[{"audio_id": "BGIZJl39dKu", "text": {"BGIZJl39dKu-00000-00000010-00000366": "the United States Census Bureau USC be", "BGIZJl39dKu-00001-00000367-00000586": "officially the Bureau of the census as", "BGIZJl39dKu-00002-00000587-00000907": "defined in title 13 USC Section 11 is a", "BGIZJl39dKu-00003-00000908-00001128": "principal agency of the US Federal", "BGIZJl39dKu-00004-00001129-00001332": "Statistical system responsible for", "BGIZJl39dKu-00005-00001333-00001536": "producing data about the American people", "BGIZJl39dKu-00006-00001537-00001842": "and economy the Census Bureau is part of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00007-00001843-00002034": "the US Department of Commerce and its", "BGIZJl39dKu-00008-00002035-00002221": "director is appointed by the President", "BGIZJl39dKu-00009-00002222-00002530": "of the United States the Census Bureau's", "BGIZJl39dKu-00010-00002531-00002740": "primary mission is conducting the u.s.", "BGIZJl39dKu-00011-00002741-00002965": "census every 10 years which allocates", "BGIZJl39dKu-00012-00002966-00003108": "the seats of the US House of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00013-00003109-00003301": "Representatives to the States based on", "BGIZJl39dKu-00014-00003302-00003390": "their population", "BGIZJl39dKu-00015-00003392-00003622": "the bureau's various censuses and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00016-00003622-00003883": "surveys help allocate over 400 billion", "BGIZJl39dKu-00017-00003884-00004117": "dollars in federal funds every year and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00018-00004118-00004306": "it helps States local communities and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00019-00004307-00004591": "businesses make informed decisions the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00020-00004592-00004789": "information provided by the census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00021-00004790-00005002": "informs decisions on where to build and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00022-00005003-00005175": "maintain schools hospitals", "BGIZJl39dKu-00023-00005176-00005413": "transportation infrastructure and police", "BGIZJl39dKu-00024-00005414-00005620": "and fire departments in addition to the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00025-00005621-00005818": "decennial census the Census Bureau", "BGIZJl39dKu-00026-00005819-00006010": "continually conducts dozens of other", "BGIZJl39dKu-00027-00006011-00006211": "censuses and surveys including the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00028-00006212-00006418": "American Community Survey the u.s.", "BGIZJl39dKu-00029-00006419-00006598": "economic census and the current", "BGIZJl39dKu-00030-00006598-00006904": "population survey furthermore economic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00031-00006905-00007111": "and foreign trade indicators released by", "BGIZJl39dKu-00032-00007112-00007303": "the federal government typically contain", "BGIZJl39dKu-00033-00007304-00007798": "data produced by the Census Bureau", "BGIZJl39dKu-00034-00007798-00008332": "topic legal mandate", "BGIZJl39dKu-00035-00008333-00008533": "the article 1 of the United States", "BGIZJl39dKu-00036-00008534-00008809": "Constitution section 2 directs the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00037-00008810-00009025": "population be enumerated at least once", "BGIZJl39dKu-00038-00009026-00009235": "every 10 years in the resulting counts", "BGIZJl39dKu-00039-00009236-00009400": "used to set the number of members from", "BGIZJl39dKu-00040-00009401-00009517": "each state in the House of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00041-00009518-00009739": "Representatives and by extension in the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00042-00009740-00009853": "electoral college", "BGIZJl39dKu-00043-00009854-00010111": "the Census Bureau now conducts a full", "BGIZJl39dKu-00044-00010112-00010345": "population count every 10 years in years", "BGIZJl39dKu-00045-00010346-00010537": "ending with a 0 and uses the term", "BGIZJl39dKu-00046-00010538-00010834": "decennial to describe the operation", "BGIZJl39dKu-00047-00010835-00011098": "between censuses the Census Bureau makes", "BGIZJl39dKu-00048-00011099-00011329": "population estimates and projections in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00049-00011330-00011566": "addition census data directly affects", "BGIZJl39dKu-00050-00011567-00011788": "how more than 400 billion dollars per", "BGIZJl39dKu-00051-00011789-00011980": "year in federal and state funding is", "BGIZJl39dKu-00052-00011981-00012139": "allocated to communities for", "BGIZJl39dKu-00053-00012140-00012313": "neighborhood improvements public health", "BGIZJl39dKu-00054-00012314-00012634": "education transportation and more the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00055-00012635-00012810": "Census Bureau is mandated with", "BGIZJl39dKu-00056-00012811-00012979": "fulfilling these obligations the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00057-00012980-00013141": "collecting of statistics about the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00058-00013141-00013459": "nation its people and economy the Census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00059-00013460-00013687": "Bureau's legal authority is codified in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00060-00013688-00014022": "title 13 of the United States Code the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00061-00014024-00014260": "Census Bureau also conducts surveys on", "BGIZJl39dKu-00062-00014261-00014466": "behalf of various federal government and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00063-00014468-00014683": "local government agencies on topics such", "BGIZJl39dKu-00064-00014684-00014929": "as employment crime health consumer", "BGIZJl39dKu-00065-00014930-00015193": "expenditures and housing within the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00066-00015194-00015433": "Bureau these are known as demographic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00067-00015434-00015697": "surveys and are conducted perpetually", "BGIZJl39dKu-00068-00015697-00015894": "between and during the seniya ten-year", "BGIZJl39dKu-00069-00015895-00016200": "population counts the Census Bureau also", "BGIZJl39dKu-00070-00016201-00016393": "conducts economic surveys of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00071-00016394-00016644": "manufacturing retail service and other", "BGIZJl39dKu-00072-00016645-00016813": "establishments and of domestic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00073-00016814-00017230": "governments between 1790 and 1840 the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00074-00017231-00017413": "census was taken by marshals of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00075-00017414-00017689": "judicial districts the census Act of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00076-00017690-00017950": "1840 established a central office which", "BGIZJl39dKu-00077-00017951-00018135": "became known as the census office", "BGIZJl39dKu-00078-00018136-00018412": "several acts followed that revised and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00079-00018413-00018649": "authorized new censuses typically at the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00080-00018650-00019015": "ten-year intervals in 1902 the temporary", "BGIZJl39dKu-00081-00019016-00019189": "census office was moved under the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00082-00019190-00019456": "Department of Interior and in 1903 it", "BGIZJl39dKu-00083-00019457-00019644": "was renamed the Census Bureau under the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00084-00019645-00019909": "new Department of Commerce and labor the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00085-00019910-00020110": "department was intended to consolidate", "BGIZJl39dKu-00086-00020111-00020335": "overlapping Statistical agencies but", "BGIZJl39dKu-00087-00020336-00020530": "Census Bureau officials were hindered by", "BGIZJl39dKu-00088-00020531-00020674": "their subordinate role in the department", "BGIZJl39dKu-00089-00020675-00020953": "and act in 1920 changed the date and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00090-00020954-00021187": "authorized manufacturing censuses every", "BGIZJl39dKu-00091-00021188-00021412": "two years in agriculture censuses every", "BGIZJl39dKu-00092-00021413-00021721": "10 years in 1929 a bill", "BGIZJl39dKu-00093-00021722-00021871": "was passed mandating the House of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00094-00021872-00022069": "Representatives be reapportioned based", "BGIZJl39dKu-00095-00022070-00022386": "on the results of the 1930 census in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00096-00022387-00022675": "1954 various acts were codified into", "BGIZJl39dKu-00097-00022676-00022933": "title 13 of the u.s. code by law the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00098-00022934-00023143": "Census Bureau must count everyone and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00099-00023144-00023415": "submit state population totals to the US", "BGIZJl39dKu-00100-00023416-00023704": "president by December 31st of any year", "BGIZJl39dKu-00101-00023705-00024001": "ending in a zero States within the Union", "BGIZJl39dKu-00102-00024002-00024163": "received the results in the spring of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00103-00024164-00024544": "the following year", "BGIZJl39dKu-00104-00024545-00025075": "topic data collection", "BGIZJl39dKu-00105-00025076-00025656": "topic census regions and divisions", "BGIZJl39dKu-00106-00025657-00025902": "the United States Census Bureau defines", "BGIZJl39dKu-00107-00025903-00026130": "for statistical regions with nine", "BGIZJl39dKu-00108-00026131-00026424": "divisions the Census Bureau regions are", "BGIZJl39dKu-00109-00026425-00026871": "widely used dot for data collection and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00110-00026872-00026958": "analysis", "BGIZJl39dKu-00111-00026959-00027208": "the Census Bureau definition is", "BGIZJl39dKu-00112-00027208-00027424": "pervasive regional divisions used by the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00113-00027425-00027760": "United States Census Bureau region one", "BGIZJl39dKu-00114-00027761-00028080": "Northeast Division one New England", "BGIZJl39dKu-00115-00028081-00028333": "Connecticut Maine Massachusetts New", "BGIZJl39dKu-00116-00028333-00028574": "Hampshire Rhode Island and Vermont", "BGIZJl39dKu-00117-00028575-00028890": "Division two mid-atlantic New Jersey New", "BGIZJl39dKu-00118-00028891-00029254": "York and Pennsylvania Region two Midwest", "BGIZJl39dKu-00119-00029255-00029560": "prior to June 1984 the Midwest region", "BGIZJl39dKu-00120-00029561-00029715": "was designated as the north-central", "BGIZJl39dKu-00121-00029716-00029785": "region", "BGIZJl39dKu-00122-00029786-00029961": "Division three east north central", "BGIZJl39dKu-00123-00029962-00030264": "Illinois Indiana Michigan Ohio and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00124-00030265-00030555": "Wisconsin Division four West", "BGIZJl39dKu-00125-00030556-00030783": "north-central Iowa Kansas Minnesota", "BGIZJl39dKu-00126-00030783-00031123": "Missouri Nebraska North Dakota and South", "BGIZJl39dKu-00127-00031124-00031576": "Dakota Region three South Division five", "BGIZJl39dKu-00128-00031577-00031833": "South Atlantic Delaware Florida Georgia", "BGIZJl39dKu-00129-00031833-00032118": "Maryland North Carolina South Carolina", "BGIZJl39dKu-00130-00032119-00032474": "Virginia Washington DC and West Virginia", "BGIZJl39dKu-00131-00032475-00032830": "Division six east south central Alabama", "BGIZJl39dKu-00132-00032831-00033105": "Kentucky Mississippi and Tennessee", "BGIZJl39dKu-00133-00033106-00033370": "Division seven West South Central", "BGIZJl39dKu-00134-00033371-00033695": "Arkansas Louisiana Oklahoma and Texas", "BGIZJl39dKu-00135-00033696-00034057": "region four West Division eighth", "BGIZJl39dKu-00136-00034058-00034126": "Mountain", "BGIZJl39dKu-00137-00034127-00034443": "Arizona Colorado Idaho Montana Nevada", "BGIZJl39dKu-00138-00034444-00034839": "New Mexico Utah and Wyoming division", "BGIZJl39dKu-00139-00034840-00035121": "nine Pacific Alaska California Hawaii", "BGIZJl39dKu-00140-00035122-00035636": "Oregon and Washington", "BGIZJl39dKu-00141-00035637-00036183": "topic uses of census data", "BGIZJl39dKu-00142-00036184-00036426": "many federal state local and tribal", "BGIZJl39dKu-00143-00036427-00036774": "governments use census data to decide", "BGIZJl39dKu-00144-00036775-00036962": "the location of new housing and public", "BGIZJl39dKu-00145-00036963-00037275": "facilities examine the demographic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00146-00037276-00037479": "characteristics of communities States", "BGIZJl39dKu-00147-00037480-00037793": "and the US a planned transportation", "BGIZJl39dKu-00148-00037794-00038118": "systems and roadways determine quotas in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00149-00038119-00038337": "creation of police and fire precincts", "BGIZJl39dKu-00150-00038338-00038676": "and create localized areas for elections", "BGIZJl39dKu-00151-00038677-00039102": "schools utilities etc gathers population", "BGIZJl39dKu-00152-00039103-00039583": "information every ten years", "BGIZJl39dKu-00153-00039584-00040062": "topic data stewardship", "BGIZJl39dKu-00154-00040063-00040305": "the United States Census Bureau is", "BGIZJl39dKu-00155-00040306-00040483": "committed to confidentiality and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00156-00040484-00040665": "guarantees non-disclosure of any", "BGIZJl39dKu-00157-00040666-00040812": "addresses or personal information", "BGIZJl39dKu-00158-00040813-00041111": "related to individuals or establishments", "BGIZJl39dKu-00159-00041112-00041421": "title 13 of the u.s. code establishes", "BGIZJl39dKu-00160-00041422-00041592": "penalties for the disclosure of this", "BGIZJl39dKu-00161-00041593-00041889": "information all census employees must", "BGIZJl39dKu-00162-00041890-00042079": "sign an affidavit of non-disclosure", "BGIZJl39dKu-00163-00042080-00042390": "prior to employment the bureau cannot", "BGIZJl39dKu-00164-00042391-00042630": "share responses addresses or personal", "BGIZJl39dKu-00165-00042631-00042846": "information with anyone including United", "BGIZJl39dKu-00166-00042847-00043023": "States or foreign government and law", "BGIZJl39dKu-00167-00043024-00043285": "enforcement agencies such as the IRS or", "BGIZJl39dKu-00168-00043286-00043561": "the FBI or Interpol providing quality", "BGIZJl39dKu-00169-00043562-00043836": "data for public good while respecting", "BGIZJl39dKu-00170-00043837-00044107": "individual privacy and at the same time", "BGIZJl39dKu-00171-00044108-00044458": "protecting confidentiality is the Census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00172-00044459-00044839": "Bureau's core responsibility keeping the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00173-00044840-00045027": "public's trust is critical to the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00174-00045028-00045229": "censuses ability to carry out the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00175-00045230-00045411": "mission as the leading source of quality", "BGIZJl39dKu-00176-00045412-00045642": "data about the nation's people and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00177-00045643-00046017": "economy only after 72 years does the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00178-00046018-00046195": "information collected become available", "BGIZJl39dKu-00179-00046196-00046401": "to other agencies or the general public", "BGIZJl39dKu-00180-00046402-00046576": "despite these guarantees of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00181-00046577-00046812": "confidentiality the Census Bureau has", "BGIZJl39dKu-00182-00046813-00046986": "some history of disclosures to other", "BGIZJl39dKu-00183-00046987-00047358": "government agencies in 1918 the Census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00184-00047359-00047536": "Bureau released individual information", "BGIZJl39dKu-00185-00047537-00047767": "regarding several hundred young men to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00186-00047768-00047949": "the Justice Department and Selective", "BGIZJl39dKu-00187-00047950-00048102": "Service System for the purpose of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00188-00048103-00048385": "prosecutions for draft evasion during", "BGIZJl39dKu-00189-00048386-00048630": "World War two the United States Census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00190-00048631-00048789": "Bureau assisted the government's", "BGIZJl39dKu-00191-00048790-00049008": "Japanese American internment efforts by", "BGIZJl39dKu-00192-00049009-00049182": "providing confidential neighborhood", "BGIZJl39dKu-00193-00049183-00049464": "information on japanese-americans the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00194-00049465-00049695": "bureau's role was denied for decades but", "BGIZJl39dKu-00195-00049696-00050001": "was finally proven in 2007 United States", "BGIZJl39dKu-00196-00050002-00050179": "census data are valuable for the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00197-00050180-00050392": "country's political parties Democrats", "BGIZJl39dKu-00198-00050393-00050599": "and Republicans are highly interested in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00199-00050600-00050773": "knowing accurate number of persons in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00200-00050774-00050992": "their respective districts these", "BGIZJl39dKu-00201-00050993-00051201": "insights are often linked to financial", "BGIZJl39dKu-00202-00051202-00051412": "and economic strategies that are central", "BGIZJl39dKu-00203-00051413-00051630": "to federal state and city investments", "BGIZJl39dKu-00204-00051632-00051851": "for locations of particular populations", "BGIZJl39dKu-00205-00051852-00052092": "such apportionments are designed to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00206-00052094-00052269": "distribute political power across", "BGIZJl39dKu-00207-00052270-00052488": "neutral spatial allocations however", "BGIZJl39dKu-00208-00052489-00052707": "because so much is at stake the census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00209-00052708-00052900": "also runs the risk of being politicized", "BGIZJl39dKu-00210-00052901-00053134": "such political tensions highlight the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00211-00053135-00053290": "complexity of identity and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00212-00053291-00053425": "classification some", "BGIZJl39dKu-00213-00053426-00053596": "argue that unclear results from the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00214-00053597-00053817": "population data is due to distortions", "BGIZJl39dKu-00215-00053819-00054022": "brought about by political pressures one", "BGIZJl39dKu-00216-00054023-00054204": "frequently used example includes", "BGIZJl39dKu-00217-00054205-00054409": "ambiguous ethnic counts which often", "BGIZJl39dKu-00218-00054410-00054622": "involves under enumeration and or under", "BGIZJl39dKu-00219-00054623-00054922": "counting of minority populations ideas", "BGIZJl39dKu-00220-00054923-00055165": "about race ethnicity and identity have", "BGIZJl39dKu-00221-00055166-00055372": "also evolved in the United States and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00222-00055373-00055597": "such changes warrant examination of how", "BGIZJl39dKu-00223-00055598-00055798": "these shifts have impacted the accuracy", "BGIZJl39dKu-00224-00055799-00055990": "of census data over time the United", "BGIZJl39dKu-00225-00055991-00056208": "States Census Bureau began pursuing", "BGIZJl39dKu-00226-00056209-00056437": "technological innovations to improve the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00227-00056438-00056647": "precision of its census data collection", "BGIZJl39dKu-00228-00056648-00056758": "in the 1980s", "BGIZJl39dKu-00229-00056759-00056962": "Robert W marks the chief of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00230-00056963-00057214": "geography division of the u.s. CB teamed", "BGIZJl39dKu-00231-00057215-00057433": "up with the US Geological Survey and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00232-00057434-00057574": "oversaw the creation of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00233-00057575-00057787": "topologically integrated Geographic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00234-00057788-00058021": "encoding and referencing Tyger database", "BGIZJl39dKu-00235-00058022-00058288": "system Census officials were able to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00236-00058289-00058525": "evaluate more sophisticated and detailed", "BGIZJl39dKu-00237-00058526-00058723": "results that the tiger' system produced", "BGIZJl39dKu-00238-00058724-00058903": "furthermore Tiger data are also", "BGIZJl39dKu-00239-00058904-00059154": "available to the public and while the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00240-00059155-00059350": "tiger system does not directly amass", "BGIZJl39dKu-00241-00059351-00059566": "demographic data as a geographic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00242-00059566-00059848": "information system GIS it can be used to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00243-00059849-00060019": "merge demographics to conduct more", "BGIZJl39dKu-00244-00060020-00060253": "accurate geospatial and mapping analysis", "BGIZJl39dKu-00245-00060254-00060475": "the Census Bureau distributes data it", "BGIZJl39dKu-00246-00060476-00060688": "collects via censuses and surveys on its", "BGIZJl39dKu-00247-00060689-00060970": "American FactFinder website topic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00248-00060971-00061204": "ongoing surveys a survey as a method of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00249-00061204-00061455": "collecting and analyzing social economic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00250-00061457-00061711": "and geographic data it provides", "BGIZJl39dKu-00251-00061712-00061905": "information about the conditions of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00252-00061907-00062127": "United States states and counties", "BGIZJl39dKu-00253-00062128-00062379": "throughout the decade between censuses", "BGIZJl39dKu-00254-00062380-00062602": "the bureau conducts surveys to produce a", "BGIZJl39dKu-00255-00062603-00062809": "general view and comprehensive study of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00256-00062810-00063025": "the United States social and economic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00257-00063026-00063262": "conditions staff from the current", "BGIZJl39dKu-00258-00063263-00063571": "surveys program conduct over 130 ongoing", "BGIZJl39dKu-00259-00063572-00063769": "and special surveys about people and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00260-00063770-00064012": "their characteristics a network of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00261-00064013-00064198": "professional field representatives", "BGIZJl39dKu-00262-00064199-00064399": "gathers information from a sample of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00263-00064400-00064627": "households responding to questions about", "BGIZJl39dKu-00264-00064628-00064864": "employment consumer expenditures health", "BGIZJl39dKu-00265-00064865-00065154": "housing and other topics surveys", "BGIZJl39dKu-00266-00065155-00065371": "conducted between decades American", "BGIZJl39dKu-00267-00065372-00065566": "Community Survey American Housing Survey", "BGIZJl39dKu-00268-00065567-00065842": "Consumer Expenditure survey census of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00269-00065843-00066012": "government's current population survey", "BGIZJl39dKu-00270-00066013-00066286": "economic census national Ambulatory", "BGIZJl39dKu-00271-00066287-00066586": "Medical Care Survey namc s National", "BGIZJl39dKu-00272-00066587-00066778": "Health Interview Survey national", "BGIZJl39dKu-00273-00066779-00067165": "hospital discharge survey n HDS 1965 to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00274-00067166-00067510": "2010 national hospital care survey NH CS", "BGIZJl39dKu-00275-00067511-00067735": "a new survey that integrates inpatient", "BGIZJl39dKu-00276-00067736-00067975": "data formerly collected by the n HDS", "BGIZJl39dKu-00277-00067976-00068161": "with the emergency department IDI", "BGIZJl39dKu-00278-00068162-00068449": "outpatient department OPD an ambulatory", "BGIZJl39dKu-00279-00068450-00068734": "surgery center ASC data collected by the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00280-00068735-00068932": "National Hospital Ambulatory Medical", "BGIZJl39dKu-00281-00068933-00069274": "Care Survey NH a MCS National Crime", "BGIZJl39dKu-00282-00069275-00069499": "Victimization survey national nursing", "BGIZJl39dKu-00283-00069500-00069685": "home survey survey of income and program", "BGIZJl39dKu-00284-00069686-00069946": "participation survey of construction", "BGIZJl39dKu-00285-00069947-00070159": "survey of market absorption survey of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00286-00070160-00070345": "program dynamics National Longitudinal", "BGIZJl39dKu-00287-00070346-00070591": "survey national survey of fishing", "BGIZJl39dKu-00288-00070592-00070801": "hunting and wildlife associated", "BGIZJl39dKu-00289-00070802-00071026": "recreation residential finance survey", "BGIZJl39dKu-00290-00071027-00071281": "national epidemiologic survey of alcohol", "BGIZJl39dKu-00291-00071282-00071578": "related conditions any SARC annual", "BGIZJl39dKu-00292-00071579-00071794": "retail trade survey annual wholesale", "BGIZJl39dKu-00293-00071795-00071959": "trade survey annual and quarterly", "BGIZJl39dKu-00294-00071960-00072199": "services surveys topic other surveys", "BGIZJl39dKu-00295-00072200-00072382": "conducted the Census Bureau collects", "BGIZJl39dKu-00296-00072383-00072589": "information in many other surveys and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00297-00072590-00072793": "provides the data to the survey sponsor", "BGIZJl39dKu-00298-00072794-00073077": "for release these sponsors include", "BGIZJl39dKu-00299-00073078-00073525": "Bureau of Justice Statistics bjs Bureau", "BGIZJl39dKu-00300-00073526-00073882": "of Labor Statistics BLS Bureau of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00301-00073883-00074278": "Transportation Statistics BTS Department", "BGIZJl39dKu-00302-00074279-00074567": "of Housing and Urban Development HUD", "BGIZJl39dKu-00303-00074568-00074750": "National Center for Education Statistics", "BGIZJl39dKu-00304-00074751-00075010": "NCES", "BGIZJl39dKu-00305-00075011-00075156": "National Center for Health Statistics", "BGIZJl39dKu-00306-00075157-00075705": "and CHS National Science Foundation NSF", "BGIZJl39dKu-00307-00075706-00076312": "Social Security Administration SSA", "BGIZJl39dKu-00308-00076313-00076925": "topic organizational structure", "BGIZJl39dKu-00309-00076926-00077250": "since 1903 the official census-taking", "BGIZJl39dKu-00310-00077251-00077487": "agency of the United States government", "BGIZJl39dKu-00311-00077488-00077732": "has been the Bureau of the census the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00312-00077733-00077940": "Census Bureau is headed by a director", "BGIZJl39dKu-00313-00077941-00078153": "assisted by a deputy director and an", "BGIZJl39dKu-00314-00078154-00078321": "executive staff composed of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00315-00078322-00078626": "associate directors the Census Bureau", "BGIZJl39dKu-00316-00078627-00078786": "has had headquarters in Suitland", "BGIZJl39dKu-00317-00078787-00079149": "Maryland since 1942 the new headquarters", "BGIZJl39dKu-00318-00079150-00079461": "complex was completed in 2007 and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00319-00079462-00079788": "supports over 4,000 employees the bureau", "BGIZJl39dKu-00320-00079789-00080028": "operates regional offices in 12 cities", "BGIZJl39dKu-00321-00080029-00080237": "Boston New York City Philadelphia", "BGIZJl39dKu-00322-00080238-00080580": "Detroit Chicago Kansas City Seattle", "BGIZJl39dKu-00323-00080581-00080844": "Charlotte Atlanta Dallas Denver and Los", "BGIZJl39dKu-00324-00080845-00081174": "Angeles the national processing center", "BGIZJl39dKu-00325-00081175-00081435": "is in Jeffersonville Indiana additional", "BGIZJl39dKu-00326-00081436-00081621": "temporary processing facilities", "BGIZJl39dKu-00327-00081622-00081840": "facilitate the decennial census which", "BGIZJl39dKu-00328-00081841-00082094": "employs more than a million people the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00329-00082095-00082401": "cost of the 2000 census was 4.5 billion", "BGIZJl39dKu-00330-00082402-00082676": "dollars during the years just prior to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00331-00082677-00082907": "the decennial census parallel census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00332-00082908-00083163": "offices known as regional census centers", "BGIZJl39dKu-00333-00083164-00083439": "are opened in the field office cities", "BGIZJl39dKu-00334-00083440-00083682": "the decennial operations are carried out", "BGIZJl39dKu-00335-00083683-00083892": "from these facilities the regional", "BGIZJl39dKu-00336-00083893-00084107": "census centers oversee the openings and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00337-00084108-00084396": "closings of smaller local census offices", "BGIZJl39dKu-00338-00084397-00084632": "within their collection jurisdictions", "BGIZJl39dKu-00339-00084633-00084909": "the estimated cost of the 2010 census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00340-00084910-00085092": "has fourteen point seven billion dollars", "BGIZJl39dKu-00341-00085093-00085440": "On January 1st 2013", "BGIZJl39dKu-00342-00085441-00085662": "the Census Bureau was to consolidate its", "BGIZJl39dKu-00343-00085663-00085994": "12 regional offices into six increasing", "BGIZJl39dKu-00344-00085995-00086205": "costs of data collection changes in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00345-00086206-00086436": "survey management tools such as laptops", "BGIZJl39dKu-00346-00086437-00086637": "and the increasing use of multimodal", "BGIZJl39dKu-00347-00086638-00086868": "surveys ie Internet telephone and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00348-00086869-00087066": "in-person has led the Census Bureau to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00349-00087067-00087326": "consolidate the remaining regional", "BGIZJl39dKu-00350-00087327-00087506": "offices will be in New York City", "BGIZJl39dKu-00351-00087507-00087828": "Philadelphia Chicago Atlanta Denver and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00352-00087829-00087915": "Los Angeles", "BGIZJl39dKu-00353-00087916-00088149": "the Census Bureau also runs the census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00354-00088150-00088365": "information center cooperative program", "BGIZJl39dKu-00355-00088366-00088575": "that involves fifty-eight national", "BGIZJl39dKu-00356-00088576-00088788": "regional and local nonprofit", "BGIZJl39dKu-00357-00088789-00089142": "organizations the CIC program aims to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00358-00089143-00089319": "represent the interests of underserved", "BGIZJl39dKu-00359-00089320-00089693": "communities", "BGIZJl39dKu-00360-00089694-00090250": "topic computer equipment", "BGIZJl39dKu-00361-00090251-00090553": "the 1890 census was the first to use the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00362-00090554-00090769": "electric tabulating machines invented by", "BGIZJl39dKu-00363-00090770-00091117": "Herman Hollerith for 1890 to 1940", "BGIZJl39dKu-00364-00091118-00091564": "details see truesdell Leon II 1965 the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00365-00091565-00091795": "development of punch card tabulation in", "BGIZJl39dKu-00366-00091796-00092104": "the Bureau of the census 1890 to 1940", "BGIZJl39dKu-00367-00092105-00092305": "without lines of actual tabulation", "BGIZJl39dKu-00368-00092306-00092803": "programs u.s. GPO in 1946 knowing of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00369-00092804-00092989": "bureau's funding of Hollerith and later", "BGIZJl39dKu-00370-00092990-00093202": "powers john mauchly approached the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00371-00093203-00093391": "bureau about early funding for UNIVAC", "BGIZJl39dKu-00372-00093392-00093676": "development a univac i computer was", "BGIZJl39dKu-00373-00093677-00094340": "accepted by the bureau in 1951", "BGIZJl39dKu-00374-00094341-00094898": "handheld computers HHC", "BGIZJl39dKu-00375-00094899-00095157": "historically the census information was", "BGIZJl39dKu-00376-00095158-00095355": "gathered by census takers going door to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00377-00095356-00095582": "door collecting information in a ledger", "BGIZJl39dKu-00378-00095583-00095878": "beginning in 1970 information was", "BGIZJl39dKu-00379-00095879-00096103": "gathered via mailed forms to reduce", "BGIZJl39dKu-00380-00096104-00096357": "paper usage reduce payroll expense and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00381-00096358-00096553": "acquire the most comprehensive list of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00382-00096554-00096859": "addresses ever compiled 500,000 handheld", "BGIZJl39dKu-00383-00096860-00097149": "computers HH sees specifically designed", "BGIZJl39dKu-00384-00097150-00097386": "single purpose devices were used for the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00385-00097387-00097621": "first time in 2009 during the address", "BGIZJl39dKu-00386-00097622-00097846": "canvassing portion of the 2010 decennial", "BGIZJl39dKu-00387-00097847-00098151": "census project projected savings were", "BGIZJl39dKu-00388-00098152-00098651": "estimated to be over 1 billion dollars", "BGIZJl39dKu-00389-00098652-00099209": "topic security precautions", "BGIZJl39dKu-00390-00099210-00099499": "the hhc was manufactured by Harris", "BGIZJl39dKu-00391-00099500-00099730": "corporation an established department of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00392-00099731-00099941": "defense contractor via a controversial", "BGIZJl39dKu-00393-00099942-00100182": "contract with the Department of Commerce", "BGIZJl39dKu-00394-00100183-00100460": "secured access via a fingerprint swipe", "BGIZJl39dKu-00395-00100461-00100679": "guaranteed only the verified user could", "BGIZJl39dKu-00396-00100680-00101005": "access the unit a GPS capacity was", "BGIZJl39dKu-00397-00101006-00101194": "integral to the daily address management", "BGIZJl39dKu-00398-00101195-00101365": "and the transfer of gathered information", "BGIZJl39dKu-00399-00101366-00101699": "of major importance was the security and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00400-00101700-00101887": "integrity of the populists private", "BGIZJl39dKu-00401-00101888-00102291": "information", "BGIZJl39dKu-00402-00102292-00102785": "soppec success and failure", "BGIZJl39dKu-00403-00102786-00103050": "enumerators information gatherers that", "BGIZJl39dKu-00404-00103051-00103249": "had operational problems with the device", "BGIZJl39dKu-00405-00103250-00103475": "understandably made negative reports", "BGIZJl39dKu-00406-00103476-00103794": "during the 2009 Senate confirmation", "BGIZJl39dKu-00407-00103795-00104004": "hearings for Robert groves President", "BGIZJl39dKu-00408-00104005-00104229": "Obama's census director appointee there", "BGIZJl39dKu-00409-00104230-00104439": "was much mention of contracting problems", "BGIZJl39dKu-00410-00104440-00104643": "but very little criticism of the units", "BGIZJl39dKu-00411-00104644-00104937": "in rural areas the sparsity of cell", "BGIZJl39dKu-00412-00104938-00105145": "phone towers caused problems with data", "BGIZJl39dKu-00413-00105146-00105459": "transmission to and from the hhc since", "BGIZJl39dKu-00414-00105460-00105631": "the units were updated nightly with", "BGIZJl39dKu-00415-00105632-00105816": "important changes in reprogramming", "BGIZJl39dKu-00416-00105817-00106024": "operator implementation of proper", "BGIZJl39dKu-00417-00106025-00106275": "procedure was imperative dramatic", "BGIZJl39dKu-00418-00106276-00106471": "dysfunction and delays occurred if the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00419-00106472-00106614": "units were not put into sleep mode", "BGIZJl39dKu-00420-00106615-00106991": "overnight", "BGIZJl39dKu-00421-00106992-00107538": "topic notable alumni", "BGIZJl39dKu-00422-00107539-00108038": "topic see also", "BGIZJl39dKu-00423-00108039-00108336": "list of u.s. states and territories by", "BGIZJl39dKu-00424-00108337-00108697": "population list of metropolitan areas of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00425-00108698-00108970": "the United States list of United States", "BGIZJl39dKu-00426-00108971-00109326": "cities by population list of United", "BGIZJl39dKu-00427-00109327-00109572": "States counties and county-equivalents", "BGIZJl39dKu-00428-00109573-00109833": "United States Office of Management and", "BGIZJl39dKu-00429-00109834-00110178": "Budget primary statistical area list of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00430-00110179-00110644": "the 574 PSAs combined Statistical Area", "BGIZJl39dKu-00431-00110645-00111073": "list of the 169 GSA's core based", "BGIZJl39dKu-00432-00111074-00111558": "statistical area list of the 929 CBSA's", "BGIZJl39dKu-00433-00111558-00111813": "Metropolitan Statistical Area list of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00434-00111814-00112263": "the 388 MSAs micropolitan Statistical", "BGIZJl39dKu-00435-00112264-00112681": "Area list of the 541 mousses United", "BGIZJl39dKu-00436-00112682-00112882": "States urban area list of United States", "BGIZJl39dKu-00437-00112883-00113454": "urban areas PITC OB title 13 of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00438-00113455-00113794": "United States Code title 15 of the Code", "BGIZJl39dKu-00439-00113795-00114082": "of Federal Regulations Director of the", "BGIZJl39dKu-00440-00114083-00114585": "United States Census Bureau data gov USA", "BGIZJl39dKu-00441-00114586-00114973": "facts", "BGIZJl39dKu-00442-00114974-00115486": "topic references", "BGIZJl39dKu-00443-00115488-00116024": "topic external links", "BGIZJl39dKu-00444-00116025-00116394": "United States Census Bureau Census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00445-00116395-00116739": "Bureau in the Federal Register USC B", "BGIZJl39dKu-00446-00116740-00117252": "population estimates USC B history US", "BGIZJl39dKu-00447-00117253-00117553": "and world population clocks pop clocks", "BGIZJl39dKu-00448-00117554-00117915": "geographic areas reference manual works", "BGIZJl39dKu-00449-00117916-00118131": "by United States Census Bureau at", "BGIZJl39dKu-00450-00118132-00118416": "Project Gutenberg works by or about", "BGIZJl39dKu-00451-00118417-00118679": "United States Census Bureau at Internet", "BGIZJl39dKu-00452-00118680-00119009": "Archive works by United States Census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00453-00119010-00119204": "Bureau at LibriVox public domain", "BGIZJl39dKu-00454-00119205-00119504": "audiobooks seventy two year rule PDF of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00455-00119505-00119708": "availability of census records about", "BGIZJl39dKu-00456-00119709-00120069": "individuals PDF of letter from Census", "BGIZJl39dKu-00457-00120070-00120266": "Bureau director Roy V peeled to", "BGIZJl39dKu-00458-00120267-00120485": "archivist of the United States Wayne C", "BGIZJl39dKu-00459-00120486-00120716": "Grover concerning the 72 year lapse", "BGIZJl39dKu-00460-00120717-00120890": "between collection and release of", "BGIZJl39dKu-00461-00120891-00121235": "decennial census records PDF of letter", "BGIZJl39dKu-00462-00121236-00121389": "from archivist of the United States", "BGIZJl39dKu-00463-00121390-00121644": "Wayne C Grover to Census Bureau director", "BGIZJl39dKu-00464-00121645-00122003": "Roy V Peale in reply to appeals August", "BGIZJl39dKu-00465-00122004-00122333": "1952 letter"}}, {"audio_id": "BHhn7ob77iA", "text": {"BHhn7ob77iA-00000-00000000-00001491": "[Music]", "BHhn7ob77iA-00001-00001492-00001948": "foreign", "BHhn7ob77iA-00002-00001950-00002815": "[Music]", "BHhn7ob77iA-00003-00002816-00004383": "[Music]", "BHhn7ob77iA-00004-00004384-00004493": "a", "BHhn7ob77iA-00005-00004494-00005412": "[Music]", "BHhn7ob77iA-00006-00005413-00006211": "[Music]", "BHhn7ob77iA-00007-00006212-00006512": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "BHucIXDyI4A", "text": {"BHucIXDyI4A-00000-00000012-00000293": "hey everyone it's Black Friday time here", "BHucIXDyI4A-00001-00000294-00000521": "are the dynavat Black Friday deals the", "BHucIXDyI4A-00002-00000522-00000808": "naughty bundle the new pixel M Cyclone", "BHucIXDyI4A-00003-00000809-00001073": "torch and the Walnut dynastash the nice", "BHucIXDyI4A-00004-00001074-00001397": "bundle the Omni starter pack with Dyna", "BHucIXDyI4A-00005-00001398-00001709": "coil and the ice fire wand the", "BHucIXDyI4A-00006-00001710-00002141": "concentrate bundle one vong eye 1B a", "BHucIXDyI4A-00007-00002142-00002495": "dyna coil a wingy dynastash a Mystic", "BHucIXDyI4A-00008-00002496-00002800": "Timber dab tool and a wand that's a lot", "BHucIXDyI4A-00009-00002801-00003184": "of stuff the cap pack the cap the", "BHucIXDyI4A-00010-00003185-00003449": "captive cap and the low temp cap the", "BHucIXDyI4A-00011-00003450-00003629": "Buddy bundle a stainless steel chill", "BHucIXDyI4A-00012-00003629-00004006": "pipe an ice fire wand and a long eye", "BHucIXDyI4A-00013-00004007-00004379": "the snow bundle an m a Rover and a", "BHucIXDyI4A-00014-00004380-00004583": "walnut dynastash now why am I out here", "BHucIXDyI4A-00015-00004584-00004756": "Ben", "BHucIXDyI4A-00016-00004757-00005081": "sail ends Tuesday November 29th at 11 59", "BHucIXDyI4A-00017-00005082-00005447": "PM now let's light this thing up hey", "BHucIXDyI4A-00018-00005448-00006022": "guys mind if I join you sure", "BHucIXDyI4A-00019-00006023-00006413": "already thanks bud", "BHucIXDyI4A-00020-00006414-00006686": "chilly"}}, {"audio_id": "BHBLXELLgsU", "text": {"BHBLXELLgsU-00000-00000078-00001016": "foreign", "BHBLXELLgsU-00001-00001017-00003173": "[Music]", "BHBLXELLgsU-00002-00003174-00003411": "you're absolutely", "BHBLXELLgsU-00003-00003413-00004090": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "BHIFC5WALxy", "text": {"BHIFC5WALxy-00000-00000248-00000438": "okay time to start", "BHIFC5WALxy-00001-00000440-00000711": "the live coding part of lecture two of", "BHIFC5WALxy-00002-00000712-00000927": "chapter five which is a week five of the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00003-00000927-00001119": "course domain specific languages of", "BHIFC5WALxy-00004-00001120-00001303": "mathematics", "BHIFC5WALxy-00005-00001304-00001582": "and what i will do today is to implement", "BHIFC5WALxy-00006-00001583-00001782": "the ring of polynomials", "BHIFC5WALxy-00007-00001784-00001934": "representing", "BHIFC5WALxy-00008-00001935-00002175": "polynomials as lists of coefficients and", "BHIFC5WALxy-00009-00002176-00002342": "getting all the numeric operations to", "BHIFC5WALxy-00010-00002343-00002502": "work for them", "BHIFC5WALxy-00011-00002503-00002615": "so", "BHIFC5WALxy-00012-00002616-00002879": "part 0 defined the dsl the types for the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00013-00002880-00003047": "syntax and semantics and the eval", "BHIFC5WALxy-00014-00003048-00003279": "function part one defining the ring", "BHIFC5WALxy-00015-00003279-00003622": "methods for polynomials and power series", "BHIFC5WALxy-00016-00003623-00003815": "and part two define methods for", "BHIFC5WALxy-00017-00003815-00004183": "derivative and integral", "BHIFC5WALxy-00018-00004184-00004463": "and i've split up the window here so i", "BHIFC5WALxy-00019-00004464-00004759": "got a header which i've been", "BHIFC5WALxy-00020-00004760-00004886": "very", "BHIFC5WALxy-00021-00004887-00005175": "sparse so i import the preload qualified", "BHIFC5WALxy-00022-00005176-00005343": "i improve improve", "BHIFC5WALxy-00023-00005344-00005615": "port nothing from the prelude so far", "BHIFC5WALxy-00024-00005616-00005854": "except instances and i will have to add", "BHIFC5WALxy-00025-00005855-00006063": "a few things to a convenience but i", "BHIFC5WALxy-00026-00006064-00006311": "would want to make it clear when i do so", "BHIFC5WALxy-00027-00006312-00006559": "and i will later import the algebra", "BHIFC5WALxy-00028-00006559-00006823": "model module from dsl so math which is", "BHIFC5WALxy-00029-00006823-00006959": "where i define", "BHIFC5WALxy-00030-00006959-00007191": "the classes for additive multiplicative", "BHIFC5WALxy-00031-00007192-00007478": "ring and so on but i will add the things", "BHIFC5WALxy-00032-00007479-00007855": "step by step when needed", "BHIFC5WALxy-00033-00007856-00008103": "okay so define the dsl so this has been", "BHIFC5WALxy-00034-00008104-00008503": "done already on the jamboard so let's", "BHIFC5WALxy-00035-00008504-00008639": "get started", "BHIFC5WALxy-00036-00008640-00008807": "so i've been saying that we can", "BHIFC5WALxy-00037-00008808-00009039": "represent polynomials by lists of", "BHIFC5WALxy-00038-00009040-00009214": "coefficients", "BHIFC5WALxy-00039-00009215-00009295": "so", "BHIFC5WALxy-00040-00009296-00009583": "i will do that in haskell by having a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00041-00009584-00009831": "new type around the list", "BHIFC5WALxy-00042-00009832-00010151": "to make sure that the type the instance", "BHIFC5WALxy-00043-00010152-00010342": "declaration doesn't clash with other", "BHIFC5WALxy-00044-00010343-00010574": "instances that we make later", "BHIFC5WALxy-00045-00010575-00010919": "so a polynomial over a type a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00046-00010920-00011255": "has a constructor let's call it just p", "BHIFC5WALxy-00047-00011256-00011759": "and then it has a list of a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00048-00011760-00011974": "okay so far so good", "BHIFC5WALxy-00049-00011975-00012206": "we define the type", "BHIFC5WALxy-00050-00012207-00012391": "now we need", "BHIFC5WALxy-00051-00012392-00012599": "a type for the semantics", "BHIFC5WALxy-00052-00012600-00012774": "so we want to write", "BHIFC5WALxy-00053-00012775-00013022": "an evaluator", "BHIFC5WALxy-00054-00013023-00013175": "so", "BHIFC5WALxy-00055-00013176-00013630": "of the standard form syntax to semantics", "BHIFC5WALxy-00056-00013631-00013951": "and the syntax here is a polynomial over", "BHIFC5WALxy-00057-00013952-00014038": "a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00058-00014040-00014271": "so the semantics well a polynomial", "BHIFC5WALxy-00059-00014272-00014655": "function is a function from a to a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00060-00014656-00014894": "so the semantics is the function type", "BHIFC5WALxy-00061-00014895-00015175": "but this doesn't work for all a it has", "BHIFC5WALxy-00062-00015176-00015455": "to be restricted to those a's which are", "BHIFC5WALxy-00063-00015456-00015655": "in the class ring", "BHIFC5WALxy-00064-00015656-00015950": "and i'll first just write error to do", "BHIFC5WALxy-00065-00015951-00016150": "here and then", "BHIFC5WALxy-00066-00016151-00016343": "try to load it and then it will say it", "BHIFC5WALxy-00067-00016344-00016550": "doesn't know what ring is", "BHIFC5WALxy-00068-00016551-00016815": "so this is the point where i need to", "BHIFC5WALxy-00069-00016816-00017071": "add to the header the import of these", "BHIFC5WALxy-00070-00017072-00017327": "math algebra if i want to be strict i", "BHIFC5WALxy-00071-00017328-00017855": "could say okay just import ring here", "BHIFC5WALxy-00072-00017856-00017950": "okay", "BHIFC5WALxy-00073-00017951-00018279": "and now as i've been very strict let's", "BHIFC5WALxy-00074-00018280-00018639": "also let me use the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00075-00018640-00018863": "the error methods from the type from the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00076-00018864-00019247": "predict okay so now adding ring from the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00077-00019248-00019479": "our own algebra module and error from", "BHIFC5WALxy-00078-00019480-00019663": "the prelude i've been able to get as far", "BHIFC5WALxy-00079-00019664-00019839": "as stating the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00080-00019840-00020175": "type of the syntax poly a and the type", "BHIFC5WALxy-00081-00020176-00020447": "of the semantics functions from a to a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00082-00020448-00020727": "and while not define eval at least give", "BHIFC5WALxy-00083-00020728-00020894": "its type", "BHIFC5WALxy-00084-00020895-00021111": "i think this is the point where i will", "BHIFC5WALxy-00085-00021112-00021319": "let this window go to make the more", "BHIFC5WALxy-00086-00021320-00021439": "visible", "BHIFC5WALxy-00087-00021440-00021614": "the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00088-00021615-00021871": "run the rebel", "BHIFC5WALxy-00089-00021872-00022135": "okay so what should we do here well we", "BHIFC5WALxy-00090-00022136-00022375": "have two possible cases for eval we have", "BHIFC5WALxy-00091-00022376-00022647": "the empty list", "BHIFC5WALxy-00092-00022648-00022775": "and we have", "BHIFC5WALxy-00093-00022776-00023007": "well okay let's keep the error", "BHIFC5WALxy-00094-00023008-00023167": "we have the empty list and we have the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00095-00023168-00023883": "non-empty list", "BHIFC5WALxy-00096-00023884-00024047": "okay", "BHIFC5WALxy-00097-00024048-00024319": "couldn't match accepted type with poly a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00098-00024320-00024614": "yes okay so notice that now i've tried", "BHIFC5WALxy-00099-00024615-00024799": "to match on the list but i've actually", "BHIFC5WALxy-00100-00024800-00025022": "said this is a new type with a list", "BHIFC5WALxy-00101-00025023-00025158": "internally", "BHIFC5WALxy-00102-00025159-00025430": "so this is actually", "BHIFC5WALxy-00103-00025431-00025558": "not quite", "BHIFC5WALxy-00104-00025559-00026039": "where we are ready so it's keeping me", "BHIFC5WALxy-00105-00026039-00026255": "clear here that eval", "BHIFC5WALxy-00106-00026256-00026470": "will take a poly", "BHIFC5WALxy-00107-00026472-00026646": "of some coefficients", "BHIFC5WALxy-00108-00026647-00026951": "and call eval l", "BHIFC5WALxy-00109-00026952-00027287": "on that list of coefficients so er l", "BHIFC5WALxy-00110-00027288-00027711": "is the one i'm defining down here", "BHIFC5WALxy-00111-00027712-00027974": "and that will have a very similar type", "BHIFC5WALxy-00112-00027975-00028062": "just", "BHIFC5WALxy-00113-00028063-00028423": "it's stripped the outermost constructor", "BHIFC5WALxy-00114-00028424-00028527": "p", "BHIFC5WALxy-00115-00028527-00028783": "oh i didn't call it poly here just for", "BHIFC5WALxy-00116-00028783-00029118": "abbreviation i call it just p", "BHIFC5WALxy-00117-00029119-00029462": "okay parse error yes this now suddenly", "BHIFC5WALxy-00118-00029463-00029823": "doesn't have a right hand side", "BHIFC5WALxy-00119-00029824-00029983": "okay good", "BHIFC5WALxy-00120-00029983-00030262": "so now we've defined at least", "BHIFC5WALxy-00121-00030263-00030535": "the shape of the definition", "BHIFC5WALxy-00122-00030536-00030751": "and let's see what should be the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00123-00030752-00031007": "evaluation of the empty list so the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00124-00031008-00031207": "empty list of coefficient represents the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00125-00031208-00031407": "zero functions so let's try to write", "BHIFC5WALxy-00126-00031408-00031614": "zero here", "BHIFC5WALxy-00127-00031616-00031767": "and now it says it doesn't know what", "BHIFC5WALxy-00128-00031768-00031983": "zero is and that's because i've been a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00129-00031983-00032239": "little bit too strict in my import", "BHIFC5WALxy-00130-00032239-00032470": "i imported just ring but i also need to", "BHIFC5WALxy-00131-00032472-00032718": "import", "BHIFC5WALxy-00132-00032719-00033031": "the additive class and its operations so", "BHIFC5WALxy-00133-00033032-00033246": "additive", "BHIFC5WALxy-00134-00033247-00033446": "which has zero", "BHIFC5WALxy-00135-00033447-00033662": "actually it has plus", "BHIFC5WALxy-00136-00033663-00034183": "and zero", "BHIFC5WALxy-00137-00034184-00034390": "okay so far so good", "BHIFC5WALxy-00138-00034391-00034662": "now i can write the right hand side as", "BHIFC5WALxy-00139-00034663-00034895": "just zero here and notice this is zero", "BHIFC5WALxy-00140-00034896-00035023": "of type", "BHIFC5WALxy-00141-00035024-00035239": "function from a to a so there is a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00142-00035240-00035390": "function instance that we defined", "BHIFC5WALxy-00143-00035391-00035567": "earlier", "BHIFC5WALxy-00144-00035568-00035799": "okay so if it's not zero", "BHIFC5WALxy-00145-00035800-00036062": "then we should provide here a function", "BHIFC5WALxy-00146-00036063-00036287": "and let's use the normal wishful", "BHIFC5WALxy-00147-00036288-00036511": "thinking style i will need to call eval", "BHIFC5WALxy-00148-00036512-00036790": "l recursive down a s and then i would do", "BHIFC5WALxy-00149-00036791-00037071": "something here let's call it", "BHIFC5WALxy-00150-00037072-00037318": "cons", "BHIFC5WALxy-00151-00037319-00037479": "so eval", "BHIFC5WALxy-00152-00037480-00037662": "cons", "BHIFC5WALxy-00153-00037663-00037967": "it will take a any val a a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00154-00037968-00038223": "so let's see what eval cons", "BHIFC5WALxy-00155-00038224-00038455": "has as type", "BHIFC5WALxy-00156-00038456-00039015": "well it should take an a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00157-00039016-00039151": "and it should take one of these", "BHIFC5WALxy-00158-00039152-00039383": "functions so notice there is no list", "BHIFC5WALxy-00159-00039384-00039695": "here i've already evaluated the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00160-00039696-00040262": "tail as to a function", "BHIFC5WALxy-00161-00040263-00040471": "sorry i'm moving around badly and then", "BHIFC5WALxy-00162-00040472-00040683": "it should return a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00163-00040684-00040967": "function and similarly as before it will", "BHIFC5WALxy-00164-00040968-00041302": "also need the ring constraint", "BHIFC5WALxy-00165-00041303-00041518": "so eval cons", "BHIFC5WALxy-00166-00041519-00041639": "takes this", "BHIFC5WALxy-00167-00041640-00041927": "first coefficient well we can", "BHIFC5WALxy-00168-00041928-00042255": "call it a is here or a0 perhaps", "BHIFC5WALxy-00169-00042256-00042455": "and under the function which i would", "BHIFC5WALxy-00170-00042456-00042783": "call f and it should return a function", "BHIFC5WALxy-00171-00042784-00042958": "and the easiest way to return the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00172-00042959-00043183": "function well okay let's let's be", "BHIFC5WALxy-00173-00043184-00043511": "uh i can return the lambda expression so", "BHIFC5WALxy-00174-00043512-00043639": "given an x", "BHIFC5WALxy-00175-00043640-00043774": "this is the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00176-00043775-00043951": "x of type a here", "BHIFC5WALxy-00177-00043952-00044199": "i should return a 0", "BHIFC5WALxy-00178-00044200-00044343": "plus", "BHIFC5WALxy-00179-00044344-00044711": "x times f of x", "BHIFC5WALxy-00180-00044712-00044815": "and maybe", "BHIFC5WALxy-00181-00044816-00045087": "maybe i can rename this one p so this is", "BHIFC5WALxy-00182-00045088-00045335": "a polynomial function", "BHIFC5WALxy-00183-00045336-00045495": "that we're building up okay and now it", "BHIFC5WALxy-00184-00045496-00045615": "complains it doesn't know what", "BHIFC5WALxy-00185-00045616-00045767": "multiplication is", "BHIFC5WALxy-00186-00045768-00045974": "variable not in scope", "BHIFC5WALxy-00187-00045975-00046230": "well it's quite reasonable", "BHIFC5WALxy-00188-00046231-00046335": "let's", "BHIFC5WALxy-00189-00046336-00046518": "import also", "BHIFC5WALxy-00190-00046519-00046727": "multiplicative", "BHIFC5WALxy-00191-00046728-00047151": "multiplicative", "BHIFC5WALxy-00192-00047152-00047823": "and that has multiplication and one", "BHIFC5WALxy-00193-00047824-00048023": "okay good", "BHIFC5WALxy-00194-00048024-00048351": "so now we have a function", "BHIFC5WALxy-00195-00048352-00048446": "eval", "BHIFC5WALxy-00196-00048447-00048774": "in terms of eval which in turn is using", "BHIFC5WALxy-00197-00048775-00049095": "eval cons let's try to use it", "BHIFC5WALxy-00198-00049096-00049351": "so this is the evaluation of well then", "BHIFC5WALxy-00199-00049352-00049583": "we need an example so let's define an", "BHIFC5WALxy-00200-00049584-00049855": "example the simplest example i guess is", "BHIFC5WALxy-00201-00049856-00050007": "x", "BHIFC5WALxy-00202-00050008-00050279": "so this should be a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00203-00050280-00050727": "for any ring a it should be a poly a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00204-00050728-00051118": "and x p should be p of", "BHIFC5WALxy-00205-00051119-00051246": "zero", "BHIFC5WALxy-00206-00051247-00051390": "one", "BHIFC5WALxy-00207-00051391-00051654": "so zero for the constant term is one for", "BHIFC5WALxy-00208-00051655-00051870": "the coefficient in front of x so let's", "BHIFC5WALxy-00209-00051871-00052126": "see xp evaluated", "BHIFC5WALxy-00210-00052127-00052375": "okay now it says no instance for show", "BHIFC5WALxy-00211-00052376-00052526": "and that's true", "BHIFC5WALxy-00212-00052527-00052838": "i should probably say deriving", "BHIFC5WALxy-00213-00052839-00052982": "show here", "BHIFC5WALxy-00214-00052983-00053319": "and then it would complain", "BHIFC5WALxy-00215-00053320-00053503": "uh that i haven't", "BHIFC5WALxy-00216-00053504-00053742": "i don't know what show is so i'll import", "BHIFC5WALxy-00217-00053744-00054047": "show as well", "BHIFC5WALxy-00218-00054048-00054319": "okay so let's see now xp", "BHIFC5WALxy-00219-00054320-00054682": "yes xp is the list zero one", "BHIFC5WALxy-00220-00054683-00055023": "perfect let's try to evaluate it so eval", "BHIFC5WALxy-00221-00055024-00055159": "of xp", "BHIFC5WALxy-00222-00055160-00055287": "well", "BHIFC5WALxy-00223-00055288-00055423": "it's something with", "BHIFC5WALxy-00224-00055424-00055750": "if we have an add group a multiplicative", "BHIFC5WALxy-00225-00055751-00055830": "and", "BHIFC5WALxy-00226-00055832-00056023": "yeah that's the expansion of ring and", "BHIFC5WALxy-00227-00056024-00056182": "then it's a function from r to r so", "BHIFC5WALxy-00228-00056183-00056463": "let's apply it to zero for example", "BHIFC5WALxy-00229-00056464-00056663": "okay that's zero", "BHIFC5WALxy-00230-00056664-00056854": "and uh yeah we don't have much else in", "BHIFC5WALxy-00231-00056855-00057142": "scope we we can apply it to the real", "BHIFC5WALxy-00232-00057144-00057342": "number three point four it will be real", "BHIFC5WALxy-00233-00057344-00057663": "number three point four", "BHIFC5WALxy-00234-00057664-00058030": "good so now we've defined the dsl", "BHIFC5WALxy-00235-00058032-00058287": "the type for the syntax so we call the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00236-00058288-00058535": "the list of coefficient syntax here we", "BHIFC5WALxy-00237-00058536-00058647": "could have", "BHIFC5WALxy-00238-00058648-00058838": "the function expression data type but", "BHIFC5WALxy-00239-00058839-00059015": "here let's just keep it simple and use", "BHIFC5WALxy-00240-00059016-00059263": "just the coefficients as syntax and the", "BHIFC5WALxy-00241-00059264-00059615": "functions from a to a as semantics", "BHIFC5WALxy-00242-00059616-00059830": "and then we'll move on to defining all", "BHIFC5WALxy-00243-00059832-00060087": "the ring operations but we'll make a", "BHIFC5WALxy-00244-00060088-00060451": "little break here"}}, {"audio_id": "BHIVEfl5Jro", "text": {"BHIVEfl5Jro-00000-00000913-00001423": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00001-00001424-00001465": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00002-00001466-00002754": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00003-00002755-00002797": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00004-00002798-00008930": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00005-00008931-00009077": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00006-00009078-00010565": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00007-00010566-00011640": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00008-00011641-00012035": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00009-00012036-00016369": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00010-00016371-00017647": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00011-00017648-00018200": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00012-00018201-00019159": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00013-00019160-00020789": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00014-00020790-00021678": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00015-00021679-00023692": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00016-00023693-00027068": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00017-00027069-00028475": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00018-00028476-00029860": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00019-00029861-00030899": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00020-00030900-00032500": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00021-00032501-00033568": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00022-00033569-00037059": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00023-00037060-00037447": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00024-00037448-00037595": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00025-00037596-00038027": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00026-00038028-00038161": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00027-00038162-00038209": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00028-00038210-00038410": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00029-00038411-00038537": "[Music]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00030-00038538-00038614": "[Applause]", "BHIVEfl5Jro-00031-00038615-00038992": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "BHU6hvF-XSc", "text": {"BHU6hvF-XSc-00000-00000003-00000200": "let's take a look at the power and heat", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00001-00000200-00000424": "situation of the leave'em five here is", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00002-00000425-00000596": "what the two versions look like while", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00003-00000597-00000784": "charging with a small fan blowing on", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00004-00000785-00000979": "them on the right we have the older", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00005-00000980-00001193": "birch version of the labrum five with", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00006-00001194-00001408": "the newer chestnut on the left both are", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00007-00001409-00001643": "up to date and running pure OS as you", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00008-00001644-00001838": "can see the chestnut is performing much", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00009-00001839-00002023": "better running around five degrees", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00010-00002025-00002251": "cooler than the birch even with the", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00011-00002252-00002498": "birch closer to the fan a more", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00012-00002499-00002723": "real-world test is charging without a", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00013-00002724-00003050": "fan oh my goodness fan goes back on", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00014-00003051-00003317": "let's kill this phone as soon as this", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00015-00003318-00003599": "recording is done based on this test I", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00016-00003600-00003788": "would not recommend charging a birch", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00017-00003789-00004025": "without a fan or at least some sort of", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00018-00004026-00004213": "metal surface for it to rest on to carry", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00019-00004214-00004436": "away some of that heat this really shows", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00020-00004437-00004622": "just how much better the chestnut", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00021-00004623-00004820": "version of the Liebherr 5 is at cooling", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00022-00004821-00005086": "the phone charges safely more than 10", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00023-00005087-00005256": "degrees cooler than the version before", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00024-00005257-00005525": "just as important as heat dissipation is", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00025-00005526-00005818": "battery life without any modification", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00026-00005819-00006031": "running Wi-Fi and with the modem turned", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00027-00006032-00006293": "off the chestnut lasted 2 hours 20", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00028-00006294-00006511": "minutes and 30 seconds this can be", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00029-00006512-00006745": "extended by turning off a few CPU cores", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00030-00006747-00007028": "and limiting the CPU frequency with that", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00031-00007029-00007289": "done the chestnut lasted 2 hours 34", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00032-00007290-00007564": "minutes and 20 seconds which gives us an", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00033-00007565-00007784": "extra 13 minutes and 50 seconds of", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00034-00007784-00008059": "runtime the few CPU tweaks that have", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00035-00008061-00008203": "applied were the only things I could", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00036-00008204-00008435": "think of to do on my own but I went over", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00037-00008436-00008585": "to the matrix channel and asked what", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00038-00008586-00008728": "they might do in order to save some", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00039-00008729-00008951": "battery life Sebastian came back with a", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00040-00008952-00009227": "few extra commands for me to try these", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00041-00009228-00009403": "commands allow us to set the DRAM", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00042-00009404-00009602": "governor to allow the clock speed to", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00043-00009603-00009995": "drop to 25 megahertz warning this does", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00044-00009996-00010192": "cause issues with the display stack at", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00045-00010193-00010424": "the moment but as an extra step let's go", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00046-00010425-00010580": "ahead and turn off the screen by hitting", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00047-00010581-00010862": "that power button once with the CPU and", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00048-00010863-00011069": "DRAM in a minimal state the chestnut", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00049-00011070-00011312": "lasted three hours 41 minutes and 20", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00050-00011313-00011567": "seconds which is a whopping 1 hour and", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00051-00011568-00011863": "20 minutes and 50 seconds extra this", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00052-00011864-00012083": "leads us to the next question can the", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00053-00012084-00012305": "device keep itself cool while under load", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00054-00012306-00012551": "I started stress testing the Leoben 5", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00055-00012552-00012716": "and walked away for about 30 minutes", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00056-00012717-00012985": "when I got back the CPU was hotter than", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00057-00012986-00013247": "I liked but once I stopped the test the", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00058-00013247-00013349": "CPU dropped", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00059-00013350-00013871": "in temperature very fast playing with", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00060-00013872-00014159": "the CPU and DRAM like we did before does", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00061-00014160-00014312": "seem to be an effective way to keep the", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00062-00014313-00014537": "Liebherr 5 cool this is what the Libre 5", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00063-00014538-00014747": "looks like under load but with the DRAM", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00064-00014747-00014987": "and CPU in a minimal state the", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00065-00014988-00015188": "temperature stays between 50 and 52", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00066-00015188-00015407": "degrees not too bad", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00067-00015408-00015659": "this is really good news it means that", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00068-00015660-00015838": "at some point the Libre 5 will be able", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00069-00015840-00016055": "to manage its own temperature simply by", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00070-00016056-00016271": "reducing performance the upcoming", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00071-00016272-00016505": "version dogwood should have even better", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00072-00016506-00016715": "cooling than what we see in chestnut we", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00073-00016716-00016874": "should also keep in mind that the final", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00074-00016875-00017044": "version evergreen will come with a", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00075-00017045-00017228": "bigger battery than what we're testing", "BHU6hvF-XSc-00076-00017229-00017648": "with today thanks for watching bye"}}, {"audio_id": "BHc4a9Msjxc", "text": {"BHc4a9Msjxc-00000-00000000-00000611": "hi today what we're going to do is plug", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00001-00000612-00000902": "leg the volume of a cylinder to do this", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00002-00000902-00001258": "we've got to use a formula now a formula", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00003-00001259-00001502": "is basically a skeleton version of a", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00004-00001503-00001777": "calculation where letters are used to", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00005-00001778-00002000": "replace the places where we put in the", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00006-00002001-00002246": "numbers so first of all got the stark", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00007-00002247-00002498": "effect our formula and the formula for", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00008-00002499-00002920": "the volume of the cylinder is V equals", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00009-00002921-00004274": "pi x are 150 r multiplied by H okay it's", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00010-00004275-00004910": "not very legible but B equals pi x are", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00011-00004911-00005404": "multiplied by r of pi PI H okay and this", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00012-00005405-00005738": "acts as a formula a template for our", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00013-00005739-00005984": "calculation and what we have to do is we", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00014-00005985-00006275": "have to put in numbers for each me so", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00015-00006276-00006542": "for this are here put in the radius of", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00016-00006543-00006833": "the cylinder for this are here you come", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00017-00006834-00007045": "to put in the righteous soda and for", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00018-00007047-00007238": "this H we've got to put in the haight", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00019-00007239-00007884": "episode okay yeah this one over here hi", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00020-00007886-00008237": "that's a number which comes up when", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00021-00008238-00008614": "Richard mess with circles and that one", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00022-00008615-00008785": "we can look up in tables a good", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00023-00008786-00010163": "approximation is 33 11 for 3.14 now for", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00024-00010164-00010342": "the radius you've got to take our", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00025-00010343-00010689": "cylinder whatever size air cylinder is", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00026-00010690-00011087": "here's what film canister just imagine a", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00027-00011088-00011876": "cylinder and we measure it so measuring", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00028-00011877-00012320": "visitor the measuring tape bounty and it", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00029-00012321-00013057": "comes out that having a radius of about", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00030-00013058-00013241": "1.2", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00031-00013243-00013647": "so I'm putting in 1.2 everywhere I see", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00032-00013647-00014658": "are so that's 51.2 here's another are so", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00033-00014659-00015633": "another 1.2 and then finally about H", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00034-00015634-00015920": "when I needed number for the H so I've", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00035-00015921-00016490": "got to measure the sounder again and", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00036-00016491-00016847": "when I measure it the sooner you're not", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00037-00016848-00016983": "going to be able to see this the", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00038-00016984-00017280": "cylinder comes out is being 5 centimeter", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00039-00017281-00017736": "by centimeter okay so now we've just got", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00040-00017737-00017908": "to put the numbers into the calculator", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00041-00017909-00018899": "so it's 3.14 that's my first number x", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00042-00018900-00019900": "1.25 second number x 1.2 by ferry number", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00043-00019901-00020496": "x 5 which is my fourth number follow", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00044-00020497-00021053": "that in quotes 22.6 okay so let's write", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00045-00021054-00022271": "down the answer 22.6 and then I've got", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00046-00022272-00022583": "to put down the unit's the inter as we", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00047-00022584-00022811": "said acute units if it going to be cubic", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00048-00022812-00023693": "centimeters when I write that as c and s", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00049-00023694-00024155": "and then the key is had CMS and then I", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00050-00024156-00024707": "put a 3 and the three means it's", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00051-00024708-00025038": "okay that's all there is to calculating", "BHc4a9Msjxc-00052-00025039-00025572": "the volume of cylinder thanks"}}, {"audio_id": "BId3p79ZOdE", "text": {"BId3p79ZOdE-00000-00000349-00000649": "[Music]", "BId3p79ZOdE-00001-00000650-00001049": "yeah Donatello", "BId3p79ZOdE-00002-00001050-00001247": "I've been rocking black G's Miss mad", "BId3p79ZOdE-00003-00001248-00001391": "stocks strikes around my hoodie and the", "BId3p79ZOdE-00004-00001392-00001523": "carrots on the wife's little shorty and", "BId3p79ZOdE-00005-00001524-00001673": "me up saying that you trying to talk I", "BId3p79ZOdE-00006-00001673-00001793": "don't want a conversation all I really", "BId3p79ZOdE-00007-00001794-00001967": "want is knots Pumas on the feet all", "BId3p79ZOdE-00008-00001968-00002165": "green like the clock dollar got me", "BId3p79ZOdE-00009-00002166-00002357": "filling out the box 18 jugging with the", "BId3p79ZOdE-00010-00002358-00002500": "homies [__] thighs moving packs like", "BId3p79ZOdE-00011-00002501-00002657": "clockwork scream my [__] cop I don't", "BId3p79ZOdE-00012-00002658-00003060": "really give a [__] what a [__]", "BId3p79ZOdE-00013-00003061-00003274": "insane I've been great this ain't new", "BId3p79ZOdE-00014-00003275-00003431": "not to put the other part just like a", "BId3p79ZOdE-00015-00003432-00003575": "Babe Ruth try to say [__] all my", "BId3p79ZOdE-00016-00003576-00003719": "teachers cause I hate school say they've", "BId3p79ZOdE-00017-00003720-00003820": "been calling me different I've been the", "BId3p79ZOdE-00018-00003821-00004646": "same dude nice come in and our buddies", "BId3p79ZOdE-00019-00004647-00005106": "[Music]", "BId3p79ZOdE-00020-00005107-00005351": "laughing so hard got me reading my knees", "BId3p79ZOdE-00021-00005352-00005513": "[__] I'm a beast that's a word on the", "BId3p79ZOdE-00022-00005514-00005620": "street they don't [__] with the kids", "BId3p79ZOdE-00023-00005621-00005765": "they can suck on my mean Don and tell", "BId3p79ZOdE-00024-00005766-00005891": "them say that [__] tell them six feet", "BId3p79ZOdE-00025-00005892-00006001": "deep", "BId3p79ZOdE-00026-00006002-00006238": "heat up with the wax in the woods and", "BId3p79ZOdE-00027-00006239-00006329": "that's where the [__] my homies", "BId3p79ZOdE-00028-00006330-00007128": "[__]", "BId3p79ZOdE-00029-00007129-00007447": "wanna see"}}, {"audio_id": "BI0bjURnpXk", "text": {"BI0bjURnpXk-00000-00000039-00000247": "just under 2000 meters it's hard to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00001-00000248-00000478": "imagine how a storm could have that okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00002-00000479-00000607": "i'm going to block balance and it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00003-00000608-00001607": "going to go black for a minute roger", "BI0bjURnpXk-00004-00001607-00001751": "can i actually can i keep double on the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00005-00001752-00002350": "front there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00006-00002351-00002534": "so as most of our viewers know what", "BI0bjURnpXk-00007-00002535-00002718": "they're doing now is calibrating the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00008-00002719-00002831": "camera", "BI0bjURnpXk-00009-00002832-00003007": "and the white balance on the camera at", "BI0bjURnpXk-00010-00003008-00003327": "the depth and color of the ocean that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00011-00003328-00003463": "we're at", "BI0bjURnpXk-00012-00003464-00003654": "and that's important for getting correct", "BI0bjURnpXk-00013-00003655-00004054": "color", "BI0bjURnpXk-00014-00004055-00004263": "if you don't white balance what you get", "BI0bjURnpXk-00015-00004264-00004575": "is a lot of a lot of blue tinged and off", "BI0bjURnpXk-00016-00004576-00004831": "color uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00017-00004832-00005006": "not the quite a matte right amount of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00018-00005007-00005286": "red uh particularly for the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00019-00005287-00005495": "coral cameras we have the shallow water", "BI0bjURnpXk-00020-00005496-00006791": "one so it's important to balance that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00021-00006792-00006919": "you have to do it every time because", "BI0bjURnpXk-00022-00006920-00007167": "your conditions are always changing", "BI0bjURnpXk-00023-00007168-00007375": "at the depths that you're going to the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00024-00007376-00008483": "location that you're in", "BI0bjURnpXk-00025-00008484-00008742": "okay it's looking good spl is not", "BI0bjURnpXk-00026-00008743-00008910": "looking great", "BI0bjURnpXk-00027-00008911-00009023": "nope", "BI0bjURnpXk-00028-00009024-00009295": "need to do something no not yet but if", "BI0bjURnpXk-00029-00009296-00009478": "it doesn't straighten itself out maybe", "BI0bjURnpXk-00030-00009479-00009631": "at some point", "BI0bjURnpXk-00031-00009632-00009871": "okay i don't know why that just started", "BI0bjURnpXk-00032-00009872-00010014": "yeah i no", "BI0bjURnpXk-00033-00010015-00010238": "it's out here to blame", "BI0bjURnpXk-00034-00010239-00010359": "um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00035-00010360-00010583": "you want to go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00036-00010584-00010767": "say again are you ready to go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00037-00010768-00010935": "i'm wondering if that turned and tripped", "BI0bjURnpXk-00038-00010936-00011167": "it into transponder or something", "BI0bjURnpXk-00039-00011168-00011446": "because this is power cycle um is there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00040-00011447-00011599": "a way you can query that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00041-00011600-00011838": "i i don't know i can look on sonar well", "BI0bjURnpXk-00042-00011839-00012046": "i mean sonardin was still going um i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00043-00012047-00012310": "kept seeing stuff come in", "BI0bjURnpXk-00044-00012311-00012519": "okay um i can scroll through", "BI0bjURnpXk-00045-00012520-00013015": "fixes", "BI0bjURnpXk-00046-00013016-00013175": "can i grab a bubble for a quick gauge", "BI0bjURnpXk-00047-00013176-00013758": "yeah go ahead", "BI0bjURnpXk-00048-00013759-00013999": "again continuous fixes", "BI0bjURnpXk-00049-00014000-00014335": "so i don't think so cool", "BI0bjURnpXk-00050-00014336-00014479": "oh we just did it and then it fixed", "BI0bjURnpXk-00051-00014480-00014615": "itself", "BI0bjURnpXk-00052-00014616-00014775": "oh no i just i don't think it power", "BI0bjURnpXk-00053-00014776-00014943": "cycles um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00054-00014944-00015086": "and i'm not ready to power cyclic", "BI0bjURnpXk-00055-00015087-00015263": "because it's not too bad yet but if we", "BI0bjURnpXk-00056-00015263-00015399": "get more of this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00057-00015400-00015519": "okay well sorry i thought you were", "BI0bjURnpXk-00058-00015519-00015607": "saying that you thought it might have", "BI0bjURnpXk-00059-00015608-00015807": "power cycles when you restarted the oh i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00060-00015808-00015919": "was thinking i might have done some", "BI0bjURnpXk-00061-00015919-00016175": "weird setting uh i don't i don't think", "BI0bjURnpXk-00062-00016176-00016439": "so but i don't know for sure okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00063-00016440-00016575": "okay uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00064-00016576-00016783": "cool as soon as antonella has done our", "BI0bjURnpXk-00065-00016784-00017030": "gauge checks we could do our start", "BI0bjURnpXk-00066-00017031-00017222": "ceremony and then be on our way i'm", "BI0bjURnpXk-00067-00017223-00017415": "ready", "BI0bjURnpXk-00068-00017416-00017671": "okay great are we ready yeah we're ready", "BI0bjURnpXk-00069-00017672-00017903": "okay okay great so for all of our", "BI0bjURnpXk-00070-00017904-00018030": "viewers", "BI0bjURnpXk-00071-00018031-00018350": "following us in adela's live.org", "BI0bjURnpXk-00072-00018351-00018671": "we have arrived to don quixote", "BI0bjURnpXk-00073-00018672-00019030": "at northwest and we are going to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00074-00019031-00019294": "go radio silent to conduct a private", "BI0bjURnpXk-00075-00019295-00019511": "ceremonial protocol to acknowledge and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00076-00019512-00019775": "honor the biocultural resources", "BI0bjURnpXk-00077-00019776-00019958": "that are present and that we are", "BI0bjURnpXk-00078-00019959-00020183": "interacting with and impacting so we'll", "BI0bjURnpXk-00079-00020184-00027799": "be back shortly thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00080-00027800-00027990": "all right back row you guys ready", "BI0bjURnpXk-00081-00027991-00028214": "we're ready all right we're ready", "BI0bjURnpXk-00082-00028216-00028374": "all right you wanna", "BI0bjURnpXk-00083-00028375-00028558": "just start going up the ridge", "BI0bjURnpXk-00084-00028560-00028774": "yeah let's take a look at uh since we", "BI0bjURnpXk-00085-00028775-00028927": "have some animals on the bottom from the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00086-00028927-00029079": "get-go let's take a look at what we've", "BI0bjURnpXk-00087-00029080-00029343": "got growing here okay sure so how about", "BI0bjURnpXk-00088-00029344-00029607": "that uh sort of fork bamboo to get", "BI0bjURnpXk-00089-00029608-00029751": "started", "BI0bjURnpXk-00090-00029752-00029999": "that's directly in the center of the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00091-00030000-00030414": "camera", "BI0bjURnpXk-00092-00030416-00030655": "i'm gonna use my toy here we go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00093-00030656-00031407": "right there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00094-00031408-00031695": "what's my toy called again tell us tell", "BI0bjURnpXk-00095-00031695-00032407": "us here i love that term", "BI0bjURnpXk-00096-00032408-00032551": "okay zoom in please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00097-00032552-00032735": "i have a note from the previous data", "BI0bjURnpXk-00098-00032736-00032927": "logger i'm not sure if it was started", "BI0bjURnpXk-00099-00032928-00033367": "but if we could start the still cam", "BI0bjURnpXk-00100-00033368-00033590": "where does that get started", "BI0bjURnpXk-00101-00033591-00033711": "um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00102-00033712-00034046": "it just says when we reach the bottom", "BI0bjURnpXk-00103-00034047-00034255": "i think i have control of that but do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00104-00034256-00034574": "you okay i think i can tap into it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00105-00034575-00034735": "okay i turned the power around at the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00106-00034736-00035023": "surface so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00107-00035024-00035351": "it's out of my hands thank you guys", "BI0bjURnpXk-00108-00035352-00035535": "well chris what do we got here um this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00109-00035536-00035711": "is a bamboo coral but could you look at", "BI0bjURnpXk-00110-00035712-00035902": "the one right behind it the smaller one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00111-00035903-00036007": "yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00112-00036008-00036239": "you have a chance i think so okay i do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00113-00036240-00036511": "not have it control of it it's gonna be", "BI0bjURnpXk-00114-00036512-00036830": "right up a little bit right there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00115-00036831-00037023": "all right that guy right there you got", "BI0bjURnpXk-00116-00037024-00037318": "some zoom for me", "BI0bjURnpXk-00117-00037319-00037455": "really far away", "BI0bjURnpXk-00118-00037456-00037943": "i do not have any more room for you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00119-00037944-00038087": "that's it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00120-00038088-00038271": "so the reason i'm looking at this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00121-00038272-00038471": "particular bamboo is we do have a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00122-00038472-00038743": "request in for one of these sparsely", "BI0bjURnpXk-00123-00038744-00038999": "branch bamboos and we've seen some but", "BI0bjURnpXk-00124-00039000-00039183": "they've all been too big", "BI0bjURnpXk-00125-00039184-00039295": "because", "BI0bjURnpXk-00126-00039296-00039511": "they it's very important to get the the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00127-00039512-00039790": "nodes or the joints where the branches", "BI0bjURnpXk-00128-00039791-00039911": "come out", "BI0bjURnpXk-00129-00039912-00040087": "i'm wondering if this is small enough", "BI0bjURnpXk-00130-00040088-00040295": "where this would actually", "BI0bjURnpXk-00131-00040296-00040495": "come wide please work do you do you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00132-00040496-00040679": "think you could actually get", "BI0bjURnpXk-00133-00040680-00040918": "most of the specimen because", "BI0bjURnpXk-00134-00040919-00041143": "or is it still a little bit too big to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00135-00041144-00041383": "kind of fold into a box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00136-00041384-00041679": "uh well", "BI0bjURnpXk-00137-00041680-00042083": "i think we could fold it into a box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00138-00042084-00042439": "um so make sure i understand the concept", "BI0bjURnpXk-00139-00042440-00042727": "the the goal is to gather the nodes", "BI0bjURnpXk-00140-00042728-00042983": "the branching area yeah and the problem", "BI0bjURnpXk-00141-00042984-00043174": "like this one in front is in order to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00142-00043175-00043335": "get that branching area we've got to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00143-00043336-00043567": "take so much of the top that it's a very", "BI0bjURnpXk-00144-00043568-00043758": "difficult collection but that one in the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00145-00043759-00043862": "back", "BI0bjURnpXk-00146-00043863-00044151": "is smaller it's smaller well the other", "BI0bjURnpXk-00147-00044152-00044335": "option available would be we could snip", "BI0bjURnpXk-00148-00044336-00044767": "off the top and then take the bottom", "BI0bjURnpXk-00149-00044768-00045039": "uh how it but you're", "BI0bjURnpXk-00150-00045040-00045215": "i'm not sure i understand how that would", "BI0bjURnpXk-00151-00045216-00045415": "work sorry frog in my throat yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00152-00045416-00045607": "imagine uh this bran so on the one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00153-00045608-00045751": "you're talking just to the right of the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00154-00045752-00045918": "lasers now right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00155-00045919-00046111": "see the big long branch on the left side", "BI0bjURnpXk-00156-00046112-00046439": "of it oh we could coral cutter that and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00157-00046440-00046655": "drop the top leave it behind and take", "BI0bjURnpXk-00158-00046656-00046846": "the rest of it i think that's a good", "BI0bjURnpXk-00159-00046847-00047079": "plan i think that could work", "BI0bjURnpXk-00160-00047080-00047230": "we could i don't know how brittle this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00161-00047231-00047358": "is but if it's flexible and kind of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00162-00047359-00047558": "bendy we could even slurp it it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00163-00047559-00047823": "flexible okay you want to try that yes", "BI0bjURnpXk-00164-00047824-00048046": "absolutely as long as i put a base first", "BI0bjURnpXk-00165-00048047-00048239": "right it's the it's the first one i've", "BI0bjURnpXk-00166-00048240-00048471": "seen that it even offers an opportunity", "BI0bjURnpXk-00167-00048472-00048543": "to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00168-00048544-00048758": "to fulfill that request i'll see if i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00169-00048759-00048855": "can", "BI0bjURnpXk-00170-00048856-00048974": "how do i get a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00171-00048975-00049127": "squeeze in here without landing on other", "BI0bjURnpXk-00172-00049128-00049358": "corals that's going to be the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00173-00049359-00050902": "problem here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00174-00050903-00051046": "i think this side's gonna be the best", "BI0bjURnpXk-00175-00051047-00053015": "bet", "BI0bjURnpXk-00176-00053016-00053535": "so a viewer wants to know if we cut", "BI0bjURnpXk-00177-00053536-00053726": "if we leave part of the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00178-00053727-00054191": "coral behind would it keep growing", "BI0bjURnpXk-00179-00054191-00054471": "yes the answer is yes it would", "BI0bjURnpXk-00180-00054472-00054726": "but under these circumstances there's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00181-00054727-00054982": "obviously some other colonies close by", "BI0bjURnpXk-00182-00054983-00055215": "of that same species we believe and this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00183-00055216-00055399": "one right in front of us this larger one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00184-00055400-00055591": "i believe is an older", "BI0bjURnpXk-00185-00055591-00055903": "uh one of the same that's behind it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00186-00055904-00056094": "and because it's so important for them", "BI0bjURnpXk-00187-00056095-00056382": "to get the the branch points on there we", "BI0bjURnpXk-00188-00056383-00056671": "would be taking most of the sponge", "BI0bjURnpXk-00189-00056672-00056879": "and leaving very little tissue on it so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00190-00056879-00057199": "it just says ask the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00191-00057200-00057919": "pilot or video engineer", "BI0bjURnpXk-00192-00057920-00058119": "sorry did you hear that aaron", "BI0bjURnpXk-00193-00058120-00058375": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00194-00058376-00058830": "um it says um pilot or video engineer", "BI0bjURnpXk-00195-00058832-00059063": "for the camera yeah camera is powered on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00196-00059064-00059271": "that's all i've got still cam now it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00197-00059272-00059447": "all i can do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00198-00059448-00059623": "thank you guys yeah it's on like it's on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00199-00059624-00059935": "a specific uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00200-00059936-00060630": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00201-00060632-00060830": "so before we sample this could we zoom", "BI0bjURnpXk-00202-00060832-00060982": "one more time and do a couple of them", "BI0bjURnpXk-00203-00060983-00061191": "one of them would be on the whole colony", "BI0bjURnpXk-00204-00061191-00061359": "that's as close as possible showing the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00205-00061360-00061479": "whole thing", "BI0bjURnpXk-00206-00061479-00061719": "and yeah secondly a close-up right at", "BI0bjURnpXk-00207-00061720-00061919": "the branch points as well and you stand", "BI0bjURnpXk-00208-00061920-00062015": "by two", "BI0bjURnpXk-00209-00062016-00062335": "i'm going to redo this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00210-00062336-00063599": "it's a little more stable here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00211-00063600-00063766": "that's better okay uh you can go ahead", "BI0bjURnpXk-00212-00063767-00063911": "and get the arm out and before we sample", "BI0bjURnpXk-00213-00063912-00064135": "it we'll get a zoom in on it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00214-00064136-00065638": "okay thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00215-00065639-00065806": "yeah roger we'll get the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00216-00065807-00066023": "nip out first", "BI0bjURnpXk-00217-00066024-00066175": "we might", "BI0bjURnpXk-00218-00066176-00066343": "be able to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00219-00066344-00066487": "uh slurping the whole thing will be too", "BI0bjURnpXk-00220-00066488-00068159": "long that won't work", "BI0bjURnpXk-00221-00068160-00068303": "okay then just get that off to the right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00222-00068304-00069111": "side there and then we'll do a zoom", "BI0bjURnpXk-00223-00069112-00069935": "um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00224-00069936-00070199": "so um sorry and antonella it's the one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00225-00070200-00070367": "in the back there if you could move the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00226-00070368-00070631": "arm a little bit more to the right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00227-00070632-00070887": "oh okay i'm sorry i was thinking she", "BI0bjURnpXk-00228-00070888-00071631": "was targeting that big one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00229-00071632-00071726": "yeah so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00230-00071727-00071862": "just get the arm out of the way for our", "BI0bjURnpXk-00231-00071863-00072647": "zoom oh sorry okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00232-00072648-00072823": "as soon as the arm is out of the way", "BI0bjURnpXk-00233-00072824-00073247": "yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00234-00073248-00073438": "that's good there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00235-00073439-00073662": "so first just the whole colony is tight", "BI0bjURnpXk-00236-00073663-00073847": "where you can get all of the branches", "BI0bjURnpXk-00237-00073848-00074126": "as close as possible", "BI0bjURnpXk-00238-00074127-00074350": "and maybe back out a little bit again", "BI0bjURnpXk-00239-00074351-00074655": "just to get the whole colony", "BI0bjURnpXk-00240-00074656-00074838": "right about there that's really nice", "BI0bjURnpXk-00241-00074839-00074991": "hold it for a little bit", "BI0bjURnpXk-00242-00074992-00075655": "and get rid of your lasers", "BI0bjURnpXk-00243-00075656-00075831": "okay and then if you could zoom maybe on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00244-00075832-00075991": "that close branch there so we can get a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00245-00075992-00076191": "look at the polyps", "BI0bjURnpXk-00246-00076192-00076615": "and the branch point", "BI0bjURnpXk-00247-00076616-00076838": "okay with another reset that's all the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00248-00076839-00077526": "zoom i have okay thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00249-00077527-00077719": "okay i think that'll do it so i thank", "BI0bjURnpXk-00250-00077720-00078111": "you very much appreciate it yep", "BI0bjURnpXk-00251-00078112-00078367": "so left branch we'll snip that off first", "BI0bjURnpXk-00252-00078368-00078526": "okay i have to turn the coral cutters", "BI0bjURnpXk-00253-00078527-00080006": "around 180.", "BI0bjURnpXk-00254-00080007-00080238": "perfect", "BI0bjURnpXk-00255-00080239-00080359": "before you get in there turn the coral", "BI0bjURnpXk-00256-00080360-00080719": "cutters around", "BI0bjURnpXk-00257-00080720-00080831": "there you go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00258-00080832-00080999": "speaking of black corals there's one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00259-00081000-00081215": "right behind it yeah a little bath about", "BI0bjURnpXk-00260-00081216-00081382": "the passages there's a meredith everett", "BI0bjURnpXk-00261-00081383-00081638": "uh had note that also there's a mushroom", "BI0bjURnpXk-00262-00081639-00081791": "coral right at the base of the big", "BI0bjURnpXk-00263-00081792-00081999": "bamboo yeah so like how much do you want", "BI0bjURnpXk-00264-00082000-00082623": "me to snip off on this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00265-00082624-00082894": "hetero polyp what is that just like", "BI0bjURnpXk-00266-00082895-00083167": "literal papas heteropolypus getting", "BI0bjURnpXk-00267-00083168-00083399": "better at saying that i like that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00268-00083400-00083638": "it makes me think of platypus for some", "BI0bjURnpXk-00269-00083639-00083782": "reason all this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00270-00083783-00083982": "is that helping or making it work", "BI0bjURnpXk-00271-00083983-00084862": "but silly bar", "BI0bjURnpXk-00272-00084863-00085094": "another one for you is if you wrist left", "BI0bjURnpXk-00273-00085095-00085375": "you can get that forearm out of the way", "BI0bjURnpXk-00274-00085376-00085518": "you know what i mean move the whole like", "BI0bjURnpXk-00275-00085519-00085655": "thing like that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00276-00085656-00085903": "yeah exactly keep that going", "BI0bjURnpXk-00277-00085904-00086511": "and you can see what you're doing", "BI0bjURnpXk-00278-00086512-00086703": "yeah there you go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00279-00086704-00086887": "okay and you call for zooms as you need", "BI0bjURnpXk-00280-00086888-00086959": "them", "BI0bjURnpXk-00281-00086960-00087438": "yeah can i get a half zoom", "BI0bjURnpXk-00282-00087439-00088247": "yeah perfect uh yeah keep it there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00283-00088248-00088543": "so just like 10 centimeters off of this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00284-00088544-00088855": "or yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00285-00088856-00089006": "you can go down closer to the node oh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00286-00089007-00089175": "that's fine yep good now give it a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00287-00089176-00089518": "little tiny twist with the wrist", "BI0bjURnpXk-00288-00089519-00089679": "a little bit tiny bit of wrist rotate", "BI0bjURnpXk-00289-00089680-00090023": "good and then now you can pull it away", "BI0bjURnpXk-00290-00090024-00090550": "oh maybe more twists on the wrist", "BI0bjURnpXk-00291-00090551-00090775": "that's not smooth", "BI0bjURnpXk-00292-00090776-00091647": "try grabbing it again", "BI0bjURnpXk-00293-00091648-00091855": "it might be just at the tip of the jaws", "BI0bjURnpXk-00294-00091856-00091999": "instead of in the knife part so i need", "BI0bjURnpXk-00295-00092000-00092487": "to redo it again", "BI0bjURnpXk-00296-00092488-00092687": "yeah i think it's you gotta go on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00297-00092688-00092823": "further there you go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00298-00092824-00093359": "uh maybe not yet no", "BI0bjURnpXk-00299-00093360-00093847": "oh sorry", "BI0bjURnpXk-00300-00093848-00094559": "that's it yeah you got it there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00301-00094560-00094726": "sorry i'm not sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00302-00094727-00096503": "good what would it be let that go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00303-00096504-00097223": "okay thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00304-00097224-00097335": "thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00305-00097336-00097487": "yeah good there you can hold the arm", "BI0bjURnpXk-00306-00097488-00097694": "there so i think we want to grab", "BI0bjURnpXk-00307-00097695-00097879": "again the same orientation of the coral", "BI0bjURnpXk-00308-00097880-00098071": "cutters coming below everything grab", "BI0bjURnpXk-00309-00098072-00098247": "that branch okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00310-00098248-00098455": "and bring it back", "BI0bjURnpXk-00311-00098456-00098599": "bring it back and we're going to feed it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00312-00098600-00098838": "bottom first so that the the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00313-00098839-00099047": "arms of the core will fold in", "BI0bjURnpXk-00314-00099048-00099191": "what i mean yep as it goes up the slurp", "BI0bjURnpXk-00315-00099192-00099391": "tube right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00316-00099392-00099631": "okay so yeah go in at your leisure and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00317-00099632-00099774": "uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00318-00099775-00099935": "once you got it we'll assess the next", "BI0bjURnpXk-00319-00099936-00100871": "steps", "BI0bjURnpXk-00320-00100872-00101726": "can i get a half zoom iron", "BI0bjURnpXk-00321-00101727-00103871": "sorry", "BI0bjURnpXk-00322-00103872-00104247": "yeah nice", "BI0bjURnpXk-00323-00104248-00104415": "pushing the vehicle", "BI0bjURnpXk-00324-00104416-00105343": "oh sorry", "BI0bjURnpXk-00325-00105344-00106686": "let's hold it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00326-00106688-00107727": "that's my bed", "BI0bjURnpXk-00327-00107728-00107895": "any chance you could move bubble up a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00328-00107896-00108854": "tiny bit", "BI0bjURnpXk-00329-00108855-00108990": "there you go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00330-00108991-00111415": "nice", "BI0bjURnpXk-00331-00111416-00111902": "great i'll just lift straight up", "BI0bjURnpXk-00332-00111903-00112415": "perfect okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00333-00112416-00112527": "if you line it up in front of that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00334-00112528-00112663": "suction hose", "BI0bjURnpXk-00335-00112664-00112871": "should be able to stay in place i'll", "BI0bjURnpXk-00336-00112872-00115447": "follow the arm down", "BI0bjURnpXk-00337-00115448-00115615": "so this is going to go into sample jar", "BI0bjURnpXk-00338-00115616-00115863": "one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00339-00115864-00115975": "thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00340-00115976-00116486": "i'm gonna set up", "BI0bjURnpXk-00341-00116488-00117639": "nothing", "BI0bjURnpXk-00342-00117640-00117854": "this might end up being a multi-grab it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00343-00117855-00117943": "might not", "BI0bjURnpXk-00344-00117944-00118102": "line up perfectly but we'll see what", "BI0bjURnpXk-00345-00118103-00118199": "happens", "BI0bjURnpXk-00346-00118200-00118839": "can you turn the valve on yeah sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00347-00118840-00119083": "there's 40", "BI0bjURnpXk-00348-00119083-00119463": "okay i'm gonna open it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00349-00119464-00119551": "yep", "BI0bjURnpXk-00350-00119552-00119895": "all right you can just re-grab it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00351-00119896-00120031": "and try and grab it with the tips of the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00352-00120032-00120254": "jaws okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00353-00120255-00120623": "even right there would be fine oh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00354-00120624-00120766": "sorry i shouldn't say oop that's not", "BI0bjURnpXk-00355-00120767-00122166": "helpful", "BI0bjURnpXk-00356-00122167-00122854": "it's not", "BI0bjURnpXk-00357-00122855-00123031": "if you need we can reposition the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00358-00123032-00123143": "vehicle let's see if you can get it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00359-00123144-00123302": "there first", "BI0bjURnpXk-00360-00123303-00123486": "is it worth just backing up and just", "BI0bjURnpXk-00361-00123488-00123671": "grabbing the slurp hose and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00362-00123672-00124143": "uh probably better to feed it in okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00363-00124144-00125847": "that way we can control the angle of it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00364-00125848-00126278": "it's right on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00365-00126279-00129151": "let me just bring it up a bit", "BI0bjURnpXk-00366-00129152-00129358": "you see it in her zoos too what's this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00367-00129359-00129447": "one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00368-00129448-00130199": "oh okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00369-00130200-00131695": "okay missing it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00370-00131696-00131943": "sorry yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00371-00131944-00132919": "okay pull the arm back", "BI0bjURnpXk-00372-00132920-00133039": "wait for the dust to clear we'll come", "BI0bjURnpXk-00373-00133040-00133975": "back we'll grab it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00374-00133976-00134111": "there's still current here which is nice", "BI0bjURnpXk-00375-00134112-00134319": "which means we'll", "BI0bjURnpXk-00376-00134320-00134631": "dust all clear and we'll come right back", "BI0bjURnpXk-00377-00134632-00134814": "your regularly scheduled programming", "BI0bjURnpXk-00378-00134815-00134919": "will be", "BI0bjURnpXk-00379-00134920-00135959": "back in a moment", "BI0bjURnpXk-00380-00135960-00138263": "you see it all right just above the yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00381-00138264-00140366": "that's stable that looks stable go ahead", "BI0bjURnpXk-00382-00140367-00140519": "remember use all the tools available to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00383-00140520-00140599": "you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00384-00140600-00140775": "including", "BI0bjURnpXk-00385-00140776-00141054": "aaron rainey", "BI0bjURnpXk-00386-00141055-00141151": "yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00387-00141152-00142302": "can i get a tool", "BI0bjURnpXk-00388-00142303-00142559": "i'm a tool that's not what i meant i'm", "BI0bjURnpXk-00389-00142560-00144359": "sorry", "BI0bjURnpXk-00390-00144360-00144543": "now if you can grab it farther up you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00391-00144544-00144695": "can actually stick the end that you've", "BI0bjURnpXk-00392-00144696-00144966": "got into the hose before letting go you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00393-00144967-00145143": "follow me yep i do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00394-00145144-00145911": "let me regrab", "BI0bjURnpXk-00395-00145912-00146063": "you might yeah i can't tell if it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00396-00146064-00146278": "sticking out right now or not", "BI0bjURnpXk-00397-00146279-00146566": "if it's sticking out you're good to go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00398-00146567-00146790": "let me", "BI0bjURnpXk-00399-00146791-00147031": "just rotate really there's a fish right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00400-00147032-00147247": "above hercules for the back row to look", "BI0bjURnpXk-00401-00147248-00147687": "at it just swam over it there it is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00402-00147688-00147935": "goodbye fish oh that looks pretty big", "BI0bjURnpXk-00403-00147936-00149175": "that fish", "BI0bjURnpXk-00404-00149176-00149423": "it's right in that little groove", "BI0bjURnpXk-00405-00149424-00149735": "located", "BI0bjURnpXk-00406-00149736-00150047": "it found a local minima", "BI0bjURnpXk-00407-00150048-00154126": "minimum", "BI0bjURnpXk-00408-00154127-00154375": "damn you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00409-00154376-00154535": "there's a gap here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00410-00154536-00156519": "get into", "BI0bjURnpXk-00411-00156520-00157487": "thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00412-00157488-00157631": "you're running into this rock try to go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00413-00157632-00158478": "beside it uh okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00414-00158479-00159543": "yeah right in there exactly", "BI0bjURnpXk-00415-00159544-00160423": "there's potential there yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00416-00160424-00160775": "yeah good nice", "BI0bjURnpXk-00417-00160776-00161695": "lovely", "BI0bjURnpXk-00418-00161696-00161799": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00419-00161800-00163447": "zoom one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00420-00163448-00163599": "once you get the end of that into the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00421-00163600-00164702": "hose i'll turn it on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00422-00164703-00164831": "it's going to present its own problems", "BI0bjURnpXk-00423-00164832-00164999": "because it's kind of sticking up into", "BI0bjURnpXk-00424-00165000-00165214": "your armpit yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00425-00165215-00167126": "not trivial but i think he'll get there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00426-00167127-00174383": "watch bubble kim", "BI0bjURnpXk-00427-00174384-00175526": "you got the right idea", "BI0bjURnpXk-00428-00175527-00176526": "if you want sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00429-00176527-00176695": "sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00430-00176696-00176854": "you have the right idea there it's just", "BI0bjURnpXk-00431-00176855-00176959": "gotta", "BI0bjURnpXk-00432-00176960-00177511": "take a lot of shoulder down", "BI0bjURnpXk-00433-00177512-00177678": "and once you get close can you zoom in", "BI0bjURnpXk-00434-00177679-00177895": "please aaron", "BI0bjURnpXk-00435-00177896-00178102": "so you have their totally right stance", "BI0bjURnpXk-00436-00178103-00178247": "and then the shoulder down it gets you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00437-00178248-00178366": "there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00438-00178367-00178638": "do a slow kind of rotate roll shoulder", "BI0bjURnpXk-00439-00178639-00181783": "down combo", "BI0bjURnpXk-00440-00181784-00181919": "and i don't think i'm actually able to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00441-00181920-00182071": "stab the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00442-00182072-00182207": "thing into the hose but we can get it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00443-00182208-00182407": "close oh bubble come on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00444-00182408-00182854": "really", "BI0bjURnpXk-00445-00182855-00183007": "okay you can turn the suction on now", "BI0bjURnpXk-00446-00183008-00183447": "hopefully i can", "BI0bjURnpXk-00447-00183448-00183831": "40 sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00448-00183832-00184143": "let's get it started", "BI0bjURnpXk-00449-00184144-00184278": "oh almost", "BI0bjURnpXk-00450-00184279-00184431": "there we go and hopefully that'll just", "BI0bjURnpXk-00451-00184432-00184535": "go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00452-00184536-00185166": "just go i say", "BI0bjURnpXk-00453-00185167-00185575": "come on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00454-00185576-00185759": "get there all right let's get more", "BI0bjURnpXk-00455-00185760-00185902": "percent", "BI0bjURnpXk-00456-00185903-00186487": "maybe 70.", "BI0bjURnpXk-00457-00186488-00187254": "how bendy is this chris", "BI0bjURnpXk-00458-00187255-00187575": "they're gonna go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00459-00187576-00187711": "now's the last chance to bail out i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00460-00187712-00188087": "don't think it's gonna go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00461-00188088-00188375": "can we put this in a box maybe", "BI0bjURnpXk-00462-00188376-00188607": "yeah sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00463-00188608-00188750": "yeah the slurps working i can see the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00464-00188751-00188926": "flow through the jar but it's not gonna", "BI0bjURnpXk-00465-00188927-00189078": "suck it through i don't think it's quite", "BI0bjURnpXk-00466-00189079-00189263": "it's too grippy", "BI0bjURnpXk-00467-00189264-00189423": "well let's go ahead and pull it out so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00468-00189424-00189623": "it didn't clog up the zero percentage", "BI0bjURnpXk-00469-00189624-00190047": "section", "BI0bjURnpXk-00470-00190048-00190702": "let's grab that better", "BI0bjURnpXk-00471-00190703-00191023": "the actual person's uh dr scott france", "BI0bjURnpXk-00472-00191024-00191231": "is on the line right now", "BI0bjURnpXk-00473-00191232-00191575": "and he's watching this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00474-00191576-00191831": "so he thinks this is the one that he was", "BI0bjURnpXk-00475-00191832-00192190": "looking for", "BI0bjURnpXk-00476-00192191-00192383": "tried slurping this uh scott now we're", "BI0bjURnpXk-00477-00192384-00192543": "gonna it didn't quite work so we're", "BI0bjURnpXk-00478-00192544-00192766": "gonna try to uh put this in one of the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00479-00192767-00193190": "side boxes", "BI0bjURnpXk-00480-00193191-00193359": "i'm gonna switch your camera", "BI0bjURnpXk-00481-00193360-00193519": "standby", "BI0bjURnpXk-00482-00193520-00193663": "oh yes you can yeah you can search the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00483-00193664-00196023": "cameras", "BI0bjURnpXk-00484-00196024-00196431": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00485-00196432-00196638": "that was very grippy in there expecting", "BI0bjURnpXk-00486-00196639-00196854": "that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00487-00196855-00197790": "expecting to be a lot softer", "BI0bjURnpXk-00488-00197791-00201238": "okay box out please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00489-00201239-00201326": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00490-00201327-00201590": "that's in delta d", "BI0bjURnpXk-00491-00201591-00201902": "got it thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00492-00201903-00202223": "and that was sample um number zero seven", "BI0bjURnpXk-00493-00202224-00202399": "three", "BI0bjURnpXk-00494-00202400-00202623": "okay i'll take forward view please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00495-00202624-00202799": "can you repeat the sample number sorry", "BI0bjURnpXk-00496-00202800-00203083": "oh yeah um zero seven three zero seven", "BI0bjURnpXk-00497-00203084-00203375": "zero oh three sorry zero seven three yep", "BI0bjURnpXk-00498-00203376-00204278": "all right copy thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00499-00204279-00204487": "okay boxes are closed i can captioning", "BI0bjURnpXk-00500-00204488-00205998": "not available", "BI0bjURnpXk-00501-00206000-00206134": "got there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00502-00206135-00206238": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00503-00206239-00206479": "um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00504-00206480-00206655": "let's see why don't we make some", "BI0bjURnpXk-00505-00206656-00207166": "distance here sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00506-00207167-00207310": "so do you want us to stay on the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00507-00207311-00207494": "northeast or southwest side of this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00508-00207496-00207798": "ridge um let's take a look and again do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00509-00207800-00208014": "the the old follow the corals bit see", "BI0bjURnpXk-00510-00208015-00208158": "which one is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00511-00208159-00208294": "okay we'll head straight up slope then", "BI0bjURnpXk-00512-00208296-00208671": "for now okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00513-00208671-00209127": "which is probably 180 i think", "BI0bjURnpXk-00514-00209128-00209271": "close yeah sure sounds good you ready", "BI0bjURnpXk-00515-00209271-00209486": "for a move yes uh you want to start with", "BI0bjURnpXk-00516-00209487-00209638": "20 meters or bigger", "BI0bjURnpXk-00517-00209639-00209887": "uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00518-00209888-00210015": "let's start with 20 meters i think it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00519-00210016-00210119": "might be", "BI0bjURnpXk-00520-00210119-00210439": "five one six five why is my original", "BI0bjURnpXk-00521-00210440-00210742": "165 20 meters", "BI0bjURnpXk-00522-00210744-00211567": "bridge enough", "BI0bjURnpXk-00523-00211567-00211791": "uh good morning can we get a 2-0 meter", "BI0bjURnpXk-00524-00211792-00212110": "step bearing 165.", "BI0bjURnpXk-00525-00212111-00212494": "thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00526-00212496-00212679": "like we've got some other species of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00527-00212680-00212958": "bamboo there over on the left side a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00528-00212959-00213103": "little more", "BI0bjURnpXk-00529-00213104-00213310": "squishy ones", "BI0bjURnpXk-00530-00213311-00213623": "looks like a couple of bushy ones", "BI0bjURnpXk-00531-00213623-00213775": "these little stalks coming into the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00532-00213776-00213942": "center top there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00533-00213944-00214215": "yeah these colonies adhere on the left", "BI0bjURnpXk-00534-00214216-00214415": "here those are bamboos as well but", "BI0bjURnpXk-00535-00214416-00214558": "they're different species they have a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00536-00214559-00214871": "lot more branches too oh really yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00537-00214871-00215046": "this is actually a good start for this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00538-00215048-00215223": "dive we've got a fair number of animals", "BI0bjURnpXk-00539-00215223-00215455": "on the bottom so it bodes well", "BI0bjURnpXk-00540-00215456-00221487": "for how this is going to go today", "BI0bjURnpXk-00541-00221488-00221631": "a couple of sponges over here it looks", "BI0bjURnpXk-00542-00221632-00222294": "like", "BI0bjURnpXk-00543-00222296-00222503": "yeah it kind of looks like the same", "BI0bjURnpXk-00544-00222504-00222663": "beast that we were", "BI0bjURnpXk-00545-00222664-00222871": "that we had collected before but we can", "BI0bjURnpXk-00546-00222871-00223175": "do some snap zooms just to confirm", "BI0bjURnpXk-00547-00223176-00224991": "yeah you bet", "BI0bjURnpXk-00548-00224992-00225775": "okay zoom in there please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00549-00225776-00225879": "well", "BI0bjURnpXk-00550-00225880-00226039": "huh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00551-00226040-00226198": "it's interesting it's attached to the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00552-00226200-00226855": "bottom no no it's non-stopped", "BI0bjURnpXk-00553-00226856-00227015": "i don't see any grappling hook feet", "BI0bjURnpXk-00554-00227016-00227134": "either", "BI0bjURnpXk-00555-00227135-00227558": "yeah let's see what i see", "BI0bjURnpXk-00556-00227559-00227831": "oh it's touched the rock there oh wow on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00557-00227832-00227942": "the right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00558-00227944-00228087": "yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00559-00228088-00228303": "um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00560-00228304-00228463": "i've just spent a fair amount of time", "BI0bjURnpXk-00561-00228464-00228631": "collecting so i'm a little bit reluctant", "BI0bjURnpXk-00562-00228632-00228839": "to try to go for it again", "BI0bjURnpXk-00563-00228840-00229039": "this is an interesting sponge we can do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00564-00229040-00229310": "a quick sample here no problem", "BI0bjURnpXk-00565-00229311-00229503": "it won't take that long will it it was i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00566-00229504-00229775": "don't think so now hold position", "BI0bjURnpXk-00567-00229776-00229998": "well um yeah this is uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00568-00230000-00230263": "come wide please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00569-00230264-00230415": "this is going to be a very brittle", "BI0bjURnpXk-00570-00230416-00230567": "sponge and the only reason i'm thinking", "BI0bjURnpXk-00571-00230567-00230703": "of this is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00572-00230704-00230910": "is it possible to grab the rock that the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00573-00230911-00231110": "sponge is on as long as it's not", "BI0bjURnpXk-00574-00231111-00231431": "attached to mother earth then", "BI0bjURnpXk-00575-00231432-00231510": "sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00576-00231511-00231606": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00577-00231607-00231734": "because i think it's going to be one of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00578-00231735-00231919": "these that's fairly fragile that's the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00579-00231919-00232223": "same coral rock stop that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00580-00232223-00232663": "yeah that would be a great idea we can", "BI0bjURnpXk-00581-00232664-00234575": "you come down to delta please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00582-00234576-00236358": "that should be good there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00583-00236359-00236575": "also we have a rock request and i see", "BI0bjURnpXk-00584-00236576-00236806": "one to the left of that sponge too", "BI0bjURnpXk-00585-00236807-00237015": "before we move off if we get the sponge", "BI0bjURnpXk-00586-00237016-00237182": "in the box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00587-00237183-00237575": "okay zoom in there please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00588-00237576-00237679": "good there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00589-00237680-00237846": "um are you talking about", "BI0bjURnpXk-00590-00237848-00237982": "this rock", "BI0bjURnpXk-00591-00237983-00238094": "i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00592-00238096-00238223": "we're a little zoomed in but i think", "BI0bjURnpXk-00593-00238223-00238406": "that's right you could even do this rock", "BI0bjURnpXk-00594-00238407-00238575": "here any rocket", "BI0bjURnpXk-00595-00238576-00238751": "you're looking for one that's about 15", "BI0bjURnpXk-00596-00238752-00238927": "centimeters so it looks like", "BI0bjURnpXk-00597-00238928-00239127": "that one to the left might be about that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00598-00239128-00239319": "size now if they're going to share a box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00599-00239319-00239479": "i would like to put the rock in first so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00600-00239480-00239767": "we don't smash this sponge", "BI0bjURnpXk-00601-00239767-00240023": "i don't know if they should share a box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00602-00240023-00240215": "the rock and the sponge i mean the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00603-00240216-00240391": "sponge is on a rock but", "BI0bjURnpXk-00604-00240392-00240639": "sure no i think the sponge ought to have", "BI0bjURnpXk-00605-00240640-00240742": "its own", "BI0bjURnpXk-00606-00240744-00240846": "sounds good", "BI0bjURnpXk-00607-00240848-00241151": "on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00608-00241152-00241358": "spot", "BI0bjURnpXk-00609-00241359-00241510": "see what we got here what are we working", "BI0bjURnpXk-00610-00241511-00241591": "with", "BI0bjURnpXk-00611-00241592-00242351": "who's that little guy okay perfect", "BI0bjURnpXk-00612-00242352-00242591": "so this is zoom in please in one of two", "BI0bjURnpXk-00613-00242592-00242855": "families this is either you read it or", "BI0bjURnpXk-00614-00242856-00243206": "it's something that we call uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00615-00243207-00243287": "oh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00616-00243288-00243430": "actually i'm", "BI0bjURnpXk-00617-00243431-00243582": "sure it's one of these they're not even", "BI0bjURnpXk-00618-00243583-00243758": "sure what family if it's this other", "BI0bjURnpXk-00619-00243759-00244223": "thing", "BI0bjURnpXk-00620-00244223-00244382": "you can put on this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00621-00244383-00244542": "side there okay i'm on the starboard", "BI0bjURnpXk-00622-00244544-00244663": "side", "BI0bjURnpXk-00623-00244664-00244879": "just keep in mind that the sponge", "BI0bjURnpXk-00624-00244880-00245246": "touches anything it's gonna fragment so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00625-00245248-00246006": "it's a very careful collection", "BI0bjURnpXk-00626-00246007-00246215": "did you get some stills", "BI0bjURnpXk-00627-00246216-00246567": "on that one okay come", "BI0bjURnpXk-00628-00246567-00246734": "you on up bubble a bit", "BI0bjURnpXk-00629-00246735-00246879": "just up", "BI0bjURnpXk-00630-00246880-00247415": "good one more yeah right there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00631-00247416-00247646": "i'm gonna try and do this really", "BI0bjURnpXk-00632-00247648-00248046": "slowly and carefully yeah this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00633-00248048-00248334": "is see how fragile it is all right it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00634-00248335-00249406": "it's fragile almost guarantee it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00635-00249407-00249606": "this one of these", "BI0bjURnpXk-00636-00249607-00249798": "hetero hetero eat", "BI0bjURnpXk-00637-00249800-00250030": "at a root", "BI0bjURnpXk-00638-00250031-00250319": "sponges chris excuse me so like this one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00639-00250319-00250591": "this uh that's a possibility", "BI0bjURnpXk-00640-00250592-00250927": "and it also could be uh in the um ureted", "BI0bjURnpXk-00641-00250928-00251151": "family it could be a smaller version of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00642-00251152-00251230": "this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00643-00251231-00251615": "one that's been problematic", "BI0bjURnpXk-00644-00251616-00251806": "you can typically tell by the size of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00645-00251807-00252230": "the pores the yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00646-00252231-00252479": "and this uh heterorite is also one of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00647-00252480-00252687": "these that's undescribed", "BI0bjURnpXk-00648-00252688-00255310": "as well", "BI0bjURnpXk-00649-00255311-00256687": "okay sample salvo please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00650-00256688-00260327": "and stand by do not open the box yet", "BI0bjURnpXk-00651-00260328-00260815": "okay uh you can open the box now", "BI0bjURnpXk-00652-00260816-00261039": "we'll go all the way we'll put that in", "BI0bjURnpXk-00653-00261040-00261894": "charlie", "BI0bjURnpXk-00654-00261896-00262071": "i think i'll fit one of the small ones", "BI0bjURnpXk-00655-00262071-00262358": "maybe yeah i think so okay come on halt", "BI0bjURnpXk-00656-00262359-00262471": "halt", "BI0bjURnpXk-00657-00262472-00262695": "halt", "BI0bjURnpXk-00658-00262696-00263119": "button is obnoxious", "BI0bjURnpXk-00659-00263120-00264439": "oh i don't want to go that way", "BI0bjURnpXk-00660-00264440-00264606": "i'm just gonna drop it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00661-00264607-00264863": "yeah that looks good", "BI0bjURnpXk-00662-00264864-00265030": "oh i think it detached from the rock", "BI0bjURnpXk-00663-00265031-00265223": "that's okay as long as oh don't float", "BI0bjURnpXk-00664-00265224-00265463": "away come on we come this far on our", "BI0bjURnpXk-00665-00265464-00265591": "journey", "BI0bjURnpXk-00666-00265592-00265815": "oh no are you kidding me", "BI0bjURnpXk-00667-00265816-00266023": "i gotta stuff now that's okay that's all", "BI0bjURnpXk-00668-00266024-00266151": "right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00669-00266152-00266447": "okay close that box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00670-00266448-00266743": "that'll work that's perfect", "BI0bjURnpXk-00671-00266744-00266982": "that was absurd you did a great job", "BI0bjURnpXk-00672-00266983-00267271": "getting it there okay so let's go for", "BI0bjURnpXk-00673-00267272-00267487": "the rock and the one we're looking at is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00674-00267488-00267758": "this guy right there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00675-00267759-00268023": "nice rock it's about that roger", "BI0bjURnpXk-00676-00268024-00268199": "and then we also have a request for a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00677-00268200-00268391": "water sample so we're gonna do a three", "BI0bjURnpXk-00678-00268392-00268679": "for here three four three four oh box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00679-00268680-00268887": "see just double check that was box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00680-00268888-00269103": "charlie correct thank you let's take a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00681-00269104-00269327": "look at this rock before it goes sure", "BI0bjURnpXk-00682-00269328-00269582": "let me even put some lasers on it i want", "BI0bjURnpXk-00683-00269583-00269758": "to make sure it's thick enough if it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00684-00269759-00269879": "tooth", "BI0bjURnpXk-00685-00269880-00270103": "oh i'm sorry that's not the rock the one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00686-00270104-00270727": "is over to the left", "BI0bjURnpXk-00687-00270728-00270943": "i think if that's not too big this one i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00688-00270944-00271191": "just circled might be roger i moved your", "BI0bjURnpXk-00689-00271192-00271855": "circle for you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00690-00271856-00272006": "boom it's too big", "BI0bjURnpXk-00691-00272007-00272279": "part of the planet okay uh how about", "BI0bjURnpXk-00692-00272280-00272519": "down below to the left let's see this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00693-00272520-00272991": "one yeah some one of those in there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00694-00272992-00273247": "it's terrible that's crusty i think", "BI0bjURnpXk-00695-00273248-00273510": "krusty yeah it's too thin", "BI0bjURnpXk-00696-00273511-00273599": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00697-00273600-00273839": "now what how about the next one that was", "BI0bjURnpXk-00698-00273840-00274087": "over this one here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00699-00274088-00274671": "roger", "BI0bjURnpXk-00700-00274672-00274799": "that's angular", "BI0bjURnpXk-00701-00274800-00275927": "go ahead zoom", "BI0bjURnpXk-00702-00275928-00276199": "let's see if", "BI0bjURnpXk-00703-00276200-00276439": "yeah let's go ahead with that one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00704-00276440-00276534": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00705-00276535-00276999": "come on please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00706-00277000-00277415": "any luck that's not just crust it's uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00707-00277416-00277910": "so it's got some basalt in there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00708-00277911-00278055": "then we'll get water and then i'm going", "BI0bjURnpXk-00709-00278056-00278175": "to regroup we're going to need to do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00710-00278176-00278399": "some community surveying", "BI0bjURnpXk-00711-00278400-00278599": "community survey community serving we're", "BI0bjURnpXk-00712-00278600-00278791": "going to do a survey of the community", "BI0bjURnpXk-00713-00278792-00278934": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00714-00278935-00279158": "like the census", "BI0bjURnpXk-00715-00279159-00279582": "i like the senses okay sample please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00716-00279583-00279695": "and now we get to see if this is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00717-00279696-00280430": "pandora's box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00718-00280431-00280599": "so will this you want a big box or a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00719-00280600-00280719": "small box", "BI0bjURnpXk-00720-00280720-00280895": "um you can put it in a big and then", "BI0bjURnpXk-00721-00280896-00281039": "we'll put a couple in the big one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00722-00281040-00281199": "because you only have to slide that out", "BI0bjURnpXk-00723-00281200-00281423": "part way right correct yeah let's go", "BI0bjURnpXk-00724-00281424-00281806": "with that keep the sponge from drifting", "BI0bjURnpXk-00725-00281807-00281991": "woo don't do that but either either one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00726-00281992-00282215": "you know would work foxtrot", "BI0bjURnpXk-00727-00282216-00282703": "great thank you very much box watch", "BI0bjURnpXk-00728-00282704-00282934": "okay you saw which one that went into", "BI0bjURnpXk-00729-00282935-00283527": "great thank you thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00730-00283528-00284079": "i got niskanen cam please and dive salvo", "BI0bjURnpXk-00731-00284080-00284271": "aaron just want to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00732-00284272-00284558": "show you this dive salvo", "BI0bjURnpXk-00733-00284559-00284910": "i'll do the real dive salvo", "BI0bjURnpXk-00734-00284911-00285447": "i did the butt cam there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00735-00285448-00285639": "sorry what was that that was when we did", "BI0bjURnpXk-00736-00285640-00285839": "the dive salvo and put butt cam where", "BI0bjURnpXk-00737-00285840-00286071": "before or now", "BI0bjURnpXk-00738-00286072-00286287": "just now and then i changed it again", "BI0bjURnpXk-00739-00286288-00288599": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00740-00288600-00288734": "you got it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00741-00288735-00289087": "okay perfect", "BI0bjURnpXk-00742-00289088-00289310": "okay let's see we got water we got rocks", "BI0bjURnpXk-00743-00289311-00289527": "we got a sponge we got coral", "BI0bjURnpXk-00744-00289528-00289710": "we've got it all we can recover yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00745-00289711-00290071": "that's it nothing no nothing to do", "BI0bjURnpXk-00746-00290072-00290543": "with fish", "BI0bjURnpXk-00747-00290544-00290703": "so the samples look right seven four", "BI0bjURnpXk-00748-00290704-00290991": "seven five seven six yes thank you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00749-00290992-00291310": "look at this falling everywhere", "BI0bjURnpXk-00750-00291311-00291630": "okay that last game was okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00751-00291631-00291847": "now we're doing our census yeah this is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00752-00291848-00292039": "kind of sampling for the deep sea coral", "BI0bjURnpXk-00753-00292040-00292295": "program to give them some distance here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00754-00292296-00292454": "to see what the community as a whole", "BI0bjURnpXk-00755-00292455-00292591": "looks like", "BI0bjURnpXk-00756-00292592-00292767": "maybe we'll do some snap zooms on the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00757-00292768-00293047": "way as far as we can we'll start a ship", "BI0bjURnpXk-00758-00293048-00293230": "move then", "BI0bjURnpXk-00759-00293231-00293406": "yeah that would be great", "BI0bjURnpXk-00760-00293407-00293743": "all right back to 165 yeah roger", "BI0bjURnpXk-00761-00293744-00294487": "original", "BI0bjURnpXk-00762-00294488-00295039": "uh two zero meters bearing 165.", "BI0bjURnpXk-00763-00295040-00295358": "right and we're off okay it's another", "BI0bjURnpXk-00764-00295359-00295575": "one of those glass sponges you read it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00765-00295576-00295799": "there was a candela gigantia that was on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00766-00295800-00295991": "the bottom and there was a xenometric", "BI0bjURnpXk-00767-00295992-00296215": "crinoid that we were so focused on the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00768-00296216-00296406": "collection he's one of these sea lilies", "BI0bjURnpXk-00769-00296407-00296615": "that was attached to oh neat", "BI0bjURnpXk-00770-00296616-00296839": "that was", "BI0bjURnpXk-00771-00296840-00297071": "really beautiful are these all", "BI0bjURnpXk-00772-00297072-00297343": "dead corals that we're looking at yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00773-00297344-00297479": "yeah red one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00774-00297480-00297734": "so this is uh really nice to start off", "BI0bjURnpXk-00775-00297735-00297958": "with this this could develop into a very", "BI0bjURnpXk-00776-00297959-00298215": "nice community yeah this is great it's a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00777-00298216-00298534": "branching ice a day one of our viewers", "BI0bjURnpXk-00778-00298535-00298767": "is wondering if the increase in life is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00779-00298768-00298975": "due to more optimal currents not being", "BI0bjURnpXk-00780-00298976-00299206": "blocked by the sea mount and you can", "BI0bjURnpXk-00781-00299207-00299447": "tell your viewer that i believe so i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00782-00299448-00299695": "think he's absolutely right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00783-00299696-00299919": "but", "BI0bjURnpXk-00784-00299920-00300079": "but we're not sure of course but we", "BI0bjURnpXk-00785-00300080-00300351": "think so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00786-00300352-00300551": "yeah thank you for the question and the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00787-00300552-00301263": "answer", "BI0bjURnpXk-00788-00301264-00301399": "what's the one on the top right corner", "BI0bjURnpXk-00789-00301400-00301471": "there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00790-00301472-00301782": "top right corner coral oh can we do a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00791-00301783-00302119": "snap soon yeah you better feel it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00792-00302120-00302671": "go ahead and zoom there please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00793-00302672-00302815": "now that i have a terrible angle to see", "BI0bjURnpXk-00794-00302816-00302943": "it perfect", "BI0bjURnpXk-00795-00302944-00303063": "sorry about that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00796-00303064-00303271": "so this is a prim noah thank you for", "BI0bjURnpXk-00797-00303272-00303487": "pointing that out um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00798-00303488-00303663": "this is um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00799-00303664-00303823": "probably the first one of these that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00800-00303824-00303999": "we've seen on this cruise it's called", "BI0bjURnpXk-00801-00304000-00304295": "calyptophora angularis i believe and i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00802-00304296-00304454": "think it's one of the first of that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00803-00304455-00304663": "genus that we have", "BI0bjURnpXk-00804-00304664-00304758": "imaged", "BI0bjURnpXk-00805-00304759-00305039": "and what am i looking at well angularis", "BI0bjURnpXk-00806-00305040-00305279": "tends to have sort of these two", "BI0bjURnpXk-00807-00305280-00305487": "branches sometimes a few more that kind", "BI0bjURnpXk-00808-00305488-00305863": "of wing out in a sort of a big wide v", "BI0bjURnpXk-00809-00305864-00306039": "and then all the sub branches that come", "BI0bjURnpXk-00810-00306040-00306239": "off of it they're all about the same", "BI0bjURnpXk-00811-00306240-00306351": "length", "BI0bjURnpXk-00812-00306352-00306430": "and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00813-00306431-00306615": "you think that that's not such a big", "BI0bjURnpXk-00814-00306616-00306823": "deal but then what that means is the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00815-00306824-00306975": "inner branches which would be the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00816-00306976-00307191": "youngest or the oldest branches they", "BI0bjURnpXk-00817-00307192-00307391": "kind of stop growing", "BI0bjURnpXk-00818-00307392-00307654": "so as the lateral branches grow out then", "BI0bjURnpXk-00819-00307655-00307887": "you get new ones that stop growing so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00820-00307888-00308079": "that there's uniformity", "BI0bjURnpXk-00821-00308080-00308295": "of the branchlets all along the stem", "BI0bjURnpXk-00822-00308296-00308534": "there a lot of the other clipped or four", "BI0bjURnpXk-00823-00308535-00308727": "you can see the bridge the other ones", "BI0bjURnpXk-00824-00308728-00308854": "and they're steps", "BI0bjURnpXk-00825-00308855-00309087": "and so in the center they're the tallest", "BI0bjURnpXk-00826-00309088-00309287": "and out toward the edges they're the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00827-00309288-00309487": "smallest because they're the newest ones", "BI0bjURnpXk-00828-00309488-00309591": "yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00829-00309592-00309743": "it's pretty interesting and i don't know", "BI0bjURnpXk-00830-00309744-00309910": "what's that do you think we'll see more", "BI0bjURnpXk-00831-00309911-00310143": "i don't know if we got uh still shots on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00832-00310144-00310295": "that one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00833-00310296-00310615": "uh caliptophora angularis", "BI0bjURnpXk-00834-00310616-00310958": "do you think we'll see", "BI0bjURnpXk-00835-00310959-00311039": "let's more", "BI0bjURnpXk-00836-00311040-00311182": "um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00837-00311183-00311327": "go ahead and bring up a picture of that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00838-00311328-00311519": "for kain olu", "BI0bjURnpXk-00839-00311520-00311775": "and you guys to take a look at i can", "BI0bjURnpXk-00840-00311776-00311975": "find my corals", "BI0bjURnpXk-00841-00311976-00312119": "so one that looks different than the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00842-00312120-00312382": "others which one is not like the others", "BI0bjURnpXk-00843-00312383-00312871": "let's do a zoom on this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00844-00312872-00312975": "aha", "BI0bjURnpXk-00845-00312976-00313319": "okay so that's a bamboo on the right and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00846-00313320-00313463": "probably a different species that one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00847-00313464-00313751": "we've seen and on the left is a para", "BI0bjURnpXk-00848-00313752-00313943": "or bubblegum coral", "BI0bjURnpXk-00849-00313944-00314239": "that has its characteristic zoanthid", "BI0bjURnpXk-00850-00314240-00314406": "overgrowing a lot of the branches and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00851-00314407-00314630": "that's the yellow so the paragorgia is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00852-00314631-00314751": "the red", "BI0bjURnpXk-00853-00314752-00314895": "that's what's actually attached to the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00854-00314896-00315054": "substrate", "BI0bjURnpXk-00855-00315055-00315239": "and then the yellow is this sort of", "BI0bjURnpXk-00856-00315240-00315599": "colonial zoanthid that's associated very", "BI0bjURnpXk-00857-00315600-00315879": "closely with it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00858-00315880-00316071": "and all i can think of is part of the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00859-00316072-00316191": "name it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00860-00316192-00316430": "emily acacia something rather because", "BI0bjURnpXk-00861-00316431-00316654": "this is named by", "BI0bjURnpXk-00862-00316655-00316830": "an expert for the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00863-00316831-00317110": "imibaco taylor's kids", "BI0bjURnpXk-00864-00317111-00317263": "of all things so", "BI0bjURnpXk-00865-00317264-00317958": "kind of interesting", "BI0bjURnpXk-00866-00317959-00318119": "so this little on the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00867-00318120-00318310": "right of the lasers right on the little", "BI0bjURnpXk-00868-00318311-00318503": "pointy bit of that rock you see the v", "BI0bjURnpXk-00869-00318504-00318582": "there", "BI0bjURnpXk-00870-00318583-00318791": "how do we know that that one's a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00871-00318792-00318982": "similar to the one we sampled or similar", "BI0bjURnpXk-00872-00318983-00319215": "to the one with all the uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-00873-00319216-00319319": "i don't know what we just saw with all", "BI0bjURnpXk-00874-00319320-00319510": "those linear-looking", "BI0bjURnpXk-00875-00319511-00319863": "branches and just hasn't grown them yet", "BI0bjURnpXk-00876-00319864-00320030": "um", "BI0bjURnpXk-00877-00320031-00320230": "one of the things is that's branched too", "BI0bjURnpXk-00878-00320231-00320391": "close to the base", "BI0bjURnpXk-00879-00320392-00320647": "okay i think that's one of the clues and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00880-00320648-00320830": "uh what scott was looking for is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00881-00320831-00321023": "something that sort of starts off as a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00882-00321024-00321199": "single branch for a while and then it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00883-00321200-00321391": "starts sub-branching after that a little", "BI0bjURnpXk-00884-00321392-00321567": "bit but not very much", "BI0bjURnpXk-00885-00321568-00321679": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00886-00321680-00321910": "so um can we just do a quick zoom on", "BI0bjURnpXk-00887-00321911-00322110": "that sponge that's just sure go ahead", "BI0bjURnpXk-00888-00322111-00322334": "zoom oh there's a lot of different", "BI0bjURnpXk-00889-00322335-00322639": "animals yeah oh that's beautiful", "BI0bjURnpXk-00890-00322640-00322927": "whoa", "BI0bjURnpXk-00891-00322928-00323479": "a little bit closer yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00892-00323480-00323823": "well float my boat", "BI0bjURnpXk-00893-00323824-00323903": "no", "BI0bjURnpXk-00894-00323904-00324039": "well we're not going to stop and collect", "BI0bjURnpXk-00895-00324040-00324239": "this but that's that's unusual we know a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00896-00324240-00324463": "lot of collections that is right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00897-00324464-00324710": "that's a weirdy that's you know", "BI0bjURnpXk-00898-00324711-00324934": "yeah you don't want it you really don't", "BI0bjURnpXk-00899-00324935-00325175": "want it do you want it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00900-00325176-00325375": "how quickly would it take to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00901-00325376-00325671": "to grab it probably a little while yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00902-00325672-00325791": "let's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00903-00325792-00326047": "pass oh this hurts", "BI0bjURnpXk-00904-00326048-00326191": "we'll see if that's just here don't", "BI0bjURnpXk-00905-00326192-00326391": "worry because this is such a fantastic", "BI0bjURnpXk-00906-00326392-00326654": "community we really need there's an i4", "BI0bjURnpXk-00907-00326655-00326951": "that bamboo that looks like a candelabra", "BI0bjURnpXk-00908-00326952-00327151": "oh my god we've got so much diversity", "BI0bjURnpXk-00909-00327152-00327287": "here it's unreal", "BI0bjURnpXk-00910-00327288-00327495": "oh i think that's what it is what it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-00911-00327496-00327606": "called", "BI0bjURnpXk-00912-00327607-00327847": "very distinctive bamboo", "BI0bjURnpXk-00913-00327848-00327982": "with the shape", "BI0bjURnpXk-00914-00327983-00328182": "and there's a different one bamboo", "BI0bjURnpXk-00915-00328183-00328343": "behind there's all types of different", "BI0bjURnpXk-00916-00328344-00329054": "species of bamboo here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00917-00329055-00329303": "scott is typing like mad right now", "BI0bjURnpXk-00918-00329304-00329534": "because we're right", "BI0bjURnpXk-00919-00329535-00329799": "right in the community that he loves", "BI0bjURnpXk-00920-00329800-00330006": "there's a sponge for you", "BI0bjURnpXk-00921-00330007-00330191": "with a shrimp living in it possibly", "BI0bjURnpXk-00922-00330192-00330454": "where is that i zoom in please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00923-00330455-00330791": "oh it's it's uh yeah right oh yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-00924-00330792-00330999": "see there are translucent", "BI0bjURnpXk-00925-00331000-00331310": "is that one of those marriages oh listen", "BI0bjURnpXk-00926-00331311-00331527": "this is walteria", "BI0bjURnpXk-00927-00331528-00331695": "and", "BI0bjURnpXk-00928-00331696-00332119": "this is walteria lucardi or something", "BI0bjURnpXk-00929-00332120-00332310": "close to it i'm looking at the round", "BI0bjURnpXk-00930-00332311-00332543": "holes on the side of it yeah that's one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00931-00332544-00332782": "of the diagnostic features and this is i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00932-00332783-00333078": "wanted to tell a quick story about this", "BI0bjURnpXk-00933-00333079-00333254": "i got an email this morning from a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00934-00333255-00333575": "viewer lydia davis who was when we", "BI0bjURnpXk-00935-00333576-00333727": "mentioned yesterday that we didn't know", "BI0bjURnpXk-00936-00333728-00333951": "the origin of the name walteria she took", "BI0bjURnpXk-00937-00333952-00334239": "the time to actually go this up", "BI0bjURnpXk-00938-00334240-00334510": "and this was named by a researcher dr", "BI0bjURnpXk-00939-00334511-00334734": "schultz way back in the turn of the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00940-00334735-00334887": "century", "BI0bjURnpXk-00941-00334888-00335223": "and he was honoring a cell biologist", "BI0bjURnpXk-00942-00335224-00335527": "walter fleming so the very first species", "BI0bjURnpXk-00943-00335528-00335687": "that was", "BI0bjURnpXk-00944-00335688-00335958": "described for this genus he named as", "BI0bjURnpXk-00945-00335959-00336303": "walteria flemingi and walter fleming was", "BI0bjURnpXk-00946-00336304-00336647": "a very sort of famous cell biologist", "BI0bjURnpXk-00947-00336648-00336910": "so lydia thank you very much i already", "BI0bjURnpXk-00948-00336911-00337087": "responded to her", "BI0bjURnpXk-00949-00337088-00337327": "and that was terrific that she took the", "BI0bjURnpXk-00950-00337328-00337639": "time to help us with that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00951-00337640-00338471": "the origin of the name", "BI0bjURnpXk-00952-00338472-00338823": "coming up to a beautiful fan here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00953-00338824-00339015": "oh this is this is a great this is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00954-00339016-00339199": "possibly the densest community that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00955-00339200-00339510": "we've come to so far yeah definitely", "BI0bjURnpXk-00956-00339511-00339823": "do a snap zoom on this if it's possible", "BI0bjURnpXk-00957-00339824-00340087": "go ahead and zoom please", "BI0bjURnpXk-00958-00340088-00340295": "that's that's so this is potentially", "BI0bjURnpXk-00959-00340296-00340551": "another genus of primnoid", "BI0bjURnpXk-00960-00340552-00340775": "this could be in a genus that's called", "BI0bjURnpXk-00961-00340776-00341103": "paracalyptophora", "BI0bjURnpXk-00962-00341104-00341399": "and i'm trying to see diagnostic", "BI0bjURnpXk-00963-00341400-00341575": "characters but typically they have", "BI0bjURnpXk-00964-00341576-00341734": "smaller polyps and they form these", "BI0bjURnpXk-00965-00341735-00341958": "beautiful fans with a lot of commensals", "BI0bjURnpXk-00966-00341959-00342151": "on them", "BI0bjURnpXk-00967-00342152-00342295": "and i'm hoping that i'm going to get", "BI0bjURnpXk-00968-00342296-00342399": "some", "BI0bjURnpXk-00969-00342400-00343406": "some help from scott here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00970-00343407-00343671": "um he also noted the i-4 that we found", "BI0bjURnpXk-00971-00343672-00344103": "so that's great", "BI0bjURnpXk-00972-00344104-00344310": "uh he said he may have seen an akanella", "BI0bjURnpXk-00973-00344311-00344463": "weber eye a little while back and i", "BI0bjURnpXk-00974-00344464-00344606": "didn't see it because there's so many", "BI0bjURnpXk-00975-00344607-00344839": "corals around there he honed in on one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00976-00344840-00345054": "and if we see another one of those we'll", "BI0bjURnpXk-00977-00345055-00345215": "get a close-up of it", "BI0bjURnpXk-00978-00345216-00345399": "another one of which sorry uh it's just", "BI0bjURnpXk-00979-00345400-00345639": "another species of bamboo that he saw", "BI0bjURnpXk-00980-00345640-00345863": "and i didn't see and i'm just saying", "BI0bjURnpXk-00981-00345864-00345967": "that we'll", "BI0bjURnpXk-00982-00345968-00346167": "try to get a close-up to confirm that", "BI0bjURnpXk-00983-00346168-00346278": "it's here", "BI0bjURnpXk-00984-00346279-00346463": "we don't need to sample that we we know", "BI0bjURnpXk-00985-00346464-00346647": "what it is but", "BI0bjURnpXk-00986-00346648-00346775": "i'm getting a little off course here but", "BI0bjURnpXk-00987-00346776-00346991": "there's a nice bright looking sponge", "BI0bjURnpXk-00988-00346992-00347727": "okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-00989-00347728-00347878": "a lot more sponges over here you can see", "BI0bjURnpXk-00990-00347879-00348006": "in argus view", "BI0bjURnpXk-00991-00348007-00348271": "oh yeah what a place all right it is", "BI0bjURnpXk-00992-00348272-00348463": "managed to pick a decent one this time", "BI0bjURnpXk-00993-00348464-00348582": "that's great", "BI0bjURnpXk-00994-00348583-00348903": "whoa uh this is this is polya pogon one", "BI0bjURnpXk-00995-00348904-00349103": "of these big massive sponges we took a", "BI0bjURnpXk-00996-00349104-00349319": "smaller sample or a smaller specimen", "BI0bjURnpXk-00997-00349320-00349454": "yesterday", "BI0bjURnpXk-00998-00349455-00349543": "are you thinking you're going to want to", "BI0bjURnpXk-00999-00349544-00349671": "sample the next little bit or should we", "BI0bjURnpXk-01000-00349672-00349878": "keep ship moves going keep ship moves", "BI0bjURnpXk-01001-00349879-00350103": "because we really need to get an idea", "BI0bjURnpXk-01002-00350104-00350334": "what this community is like for a while", "BI0bjURnpXk-01003-00350335-00350510": "and just run up hill i don't think it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-01004-00350511-00350710": "going to stop anytime soon i think it's", "BI0bjURnpXk-01005-00350711-00350934": "going to continue oh jinx it now all", "BI0bjURnpXk-01006-00350935-00351119": "right okay sorry", "BI0bjURnpXk-01007-00351120-00351263": "i won't say because i think that sponge", "BI0bjURnpXk-01008-00351264-00351430": "growing on that's going on a sponge yeah", "BI0bjURnpXk-01009-00351431-00351630": "are those the same species uh not", "BI0bjURnpXk-01010-00351631-00352119": "necessarily is it on there please", "BI0bjURnpXk-01011-00352120-00352391": "oh no it's just beside never mind", "BI0bjURnpXk-01012-00352392-00352582": "yeah but they do do that pilot they", "BI0bjURnpXk-01013-00352583-00352815": "really do they will grow on top of each", "BI0bjURnpXk-01014-00352816-00353087": "other in this case he's next to him", "BI0bjURnpXk-01015-00353088-00353278": "that's cool okay", "BI0bjURnpXk-01016-00353279-00353558": "mom and her little fawn i guess", "BI0bjURnpXk-01017-00353559-00353767": "maybe not but i don't know if mom kind", "BI0bjURnpXk-01018-00353768-00353943": "of turns a little more yellow when she's", "BI0bjURnpXk-01019-00353944-00354367": "a little bit older", "BI0bjURnpXk-01020-00354368-00354582": "wow look at this we found another one of", "BI0bjURnpXk-01021-00354583-00354782": "you oh what is this guy on the left", "BI0bjURnpXk-01022-00354783-00355382": "there holy guacamole it's a big boy", "BI0bjURnpXk-01023-00355383-00355575": "that's another one of these big fairness", "BI0bjURnpXk-01024-00355576-00355863": "added sponges and a lot of unbranched uh", "BI0bjURnpXk-01025-00355864-00356071": "bamboos next to it", "BI0bjURnpXk-01026-00356072-00356278": "got some serious uh current flow here", "BI0bjURnpXk-01027-00356279-00356647": "yeah wiggly bamboos they look so cool", "BI0bjURnpXk-01028-00356648-00356847": "and they're all flowing from", "BI0bjURnpXk-01029-00356848-00356991": "west to", "BI0bjURnpXk-01030-00356992-00357278": "no east to west east to west east to", "BI0bjURnpXk-01031-00357279-00357591": "west", "BI0bjURnpXk-01032-00357592-00357903": "uh 66 lateral to the left right now oh", "BI0bjURnpXk-01033-00357904-00358071": "wow look at that", "BI0bjURnpXk-01034-00358072-00358351": "this is so pretty this is the community", "BI0bjURnpXk-01035-00358352-00358519": "that type of community we have been", "BI0bjURnpXk-01036-00358520-00358791": "looking for these are so important and", "BI0bjURnpXk-01037-00358792-00359134": "we found one like this", "BI0bjURnpXk-01038-00359135-00359719": "screen i am in seven heavens right now", "BI0bjURnpXk-01039-00359720-00359882": "what's six seven", "BI0bjURnpXk-01040-00359883-00360063": "like i don't know", "BI0bjURnpXk-01041-00360064-00360272": "i"}}, {"audio_id": "BIjC0jZcz_4", "text": {"BIjC0jZcz_4-00000-00000084-00002530": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00001-00002531-00004007": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00002-00004008-00004852": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00003-00004853-00005927": "vocally", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00004-00005928-00007367": "um", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00005-00007368-00012131": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00006-00012132-00012581": "no", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00007-00012582-00016343": "um", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00008-00016344-00016604": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00009-00016605-00018097": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00010-00018098-00022703": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00011-00022704-00022811": "okay", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00012-00022812-00023045": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00013-00023046-00028805": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00014-00028806-00030083": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00015-00030083-00034805": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00016-00034806-00036268": "Nairobi", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00017-00036269-00038968": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00018-00038969-00039287": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00019-00039288-00041131": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00020-00041132-00042411": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00021-00042412-00045287": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00022-00045288-00046205": "quality", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00023-00046206-00047746": "yes", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00024-00047747-00048959": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00025-00048960-00050882": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00026-00050883-00051634": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00027-00051635-00052675": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00028-00052676-00053012": "even a video