282305": "national media went poorly and voter", "54XGuuII2Fu-01191-00282306-00282489": "reactions to Palin grew increasingly", "54XGuuII2Fu-01192-00282490-00282738": "negative especially among independents", "54XGuuII2Fu-01193-00282739-00282897": "and other voters concerned about her", "54XGuuII2Fu-01194-00282898-00283106": "qualifications McCain's decision to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01195-00283107-00283272": "choose Sarah Palin as his running mate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01196-00283273-00283512": "was criticized New York Times journalist", "54XGuuII2Fu-01197-00283513-00283749": "David Brooks says that he took a disease", "54XGuuII2Fu-01198-00283750-00283902": "that was running through the Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01199-00283903-00284139": "Party anti-intellectualism", "54XGuuII2Fu-01200-00284140-00284388": "disrespect for facts and he put it right", "54XGuuII2Fu-01201-00284389-00284584": "at the center of the party", "54XGuuII2Fu-01202-00284585-00284865": "Laura McGann and Vox says that McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01203-00284866-00285230": "gave the reality TV politics and tea", "54XGuuII2Fu-01204-00285231-00285399": "party movement more political legitimacy", "54XGuuII2Fu-01205-00285400-00285699": "as well as solidifying the Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01206-00285700-00285908": "Party's comfort with a candidate who", "54XGuuII2Fu-01207-00285909-00286165": "would say absurdities", "54XGuuII2Fu-01208-00286166-00286450": "unleashing a political style and a value", "54XGuuII2Fu-01209-00286451-00286656": "system that animated the Tea Party", "54XGuuII2Fu-01210-00286657-00286840": "movement and laid the groundwork for a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01211-00286841-00286992": "trump presidency", "54XGuuII2Fu-01212-00286993-00287229": "although McCain said later that he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01213-00287230-00287395": "expressed regret for not choosing the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01214-00287396-00287610": "independent Senator Joe Lieberman as his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01215-00287611-00287821": "VP candidate instead he consistently", "54XGuuII2Fu-01216-00287822-00288046": "defended Palin's performances at his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01217-00288047-00288325": "events on September 24th McCain said he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01218-00288326-00288482": "was temporarily suspending his campaign", "54XGuuII2Fu-01219-00288483-00288742": "activities called on Obama to join him", "54XGuuII2Fu-01220-00288743-00288922": "and proposed delaying the first of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01221-00288923-00289131": "general election debates with Obama in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01222-00289132-00289315": "order to work on the proposed US", "54XGuuII2Fu-01223-00289316-00289549": "financial system bailout before Congress", "54XGuuII2Fu-01224-00289550-00289717": "which was targeted at addressing the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01225-00289718-00289918": "subprime mortgage crisis and liquidity", "54XGuuII2Fu-01226-00289919-00290205": "crisis McCain's intervention helped to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01227-00290206-00290419": "give dissatisfied House Republicans an", "54XGuuII2Fu-01228-00290420-00290620": "opportunity to propose changes to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01229-00290621-00290788": "plan that was otherwise close to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01230-00290789-00291073": "agreement after Obama declined McCain's", "54XGuuII2Fu-01231-00291074-00291289": "suspension suggestion McCain went ahead", "54XGuuII2Fu-01232-00291290-00291560": "with the debate on September 26 on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01233-00291561-00291862": "October first McCain voted in favor of a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01234-00291863-00292066": "revised seven hundred billion dollars", "54XGuuII2Fu-01235-00292067-00292348": "rescue plan another debate was held on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01236-00292349-00292564": "October 7th like the first one polls", "54XGuuII2Fu-01237-00292565-00292771": "afterwards suggested that Obama had won", "54XGuuII2Fu-01238-00292772-00293074": "it a final presidential debate occurred", "54XGuuII2Fu-01239-00293075-00293352": "on October 15th down the stretch McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01240-00293353-00293563": "was outspent by Obama by a four to one", "54XGuuII2Fu-01241-00293564-00293770": "margin during and after the final debate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01242-00293771-00293979": "McCain compared Obama's proposed", "54XGuuII2Fu-01243-00293980-00294217": "policies to socialism and often invoked", "54XGuuII2Fu-01244-00294218-00294547": "Joe the Plumber as a symbol of American", "54XGuuII2Fu-01245-00294548-00294712": "small business dreams that would be", "54XGuuII2Fu-01246-00294713-00294984": "thwarted by an Obama presidency he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01247-00294985-00295131": "barred using the Jeremiah Wright", "54XGuuII2Fu-01248-00295132-00295369": "controversy in ads against Obama but the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01249-00295370-00295584": "campaign did frequently criticize Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01250-00295585-00295779": "regarding his purported relationship", "54XGuuII2Fu-01251-00295780-00295851": "with Bill hires", "54XGuuII2Fu-01252-00295852-00296068": "his rallies became increasingly", "54XGuuII2Fu-01253-00296069-00296310": "vitriolic with attendees denigrating", "54XGuuII2Fu-01254-00296311-00296488": "Obama and displaying a growing", "54XGuuII2Fu-01255-00296489-00296706": "anti-muslim and anti african-american", "54XGuuII2Fu-01256-00296707-00296958": "sentiment during a campaign rally in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01257-00296959-00297172": "Minnesota Gayle quenelle a McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01258-00297173-00297354": "supporter told him she did not trust", "54XGuuII2Fu-01259-00297355-00297739": "Obama because he's an Arab he replied no", "54XGuuII2Fu-01260-00297740-00298048": "ma'am he's a decent family man citizen", "54XGuuII2Fu-01261-00298049-00298182": "that I just happened to have", "54XGuuII2Fu-01262-00298183-00298478": "disagreements with on fundamental issues", "54XGuuII2Fu-01263-00298479-00298734": "McCain's response was considered one of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01264-00298735-00298929": "the finer moments of the campaign and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01265-00298930-00299082": "was still being viewed several years", "54XGuuII2Fu-01266-00299083-00299263": "later as a marker for civility in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01267-00299264-00299389": "American politics", "54XGuuII2Fu-01268-00299390-00299560": "Meghan McCain said", "54XGuuII2Fu-01269-00299561-00299812": "that she cannot go a day without someone", "54XGuuII2Fu-01270-00299813-00300064": "bringing up that moment and noted that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01271-00300065-00300280": "at the time there were a lot of people", "54XGuuII2Fu-01272-00300281-00300469": "really trying to get my dad to go", "54XGuuII2Fu-01273-00300470-00300847": "against Obama with you're a Muslim", "54XGuuII2Fu-01274-00300848-00301077": "you're not an American aspect of that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01275-00301078-00301441": "but that her father had refused I can", "54XGuuII2Fu-01276-00301442-00301636": "remember thinking that it was a morally", "54XGuuII2Fu-01277-00301637-00301831": "amazing and beautiful moment but that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01278-00301832-00301996": "maybe there would be people in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01279-00301997-00302185": "Republican Party that would be quite", "54XGuuII2Fu-01280-00302186-00302280": "angry", "54XGuuII2Fu-01281-00302281-00302656": "she said the election took place on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01282-00302657-00302860": "November 4th and Barack Obama was", "54XGuuII2Fu-01283-00302861-00303061": "projected the winner at about 11:00 p.m.", "54XGuuII2Fu-01284-00303062-00303220": "Eastern Standard Time", "54XGuuII2Fu-01285-00303221-00303373": "McCain delivered his concession speech", "54XGuuII2Fu-01286-00303374-00303610": "in Phoenix Arizona about 20 minutes", "54XGuuII2Fu-01287-00303611-00303889": "later in it he noted the historic and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01288-00303890-00304084": "special significance of Obama being", "54XGuuII2Fu-01289-00304085-00304267": "elected the nation's first African", "54XGuuII2Fu-01290-00304268-00304596": "American president in the end McCain won", "54XGuuII2Fu-01291-00304597-00304926": "173 electoral college votes to Obama's", "54XGuuII2Fu-01292-00304927-00305197": "365 McCain failed to win most of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01293-00305198-00305365": "battleground states and lost some", "54XGuuII2Fu-01294-00305366-00305641": "traditionally Republican ones McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01295-00305642-00305920": "gained 46% of the nationwide popular", "54XGuuII2Fu-01296-00305921-00306532": "vote compared to Obama's 53%", "54XGuuII2Fu-01297-00306533-00307115": "pick Senate career after 2008", "54XGuuII2Fu-01298-00307116-00307693": "topic remainder of fourth Senate term", "54XGuuII2Fu-01299-00307694-00307955": "following his defeat McCain returned to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01300-00307956-00308144": "the Senate amid varying views about what", "54XGuuII2Fu-01301-00308145-00308401": "role he might play there in mid November", "54XGuuII2Fu-01302-00308402-00308681": "2008 he met with president-elect Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01303-00308682-00308867": "and the two discussed issues they had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01304-00308868-00309158": "commonality on around the same time", "54XGuuII2Fu-01305-00309159-00309353": "McCain indicated that he intended to run", "54XGuuII2Fu-01306-00309354-00309536": "for re-election to his Senate seat in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01307-00309537-00309863": "2010 as the inauguration neared Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01308-00309864-00310073": "consulted with McCain on a variety of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01309-00310074-00310289": "matters to an extent rarely seen between", "54XGuuII2Fu-01310-00310290-00310520": "a president-elect and his defeated rival", "54XGuuII2Fu-01311-00310521-00310670": "and President Obama's inauguration", "54XGuuII2Fu-01312-00310671-00310913": "speech contained an allusion to McCain's", "54XGuuII2Fu-01313-00310914-00311099": "theme of finding a purpose greater than", "54XGuuII2Fu-01314-00311100-00311441": "oneself nevertheless McCain emerged as a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01315-00311442-00311642": "leader of the Republican opposition to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01316-00311643-00311867": "the Obama economic stimulus package of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01317-00311868-00312146": "2009 saying it had too much spending for", "54XGuuII2Fu-01318-00312147-00312404": "too little stimulative effect McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01319-00312405-00312614": "also voted against Obama's Supreme Court", "54XGuuII2Fu-01320-00312615-00312914": "nomination of Sonia Sotomayor saying", "54XGuuII2Fu-01321-00312915-00313166": "that while undeniably qualified I do not", "54XGuuII2Fu-01322-00313167-00313364": "believe that she shares my belief in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01323-00313365-00313585": "judicial restraint", "54XGuuII2Fu-01324-00313586-00313885": "and by August 2009 was citing more often", "54XGuuII2Fu-01325-00313886-00314083": "with his Republican Party on closely", "54XGuuII2Fu-01326-00314084-00314273": "divided votes than ever before in his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01327-00314274-00314570": "senatorial career McHenry asserted that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01328-00314571-00314795": "the war in Afghanistan was winnable and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01329-00314796-00315049": "criticized Obama for a slow process in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01330-00315050-00315248": "deciding whether to send additional US", "54XGuuII2Fu-01331-00315249-00315440": "troops there McCain also harshly", "54XGuuII2Fu-01332-00315441-00315628": "criticized Obama for scrapping", "54XGuuII2Fu-01333-00315629-00315797": "construction of the US missile defense", "54XGuuII2Fu-01334-00315798-00316022": "complex in Poland declined to enter", "54XGuuII2Fu-01335-00316023-00316220": "negotiations over climate change", "54XGuuII2Fu-01336-00316221-00316402": "legislation similar to what he had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01337-00316403-00316595": "proposed in the past and strongly", "54XGuuII2Fu-01338-00316596-00316798": "opposed the Obama health care plan", "54XGuuII2Fu-01339-00316799-00317087": "McCain led a successful filibuster of a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01340-00317088-00317251": "measure that would allow repeal of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01341-00317252-00317553": "military's Don't Ask Don't Tell policy", "54XGuuII2Fu-01342-00317554-00317837": "towards gays factors involved in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01343-00317838-00318049": "McCain's new direction included Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01344-00318050-00318263": "staffers leaving a renewed concern over", "54XGuuII2Fu-01345-00318264-00318454": "national debt levels and the scope of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01346-00318455-00318647": "federal government a possible Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01347-00318648-00318883": "primary challenge from conservatives in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01348-00318884-00319126": "2010 and McCain's campaign edge being", "54XGuuII2Fu-01349-00319127-00319418": "slow to wear off as one longtime McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01350-00319419-00319651": "advisor said a lot of people including", "54XGuuII2Fu-01351-00319652-00319892": "me thought he might be the republic in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01352-00319893-00320050": "building bridges to the Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01353-00320051-00320345": "administration but he's been more like", "54XGuuII2Fu-01354-00320346-00320625": "the guy blowing up the bridges", "54XGuuII2Fu-01355-00320626-00320913": "in early 2010 a primary challenge from", "54XGuuII2Fu-01356-00320914-00321132": "radio talk-show host and former US", "54XGuuII2Fu-01357-00321133-00321390": "congressman JD Hayworth materialized in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01358-00321391-00321639": "the 2010 US Senate election in Arizona", "54XGuuII2Fu-01359-00321640-00321825": "and drew support from some but not all", "54XGuuII2Fu-01360-00321826-00322080": "elements of the Tea Party movement with", "54XGuuII2Fu-01361-00322081-00322305": "Hayworth using the campaign slogan the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01362-00322306-00322569": "consistent conservative McCain said", "54XGuuII2Fu-01363-00322570-00322821": "despite his own past use of the term on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01364-00322822-00323097": "a number of occasions I never considered", "54XGuuII2Fu-01365-00323098-00323394": "myself a maverick I consider myself a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01366-00323395-00323625": "person who serves the people of Arizona", "54XGuuII2Fu-01367-00323626-00323819": "to the best of his abilities", "54XGuuII2Fu-01368-00323820-00324096": "the primary challenge coincided with", "54XGuuII2Fu-01369-00324097-00324342": "McCain reversing or muting his stance on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01370-00324343-00324522": "some issues such as the bank bailouts", "54XGuuII2Fu-01371-00324523-00324744": "closing of the Guantanamo Bay detention", "54XGuuII2Fu-01372-00324745-00324981": "camp campaign finance restrictions and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01373-00324982-00325236": "gays in the military when the health", "54XGuuII2Fu-01374-00325237-00325410": "care plan now called the Patient", "54XGuuII2Fu-01375-00325411-00325584": "Protection and Affordable Care Act", "54XGuuII2Fu-01376-00325585-00325812": "passed Congress and became law in March", "54XGuuII2Fu-01377-00325813-00326049": "2010 became strongly opposed the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01378-00326050-00326250": "landmark legislation not only on its", "54XGuuII2Fu-01379-00326251-00326454": "merits but also on the way it had been", "54XGuuII2Fu-01380-00326455-00326757": "handled in Congress as a consequence he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01381-00326758-00326865": "warned that congressional Republicans", "54XGuuII2Fu-01382-00326866-00327087": "would not work with Democrats on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01383-00327088-00327165": "anything else", "54XGuuII2Fu-01384-00327166-00327381": "there will be no cooperation for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01385-00327382-00327606": "rest of the year they have poisoned the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01386-00327607-00327765": "well in what they've done and how", "54XGuuII2Fu-01387-00327766-00327890": "they've done it", "54XGuuII2Fu-01388-00327891-00328143": "McCain became a vocal defender of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01389-00328144-00328515": "Arizona SB 1070 the April 2010 tough and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01390-00328516-00328686": "the illegal immigration state law that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01391-00328687-00328938": "aroused national controversy saying that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01392-00328939-00329094": "the state had been forced to take action", "54XGuuII2Fu-01393-00329095-00329268": "given the federal government's inability", "54XGuuII2Fu-01394-00329269-00329604": "to control the border in the August 24th", "54XGuuII2Fu-01395-00329605-00329892": "primary McCain beat Hayworth by a 56 to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01396-00329893-00330201": "32 percent margin McCain proceeded to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01397-00330202-00330426": "easily defeat Democratic Tucson City", "54XGuuII2Fu-01398-00330427-00330609": "Councilman Rodney Glassman in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01399-00330610-00330753": "general election in the lame-duck", "54XGuuII2Fu-01400-00330754-00331044": "session of the 111th Congress McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01401-00331045-00331239": "voted for the compromise tax relief", "54XGuuII2Fu-01402-00331240-00331377": "Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization", "54XGuuII2Fu-01403-00331378-00331749": "and Job Creation Act of 2010 but against", "54XGuuII2Fu-01404-00331750-00331884": "the DREAM Act which he had once", "54XGuuII2Fu-01405-00331885-00332169": "sponsored and the New START treaty most", "54XGuuII2Fu-01406-00332170-00332349": "prominently he continued to lead the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01407-00332350-00332571": "eventually losing fight against Don't", "54XGuuII2Fu-01408-00332572-00332898": "Ask Don't Tell repeal in his opposition", "54XGuuII2Fu-01409-00332899-00333105": "he sometimes fell into anger or", "54XGuuII2Fu-01410-00333106-00333312": "hostility on the Senate floor and called", "54XGuuII2Fu-01411-00333313-00333618": "its passage a very sad day that would", "54XGuuII2Fu-01412-00333619-00333804": "compromise the battle effectiveness of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01413-00333805-00334143": "the military", "54XGuuII2Fu-01414-00334144-00334657": "topic v Senate term", "54XGuuII2Fu-01415-00334658-00334841": "while control of the House of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01416-00334842-00334999": "Representatives went over to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01417-00335000-00335257": "Republicans in the 112th Congress the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01418-00335258-00335452": "Senate stayed Democratic and McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01419-00335453-00335608": "continued to be the ranking member of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01420-00335609-00335797": "the Senate Armed Services Committee as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01421-00335798-00336049": "the Arab Spring took center stage", "54XGuuII2Fu-01422-00336050-00336274": "McCain urged that the embattled Egyptian", "54XGuuII2Fu-01423-00336275-00336512": "President Hosni Mubarak stepped down and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01424-00336513-00336625": "thought the u.s. should push for", "54XGuuII2Fu-01425-00336626-00336842": "democratic reforms in the region despite", "54XGuuII2Fu-01426-00336843-00337033": "the associated risks of religious", "54XGuuII2Fu-01427-00337034-00337324": "extremists gaining power McCain was an", "54XGuuII2Fu-01428-00337325-00337570": "especially vocal supporter of the 2011", "54XGuuII2Fu-01429-00337571-00337868": "military intervention in Libya in April", "54XGuuII2Fu-01430-00337869-00338083": "of that year he visited the Andy Gaddafi", "54XGuuII2Fu-01431-00338084-00338278": "forces and National Transitional Council", "54XGuuII2Fu-01432-00338279-00338545": "in Benghazi the highest-ranking American", "54XGuuII2Fu-01433-00338546-00338741": "to do so and said that the rebel forces", "54XGuuII2Fu-01434-00338742-00339092": "were my heroes in June he joined with", "54XGuuII2Fu-01435-00339093-00339295": "Senator Kerry and offering a resolution", "54XGuuII2Fu-01436-00339296-00339484": "that would have authorized the military", "54XGuuII2Fu-01437-00339485-00339649": "intervention and said the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01438-00339650-00339859": "administration's disregard for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01439-00339860-00340088": "elected representatives of the American", "54XGuuII2Fu-01440-00340089-00340306": "people on this matter has been troubling", "54XGuuII2Fu-01441-00340307-00340648": "and counterproductive in August McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01442-00340649-00340849": "voted for the Budget Control Act of 2011", "54XGuuII2Fu-01443-00340850-00341090": "that resolved the u.s. debt ceiling", "54XGuuII2Fu-01444-00341091-00341383": "crisis in November McCain and Senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-01445-00341384-00341596": "Carl Levin were leaders in efforts to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01446-00341597-00341765": "codify in the National Defense", "54XGuuII2Fu-01447-00341766-00342017": "Authorization Act for fiscal year 2012", "54XGuuII2Fu-01448-00342018-00342256": "that terrorism suspects no matter where", "54XGuuII2Fu-01449-00342257-00342454": "captured could be detained by the US", "54XGuuII2Fu-01450-00342455-00342655": "military and its tribunal system", "54XGuuII2Fu-01451-00342656-00342823": "following objections by civil", "54XGuuII2Fu-01452-00342824-00343045": "libertarians some Democrats in the White", "54XGuuII2Fu-01453-00343046-00343249": "House McCain and Levin agreed to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01454-00343250-00343418": "language making it clear that the bill", "54XGuuII2Fu-01455-00343419-00343640": "would not pertain to US citizens in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01456-00343641-00343858": "2012 Republican Party presidential", "54XGuuII2Fu-01457-00343859-00344165": "primaries McCain endorsed former 2008", "54XGuuII2Fu-01458-00344166-00344363": "rival Mitt Romney and campaigned for him", "54XGuuII2Fu-01459-00344364-00344551": "but compared the contest to a Greek", "54XGuuII2Fu-01460-00344552-00344758": "tragedy due to its drawn-out nature with", "54XGuuII2Fu-01461-00344759-00344963": "massive super PAC funded attack ads", "54XGuuII2Fu-01462-00344964-00345247": "damaging all the contenders he labeled", "54XGuuII2Fu-01463-00345248-00345470": "the Supreme Court's 2010 Citizens United", "54XGuuII2Fu-01464-00345471-00345764": "v Federal Election Commission decision", "54XGuuII2Fu-01465-00345765-00346066": "as uninformed arrogant naive and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01466-00346067-00346297": "decrying its effects and the future", "54XGuuII2Fu-01467-00346298-00346483": "scandals he thought it would brain said", "54XGuuII2Fu-01468-00346484-00346643": "it would become considered the courts", "54XGuuII2Fu-01469-00346644-00346947": "worst decision", "54XGuuII2Fu-01470-00346948-00347309": "in the 21st century McCain took the lead", "54XGuuII2Fu-01471-00347310-00347442": "in opposing the defense spending", "54XGuuII2Fu-01472-00347443-00347619": "sequestration 'he's brought on by the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01473-00347620-00347856": "Budget Control Act of 2011 and gained", "54XGuuII2Fu-01474-00347857-00348059": "attention for defending State Department", "54XGuuII2Fu-01475-00348060-00348258": "aid Huma Abedin against charges brought", "54XGuuII2Fu-01476-00348259-00348471": "by a few House Republicans that she had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01477-00348472-00348762": "ties to the Muslim Brotherhood McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01478-00348763-00348900": "continued to be one of the most", "54XGuuII2Fu-01479-00348901-00349071": "frequently appearing guests on the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01480-00349072-00349395": "Sunday morning news talk shows he became", "54XGuuII2Fu-01481-00349396-00349572": "one of the most vocal critics of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01482-00349573-00349773": "Obama administration's handling of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01483-00349774-00350052": "September 11 2012 attack on the US", "54XGuuII2Fu-01484-00350053-00350289": "diplomatic mission in Benghazi saying it", "54XGuuII2Fu-01485-00350290-00350577": "was a debacle that featured either a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01486-00350578-00350856": "massive cover-up or incompetence that is", "54XGuuII2Fu-01487-00350857-00351096": "not acceptable and that it was worse", "54XGuuII2Fu-01488-00351097-00351300": "than the Watergate scandal as an", "54XGuuII2Fu-01489-00351301-00351507": "outgrowth of this strong opposite t he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01490-00351508-00351714": "and a few other senators were successful", "54XGuuII2Fu-01491-00351715-00351894": "in blocking the planned nomination of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01492-00351895-00352089": "ambassador to the UN Susan Rice to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01493-00352090-00352320": "succeed Hillary Rodham Clinton as US", "54XGuuII2Fu-01494-00352321-00352542": "Secretary of State McCain's friend and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01495-00352543-00352731": "colleague John Kerry was nominated", "54XGuuII2Fu-01496-00352732-00352932": "instead regarding the Syrian civil war", "54XGuuII2Fu-01497-00352933-00353220": "that had begun in 2011 McCain repeatedly", "54XGuuII2Fu-01498-00353221-00353370": "argued for the u.s. intervening", "54XGuuII2Fu-01499-00353371-00353568": "militarily in the conflict on the side", "54XGuuII2Fu-01500-00353569-00353838": "of the anti-government forces he staged", "54XGuuII2Fu-01501-00353839-00354093": "a visit to rebel forces inside Syria in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01502-00354094-00354378": "May 2013 the first senator to do so and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01503-00354379-00354560": "called for arming the Free Syrian Army", "54XGuuII2Fu-01504-00354561-00354705": "with heavy weapons and for the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01505-00354706-00354909": "establishment of a no-fly zone over the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01506-00354910-00355160": "country following reports that two of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01507-00355161-00355323": "the people he posed for pictures with", "54XGuuII2Fu-01508-00355324-00355518": "had been responsible for the kidnapping", "54XGuuII2Fu-01509-00355519-00355743": "of eleven Lebanese Shiite pilgrims the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01510-00355744-00355815": "year before", "54XGuuII2Fu-01511-00355816-00355955": "McCain disputed one of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01512-00355956-00356163": "identifications and said he had not met", "54XGuuII2Fu-01513-00356164-00356397": "directly with the other following the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01514-00356398-00356637": "2013 Gowda a chemical weapons attack", "54XGuuII2Fu-01515-00356638-00356874": "McCain argued again for strong American", "54XGuuII2Fu-01516-00356875-00357066": "military action against the government", "54XGuuII2Fu-01517-00357067-00357300": "of the Syrian President Bashar al-assad", "54XGuuII2Fu-01518-00357301-00357567": "and in September 2013 cast a Foreign", "54XGuuII2Fu-01519-00357568-00357744": "Relations Committee vote in favor of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01520-00357745-00357948": "Obama's request to Congress that it", "54XGuuII2Fu-01521-00357949-00358230": "authorized a military response McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01522-00358231-00358430": "took the lead in criticizing a growing", "54XGuuII2Fu-01523-00358431-00358617": "non-interventionist movement within the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01524-00358618-00358839": "Republican Party exemplified by his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01525-00358840-00359088": "march 2013 comment that senators Rand", "54XGuuII2Fu-01526-00359089-00359304": "Paul and Ted Cruz and representative", "54XGuuII2Fu-01527-00359305-00359652": "Justin Amash were wacko birds", "54XGuuII2Fu-01528-00359653-00359940": "during 2013 McCain was a member of a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01529-00359941-00360204": "bipartisan group of senators de gang of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01530-00360205-00360432": "eight which announced principles for", "54XGuuII2Fu-01531-00360433-00360612": "another try at comprehensive immigration", "54XGuuII2Fu-01532-00360613-00360873": "reform the resulting border security", "54XGuuII2Fu-01533-00360874-00361068": "economic opportunity and immigration", "54XGuuII2Fu-01534-00361069-00361386": "Modernization Act of 2013 passed the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01535-00361387-00361572": "Senate by a sixty eight to thirty-two", "54XGuuII2Fu-01536-00361573-00361791": "margin but faced an uncertain future in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01537-00361792-00362151": "the house in July 2013 McCain was at the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01538-00362152-00362337": "forefront of an agreement among senators", "54XGuuII2Fu-01539-00362338-00362526": "to drop filibusters against Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01540-00362527-00362724": "administration executive nominees", "54XGuuII2Fu-01541-00362725-00362901": "without Democrats resorting to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01542-00362902-00363207": "nuclear option that would disallow such", "54XGuuII2Fu-01543-00363208-00363459": "filibusters altogether however the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01544-00363460-00363633": "option would be imposed later in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01545-00363634-00363836": "year anyway to the Senators displeasure", "54XGuuII2Fu-01546-00363837-00364065": "these developments and some other", "54XGuuII2Fu-01547-00364066-00364296": "negotiations showed that McCain now had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01548-00364297-00364470": "improved relations with the Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01549-00364471-00364680": "administration including the President", "54XGuuII2Fu-01550-00364681-00364875": "himself as well as with Democratic", "54XGuuII2Fu-01551-00364876-00365073": "Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01552-00365074-00365241": "that he had become the leader of a power", "54XGuuII2Fu-01553-00365242-00365418": "center in the Senate for cutting deals", "54XGuuII2Fu-01554-00365419-00365583": "in an otherwise bitterly partisan", "54XGuuII2Fu-01555-00365584-00365817": "environment they also led some observers", "54XGuuII2Fu-01556-00365818-00366156": "to conclude that uh maverick McCain had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01557-00366157-00366387": "returned McCain was publicly skeptical", "54XGuuII2Fu-01558-00366388-00366561": "about the Republican strategy that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01559-00366562-00366771": "precipitated the u.s. federal government", "54XGuuII2Fu-01560-00366772-00367113": "shutdown of 2013 in u.s. debt ceiling", "54XGuuII2Fu-01561-00367114-00367383": "crisis of 2013 in order to defund or", "54XGuuII2Fu-01562-00367384-00367605": "delay the Affordable Care Act in October", "54XGuuII2Fu-01563-00367606-00367878": "2013 he voted in favor of the continuing", "54XGuuII2Fu-01564-00367879-00368157": "Appropriations Act 2014 which resolved", "54XGuuII2Fu-01565-00368158-00368373": "them and said Republicans have to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01566-00368374-00368625": "understand we have lost this battle as I", "54XGuuII2Fu-01567-00368626-00368832": "predicted weeks ago that we would not be", "54XGuuII2Fu-01568-00368833-00369039": "able to win because we were demanding", "54XGuuII2Fu-01569-00369040-00369287": "something that was not achievable", "54XGuuII2Fu-01570-00369288-00369555": "similarly he was one of nine Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01571-00369556-00369738": "senators who voted for the bipartisan", "54XGuuII2Fu-01572-00369739-00369972": "Budget Act of 2013 at the end of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01573-00369973-00370227": "year by early 2014", "54XGuuII2Fu-01574-00370228-00370413": "McCain's apostasy --zz were enough that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01575-00370414-00370620": "the Arizona Republican Party formally", "54XGuuII2Fu-01576-00370621-00370791": "censured him for having what they saw as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01577-00370792-00370932": "a liberal record that had been", "54XGuuII2Fu-01578-00370933-00371265": "disastrous and harmful McCain remained", "54XGuuII2Fu-01579-00371266-00371484": "stridently opposed to many aspects of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01580-00371485-00371727": "Obama's foreign policy however and in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01581-00371728-00371994": "June 2014 following major gains by the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01582-00371995-00372228": "Islamic state in Iraq and the Levant in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01583-00372229-00372507": "the 2014 northern Iraq offensive decried", "54XGuuII2Fu-01584-00372508-00372702": "what he saw as a u.s. failure to protect", "54XGuuII2Fu-01585-00372703-00372918": "its past gains in Iraq and called on the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01586-00372919-00373028": "president entire", "54XGuuII2Fu-01587-00373029-00373325": "national security team to resign McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01588-00373326-00373659": "said could all this have been avoided", "54XGuuII2Fu-01589-00373660-00374022": "the answer is absolutely yes if I sound", "54XGuuII2Fu-01590-00374023-00374427": "angry it's because I am angry McCain was", "54XGuuII2Fu-01591-00374428-00374634": "a supporter of the Euro Maidan protests", "54XGuuII2Fu-01592-00374635-00374790": "against ukrainian President Viktor", "54XGuuII2Fu-01593-00374791-00374991": "Yanukovych and his government and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01594-00374992-00375186": "appeared in Independence Square in Kiev", "54XGuuII2Fu-01595-00375187-00375522": "in December 2013 following the overthrow", "54XGuuII2Fu-01596-00375523-00375780": "of Yanukovych and subsequent 2014", "54XGuuII2Fu-01597-00375781-00375966": "Russian military intervention in Ukraine", "54XGuuII2Fu-01598-00375967-00376209": "McCain became a vocal supporter of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01599-00376210-00376434": "providing arms to Ukrainian military", "54XGuuII2Fu-01600-00376435-00376611": "forces saying the sanctions imposed", "54XGuuII2Fu-01601-00376612-00376974": "against Russia were not enough in 2014", "54XGuuII2Fu-01602-00376975-00377136": "McCain