Elizabeth", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00029-00053013-00056579": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00030-00056579-00056638": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00031-00056639-00059771": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00032-00059772-00062363": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00033-00062364-00063229": "getting", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00034-00063229-00064241": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00035-00064241-00064741": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00036-00064742-00066578": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00037-00066579-00071915": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00038-00071916-00074500": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00039-00074501-00075018": "cases", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00040-00075019-00077926": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00041-00077927-00080662": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00042-00080663-00081318": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00043-00081319-00082215": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00044-00082216-00084959": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00045-00084960-00089518": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00046-00089519-00090111": "um", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00047-00090112-00091060": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00048-00091061-00093203": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00049-00093204-00095088": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00050-00095089-00096844": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00051-00096845-00097243": "um", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00052-00097244-00097529": "your money", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00053-00097530-00099874": "um", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00054-00099875-00101081": "appealy", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00055-00101082-00102293": ".com", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00056-00102294-00102759": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00057-00102760-00104434": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00058-00104435-00107288": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00059-00107289-00109228": "[Music]", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00060-00109229-00109589": "Joe", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00061-00109590-00109969": "anything I'll do for you", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00062-00109970-00110460": "so let me give my number number", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00063-00110461-00110963": "can you be my commando commando", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00064-00110964-00111547": "um", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00065-00111548-00111936": "Winona higher", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00066-00111938-00113873": "now Instagram", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00067-00113874-00114839": "foreign", "BIjC0jZcz_4-00068-00114840-00115100": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "BIsD_lHFSJu", "text": {"BIsD_lHFSJu-00000-00000000-00000305": "yeah finally we we caught you here so we", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00001-00000306-00000617": "got you here we've been looking you know", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00002-00000618-00000911": "to contact you all yeah for a long time", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00003-00000911-00001324": "ago but the time is now so yeah this", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00004-00001325-00001541": "book deception of Islam you read before", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00005-00001542-00001834": "you even left Islam yeah oh yeah that", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00006-00001835-00002057": "book's amazing book and it was needed", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00007-00002058-00002326": "and yeah many many people many people's", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00008-00002327-00002633": "eyes were opened by you know that uh the", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00009-00002634-00002867": "book not only that but all things you're", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00010-00002868-00003226": "doing is amazing amazing work and uh the", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00011-00003227-00003413": "Lord the Lord is with you and his holy", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00012-00003414-00003593": "hand is upon you and many people because", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00013-00003594-00003809": "of you are leaving Islam", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00014-00003810-00004090": "so that's so great and we are so", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00015-00004092-00004385": "grateful to you learn a lot know you and", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00016-00004386-00004504": "yeah", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00017-00004505-00004870": "yeah so we're happy for you my friend my", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00018-00004871-00005099": "sister we we wish you a great life", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00019-00005100-00005272": "together you make a perfect team now", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00020-00005273-00005531": "both of you became a Christian yeah and", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00021-00005532-00005759": "we wish the family to be always with the", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00022-00005760-00005927": "Lord and we pray to God we ask all the", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00023-00005928-00006167": "people here to pray for this uh a", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00024-00006168-00006545": "beautiful uh family you can show our", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00025-00006545-00006751": "picture brother if you want because", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00026-00006752-00007013": "Muslim this is our picture it's okay we", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00027-00007014-00007253": "even have a video we when we are yeah I", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00028-00007254-00007420": "can I can show your picture I can show", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00029-00007422-00007631": "you a picture no problem no problem yeah", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00030-00007631-00007823": "yeah but I avoid someone in my picture", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00031-00007823-00007955": "because I don't want to scare the hell", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00032-00007956-00008224": "of everybody you know it's okay it's", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00033-00008225-00009355": "okay so yeah here we go this is uh", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00034-00009356-00009685": "the the work you do you do praise God", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00035-00009686-00009953": "all our family now are serving the lord", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00036-00009954-00010169": "not only me and my husband but also our", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00037-00010170-00010433": "two kids Somali Prophet we have a Somali", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00038-00010434-00010655": "prophet and Naomi they also are working", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00039-00010656-00010931": "with us on the on the YouTube channel", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00040-00010932-00011183": "and you are our role models I learned", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00041-00011184-00011287": "from you", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00042-00011288-00011645": "a lot and I always our life history will", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00043-00011646-00011801": "show you a book and you know what the", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00044-00011802-00012017": "people say on our live stream they say", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00045-00012018-00012238": "why you don't invite Christian Prince I", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00046-00012239-00012503": "said I wish I can even speak to him one", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00047-00012504-00012737": "day I don't even speak to him he doesn't", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00048-00012738-00013049": "know us but you are most welcome to our", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00049-00013050-00013277": "Channel we had David wood we had some", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00050-00013278-00013463": "Shamu because they are my teachers but", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00051-00013463-00013738": "you as well three of you being my my", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00052-00013740-00013949": "teacher and I used to come you chat room", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00053-00013950-00014333": "part talk 17 years like every night that", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00054-00014334-00014597": "chat room and and and and listen to you", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00055-00014597-00014849": "to you and give it to Sheila who was", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00056-00014850-00015058": "debating with me and you win can you", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00057-00015059-00015269": "believe you're a student to win over", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00058-00015269-00015630": "that over over Islam praise God", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00059-00015631-00015899": "well both of you are the winners you", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00060-00015900-00016121": "know it is it is you both of you you win", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00061-00016122-00016355": "not me yeah and because now you want", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00062-00016356-00016530": "your salvation you and your family", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00063-00016531-00016841": "husband yeah so yeah you know we are", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00064-00016842-00017039": "grateful to have you and now we are", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00065-00017040-00017213": "doing we're doing the same thing you're", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00066-00017214-00017477": "doing in Somali language we have Somali", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00067-00017478-00017563": "Channel", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00068-00017564-00017807": "and we have this English somal Christian", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00069-00017808-00018065": "activity ex Muslim for to reach out for", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00070-00018066-00018250": "the Somali second generation because we", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00071-00018251-00018443": "have a lot of second generation somalis", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00072-00018444-00018653": "who speak only English and they will", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00073-00018654-00018853": "listen only when they see Somali people", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00074-00018854-00019169": "saying they left Islam so we have two", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00075-00019170-00019463": "channels now so praise God praise God", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00076-00019464-00019775": "brother oh my God if there is anyone", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00077-00019776-00019967": "here he speaks Somalian language you can", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00078-00019968-00020177": "join their Channel maybe you can post uh", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00079-00020178-00020507": "yeah brother we have English one this is", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00080-00020508-00020677": "English this is somal Christianity", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00081-00020678-00020922": "English language only", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00082-00020923-00021161": "English you can join the channel too", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00083-00021162-00021485": "yeah oh thank you so much brother we", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00084-00021486-00021743": "love you please come all right yes thank", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00085-00021744-00021929": "you so much brother just keep praying", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00086-00021930-00022193": "for us and just know we are you student", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00087-00022194-00022355": "and we love you so much and we know", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00088-00022356-00022564": "you're 17 years and following you yes", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00089-00022565-00022757": "and we love you my God bless you brother", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00090-00022758-00022955": "thank you sister yeah I made a lot of", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00091-00022956-00023135": "Prosper all things you do you and your", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00092-00023136-00023363": "family yeah even our Channel we have the", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00093-00023364-00023530": "testimony people who left Islam because", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00094-00023531-00023621": "of", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00095-00023622-00023914": "one new channel so we upload", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00096-00023915-00024178": "yeah God bless you we are with you yeah", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00097-00024179-00024383": "may God bless you so much yeah and we", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00098-00024384-00024593": "love you admins you admins know as well", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00099-00024594-00024803": "our Channel and they are also our admins", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00100-00024804-00024983": "we love them thank you God bless you", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00101-00024984-00025217": "guys everyone yeah and Christian Bruce", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00102-00025218-00025414": "God bless you brother right take care", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00103-00025415-00025756": "bye", "BIsD_lHFSJu-00104-00025757-00026079": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "BIvntnKmNsk", "text": {"BIvntnKmNsk-00000-00000096-00000327": "hello world lock picking dev here today", "BIvntnKmNsk-00001-00000328-00000534": "i have an allmont rekey and i'm going to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00002-00000535-00000574": "show", "BIvntnKmNsk-00003-00000575-00000854": "you how to take this thing apart and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00004-00000855-00000958": "repin it", "BIvntnKmNsk-00005-00000959-00001231": "and let me tell you if you don't feel", "BIvntnKmNsk-00006-00001232-00001447": "like screwing up and wasting hours", "BIvntnKmNsk-00007-00001448-00001647": "uh don't even mess with this because", "BIvntnKmNsk-00008-00001648-00001807": "you're gonna have to make your own tool", "BIvntnKmNsk-00009-00001807-00001934": "to make it work because you have to make", "BIvntnKmNsk-00010-00001935-00002110": "a tool that fits in this hole", "BIvntnKmNsk-00011-00002111-00002287": "and you barely move that tool and your", "BIvntnKmNsk-00012-00002288-00002495": "pins are everywhere and um", "BIvntnKmNsk-00013-00002496-00002775": "it sucks this took me a couple hours but", "BIvntnKmNsk-00014-00002776-00002895": "yeah so here's the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00015-00002896-00003118": "all mount rekey my previous video you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00016-00003119-00003270": "see i made a key for that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00017-00003271-00003470": "i actually make this one six pins i", "BIvntnKmNsk-00018-00003471-00003686": "wouldn't try six pins again if i do this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00019-00003688-00003815": "one i'm not even going to trick the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00020-00003815-00004006": "driver pins out in this one", "BIvntnKmNsk-00021-00004007-00004279": "um i did make this one six pins and i", "BIvntnKmNsk-00022-00004280-00004391": "made", "BIvntnKmNsk-00023-00004392-00004575": "all the driver pin security pins and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00024-00004576-00004695": "that was the toughest part", "BIvntnKmNsk-00025-00004696-00004935": "is the driver pins and let me show you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00026-00004936-00005054": "why", "BIvntnKmNsk-00027-00005055-00005518": "so first off to do this we need a", "BIvntnKmNsk-00028-00005519-00005870": "modified windshield wiper blade", "BIvntnKmNsk-00029-00005871-00006270": "some people use music wire we need tape", "BIvntnKmNsk-00030-00006271-00006534": "and i also discovered this that really", "BIvntnKmNsk-00031-00006536-00006591": "helped", "BIvntnKmNsk-00032-00006592-00006798": "it's a euro repenting tool so this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00033-00006800-00007046": "little 3d printed euro repenter", "BIvntnKmNsk-00034-00007047-00007342": "euro corey pinner so what it does is you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00035-00007343-00007487": "when you spin it around", "BIvntnKmNsk-00036-00007488-00007791": "from the inside you can pin", "BIvntnKmNsk-00037-00007792-00008063": "one driver at a time and as you spin it", "BIvntnKmNsk-00038-00008064-00008239": "you can see how the rest of it covers", "BIvntnKmNsk-00039-00008240-00008407": "all the rest of the holes once you're", "BIvntnKmNsk-00040-00008408-00008495": "done", "BIvntnKmNsk-00041-00008496-00008814": "so you start at the first pin second pin", "BIvntnKmNsk-00042-00008815-00009142": "third fourth fifth sixth and then you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00043-00009143-00009231": "put it in there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00044-00009232-00009519": "but let's show you how this all works so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00045-00009520-00009567": "this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00046-00009568-00009759": "comes apart after it's picked or you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00047-00009760-00009974": "have the key you take this little tool", "BIvntnKmNsk-00048-00009975-00010446": "you stick it in the hole first off", "BIvntnKmNsk-00049-00010447-00010574": "let's go ahead and get a measurement of", "BIvntnKmNsk-00050-00010575-00010759": "this just because uh", "BIvntnKmNsk-00051-00010760-00011110": "let's try to be complete here", "BIvntnKmNsk-00052-00011111-00011246": "because i honestly don't know what the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00053-00011247-00011455": "measurement is i haven't measured it yet", "BIvntnKmNsk-00054-00011456-00011806": "i just did it till it worked", "BIvntnKmNsk-00055-00011807-00012719": "so it looks like 0.11 1.15 millimeter", "BIvntnKmNsk-00056-00012720-00012951": "and let's go all the way up to the top", "BIvntnKmNsk-00057-00012952-00013030": "so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00058-00013031-00013438": "at the top here it's 1.25", "BIvntnKmNsk-00059-00013440-00013758": "but i would go 1.15 so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00060-00013759-00014135": "1.15 millimeters", "BIvntnKmNsk-00061-00014136-00014366": "is the thickness and it needs to fit in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00062-00014368-00014494": "this hole you can see the hole is kind", "BIvntnKmNsk-00063-00014495-00014591": "of square", "BIvntnKmNsk-00064-00014591-00014758": "so you can see how much i had to file", "BIvntnKmNsk-00065-00014759-00014935": "down this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00066-00014936-00015175": "to get that so you stick this in the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00067-00015176-00015263": "hole", "BIvntnKmNsk-00068-00015263-00015383": "and this is the tool that's going to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00069-00015384-00015566": "hold your driver pins up", "BIvntnKmNsk-00070-00015568-00015743": "so right now this tool going in is", "BIvntnKmNsk-00071-00015744-00016038": "similar to the same tool with the euros", "BIvntnKmNsk-00072-00016040-00016311": "i actually have it right here similar to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00073-00016312-00016439": "the same tool like this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00074-00016440-00016750": "for euros and once you stick it in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00075-00016751-00016935": "and you hold the driver pins up when you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00076-00016936-00017103": "take the core out so that's what this is", "BIvntnKmNsk-00077-00017104-00017191": "doing", "BIvntnKmNsk-00078-00017192-00017439": "unfortunately the euro tools do not fit", "BIvntnKmNsk-00079-00017440-00017567": "in that hole so you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00080-00017568-00017943": "again will have to make your own but um", "BIvntnKmNsk-00081-00017944-00018430": "here is the part where you tape", "BIvntnKmNsk-00082-00018431-00018830": "so you have to tape this down", "BIvntnKmNsk-00083-00018831-00019039": "and there is no if answer about the bat", "BIvntnKmNsk-00084-00019040-00019263": "that you have to take that thing down", "BIvntnKmNsk-00085-00019264-00019550": "because you do not want that moving at", "BIvntnKmNsk-00086-00019551-00019614": "all", "BIvntnKmNsk-00087-00019615-00019830": "you you do not want this moving it's", "BIvntnKmNsk-00088-00019831-00020191": "just that simple", "BIvntnKmNsk-00089-00020192-00020463": "so there we go and i make it pretty", "BIvntnKmNsk-00090-00020464-00020550": "tight that way", "BIvntnKmNsk-00091-00020551-00020799": "if i want i can push the metal in and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00092-00020800-00020919": "out right there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00093-00020920-00021199": "to the back and push it back in but it's", "BIvntnKmNsk-00094-00021200-00021303": "tight enough to where", "BIvntnKmNsk-00095-00021304-00021575": "this will not wiggle a lot back and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00096-00021576-00021719": "forth", "BIvntnKmNsk-00097-00021720-00021983": "so now we have this holding up the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00098-00021984-00022191": "driver pins", "BIvntnKmNsk-00099-00022192-00022655": "actually i need to flip it over", "BIvntnKmNsk-00100-00022656-00022847": "that way the gravity is not pulling down", "BIvntnKmNsk-00101-00022848-00023039": "the driver pins as well", "BIvntnKmNsk-00102-00023040-00023727": "and uh working against us there so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00103-00023728-00023911": "let's get a better view of the core", "BIvntnKmNsk-00104-00023912-00024399": "there for the camera", "BIvntnKmNsk-00105-00024400-00024775": "there we go", "BIvntnKmNsk-00106-00024776-00025030": "okay so now we got that there this is", "BIvntnKmNsk-00107-00025031-00025283": "holding down the driver pins", "BIvntnKmNsk-00108-00025284-00025591": "now we want to pull the core out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00109-00025592-00025743": "so all you do is put something in there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00110-00025744-00025911": "and just pull straight out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00111-00025912-00026318": "let's see there we go it's coming out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00112-00026319-00026487": "and this is the hard part because see", "BIvntnKmNsk-00113-00026488-00026687": "it's getting caught on my little tool", "BIvntnKmNsk-00114-00026688-00026862": "there and that's why i'm saying", "BIvntnKmNsk-00115-00026863-00027095": "i recommend going 1.15 the whole way", "BIvntnKmNsk-00116-00027095-00027239": "across", "BIvntnKmNsk-00117-00027239-00027423": "so yeah here goes our shackle shackle", "BIvntnKmNsk-00118-00027424-00027590": "came out ball bearings probably fall out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00119-00027591-00027687": "next", "BIvntnKmNsk-00120-00027688-00028055": "there's no spring tension in this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00121-00028056-00028295": "or no actuator like you see in a lot of", "BIvntnKmNsk-00122-00028295-00028462": "locks", "BIvntnKmNsk-00123-00028463-00028639": "let's keep that in there because this is", "BIvntnKmNsk-00124-00028639-00028807": "six pins", "BIvntnKmNsk-00125-00028808-00028967": "i'm not sure if this one has the six pin", "BIvntnKmNsk-00126-00028968-00029279": "in it or not so there we go", "BIvntnKmNsk-00127-00029280-00029727": "slowly pulling this out there we go", "BIvntnKmNsk-00128-00029727-00029935": "i hear those driver pins clicking onto", "BIvntnKmNsk-00129-00029936-00030031": "the tool", "BIvntnKmNsk-00130-00030032-00030279": "hopefully they're staying in place i", "BIvntnKmNsk-00131-00030280-00030414": "really don't want to deal with that it", "BIvntnKmNsk-00132-00030416-00030583": "really sucks guys i'm telling you it", "BIvntnKmNsk-00133-00030583-00030743": "really sucks", "BIvntnKmNsk-00134-00030744-00030870": "after i did the other one i thought", "BIvntnKmNsk-00135-00030872-00031158": "about not doing this at all but", "BIvntnKmNsk-00136-00031160-00031487": "here i am oh yep one came out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00137-00031488-00031958": "so let me see in the very back there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00138-00031960-00032231": "one of those pins came out so let me get", "BIvntnKmNsk-00139-00032232-00032262": "a", "BIvntnKmNsk-00140-00032263-00032502": "flashlight see if i can help see how in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00141-00032503-00032631": "the very back there when those pins came", "BIvntnKmNsk-00142-00032632-00032951": "out and see how the tool now too", "BIvntnKmNsk-00143-00032952-00033127": "is a little off to the right so i'm", "BIvntnKmNsk-00144-00033128-00033318": "lucky you can see it kind of", "BIvntnKmNsk-00145-00033319-00033599": "see the pin sticking up there you'll see", "BIvntnKmNsk-00146-00033600-00033735": "those pins sticking up", "BIvntnKmNsk-00147-00033736-00033983": "right there coming out out of their", "BIvntnKmNsk-00148-00033984-00034062": "holes", "BIvntnKmNsk-00149-00034063-00034239": "the tool barely on the knob so i'm going", "BIvntnKmNsk-00150-00034240-00034431": "to push that back over", "BIvntnKmNsk-00151-00034432-00034583": "and i'm actually going to push it all", "BIvntnKmNsk-00152-00034584-00034790": "down as well", "BIvntnKmNsk-00153-00034791-00035039": "this is the part that sucks because to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00154-00035040-00035174": "pin these now", "BIvntnKmNsk-00155-00035175-00035431": "you have to take your tweezers hold", "BIvntnKmNsk-00156-00035432-00035511": "these down", "BIvntnKmNsk-00157-00035512-00035743": "and with the tool move this over to the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00158-00035744-00035871": "one side a little bit", "BIvntnKmNsk-00159-00035872-00036111": "to get that driver pin in there and then", "BIvntnKmNsk-00160-00036112-00036207": "put this little", "BIvntnKmNsk-00161-00036208-00036439": "thin tool back on top of it and this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00162-00036440-00036559": "tool does not have a lot of tension", "BIvntnKmNsk-00163-00036560-00036599": "homies", "BIvntnKmNsk-00164-00036600-00036815": "down so i can see the ones in the back", "BIvntnKmNsk-00165-00036816-00037239": "are springy popping up like that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00166-00037240-00037439": "all right i'm back i have a key made and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00167-00037440-00037559": "i'm ready to put the cord back", "BIvntnKmNsk-00168-00037560-00037855": "into the padlock so first i want to go", "BIvntnKmNsk-00169-00037856-00037935": "over this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00170-00037936-00038207": "use of this again just to make sure that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00171-00038208-00038335": "this is clear because this is definitely", "BIvntnKmNsk-00172-00038336-00038407": "helpful", "BIvntnKmNsk-00173-00038408-00038615": "i found it helpful for the first three", "BIvntnKmNsk-00174-00038616-00038743": "the um", "BIvntnKmNsk-00175-00038744-00039118": "pin that the cylinder locks onto um", "BIvntnKmNsk-00176-00039119-00039423": "back there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00177-00039424-00039583": "right there you can kind of see it right", "BIvntnKmNsk-00178-00039584-00039743": "there in the camera yeah right above the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00179-00039744-00039830": "tip there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00180-00039831-00039974": "there's a little pin in there and the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00181-00039975-00040199": "lock that that will not get past", "BIvntnKmNsk-00182-00040200-00040383": "that pin actually follows this groove", "BIvntnKmNsk-00183-00040384-00040502": "right here underneath", "BIvntnKmNsk-00184-00040503-00040823": "when you stick it in um", "BIvntnKmNsk-00185-00040824-00041127": "so this can only go back to that pin", "BIvntnKmNsk-00186-00041128-00041262": "so that limits you'd only do in the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00187-00041263-00041462": "first few pins but the way you do it is", "BIvntnKmNsk-00188-00041463-00041607": "you stick it in there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00189-00041608-00041807": "this will expose the first pin hole in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00190-00041808-00041918": "in the bible", "BIvntnKmNsk-00191-00041919-00042127": "stick your pin in turn a little bit", "BIvntnKmNsk-00192-00042128-00042279": "first pin is exposed", "BIvntnKmNsk-00193-00042280-00042567": "our first pin is now covered and now", "BIvntnKmNsk-00194-00042568-00042790": "this second pin is exposed", "BIvntnKmNsk-00195-00042791-00042983": "now all first and seconds covered thumb", "BIvntnKmNsk-00196-00042984-00043151": "pins exposed and you keep pinning that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00197-00043152-00043271": "way back", "BIvntnKmNsk-00198-00043272-00043527": "and so you keep doing that you keep", "BIvntnKmNsk-00199-00043528-00043687": "turning this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00200-00043688-00043887": "and see now you can see all the whole", "BIvntnKmNsk-00201-00043888-00044030": "bible will be covered when you're at", "BIvntnKmNsk-00202-00044031-00044230": "this point so now the pens can come out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00203-00044231-00044430": "and you turn it right there and right", "BIvntnKmNsk-00204-00044431-00044551": "there none of the pins can come out of", "BIvntnKmNsk-00205-00044552-00044687": "that thin hole", "BIvntnKmNsk-00206-00044688-00045030": "but this is the part that's important so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00207-00045031-00045351": "right there actually fits right onto", "BIvntnKmNsk-00208-00045352-00045567": "our metal piece there that's holding all", "BIvntnKmNsk-00209-00045568-00045758": "the pins in right there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00210-00045759-00045887": "i'm not going to push this all the way", "BIvntnKmNsk-00211-00045888-00046015": "in because i really don't want to risk", "BIvntnKmNsk-00212-00046016-00046190": "messing up the pins that are in there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00213-00046191-00046318": "but you can see how it does it so when", "BIvntnKmNsk-00214-00046319-00046527": "you're at this point you want to stick", "BIvntnKmNsk-00215-00046528-00046639": "that metal piece in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00216-00046640-00046879": "to hold the first three down that way", "BIvntnKmNsk-00217-00046880-00047007": "you can continue pinning", "BIvntnKmNsk-00218-00047008-00047215": "the last three or last two depending on", "BIvntnKmNsk-00219-00047216-00047351": "how far you want to go", "BIvntnKmNsk-00220-00047352-00047590": "um i'm actually a sucker for punishment", "BIvntnKmNsk-00221-00047591-00047662": "and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00222-00047663-00047895": "i did the sixth one because uh the fifth", "BIvntnKmNsk-00223-00047896-00048039": "one popped out and i said no", "BIvntnKmNsk-00224-00048040-00048399": "hell with it let's go ahead and do it so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00225-00048400-00048567": "before we continue make sure not miss", "BIvntnKmNsk-00226-00048568-00048855": "anything else here", "BIvntnKmNsk-00227-00048856-00049158": "okay so we have", "BIvntnKmNsk-00228-00049159-00049390": "our pins here we have our key ready to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00229-00049391-00049686": "go open it up", "BIvntnKmNsk-00230-00049687-00050039": "there's ready to go and so we want", "BIvntnKmNsk-00231-00050040-00050279": "there's our hole again so we want that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00232-00050280-00050486": "hole on the side", "BIvntnKmNsk-00233-00050487-00050655": "right there to line up with that metal", "BIvntnKmNsk-00234-00050656-00050895": "bar right there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00235-00050896-00051071": "so actually before we continue this is", "BIvntnKmNsk-00236-00051072-00051342": "what we need so my last lock i pinned in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00237-00051344-00051526": "the last video i actually took a file", "BIvntnKmNsk-00238-00051527-00051854": "one of these thin needle files and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00239-00051855-00052214": "i took it to this groove where the metal", "BIvntnKmNsk-00240-00052215-00052559": "bar follows and i filed this down till", "BIvntnKmNsk-00241-00052560-00052742": "was the thickness of this file which is", "BIvntnKmNsk-00242-00052744-00052926": "only just a little bit wider", "BIvntnKmNsk-00243-00052927-00053094": "so it won't do anything to the lock but", "BIvntnKmNsk-00244-00053095-00053247": "it'll help make this bar feel a little", "BIvntnKmNsk-00245-00053248-00053399": "bit better that way you can", "BIvntnKmNsk-00246-00053400-00053726": "maneuver in and out you know safely", "BIvntnKmNsk-00247-00053727-00054126": "so this is the next part so we want to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00248-00054127-00054566": "put our clasp in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00249-00054567-00054935": "and be very gentle with everything", "BIvntnKmNsk-00250-00054936-00055303": "this is nerve wracking", "BIvntnKmNsk-00251-00055304-00055575": "there we go okay we have our clasp all", "BIvntnKmNsk-00252-00055576-00055735": "the way in you can see that ball bearing", "BIvntnKmNsk-00253-00055736-00055911": "in the very back there is falling down", "BIvntnKmNsk-00254-00055912-00056150": "we'll get that in a second and now we", "BIvntnKmNsk-00255-00056151-00056375": "want to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00256-00056376-00056766": "turn our core until it's on that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00257-00056767-00057615": "groove is on top that metal bar", "BIvntnKmNsk-00258-00057616-00057815": "oh about to lose some pins so actually", "BIvntnKmNsk-00259-00057816-00057966": "i'm gonna", "BIvntnKmNsk-00260-00057967-00058263": "fix this real quick that's a little", "BIvntnKmNsk-00261-00058264-00058687": "scary there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00262-00058688-00058999": "there we go oh", "BIvntnKmNsk-00263-00059000-00059191": "hell looks like we did we lost the third", "BIvntnKmNsk-00264-00059191-00059319": "one", "BIvntnKmNsk-00265-00059320-00059679": "so heck with it i'll try to show you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00266-00059679-00059863": "real quick", "BIvntnKmNsk-00267-00059864-00060182": "how to put this uh how to put a pin in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00268-00060183-00060494": "lucky you and actually", "BIvntnKmNsk-00269-00060495-00060766": "i'm going to do a spool because they're", "BIvntnKmNsk-00270-00060767-00060911": "easier to grab", "BIvntnKmNsk-00271-00060912-00061142": "and they get caught on the metal piece", "BIvntnKmNsk-00272-00061144-00061406": "there that way sometimes they don't um", "BIvntnKmNsk-00273-00061407-00061815": "fly out so let's try this real quick", "BIvntnKmNsk-00274-00061816-00062079": "i put this in push all the other pins", "BIvntnKmNsk-00275-00062079-00062135": "down", "BIvntnKmNsk-00276-00062136-00062742": "while i try to stick this new one in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00277-00062744-00062911": "and with this pick i'm also moving the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00278-00062912-00063054": "bar to the side just", "BIvntnKmNsk-00279-00063055-00063382": "ever so slightly there we go i got the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00280-00063383-00063542": "third one in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00281-00063544-00063799": "i'm gonna cover all the pins back there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00282-00063800-00064006": "and push", "BIvntnKmNsk-00283-00064007-00064479": "the bar back over top of them", "BIvntnKmNsk-00284-00064479-00064871": "there we go", "BIvntnKmNsk-00285-00064872-00065175": "there we go nerve-wracking so actually i", "BIvntnKmNsk-00286-00065176-00065350": "think i'm going to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00287-00065351-00065543": "take this out of the vise for the last", "BIvntnKmNsk-00288-00065544-00065847": "part here", "BIvntnKmNsk-00289-00065848-00066023": "that way i can maneuver a little bit", "BIvntnKmNsk-00290-00066024-00066223": "better in my hands and not mess things", "BIvntnKmNsk-00291-00066224-00066343": "up", "BIvntnKmNsk-00292-00066344-00066638": "so let's go ahead and move this vice out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00293-00066639-00066943": "of the way", "BIvntnKmNsk-00294-00066944-00067311": "give us some room i guess now i'm", "BIvntnKmNsk-00295-00067312-00067591": "holding the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00296-00067592-00067999": "clasp in in the back i want that groove", "BIvntnKmNsk-00297-00068000-00068126": "to go along that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00298-00068127-00069431": "metal bar", "BIvntnKmNsk-00299-00069432-00069679": "there we go so there we go you can see", "BIvntnKmNsk-00300-00069680-00069919": "how that metal bar fits in that groove", "BIvntnKmNsk-00301-00069920-00070215": "keep pushing it back make sure we're not", "BIvntnKmNsk-00302-00070216-00070367": "getting any", "BIvntnKmNsk-00303-00070368-00070671": "pin stuck i bet you that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00304-00070672-00070838": "we have a spool that's stuck up a little", "BIvntnKmNsk-00305-00070839-00071119": "bit", "BIvntnKmNsk-00306-00071120-00071482": "try to pull it back and push it through", "BIvntnKmNsk-00307-00071483-00071631": "again", "BIvntnKmNsk-00308-00071632-00071999": "try to move it just ever so slightly", "BIvntnKmNsk-00309-00072000-00072599": "there we go i'm gonna press that one", "BIvntnKmNsk-00310-00072600-00072726": "so you saw how those spools were", "BIvntnKmNsk-00311-00072727-00072882": "sticking up so that could be a problem", "BIvntnKmNsk-00312-00072883-00073087": "sometimes", "BIvntnKmNsk-00313-00073088-00073415": "move it back forward", "BIvntnKmNsk-00314-00073416-00073806": "back a little bit", "BIvntnKmNsk-00315-00073807-00074415": "i wonder is that ball bearing", "BIvntnKmNsk-00316-00074416-00074719": "the other thing is we got that okay", "BIvntnKmNsk-00317-00074720-00074862": "it's not hitting the ball bearing yet we", "BIvntnKmNsk-00318-00074863-00074975": "can still hear it rolling around in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00319-00074976-00075223": "there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00320-00075224-00075367": "all right i was going to end the video", "BIvntnKmNsk-00321-00075368-00075550": "but i decided that this is an important", "BIvntnKmNsk-00322-00075551-00075743": "part and i need to show it", "BIvntnKmNsk-00323-00075744-00075975": "yes i do realize how ballsy it is to put", "BIvntnKmNsk-00324-00075976-00076247": "the core in without the key in it", "BIvntnKmNsk-00325-00076248-00076423": "yes i do realize that but i wanted to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00326-00076424-00076582": "make sure there was nothing", "BIvntnKmNsk-00327-00076583-00076806": "riding against this uh body when i was", "BIvntnKmNsk-00328-00076807-00076943": "sticking again because this is so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00329-00076944-00077055": "sensitive", "BIvntnKmNsk-00330-00077056-00077335": "if i got it this far in to put the core", "BIvntnKmNsk-00331-00077336-00077423": "in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00332-00077424-00077703": "and you can see that about that far in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00333-00077704-00077855": "this is the shackle hole", "BIvntnKmNsk-00334-00077856-00078087": "on the top this is the main shackle hole", "BIvntnKmNsk-00335-00078088-00078231": "you can see that the", "BIvntnKmNsk-00336-00078232-00078519": "ball bearing is just in enough so you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00337-00078520-00078662": "want to play with this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00338-00078663-00079087": "pull up this in and out just where um", "BIvntnKmNsk-00339-00079088-00079350": "just at the right distance out to where", "BIvntnKmNsk-00340-00079351-00079519": "that ball bearing is enough in right", "BIvntnKmNsk-00341-00079520-00079582": "there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00342-00079583-00079806": "that way you can get your spring in get", "BIvntnKmNsk-00343-00079807-00079975": "your spring in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00344-00079976-00080279": "and then your shackle", "BIvntnKmNsk-00345-00080280-00080423": "so when you're doing this too these ball", "BIvntnKmNsk-00346-00080424-00080559": "bearings they're rolling around in there", "BIvntnKmNsk-00347-00080560-00080694": "so you also have to roll them back and", "BIvntnKmNsk-00348-00080695-00080823": "forth and then push this", "BIvntnKmNsk-00349-00080824-00081094": "in until they're separated and then you", "BIvntnKmNsk-00350-00081095-00081175": "see how far", "BIvntnKmNsk-00351-00081176-00081294": "and then you gauge how far the ball", "BIvntnKmNsk-00352-00081295-00081462": "bearing is in to put the shackle in like", "BIvntnKmNsk-00353-00081463-00081511": "that", "BIvntnKmNsk-00354-00081512-00081799": "so now the shackle's in and that's when", "BIvntnKmNsk-00355-00081800-00081871": "we push", "BIvntnKmNsk-00356-00081872-00082247": "the core the rest of the way in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00357-00082248-00082526": "and so now the shackle can still come", "BIvntnKmNsk-00358-00082527-00082887": "out because it's been picked right", "BIvntnKmNsk-00359-00082888-00083326": "i want to", "BIvntnKmNsk-00360-00083327-00083526": "or no i mean the shackle can't come out", "BIvntnKmNsk-00361-00083527-00083735": "but you can see it's been picked", "BIvntnKmNsk-00362-00083736-00083999": "so there we go that's it it's back in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00363-00084000-00084191": "this normal shape it's still picked so", "BIvntnKmNsk-00364-00084192-00084350": "now what do we do", "BIvntnKmNsk-00365-00084351-00084550": "the moment of truth let's see how well", "BIvntnKmNsk-00366-00084551-00084887": "our key is so we turn it back", "BIvntnKmNsk-00367-00084888-00085271": "oh yeah push the shackle in", "BIvntnKmNsk-00368-00085272-00085482": "turn it back there's all those beautiful", "BIvntnKmNsk-00369-00085483-00085655": "clicks", "BIvntnKmNsk-00370-00085656-00086118": "and there we go awesome", "BIvntnKmNsk-00371-00086119-00086447": "and that was how to re-key an almond", "BIvntnKmNsk-00372-00086448-00086950": "re-key", "BIvntnKmNsk-00373-00086951-00087407": "all right everyone thanks for watching"}}, {"audio_id": "BIK8bYgYm_Q", "text": {"BIK8bYgYm_Q-00000-00000312-00000471": "hi everyone", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00001-00000472-00000726": "i'm so happy that my movie pandemic", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00002-00000727-00000878": "travelogue", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00003-00000880-00001087": "will be part of this year edition of", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00004-00001088-00001278": "flopina festival on beautiful for", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00005-00001279-00001487": "ventura island", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00006-00001488-00001718": "my name is radomir kasianowski and i'm a", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00007-00001719-00001975": "multimedia artist from serbia", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00008-00001976-00002231": "i do video art documentary movies", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00009-00002232-00002447": "performances and music", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00010-00002448-00002802": "i started to do movies during", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00011-00002803-00003166": "2013 and since then i made a lot of", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00012-00003167-00003511": "short movies motivation for", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00013-00003511-00003927": "doing art is enthusiasm", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00014-00003928-00004286": "and a very strong wish to do things that", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00015-00004287-00004343": "i", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00016-00004344-00004663": "believe in so i see", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00017-00004664-00005015": "artists as medium to", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00018-00005016-00005286": "take the messages from other world and", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00019-00005287-00005431": "to", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00020-00005432-00005838": "put in some form that is closest to", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00021-00005839-00006175": "his expression for me it's um audio", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00022-00006176-00006318": "visual", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00023-00006319-00006678": "inspiration is life itself", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00024-00006679-00007087": "people boots", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00025-00007088-00007423": "trees forest nature", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00026-00007423-00007695": "technology so i'm searching for an", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00027-00007695-00007767": "answers", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00028-00007768-00008103": "and connection between", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00029-00008104-00008519": "things that don't look so connected", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00030-00008520-00008871": "for this year edition of lacuna festival", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00031-00008872-00009127": "i will present myself with a documentary", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00032-00009128-00009206": "movie", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00033-00009207-00009567": "i made on tenerife island", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00034-00009568-00009942": "during the quality time in spain", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00035-00009943-00010231": "i was unable to return to my home", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00036-00010232-00010406": "because", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00037-00010407-00010727": "i didn't had all the papers i needed to", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00038-00010728-00010855": "enter the plane", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00039-00010856-00011167": "and return to my home so i stayed on the", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00040-00011168-00011519": "tenderify in three months luckily i had", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00041-00011520-00011687": "camera with me canon", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00042-00011688-00012119": "600d and i just found out that it's good", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00043-00012120-00012431": "to give some sense to that life", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00044-00012432-00012735": "that look somehow", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00045-00012736-00013038": "lost and senseless", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00046-00013039-00013399": "and i recorded the moments of beauty", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00047-00013400-00013830": "joy or just moments of", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00048-00013831-00014303": "everyday life", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00049-00014304-00014511": "how this movie corresponds with the team", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00050-00014512-00014647": "of distance", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00051-00014647-00015055": "well i was for three months i was", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00052-00015056-00015479": "very very alone on the island and", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00053-00015480-00015903": "very long way distance from my home", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00054-00015904-00016207": "when i came home finally it was", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00055-00016208-00016543": "june 20 i think and i", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00056-00016544-00016863": "needed some distance from the material", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00057-00016864-00017183": "because when i took first look it", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00058-00017184-00017511": "just didn't give me any story it was", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00059-00017512-00017622": "just like", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00060-00017623-00017983": "a lot of footages without any sense", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00061-00017984-00018350": "but three months later after making some", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00062-00018351-00018399": "distance", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00063-00018400-00018719": "from the material and this situation i", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00064-00018720-00018967": "started to edit this movie", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00065-00018968-00019286": "and finally in january this year", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00066-00019287-00019694": "it took this form it has now", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00067-00019695-00020030": "um why did i apply to this", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00068-00020031-00020335": "festival well my country is now in red", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00069-00020336-00020422": "zone", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00070-00020423-00020799": "so we are not allowed to travel", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00071-00020800-00021022": "maybe with some very special pyramids we", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00072-00021023-00021135": "can but", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00073-00021136-00021471": "like tourists visitors we can't", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00074-00021472-00021941": "but my movie can travel", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00075-00021942-00022055": "[Music]", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00076-00022056-00022375": "looking forward to see you", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00077-00022376-00022678": "in maybe next year live edition of", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00078-00022679-00023175": "la cona festival and", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00079-00023176-00023622": "in the meantime i wish you", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00080-00023623-00024142": "helped good luck much much love", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00081-00024143-00024463": "and beauty and", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00082-00024464-00024686": "if you're interested to see more of my", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00083-00024687-00024791": "work", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00084-00024792-00025283": "you can find them on radha mercury cloud", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00085-00025284-00025550": "space", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00086-00025551-00025822": "and for the underneath of you i am", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00087-00025823-00026055": "giving you a warm hug from belgrade", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00088-00026056-00026390": "capital town of serbia", "BIK8bYgYm_Q-00089-00026391-00026983": "and wish you all the best"}}, {"audio_id": "BJ44C__61gk", "text": {"BJ44C__61gk-00000-00007084-00007223": "so", "BJ44C__61gk-00001-00007223-00008483": "kill", "BJ44C__61gk-00002-00008484-00011283": "blood", "BJ44C__61gk-00003-00011284-00012135": "kill", "BJ44C__61gk-00004-00012136-00012849": "double kill", "BJ44C__61gk-00005-00012850-00015483": "[Music]", "BJ44C__61gk-00006-00015484-00016883": "hmm", "BJ44C__61gk-00007-00016884-00017680": "kill", "BJ44C__61gk-00008-00017681-00018263": "[Music]", "BJ44C__61gk-00009-00018264-00019683": "triple kill", "BJ44C__61gk-00010-00019684-00021083": "kill", "BJ44C__61gk-00011-00021084-00023433": "kill", "BJ44C__61gk-00012-00023434-00024550": "[Music]", "BJ44C__61gk-00013-00024551-00024759": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "BJh-mZ0u4hc", "text": {"BJh-mZ0u4hc-00000-00000631-00001169": "thank you all for us and I wanted to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00001-00001170-00001609": "begin by introducing our series poetry I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00002-00001610-00001882": "wanted to get acted by the same time I'm", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00003-00001884-00002195": "very sorry to be here hi Marilee because", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00004-00002196-00002483": "the fact that I'm here is a result of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00005-00002484-00002671": "that that Jennifer urban who", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00006-00002672-00002915": "opportunities was mentioning frequently", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00007-00002916-00003203": "in her work on these issues was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00008-00003204-00003388": "unfortunate able to make it unable to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00009-00003389-00003613": "because of family illness however I am", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00010-00003614-00003899": "incredibly grateful to be here to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00011-00003900-00004235": "able to introduce this issue and our", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00012-00004236-00004520": "distinguished panel so beginning with", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00013-00004521-00004820": "Susan tisci who is the author of Mormon", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00014-00004821-00005054": "poetry was recently gavel blasts and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00015-00005055-00005272": "bones agoda she's currently at work on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00016-00005273-00005470": "its genre book of poetry and nonfiction", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00017-00005471-00005750": "collage for more than 200 errors bones", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00018-00005751-00005972": "and historical documents she's been", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00019-00005973-00006127": "teaching at the Graduate writing program", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00020-00006128-00006431": "at george mason university since 1988 we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00021-00006431-00006698": "also have been ism who is the author of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00022-00006698-00007003": "a book called the interlude he's also", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00023-00007004-00007135": "the executive director of the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00024-00007136-00007295": "association of writers and writing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00025-00007295-00007606": "programs aw key is a national nonprofit", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00026-00007608-00007787": "literary organization for teachers and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00027-00007788-00008063": "writers amongst their many program areas", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00028-00008064-00008234": "they also publish the writers to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00029-00008235-00008510": "chronicle which in addition to provide", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00030-00008511-00008738": "information about grant scholarships and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00031-00008739-00009023": "conferences it also features critical", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00032-00009024-00009396": "essays and interviews and news", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00033-00009397-00009846": "ever seen Casey Smith is assistant", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00034-00009847-00010041": "professor Parton kinetics of corporate", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00035-00010042-00010350": "college of art and design writing poetry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00036-00010351-00010638": "in literary history his scholarly", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00037-00010639-00010935": "writing and poetry has appeared in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00038-00010936-00011046": "various traditional and non-traditional", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00039-00011047-00011406": "and I think its current course deals", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00040-00011407-00011739": "with a lot of interactions between new", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00041-00011740-00011955": "technology and new forms of distribution", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00042-00011956-00012417": "and poetry as well and finally Peter", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00043-00012418-00012627": "yangtze teaches domestic and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00044-00012628-00012785": "international copyright law here at the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00045-00012786-00013005": "University he also teaches law to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00046-00013006-00013311": "literature since 2005 he's been working", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00047-00013312-00013533": "with dr. Heidi at american university", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00048-00013534-00013821": "center for social media and projects", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00049-00013822-00014034": "designed to promote the understanding of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00050-00014035-00014268": "their views by documentary filmmakers", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00051-00014269-00014625": "and other other producers of creative", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00052-00014626-00015003": "works including recently as of last year", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00053-00015004-00015300": "a code of best practices in theories for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00054-00015301-00015786": "poetry so I think that this topic came", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00055-00015787-00016083": "about depart when I saw wrong Pinsky", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00056-00016084-00016241": "speak on it last year and in part", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00057-00016243-00016488": "because of the work that peter has", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00058-00016489-00016650": "jennifer done in reading the code of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00059-00016651-00017010": "therapies and i also wanted to point out", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00060-00017011-00017346": "i can late last year in a fall an", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00061-00017347-00017783": "article like david for a poet and critic", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00062-00017784-00018105": "that here in New York Times and he was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00063-00018106-00018339": "basically lamenting a lack of attention", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00064-00018340-00018782": "copy writing poetry that we hear about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00065-00018783-00018990": "controversies in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00066-00018991-00019401": "industry about it but when he today I'm", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00067-00019402-00019569": "appreciating modern poetry she had to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00068-00019570-00019791": "pay twenty thousand dollars for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00069-00019792-00019980": "clearance and licenses when he was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00070-00019981-00020316": "describing it criticized components and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00071-00020317-00020484": "talk about the uncertainty in here in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00072-00020485-00020787": "use so i think to lay out the background", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00073-00020788-00021020": "on some of these dishes and sort of what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00074-00021021-00021267": "the world of copyright might look like", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00075-00021268-00021633": "to appellant as as a poet as a critic", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00076-00021634-00021885": "rest teacher I hardwood strut off season", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00077-00021886-00022467": "this is thank you and thanks to some", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00078-00022468-00022743": "acknowledged for any codes to the next", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00079-00022744-00022992": "this year i was told if expect codes in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00080-00022993-00023583": "the audience other in a year I i", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00081-00023584-00023757": "sentence even my roles I should talk", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00082-00023758-00024170": "about cost and what parts are doing a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00083-00024171-00024366": "little while I think we're going to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00084-00024367-00024573": "talking about some poetic words that he", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00085-00024574-00024812": "test all of the categories for this town", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00086-00024813-00025092": "authorship ownership Eddie and poetry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00087-00025093-00025302": "but I want to start by talking about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00088-00025303-00025716": "what is flourishing closer to the heart", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00089-00025717-00025928": "into the center of contemporary poetry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00090-00025929-00026277": "for most of us any challenge to fair use", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00091-00026277-00026580": "that arises from our work arises as a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00092-00026581-00026826": "by-product created is not a deliberate", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00093-00026827-00027114": "provocation but even so it's not", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00094-00027114-00027363": "detachable you know method and meeting", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00095-00027364-00027506": "or not separable", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00096-00027507-00027812": "homes often create enough ambiguity and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00097-00027813-00028106": "contradiction that it's hard to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00098-00028107-00028286": "distinguish origins and it's hard to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00099-00028287-00028699": "codify legal nightmare in other words", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00100-00028700-00028945": "leaving aside illusion implication as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00101-00028947-00029225": "we've always known them I think you can", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00102-00029226-00029558": "divide poetic remix repurposing into two", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00103-00029558-00029855": "basic gestures incorporating fragments", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00104-00029856-00029960": "from a number of different sources", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00105-00029961-00030208": "whether a literary or non-literary into", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00106-00030210-00030473": "a new work or the opposite gesture of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00107-00030474-00030725": "really intense communion with a single", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00108-00030726-00031016": "text palms of bringing fragments of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00109-00031017-00031295": "various origins are perfect exemplars of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00110-00031295-00031591": "National Arts famous Isetta for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00111-00031592-00031814": "comparing creative work to a of bird", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00112-00031814-00032008": "bills and nasty out of its environment", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00113-00032010-00032177": "supposed to something that might bring", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00114-00032177-00032452": "out from within itself and most homes", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00115-00032454-00032651": "that do that collect such small bits of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00116-00032652-00032915": "language that fair use is easy to assume", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00117-00032916-00033122": "that at least in easy for poets to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00118-00033123-00033283": "ascend to see what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00119-00033284-00033673": "mr. even when you're going upon it as a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00120-00033674-00033871": "reader you can't always know you're", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00121-00033872-00034264": "reading a poem like that typography is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00122-00034265-00034515": "not consistent typography affects the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00123-00034516-00034737": "pace and the texture of the poem the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00124-00034738-00034984": "tonal register hasn't read it aloud so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00125-00034985-00035118": "with poets are making decisions about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00126-00035119-00035599": "how or if to mark borrowed text those", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00127-00035600-00035890": "decisions are not made solely long lines", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00128-00035891-00036298": "that would please a lawyer would even", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00129-00036299-00036510": "please your college composition teacher", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00130-00036511-00036781": "so I take my own work over the last 10", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00131-00036782-00037012": "years as an example I've been writing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00132-00037013-00037315": "about war and grief and I have quoted", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00133-00037316-00037552": "everything from traditional balance two", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00134-00037553-00037849": "essays about emigrating to other poets", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00135-00037850-00038155": "and there's a kind of mosaic effect in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00136-00038156-00038392": "many of the palms and it's a texture", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00137-00038393-00038542": "that's meant to be there is meant to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00138-00038543-00038839": "palpable but punctuating art alice", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00139-00038840-00038971": "sizing every one of those pieces would", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00140-00038972-00039145": "render the surface if not unreadable", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00141-00039146-00039473": "than certainly possible to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00142-00039474-00039743": "and things are money even further when", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00143-00039744-00040082": "the poem syntax is designed to slip in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00144-00040083-00040211": "other words providing multiple", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00145-00040212-00040361": "possibilities to learn to draw", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00146-00040362-00040667": "boundaries between phrases so in that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00147-00040668-00040877": "kind of a pond part of that is quoted", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00148-00040878-00040996": "where would you say the quotation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00149-00040997-00041242": "stopped and something else yeah", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00150-00041243-00041551": "perception deception representation re", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00151-00041552-00041824": "representation around issues of war and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00152-00041825-00041987": "grief that's exactly what I've been", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00153-00041988-00042265": "writing about so the method is part of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00154-00042266-00042770": "inquiry I'm not a much more radical", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00155-00042771-00043165": "project than mine is no idea I Gorgons", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00156-00043166-00043421": "recent book called the source which is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00157-00043422-00043682": "composed from individual words and short", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00158-00043683-00044171": "phrases from page 26 of almost 10,000", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00159-00044172-00044645": "books in the Denver Public Library in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00160-00044646-00044801": "his words of Testaments women", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00161-00044802-00045026": "connectedness and utility of all writing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00162-00045027-00045233": "as well as an exploration of the notion", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00163-00045234-00045577": "of origins both textual and spiritual", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00164-00045578-00045968": "that's a hell of a bird's nest but when", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00165-00045969-00046154": "you start reading it as my students were", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00166-00046155-00046310": "very quick to point out I thought you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00167-00046311-00046474": "immediately know you're reading it what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00168-00046475-00046664": "my know you like we're just as you know", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00169-00046665-00046840": "when you look at bird's nest what's the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00170-00046841-00046962": "nest", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00171-00046963-00047254": "but it does keep that newly made thing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00172-00047255-00047511": "continuous with its environment which", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00173-00047512-00047820": "makes it kind of camouflage camouflage", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00174-00047821-00048123": "works by confusing categories categories", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00175-00048124-00048682": "an and or is it mine is your vote and so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00176-00048683-00048873": "this becomes a politics as well as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00177-00048874-00049186": "poetics or at home that originates out", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00178-00049187-00049498": "of shared discourse and from which its", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00179-00049499-00049698": "material identity its actual language", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00180-00049699-00050092": "identity never completely separates for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00181-00050093-00050352": "obvious reasons for law has the greatest", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00182-00050353-00050605": "impact on poetic works that interact", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00183-00050606-00050883": "with a single text and dictates that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00184-00050884-00051139": "most such books reliable sources in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00185-00051140-00051313": "public domain I went through my shelves", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00186-00051314-00051738": "or I couldn't find any that that work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00187-00051739-00051888": "anyone trying to do this kind of work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00188-00051889-00052125": "with something under copyright so I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00189-00052126-00052435": "found examples like Travis McDonald's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00190-00052436-00052668": "book the mission repo which is an", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00191-00052669-00052974": "erasure done from 911 Commission report", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00192-00052975-00053398": "nor busy philipps song into the 182 page", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00193-00053399-00053653": "book made entirely from the language of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00194-00053654-00053916": "an 18th century legal decision about the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00195-00053917-00054280": "murder of Africans on a slave ship", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00196-00054281-00054556": "mark Noah the working class photos", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00197-00054557-00054787": "documentary poetics it use print sources", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00198-00054788-00055204": "and feel that nog raphy dan BTW quicks", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00199-00055205-00055453": "books spell does have a literary source", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00200-00055454-00055816": "but it's okay dick and the classical", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00201-00055817-00056077": "ratio text that sort of launched the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00202-00056078-00056284": "whole concept of a ratio poetry was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00203-00056285-00056581": "Ronald Johnson's book radios which was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00204-00056582-00056896": "created at a Paradise Lost and from", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00205-00056897-00057184": "within it using its own words created an", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00206-00057185-00057400": "alternative spiritual vision really", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00207-00057401-00057850": "could exist in any other words John", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00208-00057851-00058054": "Cage's practice roughly contemporary", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00209-00058055-00058634": "Johnson writing through a text was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00210-00058635-00058840": "barely considered writing let alone", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00211-00058841-00059023": "poetry when he was doing at a few", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00212-00059024-00059341": "decades back he used a massage tech", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00213-00059342-00059698": "forum and some arcane numerological", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00214-00059699-00059984": "methods to pull text randomly out of the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00215-00059985-00060391": "Kantos Finnegan's awake another", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00216-00060392-00060761": "kind of tests but times have changed so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00217-00060762-00061070": "much in 2003 my student Peter strike", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00218-00061071-00061265": "first when the alien reports thrives", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00219-00061266-00061513": "with a book whose longest home was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00220-00061514-00061691": "constructed using very similar methods", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00221-00061691-00061882": "you can tell from the name yo younger", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00222-00061883-00062090": "poets crisis is a mainstream suppose", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00223-00062091-00062542": "you've been so this reflects my interest", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00224-00062544-00062678": "you know the list I've just given you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00225-00062679-00062996": "but also the legal climate and not even", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00226-00062997-00063275": "a poet could believe that he was to fly", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00227-00063276-00063544": "under the radar making a project like", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00228-00063545-00063784": "this at a focus under copyright so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00229-00063785-00064051": "you'll notice in my list if John Cage is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00230-00064052-00064201": "the only one that dare to mess with", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00231-00064202-00064349": "something the poetry is still under", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00232-00064350-00064669": "copyright these are all study books you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00233-00064670-00064949": "should be every month but what I really", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00234-00064950-00065084": "started wondering when I was preparing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00235-00065085-00065444": "for today was what my show might look", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00236-00065445-00065678": "like if the law of a different practice", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00237-00065679-00065837": "of different didn't have a spare", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00238-00065838-00066082": "hovering around sortition poetry and I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00239-00066083-00066230": "also wonder what might have been written", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00240-00066231-00066791": "already thanks very much I think David", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00241-00066792-00067103": "how does somebody who works with young", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00242-00067104-00067357": "writers as well as well as a lesson all", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00243-00067358-00067676": "to yourself lovely here sort of what you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00244-00067677-00067876": "know what you think and what you can see", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00245-00067877-00068228": "how you're seeing young writers interact", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00246-00068229-00068501": "with with this intersection between the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00247-00068502-00068969": "wall and right few years ago I was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00248-00068970-00069103": "invited", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00249-00069104-00069434": "public knowledge by Gigi Sohn and at a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00250-00069435-00069838": "conversation with Gigi Bradford and the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00251-00069839-00070150": "concern was over broadening and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00252-00070151-00070535": "deepening the intellectual comments you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00253-00070536-00071021": "know what is in public domain and a lot", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00254-00071022-00071518": "of the things seem like good ideas to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00255-00071519-00072047": "limiting copyright for authors so that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00256-00072048-00072325": "that work can be used by a new data", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00257-00072326-00072781": "reset have a much wider dissemination", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00258-00072782-00073231": "and then I thought well I better see how", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00259-00073232-00073646": "I feel actually feels about this and so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00260-00073647-00073873": "I just randomly pulled about a dozen", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00261-00073874-00074171": "writers about how they felt about the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00262-00074172-00074399": "extension of copyright you know should", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00263-00074400-00074632": "your children benefit from your work is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00264-00074633-00075053": "a poet should your grandchildren benefit", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00265-00075054-00075519": "trigger great-grandchildren benefit and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00266-00075520-00075986": "what I found was that people were very", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00267-00075987-00076253": "passionate about the issue but they were", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00268-00076254-00076694": "also all over the map about the issue", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00269-00076695-00077165": "and I tried to resolve for myself what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00270-00077166-00077713": "was behind the divergent reactions to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00271-00077714-00078032": "live any comp copyright because the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00272-00078033-00078272": "writers I talked to did not feel like", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00273-00078273-00078584": "wire Penske and just one generation of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00274-00078585-00078937": "support from my poetic output is a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00275-00078938-00079385": "sufficient enough gift to my family some", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00276-00079386-00079661": "fell well it's my work and if i want to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00277-00079662-00080036": "take care you know all of my spawn", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00278-00080037-00080258": "forever you know that's the tricky my", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00279-00080259-00080735": "privilege to do that and it seemed to me", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00280-00080736-00081274": "that there were four forces pushing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00281-00081275-00081710": "these artists and educators in different", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00282-00081711-00082316": "directions and i also found that there", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00283-00082317-00082535": "was a lot of crime and middle innocent", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00284-00082536-00082817": "people because my association is an", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00285-00082818-00083105": "association of poets and writers who", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00286-00083106-00083408": "teach them higher education so the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00287-00083409-00083699": "educator and then felt one way and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00288-00083700-00084071": "oftentimes the artist and then felt", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00289-00084072-00084437": "another way and among the artists there", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00290-00084438-00084761": "were diverging you still because some", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00291-00084762-00085130": "have the aesthetic of susan tishy and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00292-00085131-00085834": "that others had more proprietary views", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00293-00085835-00086132": "individual enterprise and art being a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00294-00086133-00086636": "product of individual enterprise so I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00295-00086637-00086930": "sort of and try to find out why people", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00296-00086931-00087209": "had these different views I try to look", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00297-00087210-00087491": "at the forces pushing that and I came up", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00298-00087492-00087881": "with these four horses one was the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00299-00087882-00088252": "consolidation of publishing houses", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00300-00088253-00088652": "another was the inflexibility at later", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00301-00088653-00089087": "arena states a third was the world wide", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00302-00089088-00089342": "web cataloging and indexing of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00303-00089343-00089641": "everything which has really changed the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00304-00089642-00089992": "literary environment of how we work with", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00305-00089993-00090527": "and the fourth was a kind of a jolt", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00306-00090528-00090797": "issue and that's the dispossession of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00307-00090798-00091145": "the poor and the unincorporated and of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00308-00091146-00091490": "course poets are extremely rewarding and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00309-00091491-00091768": "unincorporated and rapidly", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00310-00091769-00092426": "unincorporated and the educators were", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00311-00092427-00092693": "very concerned about the first of these", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00312-00092694-00092966": "forces the consolidation of publishing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00313-00092967-00093278": "passes what we're formerly private", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00314-00093279-00093740": "family businesses like farrar straus and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00315-00093741-00093848": "giroux", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00316-00093849-00094378": "all the other great houses there seem to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00317-00094379-00094761": "be more discernment and even shrugs", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00318-00094762-00095088": "about the use of some of the Pocock's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00319-00095089-00095430": "fork subsequently but with the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00320-00095431-00095738": "consolidation of publishing houses and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00321-00095739-00096056": "rice being granted from one central", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00322-00096057-00096468": "office of lawyers that did the work for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00323-00096469-00096828": "all the publishing houses the requests", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00324-00096829-00097386": "for permissions were harder to fulfill", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00325-00097387-00097749": "and getting exceedingly more expensive", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00326-00097750-00098067": "the writer Francis Mays who many of you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00327-00098068-00098400": "know from the movie about Tuscany based", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00328-00098401-00098728": "on her book about her life and custody", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00329-00098729-00099135": "before she had that fame and fortune she", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00330-00099136-00099553": "was an educator and a ham colleges and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00331-00099554-00099835": "when she tried to make her anthology", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00332-00099836-00100422": "discovering poetry the state of TS Eliot", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00333-00100423-00100728": "one of twelve hundred dollars this is a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00334-00100729-00101128": "90 days for the lovesong of j alfred", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00335-00101129-00101400": "Prufrock and they wanted roughly four", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00336-00101401-00101797": "thousand dollars for the wasteland", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00337-00101798-00102322": "as a result of these high demands those", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00338-00102323-00102625": "bombs fell out of anthologies they fell", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00339-00102626-00103038": "out the classrooms you know how is that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00340-00103039-00103504": "representing the hood interests TS Eliot", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00341-00103505-00103848": "and how are we as educators to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00342-00103849-00104179": "disseminate our love for poetry one we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00343-00104180-00104649": "can't teach the poetry we love most so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00344-00104650-00104916": "the educators and people but yeah", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00345-00104917-00105229": "limited copyright that's a good idea we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00346-00105230-00105718": "need to get these poems back into the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00347-00105719-00106014": "classroom back into the public domain", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00348-00106015-00106386": "where they belong Rita Dove just", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00349-00106388-00106741": "published the penguin anthology of 20th", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00350-00106742-00107119": "century American poetry book just came", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00351-00107120-00107614": "out this year st. pride Sylvia Atlantis", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00352-00107615-00107938": "home daddy does not appear in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00353-00107939-00108157": "anthology as much as Rita would have", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00354-00108158-00108439": "loved to have at home ND anthology and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00355-00108440-00108861": "how by Allen Ginsberg does not appear", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00356-00108863-00109301": "because the rights were just too", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00357-00109302-00109529": "and oftentimes someone headed in a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00358-00109530-00109708": "mythology as a limited budget of ten", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00359-00109709-00109982": "thousand dollars to secure permissions", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00360-00109983-00110189": "if you have a budget of ten thousand", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00361-00110190-00110386": "dollars and they're asking for four", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00362-00110388-00110976": "thousand dollars for the wasteland", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00363-00110977-00111279": "problem there", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00364-00111280-00111676": "so I just I'm not only because you all", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00365-00111677-00111863": "share Hillary didn't come come back to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00366-00111864-00112090": "your main points and discussion but I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00367-00112091-00112382": "think that's a great segue onto the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00368-00112383-00112547": "pontiff Casey who's actually you know", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00369-00112548-00112994": "who his class is a addressing a lot of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00370-00112995-00113183": "these issues about anthologized and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00371-00113183-00113395": "distribution and also new technologies", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00372-00113396-00113621": "Thank You Sean thanks for everybody for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00373-00113622-00113878": "coming and public knowledge and what a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00374-00113879-00114119": "treat it is to talk about poetry in a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00375-00114120-00114310": "room booked people who aren't poets I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00376-00114311-00114620": "don't know if this ever it's really", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00377-00114621-00115008": "great for me making poetry or", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00378-00115009-00115271": "constructing poetry might be worse than", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00379-00115272-00115540": "writing for my practice which in some", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00380-00115541-00115733": "ways this like citizens in some ways", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00381-00115733-00116033": "probably further extreme and teaching", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00382-00116033-00116308": "are pretty congruent it might be because", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00383-00116309-00116575": "I teaches art college I teach at the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00384-00116576-00116734": "Corcoran where an art college is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00385-00116735-00116996": "different in funding always from most", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00386-00116997-00117158": "universities because kind of everything", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00387-00117158-00117454": "is permitted and then you kind of wait", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00388-00117455-00117778": "and see after that leaders you know", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00389-00117779-00118015": "questions from students all time in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00390-00118016-00118366": "photography video about appropriation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00391-00118367-00118585": "can I do that it's book disney come", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00392-00118586-00118874": "after you know and our faculty is of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00393-00118875-00119156": "widely divergent response most of them", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00394-00119157-00119871": "are safe yeah see if you can get this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00395-00119872-00120205": "what's the harm when it comes to poetry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00396-00120206-00120376": "I teach a course is called poetics off", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00397-00120377-00120724": "the page a third iteration of it just", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00398-00120725-00120925": "yesterday we have an event called", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00399-00120926-00121138": "bladder fest which is the celebration of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00400-00121139-00121522": "words and sounds and letterforms kind of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00401-00121523-00121860": "poetry that comes off of the Gertrude", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00402-00121861-00122170": "Stein kind of not the robert frost end", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00403-00122171-00122586": "of american poet in and in this course I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00404-00122588-00122773": "challenge one students to open up their", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00405-00122774-00123091": "minds to what poetry might be maybe it's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00406-00123092-00123349": "not what they have in mind kind of a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00407-00123350-00123549": "church basement or what they", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00408-00123550-00123769": "grandmother's favorite poem or something", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00409-00123770-00123973": "like that but to see language isn't", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00410-00123974-00124288": "alive what is poetry is still a great", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00411-00124289-00124509": "question a question is I think it's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00412-00124510-00124729": "still unsettled asst we've learned that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00413-00124730-00124983": "it's not about lyrics subjectivity alone", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00414-00124984-00125224": "it's not the poet's abiding one of my", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00415-00125225-00125515": "poems i use a first-person pronoun a lot", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00416-00125516-00125746": "of people might be confused anything", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00417-00125747-00125883": "that that pump that it's all", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00418-00125884-00126315": "biographical whereas that I and poem is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00419-00126316-00126715": "authorial construct and so a lot of my", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00420-00126716-00126928": "poems a lot of what I teach my students", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00421-00126929-00127138": "and hope that they can except for not a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00422-00127139-00127381": "lot of them are very skeptical will", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00423-00127382-00127597": "probably find room to talk about the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00424-00127598-00127860": "work of Kent bolster is the originator", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00425-00127861-00127981": "who", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00426-00127982-00128233": "some people's minds he's the arch pirate", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00427-00128233-00128460": "he's the one who's taking everything", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00428-00128461-00128725": "he's got this position is that one that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00429-00128726-00129033": "I find very compelling is that I don't", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00430-00129034-00129214": "know those thoughts would making lots of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00431-00129215-00129435": "money off their poetry I guess they are", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00432-00129436-00129739": "out there they're not my acquaintance", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00433-00129740-00130081": "sir and Kenny's position is that want to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00434-00130082-00130321": "get the work out there and that's what's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00435-00130322-00130546": "foremost he does get the cease and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00436-00130547-00130846": "desist and the takedown notices and if", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00437-00130847-00131161": "you will comply reluctantly but you will", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00438-00131162-00131469": "comply but the important thing I think", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00439-00131470-00131803": "and I've stresses to my students is to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00440-00131804-00132031": "see poultry as a field of possibility", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00441-00132032-00132385": "not as a field of limitation and so if", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00442-00132386-00132595": "they can think that a poem might be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00443-00132596-00132919": "constructed out of a shopping catalogue", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00444-00132920-00133212": "from sears might be constructed out of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00445-00133213-00133561": "studying adjacencies and some kind of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00446-00133562-00133831": "database I've done some poems based on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00447-00133832-00134092": "classic and so-called classics of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00448-00134093-00134272": "literature Jane Austen novels and stuff", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00449-00134273-00134512": "like that and just by doing very simple", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00450-00134513-00134943": "kind of search and find processes no", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00451-00134944-00135271": "studying JCC well how Jane Austen but", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00452-00135272-00135493": "what words came after the Berlin Wall", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00453-00135494-00135757": "and pride prejudice when you make up", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00454-00135758-00135970": "list let me see what I can do with that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00455-00135971-00136204": "might might be nothing really but all", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00456-00136205-00136366": "the way you can see like my bird's nest", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00457-00136367-00136582": "is that is a crazy person s come from", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00458-00136583-00136777": "all over the place I think did right now", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00459-00136778-00137029": "2012 brilliant I'm a poet", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00460-00137030-00137431": "the world pulsing with possibility Peter", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00461-00137432-00137659": "the document is so useful and helpful I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00462-00137660-00137878": "shared with my students I made a joke", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00463-00137879-00138493": "early I hope it's under fair use yes the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00464-00138494-00138682": "coded best practice is to fit on one", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00465-00138683-00139087": "sheet paper that's the students are no", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00466-00139088-00139324": "they're they're willing to understand", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00467-00139325-00139477": "they want to understand them all but", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00468-00139478-00139624": "what's right and what's wrong they're", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00469-00139625-00139999": "not going into it with just kind of wild", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00470-00140000-00140347": "eyes but they're also concerned in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00471-00140348-00140506": "making and not so much about what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00472-00140507-00140707": "happens after it's made so I think", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00473-00140708-00141028": "that's also a healthy position for any", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00474-00141029-00141288": "creative person to be to be honest", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00475-00141289-00141697": "that's a good start thanks and I think", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00476-00141698-00142018": "finally for initial presentations dreamt", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00477-00142019-00142348": "it here i think if you could you know i", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00478-00142349-00142576": "may put a legal frame on on some of the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00479-00142577-00142816": "issues that are the most amazing also", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00480-00142817-00143098": "talked about the document okay that's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00481-00143099-00143281": "dracula how private google little", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00482-00143282-00143596": "privation thank you sir and in case you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00483-00143597-00143791": "let me repeat my challenge I think it's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00484-00143792-00144091": "great to get another one page but next", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00485-00144092-00144598": "we need the wallet card we publish no", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00486-00144599-00144784": "you're right we yeah we can collaborate", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00487-00144785-00145159": "on the wallet card broadly speaking in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00488-00145160-00145414": "this in this domain of practices in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00489-00145415-00145843": "many others fair use is probably the one", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00490-00145844-00146152": "bright spot in an otherwise for the is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00491-00146153-00146587": "Bowl copyright landscape in which gets", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00492-00146588-00146824": "protected more and more for longer and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00493-00146825-00147367": "longer and with no natural and insight", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00494-00147368-00147988": "and so this escape valve and the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00495-00147989-00148303": "copyright system which is a picture that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00496-00148304-00148513": "got built into our library early", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00497-00148514-00148639": "although it didn't actually get", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00498-00148640-00148984": "incorporated into the statute the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00499-00148985-00149194": "nineteen seventies Copyright Act has", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00500-00149195-00149431": "just got more and more important in in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00501-00149432-00149723": "the last few years and unfortunately", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00502-00149724-00150146": "the courts have taken off that that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00503-00150147-00150449": "theme in the ferry was jurisprudence of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00504-00150450-00150686": "case law decisions of the last 20 years", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00505-00150687-00150971": "they've really changed in a very very", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00506-00150972-00151160": "profound it and for all kinds of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00507-00151161-00151412": "cultural practitioners very important", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00508-00151413-00151691": "way the basic analytic rubric for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00509-00151692-00151916": "thinking about fair use used to be that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00510-00151917-00152240": "what you did it was to you know by the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00511-00152241-00152770": "numbers section 107 America four factors", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00512-00152771-00153155": "see all very confusing very vague and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00513-00153156-00153827": "hard to predict the open-ended partisan", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00514-00153828-00154028": "is good right even though all of the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00515-00154029-00154286": "confusing stuff one can do without and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00516-00154287-00154553": "then as I say starting 20 or so years", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00517-00154554-00154832": "ago courts looked at this picture and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00518-00154833-00155045": "said what we probably can do better we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00519-00155046-00155384": "can probably provide a clearer record", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00520-00155385-00155549": "algorithm horrible", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00521-00155550-00155705": "thinking about this stuff what's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00522-00155706-00155840": "happened over there was a couple of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00523-00155841-00156139": "decades is in effect now various", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00524-00156140-00156473": "reasoning is different in the cases of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00525-00156474-00156806": "add value added practice as the circuit", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00526-00156807-00157001": "we talking about you now what really", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00527-00157002-00157217": "hurts too is they ask two questions they", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00528-00157218-00157454": "say it is is this use a transformative", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00529-00157455-00157796": "use and that adds value to the material", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00530-00157797-00158113": "that was assimilated and that it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00531-00158114-00158459": "represents SAP material in a new / in a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00532-00158460-00158669": "new way for new purpose or to a new", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00533-00158670-00158912": "audience and then they ask is the amount", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00534-00158913-00159185": "that got taken appropriate to the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00535-00159186-00159509": "transformative groups and if the answer", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00536-00159510-00159794": "to those two questions turns out to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00537-00159795-00160232": "in each case yes then a large the ue", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00538-00160233-00160463": "employers / induces fair which means", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00539-00160464-00160712": "incidentally not just that it's allowed", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00540-00160713-00161144": "that is being infringed racism you get", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00541-00161145-00161498": "away with very uses all right and a fair", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00542-00161499-00161839": "use is a not infringing use that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00543-00161840-00162056": "Frenchman that some happened for the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00544-00162057-00162371": "event or or privilege so that's really", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00545-00162372-00162623": "important and that in the way", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00546-00162624-00162830": "courts talk about think about fair use", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00547-00162831-00163121": "is one of the sort of two main pillars", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00548-00163122-00163402": "of the project that my colleagues and I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00549-00163403-00163649": "with different practice communities", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00550-00163650-00164120": "including the last six or seven the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00551-00164121-00164369": "other pillar is a very important scotto", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00552-00164370-00164723": "insight tribute to a guy named Mike", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00553-00164724-00164912": "Madison teaches copyright at the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00554-00164913-00165203": "University of Pittsburgh who was one of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00555-00165204-00165452": "the first scholars to read all of those", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00556-00165453-00165629": "various decisions from the earliest", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00557-00165630-00165856": "times to the present day distills", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00558-00165857-00166094": "generalizations problem including the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00559-00166095-00166364": "generalization that when courts who have", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00560-00166365-00166577": "to have the last word on these questions", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00561-00166578-00166883": "what courts ask if something of fair use", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00562-00166884-00167186": "or not especially in an area that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00563-00167187-00167390": "they're not familiar with they look to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00564-00167391-00167663": "the field for information about what's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00565-00167664-00167843": "considered appropriate about what's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00566-00167844-00168068": "considered good practice about what's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00567-00168069-00168263": "considered important to the fulfillment", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00568-00168264-00168661": "of whatever mission that field is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00569-00168662-00169102": "devoted to accomplishing in other words", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00570-00169103-00169679": "what practitioners think and say about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00571-00169680-00169931": "their consensus values around fair use", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00572-00169932-00170241": "is actually important it actually is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00573-00170242-00170731": "constituent if long as well as simply", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00574-00170732-00170993": "reflecting and understanding of law", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00575-00170994-00171149": "other way of putting this of course is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00576-00171150-00171407": "it various is one of those branches of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00577-00171408-00171575": "law that's too important to be left", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00578-00171576-00172024": "entirely to the lawyers so with these", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00579-00172025-00172288": "twin insights of the law is changing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00580-00172289-00172603": "them that professional consensus matters", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00581-00172604-00172847": "we've gone about this series of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00582-00172848-00173296": "exercises facilitate a process in which", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00583-00173297-00173581": "professional communities come together", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00584-00173582-00173870": "identify for current situations in which", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00585-00173871-00174113": "question is this various or isn't it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00586-00174114-00174339": "comes up again and again practice and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00587-00174340-00174638": "helping and I stress often those", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00588-00174639-00174983": "communities to develop sort of center of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00589-00174984-00175274": "gravity positions around those issues I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00590-00175275-00175496": "say center of gravity position because", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00591-00175497-00175844": "no group representatives of a community", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00592-00175845-00176144": "and we often talk to always talk to many", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00593-00176145-00176372": "dozens and sometimes several hundreds of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00594-00176373-00176621": "the representative practitioners in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00595-00176622-00176882": "field in coming to one of these", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00596-00176883-00177052": "statements of the best practice it's no", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00597-00177053-00177206": "group of that size is always going to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00598-00177207-00177419": "agree about everything but often there", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00599-00177420-00177814": "is going to be a substantial middle", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00600-00177815-00177995": "ground of agreement and that's what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00601-00177996-00178205": "these statements of best practice", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00602-00178206-00178442": "to document their especially powerful", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00603-00178443-00178655": "when the people who come together from", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00604-00178656-00179137": "the field to create them are already as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00605-00179138-00179483": "as Moses to David and pointed out on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00606-00179484-00179786": "both sides of the issue and that is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00607-00179787-00179993": "obviously the case it was the case with", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00608-00179994-00180350": "the poets who had after hiding Jennifer", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00609-00180351-00180818": "urban Kate coals and I helped to work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00610-00180819-00181067": "together to create a statement best", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00611-00181068-00181370": "references why because poets are", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00612-00181371-00181622": "original voices and they're also engaged", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00613-00181623-00181865": "in a wide range of a similar practices", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00614-00181866-00182303": "and happen to a very long also most", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00615-00182304-00182531": "working poets are also working something", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00616-00182532-00182981": "else's teachers three days journalists", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00617-00182982-00183539": "are kanessa the list of and often they", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00618-00183540-00184049": "have perspectives from their other from", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00619-00184050-00184256": "under their their second paths so to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00620-00184257-00184742": "speak which are which complemented on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00621-00184743-00185009": "sato is to complement their poetic", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00622-00185010-00185315": "perspectives so we went through this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00623-00185316-00185543": "exercise as we've done before the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00624-00185544-00185831": "document exists and can be found in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00625-00185832-00186209": "various places the place you can always", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00626-00186210-00186410": "get a free download of this document is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00627-00186411-00186719": "centre for social media dot org if you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00628-00186720-00186965": "the fair use tab if you go to the poetry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00629-00186966-00187073": "foundation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00630-00187074-00187652": "which which deserves consideration since", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00631-00187653-00187991": "the barking foundation-funded helped to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00632-00187992-00188246": "make this possible over AWP was up the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00633-00188247-00188564": "l2 it has to be said unfortunately to go", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00634-00188565-00188741": "to the Poetry Foundation website and get", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00635-00188742-00188993": "all sort of tangled up with stripe de", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00636-00188994-00189229": "and I wouldn't necessarily recommend it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00637-00189230-00189452": "center for social media orbit is a nice", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00638-00189453-00189701": "place to get clean free download this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00639-00189702-00189904": "document and I urge you to do so because", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00640-00189905-00190181": "I can't begin to talk about all the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00641-00190182-00190469": "details about happy to discuss some of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00642-00190470-00190697": "them later if there are questions but", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00643-00190698-00190991": "there is one thing I want to address", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00644-00190992-00191375": "actually two that came up in Susan's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00645-00191376-00191854": "remarks first without regard to the code", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00646-00191855-00192104": "but just as a matter of sort of general", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00647-00192105-00192457": "law speaking back to that issue of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00648-00192458-00192704": "transformative miss analysis and fair", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00649-00192705-00192989": "use I don't think there's any reason to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00650-00192990-00193283": "suppose that a poem that that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00651-00193284-00193586": "incorporates large numbers of quotations", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00652-00193587-00193816": "needs to mark or italicize those", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00653-00193817-00194074": "quotations in order for them to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00654-00194075-00194444": "considered fair use to the contrary I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00655-00194445-00194735": "might make the argument that the poem in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00656-00194736-00195004": "which those quotations are assimilated", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00657-00195005-00195335": "more fully rather than marked off as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00658-00195336-00195602": "being something else and from another", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00659-00195603-00195851": "source is actually a more transformative", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00660-00195852-00196333": "exercise for that reason likewise the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00661-00196334-00196625": "practice to merge and now now what I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00662-00196626-00196766": "want to talk about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00663-00196767-00197312": "is the single author of response you're", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00664-00197313-00197528": "wonderful word was with intimate", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00665-00197529-00198044": "encounter between a poet of now and a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00666-00198045-00198425": "single work of the past that's one where", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00667-00198426-00198884": "I think poets now need to pull up their", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00668-00198885-00199130": "socks and recognize the lengths that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00669-00199131-00199400": "they have rights that they won't", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00670-00199401-00199766": "actually be able to claim until they", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00671-00199767-00200060": "exercise why because there's other so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00672-00200061-00200309": "I'm sorry I thought were actually I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00673-00200310-00200669": "didn't see that if you respond to people", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00674-00200670-00200855": "perfect let's do not just say a couple", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00675-00200856-00201086": "of things on the second conclusion in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00676-00201087-00201284": "them yeah I love to hear from Susan", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00677-00201285-00201581": "because I just have got a minute minute", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00678-00201582-00201959": "more to say and one of the things I want", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00679-00201960-00202247": "to say is that there is nothing in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00680-00202248-00202514": "the off-the-shelf you lose focus of fair", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00681-00202515-00202925": "use that suggests that a new poem that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00682-00202926-00203219": "is a response to a single work would be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00683-00203220-00203564": "treated any less be fair use analysis", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00684-00203565-00203816": "than a bird's nest welcome the other", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00685-00203817-00204038": "thing for what it's worth is that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00686-00204039-00204272": "principle number two of this document", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00687-00204273-00204692": "clearly and explicitly covers that case", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00688-00204693-00205060": "and contains no reservations whatsoever", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00689-00205061-00205373": "with respect to the number of kind of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00690-00205373-00205541": "sources the greatest", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00691-00205542-00205936": "understanding the poets and others naive", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00692-00205937-00206171": "misunderstanding but what others have", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00693-00206173-00206369": "about fair use is that somebody is out", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00694-00206371-00206756": "there counting words and that everything", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00695-00206757-00207221": "turns on extreme gravity of rotation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00696-00207223-00207512": "nothing in the case law certainly", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00697-00207513-00207767": "nothing this document supports that in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00698-00207769-00207996": "the end of the discourse where did the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00699-00207996-00208271": "ten percent they come from the urban", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00700-00208273-00208583": "feel Horrors popular ain't it great I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00701-00208584-00208800": "mean I could go on but one answer is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00702-00208801-00209304": "that the ten percent has has as many", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00703-00209305-00209601": "parents but one of the one of the less", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00704-00209602-00209877": "respectable of those parents is a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00705-00209878-00210267": "document called guidelines on classroom", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00706-00210267-00210714": "photocopy that was issued in conjunction", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00707-00210715-00211116": "with the legislative history of the 1976", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00708-00211117-00211326": "Copyright Act and represented in effect", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00709-00211327-00211748": "a failed effort to bring publishers and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00710-00211750-00212033": "teachers together to agree on a safe", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00711-00212034-00212412": "harbor or classroom very", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00712-00212413-00212694": "it does have a ten percent number in it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00713-00212694-00213096": "now I could go on and on the next 25", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00714-00213096-00213378": "minutes I could do on why one could pay", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00715-00213379-00213671": "very much attention to the 1976 plasma", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00716-00213673-00213984": "guidelines in the original context for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00717-00213985-00214178": "which they were suggested and certainly", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00718-00214179-00214590": "beyond that content but I'll restrain", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00719-00214591-00215007": "myself except to say that in the context", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00720-00215008-00215211": "that we're talking about the context of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00721-00215212-00215438": "poetic practice the context of critical", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00722-00215439-00215913": "practice it has no bearing whatsoever on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00723-00215914-00216123": "the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00724-00216125-00216385": "the blocker out now that's at there are", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00725-00216386-00216619": "still issues there were finished that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00726-00216619-00216921": "the poet's got together to create this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00727-00216923-00217210": "document could be real and one of those", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00728-00217211-00217552": "was the practice of making apologies so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00729-00217553-00217777": "there is no principle that addresses", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00730-00217778-00217975": "technologies although there's some text", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00731-00217976-00218221": "in the document that helps to explain", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00732-00218221-00218578": "the pros and cons of that argument does", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00733-00218579-00218776": "the fact that anthologies aren't", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00734-00218777-00219007": "represented in the document mean that it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00735-00219008-00219265": "was anyone's consensus conclusion that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00736-00219266-00219492": "fair use isn't an available basis for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00737-00219494-00219736": "creating in that biology no it simply", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00738-00219737-00219985": "means that there was a big interest in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00739-00219986-00220246": "census on that point so I'm going to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00740-00220246-00220414": "able to throw it open just stressing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00741-00220415-00220573": "back and forth between our panelists and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00742-00220573-00220738": "just to throw in a couple of things you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00743-00220739-00221029": "mentioned Ken Goldsmith and I'm sure", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00744-00221030-00221269": "that there's a fascinating discussion to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00745-00221269-00221506": "be had there and also the question of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00746-00221507-00221742": "nobody's counting words i have dated it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00747-00221744-00221956": "in our emails about importantly you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00748-00221957-00222169": "mentioned the fact there were there were", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00749-00222169-00222439": "if not judges and account poets but", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00750-00222440-00222769": "certainly some people were rolling as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00751-00222769-00223108": "tightness so any and all these topics", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00752-00223109-00223729": "their game poets can assimilate other", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00753-00223730-00224027": "poems poems without penalty", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00754-00224028-00224240": "because there's usually no penalties", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00755-00224241-00224678": "when the poor steal from the poor now if", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00756-00224679-00225155": "a poet work to assimilate a chorus of a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00757-00225156-00225575": "popular song even if it's a bad chorus", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00758-00225576-00225851": "like I'm just a minor for a heart of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00759-00225852-00226123": "gold you know head extended metaphor", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00760-00226125-00226664": "face mama cliche that poet would", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00761-00226665-00226946": "probably buy himself or herself in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00762-00226946-00227323": "trouble because now that the web is here", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00763-00227325-00227542": "the petrol it were to publish that work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00764-00227544-00227836": "on the web where if somebody were to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00765-00227837-00228142": "type up the bowman publish the moment of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00766-00228144-00228635": "love and the state of Neil Young were to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00767-00228636-00229010": "look for protecting that work they would", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00768-00229011-00229346": "be in trouble and the music industry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00769-00229346-00229850": "does look for violation and I am quite", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00770-00229851-00230183": "so pessimistic I must say about this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00771-00230184-00230471": "this call because you're absolutely", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00772-00230471-00230719": "right there's there's there is strong", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00773-00230721-00230942": "and going on all the time cease and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00774-00230942-00231287": "desist letters are in fact there's even", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00775-00231288-00231437": "an argument that if you're old when", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00776-00231438-00231689": "you're working for a copyright owner you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00777-00231690-00231896": "ought to write a season is this letter", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00778-00231896-00232123": "that it's a part of your ethical", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00779-00232125-00232369": "commitment to zealous advocacy to do", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00780-00232371-00232727": "some and cease and desist letters some", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00781-00232728-00232881": "typical evil", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00782-00232882-00233397": "word amber from the copyright holder if", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00783-00233398-00234115": "the user has the information base the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00784-00234116-00234503": "strength of will and the support network", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00785-00234504-00234729": "necessary to stand up well the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00786-00234730-00235050": "information base is here the strength of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00787-00235051-00235216": "will we have to produce for ourselves", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00788-00235217-00236022": "the support network is I could you ten", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00789-00236023-00236295": "lawyers would take that ill young case", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00790-00236296-00236850": "broke off they would beat one another in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00791-00236851-00237088": "order to be able to represent the boat", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00792-00237089-00237417": "you described there is no shortage of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00793-00237419-00237787": "support both I run a clinic in the law", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00794-00237788-00237950": "school that are dozens of these", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00795-00237951-00238275": "intellectual property and cyber Lachlan", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00796-00238276-00238529": "is going around the country hungry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00797-00238530-00238867": "suddenly for cases to bring there are a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00798-00238867-00239023": "lot of belief", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00799-00239023-00239308": "young lawyers or looking for ways of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00800-00239309-00239571": "making their names and their plenty of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00801-00239573-00239821": "old lawyers we still have some", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00802-00239821-00240031": "principles and we have time on their", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00803-00240032-00240310": "hands and want to do good in the world", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00804-00240311-00240685": "so I tell you you know you're absolutely", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00805-00240686-00241027": "right there will be season two systems", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00806-00241028-00241323": "but more than that I don't know because", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00807-00241325-00241552": "the last thing that copyright a girl", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00808-00241553-00241885": "wants to do is to test a dubious claim", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00809-00241886-00242152": "of rights against a strong fair use", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00810-00242153-00242404": "defense why because if they lose their", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00811-00242405-00243256": "in a much much so seems exactly when we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00812-00243257-00243391": "were discussing some of the mission", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00813-00243392-00243634": "earlier you were you were commenting on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00814-00243635-00243948": "the on the code and saying that you were", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00815-00243950-00244173": "concerned that you know or as it seemed", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00816-00244175-00244317": "like they will serve in weston sentence", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00817-00244319-00244507": "and amongst the writing community all", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00818-00244508-00244756": "these things weren't so sure that this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00819-00244757-00245292": "would extend to the publishers well yeah", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00820-00245294-00245535": "i'll say that but that's displayed", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00821-00245536-00245964": "I think that that gives it such an", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00822-00245965-00246279": "important in the past efforts have been", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00823-00246280-00246609": "made to get to do deserve wonderful", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00824-00246610-00246936": "all-party negotiations in which every", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00825-00246937-00247346": "you know the lateral line negotiate over", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00826-00247348-00247683": "the nature of fair use in a particular", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00827-00247684-00248040": "field and they are without except from", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00828-00248041-00248292": "the 1976 classroom guidelines that I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00829-00248292-00248594": "mentioned earlier to the kungfu debacle", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00830-00248596-00249012": "of recent years dismal tragic failures", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00831-00249013-00249258": "why because as a practical matter the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00832-00249259-00249632": "rights holders have no impetus no", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00833-00249633-00249903": "motivation negotiate in good faith in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00834-00249904-00250412": "those situations period so we can't now", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00835-00250413-00250958": "begin to think of the way in which", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00836-00250959-00251226": "creative practitioners inform themselves", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00837-00251227-00251625": "as being somehow based on an all-party", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00838-00251626-00252021": "consensus the Madison insight on the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00839-00252021-00252273": "basis of which this document and others", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00840-00252273-00252510": "like it are premise is that you don't", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00841-00252511-00252998": "need to have what you need is a good", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00842-00252998-00253298": "balance cross-sectional representation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00843-00253300-00253358": "of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00844-00253359-00253604": "the field itself and that's what you I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00845-00253605-00253748": "think that's what's really interesting", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00846-00253748-00254044": "about what that document does and how we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00847-00254046-00254296": "can take these ideas as receiving as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00848-00254298-00254467": "we've seen in other panels where you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00849-00254469-00254714": "have maybe a normative framework an", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00850-00254715-00254894": "ethical framework that isn't necessarily", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00851-00254894-00255056": "reflected in the law is where you gain", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00852-00255057-00255311": "very used to provide avisas we import", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00853-00255312-00255701": "that framework into into copyright law", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00854-00255702-00256079": "but since since Casey who brought up ken", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00855-00256080-00256382": "bolt if he has a website lulu web com", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00856-00256383-00256919": "and he will take any copyright but i", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00857-00256919-00257282": "would pop out of print works and throw", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00858-00257283-00257501": "them up on his website and he says that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00859-00257502-00257732": "you know the minute appears that that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00860-00257733-00257855": "they're in pigeon that they're available", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00861-00257856-00258023": "to people you know even if they're in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00862-00258023-00258188": "print he says if they're available add", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00863-00258189-00258346": "some Aksarben at price that you know", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00864-00258348-00258527": "when somebody thousands thousands of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00865-00258528-00258719": "dollars to actually buy one he'll take", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00866-00258719-00259094": "it down so i was wondering if you could", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00867-00259094-00259415": "comment and actually if everyone could", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00868-00259416-00259601": "comment on sir how do you feel about how", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00869-00259602-00259841": "do we wear works do they agree with that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00870-00259842-00260155": "that's the ethical framework that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00871-00260156-00260441": "Goldsmith says he's worked behind er do", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00872-00260442-00260621": "you think that that's ethical do you get", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00873-00260621-00260813": "is legal because it should be either of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00874-00260814-00261191": "them I'll just say something really I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00875-00261192-00261425": "can only count on a gallery but I'm is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00876-00261426-00261742": "completely up involved in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00877-00261742-00261942": "I teach it I teach her that i use it i", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00878-00261944-00262114": "recommend people find someone they like", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00879-00262115-00262524": "the tech here before this day now but", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00880-00262525-00262707": "you know the kind of work that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00881-00262708-00262921": "especially what he is doing he is not", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00882-00262922-00263113": "there like like trying to find her", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00883-00263114-00263293": "readers for Robert Frost a TS Eliot he", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00884-00263294-00263524": "is he is specifically promoting work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00885-00263525-00263743": "that is extremely hard to find otherwise", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00886-00263744-00263938": "it was published in print it's usually", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00887-00263939-00264217": "great a funeral as I quickly not many", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00888-00264218-00264472": "copies hard to find some of it sound", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00889-00264473-00264775": "poetry that really you need to hear it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00890-00264776-00265107": "and so he has a very specific niche and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00891-00265108-00265300": "he is making things available that are", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00892-00265301-00265620": "not just not available otherwise it was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00893-00265621-00265833": "revolutionized teaching for me when that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00894-00265834-00266287": "looks like we come less than about two", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00895-00266288-00266484": "years ago we had kind of colston come as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00896-00266485-00266662": "visiting artist give a lecture at the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00897-00266663-00266923": "Corcoran and just done by happenstance", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00898-00266924-00267100": "that afternoon as I was getting in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00899-00267101-00267364": "tour some of the studios we came into", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00900-00267365-00267523": "one of the classrooms of the classroom", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00901-00267524-00267783": "talk by galleries here in town James", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00902-00267784-00268107": "McLeod who own and she had a guest that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00903-00268108-00268402": "day intellectual property lawyer to come", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00904-00268403-00268663": "in in to talk to students about what is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00905-00268664-00268840": "fair and what is not and here we have", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00906-00268841-00268993": "kind of goldsmiths in the back of the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00907-00268994-00269510": "room put his visa was just a irascible", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00908-00269511-00269814": "and it was one of those brilliant", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00909-00269815-00270220": "moments of genuine educational discourse", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00910-00270221-00270478": "where his idea came right up against", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00911-00270479-00270707": "this attorney the attorney was like well", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00912-00270708-00271158": "god x y&z in Kennedy's like well yes", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00913-00271159-00271537": "however we're all artists here we are", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00914-00271538-00271734": "creators I mean this is great book", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00915-00271735-00272002": "Adrian John's piracy the intellectual", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00916-00272003-00272118": "property wars", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00917-00272119-00272388": "per case after you finish it uses a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00918-00272389-00272739": "doorstop this is not new discourse", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00919-00272740-00272946": "distance it's old is recorded history", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00920-00272947-00273273": "these ideas of what's fair must not and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00921-00273274-00273489": "the riders in the hardest have always", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00922-00273490-00273615": "pushed back you can make an argument", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00923-00273616-00273932": "that writing as Ken Wilson does it's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00924-00273933-00274293": "about 50 years behind individual art you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00925-00274294-00274755": "know get Marcel Duchamp urine somehow", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00926-00274756-00274998": "for riders there's this thing that's it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00927-00274999-00275207": "makes it more difficult in writing she", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00928-00275208-00275435": "kind of thinks that and I agree that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00929-00275436-00275694": "it's a equivalent I think it's Bruce", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00930-00275695-00275882": "Andrews is quoted it's a great moving", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00931-00275883-00276188": "its all new duet called sucking on words", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00932-00276189-00276489": "difficult to watch on power law but it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00933-00276490-00276758": "kind of shows goldsmiths ideas", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00934-00276759-00277010": "conceptual poetry itself we kind of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00935-00277011-00277143": "walks you through some of these", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00936-00277144-00277620": "different these different moves now what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00937-00277621-00277830": "was made of major kind of most famous", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00938-00277831-00278145": "projects probably was called day in day", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00939-00278146-00278337": "one what he does it talks about nine", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00940-00278338-00278490": "which as a school he was a sculptor", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00941-00278491-00278829": "chemicals at risk he moved into literate", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00942-00278830-00278997": "practice like really thinks of language", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00943-00278998-00279393": "as material that can be moved flow into", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00944-00279394-00279813": "different forms refrain he took the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00945-00279814-00280194": "addition in September 12 thousand New", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00946-00280195-00280544": "York Times metro efficient OCR de and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00947-00280545-00280788": "took out all the informational", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00948-00280789-00281159": "hierarchies so every word was the same", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00949-00281160-00281364": "about the headlines the same as the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00950-00281365-00281675": "small prepon small print in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00951-00281676-00281841": "classified", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00952-00281842-00282179": "and made a book out of the cold day so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00953-00282180-00282410": "it's nothing it's you know a lot of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00954-00282411-00282597": "people the traditional calls that mr.", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00955-00282598-00282863": "Goldstone that's not fun let me say well", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00956-00282864-00283119": "yeah let's go it's have this discussion", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00957-00283120-00283406": "about what poetry is the actual book is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00958-00283407-00283583": "doc he doesn't think that poetry is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00959-00283584-00283851": "necessarily there to be read thought", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00960-00283852-00284112": "about so if you get the idea you don't", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00961-00284113-00284354": "have to read the 900-page transcription", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00962-00284355-00284628": "of day to kind of know what's going on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00963-00284629-00284759": "in that home it's pretty revolutionary", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00964-00284760-00285243": "really again it's a widening of practice", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00965-00285244-00285498": "that I think is so help and not thinking", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00966-00285499-00285690": "that poetry is this one thing that has", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00967-00285691-00286014": "to fit into a compartment but a sense of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00968-00286015-00286203": "language being alive there's something", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00969-00286204-00286416": "really bizarre and kind of pernicious", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00970-00286417-00286614": "and weird thinking about language being", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00971-00286615-00287025": "owned by somebody just in preparation to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00972-00287026-00287175": "expand on I remember I'm a basketball", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00973-00287176-00287472": "fan I remember that John Calipari had", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00974-00287473-00287727": "trademarked the phrase refused to lose", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00975-00287728-00288083": "and Pat rioting the word three people", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00976-00288084-00288332": "there's a hilarious Greg Acadia article", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00977-00288333-00288509": "about three feet I was actually in this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00978-00288510-00288795": "Robert Byrd is calling a privately", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00979-00288796-00289092": "couldn't hit in first then the remind me", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00980-00289093-00289263": "a lot of the discussion we have about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00981-00289264-00289491": "fashion earlier to that have done with", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00982-00289492-00289835": "languages we've been that or you know we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00983-00289836-00290190": "share he said 26 little marks in English", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00984-00290191-00290444": "and half a dozen marks of punctuation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00985-00290445-00290783": "those are ours at 11 right now that's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00986-00290784-00290903": "how I go", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00987-00290904-00291140": "I don't done again as I said earlier", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00988-00291141-00291344": "thinking about possibility and not", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00989-00291345-00291686": "limitation for poetry is excited i think", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00990-00291687-00291917": "the digital world is brought all of this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00991-00291918-00292382": "new work this new potentiality to close", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00992-00292383-00293249": "so again a really really exciting time", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00993-00293250-00293909": "I bed with the poet Wyn Cooper last", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00994-00293910-00294271": "night and went had the good fortune of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00995-00294272-00294563": "writing a poem that was used in a sheryl", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00996-00294564-00294812": "crow song all i want to do is have some", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00997-00294813-00295244": "fun games of sheryl crow song when it's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00998-00295245-00295484": "been living off the royalties of that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-00999-00295485-00295952": "song for 15 years and with the free time", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01000-00295953-00296231": "that that afforded him he was able to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01001-00296232-00296761": "write such okay books he was able to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01002-00296762-00297013": "organize the brattleboro literary", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01003-00297014-00297440": "festival and so the protection of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01004-00297441-00297737": "intellectual property in that case with", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01005-00297738-00298325": "you know hugely hugely beneficial so I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01006-00298326-00298685": "think that the key to Ken Goldsmith's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01007-00298686-00299048": "site is that it's material that is not", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01008-00299049-00299453": "readily available whereas with Cooper's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01009-00299454-00299916": "poem and song is real readily available", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01010-00299917-00300206": "and i think the artist should have the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01011-00300207-00300675": "benefits so I want to encourage anyone", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01012-00300676-00300837": "in the audience has any questions did I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01013-00300838-00301187": "just say two words about Google wealth a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01014-00301188-00301512": "few more than two it's wonderful it's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01015-00301513-00301848": "you can get lost there and but the two", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01016-00301849-00302129": "words I wanted to say were principal", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01017-00302130-00302603": "seven look it up because the poets that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01018-00302604-00302804": "we made the code best practices had a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01019-00302805-00303102": "very very strong and very affirmative", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01020-00303103-00303441": "share a few of the status the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01021-00303442-00303803": "appropriate status of the points of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01022-00303804-00304197": "reference such as contrast i should say", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01023-00304198-00304770": "no one thought that a a popular song", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01024-00304771-00305121": "setting let alone and advertising use of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01025-00305122-00305435": "poetic material ought to be treated as a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01026-00305436-00305670": "transformative fair use they won't find", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01027-00305671-00306087": "that in the document anymore so again", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01028-00306088-00306318": "want to encourage questions but in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01029-00306319-00306591": "meantime you know a couple of times that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01030-00306592-00306777": "I think the phrase benign neglect or the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01031-00306778-00306978": "idea that nobody cares when the poor", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01032-00306979-00307307": "sales of the forest come up do you see", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01033-00307308-00307548": "that this changing not just in terms of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01034-00307549-00308105": "the the searchability of of poems that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01035-00308106-00308271": "appear on the web but also just be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01036-00308272-00308705": "availability is it is it a silver lining", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01037-00308706-00309050": "that there are forms of distribution", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01038-00309051-00309811": "that aren't small university presses in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01039-00309812-00310301": "one of the things I wonder about and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01040-00310302-00310469": "thinking about the fees that literary", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01041-00310470-00310739": "estates charge and then publishing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01042-00310740-00311245": "houses charge is what's the proper fee", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01043-00311246-00311834": "in the age of web for something that can", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01044-00311835-00312289": "be distributed globally but has a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01045-00312290-00312770": "limited audience as poetry does you know", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01046-00312771-00312998": "if he is based on the size of the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01047-00312999-00313381": "audience it should be a very nominal fee", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01048-00313382-00313727": "but if the fee is based on the fact that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01049-00313728-00314179": "the distribution is potentially global", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01050-00314180-00314534": "the fee for that should be astronomical", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01051-00314535-00314975": "and I don't know the answer that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01052-00314976-00315161": "question that's why we have public", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01053-00315162-00315250": "knowledge", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01054-00315251-00315505": "that's good man here to help us think of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01055-00315506-00315925": "these things that but I'll say one thing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01056-00315926-00316144": "if there's a monster your quest ya think", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01057-00316145-00316396": "it helps a lot I think that the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01058-00316397-00316762": "multiplicity of channels that new", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01059-00316763-00316993": "technology opens after the circulation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01060-00316994-00317179": "of knowledge in journal and poetry in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01061-00317180-00317551": "particular made a big difference in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01062-00317552-00318016": "terms of the practicalities of this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01063-00318017-00318352": "field but there are places where that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01064-00318353-00318799": "still where the writ of the internet", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01065-00318800-00319036": "does not run let us say and the most", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01066-00319037-00319329": "important example of that is of course", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01067-00319330-00319714": "publishing book published every critic", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01068-00319715-00320034": "and many boats and have you experienced", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01069-00320035-00320548": "countering publishers who highly risk", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01070-00320549-00320923": "averse and who insists we heard these", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01071-00320924-00321091": "stories in the context of anthologies", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01072-00321092-00321346": "but the same stories exist in the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01073-00321347-00321715": "context of critical studies of poetic", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01074-00321716-00321929": "work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01075-00321930-00322154": "again and again the price tags and the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01076-00322155-00322349": "thousands and tens of thousands of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01077-00322350-00322664": "dollars which may attach unnecessary", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01078-00322665-00322946": "clearances which have which have to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01079-00322947-00323210": "sawed off as the law requires but", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01080-00323211-00323531": "because of publishers requiring so there", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01081-00323532-00323756": "is really a lot of i briefed the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01082-00323757-00324001": "channels intermatter brave but the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01083-00324002-00324275": "structure of poetic culture still", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01084-00324276-00324563": "regards the book and something more in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01085-00324564-00324782": "its own time and there is work to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01086-00324783-00324974": "done clearing away some of the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01087-00324975-00325370": "impediments to publishing the kind of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01088-00325371-00325691": "valuable poetic and critical work that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01089-00325692-00326033": "is now being blocked as a result of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01090-00326034-00326297": "either overcautious legal interpretation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01091-00326298-00326588": "or simply profound misunderstanding to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01092-00326589-00326882": "dr. nefarious speaking about profound", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01093-00326883-00327152": "misunderstanding of fair use there's a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01094-00327153-00327467": "famous case of Paul Zhukov sees the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01095-00327468-00327755": "literary air of blues costigan course of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01096-00327756-00327998": "the southern yeah I brought down leonard", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01097-00327999-00328298": "sits right on the top of its common in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01098-00328299-00328433": "some ways but i guess it's kind of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01099-00328434-00328889": "horrifying to just this dude this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01100-00328890-00329231": "is Paul zhukovsky in 2005 despite what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01101-00329232-00329401": "you may have been told you may not use", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01102-00329402-00329732": "LZ blue to kasi words as you see fit as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01103-00329733-00329963": "if you own them while you hide behind a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01104-00329964-00330290": "rubric fair use fair use is very broadly", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01105-00330291-00330527": "defined doctrine of which I take a very", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01106-00330528-00330800": "narrow interpretation and I expect my", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01107-00330801-00331127": "views to be respected he goes on for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01108-00331128-00331532": "grassing mania condensed in this benefit", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01109-00331533-00331904": "letter but a very real kind of chilling", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01110-00331905-00332129": "effect and we actually have some you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01111-00332130-00332588": "know really blocked the support of his", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01112-00332589-00332792": "father's work because father's work is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01113-00332793-00333071": "now harder to read a lot of the work is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01114-00333072-00333225": "wholly on friend", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01115-00333226-00333444": "here's Paul's and constants a and he's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01116-00333445-00333717": "very up front like this is economic my", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01117-00333718-00333894": "father did this to set up this state for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01118-00333895-00334287": "me to make money Top Chef that's how", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01119-00334288-00334517": "that's how we roll at the very end", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01120-00334518-00334737": "finally when all else fails and you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01121-00334738-00334911": "remain hell-bent on quoting Louisa", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01122-00334912-00335106": "costume but you really really really do", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01123-00335107-00335274": "not want to deal with me where you can", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01124-00335275-00335490": "suitably advised to try to start to them", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01125-00335491-00335769": "remind yourself again and again yet once", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01126-00335770-00336012": "more what mentioned Baines Johnson said", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01127-00336013-00336261": "about j edgar Hoover I'd rather have him", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01128-00336262-00337427": "inside the tent pissing out the lives of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01129-00337428-00337635": "quoting and something that came up", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01130-00337636-00338031": "earlier I'm curious because something in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01131-00338032-00338205": "game shape to in theater in Susan you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01132-00338206-00338427": "were talking about the idea that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01133-00338428-00338685": "removing the house is removing the quote", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01134-00338686-00339036": "actually does seem to does you know it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01135-00339037-00339258": "will more transform the work the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01136-00339259-00339477": "quotation and more build it into", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01137-00339478-00339684": "something new at the same time I think", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01138-00339685-00339879": "one of the things came on the journals", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01139-00339880-00340098": "and panel was the idea that a lot of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01140-00340099-00340359": "times people are upset about copyright", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01141-00340360-00340503": "law so much as they are upset about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01142-00340504-00340836": "credit how do those how does that how", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01143-00340837-00341031": "those two things work together now", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01144-00341032-00341148": "that's a really that's a really good", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01145-00341149-00341497": "question because I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01146-00341498-00341653": "I couldn't find a book but I know I've", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01147-00341654-00341920": "seen more than one what where how it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01148-00341921-00342139": "actually made a similar joke like like", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01149-00342140-00342424": "you look up welcome to be like this much", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01150-00342425-00342589": "calm and then the rest of the footnotes", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01151-00342590-00342735": "only the footnotes would sort of be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01152-00342736-00343033": "funny and strange and it really became", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01153-00343034-00343378": "more than half the book happy you know", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01154-00343379-00343690": "this post can sort of get it and face of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01155-00343691-00343840": "the law of this too because we're such", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01156-00343841-00343996": "control freaks Nina the way to do", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01157-00343997-00344245": "attribution becomes part of the gesture", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01158-00344246-00344521": "of the poetics sometimes not doing it at", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01159-00344522-00344818": "all I I tend to do things like if a poem", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01160-00344819-00345013": "just realized how to land one or two", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01161-00345014-00345229": "sources I will note that in the back and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01162-00345230-00345334": "then otherwise I just have this", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01163-00345335-00345634": "conglomerate list of why used to when I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01164-00345635-00345865": "relied on and I don't say you know on", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01165-00345866-00346108": "page 32 or in-home such-and-such a quota", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01166-00346109-00346486": "zones oh never", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01167-00346487-00346949": "but yeah the question contribution goes", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01168-00346950-00347123": "up and it comes up a lot of teaching you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01169-00347124-00347237": "know my students have all of these", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01170-00347238-00347462": "questions and it's very confusing for", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01171-00347463-00347618": "students because it you know the first", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01172-00347619-00347756": "thing they learn about these issues is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01173-00347757-00347900": "don't play your eyes so the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01174-00347901-00348110": "personalities figure out one of them are", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01175-00348111-00348338": "sampling when the plate arising it we", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01176-00348339-00348482": "always give them the rule of thumb is if", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01177-00348483-00348629": "you want people to know it came to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01178-00348630-00348770": "somewhere else and sampling and if you", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01179-00348771-00348890": "want us to think you wrote it as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01180-00348891-00349379": "plagiarism we can go from there and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01181-00349380-00349610": "another issue that comes up is whether", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01182-00349611-00349853": "or not what you are what you are drawing", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01183-00349854-00350039": "from has been published in this will", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01184-00350040-00350204": "come up in communities and writers that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01185-00350205-00350483": "have low publication rates like students", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01186-00350484-00350690": "or certain kinds of quite a practice", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01187-00350691-00350894": "where publications we normally think of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01188-00350895-00351152": "it as the norm and what I was saying it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01189-00351153-00351440": "was imagine you know Casey wrote a poem", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01190-00351441-00351677": "and I heard it I really liked it so as a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01191-00351678-00351878": "homage to Casey I had a couple lines", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01192-00351879-00352064": "that in my phone but then my phone got", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01193-00352065-00352304": "published first and his mom comes out", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01194-00352305-00352592": "Casey still is linking to them so", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01195-00352593-00352874": "there's a lot of that kind of issue it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01196-00352875-00353174": "goes on among contemporaries that the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01197-00353175-00353360": "next attribution difficult and we try to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01198-00353361-00353663": "oppose it as a kind of conversation one", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01199-00353664-00353783": "of the things that's a conversation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01200-00353784-00354173": "among the poets were holding each other", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01201-00354174-00354326": "maybe going back before buying each", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01202-00354327-00354575": "other's ponds one of the deepest irony", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01203-00354576-00354803": "is about causal kaskus decision that the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01204-00354804-00355084": "objectives poets of luminosity was", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01205-00355085-00355291": "was a leader probably the defining", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01206-00355292-00355573": "person they had such a sense of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01207-00355574-00355783": "community and a sense of cohesiveness in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01208-00355784-00356110": "a sense of supporting and sort of fits", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01209-00356111-00356242": "in with each other all the time it just", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01210-00356243-00356497": "could not be more ironic for one of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01211-00356498-00356953": "those thoughts to be withdrawn so I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01212-00356954-00357229": "think we're running up a our time on it", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01213-00357230-00357481": "so I like to ask each of them as", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01214-00357482-00357745": "interactive to close out with a couple", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01215-00357746-00358315": "of final thoughts and ya know how that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01216-00358316-00358555": "first I'm just really happy to affirm", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01217-00358556-00358795": "Peters with a strong stance about fair", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01218-00358796-00359041": "you some what we can do and I can't wait", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01219-00359042-00359418": "to spread the word and I'll add that I", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01220-00359419-00359695": "really appreciate what Susan just said", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01221-00359696-00360010": "about attribution as a conversation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01222-00360011-00360322": "because if you would when you hope its", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01223-00360323-00360601": "own read this document you'll see that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01224-00360602-00361012": "there is a conversation throughout the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01225-00361013-00361139": "document", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01226-00361140-00361493": "in and out of all the principles what", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01227-00361494-00361756": "might sum it up the server the center of", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01228-00361757-00361970": "gravity position by saying the poets", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01229-00361971-00362201": "Dalton attribution was extremely", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01230-00362202-00362506": "important when it made sense to a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01231-00362507-00362857": "tribute and that an obligation to a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01232-00362858-00363007": "tribute which is of course dr. us", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01233-00363008-00363272": "anywhere the law as such these couldn't", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01234-00363273-00364064": "extend to situations in which but the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01235-00364065-00364303": "conversation is you and its complexity", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01236-00364304-00364624": "or to the mechanics a great phrase as is", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01237-00364625-00365008": "potential rather than possibility rather", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01238-00365009-00365219": "than constraint protect about to steal", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01239-00365220-00365646": "good permanently", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01240-00365647-00365989": "unfortunately a lot of students are not", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01241-00365990-00366205": "as lucky as Susan students to be", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01242-00366206-00366510": "introduced to fair use in the classroom", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01243-00366511-00366787": "like that a lot of students especially", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01244-00366788-00367027": "grad students are learning about fair", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01245-00367028-00367312": "use from their librarians right now", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01246-00367313-00367612": "because the thesis and the dissertation", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01247-00367613-00367816": "has become a digital document that's", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01248-00367817-00367981": "going to be published on the web and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01249-00367982-00368241": "again", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01250-00368242-00368429": "there's a kind of chilling effect", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01251-00368430-00368772": "because universities are very shy about", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01252-00368773-00369240": "being sued by big corporations so again", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01253-00369241-00369528": "a poet can steal from another poet and", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01254-00369529-00369903": "it's not going to be flagged by the", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01255-00369904-00370112": "piece you know maybe reconsider", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01256-00370113-00370534": "reconsider the work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01257-00370535-00370774": "I'm effects so much as far as last words", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01258-00370775-00371050": "that just like to encourage people to", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01259-00371051-00371182": "realize especially those who live in", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01260-00371183-00371380": "Washington DC we're in the midst of a", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01261-00371381-00371635": "really vibrant poetry community that", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01262-00371636-00371792": "feels with these issues and the work", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01263-00371793-00372004": "that we make and work that we perform", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01264-00372005-00372368": "we're lucky that we have probably for my", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01265-00372369-00372658": "money the best poetry book shop in maybe", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01266-00372659-00372865": "North America at bridgestreet books", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01267-00372866-00373088": "curated by Rod Smith where you'll find", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01268-00373089-00373300": "all kinds of stuff that we're talking", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01269-00373301-00373522": "about we have a potent coming bare block", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01270-00373523-00373723": "one of the fathers of language poetry", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01271-00373724-00374032": "reading this Tuesday and so read more", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01272-00374033-00375856": "poetry poetry prose", "BJh-mZ0u4hc-01273-00375857-00376063": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "BJotlw9120c", "text": {"BJotlw9120c-00000-00000002-00000278": "well I'm David King at peak in shawnee", "BJotlw9120c-00001-00000279-00000437": "county public library and i'm here with", "BJotlw9120c-00002-00000438-00000911": "gina Millsap our CEO of Gina so I hear", "BJotlw9120c-00003-00000911-00001106": "that our library just want a pretty", "BJotlw9120c-00004-00001107-00001289": "major award can you tell me more about", "BJotlw9120c-00005-00001290-00001532": "that yes it's really exciting it's", "BJotlw9120c-00006-00001533-00001787": "called library of the year okay and it's", "BJotlw9120c-00007-00001788-00002032": "an award that any library public library", "BJotlw9120c-00008-00002034-00002507": "in North America can apply for so we", "BJotlw9120c-00009-00002508-00002933": "feel very fortunate and that we were", "BJotlw9120c-00010-00002934-00003401": "selected and it's really because of the", "BJotlw9120c-00011-00003402-00003645": "great work that our staff do every day", "BJotlw9120c-00012-00003646-00003940": "it's the support that we get from our", "BJotlw9120c-00013-00003942-00004265": "Board of Trustees and their guidance and", "BJotlw9120c-00014-00004266-00004445": "providing all those great resources that", "BJotlw9120c-00015-00004446-00004669": "we have and it's our community so", "BJotlw9120c-00016-00004670-00005006": "obviously we had to do something what", "BJotlw9120c-00017-00005007-00005216": "extraordinary out of the ordinary to win", "BJotlw9120c-00018-00005217-00005426": "this award how did we win it exactly", "BJotlw9120c-00019-00005427-00005681": "well we told a story you know and I", "BJotlw9120c-00020-00005682-00005867": "think I think maybe the best", "BJotlw9120c-00021-00005868-00006200": "applications are stories rather than", "BJotlw9120c-00022-00006201-00006409": "just a listing of things we do or", "BJotlw9120c-00023-00006411-00006698": "accomplishments that we have what we", "BJotlw9120c-00024-00006698-00006895": "talked about was how we work to help", "BJotlw9120c-00025-00006897-00007123": "build community how to create community", "BJotlw9120c-00026-00007125-00007403": "and so the library for a number of years", "BJotlw9120c-00027-00007404-00007660": "now has really been focused on what", "BJotlw9120c-00028-00007661-00007838": "difference do we make in our community", "BJotlw9120c-00029-00007839-00008110": "especially in the areas of learning and", "BJotlw9120c-00030-00008111-00008369": "literacy because that's really our mean", "BJotlw9120c-00031-00008370-00008578": "potatoes if you will that's what", "BJotlw9120c-00032-00008579-00008749": "libraries do and we know that because", "BJotlw9120c-00033-00008750-00008951": "we've asked our community in a variety", "BJotlw9120c-00034-00008952-00009230": "of ways we've got in 2014 we did a", "BJotlw9120c-00035-00009231-00009512": "community survey last summer we held a", "BJotlw9120c-00036-00009513-00009635": "series of meetings throughout the", "BJotlw9120c-00037-00009636-00009799": "community and talk to people face to", "BJotlw9120c-00038-00009800-00010001": "face and ask them what their dreams and", "BJotlw9120c-00039-00010002-00010192": "aspirations for their lives were for", "BJotlw9120c-00040-00010193-00010316": "themselves and their families and for", "BJotlw9120c-00041-00010317-00010508": "the community and then how the library", "BJotlw9120c-00042-00010509-00010760": "could help them achieve them and that's", "BJotlw9120c-00043-00010761-00011003": "really that what we focused on and what", "BJotlw9120c-00044-00011004-00011246": "we talked about in our application for", "BJotlw9120c-00045-00011247-00011667": "library of the year and also what we did", "BJotlw9120c-00046-00011668-00011942": "organizationally and to with ourselves", "BJotlw9120c-00047-00011943-00012278": "as library professionals to be prepared", "BJotlw9120c-00048-00012279-00012569": "to do that so we've we've changed the", "BJotlw9120c-00049-00012570-00012749": "definition of librarian over the last", "BJotlw9120c-00050-00012750-00012841": "few years okay", "BJotlw9120c-00051-00012841-00013108": "that's pretty cool so what what is this", "BJotlw9120c-00052-00013109-00013563": "award I mean for our community what we", "BJotlw9120c-00053-00013565-00013801": "hope first of all it's a it's a it's a", "BJotlw9120c-00054-00013802-00014116": "big thank you to the community to say", "BJotlw9120c-00055-00014116-00014413": "thank you for all your support thank you", "BJotlw9120c-00056-00014413-00014635": "to the hundred thousand people who have", "BJotlw9120c-00057-00014636-00014935": "library cards and who used this library", "BJotlw9120c-00058-00014936-00015100": "and whose lives are better because of", "BJotlw9120c-00059-00015101-00015496": "that it's a thank you to our staff for", "BJotlw9120c-00060-00015497-00015652": "all of their hard work and all of the", "BJotlw9120c-00061-00015653-00015858": "great assistance that they they provide", "BJotlw9120c-00062-00015859-00016060": "to the community and how they work with", "BJotlw9120c-00063-00016061-00016383": "the community to our board certainly", "BJotlw9120c-00064-00016384-00016768": "it's also what it also means is that we", "BJotlw9120c-00065-00016769-00017175": "are we are a world-class library any any", "BJotlw9120c-00066-00017176-00017584": "parting thoughts for us I think that for", "BJotlw9120c-00067-00017585-00017914": "us now the real work begins because", "BJotlw9120c-00068-00017915-00018144": "we're we're embarking on our new", "BJotlw9120c-00069-00018145-00018424": "strategic plan and it really is focused", "BJotlw9120c-00070-00018425-00018592": "on all of the things our community said", "BJotlw9120c-00071-00018593-00018718": "they wanted and needed from their", "BJotlw9120c-00072-00018719-00019060": "library and so everyone will discover", "BJotlw9120c-00073-00019061-00019281": "their passion for learning we're", "BJotlw9120c-00074-00019282-00019480": "committed to making sure every child is", "BJotlw9120c-00075-00019481-00019705": "ready for kindergarten we're committed", "BJotlw9120c-00076-00019706-00019912": "to being sure that everybody continues", "BJotlw9120c-00077-00019913-00020062": "to learn throughout life to live their", "BJotlw9120c-00078-00020063-00020461": "best life and we are just absolutely", "BJotlw9120c-00079-00020462-00020653": "going to go after making sure that", "BJotlw9120c-00080-00020654-00020859": "everyone in topeka and shawnee county is", "BJotlw9120c-00081-00020860-00021156": "a reader cool yes that's exciting well", "BJotlw9120c-00082-00021157-00021487": "thanks Gina you're welcome"}}, {"audio_id": "BJFRXT_-UZI", "text": {"BJFRXT_-UZI-00000-00000000-00030199": "[Music]", "BJFRXT_-UZI-00001-00030200-00030313": "you", "BJFRXT_-UZI-00002-00030314-00030780": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "BJS1Oc7rB4U", "text": {"BJS1Oc7rB4U-00000-00000025-00001124": "[Music]", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00001-00001125-00001497": "close till I get up some is barely", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00002-00001498-00001707": "outside", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00003-00001707-00002135": "I don't always would", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00004-00002136-00002556": "it's noise which is leading us is", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00005-00002557-00002964": "all-wheel ever trust ya know I don't", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00006-00002965-00003249": "always with", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00007-00003250-00003556": "[Music]", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00008-00003557-00003809": "we'll go", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00009-00003810-00004160": "three stands to the highways summer", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00010-00004161-00005878": "shadow to sunrays", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00011-00005879-00008224": "[Music]", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00012-00008225-00008745": "find along the way melodies we haven't", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00013-00008746-00009343": "played I don't know", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00014-00009344-00009827": "go in around these walls to create a", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00015-00009828-00010014": "song", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00016-00010015-00010717": "[Music]", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00017-00010718-00011026": "we'll go", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00018-00011027-00011152": "through the wastelands through the", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00019-00011153-00011437": "highways through my shadow to the", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00020-00011438-00012132": "sunrays and", "BJS1Oc7rB4U-00021-00012133-00012420": "to the waist is"}}, {"audio_id": "BJS-25GpN6U", "text": {"BJS-25GpN6U-00000-00000119-00000350": "oh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00001-00000351-00001549": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00002-00001550-00001948": "let's go let's go bro annoying ass", "BJS-25GpN6U-00003-00001950-00005383": "Ganondorf", "BJS-25GpN6U-00004-00005384-00005681": "here what is good YouTube it is your boy", "BJS-25GpN6U-00005-00005682-00005886": "LSG Melly and I'm bringing you guys", "BJS-25GpN6U-00006-00005887-00006341": "Super Smash Bros ultimate bro I had so", "BJS-25GpN6U-00007-00006342-00006454": "much fun the last time I wanted to", "BJS-25GpN6U-00008-00006455-00006731": "record this [__] again I I missed this", "BJS-25GpN6U-00009-00006731-00006995": "game way too much bro if you guys look", "BJS-25GpN6U-00010-00006995-00007228": "at my look at my takeover TV channel you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00011-00007229-00007445": "know I have a lot of Smash content on", "BJS-25GpN6U-00012-00007445-00007648": "there bro like", "BJS-25GpN6U-00013-00007650-00007925": "I'm trying to get back at it so we're", "BJS-25GpN6U-00014-00007926-00008105": "about to just start replaying this [__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00015-00008106-00008267": "again without further Ado we about to", "BJS-25GpN6U-00016-00008268-00008392": "get into this thing if you guys are", "BJS-25GpN6U-00017-00008393-00008531": "liking the content please like And", "BJS-25GpN6U-00018-00008532-00008746": "subscribe turn notification Bell on I", "BJS-25GpN6U-00019-00008747-00008842": "don't know who I'm about to play with", "BJS-25GpN6U-00020-00008843-00008981": "today though", "BJS-25GpN6U-00021-00008982-00009149": "uh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00022-00009150-00009371": "am I feeling", "BJS-25GpN6U-00023-00009372-00009556": "I'm about to say am I feeling like young", "BJS-25GpN6U-00024-00009557-00009886": "Link but young Link sounds crazy though", "BJS-25GpN6U-00025-00009887-00010217": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00026-00010218-00010421": "you know what I'm about to serve some", "BJS-25GpN6U-00027-00010422-00011023": "young Link", "BJS-25GpN6U-00028-00011024-00011296": "young Link I like young Link he's he's", "BJS-25GpN6U-00029-00011297-00011464": "kind of like a cop-out character though", "BJS-25GpN6U-00030-00011465-00011638": "because of all his projectiles and [__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00031-00011639-00012035": "like that so", "BJS-25GpN6U-00032-00012036-00013369": "we'll see we'll see we'll see", "BJS-25GpN6U-00033-00013369-00013615": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00034-00013616-00013955": "I don't know why he thought for that", "BJS-25GpN6U-00035-00013956-00014825": "[__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00036-00014826-00015154": "foreign", "BJS-25GpN6U-00037-00015155-00015972": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00038-00015974-00016177": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00039-00016178-00016403": "what the hell how how long have you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00040-00016404-00016662": "practiced that", "BJS-25GpN6U-00041-00016663-00018067": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00042-00018068-00018377": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00043-00018378-00018850": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00044-00018851-00019212": "yo", "BJS-25GpN6U-00045-00019213-00019786": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00046-00019787-00019944": "[__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00047-00019945-00021893": "thank you both we not to fob his ass", "BJS-25GpN6U-00048-00021894-00022458": "foreign", "BJS-25GpN6U-00049-00022459-00022799": "oh wow", "BJS-25GpN6U-00050-00022800-00023544": "I saved him", "BJS-25GpN6U-00051-00023545-00024372": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00052-00024373-00025800": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00053-00025801-00026737": "I think the fact that", "BJS-25GpN6U-00054-00026738-00027455": "[__] is crazy", "BJS-25GpN6U-00055-00027456-00027646": "see look the fact that he can really", "BJS-25GpN6U-00056-00027647-00027949": "just get away with that", "BJS-25GpN6U-00057-00027950-00028343": "what the [__] was that", "BJS-25GpN6U-00058-00028344-00028643": "oh we got an incineroar oh my gosh you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00059-00028644-00028805": "got to be careful with this what this uh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00060-00028806-00028945": "character bro", "BJS-25GpN6U-00061-00028945-00029323": "one go", "BJS-25GpN6U-00062-00029324-00029967": "as every incinero don't play the same", "BJS-25GpN6U-00063-00029968-00030643": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00064-00030644-00030923": "this is cineroy's kinda", "BJS-25GpN6U-00065-00030924-00031589": "he's not that aggressive", "BJS-25GpN6U-00066-00031589-00031908": "young legs [__] sword is too slow", "BJS-25GpN6U-00067-00031908-00032716": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00068-00032717-00032968": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00069-00032969-00033465": "not too slow too short", "BJS-25GpN6U-00070-00033466-00033599": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00071-00033600-00033728": "thank you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00072-00033729-00034048": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00073-00034049-00034465": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00074-00034466-00034765": "he kind of didn't think that through", "BJS-25GpN6U-00075-00034766-00034967": "incineroa has one of the worst", "BJS-25GpN6U-00076-00034968-00035468": "recoveries in this game", "BJS-25GpN6U-00077-00035469-00036412": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00078-00036413-00036882": "foreign", "BJS-25GpN6U-00079-00036883-00037331": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00080-00037332-00038336": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00081-00038337-00039354": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00082-00039355-00040098": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00083-00040099-00040321": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00084-00040322-00041099": "he's too slow for young Link", "BJS-25GpN6U-00085-00041100-00041657": "why did I blow myself up", "BJS-25GpN6U-00086-00041658-00041887": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00087-00041888-00042101": "now this man is getting three stock", "BJS-25GpN6U-00088-00042102-00042557": "today", "BJS-25GpN6U-00089-00042558-00043768": "this man is getting three stock today", "BJS-25GpN6U-00090-00043769-00043924": "this man is getting three stocks today", "BJS-25GpN6U-00091-00043925-00044387": "bro he didn't know what to do just now", "BJS-25GpN6U-00092-00044388-00044849": "hit him with that clean", "BJS-25GpN6U-00093-00044850-00045196": "Mithra and Pyro oh my gosh everybody", "BJS-25GpN6U-00094-00045197-00045467": "like you spamming Mithra for damage and", "BJS-25GpN6U-00095-00045468-00046108": "then pyro for the for the final blows", "BJS-25GpN6U-00096-00046109-00046949": "I've been fought a Metroid ages", "BJS-25GpN6U-00097-00046950-00047195": "I don't know this is not a this is not a", "BJS-25GpN6U-00098-00047196-00047489": "character a fight like that", "BJS-25GpN6U-00099-00047490-00047651": "I don't know why I don't fight mithril", "BJS-25GpN6U-00100-00047652-00047879": "like that no more", "BJS-25GpN6U-00101-00047880-00048149": "this character first came out", "BJS-25GpN6U-00102-00048150-00048515": "I don't know", "BJS-25GpN6U-00103-00048516-00048671": "oh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00104-00048672-00049037": "God", "BJS-25GpN6U-00105-00049038-00049187": "I knew she was going to do that and", "BJS-25GpN6U-00106-00049188-00050608": "still couldn't stop it", "BJS-25GpN6U-00107-00050609-00050826": "are you a [__] lucky [__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00108-00050827-00051229": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00109-00051229-00051502": "yeah no no don't get too spammy with", "BJS-25GpN6U-00110-00051503-00051820": "that move bro", "BJS-25GpN6U-00111-00051821-00052037": "back", "BJS-25GpN6U-00112-00052038-00053488": "inside", "BJS-25GpN6U-00113-00053489-00053999": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00114-00054000-00054173": "see", "BJS-25GpN6U-00115-00054174-00055554": "she's so slow", "BJS-25GpN6U-00116-00055555-00056287": "what do you I mean Pyro", "BJS-25GpN6U-00117-00056288-00056537": "yo what is what is these people doing", "BJS-25GpN6U-00118-00056538-00056834": "today", "BJS-25GpN6U-00119-00056835-00057141": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00120-00057141-00057172": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00121-00057173-00057953": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00122-00057954-00058450": "no I saw it coming I saw it coming [__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00123-00058451-00059099": "I'll change back [__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00124-00059100-00059870": "foreign", "BJS-25GpN6U-00125-00059871-00060191": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00126-00060191-00060394": "[__] change back like you [__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00127-00060395-00060753": "accomplished something", "BJS-25GpN6U-00128-00060754-00061559": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00129-00061560-00062676": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00130-00062677-00062879": "this person don't even know what to do", "BJS-25GpN6U-00131-00062879-00062965": "with me right now", "BJS-25GpN6U-00132-00062966-00063388": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00133-00063389-00063476": "oh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00134-00063477-00064012": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00135-00064013-00064475": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00136-00064476-00064859": "nope", "BJS-25GpN6U-00137-00064860-00065185": "Robin", "BJS-25GpN6U-00138-00065186-00065697": "you gotta love Pyro at all", "BJS-25GpN6U-00139-00065698-00066700": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00140-00066701-00066866": "mm-hmm", "BJS-25GpN6U-00141-00066867-00067894": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00142-00067895-00068105": "don't get too spammy now don't get too", "BJS-25GpN6U-00143-00068106-00068782": "jumpy don't get too jumpy", "BJS-25GpN6U-00144-00068783-00069548": "you're too jumpy", "BJS-25GpN6U-00145-00069549-00069871": "[Laughter]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00146-00069872-00070237": "oh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00147-00070238-00070517": "yo young Link has so much potential", "BJS-25GpN6U-00148-00070518-00070709": "though the reason why I stopped meaning", "BJS-25GpN6U-00149-00070710-00070811": "him", "BJS-25GpN6U-00150-00070812-00071026": "or not Kirby has always been my main the", "BJS-25GpN6U-00151-00071027-00071176": "reason why I stopped like trying to make", "BJS-25GpN6U-00152-00071177-00071453": "young Link a second is because his sword", "BJS-25GpN6U-00153-00071454-00071693": "is too little it's so [__] hard to", "BJS-25GpN6U-00154-00071694-00072079": "hit people with him", "BJS-25GpN6U-00155-00072080-00072599": "are you good wake up", "BJS-25GpN6U-00156-00072600-00072815": "wake up getting they don't even have a", "BJS-25GpN6U-00157-00072816-00073241": "name", "BJS-25GpN6U-00158-00073242-00073691": "I'm trying to grab me", "BJS-25GpN6U-00159-00073692-00074232": "foreign", "BJS-25GpN6U-00160-00074233-00074549": "likes to he likes to stay on okay okay I", "BJS-25GpN6U-00161-00074550-00075886": "see I see the type of player you are", "BJS-25GpN6U-00162-00075887-00076585": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00163-00076586-00076881": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00164-00076882-00077244": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00165-00077245-00077414": "oh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00166-00077415-00077838": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00167-00077839-00078076": "you think it's about to be an easy dub", "BJS-25GpN6U-00168-00078077-00078271": "Ganon [__] out of here", "BJS-25GpN6U-00169-00078272-00078826": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00170-00078827-00079267": "oh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00171-00079268-00079489": "my God", "BJS-25GpN6U-00172-00079490-00080741": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00173-00080742-00081144": "oh my gosh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00174-00081145-00081732": "oh yeah", "BJS-25GpN6U-00175-00081733-00082091": "oh you fell for that damn I gotta be", "BJS-25GpN6U-00176-00082092-00082439": "careful with him though", "BJS-25GpN6U-00177-00082440-00083372": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00178-00083373-00084244": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00179-00084245-00085379": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00180-00085380-00085985": "laughs", "BJS-25GpN6U-00181-00085986-00087801": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00182-00087802-00088205": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00183-00088206-00088493": "what the [__] I I was trying I was not", "BJS-25GpN6U-00184-00088494-00088661": "trying to stop at the ledge I was trying", "BJS-25GpN6U-00185-00088662-00089003": "to go off the ledge and do the so he", "BJS-25GpN6U-00186-00089004-00089225": "couldn't get back on [__] I got too", "BJS-25GpN6U-00187-00089226-00089429": "close now it's like there was like an", "BJS-25GpN6U-00188-00089430-00089668": "invisible stop sign I ran to the edge", "BJS-25GpN6U-00189-00089669-00089903": "but it's like he didn't want to go off", "BJS-25GpN6U-00190-00089904-00090131": "damn I want to fight this Ganon again", "BJS-25GpN6U-00191-00090132-00090376": "one more fight if I lose which I", "BJS-25GpN6U-00192-00090377-00090553": "probably might cause this Ganon is weird", "BJS-25GpN6U-00193-00090554-00091344": "then I'll get off I'ma get off", "BJS-25GpN6U-00194-00091345-00091793": "three two one go easy on me shut the", "BJS-25GpN6U-00195-00091794-00091940": "[__] up", "BJS-25GpN6U-00196-00091941-00092838": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00197-00092839-00094115": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00198-00094116-00094343": "go easy on me stop don't stop the", "BJS-25GpN6U-00199-00094344-00094546": "[__]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00200-00094547-00095497": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00201-00095498-00095747": "thank you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00202-00095748-00096102": "thank you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00203-00096103-00096789": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00204-00096790-00097109": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00205-00097110-00097349": "yeah there we go yeah there we go there", "BJS-25GpN6U-00206-00097350-00097539": "we [__] go", "BJS-25GpN6U-00207-00097540-00098204": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00208-00098205-00099394": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00209-00099395-00099611": "damn I I can't stay at that edge with", "BJS-25GpN6U-00210-00099612-00099689": "ganon's", "BJS-25GpN6U-00211-00099690-00100419": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00212-00100420-00101512": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00213-00101513-00101986": "thank you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00214-00101987-00103130": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00215-00103131-00103332": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00216-00103333-00104675": "don't die getting", "BJS-25GpN6U-00217-00104676-00104915": "traffic I'm trying to bait him into", "BJS-25GpN6U-00218-00104916-00104999": "killing himself", "BJS-25GpN6U-00219-00105000-00106108": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00220-00106109-00106481": "[Applause]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00221-00106482-00107386": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00222-00107388-00107665": "there we go", "BJS-25GpN6U-00223-00107666-00108131": "yo I was trying to get this dumbass bro", "BJS-25GpN6U-00224-00108132-00108778": "come on", "BJS-25GpN6U-00225-00108779-00108977": "no you don't know the [__] you done with", "BJS-25GpN6U-00226-00108978-00109054": "that", "BJS-25GpN6U-00227-00109055-00109810": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00228-00109811-00110195": "why did I why did I stay in his path", "BJS-25GpN6U-00229-00110196-00110338": "thank you", "BJS-25GpN6U-00230-00110339-00111757": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00231-00111758-00112029": "oh I should have oh", "BJS-25GpN6U-00232-00112030-00113002": "[Music]", "BJS-25GpN6U-00233-00113003-00113369": "let's go let's go bro annoying ass", "BJS-25GpN6U-00234-00113370-00113699": "Ganondorf", "BJS-25GpN6U-00235-00113700-00113945": "got an endorph he finished everybody off", "BJS-25GpN6U-00236-00113946-00114178": "like like with this pose because he", "BJS-25GpN6U-00237-00114179-00114497": "don't think highly high and mighty", "BJS-25GpN6U-00238-00114498-00114647": "I'm trying to talk [__] I'm over here", "BJS-25GpN6U-00239-00114648-00114778": "stutter I'm gonna end the video all", "BJS-25GpN6U-00240-00114779-00114947": "right guys that's gonna be the end of", "BJS-25GpN6U-00241-00114948-00115175": "this video I I hate when I can't end the", "BJS-25GpN6U-00242-00115176-00115354": "video properly but if you guys have", "BJS-25GpN6U-00243-00115355-00115499": "enjoyed this video I really would", "BJS-25GpN6U-00244-00115500-00115631": "appreciate it if you like And subscribe", "BJS-25GpN6U-00245-00115632-00115847": "turn notification Bell", "BJS-25GpN6U-00246-00115848-00116008": "you know", "BJS-25GpN6U-00247-00116009-00116213": "um I've been having a lot of fun with", "BJS-25GpN6U-00248-00116214-00116363": "you guys on YouTube lately like the", "BJS-25GpN6U-00249-00116364-00116566": "comments like you guys are really like", "BJS-25GpN6U-00250-00116567-00116710": "you guys you guys are showing so much", "BJS-25GpN6U-00251-00116711-00116939": "love I love it", "BJS-25GpN6U-00252-00116940-00117166": "um that's it I'm gonna probably record", "BJS-25GpN6U-00253-00117167-00117383": "another one of these tonight before I go", "BJS-25GpN6U-00254-00117383-00117575": "to bed so", "BJS-25GpN6U-00255-00117576-00117923": "you'll have two fresh ones for you I", "BJS-25GpN6U-00256-00117924-00118036": "don't know who else I'm gonna play with", "BJS-25GpN6U-00257-00118038-00118169": "though that's gonna be the end of this", "BJS-25GpN6U-00258-00118170-00118339": "video guys see you guys in the next one", "BJS-25GpN6U-00259-00118340-00118645": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "BK0vuA67qmQ", "text": {"BK0vuA67qmQ-00000-00000456-00000726": "it is now time for oral questions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00001-00000727-00001303": "i recognize the member from nickelback", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00002-00001304-00001503": "thank you speaker my question is to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00003-00001504-00001679": "minister of health every question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00004-00001680-00001855": "parliament the official opposition has", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00005-00001855-00002079": "brought the story of struggling", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00006-00002080-00002391": "ontarians people who waited hours in the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00007-00002392-00002687": "emergency room in pain people who had to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00008-00002688-00002950": "leave the hospital without getting the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00009-00002951-00003095": "care they needed", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00010-00003096-00003319": "people who have waited in agony for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00011-00003320-00003511": "urgent surgery", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00012-00003511-00003799": "all this because of staff shortages", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00013-00003800-00004022": "being made worse every day by this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00014-00004023-00004263": "government's action why is this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00015-00004264-00004502": "government willing to make the waiting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00016-00004503-00004735": "worse by expanding", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00017-00004736-00004959": "private surgical clinic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00018-00004960-00005247": "siphoning more of our staff away from", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00019-00005248-00005695": "public hospitals", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00020-00005696-00005895": "deputy premier and minister of health", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00021-00005896-00006038": "thank you speaker you know we have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00022-00006039-00006270": "always said that we need to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00023-00006271-00006542": "um look at these challenges in a way", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00024-00006543-00006734": "that goes outside of what we are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00025-00006736-00006870": "currently doing in the province of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00026-00006872-00007127": "ontario as the member opposite knows we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00027-00007128-00007246": "do have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00028-00007247-00007455": "clinics like the shoulders hospital that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00029-00007456-00007639": "currently operate and have operated for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00030-00007640-00007846": "decades in the province of ontario we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00031-00007847-00008070": "will continue to work with those", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00032-00008072-00008278": "partners all partnerships we've seen", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00033-00008279-00008503": "innovative models with community care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00034-00008504-00008727": "paramedics we've seen innovative models", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00035-00008728-00008807": "with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00036-00008808-00008959": "911", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00037-00008960-00009103": "offloads with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00038-00009104-00009342": "dedicated offload nurse practitioners", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00039-00009343-00009599": "who are able to take those emergency", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00040-00009600-00009751": "department", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00041-00009752-00009967": "patients so that the paramedics can go", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00042-00009968-00010191": "back out onto the road all of these are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00043-00010192-00010503": "innovations new ways of approaching an", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00044-00010504-00010742": "existing problem that has been plaguing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00045-00010743-00010935": "our healthcare system for frankly years", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00046-00010936-00011110": "and years and we're going to make sure", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00047-00011111-00011351": "that those innovations are available to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00048-00011352-00011551": "all communities i've often spoken about", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00049-00011552-00011727": "the paramedic program that's available", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00050-00011728-00011983": "in 49 areas we're going to expand that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00051-00011984-00012214": "because it's working thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00052-00012215-00012414": "the supplemental question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00053-00012415-00012614": "thank you speaker over the last month", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00054-00012615-00012863": "families in ontario have watched", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00055-00012863-00013119": "and across the province so have watched", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00056-00013119-00013327": "as the crisis across the province and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00057-00013328-00013663": "healthcare has gone worse and worse over", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00058-00013663-00013983": "the summer at least 26 hospitals have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00059-00013984-00014175": "been forced to close their emergency", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00060-00014176-00014455": "department to patients and across the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00061-00014456-00014671": "province nurses and health care workers", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00062-00014672-00014983": "are leaving in droves more than ever we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00063-00014984-00015286": "need a plan to strengthen publicly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00064-00015287-00015535": "delivered health care and support nurses", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00065-00015536-00015750": "and front-line healthcare workers who", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00066-00015751-00015886": "provide it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00067-00015887-00016215": "why is this government so determined to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00068-00016216-00016511": "let this crisis go on and tell us that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00069-00016512-00016879": "the only way out is to privatize more of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00070-00016880-00017422": "our health care system", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00071-00017423-00017671": "you know i'm i'm proud of the work that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00072-00017672-00017950": "we've already put in place we've already", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00073-00017951-00018207": "expanded the ability for hospitals to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00074-00018208-00018286": "have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00075-00018287-00018591": "more post surgeries happening beyond", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00076-00018592-00018855": "the standard nine to five or nine to six", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00077-00018856-00018975": "operations", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00078-00018976-00019150": "we're easing pressures on our emergency", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00079-00019151-00019343": "department and of course as recently as", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00080-00019344-00019575": "this week the colleges of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00081-00019576-00019822": "the college of nurses has now worked", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00082-00019823-00020079": "with us and expedited internationally", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00083-00020080-00020271": "educated healthcare workers you know", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00084-00020272-00020447": "we're working with our partners when", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00085-00020448-00020655": "they bring forward ideas and suggestions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00086-00020656-00020911": "that we see have an opportunity to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00087-00020912-00021127": "improve the health human resources in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00088-00021128-00021439": "ontario were doing that this is not a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00089-00021440-00021750": "ontario exclusive issue we're seeing it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00090-00021751-00021983": "in jurisdictions across canada indeed", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00091-00021984-00022191": "the world but we're making sure where we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00092-00022192-00022583": "have opportunities for engagement for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00093-00022584-00022758": "improvements we're doing that and of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00094-00022759-00022983": "course most recently that's the colleges", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00095-00022984-00023135": "of nurses with our internationally", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00096-00023136-00023671": "trained educators", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00097-00023672-00023855": "nurses and healthcare workers have been", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00098-00023856-00024127": "crystal clear this government is making", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00099-00024128-00024407": "the healthcare crisis worse whether it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00100-00024408-00024630": "is punishing seniors by forcing them", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00101-00024631-00024935": "away from their family into substandard", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00102-00024936-00025207": "for-profit long-term care home whether", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00103-00025208-00025494": "it is funding more for profit clinics", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00104-00025495-00025662": "pulling money away", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00105-00025663-00025870": "money and staff away from the public", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00106-00025872-00026174": "system the crisis is getting worse not", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00107-00026175-00026383": "better no one in ontario should be", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00108-00026383-00026607": "wondering whether the emergency", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00109-00026608-00026831": "department is going to be open when they", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00110-00026832-00026958": "need it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00111-00026960-00027239": "will the government stop selling more of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00112-00027239-00027407": "our health care system to private", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00113-00027408-00027687": "investors and bring in a staffing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00114-00027688-00028007": "strategy that will improve publicly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00115-00028008-00028567": "delivered healthcare", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00116-00028568-00028727": "thank you speaker you know i'm proud of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00117-00028727-00028918": "the fact that our five-point plan that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00118-00028919-00029190": "we announced last last month with the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00119-00029191-00029423": "minister of long-term care has already", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00120-00029424-00029679": "started to bear fruit we've seen that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00121-00029680-00029814": "with a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00122-00029816-00030118": "willingness and frankly excitement from", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00123-00030119-00030335": "both the college of nurses and the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00124-00030336-00030511": "physicians and surgeons of ontario where", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00125-00030512-00030702": "they are going to expedite and they've", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00126-00030703-00030911": "brought forward additional ideas on how", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00127-00030912-00031055": "we can get those internationally", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00128-00031056-00031183": "educated", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00129-00031183-00031367": "health care workers here working in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00130-00031368-00031631": "ontario we're doing that because we know", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00131-00031632-00031839": "we want to have the best health care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00132-00031839-00032031": "system in the province of ontario we're", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00133-00032032-00032246": "doing that by working with our hospital", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00134-00032247-00032470": "partners our nursing partners our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00135-00032472-00032679": "paramedics our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00136-00032680-00032999": "you you talk about individual", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00137-00033000-00033231": "situations we're actually coming up with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00138-00033232-00033527": "ideas we're listening to the experts in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00139-00033528-00033687": "the field and we're acting on those", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00140-00033688-00033879": "ideas thank you speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00141-00033880-00033999": "thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00142-00034000-00034143": "the next question the member for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00143-00034144-00034367": "davenport thank you good morning speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00144-00034368-00034607": "my questions to the premier after two", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00145-00034608-00034799": "long years of interruption and remote", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00146-00034800-00034983": "learning parents sent their kids off to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00147-00034984-00035111": "school this week", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00148-00035112-00035311": "they're looking for peace and stability", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00149-00035312-00035471": "and supports in the classroom so their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00150-00035472-00035639": "kids can finally get back to some sort", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00151-00035640-00035751": "of normal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00152-00035752-00035959": "yet day after day this minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00153-00035960-00036151": "education is ratcheting up the rhetoric", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00154-00036152-00036343": "against the people who make our schools", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00155-00036344-00036567": "work why does this government seem so", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00156-00036568-00036783": "determined to create conflict in our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00157-00036784-00037190": "classrooms", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00158-00037191-00037390": "mr speaker we are determined to stand up", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00159-00037391-00037543": "for the voices of parents in this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00160-00037544-00037727": "province who want their kids in class", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00161-00037728-00037879": "and this premier in our government has", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00162-00037880-00038102": "been crystal clear on our intention it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00163-00038103-00038287": "is to ensure that these kids have a more", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00164-00038288-00038527": "normal stable and enjoyable return to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00165-00038528-00038767": "class right to june without disruption", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00166-00038768-00038911": "and i ask all members of this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00167-00038912-00039135": "legislature to join the government to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00168-00039136-00039430": "oppose these types of impacts on kids", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00169-00039431-00039615": "while we agree", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00170-00039616-00039751": "while we agree speaker that we could", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00171-00039752-00039943": "have a very spirited debate at the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00172-00039944-00040207": "negotiating table what we disagree with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00173-00040208-00040415": "is the imposition of a strike on a child", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00174-00040416-00040630": "after two extraordinary and difficult", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00175-00040631-00040846": "years we want them in school we want", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00176-00040847-00041030": "them to learn want to be nourished and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00177-00041031-00041239": "supported by their educators and their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00178-00041240-00041415": "friends and speaker i hope all members", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00179-00041416-00041535": "of this house will stand with this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00180-00041536-00041711": "government to keep kids in school right", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00181-00041712-00041935": "to june", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00182-00041936-00042239": "supplementary questions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00183-00042240-00042487": "speaker the minister claiming he's here", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00184-00042488-00042662": "to help parents is like godzilla", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00185-00042663-00042951": "claiming he's come to save tokyo", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00186-00042952-00043207": "parents and teachers remember the pc", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00187-00043208-00043495": "record of cuts and conflicts mandatory", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00188-00043496-00043879": "online learning 10 000 planned layoffs", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00189-00043880-00044174": "freezing wages with bill 124", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00190-00044175-00044374": "working with the liberals to freeze", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00191-00044375-00044662": "wages with 115. does the minister", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00192-00044663-00044902": "understand that attacking people the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00193-00044903-00045111": "very people who make our schools work is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00194-00045112-00045462": "what puts the school year at risk", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00195-00045463-00045630": "of education", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00196-00045631-00045990": "mr speaker with 683", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00197-00045991-00046215": "million more dollars for this september", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00198-00046216-00046407": "with a six percent increase over the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00199-00046408-00046518": "former liberals when it comes to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00200-00046519-00046711": "investments in public education we're", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00201-00046712-00046951": "talking about per student funding up", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00202-00046952-00047158": "almost 340 dollars per child over last", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00203-00047159-00047367": "year mr speaker a 92 million dollar", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00204-00047368-00047567": "increase in special education a 10", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00205-00047568-00047711": "million dollar net increase in mental", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00206-00047712-00047967": "health now 420 increase from when the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00207-00047968-00048167": "former liberals were in power speaker we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00208-00048168-00048383": "have 175 million dollars in tutoring the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00209-00048384-00048623": "largest program of its kind in this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00210-00048624-00048846": "nation and speaker we have increased", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00211-00048847-00049039": "investment for ventilation for rapid", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00212-00049040-00049255": "filtration by another 600 million", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00213-00049256-00049423": "dollars there is no government in the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00214-00049424-00049543": "history of this province that has", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00215-00049544-00049767": "invested more in public education and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00216-00049768-00049967": "our premier and our party will continue", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00217-00049968-00050239": "to invest to ensure a safe stable and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00218-00050240-00050367": "enjoyable return to school for these", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00219-00050368-00050483": "kids at this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00220-00050484-00050974": "province final supplementary", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00221-00050975-00051111": "speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00222-00051112-00051350": "paychecks are being eaten away by", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00223-00051351-00051542": "rampant inflation", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00224-00051544-00051790": "legislated wage freezes and yet our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00225-00051791-00052038": "education workers show up every day in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00226-00052039-00052342": "our schools working so hard for our kids", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00227-00052344-00052654": "they deserve respect they have clear", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00228-00052655-00052926": "ideas on how to improve our schools", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00229-00052927-00053135": "smaller class sizes mental health", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00230-00053136-00053342": "supports fixing the decades of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00231-00053344-00053559": "backlogged capital repairs will the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00232-00053560-00053847": "minister start implementing these ideas", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00233-00053848-00054142": "to improve our schools and stop creating", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00234-00054144-00054339": "conflict in our classrooms", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00235-00054340-00054654": "[Applause]", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00236-00054655-00054838": "mr speaker we are listening to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00237-00054839-00055047": "voices of parents in this province who", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00238-00055048-00055223": "want their kids to be in school and we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00239-00055224-00055407": "are standing up for them to ensure", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00240-00055408-00055615": "stability and a more normal return to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00241-00055616-00055838": "class mr speaker that's why we put in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00242-00055839-00056030": "place a tutoring expansion because we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00243-00056032-00056182": "know in our premiere knows that these", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00244-00056183-00056342": "kids need to get back on track with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00245-00056344-00056454": "their studies and that's why we've", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00246-00056455-00056671": "invested in a historic plan to increase", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00247-00056672-00056966": "access to more educators there's 5 000", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00248-00056967-00057271": "more staff in our schools this september", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00249-00057272-00057407": "because our government and our premier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00250-00057408-00057607": "had the foresight in order to invest in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00251-00057608-00057830": "a plan to catch up we have 600 million", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00252-00057832-00058054": "more dollars in public publicly funded", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00253-00058055-00058279": "education investment and mr speaker on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00254-00058279-00058503": "top of all of this the number one", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00255-00058504-00058654": "guiding priority of the government when", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00256-00058655-00058823": "it comes to these negotiations a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00257-00058824-00058999": "contrast with the opposition is we're", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00258-00059000-00059126": "going to stand up for kids and keep them", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00259-00059127-00059654": "in school right to june", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00260-00059655-00059791": "thank you the next question the member", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00261-00059791-00060087": "for hamilton west and castro dundas my", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00262-00060088-00060230": "question is the premier good morning", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00263-00060232-00060335": "premier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00264-00060336-00060535": "you should know i received an upsetting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00265-00060536-00060750": "call regarding a 90 year old woman in my", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00266-00060751-00060959": "riding she'd been living independently", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00267-00060960-00061159": "at her home receiving home care three", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00268-00061160-00061382": "times a week she recently spent a short", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00269-00061383-00061535": "while in hospital", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00270-00061536-00061719": "when she was discharged the lynn and the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00271-00061720-00061935": "hospital signed off on her care plan", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00272-00061936-00062247": "which was to include home care when she", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00273-00062248-00062471": "returned back home alone she was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00274-00062472-00062654": "informed that would be at least three", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00275-00062655-00062879": "weeks for her just to be assessed and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00276-00062879-00063135": "that there was no home care available", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00277-00063136-00063359": "for her she felt abandoned and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00278-00063360-00063582": "frightened as we all would", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00279-00063583-00063726": "why is this government punishing our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00280-00063727-00063950": "seniors instead of fixing the health", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00281-00063951-00064263": "care crisis", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00282-00064264-00064415": "minister of health", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00283-00064416-00064575": "thank you speaker you know the member", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00284-00064576-00064847": "opposite highlights exactly why our most", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00285-00064848-00065199": "recent budget included a one billion", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00286-00065200-00065406": "dollar investment in community care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00287-00065407-00065606": "investments and i've highlighted and i'm", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00288-00065607-00065759": "going to highlight it again because it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00289-00065760-00065935": "is important for your constituent in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00290-00065936-00066038": "your community", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00291-00066039-00066223": "to understand what that billion dollar", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00292-00066224-00066435": "investment is going to get them it is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00293-00066436-00066711": "739 000 nursing visits it's a hundred", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00294-00066712-00066926": "and fifty seven thousand nursing shift", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00295-00066927-00067135": "hours it is a hundred and seventeen", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00296-00067136-00067282": "thousand therapy visits including", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00297-00067283-00067535": "physiotherapy occupational therapy and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00298-00067536-00067782": "speech language pathology in community", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00299-00067783-00068015": "speaker it's two million one hundred and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00300-00068016-00068199": "eighteen thousand hours of personal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00301-00068200-00068479": "support services in community two", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00302-00068480-00068679": "hundred and thirty six thousand other", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00303-00068680-00068871": "types of home care visits it is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00304-00068872-00069191": "precisely why we as a government has me", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00305-00069192-00069399": "have made that investment of a billion", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00306-00069400-00069623": "dollars in the community care programs", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00307-00069624-00069863": "in the province of ontario and it is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00308-00069864-00070038": "frankly disappointing that the member", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00309-00070039-00070215": "opposite does not see the value of that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00310-00070216-00070447": "and did not support it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00311-00070448-00070703": "the supplementary question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00312-00070704-00070911": "to the minister i would like to say that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00313-00070912-00071182": "your words uh do not bring home care to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00314-00071183-00071311": "the people in my community because the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00315-00071312-00071694": "money is not in the field that's right", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00316-00071695-00071935": "and instead of home care this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00317-00071936-00072119": "90-year-old woman was offered two", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00318-00072120-00072423": "choices she could pay for private care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00319-00072424-00072631": "or she could be readmitted to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00320-00072632-00072882": "hospital this is truly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00321-00072883-00073143": "unbelievable when will this government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00322-00073144-00073471": "fix our public home care system and stop", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00323-00073472-00073655": "please stop turning your backs on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00324-00073656-00074103": "seniors", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00325-00074104-00074406": "thank you this um that's not all speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00326-00074407-00074655": "we actually have also invested nearly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00327-00074656-00074823": "100 million dollars in additional", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00328-00074824-00074975": "funding over the next three years to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00329-00074976-00075247": "expand community care service programs", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00330-00075248-00075550": "such as adult day programs meal services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00331-00075551-00075759": "transportation caregiver support and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00332-00075760-00075950": "assistive living services and caregiver", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00333-00075951-00076087": "supports you know these are the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00334-00076088-00076303": "organizations that are so active in our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00335-00076304-00076559": "community with volunteers like meals on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00336-00076560-00076791": "wheels who are doing that work to make", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00337-00076792-00077119": "sure that our seniors are are frail who", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00338-00077120-00077415": "are recovering at home have the supports", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00339-00077416-00077694": "they need to do it safely in their own", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00340-00077695-00077894": "home in their communities", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00341-00077895-00078119": "surrounded by family that loves them", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00342-00078120-00078262": "neighbors who understand what their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00343-00078263-00078487": "needs are this is what we are doing as a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00344-00078488-00078775": "government enabling those organizations", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00345-00078776-00078959": "to do what they do so well which is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00346-00078960-00079391": "looking after our neighbors thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00347-00079392-00079575": "the next question the member for markham", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00348-00079576-00079847": "union built mr speaker speaker in my", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00349-00079848-00080159": "riding i see firsthand how harmful", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00350-00080160-00080438": "ontario's labor shortage truly is for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00351-00080439-00080599": "small businesses", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00352-00080600-00080871": "employers and businesses wants to do", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00353-00080872-00081167": "more but simply cannot because of the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00354-00081168-00081447": "limited supply of workers the skilled", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00355-00081448-00081743": "and semi-skilled labor shortage remains", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00356-00081744-00082015": "one of the main factors limiting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00357-00082016-00082175": "business growth", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00358-00082176-00082406": "jobs are waiting to be filled and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00359-00082407-00082671": "paychecks are waiting to be collected", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00360-00082672-00082991": "speaker my question is straight forward", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00361-00082992-00083215": "with the minister of labor immigration", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00362-00083216-00083438": "training and skill development please", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00363-00083439-00083662": "explain to this legislature", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00364-00083663-00083959": "what our government is doing to address", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00365-00083960-00084311": "ontario's historic labor saute issue", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00366-00084312-00084487": "thank you mr speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00367-00084488-00084687": "minister of labor immigration and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00368-00084688-00084831": "training and skills development thank", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00369-00084832-00084959": "you very much and i want to thank the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00370-00084960-00085167": "member from our communionville for this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00371-00085168-00085350": "very important question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00372-00085351-00085550": "through you mr speaker our government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00373-00085551-00085791": "really understands ontario is facing a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00374-00085792-00086062": "historic labor shortage in fact today in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00375-00086063-00086231": "the province there's nearly four hundred", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00376-00086232-00086471": "thousand jobs going unfilled", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00377-00086472-00086671": "we need all hands on deck to build a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00378-00086672-00086894": "stronger ontario that is why we're", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00379-00086895-00087118": "connecting job seekers with the skills", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00380-00087119-00087294": "and training that they need and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00381-00087295-00087479": "promoting the lifelong careers that are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00382-00087480-00087694": "available in the skilled trades", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00383-00087695-00087862": "we're also making it easier for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00384-00087863-00088094": "out-of-province workers and immigrants", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00385-00088095-00088343": "to fill in-demand jobs and calling on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00386-00088344-00088615": "skilled workers from right across canada", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00387-00088616-00088855": "and abroad to come here to ontario to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00388-00088856-00089015": "collect these paychecks that are waiting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00389-00089016-00089231": "to be collected mr speaker our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00390-00089232-00089415": "government has an ambitious plan to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00391-00089416-00089575": "build and we're going to get it done", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00392-00089576-00089682": "thank", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00393-00089683-00089999": "you the supplementary question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00394-00090000-00090238": "thank you minister for that reassuring", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00395-00090239-00090350": "response", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00396-00090351-00090455": "speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00397-00090456-00090759": "about one in five new jobs in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00398-00090760-00091071": "over the next five years will be related", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00399-00091072-00091279": "to skilled trades", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00400-00091280-00091655": "so to tackle the labor shortage we must", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00401-00091656-00091943": "address the skills gap and continue", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00402-00091944-00092191": "promoting the skilled trades", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00403-00092192-00092391": "the skilled trades can provide young", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00404-00092392-00092694": "people access to these incredible", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00405-00092695-00092918": "meaningful careers that will keep many", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00406-00092919-00093247": "of our local industries thriving", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00407-00093248-00093431": "speaker once again to the minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00408-00093432-00093647": "labor immigration training and skills", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00409-00093648-00093847": "development what is our governments", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00410-00093848-00094087": "doing to promote the skilled trades in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00411-00094088-00094367": "ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00412-00094368-00094511": "mr labor", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00413-00094512-00094694": "thank you again to the member for that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00414-00094695-00094967": "very important question as a government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00415-00094968-00095159": "we are determined to continue to open", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00416-00095160-00095350": "doors for young people and help them get", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00417-00095351-00095447": "the training", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00418-00095448-00095687": "and financial supports that they need", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00419-00095688-00095862": "it's our mission to give more people a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00420-00095863-00096055": "hand up to better jobs and bigger", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00421-00096056-00096294": "paychecks that's why our government is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00422-00096295-00096526": "investing billions in innovative", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00423-00096527-00096767": "training programs that connect workers", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00424-00096768-00096999": "to these bigger paychecks and working", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00425-00097000-00097199": "together with our labor unions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00426-00097200-00097399": "government and business we're making", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00427-00097400-00097631": "ontario a place where hard work pays off", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00428-00097632-00097936": "and big dreams come to life", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00429-00097937-00098487": "[Applause]", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00430-00098488-00098687": "my question is to the premier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00431-00098688-00098911": "speaker this government claims ontarians", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00432-00098912-00099079": "are accessing the health care they need", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00433-00099080-00099279": "when they need it but a constituent of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00434-00099280-00099455": "mine reached out after their partner", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00435-00099456-00099782": "waited eight hours in an er after having", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00436-00099783-00099894": "a stroke", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00437-00099895-00099974": "wow", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00438-00099975-00100255": "waiting alone without family with only", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00439-00100256-00100455": "the paramedics who brought them in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00440-00100456-00100694": "eight hours is it acceptable to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00441-00100695-00100806": "premier that anyone should have to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00442-00100807-00101262": "suffer like this after having a stroke", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00443-00101263-00101462": "reply i'm ministered", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00444-00101463-00101687": "you speaker you know the member opposite", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00445-00101688-00101903": "highlights exactly why we have been", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00446-00101904-00102191": "investing and will continue to invest in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00447-00102192-00102454": "our health care system to be clear 9 out", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00448-00102455-00102566": "of 10", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00449-00102567-00102734": "high urgency patients finish their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00450-00102735-00102990": "emergency visits within target times and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00451-00102991-00103254": "surgeries are happening at 88 percent of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00452-00103255-00103486": "their pre-pandemic rate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00453-00103488-00103718": "and we've already added 3", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00454-00103719-00104094": "500 hospital beds we've already added 10", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00455-00104095-00104399": "900 new hospital", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00456-00104400-00104518": "hhr", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00457-00104519-00104678": "so nurses", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00458-00104679-00105015": "psws doctors will continue to do this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00459-00105016-00105263": "work because we understand that we want", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00460-00105264-00105463": "to make sure that we have a robust", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00461-00105464-00105607": "health care system in the province of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00462-00105608-00105871": "ontario and most importantly speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00463-00105872-00106158": "where people want to be whether that is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00464-00106159-00106351": "needed hospital in acute care during", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00465-00106352-00106607": "acute care crisis whether that is in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00466-00106608-00106799": "their own home recovering whether that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00467-00106800-00107143": "is in a rehab bed in a in a facility or", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00468-00107144-00107423": "indeed a long-term care bed we are doing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00469-00107424-00107566": "this work we are making these", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00470-00107567-00107799": "investments because we understand it is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00471-00107800-00107975": "needed in the province of ontario to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00472-00107976-00108221": "deal with our aging population", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00473-00108222-00108583": "[Applause]", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00474-00108583-00108847": "through you speaker 9 out of 10 isn't", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00475-00108848-00108990": "good enough certainly not good enough", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00476-00108991-00109199": "for the 10th patient without nurses", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00477-00109200-00109383": "available paramedics had to stay with my", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00478-00109383-00109607": "constituent even over a shift change", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00479-00109608-00109854": "only by sheer luck the second massive", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00480-00109855-00110054": "stroke happened after my constituent was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00481-00110055-00110343": "in a bed and caught just in time", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00482-00110344-00110543": "wait times continue to grow the next", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00483-00110544-00110815": "patient might not be so lucky will this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00484-00110816-00110999": "government invest the 1.8 billion", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00485-00111000-00111166": "healthcare dollars they hoarded last", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00486-00111167-00111454": "year and respect healthcare workers by", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00487-00111455-00111702": "repealing bill 124 or will they keep", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00488-00111703-00112223": "strangling our public system", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00489-00112224-00112319": "thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00490-00112320-00112495": "speaker the member opposite actually", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00491-00112496-00112663": "highlights one of the things that we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00492-00112664-00112807": "should be lotting in the province of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00493-00112808-00112943": "ontario and that is of course our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00494-00112944-00113158": "community paramedics the amazing work", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00495-00113159-00113399": "they have been doing in community in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00496-00113400-00113671": "hospital to protect our most vulnerable", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00497-00113672-00113847": "you know i've often spoken about spoken", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00498-00113848-00114190": "about a 49 pilot projects that are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00499-00114191-00114351": "currently happening in communities", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00500-00114352-00114615": "across ontario 9-1-1 models of care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00501-00114616-00114847": "pilot projects which have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00502-00114848-00115190": "borne amazing fruit we have indeed in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00503-00115191-00115495": "london middlesex we have a success rate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00504-00115496-00115671": "of 84", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00505-00115672-00115951": "and satisfaction rate of over 80 percent", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00506-00115952-00116158": "where individuals who are able to be", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00507-00116159-00116407": "cared for by their community paramedics", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00508-00116408-00116558": "in their community", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00509-00116559-00116766": "appreciated and understood that this was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00510-00116767-00117023": "the most important and the most valuable", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00511-00117024-00117151": "role that they could play we're going to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00512-00117152-00117319": "continue to do that work we're going to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00513-00117320-00117534": "expand those models of care that are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00514-00117535-00117719": "working in our community to make sure", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00515-00117720-00117943": "that every responsible community has an", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00516-00117944-00118134": "opportunity to fully utilize their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00517-00118135-00118375": "paramedics because frankly sir they've", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00518-00118376-00118519": "made they've been making a huge", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00519-00118520-00118943": "difference in our communities", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00520-00118944-00119047": "next question the member from", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00521-00119048-00119199": "mississauga mall", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00522-00119200-00119439": "thank you mr speaker through you mr", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00523-00119440-00119607": "speaker the toronto region board of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00524-00119608-00119815": "trade estimates that the gridlock adds", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00525-00119816-00120063": "400 million to the cost of goods in the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00526-00120064-00120239": "region every year", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00527-00120240-00120414": "this morning for an example it took me", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00528-00120415-00120663": "one hour 20 minutes to drive for 40", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00529-00120664-00120895": "kilometers to come to queen's park", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00530-00120896-00121134": "this gridlock is resulting in lost", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00531-00121135-00121390": "productivity and strain on the physical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00532-00121391-00121647": "and mental health commuters are losing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00533-00121648-00121934": "over 3 million hours a year sitting in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00534-00121935-00122199": "traffic time ontarians should be engaged", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00535-00122200-00122463": "in what they love to do work hard to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00536-00122464-00122743": "grow and spending quality time with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00537-00122744-00123014": "loved ones mr speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00538-00123015-00123231": "we see firsthand how", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00539-00123232-00123478": "decades of inaction and under investment", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00540-00123479-00123671": "in transportation infrastructure have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00541-00123672-00123847": "hurt ontarians", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00542-00123848-00124102": "in my community i hear from constituents", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00543-00124103-00124351": "repeatedly how fed up they are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00544-00124352-00124534": "sitting with gridlock", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00545-00124535-00124695": "speaker to the minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00546-00124696-00124895": "transportation can you please tell us", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00547-00124896-00125110": "what this government is doing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00548-00125111-00125390": "to tackle the gridlock crisis plaguing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00549-00125391-00125599": "our ontario thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00550-00125600-00125790": "minister of transportation", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00551-00125791-00125958": "thank you speaker and thank you to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00552-00125959-00126119": "member for mississauga-malton for the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00553-00126120-00126390": "great question speaker we cannot afford", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00554-00126391-00126566": "to delay much needed infrastructure", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00555-00126567-00126814": "investments more delays equals more", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00556-00126815-00127039": "gridlock our premier is leading an", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00557-00127040-00127286": "ambitious plan to deliver the right", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00558-00127288-00127486": "balance of public transit and road", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00559-00127488-00127695": "infrastructure projects to keep pace", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00560-00127696-00127983": "with the demands of today and the future", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00561-00127983-00128214": "over the next 10 years we're investing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00562-00128215-00128486": "more than 25.1 billion dollars to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00563-00128488-00128695": "support the planning and construction of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00564-00128696-00128943": "highway expansion and rehabilitation", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00565-00128944-00129158": "projects across the province", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00566-00129159-00129358": "as part of these efforts we're getting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00567-00129359-00129566": "on with the building of new highways", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00568-00129567-00129990": "like highway 413 and the bradford bypass", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00569-00129991-00130214": "and speaker with finishing long overdue", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00570-00130215-00130431": "projects like the expansion of highway 7", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00571-00130432-00130671": "between kitchener and guelph and highway", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00572-00130672-00130823": "through the highway 3 widening between", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00573-00130824-00130975": "windsor and leamington", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00574-00130976-00131183": "speaker it's not enough just to talk", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00575-00131184-00131399": "about building a better future under our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00576-00131400-00131839": "pc government we are getting it done", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00577-00131840-00132239": "supplementary questions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00578-00132240-00132414": "thank you minister thank you for your", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00579-00132415-00132590": "assurance and action to solve the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00580-00132591-00132719": "gridlock", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00581-00132720-00132943": "speaker when the liberals were in power", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00582-00132944-00133127": "they talked a lot about building", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00583-00133128-00133399": "infrastructure but at the end of the day", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00584-00133400-00133566": "that's all it was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00585-00133567-00133719": "talk", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00586-00133720-00133911": "the fact is especially when it comes to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00587-00133912-00134111": "transportation ontario has an", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00588-00134112-00134327": "infrastructure deficit that the liberals", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00589-00134328-00134447": "cost", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00590-00134448-00134678": "with greater golden horseshoe attracting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00591-00134679-00134999": "two million people in every 10 years we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00592-00135000-00135287": "are going to reach 15 million by 2051", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00593-00135288-00135463": "more than the people we have in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00594-00135464-00135566": "today", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00595-00135567-00135839": "unless we do something now the problem", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00596-00135840-00136159": "we face today will only get worse", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00597-00136160-00136383": "when it comes to fighting gridlock we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00598-00136384-00136551": "have heard no solutions from the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00599-00136552-00136902": "opposition except to pretend that all", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00600-00136903-00137207": "growth can be solved by transit", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00601-00137208-00137495": "but speaker we know we need all hands on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00602-00137496-00137751": "deck to address this issue so through", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00603-00137752-00137927": "you mr speaker to the minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00604-00137928-00138175": "transportation can she share to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00605-00138176-00138431": "members of this house and my residents", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00606-00138432-00138623": "about the government's plan to keep", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00607-00138624-00139078": "ontarians moving thank you mr speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00608-00139079-00139295": "thank you speaker thank you for the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00609-00139296-00139511": "question speaker members of the members", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00610-00139512-00139654": "in this house of the opposition parties", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00611-00139655-00139799": "will tell you there's a choice between", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00612-00139800-00139990": "building transit and building highways", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00613-00139991-00140166": "and that's just not true", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00614-00140167-00140383": "our government is building both for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00615-00140384-00140623": "every dollar that we are spending on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00616-00140624-00140831": "highways our government is spending", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00617-00140832-00141111": "three more to build transit and speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00618-00141112-00141271": "over the next 10 years we're investing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00619-00141272-00141631": "more than 61 billion dollars to expand", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00620-00141632-00141871": "and build new transit alone", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00621-00141872-00142119": "this includes the largest plan for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00622-00142120-00142390": "subway build in canadian history and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00623-00142391-00142575": "delivering on our government's mandate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00624-00142576-00142823": "on two-way all-day 15-minute service", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00625-00142824-00143143": "across core segments of the go network", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00626-00143144-00143343": "speaker expanding our highway and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00627-00143344-00143647": "transit networks together will allow us", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00628-00143648-00143966": "to pave the way for a future that offers", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00629-00143967-00144159": "more transportation options and less", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00630-00144160-00144454": "gridlock for commuters all while", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00631-00144455-00144575": "creating", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00632-00144576-00144759": "thousands of good paying jobs in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00633-00144760-00144975": "communities right here at home response", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00634-00144976-00145278": "speaker the wheels are in motion the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00635-00145279-00145935": "government is getting it done", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00636-00145936-00146159": "this question remember thunder bay", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00637-00146160-00146383": "superior north", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00638-00146384-00146623": "my question is to the premier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00639-00146624-00146854": "for two weeks along with several of my", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00640-00146855-00147087": "colleagues i am living on a socialist", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00641-00147088-00147351": "assistance grocery budget of forty seven", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00642-00147352-00147631": "dollars and sixty cents a week", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00643-00147632-00147847": "many people who have to rely on social", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00644-00147848-00148119": "assistance have contacted us since this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00645-00148120-00148399": "action went public to tell us", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00646-00148400-00148590": "that the meager amount we have allowed", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00647-00148591-00148951": "ourselves for food is almost double what", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00648-00148952-00149151": "a single person living on social", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00649-00149152-00149463": "assistance has available for food after", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00650-00149464-00149631": "paying rent", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00651-00149632-00149871": "indeed it is abundantly clear that the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00652-00149872-00150095": "government needs to double the rates of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00653-00150096-00150223": "odsp", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00654-00150224-00150439": "and ontario works", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00655-00150440-00150663": "will the minister of children community", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00656-00150664-00150831": "and social services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00657-00150832-00151102": "join us for this two-week advocacy", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00658-00151103-00151311": "effort so that she might better", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00659-00151312-00151551": "understand even briefly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00660-00151552-00151959": "the hardship that odsp and ow recipients", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00661-00151960-00152199": "have to endure in their daily lives good", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00662-00152200-00152366": "question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00663-00152367-00152535": "mr children community and social", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00664-00152536-00152671": "services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00665-00152672-00152807": "thank you speaker and thank you to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00666-00152808-00153054": "member opposite i have spent decades", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00667-00153055-00153390": "uh as a physician assisting people uh on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00668-00153391-00153654": "odsp assisting people to get the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00669-00153655-00153935": "services that they need so i i have a a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00670-00153936-00154095": "probably a better understanding than", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00671-00154096-00154287": "most of what people are going through", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00672-00154288-00154526": "and i'm very proud of our governments", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00673-00154527-00154735": "very proud of our government's efforts", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00674-00154736-00154902": "to make sure that our vulnerable are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00675-00154903-00155143": "served that's including the historic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00676-00155144-00155495": "investment in odsp uh that's never been", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00677-00155496-00155647": "done before in the history of this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00678-00155648-00155871": "program making sure it's aligned with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00679-00155872-00156151": "inflation working across government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00680-00156152-00156326": "to make sure that we have programs that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00681-00156327-00156502": "are available to people when they need", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00682-00156503-00156583": "it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00683-00156584-00156702": "that's including working with the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00684-00156703-00156878": "minister of labor immigration training", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00685-00156879-00157054": "and skills development to get people", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00686-00157055-00157247": "back into the workforce when they're", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00687-00157248-00157454": "able and looking to support people when", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00688-00157455-00157607": "they're not through the many programs", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00689-00157608-00157854": "that we offer uh that are i listed", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00690-00157855-00158135": "yesterday as as the member would know", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00691-00158136-00158333": "and would be aware of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00692-00158334-00158919": "[Applause]", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00693-00158920-00159166": "thank you speaker back to the minister", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00694-00159167-00159295": "minister", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00695-00159296-00159526": "900 000 people in ontario are living on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00696-00159527-00159663": "social assistance and they're living in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00697-00159664-00159902": "poverty and their biggest expense is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00698-00159903-00160143": "housing upwards of sixty percent of a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00699-00160144-00160326": "person's social assistance income is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00700-00160327-00160502": "going to housing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00701-00160503-00160678": "you cannot afford to live on seven", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00702-00160679-00160814": "hundred and thirty three dollars a month", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00703-00160815-00161031": "if you're on ontario works or one", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00704-00161032-00161199": "thousand two hundred seven a month if", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00705-00161200-00161399": "you're on disability payments", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00706-00161400-00161639": "minister i am asking you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00707-00161640-00161854": "to join us on this social assistance", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00708-00161855-00162126": "diet to to have a better understanding", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00709-00162127-00162463": "of what it is like uh to to be on social", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00710-00162464-00162654": "assistance and i'm calling on this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00711-00162655-00162831": "government to double social assistance", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00712-00162832-00163102": "rates to help people get out of poverty", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00713-00163103-00163678": "can you do that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00714-00163679-00163847": "remind the members to make your comments", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00715-00163848-00163966": "through the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00716-00163967-00164159": "the minister of children community and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00717-00164160-00164407": "social services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00718-00164408-00164543": "thank you speaker and thank you again", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00719-00164544-00164783": "for the question i will continue to work", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00720-00164784-00164959": "with all of my colleagues across", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00721-00164960-00165175": "government working across levels of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00722-00165176-00165399": "government with the municipalities with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00723-00165400-00165590": "the federal government encouraging our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00724-00165591-00165790": "federal counterparts to bring forward", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00725-00165791-00165966": "their plan for the canadian disability", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00726-00165967-00166199": "benefit we have urged them to do this we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00727-00166200-00166366": "understand the importance of it we're", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00728-00166367-00166519": "working on the transformation with our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00729-00166520-00166790": "municipal partners to put more services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00730-00166791-00167014": "into the front where people can benefit", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00731-00167015-00167151": "from that when they they need that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00732-00167152-00167351": "expertise in their local communities", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00733-00167352-00167551": "this is on top of the historic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00734-00167552-00167790": "investment that we're making in odsp and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00735-00167791-00168054": "this is an all of government approach", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00736-00168055-00168302": "this is requiring the the labor pool to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00737-00168303-00168511": "be addressed getting people back into", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00738-00168512-00168702": "the workforce as quickly as possible", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00739-00168703-00168863": "understanding the mechanisms that we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00740-00168864-00169159": "have to allow people to live in dignity", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00741-00169160-00169390": "and with respect uh purposeful and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00742-00169391-00169575": "responding and this is something that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00743-00169576-00169783": "we're working with the minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00744-00169784-00170007": "finance the treasury board minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00745-00170008-00170135": "labor", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00746-00170136-00170238": "immigration training and skills", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00747-00170239-00170407": "development minister of education", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00748-00170408-00170614": "minister of health this is across the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00749-00170615-00170790": "board it's something that the previous", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00750-00170791-00171047": "government never did that was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00751-00171048-00171271": "thank you thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00752-00171272-00171463": "the next question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00753-00171464-00171726": "for kingston on the island", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00754-00171727-00171966": "mr speaker we're in a rush to procure", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00755-00171967-00172143": "enough electricity to replace the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00756-00172144-00172495": "pickering nuclear plant closing in 2025.", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00757-00172496-00172631": "how do we know it's a rush well this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00758-00172632-00172863": "government has an expedited procurement", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00759-00172864-00173175": "for prior for power starting in 2027", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00760-00173176-00173351": "with a big bonus for starting earlier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00761-00173352-00173559": "for example you produce electricity on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00762-00173560-00173751": "business days between april sorry may", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00763-00173752-00174031": "and august 2025 they'll pay you 50", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00764-00174032-00174151": "percent more", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00765-00174152-00174375": "in july 2018 this government canceled", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00766-00174376-00174526": "renewable energy projects letting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00767-00174527-00174687": "hundreds of millions of dollars of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00768-00174688-00174895": "investments go down the drain and losing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00769-00174896-00175183": "four precious years the premier said", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00770-00175184-00175423": "then that he was quote so proud to have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00771-00175424-00175687": "done that and now we realize we need", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00772-00175688-00175935": "that clean electricity", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00773-00175936-00176078": "you have to dig a little but the list of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00774-00176079-00176263": "qualified applicants for the next round", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00775-00176264-00176463": "of long-term procurement is full of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00776-00176464-00176711": "renewable energy can we just admit that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00777-00176712-00176887": "this government is quietly getting back", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00778-00176888-00177087": "into renewable energy something it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00779-00177088-00177423": "should never have abandoned", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00780-00177424-00177647": "the minister of energy pretty rich well", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00781-00177648-00177823": "uh speaker thanks to the member opposite", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00782-00177824-00177966": "for the question this morning what our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00783-00177967-00178143": "government is committed to is ensuring", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00784-00178144-00178343": "that the people of ontario and the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00785-00178344-00178678": "businesses on in ontario have a reliable", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00786-00178679-00178943": "supply of electricity mr speaker that we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00787-00178944-00179254": "have an affordable supply of electricity", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00788-00179255-00179438": "something that never happened under the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00789-00179439-00179623": "previous government's watch as a matter", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00790-00179624-00179871": "of fact as hundreds of thousands of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00791-00179872-00180111": "manufacturing jobs left our province", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00792-00180112-00180247": "they left our country for other", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00793-00180248-00180471": "jurisdictions because of the liberal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00794-00180472-00180799": "energy policies mr speaker what we have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00795-00180800-00180990": "done through the success of our premier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00796-00180991-00181175": "strategy and our minister of economic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00797-00181176-00181326": "development bringing companies back", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00798-00181327-00181599": "repatriating companies back to ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00799-00181600-00181814": "by electrifying our vehicle fleet by", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00800-00181815-00181999": "electrifying our green steel making", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00801-00182000-00182175": "process mr speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00802-00182176-00182390": "we need electricity and we have a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00803-00182391-00182566": "competitive procurement in place to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00804-00182567-00182887": "acquire that electricity 790 megawatts", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00805-00182888-00183063": "as a matter of fact in the most recent", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00806-00183064-00183263": "procurement at a 30", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00807-00183264-00183526": "savings from what was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00808-00183527-00184263": "mr contracted", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00809-00184264-00184495": "supplementary questions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00810-00184496-00184638": "mr speaker you know when the plants are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00811-00184639-00184759": "already built under a previous", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00812-00184760-00184878": "government of course it's cheaper to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00813-00184879-00185078": "keep them running la cloution de la", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00814-00185079-00185287": "santa picarino", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00815-00185288-00185790": "the pickering plant is a threat", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00816-00185791-00185943": "we cannot wait", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00817-00185944-00186166": "until the next election to replace the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00818-00186167-00186295": "energy that's going to be lost by the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00819-00186296-00186487": "closing of the pickering power plant so", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00820-00186488-00186695": "i would like to know the plan", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00821-00186696-00186854": "the following question for the good of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00822-00186855-00187063": "ontario we'll need to produce lots of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00823-00187064-00187287": "renewable energy quickly developers are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00824-00187288-00187487": "already approaching landowners quietly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00825-00187488-00187695": "in anticipation could the energy and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00826-00187696-00187926": "municipal affairs ministers talk then", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00827-00187927-00188183": "start now to help municipalities prepare", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00828-00188184-00188431": "for deciding how they will or will not", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00829-00188432-00188614": "be part of this critical project for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00830-00188615-00188831": "example could they help municipalities", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00831-00188832-00189063": "decide whether or not to zone areas for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00832-00189064-00189302": "wind and solar projects now so that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00833-00189303-00189478": "developers could know beforehand where", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00834-00189479-00189726": "they could partner clean energy projects", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00835-00189727-00189943": "with the speed we need", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00836-00189944-00190102": "question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00837-00190103-00190359": "the response minister mr speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00838-00190360-00190871": "merci castillo", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00839-00190872-00191031": "mr speaker for the member of the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00840-00191032-00191247": "government mr speaker i know that's a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00841-00191248-00191438": "new member over there and he probably", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00842-00191439-00191590": "doesn't remember the policies of the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00843-00191591-00191783": "previous liberal government that forced", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00844-00191784-00192038": "they were forced energy projects onto", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00845-00192039-00192214": "communities without any type of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00846-00192215-00192478": "consultation mr speaker they didn't care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00847-00192479-00192638": "about a willing host community over", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00848-00192639-00192895": "there mr speaker which is why", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00849-00192896-00193166": "in 2018 the people of ontario reduce", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00850-00193167-00193607": "that party to seven seats", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00851-00193608-00193799": "and you know what", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00852-00193800-00194054": "the people of ontario didn't forget in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00853-00194055-00194199": "2022", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00854-00194200-00194423": "because now they've got eight seats mr", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00855-00194424-00194550": "speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00856-00194551-00194790": "largely because of the energy policy mr", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00857-00194791-00194950": "speaker the minister of municipal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00858-00194951-00195102": "affairs and our government has committed", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00859-00195103-00195263": "to working with the municipalities and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00860-00195264-00195423": "the independent electricity system", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00861-00195424-00195590": "operator to make sure there's", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00862-00195591-00195735": "consultation with humanistic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00863-00195736-00195999": "municipalities for new energy projects", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00864-00196000-00196190": "so that we don't have the mess the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00865-00196191-00196447": "divisiveness the unaffordable crisis", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00866-00196448-00196614": "that we saw in ontario created by the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00867-00196615-00198783": "previous liberal government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00868-00198784-00199271": "order", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00869-00199272-00199983": "order", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00870-00199984-00200126": "the house will come to order so we can", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00871-00200127-00200919": "resume question period", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00872-00200920-00201511": "start the clock the member for ajax", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00873-00201512-00201671": "thank you mr pinker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00874-00201672-00201878": "we know that even before the kovit 19", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00875-00201879-00202031": "pandemic there was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00876-00202032-00202311": "a shortage of doctors in ontario many", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00877-00202312-00202550": "ontarians have challenges accessing a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00878-00202551-00202750": "family doctor for years", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00879-00202751-00202999": "which has significantly impacted their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00880-00203000-00203295": "health and well-being the rapid growth", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00881-00203296-00203535": "in areas like my riding of ajax and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00882-00203536-00203711": "other areas in the gta has only", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00883-00203712-00203902": "increased this problem of doctor's", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00884-00203903-00204183": "retention and recreation recruitment the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00885-00204184-00204407": "previous the liberal government did not", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00886-00204408-00204583": "take the necessary leadership and make", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00887-00204584-00204766": "the critical healthcare investments when", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00888-00204767-00205038": "they had the opportunity speaker can the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00889-00205039-00205255": "minister of colleges and universities", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00890-00205256-00205446": "please inform the house what our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00891-00205448-00205606": "government is doing to address the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00892-00205607-00206182": "doctor shortages across ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00893-00206183-00206319": "thank you mr speaker thank you the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00894-00206319-00206534": "member from ajax for that question we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00895-00206535-00206679": "need to increase the number of doctors", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00896-00206680-00206823": "and healthcare workers across the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00897-00206823-00207023": "province and that includes rural and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00898-00207023-00207198": "remote communities and communities like", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00899-00207200-00207423": "hers in the gta that is why our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00900-00207423-00207631": "government has taken historic action by", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00901-00207632-00207910": "building new medical schools in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00902-00207911-00208006": "the new", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00903-00208007-00208214": "toronto metropolitan university medical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00904-00208215-00208382": "school in brampton", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00905-00208383-00208566": "this is the first new medical school in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00906-00208567-00208782": "the gta since the university of toronto", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00907-00208783-00208982": "opened in 1843", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00908-00208983-00209142": "we are also creating the university of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00909-00209144-00209310": "toronto academy of medicine and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00910-00209311-00209471": "integrated health in scarborough and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00911-00209471-00209662": "expanding the queen's lake ridge health", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00912-00209663-00209823": "campus in oshawa", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00913-00209823-00210031": "but we recognize that more action needs", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00914-00210032-00210263": "to be done across the province that is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00915-00210264-00210494": "why we also created the first standalone", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00916-00210496-00210671": "medical school in the north through the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00917-00210671-00210894": "northern ontario school of medicine", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00918-00210896-00211103": "we've also invested in post-secondary", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00919-00211104-00211303": "healthcare programs like learn and stay", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00920-00211304-00211423": "and we continue to work with the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00921-00211423-00211639": "ministry of long-term care to increase", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00922-00211640-00211951": "the number of psws and nurses in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00923-00211952-00212127": "we are working to fill the gaps across", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00924-00212128-00212294": "the health care system and across the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00925-00212296-00212510": "province after 15 years of liberal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00926-00212511-00212710": "mismanagement by making these", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00927-00212711-00212910": "investments in post-secondary education", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00928-00212911-00213151": "today our expansions will help to serve", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00929-00213152-00213358": "a growing and aging population in the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00930-00213359-00213815": "years and decades to come greater", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00931-00213816-00214023": "the supplementary question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00932-00214023-00214246": "mr speaker the urgency for training new", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00933-00214248-00214487": "doctors in our province is critical the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00934-00214488-00214742": "people of my riding of ajax especially", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00935-00214744-00214894": "our seniors ex", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00936-00214896-00215071": "experienced first-hand the devastating", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00937-00215071-00215287": "and negative impacts that medical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00938-00215288-00215479": "education