led the opposition to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01603-00377137-00377367": "appointments of colleen bell noah Mamet", "54XGuuII2Fu-01604-00377368-00377496": "and george soonest to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01605-00377497-00377742": "ambassadorships in hungary Argentina and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01606-00377743-00377946": "Norway respectively arguing they were", "54XGuuII2Fu-01607-00377947-00378144": "unqualified appointees being rewarded", "54XGuuII2Fu-01608-00378145-00378414": "for their political fundraising unlike", "54XGuuII2Fu-01609-00378415-00378636": "many Republicans McCain supported the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01610-00378637-00378798": "release and contents of the Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01611-00378799-00378990": "Intelligence Committee report on CIA", "54XGuuII2Fu-01612-00378991-00379311": "torture in December 2014 saying the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01613-00379312-00379497": "truth is sometimes a hard pill to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01614-00379498-00379761": "swallow it sometimes causes us", "54XGuuII2Fu-01615-00379762-00379965": "difficulties at home and abroad", "54XGuuII2Fu-01616-00379966-00380226": "it is sometimes used by our enemies in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01617-00380227-00380526": "attempts to hurt us but the American", "54XGuuII2Fu-01618-00380527-00380838": "people are entitled to it nonetheless he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01619-00380839-00381063": "added that the CIA's practices following", "54XGuuII2Fu-01620-00381064-00381306": "the September 11th attacks had stained", "54XGuuII2Fu-01621-00381307-00381636": "our national honor while doing much harm", "54XGuuII2Fu-01622-00381637-00381927": "and little practical good and that our", "54XGuuII2Fu-01623-00381928-00382140": "enemies act without conscience", "54XGuuII2Fu-01624-00382141-00382428": "we must not he opposed the Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01625-00382429-00382710": "administration's December 2014 decision", "54XGuuII2Fu-01626-00382711-00382940": "to normalize relations with Cuba as the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01627-00382941-00383223": "114th United States Congress assembled", "54XGuuII2Fu-01628-00383224-00383493": "in January 2015 with Republicans in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01629-00383494-00383685": "control of the Senate McCain became", "54XGuuII2Fu-01630-00383686-00383874": "chair of the Armed Services Committee a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01631-00383875-00384183": "longtime goal of his in this position he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01632-00384184-00384336": "led the writing of proposed Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01633-00384337-00384558": "legislation that sought to modify parts", "54XGuuII2Fu-01634-00384559-00384831": "of the goldwater-nichols Act of 1986 in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01635-00384832-00385047": "order to return responsibility for major", "54XGuuII2Fu-01636-00385048-00385266": "weapons systems acquisition back to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01637-00385267-00385446": "individual Armed Services and their", "54XGuuII2Fu-01638-00385447-00385599": "secretaries and away from the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01639-00385600-00385767": "Undersecretary of defense for", "54XGuuII2Fu-01640-00385768-00386021": "acquisition technology and logistics as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01641-00386022-00386259": "chair McCain tried to maintain a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01642-00386260-00386466": "bipartisan approach and forged a good", "54XGuuII2Fu-01643-00386467-00386649": "relationship with ranking member Jack", "54XGuuII2Fu-01644-00386650-00387009": "Reed in April 2015 McCain announced that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01645-00387010-00387054": "he would", "54XGuuII2Fu-01646-00387055-00387300": "for a sixth term in Arizona's 2016", "54XGuuII2Fu-01647-00387301-00387525": "Senate election while there was still", "54XGuuII2Fu-01648-00387526-00387744": "conservative and Tea Party anger at him", "54XGuuII2Fu-01649-00387745-00387909": "it was unclear if they would mount an", "54XGuuII2Fu-01650-00387910-00388103": "effective primary challenge against him", "54XGuuII2Fu-01651-00388104-00388284": "during 2015", "54XGuuII2Fu-01652-00388285-00388488": "McCain strongly opposed the Obama", "54XGuuII2Fu-01653-00388489-00388713": "administration's proposed comprehensive", "54XGuuII2Fu-01654-00388714-00388908": "agreement on the Iranian nuclear program", "54XGuuII2Fu-01655-00388909-00389091": "later finalized as the joint", "54XGuuII2Fu-01656-00389092-00389340": "comprehensive plan of action jcpoa", "54XGuuII2Fu-01657-00389341-00389604": "saying that Secretary of State Kerry was", "54XGuuII2Fu-01658-00389605-00390152": "delusional and giv aim away the store in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01659-00390153-00390447": "negotiations with Iran McCain supported", "54XGuuII2Fu-01660-00390448-00390621": "the Saudi Arabian LED military", "54XGuuII2Fu-01661-00390622-00390810": "intervention in Yemen against the Shia", "54XGuuII2Fu-01662-00390811-00391002": "how this and forces loyal to former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01663-00391003-00391248": "President Ali Abdullah Saleh saying I'm", "54XGuuII2Fu-01664-00391249-00391605": "sure civilians die in war not nearly as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01665-00391606-00391903": "many as the how this have executed", "54XGuuII2Fu-01666-00391904-00392149": "mccain accused President Obama of being", "54XGuuII2Fu-01667-00392150-00392521": "directly responsible for the 2016", "54XGuuII2Fu-01668-00392522-00392755": "Orlando nightclub shooting because when", "54XGuuII2Fu-01669-00392756-00393016": "he pulled everybody out of Iraq al-qaeda", "54XGuuII2Fu-01670-00393017-00393310": "went to Syria became Isis and Isis as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01671-00393311-00393484": "what it is today thanks to Barack", "54XGuuII2Fu-01672-00393485-00393919": "Obama's failures during the 2016", "54XGuuII2Fu-01673-00393920-00394138": "Republican primaries McCain said he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01674-00394139-00394309": "would support the Republican nominee", "54XGuuII2Fu-01675-00394310-00394486": "even if it was Donald Trump but", "54XGuuII2Fu-01676-00394487-00394756": "following Mitt Romney's 2016 Andy Trump", "54XGuuII2Fu-01677-00394757-00394957": "speech McCain endorsed the sentiments", "54XGuuII2Fu-01678-00394958-00395146": "expressed in that speech saying he had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01679-00395147-00395319": "serious concerns about Trump's", "54XGuuII2Fu-01680-00395320-00395497": "uninformed and indeed dangerous", "54XGuuII2Fu-01681-00395498-00395835": "statements on national security issues", "54XGuuII2Fu-01682-00395836-00396058": "relations between the two had been", "54XGuuII2Fu-01683-00396059-00396244": "fraught since early in the Donald Trump", "54XGuuII2Fu-01684-00396245-00396484": "presidential campaign 2016", "54XGuuII2Fu-01685-00396485-00396652": "when McCain referred to a roomful of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01686-00396653-00396979": "Trump supporters as crazies and the real", "54XGuuII2Fu-01687-00396980-00397207": "estate mogul then said of McCain he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01688-00397208-00397465": "insulted me and he insulted everyone in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01689-00397466-00397643": "that room", "54XGuuII2Fu-01690-00397644-00397885": "he is a war hero because he was captured", "54XGuuII2Fu-01691-00397886-00398278": "I like people who weren't captured", "54XGuuII2Fu-01692-00398279-00398584": "perhaps he was a war hero but right now", "54XGuuII2Fu-01693-00398585-00398822": "he said a lot of very bad things about a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01694-00398823-00399133": "lot of people following Trump becoming", "54XGuuII2Fu-01695-00399134-00399329": "the presumptive nominee of the party on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01696-00399330-00399545": "May 3rd McCain said that Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01697-00399546-00399737": "voters had spoken and he would support", "54XGuuII2Fu-01698-00399738-00399955": "Trump McCain himself faced a primary", "54XGuuII2Fu-01699-00399956-00400151": "challenge from Kelly Ward a fervent", "54XGuuII2Fu-01700-00400152-00400357": "Trump supporter and then was expected to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01701-00400358-00400534": "face a potentially strong challenge from", "54XGuuII2Fu-01702-00400535-00400708": "Democratic congresswoman Ann Kirkpatrick", "54XGuuII2Fu-01703-00400709-00401018": "in the general election the senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-01704-00401019-00401198": "privately expressed worry over the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01705-00401199-00401380": "effect that trumps in popularity among", "54XGuuII2Fu-01706-00401381-00401581": "Hispanic voters might have on his own", "54XGuuII2Fu-01707-00401582-00401795": "chances but also was concerned with more", "54XGuuII2Fu-01708-00401796-00402002": "conservative Pro Trump voters he less", "54XGuuII2Fu-01709-00402003-00402188": "kept his endorsement of Trump in place", "54XGuuII2Fu-01710-00402189-00402365": "but tried to speak of him as little as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01711-00402366-00402542": "possible given their disagreements", "54XGuuII2Fu-01712-00402543-00402797": "however McCain defeated Ward in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01713-00402798-00403004": "primary by a double-digit percentage", "54XGuuII2Fu-01714-00403005-00403190": "point margin and gained a similar lead", "54XGuuII2Fu-01715-00403191-00403397": "over Kirkpatrick in general election", "54XGuuII2Fu-01716-00403398-00403606": "polls and when the Donald Trump Access", "54XGuuII2Fu-01717-00403607-00403810": "Hollywood controversy broke he felt", "54XGuuII2Fu-01718-00403811-00403973": "secure enough to uh knocked over eight", "54XGuuII2Fu-01719-00403974-00404185": "withdraw his endorsement of Trump McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01720-00404186-00404402": "stated that Trump's demeaning comments", "54XGuuII2Fu-01721-00404403-00404663": "about women and his boasts about sexual", "54XGuuII2Fu-01722-00404664-00405007": "assaults made it impossible to continue", "54XGuuII2Fu-01723-00405008-00405224": "to offer even conditional support and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01724-00405225-00405455": "added that he would not vote for Hillary", "54XGuuII2Fu-01725-00405456-00405674": "Clinton but would instead write in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01726-00405675-00405820": "name of some good conservative", "54XGuuII2Fu-01727-00405821-00406052": "Republican who is qualified to be", "54XGuuII2Fu-01728-00406053-00406412": "President McCain at 80 years of age went", "54XGuuII2Fu-01729-00406413-00406616": "on to defeat Kirkpatrick securing a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01730-00406617-00406834": "sixth term as United States Senator from", "54XGuuII2Fu-01731-00406835-00407069": "Arizona in November 2016", "54XGuuII2Fu-01732-00407070-00407233": "McCain learned of the existence of a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01733-00407234-00407450": "dossier regarding the Trump presidential", "54XGuuII2Fu-01734-00407451-00407651": "campaigns links to Russia compiled by", "54XGuuII2Fu-01735-00407652-00407894": "Christopher Steele McCain sent a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01736-00407895-00408038": "representative to gather more", "54XGuuII2Fu-01737-00408039-00408239": "information who obtained a copy of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01738-00408240-00408599": "dossier in December 2016 became passed", "54XGuuII2Fu-01739-00408600-00408835": "on the dossier to FBI director James", "54XGuuII2Fu-01740-00408836-00409118": "Comey in a one-on-one meeting McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01741-00409119-00409318": "later wrote that he felt the dossiers", "54XGuuII2Fu-01742-00409319-00409568": "allegations were disturbing but", "54XGuuII2Fu-01743-00409569-00409799": "unverifiable by himself so he let the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01744-00409800-00410126": "FBI investigate on December 31st 2016", "54XGuuII2Fu-01745-00410127-00410407": "into Blissey Georgia McCain stated that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01746-00410408-00410582": "the United States should strengthen its", "54XGuuII2Fu-01747-00410583-00410834": "sanctions against Russia one year later", "54XGuuII2Fu-01748-00410835-00411042": "on December 23rd 20", "54XGuuII2Fu-01749-00411043-00411255": "17 the State Department announced that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01750-00411256-00411422": "the United States would provide Ukraine", "54XGuuII2Fu-01751-00411424-00411878": "with enhanced defensive capabilities", "54XGuuII2Fu-01752-00411879-00412034": "you", "54XGuuII2Fu-01753-00412035-00412628": "topic sixth and final Senate term", "54XGuuII2Fu-01754-00412629-00412903": "mccain chaired the january 5th 2017", "54XGuuII2Fu-01755-00412904-00413084": "hearing of the Senate Armed Services", "54XGuuII2Fu-01756-00413085-00413288": "Committee where Republican and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01757-00413289-00413480": "Democratic senators and intelligence", "54XGuuII2Fu-01758-00413481-00413743": "officers including James our clapper jr.", "54XGuuII2Fu-01759-00413745-00414034": "the Director of National Intelligence", "54XGuuII2Fu-01760-00414035-00414218": "Michael S Rogers the head of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01761-00414218-00414437": "National Security Agency and United", "54XGuuII2Fu-01762-00414438-00414677": "States Cyber Command presented a united", "54XGuuII2Fu-01763-00414678-00414995": "front that forcefully reaffirmed the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01764-00414996-00415163": "conclusion that the russian government", "54XGuuII2Fu-01765-00415164-00415367": "used hacking and leaks to try to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01766-00415368-00415660": "influence the presidential election in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01767-00415662-00415949": "June 2017 McCain voted to support", "54XGuuII2Fu-01768-00415950-00416164": "President Trump's controversial arms", "54XGuuII2Fu-01769-00416166-00416368": "deal with Saudi Arabia repeal and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01770-00416370-00416582": "replacement of Obamacare the Patient", "54XGuuII2Fu-01771-00416583-00416785": "Protection and Affordable Care Act was a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01772-00416787-00417059": "centerpiece of McCain's 2016 reelection", "54XGuuII2Fu-01773-00417060-00417385": "campaign and in July 2017 he said have", "54XGuuII2Fu-01774-00417387-00417677": "no doubt Congress must replace Obamacare", "54XGuuII2Fu-01775-00417678-00417872": "which has hid arisen ins with some of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01776-00417872-00418076": "the highest premium increases in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01777-00418077-00418355": "nation and left 14 of Arizona's 15", "54XGuuII2Fu-01778-00418356-00418601": "counties with only one provider option", "54XGuuII2Fu-01779-00418602-00418916": "on the exchanges this year he added that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01780-00418917-00419072": "he supports affordable and quality", "54XGuuII2Fu-01781-00419072-00419270": "health care but objected that the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01782-00419271-00419453": "pending Senate bill did not do enough to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01783-00419454-00419687": "shield the Medicaid system in Arizona in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01784-00419688-00419903": "response to the death of Chinese Nobel", "54XGuuII2Fu-01785-00419904-00420085": "Peace Prize laureate Liu Xiaobo", "54XGuuII2Fu-01786-00420087-00420266": "who died of organ failure while in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01787-00420267-00420503": "government custody McCain said that this", "54XGuuII2Fu-01788-00420504-00420760": "is only the latest example of communist", "54XGuuII2Fu-01789-00420762-00420943": "China's assault on human rights", "54XGuuII2Fu-01790-00420945-00421391": "democracy and freedom in September 2017", "54XGuuII2Fu-01791-00421392-00421607": "as the ROH hinga crisis in Myanmar", "54XGuuII2Fu-01792-00421608-00421805": "became ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya", "54XGuuII2Fu-01793-00421806-00422027": "Muslim minority McCain announced moves", "54XGuuII2Fu-01794-00422028-00422197": "to scrap planned future military", "54XGuuII2Fu-01795-00422197-00422537": "cooperation with Myanmar in October 2017", "54XGuuII2Fu-01796-00422538-00422732": "became praised president Trump's", "54XGuuII2Fu-01797-00422733-00422921": "decision to decertify Iran's compliance", "54XGuuII2Fu-01798-00422922-00423247": "with the Iran nuclear deal jcpoa while", "54XGuuII2Fu-01799-00423249-00423413": "not yet withdrawing the u.s. from the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01800-00423414-00423587": "agreement saying that the Obama era", "54XGuuII2Fu-01801-00423588-00423860": "policy failed to meet the multi-faceted", "54XGuuII2Fu-01802-00423860-00424163": "threat Iran poses the goals president", "54XGuuII2Fu-01803-00424164-00424388": "Trump presented in his speech today are", "54XGuuII2Fu-01804-00424389-00424914": "a welcomed long overdue change", "54XGuuII2Fu-01805-00424916-00425538": "topic brain tumor diagnosis and surgery", "54XGuuII2Fu-01806-00425539-00425750": "mccain underwent a minimally invasive", "54XGuuII2Fu-01807-00425751-00426009": "craniotomy at Mayo Clinic Hospital in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01808-00426010-00426335": "Phoenix Arizona on July 14th 2017 in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01809-00426337-00426525": "order to remove a blood clot above his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01810-00426526-00426593": "left eye", "54XGuuII2Fu-01811-00426595-00426858": "his absence prompted Senate Majority", "54XGuuII2Fu-01812-00426859-00427041": "Leader Mitch McConnell to delay a vote", "54XGuuII2Fu-01813-00427042-00427238": "on the better care reconciliation Act", "54XGuuII2Fu-01814-00427239-00427535": "five days later Mayo Clinic doctors", "54XGuuII2Fu-01815-00427537-00427683": "announced that the laboratory results", "54XGuuII2Fu-01816-00427684-00427889": "from the surgery confirmed the presence", "54XGuuII2Fu-01817-00427891-00428097": "of a glioblastoma which is a very", "54XGuuII2Fu-01818-00428097-00428343": "aggressive brain tumor standard", "54XGuuII2Fu-01819-00428343-00428547": "treatment options for this tumor include", "54XGuuII2Fu-01820-00428547-00428775": "chemotherapy and radiation although even", "54XGuuII2Fu-01821-00428776-00428991": "with treatment average survival time is", "54XGuuII2Fu-01822-00428992-00429297": "approximately 14 months McCain was a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01823-00429297-00429531": "survivor of previous cancers including", "54XGuuII2Fu-01824-00429532-00429735": "melanoma President Trump made a public", "54XGuuII2Fu-01825-00429735-00429968": "statement wishing Senator McCain well as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01826-00429970-00430167": "did many others including President", "54XGuuII2Fu-01827-00430168-00430524": "Obama on July 19th McCain's senatorial", "54XGuuII2Fu-01828-00430525-00430700": "office issued a statement that he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01829-00430701-00430974": "appreciates the outpouring of support he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01830-00430975-00431295": "has received over the last few days he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01831-00431296-00431517": "is in good spirits as he continues to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01832-00431518-00431700": "recover at home with his family in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01833-00431701-00432021": "Arizona he is grateful to the doctors", "54XGuuII2Fu-01834-00432022-00432216": "and staff at Mayo Clinic for their", "54XGuuII2Fu-01835-00432217-00432441": "outstanding care and is confident that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01836-00432442-00432654": "any future treatment will be effective", "54XGuuII2Fu-01837-00432655-00432987": "on July 24th McCain announced via", "54XGuuII2Fu-01838-00432988-00433128": "Twitter that he would return to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01839-00433129-00433581": "United States Senate the following day", "54XGuuII2Fu-01840-00433582-00434056": "topic return to Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01841-00434057-00434293": "mccain returned to the senate on July", "54XGuuII2Fu-01842-00434294-00434525": "25th less than two weeks after brain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01843-00434526-00434842": "surgery he cast a deciding vote allowing", "54XGuuII2Fu-01844-00434843-00435022": "the Senate to begin consideration of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01845-00435023-00435304": "bills to replace Obamacare along with", "54XGuuII2Fu-01846-00435305-00435438": "that vote he delivered a speech", "54XGuuII2Fu-01847-00435439-00435646": "criticizing the party line voting", "54XGuuII2Fu-01848-00435647-00435847": "process used by the Republicans as well", "54XGuuII2Fu-01849-00435848-00436106": "as by the Democrats in passing Obamacare", "54XGuuII2Fu-01850-00436107-00436315": "to begin with and McCain also urged a", "54XGuuII2Fu-01851-00436316-00436521": "return to regular order", "54XGuuII2Fu-01852-00436522-00436754": "utilizing the usual committee hearings", "54XGuuII2Fu-01853-00436755-00437065": "and deliberations on July 28th he cast", "54XGuuII2Fu-01854-00437066-00437218": "the decisive vote against the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01855-00437219-00437422": "Republicans final proposal that month", "54XGuuII2Fu-01856-00437423-00437764": "the so called skinny repeal option which", "54XGuuII2Fu-01857-00437765-00438109": "failed 49 to 51 McCain did not vote in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01858-00438110-00438379": "the Senate after December 2017 remaining", "54XGuuII2Fu-01859-00438380-00438598": "instead in Arizona to undergo cancer", "54XGuuII2Fu-01860-00438599-00438931": "treatment on April 15th 2018 he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01861-00438932-00439084": "underwent surgery for an infection", "54XGuuII2Fu-01862-00439085-00439297": "relating to diverticulitis and the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01863-00439298-00439468": "following day was reported to be in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01864-00439469-00439884": "stable condition", "54XGuuII2Fu-01865-00439885-00440362": "topic committee assignments", "54XGuuII2Fu-01866-00440363-00440646": "Committee on Armed Services chair as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01867-00440647-00440896": "chair of the full committee may serve as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01868-00440897-00441144": "an ex officio member of any subcommittee", "54XGuuII2Fu-01869-00441145-00441383": "Committee on Homeland Security and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01870-00441384-00441658": "Governmental Affairs permanent", "54XGuuII2Fu-01871-00441659-00441883": "Subcommittee on investigations", "54XGuuII2Fu-01872-00441884-00442081": "Subcommittee on financial and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01873-00442082-00442354": "contracting Oversight Committee on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01874-00442355-00442627": "Indian Affairs Committee on Intelligence", "54XGuuII2Fu-01875-00442628-00443056": "ex officio", "54XGuuII2Fu-01876-00443057-00443616": "topic caucus memberships", "54XGuuII2Fu-01877-00443617-00443985": "international conservation caucus Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-01878-00443987-00444349": "diabetes caucus Senate National Security", "54XGuuII2Fu-01879-00444350-00444708": "caucus co-chair sportsmen's caucus", "54XGuuII2Fu-01880-00444709-00444958": "Senate wilderness and public lands", "54XGuuII2Fu-01881-00444959-00445396": "caucus Senate Ukraine caucus Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-01882-00445397-00445809": "Main Street Partnership", "54XGuuII2Fu-01883-00445810-00446343": "topic death and funeral", "54XGuuII2Fu-01884-00446344-00446635": "mccain's family announced on August 24", "54XGuuII2Fu-01885-00446635-00446863": "2018 that he would no longer receive", "54XGuuII2Fu-01886-00446864-00447114": "treatment for his cancer he died the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01887-00447116-00447625": "next day at 4:28 p.m. MST 11:28 p.m. UTC", "54XGuuII2Fu-01888-00447626-00447877": "with his wife and family beside him at", "54XGuuII2Fu-01889-00447878-00448200": "his home in Cornwall Arizona aged 81", "54XGuuII2Fu-01890-00448201-00448485": "McCain lay in state in the Arizona State", "54XGuuII2Fu-01891-00448487-00448705": "Capitol in Phoenix on August 29th", "54XGuuII2Fu-01892-00448706-00448935": "McCain's birthday followed by a service", "54XGuuII2Fu-01893-00448937-00449116": "at North Phoenix Baptist Church on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01894-00449117-00449383": "August 30th his body travelled to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01895-00449384-00449545": "Washington to lie in state in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01896-00449546-00449766": "rotunda of the United States Capitol on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01897-00449767-00449989": "August 31st before a service at the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01898-00449989-00450154": "Washington National Cathedral on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01899-00450155-00450459": "September 1st he was a lifelong", "54XGuuII2Fu-01900-00450460-00450730": "Episcopalian who attended but did not", "54XGuuII2Fu-01901-00450731-00450934": "join a Southern Baptist Church for at", "54XGuuII2Fu-01902-00450935-00451180": "least 17 years memorial services were", "54XGuuII2Fu-01903-00451181-00451459": "scheduled in both denominations he was", "54XGuuII2Fu-01904-00451460-00451627": "buried at the United States Naval", "54XGuuII2Fu-01905-00451628-00451906": "Academy Cemetery on September 2nd next", "54XGuuII2Fu-01906-00451907-00452095": "to his naval academy classmate and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01907-00452096-00452343": "lifelong friend Admiral Charles R Larson", "54XGuuII2Fu-01908-00452344-00452629": "prior to his death McCain requested that", "54XGuuII2Fu-01909-00452630-00452854": "former presidents george w bush and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01910-00452855-00453070": "barack obama deliver eulogies at his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01911-00453071-00453262": "funeral and asked that both president", "54XGuuII2Fu-01912-00453263-00453445": "donald trump and former Alaska governor", "54XGuuII2Fu-01913-00453446-00453730": "and 2008 vice presidential nominee Sarah", "54XGuuII2Fu-01914-00453731-00453984": "Palin not attend any of the services", "54XGuuII2Fu-01915-00453985-00454228": "McCain himself planned the funeral", "54XGuuII2Fu-01916-00454229-00454372": "arrangements and selected his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01917-00454372-00454516": "pallbearers for the service in", "54XGuuII2Fu-01918-00454517-00454695": "Washington including former Vice", "54XGuuII2Fu-01919-00454696-00454939": "President Joe Biden former Wisconsin", "54XGuuII2Fu-01920-00454939-00455179": "Senator Russ Feingold former Secretary", "54XGuuII2Fu-01921-00455180-00455391": "of Defense William Cohen actor Warren", "54XGuuII2Fu-01922-00455392-00455605": "Beatty and Russian dissident Vladimir", "54XGuuII2Fu-01923-00455606-00455824": "Vladimirovich Keira Mirza multiple", "54XGuuII2Fu-01924-00455825-00455977": "foreign leaders attended McCain's", "54XGuuII2Fu-01925-00455978-00456214": "service including Secretary General of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01926-00456214-00456424": "NATO yen Stoltenberg president of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01927-00456425-00456670": "Ukraine Petro poroshenko Speaker of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01928-00456671-00456945": "Taiwan's Congress su jocha yuan National", "54XGuuII2Fu-01929-00456946-00457168": "Defense Minister of Canada Harjit Sajjan", "54XGuuII2Fu-01930-00457168-00457432": "Defense Minister URI looook and foreign", "54XGuuII2Fu-01931-00457433-00457660": "minister Sven mixer of Estonia foreign", "54XGuuII2Fu-01932-00457660-00457860": "minister of Latvia Edgar's Rinka vyx", "54XGuuII2Fu-01933-00457862-00458074": "foreign minister of Lithuania Lennis", "54XGuuII2Fu-01934-00458075-00458268": "Antonis link Avicii Asst and foreign", "54XGuuII2Fu-01935-00458269-00458500": "affairs minister of Saudi Arabia Adel", "54XGuuII2Fu-01936-00458501-00458713": "al-jubeir Arizona Governor Doug Ducey", "54XGuuII2Fu-01937-00458714-00458905": "was empowered to appoint McCain's", "54XGuuII2Fu-01938-00458906-00459100": "interim replacement until a special", "54XGuuII2Fu-01939-00459101-00459328": "election is held in 2020 to determine", "54XGuuII2Fu-01940-00459329-00459466": "who has to serve out the remainder of", "54XGuuII2Fu-01941-00459467-00459712": "McCain's term which ends in January", "54XGuuII2Fu-01942-00459713-00459955": "23 and thus appointed the then former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01943-00459956-00460195": "Arizona US Senator John Kyle to fill the", "54XGuuII2Fu-01944-00460196-00460513": "vacancy under Arizona law the appointed", "54XGuuII2Fu-01945-00460514-00460722": "replacement must be of the same party as", "54XGuuII2Fu-01946-00460724-00460899": "McCain a Republican newspaper", "54XGuuII2Fu-01947-00460900-00461139": "speculation about potential appointees", "54XGuuII2Fu-01948-00461141-00461389": "has included McCain's Widow Cindy former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01949-00461389-00461566": "Senator Jon Kyl and former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01950-00461567-00461758": "representatives Matt salmon and John", "54XGuuII2Fu-01951-00461759-00462007": "scheidegg Ducey said that he would not", "54XGuuII2Fu-01952-00462008-00462199": "make a formal appointment until after", "54XGuuII2Fu-01953-00462200-00462403": "McCain's final funeral and burial on", "54XGuuII2Fu-01954-00462404-00462643": "September 4th two days after McCain was", "54XGuuII2Fu-01955-00462643-00462843": "buried Ducey appointed Kyle to fill", "54XGuuII2Fu-01956-00462845-00463263": "McCain's seat", "54XGuuII2Fu-01957-00463264-00463752": "topic tributes", "54XGuuII2Fu-01958-00463753-00463989": "mccain received many tributes and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01959-00463989-00464196": "condolences including from congressional", "54XGuuII2Fu-01960-00464197-00464360": "colleagues all living former presidents", "54XGuuII2Fu-01961-00464360-00464688": "Jimmy Carter George HW Bush Bill Clinton", "54XGuuII2Fu-01962-00464689-00465006": "George W Bush Barack Obama and former", "54XGuuII2Fu-01963-00465007-00465243": "Vice President Joe Biden as well as vice", "54XGuuII2Fu-01964-00465243-00465432": "president Mike Pence and President", "54XGuuII2Fu-01965-00465433-00465609": "Richard Nixon's daughters Tricia Nixon", "54XGuuII2Fu-01966-00465610-00465914": "Cox and Julie Nixon eisenhower French", "54XGuuII2Fu-01967-00465916-00466139": "president Emmanuel macron taiwanese", "54XGuuII2Fu-01968-00466141-00466338": "president sighing when ukrainian", "54XGuuII2Fu-01969-00466339-00466566": "President Petro poroshenko and prime", "54XGuuII2Fu-01970-00466567-00466803": "minister volodymyr groysman australian", "54XGuuII2Fu-01971-00466804-00467001": "prime minister Scott Morrison who had", "54XGuuII2Fu-01972-00467002-00467205": "just taken office the previous day and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01973-00467206-00467414": "former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull", "54XGuuII2Fu-01974-00467416-00467639": "British prime minister Theresa May and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01975-00467641-00467804": "former Prime Minister David Cameron", "54XGuuII2Fu-01976-00467805-00468075": "Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau", "54XGuuII2Fu-01977-00468076-00468267": "and former Prime Minister Stephen Harper", "54XGuuII2Fu-01978-00468268-00468516": "German Chancellor Angela Merkel and", "54XGuuII2Fu-01979-00468517-00468732": "foreign minister Heiko Maas Israeli", "54XGuuII2Fu-01980-00468733-00468987": "Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu Indian", "54XGuuII2Fu-01981-00468988-00469242": "Prime Minister Narendra Modi Afghanistan", "54XGuuII2Fu-01982-00469243-00469418": "chief executive Abdullah Abdullah", "54XGuuII2Fu-01983-00469420-00469650": "Pakistani Foreign Minister shah mahmud", "54XGuuII2Fu-01984-00469651-00469935": "Qureshi Tenzin Gyatso the 14th Dalai", "54XGuuII2Fu-01985-00469935-00470199": "Lama and former Vietnamese ambassador to", "54XGuuII2Fu-01986-00470200-00470439": "Washington when Quoc Quan also sent", "54XGuuII2Fu-01987-00470439-00470660": "condolences colonel Tran wrong do yet", "54XGuuII2Fu-01988-00470662-00470856": "who ran the Wallow prison when McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-01989-00470857-00471075": "was held there remarked at that time I", "54XGuuII2Fu-01990-00471076-00471272": "liked him personally for his toughness", "54XGuuII2Fu-01991-00471274-00471597": "and strong stance later on when he", "54XGuuII2Fu-01992-00471597-00471879": "became a US Senator he and Senator John", "54XGuuII2Fu-01993-00471880-00472097": "Kerry greatly contributed to promote", "54XGuuII2Fu-01994-00472099-00472395": "Vietnam us relations so I was very fond", "54XGuuII2Fu-01995-00472396-00472643": "of him when I learned about his death", "54XGuuII2Fu-01996-00472645-00472899": "early this morning I feel very sad I", "54XGuuII2Fu-01997-00472900-00473166": "would like to send condolences to his", "54XGuuII2Fu-01998-00473167-00473505": "family in a TV interview Senator Lindsey", "54XGuuII2Fu-01999-00473506-00473727": "Graham said McCain's last words to him", "54XGuuII2Fu-02000-00473728-00473982": "were I love you I have not been cheated", "54XGuuII2Fu-02001-00473983-00474255": "his daughter Megan McCain shared her", "54XGuuII2Fu-02002-00474256-00474447": "grief stating that she was present at", "54XGuuII2Fu-02003-00474447-00474635": "the moment he died Senate Minority", "54XGuuII2Fu-02004-00474637-00474885": "Leader Chuck Schumer dny announced that", "54XGuuII2Fu-02005-00474885-00475050": "he would introduce a resolution to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02006-00475051-00475172": "rename the Russell Senate office", "54XGuuII2Fu-02007-00475174-00475476": "building after McCain 1/4 peel of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02008-00475477-00475710": "grandsire caters in memory of McCain was", "54XGuuII2Fu-02009-00475710-00475887": "rung by the bell-ringers of Washington", "54XGuuII2Fu-02010-00475888-00476067": "National Cathedral the day following his", "54XGuuII2Fu-02011-00476068-00476360": "death another memorial quarter peel was", "54XGuuII2Fu-02012-00476362-00476553": "rung on September 6th on the bells of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02013-00476554-00476739": "Congress at the old post office in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02014-00476739-00477117": "Washington", "54XGuuII2Fu-02015-00477118-00477645": "topic reaction from the White House", "54XGuuII2Fu-02016-00477646-00477910": "president Trump reportedly rejected the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02017-00477910-00478057": "White House's plans to release a", "54XGuuII2Fu-02018-00478058-00478272": "statement praising McCain's life and he", "54XGuuII2Fu-02019-00478273-00478443": "initially said nothing about McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02020-00478444-00478624": "himself in a tweet that extended", "54XGuuII2Fu-02021-00478625-00478839": "condolences to McCain's family in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02022-00478841-00479059": "addition the flag at the White House", "54XGuuII2Fu-02023-00479060-00479254": "which had been lowered to half-staff the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02024-00479255-00479491": "day of McCain's death August 25th was", "54XGuuII2Fu-02025-00479492-00479692": "raised back to full staff at midnight on", "54XGuuII2Fu-02026-00479693-00480010": "August 27th president Trump reportedly", "54XGuuII2Fu-02027-00480010-00480202": "felt that media