cuts by the previous liberal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00939-00215480-00215687": "government had on the quality of their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00940-00215688-00215910": "health care if the previous government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00941-00215911-00216119": "had made the badly needed investment in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00942-00216119-00216310": "human health resources and medical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00943-00216311-00216582": "residences years ago my constituents and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00944-00216583-00216767": "all of ontarians would not be in the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00945-00216767-00216967": "position we currently face", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00946-00216967-00217198": "i was really shocked to hear that no", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00947-00217200-00217342": "other government had invested and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00948-00217344-00217606": "created a new medical school in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00949-00217607-00217910": "in the gta in canada for over a hundred", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00950-00217911-00218239": "years speaker can administer colleges", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00951-00218240-00218446": "and universities please tell the house", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00952-00218448-00218615": "what our government's plan is for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00953-00218616-00218839": "training more doctors so that ontarians", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00954-00218840-00219071": "can have access to health care resources", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00955-00219071-00219446": "that they need", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00956-00219448-00219567": "well thank you again to the member for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00957-00219567-00219727": "that question and building new medical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00958-00219728-00219855": "schools will increase the number of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00959-00219856-00220079": "doctors in communities like ajax the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00960-00220080-00220287": "durham region and the whole of ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00961-00220288-00220494": "however speaker our work to enhance", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00962-00220496-00220687": "healthcare infrastructure does not stop", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00963-00220688-00220910": "there speaker our government is making", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00964-00220911-00221071": "record investments in innovative", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00965-00221071-00221319": "approaches across the healthcare system", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00966-00221319-00221542": "investments that the ndp and liberals", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00967-00221544-00221671": "did not make", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00968-00221671-00221798": "that's why earlier this year we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00969-00221800-00221934": "announced that we are making historic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00970-00221935-00222127": "expansions increasing the number of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00971-00222128-00222287": "seats for doctors and healthcare", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00972-00222288-00222494": "students speaker over the next five", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00973-00222496-00222751": "years we are adding 160 undergraduate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00974-00222752-00222819": "and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00975-00222819-00222982": "295", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00976-00222983-00223175": "postgraduate seats to six medical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00977-00223176-00223271": "schools", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00978-00223271-00223487": "medical and education expansions at", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00979-00223488-00223687": "western mcmaster the university of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00980-00223688-00223910": "ottawa and others this will ensure that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00981-00223911-00224087": "ontarians will always be able to have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00982-00224088-00224327": "the health care resources they need", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00983-00224328-00224534": "here when they need them speaker our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00984-00224535-00224751": "government is creating concrete ways in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00985-00224752-00224894": "which we can increase the number of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00986-00224896-00225023": "health care professionals in this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00987-00225023-00225294": "province but as we know the ndps and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00988-00225296-00225503": "liberals always say no", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00989-00225504-00225679": "speaker i am proud to say that this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00990-00225680-00225879": "government is keeping ontarians safe", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00991-00225880-00226087": "with a high quality health care system", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00992-00226088-00226294": "supported by high quality post-secondary", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00993-00226296-00226582": "education", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00994-00226583-00226927": "thank", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00995-00226928-00227198": "thank you my questions to the premier i", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00996-00227200-00227382": "bring to the floor the heartbreaking", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00997-00227383-00227703": "experience of odsp recipients being", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00998-00227704-00227967": "faced with housing questions and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-00999-00227967-00228246": "suspect evictions too often i hear about", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01000-00228248-00228519": "suspect trends of odsp recipients", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01001-00228519-00228767": "evictions because the landlord is moving", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01002-00228767-00228934": "in family members", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01003-00228935-00229151": "by the way a claim that is nearly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01004-00229152-00229375": "impossible to prove wrong until after", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01005-00229376-00229479": "the fact", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01006-00229480-00229663": "i spoke with saint catherine's resident", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01007-00229664-00229903": "brenda lacrew who experienced this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01008-00229904-00230151": "eviction she was thrown into a housing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01009-00230152-00230415": "market where she now has to borrow money", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01010-00230416-00230646": "from her friends to pay her new rent", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01011-00230648-00230734": "rate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01012-00230735-00230882": "brenda spends", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01013-00230883-00231287": "125 percent of her income on rent right", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01014-00231288-00231375": "now", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01015-00231376-00231623": "forget the food and forget the other", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01016-00231623-00231758": "cost", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01017-00231759-00232110": "that's the reality for odsp recipients", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01018-00232111-00232303": "my question is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01019-00232304-00232615": "when will the premier commit to doubling", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01020-00232616-00232967": "odsp rates and support the most", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01021-00232967-00233351": "vulnerable people in ontario you're here", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01022-00233352-00233655": "mr mr repairs and housing thanks so much", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01023-00233656-00233846": "thanks speaker through you to the member", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01024-00233848-00234119": "for st catharines i'd like to know more", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01025-00234119-00234406": "information about this eviction issue", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01026-00234407-00234582": "obviously we have a process in place we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01027-00234583-00234782": "have a rental housing enforcement unit", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01028-00234783-00234967": "as part of the ministry of municipal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01029-00234967-00235182": "affairs and housing in addition there", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01030-00235183-00235391": "are means with the landlord senate board", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01031-00235392-00235623": "so i'm very concerned about the case", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01032-00235623-00235855": "that the member opposite has placed on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01033-00235856-00236110": "the floor uh and i can rest assured that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01034-00236111-00236271": "we will", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01035-00236271-00236487": "get the the rental housing enforcement", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01036-00236488-00236710": "unit involved in this case and do", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01037-00236711-00236967": "further investigation", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01038-00236967-00237103": "supplementary", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01039-00237104-00237334": "thank you speaker we're speaking about", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01040-00237335-00237646": "odsp rates as well here not only about", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01041-00237648-00237823": "what happened to brenda lacrew but", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01042-00237823-00238079": "however we have heard all week about", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01043-00238080-00238294": "this government's talk talking point", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01044-00238296-00238567": "that the increase to odsp at five", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01045-00238567-00238758": "percent is historic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01046-00238759-00239015": "the only thing historic about the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01047-00239016-00239310": "increase is how long it took to make any", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01048-00239311-00239558": "increase freezing the rates for as long", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01049-00239559-00239815": "as you did throughout the pandemic is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01050-00239816-00240175": "something we have not seen in decades", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01051-00240176-00240567": "so sorry premier 5 is not historic it's", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01052-00240567-00240775": "actually a slap in the face", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01053-00240776-00240975": "but don't take it from me", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01054-00240976-00241191": "take it from members in my community of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01055-00241192-00241471": "st catharines and niagara", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01056-00241471-00241775": "tabitha thomas is also facing a family", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01057-00241776-00242110": "moving in eviction and has called your", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01058-00242111-00242215": "increase", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01059-00242216-00242423": "proof ford doesn't care may i quote", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01060-00242423-00242598": "proof ford doesn't care about the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01061-00242600-00242742": "vulnerable people", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01062-00242744-00243015": "brenda la cruz said quote millionaires", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01063-00243016-00243182": "like four don't care about regular", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01064-00243183-00243310": "people like me", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01065-00243311-00243591": "question premier will you change course", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01066-00243592-00243871": "and double odsp rates in the face of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01067-00243871-00244134": "your historical freeze to those rates", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01068-00244135-00244630": "from last term", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01069-00244631-00244846": "i realize the member was using quotes it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01070-00244848-00244982": "would be better if we refer to each", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01071-00244983-00245230": "other generally speaking as uh", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01072-00245231-00245406": "with respect to our riding boundaries as", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01073-00245407-00245630": "well as our ministerial title as", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01074-00245631-00245927": "applicable start the clock the response", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01075-00245928-00246094": "the minister in community and social", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01076-00246096-00246310": "services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01077-00246311-00246487": "thank you speaker i very much appreciate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01078-00246488-00246687": "the opportunity to clarify our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01079-00246688-00246951": "government immediately began its mandate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01080-00246952-00247351": "in 2018 by increasing the odsp rate by", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01081-00247352-00247503": "1.5", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01082-00247504-00247775": "we then went into a pandemic", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01083-00247776-00247975": "and we had the 1 billion dollar social", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01084-00247976-00248151": "services relief funding", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01085-00248152-00248542": "we have now a historic historic a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01086-00248544-00248727": "unprecedented", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01087-00248728-00248942": "of spending an increase investment in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01088-00248944-00249230": "odsp but this is this does not exist", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01089-00249231-00249446": "opposition order we are aligning this to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01090-00249448-00249703": "inflation never been done before we are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01091-00249704-00249919": "creating the micro credential strategy", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01092-00249919-00250103": "to make sure people can get back into", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01093-00250104-00250319": "the labor force the road map to wellness", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01094-00250319-00250487": "official opposition comes forward the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01095-00250488-00250703": "effort that the one billion dollars in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01096-00250704-00250879": "child care spaces the ontario child", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01097-00250880-00251094": "benefit the dental care for seniors in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01098-00251096-00251303": "low-income seniors the care tax credit", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01099-00251304-00251503": "the lift tax credit the entire jobs", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01100-00251504-00251687": "training tax the ontario energy and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01101-00251688-00251894": "property tax credit the minimum wage", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01102-00251896-00252127": "increase we are making the largest", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01103-00252128-00252367": "investment in odsp rates in the history", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01104-00252367-00252534": "of this province we're aligning them", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01105-00252535-00252734": "with inflation and we will continue to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01106-00252735-00252934": "do this very important work that the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01107-00252935-00253910": "opposition never did", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01108-00253911-00254087": "thank you mr speaker mr speaker my", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01109-00254088-00254310": "question is for the solicitor general", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01110-00254311-00254479": "speaker my constituents in the writing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01111-00254480-00254646": "of carleton are concerned by the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01112-00254648-00254887": "increasing gun and gang violence faced", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01113-00254888-00255055": "by the people of ottawa", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01114-00255056-00255230": "just last week there was another", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01115-00255231-00255471": "shooting in ottawa's byward market this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01116-00255471-00255623": "brings the total number of shootings", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01117-00255623-00255855": "this year in ottawa to 41.", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01118-00255856-00256046": "the people of my riding don't deserve to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01119-00256048-00256223": "live in fear because of the actions of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01120-00256223-00256479": "criminals the city of ottawa is home to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01121-00256480-00256727": "a culturally diverse population good", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01122-00256728-00256982": "neighbors and friendly people it's not a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01123-00256983-00257182": "home for gangs engaging in criminal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01124-00257183-00257430": "activity so speaker through you could", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01125-00257431-00257639": "the solicitor general please explain to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01126-00257640-00257830": "this house our government's approach to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01127-00257831-00258055": "dealing with this troubling issue faced", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01128-00258056-00258398": "by the good people of ottawa thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01129-00258400-00258687": "reply to solicitor general", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01130-00258688-00258863": "thank you mr speaker and i'd like to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01131-00258864-00259087": "thank my colleague for her question and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01132-00259088-00259271": "our hearts go out to the victims of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01133-00259271-00259567": "senseless violence community safety", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01134-00259567-00259798": "remains a top priority for this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01135-00259800-00259998": "government and since the member was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01136-00260000-00260223": "elected in 2018", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01137-00260223-00260487": "our government invested over 57 million", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01138-00260488-00260782": "dollars in the ottawa police service i", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01139-00260783-00261023": "have recently met with chief bell in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01140-00261023-00261294": "ottawa and i know that we both share a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01141-00261296-00261527": "strong commitment to keeping our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01142-00261528-00261751": "communities safe but we know that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01143-00261752-00261951": "illegal guns continue to cross our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01144-00261952-00262151": "international borders and into", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01145-00262152-00262455": "communities like ottawa and that's why", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01146-00262456-00262703": "in my conversations with my federal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01147-00262704-00262967": "counterpart minister mendocino i have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01148-00262968-00263175": "stressed that the federal government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01149-00263176-00263447": "needs to tighten up enforcement at the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01150-00263448-00263551": "border", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01151-00263552-00263767": "and this is something mr speaker that we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01152-00263768-00264143": "will work on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01153-00264144-00264319": "our government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01154-00264320-00264558": "is taking our province's security very", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01155-00264559-00264879": "seriously and will always make this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01156-00264880-00265215": "security an absolute priority", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01157-00265216-00265415": "a supplementary question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01158-00265416-00265558": "thank you mr speaker and through you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01159-00265559-00265719": "thank you to the solicitor general for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01160-00265720-00265958": "that response mr speaker the solicitor", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01161-00265959-00266127": "general spoke about the issue of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01162-00266128-00266351": "smuggled gum guns coming across our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01163-00266352-00266591": "borders recently the national post", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01164-00266592-00266791": "published an article titled a polite", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01165-00266792-00267047": "reminder that canadian handgun crime is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01166-00267048-00267247": "mostly america's fault", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01167-00267248-00267503": "the article notes that 72", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01168-00267504-00267751": "of guns ceased from crime by toronto", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01169-00267752-00267991": "police this year alone had likely", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01170-00267992-00268215": "origins in the united states", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01171-00268216-00268406": "speaker once again threw you to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01172-00268407-00268671": "solicitor general what is ontario doing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01173-00268672-00268903": "to address the issue of smuggled guns", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01174-00268904-00269071": "thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01175-00269072-00269287": "mr general", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01176-00269288-00269479": "mr speaker and again i want to thank the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01177-00269480-00269710": "member for her question and recently i", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01178-00269711-00269943": "was in lambton county on the sinclair", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01179-00269944-00270271": "river with our mpp for sarnia lambton", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01180-00270272-00270543": "and i was at the exact location where", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01181-00270544-00270855": "the drone carrying 11 handguns was found", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01182-00270856-00271215": "in a tree back in may i saw for myself", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01183-00271216-00271471": "how close we are to the us border and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01184-00271472-00271734": "how easily guns and contraband can get", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01185-00271735-00272023": "smuggled in our country and it's no", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01186-00272024-00272239": "secret where the guns are coming from", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01187-00272240-00272527": "we've made enhancements to the opp led", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01188-00272528-00272823": "provincial weapons enforcement unit to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01189-00272824-00273087": "combat guns entering canada and in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01190-00273088-00273375": "ontario and to keep ontario safe our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01191-00273376-00273639": "government has invested over 200 million", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01192-00273640-00273943": "dollars to combat gun and gang violence", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01193-00273944-00274255": "fueled by smuggled guns mr speaker we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01194-00274256-00274455": "will work hand in hand with local law", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01195-00274456-00274695": "enforcement to tackle gun and gank", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01196-00274696-00274895": "violence in ontario but this is not", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01197-00274896-00275167": "enough we cannot do it alone we need our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01198-00275168-00275406": "federal government to step up now and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01199-00275407-00275679": "take measures to improve border security", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01200-00275680-00276175": "and inspections", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01201-00276176-00276327": "the next question member for niagara", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01202-00276328-00276423": "falls", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01203-00276424-00276623": "thank you mr speaker my questions to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01204-00276624-00276719": "premier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01205-00276720-00276919": "speaker this government has established", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01206-00276920-00277110": "a pattern of leaving ontario's in the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01207-00277111-00277367": "dark about their plans this time they", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01208-00277368-00277534": "left us in the dark about the grave", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01209-00277535-00277791": "implications of bill 7.", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01210-00277792-00278006": "ontario's were rightly horrified by how", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01211-00278007-00278263": "quickly an undemocratic bill 7 was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01212-00278264-00278519": "passed but the minister tried to pacify", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01213-00278520-00278751": "us by saying that our concerns about how", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01214-00278752-00278934": "far people will be separated from their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01215-00278935-00279158": "families against their will be addressed", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01216-00279159-00279303": "through regulations", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01217-00279304-00279510": "well speaker there's been no word about", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01218-00279511-00279671": "these regulations but we're already", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01219-00279672-00279895": "hearing stories from hospitals putting", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01220-00279896-00280119": "pressure on patients we don't need to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01221-00280120-00280279": "create obstacles for elderly and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01222-00280280-00280510": "disabled people to see their loved ones", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01223-00280511-00280758": "and their member of caregivers will the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01224-00280759-00280943": "minister confirm that people will have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01225-00280944-00281158": "regular and equitable access to their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01226-00281159-00281463": "caregivers and their loved ones", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01227-00281464-00281687": "minister of long-term care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01228-00281688-00281806": "uh", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01229-00281807-00281991": "of course mr speaker i've been saying", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01230-00281992-00282110": "that right", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01231-00282111-00282279": "from the beginning that the whole point", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01232-00282280-00282510": "of this was to ensure that those people", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01233-00282511-00282751": "those seniors who are in a hospital who", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01234-00282752-00282982": "are imminently to be discharged have a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01235-00282983-00283175": "better quality of care than sitting in a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01236-00283176-00283391": "hospital bed where everybody would", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01237-00283392-00283534": "acknowledge medical professionals", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01238-00283535-00283687": "completely acknowledge that they're", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01239-00283688-00283895": "susceptible to various forms of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01240-00283896-00284039": "different diseases which are not good", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01241-00284040-00284182": "for them that they don't get the social", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01242-00284183-00284310": "activity that they require they don't", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01243-00284311-00284430": "get the physical activity that they", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01244-00284431-00284567": "require they don't get the mental", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01245-00284568-00284782": "stimulation that is required and that a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01246-00284783-00285119": "hospital bed is the absolute worst place", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01247-00285120-00285375": "for somebody to be now if the member", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01248-00285376-00285567": "had read the bill he would understand", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01249-00285568-00285758": "that not only are we doing this making", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01250-00285759-00285887": "sure that our seniors have the right", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01251-00285888-00286015": "care in the right place at the right", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01252-00286016-00286223": "time but we're also putting money behind", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01253-00286224-00286399": "that mr speaker to make sure that when a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01254-00286400-00286551": "senior is leaving hospital for a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01255-00286552-00286751": "long-term care home that the long-term", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01256-00286752-00286951": "care home has the services that are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01257-00286952-00287158": "required whether it's kidney dialysis", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01258-00287159-00287391": "whether it is behavioral support", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01259-00287392-00287599": "services we are upgrading those services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01260-00287600-00287927": "as well to match the patient leaving", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01261-00287928-00288134": "the hospital becoming a resident at a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01262-00288135-00288263": "home", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01263-00288264-00288447": "a supplemental question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01264-00288448-00288679": "thank you mr speaker back to the premier", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01265-00288680-00288830": "i want to be clear to the minister not", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01266-00288831-00289127": "only did i read the bill i memorized it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01267-00289128-00289334": "speaker this government refuses to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01268-00289335-00289471": "commit to accountability and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01269-00289472-00289630": "transparency", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01270-00289631-00289903": "they passed bill 7. they passed bill 7", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01271-00289904-00290103": "without so much as a meeting with the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01272-00290104-00290239": "unions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01273-00290240-00290423": "and front line workers", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01274-00290424-00290734": "they won't listen to advocates patients", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01275-00290735-00290910": "or their families", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01276-00290911-00291151": "their only concern about what works for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01277-00291152-00291310": "hospital ceos", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01278-00291311-00291551": "the minister denied ontarians a chance", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01279-00291552-00291791": "to advocate for themselves their loved", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01280-00291792-00292030": "ones through public hearings", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01281-00292031-00292247": "so my question is pretty easy will the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01282-00292248-00292463": "minister deny ontarians their rightful", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01283-00292464-00292710": "opportunity to comment on regulations", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01284-00292711-00292982": "during public comment period before the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01285-00292983-00293343": "regulations are implement implemented", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01286-00293344-00293551": "minister of long-term care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01287-00293552-00293839": "mr speaker the parliamentary assistant", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01288-00293840-00294006": "along with myself have undertaken", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01289-00294007-00294239": "extensive consultations throughout the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01290-00294240-00294479": "sector both residents councils", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01291-00294480-00294671": "family councils", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01292-00294672-00294903": "as well as with applicable applicable", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01293-00294904-00295158": "associations to gather their feedback we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01294-00295159-00295423": "have also met with doctors and nurses to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01295-00295424-00295679": "get their feedback as well uh speaker so", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01296-00295680-00295839": "we've met with doctors nurses healthcare", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01297-00295840-00296047": "professionals we've met with uh", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01298-00296048-00296239": "representatives of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01299-00296240-00296391": "residence councils we've met with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01300-00296392-00296606": "residents of long-term care home and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01301-00296607-00296758": "they have all come back and told us the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01302-00296759-00297095": "same thing mr speaker that a hospital is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01303-00297096-00297295": "no place for somebody to be who is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01304-00297296-00297510": "waiting for long-term care these are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01305-00297511-00297647": "people who are on the long-term care", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01306-00297648-00297839": "waiting list mr speaker so what the bill", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01307-00297840-00298054": "does mr speaker he read the bill but yet", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01308-00298055-00298182": "he continues to say oh people are going", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01309-00298183-00298327": "to be charged eighteen hundred dollars a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01310-00298328-00298510": "day they're gonna be sent a thousand a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01311-00298511-00298806": "thousand miles from their home all in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01312-00298807-00299023": "correct but he memorized the bill", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01313-00299024-00299206": "colleagues you memorized the bill this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01314-00299207-00299287": "is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01315-00299288-00299415": "the same member who said we're gonna", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01316-00299416-00299615": "reopen three and four war bedrooms it", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01317-00299616-00299719": "was actually", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01318-00299720-00299919": "this premier and that minister who", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01319-00299920-00300110": "closed those three and four war bedrooms", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01320-00300111-00300303": "it is that premier in that minister who", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01321-00300304-00300575": "uh brought 58 000 new and upgraded", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01322-00300576-00300710": "thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01323-00300711-00301015": "thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01324-00301016-00301199": "the next question the member for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01325-00301200-00301406": "scarborough rouge park", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01326-00301407-00301639": "thank you mr speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01327-00301640-00301847": "ontario's young families are being", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01328-00301848-00302087": "frozen out of the housing market due to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01329-00302088-00302334": "a lack of housing supply ontario's", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01330-00302335-00302551": "population is continuously growing and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01331-00302552-00302791": "our current rate of housing construction", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01332-00302792-00302934": "isn't keeping up", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01333-00302935-00303103": "young people are already struggling with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01334-00303104-00303310": "inflation and the rising cost of living", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01335-00303311-00303543": "in ontario over the next 10 years we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01336-00303544-00303806": "expect over one third of the new growth", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01337-00303807-00304023": "will happen in toronto and ottawa", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01338-00304024-00304223": "housing experts have already warned us", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01339-00304224-00304454": "that the ontario is falling behind", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01340-00304455-00304654": "housing infrastructure investment", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01341-00304655-00304879": "because of the years of red tape and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01342-00304880-00305071": "delays caused by the previous liberal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01343-00305072-00305254": "government speaker can the minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01344-00305255-00305439": "municipal affairs and housing tell us", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01345-00305440-00305679": "what our government can do to empower", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01346-00305680-00305927": "our large cities such as ottawa and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01347-00305928-00306182": "toronto to increase the housing supply", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01348-00306183-00306367": "thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01349-00306368-00306551": "minister mitchell", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01350-00306552-00306719": "thanks", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01351-00306720-00306879": "the member for scarborough rouge park", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01352-00306880-00307095": "for that excellent question the simple", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01353-00307096-00307358": "fact is speaker that ontario's", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01354-00307359-00307534": "population growth", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01355-00307535-00307823": "as ontario's population grows our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01356-00307824-00308063": "housing supply needs to grow with it and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01357-00308064-00308295": "what we're doing under our proposed", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01358-00308296-00308551": "strong mayor's building homes act is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01359-00308552-00308799": "we're providing the mayors in our two", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01360-00308800-00309023": "largest cities with the tools that they", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01361-00309024-00309263": "need to get shovels in the ground faster", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01362-00309264-00309519": "you know we said to ontarians during the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01363-00309520-00309734": "last provincial election that we were", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01364-00309735-00309958": "going to present a plan to make sure", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01365-00309959-00310254": "that we have 1.5 million homes built", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01366-00310255-00310430": "over the next decade and we have to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01367-00310431-00310630": "ensure speaker that the mayors in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01368-00310631-00310806": "ontario's two largest cities where we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01369-00310807-00311063": "know that over the next decade a third", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01370-00311064-00311263": "of ontario's growth will take place in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01371-00311264-00311415": "those two municipalities we have to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01372-00311416-00311734": "ensure that after the municipal election", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01373-00311735-00312006": "on october 24th that those tools are in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01374-00312007-00312247": "place for mayors in toronto and ottawa", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01375-00312248-00312495": "that's what we're doing we need to make", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01376-00312496-00312895": "sure they have the tools to get it done", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01377-00312896-00313182": "supplementary question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01378-00313183-00313487": "speaker our housing market is facing a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01379-00313488-00313591": "crisis", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01380-00313592-00313847": "with rising living cause many young", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01381-00313848-00314095": "ontarians are starting to fear that they", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01382-00314096-00314351": "will never realize their dreams of home", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01383-00314352-00314575": "ownership the people of my riding want", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01384-00314576-00314782": "more housing choices", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01385-00314783-00315006": "whether it be rental units or", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01386-00315007-00315167": "semi-detached houses near their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01387-00315168-00315406": "workplace or fully detached houses where", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01388-00315407-00315695": "young ontarians can grow and raise their", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01389-00315696-00315895": "families speaker can the minister of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01390-00315896-00316110": "municipal affairs and housing elaborate", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01391-00316111-00316319": "on what other steps our government is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01392-00316320-00316630": "taking to ensure that the dream of home", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01393-00316631-00316863": "ownership is attainable for the people", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01394-00316864-00317146": "of my riding and all ontarians thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01395-00317147-00317591": "[Applause]", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01396-00317592-00317879": "we know that there's no one silver", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01397-00317880-00318143": "bullet that will provide a solution to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01398-00318144-00318327": "the housing crisis that we're facing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01399-00318328-00318543": "right now but for too long under the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01400-00318544-00318782": "previous government housing starts", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01401-00318783-00319047": "lagged far far behind the demand of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01402-00319048-00319319": "ontario's we knew that we had to act and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01403-00319320-00319534": "act decisively as a government by", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01404-00319535-00319743": "empowering our municipal partners by", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01405-00319744-00319991": "ensuring that they have tools to cut red", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01406-00319992-00320143": "tape and get shovels in the ground", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01407-00320144-00320303": "faster we're going to fight the housing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01408-00320304-00320534": "supply crisis we're going to ensure that", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01409-00320535-00320743": "that couple that right now doesn't", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01410-00320744-00320943": "realize the dream of home ownership we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01411-00320944-00321103": "want to give them hope we want to give", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01412-00321104-00321375": "them opportunity and we need mayors in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01413-00321376-00321534": "those big communities and quite frankly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01414-00321535-00321782": "mayors across this province to have the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01415-00321783-00322039": "tools that they need to assist us in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01416-00322040-00322439": "ensuring that dream is realized", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01417-00322440-00322575": "the next question the member from", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01418-00322576-00324863": "muskegon", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01419-00324864-00325023": "appropriately what are you going to do", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01420-00325024-00325534": "to provide the service lee accordingly", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01421-00325535-00325775": "minister of francophone affairs thank", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01422-00325776-00325958": "you speaker and thank you for the member", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01423-00325959-00326734": "for his questions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01424-00326735-00326887": "a national", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01425-00326888-00327054": "issue that is happening throughout the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01426-00327055-00327199": "country", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01427-00327200-00327334": "this is happening not only in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01428-00327335-00327510": "but also in quebec and other provinces", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01429-00327511-00327747": "speaker our government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01430-00327748-00328006": "recognizes the importance of ontarian", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01431-00328007-00328143": "francophony", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01432-00328144-00328406": "which is why we're working", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01433-00328407-00328775": "on several aspects to reinforce the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01434-00328776-00329060": "demographics", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01435-00329061-00330447": "[Music]", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01436-00330448-00330647": "we are continuing to work with the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01437-00330648-00330854": "federal government and we ask them to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01438-00330855-00331134": "provide more control over the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01439-00331135-00331263": "immigration", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01440-00331264-00331454": "process to attract more francophone", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01441-00331455-00331751": "immigrants to ontario also we request an", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01442-00331752-00331910": "immigration corridor", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01443-00331911-00332127": "to attract", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01444-00332128-00332358": "teachers of the franco that are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01445-00332359-00333078": "francophone", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01446-00333079-00333478": "we have seen this issue keep on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01447-00333479-00333791": "getting worse throughout their provinces", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01448-00333792-00334206": "services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01449-00334207-00334567": "are not being provided appropriately", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01450-00334568-00334710": "ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01451-00334711-00334910": "one call", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01452-00334911-00335143": "doesn't provide a service in front", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01453-00335144-00335734": "ppu for the security alert last week", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01454-00335735-00335903": "was only provided in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01455-00335904-00336143": "english with a population that was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01456-00336144-00336239": "60", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01457-00336240-00336487": "francophone so again", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01458-00336488-00336782": "my question is what are you going to do", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01459-00336783-00336943": "to provide these services in french and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01460-00336944-00336996": "ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01461-00336997-00337271": "[Applause]", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01462-00337272-00337543": "supplementary thank you speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01463-00337544-00337703": "it's very deceiving", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01464-00337704-00337823": "to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01465-00337824-00338039": "see that the opposite member wants to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01466-00338040-00338278": "play politics with this situation this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01467-00338279-00338454": "is not the moment it's the moment to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01468-00338455-00338615": "work together", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01469-00338616-00338710": "to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01470-00338711-00339015": "make sure that we set in place solutions", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01471-00339016-00339327": "to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01472-00339328-00339751": "address the demographics of ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01473-00339752-00339903": "the opposite member knows that our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01474-00339904-00340182": "government has set in place politics to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01475-00340183-00340878": "protect francophony in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01476-00340879-00341054": "was the first one", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01477-00341055-00341415": "that was said in the province since 1996", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01478-00341416-00341639": "this could have been done during the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01479-00341640-00341830": "liberal government but this didn't take", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01480-00341831-00342023": "place they didn't do it when they were", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01481-00342024-00342223": "in power for 15 years but it was our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01482-00342224-00342415": "government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01483-00342416-00342751": "under the leadership of this premiere", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01484-00342752-00342863": "that has", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01485-00342864-00343071": "got it done", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01486-00343072-00343527": "we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01487-00343528-00343830": "and provided courses in english", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01488-00343831-00344103": "rather in french to ensure the services", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01489-00344104-00344551": "in french", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01490-00344552-00345182": "the member for thunder bay atikokan", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01491-00345183-00345334": "morning speaker my question is for a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01492-00345335-00345471": "minister of mines", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01493-00345472-00345639": "speaker when the previous liberal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01494-00345640-00345830": "government was in power they failed to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01495-00345831-00346071": "prioritize the mining sector projects", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01496-00346072-00346247": "like cote gold sat on the shelf", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01497-00346248-00346454": "collecting dust because investors did", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01498-00346455-00346615": "not have a committed partner they could", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01499-00346616-00346727": "work with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01500-00346728-00346934": "the culture of delay and inaction by the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01501-00346935-00347078": "previous liberal government was", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01502-00347079-00347303": "unacceptable and unlike them our", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01503-00347304-00347487": "government wants more mines to get built", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01504-00347488-00347671": "in northern ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01505-00347672-00347854": "mining represents a generational", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01506-00347855-00348047": "opportunity that is already creating", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01507-00348048-00348278": "jobs and training opportunities and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01508-00348279-00348534": "promises new revenue for ontarians", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01509-00348535-00348734": "it provides the raw materials needed to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01510-00348735-00348919": "build clean sustainable new green", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01511-00348920-00349151": "technology like batteries for electric", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01512-00349152-00349382": "vehicles mr speaker what has the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01513-00349383-00349551": "government done differently to move", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01514-00349552-00349734": "mining projects forward and what have", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01515-00349735-00350143": "been the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01516-00350144-00350382": "the results of mine", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01517-00350383-00350527": "thank you very much mr speaker for the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01518-00350528-00350710": "quest for the question from the member", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01519-00350711-00350943": "from thunder bay and attic okan", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01520-00350944-00351167": "mr speaker opposite to the previous", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01521-00351168-00351391": "liberal government we see the benefits", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01522-00351392-00351582": "of unleashing the mining sector and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01523-00351583-00351863": "re-establishing ontario as a world", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01524-00351864-00352071": "leading destination for mining", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01525-00352072-00352239": "investment", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01526-00352240-00352415": "we have cut red tape", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01527-00352416-00352575": "and worked directly with companies to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01528-00352576-00352734": "find solutions to challenges so", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01529-00352735-00353087": "companies can hit development milestones", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01530-00353088-00353310": "we have seen the sector responding with", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01531-00353311-00353519": "arrogant argonaut gold building maginot", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01532-00353520-00353758": "project equinox building the greenstone", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01533-00353759-00353999": "mine and i am gold's quote a project", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01534-00354000-00354199": "finally under construction", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01535-00354200-00354487": "and mr speaker the kodi lake project is", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01536-00354488-00354734": "a world-class deposit has a critical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01537-00354735-00355151": "mass of 20 million ounces in resource", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01538-00355152-00355447": "a world-class deposit that sat and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01539-00355448-00355710": "languished for 17 years", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01540-00355711-00355830": "these are just some of the recent", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01541-00355831-00355999": "success stories and we know there are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01542-00356000-00356119": "more coming", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01543-00356120-00356319": "there is more work to be done mr speaker", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01544-00356320-00356519": "but i look forward to making ontario the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01545-00356520-00356782": "best jurisdiction to invest in the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01546-00356783-00357095": "mining industry you're here", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01547-00357096-00357519": "supplementary question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01548-00357520-00357719": "speaker unlike the previous government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01549-00357720-00357919": "we know how important mining is to the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01550-00357920-00358071": "economy in the north", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01551-00358072-00358254": "with russia's unprovoked and illegal", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01552-00358255-00358430": "attack on ukraine and the growing", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01553-00358431-00358639": "instability in asia the chinese", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01554-00358640-00358854": "communist regime attempts to stabilize", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01555-00358855-00359078": "that region our global partners are", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01556-00359079-00359303": "seeking a strong stable and reliable", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01557-00359304-00359454": "source of materials", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01558-00359455-00359654": "i know the plan to build act lays the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01559-00359655-00359791": "foundation for our government to", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01560-00359792-00359951": "strengthen ontario's", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01561-00359952-00360158": "standing as a critical global mineral", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01562-00360159-00360254": "leader", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01563-00360255-00360406": "before the election our government", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01564-00360407-00360647": "launched ontario's first ever critical", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01565-00360648-00360815": "mineral strategy", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01566-00360816-00360967": "speaker could the minister of mines", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01567-00360968-00361175": "update all members on what investments", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01568-00361176-00361351": "our government has provided to support", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01569-00361352-00361558": "the critical mineral strategy through", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01570-00361559-00361782": "the plan to build act helping to create", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01571-00361783-00361999": "jobs and opportunities for the people of", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01572-00362000-00362199": "my riding thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01573-00362200-00362615": "mr mine", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01574-00362616-00362806": "again mr speaker thanks very much for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01575-00362807-00362991": "the question", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01576-00362992-00363247": "it's very very simple we know that we", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01577-00363248-00363567": "can't be green without mining", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01578-00363568-00363719": "and that's why our government launched", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01579-00363720-00363951": "ontario's first ever critical mineral", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01580-00363952-00364239": "strategy which is by the way a world", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01581-00364240-00364630": "leading document", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01582-00364631-00364806": "this strategy is backed by investments", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01583-00364807-00364982": "including 20 million dollars to find the", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01584-00364983-00365182": "minds of the future", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01585-00365183-00365406": "create expiration jobs in the north and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01586-00365407-00365639": "work with the private sector on", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01587-00365640-00365830": "innovation", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01588-00365831-00365991": "through this strategy we are building a", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01589-00365992-00366143": "link between the critical minerals in", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01590-00366144-00366519": "the north with the manufacturing might", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01591-00366520-00366678": "in the south", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01592-00366679-00366919": "we are working towards a strong supply", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01593-00366920-00367167": "chain of extraction processing and", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01594-00367168-00367399": "manufacturing of clean technologies", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01595-00367400-00367623": "right here in ontario", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01596-00367624-00367799": "will be the world's leading", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01597-00367800-00367943": "in this technology", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01598-00367944-00368103": "this government's financial commitments", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01599-00368104-00368254": "and focus on development clean", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01600-00368255-00368510": "technologies will lead on further global", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01601-00368511-00368719": "low carbon eco economic growth for", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01602-00368720-00368958": "ontario creating more job opportunities", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01603-00368959-00369158": "in the northern and first nation", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01604-00369159-00369439": "community", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01605-00369440-00369606": "thank you", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01606-00369607-00369815": "i conclude our question period for this", "BK0vuA67qmQ-01607-00369816-00370111": "morning"}}, {"audio_id": "BKtgMc4QG84", "text": {"BKtgMc4QG84-00000-00000000-00000257": "okay thank you John I'm just going to", "BKtgMc4QG84-00001-00000258-00000518": "kind of sum up the talented city systems", "BKtgMc4QG84-00002-00000519-00000734": "as jaundice discussed people in", "BKtgMc4QG84-00003-00000735-00000850": "particular matter is going to be", "BKtgMc4QG84-00004-00000851-00001129": "important I see several questions in the", "BKtgMc4QG84-00005-00001130-00001340": "chat box about the cost the startup", "BKtgMc4QG84-00006-00001341-00001627": "costs to eat is high our colleagues at", "BKtgMc4QG84-00007-00001628-00001787": "the environmental finance center are", "BKtgMc4QG84-00008-00001788-00002017": "working hard to crunch number but", "BKtgMc4QG84-00009-00002018-00002312": "there's and their conclusions will be", "BKtgMc4QG84-00010-00002313-00002570": "included in our final report but there's", "BKtgMc4QG84-00011-00002571-00002705": "out some questions that we'll talk about", "BKtgMc4QG84-00012-00002706-00002860": "in a minute that are going to inform", "BKtgMc4QG84-00013-00002861-00003080": "that that we've not been able to dress", "BKtgMc4QG84-00014-00003081-00003415": "on our project additional challenges if", "BKtgMc4QG84-00015-00003417-00003604": "these technologies require a lot more", "BKtgMc4QG84-00016-00003605-00003838": "time to operate in VT in a traditional", "BKtgMc4QG84-00017-00003839-00003995": "heating system so they're not going to", "BKtgMc4QG84-00018-00003996-00004279": "be a good fit for every farmer also in", "BKtgMc4QG84-00019-00004280-00004490": "this makes iguana miss cringe but we are", "BKtgMc4QG84-00020-00004491-00004652": "losing the poultry litter nitrogen", "BKtgMc4QG84-00021-00004653-00004841": "almost all of it is being converted to", "BKtgMc4QG84-00022-00004842-00005117": "n2 in the thermal process and is not", "BKtgMc4QG84-00023-00005118-00005395": "available for you know agronomic use", "BKtgMc4QG84-00024-00005396-00005611": "locally and that's generally in our area", "BKtgMc4QG84-00025-00005612-00005792": "the most valuable component of ultra", "BKtgMc4QG84-00026-00005793-00006088": "litoris and nitrogen also while we've", "BKtgMc4QG84-00027-00006089-00006331": "made some inroads into establishing ash", "BKtgMc4QG84-00028-00006332-00006575": "markets we do not have a consistent way", "BKtgMc4QG84-00029-00006576-00006814": "for our poultry growers with ash to", "BKtgMc4QG84-00030-00006815-00006953": "connect with end users who are", "BKtgMc4QG84-00031-00006954-00007189": "interested in purchasing it and if", "BKtgMc4QG84-00032-00007190-00007364": "anyone on this call has suggestions for", "BKtgMc4QG84-00033-00007365-00007666": "us we would welcome", "BKtgMc4QG84-00034-00007667-00008041": "but there are giving opportunities we", "BKtgMc4QG84-00035-00008042-00008257": "think it's clear that authors can be", "BKtgMc4QG84-00036-00008258-00008467": "recycled with these technology you can", "BKtgMc4QG84-00037-00008468-00008608": "move phosphorous from high-density", "BKtgMc4QG84-00038-00008609-00008889": "animal production areas to crop", "BKtgMc4QG84-00039-00008890-00009049": "production areas that rely a lot on", "BKtgMc4QG84-00040-00009050-00009430": "commercial fertilizer and that that sale", "BKtgMc4QG84-00041-00009431-00009621": "can generate new revenue for poultry", "BKtgMc4QG84-00042-00009622-00009802": "growers with respect to their existing", "BKtgMc4QG84-00043-00009803-00010156": "nutrients on these technologies are able", "BKtgMc4QG84-00044-00010157-00010438": "to reduce fossil fuel use specifically", "BKtgMc4QG84-00045-00010439-00010752": "here propane for our projects and you", "BKtgMc4QG84-00046-00010753-00010969": "think that there may be important", "BKtgMc4QG84-00047-00010970-00011288": "opportunities related to bird help", "BKtgMc4QG84-00048-00011289-00011530": "almost every poultry grower is", "BKtgMc4QG84-00049-00011531-00011805": "incentivized in some way to conserve", "BKtgMc4QG84-00050-00011806-00011971": "propane whether they're paying for that", "BKtgMc4QG84-00051-00011972-00012235": "a pocket or whether their use of propane", "BKtgMc4QG84-00052-00012236-00012526": "is is used as a basis to determine the", "BKtgMc4QG84-00053-00012527-00012714": "cost of and you pay for their birds and", "BKtgMc4QG84-00054-00012715-00013053": "in the winter bringing in fresh air cuz", "BKtgMc4QG84-00055-00013054-00013188": "then only a house to improve their", "BKtgMc4QG84-00056-00013190-00013432": "quality requires broken so in the cold", "BKtgMc4QG84-00057-00013433-00013768": "weather season growers are grappling", "BKtgMc4QG84-00058-00013769-00014043": "with using propane efficiently and", "BKtgMc4QG84-00059-00014044-00014293": "keeping the house well ventilated and", "BKtgMc4QG84-00060-00014294-00014616": "keeping good at equality in the house if", "BKtgMc4QG84-00061-00014618-00014856": "poultry growers have this an on-farm", "BKtgMc4QG84-00062-00014857-00015175": "school that abundant and inexpensive", "BKtgMc4QG84-00063-00015176-00015378": "they can start ventilating Foley's for", "BKtgMc4QG84-00064-00015379-00015646": "air quality and that could have an", "BKtgMc4QG84-00065-00015647-00015859": "impact on winter feed conversion winter", "BKtgMc4QG84-00066-00015860-00016081": "feed conversion rates typically drop by", "BKtgMc4QG84-00067-00016082-00016297": "a few points in the cold weather because", "BKtgMc4QG84-00068-00016297-00016578": "of the challenges with ventilating as", "BKtgMc4QG84-00069-00016579-00016861": "much as you'd like to I still remaining", "BKtgMc4QG84-00070-00016862-00017074": "questions one of the big ones is", "BKtgMc4QG84-00071-00017075-00017215": "long-term performance of these", "BKtgMc4QG84-00072-00017216-00017467": "technologies if they were to be", "BKtgMc4QG84-00073-00017468-00017634": "cost-shared through the equip program", "BKtgMc4QG84-00074-00017635-00018000": "the expected life would be ten years to", "BKtgMc4QG84-00075-00018001-00018187": "our knowledge there is note there are no", "BKtgMc4QG84-00076-00018188-00018358": "systems that have been in operation for", "BKtgMc4QG84-00077-00018359-00018718": "that long and again we have questions", "BKtgMc4QG84-00078-00018719-00018958": "about how these could be used to improve", "BKtgMc4QG84-00079-00018959-00019281": "health care quality and improve bird", "BKtgMc4QG84-00080-00019282-00019519": "health this is based on anecdotal", "BKtgMc4QG84-00081-00019520-00019741": "evidence so far from poultry go to have", "BKtgMc4QG84-00082-00019742-00020025": "been using new systems and he improved", "BKtgMc4QG84-00083-00020026-00020197": "treatments and bird health and feed", "BKtgMc4QG84-00084-00020198-00020464": "conversion and that raises questions", "BKtgMc4QG84-00085-00020465-00020632": "about the carbon footprint because it", "BKtgMc4QG84-00086-00020633-00020886": "may not just be propane shavings it feed", "BKtgMc4QG84-00087-00020887-00021038": "is the largest car", "BKtgMc4QG84-00088-00021039-00021248": "footprint component of producing poultry", "BKtgMc4QG84-00089-00021249-00021440": "so if we can improve feed conversion we", "BKtgMc4QG84-00090-00021441-00021719": "reduce the carbon footprint and again", "BKtgMc4QG84-00091-00021720-00021899": "ash and biochar market development is", "BKtgMc4QG84-00092-00021900-00022091": "going to be very important to support", "BKtgMc4QG84-00093-00022092-00022307": "additional groups put our existing", "BKtgMc4QG84-00094-00022308-00022661": "farmers and additional projects"}}, {"audio_id": "BKPpZSgMmf8", "text": {"BKPpZSgMmf8-00000-00000000-00000507": "[Music]", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00001-00000508-00000802": "commish Oh Topanga sky so I can call me", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00002-00000803-00001094": "yen or mr. lien FM minuta hi I'm in", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00003-00001095-00001609": "first a slide door technique can enter", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00004-00001610-00001688": "so Bravo", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00005-00001689-00002092": "yup so how intelligent are the", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00006-00002093-00002390": "algorithms which claim to understand you", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00007-00002391-00002558": "that's the question I'm going to look at", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00008-00002559-00002870": "today and I saw about four years ago", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00009-00002871-00003025": "they started to be these types of", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00010-00003026-00003350": "headlines in the news how Facebook knows", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00011-00003351-00003638": "you better than your friends and this", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00012-00003639-00003897": "was based on a research project where", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00013-00003898-00004127": "researchers had found that looking at", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00014-00004128-00004385": "what people liked was were you were able", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00015-00004386-00004658": "to predict what type of personality they", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00016-00004659-00004911": "had and the extreme of this was that", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00017-00004912-00005186": "Facebook knows you better than anybody", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00018-00005187-00005470": "else I really wanted to test if these", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00019-00005471-00005831": "things can really be true and I started", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00020-00005832-00005993": "where everyone should start if they want", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00021-00005994-00006181": "to do an experiment I started with", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00022-00006182-00006509": "myself this is my facebook profile and", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00023-00006509-00006859": "what I did is I took what my friends", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00024-00006861-00007058": "were posting about and I made a", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00025-00007059-00007328": "spreadsheet with every type of post they", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00026-00007329-00007526": "made and their names and how often they", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00027-00007527-00007751": "posted on these different things and I", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00028-00007752-00007916": "used it my skills in applied mathematics", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00029-00007917-00008192": "I used a technique called principle", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00030-00008193-00008480": "component analysis to try and reduce my", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00031-00008481-00008834": "friends to two dimensions and this was", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00032-00008835-00009110": "the result I got of my analysis I found", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00033-00009111-00009356": "three different types of groupings of", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00034-00009357-00009653": "people this is a grouping probably some", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00035-00009654-00009874": "of you know they're the all work no play", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00036-00009875-00010139": "grouping they're the type of people who", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00037-00010140-00010259": "post that they've maybe been to a", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00038-00010260-00010523": "conference like this one workshops that", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00039-00010524-00010649": "they've been in everything to do with", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00040-00010650-00010970": "work then there's another grouping you", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00041-00010971-00011120": "might know them on Facebook they're the", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00042-00011121-00011438": "I think that grouping they're the people", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00043-00011439-00011624": "who post about news they post about", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00044-00011625-00011888": "brexit they post about politics they", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00045-00011889-00012049": "post about sport and they give your", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00046-00012050-00012308": "their opinion about these things then", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00047-00012309-00012494": "finally these are ones that you", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00048-00012495-00012755": "definitely know these are the Here I am", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00049-00012756-00013013": "people these are the ones who post", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00050-00013013-00013124": "pictures of their dinner", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00051-00013125-00013350": "pictures of their children everywhere", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00052-00013351-00013572": "they've ever been on holiday everything", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00053-00013572-00013791": "about themselves and what's interesting", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00054-00013791-00014141": "here is that we can reduce or this", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00055-00014143-00014330": "algorithm the principal component", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00056-00014331-00014663": "analysis can reduce everybody on", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00057-00014665-00014850": "Facebook or it can reduce my friends in", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00058-00014851-00015030": "any case to these three categories and", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00059-00015031-00015239": "you recognize these categories so in", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00060-00015240-00015483": "that sense an algorithm really can", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00061-00015484-00015747": "understand you and this is what Facebook", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00062-00015747-00016106": "use they take the two billion people who", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00063-00016107-00016311": "use their service they take the hundred", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00064-00016312-00016478": "million things that they like and they", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00065-00016479-00016719": "use principle component analysis to", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00066-00016720-00016905": "reduce it down to ten thousand", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00067-00016906-00017169": "advertising categories I've just got a", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00068-00017170-00017325": "few of these advertising categories so I", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00069-00017326-00017447": "think they're a bit fun there's about", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00070-00017448-00017643": "sixty million people who Facebook", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00071-00017644-00017805": "classify as liking the British rule", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00072-00017806-00018005": "family maybe you've watched the crown", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00073-00018006-00018278": "last night I did then you've got like 10", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00074-00018279-00018444": "million people who are upper-middle", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00075-00018445-00018731": "class you've got another million tens of", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00076-00018732-00018887": "millions of people who they classify as", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00077-00018888-00019077": "neck I think these are people who maybe", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00078-00019078-00019259": "need a massage I'm not quite sure and", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00079-00019260-00019449": "some of the some of the categories are", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00080-00019450-00019599": "quite bizarre bers there's a few million", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00081-00019600-00019800": "people who they classify as platypus so", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00082-00019801-00019940": "I don't really have an explanation for", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00083-00019941-00020172": "that one but Facebook can certainly", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00084-00020173-00020540": "classify us and then came this scandal", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00085-00020541-00020783": "Cambridge analytic ah so this guy's", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00086-00020784-00021075": "Alexander Nicks what he claimed was that", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00087-00021076-00021356": "he could classify the personality of", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00088-00021357-00021668": "every American voter and this guy Chris", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00089-00021669-00021852": "Wiley he agreed with him he worked for", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00090-00021853-00022002": "Cambridge analytical for a while then he", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00091-00022003-00022208": "started being whistleblower and said", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00092-00022209-00022469": "that Cambridge analytic Oh influence the", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00093-00022470-00022661": "American election using these", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00094-00022662-00022917": "personality type algorithms well again", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00095-00022918-00023105": "I'm a mathematician so I started to try", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00096-00023106-00023289": "and check out whether this really could", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00097-00023290-00023534": "be the case and my conclusion was that", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00098-00023535-00023802": "though you can identify people's", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00099-00023803-00024075": "personalities in a scientific way the", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00100-00024076-00024339": "correlations aren't particularly strong", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00101-00024340-00024636": "so this is a correlation graph showing a", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00102-00024637-00024825": "correlation between neuroticism measured", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00103-00024826-00025083": "in psychological tests and not predicted", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00104-00025084-00025415": "in Facebook data there is a very weak", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00105-00025416-00025559": "correlation there which is", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00106-00025560-00025767": "scientifically interesting but it's not", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00107-00025768-00026056": "enough to build a personality algorithm", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00108-00026057-00026295": "and when I've looked into a lot of these", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00109-00026295-00026583": "problems in in my book outnumbered or", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00110-00026583-00026702": "ooh Trek that", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00111-00026704-00026895": "I have found that a lot of the things", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00112-00026895-00027156": "you hear about like filter bubbles and", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00113-00027157-00027420": "echo chambers when you look in them at", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00114-00027420-00027624": "detail in detail and how the algorithms", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00115-00027625-00027839": "work they're not as dangerous as we've", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00116-00027841-00028077": "been led to believe one of the classic", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00117-00028077-00028302": "examples is fake news which was really", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00118-00028302-00028502": "big about the Trump election fake news", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00119-00028504-00028677": "is spread mainly by BOTS", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00120-00028677-00028881": "we're very skeptical about fake news", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00121-00028882-00029055": "when we hear it and most of all we", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00122-00029056-00029235": "simply can't remember fake news", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00123-00029236-00029477": "afterwards so a lot of the things we've", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00124-00029479-00029606": "heard about algorithms have been", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00125-00029607-00029877": "misleading and this isn't just in the", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00126-00029877-00030156": "media is also been these these guys here", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00127-00030157-00030429": "this is a max tegmark and he's Sat he's", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00128-00030430-00030600": "he's grouped together or he's got a", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00129-00030601-00030789": "group of a very diverse number of", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00130-00030789-00031005": "individuals here all of who are working", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00131-00031006-00031314": "in the artificial intelligence as Elon", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00132-00031314-00031476": "Musk at the end there the head of", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00133-00031477-00031725": "google's deepmind is there and he asked", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00134-00031726-00031932": "all these people do you think the world", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00135-00031933-00032166": "is going to be or if there's going to be", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00136-00032167-00032418": "an artificial intelligent as clever as", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00137-00032419-00032631": "us in the near future and all of these", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00138-00032632-00032883": "people answered yes well I looked a bit", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00139-00032884-00033066": "more closely into this I looked at where", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00140-00033067-00033468": "we are in AI today in biology we can't", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00141-00033469-00033690": "have the intelligence of a dog we don't", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00142-00033691-00033852": "have the intelligence of an insect we", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00143-00033853-00033978": "don't have any tell instance of an", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00144-00033979-00034263": "amoeba we have an intelligence somewhat", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00145-00034264-00034512": "equivalent to a bacterium something that", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00146-00034513-00034734": "lives inside your tummy making decisions", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00147-00034735-00034986": "about what to eat so if you want to know", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00148-00034987-00035196": "more about the dangers of algorithms", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00149-00035197-00035385": "I've said about a few things that aren't", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00150-00035386-00035502": "dangerous but if you want to know about", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00151-00035503-00035694": "what the dangers are and what the", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00152-00035695-00035982": "dangers aren't then my book is available", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00153-00035983-00036403": "thank you very much", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00154-00036404-00036772": "I will not let you leave the stage", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00155-00036773-00036949": "before you tell us something about what", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00156-00036950-00037090": "we should really be worried about right", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00157-00037091-00037333": "so I've had I've had a few speakers talk", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00158-00037334-00037501": "about this today the stuff to do with", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00159-00037502-00037762": "sexism and racism are very important", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00160-00037763-00038023": "problems and bias in AI because we train", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00161-00038024-00038323": "AI on data and so that means it makes", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00162-00038324-00038509": "the same is not very good it's got a", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00163-00038510-00038704": "bacterial instead intelligence of data", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00164-00038705-00038974": "so when it's trained on a lot of texts", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00165-00038975-00039253": "and Wikipedia and news articles it makes", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00166-00039254-00039514": "mistakes of basic sort of sexist racist", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00167-00039515-00039700": "mistakes and so I look at that a lot in", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00168-00039701-00039913": "the book but mainly we should be worried", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00169-00039914-00040279": "about that type of both bias and also", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00170-00040280-00040456": "when it just gets things wrong when it", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00171-00040457-00040600": "tells when it says that people should", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00172-00040601-00040816": "spend longer in prison because it's just", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00173-00040817-00040966": "based on some algorithm which hasn't", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00174-00040967-00041137": "actually thought through and recognized", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00175-00041138-00041305": "the person those are the problems that", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00176-00041306-00041482": "we should be worried about very good and", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00177-00041483-00041614": "we can read more about them in the book", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00178-00041615-00041836": "as I have here we are thank you very", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00179-00041837-00042284": "much we are thank you very much", "BKPpZSgMmf8-00180-00042285-00042766": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "BKQDxOHpAO0", "text": {"BKQDxOHpAO0-00000-00000000-00000214": "looking upon Jesus as he walked he saith", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00001-00000215-00000512": "behold the lamb of God and the two", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00002-00000513-00000653": "disciples heard him speak and they", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00003-00000654-00000770": "followed Jesus", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00004-00000771-00000950": "so here John the Baptist is pointing", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00005-00000951-00001166": "people to Jesus now let me point out", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00006-00001167-00001403": "that John the Baptist didn't say hey I'm", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00007-00001404-00001562": "the guy that's taking away the sin of", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00008-00001563-00001772": "the world by baptizing you because", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00009-00001773-00001937": "baptism does not save you", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00010-00001938-00002099": "baptism has nothing to do with salvation", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00011-00002100-00002302": "that's why he didn't say alright come be", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00012-00002303-00002467": "baptized that you might be saved no he", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00013-00002468-00002771": "pointed at Jesus and said behold the", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00014-00002772-00003065": "lamb of God which taketh away the sin of", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00015-00003066-00003116": "the world", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00016-00003117-00003340": "that's why again later in Acts chapter", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00017-00003342-00003520": "19 the Bible is going to tell us you", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00018-00003521-00003677": "don't have to turn there but in Acts", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00019-00003678-00003890": "chapter 19 verse 4 referring back to", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00020-00003890-00003950": "this", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00021-00003951-00004241": "the Bible says John verily baptized with", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00022-00004242-00004481": "the baptism of repentance saying unto", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00023-00004482-00004636": "the people that they should believe on", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00024-00004637-00004979": "him which should come after that is on", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00025-00004980-00005309": "Christ Jesus so the one that came after", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00026-00005310-00005483": "Jesus Christ is who they're supposed to", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00027-00005484-00005666": "believe on and that's what's going to", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00028-00005667-00005861": "take away the sin of the world believing", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00029-00005862-00006068": "on the Lord Jesus Christ not getting", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00030-00006069-00006292": "baptized now also think about this if", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00031-00006293-00006662": "baptism saved you if baptism was a way", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00032-00006663-00006892": "to wash away your sins as it's taught by", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00033-00006893-00007203": "some then why would Jesus be baptized", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00034-00007204-00007577": "Jesus didn't have any sin so why would", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00035-00007578-00007798": "Jesus get baptized he didn't have any", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00036-00007800-00007967": "sense to wash away why would he go", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00037-00007968-00008134": "through the motions of that know the", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00038-00008136-00008345": "truth of the matter is that Jesus was", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00039-00008346-00008624": "baptized and obedience to the Father", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00040-00008625-00008851": "because he said to John the Baptist", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00041-00008852-00009134": "suffer it to be so now for thus it", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00042-00009135-00009394": "becometh us to fulfill all righteousness", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00043-00009395-00009739": "it had to do with being righteous and", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00044-00009740-00009935": "fulfilling the Word of God and being", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00045-00009936-00010205": "obedient to the Father he set that", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00046-00010206-00010421": "example of obedience toward the father", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00047-00010422-00010691": "by being baptized not a washing away of", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00048-00010692-00010963": "say he had no sin he was just obedient", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00049-00010964-00011292": "and setting that example and baptism is", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00050-00011293-00011573": "symbolic the Bible calls baptism a", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00051-00011574-00011806": "figure and when we say that something is", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00052-00011807-00012067": "figurative we mean that it stands for", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00053-00012068-00012299": "something else it's not literal but it's", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00054-00012300-00012377": "figurative", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00055-00012378-00012734": "so when baptism is describing the Bible", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00056-00012735-00012971": "as a figure it's referring to the fact", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00057-00012972-00013394": "that is symbolic of the death burial and", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00058-00013394-00013544": "resurrection of Christ which is why", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00059-00013544-00013772": "people go down into the water when", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00060-00013772-00014015": "they're baptized so baptism does not", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00061-00014016-00014327": "save but it is figurative of what does", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00062-00014328-00014618": "save okay so when we go down to the", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00063-00014619-00014657": "water", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00064-00014658-00014819": "and come out representing the death", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00065-00014819-00015055": "burial and resurrection that represents", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00066-00015056-00015302": "what saves us the resurrection saved us", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00067-00015303-00015602": "okay but baptism is only figurative that", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00068-00015603-00015779": "not literal therefore a person can be", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00069-00015780-00015911": "baptized and go to help they don't", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00070-00015912-00016144": "believe in Jesus Christ or a person", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00071-00016145-00016363": "could believe on Jesus Christ not get", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00072-00016365-00016541": "baptized and they're still on their way", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00073-00016542-00016661": "to heaven of course the thief on the", "BKQDxOHpAO0-00074-00016662-00017056": "cross and many others come to mind"}}, {"audio_id": "BL1iE0rF8yy", "text": {"BL1iE0rF8yy-00000-00000048-00000311": "good evening everyone welcome to this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00001-00000312-00000628": "webinar on Steam with a in Brackets", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00002-00000629-00000941": "Steam and stem basic concepts and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00003-00000942-00001054": "differences", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00004-00001055-00001307": "this webinar is co-organized by the stem", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00005-00001308-00001739": "Alliance scientix and screwware", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00006-00001739-00001991": "my name is Aishwarya and I'm involved in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00007-00001992-00002201": "the project and pedagogy tasks and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00008-00002202-00002471": "activities with European schoolnet", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00009-00002472-00002717": "together with us in the room we have my", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00010-00002718-00002933": "colleagues Rocio Benito and Cheryl", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00011-00002934-00003160": "Martinez who will be supporting this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00012-00003161-00003317": "webinar from a technical point of view", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00013-00003318-00003527": "so if you have any issues with the audio", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00014-00003528-00003767": "or with the connection you can just send", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00015-00003768-00004115": "them a message on the chat here", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00016-00004116-00004325": "so while they're on the technical side", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00017-00004326-00004570": "of things let's just finish it all off", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00018-00004571-00004954": "at one go so uh this webinar is being", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00019-00004955-00005249": "recorded you will also see that all the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00020-00005250-00005404": "microphones and cameras have been", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00021-00005405-00005638": "disabled so if you have a question to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00022-00005639-00005806": "our speaker today you can just post them", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00023-00005807-00005909": "in the chat", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00024-00005910-00006118": "and we'll have a q a session at the end", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00025-00006119-00006359": "of the webinar today and we will address", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00026-00006360-00006623": "all your questions then", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00027-00006623-00006803": "you will also find that during the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00028-00006804-00007060": "session we will be sharing many links", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00029-00007061-00007348": "and lot of useful information so we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00030-00007350-00007510": "encourage you to keep looking at the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00031-00007511-00007810": "chat and click on the interesting links", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00032-00007811-00008014": "and make the most out of the webinar", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00033-00008015-00008159": "today", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00034-00008159-00008664": "foreign", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00035-00008665-00009017": "here that's the signature list", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00036-00009018-00009389": "I see that uh Chanel has already shared", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00037-00009390-00009569": "it once", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00038-00009570-00009869": "so this link is very important in case", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00039-00009870-00010223": "you want a certificate of participation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00040-00010224-00010469": "it's also important because if you sign", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00041-00010470-00010649": "this we can prove that this event took", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00042-00010650-00010877": "place and we'll be able to organize more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00043-00010878-00011099": "events like this in the future it's my", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00044-00011100-00011249": "great pleasure to welcome our speaker", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00045-00011250-00011645": "for the day Victor badenov", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00046-00011646-00011933": "so Victor is an educational trainer", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00047-00011934-00012167": "specialize in implementation of steam", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00048-00012168-00012449": "approach in modern schools after working", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00049-00012450-00012623": "as a teacher in public and private", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00050-00012624-00012833": "schools for many many years he is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00051-00012834-00013060": "currently working at screwware in Warsaw", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00052-00013061-00013588": "how are you today Victor", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00053-00013590-00014021": "I cannot hear you", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00054-00014022-00014255": "okay so let him take a minute while I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00055-00014256-00014572": "introduce him so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00056-00014573-00014788": "so let's move on to scriber what is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00057-00014790-00014986": "creeper so I'll take it the uh take this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00058-00014987-00015107": "opportunity to tell you a little bit", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00059-00015108-00015341": "about screenware I hope Victor will be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00060-00015341-00015438": "back soon", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00061-00015440-00015761": "okay so as we all know technology is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00062-00015762-00016019": "growing at a very rapid Pace in the last", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00063-00016019-00016288": "few years very hard to keep up with as", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00064-00016290-00016565": "adults and probably for children and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00065-00016566-00016744": "many educational models around the world", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00066-00016745-00016997": "they find themselves really like unable", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00067-00016998-00017236": "to prepare students for the challenges", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00068-00017237-00017579": "that they will face in the job market in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00069-00017580-00017843": "this 21st century and the skills that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00070-00017844-00017999": "they need Etc", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00071-00018000-00018269": "so this is where screenwear comes in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00072-00018270-00018485": "screwware believes it is time to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00073-00018486-00018677": "radically innovate both the teaching", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00074-00018678-00018893": "profession and the experience of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00075-00018894-00019211": "students the team at screwware is a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00076-00019212-00019469": "major fan of 3D printing and Robotics", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00077-00019470-00019672": "now this is all very new to me so I'm", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00078-00019673-00019883": "learning a lot myself so they have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00079-00019884-00020130": "therefore created an educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00080-00020131-00020447": "laboratory called screen lab which is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00081-00020448-00020719": "based on 3D printing programming", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00082-00020720-00021089": "robotics engineering and e-learning all", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00083-00021090-00021250": "created for teachers to be used", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00084-00021251-00021491": "regularly in their daily work", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00085-00021492-00021917": "so using Modern Hardware and software", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00086-00021918-00022133": "combined with suitable curriculum", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00087-00022134-00022300": "screwware believes that they can make", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00088-00022301-00022553": "education fun and well adapted to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00089-00022554-00022799": "needs of the 21st century it's all very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00090-00022800-00022972": "exciting developments and there's a lot", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00091-00022973-00023333": "for us to learn here today and I find an", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00092-00023334-00023489": "interesting what's behind Victor over", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00093-00023490-00023669": "there it almost looks like it reminds me", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00094-00023670-00023861": "of SpongeBob but it probably is not", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00095-00023862-00024091": "SpongeBob", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00096-00024092-00024358": "that's an interesting interesting", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00097-00024359-00024793": "association yes yeah it's the yellow and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00098-00024794-00025175": "so uh Victor welcome today to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00099-00025176-00025349": "webinar", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00100-00025350-00025528": "thank you very much thank you for the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00101-00025529-00025702": "invitation it's a great honor it's a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00102-00025704-00025943": "great pleasure to be with you today uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00103-00025944-00026237": "today as we have already stated we are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00104-00026238-00026512": "going to try and figure out the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00105-00026513-00026807": "differences between those different uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00106-00026808-00027107": "Educational Concepts stem Steam and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00107-00027108-00027364": "steaming brackets we will see how it has", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00108-00027366-00027664": "what influence it has in our nowadays", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00109-00027666-00027935": "educational programs educational system", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00110-00027936-00028301": "in general and on our life and also we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00111-00028302-00028499": "will try to delve deeper into the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00112-00028500-00028774": "history on the concepts and how they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00113-00028775-00028967": "emerged and see how can they be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00114-00028968-00029267": "implemented on some practical uh on some", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00115-00029268-00029518": "practical examples during the lessons in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00116-00029519-00029590": "different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00117-00029591-00029908": "so I hope you're ready I hope everyone", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00118-00029910-00030118": "is having a great day and of course if", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00119-00030119-00030311": "you have any questions on the go I would", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00120-00030312-00030640": "be more than happy to answer them", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00121-00030641-00031024": "so steam stem and stealing brackets", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00122-00031025-00031307": "different Educational Concepts though", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00123-00031308-00031673": "they do have a very common very common", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00124-00031674-00031985": "Basics let's have a look so Google we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00125-00031986-00032146": "are starting now and we will start with", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00126-00032147-00032320": "the historical concepts of these", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00127-00032322-00032549": "educational approaches we will see how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00128-00032550-00032771": "they evolved and then we'll see where it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00129-00032772-00032999": "led us and what is going to happen in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00130-00033000-00033299": "the future so yes steam stem and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00131-00033300-00033593": "steaming brackets as I said before three", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00132-00033594-00033845": "different educational encroaches but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00133-00033846-00034085": "they are all binded together and they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00134-00034086-00034355": "are open Together by The Game and the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00135-00034356-00034624": "game is to introduce our young students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00136-00034625-00034907": "our Learners with Technologies with the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00137-00034908-00035135": "challenges that the future labor market", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00138-00035136-00035531": "might throw at them and also to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00139-00035532-00035735": "introduce them with different approaches", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00140-00035736-00035968": "when it comes to usage of these", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00141-00035969-00036281": "Technologies in the classroom so before", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00142-00036282-00036649": "we start with the actually uh practical", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00143-00036650-00036881": "implementation of these Concepts let's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00144-00036882-00037085": "have a short let's have a short look at", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00145-00037086-00037307": "the traditional education concept of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00146-00037308-00037583": "traditional education that was uh actual", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00147-00037584-00037817": "not that long ago", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00148-00037818-00038111": "traditional education so when we say", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00149-00038112-00038279": "traditional education the first thing", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00150-00038280-00038518": "that comes to our mind is a classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00151-00038519-00038807": "around 50 60 years ago when the teacher", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00152-00038808-00039065": "is the center of the universe and the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00153-00039066-00039343": "teacher has the full Authority", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00154-00039344-00039640": "owned and transferring the knowledge", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00155-00039641-00039874": "from one source to another in that case", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00156-00039875-00040115": "it was probably there from textbooks", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00157-00040116-00040337": "from other educational sources to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00158-00040338-00040673": "students teacher as I said before was", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00159-00040674-00040871": "the center it doesn't actually mean that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00160-00040872-00041009": "students didn't have an interaction", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00161-00041010-00041224": "during the lessons of course but the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00162-00041225-00041380": "authority of the teacher was the last", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00163-00041381-00041759": "destination of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00164-00041760-00042012": "all the processes in the classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00165-00042013-00042317": "they have a theoretical Focus", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00166-00042318-00042545": "was implied by the historical concept", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00167-00042546-00042802": "it's it's hard to it's hard to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00168-00042803-00043085": "distinguish the historical concept when", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00169-00043086-00043237": "it comes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00170-00043238-00043468": "different countries different regions", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00171-00043469-00043709": "cultures from the actual means of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00172-00043710-00044027": "Education nowadays Technologies are we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00173-00044028-00044362": "have a lot of influence in our lives and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00174-00044363-00044574": "that means that we need to adjust", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00175-00044575-00044921": "to these new uh challenges that we have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00176-00044922-00045215": "back in the day the historical the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00177-00045216-00045557": "historical context was different so it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00178-00045558-00045857": "was a very theoretically focused with", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00179-00045858-00046085": "the perspective of implementation those", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00180-00046086-00046324": "skills in the future there was no need", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00181-00046325-00046511": "for immediate effect there was no need", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00182-00046512-00046823": "for inventing a new way of introducing", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00183-00046824-00047033": "the materials everything was there", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00184-00047034-00047195": "everything was there ready for the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00185-00047196-00047461": "students to open the book and read it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00186-00047462-00047735": "limited creativity and students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00187-00047736-00048017": "passengers well when I say that it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00188-00048018-00048274": "this statement is a bit exaggerated so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00189-00048275-00048407": "it doesn't mean that the teachers of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00190-00048408-00048605": "previous years have not much around with", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00191-00048606-00048868": "their students and they did not try to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00192-00048869-00049055": "make their lessons interaction though", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00193-00049056-00049295": "there was no specific focus on these", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00194-00049296-00049537": "aspects of educational process", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00195-00049538-00050015": "information transfer when it comes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00196-00050016-00050329": "when it comes to transformation the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00197-00050330-00050645": "transportation of one specific topic to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00198-00050646-00050921": "another like interchanging them in terms", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00199-00050922-00051155": "of one subject it was very one-sided the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00200-00051156-00051419": "teacher transferred his knowledge to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00201-00051420-00051670": "students that how the process they look", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00202-00051671-00051976": "like the subject was more important than", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00203-00051977-00052294": "this so let's imagine that we are in a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00204-00052295-00052649": "classroom let's say 50 years ago in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00205-00052650-00052919": "country where rocket science rocket", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00206-00052920-00053104": "building was very important to afford", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00207-00053105-00053375": "the country philosophy that means that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00208-00053376-00053650": "the final aim was to build this problem", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00209-00053651-00053842": "it doesn't matter who would do that and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00210-00053844-00054115": "in module and it doesn't matter", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00211-00054116-00054461": "how hard it might be the outcome was the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00212-00054462-00054749": "most important for this purpose students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00213-00054750-00054982": "were introduced to theoretical material", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00214-00054983-00055223": "that only after that we started to do", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00215-00055224-00055499": "their Journey when it comes to practical", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00216-00055500-00055765": "implementation of their skills", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00217-00055766-00056153": "the educational approach of modern uh of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00218-00056154-00056363": "modern education is completely different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00219-00056364-00056837": "so the lesson to become students and it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00220-00056838-00057019": "was always to accept it to some point", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00221-00057020-00057211": "but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00222-00057212-00057557": "there was no specific need for the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00223-00057558-00057959": "teacher to to make this process focused", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00224-00057960-00058157": "specifically on one student or another", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00225-00058158-00058457": "without without relation to the needs of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00226-00058458-00058800": "specific students and their cognitive", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00227-00058801-00059159": "abilities preferences in the customers", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00228-00059160-00059404": "actually practical Focus now is still", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00229-00059405-00059657": "very important but nowadays we are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00230-00059658-00060088": "focusing on not only the final game but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00231-00060089-00060365": "at the immediate result as well so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00232-00060366-00060557": "whenever a new technology whenever", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00233-00060558-00060797": "something new is being implemented in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00234-00060798-00061066": "the classroom it is important to see the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00235-00061067-00061319": "outcome the physical manifestation of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00236-00061320-00061487": "what students are actually studying", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00237-00061488-00061775": "right now right now this particular day", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00238-00061776-00062130": "this particular week or semester or year", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00239-00062132-00062513": "information transfer differs now so it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00240-00062514-00062704": "not only the teacher passing the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00241-00062705-00062879": "information to the student but the other", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00242-00062879-00063125": "way around the classroom becomes an", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00243-00063126-00063359": "interactive environment where everyone", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00244-00063360-00063604": "is not only the recipient of knowledge", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00245-00063605-00063863": "but also the source of knowledge of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00246-00063864-00064021": "course the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00247-00064022-00064450": "the practice of teaching implies that we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00248-00064451-00064769": "need to do self-improve all the time", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00249-00064770-00065009": "which also means that back in the days", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00250-00065010-00065338": "two teachers were gathering feedbacks", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00251-00065339-00065494": "from you know their personal experience", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00252-00065495-00065681": "trying to improve their educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00253-00065682-00065806": "approach", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00254-00065807-00066017": "um nowadays this process is not only", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00255-00066018-00066232": "formal but also very interactive and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00256-00066233-00066635": "very uh it's happening right now live in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00257-00066636-00066911": "the classroom so from this perspective", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00258-00066912-00067259": "the interactivity of the exercises of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00259-00067260-00067438": "the topics presented or the whole", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00260-00067439-00067619": "educational process is very important", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00261-00067620-00067955": "it's a it's a life process which Demands", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00262-00067956-00068225": "a lot of adjustments different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00263-00068226-00068417": "classrooms have different preferences", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00264-00068418-00068681": "for many students have different needs", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00265-00068682-00069005": "so interactivity is very important", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00266-00069006-00069269": "the skills are more important than the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00267-00069270-00069725": "subject itself so nowadays we Face the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00268-00069726-00070013": "problem so to say we Face the situation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00269-00070014-00070241": "when problem solving skills are more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00270-00070242-00070397": "important than the subject that is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00271-00070398-00070541": "actually presented in different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00272-00070542-00070943": "educational establishments so uh modern", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00273-00070944-00071147": "Technologies provide us with a lot of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00274-00071148-00071441": "opportunities and the Very usage of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00275-00071442-00071806": "those in place non-standard situations", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00276-00071807-00072173": "which demand non-standard decisions from", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00277-00072174-00072353": "this perspective not only theoretical", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00278-00072354-00072569": "pieces very important but the Practical", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00279-00072570-00072959": "ability of students to uh to apply their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00280-00072960-00073349": "skills and to invent new ways to solve", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00281-00073350-00073619": "different problems as well so from this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00282-00073620-00073769": "perspective", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00283-00073770-00074050": "um the knowledge becomes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00284-00074051-00074435": "not only the data so to say but also the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00285-00074436-00074875": "ways how to use this data in different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00286-00074876-00075037": "situations", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00287-00075038-00075371": "when we use we will determine technology", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00288-00075372-00075611": "it doesn't mean that we only focus on", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00289-00075612-00075905": "those students on those subjects that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00290-00075906-00076085": "focus on", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00291-00076086-00076338": "the on the process of evolving of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00292-00076339-00076697": "technology in general so anyone is using", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00293-00076698-00076882": "right now technology", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00294-00076883-00077141": "just using smartphones laptops", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00295-00077142-00077362": "everyone in the field of Education came", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00296-00077363-00077555": "into medicine is in her life without", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00297-00077556-00077776": "technology and this thing this very same", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00298-00077777-00077917": "thing is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00299-00077918-00078106": "applicable for", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00300-00078107-00078419": "any student of any subject Humanities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00301-00078420-00078629": "Arts Technologies are really important", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00302-00078630-00078881": "later on we will go through the possible", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00303-00078882-00079085": "changes that might go through the label", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00304-00079086-00079331": "marketing we will try to see how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00305-00079332-00079619": "different uh professions and job", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00306-00079620-00079841": "positions might change in the future but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00307-00079842-00080099": "for now we cannot deny the fact that the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00308-00080100-00080326": "usage of modern Technologies in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00309-00080327-00080555": "classroom and in everyday life is very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00310-00080556-00080753": "important and that's another focus of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00311-00080754-00081071": "these Educational Concepts to show how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00312-00081072-00081359": "those Technologies can be useful and can", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00313-00081360-00081593": "be used outside the classrooms but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00314-00081594-00081887": "because the line will get will give", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00315-00081888-00082144": "those people those young students The", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00316-00082145-00082385": "Challenge and they will need to use all", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00317-00082386-00082735": "they can in order to reduce", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00318-00082736-00082979": "when it comes to teaching methods of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00319-00082980-00083225": "course it depends on on the subject it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00320-00083226-00083429": "depends on the curriculum of the school", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00321-00083430-00083776": "but there are a lot of I'm sure that a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00322-00083777-00083921": "lot of you have a teaching experience", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00323-00083922-00084215": "and all of you have uh your you have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00324-00084216-00084467": "your own favorite techniques and how to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00325-00084468-00084653": "present a new topic how to engage", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00326-00084654-00084893": "students in the interactive process", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00327-00084894-00085193": "education still there are some that are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00328-00085194-00085391": "very important you can see them on the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00329-00085392-00085591": "screen with a gamification for example", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00330-00085592-00085865": "especially nowadays and specifically in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00331-00085866-00086021": "the context of new technologies it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00332-00086022-00086261": "very very important as well", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00333-00086262-00086555": "um we know a lot of examples when games", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00334-00086556-00086849": "video games board games can be used to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00335-00086850-00087131": "enhance the educational process uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00336-00087132-00087341": "Microsoft Minecraft for example had a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00337-00087342-00087605": "lot of great educational programs that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00338-00087606-00087875": "help students to achieve", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00339-00087876-00088206": "um great results in their studies", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00340-00088207-00088600": "Collaborative Learning is I think is one", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00341-00088601-00088775": "of the most important techniques when it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00342-00088776-00088943": "comes to group learning when it comes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00343-00088944-00089129": "group activities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00344-00089130-00089417": "um even with even outside the context of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00345-00089418-00089693": "steam and stem and steam brackets it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00346-00089694-00089825": "very important to give students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00347-00089826-00090053": "opportunity to socialize and where it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00348-00090054-00090143": "very important to give them", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00349-00090144-00090359": "opportunities to work in groups later on", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00350-00090360-00090593": "few of them will work on their own maybe", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00351-00090594-00090803": "on some independent projects but it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00352-00090804-00091067": "very important to give you a chance to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00353-00091068-00091355": "see how it is to how it is important to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00354-00091356-00091571": "find themselves in the group of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00355-00091572-00091871": "like-minded people when the home group", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00356-00091872-00092153": "works together to achieve the result in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00357-00092154-00092506": "this case of a greater learning can be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00358-00092507-00092843": "very much handy click click classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00359-00092844-00093106": "gives a great possibility for students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00360-00093107-00093299": "to experience the other Society of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00361-00093300-00093618": "educational purposes to feel how it is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00362-00093619-00094006": "to run the classroom and on one hand", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00363-00094007-00094241": "it's very important for the teacher", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00364-00094242-00094523": "to see how his or her students behave in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00365-00094524-00094721": "such situation and also get feedback", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00366-00094722-00094837": "about", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00367-00094838-00095243": "their approach to this new situation and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00368-00095244-00095585": "also it gives a chance for students to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00369-00095586-00095861": "see how education is just more and the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00370-00095862-00096076": "classroom is just more than coming to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00371-00096077-00096250": "school and answering some questions the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00372-00096251-00096406": "teacher asks you will do some homework", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00373-00096407-00096685": "and projects it gives a lot for", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00374-00096686-00096905": "enhancement and interactivity of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00375-00096906-00097025": "best", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00376-00097026-00097081": "um", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00377-00097082-00097391": "self-learning self-learning aspect has", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00378-00097392-00097661": "always been very important in any", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00379-00097662-00097962": "um form of meditation though I might", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00380-00097963-00098303": "though I think that sometimes it's it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00381-00098304-00098711": "been used over accessibility a bit", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00382-00098712-00098873": "um self-learning is a very important", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00383-00098874-00099112": "skill and definitely should be used in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00384-00099113-00099491": "the modern classroom to some extent of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00385-00099492-00099593": "course", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00386-00099594-00099653": "um", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00387-00099654-00100055": "unfortunately some teachers nowadays put", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00388-00100056-00100306": "a little a little more emphasis than it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00389-00100307-00100505": "than it should be done but technically", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00390-00100506-00100673": "self-learning is the part of any", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00391-00100674-00100841": "curriculum of any school around the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00392-00100842-00101032": "world and I'm sure that you also about", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00393-00101033-00101285": "that all these teaching methods are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00394-00101286-00101638": "indicted by one specific course to buy", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00395-00101639-00101879": "the teacher and the student together so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00396-00101880-00102124": "to give the interaction and even when it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00397-00102125-00102403": "comes to the historical context of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00398-00102404-00102599": "educational approach and different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00399-00102600-00102851": "approaches it was still based on the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00400-00102852-00103030": "interaction between the teacher and the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00401-00103031-00103158": "student", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00402-00103159-00103528": "the the teacher himself is the figure in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00403-00103529-00103678": "the classroom is very still very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00404-00103679-00103823": "important and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00405-00103824-00104140": "it it is very important to see how the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00406-00104141-00104344": "personality of the teacher", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00407-00104345-00104554": "um affects not only the transition of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00408-00104555-00104782": "the knowledge but also affects young", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00409-00104783-00104993": "minds affects young students and forms", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00410-00104994-00105245": "their them as personalities into", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00411-00105246-00105628": "realities and so forth so these teaching", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00412-00105629-00105845": "methods are all interactive even though", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00413-00105846-00106121": "not all of them focus on interactivity", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00414-00106122-00106427": "itself it just uses it as a method to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00415-00106428-00106690": "transfer the information", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00416-00106691-00107123": "now uh let's get to the topic itself to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00417-00107124-00107327": "stand up against team and steam", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00418-00107328-00107578": "Advocates and when did it happen again", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00419-00107579-00107819": "we're again moving back to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00420-00107820-00108175": "historical uh context of the education", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00421-00108176-00108545": "and in this case we also should look at", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00422-00108546-00108845": "the political kind of political uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00423-00108846-00109043": "approach to education that also present", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00424-00109044-00109271": "back in the day and at some point is to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00425-00109272-00109577": "some extent is present even nowadays", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00426-00109578-00109933": "um in 1950 50s 1960s", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00427-00109933-00110213": "technological advancements was a great", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00428-00110214-00110639": "level it was a great political tool in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00429-00110640-00111077": "order to state to state the country with", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00430-00111078-00111293": "one some specific country region as a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00431-00111294-00111628": "global player in 1957 Soviet Union", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00432-00111629-00111943": "created the spot me and it was a great", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00433-00111944-00112234": "achievement for the whole cure of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00434-00112235-00112577": "humankind and it was used very much from", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00435-00112578-00112828": "the perspective of political influence", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00436-00112829-00113027": "for other countries and it became a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00437-00113028-00113413": "capitalist that started this race", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00438-00113414-00113645": "it started this phrase when it comes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00439-00113646-00113908": "technological advances as the answer to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00440-00113909-00114328": "that in 1957 NASA was created and it was", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00441-00114329-00114577": "also again also a great", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00442-00114578-00115013": "it was a great impulse for the evolving", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00443-00115014-00115183": "of the whole Branch", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00444-00115183-00115402": "at some point people just found", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00445-00115403-00115673": "themselves at the situation where they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00446-00115674-00115865": "don't have enough professionals they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00447-00115866-00116123": "don't have enough Specialists to push", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00448-00116124-00116489": "this race forward to make more more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00449-00116490-00116699": "technological advancements and they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00450-00116700-00116999": "needed the results very quickly this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00451-00117000-00117425": "process was not a short one but it took", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00452-00117426-00117695": "some time for people to change their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00453-00117696-00117857": "minds in terms of changing the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00454-00117858-00118039": "educational approach", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00455-00118040-00118408": "in 1970s 1980s there was a commercial", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00456-00118409-00118834": "run by Apple in 1984.", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00457-00118835-00119002": "if you haven't seen it I strongly", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00458-00119003-00119171": "recommend you do that because it's a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00459-00119172-00119452": "very important uh Milestone on the whole", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00460-00119453-00119728": "history not all the education but also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00461-00119729-00119851": "in our", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00462-00119852-00120089": "social life it was a great social", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00463-00120090-00120334": "phenomenon which show which has shown", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00464-00120335-00120683": "that Technologies soon and now right now", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00465-00120683-00120940": "are accessible to everyone they are very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00466-00120941-00121252": "important and like and like in the novel", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00467-00121253-00121523": "that we all know they can influence the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00468-00121524-00121889": "minds of people to to a enormous extent", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00469-00121890-00122308": "that this this particular event this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00470-00122309-00122569": "commercial of 1984", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00471-00122570-00122927": "started the whole movement of uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00472-00122928-00123240": "educational transformation it was", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00473-00123241-00123431": "subconscious I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00474-00123432-00123677": "can use this word kind of transformation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00475-00123678-00123965": "of educational person but later on in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00476-00123966-00124234": "1990s there was the first time", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00477-00124235-00124534": "understand a criminal was used which of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00478-00124535-00124690": "course you know stands science", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00479-00124691-00125051": "technology engineering event later on", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00480-00125052-00125215": "after some time", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00481-00125216-00125447": "educational initiatives in the United", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00482-00125448-00125807": "States in Europe have begun and we have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00483-00125808-00126125": "come to the point when stem and steamer", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00484-00126126-00126377": "almost heard in every corner of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00485-00126378-00126658": "world and they are very important in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00486-00126659-00126886": "order to prepare young Specialists for", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00487-00126888-00127133": "our specific needs because at the end of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00488-00127133-00127384": "the day very practical approach is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00489-00127385-00127613": "something that we need to take into", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00490-00127614-00127865": "account consideration we have some means", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00491-00127866-00128284": "right now to push our technological", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00492-00128285-00128602": "technological problem the process of our", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00493-00128603-00128957": "technological Evolution further and if", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00494-00128958-00129095": "we won't have enough Specialists and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00495-00129096-00129275": "Professionals in different fields we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00496-00129276-00129484": "just won't be able to do that so we need", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00497-00129485-00129707": "to adjust we're just our curriculum we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00498-00129708-00129947": "adjust our educational approach that's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00499-00129948-00130404": "how