coverage of McCain's", "54XGuuII2Fu-02028-00480203-00480391": "death was excessive given that McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02029-00480392-00480670": "was never president in contrast with the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02030-00480671-00480862": "White House's initial decision many", "54XGuuII2Fu-02031-00480863-00481035": "governors both Democratic and Republican", "54XGuuII2Fu-02032-00481037-00481303": "had ordered flags in their states to fly", "54XGuuII2Fu-02033-00481304-00481513": "at half-staff until interment and Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-02034-00481514-00481678": "leaders Mitch McConnell and Chuck", "54XGuuII2Fu-02035-00481679-00481852": "Schumer requested support from the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02036-00481853-00482043": "Defense Department so that flags would", "54XGuuII2Fu-02037-00482044-00482235": "be flown at half-staff on all government", "54XGuuII2Fu-02038-00482237-00482476": "buildings the White House relented", "54XGuuII2Fu-02039-00482477-00482689": "following the public backlash including", "54XGuuII2Fu-02040-00482689-00482878": "from the American Legion and AMVETS", "54XGuuII2Fu-02041-00482879-00483060": "and lowered its flag back to half-staff", "54XGuuII2Fu-02042-00483062-00483334": "later on August 27 while President Trump", "54XGuuII2Fu-02043-00483335-00483541": "belatedly issued a statement praising", "54XGuuII2Fu-02044-00483542-00483706": "McCain's service to the country and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02045-00483707-00483918": "signed a proclamation ordering flags to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02046-00483919-00484102": "be flown at half-staff until McCain's", "54XGuuII2Fu-02047-00484103-00484509": "interment", "54XGuuII2Fu-02048-00484510-00485007": "topic political positions", "54XGuuII2Fu-02049-00485008-00485260": "various advocacy groups have given", "54XGuuII2Fu-02050-00485260-00485458": "McCain scores or grades as to how well", "54XGuuII2Fu-02051-00485459-00485632": "his votes align with the positions of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02052-00485633-00485893": "each group the American Conservative", "54XGuuII2Fu-02053-00485893-00486109": "Union awarded McCain a lifetime rating", "54XGuuII2Fu-02054-00486110-00486339": "of 82 percent through 2015", "54XGuuII2Fu-02055-00486341-00486499": "while McCain registered an average", "54XGuuII2Fu-02056-00486500-00486768": "lifetime 12 percent liberal quotient", "54XGuuII2Fu-02057-00486769-00487000": "from Americans for democratic action", "54XGuuII2Fu-02058-00487001-00487147": "through 2015", "54XGuuII2Fu-02059-00487147-00487402": "crowd pac which rates politicians based", "54XGuuII2Fu-02060-00487403-00487609": "on donations made and received gave", "54XGuuII2Fu-02061-00487610-00487900": "Senator McCain a score of 4.3 see with", "54XGuuII2Fu-02062-00487901-00488137": "10 C being the most conservative and 10", "54XGuuII2Fu-02063-00488138-00488335": "L being the most liberal the nonpartisan", "54XGuuII2Fu-02064-00488335-00488560": "National Journal rates of senators votes", "54XGuuII2Fu-02065-00488560-00488743": "by what percentage of the Senate voted", "54XGuuII2Fu-02066-00488743-00488943": "more liberally than he or she and what", "54XGuuII2Fu-02067-00488944-00489157": "percentage more conservatively in three", "54XGuuII2Fu-02068-00489158-00489441": "policy areas economic social and foreign", "54XGuuII2Fu-02069-00489442-00489897": "for 2005-2006 as reported in the 2008", "54XGuuII2Fu-02070-00489898-00490084": "Almanac of American politics", "54XGuuII2Fu-02071-00490085-00490272": "McCain's average ratings were as follows", "54XGuuII2Fu-02072-00490273-00490668": "economic policy 59% conservative and 41%", "54XGuuII2Fu-02073-00490669-00491050": "liberal social policy 54% conservative", "54XGuuII2Fu-02074-00491051-00491403": "and 38% liberal and foreign policy 56%", "54XGuuII2Fu-02075-00491404-00491851": "conservative and 43% liberal in 2012 the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02076-00491852-00492070": "National Journal gave McCain a composite", "54XGuuII2Fu-02077-00492071-00492385": "score of 73% conservative and 27%", "54XGuuII2Fu-02078-00492385-00492670": "liberal while in 2013 he received a", "54XGuuII2Fu-02079-00492671-00492949": "composite score of 60% conservative and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02080-00492950-00493231": "40% liberal columnist such as Robert Rob", "54XGuuII2Fu-02081-00493232-00493395": "and Matthew Continent he used a", "54XGuuII2Fu-02082-00493396-00493588": "formulation devised by William F Buckley", "54XGuuII2Fu-02083-00493589-00493966": "Jr to describe McCain s conservative but", "54XGuuII2Fu-02084-00493967-00494233": "not a conservative meaning that while", "54XGuuII2Fu-02085-00494234-00494397": "McCain usually tended towards", "54XGuuII2Fu-02086-00494398-00494587": "conservative positions he was not", "54XGuuII2Fu-02087-00494588-00494845": "anchored by the philosophical tenets of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02088-00494846-00495160": "modern American conservatism following", "54XGuuII2Fu-02089-00495160-00495403": "his 2008 presidential election loss", "54XGuuII2Fu-02090-00495404-00495604": "became began adopting more orthodox", "54XGuuII2Fu-02091-00495605-00495859": "conservative views the magazine National", "54XGuuII2Fu-02092-00495860-00496068": "Journal rated McCain along with seven of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02093-00496069-00496302": "his colleagues as the most conservative", "54XGuuII2Fu-02094-00496303-00496576": "senators for 2010 and he achieved his", "54XGuuII2Fu-02095-00496577-00496770": "first 100 percent rating from the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02096-00496771-00496951": "American Conservative Union for that", "54XGuuII2Fu-02097-00496952-00497227": "year during Barack Obama's presidency", "54XGuuII2Fu-02098-00497228-00497410": "McCain was one of the top five", "54XGuuII2Fu-02099-00497410-00497605": "Republicans most likely to vote with", "54XGuuII2Fu-02100-00497606-00497803": "Obama's position on significant votes", "54XGuuII2Fu-02101-00497804-00498022": "became voted with Obama's position on", "54XGuuII2Fu-02102-00498022-00498252": "such votes more than half the time in 21", "54XGuuII2Fu-02103-00498253-00498507": "unless censured by the Arizona", "54XGuuII2Fu-02104-00498508-00498750": "Republican Party for a so-called liberal", "54XGuuII2Fu-02105-00498751-00499146": "voting record from the late 1990s until", "54XGuuII2Fu-02106-00499147-00499375": "2008 McCain was a board member of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02107-00499376-00499596": "project vote smart which was set up by", "54XGuuII2Fu-02108-00499597-00499887": "Richard Kimble his 1986 Senate opponent", "54XGuuII2Fu-02109-00499888-00500118": "the project provides nonpartisan", "54XGuuII2Fu-02110-00500119-00500277": "information about the political", "54XGuuII2Fu-02111-00500278-00500508": "positions of McCain and other candidates", "54XGuuII2Fu-02112-00500509-00500666": "for political office", "54XGuuII2Fu-02113-00500667-00500898": "additionally McCain used his Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-02114-00500899-00501054": "website to describe his political", "54XGuuII2Fu-02115-00501055-00501433": "positions", "54XGuuII2Fu-02116-00501434-00502039": "topic cultural and political image", "54XGuuII2Fu-02117-00502041-00502256": "mccain's personal character was a", "54XGuuII2Fu-02118-00502257-00502430": "dominant feature of his public image", "54XGuuII2Fu-02119-00502431-00502706": "this image includes the military service", "54XGuuII2Fu-02120-00502707-00502907": "of both himself and his family the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02121-00502908-00503078": "circumstances in tensions surrounding", "54XGuuII2Fu-02122-00503079-00503258": "the end of his first marriage and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02123-00503259-00503429": "beginning of second his maverick", "54XGuuII2Fu-02124-00503430-00503627": "political persona his temper his", "54XGuuII2Fu-02125-00503628-00503792": "admitted problem of occasional", "54XGuuII2Fu-02126-00503793-00503981": "ill-considered remarks and his close", "54XGuuII2Fu-02127-00503982-00504143": "ties to his children from both his", "54XGuuII2Fu-02128-00504143-00504364": "marriages McCain's political appeal was", "54XGuuII2Fu-02129-00504366-00504530": "more non partisan and less ideological", "54XGuuII2Fu-02130-00504531-00504734": "compared to many other national", "54XGuuII2Fu-02131-00504735-00504995": "politicians his stature and reputation", "54XGuuII2Fu-02132-00504996-00505214": "stumped partly from his service in the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02133-00505214-00505508": "Vietnam War he also carried physical", "54XGuuII2Fu-02134-00505509-00505706": "vestiges of his war wounds as well as", "54XGuuII2Fu-02135-00505707-00506027": "his melanoma surgery when campaigning he", "54XGuuII2Fu-02136-00506028-00506255": "quipped I am older than dirt and have", "54XGuuII2Fu-02137-00506256-00506543": "more scars than Frankenstein writers", "54XGuuII2Fu-02138-00506543-00506741": "often extolled McCain for his courage", "54XGuuII2Fu-02139-00506742-00506947": "not just in war but in politics and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02140-00506949-00507118": "wrote sympathetically about him", "54XGuuII2Fu-02141-00507120-00507395": "McCain's shift of political stances and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02142-00507396-00507589": "attitudes during and especially after", "54XGuuII2Fu-02143-00507591-00507884": "the 2008 presidential campaign including", "54XGuuII2Fu-02144-00507885-00508070": "his self repudiation of the maverick", "54XGuuII2Fu-02145-00508071-00508280": "label left many riders expressing", "54XGuuII2Fu-02146-00508281-00508466": "sadness and wondering what had happened", "54XGuuII2Fu-02147-00508467-00508595": "to the McCain they thought they had", "54XGuuII2Fu-02148-00508596-00508964": "known by 2013 some aspects of the older", "54XGuuII2Fu-02149-00508964-00509177": "McCain had returned and his image became", "54XGuuII2Fu-02150-00509178-00509381": "that of a kaleidoscope of contradictory", "54XGuuII2Fu-02151-00509382-00509579": "tendencies including as one writer", "54XGuuII2Fu-02152-00509580-00509843": "listed the Maverick the former maverick", "54XGuuII2Fu-02153-00509843-00510074": "the curmudgeon the bridge builder the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02154-00510075-00510308": "war hero Ben ton transcending the call", "54XGuuII2Fu-02155-00510309-00510497": "of self-interest to serve a cause", "54XGuuII2Fu-02156-00510497-00510635": "greater than himself", "54XGuuII2Fu-02157-00510635-00510943": "the sore-loser old bull last lion loose", "54XGuuII2Fu-02158-00510945-00511205": "cannon happy warrior elder statesman", "54XGuuII2Fu-02159-00511206-00511571": "lion in winter in his own estimation the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02160-00511572-00511745": "senator from Arizona was straightforward", "54XGuuII2Fu-02161-00511746-00512078": "and direct but impatient McCain's other", "54XGuuII2Fu-02162-00512079-00512276": "traits included a penchant for lucky", "54XGuuII2Fu-02163-00512277-00512504": "charms a fondness for hiking and a sense", "54XGuuII2Fu-02164-00512505-00512681": "of humor that sometimes backfired", "54XGuuII2Fu-02165-00512682-00512903": "spectacularly as when he made a joke in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02166-00512904-00513143": "1998 about the Clintons widely deemed", "54XGuuII2Fu-02167-00513143-00513356": "not fit to print in newspapers do you", "54XGuuII2Fu-02168-00513357-00513553": "know why Chelsea Clinton is so ugly", "54XGuuII2Fu-02169-00513554-00513842": "because Janet Reno is her father", "54XGuuII2Fu-02170-00513843-00514112": "McCain subsequently apologized profusely", "54XGuuII2Fu-02171-00514113-00514358": "and the Clinton White House accepted his", "54XGuuII2Fu-02172-00514359-00514628": "apology McCain did not shy away from", "54XGuuII2Fu-02173-00514629-00514793": "addressing his shortcomings and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02174-00514793-00515042": "apologizing for them he was known for", "54XGuuII2Fu-02175-00515043-00515246": "sometimes being prickly and hot-tempered", "54XGuuII2Fu-02176-00515247-00515420": "with Senate colleagues but his", "54XGuuII2Fu-02177-00515421-00515597": "relations with his own Senate staff were", "54XGuuII2Fu-02178-00515597-00515797": "more cordial and inspired loyalty", "54XGuuII2Fu-02179-00515798-00516062": "towards him he formed a strong bond with", "54XGuuII2Fu-02180-00516063-00516287": "two senators Joe Lieberman and Lindsey", "54XGuuII2Fu-02181-00516288-00516503": "Graham over hawkish foreign policy and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02182-00516504-00516692": "overseas travel and they became dubbed", "54XGuuII2Fu-02183-00516693-00516995": "the three amigos McCain acknowledged", "54XGuuII2Fu-02184-00516996-00517184": "having said intemperate things in years", "54XGuuII2Fu-02185-00517185-00517370": "past though he also said that many", "54XGuuII2Fu-02186-00517371-00517618": "stories have been exaggerated one", "54XGuuII2Fu-02187-00517620-00517870": "psychoanalytic comparison suggests that", "54XGuuII2Fu-02188-00517871-00518054": "McCain was not the first presidential", "54XGuuII2Fu-02189-00518055-00518282": "candidate to have a temper and cultural", "54XGuuII2Fu-02190-00518283-00518501": "critic Julia Keller argues that voters", "54XGuuII2Fu-02191-00518502-00518699": "want leaders who are passionate engaged", "54XGuuII2Fu-02192-00518700-00519029": "fiery and feisty McCain employed both", "54XGuuII2Fu-02193-00519030-00519239": "profanity and shouting on occasion", "54XGuuII2Fu-02194-00519239-00519416": "although such incidents became less", "54XGuuII2Fu-02195-00519417-00519683": "frequent over the years lieberman made", "54XGuuII2Fu-02196-00519684-00519914": "this observation it is not the kind of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02197-00519914-00520222": "anger that is a loss of control he is a", "54XGuuII2Fu-02198-00520223-00520514": "very controlled person senator thad", "54XGuuII2Fu-02199-00520514-00520739": "cochran who knew mccain for decades and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02200-00520739-00520943": "had battled him over earmarks expressed", "54XGuuII2Fu-02201-00520943-00521177": "concern about him McCain presidency he", "54XGuuII2Fu-02202-00521178-00521249": "is erratic", "54XGuuII2Fu-02203-00521250-00521534": "he is hot-headed he loses his temper and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02204-00521535-00521804": "he worries me yet Cochran supported", "54XGuuII2Fu-02205-00521805-00521987": "McCain for president when it was clear", "54XGuuII2Fu-02206-00521988-00522247": "he would win the nomination the Chicago", "54XGuuII2Fu-02207-00522248-00522464": "Tribune editorial board called McCain a", "54XGuuII2Fu-02208-00522464-00522680": "patriot who although sometimes wrong was", "54XGuuII2Fu-02209-00522681-00522845": "fearless and that he deserves to be", "54XGuuII2Fu-02210-00522846-00523022": "thought of among the few US senators in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02211-00523022-00523178": "history whose names are more", "54XGuuII2Fu-02212-00523179-00523385": "recognizable than some presidents all of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02213-00523385-00523568": "McCain's family members were on good", "54XGuuII2Fu-02214-00523568-00523739": "terms with him and he defended them", "54XGuuII2Fu-02215-00523739-00523856": "against some of the negative", "54XGuuII2Fu-02216-00523857-00524033": "consequences of his high-profile", "54XGuuII2Fu-02217-00524034-00524294": "political lifestyle his family's", "54XGuuII2Fu-02218-00524295-00524519": "military tradition extends to the latest", "54XGuuII2Fu-02219-00524520-00524845": "generation son John Sidney IV Jack", "54XGuuII2Fu-02220-00524846-00525107": "graduated from the u.s. Naval Academy in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02221-00525108-00525413": "2009 becoming the fourth generation John", "54XGuuII2Fu-02222-00525414-00525662": "s McCain to do so and as a helicopter", "54XGuuII2Fu-02223-00525663-00525872": "pilot son James served two tours with", "54XGuuII2Fu-02224-00525873-00526106": "the Marines in the Iraq war and son Doug", "54XGuuII2Fu-02225-00526107-00526379": "flew jets in the Navy his daughter Megan", "54XGuuII2Fu-02226-00526380-00526544": "became a blogging and twittering", "54XGuuII2Fu-02227-00526545-00526742": "presence in the debate about the future", "54XGuuII2Fu-02228-00526743-00526922": "of the Republican Party following the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02229-00526923-00527147": "2008 elections and showed some of his", "54XGuuII2Fu-02230-00527148-00527519": "maverick tendencies in 2017 Megan joined", "54XGuuII2Fu-02231-00527520-00527747": "the cast of the popular ABC talk show", "54XGuuII2Fu-02232-00527748-00527902": "The View as a co-host", "54XGuuII2Fu-02233-00527903-00528191": "Senator McCain himself also appeared as", "54XGuuII2Fu-02234-00528192-00528395": "a guest on the program McCain appeared", "54XGuuII2Fu-02235-00528396-00528572": "in several television shows and films", "54XGuuII2Fu-02236-00528573-00528788": "while he was a sitting senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-02237-00528789-00529028": "he made uncredited cameo appearances in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02238-00529029-00529268": "wedding crashers in 24 and had to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02239-00529269-00529460": "uncredited cameos in Parks and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02240-00529461-00529739": "Recreation McCain also hosted Saturday", "54XGuuII2Fu-02241-00529740-00530018": "Night Live in 2002 and appeared in two", "54XGuuII2Fu-02242-00530019-00530525": "episodes in 2008", "54XGuuII2Fu-02243-00530526-00531029": "topic awards and honors", "54XGuuII2Fu-02244-00531030-00531278": "in addition to his military honours and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02245-00531279-00531503": "decorations McCain was granted a number", "54XGuuII2Fu-02246-00531504-00531814": "of civilian awards and honors", "54XGuuII2Fu-02247-00531815-00532132": "in 1997 Time magazine named McCain as", "54XGuuII2Fu-02248-00532133-00532464": "one of the 25 most influential people in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02249-00532465-00532677": "America", "54XGuuII2Fu-02250-00532678-00532974": "in 1999 McCain shared the Profile in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02251-00532975-00533135": "Courage Award with Senator Russ Feingold", "54XGuuII2Fu-02252-00533136-00533381": "for their work towards campaign finance", "54XGuuII2Fu-02253-00533382-00533666": "reform the following year the same pair", "54XGuuII2Fu-02254-00533667-00533864": "shared the Paul H Douglas award for", "54XGuuII2Fu-02255-00533865-00534164": "Ethics in Government in 2005 the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02256-00534165-00534381": "Eisenhower Institute awarded McCain the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02257-00534382-00534629": "Eisenhower leadership prize the prize", "54XGuuII2Fu-02258-00534630-00534854": "recognizes individuals whose lifetime", "54XGuuII2Fu-02259-00534855-00535047": "accomplishments reflect Dwight D", "54XGuuII2Fu-02260-00535048-00535247": "Eisenhower's legacy of integrity and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02261-00535248-00535614": "leadership in 2006 the Bruce F vento", "54XGuuII2Fu-02262-00535615-00535791": "public service award was bestowed upon", "54XGuuII2Fu-02263-00535792-00536093": "McCain by the national park trust the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02264-00536094-00536327": "same year McCain was awarded the Henry M", "54XGuuII2Fu-02265-00536328-00536537": "Jackson Distinguished Service Award by", "54XGuuII2Fu-02266-00536538-00536706": "the Jewish Institute for national", "54XGuuII2Fu-02267-00536707-00536922": "security affairs in honor of Senator", "54XGuuII2Fu-02268-00536923-00537351": "Henry M scoop Jackson in 2007 the world", "54XGuuII2Fu-02269-00537352-00537564": "Leadership Forum presented McCain with", "54XGuuII2Fu-02270-00537565-00537777": "the policy maker of the Year award it is", "54XGuuII2Fu-02271-00537778-00537972": "given internationally to someone who has", "54XGuuII2Fu-02272-00537973-00538316": "created inspired or strongly influenced", "54XGuuII2Fu-02273-00538317-00538697": "important policy or legislation in 2010", "54XGuuII2Fu-02274-00538698-00538941": "President Mikhail Saakashvili of Georgia", "54XGuuII2Fu-02275-00538942-00539139": "awarded McCain the order of national", "54XGuuII2Fu-02276-00539140-00539379": "hero an award never previously given to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02277-00539380-00539693": "a non Georgian in 2015 the Kiev", "54XGuuII2Fu-02278-00539694-00539885": "Patriarchate awarded McCain its own", "54XGuuII2Fu-02279-00539886-00540149": "version of the order of st. Vladimir in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02280-00540150-00540443": "2016 Allegheny College awarded McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02281-00540444-00540672": "along with Vice President Joe Biden its", "54XGuuII2Fu-02282-00540673-00540904": "prize for civility in public life in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02283-00540905-00541251": "August 2016 Petro poroshenko the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02284-00541252-00541479": "president of Ukraine awarded McCain with", "54XGuuII2Fu-02285-00541480-00541650": "the highest award for foreigners the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02286-00541651-00541997": "order of Liberty in 2017 hashim tachi", "54XGuuII2Fu-02287-00541998-00542252": "the president of Kosovo awarded McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02288-00542253-00542579": "de Byrd Hirai Leary's Order of freedom", "54XGuuII2Fu-02289-00542580-00542751": "Medal for his contribution to the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02290-00542752-00542960": "freedom and independence of Kosovo and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02291-00542961-00543147": "its partnership with the u.s. McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02292-00543148-00543341": "also received the Liberty medal from the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02293-00543342-00543639": "National Constitution Center in 2017 in", "54XGuuII2Fu-02294-00543640-00543975": "the spring of 2018 McCain was decorated", "54XGuuII2Fu-02295-00543976-00544137": "with the grand cordon of the order of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02296-00544138-00544341": "the Rising Sun from the Japanese Emperor", "54XGuuII2Fu-02297-00544342-00544539": "for strengthening bilateral relations", "54XGuuII2Fu-02298-00544540-00544739": "and promoting friendship between Japan", "54XGuuII2Fu-02299-00544740-00544950": "and the United States McCain received", "54XGuuII2Fu-02300-00544951-00545118": "several honorary degrees from colleges", "54XGuuII2Fu-02301-00545119-00545358": "and universities in the United States", "54XGuuII2Fu-02302-00545359-00545625": "and internationally these include ones", "54XGuuII2Fu-02303-00545626-00545952": "from Colgate University ll D 2000 the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02304-00545953-00546066": "Citadel DP", "54XGuuII2Fu-02305-00546067-00546441": "a 2002 Wake Forest University ll d May", "54XGuuII2Fu-02306-00546442-00546711": "20th 2002 the University of Southern", "54XGuuII2Fu-02307-00546712-00547068": "California DHL made 2004 Northwestern", "54XGuuII2Fu-02308-00547069-00547482": "University ll d June 17 2005 Liberty", "54XGuuII2Fu-02309-00547483-00547872": "University 2006 the new school 2006 and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02310-00547873-00548072": "the Royal Military College of Canada", "54XGuuII2Fu-02311-00548073-00548379": "the MSC June 27 2013", "54XGuuII2Fu-02312-00548380-00548645": "he was also made an honorary patron of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02313-00548646-00548886": "the university philosophical society at", "54XGuuII2Fu-02314-00548887-00549159": "Trinity College Dublin in 2005 on the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02315-00549160-00549522": "11th of July 2018 USS John South McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02316-00549523-00549690": "originally named in honor of the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02317-00549691-00549882": "Senators father and grandfather was", "54XGuuII2Fu-02318-00549883-00550124": "rededicated in the Senators name also", "54XGuuII2Fu-02319-00550125-00550428": "topic bibliography topic books faith of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02320-00550429-00550674": "my father's by John McCain mark Salter", "54XGuuII2Fu-02321-00550675-00551283": "Random House August 1999 ISBN Oh 375 501", "54XGuuII2Fu-02322-00551284-00551589": "nine one six later made into the 2005", "54XGuuII2Fu-02323-00551590-00551802": "television film faith of my father's", "54XGuuII2Fu-02324-00551803-00551988": "worth the fighting for by John McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02325-00551989-00552183": "mark Salter Random House", "54XGuuII2Fu-02326-00552184-00552663": "September 2002 ISBN Oh 375 five zero", "54XGuuII2Fu-02327-00552664-00552915": "five four two three why courage matters", "54XGuuII2Fu-02328-00552916-00553152": "the way to a braver life by John McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02329-00553153-00553584": "mark Salter Random House April 2004 ISBN", "54XGuuII2Fu-02330-00553585-00553863": "one four thousand six oh three oh three", "54XGuuII2Fu-02331-00553864-00554130": "character as destiny inspiring stories", "54XGuuII2Fu-02332-00554131-00554349": "every young person should know and every", "54XGuuII2Fu-02333-00554350-00554543": "adult should remember by John McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02334-00554544-00554897": "mark Salter Random House October 2005", "54XGuuII2Fu-02335-00554898-00555279": "ISBN one four thousand six four one two", "54XGuuII2Fu-02336-00555280-00555531": "Oh hard call great decisions and the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02337-00555532-00555714": "extraordinary people who made them by", "54XGuuII2Fu-02338-00555715-00555968": "John McCain mark Salter Pichette August", "54XGuuII2Fu-02339-00555969-00556410": "2007 ISBN oh four four six five eight oh", "54XGuuII2Fu-02340-00556411-00556697": "four oh six thirteen soldiers a personal", "54XGuuII2Fu-02341-00556698-00556902": "history of Americans at war by John", "54XGuuII2Fu-02342-00556903-00557151": "McCain mark Salter Simon & Schuster", "54XGuuII2Fu-02343-00557152-00557601": "November 2014 ISBN one four seven six", "54XGuuII2Fu-02344-00557602-00557877": "seven five nine six five Oh the Restless", "54XGuuII2Fu-02345-00557878-00558141": "wave good times just causes great fights", "54XGuuII2Fu-02346-00558142-00558368": "and other appreciations by John McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02347-00558369-00558745": "mark Salter simon & schuster made 2018", "54XGuuII2Fu-02348-00558746-00559152": "ISBN 978 one five zero one one seven 800", "54XGuuII2Fu-02349-00559153-00559434": "nine Tepic articles in four words", "54XGuuII2Fu-02350-00559435-00559641": "the pals fought back by John s McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02351-00559642-00559977": "three lieutenant commander US Navy US", "54XGuuII2Fu-02352-00559978-00560349": "News and World Report may 14th 1971", "54XGuuII2Fu-02353-00560350-00560660": "today under different title in 2008", "54XGuuII2Fu-02354-00560661-00560940": "reprinted in reporting Vietnam part to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02355-00560941-00561354": "American journalism 1969 to 1975 the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02356-00561355-00561780": "library of America 1998 ISBN one eight", "54XGuuII2Fu-02357-00561781-00562059": "eight three oh one one five nine oh the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02358-00562060-00562209": "Code of Conduct and the Vietnam", "54XGuuII2Fu-02359-00562210-00562434": "prisoners of war by John s McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02360-00562435-00562647": "commander u.s. n National War College", "54XGuuII2Fu-02361-00562648-00563040": "April 8 1974 actual paper foreword by", "54XGuuII2Fu-02362-00563041-00563262": "John McCain to a code to keep the true", "54XGuuII2Fu-02363-00563263-00563490": "story of America's longest held civilian", "54XGuuII2Fu-02364-00563491-00563765": "POW in Vietnam by Ernest C brace Street", "54XGuuII2Fu-02365-00563766-00564321": "Martin's Press 1988 ISBN o7o 903 five", "54XGuuII2Fu-02366-00564322-00564563": "six zero eight speeches of John McCain", "54XGuuII2Fu-02367-00564564-00564894": "1988 to 2000 foreword by John McCain to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02368-00564895-00565125": "glory denied the saga of Jim Thompson", "54XGuuII2Fu-02369-00565126-00565362": "America's longest held prisoner by Tom", "54XGuuII2Fu-02370-00565363-00565911": "Philpott w w Norton 2001 ISBN o three", "54XGuuII2Fu-02371-00565912-00566202": "nine three o - o one two six foreword by", "54XGuuII2Fu-02372-00566203-00566424": "John McCain - the best and the brightest", "54XGuuII2Fu-02373-00566425-00566538": "by David Halberstam", "54XGuuII2Fu-02374-00566539-00566958": "Random House 2001 edition ISBN one five", "54XGuuII2Fu-02375-00566959-00567144": "eight eight three six oh nine eight nine", "54XGuuII2Fu-02376-00567145-00567456": "foreword by John dass they came to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02377-00567457-00567684": "unfinished business Afghanistan the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02378-00567685-00567882": "Middle East and Beyond defusing the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02379-00567883-00568089": "dangers that threaten America's security", "54XGuuII2Fu-02380-00568090-00568418": "by Harlan omen Citadel press June 2002", "54XGuuII2Fu-02381-00568419-00568928": "ISBN DOE 806 five two four three one six", "54XGuuII2Fu-02382-00568929-00569196": "foreword by John McCain and Max Cleland", "54XGuuII2Fu-02383-00569197-00569475": "to Odysseus in America combat trauma and", "54XGuuII2Fu-02384-00569476-00569661": "the trials of homecoming by Jonathan", "54XGuuII2Fu-02385-00569662-00570138": "Shay Scribner November 2002 ISBN o seven", "54XGuuII2Fu-02386-00570139-00570455": "four three two one one five six one", "54XGuuII2Fu-02387-00570456-00570777": "foreword by John McCain - debunking 9/11", "54XGuuII2Fu-02388-00570778-00570990": "myths why conspiracy theories can't", "54XGuuII2Fu-02389-00570991-00571173": "stand up to the facts by the editors of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02390-00571174-00571596": "Popular Mechanics Hurst August 2006 ISBN", "54XGuuII2Fu-02391-00571597-00571914": "one five eight eight one six six three", "54XGuuII2Fu-02392-00571915-00572256": "five X introduction by John McCain to", "54XGuuII2Fu-02393-00572257-00572439": "Pearl Harbor the day of infamy an", "54XGuuII2Fu-02394-00572440-00572664": "illustrated history by dan van der vat", "54XGuuII2Fu-02395-00572665-00572790": "black walnut books", "54XGuuII2Fu-02396-00572791-00572817": "2", "54XGuuII2Fu-02397-00572818-00573315": "2007 ISBN one eight nine seven three 302", "54XGuuII2Fu-02398-00573316-00573654": "eight six an enduring peace built on", "54XGuuII2Fu-02399-00573655-00573981": "freedom securing America's future by", "54XGuuII2Fu-02400-00573982-00574212": "John McCain Foreign Affairs November", "54XGuuII2Fu-02401-00574213-00574710": "December 2007", "54XGuuII2Fu-02402-00574711-00575241": "topic see also", "54XGuuII2Fu-02403-00575242-00575625": "electoral history of John McCain list of", "54XGuuII2Fu-02404-00575626-00575841": "United States senators born outside the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02405-00575842-00576262": "United States", "54XGuuII2Fu-02406-00576263-00576772": "topic references", "54XGuuII2Fu-02407-00576773-00577306": "topic bibliography", "54XGuuII2Fu-02408-00577307-00577840": "topic external links", "54XGuuII2Fu-02409-00577841-00578135": "Senator John McCain official US Senate", "54XGuuII2Fu-02410-00578136-00578492": "sight John McCain for Senate Sean", "54XGuuII2Fu-02411-00578493-00578810": "Wilentz John McCain in Encyclopedia", "54XGuuII2Fu-02412-00578811-00579215": "Britannica February 15th 2018 John", "54XGuuII2Fu-02413-00579216-00579574": "McCain at Curley appearances on c-span", "54XGuuII2Fu-02414-00579575-00579836": "biography at the biographical directory", "54XGuuII2Fu-02415-00579837-00580199": "of the united states congress profile at", "54XGuuII2Fu-02416-00580200-00580475": "vote smart financial information", "54XGuuII2Fu-02417-00580476-00580672": "office at the federal election", "54XGuuII2Fu-02418-00580673-00580979": "commission legislation sponsored at the", "54XGuuII2Fu-02419-00580980-00581324": "library of congress gates HL john", "54XGuuII2Fu-02420-00581325-00581647": "mccain's interactive family tree PBS", "54XGuuII2Fu-02421-00581648-00582080": "february 11th 2016 accessed February 17", "54XGuuII2Fu-02422-00582081-00582368": "2017"}}, {"audio_id": "55fnUTi0VEY", "text": {"55fnUTi0VEY-00000-00000073-00000221": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00001-00000222-00000400": "foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00002-00000401-00000532": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00003-00000533-00001093": "[Applause]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00004-00001094-00003683": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00005-00003684-00003924": "foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00006-00003925-00005673": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00007-00005674-00006480": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00008-00006481-00006869": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00009-00006870-00007334": "foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00010-00007334-00010085": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00011-00010086-00010324": "foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00012-00010325-00013353": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00013-00013354-00013747": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00014-00013747-00014161": "thank you foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00015-00014162-00017105": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00016-00017106-00017364": "foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00017-00017365-00019786": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00018-00019787-00019924": "foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00019-00019925-00020321": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00020-00020322-00021033": "foreign", "55fnUTi0VEY-00021-00021034-00021841": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00022-00021842-00024149": "[Music]", "55fnUTi0VEY-00023-00024150-00024450": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "55idrLc-l3M", "text": {"55idrLc-l3M-00000-00000000-00000265": "hi everyone right now I'm gonna discuss", "55idrLc-l3M-00001-00000266-00000607": "the importance of our diet how our diet", "55idrLc-l3M-00002-00000608-00000947": "affects or even cause certain illness", "55idrLc-l3M-00003-00000948-00001195": "without even knowing it everything is", "55idrLc-l3M-00004-00001196-00001408": "permissible it's not like the Lord is", "55idrLc-l3M-00005-00001409-00001657": "saying do not he chopped it or do not it", "55idrLc-l3M-00006-00001659-00001946": "can be ordinate eat this everything is", "55idrLc-l3M-00007-00001947-00002300": "permissible in terms of food and but not", "55idrLc-l3M-00008-00002301-00002588": "everything is beneficial being to say", "55idrLc-l3M-00009-00002589-00002827": "the Lord already warned us that we have", "55idrLc-l3M-00010-00002828-00003071": "the freedom to to eat whatever you want", "55idrLc-l3M-00011-00003072-00003476": "but utter food we don't eat cuz they", "55idrLc-l3M-00012-00003477-00003686": "have certain consequences under hell I", "55idrLc-l3M-00013-00003686-00003856": "don't know if you have heard of leaky", "55idrLc-l3M-00014-00003857-00004118": "gut syndrome but it's been popular", "55idrLc-l3M-00015-00004119-00004328": "researched right now that this is", "55idrLc-l3M-00016-00004329-00004579": "actually our largest immune system you", "55idrLc-l3M-00017-00004580-00004802": "know the lining of our God like say in", "55idrLc-l3M-00018-00004803-00005042": "the small intestines we have the Bears", "55idrLc-l3M-00019-00005043-00005393": "Patras involved with fighting infection", "55idrLc-l3M-00020-00005394-00005777": "and in our abdomen in our intestines we", "55idrLc-l3M-00021-00005778-00005956": "have the good and we have the bad", "55idrLc-l3M-00022-00005957-00006290": "bacteria there had to be such a balance", "55idrLc-l3M-00023-00006291-00006781": "like say for example I have one pastor", "55idrLc-l3M-00024-00006783-00006970": "that I prayed for him Salinas California", "55idrLc-l3M-00025-00006972-00007228": "last