new Educational Concepts arise", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00500-00130405-00130660": "Steam and I didn't stealing with the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00501-00130661-00130936": "Arts not with both subjects right now", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00502-00130938-00131357": "it's relatively new concept and it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00503-00131358-00131885": "emerged in 2006 and it is still a very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00504-00131886-00132161": "uh it is still a very technological", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00505-00132162-00132485": "based educational concept but it implies", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00506-00132486-00132821": "the usage of other disciplines such as", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00507-00132822-00133109": "Humanities Linguistics arts in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00508-00133110-00133414": "purely scientific purely technological", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00509-00133415-00133709": "subjects like computer science math", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00510-00133710-00133954": "physics", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00511-00133955-00134345": "um we can divide we can globally we can", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00512-00134346-00134663": "divide the approach into two main", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00513-00134664-00134975": "spheres the soft skills and the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00514-00134976-00135166": "scientific skills technological skills", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00515-00135167-00135569": "so a stands for art which means that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00516-00135570-00135916": "soft skills here are most important uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00517-00135917-00136247": "working groups uh problem solving skills", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00518-00136248-00136595": "creativity in its pure form are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00519-00136596-00136795": "something that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00520-00136796-00137093": "that appear in the next application also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00521-00137094-00137435": "I mean stem is also a very creative", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00522-00137436-00137657": "occasional approach and many students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00523-00137658-00137807": "have the ability to show their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00524-00137808-00138113": "creativity in a pure technological", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00525-00138114-00138443": "uh implying different comply different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00526-00138444-00138677": "techniques from other subjects it helps", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00527-00138678-00138995": "students to use creativity in its purely", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00528-00138996-00139414": "form using all those soft skills that I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00529-00139415-00139697": "have mentioned before", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00530-00139698-00140075": "um when it comes to Innovation itself so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00531-00140076-00140314": "without Innovation we cannot imagine our", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00532-00140315-00140645": "lives and also education is any other", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00533-00140646-00140887": "sphere of our life also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00534-00140888-00141066": "undergoes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00535-00141067-00141340": "with this Roots starting from", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00536-00141341-00141569": "agricultural age thousands and thousands", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00537-00141570-00141845": "years ago Innovation was always", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00538-00141846-00142009": "something that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00539-00142010-00142327": "that pushed in our house civilization", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00540-00142328-00142673": "to create something new to to improve", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00541-00142674-00142889": "ourselves and in this field", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00542-00142890-00143147": "and it's actually quite interesting how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00543-00143148-00143363": "those Concepts that were used to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00544-00143364-00143519": "thousands and hundreds and thousands", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00545-00143520-00143704": "years ago are still being used right now", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00546-00143705-00143999": "but we don't even we actually don't even", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00547-00144000-00144311": "think about them the steam is not", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00548-00144312-00144449": "stimulus educational constantly", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00549-00144450-00144652": "surveillance of the young but the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00550-00144653-00145066": "approach to uh approach to using these", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00551-00145067-00145439": "kind of art skills in science uh were", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00552-00145440-00145745": "very very old windcraft for example for", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00553-00145746-00145890": "accounting", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00554-00145891-00146189": "civilization the hundreds and hundreds", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00555-00146190-00146459": "years ago all the knowledge back in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00556-00146460-00146681": "day considered to be scientific was", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00557-00146682-00147004": "passed down by the oral tradition of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00558-00147005-00147352": "sitting sounds and just as well telling", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00559-00147353-00147599": "stories everything was in the in in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00560-00147600-00148039": "form of World Knowledge transition", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00561-00148040-00148343": "such people as Leonardo da Vinci also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00562-00148344-00148690": "showed a very very big impact on uh of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00563-00148691-00149173": "Art and Science and if we take if we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00564-00149174-00149464": "if we take as an example", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00565-00149465-00149537": "um", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00566-00149538-00149873": "some other uh some other usage Parts in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00567-00149874-00150059": "technology", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00568-00150060-00150421": "for example there are different uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00569-00150422-00150790": "jewelry for people who need injections", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00570-00150791-00151090": "due to the medical conditions there are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00571-00151091-00151439": "many uh scientists serious scientists", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00572-00151440-00151752": "that actually do create those", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00573-00151753-00151985": "drafts of jewelries and different kinds", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00574-00151986-00152219": "of jewelries using nanotechnologies and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00575-00152220-00152489": "using Progressive Technologies in terms", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00576-00152490-00152704": "of helping people so even without", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00577-00152705-00153295": "educational context the the level of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00578-00153296-00153604": "interconnection of Art and technology is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00579-00153605-00153863": "present in chemistry in every branch of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00580-00153864-00154097": "science particular of our life in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00581-00154098-00154378": "general we are now in the transformation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00582-00154379-00154895": "page that time moves quickly quite fast", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00583-00154896-00155111": "right now so we need to clean up that's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00584-00155112-00155399": "why we are making up those Concepts so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00585-00155400-00155585": "to say which is to say that I'm saying", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00586-00155586-00155761": "it without the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00587-00155762-00155969": "non-disrespect or something but we need", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00588-00155970-00156143": "to come up with something new in order", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00589-00156144-00156407": "to come out of that that's why that's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00590-00156408-00156623": "probably the easiest way to describe", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00591-00156624-00157049": "what is happening right now progress", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00592-00157050-00157523": "implies progress", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00593-00157524-00157769": "when it comes to specific jobs and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00594-00157770-00157849": "specific", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00595-00157850-00157987": "[Music]", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00596-00157988-00158261": "specific labor market preferences that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00597-00158262-00158549": "are present right now on the screen you", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00598-00158550-00158743": "can see the jobs that are present in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00599-00158744-00159059": "2022. some of them are very well known", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00600-00159060-00159166": "as", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00601-00159167-00159419": "nothing special to me especially", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00602-00159420-00159569": "something that of course it is something", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00603-00159570-00159833": "special in the person who uh possesses", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00604-00159834-00160114": "knowledge in this kind of sphere but my", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00605-00160115-00160228": "point is that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00606-00160229-00160426": "those things that we consider to be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00607-00160427-00160654": "Progressive right now in 10 years 15", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00608-00160655-00160966": "years will not be as progressing they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00609-00160967-00161135": "are and when it comes to robotic", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00610-00161136-00161416": "engineer robotic maintains hair when it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00611-00161417-00161597": "comes to I it's quite a hard topic", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00612-00161598-00161795": "especially when it comes to the moral", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00613-00161796-00162131": "and ethnic uh part of it but I'm pretty", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00614-00162132-00162389": "sure that very soon AI will be used to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00615-00162390-00162707": "on a much really really", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00616-00162708-00162911": "it will be much more developed than it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00617-00162912-00163090": "is right now and I'm sure it will be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00618-00163091-00163289": "used in more branches in a technology", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00619-00163290-00163583": "more branches of the industry and other", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00620-00163584-00163973": "things that's why AI engineer", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00621-00163974-00164314": "might need the understanding of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00622-00164315-00164573": "philosophy the understanding of art", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00623-00164574-00164701": "skills", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00624-00164702-00164983": "in the aestheticist", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00625-00164984-00165359": "approach to the AI events usage in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00626-00165360-00165599": "model technology data analyst and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00627-00165600-00165809": "something that is very very famous very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00628-00165810-00166037": "popular right now and it definitely will", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00629-00166038-00166487": "lead to the Specialists who delve deeper", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00630-00166488-00166907": "into Data analysis and that show how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00631-00166908-00167237": "data can be used in solving different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00632-00167238-00167585": "problems so data detectors I'm sure also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00633-00167586-00167819": "uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00634-00167820-00168185": "a drone engineer art as Space Engineer", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00635-00168186-00168390": "everything becomes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00636-00168391-00168647": "everything undergoes this transformation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00637-00168648-00168881": "page and everything will be changed in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00638-00168882-00169228": "the future so our goal or aim right now", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00639-00169229-00169445": "is to be prepared for it and not only", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00640-00169446-00169733": "ourselves but also prepare", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00641-00169734-00169943": "um also preparing our students also the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00642-00169944-00170135": "very young minds to be ready", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00643-00170136-00170359": "for those challenges", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00644-00170360-00170651": "that's quite an interesting question if", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00645-00170652-00170837": "at the end of our webinar and you might", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00646-00170838-00171233": "think about some jobs professionals or", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00647-00171234-00171419": "anything else that might appear I'm", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00648-00171420-00171563": "really happy to hear your thoughts and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00649-00171564-00171775": "be good nature", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00650-00171776-00172211": "now let's go so basically stamp and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00651-00172212-00172495": "steam with Arts against more or less", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00652-00172496-00172816": "more or less covered when it comes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00653-00172817-00173219": "steam and Pagan dragons all the subjects", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00654-00173220-00173399": "the intensions of all subjects in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00655-00173400-00173597": "education", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00656-00173598-00173825": "it's a bit different approach it's also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00657-00173826-00174125": "quite relative It's relatively new but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00658-00174126-00174366": "the concept is the same we include", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00659-00174367-00174575": "interdisciplinary approaches and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00660-00174576-00174714": "educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00661-00174715-00175145": "process in order to make the the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00662-00175146-00175475": "education itself is more interactive and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00663-00175476-00175649": "more flexible", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00664-00175650-00175925": "and that is the aim of those three", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00665-00175926-00176147": "advantages now we're going to have a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00666-00176148-00176387": "look at specific examples examples of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00667-00176388-00176566": "exercises that are used in different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00668-00176567-00176783": "schools in the curricula around the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00669-00176784-00176963": "world they're super simple and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00670-00176964-00177238": "untraditional to be I'm pretty sure that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00671-00177239-00177437": "some of you have used something similar", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00672-00177438-00177664": "and maybe later on we can discuss that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00673-00177665-00178001": "in terms of practical implementation in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00674-00178002-00178181": "terms of how useful they can be during", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00675-00178182-00178504": "the last so the first one", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00676-00178505-00178709": "the constant combines you the knowledge", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00677-00178710-00178943": "it's a very simple stem experiment which", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00678-00178944-00179302": "is being used in many schools", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00679-00179303-00179621": "and I didn't mention that before but in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00680-00179622-00179881": "those three concepts they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00681-00179882-00180095": "their main", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00682-00180096-00180433": "aim is to show it it's not to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00683-00180434-00180845": "learn only or teach modeling or study", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00684-00180846-00181085": "model it it's also to show what you", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00685-00181086-00181216": "understand it's very important for the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00686-00181217-00181451": "students to have the tactile following", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00687-00181452-00181678": "what they are starting to see what it is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00688-00181679-00182002": "that the subject of the object story of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00689-00182003-00182278": "their application process so that's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00690-00182279-00182651": "where these kind of shortened very uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00691-00182652-00182813": "interesting from the perspective", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00692-00182814-00183059": "students the experiments were done handy", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00693-00183060-00183288": "because it is not only", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00694-00183289-00183647": "giving the creativity and trust but also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00695-00183648-00183911": "it encourages them to find something", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00696-00183912-00184097": "else to find because if they see the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00697-00184098-00184283": "designs can handle here and write down", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00698-00184284-00184481": "with their hands it will encourage them", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00699-00184482-00184721": "to uh to go deeper into the topic to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00700-00184722-00185075": "find other ways of checking different in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00701-00185076-00185375": "this case uh investigational constants", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00702-00185376-00185657": "so all you need is just some water into", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00703-00185658-00185914": "oranges the demonstrational concept of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00704-00185915-00186088": "this exercise is very simple you just", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00705-00186089-00186299": "show it you just show the concept of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00706-00186300-00186502": "viruses so you take to own this one as", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00707-00186503-00186713": "people that's not you put it in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00708-00186714-00186947": "water and the one a lot of people sing", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00709-00186948-00187307": "and another one", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00710-00187308-00187576": "and not build will float something like", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00711-00187577-00187966": "that and then after it later on students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00712-00187967-00188285": "will ask questions about this experiment", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00713-00188286-00188507": "and these questions can be supported by", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00714-00188508-00188651": "specifically", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00715-00188652-00188938": "by the demonstration or aspect of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00716-00188939-00189226": "experiment so this year they know how it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00717-00189227-00189521": "happens and it's much easier later on to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00718-00189522-00190026": "explain how it works what", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00719-00190027-00190331": "what's team techniques could be used", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00720-00190332-00190463": "here", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00721-00190464-00190685": "let's first face the educational value", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00722-00190686-00190954": "of the experiment is it useful from the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00723-00190955-00191164": "frontal point of view of like scientific", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00724-00191165-00191404": "point of view yes very much it shows the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00725-00191405-00191585": "concept of the bytes of knowledge so the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00726-00191586-00191969": "final thing is achieved but does it help", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00727-00191970-00192202": "students to somehow", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00728-00192203-00192514": "um now I'm talking only about the bear", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00729-00192515-00192713": "demonstration without any additional", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00730-00192714-00192959": "techniques used in Steam and steaming", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00731-00192960-00193235": "records does it help students to somehow", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00732-00193236-00193459": "use their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00733-00193460-00193738": "uh social skills to problem solving", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00734-00193739-00194026": "skills not really", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00735-00194027-00194183": "I know for sure that in many American", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00736-00194184-00194369": "schools this experiment is the part of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00737-00194370-00194573": "the curriculum but when it comes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00738-00194574-00194728": "additional activities every teacher", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00739-00194729-00195011": "comes with his or his ideas", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00740-00195012-00195281": "Can it can it be added can we add some", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00741-00195282-00195473": "group activity with that of course we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00742-00195474-00195778": "can can we add some description of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00743-00195779-00196025": "activities like students going through", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00744-00196026-00196254": "this small research and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00745-00196255-00196535": "put down their data and results of their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00746-00196536-00196823": "own experiments we can tell yes of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00747-00196824-00197033": "course we can so the same the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00748-00197034-00197333": "educational value remains and it is well", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00749-00197334-00197488": "it has going into construction and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00750-00197489-00197728": "demonstrational concept but this pain", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00751-00197729-00198028": "and in practice music so how can we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00752-00198029-00198199": "enhance that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00753-00198200-00198526": "let's go through another experiment in a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00754-00198527-00198743": "classroom experiment the maze", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00755-00198744-00198947": "construction experiment which also has a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00756-00198948-00199223": "very very similar approach and very very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00757-00199224-00199576": "similar uh final name students are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00758-00199577-00199690": "building", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00759-00199691-00200009": "um using any any TDA this specific", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00760-00200010-00200454": "School", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00761-00200455-00200897": "they are building the domains", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00762-00200898-00201088": "well the best thing to use for different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00763-00201089-00201269": "purposes the maze itself can be used but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00764-00201270-00201443": "also for example they have some robots", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00765-00201444-00201611": "when they have some other attentionated", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00766-00201612-00201916": "but use the the main they can build it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00767-00201917-00202085": "in order let's assume that the school", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00768-00202086-00202307": "has development in order for robot to go", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00769-00202308-00202523": "through the links uh demonstrational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00770-00202524-00202876": "purposes there yes it is we show so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00771-00202877-00203209": "first of all we show how to build it we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00772-00203210-00203585": "encourage students to develop the basic", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00773-00203586-00203866": "engineering construction skills and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00774-00203867-00204214": "after that they have the the result they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00775-00204215-00204383": "had result they see the intro to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00776-00204384-00204526": "person with friends and there's another", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00777-00204527-00204901": "pain that was met in terms of stem", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00778-00204902-00205123": "educational concept", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00779-00205123-00205468": "now here this experiment gives", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00780-00205469-00205594": "[Music]", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00781-00205596-00205831": "I've got a lot of opportunities to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00782-00205832-00206140": "implement the sources from other", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00783-00206141-00206398": "subjects from other disciplines first of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00784-00206400-00206686": "all group activity is very important", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00785-00206687-00206884": "here the group of students could be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00786-00206885-00207101": "divided into smaller groups and be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00787-00207102-00207364": "assign different flows the one part of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00788-00207365-00207508": "the students could be assigned as", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00789-00207509-00207790": "Engineers they for example use a visual", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00790-00207791-00207988": "pen and paper or pencil and paper to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00791-00207989-00208331": "draw a draft of the maze of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00792-00208332-00208548": "labyrinth another", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00793-00208550-00208840": "subgroup of students will be the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00794-00208841-00209044": "builders so to see who would use their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00795-00209046-00209207": "basic", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00796-00209208-00209446": "their basic engineering skills", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00797-00209448-00209596": "construction skills to actually building", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00798-00209598-00209807": "ways it doesn't mean that subgroups", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00799-00209808-00209963": "cannot interact with each other during", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00800-00209964-00210155": "it of course students from different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00801-00210156-00210415": "subgroups we can do different tasks for", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00802-00210416-00210857": "uh as well but exciting the role is very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00803-00210858-00211217": "important to kill the feeling of being", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00804-00211217-00211469": "something of being something pass or", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00805-00211469-00211775": "something bigger and having his or her", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00806-00211776-00212048": "own role is experience", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00807-00212050-00212755": "[Music]", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00808-00212756-00213053": "depending on what teaching AIDS the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00809-00213054-00213581": "school has they implement the uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00810-00213582-00213817": "um", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00811-00213817-00214073": "physical activities they can run through", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00812-00214073-00214319": "and go through it it depends on their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00813-00214319-00214421": "teacher", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00814-00214421-00214727": "uh the point in this experiment is to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00815-00214728-00215008": "include as many problems on those scales", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00816-00215009-00215231": "and the soft skills as possible group", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00817-00215232-00215453": "activity", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00818-00215454-00215603": "um there's problems on our skills but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00819-00215604-00215842": "yes like also check what is also the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00820-00215844-00216029": "most important different subgroups have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00821-00216030-00216317": "different goals and together after that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00822-00216317-00216527": "the growth of different subgroups of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00823-00216528-00216737": "students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00824-00216738-00216901": "and that body", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00825-00216902-00217163": "Steam and steamy brackets is all about", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00826-00217164-00217565": "achieving and the global goal using the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00827-00217566-00217775": "problem solving skills in the group", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00828-00217776-00217948": "activities of course that's not all but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00829-00217950-00218171": "that's one of the most important aspects", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00830-00218171-00218375": "of these educational concerns and of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00831-00218376-00218496": "course after that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00832-00218498-00218848": "students who could have other activities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00833-00218850-00219023": "connected to it when it can be used", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00834-00219023-00219215": "multiple times and can be adjusted", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00835-00219216-00219391": "according to time management", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00836-00219392-00219658": "teacher preferences many other aspects", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00837-00219659-00220006": "of course but again what was taken from", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00838-00220007-00220181": "the stem educational concept the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00839-00220182-00220415": "demonstrational aspect to show how it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00840-00220416-00220679": "done and being enhanced by those soft", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00841-00220680-00220865": "skills of problem solving skills and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00842-00220866-00221146": "creativity technically students who just", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00843-00221148-00221256": "use", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00844-00221257-00221591": "sketches Craft on the maze before they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00845-00221592-00221891": "actually build it so they need to apply", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00846-00221892-00222077": "their skills in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00847-00222078-00222313": "their art skills to finish this exercise", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00848-00222314-00222605": "that's what that's what makes it a bit", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00849-00222606-00222929": "different as I said before stem Steam", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00850-00222930-00223132": "and steaming brackets they all include", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00851-00223133-00223421": "the creativity aspect and the prioritize", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00852-00223421-00223606": "it it's very hard on the priorities to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00853-00223607-00223805": "give students opportunities to be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00854-00223806-00224056": "creative but they use different when", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00855-00224057-00224219": "they use different approaches to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00856-00224219-00224446": "scripture it is that includes creativity", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00857-00224448-00224681": "and pure technological form while", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00858-00224682-00224977": "stealing still paying brackets include", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00859-00224978-00225415": "creativity in its pure world not", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00860-00225416-00225767": "connected specifically or directly to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00861-00225767-00226121": "some scientific research some sense of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00862-00226121-00226319": "experiment or exercise", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00863-00226319-00226582": "the flexibility", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00864-00226583-00226792": "or is it important to indication of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00865-00226794-00227146": "course it is we can we can safely assume", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00866-00227148-00227392": "that normal students that are fond of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00867-00227394-00227639": "math physics biology chemistry many", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00868-00227640-00227779": "other", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00869-00227780-00228053": "subjects would become", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00870-00228054-00228287": "scientists in those specific branches", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00871-00228288-00228646": "still using those technological aspects", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00872-00228648-00228787": "and those", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00873-00228788-00229127": "techniques from other disciplines will", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00874-00229128-00229337": "help them in whatever role they choose", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00875-00229338-00229469": "the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00876-00229469-00229655": "because I said before creativity in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00877-00229656-00230056": "Superior formula is the main is the main", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00878-00230057-00230231": "aim of the whole educational process", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00879-00230232-00230560": "right now and that's what really is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00880-00230561-00230801": "great about it that we have changed this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00881-00230802-00231077": "approach of being that when the subject", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00882-00231078-00231281": "is more important than actually the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00883-00231282-00231629": "student who uh is involved in this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00884-00231630-00231982": "process and it's not going to be this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00885-00231983-00232223": "the subject will War as well but it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00886-00232223-00232519": "the student who got his or her education", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00887-00232519-00232925": "will contribute to will contribute to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00888-00232926-00233165": "this transition process of one subject", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00889-00233166-00233327": "or one discipline or one branch of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00890-00233328-00233525": "science becoming something else we can", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00891-00233526-00233681": "be something more complex becoming", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00892-00233682-00234058": "something more uh important for our", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00893-00234059-00234208": "nowadays Society", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00894-00234209-00234448": "uh so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00895-00234450-00234658": "in this way we can see a difference", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00896-00234659-00234851": "between these two concepts but of course", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00897-00234852-00235108": "it's it's really exaggerated in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00898-00235109-00235505": "approach to to judge these two concepts", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00899-00235506-00235751": "only on these small exercises of course", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00900-00235752-00235937": "the indication process is much more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00901-00235938-00236310": "complex it includes many personal uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00902-00236311-00236723": "individual and personal uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00903-00236723-00236884": "features as well", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00904-00236885-00237196": "but still if we have a look at the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00905-00237198-00237455": "global goal they both are aiming at the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00906-00237456-00237713": "same thing but just use different uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00907-00237714-00238019": "different methods and also use a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00908-00238019-00238091": "different", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00909-00238092-00238408": "um use a different level of disciplinary", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00910-00238409-00238615": "techniques", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00911-00238616-00239056": "so to give a short conclusion Steam and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00912-00239057-00239458": "steam and fragments is all about four", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00913-00239459-00239742": "things communication collaboration", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00914-00239744-00239992": "critical thinking and problem solving", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00915-00239994-00240389": "and creativity when it comes to stem it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00916-00240390-00240634": "has a heart scientific Focus technology", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00917-00240635-00241042": "as the main course of uh of progress and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00918-00241044-00241253": "creativity in its pure technological", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00919-00241254-00241517": "work so even those things that you can", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00920-00241517-00241679": "see on your screen now can be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00921-00241680-00242092": "interrelated and they can be they can", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00922-00242094-00242339": "serve the same us but at the same time", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00923-00242340-00242569": "both of those Concepts", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00924-00242569-00242842": "even there are seven seen purpose use", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00925-00242844-00243053": "different methods and those methods that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00926-00243054-00243167": "are being used during educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00927-00243167-00243527": "process then they either give you more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00928-00243528-00243821": "opportunities or not so it's hard to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00929-00243821-00244006": "compare them in terms of educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00930-00244007-00244246": "value because both stem educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00931-00244248-00244492": "projects and steam and steam records are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00932-00244494-00244858": "very useful and very important to be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00933-00244859-00245225": "implemented nowadays classrooms but it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00934-00245226-00245369": "also", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00935-00245369-00245746": "it also it is also hard sometimes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00936-00245748-00245932": "distinguish what is more important soft", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00937-00245933-00246208": "skills or technological advancement how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00938-00246209-00246329": "to implement them in the classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00939-00246330-00246725": "because uh having having experience in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00940-00246726-00247006": "teaching I'm sure that you do you do", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00941-00247007-00247223": "know that some groups of students sell", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00942-00247223-00247529": "schools sell classrooms so to say are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00943-00247530-00247751": "and it's not that easy to implement", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00944-00247752-00247931": "those specific techniques and it should", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00945-00247932-00248165": "be adjusted according to uh students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00946-00248166-00248310": "preferences as we said before", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00947-00248311-00248494": "student-centered lessons are something", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00948-00248496-00248656": "which is happening right now so that's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00949-00248657-00249017": "what we should thankful but again why", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00950-00249017-00249292": "the final word that binds it all", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00951-00249294-00249575": "together creativity creativity and the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00952-00249576-00249791": "form of this creativity is chosen by the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00953-00249792-00250025": "teacher and of course influenced by many", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00954-00250026-00250294": "other things like curricular movements", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00955-00250296-00250523": "so practical teaching things that are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00956-00250523-00250889": "present in some specific classrooms", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00957-00250890-00251225": "but yes this is pretty much it so today", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00958-00251226-00251482": "we tried to have a look at the basic", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00959-00251483-00251729": "concepts of Steels Talent steel brackets", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00960-00251730-00252041": "hanging brackets and I hope that it was", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00961-00252042-00252275": "useful that you liked it desperately", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00962-00252276-00252769": "from my from my side thank you very much", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00963-00252769-00253289": "good question", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00964-00253290-00253560": "thank you so much Victor for this very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00965-00253561-00253865": "intriguing and fascinating presentation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00966-00253866-00254201": "I feel like I have learned a lot myself", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00967-00254202-00254387": "I particularly", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00968-00254388-00254669": "um really enjoyed that slide about how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00969-00254669-00254939": "professions evolve with time", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00970-00254940-00255401": "by the year 2035 that was something that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00971-00255402-00255551": "I've never thought about before how", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00972-00255552-00255791": "everything can become you know it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00973-00255792-00256210": "oriented and also uh I think if I'd had", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00974-00256211-00256429": "an experiment like the orange", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00975-00256430-00256696": "buoyancy experiment back in school I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00976-00256698-00256823": "might have been more interested in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00977-00256823-00256991": "science", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00978-00256992-00257182": "last opportunity", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00979-00257183-00257513": "and also uh also the fact that Sputnik", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00980-00257514-00257627": "and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00981-00257628-00258077": "apple and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00982-00258078-00258317": "apple and you know other developments", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00983-00258317-00258569": "from the 70s and 80s are still relevant", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00984-00258569-00258748": "it's uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00985-00258750-00259103": "it's it's a very fascinating discussion", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00986-00259104-00259355": "also that change is inevitable then we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00987-00259356-00259571": "have to transform our education to meet", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00988-00259571-00259865": "the needs of students and yeah and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00989-00259866-00260027": "before we move on I'd just like to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00990-00260028-00260219": "direct the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00991-00260219-00260423": "participants here to the participation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00992-00260423-00260656": "list in in case you have not signed the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00993-00260657-00260782": "signature list", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00994-00260783-00261010": "please do you can find the link in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00995-00261011-00261094": "chat", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00996-00261096-00261256": "you will share some time back but in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00997-00261257-00261419": "case you need it again", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00998-00261419-00261701": "please do sign it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-00999-00261702-00261905": "we need this so that in case you want", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01000-00261906-00262234": "the uh certificate the participation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01001-00262235-00262415": "certificate", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01002-00262416-00262741": "we will be able to send it to you", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01003-00262742-00263069": "and now it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01004-00263070-00263399": "time for the Q a session", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01005-00263400-00263603": "I think there is one question and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01006-00263604-00263879": "inquiry I do see one yes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01007-00263880-00264029": "yes inquiry based on", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01008-00264030-00264341": "the good method", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01009-00264342-00264682": "the short answer is yes it's a good", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01010-00264683-00265006": "message why is it guilty so first of all", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01011-00265007-00265355": "it's good because students can make a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01012-00265356-00265708": "real life connections to to you know to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01013-00265709-00265915": "educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01014-00265916-00266117": "processes that happen in the classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01015-00266118-00266417": "so it is very connected to the real life", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01016-00266418-00266710": "so to see so I would say that yes it's a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01017-00266711-00266951": "very good uh it's a very good method to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01018-00266952-00267143": "do because you should guide students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01019-00267144-00267341": "through the whole process", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01020-00267342-00267629": "did he or she gives the students a lot", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01021-00267630-00267779": "of information about it and they have a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01022-00267780-00267947": "lot of freedom to make these real-life", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01023-00267948-00268295": "connections though uh I do admit that I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01024-00268296-00268595": "think sometimes it's very hard to take a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01025-00268596-00268930": "specific topic and include it and we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01026-00268931-00269213": "will present it in terms of inquiry and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01027-00269214-00269543": "basic learning I will cover the yes yes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01028-00269544-00269705": "of course if you have an opportunity to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01029-00269706-00269951": "check it out and we'll try it with your", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01030-00269952-00270179": "students I would recommend to do that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01031-00270180-00270479": "but it's sometimes it's practically it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01032-00270480-00270665": "hard to implement that's that's the only", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01033-00270666-00271001": "thing that that comes to my mind from", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01034-00271002-00271853": "the minuses of this but yes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01035-00271854-00272555": "okay do we have any more questions", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01036-00272556-00272860": "okay I have a few", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01037-00272861-00273160": "uh do you have any more resources like", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01038-00273161-00273569": "the orange experiment that you shared", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01039-00273570-00273923": "Yes actually we are as a company and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01040-00273924-00274327": "just me personally we are working on the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01041-00274328-00274613": "so to say on the list of teach of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01042-00274614-00274805": "list of practical tips for teachers and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01043-00274806-00275021": "how to use teams down the educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01044-00275022-00275195": "techniques during the lessons so yes of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01045-00275196-00275375": "course we do have more of them the the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01046-00275376-00275701": "formal power of our today's meeting uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01047-00275702-00275980": "did not did not give a lot of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01048-00275981-00276179": "opportunity to show all of them but I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01049-00276180-00276358": "would be happy to share with them to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01050-00276359-00276497": "share them with you later if you're", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01051-00276498-00276682": "interested I would be happy to listen", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01052-00276683-00276851": "again and maybe show you something more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01053-00276852-00277108": "and show you something uh interesting in", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01054-00277109-00277289": "terms of practical implementation of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01055-00277290-00277582": "steam and stem in the classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01056-00277583-00277915": "okay thank you and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01057-00277916-00278260": "maybe I'll ask one or two more questions", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01058-00278261-00278573": "I think we have a few minutes so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01059-00278574-00278921": "hmm", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01060-00278922-00279113": "so what would you recommend to teachers", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01061-00279114-00279334": "who want to be involved more in stem", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01062-00279335-00279521": "activities but they feel they're not", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01063-00279522-00279905": "very well equipped in technology or you", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01064-00279906-00280097": "know they don't have the skills right", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01065-00280098-00280313": "now", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01066-00280314-00280558": "um when it comes to technology and to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01067-00280559-00280756": "the access to the teaching and it's of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01068-00280757-00280895": "course it's a very hard question many", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01069-00280896-00281075": "schools around the world do not have an", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01070-00281076-00281243": "access to Technologies but they are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01071-00281244-00281519": "still very enthusiastic when it comes to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01072-00281520-00281669": "the education they want their students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01073-00281670-00281905": "to be involved in this process", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01074-00281906-00282203": "this General approach to problem-solving", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01075-00282204-00282503": "to finding the way to present students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01076-00282504-00282803": "with problem-solving skills luckily is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01077-00282804-00283121": "not only connected to the uh to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01078-00283122-00283282": "usage or Technologies in the classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01079-00283283-00283510": "so I'm sure that every teacher is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01080-00283511-00283715": "focused on self-improvement and if we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01081-00283716-00283919": "approach these three important", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01082-00283920-00284267": "milestones in our educational uh our", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01083-00284268-00284515": "educational process like creativity", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01084-00284516-00284830": "flexibility of the information about the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01085-00284831-00285089": "subjects that we had Implement in our", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01086-00285090-00285389": "classroom and also problem solving", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01087-00285390-00285815": "skills then the outcome would be very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01088-00285816-00286139": "good so it all comes with it is very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01089-00286140-00286330": "connected with the personal motivation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01090-00286331-00286517": "of the teacher of course and the ways", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01091-00286518-00286769": "how she he or she is determined to use", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01092-00286770-00287008": "these techniques during the lessons even", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01093-00287009-00287171": "though I don't understand it sometimes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01094-00287172-00287501": "it might be hard to technically just", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01095-00287502-00287758": "Implement them not also have a tools", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01096-00287759-00287980": "teaching AIDs that are needed but I'm", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01097-00287981-00288227": "sure that if the teacher is dedicated to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01098-00288228-00288455": "the purpose then", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01099-00288456-00288610": "absolutely", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01100-00288611-00288958": "okay and you said that you were a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01101-00288959-00289282": "teacher for a few years so do you have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01102-00289283-00289475": "any methods that you really enjoyed", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01103-00289476-00289829": "implementing in the classroom", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01104-00289830-00290123": "well gamification is always very nice", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01105-00290124-00290393": "because everyone likes to play games and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01106-00290394-00290549": "the teacher has a chance to you know", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01107-00290550-00290710": "have their short breaks into the same", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01108-00290711-00290815": "place", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01109-00290816-00291089": "I'm joking of course the teacher should", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01110-00291090-00291349": "always be aware of what's happening but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01111-00291350-00291725": "during my lessons I was using a lot of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01112-00291726-00291947": "techniques when it comes to gamification", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01113-00291948-00292217": "group activities and also I was trying", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01114-00292218-00292445": "to make my classes as interactive as", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01115-00292446-00292673": "possible so I think it's all about", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01116-00292674-00292945": "finding the right balance between", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01117-00292946-00293279": "giving your students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01118-00293280-00293530": "there's a lot of authority in the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01119-00293531-00293777": "classroom a lot of a lot of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01120-00293778-00293963": "possibilities to express themselves but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01121-00293964-00294239": "to uh to a reasonable extent it's all", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01122-00294240-00294493": "about the right balance between the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01123-00294494-00294839": "teacher and the student not like a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01124-00294840-00295013": "person but like a concept A person who", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01125-00295014-00295247": "teaches them the person who studies and", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01126-00295248-00295445": "it's all about finding a brain balance", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01127-00295446-00295697": "in their local issues because even", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01128-00295698-00295943": "though we are discussing uh purely", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01129-00295944-00296165": "scientific and technological Concepts uh", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01130-00296166-00296405": "connected with education interpersonal", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01131-00296406-00296621": "relation and the bond between the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01132-00296622-00296747": "teacher and the student is very", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01133-00296748-00297023": "important and it also influences the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01134-00297024-00297227": "educational process I'm sure that the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01135-00297228-00297497": "thing that I just had mentioned is quite", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01136-00297498-00297677": "self-obness self-explanatory and I'm", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01137-00297678-00297880": "sure that's all you know that but it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01138-00297881-00298139": "sometimes it's important to repeat", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01139-00298140-00298337": "ourselves these things not to forget", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01140-00298338-00298469": "about it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01141-00298470-00298858": "in our in our life educational life", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01142-00298859-00299105": "do you think it's difficult to find this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01143-00299106-00299213": "balance", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01144-00299214-00299417": "um is it more difficult in primary", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01145-00299418-00299723": "school or is it in high school do you", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01146-00299724-00299999": "think it's easier in high school", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01147-00300000-00300389": "um it's very much it very much depends", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01148-00300390-00300545": "on the personalities of the teacher", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01149-00300546-00300917": "himself herself but also I think that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01150-00300918-00301369": "it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01151-00301370-00301667": "it's just not that simple and it depends", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01152-00301668-00301943": "a lot of Athens from both sides so I'm", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01153-00301944-00302255": "not sure if we can generalize it like", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01154-00302256-00302579": "that because even even not age like even", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01155-00302580-00302747": "not speaking about age groups but", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01156-00302748-00302891": "specific", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01157-00302892-00303101": "students in specific groups it might be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01158-00303102-00303269": "very very difficult different so when it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01159-00303270-00303425": "comes to these kind of interpersonal", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01160-00303426-00303779": "relation questions relating questions", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01161-00303780-00304030": "then it's very hard to you know being", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01162-00304031-00304260": "able to find attachment to find the rule", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01163-00304261-00304571": "but yeah of course just like in usual", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01164-00304572-00304810": "novel like it's hard to to create a bond", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01165-00304811-00304949": "with someone and the teacher is someone", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01166-00304950-00305423": "who bones binds uh many young students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01167-00305424-00305710": "together like in one interactive", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01168-00305711-00305854": "environment which is the classroom so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01169-00305855-00306143": "it's very very hard uh regardless of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01170-00306144-00306521": "age you know okay and we have a question", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01171-00306522-00306617": "here", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01172-00306618-00306845": "do you have any particular method that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01173-00306846-00307013": "we can promote steam to our girls", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01174-00307014-00307241": "students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01175-00307242-00307475": "well I'm not sure if the question is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01176-00307476-00307763": "aimed at the specific group of students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01177-00307764-00308110": "girls that specifically groups of girls", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01178-00308111-00308297": "who I think it doesn't matter what", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01179-00308298-00308508": "gender the students have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01180-00308509-00308723": "all the methods that we have discussed", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01181-00308724-00308969": "today can be implied for for example", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01182-00308970-00309160": "integrated primary school and part of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01183-00309161-00309467": "course from uh those the participal of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01184-00309468-00309647": "those means that different students have", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01185-00309648-00309913": "in terms of for example their physical", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01186-00309914-00310145": "disability or something else", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01187-00310146-00310415": "it all can be combined together using", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01188-00310416-00310660": "those single techniques so one specific", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01189-00310661-00310960": "technique from interactivity a lot of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01190-00310961-00311184": "group a lot of group activities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01191-00311185-00311543": "demonstrational method of stem exercises", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01192-00311544-00311806": "that we have the time from the world", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01193-00311807-00312154": "today and also creative things in its", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01194-00312155-00312310": "evidence form even if we have like a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01195-00312311-00312527": "very simple exercise it's up to the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01196-00312528-00312730": "teacher to add the crew to the creative", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01197-00312731-00312965": "aspect to it or not it's quite it's", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01198-00312966-00313121": "quite simple when you get ahead of it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01199-00313122-00313260": "but it's very hard to start", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01200-00313261-00313480": "unfortunately sometimes it's just easier", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01201-00313481-00313649": "to follow the curriculum well the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01202-00313650-00313943": "guidelines that we all have but it all", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01203-00313944-00314182": "comes to the personal motivation adding", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01204-00314183-00314591": "creativity adding also the problem", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01205-00314592-00314782": "solving skills in the group activities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01206-00314783-00315025": "is the most important I'm sure that your", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01207-00315026-00315419": "girl students would appreciate that as", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01208-00315420-00315599": "much as any other group", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01209-00315600-00315880": "regardless of their gender age or any", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01210-00315881-00316349": "other than any other suspects", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01211-00316350-00316715": "yeah thank you for that answer I hope", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01212-00316716-00316960": "the person who asked the question yeah", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01213-00316961-00317182": "welcome", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01214-00317183-00317489": "any more questions we just have a few", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01215-00317490-00317989": "more minutes to go", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01216-00317990-00318203": "so it seems that a lot of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01217-00318204-00318587": "responsibilities on the teacher how he", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01218-00318588-00318880": "or she creates a bond with the students", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01219-00318881-00319234": "and how they manage to convey these new", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01220-00319235-00319480": "Concepts and ideas do you think they", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01221-00319481-00319637": "have enough professional development of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01222-00319638-00319782": "opportunities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01223-00319783-00320123": "you mean the teachers yep", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01224-00320124-00320369": "so do they have could you repeat the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01225-00320370-00320554": "question please yeah do you think", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01226-00320555-00320782": "teachers have enough developmental", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01227-00320783-00320932": "opportunities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01228-00320933-00321221": "uh to build themselves up and to be able", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01229-00321222-00321413": "to connect with students in a good way", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01230-00321414-00321689": "to convey these really you know", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01231-00321690-00321977": "complicated ideas of stem and steam", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01232-00321978-00322289": "well definitely yes the whole idea of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01233-00322290-00322504": "the classroom and uh you know the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01234-00322505-00322732": "interactivity of the classroom the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01235-00322733-00322979": "Lively process of launch transition it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01236-00322980-00323260": "implies a lot of opportunity to have a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01237-00323261-00323453": "lot of activities together and somehow", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01238-00323454-00323789": "find those common things that uh find", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01239-00323790-00324023": "people together but again we are we are", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01240-00324024-00324275": "discussing the very um", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01241-00324276-00324606": "it's a very specific topic of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01242-00324607-00324887": "interpersonal relations between people", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01243-00324888-00325223": "because at the end of the day a teacher", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01244-00325224-00325480": "is the person and student is a person it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01245-00325481-00325751": "all depends on you know on their", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01246-00325752-00325877": "personal approach personal personal", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01247-00325878-00326134": "motivation maybe some someone has a bad", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01248-00326135-00326393": "day today maybe maybe the student is not", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01249-00326394-00326554": "going to deal with it I'm talking now", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01250-00326555-00326710": "and for about a very particular", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01251-00326711-00326987": "situation one day in one classroom one", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01252-00326988-00327215": "situation but it all piles up and it", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01253-00327216-00327580": "forms the global effect of this of this", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01254-00327581-00327899": "binding so it's very hard to tell of", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01255-00327900-00328013": "course there are lots of opportunities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01256-00328014-00328289": "to find this part of I'm sure that most", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01257-00328290-00328565": "of you a lot of you", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01258-00328566-00328829": "do have an experience of this special", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01259-00328830-00329021": "bond with their teacher which goes", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01260-00329022-00329375": "through the years and will remain", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01261-00329376-00329530": "of course there are also experiences", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01262-00329531-00329884": "that are not that bright so it's hard to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01263-00329885-00330119": "tell what at the end of the teacher as I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01264-00330120-00330323": "said before including these Educational", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01265-00330324-00330634": "Concepts that we have today discussed is", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01266-00330635-00330841": "to combine those", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01267-00330842-00331127": "those things that cannot be taken for", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01268-00331128-00331282": "granted like interpersonal relations", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01269-00331283-00331547": "with the global goal of introducing the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01270-00331548-00331715": "typologies introducing the creativity", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01271-00331716-00331871": "and all on the things that families", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01272-00331872-00332147": "comes today in order to make it a great", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01273-00332148-00332458": "mix for the for the young personality to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01274-00332459-00332729": "to self-improve in the future and to", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01275-00332730-00333125": "find to find their way in life so yes I", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01276-00333126-00333280": "think they have a lot of opportunities", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01277-00333281-00333395": "to do that", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01278-00333396-00333695": "but it's a very it's a really broad", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01279-00333696-00333941": "topic right yeah I think Victor has", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01280-00333942-00334241": "summed it up quite well", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01281-00334242-00334691": "and I think uh now it's time to end our", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01282-00334692-00334819": "webinar today", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01283-00334820-00335141": "uh before we end uh in case you haven't", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01284-00335142-00335345": "seen the latest scientix episode you can", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01285-00335346-00335603": "find the link in the chat", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01286-00335604-00335830": "you can also click right here on the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01287-00335831-00336167": "slide", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01288-00336168-00336277": "okay", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01289-00336278-00336695": "and as a reminder this the registration", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01290-00336696-00336923": "for the scientific conference are now", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01291-00336924-00336995": "open", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01292-00336996-00337210": "you can find the link for this also on", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01293-00337211-00337589": "the chat", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01294-00337590-00337769": "you can click on this to learn more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01295-00337770-00337943": "about the experience it's one of the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01296-00337944-00338123": "major Science Education networking", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01297-00338124-00338410": "events in Europe so we hope to see some", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01298-00338411-00338608": "of you there", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01299-00338609-00338860": "and finally thank you so much Victor", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01300-00338861-00339137": "for being here with us for uh this was a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01301-00339138-00339473": "very very interesting discussion thank", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01302-00339474-00339754": "you to the teachers for uh being here", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01303-00339755-00340171": "for asking a very fascinating questions", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01304-00340172-00340445": "the recording of This webinar with the", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01305-00340446-00340649": "slides will be available on the stem", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01306-00340650-00340954": "Alliance website in a few days", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01307-00340955-00341206": "we'll also send you a follow email with", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01308-00341207-00341465": "some details thank you again Victor for", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01309-00341466-00341669": "your presentation", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01310-00341670-00341813": "yeah", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01311-00341814-00342082": "I think we'll let you all go for 36. so", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01312-00342083-00342389": "take care thank you very much it was a", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01313-00342390-00342521": "great pleasure and a great honor to be", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01314-00342522-00342725": "with you today and I really hope that we", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01315-00342726-00342960": "will meet in the future and discuss more", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01316-00342961-00343313": "and uh you know I hope our next meeting", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01317-00343314-00343487": "could be even more effective and good", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01318-00343488-00343745": "afternoon yes I hope so yes yes I'm", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01319-00343746-00344051": "looking forward to that goodbye yeah bye", "BL1iE0rF8yy-01320-00344052-00344257": "everyone"}}, {"audio_id": "BLmsmzAguaE", "text": {"BLmsmzAguaE-00000-00000054-00000346": "Dola Metis Brian Greene a is a species", "BLmsmzAguaE-00001-00000347-00000569": "of fishing spiders found in Australia", "BLmsmzAguaE-00002-00000570-00000844": "the species name honors the physicist", "BLmsmzAguaE-00003-00000846-00001124": "Brian Greene"}}, {"audio_id": "BLGOc5-NR-U", "text": {"BLGOc5-NR-U-00000-00000050-00001489": "[Music]", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00001-00001490-00001757": "hello and welcome to episode of the show", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00002-00001757-00001957": "which talks about technologies projects", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00003-00001959-00002167": "and startups and identification in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00004-00002168-00002414": "gourville blockchain revolution my name", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00005-00002415-00002740": "is Brian Fabian crane and I'm a hero", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00006-00002741-00003076": "today we are gonna talk on the topic of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00007-00003077-00003425": "decentralized exchange with will Warren", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00008-00003426-00003740": "and Amir Banda Ali were the cofounders", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00009-00003740-00004163": "of the zero X project zero X zero X", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00010-00004164-00004379": "project had a very successful token say", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00011-00004380-00004709": "last year and followed that successful", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00012-00004710-00005018": "sale with really good releases on their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00013-00005019-00005245": "technology and development of their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00014-00005246-00005549": "community villain Amir welcome to the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00015-00005550-00005861": "show thanks for having us pleasure to be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00016-00005862-00005991": "here", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00017-00005992-00006252": "yeah thank you very excited so I should", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00018-00006253-00006449": "actually also make a disclaimer right", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00019-00006450-00006653": "now because I did participate in this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00020-00006654-00006966": "token sale so I am not unbiased all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00021-00006967-00007370": "right we start disclaimer let's get into", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00022-00007372-00007634": "your background will tell us how you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00023-00007636-00007983": "ended up starting this project yeah", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00024-00007984-00008142": "absolutely", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00025-00008143-00008334": "so I initially became interested in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00026-00008335-00008748": "Bitcoin around 2011 I was in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00027-00008749-00009237": "investment club at UC San Diego I wasn't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00028-00009238-00009468": "you know my background is not in kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00029-00009469-00009669": "investing or anything like that I was", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00030-00009670-00010098": "studying engineering and I think I came", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00031-00010099-00010328": "across an article about Bitcoin on", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00032-00010329-00010671": "Hacker News or something like that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00033-00010672-00010818": "I thought it was interesting technology", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00034-00010819-00011022": "there weren't really any use cases for a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00035-00011023-00011355": "Bitcoin at the time except like Silk", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00036-00011356-00011499": "Road but I thought it was really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00037-00011500-00011658": "interesting technology and kept an eye", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00038-00011659-00012378": "on it my my wife then girlfriend also a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00039-00012379-00012633": "thought Bitcoin was really interesting", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00040-00012634-00013061": "and once coinbase kind of legitimized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00041-00013062-00013440": "the the technology and the use cases by", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00042-00013441-00013881": "partnering with overstock she left you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00043-00013882-00014043": "know New York she was doing finance in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00044-00014044-00014199": "New York she left the joint coinbase", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00045-00014200-00014502": "pretty early on and when she joined", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00046-00014503-00014969": "coinbase you know it I kind of became a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00047-00014971-00015132": "much more interested in cryptocurrency", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00048-00015133-00015422": "and was you know keeping up with it much", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00049-00015424-00015678": "more closely but I was kind of on a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00050-00015679-00015930": "research track I was doing you know I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00051-00015931-00016161": "was kind of planning to do research for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00052-00016162-00016398": "my career either in academia or an", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00053-00016399-00016832": "industry I was I was in grad school", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00054-00016833-00017141": "studying engineering", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00055-00017142-00017592": "but when aetherium came out it struck me", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00056-00017593-00017799": "as like the most important invention", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00057-00017800-00017961": "since the Internet", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00058-00017962-00018306": "and I really quickly lost interest in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00059-00018307-00018705": "everything else and basically decided to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00060-00018706-00018915": "drop out of grad school to focus on a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00061-00018916-00019308": "theory in full time and so when I was", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00062-00019309-00019722": "what I was focusing on back and this was", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00063-00019723-00020064": "back in June of 2016 when I was focusing", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00064-00020065-00020342": "on back then was creating essentially a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00065-00020343-00020763": "standard for tokenized derivatives and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00066-00020764-00021050": "the rationale for that was that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00067-00021051-00021332": "cryptocurrencies are extremely volatile", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00068-00021333-00021660": "assets and it makes it makes", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00069-00021661-00021846": "cryptocurrencies not that useful for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00070-00021847-00022242": "quite a few different use cases and I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00071-00022243-00022493": "felt like you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00072-00022494-00022694": "derivatives would provide the ability to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00073-00022695-00022997": "hedge against this volatility and that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00074-00022998-00023150": "that felt like an important thing to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00075-00023151-00023528": "work on so kind of got pretty far along", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00076-00023529-00023837": "building out that project and that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00077-00023838-00024197": "about the time I met Amir in San", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00078-00024198-00024671": "Francisco and so so we were Amir and I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00079-00024672-00025145": "were focused on kind of you know how do", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00080-00025146-00025358": "we take this technology and bring it to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00081-00025359-00025678": "market and what we realized is that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00082-00025679-00025937": "tokenized derivatives are not very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00083-00025938-00026117": "useful if there's no art to exchange", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00084-00026118-00026480": "them and so this you know Amir and I met", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00085-00026481-00026708": "and we started working together formally", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00086-00026708-00027070": "in October of 2016 and back then you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00087-00027072-00027364": "know ether Delta wasn't a thing no there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00088-00027366-00027595": "were no decentralized exchanges that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00089-00027597-00027802": "people were using at the time you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00090-00027804-00028070": "so we basically decided okay you know if", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00091-00028070-00028244": "no one else is gonna build this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00092-00028245-00028454": "infrastructure no one's gonna you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00093-00028455-00028685": "if no one else is gonna work on this and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00094-00028686-00028838": "you know someone needs to do it so might", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00095-00028839-00029117": "as well be us so I just want to kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00096-00029118-00029444": "ask here so you said when you discover", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00097-00029445-00029795": "the theorem so you knew about big point", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00098-00029795-00029933": "like we were kind of following Bitcoin", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00099-00029933-00030110": "but then when you discover the theorem", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00100-00030111-00030302": "or any human came about you felt like oh", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00101-00030302-00030455": "that was the most important thing since", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00102-00030456-00030739": "the internet like why dad reactions we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00103-00030741-00030975": "hear him", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00104-00030976-00031437": "yeah I think it's because you know I've", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00105-00031438-00031602": "been following Bitcoin for a long time", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00106-00031602-00031842": "you know the technology a completely", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00107-00031843-00032085": "open and globally accessible ledger for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00108-00032086-00032511": "payments is really compelling but you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00109-00032512-00032855": "know this I think this is our own like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00110-00032856-00033297": "you know late 2015 early 2016", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00111-00033298-00033531": "you know Bitcoin was chugging along it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00112-00033532-00033873": "was doing fine doing payments but there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00113-00033874-00034080": "was also a lot of like infighting in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00114-00034081-00034385": "community and you know it seemed like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00115-00034386-00034860": "not much innovation was occurring people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00116-00034861-00035052": "were talking about layer 2 solutions and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00117-00035053-00035355": "stuff like that but you know at the end", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00118-00035356-00035538": "of the day it's really just a network", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00119-00035539-00035694": "for payments which is incredibly", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00120-00035695-00035949": "valuable but you know aetherium you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00121-00035950-00036270": "held the promise for you know basically", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00122-00036271-00036516": "you know an infinite number of different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00123-00036517-00036798": "use cases and it just you know it felt", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00124-00036799-00037132": "like something completely different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00125-00037133-00037446": "yes a little bit about my background to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00126-00037447-00037858": "have a background in trading I was a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00127-00037859-00038215": "traitor for about five years first at a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00128-00038216-00038425": "company called chopper trading in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00129-00038426-00038949": "Chicago and then later drw got into", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00130-00038950-00039544": "Bitcoin I think it was 2014 right around", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00131-00039545-00039829": "the first run-up and initially it was", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00132-00039830-00040072": "mostly from the the trading angle just", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00133-00040073-00040360": "you know watching these crazy price", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00134-00040361-00040639": "moves but I started learning more and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00135-00040640-00040876": "more about the technology became a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00136-00040877-00041185": "pretty big believer in Bitcoin and then", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00137-00041186-00041680": "learned about aetherium in early 2016", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00138-00041681-00041917": "started getting more into the technical", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00139-00041918-00042382": "aspects of things and ended up meeting", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00140-00042383-00042703": "will through a mutual friend and I knew", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00141-00042704-00042970": "he had just recently dropped out to work", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00142-00042971-00043270": "on this derivatives project and decided", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00143-00043271-00043615": "to join will in San Francisco to work on", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00144-00043616-00044032": "that so Amir when I look at your", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00145-00044033-00044248": "LinkedIn profile the the thing that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00146-00044249-00044569": "stands out and jumps out is like your", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00147-00044570-00044860": "educational background is is not in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00148-00044861-00045073": "computer science its finance and then", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00149-00045074-00045373": "you work for five years as a trader yet", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00150-00045374-00045577": "you you are the chief technical officer", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00151-00045578-00046030": "of 0x tell us like did you go through a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00152-00046031-00046498": "phase where you transition like you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00153-00046499-00046729": "changed your field from like traditional", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00154-00046730-00047002": "finance to cryptocurrency but did you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00155-00047003-00047170": "have to spend a lot of time to build a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00156-00047171-00047347": "completely new skill set in order to do", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00157-00047348-00047497": "this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00158-00047498-00047791": "so it wasn't completely new to me I was", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00159-00047792-00047959": "monitoring in computer science in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00160-00047960-00048178": "college also you know I ended up not", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00161-00048179-00048430": "completing the minor because I I just", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00162-00048431-00048760": "got a job and graduated a year early but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00163-00048761-00049012": "yeah I've been kind of coding along the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00164-00049013-00049288": "way did some like data analysis and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00165-00049289-00049593": "stuff like that when when I was trading", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00166-00049594-00049894": "but yeah I had to had to definitely", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00167-00049895-00050254": "build it up over the years I think in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00168-00050255-00050539": "the crypto space there are very few", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00169-00050540-00050893": "experts or at least back then so when I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00170-00050894-00051052": "started learning about it it's kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00171-00051053-00051265": "on a more even playing field with with", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00172-00051266-00051520": "everyone else and I've just been you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00173-00051521-00051763": "know really deeply diving into the text", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00174-00051764-00052279": "and son so super interesting perhaps you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00175-00052279-00052573": "can start with discussing decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00176-00052574-00052873": "exchanges in general tell us what is a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00177-00052874-00053263": "decentralized exchange yeah I like I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00178-00053264-00053500": "think first of all like before we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00179-00053501-00053689": "discuss what is a decentralized exchange", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00180-00053690-00053944": "is probably first important to discuss", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00181-00053945-00054129": "what is a centralized exchange and like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00182-00054130-00054313": "what exactly are the implications of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00183-00054314-00054508": "having an exchange that is centralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00184-00054509-00054775": "and trades cryptocurrencies so a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00185-00054776-00055171": "centralized exchange is you know in some", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00186-00055172-00055471": "ways the backend infrastructure or at", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00187-00055472-00055639": "least the blockchain infrastructure for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00188-00055640-00056086": "a centralized exchange is a massive you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00189-00056087-00056338": "know hot wallet and cold wallet", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00190-00056339-00056587": "so you know all the people that are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00191-00056588-00056863": "trading on this centralized exchange are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00192-00056864-00057100": "depositing their valuable digital assets", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00193-00057101-00057363": "they're basically handing it off to this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00194-00057364-00057613": "team that's operating the centralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00195-00057614-00057942": "exchange and all of this money is being", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00196-00057944-00058147": "all this crypto currencies being pooled", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00197-00058148-00058430": "in one central location you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00198-00058432-00058663": "oftentimes hundreds of millions or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00199-00058664-00058884": "billions of dollars just sitting in one", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00200-00058885-00059367": "address and on top of you know on top of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00201-00059369-00059701": "that kind of blockchain infrastructure", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00202-00059702-00060139": "is you know some some infrastructure for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00203-00060140-00060366": "exchange so when you deposit when you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00204-00060367-00060577": "give your money to this centralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00205-00060578-00060757": "exchange they credit you with some", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00206-00060758-00060878": "virtual cryptocurrency", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00207-00060879-00061117": "see that exists on my database that they", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00208-00061119-00061352": "maintain and that they own and they kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00209-00061353-00061559": "of allow you to exchange those virtual", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00210-00061560-00061865": "units of value with other people that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00211-00061866-00062075": "are also plugged into their centralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00212-00062076-00062566": "database and so you know in the in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00213-00062567-00062828": "brief history of cryptocurrency existing", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00214-00062829-00063077": "at all you know there's just been", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00215-00063078-00063326": "numerous examples of centralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00216-00063327-00063610": "exchanges getting hacked and losing", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00217-00063611-00063812": "hundreds of millions of dollars or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00218-00063813-00064090": "billions of dollars and it just happens", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00219-00064091-00064352": "consistently every six months or more", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00220-00064353-00064874": "frequently even and so I you know now", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00221-00064875-00065029": "getting back to the question of what is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00222-00065030-00065348": "a decentralized exchange you know so a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00223-00065349-00065696": "decentralized exchange you know first of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00224-00065697-00065957": "all it's decentralized in the sense that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00225-00065958-00066254": "custody of the cryptocurrency or the or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00226-00066255-00066578": "the digital assets remains in control of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00227-00066579-00066839": "each kind of individual each peer in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00228-00066840-00067136": "that network so there's no large kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00229-00067137-00067343": "honeypot where all the cryptocurrency is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00230-00067344-00067706": "being cooled and it's also you know a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00231-00067707-00067985": "decentralized exchange is trustless so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00232-00067986-00068273": "you know there's a variety of different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00233-00068274-00068429": "kind of architectures for how a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00234-00068430-00068627": "decentralized exchange can can be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00235-00068628-00068891": "designed but you know generally across", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00236-00068892-00069086": "the board a good decentralized exchange", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00237-00069087-00069368": "allows you to remain in custody of your", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00238-00069369-00069611": "cryptocurrency and you do not have to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00239-00069612-00069866": "trust anyone to you know knock it hacks", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00240-00069867-00070279": "not run off with your money and so forth", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00241-00070280-00070625": "so so the custody aspect is one but you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00242-00070626-00070907": "also think it's an essential part of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00243-00070908-00071246": "decentralized exchange that you you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00244-00071247-00071576": "don't have to trust anybody that it's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00245-00071577-00071870": "fair you know that I actually get kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00246-00071871-00072152": "of the best deal compared to other", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00247-00072153-00072623": "people yeah so I so your song is kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00248-00072624-00072977": "like you're asking like is transparency", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00249-00072978-00073312": "around kind of price time priority or is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00250-00073313-00073556": "transparency around trade execution kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00251-00073557-00073961": "of a piece of that system", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00252-00073962-00074180": "transparency and fairness right so so I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00253-00074181-00074360": "mean one thing is okay I know nobody can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00254-00074361-00074531": "steal my phones but another thing is I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00255-00074532-00074747": "know that there's no central party that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00256-00074748-00075023": "can for example you know match my orders", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00257-00075024-00075230": "suboptimal a to their advantage is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00258-00075231-00075447": "something like that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00259-00075448-00075780": "I would say that's like I'd say that's I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00260-00075781-00075984": "mean it's super important I would say", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00261-00075985-00076187": "that that's probably secondary to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00262-00076188-00076440": "catastrophic failure right so like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00263-00076441-00076665": "what's the first thing I want to work", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00264-00076666-00076821": "you know what what's the first problem I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00265-00076822-00077069": "want to solve well I don't want someone", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00266-00077070-00077306": "to you know steal all my money", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00267-00077307-00077505": "I don't want catastrophic failure you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00268-00077506-00077697": "know once that box is checked it's like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00269-00077698-00077912": "okay well now that I'm not worried", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00270-00077913-00078216": "someone's gonna steal all my money you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00271-00078217-00078372": "know how do I ensure that when I am", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00272-00078373-00078600": "trading I'm getting a decent deal and I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00273-00078601-00078800": "think that that's also you know it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00274-00078801-00079007": "really depends on the architecture of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00275-00079008-00079244": "the decentralized exchange and I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00276-00079245-00079688": "it's extremely important obviously so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00277-00079689-00080148": "yeah I mean I guess you know maybe you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00278-00080149-00080322": "know are you saying is that kind of like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00279-00080323-00080535": "a requirement for an exchange a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00280-00080536-00080715": "decentralized exchange to be considered", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00281-00080716-00081036": "trustless yeah I think you kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00282-00081037-00081243": "answered the question right in putting", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00283-00081244-00081632": "these in an order of priorities so I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00284-00081633-00081805": "think that makes perfect sense", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00285-00081806-00082157": "I'm curious did you guys I guess you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00286-00082158-00082325": "guys anticipated because we have seen", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00287-00082326-00082505": "just huge exposure no an interest in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00288-00082506-00082665": "decentralized exchanges over the last", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00289-00082666-00083081": "years did you guys see post EE that this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00290-00083082-00083201": "was going to happen and what do you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00291-00083202-00083456": "think are the main reasons why this has", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00292-00083457-00083663": "occurred", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00293-00083664-00083843": "I definitely did not foresee this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00294-00083844-00084215": "explosion happening this quickly I mean", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00295-00084216-00084626": "it was always our thesis that this would", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00296-00084627-00084779": "happen and that there would be a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00297-00084780-00085114": "thousands potentially millions of tokens", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00298-00085115-00085634": "you know on various block chains why has", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00299-00085635-00085879": "it happened I mean it seems like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00300-00085880-00086189": "institutions and just the the general", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00301-00086190-00086354": "public has started to become aware of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00302-00086355-00086579": "cryptocurrencies I think most people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00303-00086580-00086984": "recognize that the impact it will have", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00304-00086985-00087299": "is just just massive it's it's not a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00305-00087300-00087521": "question of if it will have an impact", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00306-00087522-00087692": "it's kind of a question of when it will", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00307-00087693-00087944": "have an impact so yeah there's mass", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00308-00087945-00088343": "speculation on that front right now so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00309-00088344-00088571": "if I scan across the decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00310-00088572-00088970": "exchange space there's lots of different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00311-00088971-00089381": "projects right so there's there's ether", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00312-00089382-00089687": "Delta which is probably first that that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00313-00089688-00089780": "came online", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00314-00089781-00090380": "there's idec's there's air swap and of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00315-00090381-00090791": "course there's 0x in addition to that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00316-00090792-00090977": "there are these like there are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00317-00090978-00091231": "theoretical proposals for cross chain", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00318-00091232-00091679": "mechanisms like walk us through the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00319-00091680-00091964": "different architectures that are being", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00320-00091965-00092357": "pioneered by these projects and what", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00321-00092358-00092597": "does the design space of decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00322-00092598-00092903": "exchanges as a whole look like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00323-00092904-00093112": "a lot you know a lot of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00324-00093113-00093331": "decentralized exchanges that we're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00325-00093332-00093596": "seeing today or that you know already", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00326-00093597-00093975": "exist are there kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00327-00093976-00094094": "they're kind of like for-profit", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00328-00094095-00094371": "operations that are owned by a small", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00329-00094372-00094785": "group of people that you know kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00330-00094786-00095196": "set up this this system that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00331-00095197-00095393": "they bring people into and they can kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00332-00095394-00095738": "of extract rent they can charge fees so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00333-00095739-00095931": "yeah back when Amir and I got together", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00334-00095932-00096143": "in October of 2016", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00335-00096144-00096597": "you know our original plan was you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00336-00096598-00096903": "let's create a for-profit decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00337-00096904-00097167": "exchange that we own and that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00338-00097168-00097365": "all the fees that we charge we get to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00339-00097366-00097600": "you know feed into our you know our", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00340-00097601-00097925": "corporation or whatever it might be and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00341-00097926-00098187": "you know we were working on it but the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00342-00098188-00098432": "longer you know the longer we were in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00343-00098433-00098625": "the etherium community and the you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00344-00098626-00098801": "the more that we talked with various", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00345-00098802-00099125": "projects in the space you know the more", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00346-00099126-00099551": "apparent it became that what the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00347-00099552-00099731": "community and what the ecosystem really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00348-00099732-00100266": "needs isn't a kind of walled garden you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00349-00100267-00100436": "know there's all of these different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00350-00100437-00100698": "decentralized accept applications that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00351-00100699-00101004": "require exchange functionality so things", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00352-00101005-00101282": "like prediction markets decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00353-00101283-00101598": "fund management platforms like stable", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00354-00101599-00101894": "coins and a variety of others as well", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00355-00101895-00102153": "and you know so we would meet with the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00356-00102154-00102303": "different projects that are building", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00357-00102304-00102530": "these things and discuss with them and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00358-00102531-00102869": "they all need exchange functionality and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00359-00102870-00103098": "so you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00360-00103099-00103377": "what we kind of came to realize is that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00361-00103378-00103604": "rather than having each one of these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00362-00103605-00103984": "projects create their own walled garden", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00363-00103985-00104271": "their own kind of custom and proprietary", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00364-00104272-00104534": "smart contracts for exchange you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00365-00104535-00104642": "what there really needs to be is a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00366-00104643-00104853": "public piece of infrastructure for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00367-00104854-00105129": "decentralized exchange that any DAP can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00368-00105130-00105389": "hook into that's completely free to use", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00369-00105390-00105801": "and that's you know you know completely", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00370-00105802-00106215": "open and globally accessible and and so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00371-00106216-00106371": "that was like I think that was like a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00372-00106372-00106629": "huge realization for us is that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00373-00106630-00106806": "maybe instead of focusing on building", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00374-00106807-00107135": "something that you know we want and that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00375-00107136-00107354": "will like make a you know allow us to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00376-00107355-00107544": "kind of generate a revenue stream maybe", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00377-00107545-00107763": "we just like build something that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00378-00107764-00107964": "everyone can use and that benefits", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00379-00107965-00108156": "everyone and maybe you know we don't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00380-00108157-00108450": "need to have a business model attached", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00381-00108451-00109032": "to it so you know that's kind of you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00382-00109033-00109197": "know I think it's important to like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00383-00109198-00109497": "bring that up prior to jumping into like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00384-00109498-00109679": "the different decentralized exchanges", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00385-00109680-00109968": "that exist and their architectures I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00386-00109969-00110148": "think it's important you know one of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00387-00110149-00110427": "things that really makes 0x unique is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00388-00110428-00110816": "that it is a protocol it's public", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00389-00110817-00111083": "infrastructure anyone can build their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00390-00111084-00111372": "own for-profit business on top of it so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00391-00111373-00111485": "they can anyone can create a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00392-00111486-00111713": "decentralized exchange and charge fees", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00393-00111714-00112166": "and you know I think that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00394-00112167-00112641": "we'll see a big shift towards this model", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00395-00112642-00112903": "compared to you know things like ether", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00396-00112904-00113189": "Delta were you know they're they're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00397-00113190-00113351": "really you know when when ether Delta", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00398-00113352-00113522": "was the only game in town really wasn't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00399-00113523-00113765": "much competition around fees and user", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00400-00113766-00114041": "experience and yeah I think we're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00401-00114042-00114178": "starting to see that now which is really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00402-00114179-00114516": "a good thing for everyone", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00403-00114517-00114798": "so you talked about this kind of shift", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00404-00114799-00115133": "to thinking of 0x more as this base", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00405-00115134-00115323": "layer infrastructure that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00406-00115324-00115491": "wouldn't be owned by you guys this is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00407-00115492-00115953": "also driven in part by the this coming", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00408-00115954-00116241": "of icos and of basically funding to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00409-00116242-00116433": "tokens and creating communities that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00410-00116433-00116691": "that shape kind of you development in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00411-00116692-00116985": "that direction", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00412-00116986-00117574": "actually not really so we so we were we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00413-00117575-00117901": "were pretty much set that building an", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00414-00117902-00118168": "open protocol was the way for us to go", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00415-00118169-00118675": "around January of 2017 it just seemed", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00416-00118676-00118915": "like it would add the most value for the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00417-00118916-00119296": "most people and but back then like that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00418-00119297-00119586": "was way before the ICO craze had really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00419-00119588-00119875": "taken off you know I think like the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00420-00119876-00120144": "biggest token sale at that time was like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00421-00120145-00120352": "Gollum and they raised like eight", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00422-00120353-00120564": "million dollars or something like that I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00423-00120565-00120865": "think like one of the one of the things", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00424-00120866-00121092": "that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00425-00121093-00121490": "the ico craze kind of embraced is that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00426-00121491-00121788": "projects raise a bunch of money pre", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00427-00121789-00122190": "product but that was like you know that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00428-00122191-00122307": "was definitely not something we were", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00429-00122308-00122631": "interested in doing so you know back", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00430-00122632-00122984": "back in March of 2017 when when we kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00431-00122985-00123192": "of decided that we wanted to build this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00432-00123193-00123666": "open protocol you know we raised a small", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00433-00123667-00123867": "seed round it was led by poly chain", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00434-00123868-00124167": "capital it was just enough money to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00435-00124168-00124379": "cover our legal fees to hire a couple", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00436-00124380-00124731": "people and and enough to kind of get us", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00437-00124732-00124929": "to the point where we had a fully", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00438-00124930-00125161": "functional product that people could use", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00439-00125163-00125415": "you know in the following months that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00440-00125416-00125652": "when we really saw the ICO craze start", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00441-00125653-00125879": "to gain you know kind of take off and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00442-00125880-00126371": "all being yeah it was just insane but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00443-00126372-00126761": "yeah I don't think that our decision to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00444-00126763-00127020": "create an open protocol was at all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00445-00127021-00127551": "driven by the kind of ridiculous amounts", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00446-00127552-00127685": "of money flying around and the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00447-00127686-00127916": "irrationality of speculators like that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00448-00127917-00128064": "was that's actually something that like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00449-00128065-00128220": "we very whom we very much want to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00450-00128221-00128406": "distance ourselves from because I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00451-00128407-00128670": "that's like kind of a toxic culture and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00452-00128671-00128940": "we don't want that yeah I don't know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00453-00128941-00129039": "does that answer your question", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00454-00129040-00129426": "yeah sure I mean I I think you can you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00455-00129427-00129597": "can look at Isis in several ways but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00456-00129598-00129929": "just as one as you know having all these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00457-00129930-00130154": "aspects you mentioned but the other one", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00458-00130155-00130341": "of course also this enormous power in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00459-00130342-00130533": "building a community in its center us in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00460-00130533-00130896": "people and all that and and do be honest", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00461-00130897-00131250": "you know when when 0x when you guys take", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00462-00131251-00131427": "your token sale I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00463-00131428-00131910": "I actually put in money really I didn't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00464-00131911-00132171": "actually look very deeply at 0x as a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00465-00132172-00132411": "technology but I really like how you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00466-00132412-00132666": "approached open cell which was also very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00467-00132667-00132873": "novel and very different and I felt", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00468-00132874-00133047": "there was a lot of issues in how talk", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00469-00133048-00133245": "themselves were happening at the time so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00470-00133246-00133458": "we had these crazy things like for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00471-00133459-00133800": "example brave they did the bat token", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00472-00133801-00134058": "right so the idea is this is browser", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00473-00134059-00134304": "that hopefully you know billions of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00474-00134305-00134477": "people will use I guess that's our plan", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00475-00134478-00134699": "you have this token that can then be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00476-00134700-00135064": "used to to kind of pay for you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00477-00135065-00135260": "advertisement and pay for tension and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00478-00135261-00135554": "stuff like that but then they had their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00479-00135555-00135851": "token sale sell out in three blocks", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00480-00135852-00136142": "three hearing blocks about half a minute", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00481-00136143-00136505": "or a bit more and there was some I don't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00482-00136506-00136685": "know a hundred people or some tiny", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00483-00136686-00136847": "number of people basically bought the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00484-00136848-00137102": "entire tokens oh so you also have these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00485-00137103-00137515": "perverse distributions and it totally", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00486-00137516-00137836": "contrary to I think the idea of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00487-00137837-00138098": "decentralized technology we have also", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00488-00138099-00138335": "control that she centralized and it's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00489-00138336-00138521": "owned by community if in the end it's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00490-00138522-00138860": "really a bunch of sort of you know all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00491-00138861-00139226": "the guards that control it so I really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00492-00139227-00139358": "liked how you guys went in a very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00493-00139359-00139613": "different direction with the token sale", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00494-00139614-00139997": "and you know I have hell that was great", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00495-00139998-00140345": "yeah why distribution was super", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00496-00140346-00140642": "important to us you know 0x protocol is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00497-00140643-00140999": "a platform and it's nothing without", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00498-00141000-00141356": "people building on it so we wanted there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00499-00141357-00141580": "to be as many stakeholders as possible", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00500-00141581-00141839": "and I think it's it's really worked out", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00501-00141840-00142112": "in our favor I think that's a big part", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00502-00142113-00142274": "of the reason why there are so many", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00503-00142275-00142490": "people developing on 0x right now and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00504-00142491-00142741": "why we have such a great community of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00505-00142742-00143102": "course the other nice part about tokens", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00506-00143103-00143488": "is as you mentioned as we'll mentioned", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00507-00143489-00143927": "that 0x is not trying to be a central", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00508-00143928-00144356": "player that extracts rents out of each", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00509-00144357-00144761": "trade that is happening on using the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00510-00144762-00145016": "using the technology essentially right", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00511-00145017-00145427": "so it is basically a set of smart", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00512-00145428-00145670": "contracts and protocols and ways to do", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00513-00145671-00145724": "things", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00514-00145725-00146237": "ways to do exchanges that other parties", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00515-00146238-00146474": "can use in order to build their own", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00516-00146475-00147032": "systems and at some level we might argue", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00517-00147033-00147272": "that 0x is solving a public goods", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00518-00147273-00147665": "problem right so a decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00519-00147666-00147944": "exchange a generalized protocol for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00520-00147945-00148124": "decentralized exchange on ethereum is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00521-00148125-00148417": "valuable yet", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00522-00148418-00148621": "if there isn't a very obvious", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00523-00148622-00148987": "rent-seeking mechanism in the in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00524-00148988-00149257": "protocol itself then who exactly would", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00525-00149258-00149626": "build it and from that perspective the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00526-00149627-00150094": "ico model at least the past year and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00527-00150095-00150331": "this year seems to work well to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00528-00150332-00150738": "bootstrap these these projects", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00529-00150739-00150975": "so that's sort of my opinion like like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00530-00150976-00151185": "that's that's I think the strength of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00531-00151186-00151395": "the ico model that these people are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00532-00151396-00151701": "willing to put money to fund public", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00533-00151702-00152213": "goods development without necessarily", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00534-00152214-00152622": "the expectation of like revenue flowing", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00535-00152623-00153060": "in to to the token itself but perhaps", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00536-00153061-00153228": "we're jumping a little ahead of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00537-00153229-00153561": "ourselves and should really talk about", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00538-00153562-00154154": "what 0x is so we'll tell us what exactly", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00539-00154155-00154654": "is 0x in the in the nuts and bolts of it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00540-00154655-00155079": "at its core 0x protocol is a a message", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00541-00155080-00155404": "format so a way of kind of specifying", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00542-00155405-00155891": "your intent to enter into a trade and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00543-00155892-00156199": "you know so you can think of this large", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00544-00156200-00156451": "chunk of data that consists of different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00545-00156452-00156763": "parameters such as the different tote", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00546-00156764-00157003": "the different tokens that need you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00547-00157004-00157261": "you would like to exchange the exchange", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00548-00157262-00157575": "rate and of how long you're willing to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00549-00157576-00158068": "honor that commitment to trade you can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00550-00158069-00158356": "specify whether or not you want to enter", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00551-00158357-00158487": "into a trade with a specific", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00552-00158488-00158791": "counterparty or you can leave your kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00553-00158792-00159219": "of order open to be filled by anyone and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00554-00159220-00159472": "so this you know the message format", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00555-00159473-00159793": "basically specifies how do you create an", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00556-00159794-00160057": "order and arrange that data into a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00557-00160058-00160468": "packet and and so that everyone can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00558-00160469-00160699": "interpret it and know exactly what it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00559-00160700-00161304": "means you know and the second component", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00560-00161305-00161701": "of 0x protocol is a system of smart", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00561-00161702-00161956": "contracts that exists on the etherion", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00562-00161957-00162164": "blockchain", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00563-00162165-00162716": "and this system of smart contracts is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00564-00162717-00163015": "broken into a couple different modules", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00565-00163016-00163451": "the first module is a smart contract", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00566-00163452-00163688": "that accepts these packets of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00567-00163689-00164039": "cryptographically signed data processes", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00568-00164040-00164513": "them and you know allows trades to be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00569-00164514-00165023": "settled on the blockchain and you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00570-00165024-00165415": "that that module is responsible for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00571-00165416-00165656": "authenticating signature cryptographic", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00572-00165657-00165965": "signatures making sure that both parties", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00573-00165966-00166223": "have sufficient funds to actually settle", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00574-00166224-00166520": "the trade insuring that an order hasn't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00575-00166521-00166739": "already been filled or that you know it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00576-00166740-00167120": "is expired so it's kind of the core", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00577-00167121-00167462": "business logic for settling trades the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00578-00167463-00167848": "second module is a governance module and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00579-00167849-00168430": "the governance module allows the the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00580-00168431-00168677": "exchange and of the trade settlement", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00581-00168678-00169039": "module to be upgraded over time I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00582-00169040-00169376": "it's kind of early right now there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00583-00169377-00169547": "aren't very many decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00584-00169548-00169760": "applications that have existed for very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00585-00169761-00170009": "long so it you know I think a lot of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00586-00170010-00170336": "people it this the the need to upgrade a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00587-00170337-00170582": "system of smart contracts doesn't really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00588-00170583-00170993": "hit home for many people but I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00589-00170994-00171254": "it's extremely important that this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00590-00171255-00171467": "system of smart contracts that all of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00591-00171468-00171614": "this infrastructure is being built", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00592-00171615-00171785": "around and that all of these smart", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00593-00171786-00171968": "contracts and businesses are plugging", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00594-00171969-00172319": "into can be upgraded without bringing", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00595-00172320-00172790": "all of the markets to a halt and by", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00596-00172791-00172988": "reducing the friction associated with", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00597-00172989-00173204": "migrating to a new version of that that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00598-00173205-00173528": "exchange logic over time and you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00599-00173529-00173744": "just for an example like I think ether", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00600-00173745-00173972": "Delta is probably like the best example", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00601-00173973-00174224": "it's you know ether Delta is a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00602-00174225-00174479": "decentralized exchange kind of owned by", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00603-00174480-00174881": "one one person it's been operating for a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00604-00174882-00175099": "while now probably one of the longest", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00605-00175100-00175321": "the DAPs it's been around", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00606-00175322-00175632": "the longest an ether Delta you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00607-00175633-00175885": "ether Delta had to upgrade their smart", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00608-00175886-00176251": "contracts four times though there are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00609-00176252-00176419": "you know there's ether Delta versions", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00610-00176420-00176836": "one through five and I think that's and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00611-00176837-00177082": "that's not a knock on it I think you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00612-00177083-00177428": "know that just tells you that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00613-00177429-00177702": "it's important to upgrade smart", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00614-00177703-00177919": "contracts the technology stack that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00615-00177920-00178102": "we're building on top of is rapidly", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00616-00178103-00178426": "evolving and there are it's unavoidable", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00617-00178427-00178633": "that we're going to need to upgrade", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00618-00178634-00178866": "these smart contracts over time some new", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00619-00178867-00179275": "token standards come out etc but you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00620-00179276-00179514": "know with ether Delta", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00621-00179515-00179709": "every single time there was an upgrade", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00622-00179710-00179964": "you know it was one person that was", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00623-00179965-00180291": "making that decision everyone that was", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00624-00180292-00180486": "using the old smart contract would have", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00625-00180487-00180753": "to kind of withdraw their funds then", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00626-00180754-00181098": "deposit into a brand new smart contract", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00627-00181099-00181275": "if they were responsible they would", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00628-00181276-00181494": "probably want to see a security audit", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00629-00181495-00181734": "report of the new smart contract to make", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00630-00181735-00181988": "sure that it does what it's advertised", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00631-00181989-00182240": "to do I think people just kind of accept", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00632-00182241-00182513": "it you know the person that created the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00633-00182514-00182712": "contracts was not going to steal their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00634-00182713-00183171": "money but that's like a very disruptive", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00635-00183172-00183624": "process and you know so the way that 0x", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00636-00183625-00183861": "protocol is designed yeah you know we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00637-00183862-00184062": "have this logic for settling trades we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00638-00184063-00184287": "have this logic for upgrading the system", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00639-00184288-00184529": "over time as new token standards emerge", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00640-00184530-00184959": "etc and it allows us to upgrade the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00641-00184960-00185232": "system without requiring users to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00642-00185233-00185579": "migrate without making all of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00643-00185580-00185886": "markets stop functioning and you know I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00644-00185887-00186084": "think ultimately like that'll be a model", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00645-00186085-00186288": "that we see much more frequently going", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00646-00186289-00186636": "forward you mentioned governance before", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00647-00186637-00186846": "as one of the core modules and now we've", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00648-00186847-00187064": "been talking about upgrading so is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00649-00187065-00187352": "governance the way to upgrade the system", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00650-00187353-00187628": "and both now and is that what you see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00651-00187629-00187899": "the role in the future", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00652-00187900-00188214": "yeah I mean absolutely it's kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00653-00188215-00188266": "crazy", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00654-00188267-00188787": "just the between when we did our token", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00655-00188788-00189103": "sale and now the crazy amount of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00656-00189104-00189329": "developer interests that we've seen like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00657-00189330-00189545": "we I don't think Amir or I were really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00658-00189546-00189890": "expecting yeah I think we thought we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00659-00189891-00190056": "would