weekend she was struggling with", "55idrLc-l3M-00026-00007229-00007463": "discouragement because at one point he", "55idrLc-l3M-00027-00007464-00007720": "had a sinus infection and the doctor", "55idrLc-l3M-00028-00007722-00007958": "prescribed him with an antibiotic that", "55idrLc-l3M-00029-00007959-00008276": "actually destroyed the good bacteria in", "55idrLc-l3M-00030-00008277-00008489": "his intestines and guess what he", "55idrLc-l3M-00031-00008490-00008785": "developed lustrum difficile colitis or", "55idrLc-l3M-00032-00008786-00009044": "if you have heard CTF colitis he had", "55idrLc-l3M-00033-00009045-00009383": "chronic diarrhea he had bleeding and it", "55idrLc-l3M-00034-00009384-00009563": "literally destroyed you know the", "55idrLc-l3M-00035-00009564-00009809": "function of his intestines then he", "55idrLc-l3M-00036-00009810-00010016": "developed and society and depression", "55idrLc-l3M-00037-00010017-00010174": "because even if you're a bastard", "55idrLc-l3M-00038-00010175-00010414": "yes you're a human being he got mad at", "55idrLc-l3M-00039-00010415-00010673": "the doctor and when we prayed for him we", "55idrLc-l3M-00040-00010674-00010837": "encouraged him to just release", "55idrLc-l3M-00041-00010838-00011099": "forgiveness and he felt like you know he", "55idrLc-l3M-00042-00011100-00011345": "feels so much better and in fact the", "55idrLc-l3M-00043-00011346-00011606": "Lord has already healed him of the city", "55idrLc-l3M-00044-00011607-00011858": "of colitis so thank God that we were", "55idrLc-l3M-00045-00011859-00012196": "just able to minister to him so in our", "55idrLc-l3M-00046-00012197-00012463": "guide we have the tight Junction you", "55idrLc-l3M-00047-00012464-00012623": "know there's these these are cells that", "55idrLc-l3M-00048-00012624-00012830": "are very tight each other he said that", "55idrLc-l3M-00049-00012831-00013124": "the entry of nutrients are very", "55idrLc-l3M-00050-00013125-00013224": "selective", "55idrLc-l3M-00051-00013225-00013482": "to say that our body is designed by the", "55idrLc-l3M-00052-00013483-00013766": "Lord especially our intestines and the", "55idrLc-l3M-00053-00013768-00014037": "colon to just allow the tight Junction", "55idrLc-l3M-00054-00014038-00014291": "to open a little bit if we need it like", "55idrLc-l3M-00055-00014293-00014511": "say nutrients vitamins you know blood", "55idrLc-l3M-00056-00014512-00014754": "supply is something that our body needs", "55idrLc-l3M-00057-00014755-00014979": "it but we don't who needs virus who", "55idrLc-l3M-00058-00014980-00015197": "needs bacteria who leaves parasites we", "55idrLc-l3M-00059-00015199-00015444": "don't need it so the tight Junction has", "55idrLc-l3M-00060-00015444-00015713": "to be very tight and secure at all times", "55idrLc-l3M-00061-00015715-00015966": "also I remember one verse in Colossians", "55idrLc-l3M-00062-00015966-00016281": "1:17 that says that Jesus is before all", "55idrLc-l3M-00063-00016282-00016544": "things and in him all things hold", "55idrLc-l3M-00064-00016545-00016953": "together so I'm reminded that Wow yes he", "55idrLc-l3M-00065-00016954-00017222": "holds us you know our life plans our", "55idrLc-l3M-00066-00017223-00017274": "dreams", "55idrLc-l3M-00067-00017275-00017547": "he holds the entire universe but then he", "55idrLc-l3M-00068-00017548-00017766": "also holds an end to me but making sure", "55idrLc-l3M-00069-00017767-00018116": "that our body is protected from any", "55idrLc-l3M-00070-00018117-00018272": "infection okay", "55idrLc-l3M-00071-00018273-00018531": "I was such an example if you are eating", "55idrLc-l3M-00072-00018532-00018828": "dairy products cheese processed food", "55idrLc-l3M-00073-00018829-00019088": "fast food they actually promote the", "55idrLc-l3M-00074-00019089-00019368": "opening or the leaking of the site", "55idrLc-l3M-00075-00019369-00019619": "Junction and then when this Junction", "55idrLc-l3M-00076-00019620-00019847": "becomes more welcoming there are big", "55idrLc-l3M-00077-00019848-00020094": "protein that travels in our bloodstream", "55idrLc-l3M-00078-00020095-00020322": "that provokes an inflammatory reaction", "55idrLc-l3M-00079-00020323-00020649": "if there is an inflammatory reaction in", "55idrLc-l3M-00080-00020650-00020811": "our body it could trigger certain", "55idrLc-l3M-00081-00020812-00021222": "diseases like Hashimoto's thyroiditis if", "55idrLc-l3M-00082-00021223-00021353": "you have heard of it Hashimoto's", "55idrLc-l3M-00083-00021354-00021694": "thyroiditis causes hypothyroidism and", "55idrLc-l3M-00084-00021695-00021969": "inflammation it will manifest as", "55idrLc-l3M-00085-00021970-00022221": "decreased secretion of your thyroid so", "55idrLc-l3M-00086-00022222-00022464": "you will experience memory problem", "55idrLc-l3M-00087-00022465-00022746": "extreme fatigue dry skin", "55idrLc-l3M-00088-00022747-00023064": "constipation extreme sleepiness foggy", "55idrLc-l3M-00089-00023065-00023369": "days weight gain for example can you", "55idrLc-l3M-00090-00023370-00023603": "imagine that it's like by your diet", "55idrLc-l3M-00091-00023604-00023967": "alone it could somehow trigger thyroid", "55idrLc-l3M-00092-00023968-00024312": "problem another thing is migraine", "55idrLc-l3M-00093-00024313-00024534": "headaches they have findings right now", "55idrLc-l3M-00094-00024535-00024722": "that when you experience tension", "55idrLc-l3M-00095-00024723-00025014": "headache or if you don't know what", "55idrLc-l3M-00096-00025015-00025253": "migraine headache is it's a kind of", "55idrLc-l3M-00097-00025254-00025472": "headaches smaller common among women", "55idrLc-l3M-00098-00025473-00025844": "it's usually on one side of your head it", "55idrLc-l3M-00099-00025845-00026072": "is characterized by like a pulsating", "55idrLc-l3M-00100-00026073-00026280": "headache and you can actually feel your", "55idrLc-l3M-00101-00026281-00026580": "artery and all false ad or injustice", "55idrLc-l3M-00102-00026581-00026826": "all setting headache inside your brain", "55idrLc-l3M-00103-00026827-00027065": "it could be associated with an picolit", "55idrLc-l3M-00104-00027066-00027358": "aura aura is a term that is related to", "55idrLc-l3M-00105-00027360-00027633": "hyperactivity of your nervous system", "55idrLc-l3M-00106-00027633-00027879": "like you know before the event you would", "55idrLc-l3M-00107-00027880-00028311": "experience flashes of lights or extreme", "55idrLc-l3M-00108-00028312-00028670": "sensitivity to to smell or food or even", "55idrLc-l3M-00109-00028672-00028883": "dizziness or a tingling sensation in", "55idrLc-l3M-00110-00028885-00029208": "your face or even like a lightheadedness", "55idrLc-l3M-00111-00029208-00029537": "so those are aura for eating a signal", "55idrLc-l3M-00112-00029538-00029733": "that you are about to get migraine", "55idrLc-l3M-00113-00029733-00030057": "headache they have found out the", "55idrLc-l3M-00114-00030058-00030308": "processed food image cheese can actually", "55idrLc-l3M-00115-00030310-00030620": "trigger migraine and you know the the", "55idrLc-l3M-00116-00030622-00030821": "common belief is that you know you drink", "55idrLc-l3M-00117-00030822-00031127": "coffee to avoid migraine other studies", "55idrLc-l3M-00118-00031129-00031314": "that too much caffeine can actually", "55idrLc-l3M-00119-00031314-00031536": "trigger migraine and so for some", "55idrLc-l3M-00120-00031537-00031883": "patients coffee helps but if you are", "55idrLc-l3M-00121-00031885-00032154": "experiencing chronic migraine defined as", "55idrLc-l3M-00122-00032155-00032430": "more than 15 days in a month then you", "55idrLc-l3M-00123-00032431-00032694": "might have to avoid coffee because that", "55idrLc-l3M-00124-00032695-00032964": "will trigger my brain headaches so what", "55idrLc-l3M-00125-00032965-00033126": "can you do if you have migraine I", "55idrLc-l3M-00126-00033127-00033480": "strongly suggest that you make a theory", "55idrLc-l3M-00127-00033481-00033819": "they say the onset of the migraine you", "55idrLc-l3M-00128-00033820-00034065": "characterize what kind of pain is it and", "55idrLc-l3M-00129-00034066-00034500": "its intensity from zero to ten and what", "55idrLc-l3M-00130-00034501-00034646": "are the triggers like what were you", "55idrLc-l3M-00131-00034647-00034902": "doing with the migraine attack order any", "55idrLc-l3M-00132-00034903-00035148": "stress the triggers get like even your", "55idrLc-l3M-00133-00035149-00035424": "your menstrual cycle usually estrogen", "55idrLc-l3M-00134-00035425-00035631": "surge or an imbalance the trigger", "55idrLc-l3M-00135-00035632-00035907": "migraine headache anger disappointment", "55idrLc-l3M-00136-00035908-00036195": "stress can trigger migraines even lack", "55idrLc-l3M-00137-00036196-00036399": "of sleep so you have to make a diary and", "55idrLc-l3M-00138-00036400-00036636": "kind of like shut down your triggers", "55idrLc-l3M-00139-00036637-00036902": "that way you can live with it we believe", "55idrLc-l3M-00140-00036903-00037194": "that the Lord Jesus is able to heal that", "55idrLc-l3M-00141-00037195-00037545": "but we can do our part to manage to live", "55idrLc-l3M-00142-00037546-00037818": "comfortably when we have migraine other", "55idrLc-l3M-00143-00037819-00038096": "people use non-steroidal", "55idrLc-l3M-00144-00038097-00038462": "anti-inflammatory pills like ally or", "55idrLc-l3M-00145-00038463-00038829": "ibuprofen but others need the so called", "55idrLc-l3M-00146-00038830-00039108": "trip test or imitrex for example or", "55idrLc-l3M-00147-00039109-00039273": "sumatriptan", "55idrLc-l3M-00148-00039274-00039590": "and its function is to block the signals", "55idrLc-l3M-00149-00039591-00039821": "of the pain going to your brain also", "55idrLc-l3M-00150-00039822-00040127": "another example of the effect of leaky", "55idrLc-l3M-00151-00040128-00040329": "gut syndrome that I was talking about is", "55idrLc-l3M-00152-00040330-00040557": "when you are eating gluten containing", "55idrLc-l3M-00153-00040558-00040833": "food like wheat for example we think", "55idrLc-l3M-00154-00040834-00041070": "like weed is good but for some people", "55idrLc-l3M-00155-00041071-00041289": "they are very sensitive to to wheat", "55idrLc-l3M-00156-00041290-00041540": "products in bread wheat bread contains", "55idrLc-l3M-00157-00041541-00041811": "the protein gliadin and it's a big", "55idrLc-l3M-00158-00041812-00042074": "protein and this gliadin again will", "55idrLc-l3M-00159-00042075-00042336": "attach to the receptors of those tight", "55idrLc-l3M-00160-00042337-00042537": "Junction in your large or smooth in the", "55idrLc-l3M-00161-00042538-00042762": "intestines and trigger a reaction", "55idrLc-l3M-00162-00042763-00043086": "causing a celiac disease and you know", "55idrLc-l3M-00163-00043087-00043214": "with your celiac disease you have", "55idrLc-l3M-00164-00043215-00043467": "chronic malabsorption and to say that", "55idrLc-l3M-00165-00043468-00043739": "you are having diarrhea and usually your", "55idrLc-l3M-00166-00043740-00043955": "stools are false smelling and they have", "55idrLc-l3M-00167-00043956-00044223": "fat globules if you have chronic", "55idrLc-l3M-00168-00044224-00044417": "diarrhea then you are prone to", "55idrLc-l3M-00169-00044418-00044702": "dehydration you're prone also to", "55idrLc-l3M-00170-00044703-00045021": "osteoporosis because see our calcium is", "55idrLc-l3M-00171-00045022-00045227": "being absorbed in our contestants so", "55idrLc-l3M-00172-00045228-00045420": "without calcium then you also prone to", "55idrLc-l3M-00173-00045421-00045737": "osteoporosis and also you're prone to", "55idrLc-l3M-00174-00045738-00046070": "other kidney any problems as well so you", "55idrLc-l3M-00175-00046071-00046433": "see how everything is tied to our diet", "55idrLc-l3M-00176-00046434-00046782": "that we can actually prevent or make our", "55idrLc-l3M-00177-00046783-00047024": "illness kind of livable as we wait on", "55idrLc-l3M-00178-00047025-00047235": "the Lord's healing by just adjusting our", "55idrLc-l3M-00179-00047236-00047292": "diet", "55idrLc-l3M-00180-00047293-00047471": "sometimes I achieve - I strongly", "55idrLc-l3M-00181-00047472-00047679": "encourage you that if you have all those", "55idrLc-l3M-00182-00047680-00047921": "inflammatory tendencies like allergies", "55idrLc-l3M-00183-00047922-00048267": "for example much wider try it is lupus", "55idrLc-l3M-00184-00048268-00048657": "multiple sclerosis type 1 diabetes these", "55idrLc-l3M-00185-00048658-00048945": "are all immune related that you avoid", "55idrLc-l3M-00186-00048946-00049262": "processed foods fast foods beef and", "55idrLc-l3M-00187-00049263-00049520": "focus more and switches are fresh that", "55idrLc-l3M-00188-00049521-00049851": "are green or colorful like strawberries", "55idrLc-l3M-00189-00049852-00050010": "blueberries and all bad", "55idrLc-l3M-00190-00050011-00050189": "I just thank the Lord for all the the", "55idrLc-l3M-00191-00050190-00050480": "knowledge that is given as that we can", "55idrLc-l3M-00192-00050481-00050762": "partner with him he said in Hosea 4:6", "55idrLc-l3M-00193-00050763-00050979": "you know that my people are destroyed", "55idrLc-l3M-00194-00050980-00051249": "for a lack of knowledge and so I feel", "55idrLc-l3M-00195-00051250-00051446": "like we have the medical knowledge that", "55idrLc-l3M-00196-00051447-00051692": "he has given us that if this part of his", "55idrLc-l3M-00197-00051694-00051995": "plan to restore us by doing our part", "55idrLc-l3M-00198-00051996-00052204": "eating healthy", "55idrLc-l3M-00199-00052204-00052571": "exercising brain racing him and being", "55idrLc-l3M-00200-00052572-00052804": "and community of friends that that love", "55idrLc-l3M-00201-00052805-00053179": "us and encourage our best so thank you", "55idrLc-l3M-00202-00053180-00053396": "guys I hope that you learned something", "55idrLc-l3M-00203-00053397-00053807": "from tonight in Jesus name Amen"}}, {"audio_id": "55oxt0TBjb0", "text": {"55oxt0TBjb0-00000-00000712-00001374": "nobody can tell me what to do", "55oxt0TBjb0-00001-00001375-00001830": "there's a pounding in", "55oxt0TBjb0-00002-00001830-00002507": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00003-00002508-00002647": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00004-00002648-00002966": "but all my big ambitions", "55oxt0TBjb0-00005-00002967-00003286": "have a way of pulling up", "55oxt0TBjb0-00006-00003288-00003943": "and all my good intentions", "55oxt0TBjb0-00007-00003944-00004254": "but i", "55oxt0TBjb0-00008-00004255-00004762": "will try", "55oxt0TBjb0-00009-00004763-00005074": "[Applause]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00010-00005075-00005228": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00011-00005229-00005711": "[Applause]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00012-00005712-00005927": "is a yeah", "55oxt0TBjb0-00013-00005928-00006263": "i hold on tight to her", "55oxt0TBjb0-00014-00006264-00006506": "and then", "55oxt0TBjb0-00015-00006508-00006747": "[Applause]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00016-00006748-00007695": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00017-00007695-00007862": "uh", "55oxt0TBjb0-00018-00007863-00008077": "[Applause]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00019-00008078-00008631": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00020-00008632-00009011": "my good intentions", "55oxt0TBjb0-00021-00009012-00009059": "[Applause]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00022-00009060-00009129": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00023-00009130-00009487": "[Applause]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00024-00009488-00010313": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00025-00010314-00010420": "[Applause]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00026-00010421-00011478": "[Music]", "55oxt0TBjb0-00027-00011479-00011731": "again", "55oxt0TBjb0-00028-00011732-00012277": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "5619u0iwBz4", "text": {"5619u0iwBz4-00000-00003134-00003617": "where you at right now okay okay so", "5619u0iwBz4-00001-00003618-00003845": "um you know I I've been doing music man", "5619u0iwBz4-00002-00003846-00003995": "since high school on the cool you know", "5619u0iwBz4-00003-00003996-00004151": "since way before then my mother was an", "5619u0iwBz4-00004-00004152-00004438": "Entertainer uh my father was a dancer", "5619u0iwBz4-00005-00004439-00004588": "um internationally and stuff when we", "5619u0iwBz4-00006-00004589-00004763": "came over that [__] was in my blood so", "5619u0iwBz4-00007-00004764-00004985": "that when I got into like High School in", "5619u0iwBz4-00008-00004986-00005122": "middle school high school I played all", "5619u0iwBz4-00009-00005123-00005236": "different kind of instruments and [__]", "5619u0iwBz4-00010-00005237-00005404": "then I really started just getting that", "5619u0iwBz4-00011-00005405-00005704": "Vibe and doing [__] so then", "5619u0iwBz4-00012-00005705-00006143": "um we broke off and I did a little um it", "5619u0iwBz4-00013-00006144-00006347": "was a name Gerard we used to play for", "5619u0iwBz4-00014-00006348-00006550": "the uh for the Broncos way back in like", "5619u0iwBz4-00015-00006551-00006863": "his early 90s okay so he had a record", "5619u0iwBz4-00016-00006864-00007031": "label out here man shout out to Gerard", "5619u0iwBz4-00017-00007031-00007156": "green for the opportunities he gave us", "5619u0iwBz4-00018-00007158-00007264": "at that time you know what I'm saying", "5619u0iwBz4-00019-00007265-00007414": "because everybody play a role in your", "5619u0iwBz4-00020-00007415-00007589": "life to get you where you had to go good", "5619u0iwBz4-00021-00007590-00007787": "or bad right you feel me it's all part", "5619u0iwBz4-00022-00007788-00007991": "of the book right so when we did some", "5619u0iwBz4-00023-00007992-00008170": "stuff with him and everything boom then", "5619u0iwBz4-00024-00008172-00008374": "fast forward then I was doing my own", "5619u0iwBz4-00025-00008375-00008524": "thing then hooked up you know we do the", "5619u0iwBz4-00026-00008525-00008771": "whole hooked up with my boy Ernst rest", "5619u0iwBz4-00027-00008772-00009010": "in peace Erskine what would I please and", "5619u0iwBz4-00028-00009011-00009214": "at that time then he was um then we", "5619u0iwBz4-00029-00009215-00009407": "broke off to start doing party ball fast", "5619u0iwBz4-00030-00009408-00009641": "forward he was doing more of this of the", "5619u0iwBz4-00031-00009642-00009821": "promoting still and it was I was still", "5619u0iwBz4-00032-00009822-00010085": "doing the artist thing okay and um from", "5619u0iwBz4-00033-00010086-00010271": "talent shows and we had an r b scene", "5619u0iwBz4-00034-00010272-00010523": "group back in high school and [__] and", "5619u0iwBz4-00035-00010524-00010673": "um that's when that whole Drive thing", "5619u0iwBz4-00036-00010674-00010924": "happened and um boom and then urgent", "5619u0iwBz4-00037-00010925-00011074": "said hey I got Tony down here man you", "5619u0iwBz4-00038-00011075-00011213": "want to put high five back together I", "5619u0iwBz4-00039-00011214-00011338": "said are you [__] like a", "5619u0iwBz4-00040-00011339-00011488": "[__] man you crazy in a bit", "5619u0iwBz4-00041-00011489-00011633": "right", "5619u0iwBz4-00042-00011634-00011783": "guess what a [__] would normally", "5619u0iwBz4-00043-00011784-00011987": "[__] say to you right [__] like that", "5619u0iwBz4-00044-00011988-00012124": "you're just chilling [__] you're like", "5619u0iwBz4-00045-00012125-00012328": "yeah yeah Tony Thompson gonna uh want to", "5619u0iwBz4-00046-00012329-00012424": "put you in the group or something me", "5619u0iwBz4-00047-00012425-00012574": "trying to bring it back together man get", "5619u0iwBz4-00048-00012575-00012731": "the [__] out of man what you saying all", "5619u0iwBz4-00049-00012732-00012838": "right you know what I'm saying that [__]", "5619u0iwBz4-00050-00012839-00013024": "like that right now go pick me up let's", "5619u0iwBz4-00051-00013025-00013247": "do it boom this ain't pulled up boom", "5619u0iwBz4-00052-00013247-00013427": "Tony pulled up we started high side and", "5619u0iwBz4-00053-00013428-00013601": "then we just Brotherly Love from the gut", "5619u0iwBz4-00054-00013602-00013738": "from you know from the jump you know", "5619u0iwBz4-00055-00013740-00013991": "what I'm saying instant bro and um the", "5619u0iwBz4-00056-00013991-00014165": "high fight so he put the high five back", "5619u0iwBz4-00057-00014166-00014321": "together people know high five from back", "5619u0iwBz4-00058-00014322-00014453": "in the day you know kissing game", "5619u0iwBz4-00059-00014454-00014644": "unconditional love everything all those", "5619u0iwBz4-00060-00014645-00014933": "all those good Waco Texas shout out to", "5619u0iwBz4-00061-00014934-00015077": "everybody man should I even shout out to", "5619u0iwBz4-00062-00015078-00015216": "the new high fives", "5619u0iwBz4-00063-00015218-00015430": "there's they actually put the group back", "5619u0iwBz4-00064-00015431-00015533": "together and there's some and there's", "5619u0iwBz4-00065-00015534-00015671": "some of the original members from that", "5619u0iwBz4-00066-00015672-00015803": "group who there's like three of them", "5619u0iwBz4-00067-00015804-00016013": "ain't it uh yeah yeah there's three", "5619u0iwBz4-00068-00016013-00016258": "three Originals uh and uh and then and", "5619u0iwBz4-00069-00016259-00016450": "then and then two other ones and uh but", "5619u0iwBz4-00070-00016451-00016607": "I was part of the group where came back", "5619u0iwBz4-00071-00016608-00016871": "around the 2000 era around the 2000 when", "5619u0iwBz4-00072-00016872-00017021": "he put that back together it was Tony", "5619u0iwBz4-00073-00017022-00017429": "myself uh Joe Sean Jace move", "5619u0iwBz4-00074-00017430-00017711": "um and uh samaj okay and then you know", "5619u0iwBz4-00075-00017712-00017843": "at the time we kind of like switching", "5619u0iwBz4-00076-00017844-00018005": "members and [__] like that just part of", "5619u0iwBz4-00077-00018006-00018113": "the [__] that you go through you know", "5619u0iwBz4-00078-00018114-00018250": "like any other group like black street", "5619u0iwBz4-00079-00018251-00018461": "and [__] get all the [__]", "5619u0iwBz4-00080-00018462-00018611": "New Edition and all that kind of [__]", "5619u0iwBz4-00081-00018612-00018803": "right so we're going through all that", "5619u0iwBz4-00082-00018804-00019025": "[__] and it did what it did and you know", "5619u0iwBz4-00083-00019026-00019175": "I got a chance to really experience some", "5619u0iwBz4-00084-00019176-00019367": "really great stuff man out of that you", "5619u0iwBz4-00085-00019368-00019529": "know like Performing Artist that I never", "5619u0iwBz4-00086-00019530-00019655": "would have been able to dream that I've", "5619u0iwBz4-00087-00019656-00019799": "been sitting here talking next closing", "5619u0iwBz4-00088-00019800-00019967": "in Houston like Gerald Levert you know", "5619u0iwBz4-00089-00019968-00020261": "and and [__] silk and and all just", "5619u0iwBz4-00090-00020262-00020399": "different people I can't even name them", "5619u0iwBz4-00091-00020400-00020572": "all you know what I'm saying chopping it", "5619u0iwBz4-00092-00020573-00020878": "up and [__] you know", "5619u0iwBz4-00093-00020879-00021275": "[Music]", "5619u0iwBz4-00094-00021276-00021694": "[__]", "5619u0iwBz4-00095-00021695-00022148": "but I always knew that I would be"}}, {"audio_id": "56TROV0sLSg", "text": {"56TROV0sLSg-00000-00000668-00001003": "la parola a POW Fernandez Garrido the", "56TROV0sLSg-00001-00001005-00001667": "word fish migration foundation good", "56TROV0sLSg-00002-00001668-00001876": "afternoon everybody", "56TROV0sLSg-00003-00001877-00002597": "I hope I am doing it on purpose I nobody", "56TROV0sLSg-00004-00002598-00002952": "takes a micro siesta during my talk or", "56TROV0sLSg-00005-00002953-00003299": "watch the cell phone because I really", "56TROV0sLSg-00006-00003300-00003470": "need your attention I really need your", "56TROV0sLSg-00007-00003471-00003704": "support and you will understand why at", "56TROV0sLSg-00008-00003704-00004253": "the end of my presentation so today here", "56TROV0sLSg-00009-00004254-00004843": "I am going to try to show you a brief", "56TROV0sLSg-00010-00004844-00005268": "summary of the status of the river", "56TROV0sLSg-00011-00005269-00005911": "fragmentation in Europe and some booties", "56TROV0sLSg-00012-00005912-00006529": "value pair desecrater and and what are", "56TROV0sLSg-00013-00006530-00006851": "some what countries are doing dam", "56TROV0sLSg-00014-00006852-00007241": "removals and why but before I start", "56TROV0sLSg-00015-00007242-00007648": "about talking about dam removal I would", "56TROV0sLSg-00016-00007650-00007895": "like to really very quickly introduce", "56TROV0sLSg-00017-00007895-00008092": "you our family-owned world fish", "56TROV0sLSg-00018-00008093-00008305": "migration foundation and what they work", "56TROV0sLSg-00019-00008306-00008609": "so we work in several projects the main", "56TROV0sLSg-00020-00008610-00008924": "projects we work in our world fish", "56TROV0sLSg-00021-00008925-00009176": "migration day wall fish migration dates", "56TROV0sLSg-00022-00009177-00009442": "a worldwide event where we celebrate", "56TROV0sLSg-00023-00009443-00009671": "every two years we started very recently", "56TROV0sLSg-00024-00009672-00010171": "only four five years ago and four years", "56TROV0sLSg-00025-00010172-00010553": "ago sorry and while we do there what we", "56TROV0sLSg-00026-00010554-00010880": "are trying to do is to connect and get", "56TROV0sLSg-00027-00010881-00011260": "together all the people all the people", "56TROV0sLSg-00028-00011261-00011546": "that in one way or not or another work", "56TROV0sLSg-00029-00011547-00012041": "on River restoration Delta and lakes in", "56TROV0sLSg-00030-00012042-00012321": "a way or another environmental", "56TROV0sLSg-00031-00012322-00012617": "administration's universities research", "56TROV0sLSg-00032-00012618-00013124": "centers schools angling associations", "56TROV0sLSg-00033-00013125-00013349": "kayak associations", "56TROV0sLSg-00034-00013350-00013628": "indirectly or directly working on rivers", "56TROV0sLSg-00035-00013629-00014105": "why because only one organization only", "56TROV0sLSg-00036-00014106-00014581": "one NGO cannot have it doesn't have a", "56TROV0sLSg-00037-00014582-00014947": "big impact in politicians in the media", "56TROV0sLSg-00038-00014949-00015290": "in the citizens but if we all get", "56TROV0sLSg-00039-00015291-00015572": "together then it's not only one weirdo", "56TROV0sLSg-00040-00015572-00015788": "when we a person or two you know like", "56TROV0sLSg-00041-00015788-00016040": "all these people know we are thousands", "56TROV0sLSg-00042-00016041-00016241": "we are really thousand thousands of", "56TROV0sLSg-00043-00016241-00016640": "organizations work in rivers so our goal", "56TROV0sLSg-00044-00016641-00016943": "is to get all of you together in one day", "56TROV0sLSg-00045-00016944-00017339": "and then politicians and media really", "56TROV0sLSg-00046-00017340-00017552": "get us seriously and we are and in the", "56TROV0sLSg-00047-00017553-00017729": "last world fish migration day we were", "56TROV0sLSg-00048-00017730-00018140": "over 3,000 organization celebrating", "56TROV0sLSg-00049-00018141-00018377": "world fish migration day and how how do", "56TROV0sLSg-00050-00018378-00018719": "they participate it's really easy you", "56TROV0sLSg-00051-00018720-00019016": "can argh an organize a big event or a", "56TROV0sLSg-00052-00019017-00019292": "tiny event it doesn't matter the", "56TROV0sLSg-00053-00019293-00019715": "important thing is to reach your your", "56TROV0sLSg-00054-00019716-00020128": "neighbors your citizen you can organize", "56TROV0sLSg-00055-00020129-00020483": "an open we see in Spanish abhor nada", "56TROV0sLSg-00056-00020484-00020678": "Porto savita's open door and your", "56TROV0sLSg-00057-00020679-00020966": "Research Institute open day thank you or", "56TROV0sLSg-00058-00020967-00021412": "you can organize a kayak competition", "56TROV0sLSg-00059-00021413-00021884": "theatre place fishing days conference", "56TROV0sLSg-00060-00021885-00022268": "talks there has been even radio programs", "56TROV0sLSg-00061-00022269-00022715": "any any kind of thing you you you can", "56TROV0sLSg-00062-00022716-00022949": "think of but to share your knowledge", "56TROV0sLSg-00063-00022950-00023339": "with with the population that's one of", "56TROV0sLSg-00064-00023340-00023558": "the projects another project we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00065-00023559-00023803": "working it in its Amber adaptive", "56TROV0sLSg-00066-00023804-00023984": "management of our ears in European", "56TROV0sLSg-00067-00023985-00024359": "rivers is a horizon 2020 project we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00068-00024360-00024767": "working with another 20 partners from 11", "56TROV0sLSg-00069-00024768-00025519": "countries and always for the depressed", "56TROV0sLSg-00070-00025520-00025664": "thank you", "56TROV0sLSg-00071-00025664-00026498": "and the 485 main work packages of this", "56TROV0sLSg-00072-00026499-00026826": "projects re are as you can see there", "56TROV0sLSg-00073-00026827-00027192": "it's making an atlas of all the barriers", "56TROV0sLSg-00074-00027193-00027429": "in European rivers when I say Europe I'm", "56TROV0sLSg-00075-00027430-00027711": "talking about continental Europe 33", "56TROV0sLSg-00076-00027712-00028119": "countries okay no only European Union", "56TROV0sLSg-00077-00028120-00028395": "also studying the impacts of our years", "56TROV0sLSg-00078-00028395-00028622": "the sea creating a decision a priority", "56TROV0sLSg-00079-00028623-00028995": "realization tools we are studying as six", "56TROV0sLSg-00080-00028995-00029189": "cases of studies and the work package", "56TROV0sLSg-00081-00029191-00029355": "five is communication I would like to", "56TROV0sLSg-00082-00029356-00029505": "very briefly tell you about work package", "56TROV0sLSg-00083-00029506-00029754": "one and five so we are in the process", "56TROV0sLSg-00084-00029755-00030002": "now of collecting all various", "56TROV0sLSg-00085-00030002-00030324": "inventories that exist in Europe this", "56TROV0sLSg-00086-00030325-00030513": "has been very complicated has been two", "56TROV0sLSg-00087-00030514-00030720": "years and some countries like France I", "56TROV0sLSg-00088-00030720-00031023": "will show you now or Sweden they have an", "56TROV0sLSg-00089-00031024-00031317": "amazing database open axis where they", "56TROV0sLSg-00090-00031318-00031554": "have all their barriers listed but there", "56TROV0sLSg-00091-00031555-00031727": "are other countries they haven't even", "56TROV0sLSg-00092-00031729-00032022": "started to to make their inventories", "56TROV0sLSg-00093-00032023-00032181": "they don't know how many barriers they", "56TROV0sLSg-00094-00032182-00032400": "are but I'll tell you that our", "56TROV0sLSg-00095-00032401-00032778": "estimation in the project for now is", "56TROV0sLSg-00096-00032779-00033042": "that even though we won't show all the", "56TROV0sLSg-00097-00033043-00033255": "records in the at last it will be free", "56TROV0sLSg-00098-00033256-00033459": "access you will be able to see the atlas", "56TROV0sLSg-00099-00033460-00033966": "and access to it next year we I mean", "56TROV0sLSg-00100-00033967-00034179": "there will be just a little tiny part of", "56TROV0sLSg-00101-00034180-00034404": "what it's really out there in the rivers", "56TROV0sLSg-00102-00034405-00034668": "we estimate there is over a million", "56TROV0sLSg-00103-00034669-00034926": "barriers in European rivers in this", "56TROV0sLSg-00104-00034927-00035082": "moment and this is a very important", "56TROV0sLSg-00105-00035083-00035337": "figure because until two years ago I", "56TROV0sLSg-00106-00035338-00035721": "kept searching for a number of our years", "56TROV0sLSg-00107-00035722-00035898": "in European rivers and you always had", "56TROV0sLSg-00108-00035899-00036231": "the same number seven thousand big dams", "56TROV0sLSg-00109-00036232-00036831": "in Europe in Spain 1200 big dams in", "56TROV0sLSg-00110-00036832-00037086": "Spain that's that's the tip of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00111-00037087-00037296": "iceberg that's nothing of what it's out", "56TROV0sLSg-00112-00037297-00037452": "there and this is really important to", "56TROV0sLSg-00113-00037453-00037668": "show to population and politicians so", "56TROV0sLSg-00114-00037669-00037860": "they understand the dimension of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00115-00037861-00038187": "problem and the word package 5 it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00116-00038188-00038418": "something that I would ask you to", "56TROV0sLSg-00117-00038419-00038649": "actually right now download the", "56TROV0sLSg-00118-00038650-00038940": "application this is a free mobile", "56TROV0sLSg-00119-00038941-00039174": "application we created it's super easy", "56TROV0sLSg-00120-00039175-00039486": "to to use I won't play the video because", "56TROV0sLSg-00121-00039487-00039690": "I don't have time but you can see the", "56TROV0sLSg-00122-00039691-00039820": "video and internation too", "56TROV0sLSg-00123-00039821-00040096": "it's video where you download the", "56TROV0sLSg-00124-00040097-00040273": "application and then when you are out", "56TROV0sLSg-00125-00040274-00040776": "there in the river fishing walking", "56TROV0sLSg-00126-00040777-00041115": "kayaking or whatever you just take a", "56TROV0sLSg-00127-00041116-00041287": "picture of the very year you see in the", "56TROV0sLSg-00128-00041288-00041545": "river you send it to us you answer five", "56TROV0sLSg-00129-00041546-00041704": "questions it's in Italian the", "56TROV0sLSg-00130-00041705-00042024": "application - it's in 10 different", "56TROV0sLSg-00131-00042025-00042286": "languages and we are working on more", "56TROV0sLSg-00132-00042287-00042483": "translations in this moment so you just", "56TROV0sLSg-00133-00042484-00042727": "answer five questions like what type of", "56TROV0sLSg-00134-00042728-00042999": "Aria it is what is the height more or", "56TROV0sLSg-00135-00043000-00043315": "less from 1 to 2 2 to 3 meters that's it", "56TROV0sLSg-00136-00043316-00043498": "has a fish way that's it now", "56TROV0sLSg-00137-00043499-00043677": "is it still in use the barrier it's not", "56TROV0sLSg-00138-00043678-00043867": "and then you send it to us this", "56TROV0sLSg-00139-00043868-00044062": "application is already being used and", "56TROV0sLSg-00140-00044063-00044343": "you can actually open the map online and", "56TROV0sLSg-00141-00044344-00044587": "you can already see people uploading the", "56TROV0sLSg-00142-00044588-00044868": "barriers in Lithuania in France and", "56TROV0sLSg-00143-00044869-00045073": "Spain in Portugal it's really cool and", "56TROV0sLSg-00144-00045074-00045511": "we our goal is to first reach the", "56TROV0sLSg-00145-00045512-00045705": "population and create awareness of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00146-00045706-00045996": "problem so this is a citizen science", "56TROV0sLSg-00147-00045997-00046371": "program and second to get help and", "56TROV0sLSg-00148-00046372-00046582": "collaboration from citizens and locate", "56TROV0sLSg-00149-00046583-00046714": "barriers that we don't know where they", "56TROV0sLSg-00150-00046715-00047202": "are so please use it and if you want", "56TROV0sLSg-00151-00047203-00047424": "more information you want to get the", "56TROV0sLSg-00152-00047425-00047668": "newsletters from amber or the scientific", "56TROV0sLSg-00153-00047669-00047871": "papers we are producing everything", "56TROV0sLSg-00154-00047872-00048099": "please contact us we can send you all", "56TROV0sLSg-00155-00048100-00048292": "this information we send it like once a", "56TROV0sLSg-00156-00048293-00048598": "month once every two months and the last", "56TROV0sLSg-00157-00048599-00048760": "thing before I start with the removal is", "56TROV0sLSg-00158-00048761-00049002": "that we have a free book that you can", "56TROV0sLSg-00159-00049003-00049249": "download for free even from sea to shore", "56TROV0sLSg-00160-00049250-00049912": "calm and you can see a general overview", "56TROV0sLSg-00161-00049913-00050139": "of what's happening in the world right", "56TROV0sLSg-00162-00050140-00050356": "now in River restoration and down", "56TROV0sLSg-00163-00050357-00050662": "removal there are 37 cases the study's", "56TROV0sLSg-00164-00050663-00050998": "real that it's there explain you can see", "56TROV0sLSg-00165-00050999-00051327": "more or less maker trophies species the", "56TROV0sLSg-00166-00051328-00051663": "most iconic ones and many more things so", "56TROV0sLSg-00167-00051664-00051949": "I really recommend you to read the book", "56TROV0sLSg-00168-00051950-00052371": "and if anybody is wants to volunteer to", "56TROV0sLSg-00169-00052372-00052597": "translate and in Italian we are open for", "56TROV0sLSg-00170-00052598-00052915": "that too and now why don't remove your", "56TROV0sLSg-00171-00052916-00053266": "that's why I came here today", "56TROV0sLSg-00172-00053266-00053747": "six years ago I wasn't massachusett in", "56TROV0sLSg-00173-00053748-00054209": "2012 learning and training and then", "56TROV0sLSg-00174-00054210-00054410": "removal how they do down removals there", "56TROV0sLSg-00175-00054411-00054857": "in the East Coast and I I wasn't shocked", "56TROV0sLSg-00176-00054858-00055058": "of how much information there is in the", "56TROV0sLSg-00177-00055059-00055342": "United States about their removal and", "56TROV0sLSg-00178-00055344-00055595": "all the the inventories they have all", "56TROV0sLSg-00179-00055596-00055787": "the information and study collected and", "56TROV0sLSg-00180-00055788-00056033": "I was like what's happening in Europe I", "56TROV0sLSg-00181-00056034-00056276": "know nothing and then I met herman van", "56TROV0sLSg-00182-00056277-00056471": "again the founder of the wealthy special", "56TROV0sLSg-00183-00056472-00056779": "foundation i met their there and he said", "56TROV0sLSg-00184-00056779-00057011": "it's the same with me we know nothing", "56TROV0sLSg-00185-00057012-00057241": "about what's going on in europe so we", "56TROV0sLSg-00186-00057242-00057413": "came back and we decided to start that", "56TROV0sLSg-00187-00057414-00057698": "removal europe and we start", "56TROV0sLSg-00188-00057699-00057977": "investigating what's going on and we", "56TROV0sLSg-00189-00057978-00058270": "were amazed we were amazed because USA", "56TROV0sLSg-00190-00058271-00058550": "yes many of you will know they have", "56TROV0sLSg-00191-00058551-00058901": "demolished 1,400 very years until now", "56TROV0sLSg-00192-00058902-00059228": "but we found out that europe has a", "56TROV0sLSg-00193-00059229-00059467": "moleish over four thousand already and", "56TROV0sLSg-00194-00059469-00059732": "nobody knows and we were like what the", "56TROV0sLSg-00195-00059733-00060014": "hell I mean there's so much being done", "56TROV0sLSg-00196-00060015-00060302": "so much great case studies and nobody we", "56TROV0sLSg-00197-00060303-00060449": "are not sharing this information this", "56TROV0sLSg-00198-00060450-00060638": "experience and actually we are not", "56TROV0sLSg-00199-00060639-00060914": "showing it to the public like hey this", "56TROV0sLSg-00200-00060915-00061160": "is great and this is why you know so", "56TROV0sLSg-00201-00061161-00061523": "each time a practitioner and I'll show", "56TROV0sLSg-00202-00061524-00061838": "you cases in Spain in Sweden each time", "56TROV0sLSg-00203-00061839-00061982": "I'm a practitioner an engineer", "56TROV0sLSg-00204-00061983-00062204": "administration wants to do a dam removal", "56TROV0sLSg-00205-00062204-00062266": "in Europe", "56TROV0sLSg-00206-00062267-00062554": "same thing in USA but in Europe even", "56TROV0sLSg-00207-00062555-00062873": "more they have the same problems it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00208-00062874-00063101": "like the very first each time they they", "56TROV0sLSg-00209-00063102-00063308": "carry out the executor removal is like", "56TROV0sLSg-00210-00063309-00063574": "the very first time being removed ever", "56TROV0sLSg-00211-00063575-00063841": "it's like a taboo you know to remove a", "56TROV0sLSg-00212-00063842-00064250": "dam and sometimes the social problems", "56TROV0sLSg-00213-00064251-00064619": "and a position are more difficult that", "56TROV0sLSg-00214-00064620-00064829": "the engineering part of removing a down", "56TROV0sLSg-00215-00064829-00065126": "so we said this this must change you", "56TROV0sLSg-00216-00065127-00065402": "know people must understand that this is", "56TROV0sLSg-00217-00065403-00065612": "necessary that a dam is not forever it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00218-00065613-00065873": "not a waterfall a dam is not a waterfall", "56TROV0sLSg-00219-00065874-00066059": "in its maintenance", "56TROV0sLSg-00220-00066060-00066377": "it has safety issues and when you have", "56TROV0sLSg-00221-00066378-00066608": "and own every year well something must", "56TROV0sLSg-00222-00066609-00067022": "be done so and not only that we want it", "56TROV0sLSg-00223-00067023-00067253": "to connect experts and to share", "56TROV0sLSg-00224-00067254-00067490": "experience because sometimes some people", "56TROV0sLSg-00225-00067491-00067760": "face the situation that it's the first", "56TROV0sLSg-00226-00067761-00067958": "time they do it or the second and they", "56TROV0sLSg-00227-00067959-00068102": "think there's the first time and there's", "56TROV0sLSg-00228-00068103-00068300": "so much other examples out there that", "56TROV0sLSg-00229-00068301-00068381": "can help you", "56TROV0sLSg-00230-00068382-00068726": "so our main object is on that removal", "56TROV0sLSg-00231-00068727-00068951": "Europe ease increase awareness and and", "56TROV0sLSg-00232-00068952-00069164": "make people understand the dam removal", "56TROV0sLSg-00233-00069165-00069410": "is the best option when restraining a", "56TROV0sLSg-00234-00069411-00069572": "river when it's technically possible", "56TROV0sLSg-00235-00069573-00069787": "it's not always technically possible", "56TROV0sLSg-00236-00069788-00070007": "overall in Europe if you go to United", "56TROV0sLSg-00237-00070008-00070280": "States another story but here we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00238-00070281-00070529": "talking about we have Weir's and dams", "56TROV0sLSg-00239-00070530-00070811": "from 500 years ago a hundred years ago", "56TROV0sLSg-00240-00070812-00071165": "and a very urbanized area so not always", "56TROV0sLSg-00241-00071166-00071303": "as possible but when it's possible is", "56TROV0sLSg-00242-00071304-00071591": "the best burger the best option second", "56TROV0sLSg-00243-00071592-00071851": "we are creating a solid network of", "56TROV0sLSg-00244-00071852-00072317": "practitioners experts why because first", "56TROV0sLSg-00245-00072318-00072599": "to support each other with all the", "56TROV0sLSg-00246-00072600-00072767": "information and knowledge we are gaining", "56TROV0sLSg-00247-00072768-00073274": "and second because when the media wants", "56TROV0sLSg-00248-00073275-00073571": "to talk about dam removal in a newspaper", "56TROV0sLSg-00249-00073572-00073844": "in the TV villa they have no idea where", "56TROV0sLSg-00250-00073845-00074066": "to go and they ended up they end up", "56TROV0sLSg-00251-00074067-00074500": "going to some little or big ecologist", "56TROV0sLSg-00252-00074501-00074714": "organization bla bla bla that they are", "56TROV0sLSg-00253-00074715-00074915": "not as specialized because they don't", "56TROV0sLSg-00254-00074916-00075167": "know where to go this is another thing", "56TROV0sLSg-00255-00075168-00075454": "that we started actually to to get", "56TROV0sLSg-00256-00075455-00075764": "results on it now the media it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00257-00075765-00075992": "contacting us when there is a debt", "56TROV0sLSg-00258-00075993-00076253": "removal when there is a dam collapse", "56TROV0sLSg-00259-00076254-00076565": "they know where they have to go and we", "56TROV0sLSg-00260-00076566-00076751": "sometimes we answer the questions", "56TROV0sLSg-00261-00076752-00077069": "sometimes we redirect them to the expert", "56TROV0sLSg-00262-00077070-00077501": "of whatever friends UK use USA so we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00263-00077502-00077693": "creating a community and expert", "56TROV0sLSg-00264-00077694-00078023": "community and a reference on on this", "56TROV0sLSg-00265-00078024-00078284": "field and third we want to put our", "56TROV0sLSg-00266-00078285-00078533": "removal in Brussels agenda we have", "56TROV0sLSg-00267-00078534-00078878": "already started doing this because we", "56TROV0sLSg-00268-00078879-00079181": "want to put them removal as an option as", "56TROV0sLSg-00269-00079182-00079421": "the best option when possible and", "56TROV0sLSg-00270-00079422-00079637": "and if we put this in Brussels we know", "56TROV0sLSg-00271-00079638-00079874": "you will support and help many other", "56TROV0sLSg-00272-00079875-00080129": "people working in their countries how", "56TROV0sLSg-00273-00080130-00080423": "the hell are we gonna do this well we", "56TROV0sLSg-00274-00080424-00080690": "started only two years ago and where we", "56TROV0sLSg-00275-00080691-00080930": "started collecting the inventories of", "56TROV0sLSg-00276-00080931-00081188": "dams being removed in Europe I will show", "56TROV0sLSg-00277-00081189-00081575": "you later what we got for now actually", "56TROV0sLSg-00278-00081576-00081929": "here Sweden the the leading country in", "56TROV0sLSg-00279-00081930-00082175": "dam removal is friends they have an", "56TROV0sLSg-00280-00082176-00082376": "amazing inventory of existing dams and", "56TROV0sLSg-00281-00082377-00082745": "demolish dams there", "56TROV0sLSg-00282-00082746-00083135": "their number is to thoroughly 2,400 but", "56TROV0sLSg-00283-00083136-00083459": "that's not completely real because they", "56TROV0sLSg-00284-00083460-00083924": "also take into account collapse dams so", "56TROV0sLSg-00285-00083925-00084350": "naturally removed so super hysterical", "56TROV0sLSg-00286-00084351-00084599": "security cappucci condo parody dam", "56TROV0sLSg-00287-00084600-00084842": "parodies bara meant in general and no", "56TROV0sLSg-00288-00084843-00085106": "Saudis dig a hospital a traduzione", "56TROV0sLSg-00289-00085107-00085451": "Medusa / tracer de Chicopee I will yank", "56TROV0sLSg-00290-00085452-00085759": "a brilliant idea traverses veramente", "56TROV0sLSg-00291-00085760-00086069": "Yankee granted again thank you yeah when", "56TROV0sLSg-00292-00086070-00086432": "we say damn in English we we include", "56TROV0sLSg-00293-00086433-00086624": "also Weir's but you know we don't say", "56TROV0sLSg-00294-00086625-00086816": "diamond Weir's every time that's that's", "56TROV0sLSg-00295-00086817-00087020": "a mistake sorry yeah it's any type of", "56TROV0sLSg-00296-00087021-00087251": "every year little ones like half a meter", "56TROV0sLSg-00297-00087252-00087644": "to up to many meters okay so friends is", "56TROV0sLSg-00298-00087645-00087851": "the link country there there they are", "56TROV0sLSg-00299-00087852-00088067": "doing an amazing job really and I really", "56TROV0sLSg-00300-00088068-00088280": "congratulate them always because it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00301-00088281-00088586": "great Sweden is the second one and they", "56TROV0sLSg-00302-00088587-00088787": "in their inventories you can see they", "56TROV0sLSg-00303-00088788-00089275": "have a thousand six hundred but I put a", "56TROV0sLSg-00304-00089276-00089690": "1000 because we are in this moment", "56TROV0sLSg-00305-00089691-00089963": "investigating that they have instead of", "56TROV0sLSg-00306-00089964-00090230": "removal fish weighs in the inventory so", "56TROV0sLSg-00307-00090231-00090611": "I think the record is lower Finland has", "56TROV0sLSg-00308-00090612-00090986": "removed more than 450 actually they tell", "56TROV0sLSg-00309-00090987-00091256": "me around 900 but I will tell you later", "56TROV0sLSg-00310-00091257-00091445": "when I talk about their policy in", "56TROV0sLSg-00311-00091446-00091714": "situation why it's half the number and", "56TROV0sLSg-00312-00091715-00091837": "it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00313-00091838-00092446": "around to 250 barriers and we are now", "56TROV0sLSg-00314-00092447-00092722": "finding that Denver has removed terms we", "56TROV0sLSg-00315-00092723-00092914": "are in the process to find out how many", "56TROV0sLSg-00316-00092915-00093205": "because we have to contact 91", "56TROV0sLSg-00317-00093206-00093412": "municipalities to find out they don't", "56TROV0sLSg-00318-00093413-00093622": "have a national inventory as friends", "56TROV0sLSg-00319-00093623-00093970": "Germany in in an air in a in a region", "56TROV0sLSg-00320-00093971-00094174": "they have demolished more than 10 so we", "56TROV0sLSg-00321-00094175-00094351": "are finding this moment more and more", "56TROV0sLSg-00322-00094352-00094564": "information and more projects being done", "56TROV0sLSg-00323-00094565-00094948": "it's it's really amazing so we did this", "56TROV0sLSg-00324-00094949-00095104": "address that you can actually see", "56TROV0sLSg-00325-00095105-00095224": "already in our website and we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00326-00095225-00095452": "constantly working on it and we also", "56TROV0sLSg-00327-00095453-00095683": "organize international workshops every", "56TROV0sLSg-00328-00095684-00095850": "year we did the first one in Spain in", "56TROV0sLSg-00329-00095851-00096355": "2016 and the last one was in Sweden and", "56TROV0sLSg-00330-00096356-00096661": "last month and the next one we haven't", "56TROV0sLSg-00331-00096662-00096946": "published this yet but I can tell you it", "56TROV0sLSg-00332-00096947-00097165": "will be made in France and it will be a", "56TROV0sLSg-00333-00097166-00097477": "very near to the biggest star removal", "56TROV0sLSg-00334-00097478-00097660": "being done in Europe in this moment in", "56TROV0sLSg-00335-00097661-00097909": "the saloon River Dam being removed that", "56TROV0sLSg-00336-00097910-00098196": "is 35 meters tall and they are actually", "56TROV0sLSg-00337-00098197-00098542": "they have the water or the reservoir and", "56TROV0sLSg-00338-00098543-00098770": "they will start I'm sorry", "56TROV0sLSg-00339-00098771-00099094": "demolishing the dam in around April so", "56TROV0sLSg-00340-00099095-00099340": "we will do this seminar there and we", "56TROV0sLSg-00341-00099341-00099556": "will be sitting the field trip this dam", "56TROV0sLSg-00342-00099557-00099820": "removal so they're in the seminar we try", "56TROV0sLSg-00343-00099821-00099997": "to connect people and to share", "56TROV0sLSg-00344-00099998-00100330": "experience and everything we could like", "56TROV0sLSg-00345-00100331-00100471": "we put it on the website so in the", "56TROV0sLSg-00346-00100472-00100633": "website you can find all the", "56TROV0sLSg-00347-00100634-00100951": "presentations from past seminars", "56TROV0sLSg-00348-00100952-00101365": "everything from 2016-2017 and also from", "56TROV0sLSg-00349-00101366-00101551": "national seminars i didn't say that we", "56TROV0sLSg-00350-00101552-00101797": "also do national seminar so we did we", "56TROV0sLSg-00351-00101798-00102127": "had a national seminar two images for", "56TROV0sLSg-00352-00102128-00102520": "Lithuania and we also had this for for", "56TROV0sLSg-00353-00102521-00102949": "Sweden so and for Spain so and then", "56TROV0sLSg-00354-00102950-00103120": "you'll you can also find case studies", "56TROV0sLSg-00355-00103121-00103477": "there explain briefly real cases study", "56TROV0sLSg-00356-00103478-00103736": "of the removals you can also find", "56TROV0sLSg-00357-00103738-00104111": "scientific papers books magazines all", "56TROV0sLSg-00358-00104113-00104449": "links related with town removal and news", "56TROV0sLSg-00359-00104450-00104779": "we send a newsletter every two months", "56TROV0sLSg-00360-00104780-00105049": "about things going on in your", "56TROV0sLSg-00361-00105050-00105279": "dams being removed why who pays for it", "56TROV0sLSg-00362-00105280-00105604": "what people thinks is what type of a", "56TROV0sLSg-00363-00105605-00105958": "social program or project qualification", "56TROV0sLSg-00364-00105958-00106252": "they did so you can really contact us", "56TROV0sLSg-00365-00106253-00106399": "and if you want to receive this", "56TROV0sLSg-00366-00106400-00106765": "information we can we can include you we", "56TROV0sLSg-00367-00106766-00107095": "will be very happy to include you and we", "56TROV0sLSg-00368-00107096-00107332": "want to do a dam removal guidance for", "56TROV0sLSg-00369-00107333-00107644": "Europe and hopefully we can start", "56TROV0sLSg-00370-00107645-00107878": "working on that this fall and we will", "56TROV0sLSg-00371-00107879-00108265": "polish it in 2020 hopefully what we want", "56TROV0sLSg-00372-00108266-00108594": "is to have free access free downloadable", "56TROV0sLSg-00373-00108595-00108922": "guide where we want to explain real", "56TROV0sLSg-00374-00108923-00109288": "cases step by step how you do a dam", "56TROV0sLSg-00375-00109289-00109726": "removal lessons learned mistakes done so", "56TROV0sLSg-00376-00109727-00110167": "you try to avoid you know engineering", "56TROV0sLSg-00377-00110168-00110473": "mistakes it is difficult to find but", "56TROV0sLSg-00378-00110474-00110866": "sometimes it happens and and we want", "56TROV0sLSg-00379-00110867-00111163": "this to have to be available for free so", "56TROV0sLSg-00380-00111164-00111394": "hopefully we can we can have it ready in", "56TROV0sLSg-00381-00111395-00111724": "a year and a half to you and we started", "56TROV0sLSg-00382-00111725-00112122": "a crowdfunding campaign this summer so", "56TROV0sLSg-00383-00112123-00112567": "we we receive good cases a good sorry", "56TROV0sLSg-00384-00112568-00112983": "candidates for removing dams from", "56TROV0sLSg-00385-00112984-00113361": "countries from a marina Spain UK in this", "56TROV0sLSg-00386-00113363-00113638": "moment we have two in UK and one in", "56TROV0sLSg-00387-00113639-00113902": "Ukraine I think it is and we collect", "56TROV0sLSg-00388-00113903-00114210": "money to help fund these dam removals", "56TROV0sLSg-00389-00114211-00114501": "because not in all countries you have", "56TROV0sLSg-00390-00114502-00114904": "helps grants to help remove your dam and", "56TROV0sLSg-00391-00114905-00115243": "I will explain this in a minute I would", "56TROV0sLSg-00392-00115244-00115441": "like to start actually with with friends", "56TROV0sLSg-00393-00115442-00115702": "I don't know if the map will show six", "56TROV0sLSg-00394-00115703-00115816": "minutes oh my god", "56TROV0sLSg-00395-00115817-00116155": "okay so friends is the best is the best", "56TROV0sLSg-00396-00116156-00116431": "case they have an amazing inventory with", "56TROV0sLSg-00397-00116432-00116757": "the 95 thousand obstacles out of which", "56TROV0sLSg-00398-00116758-00117151": "70 thousands are Weir's and dams it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00399-00117152-00117520": "just incredible and the work they have", "56TROV0sLSg-00400-00117521-00117759": "been doing it's amazing they have a", "56TROV0sLSg-00401-00117760-00118177": "really complex organization but it works", "56TROV0sLSg-00402-00118178-00118355": "really well", "56TROV0sLSg-00403-00118356-00118571": "I would like to say that when I asked", "56TROV0sLSg-00404-00118572-00118748": "this question about how do you manage", "56TROV0sLSg-00405-00118749-00119006": "rivers who manages rivers they always", "56TROV0sLSg-00406-00119007-00119273": "answer me the same everybody I'm just", "56TROV0sLSg-00407-00119274-00119533": "like everybody until I understood haha", "56TROV0sLSg-00408-00119534-00119816": "there is an NGO partner from the removal", "56TROV0sLSg-00409-00119817-00120020": "Europe that made this scheme for me", "56TROV0sLSg-00410-00120021-00120155": "because I just didn't understand", "56TROV0sLSg-00411-00120156-00120416": "anything and I was like wow it's really", "56TROV0sLSg-00412-00120417-00120626": "everybody who managed River scene in", "56TROV0sLSg-00413-00120627-00120776": "France but it works really well and", "56TROV0sLSg-00414-00120777-00120977": "basically what you have to know is that", "56TROV0sLSg-00415-00120978-00121127": "they have a hundred and three", "56TROV0sLSg-00416-00121128-00121441": "departments which they are called", "56TROV0sLSg-00417-00121442-00121684": "departamento direction of territory", "56TROV0sLSg-00418-00121685-00122026": "right the partner mentor and that's", "56TROV0sLSg-00419-00122027-00122324": "those are who managed the river really", "56TROV0sLSg-00420-00122325-00122671": "Andy and then you have water agencies", "56TROV0sLSg-00421-00122672-00122933": "for regional level and then you have the", "56TROV0sLSg-00422-00122933-00123074": "national level which you have the", "56TROV0sLSg-00423-00123075-00123440": "Ministry of Environment and the FB F a", "56TROV0sLSg-00424-00123441-00123757": "FB the French agency of biodiversity", "56TROV0sLSg-00425-00123758-00124009": "which national level so when you want to", "56TROV0sLSg-00426-00124010-00124319": "remove a dam you must get in contact", "56TROV0sLSg-00427-00124320-00124577": "with the local authority d/dt the", "56TROV0sLSg-00428-00124578-00124766": "departmental direction of territory", "56TROV0sLSg-00429-00124767-00125057": "Didit e and why are they removing the", "56TROV0sLSg-00430-00125058-00125329": "ants in France first because of safety", "56TROV0sLSg-00431-00125330-00125723": "if you don't maintain a dam sooner or", "56TROV0sLSg-00432-00125724-00125935": "later is going to collapse they don't", "56TROV0sLSg-00433-00125936-00126136": "last forever second because of water", "56TROV0sLSg-00434-00126138-00126383": "quality and then third for that's that's", "56TROV0sLSg-00435-00126383-00126548": "what I've been told we took all my", "56TROV0sLSg-00436-00126549-00126735": "interviews and second for ecological", "56TROV0sLSg-00437-00126736-00126965": "continuity do they have legislation", "56TROV0sLSg-00438-00126966-00127378": "which support this yes the water law for", "56TROV0sLSg-00439-00127379-00127659": "2017 and the Water Framework Directive", "56TROV0sLSg-00440-00127660-00128008": "ad for authorization they asked for DDT", "56TROV0sLSg-00441-00128009-00128485": "and who pays for the removal well owners", "56TROV0sLSg-00442-00128486-00128696": "should pay for the removal but they have", "56TROV0sLSg-00443-00128697-00128983": "many grants they have many funds which", "56TROV0sLSg-00444-00128984-00129251": "support these removals", "56TROV0sLSg-00445-00129252-00129518": "they can even pay up to 80 percent", "56TROV0sLSg-00446-00129519-00129808": "sometimes of the removal so it's it's a", "56TROV0sLSg-00447-00129809-00129890": "really big help", "56TROV0sLSg-00448-00129891-00130181": "and usually we are talking about they", "56TROV0sLSg-00449-00130182-00130592": "are removing it small very years so", "56TROV0sLSg-00450-00130593-00130892": "usually they cost between 2000 and a few", "56TROV0sLSg-00451-00130893-00131207": "thousand euros but they are as I said", "56TROV0sLSg-00452-00131208-00131492": "before they are removing the moment", "56TROV0sLSg-00453-00131493-00131861": "biggest dam in Europe it's gonna cost 30", "56TROV0sLSg-00454-00131862-00132083": "million euros our two dams actually this", "56TROV0sLSg-00455-00132084-00132365": "is the biggest in the saloon River this", "56TROV0sLSg-00456-00132366-00132515": "scene I don't know how to pronounce that", "56TROV0sLSg-00457-00132516-00132925": "the scene dam 35 metres high and", "56TROV0sLSg-00458-00132926-00133178": "upstream right upstream these dams", "56TROV0sLSg-00459-00133179-00133628": "another dam LaRouche la roche that is 16", "56TROV0sLSg-00460-00133629-00133934": "meters they are demolishing these two", "56TROV0sLSg-00461-00133935-00134254": "dams between two they start in 2019", "56TROV0sLSg-00462-00134255-00134789": "until 2021 and we were there though the", "56TROV0sLSg-00463-00134790-00134939": "team from the foundation last month", "56TROV0sLSg-00464-00134940-00135191": "visiting ich is just amazing the works", "56TROV0sLSg-00465-00135192-00135299": "they are doing and it's really", "56TROV0sLSg-00466-00135300-00135476": "interesting we will explain all the case", "56TROV0sLSg-00467-00135477-00135829": "next year in May during the seminar and", "56TROV0sLSg-00468-00135830-00136073": "but they have removed much more as I", "56TROV0sLSg-00469-00136074-00136337": "said before they started more actively", "56TROV0sLSg-00470-00136338-00136802": "in the 90s this is a not only with new", "56TROV0sLSg-00471-00136803-00137014": "dams historical this is a great example", "56TROV0sLSg-00472-00137015-00137243": "historical dams in Spain will we say all", "56TROV0sLSg-00473-00137244-00137422": "how are you going to remove this", "56TROV0sLSg-00474-00137423-00137774": "historical is like well we have 20,000", "56TROV0sLSg-00475-00137775-00137969": "historical things you know we don't I", "56TROV0sLSg-00476-00137970-00138287": "mean it's fine how we keep some you know", "56TROV0sLSg-00477-00138288-00138389": "but it's like we are talking about", "56TROV0sLSg-00478-00138390-00138629": "thousands so sometimes it's it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00479-00138630-00138860": "necessary and actually this is an", "56TROV0sLSg-00480-00138861-00139043": "amazing example because they remove this", "56TROV0sLSg-00481-00139044-00139382": "down from the 1800s to recover salmon", "56TROV0sLSg-00482-00139383-00139634": "this was not even for safety I really", "56TROV0sLSg-00483-00139635-00139811": "admire these people because they did a", "56TROV0sLSg-00484-00139812-00139964": "really good job this is from our", "56TROV0sLSg-00485-00139965-00140360": "pictures from the demolition in 1996 I'm", "56TROV0sLSg-00486-00140361-00140597": "gonna ask you for a more know Spanish", "56TROV0sLSg-00487-00140598-00141200": "people talk a lot sorry no and then", "56TROV0sLSg-00488-00141201-00141356": "Sweden okay I switch the Sweden very", "56TROV0sLSg-00489-00141357-00141515": "quickly Sweden has a really good", "56TROV0sLSg-00490-00141516-00141911": "database too they have over 10,000", "56TROV0sLSg-00491-00141912-00142289": "obstacles in Sweden but they update", "56TROV0sLSg-00492-00142290-00142517": "their database like every month or two", "56TROV0sLSg-00493-00142518-00142760": "months so they keep finding barriers", "56TROV0sLSg-00494-00142761-00143108": "still it's not completely it's not", "56TROV0sLSg-00495-00143109-00143447": "complete the inventory and who manages", "56TROV0sLSg-00496-00143448-00143840": "the rivers in Sweden well most of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00497-00143841-00143978": "rivers are private I forgot to say this", "56TROV0sLSg-00498-00143979-00144227": "in France most of the river most of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00499-00144228-00144416": "rivers are private except the big rivers", "56TROV0sLSg-00500-00144417-00144593": "those are proudly but in Sweden all", "56TROV0sLSg-00501-00144594-00144830": "rivers are private so is the river owner", "56TROV0sLSg-00502-00144831-00144875": "who", "56TROV0sLSg-00503-00144876-00145315": "mr. rivers but if they want to do any", "56TROV0sLSg-00504-00145316-00145610": "project any activity which will impact", "56TROV0sLSg-00505-00145611-00145973": "the private or common interest then they", "56TROV0sLSg-00506-00145974-00146159": "have to ask for permission to the", "56TROV0sLSg-00507-00146160-00146327": "environmental court and the", "56TROV0sLSg-00508-00146328-00146612": "environmental court will say okay you", "56TROV0sLSg-00509-00146613-00146858": "can remove the dam you cannot and if", "56TROV0sLSg-00510-00146859-00147086": "it's not very complicated project then", "56TROV0sLSg-00511-00147087-00147638": "the regional boards which are called as", "56TROV0sLSg-00512-00147639-00147824": "the Swedish County Administrative boards", "56TROV0sLSg-00513-00147825-00148229": "they will follow the project so which", "56TROV0sLSg-00514-00148230-00148403": "are the drivers environmental", "56TROV0sLSg-00515-00148404-00148610": "restoration they basically do it to", "56TROV0sLSg-00516-00148611-00148957": "recover longitudinal Contini", "56TROV0sLSg-00517-00148958-00149339": "continuity and and to restore their", "56TROV0sLSg-00518-00149340-00149738": "salmon stocks and their fish stocks who", "56TROV0sLSg-00519-00149739-00149966": "pays for the removal in Sweden usually", "56TROV0sLSg-00520-00149967-00150164": "the owner usually is the owner but they", "56TROV0sLSg-00521-00150165-00150413": "have some funds not as may as not as", "56TROV0sLSg-00522-00150414-00150593": "much as friends but they have some funds", "56TROV0sLSg-00523-00150594-00151019": "and right now this year they created a", "56TROV0sLSg-00524-00151020-00151471": "budget that from money from hydrologic", "56TROV0sLSg-00525-00151472-00151862": "hydroelectric hydropower companies so", "56TROV0sLSg-00526-00151863-00152129": "the hydro electrical companies have", "56TROV0sLSg-00527-00152130-00152423": "created a budget so to restore rivers", "56TROV0sLSg-00528-00152424-00152630": "but Swedish people still complain", "56TROV0sLSg-00529-00152631-00152783": "because they say it's not enough money", "56TROV0sLSg-00530-00152784-00153068": "and it will run out in five years or", "56TROV0sLSg-00531-00153069-00153266": "whatever but it's it's a start I think", "56TROV0sLSg-00532-00153267-00153641": "it's a start this you can find all the", "56TROV0sLSg-00533-00153642-00153968": "removals in our map in our website too", "56TROV0sLSg-00534-00153969-00154511": "and last example ok Finland no feeling", "56TROV0sLSg-00535-00154512-00154787": "sorry Finland sorry film this was very", "56TROV0sLSg-00536-00154788-00155045": "interesting but UK super interesting UK", "56TROV0sLSg-00537-00155046-00155210": "is the most difficult place I think to", "56TROV0sLSg-00538-00155211-00155564": "remove them because they love their dams", "56TROV0sLSg-00539-00155565-00155768": "and Weir's you know when you talk about", "56TROV0sLSg-00540-00155769-00155993": "removing a we're there is like no my", "56TROV0sLSg-00541-00155994-00156284": "grandpa used to bathe here no my", "56TROV0sLSg-00542-00156285-00156574": "great-great grandpa no I'm there were", "56TROV0sLSg-00543-00156575-00157085": "whatever world is 200 years ago happen", "56TROV0sLSg-00544-00157086-00157265": "here in this bridge whatever so it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00545-00157266-00157448": "really complicated but they are managing", "56TROV0sLSg-00546-00157449-00157598": "they are managing and I would like to", "56TROV0sLSg-00547-00157599-00157903": "point out that Scotland it's the only", "56TROV0sLSg-00548-00157904-00158133": "place where you can find", "56TROV0sLSg-00549-00158134-00158442": "our fund Annual Fund they they have this", "56TROV0sLSg-00550-00158443-00158700": "money every year around 2 million euros", "56TROV0sLSg-00551-00158701-00159150": "to restore rivers the the Scotty is cut", "56TROV0sLSg-00552-00159151-00159342": "like enviromental Protection Agency it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00553-00159343-00159555": "it's really great and with this money", "56TROV0sLSg-00554-00159556-00159723": "they restore rivers and they demolish", "56TROV0sLSg-00555-00159724-00159882": "dams and they construct fish waste and", "56TROV0sLSg-00556-00159883-00160299": "Spain ok it's been please Spain in Spain", "56TROV0sLSg-00557-00160300-00160572": "out what I would like to say that the", "56TROV0sLSg-00558-00160573-00160863": "obstacles in Spain after one year", "56TROV0sLSg-00559-00160864-00161151": "collecting a database we came up with", "56TROV0sLSg-00560-00161152-00161517": "the 21,000 but I estimate this number", "56TROV0sLSg-00561-00161518-00161813": "it's so low I estimate there is around", "56TROV0sLSg-00562-00161814-00162137": "50,000 barriers in Spain that number is", "56TROV0sLSg-00563-00162138-00162555": "not reality and who owns every person in", "56TROV0sLSg-00564-00162556-00162837": "Spain they are public all of them are", "56TROV0sLSg-00565-00162838-00163113": "public who manages the river in Spain", "56TROV0sLSg-00566-00163114-00163461": "there is an authority pair River Basin", "56TROV0sLSg-00567-00163462-00163761": "which facilitates a lot of things I have", "56TROV0sLSg-00568-00163762-00163995": "heard here you have many organizations", "56TROV0sLSg-00569-00163996-00164262": "for the same river so it must be very", "56TROV0sLSg-00570-00164263-00164559": "complicated so there you have one unit", "56TROV0sLSg-00571-00164560-00164820": "for one River Basin why are they", "56TROV0sLSg-00572-00164821-00165084": "removing dams for what their Framework", "56TROV0sLSg-00573-00165085-00165135": "Directive", "56TROV0sLSg-00574-00165136-00165291": "but when you ask these to their", "56TROV0sLSg-00575-00165292-00165599": "authorities they say all about well", "56TROV0sLSg-00576-00165600-00165867": "before the Water Framework Directive we", "56TROV0sLSg-00577-00165868-00166128": "have a wonderful law and it's like yes", "56TROV0sLSg-00578-00166129-00166326": "we have a wonderful law I don't have", "56TROV0sLSg-00579-00166327-00166491": "time to tell you but we have a really", "56TROV0sLSg-00580-00166492-00166629": "wonderful and guess what", "56TROV0sLSg-00581-00166630-00166965": "nobody has followed the law so it's like", "56TROV0sLSg-00582-00166966-00167133": "whatever you know we have a wonderful", "56TROV0sLSg-00583-00167134-00167516": "lab but you know that our law says since", "56TROV0sLSg-00584-00167517-00167931": "1889 that we must build fish waste in", "56TROV0sLSg-00585-00167932-00168309": "our Weir's and it was mandatory in all", "56TROV0sLSg-00586-00168310-00168927": "rivers since the law of 1942 its mission", "56TROV0sLSg-00587-00168928-00169098": "impossible to find a fish way and then", "56TROV0sLSg-00588-00169099-00169539": "we're x' it's mandatory that once the", "56TROV0sLSg-00589-00169540-00169866": "owner of a dam has finished the use of a", "56TROV0sLSg-00590-00169867-00170088": "dam it has to leave the river exactly", "56TROV0sLSg-00591-00170089-00170343": "same as it was so it has to pay for the", "56TROV0sLSg-00592-00170344-00170571": "removal of the dam nobody has done this", "56TROV0sLSg-00593-00170572-00170820": "so it's funny when they there are 30", "56TROV0sLSg-00594-00170821-00170967": "says yes but we have a wonderful I guess", "56TROV0sLSg-00595-00170968-00171252": "but you have not followed a lot at all", "56TROV0sLSg-00596-00171253-00171603": "and we have demolished for now mm -", "56TROV0sLSg-00597-00171604-00171891": "hundred fifty dams I would like to say", "56TROV0sLSg-00598-00171892-00172086": "that not all the dams these two terms", "56TROV0sLSg-00599-00172087-00172314": "are a great case studies but most of", "56TROV0sLSg-00600-00172315-00172495": "them are little look this little down", "56TROV0sLSg-00601-00172496-00172728": "two meters high we were all there in the", "56TROV0sLSg-00602-00172729-00172974": "field trip during the first seminar down", "56TROV0sLSg-00603-00172975-00173199": "removal Europe seminar most of the of", "56TROV0sLSg-00604-00173200-00173359": "the dams we are demolitions are like", "56TROV0sLSg-00605-00173360-00173722": "that and usually is the authority who", "56TROV0sLSg-00606-00173723-00173862": "pays for the demolition although", "56TROV0sLSg-00607-00173863-00174129": "although in our law it says that it", "56TROV0sLSg-00608-00174130-00174360": "should be the owner and we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00609-00174361-00174559": "demolishing more and more at least the", "56TROV0sLSg-00610-00174560-00174958": "last one I finish this is because this", "56TROV0sLSg-00611-00174959-00175468": "dam is a 46 meter high 43 meters high in", "56TROV0sLSg-00612-00175469-00175926": "Nevada its own it by by sebastian city", "56TROV0sLSg-00613-00175927-00176076": "hall which is in the basque country but", "56TROV0sLSg-00614-00176077-00176337": "the dams in a matter and they decided", "56TROV0sLSg-00615-00176338-00176497": "that they want to demolish but there has", "56TROV0sLSg-00616-00176498-00176743": "no meaning there is no being used and", "56TROV0sLSg-00617-00176744-00176971": "they have safety problems but it's so", "56TROV0sLSg-00618-00176972-00177244": "expensive to remove a dam in the middle", "56TROV0sLSg-00619-00177245-00177457": "of a natural park the natural part is", "56TROV0sLSg-00620-00177458-00177781": "one of the best is a man of his pain is", "56TROV0sLSg-00621-00177782-00178227": "so expensive that they said ok we dig a", "56TROV0sLSg-00622-00178228-00178434": "hole we drill a hole and they are going", "56TROV0sLSg-00623-00178435-00178681": "to drill a hole so they because it's", "56TROV0sLSg-00624-00178682-00178897": "cheaper so there are many options", "56TROV0sLSg-00625-00178898-00178993": "solutions", "56TROV0sLSg-00626-00178994-00179184": "you know when removing a dams not always", "56TROV0sLSg-00627-00179185-00179521": "removing everything and please join us", "56TROV0sLSg-00628-00179522-00180339": "join us and join us thank you so much", "56TROV0sLSg-00629-00180340-00180928": "thank you thank you very much Paul for", "56TROV0sLSg-00630-00180929-00181165": "your enthusiastic speech sorry to catch", "56TROV0sLSg-00631-00181166-00181339": "you but we wanted to allow some time for", "56TROV0sLSg-00632-00181340-00181567": "questions you will speak again but just", "56TROV0sLSg-00633-00181568-00182110": "answering questions say qualcuno Kalki", "56TROV0sLSg-00634-00182111-00182341": "demanda / POW in effort Emperor record a", "56TROV0sLSg-00635-00182342-00182533": "conical k tempo fab DeMorgan in situ", "56TROV0sLSg-00636-00182534-00182836": "Nasseri the training on online in", "56TROV0sLSg-00637-00182837-00182950": "collaboration akan wetlands", "56TROV0sLSg-00638-00182951-00183235": "international propose Sula Ramona disbar", "56TROV0sLSg-00639-00183236-00183646": "Amenti turbot a hanky munal LeZion the", "56TROV0sLSg-00640-00183647-00183913": "shaman introduced own ad populum respeto", "56TROV0sLSg-00641-00183914-00184123": "Calaca photo jianchi address / DJ", "56TROV0sLSg-00642-00184124-00184381": "Fontana thematic a pupil technique", "56TROV0sLSg-00643-00184382-00184615": "administrative