have to really kind of go out and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00660-00190057-00190236": "convince people to build on top of Xerox", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00661-00190237-00190427": "protocol but we've kind of seen this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00662-00190428-00190602": "explosion of interest in development", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00663-00190603-00190814": "activity and it's really exciting but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00664-00190815-00191102": "it's also a lot of responsibility", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00665-00191103-00191469": "because at the end of the day all of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00666-00191470-00191799": "these people have kind of changed their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00667-00191800-00192073": "career trajectories", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00668-00192074-00192420": "and now they're you know their career is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00669-00192421-00192799": "building this business on top of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00670-00192800-00193057": "infrastructure that you know we're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00671-00193058-00193513": "building and that's you know if I were", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00672-00193514-00193789": "them I would be kind of terrified if you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00673-00193790-00194068": "know it was if we had a hundred percent", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00674-00194069-00194287": "power to make all the decisions about", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00675-00194288-00194785": "how the protocol should change you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00676-00194786-00195073": "so I think one of the the reasons why", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00677-00195074-00195295": "all of these different real ayres these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00678-00195296-00195457": "decentralized exchanges that are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00679-00195458-00195646": "building on top of Xerox I think one of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00680-00195647-00195958": "the reasons why they took that risk is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00681-00195959-00196168": "because we've been very clear from the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00682-00196169-00196381": "beginning that this is public", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00683-00196382-00196641": "infrastructure it's owned by the public", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00684-00196642-00196870": "and the people that are actually using", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00685-00196871-00197020": "this system the people that are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00686-00197021-00197194": "stakeholders they're the ones that are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00687-00197195-00197470": "going to drive the governance process", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00688-00197471-00197688": "and make the technology evolved over", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00689-00197689-00198098": "time not not Amir and I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00690-00198099-00198545": "too much responsibility for a small", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00691-00198546-00198698": "group of people it needs to be the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00692-00198699-00198914": "entire ecosystem that drives the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00693-00198915-00199166": "governance", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00694-00199167-00199379": "parrot to sort of aetherium so in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00695-00199380-00199667": "aetherium itself is being upgraded and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00696-00199668-00200060": "there's this e is it helium improvements", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00697-00200061-00200615": "process which is basically a set of new", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00698-00200616-00201170": "standards and and like potential commits", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00699-00201171-00201523": "that are discussed over over github and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00700-00201524-00202190": "once the community which probably is a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00701-00202191-00202388": "quorum of people that are involved in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00702-00202389-00202571": "serum development are comfortable with", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00703-00202572-00202997": "it get included into the next upgrade", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00704-00202998-00203612": "how will a future 0x how will this look", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00705-00203613-00203933": "different in the future for 0x what", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00706-00203934-00204275": "changes from the way aetherium", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00707-00204276-00204713": "improvements are done today", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00708-00204714-00204971": "right now the the process is very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00709-00204971-00205069": "similar to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00710-00205071-00205342": "etherium but in the future there will be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00711-00205344-00205666": "some form of token voting you know where", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00712-00205667-00205877": "your bow is weighted on that amount of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00713-00205878-00206330": "tokens you own and I think the reason", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00714-00206331-00206660": "this works better specifically for 0", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00715-00206661-00206962": "lakhs then then a theorem like process", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00716-00206963-00207296": "kind of kind of goes back to the reason", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00717-00207296-00207563": "we made 0x in the first place", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00718-00207564-00207905": "so the decentralized exchange ecosystem", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00719-00207906-00208058": "was very fragmented there all these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00720-00208059-00208409": "different siloed exchanges and it's it's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00721-00208410-00208712": "more important that we have you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00722-00208713-00209119": "sort of a way of soft working on chain", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00723-00209119-00209450": "using our governance to keep everyone on", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00724-00209451-00209923": "the same shared protocol if we you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00725-00209925-00210182": "we're just like pushing out upgrades in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00726-00210183-00210485": "in a centralized way and people are like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00727-00210486-00210836": "deciding to stay on the hold version or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00728-00210837-00211088": "whatever you kind of just end up back to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00729-00211089-00211298": "square one where you just have this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00730-00211298-00211463": "fragmented decentralized exchange", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00731-00211464-00211948": "environment so on the topic of token", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00732-00211950-00212132": "booting right so essentially you have", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00733-00212133-00212492": "this 0x token and the way we could", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00734-00212492-00212881": "imagine it is in the future let's say", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00735-00212882-00213171": "you have right now let's it's version", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00736-00213173-00213583": "0.8.0 and in your team develops version", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00737-00213584-00213890": "0.9.0 it might be some other team that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00738-00213891-00214141": "develops that version as well and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00739-00214142-00214696": "there's a proposal to accept 0.9 point", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00740-00214698-00215167": "OS the canonical version of it and we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00741-00215167-00215428": "say that we're gonna have a vote of all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00742-00215429-00215835": "of these 0x token holders and provided a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00743-00215836-00215989": "sufficient quorum and majority is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00744-00215990-00216312": "reached then the upgrade will take place", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00745-00216313-00216679": "my question with a mechanism like that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00746-00216680-00217281": "is does this process actually enable the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00747-00217282-00217564": "best people to have their voice heard so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00748-00217565-00217782": "let's think of it like this so you have", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00749-00217783-00218109": "a min Geun sealer steam ad at Cornell", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00750-00218110-00218467": "right now that team might have very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00751-00218467-00218752": "talented PhD students and these PhD", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00752-00218753-00218967": "students might be of the kind that can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00753-00218969-00219219": "actually analyze a protocol upgrade for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00754-00219221-00219753": "its security for its challenges but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00755-00219754-00220023": "if you know the American PhD student you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00756-00220023-00220223": "pretty much know that American phd's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00757-00220225-00220787": "don't get paid a lot in stipend right so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00758-00220788-00221063": "you cannot expect people like like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00759-00221064-00221331": "constituents like this to actually hold", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00760-00221332-00221717": "a lot of 0x tokens and therefore these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00761-00221719-00221955": "people will not have a lot of voice in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00762-00221956-00222198": "that governance process yet they might", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00763-00222198-00222450": "be the ideal people to actually vote in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00764-00222451-00222898": "the process how do you resolve this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00765-00222900-00223142": "problem or do you even seek to resolve", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00766-00223144-00223291": "it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00767-00223292-00223676": "yeah so I think you've identified that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00768-00223677-00223894": "you know not just decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00769-00223896-00224192": "governance but real-world governance is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00770-00224192-00224561": "an extremely challenging problem you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00771-00224562-00224842": "know specifically to your point around", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00772-00224844-00225217": "are the right people government you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00773-00225219-00225500": "are they the right people driving the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00774-00225501-00225809": "governance process that is yeah it's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00775-00225810-00225973": "absolutely something we're thinking", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00776-00225975-00226298": "about so yeah just to provide a little", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00777-00226298-00226496": "background right right now we're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00778-00226496-00226964": "collaborating with the Aragon team and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00779-00226965-00227108": "they're a really interesting project", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00780-00227109-00227473": "they're you know creating a general tool", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00781-00227475-00227696": "set and framework for decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00782-00227696-00228005": "governance systems kind of plug-and-play", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00783-00228006-00228323": "building blocks and one of the things", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00784-00228323-00228592": "that were collaborating with them on is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00785-00228594-00228950": "research into this concept of liquid", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00786-00228951-00229304": "democracy and the way liquid democracy", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00787-00229305-00229588": "works is that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00788-00229589-00230046": "the people that that stakeholders in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00789-00230048-00230346": "ecosystem can delegate their voting", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00790-00230348-00230921": "power to someone that they deem you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00791-00230923-00231519": "capable to vote on their behalf so you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00792-00231521-00231744": "know this is I don't want to like I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00793-00231746-00231946": "definitely don't want to claim that like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00794-00231946-00232303": "liquid democracy is the way and it's the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00795-00232304-00232521": "best decentralized governance approach", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00796-00232523-00232744": "but I think it's an interesting step", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00797-00232744-00233146": "from fully fully centralized towards", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00798-00233146-00233508": "more decentralized and it allows the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00799-00233509-00234280": "people that you know have expertise and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00800-00234281-00234517": "that are comfortable voicing their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00801-00234517-00235030": "opinions to kind of have voting power", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00802-00235031-00235204": "within the system without necessarily", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00803-00235205-00235537": "having financial resources at their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00804-00235538-00235963": "disposal and yeah I I think it's one one", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00805-00235964-00236217": "interesting approach that we're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00806-00236219-00236364": "considering right now", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00807-00236365-00236617": "cool yeah I mean I agree I think that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00808-00236617-00236776": "that's good that's gonna be one of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00809-00236777-00236944": "very exciting things about blockchain is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00810-00236944-00237139": "because it will necessitate all this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00811-00237140-00237451": "innovation around dissenters Conan's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00812-00237452-00237703": "decision-making of course they are also", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00813-00237704-00238015": "very revolutionary things online like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00814-00238016-00238261": "using prediction markets and future key", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00815-00238262-00238414": "to do things like that maybe that will", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00816-00238415-00238594": "also work", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00817-00238594-00238858": "so we talked we started talking about", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00818-00238859-00239173": "how 0x works and what kind of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00819-00239173-00239362": "architecture looks like so you talked", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00820-00239363-00239608": "about how people can basically send", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00821-00239609-00239809": "these messages right with orders and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00822-00239810-00239971": "then you have a set of small contracts", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00823-00239971-00240280": "allows those traits to be executed and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00824-00240281-00240619": "settled on a blockchain but there's also", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00825-00240619-00240894": "in 0x buy the whole you know different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00826-00240896-00241189": "kind of ecosystem participants that have", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00827-00241190-00241435": "roles in that and in particular there's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00828-00241436-00241684": "that role of a relayer can you explain", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00829-00241685-00241951": "what we layer is and what their function", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00830-00241952-00242287": "is in 0x", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00831-00242288-00242779": "yeah so a real ayres job is essentially", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00832-00242780-00243085": "to host an order book and broadcast that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00833-00243086-00243454": "order book to the public or in any way", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00834-00243455-00243792": "that they see fit since all of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00835-00243794-00244138": "orders and 0ax are stored off chain this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00836-00244139-00244453": "is a requirement in order for people to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00837-00244454-00244675": "actually you know find counterparties to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00838-00244676-00245191": "their trades I think initially the first", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00839-00245192-00245392": "decentralized exchanges were largely", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00840-00245392-00245671": "using on chain order books which means", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00841-00245671-00245932": "that people are paying transaction fees", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00842-00245933-00246190": "whenever they even place an order and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00843-00246191-00246379": "value is not necessarily being", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00844-00246380-00246682": "transferred and this is just not", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00845-00246683-00247071": "sustainable in the long term but yeah by", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00846-00247073-00247371": "having an often order book you can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00847-00247373-00247675": "drastically decrease the cost of trading", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00848-00247676-00247936": "but you do need some mechanism to find a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00849-00247937-00248113": "counterparty and that's that's kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00850-00248114-00248335": "the real layers job and and they earn", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00851-00248336-00248806": "fees for doing that so what is the trust", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00852-00248807-00249136": "model between a pair of users wanting to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00853-00249137-00249451": "exchange using 0x and a literally layer", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00854-00249452-00249781": "so I might be the buyer of maker for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00855-00249782-00249969": "either buying might with the seller and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00856-00249969-00250339": "well might be the real layer what are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00857-00250340-00250617": "the kinds of trust we are putting on", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00858-00250619-00250881": "drill on will", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00859-00250882-00251094": "just to preface this a little bit there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00860-00251095-00251392": "are various strategies real layers could", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00861-00251392-00251791": "use with varying degrees of trust I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00862-00251792-00252024": "would say the most basic strategy would", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00863-00252025-00252354": "be just a more open order book model", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00864-00252355-00252538": "kind of similar to either Delta I'm", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00865-00252539-00252831": "broadcasting my order book to public", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00866-00252832-00253080": "anyone can see an order and fill that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00867-00253081-00253326": "through their own aetherium node that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00868-00253327-00253650": "probably the most trust list model you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00869-00253651-00254021": "know relayer can't really do anything to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00870-00254022-00254341": "steal money or anything like that I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00871-00254342-00254592": "think the worst that you probably do is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00872-00254594-00255000": "hide orders but I don't see why that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00873-00255001-00255294": "would be in their best interest there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00874-00255295-00255469": "are other models that involve a little", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00875-00255469-00255567": "bit more trust", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00876-00255569-00255790": "for example the relayer can act as a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00877-00255791-00256095": "central matching engine and then", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00878-00256096-00256291": "obviously you need to trust the relayer", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00879-00256292-00256717": "to actually match our orders we kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00880-00256717-00256926": "touched on this earlier but all of these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00881-00256927-00257204": "models are non-custodial and I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00882-00257205-00257638": "that is probably what matters most but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00883-00257639-00257955": "it's up to the end-users to decide which", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00884-00257956-00258221": "relays are comfortable using", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00885-00258221-00258506": "is there also a risk here that let's say", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00886-00258507-00258848": "I is a minor I see you know you're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00887-00258848-00259289": "sending well can I gain this somehow", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00888-00259290-00259571": "can I fight front on it or I I see oh", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00889-00259571-00259925": "this this kind of order coming in and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00890-00259926-00260344": "I'm gonna interject my own and then kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00891-00260346-00260663": "of take a orbit opposing position", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00892-00260664-00260840": "elsewhere and make an arbitrage or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00893-00260841-00261173": "something like that so it it really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00894-00261173-00261556": "depends on the way that the relayer is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00895-00261557-00261805": "structured the way that they are kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00896-00261806-00262146": "operating", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00897-00262147-00262532": "so you know one of the ways I actually I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00898-00262533-00262976": "just I've been writing a blog series on", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00899-00262977-00263330": "front-running specifically and the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00900-00263331-00263691": "different ways 0x protocol can be a the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00901-00263692-00263855": "ways that it can be used in the ways", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00902-00263856-00264078": "those different approaches can be gamed", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00903-00264079-00264522": "or front-run and so generally speaking", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00904-00264523-00265119": "if I create this 0x order and I allow it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00905-00265120-00265323": "to be filled by anyone in the world", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00906-00265324-00265634": "anyone that just happens to see it that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00907-00265635-00265905": "type of order is subject to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00908-00265906-00266301": "front-running so you know someone you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00909-00266302-00266490": "know may be my counterparty sees my", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00910-00266491-00266735": "order they they want to take the other", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00911-00266736-00267072": "side of that and enter into a trade they", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00912-00267073-00267428": "kind of inject that quarter into the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00913-00267429-00267729": "etherium kind of pending transaction", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00914-00267730-00268133": "pool the mempool and that transaction", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00915-00268134-00268278": "will kind of sit there waiting to be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00916-00268279-00268559": "mined into a block and so anyone that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00917-00268560-00268767": "watching the pending transaction pool", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00918-00268768-00269043": "and see what I am attempting to do or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00919-00269044-00269196": "can see that my counterparty is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00920-00269197-00269541": "attempting to fill my order and so you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00921-00269542-00270068": "know anyone can kind of take that order", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00922-00270069-00270287": "say oh I'd actually I'm going to fill", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00923-00270288-00270479": "this order and they can set a higher gas", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00924-00270480-00270770": "price and you know they could front run", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00925-00270771-00271052": "my counterparty and they would be my new", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00926-00271053-00271364": "counterparty and you know what's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00927-00271365-00271586": "interesting is that miners they don't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00928-00271587-00271949": "even have to think about gas prices so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00929-00271950-00272483": "so miners can they can kind of they can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00930-00272484-00272792": "order trades or they can arrange", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00931-00272793-00273065": "transactions into any order they want it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00932-00273066-00273323": "can be completely arbitrary they can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00933-00273324-00273587": "they can mock miners can mine blocks", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00934-00273588-00273941": "with zero transactions in the block you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00935-00273942-00274165": "know typically a rational miner will", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00936-00274166-00274409": "prioritize transactions that pay the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00937-00274410-00274883": "highest fee per unit of gas but if a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00938-00274884-00275147": "miner is attempting to front run sort of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00939-00275148-00275474": "one of these open order books they can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00940-00275475-00275594": "do whatever they want it's kind of like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00941-00275595-00275906": "God mode for them", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00942-00275907-00276305": "so that's not very good you know the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00943-00276306-00276494": "good thing about 0x protocol is that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00944-00276495-00276857": "it's you know we don't define the way", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00945-00276858-00277184": "that people enter into a trade or the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00946-00277185-00277512": "way that you know these orders are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00947-00277513-00277794": "transported off chain so there's a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00948-00277795-00277938": "variety of different ways that 0x", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00949-00277939-00278249": "protocol can be used so the first way", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00950-00278250-00278420": "that I just discussed is called the open", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00951-00278421-00278616": "order book strategy and this is kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00952-00278617-00278780": "like the ether Delta approach a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00953-00278781-00279035": "different approach is sort of this order", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00954-00279036-00279545": "matching strategy so the relay ER which", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00955-00279546-00279746": "in this case we call the matcher", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00956-00279747-00280022": "they only accept orders on to their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00957-00280023-00280301": "order book if they are specified as the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00958-00280302-00280844": "only party able to execute that trade so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00959-00280845-00281118": "what they do is they wait for two orders", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00960-00281119-00281313": "to show up on either side of the order", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00961-00281314-00281565": "book that are equivalent in price or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00962-00281566-00281804": "overlapping in price and then they kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00963-00281805-00281937": "of batch fill that they've kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00964-00281938-00282240": "package those two orders together inject", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00965-00282241-00282497": "them both into the 0x smart contracts", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00966-00282498-00282698": "and kind of batch fill them", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00967-00282699-00283082": "simultaneously and so in that model the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00968-00283083-00283382": "matcher has full control over trade", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00969-00283383-00283550": "execution", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00970-00283551-00283781": "so you know you can imagine that's that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00971-00283782-00283943": "can be a really good thing it prevents", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00972-00283944-00284146": "front-running from traders and miners", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00973-00284147-00284447": "you know no one is able to kind of see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00974-00284448-00284705": "that batch of transaction sitting in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00975-00284706-00284888": "pending transaction pool and able to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00976-00284889-00285122": "like kind of go in swoop in like it just", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00977-00285123-00285383": "doesn't work there they're locked out", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00978-00285384-00285641": "and miners can't you know miners can't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00979-00285642-00286055": "do that either but you can also imagine", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00980-00286056-00286510": "that maybe giving this match or kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00981-00286511-00286724": "full control over the trade execution", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00982-00286725-00286871": "process maybe you don't want to give", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00983-00286872-00287209": "them that that truck you know you don't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00984-00287210-00287600": "want to get kind of give up that ability", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00985-00287601-00287903": "that power so there and there's a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00986-00287904-00288089": "variety of other ways that 0x protocol", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00987-00288090-00288269": "can be used to kind of you know it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00988-00288270-00288479": "solves both of these problems at once so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00989-00288480-00288683": "I instead of getting too deep into it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00990-00288684-00288910": "right now I would encourage people to go", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00991-00288911-00289151": "check out the blog post I wrote it goes", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00992-00289152-00289285": "it's real it goes real deep", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00993-00289286-00289499": "it's called front-running briefing in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00994-00289500-00289763": "the perils of virtual settlement and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00995-00289764-00289984": "there's there's part one and two that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00996-00289985-00290167": "are out right now", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00997-00290168-00290368": "cool that's super interesting thanks so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00998-00290369-00290641": "much for expanding on this that's just", "BLGOc5-NR-U-00999-00290642-00290800": "something kind of came to mind here I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01000-00290801-00291100": "mean there's a lot of projects in in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01001-00291101-00291343": "kind of adjacent blockchain space that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01002-00291344-00291745": "are trying to create tools so that you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01003-00291746-00292099": "can basically run code on a server that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01004-00292100-00292249": "you know it's like it's a central server", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01005-00292250-00292426": "but that someone else in from outside", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01006-00292427-00292666": "can say okay this was done correctly and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01007-00292667-00292954": "kind of tamper proof and stuff so Intel", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01008-00292955-00293176": "SGX is one example of what there are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01009-00293177-00293529": "others wouldn't you be able to build", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01010-00293530-00293974": "basically a some kind of like matching", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01011-00293975-00294196": "engine using something like Intel SGX", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01012-00294197-00294529": "that you know is users can have a very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01013-00294530-00294883": "high trust that this is fair there's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01014-00294884-00295213": "nothing funny going on but at the same", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01015-00295214-00295411": "time it can have all the benefits of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01016-00295412-00295642": "being you know a centralized entity on a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01017-00295643-00295891": "server it can be performant and and of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01018-00295892-00296194": "course also that way immune to the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01019-00296195-00296338": "front-running of the mind that you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01020-00296339-00296652": "talked about I think there are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01021-00296653-00297126": "directions that are worth exploring that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01022-00297127-00297531": "yeah like I think potentially", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01023-00297532-00297735": "there are ways that a matching engine", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01024-00297736-00298152": "could be designed to be trust lists so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01025-00298153-00298344": "kind of like what you're saying you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01026-00298345-00298757": "and but perhaps instead of relying on a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01027-00298758-00299193": "person to you know do trait kind of do", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01028-00299194-00299420": "trade execution", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01029-00299421-00299619": "according to kind of whatever rules they", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01030-00299620-00299814": "said instead let's let's all agree on", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01031-00299815-00299985": "what the rules are and kind of dump them", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01032-00299986-00300300": "into an Intel and SGX type of system", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01033-00300301-00300474": "where you know we can all kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01034-00300475-00300783": "publicly observe what's going on and we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01035-00300784-00301130": "know that it's being done you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01036-00301131-00301332": "according to the rules we all agreed", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01037-00301333-00301707": "upon I do think that there are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01038-00301708-00301959": "challenges around that that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01039-00301960-00302151": "need to be explored further so like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01040-00302152-00302532": "things like like data availability so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01041-00302533-00302781": "like you know it's very easy if everyone", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01042-00302782-00303051": "agrees upon the current state of of an", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01043-00303052-00303390": "order book and everyone agrees on the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01044-00303391-00303606": "kind of time at which different orders", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01045-00303607-00303927": "are kind of coming in you know if we all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01046-00303928-00304140": "agree about that data set and we all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01047-00304141-00304412": "agree about the rules that were kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01048-00304413-00304701": "enforcing over trade execution in this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01049-00304702-00305301": "Intel SGX type system then yes we can we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01050-00305302-00305541": "can all you know say okay this trade", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01051-00305542-00305796": "execution system is performing exactly", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01052-00305797-00306060": "how we want it to everything is good but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01053-00306061-00306318": "you know I think the most challenging", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01054-00306319-00306629": "part there is ensuring that everyone has", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01055-00306630-00306996": "the same kind of state of the order book", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01056-00306997-00307233": "and everyone is viewing these orders", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01057-00307234-00307428": "coming in at the same exact kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01058-00307429-00307745": "cadence right in the same order so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01059-00307746-00307941": "that's kind of like the data", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01060-00307942-00308157": "availability problem and I think that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01061-00308158-00308433": "a pretty challenging it you know it's a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01062-00308434-00308565": "challenging problem to solve but I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01063-00308566-00308808": "absolutely believe that you know we can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01064-00308809-00309042": "create interesting systems that that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01065-00309043-00309351": "work you know it's just going to take", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01066-00309352-00309578": "some time and more people exploring", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01067-00309579-00309789": "exploring them", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01068-00309790-00310008": "and I think one of the challenges with", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01069-00310009-00310254": "these more theoretical approaches to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01070-00310255-00310533": "solving front-running is that a lot of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01071-00310534-00310769": "them are not going to give the user", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01072-00310770-00311085": "experience that we want you know they're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01073-00311086-00311340": "gonna require like security deposits", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01074-00311341-00311621": "long lock ups long withdrawal periods", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01075-00311622-00311973": "and this really reduces the ability for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01076-00311974-00312276": "other decentralized applications to like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01077-00312277-00312669": "plug into the system and then the second", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01078-00312670-00312948": "point I wanted to make is that I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01079-00312949-00313221": "front-running is actually one of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01080-00313222-00313440": "larger problems in the blockchain space", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01081-00313441-00313791": "in general I think people view it in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01082-00313792-00313998": "context of a centralized exchange a lot", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01083-00313999-00314211": "because decentralized exchange is like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01084-00314212-00314496": "one of the first use cases in production", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01085-00314497-00314874": "of smart contract based block chains but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01086-00314875-00315252": "yeah I think I think we'll see more and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01087-00315253-00315501": "more applications having these issues as", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01088-00315502-00315774": "they start going into production and I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01089-00315775-00316149": "could see in the long run the the end", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01090-00316150-00316407": "solution might be something like zero", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01091-00316408-00316755": "knowledge mining where you can't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01092-00316756-00317034": "actually tell or you can't look at a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01093-00317035-00317286": "transaction in the mempool and see all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01094-00317287-00317463": "of its properties but you could only you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01095-00317464-00317676": "know prove that that transaction will", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01096-00317677-00317892": "pay the mine or X amount of cookies or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01097-00317893-00318495": "whatever so one other one other aspect", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01098-00318496-00318951": "of this model of free layers and users", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01099-00318952-00319401": "is the question of privacy right so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01100-00319402-00319733": "today in in the 0x model and in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01101-00319734-00319941": "virtually all these centralized exchange", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01102-00319942-00320241": "models when I'm making an order or I'm", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01103-00320242-00320700": "taking an order the linkage between what", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01104-00320701-00321147": "asset is being traded how much is being", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01105-00321148-00321585": "traded and my address is visible on the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01106-00321586-00321822": "blockchain right this address traded", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01107-00321823-00322125": "this in this much quantity for this much", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01108-00322126-00322360": "price", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01109-00322361-00322645": "see a lot of innovation coming from your", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01110-00322646-00322909": "side or in the ecosystem around", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01111-00322910-00323299": "obfuscating this linkage and what are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01112-00323300-00323503": "the interesting approaches and projects", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01113-00323504-00323723": "here", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01114-00323724-00324098": "yes oh I think privacy is a pretty big", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01115-00324099-00324401": "challenge I think in in the context of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01116-00324402-00324649": "decentralized exchange there are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01117-00324650-00324833": "probably people would prefer for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01118-00324834-00325022": "everything to be private I think there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01119-00325023-00325289": "are some advantages of things being", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01120-00325290-00325559": "transparent as well you know if you see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01121-00325560-00325772": "someone doing something shady like boss", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01122-00325773-00325919": "trading or something like that that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01123-00325920-00326432": "pretty easy to to notice but you know I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01124-00326433-00326743": "think I think in the long run we do want", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01125-00326744-00326968": "everything to be as private as possible", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01126-00326969-00327386": "I think both z.k snarks and Entering", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01127-00327387-00327614": "signatures are you know potential", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01128-00327615-00327835": "approaches that that we can take to that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01129-00327836-00328229": "the issue right now is probably the cost", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01130-00328230-00328628": "associated with doing those things it's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01131-00328629-00329114": "just not viable to you know have have", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01132-00329115-00329300": "private transactions because the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01133-00329301-00329623": "portrayed cost is going to be too high", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01134-00329624-00329936": "but yeah I'm excited about a handful of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01135-00329937-00330152": "different approaches I think keep", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01136-00330153-00330371": "network is doing some good stuff in that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01137-00330372-00330653": "space as well different signature types", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01138-00330654-00330941": "also I think and can add a decent amount", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01139-00330942-00331175": "of privacy we're looking into BLS", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01140-00331176-00331607": "signatures right now which comes comes", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01141-00331608-00331952": "with the benefit of being able to share", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01142-00331953-00332432": "fees in a more private way so speaking", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01143-00332433-00332708": "about relays before now it seems you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01144-00332709-00332915": "guys have I mean this is one of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01145-00332916-00333137": "amazing things and and you guys mention", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01146-00333138-00333329": "it a little bit before that I have", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01147-00333330-00333524": "noticed sort of from periphery that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01148-00333525-00333866": "after your token sale is there was all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01149-00333867-00334070": "these announcement okay this projects", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01150-00334071-00334352": "building a0x project Cyrax projects your", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01151-00334353-00334508": "X project so there's really this kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01152-00334509-00334694": "vibe and startup ecosystem that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01153-00334695-00334901": "developed which is having quite unique", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01154-00334902-00335315": "actually for for blockchain projects or", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01155-00335316-00335597": "talk projects I did a token sales", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01156-00335598-00335890": "especially as recently as you guys so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01157-00335891-00336182": "what are the business models that people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01158-00336183-00336509": "are trying to realize when they're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01159-00336510-00336901": "building easier X businesses", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01160-00336902-00337165": "so I think the business model is very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01161-00337166-00337312": "straightforward right now is just", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01162-00337313-00337480": "hosting the word book broadcast that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01163-00337481-00337657": "word book and charge these four trades", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01164-00337658-00337939": "and I think that's actually a big part", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01165-00337940-00338245": "of why we've been so successful the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01166-00338246-00338497": "business model is just so clear and this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01167-00338498-00338787": "is kind of one of the first ways to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01168-00338788-00339196": "monetize watching applications in in a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01169-00339197-00339490": "very cheap way without doing a token", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01170-00339491-00339919": "sale I think down the line we're gonna", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01171-00339920-00340153": "we're gonna see more business models", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01172-00340154-00340378": "where you have things like wallets who", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01173-00340379-00340705": "are just rebroadcasting orders from", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01174-00340706-00340993": "other real ayres and taking a cut of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01175-00340994-00341347": "fees and I think that's when we'll kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01176-00341348-00341682": "of see an explosion in in use of 0ax", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01177-00341683-00341962": "yeah absolutely but what I'm curious", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01178-00341963-00342534": "here it seems to me that be layers I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01179-00342535-00342769": "mean as a as a user I don't really care", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01180-00342770-00342984": "too much about you know which we layer", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01181-00342985-00343282": "right in the end if my order get settled", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01182-00343283-00343507": "it's on the chain right I get the other", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01183-00343508-00343785": "tokens and and I just want the best", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01184-00343786-00344047": "price someone like reliable execution I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01185-00344048-00344203": "don't care like you don't care about", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01186-00344204-00344548": "brand you don't care it's not really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01187-00344549-00344731": "trusted very much as we've talked about", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01188-00344732-00345004": "right so I don't have to worry too much", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01189-00345005-00345214": "about you know someone like coinbase", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01190-00345215-00345370": "have to been around for years do they", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01191-00345371-00345544": "have all like insurance all of these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01192-00345545-00346027": "things are are not relevant so how I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01193-00346028-00346345": "would be possible for those relays to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01194-00346346-00346594": "build a sustainable profitable business", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01195-00346595-00346738": "is that not just gonna be kind of a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01196-00346739-00346962": "little commodity thing that's gonna get", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01197-00346963-00347263": "you know driven to zero when it comes to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01198-00347264-00347572": "their profit margin we're definitely", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01199-00347573-00347899": "gonna see competition between the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01200-00347900-00348052": "different real layers and I think it's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01201-00348053-00348442": "gonna be extremely healthy or the entire", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01202-00348443-00348727": "kind of decentralized exchange ecosystem", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01203-00348728-00349031": "as a whole you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01204-00349032-00349340": "ether Delta you know has been extremely", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01205-00349341-00349688": "successful and I think that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01206-00349689-00350126": "it's incredibly impressive what the you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01207-00350127-00350321": "know Zack Cober and the founder of ether", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01208-00350322-00350642": "Delta did on his own that being said I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01209-00350643-00350909": "think like you know teams you know some", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01210-00350910-00351110": "of these real layers since you know we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01211-00351111-00351323": "kind of massively lower the barrier to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01212-00351324-00351557": "entry for a new new dev teams entering", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01213-00351558-00351749": "the space I think what we're gonna see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01214-00351750-00351998": "over time is just you know competition", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01215-00351999-00352436": "around user experience and as a result", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01216-00352437-00352571": "and this is something that we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01217-00352572-00352772": "desperately need in the blockchain space", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01218-00352773-00353063": "you know creating a decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01219-00353064-00353282": "application that talks to the blockchain", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01220-00353283-00353537": "and in you know does it in a way that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01221-00353538-00353753": "the user can understand and feel", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01222-00353754-00353996": "comfortable with is extremely hard and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01223-00353997-00354332": "you know if there's a you know multiple", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01224-00354333-00354551": "teams that are competing for market", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01225-00354552-00354755": "share one of the first things is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01226-00354756-00354958": "providing a great user experience", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01227-00354959-00355201": "everyone benefits from that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01228-00355202-00355514": "competing on transaction fees you know I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01229-00355515-00355766": "think these will not go to 0 but they", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01230-00355767-00356006": "will go to an economic equilibrium that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01231-00356007-00356282": "makes sense and that's also very healthy", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01232-00356283-00356486": "for everyone that uses decentralized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01233-00356487-00356873": "exchanges but I think one of the biggest", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01234-00356874-00357224": "sumption that it one of the biggest", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01235-00357225-00357439": "sumption is it kind of plays into this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01236-00357440-00357812": "you know hey there's like 12 different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01237-00357813-00358130": "real layers they're all kind of trading", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01238-00358131-00358355": "the same tokens like do we really need", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01239-00358356-00358574": "12 real layers that are doing the exact", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01240-00358575-00358786": "same thing and I think the answer's no", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01241-00358787-00359126": "but we'll end up seeing it kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01242-00359127-00359351": "what's an assumption that's built into", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01243-00359352-00359630": "that statement is that there's a finite", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01244-00359631-00359870": "number of tokens people are interested", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01245-00359871-00360148": "in trading and I think that's that is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01246-00360149-00360488": "going to turn out to be false you know I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01247-00360489-00360870": "think that over the next few years", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01248-00360871-00361146": "you know there's been this explosion in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01249-00361147-00361413": "the number of tokens that exist and I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01250-00361414-00361725": "think that's gonna continue and it yeah", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01251-00361726-00361893": "there's gonna be a massive number of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01252-00361894-00362132": "tokens that are kind of created through", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01253-00362133-00362408": "token sales there's going to be just a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01254-00362409-00362745": "Cambrian explosion of non fungible", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01255-00362746-00363027": "tokens and video game items that are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01256-00363028-00363252": "coming out once the community can kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01257-00363253-00363528": "of come to consensus on the tokens", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01258-00363529-00363753": "standard for non fungible tokens I also", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01259-00363754-00363957": "think that like securities tokens are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01260-00363958-00364412": "going to just be an incredibly huge new", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01261-00364413-00364932": "area where there's tokenization and so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01262-00364933-00365202": "you know over the next few years I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01263-00365203-00365403": "the number of tokens that exist is going", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01264-00365404-00365860": "to trend towards infinity and you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01265-00365861-00366289": "relays are not going to list millions of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01266-00366290-00366487": "tokens what they're going to do is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01267-00366488-00366766": "they're going to find a market niche", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01268-00366767-00367051": "they're going to kind of plant their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01269-00367052-00367303": "flag carve out that market niche and you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01270-00367304-00367429": "know there will probably be one or two", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01271-00367430-00367645": "real Ayres that dominate you know a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01272-00367646-00367873": "specific market niche but there is going", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01273-00367874-00368422": "to be hundreds of market niches and you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01274-00368423-00368752": "know real layers that focus on real", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01275-00368753-00368947": "estate tokens that's gonna have to be a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01276-00368948-00369136": "completely different user experience", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01277-00369137-00369463": "than real layers that offer you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01278-00369464-00369763": "prediction market tokens and even within", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01279-00369764-00369937": "prediction markets there's so many", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01280-00369938-00370114": "different kind of verticals that can be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01281-00370115-00370357": "focused on like basketball you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01282-00370358-00370636": "betting on basketball games you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01283-00370637-00370992": "betting on elections politics science", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01284-00370993-00371287": "there's just like an infinite number of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01285-00371288-00371566": "niches that can be kind of captured by", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01286-00371567-00371977": "real ayres that want to kind of create", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01287-00371978-00372211": "kind of tailor their their product for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01288-00372212-00372481": "that specific market", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01289-00372482-00372772": "I mean my feeling is and of course I I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01290-00372773-00372976": "don't know nearly as much about this as", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01291-00372977-00373168": "you and it's just sort of an intuition", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01292-00373169-00373387": "but this sounds kind of weird to me I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01293-00373388-00373516": "mean it feels to me that you know let's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01294-00373517-00373672": "say something like Google right well", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01295-00373673-00373876": "they can do email right they can do Qi", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01296-00373877-00374245": "mail I can date they literally have most", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01297-00374246-00374377": "of the world I mean they could have the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01298-00374378-00374560": "entire world running on Gmail or I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01299-00374561-00374767": "if people wanted to they would be able", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01300-00374768-00374956": "to build out that kind of capacity I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01301-00374957-00375223": "mean I agree that probably you when it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01302-00375224-00375505": "comes to user interface but that will", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01303-00375506-00375856": "vary and when it comes to marketing and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01304-00375857-00376030": "you know it may be community will matter", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01305-00376031-00376260": "and stuff like that right so I could see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01306-00376261-00376756": "there being maybe you one or a few kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01307-00376757-00377005": "of relays that just dominate everything", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01308-00377006-00377296": "and then maybe them having some sort of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01309-00377297-00377503": "you know affiliate type things where", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01310-00377504-00377875": "anybody can build their you know real", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01311-00377876-00378133": "estate funnel on top or their security", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01312-00378134-00378640": "token funnel on top of that so so Brian", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01313-00378641-00378967": "has sketched out this future", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01314-00378968-00379201": "I don't know I I don't I don't sort of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01315-00379202-00379483": "agree with Brian here and maybe I can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01316-00379484-00379639": "sketch out a different future and then", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01317-00379640-00380011": "we can discuss sort of what will lead to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01318-00380012-00380274": "either of the two futures being realized", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01319-00380275-00380554": "but if we look historically on how", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01320-00380555-00380977": "pilots have monetized it has almost", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01321-00380978-00381337": "always been through", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01322-00381338-00381801": "referring users to exchanges so when you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01323-00381802-00382124": "go to Jack's and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01324-00382125-00382352": "click on okay I want to sell my easier", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01325-00382353-00382649": "and get litecoin Jax refers you to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01326-00382650-00383048": "shape-shift and shape-shift makes the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01327-00383049-00383323": "transaction fee on that exchange and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01328-00383324-00383681": "shape shift forwards part of those", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01329-00383682-00384092": "transaction fees to Jax strangely enough", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01330-00384093-00384571": "in the in the token economy the UX maker", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01331-00384572-00384866": "seems to have this kind of power to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01332-00384867-00385124": "influence where the transaction fees are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01333-00385125-00385439": "going to flow and I think that this is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01334-00385440-00385652": "going to hold true for prediction", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01335-00385653-00386045": "markets and the real relayer economy so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01336-00386046-00386401": "it might be the case that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01337-00386402-00386854": "the application with which people access", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01338-00386855-00387079": "their crypto kitties there might be a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01339-00387080-00387418": "few successful applications that people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01340-00387419-00387604": "download in order to get access to their", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01341-00387605-00387982": "crypto kitties the UX makers of those", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01342-00387983-00388212": "script of those few two or three", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01343-00388213-00388504": "applications can basically make or break", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01344-00388505-00388699": "the real layers in the crypto Kitty", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01345-00388700-00389026": "exchange market so if there's a company", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01346-00389027-00389293": "like Google that let's say tries to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01347-00389294-00389668": "dominate each and every kind of asset in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01348-00389669-00389912": "the real layer space right", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01349-00389913-00390098": "it might be the case that there might be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01350-00390099-00390455": "a small start-up that comes into the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01351-00390456-00390671": "market and focuses only on being a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01352-00390672-00390968": "cryptic it is a layer and then it makes", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01353-00390969-00391253": "really good deals with the UX makers of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01354-00391254-00391531": "the crypto Kitty's application and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01355-00391532-00391844": "because these UX crypto Kitty uux makers", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01356-00391845-00392072": "always refer to this small startup for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01357-00392073-00392408": "the exchange needs they're that small", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01358-00392409-00392588": "startup is still able to carve out a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01359-00392589-00392792": "niche against that big Google like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01360-00392793-00392993": "player that's trying to dominate every", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01361-00392994-00393383": "niche but this is just the feeling I'm", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01362-00393384-00393596": "not sure maybe Bryan is right and this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01363-00393597-00393833": "is like one real to one relay or a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01364-00393834-00394024": "couple of real layers to rule them all", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01365-00394025-00394345": "what are your opinions on it", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01366-00394346-00394549": "this large relayer that kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01367-00394550-00394804": "dominates everything I think rather than", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01368-00394805-00395035": "being like Google I think it would be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01369-00395036-00395391": "more similar to like a reddit where", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01370-00395392-00395784": "there's literally infinite number of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01371-00395785-00396112": "topics and communities that you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01372-00396113-00396403": "kind of form around very specific topics", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01373-00396404-00396862": "and you can go to Reddit and you can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01374-00396863-00397018": "find your community and then you can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01375-00397019-00397180": "subscribe to that community and you can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01376-00397181-00397405": "become a part of that community and you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01377-00397406-00397588": "can kind of just click on the different", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01378-00397589-00397723": "communities that you want to become a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01379-00397724-00398116": "part of but it and you know I could see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01380-00398117-00398383": "something similar to that happening with", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01381-00398384-00398707": "real ayres where there's this large you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01382-00398708-00399001": "know kind of this large dominating real", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01383-00399002-00399142": "layer that's kind of similar to Reddit", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01384-00399143-00399400": "and they offer these sub communities but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01385-00399401-00399649": "if I mean I'm it's kind of hard to come", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01386-00399650-00399874": "up with a great example off the top of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01387-00399875-00400051": "my head but if you can if you compare", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01388-00400052-00400570": "like Reddit and its ability to kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01389-00400571-00400795": "create communities you know there's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01390-00400796-00401143": "still there are still like places where", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01391-00401144-00401461": "communities form off of Reddit and that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01392-00401462-00401740": "provide like a more tailored experience", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01393-00401741-00401949": "for the community that they're serving", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01394-00401950-00402262": "you know there's a limited amount of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01395-00402263-00402511": "customizability that you can provide to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01396-00402512-00403087": "your subreddit community using reddit so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01397-00403088-00403273": "I don't know like I could see both of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01398-00403274-00403636": "them existing in parallel did I don't", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01399-00403637-00403828": "know if that analogy like was very clear", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01400-00403829-00404356": "but as my sense I also think that there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01401-00404357-00404557": "are just going to be enough ways to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01402-00404558-00404839": "differentiate yourself as a new layer", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01403-00404840-00405118": "and some of those ways kind of compete", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01404-00405119-00405361": "with each other in a way that a single", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01405-00405362-00405625": "relayer probably won't won't do all of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01406-00405626-00405949": "those so to give an example you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01407-00405950-00406315": "maybe one REE layer is offering trades", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01408-00406316-00406699": "with like a certain derivatives and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01409-00406700-00406900": "margin trading protocol and another", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01410-00406901-00407137": "relayer is offering that with a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01411-00407138-00407308": "different protocol", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01412-00407309-00407497": "I highly doubt you're going to have one", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01413-00407498-00407689": "company that's offering both", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01414-00407690-00408009": "- calls but like it was both my cater to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01415-00408010-00408463": "different users that in combination with", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01416-00408464-00408745": "the various different strategies you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01417-00408746-00409002": "could take as a relay er that like would", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01418-00409003-00409353": "significantly affect user experience and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01419-00409354-00409591": "the the api's are available to provide", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01420-00409592-00409926": "to end-users you know kinda like the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01421-00409927-00410149": "difference between the order book model", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01422-00410150-00410380": "and the matching model that we discussed", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01423-00410381-00410716": "earlier is pretty big and it's not", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01424-00410717-00411087": "really something that a single relay", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01425-00411088-00411253": "would not really be able to offer both", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01426-00411254-00411493": "of those things so I think if you take", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01427-00411493-00411666": "all these different product offerings", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01428-00411667-00411912": "all these different strategies all these", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01429-00411913-00412155": "different you know demographics that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01430-00412156-00412393": "relays are targeting we're going to see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01431-00412393-00412713": "a pretty diverse environment", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01432-00412714-00413097": "so of course the there's a 0x token what", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01433-00413097-00413412": "do you see the 0x token kind of its", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01434-00413413-00413735": "evolution or the economy the economy of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01435-00413737-00413859": "the Xerox oak and what's that going to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01436-00413860-00414116": "look like in the long run", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01437-00414117-00414438": "so the 0x token first and foremost it is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01438-00414439-00414716": "a governance token it allows us to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01439-00414717-00414914": "upgrade our system of smart contracts", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01440-00414915-00415224": "over time without bringing all of the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01441-00415225-00415670": "markets built on top of 0x to a halt and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01442-00415671-00415976": "the second thing that the CRX token is", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01443-00415977-00416255": "used for in direct protocol is for", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01444-00416256-00416468": "paying transaction fees to relay errs", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01445-00416469-00416889": "right so real ayres they get to you if", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01446-00416889-00417149": "they want to they can charge trading", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01447-00417150-00417353": "fees on every trade that kind of goes", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01448-00417354-00417743": "through their order book and you know I", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01449-00417744-00418041": "think a lot of people kind of view this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01450-00418042-00418274": "you know ZRX as a payment or is like a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01451-00418275-00418476": "fee token they kind of view that as like", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01452-00418477-00418680": "oh this is why the zr x token exists", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01453-00418681-00418878": "it's you know it was kind of like a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01454-00418879-00419039": "fundraising mechanism that was kind of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01455-00419040-00419274": "bolted on as an excuse for us to you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01456-00419275-00419574": "know your token sale but like it really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01457-00419575-00419693": "couldn't be further from the truth", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01458-00419694-00419972": "so the 0x token is a governance token", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01459-00419973-00420189": "and the reason why we just we made the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01460-00420189-00420426": "design decision that the CRX token", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01461-00420427-00420720": "should be used to pay fees is because we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01462-00420721-00421050": "think it's super important that all of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01463-00421051-00421272": "the all of the stakeholders in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01464-00421272-00421545": "ecosystem or you know all the people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01465-00421546-00421707": "that are accessing the protocols", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01466-00421708-00422070": "functionality have at least we're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01467-00422071-00422268": "driving them to participate in the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01468-00422268-00422502": "governance process by forcing them to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01469-00422503-00422856": "have some amount of ZRX tokens to access", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01470-00422857-00423197": "the protocols functionality and you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01471-00423198-00423327": "like one of the problems that we're", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01472-00423328-00423702": "trying to avoid is you know if the only", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01473-00423703-00423918": "people participating in the governance", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01474-00423918-00424389": "process are the real ayres that could be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01475-00424389-00424616": "really bad because they're for-profit", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01476-00424617-00424977": "businesses and their incentives and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01477-00424978-00425145": "their interests do not necessarily", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01478-00425146-00425502": "aligned with their end users and so you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01479-00425503-00425799": "know it could be feasible that if the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01480-00425800-00425966": "real ayres band together they could", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01481-00425967-00426153": "change the protocols in ways that are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01482-00426154-00426354": "not in the best interest of the people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01483-00426355-00426493": "that are actually using this", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01484-00426494-00426822": "infrastructure the or i guess it's the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01485-00426822-00426995": "other half of the people using the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01486-00426996-00427155": "infrastructure the users the people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01487-00427156-00427425": "trading so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01488-00427426-00427583": "you know I think this is like a really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01489-00427584-00427835": "controversial point a lot of people do", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01490-00427836-00428177": "not like that the ZRX token is used to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01491-00428178-00428387": "pay trading fees it you know a lot of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01492-00428388-00428602": "people think it feels pretty arbitrary", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01493-00428603-00428856": "it's kind of annoying that you have to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01494-00428857-00429202": "let go and acquire some of these tokens", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01495-00429203-00429553": "but you know I think", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01496-00429554-00429970": "it really makes sense for the long-term", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01497-00429971-00430547": "health of the ecosystem you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01498-00430548-00430839": "if the governance process is really", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01499-00430839-00431043": "imbalanced to serve one group of people", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01500-00431043-00431383": "over another that ecosystem or that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01501-00431384-00431622": "civilization tears itself apart over", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01502-00431622-00432054": "time and we don't want that to happen we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01503-00432055-00432275": "want everyone that uses Xerox protocol", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01504-00432276-00432737": "to have a stake in the the weight of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01505-00432738-00433062": "also retirement cool no that makes that", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01506-00433063-00433208": "makes perfect sense and it would be very", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01507-00433209-00433379": "interesting to see how those governance", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01508-00433380-00433575": "experiments in C or X turn out hopefully", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01509-00433576-00433725": "it doesn't rip itself apart", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01510-00433726-00433977": "yes exactly although that would also be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01511-00433978-00434216": "interesting to watch that would be", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01512-00434217-00434406": "interesting with it but very sad I would", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01513-00434407-00434883": "say be sad yes so tell us what is kind", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01514-00434884-00435093": "of the roadmap and timeline and what can", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01515-00435093-00435592": "we expect from Xerox the next 24 months", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01516-00435593-00435853": "so yeah currently we are working on the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01517-00435854-00436300": "two of the protocol major changes are", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01518-00436301-00436630": "going to include like they're a bunch of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01519-00436631-00436987": "efficiency gains essentially it's going", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01520-00436988-00437256": "to become much easier to arbitrage", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01521-00437257-00437631": "across the different real layers per", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01522-00437632-00437932": "transit or portrayed transaction costs", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01523-00437933-00438235": "will be lower we want to support new", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01524-00438235-00438445": "token standards such as non fungible", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01525-00438446-00438814": "tokens and then we want to improve our", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01526-00438814-00439075": "upgrade mechanism so that adding new", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01527-00439076-00439389": "token standards would be easier as well", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01528-00439389-00439813": "and we're also going to is kind of a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01529-00439814-00440118": "technical piece but without getting too", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01530-00440120-00440350": "into the weeds we're going to make it a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01531-00440351-00440664": "lot easier for people to kind of build", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01532-00440666-00441076": "higher-level protocols on top of 0x make", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01533-00441077-00441331": "it essentially you like funnel all of", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01534-00441332-00441538": "their trades through their own spark", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01535-00441539-00441826": "contracts which would enforce you know", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01536-00441827-00442099": "any arbitrary set of rules or logic", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01537-00442100-00442414": "around filling an order so that's that's", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01538-00442414-00442560": "kind of on a timeline for the next", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01539-00442562-00443114": "version but I think vv3 will we'll see", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01540-00443116-00443407": "some more decentralized governance built", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01541-00443408-00443904": "into the system for sure and then", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01542-00443905-00444047": "could really go anywhere from there", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01543-00444049-00444396": "right there are scalability solutions", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01544-00444397-00444557": "we're interested in plasma chains", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01545-00444558-00444831": "potentially you know having like a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01546-00444832-00445164": "cosmos zone things like that launching", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01547-00445164-00445635": "on other EVM compatible blog chains yeah", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01548-00445635-00445914": "I think it's it's going to be wild but", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01549-00445914-00446216": "v2 is on what we're looking at right now", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01550-00446217-00446352": "cool", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01551-00446353-00446510": "that sounds that sounds very interesting", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01552-00446512-00446789": "and yeah so thanks so much for joining", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01553-00446791-00447093": "us today guys thank you so much for the", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01554-00447093-00447324": "pleasure yeah thank you for having us", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01555-00447325-00447551": "this is great", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01556-00447552-00447718": "yeah and of course thanks so much for a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01557-00447720-00447893": "list of the Front's again joining us we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01558-00447893-00448091": "were gonna have links in the show notes", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01559-00448092-00448301": "to you know some essential things to", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01560-00448302-00448487": "check out about your ex white paper", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01561-00448488-00448688": "wills blog posts and some other", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01562-00448689-00448862": "resources you want to learn more about", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01563-00448863-00449126": "your ex and try it out and yeah so", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01564-00449127-00449279": "thanks so much for joining us where we", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01565-00449280-00449501": "put out new episodes of epicentre every", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01566-00449502-00449666": "Monday you can subscribe to the shows in", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01567-00449667-00449906": "iTunes SoundCloud favorite podcast app", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01568-00449907-00450127": "or you can also watch the videos on", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01569-00450128-00450434": "youtube.com slash episode of Bitcoin and", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01570-00450435-00450701": "also we just started a either", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01571-00450702-00450920": "communities or try this out so if you", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01572-00450921-00451166": "want to go there you do that and it's a", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01573-00451167-00451502": "episode with a slash it so and of course", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01574-00451503-00451628": "you can leave us nachos review which", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01575-00451629-00451805": "helps new people find the show so thanks", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01576-00451806-00451928": "so much and we look forward to being", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01577-00451929-00452122": "back", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01578-00452124-00453083": "[Music]", "BLGOc5-NR-U-01579-00453084-00453389": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "BLIjP9tAF-o", "text": {"BLIjP9tAF-o-00000-00000601-00001491": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00001-00001492-00001813": "uh", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00002-00001814-00003143": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00003-00003144-00004283": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00004-00004284-00004467": "uh", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00005-00004468-00006063": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00006-00006064-00007083": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00007-00007084-00009883": "uh", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00008-00009884-00010063": "hey", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00009-00010064-00010946": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00010-00010947-00011200": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00011-00011201-00012325": "[Music]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00012-00012326-00013838": "[Applause]", "BLIjP9tAF-o-00013-00013840-00014047": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "BLT8jLYy6kA", "text": {"BLT8jLYy6kA-00000-00000107-00000437": "and the cool enjoys a very defined just", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00001-00000438-00000837": "like life", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00002-00000838-00001147": "dish", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00003-00001148-00001391": "one of the difficulties with this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00004-00001392-00001609": "approach with more corn base in jail", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00005-00001610-00001913": "that they give it their probation he's", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00006-00001914-00002127": "not the belt right right", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00007-00002128-00002339": "this is how it looks like so we", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00008-00002340-00002500": "shouldn't expected so important", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00009-00002501-00002792": "this is exactly basically if I don't", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00010-00002793-00003104": "have a good way of defining what is a", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00011-00003105-00003431": "zero-sum reference image I couldn't eat", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00012-00003432-00003988": "this visualization we do now you could", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00013-00003989-00004327": "of course you find some some", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00014-00004328-00004733": "communication next we can use some", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00015-00004734-00004967": "equation that you remember of the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00016-00004968-00005351": "extrinsic base if encouraged too much or", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00017-00005352-00005497": "you can just consider all the newest", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00018-00005498-00005774": "orientations so this is what we give in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00019-00005775-00006038": "this program we consider all the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00020-00006039-00006254": "consumer orientations you cut these", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00021-00006255-00006478": "results of the commercially produced the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00022-00006479-00006734": "results for almost more issues and then", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00023-00006734-00007042": "we maximum over all the small issues", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00024-00007043-00008308": "because with I don't know", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00025-00008309-00008705": "here they see no leaves at each point on", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00026-00008706-00008963": "the surface usually we use some", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00027-00008964-00009203": "geometric features somewhat consistent", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00028-00009204-00009677": "performance you actually can use me some", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00029-00009678-00010239": "spectral 361 fish manufactures", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00030-00010240-00010544": "listen to that hook always for advice", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00031-00010545-00011935": "unless you something you can cut it like", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00032-00011936-00012203": "you don't know it channel see something", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00033-00012204-00012499": "that while you or somebody just what", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00034-00012500-00012737": "will teach you something only studies so", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00035-00012738-00012890": "you can use it for different education", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00036-00012891-00013369": "for example only sleep is probably your", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00037-00013370-00013640": "business you seem to be given a set of", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00038-00013641-00013949": "sheets with all correspondence of the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00039-00013950-00014390": "points so keep your corresponding points", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00040-00014391-00015141": "to be told to play see our colors", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00041-00015143-00015734": "basically big network out here by F and", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00042-00015735-00016066": "then these set of products or the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00043-00016068-00016372": "network is a little straighter so I", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00044-00016373-00016568": "won't lose putting points for my", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00045-00016569-00016753": "paintings that these because to be a", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00046-00016754-00017156": "submersible that's these four X and X", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00047-00017157-00018077": "bus no corresponding points we have X", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00048-00018078-00018275": "next - negative", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00049-00018276-00018518": "I wanted supposed to be as far as", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00050-00018519-00018686": "physically actually far away some aren't", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00051-00018687-00018753": "you", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00052-00018754-00019088": "maybe my skis together so technically", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00053-00019089-00019292": "how it's done basically we have what is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00054-00019293-00019514": "called in silence or protection so 2000", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00055-00019515-00019900": "copies of sharing the synchronous speed", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00056-00019901-00021272": "it with a pair of and we compare and", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00057-00021273-00021455": "like the dirt would take depends on how", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00058-00021456-00022347": "you define is also very much on", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00059-00022348-00022661": "negative examples so usually in general", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00060-00022662-00022908": "if you can be some ramekins could be", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00061-00022909-00023108": "some solution the Eastern points or", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00062-00023109-00023291": "these will be actually difficult issues", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00063-00023292-00023558": "so for example people the points that", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00064-00023559-00024432": "are giving negative examples they have", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00065-00024433-00024644": "features which also look like the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00066-00024645-00025497": "positive example you go boys unless you", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00067-00025498-00025727": "have some smart way of constructing", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00068-00025728-00026355": "these training set okay so these are", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00069-00026356-00026633": "then example all these factors like so", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00070-00026635-00026843": "for the short organization manner so", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00071-00026844-00027024": "this may take fourth on the shoulder I", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00072-00027025-00027393": "look at this one I compared to least is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00073-00027394-00027624": "an old recipe points of the same eight", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00074-00027625-00027818": "different levels and I put these", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00075-00027819-00028002": "distance celebrating it at some point", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00076-00028002-00028362": "it's not well okay so this is one of the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00077-00028363-00028557": "corporate company speakers complete", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00078-00028558-00028842": "procedure using computer graphics see", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00079-00028843-00029077": "that it's Facebook if they move away", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00080-00029078-00029433": "from the point basically promos other", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00081-00029433-00029489": "change", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00082-00029491-00029699": "so basically place money back", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00083-00029700-00029990": "correspondence because these people a", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00084-00029991-00030345": "frame across another popular center with", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00085-00030345-00030636": "chrono signature you see this much", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00086-00030637-00031114": "penalize this victim becomes different", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00087-00031116-00031473": "but it's crazy so other points", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00088-00031474-00031614": "completely different parts of it", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00089-00031614-00032067": "it looks like shoulder which is this is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00090-00032068-00032349": "a famous actress capture both annexing", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00091-00032350-00032942": "Louisville may be trying to learn the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00092-00032943-00033490": "transfer function", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00093-00033491-00033808": "we can all see with our might be fooled", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00094-00033809-00034137": "us so he thinks the penalisation yes", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00095-00034138-00034699": "look okay this is the genetics and you", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00096-00034700-00034855": "see that it's much better little device", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00097-00034856-00035167": "much possibility here in particular we", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00098-00035168-00035423": "didn't distinguish at that point between", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00099-00035424-00035542": "left and right", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00100-00035543-00036704": "symmetrical somebody who's just some", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00101-00036705-00036929": "renovations showing that the philosophy", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00102-00036930-00037435": "Scripture CMC community when she first", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00103-00037436-00037720": "the closest bishops and we see Oh", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00104-00037721-00038074": "many of them are quite responsive so the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00105-00038075-00038198": "higher the better", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00106-00038199-00038601": "you see much better than these goodness", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00107-00038602-00038948": "this is our seeker will be present these", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00108-00038949-00039217": "people distance at some hope and we will", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00109-00039218-00039332": "have the trade-off between false", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00110-00039333-00039642": "positives false negatives", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00111-00039643-00040051": "this is 7 and this has a face of a big", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00112-00040052-00040480": "part so here we look at the first the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00113-00040481-00040835": "closest make first us even and we look", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00114-00040836-00041107": "at the relative correspondence where", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00115-00041108-00041290": "Chris policies that formulate certain", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00116-00041291-00041743": "error waves resistance percentage of the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00117-00041744-00041948": "geodesic diameter of the shriek again", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00118-00041949-00042187": "they hire the matter you can see this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00119-00042188-00042545": "pretty significantly over previous and", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00120-00042546-00042704": "Rosen features our previous neurons", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00121-00042705-00043586": "which now it was one application we all", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00122-00043587-00043876": "miss because when you say speakers my", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00123-00043877-00044143": "response magicians we can you know the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00124-00044144-00044590": "components directly so for this purpose", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00125-00044591-00044855": "you can consider response has a very", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00126-00044856-00045286": "open so commercial shapes she is one of", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00127-00045287-00045532": "these shapes as your wave of space she", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00128-00045533-00045757": "doesn't need me she was just convenient", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00129-00045758-00045993": "the thing but it's just some offset", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00130-00045994-00046357": "space of penises so these I would call", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00131-00046358-00046561": "these the record straight you know that", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00132-00046562-00046877": "my life basically I want to label each", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00133-00046878-00047248": "point on that query point X with the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00134-00047249-00047517": "point on the reference rate wife okay", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00135-00047518-00047764": "and see the display meaning please", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00136-00047765-00047852": "Constance", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00137-00047853-00048168": "so basically they all good of this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00138-00048169-00048477": "neural network each point f of X could", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00139-00048478-00048771": "be produced interpreted as a probability", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00140-00048772-00049018": "distribution over the reference what the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00141-00049019-00049248": "last layer will be softmax player and", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00142-00049249-00049660": "produce something for me so we want this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00143-00049661-00050139": "to be s as possible and the deep to", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00144-00050140-00050404": "appear and the crawfish pushed on this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00145-00050405-00050799": "point which I stopped this is position", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00146-00050800-00051183": "for me we can trade the network by being", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00147-00051184-00051361": "amazing there what is the progression", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00148-00051362-00051708": "cost books like this nothing else but", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00149-00051709-00052012": "the Kubek like diversions statistical", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00150-00052013-00052348": "distance between two distributions the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00151-00052349-00052516": "graph of the solution see now that my", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00152-00052516-00052711": "start and the actual distribution that", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00153-00052712-00053173": "is produced by the network this is how", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00154-00053174-00053382": "it looks like if you compare these", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00155-00053383-00053872": "matters to some standards that exist in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00156-00053873-00054148": "the literature so this is the symmetric", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00157-00054149-00054680": "which worketh divorce", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00158-00054682-00055082": "kazuto-san destination so this is some", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00159-00055083-00055366": "health of course was produced by a", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00160-00055366-00056224": "rejection", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00161-00056225-00056730": "and all right of course", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00162-00056732-00056978": "aren't you much nuisance", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00163-00056979-00057122": "that's what I'm saying that we should", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00164-00057123-00057500": "hopefully so here judicial Chris", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00165-00057501-00057845": "policies in rhetoric say cars called", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00166-00057846-00058238": "Chrisman important now for that occasion", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00167-00058239-00058562": "is so far astray we didn't do any moving", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00168-00058563-00058783": "right Israel we wanted to create", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00169-00058784-00059096": "descriptors for each point of shape in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00170-00059097-00059285": "some keys we want to create these little", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00171-00059286-00059639": "valleys but that also meant I feel you", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00172-00059640-00059903": "want to classify shapes so there's", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00173-00059904-00060154": "several ways of doing putting this she", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00174-00060155-00060322": "was very that using these paper was", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00175-00060323-00060717": "computer components networking point", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00176-00060719-00061061": "produces each other each point two", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00177-00061062-00061244": "dimensional features you complete their", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00178-00061245-00061582": "coherent States and Brazil this is our", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00179-00061583-00061865": "basis Europe at this point removes all", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00180-00061866-00062080": "the German extraction it's a kind of", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00181-00062082-00062309": "community-based and it's all", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00182-00062310-00062683": "confidential and he will train it on", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00183-00062684-00062974": "some example of positives and negatives", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00184-00062975-00063503": "the scene was so this has a rather", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00185-00063504-00063913": "simple presentation on different", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00186-00063914-00064597": "subjects from the false basic reforms", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00187-00064598-00064919": "just give an example here might quickly", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00188-00064920-00065252": "these are the sheets that book which if", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00189-00065253-00065812": "we use the key transition speed", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00190-00065813-00066061": "Leedy but these two are two different", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00191-00066062-00066337": "people it's hard to say but to me they", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00192-00066338-00066487": "work they say he's father he's always", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00193-00066488-00066589": "been different", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00194-00066590-00066958": "these two are this one this is what we", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00195-00066959-00067150": "get this realistic said it's better", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00196-00067151-00067455": "performance all the first pitches he'll", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00197-00067456-00067875": "give you all of the same something", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00198-00067876-00068212": "mostly an example we didn't this bigger", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00199-00068213-00068956": "Vegas it's so the next thing this is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00200-00068957-00069211": "actually if we simply thought that we", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00201-00069212-00069642": "were here a nice experience all are", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00202-00069643-00069925": "abstractions of quality whatever", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00203-00069926-00070183": "experience for the diffusion process so", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00204-00070184-00070336": "we've seen already the diffusion", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00205-00070337-00070504": "equation looks like this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00206-00070505-00071158": "so this genius could see the gravity is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00207-00071159-00071422": "very caustic and whistling speaks in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00208-00071423-00071674": "this piece from each point of our", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00209-00071675-00071866": "service conducts the heat in the same", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00210-00071867-00072289": "way now we release this constant with a", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00211-00072290-00072541": "matrix that this concave curvature", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00212-00072542-00072910": "tensor that basically was a behavior", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00213-00072911-00073084": "that is foolishness Direction dependent", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00214-00073085-00073387": "so we can come back to eat differently", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00215-00073388-00073618": "in each direction at each point just to", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00216-00073619-00073866": "give an example it is how is a topic", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00217-00073867-00074581": "moves like our case we see for the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00218-00074582-00074929": "construction of there are these action", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00219-00074930-00075674": "plans which will fall faster in certain", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00220-00075675-00075975": "now our unit everything is here on", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00221-00075976-00076335": "painful the granite is time in seconds", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00222-00076336-00076542": "you private", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00223-00076543-00077265": "easily and basically this is politics he", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00224-00077266-00077562": "just matrix that does something based on", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00225-00077563-00077960": "detector at each point okay in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00226-00077961-00078204": "particular books like this with the in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00227-00078205-00078609": "regarding the rotated by theta scaled by", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00228-00078610-00078785": "a factor of five rotated back back there", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00229-00078786-00086000": "we speak please somebody's over there", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00230-00086001-00086305": "okay so maybe we use these criminals as", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00231-00086306-00086838": "local wings all visually before this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00232-00086839-00087148": "extended no use these mates cute baby", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00233-00087149-00087304": "you Carl order yours in Kuwait", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00234-00087305-00088361": "where your coordinated motion especially", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00235-00088362-00088935": "exciting for each equation x angle okay", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00236-00088936-00089349": "so here actually because we have the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00237-00089350-00089673": "orientation right to be fixed like this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00238-00089674-00090010": "it will discriminate between symmetric", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00239-00090011-00090298": "wants his parents magic balls so", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00240-00090299-00090460": "basically pointing right shoulder and", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00241-00090461-00090737": "the left shoulder will be oriented in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00242-00090738-00091110": "image in all three with released skipper", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00243-00091111-00091437": "automatically has has the capability of", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00244-00091438-00091713": "discriminating meeting seeds and let me", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00245-00091714-00092976": "see if you practically well I really", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00246-00092977-00093184": "busy extended by the thing is for sure", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00247-00093185-00096768": "she doesn't use as possible which", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00248-00096769-00097150": "we didn't work for me because of the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00249-00097151-00097757": "Dorney Park", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00250-00097758-00098116": "so this is exactly the same to the point", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00251-00098117-00098335": "and shoulder completely still at this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00252-00098336-00098569": "point which is produced by the memory", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00253-00098570-00098920": "the visual supports see that it's very", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00254-00098921-00106453": "specific and very modest and also", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00255-00106454-00106946": "the average length of the femur to the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00256-00106947-00107407": "best marshal Olivia", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00257-00107408-00107675": "because if I were human income kinda", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00258-00107676-00108074": "unit for original result okay so this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00259-00108075-00108433": "was this metric benchmark so she Betty", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00260-00108434-00108653": "Richmond means that symmetric course", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00261-00108654-00108881": "policies are considered Esquire be more", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00262-00108882-00109106": "challenging which one is the aspirin you", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00263-00109107-00109346": "can see that from London force the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00264-00109347-00110207": "committee of 300 signatures degrees", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00265-00110208-00110681": "these memories is Louis more so some", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00266-00110682-00110993": "examples of crispiness at angle thing", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00267-00110994-00112858": "with vision actually in combination with", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00268-00112858-00113266": "steal the crystal is greatness and these", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00269-00113267-00113488": "with may have some coasting but I didn't", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00270-00113489-00113989": "say well okay so when they should we", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00271-00113990-00114245": "could make some Olympics", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00272-00114246-00114806": "momentum it's the your fish that appear", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00273-00114807-00114954": "the apprentice through these ago", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00274-00114955-00115177": "Michigan kettles results in the cheeks", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00275-00115178-00115390": "shall get across that maturity results", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00276-00115391-00115607": "issues so they did here is they season", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00277-00115608-00115801": "because funding local duties it", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00278-00115802-00116281": "coordinates growing that I mean for sure", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00279-00116282-00116533": "we also speaks the arisian to be a", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00280-00116534-00116740": "Tennessee vol he's been peaceful", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00281-00116741-00117108": "they must encourage in her we ultimately", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00282-00117109-00117443": "we could do here is two-dimensional", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00283-00117444-00117960": "right we used to live a core is these", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00284-00117961-00119593": "nations why these visions only function", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00285-00119594-00119875": "know if you look at it isn't horrible", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00286-00119876-00120400": "basically this is ecology cm which fix", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00287-00120401-00120848": "both these you can go we should call the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00288-00120849-00122056": "ATM so these are cute curls", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00289-00122057-00122338": "you know it's a clearly marked all that", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00290-00122339-00122843": "they are almost here this is the best", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00291-00122844-00123034": "thing that we won't release information", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00292-00123035-00123337": "and as I should look before these are", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00293-00123338-00123683": "the organizations like GC event of eight", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00294-00123683-00123988": "seven different instances of bullet with", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00295-00123989-00124513": "these kind of models so this is the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00296-00124514-00124759": "performative again now house is becoming", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00297-00124760-00125116": "water I mean yes about 90% of", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00298-00125117-00125586": "correspondents and Chris policy ones you", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00299-00125587-00126057": "of curiosity we roll 2016 us America 3", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00300-00126058-00126309": "so biologists error opportunity we get", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00301-00126310-00126663": "is 4 centimeters okay so if this move to", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00302-00126664-00126873": "your gradebook actually knowledge has", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00303-00126874-00127224": "also changed the scale goes crazy", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00304-00127225-00127727": "sitting it's 10 percent", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00305-00127728-00127989": "think it's at least in these page market", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00306-00127990-00128508": "state of their souls just give you a", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00307-00128509-00128745": "different visualization of arrow looks", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00308-00128746-00128922": "like so here's point wise to listen", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00309-00128923-00129230": "Carol okay", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00310-00129231-00129632": "this percentage of juristic damages 7.5", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00311-00129633-00130190": "7.5 would correspond to approximately 50", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00312-00130191-00130527": "this is whether of g0i century they are", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00313-00130528-00130946": "just for visualization feels pretty bad", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00314-00130947-00132111": "most of the points of air of years this", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00315-00132112-00132418": "is a judicious cannon you see that", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00316-00132419-00132711": "they're sparse set of points where is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00317-00132712-00132882": "like error but there are many points", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00318-00132883-00133193": "where they are is over 0 which is named", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00319-00133194-00133674": "this is variation from g77", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00320-00133675-00134763": "still got some points with another way", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00321-00134764-00134994": "of avoiding Christmas is financial", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00322-00134995-00136957": "ratings of the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00323-00136958-00137337": "there we get more I believe it cellphone", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00324-00137338-00138512": "beeping reapply it", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00325-00138513-00138883": "so more HC results here in our range", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00326-00138884-00139108": "images so Faust is not interesting", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00327-00139109-00139254": "because all these things have the same", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00328-00139255-00139689": "degree you can see that somehow you know", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00329-00139690-00139998": "they they make so there's a mortuary", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00330-00139999-00140383": "couple these are very useful Falls and", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00331-00140384-00141922": "severity recently apologies for the 77.4", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00332-00141923-00142183": "acceptability doctor they also graceful", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00333-00142184-00142389": "still bigger than the Google especially", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00334-00142390-00142662": "we should also see because the different", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00335-00142663-00142957": "our way of our growth is inaccurate", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00336-00142958-00143869": "because you take the USDA machine from", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00337-00143870-00143961": "which it originated", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00338-00143962-00144354": "basically they they breed size in the in", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00339-00144355-00144966": "arrangement is basically power few few", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00340-00144967-00146547": "points", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00341-00146548-00147029": "so training was the training it is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00342-00147030-00147402": "different doing some sets of forms your", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00343-00147403-00147728": "question", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00344-00147729-00148336": "it's like a policy that's capable well", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00345-00148337-00148643": "heels for mother beat sense he doesn't", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00346-00148644-00149033": "work well these geometric always with", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00347-00149034-00149387": "clothes local fighting we needed much", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00348-00149388-00149783": "reaching these disabilities McCain", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00349-00149784-00150323": "equals something like this is just an", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00350-00150324-00150392": "idea", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00351-00150393-00150632": "so there wasn't last year it wasn't easy", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00352-00150633-00151004": "to get it was people commonly used style", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00353-00151005-00151412": "of nucleons hidden or here to find the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00354-00151413-00151784": "response symmetry there that one", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00355-00151785-00152108": "consists of 1 million parameters taking", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00356-00152109-00152585": "up 50 medium which is 40 weeks we play", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00357-00152586-00152909": "on 86 we have maybe two covers of", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00358-00152910-00153101": "thousands of functions which range from", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00359-00153102-00153380": "hours the results of ethical reasons the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00360-00153381-00153617": "better we even competitive athletes from", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00361-00153618-00154028": "different basically this I think that", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00362-00154029-00154421": "this or shouts if they were really be", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00363-00154422-00161464": "the deformation wise", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00364-00161465-00165332": "in this paper", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00365-00165333-00167786": "so each point is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00366-00167787-00168009": "so what the problem is", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00367-00168010-00168240": "it depends very much very on the", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00368-00168241-00168641": "technician what the network does is it's", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00369-00168642-00170228": "great", "BLT8jLYy6kA-00370-00170229-00170528": "wizards"}}, {"audio_id": "BMh79x-_r-Y", "text": {"BMh79x-_r-Y-00000-00000016-00000103": "hey", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00001-00000104-00000247": "you", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00002-00000248-00000351": "yeah you", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00003-00000352-00000519": "go over here", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00004-00000520-00000807": "come a little bit closer come on", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00005-00000808-00000943": "hi", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00006-00000944-00001150": "i don't know if you could notice but i'm", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00007-00001151-00001391": "in a sling right now and don't you huck", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00008-00001392-00001495": "in there", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00009-00001496-00001751": "say what's up with your arm because i", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00010-00001752-00001998": "broke my collarbone and now my arm and", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00011-00002000-00002255": "i've heard that way too many times", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00012-00002256-00002423": "also my neck is kind of messed up right", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00013-00002424-00002710": "now so don't question it", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00014-00002711-00002910": "i'm recording this uh before that i had", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00015-00002911-00003015": "it because i'm probably gonna edit it in", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00016-00003016-00003199": "like three weeks because it's kind of", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00017-00003200-00003422": "hard i didn't want to end right now", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00018-00003423-00003647": "and", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00019-00003647-00003886": "i'm asking you", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00020-00003887-00004238": "join my discord", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00021-00004239-00004351": "that's really the whole point of this", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00022-00004352-00004583": "video basically i this idea", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00023-00004584-00004815": "you guys send me your really awful skit", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00024-00004816-00004911": "ideas", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00025-00004912-00005199": "and i actually create them in this one", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00026-00005200-00005495": "big video", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00027-00005496-00005718": "i don't expect them to be good", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00028-00005719-00006130": "like i said before ben's kids but um", "BMh79x-_r-Y-00029-00006131-00007329": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "BMT7BBZHigg", "text": {"BMT7BBZHigg-00000-00001000-00001366": "hi old welcome guys uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00001-00001367-00001695": "battle for third place young game", "BMT7BBZHigg-00002-00001696-00002014": "nothing for tonight one game long then", "BMT7BBZHigg-00003-00002016-00002334": "one game on the next day so", "BMT7BBZHigg-00004-00002335-00002663": "hope you guys enjoy and shout out to my", "BMT7BBZHigg-00005-00002664-00003031": "kids to isis chevelle", "BMT7BBZHigg-00006-00003032-00003303": "i love you and to my wife", "BMT7BBZHigg-00007-00003304-00003895": "i love you i miss you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00008-00003896-00004175": "see you soon", "BMT7BBZHigg-00009-00004176-00006118": "passport ibiza", "BMT7BBZHigg-00010-00006119-00008495": "ah dewey's not happy", "BMT7BBZHigg-00011-00008496-00008639": "i think he i think he finished the game", "BMT7BBZHigg-00012-00008640-00008895": "already", "BMT7BBZHigg-00013-00008896-00009119": "so i will not play it's alright if we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00014-00009120-00009287": "will play", "BMT7BBZHigg-00015-00009288-00009503": "russia you guys decide", "BMT7BBZHigg-00016-00009504-00009831": "but we already talked about the draft", "BMT7BBZHigg-00017-00009832-00010055": "because because we because we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00018-00010056-00010263": "we need briefing right cannot just say", "BMT7BBZHigg-00019-00010264-00010478": "oh okay 9 30", "BMT7BBZHigg-00020-00010479-00010799": "then you you just come in and then blur", "BMT7BBZHigg-00021-00010800-00010951": "don't know anything we don't discuss", "BMT7BBZHigg-00022-00010952-00011167": "anything then we start the game this is", "BMT7BBZHigg-00023-00011168-00011367": "the placing we're looking we're treating", "BMT7BBZHigg-00024-00011368-00011663": "that serious yep", "BMT7BBZHigg-00025-00011664-00011823": "so tomorrow", "BMT7BBZHigg-00026-00011824-00012031": "and marlon said i talked to marlon", "BMT7BBZHigg-00027-00012032-00012206": "earlier and he said", "BMT7BBZHigg-00028-00012207-00012423": "it can be the second priority tomorrow", "BMT7BBZHigg-00029-00012424-00012670": "night", "BMT7BBZHigg-00030-00012671-00012966": "if duke is available then we could do", "BMT7BBZHigg-00031-00012967-00013119": "but if he's not", "BMT7BBZHigg-00032-00013119-00014030": "then we go for marlon", "BMT7BBZHigg-00033-00014031-00014983": "oh yeah", "BMT7BBZHigg-00034-00014984-00016911": "so they go for", "BMT7BBZHigg-00035-00016912-00017094": "you can't lose", "BMT7BBZHigg-00036-00017095-00017686": "who", "BMT7BBZHigg-00037-00017687-00017879": "can choose", "BMT7BBZHigg-00038-00017880-00020935": "to pick first", "BMT7BBZHigg-00039-00020936-00022607": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00040-00022608-00024167": "viewers", "BMT7BBZHigg-00041-00024168-00026774": "see", "BMT7BBZHigg-00042-00026775-00027143": "i yes according to their discord they", "BMT7BBZHigg-00043-00027144-00027374": "win", "BMT7BBZHigg-00044-00027375-00027646": "so they win final", "BMT7BBZHigg-00045-00027647-00027895": "i think so", "BMT7BBZHigg-00046-00027895-00028214": "or semi", "BMT7BBZHigg-00047-00028216-00029262": "not sure", "BMT7BBZHigg-00048-00029263-00029543": "i think final and also for i'm not sure", "BMT7BBZHigg-00049-00029544-00029855": "for cs if they're also in", "BMT7BBZHigg-00050-00029856-00030055": "yes they they go to", "BMT7BBZHigg-00051-00030056-00030431": "for finance they go to china yeah", "BMT7BBZHigg-00052-00030432-00030639": "our team", "BMT7BBZHigg-00053-00030639-00031199": "it's okay bro", "BMT7BBZHigg-00054-00031200-00031407": "so i think they are third place", "BMT7BBZHigg-00055-00031408-00031823": "four cs", "BMT7BBZHigg-00056-00031824-00031983": "no i saw", "BMT7BBZHigg-00057-00031983-00032287": "i saw cs they went to final", "BMT7BBZHigg-00058-00032288-00032487": "oh okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00059-00032488-00032743": "we're going finer guys yeah so", "BMT7BBZHigg-00060-00032744-00032902": "we'll find us guys i think just i think", "BMT7BBZHigg-00061-00032903-00033102": "the mobile legend i'm not sure whether", "BMT7BBZHigg-00062-00033103-00033311": "just now is send me or find", "BMT7BBZHigg-00063-00033312-00033959": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00064-00033960-00035262": "right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00065-00035263-00037335": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00066-00037336-00037551": "uh we just we just mentioned i we just", "BMT7BBZHigg-00067-00037552-00037774": "mentioned we i'm going i'm going to ban", "BMT7BBZHigg-00068-00037775-00038159": "all the micro meepo laundry and also ark", "BMT7BBZHigg-00069-00038160-00038655": "warden", "BMT7BBZHigg-00070-00038656-00038767": "if you're going", "BMT7BBZHigg-00071-00038768-00039023": "to burn viper", "BMT7BBZHigg-00072-00039024-00039135": "sorry", "BMT7BBZHigg-00073-00039136-00040399": "if you're going husky you have to burn", "BMT7BBZHigg-00074-00040400-00040783": "or you can let's pick that guy also fine", "BMT7BBZHigg-00075-00040784-00040911": "let me speak", "BMT7BBZHigg-00076-00040912-00041161": "what's your hero then", "BMT7BBZHigg-00077-00041162-00041383": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00078-00041384-00041487": "you want it do you want to get drunk or", "BMT7BBZHigg-00079-00041488-00041558": "not", "BMT7BBZHigg-00080-00041559-00042079": "i thought you wanted", "BMT7BBZHigg-00081-00042080-00042311": "yeah", "BMT7BBZHigg-00082-00042312-00042671": "yeah but i like the more if you want pa", "BMT7BBZHigg-00083-00042672-00042790": "maybe", "BMT7BBZHigg-00084-00042791-00042967": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00085-00042968-00043302": "daniel can go likeness so he can give", "BMT7BBZHigg-00086-00043303-00043687": "you empower", "BMT7BBZHigg-00087-00043688-00044023": "can you go magnus daniel bro", "BMT7BBZHigg-00088-00044024-00044318": "like he said he can right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00089-00044319-00044471": "just like", "BMT7BBZHigg-00090-00044472-00044855": "collapse", "BMT7BBZHigg-00091-00044856-00045167": "we cannot hear you bro", "BMT7BBZHigg-00092-00045168-00045487": "uh yeah i can make this nice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00093-00045488-00045735": "speed and power to pierre so piano need", "BMT7BBZHigg-00094-00045736-00046287": "to buy better fury", "BMT7BBZHigg-00095-00046288-00046546": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00096-00046547-00048295": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00097-00048296-00050167": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00098-00050168-00051254": "after you blink you will", "BMT7BBZHigg-00099-00051255-00051575": "so they cannot go in", "BMT7BBZHigg-00100-00051576-00052887": "sounds like a plan right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00101-00052888-00053230": "i mean combo with magnus any any aoe", "BMT7BBZHigg-00102-00053232-00054671": "would be good", "BMT7BBZHigg-00103-00054672-00054991": "the upheaval it", "BMT7BBZHigg-00104-00054991-00055247": "the third skill i i need for", "BMT7BBZHigg-00105-00055248-00055550": "warlock i need to cast the third skill", "BMT7BBZHigg-00106-00055551-00055799": "right now", "BMT7BBZHigg-00107-00055800-00056007": "skill is slow and then you are", "BMT7BBZHigg-00108-00056008-00056294": "channeling", "BMT7BBZHigg-00109-00056295-00056582": "ah yeah i need a glimmer cape for that", "BMT7BBZHigg-00110-00056583-00056711": "right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00111-00056712-00056823": "yeah", "BMT7BBZHigg-00112-00056824-00057047": "okay okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00113-00057048-00057311": "i remember now", "BMT7BBZHigg-00114-00057312-00058103": "but i need to cast it together", "BMT7BBZHigg-00115-00058104-00059966": "right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00116-00059967-00060279": "did they mention any penalty", "BMT7BBZHigg-00117-00060279-00060511": "no no what's a penalty ah", "BMT7BBZHigg-00118-00060512-00060766": "the penalty in pro", "BMT7BBZHigg-00119-00060767-00061023": "tournaments are", "BMT7BBZHigg-00120-00061024-00061135": "less", "BMT7BBZHigg-00121-00061136-00061223": "time", "BMT7BBZHigg-00122-00061224-00061342": "for", "BMT7BBZHigg-00123-00061344-00062230": "pick right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00124-00062232-00064423": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00125-00064424-00065263": "this is", "BMT7BBZHigg-00126-00065264-00066087": "all these flavors", "BMT7BBZHigg-00127-00066088-00066311": "they can beat us last time", "BMT7BBZHigg-00128-00066312-00068535": "their player is inactive", "BMT7BBZHigg-00129-00068536-00070055": "please", "BMT7BBZHigg-00130-00070056-00070759": "rocky", "BMT7BBZHigg-00131-00070760-00070959": "rocky is the one with", "BMT7BBZHigg-00132-00070960-00071182": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00133-00071183-00072023": "one with macro skills", "BMT7BBZHigg-00134-00072024-00072287": "o p", "BMT7BBZHigg-00135-00072288-00074038": "o p one", "BMT7BBZHigg-00136-00074039-00074462": "please", "BMT7BBZHigg-00137-00074463-00074879": "the last time we play with them we use", "BMT7BBZHigg-00138-00074880-00075287": "a scar", "BMT7BBZHigg-00139-00075288-00075447": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00140-00075448-00077879": "a scar he used husker", "BMT7BBZHigg-00141-00077880-00079750": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00142-00079751-00081662": "is very hard to counter", "BMT7BBZHigg-00143-00081663-00083718": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00144-00083719-00084918": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00145-00084919-00087726": "five seconds remaining", "BMT7BBZHigg-00146-00087727-00090541": "enemies", "BMT7BBZHigg-00147-00090542-00090687": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00148-00090688-00091638": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00149-00091639-00092150": "ten seconds remaining", "BMT7BBZHigg-00150-00092151-00093535": "five seconds remaining", "BMT7BBZHigg-00151-00093536-00093791": "maybe the other player was also mobile", "BMT7BBZHigg-00152-00093792-00094143": "legends", "BMT7BBZHigg-00153-00094144-00094262": "oh they say", "BMT7BBZHigg-00154-00094263-00094438": "the captain told me there's no people", "BMT7BBZHigg-00155-00094439-00095743": "mobility oh hi", "BMT7BBZHigg-00156-00095744-00097687": "enemies turn to ben", "BMT7BBZHigg-00157-00097688-00098038": "enemies turn to ban", "BMT7BBZHigg-00158-00098039-00098367": "yeah they use", "BMT7BBZHigg-00159-00098368-00100991": "i'm dying before", "BMT7BBZHigg-00160-00100992-00101335": "we will speak tagalog in leaning visa", "BMT7BBZHigg-00161-00101336-00101550": "jim and i okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00162-00101551-00101791": "but how you guys you guys are different", "BMT7BBZHigg-00163-00101792-00102031": "different lane", "BMT7BBZHigg-00164-00102032-00102159": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00165-00102160-00102318": "different", "BMT7BBZHigg-00166-00102319-00102558": "oh you you both are support so how you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00167-00102559-00102671": "guys are in", "BMT7BBZHigg-00168-00102672-00102815": "gym", "BMT7BBZHigg-00169-00102816-00103366": "oh yeah okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00170-00103367-00105254": "gyro okay i'm gonna ban ralph king sorry", "BMT7BBZHigg-00171-00105255-00110631": "enemies turn to pick", "BMT7BBZHigg-00172-00110632-00111295": "five seconds remaining", "BMT7BBZHigg-00173-00111296-00111519": "enemies turn to pick", "BMT7BBZHigg-00174-00111520-00111695": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00175-00111696-00111958": "i am going ss", "BMT7BBZHigg-00176-00111959-00113199": "nice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00177-00113200-00113702": "ten seconds remaining", "BMT7BBZHigg-00178-00113703-00114599": "five seconds remaining", "BMT7BBZHigg-00179-00114600-00115031": "bk", "BMT7BBZHigg-00180-00115032-00115790": "who picking the keys", "BMT7BBZHigg-00181-00115791-00116039": "i'm kidding i'm kidding", "BMT7BBZHigg-00182-00116040-00116719": "oh this one isn't too bad", "BMT7BBZHigg-00183-00116720-00117407": "i think they're gonna pick ba", "BMT7BBZHigg-00184-00117408-00117895": "ea you want me ben pa or pl", "BMT7BBZHigg-00185-00117896-00118143": "yeah i think", "BMT7BBZHigg-00186-00118144-00118415": "i think we can handle pl", "BMT7BBZHigg-00187-00118416-00118839": "because we have likeness empire", "BMT7BBZHigg-00188-00118840-00120343": "enemies", "BMT7BBZHigg-00189-00120344-00120734": "flame tide", "BMT7BBZHigg-00190-00120735-00120951": "ten seconds remaining", "BMT7BBZHigg-00191-00120952-00121031": "then", "BMT7BBZHigg-00192-00121032-00121278": "carry carry ck", "BMT7BBZHigg-00193-00121279-00121399": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00194-00121400-00121871": "okay two two choices the uh sf or dp", "BMT7BBZHigg-00195-00121872-00123263": "that", "BMT7BBZHigg-00196-00123264-00123713": "ls", "BMT7BBZHigg-00197-00123714-00123910": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00198-00123911-00124247": "you can think of", "BMT7BBZHigg-00199-00124248-00124631": "s e l f", "BMT7BBZHigg-00200-00124632-00125071": "e l f uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00201-00125072-00125319": "do we have a do we have a tank or do we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00202-00125320-00125454": "need a heater", "BMT7BBZHigg-00203-00125455-00125727": "dp can be tanked", "BMT7BBZHigg-00204-00125728-00125999": "because of the audi", "BMT7BBZHigg-00205-00126000-00126271": "and also and also can silence during the", "BMT7BBZHigg-00206-00126272-00126783": "war fight", "BMT7BBZHigg-00207-00126783-00127014": "it's your hero eric right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00208-00127015-00128871": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00209-00128872-00129102": "how to play od or dk", "BMT7BBZHigg-00210-00129103-00129263": "no just", "BMT7BBZHigg-00211-00129264-00129743": "i i think", "BMT7BBZHigg-00212-00129744-00130031": "yeah because they have this uh ck if you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00213-00130032-00130239": "don't know maybe just", "BMT7BBZHigg-00214-00130240-00130478": "i want counter i want counter qop i want", "BMT7BBZHigg-00215-00130479-00130766": "saunders ck", "BMT7BBZHigg-00216-00130767-00130863": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00217-00130864-00130983": "yeah audi", "BMT7BBZHigg-00218-00130983-00131239": "his ulti kills the", "BMT7BBZHigg-00219-00131240-00131399": "illusion first", "BMT7BBZHigg-00220-00131400-00131804": "pandaren has also", "BMT7BBZHigg-00221-00131805-00132783": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00222-00132784-00133014": "amber also has", "BMT7BBZHigg-00223-00133015-00133351": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00224-00133352-00133687": "i don't know i don't know", "BMT7BBZHigg-00225-00133688-00134311": "he put daniel bro", "BMT7BBZHigg-00226-00134312-00134590": "it's gonna go wrong i don't know it's", "BMT7BBZHigg-00227-00134591-00135423": "okay enemies let's go to pick okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00228-00135424-00135711": "you may now select your heroes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00229-00135712-00138335": "you can win ba right the a", "BMT7BBZHigg-00230-00138336-00139527": "so spice is made now", "BMT7BBZHigg-00231-00139528-00139654": "i'm