should purchase so the", "56TROV0sLSg-00644-00184616-00185053": "remote service bar Amenti qual kcal/kg", "56TROV0sLSg-00645-00185054-00185871": "Amanda", "56TROV0sLSg-00646-00185872-00186157": "ironic Valerie Maurel Kunis bar Amenti", "56TROV0sLSg-00647-00186158-00186328": "Oh quick", "56TROV0sLSg-00648-00186329-00186715": "red I mean this uno anivia juniper the", "56TROV0sLSg-00649-00186716-00186931": "bear so know yo okay they will not cause", "56TROV0sLSg-00650-00186932-00187360": "a table toady the last lie to be a valid", "56TROV0sLSg-00651-00187361-00187639": "eage configure delegates genetic", "56TROV0sLSg-00652-00187640-00187978": "available diva as mental a laurel they", "56TROV0sLSg-00653-00187979-00188125": "polka providing me interest at a fat", "56TROV0sLSg-00654-00188126-00189232": "request opera cindy sorry part o in this", "56TROV0sLSg-00655-00189233-00189442": "light it do it chu a la ragazza key", "56TROV0sLSg-00656-00189443-00189649": "believe as mantle are a decision a diga", "56TROV0sLSg-00657-00189650-00189856": "a little a porcupine circus Tata patha", "56TROV0sLSg-00658-00189857-00190090": "Cristo para el gobierno span you", "56TROV0sLSg-00659-00190091-00190321": "although that be a father soon a motive", "56TROV0sLSg-00660-00190322-00190591": "at see only okay Don Pedro procedures", "56TROV0sLSg-00661-00190592-00190774": "vegetal Martino spend energy soda pop", "56TROV0sLSg-00662-00190775-00191089": "Aruna diga que cosa fácil Bello Elora", "56TROV0sLSg-00663-00191090-00191383": "animus mantle adiga record o survey", "56TROV0sLSg-00664-00191384-00191596": "McCarley motive at Sione del per guest", "56TROV0sLSg-00665-00191597-00191887": "at Acosta Rita a cell Amontillado Jerry", "56TROV0sLSg-00666-00191888-00192198": "mango no me never dear uncle alternativa", "56TROV0sLSg-00667-00192199-00192505": "okay say be paid for the motive as you", "56TROV0sLSg-00668-00192506-00192664": "mature now and in my garage G", "56TROV0sLSg-00669-00192665-00192975": "materiality a windy day", "56TROV0sLSg-00670-00192976-00193374": "no Mia date okay so no alternative a", "56TROV0sLSg-00671-00193375-00193785": "perky would have river the Loch Awe", "56TROV0sLSg-00672-00193786-00194068": "comprise I think is skip part of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00673-00194069-00194233": "translation probably so the first part", "56TROV0sLSg-00674-00194234-00194359": "of the question was about that picture", "56TROV0sLSg-00675-00194360-00194617": "that we are using now this is from the", "56TROV0sLSg-00676-00194618-00194836": "Balkans la cual la figural equal", "56TROV0sLSg-00677-00194837-00195172": "L'Aquila photo Ella got a la campaña", "56TROV0sLSg-00678-00195173-00195517": "kappa le balcony cane corso di una una", "56TROV0sLSg-00679-00195518-00195760": "de aquella problem is true trolley come", "56TROV0sLSg-00680-00195761-00195958": "all the requests the coup is the", "56TROV0sLSg-00681-00195959-00196204": "Ferrando power the question is so in", "56TROV0sLSg-00682-00196205-00196705": "case the reasons for building the dam is", "56TROV0sLSg-00683-00196706-00197104": "still there still there still applies", "56TROV0sLSg-00684-00197105-00197416": "then what's the alternative to the use", "56TROV0sLSg-00685-00197417-00197712": "of these reasons I love this question um", "56TROV0sLSg-00686-00197713-00198559": "because we mix we mix ideas our goal in", "56TROV0sLSg-00687-00198560-00198903": "this moment is to remove useless dance", "56TROV0sLSg-00688-00198904-00199045": "we have", "56TROV0sLSg-00689-00199046-00199510": "so many useless dams thousands that", "56TROV0sLSg-00690-00199511-00199735": "first we will need a couple of centuries", "56TROV0sLSg-00691-00199736-00199960": "to resolve that problem usually stay", "56TROV0sLSg-00692-00199961-00200221": "they have no use that's the problem this", "56TROV0sLSg-00693-00200222-00200518": "they are garbage okay so that's the", "56TROV0sLSg-00694-00200519-00200920": "first thing then in two in two hundred", "56TROV0sLSg-00695-00200921-00201379": "years 100 years when we resolve that", "56TROV0sLSg-00696-00201380-00201775": "problem then we can we can say okay we", "56TROV0sLSg-00697-00201776-00201925": "want to remove this dam that is being", "56TROV0sLSg-00698-00201926-00202033": "used what's the alternative", "56TROV0sLSg-00699-00202034-00202414": "I'll tell you that for those terms that", "56TROV0sLSg-00700-00202415-00202642": "we would really like to remove and", "56TROV0sLSg-00701-00202643-00202849": "they're being used there is not option", "56TROV0sLSg-00702-00202850-00203062": "we won't remove dams that are being used", "56TROV0sLSg-00703-00203063-00203296": "okay that I mean we need we need the", "56TROV0sLSg-00704-00203297-00203817": "water but what we also claim is", "56TROV0sLSg-00705-00203818-00204082": "responsibility what we have been doing", "56TROV0sLSg-00706-00204083-00204376": "until now is oh I need a dam we put it", "56TROV0sLSg-00707-00204377-00204685": "here 20 years later oh I need another", "56TROV0sLSg-00708-00204686-00204955": "name I put it here no well we are trying", "56TROV0sLSg-00709-00204956-00205114": "to say is like okay we need a dam maybe", "56TROV0sLSg-00710-00205115-00205398": "now okay where where is the place where", "56TROV0sLSg-00711-00205400-00205603": "you will impact for less it's not the", "56TROV0sLSg-00712-00205604-00205810": "same put in a dam in one location of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00713-00205811-00206137": "river on a tributary or what so first", "56TROV0sLSg-00714-00206138-00206332": "responsibility and knowledge you know", "56TROV0sLSg-00715-00206333-00206503": "not putting it down whatever you want", "56TROV0sLSg-00716-00206504-00206725": "and that I know sometimes it's difficult", "56TROV0sLSg-00717-00206726-00207148": "because incredibly the last word when", "56TROV0sLSg-00718-00207148-00207498": "making I went the last making a decision", "56TROV0sLSg-00719-00207500-00207748": "it's a politician and a politician has", "56TROV0sLSg-00720-00207748-00208015": "no background in science and it changes", "56TROV0sLSg-00721-00208016-00208119": "every four years", "56TROV0sLSg-00722-00208121-00208242": "oh it's it's sometimes it's very", "56TROV0sLSg-00723-00208244-00208504": "complicated and for me it's something", "56TROV0sLSg-00724-00208505-00208729": "that I will never understand like when", "56TROV0sLSg-00725-00208730-00208912": "you go to the doctor and you are going", "56TROV0sLSg-00726-00208913-00209194": "to be operated by the heart the the", "56TROV0sLSg-00727-00209194-00209362": "method of the operation changes every", "56TROV0sLSg-00728-00209363-00209557": "four years because of the government you", "56TROV0sLSg-00729-00209558-00209911": "know it's like no because it follows", "56TROV0sLSg-00730-00209912-00210214": "medical law rules right saying with", "56TROV0sLSg-00731-00210215-00210403": "science so it's very frustrating and", "56TROV0sLSg-00732-00210404-00210715": "it's something that we must claim I", "56TROV0sLSg-00733-00210716-00210940": "excuse me all of us scientists", "56TROV0sLSg-00734-00210941-00211186": "practitioners in years please listen to", "56TROV0sLSg-00735-00211187-00211333": "us because you have no idea what you're", "56TROV0sLSg-00736-00211334-00211378": "talking about", "56TROV0sLSg-00737-00211379-00211596": "okay and I think we need to be very", "56TROV0sLSg-00738-00211598-00211783": "serious about that and to finish your", "56TROV0sLSg-00739-00211784-00212236": "question in the future I think we will", "56TROV0sLSg-00740-00212237-00212446": "need dams for what we are so", "56TROV0sLSg-00741-00212446-00212896": "for drinking water irrigation but in", "56TROV0sLSg-00742-00212896-00213171": "certain places I think is very important", "56TROV0sLSg-00743-00213173-00213625": "to when there is an option to to store", "56TROV0sLSg-00744-00213626-00213823": "the water outside of the river I mean", "56TROV0sLSg-00745-00213823-00213991": "the river are the veins of our", "56TROV0sLSg-00746-00213992-00214248": "ecosystems so we are putting all these", "56TROV0sLSg-00747-00214250-00214513": "blocks in our veins and then a hundred", "56TROV0sLSg-00748-00214514-00214681": "years later you get the rest of the", "56TROV0sLSg-00749-00214682-00214981": "results you know so but that will come", "56TROV0sLSg-00750-00214982-00215200": "later now we have the first problem", "56TROV0sLSg-00751-00215201-00215508": "which is huge and we will take centuries", "56TROV0sLSg-00752-00215509-00215803": "super meta medium bravissimo comment o", "56TROV0sLSg-00753-00215804-00216067": "que la mayor parte de pais Inquisition", "56TROV0sLSg-00754-00216067-00216328": "or remove endows digas varam NTC parte", "56TROV0sLSg-00755-00216329-00216523": "de question op le palace cement a in", "56TROV0sLSg-00756-00216523-00216700": "util oculi chrono risky Oh Alaura", "56TROV0sLSg-00757-00216701-00216979": "Natalia ancora credo Knossos a Kuno", "56TROV0sLSg-00758-00216980-00217189": "McGary pure Jorn a toady I'm Emma well", "56TROV0sLSg-00759-00217190-00217429": "Capri musty Mophie Choza Ferrando salut", "56TROV0sLSg-00760-00217430-00217783": "DD gay parla d do a chain to the chin to", "56TROV0sLSg-00761-00217784-00217992": "chin Quantic a brave a potrebbero creare", "56TROV0sLSg-00762-00217994-00218326": "suri problema de risky Oh a structural", "56TROV0sLSg-00763-00218327-00218596": "Montano de problema en on a date okay /", "56TROV0sLSg-00764-00218596-00218817": "to take West a economic Ament AC a", "56TROV0sLSg-00765-00218819-00219277": "sustainable re construcciones poison", "56TROV0sLSg-00766-00219278-00219507": "questa through critic we partying", "56TROV0sLSg-00767-00219508-00219669": "through country were disbarment if you", "56TROV0sLSg-00768-00219671-00219727": "piccoli", "56TROV0sLSg-00769-00219728-00220044": "at the same Peola la paz cimento do you", "56TROV0sLSg-00770-00220046-00220223": "know brilli or a transformational debris", "56TROV0sLSg-00771-00220225-00220569": "ramp ever intervene to the coasting mode", "56TROV0sLSg-00772-00220571-00220719": "to limit Attica very", "56TROV0sLSg-00773-00220721-00220939": "una focaccia no table put is a transport", "56TROV0sLSg-00774-00220940-00221152": "us all the countries Adela fauna yeah I", "56TROV0sLSg-00775-00221153-00221508": "know it's no misako diva Holly Cambria", "56TROV0sLSg-00776-00221509-00221752": "goes through eating and in Quechan Akron", "56TROV0sLSg-00777-00221753-00222019": "Ozzy Costa benefic Randhawa non-core", "56TROV0sLSg-00778-00222019-00222250": "amino de modo de res so unique so multi", "56TROV0sLSg-00779-00222251-00222534": "see most Patsy Prima de tocar el caso", "56TROV0sLSg-00780-00222535-00222955": "nope you conflict - Ali paparazzo no el", "56TROV0sLSg-00781-00222956-00223153": "al in Tarot the quest along Yeley in", "56TROV0sLSg-00782-00223154-00223465": "Cancun e cos e track we quest oh we so", "56TROV0sLSg-00783-00223466-00223692": "quick a fad over there a in cuesta de", "56TROV0sLSg-00784-00223694-00223884": "Guevara pututo s Ramon Tenuta a Feeny", "56TROV0sLSg-00785-00223885-00224065": "concession Abba problema structure Ali", "56TROV0sLSg-00786-00224066-00224344": "said she's okay it benefit show a", "56TROV0sLSg-00787-00224344-00224598": "collage UN questo caso very pristine", "56TROV0sLSg-00788-00224600-00224742": "rockin tonight appraisal Mona", "56TROV0sLSg-00789-00224744-00225130": "Arif importante del beneficio in termini", "56TROV0sLSg-00790-00225131-00225214": "Depot Guccione", "56TROV0sLSg-00791-00225215-00225492": "yer electrical in Sato Fatone Queen go /", "56TROV0sLSg-00792-00225492-00225678": "so esidisi dude I know Reno Varela", "56TROV0sLSg-00793-00225679-00225951": "concezione Pro Kiara meant a party amo", "56TROV0sLSg-00794-00225952-00226353": "El Nino de la cual el facil inna ultra", "56TROV0sLSg-00795-00226354-00227030": "demand a Christian for Yoli inter Sultan", "56TROV0sLSg-00796-00227031-00228201": "mo Philippa a prophet o / que siente hoy", "56TROV0sLSg-00797-00228202-00228419": "para para que service pro DeLorean", "56TROV0sLSg-00798-00228421-00229166": "interpretive Gujarati I partook in DD", "56TROV0sLSg-00799-00229167-00229401": "transformation at the Delhi brillian", "56TROV0sLSg-00800-00229402-00229742": "Niram Purdon visto al Mamoon", "56TROV0sLSg-00801-00229744-00229989": "interventive DaCosta tip okay Amelia su", "56TROV0sLSg-00802-00229990-00230091": "la maddalena", "56TROV0sLSg-00803-00230092-00230696": "contour ent difficult dimension for a", "56TROV0sLSg-00804-00230698-00231194": "caterer for Ikeda original Rho K in a", "56TROV0sLSg-00805-00231196-00231367": "lacunae contest", "56TROV0sLSg-00806-00231369-00231733": "Kumiko little rent equality Madalena", "56TROV0sLSg-00807-00231734-00232167": "quest OTP interventive que como que", "56TROV0sLSg-00808-00232167-00232346": "viene return ooh toe in lina", "56TROV0sLSg-00809-00232346-00232679": "trenton kali linux widow de la razón por", "56TROV0sLSg-00810-00232680-00232904": "portable generator pew problema que", "56TROV0sLSg-00811-00232905-00233376": "resolver / k in questa cazzo la book a", "56TROV0sLSg-00812-00233377-00233819": "valid ellebra Lea Lunik único contest in", "56TROV0sLSg-00813-00233821-00233994": "cooper quality kilo meter is Daniel", "56TROV0sLSg-00814-00233994-00234267": "Padilla aqua in Stata so probability of", "56TROV0sLSg-00815-00234267-00234513": "found a la cumbre taco attica cuando", "56TROV0sLSg-00816-00234514-00234806": "ternal aqua recolonize amount eval Kirk", "56TROV0sLSg-00817-00234807-00234944": "want opus are you here", "56TROV0sLSg-00818-00234946-00235310": "quindi a transformer questa Bucharest an", "56TROV0sLSg-00819-00235311-00235800": "aqua in una Rapa Masucci claw PG Bui", "56TROV0sLSg-00820-00235801-00236028": "some consider Rankin intervene to the", "56TROV0sLSg-00821-00236029-00236282": "recodification effluvia le yo creo que", "56TROV0sLSg-00822-00236283-00236592": "Jie some asado su College during a", "56TROV0sLSg-00823-00236592-00236867": "foreigner if ratio / calamity series", "56TROV0sLSg-00824-00236869-00237252": "Canada Distortion aku visto que c'est", "56TROV0sLSg-00825-00237253-00237351": "par lotto", "56TROV0sLSg-00826-00237352-00237567": "Colville occasion a personal are si", "56TROV0sLSg-00827-00237567-00237731": "grazie Kristen burgers", "56TROV0sLSg-00828-00237732-00238019": "seguramente service animal importante G", "56TROV0sLSg-00829-00238021-00238331": "in general a a Tribune a charity polo", "56TROV0sLSg-00830-00238332-00238602": "Jerry interventive a priori ERT", "56TROV0sLSg-00831-00238603-00238810": "beneficial 80 per second Tata", "56TROV0sLSg-00832-00238811-00239116": "no funciona it was importante and for", "56TROV0sLSg-00833-00239117-00239227": "you power did you understand the", "56TROV0sLSg-00834-00239228-00239614": "questions oh the factors that put a ramp", "56TROV0sLSg-00835-00239615-00239815": "and then it cost more problems because", "56TROV0sLSg-00836-00239816-00240178": "of the cattle who was the last say", "56TROV0sLSg-00837-00240179-00240550": "remaining habitat for drought season so", "56TROV0sLSg-00838-00240551-00240781": "cost benefits also in ecological terms", "56TROV0sLSg-00839-00240782-00241044": "as I said in the very beginning in", "56TROV0sLSg-00840-00241046-00241264": "Europe it won't be possible to remove", "56TROV0sLSg-00841-00241265-00241558": "all dams even if we had all the money to", "56TROV0sLSg-00842-00241559-00241848": "do it technically it's not possible look", "56TROV0sLSg-00843-00241850-00242094": "that case there are many cases so it", "56TROV0sLSg-00844-00242096-00242319": "won't be possible and and there is a", "56TROV0sLSg-00845-00242321-00242563": "fish ramp well I don't know that case", "56TROV0sLSg-00846-00242564-00242800": "each case I'm a fishery engineer and", "56TROV0sLSg-00847-00242801-00242998": "definitely it's a delicate issue each", "56TROV0sLSg-00848-00242998-00243280": "case is a different case maybe in that", "56TROV0sLSg-00849-00243281-00243385": "case there should have been a", "56TROV0sLSg-00850-00243386-00243694": "naturalised channel a bypass I don't", "56TROV0sLSg-00851-00243694-00243889": "know that case but I understand your", "56TROV0sLSg-00852-00243890-00244138": "position that's why I think we must", "56TROV0sLSg-00853-00244139-00244423": "start with the useless dams that they", "56TROV0sLSg-00854-00244423-00244714": "don't have any benefit ok and we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00855-00244715-00244917": "talking about thousands and then after", "56TROV0sLSg-00856-00244919-00245152": "that we will talk and we'll see other", "56TROV0sLSg-00857-00245153-00245332": "case is more complicated I mean we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00858-00245333-00245523": "talking about really we have over a", "56TROV0sLSg-00859-00245525-00245707": "million barriers in Europe we are", "56TROV0sLSg-00860-00245708-00245857": "talking about thousands in Spain I", "56TROV0sLSg-00861-00245858-00246259": "really think there are over ten ten to", "56TROV0sLSg-00862-00246260-00246585": "fifteen thousand very years with no use", "56TROV0sLSg-00863-00246586-00246991": "we won't even finish in two centuries so", "56TROV0sLSg-00864-00246992-00247219": "I think people gets really freaked out", "56TROV0sLSg-00865-00247219-00247357": "oh we need water is like yeah but I'm", "56TROV0sLSg-00866-00247358-00247498": "not saying we are going to demolish all", "56TROV0sLSg-00867-00247498-00247842": "dams I'm saying to be responsible and", "56TROV0sLSg-00868-00247844-00248073": "not leave things in the river that are", "56TROV0sLSg-00869-00248075-00248257": "not being used and they have safety", "56TROV0sLSg-00870-00248258-00248523": "problems"}}, {"audio_id": "57dynhVYwRk", "text": {"57dynhVYwRk-00000-00000198-00002342": "[Music]", "57dynhVYwRk-00001-00002343-00002591": "welcome to the british library and to", "57dynhVYwRk-00002-00002592-00002863": "the return of the jalak prize yes the", "57dynhVYwRk-00003-00002864-00003206": "jalac is back we're so delighted to host", "57dynhVYwRk-00004-00003207-00003351": "this very special prize here in the", "57dynhVYwRk-00005-00003352-00003559": "british library for the second year", "57dynhVYwRk-00006-00003560-00003847": "running and it's my great excitement to", "57dynhVYwRk-00007-00003847-00004054": "hand over to the one and only", "57dynhVYwRk-00008-00004055-00004303": "your host for tonight the one and only", "57dynhVYwRk-00009-00004304-00004543": "professor sunny singh a big applause", "57dynhVYwRk-00010-00004544-00004735": "everybody", "57dynhVYwRk-00011-00004736-00005686": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-00012-00005687-00005999": "good evening and welcome to everyone who", "57dynhVYwRk-00013-00006000-00006183": "has logged in from home to the chalk", "57dynhVYwRk-00014-00006184-00006399": "prize 2022", "57dynhVYwRk-00015-00006400-00006598": "i am sunny sink one of the founders of", "57dynhVYwRk-00016-00006600-00006878": "the prize and its current director", "57dynhVYwRk-00017-00006879-00007070": "we have a rather wonderful program lined", "57dynhVYwRk-00018-00007072-00007391": "up for you you all at home", "57dynhVYwRk-00019-00007392-00007551": "featuring greetings from the brilliant", "57dynhVYwRk-00020-00007552-00007751": "writers shortlisted for the jalak prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00021-00007752-00007951": "and the chalak children's and adults", "57dynhVYwRk-00022-00007952-00008127": "young adult prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00023-00008128-00008391": "we also have a lovely celebration of our", "57dynhVYwRk-00024-00008392-00008823": "12 bookshop champions which are", "57dynhVYwRk-00025-00008824-00009031": "independent bookshops across the country", "57dynhVYwRk-00026-00009032-00009214": "who have each championed a book from our", "57dynhVYwRk-00027-00009215-00009327": "short lists", "57dynhVYwRk-00028-00009328-00009551": "and of course our short and long list in", "57dynhVYwRk-00029-00009552-00009687": "general", "57dynhVYwRk-00030-00009688-00009799": "take note", "57dynhVYwRk-00031-00009800-00010095": "cheer them and tomorrow and beyond pop", "57dynhVYwRk-00032-00010096-00010167": "in", "57dynhVYwRk-00033-00010168-00010319": "and buy a book", "57dynhVYwRk-00034-00010320-00010606": "from our short lists or any book at all", "57dynhVYwRk-00035-00010607-00010838": "from one of our bookshop champions or", "57dynhVYwRk-00036-00010839-00011142": "indeed your local independent", "57dynhVYwRk-00037-00011143-00011287": "a little bit of housekeeping before we", "57dynhVYwRk-00038-00011288-00011438": "kick off the readings", "57dynhVYwRk-00039-00011439-00011678": "the online version of this event will be", "57dynhVYwRk-00040-00011679-00011942": "live captioned so please enable yours if", "57dynhVYwRk-00041-00011943-00012055": "you need it", "57dynhVYwRk-00042-00012056-00012238": "the viewing links will be available for", "57dynhVYwRk-00043-00012239-00012646": "48 hours after the event for catch-up", "57dynhVYwRk-00044-00012647-00012822": "following the readings and celebration", "57dynhVYwRk-00045-00012823-00013086": "of the bookshop champions we will return", "57dynhVYwRk-00046-00013087-00013343": "here to this room to celebrate great", "57dynhVYwRk-00047-00013344-00013575": "contemporary british writing", "57dynhVYwRk-00048-00013576-00013822": "we will be joined by our judges", "57dynhVYwRk-00049-00013823-00014038": "for the jalac prize that is mary jane", "57dynhVYwRk-00050-00014040-00014230": "chan shumei salehman and stephen", "57dynhVYwRk-00051-00014231-00014511": "thompson and judges of the children's", "57dynhVYwRk-00052-00014512-00014783": "and young adult prize sophia ahmed knee", "57dynhVYwRk-00053-00014784-00015063": "ayakway parks and patrice lawrence", "57dynhVYwRk-00054-00015063-00015286": "in addition to the announcement of the", "57dynhVYwRk-00055-00015287-00015527": "winners of the r2 awards", "57dynhVYwRk-00056-00015528-00015791": "the two artists and residents elijah", "57dynhVYwRk-00057-00015791-00016103": "varto and rick and parrik will reveal", "57dynhVYwRk-00058-00016104-00016271": "the unique works of art they have", "57dynhVYwRk-00059-00016272-00016558": "created specially as trophies for our", "57dynhVYwRk-00060-00016559-00016783": "2022 winners", "57dynhVYwRk-00061-00016784-00016958": "further information jealous pride", "57dynhVYwRk-00062-00016959-00017086": "celebrations", "57dynhVYwRk-00063-00017087-00017319": "including book giveaways video clips of", "57dynhVYwRk-00064-00017320-00017622": "shortlisted writers and much more can be", "57dynhVYwRk-00065-00017623-00017855": "found on our website", "57dynhVYwRk-00066-00017856-00018094": "www.jelloutprize.com", "57dynhVYwRk-00067-00018095-00018335": "and on social media you can use chalk", "57dynhVYwRk-00068-00018336-00018735": "price 22 or jello prize hashtags", "57dynhVYwRk-00069-00018736-00019014": "to look us up or indeed to add your own", "57dynhVYwRk-00070-00019015-00019247": "so now", "57dynhVYwRk-00071-00019248-00019519": "pour yourself your favorite beverage sit", "57dynhVYwRk-00072-00019520-00019607": "back", "57dynhVYwRk-00073-00019608-00019894": "and enjoy the show", "57dynhVYwRk-00074-00019895-00021350": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-00075-00021351-00021583": "hi i'm arifa akbar i'm going to read a", "57dynhVYwRk-00076-00021584-00021886": "few pages of my memoir consumed a sister", "57dynhVYwRk-00077-00021887-00022158": "story", "57dynhVYwRk-00078-00022159-00022367": "three summers ago my neighbors told that", "57dynhVYwRk-00079-00022368-00022535": "her ovarian cancer had reached the", "57dynhVYwRk-00080-00022536-00022703": "terminal stage", "57dynhVYwRk-00081-00022704-00022886": "rosen hibbins emailed the occupants of", "57dynhVYwRk-00082-00022887-00023078": "the building about at matrifactly as was", "57dynhVYwRk-00083-00023079-00023294": "her way but when i went downstairs to", "57dynhVYwRk-00084-00023295-00023494": "see her she seemed instantly changed by", "57dynhVYwRk-00085-00023495-00023630": "the news", "57dynhVYwRk-00086-00023631-00023822": "she was in her late 60s and had always", "57dynhVYwRk-00087-00023823-00024039": "been an indomitable woman", "57dynhVYwRk-00088-00024040-00024222": "as strong and sturdy as the boulders she", "57dynhVYwRk-00089-00024223-00024399": "brought home from her stone carving", "57dynhVYwRk-00090-00024400-00024591": "workshops which had become a passion", "57dynhVYwRk-00091-00024592-00024863": "since retirement", "57dynhVYwRk-00092-00024864-00024999": "in the days that followed she seemed", "57dynhVYwRk-00093-00025000-00025358": "made of air white head and fragile her", "57dynhVYwRk-00094-00025359-00025583": "eyes watery bright her voice catching on", "57dynhVYwRk-00095-00025584-00025822": "itself in croaks and quivers", "57dynhVYwRk-00096-00025823-00025999": "a couple of months before", "57dynhVYwRk-00097-00026000-00026279": "roslyn's diagnosis my sister fazia had", "57dynhVYwRk-00098-00026280-00026495": "died suddenly leaving me suspended", "57dynhVYwRk-00099-00026495-00026743": "between shock and disbelief", "57dynhVYwRk-00100-00026744-00026911": "she'd been shuttling back and forth to", "57dynhVYwRk-00101-00026912-00027151": "acute hospital wards in north london", "57dynhVYwRk-00102-00027152-00027311": "with an illness her doctors couldn't", "57dynhVYwRk-00103-00027312-00027431": "diagnose", "57dynhVYwRk-00104-00027432-00027599": "but we didn't believe fazi was going to", "57dynhVYwRk-00105-00027600-00027735": "die and she couldn't have believed it", "57dynhVYwRk-00106-00027736-00027839": "either", "57dynhVYwRk-00107-00027839-00028007": "she'd been worrying about her cats and", "57dynhVYwRk-00108-00028008-00028207": "college assignments sending texts and", "57dynhVYwRk-00109-00028208-00028414": "paying bills from a hospital bed she", "57dynhVYwRk-00110-00028416-00028574": "hadn't been preparing for death like", "57dynhVYwRk-00111-00028575-00028790": "roslyn", "57dynhVYwRk-00112-00028791-00029070": "i was left reeling so i had to muster", "57dynhVYwRk-00113-00029072-00029295": "all my courage when roslyn called from a", "57dynhVYwRk-00114-00029295-00029639": "hospice and said she'd like to see me i", "57dynhVYwRk-00115-00029639-00029839": "followed my zed around the twisting back", "57dynhVYwRk-00116-00029839-00030062": "streets of belsize park to find the", "57dynhVYwRk-00117-00030063-00030199": "hospice", "57dynhVYwRk-00118-00030200-00030367": "it was set back from the road and", "57dynhVYwRk-00119-00030368-00030702": "obscured by two trees as if in hiding", "57dynhVYwRk-00120-00030703-00030911": "i'd grown up nearby in primrose hill", "57dynhVYwRk-00121-00030912-00031374": "without ever realizing it was there", "57dynhVYwRk-00122-00031375-00031646": "inside wasn't asked if farsi had been", "57dynhVYwRk-00123-00031647-00031870": "alone when she died", "57dynhVYwRk-00124-00031872-00032079": "it was a thing she was most afraid of", "57dynhVYwRk-00125-00032080-00032255": "she said and it made me think about how", "57dynhVYwRk-00126-00032256-00032439": "my sister might have felt with no one", "57dynhVYwRk-00127-00032439-00032679": "she knew around her in the early hours", "57dynhVYwRk-00128-00032680-00032911": "of the june morning when blood had", "57dynhVYwRk-00129-00032912-00033087": "started to pour into her brain and", "57dynhVYwRk-00130-00033088-00033431": "collect into a fatal hemorrhage", "57dynhVYwRk-00131-00033432-00033623": "roslin must have sensed my distress", "57dynhVYwRk-00132-00033624-00033862": "because she tried to comfort me", "57dynhVYwRk-00133-00033863-00034087": "don't hold on too tightly", "57dynhVYwRk-00134-00034088-00035079": "she said she'll come back to you", "57dynhVYwRk-00135-00035080-00035279": "i remember", "57dynhVYwRk-00136-00035280-00035502": "after school a park", "57dynhVYwRk-00137-00035503-00035799": "pigeons and a bench with metal scrolled", "57dynhVYwRk-00138-00035800-00035902": "arms", "57dynhVYwRk-00139-00035903-00036118": "i'm wearing a skirt", "57dynhVYwRk-00140-00036119-00036415": "the bench spat sticking into my legs", "57dynhVYwRk-00141-00036416-00036695": "so instead i'm sitting on my hands", "57dynhVYwRk-00142-00036696-00036990": "waiting for rania who's high on top of", "57dynhVYwRk-00143-00036991-00037159": "the new roundabout", "57dynhVYwRk-00144-00037160-00037318": "a witch's hat", "57dynhVYwRk-00145-00037319-00037502": "on the highest rung", "57dynhVYwRk-00146-00037503-00037735": "her hair flung back", "57dynhVYwRk-00147-00037736-00037959": "i remember a dog i was scared of and", "57dynhVYwRk-00148-00037960-00038215": "wanted to run and miss my sister", "57dynhVYwRk-00149-00038216-00038567": "shouting don't run ruby don't run from", "57dynhVYwRk-00150-00038568-00038783": "the top of her perch", "57dynhVYwRk-00151-00038784-00038943": "but i took flight", "57dynhVYwRk-00152-00038944-00039135": "i ran anyway", "57dynhVYwRk-00153-00039136-00039446": "my school satchel bumping at my hip", "57dynhVYwRk-00154-00039447-00039774": "thwack thwack on the jointed bone", "57dynhVYwRk-00155-00039775-00040030": "and the dog chasing and barking at my", "57dynhVYwRk-00156-00040031-00040335": "side and rania jumping off and landing", "57dynhVYwRk-00157-00040336-00040599": "on her knee the patella shattering like", "57dynhVYwRk-00158-00040600-00040911": "a walnut the sound of her scream", "57dynhVYwRk-00159-00040912-00041343": "a high pure scream of distilled pain", "57dynhVYwRk-00160-00041344-00041543": "and the yellow dog's owner was at her", "57dynhVYwRk-00161-00041544-00041887": "side the dog captured and tied to a", "57dynhVYwRk-00162-00041888-00041999": "stump", "57dynhVYwRk-00163-00042000-00042311": "and rania crying grabbing me by the", "57dynhVYwRk-00164-00042312-00042446": "wrist", "57dynhVYwRk-00165-00042447-00042671": "i told you not to run ruby", "57dynhVYwRk-00166-00042672-00042846": "you silly girl", "57dynhVYwRk-00167-00042847-00043127": "you stupid dumb girl ruby", "57dynhVYwRk-00168-00043128-00043455": "the wet feeling on the back of my thighs", "57dynhVYwRk-00169-00043456-00043695": "i'd been bitten by the alsatian", "57dynhVYwRk-00170-00043696-00043974": "but had i been bitten or had i passed", "57dynhVYwRk-00171-00043975-00044102": "water", "57dynhVYwRk-00172-00044103-00044246": "where was mum", "57dynhVYwRk-00173-00044247-00044407": "i didn't know", "57dynhVYwRk-00174-00044408-00044599": "i remember my mother earlier in a blue", "57dynhVYwRk-00175-00044600-00044807": "tunic with white flowers", "57dynhVYwRk-00176-00044808-00045030": "standing under a bright golden-haired", "57dynhVYwRk-00177-00045031-00045127": "tree", "57dynhVYwRk-00178-00045128-00045415": "which i now know to be mimosa", "57dynhVYwRk-00179-00045416-00045623": "i thought i saw her flickering like a", "57dynhVYwRk-00180-00045624-00045871": "candle under the mimosa for a few", "57dynhVYwRk-00181-00045872-00045999": "seconds", "57dynhVYwRk-00182-00046000-00046190": "she was there i thought", "57dynhVYwRk-00183-00046191-00046335": "and then", "57dynhVYwRk-00184-00046336-00047590": "she was gone", "57dynhVYwRk-00185-00047591-00047879": "hello my name is anthony vanni kapeldeo", "57dynhVYwRk-00186-00047880-00048095": "and i'm delighted to be reading", "57dynhVYwRk-00187-00048096-00048343": "alongside the other writers on the chalk", "57dynhVYwRk-00188-00048344-00048599": "prize longlist 2022", "57dynhVYwRk-00189-00048600-00048735": "i'll be reading to you from my", "57dynhVYwRk-00190-00048736-00048846": "collection", "57dynhVYwRk-00191-00048847-00049023": "like a tree walking", "57dynhVYwRk-00192-00049024-00049262": "published by coconut it's a very pink", "57dynhVYwRk-00193-00049263-00049455": "book", "57dynhVYwRk-00194-00049456-00049615": "and i'm reading to you from charles", "57dynhVYwRk-00195-00049616-00049767": "cosley's study", "57dynhVYwRk-00196-00049768-00050046": "in cyprus well in launch in cornwall", "57dynhVYwRk-00197-00050047-00050367": "which kindly has been lent to me", "57dynhVYwRk-00198-00050368-00050495": "reader", "57dynhVYwRk-00199-00050496-00050846": "i turned men into deer", "57dynhVYwRk-00200-00050847-00051071": "told me about a childhood", "57dynhVYwRk-00201-00051072-00051311": "running free through a rainforest those", "57dynhVYwRk-00202-00051312-00051519": "were the best days", "57dynhVYwRk-00203-00051520-00051719": "on all those paths", "57dynhVYwRk-00204-00051720-00051882": "he never saw a", "57dynhVYwRk-00205-00051883-00052199": "snake told him about a childhood within", "57dynhVYwRk-00206-00052200-00052311": "walls", "57dynhVYwRk-00207-00052312-00052503": "snake in the post box", "57dynhVYwRk-00208-00052504-00052775": "snake let unearthed wriggling", "57dynhVYwRk-00209-00052776-00053038": "never seen snake of the drain", "57dynhVYwRk-00210-00053039-00053326": "moving heavy stones we put to block its", "57dynhVYwRk-00211-00053327-00053519": "resting place", "57dynhVYwRk-00212-00053520-00053854": "yard had the displaced inhabitants of", "57dynhVYwRk-00213-00053855-00054054": "forest", "57dynhVYwRk-00214-00054055-00054142": "he", "57dynhVYwRk-00215-00054144-00054326": "would have been running through with his", "57dynhVYwRk-00216-00054327-00054607": "gun and smoke bright eyes", "57dynhVYwRk-00217-00054608-00054926": "decades and decades", "57dynhVYwRk-00218-00054927-00055159": "what you see what you do what you say", "57dynhVYwRk-00219-00055160-00055319": "what you know what you believe what you", "57dynhVYwRk-00220-00055320-00055582": "have been storying yourself in storage", "57dynhVYwRk-00221-00055583-00055894": "your storied self", "57dynhVYwRk-00222-00055895-00056199": "decades and decades", "57dynhVYwRk-00223-00056200-00056423": "is dangerous", "57dynhVYwRk-00224-00056424-00056703": "forest becomes forensics", "57dynhVYwRk-00225-00056704-00057063": "the frond is dissected oh it waves over", "57dynhVYwRk-00226-00057064-00057279": "all those paths", "57dynhVYwRk-00227-00057279-00057519": "equivocations", "57dynhVYwRk-00228-00057520-00057711": "you see you do", "57dynhVYwRk-00229-00057712-00057807": "to me", "57dynhVYwRk-00230-00057808-00058119": "as if i am a woman", "57dynhVYwRk-00231-00058120-00058303": "come on", "57dynhVYwRk-00232-00058304-00058423": "he says", "57dynhVYwRk-00233-00058424-00058550": "to control", "57dynhVYwRk-00234-00058551-00058791": "coming on he knows", "57dynhVYwRk-00235-00058791-00058926": "control", "57dynhVYwRk-00236-00058927-00059063": "you believe", "57dynhVYwRk-00237-00059064-00059223": "the narrative", "57dynhVYwRk-00238-00059224-00059607": "what thorns mistaken for companions", "57dynhVYwRk-00239-00059608-00059766": "what canopy", "57dynhVYwRk-00240-00059767-00060023": "what shutting out", "57dynhVYwRk-00241-00060024-00060294": "he discs his eyes", "57dynhVYwRk-00242-00060295-00061279": "his hooves hurt", "57dynhVYwRk-00243-00061279-00061350": "hi", "57dynhVYwRk-00244-00061351-00061487": "um", "57dynhVYwRk-00245-00061488-00061775": "my name is desertin", "57dynhVYwRk-00246-00061776-00062047": "and so i'm going to read a small part", "57dynhVYwRk-00247-00062048-00062126": "from", "57dynhVYwRk-00248-00062127-00062663": "my book keeping keeping the house today", "57dynhVYwRk-00249-00062664-00063023": "this one", "57dynhVYwRk-00250-00063024-00063279": "so the section i'm reading is one of the", "57dynhVYwRk-00251-00063279-00063430": "last times", "57dynhVYwRk-00252-00063432-00063703": "that we see a character called gemina", "57dynhVYwRk-00253-00063704-00063830": "for a little while she's quite an", "57dynhVYwRk-00254-00063832-00064006": "important character", "57dynhVYwRk-00255-00064007-00065991": "um", "57dynhVYwRk-00256-00065992-00066279": "bread knives and little hills", "57dynhVYwRk-00257-00066280-00066615": "2007.", "57dynhVYwRk-00258-00066616-00066863": "a peugeot 106 they had a trail for", "57dynhVYwRk-00259-00066864-00067063": "another car to follow", "57dynhVYwRk-00260-00067064-00067279": "it set off loudly down tottenham high", "57dynhVYwRk-00261-00067280-00067519": "road four men inside rattling past the", "57dynhVYwRk-00262-00067520-00067711": "police station before police lost sight", "57dynhVYwRk-00263-00067712-00067879": "of it", "57dynhVYwRk-00264-00067880-00068063": "earlier in these nights", "57dynhVYwRk-00265-00068064-00068279": "these four men had waved one ticket out", "57dynhVYwRk-00266-00068280-00068575": "balancer demanding four for one entry", "57dynhVYwRk-00267-00068576-00068767": "they promised that with them inside the", "57dynhVYwRk-00268-00068768-00069006": "whole place would lat up", "57dynhVYwRk-00269-00069007-00069263": "one of the men spoke in the rituals", "57dynhVYwRk-00270-00069264-00069438": "of the sativa high", "57dynhVYwRk-00271-00069439-00069694": "with each of the bouncers rejections his", "57dynhVYwRk-00272-00069695-00069967": "concentration broke and came back in", "57dynhVYwRk-00273-00069968-00070199": "gradually his fingers carved through the", "57dynhVYwRk-00274-00070200-00070438": "air like carrion picking bones sharp and", "57dynhVYwRk-00275-00070439-00070582": "deliberate", "57dynhVYwRk-00276-00070583-00070831": "he stood in a halo of smoke", "57dynhVYwRk-00277-00070832-00071071": "watched by girls in little hills and", "57dynhVYwRk-00278-00071072-00071182": "jeans", "57dynhVYwRk-00279-00071183-00071482": "holding cigarettes in their hands mouths", "57dynhVYwRk-00280-00071483-00071750": "ajar inside", "57dynhVYwRk-00281-00071751-00072015": "the dance floor was copied and it", "57dynhVYwRk-00282-00072016-00072206": "smelled of peppermint", "57dynhVYwRk-00283-00072207-00072350": "it was ravy", "57dynhVYwRk-00284-00072351-00072575": "with an hour in the middle for a cipher", "57dynhVYwRk-00285-00072576-00072775": "focused turning", "57dynhVYwRk-00286-00072776-00073047": "when the beats shift into another wave", "57dynhVYwRk-00287-00073048-00073206": "you have to catch the moment where", "57dynhVYwRk-00288-00073207-00073423": "you're moving changes", "57dynhVYwRk-00289-00073424-00073623": "correct yourself", "57dynhVYwRk-00290-00073624-00073855": "dancing as exercise", "57dynhVYwRk-00291-00073856-00074126": "carry on to your gasping", "57dynhVYwRk-00292-00074127-00074319": "water water", "57dynhVYwRk-00293-00074320-00074719": "elbow tap is popping up water water", "57dynhVYwRk-00294-00074720-00074894": "cups of water", "57dynhVYwRk-00295-00074895-00075071": "secondhand flavor", "57dynhVYwRk-00296-00075072-00075894": "bit of a twist", "57dynhVYwRk-00297-00075895-00076182": "hi everyone my name is saba khan i am", "57dynhVYwRk-00298-00076183-00076431": "the author and artist of this book", "57dynhVYwRk-00299-00076432-00076623": "called the bowls we play um it's a", "57dynhVYwRk-00300-00076624-00076847": "graphic novel which means that it's a", "57dynhVYwRk-00301-00076848-00077175": "combination of drawings and writing", "57dynhVYwRk-00302-00077176-00077343": "and today i'm going to be reading", "57dynhVYwRk-00303-00077344-00077543": "through one of the chapters with you", "57dynhVYwRk-00304-00077544-00077767": "and what i'll be doing is screen sharing", "57dynhVYwRk-00305-00077768-00078031": "the pages of the book so you can read", "57dynhVYwRk-00306-00078032-00078343": "the drawings whilst i um read the text", "57dynhVYwRk-00307-00078344-00078671": "out and so just bear with me one second", "57dynhVYwRk-00308-00078672-00079055": "whilst i do that", "57dynhVYwRk-00309-00079056-00079206": "there we go", "57dynhVYwRk-00310-00079207-00079382": "cool", "57dynhVYwRk-00311-00079383-00079735": "the roles we play", "57dynhVYwRk-00312-00079736-00079982": "chapter 14.", "57dynhVYwRk-00313-00079983-00080071": "other", "57dynhVYwRk-00314-00080072-00080359": "with a soundtrack by artists leatherette", "57dynhVYwRk-00315-00080360-00080838": "and their song titled after dawn", "57dynhVYwRk-00316-00080839-00081087": "at what point did i become aware that my", "57dynhVYwRk-00317-00081088-00081526": "identity was politicized", "57dynhVYwRk-00318-00081527-00081911": "was it on 15th feb 2003", "57dynhVYwRk-00319-00081912-00082079": "my first protest", "57dynhVYwRk-00320-00082080-00082287": "millions of us against the war", "57dynhVYwRk-00321-00082288-00082526": "all of us ignored", "57dynhVYwRk-00322-00082527-00082862": "was it on tuesday 11 september 2001", "57dynhVYwRk-00323-00082863-00083023": "when i was sitting in my philosophy", "57dynhVYwRk-00324-00083024-00083294": "class and i learned new terms and new", "57dynhVYwRk-00325-00083295-00083606": "uses of ancient words", "57dynhVYwRk-00326-00083607-00083815": "or perhaps it was the first time i was", "57dynhVYwRk-00327-00083816-00084262": "made to feel different", "57dynhVYwRk-00328-00084263-00084462": "all these experiences my body would", "57dynhVYwRk-00329-00084463-00084550": "carry", "57dynhVYwRk-00330-00084551-00084775": "silently i held them close", "57dynhVYwRk-00331-00084776-00084959": "inadvertently giving them the power to", "57dynhVYwRk-00332-00084960-00085159": "inform key junctures and crossroads of", "57dynhVYwRk-00333-00085160-00085255": "life", "57dynhVYwRk-00334-00085256-00085447": "one such time was at the end of college", "57dynhVYwRk-00335-00085448-00085662": "filling in new cast forms when i had to", "57dynhVYwRk-00336-00085663-00085926": "decide what path my future would take", "57dynhVYwRk-00337-00085927-00086150": "i had applied for two different subjects", "57dynhVYwRk-00338-00086151-00086367": "with two different personal statements", "57dynhVYwRk-00339-00086368-00086591": "arabic law", "57dynhVYwRk-00340-00086592-00086799": "i didn't want to do either of them", "57dynhVYwRk-00341-00086800-00087103": "i wanted to do fashion but drawing", "57dynhVYwRk-00342-00087104-00087455": "people is haram i would tell myself", "57dynhVYwRk-00343-00087456-00087582": "why don't you apply for an art", "57dynhVYwRk-00344-00087583-00087815": "foundation it's one year and you can use", "57dynhVYwRk-00345-00087816-00087959": "that year to decide if you want to", "57dynhVYwRk-00346-00087960-00088159": "continue or if you want to go on to", "57dynhVYwRk-00347-00088160-00088311": "other stuff", "57dynhVYwRk-00348-00088312-00088471": "this makes sense", "57dynhVYwRk-00349-00088472-00088655": "i set about applying to the same art", "57dynhVYwRk-00350-00088656-00088911": "foundation my friend was aiming for", "57dynhVYwRk-00351-00088912-00089191": "apply for prestigious art school here", "57dynhVYwRk-00352-00089192-00089382": "tic", "57dynhVYwRk-00353-00089383-00089599": "i tell my parents", "57dynhVYwRk-00354-00089600-00089855": "i've spent my life making clothes i want", "57dynhVYwRk-00355-00089856-00090094": "a better life for you", "57dynhVYwRk-00356-00090095-00090343": "but i need a lawyer", "57dynhVYwRk-00357-00090344-00090559": "i tell my a levels textiles teacher my", "57dynhVYwRk-00358-00090560-00090662": "plans", "57dynhVYwRk-00359-00090663-00090862": "you're going to apply for that art", "57dynhVYwRk-00360-00090863-00090975": "school", "57dynhVYwRk-00361-00090976-00091735": "good luck", "57dynhVYwRk-00362-00091736-00091935": "hi my name is kai miller and i'm going", "57dynhVYwRk-00363-00091936-00092206": "to read the beginning of an essay in", "57dynhVYwRk-00364-00092207-00092462": "this book things i have withheld", "57dynhVYwRk-00365-00092463-00092638": "and the essay that i'll read from is", "57dynhVYwRk-00366-00092639-00093055": "called the boys at the harbour", "57dynhVYwRk-00367-00093056-00093311": "in kingston at night the harbour is", "57dynhVYwRk-00368-00093312-00093462": "beautiful", "57dynhVYwRk-00369-00093463-00093671": "almost as beautiful as the boys who", "57dynhVYwRk-00370-00093672-00093855": "gather around it", "57dynhVYwRk-00371-00093856-00094055": "the boys who are still young and still", "57dynhVYwRk-00372-00094056-00094335": "have dreams as big and bright as the", "57dynhVYwRk-00373-00094336-00094550": "fireworks that light up the waterfront", "57dynhVYwRk-00374-00094551-00094750": "each new year", "57dynhVYwRk-00375-00094751-00095047": "on that night the first day of the year", "57dynhVYwRk-00376-00095048-00095262": "the waterfront does not belong to the", "57dynhVYwRk-00377-00095263-00095543": "boys but to a new throng of people who", "57dynhVYwRk-00378-00095544-00095791": "wouldn't normally venture into this part", "57dynhVYwRk-00379-00095792-00095943": "of town", "57dynhVYwRk-00380-00095944-00096191": "people who have learned a long time ago", "57dynhVYwRk-00381-00096192-00096471": "how not to see these boys", "57dynhVYwRk-00382-00096472-00096703": "and maybe even tonight", "57dynhVYwRk-00383-00096704-00096926": "though it isn't the new year if you pass", "57dynhVYwRk-00384-00096927-00097087": "by the harbour", "57dynhVYwRk-00385-00097088-00097311": "you will not see them either", "57dynhVYwRk-00386-00097312-00097582": "sitting as they do in the shadows", "57dynhVYwRk-00387-00097583-00097887": "under the sweet almond trees these boys", "57dynhVYwRk-00388-00097888-00098094": "talking about their big and bright", "57dynhVYwRk-00389-00098095-00098287": "dreams", "57dynhVYwRk-00390-00098288-00098494": "it hurts a little to hear them speak", "57dynhVYwRk-00391-00098495-00098767": "these dreams to hear them speak about", "57dynhVYwRk-00392-00098768-00098974": "the future i sometimes doubt will be", "57dynhVYwRk-00393-00098975-00099118": "theirs", "57dynhVYwRk-00394-00099119-00099303": "i'm going to live in one of them big big", "57dynhVYwRk-00395-00099304-00099606": "o's upon the hilltop the boy says", "57dynhVYwRk-00396-00099607-00099855": "looking behind not to the water but to", "57dynhVYwRk-00397-00099856-00100118": "the hills that rise over this brutal", "57dynhVYwRk-00398-00100119-00100287": "city", "57dynhVYwRk-00399-00100288-00100503": "i follow his gaze and look to those", "57dynhVYwRk-00400-00100504-00100599": "lights", "57dynhVYwRk-00401-00100600-00100903": "glittering like sequins on the hills", "57dynhVYwRk-00402-00100904-00101103": "the hills to which the new year's crowd", "57dynhVYwRk-00403-00101104-00101294": "will return", "57dynhVYwRk-00404-00101295-00101543": "the house that i grew up in is on those", "57dynhVYwRk-00405-00101544-00101671": "hills as well", "57dynhVYwRk-00406-00101672-00101903": "and i too will return there in just a", "57dynhVYwRk-00407-00101904-00102087": "couple of hours", "57dynhVYwRk-00408-00102088-00102294": "my father's house is emitting one of", "57dynhVYwRk-00409-00102295-00102518": "those lights", "57dynhVYwRk-00410-00102519-00102742": "among i'm not going to work for nobody", "57dynhVYwRk-00411-00102743-00102982": "neither the boy continues", "57dynhVYwRk-00412-00102983-00103206": "i'm going to be my own boss", "57dynhVYwRk-00413-00103207-00103358": "just a little money for starting a", "57dynhVYwRk-00414-00103359-00103663": "business that's all i'm a need", "57dynhVYwRk-00415-00103664-00103871": "he says none of this as if it is a", "57dynhVYwRk-00416-00103872-00104175": "question as if the future is in is in", "57dynhVYwRk-00417-00104176-00104310": "any doubt", "57dynhVYwRk-00418-00104311-00104566": "he says it as a simple fact", "57dynhVYwRk-00419-00104567-00104790": "something that will happen in the near", "57dynhVYwRk-00420-00104791-00105943": "future", "57dynhVYwRk-00421-00105944-00106223": "hello my name is sarita abhike niday and", "57dynhVYwRk-00422-00106224-00106534": "i am here today to read from ace of", "57dynhVYwRk-00423-00106535-00106790": "spades which is my debut novel", "57dynhVYwRk-00424-00106791-00106934": "chapter one", "57dynhVYwRk-00425-00106935-00107071": "devon", "57dynhVYwRk-00426-00107072-00107175": "monday", "57dynhVYwRk-00427-00107176-00107343": "first day black assemblies are the most", "57dynhVYwRk-00428-00107344-00107534": "pointless practice ever and that's", "57dynhVYwRk-00429-00107535-00107751": "saying a lot seeing as nibious academy", "57dynhVYwRk-00430-00107752-00107966": "is a school that runs on pointlessness", "57dynhVYwRk-00431-00107967-00108175": "we are seated in lion hall named after", "57dynhVYwRk-00432-00108176-00108343": "one of those donors who give money to", "57dynhVYwRk-00433-00108344-00108510": "private schools that don't need it", "57dynhVYwRk-00434-00108511-00108678": "waiting for the principal to arrive and", "57dynhVYwRk-00435-00108679-00108910": "deliver his speech in the usual order", "57dynhVYwRk-00436-00108911-00109071": "welcome back for another year glad you", "57dynhVYwRk-00437-00109072-00109215": "didn't die this summer", "57dynhVYwRk-00438-00109216-00109366": "here are your senior prefects and head", "57dynhVYwRk-00439-00109367-00109686": "prefect school values thin don't get me", "57dynhVYwRk-00440-00109688-00109927": "wrong i'm all for structure ask any of", "57dynhVYwRk-00441-00109928-00110239": "my friends correction friend i'm pretty", "57dynhVYwRk-00442-00110240-00110407": "sure that even though i've been here for", "57dynhVYwRk-00443-00110408-00110623": "almost four years no one else knows i", "57dynhVYwRk-00444-00110624-00110854": "exist just jack who generally acts like", "57dynhVYwRk-00445-00110855-00110983": "there's something seriously wrong with", "57dynhVYwRk-00446-00110983-00111223": "me still i call him a friend because", "57dynhVYwRk-00447-00111224-00111383": "we've known each other forever and the", "57dynhVYwRk-00448-00111383-00111543": "thought of being alone is much much", "57dynhVYwRk-00449-00111544-00111686": "worse but back to the thing about", "57dynhVYwRk-00450-00111688-00111895": "structure i'm a fan", "57dynhVYwRk-00451-00111896-00112071": "jack knows about the many rituals i go", "57dynhVYwRk-00452-00112072-00112254": "through before i sit down at the piano", "57dynhVYwRk-00453-00112255-00112486": "without them i don't play as well that's", "57dynhVYwRk-00454-00112488-00112615": "the difference between my rituals and", "57dynhVYwRk-00455-00112616-00112839": "these assemblies without these life", "57dynhVYwRk-00456-00112840-00113031": "animus would still be an endless drudge", "57dynhVYwRk-00457-00113032-00113254": "of gossip money and lies", "57dynhVYwRk-00458-00113255-00113471": "the microphone screeches loudly forcing", "57dynhVYwRk-00459-00113472-00113695": "my head up 20 minutes of my life about", "57dynhVYwRk-00460-00113696-00113854": "to be wasted on an assembly that could", "57dynhVYwRk-00461-00113855-00113983": "have been an email", "57dynhVYwRk-00462-00113983-00114166": "i leaned back against my chair as a tall", "57dynhVYwRk-00463-00114167-00114447": "pale guy with girl black eyes oily black", "57dynhVYwRk-00464-00114448-00114615": "hair slicked back with what i'm sure was", "57dynhVYwRk-00465-00114616-00114847": "an entire jar of hair gel and a long", "57dynhVYwRk-00466-00114848-00115047": "dark coat that almost sweeps the floor", "57dynhVYwRk-00467-00115048-00115247": "stands at the podium staring down at us", "57dynhVYwRk-00468-00115248-00115590": "all like we're vermin and he's a cat", "57dynhVYwRk-00469-00115591-00115815": "my name is mr ward but you must all", "57dynhVYwRk-00470-00115816-00116015": "address me as headmaster ward the cat", "57dynhVYwRk-00471-00116016-00116278": "says voice liquid and slithery", "57dynhVYwRk-00472-00116279-00116478": "i squint at him what the hell happened", "57dynhVYwRk-00473-00116479-00116663": "to headmaster collins the room is filled", "57dynhVYwRk-00474-00116664-00116823": "with confused whispers and unpressed", "57dynhVYwRk-00475-00116824-00116934": "spaces", "57dynhVYwRk-00476-00116935-00117102": "as i'm sure some of you are aware", "57dynhVYwRk-00477-00117103-00117271": "headmaster collins resigned just before", "57dynhVYwRk-00478-00117272-00117447": "summer break and i'm here to lead you", "57dynhVYwRk-00479-00117448-00117599": "all through your final year at nydia's", "57dynhVYwRk-00480-00117600-00118534": "academy the cat finishes his lips passed", "57dynhVYwRk-00481-00118535-00118790": "hi everyone mallory blackman here and", "57dynhVYwRk-00482-00118791-00118927": "i'm going to read from the book that", "57dynhVYwRk-00483-00118928-00119190": "dapper and i created called we're going", "57dynhVYwRk-00484-00119191-00119647": "to find the monster", "57dynhVYwRk-00485-00119648-00119799": "charlie and eddie were playing in the", "57dynhVYwRk-00486-00119800-00119951": "garden", "57dynhVYwRk-00487-00119952-00120295": "breakfast in 10 minutes called dad", "57dynhVYwRk-00488-00120296-00120423": "come on", "57dynhVYwRk-00489-00120424-00120551": "said charlie", "57dynhVYwRk-00490-00120552-00120958": "we need to find the monster", "57dynhVYwRk-00491-00120959-00121278": "but it's breakfast time he'll be grumpy", "57dynhVYwRk-00492-00121279-00121647": "said eddie he'll be grumpy and hungry", "57dynhVYwRk-00493-00121648-00121975": "said charlie he'll be grumpy and hungry", "57dynhVYwRk-00494-00121976-00122134": "and snappy", "57dynhVYwRk-00495-00122135-00122534": "said eddie he'll be grumpy and hungry", "57dynhVYwRk-00496-00122535-00122910": "and snappy and prickly they both said", "57dynhVYwRk-00497-00122911-00123039": "together", "57dynhVYwRk-00498-00123040-00123214": "shh", "57dynhVYwRk-00499-00123215-00123519": "we'll need to be very careful", "57dynhVYwRk-00500-00123520-00123719": "and off they went", "57dynhVYwRk-00501-00123720-00124239": "we're going to find the monster", "57dynhVYwRk-00502-00124240-00124566": "they sailed over a shimmering ocean", "57dynhVYwRk-00503-00124567-00124958": "look out there's a whale eddie pointed", "57dynhVYwRk-00504-00124959-00125239": "no problem said charlie and she rode", "57dynhVYwRk-00505-00125240-00125502": "their boat quickly round it", "57dynhVYwRk-00506-00125503-00125719": "over the shimmering ocean", "57dynhVYwRk-00507-00125720-00126023": "we're going to find the monster", "57dynhVYwRk-00508-00126024-00126710": "they began to climb a huge high mountain", "57dynhVYwRk-00509-00126711-00127039": "look out a hungry wolf", "57dynhVYwRk-00510-00127040-00127271": "don't worry said charlie", "57dynhVYwRk-00511-00127272-00127631": "and she sang a soft sweet song to soothe", "57dynhVYwRk-00512-00127632-00127710": "it", "57dynhVYwRk-00513-00127711-00127975": "then she gave it a massive hug and sent", "57dynhVYwRk-00514-00127976-00128199": "it on its way", "57dynhVYwRk-00515-00128200-00128414": "over the shimmering ocean", "57dynhVYwRk-00516-00128415-00128727": "up the huge high mountain", "57dynhVYwRk-00517-00128728-00129086": "we're going to find the monster", "57dynhVYwRk-00518-00129088-00129383": "they crept through a deep", "57dynhVYwRk-00519-00129383-00129623": "dark jungle", "57dynhVYwRk-00520-00129624-00129943": "look out a fearsome fierce tiger said", "57dynhVYwRk-00521-00129944-00130199": "eddie", "57dynhVYwRk-00522-00130200-00130614": "they hid in a cave but only just in time", "57dynhVYwRk-00523-00130615-00130910": "the most fearsome fierce tiger in the", "57dynhVYwRk-00524-00130911-00131287": "whole world slunk past", "57dynhVYwRk-00525-00131288-00131551": "eddie and charlie held their breath", "57dynhVYwRk-00526-00131552-00131683": "until it had", "57dynhVYwRk-00527-00131684-00131863": "gone whew", "57dynhVYwRk-00528-00131864-00133023": "that was close", "57dynhVYwRk-00529-00133024-00133383": "hello my name is jeffrey boichi and this", "57dynhVYwRk-00530-00133384-00133599": "is my book musical truth", "57dynhVYwRk-00531-00133600-00133743": "the musical history of modern black", "57dynhVYwRk-00532-00133744-00134078": "britain in 28 songs um i'm going to read", "57dynhVYwRk-00533-00134079-00134263": "a chapter called ghost town which is", "57dynhVYwRk-00534-00134264-00134502": "about a song called ghost town by a band", "57dynhVYwRk-00535-00134503-00134647": "called the specials", "57dynhVYwRk-00536-00134648-00134919": "from 1981.", "57dynhVYwRk-00537-00134920-00135135": "can you imagine living in an actual", "57dynhVYwRk-00538-00135136-00135287": "ghost town", "57dynhVYwRk-00539-00135288-00135463": "stumbling through deserted streets", "57dynhVYwRk-00540-00135464-00135671": "shivering every wailing gust of wind", "57dynhVYwRk-00541-00135672-00135871": "heart racing every creek", "57dynhVYwRk-00542-00135872-00136047": "imagine the spooky old buildings and", "57dynhVYwRk-00543-00136048-00136231": "dusty cracked windows", "57dynhVYwRk-00544-00136232-00136551": "the abandoned shops and gloomy skies", "57dynhVYwRk-00545-00136552-00136695": "and can you imagine what would have had", "57dynhVYwRk-00546-00136696-00136823": "to have happened", "57dynhVYwRk-00547-00136824-00136975": "for the place where you live to end up", "57dynhVYwRk-00548-00136976-00137207": "like that in real life", "57dynhVYwRk-00549-00137208-00137414": "some people don't have to imagine this", "57dynhVYwRk-00550-00137415-00137766": "for them it's just normality", "57dynhVYwRk-00551-00137767-00137975": "urban decay has been a backdrop for", "57dynhVYwRk-00552-00137976-00138175": "black communities in the uk since black", "57dynhVYwRk-00553-00138176-00138343": "people started to arrive in this country", "57dynhVYwRk-00554-00138344-00138487": "in large numbers", "57dynhVYwRk-00555-00138488-00138678": "it's what tends to happen to immigrants", "57dynhVYwRk-00556-00138679-00138847": "arriving in a new country", "57dynhVYwRk-00557-00138848-00139111": "gathering together in large cities where", "57dynhVYwRk-00558-00139112-00139263": "there's a better chance of finding work", "57dynhVYwRk-00559-00139264-00139511": "and housing but finding that the work is", "57dynhVYwRk-00560-00139512-00139871": "low paid and the housing is run down", "57dynhVYwRk-00561-00139872-00140102": "by 1981 this inner city environment have", "57dynhVYwRk-00562-00140103-00140278": "become pretty normal for most black", "57dynhVYwRk-00563-00140279-00140583": "communities and it came with problems", "57dynhVYwRk-00564-00140584-00140735": "unemployment had been on the increase", "57dynhVYwRk-00565-00140736-00140935": "since the mid-1960s", "57dynhVYwRk-00566-00140936-00141295": "by 1980 1.5 million people were out of", "57dynhVYwRk-00567-00141296-00141471": "work in the uk", "57dynhVYwRk-00568-00141472-00141639": "for the working classes", "57dynhVYwRk-00569-00141640-00141847": "people who have to work this meant that", "57dynhVYwRk-00570-00141848-00142047": "life became more difficult", "57dynhVYwRk-00571-00142048-00142247": "shops were closing down work was hard to", "57dynhVYwRk-00572-00142248-00142599": "find and money was scarce", "57dynhVYwRk-00573-00142600-00142790": "the song ghost town is all about this", "57dynhVYwRk-00574-00142791-00142902": "environment", "57dynhVYwRk-00575-00142903-00143166": "it's a haunting eerie song that echoes", "57dynhVYwRk-00576-00143167-00143471": "through images of a very broken briton", "57dynhVYwRk-00577-00143472-00143647": "all of this should make ghost town a", "57dynhVYwRk-00578-00143648-00143854": "depressing song to listen to but it", "57dynhVYwRk-00579-00143855-00143990": "really isn't", "57dynhVYwRk-00580-00143991-00144207": "the reason for this has a lot to do with", "57dynhVYwRk-00581-00144208-00144511": "something called two-tone", "57dynhVYwRk-00582-00144512-00144695": "the two-tone movement was all about", "57dynhVYwRk-00583-00144696-00144887": "black and white people coming together", "57dynhVYwRk-00584-00144888-00145119": "to make music and share culture", "57dynhVYwRk-00585-00145120-00145351": "it was influenced heavily by scar a", "57dynhVYwRk-00586-00145352-00145551": "traditional type of reggae music that", "57dynhVYwRk-00587-00145552-00145735": "young white musicians in places like", "57dynhVYwRk-00588-00145736-00145943": "coventry grew up listening to in the", "57dynhVYwRk-00589-00145944-00146143": "1960s", "57dynhVYwRk-00590-00146144-00146390": "two-tone took scar and combined it with", "57dynhVYwRk-00591-00146391-00146599": "modern genres to make a whole new sound", "57dynhVYwRk-00592-00146600-00146871": "that was west indian british up-to-date", "57dynhVYwRk-00593-00146872-00147783": "and traditional all at the same time", "57dynhVYwRk-00594-00147784-00148023": "hi i'm aiden chan and i'm the author of", "57dynhVYwRk-00595-00148024-00148254": "danny chung does not do maths i'm going", "57dynhVYwRk-00596-00148255-00148414": "to read an extract from the first", "57dynhVYwRk-00597-00148415-00148847": "chapter", "57dynhVYwRk-00598-00148848-00149078": "drawing makes me feel good", "57dynhVYwRk-00599-00149079-00149319": "i draw literally everywhere", "57dynhVYwRk-00600-00149320-00149511": "in bed with a torch and even on the", "57dynhVYwRk-00601-00149512-00149623": "toilet", "57dynhVYwRk-00602-00149624-00149775": "well you can except for quite a while", "57dynhVYwRk-00603-00149776-00149943": "and yes i always wash my hands", "57dynhVYwRk-00604-00149944-00150087": "afterwards", "57dynhVYwRk-00605-00150088-00150287": "sometimes i sketch in the park at", "57dynhVYwRk-00606-00150288-00150590": "weekends with ravi my best mate", "57dynhVYwRk-00607-00150591-00150775": "my favorite bit is coming up with new", "57dynhVYwRk-00608-00150776-00151031": "characters one's a half one thing and", "57dynhVYwRk-00609-00151032-00151343": "half another the best of both worlds", "57dynhVYwRk-00610-00151344-00151526": "like wholemeal red and white bread put", "57dynhVYwRk-00611-00151527-00151678": "together", "57dynhVYwRk-00612-00151679-00151871": "i was really pleased my newest creation", "57dynhVYwRk-00613-00151872-00152063": "that i called it dracon", "57dynhVYwRk-00614-00152064-00152278": "it was a mutant duck", "57dynhVYwRk-00615-00152279-00152478": "with a dragon's head", "57dynhVYwRk-00616-00152479-00152766": "it's very chinese if you ask me", "57dynhVYwRk-00617-00152767-00152966": "dragons are the most beloved and looking", "57dynhVYwRk-00618-00152967-00153271": "creatures in chinese mythology and looks", "57dynhVYwRk-00619-00153272-00153487": "are yummy and succulent", "57dynhVYwRk-00620-00153488-00153663": "the tricky part was the head", "57dynhVYwRk-00621-00153664-00153807": "chinese dragons don't look like other", "57dynhVYwRk-00622-00153808-00154039": "dragons and they have no wings", "57dynhVYwRk-00623-00154040-00154231": "ravi is basically an expert on all", "57dynhVYwRk-00624-00154232-00154431": "things medieval knights", "57dynhVYwRk-00625-00154432-00154599": "he says that chinese dragons are", "57dynhVYwRk-00626-00154600-00154726": "anomalies", "57dynhVYwRk-00627-00154727-00154871": "which is a nice way of saying they're", "57dynhVYwRk-00628-00154872-00154999": "weird", "57dynhVYwRk-00629-00155000-00155135": "and they don't go around trying to eat", "57dynhVYwRk-00630-00155136-00155366": "princesses or battle nights i think", "57dynhVYwRk-00631-00155367-00155647": "that's nice a dracon is a chinese", "57dynhVYwRk-00632-00155648-00155854": "win-win", "57dynhVYwRk-00633-00155855-00156047": "from under my duvet i heard the door to", "57dynhVYwRk-00634-00156048-00156254": "my room squeak open", "57dynhVYwRk-00635-00156255-00156447": "danny where are you", "57dynhVYwRk-00636-00156448-00156590": "it was ba", "57dynhVYwRk-00637-00156591-00156751": "i could tell from the sesame oil smell", "57dynhVYwRk-00638-00156752-00156919": "from the kitchen", "57dynhVYwRk-00639-00156920-00157263": "not now i prayed i was still drawing", "57dynhVYwRk-00640-00157264-00157431": "i nearly finished the camel like head of", "57dynhVYwRk-00641-00157432-00157687": "the dragon the duck's body would of", "57dynhVYwRk-00642-00157688-00157975": "course be in scale with the head", "57dynhVYwRk-00643-00157976-00158159": "you wouldn't want a tiny duck's body and", "57dynhVYwRk-00644-00158160-00158319": "a massive dragon's head", "57dynhVYwRk-00645-00158320-00158478": "that thing would lollop around and flop", "57dynhVYwRk-00646-00158479-00158654": "over", "57dynhVYwRk-00647-00158655-00158887": "i slid my duvet above my head some more", "57dynhVYwRk-00648-00158888-00159126": "hoping that bar wouldn't see me", "57dynhVYwRk-00649-00159127-00159326": "saturday was usually very busy so my", "57dynhVYwRk-00650-00159327-00159502": "parents wanted me to help out by folding", "57dynhVYwRk-00651-00159503-00159743": "menus or piling pop cans on the shelf", "57dynhVYwRk-00652-00159744-00159911": "behind the counter", "57dynhVYwRk-00653-00159912-00160102": "but i'd rather just draw in my pajamas", "57dynhVYwRk-00654-00160103-00160911": "instead", "57dynhVYwRk-00655-00160912-00161102": "i am rebecca henry the author of the", "57dynhVYwRk-00656-00161103-00161319": "sound of everything um it's my first", "57dynhVYwRk-00657-00161320-00161543": "novel and i'm just going to do a quick", "57dynhVYwRk-00658-00161544-00161983": "reading from the start of the book", "57dynhVYwRk-00659-00161984-00162151": "chapter one", "57dynhVYwRk-00660-00162152-00162311": "i can tell from the get-go when i'm not", "57dynhVYwRk-00661-00162312-00162414": "wanted", "57dynhVYwRk-00662-00162415-00162575": "when you're just another foster kid", "57dynhVYwRk-00663-00162576-00162719": "sometimes it seems like eventually", "57dynhVYwRk-00664-00162720-00162902": "everyone stops caring except to get", "57dynhVYwRk-00665-00162903-00163047": "chatty party about you before you've", "57dynhVYwRk-00666-00163048-00163223": "even walked in the door", "57dynhVYwRk-00667-00163224-00163399": "i'm one of those girls", "57dynhVYwRk-00668-00163400-00163671": "people know about me before they meet me", "57dynhVYwRk-00669-00163672-00163838": "i'd like to think that mr tucker sat me", "57dynhVYwRk-00670-00163839-00163975": "at the front of his history class to", "57dynhVYwRk-00671-00163976-00164143": "make sure i'm doing okay", "57dynhVYwRk-00672-00164144-00164278": "it's probably more like he was given a", "57dynhVYwRk-00673-00164279-00164487": "folder labeled katie hunt which advised", "57dynhVYwRk-00674-00164488-00164638": "him to sit me under his nose where he", "57dynhVYwRk-00675-00164639-00164887": "could keep one eye trained on me", "57dynhVYwRk-00676-00164888-00165038": "at the moment i'm actually supposed to", "57dynhVYwRk-00677-00165039-00165238": "be a lucas but i've always kept my real", "57dynhVYwRk-00678-00165239-00165351": "name", "57dynhVYwRk-00679-00165352-00165502": "i rock back in my chair and test it in", "57dynhVYwRk-00680-00165503-00165623": "my head", "57dynhVYwRk-00681-00165624-00165783": "katie lucas", "57dynhVYwRk-00682-00165784-00166038": "it was a good ring i could fit in i've", "57dynhVYwRk-00683-00166039-00166166": "got standings", "57dynhVYwRk-00684-00166167-00166351": "apart from the whole rapper singer thing", "57dynhVYwRk-00685-00166352-00166535": "my fashion sense is on point and i live", "57dynhVYwRk-00686-00166536-00166683": "in the same house as miss", "57dynhVYwRk-00687-00166684-00166902": "popularity kd", "57dynhVYwRk-00688-00166903-00167078": "an explosion on the desk in front of me", "57dynhVYwRk-00689-00167079-00167278": "jolts me back into perspective", "57dynhVYwRk-00690-00167279-00167471": "i start dropping my chair back into", "57dynhVYwRk-00691-00167472-00167735": "place and bore my hands into tight fists", "57dynhVYwRk-00692-00167736-00167887": "mr tucker has a thing with whacking", "57dynhVYwRk-00693-00167888-00168047": "wooden board rubbers on the desks to get", "57dynhVYwRk-00694-00168048-00168247": "people's attention i'm pretty sure i", "57dynhVYwRk-00695-00168248-00168535": "felt some reverb in my bones", "57dynhVYwRk-00696-00168536-00168687": "remind me when the suffragette movement", "57dynhVYwRk-00697-00168688-00168783": "was", "57dynhVYwRk-00698-00168784-00168990": "he taps the board rubber insistently on", "57dynhVYwRk-00699-00168991-00169263": "the desk i've only been at the", "57dynhVYwRk-00700-00169264-00169390": "school three weeks but i know he won't", "57dynhVYwRk-00701-00169391-00169623": "stop until i've given him my attention i", "57dynhVYwRk-00702-00169624-00169838": "grip my teeth stop banging that stupid", "57dynhVYwRk-00703-00169839-00170007": "piece of wood", "57dynhVYwRk-00704-00170008-00170247": "mr tucker's eyebrows shoot up he stops", "57dynhVYwRk-00705-00170248-00170407": "banging the wardrobe", "57dynhVYwRk-00706-00170408-00170607": "lose the earphones and pay attention", "57dynhVYwRk-00707-00170608-00170743": "next time i see them you're staying", "57dynhVYwRk-00708-00170744-00170902": "after school and that's me being", "57dynhVYwRk-00709-00170903-00171111": "ridiculously lenient open your ears and", "57dynhVYwRk-00710-00171112-00171254": "listen to me", "57dynhVYwRk-00711-00171255-00171438": "i managed to resist the urge to roll my", "57dynhVYwRk-00712-00171439-00171526": "eyes", "57dynhVYwRk-00713-00171527-00171790": "listening is effort and for the most", "57dynhVYwRk-00714-00171791-00172535": "part i don't do effort", "57dynhVYwRk-00715-00172536-00172790": "hi my name is manjit man and this is a", "57dynhVYwRk-00716-00172791-00173126": "reading for the jalap prize from the", "57dynhVYwRk-00717-00173127-00173571": "crossing", "57dynhVYwRk-00718-00173572-00173911": "366 days before", "57dynhVYwRk-00719-00173912-00174102": "natalie", "57dynhVYwRk-00720-00174103-00174423": "everyone is crying but me", "57dynhVYwRk-00721-00174424-00174663": "seven days since she passed", "57dynhVYwRk-00722-00174664-00175111": "seven days 11 hours 43 minutes and 16", "57dynhVYwRk-00723-00175112-00175495": "seconds counting the days hours minutes", "57dynhVYwRk-00724-00175496-00175766": "to stop myself from drowning", "57dynhVYwRk-00725-00175767-00176063": "everyone is crying but me", "57dynhVYwRk-00726-00176064-00176399": "dad squeezes my shoulder be brave now", "57dynhVYwRk-00727-00176400-00176647": "i walk towards the front of the church 7", "57dynhVYwRk-00728-00176648-00176871": "days 11 hours", "57dynhVYwRk-00729-00176872-00177047": "53 minutes", "57dynhVYwRk-00730-00177048-00177159": "and 9", "57dynhVYwRk-00731-00177160-00177238": "10", "57dynhVYwRk-00732-00177239-00177335": "11", "57dynhVYwRk-00733-00177336-00177559": "12.", "57dynhVYwRk-00734-00177560-00177838": "everyone is crying but me", "57dynhVYwRk-00735-00177839-00178063": "i'm trying to remember how to breathe my", "57dynhVYwRk-00736-00178064-00178326": "desert dry mouth hands trembling i", "57dynhVYwRk-00737-00178327-00178502": "swallow sand", "57dynhVYwRk-00738-00178503-00178719": "it feels like an eternity before i find", "57dynhVYwRk-00739-00178720-00178902": "my", "57dynhVYwRk-00740-00178903-00179071": "voice", "57dynhVYwRk-00741-00179072-00179311": "everyone is crying but me", "57dynhVYwRk-00742-00179312-00179526": "tears stream down dad's face he's giving", "57dynhVYwRk-00743-00179527-00179702": "up on wiping them away", "57dynhVYwRk-00744-00179703-00179951": "his voice cracks as he reminds everyone", "57dynhVYwRk-00745-00179952-00180366": "of who she was katherine kate kitty", "57dynhVYwRk-00746-00180367-00180751": "her laugh joy for life mermaid wonderful", "57dynhVYwRk-00747-00180752-00181238": "mother beautiful wife activist big heart", "57dynhVYwRk-00748-00181239-00181487": "my mum", "57dynhVYwRk-00749-00181488-00181735": "everyone is crying", "57dynhVYwRk-00750-00181736-00181926": "everyone", "57dynhVYwRk-00751-00181927-00182214": "even me", "57dynhVYwRk-00752-00182215-00182390": "sammy", "57dynhVYwRk-00753-00182391-00182599": "me and mama have laying here on the cold", "57dynhVYwRk-00754-00182600-00182863": "floor for hours or seconds", "57dynhVYwRk-00755-00182864-00183119": "it's hard to know anything right now", "57dynhVYwRk-00756-00183120-00183447": "i lie next to baba his warm hands turned", "57dynhVYwRk-00757-00183448-00183647": "cold i want more than anything to", "57dynhVYwRk-00758-00183648-00183943": "breathe life back into him", "57dynhVYwRk-00759-00183944-00184254": "baba was fearless in a country ruled by", "57dynhVYwRk-00760-00184255-00184623": "fear i wish i was like you i would say", "57dynhVYwRk-00761-00184624-00185007": "my son the stargazer he would say you", "57dynhVYwRk-00762-00185008-00192271": "are perfect just as you are", "57dynhVYwRk-00763-00192272-00192634": "welcome to the chalk prize 2022.", "57dynhVYwRk-00764-00192635-00193254": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-00765-00193255-00193495": "and welcome again to our viewers at home", "57dynhVYwRk-00766-00193496-00193726": "this is our first in-person celebration", "57dynhVYwRk-00767-00193727-00194078": "of the awards since 2019 so we are a", "57dynhVYwRk-00768-00194079-00194311": "little excited", "57dynhVYwRk-00769-00194312-00194599": "i am sunny singh um one of the founders", "57dynhVYwRk-00770-00194600-00194750": "of the jalaprise and its current", "57dynhVYwRk-00771-00194751-00194878": "director", "57dynhVYwRk-00772-00194879-00195143": "and we are joined by our judges today", "57dynhVYwRk-00773-00195144-00195302": "for the jalak prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00774-00195303-00195463": "mary jean chan", "57dynhVYwRk-00775-00195464-00195671": "shimane sulayman and stephen thompson", "57dynhVYwRk-00776-00195672-00195911": "who unfortunately couldn't be here as", "57dynhVYwRk-00777-00195912-00196190": "well as judges of the jalak children", "57dynhVYwRk-00778-00196191-00196390": "children's and young adult prize sophia", "57dynhVYwRk-00779-00196391-00196495": "ahmed", "57dynhVYwRk-00780-00196496-00196871": "and patrice lawrence and i think nia", "57dynhVYwRk-00781-00196872-00197095": "equate parks is somewhere on his way", "57dynhVYwRk-00782-00197096-00197263": "it's been a tough day", "57dynhVYwRk-00783-00197264-00197511": "um so if he arrives we've got we've got", "57dynhVYwRk-00784-00197512-00197711": "space waiting for him", "57dynhVYwRk-00785-00197712-00197902": "in addition to announcing the winners of", "57dynhVYwRk-00786-00197903-00198095": "our two awards this evening we also", "57dynhVYwRk-00787-00198096-00198326": "reveal to you the unique works of art", "57dynhVYwRk-00788-00198327-00198623": "created specially to serve as the 2022", "57dynhVYwRk-00789-00198624-00198854": "winners trophies by our two chalk", "57dynhVYwRk-00790-00198855-00199095": "artists and residents elijah avardo and", "57dynhVYwRk-00791-00199096-00199263": "rick and parrik", "57dynhVYwRk-00792-00199264-00199726": "also", "57dynhVYwRk-00793-00199727-00199966": "also further information on chalk price", "57dynhVYwRk-00794-00199967-00200183": "including book giveaways video clips of", "57dynhVYwRk-00795-00200184-00200350": "the shortlisted writers and much more", "57dynhVYwRk-00796-00200351-00200487": "can be found", "57dynhVYwRk-00797-00200488-00200735": "via our website jealousprize.com and on", "57dynhVYwRk-00798-00200736-00200983": "social media hashtag startprice22", "57dynhVYwRk-00799-00200984-00201135": "angelic prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00800-00201136-00201366": "a quick introduction to the gelat prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00801-00201367-00201638": "founded in 2016 the prize exists to", "57dynhVYwRk-00802-00201639-00201863": "celebrate the rich array of exceptional", "57dynhVYwRk-00803-00201864-00202078": "work from writers of color in britain", "57dynhVYwRk-00804-00202079-00202319": "whether it be fiction non-fiction short", "57dynhVYwRk-00805-00202320-00202575": "stories graphic novels or poetry