not sure", "BMT7BBZHigg-00232-00139655-00139951": "they have they have two they have ck so", "BMT7BBZHigg-00233-00139952-00140783": "type offlane ck is safely", "BMT7BBZHigg-00234-00140784-00141175": "guys", "BMT7BBZHigg-00235-00141176-00141366": "i need shakiro to clear", "BMT7BBZHigg-00236-00141367-00142647": "ck illusion", "BMT7BBZHigg-00237-00142648-00144302": "prepare for battle", "BMT7BBZHigg-00238-00144303-00144471": "need i can put", "BMT7BBZHigg-00239-00144472-00144766": "you just put sentry", "BMT7BBZHigg-00240-00144767-00146687": "i got this", "BMT7BBZHigg-00241-00146688-00148027": "thank you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00242-00148028-00148487": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00243-00148488-00148863": "each block", "BMT7BBZHigg-00244-00148864-00149199": "i knew daniel", "BMT7BBZHigg-00245-00149200-00149311": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00246-00149312-00149631": "i need you to communicate with melania", "BMT7BBZHigg-00247-00149632-00149712": "marlon is", "BMT7BBZHigg-00248-00149713-00149966": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00249-00149967-00150254": "he uh support you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00250-00150255-00150453": "coming in coming coming", "BMT7BBZHigg-00251-00150454-00150671": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00252-00150672-00150901": "hey okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00253-00150902-00152126": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00254-00152127-00152239": "sky", "BMT7BBZHigg-00255-00152240-00152847": "embraces", "BMT7BBZHigg-00256-00152848-00153639": "we fly", "BMT7BBZHigg-00257-00153640-00155366": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00258-00155367-00155671": "your top tower is under attack", "BMT7BBZHigg-00259-00155672-00155814": "shall we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00260-00155815-00156383": "after you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00261-00156384-00157751": "freeze and burn", "BMT7BBZHigg-00262-00157752-00159263": "the freezing drain", "BMT7BBZHigg-00263-00159264-00159943": "we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00264-00159944-00162207": "nature", "BMT7BBZHigg-00265-00162208-00162526": "here", "BMT7BBZHigg-00266-00162527-00163078": "we go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00267-00163079-00164199": "we blow hot", "BMT7BBZHigg-00268-00164200-00166678": "freeze and burn", "BMT7BBZHigg-00269-00166679-00167711": "i", "BMT7BBZHigg-00270-00167712-00169063": "52 seconds", "BMT7BBZHigg-00271-00169064-00171783": "foreign", "BMT7BBZHigg-00272-00171784-00172159": "because i don't see any communication", "BMT7BBZHigg-00273-00172160-00173519": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00274-00173520-00174799": "he's under level", "BMT7BBZHigg-00275-00174800-00175412": "nice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00276-00175413-00176254": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00277-00176255-00177814": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00278-00177815-00180407": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00279-00180408-00181054": "foreign", "BMT7BBZHigg-00280-00181055-00181359": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00281-00181360-00183407": "shall we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00282-00183408-00184831": "hey i'm sorry", "BMT7BBZHigg-00283-00184832-00184926": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00284-00184927-00185087": "i need", "BMT7BBZHigg-00285-00185088-00185519": "i need me what", "BMT7BBZHigg-00286-00185520-00185814": "anyone is buying what", "BMT7BBZHigg-00287-00185815-00186023": "can you can leave one word for me uh ta", "BMT7BBZHigg-00288-00186024-00188071": "missing ta missing okay back ready", "BMT7BBZHigg-00289-00188072-00188711": "i don't know", "BMT7BBZHigg-00290-00188712-00190295": "erica", "BMT7BBZHigg-00291-00190296-00190860": "have you taken the rune", "BMT7BBZHigg-00292-00190861-00194623": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00293-00194624-00196095": "guys", "BMT7BBZHigg-00294-00196096-00196566": "i'm gonna freeze and burn", "BMT7BBZHigg-00295-00196567-00200590": "okay i'm winning my knees", "BMT7BBZHigg-00296-00200591-00201399": "[Applause]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00297-00201400-00203119": "uh you need my help no no no no", "BMT7BBZHigg-00298-00203120-00204172": "just be patient", "BMT7BBZHigg-00299-00204173-00205582": "[Applause]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00300-00205583-00207079": "here", "BMT7BBZHigg-00301-00207080-00211255": "mission", "BMT7BBZHigg-00302-00211256-00214303": "shall we please give me", "BMT7BBZHigg-00303-00214304-00214631": "yes constantly you didn't tell me", "BMT7BBZHigg-00304-00214632-00214742": "i didn't know", "BMT7BBZHigg-00305-00214744-00218239": "ok", "BMT7BBZHigg-00306-00218240-00219206": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00307-00219207-00222663": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00308-00222664-00222942": "nice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00309-00222944-00223615": "nice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00310-00223616-00223894": "so far too far too far", "BMT7BBZHigg-00311-00223896-00224798": "yeah", "BMT7BBZHigg-00312-00224798-00224958": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00313-00224959-00229303": "it's it has no", "BMT7BBZHigg-00314-00229304-00230721": "i give you i give you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00315-00230723-00230879": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00316-00230880-00232503": "tower", "BMT7BBZHigg-00317-00232504-00232703": "uh i already got emmy", "BMT7BBZHigg-00318-00232704-00233023": "huh okay i gotta go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00319-00233023-00233255": "i can i can okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00320-00233256-00233382": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00321-00233383-00234934": "someone back", "BMT7BBZHigg-00322-00234935-00236510": "me", "BMT7BBZHigg-00323-00236511-00237663": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00324-00237664-00239063": "push", "BMT7BBZHigg-00325-00239064-00240567": "all right go back go back", "BMT7BBZHigg-00326-00240567-00240823": "here", "BMT7BBZHigg-00327-00240823-00242334": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00328-00242335-00242534": "coming bottom", "BMT7BBZHigg-00329-00242535-00243259": "37 seconds", "BMT7BBZHigg-00330-00243260-00243519": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00331-00243519-00243694": "i got smoke", "BMT7BBZHigg-00332-00243696-00243863": "can you join or what", "BMT7BBZHigg-00333-00243864-00244063": "okay let's go go smoke", "BMT7BBZHigg-00334-00244064-00244319": "let's go you guys just go i got inima", "BMT7BBZHigg-00335-00244319-00244519": "first you see", "BMT7BBZHigg-00336-00244519-00244910": "gold", "BMT7BBZHigg-00337-00244911-00247798": "x lion", "BMT7BBZHigg-00338-00247800-00248119": "if you want i have ulti i i want to find", "BMT7BBZHigg-00339-00248119-00248279": "i want to find others", "BMT7BBZHigg-00340-00248280-00248623": "you want to fight others let's go smoke", "BMT7BBZHigg-00341-00248623-00248871": "no no i got indi", "BMT7BBZHigg-00342-00248871-00249151": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00343-00249152-00251055": "daniel let's go got", "BMT7BBZHigg-00344-00251056-00251542": "eric daniel we can go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00345-00251544-00253079": "two ways up your middle tower", "BMT7BBZHigg-00346-00253080-00253763": "nice one nice youtuber", "BMT7BBZHigg-00347-00253764-00255751": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00348-00255752-00258319": "ice advances", "BMT7BBZHigg-00349-00258319-00258551": "wow", "BMT7BBZHigg-00350-00258552-00258863": "we own them at this game shall we yeah", "BMT7BBZHigg-00351-00258864-00259039": "yes sir", "BMT7BBZHigg-00352-00259040-00259228": "maintenance is", "BMT7BBZHigg-00353-00259229-00259551": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00354-00259552-00259871": "uh what's next uh let's go push bottom", "BMT7BBZHigg-00355-00259873-00260023": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00356-00260023-00260294": "or let's push mid if you want i have ice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00357-00260296-00260734": "but we can kill this one this guy", "BMT7BBZHigg-00358-00260735-00260982": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00359-00260983-00261367": "i'm gonna keep this guy", "BMT7BBZHigg-00360-00261367-00261551": "10 seconds alright forgot century or", "BMT7BBZHigg-00361-00261552-00262079": "sentry", "BMT7BBZHigg-00362-00262080-00262327": "oh [__]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00363-00262328-00262582": "illusion dude three sorry sorry my butt", "BMT7BBZHigg-00364-00262583-00262799": "my butt my butt my butt just use just", "BMT7BBZHigg-00365-00262800-00263047": "use first skill first to test", "BMT7BBZHigg-00366-00263048-00265879": "don't straight out um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00367-00265880-00266230": "see what you've done", "BMT7BBZHigg-00368-00266231-00266582": "ready i got ice spot for lion", "BMT7BBZHigg-00369-00266583-00266855": "okay there three there three", "BMT7BBZHigg-00370-00266856-00267015": "you're ready", "BMT7BBZHigg-00371-00267016-00267655": "to get this one second 79 seconds", "BMT7BBZHigg-00372-00267656-00267830": "don't be in trouble yeah they have", "BMT7BBZHigg-00373-00267831-00267999": "vision now so i don't convert we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00374-00268000-00268215": "shouldn't they have every wishes entry", "BMT7BBZHigg-00375-00268216-00268710": "everywhere", "BMT7BBZHigg-00376-00268711-00270351": "i got bkb now", "BMT7BBZHigg-00377-00270352-00270847": "um lion here lion here nice one boy", "BMT7BBZHigg-00378-00270848-00271030": "two seconds one", "BMT7BBZHigg-00379-00271031-00271167": "and go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00380-00271168-00272263": "oh [__]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00381-00272264-00272919": "hey", "BMT7BBZHigg-00382-00272920-00273895": "thank you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00383-00273896-00274293": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00384-00274294-00275287": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00385-00275288-00275767": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00386-00275768-00276775": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00387-00276776-00277406": "all right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00388-00277407-00278064": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00389-00278065-00279975": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00390-00279976-00280310": "is", "BMT7BBZHigg-00391-00280311-00280799": "shall we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00392-00280800-00282703": "hello", "BMT7BBZHigg-00393-00282704-00282882": "okay it's", "BMT7BBZHigg-00394-00282883-00283223": "okay answer thank you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00395-00283224-00283758": "your middle tower is under attack", "BMT7BBZHigg-00396-00283759-00283946": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00397-00283947-00285663": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00398-00285664-00286927": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00399-00286928-00287279": "i want to find them here", "BMT7BBZHigg-00400-00287280-00288087": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00401-00288088-00288415": "uh you guys i have 11 seconds uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00402-00288416-00288534": "uh uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00403-00288535-00288727": "uh jim from", "BMT7BBZHigg-00404-00288728-00288967": "gym from top i got smoke", "BMT7BBZHigg-00405-00288968-00289303": "eric", "BMT7BBZHigg-00406-00289304-00289654": "let's go okay okay let's go i can eat", "BMT7BBZHigg-00407-00289655-00289799": "okay let's go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00408-00289800-00291254": "let's go eric", "BMT7BBZHigg-00409-00291255-00292591": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00410-00292592-00293799": "nice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00411-00293800-00294305": "um i think you can push go and push", "BMT7BBZHigg-00412-00294306-00295406": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00413-00295407-00295879": "all right okay so i have", "BMT7BBZHigg-00414-00295880-00295991": "i have", "BMT7BBZHigg-00415-00295992-00296630": "forced up ready", "BMT7BBZHigg-00416-00296631-00296863": "suppose i have uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00417-00296864-00297343": "words", "BMT7BBZHigg-00418-00297344-00297567": "bombing with", "BMT7BBZHigg-00419-00297568-00298282": "this one", "BMT7BBZHigg-00420-00298283-00298543": "sorry hey guys", "BMT7BBZHigg-00421-00298544-00298767": "i think you should go back", "BMT7BBZHigg-00422-00298768-00299119": "first", "BMT7BBZHigg-00423-00299120-00299391": "i got let me go let me", "BMT7BBZHigg-00424-00299392-00299679": "uh let me go get some soar i need some", "BMT7BBZHigg-00425-00299680-00300634": "i'll", "BMT7BBZHigg-00426-00300635-00301095": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00427-00301096-00302250": "the updrafts", "BMT7BBZHigg-00428-00302251-00302695": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00429-00302696-00302934": "the skies are ours", "BMT7BBZHigg-00430-00302935-00303158": "your top tower is under it your beat", "BMT7BBZHigg-00431-00303159-00305087": "bottom", "BMT7BBZHigg-00432-00305088-00305543": "uh jim careful they're missing uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00433-00305544-00307587": "shall we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00434-00307588-00307727": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00435-00307728-00307815": "i got", "BMT7BBZHigg-00436-00307816-00308151": "i got smoke coming", "BMT7BBZHigg-00437-00308152-00308254": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00438-00308255-00308558": "all missing or missing", "BMT7BBZHigg-00439-00308559-00308719": "i got me i got", "BMT7BBZHigg-00440-00308720-00308847": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00441-00308848-00309119": "lion got dagger", "BMT7BBZHigg-00442-00309120-00309319": "nine got dagger right", "BMT7BBZHigg-00443-00309320-00310423": "i'm not sure", "BMT7BBZHigg-00444-00310424-00313639": "damage", "BMT7BBZHigg-00445-00313640-00315063": "there you go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00446-00315064-00316454": "it's a good", "BMT7BBZHigg-00447-00316455-00317624": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00448-00317625-00320663": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00449-00320664-00322023": "we", "BMT7BBZHigg-00450-00322024-00323567": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00451-00323568-00324015": "no one's there they're all dead", "BMT7BBZHigg-00452-00324016-00326239": "no i mean i mean how many hecks", "BMT7BBZHigg-00453-00326240-00327351": "has", "BMT7BBZHigg-00454-00327352-00327830": "yes yes yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00455-00327831-00328399": "i wanna suck some life", "BMT7BBZHigg-00456-00328400-00328687": "i wanna suck some life", "BMT7BBZHigg-00457-00328688-00328934": "hey who put the word like that", "BMT7BBZHigg-00458-00328935-00329263": "me i thought you already get it", "BMT7BBZHigg-00459-00329264-00329567": "me", "BMT7BBZHigg-00460-00329568-00329767": "fine people what", "BMT7BBZHigg-00461-00329768-00329863": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00462-00329864-00330215": "earlier laning stage", "BMT7BBZHigg-00463-00330216-00330375": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00464-00330376-00330527": "i thought you", "BMT7BBZHigg-00465-00330528-00330751": "delete it oh you get it if you want hold", "BMT7BBZHigg-00466-00330752-00331951": "on my word alone", "BMT7BBZHigg-00467-00331952-00332175": "hey guys let's go finish this i got", "BMT7BBZHigg-00468-00332176-00332430": "satanic now", "BMT7BBZHigg-00469-00332431-00332663": "let's go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00470-00332664-00333151": "i can tank", "BMT7BBZHigg-00471-00333152-00333439": "i got a guest let's go please let them", "BMT7BBZHigg-00472-00333440-00333647": "let them skew off let them secure me let", "BMT7BBZHigg-00473-00333648-00334230": "them kill me", "BMT7BBZHigg-00474-00334231-00334406": "just stand behind me stand behind me", "BMT7BBZHigg-00475-00334407-00335127": "yeah let let tide left tight", "BMT7BBZHigg-00476-00335128-00336591": "okay let's go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00477-00336592-00337967": "let me think", "BMT7BBZHigg-00478-00337968-00338591": "okay it's my time", "BMT7BBZHigg-00479-00338592-00338830": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00480-00338831-00340015": "nice one", "BMT7BBZHigg-00481-00340016-00341647": "laughs", "BMT7BBZHigg-00482-00341648-00342967": "my bad", "BMT7BBZHigg-00483-00342968-00343134": "supposed to be the arcane boots sorry my", "BMT7BBZHigg-00484-00343135-00343271": "buddy", "BMT7BBZHigg-00485-00343272-00344215": "yes i said but i don't know", "BMT7BBZHigg-00486-00344216-00344471": "seriously bye-bye", "BMT7BBZHigg-00487-00344472-00345419": "wow", "BMT7BBZHigg-00488-00345420-00345767": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00489-00345768-00347310": "collapse", "BMT7BBZHigg-00490-00347311-00347630": "i am going study guys", "BMT7BBZHigg-00491-00347631-00347799": "there you go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00492-00347800-00347907": "i'm so fun huh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00493-00347908-00348054": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00494-00348055-00348865": "yes", "BMT7BBZHigg-00495-00348866-00349103": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00496-00349104-00352854": "supposed to be finished already", "BMT7BBZHigg-00497-00352855-00353639": "i got white i got whites", "BMT7BBZHigg-00498-00353640-00353927": "nice", "BMT7BBZHigg-00499-00353928-00355158": "the enemies", "BMT7BBZHigg-00500-00355159-00356247": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00501-00356248-00356657": "um", "BMT7BBZHigg-00502-00356658-00357551": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00503-00357552-00357934": "oh no i'm dead", "BMT7BBZHigg-00504-00357935-00358719": "nice one", "BMT7BBZHigg-00505-00358720-00359951": "great", "BMT7BBZHigg-00506-00359952-00361103": "[Music]", "BMT7BBZHigg-00507-00361104-00362191": "is", "BMT7BBZHigg-00508-00362192-00363927": "the enemy's top barracks has fallen", "BMT7BBZHigg-00509-00363928-00366391": "very good", "BMT7BBZHigg-00510-00366392-00367887": "uh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00511-00367888-00369230": "oh", "BMT7BBZHigg-00512-00369231-00369399": "okay", "BMT7BBZHigg-00513-00369400-00372399": "bye guys", "BMT7BBZHigg-00514-00372400-00372695": "third place", "BMT7BBZHigg-00515-00372696-00372806": "melon", "BMT7BBZHigg-00516-00372807-00372943": "and", "BMT7BBZHigg-00517-00372944-00373830": "let's go", "BMT7BBZHigg-00518-00373831-00374943": "big party", "BMT7BBZHigg-00519-00374944-00375663": "is", "BMT7BBZHigg-00520-00375664-00375872": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "BMWOWLyWm4Q", "text": {"BMWOWLyWm4Q-00000-00000014-00000383": "the autobiography of Mark Twain refers", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00001-00000384-00000624": "to a lengthy set of reminiscences", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00002-00000625-00000919": "dictated for the most part in the last", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00003-00000921-00001133": "few years of American author Mark", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00004-00001134-00001424": "Twain's life and left in typescript and", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00005-00001425-00001607": "manuscript at his death", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00006-00001607-00001979": "the autobiography comprises a rambling", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00007-00001980-00002234": "collection of anecdotes and ruminations", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00008-00002235-00002554": "rather than a conventional autobiography", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00009-00002555-00002884": "Twain never compiled these writings and", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00010-00002885-00003160": "dictation Zinn - a publishable form in", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00011-00003161-00003529": "his lifetime despite indications from", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00012-00003530-00003724": "Twain that he did not want his", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00013-00003725-00003950": "autobiography to be published for a", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00014-00003951-00004250": "century he serialized some chapters from", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00015-00004251-00004568": "my autobiography during his lifetime and", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00016-00004569-00004790": "various compilations were published", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00017-00004791-00005143": "during the 20th century however it", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00018-00005144-00005441": "wasn't until 2010 in the 100th", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00019-00005442-00005711": "anniversary year of Twain's death that", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00020-00005712-00005897": "the first volume of a comprehensive", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00021-00005898-00006184": "collection compiled and edited by the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00022-00006185-00006431": "Mark Twain project of the Bancroft", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00023-00006431-00006709": "library at University of California", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00024-00006711-00007417": "Berkeley was published", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00025-00007418-00007763": "topic Twain's writings and dictation", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00026-00007764-00008171": "'he's", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00027-00008172-00008452": "Twain first started to compose an", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00028-00008453-00008795": "autobiography in 1870 but proceeded", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00029-00008796-00009014": "fitfully abandoning the work and", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00030-00009015-00009231": "returning to it as the mood took him", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00031-00009232-00009602": "amassing around 30 to 40 of these false", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00032-00009603-00010042": "starts over the next 35 years", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00033-00010043-00010359": "the bulk of the autobiography was", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00034-00010360-00010602": "dictated rather than written directly", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00035-00010603-00010941": "this was described by a 2010 review", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00036-00010942-00011280": "errors having a secretary follow him", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00037-00011281-00011562": "around and take down his every passing", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00038-00011563-00012030": "thought in a 1904 letter to William Dean", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00039-00012031-00012413": "Howells he wrote I've struck it and I", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00040-00012414-00012744": "will give it away to you you will never", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00041-00012745-00012990": "know how much enjoyment you have lost", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00042-00012991-00013166": "until you get to dictating your", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00043-00013168-00013308": "autobiography", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00044-00013309-00013594": "these dictations were made frequently in", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00045-00013595-00014088": "1906 and 1907 Twain then seems to have", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00046-00014088-00014418": "let the book languish in 1908 to nine he", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00047-00014419-00014640": "hardly added to it at all and he", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00048-00014641-00014952": "declared the project concluded in 1909", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00049-00014953-00015171": "after the death of his youngest daughter", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00050-00015172-00015662": "Jean his innovative notion to talk only", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00051-00015663-00015909": "about the thing which interests you for", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00052-00015910-00016163": "the moment meant that his thoughts could", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00053-00016165-00016478": "range freely Twain thought his", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00054-00016479-00016674": "autobiography would be most entertaining", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00055-00016675-00017000": "if he went off on whims and tangents in", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00056-00017001-00017159": "non-sequential order", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00057-00017160-00017361": "Twain's papers including the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00058-00017362-00017652": "autobiographical works were left as part", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00059-00017653-00017865": "of a trust for the benefit of his", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00060-00017866-00018234": "surviving daughter Clara Clemens these", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00061-00018235-00018492": "papers passed through the control of a", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00062-00018493-00018825": "number of editors and have since 1971", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00063-00018826-00019161": "been held by the Bancroft library at the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00064-00019162-00019935": "University of California Berkeley", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00065-00019936-00020655": "topic plans for posthumous publication", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00066-00020656-00020982": "writings by twaimz show intent for the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00067-00020983-00021258": "majority of the material to be published", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00068-00021259-00021591": "posthumously in an interview for The", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00069-00021592-00021966": "Times in 1899 Twain was reported to be", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00070-00021967-00022155": "considering a work which would be", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00071-00022156-00022404": "unpublished for a century Twain wrote", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00072-00022405-00022731": "instructions for future editors heirs", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00073-00022732-00023211": "and assigns in 1904 in these he", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00074-00023212-00023415": "celebrates that posthumous publication", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00075-00023416-00023730": "allowed him to speak with his whole", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00076-00023731-00024156": "Frank mind these also outlined a", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00077-00024157-00024387": "century-long plan of publications", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00078-00024388-00024591": "twenty-five years apart with", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00079-00024592-00024774": "progressively more potentially", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00080-00024775-00025134": "controversial material included in the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00081-00025135-00025380": "introduction to the second edition of", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00082-00025381-00025640": "Mark Twain's own autobiography the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00083-00025641-00025869": "chapters from the North American review", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00084-00025870-00026177": "the scholar michael kiske purports that", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00085-00026179-00026427": "these delays was less due to Twain's", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00086-00026427-00026724": "purported concern for those who could be", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00087-00026725-00026982": "aggrieved by the text and more likely an", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00088-00026983-00027267": "attempt to extend the copyright various", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00089-00027268-00027612": "modern reports refer to a 100-year", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00090-00027613-00027986": "embargo imposed by Twain on his own", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00091-00027987-00028263": "autobiographies release which expired in", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00092-00028264-00028745": "2010 topic twentieth-century", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00093-00028745-00029031": "publications Twain himself had published", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00094-00029032-00029367": "chapters from my autobiography in 25", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00095-00029368-00029595": "installments in the North American", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00096-00029595-00030008": "review in 1906 to seven since Twain's", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00097-00030010-00030308": "death in 1910 a number of different", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00098-00030310-00030552": "editors have made attempts to impose", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00099-00030552-00030789": "some order on the whole of the material", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00100-00030789-00031010": "by selection and reorganization", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00101-00031011-00031283": "producing several decidedly different", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00102-00031285-00031637": "published versions of the autobiography", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00103-00031638-00031944": "creating a publishable autobiography", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00104-00031945-00032187": "from the disorganized mass of Twain's", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00105-00032188-00032454": "unpublished writings has proven to be a", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00106-00032455-00032736": "significant challenge and access to the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00107-00032737-00033024": "physical materials of Twain's papers was", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00108-00033025-00033267": "for the first half century greatly", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00109-00033268-00033480": "limited to just small numbers of", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00110-00033481-00033780": "scholars the partial autobiography was", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00111-00033781-00034035": "published in 1924 by", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00112-00034036-00034268": "Harper and brothers consisting of about", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00113-00034269-00034605": "two-fifths of the material it was", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00114-00034606-00034883": "compiled by personal friend and literary", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00115-00034884-00035192": "executor Albert Bigelow Paine who at the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00116-00035193-00035451": "time had exclusive access to Twain's", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00117-00035452-00035745": "papers editor and historian Bernard de", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00118-00035746-00035979": "voto succeeded Payne as literary", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00119-00035980-00036285": "executor for the Clemens estate and used", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00120-00036286-00036530": "his access to the material to produce", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00121-00036531-00036827": "for book collections of autobiography", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00122-00036828-00037227": "material Mark Twain in eruption 1940 the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00123-00037228-00037629": "portable Mark Twain 1946 Mark Twain at", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00124-00037630-00037973": "work 1952 and letters from the earth", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00125-00037974-00038402": "1960 to the much-delayed publication of", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00126-00038403-00038655": "the latter was due to objections from", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00127-00038656-00038955": "Clara Clemens two publications were made", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00128-00038956-00039180": "from rearrangements of previously", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00129-00039181-00039630": "published work in 1959 Charles NIDA", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00130-00039631-00039957": "rejected both pains in order of creation", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00131-00039958-00040165": "and devote owes arranged by topic", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00132-00040166-00040457": "approaches and rearranged material to", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00133-00040458-00040682": "match the chronology of a standard", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00134-00040683-00041099": "autobiography in 1990 republished", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00135-00041100-00041405": "February 2010 scholar Michael Kiske", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00136-00041406-00041633": "edited Mark Twain's own autobiography", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00137-00041634-00041904": "the chapters from the North American", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00138-00041905-00042530": "review", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00139-00042531-00043277": "topic Mark Twain project edition the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00140-00043278-00043508": "Mark Twain project of the Bancroft", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00141-00043509-00043792": "library undertook to produce a complete", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00142-00043793-00044039": "autobiography of Twain based upon", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00143-00044040-00044351": "material within their collection the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00144-00044352-00044685": "stated goal is to publish the complete", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00145-00044686-00044982": "text as nearly as possible in the way", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00146-00044983-00045273": "Mark Twain intended it to be published", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00147-00045274-00045689": "after his death this was published in", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00148-00045690-00046085": "three volumes between 2010 and 2015 with", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00149-00046086-00046385": "the first in the 100th anniversary year", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00150-00046386-00046745": "of Twain's death all three volumes are", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00151-00046746-00047018": "available online with introductions and", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00152-00047019-00047270": "historical annotation from the editors", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00153-00047271-00047633": "also included with the text the head", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00154-00047634-00047912": "editor for this work was Harriet Eleanor", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00155-00047913-00048425": "Smith", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00156-00048426-00048980": "topic vol 1", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00157-00048981-00049204": "the first volume of a three-volume", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00158-00049205-00049762": "edition runs to 760 pages it includes", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00159-00049763-00050033": "introductory material explaining how", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00160-00050034-00050339": "trains autobiography was written then", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00161-00050340-00050587": "follows Twain's early fragmentary", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00162-00050588-00050840": "attempts at writing it and the text of", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00163-00050841-00051131": "his autobiographical dictations the main", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00164-00051132-00051420": "series beginning on the 10th of January", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00165-00051421-00051857": "1906 volume 1 collects these up until", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00166-00051858-00052669": "the 30th of March 1906", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00167-00052670-00053219": "topic vol 2", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00168-00053220-00053594": "Volume two was published in October 2013", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00169-00053595-00054130": "and runs to 736 pages this collects", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00170-00054132-00054440": "dictations from the 2nd of April 1906", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00171-00054441-00055334": "until the 28th of February 1907", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00172-00055335-00055885": "topic vol 3", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00173-00055886-00056173": "the third and final volume of the Mark", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00174-00056174-00056437": "Twain project edition was published in", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00175-00056438-00056610": "October 2015", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00176-00056611-00057157": "it contains 792 pages with entries dated", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00177-00057158-00057529": "from the first of March 1907 to the 21st", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00178-00057529-00057988": "of October 1909 Twain's autobiography", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00179-00057989-00058252": "closes with a piece written in December", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00180-00058253-00058528": "1909 where he laments the death of his", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00181-00058529-00058801": "daughter Jean and declares that with her", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00182-00058802-00059030": "his motivation for writing the", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00183-00059032-00059239": "autobiography has died", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00184-00059240-00059449": "Suffolk seing this the volume also", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00185-00059450-00059944": "contains the 429 page Ashcroft Leone", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00186-00059945-00060291": "manuscript in this Twain attacks his", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00187-00060292-00060385": "secretary", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00188-00060386-00060691": "Isabel Leon and business manager Ralph", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00189-00060691-00060937": "Ashcroft for alleged embezzlement of", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00190-00060938-00061108": "money from the author and for", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00191-00061109-00061351": "manipulation of Twain's relationship", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00192-00061352-00061678": "with Jeanne much to her distress it", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00193-00061679-00061903": "takes the form of a letter to William", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00194-00061904-00062158": "Dean Howells though it was never sent", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00195-00062159-00062497": "nor intended to be so it was not", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00196-00062498-00062752": "intended by Twain to include this as", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00197-00062753-00063016": "part of his autobiography and it had", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00198-00063016-00063291": "never been published prior to 2015", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00199-00063292-00063553": "though it had been available to scholars", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00200-00063554-00064000": "as part of his papers the 21st century", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00201-00064001-00064216": "editors considered it sufficiently", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00202-00064216-00064435": "important to include within this", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00203-00064436-00065066": "publication", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00204-00065066-00065810": "topic copyright status the version", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00205-00065811-00066110": "published in 2010 representing Twain's", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00206-00066111-00066395": "attempts from 1906 and earlier would", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00207-00066396-00066704": "have entered the public domain by 2019", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00208-00066705-00067079": "under ordinary circumstances the state", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00209-00067080-00067280": "of the law at the time of his death", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00210-00067281-00067634": "notwithstanding the 1976 revision", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00211-00067635-00067880": "provided that unpublished works created", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00212-00067881-00068246": "before January 1st 1978 would have", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00213-00068247-00068602": "entered the public domain by 2003", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00214-00068603-00068932": "however the publishers the Mark Twain", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00215-00068933-00069176": "Foundation and the University of", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00216-00069177-00069458": "California Press published the 2010", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00217-00069459-00069815": "version in secret on microfilm in 2001", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00218-00069816-00070150": "selling all three upcoming volumes for", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00219-00070151-00070589": "$50,000 because of this the 2010 version", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00220-00070590-00071021": "bears copyright marks for 2001 and 2010", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00221-00071022-00071204": "and will not enter the public domain", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00222-00071205-00071735": "until 2040 7 137 years after Mark", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00223-00071736-00072095": "Twain's death David boliya criticized", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00224-00072096-00072359": "the foundation and UC press for this", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00225-00072360-00072638": "move saying so is the argument that", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00226-00072639-00072872": "academic presses have a special", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00227-00072873-00073139": "entitlement to gain the usual terms of", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00228-00073140-00073349": "copyright law because they are doing", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00229-00073350-00073724": "God's work as academic presses copyright", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00230-00073725-00073976": "industries frequently inveigh against", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00231-00073977-00074240": "that theft of sharing copyrighted works", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00232-00074241-00074522": "online solemnly in turning that the law", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00233-00074523-00074876": "is the law so is a theft not a theft", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00234-00074877-00075134": "when the victim is the public and not a", "BMWOWLyWm4Q-00235-00075135-00075515": "private copyright holder"}}, {"audio_id": "BN9CnIPCLw4", "text": {"BN9CnIPCLw4-00000-00000080-00001891": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00001-00001892-00002958": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00002-00002959-00004022": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00003-00004023-00005002": "but it's worth it when you're with me", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00004-00005003-00005683": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00005-00005684-00005805": "be", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00006-00005806-00006199": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00007-00006200-00007767": "when just mention me", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00008-00007768-00009310": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00009-00009311-00009631": "when it comes to love we", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00010-00009632-00010348": "feel the rage", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00011-00010349-00011283": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00012-00011284-00012463": "is", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00013-00012464-00013200": "but i guess we're just meant to be", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00014-00013201-00014083": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00015-00014084-00014246": "be", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00016-00014247-00015040": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00017-00015041-00015863": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00018-00015865-00016783": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00019-00016784-00017141": "just mentioned me", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00020-00017142-00018519": "[Music]", "BN9CnIPCLw4-00021-00018520-00018728": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "BNJ7QDgE60E", "text": {"BNJ7QDgE60E-00000-00000016-00000214": "what's up peers and welcome to the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00001-00000215-00000543": "wasabi wallet 2.0 release party", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00002-00000544-00000782": "uh we have been tinkering on some pretty", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00003-00000783-00000966": "cool bitcoin technology over the last", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00004-00000967-00001127": "two and a half years", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00005-00001128-00001327": "and now finally", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00006-00001328-00001470": "it's to a point where it's good enough", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00007-00001471-00001759": "to release so we're quite excited a lot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00008-00001760-00001942": "of thoughts and a lot of research and a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00009-00001943-00002079": "lot of work", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00010-00002080-00002359": "from quite many contributors", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00011-00002360-00002567": "have been part of this software", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00012-00002568-00002734": "development and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00013-00002735-00002958": "we're quite proud of what we've achieved", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00014-00002959-00003071": "so today", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00015-00003072-00003335": "a big chunk of the team is here for us", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00016-00003336-00003575": "to celebrate that big monumental mind", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00017-00003576-00003975": "stone to hopefully make that vision of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00018-00003976-00004279": "a monetary system that is not just sound", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00019-00004280-00004438": "and hard and verifiable", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00020-00004439-00004743": "but also private for everyday users by", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00021-00004744-00004863": "default", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00022-00004864-00005079": "and i think we've done some quite", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00023-00005080-00005302": "substantial contributions to that vision", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00024-00005303-00005575": "of frictionless and effortless privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00025-00005576-00005767": "by default for bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00026-00005768-00005934": "by solving a lot of these difficult", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00027-00005935-00006095": "problems on the client side and that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00028-00006096-00006327": "what wasabi wallet is all about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00029-00006328-00006495": "um so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00030-00006495-00006767": "maybe adam a couple words from you tell", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00031-00006768-00006870": "us", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00032-00006872-00007127": "why we're working on 2.0 and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00033-00007128-00007334": "what does what this technology means to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00034-00007336-00007510": "you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00035-00007511-00007598": "wow", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00036-00007600-00007767": "where should i start", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00037-00007768-00007967": "i have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00038-00007968-00008287": "created the first plans about wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00039-00008288-00008559": "roller in 2015", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00040-00008560-00008678": "christmas", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00041-00008679-00008767": "eve", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00042-00008768-00008855": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00043-00008856-00009255": "fast forward 3 years in 2018 we actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00044-00009256-00009542": "launched the company and released wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00045-00009543-00009774": "wallet 1.2", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00046-00009775-00009991": "which was the bitcoin wallet that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00047-00009992-00010159": "enabled", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00048-00010160-00010335": "privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00049-00010336-00010678": "on bitcoin for the first time for light", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00050-00010679-00010855": "wallet users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00051-00010856-00011271": "the thing here is that enabling privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00052-00011272-00011567": "is not the same as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00053-00011568-00012023": "as as being able to use a wallet in just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00054-00012024-00012206": "in the same way", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00055-00012207-00012446": "as any other bitcoin wallet would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00056-00012447-00012710": "without privacy we want to have the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00057-00012711-00013015": "exact same user experience and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00058-00013016-00013263": "and also we will let user experience", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00059-00013263-00013383": "were", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00060-00013384-00013503": "quiet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00061-00013504-00013911": "advanced it was it was challenging", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00062-00013912-00014015": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00063-00014016-00014083": "in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00064-00014084-00014366": "2020 we started", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00065-00014368-00014566": "a research club", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00066-00014568-00014894": "wasabi research club in january", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00067-00014895-00015183": "and we started reviewing every single", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00068-00015184-00015503": "bitcoin privacy research paper", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00069-00015504-00015743": "up until that point and often even", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00070-00015744-00015919": "interviewed the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00071-00015919-00016158": "the authors of the research papers and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00072-00016159-00016486": "you know when we've done our research on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00073-00016487-00016703": "bitcoin privacy and figured out how we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00074-00016704-00016863": "can do", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00075-00016864-00016975": "better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00076-00016976-00017207": "on the privacy side", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00077-00017208-00017375": "we also", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00078-00017376-00017694": "started to completely rethink the user", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00079-00017695-00017886": "experience of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00080-00017887-00017991": "wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00081-00017992-00018263": "and and we actually ended up in a very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00082-00018264-00018503": "fortunate position", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00083-00018504-00018663": "here which", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00084-00018664-00018919": "you know i couldn't even dreamt of that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00085-00018920-00019255": "many ui developers are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00086-00019256-00019550": "maintainers of our ur framework are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00087-00019551-00019943": "working with us joined to us", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00088-00019944-00020271": "on this on this mission for this cause", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00089-00020272-00020535": "and you know no other software project", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00090-00020536-00020783": "would even dream of having a single", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00091-00020784-00021183": "maintainer of a ui framework let alone", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00092-00021184-00021263": "two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00093-00021264-00021463": "or three years", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00094-00021464-00021807": "many contributors to two maintainers and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00095-00021808-00022078": "they took this task of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00096-00022079-00022422": "of redesigning the complete ui", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00097-00022423-00022694": "user interface of wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00098-00022695-00022919": "reader with the goal", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00099-00022920-00023078": "of actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00100-00023079-00023391": "showcasing the ui framework that sabi is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00101-00023392-00023519": "written on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00102-00023520-00023791": "the template it's called avalonia but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00103-00023792-00024055": "wasabi 2.2 we reviewed over the privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00104-00024056-00024286": "research that there was and created our", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00105-00024287-00024614": "own privacy referred called babisavi we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00106-00024615-00024871": "redesigned the user", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00107-00024872-00025207": "experience and the user interface from", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00108-00025208-00025511": "the ground up and we did not only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00109-00025512-00025814": "achieve our original way which is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00110-00025816-00026199": "that's built a privacy experience that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00111-00026200-00026358": "is exactly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00112-00026360-00026662": "as good as uh as any other bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00113-00026663-00026887": "bullet without privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00114-00026888-00027223": "but we actually achieved a much larger", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00115-00027224-00027558": "goal which was that it actually the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00116-00027560-00027743": "single best", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00117-00027744-00028087": "user experience for a bitcoin desktop", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00118-00028088-00028246": "wallet that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00119-00028247-00028670": "what wasabi 2.2 has right now in my", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00120-00028672-00028902": "number opinion", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00121-00028904-00028999": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00122-00029000-00029167": "i hope that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00123-00029168-00029318": "we can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00124-00029319-00029483": "consider", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00125-00029483-00029751": "bitcoins fungibility", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00126-00029752-00029895": "fixed", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00127-00029895-00030199": "in a very narrow sense", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00128-00030200-00030351": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00129-00030352-00030679": "all we will have to do left in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00130-00030680-00030807": "following", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00131-00030808-00030902": "years", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00132-00030903-00031423": "is to enable more and more type of users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00133-00031424-00031743": "and maybe even businesses to to to have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00134-00031744-00032039": "a fungible bitcoin user experience to to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00135-00032039-00032318": "use bitcoin privately and when we have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00136-00032319-00032614": "done that then the last thing what we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00137-00032616-00032799": "will have to do is fix bitcoin's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00138-00032800-00033039": "portability too so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00139-00033040-00033383": "then we will have uh have quite a ride", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00140-00033384-00033559": "in the future to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00141-00033560-00033743": "to to try to make", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00142-00033744-00033999": "make things cheaper and faster possibly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00143-00034000-00034311": "with probably with the lightning network", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00144-00034312-00034599": "right so that's the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00145-00034600-00034759": "that's what i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00146-00034760-00034902": "i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00147-00034903-00035055": "uh face", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00148-00035056-00035287": "continue the show", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00149-00035288-00035431": "very nice", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00150-00035432-00035702": "david do you have any insights of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00151-00035703-00035871": "last couple years", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00152-00035872-00036118": "uh what are you excited about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00153-00036119-00036351": "yes so we are sitting here as you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00154-00036352-00036495": "see in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00155-00036496-00036895": "budapest headquarter office", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00156-00036896-00037127": "basically this was", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00157-00037128-00037327": "the center of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00158-00037328-00037785": "at least the budapest development here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00159-00037786-00037902": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00160-00037903-00038135": "and a lot of things happened in the last", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00161-00038136-00038223": "year", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00162-00038224-00038430": "with the company itself", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00163-00038431-00038623": "not just with the software", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00164-00038624-00038943": "different kind of teams formed since we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00165-00038944-00039174": "begin because uh more and more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00166-00039175-00039511": "developers joined to the group", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00167-00039512-00039830": "we have a marketing team as well beside", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00168-00039831-00039902": "us", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00169-00039903-00040183": "for example one graphical at least no", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00170-00040184-00040430": "two graphical designer if i can say that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00171-00040431-00040702": "just to simplify things so we are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00172-00040703-00040855": "improving", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00173-00040856-00041127": "the software in many other areas as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00174-00041128-00041255": "like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00175-00041256-00041343": "is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00176-00041344-00041815": "is is the minimum required to have um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00177-00041816-00042055": "a comprehensive software", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00178-00042056-00042343": "and all of these efforts are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00179-00042344-00042615": "forged into 2.0", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00180-00042616-00042799": "you will see", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00181-00042800-00043023": "the graphical interface is completely", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00182-00043024-00043183": "changed and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00183-00043184-00043518": "tailor made to this specific purpose to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00184-00043519-00043718": "have a bitcoin wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00185-00043719-00043974": "the most recent features to send and to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00186-00043975-00044102": "receive", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00187-00044103-00044207": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00188-00044208-00044471": "by the way meanwhile enabling the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00189-00044472-00044671": "privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00190-00044672-00044958": "by default for the user i think it will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00191-00044959-00045190": "be a very interesting journey for the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00192-00045191-00045487": "user as well how they will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00193-00045488-00045846": "get our user interface the the design", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00194-00045847-00046062": "team try to make it as intuitive as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00195-00046063-00046190": "possible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00196-00046191-00046358": "sometime this was", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00197-00046359-00046558": "hard to do because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00198-00046559-00046783": "we didn't want to have two tips there in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00199-00046784-00047079": "the software and a lot of texts", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00200-00047080-00047383": "we said that or the motto was whenever", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00201-00047384-00047623": "you need text to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00202-00047624-00047871": "to describe or to elaborate on something", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00203-00047872-00048046": "that's not intuitive", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00204-00048047-00048367": "so we again and again trying to find an", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00205-00048368-00048574": "interface that we think it is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00206-00048575-00048718": "intuitively", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00207-00048719-00049030": "working um it will turn out if we were", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00208-00049031-00049302": "right or not now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00209-00049303-00049462": "so i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00210-00049463-00049711": "personally but i don't think i'm the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00211-00049712-00049974": "only one i'm very curious how they will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00212-00049975-00050086": "get this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00213-00050087-00050374": "because we were iterating a lot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00214-00050375-00050671": "on this kind of on these interfaces as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00215-00050672-00050758": "well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00216-00050759-00050990": "so that's about the ui", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00217-00050991-00051287": "the coinjoin framework the new coinjoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00218-00051288-00051614": "framework or coinjoin protocol", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00219-00051615-00051823": "which is called bobby sobi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00220-00051824-00051926": "is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00221-00051927-00052054": "almost", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00222-00052055-00052335": "opening a new dimension in the same way", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00223-00052336-00052638": "as the ui changes in the software", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00224-00052639-00052919": "for example one of the biggest uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00225-00052920-00053199": "limitation for one point", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00226-00053200-00053542": "for vb1 for wasabi that one was the 0.1", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00227-00053544-00053911": "million denomination which was 400 at", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00228-00053912-00054047": "the at the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00229-00054048-00054399": "beginning when we started wasabi wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00230-00054400-00054682": "but meanwhile it worked much more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00231-00054683-00054823": "thus uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00232-00054824-00054975": "not letting", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00233-00054976-00055223": "many users to use the wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00234-00055224-00055454": "so one thing was the that that ada", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00235-00055455-00055694": "mentioned opera mentioned before", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00236-00055695-00055847": "that uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00237-00055848-00056215": "vasobi was for over users because there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00238-00056216-00056447": "were many advanced features the coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00239-00056448-00056542": "list", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00240-00056544-00056838": "cognitively hard to process", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00241-00056839-00057047": "ui interfaces", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00242-00057048-00057335": "it was like something like a logo for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00243-00057336-00057654": "a normal user but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00244-00057655-00057863": "2.0 tries to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00245-00057864-00058071": "tries to go over", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00246-00058072-00058407": "on this for example we try to avoid", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00247-00058408-00058654": "having a coil list in the software", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00248-00058655-00058926": "because the coin list was the biggest", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00249-00058927-00059279": "challenge as far as i noticed in wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00250-00059279-00059487": "1.0 years", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00251-00059488-00059711": "so we will try to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00252-00059712-00060023": "provide a better solution", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00253-00060024-00060254": "we will see how it will turn out i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00254-00060255-00060630": "we did what we could so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00255-00060632-00060911": "it's i i use the wallet confidently at", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00256-00060912-00061087": "least during the test", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00257-00061088-00061294": "i haven't seen any problem", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00258-00061295-00061406": "with that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00259-00061407-00061542": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00260-00061544-00061735": "we can't say it's a new", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00261-00061736-00061991": "it's a new era and uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00262-00061991-00062206": "and and we did something", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00263-00062207-00062382": "like uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00264-00062383-00062638": "nobody asked if i could say that but not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00265-00062639-00062823": "in the manner that we are the first in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00266-00062824-00063191": "this but we are the first to experiment", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00267-00063191-00063542": "with this how to have a wallet which is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00268-00063544-00063815": "privacy wallet but not having a coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00269-00063816-00063975": "list inside it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00270-00063976-00064103": "it sounds", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00271-00064104-00064311": "very good but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00272-00064312-00064591": "i think we were successful but let the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00273-00064591-00064959": "users tell us after the release so i i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00274-00064960-00065159": "am full with curiosity", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00275-00065160-00065375": "how this will turn out we have been", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00276-00065376-00065703": "working on this for two years so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00277-00065704-00065838": "it's a huge", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00278-00065839-00066038": "it's a huge uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00279-00066039-00066182": "effort", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00280-00066183-00066463": "from our side how has he having positive", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00281-00066464-00066759": "feelings right now so i hope i hope it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00282-00066760-00066903": "will be very good", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00283-00066904-00067143": "and will be exciting for sure", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00284-00067144-00067247": "there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00285-00067248-00067438": "you know we it kind of shifted the goal", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00286-00067439-00067750": "post throughout the 2.0 development era", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00287-00067751-00068006": "a bit and the the scope of the problem", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00288-00068007-00068175": "that we were trying to tackle got bigger", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00289-00068176-00068447": "and bigger and bigger um and to some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00290-00068448-00068631": "extent that's that's a bad thing right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00291-00068632-00068863": "because you you fellas waited well a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00292-00068864-00069111": "long time for a proper release with new", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00293-00069112-00069215": "features", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00294-00069216-00069375": "but on the other hand that allowed us to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00295-00069376-00069663": "really make a more holistic approach to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00296-00069664-00069935": "the big problem that's that's a big step", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00297-00069936-00070094": "that's a difficult step", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00298-00070095-00070271": "and i think we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00299-00070272-00070511": "we're doing quite well uh on many fronts", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00300-00070512-00070743": "but you know as always the more you zoom", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00301-00070744-00071126": "in uh there are numerous little problems", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00302-00071127-00071415": "uh and things that can be improved uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00303-00071416-00071559": "and that's for one", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00304-00071560-00071759": "you know scary because the software", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00305-00071760-00071935": "isn't perfect", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00306-00071936-00072255": "however uh the the great thing is that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00307-00072256-00072526": "it still works and it works quite well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00308-00072527-00072694": "and we see all these low-hanging fruits", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00309-00072695-00072894": "that we can improve in the future", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00310-00072895-00073182": "and that will lead to well even the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00311-00073183-00073431": "greater software uh but what we have now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00312-00073432-00073519": "is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00313-00073520-00073655": "is really quite something it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00314-00073656-00073871": "definitely a big improvement to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00315-00073872-00074087": "uh what we had in the past", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00316-00074088-00074182": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00317-00074183-00074399": "yeah if this is the new status quo it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00318-00074400-00074655": "can only get better from now on then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00319-00074656-00074862": "i'm having a pretty bullish outlook on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00320-00074863-00075119": "the whole situation", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00321-00075120-00075367": "so anyone any other notes before we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00322-00075368-00075647": "press that juicy big red button", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00323-00075648-00075879": "just that the first", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00324-00075880-00076238": "release of wasabi that was done", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00325-00076239-00076335": "in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00326-00076336-00076559": "two years of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00327-00076560-00076847": "one person working on it and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00328-00076848-00077231": "one year of three other persons start", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00329-00077232-00077455": "four other people started working on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00330-00077456-00077535": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00331-00077536-00077782": "this happened is three years and wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00332-00077783-00077943": "2.2", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00333-00077944-00078150": "was actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00334-00078151-00078335": "another three years", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00335-00078336-00078606": "after the initial inception of the the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00336-00078607-00078782": "the idea", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00337-00078783-00079055": "two years and six months", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00338-00079056-00079175": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00339-00079176-00079287": "it was", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00340-00079288-00079582": "i think over 40 people were working on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00341-00079583-00079719": "that and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00342-00079720-00079975": "and many many many people here never", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00343-00079976-00080238": "even experienced the wasabi at release", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00344-00080239-00080543": "so that's uh it's an interesting font", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00345-00080544-00080782": "i hope you guys are gonna like it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00346-00080783-00080911": "so there's another way to find out if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00347-00080912-00081111": "people like it other than to actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00348-00081112-00081350": "ship the code so how about we do that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00349-00081351-00081671": "david are you ready", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00350-00081672-00081855": "yes we are ready", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00351-00081856-00082231": "from roll", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00352-00082232-00082806": "also david the stage is yours", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00353-00082807-00083055": "all right okay so we have this symbol", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00354-00083056-00083343": "here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00355-00083344-00083623": "i can snipe the label", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00356-00083624-00083767": "special table", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00357-00083768-00083967": "i will press the button", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00358-00083968-00084231": "and after that we start the deployment", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00359-00084232-00084462": "which will take i think a minute and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00360-00084463-00084759": "then the software will be available so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00361-00084760-00085111": "shall i press the button guys", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00362-00085112-00085271": "press the button", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00363-00085272-00086223": "smash it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00364-00086224-00086431": "champagne", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00365-00086432-00086711": "sunlight let the sunshine in and let", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00366-00086712-00087167": "wasabi 2.2 in as well all right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00367-00087168-00087382": "it's there on github the website will be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00368-00087383-00087550": "refreshed soon", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00369-00087551-00087791": "as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00370-00087792-00088279": "we made it guys", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00371-00088280-00088606": "could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00372-00088607-00088735": "that's it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00373-00088736-00088855": "yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00374-00088856-00089206": "okay i can't look at the website", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00375-00089207-00089623": "yet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00376-00089624-00090126": "blue screen of death", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00377-00090127-00090311": "next time what we need", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00378-00090312-00090427": "is to order some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00379-00090428-00090582": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00380-00090583-00090871": "some playing band to play live music in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00381-00090872-00091031": "the background for us", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00382-00091032-00091397": "while we were waiting", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00383-00091398-00092494": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00384-00092495-00092671": "up and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00385-00092672-00093023": "down", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00386-00093024-00093318": "the champion", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00387-00093319-00093438": "all right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00388-00093439-00093838": "okay we are we are okay so um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00389-00093839-00094079": "you just download the software upgrade", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00390-00094080-00094271": "it will upgrade the existing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00391-00094272-00094535": "installation and that's it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00392-00094536-00094718": "yes it should be as straightforward as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00393-00094719-00094894": "any other update that you did to wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00394-00094895-00095126": "wallet if you're running an old client", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00395-00095127-00095294": "uh you will get a little notification at", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00396-00095295-00095494": "the bottom status bar saying that a new", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00397-00095495-00095694": "update is available click that link", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00398-00095695-00095950": "it'll show you the beautiful new website", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00399-00095951-00096143": "and there download the package for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00400-00096144-00096462": "whatever platform you are running by the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00401-00096463-00096687": "way apple m1 silicon is natively", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00402-00096688-00096871": "supported so if you have that get that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00403-00096872-00097047": "dedicated package", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00404-00097048-00097303": "and well you install it and all your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00405-00097304-00097479": "existing wallets", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00406-00097480-00097799": "will continue to work just as fine", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00407-00097800-00097959": "and they", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00408-00097960-00098191": "there's no need to import again if you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00409-00098192-00098382": "were using wasabi before", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00410-00098383-00098718": "the the import should be rather quick", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00411-00098719-00098791": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00412-00098792-00099023": "then you can use wasabi 2.0 with your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00413-00099024-00099262": "existing wallet of course alternatively", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00414-00099263-00099455": "create a new wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00415-00099456-00099574": "make sure you've got your backup", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00416-00099575-00099718": "recovery words", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00417-00099719-00099974": "uh and then receive some bitcoin into", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00418-00099975-00100255": "that wallet uh and press play in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00419-00100256-00100391": "altercoin join", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00420-00100392-00100606": "it'll ask you what type of mode you want", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00421-00100607-00100847": "if you prefer to optimize for privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00422-00100848-00101062": "for cost or for speed", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00423-00101063-00101350": "uh you just check uh whichever is the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00424-00101351-00101567": "right one for you and that's basically", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00425-00101568-00101759": "it you wait a couple hours and then you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00426-00101760-00101999": "can spend your bitcoin privately by", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00427-00102000-00102271": "default hopefully a couple of hours", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00428-00102272-00102527": "right but what if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00429-00102528-00102806": "is there any way that we are not going", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00430-00102807-00103030": "to make coin joints in the next couple", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00431-00103031-00103351": "of hours would that be possible sure i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00432-00103352-00103599": "mean for one the biggest question is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00433-00103600-00103742": "are our users going to download the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00434-00103743-00103839": "software", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00435-00103840-00103934": "uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00436-00103935-00104118": "and well hopefully they are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00437-00104119-00104415": "and if yes then hopefully they they", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00438-00104416-00104623": "send bitcoin into their wallets and then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00439-00104624-00104751": "hopefully they press play in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00440-00104752-00104902": "altercoin joint", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00441-00104903-00105102": "and if all these things check out then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00442-00105103-00105263": "we should have at least sufficient user", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00443-00105264-00105495": "base to have hopefully quite large coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00444-00105496-00105583": "joints", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00445-00105583-00105766": "then the next big question is will the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00446-00105767-00106039": "server and the client software hold up", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00447-00106040-00106239": "the stress test of potentially hundreds", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00448-00106240-00106431": "of users coming online", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00449-00106432-00106695": "and will we you know not have some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00450-00106696-00106943": "uh basically denial of servers uh that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00451-00106944-00107183": "that might be one possibility uh just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00452-00107183-00107358": "too many users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00453-00107359-00107495": "i guess there will be a good problem to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00454-00107496-00107734": "have and then uh it gets into optimizing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00455-00107735-00108063": "the code um but we will see that i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00456-00108064-00108239": "confident that we'll see something nice", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00457-00108240-00108351": "on midnight", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00458-00108352-00108471": "quite soon", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00459-00108472-00108702": "is someone watching the back end logs to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00460-00108703-00108910": "see if there's any uh successful punjab", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00461-00108911-00109134": "coordination going on maybe someone has", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00462-00109135-00109399": "a counter of the current uh registered", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00463-00109400-00109534": "input number", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00464-00109535-00109743": "we can take a look at it yes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00465-00109744-00109895": "adam can you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00466-00109896-00110015": "check the look", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00467-00110016-00110223": "on the back end", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00468-00110224-00110519": "i think we won't have an ex counter", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00469-00110520-00110623": "there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00470-00110624-00110934": "and uh like their input registration", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00471-00110935-00111310": "timeout is one hour by minimum so 150.", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00472-00111311-00111483": "one other thing is we have the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00473-00111483-00111727": "stats.wasabi wallet.io", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00474-00111728-00111934": "which shows you the current download", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00475-00111935-00112063": "numbers", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00476-00112064-00112319": "of our github packages um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00477-00112320-00112390": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00478-00112391-00112566": "i checked just now and unfortunately", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00479-00112567-00112799": "there is nothing on the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00480-00112800-00112999": "2.0 release yet so i'm guessing we might", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00481-00113000-00113190": "have a way to have to wait a bit before", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00482-00113191-00113447": "that is registered and indexed the first", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00483-00113448-00113702": "data will be on the midnight", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00484-00113703-00113975": "but max there are other sites those", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00485-00113976-00114215": "where you can check the download", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00486-00114216-00114502": "it's just not that fancy what we have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00487-00114503-00114686": "let me check that for you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00488-00114688-00115015": "20 20 downloads", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00489-00115016-00115119": "okay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00490-00115120-00115334": "so let's maybe talk a bit about the the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00491-00115335-00115575": "features of this new coinjoin protocol", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00492-00115576-00115831": "that we have rave uh could you maybe", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00493-00115832-00116054": "give a short summary uh of all the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00494-00116055-00116223": "features", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00495-00116224-00116454": "that are specific to the conjoint", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00496-00116455-00116558": "um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00497-00116559-00116751": "i don't know it's really hard to try to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00498-00116752-00116999": "even think of all of them but i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00499-00117000-00117102": "like the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00500-00117103-00117223": "biggest thing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00501-00117224-00117486": "is that we have not we don't have that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00502-00117488-00117671": "kind of minimum denomination anymore", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00503-00117672-00117839": "that we have in 1.0", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00504-00117840-00118190": "so people with less than 0.1 bitcoin are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00505-00118191-00118431": "actually able to reclaim their privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00506-00118432-00118719": "now and even the people with much larger", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00507-00118720-00118983": "amount than 0.1 are able to do it much", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00508-00118983-00119319": "more efficiently with 2.0 uh overall", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00509-00119320-00119599": "like yeah the whole point joint protocol", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00510-00119600-00119815": "is completely different input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00511-00119816-00120023": "input input links or input output links", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00512-00120024-00120343": "or output output links yeah um overall", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00513-00120344-00120551": "like i think we still have a lot of work", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00514-00120552-00120854": "to do but this is a very very nice first", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00515-00120855-00121119": "release and it should be like a big big", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00516-00121120-00121343": "improvement for bitcoin privacy in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00517-00121344-00121558": "general yeah you guys might want to dive", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00518-00121559-00121775": "deeper into those yeah so again the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00519-00121776-00121943": "minimum denomination now is five", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00520-00121944-00122151": "thousand cents uh plus whatever the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00521-00122152-00122463": "mining fee is uh which is quite nice so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00522-00122464-00122831": "that means uh you can make", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00523-00122832-00123039": "small value private payments", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00524-00123040-00123454": "uh easily uh and then uh coinjoin the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00525-00123455-00123799": "change uh or uh make sure that you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00526-00123800-00124031": "well just have a few coins that are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00527-00124032-00124254": "exactly the size that you need them uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00528-00124255-00124390": "there's no longer the need that every", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00529-00124391-00124686": "user has a 0.1 coin at least", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00530-00124688-00124927": "there's now much much more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00531-00124928-00125190": "possibilities of which denominations you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00532-00125191-00125399": "can choose in a certain round", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00533-00125400-00125654": "and a lot of randomness of for example", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00534-00125655-00125886": "how many inputs are you going to select", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00535-00125888-00126031": "or how many outputs are you going to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00536-00126032-00126310": "select and all of this of course works", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00537-00126311-00126631": "nicely by default and with our auto coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00538-00126632-00126927": "join robot and that self driving car", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00539-00126928-00127086": "that hopefully is not going to make many", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00540-00127088-00127334": "crashes but that means that a lot of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00541-00127335-00127519": "advanced decisions don't happen under", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00542-00127520-00127783": "the hood which is quite nice", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00543-00127783-00127999": "and i think the analogy of self-driving", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00544-00128000-00128207": "car is actually pretty fitting in here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00545-00128208-00128454": "it's a very interesting technology and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00546-00128455-00128566": "you only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00547-00128567-00128758": "like there's only a certain limit that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00548-00128759-00128958": "you can test a self-driving car in a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00549-00128959-00129199": "test environment at some point you just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00550-00129200-00129431": "have to put it into an actual street and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00551-00129432-00129590": "hope that there's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00552-00129591-00129895": "well not many casualties i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00553-00129896-00130063": "it's a very like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00554-00130064-00130239": "interesting technology and i think it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00555-00130240-00130519": "the future but you know these first", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00556-00130520-00130719": "steps these are going to be very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00557-00130720-00130934": "interesting and this is like you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00558-00130935-00131166": "making history maybe jumar can you give", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00559-00131167-00131359": "some more insights in the ui what are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00560-00131360-00131519": "some of the cool new features that you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00561-00131520-00131783": "implemented hey guys so yeah i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00562-00131784-00132047": "compared to 1.0", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00563-00132048-00132231": "i mean aesthetically", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00564-00132232-00132343": "um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00565-00132344-00132631": "speaking you know it looks a bit more a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00566-00132632-00132790": "bit more better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00567-00132791-00133159": "um the wallet selection as well is um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00568-00133160-00133399": "much better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00569-00133400-00133519": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00570-00133520-00133775": "we are using a coherent um design", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00571-00133776-00134014": "language across the app now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00572-00134015-00134102": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00573-00134103-00134399": "i think that will also help in the user", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00574-00134400-00134559": "experience as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00575-00134560-00134823": "and we've rounded corners now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00576-00134824-00135166": "it looks very slick oh yes i'm using a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00577-00135167-00135343": "great grip", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00578-00135344-00135527": "amount of um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00579-00135528-00135687": "blur behinds", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00580-00135688-00135911": "rounded corners you know just to have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00581-00135912-00136214": "that um modern look across all platforms", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00582-00136215-00136447": "that we support one of the other cool", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00583-00136448-00136654": "small ui changes are things like small", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00584-00136655-00136902": "animations uh which seem to be much", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00585-00136903-00137159": "smoother uh so maybe tomorrow how does", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00586-00137160-00137439": "avalonia handle these animations why", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00587-00137440-00137599": "does it look so good", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00588-00137600-00137823": "we are building at the um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00589-00137824-00138063": "the foundations we have laid years ago", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00590-00138064-00138327": "for animations you know in upcoming", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00591-00138328-00138543": "avalonia release also", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00592-00138544-00138647": "that will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00593-00138648-00138927": "get better with them better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00594-00138928-00139287": "apis render threads um animations and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00595-00139288-00139631": "stuff and also um we also", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00596-00139632-00139911": "uh base some animations from", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00597-00139912-00140095": "microsoft's uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00598-00140096-00140319": "design you know so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00599-00140320-00140559": "we had that um a bit more professional", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00600-00140560-00140790": "touch now than we had in one point", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00601-00140791-00141054": "though and it's really well i'm not sure", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00602-00141055-00141214": "if it's really great if we get more and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00603-00141215-00141478": "more like microsoft", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00604-00141479-00141702": "but probably it is uh their design is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00605-00141703-00141935": "quite nice um and definitely what what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00606-00141936-00142143": "is the wasabi looks awesome when it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00607-00142144-00142366": "comes to design i mean the top tech", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00608-00142367-00142751": "firms really has it on the game you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00609-00142752-00142895": "it doesn't get much better than that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00610-00142896-00143254": "sadly well until now because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00611-00143255-00143495": "we saw all right wasabi 2.0 over tops", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00612-00143496-00143863": "them all oh yes definitely", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00613-00143864-00144047": "lucas maybe you can give a quick update", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00614-00144048-00144207": "what were you tinkering on what are you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00615-00144208-00144599": "excited about in this release um i'm i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00616-00144600-00144983": "interesting on seeing how it works in in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00617-00144984-00145078": "under", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00618-00145079-00145335": "stress that's something that it's it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00619-00145336-00145590": "what i want to to see basically i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00620-00145591-00145895": "excited about the the technical part", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00621-00145896-00146223": "i would like to see a a huge transaction", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00622-00146224-00146495": "i i mean we have been testing and we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00623-00146496-00146783": "know it it can work with you know 100", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00624-00146784-00147014": "inputs and it can generate hundreds of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00625-00147015-00147143": "outputs but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00626-00147144-00147311": "um i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00627-00147312-00147607": "it can do much better than that and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00628-00147608-00147775": "we need more users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00629-00147776-00147966": "i mean more users participating we need", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00630-00147967-00148151": "people to migrate from whatsapp wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00631-00148152-00148366": "one i mean to the zerolink protocol to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00632-00148367-00148526": "the quality protocol", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00633-00148527-00148887": "and well that would be will be something", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00634-00148888-00149119": "really cool to see yeah definitely what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00635-00149120-00149326": "are your bets that the this back-end", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00636-00149327-00149599": "server is gonna run too hot with all the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00637-00149600-00150031": "fancy crypto that's going on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00638-00150032-00150287": "i don't think so in fact even even in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00639-00150288-00150590": "the even in the worst uh because given", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00640-00150591-00150847": "the remix is is free let's say", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00641-00150848-00151063": "you don't pay for remixes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00642-00151064-00151254": "so in terms of input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00643-00151255-00151390": "cryptography", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00644-00151391-00151511": "is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00645-00151512-00151759": "you or of the protocol in general is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00646-00151760-00152031": "that you register each input under a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00647-00152032-00152199": "separate tor identity", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00648-00152200-00152535": "um and uh with just a single input right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00649-00152536-00152695": "and if you want to register multiple", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00650-00152696-00152902": "inputs you create a new tor identity and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00651-00152903-00153102": "register it with the coordinator there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00652-00153103-00153319": "thanks to the new arbitrary amount ecash", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00653-00153320-00153551": "system that we're using in wabi-sabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00654-00153552-00153766": "this is no longer an issue that makes it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00655-00153767-00153943": "possible in cryptographic layer and on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00656-00153944-00154102": "the tor protocol here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00657-00154103-00154326": "and then we have a a plus saw", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00658-00154327-00154607": "distribution of the timing of when you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00659-00154608-00154878": "register an output sorry in input what's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00660-00154879-00155063": "kind of the same for outputs too", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00661-00155064-00155183": "and um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00662-00155184-00155254": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00663-00155255-00155431": "there there is randomness in the timing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00664-00155432-00155599": "as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00665-00155600-00155775": "and then in terms of which inputs are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00666-00155776-00156111": "going to be selected uh a couple", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00667-00156112-00156375": "checks uh in terms of what annon score", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00668-00156376-00156559": "do the inputs have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00669-00156560-00156814": "and which amounts do they have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00670-00156815-00157087": "and especially um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00671-00157088-00157302": "so when we choose a group of possible or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00672-00157303-00157607": "potential inputs we check how many of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00673-00157608-00157807": "these inputs come from the same previous", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00674-00157808-00157951": "transaction", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00675-00157952-00158151": "which of course reveals at least to some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00676-00158152-00158478": "extent a common ownership input or input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00677-00158479-00158702": "ownership and assuming that this is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00678-00158703-00158887": "quite a large number", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00679-00158888-00159159": "um it will become more difficult to find", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00680-00159160-00159423": "out which of any given inputs actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00681-00159424-00159631": "belong to the same user", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00682-00159632-00159895": "and so here of course assuming there is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00683-00159896-00160087": "natural anonymity set in terms of real", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00684-00160088-00160175": "users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00685-00160176-00160431": "um this calculation gets more difficult", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00686-00160432-00160695": "the exact extent of how difficult it is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00687-00160696-00161007": "to find the input clusters now is yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00688-00161008-00161254": "difficult to say but i believe it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00689-00161255-00161439": "quite all right how is that being", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00690-00161440-00161551": "measured", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00691-00161552-00161654": "um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00692-00161655-00161854": "i i was thinking maybe", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00693-00161855-00162190": "avi should actually reply to this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00694-00162191-00162399": "this concern because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00695-00162400-00162535": "he's actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00696-00162536-00162751": "i'm somewhere on the middle but he's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00697-00162752-00163031": "actually in a complete opposite uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00698-00163032-00163223": "i mean coming at it from a concrete", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00699-00163224-00163454": "opposite way so so that should be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00700-00163455-00163671": "interesting what he has to say about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00701-00163672-00164031": "this was researching it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00702-00164032-00164214": "i'll get back to my apartment in five", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00703-00164215-00164431": "minutes and uh i'll address the question", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00704-00164432-00164687": "then so i i guess i just did", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00705-00164688-00164919": "the short version of it of how i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00706-00164920-00165047": "about it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00707-00165048-00165238": "is that with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00708-00165239-00165447": "also between point of in the beginning", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00709-00165448-00165590": "we were", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00710-00165591-00165951": "we were trying to find an amount", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00711-00165952-00166278": "composition scoring system", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00712-00166279-00166663": "in a way that we can actually somehow", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00713-00166664-00167007": "work with number of subsets", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00714-00167008-00167311": "trying to maximize subsets of the of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00715-00167312-00167599": "coinjoin or even better trying to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00716-00167600-00167926": "minimize the probability links between", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00717-00167927-00168087": "input inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00718-00168088-00168311": "any specific input and any specific", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00719-00168312-00168414": "output", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00720-00168415-00168726": "and any specific output on any specific", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00721-00168727-00169078": "input at the beginning we are trying to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00722-00169079-00169263": "to go into this direction because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00723-00169264-00169471": "obviously this is the most complete", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00724-00169472-00169719": "solution that you can have for the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00725-00169720-00169975": "amount organization program and we did", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00726-00169976-00170102": "not actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00727-00170103-00170359": "well i wouldn't some people", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00728-00170360-00170695": "think that we did find solutions to that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00729-00170696-00170783": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00730-00170784-00170902": "we were not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00731-00170903-00171223": "convinced that those things are work and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00732-00171224-00171471": "they were very risky so what we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00733-00171472-00171919": "defaulted back to is equal outputs and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00734-00171920-00172159": "what it results in it still creates a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00735-00172160-00172559": "bunch of subsets but if we see an equal", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00736-00172560-00172671": "output", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00737-00172672-00173007": "then we can be at least sure that there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00738-00173008-00173095": "is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00739-00173096-00173487": "ambiguity there even if there are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00740-00173488-00173783": "changes in the transaction or more like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00741-00173784-00174014": "unequal outputs these are not changes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00742-00174015-00174287": "anymore even unequal outputs cannot be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00743-00174288-00174614": "followed back but we are less sure about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00744-00174615-00174711": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00745-00174712-00175031": "therefore it is not included in our", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00746-00175032-00175263": "anonymity calculations we only care", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00747-00175264-00175519": "about equal outputs so this this would", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00748-00175520-00175759": "be my short version", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00749-00175760-00175935": "short rationally", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00750-00175936-00176047": "and and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00751-00176048-00176263": "another thing to consider is we since we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00752-00176264-00176495": "have standard denominations across", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00753-00176496-00176671": "multiple rounds now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00754-00176672-00176831": "that means that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00755-00176832-00177078": "it often happens that on the input side", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00756-00177079-00177326": "users by random chance select inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00757-00177327-00177575": "that have equal amounts than other users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00758-00177576-00177726": "and this is kind of a mixing on the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00759-00177727-00178047": "input side it's not really designed or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00760-00178048-00178302": "optimized for this it just happens as a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00761-00178303-00178495": "side product but that definitely", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00762-00178496-00178711": "increases input side privacy as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00763-00178712-00178847": "again but you know to measure and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00764-00178848-00179126": "express that exactly i guess a bit tough", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00765-00179127-00179326": "oh and another thing to consider is when", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00766-00179327-00179614": "when we consolidate inputs uh in a coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00767-00179615-00179895": "join um then we take the weighted", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00768-00179896-00180254": "average for the anonymity score um so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00769-00180255-00180559": "let's say you two you have a a large", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00770-00180560-00180838": "value coin with 10 and on score and then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00771-00180839-00181111": "a low value coin with three and on score", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00772-00181112-00181359": "for example then your average weighted", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00773-00181360-00181678": "and on score would be higher uh um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00774-00181679-00181878": "because the large value coin has more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00775-00181879-00182063": "announced for and then this would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00776-00182064-00182359": "then the base set where the output side", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00777-00182360-00182607": "and on score gets added to which then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00778-00182608-00182775": "depends on the number of equal amount", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00779-00182776-00182999": "outputs maybe by now aviv is in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00780-00183000-00183231": "house no guys i'm i'm two more minutes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00781-00183232-00183438": "away i apologize", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00782-00183439-00183607": "no worries at all we should do a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00783-00183608-00183799": "different question and then we'll come", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00784-00183800-00183935": "back to it as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00785-00183936-00184143": "yeah i was actually trying to give", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00786-00184144-00184423": "questions to max uh before we come back", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00787-00184424-00184751": "to it well since then wrote up that you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00788-00184752-00185078": "become the ceo of wasabi wallet or zp", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00789-00185079-00185183": "snacks", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00790-00185184-00185278": "this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00791-00185279-00185607": "current stream is the first time you are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00792-00185608-00186014": "actually appearing as the ceo ck snacks", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00793-00186015-00186287": "so how does that make you feel", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00794-00186288-00186526": "yeah quite i'm quite excited about it to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00795-00186527-00186831": "be honest i mean i love wasabi as a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00796-00186832-00187119": "software project i always have uh and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00797-00187120-00187319": "it's it's mission and vision behind it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00798-00187320-00187487": "uh and i've been a user of the client", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00799-00187488-00187799": "for a long time and based on that an", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00800-00187800-00188054": "enthusiast contributor to the project uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00801-00188055-00188207": "and now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00802-00188208-00188487": "being on the user side of the back end", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00803-00188488-00188823": "uh i i guess i can lift that ethos", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00804-00188824-00189078": "and double down on it and i will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00805-00189079-00189278": "try to give good feedback to the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00806-00189279-00189535": "software project in terms of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00807-00189536-00189759": "back-end functionality and yeah we'll", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00808-00189760-00190095": "we'll hope that ck snacks as a company", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00809-00190096-00190319": "will continue to not just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00810-00190320-00190519": "provide incredibly valuable services to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00811-00190520-00190935": "its users and but also to continue its", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00812-00190936-00191119": "well i guess philanthropic", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00813-00191120-00191302": "uh contributions to the free and open", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00814-00191303-00191511": "source software space i think we're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00815-00191512-00191735": "already doing some quite amazing work", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00816-00191736-00191871": "there but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00817-00191872-00192078": "we can do much more uh so i'm hoping", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00818-00192079-00192343": "that ck snacks will be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00819-00192344-00192631": "yeah more more involved in in other", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00820-00192632-00192775": "software projects", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00821-00192776-00193014": "and and that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00822-00193015-00193311": "wasabi will continues to be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00823-00193312-00193623": "resilient and and feature rich and uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00824-00193624-00193847": "just working well um but to a large", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00825-00193848-00194054": "extent you know it's it's business as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00826-00194055-00194287": "usual i loved the project before i love", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00827-00194288-00194502": "it as much or more now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00828-00194503-00194590": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00829-00194591-00194847": "i'll just try my best to build something", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00830-00194848-00194990": "that's useful", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00831-00194991-00195207": "and i think we have one of the best", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00832-00195208-00195407": "teams to make that happen even though", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00833-00195408-00195671": "it's a incredibly ambitious and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00834-00195672-00195919": "difficult problem to tackle so i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00835-00195920-00196166": "definitely not too confident", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00836-00196167-00196454": "but i am hopeful and optimistic can you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00837-00196455-00196663": "maybe give an account of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00838-00196664-00196990": "yourself who are you how did you get to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00839-00196991-00197335": "study where were you before and and what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00840-00197336-00197478": "did you hear", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00841-00197479-00197575": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00842-00197576-00197926": "a bit of a history lesson please", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00843-00197927-00198102": "yeah um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00844-00198103-00198295": "so i'm mainly i would say an", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00845-00198296-00198526": "entrepreneur and economist", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00846-00198527-00198783": "right before bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00847-00198784-00199047": "it was always important for me to earn", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00848-00199048-00199278": "my earn money first and foremost right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00849-00199279-00199487": "but then coincidentally you realize that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00850-00199488-00199663": "all that means you got to be useful for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00851-00199664-00199783": "other people", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00852-00199784-00199919": "and that was always something that i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00853-00199920-00200207": "found quite enjoyable i then discovered", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00854-00200208-00200687": "economics as well the the science to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00855-00200688-00200871": "become a better problem solver and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00856-00200872-00201063": "entrepreneur and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00857-00201064-00201231": "thereafter first trying out the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00858-00201232-00201519": "keynesian mainstream nonsense i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00859-00201520-00201663": "thankfully discovered the austrian", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00860-00201664-00201926": "school of economics and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00861-00201927-00201999": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00862-00202000-00202238": "helped me a lot with understanding the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00863-00202239-00202454": "the role and the tasks of entrepreneurs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00864-00202455-00202687": "and the importance of money and so then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00865-00202688-00202919": "after studying this i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00866-00202920-00203087": "learned about the problems that the fiat", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00867-00203088-00203247": "money has", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00868-00203248-00203335": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00869-00203336-00203638": "i was eager to find a solution to it and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00870-00203639-00203902": "that led me to bitcoin ultimately as a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00871-00203903-00204175": "money that is defined verifies and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00872-00204176-00204447": "enforced by the merchants that use the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00873-00204448-00204575": "money system", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00874-00204576-00204726": "and that's such a genius idea that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00875-00204727-00204975": "solves so many problems uh and if the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00876-00204976-00205166": "software is so elegantly designed uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00877-00205167-00205342": "that it's caught my attention quite", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00878-00205344-00205551": "quick and the fault on the bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00879-00205552-00205671": "rabbit hole was", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00880-00205671-00205846": "was steep", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00881-00205848-00206190": "and and harsh um but i've enjoyed every", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00882-00206191-00206462": "minute of it uh and then wasabi wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00883-00206463-00206638": "uh i discovered back when it was hidden", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00884-00206639-00206966": "wallet i believe in the end of 2017 uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00885-00206967-00207182": "based on nopara being part of the block", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00886-00207183-00207398": "digest a phenomenal podcast and there he", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00887-00207400-00207590": "was talking about the development", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00888-00207591-00207703": "process and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00889-00207704-00207998": "i thought to try it out alofty loved the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00890-00208000-00208103": "idea", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00891-00208104-00208182": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00892-00208183-00208342": "stuck around and figured out that it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00893-00208344-00208551": "pretty bad", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00894-00208552-00208758": "despite how cool it is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00895-00208759-00208975": "and there were like a thousand and one", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00896-00208976-00209158": "things to to improve that were so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00897-00209159-00209366": "obvious uh so i stuck around had", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00898-00209367-00209534": "conversations with the other", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00899-00209535-00209782": "contributors and added some educational", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00900-00209783-00209958": "videos of how to use it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00901-00209959-00210182": "eventually answered a bunch of questions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00902-00210183-00210406": "from other users then got lazy doing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00903-00210407-00210479": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00904-00210480-00210639": "so i wrote the documentation that i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00905-00210640-00210958": "don't have to repeat myself that much", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00906-00210959-00211110": "and a bunch of others helped out with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00907-00211111-00211342": "making that happen yeah then got more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00908-00211344-00211519": "into let's say the technical side you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00909-00211519-00211703": "know reviewing a lot of the pull", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00910-00211704-00211894": "requests testing the software giving the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00911-00211896-00212134": "feedback um what's broken what could be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00912-00212135-00212223": "better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00913-00212223-00212310": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00914-00212311-00212567": "then as well the the research side you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00915-00212567-00212791": "know really thinking deep about the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00916-00212792-00212982": "architecture and the design of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00917-00212983-00213182": "software about the different tricks that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00918-00213183-00213406": "can be used to make it more private", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00919-00213407-00213679": "efficient uh useful yeah i guess all of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00920-00213680-00213798": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00921-00213800-00214071": "led me here to this point now um where", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00922-00214071-00214294": "i'm kind of just planning to continue", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00923-00214296-00214623": "doing what i do and double down on this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00924-00214623-00214839": "well open source ethos of scratchy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00925-00214840-00215023": "ownage you know we're building", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00926-00215023-00215175": "software tools that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00927-00215176-00215382": "anyone else can use when we make it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00928-00215383-00215519": "better it's better for everyone else", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00929-00215519-00215767": "that's such a massive improvement in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00930-00215767-00216046": "all resource allocation and and wealth", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00931-00216048-00216231": "that we're creating here so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00932-00216232-00216534": "uh yeah i'm i'm in it for the mission", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00933-00216535-00216606": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00934-00216607-00216839": "don't plan on stopping anytime soon", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00935-00216840-00217087": "all right thank you let's get back to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00936-00217088-00217487": "aviv then so what are your thoughts on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00937-00217488-00217855": "input input links uh before i get there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00938-00217856-00218094": "uh so firstly a big congratulations to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00939-00218096-00218487": "uh to max um i i can only imagine how um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00940-00218488-00218823": "how uh a big of a dream this this is uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00941-00218823-00219039": "for you because i i know max has always", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00942-00219040-00219239": "been incredibly passionate about this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00943-00219240-00219479": "project um for first", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00944-00219480-00219606": "almost since the beginning although", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00945-00219607-00219894": "technically the beginning was in 2013 or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00946-00219896-00220119": "even 2015 but um he's been in this for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00947-00220119-00220231": "for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00948-00220232-00220455": "a very very long time the second thing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00949-00220456-00220671": "is is that i just wanted to get to dan", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00950-00220671-00220967": "to maybe articulate more of his concerns", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00951-00220967-00221119": "you kind of mentioned a couple of things", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00952-00221119-00221423": "about timing attack coordinator and i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00953-00221423-00221606": "just wanted you to kind of elaborate on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00954-00221607-00221798": "precisely the the attack that you're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00955-00221800-00221903": "concerned", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00956-00221904-00222239": "about so like if i make a payment", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00957-00222240-00222423": "how do i make a payment through with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00958-00222423-00222663": "wasabi without making a link to my past", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00959-00222664-00222967": "history my concern is if i make two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00960-00222967-00223206": "payments unrelated identities", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00961-00223207-00223398": "and then later change from those", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00962-00223400-00223646": "payments gets coinjoined the change from", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00963-00223648-00223910": "those two payments is still related", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00964-00223911-00224023": "in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00965-00224023-00224246": "coin join that they're both input to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00966-00224248-00224446": "that both to change transactions are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00967-00224448-00224687": "input to linking them even though", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00968-00224688-00225015": "the input and the output are not linked", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00969-00225016-00225198": "yeah absolutely that that's that that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00970-00225200-00225446": "a great uh question there so there will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00971-00225448-00225767": "be instances where you do have a wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00972-00225767-00226023": "with just two change payments and it may", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00973-00226023-00226158": "it may be the case that the wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00974-00226159-00226382": "chooses to select both of those inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00975-00226383-00226575": "to mix in other situations you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00976-00226576-00226767": "imagine where the wallet might have a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00977-00226767-00226958": "lot of partially mixed coins or fully", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00978-00226959-00227167": "mixed coins and i've already spoken", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00979-00227167-00227351": "about this and i think in the future", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00980-00227352-00227615": "we'll want to have a system where we we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00981-00227616-00227894": "we combine inputs of already mixed coins", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00982-00227896-00228191": "with those change coins but the the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00983-00228192-00228342": "bigger question that you're probably", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00984-00228344-00228663": "asking is what is the link ability like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00985-00228664-00228951": "i guess you know mathematically that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00986-00228952-00229151": "i mean if the two appear in the same", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00987-00229152-00229406": "coin joins there's inevitably a link in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00988-00229407-00229679": "that they both appear in that coin join", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00989-00229680-00229982": "um so you know there's no way to get rid", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00990-00229983-00230103": "of that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00991-00230104-00230334": "that's not entirely true though like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00992-00230335-00230471": "there's a link in that they're both in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00993-00230471-00230679": "the same coin join but the probability", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00994-00230680-00230758": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00995-00230759-00231006": "two related inputs could go to any", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00996-00231007-00231271": "outputs is not necessarily the same", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00997-00231271-00231582": "across all all inputs and it's possible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00998-00231583-00231871": "that only one sub transaction fulfills a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-00999-00231871-00232046": "certain subset of outputs and then you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01000-00232048-00232167": "still have a you don't have a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01001-00232167-00232334": "deterministic link between inputs and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01002-00232335-00232487": "outputs but you still have input input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01003-00232488-00232727": "links i i don't see that mitigated it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01004-00232728-00233039": "a concern of mine not just for train", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01005-00233040-00233294": "change coins but for any inputs i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01006-00233296-00233534": "wondering how that's being mitigated", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01007-00233535-00233606": "well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01008-00233607-00233727": "yes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01009-00233728-00233942": "just as one small note that once you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01010-00233944-00234223": "make a payment the change output has a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01011-00234223-00234391": "one and on score", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01012-00234392-00234775": "and and uh the input selector prefers uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01013-00234776-00235110": "to have a low count of consolidation of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01014-00235111-00235367": "one anon score i'm not exactly sure", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01015-00235367-00235615": "about the details of that algorithm uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01016-00235616-00235863": "but we already tried to reduce uh the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01017-00235864-00236151": "consolidation of one and on score coins", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01018-00236152-00236382": "but so you even served a one two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01019-00236383-00236598": "four with a coin joint output there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01020-00236600-00236727": "could be a you could make a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01021-00236728-00236910": "deterministic link between those two on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01022-00236911-00237303": "the input side i'm not like is is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01023-00237304-00237406": "so so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01024-00237407-00237606": "let's just you're not trying to merge", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01025-00237607-00237823": "the two in the same input so there are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01026-00237823-00238055": "several questions here one question is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01027-00238056-00238423": "if you have two inputs that are from two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01028-00238423-00238534": "um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01029-00238535-00238863": "you know transactions where you um you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01030-00238864-00239015": "you have two change amounts and they", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01031-00239016-00239158": "both have some link to your identity and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01032-00239159-00239310": "now you want to mix them and they're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01033-00239311-00239510": "mixed together do those two inputs have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01034-00239511-00239703": "a link you know again you can you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01035-00239704-00239967": "you know i would say that for for large", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01036-00239967-00240175": "transactions the kind that we kind of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01037-00240176-00240471": "expect the link is is very modest and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01038-00240471-00240710": "we've looked at at the numbers you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01039-00240711-00240951": "for any amount any any doesn't matter", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01040-00240952-00241206": "what amount of of bitcoin that you have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01041-00241207-00241398": "on the left-hand side there's you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01042-00241400-00241630": "typically thousands of ways that it can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01043-00241631-00241910": "be represented as a valid amount on the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01044-00241911-00242158": "right-hand side in the form of five six", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01045-00242159-00242406": "seven you know eight outputs if if you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01046-00242407-00242551": "have you know our expectation is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01047-00242552-00242703": "something like two to three hundred", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01048-00242704-00242879": "inputs and two to three hundred outputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01049-00242880-00243110": "per coin join you know even if you could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01050-00243111-00243327": "hypothetically break down all the valid", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01051-00243328-00243558": "sub transactions which we don't we don't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01052-00243559-00243798": "think is is feasible you know barring", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01053-00243800-00243879": "some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01054-00243880-00244175": "you know crazy uh you know someone being", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01055-00244176-00244415": "um you know half the clients or or a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01056-00244416-00244575": "majority of the clients", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01057-00244576-00244798": "um why don't you think that's feasible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01058-00244800-00244958": "to to break down the subtract the valid", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01059-00244959-00245191": "sub transactions in a 200 input 200", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01060-00245192-00245351": "output coinjoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01061-00245352-00245591": "yeah it's just the the the time that it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01062-00245592-00245851": "would take is is immense", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01063-00245852-00246055": "computationally too hard is the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01064-00246056-00246271": "assumption and and it's in particular", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01065-00246271-00246503": "because we have like you know so many", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01066-00246504-00246758": "denominations and and that users only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01067-00246759-00246982": "choose you know specific denominations", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01068-00246983-00247110": "it might it might have been a different", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01069-00247111-00247255": "thing if we said you know users are just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01070-00247256-00247446": "deciding their own denominations and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01071-00247448-00247591": "they're not cooperating and then there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01072-00247592-00247710": "could be some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01073-00247711-00247951": "link but again every user regardless of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01074-00247952-00248127": "the amount of bitcoin they have will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01075-00248128-00248319": "have thousands of ways to represent", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01076-00248319-00248503": "their particular amount of bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01077-00248504-00248679": "whether it's one input or 10 inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01078-00248680-00248894": "which is the limit up to 10 inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01079-00248896-00249046": "they'll have thousands of ways to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01080-00249048-00249271": "represent that as outputs and so and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01081-00249271-00249463": "that's for every coordinator side where", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01082-00249464-00249694": "there's like a minimum threshold of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01083-00249696-00249982": "thousands uh no so it's it's it's it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01084-00249983-00250230": "uh we we know based on the amount of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01085-00250231-00250423": "bitcoin they have so this this number", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01086-00250423-00250639": "goes radically down if the amount is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01087-00250640-00250830": "really really small so if someone shows", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01088-00250831-00251110": "up with 50 000 satoshi's then yes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01089-00251111-00251310": "there's almost no ways they could they", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01090-00251311-00251551": "could represent that on the output side", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01091-00251552-00251727": "but the moment you hit more than like i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01092-00251728-00251934": "think it's like 10 millibit coins or you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01093-00251935-00252134": "know 50 million bitcoins a very small", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01094-00252135-00252255": "and reasonable amount then the number", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01095-00252256-00252510": "quickly grows and then it starts to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01096-00252511-00252751": "decay as as you go past like one one", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01097-00252752-00252975": "bitcoin amounts um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01098-00252976-00253151": "depending on and again this also depends", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01099-00253152-00253375": "on on the users and and how large their", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01100-00253376-00253679": "coins are but yes uh we've we've looked", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01101-00253680-00253871": "at this and there are in fact thousands", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01102-00253871-00254167": "of ways to represent uh your input like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01103-00254167-00254630": "99 of input amounts as uh in eight coins", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01104-00254631-00254798": "you know five six seven or eight coins", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01105-00254800-00254991": "on the right hand side yeah my question", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01106-00254992-00255119": "my question isn't asking about the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01107-00255119-00255294": "right-hand side my question is about the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01108-00255296-00255519": "probability that one input is related to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01109-00255519-00255703": "another so let's walk through that right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01110-00255704-00255951": "so how would you uh so the way that you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01111-00255952-00256079": "would um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01112-00256080-00256271": "you would figure out that input you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01113-00256271-00256551": "7 and input 12 are linked is that