the", "57dynhVYwRk-00806-00202576-00202831": "prize is also open to self-published", "57dynhVYwRk-00807-00202832-00203095": "writers a new sister award the chalak", "57dynhVYwRk-00808-00203096-00203271": "children's and young adult prize was", "57dynhVYwRk-00809-00203272-00203543": "announced in 2020 with the first award", "57dynhVYwRk-00810-00203544-00203854": "made in 2021 and won by one of our", "57dynhVYwRk-00811-00203855-00204027": "judges patrice lawrence", "57dynhVYwRk-00812-00204028-00204073": "[Music]", "57dynhVYwRk-00813-00204074-00204390": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-00814-00204391-00204575": "open to a broad church of genres and", "57dynhVYwRk-00815-00204576-00204879": "forms both both award a thousand pounds", "57dynhVYwRk-00816-00204880-00205127": "to the winner as well as a unique work", "57dynhVYwRk-00817-00205128-00205382": "of art created by artists chosen for the", "57dynhVYwRk-00818-00205383-00205655": "annual telecard residency", "57dynhVYwRk-00819-00205656-00205862": "we believe that the most profound and", "57dynhVYwRk-00820-00205863-00206062": "greatest of changes are brought about", "57dynhVYwRk-00821-00206063-00206310": "not by individuals but by collective", "57dynhVYwRk-00822-00206311-00206542": "efforts of people organizations and", "57dynhVYwRk-00823-00206544-00206751": "institutions working together", "57dynhVYwRk-00824-00206752-00207046": "this community-based ethos also means we", "57dynhVYwRk-00825-00207048-00207319": "work with and partner with like-minded", "57dynhVYwRk-00826-00207319-00207479": "organization", "57dynhVYwRk-00827-00207480-00207766": "organizations this is why first of all i", "57dynhVYwRk-00828-00207767-00207982": "would like to thank and honor our", "57dynhVYwRk-00829-00207983-00208206": "partners who make this prize and", "57dynhVYwRk-00830-00208207-00208423": "celebration possible", "57dynhVYwRk-00831-00208423-00208542": "first of all", "57dynhVYwRk-00832-00208544-00208734": "thank you to our anonymous manufacturer", "57dynhVYwRk-00833-00208735-00208894": "who provides the prize checks for the", "57dynhVYwRk-00834-00208896-00209038": "winners", "57dynhVYwRk-00835-00209039-00209303": "thanks also to our anonymous sponsors", "57dynhVYwRk-00836-00209304-00209503": "who fund the annual talk artists in", "57dynhVYwRk-00837-00209504-00209694": "residence there's a lot of people who do", "57dynhVYwRk-00838-00209696-00209831": "quiet work", "57dynhVYwRk-00839-00209832-00210134": "a shout out to author dorothy kimson who", "57dynhVYwRk-00840-00210135-00210367": "initiated the idea of the jalakart", "57dynhVYwRk-00841-00210367-00210615": "residency and that project would not", "57dynhVYwRk-00842-00210616-00210823": "exist without her", "57dynhVYwRk-00843-00210823-00210998": "from the beginning the historic authors", "57dynhVYwRk-00844-00211000-00211158": "club has supported the prize and", "57dynhVYwRk-00845-00211159-00211398": "continues to do so", "57dynhVYwRk-00846-00211400-00211623": "the pandemic pushed the prize online in", "57dynhVYwRk-00847-00211623-00211910": "2020 but also resulted in a fruitful", "57dynhVYwRk-00848-00211911-00212175": "collaboration with the british library", "57dynhVYwRk-00849-00212176-00212455": "that hosted our globally available", "57dynhVYwRk-00850-00212456-00212782": "online awards in 2021 and are providing", "57dynhVYwRk-00851-00212783-00213006": "today's hybrid celebration with an", "57dynhVYwRk-00852-00213007-00213271": "in-person reception as well as a", "57dynhVYwRk-00853-00213271-00213567": "globally live-streamed event", "57dynhVYwRk-00854-00213567-00213767": "starting this year we are delighted to", "57dynhVYwRk-00855-00213767-00214006": "partner with the london library this", "57dynhVYwRk-00856-00214007-00214215": "partnership grants all shortlisted", "57dynhVYwRk-00857-00214216-00214446": "writers one year of complementary", "57dynhVYwRk-00858-00214448-00214558": "memberships", "57dynhVYwRk-00859-00214559-00214767": "the winner received two years", "57dynhVYwRk-00860-00214767-00214975": "complementary membership the london", "57dynhVYwRk-00861-00214976-00215231": "library also hosted our first in-person", "57dynhVYwRk-00862-00215232-00215494": "shortlist event since 2019", "57dynhVYwRk-00863-00215496-00215655": "this past april", "57dynhVYwRk-00864-00215656-00215894": "we are delighted to be able to share", "57dynhVYwRk-00865-00215896-00216175": "possibly the most writerly of libraries", "57dynhVYwRk-00866-00216176-00216455": "in the world with more of our community", "57dynhVYwRk-00867-00216456-00216671": "of writers and readers", "57dynhVYwRk-00868-00216671-00216871": "there is a special place in our hearts", "57dynhVYwRk-00869-00216871-00217079": "for national book tokens", "57dynhVYwRk-00870-00217080-00217255": "with whom we have partnered for the past", "57dynhVYwRk-00871-00217256-00217367": "two years", "57dynhVYwRk-00872-00217367-00217527": "they have helped us highlight and", "57dynhVYwRk-00873-00217528-00217767": "maximize sales potential of books by", "57dynhVYwRk-00874-00217767-00217982": "writers of color across britain", "57dynhVYwRk-00875-00217983-00218206": "our partnership means that bookshops up", "57dynhVYwRk-00876-00218207-00218358": "and down the country support our", "57dynhVYwRk-00877-00218359-00218598": "shortlisted titles with creative", "57dynhVYwRk-00878-00218600-00218823": "in-store displays and promotions across", "57dynhVYwRk-00879-00218823-00219031": "websites and social media", "57dynhVYwRk-00880-00219032-00219431": "in 2022 this year waterstones foils", "57dynhVYwRk-00881-00219432-00219731": "blackwell's bookshop.org and over", "57dynhVYwRk-00882-00219732-00220023": "120 independent bookshops are promoting", "57dynhVYwRk-00883-00220023-00220242": "our shortlists", "57dynhVYwRk-00884-00220242-00220887": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-00885-00220888-00221023": "i didn't think that was hap that would", "57dynhVYwRk-00886-00221023-00221358": "happen when we started in 2016.", "57dynhVYwRk-00887-00221359-00221631": "so it's really important moreover for a", "57dynhVYwRk-00888-00221632-00221863": "second year 12 independent bookshops", "57dynhVYwRk-00889-00221864-00222119": "across britain are not only promoting", "57dynhVYwRk-00890-00222119-00222382": "our shortlists but are also championing", "57dynhVYwRk-00891-00222383-00222623": "a shortlisted book each with author", "57dynhVYwRk-00892-00222623-00222958": "events podcasts spotify playlists", "57dynhVYwRk-00893-00222959-00223182": "giveaways and more", "57dynhVYwRk-00894-00223183-00223423": "we know that independent bookshops are", "57dynhVYwRk-00895-00223423-00223623": "best placed to reach readers in their", "57dynhVYwRk-00896-00223623-00223751": "communities", "57dynhVYwRk-00897-00223752-00224398": "and can not only showcase and sell", "57dynhVYwRk-00898-00224400-00224671": "was that a bit of a glitch", "57dynhVYwRk-00899-00224671-00224879": "um yeah i don't want i don't want to", "57dynhVYwRk-00900-00224880-00225198": "hear myself thank you", "57dynhVYwRk-00901-00225200-00225375": "we know that independent bookshops are", "57dynhVYwRk-00902-00225376-00225534": "best placed to reach readers in their", "57dynhVYwRk-00903-00225535-00225742": "communities and can not only showcase", "57dynhVYwRk-00904-00225744-00225982": "and sell books by writers of color but", "57dynhVYwRk-00905-00225983-00226231": "they can also nurture an expanded", "57dynhVYwRk-00906-00226232-00226527": "expanding base of potential book buyers", "57dynhVYwRk-00907-00226528-00226791": "we are grateful to our 2022 bookshop", "57dynhVYwRk-00908-00226792-00227039": "champions some of whom are here with us", "57dynhVYwRk-00909-00227040-00227415": "today so thank you a free books brighton", "57dynhVYwRk-00910-00227416-00227646": "five leaves book job nottingham la", "57dynhVYwRk-00911-00227648-00227910": "biblioteca sheffield lighthouse bookshop", "57dynhVYwRk-00912-00227911-00228191": "edinburgh mostly books abingdon", "57dynhVYwRk-00913-00228192-00228439": "october book southampton shelf life", "57dynhVYwRk-00914-00228440-00228703": "books and scenes cardiff story smith", "57dynhVYwRk-00915-00228704-00228967": "bristol and children's bookshop newman", "57dynhVYwRk-00916-00228967-00229175": "books roundtable books and pages of", "57dynhVYwRk-00917-00229176-00229592": "hackney in london", "57dynhVYwRk-00918-00229592-00230246": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-00919-00230248-00230479": "also a huge shout out to apple books who", "57dynhVYwRk-00920-00230480-00230719": "have gillock prize curated lists so if", "57dynhVYwRk-00921-00230719-00230934": "the fruit phone is your friend look us", "57dynhVYwRk-00922-00230935-00231071": "up there", "57dynhVYwRk-00923-00231071-00231310": "also a massive thank you for to spread", "57dynhVYwRk-00924-00231311-00231542": "the word whose 2015 report writing the", "57dynhVYwRk-00925-00231544-00231710": "future was the spark that led to the", "57dynhVYwRk-00926-00231711-00231831": "jollof prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00927-00231832-00231982": "they have provided copies of the", "57dynhVYwRk-00928-00231983-00232215": "extraordinary anthology runaways london", "57dynhVYwRk-00929-00232216-00232423": "published by ink sweat and tears and", "57dynhVYwRk-00930-00232423-00232631": "featuring young poets and artists of", "57dynhVYwRk-00931-00232632-00232855": "color who have excavated silenced", "57dynhVYwRk-00932-00232856-00233127": "histories of people of color in 17th and", "57dynhVYwRk-00933-00233128-00233455": "18th century london for our in-person", "57dynhVYwRk-00934-00233456-00233775": "guests today these are talents to watch", "57dynhVYwRk-00935-00233776-00234094": "and i would recommend you take a copy", "57dynhVYwRk-00936-00234096-00234271": "we also want to thank the bookseller for", "57dynhVYwRk-00937-00234271-00234455": "their constant and much needed support", "57dynhVYwRk-00938-00234456-00234731": "and for hosting a very loud table at", "57dynhVYwRk-00939-00234732-00235087": "2022 newbies this past monday", "57dynhVYwRk-00940-00235088-00235255": "that laugh tells you all you need to", "57dynhVYwRk-00941-00235256-00235567": "know", "57dynhVYwRk-00942-00235567-00235831": "we have an outsized public image", "57dynhVYwRk-00943-00235832-00236127": "so it is often not known or is forgotten", "57dynhVYwRk-00944-00236128-00236375": "that the chalk prize is run entirely by", "57dynhVYwRk-00945-00236376-00236534": "volunteers", "57dynhVYwRk-00946-00236535-00236767": "if you are with us in person", "57dynhVYwRk-00947-00236767-00237023": "you will see most of our team here", "57dynhVYwRk-00948-00237023-00237294": "but a huge thank you to jamila ahmed who", "57dynhVYwRk-00949-00237296-00237623": "cannot join us today tashmiya owen hamsa", "57dynhVYwRk-00950-00237623-00237934": "johansepp kate burch and shai hussein", "57dynhVYwRk-00951-00237935-00238223": "who you may spot around the event today", "57dynhVYwRk-00952-00238223-00238446": "and many many other wonderful folk who", "57dynhVYwRk-00953-00238448-00238782": "prefer to be unsung heroes now these", "57dynhVYwRk-00954-00238783-00239063": "unsung heroes include the many donors", "57dynhVYwRk-00955-00239064-00239263": "for books to readers who make it", "57dynhVYwRk-00956-00239264-00239471": "possible for us to get books into hands", "57dynhVYwRk-00957-00239471-00239663": "of people who would not be able to", "57dynhVYwRk-00958-00239664-00239846": "access them otherwise", "57dynhVYwRk-00959-00239848-00240882": "and with that now to business at", "57dynhVYwRk-00960-00240883-00241215": "hand we start with unveiling the two", "57dynhVYwRk-00961-00241216-00241423": "works of art created by jalak artists", "57dynhVYwRk-00962-00241423-00241663": "and residents elijah alvardo and rick", "57dynhVYwRk-00963-00241664-00241951": "and parrik", "57dynhVYwRk-00964-00241952-00242134": "the jalakart residency annually", "57dynhVYwRk-00965-00242135-00242319": "commissions a unique work of art by an", "57dynhVYwRk-00966-00242319-00242534": "artist of color to serve as a trophy for", "57dynhVYwRk-00967-00242535-00242671": "the prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00968-00242671-00243015": "in 2021 the residency was expanded to an", "57dynhVYwRk-00969-00243016-00243206": "annual commission to an illustrator of", "57dynhVYwRk-00970-00243207-00243310": "color", "57dynhVYwRk-00971-00243311-00243534": "to create an original work of work for", "57dynhVYwRk-00972-00243535-00243679": "the children's", "57dynhVYwRk-00973-00243680-00243919": "children's and young adult prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00974-00243919-00244127": "the aim of the residency as with the", "57dynhVYwRk-00975-00244128-00244367": "prize is to shine a light on artists of", "57dynhVYwRk-00976-00244367-00244494": "color", "57dynhVYwRk-00977-00244496-00244694": "in contemporary britain to recognize", "57dynhVYwRk-00978-00244696-00244871": "their creative output and celebrate", "57dynhVYwRk-00979-00244871-00244991": "their works", "57dynhVYwRk-00980-00244992-00245239": "the 2022 artists and residents are", "57dynhVYwRk-00981-00245240-00245519": "elijah varto who created the", "57dynhVYwRk-00982-00245519-00245710": "trophy for jalak prize and rick and", "57dynhVYwRk-00983-00245711-00245967": "parrik who is amongst us here today who", "57dynhVYwRk-00984-00245967-00246134": "created the trophy for the chalak", "57dynhVYwRk-00985-00246135-00246391": "children's and young adult prize", "57dynhVYwRk-00986-00246392-00246623": "elijah vardo's you will be able to see", "57dynhVYwRk-00987-00246623-00246910": "it my grandmother's hands draws on his", "57dynhVYwRk-00988-00246911-00247198": "romani heritage and celebrates the long", "57dynhVYwRk-00989-00247200-00247446": "tradition of oral storytelling", "57dynhVYwRk-00990-00247448-00247655": "he drew inspiration from stories that", "57dynhVYwRk-00991-00247656-00247903": "are etched and carried on our skins and", "57dynhVYwRk-00992-00247904-00248167": "specifically in his grandmother's hands", "57dynhVYwRk-00993-00248167-00248375": "which appear in the work which is a mix", "57dynhVYwRk-00994-00248376-00248663": "of wash pencil and ink on paper", "57dynhVYwRk-00995-00248664-00248863": "unfortunately elijah can't be here with", "57dynhVYwRk-00996-00248864-00249087": "us today although he assured us that", "57dynhVYwRk-00997-00249088-00249334": "he's watching this at home so give him a", "57dynhVYwRk-00998-00249335-00249452": "big chair", "57dynhVYwRk-00999-00249453-00250223": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01000-00250223-00250334": "and he's watching it with his", "57dynhVYwRk-01001-00250335-00250663": "grandmother so", "57dynhVYwRk-01002-00250664-00250927": "and rickon is here with us today so do", "57dynhVYwRk-01003-00250928-00251455": "give him a big shout out", "57dynhVYwRk-01004-00251456-00251615": "you want to come up for a ticks take a", "57dynhVYwRk-01005-00251616-00251742": "quick bow", "57dynhVYwRk-01006-00251744-00252251": "come on take a quick bow", "57dynhVYwRk-01007-00252252-00252823": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01008-00252823-00253030": "rickenbaric drew on his own heritage and", "57dynhVYwRk-01009-00253031-00253255": "love of illustrating animals to create a", "57dynhVYwRk-01010-00253256-00253510": "postage stamp of a lion from the gear", "57dynhVYwRk-01011-00253511-00253671": "forest in gujarat", "57dynhVYwRk-01012-00253671-00253879": "in india the lion symbolizes not only", "57dynhVYwRk-01013-00253880-00254191": "courage but also protection and safety", "57dynhVYwRk-01014-00254192-00254375": "ricken illustrates in an analogous", "57dynhVYwRk-01015-00254376-00254575": "fashion and the illustration is created", "57dynhVYwRk-01016-00254576-00254719": "using dip pen", "57dynhVYwRk-01017-00254719-00254879": "inking brush", "57dynhVYwRk-01018-00254880-00255175": "watercolors indian ink and a very steady", "57dynhVYwRk-01019-00255176-00255382": "hand", "57dynhVYwRk-01020-00255383-00255591": "there's also an easter egg which i'll", "57dynhVYwRk-01021-00255592-00255815": "let you know or guess", "57dynhVYwRk-01022-00255816-00256060": "afterwards thank you ricken", "57dynhVYwRk-01023-00256061-00256855": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01024-00256856-00257094": "and now to our short lists", "57dynhVYwRk-01025-00257096-00257310": "six books are selected for each prize", "57dynhVYwRk-01026-00257311-00257598": "and this year the lists showcase a wide", "57dynhVYwRk-01027-00257600-00257919": "range of genres biography graphic memoir", "57dynhVYwRk-01028-00257919-00258182": "narrative fiction poetry essays and", "57dynhVYwRk-01029-00258183-00258327": "picture books", "57dynhVYwRk-01030-00258328-00258623": "taking in identity grief mental illness", "57dynhVYwRk-01031-00258623-00259023": "heritage family gender class and race", "57dynhVYwRk-01032-00259023-00259294": "the titles explore a myriad of themes", "57dynhVYwRk-01033-00259296-00259567": "through invent inventive narratives", "57dynhVYwRk-01034-00259567-00259863": "the 2020 short list 22", "57dynhVYwRk-01035-00259864-00260127": "2022 i missed the last couple of years", "57dynhVYwRk-01036-00260128-00260310": "you can see that", "57dynhVYwRk-01037-00260311-00260639": "2022 jello prize shortlist includes", "57dynhVYwRk-01038-00260640-00261542": "consumed by a refurbished scepter", "57dynhVYwRk-01039-00261544-00261798": "a beautiful and unflinchingly honest", "57dynhVYwRk-01040-00261800-00262063": "memoir of a family and especially a", "57dynhVYwRk-01041-00262064-00262295": "sibling portrait that grows to encompass", "57dynhVYwRk-01042-00262296-00262606": "medical history art culture and so much", "57dynhVYwRk-01043-00262607-00262767": "more", "57dynhVYwRk-01044-00262768-00263455": "somebody loves you mona arshi and others", "57dynhVYwRk-01045-00263456-00263719": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01046-00263720-00263903": "an elegant debut novel by an", "57dynhVYwRk-01047-00263904-00264151": "award-winning poet which of offers", "57dynhVYwRk-01048-00264152-00264439": "chapters as little gems and reads like a", "57dynhVYwRk-01049-00264440-00264734": "prose poem as much as a layered nuanced", "57dynhVYwRk-01050-00264735-00264934": "novel", "57dynhVYwRk-01051-00264935-00265103": "like a tree walking", "57dynhVYwRk-01052-00265104-00266023": "by anthony varney capildo", "57dynhVYwRk-01053-00266024-00266334": "a poetry collection that is flawless", "57dynhVYwRk-01054-00266335-00266591": "and if you look must look for a flaw", "57dynhVYwRk-01055-00266592-00266903": "maybe a little too long but that's it", "57dynhVYwRk-01056-00266904-00267110": "and it leaves the reader gasping for", "57dynhVYwRk-01057-00267111-00267367": "breath and with its ex with gasping for", "57dynhVYwRk-01058-00267368-00267543": "breath with its exquisite language and", "57dynhVYwRk-01059-00267544-00267782": "profundity of ideas", "57dynhVYwRk-01060-00267783-00267919": "keeping the house", "57dynhVYwRk-01061-00267920-00268743": "t-shirts", "57dynhVYwRk-01062-00268744-00269063": "he's regions under the story a brilliant", "57dynhVYwRk-01063-00269064-00269343": "constantly surprising debut novel that", "57dynhVYwRk-01064-00269344-00269575": "is confident in how it plays with form", "57dynhVYwRk-01065-00269576-00269687": "and style", "57dynhVYwRk-01066-00269688-00269903": "and it's at once engrossing and", "57dynhVYwRk-01067-00269904-00270055": "challenging", "57dynhVYwRk-01068-00270056-00271310": "the roles we play saba khan", "57dynhVYwRk-01069-00271311-00271510": "a graphic memoir with images that are", "57dynhVYwRk-01070-00271511-00271727": "absolutely stupendous and a fine balance", "57dynhVYwRk-01071-00271728-00271910": "of text and imagery this is a", "57dynhVYwRk-01072-00271911-00272071": "psychological this is psychologically", "57dynhVYwRk-01073-00272072-00272367": "astute powerful and haunting", "57dynhVYwRk-01074-00272368-00272679": "and finally things i have withheld kai", "57dynhVYwRk-01075-00272680-00272910": "miller canon gate books which is an", "57dynhVYwRk-01076-00272911-00273078": "accomplishment", "57dynhVYwRk-01077-00273079-00273782": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01078-00273783-00273982": "i'm hoping kai is watching from across", "57dynhVYwRk-01079-00273983-00274223": "the pond because that's where he is", "57dynhVYwRk-01080-00274224-00274463": "um accomplished collection of essays by", "57dynhVYwRk-01081-00274464-00274734": "a fearless writer this is extraordinary", "57dynhVYwRk-01082-00274735-00274975": "writing unflinching and uncompromising", "57dynhVYwRk-01083-00274976-00275215": "in its ideas and stunning in its", "57dynhVYwRk-01084-00275216-00275327": "language", "57dynhVYwRk-01085-00275328-00275495": "now you think i'm going to announce the", "57dynhVYwRk-01086-00275496-00275775": "winner right now but no", "57dynhVYwRk-01087-00275776-00275967": "we we believe in equity so we're going", "57dynhVYwRk-01088-00275968-00276143": "to go down the shortlist for both her", "57dynhVYwRk-01089-00276144-00276287": "awards", "57dynhVYwRk-01090-00276288-00276606": "the 2022 children's and young adult", "57dynhVYwRk-01091-00276607-00276758": "shortlist", "57dynhVYwRk-01092-00276759-00276958": "ace of spades", "57dynhVYwRk-01093-00276959-00278199": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01094-00278200-00278423": "a fantastic debut with the black queer", "57dynhVYwRk-01095-00278424-00278710": "character at its center unapologetic and", "57dynhVYwRk-01096-00278711-00278927": "well written and yet incredibly", "57dynhVYwRk-01097-00278928-00279047": "accessible", "57dynhVYwRk-01098-00279048-00279310": "which the judges agreed is incredibly", "57dynhVYwRk-01099-00279311-00279479": "tough to pull off", "57dynhVYwRk-01100-00279480-00279719": "we're going to find the monster mallory", "57dynhVYwRk-01101-00279720-00280655": "blackman let's trade", "57dynhVYwRk-01102-00280656-00281527": "illustrated by dapo adiola huffin", "57dynhVYwRk-01103-00281528-00281782": "an instantly lovable picture book with", "57dynhVYwRk-01104-00281783-00282087": "mallory's magical words set to dappers", "57dynhVYwRk-01105-00282088-00282391": "enchanting witty warm illustrations", "57dynhVYwRk-01106-00282392-00282695": "this is a book that will be instantly", "57dynhVYwRk-01107-00282696-00282782": "loved", "57dynhVYwRk-01108-00282783-00282882": "and then", "57dynhVYwRk-01109-00282883-00283206": "beloved musical truth a musical history", "57dynhVYwRk-01110-00283207-00283495": "of modern black britain in 28 songs", "57dynhVYwRk-01111-00283496-00284575": "jeffrey bocce illustrated by", "57dynhVYwRk-01112-00284576-00284815": "faber and faber a social history through", "57dynhVYwRk-01113-00284816-00285030": "the lens of music which provides a great", "57dynhVYwRk-01114-00285031-00285254": "entry to understanding and teaching", "57dynhVYwRk-01115-00285255-00285543": "black history to children and in schools", "57dynhVYwRk-01116-00285544-00285927": "jeffrey can't be here he said hey", "57dynhVYwRk-01117-00285928-00286382": "really now i know", "57dynhVYwRk-01118-00286383-00286652": "danny chung does not do maths", "57dynhVYwRk-01119-00286653-00287630": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01120-00287631-00287830": "piccadilly press a warm-hearted", "57dynhVYwRk-01121-00287831-00288047": "hilarious middle-grade story that does", "57dynhVYwRk-01122-00288048-00288287": "not shy away from the complexity of the", "57dynhVYwRk-01123-00288288-00288582": "diasporic experience and handles them", "57dynhVYwRk-01124-00288583-00288815": "deftly and generously", "57dynhVYwRk-01125-00288816-00289071": "the sound of everything rebecca henry", "57dynhVYwRk-01126-00289072-00289951": "everything with", "57dynhVYwRk-01127-00289952-00290047": "a words", "57dynhVYwRk-01128-00290048-00290247": "debut by a talented young writer with a", "57dynhVYwRk-01129-00290248-00290471": "unique brave voice and the ability to", "57dynhVYwRk-01130-00290472-00290806": "craft a nuanced complex narrative", "57dynhVYwRk-01131-00290807-00291079": "and finally the crossing", "57dynhVYwRk-01132-00291080-00291305": "my cheat man", "57dynhVYwRk-01133-00291306-00292295": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01134-00292296-00292487": "a powerful novel and verse that", "57dynhVYwRk-01135-00292488-00292734": "confronts big themes of displacement and", "57dynhVYwRk-01136-00292735-00293071": "grief and does so with ease subtlety and", "57dynhVYwRk-01137-00293072-00293327": "breathtaking turns of phrase", "57dynhVYwRk-01138-00293328-00293551": "these are all extraordinary books and", "57dynhVYwRk-01139-00293552-00293854": "are judges agonized over their choices", "57dynhVYwRk-01140-00293855-00294079": "as a former judge noted a couple of", "57dynhVYwRk-01141-00294080-00294327": "years ago picking a long list and then a", "57dynhVYwRk-01142-00294328-00294534": "short list and finally a winner of the", "57dynhVYwRk-01143-00294535-00294758": "jollof prize is an exercise and", "57dynhVYwRk-01144-00294759-00294887": "heartbreak", "57dynhVYwRk-01145-00294888-00295134": "as so many books are loved and beloved", "57dynhVYwRk-01146-00295135-00295399": "and must be set aside as they can only", "57dynhVYwRk-01147-00295400-00295679": "be one winner for each award", "57dynhVYwRk-01148-00295680-00295910": "yet let there be no doubt the gelat", "57dynhVYwRk-01149-00295911-00296158": "prize shortlists are testaments to the", "57dynhVYwRk-01150-00296159-00296454": "extraordinary range and quality of work", "57dynhVYwRk-01151-00296455-00296654": "being produced by writers of color in", "57dynhVYwRk-01152-00296655-00296944": "contemporary britain", "57dynhVYwRk-01153-00296945-00297815": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01154-00297816-00297991": "this year's", "57dynhVYwRk-01155-00297992-00298167": "this year's shortlists are particularly", "57dynhVYwRk-01156-00298168-00298358": "striking for the bold experiments and", "57dynhVYwRk-01157-00298359-00298630": "form and genre courageous explorations", "57dynhVYwRk-01158-00298631-00298830": "of themes and ideas and the incredible", "57dynhVYwRk-01159-00298831-00298991": "variety of creative practice", "57dynhVYwRk-01160-00298992-00299223": "demonstrated by our shortlisties these", "57dynhVYwRk-01161-00299224-00299479": "are books to be read and re-read to be", "57dynhVYwRk-01162-00299480-00299679": "remembered and cherished far into the", "57dynhVYwRk-01163-00299680-00299934": "future and now without further ado let's", "57dynhVYwRk-01164-00299935-00300191": "move on to announcing our two winners so", "57dynhVYwRk-01165-00300192-00300310": "first", "57dynhVYwRk-01166-00300311-00300510": "the jalak children's and young adult", "57dynhVYwRk-01167-00300511-00300815": "prize our judges said of the winner", "57dynhVYwRk-01168-00300816-00301039": "quote i love this book for the warm", "57dynhVYwRk-01169-00301040-00301334": "heartedness humor and the nuanced way it", "57dynhVYwRk-01170-00301335-00301495": "approaches the challenges of being a", "57dynhVYwRk-01171-00301496-00301751": "child negotiating multiple identities", "57dynhVYwRk-01172-00301752-00302015": "patrice lawrence", "57dynhVYwRk-01173-00302016-00302303": "this is a slow burn of a book that takes", "57dynhVYwRk-01174-00302304-00302558": "a common stereotype and turns it on its", "57dynhVYwRk-01175-00302559-00302639": "head", "57dynhVYwRk-01176-00302640-00302839": "it's one of the books that crept onto my", "57dynhVYwRk-01177-00302840-00303071": "long list and made me love it more with", "57dynhVYwRk-01178-00303072-00303463": "each new reading knee aique parks", "57dynhVYwRk-01179-00303464-00303671": "when i first read it i thought it would", "57dynhVYwRk-01180-00303672-00303895": "make a great class read for school", "57dynhVYwRk-01181-00303896-00304039": "children everywhere", "57dynhVYwRk-01182-00304040-00304287": "a book that can be enjoyed together and", "57dynhVYwRk-01183-00304288-00304543": "then can lead to class discussions", "57dynhVYwRk-01184-00304544-00304767": "sophia ahmed our judges", "57dynhVYwRk-01185-00304768-00305039": "unanimously selected a winner and that", "57dynhVYwRk-01186-00305040-00305347": "is macy chan", "57dynhVYwRk-01187-00305348-00307006": "[Music]", "57dynhVYwRk-01188-00307007-00308663": "oh", "57dynhVYwRk-01189-00308664-00308806": "macy chan", "57dynhVYwRk-01190-00308807-00309047": "danny chung does not do maths piccadilly", "57dynhVYwRk-01191-00309048-00309263": "press", "57dynhVYwRk-01192-00309264-00310895": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01193-00310896-00311279": "i don't think i can speak", "57dynhVYwRk-01194-00311280-00311471": "i want to thank the giant prize and the", "57dynhVYwRk-01195-00311472-00311703": "judges for choosing danny chung i didn't", "57dynhVYwRk-01196-00311704-00311903": "think i was going to win against", "57dynhVYwRk-01197-00311904-00312071": "such juggernauts of children's", "57dynhVYwRk-01198-00312072-00312230": "literature", "57dynhVYwRk-01199-00312231-00312487": "um i'm so happy i want to say thanks to", "57dynhVYwRk-01200-00312488-00312687": "my publishers uh piccadilly press who", "57dynhVYwRk-01201-00312688-00312823": "are here", "57dynhVYwRk-01202-00312824-00313175": "my agent chloe from madeleine milburn", "57dynhVYwRk-01203-00313176-00313343": "my family who should be watching from", "57dynhVYwRk-01204-00313344-00313582": "home uh alma and santi and my husband", "57dynhVYwRk-01205-00313583-00313767": "jose", "57dynhVYwRk-01206-00313768-00313982": "i have to thank lila rasheed from", "57dynhVYwRk-01207-00313983-00314263": "megaphone who without lyla rasheed and", "57dynhVYwRk-01208-00314264-00314510": "megaphone i wouldn't be here so", "57dynhVYwRk-01209-00314511-00314687": "thank you lila", "57dynhVYwRk-01210-00314688-00314951": "um thanks to writing west midlands and", "57dynhVYwRk-01211-00314952-00315206": "kit duval and all of those people that", "57dynhVYwRk-01212-00315207-00315479": "have supported me it's been a long road", "57dynhVYwRk-01213-00315480-00315639": "i might be a debut but i've been writing", "57dynhVYwRk-01214-00315640-00315847": "for a long time", "57dynhVYwRk-01215-00315848-00316015": "thanks to my friend renee and antoine", "57dynhVYwRk-01216-00316016-00316758": "for coming today to support me", "57dynhVYwRk-01217-00316759-00316967": "i was saying to my friend oh you know", "57dynhVYwRk-01218-00316968-00317127": "remember like two decades ago when i", "57dynhVYwRk-01219-00317128-00317295": "told you i wanted to be a writer and i'm", "57dynhVYwRk-01220-00317296-00317471": "like", "57dynhVYwRk-01221-00317472-00317695": "i've done it", "57dynhVYwRk-01222-00317696-00318012": "uh so thank you very much thanks senior", "57dynhVYwRk-01223-00318013-00320191": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01224-00320192-00320327": "and now", "57dynhVYwRk-01225-00320328-00320654": "the winner of the chaluk prize 2022.", "57dynhVYwRk-01226-00320655-00320927": "our judges said gone are the days of", "57dynhVYwRk-01227-00320928-00321175": "limiting what can be exciting striking", "57dynhVYwRk-01228-00321176-00321430": "and deeply profound literature this is", "57dynhVYwRk-01229-00321431-00321671": "an impeccable storyteller who commands", "57dynhVYwRk-01230-00321672-00321879": "the page in every way", "57dynhVYwRk-01231-00321880-00322087": "shimane sulayman", "57dynhVYwRk-01232-00322088-00322334": "mary jean chan said i find this book to", "57dynhVYwRk-01233-00322335-00322510": "be a powerful moving and", "57dynhVYwRk-01234-00322511-00322751": "thought-provoking story which shimmers", "57dynhVYwRk-01235-00322752-00323063": "with hard hard-earned wisdom and wonder", "57dynhVYwRk-01236-00323064-00323479": "one that is beautifully written", "57dynhVYwRk-01237-00323480-00323703": "stephen thompson added there's this this", "57dynhVYwRk-01238-00323704-00323934": "is sumptuous book with the timeless", "57dynhVYwRk-01239-00323935-00324151": "quality to the story as it moves between", "57dynhVYwRk-01240-00324152-00324367": "time and place", "57dynhVYwRk-01241-00324368-00324762": "our winner for 2022 is sabathan", "57dynhVYwRk-01242-00324763-00327015": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01243-00327016-00328575": "yes", "57dynhVYwRk-01244-00328576-00328695": "and yes", "57dynhVYwRk-01245-00328696-00328934": "the roles we play by myriad is a graphic", "57dynhVYwRk-01246-00328935-00329191": "novel which is a first not only on our", "57dynhVYwRk-01247-00329192-00329358": "short list but i think as a winner for", "57dynhVYwRk-01248-00329359-00329543": "our for the dollar prize so", "57dynhVYwRk-01249-00329544-00329727": "over to you sabbah", "57dynhVYwRk-01250-00329728-00330006": "thank you sonny um", "57dynhVYwRk-01251-00330007-00330239": "thank you judges um", "57dynhVYwRk-01252-00330240-00330367": "i think i'm in", "57dynhVYwRk-01253-00330368-00330630": "a bit of shock really", "57dynhVYwRk-01254-00330631-00330910": "i think it's going to take a while to", "57dynhVYwRk-01255-00330911-00331127": "acknowledge in my soul that this is", "57dynhVYwRk-01256-00331128-00331343": "happening", "57dynhVYwRk-01257-00331344-00331671": "and i think as i'm talking it's it's", "57dynhVYwRk-01258-00331672-00331830": "yeah it's um", "57dynhVYwRk-01259-00331831-00332006": "yeah i think it's gonna take me a while", "57dynhVYwRk-01260-00332007-00332199": "um", "57dynhVYwRk-01261-00332200-00332287": "uh", "57dynhVYwRk-01262-00332288-00332391": "i guess", "57dynhVYwRk-01263-00332392-00332710": "um", "57dynhVYwRk-01264-00332711-00332943": "my family will be uh", "57dynhVYwRk-01265-00332944-00333175": "listening uh maybe not live but a bit", "57dynhVYwRk-01266-00333176-00333463": "later perhaps um", "57dynhVYwRk-01267-00333464-00333615": "but", "57dynhVYwRk-01268-00333616-00333823": "um yeah i just i can't believe that i'm", "57dynhVYwRk-01269-00333824-00334151": "here and i'm accepting", "57dynhVYwRk-01270-00334152-00334463": "this award uh", "57dynhVYwRk-01271-00334464-00334687": "thank you to the people that are in this", "57dynhVYwRk-01272-00334688-00334927": "room that are supporting me my partner", "57dynhVYwRk-01273-00334928-00335230": "who's there in the terracotta shirt mark", "57dynhVYwRk-01274-00335231-00335503": "boncheck who's been by my side", "57dynhVYwRk-01275-00335504-00335663": "throughout this whole journey", "57dynhVYwRk-01276-00335664-00335943": "um corinne pullman from myriad editions", "57dynhVYwRk-01277-00335944-00336023": "who", "57dynhVYwRk-01278-00336024-00336319": "who really um let me just do what i", "57dynhVYwRk-01279-00336320-00336623": "wanted to do and um didn't didn't put", "57dynhVYwRk-01280-00336624-00336967": "her foot in at all at any point", "57dynhVYwRk-01281-00336968-00337263": "which was great um emma from edpr who", "57dynhVYwRk-01282-00337264-00337454": "also supported as well and really pushed", "57dynhVYwRk-01283-00337455-00337623": "it", "57dynhVYwRk-01284-00337624-00337799": "and then my mum", "57dynhVYwRk-01285-00337800-00337919": "just", "57dynhVYwRk-01286-00337920-00338151": "just being", "57dynhVYwRk-01287-00338152-00338454": "really open with her stories um and", "57dynhVYwRk-01288-00338455-00338687": "trusting me with", "57dynhVYwRk-01289-00338688-00338943": "with her memories and knowing that i", "57dynhVYwRk-01290-00338944-00339134": "would honor her in the way that i did", "57dynhVYwRk-01291-00339135-00339391": "with my book", "57dynhVYwRk-01292-00339392-00339854": "and also my inner child as well i think", "57dynhVYwRk-01293-00339855-00340087": "we're here and we're doing this", "57dynhVYwRk-01294-00340088-00340247": "it's pretty incredible", "57dynhVYwRk-01295-00340248-00341334": "um so thank you thank you guys", "57dynhVYwRk-01296-00341335-00343063": "[Applause]", "57dynhVYwRk-01297-00343064-00343239": "finally as we bring", "57dynhVYwRk-01298-00343240-00343439": "the official part of the evening to the", "57dynhVYwRk-01299-00343440-00343758": "to a close we remind you that beyond our", "57dynhVYwRk-01300-00343759-00344047": "annual long and short lists and winners", "57dynhVYwRk-01301-00344048-00344303": "every book submitted to the giant prize", "57dynhVYwRk-01302-00344304-00344495": "is an act of disruption", "57dynhVYwRk-01303-00344496-00344878": "defiance challenge and subversion", "57dynhVYwRk-01304-00344879-00345151": "these are all part of a movement", "57dynhVYwRk-01305-00345152-00345382": "to decolonize our literatures our", "57dynhVYwRk-01306-00345383-00345527": "imaginations", "57dynhVYwRk-01307-00345528-00345854": "cultures and most of all ourselves", "57dynhVYwRk-01308-00345855-00346063": "and for that we are grateful to every", "57dynhVYwRk-01309-00346064-00346382": "writer who is working away at creating", "57dynhVYwRk-01310-00346383-00346487": "stories", "57dynhVYwRk-01311-00346488-00346734": "that we need to hear", "57dynhVYwRk-01312-00346735-00346991": "so a huge thank you to all of you for", "57dynhVYwRk-01313-00346992-00347223": "being here for celebrating with us", "57dynhVYwRk-01314-00347224-00347454": "those here the party starts now", "57dynhVYwRk-01315-00347455-00347606": "so do hang out", "57dynhVYwRk-01316-00347607-00347687": "uh", "57dynhVYwRk-01317-00347688-00347943": "those at home thank you so much for", "57dynhVYwRk-01318-00347944-00348054": "joining us", "57dynhVYwRk-01319-00348055-00349010": "and with that thank you and good night", "57dynhVYwRk-01320-00349011-00350903": "[Music]", "57dynhVYwRk-01321-00350904-00351111": "you"}}]