you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01114-00256552-00256734": "take all the inputs and you take all the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01115-00256735-00256958": "outputs and you break it down into sub", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01116-00256959-00257215": "transactions valid sub transactions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01117-00257216-00257446": "right and you say i've noticed that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01118-00257448-00257655": "input 7 and input 15 or whatever i just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01119-00257656-00257910": "said i already forgot are always", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01120-00257911-00258023": "together", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01121-00258023-00258198": "right that's how you find out that input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01122-00258200-00258423": "7 and input 15 are linked is that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01123-00258423-00258558": "they're always together when we break", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01124-00258559-00258782": "into sub transactions but i'm telling", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01125-00258783-00259023": "you that um and and this goes in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01126-00259023-00259215": "reverse order as well right you could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01127-00259216-00259367": "have eight inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01128-00259367-00259439": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01129-00259440-00259630": "you can't exclude that from the table as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01130-00259631-00259791": "well and you know i've been i've been", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01131-00259792-00259942": "saying this in the research clubs that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01132-00259944-00260087": "you know it's critical that we have coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01133-00260088-00260279": "joins where individuals have you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01134-00260280-00260503": "more than eight inputs and and ideally", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01135-00260504-00260694": "eight outputs as well precisely for this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01136-00260696-00260879": "reason you're gonna have a lot of you're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01137-00260880-00261023": "gonna have a lot more than one way to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01138-00261023-00261246": "represent uh input seven and input 15.", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01139-00261248-00261327": "you know you're gonna have sub", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01140-00261328-00261439": "transactions where they're separate", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01141-00261440-00261567": "you're gonna have the subject sub", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01142-00261567-00261815": "transactions where they're they're uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01143-00261816-00262046": "with other coins entirely um you're not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01144-00262048-00262167": "it's not going to be completely without", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01145-00262168-00262358": "a link we we know that you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01146-00262359-00262487": "everything is linked to everything", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01147-00262488-00262623": "there's some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01148-00262624-00262871": "with with exceptions almost any coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01149-00262872-00263087": "could be associated with any other coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01150-00263088-00263334": "in to some degree when when the coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01151-00263335-00263503": "joint is large enough because there are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01152-00263504-00263655": "just so many coins to choose from and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01153-00263656-00263887": "there's so many ways you can construct", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01154-00263888-00264039": "uh but this is what i think about so if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01155-00264040-00264175": "you wanna if you want to talk more about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01156-00264176-00264319": "this i would love to have you join the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01157-00264320-00264534": "wasabi research club or just just uh you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01158-00264535-00264679": "know schedule time and we can we can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01159-00264680-00264991": "talk uh about this um is is that the uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01160-00264992-00265151": "only concern because that doesn't sound", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01161-00265152-00265455": "like the the coordinator uh concern i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01162-00265456-00265599": "still not sure how it's addressed is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01163-00265600-00265815": "there some like minimum", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01164-00265816-00265982": "set is there a minimum number of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01165-00265983-00266255": "participants for the coin join you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01166-00266256-00266471": "enforce or is it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01167-00266472-00266671": "yes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01168-00266672-00266919": "can i give it a try and you guys uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01169-00266920-00267263": "fix it if i say something wrong sure", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01170-00267264-00267606": "okay so we either have a coinjoin round", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01171-00267607-00267847": "going through every hour or when there's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01172-00267848-00268143": "150 inputs i think currently it's not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01173-00268144-00268430": "every hour so the minimum is 150 inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01174-00268431-00268615": "that we're targeting let's say let's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01175-00268616-00268863": "assume that so if you have 150 inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01176-00268864-00269158": "even if the two of them are yours it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01177-00269159-00269334": "very very unlikely that you're going to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01178-00269335-00269551": "be able to link them those two together", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01179-00269552-00269687": "and like any", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01180-00269688-00269958": "reasonable probability how unlikely what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01181-00269959-00270282": "probability it it varies it it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01182-00270283-00270558": "varies on the situation it's a minimum", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01183-00270559-00270910": "threshold that's what i'm asking like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01184-00270911-00271039": "or is it just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01185-00271040-00271230": "i should trust you technically the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01186-00271231-00271575": "server has a maximum number of inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01187-00271576-00271799": "which triggers around all the time so as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01188-00271800-00271982": "soon as we hit the maximum number the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01189-00271983-00272239": "coin john bond gets triggered right or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01190-00272240-00272430": "if we hit the one hour mark that's the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01191-00272431-00272663": "timeout card constrained right that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01192-00272664-00272879": "kind of similar to how we had it in 1.0", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01193-00272880-00273199": "either 100 users the heart limit upper", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01194-00273200-00273439": "limit or the one hour time node and just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01195-00273440-00273599": "now the coordinator no longer knows the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01196-00273600-00273743": "number of users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01197-00273744-00273879": "because he doesn't know input input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01198-00273880-00274095": "linkage and therefore its numbers of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01199-00274096-00274351": "inputs which is currently at 300", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01200-00274352-00274543": "and we have a minimum", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01201-00274544-00274855": "a minimum input count multiplier i guess", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01202-00274856-00275047": "in the in the configuration and that is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01203-00275048-00275303": "currently on main net set to 0.5 so with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01204-00275304-00275687": "this means we have 300 maximum and the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01205-00275688-00276103": "minimum is 50 of that meaning 150. so if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01206-00276104-00276319": "after one hour and still there are not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01207-00276320-00276615": "150 coin joints inputs registered to the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01208-00276616-00276815": "current round of coin join then this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01209-00276816-00277015": "will fail and we start another input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01210-00277016-00277271": "registration for another hour i believe", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01211-00277272-00277439": "yeah and a few things to note over here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01212-00277440-00277687": "we have whale pools so if you have a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01213-00277688-00277903": "really big amount you're gonna probably", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01214-00277904-00278175": "wait few rounds so you're not you you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01215-00278176-00278399": "actually like mix with the other big", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01216-00278400-00278487": "whales", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01217-00278488-00278703": "so that's one thing then the other thing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01218-00278704-00278887": "is that you're choosing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01219-00278888-00279134": "between one to eight inputs into your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01220-00279135-00279447": "coin join so it's very like even", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01221-00279448-00279734": "oh yeah one to ten so even if you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01222-00279735-00279991": "that you know these two inputs belong", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01223-00279992-00280263": "together for some weird reason", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01224-00280264-00280487": "you still wouldn't be able to you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01225-00280488-00280719": "like that's let's say you get to change", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01226-00280720-00281071": "out from me uh and you put these two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01227-00281072-00281255": "into coinjoin round i still don't know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01228-00281256-00281487": "if you have registered even more inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01229-00281488-00281743": "in there and also if you have a change", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01230-00281744-00281951": "output it probably has the annual score", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01231-00281952-00282199": "one so you're probably not consolidating", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01232-00282200-00282382": "these two coins together at this point", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01233-00282383-00282527": "but you're actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01234-00282528-00282719": "like decomposing them", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01235-00282720-00282919": "but either way it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01236-00282920-00283134": "it's very very unlikely that you're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01237-00283135-00283406": "gonna figure out uh these links", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01238-00283407-00283806": "uh d dan um so i i i love your your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01239-00283807-00284047": "skepticism because this is how i uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01240-00284048-00284247": "approach things and and thank you for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01241-00284248-00284463": "once again letting a meeting that i'm a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01242-00284464-00284647": "part of be hijacked into a wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01243-00284648-00284847": "research club that's kind of my goal", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01244-00284848-00285047": "here every meeting is a wasabi research", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01245-00285048-00285415": "club when i'm in the meeting but um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01246-00285416-00285591": "so one solution is that you don't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01247-00285592-00285839": "perform coin joins with uh with coins", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01248-00285840-00286023": "with an onset one with more than one", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01249-00286024-00286334": "coin um uh uh and an even better thing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01250-00286335-00286630": "would be you perform uh them with maybe", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01251-00286631-00286823": "one coin that's that's your change coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01252-00286824-00286999": "and then if you have any already mixed", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01253-00287000-00287287": "coins or almost mixed coins you can you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01254-00287288-00287463": "can begin mixing that coin with those", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01255-00287464-00287639": "coins as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01256-00287640-00287782": "because those coins are unlinked you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01257-00287783-00287934": "know in inputs are not linked by the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01258-00287935-00288119": "coordinator because of uh of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01259-00288120-00288343": "wabi-sabi protocol and so now it becomes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01260-00288344-00288495": "even harder", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01261-00288496-00288671": "because now when someone's is following", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01262-00288672-00288854": "your change amount", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01263-00288855-00288958": "right they're not going to be able to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01264-00288959-00289230": "reasonably know where that money went", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01265-00289231-00289479": "in on the right-hand side because you've", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01266-00289480-00289751": "paired a bunch of more anonymous coins", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01267-00289752-00289967": "on the left-hand side with the the the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01268-00289968-00290223": "change so would that be um one one", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01269-00290224-00290375": "solution", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01270-00290376-00290591": "i i understand more now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01271-00290592-00290839": "i'm i'm still i'm going to have to read", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01272-00290840-00291006": "i suppose um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01273-00291007-00291199": "yeah it's not easy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01274-00291200-00291406": "the solution i just told is i was just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01275-00291407-00291606": "told this don't coin join with anon set", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01276-00291607-00291775": "one coins but that's where everyone", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01277-00291776-00291903": "starts so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01278-00291904-00292119": "no no no sorry what i'm saying is that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01279-00292120-00292415": "this is the surefire 100 solution", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01280-00292416-00292767": "whereas normally it would still", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01281-00292768-00293063": "you know be not very linkable we just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01282-00293064-00293367": "cannot tell you exactly the number", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01283-00293368-00293623": "and and there are edge cases where those", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01284-00293624-00293854": "two coins could have a very strong link", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01285-00293855-00294119": "like 95 percent or even 100 percent i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01286-00294120-00294367": "like i'm not saying it's broken if if if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01287-00294368-00294567": "you don't do this method it's just it it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01288-00294568-00294743": "it's about how extreme you want to go in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01289-00294744-00294847": "terms of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01290-00294848-00294927": "um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01291-00294928-00295134": "in terms of like the certainty and just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01292-00295135-00295382": "to clarify before speaking about uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01293-00295383-00295639": "prefer not to consolidate", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01294-00295640-00295934": "more than one coin with one anon score", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01295-00295935-00296087": "when you register your inputs for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01296-00296088-00296295": "coinjoin uh and again this check is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01297-00296296-00296479": "happening i'm not sure exactly again", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01298-00296480-00296630": "about the details but another", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01299-00296631-00296854": "observation here is that if we have a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01300-00296855-00297071": "kind of deterministic protocol of things", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01301-00297072-00297415": "like input or output selection then this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01302-00297416-00297695": "someone decreases the ambiguity of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01303-00297696-00297910": "round right for example if the adversary", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01304-00297911-00298271": "knows that any client always only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01305-00298272-00298615": "registers a single one and on score", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01306-00298616-00298815": "change coin if if that's how the client", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01307-00298816-00299087": "behaves all the time 100 of the time", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01308-00299088-00299263": "then if the adversary looks at a coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01309-00299264-00299527": "join and he sees a single", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01310-00299528-00299767": "uh non-standard change", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01311-00299768-00299879": "input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01312-00299880-00299951": "then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01313-00299952-00300134": "he will know that this is the only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01314-00300135-00300382": "non-standard change input of this user's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01315-00300383-00300582": "input cluster right because the client", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01316-00300583-00300854": "never selects more than one like that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01317-00300855-00301071": "and and so he this decreases the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01318-00301072-00301406": "ambiguity of what's the input group of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01319-00301407-00301630": "any of that particular user and then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01320-00301631-00301927": "that's why in general i believe it makes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01321-00301928-00302191": "sense to have some randomness here right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01322-00302192-00302510": "so that you you don't say we always only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01323-00302511-00302782": "pick only one anon score coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01324-00302783-00302879": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01325-00302880-00303047": "you know sometimes occasionally even", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01326-00303048-00303358": "pick two or three and this all in all i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01327-00303359-00303534": "think increases the ambiguity because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01328-00303535-00303719": "now an outside observer who only sees", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01329-00303720-00303854": "the input and output list of that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01330-00303855-00304158": "coinjoin has a much harder time to try", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01331-00304159-00304358": "to fingerprint what is the behavior of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01332-00304359-00304543": "one given user", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01333-00304544-00304847": "i agree let me let me summarize this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01334-00304848-00305182": "which is how i think about it i i wrote", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01335-00305183-00305439": "an article called privacy guarantees of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01336-00305440-00305791": "wasabi at 2.2 then i asked the question", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01337-00305792-00306030": "what are the privacy guarantees", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01338-00306031-00306327": "firstly there is a computational", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01339-00306328-00306534": "hardness in the anonymizing wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01340-00306535-00306630": "wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01341-00306631-00306719": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01342-00306720-00307015": "probably that computational hardness of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01343-00307016-00307254": "quantum computers improve or whatever", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01344-00307255-00307495": "happens in a hundred year is going to be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01345-00307496-00307710": "broken but there is a second line of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01346-00307711-00307927": "defense which is the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01347-00307928-00308015": "the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01348-00308016-00308287": "subset number of subset transactions and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01349-00308288-00308371": "more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01350-00308372-00308534": "importantly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01351-00308535-00308671": "the input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01352-00308672-00308863": "inputs and outputs and outputs and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01353-00308864-00309295": "output so there are privacy hard privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01354-00309296-00309527": "guarantees there but what's the problem", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01355-00309528-00309734": "with that well the problem with that is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01356-00309735-00309871": "that we don't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01357-00309872-00310039": "know exactly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01358-00310040-00310454": "what a specific case of of coinjoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01359-00310455-00310799": "resulted in and finally this is why we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01360-00310800-00310903": "are going", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01361-00310904-00311191": "doing equal outputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01362-00311192-00311534": "because that's the third line of defense", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01363-00311535-00311830": "equal outputs which by the way people at", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01364-00311831-00312087": "1.2 that was the only line of defense", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01365-00312088-00312367": "right the third line of defense is the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01366-00312368-00312630": "equal outputs right so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01367-00312631-00312910": "that is being proven to work in vasa", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01368-00312911-00313199": "people at 1.2 but again there are those", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01369-00313200-00313503": "other two things which i know uh you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01370-00313504-00313847": "guys find the second one very very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01371-00313848-00314119": "uh exciting and i guess the thief give", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01372-00314120-00314295": "you back the bird max", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01373-00314296-00314510": "thanks for your summary adam", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01374-00314511-00314727": "if i can just add one more thing there's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01375-00314728-00315047": "like 15 additional problems that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01376-00315048-00315287": "we we've been looking at and discussing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01377-00315288-00315551": "uh you know i'm i'm personally very open", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01378-00315552-00315734": "to hearing those problems and like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01379-00315735-00315895": "thinking about them i'm not sure how", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01380-00315896-00316103": "familiar with those other problems uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01381-00316104-00316254": "and if you've been sort of following the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01382-00316255-00316510": "the wasabi research club but i i really", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01383-00316511-00316727": "encourage you to um to kind of be you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01384-00316728-00316927": "know be a part of that conversation so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01385-00316928-00317134": "we can uh can make progress yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01386-00317135-00317310": "definitely again this is a really really", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01387-00317311-00317534": "difficult problem what we have is i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01388-00317535-00317758": "think well thought through and quite all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01389-00317759-00317854": "right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01390-00317855-00318087": "but again it's definitely not perfect", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01391-00318088-00318310": "there's rooms of improvements a lot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01392-00318311-00318551": "uh and yeah getting feedback on things", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01393-00318552-00318710": "like this is very important so much", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01394-00318711-00318927": "appreciated then yeah overall this is a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01395-00318928-00319110": "very good question and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01396-00319111-00319191": "like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01397-00319192-00319399": "you saw now it's not really easy to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01398-00319400-00319543": "explain this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01399-00319544-00319710": "so we still have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01400-00319711-00319943": "a lot of work to do on making that more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01401-00319944-00320158": "efficient anything else then any other", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01402-00320159-00320254": "feedback", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01403-00320255-00320415": "the other thing i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01404-00320416-00320630": "heard that got brought up was that you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01405-00320631-00320927": "can modify the client not to pay any fee", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01406-00320928-00321191": "that's not enforced is that actually the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01407-00321192-00321271": "case", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01408-00321272-00321463": "i hate to ask a yes no question but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01409-00321464-00321582": "that's uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01410-00321583-00321782": "that one that one stuck out to me", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01411-00321783-00322079": "yeah that was no about it but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01412-00322080-00322358": "it did not end up being the case", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01413-00322359-00322551": "the answer is it's no", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01414-00322552-00322903": "basically um but if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01415-00322904-00323047": "yes no", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01416-00323048-00323191": "you cannot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01417-00323192-00323430": "i know what you mean is basically what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01418-00323431-00323687": "you can do if you don't want to pay a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01419-00323688-00323910": "coordination fees", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01420-00323911-00324223": "split your coins under the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01421-00324224-00324423": "what we call the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01422-00324424-00324582": "pleb the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01423-00324583-00324775": "threshold right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01424-00324776-00325006": "so you can if you participate with very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01425-00325007-00325310": "small coins you are not going to pay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01426-00325311-00325599": "of course you are going to pay more in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01427-00325600-00325679": "in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01428-00325680-00325767": "in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01429-00325768-00325982": "network fees because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01430-00325983-00326263": "you will need more participate in more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01431-00326264-00326447": "rounds with more coins in order to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01432-00326448-00326830": "achieve the same level of privacy right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01433-00326831-00327103": "so you can you can do that that is what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01434-00327104-00327367": "nothing much was um talking about in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01435-00327368-00327623": "fact he he clarified that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01436-00327624-00327934": "you know in a tweet uh but i would like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01437-00327935-00328047": "to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01438-00328048-00328367": "if that is okay i would like to answer", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01439-00328368-00328671": "your project your previous question if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01440-00328672-00328903": "it is good because basically", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01441-00328904-00329206": "it is basically how to guarantee if you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01442-00329207-00329510": "want that inputs to input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01443-00329511-00329871": "links are not let's say easy to to see", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01444-00329872-00330206": "right or to to discover or to analyze", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01445-00330207-00330399": "first of all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01446-00330400-00330782": "we have to in order to see how good", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01447-00330783-00331071": "quasavi wallet 2 is we can compare it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01448-00331072-00331182": "with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01449-00331183-00331406": "the other and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01450-00331407-00331663": "coinjoin protocols for example if you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01451-00331664-00331799": "have for example", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01452-00331800-00332063": "the summary one well in summary wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01453-00332064-00332223": "you have to reveal", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01454-00332224-00332334": "your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01455-00332335-00332703": "wallet your coins in a transaction zero", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01456-00332704-00333063": "or initial transaction so so everybody", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01457-00333064-00333351": "that can read the blockchain or can use", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01458-00333352-00333606": "a blockchain explorer can see", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01459-00333607-00333799": "those inputs right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01460-00333800-00334071": "something similar but but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01461-00334072-00334271": "better happens with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01462-00334272-00334487": "um joy market", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01463-00334488-00334767": "because in joy market one input belong", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01464-00334768-00335023": "to one of the the maker or the taker", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01465-00335024-00335119": "right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01466-00335120-00335454": "if it is the first first round right so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01467-00335455-00335695": "you know the input that comes from a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01468-00335696-00335991": "previous joint market coin joint", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01469-00335992-00336303": "is the taker right and and the new money", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01470-00336304-00336687": "is the is the maker right so you you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01471-00336688-00336767": "know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01472-00336768-00336903": "sometimes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01473-00336904-00337095": "the common ownership of the invoice in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01474-00337096-00337343": "what's required one only the coordinator", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01475-00337344-00337591": "can know that because all the inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01476-00337592-00337919": "goes together in one single", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01477-00337920-00338158": "http request to the coordinator so the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01478-00338159-00338375": "coordinator can know that but nobody", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01479-00338376-00338647": "else can in what's having quality 2", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01480-00338648-00338854": "no one can know that even the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01481-00338855-00339039": "coordinator doesn't know that right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01482-00339040-00339239": "because all the inputs are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01483-00339240-00339399": "registered", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01484-00339400-00339719": "with a different identity so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01485-00339720-00340030": "basically in in that specific", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01486-00340031-00340287": "area what's happening wallet 2 or what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01487-00340288-00340454": "we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01488-00340455-00340671": "is the best of the best of the best of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01489-00340672-00340782": "the product", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01490-00340783-00340871": "right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01491-00340872-00341030": "the thing is that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01492-00341031-00341191": "of course we want", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01493-00341192-00341358": "more and better and better and better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01494-00341359-00341551": "and better technology so that's why we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01495-00341552-00341839": "are asking these questions but in terms", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01496-00341840-00341910": "of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01497-00341911-00342239": "that there is nothing like uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01498-00342240-00342510": "wabi-sabi product then we can discuss if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01499-00342511-00342623": "you want", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01500-00342624-00342710": "if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01501-00342711-00342999": "those links can be analyzed", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01502-00343000-00343182": "once they are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01503-00343183-00343367": "available on the blockchain", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01504-00343368-00343615": "well it's another discussion that of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01505-00343616-00343830": "course the answer is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01506-00343831-00343958": "is not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01507-00343959-00344127": "because that is basically the service", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01508-00344128-00344358": "that we are providing right the linking", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01509-00344359-00344439": "of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01510-00344440-00344654": "the coping inputs and output basically", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01511-00344655-00344878": "that is our business well that's that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01512-00344879-00345158": "my concern is i i don't believe that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01513-00345159-00345399": "true right now the input input links the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01514-00345400-00345606": "claim that the input input links could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01515-00345607-00345806": "only be identified by the coordinator in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01516-00345807-00345967": "the past and now can't because they're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01517-00345968-00346287": "registered across different requests is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01518-00346288-00346551": "just not the case given either as aviv", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01519-00346552-00346775": "was saying sufficient computation across", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01520-00346776-00347015": "a whole coin join to find all of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01521-00347016-00347343": "possibilities or if you were to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01522-00347344-00347519": "uh if you were to make that comp", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01523-00347520-00347703": "computation more efficient in a targeted", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01524-00347704-00348063": "attack if you had some idea that perhaps", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01525-00348064-00348303": "two or three inputs were most likely to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01526-00348304-00348558": "be related and then you started", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01527-00348559-00348727": "looking for all the possibilities only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01528-00348728-00349071": "regarding those on chain i'm not well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01529-00349072-00349191": "it's not clear", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01530-00349192-00349406": "guarantee is that the those links won't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01531-00349407-00349527": "be made", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01532-00349528-00349663": "aren't we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01533-00349664-00349919": "i'm not sure that they're not any less", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01534-00349920-00350087": "dangerous than input output links", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01535-00350088-00350271": "because if i made a payment", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01536-00350272-00350343": "with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01537-00350344-00350630": "uh one coin and then i made a different", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01538-00350631-00350799": "payment with something that i got from", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01539-00350800-00351095": "an exchange maybe i made a donation to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01540-00351096-00351287": "navalny's team in the us", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01541-00351288-00351534": "and no value judgment on whether that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01542-00351535-00351743": "good or not the putin regime wouldn't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01543-00351744-00351975": "like that if they saw that related to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01544-00351976-00352095": "kyc", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01545-00352096-00352358": "account they'd be able to identify", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01546-00352359-00352495": "that transaction with me if they could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01547-00352496-00352671": "make the link like these kind of dangers", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01548-00352672-00352887": "are my concern and shipping this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01549-00352888-00353167": "software and i understand that we're all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01550-00353168-00353430": "striving for progress and there's no", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01551-00353431-00353678": "perfect solution that exists yet but i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01552-00353679-00353903": "have to voice these concerns because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01553-00353904-00353999": "there are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01554-00354000-00354278": "real visceral human dangers", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01555-00354279-00354630": "that we're trying to prevent yes but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01556-00354631-00354982": "the thing is basically right if you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01557-00354983-00355063": "know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01558-00355064-00355278": "once in the blockchain that two inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01559-00355279-00355358": "are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01560-00355359-00355654": "related the only the only way you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01561-00355655-00355967": "know that it's basically analyzing the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01562-00355968-00356358": "the coinjoin transaction right and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01563-00356359-00356463": "finding", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01564-00356464-00356615": "all the possible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01565-00356616-00356806": "the compositions you don't need to find", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01566-00356807-00356967": "all of them for the whole transaction", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01567-00356968-00357175": "you just need to find all related to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01568-00357176-00357382": "that imp to those the inputs you're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01569-00357383-00357575": "interested in you you actually would", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01570-00357576-00357703": "need to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01571-00357704-00357823": "if you wanted to if you wanted to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01572-00357824-00358006": "solidify that those two inputs are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01573-00358007-00358230": "linked you would need to find all if you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01574-00358231-00358423": "wanted to get a good approximation of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01575-00358424-00358599": "where the outputs are going then you're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01576-00358600-00358782": "correct you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01577-00358783-00359095": "just target several inputs and assume", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01578-00359096-00359247": "that they're from the same person assume", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01579-00359248-00359415": "that there are no additional inputs and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01580-00359416-00359567": "say okay these inputs here with some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01581-00359568-00359743": "margin of error what are the likely", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01582-00359744-00359927": "outputs and you will get a much reduced", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01583-00359928-00360151": "set of outputs and there equal outputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01584-00360152-00360303": "will defend the user as well as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01585-00360304-00360495": "different interpretations of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01586-00360496-00360775": "of of the outputs but no if you think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01587-00360776-00361054": "two inputs are together you still need", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01588-00361055-00361151": "all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01589-00361152-00361382": "combinations of inputs and outputs and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01590-00361383-00361615": "the subset sum problem to to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01591-00361616-00361806": "to say with confidence yes they are in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01592-00361807-00361943": "fact uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01593-00361944-00362023": "you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01594-00362024-00362215": "combined there's there's no way around", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01595-00362216-00362287": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01596-00362288-00362487": "involving those inputs and outputs not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01597-00362488-00362599": "all of the ones where they're together", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01598-00362600-00362727": "but just involving them if they're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01599-00362728-00362991": "totally involving something else", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01600-00362992-00363175": "then what you have then what you have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01601-00363176-00363351": "when you get all of those involving", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01602-00363352-00363551": "those two is you have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01603-00363552-00363767": "uh likely outputs that are linked to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01604-00363768-00363982": "those two inputs if those two inputs are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01605-00363983-00364078": "linked", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01606-00364079-00364295": "it's not you you're not getting the the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01607-00364296-00364487": "fact that those two inputs are linked", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01608-00364488-00364815": "like there is no targeted attack on two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01609-00364816-00365206": "specific inputs to get the link", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01610-00365207-00365503": "between them themselves wasabi has more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01611-00365504-00365671": "exactly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01612-00365672-00365830": "that's awesome exactly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01613-00365831-00366078": "once once you find all the possible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01614-00366079-00366375": "decompositions in which those", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01615-00366376-00366743": "inputs right participate you can say for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01616-00366744-00366871": "example okay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01617-00366872-00367071": "i found let's say", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01618-00367072-00367430": "1 000 or 100 if you want okay i found", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01619-00367431-00367615": "100 possible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01620-00367616-00367927": "sub transactions but it is because you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01621-00367928-00368263": "start from the from assuming the inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01622-00368264-00368358": "right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01623-00368359-00368543": "because you you say okay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01624-00368544-00368734": "because first you have to assume the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01625-00368735-00368958": "inputs but that is completely fake and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01626-00368959-00369223": "even if you say okay i want to see how", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01627-00369224-00369519": "many sub transactions are possible with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01628-00369520-00369806": "this input so in the in that case you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01629-00369807-00370006": "are assuming the input you will find a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01630-00370007-00370263": "lot of some transactions so you have to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01631-00370264-00370495": "also assume the outputs and if you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01632-00370496-00370695": "assume the inputs and you assume the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01633-00370696-00370967": "output then it is a very very very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01634-00370968-00371175": "extremely biased", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01635-00371176-00371399": "analysis in fact it's not an analysis", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01636-00371400-00371663": "that is something that you try to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01637-00371664-00371799": "justify", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01638-00371800-00371999": "your interpretation let's say but there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01639-00372000-00372263": "are many job execution though that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01640-00372264-00372423": "that's what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01641-00372424-00372567": "we're trying to get people in trouble", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01642-00372568-00372847": "too awesome so let me let me just um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01643-00372848-00373102": "kind of maybe summarize things um every", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01644-00373103-00373327": "person that's done the sort of more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01645-00373328-00373567": "research side of wasabi has come to the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01646-00373568-00373727": "conclusions that there's a lot of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01647-00373728-00374006": "problems and that there are a lot of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01648-00374007-00374271": "dangers a lot of edge cases uh a lot of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01649-00374272-00374502": "concerns uh the best example is you've", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01650-00374503-00374782": "all you've all uh you know was extremely", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01651-00374783-00375015": "concerned about about things uh and then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01652-00375016-00375310": "i showed up a few months ago a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01653-00375311-00375471": "month and a half ago to to look at stuff", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01654-00375472-00375782": "and then i i showed concerns so i i i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01655-00375783-00375854": "think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01656-00375855-00376006": "it's not that i'm telling you that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01657-00376007-00376247": "everything is without concerns it's the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01658-00376248-00376423": "opposite uh we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01659-00376424-00376639": "there's there's a lot of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01660-00376640-00376815": "stuff to do and and yes you know like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01661-00376816-00377023": "you know wasabi could go out and give", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01662-00377024-00377254": "these like long caveats like you know if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01663-00377255-00377406": "you do this and then you do this and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01664-00377407-00377558": "then this happens and then your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01665-00377559-00377782": "particular concern is this then this is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01666-00377783-00377927": "what you should be worried about and you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01667-00377928-00378095": "should know this on the other hand", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01668-00378096-00378319": "there's the fact that like what wallets", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01669-00378320-00378527": "do people have as options when it comes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01670-00378528-00378727": "to privacy preserving wallets what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01671-00378728-00378934": "wallet would be like number two you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01672-00378935-00379134": "there really isn't a lot to to go for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01673-00379135-00379319": "especially for like people who aren't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01674-00379320-00379527": "extremely tech oriented and can like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01675-00379528-00379719": "manage all their things and have like a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01676-00379720-00379887": "really in-depth stuff there's just this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01677-00379888-00380087": "unhappy i guess medium where we just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01678-00380088-00380254": "accept that there's there's like serious", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01679-00380255-00380471": "problems we we live with them and we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01680-00380472-00380663": "think about them and and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01681-00380664-00380799": "and and and what you're saying where", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01682-00380800-00381054": "like it's dangerous to ship this product", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01683-00381055-00381215": "you're right it's dangerous to ship this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01684-00381216-00381399": "product it's also dangerous not to ship", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01685-00381400-00381671": "this product right so you know what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01686-00381672-00381887": "would you do uh i mean delay it more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01687-00381888-00382047": "like i've i've been delaying i've been", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01688-00382048-00382351": "begging people for this project sorry i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01689-00382352-00382599": "mean but but but i i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01690-00382600-00382871": "that is not the the the way to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01691-00382872-00383063": "to go i mean", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01692-00383064-00383351": "we have to to answer the question right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01693-00383352-00383415": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01694-00383416-00383799": "i know now i don't i don't know if i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01695-00383800-00383991": "really really really understand the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01696-00383992-00384199": "question that that that could be that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01697-00384200-00384463": "the first thing to clarify because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01698-00384464-00384647": "i need to understand this in order to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01699-00384648-00384951": "answer right so let me ask questions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01700-00384952-00385199": "right to understand the question what is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01701-00385200-00385519": "the difference i mean what why is in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01702-00385520-00385767": "this specific topic", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01703-00385768-00385919": "why would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01704-00385920-00386278": "a wabi-sabi a different", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01705-00386279-00386639": "zero link or the the version one of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01706-00386640-00386991": "wasabi so why do you think that in this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01707-00386992-00387175": "case input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01708-00387176-00387334": "can be uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01709-00387335-00387671": "linked by an external observer and yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01710-00387672-00387871": "and that was not possible in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01711-00387872-00388030": "in the previous version what what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01712-00388031-00388278": "changed in this regard i'm not asking", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01713-00388279-00388463": "about any change i'm asking about the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01714-00388464-00388654": "security of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01715-00388655-00388830": "product that's being released i don't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01716-00388831-00388967": "think there's any perfect solution that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01717-00388968-00389127": "exists right now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01718-00389128-00389406": "but but i mean you have a concern and i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01719-00389407-00389639": "i want to address your concept right so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01720-00389640-00389895": "i need to understand the question what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01721-00389896-00390087": "what lucas wants to know is is your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01722-00390088-00390247": "specific concern is that two inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01723-00390248-00390495": "could be linked because there's nothing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01724-00390496-00390687": "that inherently protects them when they", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01725-00390688-00390919": "both register in a coin join right two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01726-00390920-00391071": "change in uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01727-00391072-00391302": "outputs are now inputs in a coin join", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01728-00391303-00391463": "you're concerned that they're linked", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01729-00391464-00391687": "together that's that's the concern yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01730-00391688-00391967": "my concern is okay because it's knapsack", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01731-00391968-00392247": "is this mitigated in the wasabi too or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01732-00392248-00392447": "not yet and it sounds like under some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01733-00392448-00392671": "circumstances if you do some analysis it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01734-00392672-00392927": "could be but it's not clear well just to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01735-00392928-00393143": "be clear lucas is very right about this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01736-00393144-00393367": "the analysis you need to do is the total", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01737-00393368-00393791": "breakdown of a coin join which you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01738-00393792-00394063": "once you get past like 120 inputs 120", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01739-00394064-00394343": "outputs you now need special hardware", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01740-00394344-00394567": "because for regular hardware it will", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01741-00394568-00394702": "take you days", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01742-00394703-00394943": "to to do this so once you get to you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01743-00394944-00395143": "know 200 input certain outputs it's it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01744-00395144-00395351": "it's exponentially exponential", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01745-00395352-00395647": "when when you look at the problem um so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01746-00395648-00395791": "it's you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01747-00395792-00395951": "and all that gives you is the total", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01748-00395952-00396151": "breakdown um which which again i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01749-00396152-00396319": "personally don't think it's it's very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01750-00396320-00396502": "plausible for more than a hundred and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01751-00396503-00396823": "you know 60 inputs 160 outputs um but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01752-00396824-00397071": "but that's just my you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01753-00397072-00397287": "so so but you would need to do that to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01754-00397288-00397478": "to to get the the link between those", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01755-00397479-00397678": "inputs and and it wouldn't tell you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01756-00397679-00397847": "those inputs are perfectly linked most", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01757-00397848-00397967": "the time it would say that there's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01758-00397968-00398158": "there's a probabilistic link all inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01759-00398159-00398358": "and l outputs are linked to other inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01760-00398359-00398599": "and outputs by by some probability", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01761-00398600-00398910": "just just to add this first of all it is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01762-00398911-00399095": "true that it is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01763-00399096-00399310": "really really really hard to find all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01764-00399311-00399575": "the sub transactions because it is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01765-00399576-00399751": "it grows the difficulty grows", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01766-00399752-00400071": "exponentially but that is not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01767-00400072-00400151": "the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01768-00400152-00400247": "the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01769-00400248-00400478": "what guarantees that this car", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01770-00400479-00400751": "if you for example analyze much much", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01771-00400752-00400982": "smaller transaction right you try to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01772-00400983-00401206": "find all the possible decomposition for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01773-00401207-00401495": "a four input and four output", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01774-00401496-00401654": "transactions you will find that there", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01775-00401655-00401758": "are a lot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01776-00401759-00402071": "if you use a standard denominations", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01777-00402072-00402454": "right basically the thing is that after", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01778-00402455-00402727": "you found after you find all the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01779-00402728-00403015": "possible sub-transactions all the that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01780-00403016-00403319": "are at the order of i don't know i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01781-00403320-00403534": "should do the the numbers again i don't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01782-00403535-00403767": "remember but it have to be billions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01783-00403768-00404102": "right okay now you have to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01784-00404103-00404615": "filter right those uh sub transactions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01785-00404616-00404871": "that are using coin that you are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01786-00404872-00405206": "interested on right then you have all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01787-00405207-00405551": "the possible sub transactions in which", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01788-00405552-00405799": "that specific coin can participate and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01789-00405800-00405910": "you can see", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01790-00405911-00406071": "all that those substance sub", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01791-00406072-00406391": "transactions contains multiple inputs so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01792-00406392-00406671": "probabilistically you say okay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01793-00406672-00406947": "there are there are this coin can be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01794-00406948-00407230": "probabilistically linked to this input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01795-00407231-00407367": "to this input to this input to the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01796-00407368-00407623": "symbol right what the chances well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01797-00407624-00407830": "are very very very small because the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01798-00407831-00408071": "number of sub transactions are huge", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01799-00408072-00408327": "but to simplify to simplify this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01800-00408328-00408534": "explanation because it sounds like i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01801-00408535-00408910": "mean it is objectively true but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01802-00408911-00409182": "to make it even more simple right it is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01803-00409183-00409471": "exactly the same that you have to do", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01804-00409472-00409551": "to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01805-00409552-00409751": "know the links in whatsapp you call it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01806-00409752-00409839": "one", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01807-00409839-00410110": "it's exactly exactly the same right what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01808-00410112-00410351": "is the difference well in wasabi wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01809-00410352-00410551": "one you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01810-00410552-00410687": "that the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01811-00410688-00411039": "a user can participate with up to seven", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01812-00411039-00411422": "coins so you can let's say", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01813-00411423-00411663": "narrow the the scope of your your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01814-00411664-00411895": "analysis to find all the possible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01815-00411896-00412214": "sub-transactions that have no more than", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01816-00412215-00412510": "seven coins right so you can you you can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01817-00412512-00412670": "say okay these are all the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01818-00412671-00412863": "sub-transactions that contains more than", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01819-00412864-00413063": "seven coins are not possible in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01820-00413064-00413343": "solid so because you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01821-00413343-00413607": "the result of your analysis is better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01822-00413608-00413839": "right in what's happening two that is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01823-00413839-00414055": "not possible you don't know if the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01824-00414056-00414263": "user is participating with one coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01825-00414264-00414510": "three coins seven coins fifty coins", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01826-00414512-00414782": "right so you have to take all the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01827-00414783-00415039": "possibilities into accounts are really", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01828-00415039-00415222": "really really in the order of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01829-00415223-00415551": "billions and billions you know so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01830-00415552-00415630": "how", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01831-00415631-00415903": "probably is to link inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01832-00415904-00416110": "i think that is not what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01833-00416112-00416310": "juval was talking about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01834-00416312-00416566": "was talking about is what if the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01835-00416567-00416734": "coordinator", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01836-00416735-00416951": "can perform some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01837-00416952-00417174": "kind of something that is what i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01838-00417175-00417247": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01839-00417247-00417591": "on the blockchain is it's not so easy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01840-00417592-00417814": "okay thanks for answering guys well has", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01841-00417815-00418014": "anyone else any questions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01842-00418015-00418278": "well i guess while we are waiting for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01843-00418279-00418382": "the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01844-00418383-00418647": "for the questions in the live chat", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01845-00418647-00418982": "maybe max you could continue asking the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01846-00418983-00419351": "people around here about what were their", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01847-00419352-00419503": "experiences", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01848-00419504-00419687": "i was acting pretty cool", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01849-00419688-00419918": "effect", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01850-00419919-00420263": "let me let me ask jose if you are here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01851-00420264-00420495": "because i think you are the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01852-00420496-00420855": "you are the newest", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01853-00420856-00421039": "you're the newest person", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01854-00421039-00421335": "here the newest developer", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01855-00421335-00421431": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01856-00421432-00421663": "what was your impression of the female", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01857-00421664-00421839": "and everything that's going on here so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01858-00421839-00421966": "far", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01859-00421967-00422222": "well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01860-00422223-00422327": "it's a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01861-00422328-00422447": "it's a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01862-00422447-00422566": "wonderful", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01863-00422567-00422879": "environment uh to be honest", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01864-00422880-00423070": "i haven't had", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01865-00423071-00423487": "such a soft landing in my developer life", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01866-00423488-00423566": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01867-00423567-00423910": "i'm very very very happy to be part of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01868-00423912-00424063": "your project", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01869-00424064-00424383": "and in fact i'm very happy because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01870-00424384-00424775": "uh one of the features", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01871-00424776-00425207": "wasabi 2.0 has is the search bar as you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01872-00425208-00425407": "may already know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01873-00425408-00425575": "and it's a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01874-00425576-00425847": "an insta interesting feature i'm very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01875-00425847-00426127": "happy with it it fulfilled me with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01876-00426128-00426263": "happiness", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01877-00426264-00426663": "uh to see the feature in the release", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01878-00426664-00426799": "so i can be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01879-00426800-00426943": "happier", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01880-00426943-00427079": "to see that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01881-00427080-00427359": "included as part of the release", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01882-00427360-00427703": "moreover i'm very happy to be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01883-00427704-00428022": "around with such a wonderful people", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01884-00428023-00428135": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01885-00428135-00428231": "because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01886-00428232-00428447": "an old an old one", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01887-00428447-00428663": "i'm already 41", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01888-00428664-00428743": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01889-00428743-00429055": "it's it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01890-00429056-00429247": "it's incredible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01891-00429247-00429366": "how you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01892-00429367-00429439": "uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01893-00429439-00429599": "guys", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01894-00429600-00429855": "get everything over", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01895-00429856-00430103": "and how you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01896-00430104-00430647": "realize of minor issues even", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01897-00430647-00430831": "you have a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01898-00430832-00431110": "a feeling of perfection", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01899-00431112-00431231": "and that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01900-00431232-00431455": "really really important", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01901-00431456-00431766": "this is top quality product", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01902-00431767-00432087": "i haven't filled this in other open", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01903-00432088-00432247": "source projects", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01904-00432247-00432591": "and finally it's it's a quality thing i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01905-00432592-00432687": "think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01906-00432688-00432943": "taking everything as a whole", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01907-00432943-00433239": "wasabi is is a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01908-00433239-00433566": "great place to to work in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01909-00433567-00433863": "and i'm really proud of it and that's it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01910-00433864-00434055": "i think i cannot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01911-00434056-00434270": "say anything than", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01912-00434271-00434607": "good works good words and good quirk", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01913-00434608-00434727": "everyone", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01914-00434728-00435047": "uh congratulate everyone here yeah and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01915-00435047-00435214": "actually your the search bar that you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01916-00435215-00435470": "implemented is a perfect example of what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01917-00435471-00435703": "i mentioned earlier that this is a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01918-00435704-00435959": "really cool feature um and it's very", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01919-00435960-00436143": "useful already as it is but you know he", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01920-00436143-00436439": "even had that pr that uh includes to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01921-00436439-00436614": "search for example for transaction id", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01922-00436615-00436807": "and address and stuff like this but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01923-00436808-00437047": "that's just a glimpse of the potential", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01924-00437047-00437318": "that we have now um that where we can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01925-00437319-00437535": "further refine the wallet experience", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01926-00437535-00437727": "tremendously you know like a feature", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01927-00437728-00437918": "like is this andrew's mind just paste", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01928-00437919-00438070": "something in and shows you which wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01929-00438071-00438279": "it belongs to and the details associated", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01930-00438280-00438366": "with it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01931-00438367-00438518": "that's really powerful and it's great to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01932-00438519-00438710": "see that we we have those basic", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01933-00438712-00438910": "foundations in this release but yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01934-00438912-00439135": "there's it's just one example of many of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01935-00439135-00439343": "how much more potential there is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01936-00439343-00439575": "in many different aspects so yeah things", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01937-00439576-00439710": "will say for making that search bar", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01938-00439712-00439903": "happen it's a pretty cool feature it's a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01939-00439904-00440095": "pleasure", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01940-00440096-00440295": "marnix how about you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01941-00440296-00440455": "what have you been tinkering on uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01942-00440456-00440559": "you're also", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01943-00440560-00440807": "a newer contributor to the project and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01944-00440808-00441039": "you've grown and contributed in quite a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01945-00441039-00441199": "couple different areas so what was your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01946-00441200-00441327": "experience like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01947-00441328-00441407": "hey", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01948-00441408-00441766": "yes been quite a ride looking forward to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01949-00441767-00442095": "this day everyone of course for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01950-00442096-00442414": "two years plus finally happened and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01951-00442415-00442639": "even this is just the beginning of a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01952-00442639-00442870": "wasabi 2.0 of course and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01953-00442871-00443079": "yeah let's see but we have already come", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01954-00443080-00443359": "far and it's an awesome project the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01955-00443360-00443655": "wallet is great and super happy that the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01956-00443656-00443999": "day is finally here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01957-00444000-00444214": "let me just mention someone who could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01958-00444215-00444399": "not be here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01959-00444400-00444495": "who", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01960-00444496-00444575": "was", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01961-00444576-00444822": "the person who", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01962-00444823-00445199": "created most of the ui stuff for wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01963-00445200-00445591": "at 1.2 and now with the team with wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01964-00445592-00445943": "2.0 and it's dan ramsey he's a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01965-00445943-00446191": "maintainer of avalonia the ui framework", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01966-00446192-00446583": "wasabi is using and he's actually having", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01967-00446584-00446999": "another child today a riva not only was", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01968-00447000-00447335": "available at 1.2 turns out this was the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01969-00447335-00447463": "day", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01970-00447464-00447751": "when he or she was born so i just wanted", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01971-00447752-00448047": "to congratulate him for that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01972-00448047-00448327": "likewise and uh he's been doing really", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01973-00448328-00448518": "awesome work that's one of the things i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01974-00448519-00448670": "mentioned earlier where we were shifting", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01975-00448671-00448918": "gold gold posts uh throughout the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01976-00448919-00449127": "progress and we started out with hey", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01977-00449128-00449287": "let's just you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01978-00449288-00449535": "upgrade the avalonia back end and make", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01979-00449535-00449718": "the exact same user interface you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01980-00449719-00450047": "some minor changes but nothing much", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01981-00450047-00450239": "and all of a sudden oh how about we do", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01982-00450239-00450414": "it completely from scratch", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01983-00450415-00450710": "uh but uh that yeah turned into a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01984-00450712-00450855": "behemoth work", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01985-00450856-00451207": "but then managed it uh excellently", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01986-00451208-00451399": "and also here to mention just that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01987-00451400-00451687": "collaboration of the wasabi team and the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01988-00451688-00451847": "avalonia", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01989-00451847-00452022": "framework like the upstream", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01990-00452023-00452318": "contributions uh that that we make and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01991-00452319-00452503": "the help that we get from upstream to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01992-00452504-00452766": "make wasabi better is is just insanely", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01993-00452767-00452943": "awesome that's one of the my favorite", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01994-00452943-00453110": "parts of the software of how we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01995-00453112-00453303": "collaborate with upstream dependencies", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01996-00453304-00453510": "and then is doing an awesome job of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01997-00453512-00453718": "standing there on both sides and being", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01998-00453719-00453927": "that link to make sure it works as good", "BNJ7QDgE60E-01999-00453928-00454063": "as it does now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02000-00454064-00454287": "that's that's super valuable yeah he you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02001-00454288-00454510": "know and he he called it basically by", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02002-00454512-00454663": "himself uh the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02003-00454664-00454822": "first 1.0", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02004-00454823-00455047": "wasabi gui you know just before breaking", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02005-00455047-00455343": "bitcoin and lisbon yeah he basically", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02006-00455343-00455591": "rockstar did in in a couple days or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02007-00455592-00455910": "weeks and now it took him two years", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02008-00455912-00456135": "to do it this time", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02009-00456135-00456366": "and a bunch of more cold monkeys to help", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02010-00456367-00456622": "along but ultimately i think the the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02011-00456623-00456903": "difference shows and this is quite slick", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02012-00456904-00457183": "and robust but again lots of potential", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02013-00457184-00457407": "uh it's far from perfect we have a bunch", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02014-00457408-00457607": "of work to do to make it even better and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02015-00457608-00457870": "we also have el sileon in the chat", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02016-00457871-00458175": "um he is working on some other awesome", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02017-00458176-00458510": "charmian e cash or well e-cash magic and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02018-00458512-00458718": "that's federated e-cash for money", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02019-00458719-00459014": "warehouses with ready mint so i'm siri", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02020-00459015-00459270": "and what's up hey sorry for being late", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02021-00459271-00459518": "uh but didn't want to miss", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02022-00459519-00459631": "release", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02023-00459632-00459831": "i've been waiting for it for a long time", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02024-00459832-00460047": "and really happy that it's finally out", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02025-00460047-00460327": "so uh next challenge is probably getting", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02026-00460328-00460551": "it to run on nixos", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02027-00460552-00460683": "as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02028-00460684-00461014": "always yes indeed not a supported", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02029-00461015-00461247": "operating system but would be cool if we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02030-00461247-00461470": "can make that happen you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02031-00461471-00461631": "in general", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02032-00461632-00461814": "there is a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02033-00461815-00462127": "someone that created a package for for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02034-00462128-00462407": "wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02035-00462408-00462591": "that's that would be awesome", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02036-00462592-00462839": "it is available in fact i have if we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02037-00462839-00463047": "could do you think and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02038-00463047-00463335": "i don't think so no but but anyway as i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02039-00463335-00463687": "told you i i use xos so it's it works", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02040-00463688-00463910": "perfectly right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02041-00463912-00464183": "the only the only thing is that i i i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02042-00464184-00464351": "use my", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02043-00464352-00464695": "i mean or you or you patch the door or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02044-00464696-00464927": "use the the install", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02045-00464928-00465127": "from from links but that is the only", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02046-00465128-00465295": "thing basically that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02047-00465296-00465527": "have to change is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02048-00465528-00465687": "it worked perfectly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02049-00465688-00465839": "yeah that sounds awesome and looking", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02050-00465839-00466087": "forward to building a next generation so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02051-00466088-00466655": "i can try it out and probably not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02052-00466656-00466759": "environment", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02053-00466760-00466951": "as you always do when you don't know how", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02054-00466952-00467191": "to get something to run", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02055-00467192-00467431": "uh and you know nixon is used on a lot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02056-00467432-00467670": "of uh servers and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02057-00467671-00468014": "the kind of headless wasabi server uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02058-00468015-00468391": "with a rpc server interface you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02059-00468392-00468639": "the rudiments of it are there but again", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02060-00468639-00468822": "it's far from being perfect and we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02061-00468823-00469014": "didn't really spend much time on it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02062-00469015-00469263": "before this release uh however i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02063-00469264-00469551": "it's a bunch of people are interested in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02064-00469552-00469766": "making that a lot better so i'm hoping", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02065-00469767-00470047": "that the future work here will make the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02066-00470047-00470247": "life of atlas server operators a lot", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02067-00470247-00470487": "better including xos yeah it would be an", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02068-00470488-00470695": "awesome addition to next bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02069-00470696-00470870": "yeah yeah we talked about this a while", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02070-00470871-00471087": "ago already and one of the big problems", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02071-00471088-00471327": "for example was that uh the you could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02072-00471328-00471591": "not generate a new wallet exclusively in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02073-00471592-00471807": "the headless demon uh because of some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02074-00471808-00472022": "yeah weird architecture quirks so stuff", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02075-00472023-00472214": "like this was always a bit of a handicap", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02076-00472215-00472414": "and i'm not sure how much of that is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02077-00472415-00472566": "fixed", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02078-00472567-00472847": "but yeah they're workarounds um but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02079-00472847-00472983": "hopefully it's going to be more pretty", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02080-00472984-00473199": "in the future but kik zuma has something", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02081-00473200-00473422": "to say yeah i wanted to ask if there is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02082-00473423-00473655": "any road map or if there is any priority", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02083-00473656-00474007": "or whatever about this topic so so i i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02084-00474008-00474279": "would like to have an idea like when", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02085-00474280-00474551": "it could possibly be viable well that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02086-00474552-00474759": "a super good question you know to be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02087-00474760-00474918": "honest for a large extent we were kind", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02088-00474919-00475199": "of heads down preparing this release and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02089-00475200-00475366": "we'll have to take a breath and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02090-00475367-00475639": "reevaluate now afterwards uh of what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02091-00475639-00475935": "should be the future priorities but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02092-00475935-00476127": "at least for me personally having a good", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02093-00476128-00476335": "headless experience is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02094-00476335-00476607": "and a good rpc server is going to be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02095-00476608-00476847": "overall very important i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02096-00476847-00477118": "would like if someone could do the work", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02097-00477119-00477295": "just you know unfortunately i'm not the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02098-00477296-00477559": "dictator of the free software project so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02099-00477560-00477791": "it's tough to coordinate people as usual", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02100-00477792-00478031": "but i know that lucas is also interested", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02101-00478032-00478214": "in this to at least some extent but he's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02102-00478215-00478343": "also interested in a bunch of other", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02103-00478343-00478527": "topics so yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02104-00478528-00478695": "to be honest really tough to say about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02105-00478696-00478966": "the roadmap right now other than we have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02106-00478967-00479127": "a bunch of ideas and it's going to be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02107-00479128-00479343": "super difficult to prioritize on which", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02108-00479343-00479575": "ones we should focus on we have a bunch", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02109-00479576-00479991": "of ideas i've been working on what comes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02110-00479992-00480255": "after wasabi 2.2", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02111-00480256-00480510": "and of course there is no root one but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02112-00480512-00480743": "what i was trying to do is that i am", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02113-00480743-00481014": "trying to collect the ideas", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02114-00481015-00481287": "and somehow organize them into a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02115-00481288-00481614": "coherent representation of them and i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02116-00481615-00481870": "came up with three categories one would", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02117-00481871-00482159": "be maintenance the other scaling and the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02118-00482160-00482375": "third is innovation regarding", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02119-00482376-00482695": "maintenance it's uh it's not only just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02120-00482696-00482943": "maintenance it's improving the existing", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02121-00482943-00483199": "things right that's uh that's where we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02122-00483200-00483447": "will have to pay a lot of attention in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02123-00483447-00483727": "the future but other than that uh as we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02124-00483728-00483951": "are growing we are able to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02125-00483952-00484303": "get into different things and and that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02126-00484304-00484622": "when scaling and innovation comes in now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02127-00484623-00484918": "in the innovation part that's what all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02128-00484919-00485214": "we've been doing so far with with wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02129-00485215-00485514": "well that we were trying to make", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02130-00485515-00485831": "non-incremental meaningful significant", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02131-00485832-00485959": "improvements", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02132-00485960-00486159": "based on a lot of research", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02133-00486160-00486479": "and now i believe we came to a point", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02134-00486480-00486759": "where significant improvements", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02135-00486760-00486918": "would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02136-00486919-00487087": "only possible", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02137-00487088-00487327": "if we could involve the lightning", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02138-00487328-00487639": "network because in a in a high level the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02139-00487639-00487935": "only issue left is that people who have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02140-00487935-00488151": "low amount of volume in their bullet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02141-00488152-00488447": "it's going to be expensive maybe not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02142-00488447-00488607": "today but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02143-00488608-00488847": "you know how do you scale a blockchain", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02144-00488847-00488966": "you don't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02145-00488967-00489039": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02146-00489039-00489262": "eventually it is going to get more and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02147-00489263-00489575": "more expensive for low volume people and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02148-00489576-00489743": "that's when the lighting network comes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02149-00489743-00490022": "in and that's most likely is the future", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02150-00490023-00490327": "at this point i think we can say that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02151-00490328-00490431": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02152-00490432-00490591": "we started the lightning network", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02153-00490592-00490903": "research grant where we are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02154-00490904-00491207": "trying to design uh privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02155-00491208-00491670": "oriented but we gave out as a task", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02156-00491671-00491918": "research task to design privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02157-00491919-00492143": "guarantees for lightning network or or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02158-00492143-00492343": "or do anything", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02159-00492343-00492607": "with that right like maybe just do a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02160-00492608-00492822": "survey on on hey how private is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02161-00492823-00493007": "lightning network because at this point", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02162-00493008-00493262": "there are a lot of questions but anyhow", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02163-00493263-00493559": "that's uh that's the direction we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02164-00493560-00493703": "started going", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02165-00493704-00493991": "and finally the spelling part which is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02166-00493992-00494270": "going to be the next step and scaling", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02167-00494271-00494614": "means we should enable the usage of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02168-00494615-00494943": "mastabi for more type of users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02169-00494943-00495207": "for example there are four four main", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02170-00495208-00495455": "things actually but for example", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02171-00495456-00495607": "one of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02172-00495608-00495887": "the thing is that well guess what not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02173-00495888-00496095": "everyone speaks english", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02174-00496096-00496310": "so it would be good to have a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02175-00496312-00496535": "localization so that might be the next", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02176-00496535-00496791": "thing we are working on it's it's not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02177-00496792-00497039": "probably not as large as the job as the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02178-00497039-00497191": "rest but that i'm", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02179-00497192-00497455": "talking about the other ones are going", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02180-00497456-00497831": "to other platforms maybe mobile or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02181-00497832-00497959": "or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02182-00497960-00498070": "hardware", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02183-00498071-00498359": "native hardware but coinjoin integration", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02184-00498360-00498591": "so currently people cannot do hardware", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02185-00498592-00498870": "well let's speed with coin joints", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02186-00498871-00499247": "that uh cannot do coinjs without levels", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02187-00499247-00499543": "so so that's uh that's that would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02188-00499543-00499903": "quite cool if we could uh right because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02189-00499904-00500199": "that's that's a safer way to to store", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02190-00500200-00500414": "your volume having it in a hardware", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02191-00500415-00500647": "wallet rather than in a hot wallet right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02192-00500647-00500903": "like in wasabi right now and the final", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02193-00500904-00501047": "category which", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02194-00501047-00501335": "brings back to your question would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02195-00501335-00501631": "the developer tools so there are", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02196-00501632-00501918": "projects those are interested in in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02197-00501919-00502335": "using wasabi balance among some jinkies", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02198-00502335-00502543": "there is pure here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02199-00502543-00502807": "so we would like to make make things", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02200-00502808-00503127": "easier for for them and one of the way", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02201-00503128-00503343": "to make things easier for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02202-00503343-00503647": "for integrating hospital that would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02203-00503647-00504118": "rpc and demand and bad documented", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02204-00504119-00504431": "nice user guides maybe even video guides", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02205-00504432-00504670": "and tutorials good project sorry yes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02206-00504671-00504855": "right like that would be the ideal way", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02207-00504856-00505199": "to to go about that so so that's when", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02208-00505200-00505543": "where it comes in as you can see this is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02209-00505543-00505807": "the headless mood of pasta", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02210-00505808-00506191": "is certainly in the bucket of ideas that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02211-00506192-00506422": "might come next but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02212-00506423-00506679": "but we did not decide yet we don't have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02213-00506680-00507055": "a roadmap it's a it's just an ideas", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02214-00507056-00507335": "yeah it's coming in two weeks", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02215-00507335-00507495": "i mean maybe a question for you el", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02216-00507496-00507727": "sirion uh like your your work on the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02217-00507728-00508070": "charmian e cash bank is quite nice", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02218-00508071-00508199": "uh and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02219-00508200-00508599": "i i wonder how you would uh like how you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02220-00508600-00508822": "currently deal with unchained privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02221-00508823-00509110": "for your federation uh and you know how", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02222-00509112-00509318": "coinjoin might help you in the future", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02223-00509319-00509503": "that's actually a great question i", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02224-00509504-00509727": "currently we don't deal with that at all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02225-00509728-00509839": "because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02226-00509839-00510135": "right now federated ecash is only a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02227-00510135-00510295": "privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02228-00510296-00510583": "means to gain privacy for users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02229-00510584-00510766": "and users don't really have to think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02230-00510767-00510918": "about", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02231-00510919-00511151": "like the utxos of the federation all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02232-00511152-00511343": "that much because their main way of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02233-00511343-00511470": "interacting with the federation is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02234-00511471-00511727": "through lightning and there they already", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02235-00511728-00511983": "have pretty good privacy properties", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02236-00511984-00512159": "because whenever they", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02237-00512160-00512399": "send or receive on lightning", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02238-00512400-00512695": "the other side is uh ecash and ecash has", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02239-00512696-00512887": "like the best privacy you can get", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02240-00512888-00513095": "essentially like um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02241-00513096-00513255": "you should have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02242-00513256-00513462": "like pull anonymity for the sender or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02243-00513463-00513743": "recipient um on the cash side", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02244-00513743-00514007": "respectively like the main problem", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02245-00514008-00514159": "currently we're thinking about is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02246-00514160-00514414": "lighting privacy so for example", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02247-00514415-00514599": "if you're sending money", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02248-00514600-00514751": "to some other lighting node then you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02249-00514752-00514951": "generally leak", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02250-00514952-00515047": "their", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02251-00515047-00515159": "node id", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02252-00515160-00515375": "and so while you don't leak who is the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02253-00515376-00515510": "sender you leak something about the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02254-00515512-00515710": "recipient which might in turn leak", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02255-00515712-00515903": "something about the sender again", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02256-00515904-00516166": "like there are these complicated uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02257-00516167-00516422": "problems that like if there's anything", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02258-00516423-00516631": "that's being leaked then it might be in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02259-00516632-00516735": "relation", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02260-00516735-00516887": "to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02261-00516888-00517031": "like the user who", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02262-00517032-00517239": "is using ecash and does everything right", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02263-00517239-00517343": "but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02264-00517343-00517559": "like if the other side like something", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02265-00517560-00517775": "that's a problem so on chain like in the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02266-00517776-00518079": "long term what i'd wish for is that all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02267-00518080-00518239": "these layer two and layer three", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02268-00518239-00518407": "solutions like for example federated", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02269-00518408-00518622": "ecacas are also like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02270-00518623-00518807": "liquid other federations like bigger", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02271-00518808-00518999": "custodians like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02272-00519000-00519191": "single users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02273-00519192-00519303": "that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02274-00519304-00519551": "they in the long term will use", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02275-00519552-00519807": "a utex oath of common denominations like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02276-00519808-00519966": "that's what you're already doing with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02277-00519967-00520295": "wabi zabi or wasabi 2.0", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02278-00520296-00520495": "and you have a bunch of common", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02279-00520496-00520710": "denominations that users", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02280-00520712-00521087": "can use to create utex os in and then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02281-00521088-00521222": "you can spend them", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02282-00521223-00521487": "again but like currently when you want", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02283-00521488-00521687": "to like pay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02284-00521688-00521951": "for goods and services on chain", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02285-00521952-00522143": "you need to grind down these common", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02286-00522143-00522295": "denominations because they typically", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02287-00522296-00522503": "don't fit exactly what you want to pay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02288-00522504-00522670": "but in the future i imagine like most of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02289-00522671-00522910": "the commerce moves", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02290-00522912-00523135": "into the upper layers like your actual", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02291-00523135-00523391": "day-to-day uh transferring of money", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02292-00523392-00523566": "moves to lightning moves to federate the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02293-00523567-00523703": "ecash", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02294-00523704-00523910": "and so what you can do on chain is you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02295-00523912-00524214": "only send common denominations and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02296-00524215-00524503": "once we hit that point that nobody does", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02297-00524504-00524727": "arbitrary denomination utxos anymore", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02298-00524728-00524918": "like most people don't", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02299-00524919-00525270": "then coinjoins would be so much more", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02300-00525271-00525391": "powerful", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02301-00525392-00525543": "because suddenly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02302-00525544-00525743": "you don't have any toxic change anymore", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02303-00525744-00525959": "you just create a big coin joint that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02304-00525960-00526127": "takes like common denominations as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02305-00526128-00526295": "inputs and common denominations as", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02306-00526296-00526431": "outputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02307-00526432-00526711": "and maybe you add some mutex o for fees", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02308-00526712-00526959": "that uh is not of a common denomination", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02309-00526960-00527135": "because you have to remove a little bit", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02310-00527136-00527383": "for peace but in general you would just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02311-00527384-00527503": "recycle", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02312-00527504-00527687": "like common denomination you take so's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02313-00527688-00527839": "and just keep them in these", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02314-00527840-00527975": "denominations", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02315-00527976-00528166": "making coin joints much more efficient", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02316-00528167-00528303": "and like that's the future i hope for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02317-00528304-00528431": "with bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02318-00528432-00528703": "and i hope that rabi zabi it's a great", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02319-00528704-00528927": "protocol like um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02320-00528928-00529047": "the ecash", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02321-00529048-00529287": "part makes it very resilient against", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02322-00529288-00529470": "all kinds of like de-anonymization", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02323-00529471-00529655": "attacks like it's the gold standard", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02324-00529656-00529966": "essentially when it comes to a privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02325-00529967-00530270": "and if we figure some things out on the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02326-00530271-00530439": "coin selection side like which", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02327-00530440-00530647": "denominations we choose then i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02328-00530648-00530879": "this can be a protocol", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02329-00530880-00531127": "that we use for many many", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02330-00531128-00531366": "years or decades", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02331-00531367-00531599": "so really looking forward to that future", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02332-00531600-00531927": "yeah nice that's really awesome to hear", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02333-00531928-00532095": "one thing that i'd also like to bring up", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02334-00532096-00532343": "is that i think there is a possibility", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02335-00532344-00532566": "that wasabi could make great use of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02336-00532567-00532735": "something like vetiment", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02337-00532736-00532911": "because i do believe that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02338-00532912-00533175": "it it might make sense to have some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02339-00533176-00533462": "custodial layer with cheap and small", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02340-00533463-00533799": "value payments to help alleviate some of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02341-00533800-00534183": "the problems in the coin join um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02342-00534184-00534455": "and yeah i think that i mean either that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02343-00534456-00534727": "custodial bank can use the wabi-sabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02344-00534728-00534887": "anonymous credentials", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02345-00534888-00535191": "as a centralized money warehouse or of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02346-00535192-00535351": "course fedement comes in with a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02347-00535352-00535551": "decentralized money warehouse in a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02348-00535552-00535735": "federation", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02349-00535736-00535807": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02350-00535808-00536095": "but in general the idea might be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02351-00536096-00536399": "interesting um but yeah yeah i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02352-00536400-00536487": "they're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02353-00536488-00536687": "indeed very complementary in nature like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02354-00536688-00536927": "for big amounts uh barbie's ib is still", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02355-00536928-00537183": "the way to go or like coin joints in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02356-00537184-00537295": "general", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02357-00537296-00537439": "because like you don't want to trust the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02358-00537440-00537583": "federation with like hundreds of your", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02359-00537584-00537903": "bitcoins and it probably wouldn't be a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02360-00537904-00538079": "a good way to mix anyway because the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02361-00538080-00538311": "federation might not be big enough", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02362-00538312-00538535": "or it doesn't have enough throughput", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02363-00538536-00538775": "enough flow and you can probably achieve", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02364-00538776-00539007": "much higher flow with coinjoins because", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02365-00539008-00539166": "people don't have to trust like the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02366-00539167-00539414": "coordinator it's trustless", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02367-00539415-00539591": "and on the other hand if you do small", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02368-00539592-00539799": "payments then as you said like it makes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02369-00539800-00540062": "much more sense to trust such entity or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02370-00540063-00540255": "no power i mentioned it like we have to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02371-00540256-00540447": "find ways to make private payments", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02372-00540448-00540535": "viable", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02373-00540536-00540695": "that's i think where minimum comes in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02374-00540696-00540983": "and where it can help enormously and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02375-00540984-00541231": "then there's also like this in between", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02376-00541232-00541551": "like when you pay on chain today after", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02377-00541552-00541847": "coinjoining with wasabi then you get", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02378-00541848-00542039": "like these comedy nominations and when", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02379-00542040-00542207": "you spend you get some change and what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02380-00542208-00542366": "do you do with the change like you have", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02381-00542367-00542559": "to get it into some common denomination", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02382-00542560-00542687": "again", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02383-00542688-00542911": "and you will probably get some amount of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02384-00542912-00543095": "change from that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02385-00543096-00543207": "and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02386-00543208-00543479": "like traditionally like maybe it's not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02387-00543480-00543655": "as big of a problem anymore because now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02388-00543656-00543814": "you can just use the change to pay for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02389-00543815-00543975": "peace or whatever like your common", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02390-00543976-00544183": "denominations are small enough but what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02391-00544184-00544375": "you could also do is instead of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02392-00544376-00544575": "generating like really small utxos you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02393-00544576-00544831": "just send this change to federation and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02394-00544832-00545055": "then after you accumulate a bit of such", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02395-00545056-00545295": "change then you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02396-00545296-00545431": "withdraw", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02397-00545432-00545631": "like a bigger common denomination you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02398-00545632-00545831": "take so again like you do this for a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02399-00545832-00546079": "month or so and then you have like 0.1", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02400-00546080-00546311": "bitcoin again accumulated you withdraw", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02401-00546312-00546559": "it and can do coin joints with this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02402-00546560-00546662": "again", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02403-00546663-00546799": "because it already has the common", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02404-00546800-00547159": "denomination which is great yes exactly", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02405-00547160-00547399": "and just on in a bit more for the coin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02406-00547400-00547543": "joint service could be improved with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02407-00547544-00547687": "ecash", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02408-00547688-00547870": "like money", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02409-00547871-00548111": "ecash is that for example right if you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02410-00548112-00548255": "have these standard denominations let's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02411-00548256-00548622": "say exactly 1.00 bitcoin then you might", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02412-00548623-00548862": "want to register exactly 1.00 bitcoin on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02413-00548863-00549079": "the output side but the big question of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02414-00549080-00549214": "course how are you going to pay for", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02415-00549215-00549535": "mining fees and and here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02416-00549536-00549743": "the current solution is just register", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02417-00549744-00549959": "more inputs basically", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02418-00549960-00550207": "but of course the alternative would be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02419-00550208-00550303": "pay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02420-00550304-00550511": "somehow the coordinator or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02421-00550512-00550759": "another third-party service provider", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02422-00550760-00550983": "to pay for the binding fee", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02423-00550984-00551175": "by including his own inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02424-00551176-00551407": "um and that can be done via lightning", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02425-00551408-00551622": "that can be done via", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02426-00551623-00551870": "e-cash payments or mini mint", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02427-00551871-00552166": "uh and i think that yeah that's that's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02428-00552167-00552366": "enough benefit for both yeah i think", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02429-00552367-00552631": "that's a great vision because adding out", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02430-00552632-00552911": "inputs for fees is just a wasteful", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02431-00552912-00553047": "and if you already have like common", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02432-00553048-00553255": "denomination inputs", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02433-00553256-00553495": "and you can just get them out the same", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02434-00553496-00553695": "size again then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02435-00553696-00553831": "it makes so much sense just to pay", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02436-00553832-00554127": "someone to add their utics o for fees", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02437-00554128-00554335": "and i really hope that there's will be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02438-00554336-00554543": "more work into that direction", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02439-00554544-00554775": "yeah it's very great anyone has any", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02440-00554776-00554847": "other", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02441-00554848-00555118": "ideas or thoughts or comments", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02442-00555119-00555391": "maybe the office could give us a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02443-00555392-00555727": "situation on updates like what's going", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02444-00555728-00555799": "on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02445-00555800-00556151": "is there some news yes how drunk are you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02446-00556152-00556407": "did more champions champagne bottles pop", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02447-00556408-00556607": "what time", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02448-00556608-00556831": "it was something", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02449-00556832-00557103": "getting back into reality the the path", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02450-00557104-00557239": "actually and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02451-00557240-00557447": "getting us back to the reality however", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02452-00557448-00557751": "adam is an euphoric laugh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02453-00557752-00557895": "whenever he", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02454-00557896-00558247": "see the gif because there is already a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02455-00558248-00558335": "gift", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02456-00558336-00558470": "about that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02457-00558471-00558583": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02458-00558584-00558895": "the the number of downloads is 189", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02459-00558896-00559279": "currently and the first coin joy around", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02460-00559280-00559670": "will be there in 18 minutes but only if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02461-00559671-00560022": "we reach the input number of 150 so we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02462-00560023-00560166": "will see", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02463-00560167-00560399": "if that's gonna happen the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02464-00560400-00560583": "the number is a bit high i mean the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02465-00560584-00560959": "minimum required number of inputs is a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02466-00560960-00561175": "bit high if you compare for example the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02467-00561176-00561383": "number of downloads", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02468-00561384-00561662": "it's almost the same and whoever", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02469-00561663-00561959": "download the software it is not", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02470-00561960-00562231": "deterministic that he will go and join", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02471-00562232-00562327": "as well", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02472-00562328-00562422": "so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02473-00562423-00562655": "probably the first round", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02474-00562656-00562862": "uh we'll retry", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02475-00562863-00563062": "but we previously at least if you know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02476-00563063-00563311": "how we are standing there because when", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02477-00563312-00563551": "the coordinator we restart the round", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02478-00563552-00563847": "then we will know what was the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02479-00563848-00564047": "the actual number of inputs at that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02480-00564048-00564143": "point", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02481-00564144-00564391": "yeah the last i know of is uh input", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02482-00564392-00564647": "registration count of 22", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02483-00564648-00564791": "that was like 10 minutes ago or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02484-00564792-00565070": "something so probably more by now but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02485-00565071-00565247": "probably not enough to trigger the first", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02486-00565248-00565447": "round yet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02487-00565448-00565614": "and in this case if i understand it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02488-00565615-00565935": "correctly we go we abandon this current", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02489-00565936-00566159": "round and go into a new round a new", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02490-00566160-00566462": "input registration where uh anyone can", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02491-00566463-00566622": "register again", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02492-00566623-00566822": "kik sunil you have here something on", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02493-00566823-00567007": "your mind what's up", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02494-00567008-00567222": "so there was discussion about uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02495-00567223-00567535": "integrating lightning i wonder if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02496-00567536-00567807": "there are any plans for zetka snakes to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02497-00567808-00568207": "also provide like lightning service", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02498-00568208-00568510": "lighting services like uh some opero", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02499-00568511-00568822": "mobile wallets do or if there is idea to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02500-00568823-00568943": "just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02501-00568944-00569279": "make it available and let people connect", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02502-00569280-00569431": "to their own", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02503-00569432-00569759": "nodes i mean not their own but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02504-00569760-00570055": "to the nodes they select themselves", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02505-00570056-00570214": "at the random or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02506-00570215-00570447": "based on some recommendation or whatever", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02507-00570448-00570670": "that's a really good question", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02508-00570671-00570847": "and in general it's", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02509-00570848-00571047": "it's definitely something that we're", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02510-00571048-00571214": "looking into because lightning service", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02511-00571215-00571422": "providers are another great bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02512-00571423-00571631": "native business model alongside two", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02513-00571632-00571799": "conjoined coordination", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02514-00571800-00571895": "um", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02515-00571896-00572110": "of course different in many aspects if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02516-00572111-00572318": "we actually end up doing it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02517-00572319-00572470": "i guess depends on the research that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02518-00572471-00572631": "we're doing right now", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02519-00572632-00572807": "because if we find that we can have a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02520-00572808-00573062": "lightweight private by default wallet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02521-00573063-00573310": "experience or architecture without any", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02522-00573311-00573510": "third-party service providers well then", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02523-00573511-00573687": "we will probably do that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02524-00573688-00573991": "um however i'm thinking and that's just", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02525-00573992-00574335": "an intuition is that a service provider", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02526-00574336-00574670": "will alleviate a lot of problems and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02527-00574671-00574814": "frictions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02528-00574815-00574959": "in lightning", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02529-00574960-00575222": "and then the big question is can we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02530-00575223-00575535": "design a protocol for this lightning", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02531-00575536-00575822": "service provider to perform the service", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02532-00575823-00575903": "in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02533-00575904-00576214": "the in in the most privacy optimized way", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02534-00576215-00576431": "and you know here are things like ck", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02535-00576432-00576599": "channels or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02536-00576600-00576735": "you know maybe coordinated channel", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02537-00576736-00577095": "factories or stuff like this yeah lots", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02538-00577096-00577270": "of possible things you know maybe some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02539-00577271-00577399": "blinded", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02540-00577400-00577647": "route path calculations or", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02541-00577648-00577839": "what whatever might be possible and to", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02542-00577840-00578022": "be honest i don't know about all half of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02543-00578023-00578191": "these so we", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02544-00578192-00578431": "we will see if it's necessary and if", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02545-00578432-00578710": "we're able to provide a useful service", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02546-00578711-00578959": "according to our privacy ethos and in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02547-00578960-00579095": "any case", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02548-00579096-00579295": "it's a long way out so it'll come to you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02549-00579296-00579535": "in two weeks of course yeah one of the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02550-00579536-00579759": "things i had in mind is maybe it could", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02551-00579760-00579839": "be", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02552-00579840-00580087": "combinable if uh coinjoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02553-00580088-00580327": "so for instance it could be a way of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02554-00580328-00580455": "dealing with", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02555-00580456-00580910": "change outputs so you could conjoin and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02556-00580911-00581118": "put the change directly into lightning", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02557-00581119-00581383": "channel that is opened with case next", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02558-00581384-00581735": "which provides a way to then like mix up", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02559-00581736-00581943": "the amount especially if this was", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02560-00581944-00582191": "implemented on top of taproot it it", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02561-00582192-00582375": "would actually", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02562-00582376-00582591": "improve privacy even of those people who", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02563-00582592-00582718": "don't do this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02564-00582719-00582862": "yeah for sure", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02565-00582863-00583031": "and again maybe we can do even better", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02566-00583032-00583151": "right and get some block space", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02567-00583152-00583422": "efficiencies by something like a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02568-00583423-00583631": "private channel factory uh and that is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02569-00583632-00583783": "of course great for for conjoined", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02570-00583784-00583927": "coordinator because the channel factory", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02571-00583928-00584127": "after all is just a coin join of many", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02572-00584128-00584335": "users opening a channel in single output", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02573-00584336-00584607": "um but yeah that also also the these", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02574-00584608-00584679": "whole", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02575-00584680-00584918": "coin swaps and lightning channels and", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02576-00584919-00585151": "stuff like this they as you say", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02577-00585152-00585383": "increase the subset ambiguity of every", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02578-00585384-00585559": "calendar and participant even if they", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02579-00585560-00585862": "don't use these fancy second layer magic", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02580-00585863-00586079": "especially if temperatures involved so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02581-00586080-00586431": "uh yeah it's it's a big idea it's it's a", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02582-00586432-00586607": "lot of work", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02583-00586608-00586839": "so we will consider again there's so", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02584-00586840-00587047": "much to do right these are all awesome", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02585-00587048-00587207": "ideas the questions just which of them", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02586-00587208-00587455": "do we tackle first and that's just yeah", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02587-00587456-00587583": "super difficult", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02588-00587584-00587735": "but that's why feedback rounds like this", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02589-00587736-00587927": "are super important right because we see", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02590-00587928-00588159": "what what you guys think are uh is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02591-00588160-00588375": "important to tackle next", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02592-00588376-00588527": "adam do you have anything else to bring", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02593-00588528-00588655": "up", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02594-00588656-00588807": "no i'm good", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02595-00588808-00589127": "anyone uh is there any marketing on like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02596-00589128-00589303": "reddit i know there was like a tweet", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02597-00589304-00589439": "that went out but are there any other", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02598-00589440-00589614": "like campaigns right now to get some", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02599-00589615-00589783": "early liquidity in", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02600-00589784-00590055": "i think there is did not yet confirm but", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02601-00590056-00590255": "there should be so there's like a reddit", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02602-00590256-00590614": "post somewhere about this i believe yes", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02603-00590615-00590951": "there's also a blog post on blog.wasabi", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02604-00590952-00591247": "io and it's reddit.com", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02605-00591248-00591479": "ce slash wasabi wallet or something like", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02606-00591480-00591822": "that okay so i see a uh i see a post", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02607-00591823-00592135": "from four minutes ago yahia posted you", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02608-00592136-00592318": "see that synchronicity", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02609-00592319-00592518": "at least someone is working here", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02610-00592519-00592679": "all right fellas if there's nothing else", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02611-00592680-00592951": "to discuss i would say let's conclude uh", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02612-00592952-00593207": "this wasabi wallet 2.0 release", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02613-00593208-00593503": "livestream party uh was nice to get", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02614-00593504-00593599": "everyone", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02615-00593600-00593791": "involved with sharing a bit of the story", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02616-00593792-00594047": "of how we got to this point and thanks", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02617-00594048-00594231": "for the people joining uh with some nice", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02618-00594232-00594335": "questions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02619-00594336-00594559": "um we keep it coming", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02620-00594560-00594751": "we're happy for feedback let us know", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02621-00594752-00594927": "what you think of the new wallet the new", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02622-00594928-00595127": "user interface the new conjoined", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02623-00595128-00595287": "functionality", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02624-00595288-00595503": "and let's see how we can make wasabi 2.0", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02625-00595504-00595759": "even better in the upcoming versions", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02626-00595760-00596039": "uh there is a lot of room uh to do that", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02627-00596040-00596222": "so i'm eager for all the future", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02628-00596223-00596439": "contributions and quite bullish on what", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02629-00596440-00596687": "we're about to build if you got any", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02630-00596688-00596822": "final words", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02631-00596823-00597079": "um please do otherwise we'll end the", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02632-00597080-00597287": "stream", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02633-00597288-00597518": "bitcoin to the moon", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02634-00597519-00597743": "privacy by default", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02635-00597744-00597959": "2.0 to the moon", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02636-00597960-00598262": "if you open a champagne always make sure", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02637-00598263-00598470": "you don't have anything", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02638-00598471-00598759": "above you or put your thumb on top of", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02639-00598760-00598879": "the cork", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02640-00598880-00599310": "don't put the cat in the microwave", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02641-00599311-00599775": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02642-00599776-00599918": "for whatever you want", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02643-00599919-00599976": "bitcoin", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02644-00599977-00600735": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02645-00600736-00601503": "improve your is", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02646-00601504-00601966": "build your dreams", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02647-00601967-00602165": "care for yourself", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02648-00602166-00602799": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02649-00602800-00602969": "find your love", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02650-00602970-00603487": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02651-00603488-00603987": "develop your ideas", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02652-00603988-00604447": "[Music]", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02653-00604448-00604751": "bitcoin is the future", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02654-00604752-00605079": "but is visible to all", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02655-00605080-00605551": "your transactions are your business", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02656-00605552-00605820": "reclaim your privacy", "BNJ7QDgE60E-02657-00605821-00606139": "[Music]"}}]